Europe's Quest for the Universe Lodewijk Woltjer
Europe’s Quest for the Universe ESO and the VLT, ESA and other projec...
215 downloads
952 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Europe's Quest for the Universe Lodewijk Woltjer
Europe’s Quest for the Universe ESO and the VLT, ESA and other projects
Lodewijk Woltjer
EDP Sciences 17, avenue du Hoggar Parc d’activités de Courtabœuf, BP 112 91144 Les Ulis Cedex A, France
Cover: THE VLT Array on the Paranal Mountain. © ESO. ISBN : 2-86883-813-8 Tous droits de traduction, d’adaptation et de reproduction par tous procédés, réservés pour tous pays. La loi du 11 mars 1957 n’autorisant, aux termes des alinéas 2 et 3 de l’article 41, d’une part, que les « copies ou reproductions strictement réservées à l’usage privé du copiste et non destinées à une utilisation collective », et d’autre part, que les analyses et les courtes citations dans un but d’exemple et d’illustration, « toute représentation intégrale, ou partielle, faite sans le consentement de l’auteur ou de ses ayants droit ou ayants cause est illicite » (alinéa 1er de l’article 40). Cette représentation ou reproduction, par quelque procédé que ce soit, constituerait donc une contrefaçon sanctionnée par les articles 425 et suivants du code pénal. © EDP Sciences 2006
CONTENTS
I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI. XII. XIII. XIV. XV. XVI. XVII. XVIII. XIX.
Preface.................................................................................. Préface.................................................................................. Acknowledgements.............................................................. Introduction ........................................................................ The Development of European Astronomy during the 20th Century .................................................................. ESO, La Silla, the 3.6-m Telescope, Other Telescope Projects in Europe ............................................................................ Origin of the ESO VLT Project; The NTT ........................ Technological, Financial and Scientific Planning of the VLT............................................................................ Construction of the VLT .................................................... Sites for Telescopes ............................................................ The VLT Observatory: Adaptive Optics, Instruments, Interferometry and Survey Telescopes .............................. Ground and Space Based Optical Telescopes.................... Radio Astronomy; ALMA and SKA.................................... Europe in Space: ESA’s Horizons 2000 .......................... European Space Missions: IR, X- and Gamma Rays ...... European Space Missions: The Solar System .................. European Space Missions: The Sun and the Heliosphere .. Astroparticles and Gravitational Waves ............................ Looking for Planets and Life in the Universe .................. Publications ........................................................................ European Astronomy: Researchers and Funding ............ The Future .......................................................................... Epilogue .............................................................................. Notes .................................................................................... Acronyms ............................................................................ Index .................................................................................... Photo credits........................................................................
3 4 5 7 11 25 43 59 69 87 109 123 139 161 175 203 219 231 243 253 265 277 289 291 301 317 325
Preface
What a magnificent title, “Europe’s quest for the Universe”, for the opening of this new book by Professor Woltjer, which presents and expands on two grand themes. Since the days of Copernicus, Galileo, Tycho Brahe and Kepler, as a research community Europe has been at the cutting edge of science, in its incessant quest to understand the universe we live in. In this book we trace the history and development of more recent institutions such as the ESA and ESO. This is thanks to the great skill and experience of the author who, by writing this work, passes on the fruits of a unique and exceptional career. Great pride and optimism for European science comes across on reading these pages, all beautifully illustrated. Written to a high scientific level, this book provides the reader with a top quality reference on the subjects covered, and gives us ample reason to believe in a European research environment directed firmly to the future. The second theme is that knowledge and exploration of the universe are fundamental elements of the human psyche, a drive inherent in all of us to understand and discover our destiny. The Universe is a magnificent question which inspires scientific and technological development. At the same time it remains that star studded sky which acts as a source of wonderment and inspiration for our thoughts and dreams. Thank you Professor Woltjer for returning us, through this book, to the very roots of our humanity, and revealing to us such marvellous advances in understanding. Philippe BUSQUIN, July 2005 European member of parliament, Former European commissioner for Research
Préface
Quel magnifique titre pour l’ouvrage de Monsieur Woltjer “Europe’s Quest for the Universe” qui exprime deux idées fortes et l’évolution de celles-ci. L’Europe, comme espace commun de recherche, depuis Copernic, Galilée, Tycho Brahe, Kepler, a été à la pointe de la science et de cette quête incessante de compréhension de notre Univers. L’histoire et le développement des institutions plus récentes comme l’ESA et l’ESO sont retracés grâce à l’expérience et à la compétence de l’auteur qui, par le truchement de cet ouvrage, nous transmet les fruits d’une carrière unique et exceptionnelle. Quelle fierté et quel optimisme pour le savoir européen à la lecture de ces pages si bien illustrées et d’un haut niveau scientifique qui contribueront à nous donner une référence de très haute qualité sur les sujets abordés et nous fournissent toutes les raisons de croire en un espace européen de la recherche tourné vers l’avenir. La deuxième idée est que la connaissance et la conquête de l’Univers sont des éléments fondamentaux du besoin inhérent à l’homme de comprendre et de découvrir le sens de son destin. L’Univers demeure cette magnifique interrogation qui inspire le développement scientifique et technologique mais aussi le ciel étoilé propice aux rêves, aux réflexions et à l’émerveillement. Merci, Monsieur Woltjer, de nous replonger, grâce à votre ouvrage, aux racines de l’humanité et aux merveilleuses avancées de la connaissance. Philippe BUSQUIN, juillet 2005 Membre du Parlement Européen, Ancien Commissaire Européen à la Recherche
Acknowledgements
First of all I would like to thank Ulla Demierre Woltjer without whose active participation this book would not have come about. Jean Pierre Swings and James Lequeux read the whole book, Roger Bonnet, Daniel Hofstadt, Marc Sarazin and Giancarlo Setti some chapters and provided much information. Many persons supplied data or contributed in less formal discussions. I mention here Arne Ardeberg, Adriaan Blaauw, Roy Booth, Jacques Breysacher, Harvey Butcher, Giacomo Cavallo, Roger Cayrel, Thierry Courvoisier, Rodney Davies, Margo Dekker-Woltjer, Michel Dennefeld, Franca Drago, Hilmar Duerbeck, Daniel Enard, Peter Fischer, Robert Fosbury, Reinhard Genzel, Roberto Gilmozzi, Alvaro Gímenez, Michael Grewing, Einar Gudmundsson, Martin Harwit, Günther Hasinger, Martin Huber, Henning Jørgensen, Martin Kessler, Pierre Léna, Duccio Macchetto, Kalevi Mattila, Brian McBreen, Jorge Melnick, Evert Meurs, George Miley, Alan Moorwood, Antonella Natta, José Miguel Rodriguez Espinosa, Francisco Sánchez, Aage Sandquist, Richard Schilizzi, Hans-Emil Schuster, John Seiradakis, Peter Shaver, Boris Shustov, Jason Spyromilio, G. Srinivasan, Jean Surdej, Yasuo Tanaka, Virginia Trimble, Sergio Volonté, Malcolm Walmsley, Roland Walter, Robert Williams, Ray Wilson. Edmund Janssen, who drew the map in Figure VI, 3, Hans-Hermann Heyer and Claus Madsen searched the ESO archives for photographs. To all my thanks. I wish to thank Catherine Césarsky, Director General of ESO, and David Southwood, Director of the ESA Science Programme, for having contributed towards making the publication of this book possible, and EDP Sciences for taking the risk to publish it in color. Parts of this book were written while “chercheur associé” at the Observatoire de Haute Provence ; I thank the directors Philippe Véron, Antoine Labeyrie, Jean-Pierre Sivan and Michel Boër, as well as Mira Véron-Cetty, for their support. Other parts were written while “Rossi Fellow” at the Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, and I thank the directors Franco Pacini and Marco Salvati, as well as the chairman of the Astronomy Department Claudio Chiuderi for their support. Some sections were written during visits to the Raman Research Institute in Bangalore, and I thank the directors V. Radhakrishnan and N. Kumar for the friendly reception I received there.
Introduction
The progress of science depends on the technological development of its instrumentation. This is particularly true for the astronomical sciences where the study of remote objects requires sophisticated and costly detection techniques. In this book I shall analyze some of the large European astronomical projects, both on the ground and in space, their development during the last two decades, and their prospects in the future. While scientific progress is intimately related to technology development, both are contingent on professionals and funding, and I shall consider the situation with regard to both of these. This book is addressed to a varied audience: scientists who wish to see what is happening outside their own domain, students who look for fruitful areas of thesis research, functionaries who need some background for decision making, amateur astronomers interested in knowing what is going on in the profession, and also to an educated public that wants to get the flavor of what is behind the newspaper articles reporting scientific results and to know how European activities compare to what is being done elsewhere. The more detailed description of the development of the VLT, ESO’s Very Large Telescope, illustrates how a large technological project gets underway and after some pitfalls reaches completion. In the first half of the twentieth century observational astronomy was ipso facto astronomy done from the ground in the visible part of the spectrum. While in the USA ever larger telescopes were being built, in Europe developments were much more modest, partly owing to unsuitable meteorological conditions, but even more because private donors on the scale of an Andrew Carnegie did not exist here. In the early fifties some proposals were made to construct a large European telescope at a suitable location. Political and financial conditions for science were much improving, and in 1964 ESO, the European Southern Observatory, was founded by half a dozen countries as an intergovernmental organization; in the meantime most countries in Western Europe have become members. In writing this book, I have placed ESO at the beginning because of its increasing role in several areas of European astronomy. The early evolution of ESO has been well described by Adriaan Blaauw in his book “ESO’s Early History”1), so I shall give only a brief recapitulation and then sketch the origin of the VLT, which has brought Europe to the forefront of contemporary optical astronomy. Following a brief overview of the
8
Europe’s quest for the Universe
development of the astronomical sciences, subsequent chapters of the book deal with the origin, development, construction and siting of the VLT, its interrelation with the Hubble Space Telescope and with possible successors of these instruments. Also during the fifties radio astronomy became a major contributor to scientific progress. The European radio community has made many advances – in part by tying national facilities into a network, the EVN (European VLBI Network). The French-German-Spanish IRAM has been successful in radio astronomy at millimeter wavelengths. ESO entered this field with SEST, the Swedish-ESO Sub millimeter Telescope. ESO is the European partner in ALMA – the Atacama Large Millimeter Array, the major Europe-Japan-US venture in submm astronomy. With the advent of the space age other parts of the spectrum became observable. Thus, infrared, ultraviolet, X- and gamma-ray observations allowed entirely new objects to be discovered and studied. Moreover, possibilities opened up for in situ exploration of the solar system. At about the same time as ESO, the precursors of the European Space Agency ESA came into being. The ESA has constructed large facilities for space research. Again I shall be brief on early ESA history, since it is described by Roger Bonnet and Vittorio Manno in their excellent short book “International Cooperation in Space: the example of the European Space Agency”2), while early worldwide space science developments are comprehensively covered in “The Century of Space Science” edited by Johan A.M. Bleeker, Johannes Geiss and Martin C.E. Huber3). Subsequently, I deal with recent and future European scientific projects in space. Most of these have been developed in the ESA context, but also some national projects have had an important role. ESA and ESO are increasingly cooperating: The European Coordinating Facility for the Space Telescope is one example; joint studies in interferometry another. The latter may be essential in one of the most exciting astronomical subjects: the search for earth like planets and life. Also archiving the enormous data flows is a common interest of ESA and ESO. A more sociological discussion of European astronomy follows. How many astronomers are there in the different countries and how much is spent on astronomy? The end product of the astronomical activity consists of publications, and the productivity of the different communities is evaluated. The final chapter deals with the future and the difficult selection of expensive projects in a relatively less favorable economic and political environment, but ending on a positive note: the past achievements augur well for the future in which the countries now entering the EU should also play their part. The present book deals with European achievements and prospects which do not seem to have been described previously in a coherent way. Others have described their achievements elsewhere. Of course, comparisons are made with what other nations – in particular Japan, Russia and the US – are doing. Also cooperative projects with these countries play an
Introduction
9
important role. But is is important to realize that Europe has the full capacity to an autonomous role in science. Sometimes the necessary self-confidence seemed to be lacking among Europeans who measured their own success by how they are regarded across the Atlantic. The press services are not very helpful in this respect; even European results appear to become more respectable after a round trip across the ocean. Cooperation is a very good thing with mutual benefits. But such cooperation can only be profitable if it is based on equality, self-confidence and mutual respect. Europe has the capacity to autonomously plan its scientific future and does not have to try to fit into plans made elsewhere. It only has to strengthen its will to do so. Two caveats should still be made. In this book I discuss mainly the larger astronomical projects. Many smaller ones are also important, but including these would require a much more voluminous tome. Secondly, when I discuss collaboration, it refers to institutional collaboration. Individuals participate in an infinite number of collaborations with fellow scientists in their researches without regard to nationality or to political factors. This contributes much to the liveliness of the field and may also be beneficial in the creation of a more harmonious world.
10
Europe’s quest for the Universe
The Crab Nebula. First catalogued by Messier as M1, it was named by Lord Rosse who observed it in the middle of the 19th century with his six foot telescope in Ireland. It is the expanding remnant of the supernova which was extensively observed in 1054 in China and Japan. The Nebula remained mysterious until 1968 when a pulsar – a rotating neutron star – was discovered at its center. The strong magnetic fields of this star accelerate cosmic rays, including energetic electrons which produce synchrotron radiation in the nebular magnetic fields. That radiation is observed from the longest radio waves at 30-m through infrared, visible and ultraviolet light to the hardest X- and gamma-rays. In visible light it is seen as a smooth bluish continuum. The reddish filamentary structures on the image are due to emission lines from gas ionized by the ultraviolet radiation. Since almost all important cosmic processes may be studied in the Crab Nebula, it has been called the Rosetta stone of astrophysics. The image was taken with the FORS instrument (PI Immo Appenzeller) attached to ESO’s VLT, the Very Large Telescope.
I. The Development of European Astronomy during the 20th Century
Praised be your intellect, you interpreters of the heavens, you who understand the Universe, discoverers of a theory by which you have bound gods and men. Gaius Plinius Secundus1)
A visitor to one of the hundred odd observatories in the world early in the 20th century would have found some astronomers at work during the night at telescopes with diameter generally less than a meter. Some would peer through an eye piece and note down their findings, but photographic plates were coming into widespread use which gave a more quantitative and less subjective record of the observations. Mostly the astronomers would be measuring the positions of planets, asteroids and stars. By a comparison with previous observations they also determined their motions across the sky. The brightness (generally denoted magnitude) and the color of the stars were also ascertained, and some of the more venturesome professionals had begun to use spectrographs with which the stellar light could be split into different wavelength bands. This allowed the detection of absorption and emission lines in the spectra. By measuring their wavelengths precisely and comparing these with the wavelengths at which gases in the laboratory emitted or absorbed radiation, they could identify the main chemical elements present in the stellar atmospheres. Variable stars were also extensively studied, different types were recognized and their detailed characteristics identified. If he returned during the day, the visitor at the larger observatories would see numerous employees at work who would make the extensive calculations needed to establish catalogues of positions and motions of celestial bodies and to compare the results with theoretical models. Calculations were made with multiplication tables, tables of logarithms or very simple mechanical machines.
12
Europe’s quest for the Universe
The photographic plates used behind the telescopes were terribly inefficient; less than 1% of the incoming light (or as one would frequently say nowadays: of the incoming “photons”) was actually detected. Nevertheless, progress was made. By 1920 the magnitudes, colors, spectra and motions of many thousands of stars had been determined, and some ideas had been formed about their distances. So one could begin to construct more fact based models of how the stars are distributed in space. In fact, most stars were found to belong to a flattened system, with the Milky Way globally corresponding to its plane of symmetry. In this “universe” systematic streaming motions were suspected. Somewhat later it was concluded that the whole system is rotating. Whether there was anything outside this “universe” was unclear. Subsequently, evidence was found from photographic plates taken with the new 100-inch telescope on Mt. Wilson, California, that the faint luminous patch called the Andromeda Nebula was an independent stellar system, far away from our Milky Way Galaxy. Other “nebulae” were also resolved into stars and the “universe” was gradually growing in extent (Figure I, 1a).
Figure I, 1a. VLT image of the spiral galaxy NGC 1232; blue light comes from massive young stars which have formed recently in the spiral arms, while the yellow light around the center is contributed by older stars formed earlier in the history of the galaxy. To the left is a dwarf galaxy tied gravitationally to NGC 1232.
Development of European Astronomy
13
Most of the early observatories had been constructed on small hills in the neighborhood of towns. As the towns grew and street lighting increased, they were sometimes moved a bit further out. In Europe most observatories were located in unfavorable climates, and in the north east of the US the situation was not much better. Turbulence in the atmosphere caused the stellar images to be smeared out over several arcseconds on the photographs. This made it hard to detect faint stars. It was G.E. Hale who decided that the solution was to go to the calmer skies in California. Raising enough private money, he founded the Mt. Wilson Observatory, which would be equipped with a 60-inch and later a 100-inch telescope. When the city lights of Los Angeles became too strong, a more distant site was developed at Mt. Palomar. As a result of these developments, the Californian astronomers were able to take the lead in investigating fainter stars and galaxies, and thereby to explore a much larger part of the Universe. This led to the discovery of the expansion of the Universe – the fact that more and more distant galaxies move away from us at larger and larger speeds. In our own Galaxy stellar populations with different chemical compositions were recognized. The important conclusion followed that most of the chemical elements were not created in the birth of the Universe, but have their origin in processes in the deep interior of stars. When stars die they may eject gas containing these elements out of which new stars may form (Figure I, 1b). Some of the European countries had founded observatories in their colonial empires, the UK in S. Africa, Australia, Canada and India, the French in Algeria, and the Dutch in Indonesia. Also Germany had considered the possibility. While these observatories collected useful data on a variety of objects, in particular on parts of our Galaxy invisible from Europe, they hardly contributed to a redirection of efforts in the mother countries. Of course, a few individual researchers could make visits to the Californian institutions, but most European observatories continued with the types of research they had been performing before. In addition, the second world war had a very damaging effect. So by 1949, when the 200-inch telescope at Mt. Palomar was inaugurated, the astronomical center of the world had largely moved to the US. In theoretical astrophysics much strength remained in Europe. This had led to a basic understanding of conditions in the stellar atmosphere and interior and of the nuclear reactions which produce the luminous energy radiated from the surface. A beginning had been made with studies of stellar evolution, while also the dynamics of our Galaxy and the orbits of stars therein were being explored. However, the rise of theoretical physics in the US (in part due to European refugees) and the early availability there of powerful computers also threatened the European pre-eminence in the theoretical domain. Four very different developments led to a rebirth of European observational astronomy: the discovery of radio waves from cosmic sources,
14
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure I, 1b. VLT image of the “planetary nebula” M27, a gaseous shell ejected by the star at the center. The interstellar gas may become enriched in elements synthesized in the star, which now ionizes and excites the shell. Different densities and temperatures in the gas lead to different emission lines and thereby to different colors in this image.
the availability of government money for research, the development of air travel and European cooperation. Soon space research would add further possibilities for observations of celestial X- and gamma-radiation and in the infrared part of the spectrum. In the appendix to this chapter the definition and units of measurement of the electromagnetic spectrum are indicated for future reference. Cosmic radio waves had been serendipitously discovered in 1933 by K. Jansky, an engineer at AT&T, but until the end of the war only some very limited follow up had been done. So the field was wide open. The poor climate in Europe did not matter, since radio waves pass through clouds and atmospheric turbulence unhindered, except at short mm wavelengths. Some of the leftover military radar equipment could be quickly converted to astronomical use, and so the cost of the first radio telescopes was modest. It soon turned out that the scientific returns were very large. Radio emission due to cosmic ray electrons throughout the Galaxy could be extensively studied.
Development of European Astronomy
15
The 21-cm emission line emitted by diffuse interstellar hydrogen gas provided a means for studying the whole galaxy without the problems associated with absorption by interstellar dust which had stymied the attempts to derive its structure by observing stars. Discrete sources of radio emission were discovered which turned out to be frequently associated with remote galaxies. So here was a whole new universe, and scientists in Europe, Australia and the US started its study at about the same time in conditions of equality (Figure I, 2). However, the radio sources that were discovered had to be identified with visible objects to determine their nature and distances. Since even strong radio sources are frequently very faint optically, this still required the large telescopes in the western US. An important contribution to the American prominence in astronomy had been made by the availability of ample private money. During the period of the wildest capitalism huge fortunes had been built, and some of the owners of these or their heirs were fascinated by the astronomical universe or liked having telescopes carry their names. Thus, Carnegie had financed Mt. Wilson and Hooker had contributed much to the cost of the 100-inch telescope. Even very recently the Keck Foundation provided an important part
Figure I, 2. The 76-m radio telescope near Manchester. Completed in 1957, it illustrates the rapid growth of radio astronomy in Europe after the war. For 15 years it was the largest radio telescope in the world.
16
Europe’s quest for the Universe
of the funding for the two 10-m telescopes at Mauna Kea, Hawaii. No similar tradition existed (or exists today2)) in Europe, and so most observatories lived a more precarious existence. After the war, and because of the important role science and technology had played for the winning side, this changed and governments began to consider it their function to sponsor research. With radio astronomy having some connections to radar and telecommunications, both funding and competent engineers were available. Typical optical observatories had resident staff. Especially in poor climates it was necessary to use every clear hour, and this could be done only when the astronomer lived on the site. However, with air travel becoming cheaper and faster, a different modus operandi became possible in which observatories could be located in optimal places anywhere in the world and astronomers would travel there just for an observing period – initially months or weeks, nowadays frequently no more than a few days. Constructing large observatories in remote places was expensive. To provide adequate funding remained difficult for individual governments. With Europe gradually becoming more unified, it seemed appropriate to consider the possibility of financing expensive scientific installations on a wider basis. Thus, CERN – the European center for nuclear and particle physics – was founded at an early date. Later ESO, the European Southern Observatory, and ESA, the European Space Agency, followed. These collaborations created the intellectual and financial basis for Europe to have the ambition to compete on the world level. By now, more than a third of all astronomy spending in Europe is done on a European rather than on a national basis. Few things happen very fast in Europe and it took a rather long time before ESO was organized. Its first “large” (3.6-m) telescope was completed only in 1976, some 23 years after it had been first proposed. In the meantime, other telescopes of similar size were being developed by several countries. Not surprisingly, many European astronomers wanted to continue to do the things they had done before: to study the distribution and motion of the stars in our Galaxy, variable stars of every kind, the motions of double stars, stellar atmospheric structure, comets and asteroids. Even though valuable research was done in these areas, European optical astronomy lacked some of the excitement that prevailed on the other side of the Atlantic, where the unknown deeper reaches of the Universe were being explored. The difference in astronomical orientation is conspicuous if one compares the ambitions for the Palomar 200-inch telescope and that for ESO. In his 1928 proposal for the construction of a 200–300-inch telescope, Hale3) indicates the principal areas of research which three quarters of a century later have lost none of their interest, though today we might phrase them somewhat differently. The topics were: The structure of the Universe. The structure of our Milky Way Galaxy.
Development of European Astronomy
17
The evolution of stars. The successive stages in the development of spiral galaxies (“the greatest of these problems”). The Universe as a cosmic laboratory to investigate the nature of matter. In a much narrower way the preamble to the ESO Convention places the emphasis strongly on the second item of this list, with the following statement: “Considering that the study of the Southern celestial hemisphere is much less advanced than that of the Northern hemisphere, that the data on which the knowledge of the Galaxy is based are accordingly by no means of the same standing in the different parts of the sky and that it is essential to improve and supplement them in all instances where they are inadequate,…” This is effectively a statement that the principal reason for founding ESO was to fill in the missing southern parts of the structure of our Galaxy, including its satellites the Magellanic Clouds. The first instrument built for the 3.6-m was a stellar photometer mainly suited for Galactic research. Certainly such research was important, and it had provided the justification for placing ESO’s facilities in the southern hemisphere. But for European astronomy to partake in the newer developments, a change of attitude and more suitable instrumentation would be needed. Several astronomers were well aware of this, and in some places researches were initiated on extragalactic topics, on interstellar matter and on high energy astrophysics. When ESO finally could organize a scientific division, the emphasis was mainly on the new domains. Young postdocs staying for a few years before returning to national institutes would develop cooperations in these subjects and later contribute to the creation of a strong coherent European astronomical research community. The increased coherence of that community would allow ESO thereafter to become much more ambitious and to build the world’s top telescope, the 16-m equivalent VLT. As in radio astronomy, the development of high energy astrophysics in Europe was very rapid once the essential tools became available. Less than five years after Sputnik, the UK observed cosmic-rays and solar X-rays with the Ariel 1 satellite. Particularly successful were Ariel 5 (1974) which made an X-ray sky survey and Ariel 6 (1979) which determined cosmic-ray composition. In 1974 the Dutch launched the ANS satellite with X-ray instrumentation and the Germans the first of the Helios spacecraft to study the solar wind. In the meantime, ESRO, later transformed into ESA, the European Space Agency, had launched its first satellite ESRO-II (1968) which observed solar X-rays. Among the European astronomical satellites TD-I (1972) for uv operations and COS-B (1975) for γ-rays were quite successful. IUE (1978), the International Ultraviolet Explorer, a NASA-UK-ESA collaboration, was also important in integrating the astronomy and space communities in Europe. Thereafter ESA missions became larger, more competitive and well centered
18
Europe’s quest for the Universe
on the newer astronomical research areas: EXOSAT (1983) and XMM-Newton (1999) in X-rays, INTEGRAL (2002) in γ-rays, ISO (1995) in the infrared, supplemented by a participation in the Hubble Space Telescope from 1991 onward, gave European astronomers access to much of the wavelength range of space astronomy. In addition, the national X-ray satellites ROSAT (D, 1990) and BeppoSAX (I, 1998) made major contributions. Hipparcos (1989) gave Europe the lead in astrometry, determining positions and motions of 100,000 stars. In the exploration of the solid bodies of the solar system Europe was a latecomer. Of course, planets, asteroids and comets had been observed with telescopes on earth, but only limited results could be obtained from large distances. The first space mission to observe such an object from close by would be Giotto in 1985, which obtained the most detailed information ever on a cometary nucleus. It took 18 years before the next such European mission arrived at Mars. Both Russia and the US had left Western Europe far behind in planetary exploration. Ulysses (1990) and SOHO (1995), both joint missions with NASA, and Cluster (2000), continue to study the Sun and the heliosphere with advanced instrumentation. All of the IR, X- and γ-ray missions require much follow up with optical telescopes, and it is fortunate that ESO is now able to provide unique possibilities for this with the VLT. When today one looks at European astronomy, one sees a vibrant community active and competitive in all the exciting areas of research on the Universe, its contents and evolution. Not surprisingly, in parallel with the increased instrumentation also the number of professional astronomers has much increased (Figure I, 3). Less than a century ago they were rare and frequently considered as oddballs with rather doubtful economic prospects. Few parents would approve their daughter marrying an astronomer! Their nightly work also set them apart from the typical social schedule. Today being an astronomer no longer makes one very different from people in other scientific professions. In the developed world there are typically ten to twenty astronomers per million inhabitants. And while most are not particularly rich, their material prospects are no different from those in other academic professions. They used to work as individuals or in groups of two or three. Nowadays it is not unusual to see research projects of fifty scientists, postdocs and graduate students. This has had several consequences. Such groups tend to have a hierarchical structure, with the leaders not only controlling the research of the more junior staff but also their economic well being. This would seem to be unavoidable, but it makes the jobs of the junior staff less attractive. All of this is accompanied by a certain “industrialization” of the research, with projects defined and executed on financial and time schedules. Since many staff members are needed in such projects and insufficient long term academic positions are available, a system of temporary postdocs has arisen with appointments on time scales of typically two or three years. This was not too serious when
Total reflecting surface area in m2 of fully steerable telescopes/number of members of the International Astronomical Union (divided by 10)
Development of European Astronomy
19
1000
100
10
1 1900
1950
2000
Year Figure I, 3. Astronomers and telescopes. The total reflecting surface area in m2 of fully steerable telescopes for the world (green) and for Europe (blue) compared to the number of members of the International Astronomical Union (divided by 10, in red) for different years. Exponential growth is noticeable in all, though now the numbers of IAU members are beginning to flatten off. It is seen that after the war Europe had fallen far behind in telescope construction, but that by now it has caught up again. The cross indicates what would be the result of the construction of OWL (Chapter VIII).
overall employment increased and more continuing appointments were available but now long term positions are not easy to find, and a large number of postdocs are floating around from one temporary position to the next. Some ultimately quit and take jobs in industry or government. Young astronomers tend to be well qualified in subjects like programming, image processing and the handling of large data sets. In addition, they are used to
20
Europe’s quest for the Universe
arrive at conclusions concerning systems about which insufficient information is available. So, at least in some European countries, they fit relatively easily into jobs in insurance, banking and government planning offices. For example, in Holland two out of three people with a degree in astronomy wind up in nonastronomical positions. There is nothing wrong with this, but it implies that astronomy education should not be too narrow. Of course, some astronomers also become science teachers in high school. Nevertheless, one may wonder if the postdoc system has not been overstretched. Especially at a time when alternative jobs become also more difficult to obtain, the prospects become so uncertain that many of the more perspicacious students may choose other directions. To summarize, there thus were three phases. Till the early years of the 20th century astronomy was largely a European affair. During the subsequent decades, the American dominance was established partly by a better funding situation and also by the unfortunate developments in Europe which paralyzed research and caused many prominent researchers to leave, never to return. After the war ended European astronomy began a slow recovery process which accelerated in the seventies and eighties. By now Europe has reached again a position of equality in most astronomical fields and leadership in some. Two fundamental factors have contributed to this: a well educated pool of young talent and nearly adequate funding. If these would begin to be lacking, a decline would be rapid. In this respect, some fears for the future are justified. At the political level in Europe there is much talk about the “knowledge based economy”, while at the same time the financial underpinnings of such an economy are being weakened. Besides, the evolution of high schools and universities is not always encouraging. So what around 1975 were the main problems that the world astronomical community perceived as essential to tackle, and which have shaped astronomical technology in the subsequent decades? Perhaps clearest was that only a very small part of the Universe had been surveyed. A few quasars at larger redshifts were already known, but since they were not understood, they did not yet help much in cosmological studies. The key to further progress was the ability to observe fainter galaxies at greater distances and also fainter stars in our own Galaxy. Second, it was also evident that we had only a very washed out view of astronomical objects ranging from remote galaxies to the planets. Much of the essential physics would only be seen when angular resolution would be improved by better observational techniques or in the case of our solar system by in situ studies. Third, we had seen enough to realize that the view at visible wavelengths was very incomplete. More satisfactory radio observations were in sight, but in the IR, X- and γ-rays and in the study of particles like neutrinos or of gravitational waves we had just scratched the surface sufficiently to know that our ignorance was complete. Thus, the trio that since then has dominated progress was increased sensitivity, increased angular resolution and increased wavelength coverage.
Development of European Astronomy
21
Increased sensitivity could be achieved by larger telescopes and by more efficient detectors. Some of the first CCD detectors were developed for space imaging; infrared detectors were developed by the military for night vision devices and other purposes. X- and γ-ray and particle detectors were developed by physicists for a variety of aims. By now CCDs of large formats and low noise are abundantly available; even a 100 € camera has a CCD. To obtain better sensitivity and angular resolution, larger telescopes now are needed. We have a general idea how to build these, but more and more the cost is a limiting factor. So to the above mentioned trio we have to add a fourth: cost reduction. The story of ESO, ESA and European astronomy in general over the last 30 years has been one of finding better and cheaper solutions to instrumental problems so as to be able to afford what we can conceive. Of course, the scientific utilization of our instruments is the ultimate aim. But it may well be that the good scientific use of these instruments is easier to achieve than their development at acceptable cost. Observational results will remain isolated facts if there is not a theoretical framework in which they find their place and for which at the same time they provide the foundation. Such a framework is also needed to see which future observations are most likely to increase our understanding. Thus, theoretical research is an essential part of astronomy, though its detailed aspects are outside the scope of this book.
Annex: Electromagnetic Radiation Different aspects of electromagnetic radiation are described in terms of waves or particles. When we discuss diffraction of light through a small opening or interference of light beams, the wave description is more convenient; when we study the effect of light on a solid state detector like a CCD, it is simpler to think in terms of photons ejecting electrons from the material. However, both descriptions refer to the same underlying physical phenomenon. In image forming systems (lenses, mirrors) the image is formed by the interference of refracted or reflected light beams. An important result concerns the angular resolution – the minimum separation in angular measure (degrees, arcminutes, arcseconds) which allows us to see two stars as separate objects. At a wavelength λ the angular resolution θ of a telescope with a diameter d is given approximately by θ = 200 000 λ/d arcsec, where λ and d are in the same units. Thus, at visible light with λ § 0.5 μm a telescope with a circular aperture of 1 meter diameter has an angular resolution of 0.1 arcsec. If we inspect two stars or other objects at a distance D, the linear separation l corresponding to the angle θ is about θD/200 000 and, therefore, the linear resolution l = λD/d. Thus, with our 1-m telescope we
Europe’s quest for the Universe
22
would be able to see details on the moon (D = 400 000 km) 200 m in size. This would, in fact, be the case in space. However, from the ground the angular resolution is degraded due to atmospheric turbulence to values typically ten times larger, unless adaptive optics (Ch. VII) is implemented. Astronomical measurements extend over a range of a factor of about 1021 in wavelength. Three types of units are commonly employed in different parts of the spectrum: wavelength, frequency and photon energy (Figure I, 4). In the radio part of the spectrum frequency ν is most commonly used, or alternatively wavelength λ. The relation between the two is νλ = c, with c the velocity of light 3 × 108 m/sec. Frequency is measured in Hz (cycles/sec). In the IR, visible and uv it is more common to use wavelength. In the X-ray region of the spectrum the eV (electronvolt) is the unit of choice, with a photon energy of E expressed in eV corresponding to a wavelength λ expressed in μm by the relation E (eV) = 1.24/λ (μm).
Wavelength atmospheric transparency frequency/energy name
km
MHz
m
GHz Radio
μm
mm
nm
eV
THz IR
keV V
UV
X-rays
MeV
GeV
TeV
γ-rays
Figure I, 4. The electromagnetic spectrum. The tickmarks correspond to factors of ten, but those of the Hz and eV scales are not continuous. The prefixes n, μ, m, k, M, G and T correspond to 10-9, 10-6, 10-3, 103, 106, 109, 1012. The blue parts of the spectrum in the figure cannot be directly observed from below the earth’s atmosphere. Above 10 GeV indirect measurements are possible by observing the interaction of the very energetic photons with the atmosphere. The atmospheric transmission in the IR is more complicated than indicated here with some narrow “windows” in the 2–30 μm and the 200–1000 μm spectral domains. Common terminology for the latter is “submm” or “far IR”, while “near IR” refers to 1–2.5 μm. Terminology at shorter wavelength is less well defined, with “near uv”, followed by “far uv” and “EUV”, the extreme ultraviolet. The EUV gradually becomes “soft X-rays” ( 1–2 keV), “hard Xrays” ( 5–10 keV), and “soft γ-rays” with a considerable overlap.
Development of European Astronomy
23
The southern Milky Way and the Magellanic Clouds (photo: C. Madsen). Just under the Small Magellanic Cloud is the second brightest globular cluster 47 Tucanae, just above the bar of the Large Cloud the Tarantula Nebula, a region of dense gas and intense star formation. The dark area in the Milky Way is the “Coal Sack” due to a nearby cloud of dust which blots out the stars behind it; at its top is the star α Crucis, which with the three bright stars to the left constitutes the “Southern Cross”. The two bright stars below the Coal Sack are α and β Centauri. Just outside this image to the left are ω Centauri, the brightest globular cluster in the sky, and Centaurus A, the nearest radio galaxy (Fig. IX, 1).
II. ESO, La Silla, the 3.6-m Telescope, Other Telescope Projects in Europe
Among the other most remarkable spectacles which we have beheld, may be ranked the Southern Cross, the cloud of Magellan and the other constellations of the Southern hemisphere. Charles Darwin1)
During a visit to Jan Oort in Leiden, Walter Baade, a German astronomer working in Pasadena, gave the impetus to the idea of a joint European observatory. At Lick Observatory in California a 3-m telescope was under construction, and the proposal was to quickly build a copy and place it in the southern hemisphere which was the optimal location for the study of our Milky Way Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds. Since some connections already existed to South Africa, the first thought was to go there. The emphasis on Galactic research was not unnatural since because of their relatively small telescopes European astronomers had not participated much in the study of remote galaxies which had remained the prerogative of the large Californian telescopes. As a consequence, many of them saw such an observatory as a means of extending their researches in stellar and galactic astronomy. By a fortunate coincidence, preparations for CERN, the Center for European Research in Nuclear Physics, were just coming to a satisfactory conclusion and so a ready made model for a European scientific research organization was in place. Nevertheless, it took another decade before the convention establishing the European Southern Observatory was agreed on (1962) and ratified by five European parliaments (1964): Belgium, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Sweden, followed in 1967 by Denmark. The United Kingdom had participated in some of the discussions. However, the Commonwealth Astronomer, later Astronomer Royal in England, R.v.d.R. Woolley strongly opposed a project with the Europeans, while the eminent scientist F. Hoyle,
26
Europe’s quest for the Universe
seeing the governmental lawyers at work armed with French-German dictionaries, concluded “I thought that an observatory organized this way is not going to work”2). So in 1961 the UK decided on a joint project with Australia instead. History repeated itself in 1987 when I had discussions with the UK representatives on participation in the VLT, which were followed by the UK joining the Gemini project of the US. Finally, when the superiority of the completed VLT had become clear and even larger telescopes were beginning to be discussed, the UK joined ESO in 2002. It had to pay a substantial entrance fee without its industry having had a chance to profit from the project. In the meantime Italy and Switzerland (1982) and Portugal (2001) had also become full members. Finland followed in 2004. Well before the convention was signed, a beginning had been made with studies of possible sites in South Africa, where several European astronomers had scientific contacts and where a functioning observatory already existed. In retrospect, the long delay in getting ESO started may well have been advantageous; by 1964 the superiority of sites in the Andes had become clear3) and it was still possible to opt for a place in Chile. The ESO convention specified that the principal instrument would be a telescope of “about 3 meters aperture”. At the time it was considered necessary that such a telescope have three focus positions (Figure II, 1): a prime focus for very deep photography and low resolution spectroscopy, a Cassegrain focus for photoelectric photometry and medium resolution spectroscopy and a fixed coudé focus for very high resolution stellar spectroscopy. Since remote control was still beyond the horizon, it was necessary to have the observer in a “prime focus cage” to guide the telescope and to change the photographic plates. Because such a cage had to accommodate a human being it could not be so very small, and with a 3-m telescope an unacceptable amount of light would be intercepted by the cage. So finally the wording of the convention was stretched and the aperture enlarged to 3.57 m. The long delay before the ESO convention was concluded had also some negative consequences. While in the sixties a 3.6-m telescope in the southern hemisphere would have been unique, by 1976 the 4-m US telescope at Cerro Tololo and the Anglo-Australian 3.9-m had already been operating for more than a year. Even more serious for ESO, some of its member countries were building their own 3.5-m class telescopes. France was involved with Canada in the 3.6-m CFHT (Canada-France-Hawaii-Telescope) on the excellent site on Mauna Kea at 4200 m altitude. In Germany Zeiss was building a 3.5-m telescope for the Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie; though ultimately placed on Calar Alto in Spain, it had been foreseen for the Gamsberg in Namibia. A 3.5-m telescope was planned by the Italians for Castel Grande in southern Italy, though it was completed only some twenty years later at La Palma in the Canary Islands. Thus, ESO had lost its preeminence in the southern hemisphere, while in a European context it was in
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
27
a
b
c
d
Figure II, 1. Different types of telescopes. a – prime focus with only one reflection on a concave mirror; b – Cassegrain with two reflections on a concave primary and a convex secondary; c – Nasmyth, with a flat tertiary mirror sending the light through one of the axes; d – coudé with a number of flat mirrors which allow the focus to be at a fixed location while the telescope moves. A representative light-ray is indicated in red, while the mirrors are shown in white and the focal position as a green dot. The Nasmyth focus is particularly suited for an alt-azimuth telescope. The number of flat mirrors in the coudé depends upon the layout. At each reflection on aluminum coated mirrors about 15% of the light is lost at visible wavelengths.
competition with several equivalent national projects. Why have a costly European venture at a level attainable by the major countries in Europe by themselves? Initially the 3.6-m telescope project had been placed in the hands of a well qualified engineer, W. Strewinski. However, neither he nor ESO’s management had appreciated the magnitude of the task. By 1970 alternative solutions were looked for, and this led to the creation of the ESO Telescope Project Division on the CERN campus with a generous contingent of CERN personnel temporarily added to the ESO staff. This finally resulted in 1976 in the successful installation of the 3.6-m telescope (Figure II, 2) at La Silla some 500 km north of Santiago de Chile. As a consequence of its history,
28
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure II, 2. The 3.6-m telescope at La Silla. From bottom upwards the Cassegrain cage inside which spectrographs or other instruments are located, the primary mirror (invisible), the declination (celestial latitude) axis attached to the horseshoe like structure at the end of the polar axis on the right, and near the top the Cassegrain secondary with some baffles or the prime focus cage. Initially, an observer was present in one of the two cages, but subsequently remote controls were installed.
it was of conservative design and had cost a great deal of money (68 MDM4) or 78 M€ in 2004 value, including its housing and personnel costs). Hardly any instrumentation for the effective use of the telescope had been developed. All the 3.5–4-m telescopes constructed during the seventies share this conservatism. Some relatively small differences in the mechanical design occur, but globally all follow the overall pattern set by the 200-inch telescope
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
29
on Mt. Palomar. A prime focus cage accommodating an observer, a Cassegrain cage behind the primary mirror and a fixed coudé focus for heavy auxiliary equipment reached after extra reflections, the telescope rotating around an axis pointing towards the celestial north or south pole so as to track the daily motion of the stars with a rotation around this axis. Only the astronomers in the USSR had had the courage already in 1960 to adopt an altazimuth (one horizontal and one vertical axis) design for the 6-m telescope. To some extent they were forced in this direction by the large weight of the 6-m mirror. From a mechanical point of view there is much advantage to have the telescope tube move only in a meridional plane on a rotating platform, thus avoiding the complex mechanical stresses of the polar mount. This leads to important cost savings (see chapter III). Also heavy equipment may be mounted easily and accessibly at the two Nasmyth foci. The inconvenience is the fact that the telescope has to be driven in two coordinates at varying rates, which at the time of more primitive computers was not a trivial matter. However, when refraction and telescope flexures are taken into account, even a polar mounting requires more than just an axial rotation. More serious is the image rotation in an alt-azimuth mount which has to be compensated. At ESO not much discussion seems to have taken place on a possible alt-azimuth mounting5). There was a general feeling that the American engineers knew what they were doing and that one should not deviate too much from their designs which had been proven to function well. Of course, this implied that the technology was not necessarily the newest. A certain conservatism was perhaps justified by the fact that the observatory, as specified in the convention, looked very much like a one shot affair to provide a European observing capability. If one would have considered the convention program as a first step in a long range enterprise, the need for an independent European capability in telescope technology would have been clear. Of course, in all of this one has to take into account that ESO came into being at a time of very rapid developments in computers and detectors and that many aspects were still not clear at the time decisions were made. Nevertheless, it remains surprising that cost-to-benefit considerations were so largely absent. Perhaps the ample availability of money in those days provides an explanation. Progress on ESO’s 3.6 m telescope had been slow, but instrumentation developments were in a catastrophic state. The only instrument being designed was a 4-color photometer/polarimeter. Though the instrument, developed by Alfred Behr, was excellent, it was hardly the most urgent one for a large telescope. Following numerous test nights, it was in operation for only 24 nights before being decommissioned. Much discussion had taken place about the construction of a large coudé spectrograph. To maximize the optical path the building plans at some stage had become quite fantastic: below the round dome the coudé floor would be square. Along the diagonal this would increase the available length by ¥2. Finally, fear for the image
30
Europe’s quest for the Universe
quality as a result of this awkward aerodynamical shape led to its abandonment6); undoubtedly this also reduced costs. Because of the high cost of the coudé spectrograph, it had been decided to construct next to the 3.6-m telescope a 1.4-m Coudé Auxiliary Telescope (CAT). During the time that the large telescope would be used for other purposes, the CAT would allow the spectrograph to be used for the observation of brighter stars. The coudé focus also had a major impact on the telescope design with three large flat mirrors, needed to bring the light from the moving telescope to the stationary focus. By the time the 3.6-m telescope was completed, classical coudé spectrographs were being abandoned in many observatories since more compact and efficient Cassegrain instruments had been developed. In fact, only two of the three flats have been installed in the telescope and the classical coudé focus has never been implemented. When I came to ESO in 1975, it was evident that there was no real plan to effectively use the 3.6-m telescope for contemporary science. There also would be no suitable instrumentation to attach to the telescope. All of this reflected the absence of any scientific identity of ESO. In particular the French had been insisting that ESO be an “Observatoire de mission” with only the staff needed to run the telescopes. Instrumentation would be decided by an Instrumentation Committee and built largely in the national institutes, while scientists residing in their home institutes would decide what programs to execute. This approach was inadequate in giving the instrumentation the necessary coherence and realism. In December 1972 my predecessor, Adriaan Blaauw, had tried to get the ESO Council to agree to the creation of a small “scientific group” in Geneva, which I would be heading. Instead, Council offered a visiting appointment to discuss with the member countries the instrumentation issues. This did not seem a particularly attractive job. The issue came again to the fore in 1974 when a new Director General had to be found. Council had begun to realize that things were not going well and so became more receptive to a change of policy. Still a long period of wrangling followed which lasted more than a year. This began when I was to be appointed. I had made the creation of an in-house scientific group a condition for taking the position. Council met in closed session to discuss the appointment and was expected to come to a rapid conclusion, but for several hours nothing happened. Inside the meeting room, however, the situation was dramatic. The French President had received the agreed view of Council as to what he would tell me. At some moment during this process, he felt that his honor had been questioned by the German Vice-President. In true gallic tradition he resigned as President. The Vice-President automatically became President, but immediately also resigned. Since some decision had to be taken, J.H. Bannier as the most senior member of Council assumed the presidency, and finally the appointment was made in a provisional way. Several weeks later three Dutchmen: the Director General A. Blaauw, the interim President J.H. Bannier and I met to see how to
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
31
proceed further. At the December Council meeting I was to present a complete plan for the future of ESO with proposals for both Chile and Europe. If these were acceptable to Council, then my appointment would be confirmed. No one seems to have wondered what to do four weeks later if no agreement were reached. However, everything went smoothly, because several issues were left hanging. Half a year later the disagreement with the French came again to the fore, with an implied threat that they might leave the organization if outvoted. As a delegate of one of the small countries said, they would support me entirely except if this threat were to become fully serious. Some discussions between a few delegations took place outside, and the final result was an agreed resolution scribbled on a sheet of paper. Before this came to a vote, someone wondered if one should not ask the Director General’s opinion. If only because of the way in which that resolution had come about, it was obviously unacceptable. Following this, Bengt Strömgren, the President of Council, took the piece of paper with the resolution in his fist and crumpled it. An absolute silence followed with everyone waiting to see what would happen. Strömgren’s prestige was such that no one dared to say anything, and he simply resumed the discussions. The final result was that a beginning of a scientific group was agreed, while Jean-François Denisse would travel to Chile with me to evaluate the situation there. That visit was decisive. He saw there that the drastic remedies I was proposing were fully justified. Moreover, he discovered that the French complaint of a lack of French staff was unfounded: people like Jacques Breysacher and Daniel Hofstadt turned out to be French rather than German! Soon after this visit a final compromise was reached. In the subsequent twelve years I enjoyed excellent relations with all delegations in Council, which finally led to the unanimous approval of the VLT project. It shows the importance of forcing the issues early, rather than having them fester on unsettled for a long time. When I arrived at ESO, it was clear that to effectively use the 3.6-m telescope for contemporary science the absolute necessity was to have a simple spectrograph for the observation of faint galaxies, nebulae and stars. Since no time was available for an optimized design, a ready made Boller & Chivens spectrograph was purchased. The Instrumentation Committee had little love for this spectrograph, claiming that the optics were not optimal. However, it was the only instrument that could be acquired rapidly. Because of the lucky absence of some members at the decisive meeting, the IC finally agreed. For some 6 years this remained the only spectrograph at the 3.6-m suitable for observing faint objects. Especially with the newer detectors it was quite successful. During 1976 a new instrumentation plan was developed (largely based on a proposal of Johannes Andersen at Copenhagen and Daniel Enard at ESO) which in addition to the low resolution spectrograph contained a crossdispersed échelle Cassegrain spectrograph for resolutions of the order of
32
Europe’s quest for the Universe
30,000. Furthermore, a high resolution (λ / Δλ ≈ 100,000) coudé échelle scanner (CES) would be constructed for use with the 1.4-m CAT exclusively. This allowed the 3.6-m and CAT telescopes both to be used 100% of the time and to “postpone” the extensive work needed to implement the coudé focus of the 3.6-m, which still had many adherents. This liberated the personnel needed for more urgent instrumentation. The instrumentation plan also foresaw the introduction of new electronic detectors as an essential part of all instruments, replacing photographic plates. The Boller & Chivens spectrograph served the ESO community well for nearly a decade. However, its reflecting optics caused significant light losses, though it was necessary for covering a large wavelength range. In the meantime new glasses had been developed by Schott in Mainz which made it possible for Enard to design an all-transmission spectrograph containing only lenses and prisms. With the ESO Faint Object Spectrograph and Camera, EFOSC, the sum of all the light losses amounted to less than 25%. In addition, the lenses were so arranged that the optical beam was parallel over a certain distance and here filters and dispersive elements could be placed. These were mounted on remotely controlled wheels. By rotating these one could obtain images or spectra with different characteristics. This very much enhanced the overall efficiency. Instead of losing valuable telescope time while changing from imagers to spectrographs or mounting different dispersing elements to change the spectral resolution, a few computer commands sufficed to change modes in a matter of seconds. Improved versions of EFOSC were later developed by Sandro D’Odorico. The detector area had some political sensitivities. A. Lallemand in France had developed an electronic camera that was far superior in performance to photographic plates, but cumbersome to use. After a dozen exposures had been taken, the vacuum seals had to be broken, the exposed emulsions taken out and the camera rebuilt. At the time the 3.6-m was being completed, a Grande Caméra Électronique with a sensitive area of 80 mm diameter had been constructed, and it had been envisaged to use this object of national pride as a detector at the 3.6-m. However, the new solid state detectors that were becoming available in the US were much easier to use and they could communicate directly with a computer. So the installation of the electronic cameras at La Silla would be a major wasted effort. After the initial period up to 1984, in which image tubes, image dissector scanners, reticons and digicons had been used, the quality of the Charge Couple Devices (CCDs) had become so excellent that they became the detector of choice for almost all instruments, be it for imaging or for spectroscopy. Their efficiency in yellow light was coming close to values around 80%, i.e. a factor of fifty better than photographic plates. Infrared astronomy was still in its infancy. The main problem was that at wavelengths longer than 2.5 μm everything, including the atmosphere and the telescope itself, begins to radiate prodigiously at ambient temperatures.
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
33
To detect the faint extraterrestrial sources, rapid switching techniques are needed in which the source is compared repeatedly with the “empty” sky. Because the atmosphere is rather variable, the switching between source and background has to be done dozens of times per second. Moreover, to reduce the background due to the infrared instrument itself, the detector and the critical optical elements have to be cooled to temperatures of a few K above absolute zero. Under the leadership of Alan Moorwood some infrared photometers were constructed for the 3.6-m telescope, followed in 1985 by an advanced cryogenic infrared spectrograph based on a small solid state detector array. As a result of the new instrumentation, the ESO 3.6-m / CAT combination was changed from a late-comer of the previous era into a fully up-todate combination. Instead of having to adapt photographic instruments to the new world, the instruments were designed from the beginning for the new detectors. Of course, the CAT remained a small telescope (1.4-m) and only relatively bright stars could be observed. Later, when efficient optical fibers became available, the coudé échelle spectrograph was coupled directly to the 3.6-m telescope and the CAT was closed down. Later additional instrumentation for the 3.6-m telescope would also include a multiple object spectrograph, allowing numerous objects to be observed at the same time, an adaptive optics imager (chapter VII) and a very precise radial velocity meter for planet detection (chapter XV).
The La Silla Telescope Park and its cost At the end of 1971, construction of the 3.6-m telescope was still to begin, but at La Silla smaller telescopes had been springing up like mushrooms: a 1.5-m for spectroscopy, a 1-m for photometry, four 40–60 cm telescopes (partly in cooperation with institutes in the ESO countries) and a 1-m Schmidt telescope for photographing the whole southern sky. While these telescopes could certainly be justified scientifically and politically, the multiplicity of efforts may well have been detrimental for the progress of the main project, the 3.6-m telescope. Instrumentation for these telescopes also represented much effort. Although this was supposed to create valuable experience for the instrumentation of the 3.6-m telescope, hardly anything had been built for the latter when it was completed. Later a 2.2-m and a 1.5-m telescope were also added (Figure II, 3). All these activities came at a considerable cost. Blaauw7) estimates that when the 3.6-m telescope became operational, the (3.6-m) Telescope Project Division had been responsible for only 28% of the cumulative ESO expenditure. While to this should be added the part of the infrastructure needed for the 3.6-m at La Silla, it shows that the cost of the smaller telescopes was far from negligible. Later in the 1986 ESO Annual Report, I presented an
34
Europe’s quest for the Universe
analysis of the operational cost of the various telescopes at La Silla. Costs incurred in Garching were appropriately apportioned, including those for instrumental development, Visiting Astronomers and administrative overhead. During 1986 the cost for the 3.6-m telescope came to 4.6 M€
Figure II, 3. La Silla in 2003. In the lower part are offices and dormitories. Then come some small telescopes, followed by the 1.5-m, the GPO, the 1-m, the 1.5-m DK, the 2.2-m and the 1-m Schmidt. Higher up are the NTT and the 3.6-m/CAT and to the right the 15-m SEST. Near the bottom is the 15-m inflatable dome for VLT experiments.
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
35
(2004 value), that for all the others (except for the 2.2-m) to 6.3 M€. The 2.2-m is not included here, because its installation was too recent and the cost for its initial instrumentation still high. The light collecting power of each telescope is proportional to the area of the primary mirror; so the cost per m2 is an appropriate indicator of financial efficiency. For the 3.6-m the annual cost amounted to 450 k€/m 2, that for the others on average 780 k€/m2. Thus, the large telescope was cheapest for collecting a given amount of light. While small telescopes may have their uses for special, well focussed projects (see Gamma-Ray Bursts in Chapter XI) or for long time monitoring of interesting objects, in most cases their cost effectiveness is too low to operate them on an isolated site at 10,000 km distance. The economic situation is very different in the vicinity of a university campus where a low cost operation with students is possible. In fact, by now the small telescopes at La Silla have been largely closed down (Table II, 1). Table II, 1. The La Silla Telescopes. Subsequent columns give the diameter, the name or the national partner, the first and last years of use. For some of the smallest telescopes the closing dates are ambiguous, since there was a gradual winding down. The 1.5-m Danish is no longer used by ESO.
2.2-m (MPG) 3.6-m 3.5-m NTT 2.2-m (MPG) 1.5-m 1.5-m DK 1.4-m CAT 1.2-m CH 1.0-m
1983 – 2006? 1976 – 1989 – 1983 – 2006? 1968 – 2002 1979 – 2006? 1981 – 1998 1998 – 1966 – 2001
0.6-m Bochum 1.0-m Schmidt 0.9-m NL 0.6-m Bochum 0.5-m 0.5-m DK 0.4-m GPO
1972 – 1998 1972 – 1998 1979 – 1999 1968 – 1989 1971 – 1997 1969 – 2003 1968 – 1992
15-m SEST
1987 – 2002
In 2004 ESO operated only the 3.6-m, NTT and 2.2-m telescopes. From the budget 2004 it appears that the La Silla operating costs amount to 5.9 M€. Including also the other cost elements, I estimate a total cost of 7 M€ for La Silla, corresponding to 300 k€/m2 for the three telescopes, about a third less than 18 years earlier. So the largest cost reduction at La Silla during the last decade has been due to the closing of the smaller telescopes. These cost figures do not include the capital costs of the construction of the telescope. If we assume the 3.6-m continues to function till 2010, its 78 M€ cost would correspond to some 2.3 M€/year. For the NTT, also with a 33 year lifetime, the corresponding figure would be only 0.7 M€/year. So the capital cost of these telescopes is below the integrated operating cost during their lifetime. Adding the capital and operation costs of the three
36
Europe’s quest for the Universe
remaining telescopes, we find that the average cost of one clear night at these telescopes amounts to some 13 k€. In political circles sometimes the complaint has been made that astronomers are good at inaugurating new telescopes, but not at closing old facilities. In fact, when a telescope is to be closed down, it will be said by many astronomers that there is still much useful work that can be done with it. However, this misses the point. The real issues are the cost-to-benefit ratio becoming too high and could the funds needed to operate an older telescope be used more advantageously on newer instruments. From Table II, 1 it is seen that ESO’s record in this respect is rather favorable. From 15 telescopes at La Silla only 5 are still operating, and that number is likely to further diminish. The average lifetime of the 10 obsolete telescopes has been 25 years.
ESO Operations in Chile and in Europe Coming to ESO, I found one other aspect that needed radical change, the operations in Chile. Here there was an astronomical-technical establishment in Santiago far too separated from its raison d’être, the observatory at La Silla. Productivity in the agreeable colonial atmosphere of Santiago was not very high, and in any case it was not ESO’s role to finance an astronomical center there. There was also too large an administrative establishment that found unnecessary roles for itself. So I decided to move almost everyone to La Silla: astronomers, engineers, technicians and much of the administration, leaving only a small office in Santiago. This necessitated the construction of more working and living space on the mountain and the transportation of the staff members living in Santiago or La Serena to La Silla and back at a reasonable frequency. Here the solution involved the airstrip that had been constructed for emergency purposes at Pelícano, in the plain below La Silla. The astronomers in Santiago, who feared the end of their cozy existence, had arranged for one of their friends who owned an airplane to fly me to La Silla so that I could see how easy it would be to stay in Santiago and to pay visits to La Silla when needed. Ironically, this provided the solution in the opposite direction: everything could be moved to La Silla, and the required Santiago-based staff would work at La Silla on a schedule of eight consecutive days of work, followed by six days of rest at home, the transfer being made by air. After some initial grumbling most of the staff rapidly got used to the scheme and many found the six days vacation every two weeks a positive benefit. Thanks to the efforts of Peter de Jonge who managed the difficult transition phase very well, it took less than a year for the new setup to be fully implemented. The whole arrangement contributed much to the efficient functioning of La Silla, also by a much more effective interaction between engineers and astronomers. The administration now was closer to the users of its services,
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
37
and a smaller number of international staff was far more effective. This arrangement functioned well until ESO developed the Paranal site for the VLT. With operations at two observatory sites a different structure was needed. Managing the mountain was not so simple from the human point of view. The enforced togetherness outside working time gave ample opportunity to exchange and amplify grievances. The mix of international staff and local Chilean staff with different financial conditions also created problems. The basic ESO philosophy was straightforward. In professions for which no suitable staff could be found in Chile, international staff was employed; to find such staff, rather generous payment was required. In professions that could be filled by Chileans, staff was recruited locally and paid according to the scales of the more favorable Chilean enterprises. How to place individual jobs in that scheme remained contentious, and the efforts of the administration to design a detailed job classification on the basis of abstract criteria were not very helpful8). Even though few of the Chilean staff members left voluntarily, because better paymasters were not to be found, their large number on the mountain led to increasing discontent and, finally, to a strike. While this strike led to a number of small measures favorable to the Chilean staff, the long term effect was more negative: to avoid the recurrence of a situation where La Silla could be completely paralyzed, more and more use was made of manpower provided by Chilean companies. By 1978, La Silla was a well functioning observatory with an excellent large telescope much used by visiting astronomers from the member countries and with a slowly growing complement of up-to-date instrumentation. Several smaller telescopes were in routine use (1.5-m, 1-m, Schmidt and some in the 50-cm class). Soon to come was the 1.5-m Danish telescope, with 50% of the time available to ESO. For several years this would be the most solicited telescope after the 3.6-m, but its initial history was not auspicious. In order to save money the 1.5-m mirror was to be polished at an institute in one of the ESO countries. Of course, at the end of the polishing its quality had to be tested, and I was informed by the two astronomers responsible for this that this would be done not by the old outdated methods of ESO, but by marvellous new technology involving interferometers. They declared the mirror to be excellent and it was shipped to Chile. Upon installation in the telescope it was found to have images with 8 arcsecond astigmatism. B. Strömgren at Copenhagen saved the day by raising the necessary funds to bring the mirror back, to have it polished by a reputable professional company and to have it returned to La Silla, albeit with a delay of two years. Upon investigation it turned out that these highly modern testers had assumed in their method that the mirror was axisymmetric! One of them still had the nerve to show up at the next meeting of the IC with a proposal for a novel, rather special instrument for the 3.6-m telescope. Nowadays technical matters concerning large optics are generally better left to optical engineers rather than to scientists.
38
Europe’s quest for the Universe
While ESO operations in Chile were drastically reorganized, important changes also took place in Europe. The Telescope Project division at CERN in Geneva gradually switched its emphasis from work on the telescope to the realization of the instrumentation plan. This also increased the need for a stronger interaction between engineers and scientists. In 1975 a “scientific group” had been established. Its functions were to increase contacts between ESO and the scientists at the member country institutes, to allow young scientists to spend time in the ESO environment, to interact with the engineers, and to perform research especially in areas of European weakness. Very soon this group was also to play a role in data analysis and in particular in image processing which was becoming a prerequisite for the effective use of the new detectors. The first ESO image processing system, IHAP, was developed single-handedly by a young assistant, Frank Middelburg. For a decade, it was used extensively inside and outside of ESO. Following his untimely death and the appearance of a new generation of computers, a new system “MIDAS” gradually took over. A further great change in ESO’s European operation came as a result of the move to Garching. ESO’s first Director General, O. Heckmann, had been the director of the Hamburg observatory at Bergedorf. So looking for some space to start the ESO activities, he found it more or less in his own backyard. When later the telescope project was transferred to the CERN campus, the administration remained behind and the German delegation watched carefully that there would be no change in this. In fact, the Germans hinted in 1973 at an offer to provide space for the ESO headquarters, but the French were reluctant to move the larger part of ESO from Geneva. However, while Germany was paying a large share of the budgets of international scientific organizations (in ESO’s case 1/3), it had no such organizations on its territory. It already had been reluctant to approve CERN II (LEP) in Geneva. Moreover, Switzerland was not a member of ESO and taxes (albeit at a reduced rate) were levied on ESO salaries. And finally Germany was offering to pay for a Headquarters building, while none of the other countries would. At the end of 1975, an agreement was reached that ESO would retain its European headquarters in Germany. Before coming to Geneva I had expected to be able to keep ESO there on the CERN campus. With CERN excellent relations in science and technology were beginning to develop. CERN was an organization run by physicists for physicists and the intellectual environment was most stimulating. Moreover, Geneva is an ideal place for international staff families. However, after six months in office I realized that this would lead to a political disaster endangering the whole organization. So, to the surprise of the staff, I soon became an enthusiastic supporter of the move to Germany. The choice of the location within Germany was left up to me. An appropriate scientific environment was needed, and so the realistic choices were Hamburg, Bonn with the Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie and
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
39
München with in particular the MPI für Astrophysik (theoretical) and the MPI für Extraterrestrische Physik (largely space research). Both from the scientific and the environmental point of view München appeared the most suitable. The final result was that Reimar Lüst, President of the Max-PlanckGesellschaft, on behalf of the German Government made an offer to construct a 3000 m2 building in Garching to house all ESO’s European activities. After some further political hassles, the ESO Council at its meeting in December 1975 accepted the offer. To celebrate the event, the German delegation took the Council to the Munich opera where it so happened that there was a performance of Verdi’s La Forza del Destino! As ESO’s requirements were further analyzed the building grew to 7000 m2, which Germany generously agreed to finance. In September 1980 the building9) was ready for occupation (Figure II, 4) and the staff was transferred, though about one third chose to quit and remain in Geneva. This led to substantial delays in the completion of instruments. New staff had to be attracted and some lost experience regained. However, the effects of this shake up were perhaps not entirely negative. Technologically in future projects a break with the past was necessary. With the partial replacement of the staff this was much easier to achieve. There was one more important transaction with the MPG which concerned the 2.2-m telescope. In the sixties the MPI für Astronomie had been founded to operate observatories equipped with one 3.5-m and two 2.2-m telescopes for use by the whole German community. The idea had been to
Figure II, 4. The elegant ESO headquarters building in Garching near Munich designed by the architects Fehling and Gogel. Since this photograph was taken, the building has been further enlarged.
40
Europe’s quest for the Universe
place these at Calar Alto in Spain and on the Gamsberg in South West Africa (Namibia). Because of political problems with the latter site, the 3.5-m and one of the 2.2-m telescopes had been placed at Calar Alto, while the remaining 2.2-m was stored awaiting better days. However, the political situation remained unchanged and having an expensive telescope lying about unused and ageing became an embarrassment. Hence an approach from the President of the MPG to discuss the possibility of placing it at La Silla. Since the attitudes of the MPIA and ESO at the time were rather different, it seemed clear that this could only work if ESO would gain full control of the telescope and its modernization. After some difficult negotiations an agreement was reached under which ESO would receive the telescope on long term loan and have the exclusive responsibility for its upgrading and operation. In return the MPIA would receive 25% of the observing time. This provided an excellent 2.2-m telescope at La Silla, suitable for programs that did not require the 3.6-m, but for which the 1.5-m Danish was inadequate. After the telescope began to function successfully the relationship with the MPIA became smooth and cordial.
Other European 4-m Class Telescope Projects In 1961 the UK had definitely abandoned participation in ESO and decided to have a joint project with Australia for a 3.9-m telescope. The telescope was to be as much as possible a copy of the Kitt Peak (Arizona) 150-inch national US telescope. It was finally completed in 1974 and placed on the Siding Springs site near Coonabarabran (NSW) which belonged to the Australian National University. While this site was free from the light pollution that had plagued the ANU observatory at Mt. Stromlo near Canberra, it was only moderately suitable because of its low altitude. However, the excellent quality of the telescope, and especially of its computer control system, made up for this drawback, and it has been very productive. Now that the UK has joined ESO, it is expected that its participation in the AAT will diminish. The UK – later joined by the Netherlands with 20% participation – also developed major facilities on La Palma in the Canary Islands, where it now operates 4.5-m and 2.5-m telescopes. The site is excellent for optical telescopes, but was considered not optimal for the infrared. So, a 3.8-m IR telescope was also built, the UKIRT, at 4200 m on Mauna Kea (Hawaii). It is now also part of the UK – NL cooperation. Due to the high altitude atmospheric transmission is very favorable and excellent results were obtained even in the 300 μm window. Also the French were anxious to construct a national telescope. Site tests in France and southern Spain gave unsatisfactory results. So they joined (initially at 42.5%) the Canadians and the University of Hawaii in the
ESO, La Silla, the 3.6 m Telescope
41
construction of a 3.6-m telescope on Mauna Kea, a most fortunate choice. In the beginning the telescope suffered from an excess of instrumentation. This led to frequent instrument changes. Since it takes some time before a newly installed instrument functions optimally, this resulted in a significant loss of effective telescope time. After this had been corrected, the CFHT became very successful, in part because of its excellent site. Today it is equipped with a 400 Megapixel CCD camera built in Saclay (F) which allows more than one square degree of the sky to be imaged all at once with high resolution and sensitivity. Italian plans for a national telescope led to the selection of a site near Castel Grande in southern Italy. However, thereafter the project stalled. Renewed activity began when Italy joined ESO and the plan was made to model the telescope on the NTT. It took, however, till 1999 before the 3.5m Galileo Telescope became operational at La Palma, the inferior Italian site having been largely abandoned in the meantime. In Germany it had been difficult to find a suitable organisation to take charge of a major observatory. Because the universities belonged to the numerous state governments they did not have the capacity for this. Finally, the German government funded telescopes to be built by Zeiss, and the MaxPlanck-Gesellschaft founded the Institut für Astronomie in Heidelberg, which opened in 1969 and which was to operate the telescopes. Site surveys in Greece and southern Spain resulted in the selection of Calar Alto near Almeria, where there are now 3.5-m and 2.2-m telescopes, as well as some smaller ones. Unfortunately, the quality of the site is not optimal. From 2005 onwards Calar Alto will become a joint venture of the MPG and the Spanish Research Council. Adding it all up (Table II, 2), we see that Europe has some seven 4-m class telescopes at its disposal, about the same number as the U.S. A smaller European venture needs to be mentioned – the 2.5-m Nordic Optical Telescope (NOT, 1989) at La Palma. This joint venture of Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, later joined by Iceland, has been very successful because of the excellent image quality.
Europe’s quest for the Universe
42
Table II, 2. The 3.5–6 meter Astronomical Telescopes in the World.
Year
+
Country/ Diameter Organisation (m)
1949
USA
5.1+
1973
USA
4.0+
1974
UK/Australia
3.9+
1975
USA
4.0+
1976
Russia
6.0+
1976
ESO
3.6+
1978
USA
4.5+
1979
UK/NL (20%)
3.8+
1979 1985
Can/F/USA D (MPG)
3.6+ 3.5+
1987
UK/NL (20%)
4.2+
1989 1994
ESO USA
3.5+ 3.5+
1995 1999 2004
USA I USA/Brazil/Chile
3.5+ 3.5+ 4.1+
Alt Azimuth mounting.
Location Mt. Palomar, California Kitt Peak, Arizona Siding Springs, Australia Co. Tololo, Chile Zelentchuk, Caucasus Co. La Silla, Chile Mt. Hopkins, Arizona Mauna Kea, Hawaii Mauna Kea Calar Alto, Spain La Palma, Canaries Co. La Silla Apache Pt., New Mexico Kitt Peak La Palma Co. Pachon, Chile
Altitude (m)
Usual Name
1700
Hale
2100
Mayall
1100
AAT
2200
Blanco
2000 2400 2400
MMT
4200
UKIRT
4200 2200
CFHT
2400
W. Herschel
2400 2800
NTT ARC
2100 2400 2700
WIYN Galileo SOAR
III. Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
Part of the task is done and part remains. Here let us rest and moor our boat. Ovidius1)
By 1978 the 3.6-m telescope had been installed at La Silla, visiting astronomers were regularly observing there, the instrumentation plan was being executed and the ESO organization functioned smoothly. The member states contributed 32.5 MDM (32 M€ 2004 value) annually to the organization and some expected that a reduction would be possible, since the main aim had been achieved. But though the progress made was very satisfactory, there was still much in the Universe that was out of reach even with a 3.6-m telescope: galaxies at large redshifts essential to cosmology, the chemical composition of stars far away from the disk of our Galaxy and many others could be mentioned. Still larger telescopes would therefore be needed in the future to analyze problems that could be only dimly perceived with telescopes in the 3.6-m class. And while it was most satisfying that Europe now had its own large telescopes and that its scientists could begin to compete at world level, it was clear that this happy state of affairs could not last forever. If ESO did not look for future opportunities others certainly would, and European scientists would soon again be at a competitive disadvantage. The situation is very similar to that in particle physics. To create new and heavy particles or to search for rare decay modes, ever higher energies or more intense beams are needed. The result has been that accelerators have become bigger and technologically and financially more challenging. This is not a quest for bigness per se, but the unfortunate fact that the exploration of new areas tends to be ever more demanding. In exactly the same way the observation of ever fainter objects requires telescopes of increasing flux collecting power. Thus, in California the 60-inch telescope (1908) was succeeded by the 100-inch (1917) and the 200-inch (1949) telescopes. Each of these allowed major new discoveries to be made.
44
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Construction of the 200-inch telescope was followed by a period of stagnation in telescope sizes until the U.S.S.R. 6-m telescope was completed in 1976. However, its mirror was so massive that thermal equilibrium with the surrounding air could not easily be established, while its long focal length required a very large dome. Both had negative effects on the image quality. The other large telescopes constructed in the seventies and eighties all were in the 4-m class. Nevertheless, much progress was made in the detection of fainter objects. The reason was that the efficiency of detectors had increased spectacularly. The light detecting capability of a telescope is proportional to the total light collected multiplied by the fraction that is actually detected. Thus, a 10-m telescope equipped with a detector with 1% efficiency detects as much light – as many photons – as a 1-m telescope with a detector that has 100% efficiency. The photographic plates used with the 60-inch telescope probably had an efficiency of no more than 1% (and because of reciprocity failure probably even less for very faint objects). With present day CCD detectors efficiencies of up to 80% have been attained. Thus, in a global sense, the 60-inch telescope equipped with today’s CCD is equal to a 14-m telescope with the photographic plates of a century ago. Of course, this analysis is too simple-minded, and other factors have to be considered in the comparison. But it is clear that while telescope size remained more or less stationary, the effective light gathering power increased very substantially. Now that detectors have reached efficiencies close to 100%, no further progress in light gathering ability is possible without increasing the telescope size - at least when direct imaging is considered. Other reasons to increase telescope size relate to angular resolution, which we shall consider later. It was clear then that the construction of a telescope larger than the 3.6-m would be advantageous from a scientific point of view. It was also important to start considering such a possibility rather soon. Much technological development would be needed. Moreover, if there would be no new project, the ESO budget would decline; politically it is much easier, especially in an international organization, to maintain a constant budget than to have one that first goes down and then has to be increased later. And finally the Americans were not sitting still, with first ideas about telescopes of up to 25 m diameter being discussed. A large telescope does not necessarily have to be made as one unit (Figure III, 1). One can also build an array of telescopes and combine their output optically or the output of their detectors digitally. In fact, optical combination was already being implemented in the multi-mirror telescope (MMT), a set of six 1.8-m telescopes of the University of Arizona. The light gathering power was therefore nominally that of a 4.5-m telescope, though losses in the reflections of the combining mirrors made it somewhat less. At the MMT2) the six telescopes were located in a common mounting, but in principle also the light of an array of fully independent telescopes could be combined at a common focus, though the combining optics would be more
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
a
b
45
c
Figure III, 1. Three ways to build a large telescope. a – A segmented mirror composed of a number of hexagonal (or otherwise shaped) appropriately figured segments which are accurately supported so that the overall surface has the required form. The individual segments should be thick enough to be rigid, but the overall thickness to diameter ratio, and therefore the weight, remains low. b – A multimirror telescope in which a number of mirrors are placed in a common mounting and the light is combined optically. c – An array telescope in which the mirrors have separate mounts. Again, the light may be combined optically. A solution of type a has been implemented in the two 10-m Keck telescopes in the US and in the Spanish 10-m Grantecan, solution b (with only two mirrors) in the 2 × 8 m LBT (US, D, I) and solution c in the 4 × 8 m ESO VLT.
complex. Arrays of this type are required for interferometry, and at the time an array of two small telescopes had been constructed by A. Labeyrie3) in France, while large arrays of 1-2 m class telescopes were being advocated by M. Disney4) in the UK. So what could be the next ESO telescope project? It seemed to me that it should represent a large step compared to what had been done before; it was no longer a question of catching up with the rest of the world, but of taking the lead. Otherwise it would be difficult to obtain the necessary support. A 16-m telescope might be within reach or, more probably, an array of telescopes with a total collecting area equal to that of a 16-m. The reasoning was simple. ESO had built a very complex 3.6-m telescope at a cost of some 68 MDM or 78 M€ (2004 value). With an alt-azimuth mounting, a very simple building, no exchangeable parts and a highly simplified coudé focus, a cost of 20–30 MDM would appear not unreasonable, and newer technology might well allow the lower figure. In the preceding decade, the European countries had invested in total more than 200 MDM in large telescope projects. Hence, with a comparable investment in a large ESO project some ten 3.6-m telescopes could be acquired. But if one constructs a large number of identical objects, the unit price goes down. With 10 identical objects the cost might be about halved. So then some twenty 3.6-m telescopes could be financed, corresponding to the area of a 16-m telescope. This estimate
46
Europe’s quest for the Universe
neglected the problems associated with the combination of the light from the telescopes and the cost of the instrumentation. But it showed that it was not an excessively ambitious aim to build a 16-m equivalent telescope. I made the first proposal to do so at the ESO conference “Optical Telescopes of the Future” held in Geneva, December 19775). At this conference many interesting ideas were presented which also helped to further crystallize our own. Of course, the model of twenty 3.6-m telescopes was not a particularly attractive option, but it could easily be costed. A more ambitious project with larger unit telescopes was called for, but needed more analysis. At the time I listed just five illustrative examples of what such a telescope would do. They were the following: 1. Abundances of elements in globular cluster stars. Composition variations were believed to be due to differences in the elemental abundances of the gaseous medium from which such stars formed, but since only evolved stars could be observed effects of stellar evolution could also play a role. But adequate analysis of unevolved stars was hardly possible because they were too faint for 4-m class telescopes. Actually the VLT has been used extensively to study the abundances of cluster and halo stars. 2. The motion of globular clusters in other galaxies informs us about their masses and about their “dark matter” content. 3. Cosmological studies involving faint galaxies and quasars would be of much importance. While the faintest objects might best be detected with the Hubble Space Telescope, more detailed spectroscopy of somewhat brighter objects would be the domain of the 16-m telescope. This complementarity has been very much in evidence with the VLT. 4. Correlative optical studies of radio and X-ray sources. In fact, extremely faint counterparts to X-ray sources have been found at the limit of what the VLT can observe. 5. High time resolution photometry of X-ray sources. Today one would have replaced this by observations of remote supernovae to determine the structure of the Universe. Of course, many other topics could have been listed, in particular also in the infrared. To me it seemed highly premature to go in one step to a 16-m telescope. ESO had constructed a moderately satisfactory 3.6-m. The USSR 6-m telescope was the largest in the world. It was a heavy monster. Just scaling up these telescopes to 16-m was not going to work. The step to 16 m was too large. If something would go wrong, the loss would be total. On the other hand, the optical combination of a large number of small telescopes would lead to important light losses, which could defeat the aim of efficient photon collection. And if all of these would be individually instrumented, the cost of the instruments might become a large part of the total. While such an array might yield high angular resolution on bright objects when used in an interferometric mode, for the imaging of very faint objects it would be far from
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
47
optimal. With galaxies and quasars at large redshifts and distant halo stars looming as the dominant scientific topics of the future, this was an essential point. In a very general way an array of 8-m telescopes would have several advantages. Each of these would represent a significant advance in telescope technology and scientific capability compared to the 3.6-m telescope. With such an array one would have the choice to use the 8-m telescopes, when required, as an array, but they could also be used as four large telescopes for different projects and perhaps also be instrumented differently. This argument was slightly delicate, since if the integrated array concept were too much deemphasized very soon funding for only one telescope of 8 m would be obtainable. And if the array concept would turn out to be successful, additional possibilities would open up – like interferometry. Immediately after the conference I asked our technical staff to make a first study of three options: one 16-m telescope and arrays of four 8-m and sixteen 4-m telescopes. All three would have the same collecting area. With this specification I had little doubt that the result would be that one would see the disadvantages of the two extremes and therefore settle on the intermediate solution. In fact, the solution with 4-m telescopes did not find much favor with anyone. It would require complex and expensive combining optics if the telescopes would be coupled optically and a large amount of instrumentation if each telescope would be instrumented separately and the outputs combined electronically. For the infrared larger unit telescopes would have significant advantages. Some in the infrared community favored one 16-m as this could have an advantage in angular resolution, but there was no unanimity about this. There was also the suggestion to place the 16m telescope on a very high site with low atmospheric water vapor which absorbs IR radiation and, because of the physiological problems associated with this, to have it operated by technicians rather than by astronomers. Apparently some engineers did not think much of the endurance of their astronomical brethren! All these studies had been done with an inadequate level of effort, since most of the staff was very busy with work on the 3.6-m and CAT telescopes and their instrumentation. Moreover, ESO’s departure from Geneva was approaching, part of the engineering staff were looking for alternative employment, and replacements still had to be found. Not surprisingly, there were quite a few astronomers who had other ideas of what to do when money would become available. This made it dangerous to push the project too much before proper technical studies had been made. So, on the one hand, it was important to keep the project alive so that it became part of the astronomical consciousness in Europe, but, on the other hand, not to stress it too much and too prematurely so that not too much opposition would arise. The opportunity to build the New Technology Telescope with the entry fees of two new member countries facilitated this and allowed the required technologies to be developed.
48
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Italy and Switzerland In 1980 ESO’s horizons were suddenly enlarged and wonderful opportunities to push telescope development arose. For some years discussions had been taking place with Italy and Switzerland concerning eventual membership in ESO. The great majority of Swiss astronomers had been interested in joining ESO. The Geneva Observatory had obtained permission to place a 40cm photometric telescope at La Silla, and its director Marcel Golay pushed very hard for membership. From ESO’s side it had been noted that the agreement to place that telescope at La Silla was made in the anticipation that full membership would follow. Also in Basel much support was given. However, the well known solar astronomer M. Waldmeier in Zurich was strongly opposed and held up the matter for a long time. So the Swiss authorities turned down the proposal. When it became clear that Italy was going to join, it was evident that ESO would be the European organization in astronomy and the Swiss proposal was successfully revived. According to the convention, new member countries would have to pay an “entrance fee” for their share in the investments made by the other countries. The negotiation about the sum to be paid was essentially political, but had to be justified in terms of the assets of the organization and the depreciation thereof. A sum of DM 6,000,000 was asked for, which was not quite acceptable for the Swiss. Finally, I proposed a compromise on the basis of CHF 5,000,000, which at the time was some 10% less than the DM amount, but by the time it was paid in 1982 was actually slightly more. The negotiations with Italy had been going on for some years, pushed forward by Franco Pacini and Giancarlo Setti. Between the two of them they covered the most essential parts of the Italian political spectrum in parliament. The frequent changes in government had made it difficult to progress; in fact, some five subsequent ministers or state secretaries had been involved! The decisive push came when Consigliere U. Vattani, at the time the Chef de Cabinet of Research Minister Scalia, took a personal interest in the matter. A final negotiation took place in Taormina where after some discussion our positions were still rather far apart concerning the entrance fee. When Minister Scalia arrived and was informed of the situation, he said: “My region (Sicily) may be a poor region, but when we arrive at such a situation, we usually divide the difference in two” – and so it was done, somewhat to the distress of Cons. Vattani who believed that ESO ultimately would have been satisfied with less. An interesting aspect was that 3 MDM in money would be replaced, if technically feasible, by a slice of the 3.5-m disk of fused silica that the Italians had acquired earlier for their national project. Since ESO was now planning to build a thin mirror telescope and the Italians a copy of this, in principle it seemed possible to slice that disk in two. After the agreement had been reached, some speeches were held at dinner, and it turned out that the
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
49
political people believed that the disk would be cut into two half circular pieces! Later it appeared that the distribution of bubbles in the disk made the slicing impossible. However, by that time the political negotiations had produced a result that was irreversible, and this did not create further problems. In Italy it may take many years to obtain parliamentary ratification of international agreements. However, Consigliere Vattani, by that time chef de cabinet of the prime minister, succeeded to place it on a fast track. By 1981 Italy was a de facto member and the year thereafter all formalities had been completed. Also in 1982 the Swiss parliament ratified the ESO Convention, although some deputies complained that ESO membership was funded, while a proposal for support of the Rhaeto-Romanic language was not. According to the ESO Convention (article VII; 4), the entrance fees paid by new member states should be used to reduce the contributions of the other member states, unless the Council would unanimously decide otherwise. Observing time was already in short supply, and with an increase of the user community by some 35%, the situation would become untenable. Council therefore readily agreed to my proposal to use the entrance fees to build a simple 3.5-m New Technology Telescope (NTT) to improve the situation. In 1982 the budget for this was set at 24 MDM. Upon completion of the NTT, a surplus of 3.4 MDM remained, which could be used to instrument the telescope. So the cost of the NTT amounted to 21 MDM or some 18 M€ (2004 value). If we include the uncertain in-house personnel costs, the total becomes 25 M€ (2004), or only 32% of the cost of the 3.6-m telescope, a remarkable progress in some 13 years. The annual contribution of the ESO member countries had remained fixed from 1976-1981 at 32.5 MDM. By 1982 this constant level would have represented a loss of 31% in real terms. The adhesion of the new countries made it possible to remedy the situation in a painless way. The contribution level in 1982 was raised to 40 MDM. Through partial inflation correction it became 49.5 MDM (equivalent to 38 M€, 2004 value) six years later. A rapid increase followed to pay for the VLT and thereafter for ALMA. In 2004 it amounted to 100 M€. While the new member countries were important in increasing the financial resources of ESO and allowing a new telescope project to be started, perhaps the most significant aspect was that it provided a new political legitimacy to ESO as the organization for astronomy in Europe. If new countries bothered to join, the organization must have a certain importance, and a whole new dynamics arose which gave it the necessary momentum and confidence to later start the VLT project. However, at the time that the NTT was decided, Council considerably watered down the resolution I had proposed in which the NTT was stated to be the prototype of the VLT. Anything that looked like a commitment to the VLT was still far off.
50
Europe’s quest for the Universe
The NTT When in 1980 it seemed that Italy and Switzerland would join ESO, it was essential to have a telescope project ready to have a specific destination for the entrance fees. While this did not have to be a fully developed design, it should at least give a believable cost estimate. Since the available time at the 3.6-m telescope would now be shared with an enlarged community, it should also be realizable quickly so as to enlarge the pool of observing time. With a slice of the Italian mirror being part of the deal, the diameter was fixed at 3.5 m. And even though officially there was no connection to the VLT, the new telescope should serve as a demonstration of various technologies which later could make the case for that project more convincing and show that it could be constructed at an acceptable cost. Thus, cost and speed became the dominant design criteria for the NTT. The 3.6-m telescope had had a high cost because it was mechanically awkward with its polar mount and multiple focus options based on exchangeable top units, because it was heavy and because it was enclosed in a very large building, which accounted for some 40% of the total cost. The building was 30 m in diameter. It was 30 m high, with a 30 m diameter dome on top, because it had been believed that the atmospheric turbulence would be reduced far above the ground. However, it was beginning to be clear that the large volume of the telescope enclosure did much harm with turbulence created by warm areas in the building degrading observing conditions. At Las Campanas, 50 km from La Silla, the Carnegie Institution had built a 2.5-m telescope and because of its limited budget it had been placed in a low building. No harmful effects were in evidence. So to bring down the cost of the NTT, the general guidelines were simplicity, weight reduction and a small building volume. More specifically the following items were considered important6): (1) The NTT would have an alt-azimuth mounting. The more straightforward mechanical structure would weigh less and have lower cost. (2) The alt-azimuth design provides, rather naturally, two Nasmyth foci where heavy instruments may be placed on platforms rotating with the telescope (Figure III, 2). The light is deflected by a flat mirror at an angle of 45˚ with respect to the optical axis (Figure II, 1). To go from one Nasmyth focus to the other the mirror must be turned by 180°, a relatively simple operation. As a result, one may switch very rapidly from an instrument at one focus to another at the other focus. This makes instrument changes very much less cumbersome than at the Cassegrain focus of the 3.6-m, where one instrument has to be removed to make place for another, which in practice cannot be done during the night. It is also considerably more efficient than the complicated coudé setup which has additional reflections in most versions and a small field of view. The Nasmyth flat mirror takes away some 15% of the light, and so there
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
51
Figure III, 2. Model of the NTT. The telescope rotates around a vertical axis (the azimuth axis) on a large bearing; the telescope tube can rotate from horizontal to vertical on the elevation axis. The housing of the direct drive motors is visible on this axis. The light of a celestial object first falls on the 3.5-m mirror at the bottom of the tube, returns to the secondary at the upper end and then is directed by the third, flat, Nasmyth mirror sideways through the elevation axis to either the left or the right Nasmyth focus where instrumentation may be placed. In this model, the Nasmyth platforms have not yet been mounted. The black baffle shields the Nasmyth mirror from stray light.
were some wishes to also have a Cassegrain focus. However, this would have required a mechanism to take the flat mirror out of the optical path and a prolongation of the fork to accommodate instrumentation. This would have added a significant cost to which I could not agree. (3) The length of the telescope tube is largely determined by the focal length of the primary mirror. A low focal ratio (focal length / mirror diameter) allows a short tube. This reduces the size of the enclosure housing the telescope. However, a mirror of low focal ratio (usually called a “fast” mirror) was more expensive to manufacture , and in general the optical tolerances are tighter if the mirror is very fast. From such considerations an optimal focal ratio 27% smaller than that for the 3.6-m was adopted.
52
Europe’s quest for the Universe
As a result of this and of the compact alt-az design, the mean diameter of the enclosure was 19 m, instead of 30 m for the 3.6-m telescope. (4) The height of the building would be much smaller than in the case of the 3.6-m telescope (Figure III, 3). The top of the dome of the latter was more than 40 m above the ground. The highest point of the enclosure of the NTT was only at 17 m, and its total volume only one fifth of that for the 3.6 m. (5) Since the telescope rotates around the azimuth axis, all connections between it and a stationary building (cables, pipes, etc.) have to be made in a rather special way. At the MMT of the University of Arizona it had therefore been decided to let the building rotate with the telescope, and this same solution was adopted for the NTT. This had another major advantage. Since with respect to the building the telescope moved only in elevation, walls could be placed on either side. This allowed all heat sources to be away from the telescope and thereby to eliminate much of the dome turbulence that had plagued the 3.6-m. In addition, no classical dome was needed and the telescope enclosure could be designed in a more cost effective way. (6) The telescope drive also would contain a major innovation – the use of large torque motors. Keeping a telescope pointed to the same point in the sky to within a fraction of an arcsecond requires a very finely tuned drive system. This had generally been achieved in large telescopes by a set of gears which diminished the requirements on the precision of the motors by a substantial factor. However, in the meantime, very large torque motors had been manufactured in the USA, which could be directly
Figure III, 3. The relative sizes of the enclosures of the 3.6-m (black), the VLT 8.2-m unit telescope (green) and the 3.5-m NTT (red). Since the latter two are not circularly symmetric, they would have somewhat different shapes when seen from different directions.
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
53
mounted on the telescope axes. In fact, at the 1.4-m CAT such motors were already in use and functioned well. However, much bigger motors were required to steer the larger mass of a 3.5-m telescope. The great advantage is that the backlash in the gears is eliminated and the overall control system is simplified. 7) The greatest innovation would be the use of active optics, pioneered by Ray Wilson at ESO7). In conventional telescopes mirror deformations under the changing orientation of gravitational forces had been minimized by making the mirror thick – typically with thickness / diameter about equal to 1/6. Such a mirror is heavy – of the order of 10 tons for a 3.5-m mirror. But even a thick, heavy, stiff mirror will experience serious deformations due to gravity when the telescope moves. The mirror is therefore placed in a “mirror cell” in which it is supported by an appropriate set of levers that should compensate the varying gravitational forces. If the mirror is thick enough a rather simple setup is sufficient. For large telescopes the weight of a thick mirror becomes prohibitive, and other solutions are needed. Active optics holds the key. If a mirror is deformed from its perfect shape, the image of a star becomes distorted too. With an “image analyzer” the nature of the deformation may be ascertained. By exerting appropriate forces on the mirror the deformation may be removed and the image quality restored (Figure III, 4).
Figure III, 4. Active Optics. The light of a star is reflected first by the primary mirror supported by a large number of motorized levers which determine its shape. Subsequently, it is reflected by the secondary mirror, the position of which can also be adjusted by motors, and finally brought to the focus by a third, flat, mirror. Some of the light is analyzed by a wavefront sensor coupled to a computer which determines the corrections to be made to the shape of the primary and the position of the secondary for optimal imaging and which sends the appropriate instructions to the motors.
54
Europe’s quest for the Universe
The image analyzer may, for example, be based on a “Hartmann screen”, a screen with a regular array of holes placed in the parallel beam or closer to the focal plane. When a photographic plate is placed some distance from the focal plane, a set of spots is seen. If the mirror is distorted by large scale deformations, the positional pattern of the spots is also deformed. When the photographic plate is replaced by a solid state detector (CCD) with the readout directly fed into the computer, the spot positions may be determined on line. The mirror is supported by motorized levers or pistons that exert forces on the mirror (Figure III, 5). After having calibrated the relation between the magnitudes of these forces and the deformations of the mirror, it becomes a simple matter to have the computer translate its knowledge of the deformation of the mirror into instructions to the motors so that the required forces are applied to undo the deformation.
Figure III, 5. Support system for a 1-m mirror active optics experiment at ESO. Each support is adjusted by a motor which in turn is computer controlled. The instructions of the computer are based on the measurements of the wavefront sensor which determines the corrections needed to the shape of the mirror to compensate for its deformations.
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
55
To control the 3.5 m diameter mirror of the NTT 78 axial levers are required (Figure III, 6) and for the 8.2 m VLT mirrors 150, but enough computing power is nowadays available to control these appropriately. In the same way also the position of the secondary mirror in a Cassegrain system may be controlled. Since a sufficiently bright reference star may not be available near to the object, in practice the active optics measurements are made only from time to time and the levers adjusted in between by extrapolation based on previous experience. Active optics also relaxes the specifications for mirror polishing and thereby may reduce cost and allow the correction of errors. A thick mirror has to be polished to high specifications to avoid image deformation. With a thin actively controlled mirror errors in shape can be partly corrected. The problems of the Hubble Space Telescope (wrong focus of the primary) could have been corrected remotely if it had had an active optics system. Of course, small scale roughness cannot be corrected. With a system of levers only errors on at least the scale of the separation between levers can be dealt with.
Figure III, 6. The main mirror cell of the NTT. The 78 actuators are placed in four rings. Above the mirror cell is the main massive support structure between the two wheels that steer the telescope in elevation. The support structure for the secondary mirror is partially visible at the top.
56
Europe’s quest for the Universe
With active optics the primary mirror could be thin. If the mirror weight is smaller, the telescope tube can also be less heavy, and finally the whole telescope will have less weight and thereby less cost. The concept seemed very promising, but it had not yet been tried in a real telescope. I therefore concluded that one should not go to the extremely thin mirror that this technology allowed, but keep the mirror thick enough that even with the classical support systems acceptable images would be obtainable. After all, it would be a disaster for the prospects of the VLT if the NTT would not function correctly within a reasonable time. At the same time, the 3.5-m mirror should be thin enough to test the active optics scheme. The aspect ratio (thickness/diameter) was finally set at 1:15 to be compared with 1:6 for the 3.6-m telescope. As a result, the weight was only 40% of that of the latter. A very preliminary mechanical design by Wolfgang Richter, based on an altazimuth mounting, sufficed to estimate its cost. As soon as the Italian and Swiss parliaments had ratified the ESO Convention, a small NTT project group was set up at ESO. Initially it was headed by Ray Wilson who had developed the active optics concepts. However, he did not find project management very congenial and at his request was succeeded by Massimo Tarenghi who later also would successfully manage the VLT. This led to a tight management which, though essential for the project, did not please everyone. Evidently during the conceptual phase it is best to “let a thousand flowers bloom”, but once contracts have been concluded, changes should be infrequent and deadlines should be met. If not, the cost rapidly escalates. While ESO had made the conceptual design, a detailed design as the basis for a construction tender had to be done and after the move from Geneva ESO’s manpower was inadequate to do this in-house. A tender was given out and several offers were received; included were a very satisfactory offer by Krupp-MAN that was selected, and a technically totally inadequate offer from a firm in another country at only 40% of the price. This led to some political upheaval, and it took much effort to have the contract approved by the ESO Finance Committee. While price is a relatively simple criterion to compare contracts, quality is necessarily more ambiguous. Another problem was how to acquire a disk for the mirror. It had been found that the idea of slicing the Italian disk, which had played a very useful role in the political discussions, was not feasible. Initial contacts with Schott, the maker of Zerodur, did not yield a satisfactory price. So it was decided to talk in Moscow about a possible disk in astrosital, another low expansion material. The concern here was that this would have too much internal tension since it was to be cut out of pieces of a cracked 6-m disk. Discussions took place on how to test such a disk in East Germany, since gaining full access to the factory in Moscow proved difficult. I had expected that Schott would not wish to have competition from astrosital in western markets. In fact, rather soon a much more satisfactory offer for a Zerodur disk was made by Schott and accepted by ESO.
Origin of the VLT Project; The NTT
57
Some ideas had also been developed about mirrors in aluminum or steel, and some experimental studies were being performed at ESO. These experiments were continued for some time in case problems would be encountered with the acquisition of mirror blanks for the VLT, but for the NTT it seemed preferable to stay with the proven Zerodur. Though this was disappointing to the optical engineers who looked forward to an interesting innovative mirror experiment, the approach of the VLT decision necessitated the most rapid completion of a system that was guaranteed to work. In 1986 the Zerodur disk was delivered and sent to Zeiss for polishing. By mid-1988 the polishing had been completed and a test of the complete active optics system was made, which showed the high quality of the mirror and the successful implementation of the active optics concept. Later that year the mirror joined the mechanics (Figure III, 7a) and enclosure erected at La Silla (Figure III, 7b).
Figure III, 7a (left). The NTT. Below the floor is the azimuth bearing and the base of the fork-like structure. Behind the walls on the sides are the Nasmyth platforms. So the telescope is shielded from most sources of heat which could cause turbulence in the air in or above the tube of the telescope and degrade the image quality. In the upper ring is the support structure for the secondary mirror whose position is computer controlled. In the square structure is the support for the Nasmyth mirror which can send the light to the left or to the right through the elevation axis. Below this the primary mirror and its support structure are seen. Figure III, 7b (right). The enclosure of the NTT. The telescope rotates in azimuth on a high precision hydrostatic bearing, while the enclosure rotates along on a simpler 7m roller bearing. The metallic structure of the enclosure is of much lower cost than a conventional building plus dome.
58
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Finally, on the night of 22 March 1989 the first direct CCD images were taken; by luck that night also the atmospheric turbulence was low and the images were probably the best ever taken by a ground-based telescope. The successful completion of the NTT showed that ESO now had the engineering competence for innovation in telescope technology. While the 3.6 m telescope had been one of the last of the previous generation of large telescopes, the NTT was the first of a new generation of telescopes based on active optics, new control concepts and rationally designed enclosures which suppressed dome seeing. The success of the NTT gave the ESO countries the confidence that the VLT had become a realizable dream. One last question remained to be settled when the telescope mechanics were shipped to Chile. Where should the NTT be placed? By 1986 the excellent qualities of the Paranal site had become clear, though the site testing was far from terminated. While the Paranal peak itself had been reserved for the VLT, there was a small hill somewhat lower and usually upwind from Paranal that would provide an excellent place. Some tests were made there which indicated that the quality of what became to be known as “NTT hill” could be expected to be excellent. While I was very much tempted to place the NTT there, the total absence of any infrastructure at Paranal would be difficult. Since the NTT was a highly innovative telescope, it was not excluded that there would be problems that would be much easier to solve at La Silla. The risk was too great, and serious problems with the NTT would have endangered the VLT. So, the NTT was placed at La Silla. If the NTT had been in the Paranal area, subsequent considerations about the future of La Silla and its relation to Paranal might have been much simplified.
IV. Technological, Financial and Scientific Planning of the VLT
Ein bis dahin unbekannter, beinahe politisch zu nennender Gemeingeist hat eine Organisation entwickelt, die auf ein wissenschaftlich ganz neues Niveau hinstrebt. Otto Heckmann1)
On 1 September 1980 ESO’s scientific-technical establishments moved from CERN, Geneva, to Garching near Munich. Nearly half of the technical staff did not follow ESO and so their personal priorities became rather different from those of ESO. Moreover, the staff who moved to Garching had to get settled there, contribute to the recruitment of new staff and introduce the newcomers to the various projects. As a result, the move delayed ESO’s projects by a year. By the time the new ESO establishment was inaugurated on 5 May 1981 by the President of the Federal Republic of Germany, most of the scars from the rupture had been removed and the organization again began to function normally. There were at that time still several major instrumental projects for the 3.6-m telescope at La Silla which had to be completed urgently if that telescope were to be competitive. As a consequence, the technical staff hardly could devote much time to projects for the more distant future, including the VLT. Moreover, the development of the NTT already stressed the available manpower. Still advances could be made by involving a number of scientists from the ESO countries in discussions of some critical issues. I therefore set up a “VLT Study Group” under the chairmanship of Jean Pierre Swings of Liège, with a core membership of about a dozen scientists and engineers2) and with additional contributions by a number of interested persons. About twenty meetings of the Study Group took place. This led to a workshop with 46 participants, two thirds from institutes in the ESO countries and the others
60
Europe’s quest for the Universe
from ESO, held in Cargèse, Corsica, 16-19 May 19832). Among the conclusions reached there were a reaffirmation of the 16-m equivalent diameter, a strong inclination towards an array of three or four telescopes with monolithic mirrors, and a lukewarm emphasis on interferometry with the large telescopes. The latter resulted from studies by Pierre Léna3) and François Roddier4) which indicated that the gain in limiting magnitude with larger telescopes was rather small due to the effects of the earth’s atmosphere. For interferometry more numerous smaller movable telescopes seemed preferable to the large fixed ones. This created a dangerous situation from the political point of view. In particular for the French, interferometry was a high priority. And it could easily be argued that four eight meter telescopes would be very nice, but that with three one could do already a great deal and then the cost reduction could be used to build an interferometric array of smaller telescopes. Of course, the three 8-m telescopes could easily become two and then one at even greater savings. I had always considered interferometry an interesting option for the VLT, but without much confidence in its early realization. True enough, one had already measured the diameters of some bright stars by interferometric methods; but until one would be able to make images and to reach faint objects, the scientific benefits seemed insufficient. The solution to the problem was to add two (now four) small mobile telescopes to the VLT. If more efficient ways to do interferometry with the large telescopes could be developed, then perhaps an integration of the whole setup would become worthwhile. Another reason to combine the VLT and the small telescope interferometry was that for a project of the financial size of the VLT it would pay to look for the world’s best site. Since interferometry was extremely sensitive to the “seeing” quality of a site, placing it at the best possible site was imperative. Thus, the proposal became to enlarge the VLT project of four 8-m telescopes by including some mobile 1.5-m (finally 1.8-m) auxiliary interferometric telescopes. This combination now looks optimal, indeed. A start has been made with a modest interferometric program, and the large telescopes have been successfully combined in some experiments. With the successful implementation of adaptive optics in the individual telescopes, the interferometric option now looks more promising. By the end of the Cargèse meeting a large part of the European community had become convinced that an array of something like 3–4 telescopes in the 8–10-m class was what was needed for the future. So in May 1983 a qualitative consensus on the scientific rationale and on the technological philosophy of the VLT was largely in place. Now it became necessary to convert these vague ideas into a project with a clear architecture and cost. While the Swings study group had done an admirable job in shaping an idea that enjoyed wide support in the community, this next phase clearly needed a much stronger engineering input. This could not be done on the basis of
Technological, Financial and Scientific Planning of the VLT
61
the part-time involvement of a few people. A full time VLT project group was needed which was soon set up, headed by Daniel Enard, with initially five full time persons, but also support from other parts of ESO. Since the VLT would become a major industrial project, this group needed a dedicated budget with which to award study contracts to industry to explore technical feasibility and cost. Furthermore, to continue the close connection with institutes in the ESO countries and to supplement the activities of the project group, a VLT Advisory Committee was set up with five working groups: Site Selection, High Resolution Spectroscopy, Low Resolution Spectroscopy, Infrared Aspects and Interferometry, in which 32 outside scientists participated, again under the overall chairmanship of Swings. Very early in the VLT studies it had appeared that while there would be many problems in mechanics and controls, the critical item, both technically and financially, would be the acquisition and polishing of the 8-m mirrors. The only European manufacturer of suitable mirror material was Schott in Mainz, which had developed “Zerodur”. This is a glass ceramic of excellent uniformity and polishability with a very low thermal expansion coefficient. So a mirror of Zerodur does not change its focal length when the temperature of the telescope changes. This is archieved by having on the microscopic scale a mixture of glass with a positive expansion coefficient and crystalline material with a negative one. At the appropriate temperature (⬃ 800 – 1000 °C) the glass slowly crystallizes; in the case of the 8-m mirrors the right balance would be obtained after about eight months. First, however, the glass disk has to have more or less the right shape. While for smaller mirrors, like the 3.5-m for the NTT, this may be achieved by machining away the necessary material, for large thin mirrors this would be very uneconomic. Hence, Schott proposed to use spin casting which they had previously used in other contexts. The molten material would be poured into a form having the shape of part of a sphere. When this form would be rotated, the centrifugal forces would give the upper surface also a concave shape. Upon cooling this shape would remain and thereafter the ceramization process would be started. So by the time the VLT proposal was written, the way to an 8-m blank was technologically clear. However, the existing facilities at Schott were inadequate and a new factory building would have to be constructed, which would add to the cost. Some informal discussions about a possible contract had taken place before the approval of the project, but neither the technical nor the financial viability had been unambiguously established. It was therefore necessary to study other possibilities in case unforeseen technological problems would arise and also to maintain a competitive pressure on the price. One alternative was to use fused silica. In fact, procedures had been developed by Corning in the USA for fusing silica pieces together, and this technology had no apparent size limits. A radically different possibility was to use metal mirrors5). These had been extensively used in the nineteenth century but abandoned because of
62
Europe’s quest for the Universe
the high thermal expansion and also problems with polishing and corrosion. An attempt at resurrecting aluminum mirrors had been made in the sixties, but had been unsatisfactory because of warping at the edges. However, this problem may have been more a consequence of the thin rimmed vase-like shape given to these mirrors than of the use of aluminum per se. Since the thermal expansion problem did not seem prohibitive if active optics were implemented, it seemed worthwhile to start a program of studies of metal mirrors. Actually the high thermal conductivity of metals might be an advantage in allowing a fast control of the temperature of the mirror to prevent turbulence in the air in the telescope tube above it. Aluminum had many attractive properties, but the drawback that it could not be polished. Thus, it had to be coated with a layer of harder material – actually canegen, a nickel alloy. The long term stability at the interface of the two materials was a source of concern. It therefore seemed attractive to look at harder metals that could be produced in large disks, and here steel offered itself as a low cost possibility. Among the specialty steels polishable materials could be found. Some steel disks were fabricated and initial tests were satisfactory (Figure IV, 1). Since the steel mirror tests involved only 50 cm disks, a substantial development program would still be needed for the metal option. The long term characteristics of the metal mirrors remained uncertain, while much experience existed with Zerodur. So it was decided to go for Zerodur in the VLT project plan, although for some time the metal option was kept alive, just in case.
Figure IV, 1. A 50-cm experimental steel mirror. At a time when it was uncertain that affordable Zerodur 8-m mirrors could be made, experiments were started at ESO with steel and aluminum mirrors.
Technological, Financial and Scientific Planning of the VLT
63
The metal development phase was concluded in 1990 with the successful fabrication and testing of two 1.8-m aluminum mirrors which were subjected to stringent thermal cycling, showing a good long term stability. By that time, however, a contract had been concluded with Schott which was completing the construction of a new facility for casting 8-m Zerodur disks. Since ESO had its hands full with the execution of the VLT project, it was not possible to invest further effort in more long term technological mirror developments. However, now that new, larger telescope projects are beginning to be discussed, it might well be worthwhile for technological institutes or universities to further study metal mirrors. Another important issue concerned the polishing of the mirrors for which a major new industrial facility would have to be constructed. This would include not only a computer controlled polishing machine, but also a tower of substantial height to house the necessary optics to test the mirrors. The tower was to be evacuated of the atmospheric air or perhaps to be filled with helium so as to avoid problems with variations in temperature with attendant optical refraction. This was particularly important because of the unusually tight tolerance imposed on the optics –80% of the light within a circle of 0.15 arcsecond diameter, almost a factor of three better than the specification of the 3.6-m telescope. While in the past the atmosphere had in practice limited image diameters to 0.5 arcsecond or more, speckle interferometry (the effective superposition of short exposures to reduce the effects of atmospheric turbulence) could do better, and the realization of the dream of compensation for atmospheric effects by adaptive optics was beginning to be clearly visible on the horizon. Two study contracts were given to Zeiss in Germany and to REOSC in France, the two companies in Europe with experience in the polishing of 4-m class mirrors. The results of these studies confirmed that the polishing of thin 8-m mirrors would be feasible and that the cost might be manageable within the VLT budget. Such thin mirrors are very delicate and have to be handled with care to avoid breakage. For example, lifting a thin mirror with only support at the edges would lead to a catastrophe. Another issue concerned transport, which would mainly occur over waterways. So the possibility for transport from the factory to the nearest waterway was studied. It was found that for an 8-m mirror there would be no problems, but for a 10-m serious difficulties would occur. After all it would not be very good to get stuck under a bridge! The issue of the mirrors is important for the technical aspects and the cost of the whole project. If the mirrors are heavy, the metal tube of the telescope has to become stronger and heavier and this weight increase propagates through the whole structure which has to be supported by more powerful bearings. Thus, the thinner the mirror the better. However, there are limits if the mirror is not to become too fragile and also because of the fabrication process. It is simplest to figure a mirror with a relatively long focal
64
Europe’s quest for the Universe
length. But if the focal length is long, the secondary has to be far away from the primary mirror, the telescope tube becomes long and heavy, etc. Also, the longer the telescope tube the larger the enclosure has to be, and this again augments the cost. The determination of the optimum characteristics of the mirrors to obtain the lowest cost is therefore a complex process. Finally a focal length 1.8 times the mirror diameter was chosen. Another issue was the housing of the telescopes. In the case of the 3.6-m telescope dome and building had accounted for nearly 40% of the total cost, which for the NTT had been brought down to 20%. The much reduced building cost would be accompanied by a significant improvement of telescope performance, since “dome seeing” associated with thermal disequilibrium of the air in the dome was much reduced. The question then was whether further improvements and cost reductions would be possible by operating the telescope in open air and having a simple housing to protect it during the day time or in bad weather. In this spirit a solution was explored where the four telescopes would be placed on a straight line, with during the night only a wind screen and during the day an inflatable dome as protection6). Such inflatable structures had been used in various places in the world to protect radar dishes. A 15-m diameter inflatable dome was ordered and placed at La Silla for experimental purposes. Of course, these inflatable domes were more complex than those for radar domes, since they should be opened every night. A model of the VLT (Figure IV, 2) with the inflatables was made and extensively used for familiarizing the scientific community and governmental representatives with the VLT. Since this created the image de marque of the VLT, it seemed dangerous to change it before the project was approved. However, in the “VLT Proposal” it was made clear that this was “only the presently nominal solution within a general concept”. Perhaps not surprisingly wind tunnel experiments later showed that cylindrical structures with a natural but controlled air flow were superior to the open air operation, especially when the wind was relatively strong. Also the linear telescope array seemed non optimal for interferometry, and the four telescopes were finally placed in independent enclosures in a somewhat different configuration. The mirror disks, the polishing and the enclosures together were estimated to account for half of the telescope cost. At the same time they created most of the uncertainty. There were, of course, many other issues of importance to be considered. The mechanical structure (Figure IV, 3) had to be optimized to avoid vibrations, the design of the active optics system and the mirror cells had to be refined and scaled up from the NTT design and the control system had to be upgraded with newer computers. In the early developments the software aspects took second place, but in order to obtain a working telescope a major software effort would be needed. All of this was essential for the functioning of the VLT, but one had enough knowledge to see how this could be done and to determine the cost with some confidence.
Technological, Financial and Scientific Planning of the VLT
65
Figure IV, 2. The first VLT model. The four 8-m telescopes were placed on a common platform in inflatable shelters. Observations would be made in open air, and to reduce the effects of wind, a screen would be mounted on the side of the prevailing wind. At the bottom of the telescopes the pipes are visible that would bring the light beams from the unit telescopes to the interferometric laboratory in the middle to the left. The linear arrangement was not optimal for interferometry, and there was concern about turbulence created by the wind screen. So later the telescopes were placed individually in protective enclosures.
A difficult issue arose with the secondary mirror. Since in the infrared beyond two microns there is strong background radiation due to the atmosphere and the telescope, it is essential to continuously monitor the background when measuring the flux from a weak source. The optimal way to do this is to wobble the secondary – to move it back and forth between two positions as frequently as possible – and then to measure the difference signal between the source position and the background reference position. But in an 8-m telescope the secondary mirror is a large (1.2 m), massive object and to move this back and forth some ten times a second is no small matter. It is therefore important to reduce the weight of the secondary as much as possible.
66
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure IV, 3. Early model of an 8-m unit telescope. The support structure for the elevation axis is placed on the large circular azimuth bearing. The two yellow boxes contain instruments with the light entering through the elevation axis. The light beam to the coudé focus and to the interferometric laboratory passes through the white tube. The Nasmyth mirror which directs the light into the elevation axis is just visible At the time no Cassegrain focus was foreseen, because it would necessitate an increase in the height of the elevation axis and a mechanism to remove the Nasmyth mirror out of the Cassegrain beam with significant cost implications. In later designs of the telescope tube (Figure V, 4) fewer tubular structures of greater strength and a solid center piece replaced the numerous small elements to improve the stiffness of the tube.
While a tolerable result could be achieved with a zerodur mirror, a substantial weight reduction would very much enhance the performance. The possibility of beryllium as a mirror material was therefore explored. This material is not easy to handle being quite poisonous as a powder. Some experience had been gained in space applications, though only with smaller mirrors. Ultimately beryllium mirrors were chosen, but serious problems were encountered before full success was attained. Of course, the wobbling secondary also had to be made compatible with the active/adaptive optics system.
Technological, Financial and Scientific Planning of the VLT
67
One issue led to controversy: should the unit telescopes have only the two Nasmyth foci that naturally go with the alt-azimuth mounting or should there also be a Cassegrain focus? Not surprisingly the scientists wanted this, since it reduced the number of reflections from three to two with a 15% reduction in light losses. In addition, it would have a much improved polarization performance. However, the technical implications were serious. For the light to reach the Cassegrain focus the Nasmyth mirror would have to be removable out of the light path. Moreover, to have space for the Cassegrain instruments, the altitude axis would have to be moved higher with consequences for the mechanical structure and the enclosure. It was clear that all of this would have a significant cost impact, and so it seemed dangerous to include it in the baseline VLT proposal; however, the Cassegrain option could be reviewed later. A year thereafter, when a new Director General had taken over, that review led to the inclusion of the Cassegrain. It was approved by Council without much discussion of the increased costs that would be incurred. Not surprisingly it was later claimed that the VLT proposal had underestimated the costs. A realistic analysis ten years later showed that the extra costs incurred were largely the consequence of such extra requirements (see chapter V.). The VLT project group, which between 1983 and 1987 gradually increased from 5 to 10 persons, made a very complete preliminary design, outlining also choices that could be made following more detailed studies. The resulting proposal, including the cost estimates, inspired confidence. Particular care was taken to remain consistent: The 16-m equivalent diameter never varied, the four telescope array concept was there from the beginning, though the exploration of alternatives was necessary to establish that this was really the optimal solution. And most importantly for gaining support from the governments in the member countries, the overall financial envelope remained the same during the ten years leading up to the proposal in 1987. Galileo had made the first telescopic observations of stars and planets in Venice. So it was only appropriate that ESO presented the VLT design to the European astronomical community in Venice at the end of September 1986 at a workshop at the beautiful property of the Cini Foundation on the Isola di San Giorgio (photograph overleaf). Some 80 scientists participated, and a consensus of the great majority was achieved. In March 1987 the complete proposal (dubbed the “Blue Book”) was presented to Council. Much of the rest of the year was used for the resolution of the last political problems. In some countries these centered around the issue of what national projects should be reduced or abandoned. Finally, in December 1987 Council unanimously approved the project with a total budget of 388.2 MDM (1986), corresponding to 300 M€ (2004), including instrumentation and interferometry. Only six member countries could guarantee their participation. However, in 1988 also Belgium was able to join, followed by Denmark in 1989. The largest project ever undertaken in ground based astronomy was on its way.
68
Europe’s quest for the Universe
V. Construction of the VLT
Could we handle that dumb thing or would it handle us? I felt how confoundedly big, was that thing … Joseph Conrad1)
While many aspects of the realization of the mechanics, electronics and enclosure would require much effort at ESO and in industry, there were no unsurmountable problems in view. The mechanics had been well studied and even though no fully optimized design existed yet, the design one had made met the minimum specifications for flexure and resonant frequencies. Computers and electronics in general were in a state of flux with every year important industrial advances being made. ESO had constructed the NTT and even without further technological improvements it could, if need be, be adapted to meet the requirements of the 8-m telescopes. Experiments had been made with the inflatable shelters and the results were encouraging, even though not everyone thought this was the way to go. But the design of the NTT enclosure could easily be scaled up. The situation was much less clear with regard to the optics. No one had cast an 8-m mirror blank and no one had polished one. This had been the reason to explore other possibilities during the design phase. However, since 3.6-m Zerodur blanks had been cast in Europe with a good record of thermal stability and polishability, there was an obvious preference for this material. Thus, soon after approval of the project discussions were started with Schott about a contract for the delivery of four 8-m mirror blanks. Since the existing factory at Mainz was inadequate, a new building would have to be constructed, which obviously would add to the cost. The negotiations with Schott were difficult. An initial informal Schott offer was not accepted by its board of directors. As a result, an offer from Corning in the US was 22% cheaper with a schedule at least a year shorter. Since ESO preferred the Zerodur option because of the excellent uniformity
70
Europe’s quest for the Universe
of the material and because it came from European industry, further negotiations followed which finally led to a price reduction of about 20% though increased with future inflation corrections2). After many more discussions about the details, the contract at 47.5 MDM + cost variation (~ 35 M€, 2004) was signed in September 1988. However, permits for the construction of the new factory had to be obtained and the new factory had to be built. The firing of the new furnace took place in October 1990. The first three blanks cracked3), which was not unexpected, since no such large pieces of Zerodur had ever been made, and so a learning process was needed. As a result, significant delays were incurred and the first blank was delivered in June 1993 (Figure V, 1), about 2 1/2 years later than foreseen in the Blue Book. This delay continued throughout the whole project, though the fourth blank had been delivered on schedule at the end of 1995, and the polishing also went faster than anticipated. In the meantime discussions took place with the two firms in Europe that would be able to develop the tools for polishing 8-m mirrors. This led in July 1989 to the award of a contract for 33.75 MDM (~ 25 M€, 2004) to REOSC near Paris for polishing the four 8-m mirrors4). Again, this involved construction of a new building with a high test tower and the development of a new computer-controlled polishing machine. With the two critical
Figure V, 1. The disk of Zerodur for the first 8-m mirror at Schott. The yellow color of the rather transparent material is noticeable. The disk was still to be ceramized for eight months at temperatures of 800 – 1000 °C.
Construction of the VLT
71
contracts for the mirrors concluded, at a price below that foreseen in the Blue Book, it was clear that the VLT as an industrial project was on its way. In mid-1993, the first 8-m blank arrived at REOSC after a week long travel through European waterways. The grinding and polishing operation could begin. In 1995 the last blank was ready at Schott, and the polishing of the first one was completed at REOSC. Four years later four outstanding mirrors had been completed (Figure V, 2), and the first two were mounted in their telescopes to produce some stunning images which demonstrated their high quality. The investment at REOSC paid off well. Subsequently, it won the contract for polishing the two eight meter mirrors for the Gemini Project, a U.S. led consortium, including the UK. Though the mirrors were the most critical part of the VLT, the amount of work that needed to be done at ESO was quantitatively relatively limited. Once the optical specifications had been made, ESO had to check that they had been met, but no further design work was needed. It was very different for the overall structural design in which ESO had a more direct involvement; it had to ensure that the many other mechanical parts would be integrated in a coherent way. In 1990 ESO tendered for the main mechanical structure of the four telescopes. Several offers were received, the lowest one from an Italian consortium Ansaldo/EIE/SOIMI. This appeared to be an entirely suitable offer. Even though ESO does not follow a juste retour scheme to distribute industrial orders proportional to the national contributions, it seemed a very lucky circumstance that the three big countries each had obtained a large
Figure V, 2. The 8-m mirror being polished at REOSC. On the right a polishing tool is seen attached to the computer-controlled machine.
72
Europe’s quest for the Universe
contract in the VLT. Moreover, ESO had had a positive experience with Ansaldo during the construction of the NTT. However, one of the unsuccessful companies complained and the Finance Committee did not approve the contract; instead the suggestion was made to hold a meeting of all the bidders, ESO management and Finance Committee to discuss “technical and juridical points of the contract”5). This certainly was an unusual notion, which reflected national greediness on the part of some delegates. As a result, a 5 months’ delay was incurred and much time wasted by ESO staff before construction of the mechanics could start. The contract was finally concluded in September 1991 for 79 MDM (~ 54 M€, 2004) Two other mechanical items were particularly critical. The mirror cells with all the electro-mechanical active supports for the thin 8-m mirrors were determinant for the optical quality of the telescopes. The cells should give a sufficiently rigid support to the 150 axial supports (pushing in the direction parallel to the telescope tube) and 64 radial supports, but at the same time be as light as possible since a weight increase would propagate through the whole telescope structure (Figure V, 3). In addition, attached to the cell would be the Cassegrain instrumentation as well as the support structure for the (removable) Nasmyth tertiary mirror. Two parallel design studies were contracted out for nearly 8 MDM each to two different firms, and one of these, GIAT in France, thereafter fabricated these units for about 40 MDM (~ 25 M€, 2004). In fact, the total cost of these units significantly exceeded the cost of the polishing of the 8-m mirrors. An interesting aspect of the active optics system is that the changeover from the Nasmyth to the Cassegrain focus may be made without a change of the secondary mirror as in conventional telescopes. By modifying the curvature
Figure V, 3. The mirror cell. The thin 8.2-m mirror is supported axially by 150 motor controlled pistons which are part of the active optics system.
Construction of the VLT
73
of the primary mirror which is possible because of its thinness, one may switch between the two foci. Equally difficult and costly was the secondary mirror unit. Made of beryllium, the polishing was a delicate operation (REOSC) while the mechanics (Dornier) were complex since the 1.2 m mirror should wobble at frequencies over 10 cycles per second and also be part of the active optics setup. While these two items led to a significant cost overrun (Table V, 2) over the Blue Book, they have much contributed to the excellent performance of the telescopes (Figure V, 4). Thermal control of the telescopes and their environment was of prime importance. If the primary mirror is warmer than the air in the telescope tube, convection will arise which deteriorates the image quality. On the other hand, on humid days a cold mirror could suffer from condensation. So a back plate on the mirrors had to control their temperature precisely. Also turbulence in the enclosures could pose a serious problem. The design of the appropriate air conditioning system therefore was critical. In the Blue Book design the telescopes were enclosed in inflatable shelters which appeared to provide a particularly low cost solution. Night time operation would be in the open with the wind blowing away the turbulent air. Experiments were made with a 15-m inflatable dome placed at La Silla and wind tunnel tests were conducted. Fear of problems with wind forces on the 8-m mirrors led to the decision to place the telescopes in more conventional, but well ventilated, rotating metallic enclosures. A formidable task remained. A large number of smaller and larger motors and sensors was needed to control the movable parts, more than 200 for the active optics systems in each telescope alone. Electronic hardware was needed to connect these to the control computers. Software had to be developed to ensure that everything would function coherently and automatically. This represented an enormous effort under the leadership of Manfred Ziebell. In the past much of the software for telescope control and operation had been developed at ESO. However, with many standardized, reliable commercial and industrial packages now available, it was preferable to use these as the basic software building blocks. In the beginning the NTT software had been considered as a prototype for the VLT. In the end the opposite happened and the improved VLT software was retrofitted onto the NTT. In addition, the instruments at the twelve foci had to be integrated with the telescopes and their output had to be displayed and archived conveniently. At the end of 1990 Paranal had been chosen as the site for the VLT (chapter VI.)6). It then became necessary to determine the layout. Some 28 m of rock were blasted away from the top of Paranal to create a large enough platform (Figure V, 5). This had to be done cautiously in order not to fracture the rock on which the telescopes would be placed. In the Blue Book design the four 8-m telescopes were located on a straight line. However, the linear array was not optimal for interferometry. It was replaced by a
74
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure V, 4. One of the four finished 8-m telescopes. Note the much simpler structure with fewer, but stronger elements than in the first design (Figure IV, 3). Just below the center piece the location of the Nasmyth mirror is visible which directs the light beam through the elevation axis. When it is removed the light can pass through the hole in the primary mirror to the Cassegrain focus below. Around the primary mirror the edge of the mirror cell is visible with the wiring that connects the actuators supporting the mirror. At the top is the secondary mirror made of beryllium. It can oscillate between two positions at a high frequency during observations at infrared wavelengths.
Construction of the VLT
75
Figure V, 5. The four telescopes at Paranal in the early evening. Some of the shutters in the enclosures have been opened to let the cool air freely circulate. The octagons in front are supports for the movable 1.8-m auxiliary interferometric telescopes. The building to the right is the upper part of the interferometric laboratory, where the light from the different telescopes may be combined. Just to its left the first 1.8-m auxiliary telescope is visible and behind it the housing of the 2.5-m VLT Survey Telescope.
crescent-shaped arrangement which is more advantageous for interferometry. A maze of tunnels would connect the four telescopes and the 1.8-m mobile auxiliary ones to the central interferometric laboratory. At a distance from the telescope area other elements of the infrastructure would be located: workshops, a residential building, an electricity generating plant and a water reservoir. The latter would be replenished by water regularly trucked in from Antofagasta, since no local water wells were to be found in the dry desert. The most critical item was the mirror washing and aluminizing plant made by AMOS (B) and Linde (D). The vulnerable 8-m mirrors were transported to this plant and placed in the vacuum chamber in a series of highly automated operations. The old Panamericana (unasphalted) connected the Paranal area with Antofagasta, but the local roads in the Paranal area had to be made. Construction of the infrastructure started in 1991 and continued into 2002 when the temporary huts for lodging the staff were replaced by the elegant Residencia, complete with swimming pool and even several palm trees (Figure V, 6a). Most areas of the Residencia are climate controlled, since the extreme desert air is too dry for long term
76
Europe’s quest for the Universe
comfort. The building is largely underground with a 35-m semitransparent dome ensuring a luminous aspect. Of course, during the night precautions are taken to ensure that no light escapes to the outside. The 175 m long façade, with behind it the rooms for the staff and with small windows to avoid the strong glare, blends perfectly into the surrounding desert (Figure V, 6b).
Figure V, 6a. The Residencia. In the central area a garden gives some greenery to the staff in an otherwise extreme desert environment. The completely air-conditioned building is mostly located underground, but natural light may enter through the 35-m dome. Provisions have been made to ensure that at night no unwanted light pollution is produced.
Figure V, 6b. The façade of the Residencia, behind which are the rooms for the staff and visitors.
Construction of the VLT
77
The design of the building was the result of an international competition won by the architects Auer & Weber (Stuttgart). Most of the basic design was done by the architect D. Schenkirz, while the interior aspect of the building owes much to Daniel Hofstadt, ESO’s representative in Chile. The 11 M€ Residencia has contributed significantly to make life of the staff liveable in the harsh desert. From this brief description of the various activities relating to the realization of the VLT, it might seem that most things went rather smoothly. However, along the way some obstacles were encountered which led to delays which, as always, also had cost consequences. Two of these stand out. Less than a year after the approval of the VLT project Council became concerned about ESO’s management and expenditures. As Pierre Léna said in Council7), the French astronomers had had to agree to close some national facilities to obtain VLT approval. A parallel effort on the part of ESO would be desirable, with a stronger focus on the VLT. Of course, in some of the other member countries the situation was no different. As the concern of Council increased, Council set up a VLT management review board which reported in May 1990. Among other items the board was concerned about significant morale problems among the staff and recommended the appointment of a VLT program manager8). ESO involved a costly high powered management consulting firm, which identified 131 potential candidates9). Finally someone was appointed, who left nine months later after having introduced much additional bureaucracy. A few years thereafter, for the position of Head of Administration, the experience was repeated with another consulting firm10) with an equally distastrous result. Whatever their merits in other circumstances, business consultants apparently do not have much of a feeling for the requirements of an international, scientific/technological organization. Immediately after the departure of the new project manager, Massimo Tarenghi, who had already brought the NTT project to a successful conclusion, was appointed as his successor11). The situation in the ESO Council remained difficult, with several times the three large countries outvoted by the five small ones. While it is true that according to the ESO Convention each country has an equal vote, it is also evident that an organization cannot be run against the will of its principal paymasters. So a change was needed, and Council appointed Riccardo Giacconi as the new Director General as of January 1993. A period of American style management followed. While this did not please everyone, it created the conditions under which the VLT project could be brought to a fully successful conclusion. Council received a clear view of the problems and their solutions. But the management problems had set the project back by the better part of a year. In the meantime, a serious issue had arisen in the relations between Chile and ESO which were governed by the “Acuerdo” concluded in 1963. In the beginning everything went very smoothly, and relations between ESO and
78
Europe’s quest for the Universe
the Chilean government, as well as with the small astronomical community and with ESO’s local staff, were excellent. In 1972/73 economic conditions in Chile became difficult and a black market appeared which created opportunities for some and difficulties for others. Then at the end of 1973 came the Pinochet coup. Relations between European countries and Chile became very cool, with ESO being in the middle. Obviously, it was important for ESO to continue to have positive relations with the government in power, and equally obviously some governmental delegates in the ESO Council could not agree to this too openly. In a confidential session of Council I said: “If you live in hell, you treat with the devil”, and this argument led to a tacit understanding allowing us to continue our relations with the government at the required level. Relations with the community and local personnel were not helped by ostentatious consumption by some European staff. Since cars could be imported tax free and sold on the Chilean market two years later, a curious traffic arose with even medium level personnel owning or driving top of the line Mercedeses or Maseratis. Evidently, this created resentments, which were not diminished when the Pinochet government donated the land around Paranal for a gigantic European project. With the election of a democratic government in December 1989, some of these resentments came to the fore. The Chilean astronomers claimed observing time at ESO, the staff wanted improved conditions, and the original owners, the inheritors of the La Torre family, claimed the land of Paranal. Though worthless desert, multi million dollar claims were made. A Chilean astronomer consultant for the claimants made complex calculations partly based on the documents I had presented to Council in which the astronomical excellence of the site had been described. He arrived at a sum of some 30 MUS$! The issue of guaranteed observing time for Chilean scientists had been raised already early in 1988 by the foreign ministry in Santiago12). Although this was repeated several times thereafter, it had not been taken sufficiently seriously by ESO13). During 1994 negotiations took place between the Chilean government and ESO, and in November of that year an agreement was initialed. Unfortunately, this provisional agreement had not yet settled the ownership of the land. A century earlier it had been a reward for heroic deeds during the war with Bolivia and Peru. This gave the issue an even stronger patriotic flavor. The Chilean parliament also entered into the fray, and soon a local judge violated ESO’s diplomatic immunity and ordered a halt to the work at Paranal. Fortunately the Chilean foreign minister J.M. Insulza gave strong support to ESO and a final agreement was signed in April 1995. Towards the end of the year the Chilean government settled matters with the La Torre relatives for a substantial sum. It is undoubtedly the first time in history that such a sum has been paid for a piece of real estate exclusively on the basis of its value for astronomy. In September 1996 the Chilean senate followed congress in ratifying the “Interpretative, Supplementary and Complementary
Construction of the VLT
79
Agreement” to the 1963 Acuerdo. This gave Chilean astronomers rights of up to 10% of the observing time at ESO telescopes and also contained provisions aligning the statute of the Chilean workers closer to the Chilean labor law. It is not evident that the latter was to their advantage, but it satisfied a strong sentiment. While this new acuerdo appears to have solved all problems, the activities on Paranal had been set back by about half a year. Subsequently, the relations between Chile and ESO rapidly improved and now are very positive and cordial. So on 4 December 1996 the “Foundation Ceremony” for the Paranal observatory could take place in the presence of the President of Chile, Eduardo Frei Ruiz-Tagle, and many other dignitaries. Relations with the Chilean astronomical community also became much more positive. When ESO came to Chile there were few astronomers, mainly at the Cerro Calan observatory of the Universidad de Chile in Santiago. Programs included a radio survey at 7 m wavelength which has yielded an excellent map of the southern sky. Some photometry was done and also astrometry, the latter subsequently in part with an astrolabe in cooperation with ESO. Some four decades later astronomical activity in Chile is expanding rapidly, with greatly invigorated departments at the Universidad de Chile and at the Universidad Católica, also in Santiago. Moreover, new programs in astronomy were started at universities in Concepción, La Serena and Antofagasta14). Of course, the instrumental opportunities at ESO and at the US sponsored observatories played a role in this, as did increased governmental funding, augmented by some support from ESO. The move of ESO astronomers back to Santiago facilitated interaction between the two communities, fostering joint research projects, colloquia, etc. The general improvement of the universities and technological institutes also created a steady stream of competent engineers and technicians which allowed ESO to recruit locally an increasing fraction of its staff. In fact, at Paranal and La Silla well above 75% of the technical staff is now Chilean. The events at Paranal had a precursor at La Silla. There ESO had bought the land from the government for 45,000 Escudos (8,000 US$). Some time thereafter a person appeared who claimed ownership of part of the land. Since a court case would have held up the start of activities at La Silla for a long time, ESO paid another 15,000 Escudos to deal with this claim15). Unfortunately, the sum at issue at Paranal was so much larger that the same approach was not possible. Subsequently, activities at Paranal proceeded at a rapid pace. By the end of 1996, parts of the structure of the first unit telescope arrived, followed a year later by the first 8-m mirror. On 25 May 1998 “first light” was achieved at the completed telescope, followed at 10 months intervals by Unit Telescopes 2 and 3. Finally, UT 4 saw first light on 3 September 2000, thereby completing the VLT as such. It had taken 23 years since I had first proposed that ESO construct a 16-m equivalent telescope and nearly 13 years following
80
Europe’s quest for the Universe
project approval. Of course, much work remained to be done before every last adjustment would have been made. However, it is a tribute to the quality of ESO’s staff and of their industrial partners that soon thereafter the VLT was fully functional according to its specifications without significant mishaps appearing along the way. The four 8-m telescopes are only part of the VLT project. Each telescope has to be equipped with instrumentation – imagers and spectrographs for different wavelength regions. Already in the Blue Book it was clear that ESO could construct in-house only a small part of the instrumentation; most of it should be contributed by institutes in the ESO countries. This had the further merit of making the VLT project a community wide effort: ESO would provide much of the necessary funding for the acquisition of hardware and industrial contracts, while the institutes would design and develop the instrumentation and would obtain in exchange a certain number of observing nights. From the experience with the 3.6-m telescope, it was clear that work on the instruments should begin as soon as possible. So in 1990 the first instrumentation plan was developed and two years later the first contracts were concluded with institutes in the member countries. Instrumentation is discussed in chapter VII. The other aspect of the VLT is interferometry. In the Blue Book provisions had been made for adding two mobile auxiliary telescopes of about 1.5 m in diameter to improve the interferometric image quality obtainable with the four stationary telescopes. Subsequently, the MPG in Germany and l’INSU (CNRS) in France suggested that they could provide a third auxiliary telescope in exchange for observing time13). However, ESO’s financial problems led to the elimination of the interferometry from the near term financial plan. Some years later, interferometry was successfully brought back into the planning16) and a contract was concluded with the MPG and l’INSU17). Subsequently Belgium offered to pay for most of a fourth telescope and with support from some other countries it could be acquired. The increase of the diameter to 1.8 m and of the number of small telescopes from two to four are of great benefit to the whole program. A further increase to six would be very much worthwhile. The layout and various subsystems were completed or on their way when in 1998 the contract for two, later increased to four mobile 1.8-m telescopes was signed with AMOS in Liège at about 5 M€ per telescope. The last of the four should be completed in 2006. Work on instrumentation for the VLTI also progresses at various institutes (see chapter VII). In the meantime successful interferometric observations have been made with the large telescopes.
Planning and Reality In December 1987 the Council approved the VLT project as presented in the “Blue Book” with a budget of 382.2 MDM (1986 value), corresponding
Construction of the VLT
81
to 272 M€ in 1999 according to ESO’s inflation calculation, which is based on some kind of weighted average of inflation in the relevant European countries, where ESO makes its purchases. In 1999, when about 90% of the total had been spent or contracted, it was found that the actual cost amounted to 313 M€, 15% in excess of the 272 M€ in the Blue Book. In Table V, 1 a comparison is given in more detail (where we have omitted the 20 M€ for the interferometry which has become very much open ended), from which it appears that the extra costs came from three items: the cells supporting the 8.2-m mirrors and the Nasmyth mirror units, the secondary mirror units and the costs of Paranal developments. An important part of these cost increases is due to additions made to the project after its approval. The most evident of these are the Cassegrain foci for all four telescopes. Access to the Cassegrain focus requires removal of the Nasmyth unit out of the light beam. Not only did this very much complicate the mirror cell and the M3 unit, it also caused cost increases in the telescope structure; the height of the altitude axis had to be increased to make space for the Cassegrain instruments. So overall weight increased. Furthermore it required additional focal plane instrumentation (adapters/image rotators/etc.) at the Cassegrain focus. It is difficult to reliably determine the extra cost incurred, but I would estimate it to be in the 15–25 M€ range. Of course, there is no doubt that from a scientific point of view the implementation of the Cassegrain foci has been very much worthwhile. Table V, 1. Comparison of the VLT budget approved in 1987 (Blue Book), updated to 1999 values, with actual spending (90%) through 1999 + foreseen thereafter (10%). All values have been converted to M€ . The contingency (20 M€) in the Blue Book has been distributed over the various items. Major additions to the scope of the project are indicated by + or ++. These include the four Cassegrain foci and the four beryllium secondaries. Interferometry is not included in the table, since its scope had not yet been decided.
Item 8.2-m mirrors M1 cells + M3 units M2 units Main telescope structures Other telescope items Infrastructure / buildings / enclosures Instruments TOTAL
Blue book 65 15++ 7++ 43 31+ 58 33+ 252
Actual
Difference
57 32 26 43 28 80 27
–8 + 17 + 19 0 –3 + 22 –6
293
+ 41
82
Europe’s quest for the Universe
The question of the wobbling secondary for IR observations was left rather open in the Blue Book, with some doubt expressed about its necessity. As a result, a rather modest sum was foreseen for this item, though mention was made of a sophisticated system based on beryllium mirrors, which had been used in some space applications. Later it was decided to implement such mirrors at all four telescopes, which led to a quadrupling of this budget item. Finally, also the cost of Paranal development increased substantially. In part this was related to additions made beyond the perhaps somewhat too primitive setup initially foreseen. Since life in the Atacama desert has its difficulties, the more comfortable surroundings created for the scientific technical staff are certainly beneficial. In conclusion, it appears that the estimates made in the Blue Book were essentially correct. The cost overrun of 15% is largely the result of increased demands made on the VLT following its approval. The same conclusion was reached already during the program audit in 1994. The audit committee wrote then18): “We cannot argue that the increases are only due to the increased scope of the project, errors in the initial estimates may also play a significant rôle, but the correspondence between the most significant cost increases and the areas of project modifications is striking.” Of course, the contingency included in the original budget was there to deal with possible errors in the initial estimates and not for covering an enlargement of the project. In the Blue Book also the schedule of the project was specified. The first 8.2-m blank was to be fabricated in three years, by the end of 1990, and to be polished three years after that. However, as explained before, the first blank was completed 30 months late. Other delays resulted from the management problems in Europe, from the contract difficulties for the mechanical structure and from the political problems in Chile. The first unit telescope suffered most and had a delay of about four years, the last one of only 2 1/4 years. But what counts is that at the end of the construction process, Europe had completed the world’s most powerful telescope as planned and placed it on the world’s clearest site.
Other 8-m class telescopes Not surprisingly, other countries have also decided to construct large telescopes. By the end of 2006 the total number should be fifteen, including the four of the VLT (Table V, 2). In addition there are two large telescopes of more limited steerability and optical quality for spectroscopic purposes. The two 10-m Keck telescopes, built with private and NASA money, may also be used interferometrically, but, of course, only one baseline (85 m) between the large telescopes is available. This somewhat restricts the potential, because “phase closure” techniques cannot be used, since these require at least three
Construction of the VLT
83
telescopes. However, it is planned to add also some smaller auxiliary interferometric telescopes. By 2004 the necessary permits had still not been obtained because of eco-religious claims on Hawaii. The 10.4 m Spanish Gran Telescopio de las Canarias (GRANTECAN, Figure V, 7) with a segmented mirror is essentially a copy of the Keck telescopes. Funding came in part from the EU which has programs to support
Table V, 2. The world’s 8-m class telescopes.
Diameter
Name
Country
Year
4 × 8.2
VLT
ESO
1998/00
2 × 9.8
Keck
US
1993/96
2 × 8.4
LBT
2004/05
10.4
GRANTECAN
US, D, I 1/2 1/4 1/4 ESP, …
2006
8.2
Subaru
Japan
1999
8.0
Gemini N
8.0
Gemini S
US (1/2), 2000 UK (1/4), Can … US (1/2), … 2002
6.5
Magellan I
US
2002
6.5
Magellan II
US
2003
6.5
MMT +
US
2002
9.2
with limitations HET US …
2000
9.2
SALT
2005
SA,
Location Paranal Chile Mauna Kea Hawaii Mt. Graham Arizona La Palma Canaries Mauna Kea Hawaii Mauna Kea Hawai Pachon Chile Las Campanas Chile Las Campanas Chile Mt. Hopkins Arizona McDonald Texas Sutherland S. Africa
Alt (m)
Type
2700
Z
4200
S, Z
3200
BSC
2400
S, Z
4200
ULE
4200
ULE
2700
ULE
2400
BSC
2400
BSC
2600
BSC
2100 1800
S: Segmented; Z: Zerodur (Schott); BSC: Borosilicate Ceramic (U. of Arizona); ULE: UltraLow Expansion (Corning).
84
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Fig. V, 7. Model of the 10-m GRANTECAN on La Palma.
activities in less developed regions in Europe. Placed at La Palma, it may also help to determine the suitability of that site for even larger future telescopes. The two 8-m Gemini telescopes – one in the northern and the other in the southern hemisphere – represent a cooperation between the US (~ 50%) and the UK, Canada, Australia, Argentina, Brazil and Chile. Funding is governmental. The solid 8-m mirrors have been polished by REOSC. Optimization for the IR has been stressed. The most innovative of these new telescopes is the Arizona (1 / 4)/Germany (1/4) / Italy (1/4) / other US (1/4) Large Binocular Telescope, originally called the Columbus Telescope, which was later considered “politically incorrect” in the US. It has two 8-m telescopes in a common mounting. This has the advantage that interferometry between the two is possible over a relatively large field, but, of course, there is not much choice in baselines. The LBT has suffered major delays because of native Indian and ecological claims about the site at Mt. Graham in Arizona. While the red squirrels were still being hunted in various places, it was said that the telescope construction would risk the extinction of the subspecies on the mountain. Actually, their numbers appear to have increased after construction began! The first mirror was installed in 2004, the second should follow a year later. Perhaps the most innovative feature is the thinness (1.6 mm) of the 91-cm secondary mirrors.
Construction of the VLT
85
Supported by (or rather hanging on) 672 actuators, they allow the adaptive optics to be implemented without auxiliary optics and so to avoid the corresponding light losses. Rather contradictory statements about the cost of the LBT have been made with values around 140 MUS$ (excluding instrumentation) being plausible. The more limited HET and SALT have composite mirrors made of numerous spherical segments. Moreover, these telescopes can only track in azimuth which limits observing time on any object to less than an hour. However, they have a large collecting area (70 m2) at low cost (25–30 MUS$). They should be particularly suitable for spectroscopy of objects of intermediate brightness. With GRANTECAN, LBT and Gemini N, the European countries have the equivalent of 2 1/4 telescopes of the 8–10 m class in the northern hemisphere to supplement the four of the VLT in the south.
VI. Sites for Telescopes
The only remedy is a most serene and quiet air such as may perhaps be found on the tops of the highest mountains, above the grosser clouds. Isaac Newton1)
The earth’s atmosphere has negative effects on astronomical observation. Clouds, haze and dust absorb the light from celestial sources. Turbulence in the atmosphere causes small temperature variations which lead to small scale variations in the atmospheric refraction (the bending of light) which smear out images of astronomical objects. Thus, a stellar image which should be essentially point-like is smeared out over a “seeing” disk of typically an arcsecond or less in diameter on good sites and more than that in poorer places. Some of the turbulence is caused by layers of varying wind speed rather high in the atmosphere (some km), some occurs close to the ground by the effect of the surface features on the wind driven air and some results from convection when the lower air is too warm for a stable atmospheric structure. With the advent of infrared astronomy the total atmospheric water vapor content has become important since water vapor absorbs incoming radiation and itself emits infrared radiation which gives the IR sky a luminous glow which makes it difficult to detect celestial sources. Submm radio waves are also subject to much absorption from water vapor. Newton already suggested that it would be advantageous to place a telescope on a high mountain, where one would have left some of the ill effects of the atmosphere below. However, according to Piazzi Smyth2) Newton’s “very simple and probable piece of speculation” had “dropped out of notice” and when he was going to put it to the test “a few voices even loudly proclaimed that high mountain tops, all the world over, are invariably loaded with clouds and mist and sleet and tormented forever with impetuous storms”. This led him in 1856 to mount an expedition to Teneriffe where he found that stars four magnitudes fainter could be observed from a site 2700 m high on
88
Europe’s quest for the Universe
the Teíde volcano than at sea level (Figure VI, 1). It is interesting that the expedition was made possible by Mr R. Stephenson, a member of the British parliament, who provided his own yacht, because “his early experiences on South American cordilleras had long since led him to look with favour on Newton’s mountain method of improving astronomical observations”. More than a century later his experiences were amply confirmed. In the tropics humidity is high and atmospheric convection strong. At latitudes around 50˚ the jet stream generates strong turbulence, while cloudiness is relatively high. As a result, most high quality astronomical sites are found at subtropical latitudes. A notable exception is the high central Antarctic plateau. It is high, very cold, extremely dry and in contrast to the Antarctic periphery without strong winds. However, it is no simple matter to build and operate a telescope there, though some specialized instruments have been erected. Over land temperatures are rather variable and this creates instability. Above the oceans the air flow tends to be much more stable, in particular when cold currents cool the oceanic surface. Then a temperature inversion (temperature increasing upwards) occurs which inhibits convection. At the boundary of this layer, typically a km high, low clouds are common, but higher up the atmosphere is calm. Thus, high island or coastal sites bathed in cold water have long been believed to be particularly favorable for astronomical observation. However, at sufficient altitude the coastal advantage seems to be less strong.
Figure VI, 1. The Teíde Observatory (2390 m) on Tenerife. In the background is the Pico de Teíde (3700 m) which last erupted in 1798. The volcano is still slightly active today and the observatory has been built on its shoulder. To the right is the 90 cm French-Italian solar telescope THEMIS, and to the left the German 40, 45 and 60 cm solar towers, the Spanish 1.5-m infrared telescope and an ESA-Spanish optical ground station (1-m) for tracking space debris and space communication experiments.
Sites for Telescopes
89
Because of the rotation of the earth, cold currents coming down from upwelling circumpolar waters tend to occur on the east side of the oceans. Of course, geographic constraints also play a role. In the northern hemisphere cold currents along the coasts of California and West Africa have created favorable conditions, in particular on the Canary Islands in front of the African coast. Here the island of La Palma with its 2400 m high volcanic rim is an excellent site (Figure VI, 2). The Pico de Teíde on Tenerife at 3700 m is unsuitable because of volcanic activity, but seeing conditions on its lower flanks are excellent, in particular for solar observations. Thanks to Francisco Sánchez, major observatories have been developed on both islands. Conditions in
Figure VI, 2. The Roque de Los Muchachos Observatory (2400 m) on La Palma some 140 km NW of Teíde. A large number of telescopes has been placed close to the upwind rim of an extinct caldera. These include the 2.5-m Nordic Optical Telescope, here just visible on the rim, the 1-m, 2.5-m and 4.2-m telescopes of the UK-NL cooperation, a Liverpool University 2-m, a Flemish 1.2-m and the 3.5-m Italian “Telescopio Nazionale Galileo”, as well as 96-cm Swedish and 45-cm Dutch solar telescopes. The 10-m Spanish “Gran Telescopio de las Canarias” is currently nearing completion. The La Palma Cosmic-Ray Observatory observes the Cerenkov light produced by cosmic gamma-rays of very high energy with MAGIC, seen here in front, a 17-m diameter segmented telescope. Since no high optical resolution is required, a place in the wind shadow was acceptable.
90
Europe’s quest for the Universe
southern Spain, where the German Calar Alto observatory, with its 3.5-m telescope, was placed, are less favorable3). The best place in the northern hemisphere is probably Mauna Kea at 4200 m on the big island of Hawaii. Because of its high altitude and stable oceanic environment, water vapor column density is low and seeing conditions are as excellent as at La Palma. Several US telescopes, including the two 10-m “Keck telescopes” are placed here. Also the UK (now joined by the Dutch) placed here the 3.6-m infrared telescope UKIRT, while France participates (now at 45%) in the 3.6-m Canada-France-Hawaii telescope. In addition, the 15-m submm JCMT radio telescope is operated by the UK in collaboration with the Netherlands. As several of the best places on Mauna Kea and La Palma have been taken, other northern hemisphere sites have been looked for. At sufficient altitude the difference between oceanic and continental sites may well become smaller. In fact, Germany and Italy – each at 25 % – participate with the US in the Large Binocular Telescope (2 × 8 m), the first half of which became operational in 2004 on Mt. Graham in Arizona at 3200 m. Also optimistic speculations are being made about high sites in central Asia, but only limited reliable data are available to date. Turning now to the southern hemisphere, we find cold currents along the western rims of three continents. In Western Australia there are no high mountains. In South Africa ESO found relatively modest conditions, but further north at the Gamsberg in Namibia – a table mountain 2350 m high – conditions have been claimed to be comparable to those at La Silla. Because of political problems, German attempts to place telescopes there have come to naught. An earlier expedition by the Smithsonian Institution to Fogo (2700 m) in the Cabo Verde islands and to six peaks in Namibia concluded that the sites were all unsuitable for measuring the solar radiation intensity, which requires a very pure sky with high IR transparency and therefore a low column density of water vapor4). By far the strongest cold current – the Humboldt current – flows along the South American coast and brings cool conditions even to the equator. When Humboldt reached the Peruvian coast in 1802, he measured a temperature of 16 °C – more than 10° lower than normal so close to the equator5). Close to the coast, frequently at no more than 100 – 200 km, the Andes rise to above 6000 m and form a barrier against humidity coming from the Atlantic. The result is an extremely dry coastal strip, with the Atacama desert being one of the driest areas on earth. As a consequence, some of the world’s finest sites for optical and for submm telescopes are found in Chile.
Early Astronomical Sites in Chile The early history of Chilean astronomy has been well described by Keenan, Pinto and Alvarez6). The first organized astronomical activity in
Sites for Telescopes
91
Chile was the Gilliss expedition of the US Navy (1849–52) for observations of stellar and planetary positions. Subsequently, his observatory in Santiago was taken over by the Chilean state with the founding of the National Observatory. In 1893 a solar eclipse was observed near the town of Vallenar (50 km north of La Silla), where several expeditions had gone to profit from the clear skies. In 1903 Lick Observatory placed a 92-cm telescope on San Cristobal, close to Santiago, where during 26 years the radial velocities of southern stars were measured with the Mill’s spectrograph. From here H.D. Curtis in 1909 made an expedition to the region NE of Copiapo and reported the night sky to be “very transparent and clear”, estimating that some 300 nights per year might be cloud-free7). From 1920 to the early fifties C.G. Abbot from the Smithsonian Institution conducted a program at Cerro Montezuma to measure the intensity of the solar radiation (the “solar constant”)4). According to Abbot, this site at -22.5 ˚ latitude near Calama was the best place he had found in the southern hemisphere for his observations which required high IR transparency. It is interesting that the excellent sites found by ESO are all close to the one Abbot found without all the modern data and equipment available now. In the late fifties F. Rutlland, the director of the Chilean National Observatory, induced G.P. Kuiper – one of the great astronomical entrepreneurs – to consider the possibility of an observatory in Chile. In 1959 J. Stock arrived to make detailed site surveys first in the vicinity of Santiago, but rapidly moved north where clear skies appeared to be more frequent. Stock8) extensively studied Cerro La Peineta near Copiapo and Cerro Tololo further south, which was subsequently chosen by the Americans for their observatory. From Stock’s results it appeared that the Chilean sites were substantially better than those in South Africa, where ESO had been studying several places9). In December 1962 A.B. Muller then visited La Peineta and Tololo for a total of 27 nights, and in 1964 ESO selected Cerro La Silla (Figure II, 3) 100 km north from Tololo situated between La Serena and Vallenar (Figure VI, 3). The ESO Council had made the choice contingent on water being available near the site, and subterranean water was found in 1965 in one of the old river beds below La Silla. The choice of La Silla had also more political aspects. There had been a growing concern in ESO circles about developments in South Africa, and the discovery of the superiority of the Chilean sites therefore came as a relief10). There then were discussions about joining the Americans on or near Tololo11). While in particular the more American oriented Dutch were very favorably inclined to such an association, others were more concerned about the independence and visibility of the European entity. In retrospect, the decision to go to an independent mountain was certainly the right one. Different ways of doing things would have led to problems, and ESO with its limited experience would have been very much the junior partner. Relations between the observatories always remained very cordial.
Figure VI, 3. Map of northern Chile. Squares indicate cities; circles indicate observatory sites, filled circles those currectly active with telescopes of 2-m or more.
Sites for Telescopes
93
O. Heckmann, who became ESO’s first Director General, found easy access in Chile due to the strong element of German descent in that country. With K. Walters, an international lawyer who had handled many delicate matters during the war and who had a very extensive set of friends and acquaintances, Heckmann negotiated a treaty between Chile and ESO as an intergovernmental organization, which gave ESO many immunities and considerably facilitated future operations. Without waiting for Council approval, he signed the treaty, an act of independence which, though not applauded by everyone at the time, much speeded up ESO’s installation in that country11). At the same time, ESO’s quasi-diplomatic status complicated relations with Tololo and an independent site became even more necessary. While without further site surveys it was clear that the various mountains between La Serena and Copiapo should have excellent conditions, it remains remarkable that no local survey at all was conducted before the selection of La Silla. In retrospect, this may have been all to the good in accelerating the construction of the observatory. While ESO could be satisfied to have escaped the deteriorating political situation in South Africa, its optimism about Chilean politics was less justified. In this seemingly so peaceful country several violent revolutions and coups d’état had taken place since independence, and the next one was to come in 1973 12). In these troubled times the “acuerdo” negotiated by Heckmann proved to be of great value. Also the astronomers from the USSR were attracted by the Chilean skies, and in 1967 a small astrometric observatory was built on Cerro Roble, some 80 km north of Santiago6). Site surveying for a larger observatory came to an abrupt halt after the 1973 coup. Finally, in 1970 the Carnegie Institution of Washington built its observatory at Las Campanas, 50 km north of La Silla. By the late seventies large telescopes had been installed at Tololo, La Silla and Las Campanas. The high quality of the three sites was confirmed and many scientific results were obtained. However, these sites were not as excellent in the IR as Hawaii at 4200 m altitude because of a higher atmospheric water vapor content. In the meantime, the Astronomy Department of the Chilean University had begun in 1966 to take a new look at the north. J. Stock who by then was based at the National Observatory gives a brief description of the conditions there13): “There are a number of mountains of sufficient elevation south of the town of Antofagasta and very close to the coast. The abrupt rise from the Pacific Ocean on one side, and a large flat plain, more than 1000 m lower, on the other side give these mountains rather special conditions. High stability, that is, good seeing, is expected for night time conditions. Furthermore, the extremely low humidity makes this area very suitable for astronomical work in the infra-red. Since this area is absolutely arid, water supply for an observatory will be difficult and costly. Underground currents may exist, but most likely at a prohibitive distance and depth.” Since water sources had been a major concern in the location of the various observatories, Stock thought that sites further to the East, where
94
Europe’s quest for the Universe
abundant water falls on the high Andes, would be preferable. Accordingly, he selected a site for further study at 20 km from San Pedro de Atacama, the flattish summit of Cerro Chaupiloma at 3300 m altitude. According to Stock a nearby river had sufficient flow for a hydroelectric power plant! Somewhat later, in 1971, astronomers from the USSR started measurements also on this mountain as well as on Cerro La Peineta14). Moreover, in 1967, the National Observatory reported that sites for a radio telescope had been looked for at the Salar de Atacama and that a suitable 6 × 3 km area had been found at 20 km from San Pedro15). After the coup in 1973, the Chilean activities of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR came to a sudden end, the Americans and Europeans were busy with the construction of their observatories, and for the Chileans other concerns predominated. Interest in the North largely vanished.
The New Push Northward During 1977 I initiated plans for a future large telescope at ESO. Technical studies were made, and it became clear that the Very Large Telescope would be expensive – well above a hundred million euros. It also seemed probable that the VLT would be constructed as an array of several large telescopes and that there was no suitable place at La Silla for such an array. These two factors together implied that a new site had to be looked for, and that site quality might be more important than low cost, at least as long as that cost was small compared to that of the telescope array. Within the ESO territory two mountains seemed to offer possibilities of comparable quality: Cerro Duran to the north halfway to Las Campanas, and Cerro Vizcachas closer to La Silla to the southeast. A visit to Cerro Duran showed a suitably shaped free standing summit. However, the layout of a road to La Silla was far from evident. In any case, the time needed to drive from one site to the other would be too long to have a common infrastructure. Cerro Vizcachas was easier to reach and a provisional road was constructed for testing. The top had enough space to accommodate the VLT. While there was some concern that this site was relatively close to the southern border of ESO’s territory and, therefore, of the area protected from mining, overall it seemed the most attractive in the La Silla area. So this became the reference site for comparison with others. To the east of La Silla much higher mountains could be found. One of these, Cerro Peralta, was clearly visible on the sky line as a free standing 4500 m high summit. An expedition there by D. Hofstadt and myself showed access to be very difficult. Much running water was found on the lower slopes, the result of frequent summer rains which appeared to be related to thunderstorms drifting in from Argentina. Towering clouds can frequently be seen over these high mountains which only rarely reach La Silla. While it may well be that winter nights with extremely low water vapor content can be found there, the overall level of cloudiness would be higher than at La Silla.
Sites for Telescopes
95
It therefore seemed that if more exceptional sites were to be found we would have to go northward (Figure VI, 3, 4). From La Silla to the north cloudiness slowly diminishes as may be seen from Stock’s data near Copiapo who found there 20% more clear night hours than at Tololo. Partly because of stronger winds the site had not been selected by the Americans. Much further to the north at the cosmic ray station at Chacaltaya (5400 m, near La Paz, Bolivia) measurements had been made which showed much more cloudiness and for its altitude a relatively high atmospheric water vapor content16). In between there should be an optimum.
Figure VI, 4. Satellite image of northern Chile taken by the ESA astronaut Claude Nicollier on his way to the Hubble Space Telescope. North is towards the lower left. The curving coast line north of Arica and the anvil like figure at Antofagasta are easily recognized. Along the coast clouds above the Humboldt current stabilize the atmosphere, but remain well below the level of Paranal. Further to the east of Antofagasta one can see the eastward curve in the main chain of the Andes with the whitish Salar de Atacama, an ancient dried up lake with below the surface brines which contain much of the world’s exploitable lithium. Somewhat further to the NW the plume of the copper smelter at Chuquicamata, near Calama, is visible. To the east of the Salar de Atacama, in between the first mountains, is the Llano de Chajnantor – site for ALMA, the Atacama Large Millimeter Array. On this image the blocking of humidity from the Atlantic and the general increase of the cloudiness towards the more tropical areas of Bolivia is also in evidence.
96
Europe’s quest for the Universe
A visit was made to La Peineta, the 3000 m high mountain near Copiapo, by A. Ardeberg and myself; we found the road to the top very damaged (by rainfall), and since Stock had already investigated the site at some length some years earlier, it did not seem worth the effort to set up a site testing station there. All of the sites which had been studied till then were relatively far inland. But for astronomical sites the more stable oceanic air has a great advantage. So when one evening I looked again at a large map of Chile, it struck me that there was, in fact, a rather unique high mountain very close to the coast, Cerro Paranal at 2700 m. Later I realized that it was located in the general area south of Antofagasta that Stock had referred to. So why not have a look? Soon thereafter, in March 1983, I mounted an expedition (Figure VI, 5) during which the extreme dryness, the purity of the sky, the general suitability of Cerro Paranal (Figures VI, 6, 7) and the relatively easy access along the old Panamericana were seen from land and from the air17). By September Arne Ardeberg had set up a meteorological station where every two hours the general condition of the sky and also the integrated atmospheric water vapor content were measured in addition to the standard meteorological quantities. The local dryness was so extreme that at times it was thought that the hygrometer had gotten stuck at zero! This station, under the direction of Marc Sarazin, has remained in operation for more than two decades with increasingly sophisticated instrumentation - including also a seeing monitor, the Differential Image Motion Monitor which he built. It was temporarily dismantled when the top of the mountain was removed for the VLT construction. Following the establishment of the monitoring station at Paranal, Ardeberg made repeated visits to some other mountains in northern Chile, transporting in particular a second apparatus for measuring total atmospheric water vapor. Carrying such a 25 kg instrument on foot from 5500 to 6000 m at the top of Cerro Tacora was no mean feat! The conclusion of Ardeberg’s work was that only at substantially greater altitude could lower atmospheric water vapor be found and that the high sites east of San Pedro sometimes suffered from cirrus clouds, which would be unfavorable for optical observations18). Once seeing measurements were started at Paranal by Sarazin, the exceptional qualities of the site were confirmed. Not only was the frequency of clouds half of that at La Silla, but seeing was significantly better with the light of a point source smeared out over an area on average 25% smaller. Furthermore, during the nine driest months water vapor content was substantially less that at La Silla. So after six years of cloudiness measurements and two years of seeing measurements, in 1990 Paranal was chosen as the site for the VLT19). In retrospect the issue of the availability of water, so important in earlier site selections, seems curious. If no local water is available, it can be
Sites for Telescopes
97
Figure VI, 5. The first expedition to the Paranal area. From left to right: Gerhard Bachmann, Hans-Emil Schuster, the author and André Muller, photographed by Ulla Demierre. In the background is the escarpment which terminates the higher area around Paranal. Figure VI, 6. Image of the Paranal area taken from SPACELAB with the University of Munich camera. The summits of these mountains are exceedingly dry which is very important for observations in the infrared. Because of large climatic fluctuations from year to year, it was necessary to continue the ESO studies of atmospheric conditions in this region for seven years, before a definite decision about the VLT site was made. Conditions were monitored in particular at Cerro Paranal (2700 m) close to the Pacific coast and occasionally at Cerro Armazoni (3000 m), the isolated mountain half way up along the right side of the picture. The old Panamericana highway passes just east of the north–south escarpment in the middle. The scale is 6 km/cm. North is up.
98
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure VI, 7. The Paranal area photographed by C. Madsen and H. Zodet. In front of the Pacific, Co. Paranal connected by a road to the NTT hill and to Co. La Montura on the right. The VISTA optical/infrared wide field telescope will be placed on the NTT hill, so named because I considered placing the NTT there rather than at La Silla.
brought in by truck at a cost that is manageable. The same is done at several Chilean copper mines. And it is interesting to note that for the city of Antofagasta with 300,000 inhabitants much of the water is transported from the east by a pipeline, since none is available locally. Even during the darkest political periods, nobody has seriously disrupted that water supply. In the meantime a desalination plant has also been built. Today all the water for Paranal is bought near Antofagasta and trucked to the mountain.
Millimeter Sites The very high sites in the main chain of the Andes had been inspected rather casually during the VLT site surveys. Numerous high mountains, with altitudes up to 6000 m, were found in the latitudes considered. Low water vapor column density was found, substantially lower than at Paranal, but the relatively high frequency of cirrus clouds made the area less attractive for optical telescopes and so no measurements of seeing had been made. Since such cirrus is composed of small ice crystals it does not affect mm radio waves which are absorbed only by water vapor. Also large areas were excluded by the smoke from the Chuquicamata copper smelters, which could be traced visually for more than 100 km to the east. In between the mountain peaks high plateaus are found, and these have drawn the attention of radio astronomers looking for a site for a large submm interferometer for which large flat areas with very low water vapor column density are required. The Nobeyama Radio Observatory (Japan) has been
Sites for Telescopes
99
testing an area (Río Frío at 4200 m) 180 km SE of Antofagasta in the Cordillera Domeyko, while the Europeans visited the nearby Pampa San Eulogio, a flat area 20 × 20 km at 3700 m altitude. The US National Radio Astronomical Observatory has extensively studied a higher site at 5200 m, the Llano de Chajnantor, 300 km east– north–east of Antofagasta, 60 km from the picturesque village of San Pedro de Atacama and conveniently just a few km from the road to Argentina (Figure VI, 8). This site appears to be exceptionally dry and has been selected as the location for ALMA, the Atacama Large Millimeter Array – which will combine the American, European and Japanese projects (see Chapter IX)20). It remains to be seen how many scientists and engineers are able to work at this altitude. In my (qualitative) experience most people are able to cope with the conditions at 4000 m but at 5000 m this is much more difficult to do. However, with an operational facility at 2900 m where most engineering activities will take place, the situation should be manageable. The 12-m radio telescopes can be transported there for refurbishment.
Figure VI, 8. The 5000 m high Llano de Chajnantor. Scattered over an area 10 km in diameter, the 64+ submm telescopes of 12-m diameter of the Europe-Japan-US ALMA project should be in place here by the end of 2011.
100
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Climatic Variability Some observatories have been placed in the wrong spot on the basis of site testing of inadequate length. Almost every site has substantial yearto-year variations, and a short campaign will tend to lead to the selection of a place that had an above average quality during that time, even though on a long term basis it could be inferior. To avoid such problems, the site testing for Paranal continued for more than six years before a decision was made. Since then the conditions at Paranal have been monitored for a period three times longer (Figure VI, 9). According to Sarazin21), for the 20 year interval 1984–2003 photometric nights (with clear sky for at least six consecutive hours) averaged 76%, slightly below the 80% of the first six years, but remained well above conditions at observatory sites elsewhere. The La Silla average was 61%, essentially the same as the the 62% found there during 1966–75. In both places there seems to be some tendency for above or below average conditions to persist for several years in succession. Seeing conditions also have varied. At Paranal the 0.7 arcsecond mean seeing of the years 1987–1997 quite suddenly deteriorated to values around 0.9 arcsec for 1998–2003. The more fragmentary La Silla data also show a deterioration at about the same time. At both sites 2002 was the cloudiest year ever. Note that the seeing values are mean values. Median values are typically 10 better. Also these data come from the seeing monitor which appears to overestimate the image diameter measured by the VLT telescopes by some 10% in the visible and up to 30% at 2.4 μm21). The climate in the eastern Pacific appears to be subject to cyclical variations on various time scales. The variable El Niño – La Niña cycles of typically half a decade are, of course, well known to be associated with climate events over a good part of the earth. Recently a 50 year cycle has been found22). During the cooler half of the cycle in the eastern Pacific anchovies were abundant, to be replaced by sardines during the warmer part. The transition between the two appears to be rather abrupt. The fish catches have enabled two such cycles to be identified during the twentieth century. The last warm phase began in the mid-seventies and ended in the mid to late nineties. Rather remarkably, at La Silla and Tololo the annual number of photometric nights diminished significantly around 1976, only to recover some twenty years later – with the exception of the catastrophic year 2002. Large fluctuations possibly associated with the higher frequency El Niño– La Niña cycles superposed on the longer term trends are not unexpected. Changes on even longer time scales have also occurred. Anecdotal evidence was provided by locals at Pelícano near La Silla who stated that half a century earlier tall grass was growing where now not much vegetation is to be found. The Pelícano river, ESO’s source of water, went underground and only reappeared for a few months during the nineties. Also the derelict
Sites for Telescopes
101
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4 1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.1 1980
Figure VI, 9. Evolution of annual mean conditions at Paranal (■) and at La Silla (■). The upper graph gives the fraction of photometric nights, the lower graph the mean diameter of the seeing image in arcseconds. Incomplete data are indicated by open symbols. The horizontal bar in the upper graph represents the average for the La Silla data for 1966–1975. For 1993 and 1999 the incomplete La Silla seeing data have been combined with those for the preceding year to obtain 12 months of data appropriately distributed through the year. The figure is based on monthly data provided by M. Sarazin21).
102
Europe’s quest for the Universe
irrigation ditches in the La Silla area suggest a wetter past climate. More quantitatively at La Serena the rainfall appears to have diminished over the past century by 63%23). It is perhaps not surprising that the La Serena – La Silla area would be particularly sensitive to climate changes. Over the 300 km distance between Copiapo and La Serena average annual rainfall during the 1971–1984 period varied from 11 to 78 mm24), to increase a further factor of 4.5 over the 400 km to Santiago. With such strong gradients relatively small changes in the location of the pressure systems can have very large local effects. In that respect Paranal is better situated within a wide latitude range with rainfall below 10 mm per year. Latitude shifts of a few hundred km of pressure systems would be expected to cause less change at Paranal. Of course, rainfall and astronomical conditions are not quite the same. In particular, seeing may depend on more subtle effects. In fact, Sarazin has noted that the deterioration of the seeing at Paranal over the last years appears to be related to a change in the large scale pressure distribution which shifted the winds more to the NE. On much longer time scales, some recent studies seem to show that the climate in the region east and north of the Salar de Atacama was very dry much of the time25). The very dry period during the late parts of the last ice age was followed by a somewhat more humid interval from perhaps 16,000–10,000 years ago. Numerous archeological remains are found around ancient lake shores which date to this period. An extremely dry period thereafter left the area uninhabited. A certain recovery to slightly less dry conditions took place subsequently, but the record from different sites is sometimes contradictory. The last 4000 years appear to have been more or less as at present. In one of the lakes on the altiplano the water level never exceeded present values during the last 9000 years. Thus, the astronomical sites in northern Chile may look forward to a continuation of present day favorable conditions unless unforeseen effects of global warming intervene.
Sites for future telescopes The quantitative comparison of sites involves a number of parameters. Clear sky is obviously essential. “Photometric nights” are commonly defined as nights with at least six consecutive hours of clear sky. When also shorter periods are included, the time is referred to as “spectroscopic” or “usable”. The additional time may be used for obtaining spectroscopic data like redshifts where only the wavelength of spectral features is needed. However, to obtain accurate photometrically calibrated spectral data, sufficiently long continuous periods of observation are needed. The second essential parameter is the “seeing” or more specifically the diameter of the image of a point source due to atmospheric turbulence. The turbulence may be excited, for example by instabilities, at the interface of
Sites for Telescopes
103
atmospheric layers moving at different speeds. The simplest way to measure the seeing is to take images with large telescopes. Since these are not transportable, other methods are needed to compare sites. Moreover, when the housing of a large telescope contains air at different temperatures, the local “dome seeing” may make site conditions seem worse than they are. At ESO Marc Sarazin has built the DIMM, the Differential Image Motion Monitor26). It consists of a 35-cm telescope with in front of a detector a mask with two small holes separated by perhaps 20 cm. The two resulting images are continuously moving over the detector because of the atmospheric turbulence. The relative motion of the two images gives quantitative information about the turbulence. On the assumption that the distribution of the turbulent elements follows a standard (Kolmogorov) law, the turbulence is fully characterized and the image that would be observed with a large telescope may be inferred. The great advantage of the DIMM is that contrary to earlier instruments it only measures relative motions of the images and so it is impervious to movements of the telescope by the wind or other causes. At Paranal the actual images observed with the VLT are some 10% smaller in the visible and, therefore, better than inferred from the DIMM. This is presumably related to the fact that the larger turbulent elements do not follow the standard distribution. The DIMM or some version thereof has now become a worldwide standard for seeing measurements. When adaptive optics systems (Chapter VII) are considered for correcting the turbulent effects on the images, other site parameters become of interest: the number of turbulent layers, their altitude and the speed at which they move. These may be determined by campaigns with balloon borne equipment, lidars, echo sounders, etc. Unfortunately, such campaigns tend to be of short duration. A third main parameter is the quantity of water vapor above the site. IR observations are affected both by the emission from the H2O in the atmosphere and by its absorption of the radiation coming from the outside. The quantity of H2O in vapor form is measured in mm of precipitable water. Ice crystals in cirrus clouds are largely irrelevant in the IR, though they are a hindrance to observations in the visible. H2O may be measured from its IR emission and from its absorption of radio waves at submm wavelengths. A site with 1 mm of H2O is excellent, but several mm are found at typical observatories. Not surprisingly, the best results are obtained at high, cold sites. Data for a selection of sites are assembled in Table VI, 1. Seeing measurements have been transformed to median values on the ESO DIMM scale. The table documents the remarkable frequency of clear nights at Paranal, which appears to be unparalelled in the world. For its altitude it is also particularly dry. Chajnantor is, of course, much drier, but the available information suggests that clouds are more frequent. Cornell University has started a site testing campaign on Co. Chico, about a hundred meters above the Llano de Chajnantor27). Seeing measurements yielded a median value of 0”71 compared
104
Europe’s quest for the Universe
to 0”80 at Paranal during the same 38 nights. However, the distance of some 300 km between the two is probably too large for reliable conclusions to be based on so few nights. The Cornell study indicated that a few hundred meters higher above the plateau the dryness may become even more extreme, but obviously life becomes more difficult. The Argentinian side of the Andes does not appear to offer advantages compared to Chile, and the same appears to be the case for southern Africa and Australia. Sarazin performed some limited testing for ESO on the island of La Réunion, but conditions were not particularly favorable19). Turning to the northern hemisphere, I would doubt that any US sites would be suitable for new large European telescopes. Some continental sites are good, but not as outstanding as Mauna Kea on the big island of Hawaii. There the fraction of clear sky is perhaps on the modest side, but seeing and low H2O are excellent. According to the Keck telescope website image diameters have a median value of 0”55. When comparing Paranal and Mauna Kea, we should take into account that the median values are some 10% smaller than the mean values given in Figure VI, 9. Moreover, the DIMM results are some 10% larger than the directly measured image diameters. Taking also into account the fraction of photometric time, the number of hours with sub 0”6 seeing should be comparable on the two sites. However, Mauna Kea begins to be rather full, and the religio-ecological problems, which have caused long delays both there and at Mt. Graham, make these sites not very attractive for a large European telescope. In that respect the Mexican sites, like S. Pedro Martír or Sierra Negra, are more promising27). High sites in central Asia could perhaps have been worth considering28), but political factors effectively exclude large investments there. Maidanak in Uzbekistan appears to have excellent seeing (0”69 median, comparable to Paranal intercalibrated with ESO instruments), but the 60% clear sky is disappointing. Hanle in the Indian Himalaya also appears to be rather good. The low water vapor values at St. Katherine in the Sinai4), combined with the recent easy accessibility of the Red Sea resorts, makes this perhaps an interesting area for further study for a regional telescope. For Europe the most suitable site for a large northern hemisphere telescope would appear to be La Palma. The median seeing of 0”65 on the better subsites (intercalibrated with ESO) is excellent29); unfortunately, the 3.7 mm median column density of H2O is not30). The percentage of photometric nights is acceptable, but on the low side31). The mean seeing of 0”75 compares well with the long term average at Paranal of 0”80, though for the number of photometric hours with excellent seeing the latter still has the edge. The La Palma site is situated in Spain and, therefore, in the EU, while the national and regional governments have demonstrated an admirable engagement for its protection. Perhaps with JWST and ALMA expected to be in operation early in the next decade, the H2O problem should carry less weight than the excellent seeing. In any case, on the basis of presently available
Sites for Telescopes
105
Table VI, 1. Astronomical sites. Subsequent columns give the altitude in m, the percentage of photometric nights, the percentage of “spectroscopic” or usable time, the median seeing in arcsec as measured by a DIMM, the median column density of H2O in mm and the longitude and latitude. Note that these data sometimes are based on insufficiently long observations to yield a reliable long term average. Figures placed between the ph and sp columns give the percentage of clear time without the requirement of 6 hours continuously clear. Alt. Chacaltaya Chajnantor Paranal La Silla El Leoncito Mauna Kea S. Pedro Martír Sierra Negra Kitt Peak Mt. Graham McDonald Obs. La Palma Oukaimeden Calar Alto Maidanak Hanle La Réunion AAO Dome C
(Bolivia) (Chile) (Chile) (Chile) (Argentina) (Hawaii) (Mexico) (Mexico) (Arizona) (Arizona) (Texas) (Spain) (Marocco) (Spain) (Uzbekistan) (India) (France) (Australia) (Antarctica)
5400 5200 2700 2400 2400 4200 2800 4600 2100 3200 2000 2400 2700 2200 2600 4500 2900 1100 3250
% ph
% sp
)1
DIMM
)1
( (63) 76 61 48 55 64
( (81) 91 82 72 81
64 38 51 30 53 (38) 40 >755
67 75 65 73 652 57 60 71 (69) 65
H 2O 2.32
.703 .843 .604 .60 .73
1.2 2.2 3.8 2.0
6.72 2.9 .65 .92 .69 .8
.275
3.7
<2 (5) 0.255
I
b
68W 68W 70W 71W 69W 155W 115W 97W 112W 110W 104W 18W 8W 3W 67E 79E 55E 149E 123E
–16 –23 –25 –29 –32 +20 +31 +19 +32 +33 +34 +29 +31 +37 +39 +33 –21 –31 –75
average day time cloud cover 53%. 2 day time. 3 mean value × 0.9. 4 image diameter × 1.1. 5 winter only.
1
evidence, there would be only three plausible sites for a large European telescope: The Paranal area (Armazoni?), one of the summits around the Llano de Chajnantor and La Palma. Moving the NTT from La Silla to the Chajnantor area might be an effective way to test its suitability for future large telescopes. For the other two sites telescopes of sufficient size will continue to provide data for a comparison. Concerning Paranal and surroundings, much will depend on whether the deterioration of the last six years is a temporary aberration or not and on whether it affects Armazoni equally. Finally, it might be worthwhile to further study the Mexican sites which look promising, but for which the data are still very limited. Another site that at present evokes much interest is the South Pole. In the interior of Antarctica winds are very weak and the atmosphere extremely dry and cold. The SP is not very suitable for most observations in
106
Europe’s quest for the Universe
the visible, because it is astronomically dark (Sun more than 18 ° below the horizon) for only 79 days per year. Moreover, a turbulent layer at low altitude causes the seeing to be terrible. However, in the IR and submm domain this is not so much of a problem. Measurements made at 350 μm show that in the zenith direction the median atmospheric transmission is 0.30 versus 0.25 at Chajnantor and 0.15 at Mauna Kea28). The stability of the transmission is particularly favorable at the SP. However, the fraction of the sky accessible at small zenith angles is small, while at low latitude sites like Chajnantor it is much larger. For special projects, like the high precision determination of the fine structure of the Cosmic Microwave Background, the SP appears to be unsurpassed, but for a broader range of programs the advantage over sites like Chajnantor is not evident. Moreover, the Cornell measurements have shown that the water vapor content of the atmosphere above the Llano de Chajnantor may diminish rapidly with height27). So conditions on the surrounding mountains may well be as good as at the SP. Conditions appear to be much more favorable at “Dome C”, a high Antarctic plateau (3250 m) some 15 ° from the SP. Here a French-Italian cooperation has constructed the “Concordia” base for a variety of purposes. Dark time and the area of the sky at low zenith angles are already more favorable. The most outstanding characteristic of Dome C is its incredibly stable atmosphere. Recent measurements of atmospheric turbulence correspond to wintertime seeing with a median of 0.27 arcsec, spectacularly better than anywhere else in the world32). Also the angular distance over which the turbulent patterns are correlated and the slowness of their variation appear to be optimal. Though a longer term data set would be desirable, it seems probable that both for observations in the IR and for interferometry in the visible Dome C would offer unique advantages. However, in the absence of a large base at Dome C, it would not be very realistic to try to place a 100 m telescope like OWL there. So far we have discussed only conditions in the atmosphere. A serious threat comes from city lights, which even at tens of kilometers distance may cause a significant increase in the background luminosity of the sky. Even at La Silla and still more at Tololo this is becoming noticeable. Fortunately, the authorities in La Serena and in the Atacamean region are beginning to impose standards on street lighting which reduce the upward flux33). This has both economic and astronomical benefits. The difficult conditions of life in the Atacama desert for the moment limit light pollution at Paranal, though mining operations pose an ever present threat. In fact, the Yumba mine SE of Paranal has become increasingly visible. The commercial exploitation of space may also pose grave dangers. Various proposals for space advertising have been successfully defeated for now. However, experiments have been made to light cities in the Arctic by solar reflectors, and the risks to ground based astronomy are all too real.
Sites for Telescopes
107
In Chile earthquakes pose an additional danger. While modest earthquakes cause no greater problem than the temporary loss of the telescope pointing, larger ones may do more lasting damage. From the data of Barrientos34), an earthquake stronger than 7.5 on the Richter scale may be expected in the Paranal region once every 250 years. Of course, the damage would depend very much on its precise location. So the risk is small, but real.
VII. The VLT Observatory: Adaptive Optics, Instruments, Interferometry and Survey Telescopes
Die Daten der kosmischen Schöpfung sind ein nichts als betäubendes Bombardement unserer Intelligenz mit Zahlen, ausgestattet mit einem Kometenschweif von zwei Dutzend Nullen, die so tun, als ob sie mit Maß und Verstand noch irgend etwas zu tun hätten. Thomas Mann1)
The VLT array of four 8.2-m telescopes has been built, but many other aspects have to be taken care of before it could be a fully functioning observatory. The deleterious effects of the atmosphere have to be mitigated to obtain the full benefit of the large unit telescopes. A wide variety of instruments is needed to analyze the light collected. A substantial infrastructure is required to make use of the VLT as an interferometric array. And, finally, since the large telescopes can observe only a minuscule fraction of the sky, it would be beneficial to have wide angle survey telescopes – the successors to the Schmidt telescopes of the past – to discover important objects for the 8.2-m telescopes to study in detail.
Adaptive Optics (AO) The performance of ground based telescopes is degraded by the earth’s atmosphere, while space based telescopes are very expensive. So simple economics tells us that we should look for ways to reduce the atmospheric effects. In the ultraviolet the ozone layer is opaque, and in part of the infrared various atmospheric constituents block the incoming radiation. So in these wavelength ranges we have no choice but to observe with space telescopes.
110
Europe’s quest for the Universe
There are also some wavelength ranges in the IR where water vapor is the main problem. Hence, the selection of high, dry sites is advantageous. Observations at some submm wavelengths may be made from places like Chajnantor, Mauna Kea or even better from the high, cold Antarctic plateau. But even in the optical/near IR spectral domain from 0.3 – 2.5 μm, where the transparency is good, there is a serious problem: the atmospheric turbulence disturbs the incoming light rays making the astronomical images unsharp, or in astronomical parlance causing “seeing”. Typically the seeing smears out the image of a point-like star over an arcsecond or more, far larger than the intrinsic diffraction image of a telescope a few meters in diameter. This was one of the reasons the 2.4-m Hubble Space Telescope (HST) was constructed, which gave spectacular images with much fine detail not seen on images from ground based telescopes. However, by now, new technologies are being developed – adaptive optics – which allow equally excellent images to be obtained from the ground, at least in the near IR. When different layers of the atmosphere move at different speeds, turbulence tends to result at the interface. Different parcels of gas – different cells – then move in randomly different directions and at different speeds. This also causes small temperature variations, as a result of which the light rays passing through the medium are refracted and this leads to the diffusion of the images. The smallest turbulent cells are only a few cm across, and the pattern of cells may change on millisecond timescales. Suppose now that we take the image of a star with only a millisecond exposure time. Then the turbulence will effectively be “frozen”. The image of the star will be deformed by the turbulent medium, but during the millisecond it will not change much. We then observe another star, so near to the first one that its light passes through the same turbulent pattern. Its image will be deformed in the same way. We analyze the image of the first star, and we can find out how it has been deformed from the point-like image it should have had in the absence of the atmosphere and what corrections have to be applied to the deformed image to recover the true one. We now can apply these same corrections to the neighboring star and also recover its image. The next millisecond we will find somewhat different corrections, and again we can restore the image of the second star with these, and so on. Of course, all of this only works if the first star is sufficiently bright so that there is enough information in the image to determine the corrections. But the second star can be very much fainter or it may be a more composite image, like a double star that due to the seeing could not be resolved. In principle, to make an adaptive optics system we could deform the primary mirror of the telescope in such a way that it corrects for the seeing effects in exactly the same way as the active optics system in Figure III, 4. Instead of making the mirror optically more perfect as in that case, we could introduce the imperfections needed to compensate the seeing
The VLT Observatory
111
effects. However, the primary mirror is generally too heavy to do this on millisecond timescales. So a thin flexible mirror is introduced into the optical beam with the necessary actuators to shape it. Alternatively, it may be feasible to achieve the same result directly with the Cassegrain secondary mirror if it is made sufficiently thin2). The principle of adaptive optics is identical to that of active optics. However, apart from the faster response that is needed, there is one fundamental difference. The active optics corrections are valid in the whole focal plane. But since the turbulence pattern is different in different directions, the adaptive optics corrections are only valid in close proximity to the star from which they are determined. The size of the “isoplanatic patch” over which the corrections are well correlated depends on the wavelength. In the optical at 0.5 μm it is typically 2 arcsec on a good site. But in the near IR at 2.5 μm it would be about 14 arcsec. Also the corrections change more slowly. The number of actuators needed on the deformable mirror is proportional to the square of the diameter of the primary mirror. For an 8.2-m VLT telescope it is about 6000 at 0.5 μm wavelength, but at 2.5 μm only 125. So adaptive optics is much simpler in the near IR than at visible wavelengths. At ESO the first adaptive optics instrument was developed very much under the influence of Pierre Léna by a cooperation of ESO, ONERA in Paris and some French observatories. In 1990 this instrument “COME-ON” was placed at the 3.6-m telescope. It had 19 actuators on the flexible mirror and was intended to give perfect diffraction limited images at 3.5 μm. With the completion of the VLT, a MultiApplication Curvature Adaptive Optics (MACAO) program was implemented to build seven AO systems for some instruments and for the VLT Interferometer3). An example of the results from one of the VLTI systems is shown in Figure VII, 1. Also for the high resolution camera CONICA a German-French collaboration has constructed the AO system NAOS with 185 actuators, which gives diffraction limited images at 2.2 μm. Even at 1.2 μm the system worked well with 0.04 arcsec resolution, probably the best reached so far by any telescope on the ground or in space! It remains a formidable task, however, to advance to full adaptive optics correction at visible wavelengths around 0.5 μm. Both the fast image analysis and the control of the flexible mirror still pose some problems. We have not yet mentioned another limitation of adaptive optics. The reference star which determines the corrections to be applied has to be sufficiently bright. But within the small isoplanatic patch of an object we wish to study, there may not be such a star. Artificial laser stars may be the answer. There are two options. In the high atmosphere, about 100 km up, there is a layer of neutral sodium. Higher up the sodium is ionized, lower down it is incorporated into molecules. When we shine a laser tuned to the wavelength of the strong sodium D line onto this layer, some of the light is scattered back, creating an artificial star. Alternatively, laser light in the blue part of the spectrum may be scattered by nitrogen or oxygen molecules. If the laser is
112
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure VII, 1. Adaptive Optics. To the left a star imaged in the K-band (2.4 μm) at a time the atmospheric seeing was 0.75 arcsec. To the right the same star seen after the adaptive optics system for the VLTI was switched on. The resulting image shows that the “star” is actually a close double star with a separation of 0.12 arcsec between the components. The first AO system at ESO was COME-ON implemented in 1990 at the 3.6-m telescope. Not only is a more detailed image obtained, but also the sharp peak of light allows fainter objects to be detected above the background.
pulsed and if we suitably select the time delay of the returning light, the altitude of the apparent laser star is also determined because of the finite velocity of light. Even though there are many complications, the advantage of the laser star is that by pointing the laser beam in the right direction, we can ensure that it is within the isoplanatic patch around the object under study.
Instrumentation Each of the four 8.2-m unit telescopes has two Nasmyth foci and one Cassegrain focus. So at these foci one may install 12 instruments which can remain in place for long times. In the past, at the 3.6-m telescope with effectively just one Cassegrain focus, multiple instruments were used. The frequent instrument exchanges caused much loss of time, since new calibrations had to be made each time an instrument was replaced, and because malfunctions were most frequent when another instrument was put in place. At the VLT, each instrument is permanently placed until a new instrument or an upgrade arrives. As a result, quality and efficiency have much increased. The only exception is the “visitor focus” where astronomers from the community may place an experimental – or a niche – instrument they have developed. The construction of instruments for the VLT is a major undertaking. So it was neither feasible nor desirable for ESO to build all the instruments in-house. Instead, with some exceptions, most have been contracted out (competitively) to institutes, or more usually consortia of institutes, in the
The VLT Observatory
113
member countries: ESO would provide the funding for the industrial hardware and the institutes would provide the necessary personnel. In exchange, the institutes would receive a specified amount of privileged observing time outside the normal time allocation channels. After this time has been used up, the persons who have participated in the building of an instrument still have the advantage of a better knowledge of its potential and therefore a certain advantage in the preparation of proposals for the normal time allocation process. The participation of many institutes in the instrument building has created a much stronger sense of participation in the VLT by the community and fostered European cooperation in multinational consortia. We note that the ESO procedures are different from those at ESA, where the total cost of instruments is (in principle) assumed by the institutes of the member countries and their space agencies; correspondingly, the return of privileged observing time is also larger at ESA. However, in the meantime the situation at ESO has become more mixed. To ensure uniformity, also in later maintenance and data handling, ESO has taken more responsibility for the area of detectors and associated electronics. On the other hand, hardware expenses have also sometimes been assumed by the national institutes to speed up the construction. And, of course, ESO staff always has a role in ensuring that the instruments can be properly integrated at the telescope. The total cost and effort involved in the instrumentation is quite large. For example, UVES built at ESO cost some 2.5 M€ in money and in addition 40 man/years of effort. For the MIDI interferometric instrument the consortium members invested 1.8 M€ in hardware and 4.2 M€ in personnel costs. I would estimate that in total the instrumentation cost for ESO and the national institutes to-date is some 20% of the cost of the VLT itself. This is not very different from the situation at ESA where the national payload support (for instruments) during the nineties amounted to 24% of the spending of the Science program, the latter essentially used to build and manage the satellites. When a few decades ago ESO received instruments from astronomical institutes, the quality sometimes was modest. Loose wires would be hanging around, electronic interfaces or components would be incompatible with La Silla standards and data handling software limited. The situation now has changed. Most instruments built so far are of the highest engineering quality, and only in two cases did ESO have to cancel a contract. The improved quality of the work of the institutes is in part the result of their participation in the space program. An instrument built for a satellite has to undergo stringent tests and to meet certain deadlines. If not, the satellite may leave without it. The resulting attitudes towards quality control have benefitted ESO and also the participating industries. The selection of the 11 facility instruments has been preceded by much consultation with the community. Some instruments have been functioning for six years, others have just been finished. At the same time, plans for
114
Europe’s quest for the Universe
second generation instruments have been made. In Figure VII, 2 and Table VII, 1 the instruments located at the four unit telescopes are identified. Around full moon the sky is too luminous to observe faint objects at visible wavelengths, but in the IR this is less of a problem. Also observations of brighter objects at very high spectral resolution are not much affected. So each unit telescope has at least one instrument in these categories. Six of the instruments are imagers. With filters broad or narrow wavelength ranges may be selected. The near IR imagers are provided with adaptive optics. Different angular resolutions may be obtained, with the corresponding field of view determined by the size of the detector. The better the resolution, the smaller the angular field of view. Even though it does not have a real adaptive optics system, ISAAC has yielded excellent images which
Figure VII, 2. The VLT and its instruments. From left to right, the four unit telescopes with their Mapuche names. UT1: Antu, the Sun; UT2: Kueyen, the Moon; UT3: Melipal, the Southern Cross; UT4: Yepun, Sirius. In front, the stations where the auxiliary interferometric telescopes may be placed. Schematically, the subterranean tubes are shown through which the light reaches the VLTI laboratory, which houses the delay lines (Figure VII, 7), the beam combiners and the interferometric instruments. Between UT3 and UT4 the 2.6 m VLT Survey Telescope, VST, is visible. VISTA is a 4-m IR survey telescope on NTT hill.
The VLT Observatory
115
Table VII, 1. Instruments at the VLT. The columns from left to right give the year of completion, the unit telescope and the focus Nasmyth or Cassegrain, the acronym, the wavelength range in μm, the characteristics with im for imager and the maximum spectral resolution for spectrographic modes, the largest field of view in arcminutes, the smallest number of arcsec per detector pixel indicative of the angular resolution and the eventual combination with adaptive optics, the maximum number of spectra taken in multiple object spectroscopic mode and the presence of an integral field unit (IFU) or of a long slit (ls), the number of pixels on the detector in units of a million, and a reference to an article in the ESO Messenger. It is important to note that the field of view is smaller if the angular resolution is high and that at high spectroscopic resolutions multiplicity of objects is smaller. For a more complete review of the instruments, the articles in the “Messenger” or the ESO web pages should be consulted.
Year
UT
Name
λ (μm)
1998 1999 1999 2002 2002 1998 2001 2004 2004 2004 2006 2007 2010
1C 2C 2N 3N 2N 1N 4N 4C 1N 3C N C N
FORS1 FORS2 UVES VIMOS FLAMES ISAAC NAOS-CONICA SINFONI CRIRES VISIR HAWK-1 X-shooter KMOS
0.3–1.1 0.3–1.1 0.3–1.0 0.4–1.0 0.4–1.0 0.9–5 1–5 1.1–2.5 1-5 8–25 0.9–2.5 0.3–1.9 0.9–2.5
max res im, 1800 im, 5000 115000 im, 2500 47000 im, 3000 im, 2000 4000 100000 im, 25000 im 7000 4000
max FOV (arcm)
min arcs/pix
MOS
Mpix
ref
7 7 0.2 15 25 2.5 1.2 0.13 0.8 1 7.5 0.2 7.2
0.1 0.1 0.5 0.2 0.5 0.15 0.013 AO 0.025 AO 0.1 AO 0.075 0.1 AO? 0.6 0.2 AO?
19 100 7 ls 1000, IFU 125, IFU ls ls IFU ls ls – ls IFU
4 4 16/8 8 8 1 1 4 4 0.06 16 8/1
a a b c d e f g h i j j j
References: a. ESO Messenger 94, 1, 1998; b. 99, 1, 2000; c. 109, 21, 2002; d. 110, 1, 2002; e. 95, 1, 1999; f. 107, 1, 2002; g. 117, 17, 2004; h. 114, 5, 2003; i. 117, 12, 2004; j. 115, 8, 2004.
frequently show very different features from those seen in the visible. In many heavily absorbing nebulae ISAAC can penetrate the absorbing dust and study star formation. Also interesting multicolor observations in the solar system may be obtained. In the case of Jupiter different wavelengths show different features because of the different absorption by methane and other molecules (Figure VII, 3). Particularly spectacular results on the center of our galaxy have been obtained with NAOS-CONICA (Figure VII, 4)4). In visible light it is unobservable because of very heavy interstellar absorption. However, in the near IR numerous stars shine through (left figure). One of these is extremely close to the radio source Sagittarius A* which is believed to be coincident with the black hole at the Galactic Center. In fact, repeated observations, first with
116
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure VII, 3. False color combination of several broad and narrow band images of Jupiter in the 3.2–4.1 μm spectral range. The auroral oval is well visible. The energetic particles which create the aurorae interact with the atmosphere and generate the “blue haze” which is spread around in longitude by the strong zonal winds.
Figure VII, 4. The Galactic Center imaged by NAOS-CONICA. To the left the orbit of the star (S2) closest to the radio source Sagittarius A*, which describes an elliptical orbit with 15.2 year period around it. This effectively demonstrates that Sag A* is coincident with the 2.6 million solar mass black hole at the Galactic Center. At the moment of closest approach Sag A* was hidden by the star. To the right are two exposures in the IR of the area of the Galactic Center taken later in 2002 after Sag A* became again observable. In the image at t = 0 no emission was visible at its location, but 39 minutes later (t = 39) it had erupted, presumably due to some matter spiralling into the black hole.
The VLT Observatory
117
the NTT and later with the VLT, have enabled to determine the highly elliptical orbit of this star around Sag A* (left figure). It has a period of 15.2 years and passed closest to Sag A* in April 2002 at a distance of about 0.015 arcsec or 17 light hours with a speed of 8000 km/sec. The origin of this star and others close by is baffling. But these results show the incredible power of a large diameter high quality telescope with Adaptive Optics. At the moment of closest approach Sag A* was hidden by the star. As this star began to move away, Sag A* became observable again. Hour long bursts of IR radiation were detected which were precisely coincident with this object. Also XMM-Newton (Chapter XI) has detected X-ray bursts from the area of the Galactic Center. However, its angular resolution is inadequate to prove that the X-rays come from Sag A*, though that is the most likely interpretation. A typical spectrograph consists of a slit through which the light enters, a dispersing element (prism, grism, grating), some further optics and a detector. With a relatively long slit the spectra of more than one star or of a slice of an extended object like a galaxy may be determined. But if, for example, we wish to measure the redshifts of the numerous faint galaxies in a field of view, it is unlikely that more than two or three will be located exactly on the slit. It is here that the Multiple Object Spectrographs (MOS) come in: numerous slitlets are placed in the focal plane at the positions of stars or galaxies to obtain their spectra. Two ways to do this are employed in the VLT instruments. The simplest is the metal mask with small slits cut in. First, an image of a certain field is taken and the positions of the objects of interest determined. Subsequently, the slitlets are cut at these positions. At first this was done mechanically, now a laser cutter is used which does this much faster. The most extreme MOS is VIMOS which allows up to 1000 slitlets in one go (Figure VII, 5). Of course, for each new field a new mask is to be made. The alternative is to use fiber optics. Small lenses coupled to optical fibers are mounted on arms so that they may be placed anywhere in the field. Through the fibers the light reaches the slit of a long slit spectrograph. In the case of FLAMES, 125 fibers allow 125 spectra to be stacked above each other. It is necessary to design the system of fibers so that they cannot collide or become entangled. An alternative type of spectrograph is the Integral Field Unit. Here a two-dimensional array of contiguous lenslets images a certain area. Subsequently, the light of all these lenslets is projected on a slit spectrograph. In the case of SINFONI, the array consists of 32 × 32 lenslets, and so 1024 spectra are taken at the same time. Thus, a star cluster or a galaxy can be completely analyzed all at once. At very high resolutions more conventional single slit spectrographs with échelle gratings have been constructed. In the échelle format different segments of the spectrum are stacked above each other on the detector. So a large stretch of spectrum at high spectral resolution can be obtained. In the case of UVES, the segments are separated by 12 arcsec and so there is
118
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure VII, 5. Some 220 stellar spectra taken simultaneously by VIMOS with a spectral resolution of 250. With VIMOS up to 1000 spectra may be taken at the same time.
space for the spectra of some other objects in between. A mode has been developed in which UVES at one Nasmyth focus of UT2 is coupled to FLAMES at the other focus with 50-m long fibers; this allows seven stars to be observed at the same time. Three new instruments are being planned. HAWK-1 will be an imager and KMOS an Integral Field Spectrograph, both for the near IR and both covering as large an area as possible. When adaptive optics on the secondary mirror are implemented (as on the LBT, Chapter V), this would further enhance the performance. X-shooter would be a spectrograph that allows simultaneous coverage of the visible and most of the near IR. Irrespective of the details of their construction, all spectrographs share a very much increased efficiency. Through mirrors or fibers the spectra are stacked in such a way that most pixels of the detectors obtain useful data; nothing is wasted. The VLT has become very much one integrated facility. Observers for all telescopes are located in the VLT control center. By activating remotely controlled mirrors, they may switch in seconds from one instrument to another and in each instrument between different imaging and spectroscopic modes. During routine observation, manual intervention on the spot should not be needed. Unless something goes wrong, it is not necessary to touch the instruments since they all have their fixed place. In fact, most observers need not see their telescope at all!
The VLT Observatory
119
Interferometry A high angular resolution requires a large telescope. However, it is not necessary that all of the mirror surface be covered with reflecting material. In fact, if a number of small reflecting areas are suitably chosen, much of the image resolution is preserved, but, of course, the light collecting power is diminished. If now these reflecting areas are mounted individually, the situation is no different. Hence, instead of building a 10-m telescope, one could build a number of 1-m telescopes and obtain a comparable angular resolution. This is the principle of the interferometer where light is combined from a number of independent telescopes scattered over an area large compared to the areas of the individual telescopes (Figure VII, 6). There is, however, one difference. In a single surface telescope the optical path length to different parts of the mirror is the same, no matter what the orientation of the telescope is. In two separately mounted mirrors this is no longer the case, and the path length difference depends on the direction of the object being studied. To compensate for this, “delay lines” are introduced which allow the optical path to the different telescopes to be equalized. Since the optical path length should be stable to a fraction of a wavelength, the delay lines represent high precision optomechanical systems (Figure VII, 7). Of course, the positions of the mirror surfaces should be equally stable. Vibrations of the telescope mechanics and of the soil on which they rest should be minimized. In interferometry the atmospheric turbulence is also a major obstacle and with large telescopes adaptive optics is essential. At the VLT the four telescopes have fixed locations, and this is insufficient to obtain complete interferometric images. To improve the situation, four mobile 1.8-m telescopes are being added to the interferometer, so that by positioning these in various places a better approximation to a large telescope may be realized. While in this way the image quality may approach that of a 200-m telescope, the limiting brightness corresponds to that of a 1.8-m telescope. Still the angular resolution of a milliarcsecond at 1 μm wavelength should allow very detailed observations of numerous interesting objects. Since the tolerances of the optomechanical systems are proportional to the wavelength and since AO is required, the VLT interferometer has been initially restricted to the nearer infrared. Observations at longer wavelengths are also foreseen, but since the atmosphere radiates rather strongly in the “windows” around 10 and 20 μm, even on as dry a site as Paranal, very faint objects cannot be observed. For most interferometry in the midand far-infrared space based interferometers are required. Both ESA and NASA are planning such interferometers, but the technological challenges are daunting. Several facility instruments are being constructed for the beam combination in the VLTI laboratory5): MIDI6) (2003) is a mid IR (8–13 μm)
120
Europe’s quest for the Universe
Figure VII, 6. Interferometry with two independent telescopes of the VLT array. Several flat mirrors bring the light beams from the moving Nasmyth focus to the stationary coudé focus. Since the light waves from a star will reach the two telescopes at variably different times, delay lines (essentially moving mirrors, see Figure VII, 7) are inserted to ensure that the optical path length remains the same. Then the two beams can be made to interfere in the Beam Combination Lab, resulting in an image composed of bright and dark stripes – the interferometric fringes.
instrument which combines the beams of two telescopes and provides a spectral resolution of 300. AMBER 7) (2004), a near IR instrument (1–2.4 μm), can combine three beams. This is important because then “closure phase” techniques (developed by radio astronomers) may be used which improve the image quality. It provides spectral resolutions of 10,000.
The VLT Observatory
121
Figure VII, 7. The VLT interferometric tunnel with the delay lines. These have to be extremely straight and accurate to ensure that differences in optical path length remain much l