English Clandestine Satire 1660–1702
This page intentionally left blank
English Clandestine Satire 1660–1702 HAROLD...
208 downloads
3042 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
English Clandestine Satire 1660–1702
This page intentionally left blank
English Clandestine Satire 1660–1702 HAROLD LOVE
1
3
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford ox2 6dp Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Bangkok Buenos Aires Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kolkata Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi São Paulo Shanghai Taipei Tokyo Toronto Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Harold Love 2004 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2004 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Data available ISBN 0-19-925561-x 1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2 Typeset in Sabon by Jayvee, Trivandrum, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd., King’s Lynn, Norfolk
Acknowledgements My interest in scribally transmitted clandestine satire began in the mid-1960s at the time when it was first opened for serious scholarly study by the publication of David M. Vieth’s Attribution in Restoration Poetry, John Harold Wilson’s Court Satires of the Restoration, and the early volumes of the Yale Poems on Affairs of State series, all of which have remained foundational to the subject. At a later date I profited from the published scholarship and personal encouragement of Peter Beal, John Burrows, Andrew Carpenter, Nicholas Fisher, Paul Hammond, Robert D. Hume, Hilton Kelliher, Arthur Marotti, and Timothy Raylor, to all of whom I am indebted. The death of Keith Walker while this book was in the press deprived me of an unfailing source of knowledge, friendship, and encouragement. Many other friends and colleagues have contributed useful suggestions and help in locating sources and I have also received a great deal of assistance over the years from librarians, among whom I particularly need to mention Stephen Parks and Earle Havens, of the Osborn Collection at the Yale University Library. Among my Monash colleagues Wallace Kirsop and Clive Probyn have been generous with time and knowledge. While preparing the first edition of The Penguin Book of Restoration Verse (1968) I acquired microfilms of a number of the primary sources for clandestine satire, which were added to across the years. A simple first-line index of this material proved invaluable in investigating connections between sources and allowing me to frame questions about the nature of transmission, authorship, and reception. A chapter on ‘Restoration Scriptorial Satire’ in my Scribal Publication in Seventeenth-Century England (1993) was my first attempt to synthesize this material; however, this did not address the problem of how to identify authors, which, over a much broader field, is the subject of my Attributing Authorship: An Introduction (2002). Work for my edition of Rochester (1999) deepened my practical acquaintance with every aspect of scribal culture and demanded the acquisition of more microfilms. A three-year grant by the Australian Research Council allowed me to employ Meredith Sherlock to
vi
Acknowledgements
prepare detailed indexes of all the major sources then known to me (several through the agency of Peter Beal). Her invaluable, meticulously prepared lists were then used to generate a much improved first-line index, a version of which is included in this book as the Appendix. Further indexes were prepared by Felicity Henderson who in 2001–2 also reviewed the entire body of indexes. My debt to both of them is great, as will be that of all future scholars who make use of their indexes, which it is hoped can eventually be made available for reference through the Monash English Department website. A substantial proportion of the sources themselves are to be published in 2005 in a microfilm edition by Adam Matthew Publications. I must also thank Anthony Butler and Tracey Caulfield for their assistance with the final checking of the typescript. I am deeply grateful for the support of Oxford University Press in publishing what has turned out to be a trilogy of studies, the first the general survey of scribal publishing, the second the edition of a major author who worked in the medium, and now the extended survey of the literary genre in which that author made his most important contribution. Finally, as always, my thanks and gratitude to my wife Rosaleen, our children and grandchildren, and our dog, the all-too-aptly named Wilmot, for providing the perfect antidote to so many years of absorption with a world of the imagination not notable for its cultivation of the finer human feelings. H.L. Monash University Clayton, Victoria
Contents Abbreviations
viii
A Note on Texts and Citations
ix
1 Origins and Models
1
2 The Court Lampoon
21
3 The Town Lampoon
66
4 State Satire
99
5 Lampoon Authorship
151
6 The Lampoon as Gossip
191
7 A Poetics of the Lampoon
218
8 Transmission and Reception
248
Appendix: First-Line Index to Selected Anthologies of Clandestine Satire
303
Select Bibliography
415
Index
421
Abbreviations CSP (Dom) CSR Dorset, Poems Dryden, Works
POAS (1702–7)
POASY
Rochester, Works SPISCE
Calendars of State Papers (Domestic Series) John Harold Wilson (ed.), Court Satires of the Restoration (Columbus: Ohio State UP, 1976) The Poems of Charles Sackville, Sixth Earl of Dorset, ed. Brice Harris (London: Garland, 1979) The Works of John Dryden, ed. Edward Niles Hooker, H. T. Swedenberg Jr., and Alan Roper, 20 vols. (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1956–89) Poems on Affairs of State, 4 vols. (London, 1702–7) [Case 211 (1) (e) 1702; (2) (a) 1703; (3) (a) 1704; 211 (4) (a) 1707] George deF. Lord (gen. ed.), Poems on Affairs of State: Augustan Satirical Verse 1660–1714, 7 vols. (New Haven: Yale UP, 1963–75) The Works of John Wilmot, Earl of Rochester, ed. Harold Love (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1999) Harold Love, Scribal Publication in SeventeenthCentury England (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993)
A Note on Texts and Citations Some anomalies in the citation of sources require explanation. Wherever possible clandestine satires are quoted from the annotated, modern-spelling, edited texts in POASY and CSR, where they can easily be located for reference. Where a satire is cited from a manuscript source, the text and title are given in the exact spelling and punctuation of that source except for common contractions being silently expanded; however, the first line, which is used throughout this book as the primary identifier, will be in the standardized form found in the Appendix (pp. 303–414), and therefore in modern spelling and without punctuation. Where no first line is cited it is because the first line is already contained in a quoted passage. In that case it will be in the version and spelling of the source of that quotation, which may differ in some particulars from that of the Appendix, but not to the extent of making it unlocatable. All quotations are cited to a source. When a satire not directly quoted is identified by a first line but not a source, the Appendix should be referred to for locations.
This page intentionally left blank
1
Origins and Models George Villiers, second Duke of Buckingham (1628–87) has not had a good press. A still current view would have him a glamorous lightweight with an unrealistic estimate of his military and political capacities whose attempts at great achievements all ended in failure. Accounts routinely narrate the sordid incidents of what looks at first sight like an entertaining but futile existence.1 He followed the king into exile and then deserted him in order to make peace with the Protector. Having smarmed his way back into favour at the Restoration, he used his talent for ridicule to undermine devoted patriots such as Clarendon, Arlington, and Sir William Coventry. He developed an absurd crush on the king’s sister and chased her to Paris when she was already engaged to the brother of Louis XIV, thus sparking an international incident. He associated with revolutionary sectaries without suspecting their evil designs. He was a bisexual rake who was prosecuted for sodomy. He ruthlessly killed the husband of his mistress while she was present disguised as a boy and slept with her afterwards in the shirt stained with her murdered husband’s blood. When his wife complained about the relationship he told her to pack her things and go back to her father. Plays and poems attributed to him were largely written by others. He was the dupe of alchemists and foolishly believed he could restore his health and fortune by finding the philosopher’s stone. Charles II sent him on sham embassies, when the real negotiations were in other hands. Having been dismissed from his ministerial post for incompetence, he petulantly joined the Whigs but was never taken seriously even by them. He made foolish speeches in parliament which led to his being sent to the Tower. His ears, as Samuel Butler put it, ‘were perpetually drilled with a Fiddlestick’. He squandered a vast fortune through being 1 For the life see Winifred, Lady Burghclere, George Villiers, Second Duke of Buckingham (London: John Murray, 1903), Hester Chapman, Great Villiers (London: Secker and Warburg, 1949), and John Harold Wilson, A Rake and his Times (New York: Farrar, 1954).
2
Origins and Models
‘Begger’d by Fools’, as Dryden put it, and died a miserable death, as Pope put it, in ‘the worst inn’s worst room’.2 Not much of this is supportable. Buckingham’s misfortune was to have lived at a time when there was little reliable information about events at the upper reaches of power. Court politics was premissed on exclusivity—kings were not accustomed to take their subjects into their confidence. Newspapers only appeared relatively late in the century and at most periods prior to 1694 were subject to state censorship. An indiscreet pamphlet might send its author and printer to prison or the gallows. The enormous information vacuum thus created was filled by gossip, correspondence, and clandestine satire, each (as we will see) feeding off the others. Buckingham’s life as it is told today is essentially one that has been compiled from satires—a process as likely to yield a balanced account as if the lives of presentday political leaders were to be written from newspaper caricatures or impersonations by stand-up comedians. In Buckingham’s case the satires would fill a book. The opening of one of them, not altogether implausibly attributed to Dryden, will indicate the style. It begins with a distillation of what earlier satires had said about Buckingham’s famous father. I sing the Praise of a Worthy Wight, Whose Father King Jemmy that never wou’d fight For his Face, but more for his Arse made a Knight; With a fa, la, la, la. This Knight soone after a Duke became, And got at the Island of Rhee such Fame That all true English curse Buckingham. With a fa, la, la, la. This Idoll Duke, to that greatnesse did swell, That Honours, and Riches, before him fell, Till Felton, the Brave, sent his Grace to Hell With a fa, la, la, la. And now shall heare how mighty the Son With that very small Sin of Incest begun And then to Treason and Bugg’ry went on With a fa, la, la, la. 2 Butler, Characters, ed. Charles W. Daves (Cleveland: Case Western Reserve UP, 1970), 67; Dryden, Works, ii. 22; The Poems of Alexander Pope, ed. John Butt (London: Methuen, 1963), 583.
Origins and Models
3
For the Incest Old Richmond, can tell when and where, For the Treason, the papers of Old Oliver; And Kenistons Arse, knows his Buggerer With a fa, la, la, la. Now he who soe bravely, and Nobly begins, Must afterwards thinke (when such glory he wins) Adult’ry and Treason, but triviall Sins . . .3
The poem was circulating in manuscript by 1680, together with a parody of the Anglican litany to be sung to the same tune, which recounts in compressed form every accusation made against Buckingham its writer could remember. From a sensual, proud, atheistical life, From arming our lackeys with pistol and knife, From murd’ring the husband and whoring the wife, Libera nos. From going ambassadors only as panders, From re-killing dead kings with monstrous slanders, From betraying the living in Scotland and Flanders, Libera nos. From a wild rambling nowhere abode, Without day or night, nor at home nor abroad, From a prince to unhorse us on Dover road, Libera nos. From crowning the hearse of our babe of adultery, Interr’d among kings by a lord of the prelacy, Whom we got cashier’d for carnal arsery, Libera nos. From selling land, twice ten thousand a year, All spent, no mortal can tell how or where, And then reform kingdoms as a sanctifi’d peer, Libera nos . . .4
And so on to a total of sixty lines, not counting ‘Libera nos’. What is telling about this passage is that its writer is able to assume that each of his highly compacted biographical allusions will be intelligible to 3 ‘A New Ballad to an Old Tune Call’d Sage Leafe’, Yale MS Osborn b 105, pp. 369–71. ‘Sage Leaf ’ is unrecorded in Claude M. Simpson, The British Broadside Ballad and its Music (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers UP, 1966) but the lines go well to ‘Cavalilly Man’ (pp. 87–9). 4 POASY, ii. 192–3.
4
Origins and Models
readers—in other words, that they had access to a detailed life history not obtainable from any printed source, but only from gossip and earlier lampoons. The papers of ‘Old Oliver’, if they survived at all, were not available for the asking, nor would ‘Old Richmond’, the duke’s sister, so called to distinguish her from a younger, concurrent bearer of the same title, have been willing to answer questions about putative incest. The lampoon genre was the bearer of a vast secret history of the times with which politically active members of society were assumed to be familiar. Further attacks on Buckingham will be cited later in this book. The question that immediately arises is ‘Why Buckingham?’ He could not have had the career he did at the centre of English politics if even a fraction of the accusations made against him were true. A long satire on his enthusiastic reception in 1677 by the mayor and aldermen of Oxford gives the game away Now when as the Duke he appeared in sight They all march’d out in their scarlet so bright, And Carfax bells they did ring out right, For the Duke was come to the town-a, For the Duke was come to the town-a.5
Could it be that he was much more formidable than we imagine: a dangerous political opponent who had to be stopped by any means? In any case most of the accusations recorded in the opening paragraph are demonstrably untrue. The civil war desertion sprung as much from fundamental policy differences within the royalist court in exile as personal disloyalty. Buckingham championed accommodation with the English and Scottish Presbyterians as a means of regaining the throne, a policy resisted by both the Anglicans around Clarendon and the crypto-Catholic king. He pursued that goal after his return to England by allying himself with Fairfax against Cromwell, and remained a lifelong advocate of toleration. His reputation for promiscuity was very likely exaggerated and, in any case, was nothing unusual for his time, or ours. His relative Brian Fairfax insisted that ‘He was the onely person in a vicious age and Court that was publicly censured for Weomen; not so much out of hatred to the Crime, as the Person. He lay under so ill a name for it, that if he was 5 ‘A Proper New Ballad Concerning the Reception of his Grace the Duke of Buckingham by the Right Worshipful the Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Oxon. 1677’, ll. 36–40, ibid., i. 432.
Origins and Models
5
shut up with a Fox hunter, a Chymist, a Poll, or Poet, it was sayd to be with a woman.’6 His pursuit of the Duchess of Orléans, almost an adoptive sister, was so far from causing an international incident that Louis XIV regarded it as a great joke at the expense of his unpleasant brother—which may have been how Buckingham meant it. The prosecution for sodomy (with a female not a male) was a trumped-up one engineered by the notorious Colonel Blood in which Buckingham was vindicated by the court and his accusers punished. If he had a homosexual relationship with the actor Edward Kynaston (a claim made only in ‘Sage Leaf’), they were both consenting adults. He fought a duel with the Earl of Shrewsbury because he could not honourably refuse it, and wounded but did not kill him. Shrewsbury’s unexpected death was the result of septicaemia. The countess was in France at the time. Buckingham’s life with his duchess had its ups and downs like many marriages but she always stood by him when loyalty was called for, including an episode when she raced a king’s messenger in her coach to warn him of an impending arrest. Fairfax records that they lived ‘loveingly togeather, she patiently bearing with those faults in him which she could not remedy’.7 His interest in chemistry was a perfectly serious one: a volume of scientific notes prepared for him is preserved at Alnwick Castle.8 Dramatic writing was a recreation which he liked to pursue collaboratively in the company of friends but it can hardly be questioned that the principal works—The Rehearsal, Sir Politick Wouldbe, The Country Gentleman, and the adaptation of Fletcher’s The Chances—are informed by his distinctive spirit of urbane mockery. Far from being bubbled out of his estate, he shrewdly put it into the management of sympathetic City bankers who paid off his debts and gave him a guaranteed income of £5,000 a year—a princely sum for those days. This device—the origin of today’s family trusts—also protected the estate from seizure by the crown.9 He was a founder not a follower of the Whig party and its principal public face in parliamentary and municipal election campaigns. Anthony Wood bitterly resented his influence among the townspeople of Oxford.10 ‘Account of the Family of Fairfax’, BL MS Harl. 6862, fos. 21r–v. 8 Ibid. fo. 24r. MS 609. 9 See Frank T. Melton, ‘A Rake Refinanced: The Fortune of George Villiers, Second Duke of Buckingham, 1671–1685’, HLQ 51 (1998), 297–318. 10 The Life and Times of Anthony Wood, ed. Andrew Clark (Oxford: Oxford Historical Society, 1891–1900), ii. 391, 516. 6 7
6
Origins and Models
He died after falling ill far from home at the end of a day’s hunting. He was taken to the best not the worst house in the nearest village— Pope’s squalid room is entirely imaginary.11 Buckingham certainly had his faults but the highly coloured picture that has been conveyed to us by means of clandestine satire is one that was concocted by his enemies for the purpose of countering his political influence. Had he lived a few months longer to see the triumph of his cause in the Revolution of 1688, history and poetry would probably both have come to kinder verdicts. Instead, his reputation was mortally wounded by satire in exactly the way he had wounded the reputations of others through his own satires. Having said that, we must also acknowledge that the ‘Buckingham’ created by the satirists is a fascinating figure in its own right, and one that reveals a great deal about the dreams and nightmares of the Restoration political imagination. The lampoon lived by the hyperreal and fantastical, and it was in hyperreality and fantasy that early modern subjectivities were founded. The virtuosi who gathered at Gresham College to inaugurate a new way of modelling the world through number and exact measurement; the political arithmeticians who debated with Sir William Petty and Gregory King, with uneasy glances over their shoulders at Hobbes, whether the same mechanistic principles might yield an account of the operations of society; and the philosophers who followed Locke in his rejection of the figurative from the operations of thought in favour of a regulated discourse of corporeal reason, could at any time have exploded the narratives of the actions of great persons presented to them through satire and gossip; but as far as we are able to tell they swallowed them whole. Pepys, who was one of their number, certainly did. Perhaps Hobbes had predisposed them to accept that the lowest common denominator of human motivations was likely to yield the most accurate account of any given action. The ever-extending reach of scepticism spared the lampoon. Politics at all its levels from that of the village to that of the nation was to remain something perceived in mythic terms, with its real-life performers encased behind masks of their own or someone’s else’s imposing. 11 See Stuart Gillespie, ‘ “The worst inn’s worst room”: Pope’s Setting for Buckingham’s Death’, N&Q 235 (1990), 306–8. This and other matters raised are considered in fuller detail in the biographical introduction to the forthcoming OUP critical edition of Buckingham, edited by Robert D. Hume and Harold Love.
Origins and Models
7
modes and origins Clandestine satire is satire written for circulation through means other than the licensed press, which is to say by oral recitation, manuscript transcription, or surreptitious printing. Of these, the first two predominated in both volume and authority. It arises from poetic traditions independent of and often actively hostile to those fostered by the metropolitan book trade. Clandestine satires are usually referred to in this book as ‘lampoons’, but this is purely a matter of convenience, which involves some stretching of the contemporary meaning of that term. In their own day they would have been lumped under the umbrella term ‘libels’. The view of both private and public life given by clandestine satire was distorted, irreverent, and partial; but where many important events and issues were concerned it might be the only written commentary available. Irrespective of one’s sympathy with its viewpoints, one had to consult it for clues to what was likely to befall the nation, and when one did so some of its mud was bound to stick. So much for Buckingham! The richness of this verse repertoire is demonstrated for the period 1660–1714 by the admirable seven-volume Yale University Press Poems on Affairs of State series, which borrows its title from a series of collections published between 1689 and 1707 of satirical and also non-satirical verse, much of which had formerly circulated only in manuscript.12 However, political satires were only one part of the huge body of verse lampoons written, and even of these only a proportion has ever been available in print. For the period before 1660 the best current guide is Arthur Marotti’s in the second chapter of Manuscript, Print and the English Renaissance Lyric.13 The carryover of themes and forms from one period to the other was considerable, yet, curiously, the many manuscript anthologies of Restoration lampoons that survive contain very little pre-1660 material. The world the later satirists addressed and the social and political questions that stirred them to verse were both different from those of 12 Cited in this study as POAS (1702–7), from the last and most comprehensive collection, issued in four volumes of which the first reprints two separate, earlier collections, each with its own pagination. The Yale collection (gen. ed. George deF. Lord) is cited as POASY. 13 (Ithaca, NY: Cornell UP, 1995), 75–133. See also Harold Love and Arthur F. Marotti, ‘Manuscript Transmission and Circulation’, in David Loewenstein and Janel Mueller (eds.), The Cambridge History of Early Modern English Literature (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2002), 55–80.
8
Origins and Models
their parents’ generation. Robert D. Hume has argued that scholarship should always avoid ‘dangerously generalized contexts’ such as ‘the seventeenth century’ and ‘the Victorian frame of mind’, warning that ‘the context that does not come from within the decade at issue is unlikely to be anything but misleading’.14 In what follows I will be examining a number of contexts for the writing and reading of lampoons which stretch for as long as forty years—a procedure whose risks have always been vividly present. In order not to worsen the situation even more, I have chosen to reduce my coverage of the preRestoration lampoon to the minimum of information necessary to begin the study of its successor. Timothy Raylor’s invaluable study of mid-seventeenth-century burlesque and satire and future accounts promised by Andrew McRae of the earlier seventeenth century and Steven May of Elizabethan clandestine satire will help in establishing longer continuities, discontinuities, and recurrences; but even then we may well find that we are dealing with the pursuit of different goals by similar means.15 From very early times, individuals who behaved in ways that were displeasing to a community have been mocked in verse, often to the accompaniment of music and mimicry. One form of this was the ‘rough music’ of the traditional British skimmington but related forms of shaming can still be observed in any schoolyard.16 Horace believed that stage comedy and literary satire had arisen from such rituals, which in Roman Italy were associated with the gatherings of farm families after the harvest: Through this custom came into use the Fescennine licence, which in alternate verse poured forth rustic taunts; and the freedom, welcomed each returning year, was innocently gay, till jest, now growing cruel, turned to open frenzy, and stalked amid the homes of honest folk, fearless in its threatening.17 14 Reconstructing Contexts: The Aims and Principles of Archaeo-historicism (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1999), 60, 139–40. 15 Timothy Raylor, Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture: Sir John Mennes, James Smith and the Order of the Fancy (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1994). 16 For the skimmington, see in particular Douglas Gray, ‘Rough Music: Some Early Invectives and Flytings’, YES 14 (1984), 21–43; Martin Ingram, ‘Ridings, Rough Music and Mocking Rhymes in Early Modern England’, in Barry Reay (ed.), Popular Culture in Seventeenth-Century England (London: Routledge, 1985), 166–97; and James Grantham Turner, Libertines and Radicals in Early Modern London: Sexuality, Politics and Literary Culture, 1630–1685 (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2002), 32–7, 47–73. 17 Epistles 2. 1. 145–50, from Horace, Satires, Epistles, Ars Poetica, trans. H. Rushton Fairclough (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard UP, 1955), 409.
Origins and Models
9
At various stages in the ancient world versions of this improvised folk poetry made the transition to literate culture, as in abusive verses inscribed on walls at Pompeii and Herculaneum. In Greece and Rome this eventually gave rise to the satirical epigram as practised by Martial and Catullus, the versified curse, as exercised in the iambics of Archilochus and the Ibis of Ovid, and, most prestigiously, the extended verse satire and satirical epistle of Lucilius, Horace, Persius, and Juvenal. In Celtic societies, the duties of a court bard might include the ritual cursing of enemies and the giving of licensed criticism to rulers, as in the rhymes of Lear’s fool.18 The Scots Dunbar and Kennedie drew in their famous ‘flyting’ on an indigenous tradition of competitive excoriation similar to that described by Horace.19 Early modern England possessed a similar folk heritage of orally composed communal satire which passed over first into literacy and then literature. Examples of shaming verse composed in small towns and villages have been discussed by C. J. Sisson, David Underdown, Alastair Bellany, and Adam Fox.20 Underdown found that organized shaming behaviour was likely to be strongest in the ‘regions of arable cultivation covering much of southern and Eastern England’ where villages were ‘nucleated, tightly packed around church and manor-house (often with a resident squire), the whole structure firmly bound by neighbourhood and custom’, as opposed to more dispersed woodland and pastoral communities.21 The arable community was also more likely to resist the attempts of the godly to suppress seasonal revelry. In Sisson’s main example the victim was a Puritan vicar of Stratford-upon-Avon. Yet, shaming behaviour could just as easily be provoked by simple violations of the moral code, especially through unchastity. Moreover, there is no need to believe it was restricted to 18 One of the themes of Robert C. Elliott, The Power of Satire: Magic, Ritual, Art (Princeton: Princeton UP, 1960). 19 ‘The Flyting of Dunbar and Kennedie’, in The Poems of William Dunbar, ed. James Kinsley (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979), 76–95, and on its background pp. 282–6. 20 C. J. Sisson, Lost Plays of Shakespeare’s Age (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1936), 186–203; David Underdown, Revel, Riot, and Rebellion: Popular Politics and Culture in England 1603–1660 (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1985); Alastair Bellany, ‘Railing Rhymes and Vaunting Verse: Libellous Politics in Early Stuart England, 1603–1628’, in Kevin Sharpe and Peter Lake (eds.), Culture and Politics in Early Stuart England (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford UP, 1993), 285–310; Adam Fox, Oral and Literate Culture in England 1500–1700 (Oxford: Oxford UP, 2000). 21 Revel, Riot, and Rebellion, 5.
10
Origins and Models
villages. When, in Beaumont and Fletcher’s Philaster (first acted c.1611), the maid of honour, Megra, is caught in bed with Pharamond, the poltroonish suitor to the princess, her punishment is depicted as a subjection to various forms of ridicule: I dare my lord: your whootings, and your clamors, Your private whispers and your broad fleerings . . .
on which the king elaborates: and all the Pages, And all the Court, shall hoote thee through the Court, Fling rotten Oranges, make ribal’d rimes, And seare thy name with candles upon walls:22
The rotten oranges (an expensive import) would not have penetrated far down the social ladder but the hooting, the pelting, and the pursuit were regarded by the dramatist as being as likely to occur at court as in the country. The ‘ribal’d rimes’ are here presented as a just vengeance on a transgressor. Megra responds in the play with an untrue accusation that the princess has been unchaste with a page-boy, which is immediately believed. This will trigger the same process of insult: The Princesse, your deare daughter, shall stand by me On walls, and sung in ballads, any thing:23
We know about the circumstances of composition of several such impromptu ballads because their texts are preserved in the records of court cases for slander. Fox, Underdown, and Laura Gowing all cite examples.24 By the sixteenth century it had become common for such pieces to be written out and ‘posted’ in some public place. While the ostensible aim of this was to give publicity to the accusations, it may also have been felt to possess a magical function like the ancient depositing of written curses at wells, where they were thought to be more accessible to the gods of the underworld.25 It was then a short step for them to be circulated in manuscript copies and for new 22 The Dramatic Works in the Beaumont and Fletcher Canon, ed. Fredson Bowers (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1966–), i. 429–30. 23 Ibid. 430. 24 Fox, Oral and Literate Culture, 299–334; Underdown, Revel, Riot, and Rebellion, 29, 57, 84, 115, 121, 127, 143, 280; Gowing, Domestic Dangers: Women, Words, and Sex in Early Modern London (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1996), 84, 108, 121, 126. See also SPISCE, 232–3. 25 There is a Latin example from Bath illustrated in Simon Hornblower and Antony Spawforth (eds.), The Oxford Companion to Classical Civilization (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1998), 201.
Origins and Models
11
pieces of the same kind to be written for scribal circulation. A good deal of later English written lampooning was a straightforward transference of oral models to new social circumstances and a more refined mode of expression. Such satire is always personal. By contrast, most admonitory verse of the Middle Ages and early Renaissance had prided itself on attacking the vice in generalized terms rather than the vicious individual. John Peter distinguished reprobations of this kind as ‘complaint’ from what was subsequently known as satire, which is normally held to have come into existence as a recognized literary mode with the naturalization of the classical Roman satire and epigram during the 1590s by Donne in manuscript and Hall, Marston, and Sir John Davies in print.26 These writers drew on a Humanist classical heritage and the particular examples of Horace, Juvenal, and Martial; but where the folk lampoon had spoken on behalf of its communities, the new manner of verse reprobation foregrounded the personality, or persona, of the satirist, often representing him as an alienated railer. Victims too might be personalized, though under the disguise of type names, since printed satire was public, not clandestine.27 Hall and particularly Marston favoured an esoteric vocabulary that was about as far removed as it could be from the directness of the folk lampoon. At v. i. 464–528 of Jonson’s Poetaster, modelled on Lucian’s ‘Lexiphanes’, Crispinus, representing Marston, is made to vomit up a series of such excesses, beginning with ‘retrograde’, ‘reciprocall’, ‘incubus’, ‘glibbery’, ‘lubricall’, and ‘defunct’ and concluding with ‘obstupefact’.28 The experiment was brought to a halt by the ‘Bishops’ ban’ of 1599. Its influence on later satire was small, though some of its features survive in Cleveland and it probably encouraged the writing of invectives in pentameter 26 Complaint and Satire in Early English Literature (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1956). Marston’s and Hall’s claims to have founded a new verse genre should not be taken too seriously; but they had certainly created a new performative identity for the satirist and a new urban orientation for satire. 27 Discussed in Peter, Complaint and Satire; O. J. Campbell, Comicall Satyre and Shakespeare’s ‘ Troilus and Cressida’ (San Marino, Calif.: Aderaft Press, 1938); Anthony Caputi, John Marston, Satirist (Ithaca, NY: Cornell UP, 1961); and Alvin Kernan, The Cankered Muse: Satire of the English Renaissance (New Haven: Yale UP, 1959). The social context of the new satire is illuminated by Lawrence Manley in the closing section of his ‘Literature and London’ in Loewenstein and Mueller (eds.), Cambridge History of Early Modern English Literature, 399–427. 28 Ben Jonson, ed. C. H. Herford and Percy Simpson (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1932–52), iv. 312–13.
12
Origins and Models
couplets rather than in Goliardic tetrameters or stanzas sung to a broadside ballad melody. The reigns of James I and Charles I saw both the couplet and the stanzaic kinds of literate clandestine satire engendering formal subtraditions of some complexity. As well as the straightforward lampoon pattern of either sustained invective directed at a single person or a series of separate, epigram-like attacks on several, verse libels made frequent use of parody, especially the mock-epitaph, the mockencomium, and, as we have seen, the mock-litany. Lampoons in pentameter couplets would sometimes mimic the gravity of the classical grand style, in anticipation of Augustan mock-heroic though without the polish. A lighter form of burlesque, written in octosyllabic couplets, had as one of its inspirations a centuries-old tradition of rhymed Latin satirical verse most signally represented by Richard Braithwaite’s Barnabae Itinerarium (1638), which was actually an extended stanzaic lampoon meant for singing. The Latin is presented side by side with an English version, describing how the eponymous Barnabas visits town after town (usually at a rate of one per stanza) and immediately heads for a tavern or vinous friend: Tenens cursum et decorum, Brickhill, ubi Juniorem Veni, vidi, propter mentem Unum octo Sapientum; Sonat vox ut Philomela, Ardet nasus ut candela.
Holding on my journey longer, Streight at Brickhill with Tom Younger. I arriv’d; one by this cheese-a Styl’d the eighth wiseman of Greece-a, Voice more sweet than Prognes sister, Like a Torch his nose doth glister.29
Either version can be read singly but the real pleasure lies in the ingenuity with which effects in one language have been recreated in the other. There was also some awareness of English forebears: Sir John Mennes admired Chaucer and James Smith praised Skelton. Timothy Raylor suggests a closer influence from Herrick: Mennes and Smith were familiar with Herrick’s sack poems . . . The fairy poems were well known and exhibit many features found in earlier travesties and burlesques as well as in the drolling manner of Mennes and Smith: these features include competitive composition, the use of comic octasyllabics with absurd rhymes, the debunking of mythology through the filter of rustic domesticity, the juxtaposition of the charming and the grotesque, and a tone of knowing and playful irony.30 (London, 1638), K4v–5r. Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture, 128. For the history of the style in English see pp. 124–8. 29 30
Origins and Models
13
Burlesque and travesty were separate genres from the lampoon, in the sense that neither demanded that attacks be made on persons rather than literary modes; yet they contributed much to its characteristic tone and language. As with lyric verse circulated in manuscript, a lampoon often provoked a reply which then circulated along with it.31 The genre was characterized from the start by sexual explicitness, portraying its victims as either monsters of lust or ludicrously ineffectual aspirants to that status.32 As these aspects of the lampoon will be copiously illustrated in the following chapters, examples will not be given at the present time. A crucial transition was that by which the popular forms, having emerged from orality to literacy, were then accommodated to the more discerning tastes of educated and courtly readers. Smith’s The Loves of Hero and Leander (London, 1651, but written perhaps two decades earlier) is described by Raylor as ‘an extended collage of proverbs, ballads, idioms, and colloquialisms’, illustrating the poet’s intense awareness of the world of orally transmitted texts, but using them ‘with a gently ironic affection’ that reveals a ‘developing awareness among the elite of a distinction between their own and popular culture’.33 But Smith had no pretensions to elegance. Suckling was one of a number of poets of the court of Charles I who helped bestow polish and literary respectability on clandestine satire. Two of his poems stand at the head of enduring traditions. The ‘Ballad upon a Wedding’ is not itself a satire but was used as the basis of several later parody lampoons, while the model of ‘A Sessions of Poets’ was repeatedly reaccommodated to new generations of writers as well as being extended to other groups of victims in the sub-tradition of what will be referred to as ‘sessions satire’. The term ‘lampoon’ seems itself to have emerged about this time, as a refrain word to be sung after each verse of a stanzaic libel. In its French derivation (‘lampons’ from ‘lamper’) it means simply ‘let us drink’. Among the Cavalier poets, the lampoon was one of a number of genres to which acknowledged wits would be expected to turn their hands and through which they could demonstrate their abilities. It is often difficult to judge whether a particular piece was written to display its writer’s talent, to utter an unwelcome but necessary truth, or out of gratuitous malice: the effect need not be much different. Stanzaic 31 32 33
Cf. Marotti, Manuscript, Print and the English Renaissance Lyric, 159–71. For the prevalence of bawdy verse in manuscript collections see ibid. 76–82. Raylor, Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture, 140.
14
Origins and Models
lampoons emanating from the court were still almost always written to a ballad melody, even when this was not declared in the title. In its movement from being part of a social ritual of popular shaming to being an element in the written culture of the educated, the lampoon also became a constitutive practice of communities based on the production and exchange of documents, such as the universities, the Inns of Court, and the Church of England. Erudite libels (often in Latin) were a commonplace of university life. On the occasion of the contested entry of Sir Thomas Clayton in April 1661 to the wardenship of Merton College, Anthony Wood wrote: All seniors, that had known what Thomas Clayton had been, did look upon him, as the most impudent fellow in nature to adventure upon such a place (the wardenship of Merton coll.) that had been held by eminent persons. They knew him to have been the very lol-poop of the University, the common subject of every lampoon that was made in the said university, and a fellow of little or no religion, only for forme-sake. They knew also, that he had been a most lascivious person, a great haunter of women’s company and a common fornicator.34
Wood’s assuredness over the last-raised matter may, of course, have been dependent on the lampoons themselves. Inns of Court satire numbered the court among its targets, as the satirical verse of Donne and Sir John Davies shows. Within such closed communities, libels performed a homeostatic function, confirming members’ sense of their own institutional identity, providing a sanctioned way of dealing with deviations from agreed norms of behaviour, and offering an outlet for otherwise irremediable dissatisfaction.35 As long as they restricted themselves to these functions, they were not seen as socially disruptive. Yet by early in the reign of James I a new kind of verse libel was in circulation whose intended audience was general rather than communal or institutional and which instead of attacking local authority figures directed its often considerable venom at the political and religious leaders of the nation. The immediate, though not the sole, cause of this mutation was the accession of a king with poor communication skills, inflexible ideas about the power of the prerogative, and a 34 Life and Times, i. 394. For further references to Oxford lampoons see i. 487–9, ii. 44, 150, 391, 496, 550, iii. 138. 35 These functions are explored for university and Inns of Court clandestine satire in Felicity Henderson, ‘Erudite Satire in Seventeenth-Century England’ (Monash University Ph.D. thesis, 2003).
Origins and Models
15
preference for ruling through favourites. The great seventeenthcentury outburst of clandestine satire was in a real sense an outcome of the Stuart phenomenon and the particular vision of modernity that dynasty tried to impose. What were later to be called ‘state poems’ had existed in the past but never in such numbers, nor had they ever been so eagerly sought after; moreover, their circulation was almost impossible to control. Archbishop Whitgift had been able to ban the print publication of satires and epigrams, but at his funeral in 1604 the manuscript of a Puritan lampoon was found pinned to his hearsecloth.36 Clandestine state satire provided a steady stream of uninhibited commentary on court scandals and unpopular ministers. Marotti lists some of its targets: The falls of ambitious or highly placed individuals in the Elizabethan, Jacobean, and Caroline periods attracted much attention in the manuscript collections of the period, which contain poetry (and prose) related to the treason and execution of the earl of Essex; the trial, long imprisonment, and eventual execution of Sir Walter Raleigh; the political eclipse and death of Robert Cecil, earl of Salisbury; the murder trial and conviction of Robert Carr, earl of Somerset (and of his wife Frances Howard); the impeachments of Sir Francis Bacon and of Lionel Cranfield, earl of Middlesex; the career and assassination of George Villiers, duke of Buckingham; the political fall and execution of Thomas Wentworth, earl of Strafford; and the trial and execution of the earl of Castlehaven for sexual crimes.37
Thomas Cogswell has described this early body of state satire as providing ‘as close to a mass media as early Stuart England ever achieved’.38 The death of Cecil in 1612 was the occasion for an extraordinary outburst of libels, which has been studied by Pauline Croft.39 In The Politics of Court Scandal in Early Modern England: News Culture and the Overbury Affair, 1603–1660, Alastair Bellany has traced the operations of an amazingly rich body of orally 36 Alastair Bellany, ‘A Poem on the Archbishop’s Hearse: Puritanism, Libel and Sedition after the Hampton Court Conference’, Journal of British Studies, 34 (1995), 137–64. 37 Marotti, Manuscript, Print and the English Renaissance Lyric, 94. 38 ‘Underground Verse and the Transformation of Early Stuart Political Culture’, in Susan D. Amussen and Mark A. Kishlansky (eds.), Political Culture and Cultural Politics in Early Modern England: Essays Presented to David Underdown (Manchester: Manchester UP, 1995), 277–300. 39 ‘The Reputation of Robert Cecil: Libels, Political Opinion and Popular Awareness in the Early Seventeenth Century’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 6th ser. 1 (1991), 43–69. See also Marotti, Manuscript, Print and the English Renaissance Lyric, 101–2.
16
Origins and Models
and scribally communicated texts, including lampoons, in broadcasting and interpreting the events that culminated in the trials of the Earl and Countess of Somerset for the murder of Sir Thomas Overbury.40 Overall, ‘approximately twenty five different poems and two libellous anagrams survive, about half in multiple copies’. One collector, William Davenport, possessed ten, one of which he might have written himself.41 Verses on the Castlehaven case were almost all short, cheap and public, drawing their authority from humour and an alleged immediacy to their subject matter. They appeared (or at least this is where later copies claim that they appeared) affixed to hearses, statues, or anything available where a literate person might find, read, and recite them.42
Milton’s friend Alexander Gill was lucky to escape with his life after being found in possession of ‘libels and letters . . . touching on the late Duke of Buckingham’.43 The older style of personal invective associated with seasonal festivities had not given rise to political anxiety because it was seen as communally contained. Objections were rather to the festivities themselves, with their temptations to heavy drinking, promiscuity, and riot. Only the dissident productions of militant Catholics on one side and extreme Puritans on the other had given any real cause for concern and, since it was hard to disguise one’s membership of these communities and the bare possession of such a text might be judged treasonable, fear had inhibited their free circulation. Public outbreaks of personal abuse, such as the Martin Marprelate and Nashe–Harvey controversies or the so-called ‘war of the theatres’, were dealt with through established legal mechanisms. Yet, with the wide circulation of manuscript libels directed at leading figures in Church and state, there was a change of view by which all forms of criticism, slander, and defamation came to be regarded as a corrigible threat to public order. The response of the legal system to this challenge has been summarized by Lindsay Kaplan, who quotes a telling passage from Ferdinando Pulton’s De Pace Regis and Regni (1609), in which the libeller is described as a ‘foule puddle that ouzeth from the same corrupt quagmire’ of slander but does so not by open words (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2002), 74–135. Ibid. 97, 102, and on verse libels generally, pp. 107–11. 42 Cynthia B. Herrup, A House in Gross Disorder: Sex, Law and the 2nd Earl of Castlehaven (New York: Oxford UP, 1999), 120. 43 CSP(Dom) 1628–9, 338–9. 40 41
Origins and Models
17
but ‘seeming to sit quietly in his study’.44 In 1593 the Privy Council authorized the use of torture to discover the authors of libels. In the early years of the following century the Star Chamber, as the judicial arm of the Council, made use of the new notion of criminal libel in a series of prosecutions of which that of William Prynne in 1632 was the most momentous. Under a judgement of the same year, anyone encountering a written libel was legally required to burn it if its target was a private person or to bring it to ‘the Kings Councell or some competent judge’ if it touched on matters of state.45 To compose one, according to the resurrected principle scribere est agere, was to engage in constructive treason.46 Lampoons, as a subset of the wider category of libel, might be dealt with under any of three jurisdictions. Where no temporal loss was involved, the matter was traditionally left to the ecclesiastical courts. Where damage to a reputation required restitution, the injured party would seek it through the common law. However, a libel that threatened a breach of the peace became a matter for the Star Chamber, which steadily expanded its criteria of relevance to the point where it was eventually dealing with humble cases of village insult that would previously have been handled by one of the other two jurisdictions.47 While the severity of this court is notorious, it could not apply the death penalty. It was the passing of its jurisdiction after 1660 to the court of King’s Bench that was to prove fatal in 1683 to Algernon Sidney. Yet, whether judicial intervention had any effect on the writing and communication of lampoons is doubtful. It should rather be seen as evidence of sharply escalating official anxiety over their ubiquity and influence. Needless to say, not all satire was directed towards the crown and high-placed favourites: there was a strong counter-tradition of loyal satire whose targets were Puritans and parliamentarians. Andrew McRae has explored one phase of its development in a study of Richard Corbett as both a panegyrist of the court and excoriator of its enemies.48 But even royalist satire had its problems in a society 44 The Culture of Slander in Early Modern England (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1997), 20–4; Pulton, De Pace, fo. B1v. 45 S. R. Gardiner (ed.), Reports of Cases in the Courts of Star Chamber and High Commission, Camden Society, ns 39 (London, 1886), 152. 46 See David Sandler Berkowitz, John Selden’s Formative Years (Cranbury, NJ: Folger Books, 1988), 79–80. 47 As in Skipwith’s case, 1622, discussed in SPISCE, 232–4. 48 ‘Satire and Sycophancy: Richard Corbett and Early Stuart Royalism’, RES 54 (2003), 336–64.
18
Origins and Models
where the very right to criticize was under attack. A personal libel, according to Sir Edward Coke, was likely to disturb the peace because it provoked revenge. Libelling also undermined the moral standing of the individual, leading to ‘1. Prauitatis incrementum, increase de lewdnes: 2. Bursae decrementum, euacuation del burse et beggerie. 3. Conscientiae detrimentum, shipwracke de conscience.’49 Erudite and literary quarrels were to be regretted because they distracted participants from their proper task of encouraging order and obedience. Shortly before his death James was considering the establishment of a historical Academy of eighty-four appointed members as ‘an institution for policing the realm of ideas’.50 Gowing examines insult and slander as expressions of conflict between households in the urban environment of London with its huge population of immigrants from the country. It is still widely believed that married women could not go to law in their own right in early modern England; but this only applied to the secular courts, not the ecclesiastical ones, where women comprised a majority of plaintiffs in cases of slander. The records of these cases yield a good haul of street insults which we can measure against those of the verse libellers, as well as revealing a number of cases where verse libels were used as an element in disputes between households, families, or neighbourhoods.51 But their significance to a contemporary would have lain in their potential to disrupt social cohesion at its most fragile level, that of the overcrowded metropolitan streets and tenements with their incessant turnover of population. Unlike the punitive Star Chamber, the church courts that heard these cases sought wherever possible to promote reconciliation. Cavalier attempts to support Sunday sports and seasonal revelry against Puritan criticism had as one offshoot a strong tradition of libertine lampooning in which attacks on the opponents of festive liberty were accompanied by unashamed celebrations of sexual and bacchanalian excess. Théophile de Viau and the poets of Le Parnasse satyrique offered models for this which may have influenced the libertine verse of Charles Cotton and later Rochester. Théophile had himself spent time in England in the entourage of the first Duke of Buckingham. One striking body of libertine verse associated with the royalist wits of the ‘Order of the Fancy’ has been studied in Raylor’s 49 50 51
Quinta pars relationum Edwardi Coke (London, 1612), fo. 126r. Berkowitz, John Selden’s Formative Years, 82–3. Domestic Dangers, passim.
Origins and Models
19
Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture. The two leaders of this group, Mennes and Smith, had both been present in 1627, along with D’Avenant, Herrick, and Suckling, on the disastrous military expedition to the Île de Ré. They became the literary stars of meetings at which doggerel, travesty, and the improvisation of meaningless speeches were the approved modes of displaying wit. During the interregnum, clandestine satire made an important contribution to the maintenance of Cavalier solidarity and the spread of opposition to military rule. Mennes has left an account in exuberant tetrameters of an entertainment given in 1654 at Cologne by Lord Chancellor Hyde at which all the participants got hopelessly drunk; however, it would be incorrect to call this a lampoon: rather it exploits the ancient comic topos of the repas ridicule.52 The Mennes–Smith circle also cultivated the no less ancient topos of the paradoxical encomium, in which ironic praise was lavished on something intrinsically unworthy of it. There is a Restoration successor to this in Oldham’s prose ‘Character of a Certain Ugly Old P——’.53 The burlesque and lampoon verse of the Cavalier poets, after initial oral and manuscript circulation, came to wider knowledge through such printed ‘drolleries’ as Musarum Deliciae (1655), Sportive Wit (1656), and Choyce Drollery (1656), the latter two of which were seized and destroyed by the interregnum government.54 The lampoonists of the Restoration were, therefore, the inheritors of several well-cultivated prior traditions. That of oppositional anticourt satire fell out of favour for a while after 1660 but was to experience a spectacular revival following the failures of the second Dutch War. A predictable early vogue for anti-Puritan satire was sustained by the success of Butler’s Hudibras, not in this case a clandestine work but the result of ‘a lengthy process of generic transmutation, as the gentlemanly drolling style of the 1630s was applied to the horrific events of the 1640s’.55 Court satire from the days of Charles and Henrietta Maria offered models for a new, less idealistic generation installed at Whitehall, which Dorset, Buckingham, Sedley, and Rochester were to develop in remarkable ways. The 52 Text in Raylor, Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture, 242–5. For the tradition, see Olga Rossettini, Les Influences anciennes et italiennes sur la satire en France au XVIe siècle (Florence: Institut français, 1958), 204–13 and Harold Love (ed.), Restoration Literature: Critical Approaches (London: Methuen, 1972), 158–9. 53 Remains of Mr. John Oldham in Verse and Prose (London, 1684), 109–30. 54 Raylor, Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture, 202–7. 55 Ibid. 187.
20
Origins and Models
Jacobean experiments of Hall and Marston had been forgotten but models for how moral verse of a classicizing kind might be written were available in Donne, Lovelace, and Cowley on one side of the channel and Regnier and his successors on the other.56 How to write outrageous invective could be learned from Cleveland: Oldham was one of his pupils-at-a-distance. Burlesque and travesty not only appealed enormously to the spirit of the age but could draw on contemporary French models, especially that of Scarron, with which the returned Cavaliers were thoroughly familiar—Charles Cotton proved the English master of Scarronian travesty. Most important of all, the native tradition of satirical rhymes set to familiar broadside ballad tunes continued to be practised in villages and towns, in the streets and taverns of London, in university colleges and legal inns, and even by the frequenters of Presbyterian and Anabaptist meeting houses. There was a heady mix of possibilities all of which would be taken further as clandestine satire advanced to its greatest, and most deplorable, period of achievement. But while much had been inherited, the ground under the satirists’ feet had shifted irrecoverably. As Raylor puts it: ‘The tone of Restoration society, conditioned by the long years of exile and poverty, involved an obscenity more vulgar, a cynicism more bitter, and a vandalism more fundamental and skeptical than anything ever dreamt up by the Order of the Fancy.’57 The case of the second Duke of Buckingham, discussed at the beginning of this chapter, illustrates the correctness of this opinion. 56 Consultable in the collection Fernand Fleury and Louis Perceau (eds.), Les Satires françaises du XVIIe siècle, 2 vols. (Paris: Garnier, 1923). 57 Cavaliers, Clubs, and Literary Culture, 210.
2
The Court Lampoon Like Restoration comedy, the Restoration lampoon took several years to mature into a distinctive genre. The resumption of monarchical rule in 1660 was rejected root and branch only by extreme Puritans; most other republicans were prepared to bide their time and see how the new order of indemnity and oblivion promised under the Declaration of Breda worked in practice. In any case open opposition would have been dangerous: Milton came close to losing his life for having persevered in the good old cause when it was already lost. Savage satire was to be encountered everywhere but it was directed at Puritans, not the restored monarchy, and followed wellestablished models. The verse collected in such much-reprinted collections as J. Cleveland Revived (1659) and Ratts Rhimed to Death, or, the Rump Parliament Hang’d up in the Shambles (1660) exhibits the same tauntingly vengeful spirit as John Tatham’s theatrical burlesque The Rump; or the Mirrour of the Late Times (February 1660) in which the Commonwealth leaders are brought on as characters in an Aristophanic farce. The publication in 1663 of the first part of Samuel Butler’s Hudibras was the high point of anti-Puritan satire, after which it mutated into a stock reflex of attacks on citizens, Nonconformists, and eventually Whigs. The verse of the royalist drollery poets could now be printed with impunity in such collections as Merry Drollery . . . The First Part ([1661?]) and an enlarged reprint of the 1656 Wit and Drollery. These poets were inheritors of a time when alcoholic and sexual excess had in itself been a form of political loyalism. In ‘Timon’ (1674)
}
. . . mine Host Had beene a Collonell, wee must heare him boast Not of Townes won, but an Estate he lost, For the Kings service; which indeed he spent, Whoreing and drinking, but with good intent. (ll. 95–9)1 1
Rochester, Works, 261. The poem is also attributed to Sedley.
22
The Court Lampoon
Deprived of its validating political context, the drollery tradition also lost its good intent by being absorbed into the general current of Anacreontic and libertine verse represented by the work of Charles Cotton and Alexander Radcliffe. If there were catcalls to be heard among the hurrahs, they were those of old Cavaliers, ruined by the wars, who saw that their sacrifices had gone unrewarded, while turncoats and time-servers of the ‘phanatical crue’ had . . . got so much wealth, By their plunder and stealth, That they creep into profit and power:
But even these grumblings were decently muted: Alexander Brome’s bill of complaints is followed by reassurance: Yet we will be loyal still, And serve without reward or hire, To be redeem’d from so much ill, May stay our stomacks, though not fill; And if our patience do not tire, We may in time have our desire.2
The theme of Brome’s poem was to resurface among ‘country’ criticisms of crown policies in the 1670s. An inflammatory speech of 1671 by Charles, Lord Lucas deplored royal bounty ‘poured out into the Purses of private men’, many of whom ‘att his Maties returne were worth little, or nothing’, but who now kept ‘their Coaches, and sixe Horses, their Pages, and Lacqueys’ while loyal Cavaliers had ‘scarce sufficient left, to buy them Bread’.3 Yet, those established wits who had retrieved their estates or found profitable niches under the new regime were disinclined to bite the hand that fed them. Sir John Mennes was reinstalled as an admiral in Charles’s navy, James Smith received church preferments, Denham became surveyor of works, and D’Avenant and Killigrew patentees of theatre companies. Waller, having blotted his copybook during the interregnum, returned to a new and fruitful career as a court poet for Charles II, whom he outlived. It is only from the mid-1660s that we begin to encounter satires expressing open hostility to the new regime. The spirit of opposition engendered by the great ejection of Nonconforming ministers which 2 3
Alexander Brome, Songs and Other Poems, 2nd edn. (London, 1664), 50. Bodleian Library, MS don. b 8, p. 198.
The Court Lampoon
23
took place on 24 August 1662 was initially conveyed through surreptitiously printed pamphlets and sermons. The idea that a few jesting stanzas circulated in manuscript might be just as effective in manipulating public attitudes took time to catch on. A good proportion of the satire of the 1670s was to be concerned with the religious question or political issues that flowed directly from it; but the foundations of a new tradition of ‘state’ satire could not be laid until public opinion had been further alienated by the incompetence displayed in the conduct of the second Dutch War (1664–7). Charles II was quicker to squander the contents of his treasury than the huge fund of goodwill engendered by his Restoration but eventually he managed that as well. Apart from this erosion of support, there were two other preconditions for a restoration of the verse libel—a rejuvenation of poetic forms and the creation of a repertoire of easily identifiable targets. As regards the first, it should not be assumed that, because lampoon-like poems had been written for many decades, it was a simple matter to crank out more of the same, or that the older manner was still acceptable to a self-consciously ‘polite’ age. Despite a degree of continuity in verse forms and structural principles, the Restoration lampoon has a characteristic tone, even a characteristic kind of viciousness, that was foreign to its Caroline and interregnum precursors briefly discussed in Chapter 1. Before the lampoon could reassume its centrality to the communication of opinion it had to be remade in ways that will be considered shortly. It also needed a cast. Few things fall flatter than a satire written about people about whom nobody knows or cares. What is not so obvious is that even before well-known people can be used effectively as butts of satire there have to be instantly recognizable signs by which they can be identified, and stock accusations against them that are universally known and accepted. Satire does not have time to explain: it must get straight to the business of vilification. The charges do not have to be true; indeed, in order to satisfy the strange needs served by the genre it is often a good idea if they are not true, or no better than half-true. Rochester insisted to Burnet that ‘the lyes in these Libels came often in as Ornaments that could not be spared without spoiling the beauty of the Poem’.4 The untrue accusation is also likely to be especially wounding to its victim. Shadwell, aware 4 Gilbert Burnet, Some Passages of the Life and Death of John, Earl of Rochester, in V. de Sola Pinto (ed.), English Biography in the Seventeenth Century (London: Harrap, 1951), 106.
24
The Court Lampoon
that his plays had been as successful as Dryden’s, was as irritated as much by the inaccuracy of MacFlecknoe as by its abuse: the Author of Mack-Fleckno reflects more upon himself than me; where he makes Fleckno commend Dullness, and chuse me for the Dullest that ever writ; and repeats dull, dull, &c. over and over . . . and has no more reason for that, than for giving me the Irish name of Mack, when he knows I never saw Ireland till I was three and twenty years old, and was there but four Months.5
A character in satire was as much a conscious artistic construction as a character in comedy and might bear as little relationship to the real world. Once an accusation was given currency it would stick, regardless of truth. Jane Middleton, a beauty of the court of Charles II who was also a gifted painter, was pursued throughout her long career as a subject of lampoon satire by the accusation of unpleasant body odour. Mordaunt’s ‘The Ladies’ March’ (1681) includes the quatrain Middleton, where’er she goes, Confirms the scandal of her foes; Quelled by the fair one’s funky hose, Even Lory’s forced to hold his nose.6
‘Lory’ was Laurence Hyde, Earl of Rochester: that he was Middleton’s lover at the time was another convenient assumption by the lampoon writers for which we have no objective evidence. Pepys is our witness to gossip circulating as early as 1665 that ‘the fine Mrs Middleton is noted for carrying about her body a continued soure base Smell that is very offensive, especially if she be a little hot’.7 From the moment this rumour first circulated, the lampoon poet had both a stock character and a stock accusation to fill up a stanza whenever required, as will be demonstrated in what follows. The technique of turning real-life individuals into satirical icons is familiar to us from visual caricature, which customarily begins from the exaggeration of one or two prominent physical features. At the 5 Dedication to The Tenth Satire of Juvenal (1687), in The Complete Works of Thomas Shadwell, ed. Montague Summers (London: Fortune Press, 1927), v. 292. 6 (‘Stamford’s countess led the van’), CSR, 57. For the attribution to Mordaunt, see Harold Love, ‘Charles, Viscount Mordaunt and “The Ladies’ March” ’, RES (forthcoming). 7 The Diary of Samuel Pepys, ed. Robert Latham and William Matthews, 11 vols. (London: G. Bell & Sons, 1970–), vi. 251 (3 Oct. 1665).
The Court Lampoon
25
present day when a new celebrity becomes a subject of newspaper cartoons, there is often an introductory phase in which the portraits do not immediately declare the identity and may differ from artist to artist; but in a short space of time, through a process of professional complicity or mutual plagiarism, an iconography is created which makes that person immediately recognizable. It is only by this means that caricature, as a language of elementary signs that need to deliver their meaning instantaneously, becomes possible. These people are not always the most important figures of their time; rather, they belong to a class of publicly emergent zanies or stock butts around whom an endless variety of comic inventions can be generated. The British fortnightly magazine Private Eye has made notorious use of such repetition, often choosing marginal public figures almost at random, or because of some transient dislike, and then recycling their names, appearance, or opinions for years or decades. Behind this technique lies the perception that a good joke can be repeated for ever and that satire, so conducted, does not destroy its victims but nurtures them up to continued life. The original moral or political purpose of such attacks is quickly lost sight of in the pleasure of the repetition. A certain arbitrariness in the selection of victims may also be a way of magnifying the apprehensiveness inspired by the journal or the medium. The Restoration lampoon did all these things and could not have developed as it did before it had spawned instantly recognizable stock figures who could be assailed over and over again in a kind of satirists’ shorthand that dispensed with any need for explanation. At times this extended to whole classes of individuals, such as the ladies of honour and gentlemen of the bedchamber at court, the royal bastards, or the aldermen of the City of London. Some later verse libels seem to have been written solely around collections of these stock figures, without any other detectable point of view or animus: they were simply games with the lampoon-writers’ Lego set. As the number of recognizable butts grew, the lampoons became easier to write and therefore longer. Attacks on completely new targets were most likely to work when they were inserted into populations of old ones. When Marvell in the ‘Third Advice to a Painter’ tried to make a lampoon protagonist out of the Duchess of Albermarle, it failed to work because there was no hinterland of previous representations to give point to this ambitious new one. Not even the author seems quite sure where the joke lies or how it should be elaborated and he ends
26
The Court Lampoon
up over-prolonging it. Yet, it should not be thought that the writing of these pieces, any more than the writing of a modern newspaper gossip column, was an effortless process: one needed contacts, a retentive memory, and opportunities for research. Rochester hired a spy disguised as a sentinel to lurk about the court at night in order to discover who was paying nocturnal visits to whom. Jack Howe was briefed by his sisters.8 These shorthand methods of characterization were part of a wider simplification in which all human actions were reduced to matter in motion under the influence of irresistible instinct. Mordaunt’s ‘The Ladies’ March’ (1681) brings on what John Harold Wilson describes as ‘a procession of twenty-three Court ladies marching across a stage, as if seeking erotic preferment and applause’.9 The opening ten lines will give the flavour: Stamford’s countess led the van, Tallest of the caravan, She who ne’er wants white or red, Or just pretense to keep her bed. Lofty Richmond followed after; Richmond scorns to hold her water, Piqued that Stamford should take place For height or lewdness of her grace. She distills her heavenly dew On all that swear they will be true.10
Wilson’s description does not do justice to the kinaesthetic force of the poem’s trochaic tetrameter couplets (formally anticipatory of contemporary rap lyrics) in turning the unfortunate ladies into sexually possessed automata. In its concluding portrait of Moll Howard, it moves from couplets to the repetition of a single rhyme: Courteous Mall would fain pass by her, Lined by duke, lord, knight, and squire, And eke by her confessing friar. All trades help to quench the fire, Pricks as tall as Sarum spire, Daily plunged into her mire, All too short to satisfy her. 8 Gilbert Burnet, Bishop Burnet’s History of his Own Time (London, 1724–34), i. 264; Wilson, CSR, 42. 9 10 CSR, 56. Loc. cit.
The Court Lampoon
27
This is the original ending; however, one unsatisfied reader, was driven to rewrite the last four lines: Yet still she burns, or men belie her; Mall is scratched by every briar, Hers is no common low desire, If you wont believe me, try her, Ask her but once, and she’ll retire. Nay, she’ll beg, who can deny her? Though to plunge into the mire. Pricks as long as Sarum spire Most devoutly, daily ply her, All not enough to satisfy her. Mall, adieu; you’ve lost your squire.11
The rhyme repetitions seem meant to mimic the motions of orgasm, with the ‘loss’ of the squire representing the speaker’s inability to continue with either the verbal or the (analogized) sexual performance. The vision of human nature which informs this unflattering picture, and the twenty-two that precede it, recalls the monomania which Jonson, at the beginning of the century, had made the foundation of his dramatic characterizations; but Jonson’s method was no longer a usable one for Restoration topical satire. Where the words and actions of Jonson’s characters were expressions of a diseased subjectivity, the characters of the Restoration verse libel exist purely as material bodies engaged in a Hobbesian pursuit of material objects of desire, whether these are other bodies or such tangibles as money, land, white staffs, letters patent, and coronets. In the case of ‘Courteous Mall’ and her flock of lovers (the males as machine-like in their rutting as herself), the subjective is reduced to a raw succession of sensations and the universally shared passions which are triggered by these. Or as Rochester (paraphrasing Hobbes) put it: What ever is to come is not: How can it then be mine? The present moment’s all my Lott And that as fast as it is gott Phillis is wholly thine.12 Ibid. 62. Rochester, Works, 25. As Jeremy Treglown was first to point out in The Letters of John Wilmot, Earl of Rochester (Oxford: Blackwell, 1980), 12–13, this passage is directly derived from Leviathan, ch. 3 (Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, ed. C. B. Macpherson (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1968), 97). 11 12
28
The Court Lampoon
Rochester has at least paused to consider the cognitive basis of desire. The libellers concern themselves only with the externals of dress, manners, and motions, as these become manifest in the eternally present moment, leaving them in the happy position of simplifying a simplification. Satire has always operated through simplification; but in the period with which we are concerned there seems to have been a widespread conviction that the imagined world of all-compelling desire in which the only allowed motivations were those of vanity, lust, and acquisitiveness, pursued behind a screen of dissimulation, was being lived out in real life by the new power elite of the Restoration court. Moreover, this pursuit could hardly be, as Jonson would have had it, a form of mania, for no one could deny that these material things were, by any rational assessment, well worth possessing. Alan Marshall correctly describes the court as a ‘Hobbesian world of all against all, where trust was never given freely and life was always lived on the edge’.13 James Grantham Turner summarizes even more sensationally: As Stallybrass and White observe, ‘the Restoration court projected a collective image of living in ironic and even defiant incompatibility with its inherited forms of public representation . . . The Court was both classical and grotesque, both regal and foolish, high and low.’ ‘The Practise of their Lives’, as Margaret Cavendish would say, was ‘not answerable to the Degree of their Dignities.’ To Pepys, and indeed to every eager consumer of gossip and lampoon, the Court presented a monstrous spectacle of ‘wanton talk’ and obscene writing, drunken brawling, riot, injury, outrage, window-smashing, and wife-snatching—a general state of warfare, both verbal and physical, in which sexuality and disease are the weapons. The age that coined the ‘noble Savage’ also produced the savage noble.14
Within this world nothing, naturally, was to be taken at its face value; indeed it was safer to assume that realities were the diametric opposite of appearances: Wherever too much sanctity you see, Be more suspicious of hid villainy. Whoever’s zeal is than his neighbor’s more, If man think he’s a rogue, if woman whore . . .15 13 The Age of Faction: Court Politics 1660–1702 (Manchester: Manchester UP, 1999), 92. 14 Libertines and Radicals in Early Modern London (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2002), 166. 15 ‘Rochester’s Farewell’, POASY, ii. 225.
The Court Lampoon
29
All was subjugated to ‘a perpetuall and restlesse desire of Power after power, that ceaseth onley in Death’—in Hobbes’s famous phrase— or, at least, a pursuit of the appearance of power, for Charles’s system of government by divide and rule was designed to leave no minister, or mistress, in unthreatened possession of their place.16 If it is true, as Halifax judged, that Charles had ‘as little mixture of the Seraphick part as ever Man had’, it is possible that it was only in satire that he could truly be represented.17 By the same token, writers who agreed with Hobbes that ‘Life it selfe is but Motion, and can never be without Desire, nor without Feare, no more than without Sense’18 would find it difficult not to write satire. Yet, even when strong provocations to topical satire appeared in the mid-1660s the Restoration lampoon required time to respond to them. The materials, the tool-kit, the cast, the universe, the psychology, and the physiology all had to be fine-tuned before the genre was ready to set off on its triumphant progress. There also had to be an apparatus for the distribution of verse libels, another matter to be considered elsewhere: a libel that did not travel was defeated of its purpose. For all these things to come together, experiments had to be performed in a laboratory, which in this case was the court.
t h e c o u rt a n d c o u rt l a m p o o n The Restoration lampoon, as a kind distinct from its precursors, first took shape at the court of Charles II as an instrument of factional warfare within that court. That it should have become a nationwide phenomenon probably surprised no one as much as its first exponents. Many of the key texts for a discussion of this evolution are fortunately available in John Harold Wilson’s superbly annotated Court Satires of the Restoration and the Yale Poems on Affairs of State series; however, the definition of a ‘court’ satire used in this book is a more restricted one than that of Wilson, who includes a number of what I would call ‘Town’ satires. A court satire, for present purposes, is a satire written within the court by a court author about court personalities for a court readership: if it happened to be Leviathan, 161. The Works of George Savile, Marquis of Halifax, ed. Mark N. Brown, 3 vols. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1989), ii. 490. 18 Leviathan, 130. 16 17
30
The Court Lampoon
read outside the court that was a secondary and unanticipated consequence. The moment satire began to be written by court insiders which envisaged outsiders as its primary audience it ceased to be court satire and became something different. Court satire also has to embody the views and values of the court or of a faction within the court: satire written from an erudite humanistic perspective or from a religious one was by definition invoking a different value system from the court’s Hobbesian criteria for assessing human worth. The court lampoon, as here defined, was a highly specific product of a highly idiosyncratic institution, which we will need to understand. Only historians these days are likely to have a clear idea of what a court really was and how it worked; and even they may be hazy about the details of a court like that of Charles II, in which carefully reinstalled ancient structures were buckling under the weight of innovative modern content.19 It will therefore be necessary to describe some institutional fundamentals. Though principally located at the palaces of Whitehall and Windsor, the court of an English monarch was a portable affair which might be set up anywhere. Charles took his with him to Bath, Tunbridge Wells, and Newmarket. It served two sometimes concordant, sometimes conflicting roles as the royal household and as the headquarters of the national administration. In the late seventeenth century these functions were still not clearly separated. Fundamentally, the court was a structure of spaces arranged in a hierarchy of exclusiveness and of appointments attached to those spaces. The most exclusive space was the bedchamber. It had a staff of gentlemen (all nobles) and grooms (highly placed commoners), who took turns at ‘waiting’, as well as more mundane functionaries. One of the tasks of the gentleman of the bedchamber was to sleep the night on a truckle bed close to the royal four-poster which stood in an ‘alcove’. Rochester’s graphic portrait of what supposedly went on in that most sacred of spaces (‘This to evince wou’d be too long to tell yee | The painefull Tricks of the laborious Nelly, | Imploying Hands, Armes, Fingers, Mouth and Thighs | To raise the Limb which shee each Night enjoyes’20) could well rest on actual 19 Marshall’s The Age of Faction is a sound introductory study. See also Eveline Cruikshanks (ed.), The Stuart Courts (Stroud: Sutton, 2000); R. Malcolm Smuts (ed.), The Stuart Court and Europe: Essays in Politics and Political Culture (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1996); and for the earlier heritage David Starkey et al., The English Court from the Wars of the Roses to the Civil War (London: Longman, 1987). 20 Works, 86.
The Court Lampoon
31
overheard dialogue. External to the bedchamber was the privy chamber, with its own staff of gentlemen and grooms, but of a lower rank and with lower emoluments. Least exclusive was the presence chamber, where the king made his public appearances. Any commoner of some standing and suitably attired could gain entrance to this third space. Being seen there regularly was the accepted way for a newcomer without powerful friends to make a beginning at court. A well-filled, splendidly dressed presence chamber was an outward sign of successful monarchy and while Charles, unlike Louis XIV, never made such attendance compulsory, one might easily be drawn to the chamber in order to make use of the court’s other public areas—the long and the stone galleries for strolling, the groom porter’s lodgings for gambling, the great withdrawing room for exchanging gossip, and the court theatre for plays. Pepys’s accounts of his visits to these areas are a good guide to their atmosphere.21 When the king dined in state he would be surrounded by respectful bystanders under the same principles that governed his appearances in the presence chamber. The motive for attending is made clear by an exchange in Wycherley’s The Country-Wife: Harcourt. Pray, first carry me, and reconcile me to her. Sparkish. Another time, faith the King will have sup’t. Harcourt. Not with the worse stomach for thy absence; thou art one of those Fools, that think their attendance at the King’s Meals, as necessary as his Physicians, when you are more troublesom to him, than his Doctors, or his Dogs. Sparkish. Pshaw, I know my interest, Sir . . .22
Sparkish is present to be seen as much as the monarch is. His hope is that assistance in adding to the glitter of such occasions will translate itself into an offer of preferment. The Stuart tradition of government through favourites was continued intermittently by Charles, giving rise to two distinct kinds of power, one of which came from office and the other from physical closeness to the monarch. A highly placed administrator without direct access to the king could only put forward policies through presenting them at Privy Council meetings (at which the king was notoriously inattentive) or invited interviews, and otherwise had to See Diary, ii. 239 (27 Oct. 1662); iv. 75 (16 Mar. 1663); iv. 360 (2 Nov. 1663). The Plays of William Wycherley, ed. Arthur Friedman (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979), 291. 21 22
32
The Court Lampoon
make use of intermediaries with freer access. The holder of a bedchamber appointment, by being close to the king in his private moments, had the capacity to insinuate policies in subtle ways: there is a sense in which Clarendon and later Arlington were laughed out of office. However, the most influential of all denizens of the household were the court mistresses, who came to assume a position similar to that of the court eunuchs in imperial China. Those wishing to influence the king when he was most impressionable had to work through these women and reward them accordingly. Charles seems to have been perfectly happy with this arrangement: the women both screened him from importunity and allowed him to communicate on his own terms with those whom they represented. As a result, as Halifax reminds us, ‘It was resolved generally by others, whom he should have in his Arms, as well as whom he should have in his Councils.’23 The Duchess of Portsmouth throughout her long career at court remained a loyal agent of influence for Louis XIV. Factions would intrigue to install their own candidates in this post.24 As can be imagined, the court was a fiercely competitive environment. Acquiring a position was difficult enough; retaining it could be no less so. Many positions were purchasable under a system which allowed a retiring incumbent to retrieve the investment or to accept money for the ‘reversion’ while continuing to occupy it; others were virtually heritable; but many were held purely by royal favour and could be ended on a whim, as a punishment, or as part of a political deal. Uncertainty was institutionalized. An acceptable level of social performance was an important qualification for success. Inability to reach required standards of conversational wit or elegance in dress could make one the subject of humiliating ridicule. Rochester in ‘A Ramble in St James’s Park’ displays insider’s malice at an aspirant who could only perform an imperfect imitation of these arts: The First was of your Whitehall Blades, Near Kin to th’ Mother of the Maids, Grac’d by whose favour he was able, To bring a Friend to th’Waiters Table; Where he had heard Sir Edward Sutton Say how the King lov’d Bansted Mutton. ‘A Character of King Charles II’, in Works, ii. 491. As Buckingham, and his sister, the Duchess of Richmond, tried to do with Elizabeth Lawson in 1680. See POASY, ii. 189–91; CSR, 259–60. 23 24
The Court Lampoon
33
Since when he’d ne’er be brought to eat, By’s good will any other Meat. In this, as well as all the rest, He ventures to do like the best. But wanting common Sence, th’ingredient, In choosing well, not least expedient, Converts Abortive imitation, To Universal affectation; So he not only eats, and talks, But feels, and smells, sits down and walks; Nay looks, and lives, and loves by Rote, In an old tawdrey Birth-Day-Coat.25
Samuel Butler’s character of ‘A court-wit’ offers an outsider’s view of the reigning court manner: ‘They have agreed on a mode of repartees, as well as a demeanour of faces, legs and elbows; and he that is unaccomplished that way is as ridiculous as he that wears the colours of his garniture out of season, or is trail’d by an old-fashion’d scent.’26 Marshall sees court life as comprising ‘a series of minidramatic performances’ allowed to unfold ‘before a select audience, in a form of politics by other means’. A successful courtier ‘was the sum of many calculated poses’.27 The training that royal and aristocratic children received in deportment, walking, sitting, rising, and dancing was designed to ensure that every action had an arresting balletic ease. Dean Spence remembered that when Buckingham entered the presence chamber ‘it was impossible not to follow him with your eyes, he moved so gracefully’.28 Even the deadly art of fencing was to be performed with a hypnotic grace. To shine in such an environment required not only personal virtuosity but the ability to unsettle others. Hamilton’s narrative of Gramont’s sojourn at court in the early 1660s contains numerous accounts both of dazzling acts of self-advertisement and of practical jokes designed to embarrass and humiliate.29 Heads of factions used every stratagem available in order to insert their own candidates into household positions and to displace those ll. 45–62, in Works, 77–8. See below p. 34 and n. 31. Characters, ed. Charles W. Daves (Cleveland: Case Western Reserve UP, 1970), 261–2. 27 Age of Faction, 28, 76. 28 Joseph Spence: Observations, Anecdotes and Characters of Books and Men, ed. James M. Osborn (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1966), i. 276. 29 Anthony Hamilton, Memoirs of the Count de Gramont, ed. Henry Vizetelly (London: Vizetelly & Co., 1889). 25 26
34
The Court Lampoon
of their rivals. A lampoon, as stated, could be an effective weapon in such campaigns. Rochester’s role was for many years that of a poetical gladiator for the powerful faction headed by the Duke of Buckingham. In a satire of the early 1670s Buckingham is portrayed giving an account of the membership of his faction as it then stood: The party I have made are brave and strong. First Rochester next envy’d Arlington And next Albermarle’s Debauched Sonn. Next Buckhurst, Sidley and their wenching Traine, And Mulgrave soe belov’d of Castlemaine. Our p<ar>ty in the house are numerous, Wee hate all those who seeme religious. Nay, to make sure wee’ve gott the Speaker too, Then name the thing that wee han’t power to doe.30
Rochester returned the compliment in lines 120–5 of ‘An Allusion to Horace’ by including Buckingham among the inner audience of his scribally circulated verse: I loath the Rabble, ’tis enough for me If Sydley, Shadwell, Shepheard, Wicherley, Godolphin, Butler, Buckhurst, Buckinghame And some few more, whome I omitt to name Approve my sence, I count their Censure Fame.
}
The second of these passages needs to be read in the light of the first. The satires of these courtier poets were never disinterested: probe them hard enough and there will nearly always be a factional occasion. Rochester’s attack quoted above on the ‘Whitehall blade’, who was probably Charles Blount, is coloured by the fact that he had gained his entrée through a member of the queen’s court, not the king’s.31 Rochester, Buckingham, and their close friend the Earl of Dorset (previously Lord Buckhurst, as above, and Earl of Middlesex) held appointments as gentlemen of the bedchamber, and were therefore always in a position to influence the king or to annoy him, as also sometimes happened—these were high-risk appointments, interrupted in 30 Yale University, Beinecke Library, MS Osborn fb 140, p. 98. Compare the parallel list of members given in Marshall, Age of Faction, 41–5. Arlington’s presence in the lampooner’s list is a mystery. 31 Blount was a nephew by marriage of Lady Sanderson, the ‘Mother of the Maids’ referred to.
The Court Lampoon
35
Rochester’s case by at least two banishments and in Buckingham’s by a long sojourn in the Tower. Politically, on both the court and the national scale, they constituted an Erastian Protestant faction to balance the supporters of the Catholic faction headed by the king’s brother, James, Duke of York and the Church of England faction founded by Clarendon and resuscitated in the mid-1670s by Danby; but their primary objective in court politics was simply to maintain themselves in wealth and office. (It should be noted here that court factional politics and national politics, while often closely aligned, were not identical. The long career of Sunderland, which makes no sense at all with reference to national politics, and may even be seen as a series of disasters rather than the splendid success it really was, is perfectly comprehensible in terms of court factional politics, to which it is a valuable index.) The king had been glad of Buckingham’s services in getting rid of Clarendon, which was performed as much through wit as through policy; however, bedchamber influence alone proved insufficient to maintain him in power after the failure of his toleration policies and the setbacks of a new Dutch War and an unpopular French alliance.32 James, as heir to the throne, had his own separate court, smaller in size than the king’s but with a similar hierarchy of spaces and appointments. His personal political following was largely constructed out of trusted courtiers and the officials of his household. Pepys’s administrative career was pursued as client of the duke. Conflict between the king’s and the duke’s courts was intense, especially after James’s acknowledgement of his conversion to Catholicism. In the late 1670s a Yorkist group of writers, with Dryden as its star, was assembled by John Sheffield, Earl of Mulgrave to ensure that the duke’s court did not lose out in the game of wit; however, the members of this group were mostly professionals rather than courtiers.33 Rochester responded with a series of savage attacks on Mulgrave as ‘My Lord All-pride’. Mulgrave hit back in ‘An Essay upon Satyr’ with a scarifying portrait of Rochester for which he probably had the assistance of Dryden. Administratively distinct courts were also created for the queen, the queen mother, Prince Rupert, and the two successive Duchesses of York and their children. Hamilton records how the first duchess, the former Anne Hyde, ‘in order to form her For the unseating of Clarendon see Marshall, Age of Faction, 100–5. A kind of roll-call of them is given by the contributors to the group enterprise Ovid’s Epistles Translated by Several Hands (1680). 32 33
36
The Court Lampoon
new Court, resolved to inspect all the young persons that offered themselves, and without any regard to recommendations, she chose none but the handsomest’ and the difficulties that flowed from choices made under this principle in an environment where mental endowments were also essential.34 The structure of the court of Mary of Modena, the second duchess, as it stood in 1677, will suggest something of its more fully staffed counterparts. The senior functionary was the Groom of the Stole (i.e. close-stool), Lady Peterborough, who managed the bedchamber. Under her were two ladies of the bedchamber, four maids of honour, and six bedchamber women (all gentlepersons). There were also a starcher, a seamstress, a lacemender, a secretary, two gentlemenushers, four gentlemen waiters, four pages of the back stairs, a master cook, a necessary woman, eighteen watermen, a master of the horse (the Earl of Roscommon), two equerries, eight footmen, four coachmen with postilions and helpers, five grooms, and two chairmen.35 Many of the households of the great aristocrats were organized along similar lines. So, to take one example, the elderly dowager Countess of Devonshire lived ‘in the style of something more than a great princess’, setting ‘a sumptuous table every day’.36 The senior royal mistresses also presided over court-like establishments. When the Duchess of Portsmouth went to take the waters at Bath in 1674 she dined in state every night and expected other noble ladies present in town to wait on her on these occasions. She also had her own musical establishment of French virtuosi, whose performances were particularly relished by the king. When her position as premier mistress was threatened in 1676 by Charles’s departure with the Duchess of Mazarin for holidays at Windsor, Louis XIV reinforced this body with singers from the Paris opera, from whose performances Charles found it impossible to remain absent.37 Mazarin in due course set up a mini-court at Chelsea, of which Saint-Evremond and the composer Jacques Paisible were ornaments, financing it with rigged gambling. Memoirs, ii. 90. Edward Chamberlayne, Angliae Notitia: or, The Present State of England. The First Part (London, 1677), 205–6. 36 Lorenzo Magalotti at the Court of Charles II: His Relazione d’Inghilterra of 1668, ed. and trans. W. E. Knowles Middleton (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier UP, 1980), 117. 37 For a detailed account of this highly revealing episode, see John Buttrey, ‘New Light on Robert Cambert in London and his Ballet et Musique ’, Early Music, 23 (1995), 199–220. 34 35
The Court Lampoon
37
Being prepared to lose money at cards seems to have been a kind of entrance fee to the more interesting minor courts. The queen’s and the two Duchesses of York’s courts, in addition to their domestic staff, each had an allowance of maids of honour and ladies of the bedchamber. These were the most prominent court appointments reserved for women. Each group of maids had a gouvernante known as the ‘Mother of the Maids’ but she possessed little real authority. The position of the maids was not a happy one. Their expenses, particularly in dress, were heavy and their emolument light: in May 1674, when the queen’s maids were refused subvention for their annual journey to Windsor, they actually went on strike, appointing Frances Sheldon their negotiator.38 Those of them who did not take lovers, especially royal lovers, were accused routinely of being lesbians. (Elizabeth Harvey apparently was.) But at least they had recognized appointments, whereas the mistresses (unless they were simultaneously maids or matrons of honour, a matter of some delicacy) held their positions by courtesy alone: there was no establishment position of maîtresse en titre. Appreciating this, the Duchess of Cleveland badgered Charles until he forced the queen, after violent protests, to accept her as one of her ladies. The lives of the mistresses were perpetual theatre: they were the target of all eyes, and the gossip of all tongues. Most difficult of all were their appearances in ‘the circle’ at court, where their dress and appearance would be subjected to hostile scrutiny. It is with this trial by ordeal that Dorimant threatens Harriet in The Man of Mode: Dor. Though you are obstinate, I know ’tis capable of improvement, and shall do you Justice, Madam, if I chance to be at Court, when the Critiques of the Circle pass their judgment; for thither you must come. Har. And expect to be taken in pieces, have all my features examin’d, every motion censur’d, and on the whole be condemn’d to be but pretty, or a Beauty of the lowest rate. What think you? Dor. The Women, nay the very lovers who belong to the Drawing-room will malitiously allow you more than that; they always grant what is apparent, that they may the better be believ’d when they name conceal’d faults they cannot easily be disprov’d in.39
‘Conceal’d faults’, like Middleton’s body odour or Harvey’s ‘long clitoris’, whether real or imaginary, are a dominant theme of the Henry Stubbe to the Earl of Kent, [20 May 1674], BL MS Add. 35838, fo. 274v. iv. i. 135–47, in The Dramatic Works of Sir George Etherege, ed. H. F. B. BrettSmith (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1927), ii. 248–9. 38 39
38
The Court Lampoon
court lampoon.40 Seeing that the mistresses, despite their insecurity of tenure, were always the wealthiest and most powerful group among the court women, male courtiers of the king’s court were keen to cultivate them. One way of doing this was to write ribald satires on their behalf against their despised, tenured rivals of the queen’s and duchess’s courts. Court factional politics also had its territorial element concerned with the possession of privileged living space within the palace of Whitehall. The group-authored lampoon ‘Seigneur Dildoe’ contains a joke at the king’s expense put into the mouth of the Duchess of Portsmouth whose lodgings (three times demolished and reconstructed before she was satisfied with them) were at the end of the Long Gallery, the upper storey of the main north–south range of the palace: Great Sir, I pray, what doe you intend, To fumble soe long att the Galleryes end? If you Fuck mee noe better, I’le have you to know, I’le lay you aside for Seignior Dildoe.41
Her predecessor Cleveland had occupied apartments above the king’s with an interconnecting staircase. Less favoured invitees to the bed in the alcove had to make their way through the famous back stairs which led up from the Stone Gallery, the lower storey of the Long Gallery. Courtiers’ ‘apartments’ should not be seen as elements of a classically designed palace like Versailles. Apart from its major east–west range and north–south gallery, Whitehall was more like a crowded medieval town, in which one’s personal rooms might be in the form of a detached or semi-detached building or a lean-to erected against the side of some larger structure. Status was determined partly by the amount of space assigned and partly by proximity to the bed royal and privy chambers; insignificance was measured by their opposite, as in ‘The Ladies’ March’: Behold a dame too old to chancre ’em, Vulgarly called my Lady Ancram, Lodged in a garret at Whitehall, Hard by the Countess of Fingal.42 40 For the latter see ‘Oh! what damn’d Age do we live in’, l. 7, in Rochester, Works, 279 and ‘Colin’, l. 45 (CSR, 25), where Middleton and Harvey are represented as lovers. 41 42 Rochester, Works, 250 (ll. A69–A72). CSR, 57.
The Court Lampoon
39
Both the women mentioned belonged to the queen’s court. There was keen competition for favoured locations. Court lampoons often have an implicit geography, unperceived by modern readers—a matter further discussed in Chapter 5. Their writers and readers would have been well aware of places of waiting and residence within the palace.43 So, conflict at court was never a simple matter. To factional competition for status and privilege within the king’s court, rivalries between official and supernumerary place-holders, and competition between the four official courts and a number of unofficial ones, we have to add acute competition for favoured pieces of territory within the palace. The other major form of conflict was generational. The early Restoration court was still dominated by elderly survivors, headed by the Earl of Clarendon and the Duke of Newcastle, from the pre-interregnum courts and the court in exile. The exiled court had already seen tension between the old Cavaliers and those of the young king’s generation, such as Buckingham and his allies. These came to a head while plans were being made for the invasion from Scotland of 1651. The 23-year-old Buckingham had successfully opposed Clarendon by advocating an alliance with Argyle and the Covenanters at the expense of the Scottish royalists under Montrose, a decision which led inevitably to Montrose’s execution. Once away from Clarendon’s direct influence Buckingham became even more peremptory towards the king, pursuing him on horseback when he attempted to escape to the royalists. The failure of the expedition left Clarendon in unchallenged control of policy. Unable to match the older generation at statecraft, Buckingham resorted to ridicule. Clarendon wrote about him that His quality and condescensions, the pleasantness of his humour and conversation, the extravagance and sharpness of his wit, unrestrained by any modesty or religion, drew persons of all affections and inclinations to like his company, and to believe that the levities and vanities would be wrought off by age . . .44
Burnet saw the situation in darker terms: The man then in the greatest favour with the king was the Duke of Buckingham; he was wholly turned to mirth and pleasure; he had the art of turning 43 For one application of court geography to a text created for court performance, see my ‘Was Lucina Betrayed at Whitehall?’ in Nicholas Fisher (ed.), That Second Bottle: Essays on John Wilmot, Earl of Rochester (Manchester: Manchester UP, 2000), 179–90. 44 Selections from the History of the Rebellion . . . and the Life by Himself, ed. G. Huehns (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1955), 471.
40
The Court Lampoon
things into ridicule beyond any man of the age; he possessed the young king with very ill principles both as to religion and morality, and with a very mean opinion of his father, whose stiffness was with him a frequent subject of raillery.45
Charles, however, greatly preferred Buckingham’s personal style to Clarendon’s and so, following the Restoration, did a new generation of place-holders who were too young to have had any meaningful experience of the civil wars but were formed by the triumphalism and the rapidly succeeding cynicism of the Restoration. The wits of this generation, who included Rochester, Dorset, and Sedley, used a three-pronged method to unseat their elders, exploding their moralism with flagrant assertions and performances of its opposite, undermining their seriousness with unrelenting frivolity, and countering their formal antiquated manners with the new ‘easy’ elegance. The lampoon contributed to all three processes. This intergenerational strategy also poised the lampoon on a delicate balance between elegance and vulgarity which could easily tip over in either direction but which, when it is successfully maintained, produces a characteristic tone which has been admired in the satirical lyrics of Rochester, Dorset, and Sedley. It will be convenient to use one of Rochester’s grossest poems to illustrate this point since it is, in a sense, one that only a virtuoso of the genre could have brought off. The lyric ‘By all Loves soft, yet mighty Pow’rs’ is short enough to quote in full: Song By all Loves soft, yet mighty Pow’rs It is a thing unfit, That Men shou’d Fuck in time of Flow’rs Or when the Smock’s beshit. Fair nasty Nymph, be clean and kind, And all my joys restore; By using Paper still behind, And Spunges for before. My spotless Flames can ne’re decay, If after ev’ry close, My smoaking Prick escape the Fray, Without a Bloody Nose ;
45
Burnet, History, i. 33; see also i. 69.
The Court Lampoon
41
If thou wou’dst have me true, be wise, And take to cleanly sinning; None but fresh Lovers Pricks can rise, At Phillis in foul linnen.46
The achievement of the poem resides in a perfect matching of the form and cadences of the Cavalier lyric, as perfected by Waller and Suckling, with wholly incongruous content. This in itself brings about a further complication of tone, which arises in the piece’s double quality as a knowing and irreverent dislocation of the elements of the Wallerian genre and an expert and even deferential tribute to it. Great skill was required to sustain such a balance without tumbling over into burlesque or parody, and yet this does not happen: what we have instead is a perfectly poised piece of vers d’occasion. The poem does not convey dislike of the woman addressed and expresses neither repugnance nor unseemly arousal at the manifestations of her bodily functions; rather, it constitutes a good-humoured recommendation how intercourse, like other relationships of court civility, could be made more decorous for both of them, or, if we like, that Butler’s agreed ‘demeanour of faces, legs and elbows’ might be extended to other bodily parts. Phillis would hardly be flattered by being the recipient of this poem, and would be even less pleased by the revelation of her ‘conceal’d faults’ to all its other readers; and yet it is also a compliment to her presumed savoir faire and even an act of friendship in that it is alerting her to a handicap affecting her performance in the universal battle for wealth and status. (No rival would warn her of this!) A contextual reading would suggest that Phillis was a woman of wit and address but new to the refinements of court civility, which would be exactly the case if, as seems likely, she was Nell Gwyn.47 The poem also clarifies to the modern reader that, while there was nothing in any way mystificatory about courtly sex, it was always an intensely theatrical transaction in which attention had to be paid to every detail of self-presentation. If it shocks us today it is not because of its images (though divorced from a particular kind of generic control these would certainly shock) but because of a threatened transgression of both social and poetic decorum which, in the event, proves not to have taken place. What first presents itself as a piece of Works, 37–8. See my ‘Nell Gwyn and Rochester’s “By all Love’s soft, yet mighty Pow’rs” ’, N&Q 247 (2002), 355–7. 46 47
42
The Court Lampoon
impertinent malice has persuaded us by its close that it was almost well-meaning. It is this reconciliation of vulgarity of content with polished assurance that is the distinctive achievement of the Restoration court lyric and the best of the lampoons. It is not always achieved, and it must be acknowledged that many of the poems directed at women are blatantly misogynistic; and yet at its best such verse stays in touch with the canons of civilized conversation, in the gladiatorial sense in which these were then understood. The origin of this discordia concors lay in the intergenerational politics of the early years of the Restoration. The young needed to display their contempt for the idealism of the older generation of court Platonics, while simultaneously demonstrating that they exceeded them in the arts of courtliness which had been so prized in the last age. A lyric like ‘By all Loves soft, yet mighty Pow’rs’ performs both tasks; however, this represents an achievement of the 1670s that was still to be secured in the early 1660s when the lampoon and the lyric traditions both began. We need now to return to these beginnings.
t h e e a r ly c o u rt l a m p o o n It is from the rivalries enumerated, as they took form around 1663, that we can identify the birth of the Restoration court lampoon. Its first recorded manifestations are partly generational but also arise from a state of endemic rivalry between the male courts and the female ones. Early in 1663 the Earl of Chesterfield, learning of an affair between his countess and the Duke of York, had the bad taste to remove her to the country. Hamilton’s account of this is as follows: It was certainly some evil genius that induced Lord Chesterfield to distinguish himself from his patient countrymen, and by making a ridiculous fuss to afford the world an opportunity of examining into the particulars of an adventure, which would perhaps not have been known beyond the Court, and would have been everywhere forgotten in a month’s time. As soon as ever he had turned his back, to start on the march with his prisoner, and the ornaments she was supposed to have bestowed upon him, God knows what a terrible attack was made upon his rear. Rochester, Middlesex, Sedley, Etherege, and the whole band of wits, produced a number of ballads which diverted the public at his expense.48 48
Memoirs, ii. 41–2.
The Court Lampoon
43
There are problems with this narrative, written decades after the events described and in a form that was intended for the diversion of ladies at the courts of Hanover and France rather than to give a faithful account of historical facts.49 Rochester was only 15 at the time and absent from England on the Grand Tour; moreover, no verse libels on this subject are known to survive. Nonetheless, Hamilton’s narrative is plausible as a confused memory of one such occasion overlaid with memories of others of the same kind for which corroborating records do survive.50 Chesterfield was transformed into a stock butt partly because of his refusal to be a compliant cuckold in a court where oldfashioned values of that kind and those who maintained them were under constant attack, but principally, one suspects, because of his position as Lord Chamberlain to Catherine of Braganza, who headed the staidest and least fashionable of the three major female courts. George deF. Lord’s comment that ‘Except for The Queen’s Ball, the unfortunate Queen Catherine is hardly mentioned in Restoration satire’51 is misleading, since she was continually under attack by proxy through her ladies and maids. (Any direct assault might have compromised the king.) There were also to be hysterical Whig attacks during the Popish Plot agitation. By contrast the Chamberlain of the queen mother’s establishment at Somerset House was the rakish Henry Jermyn, an elderly favourite of the younger wits. Conflict between the male and female courts certainly underlies another surviving satire of 1663, which exists in two forms, the first beginning ‘Cary’s face is not the best’ and the second ‘Roger told his brother clown’. It consists of seventeen six-line stanzas using a distinctive trochaic opening to the first line and with the fourth and fifth only half the length of the others, suggesting that it was written to a pre-existing tune. The tone can be gathered from the two opening stanzas of the shorter version: Cary’s face is not the best, But sh<e’s> as useful as the rest, Though not so much alluring; She’s near as good As Madam Wood For pimping and procuring. 49 The origins of Hamilton’s text are described in Paule Koch, ‘Trajectoire européenne d’une œuvre sans passeports: les “Fragments de la vie du comte de Gramont” ’, in Giovanni Crapulli (ed.), Transmissione dei testi a stampa nel periodo moderno (Rome: Edizioni dell’Areneo, 1987), ii. 207–54 + 8 pp. plates. 50 51 Cf. Rochester, Works, 92, 424. POASY, i. 421.
44
The Court Lampoon Strangely pleasant were their chats, When Mayne and Steward played at flats, Their marriage night so taught them; Till Charles came there And with his ware Taught how their fathers got them.52
The second stanza illustrates the way in which the lampoon both fed off and was dependent on pre-existing gossip. Without knowing the story involved one would not be in a position to identify ‘Mayne’ as the Countess of Castlemaine (later Duchess of Cleveland) nor have any chance of decoding the very elliptical narrative of a female samesex mock-marriage ceremony in which she was the bridegroom and, after taking Frances Stuart to bed, allowed the king to take her place, a story which Pepys records as ‘said to be very true’ (8 February 1663).53 More to the point is that all of the women libelled in the first five stanzas were members of the queen’s court: Simona Cary, a maid of honour, Castlemaine, a lady of the bedchamber, Stuart a maid of honour, Winifred Wells, a maid of honour, Ellen Warmestry, a maid of honour, Katherine Boynton, a maid of honour, and Bridget Sanderson, the Mother of the Maids.54 Stanza 8 brings in Sir William Killigrew, Vice-Chamberlain to the queen, and his daughter Elizabeth, one of the queen’s dressers, and stanza 16 Elizabeth Livingston, a maid of the privy chamber to the queen. The remaining stanzas, some of which may have been additions tacked on in circulation, deal with other court figures; however, there can be little doubt that the satirist’s initial aim was to libel women of the queen’s court and that any other attacks were secondary to that. While making use of already circulating gossip, the poem is emphatically the work of an insider writing for other insiders. Its trochaic metre was to recur in such later satires on court ladies as Dorset’s ‘Colin’ (1679), Mordaunt’s ‘The Ladies’ March’ (1681), and ‘On the Mayds of Honor 1689’ (‘Franklyns beauty does surprize’).55 It should be noted that the queen’s appointees were mostly Catholics or Catholic sympathizers, as were the duchess’s after her conversion. In the early 1660s this was unlikely in itself to have been a source of antagonism but 52 CSR, 3, slightly relineated. See also Elmer L. Brooks, ‘An Unpublished Restoration Satire on the Court Ladies’, ELN 10 (1973), 201–8. 53 54 Diary, iv. 38. For these identifications see CSR, 6–9. 55 First two ibid. 23–31; 56–62.
The Court Lampoon
45
was soon to become so. Attacks on the female courts are increasingly coloured by sectarian bitterness. That we do not have a richer harvest of court lampoons from the early 1660s may in part be owing to the absence at the time of any effective mechanism for collecting and recording scribally circulated clandestine satire. For this to happen there had to be a recognition that such pieces were worth preserving in written form (within the court they may well have travelled memorially or by being read aloud rather than retranscribed), so ensuring that a large enough pool of copies emerged to offset the inevitable vulnerability of fugitive ‘separates’ passed from hand to hand. By the late 1670s this task was being performed by professional copyists who prepared both single copies and anthologies of libels for sale, and by compilers of private commonplace books who would make copies for their personal records; but for the early 1660s we have only one known manuscript source, Yale MS Osborn fb 140, ‘A Collection of Poems, Sayters and Lampoons’. The manuscript as we have it was written during the mid-1670s but incorporates a number of earlier linked groups of poems of varying date and theme encountered as already formed collections. The volume begins with a sequence of preRestoration drollery poems and anti-Puritan satires which are followed by a ‘state’ satire of 1670, ‘The King’s Vows’. Next comes a group of early court satires beginning with ‘On the Duke’s Servants’ (‘Charles Berkly talks aloud’) and the first two stanzas of ‘The Court Ladies, a Lampone’ (‘Cary’s face is not the best’ in the ‘Roger’ version). The following nine leaves have been excised; however, the index reveals that, besides the rest of ‘Cary’s face’, they contained three satires whose titles were ‘A Lampoon’ commencing on p. 22, ‘Upon the Dks: Maids of Honour’ commencing on p. 38, and ‘A Lampoon’, commencing on p. 40. These are followed by an attack on a group of male courtiers ‘Young gallants of the town leave whoring I pray’ of which the larger part survives.56 It is possible that among the excised pieces were lost poems by Rochester referred to in two anecdotes recounted by Hamilton: Saying this, the perfidious Hobart showed her friend half a dozen shameful couplets [i.e. stanzas], which Rochester had made against the former maids of honour. It was Miss Price whom he mainly assailed with the most bitter
56
For sources of the full version see Appendix.
46
The Court Lampoon
shafts, anatomizing her person in the most hideous manner imaginable. Miss Hobart had merely substituted the name of Temple for that of Price, which she made to agree with both the measure and tune of the song. *** Upon this discourse, Talbot thought it right to begin the recital of his sufferings and fidelity, when Miss Temple, with a paper in her hand, entered the room. This was a letter in verse, which Lord Rochester had written some time before, upon the intrigues of the two Courts; wherein, upon the subject of little Jennings, he remarked that Talbot had struck terror among the people of God, by his gigantic stature; but that Jermyn, like a little David, had vanquished the great Goliath.57
Rochester made his first formal appearance at court on Christmas Day 1664, immediately following his return from the Grand Tour. The ‘Satire on the Duke’s Servants’, taken together with the lost satire on the duchess’s maids of honour, might have constituted the satire on ‘the intrigues of the two Courts’ remembered by Hamilton. The male-directed lampoon uses the same tetrameter couplets as ‘Cary’s face’, distinguished from the Hudibrastic kind by the predominant trochaic metre: Never Prince was soe provided Of things more fitt to be derided Here’s a Stock would make one Cry Coxcombes for th’ whole Family58
Suspect though Hamilton’s accounts may be in matters of date and fact, there is no need to reject his testimony that libels were frequently transmitted by being read aloud and that they could be rewritten in transmission to change their application. The textual history of two well-documented later court lampoons, ‘Seigneur Dildoe’ and ‘In the Isle of Brittain’, show each being supplemented, revised, and interpolated as they passed from scribe to scribe.59 From the early 1670s court lampoons were much more likely to be 57 Memoirs, ii. 106, 168. For further commentary on these passages see Harold Love, ‘Hamilton’s Mémoires de la vie du comte de Grammont and the Reading of Rochester’, Restoration, 19 (1995), 95–102 and Rochester, Works, 474. Brooks, ‘An Unpublished Satire’, 201 records an advertisement for a printed version of ‘A Satyr on the Court-Ladies’ by Rochester which either never appeared or has failed to survive. 58 Yale MS Osborn fb 140, p. 22. 59 See my ‘A Restoration Lampoon in Transmission and Revision: Rochester’s(?) “Seigneur Dildoe” ’, Studies in Bibliography, 46 (1993), 250–62; ‘A new “A” text of “Signior Dildo” ’, Studies in Bibliography, 49 (1996), 169–75; and ‘Rochester’s “I’ th’isle of Britain”: Decoding a Textual Tradition’, English Manuscript Studies 1100–1700, 6 (1997), 175–223, as well as Rochester, Works, 596–9.
The Court Lampoon
47
preserved, largely because they had come to be eagerly sought by collectors outside the court. ‘Seigneur Dildoe’, written late in 1673 as an unofficial set of Fescennine verses for the marriage of James II to Mary of Modena, is a series of highly abusive stanzas directed chiefly at Catholics and with a strong representation of the women functionaries of the queen’s court.60 In this respect the hostilities underlying ‘Cary’s face’ remained unchanged, though it would be fair to say that Catholic faith was much more of a political issue now that the heir to the throne had declared himself a Catholic and married a Catholic duchess. Rivalry between the women of the king’s, the queen’s, and the duchess’s courts seems also to have inspired a complex satire of 1674, ‘Say Heav’n-born Muse’, which is one of the most unpleasant examples of its genre, a fact that has led some editors of Rochester to demote it from the canon.61 However, the piece deserves attention for the sheer brilliance with which, by deploying a tissue of allusions to Virgil, Milton, Spenser, Shakespeare, Homer, and the New Testament, it marries the materials of the court lampoon to the formal tradition of classical burlesque, anticipating in this respect the mock-heroic method of Dryden’s MacFlecknoe, written three or four years later. In my edition of Rochester I argue for its being an authentic work, despite the fact that Rochester himself appears in a not very flattering light as a character in the poem; but in view of David M. Vieth’s rejection I will simply refer readers to the evidence for and against presented there.62 The action of the poem (a competition, parodying that over the Homeric apple of discord, between three aristocratic ladies for the ownership of a dildo donated by Rochester) is set in Bath. The latest datable event referred to in it took place on 23 April 1674. Rochester’s presence in Bath in the following July is proved by a letter of Henry Stubbe, which also establishes that he was in attendance on the king’s maîtresse en titre, Portsmouth. Stubbe’s letter indicates that she had set up a miniature court of her own, that she regularly dined in state with ‘all people . . . admitted to see her, as were she Queen’, and that the aristocratic ladies of the district had reacted to this presumption by not ‘visiting’
For identification see Rochester, Works, 475–81. See in particular David M. Vieth, Attribution in Restoration Poetry: A Study of Rochester’s ‘Poems’ of 1680 (New Haven: Yale UP, 1963), 174–7. 62 Works, 414–15. 60 61
48
The Court Lampoon
her.63 The queen’s partisans in Bath would naturally have given their support to the boycott even if they did not organize it. The satire gives every sign of having been written from within Portsmouth’s retinue in order to revenge the snub. There is an additional slur at the expense of the Earl of Mulgrave, whose adherence to York had recently secured him the Garter. The poet has, therefore, aligned himself with Portsmouth’s faction within the king’s court against the representatives of the queen’s and the duke’s courts. The next problem is to identify Portsmouth’s enemies. This proves difficult because the poem gives every sign of having been revised in order to change the identities of its subjects. These are four women (Tall-boy, Kill-prick, Suck-prick, and ‘the mother of the maids’) and a clergyman. The first three named are living in the same house in Bath, where they are ‘Wanton in Bed, and Riotous at Board’. The clergyman seems to have been intended in the first version for a Catholic, possibly the queen’s almoner, Father Patrick, a stock figure of such lampoons: the field of candidates is a restricted one owing to the stringent laws then in place against Catholic worship. There are jokes about ‘the man of God’ singing te deum, his devotion to ‘Holy Church’, and his advocacy of intercession to saints. But the portrait has been overwritten to apply to the rector of Bath, Joseph Glanville, an Anglican cleric of Puritan inclinations who is pointed to by an obscene joke about the title ‘rector’ and a pun on the title of his philosophical treatise, Plus Ultra. The first of the women, Tall-boy, appears to be a similar composite of the queen’s maid of honour Philippa Temple and one of the queen’s ladies of the bedchamber, Mary Berkeley, Countess of Falmouth. Jokes about ‘Gigantick’ size, drunkenness (a tallboy was a drinking glass), and affairs with clergymen were the lampooners’ stock accusations against Temple. In ‘Seigneur Dildoe’ she is ‘Temple soe tall’. In ‘The Ladies’ March’ (1681) she is ‘Manton’s spouse’ (referring to the Presbyterian divine Thomas Manton) and a devotee of ‘ale and cheese’. In ‘An Essay of Scandal’ (1681) a repetition of the ‘ale and cheese’ taunt is combined with an accusation of her having been sodomized by the Bishop of London. In ‘An Heroic Poem’ (1681) she is pilloried for her grotesque appearance and susceptibility to ‘some spread pampered 63 Henry Stubbe to the Earl of Kent, 18 July 1674, BL MS 35838, fo. 276r–v, reprinted in James Jacob, Henry Stubbe, Radical Protestantism and the Early Enlightenment (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1983), 135–6.
The Court Lampoon
49
stallion robed in black’.64 In ‘A Ballad’ (‘To honourable court there lately came’) she is accused of an addiction to ‘bottle ale’.65 However, the fact that Tall-boy was a widow skilled at the ‘Cornish hug’ points at another frequent butt in Falmouth.66 In this case it is not clear which portrait is the overwritten one; but there may have been a good reason for removing Falmouth, who in June 1674 had secretly married Rochester’s friend the Earl of Dorset. Kill-prick and Suckprick, a mother and a daughter, are still unidentified, probably because a similar overwriting has produced a confusing mixture of features; but they may be one (or both) of two mother-and-daughter pairs introduced in the slightly earlier satire on the Catholic nobility, ‘Seigneur Dildoe’.67 ‘The mother of the maids’ is Lady Sanderson, the gouvernante of the queen’s maids of honour. While there is an element of speculation to all these identifications except the last, collectively they identify the poem as directed at the queen’s supporters. It might well be asked whether the portraits could have been constructed on a scattergun principle to catch as many victims as possible; but, if so, it would be against the overwhelming tendency of Restoration court satire to be extremely precise in its targeting. Indeed, it was rare not to give names directly. Wilson in his Court Satires seldom has to look far for an identification. Even Rochester’s more literary satires will often when probed reveal particular identities behind supposedly general portraits—Charles Blount and Lady Sanderson again in ‘A Ramble in St James’s Park’, Isaac Barrow in ‘Against Reason and Mankind’, Nell Gwyn in ‘By all Loves soft, yet mighty Pow’rs’.68 It must again be stressed that lampoons, like Private Eye and stand-up comedians today, depended on a small number of stock figures, who would be recognized immediately by readers. The key assumption is that of revision. Let us hypothesize, without making any assumptions about Rochester’s involvement, that ‘Say Heav’n-born Muse’ had been drafted as a Whitehall not a Bath lampoon by a member of the king’s court as a contribution to an already established genre of attacks on members of the queen’s 64 CSR, 16, 19, 57, 60, 64, 72, 75. She was a different person from the Miss Temple mentioned in the Gramont passages quoted earlier. 65 BL MS Harl. 6913, fo. 59r. 66 The port of Falmouth is in Cornwall. The countess had been a widow since 1665, but not according to the lampooners a chaste one. Temple was single. 67 ll. A25–36, A73–6, in Rochester, Works, 248–50. 68 See Works, 412, 388 and Love, ‘Nell Gwyn and Rochester’s “By all Love’s soft, yet mighty Pow’rs” ’.
50
The Court Lampoon
court. An awkward aspect of the narrative is that ‘Rochester’ has to return from Bath to Whitehall in order to consult the Mother of the Maids: this would have been avoided if the whole action had been set at the palace. There is even a possibility that not Rochester himself but another ‘Spiney Lord’ may have been the protagonist of the earlier version: the most likely substitute would be a Catholic member of the queen’s or the Duke or Duchess of York’s households. Let us hypothesize further that having been brought to Bath, the poem was then hastily revised to apply to supporters of the queen involved in the snubbing of Portsmouth. Rochester may have been the author of the original version, the Bath revisions, or both. He must certainly be a very strong candidate for the Bath revisions. In adjusting an existing verse libel to new circumstances he was doing no more than what was done, as Hamilton records and the textual history of ‘In the Isle of Brittain’ verifies, to his own writings. Information yet to be discovered may help confirm or confute this hypothesis but can hardly disqualify this unpleasant piece from being one of the masterpieces of Restoration court satire. It is also fairer than most in its allocation of abuse to male and female: ‘Rochester’ is moved by exactly the same Hobbesian, corporeal impulses as the three women, and is forced in the end, despite his display of prodigies of fornicatory valour, to relinquish them to his superior in virility, the parson.69
c o u rt sat i r e b e c o m e s n at i o n a l ‘Say Heav’n-born Muse’ is a particularly pure form of its genre. Its centring on a set of conflicts that were very much internal to the court meant that it would have had very little interest or meaning outside the court, or even outside Bath, and it is not surprising that it comes down to us via a single manuscript and one printed source.70 It also affirms the mystique of the court as an institution constituted out of rules of behaviour that were unintelligible to outsiders. Nonetheless, from the mid-1670s other, less hieratic kinds of court satire were beginning to find a double audience through being read both inside the court, as in-house communications, and outside it as accounts of the 69 Another argument for Rochester’s authorship: compare ‘Against Reason and Mankind’, ll. 202–9 and ‘A Ramble in St James’s Park’, ll. 90–6 for two other examples of clerical stallions. 70 Works, 594.
The Court Lampoon
51
circumstances under which the state was being ruled. One channel of transmission was through the Inns of Court, whose members, while generally hostile to the younger male courtiers, were also fascinated by them and secretly aspired to join their ranks.71 A considerable amount of copying of court lampoons seems to have taken place in the Inns and further copies to have accompanied communications to legal clients in the country.72 The effects of this external rereading were sensational. Accusations of sexual misconduct routinely made in the course of factional rivalry under a figurative substitution in which, as we will see, they stood as metaphors for power relationships were now given a new literal force as an index of the corruption of the whole system of monarchical government. The impact of these pieces can be compared with that of the Nixon and Clinton White House scandals: in both cases deeply treasured images of the dignity of supreme power were shattered beyond restitution. The difference between the reading practices of the two audiences soon came to be reflected in the appearance of new state lampoons written outside the court, attacking the court mistresses, which have none of the polish and playfulness that redeem the grossness of the true court lampoons, but display an almost hysterical misogyny. Consider the title alone of a performance directed at the Duchess of Portsmouth: ‘The Downfal of the French Bitch, England’s Metropolitan Strumpet, The three Nation’s Grievance, The pickled pocky Whore, Rowley’s Dalilah, all in a word, The damn’d dirty Dutchess.’73 Under the same influence genuine court lampoons began to appear which had more than half an eye on the wider national audience. It will be helpful to look quickly at a few of these in their relationship to the parallel genre of state satire, concentrating on those which are available for consultation in Wilson’s Court Satires and the Yale POAS collection. Dorset’s ‘Colin’ stands firmly in the tradition of the satires on the court women we have already considered. It is linked directly with ‘Cary’s face’ not only through its strong admixture of trochaic lines 71 On the hostility, see Brice Harris, Charles Sackville, Sixth Earl of Dorset, Patron and Poet of the Restoration (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1940), 51–2. 72 For one example of legal involvement in the transmission of satires see my ‘Scribal Texts and Literary Communities: The Rochester Circle and Osborn b. 105’, Studies in Bibliography, 42 (1989), 219–35. John Hoyle and Godfrey Thacker were among legal figures involved in the transmission of court satires. 73 (‘What down in the dirt by St Leonard her grace’), POAS (1702–7), iii. 211. Even this piece has to yield in point of grossness to an attack on Queen Catherine, ‘Thou worst of flesh in superstition stewed’.
52
The Court Lampoon
but by the device of the pastoral introduction. In the ‘Roger’ versions of the earlier poem this takes the form of a single introductory stanza: Roger told his Brother Clowne Such newes as hee heard in the Towne Just as they came from ringing Soe they sat downe upon the ground And thus they fell a singing74
No more is then heard of the pair. In ‘Colin’ the corresponding introduction runs as follows: As Colin drove his sheep along By Whitehall there was such a throng Of early coaches at the gate, The silly swain was forced to wait.
At this point Colin too effectively disappears until the concluding So they adjourned, And Colin to his flock returned, Swearing there was at every fair Blither girls than any there.75
Likewise each lampoon is constructed round a series of abusive penportraits of court ladies, those of ‘Colin’ being more extended but essentially the same mixture of received scandal and revelations of ‘conceal’d faults’. Wilson calls ‘Colin’ a ‘sessions’ satire, comparing it with the two Restoration ‘Sessions of the Poets’, modelled on Suckling’s original,76 and other lampoons in which malefactors are brought before an imaginary court; but it is equally suggestive of a parallel tradition in which the victims are introduced in a march or procession. ‘The Ladies’ March’ (1681; CSR, 56–9) is a poem of a very similar kind to the two under discussion, which also makes free use of the trochaic tetrameter. The pattern reminds us that real-life courtiers did quite a deal of processing, in strict hierarchical order. But in other ways ‘Colin’ stands outside this tradition: for a start it is not concerned with rivalry between the courts or even within the king’s court but with the malign influence of the office of maîtresse en titre on the king’s governance of the realm. 74 76
75 Yale MS Osborn fb 140, p. 22. CSR, 23. POASY, i. 327–37, 352–6. See also below pp. 80–1.
The Court Lampoon
53
The situation presented is one in which Portsmouth is imagined as having offered her position for sale through a bidding process in which Charles was to choose the winner. The bidders enter one by one, are described, present their proposal, and are dismissed, with no final decision being made. Dorset’s position at the time of the poem’s composition was an ambiguous one. As a gentleman of the bedchamber he was still involved in court ceremonial and factional politics on a day-by-day basis but at a national level he was opposing court policies in the Lords. The Buckingham faction, of which he had been a leading member, had been driven from political power by Danby and were now doing their best to destabilize Danby’s administration. Danby was simultaneously under attack from the Yorkist faction who were even more violently opposed to the Buckinghamites. A short lapse of time would see Danby in the Tower and the Yorkists on the defensive in the state against a concerted Whig parliamentary and popular movement to have the succession altered to debar the duke from becoming king. Dorset writes as a court poet whose attention is now diverted towards political action outside the court rather than intrigue within it. His poem reflects this tension and as a result invites different readings not by accident but by design from two differentially envisaged audiences. As a court poem it works by recycling time-honoured gossip about love affairs and ‘conceal’d faults’, such as Jane Middleton’s body odour. Next Middleton appeared in view, Who soon was told of Montague, Of baits of Hyde, of clothes from France, Of armpits, toes, and sufficance. (ll. 34–7)77
There is a certain routine quality about the retailing of this and other court lampoon clichés, suggesting that the genre was beginning to live off its past. As a national poem, on the other hand, its aim is to strip the court of its glamour. There is nothing particularly erotic about the women, as the poem presents them, or about the appeals they offer the king which, since this is a formal sale of a place, have to be monetary as well as sexual. And Morland fair enters the list, Husband in hand most decently, And begs at any rate to buy. 77 CSR, 24. ‘Sufficance’ here has its secondary French sense of vanity or bumptiousness.
54
The Court Lampoon She offered jewels of great price And dear Sir Samuel’s next device, Whether it be a pump or table, Glass-house or any other bauble. (ll. 47–53)
Charles’s own motives are also primarily economic: This hour from French intrigues, ’tis said, He’ll clear his Council and his bed. Portsmouth, he now vouchsafes to know, Was the cast miss of Count De Soe, Each night with her dear as a sessions Of the House, and fuller of petitions . . . (ll. 11–16)
He has decided in favour of ‘retrenching’ and ‘would no more of costly wenching’. In other words he is behaving exactly as the parliamentary Whigs wished him to behave. The materials of this poem are drawn from court life and Dorset’s voice is still recognizable as that of a court factional satirist; but the perspective of appraisal and condemnation is external to the court. The sense of court life being represented for the amusement or instruction of another constituency becomes even more strongly evident in satires of the next few years. Even so unmistakable a court satire as ‘Ignis Ignibus Extinguitur’ (1682) feels the need to make a concession to possible women readers outside the walls of Whitehall. The main theme of the poem is that Charles (who is directly addressed in court style as ‘sacred Sir’) should dispose of Nell Gwyn. Protect this Drab no more; If you must have One, have a handsome Whore. Of such foul Hags there ne’r can be a Dearth; O send her to her Dunghil, Mother Earth! Old, Wrinckled, Ugly, Loathsome as a Grave, She’d turn the Stomach of your meanest Slave.78
The objection is, again, primarily aesthetic: Nell no longer looks good enough to hold her position at Whitehall, and is in any case of low birth. (She was also of course a Protestant, though this is not explicitly raised: the lampoon could well have originated from the retinue of one of the Catholic mistresses.) However, the author is uncertain enough about his audience to preface the piece with a general apology: 78
BL MS Harl. 7319, fo. 110r.
The Court Lampoon
55
Your pardon then, you Fairest ones, (for all Under that Universal notion fall), If what I paint, you construe for ill Nature. The wise will Kindness see in every Feature; Ungovern’d Lewdness wou’d I fear Traduce The pleasing Sport, and shame it of use.79
This is not the tone of court satire, which had always been totally unapologetic about its misogyny and totally frank about the prevalence at court of ‘ungoverned lewdness’. The poem’s concern for the sensibilities of female readers is a ‘Town’ one. ‘Rochester’s Farewell’ (‘Tired with the noisome follies of the age’; late 1680 and present in twenty MS sources) is a diatribe written from what appears to be a moderate Yorkist factional position. Mulgrave is ridiculed for seeking military glory in Tangier, while Monmouth, Buckingham, and the inevitable Mazarin and Portsmouth are treated much more roughly. The opening expresses a general hostility towards the court as an ‘Augean stable’ which is impossible to clean, and there is a vividly dismissive depiction of the departing Tangier officers at a court ball: First at her Highness’ ball he must appear, And in a parting country dance learn there With drum and fife to make a jig of war. What is of soldier seen in all the heap Besides the flutt’ring feather in the cap, The scarf, and yard or two of scarlet cloth From Gen’ral Mulgrave down to little Wroth?
(ll. 57–63)80
But what follows is a series of personal attacks with no evident thematic connection. It is as individuals rather than as courtiers that the satirist’s victims are brought to judgement and the faults for which they are castigated are moral ones not violations of courtly decorum. ‘An Heroic Poem’ (1681), which survives in thirteen MS sources, is superficially easy to categorize as a court poem because of the large number of court functionaries and hangers-on named in its short, barbed attacks.81 A passage of particularly gross, visually specific abuse directed at the long-suffering Philippa Temple indicates that hostility towards the queen’s maids of honour was still a motivating force: 79 81
80 Fos. 109v–110r. POASY, ii. 221. Texts in CSR, 68–75 and POASY, ii. 228–34.
56
The Court Lampoon First Temple shall forbear t’admire the back Of some spread pampered stallion robed in black, She who so long a fallow land has laid, And brought a scandal on the name of Maid, Who while before the other nymphs she walks, And with her hanging dugs like dewlaps stalks, As some milch cow that leads the tender mulls, Licks up and goads the cods of slouching bulls; So, drunk with lust, she rambles up and down And bellows out, ‘I’m bulling round the town.’ Not Felton’s wife was in her youth more lewd, Or on the rising cud has oft’ner chewed, Nor Nell so much inverted nature spewed.82
Having conceded the grossness and no doubt unfairness of this portrait, we should also acknowledge it as evidence of the point made earlier about the arbitrary nature of lampoon accusations. Once Temple had been set up as a stock butt, the accusation of her being a seductress of clergymen became an automatic reflex. So far the poem is firmly anchored in court life and appearances; yet, there is no strong sense of factional animus and the victims seem to have been chosen merely because they irritated the satirist personally. Like ‘Rochester’s Farewell’ ‘An Heroic Poem’ is written in heroic couplets of a sententious neoclassical kind. Opening with a mock-Virgilian statement of topic followed by a burlesque invocation, it constitutes polished writing by the standards of the genre. Consider this: He was a vermin that stuck fast to bite; Put sullen virtue on to cloak his sin, Scipio without, but Catiline within.83
or this, with its ironical echo of Othello in the closing line: Victorious dullness sits upon his brow, And in each line of his notorious face, As in its proper indisputed place. In full defiance to pretense of wit, In broad Scotch characters, Fool, Fool is writ.84
The Homeric simile of the milch cow leading the mulls has Spenserian analogues. It comes as no surprise to find the poem ascribed to 82 84
83 CSR, 72. Ibid. 69; also POASY, ii. 229. CSR, 70; also POASY, ii. 231.
The Court Lampoon
57
Dryden in one manuscript source nor that stylometric tests conducted by John Burrows point to Dorset as the author.85 Its neoclassical polish would suggest that it was not intended for court readers alone, who had little appreciation of such things, but the wider constituency of the wits of the Town, the Inns of Court, and the universities. A later poem by Dorset, ‘A Faithful Catalogue of our Most Eminent Ninnies’, shows a further stage in the colonization of court satire by neoclassicism. While ‘Say Heav’n-born Muse’ and ‘An Heroic Poem’ move the court lampoon into the territory of the mock-heroic, it is the 481-line ‘Faithful Catalogue’ (discussed in detail in Chapter 7) that represents its most determined genuflection towards the Juvenalian model of formal verse satire.
s e x a n d t h e s i n g l e c o u rt i e r Since the lampooners’ hostile treatment of Philippa Temple has been instanced several times in this chapter, there is an obligation to make some kind of sense of it. The satirists’ vision of her ‘bulling’ around the court is unlikely to bear any relation to reality. Temple’s vulnerability to insult is more likely to have resulted from her being unusually tall and attached to the least fashionable of the sub-courts, that of Queen Catherine. That she was an alcoholic and a compulsive seducer of clergymen is most unlikely. Her much-ridiculed fondness for ale probably indicates no more than that, following traditional English custom, she made small beer her table drink in a court of Gallophile winebibbers. (The queen herself drank only water.) For the second accusation to arise required only that she should display a degree of religious commitment which, while unusual among Protestants at court, was common in society at large. In any case we would hardly blame a woman in her situation for wishing to distance herself from the Catholics of the queen’s court during the dangerous Popish Plot years when Catherine herself became the object of accusations by Titus Oates which were much worse than any directed at her maid of honour.86 The writer of another lampoon on the maids 85 From a database of major poets of the period, he is strongly preferred. The question then arises whether an unrepresented minor poet could have been capable of so virtuosic a piece. 86 These included her involvement in the murder of Sir Edmund Berry Godfrey and planning to poison her husband. Oates went too far here: despite his many infidelities Charles was always totally loyal to Catherine in her position as his consort.
58
The Court Lampoon
of honour, ‘To honourable court there lately came’, can find nothing worse to say about her than Pious Temple who has long been musty and stale By her dayly devotion and hope to prevail To gaine . . . kind creddit for more bottle Ale87
Allowing that she may have had affairs, she could hardly have been the monster of lust depicted by the lampooners and simultaneously held her position as a maid of honour to the queen for over twenty years.88 So how are we to interpret such descriptions as the following from ‘An Essay of Scandal’ (1681) in which Charles is urged to cashier the expensive Portsmouth and Gwyn in favour of ‘cheap, wholesome whores’. To achieve this he should Take Temple, who can live on cheese and ale, Who never but to bishop yet turned tail; She’s seasoned, fit to bear a double brunt, In her arse London, Rowley in her cunt. Bishop and King, choose (handy-dandy) either; They still club votes, why not club seeds together?89
The author has the grace to concede that Temple is only a putative lover for Charles and no one would for a moment have believed the accusation directed against Henry Compton, the Whig Bishop of London—indeed, it is explicitly conceded that she was ‘wholesome’ (i.e. free of venereal disease). What we are actually given is an allegory of the political alliance (clubbing of votes) in which the bishops in the Lords had unanimously supported Charles’s anti-exclusionist policies in the cycle of parliaments recently completed. ‘Temple’ in this description is the surrogate for those parliaments, corrupted simultaneously by the king’s gold and the more subtly disbursed patronage of the Church of England hierarchy. We have to read past this sexual narrative for its political core in the same way as Lois Potter has instructed us how to read through the more decorous narratives of royalist writers of the interregnum.90 ‘Ballad’, BL MS Harl. 6913, fo. 59r. Temple was still a maid of honour in the absent queen dowager’s residual English court as late as 1700. 89 CSR, 64. 90 Secret Rites and Secret Writing: Royalist Literature 1641–1660 (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1989). 87 88
The Court Lampoon
59
Sodomy, with both sexes, was ineradicably associated in the minds of Protestant Britons with the Roman Catholic clergy and with Catholicism generally.91 In the obscene play Sodom, Charles’s Declaration of Indulgence of 1672, which gave Catholics a measure of religious freedom, is parodied as a universal legitimization of buggery.92 Elsewhere, Rochester, in a morbid piece of self-parody, announces that he has . . . swiv’d more whores more ways then sodoms walls E’re knew or the Colledge of Romes Cardinalls.93
It was also tacitly assumed that those members of the Church of England who had to endure enforced celibacy, which included the fellows of Oxford and Cambridge colleges, were addicted to the Roman vice, while their Nonconformist counterparts were portrayed as ‘stallions’ to ‘holy sisters’. The association of Catholicism with sodomy recurs in a verse lampoon comparing Portsmouth with Nell Gwyn: Have you not heard how our Soveraigne of late Did first make a Whore then a Dutches Create A notable Wench of the Catholick kinde A Whore not onely before, but a Bugger behinde Poor Protestant Nell, well were it for thee Wert thou a Whore of a double Capacity Alas the Royall Pintle never yet went Into thy Maiden Lach or Fundament Thou art Resolv’d, what e’re on it come Protestant like to keep Chast thy Bum. Thou nobly scorns’t, by such base Arts to thrive But let the best French Whore that’s now alive Meet if she dare, and fairely with thee swive.94
Taken together, these examples and the Temple satires point at a more general analogy through which sexual subjection stands as a metaphor for the subjections enforced at every level of court behaviour by the assertion of absolute power. Either the male or the female 91 On the history of this prejudice see Alastair Bellany, The Politics of Court Scandal in Early Modern England (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2002), 257–61. 92 On this point see Richard Elias, ‘Political Satire in Sodom’, SEL 18 (1978), 423–38. 93 ‘To the Post Boy’, ll. 5–6 (Works, 43). 94 ‘A Satyr’, Yale MS Osborn fb 140, p. 173. For Portsmouth, cf. Turner, Libertines and Radicals, 259–60.
60
The Court Lampoon
might be dominant in such relationships: the point at issue was whether the person who was sexually dominant was also dominant in the ‘natural’ hierarchy of the state. If this was the case both the relationship and the lust it aroused might be seen as laudable; but in situations where the power gradient of the relationship was opposed to that of the established hierarchy we would expect to discover constructive treason, which would express itself through irregular forms of sexual activity. So, while there could be no objection to Temple’s submitting to the king, there clearly was to her submitting, in explicit violation of Erastian principles of statecraft, to the bishop. The unnaturalness of Portsmouth’s sexual domination of the king is a perpetual theme of both the court and the state lampoon. By a symbolism most memorably encapsulated by Rochester, the woman who had control of the king’s penis was in control of the state: Nor was his high desire above his Strength: His Scepter and his Prick were of a length, And she may sway the one who plays with t’other95
Because Portsmouth’s intercourse with the king reverses the constitutional delegation of power, it cannot count as fair swiving and must, therefore, be depicted as sodomy. Nell on the other hand, who offers the king pleasure without in any way wishing to encroach on his prerogative, becomes a champion not only of Protestantism but of orthodox intercourse. In such ways the sexual invective endemic to the lampoons often asks to be construed as political allegory. I believe this was sensed by at least some of the writers of these pieces and that in their narratives of scandal they were interrogating problems in the exercise of power that could not at that period be addressed in any more satisfactory or intelligent way. One consequence of this emblematic use of sexual insults is that accusations of sodomy, whether heterosexual or homosexual, made in lampoons cannot, when they belong to the language of political allegory, be taken as a guide to actual patterns of sexual behaviour at the court or elsewhere. (It should also be noted that ‘arse’ will often be used as a metonym for vagina in couplets where it is needed as a rhyme word for ‘tarse’ and ‘bum’ when it has to rhyme with ‘thrum’.) The same naturally applies to heterosexual behaviour attributed as 95 Works, 85–6. The theme of Portsmouth’s power over the kingdom exercised through her sexual control of the king is most fully developed in a state satire, ‘The Looking Glass’, BL MS Harl. 6913, fos. 51r–52v.
The Court Lampoon
61
part of the same hermetic language to men and women who were real-life homosexuals. While the lampoon tradition, taken collectively, contains much otherwise unobtainable evidence about Restoration homosexuality its purpose was never sociological. One of several lampoon references to Anne, Lady Freschville, accusing her of being a lesbian, adds the anatomical detail: It once was my fortune to turn up her Cloths, Three Inches of P—k hard by her C—t grows. You Ladies who yet have not heard of her Name, At her House may be sped with a Man or a Dame.96
The notion that lesbians had large clitorises comes from folk legend, while its introduction as a ‘concealed fault’ is patently generated by the medium, not any personal knowledge of the lampooner. The political subtext of the reference is to be sought in Freschville’s position as a gentlewoman of the bedchamber to Princess Anne at a time of hostility between her and her sister Queen Mary, one of the issues of which was Anne’s infatuation with Sarah Churchill.97 These decodings of sexual insults are not meant to absolve the lampooners of their habitual, often brutal misogyny, something explicitly proclaimed in the opening lines of ‘Essay on Scandal’: Of all the plagues with which this world abounds, Our discords causes, wid’ners of our wounds, Sure woman is the lewdest can be guessed; Through woman, mankind early ills did taste; She was the world’s first curse, will be the last.98
Patriarchal prejudice could not be more nakedly displayed. Homophobia is just as routine and unthinking. Surprisingly little lampoon verse openly adopts a gay perspective.99 In other cases, the pornopolitics of the lampoon betrays a very ancient and persistent moral position in which sex itself is seen as inherently corrupt. There is little uncomplicated celebration of the pleasures of copulation to be found among the writers of scribally circulated verse, and when this is attempted, as in Mulgrave’s ‘The Perfect Enjoyment’ (‘Since now my ‘Satyr, on the Ladys of Honor’, Bodleian Library, MS Firth c 16, p. 213. For this see POASY, v. 339–44 and the attack on the ‘Princess’ ladies’ at v. 351, which accuses them of being prudish and malicious. 98 CSR, 63. 99 That which does is considered in Paul Hammond, Figuring Sex between Men from Shakespeare to Rochester (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2002). 96 97
62
The Court Lampoon
Sylvia is as kind as fair’), it often strikes a strangely unpersuasive note. Instead, the governing equation is one between sexual performance and physical decay. Lust is a fire that not only corrupts the soul but distorts the body, especially those parts of the body most directly engaged in it. Penises are deformed, chancred, or become too ‘limber’ to execute their function; clitorises ‘mount in open day’; vaginas become monstrously enlarged or congested with ‘whites’: Besides her other charming qualities, As dewlaps hanging down her tawny thighs And ever moistened with congenial glue, Just like the bull that fierce Almanzor slew; Besides an odoriferous perfume, Which yet, like strength of cordials, may o’ercome.100
The comic exaggeration of decay at the conclusion of Sodom is different only in degree from the habitual representations of the court lampoon. The Pr—s are eaten off the womens parts Are witherd more then their dispareing hearts The Children harbour heavy discontents Complaineing sorely of their fundaments. The old doe curse and envy all that swiue And yet in spight of impotence will striue And Fuck and bugger tho’ they stinke aliue101
}
These descriptions, for all their comic bravura, reinscribe an ancient body-hating morality inherited from the medieval Church and the attendant medical doctrine, also embraced by Donne, that orgasm was a dissipation of vital powers that were essential for the prolongation of life and health. For all their impropriety, their moral lesson is actually a very conservative one—a matter to be considered further in Chapter 6.
t h e r e i g n s o f J a m e s a n d W i l l i a m a n d M a ry The accession of James II in 1685 saw a serious attempt to suppress the sexual excesses of Charles’s time, a campaign that became even more marked as Protestant functionaries were replaced by Catholic 100 101
‘On Three Late Marriages’, ll. 65–9; CSR, 78. Rochester, Works, 330.
The Court Lampoon
63
ones, including those holding orders. This should have led to a decline in the older style of court lampooning but its effect was the reverse, in that much had now come to depend on the new reforms being proved to be as hypocritical as those formerly made by the Puritans. To be godly in either form was to provoke an immediate suspicion of insincerity. How the court was now seen from outside is indicated by a revealing passage in ‘The Town Life’ (‘Once how I doted on this jilting town’), a ‘Town’ lampoon of 1686 describing a typical day spent in the new pleasure city of the West End. Viewed from this perspective the court is no longer the fons et origo of values and styles but simply one of the sideshows of the Town to be visited in the normal course of the day. It was still of course the centre of the national administration but actual power, as the events of 1688 were to show, was steadily slipping out of the hands of that administration. But now for cards and play they all propose, While I who never in good breeding lose, Who cannot civilly sit still and see The ladies pick my purse and laugh at me, Pretending earnest business drive to court, Where those who can do nothing else resort. The English must not seek preferment there, For Mac’s and O’s all places destin’d are. No more we’ll send our youth to Paris now— French principles and breeding once would do— They for improvement must to Ireland sail, The Irish wit and language now prevail. But soft my pen, with care this subject touch, Stop where you are, you soon may write too much!
(ll. 116–29)102
The court so reconstructed was no longer central in any meaningful way to the cultural and intellectual life of the metropolis but had become an outpost of an alien minority. This siege predicament had the effect of muting factional conflict within the court itself, even though important differences certainly existed at the political level, even among Catholics. A large portion of the old functionary class simply withdrew from active participation in the ceremonial life of the court or kept their appearances to a minimum. Unlike Charles, who had liked to keep factions at each other’s throats in order to prevent any single one from gaining an ascendancy, James wanted a court that 102
POASY, iv. 67.
64
The Court Lampoon
was unified in politics and, if possible, also in religion. The copious satire directed at his priests, the old Catholics, and the new converts came from outside the court. Much of it had its origin in a kind of dispersed, Protestant court in exile who were perfectly acquainted with the life of the palace. The coming to the throne of William and Mary brought yet another set of relationships between the court and the outside world. William was contemptuous of court ceremonial and was no more inclined than James to tolerate the older kinds of flagrant immorality. He restricted himself to a single discreet mistress, and though the Jacobites never ceased to accuse him of homosexual relationships with his closest Dutch male advisers there is a sense of a desperate raking for scandal to these attacks. Mary’s female court was relatively free of the kind of scandal which had stigmatized its predecessors. Both of them disliked the old palace of Whitehall (which in 1698 was destroyed by fire), preferring to spend their time at other residences, especially Hampton Court. The only competing court on English soil was that of Mary’s sister, the future Queen Anne, the two being distinguished in one satire as ‘Kensington Court and the Court of Bantam’, but neither provided much occasion for lampoons.103 Despite this superficially unpromising atmosphere, poems about court life, largely from the pens of Dorset and his circle of protégés, continued to appear, circulated in manuscripts written by the ‘Cameron’ scriptorium.104 However, the bulk of the lampoons on court topics do not constitute court poetry in the sense given to the term at the beginning of this chapter. Instead we encounter work by exiles from the court writing about the court for an external audience, total outsiders writing about the court, and political satire with no connection with the court using the language and tropes of court satire as a way of attacking the great. All these will be considered shortly under other headings. As a sign that an era was at an end, the period also saw the consolidation of the court satire of the previous two reigns into vast manuscript anthologies, some of which, arranged in chronological order, constituted a kind of secret history of past events in the inner recesses of power.105 But little of the new, genuine verse had either POASY, v. 369. W. J. Cameron, ‘A Late Seventeenth-Century Scriptorium’, Renaissance and Modern Studies, 7 (1963), 25–52. 105 Collections of this kind include BL MS Harl. 7319; Victoria and Albert Museum MS Dyce 43 and its near twin Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Cod. 14090. 103 104
The Court Lampoon
65
the savagery or the vivid particularity of the old. Rather it recounted, with urbanity and amusement, the kind of day-to-day altercations and impertinencies that might have arisen in any large settled community. In some cases, represented by the two poems ‘The Nine’ and ‘The Female Nine’, the occasions arose during William’s frequent absences in Ireland or to campaign in the Netherlands when the conduct of the state was left in the hands of a council.106 It is doubtful how far the considerable body of vituperative verse that emerged from the court in exile at Saint-Germain should be allowed to count as court poetry: for the most part its motivation is undisguisedly national and political. The cultural life of the exiled court was a richer one than is normally realized and it had its distinguished writers as well as its great musicians (including François Couperin); but it remains beyond the consideration of this study. Court satire was to revive at several points during the eighteenth century but by 1700 the particular heteroform composition of the Restoration court, and the fierce energies released within that unstable compound, were largely neutralized. It is time now to consider what the court invention had contributed to the broader field of satirical writing beyond its walls. 106
See POASY, v. 195–201, 202–10 and pp. 163–4 below.
3
The Town Lampoon In the epilogue to Aglaura (1638), Suckling divides up the Blackfriars audience into five juries, each of which is to give its separate opinion of the play. The first is a ‘Grand Jurie . . . of Towne-wits’. The second is a ‘Jurie of the Court’. The third and fourth are composed of the ‘Ladies of the Towne’, and ‘their servants’. The fifth is that of ‘the Citie’.1 This indicates that there was already a clear conception of the ‘Town’ as something distinct from the older urban entities of the court and the city—a matter that has been perceptively explored by Lawrence Manley.2 In the prologue to Marriage A-la-mode (1671) Dryden speaks more specifically of the theatre’s ambition ‘T’oblige the Town, the City, and the Court’ (l. 39). This triform division of the metropolis, which is also made by several other Restoration dramatists, reflects a distinction that by that time was geographical and demographical as well as cultural.3 Geographically the City was the old London within the medieval walls and its ancient suburbs beyond them, and was governed by its mayor, aldermen, and livery companies. The court was identified with the palace of Westminster at what was then the southern extremity of the metropolis, facing open fields on the opposite bank of the Thames. The Town was the new westward and south-westward extension from the City that was rapidly 1 The Works of Sir John Suckling: The Plays, ed. L. A. Beaurline (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1971), 95. 2 Literature and Culture in Early Modern London (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1995), 481–97. 3 For further examples of this tripartition, see the epilogue to Shadwell’s The Sullen Lovers (1668), l. 8, in The Works of Thomas Shadwell, ed. Montague Summers (London: Fortune Press, 1927), i. 92; Buckingham’s ‘A Familiar Epistle to Mr Julian, Secretary to the Muses’, l. 61, in POASY, i. 390; the epilogue to Nathaniel Lee’s Theodosius (1680), l. 29, in The Works of Nathaniel Lee, ed. Thomas B. Stroup and Arthur L. Cooke (New Brunswick, NJ: Scarecrow Press, 1954–5), ii. 304; v. i. 489–90 of Otway’s The Soldier’s Fortune (1681), in The Works of Thomas Otway, ed. J. C. Ghosh (Oxford, 1932), ii. 186; and ii. iii. 25 of Crowne’s The English Frier (1690), in The Comedies of John Crowne: A Critical Edition, ed. B. J. McMullin (New York: Garland, 1984), 522.
The Town Lampoon
67
filling the space between it and the palace. Dryden makes no reference to the Southwark area of the south bank, although half a century earlier this had been the primary site of theatrical performance. The pull of the court and the Town had drawn the players and dramatists northwards. At the time he wrote, one house, Drury Lane, stood in Covent Garden, and the other, specializing in spectacular drama, was operating within the boundaries of the City at Dorset Garden. The geographical Town is usually designated by that name; however, since ‘town’ continued to be used in its old general sense of the entire conurbation, it was also common to speak of ‘this end of the town’ or ‘t’other end of the town’, with the import of the phrase varying with the social allegiance of the speaker. One also encounters ‘t’other-end-of-the-town’ and ‘this-end-of-the-town’ as compound adjectives.4 Characters in Ravenscroft’s The London Cuckolds i. i contrast ‘that damn’d lewd other end of the Town’ with ‘this sober end of the Town’ (i.e. the City).5 Though terminology wavered, there was an acute sense of a cultural difference which is reflected in the styles of lampooning characteristic of court, City and Town.
T ow n v e rs u s c o u rt While the Town lampoon and the court lampoon use a similar verse manner to attack many of the same members of the ruling elite, and while ‘Rochester’s Farewell’, ‘An Heroic Poem’ and the ‘Faithful Catalogue’, already discussed, might, depending on one’s personal orientation, have been read as either, there is usually little problem in categorizing particular works as being written from a court or a Town perspective. A court satire is of the court, courtly: it is written for a court readership about court concerns of status, factional striving for power, and corporate style. It arises from a sense of the special identity of the court as a community and sets out to reinforce that community’s sense of exclusiveness. A Town satire speaks to a new social formation which was still in the process of fashioning its identity. 4 e.g. in Behn, The City Heiress, ii. i. 87–8, The Revenge, i. i. 30, and Sir Patient Fancy, iv. iii. 92–3, in The Works of Aphra Behn, ed. Janet Todd, 7 vols. (London: Pickering and Chatto, 1992–6), vii. 23, vi. 167, vi. 57; and Cibber, The Double Gallant, iv. i. 314–15, in Colley Cibber’s ‘ The Double Gallant’: A Critical Old-Spelling Edition, ed. John Whitley Bruton (New York: Garland, 1987), 130. 5 (London, 1682), 2, 7.
68
The Town Lampoon
Satire was a means of asserting this community’s independence from the older, competing pair, of training its members in acceptable modes of deportment, and of articulating shared values. The Town looked to its lampooners, along with its dramatists, to explain to it what it was and what it might become. This applied even when writers and readers were technically members of more than one community, since individual allegiances might easily vary to suit the environment of the moment. An analogy today might be the kind of change in attitude that takes place when a member of the community of pedestrians gets behind a wheel to become a member of the community of drivers or vice versa, switching one variety of road rage for an entirely different one. Rochester ‘was wont to say that when he came to Brentford the devill entred into him and never left him till he came to the country again’ but he might well have had a similar experience in moving between Whitehall and Covent Garden.6 However, before attempting to discover what distinguished a Town mindset from a court one, it will be necessary to give some attention to the urban dynamics of the metropolis during the Restoration decades. In the reign of Charles I, when government policy was firmly opposed to the development of the West End for housing, much of it was still fields. This anti-development policy was prompted by a fear that, if the opportunity were available, the better-off gentry families would abandon their responsibilities as landlords, justices of the peace, and manipulators of parliamentary elections in favour of spending the greater part of the year in London. During the interregnum, with political priorities reversed, this was exactly what began to happen. After 1660, squares and terraces, many bearing the names of Restoration courtiers, marched steadily westward and south-westward from the City into the parishes of St James, St Paul, St Anne, St Giles, and St Martin. The Fire of 1666, which destroyed the City, spared the West End. In the decades that followed many families who had formerly been renters during short winter residences became householders, only returning to their estates for the summer. This alteration was particularly agreeable to the females of those families, for whom the country regimen of agriculture and hunting was less congenial than to their menfolk and who, being less mobile, were more affected by the isolation of rural existence. They 6 John Aubrey, Brief Lives, ed. Andrew Clark (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1898), ii. 304.
The Town Lampoon
69
took to Town life and its attendant freedoms with enthusiasm. The presence in this newly settled area of the metropolis of a continually growing body of wealthy countrypersons come to Town brought with it a migration of professionals to serve their practical needs and entertainers and shopkeepers to minister to their pleasures.7 The new arrivals brought new forms of sociability, initially built around county affiliations. There was an annual Kentish feast, and Jeffrey Boys inaugurated a Kentish Club in 1671 which met for a number of weeks at the Greyhound Tavern.8 Yorkshire gentry, meeting in 1690 for their annual feast, commissioned an ode from Purcell.9 But the most important changes were in modes of interpersonal communication. Court sociability was structured around the hierarchical relationships of the levee, in which those of lower rank would ‘wait’ upon those of higher rank in a display of conspicuous clientage which has already been glimpsed, at its highest level, in the descriptions of waiting and dining at Whitehall but which was imitated at the subordinate strata of an extended culture of deference. In opposition, the new arrivals developed a kind of sociability based on ‘visiting’, which quickly acquired its own rules and exclusivities but was essentially an adaptation of a freer country practice to the new opportunities of the metropolis.10 Visiting was performed by coach among near equals and, while not free of hierarchical constraints, represented a conscious reaction against court formality. Many scenes in Restoration comedy are constructed as visits. In Act I of Etherege’s The Man of Mode (1676), Dorimant, an aristocratic 7 For some of the consequences of this see my ‘Dryden, Rochester and the Invention of the Town’, in Claude Rawson (ed.), John Dryden (1631–1700): His Politics, his Plays, and his Poets (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 2003), 36–51 and ‘Dryden’s London’, in Steven Zwicker (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Dryden (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2004), 111–28. This second migration was opposed by the City, which wished to keep crafts and trades housed within the walls where they were under the legal jurisdiction of the respective companies. Emigration of craftsand tradespersons into the newly settled parishes, where they were free of City supervision, undermined the anti-competitive aspect of the guild system. 8 See H. R. Plomer, Kentish Feast: Being Notes on the Annual Meetings of the Honourable Society of Natives of the County of Kent, 1657–1701 (Canterbury: Cross & Jackman, 1916) and G. J. Gray, ‘The Diary of Jeffrey Boys of Gray’s Inn, 1671’, N&Q 159 (27 Dec. 1930), 452. 9 ‘The Yorkshire Feast Song’ (‘Of old when heroes thought it base’, Z333). 10 For the visit, see Hannah Woolley, The Gentlewoman’s Companion; or, a Guide to the Female Sex (London, 1675), 48–50 and, for an invaluable modern account, Susan E. Whyman, Sociability and Power in Late-Stuart England: The Cultural Worlds of the Verneys 1660–1700 (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1999), esp. 87–109.
70
The Town Lampoon
libertine, receives news of Town happenings from his friends Medley and Bellair. That the meeting is a visit, not a levee, is made clear by bonhomie and mutual kissing. Earlier Dorimant had chatted amiably to Swearing Tom, the shoemaker, and Orange Nan, the fruit woman and bawd, neither of whom shows any particular deference. His own later visit in the persona of Mr Courtage to Lady Woodville’s house requires more formal manners but is still portrayed as part of a relaxed coming together of near equals, which is to say as a Town rather than a court occasion. Visits might often include the exchange and discussion of lampoons: one satirist, who will be quoted again, complains: A man can make no visitt now but his Caresse Is a Lewd satyr shewn which Pray sir Guess whose still [style] it is:11
At other times the Town gathered to fare la passegiata on foot in the Mall, to parade by coach in Hyde Park, to converse in the ordinaries and coffee houses that now proliferated, to shop in the New Exchange and the India houses, to visit dressmakers, tailors, wigmakers, booksellers, and portrait painters, and to see and be seen in the dress circle and pit of the theatres, especially Drury Lane. Southerne’s The Wives’ Excuse (1691) shows us the Town engaged in several of its social rituals. The play opens with a scene set in the antechamber to the concert room at York Buildings, in which footmen and pages gossip about the love affairs of their employers in a manner very similar to that of the lampoon writers. We are then taken inside the concert hall to see the Town engaged in two of its principal diversions, music and sexual intrigue. When the concertgoers emerge there is a busy interlude of calling for chairs and coaches and arranging meetings, an attempt to pass a billet-doux, and a stage-managed quarrel. Act II begins with a description of visits hosted by Mrs Witwoud, ‘an old blown-upon she-wit’: you’re never to be seen in your Lodging at any other time of the day; and then, too, as soon as you’re out a Bed a morning, you Summon a Congregation of your Fellows together, to hear you prate by the hour, flatter every body in the Company, speak ill of every one that’s absent, and scatter about the scandal of that day.12 11 ‘ The Visitt’ (‘Pox on the rhyming fops that plague the town’), Lincolnshire Archives Office, MS ANC 15/ B/4, p. 20. 12 The Works of Thomas Southerne, ed. Robert Jordan and Harold Love (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1988), i. 289.
The Town Lampoon
71
In real life such meetings might also be research sessions for lampoons. iii. ii is a Mall scene. Group after group pass over the stage absorbed in the various concerns of the Town. Act IV shows us the closing stages of a fashionable dinner party during which the guests drink tea, intrigue, and settle to cards and a raffle. Southerne mocks the endemic consumerism of the Town, when Mr Friendall launches into catalogues of his rare wines, snuffs, and teas. The last and grandest scene is a masquerade. Though the principal characters are all from the beau monde, they are not ostensibly connected with the court (Mr Friendall boasts of his influential friends in the City who are the source of his rare consumer goods). Their lives are wholly devoted to the pleasures of the Town and an unending round of sexual pursuit and resistance. What the play sets out to tell us is that this life is never simple to live and that dangers to status, reputation, and, for the few who possess it, integrity lurk everywhere. One of these dangers is poetical: after, as he imagines, being stood up at an assignation, Mr Friendall snarls, ‘There are Lampoons, Sir, I say no more; But I may do my self reason in one of ’em, and disappoint her yet of her disappointment.’13 While the inexperienced and the overconfident lurch from disaster to disaster, those with more understanding are occupied with schemes either to ruin them entirely or to rescue them from the consequences of their folly. The only wisdom that matters is the wisdom of the Town, and even that is a dubious entity whose governing rules are never clear, though by the end of the play one of them—that fidelity to an unfaithful spouse is ipso facto ridiculous—has at least been called into question. What is never questioned is that this new, pleasure-centred Town life is the best that can rationally be hoped for. Even those who despise it have no desire to escape from it. Insofar as the Town had a central meeting place for the assertion of its collective identity, it was the theatre. It is at the King’s House in Drury Lane that Wycherley’s Horner in The Country Wife must present himself to establish his new status of eunuch by surgery and to discover how he is to be treated by society at large. In i. i. 166–89 he interrogates his friends about the judgements which have been passed on him. In The Wives’ Excuse Mr Friendall chooses ‘the Sidebox, before the Ladies’ as the place where he is to receive a public apology for an affront.14 The Restoration comedy of manners is in a 13
v. iii. 138–9 (ibid., i. 335).
14
Ibid., i. 302.
72
The Town Lampoon
fundamental sense Town comedy, concerned with teaching practical lessons about how to distinguish between prudent and imprudent behaviour—lessons which had to be assimilated by new immigrants from the country if they were to enjoy the Town rather than being destroyed or corrupted by it. This holds particularly for ‘comedies of manners’ written for Drury Lane. Dorset Garden favoured a more populist style directed at its City audience; however, The Man of Mode was performed at Dorset Garden. Of the three plays just mentioned, The Wives’ Excuse contains fifty occurences of the word ‘town’, The Country Wife sixty, and The Man of Mode a remarkable 115. The Country Wife deals explicitly with the collision of country spontaneity and Town dissimulation in its two models of naivety, the sophisticated but incorrigibly trusting Alithea and the ignorant but quick-to-learn Margery.15 Marriage was placed under particular stress as country husbands encountered the artful operators of the Town sex industry, with consequences described in the history of Corinna as narrated in Rochester’s ‘Artemiza to Chloe’, and wives found themselves subjected to the flattering attentions of predatory Town rakes. Neither class of temptation had been prevalent in the shires. That marriage in its country conception had a hard time bearing up under this new liberty is the explicit theme not only of The Wives’ Excuse but of Southerne’s darker The Maid’s Last Prayer, Cibber’s Love’s Last Shift, Vanbrugh’s The Relapse, and Farquhar’s The Beaux’ Stratagem and The Recruiting Officer. The governing assumption of the Town, as presented in these plays, is that regulated adultery was a satisfactory substitute for an unsatisfactory marriage (the lampoon being one of the modes of regulation), but some playwrights go further to suggest that an institution which in its country sense was essentially a contract between families needed to be revised to take account of individual needs for love and fidelity.16 Congreve’s three mature comedies experiment warily with this possibility, but only Love for Love could be said to embrace it unreservedly. Here a male dupe of Town consumerism, having exhausted his money, finds he is still 15 For this aspect of the plays see my ‘Restoration and Early 18th-Century Drama’, in The Cambridge History of English Literature 1660–1780 (forthcoming). D’Urfey’s The Fool Turn’d Critic (1676) and Squire Oldsapp (1678) present a broader, farcial version of the theme of the Town tyro. 16 Historically these represent a development, charted by Laurence Stone in The Family, Sex and Marriage in England 1500–1800 (London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1977), towards a new ‘companionate’ ideal of marriage.
The Town Lampoon
73
valued as a marriage partner because he is constitutionally generous. The other side of the coin is shown by the two marriages in The Way of the World, in one of which the partners agree to be ‘as well bred as if we were not marri’d at all’ while the other gives rise to the plaintive complaint ‘Why did you make me marry this Man?’ and the Machiavellian Town reply ‘To save that Idol Reputation. If the familiarities of our Loves had produc’d that Consequence, of which you were apprehensive, where could you have fix’d a Father’s Name with Credit, but on a Husband?’17 The daily round of pleasures depicted in the comedies is also the topic of ‘The Town Life’, cited in Chapter 2. The male speaker has grown jaded with the ‘jilting town’, finding its beauties ‘artificial’ and its pleasures ‘but a short and giddy round’, and has retired to, of all places, the country.18 Nonetheless, he continues to relive its activities vividly in remembrance. Town ‘sparks’ begin their day by getting dressed ‘with much ado’ by noon. They then walk in the Mall in the hope of snaring some ‘flutt’ring, gaudy butterfly’. Next comes dinner at Locket’s ordinary, where they take their fill of gossip, and then the theatre, where neither the faces nor the performance—‘a tragic farce of Banks’—yield much enjoyment. Now comes a coach journey to Hyde Park, where the occupants take part in a ritual known as ‘side-glassing’ in which an exchange of ogles from vehicle to vehicle may provoke a pursuit of one by another. Another satirist gives us a gloss: In vain the Coachman turns about, And whips the dappl’d Greys; When the old Ogler looks out, We turn away our Face19
Since it is too early to drop in at court, the next activity is to ‘visit where the beaux in order come’. 17 iv. i. 209 and ii. i. 263–9, in The Complete Plays of William Congreve, ed. Herbert Davis (Chicago: Chicago UP, 1967), 450, 417. 18 Text in POASY, iv. 61–7. 19 ‘Advice to the Old Beaux’, The Poetical and Dramatic Works of Sir Charles Sedley, ed. V. de Sola Pinto (London: Constable, 1928), i. 35. Cf. also the speech of Laura in Crowne’s The English Frier (London, 1690), iii. ii. 32–7: ‘When I go to Hide Park, my motions seem to turn the world, for as I turn, all the coaches i’ the Circle turn to meet mine, the ladies to see my dresses, the men to see me. There do I ride i’ my shining chariot, like the moon on a bright cloud, while all the little beautys move round beneath me, like fairys’ (Comedies, 536).
74
The Town Lampoon Flatt’ring the present, the absent they abuse And vent their spleen and lies, pretending news; Why such a lady’s pale and would not dance, This to the country gone, and that to France, Who’s marri’d, shipp’d away, or miss’d at court; Others’ misfortunes thus afford them sport. A new song is produc’d, the author guess’d, The verses and the poet made a jest . . .
After a while the company turn to cards, upon which the ‘spark’, who has by now become an ‘I’, not wishing to ‘civilly sit still and see | The ladies pick my purse and laugh at me’, finally leaves for court, though this too is to prove a wasted journey as there is no company in the reformed drawing room of James II except ‘Mac’s and O’s’ in whose presence it is dangerous to speak. The poem concludes with a review of the various destinations of the night. His is his ‘peaceful home’; some ‘May have, but oft pretend, a close intrigue’; others head for the tavern, while the rest ‘Must see an easy mistress ere they sleep’. Although the poet sneers at this lifestyle, his progressive movement from the third to the first person shows he is still in thrall to it. In his withdrawal to the country he is not only identifying himself as part of an emigration of influential Protestant gentry and aristocracy that was to prove politically fatal to the king, but temporarily reversing the migration that had created the Town in the first place. Returned to the active leadership of their local communities, these families were soon involved in anti-centrist conspiracy. The lampooners also share comedy’s concern with the problematical state of marriage. Country notions of honour and ‘that Idol Reputation’ still needed to be sustained at least as a façade. Otherwise this new kind of urban society based on leisure, pleasure, and conspicuous consumption would inevitably succumb to its own excesses. Whether the perspective from which this critique was made was the libertine ethic of following nature, espoused in Rochester’s ‘Against Reason and Mankind’, or a more traditional moral rigourism, inherently suspicious of the body, its immediate function was that of pillorying those of either sex in the Town who were insufficiently attentive to the health of their reputations not to transgress discreetly. It is true that such attacks also served the contrary function of advertising the prevalence of the behaviour they castigated, but this was no surprise to a generation whose notion of social order was deeply influenced by Hobbes. The problem articulated
The Town Lampoon
75
by Hobbes and re-explored by Mandeville of how to construct a working society out of the materials of a human nature energized by desire for pleasure and power required the striking of a delicate balance between acceptance and inhibition that was best pursued through the vivid depiction of negative examples. There being no easy way of explaining what was right with the Town—an entity still imperfectly understood by those who composed it—there must be no mistake about what might go wrong. This was particularly so for the reason that the pursuit of pleasure easily became a distraction from the pursuit of power and necessary corrective reactions to that pursuit by its potential victims. Historical retrospect suggests that the circle of Town pleasures had until the date of the reverse migration described in ‘The Town Life’ exercised a politically anaesthetizing effect, and that Charles II may have been wiser than he is given credit for in encouraging members of the ruling class to come to Town, with one sex devoting its time to the pursuit of wine and drabs and the other to ratafia and sparks. With these demographical points in mind, we are able to refine our distinction between court satires and Town satires. The central discriminant is that a Town satire is concerned with a new kind of identity and new patterns of behaviour which are associated with the life of urban pleasure as it was lived in the newly settled squares of the West End and with the hedonistic social round of the parks, the Mall, the coffee and chocolate houses, the ordinaries, visits, bookshops, and theatregoing. A further mark of a Town satire is a way of regarding the court as just another of the sideshows of the Town to be included in the regular round of its sights and pleasures but not conceded any overriding authority in questions of style, manners, or wit. To become besotted with the court was a kind of treason to the Town. Melantha in Dryden’s Marriage A-la-mode is characterized in i. i. 182 as ‘a Town-Lady, without any relation to the Court’ who nonetheless insists on being ‘seen there three or four times a day’. Her ideal life is described in ii. i. 73–5: ‘you shall be every day at the King’s Levé, and I at the Queen’s; and we will never meet, but in the Drawing-room’.20 At iii. i. 107 she asserts that ‘nothing can be so ridicule, as a meer Town-Lady’, without realizing that she is one herself. Doralice and Artemis, two of the princess’s maids of honour, gently convey this to her by ridiculing the behaviour of Town ladies 20
Works, xi. 244.
76
The Town Lampoon
who ‘crowd and sweat in the Drawing-room’ so that they can ‘write Letters into the Countrey’ about what they see. The passage cuts both ways: the courtier would presumably read it as an affirmation of the exclusivity and cultural pre-eminence of the court while the Town viewer or reader would draw the very different message that the court was never to be taken at its own exaggerated valuation. Melantha’s fault in this larger view would be to have neglected the greater good of belonging to the Town for the lesser one of nourishing an obsession with the court. Harcourt’s ridiculing of Sparkish in The Country Wife for his ‘attendance at the King’s Meals’ asserts a robust Town perspective on the court, while Sparkish’s reply that he goes to court merely to pursue his ‘interest’ concedes the point without argument.21 As the Town gathered confidence in its own centrality to the life of the nation the court slowly dwindled to a marginal club for ‘Mac’s and O’s’ and after them for Dutchmen. This point is further made in a body of Town lampoons whose aim is simply to denigrate the court as an institution. How this might be done had been shown by the court lampooners themselves in satires intended for internal court consumption which were very differently read when they circulated outside the court.‘Rochester’s Farewell’ opens with a Jeremiad against the court on the grounds of its vice and hypocrisy: Tir’d with the noisome follies of the age, And weary of my part, I quit the stage; For who in life’s dull farce a part would bear Where rogues, whores, bawds all the chief actors are? Long I with charitable malice strove, Lashing the Court these vermin to remove; But thriving vice under the rod still grew, As aged lechers, whipp’d, their lust renew. Yet though my life has unsuccessful been (For who can this Augean stable clean?) My gen’rous end I’ll still pursue in death, And at mankind rail with my parting breath.22
Nothing in this satire quite lives up to its induction; but to classify it as a court lampoon would be misleading. Although its author clearly possessed an insider’s knowledge of the court, the assault is directed from the hostile perspective of the Town. 21 iii. ii. 133–6, in The Plays of William Wycherley, ed. Arthur Friedman (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979), 291. 22 POASY, ii. 218–19.
The Town Lampoon
77
A widely copied satire of 1681, ‘The Quarrel between Frank and Nan’ (‘Nan and Frank two quondam friends’) is useful evidence for the dismissive, even patronizing, way in which the court might be viewed from a Town perspective.23 The subject was an altercation which had taken place between a court functionary, Francis, Lord Newport, and a well-known Town identity, Nan Capell, who as well as holding the concession for the sale of oranges in the theatres was also a bawd. She was the original of the Orange Nan who makes an appearance in Act I of The Man of Mode. What actually happened on this occasion is undiscoverable. Possibly Nan had asked the notoriously mean Newport for what was owed to whores provided for him by her and been peremptorily reminded that the court was a sanctuary zone in which dunning was not permitted. Whatever the case, words were exchanged and Newport is reported as having broken his white staff of office over Nan and then used his authority to have her committed to the Gatehouse and whipped. Newport, as first Comptroller and then Treasurer of the Household, was a figure of fun even at court, as in ‘An Heroic Poem’, ll. 65–6: At thee, old Newport, who can choose but laugh. With thy white wig, white gloves, and thy white staff?24
He was also a Whig which made him doubly unpopular in an increasingly Tory court.25 In the poem the quarrel becomes a Hudibrastic narrative in which Newport at first welcomes Nan, thinking she is going to provide him with a whore, and then reacts adversely when she professes her own desire for him. Nan is presented in fine mock-heroic style: Majestic wrinkles deck her brow, And goodly glaring eyes below, That still with maudlin kindness shine, The soft effects of brandywine. Rich carbuncles adorn her nose, The envy of her sober foes; And from her lips discourses fall That make her welcome at Whitehall.26 24 Text ibid. 235–41. CSR, 70. The style of the piece is suggestive of Etherege’s later verse letters to Middleton, though Dryden in his reply written on Middleton’s behalf showed that he was capable of the same manner. 26 POASY, ii. 239. 23 25
78
The Town Lampoon
However, Newport’s hostile reaction provokes her to an act of what can only be described as lingual rape: Quoth Frank in rage, ‘Avaunt, you bitch! Have I for this through all my life Kept civil distance with my wife? Studi’d fine speeches from romances, And in my age led country dances? Do I for this e’en at this hour Cheat ev’ry creature in my pow’r; Gripe the poor the utmost farthing To keep my credit up at carding? Do I for this affect a grace And paint my old John-apple-face, Only to have a bawd adore me? No I’ll have virgins fall before me.’ ‘Virgins!’ quoth Nan, and then she hung A tongue out full two handfuls long, And with desire or malice stung, Lick’d o’er the thickest painted place, And spoil’d entirely that day’s face.27
‘Virgins’ should clearly be uttered with the same cantar di sbalzo employed by Lady Bracknells of all stages in intoning ‘A handbag?’ This is comic verse of high competence, which while statedly written in tribute to the recently deceased Samuel Butler, is as self-consciously ‘polite’ as Hudibras is abrasively Rabelaisian. Rather than being a send-up of a single, unpopular court figure for a readership of courtiers, this is a polished piece of Covent Garden verse written for a coffee house readership in which it is the court itself that is ridiculed through the gross affront offered by the Town intruder. Other lampoons only treat the court briefly and dismissively before moving on to more interesting topics. ‘A Ballad to the Tune of Cheviot Chace’ (‘Come all ye youths that yet are free’, 1682) issues warnings to those contemplating marriage about a string of potential ‘London wives’, the first part covering single women and the second part widows. The court is brought in stanza 6 of the first part: Hyde’s not yet tapped, but bred at Court, And all within those doors, Where none but knaves and bawds resort, Or are, or will be, whores.28 27
POASY, 240.
28
Wilson, CSR, 103.
The Town Lampoon
79
After a couple more court examples, the satirist returns to the wider sphere of the Town. Or consider ‘Quem Natura Negat’ (‘I who from drinking ne’er could spare an hour’): But must I find Patch’d up at every Wall Stuff none can bear, who starves not at Whitehall?29
The manner of these pieces is often closely modelled on that of the court lampoons, and leading courtiers take their place among the victims, but their concern is with the beau monde in general, not the court in particular.
sat y rs o n t h e p o e t s The influence of the court was also contested in a tradition of lampoons reviewing the agents through whom the Town digested and communicated its identity: theatre personnel, professional authors, and the transmitters and (generally) amateur writers of lampoons themselves. Theatre performers are attacked in the scabrous ‘Satyr on the Players’ (‘The censuring world perhaps may not esteem’) and Robert Gould’s ‘The Play-House’.30 ‘Of Three Late Marriages’ (‘Three nymphs as chaste as ever Venus bred’), which Wilson dates to the summer of 1682, includes violent abuse of the performers Elizabeth Barry and Charlotte Butler; Barry is also assailed in the vilest terms in ‘Satire on Benting’ (‘Long had my pen lain dull and useless by’, 1688/9).31 Satires on writers belong to a tradition established long before the civil wars and which rapidly reasserted itself after. They may be read productively as tracing a struggle on the part of the Town professionals to escape the dominance of court amateurs, a number of whom were also patrons. This history ran parallel to that already considered of the Town’s search for alternatives to court models of sociability. In the early Restoration years court patronage was the logical avenue to preferment. The elderly Duke of Newcastle, a patron in the last reign of Jonson, Shirley, and D’Avenant, reinstated himself at the Restoration as a kind of unofficial minister for culture, assisting the careers of BL MS Harl. 7319, fo. 114v. ‘ The Play-House. A Satyr’ in Poems Chiefly Consisting of Satyrs and Satyrical Epistles (London, 1689), 161–95. 31 CSR, 76–80, 217–25. 29 30
80
The Town Lampoon
Shadwell, Flecknoe, and for a time Dryden. Dryden’s MacFlecknoe has the duke’s circle as one of its covert targets.32 The duke and his these days much better known duchess were both themselves voluminous writers. Newcastle, however, was an old man and his mantle was soon allowed to pass to the partnership of his former pupil, Buckingham, and Buckhurst, later sixth Earl of Dorset. With this inheritance went a connection with the ‘Tribe of Ben’, of which Newcastle had been a member and which Dorset was to emulate in meetings at the Poets’ Parlour at Knole. The perpetuation of Jonsonian principles was part of the artistic programme of the group, which encouraged Shadwell’s attempt to revive a form of Jonsonian comedy and in 1669 supported a revival of Jonson’s rarely performed Catiline. Buckingham was a friend of writers, including Cowley, Sprat, Martin Clifford, Samuel Butler, and Waller, and, from his own court faction, Rochester, Sedley, and Dorset; but was less reliable in his bounty and assiduousness than Dorset, who deserved the compliment often bestowed on him as the Maecenas of the age.33 Rochester’s glamour and brilliance as a poet led many writers to seek him as a patron but he was never rich enough to support them properly and proved even more capricious in his favours than Buckingham. The progress of the campaign to impose court discipline on the unruly tribe of professionals can be demonstrated from satires of 1668 and 1676 which use the ‘Sessions of Poets’ format borrowed from Suckling’s Caroline satire. The earlier of the two (‘Apollo, concerned to see the transgressions’)34 adopts a genially erudite tone that suggests a poet of an older generation, albeit one with much inside knowledge of the playhouses. The declared occasion of the sessions is to punish ‘the abuses of wit’. Virtually all active poets of the time are included in the roll-call, with no particular deference exhibited towards the courtiers. In the outcome the laurel is given to two actors, Lacy and Harris, on the grounds that ‘they alone made the plays go off ’.35 By contrast, the 1676 poem (‘Since the sons of the muses grew numerous and loud’) has a clear court perspective and distinguishes sharply between the gentlemen poets, Etherege and 32 For this connection see my ‘Shadwell, Flecknoe and the Duke of Newcastle: An Impetus to MacFlecknoe’, Papers on Language and Literature, 21 (1985), 19–27. 33 Brice Harris, Charles Sackville, Sixth Earl of Dorset, Patron and Poet of the Restoration (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1940), esp. 173–214. 34 POASY, i. 327–37. 35 Both actors had some standing as writers, with Lacy associated with the widely circulated lampoon ‘Preserved by wonder in the oak O Charles’ (ibid. 425–8).
The Town Lampoon
81
Wycherley, and the mere traders, the intervening years having seen a consolidation of the latter category, and the withdrawal from the craft of the older amateurs of the Cavalier generation.36 In this case the imaginary meeting has been called to establish a ‘government, leader and laws’ of the writing community. Dryden is treated with consideration but hardly respect: in any case it is assumed, incorrectly, that he was on the verge of abandoning the Town for the Church. Shadwell is represented as a buffoon and Lee as a drunk. Settle is dismissed as a ‘great boy’. Otway is abused as the ‘scum of a playhouse’. Crowne is branded with dullness. Behn is chided for being too old to secure conquests with her ‘black ace’. Once more, an actor, this time Betterton, is declared the winner, the ground being that ‘he had writ plays, yet ne’er came in print’. This last detail reflects the court wits’ preference for the more prestigious scribal circulation. In allusion to a recent print controversy, Settle brings with him ‘an Ibrahim with the preface torn out’, while Crowne is arraigned ‘for writing romances and shiting of plays’. Betterton does indeed rule the stage but authority over the realm of letters is clearly left with the court. A later poem linked to the ‘Sessions’ tradition, ‘Advice to Apollo’ (‘I’ve heard the muses were still soft and kind’, 1677), frames itself as a defence of true poetry against the rising vogue of lampoon satire.37 Dryden is once again treated with some measure of consideration, Dorset and Rochester are praised, and Rochester’s enemies Scroope and Mulgrave are severely criticized. The poem concludes with a curt dismissal of ‘saucy Sheppard, with the affected train | Who satires write, yet scarce can spell their name’. This satire seems to come from an admirer of the Whig court wits rather than from within the group itself, of which Sheppard was a core member. No professionals apart from Dryden are mentioned. The attempt to assert court hegemony through satire as well as patronage had begun circa 1670 with a series of mock-commendatory verses directed at Edward Howard’s narrative poem The British Prince and his comedy The New Utopia.38 One of these poems, Dorset’s ‘Come on ye critics! Find one fault who dare’, survives in numerous manuscript and printed sources. Howard stood in this instance as a surrogate not for the professional poets (he was the fifth son of the Earl of Berkshire) but for the older group of Cavalier 37 Text ibid. 352–6. Ibid. 392–5. Complete series in Bodleian MS Eng. poet. e 4, pp. 188–99; see also POASY, i. 338–41. 36 38
82
The Town Lampoon
poets, who were assailed as part of the generational antagonism described in Chapter 2. At a later date, relations between the Buckingham circle and the Howard family, most of whom were Catholics, were further worsened by religious difference; however, Edward Howard and his brother Sir Robert were Protestants, and Sir Robert became a close political ally of Buckingham. Dryden was married to their sister. In Rochester’s ‘An Allusion to Horace’ (1675) the main weight of the attack falls on Dryden but lesser lashings are meted out to Lee and Otway, while Shadwell and the court poets of the Buckingham faction are solemnly commended. Dryden replied on behalf of the professionals in the preface to All for Love (1678). The contestation of court and Town within the sphere of letters reveals itself with particular clarity through the career of Dryden. In the 1660s he was an assiduous seeker after court preferment, obtaining a marginal household position when in 1668 he succeeded D’Avenant as poet laureate. During these years he actively supported the view of the court as the fountainhead of national values, whether expressed as gallantry in war by the Duke of York or elegance in impromptu conversation by Dorset and Rochester. In the dedication to Marriage Ala-mode, he addresses Rochester in very different terms from those used in the preface to All for Love: ‘Wit seems to have lodg’d it self more Nobly in this Age, than in any of the former: and people of my mean condition, are onely Writers, because some of the nobility, and your Lordship in the first place, are above the narrow praises which Poesie could give you.’39 Responding to Rochester’s letter of thanks for the dedication he added: ‘I find it is not for me to contend any way with your Lordship, who can write better on the meanest Subject than I can on the best.’40 In Dorset’s case, he was prepared to supplement praise with the more practical help of pimping.41 But there was always a tension in these relationships, arising on Dryden’s side from his consciousness of superior talent and the attendant realization that it was only regular professional work, not aristocratic amateurism, that would permit talent to be honed and extended. His real opinion is hinted at in a note to his translation of the first satire of Persius (1693) in which he refers to ‘the Noblemen and their abominable Poetry, Works, xi. 223. The Letters of John Wilmot, Earl of Rochester, ed. Jeremy Treglown (Oxford: Blackwell, 1980), 87. 41 See The Letters of John Dryden: with Letters Addressed to him, ed. Charles E. Ward (Durham, NC: Duke UP, 1942), 13. 39 40
The Town Lampoon
83
who in the Luxury of their Fortune, set up for Wits, and Judges’.42 On the courtiers’ side we find contempt for the ‘saturnine’ Dryden’s backwardness in their own highly prized art of witty, impromptu conversation, which for them was also a standard for measuring the excellence of writing.43 Already in Of Dramatick Poesie (1668) Dryden had boldly placed himself in dialogue with Dorset and Sedley over fundamental questions of literary value. There was also the question of political allegiance, with Dryden aligned with the Yorkist faction at court and most of the poetical court wits following Buckingham. Satire, including Buckingham’s The Rehearsal (1672) and Rochester’s ‘An Allusion to Horace’, were one means used to keep the laureate in his place. In print, the debate was carried on in a series of prefaces by Shadwell, which were replied to in kind by Dryden. This particular contest climaxed in the sublime character assassination of MacFlecknoe, written as a challenge to the hegemony of the wits of the Buckingham faction, who had supported Shadwell throughout his career, but also a pointed demonstration that Dryden could write clandestine satire even more brilliantly than they did. By this time Dryden had entered into league with John Sheffield, Earl of Mulgrave in the writing of at least one additional lampoon, the notorious ‘An Essay upon Satyr’, and in the recruitment of a group of mostly professional Tory and Yorkist poets to oppose the Whigs of the Buckingham faction. The ‘Essay’, while concentrating its fire on the Whig wits, did not spare ‘saunt’ring Charles, between his beastly brace’ of Portsmouth and Nelly.44 Representing itself as a critique of lampoon culture, which it dismisses as ‘the loose-writ libels of the age’ (l. 37), it is actually a continuation, masking its actual court factionalism behind a veneer of Town disinterestedness. In acknowledging the failure of a series of ‘loyal libels’ (l. 68) to inform Charles of the true state of affairs at court, it also tacitly concedes that effective court satire could only be written from the external perspective of the Town, and with the assistance of a Town professional. The subsequent history of this conflict between Yorkist and Whig poetical factions belongs to the history of state rather than Town satire and will be dealt with under that heading: its significance for the present Works, iv. 257. On this issue see my ‘Shadwell, Rochester and the Crisis of Amateurism’, in Judith Slagle (ed.), Thomas Shadwell Reconsider’d, published as Restoration, 20 (1996), 119–34. 44 POASY, i. 396–413 (l. 65). 42 43
84
The Town Lampoon
discussion is that it marks one in a series of stages in which authority over polite letters moved from the Great Withdrawing Room at Whitehall to the professionals’ meeting place in the upper room of Will’s coffee house in Covent Garden in the heart of the Town. This change also brought a supplementation of the older style of ‘plain natural chit-chat’ to include a proto-Augustan neoclassicism of the kind illustrated in Chapter 2.45 Classicizing lampoons begin to appear from the late 1670s onward, competing for space in the scribal anthologies with the more colloquial kind of couplet and stanzaic lampoons. Scroope’s ‘In Defence of Satyr’ (‘When Shakespeare, Jonson, Fletcher ruled the stage’, 1677), ‘Rochester’s Farewell’ (1680), ‘Barabara Piramidum Sileat Miracula Memphis’ (‘Of all the wonders since the world began’; 1680?), and ‘An Heroic Poem’ (1681) are all distinguished by learned allusions, antithetical wit of the Popean kind, and self-conscious use of rhetorical figures.46 The second of these learnedly compares Mulgrave’s being awarded the Garter with the contention between Ajax and Odysseus for the shield of Achilles: Ulisses with stout Ajax did contend And by his crafty cunning gain’d his end Yet ’twas thought strange that in the bloody Field He shou’d obtain the fam’d Achilles shield But here’s the prize of honour stole away By one who yet ne’re saw a scarlett day But represented in some Tragick Play.47
The readership that would be swayed by the aptness of this allusion was that of the literary coffee house not the presence chamber. The authority claimed by these neoclassical lampoons rests on an urban naturalization of erudite culture, begun in France, whose arrival in England was revealed by a spate of translations and imitations of Boileau.48 Although Rochester was responsible for some influential experiments with the classicizing style, it had little vogue at court, nor did the new Town preoccupation with smooth numbers hold 45 Lamb’s description in ‘The Genteel Style in Writing’ of Temple’s prose (Last Essays of Elia, in The Works of Charles Lamb, ed. Thomas Hutchinson (Oxford: Oxford UP, 1940), 719). 46 Among the allusions, Scroope’s first line is adapted from the third of Suckling’s prologue to The Goblins. 47 BL MS Harl. 6913, fo. 20r. 48 By Rochester, Oldham, and Crowne among others.
The Town Lampoon
85
much attraction for him.49 For the professionals, on the other hand, the couplet lampoon offered a natural avenue for applying the lessons learned from their other classicizing experiments, the Town prologue and epilogue and the heroic play. Dryden’s growing concern with translations from Latin and Greek and his enrolment of younger writers in these projects actively furthered this stylistic tendency. The new Horatian elegance he had given to the art of the prologue was soon extended to the lampoon. Prologues and epilogues, regularly delivered at the Town’s key point of assembly and usually heard with attention, even if the intervening play was not, were the professionals’ main means of reply to their court censurers. Courtiers might also write such pieces but had in such cases to accommodate themselves to the expectations of the Town. Only in the very specialized body of ‘stage orations’ written for the court’s own theatre in Cardinal Wolsey’s old hall at the palace or for royal appearances in state in the commercial theatres could they freely assert court values. Vital texts for any study of the evolution of a distinctive Town identity, stage orations also contain some of the finest satire of the time; however, they are not included among the subjects of this book because they were the reverse of clandestine, being publicly performed and nearly always printed. While often taken up with presenting the Town with unflattering images of its bad behaviour, they also contain many pleas for the rights of dramatists to be assessed fairly and respectfully by the Town audience as a whole, rather than being judged by the prejudiced representatives of the court. An epilogue of 1673 sets its scene in a coffee house: Lord how they wait a Wit that’s fam’d in Town! He lookes about him with a scornful frown, Then picks his Favourite out and sits him down. Take me how is’t? Have you seen our new Play? Yes faith; and how? a half Crown thrown away, Pox on’t he cries, I Droll’d and Slept it out; ’Twas some Raw Fop: Then proudly stares about; Then shrugs and whispers, laughs, then swears aloud. The whilst there’s silence kept by all the Croud. At length he nods and cocks, is heard to say, D—— me ’tis true, and thus he damns the Play, Rises, lookes big and combs, then goes his Way. 49 See in this connection Dryden’s damning critique of the ‘Allusion to Horace’ in the preface to All for Love.
86
The Town Lampoon
Date and context both suggest that this is a courtier throwing around his literary weight rather than an overweening professional (who would not have had to pay for his ticket). The exhortation to the Town audience is prefaced by the assurance ‘Come, we’re amongst our selves’. Its message is one of revolt: the audience is told that By such like Arts they rule the stage and you, And what was Favour first, now claim as due.
In a re-enactment of the Restoration the Town should free itself ‘from these usurpers Tyranny’.50 The evident uncertainty of the Town audience over its capacity to judge plays, and deference to those who appeared to know, is reflected in a parallel deference which allowed poets to be censurers of personal behaviour through the medium of the lampoon. The only difficulty concerned which group of poets were to undertake this responsibility. In the end both the professionals and the courtiers were displaced by a body of self-elected poetical vigilantes who will be introduced in a subsequent chapter. The qualifications for entering this group were amateur status, some degree of recognition as a writer, and profound knowledge of the Town and its secrets, with the last the most important. It was also necessary that the lampooner knew how to get his or her work into circulation through networks that were increasingly dominated by commercial copyists. This will also be considered.
t h e s o c i a l a i m s o f T ow n l a m p o o n i n g While important for matters of definition, Town lampoons concerned with denigrating the court or standing up for professionals against court amateurs are not the most characteristic of the genre as a whole. The Town lampooners’ main concern was with the Town’s own and, like the court satirists, they quickly built up a gallery of iconic targets and an armoury of stock accusations. But the field available to them was a much larger and continually growing one, with the consequence that the Town lampoon is often much longer than its 50 Joseph Arrowsmith, The Reformation (London, 1673), 80. See also Pierre Danchin (ed.), The Prologues and Epilogues of the Restoration 1660–1700, 7 vols. (Nancy: Presses Universitaires de Nancy, 1981–8), i/2. 535–7.
The Town Lampoon
87
court counterpart. The stanzaic lampoon written to a familiar ballad tune was particularly well adapted to rattling through a long list of targets, linked only by their common membership of the Town. Take for example ‘The Lovers’ Session’ (‘A session of lovers was held t’other day’), dated by Wilson to June 1687, and therefore close to the high tide of the Town lampoon.51 Following the by now familiar conventions of sessions satire, it introduces a series of pretenders to a prize, to be awarded in this case by Venus to the one ‘who did least deserve’. Anticipating Dunciad IV, it brings in its pretenders first in tribes (‘fools of the flute and fools of the pen’, ‘sour fanatics’, ‘Cits apeing Court fops’, and so on), then as groups of named victims four or more to a stanza, and finally as individuals deserving a more extended treatment, the first part of which, in each case, is their personal plea, and the second the judgement of Venus. Eighty-three four-line stanzas (probably meant to be sung two at a time to ‘Packington’s Pound’) are expended before the prize, in the person of ‘young Luck’ is awarded to a rich old lawyer. The judicial framing is mirrored in the social authority claimed for the satirist’s carefully articulated verdicts. This is no irresponsible railer but an aroused social critic who assumes that right-thinking members of the Town will concur with his evaluations. Its success led irresistibly to the writing of a parallel satire on the women, ‘The Session of Ladies’ (‘A session of ladies was held on the stage’), dated by Wilson to April 1688.52 This presents a group of Town ladies competing for the actor Carlell Goodman, who is the prize in a competition awarded this time by Cupid. As before, the early stanzas introduce groups of women, first generally There were monkeys in top-knots and owls in settee, High jilts in sultana and bulkers in crepe, Who flocked from each quarter Adonis to see, Admiring his beauty, his person and shape. (ll. 25–8)
and then more particularly There was pockey lewd Hinton and Howard’s pert Mall, With Grafton’s chaste widow of Worcester Park, Fantastical Brandon and her sister Doll, Who had many a bout with his grace in the dark. (ll. 29–32)
Each of these brief accusations rests on an item of gossip decipherable from other lampoons. As the poem proceeds its subjects acquire 51
Text and annotations in CSR, 175–98.
52
CSR, 204–16.
88
The Town Lampoon
whole stanzas to themselves in which they make their claim for the prize and are answered antiphonally by Cupid. Chaste Norfolk the first was that put in her claim, A privilege due to her person and place. The court had respect to her title and name, And was at the point to comply with her grace. But Cupid, recalling the German to mind, Said ’twas pity Adonis should e’er be her prize, Whose lust the Town stallions, though never so kind, And all the whole family could not suffice. (ll. 53–60)
The casual reference to ‘the German’ (the duchess’s lover, and later, after one of the rare divorces of the period, her husband, John Germaine) and the veiled reference of the last line indicate that this is a poem for readers and hearers who were already familiar with current gossip. The tone of the piece is more lubricious and its language more obscene than its predecessor. The sense of considered reproofs delivered to deserving targets is replaced by one of gratuitious libertine malice. Where the men have been abused as fools and cullies the women are without exception arraigned as whores. It would be nice to be able to excuse this as the effect of a subtle shift in genre, but the real reason is the engrained misogyny of the Town lampoon. Where the poem directed at the males points through its bad examples at a reform of manners, that against the females presupposes an endemic and therefore unreformable devotion of the whole sex to lust. Such incessant character assassinations of the ruling elite have generally been received with either embarrassment or distaste: the dispassionate attention given by Wilson and the Yale POAS editors has had no sequel prior to the present study. Literary qualities, which might have been respected if they had been exercised in texts defending the powerless against the strong, become devalued when it is a question of members of the leisured classes bickering with each other or blatant vilification of the defenceless. Town satire was often factional in the same way that court satire was, and, as the century progressed, increasingly politicized; yet court factions were at least concerned with issues of real significance for the nation. This can hardly be claimed for poems attacking actresses, self-opiniated poets, syphilitic rakes, cuckold husbands, or barely distinguishable Town beauties, even if we were to assume, uncharitably, that many victims were only marginally better than they were painted. Since it
The Town Lampoon
89
is undeniable that much of this material is the undissimulated product of spite, lubricity, misogyny, and other unadmirable aspects of human nature, it is a genuine issue why it should be looked at in any other light than the pathological. This point of view was frequently expressed in the satirists’ own time, as in ‘The Visitt’: The Ta[vern] was the next reso[r]t, where I Quite weary of there Tipling company went home a Cursing of this wretched age That Couples each old Lady with her Page And whores the Chastest virgin with her dog And Calls the best of Kings a senceless Log.53
The author of ‘Quem Natura Negat’ (‘I who from drinking ne’er could spare an hour’) regards men as fair game but bridles at the incessant attacks on women: Just now, methinks, I hear some Critick Wit, Censure aloud, all I’ve already writ: Dam me says he what does this Blockhead mean? The Women’s faults become a Satyr’s Pen. But I, who all the charming Sex adore, And daily their Compassion must implore, For Panegerick keep their sacred Names. Libel attend all those who wrong their Fames.54
Nobody, as we will see again in Chapter 5, has a good word for lampooners. The most common defence against these charges was the corrective one. The lampooners themselves frequently make the familiar neoclassical point that these poems, malicious and unfair as they frequently were, provided an effective kind of social regulation in a society in which, for what seemed good reasons at the time, older forms of regulation had become ineffective. Consider the following from ‘Ignis Ignibus Extinguitur’ (‘But why this fury all that e’er was writ’): These from the many, and the chosen few My Indignation has expos’d to view, As Beacons to the rest, who now I’ll spare, In hopes they’l mend by what I’ve Blazon’d here For oft I’ve seen (not quell’d by other force) Houses blown up have stopt a Fire’s Course.55 53 54
Lincolnshire Archives Office MS ANC 15/ B/4, p. 20. 55 BL MS Harl. 7319, fo. 119r. Ibid., fo. 114v.
90
The Town Lampoon
In this view, which invokes attempts to halt the Great Fire of 1666, the lampoon was a means by which the Town dealt with nuisancemakers. Another lampooner uses the country metaphor of hanging up the bodies of predators: Mark a bold leading Coxcomb of the Town, And single out the Beast and hunt him down; Hang up his mangl’d Carcass on the Stage, To fright away the Vermin of the Age.56
A moderate ‘neoclassical’ version of the same case was argued by Carr Scroope in ‘In Defence of Satyr’: And (without doubt) though some it may offend, Nothing helps more than Satyr, to amend Ill Manners, or is trulier Virtues Friend. Princes, may Laws ordain, Priests gravely Preach, But Poets, most successfully will teach.57
and by Rochester in his conversations with Burnet: He would often go into the Country, and be for some months wholly employed in Study, or the Sallies of his Wit: Which he came to direct chiefly to Satyre. And this he often defended to me, by saying there were some people that could not be kept in Order, or admonished but in this way.58
To Burnet’s advocacy of a ‘grave way of Satyre’ that spared personalities and did not make untrue accusations, Rochester replied that ‘A man could not write with life, unless he were heated by Revenge’ and that to do otherwise would be ‘as if a man would in cold blood, cut mens throats who had never offended him’ (p. 26), thus defending not only the lampoon but its undisguised personal malice towards its victims as a case of private vices producing public benefits. So far this is no more than a commonplace: satire makes vice ridiculous and ugly and therefore those who would otherwise have become vicious are deterred. No one would doubt that this occasionally happened, even with lampoons. But when this question is rephrased in terms of the particular needs and interests of the Town it becomes a much more interesting one. Here satire becomes part of ‘Prologue’ [by Edmund Ashton], POAS (1702–7), i. 2215. Rochester, Works, 103. 58 Gilbert Burnet, Some Passages of the Life and Death of John, Earl of Rochester, in V. de Sola Pinto (ed.), English Biography in the Seventeenth Century (London: Harrap, 1951), 105–6. 56 57
The Town Lampoon
91
the creation of a new kind of urban civility in which the companionship of the visit would replace the stilted deference of the levee, and in which the polished cit would sit down at the same coffee house table as the intelligent squire and the complaisant lord—a civility which was to find its realization in the social world of the Scriblerians and in Augustan epistolary culture as it has been charted by William C. Dowling.59 An attack on the misdoings of those in high places was also one on the way in which the assertion of rank distorted sociability. Dignity was ruthlessly stripped from those who claimed high birth as a means of enforcing deference, something especially evident in the lampooners’ depictions of John Sheffield, Earl of Mulgrave.60 From this perspective, the lampoon can be seen as a necessary instrument for the regulation of the Town as a functioning society organized around the sociable pursuit of pleasure. Once it became a settled society with thoroughly internalized rules and conventions such means would no longer be necessary, but during the stage of construction a kind of rough, vigilante justice was in order. Satire of this kind arises not from the invocation of a more admirable past, like that of Juvenal’s unkempt Roman wife and acorn-belching husband, but from an engagement with a world whose values were still contested and provisional and which required simple rules of thumb while it worked out better ones. The ‘soft Hobbesian’ vision of the human being as a pleasure-seeking animal is accepted by the lampooners even in their castigations of the results of taking that pursuit to an extreme. When individuals are presented as monsters of greed and lust it is not in order to reject the pleasure principle but from impatience (mixed at times with an imperfectly concealed envy) at those who were unable to enjoy their pleasures temperately. The Town lampoon’s visions of ‘normality’ are themselves hedonistic. ‘I who from drinking ne’er could spare an hour