EMPOWERING FRAIL ELDERLY PEOPLE
EMPOWERING FRAIL ELDERLY PEOPLE Opportunities and Impediments in Housing, Health, and ...
30 downloads
2680 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
EMPOWERING FRAIL ELDERLY PEOPLE
EMPOWERING FRAIL ELDERLY PEOPLE Opportunities and Impediments in Housing, Health, and Support Service Delivery Edited by Leonard F. Heumann, Mary E. McCall, and Duncan P. Boldy
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Empowering frail elderly people : opportunities and impediments in housing, health, and support service delivery / edited by Leonard F. Heumann, Mary E. McCall, and Duncan P. Boldy. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–275–96651–8 (alk. paper) 1. Frail elderly—Services for—United States. I. Heumann, Leonard. II. McCall, Mary E., 1960– III. Boldy, Duncan P., 1941– HV1461.E464 2001 362.6—dc21 00–025465 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright 2001 by Leonard F. Heumann, Mary E. McCall, and Duncan P. Boldy All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 00–025465 ISBN: 0–275–96651–8 First published in 2001 Praeger Publishers, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. www.praeger.com Printed in the United States of America TM
The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48–1984). 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Copyright Acknowledgments The editors and publisher gratefully acknowledge permission for use of portions of Chapter 8 based on the articles “Aging in conventional housing: A planner’s evaluation of the new Australian home based care management programs,” parts I and II, by Leonard F. Heumann. Originally published in Australian Planner, XXXIV 3, 4 (1997). Reprinted with permission from the publisher. Figures 9.1, 9.2, and 9.3 Kirkwood Design Studio.
This book is dedicated to Rob, Sarena, Chris, Aaron, Gina, Micah, Sydney, and Allena; to Tom, Betty, Frank, Andrew, Colby and the residents of Satellite Housing, Inc.; and to Arthur, Ruth, David and Phillip Boldy.
Contents
Preface
xi
Part I. Introduction 1
2
Empowerment: Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects Mary E. McCall, Leonard F. Heumann, and Duncan P. Boldy
3
Opportunities and Impediments in Housing, Health, and Support Service Delivery Leonard F. Heumann, Duncan P. Boldy, and Mary E. McCall
25
Part II. Service Providers and Empowerment: Information, Training, and Coordination 3
4
Promoting Empowerment in Residential Aged Care: Seeking the Consumer View Duncan P. Boldy and Linda E. Grenade
41
Reimagining Senior Empowerment in Service Delivery: Creative Applications in a Global Context Mary E. McCall
53
viii
5
6
Contents
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment in the Transition from a Family to a Community-Oriented Support System: Japan in the 21st Century Tokie Anme Empowerment in Post-Reform Community Care in England and Wales Bleddyn Davies
65
81
Part III. Environment and Empowerment in Conventional Housing 7
8
9
Another Way of Living in One’s Own Home: The Salmon Group Projects Robin Currie, Marie-Jo Guisset, and Niek de Boer The Role of the Built Environment in Holistic Delivery of Home- and Community-Based Care Services to Frail Elderly Persons Leonard F. Heumann When Community Planning Becomes Community Building: Place-Based Activism and the Creation of Good Places to Grow Old Philip B. Stafford
101
119
137
Part IV. Client Empowerment in Long-Term Care 10
11
12
13
The Rights of Elderly People in a Nursing Home—A Little Creativity, a Lot of Respect, a Taste for Adventure, and an Allergy to Bureaucracy Germain Harvey. Translated by James Lawler
155
Bringing Managed Health Care Home: A New Service Strategy for People with Chronic Illnesses and Disabilities Dennis L. Kodner, Meg Sherlock, and Jonathan Shankman
175
Elderly Persons with Severe Mental Illness: Empowering a Neglected and Growing Population Paul H. Carmichael
191
Older People with Longstanding Disabilities and Their Caregivers: Empowering a Neglected and Growing Population Lindsay Gething
205
Contents
ix
Part V. Overview and the Future 14
15
Empowerment in Pathways Through Care: A Cross-National Comparison of Care Delivery Systems in Britain and Germany Michaela Schunk
223
Empowerment of Frail Elderly People and the Vision of a Self-Actualized Society Duncan P. Boldy, Mary E. McCall, and Leonard F. Heumann
239
References
255
Index
273
About the Editors and Contributors
279
Preface
“Empowerment” is a term that has become increasingly applied in various human service fields to efforts aimed at both giving power to individuals, or removing obstacles that people may face in attempting to make decisions for themselves. These decisions can occur in such diverse arenas of one’s life as education, health care, living and employment circumstances. In this book, we specifically examine the impediments that frail older persons face in securing and maintaining power over their own housing, health and social service needs and desires. As the number of frail older people continue to increase in industrialized countries around the world, the need for sustaining the rights of older persons to make such decisions for themselves is becoming critical. Understanding the myriad mechanisms and constraints on older persons’ empowerment will help us identify the ways in which we unwittingly contribute to stripping people of the power and dignity that all persons deserve to retain. Properly identified and understood, we can then make our best efforts to both remove barriers to, and increase opportunities for, true empowerment of older frail people, who deserve, as do we all, the right to make decisions for themselves. This includes decisions that others may deem to be unreasonable, unsafe or risky. The case studies in this book provide concrete and creative models of ways to preserve the dignity of frail elderly persons in a variety of housing, health and social service settings. All of the authors uphold the value of honoring the autonomy and freedom of older persons, regardless of their physical, health or mental status. We aim, in this book, to map out theoretically, the broad range of impediments to empowerment that fall into four main areas (service provision, environment, client-related, and society-related), and then to present ex-
xii
Preface
emplary approaches to overcoming some of these impediments. This book, then, is addressed to service providers, health professionals, housing and environmental designers, policymakers, caregivers, and older persons themselves. Chapter 1 is divided into two parts. The first analyzes various conceptual approaches to the notion of empowerment, and the second examines changing societal values and how the values a nation espouses directly affect the efforts to increase or maintain the power of frail elderly persons. Chapter 2 outlines the theoretical framework of this book, in which all of the case studies are embedded. This framework provides an analytic structure for the evaluation of various impediments to empowerment. The four components of this framework are provider-based, environment-based, client-based, and societal-based limits or impediments to true empowerment and provide a reference point for the remaining chapters. We believe the case studies chosen for inclusion in this book together reflect universal values and provide meaning and interest to persons in all countries who seek to maximize personal control and functional independence for even their most frail elderly citizens. Chapters 3 through 6 address issues of empowerment related to service providers. Chapters 3 and 4 outline specific methods of increasing the involvement of older persons themselves in the design and evaluation of services. Chapter 5 analyzes the major cultural changes happening in Japan and the efforts to increase empowerment of older persons in the face of diminishing family caregiving. Chapter 6 provides a unique broad-stroke analysis of the economic implications of choosing empowerment as a social goal over other potential goals, such as increasing the number of days one is able to stay in one’s own home. Chapters 7 through 9 examine the challenges to empowerment within housing and environmental arenas. Chapter 7 presents a unique approach to housing design across Europe by the Salmon Group, setting out how group members in different countries actively enlist older persons in designing their own housing and neighborhood environments. Chapter 8 describes an Australian study that analyzed service providers’ knowledge of and attitudes toward housing adaptations that remove barriers and introduce physical changes that make it easier to live independently and thus empower the resident. Chapter 9 outlines the process an entire American community went through to design housing and services to accommodate the needs of all generations in the community. Chapters 10 to 13 address client impediments to empowerment in longterm care settings. Chapter 10 describes a unique living environment in Canada where design of buildings, daily schedules and the like begin with the desires of the residents themselves. Chapter 11 presents a proposed new approach to home care for frail elderly persons in the U.S., describing the impediments of traditional care systems for the frail that this new program
Preface
xiii
is designed to overcome. Chapter 12 examines the needs of a critically neglected population—older persons with severe mental illness. Similarly, chapter 13 addresses the empowerment of an under-noticed and underserved segment of older persons—those with long-standing disabilities. Chapters 14 and 15 are designed to step back and examine from a broad, societal perspective, how policies of different countries reflect different value systems. Chapter 14 specifically compares Great Britain and Germany by analyzing how their policies are manifested in different concrete service systems, with divergent consequences for potential empowerment of frail elderly persons. In our final chapter, we present a vision of a fully selfactualized society, where members of all ages are truly empowered to the full extent of their desires and capabilities. We hope that the examples set forth in this book inspire us all to reach our highest goals of freedom, dignity and respect for all—of any age, and in any country. Leonard F. Heumann University of Illinois Mary E. McCall St. Mary’s College of California Duncan P. Boldy Curtin University, Perth, Australia
PART I
INTRODUCTION
1
Empowerment: Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects Mary E. McCall, Leonard F. Heumann, and Duncan P. Boldy
In a mountainous region of southern Appalachia in the United States, an impoverished 75-year-old man, who is functionally deaf but lip-reads proficiently, proudly displays his new walker. He has had both legs amputated below the knees and wears ill-fitting prosthetic legs. With his new walker, made of PVC plastic pipe by his neighbors, he can happily hobble to the front of the yard where his two-room, cement-walled, tin-roofed house sits uneasily on a sloping cement floor. Here he can lean awkwardly on a crate by the street and talk with the young men and women who gather to play cards and the children who play among the rubble. He is known in the neighborhood as the “wizard” because of his vast knowledge of history and geography. The young man who lives with his small children and wife (who cooks and does laundry for the older neighbor) in the front two-room cement “house” of the “yard,” admirably remarks. “You can ask him anything about that stuff—he knows it all.” While this older man would qualify for government-funded nursing home care, he chooses to stay in his own neighborhood where he is comfortable and well known. In a suburb of San Francisco, California, a well-educated, very wealthy 80-year-old man is taken from the assisted living facility where he has recently moved, following the death of his wife of 60 years. His children are concerned that he is being “taken advantage” of by a woman who lives in his building—she comes over too often, according to the children, and seems to be “taking over” his life. They are afraid that he is too vulnerable and does not know how to protect himself from such people. He is unhappy about leaving, as he now has the ability to be with people his own age and
4
Empowering Frail Elderly People
have things done for him (meals, laundry, etc.). He accedes to his children’s wishes and moves to another facility of their choosing. In the United States, the “land of the free,” which of these men has more freedom or power to choose for himself what makes him happy? Who has more control over his life? Words such as control, freedom, and power conjure up in our mind pictures of older people making choices for themselves that lead to happy and fulfilling lives. We often assume that, given such control or power, people will make the best possible choices for themselves and utilize all their faculties and resources to assess the available options and maximize their outcome. “But for the elderly, particular conditions affecting their choice-making are entailed by structural and contextual issues” (Rubinstein, Kilbride & Nagy, 1992, p. 4). This chapter is divided into two parts that address both components of the types of situations just described—making choices and what that means to different people, and the structural and social contextual issues that affect decision making by frail older persons. First, we start with a definition of the term “empowerment” and how it might apply to frail elderly people. This first section will show that to some researchers and practitioners empowerment means better “informed” clients, care managers and providers; to others it means clients who are better able to “voice” their perspectives and desires to providers who are better able to listen; to others it means “expanding choices” and options in care delivery; and to others it means giving frail adults greater participation in, and control over, their own care planning and management. The “idealistic” degree of ultimate empowerment is often defined as full control of planning and management of care and all the risks of deciding one’s own fate. Using P. G. Clark’s (1989) four philosophical interpretations of the concept of empowerment, we examine the ways in which empowerment has been defined, applied and evaluated in various service arenas. In this chapter, and this book, our goal is to show that all these definitions may be useful and meaningful in the right setting. But the key is allowing and encouraging all seniors to understand and realize their abilities and desires to meet their needs related to independence. Then we must allow them to control their care planning and delivery to the margin of that ability, desire and need. For them to do this, they need to be served by formal and informal caregivers who understand the meaning and support the achievement of a desired level of personal independence in a flexible and accommodating way. In the second part of this chapter, we look at changing societal values and the aging process. We do this by first presenting a continuum of social value models developed by H. R. Moody (1976). Moody defined four models or stages of support and care for seniors that represent a progression toward more enlightened philosophies of care. These are (1) rejection; (2) social service; (3) participation, and (4) self-actualization. Moody states, and we
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
5
agree, that most advanced societies are currently in transition between stages 2 and 3, the models of social service and participation. However, full empowerment can occur only when society reaches a self-actualization model where acceptance of and empathy toward all stages of the life cycle has risen to a higher and equally valuable status. As we will argue here, many formal service institutions, individual professional care providers and many elderly persons and their informal support networks still believe in a “social service” model of support and care where only trained “professionals” should be empowered with care planning, management and delivery. Despite rhetoric that espouses true empowerment of frail elderly persons, this widespread consumer acceptance or the belief in the submission of care control in older age to professionals is the key impediment to more enlightened and progressive forms of empowerment. Fuller examination of this and other impediments and illustrations or case studies related to how they can be creatively addressed and overcome shape the entirety of the book. EMPOWERMENT: MANY THINGS TO MANY PEOPLE P. G. Clark (1989), in his article titled “The Philosophical Foundations of Empowerment,” presents four interpretations of empowerment with regard to older persons and their health care. However, these interpretations are appropriate enough to apply to almost any arena of service for frail elderly people. These four interpretations are (1) empowerment as effective deliberation and moral reflection; (2) empowerment as personal process; (3) empowerment as political activism and social process; and (4) empowerment as balance and interdependence. Each of these bears reflection in terms of the ways in which they have been utilized most recently in research, practice and service design and delivery for older people in countries around the world. Empowerment as Effective Deliberation and Moral Reflection In this first interpretation, Clark is referring to empowering individuals in contexts where personal decision making should be with the greatest reflection. For example, arenas of one’s life that might have a major impact on the day-to-day quality of the person’s life (e.g., housing environs, level of service desired or provided) may all be affected by how and what decisions are made. He states that the notion of autonomy is “helpful in drawing our attention to two essential decision-making elements: effective deliberation and moral reflection” (p. 5). These two factors are two of what Liaschenko (1998) refers to as “the four senses of autonomy.” The other two are free action and authenticity. The concept of autonomy has been one that has been extensively discussed in the field of gerontology and debated as to the
6
Empowering Frail Elderly People
extent of practical application that can be safely engaged in when designing and implementing services for the elderly. Collopy (1988, cf. Hofland, 1990a) defined autonomy as “a cluster of notions including self-determination, freedom, independence, liberty of choice and action. In its most general terms, autonomy signals control of decisionmaking and other activity by the individual. It refers to the human agency free of outside intervention and interference” (p. 5). But the application of the principle of autonomy in the variety of circumstances in which many older people find themselves complicates the seemingly noncontroversial notion of allowing people to make choices for themselves, based on their personal values and preferences. For example, Hofland (1990a) delineates more specific dimensions of autonomy where the elderly are concerned—the physical dimension and the psychological dimension. The physical dimension refers to environmental freedom of movement and the lowest level of physical restrictions. The psychological dimension is related to the ability to freely make choices about one’s environment and to exercise control. And, while one may be completely physically dependent or unable to exercise physical autonomy, this ought not prevent that person from being able to exercise psychological autonomy in making choices about his or her care, environment, and so on. Collopy (1990) distinguishes between “decisional autonomy” and “autonomy of execution.” The former, closely related to the psychological dimension just described, means the “capacity and freedom” to make choices and decisions. The latter refers to “the ability and freedom to carry out such decisions.” Thus, while one may not be able to physically execute decisions, this limitation should not prevent one from being able to make a choice that directs others to implement it. One of the most vexing concerns that many people hesitate to face when discussing autonomy and older persons is the real possibility that some people may choose to exercise autonomy in ways that others (many times family members or service providers) judge to be risky or not in their best interests (Collopy, 1990; Hofland, 1990a; Liaschenko, 1998; Rice, Beck & Stevenson, 1997; Rubinstein, Kilbride & Nagy, 1992). What do we do when 89year-old Dad insists that he can still drive, and refuses to surrender his car keys? Or when Mother refuses to move out of her home of 45 years, even though it’s in a state of severe disrepair? Not uncommon occurrences, these circumstances place the question squarely on the table of when, and under what circumstances, elderly persons should be allowed to exercise their autonomy, even when dangerous results may occur. As Young (1990) states, “The very nature of autonomy is that individuals are able to choose against themselves if they wish.” The ethical principles involved in this dilemma pit autonomy against beneficence. There may be an inherent conflict between the older person’s judgment of what is best for himself and the judgment of another about the risks involved. Young points out that while American society sees itself as the epitome of independence and claims autonomy and
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
7
dignity for many, we have yet to develop a “communal sense” of what is most important in the care of frail elderly people in our society. Many other countries have social policies that reflect more socialistic attitudes about the rights of older persons to exercise their own best judgment, and will intervene only if there is sufficient risk involved (see Chapter 8 for a discussion of some Western European countries that are developing such approaches to housing design). Collopy (1990) also discusses the danger of judging an older person to be incompetent based on the fact that she is making a choice with which other people may not agree. He says, “to judge the reasonableness of a decision, [others] ought to view her decision not from some outside professional standard of care, but from her perspective, from the woman’s own attempt to balance pain and purpose in what might be the finale of her life.” This is where Liaschenko’s third “sense of autonomy” may apply—that of “authenticity.” As Liaschenko (1998) defines it, “autonomy as authenticity means a person’s actions are congruent with his or her beliefs, attitudes, values, dispositions and life plans. In other words, the person is acting ‘in character.’ ” Such an approach is exemplified by a program in Montreal, Canada, which provides a “Life Context Advisor” to each resident in a residence for frail elderly people (Harvey, 1997; see Chapter 10 herein). This advisor calls for nursing home patients to reassess priorities for an individual and design a unique service program based on that person’s values and needs. And while the exercise of autonomy is obviously complicated by issues of cognitive incapacity, the fine line between supporting a person’s wishes, even in the face of potential risk and danger to him, remains to be carefully evaluated by service providers and family members alike. Rubinstein, Kilbride and Nagy (1992) also argue that even in limiting circumstances, such as a nursing home or other institutional setting, independence and autonomy may be relatively defined by older persons, as opposed to absolutely defined by older persons. “People who are, say, merely physically impaired may feel themselves to be considerably more independent compared to someone with profound cognitive impairments. Practically, one person’s notion of his independence may be different from another’s notion of her independence.” Thus, independence or autonomy are defined individually, and in the context of that individual’s unique set of values and personal history. This notion of being authentic to one’s own set of values is important to discuss because we believe it can lead the way to understanding in a more complex way the manner in which older people may make choices for themselves that others (health care providers, family members, etc.) may not understand or agree with. Authenticity is related to another dimension of autonomy delineated by Hofland (1990b)—the spiritual dimension. Hofland defines this dimension as “an expanded concept of self.” He believes that it is not simply that people are able to make choices for themselves, but
8
Empowering Frail Elderly People
that those decisions must be consistent with people’s personal values and goals and the meaning with which they imbue their life. For example, a person living in a nursing home might choose to bring with her personal items that have special meaning—photos, a small table, and so on. This ability to shape her immediate environment in a meaningful way contributes to the better mental health and well-being of that resident (Rubinstein, Kilbride & Nagy, 1992). An understanding of what is important to an individual can often be deduced from his or her choices. For example, an older couple, one of whom suffers from deteriorating cognitive abilities, may choose to remain at home, even given the extraordinary burden of caregiving that such a choice places on the lucid spouse. If the family (and, perhaps, their physician) knows that this decision is consistent with the values that couple has maintained throughout their lives with each other, there may be a greater degree of comfort with the choice, and a greater willingness to support that decision. Liaschenko (1998) poses the question of whether the person’s cognitive impairment necessarily means that such a choice is inauthentic. With proper discussion and deliberation, as well as reflection upon the choices made by an individual in light of who that person has been in the past, and who she hopes to be in the future, support of the empowerment of the older person to make and implement those choices may be more likely. Thus, effective deliberation and moral reflection related to empowerment suggests that older persons and their families can benefit from support when making decisions about services and housing. The amount of time needed for such deliberations and reflections is often protracted as each elderly person copes with marginal changes in his or her functional independence, thus making empowerment a process rather than an “outcome.” Empowerment as Personal Process Clark (1989) also defines empowerment as a personal process requiring the kind of time noted above for advance planning to help older persons and their families both to make decisions and to prepare and/or access support systems needed to help them face future challenges (e.g., increasing frailty). Part of this process is helping individuals and families articulate not only their values, but also their preferences, feelings and fears about possible future scenarios. Programs and services are needed to help focus discussions on these issues, since they rarely arise during “normal” day-to-day conversations. Most such conversations take place in emergency rooms (i.e., regarding choices about employing life-saving measures to save a person’s life) or prior to hospital discharge (i.e., whether to go home again, to an interim care facility or to a long-term facility). Some view advance planning as a moral responsibility in which all older
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
9
persons should engage (Pratt, Schmall & Wright, 1987). However, the vast majority of elderly people cannot plan for unknown, and largely unhoped for, future contingencies. Moreover, without adequate resources to actualize any potential plans (e.g., saving enough money for home care), the notion of requiring people to make long-range plans for themselves seems naı¨ve. While many countries around the world are attempting to devise financial, medical, social or housing schemes that facilitate such planning (e.g., continuing care facilities in the United States or Sweden’s movement from a welfare “state” to a “welfare society,” with the meaning of welfare as individual well-being, not welfare as charity or entitlement programs [Henning & Karp, 1997]), most are far off from achieving that goal. Thus, empowerment remains largely a personal phenomenon in the midst of slow-moving social and institutional change. Personal empowerment has also been defined by Gibson (1991) as a “process of recognizing, promoting and enhancing people’s ability to meet their own needs, solve their own problems and mobilize necessary resources in order to feel in control of their own lives” (p. 359). She sees empowerment as a transaction between the individual and providers. She and others (Nystrom & Segesten, 1994; Vander Henst, 1997) agree with Clark that empowerment is a developmental process that will take different forms for different people. Empowerment is a complex concept to define and sometimes, according to Gibson (1991), is more easily understood in its absence: powerlessness, helplessness, hopelessness, paternalism, and an external locus of control and dependency. There have been many studies of programs designed to build empowerment in the elderly, often through the removal of impediments to individuals’ abilities to make choices for themselves. But, as noted before, these strategies often assume that people will become empowered in the way we hope them to be, or that they will even choose to take the power they may have access to. Again, empowerment for some people might be to give that power to someone else—to consciously allow another to make and implement decisions for them (Jones, 1998; Vander Henst, 1997). Another important issue related to the development of empowerment is the role of history—both individual and social—in allowing some persons to claim power and others to be unable to. How can empowerment occur for individuals and groups whose experience over their lives has been one of being marginalized and alienated from mainstream health and/or social services? Groups such as the very poor, those with low levels of formal education, minorities and immigrants, may not even understand the concept of empowerment, never having had experience with it in perhaps any arena of their lives (McMillian & Preston, 1996; Simons-Morton & Krump, 1996; Skelton, 1994; Wallace, Fox & Napier, 1996). As noted above, there may be individual differences in the desire for control. In the United States, with the generation born and raised before World War II, it is common to find
10
Empowering Frail Elderly People
that individuals are not comfortable challenging authority figures such as physicians. And in Sweden, where large generational differences in perspectives on one’s role in one’s own health care have been observed, it can be seen that current generations of older people may perceive personal power and empowerment in a very different way than the researchers and service providers might wish them to. For example, elderly women, especially, feel it is more important to be seen as self-sacrificing and non-effacing than to be assertive or seen as aggressively desiring power (Nystrom & Segesten, 1994). Patient empowerment may also contradict some cultural practices in which major decisions may be made by the family patriarch, or by family consensus (Alvarez, 1997). Thus, the notion that empowerment is only a personal process is simplistic. There are clearly a number of other factors affecting any one individual’s ability to engage in the process of becoming empowered. For example, according to Kari and Michels (1991), the word “power” means “to be able.” Empowerment, therefore, is not something one does to or for another person, they claim, but rather, is “the ability to act collectively to solve problems and influence important issues. Empowerment occurs when parties influence one another” (p. 722). Therefore, to participate in empowering someone means to participate with them rather than doing something for them or something to them. “The broader goal of the creation of an empowering environment in which persons can assume control over their lives and establish meaningful roles cannot be easily achieved” (Kari & Michels, 1991 724). Empowerment as Political Activism and Social Process The creation of such an empowering environment requires more than a personal process; ultimately, it must include political and social processes (Vander Henst, 1997). Clark (1989) agrees with Kari and Michels (1991) when he notes that “it does little good to speak of personal empowerment without considering the need for sufficient social resources to enable individuals to exercise choice in their lives. Asking people to make decisions in a world with very few or no options—because of inadequate food, clothing, or shelter—is simply a mockery of empowerment. The distribution of social resources is ultimately a problem based on the principle of social justice” (p. 271). Stoller and Gibson (1994) raise the question of how public policy can serve to compensate for life course histories of groups (e.g., ethnic and minority older people) that have traditionally been undeserved in many social and health service arenas. In the United States, advocacy groups such as the AARP (American Association of Retired Persons) have worked to ensure that more elderly Americans have opportunities for a stable life. However, there are still many subgroups of Americans who suffer from poverty, ill health and a profound sense of helplessness when it comes to meeting their needs. Therefore, efforts to provide a minimally decent existence
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
11
for older people have become more clearly focused and sophisticated, dealing with such specifically social and political issues as housing, health care, and long-term care. In particular, relevant strategies adopted by some policy makers and service providers more recently have focused on expanding the supply of services to enhance opportunities for choice. For example, the establishment of funding for community-based services has created new alternatives to institutionalization for the frail elderly people in many countries around the world. But these efforts have been complicated by the myriad factors that affect people’s ability to capitalize on options made available to them. For example, when we examine housing decisions, the choice of living alone in contrast to living in an institution may be based solely on health status. On the other hand, for some older persons, the choice of living with relatives versus living by oneself may depend more on other issues, such as economics, family proximity or social/cultural/familial norms guiding appropriate housing arrangements. In addition, the absence of viable informal supports of the kind needed or in an accessible area may also narrow the choices that people see for themselves. Communities where large numbers of elderly people dwell are more likely to provide formal services where informal support networks among family members do not exist. For elders who might live in a high-density, urban area with no particular concentration of older people, both formal and informal services may be lacking. One interesting change has been in the evolution of the service of discharge planning. Until the late 1970s in the United States, much discharge planning was the responsibility of the staff nurse, who sometimes consulted with the physician and, occasionally, a social worker. The patient and family were simply told what would happen, rather than including them in the planning discussion. As the demand for hospital care by frail elderly people increased, the term “bed blockers” came into use in hospital language. Then, in the 1980s, Great Britain became one of the leaders among countries with universal health care systems to create a more formal structure in the specialized area of hospital care for older people. And while discharge planning in the United States had been part of the American Social Security Act revision in the 1970s, it was not until the 1990s that it became formalized, employing written policies, role descriptions, methods of follow-up and so on. But a study done in 1992 (Dugan & Mosel, 1992) found that 46.2% of hospital records of older people reviewed had no discharge planning information. Given that the outcome of hospital stays are typically either a long-term care facility (with obvious longterm consequences) or home care (with important consequences for health status and future health care needs), the advance planning that is missing is crucial for all constituents. When we examine the delivery of home care service (health and/or social) the complexities of supporting autonomy and empowerment become crys-
12
Empowering Frail Elderly People
tallized. Young (1990) has identified three major factors that differentiate home care from institutional care in terms of issues of autonomy. First, the location of service delivery in the person’s own home versus an institution highlights the importance of dealing with the individual, her preferences and her values, in an environment in which she is “in charge.” Violation of the autonomy of an individual, in his or her own home, is much more likely to be felt and resented than in an institutional setting. Secondly, the caring mix of both formal providers and informal family caregivers may complicate further the ability for an older person to be and to act empowered. Their family may serve as a buffer between him and formal providers, supporting the older person’s wishes. On the other hand, the family members may cripple an older person’s power by being paternalistic and granting power, by invalid proxy, to the formal caregiver. And finally, home health nurses are caring for more ill patients who require new levels of medical technology to maintain them. With the expansion of home care, new technologies for the home have been developed. Today, patients who wish to return home or want to stay at home, can do so with ventilators, feeding pumps, intravenous fluids or similar technologies. These can allow patients to maintain a greater level of autonomy while in their own personal environs. Thus, the question may no longer be whether home care is cost-effective or not, but what methods are needed to make it cost-effective (Fast & Chapin, 1996). One relatively new approach to social and health service provision in home care is the “strengths approach” (Fast & Chapin, 1996). This perspective focuses on helping people, families and communities, “discover and develop their own capacities, talents, skills and interests while connecting them with the resources needed to achieve their goals” (p. 51). As we know, many older adults do not plan for health-related crises. Very frail elderly people are often subject to short-term hospitalizations, leaving them further weakened and hardly in a position to assert their values and preferences. Many people thus end up in institutions against their wishes. In the strengths model, the case manager would discuss such an emergency plan and negotiate with both the individual older person, his or her family members and doctors, if required, before such a crisis might occur. When such a plan is not in place, then often the most high-cost and formally structured care is the easiest option for health care providers to recommend or choose, even when not the most preferable (Fast & Chapin, 1996). Another recent attempt at empowerment in the arena of home health care is the education of older people in “self-care” skills. This is another way in which health care providers are both advocating for older persons and trying to engage them actively in their own care. Medical self-care is what people do to “recognize, prevent, treat and manage their own health problems” (Mettler & Kemper, 1993, p. 7). It implies self-determination, self-reliance and public/client involvement (Beckingham & Watt, 1995). This self-care “movement” has been compared to other social movements (e.g., the
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
13
women’s movement and the union movement), in terms of its response to general social trends at any given time. In this case, the trend is demographic, portending a dramatic increase in health and social care of the growing number of aging people around the world (Boldy, 1997). In the context of American culture, the self-care movement is largely driven by the cultural value of maintaining control over one’s life, and a strong desire for self-reliance. And while many think of self-care strategies as focused on an individual, they are, in fact, incumbent upon the support of family, communal and social efforts. These efforts involve conscious decisions about balancing risks and resources, including the aid and support of others—both formal and informal. The same delicate balance can be seen when one examines the role of self-care and empowerment in long-term care settings. While laws may set minimal standards for what is required in institutions, ethical standards point out what practitioners and providers should do (Hofland, 1990a). Hofland gives the example of an older woman who has difficulty walking and, therefore, may be limited in her mobility by staff because of their concerns about her falling and injuring herself. However, the woman may be defining the situation not in terms of physical risk, but in terms of her ability to maintain her independence. In the former case, the intervention might call for constant supervision. From the latter perspective, the needed response may be the removal of barriers and the provision of a sturdy walker. He points out that, while there may be “no objective standard for weighing the good of security more heavily than the good of maintaining independence,” the evaluation of the older person’s values and preferences is important in making any decision. Lidz and Arnold (1990) posit that the many particulars of the environment of long-term care institutions require a rethinking of the concept of autonomy and, thus, empowerment. They note that philosophers, as discussed earlier, equate autonomy with “independence from external influences.” They suggest that, instead of thinking of these as synonymous, that our notion of autonomy must acknowledge individuals who live in a specific social, cultural and historical context. They propose, appropriately, we think, that the existence of institutional structures, by itself, is neutral regarding autonomy or empowerment. Thus, rather than asking whether one’s choice is influenced by outside factors, and assuming that all those factors are necessarily negative influences on autonomy, the more appropriate question is how institutional factors affect one’s decisions and behaviors and whether those particular influences compromise or undermine one’s control, reasoning, or personal power. This recognition and balancing of the inherent contradictions in promoting empowerment in frail elders in institutional settings is the first step in beginning to creatively address the challenge of empowering this population.
14
Empowering Frail Elderly People
Empowerment as Balance and Interdependence Clark’s (1989) fourth interpretation of empowerment addresses another kind of balance; that is, “that each person represents a mixture of dependence and independence, which are balanced by the individual in accommodating to the realities of his or her personal history and life situation.” His concern is that the focus on autonomy only detracts from the reality of the need for all of us—and perhaps even more for frail elderly people—to be connected with others in a meaningful web of interdependence. The process of being able to strike such a balance may result in what Rawls (1971) refers to as “reflective equilibrium”—a state in which the thoughtful comparison of one’s principles and judgments has concluded in a relevant merger of the two. This harkens back to the first interpretation of empowerment—effective deliberation and moral reflection. While this process may be the ideal, there are a variety of factors that can impede a person from reaching this state of reflective equilibrium. While the rest of the book is organized around approaches to overcoming explicit impediments to empowerment, we want to briefly mention four factors here that are not as closely examined in the other chapters: (1) family conflicts; (2) financial considerations; (3) rhetoric and the language of empowerment; and (4) the necessary paradigm shifts that must occur in a variety of arenas, but especially in the area of providers themselves. Family Conflicts Family conflicts—both between spouses, and between older parents and adult children—can muddy the waters of clear decision making by an older person. As Hofland (1990) points out, “the family caregiver faces trade-offs that relate to intergenerational responsibilities and balancing the preferences of the impaired family member against concerns for his or her safety or the needs of the rest of the family.” Unresolved family issues from the past may also further complicate this conflict. For example, a child who resents a parent for “not being there” when she was growing up may be less willing to sacrifice or assist her needy parent later. Sometimes it is the breakdown of informal family support that means that an older person has to enter residential care. Perhaps the caregiver’s own health is ailing, or there are conflicts between family and paid employment responsibilities. In many cases, the transition from home to residential care is fully negotiated between those involved. But a number of older persons in one study reported that it was “not their choice to make”; either they did not want to ‘burden’ their children or they were concerned about ‘being a nuisance’ to friends and neighbors” (Hardy, Wistow & Young, 1997, p. 6).
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
15
Financial Considerations The burden of providing care may be mainly financial, and, in the United States, for example, may be prohibitive. In 1995, the average annual cost of nursing home care in the United States was $37,000, while even home care could cost more than $12,000 per year. This latter figure does not take into account the hidden costs of the in-kind, informal services that families and neighbors may be providing in order to keep that person at home. And current federal financing programs in the United States only cover home care under certain circumstances. Many individuals in countries where private-pay services predominate are left with no option but to spend all their own resources and then rely upon the government for federally funded services, many of which are of lower quality than “private-pay” services. In many countries, creative financing arrangements are being explored in order to lighten the load of individuals needing expensive or long-term care. However, in some places, the stated priority of rearranging financing of care services is simply “lip service,” seen as politically correct to support, but not necessarily practically feasible. Rhetoric and the Language of Empowerment The kind of politically correct language that has more recently been heard around the issue of empowerment, and the closely related idea of patient/ client/consumer “participation” often maintains the status quo by substituting appealing rhetoric for substantive change. For example, the position of professional groups can be perpetuated through coercing people, in the name of autonomy and choice, to engage in behaviors or to make choices that the professionals deem appropriate. In the historical development of aging services (the “Aging Enterprise”) we can see that certain basic principles of autonomy have been espoused (e.g., informed consent). However, the reality of care practice, especially in long-term settings, has been more of a “colonization of the life-world” of old age, according to Harry Moody (1992). He means by this that the last stage of life has been simply reduced to biological survival, and that that goal, of simple survival, is more a manifestation of the values of a particular social and historical period than the result of any one individual’s autonomous choice. So, while current medical ethics might encourage the use of advanced directives, for example, the instruments themselves, and the goals they are meant to help a person reach, are compromised by the institutional framework and oblique language used (Moody, 1992). In one Italian study, the reasoning behind the use of physical restraints on patients in nursing homes reveals a fascinating example of the distorted manner in which the “values” of the providers outweigh the rights of the patients, but within the context of seemingly reasonable and appropriate guidelines for safety. Survey results indicated that use of re-
16
Empowering Frail Elderly People
straints is extremely widespread (81%) in spite of their ineffectiveness as reported in the literature. Even in this study, the investigators found that staff felt restraints contributed to greater degrees of dementia, anxiety, depression and aggression in patients. But the staff “rationale” was that restraints prevented patients from falling, or from potentially harming themselves or others, and that this “protective” function took precedence. In addition, the vast majority of decisions made about the use of restraints did not include consultation with the patient and/or the family (Constantini et al., 1997). The use of such language to rationalize certain behaviors or to achieve a provider’s goals (e.g., compliance) seems to be in stark contrast to the deeper spirit of empowerment. Gibson (cf. Vander Henst, 1997) recommends an examination of how those with power obtain it and a look at how the powerful relinquish some of their power. Even the lack of consensus as to what empowerment means or how it is defined contributes to the potential for manipulation of its better goals toward other ends. In the nursing literature, for example, Skelton (1994) notes that empowerment has been spoken of in terms of “a way of organizing teaching and learning; a strategy for equalizing power in the health care division of labor; a practice of behavior modification; a technique of pain relief; and as a political intervention aimed at reducing health inequalities between social groups.” Paradigm Shifts Required from Providers Others agree that for health professionals to truly participate and encourage a shift in control from themselves to older persons, they must be prepared to give up some of their own power and status. These changes will require a reorientation in training and education of all health and social care workers around the world (Beckingham & Watt, 1995; Clark, 1989; DeFriese & Konrad, 1993). Part of this change would be for care providers to ensure that initial assessment of older persons is framed by a resolve to support self-care and as much autonomy as is possible and felt by the recipient as appropriate. This must include a deep respect for the client’s capabilities, limitations and cultural preferences and a starting point of asking the question, “How can I enhance this person’s power to improve his or her life situation?” (Beckingham & Watt, 1995). The reality is that health care professionals cannot empower people; only people can empower themselves. Professionals, however, are in a position to create an environment in which personal empowerment can happen, and to work actively to help balance providers’ concerns and clients’ concerns in a functionally interdependent way. Empowerment is the result of self-awareness, self-growth and resources—not any particular program or service that might be provided (Gibson, 1991). Looking ahead, Stoller and Gibson (1994) ask: “How do we fashion public policy that serves to ameliorate the obstacles . . . often constructed earlier in the life course that handicap many ethnic and minority older people? How can public policy offer equal access to social and eco-
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
17
nomic opportunities to minority and non-minority elders alike?” (pp.xxvi– xxvii). As Clark (1989) concludes: “Indeed, unless empowerment becomes a theme characterizing the philosophies of consumer, provider, and policymaker alike, it is likely that the empowered consumer will become the disappointed and disillusioned recipient of policies, programs and decisions made by others” (p. 283). SOCIETAL VALUES AND THE EMPOWERMENT OF FRAIL ELDERLY PERSONS In this section of the chapter, we now turn to an analysis of how different societies have approached the need for developing a universal theme or goal of empowerment of frail elderly people among all involved in service design, implementation and financing. Here we will refer to the framework offered by H. R. Moody (1976) of a continuum of social values concerning elderly people in any society. While Moody (1976) initially developed this framework in terms of analyzing the role of educational opportunities for older persons, Hofland (1990b) expanded its application to the issues involved in creating residential environments for seniors. The four models or stages in Moody’s framework describe a continuum of social values from materialism to a holistic approach to the role of elders in a society, and they are (1) rejection; (2) social service; (3) participation; and (4) self-actualization. Stage 1—Rejection Repression, segregation or neglect of elderly people in a society exemplify the first stage, Rejection. In many countries, we can see this attitude manifested in mandatory retirement ages, regardless of any individual state of health or functioning, the rationing of health care based on age alone (e.g., organ transplants), and the segregation of older persons in “retirement villages” or the newest “continuing care communities.” In such communities, we can “put” people there at one point and know that they will remain there—often out of contact with the rest of society—until death. Even the removal of death, in many industrialized countries, from the home to a hospital or nursing home, illustrates our implicit or unconscious distaste for the vagaries of old age. In such a model, there is no motivation for conscientious design of policies or services for older persons, as they are barely visible on the horizon of our social awareness. However, given the demographics of aging in most countries today, there are few places left which can maintain a wholesale attitude of rejection of elderly people. Stage 2—Social Service In the second stage, one of Social Service, recognition of the needs of the elderly by government is present. However, this recognition is based on an
18
Empowering Frail Elderly People
interpretation of “neediness” of the elderly, for which they cannot be responsible. Thus, officials in the “expert-based” government must “provide” what they decide is needed. And while older persons may be receiving more services than under the first model of Rejection, there is still an implicit judgment of their uselessness. The difference is a sense of moral responsibility of the public institutions to care for them. We can see this model embodied in many public policies and program structures in most industrialized countries today. In the United States, we see this paternalistic approach underpinning most social policies regarding the older segment of our population. For example, an analysis of several developed countries revealed that the potential contribution of health-determining factors to lower mortality ranged from health care systems (11%) through environment (19%) and human biology (27%) to lifestyles (43%). However, the percentage of the U.S. health budget allocated for these factors was 90% for health care systems (e.g., managed care) and 1.5%, 1.6% and 7.9% for lifestyle, environment and human biology, respectively (Costa-Alonso et al., 1998). Specific government policies determine which limited services Medicare, the entitlement program of health care, will pay for those over the age of 65. Specifically, in 1993, 85% of Medicare expenses went to institutional care even in the face of evidence that home care might be more economical and psychologically more palatable to older individuals (Fast & Chapin, 1996). According to Fast and Chapin (1996), these current financing schemes perpetuate the use of highcost medical services even when such a high level of service is not needed to compensate for any inability to perform activities of daily living or to cope with chronic illness. There have been recent attempts to creatively address the varied needs of older individuals, such as the Channeling Projects, where individual states (i.e., Oregon and Florida) are allowed to use the block of federal monies assigned to their state to rearrange the way in which services are provided. While this has worked well in the states that have been ambitious enough to develop such projects, the fundamental system of federal limits on assigned spending has not been modified. In Finland, a group has developed a highly sophisticated computer software program to assist local authorities in the planning, monitoring and evaluation of care for older persons. Using a variety of demographic and service utilization databases, it is possible for the user to analyze the balance between demand, supply, resources and cost of services. But, in this case, effectiveness is defined as “the service system’s performance in either satisfying the client’s needs or at least in meeting the (planned) policy goals given to the care system” (Varaama, 1997). In Chapter 6 of this book, a similar plan is presented, which aims more explicitly to incorporate the desires of frail elderly people. On a more direct service level, there are also factors that operate to perpetuate the social service model of service provision. Rice, Beck and Steven-
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
19
son (1997) believe that Western societies contribute to the lack of potentially empowering methods for service delivery by valuing dependence over autonomy, compliance over individual preference, and youth over lived experience. Specifically, health care providers often expect too little of elders in terms of being able to comprehend technical information and therefore be informed enough to make an intelligence choice. Also, providers often assume that because a person is limited in one way (e.g., physically), he must also be limited in other areas, perhaps cognitively, that would inhibit his ability to participate in his own care. On an interpersonal level, today’s elders in many societies are used to unquestioningly accepting a “professional’s” opinion of what is right for them. Both elders themselves and providers do not yet “expect” that an equal partnership in health or social services is normal or desirable. Both “expect” that elders will relinquish control to the experts (Haug, 1994). This often results in the “learned helplessness” that is observed in many elders, an attitude that may also undermine any attempts to teach or encourage them to now become active in their own care. However, the principle of collectivism would suggest that society has the right to expect citizens to take care of themselves, and to avoid becoming excessive burdens in terms of health care costs and care requirements. The federal health care system in the United States, however, is sending mixed messages. On the one hand, federal guidelines mandate healthy lifestyle changes, such as those cited in Healthy People 2000 (1990); on the other hand, the federal government prohibits Medicare or Medicaid reimbursement for health promotion and preventive services such as smoking cessation and weight loss clinics. In the new managed care environment, elders have not yet been held accountable for their high-risk behaviors (Rice, Beck & Stevenson, 1997). Stage 3—Participation The third stage, Participation, is built on the assumption that some degree of being active in and, perhaps accountable for, one’s own care is important and valuable. Underlying this stage is a broader view of the dignity, social integration and self-determination of older persons. Here, the potential for growth and consistent and meaningful engagement in social life are the underlying values and articulated goals of government and citizens. We see this in the current political philosophy of the United Kingdom, where “consumer rights” are actively promoted (Boldy, 1997; Caraher, 1994; Connolly et al., 1994); Hardy, Wistow & Young, 1997; Trnobranski, 1994). These values were explicitly stated in the 1989 White Paper, “Caring for People,” and in the 1990 National Health Service and Community Care Act. The government made a three-fold commitment to its citizens: first, to enable individuals to live at home or in “homely” settings in the community, rather
20
Empowering Frail Elderly People
than in residential institutions; second, to provide services based not on what is currently available, but rather based on what a given individual needs; and third, to fully involve older persons and their informal caregivers in the assessment of their need for services, and the design, implementation and review of those services once delivered. While local authority social services departments were given the responsibility for development and management of this model (see Chapter 7 for a discussion of the challenges of implementation), the government has given explicit encouragement to innovation and responsiveness in service provision. In the United States, even while government policies and programs have been slow to change, the rapid growth in the number of elderly people has prompted many health care organizations to modify their attitudes and their policies. Thus, the motivation for development of self-care programs needs to be understood in the context of this changing environment in the health care system. As the amount of money spent on health care grows more quickly than the growth of the U.S. economy as a whole, there is a frantic focus on how to better organize services more efficiently and cost-effectively. A national survey of large group practices in 1990 (Zitter, cf. DeFriese & Konrad, 1993) revealed that over half provided home health care, geriatric assessment teams and a staff member responsible solely for patient care. Financing of preventive and health promotion services is changing from the traditional fee-for-service schemes to more inclusion in managed health care systems (DeFriese & Konrad, 1993). As Mettler and Kemper (1993) point out, patient involvement in health care decisions may make those choices more appropriate and relevant to the person. They believe that patientcentered medicine also helps avoid medical treatments that are not in the best interests of the older person. By encouraging shared decision making about health care, self-care programs promote the inclusion of the older person’s values as part of the deliberation process. This may ultimately result in lower utilization of high-cost, low-benefit treatments. However, because many practitioners have had their services narrowly defined by external, third-party payers, motivating change within the system is a complicated slow-moving political process (Kari & Michels, 1991). Not only do bureaucratic barriers exist, but there are also provider barriers that can block the empowerment of an older person. Jewell (1994) believes that the increasing popularity of the concept of patient participation has resulted in practitioners having “both a cursory understanding of the concept and an unreflective approach to their practice” (p. 435). For many care providers the goal has become getting patients to “be active,” assuming that any action therefore means that the patient is participating and thereby empowered, as well. Participation, as such, may range from sharing information, being involved in decision making, or actually taking part in one’s own physical care. Participation may also include the family members or other informal caregivers. However, how individual older persons would define
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
21
participation for themselves may not be the same as the way providers would (Hardy, Wistow & Young, 1990; Jewell, 1994). This conflict over the meaning of participation is yet another concrete example of the point Clark makes about the rhetoric of empowerment—meaning that may be manipulated toward ends other than true autonomous power for the individual. Stage 4—Self-Actualization The final stage of Moody’s model of social values is that of selfactualization, where individuals do, indeed, gain a true sense of power over one’s own life. This is characterized by some as a focus on spiritual values and the potential for growth. Hofland (1990b) describes potential housing arrangements under this model as “designed to incorporate the collective practice of meditation and other spiritual practices in an effort to develop individual and group consciousness.” Also, preventive and health promotional support services might be provided on site. While there are no countries that can claim this model as a universal reality, there are a few that recognize self-actualization as a goal. The ultimate goal here is for a society to evolve to a stage where the “giving” or “taking” of power between people becomes obsolete because society recognizes the individual worth and value of each individual and allows them to develop their own potential based on their particular set of values. In Canada, according to Beckingham and Watt (1995), “Health is now viewed as a resource that allows people to reach their potential by interacting with and changing aspects of their environment” (p. 479). Health care is viewed as a social good, not just a social obligation but a common responsibility to be shared by all. The Health Act of 1984 provides for universal, comprehensive, portable, prepaid and not-for-profit health insurance. This insurance covers accessible and equitable health services that are administered at the provincial level, but are provided by a wide range of public and private organizations. While there may be provincial variations in structure, services are similar and are provided in both community and institutional settings. While Great Britain has made great strides in modifying its health care system, as discussed before, there is little or no mandate in the law of social policy for professionals to do more than involve, or encourage the participation of, users and caregivers in decisions about their own future. Involvement in the decision-making process is not, however, the same as having the authority or the resources to act on the decisions made; that is, it does not require users and caregivers to be empowered in the same way as consumers of other types of goods and services. Some have argued that until they are given the resources to purchase services on their own behalf, users and caregivers will be denied real choices in how they live their lives. Empowerment, then, will involve struggles over those resources; its
22
Empowering Frail Elderly People
achievement will not be some kind of neutral administrative procedure. It will involve disagreements over definitions of what health is and over how to implement health-enhancing policies and actions. For example, nurses, even though professionals, at their “micro level” of direct care, are not independent from but are subject to constraints on their actions from nursing, managerial and medical hierarchies. Furthermore, at the macro level, health services are not independent of socioeconomic and political constraints on their operation. In the recent past in the United Kingdom where so much government-initiated radical change in the structure and funding of the National Health Service has taken place, the point is fairly obvious. A more invisible, but nonetheless real, controlling factor even above the macro level, is a “mega level” of governmental Departments (e.g., Ministers and not least the Treasury), where agendas for health and social care are set and where the constraints on power for patients, clients and service providers are really established (Skelton, 1994). In the United States, as mentioned in the previous section, there are discrete efforts being made to create empowering programs that uphold the values of individual dignity and self-worth and that try to support and encourage self-actualization. For example, the “strengths approach” to selfcare, referred to in the first section of the chapter, is also relevant here, on a case-management level. Collings (1991) asserts that social policy that ensures seniors the right to community-based long-term care, with payment and choice as requisite components, is required for the maintenance of a person’s sense of personal control. While a system modification that guaranteed such care would no doubt be empowering, the strengths approach has the potential to develop empowerment within the current policy and program structures. As will be discussed in both Chapters 4 and 10, there are efforts being made by the states to illustrate the feasibility of putting such values into actual practice. But, as Krivo and Mutchler (1989) state, “Appropriate types of available housing, supportive health care, financial assistance, demographic composition, or normative social support may be necessary to make [independent] living feasible for many elders.” Other necessary resources include transportation (and thus access to other services) and assistance with environmental maintenance. And, many of these resources vary from state to state or even from community to community, let alone from country to country. So, while in some areas such supports will be available, in others the lack of them will force elders into premature institutional care arrangements. Thus, Krivo and Mutchler conclude that individual choices made at a household level are dependent upon the matrix of events, characteristics and resources in and of a given community. Therefore, to develop sound public policy, governments anywhere in the world must take into account the views of older people regarding the degree to which local communities’ programs and policies actually affect the elderly population they support (Beckingham & Watt, 1995; Caraher, 1994).
Definitions, Applications, Problems, and Prospects
23
ON THE HORNS OF THE DILEMMA OF EMPOWERMENT The type of social policy that supports the notion of the consumer choice and empowerment is not, on its face, controversial. But, as Kapp (1990) points out, “In its application, it is riddled with choices among competing, legitimate social policy considerations.” As has been mentioned throughout this chapter so far, when an elderly person makes decisions or acts in ways that seem harmful, both informal caregivers and professionals are faced with conflicting commitments. The latter must choose between respecting the person’s autonomy on the one hand, and promoting his/her well-being on the other hand. Social policy is riddled with competing values, since it requires choosing not right from wrong, but right from right (Collopy, 1990; Small, 1993). For example, home care practitioners recognize that being able to live alone is not a single capacity but that it might be considered more of a continuum. These providers often care for patients in whom the capacity to care for themselves is not an all-or-nothing situation. When to intervene along this continuum is often the heart of this difficult issue; pat answers are not available. If no incidents endangering the physical safety of the client have occurred, clinicians often take a wait-and-see position in which vigilance is increased in the hope that appropriate caregivers are present in a crisis (Liaschenko, 1998). Jackson (1994) also cites the many ethical questions surrounding discharge planning. Do patients have the right to deny having family as part of the planning process? Do older patients have the right to make what may be foolish and risky choices about where to live after their discharge? Are there patients, given their health status and the costs involved, who should not be in any discharge planning program? What are appropriate screening criteria for such patients? Discharge planning includes the placement of patients in long-term care facilities. A challenge to hospital staff is to ensure that the planning process distinguishes between coercion and choice, especially for elderly patients with diminished or fluctuating mental capacity. According to Kapp (1990), the dynamics of consumer involvement run the gamut from (a) a paternalistic, almost coercive steering based on the case manager’s virtually unexamined judgment of client welfare to (b) a participatory, supportive process entailing active consumer/case manager negotiations to (c) leaving the consumer practically on his or her own to locate, recruit, hire, supervise, document, pay and perhaps fire an independent provider without case management support. Some would describe the last dynamic as an almost nihilistic abandoning of the consumer to his or her theoretical rights. Providing the proper degree of assistance to enable the real, as opposed to the nominal, exercise of choice and control without smothering those rights is a difficult, value-laden balancing act. But, as Kapp (1990) points out, to what extent does providing consumers
24
Empowering Frail Elderly People
with the power of the purse (that is, allowing them to hire, fire and control payment for their providers) best ensure the quality of home care services? Are older persons really capable of exercising that power responsibly? Do we deal with incapable consumers through benign neglect or by imposing intrusive, overgeneralized government regulation? How do we determine which consumers require social protection? How much risk will we tolerate and who will endure it? Choice and control imply an allocation of risks as well as rights. If we ask consumers what they want, are we ready to live with their answers? To what extent will we permit home-care consumers to assume the risks attendant to their (sometimes foolish) choices and to waive the right to seek redress from providers who accede to consumer choice (Kapp, 1990; Rice, Beck & Stevenson, 1997)? So, while we hope that people choose to do what is “for their own good,” we know they don’t always do so. For example, the opposite of selfcare is self-neglect. We’ve seen this become an issue of growing concern with the increased visibility of deinstitutionalized, mentally ill, homeless elderly people and the increased number of older people still in their own homes or in institutions. Self-neglect is frequently secondary to cognitive and physical limitations that result in institutionalization. But when does self-care turn into self-neglect? And who has a right to make that decision? When does society have an obligation to intervene by requiring individuals to use services that are available to them? What if you create these “better” options and people still choose to behave in a manner deemed unhealthy or inappropriate? Who do you blame? Is it society’s right to intervene because of the eventual cost and burden of the elders’ inevitable health decline, partially stemming from poor care (Caraher, 1994; Rice, Beck & Stevenson, 1997; Small, 1993)? The basic principles of autonomy that we began this chapter with would suggest that frail older persons have the right to live at risk, if they so choose. Therefore, the goal may be to create the most empowering environment we can, as a society, as practitioners and as informal caregivers, so that at least those older persons who would choose to live more healthfully and happily, have the freedom, resources and power to make that choice. In service of this goal, Neill (1994) offers what might be seen as a negative definition of empowerment: “It is not about the things you do to or for people . . . it is the impediments you take away leaving space for folks to empower themselves.” We find this view of empowerment particularly compelling and have organized the rest of the book around presenting programs and policies designed to remove such impediments. Prior to presenting such case studies in detail, the second introductory chapter provides an overview and classification of the various opportunities and impediments to empowerment. In this, the relationship of each case study to the classification scheme and its contribution to mitigating or removing particular impediment(s) is outlined.
2
Opportunities and Impediments in Housing, Health, and Support Service Delivery Leonard F. Heumann, Duncan P. Boldy, and Mary E. McCall
There are fundamental impediments to empowerment models of care and support that are rooted in the value biases of society. These values and biases are reflected in the program and service options available to its citizens and differentiated by its care providers, its social, economic and governmental institutions, and in the physical and social environments in which we all live. In order to structure future discussions and considerations of empowerment related to frail elderly people, we present a classification scheme or taxonomy of the numerous and varied potential limits and impediments. The classification is structured under four groups (or “limits”), as follows: providerbased; environment-based; client-based; and societal-based (see Figure 2.1). In the various chapters of this book we illustrate, via case studies, how particular programs have attempted to address some of the impediments to empowerment under each heading. The particular case studies were chosen because we believe they provide universal meaning and interest to persons in all countries who seek to maximize personal control and functional independence for even their most frail senior members. The impediments addressed by each chapter are summarized in Figure 2.2, a matrix that indicates whether a particular impediment is a central, primary or secondary focus of the chapter. Book chapters are grouped into three sections, namely: • Service Providers and Empowerment: Information, Training and Coordination • Environment and Empowerment in Conventional Housing • Client Empowerment in Long-Term Care.
Figure 2.1 Framework of Limits and Impediments to Empowerment
Opportunities and Impediments
27
Figure 2.2 Matrix Showing Impediments to Empowerment Covered by Chapters of the Book
This framework focuses on frail and dependent people for whom independence and empowerment have real limits. For them to be empowered to the margin of their ability and desires requires proper training, cooperation, coordination and flexibility of multiple care providers, both formal and informal. Real empowerment may only be achievable after a basic “paradigm shift” in the attitudes and beliefs of formal and informal service providers about the abilities and worth of frail older persons. We therefore intentionally focus first on impediments related to empowering frail elderly people in the area of Provider Based Limits. PROVIDER BASED LIMITS If providers and their service format are not ideologically sympathetic to support provision that puts elderly clients in control at the margin of their
28
Empowering Frail Elderly People
ability and desire, then they become an impediment to empowerment. This can be reflected in inappropriate or limited formal provider training and education. It can be reflected in a support delivery philosophy that prohibits client involvement in planning, or that is biased or limited by funding mandates, program design or political policy, to specific services delivered only in specific ways. Such impediments can also be reflected in failure to fully and carefully coordinate with other service providers into a comprehensive and unified whole. Poor management of service coordination can intrude on personal privacy and eliminate one’s remaining independence and disrupt or eliminate natural informal support bonds with family and friends. All these limits can lead to atrophy of remaining skills and the will to retain whatever independence remains. This can then lead to inappropriate referral and admission to institutions. Provider Based Limits focus on individual control over lifestyle, housing and care management and retaining or obtaining support settings of choice that fit the preferences of each frail individual, rather than on political empowerment directly. The final Provider Based Limit to empowerment is an example of one that we need to list but cannot go into much detail defining. Civil and criminal law regarding care, risk and professional practice can vary dramatically from country to country depending on economic market structure, social welfare values and legal structure. Laws, codes and regulations that can affect one’s ability to choose housing and support options can even vary within states and provinces of a country. Part II of the book, “Service Providers and Empowerment: Information, Training, and Coordination,” comprises four chapters, each of which address many of the provider impediments in service delivery, as well as common challenges in redesigning service delivery and choice in new ways. Three of the four chapters (3, 4, and 5) present specific and concrete methods by which to increase the involvement and empowerment of frail elderly persons in service delivery. With some similar degree of overlap, three of the chapters (3, 4, and 6) address the challenges that are faced on a societal level in attempting to change service delivery modes. One major challenge is how to capitalize on cultural values to move them in a direction that acknowledges the realistic pressures and changes that are happening in each society. For example, in Chapter 5, we see the poignant reality of a very traditional society (Japan), whose model of caregiving and service provision has historically been the family, facing the challenge of how to move to a new model. This new model is one of more cooperation between informal and formal modes of service and care. In Chapter 6, we are given a much broader perspective on the potential costs and benefits on a larger, economic scale of choosing to focus on “empowerment” as the stated, or even implicit, goal of service delivery. This focus on empowerment may be made versus other, perhaps equally laudable, goals of increasing the days that a person
Opportunities and Impediments
29
may stay in his own home, or reducing caregiver burden. Each of these chapters discusses the challenges and impediments in service provision those four different societies face, and presents ways in which both local and national creative efforts have been made, and are still being made, to overcome these impediments. In Chapter 3, “Promoting Empowerment in Residential Aged Care: Seeking the Consumer View,” Duncan Boldy and Linda Grenade present a new approach in Australia for involving frail elderly persons in evaluation of service provided in residential care. This approach arose from the national recognition of the need to meet the growing care requirements of an increasing elderly population. This recognition culminated in the development of the Aged Care Reform Strategy of 1986. One of the goals was to place an increased emphasis on community care and less emphasis on institutional residential care, and to develop specific outcome standards and measures for residential aged care facilities. This chapter presents the efforts to assess a key component in service delivery, namely the perspective of the frail older resident. While very few would argue the importance of respecting consumers’ views, there are several challenges involved in this process, which the authors discuss. One of the key lessons to be learned from this enterprise is that involving consumers directly in service evaluation is costly and time consuming. While this process may also potentially identify conflicts of interest (e.g., institutional fiscal constraints vs. residents’ desires), the overriding values of individual worth, respect and empowerment must take precedence over easing institutional processes and financial considerations. Knowledge of clients’ views and wishes, and biases in service delivery, are the impediments that form the central focus of this chapter, with primary focus also being directed toward addressing issues related to clients’ mental and physical limitations. In Chapter 4, “Reimagining Senior Empowerment in Service Delivery: Creative Applications in a Global Context,” we see how local agencies and communities can, on a small scale, attempt to empower local residents in a variety of areas of concern to them. Mary McCall presents three different U.S. programs or projects that address issues of housing needs, physical health needs and social-emotional needs of elderly residents living in two communities. One is a relatively affluent suburban community while the other is government-subsidized housing for low-very low income residents in an urban, high-rise building. These three projects reflect common goals of (1) involving elderly persons in defining the objectives of programs designed to “serve” them, (2) providing an avenue for voicing their needs and desires in an arena where providers (either housing managers or local city officials) will hear them clearly, and (3) engaging various agencies and local groups in collaborative efforts to promote empowerment of elderly persons. The projects demonstrate the success that can be achieved in a diversity of settings with the cooperation of a diversity of agencies and constituencies,
30
Empowering Frail Elderly People
and the ways in which “win-win” situations can be created. Similar to the authors of Chapter 3, this author makes it clear that to conscientiously move toward empowerment a great deal of effort and creative energy must be marshaled to overcome the status quo of “how things are usually done” and the ease of inertia in organizations. But the outcome of respect and dignity of individual persons is worth the time and effort expended. Coordination and biases in service delivery represent the central foci of this chapter, with a primary focus being placed on issues related to the training and knowledge of service providers and flexibility in service design and delivery. In Chapter 5, “Retaining and Expanding Empowerment in the Transition from a Family to a Community-Oriented Support System: Japan in the 21st Century,” we have the unique opportunity to get an “inside” view of a society in the midst of a major cultural shift. Tokie Anme poignantly documents that move from a traditional, Eastern, family-based system of care and support to one where the influences of Western culture have forced Japan to meet the needs of a growing older population (similar to Australia in Chapter 3) in new ways. Some of these ways feel to Japanese citizens as if they are going against their cultural values. We are given an outline of the national effort to install systemic changes in local and national care systems. While on the national level many financial resources have been committed to building the nursing homes and care facilities projected to be needed, on the local level, smaller communities are working to promote a “culture of empowerment.” The strategies used to engage older Japanese in taking personal responsibility for their health and wellness are described—for example, getting them to “buy in” to the new ways through the importance of respecting their values and meeting them on their own terms in their own villages and neighborhoods to convey respect. As in Chapter 3, the importance of good organization and development of methods is emphasized. As in the other chapters in this section, it is clear here that a multipronged and collaborative approach between all constituencies (providers, elderly persons, families and service managers) is a requirement for success. Like the previous two chapters, this chapter has a central focus on service delivery biases and coordination, in the context of a particular set of cultural values. Issues related to the role and place of training, knowledge and informal care are also prominent, whilst particular attention is also given to family dynamics and ageism. In Chapter 6, “Empowerment in Post-Reform Community Care in England and Wales,” Bleddyn Davies gives us a unique economic perspective on the costs and benefits of choosing various goals in community care models. Somewhat similar to Chapter 5, we are presented with a broad national view of changes in the goals and methods of service delivery in a society facing increasing needs for services. For example, the choice to maximize the goal of empowerment of frail elderly persons may be at the cost of the
Opportunities and Impediments
31
number of days that a person could stay in her own home. If empowering a person to choose to stay in unsafe conditions means she needs nursing home care sooner than if she had help at home, we are making a trade-off. Davies’ main point is that many economic outcomes may or may not reflect the explicit goals that government state, but may in fact, be a manifestation of implicit goals of which we are unaware. His call for making the implicit more explicit in economic decisions—which underlie all service delivery systems—is a crucial one that needs to be heeded. This chapter also has a central focus on service delivery biases, in addition to inflexibility of program design, funding and the role of informal care. Attention to the knowledge of clients’ views and wishes is a primary focus, as is the issue of informal care, fragmentation of services and lack of coordination. ENVIRONMENT BASED LIMITS These listed reflect those imposed on empowerment by housing and surrounding environments. The very location of a home can be an impediment. Homes located in areas with high crime, high pollution, steep topography, no pavements/sidewalks and heavy traffic with no safe way to cross streets, are all examples that can limit mobility and trap a frail elderly person in her home. Environmental barriers within the home, like stairs, inadequate heating and lighting and inappropriate room arrangements and furnishings, can all limit functional independence. Certain forms of living arrangements—be they alone, with family or strangers—can limit the ability to empower a person with desired support options. Even homes that are adequately furnished and located can be impediments if they are too costly and difficult to manage and keep clean. The local economy and supply of housing options can be so limited and costly that the preferred lifestyle choices with regard to living arrangements and care options are not realizable. Modern technology can often eliminate human support and increase privacy for those who choose such an option, but lack of knowledge, affordability, training and human service delivery biases can all prohibit or limit the uses of such equipment and devices. Finally, local building codes and regulations can prevent certain housing options from being built in desired locations or prohibit living arrangements between unrelated individuals. Part III of the book, “Environment and Empowerment in Conventional Housing,” comprises three chapters, each of which addresses some major impediments in working with the physical and built environment to facilitate empowerment of frail elderly people living in conventional community housing. All three chapters address the very serious impediment to empowerment of the traditional problem-centered medical model of service and care. The consequence of this biased focus is an underestimation of the role of the
32
Empowering Frail Elderly People
physical environment in putting power over decisions around daily life activities in the hands of aging residents. In Chapters 7 and 8, we see the constraints put on the employment of environmental options by financing systems and programmatic biases that do not provide the institutional or organizational context in which to incorporate such options in care or service plans. The focus of Chapter 8 is a clear documentation of the lack of basic knowledge about environmental modifications that, while cutting costs, can provide frail elderly people with more freedom and power within their most basic and important environment—their home. Chapters 7 and 9 provide case illustrations of the ways in which some communities and providers have struggled to overcome institutional, organizational and even community impediments to create meaningful and empowering conventional living environments for frail older persons. In Chapter 7, “Another Way of Living in One’s Own Home: The Salmon Group Projects,” we are presented with a clearly articulated analysis of the tensions faced when trying to change the system—to be a “salmon swimming upstream, against the current.” The unique approach to conventional housing—small, homey, community-based residences—serve to illustrate the challenges encountered in truly empowering frail elderly people, especially those persons with severe mental and/or physical limitations. The Salmon Group represents a broad-based effort in countries throughout Western Europe to move from a disease-centered “medical model” of dealing with elderly persons to a person-centered “life model,” which is more processoriented than goal-oriented. This process includes the older person at each stage from housing design, location choice, selection of other residents and staff, to the scheduling of meals, cleaning and other services. The aim is to keep people in their communities, ideally within their same neighborhood, even keeping their same family doctor and other private networks. The challenges of precipitating a paradigm shift in professionals away from the “problem” to the “person,” of helping the helpers give up some of their power in order for older persons to be empowered, and of suggesting alternative approaches to program funding, have been creatively met by the Salmon Group. They clearly acknowledge the risks and potential dangers associated with true empowerment—such as letting someone reject recommended services or support—but believe that the rewards of individual dignity of all persons is worth such risks. Living arrangements and housing options, linked to issues of location, are the central foci of this chapter, along with concerns related to service delivery bias. Inflexibility in program design/funding and cultural aspects are also addressed as primary foci. In Chapter 8, “The Role of the Built Environment in Holistic Delivery of Home- and Community-Based Care Services to Frail Elderly Persons,” Leonard Heumann analyzes the attitudes of care and case managers in Australia toward the use of environmental modifications and adaptations to the
Opportunities and Impediments
33
homes of frail elderly persons. In his survey and interview research, it is clearly shown that the stated goals of managers were to keep at home those elderly persons who were at highest risk of institutionalization, and to help them maintain the highest level of independence and quality of life possible. In spite of these stated goals, however, the actual use of or integration of physical modifications in private homes was virtually non-existent. Not only was this discrepancy found at the individual care manager level, it was mirrored at the bureaucratic and institutional levels as well. The two new home and community based care management programs developed in Australia in the early 1990s were to meet the goals of decreasing costs and increasing efficiency in service delivery. Yet the diversity of kinds of services available, of which most elderly persons were unaware, worked against efficiency, as well as empowerment of clients. In addition, the implicit preference for traditional human social services precluded a need for service providers to become aware of and utilize newer technological devices and barrier-free environmental modifications. Government funding regulations actually prevented providing such technologies and modifications. In most home and community based services, human services continue to be the primary option. Care managers’ attitudes toward, knowledge of, and ability to replace human services with supportive devices or environmental modification remain minimal. This eliminates a choice for residents in need of assistance with independent living who want to maximize privacy and hence limit the presence of human service providers in their homes. Built environment barriers, knowledge of support features/technology and the complexity of maintenance and service delivery bias are the central foci of this chapter. Particular attention is also paid to issues of service provider training and the lack of knowledge on their behalf of the views or wishes of clients. In Chapter 9, “When Community Planning Becomes Community Building: Place-Based Activism and the Creation of Good Places to Grow Old,” Philip B. Stafford presents a truly community-based approach to empowering older persons in creating, as he calls it, “a good place to grow old.” He describes and analyzes the efforts of the Evergreen Institute to conduct collaborative research and community development activities toward this end in the context of the traditional medical model of health care and service delivery. He articulates the novel assumptions of their work—that community is the smallest unit of health, and that aging is not about time, but about place. He also outlines many of the creative methods used to facilitate a new vision of community and care for older persons. Members from all age groups in the community are involved in planning through mechanisms such as focus groups, household surveys, ethnographic research, and interviews with older persons conducted by students and other intergenerational activities. This chapter illustrates the considerable successes that can be achieved, in spite of attitudinal and institutional impediments, when all concerned are
34
Empowering Frail Elderly People
empowered throughout the process. As stated in the conclusion of this chapter, “the process, when well done, is time-consuming.” But, clearly, for this American community in Indiana, the time has been very well spent. Issues related to support design and complex maintenance, linked to housing choice, form the central foci of this chapter. Of primary concern are the lack of knowledge of clients’ views/wishes, fragmentation of services and lack of coordination; also, problems caused by code and regulation restrictions and wider societal based limitations related to program choice alternatives and the willingness to empower and be empowered are discussed. CLIENT BASED LIMITS Frailty by definition presents limitations, but the obvious ones such as physical and mental disabilities, can be exacerbated by problems with selfesteem, culture and language, and basic expectations about remaining in control in old age. Often it is how the frail senior’s family thinks about empowerment in old age that becomes a major obstacle to empowerment. Family dynamics involving cultural roles, length of life, cost of care tradeoffs between the generations and many other factors can seriously affect the will to retain power over one’s support and living choices. Part IV of the book, “Client Empowerment in Long-Term Care,” addresses empowerment issues for different groups of elderly people receiving long-term care in a variety of settings. Issues of rights, involvement, ageism and care staff attitudes, training and selection are common themes, as are those of cooperation and collaboration between caring “systems.” In Chapter 10, Harvey argues the case for the residents of nursing homes to be granted the right to live at a “level of risk” similar to that considered acceptable in society at large. The rights of residents over those of the organization are emphasized in a particular case study nursing home, which has developed thirty-one components covering five key areas. Kodner and colleagues in Chapter 11 discuss how “consumer direction” can be achieved in home health care, even within a managed care model. They aim at having informed consumers (clients and family caregivers) participating in the assessment of their needs, how these are met and the monitoring of service quality. Carmichael and Gething, in Chapters 12 and 13, respectively, specifically discuss problems of ageism and cooperation and collaboration between the aging network and the mental health and disability systems. Achieving empowerment for clients receiving long-term care is perhaps one of the greatest challenges for caring systems, given the particular vulnerability of the clientele. In Chapter 10, “The Rights of Elderly People in a Nursing Home—A Little Creativity, a Lot of Respect, a Taste for Adventure, and an Allergy to Bureaucracy,” Germain Harvey presents a case study of a Canadian nursing home which puts residents’ rights at the center of its philosophy. Taking
Opportunities and Impediments
35
the stance that elderly residents of institutions are full citizens who should enjoy the same rights as other people, this public institution, in which nearly 200 people live, has developed what is described as a “unique living environment approach.” In order to increase resident choice, a level of risk has been defined, based on what is typically considered acceptable in society at large. Pursuing its philosophy further, the nursing home has created the position of living environment advisor (or residents’ advocate). The role of this advisor is to ensure the quality of life and living environment of the residents, and create and implement the necessary mechanisms to ensure the primacy of the rights of residents over those of the organization. A Charter of Rights and Freedoms has been developed, the thirty-one components of which relate to five major areas, namely: information and freedom of expression, privacy, respect and dignity, continuity, and responsibility and participation. Perhaps the fundamental message of this chapter is that a key judgment of a society is how it treats its most vulnerable citizens, which implies that there should be one set of rights for all, whether living at home or in an institution. Provider based limitations form the central foci of this chapter, in particular those related to training/education, knowledge of clients’ views and wishes, biases in service delivery and inflexibility in program design and funding. Issues of ageism and client self-esteem are also central foci, with primary focus being directed to an awareness of choices and options and the willingness to empower and be empowered. In Chapter 11, “Bringing Managed Health Care Home: A New Service Strategy for People with Chronic Illnesses and Disabilities,” Dennis Kodner and colleagues describe a managed home care program for people with chronic illnesses and disabilities which is being planned according to a consumer directed philosophy. This involves informed consumers (clients and family caregivers) participating in the assessment of their needs, determining how they wish such needs to be met and monitoring the quality of service they receive. The starting point is with consumer desires, not with the problems or availability of services. Clients have a choice of provider, with the option of changing to another provider, or even another multidisciplinary care planning team, if they so decide. Ownership in the program includes clients represented on the governing board (and encouraged to play an active role) and client involvement in the proposed quality improvement process. Particular attention is being paid to the selection of staff who are open to the idea of client empowerment, these staff then being trained to be sensitive to the consumer’s role and point of view. This model demonstrates that consumer direction is possible within managed care, despite it being generally considered to be synonymous with a “command and control” approach. Issues of staff training, fragmentation of services and lack of coordination and inflexibility in program design and funding form central foci of this
36
Empowering Frail Elderly People
chapter. Issues of personal choice by clients are also central, with a primary focus on the mental and physical capacity of clients and resource limitations. In Chapter 12, “Elderly Persons with Severe Mental Illness: Empowering a Neglected and Growing Population,” Paul Carmichael presents an illuminating account of the various barriers that exist to effective mental health service delivery to elderly people. He spells out the various provider-based and client-based limitations, pointing out that those that are provider-based are especially important to identify and overcome, including inadequate relevant provider training and education. A common problem identified is the general lack of cooperation between the aging network and the mental health system. The concept of “social disability” as a need indicator for people suffering from chronic mental health conditions is presented as providing an opportunity for those concerned about empowerment of elderly people to find common ground and shared “solutions.” Carmichael points out that within the mental health recovery movement there is a strong emphasis on social skills training to help individuals cope with, or to some extent overcome, their social disabilities. This is considered as an essential contribution to more fully empowering frail elderly people with severe mental illness. As already indicated, issues of training/education of service providers are the central focus of this chapter, addressed specifically to the mental capacity of clients. The lack of knowledge of clients’ views and wishes is a primary focus. In Chapter 13, “Older People with Longstanding Disabilities and Their Caregivers: Empowering a Neglected and Growing Population,” Lindsay Gething addresses issues of empowerment related to people aging with longstanding disabilities. She makes the case that a variety of impediments reflect lifelong cumulative disadvantage related to a lack of relevant government policies and service provider neglect. Ageist attitudes prevalent among older people themselves, as well as service providers, policy makers and the general community, exacerbate this situation. Gething points out that particular biased definitions of healthy or successful aging need reworking to ensure that they encompass aging with a disability. Intellectual disability poses particular issues related to empowerment, as many (probably most) people with intellectual disabilities have lived most of their lives in situations where they have little sense of control or freedom of choice. Goal attainment scaling is presented as a strategy for including older people in decision making related to the design and evaluation of service programs. The approach encourages a multidisciplinary group of care professionals to listen to their clients and work together in implementing a care plan. Similar to the previous chapter, issues related to the training and education of service providers, linked to both physical and mental capacity, are the central foci of this chapter. The lack of knowledge of clients’ views and wishes forms a primary focus.
Opportunities and Impediments
37
SOCIETAL BASED LIMITS Finally, if a society does not value its seniors, or only provides very limited program policy choices for care management in old age, these become impediments. This is especially true for those seniors who lack the financial resources to make up the difference in societal ignorance or complacency. In some cases the choices are there but society fails to provide the information or knowledge to make optimal choices. This is most prevalent when certain ethnic or economic minorities are systematically uninformed or only provided with the options available to the majority. The ultimate impediment is always ageism on the part of a society. In the final section of the book, we offer two chapters that step back from specific programs in specific countries and take a broader view of empowerment and the avenues to achieving it for frail older persons. In Chapter 14, “Empowerment in Pathways Through Care: A Cross-National Comparison of Care Delivery Systems in Britain and Germany,” Michaela Schunk offers us a cross-national analysis of the intersection of many levels of impediments in service delivery. Her investigation reveals major variations in the two countries in both the nature and functioning of the social state and in the organization of service delivery through social agencies. Due to this institutional variation, she illustrates how the frameworks for empowerment of frail elderly persons can be very different across countries and societies. In the final chapter of the book, “Empowerment of Frail Elderly People and the Vision of a Self-Actualized Society,” we revisit the two theoretical frameworks we began with in Chapter 1: Philip Clark’s philosophical approach to understanding what empowerment can mean and Moody’s social values continuum in relation to aging persons in a society. We highlight major common impediments found across the chapters but remain strong advocates for the hope of achieving true empowerment for frail elderly persons in all societies. We believe that regardless of the particular definition of empowerment currently understood or used, or the place of any given society along the path to a self-actualized society, the struggle to achieve empowerment for some of the most vulnerable of our world is a worthwhile and dignified endeavor.
PART II
SERVICE PROVIDERS AND EMPOWERMENT: INFORMATION, TRAINING, AND COORDINATION
3
Promoting Empowerment in Residential Aged Care: Seeking the Consumer View Duncan P. Boldy and Linda E. Grenade
This chapter presents an approach developed in Australia by which residential aged care services can provide their residents with the opportunity to express their views and any concerns they might have about the quality of their care. It considers both the extent to which the overall approach contributes to the increased empowerment of frail elderly people in residential care, as well as the extent to which specific impediments to empowerment, as identified in Chapter 2, are (or could be) mitigated through its utilization. First, however, we present some background information about aged care trends and associated policies in Australia, with an emphasis on those particularly relevant to issues of quality improvement and empowerment in residential aged care. Demographically speaking, Australia is a somewhat young country, with only 11.7% of its population aged 65 and older in 1993 compared to, for example, 15.8% in the United Kingdom (Gibson, 1998: 8). However, the Australian population has been aging more quickly in recent years, so that it is rapidly catching up. High rates of growth in the very old (85⫹) population, along with policy considerations, have led to considerable changes in the Australian aged care system, culminating in the Aged Care Reform Strategy, which was implemented over a ten-year period beginning in 1986. Relevant aspects of this strategy include: • a revision of the national planning guidelines leading to a greater emphasis on lower dependency institutional care (hostels—similar to residential homes) rather than nursing homes.
42
Empowering Frail Elderly People
• the introduction of specific “outcome standards” for residential aged care facilities. • increased resources for home and community care (Department of Health, Housing and Community Services, 1992).
OUTCOME STANDARDS, ACCREDITATION AND THE CONSUMER VIEW A key trend in health and social services in many developed countries is the increasing recognition of the relevance and importance of the consumer’s voice in determining how well services are meeting needs. In the residential aged care sphere in Australia, one of the most notable developments in this regard has been the introduction of outcome standards. These standards, initially developed for nursing homes (1987) then later for hostels (1990), have been used as a basis for external monitoring and assessment of residential aged care facilities by the federal government. While this monitoring and assessment process has always taken residents’ views into account, it has not done so in any systematic way, relying largely on ad hoc, often impromptu “interviews” with a small number of residents during visits by standards-monitoring teams to different aged care homes. Revised residential aged care standards, which reflect a number of recent changes within aged care provision, linked to accreditation, were introduced in 1998. A key feature of these revised standards is the requirement that service providers demonstrate that they have in place appropriate management systems, which permit continuous quality improvement (CQI) across all their operations. This requires that aged care facilities adopt a cycle of monitoring, assessment, action and follow-up. A particular example of CQI given in the standards guidelines is that “consumers are more informed and satisfied.” In addition, it is indicated that CQI activities should be responsive to management, staff and residents; in fact, CQI activities should actively seek their feedback “on all aspects of the services provided” (Department of Health and Family Services, 1998: G-8). Evidence that appropriate mechanisms have been implemented to meet these requirements is now a key aspect of the new accreditation process. At the formal level, this requirement that residents’ views should be systematically incorporated into quality improvement systems is an important development related to the increased empowerment of residents, in that they are being given the opportunity to participate more directly in the planning and provision of their care. KEY ISSUES IN ELICITING RESIDENTS’ VIEWS Consumer satisfaction has been increasingly acknowledged as an important indicator of the quality of care in relation to health and human services (e.g., Westbrook, 1993), including the field of institutional care for older
Promoting Empowerment
43
people, and a number of studies have provided important insights into matters of concern to residents (e.g., Bartlett, 1993; Willcocks et al., 1987). Resident/patient input related to the assessment of quality of care issues, linked to the standards-monitoring processes, is now quite common in the United States (Phillips-Doyle, 1992). It is acknowledged that consumer views can provide an additional source of information about quality of care issues (including those explored via statutory standards monitoring) and valuable feedback to managers, administrators and staff about the services they are providing, including information about any deficiencies. There are, however, many problems associated with measuring consumers’ views, and these have been well documented (e.g., Carr-Hill et al., 1989; Peace et al., 1997). First, the validity of formal measurement instruments is often questionable. In the absence of any agreed-upon satisfaction criteria or of a direct measure of satisfaction, there can be no guarantee that an instrument is measuring what it is intended to measure. Second, instruments often lack reliability, as stability over time and between different raters is not usually demonstrated. Third, the scale used may influence the quality of the instrument; for example, rating scales using “excellent” to “poor” have been found superior to satisfaction scales using “very satisfied” to “very dissatisfied.” Fourth, there is often little opportunity provided for the collection of qualitative data via open-ended questions, so as to give depth and meaning to quantitative scores. Fifth, measures have often been used by providers to identify unsatisfactory elements of care, but not necessarily to develop consumer criteria for quality of care. There are several other issues concerning the assessment of consumers’ views. Given the increasing mental and physical frailty of residents in nursing homes, it is usually not possible to obtain feedback from them all. The extent to which family, caregivers or health professionals are able to act as residents’ agents or proxies is thus an important question. Who is most appropriate to undertake an evaluation is also an important question. If it is to be conducted by service providers themselves, there are many sensitive issues, including possible bias in the selection of residents. The tendency of residents to give bland responses, and their reluctance to criticize services upon which they are dependent, further hinder the usefulness of consumerderived information. This is exacerbated by the low expectations of many older people; residents’ views may reflect not only their present circumstances but also adverse previous life events and experiences (such as the war years, the Depression and other hardships). Finally, it can be very timeconsuming to administer consumer instruments, particularly interview schedules. AN AUSTRALIAN APPROACH The overall aim of our project was to develop a manual or package that would allow managers and administrators of aged care homes in Australia
44
Empowering Frail Elderly People
to explore in depth the needs and concerns of their residents and, thereby, to identify any issues requiring attention or action. It was also seen as a means by which residents themselves could voice their opinions about a range of issues relating to living in the homes, which could be used as a basis for both immediate action as well as longer-term planning. The approach developed provides one means by which the consumer consultation and input requirements of the new accreditation system outlined earlier can be met. The project, which was funded by the Commonwealth Department of Health and Family Services, was conducted on a national basis and extended over a period of approximately two and a half years, commencing in mid1995. Residents played a vital role throughout the project, which also involved extensive consultations with service providers and consumer representatives. The process of developing the manual occurred in a number of stages, namely: 1. Development of survey instruments. 2. Testing of survey instruments and development of a draft manual. 3. Testing of the draft manual and production of a final version.
The first stage of the project focused on identifying the key issues and problems associated with obtaining consumer feedback (in particular within residential aged care) as well as any existing relevant instruments that might be useful. A further aim was to identify key dimensions as well as specific issues to be included in the survey instruments. These aims were addressed via a review of relevant literature, focus groups with residents and/or their representatives in a variety of aged care homes around Australia, and consultations with other relevant stakeholders (e.g., staff and managers of aged care homes, consumer organizations, researchers in the aged care area). The involvement of residents (and/or their representatives) in this initial stage of the project was regarded as particularly crucial in that it helped to ensure that the survey instruments developed would be meaningful and relevant to them. Fairly early in the project, the decision was made to focus on the personal interview method as the most preferable survey option. This decision was based not only on evidence from the literature in terms of the strengths and limitations of different methods but also on our own previous experience in aged care research. In particular, it was felt that providing an opportunity for residents to discuss their views and concerns on a more in-depth basis provided a better means for identifying the issues of importance to them. Particularly from a service provider point of view, however, the survey by interview method has a number of limitations in terms of, for example, the time and cost commitments involved. For this reason it was also decided to
Promoting Empowerment
45
include a self-complete (or self-report) questionnaire as another survey option, this being derived from the interview schedule. The content of the two survey instruments was based on a number of dimensions and issues identified from analysis of the information obtained via the focus groups, discussions with other stakeholders and the literature review (which included various policy documents such as the current outcome standards for residential aged care). Key dimensions included adjustment to moving into residential care, the physical environment (e.g., residents’ rooms, general amenities, gardens and grounds), social life, and services and care. Questions relating to issues such as freedom of choice and resident involvement were also included. A major challenge at this point was to develop an instrument that was not too long but that still managed to be sufficiently comprehensive. Two versions of the interview schedule and self-complete questionnaire, respectively, were developed. One was for use with residents directly, the other was for use with proxies (or resident representatives) in cases where residents, for reasons such as cognitive impairment, were not able to participate directly in the survey process. While recognizing the limitations of the use of proxies, it was felt to be the most preferable compromise, given the general survey approach adopted, in that it at least attempted to obtain a perspective on behalf of the resident. An important feature of the interview schedule, in particular, was the emphasis on open-ended questions, which allowed for in-depth discussion of the different issues covered. It also provided the opportunity for participants to identify other issues and concerns. Given the target group in question, the self-complete questionnaire was of necessity a much more structured instrument, based primarily on a rating scale response format (check a box), although there was some opportunity for participants to raise other issues or make additional comments if they wished. In order to make the latter as user friendly as possible, the questionnaires were produced in large print. The second stage of the project involved extensive testing of the survey instruments developed in the first stage as well as development of the draft manual. Instrument testing, which, as indicated earlier, focused mainly on the interview schedule, was conducted in a range of aged care facilities around the country. This included metropolitan and rural facilities of varying sizes and types (e.g., new, such as modern cluster housing design; traditional or old style), which were sponsored by different types of organizations (e.g., religious or charitable groups, local government). Within each facility, a wide variety of types of residents were involved, although in homes with higher proportions of high dependency residents, selection was largely based on ability and willingness to participate. A total of 258 residents or their representatives, living in 28 facilities, were interviewed. The interviews aver-
46
Empowering Frail Elderly People
aged 30 to 45 minutes and were conducted by the authors and a research assistant recruited for the purpose. The process of testing and refining the schedule was a cyclical one, involving interviewing residents (and/or their representatives) in a number of facilities, reviewing the appropriateness of the schedule, and making relevant modifications. Throughout this process, residents, as well as service providers and other stakeholders, were also encouraged to give their views on the schedule, in terms of content, wording and so on. The dimensions covered by the final versions of both interview schedules and questionnaires were similar to those mentioned previously with some minor modifications; for example, greater emphasis was placed on covering issues relevant to residents’ involvement with and in the local community. As regards validity and reliability, the former is felt to have been ensured via the consultations and literature review conducted as part of the first stage as well as the testing, refinement and ongoing consultation conducted throughout the second stage. The interview schedule was also tested for inter-rater reliability which resulted in some changes being made, primarily in relation to question wording (e.g., to eliminate possible ambiguity). After appropriate changes had been made, the resulting interview schedule was found to demonstrate a very high level of reliability. The self-complete questionnaire was also tested in a range of facilities (13 in all, covering a total of 159 residents) and modified as appropriate. As for the interview schedule, feedback about the questionnaire from residents as well as service providers and other stakeholders was encouraged throughout the testing process. The questionnaire was found to have a high level of internal reliability (based on Cronbach’s Alpha) and stability (test-retest reliability). The final phase of the second stage of the project involved developing other components of the manual, specifically a means by which the information obtained from both the interview schedules and questionnaires could be summarized (either manually or via computer), a proforma reporting format and guidelines relating to surveying residents using the respective methods. These guidelines included advice regarding resident selection, use of survey instruments, choice of interviewers, (where involved), summarizing and interpreting the results and, importantly, strategies for follow-up action that placed heavy emphasis on the (continuing) involvement of residents. Also included was an appropriately modified version of the Mini-Mental State Examination questionnaire (Folstein et al. 1975) to be used, if necessary, as a means of identifying residents who would not be capable cognitively (e.g., due to dementia) of participating directly in a survey (i.e., necessitating the involvement of a representative). The third and final stage of the project involved distributing the manual to a variety of residential aged care facilities for them to administer independently. Managers of the 33 facilities involved in this stage were free to
Promoting Empowerment
47
choose whatever approach they wished to survey their residents, with almost two-thirds opting for the survey by interview approach. Feedback about the manual was obtained via a written evaluation form sent out with the draft manual in conjunction with follow-up phone calls and some face-to-face discussions. In general, the feedback obtained was extremely positive, with the manual being considered sufficiently comprehensive, easy to understand and use, and a source of valuable information. Apart from a variety of comments relating to specific sections of the manual (e.g., advice on selecting residents to be included in a survey), the most common issue raised was the overall time involved in preparing for and conducting the survey itself, particularly in relation to summarizing the information provided by residents. The view of the authors is, however, that if facilities really wish to know how residents feel about the standard of care and services being provided, the process will inevitably be time consuming. The final version of the manual has emphasized this point even further. The inclusion of a survey by self-complete questionnaire, however, does provide a less time-consuming (and also less costly) option for facilities if they wish to use it although, as previously mentioned, and particularly in terms of really providing residents with an opportunity to air their views, the survey by interview approach is a much preferable option. OVERALL RELEVANCE OF THE APPROACH TO EMPOWERMENT In terms of Clark’s (1989) four interpretations of empowerment, our approach to eliciting the views of the residents of aged care facilities probably has most relevance to personal process and effective deliberation and moral reflection. It also has a connection with issues related to balance and interdependence, but is only indirectly related to political activism and social process. In relation to personal process, while it may not directly empower residents, a sincere, unbiased and scientific attempt on behalf of the management of aged care facilities to identify issues of concern, as perceived by the residents themselves, with the intention to act where possible/feasible to improve the situation, has obvious positive implications for the residents’ feelings of powerlessness and perceptions of paternalism and limited control. The use of interview schedules or self-complete questionnaires within the approach also provides residents with an opportunity for some degree of effective deliberation and moral reflection, in that it encourages them to think about their situations and care in some depth and to identify any possible areas for improvement or change. A particularly important issue in relation to residential care is that of empowerment related to balance and interdependence. The management of residential aged care facilities needs to balance financial considerations, which are often unavoidable or at least imposed from outside, with the
48
Empowering Frail Elderly People
desires of residents to exercise freedom of choice regarding such decisions as when to get up, when to have their meals, and so on. Staffing levels in residential aged care, reflecting financial constraints, often limit severely the extent to which personal choice on behalf of residents is permitted. The use of our approach could help in identifying the particular priorities for change desired by residents, which could be more readily accommodated within existing staffing constraints and/or provide evidence for arguing for increased funding (perhaps leading to political activism?). IMPEDIMENTS ADDRESSED BY OUR APPROACH Before discussing some of the impediments to empowerment that can be addressed by the use of our approach, it is worth noting that various aspects of the process employed to develop the manual—in particular, the continued emphasis on resident involvement and feedback throughout the project— can also be regarded as (potentially) empowering. Specific examples include the use of qualitative methods as a means of identifying key dimensions and issues (e.g., focus groups with residents), the emphasis on the in-depth interview method (as the preferred survey option), the continued insistence on the participation of residents as being entirely voluntary, and the attention paid to preserving confidentiality and anonymity. Provider-based Limits As should be obvious, one of the main impediments to empowerment addressed by our approach relates to the lack of knowledge of clients’ views, needs and wishes on the part of service providers. Many service providers may, of course, have some idea of residents’ needs and views (or at least those that residents are prepared to express), either as a result of their own efforts to actively seek such views (for example, via residents’ meetings or ad hoc, in-house surveys) or through informal contact or feedback from residents, family members and/or staff. This is certainly not always the case, however, for reasons such as a lack of time and appropriate tools and/or expertise. The availability of a manual that provides all the tools necessary to conduct a survey, including advice regarding such things as interviewing techniques, interpreting results and follow-up, thus provides one means by which service providers can not only increase their knowledge and awareness of residents views, but can do so knowing that the information they obtain is both valid and reliable. A similar argument can be applied in cases where, for example, service providers assume they know what their clients need or want, this being reflected in the kinds of or ways in which services are provided and by particular biases in service delivery. Biases in service delivery might also be the result
Promoting Empowerment
49
of service providers responding, for example, to the views of a vocal minority of residents or to pressure from family members. Again, our approach provides a means by which such problems can be addressed; for example, by the inclusion of detailed advice regarding the sampling of residents and how to maximize participation or response rates. It is also our view that the approach, in providing a means by which service providers can become more aware of the particular service and care needs of residents, provides an information base relevant to the development of more flexible and coordinated programs, where appropriate. Environmental Limits Particularly within the residential age care setting, different aspects of the living environment can represent a serious limitation in terms of resident empowerment. Exploring different aspects of this environment—both physical aspects such as residents’ rooms, communal areas, complex maintenance and so on, as well as from a policy perspective (i.e., rules, routines and codes of practice), and the ways in which such impediments might be removed or reduced—represents an important component of the approach. To this end, both survey instruments contain a comprehensive range of questions on relevant topics. In addition, various aspects of the social environment, such as activities and links with the community (e.g., access to and involvement in community activities) are also explored. Client-based Limits In terms of client-based impediments to empowerment, our project presented some major methodological challenges, several of which have already been discussed. One of these was how best to overcome problems associated with people’s physical and cognitive limitations, which, in many cases, particularly in nursing homes, are often severe. As regards physical limitations, such as deafness and blindness, the approach provides a number of ways by which input can be provided; for example, the availability of written questionnaires for hearing impaired people and, for those with sight impairments, the availability of the interview method and/or large-print questionnaires, depending on the extent of impairment. Large-print cue cards are also provided in conjunction with the interview approach for use when respondents are asked to rate a particular aspect of care; this was also found to be useful from a cognitive impairment perspective, in terms of helping residents to remember the various rating options. Involving residents with cognitive impairments has proved a particular challenge and involved considerable research, via existing literature, consultation and discussion. As noted earlier, after careful consideration it was decided that, within our approach, we had no better alternative than to rely
50
Empowering Frail Elderly People
on the views of representatives (generally family members) for residents who are more seriously impaired, both cognitively and physically. While there is, of course, no guarantee that the views of proxies correspond to those of residents, it at least provides a perspective on behalf of those who would not otherwise be able to participate. On several occasions during pilot testing, representatives were interviewed together with the resident who, in some cases, was also able to provide input. This is an alternative option. In terms of being able to fully participate in a survey, language and cultural background are also important factors. While not specifically intended for use in ethno-specific facilities, the interview schedule has been used with a number of people from non–English speaking backgrounds with the assistance of interpreters and has appeared to work quite satisfactorily. Accordingly, the final version of the manual contains detailed advice regarding how best to deal with language- and culture-related issues (e.g., how to work with an interpreter). At a more specific level, several questions within the interview schedules and questionnaires allow issues relating to language and culture to be explored in some detail. Another major challenge in terms of client-related limits to empowerment was how to deal with issues such as the general reluctance of many elderly people who are dependent on the services and care they are receiving to criticize that care, because of fear of retribution and/or not wishing to offend or make trouble for staff members. As noted earlier, another related issue is the tendency, well documented in the literature, for elderly people to give overly positive or bland responses when asked about issues relating to their care. The approach developed has attempted to address such issues in a number of ways in order to maximize the likelihood that residents will indicate what they really think or feel as opposed to what they think they should say. These include the particular attention paid to issues of confidentiality and anonymity (e.g., detailed advice regarding these issues in the survey guidelines, no identifying information on forms), the emphasis on the interview method as the preferable survey option and the generally relaxed style of the interview schedule. A particular example is the use of open-ended questions (with additional probes) as a means of encouraging discussion. Research evidence indicates that people are more willing to criticize when this type of question format is employed. Recommendations in the survey guidelines that skilled interviewers who have no connection with the facility should be employed to conduct the interviews with residents is another relevant facet of our approach. There are a number of other ways in which our approach could be regarded as, at least indirectly, addressing other specific, client-based impediments to empowerment. First, the very fact that the approach focuses specifically on seeking residents’ views implies that their opinions are important and may hence help overcome problems relating to—perhaps even
Promoting Empowerment
51
help boost—self-esteem. More specifically, the time involved in conducting the survey, particularly in the case of the survey by interview approach, where residents’ views are sought in some detail in a relaxed, unrushed manner, can have a positive effect and encourage residents to say what they really think; indeed, during piloting, some people actually expressed their appreciation that someone was taking the time to seek their personal views. The tendency of many elderly people living in residential care to accept the current standard of care as the norm (e.g., “what you haven’t had, you don’t miss”), particularly when there is generally nothing with which to make comparisons, is another related problem. While, as noted above, strategies such as the emphasis on the survey by interview method as a means of promoting in-depth discussion and the specific structure of the survey instruments themselves (e.g., use of open-ended questions with probes, careful wording of questions), have been employed in order to encourage people to think about their situations and say what they really think and/ or would like, we cannot expect to overcome this problem completely. In a similar way, our approach, with its emphasis on encouraging people to discuss their situations and various aspects of their lifestyle and care, could also be regarded as at least indirectly helping to overcome barriers relating to personal choice and perceptions regarding the aging process and the meaning of care. Societal Limits As regards societal-level impediments to empowerment, it could be argued that our approach—by virtue of its focus on seeking the views of residents specifically, and the emphasis, in the guidelines, on involving them in later follow-up and development of action plans—implies that their views and ideas are of value and hence represents an important contribution toward combating ageism. Similarly, providing an approach by which residents can influence service provision and planning, particularly when linked with developments in the accreditation process in Australia, implies some willingness, at the broader level, to empower elderly people, as does the increasing emphasis on residents’ rights and the growth of the advocacy movement within residential aged care. Highlighting the importance of resident input can also be regarded as a way of helping to overcome any fear or reluctance on the part of residents to be involved and, hence, can actually increase their own willingness to be more empowered. CONCLUDING COMMENTS Given the institutional setting with which we are dealing, and the fact that, ultimately, residents will always remain, to some degree, dependent on
52
Empowering Frail Elderly People
the service provider, this chapter is not about ultimate empowerment in the idealistic sense of full control of the planning and management of care; rather, it relates more to interpretations of empowerment that focus on better informed clients, care managers and providers, and clients being better able to voice their perspectives and desires (and providers who are better able to listen) (see Chapter 1). The approach can also be regarded as facilitating the balance and interdependence aspect of empowerment through its potential for promoting greater mutual understanding and cooperation. Nevertheless, the fact that we were funded by the key Federal body in Australia with responsibility for aged care policy and provision to develop the manual and approach described in this chapter indicates that issues related to the empowerment of elderly people in residential care are viewed, by at least some policy makers, as having a degree of importance. While we do not claim that the approach we have described provides a definitive solution to all of the methodological challenges involved in assessing the views of residents of aged care homes, or that it counteracts all possible impediments, we believe that it does represent an excellent and valid attempt to obtain the views of older people in residential care facilities and that it provides a valuable model that other countries might consider replicating.
4
Reimagining Senior Empowerment in Service Delivery: Creative Applications in a Global Context Mary E. McCall
Several years ago, Marvin Kaiser (1993), in his analysis of the roles of older people in developing countries, talked about the notion that successful adaptation to aging depends upon the availability of choice plus the retention of a sense of usefulness derived from participation in productive activities. Such successful adaptation clearly incorporates the four interpretations of empowerment (Clark, 1989) as outlined in Chapter 1: effective deliberation and moral reflection: personal process; political activism and social process; and balance and interdependence. This chapter will discuss three health and social service projects in the United States that sought to empower frail elderly people in a variety of ways, all of which reflect the various definitions of empowerment used here. Around the world, it has become increasingly clear that we need to move beyond the traditional views of providing health and social services to frail elderly persons from a “provider-knows-best” perspective. This perspective reflects a “social service” stage of societal development according to Moody’s model of social values (see Chapter 1). There are a variety of reasons for such an imperative. Given the changing demographics reflecting the increase in the number of elders in developed countries, the time has come to move beyond the status quo of pitting expensive government services against uncompensated family provision of care and service to our seniors. In many countries, where government support of services for seniors is decreasing, societies need to envision new and creative approaches to empower citizens in their own care and provide options and information which enable people to make informed decisions about their quality of life. However, if
54
Empowering Frail Elderly People
a society is firmly entrenched in a “social service” model, such efforts may be futile. In the United States, where we are squarely in between the “social service” model and the “participation” model outlined in Chapter 1, we are facing the same challenges that many industrialized countries are: How do we truly empower individuals and yet be willing to deal with the potential consequences of older persons making choices that, as a society, we have a stake in? This is the theme of the public-private collaborations that have been observed over the last several years. These represent new and needed approaches for nations facing an increased number of very diverse older persons, some of whom are more capable than ever and some of whom are more frail than ever. One of the major lessons learned from this work is the need to look for unlikely sources of assistance and advocacy that can be major contributors to empowerment. It is also important to look beyond the obvious—what may seem to make the most sense to us as providers, may not make any sense to the elderly person. The goal in all these projects has been to meet the needs of frail elderly people at varying levels of independence/dependence both effectively and efficiently while maintaining their autonomy and dignity as individual human beings. Each of these projects illustrates how the different definitions of empowerment (Clark, 1989) can be manifested in various areas of services for frail elders. SENIOR HOUSING NEEDS SURVEY The first project was a survey conducted in a small suburban town in the San Francisco, California, East Bay Area, designed to gather information about housing needs and desires of residents over 55 years of age. As this information was used to try to project future housing needs for the whole of Contra Costa County, it is important to understand the geographical and social layout because the disparate sections represent different constituencies with potentially different needs. This is a case where context became very important in understanding the priorities of different areas of this county. However, these factors of geographical location, neighborhood composition and access to services are relevant in any county or nation. Contra Costa County is geographically divided into three parts: West County, Central County and East County, and a vast delta divides Central county from East county. Elders in East County come from varied minority ethnic groups; Central County is populated by more affluent, mostly white, retirees and is the seat of the county government; West County seniors are mainly blue-collar workers who were left without jobs after the end of World War II, when the main supply point to the Pacific Theater was eliminated. Better transportation in recent years has allowed the separate parts of the county to be less isolated. Nevertheless, the three parts remain fairly distinct in their environmental context and feeling. In a different survey that was completed throughout the entire county, over 1,500 respondents indicated
Reimagining Senior Empowerment
55
health as their major concern, with crime and elder abuse as close seconds. Other concerns were long-term care, income security, mental health, nutrition, housing, and in-home services. While these responses may be a clear case of hearing the obvious, these concerns did differ slightly by county area. In the specific housing survey that was conducted in one town in Central County, adults over the age of 55 indicated their preference for remaining in their community, even if they needed to move out of their existing residence. Most would prefer to remain in their residences, even in the states of disrepair in which some of them exist. While it may seem obvious to us that most older people want to stay in their homes, what is not as obvious is the need for attention to some details that can make this a realistic possibility. For example, simple things such as safety carpets, safety rails in the bath and/or hallways, external lighting, and even inexpensive items such as deadbolt locks and smoke alarms were lacking in many homes. The town’s Council on Aging used this information to identify creative ways in which the community might meet some of these basic needs. For example, some of the more inexpensive items could be obtained by soliciting donations from local hardware companies whose reputation for being communityminded improves their image and, as a consequence, perhaps, their local business. Organizing volunteer labor groups of young persons from the local schools to install items or to clean up debris, perform simple repairs and the like, was another way to use “unlikely sources” to help the seniors in the neighborhood maintain their residences and their ability to stay in those residences. Another way in which larger community organizations and members were involved in this project was through the donation of funds from the local telephone company to cover some of the costs of the project. In addition, we were able to utilize members of the local chapter of the Retired Senior Volunteers Program (RSVP) to conduct some of the surveys. They participated in a day of interviewer training and then each took as many names as they could and contacted community residents to solicit their participation in the survey. Such involvement demonstrates how collaboration can achieve empowerment of some through support from others. This survey illustrates several of the definitions of empowerment. First, involving older persons themselves in determining housing priorities puts them in the position of reflecting and deliberating on their current status as well as imagining where they might be in 10 or 20 years, and how their current values can inform their future desires. Second, this process of collecting information from community seniors clearly engages them in the personal process of planning and advanced thinking that Clark advocates. Third, the involvement of seniors in the town housing planning process allows them to feel empowered in a political arena in ways they have not before. The social process of meeting with other residents, interacting with both peers and persons of other age groups, underscores the sense of inter-
56
Empowering Frail Elderly People
dependence that Clark also refers to in his typology of definitions of empowerment. However, one of the impediments to meeting the needs of some older persons is often the attitude of the older people themselves, who balk at the notion that they are dependent in any way. They do not want to be seen as “needy” or unable to take complete care of themselves any more. Again, where we may think it is obvious that people will accept the help they need to get what they want—in this case, staying in their home—the situation may not be that simple. Such resistance may be seen in areas of need for financial assistance (some residents cannot afford smoke alarms or safety bars because of their limited income), physical assistance (they do not want to admit they need help getting in and out of the bathtub, or cleaning their roof gutters), or help in making decisions about issues such as health care or medication use. Most providers respond to such resistance with the attitude that “we know best and so you should follow our advice.” In discussing the role of empowerment in health education, Rodwell concludes that “whilst health promoters emphasize the principles of voluntarism—the freedom to make any choice—it is clear that some choices are assumed to be better than others. There is also an implicit assumption that healthy choices are synonymous with rational choices and this is not always the case” (Rodwell, 1996: 309). We can see that allowing for true choice by older people can sometimes be a risky proposition if they choose to stay in their home under unsafe conditions. In addition to the notion that the “obvious” may not always be “right” in a given situation, the problem of overcoming attitudinal challenges may also be very context-specific. As the following example illustrates, this attitude of not wanting to admit the need for help is especially acute in another setting in which frail elderly persons are residing. In a group of buildings that offer government-subsidized housing to very low-income elders, frail seniors do their best to maintain the “independence” that is required by the government to qualify to stay in such housing. Satellite Senior Homes, Inc. is the nonprofit housing management corporation that owns and operates 16 buildings in the San Francisco East Bay Area. These buildings are primarily located in urban areas—some in very high-crime areas—and range from 35 to 150 units, typically in elevator-served 3–8 floor buildings. Residents in these buildings are ethnically and racially diverse (although a few buildings are almost exclusively African American and two are entirely Chinese), speak multiple languages and come from a wide diversity of geographical, educational and social backgrounds. While there is often some resistance among middle-class seniors (such as those in Contra Costa County) to discussing financial issues, or admitting that their physical capabilities are declining, for very low-income seniors, the fears and level of resistance escalate dramatically. For these residents, their
Reimagining Senior Empowerment
57
ability to stay in their apartments is based on their “ability to maintain independence.” However, these residents have been marginalized in our society for most of their lives. They have not received the kind of adequate education, training, employment, and health care that many middle class citizens take for granted. Thus, they are very reluctant to admit any form of neediness. However, the definition of independence, according to the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) criteria has changed over the years as these residents have “aged in place.” Many residents are eligible to receive in-home supportive services (housekeeping, meals-onwheels, etc.) and still remain in their apartments. However, trying to explain to them the changing guidelines that govern their ability to stay in their current housing is a challenge, because they are so suspicious. The importance of understanding someone’s background and life history is an important contextual component that we often fail to acknowledge or explore when we try to design or deliver services to seniors. Despite the widespread admission by service providers that each senior is unique, we continue to design support programs, and even make assumptions about what empowerment means, as if all seniors were the same. This is a poignant example of the notion of empowerment as personal process—understanding where individuals have come from in their life, what their values and priorities are, and what they may even want to have power over, if anything. Even within this group of low-income seniors, the importance of context could be seen in how the residents and their respective needs differ from building to building and neighborhood to neighborhood. This became very clear as we proceeded with a health-based project in some of these buildings. HEALTH SCREENING AND EDUCATION PROJECT In one project (funded by the True North Foundation), instituted in two of these buildings, third-year undergraduate nursing students (in a Bachelor of Science in Nursing program) from a nearby college provided on-site health screening and promotion to the residents on a weekly basis during the academic year. Students conducted a weekly “health clinic” where they checked blood pressure, blood glucose levels, weight and vision; conducted an exercise class; and presented health education workshops on various topics ranging from “How to Have a Healthy, Happy Bladder” to “Fabulous Foot Care” to “Coping with Grief and Loss.” The students were responsible for designing the workshops, including graphics and handouts and presenting the material in pairs to the residents. A gerontological nurse faculty member was responsible for supervising the students. Home visits were also conducted and students interviewed all participating residents (in the clinic or at home) to take health histories and fill out a lifestyle profile questionnaire about nutrition, stress, and exercise habits (Walker, Sechrist and Pender, 1987), medication use profiles and
58
Empowering Frail Elderly People
other basic health inventories. In this way, residents could gain a broader perspective on their health status, and students could provide residents with health information to which they might not otherwise have access. Students and the faculty member also assisted residents in identifying questions to ask their doctors. The goal of this project was to empower residents when it came to their own health status and health-related knowledge through education and support. As they learned more about their current condition, how to maintain it and how to prevent exacerbation of existing conditions, residents gained more control over their health. This is one of the specific goals of the government-sponsored national health agenda in the United States— Healthy People 2000 (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 1991). One of the important things that we learned from this project is that individuals who are already health-conscious look for opportunities to maintain and/or improve their health status. At-risk seniors and elders who do not view their health as a priority pose a challenge for health professionals and students. Again, although it may seem obvious that older persons would want to do what is right for their health, and learn more about how to take better care of themselves, that is not necessarily true. This is another example of the potentially negative or threatening consequences of giving people power over their own lives—regarding health care, diet, exercise, environment or anything else. Reaching the residents and engaging them in the services offered required the use of creative approaches. These included game-playing for exercise, use of music, offering individualized home visits and tailoring educational presentations to specific interests and needs identified by the residents. These innovative methods to reach the residents proved to be successful, as over one-third of the residents were served in the first year. Fundamental to the success of such a program is the identification of and collaboration with various sources of input and approval for such an undertaking. And while this may seem obvious, many times program planners do not consult with the most likely sources of support—the recipients of the services themselves. For example, meetings were initially conducted with the resident councils in each building to get the residents to “buy in” to the program, as well as with on-site support staff and personnel (e.g., the social worker for the particular building) to secure their cooperation. Residents gave suggestions about topics for the workshops, and indicated their preferences for the kind of exercise they enjoyed. The nurse faculty was also able to solicit the assistance of one bilingual resident who spoke both English and Cantonese to enlist the participation of many of the Cantonesespeaking residents. While they came at a separate time from the other residents (they always came right at the end of the health-screening session), they did consistently participate in the clinic activities. Such inclusion and cooperation is essential for all to invest in the project and feel that each is
Reimagining Senior Empowerment
59
benefiting from as well as contributing to the overall outcomes. Again, this process facilitated the empowerment of the residents in their own personal process of reflecting on, identifying and planning for what they wanted to get out of the program. One of the most positive outcomes for residents was feeling “needed” and useful to the students, knowing they had something of their own life experience to offer. Their participation in the students’ education increased their sense of usefulness and self-esteem, and helped them recognize and acknowledge their social value. This exemplifies Kaiser’s (1993) point that elders need to retain a sense of social importance and purpose. In addition to the residents’ improving their sense of worth, students also increased their knowledge of and sensitivity to community-dwelling independent seniors. While this may seem an obvious outcome, it is one that is often discounted in its importance to developing a generation of future health providers with a mindset of understanding and respecting the independence and dignity of older persons. One of the most important ways we can all work to maintain the power of older persons is to build that goal into the ways in which all of us in society deal with seniors, no matter what field we work in or what kind of contact we have with older persons. One of the major lessons here is that community partnerships such as these benefit all who are involved. Seniors improve their health knowledge and their health awareness and perhaps improve or at least maintain their positive health behaviors. They learn that they can contribute to the growth and development of a younger generation. Students get a real sense of the range of behaviors and abilities that are encompassed in the term independent, and how to communicate with and listen effectively to seniors with a variety of educational, ethnic and socioeconomic backgrounds. While many seniors of racial minority status in the United States have objectively poor health, oftentimes they report better subjective health status. The students get a much clearer sense of the distinction between the two types of health status and the importance of understanding the subtle differences between them, as well as the role of contextual factors in such differences. The experience of one older woman, who has lost one leg below the knee from diabetes and was in danger of losing the other, illustrates this. Objectively, she seemed to be in dire straits. However, in a building where she had many friends who helped her with practical tasks such as dressing or shopping, as well as provided emotional and moral support, her outlook on life was very positive. Many students continually remarked on the positive attitudes that residents maintained in the face of what, as middle-class Americans, they would consider almost unlivable circumstances. In addition to the benefits to both residents and students, the local college gained a wider reputation within the community as an institution that is open to collaboration in meeting community needs. In fact, one of the commitments that was made at the time of the initial connection between
60
Empowering Frail Elderly People
the two agencies was that the housing site would become a permanent clinical rotation for the nursing students. That commitment has been maintained since the official project ended and is crucial in circumstances such as these, where residents have often felt used or exploited by researchers for their own purposes. It sends a message that others care for them as individuals, and not just as research subjects. Through such a collaboration, the nonprofit housing corporation can also more fully meet the needs of its residents at minimal or no cost. In this way, all involved are winners. One of the most effective ways of overcoming the impediment of negative societal values regarding the role of elderly people in any society is by changing the attitudes of people across all segments of society. As psychological research has shown, the best way to break down stereotypes is through personal interaction and learning that all people are unique and that everyone has something to offer to the common good. In the United States, as in other countries (e.g., Japan), there has been a push toward expanding intergenerational contact, precisely to create opportunities for people of different ages to get to know, understand and respect one another. Through such contact, persons of all ages come to understand the reality of interdependence among generations, and begin to develop a deeper investment in others, seeing that they, too, were either once part of a younger generation, or will one day be part of an older generation. This is the way in which societies can move from a “social service” stage of values through “participation” toward the “self-actualization” stage. Work in Australia by Borowski and Ozanne (1993) has recommended a move that would reinforce such values—developing a needs-based planning, funding and service approach. This would include a shift in the balance of care from nursing home to hostel (similar to board-and-care homes in the United States) and community care provision and the improvement of assessment services. They also advocate change in federal funding to boost incentives for such approaches, such as the monitoring system presented in Chapter 3. These approaches mirror the “channeling” projects in the United States, where federal monies are channeled to the individual state, which then uses them creatively to meet the needs of elders in ways other than the traditional nursing home setting. The states of Florida and Oregon have been especially successful in utilizing such programs. Currently, the state of California, where all the work discussed in this chapter took place, is also applying for a similar Medicaid waiver status, which would enable the state to use blocks of funding to provide services in a new and, hopefully, more efficient and effective manner. Such a move is based on the premise that more flexibility in meeting the individual needs of frail elders is of greater importance than maintaining an antiquated system that treats all elders in the same or similar ways. In British Columbia, Canada, the government is involved in developing programs such as the collaborative one described above. In Canada’s na-
Reimagining Senior Empowerment
61
tional health system, the government provides all services and has a strong home health care system in place. So the notion that students in the health professions could participate in service delivery was not seen as very viable. Whether a government is structured hierarchically, with consistency in policy and service from the top down, such as in Japan (see Chapter 5), or whether a pluralistic structure exists, such as in the United States, is clearly going to affect the potential success or even possibility of the development of creative programs and approaches. In a recent article discussing collaborative research (between government and academe) in Manitoba, Canada, in the early 1990s, the authors conclude “perhaps expecting a true partnership between academic research groups and government agencies—which have a political agenda in addition to a social agenda— . . . is unrealistic” (Chappell et al., 1998:37). Borowski and Ozanne (1993) also urged that standards be developed to include health care, social independence, freedom of choice for elders, a homelike environment, privacy and dignity, safety, and a variety of experiences. This is a very different model from that found in the United States, where solely objective standards are assessed (e.g., staff/patient ratios) and it is left up to individual nursing homes or senior housing projects to develop, maintain and assess the more subjective quality-of-life issues. This is an area where empowerment through political activism could be instrumental in facing the impediment of the “social service” mentality that permeates much of the health care system in the United States. REMINISCENCE PROJECT The third project was designed specifically to enhance the quality of life of seniors living in this same subsidized senior housing in which we established the health clinics. Research has shown that the most common functional psychiatric condition of late life is depression (Blazer & Busse, 1996; see also McDougall et al., 1997). Because of its association with excess morbidity and mortality, depression in older adults calls for focused and intense intervention. A meta-analysis of 17 studies in which older adults received a variety of psychosocial treatments revealed reminiscence therapy to be an effective method for helping older persons deal with emotional distress. Life-review approaches are much less expensive than clinical treatments, some of which may not be fully covered by insurance. Life-review approaches can also be used to promote social relationships among older persons. Parson (1986, see also McDougall et al., 1997) found a lessening of depression measured by the Geriatric Depression Scale in a small group (n⫽9) of older persons living in similar federally funded housing after only six group reminiscence sessions. The project consisted of a series of 10-week reminiscence “classes” designed for older adults in small groups of 8 to 10. This was based on a
62
Empowering Frail Elderly People
model developed by Edmund Sherman (1991). Each week the group met for 1–11⁄2 hours, discussing a specified period of time in their lives (e.g., childhood, adolescence, young adulthood, etc.). The process of reminiscence has been shown in previous research and theoretical work to assist in the important late-life psychological tasks of developing what Erik Erikson called “wisdom” and coming to accept one’s impending death (Papalia & Olds, 1995). This project was designed to address these psychological needs, as well as some social needs, of this very diverse group of low-income, urbandwelling seniors. The group was composed of residents from both the “independent living” sections of the building and the “assisted living” areas. Residents from each of these parts were hand-selected by the social worker in order to create a mixed group of residents who, under regular circumstances, might never have any contact with each other. This is another example of how both context (which part of the building they resided in) and the use of unlikely sources (the social worker who knew the residents personally and could capitalize on that relationship to coax people into trying something unfamiliar) come into play when trying new approaches. The psychological goal of the group was to improve the individuals’ selfesteem through reminiscence exercises and oral/written re-examination of important life events, relationships and experiences and their meaning to the individual. The social goals of the group were to break down stereotypes based on living status (independent vs. assisted), race, age and background and facilitate a unique connection and ongoing relationship among group participants that would spill over into areas outside the group setting. Results indicated that success for both individuals and the group as a whole can be achieved, although success may be defined differently by different group members or facilitators. So, once again, we see that, what may seem obvious to one person, is not at all the understanding of another. For example, many people felt they had not lived a particularly “important” life. However, when seen through the eyes of the others in the group, a resident was seen as an effective special education teacher or as someone who had raised productive, gifted children. These elders were seen as valuable and worthwhile people, and this developed a sense of pride in those who had felt that their past achievements were minimal. Admiration from others reminded the participants that “life success” could be achieved in varied, but equally meaningful, ways. Other research (McDougall et al., 1997), using a content-analysis method to understand the process of change over the course of reminiscence sessions, utilized a framework of empowerment/disempowerment themes. Disempowerment themes included anxiety, denial, despair, helplessness, loss, and loneliness. Themes of empowerment included hope, coping, efficacy, trust, and connection. Reminiscence, then, can be one way in which elders living in any circumstance can reclaim some of their self-esteem and dignity
Reimagining Senior Empowerment
63
and also forge new relationships, which can contribute to a current sense of worth, all of which increase a sense of empowerment and control over their lives. The greatest and most unexpected success, because it was not an obvious outcome, was the forging of such close relationships with others in their building that they had not even known before the group. Common historical experiences, like living through the Great Depression and World War II, and common social experiences, like seeing the same first movies and sharing the same music, and common current interests, like writing and dancing, formed the basis for unique friendships that transcended the group and became the foundation for conversations and connections outside the group setting. Networking among other friends spread the sense of community throughout a building where there had previously been a prevailing sense of disconnection and alienation. For example, residents who might never have sat with “strangers” at another table in the dining room now had friends among those “strangers,” and eating with them allowed them to meet other residents as well. This experience empowered residents to see their own lives in a more positive light, as well as established rewarding social relationships that improved the quality of their daily lives. This is another example of how support can come from unlikely sources and facilitate empowerment as both a personal process and a social one. Other research has shown that a holistic approach to health prevention and promotion—both physical and mental—can be very effective in maintaining the independence of frail elders (Lamm et al., 1991; see also Abbey et al., 1994). In one study, they found that a lifestyle-management project that provided counseling, social support and education to chronically ill older adults facilitated development of self-care abilities and self-esteem, while reducing the adults’ reliance on traditional health-care services. The Nursing Department of Lourdes College in the state of Ohio also developed a similar student clinic approach to providing wellness services to senior housing units, which they called Neighborhood Wellness Centers (NWCs) (Abbey et al., 1994). They experienced some of the same obstacles, including reluctance to share functional limitations due to the fear that this information would jeopardize their ability to stay in “independent” housing. They also experienced the complexity of dealing with multicultural populations both in terms of meeting the diverse needs of different groups, but also in terms of the having residents come together with neighbors different from themselves to join in a common activity. Another finding was that good collaboration with facility managers and resident leaders was invaluable in dealing with and overcoming these challenges. A similar collaborative program approach has been used by the Visiting Nurse Association (VNA) of Washington, D.C., which provides home visits to residents of senior citizen buildings, geriatric day care center clients and low-income seniors in housing developments (Van Croft, 1994). This pro-
64
Empowering Frail Elderly People
gram has incorporated student nurses into their service provision, as well as developed positive collaborative relationships with building managers and residents. CONCLUSIONS A few years ago, having spent a week in Minneapolis with an intergenerational group of people working to design policy and research recommendations for both the White House Conference on Aging and the United Nations’ Year of the Family, it became obvious that there was a pressing need for intergenerational, international and interagency perspectives on many social problems facing nations with aging populations. If we continue to segment our larger society and ourselves by age, using age-based policies to provide services, we will be ignoring the fundamental social truth that we are all interdependent. This is one of the definitions of empowerment that Clark discusses. As societies strive to meet the needs of all citizens, this may be the most important definition or “aspect” of empowerment. This is even more important now, not just locally but globally, where we need to understand that we can all contribute to our communities no matter what our age and we can all benefit from what others may provide at different points in the life cycle. This interpretation of empowerment is one of the most important, I believe, if we are to move toward a self-actualized society. It is people on residential blocks and in neighborhoods, villages and towns who can come together to solve the problems we face as individual nations and as a global village. As Kaiser (1993) concludes, It moves the discussion to one of societal adjustments that ensure the retention of usefulness through the provision of flexibility and choice in how older persons adapt to aging, while addressing their real economic needs. This approach means that appropriate policies and programs must be developed and maintained to support positive social and economic roles for older men and women in developing and developed countries, while ensuring appropriate levels of care for those in need. Ultimately, it means an investment in policies and programs that support human resource development throughout the lifetime of all individuals, including older people. (p. 69)
5
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment in the Transition from a Family to a Community-Oriented Support System: Japan in the 21st Century Tokie Anme
INTRODUCTION Empowerment is one of the most important terms for Japanese society these days, as Japan is facing a turning point in changing societal values from a group orientation to an individual orientation. Historically, Japanese society has been based on Confucianism, similar to other northeast Asian countries. According to the historical concept of mura (a village-based society), all community members help each other meet all needs, with extraordinary pressure from both regional and national levels. Thus, it has been very natural for the Japanese to develop a community-oriented care system for older persons. But this community was not a real one, because complete mutual interdependence was never really developed in these so-called communities. This concept of mura, then, declined after World War II. Since then, the younger generation of Japanese adults has been moving to big cities while rural areas have remained a relatively stable, but closed segment of Japanese society, with a high proportion of elders and delayed social development. It is not too much to say that empowerment for both the individual and the community is crucial to maintaining a sense of social solidarity in this fragile situation. The aim of this chapter is to examine the nature of empowerment within the context of the dynamics of a society changing from a family-based care system to a community-based system. In a larger context as well, we see that while social values are changing, Japan is also dealing with the aging of its population overall, which intensifies the importance of these value changes. The chapter is organized around five sections:
66
Empowering Frail Elderly People
1. social changes occurring in Japan; 2. trends in community support systems; 3. changes in the national support systems; 4. presentation of a new model for community empowerment in Japan; and 5. development of professional staff and skills needed to facilitate the empowerment of frail elderly persons.
SOCIAL CHANGES IN JAPANESE SOCIETY The Japanese population is aging faster than that in other countries, and Japanese enjoy the longest life span in the world. In 1997, the average life expectancy for females was 83.8 years and for males, 77.2 years. Almost 16% of the population were 65 years of age or over (Ministry of Health and Welfare, 1998). Recent changes in household structure—particularly the increase in households with old-aged single persons or couples, together with the increase in younger adult female workers—have made it difficult for the family to take care of the elderly, as has been the cultural tradition. Income guarantees in the form of pensions are becoming a substantial burden on Japanese society and the needs for health and social services have increased dramatically, but the resources are limited. So the useful utilization of such services is strongly desired and there is much research being conducted to find different ways to use the limited resources effectively. The government is serious about coming to grips with this problem, exemplified by, for example, the establishment of long-term care insurance. These problems are placing tremendous pressure on Japan’s traditional and culturally preferred family care system. The obvious way to ease these growing pressures is to introduce more formal, community-based services, which can be provided at home to the older person and thereby supplement family members’ limited resources to make the life of the elder as comfortable as possible. But this must be done with very special sensitivity to the individual and with the dignity and empowerment of the older person in mind. There is a dramatic separation between the large urbanized areas, where economic pressures and changing social values have meant a rapid decline in family-based care for elderly people, and the rural villages, which remain almost a separate, cloistered segment of society, but with a high number of dependent elders who need care and support. Furthermore, changing social values of care for the elderly disabled have been so rapid that it has evoked confusion and insecurity among contemporary elders in Japan. Historically, family members had provided Japanese elders’ care. Because of the loosening of family ties, many nuclear families are unwilling to care for their older parents. And tremendous urbanization
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment
67
has made it difficult for nuclear families to live with their parents in their small houses. It has made it very difficult for them to take care of their parents. This phenomenon has gathered steam and cannot be reversed, only faced openly. So, in Japan, at the moment, we do not face the impediment of governmental obstruction of social goals. TRENDS IN COMMUNITY CARE Because of these changes, several local communities have tried to establish community-based support systems for elderly and disabled people. For example, in a suburb of Tokyo, special nursing homes have established a network system combining consultation, home nursing, day care, rehabilitation and education, and the like. Clients have a chance to visit each institution and can use every service according to their care requirements and plan, which are managed by professionals. This model still has several problems to be sorted out before it can be instituted throughout the country. First, there is the budget problem; second is the shortage of staff; and third is the unwillingness of the community residents to have such facilities located in their neighborhoods. It is very hard to solve the budget and staff shortage problems at this point, so it is vitally important to encourage people in the community to promote the system. Our goal is to get citizens to become committed to such a plan, based not necessarily on expanding the services but on effective utilization of the available resources. However, the community residents themselves need to be empowered if they want real community-based care. Because of the cost, local government supports most of the community-oriented services. One of the features of the health and social support system in Japan is its dependence on the public sector, while private sector or individual volunteer components are still underdeveloped. If the clients are viewed and accepted as consumers, private companies will be seriously motivated to enter the support system market. Also, if community residents are empowered to voice their needs, many nonprofit support systems will emerge in response to residents’ demands. But now, even private companies depend on public money because the consumer field is underdeveloped and the majority of older people think those social services should be free. On the other hand, the younger generation has serious worries about the increasing burden of care for elderly people. Before serious budget and staffing crises emerge, real community-based care systems must be established, and this will have to be done by the residents themselves, not the government. In 1993, the national government decided that all local communities should have their own plan or strategy for dealing with their aging population. The specific goals were given in great detail, including the number of institutes and staff in health and social services, transportation, local environ-
68
Empowering Frail Elderly People
ment factors such as barrier-free buildings and even the type of education people in the community should have. According to the instructions, all 3,300 cities and 49 prefectures (states) were to devise their own plan to realize these goals. The amount of required services was tremendous and the national government could not afford to bear those costs, so new revenue sources had to be secured. This was the “system of public long-term care insurance,” to which Japanese citizens contributed. One of the few exceptions to this model were “consumer institutes” (called “co-ops”), which developed their own system of care. They empowered their members to provide health and social services for other members in the community. This “mutual self-help system” has become one potential model of service delivery, not only for health and social services, but also for crisis services and natural disaster management (e.g., earthquakes). The most important role of such community-oriented and community-based support is to empower people for the promotion and maximization of independence through interdependent self-care. THE NATIONAL SUPPORT SYSTEM The health and social support systems in Japan have been going through major reforms for the last ten years. The pattern of the reform reveals a dramatic change from the early-anticipated trajectory. The original underlying issue was always the aging of the Japanese society and the urge to find a “Japanese” solution for it. That problem had been evolving since the end of the 1970s. Initially, it was considered merely as a future possibility, highlighted by the maturing of the economy and the decline in the rate of economic growth. But, in the 1990s, it has become a widely recognized, urgent social problem, which reflects not only the demographic realities of contemporary Japan, but also a dramatic transformation of Japanese social and family structures. In order to make our aging society more vibrant, and ensure that people are healthy, secure and have something to live for, the national government established two plans in the field of health and social support services—the New Golden Plan and public long-term care insurance. New Golden Plan The first plan established by the national government is the “New Golden Plan,” which is a ten-year strategy to promote health care and social services for elderly people. It sets forth specific goals to be achieved in the decade between 1994 and 2003. It evolved from the “Golden Plan” that was established in 1990 and now is being energetically promoted. The main goals of the Plan are as follows:
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment
69
1. Urgently prepare welfare measures for elderly people living at home a) increase the number of home helpers (those who visit and care for elderly people) b) increase the number of short stays for nursing care c) increase the volume of day care services d) establish care support centers for elderly people staying at home e) promote “projects to develop welfare communities for comfortable living” 2. Drastically reduce the number of elderly people who are bedridden a) improve physical training b) secure places for functional training (e.g., municipal health centers) c) provide lift-equipped buses to transport frail elderly persons to and from physical training centers d) develop cerebral apoplexy information centers e) improve health care education to prevent cerebral apoplexy, bone fractures, and so on 3. Develop a longevity social welfare fund to improve the human services for elderly people living at home 4. Urgently provide new facilities (and budget for such provision) a) provide special nursing homes for frail elderly persons b) provide health service facilities for frail persons c) provide homes for older persons at a modest charge (care houses) d) provide multipurpose senior citizen centers in less densely populated areas 5. Promote measures of “fruitful” lives among elderly persons a) establish organizations to develop comfortable old-age communities b) support “model projects” to promote the health and worthiness of older persons 6. Promote studies on the science of aging a) develop national hospital facilities as part of the aging science medical system b) secure enough resources to promote comprehensive research 7. Prepare comprehensive human service institutions for older people a) promote the idea of “my home town 21”—a program of developing communities that would enable all residents to lead long and happy lives by using an empowerment approach.
All these strategies are designed to meet the overarching goal of providing the most appropriate social and health services for aging Japanese citizens. Public Long-term Care Insurance The second major plan promoted by the national government is a plan for the public financing of long-term care insurance. The Japanese people have decided that they are willing to pay an increased service cost in order to provide social insurance for older persons. The revenues from this plan have provided support for many model projects. The original impetus for the development of such projects came from the increase in needs of elderly
70
Empowering Frail Elderly People
persons with disabilities who needed more help with activities of daily living and, therefore, needed new and more effective ways to be assessed. However, the outcome has been a move toward empowerment of all community members to whatever degree they need assistance.
A NEW MODEL FOR COMMUNITY EMPOWERMENT Empowering a community requires a step-by-step process based on empirical evidence. Fundamental components that are important to community empowerment are: (A) people-oriented services; (B) empirically based ideas; (C) system flexibility; (D) system consistency; and (E) mutual cooperation. A. People-oriented service means participation of all community members. This implies not only their physical attendance, but also their participation in choosing services and obtaining information. Having some role in the development of services motivates elders to achieve the project goals and, if they feel the project is their own, this will accelerate achievement. This process will facilitate the empowerment of community members. B. Empirical evidence makes it easier for people to accept the prediction of benefits of the project. Comprehensive scientific data, analyzed by well-established methods, confirm for people the merits and limitations of the project. Evidence-based results will give people security and confidence in the programs and, therefore, encourage continued investment in the project. C. System flexibility cultivates greater support in the community for the projects, as it allows for better responses to individual needs. Flexibility includes adaptability to various subjects, methods and timing. Effective utilization of services depends on system flexibility, because people are more likely to use such a system. Flexibility prevents such stagnation and may promote ongoing interest in continued project development. D. System consistency promotes teamwork in the community by requiring collaboration between providers. And working toward common goals through mutual support expands the empowerment of people in the community, because it requires their participation to realize their goals. For example, consistent evaluation makes clear the distinction of various goals and the ways to reach them in a consistent manner. Realistic prospects for project outcomes, based on evaluation research, provide guidelines for people as to what to choose and what not to choose. E. Mutual cooperation directly contributes to empowerment and increases public responsibility for the project. Mutual cooperation toward common goals requires good interpersonal communication, which will also contribute to empowerment within the community. Community discussion is one of the important methods for enhancing empowerment. It promotes the notion of empowerment as a social process, according to Clark (1989; see Chapter 1).
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment
71
Incorporating these concepts, a comprehensive longitudinal study to develop and evaluate the “new model for community empowerment” started in 1991 and has continued every year since. The purpose of the project discussed in this chapter was to develop methods for motivating people in a community to become empowered. One of the typical farming communities near a major urban center was selected. The participants were all the residents of the community 20 years of age or older—a total of 952 persons. First, however, we needed to develop an “empowerment culture” for both individuals and the community to promote mutual help. What is an “empowerment culture?” It is a social and value context for developing empowerment. How do you use this culture effectively? Culture can sometimes be a big impediment to overcome, but culture can also be used as a strong means to influence people. To alter the existing but unsatisfactory situation, we needed to change its culture. As a result, more of the participants had the attitude of “Let’s see how it goes.” Empowerment culture helped to promote the goals of self-care and mutual care in the community. The steps in the process of developing such an empowerment culture were as follows. 1. Create a Project Team Societal values regarding elders in a society range across four stages as delineated by Moody (1976, see Chapter 1), namely Rejection, Social Services, Participation and Self-Actualization. Our goal was to develop an empowerment culture that would begin by promoting participation by people and finally, come to realize self-actualization. To start the process, a project team was established that included community authorities such as the chief of the Residents’ Association, health professionals in the community and academic authorities. It was important for all members to embrace the goals of the project team and to feel a strong investment in future community development. 2. Utilize a Scientific Approach to Evaluation The development of individual and community empowerment draws strength from a foundation built on reliable scientific data. Reliable information about empowerment activities makes it easy for people to accept the program. Using statistical methods, a variety of factors were analyzed to predict future physical decline and mortality. One of the factors examined was social interaction, which was measured by the Index of Social Interaction (ISI). The ISI measures the amount and quality of interaction between the individual and the community. Other factors examined were health and lifestyle, individuals’ feelings about themselves and their social activities. The Index of Social Interaction is divided into five subscales: Independence (active approach, lifestyle motivation, health motivation for regular lifestyle);
72
Empowering Frail Elderly People
Figure 5.1 Score of Social Interaction (1992) and Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (1994).
Social Curiosity (use of electronic equipment, having a hobby, reading books and/or newspapers, feelings of importance); Interaction (communication with outsiders, interaction with outsiders, communication within the family); Participation in Society (participation in social groups, participation in neighborhood affairs, watching television, having an active social role); and Feelings of Safety (having someone to give advice, having someone to give support in an emergency). Lack of social integration was found to be significantly correlated with physical deterioration (see Figure 5.1) and later mortality (five years later) (see Figure 5.2). Cohort analysis revealed that interaction with the community decreased with age. In addition to the simple age factor, the nature of social interaction was changing in general because of the broader social changes discussed earlier (Anme, 1997a). We see this in the findings that one’s sense of importance in the society or in the family also decreased with age. Those changes also seemed to cause physical deterioration. For example, persons who reported that they were “losing their social role” deteriorated earlier than persons who reported still having meaningful roles in the community. Negative attitudes toward aging, such as “Everything becomes more difficult as you get older,” increased with age, and this feeling induced isolation from society. Positive self-reliance factors were also strongly related to the physical deterioration and mortality, such as the feeling about themselves still having social roles and the feeling about keeping good relationships going with family members. As a tool, the Index of Social Interaction was found to be useful for
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment
73
Figure 5.2 Social Interaction and Mortality within Five Years
predicting the future status of elders and thus can be used to develop strategies for early intervention. Compared to scales measuring Activities of Daily Living (ADLs), the predictive validity of the ISI is almost equivalent. Using effective predictive scales would strengthen an individual’s and a community’s sense of empowerment. Understanding both the present situation and the possible future will motivate individuals to take an active part in shaping that future. 3. Establish an Empowerment Center After a needs assessment and system development process of three years, the Empowerment Center was constructed as the core of the project. The purpose of this Center was to promote empowerment of people, not just at the participation level of social values, but also at the self-actualization level. Figure 5.3 shows the functions of the Center. First is the Zone of Health Check-Up, which promotes strong health as the basis for empowerment. Second is the Zone of Promotion for Self-Actualizing Activity, which contains a swimming pool, gymnasium, library and place for hobbies. Third is the Zone of Promotion for Mutual Support Activity, which includes several programs such as a volunteer center for facilitating mutual support in the community. Fourth is the Zone of Care Management, which utilizes a targeted systems approach by various professionals and others in cases where individuals need more comprehensive care and support.
74
Empowering Frail Elderly People
Figure 5.3 Functions of Empowerment Center
Because the Center was located near people’s homes, the residents easily noticed the effects on individuals and the sense of empowerment that was emerging from the Center. This provided strong incentives for the people to utilize the opportunities effectively. 4. Develop New Information Management Systems After setting up the Empowerment Center, systems to manage the function of the Center should be developed to continue the process of empowerment. Key components of such development were information systems, a self-evaluation scale for future well-being, and self-training programs to keep well-being for each person as well as promoting mutual support. Information Systems Information is the lubricating oil for the total system, supplying the necessary means to keep the system fluid and working. Effective usage of information can be a proactive system component in empowering community members. For community situations, it is good to set up one core center and then establish several branches for information services. People can conveniently get information and consultation for any need they have simply by calling the Empowerment Center. An effective information system should also have the flexibility to distribute and diffuse any informational content as soon as possible. Precision and keeping information up-todate are important to maintaining the reliability and validity of the system.
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment
75
Self-evaluation Scale for Future Well-being From the data analysis, a self-evaluation scale for future well-being was developed. In this scale, points were assigned to each related item, such as healthy behavior and social interaction, which reflect the magnitude of risk for physical deterioration and mortality. Adding up the points of all items, people get their own total score, which indicates the expected level of future well-being. If the total score is lower than the standard, people realize that their lifestyle had better change to improve their future well-being. This instrument is useful in reviewing activities of everyday life and gives people meaningful information related to their ongoing lifestyle choices. Improved empowerment can thereby successfully utilize an analysis of factors associated with future well-being. Self-training Programs to Maintain Well-being for Each Person Individual action plans, including a self-training program to keep well, were designed, based on longitudinal data collected from the community. Seventy-two patterns of action plans were developed and then each person was given the most appropriate plan, according to his lifestyle. Each action plan had three parts: first was the self-training program at home; second was a training program including activities such as swimming at the Empowerment Center; and third was the anticipated direction and effects of their healthy lifestyle. This individualized prescription for future well-being induced motivation and produced healthier behavior among the people in the community. Promoting Mutual Support Independent individuals may be able to establish a real mutual support system, but it is much more challenging for a dependent culture such as one based on the historical mura or village concept. These social ties have been gradually disintegrating over time, especially in big cities, where most people have lost the old type of community spirit. In the past, familyoriented care was the only choice for many people. Yet clear limitations of contemporary family care opened new fields in social support—for example, co-ops and public long-term care insurance. Furthermore at this point a mutual support system is strongly desired not only by the government, but also by the people themselves (Anme, 1993). To promote this mutual support system, new methods were developed, such as education of volunteer leaders, dissemination of information to volunteers and the establishment of places to exchange information. Self-checking and Self-development Programs The function of self-checking and self-development programs is to provide the foundation for efficient administration maintenance and to refresh
76
Empowering Frail Elderly People
Figure 5.4 How to Develop an Empowerment Model in the Community
the system when needed. All programs should have feedback and assessment routines for further refinement and development. We have developed software that will allow us to evaluate services and we plan to do so every three years. These procedures are essential to guarantee the system’s reliability and validity. In conclusion, to develop an empowerment model in the community, the effective utilization of a supportive culture is indispensable (see Figure 5.4). Communication, motivation and science are important elements in forging such a supportive culture. Communication must come with acceptance and understanding. Motivation must be achieved through participation and an attitude of do-it-ourselves. Science can capitalize on the respect for logical analysis and clear expectations that make it easier to understand the factors involved in empowering people in the community. QUALITY OF STAFFING To realize empowerment we need high-quality staffing in the provision of health and social services. In order to secure staff for successful empowerment of people, we have developed an evaluation method for professional caregivers. We found that professionals in the health–social service area need three phases of support (Anme, 1998). The first is person-to-person support, the second is teamwork support and the third is system support. Person-to-person support means that the relationship between professional and client is one direct line. Teamwork support means that the relationship between a professional team and their client is more complex and that complexity must be acknowledged and paid attention to. System support refers to a community-based system, the community including the professional team itself that is ready to provide better support for its clients. Our goal for a community-oriented system is predicated on this. So, appropriate evaluation methods are needed to measure the effectiveness of the support. To establish effective community-oriented empowerment, three points are
Retaining and Expanding Empowerment
77
crucial: (1) evaluation methods for health-social services, (2) an education system to produce a higher quality of professional staff, and (3) an influential person to motivate the people in the community to promote a better system for the future. Evaluation methods for assessing professional skills and knowledge are the fundamental basis for practice and education. And the basic concept of professional skills and knowledge must be common for professionals all over the world in this time of international cooperation. We have developed a conceptual framework as well as practical methods to assess professional skills and knowledge of health-social professions and their provision of programs (Anme, 1997b). Over 1,100 professionals in the health and social services fields (including social workers, institutional care workers, nurses, physiological therapists, occupational therapists and other health care professionals) were asked to complete an Index of Professional Skills and Knowledge questionnaire. A model of this Index was constructed by using three categories—self-care, mutual care and professional care (see Table 5.1). This model of evaluation is divided into five processes: (a) finding the problem, (b) assessment, (c) intervention, (d) evaluation, and (e) feedback. Each subscale focuses on specific professional skills and knowledge, covering all health and social service professions. The basic criteria of this Index are as follows: (1) the availability for support, meaning that older persons are able to get the information available for practical support; (2) the opportunity to integrate information, which means that data from various areas are integrated into a care plan; and (3) prediction, which means that one can predict how to improve the situation from the present to the future. As the result of our investigation, almost all professionals agreed on the framework and the items in this index (Anme, 1997b; see Table 5.2). Very few differences existed between the mean responses of several kinds of professionals. In other words, this Index should be useful for all kinds of health and social service professionals in helping them to facilitate coordination with other professionals. It should also be effective at the educational stage to help shape the development of professionals in the health and social service fields. It is very important to share methods with other professionals in this field. CONCLUSION: ENHANCING EMPOWERMENT FOR ELDERLY PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY Working toward the utopia of a comfortable life for elderly people can be realized by evoking images of control, freedom, or power in people’s minds. In conclusion, five points have emerged that should enhance empowerment (1) prevention orientation, (2) effective evaluation, (3) investigation of
78
Empowering Frail Elderly People
Table 5.1 Professional Skills and Knowledge Index Chart
needs, (4) utilization of information technology and (5) promotion of participation. A prevention orientation means that empowerment is developed by focusing on the prevention of risks over one’s life span. Even for frail elderly, as well as healthy ones, prevention of decline in physical or mental function is essential to expanding their potential for becoming empowered. Effective evaluation means utilizing all facilities and resources to assess the available options and to maximize a person’s outcomes. Investigation of needs means providing formal and informal services with a clear understanding of their meaning and role in supporting the achievement of a desired level of personal independence in a flexible and accommodating way. Utilization of information technology is an issue of utmost importance for frail elderly people. Alienation from information is a key impediment to more enlightened and progressive forms of empowerment. Promotion of participation, with an eye on self-actualization, means espousing true empowerment for frail elderly persons as consumers, allowing them to understand and realize their abilities and desires to meet their needs related to independence. It also means allowing frail elderly people to control their care planning and acceptance of services to the limits of their ability, desire and needs.
Table 5.2 Index of Professional Skills and Knowledge for Health-Social Services
Table 5.2 (continued)
6
Empowerment in Post-Reform Community Care in England and Wales Bleddyn Davies
The British have been attempting a radical reform of long-term care. The first statement of the logic of the new policy was published in 1989 (Department of Health, 1989). All the legislation of that first phase came into effect in 1993. The administration introducing the reform was one of the most determined in postwar British history. It used the great power of the central government, in a unitary state with a belief in the legitimacy and quality of government, in new ways, which secured greater and faster change in the reality of community care than ever before. That forceful Conservative administration was succeeded by an equally determined Labour administration that was committed to giving the reforms new impetus. The essential elements of the Conservative statements of ends and means were maintained, though with more attention to equity generally. Labour rebalanced and refined the definitions of means and ends by taking into account the lessons learned from the monitoring of policy impact, and by developing new instruments to achieve the implementation of national policy (Department of Health, 1998). The policy statements and the guidance about how to implement the reforms were seen by its authors as highly principled and value-based (Utting, 1996). The promotion of empowerment and independence were key themes. People were to be enabled to lead as normal a life as possible. They were to be helped to achieve the maximum possible independence and their full potential. They were to have a greater individual say in how they lived their lives (Department of Health, 1989). All four interpretations of empowerment outlined in Chapter 1 have been the focus of detailed guidance,
82
Empowering Frail Elderly People
and of standards used for the central evaluation of local performance through monitoring and inspection. National policy in the United Kingdom is certainly in transition from a mere “social services” model to a “participation” model, in Moody’s terminology (Moody, 1976). So are most of the field agencies, particularly the local social services authorities that are responsible for the policy performance in their areas. Indeed, we shall suggest below that there are respects in which, for most users in many areas, a transition is being made toward a “selfactualization” model, though less in the forms adopted than in the style of specific activities conducted within the forms. The British national government worked the themes of empowerment and independence through at the level of policy logic. The exercise of pressure on field agencies to implement that logic has had an intensity that has been rare—arguably unequaled—in any other country taken as a whole. Perhaps it is for that reason that some of the policy statements and guidance about how to implement them have almost the status of sacred texts in certain other countries. b But the key concept in British policy statements is not “empowerment” but “independence.” Independence is not just the empowerment rose by another name. Partly, it reflects the distinction between an end (independence) and one of the means (empowerment) to that end. And independence has yet other significant meanings. Among its overtones are what some see as the redefinition of the rights and responsibilities of the individual, the primary social units like the family, and the State. The Griffiths Report of 1988 and the Conservative White Paper of 1989 (Griffiths, 1988; Department of Health, 1989) implied rather than stated these rights and responsibilities, defining the responsibilities of the State rather than of others. That, too, was the approach in the Labour white paper of 1998. It describes the social services as “for all of us,” and “an important part of the fabric of a caring society,” with everyone benefiting from “good, effective services for those who need them.” However, its approach is a policy that “spells out exactly what people can expect” (Department of Health, 1998). In contrast, the Minority Report of the Royal Commission on Long-Term Care, one of whose authors (David Lipsey) has been one of the most influential intellectuals of the Labour Party’s middle way, stated the implication of the Labour position with an explicitness and clarity verging on the ferocious (Royal Commission on Long Term Care, 1999). For instance, it argues that elderly persons have responsibilities as well as rights. And, to a degree understated in assertions to the Royal Commission on Long Term Care based on less structured evidence, this emphasis on independence is reflected in the way local managers interpreted the priorities that their authorities had to actually put into effect. This emphasis existed at all levels of management, from the directorate at headquarters to the managers of small facilities and field sections. A series of interviews of 133 managers, as part of the evaluation of the reforms described below, showed
Post-Reform Community Care
83
a high degree of consensus between authorities and levels of management about the effect most desired: providing “a real chance for more users to stay at home rather than enter a care home.” “Empowerment, choice and control over their own lives” and “support for family carers to enable them to have respite” were ranked next (Davies, 1997). But what matters is who benefits in what way and at what costs to whom. Harding (1999) rightly argued to the Royal Commission on Long Term Care that the research and monitoring of the reform impacts have been excessively focused on activities, service change, quantities of services, and impressions of participants. Her review well illustrates the point by alluding exclusively to such evidence, whether pre- or postreform. Judging from what the Royal Commission collated, the British evidence is primarily of ungaugeable representativeness; is small-scale, impressionistic, and narrow in its perspective; and is focused on input factors and processes rather than outcomes. Such imbalance in the methodological basis seriously risks distorting the message. We badly need to correct the balance with larger and more reliable evidence about who benefits in what way and at what costs to whom, and about how and why policies and process influence these outcomes. This chapter has three objectives: 1. to explore who are empowered and to what degree, examining three indicators of the concept; 2. to explore the implications for other benefits of community care of making the maximization of empowerment of users the central aim of community care, given existing relationships between service inputs and outcomes; and 3. to explore the implications for the levels of empowerment of users and caregivers by maximizing other benefits.
First, the source of evidence and methods of analysis are briefly described, because such explanation is essential if the reader is to understand what follows. DATABASE The evidence analyzed here is from a major project, funded by the Department of Health, titled Evaluating Community Care of Elderly People (ECCEP). ECCEP is the second stage of a before–after evaluation of changes in equity and efficiency in community care during the reform period. Two sets of interviews were conducted six months apart during 1985 and 1986, with triads consisting of the three persons who most influence the patterns of community services during the crucial early setup (SUP) stage of care-managed community care. Each triad had one of 419 frail elderly users themselves, their principal informal caregiver, and the worker responsible for performing the most important care-management tasks for
84
Empowering Frail Elderly People
them. First, the study looked in at baseline need-related risk factors such as perceptions, values and desires, as well as behavior- and decision-influencing factors such as perceived benefits, costs, and other outcomes at the setup stage. Six months later, during the phase of continuing care (COCA), we also monitored changes in utilization, location, and broad need-related circumstances until death. The study also looked at service-input factors and the roles of field personnel in their agency and others. It then examined the policies and structures of the social services department and other agencies. For instance, there were interviews with social service managers at all levels and with a wide range of functions. We measured the relative priority that 133 of them thought had been given during the early stages of the reform by their authorities to the policy’s ends and means. There were also interviews with managers of related agencies, and collections of agency documentation covering a period commencing in the early 1980s, when the first stage of the before–after study commenced. So, priority was given to the range and richness of the information rather than to sample size. METHODS OF ANALYSIS As the best database for the detailed description of postreform community care likely to be available for some years, there are extensive quantitative descriptions of the large number of individual variables. These vary from 24-page accounts to a book (ECCEP team, 1998). A wide variety of themes are being explored in more depth, using modeling and other forms of analysis—particularly care management themes and the evaluation of utilization patterns. The stream of analysis on which this chapter depends uses production function analysis, as adapted for the Production of Welfare Approach (Davies, 1995). By the term production function, we mean the statistical relationship between quantities of service inputs and final outputs; that is, outcomes of value in their own right. For example, desired final outputs might be the degree to which users feel that they control their own lives, the reduction of the felt caregiving burden among caregivers, or an increase in the number of days spent in the community. Thus, these final outputs are the dependent variables of production functions. The independent variables in such analyses include service inputs (e.g., money spent on services) and risk factors (e.g., level of cognitive impairment). Marginal productivities measure the increase in an output indicator that is associated with a unit increase in service input. Productivity curves describe the relationships between service inputs and final outputs for users in general or for subgroups of users distinguished by one or a combination of risk factors or other circumstances. The details of the techniques for using Production of Welfare
Post-Reform Community Care
85
Analysis have been described elsewhere (Davies, 1985, 1995; Davies and Challis, 1986; Davies & Fernandez, in press). Seventeen final outputs were analyzed. In addition to empowerment, choice and control, they cover six domains: • length of stay in the community • satisfaction with service • perceived improvement in functioning in service-related areas and reported unmet needs for help • general psychological well-being • reduction in social exclusion and improvement in relationships • care managers’ retrospective perceptions of the degree of beneficial impact.
Between them, the output indicators measure benefits for principal informal caregivers, as well as frail elderly users themselves. EMPOWERMENT, CHOICE AND CONTROL Three indicators were used to measure empowerment. One indicator, (IMPEMP, a measure of the degree of empowerment felt by users) was a score based on items indicating the degree to which users feel that they control their own lives. This is a score based on items from the Philadelphia Geriatric Center Morale Scale (Lawton, 1975). (Factor analyses for American populations have shown that a subscale based on the items used here is a psychometrically adequate indicator of the locus of control dimension of morale.) A second indicator, (UEMPOW, user empowerment during setup of services), measured the degree to which users felt that they had an influence, were given choice, and were treated in a way that addressed their problems in the care management process during the setup stage. The third indicator (CEMPOW, level of caregiver empowerment) assessed the degree to which the principal informal caregiver felt that she had influence or was empowered during the setup stage of the case management process. Items included whether the care manager involved the caregiver in separate discussions about the user, discussions about her problems of caregiving, discussions about her needs in her own right; and the degree of satisfaction of the caregiver with the extent to which her own needs had been taken into account. The productivity curve represented the overall effect of service inputs on the outcome or output in question. The full structural model consisted of a set of simultaneous equations that showed all the productivity effects, whether direct or indirect.
86
Empowering Frail Elderly People
RESULTS OF ANALYSES Low morale and high degrees of physical disability at baseline both depressed, to a great degree, the effects of services on subsequent felt control over life (IMPEMP). Results suggest that home care, home-delivered meals and respite care had the highest impact on the most dependent—those in “critical interval need” (see Figure 6.1). [Interval need is a crude measure of the frequency and predictability of the need for help developed by British geriatricians for use in epidemiological studies (Isaacs and Neville, 1975). The circumstances of “long interval users” suggest that help is required less frequently than daily. “Short interval” cases require help at least daily, but at predictable times. “Critical interval need” means requiring help several times daily at unpredictable intervals.] Community nursing inputs, on the other hand, had greater effects among cognitively impaired people targeted for day care, the effect being greater as their day care allocation increased. Several effects showed that inputs had diminishing returns: the improvement in empowerment (IMPEMP) associated with an additional unit of a service or resource was greater at lower levels of outputs than at higher levels. Next, we analyzed how the risk factors impacted the effects of services on empowerment or control over life (see Figures 6.1 and 6.2). The service effects on control over life (IMPEMP) were highest for the most dependent [those with high levels of “interval need”; that is, problems with Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADLs)], particularly if they have principal informal caregivers (PICs). Most of the additional impact of the services for those with informal caregivers was due to additional day and respite care. There was a substantial effect for those requiring interventions at predictable intervals at least once a day—those in “short interval need”—largely because of the inputs of day care. Among users as a group, the degree to which the effects of the risk factors in the equation were offset by service impacts is a substantial 24%. We lack estimates for other systems, or for prereform community care in the United Kingdom. However, on the face of it, this suggests a substantial degree of success of the services in offsetting the decline in control or empowerment (IMPEMP), due to varying levels of need. Additionally, some 54% of all users benefited from one or more of the productivity effects. Informal care had a powerful buffering effect on the user’s sense of influence and control during the setup stage of care management (UEMPOW). The better the support structures and relationships, the greater the impact of service inputs on this measure of control. This suggests that when elderly people live with the principal informal caregiver and perceive themselves to have a confiding relationship with the caregiver, these factors are important, and so may be the perception that the caregiver herself is a beneficiary from the services, though the effect is less clearly established. Figure 6.3 (UEM-
Figure 6.1 Returns to Factor: Home Care and Day Care Effects on User Control over Life (IMPEMP)
Figure 6.2 Returns to Factor: Respite Care, Nursing and Meals Effects on User Control over Life (IMPEMP)
88
Figure 6.3 Contributions of Services and Need-Related Services to User Felt Control Score
89
90
Empowering Frail Elderly People
POW) shows the estimated productivity effects. They suggest productivity effects associated with higher dependency (at the higher IADL range or greater, or among those discharged from hospital at the beginning of the SUP phase to which UEMPOW relates), caregiver (PIC) stress, and homecare users living alone. Three of the productivity effects have sharply diminishing returns. These essentially amount to threshold effects—effects that shift a relationship from one form to another at some level of input. Other analyses (not shown) suggest that the service contributions may be substantial, but very similar across case types (e.g., those with long or short intervals of need, or those with or without a caregiver). Overall, the proportion by which the service effects offset risk factors (such as level of need) was estimated to be a substantial 14%. In addition, the proportion of users likely to be influenced was 74%, suggesting large and widespread service effects on an outcome of importance—felt control during the setup phase of care. A crucially related factor in understanding the felt sense of control by frail elderly people themselves is the experience of control and support that their caregivers have. The indirect effect of caregiver empowerment on the empowerment of the care recipient is one that has rarely been articulated, let alone analyzed in a broader context of service delivery and management. Thus, we analyzed the effects of services on the sense of influence felt by caregivers during the setting up of their community care. We found that empowerment of caregivers is adversely affected by user stress and coresidence with the user, particularly if the user judges that the relationship with the caregiver is marked by powerful affect. Perhaps the user feels that the caregiver might be “engulfed” by the caring role. Indeed, the important variables seem to have more to do with relationships and perceptions of dependency that must be worked through between caregiver and recipient. This may be the most important factor save, perhaps, for severe cognitive impairment. The productivity curves (not shown) for two home care groups (one with mild to severe cognitive impairment and the other with long interval care needs) were quite different. They suggest that home care has increasing productivities as the level of input is increased among the 50% of users predicted to be cognitively impaired. But we found diminishing returns for the 16% of users with only “long interval needs,” that is, needs for care less frequently than daily. On the other hand, there also appear to be diminishing returns for each of the two groups of recipients of day care for which any effects were found (those having suffered a stroke and those with employed caregivers). But the effects of respite care on caregiver empowerment for users with behavioral problems or user-caregiver relational problems do not seem to diminish with the level of the input. Other analyses showed that despite these apparently substantial produc-
Post-Reform Community Care
91
tivity effects, risk factors dominated. The overall proportion of risk factors offset by services is relatively low at only 9%, which is lower than for the other outputs. Perhaps unsurprising, in the context of the literature on the effects of correlates of cognitive impairment on caregiver burden, the degree of cognitive impairment better predicts the risk offset effects than the more general need interval (long or critical) classification. But though the service effects are weak compared with the risk factors, a high proportion (74%) of users are still affected by them. And the estimated productivity effects are not small in relation to the variation in caregiver empowerment, so that service variations do substantially influence how much power caregivers feel they have over setting up care. Thus, the results point to a conclusion that postreform community care does seem to improve the sense of users’ control over their own lives quite substantially, compared with what would be predicted in the absence of such reforms. It does give the users and caregivers (to a lesser degree in relation to what risk factors predict, but still to a degree that is statistically distinguishable), a sense of influence over the processes of assessment, care planning and care arranging. These results help to put some of the more depressed opinions about the effectiveness of community care into perspective. One such opinion is a conclusion by Harding (1999: 43) that, “older people . . . have not had a way of voicing their own priorities or discussing how best to meet them.” Another is a statement by Parker (1999: 53) that “care management, as implemented in the UK, cannot be for the carer; the focus must logically (and some would argue, morally) be on the user.” The latter statement has also to be qualified in light of the finding of the ECCEP study that in approximately one case in ten, care managers expected the principal informal caregiver to be the sole beneficiary of the care plan, the user gaining little (Davies, 1997). ISSUES RAISED BY MAKING EMPOWERMENT THE ULTIMATE GOAL That postreform community care clearly does, on average, substantially offset the feelings of loss of control predicted (and caused) by the worsening circumstances of elderly users is not evidence that the British system is producing the best balance of outcomes given existing levels of efficiency. Nor do these results indicate that attainable improvements in efficiency could do little to improve the levels of what are implicitly the system’s priority outcomes. Two questions are begged. One is whether empowerment itself is implicitly one of the highest priority goals of the system. The other is what would be the consequences for other desirable outcomes of making empowerment the key goal.
92
Empowering Frail Elderly People
The Relative Importance of the Empowerment Goal Clues to the answer to the first question are found by examining the proportion of cases that could be influenced by a service impact. It is true that real technological constraints on service productivities will affect these proportions, even when trying to reflect user priorities and values. For obvious reasons, care managers and care workers face real limits in trying to change the general sense of empowerment of an elderly person whose medical circumstances cause irremovable constraints. But it is also the case that how things are done can often have a major influence on the perceptions of these constraints. That is, the degree to which the way things are done can make community care services agents for Maslovian self-actualization, and so move both elderly persons and societies further along the Moody progression of social values discussed in Chapter 1. But, the proportion of risks offset by services also reflects the implicit priorities of the system. In an analysis of the proportion offsets for the initial 17 outputs, the “Risk Offset Proportion” for control over life (IMPEMP) is among the highest. So whatever output or combination of outputs it is that actors in the community care system are seeking to maximize, community care is actually producing a pattern that creates good empowerment outcomes compared with the levels achieved for most other outputs. However, these service impacts influence only a small majority, not the vast majority of recipients. Should We Make Empowerment the Overarching Goal? Not only empowerment, but also other outcomes are desirable in their own right. Given the absence of watertight empirical evidence about the preferences of persons before and after experiencing alternative outcomes, an analysis of the hypothetical effects of optimizing other outcomes than empowerment gives us insight into the potential costs of maximizing empowerment over other outcomes. Thus, the most relevant evidence for judging whether empowerment should be the overarching goal would be the pattern of outputs that would be produced if empowerment—rather than one of the other main outputs—were to be maximized. These other outputs can be conceptualized as somewhat analogous to collateral damage in war: an unavoidable consequence of attempting to hit a target. To simulate the effects of explicitly prioritizing empowerment requires that we study the effects of choosing empowerment rather than some other likely alternatives as the output to maximize. Maximization means creating a hypothetical world in which services are used to the best effect given their relative prices and productivities; that is, optimization. But assumptions have to be made about the constraints on the optimization. In this analysis, we contrast the actual patterns observed with predictions assuming that the
Post-Reform Community Care
93
pattern of inputs can easily be adjusted to maximize the output without having to pay higher prices for the services, or accepting services of lower quality: what we call “unconstrained” optimization. (For other optimization scenarios, see Davies and Fernandez, in press.) In Figure 6.4 the levels and mixes of “collateral outputs” given the most efficient balancing of resources to maximize empowerment (IMPEMP) are shown. Some explanation is needed. The figure consists of pairs of columns, each pair relating to one of the final outputs. • The first column of each pair describes the actual level of output produced currently. • The second column of the pair predicts what would be produced given the optimization of IMPEMP. That is, this column reflects the “collateral” level of outputs. • The height of the column shows the proportion of the output that would be achieved with a perfectly efficient combination of services to produce the outcome in question (e.g., days at home, caregiver burden, etc.). • The levels of actual current and collateral outputs are described for six case types, each of which has the characteristic of the average case of that type. The typology combines two characteristics. The first is whether a user has a “principal informal caregiver” (defined as someone whom the user claims to provide regular help with practical tasks of daily living). The second is “interval need.”
The results presented in Figure 6.4 suggest that to maximize frail elderly people’s feelings of empowerment over their own lives would: • actually cause a reduction in the number of additional days in the community produced for all case types but those with principal informal caregivers and critical interval need, leaving the level of the output low in relation to what could be achieved for some case types. That is so even though the current pattern reflects great variations in inefficiency, and this hypothetical optimization assumes the removal of inefficiency in combining service inputs. • reduce the level of user satisfaction with service (USATISF) for most case types, again leaving the level low for some case types. • leave the level of reduction of caregiver stress (KOSBERG) low, usually lower than currently. • for some other outputs (e.g., DLD—a life development score), create unsatisfactory patterns of collateral outputs. Felt sense of control (IMPEMP) is already, and would continue to be, high for users without principal informal caregivers. This result is not surprising.
These patterns would, on the face of it, seem to be unsatisfactory; all the more so because the estimates assume an unattainable level of efficiency in mixing service inputs given their prices and productivities. The question begged is whether seeking to maximize some other output would yield a
Figure 6.4 Collateral Output Levels for Optimization on IMPEMP with ‘Unconstrained’ Optimization
Post-Reform Community Care
95
more satisfactory pattern, including a satisfactory output for control (IMPEMP) but much better levels for other important indicators. We consider three candidates for alternative maximands: the number of days supported in the community (DAYS), user satisfaction with service (USATISF), and the reduction in caregivers’ felt burden of caregiving (KOSBERG). All three are implicitly of the highest priority in the value statements made in the official statements by the two administrations (Department of Health, 1989; 1998). Figure 6.5 shows the results for maximizing days at home (DAYS). Control (IMPEMP) would be improved or much the same as currently for most groups. By our criteria, the levels for users without principal informal caregivers would again be more satisfactory, although it would remain low for those with a PIC. User satisfaction (USATISF) would be substantial and/ or improved for all groups save long interval users with principal informal caregivers. But, once again, the reductions in caregiver burden would be low, and actually lower than currently—a serious weakness. Analyses with user satisfaction (USATISF) as the maximand were also performed. In such a case, DAYS would have a higher collateral output for most case types than if control (IMPEMP) were to be the maximand. But there are important exceptions, particularly for critical interval users with principal informal caregivers. IMPEMP would again tend to be higher for most users without principal caregivers than for others, for which it would tend to be lower than it is currently for critical interval users. One unsatisfactory feature of the patterns maximizing control, days at home, or user satisfaction would be the low level of reduction in caregivers’ felt burden. Would it be better to maximize the reduction in caregiver burden for the case types involved, and choose another maximand for the others? Such an analysis suggests that user sense of control (IMPEMP) would be little different from now. Days at home would be substantially, but not catastrophically, lower than currently for each case type. User satisfaction would be higher for all three groups. So the main cost of very large reductions in caregivers’ felt burden would be in an apparently much smaller proportional reductions in days. However, the caveat is that the reduction is only apparently much smaller because the indicator for reduction in felt burden is not likely to have the properties of a ratio scale. To assess the consequences of adopting different criteria for the case groups without principal caregivers, we need to prevent redistribution between types with and without principal caregivers. An optimization was undertaken that imposes the constraint that there is no redistribution of money spent on services across the six case types. Results suggest that optimizing days at home would yield much lower levels of control (IMPEMP) than with unconstrained optimization, though that level would be higher than currently for all except those with critical interval needs. Optimizing user satisfaction, control or empowerment would be substantially improved com-
Figure 6.5 Collateral Output Levels for Optimization on DAYS with ‘Unconstrained’ Optimization
Post-Reform Community Care
97
pared with current levels for two of the three groups, and much the same for the third. The collateral outputs for days at home in this case, would be better than with unconstrained optimization for long and critical interval cases, but still unsatisfactorily lower than is currently the state. Arguably, therefore, to combine the maximization of the reduction of caregiver stress where relevant with the maximization of user satisfaction for others might yield better outcome patterns than maximizing empowerment. CONCLUSIONS This chapter has shown that the United Kingdom is one of the more interesting cases of a nationally implemented plan for modernization of community care. It also happens to have been the subject of research that directly examines and evaluates equity and efficiency of factors that include indicators of empowerment. Therefore, it is interesting to consider what it teaches us about reform issues. The empirical results suggest that the pattern of outcomes produced by attempting to use the effects of services as they are now to maximize an indicator of empowerment does not yield a general output pattern that achieves some of the main aims of the reform. These main aims have been about independence, rather than empowerment per se, and an important element of independence was judged by the policy makers to give people the opportunity of spending a longer time in their own homes rather than living in conventional residential and nursing facilities. The policy makers also committed themselves to taking account of caregivers’ needs, increasingly doing so not just for those arising from caregiving itself, but from other associated sources of stress. Thus, the goals must not only yield satisfactory outputs for the extension of stays in the community and the reduction of caregiver stress, in particular, but also most of the other outcomes discussed above. So, what the results suggest is that it would be dangerous to overestimate the importance of any one goal, even empowerment. There is probably no single goal, and no simple combination of goals, which will yield an excellent pattern in all relevant respects. The dilemma of goal setting in policy making is that the choices so rarely seem to be between really satisfactory solutions. Of course, that is not an excuse for failing to search for solutions that better reconcile the aims. We are conscious that we are only starting a long journey of exploration and discovery, even in the application of the evidence that we have collected in this one project. However, it would be misleading to attach too much precision to the actual estimates presented here. The empirical argument is based on things as they are—on current productivities and efficiencies—based on current policies, structures and resources, assumptions and skills. Echoing Marx, the point is not to study the world, but to change it. And our estimates are no
98
Empowering Frail Elderly People
better than the validity and reliability of the indicators and the technical skills, imagination and judgment of the modelers. As a branch of science requiring the practice of what must become a cultivated form, the mapping of productivities and efficiencies in the production of welfare is at an early stage. And that world will always elude capture. “Ah, what a dusty answer gets the soul when hot for certainties in this life our life” (George Meredith, “Seed Time” 1923). But the results certainly provide new insights into how we might conceptualize and handle these important dilemmas of community care policy.
PART III
ENVIRONMENT AND EMPOWERMENT IN CONVENTIONAL HOUSING
7
Another Way of Living in One’s Own Home: The Salmon Group Projects Robin Currie, Marie-Jo Guisset, and Niek de Boer
INTRODUCTION This chapter examines the role of small housing units in the care of older dependent people as developed by different projects in Western Europe. It explores the ideas behind the concept of small housing units, examines the experiences of those involved in the developments and evaluates their contribution to the empowerment of older people and improvement of the quality of their lives. People managing all the projects found that in implementing their ideas they encountered impediments of different kinds arising from various sources. However, they also discovered that the common approach they shared to overcoming these impediments was an important and powerful advantage. The first part of the chapter discusses how in each of the countries concerned older people had expressed fear and hostility toward the idea of ending their days in a large institution. The response to these feelings was at the core of the concept of small units and the development of the individual projects. Arising out of the European Commission’s “Year of Older People and Solidarity Between Generations” in 1993, several projects from the countries formed an informal network, the Salmon Group. The next part of the chapter looks more closely at the Salmon Group—its work and its philosophy. Finally, the chapter provides a brief description of individual projects showing how each has translated the Salmon Group’s philosophy into its daily practice.
102
Empowering Frail Elderly People
OLDER PEOPLE: THEIR WISHES, NEEDS AND ANXIETIES—AND THE SALMON GROUP’S RESPONSE All the Salmon Group projects are different, yet in each country these projects have constituted a new approach, a different way of working, a reaction against tradition—the approach of the salmon swimming against the stream. Each project has sought to listen and react to what older people have said. Older people have posed specific challenges and led us to adopt particular models and work practices that have best responded to what we have been told. The feelings expressed by older people in our different countries were remarkably similar. Most older people living on their own in the community hoped desperately that they would not end up in large institutions. Some people living in large residential or nursing homes had adapted well. However, the majority regretted that they had moved there. Many were bewildered and depressed and did not seem motivated to adapt to institutional life. Often, the older people had lost contact with their previous lives; for example, in Liverpool a survey of older people living in large residential homes showed that 50% had no outside visitors apart from paid staff (Currie, 1992a). Our own findings have been reinforced by independent academic research. In the United Kingdom (UK) there have been two large studies. The first listened closely to the views of 1000 elderly people living in 100 large residential homes (Willcocks, Peace & Kellaher, 1987); the second talked with and examined the experience of 7,000 older people living in 175 homes (Booth, 1985). The findings of both studies were strongly critical of the way large institutions affected older people. These studies showed that even when enlightened methods of care were used and better training was given to staff, there seemed to be little effect on reducing the damaging effects of institutionalization. The powerful influence of the large institution was, it seems, overwhelming. These major studies, together with our own findings drawn directly from talking with older people in our own areas, have highlighted serious objections raised by older people to traditional large residential and nursing homes. Five major criticisms form the challenges to which the Salmon Group has responded: older people feel that in large institutions (1) it is not their own home, (2) they lack control over their own lives, (3) they become increasingly dependent on others, (4) they lose their own individuality, and (5) it is a strict and isolating experience. The Salmon Group is a European network of small housing units set up in 1993 after the European Year of Older People and Solidarity Between Generations. It comprises projects in Spain, Belgium, France, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and Germany. The projects of the Salmon Group are essentially about how we have responded to the challenges and criticisms of traditional care of older people. The different situations faced in the dif-
Another Way of Living
103
ferent countries have led to the projects adopting different ways of responding. The size of the houses varies from the largest with 20 residents to the smaller units with just 3 people. Despite the size differences, the projects are based on the same philosophy of providing ordinary housing in conventional residential neighborhoods. The Salmon Group members work together through study visits, seminars, training sessions, exchanges of staff and workshops. These regular activities give opportunities to share practical experiences and to exchange ideas and findings, giving them a collective and individual strength to face impediments in developing their practice. Using the name of a fish that swims against the current is fitting as the group “swims” against the traditional, large-scale “total” institutions normally seen. It also reflects the experience that the salmon often has to overcome enormous obstacles or impediments to reach its goal. The Salmon Group includes, on the one hand, projects that have arisen from traditional institutional care and, on the other, schemes that have developed as an extension of domiciliary care as a way of allowing people to continue to live in the community using ordinary domiciliary services. Thus the conceptual framework that is outlined has arisen from two quite different origins. In spite of their different professional and cultural backgrounds, the Group members discovered that they share the same approach to care and of a “way to be” with frail, handicapped or ill older people who need help and assistance. DIFFERENT PHILOSOPHIES OF CARE: THE MEDICAL MODEL AND THE LIFE MODEL The most essential aspect of the Salmon Group philosophy of care is the paradigmatic shift from the traditional, medical or therapeutic model to what we call the life model. To change from the well-established paradigm to this new paradigm of the life model is seen by the Salmon Group as the most important and basic step to realizing empowerment for frail older people. Many professionals as well as members of the general public talk about older patients, handicapped people or dependent people. For instance, the phrase “demented person” reflects the traditional way of viewing a type of frailty. It is focused on the illness itself, its symptoms and its consequences. It leads to a way of thinking and acting that fits the medical or therapeutic model. The phrase “person with dementia,” however, arises from an alternative way of looking at the situation, where people themselves, their life situations and social surrounding are the central focus. This leads to a different way of thinking and acting, the life model, which can be seen as an extension of the social model of disability developed in the United Kingdom and elsewhere (Oliver, 1996). In the medical model, disabilities or illnesses and their effects are seen as deviating from so-called normality at an organic and/or behavioral level;
104
Empowering Frail Elderly People
therefore, interventions by caregivers mainly consist of reducing the gap between the normal and the pathological. The objective is to allow or compel the person to behave in a normal, well-adjusted way, which does not disturb her surroundings. In the case of people with disabilities, the professional’s objectives may be to provide a secure and comfortable environment. This is generally done, however, according to an established professional view on how to solve problems or avoid risks. A medical scheme is designed according to the methods prevailing in applied sciences, focusing on the disease rather than on the person with the disease. The model, in essence, focuses on crises, problems and deficiencies. The medical model is based on a well-structured theory, which purports to provide an objective view of the situation, setting out rigid, but clear methods and practices leading to specific goals. According to this model, the expert knows what is best and so the only possible relationship, or “way to be,” is one in which the professional dominates and the older person becomes dependent and acquiescent. This also has the effect of discouraging participation by family members and friends in the older person’s social network who feel outside this exclusive relationship. At best, they tend to view themselves as helpers or even beneficiaries of the professional. So, at the onset of the illness, divisions appear between the position, the power, the role, the wishes and needs of the frail or ill older person and those of the professionals, volunteers and families. The consequences of these divisions are far reaching. A WAY TO BE WITH FRAIL OR ILL OLDER PEOPLE: COMMUNICATION, EMOTIONS AND RELATIONSHIPS The basis of the life model is individual empowerment. In spite of the onset of illness, a person remains an individual and recognition of this is at the center of the relationship between that individual and his caregivers. In the life model, the individual is the central point and not, as in the medical model, the illness or the staff. This point of view raises many questions: Who are the experts? What can be done when people cannot express themselves? Why do we want to make so many decisions for older people who need help and care? Who knows what is good and what is bad for them? As the life model starts from the subject, it has to be flexible and creative and it is pre-eminently subjective. The life model is process-oriented, not goal-directed, which makes it much more difficult to define what is good care or good practice. In following this model, it is less important to find “solutions” than to define a “way to be” for the relationship between the caregivers and the older person with an illness or disability. The life model does not aim to cure the disease but to respond to the person needing help and care—first by understanding the person and second by building or
Another Way of Living
105
maintaining a good relationship and a personal way of living. Help is then given in order to support the realization of the older person’s wishes. When good emotional contact is established, caregivers are more able to understand people as individuals in spite of their illness and disabilities and more able to identify their needs and interests and to promote empowerment. By the same token, a positive caring environment encourages commitment and involvement by family, friends and other community resources. IMPEDIMENTS TO THESE IDEAS Large institutions have traditionally followed the medical model of care. By contrast, the capacity for flexibility in small housing units has made it possible to develop the life model. The different Salmon Group projects have had to fight first to put into practice the life model, then to prove that it is a worthwhile solution, or at least no worse a solution than the traditional response of large-scale institutions. The main impediments to the life model and the practices of small housing units come in the form of resistances from different sources for different reasons using different arguments. A few examples from the most important stakeholders and their concerns follow: • Government, national and/or local resist a new project because it is unknown to them. The norms and values of any different approach are new and not yet clearly defined in the initial phase: therefore, it does not fit in with the existing laws, rules and financial regulations they apply to services for this client group. • Professionals feel that an innovative project constitutes an attack on their own practices, standards and professionalism. If an innovative project is successful, then their body of knowledge or received wisdom, as well as their expertise, is questioned and their authority and security are undermined. At best they might have to reconsider their own practices, at worst they are redundant. • Relatives of older people also experience feelings of insecurity. A new approach means that relatives are confronted with the need to choose which way of care they prefer. They cannot simply rely on the expertise of the professionals but have to take responsibility for their choices.
These general resistances occur with every innovation, but in the case of the life model and small housing units there are even greater resistances located at the core of professional organizations: their goals, responsibility, effectiveness and efficiency—in other words, an organization’s very identity. PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONAL GOALS In general, a professional organization tries to realize goals that justify its existence. These goals are worded in objective and, if possible, measurable terms through which it demonstrates the level of its success to its key stake-
106
Empowering Frail Elderly People
holders. In the case of housing and care, these stakeholders include not only the direct users, but also relatives, funders, professional associations, and society as a whole, which controls quality through regulations and laws. Generally speaking, managers try to satisfy their stakeholders by adhering to accepted norms and values. Even if managers see their primary objective as satisfying the client’s self-defined needs, they may find a problem in reconciling the client’s wishes and values with those of the other stakeholders. In the traditional health or care situation, managers look for objective goals in terms of therapeutic success or at least controlling deterioration in the situation of the patient or client; that is, they concentrate first on the deficiencies and second on doing something about them. If the situation is viewed from a life model perspective, then the subjective experience and preferences of the older individual—as a person not as a patient—are the central determinants of the action rather than the professional’s goals. This presents the professional organization with an identity crisis. If it is to adopt the model, it will have to change its paradigm, that is, its raison d’eˆ tre, in a way that goes against the accepted values of most stakeholders, except perhaps the primary client, the older person himself. Even if the organization puts the happiness of the older person as its primary goal, it is still adopting a deficiency perspective, that is, the medical model, since it seeks to improve the situation of the client. Happiness is a subjective experience. If one sees it as one’s goal to make people happy, one makes oneself completely dependent on those people. It is as if one gives carte blanche to the client to ask or even demand happiness as a right. One cannot resist because that would frustrate the goal of making someone happy. The life model and small housing units take a different perspective. They are not about happiness. For them the only definable goal is to respond to the wishes and values of dependent older people through empowerment. This means that the organization has no preset outcomes; its goals can only be described in terms of process. It is only to be expected for these reasons that challenging and changing existing practices and values encounters strong impediments. This is borne out by the experiences of Salmon Group projects. PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONAL RESPONSIBILITY In the traditional care and housing organization the managers and professional staff consider themselves responsible for ensuring the attainment of the organization’s goals. Or, in more general terms, they feel responsible for everything that happens inside the institution. In the words of Goffman, they operate within and help to ensure the continuation of a “total institution” (Goffman, 1968). In the life model, older people are empowered, but with power comes responsibility. The control as well as the consequences of choices and daily routines are in the hands of the older people and are no longer the responsi-
Another Way of Living
107
bility of the professionals. This results in role confusion for management and professional staff who see themselves not only as having responsibility because of their position but because of their expertise. They will have to redefine their own roles and goals, together with their professional identity and responsibility; they will have to come to terms with their own disempowerment. In the traditional organization, risks, problems and failures logically should be avoided or solved since they are seen as signs of failure or lack of expertise by the organization. In the life model, risks, problems and failures could arise from the choices made by the older person. Of course, this will generate a great deal of resistance, as it appears to run counter to logical thought as well as traditional practice. However, risks, problems and failures form part of the daily life of every citizen and are inherent in the basic human right to choose and make one’s own decisions with attendant consequences. In other words, the shift of paradigm from the traditional therapeutic model to the life model is a shift from the totalitarian, controlled organization to the open society with the chance and danger of personal growth, change and chaos. The relationship between the helper and the helped changes from control to trust, from fixed roles to open communication and dialogue. The role of the helper changes from caregiver to enabler or personal assistant. In societies where the threat of lawsuits for malpractice is commonplace, management will feel obliged to try to prevent any problem and risk and to make sure that failures do not happen. In this situation it is unrealistic to expect management to readily choose the life model in which they consciously relinquish control over the situation and give responsibility to the client. Hence, projects experience resistance to the introduction of such ideas. PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS By its very nature, each professional organization will strive to optimize its practice in order to reach its goals, if only to survive in competition with other organizations. To optimize practice one tends to specialize and by doing that to break up reality into parts that one can control and influence. In that way, subgoals are created, which, in care institutions, reduce the understanding of the older person of what is actually happening and so erode still further their power and ability to control their private lives. Any goals that define optimal daily life for people categorically keep the power in the hands of the professionals rather than allowing the older people themselves to determine their own quality of life. PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONAL EFFICIENCY By its nature and by the influence of its stakeholders an organization strives for maximum efficiency. To achieve this objective goals and subgoals
108
Empowering Frail Elderly People
are needed. It is very doubtful if the subjective life goals of any person are focused on maximum efficiency. They certainly will not be focused on the objective goals of the professional organization. Therefore the life model seems a direct threat to efficiency of the organization and the goals of its funding sources. To summarize these arguments, it could be said that all four aspects— professional goals, responsibilities, effectiveness and efficiency—are essential for the identity of a professional organization and are perceived as determining its quality. In many countries governments have introduced laws to control the quality of at least state-financed health care organizations. Such organizations are thus also forced by law to control their operations in order to demonstrate their quality objectively. Seen in this way, the primary client—the older dependent person—is at the same time the raw material, the product and the result of the actions of the organization. The client is the proof of the quality of the professional organization. All this presents a clear message that the professional organization is the expert and what it does is all for the client’s own good. Even if an individual thinks differently, the expert “knows” that the client is wrong and, in fact, thinking differently is part of the individual’s problem as defined by the experts. CONDITIONS AND METHODS TO IMPLEMENT THE LIFE MODEL IN SMALL HOUSING UNITS Diverse Skills and Methods In spite of what may appear as criticism, even an undermining of the professional by the life model approach, in order to put the life model into practice in small housing units, the first requirement is diverse professional and personal skills and methods. These skills can be taught, and the methods can be developed. Among the many skills and methods needed the key ones are the following. Organizational and Practical Requirements • A clear and explicit vision by the project initiators and managers. • An organization willing to take risks. • Sufficient “traditional” professional knowledge, expertise and credibility to withstand professional, funder, relative and societal criticism of the model. • Professional knowledge and ability to establish and manage an organization. • Professional skills, medical and therapeutic knowledge and equipment. • Skills in housing and interior design and the creative use of space. • A system of continuous, critical self-reflection by managers, professionals, caregivers and the support organization as a whole. • A system and style of open communication with all people involved.
Another Way of Living
109
• A constant awareness of the possible dangers arising from management and organization goals, rules and regulations, especially those trying to maximize efficiency. • A management style that strives to be as flexible as possible with a minimum of structured operations. • A regimen in which each rule, protocol and regulation is regarded as temporary, to be changed when no longer needed or appropriate. • A management style of trust and questioning, rather than of command and control.
Philosophical and Personal Conditions: State of Mind • Trust in other people, in oneself and in life. • Basic concept: Everything is possible, until it is proved to be impossible. • Compare everything that is done with the way the older people used to live independently in the community. • Learn to live with uncertainties and feelings of insecurity. • Personal motivation and commitment of people toward the life model. • Perseverance and self-confidence of the project initiators and managers.
Management Methods • Involve key stakeholders, especially funders, with the project aims, developments and achievements. • Involve administrative and financial staff in the wider organization, particularly direct care, so they share the aims, problems and achievements. • Select project staff carefully—values are more important than professional qualifications or even skills and knowledge, which can be taught. • Ensure that staff understand, internalize and live the life model. • Give staff responsibility with support. Ensure that they know they will receive organization backing for any consequences arising from taking risks in the proper implementation of the life model. • Always be ready to introduce new support systems or adjust existing ones, when appropriate. • Join or form a wider network of projects with similar ideals and methods in order to share ideas and achievements and broaden the political and funding support base. • Institute an external system of evaluation and consultation.
EXAMPLES OF SMALL HOUSING UNITS The projects that work together in the Salmon Group share the same philosophy on housing and care facilities for older dependent people. Despite the common philosophy however, a number of key elements are different in each housing unit. The projects are located in different countries in Western Europe, with different political, social and cultural backgrounds,
110
Empowering Frail Elderly People
different laws and financial regulations as well as community expectations of the role of care services, of the family and of the position of older people in society. These different situations have led the projects to adopt different ways of responding to the challenges. However, no matter how different they are, each has found it easier to respond positively by providing small residential units that stress individuality in a community setting as opposed to institutional living. Because of this, the Salmon Group has shown that, in practice, the life model can be realized in many different circumstances and still share the same basic ideas and goals. Based on resident feedback, the projects have also achieved the same outcome of a higher quality of life, especially in comparison to the traditional institutional solutions (Plaisier et al., 1992). It is interesting that the model of small units can be adapted to different client groups. The following sections describe three examples of Salmon Group projects: Antenne Androme`de, Belgium; Personal Service Society (PSS), United Kingdom; and Anton Pieckhofje, the Netherlands. In each case, the needs for care and housing are caused by different problems in the everyday life and routine of the older people. The Anton Pieckhofje project in Haarlem, Holland, will be examined in the greatest detail. This project demonstrates that small units can also be adapted to the needs of older people in the final stages of dementia with high demands for care and, eventually, medical treatment, because of constant severe mental and physical problems. Antenne Androme`de Located in Brussels, Belgium, the Antenne Androme`de project is designed for older people unable to live on their own any longer largely because of social problems such as solitude, feelings of anxiety, and alcohol abuse. By living with five other people in a house that provides a private sitting/bedroom, and shared central sitting/dining room, kitchen, and bathrooms, these seniors are able to live a largely independent life again. Some outside professional help for housekeeping is available three hours a day. Two social workers assist the residents, if necessary, during weekly group meetings; they also provide individual support and counseling to help residents grappling with specific social and psychological problems and issues arising from living together in a group. Most of the time the residents function without staff on the premises and provide mutual support. Personal Service Society Personal Service Society (PSS) is a large nonprofit organization providing a range of community alternatives to institutional care for disabled people in the United Kingdom. It manages 25 ordinary houses located inconspicu-
Another Way of Living
111
ously in different neighborhoods of Liverpool. In each house three older people live together, sharing the home and supporting each other. Some houses provide help to people who have spent many years living in longstay psychiatric hospitals. Four of the houses cater to older people from particular racial minority groups, for which the model is especially well suited because it is so flexible and the care provided can easily be adapted for individual and cultural needs. For example, in one house three Somali elders live together. The house is located close to their mosque and has been designed to provide space designated as a prayer room for those times when they might be too sick to go outside. They are supported by a paid Somali caregiver who goes in each day, preparing three traditional meals for them, speaking their language, understanding their religion and their customs. ANTON PIECKHOFJE Among Dutch experiments in the care of older people with dementia, Anton Pieckhofje holds a unique place. It can be seen as an innovation in vision and structure of care provision and housing facilities for dementia sufferers. Described below are the main characteristics of the project and the conclusions of the scientific research program that has been carried out at the facility. CHARACTERISTICS OF THE ANTON PIECKHOFJE PROJECT In Holland, when older people with dementia are no longer able to live independently (even with home care and/or care by relatives), they are moved to psychogeriatric clinics. Traditionally, the methods of care provision and the involvement of professional helpers in these clinics are based on therapeutic principles, in accordance with the health care system and the medical model, and on goals based on the needs or the organization. In the vision of Anton Pieckhofje, it does not make sense to have therapeutic aims as the center of the care policy, since the syndrome of dementia is an irreversible and progressive illness, and the stay in the clinic always ends with the death of the patient. A therapeutic approach in a clinical setting might even be undesirable, since it might work against the real wishes of the older person with dementia. For Anton Pieckhofje two principles are important in care and housing for dementia sufferers: 1. to offer residents the opportunity to retain their individuality and to live their lives according to their own wishes, in spite of any confusion or disorientation they may experience.
112
Empowering Frail Elderly People
2. to offer physical surroundings, daily routine, tasks and activities that are recognizable, well-known and meaningful, and that fit with the way residents see the world.
It is hoped that the realization of these two principles gives the person with dementia a sense of belonging and security in their world, a sense of self-respect, and of being respected and cared for. Description of the Project The two principles presented above are realized in four key features of the project: 1. Anton Pieckhofje is located in the middle of an ordinary residential area in the town of Haarlem. It consists of six houses, in each of which six residents live together. The houses are situated around an inner court. This court provides a secure area in which the residents have relative freedom of movement. Living in a small, familylike group prevents social isolation. It creates a recognizable and safe environment, furnished with the older people’s own furniture and belongings, even including their own dogs and cats. All this contributes to the ambience and feeling of well-being and belonging. 2. The relatives of the residents are expressly invited to continue their contribution to care, with the goal of keeping meaningful family relationships intact as much as possible. 3. Each house has its own small team of professional caregivers, providing care 24 hours a day. They are assisted in their tasks, as necessary, by people from local home help and home care services. The caregivers are responsible for all the personal care of the residents and for running the household in partnership with the residents. In this way continuity and intimacy in care and daily living are realized. 4. Housekeeping and individual care for the residents are combined. All aspects of these activities are incorporated in the normal routine of the day, and are recognizable and meaningful to the residents. As far as possible they fit with the individual wishes of the residents, who can participate as much as they want, ensuring that they are active players in the life of the house. In this way each house has its own unique characteristics and activities, changing from day to day according to the residents’ wishes and the interests and attitudes of the staff working at that moment. Together they live their daily life and make their own decisions in their own way. On occasions, medical or other professional treatment will be needed. Normally this will be given by the older person’s own family doctor, as it would in a domestic situation. If complicated medical problems arise, professional specialists—such as psychologists or physiotherapists from the psychogeriatric clinic— are available for advice or treatment.
Scientific Evaluation A four-year program of scientific evaluation was carried out by a group of scientists from the University of Amsterdam and the Dutch National Hospital Institute. The main conclusions from this project are:
Another Way of Living
113
1. “The project is much more successful than most institutions in providing a high quality of patient-centered care in a situation resembling an ordinary household. The families of residents and the staff speak of a ‘difference between heaven and hell’ in comparing this new form of care with more traditional ones.” 2. “In general the project is very successful. The project attracts well qualified and enthusiastic personnel, and no major problems occur. In operating the project this way, the organization of care also works out to be somewhat cheaper than in ordinary institutions.” (Plaisier et al., 1992, 1995)
THE LIFE MODEL IN PRACTICE As highlighted at the beginning of this chapter, the projects of the Salmon Group are essentially about how they have tried to realize a life model, how they have responded to the criticisms made by older people of traditional institutional care and the consequent challenges these pose. What follows are some concrete examples of each of the major challenges of overcoming institutional living, and highlights of the underlying importance of using conventional housing design, which blends easily into the community in which it is located. It Is Not Their Own Home Salmon projects have found that older people living in large institutions complain that they do not feel they are living in their own home. Our projects have sought to respond to this challenge by demonstrating in very tangible ways that the units we provide and manage are first and foremost the homes of the older people themselves rather than of the staff. This means that in many projects older people participate in the choice of new residents moving into the houses and in the selection of staff. At Anton Pieckhofje, as described in the previous section, each older person brings her own furniture and pets with her, just as any of us would if we were moving into a new house. This is contrast to a traditional institution that provides furniture that is passed on in turn to every new resident and prohibits pets. Older People Lack Power Over Their Own Lives This particular challenge, set for us by older people, has been met in a number of ways. Within Salmon Group projects there is an emphasis on responding to the individual choices of older people, not on domination by professionals. Often, for example, the timing of cleaning of individual bedrooms is varied according to the individual wishes of the particular older person, rather than according to the timetable of an institutional regimen. At Anton Pieckhofje we had a man without any legs and only one arm who wanted physiotherapy. A program of physiotherapy was arranged for him
114
Empowering Frail Elderly People
even though the professionals and other staff in the unit felt it would not help him physically. Responding to individual choices has meant taking risks, particularly when this has meant allowing vulnerable people to go out into their own communities. For example, at Anton Pieckhofje a highly confused, demented elderly lady wanted to go out and wander around the town on her own