English Adjective Comparison
AMSTERDAM STUDIES IN THE THEORY AND HISTORY OF LINGUISTIC SCIENCE General Editor E.F.K. ...
70 downloads
1764 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
English Adjective Comparison
AMSTERDAM STUDIES IN THE THEORY AND HISTORY OF LINGUISTIC SCIENCE General Editor E.F.K. KOERNER (Zentrum für Allgemeine Sprachwissenschaft, Typologie und Universalienforschung, Berlin) Series IV – CURRENT ISSUES IN LINGUISTIC THEORY Advisory Editorial Board Lyle Campbell (Salt Lake City) Sheila Embleton (Toronto) Elly van Gelderen (Tempe, Ariz.) Brian D. Joseph (Columbus, Ohio) John E. Joseph (Edinburgh) Manfred Krifka (Berlin) Martin Maiden (Oxford) E. Wyn Roberts (Vancouver, B.C.) Joseph C. Salmons (Madison, Wis.)
Volume 299
Victorina González-Díaz English Adjective Comparison A historical perspective
English Adjective Comparison A historical perspective
Victorina González-Díaz University of Liverpool
JOHN BENJAMINS PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM/PHILADELPHIA
4-
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences — Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data González-Diaz, Victorina. English adjective comparison : a historical perspective / Victorina González-Diaz. p. cm. -- (Amsterdam studies in the theory and history of linguistic science. Series IV, Current issues in linguistic theory, ISSN 0304-0763 ; v. 299) Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. English language--Adjective. 2. English language--Comparison. I. Title. PE1241.G66 2008 425'.5--dc22 2008023398 ISBN 978 90 272 4815 2 (Hb; alk. paper) © 2008 – John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. • P.O.Box 36224 • 1020 ME Amsterdam • The Netherlands John Benjamins North America • P.O.Box 27519 • Philadelphia PA 19118-0519 • USA
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:13/05/2008; 8:16
F: CI299DE.tex / p.1 (v)
Ángeles, Ramón, Jaime Va por ustedes
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 15:27
F: CI299CO.tex / p.1 (vii)
Table of contents
Acknowledgements Abbreviations chapter 1 Introduction 1. Three ‘strands’ in the study of English adjective comparison 1 1.1 Standard grammars of English 1 1.2 Formal approaches to adjective comparison 2 1.3 Corpus linguistics and adjective comparison 3 2. Adjective comparison: A synchronic and diachronic account 6 2.1 Theoretical stance 7 2.2 Methodology 9 3. Organisation of the book 12 chapter 2 The origin of English periphrastic comparatives 1. Introduction 15 2. The origin of periphrastic comparatives: A corpus-based study 18 2.1 Analysis of the data 18 2.2 The ambiguity of past participles in Old English 22 2.2.1 Coordination 24 2.2.2 The use of modifiers 25 2.2.3 Latin passive constructions 27 2.2.4 Conclusion 27 2.3 The development of adjectival periphrastic comparison 28 3. The evolution of the periphrastic comparative marker(s) 30 3.1 Introduction 30 3.1.1 Bet 31 3.1.2 Swiþor 32 3.1.3 Ma 33 3.1.4 Conclusion 34
xiii xv
1
15
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 15:27
F: CI299CO.tex / p.2 (viii)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
4. Latin influence on OE periphrastic comparatives 35 4.1 English periphrastic comparatives: A Latin borrowing? 35 4.2 The Latin comparative system: Some introductory remarks 36 4.3 Analysis of the data 37 4.3.1 The Latin original examples and their English translation 37 4.3.2 Conclusion 41 5. Periphrastic comparison and contact-induced grammatical change 42 6. Motivation for the rise of English periphrastic comparatives 47 7. Concluding remarks 49 chapter 3 French influence and the spread of periphrastic comparatives in English 1. Introduction: French vs. English in medieval times 51 2. Middle English: A creole? 53 3. Linguistic studies on the influence of French on English 56 4. French influence on adjective comparison 58 5. Analysis 61 5.1 Corpus analysis 61 5.2 Individual author’s analysis 65 5.2.1 Ancrene Wisse 65 5.2.2 Malory’s Le Morte Darthur 67 5.2.3 Conclusion 69 5.3 Comparison in a translated text: Dan Michell’s Ayenbite of Inwyt 70 6. Concluding remarks 71 chapter 4 Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode 1. Introduction 75 2. Adjective comparison: Previous literature 76 3. The data 78 4. Syntactic factors conditioning the choice of comparison 80 4.1 The position of the adjective 80 4.2 Presence of a second term of comparison 83 4.3 Presence of adverbial premodifiers 85 4.4 Presence of complements 86 4.4.1 Infinitival and prepositional complements 87 4.5 Conclusion 88
51
75
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 15:27
F: CI299CO.tex / p.3 (ix)
Table of contents
5. Inflectional vs. periphrastic comparatives: A semantic-pragmatic analysis 89 5.1 Previous literature on the topic 89 5.2 Frequency 90 5.3 Coordination 91 5.4 The position of the adjective: A semantic interpretation 93 5.4.1 Attribution and predication in positive adjectives 93 5.4.2 Attribution and predication in comparative adjectives: Some theoretical remarks 95 5.5 Establishment in discourse 97 6. The influence of adverbial intensifiers on comparatives 99 6.1 Much 100 6.2 Far 101 6.3 Conclusion 102 7. Determinants of adjective comparison: Variable rule analysis 103 8. Concluding remarks 106 chapter 5 Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English 1. Introduction 109 2. The data 109 3. Syntactic and semantic factors conditioning the choice of comparison 110 3.1 The position of the adjective 110 3.2 Presence of a second term of comparison 111 3.3 Presence of adverbial premodifiers 111 3.4 Presence of complements 112 3.5 Establishment in discourse 113 3.6 Determinants of comparative variation in PDE: Variable rule analysis 114 4. Adjective comparison and semantic scales 116 4.1 Cruse’s model of antonymy 116 4.2 Cruse’s true- and pseudo-comparative constructions 119 4.3 Semantic-pragmatic differences between inflectional and periphrastic comparatives 123 4.3.1 The system 123 4.4 Analysis of the data 130 4.4.1 Conclusion 132 5. Concluding remarks 133
109
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 15:27
F: CI299CO.tex / p.4 (x)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
chapter 6 Double periphrastic comparatives in English: Linguistic development 1. Introduction 135 2. The origin of double periphrastic comparatives 137 3. Double periphrastic comparatives in cross-linguistic perspective 138 4. Double periphrastic comparatives: An analysis 141 4.1 Second term of comparison 142 4.1.1 Distribution across periods 144 4.2 Establishment in discourse 146 4.2.1 Distribution across periods 147 4.3 Adverbial premodifiers 147 4.3.1 Distribution across periods 148 4.4 Linguistic distribution of double comparatives: Concluding remarks 151 5. The influence of even on the development of double periphrastic comparatives 154 5.1 Analysis of the data 155 5.2 Conclusion 157 6. Concluding remarks 157 chapter 7 Double periphrastic comparatives: A socio-stylistic analysis 1. Introduction 159 2. Double comparatives in Old English 160 3. Double comparatives in Middle English 162 3.1 Introduction 162 3.2 Double comparatives in Le Morte Darthur 165 3.2.1 Extant manuscripts: General background 165 3.2.2 The Winchester Ms 165 3.2.3 Caxton’s Le Morte Darthur 169 3.3 Concluding remarks 172 4. Double comparatives in Early Modern English 172 4.1 General background 172 4.2 Socio-stylistic distribution of double comparatives in EModE 4.2.1 Analysis of the data 176 4.2.2 Double comparatives in EModE grammars 189 4.2.3 The social downgrading of double forms: Some suggestions 192 4.3 Concluding remarks 195
135
159
175
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 15:27
F: CI299CO.tex / p.5 (xi)
Table of contents
5. Double comparatives in Late Modern English 196 5.1 General background 196 5.2 Socio-stylistic distribution of double comparatives in LModE 197 5.2.1 1700–1800 197 5.2.2 1800–1900 200 5.3 Conclusion 205 6. Double comparatives in Present-day English 205 6.1 General background 205 6.2 Social distribution of double comparatives in Present-day English 207 6.2.1 Written BNC 207 6.2.2 Spoken BNC 208 7. Concluding remarks 210 chapter 8 Comparatives and beyond 1. Introduction 215 2. Chapter 2: Internal v. external factors of change, gradience issues 3. Chapter 3: Language contact, complexity issues 218 4. Chapter 4 and Chapter 5: Iconicity issues 220 5. Chapter 6 and Chapter 7: Double marking of degree, linguistic purism 221 6. Further research 223
215 216
References
227
Index
249
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:13
F: CI299AC.tex / p.1 (xiii)
Acknowledgements
Adiós, ríos; adiós, fontes; adiós, regatos pequenos; adiós, vista dos meus ollos: non sei cando nos veremos. (...) amoriñas das silveiras que eu lle daba ó meu amor, caminiños antre o millo, ¡adiós, para sempre adiós!
Farewell, rivers; farewell fountains farewell, little streams; farewell, beloved view: I don’t know when we will see each other again sweet berries from the bramble patches which I used to give to my beloved paths across the wheat fields farewell, forever farewell! (Rosalía de Castro, Cantares Gallegos 15)
In the poem from which this extract was taken, Rosalía de Castro bids farewell to Padrón (Galicia) before emigrating to Castilla. Her goodbye is sad and gloomy; full of that morriˇna (‘melancholy’) that is so much ingrained in the Galician character. My words here also constitute a farewell – although stemming from a completely different frame of mind, as I am unashamedly happy to say adiós para sempre, adiós to the work contained in the following pages. However, like Rosalía, before emigrating to new research projects I would like to acknowledge those who, directly or indirectly, helped me through the writing of my PhD thesis and its subsequent adaptation into a research monograph. First and foremost, I owe enormous thanks to Sylvia Adamson. She is, and always will be, my point of reference. Her generosity while I was her research student, and her help in all things linguistic and personal afterwards have been invaluable. What more can I say except that, without her, this book would have never happened. I would also like to go back in time to acknowledge those who elicited my interest in historical linguistics and guided, advised, and encouraged me all the way: Javier Pérez-Guerra, Dolores González-Alvarez, Eduardo Varela and David Denison. I still fondly remember Eduardo’s live declamation of bits of Beowulf during his Old English classes and the landwige sandwidge sessions on Tuesdays afternoons in Manchester.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:13
F: CI299AC.tex / p.2 (xiv)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Moving now from past to present, thanks also go to my colleagues of the School of English at the University of Liverpool, in particular to the School’s Research Committee for having granted me a period of research leave during which this book got its final shape. In this shaping process, the expert comments of Ingrid Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Teresa Fanego-Lema, Belén Méndez-Naya, Susan Pintzuk, Terttu Nevalainen and, above all, Olga Fischer, proved invaluable. Similarly, Chris Routledge and Anke de Looper duly deserve a mention for their care in making this manuscript tidy. Last but not least, muchas gracias are due to my family and friends for supporting me during my particular longa noite de pedra. Anita, Nuria, Ana, Filomena, Paulo, Claire and especially Iria were always there for me. I have had many a laugh and quite a number of good nights in and out with the Carnatic Crew (Thomasz, Phil, Ji, John, Tim and Jenny) and the Red Cross Mersey Group (Neil, Duff and Adamski). Finally, Neil Clark cannot be forgotten. It takes more than patience and good will to let me listen to There’s a light that never goes out for thirty consecutive times without losing the will to live. Liverpool, January 2008
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:14
Abbreviations
.
General
Ch. Ed. FG. Gmc. LAT. MED OF OED Pt.
Chapter Edition/edited Functional Grammar Germanic Latin Middle English Dictionary Old French Oxford English Dictionary Part
. Grammatical Adj. Adv. AJC Comp. IC Infl. MOD MTD Pass. Perip. PC V.
Adjective Adverb Comparative adjective Comparative construction Infinitival Complement Inflectional Comparative Modifier Morphological Doubling Theory Passive Periphrastic Comparative Prepositional Complement Verb
. Historical periods OE2 OE3 OE4 HM1 HM2 HM3 HM4
Old English 2 (850–950) Old English 3 (950–1050) Old English 4 (1050–1150) Middle English 1 (1150–1250) Middle English 2 (1250–1350) Middle English 3 (1350–1420) Middle English 4 (1420–1500)
F: CI299ABB.tex / p.1 (xv)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:14
F: CI299ABB.tex / p.2 (xvi)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective EOE LOE EME LME EModE LModE PDE
Early Old English ( –950) Late Old English (950–1150) Early Middle English (1150–1350) Late Middle English (1350–1500) Early Modern English (1500–1700) Late Modern English (1700–1900) Present-day English (1900–present-day)
. Corpora ARCHER. BNC. CED. CEEC. CMEPV. EMODD. HEL. LAMP. LMODF. PPCME2. TOR.
A Representative Corpus of Historical English Registers British National Corpus Corpus of English Dialogues Corpus of Early English Correspondence Corpus of Middle English Pose and Verse Early Modern English Drama Corpus Helsinki Corpus Lampeter Corpus Late Modern English Fiction Corpus Penn-Helsinki parsed Corpus of Middle English Toronto Corpus
. Authors AELF. AELR. ANON. AUST. BEDE. BOUC. BOYL. BRINS. CAXT. CHAU. DEFO. DEKK. DICK. FCOR. FIEL. FLET. GAY. GOLD. GREG. HEYW. JON.
Ælfric A. de Rievaulx Anonymous J. Austen Bede D. Boucicault R. Boyle J. Brinsley W. Caxton G. Chaucer D. Defoe T. Dekker C. Dickens F. Cornwallis H. Fielding J. Fletcher J. Gay O. Goldsmith Gregory the Great T. Heywood B. Jonson
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:14
F: CI299ABB.tex / p.3 (xvii)
Abbreviations MIDD. MITC. ROBE. ROW. SHAK. SMOL. THCK. TOUR. WULF.
T. Middleton D. Mitchel T. W. Robertson W. Rowley W. Shakespeare T. Smollett W. M. Thackeray G. of La Tour Landy Wulfstan
. Works AB.ML. AELF.HO. AELF.LIV. AELF.ME. AELR.DI. ANON. NI. ANON.AW. ANON.BO. ANON.EMA. ANON.HALI. ANON.MA. ANON.MR. ANON.OT. ANON.TK. ANON.YP. APUL.HB. AUST.MP. BEDE.EH. BOUC.FS. BOYL.EM. BRINS.LL. CAXT.MD. CHAM.LT. CHAU.ME. CHRD.RU. CHRO.A. CHRO.E. CLA.WII. DEFE.LS. DEFO.FM. DEFO.RC. DEKK.LO. DEKK.NS. DEKK.SA.
A.B’s Letter of Advice Concerning Marriage Catholic Homilies (Ælfric) Lives of Saints (Ælfric) Memories of Saints (Ælfric) De Institutione Inclusarum (A. de Rievaulx’s translation) Life of St. Nicholas (anon.) Ancrene Wisse (anon.) OE Bounds (anon.) England’s Monarchy Asserted (anon.) Hali Meidenhad (anon.) Mandeville’s Travels (anon.) Marianus (1641, Corpus of English Dialogues, anon.) Old Testament (anon.) Three Kings of Cologne (Anon.) The York Plays (anon.) Herbarium Apuleii Mansfield Park (J. Austen) Historia Ecclesiastica Gentis Anglorum (Bede) Flying Scud (D. Boucicault) Electricity and Magnetism (R. Boyle) Boethius (J. Brinsley, EModE) Le Morte Darthur (W. Caxton) Chamberlain letters (Estival 1989) Tale of Melibee (G. Chaucer) Rule of Chrodegang (anon.) Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (MsA) Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (Peterborough Chronicle E) Laws (II, Cnut) Defensor’s Liber Scientiarum The Fortunate Mistress (D. Defoe) Robinson Crusoe (D. Defoe) London’s Tempe (J. Fletcher) The Noble Souldier (T. Dekker) Satiro-Mastix (T. Dekker)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:14
F: CI299ABB.tex / p.4 (xviii)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective DICK.BH. DICK.DA. DICK.GE. DICK.LD. DICK.NN. DICK.OC. DICK.OT. DICK.PP. DICK.PP. EADW.CP. FARM.RW. FCOR.LET. FIEL.AA. FIEL.JO. FIEL.TJ. FLET.CC. FLET.ML. FLET.TH. FLET.WP. GAY.MH. GOLD.GM. GREG. BO. GREG.CP. GREG.D. GREG.OR. HAMI. HEYW.MW. JON.EM. MESS.LET. MIDD.FG. MIDD.IN. MIDD.VA. MIDD/ROW.WTT. MITC.AY. ROBE.CA. SHAK.2H4. SHAK.AC. SHAK.AW. SHAK.AYL. SHAK.CO. SHAK.H5. SHAK.H8. SHAK.HA. SHAK.JC. SHAK.KJ. SHAK.KL. SHAK.LLL. SHAK.MM. SHAK.MN.
Bleak House (C. Dickens) David Copperfield (C. Dickens) Great Expectations (C. Dickens) Little Dorrit (C. Dickens) Nicholas Nickleby (C. Dickens) The Old Curiosity Shop (C. Dickens) Oliver Twist (C. Dickens) The Pickwick Papers (C. Dickens) The Posthumous Papers of the Pickwick Club (C. Dickens) Eadwine’s Canterbury Psalter Farman’s Rusworth Gospel Letter to Lady J. Bacon (F. Corwallis) Amelia (H. Fielding) Jonathan Wild (H. Fielding) Tom Jones (H. Fielding) The Custome of the Countrey (J. Fletcher) The Mad Lover (J. Fletcher) Thierry and Theodoret (J. Fletcher & P. Massinger) Women Pleas’d (J. Fletcher) The Mohocks (J. Gay) The Good Natur’d Man (O. Goldsmith) Boethius (Gregory the Great) Cura Pastoralis (Gregory the Great) Dialogues (Gregory the Great) Orosius (Gregory the Great) Hamilton 1778 The Fair Maid of the West (T. Heywood) Every Man out of his Humour (B. Jonson) Jane Messyndyne’s letters (CEEC) Your Fiue Gallants (T. Middleton) An Invention (T. Middleton) The Nice Valour (T. Middleton) The World Tost at Tennis (T. Middleton and W. Rowley) Ayenbite of Inwyt (D. Mitchel) Caste. An Original Comedy. (T. W. Robertson) King Henry IV (part 2) (W. Shakespeare) Anthony and Cleopatra (W. Shakespeare) All’s Well That Ends Well (W. Shakespeare) As You Like It (W. Shakespeare) Coriolanus (W. Shakespeare) King Henry V (W. Shakespeare) King Henry VIII (W. Shakespeare) Hamlet, Prince of Denmark (W. Shakespeare) Julius Caesar (W. Shakespeare) King John (W. Shakespeare) King Lear (W. Shakespeare) Love’s Labour’s Lost (W. Shakespeare) Measure for Measure (W. Shakespeare) A Midsummer Night’s Dream (W. Shakespeare)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:5/08/2008; 9:14
F: CI299ABB.tex / p.5 (xix)
Abbreviations SHAK.MV. SHAK.OH. SHAK.TA. SHAK.TC. SHAK.TE. SHAK.TNK. SMOL.LA. SMOL.RO. THCK.BA. TOUR.KN. WMS.MD. WULF. PO. WULF.HO.
The Merchant of Venice (W. Shakespeare) Othello (W. Shakespeare) Timon of Athens (W. Shakespeare) Troilus and Cressida (W. Shakespeare) The Tempest (W. Shakespeare) The Two Noble Kinsmen (W. Shakespeare & J. Fletcher) The Life and Adventures of Sir Launcelot Greaves (T. Smollett) Roderick Random (T. Smollett) The Memoirs of Barry Lyndon (W. M. Thackeray) Book of the Knight of La Tour Landy (G. of La Tour Landy) Le Morte Darthur (Winchester Ms) Institutes of Polity (Wulfstan, bishop of Worcerster) Homilies (Wulfstan, bishop of Worcerster)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.1 (1)
chapter
Introduction
.
Three ‘strands’ in the study of English adjective comparison
. Standard grammars of English The following passage illustrates the standard account of English adjective comparison: Comparison in relation to a higher degree is expressed by the inflected forms in -er (. . .) or their periphrastic equivalents with more (. . .): Anna is {cleverer/more clever} than Susan (. . .)
The choice between inflectional and periphrastic comparison is largely determined by the length of the adjective. a. Monosyllabic adjectives normally form their comparison by inflection: low ∼ lower ∼ lowest (. . .)
b. Many disyllabic adjectives can also take inflections, though they have the alternative of the periphrastic forms: Her children are politer/more polite (the) politest, (the) most polite (. . .)
c. Trisyllabic or longer adjectives can only take periphrastic forms: beautiful ∼ more beautiful [BUT NOT: *beautifuller] (. . .)
d. Participle forms which are used as adjectives regularly take only periphrastic forms: interesting ∼ more interesting ∼ most interesting (. . .)
Most adjectives that are inflected for comparison can also take the periphrastic forms with more and most. With more, they seem to do so more easily when they are predicative and followed by a than clause: John is more mad than Bob is (Quirk et al. 1985: 458, 461–463)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.2 (2)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
The passage features a general description of how the different comparative types (inflectional – friendlier; periphrastic – more friendly) are formed, followed by a report of the factor(s) that govern the selection of one or the other strategy (note that a morphological factor, i.e. the length of the adjective, is considered the main determinant in the choice of comparative strategy).1 Similar descriptive accounts of comparison were offered in the grammars of the early twentieth century (e.g. Jespersen 1909–1949; Poutsma 1914; Curme 1931). While accurate, these analyses are perhaps too general to be taken as more than a good starting point for a study of how the English comparative system works. A further problem associated especially with the early twentieth-century grammars is that they are based on the intuitions and/or the selective (and often limited) textual choice of the linguist. Some of these issues are addressed by more recent grammars of English. For instance, Biber et al. (1999) is not only a corpus-based work, but also – probably because of its corpus-based nature – it acknowledges the existence of double comparative constructions (e.g. worser, more lovelier). However, grammars are broad in terms of the number of the topics they cover, which in its turn precludes the possibility of an in-depth treatment of the nature of comparative constructions. . Formal approaches to adjective comparison Scholarly interest in comparative constructions grew in the second half of the twentieth century, especially in works couched within the generative tradition. From a syntactic point of view, these generative studies were mainly devoted (a) to determining the transformations undergone by comparatives from deep to surface structure and finding a suitable way of representing them in phrase markers, (b) to ascertaining whether comparatives are derived from one or two base strings (Huddleston 1967; Campbell & Wales 1969) and (c) to analysing the syntactic status of the particle than (Hankamer 1973). With respect to semantics, their research focused on the relation between positive and comparative adjectives,2 the general meaning of the comparative construction (Cresswell 1976; Klein 1980, 1982; Hellan 1981; von Stechow 1984) and the polarity of the particle than (Joly 1967; Mittwoch 1974; Napoli & Nespor 1976; Hoeksema 1983). I observed above that the account of comparison provided by the grammars of the early twentieth century was not completely satisfactory because of the gen. Huddleston & Pullum (2002: 1582–1584) offer a very similar view to the one reproduced above. . Some scholars considered positive adjectives the source of comparative constructions (Stassen 1984); whereas other linguists claimed that comparatives were the primary adjectival structures and therefore, that positive adjectives had to be interpreted against the comparative degree (Bartsch & Vennemann 1972; Gnutzmann, Ilson & Webster 1973).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.3 (3)
Chapter 1. Introduction
eralised nature of their statements. The opposite shortcoming may be attributed to these generative studies: although they constitute a valuable contribution to the field, they focus on very specific aspects of comparison that can only marginally lead us to a better understanding of the functioning and the characteristics of the system as a whole. Moreover, they adopt a sentence-based, introspective approach which, as previous literature suggests (cf. for instance Noël 2003), is controversial on two counts: firstly, the examples are deprived of a context, which is often an essential factor for the correct interpretation of the linguistic structure under consideration. Secondly, de-contextualised, made-up data may be easily manipulated to suit the claims of the researcher. With this, of course, I am not implying that formally-oriented linguistics systematically avoids the analysis of data (cf. among others, Kroch & Taylor 2000; Haeberli 2000; Pintzuk 2002; Pintzuk 2005) – although, to the best of my knowledge, no corpus-based formalist study on adjective comparison has been carried out. . Corpus linguistics and adjective comparison The third approach to the study of comparison that I would like to deal with here is corpus linguistics. The first modern corpus of texts was the Survey of English Usage (compiled in the 1960s). However, the possibilities offered by computers soon brought about the development of the first electronic corpora, namely, the Brown University Corpus (1964), the Lancaster-Oslo/Bergen Corpus (1978) and the London-Lund Corpus of Spoken English (the electronic version of the Survey of English Usage, 1980). The use of computerised corpora as a research tool became a very productive practice at the end of the 1980s (when the Helsinki Corpus of English Texts was completed) and, as a result, the production of electronic corpora both synchronic and diachronic notably increased in the following decades – e.g. the Lampeter Corpus of Early English Tracts (1991), the British National Corpus (1992) the ARCHER (1993) and the Corpus of English Dialogues (2006; see Section 2.2 below for a brief description of each of these corpora). The availability of larger quantitative data represented by these electronic corpora drew scholars’ attention to issues that either had not been studied before or that, having been studied, had not produced the expected results due to lack of statistically significant amounts of empirical support; among them, the suggestion that English is shifting towards being an analytic (as opposed to synthetic) language (e.g. Potter 1969: 146–147; cf. also Barber 1993: 274).3 The analysis-synthesis debate, in its turn, led to a greater interest in comparative constructions, for scholars considered . See Vincent (1997) for a critique of the (widespread) tendency to apply the labels analytic/synthetic to languages in general (cf. also Ch. 2, Section 6 below).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.4 (4)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
that the overall tendency of the language would be reflected in the distribution of the inflectional and periphrastic forms in comparative adjectives – note, in this connection, Strang’s (1970: 58) observation about the “lack [of] precise numerical information” about the distribution of PDE inflectional and periphrastic comparative structures. Brook (1973: 180) observed that “comparison of adjectives with more and most is gaining on the use of -er and -est”. A similar statement can be found in Barber (1964: 131, 1997: 146–147). Barber also suggested that the analytic tendency in adjectives can nowadays be clearly appreciated “in a group of disyllabic adjectives (like cloudy, common, cruel, pleasant, quiet, simple) which a few years ago were normally compared with -er/-est, but which are now usually compared with more/most” (Barber 1997: 146, see also 1993: 274). Brook’s (1973) and Barber’s (1993, 1997) intuitive impressions were, to a certain extent, supported by Bauer’s (1994) analysis of (a number of) disyllabic adjectives in Present-day British and American newspapers. Bauer’s study reveals “a tendency for periphrastic comparison to be used later in the century than the suffixed comparison” (1994: 54), especially with disyllabic adjectives ending in -ly. Nevertheless, he does not interpret the tendency towards analyticity in disyllabic comparatives as a structural shift, but as the result of the gradual regularisation of the comparative system in disyllabic adjectives (Bauer 1994: 58). More recently, Denison has reported that “the general tendency over the recorded history of English has been for syntactic [i.e. periphrastic] comparison to expand at the expense of morphological [i.e. inflectional] comparison” (1998: 128). However, Denison’s (1998) own corpus analysis of superlative constructions in the ARCHER corpus (1675–1900) does not seem to support the (supposed) drift of forms towards periphrastic parameters, as it shows that there is “no any clear frequency change” between inflectional/periphrastic superlative constructions in LModE (ibid.). A stronger challenge to the (supposed) analytic drift of English is represented by the diachronic corpus-based studies of comparison carried out by Kytö (1996) and Kytö & Romaine (1997). These works chart the distribution of inflectional and periphrastic comparatives in British English from LME to PDE, showing that it is in fact the inflectional rather than the periphrastic mode of comparison that has been on the increase in the Modern period. Kytö & Romaine (2000) offers a contrastive study of the distributional tendencies of comparative forms from the wider perspective of both British and American English throughout the modern and present-day periods, arriving at the same conclusion. The other corpus-based studies of comparison deal almost exclusively with syntactic matters: Leech & Culpeper (1997), Lindquist (2000), Mondorf (2002) and Suematsu (2004) concentrate on an analysis of the syntactic features that determine (or, at least, favour) the deployment of inflectional vs. periphrastic forms in simple adjectival forms in LModE and PDE, while Mondorf (2000) investigates
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.5 (5)
Chapter 1. Introduction
the choice of comparison in PDE adjectival compounds. The only exception to this trend is Mondorf (2003, 2007), which explores some cognitive and semantic determinants of comparative variation. One may argue that these corpus-based studies are more comprehensive than the accounts of comparison mentioned above (i.e. standard grammars and formalist works) in that their results are backed up by an analysis of a representative amount of (contextualised) data. There is nonetheless still room for further research. For instance, Kytö (1996) spearheads the use of computerised corpora in the study of adjective comparison, showing that in LME and EModE (simple) inflectional comparatives are generally more frequent than the periphrastic ones and that “the inflectional uses thrive in matter-of-fact text types such as handbooks and language written to reflect spoken or colloquial registers” (Kytö 1996: 130). However, the historical, linguistic or social reasons underlying the preference for inflectional over periphrastic forms in the period as a whole, why periphrastic comparatives are dispreferred in “colloquial registers”4 or whether there is any interconnection between these two facts (i.e. the increase of inflectional forms and their being preferred in colloquial environments) do not receive much attention. Similarly, Lindquist (2000) presents his work as a follow-up study of Leech & Culpeper (1997), concentrating on the distribution of comparative strategies for -ly adjectives. His contribution tests against the data the same syntactic factors examined by Leech & Culpeper’s (1997) study (which already included a number of -ly disyllabic adjectival types) and confirms their results; however, it does not fully explain why the presence of those syntactic factors (e.g. adverbial intensifiers/presence of a second term of comparison) would skew the results towards one or the other comparative strategy. A noticeable shortcoming of the corpus-based approach to comparison is that, with the exception of Kytö (1996), Kytö & Romaine (1997) and Suematsu (2004) all the studies that have appeared to date are synchronically oriented. The preference for this kind of research may to a certain extent be understood in the light of the larger amount and greater availability of synchronic data (in both spoken and written media) and the fact that detecting syntactic correlates of (synchronic) variation is relatively straightforward. At any rate, diachronic and non-syntactic synchronic research questions on the comparative degree remain largely unexplored. With regard to the diachronic study of comparison, it is interesting to observe that the Cambridge history of the English language (1992–1999) – currently considered the standard work of reference for the study of the history of English – devotes very little space to comparative constructions. In fact, if their treatment of . See Biber et al.’s (1999: 521–525) corpus-based grammar for some comments on the distribution of the comparative modes across registers in PDE.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.6 (6)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
comparative forms is collectively considered, the overall view of its development is rather patchy. Traugott (1992: 262–264) discusses the morphological and syntactic characteristics of comparative clauses in Old English (henceforth OE). Lass (1992: 116, 1999: 155–156, 158) and Denison (1998: 128) comment on the historical establishment of the length of the adjective as the rule for the selection of comparative strategy as well as linking the disappearance of double comparative forms to the prescriptivist attitudes of eighteenth century grammarians.5 Finally, Adamson (1998: 552) briefly refers to the stylistic use of double comparative forms in the Renaissance. Concerning double comparatives (e.g. more better, worser) Adamson’s (1998) remarks are an exception to the overall tendency, in studies on comparison, to ignore them. At most, they are mentioned in passing in the grammars of English (see, for instance Curme 1931: 503 or, more recently, Biber et al. 1999: 525). No reference to double forms is found in any of the formal studies mentioned above.6 As for the corpus-based works, both Kytö (1996: 124) and Kytö & Romaine (1997: 331, 2000: 173) explicitly acknowledge the existence of this third mode of comparison, and indeed some double comparatives are attested in their data. However, neither they nor subsequent (corpus-based) scholarship investigates any aspect of the use of double forms – probably, as Kytö & Romaine (1997: 337) suggest, due to their (relative) infrequency in the corpora.
. Adjective comparison: A synchronic and diachronic account The present work intends to contribute to a better understanding of the English system of degree by means of a study of a number of aspects of the evolution of adjective comparison that have either been considered controversial or not been accounted for in previous literature. My main interest is thus, diachronic. Nevertheless, as will be shown in the following chapters, the diachronic aspects analysed will also have synchronic implications. Furthermore, unlike previous synchronic and diachronic accounts of adjective comparison, the present work does not concentrate on the ‘standard’ comparative strategies (i.e. inflectional and periphrastic forms) only but also deals with double periphrastic comparatives, thus providing an analysis of the whole range of comparative structures. . Note also Denison’s (1998) comment on the distribution of inflectional and periphrastic forms in LModE mentioned above. . One may suppose that formal linguists would justify their exclusion of double forms by pointing to the fact that they are only interested in the study of well-formed sentences. Obviously, sentences showing ‘ungrammatical’ forms such as double comparatives cannot but be considered deviant structures, and therefore, unsuitable for their investigation.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.7 (7)
Chapter 1. Introduction
. Theoretical stance Without committing to any particular model, the theoretical stance that will be adopted in this book is a broadly functional one (cf. Van Valin 2003: 329 for a summary of different functional approaches to the study of language). Firstly, I observed above that, although I will consider synchronic issues, the main concern of this work is the evolution of comparative constructions. And it is in functional approaches that diachrony plays a key role in explaining language change (Nettle 1999: 447). As Mithun (2005 [2003]: 553) puts it, in functional approaches to language, “synchronic systems are understood as historical products of sequences of individual events.” In connection to this, one should also pay attention to the fact that, while “formal theory is not interested in the actual behaviour of speakers but only in the general properties of the language use of the individual speaker in ideal situations” (Fischer 2007: 55), functional approaches make performance the central focus of their investigation. Secondly, against formal frameworks, functionalism rejects the idea that syntax is a self-contained component of grammar (Anderson 1999: 111; Croft 1995: 491). Functionalism postulates that language is an instrument of social interaction (Dik 1989: 3) and as such, that its structure and organisation is determined “by the communicative and interactional functions which it serves, and the full cognitive, social and psychological properties of the human user” (Thompson 1992: 37; cf. also Mithun 2005 [2003]: 552; Van Valin 2003: 336). In other words, functional approaches reject the idea that change is driven by languageinternal structural factors only and advocate a model where language-external considerations (i.e. social or cultural changes) are also accommodated (Newmeyer 1999: 470–471; Mithun 2005 [2003]: 552).7 Moreover, to a functionalist, languageinternal factors are not restricted to considerations of structure but also include cognitive/semantic factors (e.g. desire for expressiveness, maintenance or development of iconicity, avoidance of ambiguity). Further precision should be added at this point. In their jointly edited volume Determinants of grammatical variation in English, Rohdenburg and Mondorf (2003: 1) claim that scholars working within the functional paradigm have traditionally focused on semantically-motivated functional differences. They (Rohdenburg & Mondorf 2003: 1) however, argue for a broader approach to studying form/function variation, where not only semantic but also “major extrasemantic and largely neglected factors determining grammatical variation” should . It should be emphasized again that not all formal approaches reject the interplay of internal and external factors in processes of language change. Pintzuk (2005: 525), for instance, admits their interaction between external and internal motivations of change – although she seems to advocate the prevalence of the internal factors over the external ones.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.8 (8)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
be taken into consideration (2003: 1). These “neglected” determinants are phonological (preference for alternating syllable structure and avoidance of stress clashes, Schlüter 2003), cognitive (processing efficiency, Hawkins 2003), discursive (Nöel 2003), socio-stylistic (genre and level of formality, Mair 2003), dialectal (Siemund 2003) and frequency factors (Krug 2003). In line with the views put forward above, in this book I shall be arguing that the grammatical variation found in adjective comparison of superiority is to a great extent motivated by differences in the function performed by each of the variants (i.e. inflectional, periphrastic and double comparatives), these differences being best appreciated through the analysis of the context in which the comparative forms occur. Furthermore, I will examine comparative constructions in the light of “more traditional” functional notions and ideas such as iconicity (Ch. 8, Section 4), informativeness (see Ch. 4, Section 5.4.1), avoidance of ambiguity/need for clarity (in the conveyance of degree; see Ch. 2, Section 6) and increase of (comparative) expressiveness (see Ch. 6, Section 3). At the same time, the following chapters bring into play a number of the “new” determinants of variation also considered in Rohdenburg & Mondorf (2003); namely, the (possible) influence of frequency factors in the establishment of periphrastic comparatives (see Ch. 2, Section 3); the importance of the discourse situation in (a) determining the semantic type to which inflectional and periphrastic forms conform (see Ch. 5, Section 4) and (b) describing the different stages of the evolution of simple and double comparatives (see Ch. 4, Ch. 5, Ch. 6 and Ch. 7) and the need for a detailed analysis of the socio-stylistic characteristics of double periphrastic forms in order to obtain an accurate picture of their historical development (see Ch. 8, Section 5). In this respect, recent literature suggests that, although from the second half of the twentieth century onwards extra-linguistic aspects have been considered alongside intra-linguistic factors as cause of change, language contact “still seems to be given second place behind internal motivation” (Farrar & Jones 2002: 1).8 As will be shown below, language contact and its impact on the evolution of comparison will be a prominently discussed issue in Ch. 2 and Ch. 3 below. A final word on the interface between language acquisition and language change. Formalist approaches to language tend to reject the possibility of a separate theory of language change (Pintzuk 2005: 511). They maintain that language acquisition during childhood is the locus for language change, which is defined as change in “parameter setting (. . .) manifested by a cluster of simultaneous surface changes” (Lightfoot 2005 [2003]: 496). Surface changes may of course involve gradual shifts; however, grammar change (which involves parameter changing) is . Note, however, that it is not always on “easy to make a distinction between internal (intralinguistic) and external (extra-linguistic) causes in each case of change” (Fischer 2007: 35).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.9 (9)
Chapter 1. Introduction
often seen as an abrupt, “catastrophic” process (Lightfoot 2005 [2003]: 496). By contrast, functionalism rejects the idea of language change as a parameter-shifting activity, assuming instead that it is a gradual process produced at any time during the speakers’ lifetime (as opposed to during the language learning period only). In line with this idea, the corpora selected for the investigation feature a wide range of adult interaction, both spoken and written. . Methodology I have observed above that corpus-based analyses have an advantage over introspective approaches in that they allow the researcher to take into account the context in which linguistic structures occur. In addition, they provide a relatively faithful reflection of the contemporary linguistic practices as well as allowing the researcher to process important amounts of material and to trace parallel changes over time (cf. Nevalainen & Raumolin-Brunberg 2003: 12). This, of course, is not to say that a ‘bottom-up’ approach like corpus linguistics does not have its shortcomings (see, in this connection, Harris 2005 [2003]: 250). Nonetheless, given its suitability for the questions raised with respect to the topic under consideration, the methodological stance adopted here will be a corpus-based one. The results obtained from the different corpus analyses will, at a later stage, be analysed in the light of the relevant literature. The following list details the corpora that I have used for my analysis: 1. A Representative Corpus of Historical English Registers (ARCHER) ARCHER is a 1.7 million-word corpus of American and British texts ranging from Early Modern English (henceforth EModE) to the present day (1650–1990, henceforth P(resent)D(ay) E(nglish)). The texts have been classified according to register. For more information, see Biber, Finegan and Atkinson (1994). 2. Bergen Corpus of London Teenage Language (COLT) The Bergen Corpus of London Teenage Language consists of about 500,000 words of conversation between teenagers (aged 13 to 17) coming from different London districts. It was compiled in 1993 by a research group at the University of Bergen. At present, COLT constitutes part of the spoken subcorpus of the British National Corpus (see 3. below). For further information on the COLT, see Stenström and Breivik (1993), Haslerund and Stenström (1995). 3. British National Corpus (BNC) The BNC is a 100 million-word corpus of present-day British English, both spoken (10 million words; 863 transcribed texts) and written (90 million words; 3,261 texts). See Aston and Bournard (1998) or http://www.natcorp.ox.ac.uk/ (accessed 20-01-2008) for further information.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.10 (10)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
4. Brooklyn-Geneva-Amsterdam-Helsinki Parsed Corpus of Old English The Brooklyn Corpus is a 106,210 word-corpus of syntactically annotated texts taken from the OE subcorpus of the Helsinki Corpus (see 10 below). For further information, see http://www-users.york.ac.uk/∼sp20/corpus.html (accessed 20-01-2008). 5. Corpus of Early English Correspondence (CEEC) The Corpus of Early English Correspondence was compiled by the Sociolinguistics and Language History Research Group at the University of Helsinki. It contains about 2.7 million words of private correspondence written between 1417 and 1681. See http://khnt.hit.uib.no/icame/manuals/ceecs/INDEX.HTM (accessed 2001-2008) or Nevalainen and Raumolin-Brunberg (1996) for more information about the CEEC. 6. Corpus of English Dialogues (CED) The CED is a 1.2-million-word corpus of texts featuring EModE speech-related practices. For more information, see http://www.engelska.uu.se/corpus.html (accessed 20-01-2008). 7. Corpus of Late Modern English Prose A 100,000 word-corpus of informal private correspondence (1861–1919) of nineteenth-century British writers. The corpus was compiled between 1992 and 1994 under the supervision of David Denison at the University of Manchester. For further information, see http://www.llc.manchester.ac.uk/subjects/lel/staff/daviddenison/lmode-prose/ (accessed 20-01-2008). 8. Corpus of Middle English Prose and Verse A collection of sixty-two Middle English texts (about 3,700,000 words). The texts included in this corpus constituted the primary source for the creation of the Middle English Dictionary. Both the Middle English Dictionary and the Corpus of Middle English Prose and Verse are the result of a project carried out by the Humanities Text Initiative at the University of Michigan. See http://www.hti.umich.edu/c/cme/ (accessed 20-01-2008) for further information about the Corpus. 9. Freiburg-LOB Corpus (FLOB) A parallel corpus to the LOB (see 12. below) containing written material from the 1990s. For further information, see http://khnt.hit.uib.no/icame/manuals/frown/ INDEX.HTM (accessed 20-01-2008). 10. Helsinki Corpus of English Texts (diachronic part) The diachronic part of the Helsinki Corpus contains a 1.5 million-word corpus of historical English texts which are subdivided in three main chronological periods, OE (850-1150; 413,250 words), Middle English (henceforth ME; 1150-1500;
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.11 (11)
Chapter 1. Introduction
608,570 words) and EModE (1500-1710; 551,000 words). For further information, see Rissanen, Kytö & Palander-Collin 1993 or http://khnt.hit.uib.no/icame/ manuals/HC/INDEX.HTM (accessed 20-01-2008). 11. Lampeter Corpus of Early Modern English Tracts A 1.1 million-word collection of non-literary prose text ranging from 1470 to 1740. See http://users.ox.ac.uk/∼lou/wip/Lampeter/Lampman.doc (accessed 2010-2008) or Schmied (1994) for further information. 12. Lancaster-Oslo-Bergen Corpus of British English (LOB) This corpus is the British counterpart of the BROWN. It contains one million words of written British English from the 1960s. As its name indicates, it is the result of a project carried out among the universities of Lancaster and Oslo and the Norwegian Computer Centre for the Humanities at Bergen. The LOB is also available in tagged version. For further information, see http://khnt.hit.uib.no/icame/ manuals/lob/INDEX.HTM (accessed 20-01-2008). 13. Letters of Jane Austen An electronic collection of the private letters of Jane Austen to her sister Cassandra and others (155,243 words). It was edited by R. W. Chapman for the Oxford English Text Archive and coded and indexed by David Denison and Linda van Bergen at the University of Manchester. 14. London Lund Corpus of Spoken English As its name indicates, this corpus is the result of two research projects, the first one (the Survey of English Usage) carried out at the University College London, the second one (the Survey of Spoken English) at the University of Lund. The final version of the corpus contains approximately 1 million words of Present-day spoken English. See Svartvik (1990) or http://khnt.hit.uib.no/icame/manuals/LONDLUND/ INDEX.HTM (accessed 20-01-2008) for further information. 15. Penn-Helsinki Parsed Corpus of Middle English 2 The PPCME2 is a compilation based on the ME texts of the Helsinki Corpus (see 10. above). For more information on this corpus, see http://www.ling.upenn.edu/ hist-corpora/PPCME2-RELEASE-2/index.htm (accessed 20-01-2008). 16. Toronto Corpus of Old English A 3.5 million-word corpus containing all the surviving Old English texts (3037 texts). The corpus constituted the primary source for the Dictionary of Old English, which is being compiled at the Centre for Medieval Studies (University of Toronto). For further information, see http://www.doe.utoronto.ca/ or DiPaolo-Healey and Venezky (1980).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.12 (12)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
17. Zurich English Newspapers (ZEN) The ZEN is a 1.5 million-word corpus of English newspaper texts covering the period 1660–1800. The corpus was compiled in the 1990’s under the supervision of Udo Fries (University of Zurich). For further information, see Fries and Schneider (2000). In addition, two new diachronic compilations: a corpus of EModE drama and a corpus of LModE drama and fiction9 were created in order to investigate the evolution of comparison in earlier periods of the language (see Ch. 6 and Ch. 7 below).
. Organisation of the book The issues that I will be addressing in the following chapters constitute longstanding unresolved questions within the realm of adjective comparison. Chapter 2 focuses on the genesis of the English system of comparison. Perhaps due to their greater frequency, inflectional and periphrastic forms (as opposed to double comparatives) have been considered the standard comparative strategies and, as a result, have elicited most scholarly attention. However, as has been observed above, this scholarly interest in comparison has mainly been restricted to an on-going debate about the syntactic distribution of the inflectional and periphrastic forms in the present-day. Applying Givón’s (1971: 413) aphorism “today’s morphology is yesterday’s syntax” in a very loose way to the present study, one may suggest that the present-day distinctions between inflectional and periphrastic comparatives may be illuminated by an analysis of their diachronic evolution. No such analysis has been carried out to date, the main reason being that there seems to be no consensus in the literature as to when, why and how periphrastic comparatives appeared in the language. Chapter 2 below is a detailed study of the issue. Chapter 3 constitutes a natural continuation of Chapter 2. It deals with the spread of the periphrastic comparative strategy across time and adjective types, focusing on the possibility that language contact issues (e.g. the ‘creolisation’ of English as a result of the Old Norse and the Norman invasions in Old English . The EModE drama corpus features the works of Shakespeare, Jonson, Middleton, Fletcher, Dekker, Heywood and Marlowe (6,794,374 words). The corpus of LModE drama and fiction contains the prose works of Defoe, Swift, Fielding, Sterne, Smollett, Austen, Dickens, Thackeray and the drama of Vanbrugh, Goldsmith, Sheridan, Lillo, Gay, Steele, Cibber, Bocicault, Robertson, Tennyson and Browning (12,680,951 words).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:14
F: CI29901.tex / p.13 (13)
Chapter 1. Introduction
and Middle English times, respectively) may have had an impact on the rise in frequency and eventual establishment of the structure in the English language. Once the origin and diffusion of periphrastic comparatives is ascertained, I will move on to examining the distributional differences between inflectional and periphrastic forms from EModE until the present-day. As noted above (Section 1), standard grammars of English suggest that the most general determinant in the choice of comparative strategy is morphological (i.e. the number of syllables of the adjective),10 while at the same time acknowledging the existence of variation between inflectional and periphrastic forms (especially in the case of disyllabic adjectives). I have already suggested that a number of recent corpus-based studies seem to account for this variation mainly in syntactic terms – although some of them explicitly mention the possibility of further, (yet largely unexplored) constraints on variation (cf. Kytö & Romaine 1997; Mondorf 2003, 2007). The need for further research in this area becomes even more apparent if one considers that these syntactically oriented studies have not yet reached a general consensus as to what syntactic factors are the main determinants in the choice of comparison.11 Chapters 4 and 5 are thus devoted to (a) re-assessing the validity of the syntactic factors put forward by previous corpus-based scholarship in relation to the distribution of simple inflectional and comparative forms and (b) examining the possibility of a semantic-pragmatic differentiation between the two strategies from the EModE period until the present-day. As observed in Section 1.3 above, double comparatives have been consistently omitted from scholarly consideration due to their ‘marginal’ status both in social and linguistic (i.e. frequency) terms. The subsequent two chapters of the book offer a detailed study of their linguistic characteristics (Ch. 6) and their sociolinguistic distribution (Ch. 7) from their emergence in the language to the present day. They also examine the reasons behind their appearance. The closing chapter (Ch. 8) puts the research carried out in the book into a wider perspective and suggests a number of issues for further research in the realm of adjective comparison.
. This claim applies to Present-day English only. As Bax (2008) notes, eighteenth-century grammars of English commented on a wider range of determinants of comparative variation. . Most studies (Leech & Culpeper 1997; Lindquist 2000; Mondorf 2002, 2003) observe the influence that syntactic position (i.e. attributive/predicative) has on the selection of comparative strategy. However, their own data (see, for instance, Leech & Culpeper 1997; Lindquist 2000) reveal that differences in syntactic position cannot explain all comparative variation. In keeping with these findings, recent research (Gries 2003) shows that it is highly unlikely that grammatical variation may be explained by invoking a single type of determinant.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.1 (15)
chapter
The origin of English periphrastic comparatives12
.
Introduction
The comparative degree in Present-day English is expressed in two main ways: by the addition of suffix -er to the adjectival stem (‘inflectional’ or ‘synthetic’ comparison, as in hard:harder), or by means of the pre-position of the adverb more to the positive adjective (‘periphrastic’ or ‘analytical’ comparison, as in beautiful:more beautiful; see, e.g. Quirk et al. 1985: 458; Biber et al. 1999: 522; Huddleston & Pullum 2002: 1582–8; Dixon 2005 [1991]: 91). It is commonly agreed in the literature that inflectional comparison (derived from the Germanic suffixes */iz/ and */oz/) was the earliest strategy deployed in English (Mitchell 1985: 80, 84). The origin of the periphrastic mode creates, however, two controversies: a ‘chronological’ controversy (i.e. when exactly periphrastic forms appeared) and a ‘philological’ controversy (i.e. whether periphrastic comparison arose through language contact or language-internal causes of change, and, in the latter case, through what process of internal change; cf. Danchev 1989: 168). Scholarly interest in the issue arose at the turn of the twentieth century. In her study of popular speech, Wright (1913: 145) suggested that inflectional forms were the preferred mode of comparison for virtually all adjectives in LModE dialects, periphrastic forms serving only as a means of intensification of the regular (i.e. inflectional) comparison. As Mustanoja (1960: 279) observed, this reluctance to deploy periphrastic forms in dialectal speech might suggest that they were not in the original repertoire of English linguistic structures, but were the result of foreign influence. Furthermore, the fact that English periphrastic comparatives gained ground at a time when French influence was particularly noticeable (i.e. the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries) was cited as evidence that they were introduced in
. A preliminary version of this chapter can be found in González-Díaz (2006). Unless otherwise stated, the emphasis (i.e. italics/bold) in the examples provided through the chapter is mine (VGD).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.2 (16)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
English by analogy with French periphrastic constructions (cf. in this connection, Danchev 1989: 170, 172–173). Other scholars such as Pound (1901: 3) pointed to Latin as the most probable origin of periphrastic comparatives. Pound observed that periphrastic constructions appeared in ME, a period in which Latin was considered the language of culture and civilisation (Samuels 1972: 94). This, in her opinion, encouraged the calquing of many Latin constructions into English (for instance, the elative use of superlatives, e.g. most brave man, which she considered a calque on Latin absolute constructions – in this particular example, on the form vir fortissimus). Taking into consideration the structural similarity between English and Latin analytic forms, she observed that it would not be strange to suppose that this might have been the case with periphrastic constructions. By contrast, other linguists considered periphrastic forms a native development. At the end of the nineteenth century, Emerson (1894:368) argued that periphrastic comparison was the result of the spread of the use of more with participles and adjectives “not strictly allowing comparison” in ME – although he did not specify what kind of adjectives he was referring to. This suggestion was taken up again by Knüpfer (1921), Curme (1931: 503) and Brunner (1951: 64), who pointed to the combination of degree intensifiers with participles in OE as a possible source of periphrastic forms in English. The origin of periphrastic forms was also considered in some specialist works on OE and ME in the second half of the twentieth century. In keeping with Knüpfer’s (1921) ideas, Mitchell (1985: 84–85, cf. also Mossé 1952: 92; OED more, C. adv.) traces the origin of periphrastic forms back to OE, more specifically, to the combination of the adverbial intensifiers swiðor, ma and bet with participles. He also mentions the appearance of “occasional” adjectival examples (see (1) below). (1) The beginnings of periphrastic comparison are probably to be seen in OE examples like GD 111 bet. . . gelæred, Bede 260.17, ma. . . gelæred (. . .) There are occasional examples with adjectives; they include CP 33.17 bet wyrðe and GD(C) 151.21 ma gode where MS H has beteran (Mitchell 1985: 84)
Interesting as his claims are, they require substantiation. Mitchell does not provide further examples of the supposed OE periphrastic (participial) constructions, the instances given consisting in the periphrastic participial form in itself, without any further contextual information which could help to illuminate the origin of the construction. Furthermore, while insightful, his suggestions are based on his personal observations and/or selective reading of OE texts. A corpus-based analysis of OE texts will therefore contribute to a fuller exploration of Mitchell’s remarks. The flourishing of computerised corpora in the last quarter of the century led to a revival of the interest in the evolution of comparative constructions. As
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.3 (17)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
a consequence, several corpus-based works on adjective comparison came out in the last two decades: Kytö (1996), Kytö & Romaine (1997, 2000), Leech & Culpeper (1997), Lindquist (2000), Mondorf (2000, 2003, 2007) and Suematsu (2004). Only Kytö (1996) and Kytö & Romaine (1997, 2000) explicitly mention the problem of the origin of periphrastic comparative forms. Their comments reflect the controversial nature of the issue (see (2)–(4) below):13 (2) The periphrastic construction first appeared in the thirteenth century, more probably under Latin than French influence. At the same time, the construction seems to have been of native origin and arisen from the need for emphasis and clarity felt by the speakers (Kytö 1996: 123) (3) . . . a variety of factors has been cited as responsible [for the appearance of periphrastic comparatives]. We have already noted above historians’ attribution of the development to foreign influence. At the same time others pointed to stylistic factors such as speakers’ need for emphasis and clarity (Kytö & Romaine 1997: 330) (4) From a historical point of view, the periphrastic construction with more and most (e.g. more effective, most effective) are innovations (. . .) According to Mitchell (1985: 84–85), who lists the few possible attested examples in Old English, the periphrastic forms first appeared in the thirteenth century, possibly under the influence of Latin (and to a lesser extent French) (Kytö & Romaine 2000: 172)
Passage (2) appears to be contradictory, as it suggest that English periphrastic comparatives are the result of a foreign borrowing and, at the same time, a native development (see also quote (4)). Similarly, in (3) and (4) the authors report the opposing views of previous scholars, without taking a clear position themselves. All in all, the account given in the literature on the origin of periphrastic forms is not completely satisfactory: on the one hand, the earliest explanations are based on hypotheses that have never been tested against a substantial amount of data; on the other, the most recent comments seem to fall back on the claims made by previous scholarship. Further research on where periphrastic comparatives come from and how they arose is therefore needed. The present chapter focuses on the treatment of these issues. Sections 2 and Section 3 are devoted to a corpus-based analysis of those constructions that may . No mention to this controversial issue is made in The Cambridge history of the English language (vol. 1). In his chapter on morphology, Hogg (1992: 141) states that the normal method of comparison in OE was the inflectional one, periphrastic forms being “relatively rare and mostly restricted to later texts.” Unfortunately, he does not provide references to any of those Late OE (henceforth LOE) texts displaying periphrastic comparatives nor any actual examples of the construction.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.4 (18)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
be considered the beginnings of adjectival periphrastic comparatives and discuss the reasons behind the establishment of (PDE) [more + adj.] as the standard periphrastic comparative construction. Section 4 investigates the (possible) connection between English periphrastic forms and Latin comparative constructions. On the basis of the results obtained in Section 4, Section 5 is devoted to a discussion of the rise of periphrastic comparison in the light of recent literature on contact-induced grammatical change. Section 6 concentrates on a critical analysis of the factors that, according to previous literature, may have favoured the appearance of periphrastic comparatives. Finally, Section 7 summarises the results obtained from the case studies carried out in previous sections.
. The origin of periphrastic comparatives: A corpus-based study . Analysis of the data In view of the lack of consensus in the literature on the topic, the first step in this investigation consisted in the analysis of one of the hypotheses suggested by previous scholars, i.e. that of the native origin of periphrastic comparatives. To this end, I examined the collocations of the adverbs ma, bet and swiðor in the Toronto Corpus14 – note that Mitchell (1985, see quote (1) above) suggests that these combinations constitute the first examples of the English periphrastic comparative construction. The analysis showed that, apart from functioning frequently as adverbial modifiers (see examples (5)–(7) below), these adverbs occurred in two other relevant combinations. (5) hit nu swiður gefihð on his yfelum (TOR.GREG.CP.) it now more rejoices on its evil “now it rejoices more in its evil ways” (6) se biscop swor þæt he wolde ut of Englelande faran. & na the bishop swore that he would out of England travel and no “the bishop swore that he would leave England and that he would not mare cuman on ðisan lande butan se cyng him æfter sende more come on this land but the king him after send come back any more unless the king would send for him” (TOR.CHRO.E.) (7) and me bet licað to forlætenne nu þisne hwilwendlican wurðmynt, and me better like to abandon now this temporary honour “and I consider it better to abandon this temporary honour now
. I am indebted to David Denison and the University of Manchester for having given me access to this corpus.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.5 (19)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
and þæs wuldorfullan Godes cynedome gehyrsumian on haligre and of the wonderful God kingdom serve on holy drohtnunge (TOR.AELF.LIV.) behaviour and to serve the wonderful kingdom of God through a holy behaviour”
First, ma, bet and swiðor collocate with fully-fledged adjectives, forming a prototypical periphrastic comparative construction (see Table 2.1 and examples (8)– (10)). Table 2.1. Adjectival periphrastic comparatives in the Toronto Corpus Example
Translation
Work15
Period16
Edition
Swiþor bettra Ma gode Bet wyrðe More andlang Bet wyrðe Mare heare Swiðor eadmodra Bet wyrðe Ma fexede Ma unscyldige Ma wuldorful Ma wyrse Ma hludre
More better More good More worthy More long More worthy More higher More humbler More worthy More hairy More virtuous More glorious More worse More loud
FARM.RW. GREG.D. GREG.CP. CHRO.A. WULF.PO. ANON.NI. ÆLF.HO. CLA.WII. APUL.HB. DEFE.LS. DEFE.LS. DEFE.LS. CHRD.RU.
(850–950, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c897, OE2) (10th c., OE2-3) (950–1050, OE3) (9th c., OE2-3) (950–1050, OE3) (c1020, OE3) (c1050, OE3-4) (11th c., OE4) (11th c., OE4) (11th c., OE4) (c1050, OE3)
Skeat 1887 Hecht 1900 Sweet 1871 Plummer 1965 Jost 1959 Brown 1970 Thorpe 1844 Liebermann 1903 Lignamine 1420 Rhodes 1889 Rhodes 1889 Rhodes 1889 Napier 1916
(8) þæt hi syn sylfe ma gode þonne oðre men (TOR.GREG.D.)17 “that they themselves are more good than other men” (9) Ne fleah he ðy rice ðy his ænig monn bet wyrðe wære (TOR.GREG.CP.) “He did not abandon the kingdom because any man was more worthy of it” . See the Abbreviations section above for a list of abbreviations of the works mentioned in this chapter. . I have adopted the chronological divisions established by the compilers of the Helsinki Corpus (see http://khnt.hit.uib.no/icame/manuals/HC/INDEX.HTM or the list of corpora provided in Chapter 1, Section 2.2 above). . Given the localised nature of the construction in which I am interested (i.e. verb + intensifier + adjective/participle), in the remaining examples of the chapter I will not provide a word-by-word translation of the passage (although I will use typography to highlight the relevant strings).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.6 (20)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
(10) & swyþe smælon leafon swylce heo ma fexede gesewen sy (TOR.APUL.HB.) “and very small leaves in such a manner that it (she) may appear to be more hairy”
The table also shows that ma and swiðor form double periphrastic comparatives when they combine with adjectives already inflected for comparison (see examples (11) and (12) below): (11) he bið swa micele wlitegra ætforan Godes gesihðe, swa he swiðor ætforan him sylfum eadmodra bið (TOR.ÆLF.HO.) “he was so much fairer in front of God’s eyes as he was more humbler in front of himself ” (12) hu miccle mae ł swiþor bettra is monn þonne scep forþon is alefed on restedagum god to doanne (TOR.FARM.RW.) “how much [more advanced] and more better a man is than a sheep because he is allowed to do good on Sabbath”
In Section 1 above I observed that one of the points of contention about the appearance of periphrastic forms was their date of origin (i.e. whether they appeared in OE or in ME). Corpus-based studies suggest that “the periphrastic forms first appeared in the thirteenth century” and that the availability of the construction “added yet one more option to the system”, i.e. double periphrastic comparatives (e.g. more better, more lovelier; Kytö & Romaine 1997: 330–331; cf. also Kytö & Romaine 2000: 172). The OED also traces the use of more as a comparative particle back to the beginning of the thirteenth century18 – when it also records the first occurrence of double comparative forms.19 By contrast, the data shows that adjectival periphrastic comparison was a new option available in English already in the ninth century. The other collocational pattern observed in the Corpus (26 examples) consists in the verb beon (although there is one example with weorðan, see (13) below), the intensifier (swiðor, ma and bet) and a participle in predicative position (see Table 2.2 and examples (14)–(15)). In this connection, one may observe predominance
. “Traces of periphrastic comparison are found in Old English in the use of ma, bet, and swiþor with participles and occas. with adjectives. Periphrastic comparison of adjectives and adverbs with more (. . .) is found from early Middle English, although only sporadically before the 14th cent.” (OED, more, C., adv. c.). The first example of periphrastic comparison according to the OED is: c1225 Lamb. þes we ahte to beon þe edmoddre and þa mare imete (“therefore we have to be the humbler and the more moderate”). . The first double periphrastic form cited by the OED is: c1205 LAY. 4349, þu eær . . . mare hærdere (“you are. . . more harder”).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.7 (21)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
of constructions with past participles over those with present participles (22 out of the 26 examples; 85% of the total). Table 2.2. Participial periphrastic comparatives in the Toronto Corpus Example20
Translation
Work
Date/period
Edition
Swiþor geangsumod Ma scamigende Ma gyldende Ma geswenced Ma witnode Ma besmiten Ma hreosende Swiþor beswicen Swiþor forsewen Swiþor beswicen Swiþur underðied Ma gedafonade *Ma gelæred *Bet gelæred Swiþor gebrocede Swiðor geswenct Swiðor afandod Swiþor gehalgod Swiðor byrnende Swiðor gegladod Swiðor gemærsod Swiðor forscyldgod Ma gelyfdon Ma gelyfdon *Swiþor gewurðod Ma gestired
More vexed More ashamed More rewarded More troubled More punished More defiled More agitated More deceived More despised More deceived More obedient More suitable More learned More learned More afflicted More troubled More experienced More dedicated More (being) burnt More contented More glorified More condemned More trusted More trusted More esteemed More moved
GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.OR. GREG.OR. GREG.BO. GREG.CP. GREG.CP. BEDE.HE. BEDE.HE. BEDE.HE. CHRO.A. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.ME. WULF.HOM. ANON.CPS.
(c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c897, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c891, OE2) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (c1150, OE4/ME)
Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Sweet 1883 Sweet 1883 Sedgefield 1899 Sweet 1871 Sweet 1871 Miller 1890 Miller 1890 Miller 1890 Plummer 1965 Thorpe 1844 Thorpe 1844 Thorpe 1844 Thorpe 1844 Thorpe 1844 Thorpe 1844 Thorpe 1844 Skeat 1887 Thorpe 1844 Bethurum 1957 Harsley 1889
(13) Ac hit wyrð swa micle swiður beswicen mid ðæm witum swa hit nu swiður gefihð on his yfelum (TOR.GREG.CP.) “But it is so much more deceived with punishments, the more it now rejoices in its evil ways” (14) forðam ðe þu ne leofast be ure sylene, ac ðu bist swiðor gegladod on offrunge ure heortan (TOR.ÆLF.HO.) “because you do not live by our gift, but you are more gladdened by the offering of our hearts” . Those instances marked with an asterisk (*) are ‘discontinuous’ examples, that is, examples where the adverbial particle does not immediately precede the participle.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.8 (22)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
(15) Se wæs ma in ciriclecum þeodscipum & in lifes bylwitnesse gelæred, þon he from wære in worulde þingum (TOR.BEDE.HE.) “(he) who was more learned in ecclesiastical discipline and simplicity of life than he was energetic in the things of this world”
Given that there is no (noticeable) structural difference between the periphrastic constructions occurring with either a present or a past participle, in what follows the investigation will concentrate on those periphrastic forms containing past participles only. However, before proceeding to the analysis of the development of the periphrastic construction, an important issue should be taken into consideration, namely, the ambiguous grammatical status of OE past participles (see e.g. examples (13) to (15) above). Section 2.2 below will explore this problem in more detail. . The ambiguity of past participles in Old English In a classic paper, Lyons (2004 [1968]: 217) observes that “the tripartite distinction of nouns, verbs and adjectives (as independent parts of speech) was not established until the medieval period” and suggests that the distinction that modern linguists make between verbs and adjectives is not completely justified, for it only takes into consideration the inflectional properties of the two classes (as opposed to their ‘notional’ or conceptual properties). The similarities between verbal and adjectival categories observed by Lyons become more evident if one examines the nature of participles. Malouf (1998: 90) states that participles were considered ‘mixed’ categories in the traditional Western grammatical tradition because, as their name indicates, they participate “in the characteristics of both verbs and adjectives” (Malouf 1998 in Hudson 2003: 585). Their status in current grammatical theory, however, is less straightforward, as they are normally considered ambiguous elements that belong to one or another category depending on their syntactic behaviour (cf. Quirk et al. 1985: 414, 1327ff.). The fuzzy nature of participles – and, particularly, of past participles – has an obvious impact on the present study (cf. in this connection, the remarks in Anderson 1993: 17ff.), as it makes it difficult to ascertain the syntactic status of the early comparative constructions. Example (14) above clearly illustrates the problem: the participle gegladod ‘gladdened’ in the construction bist swiðor gegladod (i.e. ‘be (more) gladdened’) could be interpreted as either a passive participle dependent on the auxiliary beon (which would mean that bist gegladod is a passive
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.9 (23)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
construction) or as a participial adjective (in which case bist gegladod would be a copula construction).21 In this connection, Visser (1973: 2087, 2088) observes that: Originally the statal passive was the normal one, for the simple reason that in Primitive Germanic wesan/beon (. . .) was a notional verb with the sense ‘to exist’, ‘to be (t)here’ while the past participle functioned as a predicative adjunct with adjectival import (. . .) [D]ynamic and statal passives have occurred side by side from Old English times
However, he does not provide further information about when or why exactly the dynamic passive (i.e. the verbal one) appeared in the language. Likewise, Traugott (1992: 198, 199; cf. also Mustanoja 1960: 440 and Lightfoot 1979: 258) notes that passives in OE derive from “a construction with a BE-verb and an inflected, originally adjectival, past participle” and that the “development of the phrasal passive involved the reanalysis of the predicative adjective as part of the verb complex.” As in the case of Visser’s quotation, one can observe that Traugott avoids the question of when exactly predicative past participles acquired their verbal meaning. Two factors have traditionally been considered indicative of the verbal/adjectival nature of past participles in OE. Firstly, Visser (1973: 2087) argues that “in general the dynamic nature [of the past participle] is obvious when there is a prepositional agentive adjunct or another adjunct denoting particulars of the action” in the context. Now, if one applies this test to the examples listed in Table 2.2 above, one will realise that, at least in four cases, the past participle of the construction is more verbal than adjectival (see examples (16) and (17) below, where the agentive22 complement is introduced by the preposition mid): (16) swa mycle swa he ma besmiten byð mid þy dysilicran spræce (TOR.GREG.D.) “so much as he is more defiled by the foolish speech” (17) Ac hie wæron micle swiþor gebrocede on þæm þrim gearum mid ceapes cwilde 7 monna (TOR.CHRO.A.) “In those three years they were much more afflicted by the destruction of cattle and people”
This criterion is, however, of limited use, as it does not help us to classify participles when there is no agentive adjunct in the sentence – which unfortunately is the case in most examples. . Mitchell (1985: 315) also notes that “the position of the participle does not affect either inflection or sense and cannot throw any light on whether it is adjectival or verbal.” . Mid was also the marker of the instrumental case in OE, and therefore, in (16) and (17) above the constituent introduced by mid can be classified as instrumental as well as agentive adjunct. I am grateful to David Denison for bringing this to my attention.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.10 (24)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Secondly, it is commonly accepted (Estival 1989: 26–27) that predicative past participles are more adjectival when they are inflected and, conversely, that they are more verbal when they do not undergo inflection. Mitchell (1985: 314) provides some counterexamples to this claim (see the examples under (18) below): (18) a.
Ac þa þa Octavianus se casere to rice feng, þa wurdon Ianas dura betyneda “But when the Caesar Octavianus came to the throne, then the gates of Janus were closed” (TOR.GREG.OR.) b. þæt Ianas dura siþþan belocen wurde buton anum geare (TOR.GREG.OR.) “that the gates of Janus were closed but once a year since then”
In (18a) the participle betyneda is inflected in agreement (nominative plural) with the subject dura. This seems to suggest that the participle is more adjectival than verbal. However, in (18b) the syntactic relation between the participle belocen and the noun dura is similar to the one established between bentyneda and dura in (18a) and in this case the adjective is not inflected for agreement. This leads Mitchell (1985: 314) to suggest that the presence/absence of inflections in past participles is by no means so systematic, and therefore, that it cannot be taken as a decisive criterion for categorising participles as either adjectives or verbs. On the whole, one may conclude that the two criteria mentioned above are neither reliable nor sufficient for a correct classification of OE participial forms. Three other factors were thus taken into consideration in my own categorisation of past participles in OE (see Sections 2.2.1–2.2.3 below). .. Coordination Estival (1989: 34–35) shows that it has been possible to coordinate predicative past participles with both verbs and adjectives in all periods of the language (see examples (19) to (21)): (19) On þis gaer waerd þe king Stephne ded & bebyried þer (TOR.CHRO.E., 1122–1154, Estival 1989: 33) On this year king Stephen was deadADJ and buriedPPLE there “This year the king Stephen died and was buried there” (20) as þe este. & al þe eise. is þer as þe oþre. beoð godlese & ignahene “All the delicacy and all the ease is here [on earth] as the other [things of earth] are void of good [godless] and corroded” (ANON.HALI., 1210–1220, Estival 1989: 33) (21) Here is great and curious present going to the great Turk, which no doubt will be much talked of and very scandalous among other nations, especially the Germans (CHAM.LT., 1599, Estival 1989: 34)
She also observes that, in this type of coordinate constructions, the auxiliary verb of either of the conjuncts can be omitted “only if both conjuncts have the same
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.11 (25)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
aspect, i.e. either both are stative or both are dynamic” (Estival 1989: 35).23 In her examples, the deletion of the auxiliary is possible when the past participle combines with either adjectives or verbs (e.g. in (20) above, beoð godlese & beoð ignahene). This leads her to conclude that, in all periods, past participles may have had either stative (i.e. verbal) or dynamic (i.e. adjectival) interpretations. Furthermore, Estival suggests that, if past participles were exclusively adjectival elements in OE, we would expect that, in predicative position, they would more often coordinate with adjectives in OE than in Modern English, as in OE they supposedly lack the verbal nature that they possess in Modern English. By contrast, her study (1989: 34) shows that predicative past participles combine more often with verbs than with adjectives in all periods, and that, in fact, the proportion of participles in coordination with verbs in late OE is higher than in any other period of the language (see Table 2.3): Table 2.3. Past participle coordination in predicative position (from Estival 1989: 35) Period
With ADJ.
With verb
EOE LOE EME LME EModE PDE Total
0 (0%) 2 (2.2%) 1 (1%) 1 (0.9%) 6 (2.9%) 3 (0.5%) 13 (100%)
0 (0%) 20 (22.2%) 14 (15.4%) 6 (5.2%) 20 (9.6%) 22 (3.4%) 82 (100%)
Although the number of texts used for her analysis is rather limited,24 Estival’s investigation provides support for the suggestion that OE past participles possessed, to a certain degree, the semantic import characteristic of verbal elements. .. The use of modifiers Denison (1998: 229) argues that in sentences such as Jim was amused, the syntactic status of the participle amused is ambiguous between an adjectival and a verbal interpretation. He also claims that a recent development in the language has been . The existence of a semantic affinity between the members of a co-ordinate construction is also suggested by Schachter’s (1977) Coordinate Constituent Constraint, which holds that, in order for two elements to form a coordinate structure, they must not only “belong to the same syntactic category” but also have “the same semantic function” (Schachter 1977: 90). . Estival uses Beowulf and the Peterborough Chronicle for her analysis of the OE period; for ME, Hali Meidenhad and the Paston Letters and for EModE and PDE, the Chamberlain Letters and the Philadelphia Interviews, respectively (Estival 1989: 24).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.12 (26)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
a growing tendency to analysing participles in this type of constructions as adjectival rather than verbal. This shift, according to him, can be clearly appreciated in the range of adverbial intensifiers that collocate with the participle. Thus, whereas in the nineteenth century the (verbal) intensifier much was a frequent modifier of predicative participles (e.g. I was much disappointed, in Denison 1998: 229), nowadays very (an adjectival intensifier) has replaced much in these contexts (e.g. I was very disappointed). Unfortunately, this kind of distributional test is not possible for OE past participles, as in OE there were no intensifiers/set of intensifiers categorically restricted to either verbal or adjectival modification (Estival 1989: 28). However, Estival (1989: 29, cf. also Ingersoll 1978: 196) notes that the adverb wel is one of the most common modifiers of both verbal and adjectival past participles in OE and she suggests that the past participle modified by wel has a verbal import in those cases in which wel “c[an] not be translated as Modern English well”. Estival does not elaborate further on either the reasons for her claim or on the kind of translation that we should expect when well collocates with a (verbal) participle. Furthermore, on many occasions a single word can have different but equally valid translations – which does not help the decision-making process as regards which translation should be considered the best one (and hence, the translation on which we should base our judgement on the verbal/adjectival nature of the participle). Still, one may argue that, in combination with the other factors considered in this section, Estival’s (1989) ‘translation test’ may provide a better understanding of the nature of the OE past participle. Those instances in which wel modifies a past participle were retrieved from the Toronto Corpus. More specifically, my search was restricted to those texts of the Corpus in which instances of periphrastic comparison were also found. The reason for this restriction was that, if any further conclusions with respect to the categorial status of the participle were to be reached by means of an analysis of the combination [wel + past participle], then, one would be able to extrapolate them safely to the participial periphrastic constructions attested in the same text(s), as one may assume that the author(s) of the text(s) conceptualised and used past participles in a consistent, uniform way. 64 examples of wel in combination with a participle were found in the Corpus. In 45 of them (70% of the total),25 the different variants of OE wel cannot be literally translated as PDE well, thus conforming to the behaviour that Estival (1989) considers characteristic of a verbal modifier (see (22) and (23) below): . Note that 30 of these 45 examples feature the same collocation, i.e. wel gelæred (14 examples, all of them in King Alfred’s translation of Cura Pastoralis) and wel gecueden/gecweden (16 tokens in the translation of Bede’s Historia Ecclesiastica). In either case, the semantics of the participle does not allow for a literal translation of the intensifier well.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.13 (27)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
(22) æc ma hi wyllað þæt hi syn beforan oðrum mannum wel geherede “but they wish more that they were well praised (PDE very much praised) in front of other people” (TOR.GREG.D.) (23) Ioppe hatte sum burh, hehende þære Liddan, on þære wæs an wydewe wel gelyfed, Thabitas geciged (TOR.ÆLF.CH.) “Iop is called one fortified place next to Lidda, where there was a well faithful (PDE very faithful) widow called Thabitas”
.. Latin passive constructions A consideration of the origin of the text in which the periphrastic forms appear seems to supply some interesting information. Three of the earliest examples of participial comparatives attested in my corpora are translations of a Latin passive form (see (24) and (25) below). (24) LAT. Et enim ipse est deus meus et salutaris meus audiutor meus non movebor amplius “And he himself is my god, my saviour, my help and I will not be moved any more” OE He is god myn 7 helo min fultumend min ne beo ic ma gestired “He is my god and my saviour, my help and I will not be more moved” (TOR.EADW.CP.)
In this example, the Latin inflectional passive form movebor (I will be moved) is translated as ic beo gestired in OE. The OE text is a literal rendering of the Latin original, and therefore, one may interpret ma in the OE text not as an adjectival modifier (of gestired) but rather as the English equivalent of the Latin adverb amplius, which modifies the passive verb form movebor (i.e. beo gestired). A similar construction is illustrated in (25) below: (25) LAT. quanto amplius inquinatur stulta locutione (GREG.D., Vogüé 1978: 324) “how much more it is defiled with foolish speech” OE swa mycle swa he ma besmiten byð mid þy dysilicran spræce “so much as it is more defiled by foolish speech” (TOR.GREG.D.)
.. Conclusion The evidence examined in Sections 2.2.1–2.2.3 above suggests that the past participle in constructions such as the ones exemplified in (13) to (15) already possessed some kind of verbal force in OE. With regard to this, one should note that among the proponents of the native origin of periphrastic comparatives, Knüpfer (1921) had already advocated the verbal nature of the participles combining with swiðor, ma and bet. However, he went as far as to claim that the latter were already pure verbal elements in OE. As observed above, the analyses of previous sections do not support Knüpfer’s (1921) views, as the past participle cannot be straightforwardly
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.14 (28)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
accommodated in either the adjectival or the verbal category. In what follows, I will thus contend that OE part participles are hybrids between verbal and adjectival elements (cf. Malouf ’s (1998) comments about ‘mixed’ categories in Section 2.2 above). The next step of the investigation will be then to investigate the implications that the hybrid nature of participles has the status and development of the early examples of periphrastic comparatives. . The development of adjectival periphrastic comparison The previous section was devoted to describing the relevant collocations of swiðor, ma and bet in my data. Yet an important issue remains to be resolved: the relation between the two (i.e. adjectival/participial) comparative patterns. As illustrated in quotation (1) above, Mitchell (1985) suggests that “the beginnings of periphrastic comparison are probably to be seen” in the participial constructions described in Section 2.1 above (Mitchell 1985: 84 [emphasis added]); however, he does not develop the issue further. A close look at the chronological distribution of the adjectival and participial periphrastic comparatives attested in my data may prove instructive in this respect (see Table 2.4 and Table 2.5; the total number of examples under consideration is provided in Table 2.2): Table 2.4. Participial and adjectival periphrastic constructions in OE2 Example
Translation
Work
Date/period
Swiþor geangsumod Ma scamigende Ma gyldende Ma geswenced Ma witnode Ma besmiten Ma hreosende Swiþor forsewen Swiþor beswicen Swiþor beswicen Ma gedafonade Ma gelæred Bet gelæred Swiþor gebrocede Swiþur underðied Swiþor bettra Ma gode Bet wyrðe
More vexed More ashamed More rewarded More troubled More punished More defiled More agitated More despised More deceived More deceived More suitable More learned More learned More afflicted More obedient More better More good More worthy
GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.OR. GREG.BO. GREG.OR. GREG.CP. BEDE.HE. BEDE.HE. BEDE.HE. CHRO.A. GREG.CP. FARM.RW. GREG.D. GREG.CP.
(c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c890, OE2) (c891, OE2) (c897, OE2) (850–950, OE2) (c875, OE2) (c897, OE2)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.15 (29)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
Table 2.5. Participial and adjectival periphrastic constructions in OE3 Example
Translation
Work
Date/period
Swiðor geswenct Swiðor afandod Swiþor gehalgod Swiðor byrnende Swiðor gegladod Swiðor gemærsod Swiðor forscyldgod Ma gelyfdon Ma gelyfdon Swiþor gewurðod Ma gestired More andlang Bet wyrðe Mare heare Swiðor eadmodra Bet wyrðe Ma fexede Ma unscyldige Ma wuldorful Ma wyrse Ma hludre
More troubled More experienced More dedicated More (being) burnt More contented More glorified More condemned More trusted More trusted More esteemed More moved More long More worthy More higher More humbler More worthy More hairy More virtuous More glorious More worse More loud
ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.HO. ÆLF.ME. WULF.HO. EADW.CP. ANON.BO. WULF.PO. ANON.NI. ÆLF.HO. CLA.WII. APUL.HB. DEFE.LS. DEFE.LS. DEFE.LS. CHRD.RU.
(950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (950–1050, OE3) (c1150, OE4–ME) (10th c., OE2-3) (950–1050, OE3) (9th c., OE2-3) (950–1050, OE3) (c1020, OE3) (c1050, OE3-4) (11th c, OE4) (11th c, OE4) (11th c, OE4) (c1050, OE3)
In OE2 (the period in which periphrastic forms are first attested in writing), the majority of cases feature participles (as opposed to unambiguous adjectives – of which there are only 3 examples (0.0008 tokens/thousand words); see the underlined forms in Table 2.4). By contrast, in OE3 the number of constructions with unambiguous adjectives has increased considerably (10 examples (0.003 tokens/thousand words) – see the underlined forms in Table 2.5). The chronological distribution of the examples indicates (a) that English periphrastic comparison was first attested in participial constructions and (b) that the spread of the construction from participles to adjectives started in OE2.26 One may argue that this spread was ultimately promoted by the ambiguous nature of the OE participles: I have suggested above that past participles possessed verbal characteristics already in Old English; at the same time, previous literature has shown that the English passive arose from a copula construction (cf. Visser 1973
. The lack of earlier data (due to the scarcity of surviving texts) makes it impossible to ascertain whether this spread started before the period 850–950.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.16 (30)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
or Traugott 1992 in Section 2.2 above),27 and that this development was not fully completed in OE. In other words, the early periphrastic comparatives could well be considered examples of ‘syntactic blends’ (cf. Jespersen 1909–49: 385ff.; Bolinger 2004 [1961]: 318). The lack of a clear boundary between the two constructions involved (i.e. copula construction/passive construction) may have over time favoured the gradual reanalysis of past participles as (more) adjectival elements.28 This, in its turn, may have led to the analogical spread of the periphrastic construction from (adjectival) participles to prototypical adjectives. Another scenario is, however, possible, i.e. that in which the spread of the construction from participles to prototypical adjectives was driven by the original adjectival import of the past participle.
. The evolution of the periphrastic comparative marker(s)29 . Introduction So far this chapter has concentrated on determining where English periphrastic comparative constructions come from. However, very little attention has been paid (here and in previous literature)30 to the adverbial particles that formed the earliest periphrastic comparatives, especially to the factors that may have led to the disappearance of two of them (bet and swiðor) and, consequently, to the establishment of ma (‘more’) as the prototypical analytic comparative marker. Table 2.1 and Table 2.2 showed that there was a difference in the frequency with which the three adverbs occurred in the comparative construction. Bet seemed to be the least used particle (with 11% of the total number of examples) in OE. Swiðor was attested in 39% of the cases, while ma was the most frequent marker, with 50% of the total number of forms analysed. Recent functionally-oriented studies (cf. Bybee & Schreibmann 1999 or Bybee & Hopper’s 2001 volume) have emphasised the role of frequency in language . The development of passives constructions out of copula constructions seems to be, crosslinguistically, a usual process (Haspelmath 1994: 167, 168). . Note, in this connection, Denison’s (2006: 302) comment on the fact that “categories may be cluster concepts” and that category changes may be the result of “stepwise acquisition of properties” as opposed to the simultaneous acquisition of the definitional characteristics of the new category. . I am very grateful to Belén Méndez-Naya for her comments on this section. . Note, for instance, that Mitchell’s (1985: 84) account of the particles does not go beyond the enumeration of the different linguistic variants available (e.g. ma, bet, swiðor).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.17 (31)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
variation and change. It not only underlies key linguistic concepts (cf. Haspelmath 2006 on the notion of markedness) but can also “effect linguistic behaviour” both synchronically and diachronically (Bybee & Hopper 2001: 10). In this connection, Bybee & Hopper (2001) point to the importance that frequency has in the formation of new constructions, noting that “the more often two elements occur in sequence the tighter will be their constituent structure” (Bybee & Hopper 2001: 14). Along the same lines, Krug (2003: 15) suggests that high linguistic frequency favours entrenchment (i.e. fixation in the mental lexicon), and therefore, that more entrenched or more frequent (morphological) elements tend to be more resistant to change and disappearance.31 Applying these ideas to the OE periphrastic markers, one may initially suggest that the disappearance of bet and swiðor as comparative markers may have been related to their (relative) lower degree of cognitive entrenchment as compared to ma – which in its turn may have had an impact on the degree of grammatical ‘fusion’ with the other constituent (i.e. participle or adjective) with which they formed the periphrastic comparative. This is, however, a very general claim that needs further substantiation. Previous research (Phillips 2001; Hare, Ford & Marslen-Wilson 2001) notes that frequency is often inextricably linked to the operation of other (cognitive, phonological, grammatical) factors in processes of variation and change. This may well be the case of the comparative markers – note that, so far it has only been stated that ma is the most frequent form among the available options, but no explanation as to why that is the case has been provided. With the aim of answering this question, an individual analysis of each of the comparative markers is given in Sections 3.1.1–3.1.3 below. .. Bet As noted above, bet, being the least frequent adverb, was the most likely candidate for disappearing as a comparative marker. According to the OED (cf. also Bosworth 1882:93), bet is originally an uninflected adverbial comparative stem from which the comparative adjective better derives.32 At the end of the OE period, bet(e)re (the neuter gender of the adjective) began to be used in the place of (adverbial) bet in certain constructions where it was dubious whether bet was an adjective or an adverb (as in hit is bet = ‘it is well/good’). The use of better gradually . High frequency has a ‘conservative’ effect only on morphosyntactic structures. By contrast, high frequency in phonological environments is a ‘progressive’ force, as it “causes the lenition and erosion of overt phonetic substance” (Krug 2003: 18). . The Gmc. comparative ending <-iz> of adverbial bet underwent several phonetic changes, with the result that, by the OE period, it either had been reduced to -e or lost in its entirety (see OED, bet, adv. and a., s.1).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.18 (32)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
spread to other environments until it finally ousted bet (c1600), probably helped by the fact that bet, due to the lack of the comparative suffix -er, was no longer a transparent comparative (see Table 2.6): Table 2.6. Bet/better in the OE and ME subperiods of the Helsinki Corpus OE2
OE3
OE4
HM1
HM2
HM3
HM4
Bet 10 (29%) 14 (39%) 4 (37% ) 22 (38%) 11 (20%) 6 (8%) 2 (2%) Better 25 (71%) 22 (61%) 7 (63% ) 36 (62%) 44 (80%) 69 (92%) 80 (98%) Total 35 (100%) 36 (100%) 11 (100%) 58 (100%) 55 (100%) 75 (100%) 82 (100%)
Factors other than morphosyntax may have also played a role in the gradual disappearance of the form in its function as a periphrastic comparative marker. Originally, bet conveyed a positive semantic load (bet = ‘of superior quality than the average’). A close look at Table 2.2 and Table 2.3 shows that bet is very much restricted in its scope to combinations with items in line with its original meaning; more in particular, with adjectives denoting positive value (the adjective wyrðe (‘worthy’) in all but one of my examples).33 This hypothesis is, nevertheless, tentative due to the low number of periphrastic comparatives with bet attested in my data (4 examples). .. Swiþor Swiþor is the comparative form of the degree adverb swiþe (from OE swiþ (‘strong’), meaning ‘very, extremely’ / ‘fast, quickly’). Mustanoja (1960: 325; cf. also Fischer 2000: 170) observes that swiþe was frequently used as an intensifier of adjectives, adverbs and verbs in OE and EME.34 In addition, Méndez-Naya (2003: 379) suggests that the intensifier function of swiþe “developed at a very early stage”, a fact that might have favoured the development of the adverb as a comparative marker. The general distribution of swiðor in the Helsinki Corpus35 indicates that it was first attested both as a comparative adverb and comparative marker (see examples (26)–(27) below) in OE2 (i.e. 850–950), and that it had (virtually) disappeared in either function by the second half of the 12th century (see Table 2.7): . There is only one case in which bet co-occurs with a participle (bet gelæred, ‘better/more learned’). Note however, that this participle (gelæred; PDE ‘learned’) also has positive connotations. . See Méndez-Naya (2003) for a corpus-based distribution of swiþe in intensifier function in OE and ME. . I have used the Helsinki Corpus for this analysis, as it allows a (relatively) balanced comparison of the distribution of any linguistic item throughout the early periods of the language.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.19 (33)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
Table 2.7. Development of swiþor in OE and ME (Helsinki Corpus) Swiþor
OE2 OE3 OE4 HM1 (no./1,000 words) (no./1,000 words) (no./1,000 words) (no./1,000 words)
Comp. adverb 16 (0.17) Comp. marker 3 (0.03)
44 (0.17) 2 (0.007)
12 (0.17) 1 (0.01)
3 (0.02) 1 (0.008)
(26) Sume him ondræadað earfoðu swiðor þonne hi þyrfen (TOR.GREG.BO.) “Some feared the troubles with him more greatly than they needed” (27) Ac hie wæron micle swiþor gebrocede on þæm þrim gearum mid ceapes cwilde & monna (TOR.CHRO.A.) “And they were much more afflicted in these three years by the destruction of cattle and people”
The disappearance of swiðor may be related to the general decrease (and eventual loss) of swiþe in ME. The Helsinki Corpus shows that swiþe was relatively frequent in OE (reaching its peak in OE4, see Table 2.8). By contrast, it started to lose ground steadily in HM2 (the first period in which I could not find any examples of swiðor in the Helsinki Corpus), until its complete disappearance by the end of the ME period. Table 2.8. Development of swiþe in OE and ME (Helsinki Corpus) OE2 OE3 OE4 HM1 HM2 HM3 HM4 (no./1,000 (no./1,000 (no./1,000 (no./1,000 (no./1,000 (no./1,000 (no./1,000) words) words) words) words) words) words) words) Swiþe 196 (2.1)
416 (1.6)
251 (3.7)
247 (2.2)
113 (1.2)
5 (0.02)
1 (0.004)
Furthermore, as in the case of bet, one may establish a link between the original meaning of swiðor and the linguistic items with which it combines as a degree marker. Thus, in Table 2.1 and Table 2.2, swiðor, perhaps due to its (relatively) verbal character, tends to combine mostly with participles (e.g. gebrocede (‘afflicted’), beswicen (‘deceived’); see also example (28) below): (28) For ðæm andbide & for ðæm geþylde me ðincð þæt he sie ðe swiðor forsewen “Because of his waiting and his resignation, it appears to me that he (was) therefore the more despised” (TOR.GREG.BO.)
.. Ma The case of ma is, however, different. As Table 2.1 and Table 2.2 illustrate, ma was the comparative particle that most frequently combined with both adjectives (e.g. ma gode, ma mærlecra) and participles (e.g. ma gelæred, ma gyldende).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.20 (34)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
One may then hypothesise that, after an initial period of competition between the three periphrastic markers, ma, the (semantically) more general particle (i.e. ma = ‘greater’), gained ground at the expense of the other two until it ousted them completely and established itself as the prototypical analytical comparative marker. Table 2.9 summarises the distribution of the three comparative adverbs in OE. Table 2.9. General distribution of periphrastic markers in OE Adverb
+ Adjective
+ Participle
Total
Ma Bet Swiðor
8 (42%) 3 (75%) 2 (14%)
11 (58%) 1 (25%) 12 (86%)
19 (100%) 4 (100%) 14 (100%)
.. Conclusion The study of the three early periphrastic markers shows that, unlike bet and swiðor, ma combined freely with both participles and adjectives. I would like to mention here Paradis’ (1997, 2001, 2003) model of semantic bidirectionality. Following previous cognitive research (e.g. Langacker 1987; Clausner & Croft 1999), Paradis suggests that the elements in a collocation exert pressure on one another and, in consequence, that the success/failure of the collocation will ultimately depend on whether harmony between the semantics of the collocates has been reached (Paradis 1997: 26, 66, 2001: 239). Applying this idea to the present study, one may suggest that it was the (more) general semantics of ma that made its collocation with participles and adjectives more ‘harmonious’ (and, possibly, frequent) and therefore, rendered it the most obvious candidate for grammaticalisation into the obligatory comparative particle.36 Another factor that may have led to the spread of ma as the preferred comparative marker is the fact the etymological connection between mara (‘PDE ‘more’) and mycel (PDE ‘much’, ‘great’) was no longer clear in OE: the two forms had formally diverged from one another to such an extent in OE that mara could no longer be connected to either mycel or the idea of ‘great’ (Olga Fischer, p.c.).
. The ways in which the rise and development of periphrastic comparatives relate to grammaticalisation theory will be discussed in Section 5 below.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.21 (35)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
. Latin influence on OE periphrastic comparatives . English periphrastic comparatives: A Latin borrowing? The results obtained so far indicate that periphrastic comparative forms are a native development. Note, however, that all adjectival periphrastic examples mentioned by Mitchell (1985: 84) come from works originally written in Latin. Likewise, 24 out of the 39 examples attested in my corpus are translations of Latin texts (see Table 2.10). Table 2.10. Summary of the translated OE periphrastic comparatives OE example
Translation
Work
Edition
Ma hreosende Swiþor beswicen Swiþor forsewen Swiþor beswicen Swiþur underðied Bet wyrðe Ma scamigende Swiþor geangsumod Ma gyldende Ma gode Ma besmiten Ma witnode Ma geswenced Swiþor bettra Ma gelæred Bet gelæred Ma gedafonade Ma wyrse Ma unscyltige Ma wuldorful Ma fexede37 Ma gestired Mare heare Ma hludre
More agitated More deceived More despised More deceived More obedient More worthy More sad More vexed More rewarded More good More defiled More punished More troubled More better More learned More learned More befitted More worse More innocent More glorious More hairy More moved More higherer More loud
GREG.OR. GREG.OR. GREG.BO. GREG.CP. GREG.CP. GREG.CP. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. GREG.D. FARM.RW. BEDE.HE. BEDE.HE. BEDE.HE. DEFE.LS. DEFE.LS. DEFE.LS. APUL.HB. CPS. ANON.NI. CHROD.RU.
Sweet 1883 Sweet 1883 Sedgefield 1899 Sweet 1871 Sweet 1871 Sweet 1871 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Hecht 1900 Skeat 1887 Miller 1890 Miller 1890 Miller 1890 Rhodes 1889 Rhodes 1889 Rhodes 1889 Cockayne 1864 Harsley 1889 Brown 1970 Napier 1916
. Cockayne (1874: xxxix) observes that the English Herbarium consists of two parts. The first part is a translation from the Latin Herbarium Apulei. The second part (where this example was found) was originally taken from a scientific tract by a Greek botanist called Dioskorides. According to the literature, this second part of the Herbarium was not drawn directly from Dioskorides but from a Latin text based on Dioskorides’ work instead (cf. Gunther 1934 for an English translation of the treatise). Unfortunately, this Latin manuscript was lost and it is there-
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.22 (36)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
This may weaken the hypothesis of a native origin of the periphrastic comparatives, as it would be possible to suggest that the periphrastic forms occurring in these OE texts were calques on Latin analytic comparative constructions. In order to investigate this possibility in more detail, a contrastive study of the OE periphrastic comparatives and their Latin original is necessary. But before turning to the results, a brief summary of the main characteristics of the Latin system of comparison may prove instructive. . The Latin comparative system: Some introductory remarks Like OE, Latin possessed an essentially binary comparative system with both inflectional and periphrastic strategies (the uncommon double comparative in Latin and OE is disregarded here). The inflectional comparative was formed by the addition of the suffix -or (when the adjective modified either masculine or feminine nouns) and -ius (for adjectives modifying neuter nouns) to the adjectival stem, while the periphrastic form pre-posed the adverb magis to the adjective in the positive degree. This option was usually preferred for adjectives of three endings (i.e. -us -a -um) with a vocalic stem (e.g. idoneus) due to phonetic and metrical reasons (Hofmann & Szantyr 1965: 165; Bassols de Climent 1967: 170; Leumann & Hofmann 1977: 498).38 According to Bassols de Climent (1967: 17), the periphrastic comparative gradually gained ground at the expense of its inflectional counterpart “sin razón alguna que lo justifique” (i.e. “without any obvious reason”) and prevailed as the most frequent comparative strategy in post-classical spoken Latin first and later in the Romance languages. It should also be noted here that in the post-classical period the adverbial intensifier plus sometimes replaced magis as a comparative marker (e.g. plus miser sim, i.e. ‘I am more miserable’; Hofmann & Szantyr 1965: 166). The second term of comparison was expressed in Latin in two ways; either by the postposition of the particle quam to the comparative adjective (e.g. Petrus altior quam Paulus est) or in ablative case without quam (Petrus altior Paulo est).39 fore impossible to determine whether the OE comparative correlates to a similar form in the text from which it was translated. The reading of Dioskorides’ original work (cf. Asulanus 1518) shows that the Greek manuscript does not contain any comparative structure in the passage under consideration. However, it is and it will remain uncertain whether the (lost) Latin version of Dioskorides’ work was either a literal translation or an adaptation of the Greek original text – in which case the (Latin) paragraph under analysis might have presented a comparative form. . Although with some exceptions, e.g. antiquus, antiquor. . In addition, there were some irregular inflectional comparatives: bonus:melius (good: better); malus:peius (bad:worse).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.23 (37)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
. Analysis of the data .. The Latin original examples and their English translation Table 2.11 summarises the results obtained in the comparison between the OE examples and their Latin source. Only 6 out of the 24 OE examples under consideration (numbers 2, 5, 6, 13, 14 and 15 in the table) were literal translations of the Latin original form. In 3 of these examples (2, 5 and 6 in the table), however, the OE text consists of glosses written above the Latin original. This fact may have contributed to the structural correlation between the English rendering and the Latin original construction, as in these cases the aim of the translation is not to achieve a coherent sentence but just to create good correspondences at word-level (see (29) to (31) below). (29) LAT. plus erubescens uultum hominum quam Dei iudicium metuens (GREG.D., Vogüé 1978: 94) OE (forþon þe heo wæs) ma scamigende for manna onsyne, þonne heo wære þone godes dom ondrædende (TOR.GREG.D., Hecht 1900: 72) “(because she was) more (being) ashamed of the face of men than fearing the judgement of God” (Gardner 1911: 38) (30) LAT. quanto magis melior est homo oue itaque licet sabbatis bene facere OE hu miccle mae þ swiþor bettra is monn þonne scep forþon is alefed on reste dagum god to doanne (TOR.FARM.RW., Skeat 1887: 99) “how much [more advanced] and more better is a man than a sheep because (he) is allowed to do good on Sabbath” (31) LAT. ordinavit virum magis ecclesiasticis disciplines institutum (. . . ) quam in sæculi rebus strenuum (Moberly 1869: 216) OE þa gehadode he sume mon, se wæs ma in ciriclecum þeodscipum (. . . ) gelæred þon he from wære in worulde þingum (TOR.BEDE.HE.) “he consecrated a man who was more learned in ecclesiastical discipline (. . .) than was energetic in the things of this world”
There is also another example in which the OE comparative corresponds to a comparative in Latin. The Latin form is, however, a comparative of inferiority and, consequently, irrelevant for the purposes of the present analysis (see (32) below – which corresponds to example 3 in Table 2.11):40
. Note that the comparative of inferiority in English does not display variation between inflectional and periphrastic comparative strategies.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.24 (38)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 2.11. Summary of the OE translations and the corresponding Latin originals
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Example
Translation
Lat. original
Translation
Ma hreosende Ma scamigende Swiþor beswicen Swiðor forsewen Ma gelæred Swiþor bettra Bet gelæred Bet wyrðe Ma gyldende Swiður underðied Ma gode Swiþor geangsumod Ma wyrse Ma wuldorful Ma unscyldige Ma gestured Ma geswenced Ma besmiten Ma witnode Ma gedafonade Ma hludre Mare heare Ma fexede Swiþor beswicen
More agitated More ashamed More deceived More despised More learned More better More learned More worthy More (being) rewarded More obedient More good More vexed More worse More glorious More innocent More moved More troubled More defiled More punished More suitable More loud More higher More hairy More deceived
Magis quam Plus erubescens Minus quam (OE addition) Magis institutum Magis melior Aptius erudiri (OE addition) Debitores (OE addition) Plus meminerunt (OE addition) Magis peius Magis gloriosum Magis innocentes Movebor amplius Noli fatigari Amplius inquinatur Amplius puniantur Magis quam Excelsa (OE addition) n/a41 (OE adition)
More than Being more ashamed Less than — More learned More better Be greatly learned — Debters — To consider oneself more — More worse More glorious More innocent To be moved more Do not be troubled Be defiled more Be punished more More than Loud — n/a —
(32) LAT. Non minus arte Alexadri superata quam virtute Macedonium “(They went back) overcome no less by Alexander’s craft than by the virtue of the Macedonian people” OE þe swiðor beswicen for Alexandres searewe þone for his gefeohrte “(they were) more deceived by Alexander’s craft than by his fight” (TOR.GREG.OR.)
At this point, one should bear in mind that many of these examples come from translations made by King Alfred and his circle of scribes. As Sedgefield notes, King Alfred’s translations are “by no means what would in these days be called ‘literal”’ (1899: xxv), and therefore, it is not surprising to find many cases in which a whole paragraph is paraphrased rather than rendered word by word in OE (compare, for instance, the Latin and OE preface to Bede’s Ecclesiastical history, cf. Moberly 1869; King 1930; or the OE translation of Agustine’s Soliloquies; Endter 1922). . See fn. 37 above.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.25 (39)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
This is what seems to happen in 6 of my comparative examples (numbers 4, 8, 10, 12, 22 and 24 in Table 2.11), where the sentence/paragraph in which the OE periphrastic comparative occurs is a textual addition to the Latin original text. See, for instance, (33) below, where the zero symbol (i.e. ø) in the Latin original corresponds to the sentence in bold in the OE translations – which is where the comparative bet wyrðe (‘more worthy’) appears: (33) LAT. quam is qui hos nimirum regeret, quos ipse creaverat? ø (. . .) exemplum se sequentibus praebens, rex fieri noluit “who could rule men without sin but the man who created them? ø (Christ) eager to offer an example to his followers. . .” OE Hwa meahte ieð monnum rædan butan scylde, ðonne se ðe hi gescop? Ne fleah he ðy rice ðy his anig monn bet wyrðe wære, ac he wolde us ða bisene astellan “Who could easier rule men without sin than he who created them? He did not leave the kingdom because any man was more worthy of it, but he wished to set us an example” (TOR.GREG.CP.)
Another type of addition is the one exemplified in (34) and (35) below. In this case, the Latin original (which does not formally convey the idea of degree) is translated in OE as a comparative (4 examples; numbers 9, 11, 17 and 21 in Table 2.11). 42 (34) LAT. “Quare tardasti pater? Noli fatigari, quia iam defunctus est” (Vogüé 1978: 112) “Why were you late, father? Don’t be troubled because he is already dead” OE la fæder, to hwon latedest þu? nelle þu nu beon ma geswenced, forþon þe he is forðfered” (TOR.GREG.D.) “why were you late, father? Don’t be more troubled now, for he is dead” (35) LAT. quoniam quamuis cantilene sonus in aliis officiis excelsa soleat fieri voce “because however the sound of the song in other services is used to occur with loud voice” OE for þam þeah hit an oðrum þenungum gewuna sy þæt ma hludre stefne bruce “because it is a habit of other services the use of a more loud voice” (TOR.CHRD.RU.)
Apart from literal translations and vernacular additions, I found 6 examples where the OE periphrastic form conveyed a meaning similar to that of the Latin construc-
. Observe that in example (34) the adjective excelsa is semantically an implicit superlative and carries the idea of “a very high degree”.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.26 (40)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
tion, although the Latin form was not formally a comparative adjective. These examples conform to two main Latin syntactic patterns. The first pattern (2 examples) involves the use of the (adverbial) particle magis (“more”) in comparative function (i.e. [v. + magis (quam)], see (36)–(37) below, examples 1 and 20 in Table 2.11): (36) LAT. si Romanæ republicæ moles nunc magis imbecilitate propia senectutis, quam alienis concussae viribus contremiscunt “if the bases of the Roman Republic are sadly agitated more due to the weakness which is characteristic of the elder age than for the strength of foreign people who beat it” OE ðæt ægþer ge hio self ge hiere anweald is ma hreosende for ealddome þonne of æniges cyninges niede (TOR.GREG.OR.) “that both it (the Roman Republic) itself and its power is more feelingsorrow (more being agitated) due to age than for need of any king” (37) LAT. Under multis visum et sæpe dictum est, quia talis animi virum, episcopum magis quam regem ordinary deceret (Moberly 1869: 234) “In the eyes of many and often was said that a man of such soul, bishop more than king ought to be consecrated” OE þonon monegum was gesewen 7 oft cweden, þaette swelces modes wer ma gedafone beon to biscope gehalgad, þonne cyning wære (TOR.BEDE.HE.) “for this reason many thought, and often repeated, that a man of such a character was more suitable for consecration as bishop than for being king”
The second pattern (4 examples; 7, 16, 18 and 19 in Table 2.11) is constituted by a Latin passive verb followed by a comparative adverb ([pass. + comp. adv.], see (38)–(40) below): (38) LAT. Et enim ipse est deus meus et salutaris meus audiutor meus non movebor amplius (Harsley 1889: 102) “And he himself is my god, my saviour, my help and I will not be moved more” OE He is god myn 7 helo min fultumend min ne beo ic ma gestired “He is my god and my saviour, my help and I will not be more moved” (TOR.EADW.CP.) (39) LAT. ut isti uideat mala quae caueant, illi uero amplius puniatur “in order that they see the evil things that they ought to avoid and those evil (people) being punished more” (Vogüé 1978: 134) OE 7 þas beoð þe ma witnode þe hi noldon heom bewarnian þa helle witu, þe hi gesawon 7 ongæton (TOR.GREG.D.)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.27 (41)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
“that (the others) to be the more punished, in that they would not take heed of these torments, which they both knew and saw” (Gardner 1911: 132) (40) LAT. quanto amplius inquinatur stulta locutione. (Vogüé 1978: 324) “how much more it is defiled with foolish speech” OE swa mycle swa he ma besmiten byð mid þy dysilicran spræce (TOR.GREG.D.) “how much it is more defiled with foolish speech” (Gardner 1911: 132)
.. Conclusion The results obtained from the analysis carried out in Section 4.3.1 above provide support for the hypothesis that English comparatives are not Latin borrowings but a native development. Periphrastic forms not only occur in OE translations of Latin original texts, but they also appear in vernacular texts (39% of the total number of examples analysed) written approximately in the same period in which the translations were made. Moreover, only 6 out of the 24 instances of the translated OE periphrastic forms are verbal calques on the Latin original comparative; the majority of the (OE) examples (71%) being either vernacular additions to the Latin original text or the result of a non-literal translation of Latin structures which are not comparatives of superiority. I suggested above that English periphrastic forms could have well resulted from the gradual reanalysis of a syntactic blend (i.e. passive and copula construction), where the (adjectival-verbal) participle gradually becomes the head of an adjective phrase and takes the pre-posed intensifier as a modifier. This syntactic pattern would have extended by analogy from participles to true adjectives later on. Now, taking into consideration the relatively most frequent Latin construction rendered as a periphrastic comparative in OE (that exemplified in (38) to (40) above, i.e. an inflectional passive modified by an adverbial intensifier), one might be inclined to argue that this kind of Latin construction had an influence on the rise of the early periphrastic forms in English. This however does not seem to be a very plausible option, as the passive in Latin was formed synthetically and not by the combination of an auxiliary verb and a participle as is the case of English. The adverb in Latin did not have a participial form to modify and, consequently, it could not have had an influence on the interpretation of the participle as an adjective in the English passive construction. The occurrence of adverbial intensifiers other than PDE more as comparative particles also seems to weaken the hypothesis of a foreign origin of the periphrastic comparative – at least in the sense that it invalidates the possibility that the morphosyntactic structure of English periphrastic comparatives is a lexical calque on Latin analytic forms. In addition, as Table 2.2 shows, the vernacular examples of
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.28 (42)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
previous sections mostly come from texts which can be broadly classified as religious tracts. One may argue that the influence of Latin as a prestige language may have been more noticeable in religious and political domains, and therefore, that religious writers might have been prone to incorporate Latin features in their works when they wrote in the vernacular. At the same time, one of the factors that may have led these authors to write in English instead of in Latin may have been the need to reach all kinds of people, even the most illiterate ones.43 To the extent that this was the case, using a structure that was not available in English would clash with this aim. Sound as these arguments are, the situation turns out to be rather more complicated (see Section 5 and Ch. 3 below).
. Periphrastic comparison and contact-induced grammatical change The idea that underlies the suggestions made in Section 4.3.2 above (i.e. that English periphrastic comparatives is not the result of Latin influence) is that calquing is the only possible outcome of language contact. However, recent literature on contact linguistics suggests otherwise (cf. Thomason & Kaufmann 1988; SilvaCorvalán 1993; Aikhenvald 2003; Heine & Kuteva 2003, 2005) for, together with calquing (or “form-meaning transfers”), transfer of the following linguistic material is also possible: a. Form, that is, sounds or combinations of sounds b. Meanings (including grammatical meanings or functions) or combinations of meanings (. . .) c. Syntactic relations, that is, the order of meaningful elements d. Any combination of (a) through (d) (adapted from Heine & Kuteva 2005: 2) Factor (b) seems to be most interesting as regards the present investigation, for it suggests that a language can replicate a concept/meaning/function from another language without copying or adapting the form that is associated with it. As one of their many examples, Heine & Kuteva (2005) mention the case of Malinche Mexicano. Classical Mexicano speakers usually formed passive and impersonal constructions by adding -l¯o, -¯o or -ohua. However, due to intense contact with Spanish (which uses the third person reflexive pronoun se as an impersonal passive strategy), Malinche Mexicano has seen the rise of an impersonal construction . For instance, Ælfric claims to use a simple language in order to reach a wider – and less learned – audience (Godden 1992: 521).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.29 (43)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
with the third person native reflexive pronoun -mo – a pattern that was very much restricted in use before the contact situation with Spanish (Heine & Kuteva 2005: 67; from Hill & Hill 1986). The spread of this construction took place first in verbs borrowed from Spanish, then to some etymologically Mexicano verbs that did not take reflexive pronouns and finally, to all verbs taking reflexive markers. Heine & Kuteva (2005) thus argue that the new impersonal construction in Malinche Mexicano is the result of contact-induced replication, where “mo- has been . . . generalized to an impersonal use pattern ‘precisely equivalent in meaning to Spanish impersonals”’ (Heine & Kuteva 2005: 67; from Hill & Hill 1986: 292). Applying the same line of reasoning to the present case-study, one may argue that the periphrastic construction in English could be understood as the conceptual replication (or transfer) of the Latin comparative strategies through the use of the language’s own structures. Heine & Kuteva (2005) also observe that [O]ne of the most ubiquitous phenomena characterizing [contact-induced] grammatical replication concerns minor use patterns, that is, pieces of discourse that are of low frequency of use and confined to use in highly restricted contexts. Such minor use patterns can be activated and gradually develop into major use patterns, being used more often and in novel contexts, and becoming functionally equivalent to some major use pattern or category of the model language (Heine & Kuteva 2005: 263)
In addition, they suggest that processes of grammatical replication are regular and in accordance with principles of grammaticalisation (Heine & Kuteva 2005: 80, which they describe as follows: extension, i.e. the rise of novel grammatical meanings when linguistic expressions are extended to new contexts (contact-induced reinterpretation) desemantization (or “semantic bleaching”), i.e. loss (or generalization) in meaning context decategorialization, i.e. loss in morphosyntactic properties characteristic of lexical or other less grammaticalized forms erosion (or “phonetic reduction”), i.e. loss in phonetic substance
To what extent can these claims be said to lie behind the rise of periphrastic comparatives in English? The data from the Toronto Corpus show that the pattern swiþor, ma and bet + participle was available in OE, both in translations and (even more frequently) in native texts. Furthermore, with the benefit of hindsight (cf. also Kytö 1996 or Kytö & Romaine 1997), we can see how the OE periphrastic comparative pattern spread over time and became one of the main comparative strategies in English. Put differently, the development of periphrastic comparative forms in OE seems to fit in with the developments that Heine & Kuteva (2005) consider frequent pathways of contact-induced change; i.e. “a minor use pattern,”
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.30 (44)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
which through frequency of use eventually develops into a “major use pattern” and finally, into a grammatical construction (see Table 2.12). Table 2.12. From minor to major use patterns (from Heine & Kuteva 2005: 46) Stage Frequency 0 I
II
Context
Meaning
Low frequency Restricted Weakly grammaticalized Increase in frequency Extension to new contexts An additional, more grammatical meaning may emerge in the new contexts High frequency Generalized Generalization of the new grammatical meaning
One should also note that the development of periphrastic comparison in English seems to follow some44 of the grammaticalisation parameters put forward by Heine & Kuteva (2005); i.e. extension (the pattern spread from participial adjectives to fully-fledged adjectives) and desemantisation (Section 3.1 above shows that the initial comparative particles – swiþor, ma, bet – had different lexical meanings). Standard literature on grammaticalisation also points to a process of ‘fixation’ or ‘obligatorification’ of the grammaticalising elements (cf. Lehmann 1995) – which in the case of periphrastic comparatives would be manifested by the eventual reduction of the periphrastic comparative markers to more (ma). Furthermore, previous literature on language contact (Trudgill 1983: 103–105; cf. Thomason & Kaufman 1988) suggests that changes from synthetic to analytic structures are developments that evidence the ‘foreignisation’ (using Thomason & Kaufman’s terms) of a language.45 Finally, although contact induced grammatical replication as described by Heine & Kuteva (2005: 13) “is most likely to occur if there is a large degree of intensive and extensive bilingualism” – a situation that does not apply to the English-Latin contact in OE times – research shows that contact-induced grammatical changes can arise when the model46 language is only available through the written medium, “in particular if the latter [i.e. the model . As Heine & Kuteva (2005: 165) observe, not all linguistic items undergoing a grammaticalisation process need to fulfil all grammaticalisation parameters. . In this connection, McWorther (2002: 248) mentions the presence of “comparative and superlative suffixes” (in other words, inflectional forms) as characteristic grammatical features of Germanic languages. . In Heine & Kuteva’s (2005) model, the “model language” is the language exerting influence over one another – which is called “replica” language.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.31 (45)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
language] is considered to represent a more attractive religion and/or a more powerful civilization” (Heine & Kuteva 2005: 250). This seems to be the case of Latin in OE times (see Section 4.3.2 above). One should nevertheless bear in mind that there are a number of arguments against the pro-Latin explanation of the rise of English periphrastic forms. First, it has been argued above that the status of periphrastic comparison in OE is that of a ‘minor use pattern.’ But whereas Heine & Kuteva (2005) suggest that, in contact-induced changes, it is the influence of the model language that makes minor language patterns shift into major ones (see Table 2.12), no such notable increase of the fully-fledged adjectival periphrastic forms (as well as the participial ones) is observed in OE texts that have survived until the present day, even though the (written) influence of Latin on OE dates at least from King Alfred’s times (OE2). As previous scholarship has observed (Mustanoja 1960; Kytö & Romaine 1997), the increase of the periphrastic forms does not take place until the LME period – when the influence of French is most notable. With this I am not willing to claim that Latin may not have had any influence on OE periphrastic form, but instead I would like to point out that the evidence does not seem to support fully the idea that Latin influence is the force (or, at least, the major force) behind the establishment of periphrastic forms as major use comparative patterns. Second, I also noted that contact induced grammatical replication follows, according to Heine & Kuteva (2005; cf. also Heine & Kuteva 2003), four main grammaticalisation parameters. But, in this connection, it should also be borne in mind that the same parameters apply to other, language internal, grammaticalisation processes. Third, as previous studies have shown (Thomason & Kaufman 1988: 58ff.; Thomason 2005 [2003]: 688; Heine & Kuteva 2005: 22ff.), in many cases it is very difficult to determine when grammatical transfer is a result of language contact or could instead have simply occurred as a result of universal tendencies of linguistic change. In this connection, Thomason (2005 [2003]: 688) states that: [C]ontact between languages. . . is a source of linguistic change whenever a change occurs that would have been unlikely, or at least less likely, to occur outside a specific contact situation
Further detail is provided by Heine & Kuteva (2005: 33) when they claim that: If there is a linguistic property shared by two languages M and R, and these languages are immediate neighbors and/or are known to have been in contact with each other for an extended period of time, and x is also found in languages genetically related to M but not in languages genetically related to R, then we hypothesize that this is an instance of contact-induced transfer, more specifically, that x has been transferred from M to R.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.32 (46)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Coming back to the topic of the present investigation, it was noted before that the development of analytic comparison was considered by some previous scholars (e.g. Trudgill 1983) as contact-induced change. Heine & Kuteva (2005: 198) observe that this type of change is indeed the result of language contact in the case of the Balkans Sprachbund; however, they also suggest that is “a crosslinguistically common” phenomenon – in other words, that it could also be the result of universal tendencies of change (cf., in this respect, Britain & Sudbury 2002; Cremona 2002). In fact, in previous work, they (Heine & Kuteva 2002: 329) identify the meaning of ‘exceed’ (closely related to the meaning of more, cf. Heine & Kuteva (2002: 124) on Igbo and Margi languages) as one of the possible (Universal) sources for the grammaticalisation of patterns into comparative constructions. Furthermore, the table that Thomason & Kaufman (1988: 316–317) provide of “simplification and foreignization in modern Germanic languages” shows that not all Germanic languages have developed a periphrastic comparative structure (e.g. Saterland, East Frisian or Standard High German, although Thomason & Kaufman (1988) do not pronounce themselves clearly in this respect; Standard Dutch, North Low German and Mecklen-burgish) even though they have undergone, either directly or indirectly, the influence of a Romance language like French.47 Last but not least, as recorded in Table 2.12, Heine & Kuteva (2005) suggest that contact-induced grammatical transfer most often translates into an increase in use and the eventual grammaticalisation of infrequent parameters that already exist in the replica language (contact-induced use patterns do not normally appear ex-nihilo, cf. Heine & Kuteva 2005: 45). Technically speaking, then, the original pattern is a native structure, which the influence of a language in contact renders more frequent. See, in this connection, Heine & Kuteva (2005: 266): Language contact can and frequently does trigger or influence the development of grammar in a number of ways. . .there is reason to assume that language in contact in general and grammatical replication in particular may accelerate grammatical change, and in fact quite a number of examples that we reviewed might have occurred independently of language contact but took place presumably more rapidly as a result of contact. (Heine & Kuteva 2005: 265–266)
Given the lack of speakers and the limitations of the extant texts, it is difficult to ascertain the status of the periphrastic comparative form in OE with total confidence – yet the fact that examples of periphrastic forms can be found in native OE texts (as opposed to translations) seems to provide support for the claim that periphrastic comparison is ultimately a native construction. . Note that for some languages (i.e. North Low German, Mecklen-burgish, Standard High German), Thomason & Kaufman (1988: 316–317) indicate that such contact with French was “moderate”.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.33 (47)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
Finally, the fact that one can find instances of periphrastic comparatives with prototypical adjectives in OE (before the Norman Conquest and therefore, before the influence of French on English became strong) rules out the hypothesis of a French origin of periphrastic comparison mentioned at the beginning of this chapter (Section 1 above). Indirect support for this claim is provided by Fischer (1992a: 68), who states that constructions introduced purely for reasons of prestige tend not to acquire a permanent status in the syntactic component of the language. This, however, does not preclude the possibility that French may have had an influence on the development of periphrastic comparatives (see Ch. 3 below).
. Motivation for the rise of English periphrastic comparatives So far I have discussed different aspects of the origin and the morpho-syntactic configuration of English periphrastic comparatives. The next step of the investigation will be to explore the reason(s) for their coming into the language. Mustanoja (1960: 279; cf. also Kytö & Romaine 1997: 330) mentions some factors that may have led to the rise and spread of periphrastic comparatives; namely, the supposed analytic tendency of ME as compared to OE, certain rhythmical considerations (especially important in poetry) and the need of the speakers for emphasis and clarity. It could be argued that the (supposed) tendency of ME towards analyticity may have contributed to the spread of periphrastic adjectival forms but not to their rise, since one can find (adjectival) periphrastic comparatives already in OE – when this analytic tendency does not seem to be fully operative yet. In any case, it is worth noting that one should not apply the label ‘analytic’ to the overall structure of ME, as this reflects the conventional (and inaccurate) use of the terms ‘synthetic’ and ‘analytic’. According to standard accounts, a construction X is more analytical than another construction Y, if, both constructions having approximately the same grammatical content, the constituent elements of construction X show a greater morphological and phonological autonomy than those of Y (Vincent 1997: 101). Linguists have traditionally concluded from this that a language can be considered more analytic than another if it possesses a higher number of analytic constructions, and vice-versa (Mustanoja 1960: 279). However, as Schwegler (1994) argues, measuring the analyticity or syntheticity of a language as such is not an easy task. Firstly, the traditional method for determining whether a language is either analytic or synthetic (i.e. Greenberg’s morpheme- and word- calculation system) was found to be highly problematic in cross-linguistic research (see Schwegler 1994: 113 for a brief description of this method). Secondly, ‘analytic’ and ‘synthetic’ are relative terms that designate the end-poles of a continuum along which
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.34 (48)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
grammatical constructions (not entire languages) can be compared. Convincing arguments against the traditional view can be found in Vincent (1997: 99–105). As he points out, Romance languages can be considered both analytic and synthetic. They qualify as analytic in terms of their nominal and verbal morphology when compared to Latin. By contrast, they are synthetic languages when their tense, aspect, number and gender marking systems are compared to those of languages such as English. The influence of the second factor (rhythm) on the rise of periphrastic forms does not seem a very plausible option either (at least as far as my data is concerned): rhythmical considerations, as Mustanoja says, are especially important in poetry; however, the influence of rhythm in prose texts (from which the bulk of the examples presented here is taken) appears not to be particularly relevant. More interesting (and, to date, subject to less counterarguments than the previous ones) is the last suggestion; namely, that the appearance of periphrastic forms in the language is due to the speakers’ need for emphasis and clarity. In keeping with this idea, one might hypothesise that at some point (when inflectional forms were the only comparative strategy available in the language), speakers felt that they did not clearly express the idea of degree, and therefore they looked for a new way for doing so (see, in this connection, Haspelmath’s (1993) comments on morphological opacity in Ch. 7, Section 7 below). Now, the lack of comparative distinctiveness of inflectional forms could well have been influenced by the decline of the Old English system of inflections – which, as McWorther (2002) convincingly argues, was in all probability influenced by the contact between Old English speakers and the Scandinavian tribes. Thus, following Lass (1992: 113), McWorther (2002: 255) observes that the loss of nominal inflections was faster in the north and the east of the country – in other words, the places in which the Scandinavian settlements were concentrated. In this context, the (participial) periphrastic construction was the most suitable means for conveying the said comparative meaning, firstly because the participle could perform an analogous function to that of any prototypical adjective, and, secondly, because the comparative marker (ma, bet, swiþor) was an independent morpheme that could be easily stressed (or, at least, more easily than the -er morpheme of inflectional forms) in order to highlight the idea of degree (this suggestion is supported by Curme 1931: 504 and, more recently, by Mondorf 2003 for PDE periphrastic forms). The rise of periphrastic comparatives in English may thus be explained as a process of grammaticalisation (cf. Heine, Claudi & Hünnemeyer 1991; Hopper & Traugott 2003 [1993]), understanding the concept of grammaticalisation in two slightly different yet related senses. It is a process of grammaticalisation in the (narrow) sense that the collocation [intensifier + participle/adjective] became a standard grammatical construction for expressing comparison. The rise of
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.35 (49)
Chapter 2. The origin of English periphrastic comparatives
periphrastic forms can also be considered the result of a grammaticalisation process in a broader sense, i.e. an old inflectional form (i.e. the comparative suffix -er) loses (part of) its expressive potential and a new, more emphatic and transparent periphrastic form is introduced in order to perform the same function. Against this suggestion, one may argue that in ‘standard’ grammaticalisation processes, the old form is gradually ousted by the new construction until its virtual disappearance – which is obviously not what happened in the case of comparative constructions.48 However, the historical re-establishment of inflectional comparatives does not preclude the possibility of considering the rise of periphrastic comparatives the result of a grammaticalisation process. Fischer (2003) convincingly argues that there is not a fixed set of parameters of grammaticalisation but that they vary according to the “circumstances of the language or its grammar under investigation” (2003: 469). Furthermore, her research shows that not all grammaticalisation processes necessarily go all the way to completion. They can be interrupted at any point – as may have been the case in the grammaticalisation of inflectional comparatives.
. Concluding remarks The chapter set out to investigate two main issues concerning the history of adjectival periphrastic comparatives; namely, their date of appearance in the language and the question as to where they come from. As for the first issue (the date of origin of periphrastic forms), the data showed that periphrastic comparatives appeared around the second half of the ninth century, initially as a result of the combination participles with the adverbial intensifiers swiðor, ma and bet. The answer to the second question seemed to be less straightforward. The results (a) showed that periphrastic forms are not a lexical calque on Latin comparative structures and (b) suggested that the initial comparative pattern (i.e. swiðor, ma and bet + participle/adjective) was of native origin and that it may well have spread and become one of the ‘standard’ comparative constructions of the language due to language contact. This idea will be explored further in Ch. 3 below. The chapter also dealt with the conditions under which these periphrastic comparative forms originated and explored aspects of the early history of the periphrastic comparative that were not considered in previous studies. Firstly, it investigated the reasons that led to the spread of ma as a comparative particle at . Inflectional comparison is very much used in PDE; Kytö & Romaine’s (1997: 335) research suggests that they have been on the increase in the modern period – at least in the spoken language.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:18
F: CI29902.tex / p.36 (50)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
the expense of the other two OE comparative markers bet and swiðor. Secondly, it critically examined the claims put forward in previous scholarship concerning the appearance of periphrastic forms and suggested that their rise may be related to what that these earlier accounts have described as the “speakers’ need for emphasis and clarity” (Kytö & Romaine 1997), i.e. a possible (partial) loss of comparative force of inflectional forms due to the general weakening of the OE morphological system.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.1 (51)
chapter
French influence and the spread of periphrastic comparatives in English
.
Introduction: French vs. English in medieval times49
Although it has recently been suggested (Iglesias-Rábade 1992: 16; Burnley 1992: 423) that the religious and political relations established between Normandy and the Anglo-Saxon kings resulted in the arrival of French culture in England long before the Conquest,50 it is commonly accepted that the year 1066 marks the beginning of the influence of the French language and culture on England. The linguistic situation of medieval England seemed to attract the attention of historians in the first half of the twentieth century. These studies can be grouped into two main schools, the literary and the historical, according to the nature of their source materials. On the basis of an analysis of ME literary texts, scholars belonging to the literary tradition (Vising 1923; Galbraith 1941; Legge 1950) suggested that AngloNorman gradually imposed itself during the years following the Conquest, with the result that, from the second half on the twelfth century, it superseded English in both spoken and written domains (Vising 1923: 18). By contrast, scholars coming from the historical school (Clover 1888; Woodbine 1943; Wilson 1943; Berndt 1969) aimed at reconstructing the linguistic history of medieval England from both the records of historians and a number of ME official documents (cf. IglesiasRábade 1992: 35; Dalton-Puffer 1996: 5). There existed some discrepancies among the proponents of the historical tradition with respect to the significance of the
. Unless otherwise stated, the emphasis (i.e. italics/bold) in the examples provided through the chapter is mine (VGD). . English Benedictine congregations tried to adapt to the religious reforms promoted from France. In political spheres, the matches between Anglo-Saxons and Normans (e.g. the three daughters of Edward the elder married in France; likewise, King Ethelred married a Norman noblewoman in 1002) strengthened the ties between the two cultures and led to a gradual gallicisation of the Anglo-Saxon court (Iglesias-Rábade 1992: 16).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.2 (52)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
loss of Normandy (1204)51 yet in general terms, they agreed that, although French (or better, Anglo-Norman) had a noticeable influence in literary, political and economical circles during the middle ages, it was always a minority language (i.e. that of the upper classes) that “had neither ousted English nor become dominant” in England (Berndt 1969: 388). A similar opinion is found in recent literature on the social situation of English in medieval times (Blake 1992: 4ff.; Smith 1992: 48ff.; Skaffari 1998: 75). According to it, Latin was the language of culture and government during the tenth and twelfth century (Blake 1992: 5; Smith 1992: 48) and it remained the vehicle of scholarship up until the sixteenth century (cf. the ‘Inkhorn controversy’). During the twelfth century, however, Anglo-Norman, “the aristocratic [French] vernacular” (Blake 1992: 5), took over as the preferred language of literature. AngloNorman would give way to Anglo-French as the language of the government and administration from the thirteenth century onwards.52 By contrast, English was the language spoken by the majority of the population, although the conquest meant its virtual disappearance from the written medium during the eleventh and twelfth centuries (Smith 1992: 49).53 Some written records in English appear in the second half of the thirteenth century, however, it is not until the beginning of the following century that English could be perceived as a challenge to the prestige of French (Smith 1992: 49) – and, by the end of the ME period, English seems to have taken over all the (formal) environments formerly occupied by it. One may wonder about the causes behind this change. Görlach (1986: 336; cf. also Skaffari 1998: 75; Hornero-Corisco 1997: 34) observes that the Normanspeaking population in England was low (2–10% of the total)54 and therefore, that it started to learn English in order to be able to carry out business with the English. It is difficult to point to a specific date for this shift; yet it seems to have occurred . According to some scholars (e.g. Clover 1888:16), the influence of French on English was most noticeable in the years between the Conquest and the loss of Normandy, for in this period French was still the native language of both the conquerors and their descendants. After this period (1204 until the end of the reign of Edward III), French gradually became a foreign language, studied only for the sake of fashion (cf. also Burnley 1992: 427). By contrast, other historians such as Woodbine (1943: 410) contend that the influence of French thrived just after the loss of the said territory. . Note, however, Rothwell’s (2000) point about the fact that mixing of languages (i.e. Latin, French and English) in Late ME administrative documents seemed to be “a recognised policy” (Rothwell 2000: 230). . Smith (1992: 49) and Blake (1992: 6) observe, however, that OE manuscripts were still copied in some monastical scriptoria after the Conquest. . According to Hornero-Corisco (1997: 43), these upper classes were constituted by the secular clergy, the regular clergy and a small minority of the urban oligarchy.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.3 (53)
Chapter 3. French influence
relatively early – Smith (1992: 50) observed that English was spoken in some noble households in the early twelfth century – and to have been fostered by the combination of the following factors: (a) the loss of Normandy in the early thirteenth century, (b) the development of continental (Parisian) French as the language of social prestige, (c) the Black Death, (d) the appearance of the cities and (e) the Hundred Years war (see, among others, Lambley 1920: 18; Burnley 1992: 426–428; Iglesias-Rábade 1992: 183–184; Crespo-García 2000: 24ff.). All in all, one may conclude that the overall linguistic situation of medieval England was one of diglossia (cf. Dalton-Puffer 1996: 6; Schendl 2000: 78ff.). English was restricted to colloquial and familiar registers, whereas French was considered prestigious and used in public, formal contexts. In this connection, one may bear in mind that, notwithstanding the importance that it had in intellectual, political and administrative environments, (Anglo-) French never acquired the status of native language. By contrast, it was restricted to the uppermost (foreign) social classes, who gradually acquired English as a second language.
. Middle English: A creole? The previous section emphasised the multilingual character of medieval England,55 where Latin, French and English competed for dominance in public and private spheres (cf. Trotter’s (2000) volume). Note, however, that, in comparison to French and English, Latin was at the time a ‘dead’ language whose influence on the (English) vernacular was mostly reduced to specific written genres and domains. The impact of French on English is, and has been, a more contentious issue. The interest in the status and the making of Middle English revived in the late twentieth century with the publication of a number of articles discussing ME from a creolist approach; e.g. Domingue (1977)56 and, more importantly, Bailey & Maroldt (1977). Bailey & Maroldt (1977: 21) define a creole as “the result of mixing which is substantial enough to result in a new [linguistic] system, a system that is separate from its antecedent parent system”. Following this line of reasoning, they argue that Middle English qualifies as a creole because “at least forty per cent of each component – lexicon, semantax, phonetology, and morphology – is mixed,” i.e. the result of the massive import of Anglo-Saxon vocabulary on to Old French . There were a number of minority languages (e.g. Hebrew, Cornish) in medieval England but, as Smith (1992: 49) suggests, these did not have any major impact on English and therefore, they will not be discussed here. . See Dalton-Puffer (1996: 47–48) for a brief account of Domingue’s (1977) paper.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.4 (54)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
structural paradigms. Although Bailey & Maroldt’s suggestions have been – fully or partially – accepted by some linguists (see Poussa 1982 or Trudgill’s 1983 concept of ‘creoloid’); their position has been considered untenable by an important number of scholars (e.g. Görlach 1986; Thomason & Kaufman 1988; McMahon 1994; Danchev 1997). Görlach (1986: 330, 334; see also Danchev 1997: 79ff.) criticises Bailey & Maroldt’s inadequate definition of the concept of creolisation and their selective use of data (which, in his opinion, is “taken from inappropriate registers, and disregards frequencies, chronological distributions and social functions of individual features”). The fuzziness of Bailey & Maroldt’s terminology was criticised again by subsequent scholars. Thus, Thomason & Kaufman (1988: 312; cf. also Dalton-Puffer 1996: 49) claim that, in Bailey & Maroldt’s account, creolisation simply “means any kind of structural interference from another language and any kind of ‘analytic’ development in language is taken as evidence of foreign inference”. As they correctly point out, hardly any language in the world has not been exposed to the influence of other language(s), and therefore, if we were to take Bailey & Maroldt’s explanations at their face value, virtually all languages of the world should be considered creoles (cf. also Görlach 1986: 334–335). In addition, they point out that not all analytic developments can be attributed to foreign influence. They also suggest that the only possible scenario for the coming into play of a creolisation process in medieval England would have involved an “extremely unsuccessful” learning of English by the Anglo-Norman speakers at the time in which they shifted towards English. They enumerate, however, a number of specific circumstances which made this possibility highly unlikely (for a detailed criticism of Bailey & Maroldt’s 1997 arguments, see Thomason & Kaufman 1988: 307ff.). Observations along similar lines have been put forward by other scholars, who have often pointed to the fact that “the Norman Conquest. . . left its imprint mainly in the top layers of society” (Van Kemenade 1994: 112). One should observe that the creolisation hypothesis has also been mentioned in connection to the contact between Old English and Old Norse. Van Kemenade (1994: 112–113) notes that the “pervasive” phonological, grammatical and lexical changes occurred in the transition period between Old and Middle English may be the result of the Scandinavian invasion – which, in her words “resulted in longterm settlement and assimilation of invading and native population”. However, the impact of the Scandinavian invasion is, as Van Kemenade (1994: 114) herself observes, difficult to ascertain. The OE records that have survived to the present-day are written in the West Saxon dialect and since “it was king Alfred’s business to get the Vikings out of England. . . Scandinavian influence is not apparent here.” In other words, had the Viking invasions had an impact on the different subsystem of the language, those traces would have only been visible in ME texts. The influence of Old Norse on Old English has been recently reassessed by McWorther (2002), who provides a list of forty-two characteristic features of Proto-Germanic and
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.5 (55)
Chapter 3. French influence
discusses the disappearance of ten of them in English (as compared to other Germanic languages, McWorther 2002: 248). His results show that those extinct ProtoGermanic features “persisted longest in regions where Scandinavians did not settle.” Furthermore, in six out of the ten cases, McWorther claims that the losses in English “have parallels in aspects of Old Norse” (McWorther 2002: 254–257). From this he concludes (a) that there has been a historical disruption in the transmission of English between the OE-ME periods caused by contact with Old Norse and (b) that this disruption was stronger than the transmission disruption associated with “semi-creole” languages like Afrikaans. He nevertheless does not support the idea that contact with Old Norse languages resulted in the creolisation of Old English but instead he concludes that the Scandinavian influence “simplified English grammar to a considerable extent” (McWorther 2002: 272). I would like to go back now to my initial considerations regarding the FrenchEnglish contact and possible language transfer in the medieval period. Thomason & Kaufman (1988) differentiate between processes of borrowing (acquisition of foreign features into a speaker’s native language (1988: 36)) and processes of substratum interference (linguistic interference resulting from imperfect learning in a process of language shift (1988: 37)).57 While Bailey & Marold’s (1977) account of the ME situation seems to suggest the latter – or, at best, a combination of the two aforementioned processes – Thomason & Kaufman (1988) clearly classify it as a case of borrowing. In the line of previous scholarship (e.g. Meillet 1921; Weinreich 1953), they note that vocabulary is the first (and easiest) element to be borrowed from one language to another; still, they also suggest that structural borrowing (i.e. the borrowing of elements from the traditionally considered more stable elements of the language, such as morphology or syntax), can also be borrowed (cf. Balland 1995; Aikhenval 2003; Heine & Kuteva 2003; Heine & Kuteva 2005). As regards what determines the type of borrowing of one language from another (i.e. lexical vs. lexical and structural), Thomason & Kaufman (1988: 72) point to the notion of “intensity of contact”, which includes the following social and linguistic factors:58 a. length of time (which is directly related to the linguistic competence and number of bilingual speakers) b. proportion of source-language speakers vs. borrowing-language speakers . See in this connection, Van Coetsem’s (1995) distinction between ‘borrowing’ and ‘second language learning’. . The concept of intensity of contact is also mentioned as an important factor in other works on contact-induced change (e.g. Trudgill 1989), although Thomason & Kaufman’s (1988) description seems to be more exhaustive.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.6 (56)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective casual contact
lexicon
slightly + intense contact
lexicon + structure (I)
more intense
strong cultural
contact
pressure
lexicon + structure (II)
very strong cultural pressure
lexicon + structure (IV)
lexicon + structure (V)
Figure 3.1. Borrowing scale (adapted from Thomason & Kaufman 1988: 74–75)
c. political dominance d. typological distance between source and borrowing language (As may be obvious from above, the greater the contact time/the no. of source speakers and their political dominance/the typological similarity between the languages in contact, the more intense or ‘disruptive’ the influence of one language over the other will be). However, Thomason & Kaufman (1988: 35) explicitly state that the “sociolinguistic history of the speakers”, i.e. their attitude towards the language(s) with which they are in contact and their speakers it is what determines the outcome of the contact. On the basis of these considerations, they devised the ‘borrowing scale’ featured in Figure 3.1 (cf. Thomason & Kaufman 1988: 74–75). As for the French influence on ME, Thomason & Kaufman (1988) state that, although the length of the contact time between the two languages was extensive and the (Anglo)-Normans constituted the social elite of the country (and therefore the social group exerting linguistic pressure); the lack of a significant number of native Norman speakers in the country (and later on, of French-English bilinguals), rendered the linguistic influence of French on English as a “borderline type 2/ type 3 case” (1988: 265), where, apart from a massive influx of lexical items, French had a “mild” influence on English morphology and syntax and a “practically trivial” influence on phonology. These suggestions are in line with subsequent specialist work on the topic, as will be discussed in the following section.
. Linguistic studies on the influence of French on English The preceding sections offered an account of (a) the social status of French and English during the ME period (Section 1) and (b) the scholarly opinion about the overall influence that French exerted on ME (Section 2). This section narrows down the topic of investigation further. It provides a brief outline of the main
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.7 (57)
Chapter 3. French influence
works that have dealt with French influence on the different language levels, while at the same time constituting a suitable background for the analyses carried out in Section 4 and Section 5 below. As noted above, lexical transfer is the most common (and most easily observable) result of processes of language contact. It is thus not surprising the existence of a number of early twentieth-century works assessing the French influence on English through the study of loanwords. According to Jespersen (1905: 94) and Baugh (1935: 91), the greatest influx of French borrowings occurred between 1250 and 1400.59 In the second half of the twentieth century, however, Dekeyser (1986) convincingly showed that the decrease in the frequency of the French loans began earlier than what Jespersen and Baugh suggest (c1350). The interplay between the French and the English morphological systems has elicited far less attention than the lexicon. Still, one can find monographs such as Marchand (1969)60 and Dalton-Puffer (1996). This latter work provides a detailed list of the derivative affixes imported from French into English, their meaning, their chronology (i.e. when they were used in English for the first time) and their combinatorial possibilities (i.e. if they are restricted to a specific word class or etymological type). In line with Thomason & Kaufman’s (1988) views, she concludes that the influence of French on ME morphology “was certainly there but should not be overestimated” (Dalton-Puffer 1996: 209). Finally, in the realm of syntax, the works of Sykes (1899), Prins (1952), Hornero-Corisco (1997), Iglesias-Rábade (2000, 2003) and Fischer (2006) should be taken into consideration. The first two of these studies focus on French calques on English phrasing. Sykes (1899: 7) suggests that, in general, “Middle English became, not only in its vocabulary alone, but in its phrasal forms, ‘halbfranzösisch”’. Prins (1952) also argues for a positive influence of French on English phrasing, although his claims are more moderate. He points to the fourteenth century (and especially the second half) as “the culminating point both in the influx of words and of phrases from the French” (Prins 1952: 37–38). It should be observed that both Sykes’ (1899) and Prins’ (1952) conclusions are based on the analysis of a limited number of texts selected by the authors themselves. Therefore, one should be very careful in extrapolating their conclusions to ME as a whole. A similar note of caution may be made with reference to Hornero-Corisco’s (1997) work on French influence on English prepositions, as it focuses on Ancrene . This opinion is also shared by Burnley (1992: 431; cf. also Mossé 1943: 38–39), who suggests that the density of French loans in English reached its peak in the second half of the fourteenth century. . The reader should be warned that this work is not exclusively focused on French affixes borrowed into English but to a description of English word formation in general.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.8 (58)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Wisse exclusively. Hornero-Corisco’s claims, however, are to a certain extent supported by Iglesias-Rábade (2000, 2003), who, in his analysis of English phases with nime(n)/take(n) and at from the Middle English Dictionary (henceforth MED) and the ME part of the Helsinki Corpus observes that the figurative senses of atprepositional phrases (e.g. at large, at ease) increased greatly in the last part of the ME period; a development that he carefully relates to the influence of Old French à-phrases (e.g. chevaucha a une autre cite). He reaches a similar conclusion with regard to nime(n)/take(n) phrases, which were “at least favoured by Anglo-Norman” (2000: 96). It should nevertheless be pointed out that HorneroCorisco’s and Iglesias–Rábade’s claims are slightly different from previous scholars in the field, in that they do not claim the direct transfer or copy of particular prepositional constructions into English. Instead, they argue for an indirect French influence, which manifests itself through the increase in use of specific native constructions (see, in this connection, Silva-Corvalán’s (1993) or Heine & Kuteva’s (2005) views on contact-induced grammatical change). Although not devoted exclusively to the topic, some comments on the possible French influence of post-nominal adjective position (e.g. the service dyvyne),61 on the development of wh- interrogatives as relative pronouns or on one as a indefinite pronoun can be found in Fischer (1992b: 214, 216, 225). In addition, a detailed treatment of adjective position in ME is provided in Fischer (2006). She shows that the determinants of adjective placement in ME are not substantially different from those in Old English, although they start to reflect the gradual change of the English grammatical system towards more rigid, word-order based parameters. In connection to language-contact issues, Fischer (2006) investigates the preference of French adjectives for occupying post-positive slots in English (a position which mirrors one of the slots traditionally associated with adjective placement in French) and concludes that “the influence of French cannot be said to govern adjective position in all circumstances” (Fischer 2006: 260).
. French influence on adjective comparison In the light of Heine & Kuteva’s (2005) research, in Ch. 2 above I observed that contact-induced change could manifest itself in forms other than lexical calquing – and that, in fact, changes from minor to major use patterns in a target language (B) due to the influence of a similar construction in a source language (A) seemed to be a very common cross-linguistic process of meaning transfer. The question is then to examine the extent to which this could have been the case with respect ˇ & Crespo-García (2002). . A similar comment is also found in Moskowich-Spiegel Fandino
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.9 (59)
Chapter 3. French influence
to the influence of French periphrastic comparatives on the development of English periphrastic comparison – note that Mustanoja (1960: 280) suggests that the influence of French “has considerably strengthened the position of more and most in the English system of comparison.” In the same line, Kytö (1996) and Kytö & Romaine (1997) observe that periphrastic comparison increased in use in the second half of the ME period – which coincides with the period in which Dekeyser (1986) observed the greatest influx of French loanwords in English. More recently, Terasawa (2003) investigated the evolution of periphrastic comparison in the ME and EModE texts of the Helsinki Corpus, showing that the rates for periphrastic comparison are higher in those texts that are translations from French or Latin (Terasawa 2003: 194). He also suggested that, in ME and EModE, periphrastic forms first appeared in more ‘formal’ texts like those concerning “philosophy, science, religion and education” and later on, they expanded to more informal texts like travelogues and letters (Terasawa 2003: 197). While Terasawa’s comments on the text-type spread of the periphrastic comparative construction are highly valuable, one should also bear in mind that the range of genres considered in the Helsinki Corpus increases over time. Thus, whereas in HM1 the text-types distinguished in the Helsinki Corpus are handbooks, philosophy, homilies, religious treatises, history and biography, in HM4 one finds a much wider repertoire of genres,62 which of course has an effect on the way in which the expansion of periphrastic forms should be determined. Terasawa (2003) also considers the possibility of a geographical spread of the periphrastic comparative, which, according to his hypothesis, would initially be more frequent in texts coming from the Southern part of the country (i.e. which was where most French noblemen settled) as opposed to the North. However, the analysis of these texts (based on the Helsinki Corpus) does not provide any substantial evidence for this claim (Terasawa 2003: 198. Anne Hudson’s (p.c.) study of selected ME manuscripts seems to lead to a similar conclusion to that of Terasawa). One may also argue that this kind of research may not be completely reliable, as the number of extant ME texts is relatively limited and it would thus be virtually impossible to find similar influenced/non-influenced texts (in terms of period, length, genre, dialect and register) in order to carry out a balanced comparison (cf. in this connection, Fischer’s (2007: 13) comments on textual comparability). Furthermore, the analysis would perforce be restricted to a very limited number of works which could by no means be taken as representative of the comparative tendencies of the whole ME writing tradition (note my criticism of the textual basis of Sykes 1899; Prins 1952 and Hornero-Corisco 1997 in Section 3 above). . The genres considered in the HM4 part of the Helsinki Corpus are: law, documents, handbooks (medicine, astronomy), sermons, rules, religious treatises, prefaces, proceedings, history, biography fiction, romances, drama, letters (private / non-private) and the Bible.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.10 (60)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
He finally suggests that “we could then assume that the periphrastic comparative, being first developed in translations from French and Latin, continued to be used in a formal register until it gradually expanded its use towards the end of Early Modern English.” Kytö’s (1996) research also suggests that inflectional comparatives in EModE are more frequent in matter-of-fact (or less formal) texts, thus indirectly supporting Terasawa’s (2003) suggestion that periphrastic comparatives are, by default, preferred in more formal environments. Although more fine-grained research on translation procedures would be needed in order to reach a definitive conclusion (e.g. on the closeness of translated texts to their original sources or on the extent to which French and Latin may differ as regards their impact on Old English), the claim that periphrastic comparison developed in translations does not seem to be supported by the investigation carried out in Ch. 2 above. The latter showed that, even in those cases where periphrastic comparatives appeared in OE translations from Latin, more often than not, these comparative forms were not calques. A different influencing factor was explored by Hornero-Corisco (1997). In her study of French influence on prepositions in English, she claims that the increasing frequency of the periphrastic genitive in ME (e.g. repentant neauer nes of mine sunnen; “I was never repentant of my sins” AW. 36.20) was, among other reasons, due to the influence of a similar (periphrastic genitive) construction in French with the preposition de. More importantly, she observes that, in her data, “the of -phrase is more frequent after French loans” (1997: 40). Thus, what she seems to be suggesting is the possibility that the combination of the preposition of with loanwords could have been a way of spreading the construction in English. In other words, this could be considered a case of ‘meaning transfer’ like the ones described in Heine & Kuteva (2005). Applying the same idea to the issue under investigation, one could hypothesise that the spread of periphrastic comparatives may have been, to a certain extent, initially linked to combinations with Romance63 adjectives by analogy with French/Latin periphrastic comparative structures. Put differently, the nature of the (compared) adjective could have had an influence on the selection of comparative strategy, in such a way that those comparative constructions wherein the adjective was of foreign (i.e. Latin and French) origin would more likely be of the periphrastic type; native adjectives being the ones that most easily selected inflectional forms. With the passing of time (and due to the prestigious status of . I will be using the term ‘Romance adjectives/borrowings’ (as opposed to ‘French adjectives/borrowings’) throughout the chapter, the reason being that, although most of the foreign adjectival forms retrieved from the data were borrowed from Old French, they are ultimately of Latin origin.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.11 (61)
Chapter 3. French influence
French in England during the ME period) then, the periphrastic pattern would have caught on with native adjectives. With the aim of testing this hypothesis, I retrieved all the inflectional and periphrastic comparative constructions of the PPCME2 corpus.64
. Analysis . Corpus analysis As observed in the section above, the first division of the data to be made was that of inflectional vs. periphrastic comparatives. After this division and with the help of the MED and the OED, a further separation between Romance and native adjectives was carried out. Table 3.1 and Table 3.2 summarise the analyses: Table 3.1. Distribution of native adjectives in ME Native adjectives65
HM1
HM2
HM3
HM4
Total
Inflectional Periphrastic Total
437 (97.7%) 10 (2.3%) 447 (100%)
80 (88%) 11 (12%) 91 (100%)
589 (86.6%) 91 (13.4%) 680 (100%)
316 (90.2%) 34 (9.8%) 350 (100%)
1422 (89.5%) 146 (10.5%) 1568 (100%)
Table 3.2. Distribution of Romance adjectives in ME Romance adjectives
HM1
HM2
HM3
HM4
Total
Inflectional Periphrastic Total
1 (50%) 1 (50%) 2 (100%)
3 (42.9%) 4 (57.1%) 7 (100%)
10 (12.9%) 68 (87.1%) 78 (100%)
11 (26%) 31 (74%) 42 (100%)
25 (19%) 104 (81%) 129 (100%)
Focusing on the native adjectives first, one can observe how the preferred comparative strategy for all periods is the inflectional one. The rate for periphrastic comparison in HM1 is very low (2.3%) and its increase is not extremely marked either, rounding an average of 10–11% between HM2 and HM4 (see examples (1)–(3) below): . I am very grateful to David Denison and the University of Manchester for granting me access to the corpus. . In terms of dates, the PPCME2 also includes in-between period categories (e.g. HM23, HM24, etc.); however, for the sake of clarity of argumentation (and the fact that there are not very many comparative tokens in these middle periods), I have not included them in the tables.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.12 (62)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
(1) For wel we knowe that youre liberal grace and mercy strecchen hem ferther into goodnesse (PPCME2.CHAU.ME) (2) And after whan god had preued his pacyence & it was so gret, he broughte him aŠen to richess & to heere estate þan he was before (PPCME2.ANON.MA.) (3) þe oþer is to wyfmanne commune. þis zenne is more hard: uor hi is more ald (PPCME2.MITC.AY.)
Moving now to the Romance adjectives, the first two ME periods do not feature a statistically significant number of examples. Therefore, it is from HM3 onwards that more reliable results can be drawn (see examples (4) and (5) below): (4) let also simplenesse be associod to good inward wysdom, and noþyng schal be clierere (PPCME2.AELR.DI.) (5) Gode Ihesu, art þu bycome straunge and mor enemy, for þi body is mor glorious? (PPCME2.AELR.DI.)
The number of periphrastic forms is higher than that for the inflectional ones at all times, although the number of inflectional comparatives seems to undergo a noticeable increase in the last part of the ME period (from 12.9% in HM3 to 26%). I would like to move on now to the comparison of the type/token ratio of inflectional comparatives. In the PPCME2 data, 25 inflectional Romance tokens were found (as opposed to 1422 native ones). The Romance adjective types (19) are featured below. Further explanations may be required at this point. When the adjective appears more than once, the number of times that it occurs in the corpus is given in brackets (e.g. clere (x3)). In addition, the first date between the [square] brackets is the year that the MED gives for the first attested example of the adjective in the language; the other dates (e.g. [in X]) are the dates in which the adjectives appear in the texts compiled in the PPCME2 in their comparative form.66 For instance, the entry clere (x3) [1300 in 1340, 1470, 1400] reads: “the adjective clere (‘clear’) was first attested in English in 1300. There are three examples of clere with inflectional comparison in the corpus, which date from 1370, 1400 and 1470”. See (6) below for a list of Romance inflectional comparatives in the corpus: (6) Bisegere [1175 in 1230], clere (x3) [1300 in 1340, 1400 and 1470], feble (x2) [1225 in 1380–1425, 1390], easy (x2) [1225, in 1380–1425, 1384], delitabel [1300, in 1440], byrnande [1385, in 1440], graciouse [c1300, in 1350], parfite (x2) [1350, in 1400, 1497], poor (x2) [1200, in 1400, 1400], profitable [1330, in 1400], proud [1225, in 1452], noble [1230 in 1387], jantill [1250 in 1470],
. For those words with different spelling variants in the corpus, I have, for the sake of clarity, only used one (the most frequent) spelling form.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.13 (63)
Chapter 3. French influence
light [1122 in 1340], gay [1310 in 1387], substancial [1340, in 1340], simple [1230, in 1440], troubli [1382, in 1440], vilore [1300, in 1390]
A common trait to most of the inflectional Romance adjectives in the corpus (graciouse, gay, and substancial excepted) is that they seem to have been borrowed noticeably earlier than their first attestation as comparative adjectives. Put differently, there seems to have existed a period for the adaptation of the new word into the morphosyntactic system of the language before its appearance with the ‘native’ (i.e. inflectional) comparative strategy. One may also wonder about the nature of the (Romance) periphrastic constructions. The paragraph in (7) below features the list of Romance adjectives appearing with periphrastic comparatives: (7) Priue (x3) [1230 in 1230 (first attested example?) and 1400–1450 (x2)), large [1225 in 1340], corteys [1300 in 1340], sotil (x3) [1300 in 1340, 1340, 1400– 1450], noble [1230 in 1340], verray [1275 in 1348], perfite (x4) [1300 in 1348, 1438 (x3)], stabill [1275 in 1348], virtuous [1330 in 1348], fervent [1340 in 1348–50], profitable (x3) [1330 in 1350–1440, 1400 (x2)], covenable, cruel (x2) [1225 in 1380-1425, 1438], excellent [1380 in 1380–1425, 1400–1425], grievous (x3) [1300 in 1387, 1390, 1390], honest [1325 in 1387], homeliche [1382 in 1387], fyguratif [MED first attested example: 1398, but 1388 example in corpus], abominable (x2) [1340 in 1388, 1390], pleasa(u)nt [1350 in 1390, 1400], ententif [1390 in 1390 (first attested example?)], cleer (x4) [1300 in 1390 (x2), 1348–1440, 1400–1425], esy (x6) [1325 in 1390, 1438 (x2), 1452 (x3)], humble [1275 in 1390], speciale (x2) [1230 in 1390, 1400–425], digne [1300 in 1390], perilous [1300 in 1396–1450], egre [1300 in 1396– 1450], maistirful [1390 in 1396–1450], unchangeable [1250 in 1396–1450], necligent [1382 in 1400], supple [1325 in 1400], obedient [1230 in 1400], contemptible [1384 in 1400], competent [1398 in 1400], fructuous [1382 in 1400], ioyeful (x2) [1250 in 1400, 1415], fortunate [1387 in 1400], plentevous [1325 in 1400], tolerable [ first attested example in MED: 1434, but 1400 example in corpus], aperte [1400–1425], beastly (x2) [1220 in 1400–1425, 1400–1450], feble (x2) [1225 in 1390, 1400–1425], dispytuos [1385 in 1400–1425], tender [1230 in 1400–1425], attempree [1340 in 1400–1425], merveyllous [1300 in 1400–1425], homly [1382 in 1400–1424], sufferable [1348 in 1400–1450], pleyn [1322 in 1400–1450], spiritual [1382 in 1400–1450], general [1230 in 1400–1450], venomous [1300 in 1400–1450], euyl [1225 in 1400–1450], sauery [1225 in 1400–1425], vnsauery [1230 in 1400–1450], foolys [1300 in 1400–1450], amiable [1385 in 1415–1500], habundant [1366 in 1415–1500], expedient [1418 in 1438], reuerent [1390 in 1400–1450], diligent [1340 in 1438], gentil (26) [1250 in 1452, 1500], natural [1325 in 1470], ardente [1350 in 1450], sufficient [1322 in 1470–1500], nobill [1230 in 1350–1440], precious (x5) [1350, in 1400, 1400, 1400–1425, (x2), 1400–1450), acceptable
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.14 (64)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
[1384 in 1470], deynty [1300 in 1475], gracious [1325, in 1425–1450], sutyl [1300 in 1400–1450], glorious [1275, in 1400]
The first observation that one can make is that the list of Romance adjectives with periphrastic comparison is noticeably longer than that of its inflectional counterparts. Furthermore, if one pays close attention to the adjectives featured above, one will realise that, although there are many adjective types whose use in the corpus appear much later than the first attested example of the adjective in the MED, on the whole, there seems to be a noticeable number of cases in which there is a shorter time-span between the first MED attestation of the adjective and its use in a periphrastic comparative construction (see the adjective types in bold). These results, thought only tentatively, may provide support to the hypothesis that periphrastic comparison could have been initially preferred with Romance adjectives in the ME period (see Table 3.3): Table 3.3. Native/Romance adjectives and comparison
Native adjectives Romance adjectives
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
1422 (90.6%) 25 (19%)
146 (9.4%) 104 (81%)
1568 (100%) 129 (100%)
A plausible intra-linguistic reason for this preference could be that, as Leech & Culpeper (1997: 362) suggest, periphrastic comparison is the “type of comparison which does not interfere with the basic form of the word”, thus allowing the morpho-phonological structure of Romance adjectives to remain intact. This may have been especially desirable in the earlier stages of the introduction of new forms, when speakers may have found awkward to add the -er comparative suffix to words with which they were not familiar. I would like to emphasise the word tentatively, for corpora can be considered ‘representative’ of a particular period, genre or text-type only to a certain extent. Furthermore, although it constitutes a great help in discovering general patterns of use, it may be the case that neither all the patterns (for instance, the most infrequent ones; cf. Cornips & Jongenburger 2001) and more importantly for the present investigation, nor the earliest examples of a pattern or construction may be represented.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.15 (65)
Chapter 3. French influence
. Individual author’s analysis67 The analyses carried out in the sections above could be considered to have been carried out at a ‘macro-level’, i.e. taking into consideration all (electronically-) available texts from a specific period. In his article, Terasawa (2003) also provides a micro-analysis investigation where he compares the use of periphrastic comparison in the works of individual authors, i.e. “Chaucer, Gower, Langland and the Gawain-poet” (Terasawa 2003: 199ff.). His research is nevertheless focused on the verse texts of these authors, where metrical needs may have played a role in the choice between inflectional and periphrastic comparative strategies. This type of individual author analysis constitutes an adequate complement to the kind of investigation provided in Section 5.1 above. In line with Teresawa’s (2003) work, this section will thus mainly be devoted to the analysis of periphrastic comparison in individual works coming from different chronological periods of ME (early vs. late ME) yet the same geographical area (cf. the comments on the dialectal spread of periphrastic comparison in Section 4 above). This difference in chronology will help us determine the degree to which French influence may have had an impact on the English periphrastic constructions at a more local level. The texts chosen for this analysis are Ancrene Wise and the Winchester/Caxton’s version of Malory’s Le Morte Darthur, as both texts come from the West-Midland area. Some work on periphrastic comparison in Ancrene Wisse/Riwle has been recently carried out (cf. Janecka 2006). This work focuses on the diffusion of periphrastic forms across five surviving versions of the manuscript and therefore, although related to the topic investigation, it is not central to the discussion and will not be mentioned further. The last section of this study will focus on the comparative strategies of a text highly dependant on French, namely, the Ayenbite of Inwyt. The latter investigation will provide a way of controlling for any differences in the use of comparison between native and translated texts (see, in this context, my remarks in Section 4 above). .. Ancrene Wisse As Wada (2003: 1) observes, the book known as Ancrene Wisse was a “beginner’s guide for female recluses” which was published in the early part of the ME period (c1230, according to the compilers of the PPCME2, cf. www.linng.upenn/mideng/ppmce2/dir (accessed 27-11-2007; cf. also Tolkien 1962: xv; Trotter 2003: 88). The manuscript seems to have been originally written in English, from which four translations into French and four into Latin were . I am very grateful to Anne Hudson for her suggestions as regards the choice of texts for this analysis.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.16 (66)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
made (Wada 2003: 1). The work gained great popularity over the centuries, as shown by the fact that it was read (and even incorporated into other works) in the following centuries (i.e. sixteenth century, Tolkien 1962: xviii; Wada 2003: 5ff.). For this analysis, a concordance to the MS Corpus Christi College Cambridge 402 version of the text was used (cf. Tolkien’s 1962 EETS volume and the concordance by Potts, Stevenson and Wogan-Browne 1993). As Trotter (2003: 90) suggests, there have been a number of works discussing the French loanwords of Ancrene Wisse from different angles. Now, if one pays attention to the actual periphrastic comparative forms (see (8) below), one would realise that the number of Romance adjectives is very limited. Furthermore, the results support the macro-level analysis carried out before, in that two out of the three Romance adjectives in the work appear with periphrastic comparison (see (8) below; the Romance adjectives have been provided in a fuller context in example (10) (see comparatives in italics) below):68 (8) mare iuppet, mare isprengde, mare lusti, mare fersch,69 mare iolhnet, mare priue, mare dred, mare fur, mare scheomeful, mare bihate (9) Sire ich am a wommon 7 schulde bi rihte beo mare scheomeful to habben ispeken as ich spec (PPCME2.ANON.AW.) (10) . . . 7 hwa wes mare priue wiδ þe king of heouene hwil he her wunede þes sondesmon (PPCME2.ANON.AW.)
The inflectional comparative adjectives are much more numerous (see the list in (11) below). Only one example of a Romance adjective appears in the list (e.g. largere). (11) Betere (x44), bittrure (x2), brihtre (x7), cwickre, deoppre (x3), deorre (x3), earre (x12), earunder, eateluker, eþre, estfulre (x3), feier (x15), forþre (x13), gleadfulre, gleadluker (x2), greatluker, greattre (x4), inre (x4), largere, leatere (x10), lengre (x9), lihtre (x2), luþer (x5), luþere (x9), meadlesluker, meadluker, mildre, ruhre, sarre (x5), schenre (x5), sikerure, smealre, sohlful (x3), strengre (x2), swartre, swiftre (x2), swiþere/swiþre, tomre, þiccre, unhalre,
. I am aware of the fact that in a couple of examples, the adjectival form is not a prototypical adjective but a participle (i.e. iuppet, bihaten, isprengde). . Although here it has been included within the Romance category, the Romance origin of fersch (‘fresh’) could perhaps be contested (Olga Fischer, p.c.). On the one hand, Old French has the form freschir (‘restore’, ‘invigorate’ cf. MED); on the other, OE had the form fersc, with a rather similar meaning (‘new, recent, novel’, OED, fresh, adj, A.I). A possible solution would be to consider it a hybrid resulting from the combination of an OE stem and a semantic loan from French.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.17 (67)
Chapter 3. French influence
unstrengre, uttre (x34), weorre/weorrur (x5), wisre (x3), woddre, wraþer (x2), wurse/wursi (x24)
Interestingly, in this case, the positive form of the adjective (large) does not seem to have been borrowed into English much earlier than the Ancrene Wisse example; appearing, according to the MED, initially in surnames (see (12)–(13) below). (12) Hugonem le Large (1220, MED, large. 13) (13) Þe large Men and þe milde Men . . . sculen beon icleopd on þe fader riht halue (c1225 MED, large, 1.a (a))
.. Malory’s Le Morte Darthur As will be discussed in more detail in Ch. 7 below, there are two extant versions of this work, the Winchester Ms (which is supposed to be the version closest to what Thomas Malory actually wrote) and Caxton’s version of the Ms (see Tieken-Boon van Ostade 1995 for a discussion of the date and composition of the manual). Based on French romances and the English Alliterative Morte Darthur, the Winchester manuscript was probably finished around 1469, whereas Caxton’s version dates from almost twenty years later, i.e. c1485. It is interesting to compare the two versions of the texts, as Caxton is well-known for having made certain changes to the ‘original’ Ms in order to bring it more in line with the taste of the court (which at the time was very much influenced by the French literary tradition – for more details, see Ch. 7, Section 3.2.1 below). Table 3.4 summarises the results for the inflectional comparatives in the two versions of the work. Not surprisingly, the two manuscripts contain a rather similar number of comparative types (and of tokens). Among them, there are very few Romance inflectional comparatives. The Winchester Ms features the forms valyaunte (x1), nobler (x1) and simpler (x1). The latter form is not attested in Caxton’s version of the work. Again, as in the case of the Ancrene Riwle, these Romance comparatives were all borrowed into English from Old French significantly early (see (14) below, all dates come from the MED: (14) noble (1200–1230), simple (1230), valyaunt (1325)
Moving now to the periphrastic examples, one finds, again, a close match between the periphrastic forms found in the two versions of the work (23 similar tokens; the adjectival types are reproduced in (15) below):70
. Note again, that some of the periphrastic comparative forms found contain participial (as opposed to prototypical) adjectives (c.f. blessid, naked).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.18 (68)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 3.4. Inflectional comparatives in Le Morte Darthur Malory (Winchester Ms)
Tokens
Malory (Caxton)
Tokens
better/bettir/bettur (OE) blacker (OE) bigger (ON) bitterer (OE) derrer (OE) elder (OE) fayrar (OE) further (OE) fowler (OE) fyerser (OF) gladder (OE) goodlyer (OE) gretter (OE) harder (OE) hardier (OF/Gmc.) heyre/higher (OE) holier (OE) heuiar (OE) leuer (OE) lengar (OE) richer (OE) nobler (OF) shorter (OE) sorer (OE) soriar (OE) strenger (OE) valyaunter (OF) simpler (OF) wayker/weyker (ON) wylder (OE) wers/werse/worse (OE) yonder (OE) yonger (OE) worthier (OE) trewer (OE) Total
105 2 21 2 1 3 16 5 2 1 2 1 13 2 4 3 3 4 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 8 53 8 1 1 278
better (OE) blacker (OE) bigger (OE) bitterer (OE) derer (OE) elder (OE) fayrer (OE) ferther (OE) fouler (OE) fyerser (OF) gladder (OE) goodlyer (OE) gretter (OE) harder (OE) hardyer (OF/Gmc.) heyer/higher/hyher (OE) holer / holier (OE) heuyer (OE) leuer (OE) lenger (OE) richer (OE) nobler (OF) shorter (OE) sorer (OE) soryer (OE) stronger (OE) valyaunter (OF) — waiker/weyker (ON) wylder (OE) werse (OE) yonder (OE) yonger (OE) — — Total
105 2 18 1 1 2 15 7 2 1 3 1 13 4 4 3 3 1 2 1 2 1 2 4 1 1 1 3 1 5 53 6
269
(15) acceptable (OF), aferd (OF), ardant (OF), forborne (OE), blessid (OE), bytter (OE), coward (OF), dismayed (OF), hardy (OF/Gmc.), heuy (OE), hyghe (OE), meker (OE), naked (OE), naturel (OF), nere (OE), renomed (OF), vncurteis (OF), wrothe (OE)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.19 (69)
Chapter 3. French influence
Examples (16)–(18) are, however, exclusive to the Winchester Ms: (16) And thys were. . .more perfite to their soulis than ye, my moste noble kynge (WMS.MD.) (17) for He hath caused you to have more worldly worship than ony knight that is now lyvynge (WMS.MD.) (18) and sir Marhalte fyebled, and sir Trystamys ever more well-wynded and bigger (WMS.MD.)
Whereas (19)–(20) reproduce examples only featured in Caxton’s work: (19) And in the meane whyle syr Tristram was that same day ryden in to the forest to chace the herte of greese / but sire Tristram wold not ryde on huntynge neuer more vnarmed by cause of syr Breuse saunce pyte (CMEPV.CAXT.MD.) (20) But Dynadan had wende the haute prynce had ben more wery than he was (CMEPV.CAXT.MD.)
The following example appears in both the Winchester MS and Caxton’s version of Le Morte Darthur – although in the former work, as an instance of double comparison: (21) Whanne they vnderstood that it was Dynadan / they were more wroth than they were before (CMEPV.CAXT.MD.)
.. Conclusion I observed above that (a) there were not very many periphrastic comparatives in the Ancrene Wisse and (b) that 2 out of the 3 Romance (i.e. French) adjectives found in the work seem to show a preference for this strategy. For want of data, however, these results were only considered indicative. Still, they appear to be in line with the results obtained from the analysis of a later West-Midland work, i.e. Malory’s Le Morte Darthur. Although featuring a number of different adjective types, both the Winchester Ms and Caxton’s version of the work contain roughly the same number of Romance adjectival loans. These latter are more frequently found with periphrastic comparatives (see Tables 3.5 and 3.6). Note, also the preference of native adjectives for inflectional comparison: Table 3.5. Caxton’s Le Morte Darthur
Romance Native Total
Infl. Comp.
Perip. Comp.
Total
3 (21%) 266 (95%) 269 (91%)
11 (79%) 14 (5%) 25 (9%)
14 (100%) 280 (100%) 294 (100%)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.20 (70)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 3.6. Winchester Ms’ Le Morte Darthur
Romance Native Total
Infl. Comp.
Perip. Comp.
Total
4 (27%) 274 (95%) 278 (91%)
11 (73%) 15 (5%) 26 (9%)
15 (100%) 289 (100%) 304 (100%)
. Comparison in a translated text: Dan Michell’s Ayenbite of Inwyt The Ayenbite of Inwyt is a translation from La Somme de Roi, a didactic text written in 1279 under the command of Philip II of France (Wallenberg 1923: xiii–xvi). Wallenberg (1923: xiii, xvi) claims that Michel had only a “rather modest” command of French, which, in his view, explains Michel’s almost “word for word” rendering of the text. As in the preceding sections, the inflectional and periphrastic constructions of the Ayenbite of Inwyt were retrieved and analysed in terms of the etymology of the adjective. Illustrative examples of either construction are provided in (22)–(23): (22) uor we byeþ þe more ymylded / and þe dreduoller / and þe more wys ine alle þinges (CMEPV.MITC.AY.) (23) þe spot of lecherie more uouler / and more perilous ine clerkes and ine prelas (CMEPV.MITC.AY.)
As in the previous analyses, inflectional comparison is preferred when the adjective under consideration is a native word. Table 3.7. Distribution of comparative adjectives in the Ayenbite of Inwyt
Romance Native Total
Infl. Comp.
Perip. Comp.
Total
4 (27%) 87 (70%) 91 (65%)
11 (73%) 38 (30%) 49 (35%)
15 (100%) 125 (100%) 140 (100%)
The figure for native periphrastic comparatives is however higher than in the texts considered in Sections 5.1 and 5.2 above (i.e. 30%). This difference in frequency can perhaps be explained if one has a look at the adjectival types occurring with periphrastic comparison: note that no fewer than 10 (out of 38) periphrastic native constructions feature participial forms (see tokens with an asterisk in Table 3.8). It would thus not be strange to suppose that the verbal nature of the participial adjectives could have made them unsuitable or, at least, dispreferred as regards their combination with the inflectional strategy. No major surprises are to be found in relation to inflectional forms (see Table 3.9).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.21 (71)
Chapter 3. French influence
Table 3.8. Adjectives taking periphrastic comparison in the Ayenbite of Inwyt Native
Romance
ald, borynde*, clene(x3), dreduol, grat(x2), grislich, hard, heuy, holy(x4), keruinde*, kueade, miŠten, milde(x3), quic, riŠ, strang, uoul(x2), wis, worth(x2), wylneþ, yblissed*, ydo*, yharmed*, y-layd*, ypined*, yzyenne*, ymad*(x2) atempred*, assayd*, chast, corteys, large, noble, parfit, perilous, sotil(x2), y-damned*,
Table 3.9. Inflectional comparatives in the Ayenbite of Inwyt Native
Romance
bleþelaker(x2), betere(x26), blondere(x2), hotter, leuere(x2), derrer(x3), dreduoller, grater(x10), harder, holyer(x2), hroþer, hye(x9), lenger(x2), lostuoller, milder(x2), nyer, smaller, stranger(x4), uayrer, uouler(x3), wiser(x2), zyker(x10), graciouser [in 1300], largere [in 1225], parfiter [in 1300], substancieler [in 1340]
Most of the inflectional comparatives feature native forms. Furthermore, those Romance loans attested with periphrastic comparison appear to have been introduced in the language relatively long before their first use in comparative structures. The only exception to this general trend is the adjective substancieler. One should note that the MED cites the Ayenbite of Inwyt as the first record of the form and that no other example of the comparative form appears in the Corpus of Middle English Prose and Verse. It is probably a nonce formation that did not catch on. Finally, it is worth pointing out that the distribution of comparatives in the Ayenbite does not seem to be noticeably different from that of either the Ancrene Wisse or Morte D’Arthur (but note my comments on periphrastic native forms above). In other words, the nature of the text (i.e. native vs. (rather) literal translation) does not seem to have an impact on the selection of comparative strategy.
. Concluding remarks Ch. 2 dealt with the (controversial) origin of periphrastic comparative structures in English. Without denying the possibility of an influence of Latin on their relative frequency of the forms towards the end of the OE period, it suggested that periphrastic comparison in OE was, ultimately, a native construction. The present chapter constituted a natural continuation to the previous one, as it focused on the spread of this construction in the language and, particularly, on the role that French may have had in this process in ME.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.22 (72)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Kytö’s (1996) and Kytö & Romaine’s (1997) work show the increase in frequency of periphrastic constructions throughout the period and especially towards the last part of it. In this respect, it is worth noting that it is precisely the LME period when the influence of French was at its peak, as shown by the fact that it was in LME that the influx of French loanwords – the most frequently borrowed linguistic item in cases of language contact, cf. Thomason & Kaufman (1988) – was strongest (Jespersen 1905: 94; Baugh 1935: 91; Mossé 1943: 38–39; Smith 1996: 135). Taking this into consideration, one may argue that these results fit nicely with Heine & Kuteva’s view of contact-induced grammatical change; i.e. the existence of a pattern/construction in a language (A) considered prestigious by the native speakers of language (B), leads to the increase of use of a pattern in (B) that speakers of that language consider, in some sense, equivalent to that pattern in (A). Put differently, in our case, then, the diffusion of periphrastic comparatives may well have been favoured by the influence of French throughout the medieval period, this influence being reflected in the (initial) preference of English speakers for using periphrastic comparatives with Romance loans, possibly as a means of maintaining the morphological integrity of the foreign adjectival base. It is worth mentioning at this point Deuchar & Vihman’s (2002) research. They suggest that early bilinguals make an interesting distinction between content and function words in mixed language utterances. Content words are shown to be language-specific (i.e. match the language context, i.e. they appear in the dominant language in the utterance), whereas function words are language neutral, i.e. they do not necessarily have to match the language context. Interestingly, although standard grammars (e.g. Quirk et al. 1985: 72) class adverbs as content words, Deuchar & Vihman (2002: 271) couch Spanish más and its English equivalent, more, as functional because “on semantic grounds we considered them to be. . .relational words.” Admittedly, the situation of English and French in medieval England was qualitatively different from that in Deuchar & Vihman’s (2002) research context. Firstly, we are not dealing (or, at least, not exclusively) with chidren’s language learning; second, as noted in Section 1 above, the linguistic situation of England at the time was not one of bilingualism but one of diglossia. Still, Deuchar & Vihman’s (2002) research matches with my findings, as it points to a high adaptability of the periphrastic comparative marker more in language contact situations. The spread of periphrastic comparison also seems to provide support to other hypotheses about contact-induced change and, more specifically, to Kerswill & Williams’ (2002) concept of “salience”. According to Kerswill & Williams (2002: 81) salience is “a [psychological] property of a linguistic item or feature that makes it in some way perceptually and cognitively prominent” and therefore potentially more prone to spread or be adopted in a linguistic community, especially in cases of language contact. They (Kerswill & Williams 2002: 105) also note that, in order for a
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:21
F: CI29903.tex / p.23 (73)
Chapter 3. French influence
linguistic element/phenomenon to be salient, there should be a match between language-internal factors (presence of phonological contrast, internally-defined naturalness, semantic transparency) and language-external ones (psychological, pragmatic, cognitive, socio-demographical). Applying Kerswill & Williams’ (2002) ideas to periphrastic comparatives, one may suggest that, intra-linguistically, periphrastic forms are more ‘salient’ because they are semantically more transparent comparative structures than inflectional forms (as noted above, they do not alter the adjective to which they attach; also, the particle more makes more explicit their comparative status; cf. Ch. 4, Section 5.4.2 below). At the same time, the formal similarity between English and French periphrastic comparatives in a period in which French was considered a prestige language (cf. Samuels 1972: 94) may very well count as the extra-linguistic factor that rendered them more ‘salient’ than their inflectional counterparts, thus favouring their spread.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.1 (75)
chapter
Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
.
Introduction71
In Ch. 2 above I argued in favour of considering periphrastic comparatives native structures. Ch. 3 examined their spread and establishment as one of the ‘standard’ comparative strategies in the language. The continued co-existence of the two comparative variants from the OE period up to the present-day poses an interesting question to the researcher: is there any difference in use between simple inflectional and simple periphrastic comparative structures? From an iconic point of view, one would assume that this is the case, as different forms (in this case, adjer and more + adj.) are normally associated with different meanings (‘isomorphism principle’, Haiman 1985: 14). However, as the sections below will show, no consensus has been reached as regards the extent to which inflectional and periphrastic forms diverge either syntactically or semanticpragmatically. This chapter and Chapter 5 below concentrate on these issues. The periods under consideration in this chapter will be EMode and LModE, as it was not until the last part of the ME period that periphrastic forms established themselves as a standard comparative option in the language (cf. Kytö & Romaine 1997). The Present-day English situation will be explored in Ch. 5 below. Section 2 outlines the morpho-phonological and syntactic factors that previous literature has associated with the selection of comparative strategy. Section 3 describes the data used in the study. Section 4 concentrates on the influence of the syntactic factors mentioned in Section 3 on comparatives in early and late Modern English. The results obtained from the latter analysis call for a semantic interpretation of the data, which will be provided in Sections 5 and 6 below. Section 7 measures the significance of the semantic and syntactic factors in Sections 4–6 through a variable rule analysis. Finally, Section 8 summarises the main conclusions and points to some issues for further research. These will be explored in
. Unless otherwise stated, the emphasis (i.e. italics/bold) in the examples provided through the chapter is mine (VGD).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.2 (76)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Ch. 5 below in connection to the distribution of the comparative strategies in the present-day.
. Adjective comparison: Previous literature Traditional scholarship points to phonological and morphological factors as the reason for the difference in distribution between inflectional and periphrastic comparative forms. Jespersen (1909–49: 350–351) observes that adjectives take either inflectional or periphrastic comparison mainly depending on their length72 (cf. also Pound 1901: 9–10, Kytö & Romaine 2000: 180; Suematsu 2004: 37ff.). Thus, according to Quirk et al. (1985: 461–463, cf. also Ch. 1 above), monosyllabic adjectives are usually compared by means of inflection (e.g. low → lower), polysyllabic adjectives (i.e. three or more syllables) “can only take periphrastic forms” (e.g. beautiful → more beautiful),73 whereas (many) disyllabic adjectives can occur with both inflectional and periphrastic comparison (friendly → more friendly/friendlier). Poutsma (1914) admits the importance of word length and word ending in the choice of comparative forms (cf. also Bauer 1994: 51); yet he claims that this latter is “chiefly a matter of euphony, convenience and rhythm and partly one of meaning” (1914: 474). He also remarks that periphrastic comparatives, being more “artificial”, are more likely to occur in literary registers and with longer words, while inflectional forms are favoured “in the vulgar (i.e. spoken or colloquial) language” (1914: 478). In keeping with this idea, Sweet (1891: 327) and Bolinger (1968: 120) note that frequently used adjectives (usually the shorter ones – which tend to be of native origin) have a stronger tendency to take inflectional comparison (cf. also Graziano-King 2003). Kruisinga (1932: 62) deems “immaterial” the number of syllables of the adjective and claims that the position of the primary stress is the main factor in the distribution of inflectional and periphrastic forms. If the last syllable bears the main stress, the adjective will take inflectional comparison. By contrast, if the primary stress falls on the penultimate syllable or further forward, the use of the periphrastic construction is preferred. This idea was further developed by Kuryłowicz (1964: 15) and Cygan (1975: 56). Subsequent scholarship (Leech & Culpepper 1997: 361–362) questioned the validity of the original claim by show. Jespersen (1909–49: 346ff.) also mentions other (minor) determinant factors of comparison such as orthography, stress, word ending and the origin of the adjective. . The exception being trisyllabic adjectives with the prefix un-, which can take inflectional comparison (unhappy → unhappier, untidy → untidier; Quirk et al. 1985: 462).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.3 (77)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
ing that a number of disyllabic adjectives (22 types) stressed on the final syllable more frequently select periphrastic comparison (Leech & Culpepper 1997: 361– 362; cf. also Suematsu 2004: 45).74 However, Elzinga’s (2006: 767) system of analogical modelling for comparatives claims that “phonological variables, including the number of syllables, stress pattern and segmental makeup of the final two syllables were shown to be significant in predicting the correct comparative outcome.” Recent commentators also suggest that syntactic considerations play a role in the distribution of comparative strategies. Rusiecki (1985: 89; cf. also Leech & Culpeper 1997: 366) observes that adjectives take different comparative strategies depending on the syntactic position that they occupy (i.e. predicative positions seem to favour the appearance of periphrastic forms). Other scholars claim that the occurrence of adverbial premodifiers (Leech & Culpeper 1997: 367; Lindquist 2000: 127), of a second term of comparison (Quirk et al. 1985: 462) or of an infinitival/prepositional complement after the comparative form favours periphrastic comparison (Mondorf 2002; Mondorf 2003). Finally, a number of corpus-based studies on comparison (i.e. Kytö 1996; Kytö & Romaine 1997, 2000: 185) indicate that “inflectional forms prevail[...] in matterof-fact texts types” whereas “[m]ore rhetorical texts such as philosophical and religious treatises, and correspondence. . . make greater use of periphrastic forms.” It should be observed at this point that most of the works mentioned above concentrate on the distribution of comparative constructions in present-day English only. Pound (1901), Kytö & Romaine (1997, 2000) and Suematsu (2004) are the exception. Pound (1901: 18) contends that although the length, ending and the stress pattern of the adjective may have play a role, individual preference was the factor that carried most weight in the choice of comparison in EModE. Kytö & Romaine’s (1997, 2000) and Suematsu’s (2004) corpus-based studies show that the latter morpho-phonological considerations were also operative in the LModE period. Along the same lines, Bax’s (2008) work highlights their importance as determinants of comparative selection in the eighteenth-century British grammar tradition. No research along the same lines has however been carried out as regards syntactic factors. The following section will thus be devoted to a corpus-based analysis of the syntactic determinants of comparative variation in EModE and LModE.
. One should bear in mind that all but two of the adjective types analysed by Leech & Culpeper (1997) are Romance borrowings.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.4 (78)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
. The data In order to avoid genre-bias issues, my selection of corpora drew from as many and as varied historical sources as possible. For the EModE period, I selected the EModE part of the Helsinki Corpus, the Corpus of Early English Correspondence (Sampler), the EModE part of the Lampeter Corpus, the Corpus of English Dialogues as well as a self-compiled corpus of EModE drama. The LModE data consisted in the ARCHER and a self-compiled corpus of late Modern English drama and fiction (see Ch. 1, Section 2.2 above for a brief description of these corpora). As regards the data, recent scholarship on the topic (Kytö & Romaine 1997: 340; Suematsu 2004: 36) observes that disyllabic adjectives are the group showing most variation between inflectional and periphrastic comparison. The study presented in this chapter is thus based on the analysis of a group of disyllabic adjectives. In keeping with Leech & Culpeper’s (1997: 359) study, the disyllabic adjectival category was divided into 3 different groups;75 i.e. adjectives ending in unstressed vowel (e.g. friendly), in syllabic /l/ (e.g. simple) and in schwa (e.g. mature).76 Using Wordsmith, two frequency wordlists were made, one for EModE and another for LModE. Only those adjectives in the so-called ‘positive’ degree which (a) were within the 500 more frequent words in each of the lists and (b) complied with the classification of disyllabic adjectives mentioned above were initially selected. Graziano-King & Cairn (2005) observe that in monosyllabic and in disyllabic adjectives of the three types mentioned above, the higher the frequency of the adjective, the greater the likelihood of inflectional forms being selected as the comparative strategy. I thus decided to run an initial search for the periphrastic forms (i.e. more + adj.) of the selected adjectives, for, in line with Graziano-King & Cairn’s (2005) observations, I assumed that a sufficient number of periphrastic forms in high-frequency adjectives across my corpora would probably entail the presence of similar token frequencies of inflectionally-compared forms. In connection to frequency distribution, in this secondary search I discarded from the tally those adjectives (a) with less than 20 comparative tokens for each period and (b) whose least frequent comparative strategy would amount to less than 15% of the . Excluded from the analysis were those adjectives ending in -ful and -ous (i.e. famous, careful), as Kytö & Romaine (1997: 342, 2000: 181) observe that their phonological configuration makes them invariably take periphrastic comparison. . No examples of adjectives ending in schwa were included in Leech & Culpeper’s (1997) study. It should also be observed that mature cannot be unambiguously classified as an adjective ending in schwa, as its pronunciation varies across dialects (the OED gives the following alternative British pronunciations of the adjective: /m6’tw~6/, /m6’tj~6/, /m6’twf ˜/, /m6’tjf ˜/, OED, mature, a.).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.5 (79)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
total number of tokens of the adjective in each of the periods under consideration. Table 4.1 records the adjectives that met the above-mentioned criteria: Table 4.1. Selected adjectives EModE
happy easy worthy noble ready
LModE
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Inflectional
Periphrastic
29 (57%) 42 (67%) 25 (63%) 69 (73%) 17 (81%)
22 (43%) 21 (33%) 15 (37%) 25 (27%) 4 (19%)
294 (77%) 178 (83%) 32 (47%) 110 (86%) 13 (33%)
90 (23%) 37 (27%) 36 (53%) 18 (14%) 26 (67%)
One should also note that, within the selected adjectives, I also excluded from the tally those examples in which: a. more has a quantifier function in connection to a nominal constituent (see (1) below): (1) The dead with charity enclosed in clay: And then to Calais; and to England then: Where ne’er from France arrived more happy men (EMODD.SHAK.5H.)
b. the adjective inflected for comparison is nominalised (see (2) below): (2) LEWIS
Bethink you, father; for the difference Is purchase of a heavy curse from Rome, Or the light loss of England for a friend: Forego the easier (EMODD.SHAK.KJ)
c. the comparative form has adverbial function (I am interested only in adjectival comparison; see (3) below): (3) Embrace then Tytan’s counsell:-now so guide The chariot of your sway in a just pace, That all (to come hereafter) may with pride Say, None like you did noblier quit the place (EMODD.DEKK.LO.)
d. the comparative occurs in correlative constructions such as “the more X. . .the more Y” or “more and more X”. (In these cases, the comparative form lacks all semantic flexibility which, as will be shown below, is a very important factor in the choice of comparison; see example (4) below):
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.6 (80)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
(4) the behaviour of Potion and his wife, and of my female cousins – our reception at the estate – Strap marries Miss Williams, and is settled by my father to his own satisfaction – I am more and more happy (LMODF.SMOL.RO.)
The following sections will outline the factors that previous literature has associated with the preference for one or another comparative strategy and test them against the data.
. Syntactic factors conditioning the choice of comparison . The position of the adjective The corpus analysis carried out by Leech & Culpeper (1997: 366) suggests that, in present-day English, comparatives in attributive position are mainly of the inflectional type (57.7%) and, conversely, that predicative positions favour the deployment of periphrastic comparison (67.2%).77 In his study of -ly comparatives and superlatives in the The New York Times and The Independent, Lindquist (2000) also explores the possibility that syntactic position is a determinant factor in the distribution of the comparative modes. The results of his corpus analysis (see Table 4.2) are somewhat different from those of Leech & Culpeper’s (1997) and he concludes that “[inflectional and periphrastic] comparatives are rather evenly spread between the attributive and predicative position” (2000: 126). 78 Table 4.2. Attributive vs. predicative comparative uses in Lindquist (2000) Position
Attributive Predicative Total
Inflectional
Periphrastic
NY Times
Independent
NY Times
Independent
67 (51%) 65 (49%) 132 (100%)
63 (55%) 51 (45%) 114 (100%)
24 (44%) 31 (56%) 55 (100%)
42 (37%) 73 (63%) 115 (100%)
The reason for the differences in figures between these authors may well be related to the fact that Lindquist’s study takes a different experimental basis from that . It should be noted that the figure for predicative comparatives also include postpositive adjectives. . Observe that the percentage for attributive/predicative periphrastic forms in The Independent in Table 4.2 appears to show a clear preference for periphrastic comparatives to occur in predicative positions.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.7 (81)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
of Leech & Culpeper.79 Leech & Culpeper analyse how the syntactic factor under consideration (i.e. syntactic position) is distributed between the two comparative strategies. By contrast, Lindquist takes the comparative form as the starting point of his analysis and examines how attributive/predicative uses are distributed between inflectional and periphrastic comparative strategies. Arguably, an analysis along the lines of Leech & Culpeper (1997) seems more appropriate for the purposes of the present investigation, since what is at stake is the influence of the factor itself on the selection of comparative strategy (cf. Tagliamonte 2007: 191–92). It should be noted here that both Leech & Culpeper (1997) and Lindquist (2000) include postpositive adjectives amongst their predicative tokens. As Fischer (2006: 254) states, postposed adjectives in present-day English are “a mixed bag of remnants”, usually restricted to either fixed expressions or a number specific collocations; see Biber et al. (1999: 519), cf. also Quirk et al. (1985: 1294ff.): (7) It’s a shame if you haven’t got anyone musical here (Biber et al. 1999: 519) The heir apparent (Quirk et al. 1985: 1294)
By contrast, the position of the adjective in Old and Middle English was rather flexible due to the highly inflectional nature of their morphosyntactic system. The decline of the OE inflectional system led to a gradual fixation of the word order options from the ME period onwards, a process which of course affected the placement of noun modifiers (Fischer 2006: 282). Taking this into consideration and, for the sake of accuracy, the postposed adjectives in my EModE and LModE data will be initially considered independently from the attributive and predicative tokens (see Table 4.3 and Table 4.4 and examples (8)–(9)). (8) I make no question but wee shall have cause to say and thinke, that noe children are more blessed in a mother, and I hope your La=pp= will thinke noe mother happier in children (CEEC.FCO.LET.)
. Lindquist justifies the discrepancies between his and Leech & Culpeper’s (1997) figures by claiming that the meaningful correlation is not the one established between attributive/inflectional on the one hand and predicative/periphrastic on the other. Instead, he argues that “the important factor seems to be whether the adjective is in the comparative or superlative form” (Lindquist 2000: 126). Thus, he suggests that examples such as The deli has the friendliest atmosphere (i.e. when the superlative occurs in attributive position) are “much more common” than examples like It was the ugliest but the best because “in predicative position [the superlative] often demands some sort of postmodification to achieve balance in the sentence” (Lindquist 2000: 127).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.8 (82)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 4.3. Syntactic position in selected EModE adjectives Position LModE
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
Attributive Predicative Postpositive80 Overall distribution
104 (77%) 68 (57.1%) 10 (66.7%) 182 (67.7%)
31 (23%) 51(42.9%) 5 (33.3%) 87 (32.3%)
135 (50.2%) 119 (44.2%) 15 (5.6%) 269 (100%)
Table 4.4. Syntactic position in selected LModE adjectives Position LModE
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
Attributive Predicative Postpositive Overall distribution
257 (90.5%) 349 (69.4%) 21 (44.7%) 627 (75.2%)
27 (9.5%) 154 (34.1%) 26 (55.3%) 207 (24.8%)
284 (34.1%) 503 (60.3%) 47 (5.6%) 834 (100%)
(9) I will not urge, with one unwelcome word, this unkindness I’ll conceal it – If your heart has made a choice more worthy, I forgive it – pursue your pleasures – drive without a rein your passions – I am the mistress of my own mind, that shall not mutiny – If I retrieve you, I shall be thankful – If not, you are and must be still my lord (ARCHER. HAMI.)
In general terms, the results show the preference for inflectional forms in all positions in either period. This is not surprising if one takes into consideration that inflectional comparison was the first strategy attested in the language and that, after an initial increase in the use of periphrastic forms, it has “been reasserting itself since the Early Modern period” (Kytö & Romaine 2000: 172). It should nevertheless be pointed out that the preference for inflectional forms is less marked in predicative (and postpositive) slots, especially once one moves closer to the present-day (i.e. in the LModE period). This seems to be in line with Leech & Culpeper’s findings (1997) for present-day English. They elaborate on the causes of the positive association between periphrastic forms and predicative environments (Leech & Culpeper 1997: 358). First, they argue that in sentences where periphrastic forms occur attributively such as “I ought really to have driven more cheap ‘bread and butter’ cars”, more could be interpreted both as a comparative particle and a determiner; by contrast, no ambiguity . It should be borne in mind that EModE drama is well-represented in my data and that most of the Elizabethan drama was written in verse – which suggests that metric considerations may well have played a role in the use of postposition in my EModE texts.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.9 (83)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
is possible in those cases where the periphrastic comparative occurs predicatively.81 Also, following Rusiecki (1985: 89), they suggest that “periphrastic forms, being complex, are less handy to use attributively” (Leech & Culpeper 1997: 358. Note that neither Rusiecki nor Leech & Culpeper explain what constitutes the greater complexity of periphrastic forms as opposed to the inflectional ones).82 However, Lindquist (2000) contends that periphrastic forms are phonologically heavier than inflectional comparatives because they have a higher number of consonantal phonemes than inflectional comparatives. In his opinion, this “makes it more natural to place a periphrastically compared adjective at the end of the clause to achieve end-weight” (Lindquist 2000: 126). Although accurate, this suggestion seems to constitute a partial explanation of the phenomenon only, for it pays no attention to semantic-pragmatic considerations – which, as will be discussed below (see Section 5), play an important role in the choice of comparison. . Presence of a second term of comparison According to Quirk et al. (1985: 462), adjectives that tend to take inflectional comparison may also occur with periphrastic forms. This option is, according to them, favoured when these adjectives “are predicative and followed by a than-clause.” This idea is further investigated by Leech & Culpeper’s (1997: 367) and Lindquist’s (2000: 128–129) corpus studies. The results obtained, however, led them to discard the idea that than-phrases have any influence on the choice of comparison, as they show that the percentages of inflectional and periphrastic forms followed by a second term of comparison are rather similar (e.g. 21.8% inflectional vs. 22.7% periphrastic in Leech & Culpeper’s study).83 I initially considered comparative forms attested in both attributive and predicative positions; however, given that than-phases are strongly dispreferred in attributive position (e.g. “?a more ugly than X house”; see rows in italics in Tables 4.5–4.6.), I concentrated on predicative comparatives only (examples (10) and (11) below). . One may nevertheless argue that this alleged ambiguity can only operate at the written level, as in oral communication the intonation and conversational situation usually makes the intended meaning clear to the hearer. . It is also worth mentioning that there is no consensus in the literature on how to establish objective measures for the notions of ‘grammatical complexity’, ‘heaviness’ or ‘weight’ (see Mondorf 2002: 70). . Lindquist’s study of The New York Times and The Independent also reflects a balanced distribution of than-phrases between inflectional and periphrastic forms (both inflectional and periphrastic comparatives are followed by a than-phrase in around 20% of the cases).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.10 (84)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 4.5. Cross-tabulation of syntactic position and second term of comparison (EModE) Predicative
Attributive
Postpositive
Total
Without than-phrase
Infl. Perip. Total
47 (64%) 27 (36%) 74
100 (78%) 28 (22%) 128
3 (50%) 3 (50%) 6
150 (72%) 58 (28%) 208
With than-phrase
Infl. Perip. Total
21 (47%) 24 (53%) 45
4 (57%) 3 (43%) 7
7 (78%) 2 (22%) 9
32 (52%) 29 (48%) 61
TOTAL
Infl. Perip. Total
68 (57%) 51 (43%) 119
104 (77%) 31 (23%) 135
10 (67%) 5 (33%) 15
182 (68%) 87 (32%) 269
Table 4.6. Cross-tabulation of syntactic position and second term of comparison (LModE) Predicative
Attributive
Postpositive
Total
Without than-phrase
Infl. Perip. Total
225 (74%) 79 (26%) 304
250 (91%) 24 (9%) 274
10 (40%) 15 (60%) 25
485 (80%) 118 (20%) 603
With than-phrase
Infl. Perip. Total
124 (62%) 75 (38%) 199
7 (70%) 3 (30%) 10
11 (50%) 11 (50%) 22
142 (61%) 89 (39%) 231
TOTAL
Infl. Perip. Total
349 (69%) 154 (31%) 503
257 (90%) 27 (10%) 284
21 (45%) 26 (55%) 47
620 (75%) 207 (25%) 834
(10) Fanny was most conveniently in want of rest. Crawford could not have wished her more fatigued or more ready to sit down (LMODF.AUST.MP.) (11) BOE. I say it is so. PHIL: Then yf anye good be added or put to the wretchednes of any man, is not he more happy then the man, whose myserye is pure (HEL.PRES.BO.)
Furthermore, a number of examples where a comparative adjective is attested attributively and the head noun is followed by a than-phrase were attested (24 tokens across periods; see (12) and (13) below). (12) First Citizen Second Citizen Third Citizen
If it be found so, some will dear abide it Poor soul! his eyes are red as fire with weeping There’s not a nobler man in Rome than Antony. (EMODD.SHAK.JC.)
(13) when Charlotte being called out of the way, there ensued a brief interval of time, which Noah Claypole, being hungry and vicious, considered he could not possibly devote to a worthier purpose than aggravating and tantalising young Oliver Twist (LMODF.DICK.OT.)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.11 (85)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
These examples create complications for the analysis, as they cannot be easily accommodated within the parameters of my classification (they would have to be included in both predicative and attributive groups; i.e. predicative according to the syntactic slot occupied by the than-phrase, attributive because of the premodifying function of the comparative). Given their statistical insignificance, I decided to discard them from the tally. The results are summarised in Tables 4.7–4.8. They suggest that, in predicative positions, periphrastic comparatives are slightly more strongly associated with a second term of comparison than inflectional forms, especially in the EModE period. The chi-square test, however, suggests that the results are statistically significant only for the LModE period. Table 4.7. Predicative comparatives with/out a second term of comparison in EModE
+ than-phrase – than-phrase Overall distribution
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
21 (47%) 47 (64%) 68 (57%)
24 (53%) 27 (36%) 51 (43%)
45 (100%) 74 (100%) 119 (100%)
Table 4.8. Predicative comparatives with/out a second term of comparison in LModE
+ than-phrase – than-phrase Overall distribution
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
124 (62%) 225 (74%) 349 (69%)
75 (38%) 79 (26%) 154 (31%)
199 (100%) 304 (100%) 503 (100%)
. Presence of adverbial premodifiers Leech & Culpeper’s (1997: 367) and Lindquist’s (2000: 127) studies suggest that there exists some kind of association between periphrastic forms and the occurrence of adverbial premodifiers (e.g. a bit, even, far; see Table 4.9): Table 4.9. Adverbial premodifiers and comparative adjectives in Leech & Culpeper (1997) and Lindquist (2000) Mod. + infl. Leech and Culpeper Lindquist
Mod. + perip.
19.1% 22%84
25.6% 33%
28%
46%
. The figures on the first columns stand for Lindquist’s (2000) results of The New York Times’ analysis; the second ones represent the outcome of The Independent.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.12 (86)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
My results for the early and late Modern English periods seem to point to the same direction; i.e. periphrastic comparatives being preferred over inflectional ones when they are premodified by adverbial intensifiers – especially in the EModE period. Nevertheless, the chi-square test suggests that the results are not statistically significant (see Table 4.10 and Table 4.11): Table 4.10. Adverbial premodifiers and comparatives in EModE
EModE data without intensifiers EModE data with intensifiers Overall distribution
Mod. + infl.
Mod. + perip.
Total
166 (68.9%) 16 (57.1%) 182 (67.75)
75 (31.1%) 12 (42.9%) 87 (32.3%)
241 (89.6%) 28 (10.4%) 269 (100%)
Table 4.11. Adverbial premodifiers and comparatives in LModE
LModE data without intensifiers LModE data with intensifiers Overall distribution
Mod. + infl.
Mod. + perip.
Total
498 (67%) 129 (72.1%) 627 (75.2%)
157 (24%) 50 (27.9%) 207 (24.8%)
655 (78.5%) 179 (21.5%) 834 (100%)
. Presence of complements Rusiecki (1985: 89) finds a positive correlation between predicative environments and periphrastic forms and he justifies it on the basis of the more complex nature of periphrastic forms when compared to their inflectional counterparts. (But, as observed above, he does not specify what makes periphrastic forms more complex structures than inflectional comparatives). Mondorf (2003) also invokes the idea of complexity in relation to periphrastic comparatives, although taking a rather different stance. She argues that periphrastic comparatives are more explicit (comparative) variants that tend to be used in complex environments in order to minimise the cognitive processing effort. In her view, then, what is complex is the context, not the periphrastic comparative itself (see her definition of the notion of more-support85 below): In cognitively more demanding environments which require an increased processing load, language users– when faced with the option between a synthetic and an analytic variant – tend to compensate for the additional effort by resorting to the analytic form. (Mondorf 2003: 253) . This principle has its foundations on Rohdenburg’s (2003: 217) Complexity Principle, which holds that “in the case of more or less explicit constructional options, the more explicit one(s) will tend to be favoured in cognitively more complex environments.”
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.13 (87)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
According to Mondorf (2003: 254; cf. also Mondorf 2007: 214), the reason why periphrastic comparatives mitigate the complexity of the cognitive load better than inflectional forms is threefold. First, the particle more unambiguously signals the beginning of the Degree Phrase; second, periphrastic forms are syntactically more transparent, as they consist of two differentiated parts: the degree marker (more) and the adjective; third, periphrastic comparatives allow the speaker to alert the addressee to the subsequent appearance of a cognitively complex Adjectival Phrase. In the light of this principle, Mondorf (2002, 2003) suggests that the appearance of prepositional and infinitival complements by the side of comparatives (see examples (14) and (15) below) makes the comparative environment cognitively more complex, which, according to the quote above, in its turn calls for the occurrence of the periphrastic mode of comparison. (14) It would be hard to find a couple more proud of their home than Michael and Kathleen Kinsella (Mondorf 2002: 70) (15) Crack is far more easy to conceal than cannabis
(Mondorf 2003: 266)
.. Infinitival and prepositional complements It was noted above that Lindquist (2000: 126) attributed the preference of periphrastic forms for predicative positions to reasons of end-weight (i.e. periphrastic forms are phonologically heavier than their inflectional counterparts). Quirk et al. (1985: 361–362) expand this notion of phonological weight to semantics, claiming that “clause-final position is associated with prosodic and semantic ‘weight’.” Following this line of reasoning, one may argue that periphrastic comparative constructions are heavier than their inflectional counterparts, and as such, that they will be preferred in predicative final positions regardless of whether or not they are combined with complements. One may thus conclude that, without isolating the effect that end-weight has on the choice of comparative strategy, the influence of PCs on the selection of comparative strategy cannot be clearly ascertained. In order to minimise the influence of end-weight on my data, I discarded from the tally those examples in which the comparative construction appears in final position. Included in this group were cases where the comparative occurs with a sentence-final PC or a than-phrase (as one may argue that the than-phrase is part of the comparative construction). In addition, I did not consider comparative constructions appearing with infinitival complements, since Mondorf (2003) also suggested that infinitival complements favour the occurrence of periphrastic comparatives (they make the comparative form longer and more difficult to process, thus triggering the operation of Rohdenburg’s Complexity Principle). However, once the factors (potentially) influencing the mode of comparison were filtered
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.14 (88)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
out, no comparative tokens were available for analysis, as all the adjectives in my data combined with final PCs. A similar situation obtained when I tried to investigate the influence of infinitival complements in my data. Again, I discarded those examples where the comparative adjective occurred in sentence-final position and with a prepositional complement. Only three examples in my corpora could be selected for the analysis (see examples (16)–(18) below): (16) “I am not required to go yet; I would not desert him, dear Miss Summerson, even if I were.” One other thing I felt it needful to touch upon before he left me. I knew that I should not be worthier of the love I could not take (LMODF.DICK.BH.) (17) It was not too late for that. Although I closed this unforeseen page in my life to-night, I could be worthier of it all through my life (LMODF.DICK.BH.) (18) POLONIUS I hear him coming: let’s withdraw, my lord. [Exeunt KING CLAUDIUS and POLONIUS] / [Enter HAMLET] HAMLET To be, or not to be: that is the question: Whether ‘tis nobler in the mind to suffer The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune (EMODD.SHAK.HA.)
. Conclusion The corpus-based study presented in this section revisited those syntactic factors that previous scholarship considered influential on the appearance of one (inflectional) or the other (periphrastic) comparative mode in EModE and LModE. The results obtained suggest that only one of the factors examined, i.e. the syntactic position of the adjective, seems to have an influence on the selection of comparative strategy.86 Put differently, syntax cannot provide a fully satisfactory explanation for the behaviour of disyllabic comparative adjectives. With the aim of shedding more light on the issue, Section 5 below will be devoted to a study of the semantics-pragmatics of the comparative modes.
. But note that the impact of Mondorf ’s (2000, 2003) claims could not be ascertained for want of data.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.15 (89)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
. Inflectional vs. periphrastic comparatives: A semantic-pragmatic analysis . Previous literature on the topic The semantics of adjective comparison received a considerable amount of scholarly attention at the end of the last century; the issues that elicited most interest being the source of comparatives and whether or not than is a semantically negative element (see Ch. 1, Section 1.2). Interesting and valuable as these studies are, they left unanswered an important issue, namely, the relation between the form of the comparative (adjer / more + adj.) and its meaning. Traditional grammars (Poutsma 1914; Curme 1931; Kruisinga 1932) mentioned the question only in passing. According to Curme (1931), the conveyor of degree in inflectional comparatives (i.e. -er) is a suffix “intimately associated with the stem” that is never stressed (Curme 1931: 504). Conversely, periphrastic forms consist of two independent words (more and the adjective), which allow the speaker to emphasise either the idea of degree (when the stress is placed on more) or “the meaning” (when the adjective is emphasised, cf. Curme 1931: 504). Unfortunately, neither Curme nor subsequent scholarship developed this idea further (see, however, the comments in Kytö & Romaine 2000: 185 or Janecka 2006). Some authors ignored the issue altogether, suggesting that inflectional and periphrastic comparatives may be seen as synonymous structures (Quirk et al.’s (1985: 458) claim that comparison in English is “expressed by the inflected forms in -er (. . .) or their periphrastic equivalents with more” [emphasis added]). Other scholars recognised the possibility of a semantic difference between the two comparative strategies, although they decided not to pursue the study of the issue further. Ryan (1986: 55) suggests that “the lexical relationship between ADJ+er to MORE+ADJ (. . .) has never been conclusively established”. She admits that in certain cases, “there are syntactic consequences of the difference between -er forms and more forms”, however, “for the purposes of analysis” she assumes that the “-er forms and more forms of comparative are categorially indistinguishable” (ibid.). A similar position is adopted by Rusiecki (1985: 88), who states that “whether there is any semantic difference between the two (inflectional and periphrastic comparatives) and if so what it is, deserves investigation (. . .) but so far has not been attempted”. More recently, however, Mondorf (2003, 2007) convincingly argues for a semantic difference between the two strategies in terms of abstract vs. concrete meanings. In keeping with Rohdenburg’s (1996) complexity principle and previous psycholinguistic research, she suggests that concrete adjectival meanings are less complex (i.e. require less processing effort) than abstract ones and therefore that they tend to be associated with inflectional comparatives. By contrast, periphrastic
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.16 (90)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
comparison can mitigate better the cognitive complexity of the context, hence being preferred for the conveyance of complex abstract notions. Furthermore, in the realm of language acquisition, Graziano-King & Cairn (2005: 348; cf. also Graziano-King 1999, 2003) suggest that, for specific adjectival groups,87 adjective frequency and gradability (whether the adjective refers to an attribute that can vary in degree) influences the comparative type preference; inflectional comparison being preferred for certain frequent adjectives. Drawing on the syntactic factors discussed above, the following sections constitute an attempt at providing a better understanding of the semantics-pragmatics of adjective comparison. I will start by considering the implications of type frequency and coordination factors on the pragmatic distribution of comparative strategies (Sections 5.2–5.3). Also, given that the position of the adjective is the only syntactic factor that appears to condition to a considerable degree the use of comparative structures, in Section 5.4 I will first give an overview of the relevant studies on the semantic-pragmatic differences between attribution and predication and then relate these differences to the syntactic behaviour of comparative adjectives. Finally, an analysis of the semantic impact of adverbial premodification will be offered in Section 6 below. . Frequency Although not a strictly syntactic factor, the impact of frequency on the selection of comparative strategies will be considered here. Krug (2003: 15) observes that high frequency triggers mental entrenchment. Furthermore, on the basis of previous research on language acquisition, GrazianoKing & Cairn (2005) state that inflectional comparison is the first or ‘default’ strategy acquired by English children (cf. also Gathercole 1985; Graziano-King 1999). From this one can hypothesise that the higher the frequency of the adjective, the greater the likelihood of the inflectional forms for being selected as the preferred comparative strategy – which is what Graziano-King & Cairn (2005) predict for monosyllabic and in disyllabic adjectives ending in -le, -ly, -ow, -some and -er. Table 4.12 features the frequency of each of the selected adjectives in this study. For the sake of convenience, Table 4.1 above (which records the distribution of comparative strategies across adjectives and periods) is also given below as Table 4.1’:
. The adjectival groups considered in Graziano-King & Cairn’s (2005) study were monosyllabic adjectives and disyllabic adjectives ending in -le, -y, -ly, -ow and -some.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.17 (91)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
Table 4.12. Frequency of selected adjectives (positive degree)
Easy Happy Noble Ready Worthy
EModE
LModE
0.0009% 0.0008% 0.018% 0.001% 0.0015%
0.0138% 0.0317% 0.0127% 0.0224% 0.001%
Table 4.1’. Selected adjectives
Happy Easy Worthy Noble Ready
EModE Inflectional Periphrastic
LModE Inflectional Periphrastic
29 (57%) 42 (67%) 25 (63%) 69 (73%) 17 (81%)
294 (77%) 178 (83%) 32 (47%) 110 (86%) 13 (33%)
22 (43%) 21 (33%) 15 (37%) 25 (27%) 4 (19%)
90 (23%) 37 (27%) 36 (53%) 18 (14%) 26 (67%)
Graziano-King & Cairn’s (2005) suggestions are confirmed by an analysis of the data; the most frequent of my selected adjectives (i.e. noble and ready in EModE, together with happy in the LModE) being more frequently attested with inflectional forms in my corpus. . Coordination Although strictly speaking coordination is not a factor that triggers the deployment of either mode of comparison, Leech & Culpeper (1997: 367–368) observe in their data a tendency for the same kind of comparative strategy (i.e. inflectional/periphrastic) to occur in each member of a coordinate construction (see examples (19) and (20) below).88 (19) thirstier and hungrier and wearier and unhappier (20) proved to be more interesting and certainly more lively
They suggest that the reason for this is the tendency for comparative forms “to imitate neighbouring comparative adjectives” (Leech & Culpeper 1997: 367). This . A similar claim is put forward by Jespersen (1909–56: 390–391) and König (1971: 105) as regard ‘gradual increase’ constructions (e.g. he became angrier and angrier / more and more angry). The validity of this claim is supported by Mondorf ’s (2007: 220ff.) research. It should be observed here (cf. also Section 3 above) that ‘gradual increase’ constructions have not been considered in this analysis.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.18 (92)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
echoes an observation made by Poutsma (1914: 478), who claimed that “convenience (. . .) causes periphrastic comparison to be used of groups of adjectives forming a kind of unit.” But neither of these claims seems to provide a completely satisfactory explanation for the phenomenon. Coordination can be defined as “the relation between elements arranged or placed in the same order, rank or degree” (OED, co-ordination, 2). This implies that the elements of any coordinate construction must share the same syntactic rank. Schachter (1977) goes further in his Coordinate Constituent Constraint (CCC) and emphasises the functional importance of the semantics of the coordinate elements. Thus, according to his CCC, in order for two elements to form a coordinate structure, they must not only “belong to the same syntactic category” (as the OED definition suggests) but also have “the same semantic function” (Schachter 1977: 90). Coordinated adjectives are not very frequent in my corpora (see Table 4.13. and examples (21)–(23)). Table 4.13. Coordinated adjectives in the EModE and LModE data Same comparative Different comparative Positive adjective
Other
EModE Inflectional Periphrastic
33 14
4 1
2 1
1 (superlative)
LModE Inflectional Periphrastic
25 8
4 2
0 0
0 0
(21) Ho. Dare defend baldnes, which our conquering Muse Has beaten downe so flat? Well, we will goe, And see what weapons theyr weake wittes doe bring; If sharpe, we’ll spred a large and nobler wing (EMODD.DEKK.SA.) (22) there were plenty of scullers going here and there that morning, and plenty of barges dropping down with the tide; the navigation of the river between bridges, in an open boat, was a much easier and commoner matter in those days (LMODF.DICK.GE.) (23) Or if you will let them learne but one letter at once, untill they can readily know or finde out that letter in any place, and after that another in the same manner: This is holden the surer and more easie way (HEL.BRINS.LL.)
The results for same coordinated periphrastic comparatives should be taken as merely indicative, for in 16 out of the 22 tokens attested across periods, one cannot ascertain with total confidence whether the comparative marker more has been
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.19 (93)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
elided or whether the coordinate structure is established between a periphrastic comparative and a positive adjective (see (24) below): (24) the fame of Wisdom, amuse and perplex themselves in pursuit of somewhat to be acquired by Marriage or purchase, no doubt as a Trophy of their good conduct; forsaking in the mean time their more noble and solid advantage (LAMP.AB.ML.)
All in all, the results of the data analysis (a) corroborate the claims put forward above for positive adjectives and (b) support the hypothesis that the infrequent combination of inflectional and periphrastic comparison in coordinate constructions may be related to the fact that the two comparative modes, although belonging to the same syntactic category, are not semantically similar. . The position of the adjective: A semantic interpretation .. Attribution and predication in positive adjectives It was observed in Section 4.1 above that the position of the comparative adjective (i.e. attributive/predicative) has some effect on the choice of strategy. Inflectional comparatives are generally preferred over the periphrastic ones in both attributive and predicative positions, this preference being less marked in predicative slots. Interestingly, cross-linguistic differences between attribution and predication have been consistently noticed by scholars, although always in relation to positive adjectives. Croft (1991: 51–52; cf. also Croft 2001: 66, 88) argues that syntactic categories (the major ones being verb, noun and adjective) are not linguistically but pragmatically motivated, i.e. they are associated with propositional speech acts, which they prototypically, although not always, represent (in case they do not, they appear in a form that is somehow marked). According to this system, nominals prototypically perform the propositional act of reference, verbs of predication, and adjectives of modification. Croft distinguishes between two types of modification: restrictive and non-restrictive. The former “helps fix the identity of what one is talking about (reference) by narrowing the description, while [the latter] provides a secondary comment (predication) on the head that it modifies, in addition to the main predication” (Croft 1991: 52; see also Wierzbicka 1988: 484). The pragmatic function of modification is associated with attributive adjectives. The other propositional act the adjective can perform is that of predication (which, as the name indicates, is associated with adjectives in predicative positions, where the markedness of the adjective is displayed by the presence of a copula). This propositional act corresponds to “what the speaker intends to say about what he is talking about” (Croft 1991: 52); put differently, it “ascribes something (in this case, a property) to the referent”. Croft (2001: 66) further specifies that the act of predication
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.20 (94)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
“prototypically reports relatively transitory states of affairs” ([emphasis added] also Wierzbicka 1986, 1988: 486 or Dik 1989: 166). The correlation between attributive position and permanence, on the one hand, and predicative position and transitoriness, on the other, is also present in works focusing on specific languages. With regard to English, Bolinger (1967, cf. also Kruisinga 1932: 121; Teyssier 1968: 225) contends that the adjective navigable in the only navigable river is “unambiguously characteristic”, for it refers to a river that has the permanent (or characteristic) quality of being navigable. By contrast, navigable in the only river navigable is “occasional”, as it relates the condition of navigability to a particular, temporary occasion. Fischer (2006: 255) also notes that further differences between attribution and predication in (Old and Middle) English adjectives can be observed in terms of the linear organisation of the discourse, as the communicative requirements of the situation can to a certain extent determine the organisation of the information in the sentence (cf. also Lambrecht 1994: 26–27 for more general remarks on discourse organisation). Attributive adjectives prototypically belong to what systemic-functional grammar defines as the Theme of the clause (i.e. “the point of departure of the message; it is that which locates and orients the clause within its context”; Halliday 2004 [1985]: 64), whereas predicative adjectives occur in the Rheme component (“the part in which the Theme is developed”; Halliday 2004 [1985]: 64). In its turn, the difference between Theme and Rheme is, in general terms, closely associated with a difference in informativeness (given v. new). The Theme of a clause is, as noted before, the starting point of the message and as such it represents the shared knowledge between the speaker and the addressee necessary to establish successful communication. By contrast, the Rheme of the clause is related to newness, i.e. it conveys information that has not been previously available to the hearer.89
. A more fine-grained analysis of information structure is provided by Lambrecht (1994: 334ff.). He makes a distinction between ‘topic’ and ‘focus’ and tries to relate it to the way in which the entities/propositions being talked about are represented in discourse. Topical elements/sentence constituents are those which are identifiable by the speaker in the discourse situation and have some kind of activation status in the mind of the hearer (in other words, they are closely related to what Halliday (2004) calls ‘given information’); whereas focus elements are those that are not identifiable or predictable (i.e. inactive) at the time of the utterance. (This latter definition roughly corresponds to Halliday’s ‘new information’ category). Lambrecht (1994: 200) also observes that initial positions tend to be the preferred topic position, and post-verbal placement the preferred focus placement – but that in no sense this is an univocal correlation; i.e. focal structures can occur preverbally (and viceversa, topic structures can be placed post-verbally).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.21 (95)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
Finally, to come back to something I hinted at before, attributive and predicative adjectives also seem to differ in markedness. Croft (2001: 88–89) observes that when adjectives act as predicating constructions, the copula be appears as a marker of the function (e.g. “That cypress is big”; Croft 2001: 89 [emphasis added]). By contrast, when adjectives perform the propositional function of modification, no such overt coding is necessary (“The big cookie is hers”; Croft 2001: 89 [emphasis added]). This leads Croft (1990: 140–141) to suggest that predicate adjectives are typologically marked constructions with respect to their modifying counterparts (which, in their turn, constitute typological prototypes of the speech act of modification, i.e. as compared to nominals and verbs performing this function– which are formally marked by e.g. a genitive -’s, as in “vehicle’s”, or present participial -ing, e.g. “destroying”).90 I have observed above that comparative adjectives display a difference with regard to the syntactic position that they occupy: inflectional comparatives are preferred in attributive positions whereas periphrastic comparatives are more likely to occur predicatively. This difference between attributive and predicative slots presumably holds regardless of the degree of the adjective. Hence, if there is a tendency for inflectional comparatives to appear in attributive position and for periphrastic forms to occur in predicative position, this is because these forms somehow fit better in the attributive/predicative meaning of the adjective, which means in its turn that they convey a different semantic-pragmatic load. This issue will be analysed in detail in Section 5.4.2 below. .. Attribution and predication in comparative adjectives: Some theoretical remarks As noted above, if the predicative tendencies of periphrastic comparison run parallel to the predicative use of positive adjectives (and vice versa, the preference of inflectional forms for attributive positions mirrors the tendency of positive attributive adjectives), then, one would expect that the correlation predicative/temporal/new/marked vs. attributive/permanent/given/unmarked suggested for positive adjectives would also hold for comparatives. I will start by examining the (possible) difference in markedness between inflectional and periphrastic comparatives. Croft (1991, 2001; see Section 5.4.1 above) considers the appearance of overt structural coding a decisive criterion for classifying constructions as either marked or unmarked within a particular (usually binary) system. This idea of overt coding, although useful, cannot be properly applied in such general terms to my investigation, as both inflectional . Note, however, Haspelmath’s (2006) observations regarding the usefulness and/or necessity of the concept of markedness in linguistics.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.22 (96)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
and periphrastic constructions are overtly coded for comparison (i.e. through the appearance of -er or more). Givón (1990: 947) approaches the idea of markedness from an iconic perspective and suggests three criteria that may help “to distinguish the marked from the unmarked category in a binary contrast”, i.e. structural complexity (marked structures tend to be larger/more complex than the unmarked ones), frequency distribution (marked forms are usually less frequent than unmarked forms and therefore, cognitively more salient) and cognitive complexity (the marked category requires more attention, mental effort or time to be processed than the unmarked form). Now, if one examines inflectional and periphrastic comparatives in the light of Givón’s ideas, one may suggest that periphrastic forms meet the required conditions for being considered “marked” constructions in relation to inflectional forms: they are longer comparative structures than their inflectional counterparts and, as Kytö & Romaine (1997: 334–335) show, they are, and have been historically, less frequent than inflectional comparatives. Finally, with regard to Givón’s (1990: 947) cognitive complexity criterion, one might suspect that the periphrastic comparatives draw more attention to themselves due to their increased morphophonological substance. In this respect, Graziano-King & Cairns’ (2005: 349) work suggests that, in language acquisition, “while comparative formation can sometimes be a complex matter, complexities are always resolved with the periphrastic form overriding the synthetic [i.e. inflectional] – never the reverse”. It could also be suggested that periphrastic comparatives are marked with respect to inflectional forms, in the sense that their morphological configuration, in particular the relative autonomy, hence salience, of the particle more as compared to the bound morpheme -er, represents greater emphasis on the idea of contrast of degree (see Kytö & Romaine 2000: 185). It is significant that Curme (1931: 504) observed that the comparative marker of inflectional forms is an affix that can never be stressed, whereas comparison in periphrastic forms is marked through the deployment of an independent morpheme that may be easily emphasized. The other two semantic-pragmatic differences associated with attributive and predicative positions for positive adjectives (i.e. permanent and given v. temporary and new) also seem to hold for comparative constructions. Temporary properties tend, due to their changeable nature, to be associated with new information (cf. Fischer 2001, 2006). In its turn, new information requires, for obvious communicative reasons, a greater explanatory effort and therefore, a greater amount of linguistic material. The association between new information and newsworthiness is also found in Givón’s Quantity Principle: a. “A larger chunk of information will be given a larger chunk of code” b. “Less predictable information will be given more coding material”
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.23 (97)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
c. “More important information will be given more coding material” (Givón 1990: 969) Periphrastic comparatives are morphologically longer than their inflectional counterparts, and consequently, more suitable, according to Givón’s principle, to carry new or unpredictable information. Issues of cognitive complexity in relation to comparative structures have been dealt with in recent corpus-based work by Mondorf (2003, 2007) for both the present-day and the LModE period. Given that complexity factors are directly related to the universal cognitive abilities of the individual and that these latter are, in principle, not likely to change across generations of speakers, one may assume that their impact on the choice of comparative structure will apply equally to all periods of the language (at least once both – inflectional and periphrastic – strategies are established in the language as competing options). Consequently, they will not receive any further attention in this chapter. Instead, the following section will concentrate on one of the other theoryoriented claims mentioned above, i.e. the possible correlation between comparison and ‘new’ vs ‘given’ information. . Establishment in discourse This section sets out to investigate the differences in distribution of the inflectional and periphrastic modes according to whether they introduce a new quality or describe a quality that has already been established in the discourse. The latter, “given information”, would, along the lines outlined before, be initially associated with inflectional comparison – and vice-versa, i.e. new information is supposed to be more frequently conveyed by periphrastic comparatives. Table 4.14 reflects the distribution of inflectional and periphrastic comparatives when the quality under comparison is previously mentioned in the discourse. It should be observed that only the results for adjectives in predicative position are recorded here, as the chi-square test showed that the analysis of attributive adjectives did not produce significant results – note also that attributive slots strongly disfavour certain comparative constructions (i.e. those with complements or a second term of comparison) that are rather frequent in my data. Post-posed adjectives were not included in the analysis either due to their low frequency in my data. Furthermore, in order to avoid subjective interpretations, I only considered ‘previously mentioned in discourse’ those instances in which either the positive form of the adjective is attested or when another adjective/phrase with a similar semantic import is mentioned in the preceding context (note that Halliday (2004 (1985): 572) suggests that synonymy is another very effective tool to create lexical cohesion; see examples (25)–(27) below).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.24 (98)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
(25) “No, indeed, my dear. Hem!” “Thinking is easy enough,” said the grave lady. “What is easier, you know?” assented Miss Sarah Pocket (LMODF.DICK.GE.) (26) and was now convinced that virtue only makes a man truly wise, rich, and great, and preserves him in the way to a superior happiness in a future state; and in this, he said, they were more happy in their banishment than all their enemies were (LMODF.DEFO.RC.) (27) at this present moment, and will die myself, or kill the man who possesses her before me” “You marry the greatest heiress and the noblest blood in England?” said Lord George, haughtily. “There’s no nobler blood in Europe than mine,” answered I (LMODF.THCK.BA.)
Finally, those examples where the comparative form was modified by an adverbial intensifier (e.g. much happier, even more easy) were discarded in order to control for any possible influence of the adverbs on the selection of the comparative strategy. (The influence of adverbial premodifiers on comparatives will be explored in Section 6 below). Table 4.14. Comparatives and establishment in discourse in EModE and LModE EModE
Established Not established TOTAL
LModE
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Inflectional
Periphrastic
3 (60%) 13 (56.5%) 16 (57%)
2 (40%) 10 (43.5%) 12 (43%)
12 (21.8%) 116 (94.3%) 128 (72%)
43 (78.2%) 7 (5.7%) 50 (28%)
As expected, contexts where the quality under comparison is not established are generally more frequent in either period. Focusing now on the distribution of comparative strategies across periods, one can observe a preference for inflectional comparatives when the quality under comparison has been established in EModE, whereas periphrastic forms seem to be more frequent in the same established environments in LModE. The disparity of the results should perhaps be taken with a pinch of salt, as the chi-square tests indicate that the statistical significance of the results is only suggestive for EModE .91 Before moving on to the next section, I would like to comment on a number of examples (6 in EModE, 21 in LModE) where the immediate previous context features a quality semantically opposite to that expressed by the comparative adjective, hence creating a contrast of quality (as opposed to one of degree) between them. These examples seem to be often associated with inflectional comparatives (see (28)–(29) below). . By contrast, the LModE results are highly statistically significant.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.25 (99)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
(28) No words can express the secret agony of my soul as I sunk into this companionship; compared these henceforth everyday associates with those of my happier childhood – not to say with Steerforth, (LMODF.DICK.DA.) (29) Omnes. Bal.
A brave blacke villaine. That’s I; all that brave blacke villaine dwels in me, If I be that blacke villaine; but I am not, A Nobler Character prints out my brow (EMODD.DEKK.NS.)
Examples of this kind will receive more ample treatment in Ch. 5 below.
. The influence of adverbial intensifiers on comparatives In the previous section I discarded from the count those examples where the (preestablished) comparative form was premodified by an adverbial intensifier. The reason for this restriction was to avoid a possible influence of this factor on the choice of the comparative mode. In this connection, Leech & Culpeper (1997: 367) claim that “degree modifiers such as a bit, even or far are more likely to occur with the periphrastic than the inflectional comparative”, although they do not offer an explanation for the preference of intensifiers to occur with periphrastic forms. The present section will thus be devoted to analysing in more detail the semantics of those degree intensifiers that most often combine with comparative forms, paying particular attention to any effect that they may have on the conveyance of comparative meaning. Tables 4.10 and 4.11; summarised in 4.15, show the frequency of degree intensifiers in combination with comparative forms in my data: Table 4.15. EModE and LModE comparatives in combination with adverbial intensifiers
Far Much Still Even Rather A good/great deal TOTAL
EModE
LModE
9 (100%) 15 (100%) 3 (100%) 1 (100%) – – 28 (100%)
40 (100%) 120 (100%) 5 (100%) 4 (100%) 4 (100%) 6 (100%) 179 (100%)
In order to obtain as reliable a semantic analysis as possible, I will only focus on the best represented degree adverbs in my data; namely, much and far (see Table 4.16). Although the semantics of these adverbs will be discussed in the following sections, one may initially suggest that the association of much with inflectional
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.26 (100)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
comparison seems to become stronger in LModE, whereas no consistent trend of usage is observed across periods for far. Table 4.16. Comparatives in combination with much and far EModE Infl. Much Far TOTAL
9 (60%) 4 (80%) 13 (100%)
LModE
Perip.
Total
6 (40%) 5 (20%) 11 (100%)
15 (100%) 9 (100%) 24 (100%)
Infl. 94 (81%) 20 (50%) 114 (100%)
Perip.
Total
26 (19%) 20 (50%) 46 (100%)
120 (100%) 40 (100%) 160 (100%)
. Much According to Quirk et al. (1985: 590), much is a booster whose function is to “denote a high degree, a high point on a scale”. My data show that much is more frequent with inflectional than with periphrastic forms in both early and late Modern English. A close look at the comparative examples of much also reveals that the semantics of both inflectional and periphrastic forms are rather similar when this adverb is involved in the expression of comparison. In those cases in which the quality under comparison has been established in the context (either lexically or semantically), much enhances the contrast established by the comparative construction (regardless of whether the strategy used is the inflectional or the periphrastic one). Note the increasing repetition (happy, very happy, much happier) in (30) below. Similarly, in (31) below, the word lenity implies ‘mildness, gentleness’ and ‘mercifulness’ (OED, lenity, n.) – ideals that are very much in line with the high moral principles one normally associates with nobility of character (cf. OED nobility, n. 4a) and which are surpassed by the use of more noble: (30) Mr Cibber: Q.: Mr Cibber:
Because She had no Fortune. Did they at first live happily together? They did live happy, very happy, much happier than I expected (EMODD. CIBB.)
(31) for, he said, as they had seen their Errors, and repented, nothing was nobler than Forgiveness. But though he was pleased modestly to ascribe this to his Lenity, it really arose from much more noble and political Principles (LMODF.FIEL.JO.)
Conversely, when the quality under comparison is not mentioned in the context, the presence of much by the side of comparative forms creates a contrast with what has been previously said, again, regardless of the comparative strategy used. Consider examples (32) and (33) below, where the use of much before more easy and
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.27 (101)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
worthier implies that the earlier method of revenge and the prospects of gentleman are, respectively, neither easy nor worthy: (32) Launcelot was not now so much of a knight-errant, as to leave Aurelia to the care of Providence, and pursue the traitors to the farthest extremities of the earth. He practiced a much more easy, certain, and effectual method of revenge (LMODF.SMOL.LA.) (33) ‘That is because you are good; not because I am! Oh, my dear, it might have been a better fortune for you, if you had been fond of someone else – of someone steadier and much worthier than me’ (LMODF.DICK.DA.)
. Far The adverb far (OED, adv., 2a) originally conveyed a concrete meaning, i.e. that of “great physical distance”.92 However, it soon began to denote “mental or abstract distance”, thus acquiring a metaphorical sense that nowadays pertains to its combinations with comparative constructions. In this respect, the OED records that far (adv., 4b.) started to qualify adjectives and adverbs “or their equivalents, implying excess, defect, or variation from a standard” from the end of the fourteenth century, and that in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries “was often prefixed to adjectives and adverbs of negative import.” None of the adjectives selected in this analysis carry any negative semantic prosody and therefore, the OED comment on the negative import of the collocates of far in EModE cannot be empirically verified. Focusing now on the data, in Section 6.1 above I observed that much can combine with comparatives when the adjectival quality is established in the discourse. Only one instance of far in these (pre-given) environments was attested in my data (see (33) below): (33) Guio.
How happy am I now; since my Sonne fell, He fell not, by a base unnoble hand? As that still troubled me; how farr more happy Shall my revenge be (EMODD.FLET.CC.)
In all my other examples (displaying either inflectional or periphrastic comparison), the use of far creates a contrast between the quality conveyed by the comparative and the preceding context. Take for instance example (34) below, where far helps to emphasise the speaker’s hyperbolic statement (i.e. ‘a Queen’s life could not have been happier than mine, had I received. . .’).
. The evolution of far in combination with comparatives seems to share many features with that of the phrase far from. For a brief account of the development of this phrase, see Akimoto (2001).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.28 (102)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
(34) myself out of the reach even of Disaster itself; his Estate and mine, wou’d have purchas’d even then above two Thousand Pounds a Year, and I might have liv’d like a Queen, nay, far more happy than a Queen (LMODF.DEFO.FM.)
Another illustrative example of this contrastive use of far is (35) below: (35) I cannot yet, But forcedly, on marriage fixe my heart, Yet heauen forbid I should deiect your hopes Conceiue not of me so vncharitably, I should belie my soule if I should say, You are the man I neuer should affect: I vnderstand you thus far, you’r a Gentleman Whom your estate and vertues may command To a farre worthier brest, then this of mine (EMODD.MIDD.FG.)
It is also worth noting that, with the exception of 6 examples (see, for instance, (36) below), all my inflectional and periphrastic examples modified by far occur with a second term of comparison: (36) if I had then known, and told you that I loved and honoured you, not as the poor child I used to call you, but as a woman whose true hand would raise me high above myself and make me a far happier and better man (LMODF.DICK.LD.)
One may account for the different behaviour of far and much in iconic terms: the original semantics of far (“at a great distance, a long way off ”, OED, far, adv.) creates a metaphorical distance between the comparative construction and its surrounding context. As a result of this, the comparative proposition introduced by far will by default tend to establish a scalar contrast with, rather than to enhance the standard of, any quality established in the previous context.93 This also explains the preference of far-comparatives for occurring with than-sentences, as a second term of comparison makes any contrast more explicit. The semantics of much only implies ‘greater amount’ (without the implications of extremity; see Dekeyser (1994) hence allowing for the creation of comparative meanings can lead to both degree enhancement and degree contrast. . Conclusion Previous scholarship (Leech & Culpeper 1997: 367; Lindquist 2000: 127) argued for a positive association between the presence of adverbial intensifiers and the use of periphrastic comparison. Their account of the phenomenon was (although grounded in corpus research) limited, to a certain extent, to a report of the fig. The idea of a “great variation from the established norm” is lost in Quirk et al.’s (1985: 591) account of the particle, as they group far together with much as an amplifier of the subcategory of boosters.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.29 (103)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
ures obtained in their respective analyses, without considering the reasons for this (alleged) preference of intensifiers for occurring with periphrastic forms. The corpus analyses carried out in Sections 6.1–6.2 above readdressed the issue. The results indicated that the presence of adverbial intensifiers does not seem to have an influence on the selection of comparative strategy. Instead, I contend that adverbial intensifiers (or at least the two adverbial intensifiers that I have investigated) have a homogenising effect on comparatives, in the sense that they trigger similar readings from both inflectional and periphrastic comparatives. The effect of these two intensifiers on comparatives can be captured in Figure 4.1:
far Contrast of quality
much Contrast of degree
Figure 4.1. Adverbial intensifiers and their influence on comparatives
Far stands on the leftmost side of the scale; the metaphorical detachment created between the proposition that the far-comparative construction takes as a starting point and the far-proposition itself being so pronounced that the comparative construction introduced by far tend to oppose rather than intensify the scalar denotation conveyed by the comparative. By contrast, much occupies the middle point of the scale: it works within the same scale denoted by its corresponding comparative when the quality under comparison has been established in the discourse; when no such quality is mentioned in the context, much (like far) elicits a contrastive reading from the comparative it combines with.
. Determinants of adjective comparison: Variable rule analysis The corpus-based study presented in the sections above investigated a number of syntactic and semantic factors considered to be influential on the selection of one (inflectional) or the other (periphrastic) comparative mode in EModE and LModE. In this analysis, however, each of the factors were considered independently; i.e. without paying attention to the possibility that their impact on the choice of comparative strategy may overlap and/or be measured and ranked in some way. In this connection, Gries (2003: 172) claims that linguistic behaviour mirrors social behaviour in that it is rarely motivated by a single factor, thus arguing for the use of multifactor analysis as the only methodology “that can readily cope with the intricate complexity” of linguistic phenomena.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.30 (104)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
In order to investigate the issue, I made use of Goldvarb, an application which allows the simultaneous manipulation and processing of independent linguistic factors (see http://individual.utoronto.ca/tagliamonte/Goldvarb/GoldVarb_ MANUAL.htm (accessed 15-01-2008) or Tagliamonte 2007). At a first stage, a binomial one-step analysis was carried out in order to ascertain how the data were distributed and how well they fit the model (see Tagliamonte 2007: 139–140). Taking into consideration the remarks put forward in Section 4.4.1 above, I did not consider the presence/absence of complements as a variable in my data. A graphic representation of fit between the model and the data is provided by scattergrams (see Figure 4.2 and 4.3).
Figure 4.2. Scattergram (EModE data)
Figure 4.3. Scattergram (LModE data)
The closer the points to the diagonal line of the scattergram, the better the fit between the data and the model (Tagliamonte 2007: 224). Furthermore, the size of each point in the scattergram is proportional to the amount of data, “a large point far from the diagonal” suggesting “interaction” among the factors considered (Rand & Sankoff 1990: 24; in Tagliamonte 2007: 224). As the scattergrams in the Figures above show, my comparative data are highly suitable to this type of analysis: the points furthest away from the diagonal are neither too numerous nor too big. The second step of the investigation consisted in a binomial step-up/stepdown analysis. This type of analysis measures the influence of each factor on the selection of the variable (‘factor weight’, Tagliamonte 2007: 156) and indi-
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.31 (105)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
cates their statistical significance and possible overlaps between them (see Tables 4.17 and 4.18). Table 4.17. Inflectional vs. periphrastic comparatives, variable rule analysis (Early Modern English) Significant vs. non significant factors (non-significant factors in brackets) Corrected mean 0.68 Significance: 0.005 Log likelihood –163.556 Total no. of comparatives 269
Position
2nd term of comp. Modifiers Establishment in discourse
Attributive Postpositive Predicative Range – than-phrase + than-phrase – Modifiers + Modifiers Established Non-established
Factor weight
%
N
0.61 0.48 0.38 21 [0.53] [0.39] [0.51] [0.44] [0.49] [0.63]
50.2% 5.6% 44.2%
135 15 119
77.3% 22.7% 89.6% 10.4% 9.7% 90.3%
208 61 241 28 243 26
Table 4.18. Inflectional vs. periphrastic comparatives, variable rule analysis (Late Modern English) Significant vs. non significant factors (non-significant factors in brackets) Corrected mean 0.78 Significance: 0.008 Log likelihood –427.592 Total no. of comparatives 834
Position
2nd term of comp.
Modifiers Establishment in discourse
Attributive Predicative Postpositive Range – than-phrase + than-phrase Range – Modifiers + Modifiers Established Non-established
Factor weight
%
N
0.70 0.40 0.20 50 0.0.54 0.41 13 [0.50] [0.51] [0.38] [0.51]
34.1% 60.3% 5.6%
284 503 47
72.3% 27.7%
603 231
78.5% 21.5% 92.3% 7.7%
655 179 769 64
The log-likelihood values indicate a better fit between the data and the model for the EModE period than for the LMode one (–163 for EModE vs. –427 for LModE, respectively). However, no overlaps between factors were observed in either period.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.32 (106)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
As regards significance, the results show that syntactic position is the factor with the largest range94 in either period. Note, in this connection, that the number of significant factors increases (cf. the presence of a second term of comparison) the closer one gets to the present day. On the whole, one may conclude that the variable rule analysis confirms the suggestions put forward above, i.e. the key role played by syntactic position in the selection of comparative strategy.
. Concluding remarks Recent scholarship on the topic suggests that – together with the phonological and/or morphological factors put forward by the standard literature – the selection of comparative strategy depends on a number of syntactic and cognitive variables; namely, the complexity of the context, the position of the comparative adjective and the presence/absence of a second term of comparison, of infinitival/prepositional complements and of adverbial premodifiers (Section 2 and Section 5.1). These studies were mostly based on the analysis of present-day data (but cf. Mondorf 2007); this chapter intended to investigate the extent to which the same criteria apply to previous stages of the language (i.e. Early and Late Modern English (Section 3)). By means of a corpus-based study of the comparative behaviour of (a group of) disyllabic adjectives, I tested the diachronic validity of the syntactic claims put forward by previous literature. The study revealed that, with the exception of the position of the comparative, none of the syntactic factors mentioned above had a significant influence on the distribution of the comparative modes in EModeLModE (Section 4). A study of the semantics-pragmatics of adjective comparison was subsequently carried out (Section 5). For this study, I first examined the semantic-pragmatic functions, cross-linguistically, of attribution and predication and I found that, from a theoretical point of view, they held with respect to the behaviour of comparative adjectives. The data analysis showed that these functions seemed to be less marked than one would perhaps have expected, at least as regards the correlation between newness of information and periphrastic comparatives, which was considered to be only suggestive. Section 6 was devoted to examining the (possible) influence that (a number of) adverbial intensifiers have on comparison. A qualitative investigation of the semantics of much and far showed that these are semantically-homogenising parti. Range can be defined as “the relative strength exerted by a factor group in an analysis of variation” (Tagliamonte 2007: 242).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:26/06/2008; 15:30
F: CI29904.tex / p.33 (107)
Chapter 4. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in EMode and LMode
cles; i.e. they trigger a particular interpretation of the (inflectional or periphrastic) comparative forms with which they combine: far always creates a contrast between the comparative adjective that it modifies and the preceding context, whereas much-comparatives can either enhance the quality under comparison or create a contrast with this latter depending on the particular characteristics of the context. The chapter was brought to a close by a consideration of the overall significance of and (possible) interaction between the syntactic and semantic factors examined in Sections 4–6. On the whole, the analyses above contributed to a better understanding of the diachronic distribution of the standard comparative strategies. They nevertheless also brought to the fore a number of issues that need further scrutiny. First, I observed above the mismatch between my data analysis and previous (synchronically-oriented) literature in connection to both the syntactic determinants of comparative variation and the theoretical semantic expectations as regards adjective position. One may argue that these discrepancies may be motivated by the establishment of the periphrastic strategy in the language in a slower fashion than has been standardly assumed, or that perhaps the idiosyncrasies of the adjective types selected for the analysis may have skewed the results in a particular direction. At any rate, a new look at the present-day situation under the same parameters is necessary. Second, the analysis of the semantic influence of adverbial intensifiers revealed the importance of the notion of semantic scale for an adequate description of the comparative behaviour (cf. also my comments in relation to examples (28)–(29) in Section 5.5 above). To the best of my knowledge, only Rusieki (1985) and, more recently, Cruse’s (1986; see also Croft & Cruse 2004) model of antonymy have exploited the notion of scale in connection to the behaviour of comparative adjectives – although not in connection to corpus-based material. These issues will be examined in Ch. 5 below.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.1 (109)
chapter
Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
.
Introduction95
Chapter 3 above examined the extent to which the distribution of inflectional and periphrastic comparative structures in early and late Modern English is influenced by the same determinants of variation that previous literature associated to the deployment of comparative strategies in Present-day English (cf. among others, Leech & Culpeper 1997; Mondorf 2003, 2006). The results were, however, not conclusive. They suggested that the factors analysed either did not have a noticeable impact on the selection of comparative strategy or when they did, the results sometimes challenged the syntactic/semantic effects that previous literature had associated with them. This chapter constitutes a natural continuation of the investigation carried out in Ch. 4 above, as it revisits the comparative situation in the present-day as well as exploring the notion of semantic scale from a corpus-based perspective.
. The data The data for this study come from the British National Corpus (henceforth BNC). In keeping with the investigation carried out in Ch. 4 above, the adjectives selected for the analysis were disyllabic and belonged to the following three groups: adjectives ending in unstressed vowel (e.g. friendly), in syllabic /l/ (e.g. simple) and in schwa (e.g. mature). Similar selectional criteria to those mentioned in Ch. 4, Section 3, above were applied to the present-day data. The only exception was the percentage distribution of inflectional and periphrastic tokens across adjective types: given the large(r) size of the BNC (as compared to my EModE and LModE sources), it was decided that the less frequent comparative strategy for
. Unless otherwise stated, the emphasis (i.e. italics/bold) in the examples provided through the chapter is mine (VGD).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.2 (110)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 5.1. BNC disyllabic adjectives analysed Type
Adjective
-Ly class
-Y class
Syllabic /l/ class
Inflectional
Periphrastic
lonely lowly friendly lively
11 (73%) 6 (46%) 47 (41%) 55 (60%)
4 (27%) 7 (54%) 67 (59%) 37 (40%)
weighty scary ready empty angry shaky glossy risky sleepy clumsy cloudy cosy noble feeble
19 (76%) 8 (57%) 23 (31%) 11 (68%) 38 (57%) 7 (88%) 7 (70%) 39 (49%) 3 (33%) 12 (75%) 3 (27%) 20 (59%) 20 (65%) 11 (61%)
6 (24%) 6 (43%) 52 (69%) 5 (32%) 29 (43%) 1 (22%) 3 (30%) 41 (51%) 6 (67%) 4 (25%) 8 (73%) 14 (41%) 11 (35%) 7 (39%)
340 (53%)
308 (47%)
Total (18 types, 648 tokens)
each adjective should account for at least 25% (as opposed to 15% in Ch. 4 above) of the total number of examples of the said adjective. Table 5.1 summarises the BNC adjectives that met the required conditions.
. Syntactic and semantic factors conditioning the choice of comparison . The position of the adjective In keeping with Leech & Culpeper’s (1997: 366) study, my early and late Modern English data suggested some kind of correlation between predicative positions and periphrastic comparison. A similar analysis was performed on the BNC data (see Table 5.2), the results showing that the trend is also observable in PDE.96 Note, however, that my results also reveal a noticeable association between attributive slots and inflectional forms.
. For the sake of coherence with the previous chapter, Table 5.2 records postpositive positions independently from the predicative ones.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.3 (111)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
Table 5.2. Attributive vs. predicative uses in the BNC Position
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
Attributive Predicative Postpositive Overall distribution
152 (67.9%) 179 (44.4%) 9 (42.9) 340 (52.5%)
72 (32.1%) 224 (55.6%) 12 (57.1) 308 (47.5%)
224 (34.4%) 403 (62.2%) 21 (3.2%) 648 (100%)
Table 5.3. Syntactic function and second term of comparison, cross-tabulation Predicative
Attributive
Postpositive
Total
Without than-phrase
Infl. Perip. Total
119 (40%) 181 (60%) 300
148 (68%) 70 (32%) 218
4 (29%) 10 (71%) 14
271 (51%) 261 (49%)
With than-phrase
Infl. Perip. Total
60 (58%) 43 (42%) 103
4 (67%) 2 (33%) 6
5 (71%) 2 (29%) 7
69 (59%) 47 (41%) 116
Total
Infl. Perip. Total
151 (68%) 72 (32%) 224
179 (44%) 224 (56%) 403
9 (43%) 12 (57%) 21
340 (52%) 308 (48%) 648
. Presence of a second term of comparison As in the previous chapter, syntactic position and second term of comparison were cross-tabulated (see Table 5.3) and only predicative comparatives were looked at in more detail. The contexts in which the comparative form appears without a second term of comparison are more numerous in my data. However, when a than-phrase is attested, inflectional comparatives seem to be preferred. The outcome appears to go against the trend observed for the earlier periods of the language, where periphrastic form were slightly more frequent in combination with than-phrases (cf. Section 4.2 in Ch. 4 above). . Presence of adverbial premodifiers Moving on now to the analysis of comparatives premodified by intensifiers, the BNC data suggest that the proportion of modifiers (in particular much, even and far) with inflectional comparatives in present-day English is slightly higher than with periphrastic forms (see Table 5.4):
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.4 (112)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 5.4. Premodifiers and comparative adjectives in the BNC
With intensifiers Without intensifiers Overall distribution
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
70 (46.4%) 273 (53%) 340 (52.5%)
81 (53.6%) 268 (47%) 308 (47.5%)
151 (23.3%) 538 (76.7%) 648 (100%)
. Presence of complements Mondorf ’s (2003, 2006) suggestion regarding the correlation between periphrastic comparatives and infinitive/prepositional complements (IC and PC, respectively) in connection to issues of cognitive complexity was also investigated. All predicative inflectional and periphrastic forms in combination with non-final PCs data were retrieved and compared against the total number of inflectional and periphrastic comparatives in the BNC data. Only three adjectives, i.e. angry, ready and empty provided enough examples for the analysis (see Table 5.5): Table 5.5. Inflectional and periphrastic comparatives with PCs in the BNC Infl. Angry Empty Ready
Without PC Perip.
36 (59%) 10 (71%) 25 (31%)
25 (41%) 4 (29%) 34 (69%)
Infl.
With PC Perip.
2 (33%) 1 (100%) 1 (100%)
4 (67%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
Overall distribution Infl. Perip. 38 (57%) 11 (73%) 16 (32%)
29 (43%) 4 (27%) 34 (68%)
The number of periphrastic comparatives with PCs is higher than the corresponding percentage for inflectional comparatives only in the case of angry; with respect to empty and ready, the (single) comparative example attested with a PC in either case is of the inflectional type. On the whole, the low frequency of PCs in combination with disyllabic adjectives renders my results inconclusive. A similar problem was encountered when trying to measure the influence of IC complements on my data. Once all the possible intervening factors were filtered out, the only adjectives that met the conditions for analysis were ready and friendly. Table 5.6 summarises the overall results of the analysis, Table 5.7 breaks down the data in more detail: Table 5.6. Inflectional and periphrastic comparatives with ICs in the BNC With IC
Without IC
Infl.
Perip.
Infl.
Perip.
8 (33%)
16 (67%)
62 (39%)
99 (61%)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.5 (113)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
Table 5.7. Comparatives with and without ICs (detailed analysis) in the BNC Infl. Ready Friendly
With IC Perip.
7 (32%) 1 (50%)
15 (68%) 1 (50%)
Infl.
Without IC Perip.
11 (27%) 51 (42%)
30 (73%) 69 (58%)
Overall distribution Infl. Perip. 18 (29%) 52 (43%)
45 (71%) 70 (57%)
The results (see Table 5.7) suggest that the presence of ICs does favour the occurrence of the periphrastic mode of comparison. One must nevertheless be very careful in extrapolating the distributional patterns in my data to adjectives in general, as the they seem to be skewed in favour of the comparative tendencies of ready (which, as illustrated in Table 5.1, tends towards periphrastic comparison in 69% of the cases). . Establishment in discourse The syntactic analysis carried out in the sections above is consistent with that of the previous chapter in that it shows that position is the factor that may influence the selection of comparative strategy most clearly. Focusing now on semantics, the corpus-based investigation carried out on the semantic-pragmatic functions of attribution and predication in Ch. 4, Section 5.4 above, revealed that some of these functions hold with respect to the behaviour of comparative adjectives only on a theoretical basis. More specifically, here I am referring to the distribution of inflectional and periphrastic comparison according to whether they introduce a new quality or describe a quality that has already been established in the discourse. This section sets out to analyse the issue in relation to the BNC data (see Table 5.8). In line with the research carried out in the previous chapter, examples where the comparatives are premodified by adverbial intensifiers were excluded from the tally.97 Furthermore, similar constraints regarding what constitutes ‘establishment in discourse’ were applied (cf. Ch. 4, Section 5.5 above). The data shows that, when the quality under comparison has been established in the context, the proportion of periphrastic forms noticeably increases (from 37.4% to 49.5%) – although inflectional forms are, overall, the most frequent option. As for the question of why this should be so, I refer to discourse analysts such as Halliday, who argues that “lexical cohesion results from the choice of a lexical . In Ch. 4 Section 6 above I explored the effect of adverbial intensifiers on the selection of comparative strategy. The results showed that adverbial intensifiers (or at least the adverbial intensifiers selected for the analysis) did not skew the choice to either comparative strategy but instead served as ‘comparative homogenising’ elements. Similar results were obtained for the present-day data and therefore they will not receive any further attention here.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.6 (114)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Table 5.8. Comparatives and establishment in discourse in PDE
Established Not established Overall distribution
Inflectional
Periphrastic
Total
273 (50.5%) 67 (62.2%) 340 (52.5%)
268 (49.5%) 40 (37.4%) 308 (47.5%)
241(83.5%) 107 (16.5%) 648 (100%)
item that is in some sense synonymous with a preceding one” (2004 [1985]: 572). As observed above, the key point here is that the periphrastic strategy leaves the (previously mentioned) adjective completely intact, whereas the inflectional one does not. . Determinants of comparative variation in PDE: A variable rule analysis The sections above revisited the syntactic and semantic determinants explored in Ch. 4 (Sections 4 and 5) above in relation to comparative distribution in EModE and LModE. As in the preceding discussion, an understanding of how they simultaneously constrain the choice of comparison is also needed for the PDE data. As in the preceding chapter, Goldvarb was used to measure the significance of the factors. The goodness-of-fit between the data and the model is illustrated in Figure 5.1. Table 5.9 summarises the results of the multivariate analysis.
Figure 5.1. Scattergram (PDE)
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.7 (115)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
Table 5.9. Inflectional vs. periphrastic comparatives, variable rule analysis (PDE) Significant vs. non significant factors (non-significant factors in brackets) Corrected mean 0.53 Significance: 0.005 Log likelihood –421.207 Total no. of comparatives 648 Factor weight
%
N
Position
Attributive Predicative Postpositive Range
0.69 0.40 0.39 30
34.6% 62.2% 3.2%
224 403 21
2nd term comparison
+ than-phrase – than-phrase Range
0.65 0.47 18
17.9% 82.1%
116 532
Establishment in discourse
Established Non-established Range
0.64 0.47 17
16.5% 83.5%
107 541
Modifiers
– Modifiers + Modifiers
[0.44] [0.52]
76.7% 23.3%
497 151
Table 5.10. Relative strength of significant factors of comparative variation (EModE-PDE) Factors
EModE
LModE
PDE
Position 2nd term of comparison Establishment in discourse Modifiers
21 – – –
50 13 – –
35 18 17 –
The position of the adjective is the factor that seems to exert the greatest influence on the deployment of comparison in PDE. It was also observed above (Ch. 4, Section 7) that the number of significant determinants increases from early to late Modern English (i.e. position (EModE) / position and second term of comparison (LModE)). The present-day situation constitutes a natural continuation to this trend, as ‘establishment in discourse’ has become another statistically significant factor in the data. In addition, note that, from a diachronic perspective, syntactic position appears to be the strongest constraint on comparative variation (see Table 5.10).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.8 (116)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
. Adjective comparison and semantic scales The analysis of the EModE data revealed the presence in the corpora of a number of examples where the comparative (normally an inflectional form) established a contrast with another adjectival quality mentioned in the previous discourse (see Section 5.5 in Ch. 4 above and example (1)): (1) Omnes. A brave blacke villaine. Bal. That’s I; all that brave blacke villaine dwels in me, If I be that blacke villaine; but I am not, A Nobler Character prints out my brow (EMODD.DEKK.NS.)
Examples like (1) above brought to the fore the importance of the notion of ‘semantic scale’, which had so far not been taken into consideration in the study. As observed in Ch. 4, Section 8 above, some previous studies (Rusiecki 1985; Cruse 1986; Croft & Cruse 2004) explored the relevance of the notion in connection with comparative structures. However, as was also observed in the previous chapter, their claims were not tested by a corpus-based investigation. The following section brings together the two aspects (semantic scales and corpora) through an analysis of Cruse’s model of antonymy. . Cruse’s model of antonymy Cruse (1986: 204; cf. also Cruse & Togia 1995; Croft & Cruse 2004) observes that properties “can be conceptualised in terms of “more” and “less”, thus creating a scale.” He further specifies that the system of antonymy comprises not one but two semantic scales: the absolute scale (which “covers all possible values of the scaled property, from zero to infinite”; Cruse 1986: 205) and the relative scale (which is “movable relative to the absolute scale and whose values are directly relatable to the terms of the antonymous pair”; Cruse 1986: 205). The examples under (2)98 below show how the antonymic pair long:short operates on either of the scales: (2) a.
A: How long it is? B: It is quite short b. A: How short is it? B: ?It is quite long
In (2a) long is neutral with respect to the specific length of the referent, i.e. the referent can be intrinsically long or short. This is proved by the fact that a possible answer to the questions would be “it is quite short” without the sentence resulting . The emphasis in (2a) and (2b) is mine (VGD).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.9 (117)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
Length (2a) long
(2b) short
Figure 5.2. Impartial and committed readings (from Cruse & Togia 1995: 118)
in awkwardness. In other words, long in (2a) semantically comprises the meaning of long and short and relates to the absolute scale of ‘length’,99 as illustrated in Figure 5.2 above (Cruse & Togia 1995: 118). In examples like (2a) above, where the antonym operates on the absolute scale, Cruse (1986: 208; cf. Cruse & Togia 1995: 118) argues that the adjective has an impartial reading. Conversely, the question in (2b) entails that the referent of the adjective is indeed short, for an answer analogous to that in (2a) (i.e. “it is quite long”) would be deviant. This means that short in (2b) refers only to that part of the scale where long is excluded, that is, to the “relative” scale of ‘shortness’ (i.e. the one represented in Figure 5.2 as short). Cruse (1986: 209) and Cruse & Togia (1995: 118) claim that in contexts such as the one in (2b) (where the antonym operates on the relative scale), the adjective has a committed reading.100 The difference between impartial (absolute scale) and committed (relative scale) readings allows Cruse (1986: 207; also Cruse & Togia 1995; Croft & Cruse 2004) to differentiate three antonymic types, i.e. polar antonyms (see (3) below), overlapping antonyms (see (4) below) and equipollent antonyms (see (5) below). (3) long:short, heavy:light, fast:slow, thick:thin (4) sweet:sour, polite:rude, clean:dirty (5) nice:nasty, hot:cold, happy:sad
Each term of a polar antonym has both committed and impartial interpretations. The comparative examples under (6) below illustrate the impartial uses of the polar antonymic pair heavy:light, as in either case they map on to the scale of ‘weight’ (as opposed to their respective scales of ‘lightness’/‘heaviness’). The examples under (7) feature the corresponding committed readings of each comparative adjective (in these cases the mapping of the adjectival quality takes place within . In fact, it would be in fact possible to reformulate the question as “what is its length?” . Note, however, that short can also have an impartial meaning in contexts like The third Harry Potter book is long, but it’s shorter than the seventh book – where shorter does not mean that the book is intrinsically ‘of reduced length.’
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.10 (118)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
the ‘light’ and ‘heavy’ relative scales; i.e. the boxes are, respectively, inherently heavy/light; cf. also Figure 5.3):
Weight
(6a, b)
(7a) light
(7b) heavy
Figure 5.3. Scalar representation of polar antonyms (from Cruse & Togia 1995: 116–117)
(6) a. This box is light, but it’s heavier than that one101 b. This box is heavy, but it’s lighter than that one (7) a. This box is light, but that one is lighter b. This box is heavy, but that one is heavier
In the overlapping class, both terms have committed interpretations but only one term of the pair has impartial readings (cf. example (8a). Note that (8b) below shows that, unlike polite, rude does not have an impartial interpretation; see also Figure 5.4):
(8a)
polite
Politeness 0 Rudeness rude (8b)
Figure 5.4. Scalar representation of overlapping antonyms (from Cruse & Togia 1995: 116–117)
(8) a. Pam is rude, but she’s politer/more polite than Kay b. ?Pam is polite, but she’s ruder/more rude than Kay
. Example adapted from Cruse (1986: 206). The emphasis is mine (VGD).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.11 (119)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
As for equipollent antonyms, the two terms of the pair have committed interpretations only (see (9)102 and Figure 5.5):103
Coldness (9a) hot
Hotness (9b) cold
Figure 5.5. Scalar representation of equipollent antonyms (from Cruse & Togia 1995: 116–117)
(9) a. ?It is cold, but it’s hotter than yesterday b. ?It is hot, but it’s colder than yesterday
I would like to turn now to the analysis of comparative constructions proper, since, as has been shown by examples above, it is in comparative contexts that the differences between impartial and committed readings are better exemplified. . Cruse’s true- and pseudo-comparative constructions Compare the following two examples from the BNC: (10) a.
She moved over to the window, staring out into the darkness. There was a long silence. (. . .) The telephone rang, sounding unnaturally strident in the quiet room. (. . .) They heard Alex Mair’s voice. (. . .) Then there was a longer silence, then Mair’s voice again (BNC.C8T1598) b. Gloria had two white woollen socks. (. . .) One was longer than the other and a different, more yellowy, shade of white (BNC.AC5379)
Example (10a) illustrates a committed use of longer, as it establishes an explicit contrast between the length of the first and the second moment of silence: the second silence is “long to a greater degree” than the first silence, which is intrinsically long. Cruse (1986: 206) calls comparative constructions with committed interpretations “true comparatives”, because, as their name indicates, they establish a real comparison between the degrees of a given property. . The italics in the examples under (9) are mine (VGD). . Cruse (1986: 208) also points to a semantic difference between the three antonymic types. Polar antonyms denote objective properties that are calibrated in conventional units (e.g. weight, speed, length, etc.), equipollent antonyms describe subjective sensations and emotions and overlapping antonyms have an evaluative polarity (one term being commendatory, the other deprecatory).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.12 (120)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
By contrast, in (10b) longer has an impartial reading, for it does not mean that either of the socks has the quality of being long (in fact, both of them could be short, one having ‘greater length’ than the other). Comparative sentences with impartial interpretations are called “pseudo-comparative” constructions (Cruse 1986: 206), because they do not make a real comparison between degrees, but rather they only denote that the referent of the noun (in (10b), one of the socks) has “more of property X” than another referent (in (10b), the other sock), without either of the referents possessing the property itself (in example (10b), the property of being long).104 Cruse & Togia (1995: 128; cf. also Croft & Cruse 2004: 177) establish a correlation between true and pseudo-comparatives on the one hand, and inflectional and periphrastic comparatives on the other, by means of what they call the Principle of Exposure. This (iconic) principle holds that the more “exposed” or transparent an adjective, the greater its correlation with the relative scale (and therefore, with committed interpretations) and vice-versa: the less exposed an adjective, the greater its tendency to be interpreted against the absolute scale. Now, if one examines comparative structures in the light of the Principle of Exposure, one will realise that the adjectival root of inflectional comparative structures is, due to the addition of the suffix -er (e.g. friendlier), somehow less transparent than that of their periphrastic counterparts (i.e. the bare adjectival root preceded by the adverbial quantifier more; e.g. more friendly). From this it follows that inflectional forms should be more easily associated with the absolute scale and, in consequence, with impartial readings. Conversely, periphrastic forms, being more “exposed”, should be more frequently attested in committed constructions. Cruse & Togia (1995: 129; also Croft & Cruse 2004: 178) provide the examples105 reproduced below in order to support their claim: (11) a. Process X is fast, but is nonetheless slower than process Y b. ?Process X is fast, but nonetheless more slow than process Y
They suggest that the reason why more slow in (11b) is deviant when compared to slower in (11a) is that the context requires an impartial interpretation, which, according to the Principle of Exposure, is at odds with the tendency of periphrastic comparatives towards committed readings. In addition, Croft & Cruse (2004: 178) . This idea of impartial constructions where no ‘real’ comparison is established seems to be in line with Hamamoto’s (1993) fuzzy-theoretical approach to adjective comparison. He suggests that “adjectival expressions . . . reflect the utterer’s subjective judgement” of the differences existing in the real world (Hamamoto 1993: 18); in other words, what the speakers perceive as true or real (as opposed to what the reality or truth really is). . The emphasis in the examples under (11) is mine.
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.13 (121)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
observe that morphological (i.e. inflectional) comparison is the ‘default’ comparative variety and therefore, the one that attracts the priority construal. One may wonder, however, whether another factor favouring the oddness of (11b) above may be that, all other things being equal, monosyllabic adjectives strongly tend towards inflectional comparatives. Unfortunately, neither Cruse & Togia (1995) nor Croft & Cruse (2004) give further illustrative examples of how the Principle of Exposure works on comparatives (especially in disyllabic adjectives, since, as observed above, they are the group that most easily take periphrastic forms). I have already mentioned that Cruse’s antonymic distinctions offer a valuable account of how adjectives map onto the different semantic scales. His system, however, also has some shortcomings. Firstly, as he himself observes (Cruse 1986: 207), only polar antonyms and one term of the overlapping antonymic type have both impartial and committed interpretations. This means that the correlation between impartial readings/pseudo-comparatives/inflectional forms and committed readings/true comparatives/periphrastic forms can only be successfully applied to a small subset of adjectives. Secondly, Cruse’s (1986) and Cruse & Togia’s (1995) scale distinctions are drawn on a limited number of sentence-based examples made up by the linguists themselves (e.g. I observed above that the only examples provided to support the validity of their Principle of Exposure are the ones reproduced in (11) above). Some difficulties arise when one tries to apply their neat classification of antonymic uses to contextualised data. Thus, the comparative examples in Cruse’s studies (1986; Cruse & Togia 1995; Croft & Cruse 2004) seem to suggest that committed interpretations are only established within a single scale. For examples, consider examples (12) and (13) below (taken from Cruse 1986: 207) and their scalar representation: (12) It’s hot today It’s hotter today than yesterday (13) a. This box is less heavy than that one b. This box is not as light as that one
(Coldness) cold
Figure 5.6. Committed interpretations, hotter
(Hotness) hot
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.14 (122)
English adjective comparison: A historical perspective
Weight (13a)
(13b) heavy
light
Figure 5.7. Committed interpretations, heavier vs. lighter
In these examples, a contrast of degree (of hotness/heaviness/lightness) is established within the respective relative scales of hot, heavy and light; in other words, the entities compared share the same adjectival quality (see Figures 5.6 and 5.7). However, it is not difficult to find corpus examples that cannot be accommodated within Cruse’s notion of committedness: (14) Claire watches the two men grapple. They have mud in their eyes, on their stomachs, dripping down their thighs. They are tired, grunting. Keith is by far the most graceful. His skin is smooth and shiny, his muscles ripple. The other man is bigger, clumsier, and Claire cannot believe the bulge between his legs. She wants Keith to win (BNC.HGU1909)
According to Cruse’s classification, clumsy, being the “sub” term106 of an equipollent antonymic pair (i.e. skilful:clumsy), can only have a committed (i.e. contrast of degree) interpretation. However, unlike in examples (12)–(13), in (14) above one cannot interpret the form clumsier as indicating a contrast in the degree of clumsiness between Keith and the “other man” who Claire is observing, since the context makes it clear that Keith is not a clumsy person. What this example reveals, then, is the possibility of establishing a different kind of contrast (see Section 4.3.1.2) through a ‘crossing’ from one scale (in this case, the scale of skilfulness/gracefulness) to another (in this case, the scale of clumsiness; see Figure 5.8). Examples (15) to (17) below further illustrate this cross-scale comparative meaning (observe the ‘jump’ or qualitative change from hostile to friendly in (15) and (16) and from cold to cosy in (17) below). It is perhaps interesting to observe here that the context seems to have an impact on the perception of the comparative scales. In (15) and (16) below we have the same positive adjective being compared, i.e. friendly. However, while in (15) below the change from hostile to friendly seems to occur in a gradual fashion, bringing the two qualities closer together (note, in . The “sub” term (as opposed to the “supra” term) of an antonymic pair conveys a low(er) value of the property (i.e. long, the “supra” term of the antonymic pair long/short, means “more than average length”, while short – the “sub” term – denotes the lack of that property, cf. Ljung 1974: 74).
TSL[v.20020404] Prn:29/07/2008; 14:23
F: CI29905.tex / p.15 (123)
Chapter 5. Inflectional v. periphrastic comparison in Present-day English
Gracefulness graceful
Clumsiness clumsy
Figure 5.8. Semantic representation of clumsier in (14)
this connection, the use of turned), in (16) the semantic scale is left implicit and friendly seems to be used in a more absolute sense (Olga Fischer, p.c.). (15) Electronic soup AT&T’s hostile bid for NCR turned a lot friendlier when Ma Bell met the computer company’s asking price of $110 a share, though none of the $7.5 billion will be in cash (BNC.ABJ2955) (16) She woke up in the morning feeling heavy-eyed and with a dull headache lurking behind her eyes. She picked unenthusiastically at the breakfast she made for herself (. . .) Jessamy shaded her aching eyes from its brightness, and wished it would rain. She wanted the weather to be gloomy and overcast, with lots of black clouds to match her mood. “Are you in a more friendly mood this morning?” Julius enquired, moving silently up behind her. Jessamy jumped violently (BNC.H8F2308) (17) “You go down and get it, while I make a fire in the living-room. This place is like a morgue” (. . .) He loped down into the basement, dusted off half a dozen bottles of beer and brought them up, found glasses and an opener and took them into the living-room on a tray. His father, an expert woodsman, had already got a fire going, and the room had lost some of its pristine newness and was looking much more cosy (BNC.CDN1458)
This type of comparative readings needs to be accommodated within a semanticpragmatic classification of comparative adjectives (see Section 4.3 below). . Semantic-pragmatic differences between inflectional and periphrastic comparatives .. The system I concluded above that Cruse’s (1986; Croft & Cruse 2004) antonymic system may be too restricted to accommodate the variation found in English comparatives. Taking the BNC data described in Table 5.1 ab