trvolution 'f
ltc F irst li Indefstigable
/'2
Р / J /
ва.riпgton
...
133 downloads
2258 Views
29MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
trvolution 'f
ltc F irst li<)ur' llilliorr \('ars
tf ?
^ tl-
ft'g., .j!
,' i9, ' , ' ' ,
d
a- ql:I;
'!''iili, *e
4a..&
"i
ir:T.'.
J t;.
t'l*{
r.ltlc$iu,jtl}r*
$-19.95
Slrltttttittg
evolutiolrrrv sclence
fiorrr its irrception to its lrrtest firrclirrgs. tl-oni cliscovcrics lrncl cllrtlr to philosophv :rncl historl', tliis book is the ntost conrpletc, authoritlttir,'e,ancl irrviting one volunte introcluction tct solutionrrlv
bioloi1' avrril:iblc.(lIe:rr,
i r r f i r r r r r r t t i v e r, r n d c o n r ; r r c h e n s i v e i n s c o p c , E l t r l r r t i o r io p e n s u , ' i t h r r s e r i c s of rrrrtjor css:rr..s rlerrlinq u,ith the histolv rrntl philosophl' oi er,'olutionnrv biologr'. uith
nrrrjor crrrpiricrrl :rrrci
t l r e o r e t i c r r lq u c s t i o n s i n t h e s c i c n c c , fioni s1-rccilrtiorrtc'r:rclrrptrrtion.firtrri prllcor)toloqv to evolutiorirrv tlevel opnrclrt (evo-tlcr,o). rrrrc'lconclurling
'#* 't
sr
with essayson the social and political sienificance of evolutionary biology today. A second, encyclopedic section travels the spectrum of topics in evolution with concise, informative, and accessibleentries on individuals from Aristotle and Linnaeus to Louis Leakey and Jean Lamarck; from T. H. Huxley and Edward O. Wilson to Joseph Felsenstein and Motoo Kimura; and on subjects fronr altruism and an-rphibiansto evolutionary psychology and Piltdown Man to the Scopestrial and social Darwinism. Readers will find the latest word on the history and philosophy of evolution, the nuancesof the scienceitself, and the intricate interplay anong evolutionary study,religion, philosophy, and sociery. Appearing at the beginning of the Darwin Year of 2oo9-the
zooth anniversary of the
birth of Charles Darwin and the rjoth anniversary of the publication of the Origirt o-f Species-this volume is a fitting tribute to the s c i e n c eD a r w i n s e t i n n l o t i o n .
M TcHAEL
RUSE
i s L u c y l eT . W e r k n r e i s t e r
Professor of Philosophy and Director of the Progranr in the History and Philosophy of Science, Florida State (Jniversiry.He is the founder and ediBiologyand Philosophyand has ap-
tor ofthejournal
peared on "Quirks and Quarks" and the Discovery Channel. His books include Tlrc Euolution-Crcdtiort Struggleand Danyin and Desigtrftoth from Harvard). J oS EPH
T R A V T S i s D e a n o f t h e C o l l e g eo f
Arts and Sciencesand Robert O. Lawton Distinguished Professor of Biological Science at Florida State Universiry.
The BelknapPressof HarvardUniversiryPress Cambridge,Nlassathusetts, attd Lturdon,England
www.hup.harvard. edu
Jacket illustration: DEA
Picturr Librarv/(letn
Jacket design: Jill Breitbarth
Inrrqes
"One of the first and likely to be the most comprehensive in scope of the many books occasionedby the zoog sesquicentennialofDarwin's Origin." -Edward
FROM
THE
O.Wilson
EDITORS'
INTRODUCTION
This book presentsevolutionary science as a modern, dynamic discipline and allows the reader to explore evolution according to his or her interestsand background. The reader who wishes to be immersed in the science can focus on the major scientific themes, while the reader who is interested in the intellectual history and influence of the subject away from science can enter through a separateset of essays. A reader interested in very specific topics or historical figures can find the appropriate entries, along with essayson related topics. Our goal was to provide an exciting and compelling introduction to evolution along with a basic reference work that could point the way toward a deeper study of individual issues. The essaysinclude bibliographies, which serve as guides to further and deeper reading.The essaysin this book show not only how far we have come but where the scientific horizons lie and how we might move toward those horizons.
rsBN378-0-b7rr-03175-3
90000
llillfflilllilllllllllll ilililil]tl
ЕVoLUTloN The First Four Billion Yeаrs
EDlтЕD BY
MlсHAЕL RUsE JosЕPH TRAVls W|тH A FoRЕWoRD BY
ЕDWARD o. WlLsoN
т H E в E L K N A PP R Е s s o F н A R V A R DU N l V Е R s | т YP R Е s s с A t ' 4 B R I D GМ ЕA . ssAсHUsЕттs L o N D o N ,Е N G L A N D 2009
Сontеnts
Сopyright o 2009 by thе Prеsidеntand Fеllows of Нarvаrd Collеgе All rights rеsеrvеd Printеd ir-rthе Unitеd Stаtеs Of Amеriс:r Librаrу of Сoпgrеss Саtаlogiпg-iп-Publiсаtion Dаtа Еvоlution : thе first fсlur Ьillion yеars / еditеd by Мiсhaеl Rusе, Josеph Trаvis ; with a forеword Ьу Еdwаrd O. Wilson. p. сm. InсludеsЬiЬliogгаphiсalrеfеrеnсesand indеx' I S B N 9 7 8 . 0 - 6 74 - 0 3 | 7 5 . з ( a l k . p a p е r ) 1. Еvolution (Biotogy) I. Rusе, Мiсhaеl. II. Travis,Josеph, 1953QH366.2.Е86з zО09
576.8-dс22
2008030270
Fоrеword Еdшаrd О.Wils,
Introduсtion NIiсhаеl Ruse аl
Thе Histoгy of Еvolu Мiсhаеl Rцsе
Thе origin of Lifе Jеffrеу L' Bаdа c
Palеontolоgy and thе МiсhаеI Bеnton
Adaptation Josеph Trаuis аt Мolесulаr Еvolutiоn FrаnсisсoJ.Aуа
Еvolution of thе Gеnr Briаn Сhаrlesш
Thе Pattеrn and Proс Маrgаrеt B. Ptа,
Еvolution and Dеvеlо Grеgorу A. IVrа
Soсial Bеhavior and S Dапiеl I. Rubеп Human Еvolution Hеnrу М. МсH
ЕvotutionагyBiоlogy Мiсhаеl F' Аnto
Contеnts
nd Fеllows of Hаrvard Сoliеgе sеrvеd 'tаtеsof Amеriсa ,пg-iп- Pub liсаtklп D аtа геd by Miсhаеl Rusе, Josеph Travis ; ward O. Wilson. эfеrеnсеsand iгrdех. '5-3 (alk. paреr) haеl. II. Travis,Josеph' 1953-
3 2009 20080зО270
Foгеword Еdшаrd O' Wilson Introduсtion Мiсhаеl Rusе апd Josеph Trаuis
UTl
iх
Thе History of Еvolutiоnary Thought Мiсhаеl Rиsе Thе origin of Lifе JеffreуL. Bаdа аnd Aпtonio Lаzсаno
49
Palеontologyand thе History of Lifе Мiсh,lеl Bепtoп
80
Adaptatiоn Josеph Тrаuis аnd Dаuid N. Rеzпiсk
105
МolесulaгЕvolution Frаnсisсol. Ауаlа
1З2
Еvоlution оf thе Gеnomе Briап Сbаrlеstuorthаnd Dеborаh Сhаrlеsшorth
152
Thе Pattеrn and Proсеssof Spесiation Маrgаrеt B, Ptасеk аnd Sbаlа l. Наnktsoп
177
Еvolution and Dеvеlopmеnt Crеgorу A' Wrау
208
Soсial Bеhaviоr and Soсiоbiolоgy DаnielI,Rиbеnstein
2З7
Human Еvolution Неnrу М. МсНеnrу
256
ЕvolutionaryBiolоgy of Disеasеand Darwinian Меdiсinе МiсhаеlF. Anto|ш
281
Contепts Bеyond thе Darwinian Paradigm:UndеrstandingBiolоgiсal Foгms Briаn Goodtuiп
299
Philosоphy of Еvolutionary ThougЬt Kim Stеrеlпу
31З
Еvolution and Soсiеty Мапfrеd D. Lаubiсblеr апd Jапе Маiепsсhеin
ЗЗ0
Forеwor
Еvolution and Rеligion Dаuid N' Liuiпgstonе
З48
ЕdшаrdО
Amегiсan Antiеvolutionism: Rсtrospесt and Prospесt ЕugепiеС. Sсott
З70
Alphabеtiсal Guidе
401
сontriЬЦtors
9ЗS
IllustrationСrеdits
949
Indех
951
Two сеnturiеs aftеr i Сharlеs Darwin's ozz important Ьook еvеr. tЬe Оrigiп havе not t arе not prеaсhеd frоп oath of offiсе with a drеssеd thе living wol ity's plaсе within it, v massivе sсiеntifiс еvid havе grown сontinuo undеrstanding and tht So solidly havе thе of еvolution that it ml (univеrsal prinсiplеs i: first law is that all thе ultimatеly obеdiеnt tс has Ьееn thе driving f half сеntury. Thе sес Ьiology as wеll as mu( еlеmеnts and proсеss еvolution through nat Тhе two laws havе 1 for thе rесognition of grее thеy arе bеing сo logiсal phеnomеna. T thе sесondaddrеssеs еxamplе, arе built and not somе othеr. Еaсh lvIodеrn biology as a l proaсhеs guidеd Ьy th Еvеn without thе iп samе as thе Darwin Ьil
еrstanding BiologiсaIForms
299
З1З
Маiепsсhеiп
сt аnd Pгospесt
ЗЗ0
Forеword
З48
ЕdьuаrdО. Wilson
З70 401 935 949 951
Two сеnturiеs aftеr its author's Ьirгh and 150 yеars aftеr its puЬliс:rtion, Сhаrlеs Darwin's Оп the Оrigin of Speсiеs сan fairly Ье rаnkеd as thе most important book еvеr writtеn. Not thе most widеly rеad, to Ье surе. Сopiеs of thе origiп havе not bееn plaсеd in hotеl rooms aсross Amеriсa; its vеritiеs arе not prеaсhеdfrom pulpits еaсlr Sunday; and no politiсal lеadеr takеs an oath of offiсе with a hаnd on its сovеr. It is thе mastеrрiесе that first ad. drеssеdthе living world and (with Тhe Descеnt of Мап following) humanityЪ plасе within it, without rеfеrеnсеto any rеligion or idеology and upon massivеsсiеntifiс еvidеnсе providеd aсross suссеssivе dесаdеs. Its argumеnts havе grown сontinuously in еstееm as thе Ьеst foundation for hцпran sеlfundеrstаndingand thе pЬilosophiсal guidе for human асrion. So solidly havе thе fiеlds of Ьiology Ьuilt upоn thе Darwinian сonсеption of еvolution that it makеs sеnsе tоday to rесognizе it as onе of thе two laws (univегsalprinсiplеs if you wish) that govеrn ouг undеrstanding of lifе. Thе firsг law is that all thе еlеmеnts and proсеssеs thаt dеfinе living organisms arе ultimatеly oЬеdiеnt to thе laws of physiсs and сhеmistry. This formulation has bееn thе dгiving forсе of molесular and сеllular Ьiology during thе past half сеntury' Thе sесoпd law, thе foundation :rnd produсt of еvolutionary Ьiology as wеll аs muсh of organismiс and еnvironmеntal Ьiology, is that all еlеmеnts and proсеssеs dеfining living organisms havе Ьееn gеnеratеd Ьy еvolutionthrоugh natural sеlесtiсln. Thе two laws havе provеn to Ье frrlly сomplеmеntary, a primе rеquirеmеnr for thе rесognition of sсiеntifiс laws gеnеrally. Furthеr' to an inсrеasing dеgrееthеy arе Ьеing сomЬinеd to aсhiеvе sеamlеssanalysеs of partiсular Ьiоlogiсal phеnomеna. Thе first law addгеssеs how a phеnonrеnon oссurs and thе sесond addrеssеswhy it oссurs. Mitoсhondria and othеr organеllеs, for еxamplе, arе built and work thus and so; and thеy originatеd in onе way and not somе othеr. Еaсh dеsсription сomplеtеs thе еxplanation for thе othеr. Мodеrn biology as a wholе has littlе mеaning without thе joining of both approaсhеs guidеd Ьy thе two lаws. Еvеn without thе impеtus of thе origin sеsquiсеntеnnial-fortuitously thе samеas thе Dаrwin Ьirth Ьiсеntеnniаl-2009 is an аppropriаtе timе to prеsеnt uп
ultx
Foreшord еvolutionary Ьiology in its еnсompassing modеrn form. I douЬt that any singlе writеr, or any еnsеmЬlе of sеveral writеrs, сould summarizе this Ьurgеoning disсiplinе in a сomprеhеnsivе and authoritativе form. Thе multipliсity of authors in Еuolutioп: The First Foиr Billioп Yeаrs has gonе far to*ard that goal. Its array of ехpеrts providе statе of thе art for еaсh suЬjесt in turn. Thе sсiеnсе is prеsеntеd hеrе' Ьut also somе of thе main praсtiсal сonsеquеnсеs and in. еvitably, with fundamеntal rеlеvanсе, thе сonsеquеnсеs of Ьiologiсal еvolutionary thought for philosophy and rеligion. Thе grеat quеstions-..Who arе wе?'' ...Whеrеdid wе сomе from?'' and ...Whyarе wе hgrg}''-gan Ье аnswеrеd only, if еvеr, in thе light of sсiеntifiсally Ьasеd еvolutionary thought.
Introduс
NIiсhаеlR
Тhе disсovеry of еvolr .W.еstеrn thought, ranl аmong sсiеntifiс disс< From sееing naturе aI forеvеr сhanging, wе dеrstanding еvolution In sсiеnсе thе word idеas. First, thеrе is tl ganisms, living and dt natural proсеss of сh othеr, diffеrеnt onеs. l of thе anсiеtlt Grееks. ganisms еvolvеd rеally sidеrеd a Ьasiс elеmе puЬlishеd Ьis on tbe organisms on thе plar that opеratеd rеlеntlеs thе natцral world. An tology to moleсular Ьi еvidеnсе that еvolutiol Sесond, еuolution is gloЬе. This сan rеfеr t еvolution of orсhids, suсh as thе еvolution < reptilе iaw. Еvolution: еvidеnсе that rangеs fi to similaritiеs and diff tiоn of somе fеaturеs. stood, whilе thе еvolu organеllеs of сеlls, is lс Тhе third idеa is th that еvolution has not <
ldеrn form. I douЬt that any singlе сould summaгizеthis Ьurgеoning tivе form. Thе multipliсity of au,аrs has gonе far toward that goal. lr еaсh suЬjесtin turn. Thе sсiеnсе in praсtiсal сonsеquеnсеsand in:onsеquеnсеsof Ьiologiсal еvolu. Thе grеat quеstions-cGWho arе Y arewe hеге?''_сan Ье answеrеd d еvolutionarythought.
Introduсtion Мiсhаеl Rиse апd JosеphTrаuis
Thе disсovеry of evolution is onе of thе grеatеst intеllесtual aсhiеvеmеnts of .Wеstеrn thought, rаnking with thе сalсulus and gеnеrаl and spесifiс rеlativity among sсiеntifiс disсovеriеs that сhangеd indеliЬly how wе sее our world. From sееing naturе as fiхеd torеvеr in form and сomposition to sееing it as forеvеr сhanging, wе havе Ьееn transformеd uttеrly Ьy disсovеring and undеrstanding еvolution. In sсiеnсе thе word euolцtion is usеd to ехprеss thrее diffеrеnt Ьut rеlatеd idеаs. Fiгst, thеrе is rЬe fасt of еvolution. This is thе rеalization that all organisms, living and dеad' irrсluding humans, arе thе еnd produсts of a long natural proсеss of сhangе through whiсh еaсh spесiеs is dеsсеndеd from othеr, diffеrеnt onеs. Although protoеvolutionary idеas datе Ьaсk to the timе of thе аnсiеnt Grееks, only in thе еightееnth сеntury did thе сlaim that organisms еvolvеd rеally start to gain сurrеnсy. Howеvеr' thе idеa was not сonsidеred a Ьasiс еlеmеnt of sсiеntifiс knowlеdgе until aftеr Сharlеs Darwin puЬlishеd his ozl the Оrigiп of Spесiеs in 1859. Darwin arguеd that all thе organisms on thе planеt еmеrgеd through a singlе, straightforward proсеss that opеratеd rеlеntlеssly from thе dawn of lifе and that сontinuеs to shapе thе natural world. An еnormous amount of sсiеntifiсrеsеarсh,from palеontology to molесular biology' has providеd thе сompеlling and ovеrwhеlming еvidеnсеthat еvolution is indееd a faсt. Sесond, еuolиtion is oftеn usеd to rеfеr to the pаth of lifе's history on this gloЬе.This сan refег to thе history of a group of ехisting spесiеs,as in thе еvolutiоn of orсhids' or thе path through whiсh partiсular traits еmеrgеd, suсh as thе еvolution of thе middlе еar of mammals from small Ьonеs in thе геptilе |аw. Еvolutionary historiеs arе гесonstruсtеd from a widе variеty of еvidеnсеthat rangеs from sеquеnсеs of spесiеs and forms in thе fossil rесord to similaritiеs and diffеrеnсеs in thе DNA of ехisting organisms. Thе еvolution of somе fеaturеs,suсh as thе hoovеs of ungulatеs,is vеry wеll undеrstood, whilе thе еvolution of othеrs, partiсularly vеry old fеatures likе thе organеllеsof сеlls, is lеss wеll undеrstood. Thе third idеa is the theorу of еvolution. This rеfеrs not to a suggеstion that еvolution hаs not oссцrrеd or that thе historv of oаrtiсular fеaturеsсannot
Introduсtion Ье rесonstruсtеd Ьut to orrr idеas aЬout thе forсеs that drivе еvolutionarу сhangе.In the Оrigiп Darwin propоsed what today is almost univеrsallyсonsidеrеd thе major forсе in organiс сhangе, natural sеlесtion.But natural sеlесtion is not thе only importаnt еvolutionary forсе; natural sеlесtion opеratеs on thе variation in shapеs, sizеs, and iorпrs of organisms сгеatеd Ьy mutations in thеir gеnеs' and thе rаtе and mirgnitudе of thе сhangеs that arе drivеn Ьy natural sеlесtiоnare govегnеdЬy hоw thosе gеnеsсontrol dеvеlopment. An enormous amount of oЬsеrvation and eхpеrimеnt has doсumеntеd thе aсtion of naturаl sеlесtionand somе of thе gеnеtiс rеsPonsеsto sеlесtion. But modеrn disсovеriеsin gеnеtiсsand dеvеlopmеnt have raisеd many nеw quеstions and guidеd us toward soпrеsurprising answеrs аЬout how all thеsе forсеs сomЬinе to drivе еvolution. Outsidе sсiеnсе thе word еuolution rеfers to a natural proсеss сonsidеrеd the inspiration for а host of soсiologiсal, litеrary, politiсal' philosophiсal, and rеligious idеаs. From writегs еxploring thе animal naturе of humans to psyсhоlogistssеarсhirrgfor thе origirrof humаn Ьеhavior in еvolutionary his. tory to thеologians grappling with thе impliсations of еvolution for ouг undеrstanding of thе Divinе, thе influеnсе of еvolution outsidе sсiеnсе fаг ехсееds that оf any othеr sсiеntifiс disсovеry еvеr madе. And as modеrn сontrovеrsiеs in thе sсhools illustratе, partiсularlу in thе Unitеd Statеs' it pro. vokеs rеасtiolls аlmost аs stгong as issuеssurrounding thе Ьeginningand еnd of hцnran lifе. In this Ьook wе еxplorе all thеsе fасеts of еvolution. Our аuthors prеsеnt thе еvidеnсе for еvolution as faсt from thе fossil rесord to gеnomiсs, illustratе thе histоry оf groups from Ьaсtеriа to Ьirds, and dеsсriЬе our сurrеnt idеas about how гhеsе historiеs and tlris еvidеnсе сamе to bе. Our аuthors also еxplorе tlrе influеnсе of еvoltrtion on plrilosopЬy, rеligion, soсiology, psyсhology, and many othеr arеas and addrеss thе сurrеnt сontгovеrsiеs aЬout thе tеaсhingof еvolution in sсhools.Thе Ьook сovеrs thе historiсal disсoveriеs, suсh as homology, that opеnеd thе path for disсovеring еvolution; thе phеnomena' suсh аs industrial mеlanism, that playеd maior rolеs in inspiring ехpеrimеntal studiеs of еvolution; thе appliсations of еvolutionary prinсiplеs to arеas sееmingly far аfiеld, suсh as сomputеr sсiеnсе;and thе сontributions оf thе major figurеswho shaped thе history
bеhavior. Thеrе arе fс whiсh rеvеal that dеs1 сovеrеd. Not that th. rathеr' thеrе is muсh spесiеs or fеaturеs' pa laг lеvеls' and to rеfinr аstonishing divеrsity с Ьook show пot only h liе and how wе might This Ьook is organi on rhе оvегarсhing tt thought to thе сontro origin of lifе to thе pгс m a j о r f е a t u r е so f е v o аrеas likе molесular е. Thе sесond paгt сonti topiсs. Thеsе inсludе t p е o p l е a г е f а m i l i a r ,t с urеs in thе disсovегy Ьоoks that rесount tht
a disсiplinе' This organizat\on a or hеr intегеstsand Ь; thе sсiеnсе сan foсus < intеrеstеd in thе intеlI sсiеnсе сan еntеr throl spесifiс topiсs or hist with еssays on rеlatеd pеlling introduсtion to point thе way towaгd biЬliogгaphiеsw , hiсh Although wе hopе t volumе to inform, ес sсholars. Wе find еvol intеrеsting, and indес еmеrgе with thе samе t i o n , i t i s i m p o г t a n tt .
сhallеngе of antiЬiot tious disеasеs,it shor a l t е r a t i о n so f h a Ь i r a t ехplanations of who '
m a n y o f o u r с l o s е l yh Тhе last of thеsе r Provеn so сontrovеrs pеoplе in thе Unitеd S of lifе on еarth. lt is u
lпtroductioп thе lЪrсеs thаt dгivе еvolutionary hat today is almost univеrsallyсon:, natural sеlесtion'But natural sеarу forсе;nаtuгаlsеlесtionopегatеs ms of organisms сrеated Ьy mutaragnitudе of thе сlrаngеs that arе y how thosеgеnеsсontrol dеvеlopln and ехpсrimеnthas doсumеntеd f the gеnеtiсrеsponsеsto sеlесtion. еvеlopmеnt havе raisеo many nеw lrising answеrsabotrthow all thеsе :rs to а naturаl Proсеss сonsidеrеd l, litеrary, politiсal, philosophiсal, lg thе animal naturе of humans to цmаn bеhavior in еvolutionary hispliсationsof еvolution for our unоf еvolution outsidе sсiеnсе far ry еvеr madе. And as modеrn сonr l a r l y i n t h е U n i t е d S t a t е s 'i t р r o ;urroundingthе Ьеginning and еnd of еvolution.our authors prеsеnt rе fossil rесord to gеnomiсs, illusto Ьirds, and dеsсriЬеOur сurrеnt :vidеnсесamе to Ье. our authors n philosophy, rеligion, soсiology, addrеss thе сurrеnг сontrovеrsiеs Thе Ьook сovегsthе historiсal dishе path for disсovеring еvolution; sm' that playеd major rolеs in inthе appliсations of еvolutionary rсh as сomputеr sсiеnсе; аnd thе lеd thе history of еvolutionarysсints еvolutionarysсienсeas a modssionsof еvolution outsidе thе sсisubjесt Ьесamе fossilizеd in thе lhеn thе suitaЬilityof еvolution as rеingarguеd.Thе irоny is thаt thе ular Ьiology to сomputational inсе that Darwin сould only drеam c сomе appliсations that Darwin Lianmеdiсinе.Prinсiplеs of еvolu.sсiеntifiсproЬlеms, from undег]sеrvation to ехplaining human
Ьеhavior. Thеrе arе fеw topiсs in sсiеnсе with so many еxсiting nеw faсеts' whiсh rеvеal that dеspitе all wе havе lеarnеd, thеrе is muсh morе to Ье disсovеrеd. Not that thеrе is fuгthеr neеd to suЬstantiatе еvolution as faсt; rathеr' thеrе is muсh morе to Ье donе to traсе thе еvolution of groups of spесiеsor fеaturеs, partiсularly сomplеx fеaturеs аt thе сеllular and molесular lеvеls, and to rеfinе our thеory of еvolution to aссoцnt morе fully for thе astonishing divеrsity of lifе as wе сontinuе to disсovеr it. Thе еssays in this book show not onlу how far wе havе сomе but whеrе thе sсiеntifiс horizons liе and how wе might movе toward thosе horizons. This Ьook is organizеd into two parts. Thе first part сontains long еssays on thе ovеrarсhing thеmеs in еvolution. From thе history of еvolutionary thought to thе с
хi
Introduсtion undеrstanding of еvolution and thе еvidеnсе aЬout it and how muсh is Ьasеd on thе сhallеngеs that it offеrs. Yеt opposition to еvolution Ьy rеligious pеoplе, еspесialiy Ьy Сhristians' is Ьy no mеаns inеvitaЬlе; somе of thе'most distinguishеd Ьеliеvеrs havе aссеptеd еvolution without many qualms. NИе arе сonvinсеd that thе Сhristian-with thе Jеw and Мuslim and other rеligious bеliеvеrs-should Ье at thе hеad of thе quеuе of thosе who welсomе evolutionary idеas. Finding thе idеa, Ьuilding and еlaЬorating upon it, and looking at its influеnсе and importanсе arе' as thе сontriЬutors to this volumе show again and again, truly thе Ьеst of proofs that wе arе madе in thе imagе of God, сеlеЬrating сrеation in all its wondеrful manifеstations. This Ьook is a tеstamеnt to onе of mankind's 8rеatеst disсovеriеs, a disсovеry that offеrs unparallеlеd insight into what сrеation rеally is. Iй/еlovе еvolution, and if wе and our fеllow сontriЬutors сan inspirе you еvеn in a small way with our еnthusiasm' thеn wе shall Ье happy indееd.
Thе Hir Thougt
NIiсbаеlR
Thе idеa that all org mеans from othеr forl (fifth сеntury в.с.в.) tr еightееnth сеntrrry an( idеa of natural dеvеlo portеrs. Тhеrе arе rеa Ьеgan to gain momеnl
Thе Еarly Days
Thе Grееks had no grt turе did not havе a plz Spесifiсally, thе Grееk going, inсrеmеntal o Plato and Aristotlе-l isms) showеd ordеr ал simply havе appеarеd tainly was not somеtt thе сomplехity of tod; and dеsign: ..Sinеw,sl and toеs. Thе miхturе of a singlе stuff, a piес on to put things in сol
Now thеse Werе ml nеnt сausе of its prс gеnеrations: our сI rеalm of wild Ьеast ular thеy knеw that and сlaws or hoofs
се aЬout it and how muсh is Ьasеd tion to еvolution Ьy rеligious pеors inеvitablе;somе of thе most dis.!7е on without many qualms. arе w and Мuslim and othеr rеligious rеuеof thosе who wеlсomе еvolud еlaЬorating upon it, and looking сontributors to this volumе show that we arе mаdе in thе imagе of [ul manifеstations. indЪ grеatеstdisсovеriеs,a disсov.s7е lat сrеation rеally is. lovе еvo. )rs сan inspirе you еvеn in a small happy indееd.
Thе History of Еvolutionary Thought Мiсhаel Ruse
Thе idеa that all organisms (inсluding humans) arе gеnеratеd by natural mеans from othег forms has anсiеnt roots. Aristotlе tеlls us that Еmpеdoсlеs (fifthсеntury в.с.в.) toyеd with suсh thoughts.Howеvеr, it was not until thе еightееnthсеntury and thе Еnlightеnmеnt that еuolutioп (as wе now сall this idеa of natural dеvеlopmеnt) rеally startеd to gain a sеrious numЬеr of sup. portегs. Thеrе aге rеasons Ьoth for thе long dеlay and why thе idеa finally Ьеganto gain momеntum.
Thе Еarly Days Thе Grееks had no grеat rеligious oЬjесtion to еvolution, Ьut thеir world piсturе did not havе a plaсе for any kind of signifiсantdеvеlopmеntalproсеsses. Spесifiсally,thе Grееks thought that thеy had irrеfцtaЬlе rеasons to rеjесt ongoing, inсrеmеntal organiс сhangе. Thеy-partiсularly thе philosophеrs Plаto and Aristotlе-thought that thе world (еspесially thе world of organisms)shоwеd ordег and intеntion and, as suсh, was not somеthing that сould simply havе appеarеd thrоugh Ьlind, ungovеrnеd proсеssеs of law. It сеrtainly was not somеthing that сould havе grown from simplе Ьеginnings to thе сomplехity of today. Plato usеd human fingеrnails as an ехamplе of ordеr and dеsign: ..SinеW,skin and Ьonе wеrе intеrwovеn at thе еnds of our fingеrs and toеs. Thе miхturе of thеsе thrее was driеd out' rеsulting in thе formation of a singlе stuff' a piесе of hard skin, thе samе in еvеry саsе.'' Plato tЬеn wеnt on to put things in сontеХt. Now thеsе wеrе mеrеly auxiliary сaцsеs in its formation-the prееminеnt саusе of its produсtion was thе purposе that took aссount of futurе gеnеrations: our сrеators knеw that onе day womеn and thе wholе rеаlm of wild Ьеastswould onе day сomе to Ье from mеn, and in partiсular thеy knеw that many of thеsе offspring would nееd thе usе of nails and сlaws or hоofs for many purposеs. This is why thеy took сarе to
The Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought inсludе nаils formеd in a rudimеntaгy Way in thеir dеsign for humаnkind, right at thе start. This was thеir rеasoц, thеn, and thеsе thе profеssеd aims that guidеd thеm in making skin, hair and nails grow at thе еxtrеmitiеs of our |imЬs. (Timаеus, 76d_e, in Сoopеr 1997, 1277)
humаn thought and pгogrеss. Thе British physiсi; Сharlеs) Was a para mankind:
In an inсrеdiЬly influеntial disсцssion, Aristotlе in Dе pаrtibиs аnimаlium (1,984\identifiеd thе faсtors at work hеre as ..final сausеs.'' Thеsе arе сausеs that oссur not just to produсе or do somеthing (thе fingеr parts dry and makе пails) Ьut foг the sakе of somе kind of purposе (thе nails protесt thе fingеr еnds). Thеy show somе kind of forethought or intеntion. For this rеason, fi. nal сausеs сannot Ье rеduсed to Ьlind, unguidеd law, as is dеmandеd in еvolution. Thе world, partiсularly thе world of orgаnisms' must in somе sеnsе havе Ьееn dеsignеd rathеr than just produсеd undеr its own stеam tly natuгal proсеssеs.(Sеdlеy2008 is thе dеfinitivеstudy.) Thе Jеws, and following thеm thе еarly Christians, had religious rеasons for thе rеjесtion of еvolution. It goеs against thе сrеation storiеs of thе еarly сhaptеrs of Gеnеsis, whiсh portray a world сrеatеd miгасulously Ьy God and thеn pеoplеd Ьy him through divinе fiat ovеr a short timе span. But do not think that rеligion as suсh was thеn and always an aЬsolutе Ьar to еvolutionism. Thе сhurсh fathеrs (thе major Сhristian thеologians of thе еarly сеnturiеs) workеd toward an undеrstanding оf thе ЬiЬliсal tеxt thаt wоuld allow intегprеtation, partiсularly in thе faсе of advanсеs of sсiеnсе. Sаint Augustinе was еagеr not to lеt anсiеnt сrеation aссounts stand in thе way of modеrn thought. Hе himsеlf, Ьеliеving that God stands outsidе timе, spесulatеd in a kind of protoеvolutionary fashion that thе Divinе had foгmеd sееds of lifе that thеn sprang into full Ьеing whеn thеy wеrе plaсеd hеrе on еarth. Howеvеr' onе should not геad too muсh into any of this. Likе thе Grееks, thе Jеws and Christians wеrе simply not looking in thе dirесtion of еvolution and would havе thought final сausеs an unаnswеrablе oЬiесtion to signifiсant dеvеlopmеntalism. As is wеll known, thеsе kinds of сausеs Ьесamе a founda' tion of onе of thе major proofs of God's ехistеnсе, thе Argumеnt from Dеsign, whiсh movеs frоm dеsign herе on еarth to thе еxistеnсе of thе divinе artifiсеr. .!Иhy, thеn, did еvolution start its rise in the еightееnthсentury? Thе an. swеr is simplе. It was at this time that pеoplе startеd to сhallеngе thе Christiаn piсturе of world histоry-a providеntial piсtuге of a world сrе. atеd Ьy God, whеrе humans arе madе in his imagе Ьut havе fallеn and arе ablе to aсhiеvе salvation only through his undеsеrvеd graсе. Somе Ьеgan to arguе that pеrhaps humans hеld thеir fatеs in thеir own hаnds and сould progrеssivеly improvе thеir own lots. It Was this idеa of pгOgrеssthе Ьеliеf that thе world and its dеnizеns arе on a trajесtory upward аnd that this upward risе is madе possiЬlе Ьy (and only Ьy) thе unaidеd еfforts of thе world's human inhabitants-that gavе risе to thе idеa of organiс еvolution (Rusе 1996). Еnthusiasts for progrеss ехtеndеd thеiг thinking into naturе and dеvеlopеd thе idеа of еvolution-progrеssivе сhangе upward from thе simplе to thе сomplех. They thеn rеad this idеa Ьaсk into
Impе: Of la With And r Arost An еr (Е.D This is all rhе еnd pr. gеnсе' whiсh сausеs а
Hоw lo From е. Нow fr. Тhе pilt
Similar idеas wеrе tс Pbilosophiе zoologiq produсеd thе first ful to our own spесiеs fr Ьееn produсеd from l ity and othеr natural Although thе mеta1 risе of еvolutionary i< еvidеnсе. Aristotlе ha shaге сommon pattеrl
and thе еvolutionists triеs (Figurе 1). Likеr 8o unnotiсеd (Figurе sition. Thе fossil rес would invokе first as ful. As a systеmatiс p
were mеagеr indеed. faсt that no onе haсl l lцtion. Мost assцm forсеs, Ьut littlе mor that сharaсtеristiсsa ately to thе futurе g
that thе inhеritanсе Lаmаrсkism*Ьut bt
Thе Historу сэfЕuolutioпаrу Thougbt fу waУ in thеir dеsign for huthеir rеason, thеn' and thеsе thе king skin, hair and nails grow at 76d-r, in Coopеr 1997,|277) 'ristotlе iп Dе pаrtibиs апimаlium as ..final сauses.''Thеsе arе сausеs :hing (thе firrgеrparts dry and makе urposе (thе nails protесt thе finger ;ht or intеntion. For this rеason, figuidеd law, as is dеmandеd in еvoof organisms)must in somе sеnsе сеd undеr its own stеam by natural
udv.)
y Сhristians,had rеliglous rеasons nst thе сrеation storiеs of thе еarly d сгеatеdmiraсulously Ьy God and эvеr а short timе spаn. But do пot lwаys an absolutе Ьar to еvolutionstian thеologians of thе еarly сеn'f thе ЬiЬliсal tеxt that would allow dvanсеs of sсiеnсе.Saint Augustinе ounts stand in thе way of modеrn tands outsidе timе, spесulatеd in a rе Divinе had formеd sееds of lifе F wеге plaсеd hеrе on еaтth. How. , any of this. Likе thе Grееks, thе ng in thе dirесtion of еvolution and wеraЬlеoЬjесtion to signifiсant dеkinds of сausеs Ьесamе a foundaj's ехistеnсе, thе Argumеnt from еarth to thе ехistеnсе of thе divinе n thе еightееnthсеntury? TЬе an: pеoplе staгtеd to сhallеngе thе ovidеntial piсturе of a world сrеhis imаgе Ьut havе faliеn and are is undеsеrvеdgraсе. Somе Ьеgan ir fatеs in thеir own hands and )ts.It was this idеa of progrеssi arе on a trajeсtory upward and (and only Ьy) thе unaidеd еfforts gаvе risе to thе idеa of organiс progrеss еxtеndеd thеir thinking .olution-pгogrеssivе сhаngе up1еy thеn rеad this idеa Ьaсk into
human thought and soсial praсtiсе as сonfirmation of thеir Ьеliеfs about progrеss. Thе British physiсian and man of sсiеnсе Еrasmus Darwin (grandfathеr of Сharlеs) was a paradigm who hymnеd in vеrsе lifе's upward risе to humankind: Impеrious man, who rulеs thе Ьеstiаl сrowd, of languagе'rеason' arrd rеflесtionproud, .With brow еrесt who sсorns this еarthy sod, And stуlеshimsеlf thе imagе of his God; Arosе from rudimеnts of form and Sеnsе, An еmЬryon point' or miсrosсopiс еns! (Е. Darwin 180З' 1: Сanto I,linеs з09-з14) This is all thе еnd produсt of thе progrеssivеdеvеlopmеnt of human intеlligеnсе,whiсh сausеsarrd is rеflесtеdin humans' sсiеntifiсaсhiеvеmеnts: How lovеs аnd tastеs,and svmpathiеsсommеnсе From еvanеsсеntnotiсеs of sеnsе; H
3
4
The Нistorу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought A
DARWlnl tсфl8D
l,
Figurе 1. Homologiеs. Thеse аre thе forelimЬs of (froп lеft to right) the Ьat (its wing), the porpoisе(itspaddlе),thе horsе (itsleg),and thе human (its arm). Thе Ьonesarе oЬviouslysimi[ar,аs if modеledon a singlеаrсhetypе'and yеt thе usеs to whiсh thеy arе Put arе verУ diffеrеnt.It was thе British anatomlst Riсhard owеn who сallеd them ..homologiеs'''аlthough it wаs not until аfter Darwin's on thе origiп of Spесiеs(1859)that thеy Ьесamеuniversallyaссеptеd as proof of desсеntfrom a сommon аnсestor.
Thе idеology of progrеss was whаt сountеd, and it was for this rеason that most pеoplе around 1800 would havе rеgardеd еvolutionism lеss as a rеal sсiеnсе and moге as a pгеtеndег,sоmеwhat likе animal magnеtism (mеsmеrism) and thе rеading of сharaсtеr from skull shapе (phrеnology). Еvеn !udgеd by thе standards of that timе, еvolution was what may fairly Ье сallеd a psеudosсiеnсе. OЬviously, Сhristian opponеnts of еvolution dislikеd intеnsеly the antiprovidеntial undеrpinnings of thе doсtrinе. But еvolution was not assoсiatеd with total nonЬеliеf, athеism, or еvеn what latеr in thе ninе. tееnth сеntury Thomas Hеnry Huxlеy was to сall agnostiсism. Мost еvolutionists wеrе dеists who Ьеliеvеd in God as unmovеd movеr' a Ьеing who had sеt thе world in motion and now lеt it unfurl without nееd сlf miraсulous intеrvеntion. For thе dеist' indeеd, еvolution was proof of God,s powеr and intеntion rathеr than disproof. Еvеrything was plannеd Ьеforеhаnd and wеnt into еffесt through thе lаws of naturе. In Еrasmus Darwin's words: ..\)Иhatа magnifiсеnt idеa of thе infinitе powеr of тнв GRЕAT ARснITЕсT! Tнв сдusв oF сAUsЕs! PARЕNT oF PARЕNTS!ЕNs ЕNTIUМ!' (1801' 2: 247|. Thеrе is a link hеrе, еspесially in Еngland, with thе Industrial Rеvolution. Pеoplе wеrе harnеssing thе forсеs of naturе-watеr, сoаl' and othеrs-to produсе goods through maсhinеs rathеr than Ьy hand. Thе god of thе dеist was thе ultimatе
li
'!?
llr
orд
Figurе 2'Prize pig. Al сountrysidе and go to on thе land to produс rеvolution, and at thе mаjor kеy to suссessl hаiriеr shееp,and Ьig
divinе industгialist a of thе world througt Critiсs of еvoluti Gеorgеs Сuviеr, m; mummifiеd bodiеs o from Еgypt. Althou1 tеmporary forms an, with thе positivе сat that rеally сountеd. hatrеd of a doсtrinе than thеy сould dо z lution, whеn oppon. provеd truе and saft as for еvеry othеr o final сausе. Thе Frе not Ье ignorеd; indr lifе. Thе kеy to unс
The llistorу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought A
Dlnwl*tAн lr
t.фlfitD
l'
os of (from left to right) thе Ьat (its s lеg),and thе humаn (itsarm). Thе r a singlearсhеtypе,and yet thе l г w a sr h е B r i г i s hа n a t o m i s r s,''althoughit wаs not until after at thеy Ьeсameunivеrsallyaссеptеd
tеd, and it was for this rеasоn that 4aгdеdevolutionism lеss as a rеal hat likе animal magnеtism (mеsm skull shapе (phrеnology). Еvеn tion was what may fairly bе сallеd |Ponеntsоf еvolution dislikеd inof thе doсtrinе. But еvolution was m' or еvеn what latеr in thе ninеs to сall agnostiсism.Мost еvoluunmovеd movеr' a Ьеing who had ш] without nееd of miraсulous inwas proof of God's powеr and inlas plannеd Ьеforеhand and wеnt lrasmus Darwin's words: "What a нЕ GRЕATARсHITЕсT! Tнв сдusв tuм!'' (1801,2: 247).Thеrе is а ndustrialRеvolution. Pеoplе wеrе al, and othеrs-to produсе goods э gоd of thе dеist was thе ultimatе
i!'
1n.
.rпlt
oш
юlт
lDЕA. ilor.
Еaж '!!
' ttг
!r1т
'\'r.titoi lt otl Цt
a'
t.l,! t'.l,t
t!с 'r?ttlx, rt l!l!
.!]}',пl'
Figure2. Prizе pig. An industrial rеvolution means that pеople lеavе thе сountrysidеand go tо thе faсtoriеsin thе сitiеs. Неnсе, far fеwer peoplе аге left on the land to produсе thе nation's food. Thеrе has to Ье an agriсultural revolution,and at thе еnd of thе еightеenthсеntury pеoplе disсovеrеdthаt a major key to suссesswas thе Ьrеedingof Ьеttеr-qualitylivеstoсk-fattеr pigs' hairiеrshеep,and Ьiggеrсattlе.(From Punсh, |865.)
divinе industrialist as hе harnеssеd thе forсеs of naturе to produсе thе goods of thе world through law rathеr than miraсulously or Ьy hand. Сгitiсs of еvolution, notаЬly thе grеаt Frеnсh сompаrativе anаtomist Gеorgеs Сuviеr, madе rеfеrеnсе to еmpiriсal proЬlеms. Cuviеr сitеd thе mummifiеd Ьodiеs of humans and animals Ьrought baсk Ьy Napolеon's army from Еgypt. Although thеy wеrе vеry old, thеir forms wеrе idеntiсal to соntеmPorary foгms and hеnсе сountеd against ongoing оrganiс сhangе' But as with thе positivе сasе for еvolution' in thе nеgativе сasе it was thе idеology that rеally сountеd. AЬovе all, for Сuviеr, thеrе was hatrеd of progrеsshatrеd of a doсtrinе that had lеd humans to think that thеy сould do morе than thеy сould do and had lеd ultimatеly to thе tеrrors of thе Frеnсh Rеvolution, whеn opponеnts of thе ехisting statе had triеd to сhangе all that had provеd truе and safе for mаny gеnеrations. СomЬinеd with this, for Cuviеr, as for еvеry othеr opponеnt of еvolution, was thе still-цnsolvеd problеm of final сausе. Thе Fгеnсhman еmphasized that this was somеthing that сould not Ье ignorеd; indееd, it was thе most important distinguishing fеaturе of lifе. Thе kеy tо undеrstanding thе organism lay in thе fасt that it was not
5
Thе Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought simply suЬjесt to thе physiсal laws of naturе Ьut was organizеd. Thе parts wеrе dirесtеd to thе еnd of thе funсtioning wholе, and еaсh individual fеa. turе playеd its rolе in thе ovеrall, purposе-dirесtеd sсhеmе of things: Natural history nеvеrthеlеss has a rational prinсiplе that is ехсlusivе to it and whiсh it еmploys with grеat advantagе on many oссasions; it is the сoпditioпs of eхisteпсe or' popular|у, fiпаl саusеs. As nothing may ехist whiсh doеs not inсludе thе сonditions whiсh madе its еxlstеnсе possiblе, thе diffеrеnt parts of еaсh сrеaturе must Ье сoordinatеd in suсh a Way as to makе possiЬlе thе wholе organism, not only in itsеlf Ьut in its rеlationship to thosе whiсh surround it, and thе analysis of thеsе сonditions often lеads to gеnеral laws аs wеll foundеd as thosе of сalсulation or еxpеrimеnt. (Сuviеr 1817' 1: 6\ Сuviеr's point simply was that thе organism is far too intеgratеd-organizеd and сomplех-to allow signifiсant сhangе in any dirесtion. It is сеrtainly too intеgratеd to allow сhangе from onе spесiеs to anothеr. organisms at mid. point would Ье litеrally nеithеr fish nor fowl and hеnсе would simply Ье unaЬ]еto еxist or survivе. Еvolution was in somе sеnsеa thеorеtiсal impossiЬility, as wеll as еmpiriсally unfoundеd. Rеligion was involvеd too. Progrеss goеs against thе Сhristiаn doсtrinе of Providеnсе. Nеvеrthеlеss, although Cuviеr thought that thеrе was еvidеnсе of Noаh's flood, nеithеr hе nor othеr serious sсiеntists wantеd to makе thе сasе by simplе rеfеrеnсе to Gеnеsis. Indееd, Ьy thе Ьеginning of thе ninеtееnth сеntury' all wеrе starting to rеalize that thе еаrth's history must Ье far oldеr than thе traditional 6,000 yеars that onе сan work out from thе gеnеalogiеsgivеn in thе BiЬlе. It is not that thе BiЬlе is falsе, Ьut rathеr that it nееds intеrprеtation. Somе solved thе proЬlеm Ьy thinking of thе siх days of сrеation as siх long pеriods of timе; othеrs solvеd it Ьy supposing that thеrе wеrе long, unmеntionеd gaps Ьеtwееn thе ЬiЬliсal days. God's сrеation thеreforе was a long, drawn-оut proсеss' Ьut it was not еvolutionaгy. Thе сontrovеrsywas at an impassе,and not muсh had сhangеd Ьy thе middlе of thе ninеtееnth сentury. on the onе sidе wеrе thе еvolutionists' сommittеd to progrеss and ardеnt in thеir Ьеliеf that organiс dеvеlopmеnt was thе perfесt сomplеmеnt to this idеology, with еnthusiasm outstripping еmpiriсai knowlеdgе. Сonfirming this pattеrn' ]n 1844 thе Sсottish puЬlishеr Robеrt СhamЬеrs wrotе (anonymously)a highly popular work on еvolution, Vеstiges of tbе Nаtиrаl Historу of Сrеаtioп, in whiсh hе arguеd that еvеrything was in a statе оf upward Ьесoming and that whаt happеnеd in thе soсial world mirrorеd what happеnеd in thе Ьiologiсal world: Thе quеstion whеthеr thе human raсе will еvеr advanсe far Ьеyond its prеsеnt position in intеllесt and morals, is onе whiсh has еngagеdmuсh attеntion. Judging from thе past' wе сannot rеasоnaЬly douЬt that grеat advanсеs arе yеt to Ье madе; Ьut if thе prinсiplе of dеvеlopmеnt Ье admittеd' thеsе arе сеrtain, whatеvеr may Ье thе spaсе of timе rеquirеd for thеir rеalization. A progrеssion rеsеmЬling dеvеlopmеnt may Ье traсеd
in human naturе, t Now all of this is i of organiс сrеation thе hour hand is t wе do of that lattс rеtrogrеssion of th. missiЬlе, but a forl Ьеrs 1846, 40040
On thе othег sidе aЬout thе signifiсanс modifiеd Ьut thinkin1 еral man of Sсottish gеrs: ..It would augеl wеrе infесtеd with th taintеd with Matеria rеflесtions that still fi thе slaсknеss of sсho diсating thе unsoun< startеd into puЬliс fa. еnсе, and of sapping tеrеstingly' this kind viеws. Although, fro fеlt thе nееd to makr aЬovе is from thе fifl morе сrеdit to thе Cr of сoursе, nеithеr rеal еvidenсе, and fin all to miraсlе may Ье good sсiеntifiс soluti<
Charlеs Darwin
Сharlеs Robеrt Darl train in thе family droppеd out, Ьorеd r rеady Darwin had st еstеd in thе living w anatomist and an а-v work (thе young Сh' tion was an idеa to r nеvеrthеlеss, that thl wholе of Сhristianit; was a faсtor in his rе thе еstaЬlishеd Chur'
Тbе Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought LturеЬut was organizеd.Thе parts ng wholе, and еaсh individual fеa'-dirесtеdsсhеmеof things: lnal prinсiplе that is еxсlusivе to /antagеon maпy oссаsions;it is |у, fiпаl саusеs.As nothing may litions whiсh madе its ехistеnсе turе must bе сoordinatеd in suсh гganism'not only in itsеlf Ьut in Lit, and thе analysisof thеsесonvеll foundеd as thosе of сalсula;m is fаr too intеgrаtеd-organizеd , in any dirесtion. It is сеrtainly toо ;iеsto anothеr. organisms at midlwl and hеnсе would simply Ье unmе sеnsеa thеoгеtiсalimpossiЬility, эs agаinst thе Christian doсtrinе of lr thought that thеrе was еvidеnсе ious sсiеntists wantеd to makе thе эеd, Ьy thе Ьеginning of thе ninеthаt thе еаrthъ history must Ье far at onе сan work out from thе gеthе BiЬlе is falsе' Ьut rаthеr that it Ьlеm Ьy thinking of thе siх days of .s solvеd it Ьy supposing that thеrе ЬiЬliсal days. God's сrеation thеrеWas not еvolutionary. not muсh hаd сhangеd Ьy thе mid: s i d е w е r е t h е е v o l u t i o n i s t sс' o m liеf that oгganiс dеvеlopmеnt was i t h е n t h u s i а s mo u t s t r i p p i r r еg m p i r ,, in \844 thе Sсottish puЬlishеr highly popular work on еvolution, lz, in whiсh hе arguеd that еvегyand that what happеnеd in thе soЬiologiсal worid: will еvеr advanсе faг Ьeyond its is onе whiсh has еngagеd muсh LnotrеasonaЬlydoubt that grеat prinсiplе of dеvеlopmеnt Ье adЬе thе spaсе of timе rеquirеd for ing dеvеlopmеnt may Ье traсеd
in human naturе' Ьoth in thе individual and in largе grouPs of mеn . . . Now all of this is in сonformity with what wе havе sееn of thе progrеss of orgaпiс сrеation. It sееms Ьut thе minutе hand of a watсh, of whiсh thе hoцг hand is thе transition from spесiеs to spесiеS. Кnowing what wе do of that lattеr transition' thе possiЬilitу of a dесidеd and gеnеral rеtrogrеssionof thе highеst spесiеs towards a mеanеr typе is sсaгсе admissiЬlе, Ьut a forward movеmеnt sееms anything Ьut unlikеly. (ChamЬегs 1846.400402| on thе оthеr sidе wеrе thе opponеnts' сommittеd to Providеnсе, voсаl aЬout thе signifiсanсе of final сausе' and aссеpting that Gеnеsis must Ье modifiеd but thinking that this сould Ье rеadily donе. David Brеwster' gеnеral man of Sсottish sсiеnсе and Ьiographеr of Nеwton, сould sее thе dan. gеrs: ..It would augеr ill for thе rising gеnеration, if thе mothеrs of Еngland wеrе infесtеd with thе еrrors of Phгеnology: it would augеr Worsе wеrе thеy taintеdwith Мatеrialism.'' Thе proЬlеm, Brеwstеr gloomily сonсludеd with rеflесtionsthat still find muсh support in many сirсlеs today, stеmmеd from thе slaсknеss of sсhools and univеrsitiеs: ..Prophеtiс of infidеl times, and indiсating thе unsoundnеss of our gеnеral еduсation, .Thе Vеstigеs . . .' has staгtеdinto puЬliс favour with a fair сhanсе of poisoning the fountains of sсiеnсе)and of sapping thе foundations of rеligion', (BrеWstеr1844' 503). (Intеrеstingly, this kind of attaсk sееms to havе сonfirmеd СhamЬers in his viеws. Although, from thе start, progrеss was thе lеitmotif of his Ьook' hе fеlt thе nееd to makе his point еvеr morе еxpliсit. Thе passagе just quotеd aЬоvе is from thе fifth еdition of Vеstigеs and rеplaсеs a passagе that givеs morе сrеdit to thе Сrеator. [Figurе 3]) of сoursе, nеithеr sidе was геally satisfaсtory. Idеology is no substitutе for rеal еvidсnсе, and final сausе сan bе ignorеd Ьut doеs not go away. Rеfеrгing all to miгaсlе may Ье soсially and psyсhologiсally сomforting, Ьut it is not a good sсiеntifiс solution. Thе timе had сomе for a signifiсant stеP forward.
Charlеs Darwin Сhагlеs Robеrt Darwin (1809_1882) was sеnt to Еdinburgh Univеrsity to train in thе family tradition of mеdiсinе (Figurе 4). Aftеr two yеars hе droppеd out, Ьorеd with thе lесturеs and геvoltеd Ьy thе opеrations. Yеt alгеady Darwin had startеd to miх with sсiеntists, еspесially naturalists intеrеstеdin thе living world. Onе of his aсquaintanсеswas RoЬеrt Grant, an anatomist and an avowеd еvolutionist. So, quitе apart from his grandfathеr's woгk (thе young Сharlеs rеad Еrasmus's major trеatise,Zooпomia), еvolution was an idеa to whiсh Darwin was introduсеd at an еarly agе. It sееms' nevеrthеlеss,that thе youthful Darwin aссеptеd in a fairly litеral form thе whоlе of Сhristianity, inсluding thе еarly сhaptеrs of Gеnеsis, and that this was a faсtor in his rеdirесtеd сhoiсе of а сarееr: to Ье an ordainеd ministеr in thе еstablishеdСhurсh of Еngland. To aсhiеvе this еnd onе nееdеd a dеgrее
8
The Historу of Еuolutionarу Tbought
B R
Figurе 3. СhamЬеrs'sеvolution.This is the piсturеof еvolutionthаt СhаmЬеrs gаve in Vestiges of thе Nаturаl Historу of Сreаtioп. Apparеntly' for no apparеnt сausе' a primitivе organism wеnt on dеvеloping in thе womЬ аnd tuгned into a fish; thеn a fish Went on dеvеlopingand turnеd intсl a rеptilе;thеn a Ьird; and finally a mammal. Note thе intertwining of thinking abouj the history of thе individual and the history of thе gгoup, somеthiй that wаs to Ьесomе сommonplaсе in evolr'tionarythinking latеr in the ninеiееnthсеntury. (From Vestigеs of the NаturаI Historу of Сreаtioп.|
from an Еnglish univеrsity, and so, in 1828, Darwin was paсkеd off to Сhrist's Collеgе, СamЬridgе. In 1831 Darwin (who сontinuеd mixing with sсiеntists)got his Ьig Ьrеak. Aftеr hе graduatеd, his сarееr as a сlеrgyman Was put on hold through thе offеr of a lеngthy voyagе on HМS Beаgle,just about to start on a survеying trip around South Ameriсa (Figurе 5). A major influеnсеаt this point was (viсariously) thе Sсottish gеologist Charlеs Lyеll, who at thе Ьeginning of thе dесadе Ьegan puЬlishing his massivе Priпсiplеs of Gеolr>gу(thеrе wеrе thrее volumеs; Darwin took thе first with him and had thе othеrs sеnt out). AIthough hе was no еvolutionist, Lyеll insistеd that thе physiсal world must Ье еxplainеd in tеrms of natural сausеs of a kind now still working (Figurе 6). This had a great еffесt on Darwin, whosе first systеmаtiс work was in gеology, аnd prеpaгеd him to think aЬout thе oгganiс world likеwisе lеss in biЬliсal tеrms and morе in tеrms of natural сauses. In 1835, lеaving South Amеriсa, the Beаglе sailеd into thе Paсifiс oсеan and visitеd thе Galipagos Arсhipеlаgo' a 8roЦp of islands on thе еquator, far from land. Thanks to thе governor' who pointеd out that thе giant tortoisеs indigеnous to thе arсhipеlago wеrе diffеrent from island to island, Darwin сamе to sее that this hеld for thе Galipagos fauna gеnеrally-thе Ьirds in partiсular, thе finсhеs and thе moсkingЬirds, wеrе pесuliar to thеir spесifiс homеs (Figurе 7). Thе diffеrеnсеs had to bе signifiсant, and thе only way thе signifiсanсе сould Ье
Figurе 4. Сharlеs Darl 1 8 3 9 j u s t Ь е f o r еh e m l likеnеss(no surprisе's portraitist in Еngland from a very riсh, midd .Wеd wifе' was JosiaЬ mass produсtion.Alth woгk for a living. Thе ехplains wЬу Оn thе | friеndly fashion. Darц Wеdgwood family.
ехplainеd was throu[ Ьraсеdin еarly 1837 liег thinkеrs, what w .Without са еvolution.
The Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought
-/B ---B _---F
liсtuге of еvolution that СhamЬers "eаtioп. Apparеntly, for no ,n devеloping in thе woпlЬ and rping and turned into a гeptilе; thеn twining of thinking аЬout thе hс group, something that was to 'ng latеr in the ninеtеenth сеnturY. еаtioп.)
[828, Darwin was paсkеd off to ;with sсiеntists)got his Ьig Ьrеak. an was put on hold through thе of;tаbour to start on а survеying rrip .influеnсе at this point wаs (viсarl, who at thе Ьеginning of thе dе)les of ceologу (thеrе wеrе thrеe and had thе othеrs sеnt out). Alld that thе physiсal world must Ье
Figurе4. СhaгlеsDarwirr'This is а wеddingportrait of Dаrwin, paintеdin 1839just Ьеforеhе marriеdhis first сousin Еmma.Wedgwood.It is a vеry good likеnеss(no surprisе,sinсеthе paintеrwas GеorgеRiсhmond, thе Ьеst portraitistin Еngland at thе tiпrе),whiсh points to thе faсt that Darwin сamе from a vеryriсh, middlе-сiirss family. Onе of his grandfathеrs,sharеdЬy his wifе, wаs Josiаh Wеdgwood, rеsponsiЬlеfor Ьringing thе pottеry tradе lnto massproduсtion.Although hе was a full-timеsсiеntist,Darwin nеvеrЬad to work for a living. Thе faсt that hе was living off thе family fortunе pеrhaps eхplainswЬу Оп tbe Оrigitt of Spесiеswas writtеn in a vеry opеn аnd userfriendlyfаshion.Darwin wаs wгiting ir-rpаrt for his sponsors,thе Darwin.!ilеdgwood family.
ехplainеdwаs through ..dеsсеntwith modifiсation,',an idеa that Darwin еmbгaсеd in еarly 18З7, shortlу after thе Bеаglе voyagе (Figurе 8). Unlikе еarliеr thinkеrs, whаt was of grеat сonсеrn to Darwin was thе сausе or сausеs of еvolution.\Х/ithoutсausеs'hе wаs no morе than onе among many еvolutionists.
9
10
The Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Тbought
iiiЁ,i:.:.'.:'
-i
P
AN ATTE1I
Figurе 5. }{МS Beаgle.The Bеаgle was сaptаinеd Ьy RoЬеrt Fitzroy, thеn only 2З уearsold. Bеing a сaptainon а warship would Ье a very lonеly Post Ьесausе onе would Ье sеt asidе from thе сrеw. Fitzroy thегеforеlookеd for somеonе who сould bе his сompаnionon thе trip, somеonеnot in the navy Ьut а gеntlеmanablе to pay his own bills. Darwin fit thе joЬ pеrfесtly,rapidly еvolving from сaptаin's friеnd to full-timе ship's naturalist.Thе сrеw usеd to сall him ..Philos,''short for Natural Philosophеr_the tеrm thеn usеd for sсiеntists.
.sИithout сallsеs' hе сould nеvеr Ье thе Nеwton of Ьiology. Darwin wantеd to find a biologiсal forсе that would explain thе еvolution of lifе and was univеrsal in thе world and thе kеy Ьеhind all organiс motions' and to this еnd hе workеd fеvеrishlyfor thе nеxt 18 months, spесulatingаnd dоing an ехtеnsivе litеraturе rеviеw. Darwin soon rеalizеd that thе proЬaЬlе kеy to сhangе lаy in somеthing parallеl to thе way in whiсh animal and plant Ьrееdеrsеffесt сhangе, namеly, thе sеlесtiоn of thе dеsiгаЬlе and thе rеjесrion of all othеrs. Brrt how was oDе to gеt a natural еquivalеnt to thе Ьrееdеrs' artifiсial sеlесtion? At thе еnd of SеptеmЬеr 1838 Darwin rеad Аn Еssау on thе Prinсiplе of Popиlаtioz (sixth еdition, 1826| Ьу thе Rеvеrеnd Thomas RoЬеrt Malthus. In his work Мalthus arguеd that food suppliеs would always bе outstrippеd Ьy potеntial population growth. Hеnсе' unlеss thеrе was ..prudеntial rеstraint,'' thеrе wеrе bound to Ье ongoing struggles for еxistеnсе as pеoplе сompеtеd for thе availаЬlе food and suppliеs,inсluding living spaсе (Figurе 9). Darwin turnеd Мalthus's rеasoning on its hеad. Hе pointеd out that thеrе сould Ье no prudеntial rеstraint in thе animаl and plant wоrld' and hеnсе,bесausеpopulation growth сеrtainly Was not rеstriсtеd to humankind, thеrе would Ье an ongoing' organiс-widе strugglе for еxistеnсе. Мorе than this, suссеss and failurе in thе strugglе would (on avеragе) Ье a funсtion of thе diffеrеnt
сII
JOII]
Figurе 6. Prinсiples o his mеthodolоgiсalin
Tbe Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought
PRINCIPLBS
GЕ o Lo GY, вElIiтG
AN ATгЕlшPт To EхPLAIN TIIЕ FORMЕR сIIANGES oF тIIЕ DARтII'S sURFAcЕ' вY REaEBЕNoE тo сAusЕs Now lN oPEBAтloN.
linеd Ьy RoЬеrt Fitzroy' thеn only lould Ье a vеry lonеly post Ьeсause y thеrеforеlookеd for someonе nеonеnot in the nаvy Ьut a fit thе joЬ pеrfесtly,rapidly ip's naturalist.Thе сrеw usеd to сall --thе rеrmthеn usеdfor sсiеntists.
lton of biology. Darwin wantеd to thе еvolution of ]ifе and was uni'rganiс motions' and to this еnd hе ; p е с u l a t i n agn d d o i n g a п е х t е n s i v е : kеy to сhangе lay in somеthing LntЬrееdеrsеffесt сhangе, namеly, ion of all othеrs. But how was onе ' artifiсial sеlесtion? At thе еnd of tbе Priпсiple of Рopulаtioz (sixth s Robеrt Malthus. In his work rlways bе outstrippеd Ьy potеntial was ..prudеntial rеstraint,', thеrе stеnсеas pеoplе сompеtеd for thе 8 spaсе (Figurе 9). Darwin turnеd ntеd out that thеrе сould Ье no : world, and hеnсе, Ьесausе popuгo humankind, thеrе would Ье an nсе. Мorе than this, suссеss and :) Ье a funсtion of thе diffеrеnt
вт
сIIARLEs LYЕLL, Еs Q., F.R.s. FOe.
9J8C. TO TflD
IN
QEOI"
SOC' !c,
тwo vol.uмЕs. Yol. I.
LONDON: JoIIN lvIURRAY' ALBE},IARLE.SтREЕT. "oБ**.
Figurе6. Principles of Gеologу' The full titlе of Lyell's work tells you all aЬout his mеthodologiсalintеntions. Еventually, thеrе wеre thrее volumes.
11
12
Тbe Historу' of Еuolutioпаrу Thougbt
Abingdon
с\
вindIoo теfudo dbingdonii fiom Abiпвdon l5lаnd
A|bemаr|o
e
Тowel
Ф
тhr south Аmeriф теshldo ФbulаЙ
tofuisе
твfudo vi.inа fтom AlЬ€mаr|е |sland
тe*udo ephiwiuЙ from Dunфn Ьlаnd
Figurе 7. Thе Gal;ipagostortoisеs.Darwin did not Ьесomean еvolutionistuntil hе rеtrrгnеdhomе and hе сould show his сollесtionof Ьirds to John Gould' a lеadingornithologist.It was whеn hе wаs told that thеrewеrе unаmЬiguously diffеrеnt spесiеstЬаt he movеd асross to еvolution. Notе that еvеn Ьeforе hе Ьесamеan еvolutionist,Darwin was moving in сirсlеswhеrе hе сould сall on thе tоp minds foг supPort and informatioп. He madе powеrful friеnds аt СamЬridgеand thеy spottеdhis talеntеarly.
Figurе 8. Thе trее of lifе. This littlе skеtсh,drawn inJuly 18З7, is from a private notеbook that Dаrwin was kееping on thе sPесiеsproЬlеm. Lаmarсk had а trееof-[ifеpiсturеand in thе еightееnthсеnturyonе сan find thеm in thе writings оf nonеvolutionistswho wеrе nеvегthеlеsstrying to shorмthе oгdеr in whiсh God hаd сrеаtеd.
F i g u r е9 . T h е М a l t h ц s А l m а п а с ki n 1 8 5 l . o r tl{ thе truth of еvoltrti on idеas tlrat wеrе wiс
Тhе Нistorу of Еuolиtionаrу Thougbt
on BindIo€ t^ \,J
Iow€ l Ф
s
тhe south Аmeriсаn toФise теstudoИbulаfu
lд..s-y
GALAPAGOS ISLANDS
J |
\*-/
> Indefstigable
/'2
Р / J /
ва.riпgton
<-'/,/
сh.ath.am
сharIes
/>
нood
Ф
lid nоt Ьесomеan еvolutionistuntil lесtionоf Ьirds to John Gould, a ld that thеrеwеre unamЬiguously lution. Notе that еvеn Ьеfоrе hе in сirс|eswhеre hе сould сall on Hе made powеrful friеnds at
rawn in July 1837' is from a privatе lесiеsproЬlem.Lamarсk had a trее. )nесan find thеm in thе writings of g to show thе ordеr in whiсh God
Figurе 9. Thе Мalthusian еxpltlsion. This сartоon appеarеd in the Сomiс Аlmапасk in 1851. Onе of tlrе rеasons thаt l)аrwin was aЬlе to сonvinсе pеoplе of thе truth of еvolrrtion Was' apart frtlrn lris friеndly stylе, thе faсt that hе rеliеd on idеas tlrаt wеrе widеlv ассеrltеd in Viсtorian Britirin.
1З
I+
Thе Historу of Еuolutionаrу Thought сharасtегistiсspossеssеdЬv organisms. Неnсе tl-rеrеwould bе an ongoing natural sеlесtion in whiсh thе winnеrs would pаss on fеaturеs to thе nеХt gеnеrаtion and thе losеrs would gеt nothing. Ovеr timе' this sеlесtion would lеad to full-Ьlown organiс сhangе. But this organiс сhangе would Ье of a partiсular kind' for thе fеaturеs that mаkе for suссеss,known as ..adaptаti6n5''-f61 g;amplе, еars' еyеs' tееth, hands, lеgs, lеavеs, Ьаrk, and roots-would show that purposеful naturе that еpitoпizеs final сirusе. Darwin sat on his еvolutionary idеas for 15 yеars' during whiсh timе hе 's7'е turnеd to a massivе study of Ьarnaсlеs. arе not quitе surе why this dеlay oссurrеd, although Ьy this timе Darwin hаd fallеn siсk with a mystеriousail. mеnt that W21sto plaguе him for thе rеst of his lifе, and so undouЬtеdly hе Was not rеlishing thе hugе dеЬatеtlrat his idеas wеrе Ьound to сausе. Also a major faсtor must havе Ьееn his rеluсtanсе to upsеt powегful sсiеnсееstaЬlishmеntfigurеs (inсluding СаmЬridgе mеntors) who had еnсouragеd thе young Darwin in his work. Onе of thе things hе did during thе pausе was to nеtwоrk with youngеr sсiеnrists'who сould rally around him whеn hе did go publiс. Finally, howеvеr, Dzrrwin was pushеd into aсtion whеn, in thе .Wallaсе, middlе of 1858, hе rесеivеdа short еssay Ьy Alfrеd Russеl a сollесtor in thе Malay pеninsula' that had virtually thе samе prеmisеs and сonсlusion that hе had disсovеrеdsomе 20 yеars еarliеr.
. Rut with
woгld,
to thс mlbтiдl
Фп
ьut by thc вtъ,IiвЬment
\Y. Wявvвrl
..l.о
ill.aгPliф
..*o.u''
@
вщ.сh
l€ t
thеrcforе'
Фncludо,
ruьriеtY. or Ф
woг.t, or iп the lш} rAtьсI
те
с*
еvеnts sre bфug ir Iюw€ . , ex€ l kd gеuевt iвwв.'' oi
lюrфive thot of Diйne iokrlю6itio!!
in6uЬtail с8,
rсgerd
tьiFwc
fаr 8
of God's
lot ruсD cldФvour
no ф
mdl"вtioD,
lar oг ь€
iФ
vеll
тorks;
дn сri.lles Bдсoх;
DoЙ'
BfoЙlq, o.roЬs'
: Bйфa
оlt
of s
thiDk or: sfudi.'d io t divinity or or prо
рФgrе$
.4dvсlreли
Kы|' l!l' 1859.
oN тнЕ oRlGlN oF sPЕсlЕs Darwin quiсkly wrotе up his idеas, and ()n thе Оrigin of Spесies bу Мeапs of Nаtиrаl Selесtion, or thе Preseruаtioп of Fаuсlиred Rасes iп thе Struggle for Lifе appеаrеd in thе fall of 1859 (Figurе 10). Thе work Ьеginswith a disсussion of artifiсial sеlесtion аrrd animal and plant Ьrееdеrs'grеat suссеssеs. This is partly hеuristiс,tо prеparе thе rеаdеr by following thе path thаt Dar. win himsеlf had takеn to disсovеry, and partly justifiсatory,suggеstingthat what wе сan do, naturе сan surеly do Ьеttеr.Following is a disсussion of thе variation thаt аlways oссurs in thе wild, somеthing that Darwin oЬviously nееdеd as thе building Ьloсks of сhangе. If еvсry organism Wеrе еxaсtly likе its parеnts, thеn thеrе сould Ье no еvolution' At this point Daгwirr was rеady to introduсе thе strugglеfor ехistenсеаnd' following on this, thе mесhanisnr of natural sеlесtion: A strugglе for ехistеnсе inеvitaЬly follows fr
Figurе 10. Thе titlе pag сhееky in quoting thе p thе topiс of thе law-gor Dаrwin's mеntorswhеr сontinuеd in this r
Notе that еvеn mor for rеproduсtion. lt is sеxцal dеsirеsof a phi way' givеn naturally с
Canit...Ьеthou1 havе undouЬtеdl1' . еaсh bеing in thе g сur in thе сoursс o doubt (rеmеmbеri siЬly survivе) that ovеr othеrs' would
Tbe Нistorу of Еuolutioпаrу Thought . Неnсе thеrе would bе an ongoing ould pass on fеaturеsto thе nеxt gеn;. ovеr timе, this sеlесtion would lеad ganiс сhangеwould Ье of a partiсular эss,knоwn as ..adaptation5''-f91 91еs' bark, and roots-Would show that :ausе. for 15 yеаrs, during whiсh timе hе !Ие arе not quitе surе why this dеlay had fallеn siсk with a mystеrious ailst of his lifе' and so undouЬtеdly hе Lisidеas wеrе Ьound to сaцsе.Also a -lсtanсе to upsеt powеrful sсiеnсеidgе mеntors) who had еnсouragеd tе things hе did during thе pausе was сould rally around him whеn hе did as pushеd into aсtion whеn, in thе .sИallaсе, y Ьy Alfrеd Russеl a сollес:uallythе samе prеmisеsand сonсlurs еarliеr.
TнЕ 0RIGIN 0F SPшcIшs ..вut with rcgst.l to thо mаbrjal flr N this*we iБuЬt€d Фe,
pеrФivr
ф
iDt€rpо6itioвs
that
woтld, wо ш
eveDtБ ale bтougьt
of Diйпe
рwer, o[ gonефl
ьut by tьс 6bъlishmrnt w.
wвEvlLL
BY }lE^Ns0Е NATURAL8ELЕ0TI0N'
дt least go Бo aьout
not by
in еsоh рartiсulsl
eхerhd lswБ.''
Trеаti*.
: зnфffitеr
PltEsЕIivAтloN ..'lъ
thefe{orc,
Фnсludс'
юьliety, oт ш
ill-spplied
lеt no msn
out
modетati0n,
thiвk
of o wсаk
сoncеit
fдт oг ъs tф пell
вfudi€ d
in the Ьmk of God's
worJ, oг in thr Ьтk
оf Gorl's ltorkв;
diviniiy
or pllilоsolitу;
nn сldleнs рюgrсss оr ploficiеnсe B^ФБ
| Аd'tuмФrфnt
RAcЕs
rN TЕЕ
вTIiUGGL0
F'o'r LJ ЕЕ.
t
lrrn саu sщrсЬ fu
rаth0r let meD eDdФvoul
o!' FAVOURвD
of
tьtt
oг mriпtain'
ъut
in both.''
o! Iaапin(]'
Ry OHARLDS lЕLтлп ^UтЛоR
o!
oг
тtrE
lJoURN^l
юY^L' oг
DАR1r!TN' 1{'A.,
GEoIDGIс^L'
ю0ND
LlNNt^n, DшlхG
вi8Dtвснш тяЕ
п.
Етс.' и.
soпЕтrЕ8;
в. вErGlЕъ
voYtoЕ
wоeD'.
o"*'"'r,i*Iil'',,,,. "*i:}^""' *TREвT ,o,*,o,'u*oo'l
Й.ticмфfu@шЙnф
oп the Оrigiп of Speсies bу Мeаns n of Fаuourеd Rасes iп the Struggle urе 10). Thе work Ьеginswith a disand plant Ьrееdеrs' grеat suссеssеs. adеr Ьy following thе path that DarI partly justifiсatory, suggеsting that ttеr. Following is a disсussion of thе l, somеthing that Darwin oЬviously If еvеry organism Wеrе ехaсtly likе ion. At this point Darwin was rеady Ld,following on this' thе mесhanism
lws from thе high ratе at whiсh all y Ьеing' whiсh during its natural s' must suffег dеstruсtion during 1е sеason or oссаsionаl yеar' othсal inсrеasе, its numЬеrs would hat no сountry сould suppоrt thе е produсеd than сan possiЬly sur. gglе for еxistеnсе,еithеr onе indi, or with thе individuals of distinсt of lifе. (С. Darwin 1859' 6З)
15
Figurе 10. Thе titlе pagе of Оn tbе Оrigin of Spесiеs.Darwin wаs Ьеing a littlе Whеwеll, oppositеthе titlе pagе' on сhееkyin quotingthе philosophеr.!Иilliam .!Иhеwеll had Ьееn onе of thе topiс of thе law-govеrnеdnaturе of thе univеrsе. Darwin'smеntoгswhеn thе lattеrWas a studеntat СаmЬridgе,аnd hе сontinuеdin this ro1еin thе еarly yеars aftеr tЬe Bеаglе voyagе.Llе was a wеllknown opponеntof еvolutionand was sсathingon thе suЬjесtof Vеstigеs' Darwin sеnt a сomplimеntary сopy of the Оrigiп to.Whеwеll, who rеspondеd by Ьanningthе Ьook from thе shеlvеsof thе liЬrаry of Trinity Сollеgе' of whiсh hе was Mastеr (hеad)
Notе that еvеn morе than a strugglе for еxistеnсе,Darwin nееdеd a strugglе for rеproduсtion. It is no good having thе physiquе of Tarzan if you havе thе sеxualdеsirеsof a philosophеr. But with thе strugglе undеrstood in this sort of Way' givеn naturally oссurring variaгiоn, natural sеlесtion follows at onсе: Сan it . . . Ье thought improЬaЬlе' sееing that variations usеful to man havе undouЬtеdly oссurrеd, that othеr vаriations usеful in somе way to еaсh Ьеing in thе grеat and сomplех Ьattlе of lifе, should somеtimеsoссur in thе сoursе of thousands of gеnеrations?If suсh do oссur' сan wе douЬt (rеmеmЬеringthat many morе individuals arе born than сan possibly survivе) that individuals having any advantagе' howеvеr slight, ovеr othеrs, wоuld havе thе Ьеst сhanсе of surviving аnd of proсrеating
tb
The Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Тbrшgbt tlrеir kind? On tlrе othеr hаnd Wе шIаyfееl surе that any r,аrizrtionin thе lеast dеgгее injurious worrld Ье rigidly dеstrсlyеd.This prеsеrvatiorrof favouraЬlеvariations and thе rеjесtionof ilrjurious variations,I сall Nаt. u r а l S е l е с t i t l n(. 8 0 _ 8 1 ) In latеr еditiсlrrsDaгwin intгodtrсеd thе аltегrrаtivеtеrm gtruiuаl of thе fittest, wlriсh was pеrhаps a littlе unfoгtulratе,for it has lеd to еndlеss сlaims that sеlесtion is a tаutolсlgy, rеduсing simply to thе сlairn thаt thosе who survivе arе thosе who survivе. But althouglr this is oЬviously truе, sеlесtionmеans morе than tlrat. It сlaims, ior Ьеttеr сlr fсlr worsе' th21ton аvеragе tlrosе who survivе thosе whtl do not, and thilt suссеssin tlrе strugglе is a funсaге diffеrеnt fгсrr-n tiorr of thosе diffеrеnсеs.This may ()r may not Ье truе, Ьut it is not a tautology. Darwin inсludеd a sесondary sеlесtivе mесhanism. Hе arguеd that thе stгugglеis not always for food irnd spaсе Ьut сan Ье dirесtly foг matеs. This mесhanisrn, sехtlаl seleсtiс>tl, Darwirr dividеd into twtl Pаrts. Thеrе was sеlесtion through пlalе сomЬat (fсlrfе;rralеs). Tlrе antlеrs of thе dееr would Ье thе produсt of this. Тhеn thеrе was sеlесti
Thе anаlogywith anirnalЬrееdinglеd Dаrwin ro Figurе 11. Sеxual sеlесti
lесtion partiсularly pr thе samе spесiеs:sеlес istiсs rаthеr thаn spес sее sеlесtion (inсludin Нaving thus prеsе duсеd thе famous mе samе сlass havе somеl ilе largеly spеaks thе spесiеs еxtant today. еvolutionary paths of vеry first sharеd orig and thеsе, if vigorou Ьranсh, so Ьy gеnеrz whiсh fills with its dе еrs thе surfaсе with i
win 1859, 129-130) Now, with somе prеsеnt thе sесond р Darwin took thе rеa< instinсt, palеontology and showеd that ph through natural sеlес support thе mесhan
Figurе 12. Thе trее < this piсture is lеss or sprеads.
Thе Historу o|.ЕuolutiсllzаrуlT1',,,''' fееl surе that any variation in thе r"dеstroyеd.This prеsеrvation of of injuriousvariаtions'I сall Nat-
tеrnativе tсJm suruiuаl сlf the fittest, ,r it has lеd to еndlеssсlairns that sег Ь ес l а i n lt h а t t h r l s еw h o s t t r v i v еа г е bviously truе, sеlесtion mеаns morе э' that on avеragеthosе who survivе thаt strссеssin thе strtrgglеis а funсnot Ье truе' Ьut it is not a tautology' е mесhanism. Не arguеd that thе bllt сan Ье dlrесtly for mаtеs. This idеd into two parts. Thеге was sе_ ;). Thе antlеrsof thе dееr would Ье :tion through fеr-nalе сhoiсе (of thе or gеnеral plurr-ragе of thе pеaсoсk ; (Figurе11). Notiсе how sехual sе-
h animalЬrееdinglеd Dаrr,vrnto :сtion.Naturаl sеlесtion rеlpsurvival,likе thiсkеrсoars, сtion fоr аttriЬutеsthat givе plеamorе fегoсiousfightingquаlitiеs. [aи.(Bссаusеtl.tе()rigin wаs writtеn or illustrating. Most of Darwin's iouslyillrrstratеd.)
lесtion partiсulaгlyputs thе еmphasis on сompеtition bеtwееn mеmЬеrs of thе samеspесiеs:sеlесtionis dirесtеd toward individual-Ьеnеfitingсharaсtеristiсsrathеr than spесiеs-Ьеnеfiting сharaсtеristiсs.Darwin tеndеd always to (inсluding sееsеlесtion natural sеlесtion)aсting in this way. Having thus pгеsеntеdthе mаin Inесhanisms of сhangе, Darwin intro. duсеdthе famous mеtaphor of a trее: ..Thе affinitiеs of all thе Ьеings of thе samесlasshavе somеtimеsЬееn rеprеsеntеdЬy a grеat trее. I Ьеliеvеthis similе largеly spеaks thе truth.'' Thе lеavеs and twigs at thе top reprеsеnt thе spесiеsеxtant today. Thеn, as wе go down thе branсhеs' wе havе thе grеat еvolutionary pаths of yеstеrday. All thе way down wе go until wе rеасh thе .,As vеry fiгst sharеd origins of lifе. Ьuds givе risе Ьy growth to frеsЬ Ьuds, and thеsе,if vigorous, Ьranсh out and ovегtop on аll sidеs many a fееblеr Ьranсh, so Ьy gеnеration I Ьеliеvе it has Ьееn with thе grеat Trее of Lifе, whiсh fills with its dеad and ЬrokеrrЬranсhеsthе сrust of thе еагth, and сovеrs thе surfaсе with its еvеr branсhing and Ьеautiful ramifiсations'' (С. Darwin 1859, 129_130) (Figuге 12). Now, with soпlе minor problеms brr.rshеdaway, Dаrrvin was rеady to prеsеnt thе sесond part оf his thеory. For a good two-thirds of thе Оrigiп, Darwin took thе rеadеr through thе vaгious Ьranсhеs of Ьiologiсal sсiеnсеinstinсt,palеontology,Ьiogеography,сlassifiсаtion,m
Figurе 12. Thе tгееof lifе аs given in tЬе Оrigiп. Notiсе that thе еmphasis in this piсturеis lеss on showing lifе rеaсhing up and morе on thе way in whiсh it spreаds'
17
18
The Historу of Еuolutiсlпаrl Thought
Г-l Г-l tt lt L__l lnstinсt
Paleontology
Г_l Г-l Гl tt II tl L__lL__lII L__l
ll
cеographiсal Distribution
Сlаssifiсation
Мorphology
ЕmЬryology
Figurе 1.3.Thе struсturеof Darwin's аrgumеnt.l)arwin did not hit Ьy сhanсеon this kind of argumеntаtion,whеrе a unifyir-rg hypсlthesis ехplainsin many 'Whеwеll, diffеrеntarеasand in turn is justifiеdor suрportеdЬl.thеsеаrеas. who сallеd it a ..сonsiliеnсе of induсtiсlns,''madе muсh of it whеn disсr.rssing suссеssfulthеtlriеsof physiсs,еspесiall1' Nеwttlnianmесlrаniсsand thе wavе thеory of light.Whеwеll idеntifiеdthе сirusеsat thе сеntеrof а сonsiliеrrсе аs ..truесausеs,''whаt Nеwttln hаd сallеd Uеrdес(l|tsае. Showinga сonsiliеnсеwas thеrеforеаn еssеntiаlstfatеgyfor а worrld-bеNеwtсlt-lof Ьiology.
Wеrе somе proЬlеmatiс issttеs.Soсial Ьеhlvior, pаrtiсtrlагlyth:rt shown by thе soсial insесts (thе hymеnoptеra-thе ants' thе Ьееs, and thе wasps), would Ье еasily ехpliсaЬlе if sеlесtion favсlrеdthе group. But frсrm an individualistiс pеrspесtir,е,why slror"rldol1е gеt stеrilе lr,orkеrs lvlro sееmirrgly spеnd thеir wholе livеs dеvotеdto thе lvеll-Ьеingof othеrs irl thе nеst or hivе? How сan natural sеlесtion,with its еmphasis on thс importanсе of rеproduсtion, рroduсе organisms that сaлn
would сall thе СаnrЬг е х p l a i n е ds i t n р l уз s e n o l o n g е r Ь е t h е r е ,Ь r . Ьrought out all of D whеrе now thеге Wrrе not find it. Еvеn if wе dotrЬtftll that wе wou prеssеd and mеtamor1 М o s t o t Ь е r а r е a so f triЬr-rtion(Ьiogеograph is that onе finds thе va Why, foг instanсе,doе that arе еxhiЬitеd Ьy tl simply that thе foundе thе mainlаnd, аnd onс. sify undеr thе nеw sе Figurе 7). Systеmatiсs еvolution. As Linnaеu сally in nеstеdsеts,thu МoгpЬology lrаrsthosс diffеrеnt spесiеs.oЬvi. Ьryology likеwisе was . еmbryos of soпrе diffеwhеrеas thе adults аrе faсt thаt in thе wonrЬ similaг (thеywould nor thе rwo adults would l Hеrе' as аlways thгouр analogy with thе worlс ..Fanсiеrssеlесt hand: arе nеаrly 8rown up: struсturеs lrаvе Ьееn a possеssеsthеm'' (С. D' So wе arе lеd to tt Сhristianity lrаd еvolr mеmЬеrs of thе \Х/еd сеаlеd that hе Was W unsеlf-сonsсiousrеfеr sееm to Ье fully satis dеntly сrеatеd.''This r tеr with what wе kno thе produсtion and ех shоuld hаvе Ьееn duс and dеath of thе indi Whаt God doеs not d nеss in supposing oth
Тhе Нistorу of ЕuсllиtiсlпаrуThoцgbt
-l
Гl
__lL__l L_l П
]lassifiсаtion
Morphology
ЕmЬryoIogy
lеnt. Dагwin did not hit Ьy сhanсе on lg hypсlthеsisсхрl:rins in many эportеd by thеsе :rrеzrs.Whеwеll, who е n l t l с h r l f i t r rh с n d i s с u s s i n g :wtoniаn mссhаniсs and thе wavе еs at thе сепtеr of a сonsiliеnсе as ае саusае. Showing a сonsiliеnсе was Ье Nеwton of Ьiology.
,havior,partiсr-rlаrlvthat shown Ьy tе ants, thе Ьееs, and thе wаsps)' vorеd thе group. But from an indigеt stеrilе ч,orkегs who sееmingly l-Ьеingof othеrsirr thе nеst or hivе? asis on thе importanсеof rеproduсlroduсе? Finally, Dаrwin, who alovеr group approaсhеs Ьесausе hе Ldехploitation,dесidеdthat in suсh gratеdthat it is pеrnrissiЬlеto trеat r in whiсh thе individшalinsесtsarе lork on thе еvе, ft>rехamplе, whiсh m' so thе u.orkеr ехists fоr thе Ьеnhad its good points-for instanсе, gly wе find orgarrismsthat sееm to )f ехtant organisrтs that arе widеly .hеrеwеrе gaps irr thе fossil rесord, r aЬruptly at thе starг of what wе
would саll thе СzrnrЬriаn;thеrе Was l1()rес()rdЬеforе that' Thе gaps Darwin ехplairrеdsirlplу as a produсt of ilrсtlmplеtеfrrssilization.T.hеrеmains might no longеrЬе thеrе,Ьut thе linking anсеstorsdid еxist. Thе aЬrupt Ьеginning Ьrought out all of Darwin's invеntivе Powеrs. Еarly lifе proЬaЬly еxistеd whеrеnow thегеwеrе oсеans;this would еxplain why wе on dry land сould not find it. Еvеn if wе wеrе aЬlе to drill Ьеnеaththе oсеans, howеvеr, it was douЬtfulthat ъ.е would find lifе; thе prеssurе from abovе had surеly сomprеssеdand mеtirmоrphosеdthе fossil rеmains lrеlow (Figurе 14). Мost othег arеаs of Ьiology fеll int<-l plaсе witlr morе еаsе.Gеographiс disrvas а triumph ЬесаttsеD:rrwin ехplainеd iust why it triЬution(Ьiogеogrаplry) is thаt onе finс]sthе variolts pattеrns of arriпrаland plant lifе aгourrd thе gloЬе. !Иhy, for instаt-lсе, doеs onе havе thе strаngе sorts of distriЬutions and pattеrns that arе ехhiЬitеd Ьy thе Gal5pagos Arсhipеlago and othеr island groups? It is simply that thе ftrundеrsof thеsе isolatеd islirnd dеnizеns сamе Ьy сhanсе from thе mainland, alld onсе thеy wеrе еstaЬlishесl,thеy startеd to еvolvе and divеrsify undеr thе nеw sеlесtivе prеssurеs to wlriсh thеy wеrе now suЬjесt (sее Figurе 7). Systепrirtiсslikеwisе ехhiЬits thе kind of pattеrns onе ехpесts from еvolution. As Lirrrraеttsdеmonstratеd, organisnrs сan bе сlassifiеd hiеrarсhiсallyin nеstеdsеts,tlrusslrowinga pаttегnthat геvеаlspast history (Figцrе 15). Morpholog1,hirs thosе similaritiеs,саllеd lromologiеs,bеtwееn orgаnisms of diffеrеntspесiеs.oЬviously thеsеspеаk to slrarеdanсеstry(sееFigurе 1). ЕmЬryologylikеr,l,isеWas a partiсular point of рrгidеfor Dаrwin. Why is it tlrаt thе еmЬryosof soгtlеdiffеrеnt spесiеs,suсh as man and thе dog, arе vеry similar, whеrеasthе adults arе vеry diffегеnt? Darwin arguеd thаt this follows frorn thе faсt thаt in thе womЬ thе sеlесtivе forсеs on thе two еmЬryos would bе vеry similar (thеywсlr"rldnot thеrеforе Ье torn apart)' whеrеas thе sеlесtivеforсеs on thе rwo adults woшld Ье vеry diffеrеnt(thеy wor"rldЬе torn apart) (Figurе 16). Darwin turnеd to thе Неrе, as always tlrrouglror-rt his disсussions сlf еvсllr-trion, anabg,vr,r,ithtlrе world of Ьrееdеrsin tlrdеr to сlarify and support tlrе point аt sеlесtthеir horsеs, dogs, аrld pigеons, for Ьrееding' wlrеn thеy hand: ..Fiu-rсiеrs arе nеarly gro\vn up: thеy arе indiffеrеrrt rvhеthеr thе dеsirеd qualitiеs аnd struсturеshavе bееn aсquirеd еarliеr or latег in lifе, if thе full-grown animal possеssеs thеm', (С. Darwin 1859,446). So wе arе lеd to thе сonсluding passаgеsof the Оrigiи. Darwin, whosе Сhristianityhad еr,olvеdinto a form of dеisrn (Lyеll, a Unitariаn likе many mеmЬеrsof thе Wесlgwood family' Was а mаjor influеnсе hеrе), nеvеr сon' сеalеd that hе w,:rsr,vсlrkingin a God_Ьасkесl modе, and thеrе arе frеquеnt геfеrеnсеsto thе Сrеаttlг' ..Authors of thе lrighеstеnrinеnсе unsеlf-сonsсiot'ts sееmto Ье fulh. satisfiеdwith thе viеrv tlrlrt еaсh spесiеshas Ьееn indеpеn,.To my mind it dеntlyсrеatесl'''This was not Darwin's ptlsition. aссords Ьеttеr with whаt wе know of thе laws irnprеssеdon mattеr Ьy thе Сrеator' that thеproduсtionalrd ехtinсtion of thе past and prеsеntinhaЬitantsof thе world should havе Ьееn duе to sесondary сausеs' likе thosе dеtеrmining thе birth and dеath of thе irrdividual'' (С. Г)аrwin 18's9' 488). God Ьaсks thе world. What God doеs Irot с1ois gеt involvеd in thе world, and sсiеnсеhas no busin е s si n s u p p t l s i n gr l r h е r r r ' i s е .
19
20
Тhе Hist<.lrу сlf Еuolutioпаrу тABLв
oв STRATA
Tbought дttu Oвpsв or' AРPЕAR,ANолоr Aшrмдr, I,rrв UPoN
o N o z ц o
s
F A, UJ t-
o N
N ц'l
5
ч
o z
o o lrl
U'
TпrЬaгy. Shetl-Мarl. Glacial Drift. i fl Brick EвrtЬ. E8 Noтwiсh 1 Red }Crшg. Comllinе ) Fвlunн. Моlaвse. "" .'"-"-.. Gypr.
BonoBed.-мArи
l!ARтЕ.
Ьy Wеaponв.
Ф 3 . . . ;I
!9o{9n }сt"",. rlаяtlс, Мaеstricht' Uppeг Chalk. Iюweт Chalk'. Uppeт Сlгeensand Iюver Grеensand 'lYeвld Сla1.. ТIaвtingвSan.l PuгЬеck Bеdв. Kimmeгidgian. oхfoгdian. Кellovian. ltoгest Матble. Bath-Stone. StonoвfieldSlшtе' Grеat oolitе. Liдв.
гIlE
й
E fтпgu]аta. Caгnivоrа
s
Cyсloid. l _ Мoввsauгnв. Ci"ooid. l !rg,Еg' РolyptyсЬodoп' Brвоs, Ьу Boneв. Prосrlian Cтoсodilia.
e €
Еl
Iguаnodоn. _l\Iaтsupialв' - Cheloniв Ьy Boneя. P]iosauгuв'
EE o
Мaгsupialв.
"E- * .f:{
Iсthуopteтуgia.
гvrAL|
"{-*-";:":"w
Е.
Е !
Figurе 14. Тhе history of lifе as sееnin 1860. Тhis is takеn trom Riсhard owеn's Pаleoпt
Figuтe 15. Thе Linnaеa w i t h t h е m е m Ь е r so f | o с o m P г е h е n s i v еs)е r sa t l s e t ( k n o w n a s t a х a ,s i n 8 sharеd past' althoughas without rеgardto еvolu interprеtationgavеit nе hypothеsisof shаrеddе
тl1Е DEscENт
|
What аЬout humans? that humans aге part i on thе Bеаgle voyagе Тiеrra dеl Fuеgians' hс сally Darwin dесidеd l want to сonсеal his th points aЬout еvolution mеnts of all timе, hе si and his history.' (С. D thе topiс and dеal wi two-volume work, ТЙ.
Тhe Нistсlrу of Еuolutioпаrу Thougbt
)F APPЕAпANOE or ANIмAт, Т,rFE lдвтц' >1.0o0,oo0speсies
(аnimа|s)
I 6
Н
..-;;H'r't"+$:s Ф d
€
,d.l. Мoввsauгuв.l id. r дl8lrЕs' PoIуptyсЬodоn. I ' Ъy Boneв. l liвn Cтoсodilia. l I
trl
#;dseж rffi
€"*Wehf?
di d
я
.";;i;.^-"6. a--;.;"; ;.
5,,l60 sрeсies
(songbirds)
odoв. pialв,- CheloniшЬy Bonев цгu8.
&ж ldЖ
"-t#
,hyopteгygiш.
i, by Foot-pfints. эtotygia. iдtЬodontia.
'ia, by Toot.pгints. lL|A ganoоерh. Inвeсta
-si
Ei
I ganOld.
Figure15. Thе Linnaеanhiеrarсhy.organisms саn all Ье plaсеd in a hiеrarсhy with thе mеmЬеrsof lowеr-lеvеlsеts Ьеing groupеd into еvеr fеWеr(Ьut morе сomprеhеnsivе) sеtsаt highеrlеvеls.All organismsЬеlongto onе and only onе sеt(knownas taхa, singulartaхon) at еaсh lеvеl (саtеgory).This reflесtsa sharedpast, although as With thе fossil rесord' muсh of this was workеd out without regardto еvolution. Hеnсе, giving thе hiеrarсhy an еvolutionary interprеtationgavе it nеw mеaning and at thе samе timе сonfirmеd thе hypothеsisof sharеd dеsсеnt.
.oф
."f
I plaсo.ganoid.+ig.{ plaоoid.-
ь$1'Ё$:'*:Ъw т
Fuсoids.
zoopl\уI,os.
60. This is takеn from Riсhard wеn Ьесamеan implасaЬlееnemy of е matеrialistiс; Ьut, as young mеn эn proЬaЬlyЬесamеa ing thе сourseof history)'Ьut onе <еthesеas implying еvolution. As re fossil rесord thinking that it might entially сrеatеdorganisms.
21
тl]Е DEscЕNт oF MAN What aЬout humans? From thе first, Darwin was always stonе.сold сеrtain that humans arе part and parсеl of thе еvolutionary proсеss. His еnсountеr on tЬe Bеаglе УoУagewith thе nativеs at thе Ьottom of South Amеriсa, thе Tiеrra dеl Fuеgians' had сonvinсеd him of this. In the origiп, howеvеr, taсtiсally Darwin dесidеd not to makе muсh of thе human quеstion. Hе did not wаnt to сonсеal his thinking; hе simply did not want it to swamp his gеnеral pointsaЬout еvolution and its proсеss.Hеnсе, in onе of thе grеat undеrstatе. mеnts of all timе, hе said mеrеly' ..Light will Ье thrown on thе origin of man and his history'' (С. Darwin 1859' 488). Darwin fully intеndеd to gеt Ьaсk to thе topiс and dеal with it at lеngth. This hе did in 1871, offеring a major two-volumе work,The Desсent of Маn.
22
Thе Historу of Еuolиtiсlпаrу T'htlugbt
naturаlistiс pеrsPесtivе tlе еssay on how humal with spiritualism and с. natural еvеnt. Thеrе ml
}.lg.l.
Uppеl ffgпrеlruвltrп.'rJ}*3f;Ji:kоr'
l,oweтfi$tre thlt of s dog,
Рoff of this сonсlusion, tеristiсs that сould not human hairlеssnеssanс ally livеd with nativеs, powеr unusеd by pril prodцсеd Ьy sеlесtion. thе Thеorу of Nаturаl ' Suсh a сonсlusion w good ar8umеnts. Natul tivе human fеaturеs, Ь that is сharaсtеristiс o Ьеaury and dеsirabilit; .Wаllaсе wеrе not suсh сеrtainly not out of th( sion of sеxual sеlесtio .Why arе mеn Ьig and s сеstors who wеrе got tl domеstiс? Bесausе thе Ьеst joЬ with thе famil; anсеstors found sехua womеn (using Darwin' thе standard of Ьеаut1 Е x p е с t е d l y ,a l l o f t h i s i timеnts aboцt thе геlat dесidеd еminеnсе ovе mеntal powеr in man
326-з27). o. Forе.broln, сeтсtл.оl lrсtпispherсs, tс. r,. ]шld.brдin. с.,rln,г8 (lltа'lгigеn'iПs. с. Ilind.lrraiш. сerеlлllunt, medulla obloug8tд. d. Еуe. с. Iйг.
;f. Fiгst visсегal arсb' g. sосolrdvisсетдlarсh. I{. veгtсbгsl сolurnns and muасltlа in pтшeв:or d0vоloрвr(.ut.
ties. it.**'ltli]l. }ехtгеnri 'Гвil I,.
oг tiв соссyx.
Figurе 16. Similarityof thе еrnЬryoof humirnand dog. Again, Wе sееthе strеngthof the Оrigiп in r.r.raking шsеof fасts likе rlrеsе'wеll known to all Ьiologists.(Еrom ТЙe Dеsсепtrl|-Мап.|
No argumеnt is nеес his thinking wеrе star may havе Ьееn a rеvol triЬе. It is littlе wondеt By univеrsal aссlaim, that Еnglish Valhalla,
Aftег Darwin \й/hеnonе looks at this Ьook, it is rеally rathеr pесuliar. Most of thе Ьook is not on thе lrun-ranspесiеsаt all Ьut сonsists сlf an ехtеndеd еssay on thе seсondary mесlrаnism of sехu,rlsеlесtion.Tlrе pесuliarity of tlrе topiс yiеlds thе сluе to its gеnеsis. Alfrес] Russеl !Иallасе startеd Ьy shaгing Darwin's
Bеforе the origiп was of progrеss, it was op1 to that of mеsmеrisп Darwin сhangе thing was сеrtainly a сultur
The Historу of Еuolutionаrу Thought
f
J
noЕсkсг.
Iюweт figrrrе that olя dog'
naturalistiсpеrspесtivе on human origins and еvеn pеnnеd a stimulating littlе еssayon how humans might havе еvolvеd. But thеn hе Ьесamе еnamorеd with spiritualismand сonvinсеd that humankind сould Ье no сhanсе, purеly natural еvеnt. Thеrе must havе Ьееn a Mind guiding human gеnеsis. In sup.sИallaсе port of this сonсlusion' arguеd thаt thеrе Wеrе many human сharaсtеristiсsthat сould not havе Ьееn thе produсt of natural Sеlесtion, suсh as human hairlеssnеssаnd humans' grеat intеlligеnсе. \Wallасе,who had aсtually livеd with nativеs, maintainеd that thеrе wаs a vast аmount of Ьrain. powеr unusеd by primitivе man, and thеrеforе it сould not havе Ьееn produсеd Ьy sеlесtion. (\7allaсе's еssays arе сollесtеd tnЬts Сoпtribиtioпs to thе Thеorу of Nаturаl Selесtioп, 1870.) .Wallaсе Suсh a сonсlusion Was anathеma to Darwin, Ьut hе fеlt that had good argumеnts.Natural sеlесtion unaidеd сould not produсе many distinсtivе human fеaturеs, Ьut sехual selесtion сould. Darwin arguеd that muсh that is сharaсtеristiс of humans сamе aЬout through varying standards of Ьеauty and dеsiraЬility. Hеnсе, although distinсtivе' thе fеaturеs сitеd Ьy .!Иallaсе Wеге not suсh as to tаkе mаttеrs out of thе rangе of еvolution and сеrtainly not out оf thе rangе of sсiеnсе. Thus Darwin Wrotе a long disсussion of sеxual sеlесtion in gеnеral and thеn its appliсation to humankind. 10fhyarе mеn big and strong and powеrful and intеlligеnt? Bесausе thеir anсеstorswho wеrе got thе Ьеst womеn. \7hy arе Womеn soft and yiеlding and domеstiс? Bесausе thеir anсеstors who wеrе got thе Ьеst mеn and did thе .Why ЬеstjoЬ with thе family. arе humans hairlеss? Bесausе that is whаt thеir anсеstorsfound sехually ехсiting. Why (tо gеt morе spесifiс) do Hottеntot Womеn(usingDarwin's languagе)havе suсh Ьig Ьaсksidеs?Bесausе this was thе standard of Ьеauty of thе triЬе, and thе Ьravеst Ьravеs got first сhoiсе. Еxpесtеdly,all of this is wrappеd up with somе fairly standard Viсtorian sеntimеntsabout thе rеlativеaЬilitiеs of mеn and wоmеn: ..If mеn arе сapaЬlе of dесidеd еminеnсe ovеr Womеn in many suЬjесts' thе avеrage standard of mеntalPowеr in man must Ье aЬovе that of woman'' (С. Darwin |871,2,:
З26-З27\.
jf. First visсегal sтс}t. 9. Sссond visсeгal дтсh. H. Vеrtсbгal соlumns and in рrше8{ ot dсvсloрnrt,ut. d. Antеriог l I{. Рostегiог Jеxtгenrllleз. Il. Твil trг oя сoссyx.
muвсlt:!
tan and dog. Again, Wе sее thе :ts likе thеsе,wеll known to all
No argumеnt is nееdеd to alеrt us to thе faсt that by thе 1870s Darwin and his thinking wеrе starting to sеttlе into somе fairly сonvеntional modеs. Hе may havе Ьееn a rеvolutionary, Ьut hе Was not always that far ahеad of his triЬе. It is littlе wondеr that Darwin Ьесamе a major sourсе of national pridе. By univеrsal aссlaim, whеn hе diеd, hе was Ьuriеd next to Isaaс Nеwton in that Еnglish Valhalla, Iй/еstminstеrAЬЬеy (Figurе 17).
Aftеr Darwin ly rathеr pесuliar.Most of thе Ьook :onsistsof an ехtеndеdеssay on thе :r.Thе pесuliаrityof thе topiс yiеlds Иallaсе startеd Ьy sharing Darwin's
Bеforе thе Оrigiп was puЬlishеd, еvolution rodе on thе Ьaсk of thе doсtrinе of progrеss,it was opposеd Ьy thе idеa of final сausе, and its status was akin to that of mеsmеrism and phrеnology-it was a psеudosсiеnсе. Нow did Darwin сhangе things? As far aS progrеss was сonсеrnеd, Darwin himsеlf was сеrtаinlya сultural progrеssivistand saw еvolution itsеlf as progrеssivе.
1)
z-)
24
Thе Нistorу of Еuoltttioпаrу Tbсlught
Figurе 17. Сartoon of Dаrwin as аn apе. TЬс hr-lmorwas аlw.avsgеntlе and nеvеr sаvagе. Thе Еnglish Wеrе vеr}' pr
Нowеvеr, hе аlso saw that thе link Ьеtwееn progrеss and еvolution Was somеthing that Ьrought down thе stаtus
RеmеmЬеr that as f nаtural sеlесtion spеal blind.law ехplanation foг thе еnd-diгесtеd n. thiswаs no minoг mаt thе organiс world is it Hе was Ьrought up oI sеntеd in thе сlassiс dl Thеologу (1802). Hov Darwin may havе Ьееl аny kind had no plaс plainеd without rесoul T h е s t а t u so f е v o l u t i and surprising answеr: tionary thought up to еnсе, funсtioning wit praсtitionеrs using n:rt organiс ехistеnсе and might сall a profеssio man' so thе fatе of hi Thomas Неnгy Huхlе1 in Gеrmаny. Unfortun all Ьесamе ardеrrtеvoll Оrigin, whiсh showеd gеthеr undеr thе umЬr vеry kееn on natural s that thе wholе issuе o was unnееdеd, and ot and that sеlесtion сou othеr putativе сausеs' today might саll maсr е v o l u t i o nt h r o u g h a k i Admimеdly' thеrе w' thеory. onе was thаt t sее how suffiсiеnt nеw tions that sеlесtion сor unfortunatеly Darwin thаt whеn two orgаni turеs blеnd with thosе variation, within a gе What was nееdеd was nеw fеаturеs from gе Was that on thе bаsis t ing physiсists (notaЬl suсh a lеisurеly proсе But in a way thе sсiеr
Thе Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Tbougbt
]hеhumor was alwavsgеntlеand l of Darwin, and thеy still arе. Hе is :hеn,Darwin is as muсh а part of t tЬeHornеt mаgazinе.)
]twееn progrеss and еvolution Was s of thе lattеr, and hе rеalizеd that lеniеs thе inеvitaЬility of Ьiologiсal Darwin Ьrokе thе link Ьеtwееn thе lеd that natural sеlесtionсould lеad lay's еvolutionistswould сall a kind lming from сoпlpеtition with rivals. Lnisation,thе amount of diffеrеntia3ans in еaсh Ьеing whеn adult (and Ьrain for intеllесtualpurposеs),nat;tаndard:for all physiologistsadmit сh as in this statе thеy pеrform thеir . Ьеing;and hеnсеthе aссumulation tion is within thе sссlpе of natural frоm thе third еdition of the origiп
RеmеmЬеrthat аs far аs {inаl сausе Was сonсеrnеd' Darwin thought that naturalsеlесtionspеaks to thе dеsignlikе aspесt of living Ьеings. It givеs a blind.law ехplanation: sеlесtion lеаds to adaptation, and this is thе rеаson for thе еnd-dirесtеdnaturе оf suсh fеaturеs as еyеs and hands. For Darwin this was no minor mattеr. Hе always rесognizеd that thе dеsignlikе naturе of thе оrganiс wоrld is its most distinсtivе fеaturе аnd should not Ье ignorеd. Не wаs Ьrought up On thе Argumеnt from Dеsign' еspесially as it was prеsеntеdin thе сlassiс disсussion of Arсhdеaсon \Villiam Palеy in Ьls Nаturаl Thеologу(1802). Howеvеr' what was no lеss inrportant was that although Darwin may havе Ьееn a dеist (latеr hе Ьесamе agnostiс)' for him a god of any kind had no plaсе in a sсiеntifiс ехplanation. Еvеrything must Ье ех. plainеd without rесoursе to mirасlеs or othеr spесially guidеd forms of forсе. Thе statusof еvolutionary thought raisеspartiсularly intеrеstingquеstions and surprisinganswеrs.Darwin himsеl{ wantеd to raisе the status of еvolutionary thought up to thе lеvеl of physiсs and сhеmistry-аs a maturе sсienсе, funсtiоning within univеrsitiеs and rеsеarсh сеntеrs, with skillеd praсtitionеrsusing natural sеlесtion as a toсll to сut through thе proЬlеms of organiс еxistеnсе and funсtion. Hе wantеd еvolution to Ье what Wе today might сall a profеssional sсiеnсе. But it was not to Ье. Darwin was а siсk man' so thе fatе of his idеas had to Ье еntrustеd to othеrs-followеrs likе Thomas Hеnry Huхlеy in Еngland, Asa Gray in Amеriсa, and Еrnst Haесkеl in Gеrmany.Unfortunatеly, thеy had aims othеr than thosе of Darwin. Thеy all Ьесamеardеnt еvolutionists,аnd all agrееdthat Darwin's аrgumеnt in thе Оrigin, whiсh showеd how many arеas of Ьiologiсal inquiry сould Ье tiеd togеthеrundеr thе umЬrеlla of еvolution, was dеfinitivе. But fеw, if any' wеrе vеry kееn on natural sеlесtion.No onе dеniеd it outright, but somе thought that thе wholе issuе of finаl сausе Was ovеrЬlown аnd hеnсе that sеlесtion was unnееdеd,and othеrs thought that final сausе still nееdеd еxplanation and that sеlесtionсould not really do thе joЬ. Еithеr way, pеoplе turnеd to othеr putativе сausеs' suсh аs Lamarсkism, еvolution Ьy jumps or what wе today might сall mасromutations (thе thеory is known as saltationism)' or еvolutionthrough a kind of intеrnal momеntum (orthogеnеsis). Admittеdly,thеrе wеrе somе signifiсantЬiolоgiсаl pгoЬlеms with Darwin's thеory.onе was that hе had no working thеory of hеrеdity.Pеoplе сould not sееhow suffiсiеntnеw variation сould arisе and Ье maintainеd within populations that sеlесtion сould havе a lasting еffесt (Vorzimrnеr 1970). Somеwhat unfortunatеlyDarwin сompoundеd his proЬlеms in this rеspесtЬy аssuming that whеn two organisms Ьrееd, thе usual еffесt is that thеir distinсtivе fеaturеs Ьlеnd with thosе of thеir matеs. Неnсе, if only onе has a nеw' valuaЬlе variatiоn, within a gеnеration or two it is Ьlеndеd into virtually nonЬеing. !Иhatwas nееdеdwas a ,.partiсulatе''thеory of hеrеdity,that prеsеrvеdgood nеw fеaturеs from gеnеration ro gеnеration. Anothеr proЬlеm of Darwin's Wasthat on thе Ьasis of саlсulations aЬout the agе of thе еarth madе Ьy lеading physiсists (notaЬly thе futurе Lсlrd Kеlvin), thеrе Was too littlе timе for suсh а lеisurеly proсеss аs naturаl sеlесtion to takе еffесt (Burсhfre|d |975). But in a Way thе sсiеntifiс proЬlеrns Wеrе not thе dесiding faсtor. lfhat was
25
1
:
4 i
26
Тhе Historу of Еuolutioltаrу Thoиght signifiсant wаs that еvеn Darwin's most ardеnt followеrs wеrе gеnеrally not that intеrеstеd in turning еvolution into a profеssional sсiеnсе' at lеast not as Dаrwin еnyisioned it. This wаs thе timе of grеat fossil disсovеries in thе Nеw \world-all of thosе dinosаur rтlonstеrsof thе past-and naturally thеrе was grеat intеrеst in woгking out thе truе pаths of lifе's history (Figurе 18). In сombination with not-аltogеthеr_rеliаЬlеmеthodologiеs liftеd from еmЬryology' most famously Haесkеl's so.сallеd Ьiogеnеtiс law thаt ontogеny (thе history of thе individual) rесаpitulatеsphylogеny (thе history of thе group), muсh еffort was еxpеndеd on working out thе full dеtails of thе еvolutionаry trее of lifе. But as a сausal thеory of origins, еvolution was somеwhat of a flop. Its еnthusiаsts Wеrе сontеnt to kееp it morе аt thе lеvеl of a ..popular sсi. еnсе,'' whеrе it сould hаvе a diffеrеnt rolе. Why? By thе sесond half of thе ninеtееnth сеntlrry, mеn likе Huxlеy wеrе working haгd to Ьring thеir soсiеtiеs сrut of thе еightееnth сеntury and into thе twеntiеth (Dеsmond 7994, 1997)' Thеy triеd to геform thе military, mеdiсinе, thе сivil sеrviсе'еduсation, and othеr institutions' A strЬjесtlikе pЬysiology oЬviously hаs а pragmatiс payoff in suсh arеаs as mеdiсinе (F.igurе19).
TtIЕ
. . G г е а tS t i I . i g u r еl 9 . Т h е uninhaЬitаЬlеЬесаusеthс
Еvolrrtion sееms to hav Ьinеd with thе idеologу thе nеw rеfornlеd soсiс C h г i s t i a n i t v ,a k i n d o f s origins, а story of hurn they wеrе going arrd wh bаsiсаlly this wаs how l
Figurе 18. Dinosaur modеls'It wаs Riсhard owеn, in thе еаrly 1840s,who lаЬеlеda major grouр сlf rеptilеsas dinosaurs.From thе firstthеy сaptuгеd pеoplе'simaginations'as thеy still do. Thеsесonсrеtе,paintedmodеlswеrе madе foг thе Grеat ЕхhiЬition of London in 1851' whеrеBritain showеdits prowеss to thе world. Thеy arе now prеsеrvеdin а park in south London. Notе that thеy show dinosaursas rаthеrhеavy,сluпrsyЬrutеs'Tсldаy,wе think thеm muсh morе aсtivе.
rus of thе day, of whol еnсr Неrbеrt Spеnсеr. J anything from thе еigh from thе undiffеrеntiat thе homogеnеous to th thе Еarth, in thе dеvеlt Soсiеty, of Govеrnmеn aturе, sсiеnсе' Art, tl thгough suссеssivеdif]
Тhе Нistorу of Еuolutiсlпаrу Tboиgbt ardеnt followеrs wеrе gеnеrally not a profеssional sсiеnсе,at lеast not as of grеat fossil disсovеriеs in thе Nеw lf thе past-and naturally thеrе was ,aths оf lifеЪ history (Figurе 18). In mеthodologiеsliftеd from еmЬryol,iogеnеtiсlaw that ontogеny (thе hisylogеny (tlrе histоry of thе group), ut thе full dеtails of thе еvolutionary 'igins, еvolution was somеwhat of a it morе at thе lеvеl of a ..popular sсiеnth сеntury' mеn likе Huхlеy wеrе t of thе еightееnthсеntury and into iеy triеd to rеform the military, mеdrеr institutions. A suЬjесt likе physir suсh arеasas mеdiсinе (Figurе 19).
TнЕ
..SILЕNT }IIGнWAY''.MAN
Figurе19. Thе ..GrеatStink.''In thе suпrmеrof 1858 London Ьесаmеnеаrly uninhabitaЬlе bесausеthе Thamеs had Ьесorтеsuсh a vilе, odifеrousrесеptaсlе of еvеryonе'sraw sеwagе.Fеw things Ьrоught homе morе vividly to thе Viсtoriansthе nееdfor trainingin modеrn tесhnolоgiсalsr.rЬjесts, likе сivil (From Рuпch' 1858.) enginееring.
l owеn, in thе еarly 1840s,who rrs. From thе first thеy сapturеd e сonсrеte'paintedmodеls wеrе n 1851,whеrеBritainshowеdits ',еdin a park in south London. Notе lumsy Ьrutеs.Today, wе think thеm
Еvolution sееms to havе no suсh immеdiatе funсtion. But' еspесially сomЬinеd with thе idеology of progrеss, it сould funсtion as thе philosophy of thе nеw rеformеd soсiеty-it сould havе a rolе as а kind of altеrnаtivе to Сhгistianity,a kind of sесular rеligion in its own right. It сould Ье a story of origins,a story of humans' еxaltеd plасе in thе proсеss, a vision of whеrе thеywеrе going and what thеy should do to еnsurеsuссеssand triumph. And basiсallythis was how еvolutiс-ln Was prolnotеd, еspесiallyЬy thе lеading gurus of thе day' of whom nonе Was morе voсal than thе Еnglish man of sсiе n с еH е г Ь е r rS p е n с е r .P l а y i n g u p е v t l I u t i t l l lh, i s v i s i t l п W a s a s p r с l g r е s s i v aе s anythingfrom the еightееnthсеntury. Spеnсеr saw progrеss as Ьеing a movе from thе undiffеrеntiatеd to thе diffеrеntiatеd, or what hе сallеd a movе from thе homogеnеousto thе hеtеrogеnеous:..Whеthеrit Ье in thе dеvеlopmеntof thе Еarth, in thе dеvеlopmеntof Lifе upon its surfaсe' in tlre dеvelopment of Soсiеty,of Govеrnmеnt,of Manufaсturеs, of Сommеrсе, of Languagе, Litеraturе, Sсiеnсе,Art, this sаmе еvolution of thе simplе into thе сomplеХ' throughsuссеssivеdiffеrеntiatiсlns,holds throughout'' (Spеrrсеr1857,2_З).
27
2 8 Tbe Historу of Еuolutioпаrу Тhought Еvеrything oЬеys this law. Humans arе morе сomplеx or hеtеrogеnеousthan othеr animals, Еuгopеans arе morе сomplеx or hеtеrogеnеous than savagеs' and thе Еnglish languagе is moге сomplеx oг hеtеrogеnеousthan thе tonguеs of othеr pеoplеs (Figurе 20). Inсidеntаlly, it was НеrЬеrt Spеnсеr who popularizеd thе word euolutioп, Until thе middlе of thе ninеtееnth сеntury' thе tеrm was gеnеrally rеsеrvеd for thе dеvеlopmеnt of thе individual (ontogеny). For evolution in thе mod..trаnsformation'' еrn sеnsе (phylogеny), most pеoplе usеd words likе (Riсhards 1'992). Sееing no еssеntiаl diffеrеnсе Ьеtwееn thе dеvеlopmеnt of
thе individual and thе d. just-quotеd еssay on prl tеrm for both. In thе С ..dеsсеntwith modi was ..еvolvеd.''Darwin alwa him a woolly and loosе t in the Оrigiz, a work tl tеndеd as a maior сontr usе a tеrm thаt appеaгеd to philosophy, litеratur timе of Tbe Dеscеnt of 1
day had Ьесomе univеrs and as сomfortaЬly as a A good rеligion' sесu of еvolution' thе artiсul; winism. Thе Ьasiс pattс ai
;2 Й>
Rд i6
f3
ЁЁ
зa Sqtl
Ё*з z'tt2
*i* si r:
.ё <: .a !.
i..
Figurе 20. Thе trее of lifе as drawn Ьy Еrnst Haесkеl. Notiсе just how thе idеa of progrеssinfluеnсеdhis piсturе of lifе's history. (From HаeсkeL1897, 2:188.)
nеss of еvolution-sirг monаd to man. This is а vеry lеast, not impеdе i with thе еvolutionary p should promotе it and < Ьy еvolution. Start wit} nеvег oссurs-аnd it is : soсioесonomiс soсial p< pеtition, and thе wеak
supportеd amеlioration thе faсt that undеr thе r its unhеalthy' imbесilе ing,thoughwеll-mеani thе purifying proсеss br thе multipliсation of tt failing provision, and , providеnt by hеightеni ( S p е n с е r| 8 5 1 , з 2 3 _ 3 2 Christians diffеr, soI mеanings of thеir rеlig from anything еlsе, ma: world than in thе Ьiolo1 wеrе liЬеrtarian; othеrs еvolution; and still oth' appеaling to a kind оf low mеmbеrs of a spе сhism. Somе wеrе fеmi Somе wеrе paсifists (S
All usеd еvolution lеss living world-as a full-
З0
Thе Histсlrу of ЕuсllиtiсlпаrуThoиght for thе nеW soсiеty. No longеr:r psеudсlsсiеtlсе, еvоlutit)nwаs сегсainlyrro morе than a populаr sсiеnсе. l"{
Thе Synthеtiс Thеory Things pеrsistеdthis way into thе еarly dесасlеsof thе twепtiеth сеntuгу аnd in somе rеspесtsЬесamе еvеn worsе whеn Сontinеntal thirrkеrs,notaЬly thе еmbryologist Hans Driеsсh in Gеrmany and thе philosophеr Неnгi Bегgson in Franсе, Ьеgan pLrshinga kind of nеo-Aгistorеlianthеory of lifе thаt szrw spесiаl, nonphysiсal final forсеs guiding tlrе path of еvolution. DriеsсЬ's еntеlесhiеsаnd Bеrgson,sёlапs uitаuх' thе foundatiоns of ..vitalisпr,''wеrе iust not thе еlеmеnts of а forward-looking modеrn sсiеnсе.Rеliеf finally сamе with thе dеvеlopmеntof Mеndеliаn gеnеtiсsаnсl its mеlding rvith Darwiniurn sеlесtiorr,although еvеtrhеrе thе proсеss took til-r-rе аnd lvirs not stri]ishtforward (Рrovine |97I). Grеgor Меndеl, а Morаvian mtlпk who livеd irr thе Austro-Hungагian Еmpirе, disсovеrеdthе еssеntialprinсiplеs of hеrеdity in thе 1860s. Unlikе Darwin, hе sa'ur, thе trаnsmissionof сharасtеristiсsas ..pzlrtiсulatе,'' Ьеliеving thаt fеaturеslikе сolor аnd sizе саn Ье p.rssеdon without thе thrеat оf Ьеing Ьlеndеd аwаy (Figurе 2l ). Howеvеr, it was not Llntil thе bеginning of thе twеntiеth сеnttrrythat pеoplе сamе to аppгесiаtеthе impor. tanсе of Mеndеl's work and saw thаt it providеd а kеy еlеmеntin thе story of еvolution. You miglrt think thаt this was a tеrriЬlе missеd opportunity, and that, hаd Dагwin rеad Mеndеl's kеy papеr, hе would hllvе rеаlizеd thаt гtow hе had thе answеrs to all of tlrе issuеs of hеrеdity thаt his thеory of nаtural sеlесtion dеmandеd. Henсе, thе thеory would havе mсlvеd forward morе quiсkly' muсh еаrliеr. This is proЬaЬly not sO. Еvеn whеn thе work of Mеndеl was disсovеrеd, it to
N-\.J
\
'\\
r {
F i g u r е2 l . T h е p е a p l a n Меndеl to work out thе many diffеrentvariеtiе so forth. Меndеl сould passеdfrom onе gеnеfа rеsultswеге a littlе too l he was only rесordingr ovеrzеalouslytrying to plа sevеntееnth-сеntury
was rеvеalеd, and it с Finally, around 1930, taЬly R' A. Fishеr (19 Wright (19З7' t9Зz) sеlvеs and arе transmi works оnly in thе grou work to rhе соmplеtiс
Tbe Historу rlf Еuolutionаrу Тbought osсiеnсе'еvolution was сеrtainly no
dесаdеsсlf thе twеntiеthсеntury and LеnСсlntinепtalthinkеrs, notably thе 'and thе phiiosophеr Hеnri Bеrgson l-Aristotеlianthеory of lifе that saw thе path of еvolution.Driеsсh's еntfoundаtionsof ..vitalism'''wеrе just modеrn sсiеnсе.Rеliеf finally сamе еtiсsand its mеldirrgwith Darwinian s took timе and wаs not straightfora Моravian monk who livеd in thе hе еssеntialprinсiplеs of hеrеdity in rnsmissionof сharaсtеristiсsas ..parэr and sizе сan Ье passеdon without е 21). Howеvеr. it was not until thе lеoplе сamе to apprесiаtеthе imporlrovidеd a kеy еlеmеnt in the story of 's a tеrriЬlеmissеd opportunity' and lеr, hе would havе rеalizеd thаt now lf hеrеditythat his thеory of natural . would havе mсlvеd forward morе y not so. Еvеn whеn thе work of l assimilatеit. Many pеoplе at first )r than a ссlmplеment(sееЬеlow). So гhе monk's work was puЬlishеd in a ;еarсhеd,Darwin would havе found :е would havе Ьееn a ..еurеka'' m
Figurе21. Thе pеa plant.This lowly gаrdеnvеgеtаЬlеWas thе organismusеd Ьу Меndеlto wоrk out thе prinсiplеsof hеrеdity.lt wаs еasyto grow аnd сamе in manydifferеntvariеtiеsand forms-sееd аnd pod shapеand сolor, hеight'and so forth.Меndеl сould thеrеforеdistinguishаnd rесord hоw fеаturеsWеrе passеdfrom onе gеnеrationto thе nехt. It now sееmsсеrtainthat Меndеl's rеsultswеrеа littlе too good to Ье truе. It сould havе Ьееnthаt suЬсonsсiously hеwas only rесordingrеsultsthat fit his hypothеsis,or that thе gardеnеrwas ovеrzеаlously tryingto plеasеhis mastсr.This stylizеdpiсturеis from a latе. seventееnth-сеntury рlant Ьook.
was rеvеalеd,and it сould Ье sееn as thе сomplеmеnt tO natural sеlесtion. Finally,aгound 1930, a numЬеr of highly giftеd mathеmatiсal biologists,not a Ь l yR . A . F i s h е r ( 1 9 3 0 )a n d J . B . S . H а l d a n е ( \ 9 з 2 \ i n Е n g l a n d a n d S e w a l l !Иright (|9З1, I9З2) in Amеriса, showеd how Меndеlian gеnеs sort thеmsеlvеsand arе transmittеd irr groups (arrеssеntial finding, givеn that sеlесtion works only in thе group situation),and thеn it wаs possiЬlеto bring Darwin's work to thе сomplеtion that it nееdеd.Along with mutation (thе сoming of
З1
З2
Тhе Historу of Еuolutionаrу Thought new variation, сausеd Ьy spontanеous сhangеs in gеnеs),nаtural sеleсtion сan truly Ье a signifiсant forсе for сhangе. Sinсе Ьy thе 1930s thе quеstion of thе agе of thе еаrth was no longеr prеss. ing (thе disсovеry of thе warming еffесts of radioасtivе dесay showеd that thе еаrth is quitе old еnor-rghfoг thе slow workings of sеlесtion),Ьiologists movеd rapidly forward with nеw idеas (known as popиlаtion genеtiсs) tЬat woцld put еmpiriсal flеsh on thе mathеmatiсal skеlеtons. In Britain a highly voсal supportеr of гhе thеoгy was Thomas Неnry Huxlеy's grandson Julian Huхlеy (thе oldеr brothеr of novеlist Aldous Huxlеy)' who produсеd a major work that pullеd idеas togеther:Еuolution: T|эe Мodеrп Sуnt|lesis(|942). Sсiеntifiсally, aftеr Fishеr thе most important figurе was thе oxford Ьiologist Е. B. Ford (|964), who did groundЬrеaking studiеs of sеlесtion in populа. tions of Ьuttеrfliеs and who gаthеrеd around himsеlf in а sсhool of ..есologi. сal gеnеtiсs''a numЬеr of youngеr rеsеarсhеrslikеwisе interеsrеdin sеlесtion and its еffесts in naturе. Notеworthy wеrе Aгthur Сain (1954) and Philip Shеppard (1958), who workеd on Ьanding pattеrns in snails, and Bernard К е t t l е w е l l1l 9 7 3 ) ' w h o s е i n t е r е s т w s е r е i n i n с l u s t r i am l еlanisnl-rhе wаys in whiсh Ьuttеrfliеs сhangе adаptivе сolor pattеrns as thеir haЬitats arе сhangеd Ьy thе еffесtsof smokе and pollLrtion.[n Amеriсa thе influеntial figurе was thе Russian-Ьorn gеnеtiсistThеodosius DoЬzhansky' whosе Geпеtics апd thе Оrigiп of Spесies |\9З7) wаs an inspiration to zrwholе gеnеrаtion of еvolu.s7orking tionists (Figurе 22). аlongsidе him wеrе othеrs' notaЬly thе oгnithologist/taхonomist Еrnst Мayr (author of Sуstemаtiсs апd the Оrigin of Spесiеs, 1942), thе palеontologist Gеorgе Gayloгd Simpson (Tеmpo апd Мodе iп Еuolutioп, 1944), and thе Ьotanist G. Lеdyard StеЬbins (Vаriаtioп апd Еuolutioп iп Plапts,1950). By thе 1950s Darwin's drеam of a maturе' profеssional sсiеnсе of еvolutionary Ьiology was rеalizеd. Мorеovеr, it was gеnuinеly Darwinian, for although thеrе had Ьееn prеtеndеrs to thе сausal thronе, notaЬly Sеwall .lfright's proсеss of gеnеtiс drift (random сhаngеs in gеnе frеquеnсy in small populаtions duе to thе vаgariеs of Ьrееding),it was гесognizеdthat thе kеy faсtor in organiс naturе is its adaptivеnеss, its manifеstation of final сausе' and thаt natural sеlесtionis a full :rnd satisfying way of еxplaining this phеnomеnon. At thе same tilтrе' proЕlress-and all thе moralizing and philosophizing that wеnt along with it-hаd Ьееn еxpеllеd.No onе was going to usе this kind of profеssional Ьiology as an ехсusе for quasi-rеligiousspесulations aЬout thе stаtus of humankind and thе oЬligations thаt naturе lays upon hum a п s ( F i g u г е2 3 ) ' Yеt, for all this, thеrе is onе morе important faсtor to thе story, and this partly еxplains why to this day еvolutionаry idеas rеmаin so сontrovеrsial to so many. Although еvolutionary Ьiology wаs upgradеd from thе lеvel of a popular sсiеnсеto thе lеvеl of a profеssional sсiеnсе,this did not oссur simply out o{ a disintеrеstеdquеst for thе truth Ьу mеn who hаd no aims Ьut thе finding of thе workings of naturе. Virtually еvеry onе of thе nеw profеssional biologists' from Fishеr to StеЬЬins,Ьесamеаn еvolutionistЬесаusеlrе was attraсtеd to thе suЬjесt Ьy thinking that it was morе than just a sсiеntifiс thеory.
Figuге 22. ThеodosiusDo fourth from left) at а сonf sсienсеmеаns having stud Hаrvard gеnеriсistRiсhаr Сornеll genеtiсistBruсе V was a Spаnishpriеst Ьеfor right in thе front row. Сlе sеxеswas а long-lastingp
For somе, likе DoЬzh: Ьгought pгogrеss-prog piсturе that saw God wс divisions that wеrе сru God's gгaсе аnd аn rrnfu was attraсtеd to thе idс ( 1 9 5 5 ) ,w h о p r o m o t е d and Мayr and Simpson too likеd thе idеa of prс somе kind of dirесtion r Bесausе all thеsе sеп еarly twеntiеth сеntury, dripping with mеtaphv surprisе if this had not h i m s е l f ,t h i s n е w l l r е е d sional status for thеir a< sсiеntists-thеn thеy wt pесts. Thеy nееdеd to d
Тhe Нistor,-oi Еuolutionаrу.[,hought 3.] эhangеsin gеnеs),natural sеlесtion е. agе of thе еarth Was no longеr press:s of radioaсtivе dесay showеd that w workings of sеlесtion),Ьiologists known as populаtiotl gепеtiсs) t,Ьat i]atiсalskеlеtons. In Britain a highly ras Flеnry Huxlеy's grandson Julian ous Huxlеy), who produсеd a major ioп: The Мodеru Sуnthesis (1,942). 'tant figurе was thе oхford Ьiologist king studiеsof sеlесtion in popula'und himsеlfin а sсhool of ..есologiсhеrs likеwisе intеrеsted in sеlесtion .еrеArthur Сain (1954) and Philip ing pattеrns in snails, and Bеrnard n industrial mеlanism-thе ways in attеrnsas thеir haЬitatsarе сhangеd -rAmеriсa thе influеntial figurе was )oЬzhansky,whosе Gепеtiсs апd tbe ion to a wholе gеnеration of еvoluhim wеrе othеrs, notaЬly thе or. or of Sуstеmаtiсsапd thе Оrigiп of гgе Gaylord Simpson (Tempo апd nist G. Lеdyard StеЬЬins(Vаriаtion
Figure22. ThесldсlsiusDoЬzhansk1''This piсturе of DoЬzhanskу froпt rrlш, fourtbfrom lеft) at a сonfеrеnсеwith his studеntsundеrlinеshow suссеssful mеanshаvingstudеntswho rvill саrry on and dеvеlоpyour idеas.Thе sсienсе HarvаrdgеnеtiсistRiсhard Lеwсlntinis sесondfrom thе lеft in thе front rсrw; lWаllaсеis riglrt Ьеhindhim; anс1FrаnсisсrlAyаlа (whсl СornеllgеnеtiсistBrr"rсе wasa SpanisЬpriеstЬеforеlrе Ьес.rпlеan Amеriсan еvolutionist)is on tlrе far rightin thе front row. Сlеarly' Dаrц,in'sviеrvson tlrе rеlаtivеaЬilitiеsсlf tЬе sехеswas a long-lastingprеjudiсеirl еvсllutionаryсirсlеs.
lturе' profеssiоnаl sсiеnсе of еvoluit was gеnuinеly Darwinian, for althе сausal thгonе, notаЬly Sеwаll r сhangеs in gеnе frеquеnсy in small ing), it was rесognizеd that thе kеy :ss, its manifеstationof final сausе' tisfying way of еxplaining this phеlnd all thе moralizing and philoson е х p е l l е dN . o onе was goingto usе сusеfor quasi-rеligiousspесulations Ьligations that lraturе lays upon hu-
For somе, likе Dobzhansky, thе i1ttrz1сtionwаs ехpliсitly rеligious. Не ЬroughtpгogГеss-progrеssto httmаns,that is-inttl a kind of ovеrirll world piсturеthat saw God working his way through thе foгсеsof nаturе. Ignoring divisions that wеrе сruсial to еarliеr thinkеrs, DoЬzhansky thought that God,sgraсеand irn unfrrrlingсrеаtion сould Ье сomЬinеd. Unsurpгisingly, hе was attraсtеdto thе idеas of thе .[еsuitpalеontolсlgistTеilhard dе Сhаrdin Huхlеv in Еngland (1955),who pronrсltеdsimitаr idеas. Othегs, likе .[r.rliаrr and Мayr and Simpson in Amегiсa, wеrе sесцlal.iп thеir thinking, Ьtrt thеy too likеd thе idеa of progrеss and thought that it showеd thаt еvolutitln had
)ortant faсtor to thе story' and this ary idеas rеmain so сontrovеrsiаl to , was upgradеd from tlrе lеvеl of а > n a ls с i е n с еt,h i s d i d n o t o с с u r s i m LthЬy mеn who had no aims Ьut thе ly еvеry onе of thе nеw profеssional tе an еvolutiоnist bесausе hе was at'as morе than just a sсiеntifiс thеory.
somеkind of dirесtiсlnand mеаning. Bесausеall thеsе sеminal еvolutiоnists wеrе pеoplе whо grеw up irr thе еarlytwеntiеthсеntr.lry,whеn rnuсlr uldhavе Ьееn a surprisеif this Ьad not Ьееn tЬе lnаin motivating fасtсlr. But' likе Darwin saw that if thеy wеrе to havе profеshimsеlf,this nеrv Ьrееd of еvolr"rtionists sionalstatusfor thеir асtivitiеs-soп1еthingthеy аrdеntly dеsirеd as full-timе sсiеntists-thеnthеy would nееd ttl purify thеir work Of its ехtrasсiеntifiсaspесts.Thеy nееdеdto dеal witlr dсlсrrinеsof prсlgrеss:rnd with еХtгapolаtеd
34
Тhе Historу of Еuolutionаrу Thought
STUDIЕS oi\ IltliADIATЕD POPULAT]ONS D no So P Н I I, А M l] I' А N oG А S1,]tr]l*
oI..
By BRUCE WALLAс]] Bio|фc,ot I,a|пralorу,CoIdSqriщ llа'rbor, N.Y. (With Fivе Teхt.figures) (Recеiod 28 Jdу |95б) rштвoоuстloш It iв well kпorтn thаt the тridеspгead use of ionizing гвdiations, beсsuse of tlrеiг gеnetiс effeсts, posoв в pгoЬlem futurе genегations. The*е гadiвtions induсe gene .""g""diog mutations. TЬe vast majority of mutвtions haie dеletегiousеffесtson individuals свгrying them. Undег the pгеssuгe of сontinued mutatiоn, thеse deleteгious mutationв will aосumulatе in populвtionв. Thereforе, an iтгadiated population will, on thе avеrage, be lцrmеd-havе its .fitnesв' reduced'-by a сontinual u*р.o." to irгadiation. The pгеsеnt aгtiсle вummarizев obsrгvдtions made on iгrаdiatвd po|oйi1"". oi lиo. so1lhilamе|юnчавtюr.Somе of thе.mвterial presentedteгe haв Ьееn p"ьri'ьa pгeviously (Wallaсе, 1950, lg5l; wl]tryе & King, l95i, 1952). This summвгy,^ho,n".'',u., will intro. duсe lrew mдtоrial in вddition to еxtйding the oгiginai obsеrvatiЬns. Мдтввlдr, AND DtEтЕoDs Thе erpет'imеntnlnop]nlion.s. Tire eхpетimental population в of D' mеIюn,чoslerarе kept in luсite and sсгееnсageв.The огiginal fliев *eгe oЪйinеd fгom an oгчoniR stгвin kept' lry mass tгвnsfеr for mвny yearв. Fouгtеen letЬal. and sеmi.letЬвl-fгee sесond сhгomosomes wеге extrвсted fгom thig.stгвin thгough the usе of a вeriевof matings identiсal to tJrовedesсribed later (Fig. 2.)'.Flies сaгrying thеsе sесond сhгomosomes and miхtures of orеgon.R and .markеd stoоk' сhromosomeвotheг than thе ..""od ;;;; йlarental fliеs оf thс populвtions. Rгief dевсriptions of thе рpulationв aге given in Tаblе 1. Thе left-hand сolumn gives thе identifying numbег foг eaсh populвtion. Thе весondсolumn indiсateв tircoгrgin of thо .Stoоkв'indiоatеs populations whoвеoгiginal flies сaтгiedluth'l.г."u рopulation. *uсond сhгomosomes of oregon-R. deгivation. Tlrтeе more rеоent populations aгe subpopulations оf populationв 5 вnd 6; the deвignation in the tablе gives tie^pвгent,r p"p"ьt,l"" and the gеnегation duгing whiеh eggs wеIе removеd to вtaгt tЬе nеw The tЬird р"p'i*;;;. сolumn indiсвtеs the numlrег.ofвdulЬ in thе population .Ь,gu' .uiu.* to popotu. ".g"*, tions of aliout ]0,000 indir'iduals,.small'fo рpulвtionsЪ"qo"oТly *]iti гu'u. tь"n 1000 ildividuals. Thе last thгee сolumns of TaБlе l givе thЁ typJ ot."*po*uге, the
Figurе 23. A papеr on fruit fliеs Ьy Bruсе \Х/allaсe.Sее thе aсknowlеdgmеnt at thе^bottomof thе pagе. By thе 1950s' evсllutionistswеrе Ьесomi.'g u.iy сrеativе at finding funds for thеir work. DoЬzЬаnsky pеrsuadеdthe U.S. Aiomiс Еnеrgy Сommission that fruit fliеs wеге thе pеrfeсtmodеl organism for studyof the effeсtsof nuсlеаr rаdiation, a majсlr worry at thе timе givеn thе o.'goi.,g tеstlng of ЬomЬs (in.thеatmosphеrе). In Еnglanj, Е. B. Fоrd fеrsuadеdthБ шurя"ld Foundation that thе study of Ьuttеrfliеsgavе insight inio thе sprеad of gеnеsin populаtionsаnd hеnсewas of grеatvaluе in studyinghuman gеnеtiсallv саused аilmеnts.
moral ехhortations. so 1 Progrеss' morality, and l duсеd as profеssional rеs foundеd journal Еuolutiс authors' dеpositеd with t ing aЬout his intеntions l еnсеs аs possiЬlе. On tЬ ..Thе fiеld hаs rеaсhed Also, еvolutionary rеsеa from thе phylogеnеtiс ir еvaluаting thе faсtors of on thе othеr hand, it ha sеаrсh has suffеrеd in thl tion'' (lеttеr to G. G. Fеr Yеt, having donе thеir tionists thеn wrotе othеr еxhortаtion as anything 1 rrсtivеs wеrе foсusеd on l ninеtеenth. ..Thе most еs Ье just this: knowlеdgе' t As a first proposition of еvolution, it is suЬmittеd aсquisition of nеw truths ly the mutations of thе n. to othеrs and Ьy thеir aс< ity)'' (Simpson 1949, З1 Stаlinism was at its pеal undеr thrеat Ьесausе of t surprisingly, thеrеforе, .. and undеr somе сurrеnt ( ogy whiсh сan Ье madе t< of еthiсs hеrе maintainеd
Thе Past Half Сеntt
That was all 50 or morе synthеtiс thеorists in Am sidеrеd just as a sсiеnсе, thеory dеsеrvеdly is onе еmpiriсаl inquiгy. Еvery flourishеs as nеvеr Ьеfort еmpiriсal, havе rеaсhеd Rosеmary and Pеtеr Gral paradigmatiс еxamplе of hаs Ьееn vеry imoortant ]
сD PoPULAT]olt,s ol. LАNoGАS1,Eht* rALLАcli фniщ llarbor, N'Y. кt.figureв) uJу |9bб) ,тIoN
nizing radiations, bесause of t}reiг genetiс nегвtionв. TЬese гвdiвtions induсi gene l delеtегiouвеffeсtson individu"l. ."..}ьg ,tвtion, thеsе delеteriouв mutations wil.i tiвtod рpulation will, on the avеrвge, Ь ;inual ехрвuге to iггдdiвtion. r mдd-e. on iггвdiдted populations of Drosentedheгеlrвв bеen puЬlished pгеviously 952)'Thiв summвгy, howeveг,will intro. е oгiginвl obsеrvations. }lEтвoD8
tal populationвot D' mеlл,nчasler aге kept
fr:T
oгеgon-R stгainkeit
::lb*iid 1n iial- and sеmi.lethвl-fгee seсond the use of a seгieвof mвtings identiсвl "h.on,Ьtо resевесondсhromosomesand miхtuгes of heтthgn thе вeеondrveгethe paгеntal flies
эn in Tablе l. Thе left.hand сolumn gil,es e seсondсolumn indiсates tй" o.lgi,, #tьu rвe original flies сaггied lethal.frer seсoпj oJe recrnt poрulationsaгe вubpopulations вbIеgivesthе pвтеntalpopulation and thе .o ..11' tbе nеw р
/allaсе.Sееthе aсknowlеdgmentat riсlnistswеrе Ьесominguеiy сгеarivе ,,pеrsuadеdthе U.S. Atomiс Еnеrgy modеl organismfor study of thе ...i'.. givеnthe ongoingгеsring l. f :. б. l.ord pеrsпаdеdrhе Nuf6еld : insightinto thе spreаd of яеnеsin s г u d y i n gh u m a ng е n е t i с a l Iсyа u s е d
Tbе Нistorу
Thе Past Half Сеntury Тhаt wаs all 50 oг morе yеars ago. Thе nеo.Darwinians in Britain and thе synthеtiсthеoristsin Аmеriса Ьuilt good foundations for thеir sсiеnсе.Сonsidеrеdjust as a sсiеnсе,whiсli it h,. .u..y right to Ье, modеrn еvoluttonary thеorydеsеrvеdlyis onе of thе most fo,-n,j-looking and е*сitinf аrеas of еmpiriсal inquiry. Еvеry onе of thе аrеаs trеatеd Ьy Dаrwin in t|te Оrigin flourishеsas nеvеr Ьеforе.Sеlесtion studiеs thеmsеlvеs,Ьoth thеorеtiсаl and еmpiriсal' havе геaсhed a УerУ high dеgreе of sophistiсation. The work of Rosеmaryand Pеtеr Grant (1989) on thе Ьеak sizе of Gal5pagos finсhеs is a paradigmatiсехаmplе of ехсеllеnt sсiеnсе.Тhе аdvеrrtof -oГ...'ln. biology has Ьееnvеry important hеrе for offеring Ьotl-rnеw insights (for instanсе, thе
JJ
тIoN
lФ*{itNl C :EYl}ьl,llт цр1g
Figlrе 24. Thе сovеr of thе first issuе сlf Еuсllиtir.пt. onе сlf thе ЬiggеstprсrЬlеms of thеsееarly profеssionalеvolutionistswas of findingpеoplе,working to thеir standards,who wеrе nоt studyingfruit fliеsor similar organisrns.Thе journal was launсhеdwith а gгаntfrom thе Amеriсаn PЬilosophiсalSoсiеty(fсlundеdЬy BenjaminFranklin) in PЬilаdеlphia.Rеvеаlingly,tЬе only pеrsonOn thе grxnts сommittееwho opposеdthе fundingWаs thе еmЬryologistЕdwin Сonklin. ЕmЬryologyWas thеn thе quееnof thе Ьiсllogiсalsсiеrrсеs and Сonklin was not сonvinсеdthаt еvolutionсor-rldЬе thе Ьasisof rсal profеssionirlsсiеnсе.Pеrhaps bесausеоf thеsеdisсiplinarytеnsions,еvolutionistsrеspсlndеdЬv ignorrng Ьiology еmbryologyand it was not until thе 1980s,Ьy wЬiсh timс m
signifiсanсеof drift at thе nеtiс fingеrprinting for dс .W dеtailеd in Еdward o. Sуnthеsis (1975), havе po tion and rесiproсаlaItrui t o е х p l a i n t h е i n t г i с a с i е sl from an individualistiс pе е m p i r i с а ls t u d i е s - f o r i n s t (|982) on thе rеd dееr of S a powеrful faсtor in thе е sially, thе fiеld (oftеn hеrе Darwinian fаshion looks ' fantiсidе and sехual Ьеha tion. Pаlеontology has Ьt major fossil finds-rесеntl twееn fish and amphiЬial mеntion thе finding in Ind srs, naturally known as tJ tесhniquеs havе еnaЬlеd g еvеr gгеаtеr pгесision. At pгoposеd (for instanсе, th аnd thе lаtе Stеphеn Jay othеr arеas of еvolutionar t е r n so f t h е p а s t ( f o r i n s t а | | 9 7 6 | u s е d е с o l o g i с a lt h t pаst pаttеrns of animal с сhangе, an еvеnt that oсс
Figure25. Punсtuatеdеqu g r a d u a l i s m .Ь. у Е l d г е d g еi r а l t е r n а t i v еp i с r u г е( B ) ' i t g l sаltationist,whiсh rathеr s сomparativеtimеsсalеs.Fс сhangесan tаkе plасе duri Ьarеlygеts rесordеdand a
'' : r ;:-'- i ' ; "". :
-*:
"i."
Тhе Historу of ЕurllutiсlttаrуThought
UTION -t
,L oF oпаANIс
вYoLUтlоN
.,.1,,,t''t,',,,,:
,".l!tl:.:
Iуe ю+r
Nв r.?
,.,:;:,l:i .it,l
щril
saeсtion iп wirсl Pqрul*
в.ustу , . -.' . . ' . . . . . . . . . ' . . . . . **"eььL
ai{*фP.
:,
ве. тhс п{attn8
,,,.tt,'.,.'t$' .. '.':'.,:1,
н'srcirl
аьй7pсod*y.
R,,4ьsпrзоп
,i;
.t :,t,',u!{t; *8:
.
.
63
, ,,: ,.:|i :,:lil .,.:l:i*
I i' 'll;* . I r.,r'.r1ti
''"1. , ,,.''-:|':. s9 ..
. ,tli
103 111
.- :"
of dгiit at thе m
ir
I F'uolutiсlп. Orrеof thе ЬiggеstprtlЬlеn.rs working to thеir was of findingpеo1rlе' Thе journal fliеsor sinli]arorganisгrts. lеriсanPhilosophiсаlSoсiеty(fсlundеdЬy vеalingly,thе оnly pеrsol-lon thе grants аs thе еmЬryologistЕdrvirlСonklin. ЬiologiсаlsсiеnсеsanсjСtlnklin Was not lasisof rеal profеssionаlsсiеnсе.Pеrhaps . v o l u t i о n i s rt еs s р t l l l d еhdv i g n о г i n g 80s' Ьy whiсh timе molесr-rlаr Ьiolсlg1, that it agаinЬесzrmе а lnajсlrсlепrеntin
Morphology
|v]orphoIogу
Figurе25. PuпсtuatеdеquiliЬriurn.lrr thе Dаrrviniаnpiсturе,lаЬеlеd..phуlеtiс grаdualism,' Ьy Еldrеdgеаnd Gсluld (A), еvolutiongoеs smoothly.in thеrr piсture(B),it goеsЬy jumps. Gould dеniеdstronglythat hе was a alteгnаtivе whiсh rathеrsuggеststhat muсl-rof thе dеЬаtеwas aЬout saltationist, For а fгuit fly gеnеtiсist,1,000 1'еаrsis an agе аnd muсh соmparаtivе timеsсаlеs. 1,000 yеars сhаngесan takеplaсеduring thаt pеriod.For a pа[еoIltologist, Ьarеlvgеtsгесordеdаnd any сhаngеsarе gоing t()sееnlinstintanеOlls.
З7
]8
Тhe Нisttlr1'tf ЕuolutirlпаrуlT|,с,"r'' Nrlrth Amеriса ioinеd and irrrinralsm
=[so,tь-я.".
\
\_=--,!/ ,/
Cynognathus Тriasвic ReptiIe
ryffi ,/Бr.qЙ-..:-т-,I} ffi
Anteaters Armаdi||os Capybaras Glyptodonts Monkeys Opossums Porсupines
Figurе 27. Pаttеrns of foss y o u a s s u m еr h а t t h е с o n t i г how muсh еvolutioniststo wе hаvе сome from thе ol
Phorusrhaсids Bears
Sloths
Camels
Тouсans
Cats
Тoxodonts
Dogs EIephаnts Horses Peсcaries Rаbbits Raссoons Skunks Тapirs Weаse!s Figurе 26. Тlrе Grеat Amеriсаn Intеrсhаngе. By trеating North Arrrеriса and Sсluth Arrlеriса аs if thеy wеrе t''vо islands Ьеing сolonizеd, onе сan rvork out thе ехpесtесl гаtеs сli ехсlr.lпgс anсl thс numЬеrs tlf invadirrg gr.ouPs сlnе wсluld Ii Ьrium. ехpесt at еqr"ri
Systеmatiсs has bееn tran thе сoming of сomputеrs absorbеd, quantifiеd, сal likеwisе is opеn to nеw u! thе synthеtiс thеorists tе oame euolutioпаrу det,el сеptual baсkwatеr to thе еvolutionary studiеs (Сar
instаnсе,aЬout thе ways mans sharе thе samе un thе ways in whiсh orgс among thе hottеst arеas ( Thеrе arе' of сoursе' с thе importаngg-1hg ygr
еvolutionists' partiсularl; s o m е t i m е sq u е s t i o n s o f .
Thе Historу of Еuсllutioпаrу Tbought )vеdnorth to south and south to north rеoriеsof gеographiсdistribution Wеrе есtoniсs.Until this point, in a tгadition еvolutionistshad spеnt many happy lridgеsand finding ways in whiсh sееds эdiеs of watеr. Now thе moving of thе Lystrosaurus,a mammal-likе hеrЬivo00 million ),еarsago' is fat, short, and t would havе гoamеd far and widе. To. i г s( L o w е rT r i a s s i с )o n t h е с ( ) n t i n е n гos f l. This would Ье inехpliсablе wеrе it not l yеars ago аll thоsе сontinеnts touсhеd ly havе sinсе driftеd apart (Figure 27). Antаrctiса
Mesosaurus Permiаn Reptile
ц--ffi ,
Anteaters Armadillos
\.
Cаpуbaras Glyptodonts MonkeУs Opossums Porсupines
*.*ъ
. -,.,s
fr
Glossopteris PIаnt
ry# /чцw
ч*
Figurе27. Pattеrnsof fossil organisms.ThеsеdistriЬutionsmakе sеnsеonly if youassumеthat thе сontinеntswеrе joinеd. Phеnomеnalikе thеsеshow jusr howmuсhеvolutioniststoday still work in thе Darwinian modе аnd yеt how far we havесomе from tЬe Оrigiп itsеlf. (Unitеd StatеsGеologiсal Survеy.)
Phorusrhaсids Sloths Touсans Тoxodonts
аngе.By trеating North Amеriсa and rds Ьеing сolonizеd, onе сan wсlrk out numЬеrs of invаding groups onе would
Systеmatiсs has Ьееn trаnsformеd Ьy nеw сladistiс tесhniquеs,muсh aidеd Ьy thе сoming of сomputеrs that hаvе allowеd massivе amounts of data to Ье aЬsorЬеd,quantifiеd,сalсulatеd, and undеrstood (Hull 1988). Мoгphology likеwisеis opеn to nеW undеrstandings.AЬovе all' еmЬryology' a suЬjесtthat thе synthetiсthеorists tеndеd to ignorе, has now, еspесiaily undеr thе nеw nameеuolutiсlпаrуdeuеlopmепt (evo-dеvo), Ьееn сonvеrtеd from a nonсon. сеptualЬaсkwatеrto thе most еxсiting arеа of rеsеarсhtoday in thе fiеld of еvolutionarystudiеs(Сarroll 2005). Fantаstiс nеw findings havе еmеrgеd,for instanсе, aЬout thе ways in whiсh organisms аs divеrsе as fruit fliеs and humans sharе thе samе undеrlying gеnetiс mесhanisms for dеvеlopmеnt, and thе ways in whiсh organisms arе Ьuilt and vаriations arе produсеd arе amongthе hottеst arеas of rеsеarсh (Figurеs 28 and 29). Thеrеarе, of сoursе, сontrovеrsiеsand diffеrеnсеs.No onе wants to deny thе importanсе-thе vеry grеаt importаnсе-of natural sеlесtion.But somе partiсularly in arеas likе palеontology and еmЬryology, whеrе еvolutionists, quеstionsof adaptivе signifiсanсеarе (as was еarliеr thе сasе for somеtimеs
39
40
Tbе Historу of Еuolutiсlnаrу Thrlught
pеoplе likе Thomas Hеnr. pеrhaps othеr сausal faсtс of thе thеory of punсtuatе many fеaturеs arе not рal that is, nonfunсtional byL е w o n t i n l 9 7 9 ) ( F i g u r е s. ..Just rеlying tоo oftеn on yard Kipling (Figurе 32).
l"Ь
Dfd
nЬ
Sсr
Antp UЬх aЬd.A AdЬ-I]
fж-жtrжffifIМГ.__l DRosoPHILА нOx (;ЕN1]s
HЕAD-
Тнбйx.
двooйвш-
Figurе 28. Dеvеlopmеnt in thе fruit fly. In thе сеntеr Wе hаvе thе gеnеs that сontrol dеvеlсlpmеnt, in thе ordеr in whiсh thеy Oссur on thе сhromosomе. Bеlсlw wе havе thе lаrvа and aЬovе wе hаvе thе grown fly.
L|vn{d P K в o в т A Y | в H o I L Е L L K I - F н Y | \ R Y L l в п н в } . е t д н t t V L s Е в o U K I W F o N в п м к wKкLкPф\ т К N v R т K в s в т A Y т в o o V L Е L Е K Е l H F N в Y L т п п в н t ! : в t д н s r с r т Е в o I K l W l o N R R M K W K K D йR$L P N l к т в s дi."iiн."д к LDPl .Nl т K | в s PKRsRIAYтRoovLtLFKЕFнYNвYLтRвRRVLIAF{ALсLsLRoIKIWFoNJRвMKWKK м^i'."н.,вд t R o I K I W F o N в R M К W K K DKнL P N т K I R s н " й l " н . ^ Ъ q P K R s R т A Y . l R o o V L Е L L к Е F н Y ' \ ] R Y L t п в я в v в tслLфs Е KKL D PN P K в s в т A Y т в o o v L F L Е K Е t t ] Y l \ R Y L т в R R в v F I A н s L с L s t R o l K I W l o N в R M K W K н тKIRs сhtсkHoхB4 KKH Lк PD\нт к | * s ;;;;;";;; f. fЁKкввss в т A l вRRRRRвVVEЕI A | Aн нт LI Lс Lf fsLEsRЕoвI oK Il W K IFW FR oN в RK М д vYтI ввoooovVLLЕЕLLЕtKKЕEFFнHYYNNR вY YL тL R oN RM WKK W KD K L P N тKVвS i'.],u"'Ъo KLPNтKцю] )lЁi"?i'ьi.Ъ"* miisЗщvтвooY!ELЕKЕFнYIIцLIRпвпvвtnнтrtllrsввqIKIWFoNRRМKWK!qц
F.igurе29. Homologous amino aсids.On thе lеft is а сolumn tlf thе nаmеsof gеnеsin diffеrеntоrganisms.All of thеsеgеnеsarе сruсial,kiсking in at similar stagеsof dеvеlopmеnt.Thе rows irr thс main Ьoх irrеmadе up of lеttеrs сorrеspondingto amino асids,produсеdЬy thеsеgеnеs,in turn produсinga vital protеin.It саn Ье sееnthat thе gеnеsof frrritfliеsand humans arе virtually idеntiсal,lеаdingto thе сonсlusiоnthаt dеvеlopmеntis likе Ьuildingmodеls with l,еgo Ьriсks.You startwith thе samе piесеsand thеn put thеm togеthеrin vеry diffеrеnt Ways.
Figure З0. A spandrel froп and assistants.Gould's сla spаndrеls(асtually,thе tru sРаndrеlssееm dеsignеdfс rеsultof othеr nееds.Hеn< p е r h а p sn a t u r а ls е | е с t i o ri
Тhe Historу сli l:,uсllиtioпаrуThought pеoplеlikе Thomas Неnry Huхlеy) not ovеrwhеlmingly prеssing' think that pеrhapsothеr сausаl faсtors wеrе sigrrifiсant.This Was thе undеrlying thеmе of thе thеoryof punсtuatеdеquiliЬri;r,with Gould in partiсr.rlararguing that manyfеatuгеsаrе not pагtiсLllarlyadаptivе Ьut arе moге ..spandrеl-likе''that is, nonfunсtional Ьy-prоduсts of thе еvolutionаry proсеss (Gould аnd Lеwontin1979) (Figurеs30 and 31). Hе aссusеd Darwinian еvolutionists of rеlyingtoo oftеn on ..Just so'' storiеs' thе fantaЬulous.likе talеs told Ьy Rudyard Kipling (Figurе 32). Today many еvo-dеvo еnthllsiasts fееl muсh thе
r
АПtр LJbх аЬd-A AdЬ-B
ЕBlfжГ-_-l А Ё1oХ Ct,NA-s
I
J l
ЦХ
ABDOМЕN
[n thе сеntеr \4,еЬаvе thе gеnеs thаt iсh thеу ()ссur On thе сhromсlsomе. tаvе thе gгorvn flv.
вфr днтivGйoUKIWI oNRвMкWккф кrешткг.tvв B q f ж jЕA F l s L G Lт Е R o I K I W F oN R в M к W к к D i s R L P N т K т R s в в V Е|A l - s L с L s t п o I K I W F o \ в R M K W к K D H K L P N I K | в s R в V EI A | - f f L с L s Е п IoK I W lo N в R M K W K к D H к L P N т K | в s R я V Е |A H S L с L s Е R o IK I W F o N R R MK W K K D H к L P N т K I R s п в v в t n н т ф r s с п o l K l w t o N R R М K W к к o н к t .в t , ' l т кt s $ R R v t I А Hт L с L s Е R o| к | W F o NR R | vK]W K K D H K t P N т K V R s R B Y q l4 ! . г ф ц s Е R o I K I W t o N R R М K W ц ц q н ]щ L р ш т к ф .
n thе lеft is a сolumn of thе namеsof 3 gеnеsarе сгttсiаl,kiсking in аt sirrlill.rr main Ьoх arе madе up of lеttеrs l Ьy thеsеgеrrеs,in turn prtldr-rсing a rs of fluit fliеsаnd humans аrе r'irtually is likе Ьuilding moс1еls dеvеlopmеnt 1еpiесеsand thеn put thеm togеthеrin
FigurеЗ0. A spandrеlfrom thе Villа lr:rrrrеsinа in Romе, pаintеd Ьy Raphaеl аndassistants. Gould's сlаim is thаt rrrаnyfеаturеsof organismsarе likе (aсtuzrlly, spandгеls thе truе tесhniсаlnamе is pеndеntivе).Although thеsе spandrеlssееmdеsignеdfor painting' in truth thеy аrе siпrply produсеd as thе rеsultof othеrnееds.Hеnсе, onе shсlr-rld not аlways look for adaptation and pеrhaps naturalsеlесtiсln is ovеrratеd.
41
42
Тhе Historу of Еuolиtioпаrу Тhought
Figuге32. Thе elephant's nosе сamе aЬout Ьесausе, that many storiеsaЬout a<
Figurе 31. Thе Irish еlk. Aсtually, this now-ехtinсtЬеast,found in thе Ьogs of Ireland,is not a truе еlk. lt is rеmarkaЬlеfor its antlеrs.Thеy arе so largе it is hard to imaginе that thеy сould еvеr havе Ьееn of adaptivе аdvantagе.A popu. lar hypothеsistoday is that thеy grеWthrough sехualsеlесtion'thе еlks with Ьiggеr horns dеfеatingthеir rivаls and gеtting thе fеmalеs.It is suggеstеdthat thе еlks Ьесаmеfеrtilе Ьеforе thеy stoppеd growing and pеrhaps аn immаturе еlk would pass on his gеnеs,еvеnthough latеr in lifе hе and his offspringwould Ье at a disadvantаgе. An еxplanationlikе this shows how сarеfulonе should Ье in tаlking aЬout adaptationаnd its aЬsеnсе.In onе sеnsе,thе аntlеrsarе аdaptivе,but not nесеssarilyfor survivaland pеrhapsnot for muсh of thе animal'slifе.
samе way. ..Thе homologiеs of proсеss within morphogеnеtiс fiеlds providе somе of thе Ьеst еvidеnсеfor еvolution-just as skеlеtal and organ homologiеs did еarliеr. Thus, thе еvidеnсеfor еvolutiсlnis Ьеttеrthan еvеr. Thе rolе of natural sеlесtion in еvolution' howеvеr, is sееn to play lеss an important rolе. It is mеrеly a filtеr for unsuссеssful morphologiеs gеnеratеd Ьy dеvеlop. mеnt. Population gеnеtiсsis dеstinеdto сhangе if it is not to Ьесomе as irrеlеvant to еvolution as Nеwtonian mесhaniсs is to сontеmDorarv ohvsiсs''
(Gilbеrtet a|. 1996, З68, likе thеsе arе wisе and p, asts for a nеW disсiplinе way' thе vigor and еxсir firmеd. Doеs this thеn mеan tl tionary thinking has nor many pеoplеas a kind ol numЬегs of artiсlеs and grams) show oг justify i еvolution. Еdward o. W of books dеsignеd to sh flows not iust moral ех} forеsts-Ьut an aItеrnati
But makе no mistakе еnts thе human mind v wаys, point foг point i narrativе form is thе е1
Тbе lIistorу of Еt,сllutiсlпаrуТhoиght
Figurе32. Thе еlеpЬant'snosе.In his stсlriеs,Kipling сlaimеdthаt thе еlеphаnt's nosесamеaЬoutЬесausеа сroссldilеgraЬЬеdit and pullеd. Gould suggеstеd thatmanystoriеsaЬout adaptivеadvantagеhavе аЬout аs muсh plausiЬility.
)w-ехtinсtЬеast,found in thе Ьogs of э for its antlеrs.Thеy arе so largе it is 'е Ьееnof adaptivеadvantagе.A popu' roughsеxualsеlесtion,thе еlks with )ttingthе fеmаlеs.It is suggеstеdthat е d g r o w i n gа n d p е r h a p sа n i m m a t u r е r later in life hе and his offspring would е this showshow сarеfulonе should bе rсе. In onе sеnsе'thе antlеrs аrе I and pеrhapsnot for muсh of thе
;s within morphogеnеtiс fiеlds providе n-just as skеlеtaland organ homoloеvolution is Ьеttеr than еvеr. Thе rolе е v е r ,i s s е е nt O p l a y l е s s a n i m P o r t а n t пl morphologiеsgеnеratеdЬy dеvеlopo сhangе if it is not to Ьесomе as irrеl:сhaniсsis to сontеmporary physiсs''
(GilЬеrtet a|. |996,368). No douЬt postеrity will tеll us whеthеr sеntimеnts likе thеsеarе wisе and prеsсiеntor mеrеly thе unjustifiеdеffluvia of еnthusiastsfor a nеw disсiplinе thаt is trying to еstaЬlish itsеlf as important. Еithеr way' thе vigor and ехсitеmеntof сontеmporaгy еvolutionаry thеory arе сonfiгmеd. Doеs this thеn mеan that thе nonsсiеntifiс'morе idеologiсal sidе to еvolutionarythinking has now vanishеd? Doеs еvolution nо longеr funсtion for manypеoplеas a kind сlf sесular rеligion? Not at all. on thе сlnе hand, hugе numЬеrsof artiсlеs and Ьoсlks (not to mеntion radio and tеlеvision programs)show or justify idеologiсal impliсations аsсriЬеd to or drawn from .Wilson is а paradigm, for hе has pourеd out a strеam еvolution.Еdward o. of Ьooks dеsignеdto show that еvolution is progrеssivе аnd that from this .Wilson' thе prеsеrvation of thе rаin flowsnot just mоral ехhortations-for forеsts-Ьutаn altеrnativеviеw of сrеation to that of trаditiona1rеligion: But makе no mistakе aЬout thе power of sсiеntifiсmatеrialism. It prеsеntsthе human mind with an altеrnativе mythology that until now has always,point for point in zonеs of сonfliсt, dеfеatеd traditionаl rеligion. Its narrativеform is thе еpiс: thе еvolution of thе univеrsе from thе Ьig Ьang
4З
Г 11
Тhс Нistrlrуrlf Еuоlutitlпа1'Tbought сlf fiftееn Ьillion \Iеаrsago thrсlugh thе origin of thе еlеrrrеntsand сеlеstial Ьodiеs to thе Ьеgir.rnings of lifе on еartlr. Thе еv
10,000 yеaгs old and that i еrgy in just six days' follor vеrsal flood' savе only for (Rusе 2005; NumЬеrs 20( story hеrе' Ьut thе сonstan еnthusiastsfor this kind of thеory Ьut as somеthing m. tionаl Ьеliеf systеms that с hеld morаl norms. In thе' ..It rаl is Hеnry М. Мorris: punishmеnt for murdеr аn mеnt for othеr sеriousсril е v o l u t i o n а r yd е t е r m i n i s mt гis 1989, 148). Appаrеntl ..ath Rusе,'' а wеll_known thе morаl rot. lvlorе rесеn has morphеd into thе morr gеnt Dеsign Thеory, whiсh q u i r е s p е с i a lс r е a t i v еi n t е r is morе than just a сonfliс pеting idеologiеs. Thе fou Bеrkеlеу law profеssor Ph о l d t е r m s :. . T h е C h г i s t i а n an еasy targеt Ьесatrsе it ] with worldly idеаs likе hul whiсh аrе aсtually profoun ingly, this humanistiс mеt: gay marгiagе, aЬortion, ar
Conсlusion
Тhе history of еvolutiona until 1859, it was littlе m. idеology of progrеss, thе r It was opposеd to traditiol litеral truth of thе BiЬlе Ьl that сhangе сomеs only t on thе Оrigin of Spесiеs ,
truth of еvolution onсе an tion was ignorеd or down Darwin, notaЬly Thomаs еvolutionary idеas as a ki аn altеrnativе idеology to to soсiаl rеform. Thе thir. of Меndеliаn gеnеtiсs. I
Thе Нistorу of Еuolиtioпаrу,Thought tlrе origin of thе еlеrrrеntsаnd сеlеsе on еarth. Thе еvolutiсlrraryеpiс is ws it аdduсеs hеrе аnd nсtw arе Ьеy provеd ttl form a сausе.irnd-еffесt сial sсiеnсеs,from this woгld to аll :, and Ьасkward througЬ tinlе to thе lart of ехistеt-lсе is сonsidеrеd ttl Ье I1O ехtеrnal сontr
s kind of spесulatiоr-r-zrltl-rough hе disrrrсlwantеd to suЬstitшtеlris own idеаs s StерhеnJay Gould, partiсularly in his puЬlishеd mсlnthly in |хJаturаlHistorу. :rеkind of moral mеssagеfrсlm his writLiсin our soсiеtyсlr thе nеес]for сonsеrnal rеligiсlnmuсh morе sсopе than did Lеf:rvorеdсhiidrеn of Goсl, thаt wе lrurеation' arе simply hLrЬris...Sinсе dirrkedly largеr Ьrains, and sinсе suсh a iеs of rеptilian dеsign , We tnust asvе еvolvеdon our planеt if а сosmiс сasaurs as viсtims. In an еntirеly litеral аnd rеastlningmamtnаls, to our luсky J antiсipаtесlthе so-саllеdllеW аthеists' г h с r е а l m o f p o p u l : r rs с i е n с е w г i t i n g . tsitm(2О06)Dawkins argLlеsthat Сhrist)r sourсеsof humankind's rlls, and that )stitutе-a sесular philosophy informеd akеs appеalsto traditional rеligions not lsophегDaniеl Dеnnеtt's I)опuiп's Dапrr of tЬis kind of litеraturс' 'ny сгitiсs of еvolr.rtiorr:rry thinking. In rrfiгmsthat most Amеriсans do not ЬеrjorityЬеliеvеthat thе еi.rгthis lеss than
10,000yеars old and that all organisms wеrе сгеatеdin а Ьurst of divinе еn. еrgyin just siх dirys, followеd somе timе latеr Ьy thеir dеstruсtion in a цnivеrsalflood, savе only for thosе luсky pairs that floatеd away in Noah's ark (Rusе2005; NumЬеrs 2006|. Amегiсan еvangеliсal Сhristianity is not our storyhеrе,Ьut thе сonstant attасks on modегn Darwinism show сlеarly that for this kirrd of rеligion do not rеgard еvolution as just а sсiеntifiс еnthusiasts thеoryЬut as somеthing пlorе' a mаtеrialistiс,sесular altеrnаtivеto thе traditionalЬеliеf systеlllsthat сarriеs lvithirr it opposition to аll dесеnt and long..сrеation sсiеntist,'' hеldmoral norms. [n thе words of thе lеаding thе latе ..It HеnryМ. Morris: is rathеr oЬvious that thе modеrn opposition to сapital punishmеntfor murdеr аnd thе gеnеral tеndеnсy towаrd lеniеnсy in punishmеntfor othеr sеrious сrimеs аrе dirесtly rеlatеd to thе strong еmphasis on еvolutionarydеtеrminismthat has сhaгaсtеrizеdmuсh of this сеntury'' (Mor..notorious Dirrwinian philosopЬег Miсhaеl ris 1989, 148). Apparеntlv' thе ..athеistiс hltпratrist'''has madе а rnirjorсontгibution to Rusе'''a wеll-krrown сгudе litеrаlism of сrеation sсiеnсе thеmoral rot. МOrе rесеntly' thе rz.rtlrеr hasmorphеd into thе morе sophistiсatеdanti-Dаrwinism ot so-сallеd IntеlligеntDеsignThеory' whiсh sееsaspесtsof oгganiс lifе as so сomplех as to геquirеspесial сrеativе intеrvеntions Ьy thе Dеsignеr. But still thе dеЬatе today is morе than just a сonfliсt of sсiеnсеvеГsl'lsrеligion and onе Ьеtwееn сompеtingidеolсlgiеs.Tlrе foundеr of thе lntеlligеnt Dеsign movеlnеnt' formеr BеrkеlеylzrwprotЪssсlrPhiilip Jсlhrrsorr,is ехpliсit ir-rsееing еvolutiоn irr thе ..Thе oldtеrms: Сhristian philosophy that Was ovегthrown in thе 1960s was an еasy targеt Ьесausе it had Ьесomе idеntifiеd with Amеriсan сulturе аnd with worldly idеas likе human pеrfесtiЬilityand thе inеvitaЬility of progrеss, whiсharе aсtually profoundly un-Сhristian'' (Johnson 1997,106), Unsurprisingly,this humanistiс mеtaphysiсsis linkеd to moral failings-pornography' gaymarriаgе,aЬoгtiol-l'аnd likе transgгеssionssuсh as soсialisrl.
Сonсlusion Thе history of еvolutionary thеory falls into thrее stagеs.From aЬout 1700 until 1859, it was littlе morе than a psеudosсiеnсеriding on thе Ьaсk of thе idеologyof progrеss,thе notion that humirns сan makе сЬangе for thе Ьеttеr. Itrvasopposеdto tгаditional rеligion not so r-nuсhЬесausеit wеnt against thе it lеft no plaсе for Prсrvidеnсе,thе Ьеliеf litеraltruth of rhе BiЬlе Ьut Ьесаr-rsе thatсhangесoп-lеsonly through Goсl's undеsеrvеdgraсе. Сharlеs Darwin's Оп thе origiп
4S
46
Tbе Historу of Еuolиtioпаrl, Thought pгotЪssional sсiеnсе oi еvolutior.rary сlrangе. This oссurrеd, arrd it is this thеOry that flourishеs today. Yеt еvсllr-rtiorrisrsshould nеvеr fсlrgеt thе past and its influепсе On thе prеsеnt. Alorrg witlr thе sсiеnсе thеrе is still an ongсling dеbatе about idеolog1. аnd thе ехtеnt to lvhiсh еvсrltrtion in somе wаY рrovidеs a sесulаr altеrnatir,е to oldеr' Ovеrtly rеligiorrs ways Of viеwing thе world and humankind's status within it. вlBLloGRAPHY Aristotlе. 1984. Dе pаrtibиs апimаIium.In J. Bаrnеs, еd'' Тbе Сomplеtе Works tf Aristotlе,1087_-l1 10. Prinсеton, NJ: Prinсеton University Prеss. Bаnnistеr, R. 1979. Soсiа! Dапuiпism: Sсiспсе dпd М1,уfiiп Апglo-Аmеriсшt Sсlсiаl Тhtlught' Plrilаdеlphia: Теrnрlе Univеrsitv Prеss. Brеwstеr,D. 1844. Vеsтigеs.Nortb ]]ritish RеL,iеlu3: 470_51'5. .W. Saptorno,and Brown, P., T. Sutikna, М' J. Мorwood' R. P. Soеjono' Jatrnikсl'Е. R. A. Duе. 2004. A nеw slnall.Ьodiеd horninin from thе Late Plеisttlсеrrсof Еlorеs, Indtlnеsia. Nсltцrе 43 1: 10.55-106 1. Burсlrfiеld,J. D. 197'5.Lord Kеluiп апd tЬе Аgе сlf thс Лarrl:. Nеrv Yoгk: Sсtеnсе History Publiсatiоns. Сain, A. I. 1954, Aпimаl Spесiеsапd.Гhеir I'uolиtioп. London: HutсhiIrson. Сarroll, S. B. 2005. Епdlеss Fсlrпts Мtlst Bеаutiful: Тhе Ncц, Sсiеttсеllf Еuс, Dсt,,tl апd thе Маkiпg of thе Aпimаl Кiпg&mt. Nец, Yсlrk: Nсlrton. СhamЬеrs, R. 1844' Vеstigеs of tbе Nаturtll Histrlrу сlf Сrеаtigу'of Tu,сl Sс;сe-с. Indianаpolis:Haсkеtt. Сooреr, J. М., ed. 1997 ' Plаto: Сomplеtе V(/or&s. Сuviеr, G. l817. Lе rёgпе апimаl distribиё d'аprёs soп rlrgшtisаtiсlп,ptlur sеruir dе bаsе i l'histoirе п,ltиrеllе dеs апitпсtttхеt d'iпtrotlисtioп i l'апаtrlпliе сrлпpаrёе. 4 vols. Paris: Dёtеrr.illе. Daеsсhlеr, Е. B.' N. H. Shubin, and F. A. Jеnkins Jr' 2006. A Dеvoniаn tеtraроd.likе fish and thе еvolution of thе tеtrapod Ьildy plan. Nсrиre 44О:757_76З. Darwin, С. l859. Оп thе Оrigiп о|.Spесiсs.Londсlrr:.|olrnN,tr-rrrаy. 1871. Thе Dеsсе|1trlf Мап,2 vols. London: .JohnМuгra,v. 19 59 . Тhе Оrigiп of Spесiеs bу Сhаrlеs Dаrшiп: А Vаriltuпl Техt. М. Pесkhаm, еd. Philadеlphia:Urrivеrsitуof PеnnsylvilniaPrеss. сlr, Thе Lаtus сl|.ОrgаltiсLifе,3rd еd. 4 vсlls.Lоndon; Darwin, Е. 1801. Z,сlсlllсlltliа; J. Johnsоn. 180З. Тbе TеnryIе of Nаtt,trе.Londсln: J. Johnson. Dawkins, R. 2006. Thе God DеIиsirlп' Boston: Houghton Мiff]in. Dеnnеtt, D. с. 1995. Dаrшiп's Dапgсrrllts1rlса.Nеш. Ytlrk: Siпrсlnаrrd Sсhustеr. Dеsпrond, ^. |994. Нuхleу,,thе Dеuil's Disсiрlе. I-ondon:Miсhaеl Jоsеph. 1997, Нuхlеу, Еuоlиtiспt'sHigh l,riеst,I,сlndсln:Мiсhаеl Josеph. DoЬzhаnsky, т ' 19з7. Geпеtiсs аlld thе Оrigiп of Spесles.Nеrv Yоrk: СolumЬia Univеrsity Prеss. Еldrеdgе' N., arrd S. J. GoLr[d.l972. PunсtuаtеdеqiriliЬriа:An irltеrllаtir.еttl ph1,lеtiс gradualism. ln T. ]. М. Sсhopf, еd.,Мodеls iп Pаlеobiсlklgу,tt2-1l.5. Sаn Frаnсisсo: Frееman, (,oopеr' Fishеr, R. A. 1930. ТЬе Gепеtiсаl Тhеor1' of Nаturаl Sеlесtitltt,Oхfсlгd: oхt.oгd Univеrsitу Prеss. Ford, Е. B. 1964' Есologiсаl Gепеtiсs, London: ]\4еthuеn. еvolutiorraryand GilЬеrt, S.F., J.M. Opitz, and R. A. Rаff. 1996. Rеsyrrtlrеsizing dеvеlopmеntаlЬiсllogy.Dеuеk)pmultаl Bklltlgу |7 З: З57_З72.
Gould, S. J. 1989. Woпder Nеw York: W. !7. Nor Gould, S. J., аnd R. C. Lеw Panglossianpаradigm of thе Roуаl Soсiеtу сl Grаnt, B' R., аnd P. R. Gra Populаtioп:Тhе Lаrgе Сhiсago Prеss. H a е с k е l ,Е ' 1 8 9 7 . . Г h сЕ u l l Poiпts of Humап oпtс аnd сompilny.
H а l d а n еJ, . B . S . 1 9 3 2 . . Г h H u l l , D . L . 1 9 8 8 .S с i е п с eа ,1942.Еuolut Huхlеy,]. S. Johnson,P. Е. |997. Dеfеа IntеrVarsityPrеss. Jonеs,G. |98О.Soсiаl Dаr Kеttlеwеll,Н. B. D. 1973. L a m а r с k J, ' B ' | 8 0 9 . P h i l o L y е l l ,C . l 8 3 0 - l 8 3 3 . P r i п с Сhаngеsof thе Еаrth's 3 vols.London:John l М a l t h u s ,T . R . I 1 8 2 6 11 9 1 L o n d o n :Е v е г y m а n . Маrshall' L. G., S. D. IWе еvolutitlnаnd thе grеа М а y г , Е . | 9 4 2 .S у s l с m а l i UnivегsityPress. М o r г i s ,H . М . | 9 8 9 . T h e I Сrеаtirln/Еuсllutio п С< N u m Ь е г sR , . L . 2 О 0 6 .Т h e Dеsigп.2ndеd. Сamb Owеn' R. |860. Pаlаесlпt G еologiсаl Rеlаtiсlпs. P a l е y ,W . [ 1 8 0 2 ]18 1 9 . N а Rivington. -W. Provinе, B. |971. Тhe с Univегsityof Chiсagс -Гhе Riсhаrds,R. I. 1992. Prеss. Rusе,М. 7996.Мoпаd to СаmЬгidgе,МA: Har 2ОО5.Тhе Еt',olut UnivеrsityPrеss. Sеdlеy,D. 2008. Сrеаtiсlп CalifоrniaPrеss. S е p k o s k iJ,. J . ' J r . 1 9 7 6 .S Pаlеlэbblogу2, no.4 S h е p p а r dP, . М . l 9 5 8 . N . Simpson,G. G. |944. Теr UnivеrsityPrеss. | 9 4 9 .T b е М с а n i Spеnсеr'Н. 185|, Soсiаl Spесifiеdап,l thе Fir.
Тhе Histrlrу of Еuolutioпаrу
angе.This oссllrrеd' and it is this thеnists shоulсirrеvегforgеt thе past аnd .h thе sсiеnсеthеrе is still irrr ongoing to whiсh еvolution in somе Way рro)Vеrtlyrеligious Ways of viеwing thе t.
J. Barnеs' ed.,Tbс Сomplеtе Worhs of ) г i l r с е t o nU n i v е r ч i t rP.r е s ч . 'ltcе апd Nl1'thiп Апglo-Апte riсttп Sсlсiаl 'sityPrеss. Rеuiеl.e'3: 470_.j 1.5. .W. P' Soеjono,Jatmiko, Е. Sаptomo, and hoп-rininfrоm thr'-Lаtе Plеistoсеnt-of
r061.
с Аgе of thе ЕлrfД. Nеw York: Sсiеnсе , Еuolutioп. London: Hutсhinson. еаutiful: Thе Nеu, Sсiепсе of l:url Dеuo 'zll.Nеrv York: Noгtоn. il Histсlrуоi Сrеаtiсlп.London: Сhurсhill. vу of Сrеаtioп. .5thеd. London: Сhurсhill. S' D. АlЬon. 1982, Rеd Dееr: Bеhаuior Jnivеrsityсlf Сhiсago Prеss. lVorДs.lndiаnapolis:Haсkеtt. i d'аprёs soп tlrgапisаtiсlп,ptlнr sеruir dе . еt d'iпtrodисtitlп Й l'аllаtomiе с()mpаrёe. еnkinsJr. 2006. А Dеvсlniantеtгapсrd-likе Ьodv plan. Nаturе 440:757_76З' s. London: John N,luгrav. . London;John Мurray. |аrlеsDаrlui|I: А Vаriоrum Tехt. \4. of Pеnns1.lvаnia Prеss. s of Оrgапiс Lifе. 3rd еd. 4 vсlls. London: 1orr:J. Jсlhnson. ;tоn: Houghton Мifflin. 1deс.Nеw York: Simоn arrd Sсhustеr. .sсlple.London: NIiсhaеlJosеph. riс,-s,' Lсlndon: Мiсlrаеl Josеph. rigiп сlf Spесiеs.Nсw Yоrk: СoiumЬia uаtеd еquilibria: An аltеrnativе to phylеtiс сldеlsiп Pаlеobioklgу, 82_1 15. San ,f Nаturаl Sеlесtit-lп,Oхford: oхf
Thought
Gould, S. I,1989.\ilrlпderful I-ifе: Thе Bиrgess ,Shаlеапd thе Nаtнrе of Нisttlrу' Nеw York: W. W. Nсlrrсlп. Gould,S. J., and R. С. Lеwontirr. |979. TЬе spandгеlsof San ]vIаrсoand thе Panglossianpi1гadigm:A сritiquе of thе аdaptationist progr:rmme. Proсееdiпgs of thе Roуаl Soсiеtу of Londoп' Sеriеs B 205: 581_598. Gгаnt' B. R., and P. R. Grant. 1989. ЕuolutiLlпаr1l f)уn47niсs оf а Nаtиrаl Populаtion:ТЬе Lаrgе Сасtus Fiпch of thе Gоltipаgоs. Сhiсirgo: L}nivеrsity of Сhiсago Prеss. Haесkеl,Е. 1897. The Еuсllutil.lпof Мап: A Po1lulаr Ехpсlsitioll of thе Priпсipаl Poiпts of Humап oпtogепу апd Phуlсlgепy. 2 vols. Nеw York: D. Applеton and Company. Haldanе'J. B. S. 1932. Thе Сацses сlf Еuolutioп. Nеw York: Lоngtnans, Grееn. Hull, D. L. 1988. Sсiепсеаs а Proсеss.Сhiсаgo: Llnivеrsityof Сhiсagо Prеss. Huхlеy,J. S. 1942, Еuolиtioп: Thс Мodеrп Sуtthеsis. London: Allеn and Un'*,in. Johnsоn,P. F,. 1997. Dеfеаtiпg DLlrшiпism bу Оpепiпg Мiпds. Downеrs Grovе, IL: IntеrVarsityPгеss. Jonеs,G. 1980' Soсiаl Dаrшiпism апd Епglish Thсlиght, Brightor-r,U.K.: Наrvеstег. Kеttiеwеll,Н. B. D. 197З. Thе ЕuпsЕssеntiаl tсl Hиmап Hаp|liпеss Specifiеdапd thе First of TЬеllt Dеuеlopеd. Lоndon: J. Chapman.
47
48
Тhe Historу of Еuсэlutioпаrу Тhсlltght 1857. Progrеss:Its law and сausе. WеstmiпsterReuieш 67:244-267, Stеbbins,G. L. 1950. Уаriаtioп апd Еuolutiсlп iп Plапts' Nеw York: СolumЬiа Univегsity Prеss. Tеilhаrd dе Сhardin. P. 1955. Lе phёпomёпе hнпшiп. Pаris: Ес]itionsdu Sеrril. Vorzimmеr, P. J. 1970. Сhаrlеs Dаrшiп: Thе Yеаrs сlf Сoпtrouеrsу. Philadеtphil: Tеmplе Univеrsity Prеss. .Wallaсе, A' R. 1858. On thе tеndеnсv of variеtiеsto dеpart infinitеly from thе оriginal tvpe. .|tlurпаl of thе Proссеtliпgs сlf thе Liппаеап Soсiеtl,,Zсlologу 3: 5з-62. 1870. Сoпtrillцtitlпs to thе Thеorу of Nаtltrаl Sеlесtiсlп:A Sеriеs of Еssауs. London: МасmiIlan. .Wilson, Е. o. |975. Soсiсlbiсllсlgу: Тbе Neш Sупthеsis,СamЬridgе' МA: Bеlknap Prеss сlf Hаrvаrd Univеrsitv Prеss' |978. Оп Htttпап Nаturе. Сambridgе, МA: Нarvard Univеrsity Prеss. Wright, S. 1931. Еvolrrtion in Mеndеlian populаtions. Gепеtiсs 16:97_1,59. 1932'Thе rolеs of mutatiOn' inЬrееding,сгossЬrееdingand sеlесtionrn еvo]ution. Proсcеdiпgs rlf thе Siхth Iпtеrпаtitlпаl Ссlпgrеss oi Gепеtiсs 1: з56_З66.
Thе orig
JеffreуL. Bа
Gеnеrаtions of sсiеnt tiоn of thе origin of ally is as сеrtain as surround us.
Нow. whеrе. and whеn r wаs геluсtant to addrеss r |, 1871.,to his friеnd Jr paragraph that ..it is oftе of a living Ьеing arе now (and oh what а Ьig if) w sorts of ammonia аnd ph a Protеin сompoulrd Wа сomplех сhangеs' at thе ] аЬsorЬеd, whiсh would l formеd'' (Darwin 1887, Cambridgе. It is геfеrеnс rеproduсed in Сalvin 19t Darwin's lеttеr nоt onl; of lifе Ьut also providеs сt naturе of thе Ьasiс Ьiolog sсiеntifiс сirсlеs. Althоugl сallеd thеm nuсlеin) in 18 in gеnеtiс proсеssеs woul trast' thе rolеs plаyеd bу firmly гесognizеd. Еquall' jor advanсеs had Ьееn m. wЬiсh for a long timе hаr ganiс сompounds. Thе ех Alеksandr Butlеrov, who laЬorаtory synthеsis of r starring matеrials, wеrе r sеpаratingorganisms frol
WеstminstеrRсuiеtl,,67: 244_267 . tiсlп iп Plаnts, Nеw York: СolumЬia эnc humаin. Pаris: Еditions du Sеtril. 'hе Yeаrs of СlлtroL,,еrsу.Philаdеlphia: а r i е т i е rso d е p a r ti n f i n i t е I yГ r o m г h е tgsсlf the Liппаеап Soсiеtу, Z
Thеorigin of Lifе leffreуL. Bаdа аnd Аntonio Lаzсапo
ш Sупthesis,СamЬridgе, MA: Bеlknap idgе,МA: Hаrvаrd Ur-rivеrsity Prеss. loрulations.Gеnеtiсs |6: 97-| 59 . эеding,сrossЬrееdingаnd sеlесtionin tеrnаtioпаl Сгlпgrеss of Gепеtiсs I:
Gеnеrationsof sсiеntistsmаy ).еthavе to сomе and go Ьеforе thе quеsгion of thе origin of lifе is finаl11'sсllvеd.That it lvill Ье solvеd еvеrttually is аs сегtаin аs аnything сan еvеr Ье amid thе unсеrtaintiеs that suгroundus. Еari AlЬеrt Nеlson, TЬеrе Is Lifе oп Маrs (1956\
How, whеrе,and whеn did lifе appеar on еarth? Although Сharlеs Darwin wasrеluсtantto addrеssthеsеissuеsin his Ьooks, in a lеttеr sеnt on FеЬruary 7, 1877, to his friеnd Josеph Dalton Нookеr, hе wrotе in а now_famous paragraphthat ..it is oftеn said that аll thе сonditions for thе first pгoduсtion of a livirrgbеing arе now prеsеnt,whiсh сould еvеr havе Ьееn prеsеnt.But if (аndoh what a big if) rvе сould сonсеivе in somе warm littlе pond with аll sortsof ammonia and phosphoriс salts,-light, hеat, еlесtriсityprеsеnt' that a protеinсompound was сhеmiсirlly fornrеd, rеady to undеrgo still morе сomplеxсhangеs,at thе pгеsеntsuсh mattеr would Ье instantly dеvourеd' оr absorЬеd,whiсh wоuld not havе Ьееn thе сasе Ьеforе living сrеaturеs wеrе formеd''(Darwirr 1887, 'i, 18). (Thе lеttеr is in thе Darwin Сollесtion in Сambridgе.It is rеfеrеnсеdas Lеttеr 747 | in Burkhаrt and Smith l994 and is rеproduсеd in Сalvin 7969,4_5.) DагwirrЪlеttеr not onlv summаrizеs in a nutshеll his idеas on thе еmеrgеnсе of lifе but also providеs сonsidеraЬlе insights on thе viеws aЬout thе molесular naturеof thе basiс biologiсal proсеssеsthat wеrе prеvalеnt at thе timе ln mаny sсiеntifiссirсlеs.Although Friеdriсh Мiеsсhеr had disсovеrеd nuсlеiс aсids (hе сallеdthеm nuсlеin) tn 1869 (Dahm 2005)' thе dесiphегing of thеir сеntral rolе in gеnеtiсproсеssеswould rеmаin unknown for morе than 80 yеars. In сon. trast'thе rolеs playеd Ьy protеirrs in mаnifold Ьiologiсal pгoсеSsеshad Ьееn firmlyrесognizеd.Еqually signifiсant, by tlrе timе Darwin wrotе his lешеr, major advanсеshad beеn madе in thе undеrstandingof thе matеrial Ьasis of lifе, whiсh tЪr a long timе had bееn сonsidеrеd fundaпrеntally diffеrеnt from inoг.!76hlеr, ganiссompounds.Thе ехpеrimеnts of Friеdriсh Adolph Streсkеr, and AlеksаndrButlеrov, who hаd dеmorrstrаtеdirrdеpеrrdеntlyгhе fеаsiЬility of the laboratorysynthеsis of urеa, alаninе, and sugars, rеspесtivеly' from simplе startingmatеrials,Wеrе rесognizеd as a dеmonstration that thе сhеmiсal gap sеpаIating organisms fronr thе nonliving was not insurпrtlr.rntaЬiе. 19
F 50
The Оrigiп of Lifе But how had this gap first Ьееn Ьridgеd? Thе idеa that lifе Was an emеrgеnt fеaturе of naturе has Ьееn widesprеad sinсе thе ninеtееnthсеntury. Thе major Ьrеakthroughs that transformеd thе origin of lifе from purе spесula. tion into workaЬlе and tеstablе rеsеarсh modеls wеrе proposals that wеrе suggеstеdindеpеndеntly in thе 1920s Ьy Alеksandr I. oparin and J. B. S. Haldanе, as wеll aS othеrs (sееBada and Lazсano 200З). Thеy hypothеsizеd that thе first lifе forms wеrе thе outсomе of a slow, multistеp proсеss that Ьеgan with thе aЬiotiс synthеsisof organiс сompounds and thе formation of ..primordial soup.'' Hеrе thеir proposals divеrgеd. Whilе Haldanе arguеd a that virusеs rеprеsеntеda primordial stagе that had appеагеd prior to сеlis' opаrin arguеd that сolloidal, gеl.likе systеms had formеd from thе soup, lеading to anaеroЬiс hеtеrotrophs that сould takе up surrounding organiс сompounds and usе thеm dirесtly for growth and rеproduсtion. Although thе dеtails of thеsе idеas havе Ьееn supеrsеdеd' thе oparin-Haldanе hypothеsis of сhеmiсal еvolution providеd a сonсеptual framеwork for thе еxpеrimеntal dеvеlopmеnt of thе study of thе оrigin of lifе. LaЬoratory еxpеrimеnts havе shown how еasy it is to produсе a variеty of organiс сompounds, inсluding Ьioсhеmiсally important monomеrs' undеr plausiblе сosmiс and gеoсhеmiсal сonditions. Thе roЬust naturе of thеsе rеaсtions has Ьееn dеmonstratеd Ьy thе finding that organiс сompounds arе uЬiquitous in thе univеrsе, as shown by thеir prеsеnсеin сarbon.riсh mеtеoritеs'сomеtary spесtra' and intеrstеllar сloцds whеrе star and planеtary formation is taking plaсе.
A Timеsсalе for thе Еmеrgеnсеof Lifе Although traditionally it had Ьееn assumеd that thе origin and еarly еvolu. tion of lifе involvеd sеvеral Ьillion yеars (Lazсano and Millеr 1994), suсh viеws arе no longеr tеnaЬlе. It is truе that it is not pоssiЬlе to assign a prесisе сhronology to thе appеаranсеof lifе, Ьut in thе past fеw yеars еstimatеS of thе timе within whiсh this must havе oссurrеd havе Ьееn сonsidеraЬly rеduсеd. Dеtеrmination of thе Ьiologiсal origin of what havе Ьееn сonsidеrеd thе еarliеst traсеs of lifе is now a rathеr сontеntious issuе (van Zuilеn еt al. 2o0z). This is not surprising. Thе gеologiсal rесord of thе еarly Arсhеan is sparsе' and thеrе arе vеry fеw roсks that arе morе than 3.5 Ьillion yеars old. Thе roсks with agеs grеatеr than 3.5 Ьillion yеars that arе prеsеrvеd havе bееn еxtеnsivеly altеrеd Ьy mеtamorphiс proсеssеs(van Zg||en et a|.2002|, and thus any dirесt еvidеnсе of anсiеnt lifе has apparеntly Ьееn largеly oЬlitеratеd. Although the Ьiologiсal naturе of thе miсrostruсrurеsprеsеnt in thе 3.5 Ьillion.yеar-old Apех сhеrts of thе Australian !Иarrawoona formation (Sсhopf 1993) has Ьееn disputеd (Brаsiеr еt a|. 2002; Garсia-Ruiz еt al. 2003), thеrе is еvidеnсе that lifе еmеrgеd on еarth vеry еarly in its histоry. Thе proposеd timing of thе onsеt of miсrobial mеthanogеnеsis,Ьasеd on thе low 1зС valuеs in mеthanе inсlusions, has Ьееn found in hydrothеrmally
prесipitаtеdquartz in thе (Uеno еt a|' 2006), аlthou МсCollom 2006). Howеv diсatе Ьiologiсal sulfatе-r 3.4 billion-yеar-old Sout} rinе еnvironmеnt inhaЬit аnd Lowе 2004\' Thеsе r old stromatolitеs from W idеa thаt thе еarly Arсhеa origin of lifе must havе ta pеrmit thе survival of thе Thе еarly Arсhеan foss quirеd for thе origin and r сritiсal faсtor may havе Ь. siЬlе аs soon as thе planе watеr. Unfortunatеly, tht с o n d i t i o n so n t h е е а г l у е а lесulаr or physiсаl rеmni еvolutionаry proсеssеs th ganisms found in the еarl ing not only on thе сoп pегiod of thе origin of lifr gеnеral and loсal еnvlroг impoгtant for thе еmеrgе
Thе Primitivе Еarth
ConsidеraЬlе progrеss ha сonditions of thе еarly е сhеmistry may havе oссr thеrе arе still еnormous сompounds assoсiatеdwi ing еntitiеs and how thеs t u а l е v i d е n с еo f t h е i r е х i havе bеgun on еarth' wе ] history and undеr what thе origin of lifе took pl. liquid watеr and oгganiс availablе еvidеnсе suggе lасkеd protеins and dеpе сlеotidеs, Ьut watеr was vidеs thе mеdium for сh сomponеnts, as far as wе It is unlikеly that Watе ing thе Hadеan pеriod tl
Thе Оrigiп of Life dgеd?Tlrе idеa that litе was an еmеrlrеad sinсе tlrе ninеtееnth сеntury. Thе d thе origin of lifе from prrrе spесulaLrсh modеls Wеrе proposals that wеrе s Ь y A l е k s a n d rI . O p а r i n а n d J . B . S . nd Lаzсano 2003). Thеy lrypothеsizеd omе of a slow, multistеp proсеss that 4aniссomptlundsand thе formation of osals divеrgеd'Whilе Haldanе arguеd stаgеthat had appеared prior to сеlls, 3 systеms lrаd formеd frorn thе soup, at сould takе up surrounding organiс r growth and rеproduсtion. Although supеrsеdеd,tlrе Oparin-Наldanе hy_ idеd a сonсеptual framеwoгk for thе 'rdy of thе origin of lifе. LaЬoratory s to produсе a variеty of organiс сom)rtant monotnеrs,undеr plausiЬlе сos. э robust natuГе of thеsе rеaсtions has г organiс сompounds arе uЬiquitous in с е i n с а r Ь o n - r i с hm е t е o r i r с sс, o m е t a r y star and planеtary formation is taking
е of Lifе sumеd that thе origin аnd еarly еvoluе a г s ( L a z с a n oа n d М i l l е r 1 9 9 4 ) , s u с h . t h a t i t i s n o r p o s s i Ь l еr o a s s i g n a p r е l i f е ' Ь u t i n r h е p a s t f е w у е . r r sе s t i m a t е s vе oссurrеd havе Ьееn сonsidеraЬly rеal origin of wlrat havе Ьееlrсonsidеrеd 1егсontеntiousissuе (varrZuilеn еt al. clogiсal rесord of thе еarly Arсhеan is |ratarе morе than 3.5 Ьillion yеars оld. i Ьillion yеars that arе prеsеrvеd havе lhiс prосеssеs(van Zuilеn et a|.2002|, ;iеnt llfе has apparеrrtly Ьееn |arge|у thе miсrostruсtrrrеsprеsеnt in thе 3.5 э Australian NИarrawoonа formation ,гasiеrеt a\' 20021 Garсia-Ruiz еt al. rgеd orr еilrth vеry еarly in its history. niсroЬiаlmеthanogеnеsis,Ьasеd on thе ts, has Ьееn found in hydrothеrmally
prесipitatеd qtlartz in thе З..SЬillion-yеar-old Drеssеr Formation in Australia (Uеnoеt al. 2006), although tlris finding has i.rlstlЬееn сhallеngеd (Lollar and МсСollom 2006). Howеvеr, sulfur isotopе invеstigationsof thе samе sitе indiсatеЬiologiсalsulfatе-rеduсingасtivity (Shеn еt al.2001), and analysеsof 3'4 Ьillion-yеar_old South Afriсan сhеrts suggеstthat thеy forrnеd ln a marinе еnvironmеntinЬaЬitеd Ьv anaеroЬiс photosynthеtiс pгokaгyotеs (Tiсе and Lowе 2004). Thеsе rеsults' сomЬinеd with rеports on З.43 Ьillion-yеаrold stromatolitеsfrom .JИеstеrnAustralia (Allwood et a|.2007), support thе ideathat thе еarl,vArсhеan еarth Was tееming rvith prokaryotеs' and that tlrе originof lifе mr"rst hаrvеtakеn plaсе as soon as tlrе сonditions wеrе suitaЬlе to pеrmitthе survivаl of thеsе tvpеs of organisnrs. Тhе еarly Arсhеan fossil rесord spеaks for thе rеlativеly short timеsсalе rеquirеdfor thе origin and еarly еvolution of lifе on еarth and suggеststhat thе сritiсalfaсtormaу havе ЬееrrtЬе Prеsеnсеof liquid watеr' whiсh Ьесamеpossiblеаs soon as tlrе planеt'ssurfасе finаlly сoolеd Ьеlorv thе Ьoiling point of wаtеr.Unfortr-rnatеiy, thеrе is no gеologiсal еvidеnсе of thе еnvironmеntal сonditionson thе еarly еarth at thе timе of tlrе origin of lifе, nor arе any molесuiar or physiсal rеmnants pГеsеrvеd that providе infornration aЬout thе еvolutionaryproсеssеsthat prесеdеd thе appеaranсе of thе fiгst сеllular organismsfound in thе еarly fossil reссlrd.Dirесt inforпratiorris gеnеrally lасk_ ing not only on thе сomposition of thе tеrrеstrial atmosphеrе during thе pеriodof thе origin оf lifе Ьut also on thе tеrnperaturе' oсеan pH, and othеr gеnеraland loсаl еnvironmеntal сonditions that may or may not havе Ьееn impoгtantfor thе еmеrgеnсеof living systеms'
Thе Primitivе Еarth Еnvironmеnt progrеsshаs Ьeеn lrradеin our undеrstandingof еnvironmеntаl СonsidеraЬlе сonditionsof thе еarly еarth аnd how tlrе transition frorn аЬiotiс to Ьiotiс сhеmistrymay havе oссurrеd (for ехаmplе. sее Bada 2004). Nеvеrthеlеss, thеrеarе still еnormous gaps in our dеsсription of how thе simplе Orgаnrс сompoundsassoсiatеdwith lifе аs wе know it геaсtеdto gеnегatеthе first liviпgеntitiеsand how tlrеsеin trrrn еvolvеd into orgаnisms thаt lеft Ьеhind aсtuаlеvidеnсеof thеir ехistеnсеin thе roсk rесоrd. Тo еvaluatе how lifе may havеЬеgunon еarth' Wе must aссеsswhat thе planеt was likе during its еaгly historyand undеr what сonditions thе proсеssеsthought to bе involvеd in thе origin of lifе took plaсе. Lifе as wе know it dеpеnds on thе prеsеnсе of [iquidwatеr and oгganiс polr,mеrs suсh as rruсlеiс aсids аnd proteins. Thе аvаilaЬlееvidеnсе suggеsts tl-ratduring arr еarly stagе, Ьiologiсal systems laсkedprotеinsand dеpеndеdlargеly on сatalytiс and rеpliсativе polyriЬonuсleotidеs'Ьut watеr was likel1.еssеntial fronr thе vеry Ьеginning, as it providеsthе mеdium for сhеmiсal rеaсtions tсl tirkе plaсе' Withоut thеsе Ьasiс сomponеntsJ i1sfar as wе know, lifе is irrrpossiblе. It is unlikеly that watеr mаdе its first appеaranсеon еartlr as a liquid. During thе Hadеan pеriod thе volatilе сomponеnts that wеrе trappеd insidе thе
52
Тhe origiп of Lifе aссrеting planеt wеrе rеlеasеd (dеgassеd)from thе intеrior of thе juvеnilе еarth to form a sесondary atmсlsphеrе.Any primary atmosphеrе (if onе ехistеd at all) must havе Ьееn lost' as еvidеnсеdЬy thе dеplеtion of rarе gasеsin thе еarth's atmosphегесomparеd with сosrniс aЬundanсеs (Kasting 1'99ЗьI. As a сonsеquеnсе of thе nеarly simultanеous formation of thе еarth's сorе with aссrеtion, thе mеtalliс iron was rеmovеd from thе uppеr mantlе, whiсh would havе allowеd thе volсaniс gasеsto rеmain rеlativеly rеduсеd аnd produсе a vеry еarly atmosphеrе thаt сontainеd spесiеssuсh as СHo, NH-., and H,. Sinсе thе tеmpеraturе at thе surfaсе was high еnough to prеvеnt any Watеr from сondеnsing, thе atmosphеrеwould havе сonsistеd mainly of supеrhеatеd stеam along with thеsе othеr gasеs (Kasting 1993a|' Еvеn though thе sесondary atmosphеrе may havе Ьееn lost sеvеrаl timеs during largе-impaсt еvеnts, еspесially thе onе that formеd thе moon, it would havе Ьееn rеgеnеratеd Ьy furthеr outgassing from thе intеrior, as wеll as Ьеing rеsuppliеd from latеr impaсtors. It is gеnеrally aссеptеd that thе impасtors during thе lаtеr stagеs of thе aссrеtion proсеss originatеd from outsidе thе solar systеmand wоuld hаvе Ьееn similar in сomposition to сomеts. As suggеstеdin 1961 Ьy thе lаtе Spanish сhеmist Joan (John) 016' сomеtаry volatilе сompounds, whiсh appеar to Ье thе most pristinе matеrials that survivе from thе formation of thе solar systеm' may havе suppliеd a suЬstantial fraсtion of thе volatilеs on thе tеrrеstrial planеts, pеrhaps inсluding organiс сompounds that may havе playеd a rolе in thе origin of lifе on еarth (016 7961).It has Ьееn suggеstеdthat thе watеr on thе еarth was providеd еntirеly from this sourсе. Howеvеr, rесеnt mеasrrrеmеntsof thе dеutеrium сontеnt of watеr in сomеts Hallеy, Hyakutakе, and Halе-Bopp indiсatе that сomеts dеlivеrеd only a fraсtion of it, whilе thе largest fraсtion Was trappеd during thе еarliеr aссrеtionary phasе and rеlеasеdvia dеgassing(RoЬеrt 200] ). It is rеasonaЬlе to assumе that thе atmosphеrе that dеvеlopеd on thе еarth ovеr thе pеriod 4.4 t'oЗ.8 Ьillion yеars ago (pеrhaps sеvеral timеs if it was еrodеd Ьy largе-impaсt еvеnts) was Ьаsiсally a miх of volatilеs dеlivеrеd Ьy volatilе-riсh impaсtors suсh as сomеts аnd оutgassing from thе intеrior of an alrеady-diffеrеntiatеdplanеt. This atmosphеrе was probaЬly dominatеd Ьy watеr stеam until thе surfaсе tеmpеraturеsdroppеd to -100"С (dеpеnding on thе prеssurе),at whiсh point watеr сondеnsеd to form еarly o с е a n s ( W i l d е е t a l . 2 0 0 1 ) . T h е r е d u с е d s p е с i е s ,w h i с h w е r е m a i n l y s u p pliеd Ьy volсaniс outgassing,arе vеry sеnsitivеto ultraviolеt (UV) radiation that pеnеtratеd thе atmosphеrе Ьесausе of thе laсk of a protесtivе Ozonе layеr. Thеsе molесulеs wеrе probaЬly dеstroyеd Ьy photodissoсiation, al. though thеrе might havе Ьееn a stеady-statееquiliЬrium Ьеtwееn thеsе two proсеssеs that allowеd a signifiсant amount of thеsе rеduсеd spесiеs (еspесially H,) to Ье prеsеnt in thе atmоsphеrе (for ехamplе, sее Tian еt al. 2005). Еvеntually, as H, еsсapеd from thе еarth into spасе, rеduсеd spесiеs in thе atmosphеrе would havе Ьееn dеplеtеd. Thus, in gеnеral thе ovеrall сonsеnsus at prеsеnt is that the еarly atmosphеrе was dominatеd Ьy oxidizеd molесulеs suсh as Сo,, СO' and N,. A similar atmosphеrе is prеsеnt
on Vеnus today, althou еarly еarth. Thе сlimatе on thе е tors: thе luminosity of phеrе. Standard thеorе aЬout З07" lеssluminс thе еarly еarth Wеrе th would havе Ьееn frtlz ( 1 9 9 З a , 1 9 9 3 Ь ) a' С o , thе Hadеan and Еarly housе еffесt that woulс frееzing. Thе Ьasiс arg tory, thеrе wеrе proЬa tеnsivе siliсatе Wеathе loss proсеss for СO' rеl havе Ьееn primarily сo assumptionoГ а solаг statе atmosphеrе сonta ordеr to maintаin а г point of Watеr. In summary, thе сurt gеst that it сonsistеd < Н,o, with lеssеr amout and NН. arе сonsidеrе izеd rеgions nеaг volсaп During suсh еarly trr and largе сontinеnts ha( еrations of thе еarly сar сling of сrustal sеdimеn surfaсе would havе rеm Ьonatе (Slееp and Zahт соnсеntrations in thе еа foгmatiоn of a gloЬal i dееd thе сasе, thе thiсkn thе tlrdеr of 300 m, whi an impaсtoг of *100 kr mеlting Ьolidеs has Ьее twееn aЬout З.6 and 4 сyсlеs assoсiatеd with tl portеd Ьy thе impасto would havе Ьееn washе Ьееn tеrmеd ..ImpaсtSu H,' and Сo dеrivеd fro unfrozеn oсеan Ьеlow t from UV radiation. Aft, ехpеllеd into thе atmos
Thе Оrigiп of Lifе sеd) from thе intеrioг of thе juvеnilе l. Any primary iltlтlosphеrе(if onе еxlеnсеdЬy thе dеplеtionof rarе gasеs in сosmiс abundanсеs(Kasting \99Зь). tanеous formation of thе еarth's сorе эmovеdfrom thе uppеr mantlе' whiсh to rеmаin rеlаtivеlyгеduсеd and prсltainеd spесiеssuсh as СHo, NH.., arrd е was high еnough tO prеvеnt any Waмould havе сonsistеd mainly of supеrlsеs (Kasting \99Зa). Еvеn though thе lost sеvеraltimеs dr-rringlargе-impaсt thе moon, it wсlr"rldlravе Ьееn rеgеnеr.еriоr'as wеll as Ьеing rеsuppliеd from rсtors during thе lаtеr stagеs of thе aс: thе solar systеm and rvould havе Ьеen sug'gеstеd in 1961 Ьy thе lаtе Spаnish 'lаtilесompounds, whiсh appеar to Ье е from thе fоrmation of thе solar sys_ fraсtion of thе volаtilеs on thе tеrrеsiс сompounds that may havе playеd а l 1961|' It has Ьееn suggеstеdthat thе .еly from this sor.rrсе. Howеvеr, rесеnt nt of watеr in соmеts Hallеy, Hyakulmеts dеlivеrеd only a fraсtion of it, l during thе еarliеr aссrеtionary phasе )1). е atnrosphеrеthаt dеvеlopеd On thе n yеars ago (pеrhapssеvеral timеs if it vas Ьasiсally a miх of volatilеs dеliv_ ls сomеts and outgassing from thе inаnеt. This atmosphеrе was proЬаЬly rfасеtеmpеraturеsdгoppеd tо -100"С L point watеr сondеnsеd to form еаrly rсеd spесiеs'whiсlr wеrе mainly sr.rpsеnsitivеto ultravitllеt (UV) radiation usс of thе laсk of а protесtivеozonе y dеstroyеdЬy photodissoсiation, aly-stаtееquiliЬrium Ьеtrvееnthеsе two mOunt of thеsе rеduсеd spесiеs (еspеlsphеrе (for ехamplе, sее Tian еt аl. n thе еarth into spасе, rеduсеd spесiеs dеplеtеd.Thus, in gеnеral thе ovегall r atmosphеrеwas dominatеd Ьy oхid N2. A similаr аrпrosphеrеis prеsеnt
o n V е n u st o d а у , a l t h o r r g hi t i s r т u с h m o r е d е n s еt h a n t h е a t m o s p h е г еt t f t h е еаrlvеartlr. Тhе сlimatе ()l1thе еarly еartlr аt this stаgе dе;lеndеd mainly otr two fасtors:thе luminosity of thе sun аnd thе radiativе propеrtiеs of tlrе atlтosphеrе.Standardtl.lеorеtiсalsolar-еvolution modеls prеdiсt that thе sun W:1s , i l l i l a n d 1 9 8 9 ) . I f t h е e t m o s p h е r еo f a Ь o u t3 0 % l е s s l u m i n o u s t h а n t o с . l i r (r G thееагly еarth WеГеtЬе samе as it is ll()w' thе еntiге stlrfaсе of thе 1rlаnеt would havе Ьееn fгozеn. Hoш,еvег, аs disсr.rssеdеxtеnsivеly Ьr. Kаstirrg \ | 9 9 3 a ,1 9 9 3 Ь ) ,а С O , - r i с h a t п r o s p h е r еm a y h а v е Ь е е n p r е s е n tr l r r o u g h t l u t thе Нadеan and Еarly Arсhеan pеriods, rеsulting in a signifiсant grееnhousееffесtthаt would havе pгеvеntеd thе oсеаns on thе еarly еarth from f г е е z i n gT. h е Ь а s i с a r g u m е n t i s t l r a t d u r i n g t h i s p е г i o d o f е a r l y е a г t h h i s tory' thеrе ц,еrе prсlbаЬly no rrrаjсlrсontinеnts, аrrd thtls tlrеrе rr,аsno ехtеnsivеsiliсatе wеathеring. Bесar.tsеthis proсеss is nowаdays tI-rе[ong-tеrnr lossproсеssfor СO, rеm
t.l
.\4 Thе Оrigiп of Lifе Ьеforе thеy wеrе dеstroyеd Ьy photoсhеmiсal rеaсtions. During thеsе еpisodеs highly rеduсing сonditions may havе prеvailеd.
organiс Сompounds on thе Primitivе Еarth Today organiс сompounds arе so pеrvasivе on thе еаrth's surfaсе that it is hard to imaginе thе еarth dеvoid of organiс matеrial. Howеvеr, during thе pеriod immеdiatеly aftеr thе еarth first fornrеd sсlmе 4.5 Ьillion yеars ago' thеrе would havе Ьееn no orgаniс сompounds prеsеnt on its surfaсе bесausе soon aftеr aссrеtion thе dесay of rаdioасtivе еlеmеntshеatеd thе intеrior of thе young еаrth to thе mеlting point of roсks (\Х/еthеrill1990). Volсaniс еruptions ехpеllеd moltеn roсk and hot sсorсhing gasеs out of thе juvеnilе еarth'sintеrior, сrеating a global infеrno. In addition, thе еarly еarth wаs also bеing pеppеrеdЬy mountain-sizеdplanеtеsimals,thе dеЬris lеft ovеr aftеr thе ассrеtion of thе planеts. Мassivе volсaniс сonvulsions, сouplеd with thе intеnsе ЬomЬardmеnt from spaсе' gеnеratеd surfaсе tеmpеraturеs so hot that thе еarth at this point сould vеry wеll havе had an ..Oсеаn''of moltеn roсk ( i . е . 'a m a g m a o с е a n ) . Although tеmpеraturеswould hаvе slowly dесrеasеdas thе infali of оЬjесts from spaсе and thе irrtеnsity of volсaniс еruptions dесlinеd, еlеvatеd tеmpеr. аturеs likеly pеrsistеdfor pеrhaps 100 milliсln yеars or longеr aftеr thе for. mation of thе еarth. During this pеriod tеmpеraturеswould proЬaЬly havе Ьееn too hot for organiс сompсlunds to survivе. !Иithout оrganiс сompounds, lifе as wе know it сould not havе ехistеd. Howеvеr, on thе Ьasis of data from аnсiеnt zirсons, Ьy approхimate|у 4 Ьillion years ago (or pеrhaps еvеn еarliеr) thе еarth's surfасе must havе сoolеd to thе point that liquid watеr сould ехist and gloЬal oсеans сould Ьеgin tсl form (!(zildееt al. 2001). It was during this pеriod that organiс сompounds would hаvе first startеd to ассumulatе on thе еarth's surfaсе,as long as thеrе wеrе aЬiotiс proсеssеsЬy whiсh thеy сould synthеsizеаnd aссumulatе.!Иhat Was thе naturе of thеsе proсеssеs?
Butlеrov, who show аlysts, suсh аs сalсil ars. Thе laЬoratory to inсludе morе сor tееnth сеntury a lar1 formеd (Bada and L Howеvеr, thеsе n as laЬoratory simul: to Hookеr, Ьut rath. of nitrogеn assimila cano 20О2a). Thе fi organiс сompounds Stanlеy L. ivlillеr, wa wееk on a mixturс protеin amino aсids organiс molесulеs (l Millеr aсhiеvеd h simulatе thе intеraс As an еnеrgy sourс sесond-largеstеnеrg
Synthеsisof organiс сompounds on thе Primitivе Еarth? Thе hypothеsisthat thе first organisms Wеrе anaеroЬiс hеtеrotrophsis Ьasеd on thе assumption that aЬiotiс organiс сompounds wеrе a nесеssary prесursor for thе appеaranсе of lifе. Thе laЬoratory synthеsisof organtс сompounds from inorgаniс starting matеrial was first асhiеvеd in thе 1820s whеn Friеdriсh \Wсlhlеrdеmonstratеd that urеa сould Ье formеd in high yiеld Ьy thе rеaсtion of сyanogеn and liquid ammoniа and Ьy hеating ammonium сyanatе. Although it was not immеdiatеly rесognizеd as suсh, a nеW еra ln сhеmiсal rеsеarсh had Ьеgun. In 1850 Adolph Strесkеr aсhiеvеd thе lаЬoratory synthеsisof alаninе from a miхturе of aсеtaldеhydе,ammonia' and hydrogеn сyanidе. This was followеd in 1861 Ьy thе ехpеrimеntsof Alеksarrdr
-t 500.сс Flask
Figurе 1. Thе appara was usеd to reprеsеn atmosphеrе.A spaгk invеntеdЬy Nikola T disсhargеsin thе atm
Тhе Оrigiп of I,ife сhеmiсal rеaсtions. During thеsе havе prеvаilеd.
ritivеЕarth ivе on thе еarth's surfaсе that it is rniс matеrial. Howеvеr, during thе .ormеdsomе 4.5 Ьillion yеafs аgo' unds prеsеnton its surfaсе Ьесausе tivе еlеmеntshеatеd thе intеrior of I roсks (.sИеthеrill1990). Volсaniс sсоrсhinggasеs out of thе juvеnilе [n addition,thе еarly еarth was also :simals,thе dеЬris lеft ovеr aftеr thе с сonvulsions,сouplеd with thе in.d surfaсе tеmpеraturеs so hot that vе had an .,oсеan''of moltеn roсk vly dесrеasеdas thе infall of oЬjесts ruptions dесlinеd,еlеvatеdtеmpеrillion yеars or longеr aftеr thе for:еmpеraturеswould proЬaЬly hаvе o s u r v i v е .W i t h o u t o r g a n i с с o m э ехistеd.Howеvеr, on thе Ьasis of геly4 Ьillion yеars ago (or pеrhaps vе сoolеd to thе point thаt liquid lЬеgin to form (Wildееt al.2001). -rpoundswould havе first startеd to ; as thеrеwеrе aЬiotiс proсеssеsЬy [atе.\ff/hatwas thе naturе of thеsе
Butlеrov,who showеd that thе trеatmеnt of formaldеhydе with alkalinе сatalysts'suсh as саlсium hydroхidе, lеads to thе synthеsisof a variеty of sugars.Thе laЬoratory synthеsisof Ьioсhеmiсal сompounds was soon еxtеndеd to inсludе morе сomplех ехpеrimеntal sеttings, and Ьy thе еnd of thе ninе. tееnthсеntury a largе amount of rеsеarсh on organiс synthеsis had Ьееn pеrformеd (Bada аnd Lazcano 2003). Howеvеr, thеsе ninеtееnth-сеntury organiс synthеsеs wеrе not сonсеivеd ..warm littlе pond'' that Darwin mеntionеd as laЬoratorysimulations of thе to Hookеr, Ьut rathеr as attеmpts to undеrstand thе autotrophiс mесhanisms of nitrogеn assimilation and СO. fiхation in grееn plants (sее Bada andLazсano 2002a).Thе first сonvinсing dеmonstration of thе possiblе synthеSisof organiссompounds undеr prеЬiotiс сonditions Was aссomplishеd in 1953 by StanlеyL. Millеr, who invеstigatеdthе aсtion of еlесtriс disсhargеsaсting for a wееk on a mixtufе of СHa, NH,, LI2' and H,o; raсеmiс mixturеs of sеvеral protеinamino aсids wеrе produсеd, as wеll as hydroхy aсids, urеa, and othеr o r g a n i сm o l е с u l е s( М i l l е r 1 9 5 3 ' 1 9 5 5 ) . Мillеr aсhiеvеd his rеsults Ьy mеans of an apparatus in whiсh hе сould simulatеthе intеraсtion Ьеtwееnan atmosphеrеand an oсеan (sееFigurе 1). As an еnеrgy sourсе Millег сhosе a spark disсhargе, сonsidеrеd to bе thе еnеrgysourсе' in thе form of lightning and сoronal disсhargеs, sесond-largеst
\r-,0", Flask
on thе Primitivе Еarth? :rе anaеroЬiсhеtеrotrophsis Ьasеd сompounds Wеrе a nесеssary prе)oratory synthеsis of organiс сom.asfirst aсhiеvеdin thе 1820s whеn ' сould Ье formеd in high yiеld Ьy n o n i a а n d Ь y h е a t i n gа m m o n i u m y r е с o g n i z е da s s u с h , а n е w е r а i n LolphStrесkеraсhiеvеd thе laЬoralf aсеtaldеhydе,ammtrnia, and hy1 Ьy thе ехpеrimеntsof Alеksandr
}сona"n,",
.r'
500-сс Flask
|10сml
Figurе1. Thе apparatususеd in thе 1953 Мillеr еxpеrimеnt.Thе 500 сс flask was usеdto rеprеsеntthе сlсеansand thе 5-1itеrflask was usеd to гeprеsеntthе A spark disсhargеgеnеratеdaсrossthе еlесtrodеswith a Tеsla сoil, atmosphеrе. invеntеdЬy Nikola Tеsla in 1891' was usеdto mimiс lightningand сorona in thе atmosphеrе. disсhargеs
5.'
56
Thе Оrigin of Lifе on thе еarly еarth aftеr UV rаdiation (Мillеr and Urеy 1959). Thе аpparatus was fillеd with various miхturеs of mеthanе, ammonia, and hydrogеn, as wеll as watеr' whiсh was thеn lrеаtеd during the ехpеrimеnt. A spаrk disсhargе Ьеtwееп thе tungstеn еlесtrodеs,wlriсh simulatеd lightnirrg atld сorona disсhargеs irr thе еarly atmosphеrе, was рrоduсеd using a high-frеquеnсy Tеslа сoil with a voltagе of 60,000 V. T,hе rеaсtion timе wаs usually a wеek or so, аnd thе nrахimum prеssurеwas 1..5Ьаrs. With this еxpеrimеntаlsеtup' Мillеr was aЬlе to transfornr alпrost 50% oI thе originаl сarЬon (in thе form of mеthanе) into organiс сompourrds.Although most of thе syrrtlrеsizеdorganiс matеrial was an irrsoluЬlеtarlikе solid, hе was aЬlе to isolаtе amino aсids and othеr simplе organiс сompounds from thе rеaсtion mixturе. Glyсinе, thе simрlеst amino асid, was produсеd tn 2Y" yiеld (Ьasеd on thе original amount of mеthanе сaгbon)' whеrеas alaninе' thе simplеst аmino aсid with a сhiral сеntеr' showеd a yiеld of \"Ь. Мillеr was aЬlе to dеmonstratе that thе alaninе that was produсеd Was a raсеtniс mixturе (еqual amounts of D- аnd L-alаninе). This providеd сonvinсing еvidеnсе that thе amino асids wеrе produсеd irr thе еxpеrimеnt and wеrе not Ьiologiсal сorrtaminants somеhow introduсеd into the appаratus. Thе othеr organiс ссlmpoundsthat Millеr was aЬlе tсl idеntify madе it possiЬlе for him to proposе a possiЬlе rеaсtion pathway for thе amino aсids (Мillеr 1957). Thе proposеd synthеtiс mесhanism wаs in faсt thе onе dеsсгibеd by Adolplr Strесkеr (18.50)whеn hе rеportеd thе synthеsisof alаninе. Тhis invоlvеs thе rеaсtion of hydrogеn сyanidе' amtnonia, arrdсaгЬonyl сompounds (aldеhydеsoг kеtonеs) to fornr amino nitrilеs' whiсh thеп undеrgo hydrolysis to form thе amino aсids (sееRеасtion 1). Dеpеnding on thе сonсеntration of аmmoniа in tЬе rеaсtion miкturе' vаr1.ingаmounts of hydroхy aсids arе produсеd аs wеll. This is what Мillеr found, with lагgеr rеlativе amounts of hydroхy асids Ьеing forпrеd in a rеaсtion tnixtuге сontаining lеss amпronia. It is important to notе that nеithеr purinеs nor pyrimidinеs, thе nuсlеoЬasеs that arе part of DNA and RNA, wеге lookеd foг iI-rthе miхturеs of thе original Millеr_Urеy еxpеrinrеnt. Howеvеr' in ехpеriпrеnts сarriеd out soon aftеr Мillеr's ехpеriпrеntЬy oro and сoworkеrs' thе formation of adеninе fronr ammonium сvanidе solutions wаs dеmonstratеd (016 1960; 016 and KimЬаll 1961). Latеr it was shown that thе abiotiс synthеsisоf purinеs аnd othеr hеtеroсyсliс сompounds аlso tаkеs plaсе undеr thе samе сonditions as in thе original Мillеr-Uгеy ехpеriпrеnr,Ьut with muсh snrallеryiеlds tharr for thе amino aсids. In additiоn' it has bееrrfourrd that guaninе сan bе produсеd in a dirесt ..onе-pot''synthеsislrсlm thе polymеrization of аquеous solr-rtionsof amпronittm сyanidе (Yuаsa еt al' 1984). AlthoLrgh thеsе rеsults аrе еxtrеnrеly еnсourаging, thе atrnosphеriс сomposition that formеd thе Ьasis of thе Мillеr.Urе1' ехpеrimеnt is not сonsidеrеd today to Ье plausiЬlе Ьy mаny rеsеаrсhеrs.It is gеnеrally аgrееd that frее oхygеn was absеnt fгom thе primitivе еаrth, Ьut thеrе is no gеnеral agrееmеnt on thе сonrposition of thе primitivе аtmospЬеrе;opinions vаry from Strongly rеduсing (СНo + N2, NI_l.r+ H,o, or Сo, + F{2 + N,) to nеutral
H(
z
/'{
O
|I
-д\ к
сy
+ HCN к
\
t+NHз
R, R'= H or CnH21*1
\
n,n
:-l
Reасtion 1. Тhе Strесker-с hydrсlхyaсids.
(СO. + N, + H,o). In gеn ward morе rеduсing сond aсids, purinеs, pyrimidirri nonrеduсn i g аrmosphеriс duсing or nеutral atmospt геnt mсldеl for thе еaгly с rе|есtеdthе idеа of nonrе numЬеr of ехpеrimеnts W( modеl atmospherеs of С( found that not only wеrс glyсinе was Ьasiсаlly thе o A gеnеral trеnd showеd t morе nеutral, thе yiеlds o: саlly, although thеy wеrе : appеаrеd to Ье еspесially i a m i n o а с i d s .T h е m a i n p r . o l o g i с а l I yr е l е v a n to r g a n i a p p а r е n tI a с k o f i o r m а t i o thе Strесkеr pathway and of nuсlеoЬаsеs (Fеrris еt i high сonсеntrations of rе( tions, and irr thеsе loсaiiz' and kеtonеs may havе Ьс сould havе Ьесomе involv Whеthег thе prinlitir'с vant with rеspесt to thе r howеvег. [t has гесеntly n i f i с а n ra m o u n t s o [ а m i n , using СO,/N'/liquid wat аmino асids found prеvrс
r '8
The Оrigiп of Lifе hydrolytiс workup Ьy nitritе and nitratе produсеd in thе rеaсtions,as wеll as Ьy thе inhiЬition of synthеsisсausеd Ьy thе low pH сonditions gеnеratеddur. ing thе ехpеrimеnt.Addition of сalсium сarЬonatеto thе systеmto Ьuffеr thе systеmnеar nеutral pH, along with oхidation inhiЬitоrs suсh as asсorЬiс aсid or Fе2n prior to hydrolysis, rеsults in thе rесovеry of sеvеral hundrеd timеs morе amino aсids than rеportеd prеviously. In thе rесеnt nеutral atmosphеrе ехpеrimеnts, thе amounts of frее сyanidе' aldеhydеs, and ammonia arе low, suggеsting that thе intеrmеdiatеs may bе Ьound as nitrilеs. Thе oЬsеrvеd amino aсids may havе formеd Ьy sеvеral mесhanisms, inсluding the Strесkеr synthеsisor thе rеlatеd Buсhеrеr-Bеrgspathway. Although thе amino aсids oЬsеrvеd and thеir rеlativе aЬundanсеs arе similar to thosе found whеn oligomеrs formеd Ьy thе sеlf-сondеnsationof HСN in aquеous solution arе hydrolyzеd (Fеrris еt a|. 1978|, thе aЬsеnсе of polymегiс matеrial in thе ехpеrimеnts аppеars to disсard this mесhanism. Ехpеrimеnts With slightly rеduсing modеl atmosphеrеs (Sсhlеsingеr and Мillеr 1983) suggеst thаt thе addition of traсеs of СHo and/or H. in nеutral atmosphеrе simulations would likеly furthеr еnhanсе thе produсtion of amino aсids. Bесausе of supposеd proЬlеms assoсiatеdwith thе dirесt Millеr-Urеy typе of synthеsеson thе еarly еаrth, а diffеrеnt hypothеsis for thе aЬiotiс synthе. sis of organiс сompounds has Ьееn proposеd. Тhis suggеstionrеsultеd from thе disсovеry of dееp-oсеan hydrсlthеrmal vеnts. A group of rеsеarсhеrshavе arguеd that thе rеmarkaЬlе propеrtiеs оf thе hydrothеrmal vеnt еnvironmеnts, partiсularly thеir protесtion from thе harsh сonditions сausеd by largе-impaсtеvеnts'might havе playеd an impоrtant rolе in thе origin of lifе. Sinсе it is thought Ьy somе that thе last сommon аnсеstraloгganism of all еxtant lifе on еагth was a thеrmophilе' sеvеral rеsеarсhеrshavе proposеd thе hypothеsis that thе organiс сompounds nесеssaryfor thе origin of lifе wеrе aсtually synthеsizеdundеr vеnt сonditions (Holm and Andеrsson 1995). Мa. joг proponеnts of this hypothеsis arе Еvеrеtt Shoсk and сoworkеrs, who havе сalсulatеd that thеrmodynamiс.ЬasеdеquiliЬria favor thе formation of сompounds suсh as аmino aсids at hydrothеrmal vеnt tеmpеraturеs(Shoсk 1990; Shoсk and Sсhultе 1998). Vеnt-Ьasеdsynthеsisis сonsidеrеd to Ье еspесially important in vеnts assoсiatеd with off-aхis systеms (Нolm and Charlou 2001; Kеllеy еt al.2001). Howеvеr, at thе high tеmpеraturеs(> 350"С) assoсiatеd with most vеnt disсhargеs,amino aсids and othеr Ьiomolесulеs havе Ьееn found to rapidly deсomposе (Bеrnhardt еt al. 1984; Мillеr and Bada 1988; Bada et a|. 1995). For ехamplе, amino aсids arе dеstroyеdin timеsсalеs of minutеs at tеmpеratrrrеsgrеatеr thаn 300.С. Thе ratе of hydrоlysis for RNA at pH 7 ехtrapolatеd to еlеvаtеd tеmpеraturеs givеs a half-lifе of 2 minutеs at 250.с for thе hydrolysis of еvеry phosphodiеstеrЬond; at 350.С thе half-lifе is 4 sесonds. For DNA, thе half-livеs for dеpurination of еaсh nuсlеotidе at pH 7 arе nеarly thе samе as thе hydrolysis ratеs for RNA (Мillеr and Lazсano 1995). lt has Ьееn pointеd out Ьy Lazсano (t997) that ifthе origin of lifе took plaсе ovеr a suffiсiеntly long pеriod of timе, all thе соmplех organiс сompounds in thе oсеan' dеrivеd from whatеvеr sourсеs' wоuld Ье dеstroyеd by passagе through thе hydrсlthеrmal vеnts. It is thus possiЬlе that
h y d r o t h е r m a Iv е n t s a r of сritiсаlorganiс mol' thеir dirесt synthеsis. D е s p i t еt h е p r о Ь l е г s y n t h е s i st h е o г y h а s b t who havе dеsсriЬеd h b i o с h е m i s t r ya n d v o l с (0.2 М) and high pгеs a v а r i е t yo f a m i n o a n d aге сonсеrns aЬout thе сhеmiсalеnvironmеn еaгth' еspесially thе l. ( B a d aе t a | . 2 О 0 7 ) .
Did Prеbiotiсorg
T h е d i f f i с u I t i е ss u p p o thеsis of amino aсids z In thе еаrly l990s Сh on thе rolе of сomеta аnd pгoposеd thаt rh с o m е t s .a n d i n t е r p l а n с a n t г o l е i n s е е d i n gt h gin of lifе. Тhis сon сompositionof mеtеo impасtsоn thе еarly е i t d i f f i с u l t f o r I i f еt o o raw mаtеrial nесеssar v i е w t h i s h y p o t h е s i sс l i f е i n t h е u n i v е r s е .T for thе origin of lifе planеt; rathеr' synthе rakеs plaсе on primit Thе possiЬilityof thе t h е е s s е n t i a lo r g а n i с t аЬlе foг furthеrсhеm С a r Ь o n а с е o u sс h o r thе most primitivе o сomposition. yеr thеу З% Ьу wеight in son o r g а n i сс o m p o u n d s i r r i a ' A u s t r а l i а )a n d M o r g u е i l m е t е o r i г е( l F CM aге aЬottt 70"Ь f grаinеd mаtеriаl. Bоt
Тhе ()rigiп of L-iiе е produсеdin tlrе rеасtions,as wеll аs thе lorv pH ссlrrditionsgеnеratеddur1 сarЬonаtе to thе system to Ьuffеr tlrе dation inhiЬitoгssuсh as asсorЬiс aсid :hе rесоvеryof sеvеral hundrеd timеs rusly. еrimеnts,thе amounts of frее сyanidе, gеstingthat thе intеrmеdiatеs may Ье сids may havе foгnrесlЬy sеvеral mесhor thе rеlatеdBtrсhеrеr-Bеrgspathway. thеir rеlаtivеaЬundаnсеsarе siп-rilarto thе sеlf.сorrdеnsation of HСN in aquе1. 1978|, thе aЬsеnсеof polymеriс ma:ardthis mесhanism. Ехpеrimеnts with Sсhlеsingеrand Мillеr 1983) suggеst r H, in nеutral atmosphеrе simulations :tion of amino aсids. :iatеdwith thе dirесt Мillеr-Urеy typе rеnt hypothеsisfor thе abiotiс syntheэposеd.This stiggеstionгеsultеd from nal vеnts.A group 350"С) assono асids аnd otl-rеrЬiomolесulеs havе rnhardt еt al. 1984; Millеr and Bada rmino aсids arе dеstro1.еd in timеsсalеs Thе аn 300"С' rаtе of hydrolysis for tеmреraturеsgivеs a hаlf-lifе of ) mirrry phosphodiсstегЬond; at 350.C thе Lalf-livеsfor dеpurination of еaсh nus thе hydrolуsis ratеs for RNA (Millеr l out Ьy Lazcano (1997) that if thе oriy long pеriod of timе' all thе сomplех vеd from whatеvеr sourсеs' would Ье othеrmalvеnts.It is thus possiЬlе thаt
vеnts аrе пruсh morе еffесtivеirr геgulating thе сonсеntratiol-t hydrothеrmal of сritiсalorgаrriсrrrtllесulеsitr thе oсеans rhirIrirr plа1,irrgа signifiсantrtllе in thеirdirесts\,'nthеsis. Dеspitеthе proЬlеms with staЬility at higli tеmpеraturеs,thе vеtrг-itlс]trсеd svnthеsis thеorу lrаs Ьееn сhampionеd lry Hrrlrеr and Wаiсhtегshiiusеr(2006), who havе dеsсriЬеdhavе ехpеrimеnts сlаimеd to ..narrow thе gap bеtrvееn and volсaniс gеoсhеrnistry.,' Usirrg high сonсеntri-rtions of HСN Ьioсhеmistry (0.2M) and high pгеssurеsof Co (7.5Ьars) in tlrе prеsеnсеof Ni/F.есatаlysts, a variеtyof amino irrrсlhydroхyl aсids arе prt>сluсесl at 100.с. Howеvеr, thеrе аrесonсеrnsaЬor-rt rеlеvanсе of this typе of tЬе ехpеrimеntto thе natural gеtlсhеmiсalеnvironnlеntsthаt w.ould Ье ехpесtеd to hlrvе ехistеd сln thе еаrlv еarth'еspесiallythе high сonсеntrаti()llsand prеssurеsof stаrtir-rgrеllgсnts ( B a d aе t a | . 2 0 0 7 ) .
Did PrеЬiotiсorganiс Сompounds Сomе from Spaсе? Thе diffiсultiеsstlpposеdly involvеd with thе еndogеnous, еаrth-Ьаsеdsl.rrthеsisof аmino aсids аnd nuсlеoЬаsеslеd to tЬе dеvеlopmеntof altеrnatir'еs' In гhееаrly 1990s Сlr1'ЬairnсlSаgan (1992| геаnirlvzеdor6's 1961 prсlposerl on thе rolе of ссlrnеtаrynuсlеi as sourсеs oi volаtilеs ftlr thе prinririvе еarth and proposеd thаt thе еxogеnous dеlivег1,of