Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
edited by
Kiyotoshi Yasumoto Kyushu University Fukuoka, ...
77 downloads
1113 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
edited by
Kiyotoshi Yasumoto Kyushu University Fukuoka, Japan
Boca Raton London New York
A CRC title, part of the Taylor & Francis imprint, a member of the Taylor & Francis Group, the academic division of T&F Informa plc.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Published in 2006 by CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number-10: 0-8493-3677-5 (Hardcover) International Standard Book Number-13: 978-0-8493-3677-5 (Hardcover) Library of Congress Card Number 2005041895 This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use. No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC) 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Electromagnetic theory and applications for photonic crystals / edited by Kiyotoshi Yasumoto. p. cm. -- (Optical engineering) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-8493-3677-5 (alk. paper) 1. Photonics--Materials. 2. Crystal optics--Materials. 3. Electrooptics. I. Yasumoto, Kiyotoshi. II. Optical engineering (Marcel Dekker, Inc.) TA1522.E24 2005 621.36--dc22
2005041895
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com Taylor & Francis Group is the Academic Division of Informa plc.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
Preface Photonic crystals are periodic dielectric or metallic structures that are artificially designed to control and manipulate the propagation of light. A photonic crystal can be made either by arranging a lattice of air holes on a transparent background dielectric or by forming a lattice of high refractive index material embedded in a transparent medium with a lower refractive index. The lattice size may be roughly estimated to be the wavelength of light in the background medium. The behavior of light propagating in a photonic crystal can be intuitively understood by comparing it to that of electrons in solid-state materials. The electrons passing through a lattice of the atoms interact with a periodic potential. This results in the formation of allowed and forbidden energy states of electrons. The light propagating in a photonic crystal interacts with the periodic modulation of refractive index. This results in the formation of allowed bands and forbidden bands in optical wavelengths. The photonic crystal prohibits any propagation of light with wavelengths in the forbidden bands, i.e., the photonic bandgaps, while allowing other wavelengths to propagate freely. The band structures depend on the specific geometry and composition of the photonic crystal such as the lattice size, the diameter of the lattice elements, and the contrast in refractive index. It is possible to create allowed bands within the photonic bandgaps by introducing point defects or line defects in the lattice of photonic crystals. Light will be strongly confined within the defects for wavelengths in the bandgap of the surrounding photonic crystals. The point defects and line defects can be used to make optical resonators and photonic crystal waveguides, respectively. The photonic crystals with bandgaps are expected to be new materials for future optical circuits and devices, which can control the behavior of light in a micronsized scale. Although there is continuing interest in new findings of photonic bandgap structures associated with particular lattice configurations, recent attention has been focused on the engineering applications of the photonic crystals. To be able to create photonic-crystal-based optical circuits and devices, their electromagnetic modeling has become a much more important area of research. From the viewpoint of electromagnetic field theory, the photonic crystals are optical materials with periodic perturbation of macroscopic material constants. Fortunately we have a great deal of knowledge about the electromagnetic theory for periodic structures. During the past few decades, various analytical or computational techniques have been developed to formulate the electromagnetic scattering, guiding, and coupling problems in periodic structures. The aim of this book is to provide the electromagnetic theoretical methods that can be effectively applied to the modeling of photonic crystals and related optical devices. This book consists of eight chapters that are ordered in a reasonably logical manner from analytical methods to computational methods. Each chapter starts with a brief introduction and a description of the method, followed by detailed formulations for practical applications. Chapter 1 describes the scattering matrix method based on multipole expansions, its extension combined with the method
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
of fictitious sources, and the Bloch modes approach. The applications of the methods and numerical examples are presented with a particular emphasis on phenomena of anomalous refraction and control of light emission in photonic crystals. In Chapter 2, the multipole theory of scattering by a finite cluster of cylinders is discussed to investigate the propagation of light in photonic crystal fibers and the radiation dynamics of photonic crystals. The multipole method combined with the notions of lattice sums and Bloch modes is presented to model the scattering and guidance in various photonic crystal devices. The scattering and guidance by photonic crystals are formulated in Chapter 3, using a model of multilayered periodic parallel or crossed arrays of circular cylinders standing in free-space or embedded in a dielectric slab. The method uses the aggregate transition matrix for a cluster of cylinders within a unit cell, the lattice sums, and the generalized reflection and transmission matrices in a layered system. Chapter 4 is devoted to the method of multiple multipole program applied to the simulation of photonic crystal devices. The method comprises a modeling of periodic structures using the concepts of fictitious boundaries and periodic boundary conditions, novel eigenvalue solvers, a so-called connections scheme that is a unique macro feature of the method, and eigenvalue and parameter estimation techniques. In Chapter 5, the mode-matching method for periodic metallic structures is reexamined. A novel technique for mode matching combined with the generalized scattering matrix method is presented to deal with the scattering and guidance by metallic photonic crystals with lattice elements of arbitrary cross sections. Chapter 6 describes the method of lines, which is one of the efficient numerical algorithms for solving electromagnetic guiding problems. The mathematical formulation and analysis procedure based on the generalized transmission line equations are discussed. The results of applications are demonstrated for photonic crystal devices consisting of various bends, junctions, and their concatenations. In Chapter 7, the full-vectorial finite-difference frequency-domain method is treated. The absorbing boundary conditions, the periodic boundary conditions, and an interface condition for dielectric interfaces with curvature are implemented in the finite-difference scheme. The method is applied to the analysis of photonic crystal fibers, photonic crystal planar waveguides, and bandgap structures. Chapter 8 describes the finite-difference time-domain method based on the principles of multidimensional wave digital filters. The method employs the finite difference schemes using the trapezoidal rule for discretizing Maxwell’s equations that has advantages with regard to numerical stability and robustness. Numerical examples are presented for various photonic crystal waveguide devices. It is hoped that the material is sufficiently detailed both for readers involved with the physics of photonic bandgap structures and for those working on the applications of photonic crystals to optical circuits and devices. Finally, I would like to thank the authors for their excellent contributions. It is also a pleasure for me to acknowledge Jill J. Jurgensen and Taisuke Soda of CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, for their help throughout the preparation of this book. Kiyotoshi Yasumoto © 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
The Editor Kiyotoshi Yasumoto earned the B.E., M.E., and D.E. degrees in communication engineering from Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan, in 1967, 1969, and 1977, respectively. In 1969, he joined the faculty of engineering of Kyushu University, where since 1988 he has been a professor of the Department of Computer Science and Communication Engineering. He was a visiting professor at the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Wisconsin in Madison in 1989 and a visiting fellow at the Institute of Solid State Physics, Bulgarian Academy of Science and Institute of Radiophysics and Electronics, Czechoslovakian Academy of Science, in 1990. He is a fellow of the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE) of Japan, a fellow of the Optical Society of America (OSA), a fellow of the Chinese Institute of Electronics (CIE), a senior member of IEEE AP, MTT, and LEOS Societies, and a member of IEE Japan and the Electromagnetic Academy. His research interests are in electromagnetic wave theory, analytical and numerical techniques in microwave and photonics, and radiation and scattering in electron beam–plasma systems. He has served as a member of organizing, steering, technical program, and international advisory committees and as a session organizer for various international conferences. He has published more than 250 papers in various international journals and conference proceedings.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Contributors Ara A. Asatryan Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Technology Sydney, Australia
Christian Hafner Computational Optics Group Laboratory for Electromagnetic Fields and Microwave Electronics ETH Zentrum Zurich, Switzerland
Lindsay C. Botten Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Technology Sydney, Australia
Stefan F. Helfert Allgemeine und Theoretische Elektrotechnik University of Hagen Hagen, Germany
Hung-Chun Chang Department of Electrical Engineering Graduate Institute of Communication Engineering National Taiwan University Taipei, Taiwan, Republic of China Stefan Enoch Faculté des Sciences de Saint Jérôme Institut Fresnel Université Paul Cézanne-AixMarseille III Marseille, France Daniel Erni Communication Photonics Group Laboratory for Electromagnetic Fields and Microwave Electronics ETH Zentrum Zurich, Switzerland David P. Fussell Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and School of Physics University of Sydney Sydney, Australia
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Hiroyoshi Ikuno Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering Kumamoto University Kurokami, Japan Hongting Jia Department of Computer Science and Communication Engineering Kyushu University Fukuoka, Japan Boris T. Kuhlmey Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and School of Physics University of Sydney Sydney, Australia Timothy N. Langtry Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Technology Sydney, Australia
Daniel Maystre Faculté des Sciences de Saint Jérôme Institut Fresnel Université Paul Cézanne-AixMarseille III Marseille, France
Geoffrey H. Smith Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Technology Sydney, Australia
Ross C. McPhedran Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and School of Physics University of Sydney Sydney, Australia
C. Martijn de Sterke Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and School of Physics University of Sydney Sydney, Australia
Yoshihiro Naka Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering Kumamoto University Kurokami, Japan
Gérard Tayeb Faculté des Sciences de Saint Jérôme Institut Fresnel Université Paul Cézanne-AixMarseille III Marseille, France
Nicolae A. Nicorovici Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Technology Sydney, Australia
Thomas P. White Centre for Ultrahigh-Bandwidth Devices for Optical Systems and School of Physics University of Sydney Sydney, Australia
Reinhold Pregla Allgemeine und Theoretische Elektrotechnik University of Hagen Hagen, Germany Jasmin Smajic ABB Switzerland, Ltd Corporate Research Baden-Dättwil, Switzerland
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Kiyotoshi Yasumoto Department of Computer Science and Communication Engineering Kyushu University Fukuoka, Japan Chin-Ping Yu Graduate Institute of Electro-Optical Engineering National Taiwan University Taipei, Taiwan, Republic of China
Table of Contents Chapter 1
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals ...........................................................................1 Daniel Maystre, Stefan Enoch, and Gérard Tayeb
Chapter 2
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling ..........................................................................47 Lindsay C. Botten, Ross C. McPhedran, C. Martijn de Sterke, Nicolae A. Nicorovici, Ara A. Asatryan, Geoffrey H. Smith, Timothy N. Langtry, Thomas P. White, David P. Fussell, and Boris T. Kuhlmey
Chapter 3
Modeling of Photonic Crystals by Multilayered Periodic Arrays of Circular Cylinders .......................................123 Kiyotoshi Yasumoto and Hongting Jia
Chapter 4
Simulation and Optimization of Photonic Crystals Using the Multiple Multipole Program........................191 Christian Hafner, Jasmin Smajic, and Daniel Erni
Chapter 5
Mode-Matching Technique Applied to Metallic Photonic Crystals .........................................................225 Hongting Jia and Kiyotoshi Yasumoto
Chapter 6
The Method of Lines for the Analysis of Photonic Bandgap Structures .....................................................295 Reinhold Pregla and Stefan F. Helfert
Chapter 7
Applications of the Finite-Difference Frequency-Domain Mode Solution Method to Photonic Crystal Structures........................................................351 Chin-Ping Yu and Hung-Chun Chang
Chapter 8
Finite-Difference Time-Domain Method Applied to Photonic Crystals ...................................................................401 Hiroyoshi Ikuno and Yoshihiro Naka
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Matrix Method 1 Scattering Applied to Photonic Crystals Daniel Maystre, Stefan Enoch, and Gérard Tayeb
CONTENTS 1.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................2 1.2 Scattering Matrix Method ............................................................................3 1.2.1 Presentation of the Problem and Notation ......................................3 1.2.2 Fourier–Bessel Expansions of the Field inside the Cylinders ........5 1.2.3 Fourier–Bessel Expansions of the Field outside the Cylinders........7 1.2.4 First Set of Equations: Causality Property for Each Cylinder......11 1.2.5 Second Set of Equations: Introducing the Coupling between Cylinders ........................................................................12 1.2.6 Final Equation ..............................................................................15 1.3 Combination of Scattering Matrix and Fictitious Sources Methods..........16 1.3.1 Introduction....................................................................................16 1.3.2 Setting of the Problem ..................................................................17 1.3.3 The Method of Fictitious Sources (MFS) ....................................18 1.3.4 Implementation of the Scattering Matrix Method (SMM)............22 1.3.5 Hybrid Method Using MFS and SMM ........................................23 1.3.6 Numerical Example ......................................................................24 1.4 Dispersion Relations of Bloch Modes ......................................................25 1.4.1 Infinite Structure............................................................................26 1.4.2 Finite-Size Photonic Crystals ........................................................30 1.5 Theoretical and Numerical Studies of Photonic Crystal Properties ..........35 1.5.1 Ultrarefraction with Dielectric Photonic Crystals ........................35 1.5.2 Ultrarefraction with Metallic Photonic Crystals ..........................36 1.5.3 Negative Refraction by a Dielectric Slab Riddled with Galleries ................................................................................39 1.6 Conclusion..................................................................................................42 References ..........................................................................................................43 1
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
1.1 INTRODUCTION The scattering matrix method (SMM) is one of the most efficient methods for solving a problem of scattering by a large but finite number of objects. It basically takes into account separately the specific scattering properties of each object and then evaluates the coupling phenomena between them. Even though it can be presented in a quite rigorous form, it is based on a physically intuitive approach to the problem of scattering from a set of objects. One of its advantages is to be accessible to postgraduate students. Moreover, the numerical implementation does not present major difficulties. In contrast to other classical methods like Finite Difference Time Domain method (FDTD) or the finite element method, it becomes much simpler in the case of two-dimensional (2D) photonic crystals with circular cross sections or 3D photonic crystals formed by spherical inclusions. It deals with crystals of finite size regardless of whether or not they have defects of periodicity. The first achievement relating to that method should be attributed to Lord Rayleigh, who dealt with the electrostatic case [1]. The electromagnetic version of this method has been developed since the 1980s in various forms by different groups working independently [2–9]. Their studies deal with 2D or 3D, dielectric, metallic, or perfectly conducting objects placed in space in a periodic or random way, but the essence of each of the approaches remains the same. However, the SMM is not able to deal with some interesting configurations, especially when the set of scatterers is surrounded by a jacket. To extend the method to more complicated structures, it is possible to combine the SMM with the method of fictitious sources (MFS). The MFS is another rigorous method that is able to solve the problem of scattering from arbitrary scatterers. In MFS, the field in each medium is represented as the field radiated by a set of fictitious sources with initially unknown intensities. These intensities are obtained by imposing the boundary conditions for the fields on the surfaces of the scatterers. By combining these two methods, we concurrently procure their advantages. The method is described in Section 1.3 in a 2D case and can, for instance, address structures such as a finite dielectric body pierced to form galleries, such as a photonic crystal made with macroporous silicon. More generally, the method could be useful for the study of problems dealing with small clusters of buried objects. These two methods enable one to deal with a large range of two-dimensional photonic crystals. However, the phenomena generated by photonic crystals are so surprising and so complex that a theoretician needs a preliminary phenomenological approach. For this purpose, the notion of Bloch modes provides a valuable tool. We will describe such modes, and we will show that their dispersion curves enable one to predict most of the properties of photonic crystals. Indeed, these dispersion curves enlighten us on quantities such as the average energy velocity and provide an intuitive way of grasping the vital notion of effective optical index in the case of a heterogeneous material. A special emphasis will be put on anomalous refraction phenomena and the control of light emission. Two kinds of anomalous refraction phenomena can be distinguished. In the phenomenon of ultrarefraction, a photonic crystal simulates
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
3
a material having an optical index between zero and unity, while in negative refraction, it acts like a material having a negative index. These phenomena will be predicted from three-dimensional dispersion diagrams and illustrated using the two methods. It will be shown that these phenomena can lead to new optical components: directive sources, microlenses, and so on.
1.2 SCATTERING MATRIX METHOD The method discussed here can deal with collections of objects having different electromagnetic parameters or different shapes. However, for simplicity, we will limit ourselves to a set of identical objects, which is in general the case for photonic crystals. Furthermore, we will confine the theory to the particular case of 2D photonic crystals with identical circular cylinders illuminated with s-polarized light (electric field parallel to the cylinder axes). The generalization to p-polarized light (magnetic field parallel to the cylinder axes) or to the case in which the cylinders are different is straightforward, while the extension to 3D photonic crystals leads to a considerable increase in the complexity of the algebraic developments.
1.2.1 PRESENTATION
OF THE
PROBLEM AND NOTATION
The scattering problem is represented in Figure 1.1. An incident monochromatic plane wave with wavelength 0 2/k0 in vacuum propagates in a homogeneous y inc
Incident field
Z O
x
FIGURE 1.1 Presentation of the problem of scattering: an s-polarized incident plane wave illuminates N cylinders (here N 6).
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
4
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
material of relative permittivity r,ext. The generalization to an incident beam or to a field generated by a 2D antenna is not problematic. It illuminates under s-polarization and incidence angle inc a set of N identical dielectric cylinders of radius R and relative permittivity r,int. We work under the assumption that all the materials are nonmagnetic, and the optical indices of the materials outside and inside the cylinders are denoted respectively by next r,ext and nint r,int . Using a time dependence in exp(it) and denoting by xˆ, yˆ and zˆ the unit vectors of the three axes in the Cartesian coordinate system xyz, the incident electric field is given by: Ei Ezi zˆ (1.1) with: Ezi exp(ik0 next(x sin inc y cos inc))
(1.2)
From Maxwell’s equations, the total electric field satisfies a Helmholtz equation in the sense of distributions: 2 Ez k02er ( x , y) Ez 0
(1.3)
er , ext outside the rods er (x , y) e r , int inside the rods
(1.4)
with:
The reader who is not well acquainted with the theory of distributions may consider that Equation (1.3) is valid in the sense of functions but includes in addition the boundary conditions at the interfaces between different materials (continuity of Ez and of its normal derivative). In outline, the method can be divided into three steps. The first step consists of showing that the total field can be expressed in the form of Fourier–Bessel series. Outside a cylinder, the series can be separated into two parts: the first part describes the total incident field on the cylinder. The total incident field includes not only the incident plane wave given by Equation (1.2), but also the field scattered by the other cylinders in the direction of the cylinder that is considered. The second part represents the field scattered by the cylinder. The second step is achieved by requiring that a relation of causality exists between the field scattered by a cylinder and the total incident field that illuminates the same cylinder. This relationship can be expressed in terms of the Fourier–Bessel coefficients through the notion of the scattering matrix. The third step addresses the fact that the total incident field on a cylinder is the sum of a known component (the incident plane wave) and of the fields scattered by the other cylinders. A second relation between these two parts of the field surrounding each cylinder can thereby be obtained. In contrast to the second step, the last step expresses the coupling phenomena between all the cylinders.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
1.2.2 FOURIER–BESSEL EXPANSIONS
OF THE
5
FIELD
INSIDE THE
CYLINDERS
The expansion of the field in Fourier–Bessel series inside and outside the cylinders constitutes the basis of the formalism, allowing the initial problem, namely the determination of the field at any point of space, to be reduced to the evaluation of a set of complex coefficients. First, let us establish that the field inside each cylinder is described by a Fourier–Bessel series. This can be demonstrated using a local system of polar coordinates (rj, j) with an origin located at the center Oj of each cylinder (Figure 1.2). It can be shown that this property extends to noncircular cylinders, but in that case the domain of validity of the Fourier–Bessel series does not include the entire cross section of the cylinder. Obviously, the electric field is, for a given value of rj, a periodic function of j with period 2, and thus it can be represented by a Fourier series: Ez (rj , u j )
∑
mZ
(1.5)
Ez , m (rj ) exp(imu j )
Inside the cylinder, the total field obeys the equation: 2 Ez k02 er ,int Ez 0
inc
(1.6)
y
Incident field P)
r j(
l
j
j
l
Oj
P
j
Ol rj
j th rod j
O
x
FIGURE 1.2 Domains of validity of the Fourier–Bessel series inside and outside the jth cylinder. The deep gray region represents the domains of validity of the Fourier–Bessel series inside the cylinder (with Bessel functions of the first kind). The light gray domain represents the domain of validity of the Fourier–Bessel series around the cylinder (with Hankel functions and Bessel functions of the first kind). The arrows l → j and j → l show the fields scattered by the lth and jth cylinders, respectively, which propagate toward the interior (and exterior) of the light gray ring.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
6
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
Using the expression of the scalar Laplacian in polar coordinates: 2V
2V 1 V 1 2V 2 2 rj rj rj 2j rj
(1.7)
Then substituting the expression of the field given by Equation (1.5) into Equation (1.6), a straightforward calculation shows that the Fourier coefficients satisfy the following equation: d 2 Ez , m
∀m,
drj2
m 2 1 Ez , m 2 k0 er ,int 2 Ez , m 0 rj rj rj
(1.8)
Defining rj k0nintrj, this equation becomes: ∀m,
d 2 Ez , m drj′2
1 Ez ,m m2 1 2 Ez , m 0 rj′ rj′ rj′
(1.9)
Thus, Ez,m satisfies the Bessel equation, whose general solution [10] is given by: Ez , m c ′j ,m Jm (rj′) d ′j , mYm (rj′) c ′j , m Jm (k0 nint rj ) d ′j , mYm (k0 nint rj )
(1.10)
with Jm and Ym being Bessel functions of the mth order, respectively of the first and second kinds. It is interesting to express the right-hand member of Equation (1.10) in a different form: Ez ,m (c ′j , m id ′j , m )Jm (k0 nint rj ) id ′j , m (Jm (k0 nint rj ) iYm (k0 nint rj ))
(1.11)
and bearing in mind the definition of the Hankel function of the mth order and of the first kind: H m(1) (u) Jm (u) iYm (u) (1.12) Equation 1.10 can be rewritten: Ez , m c j ,m Jm (k0 nint rj ) d j ,m H m(1) (k0 nint rj )
(1.13)
Introducing the expression of Ez,m in Equation (1.5), we are led to an expression of the total field in the cylinder in the form of a Fourier–Bessel expansion: Ez (rj , u j )
∑ [c j ,m Jm (k0 nint rj ) d j ,m Hm(1) (k0 nint rj )] exp(im j )
(1.14)
mZ
The expression of the field given by Equation (1.14) is best adapted to an intuitive physical interpretation of the two terms on the right-hand side. Indeed, inside
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
7
the cylinder, all the coefficients dj,m vanish. This is a straightforward consequence of the fact that the Hankel function Hm(1)(s) has a singularity for s 0 and that the field should not be singular inside the cylinder. Thus, if rj R,
Ez (rj , u j )
∑ c j ,m Jm (k0 nint rj ) exp(imu j )
(1.15)
mZ
Finally, the determination of the field inside the cylinders reduces to the calculation of the coefficients cj,m of the Fourier–Bessel expansion on the right-hand side of Equation (1.15).
1.2.3 FOURIER–BESSEL EXPANSIONS OF THE FIELD OUTSIDE THE CYLINDERS The calculations we have done for the expression of the field inside a cylinder can be reproduced almost identically for the regions surrounding the cylinders. The field outside the cylinders satisfies the following Helmholtz equation: 2 Ez k02 er , ext Ez 0
(1.16)
We consider the ring surrounding the jth cylinder and extending to the nearest point of the closest cylinder (the light gray region in Figure 1.2). Using the same coordinate system as in the preceding section, following the same mathematical lines, and remarking that for a given value of rj, the value of the optical index remains equal to next, it can be shown that inside this region the field takes the form of another Fourier–Bessel series having the same form as that given in Equation (1.14): Ez (rj , u j )
∑ a j , m Jm (k0 next rj ) exp(imu j ) ∑ b j , m H m(1) (k0 next rj ) exp(imu j ) mZ
mZ
(1.17)
By contrast with the expansions inside the cylinders, it is not possible to show that the coefficients bj,m vanish, because no physical argument prevents the expression of the field in the light gray ring from being singular at the center of the cylinder, due to the fact that this center does not belong to the ring. Now, it turns out that the properties of Bessel functions allow us to give a physical meaning to each of the terms on the right-hand side of Equation (1.17). Indeed, from an intuitive physical viewpoint, the field in the ring can be separated into three different parts: • The incident plane wave (source) given by Equation (1.2). • The fields scattered by all the other cylinders toward the jth cylinder, which behave for this cylinder as incident fields. These fields add to the incident plane wave (source) to constitute the total incident field on the jth cylinder. • The field scattered by the jth cylinder, which according to the radiation condition must propagate away from the cylinder.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
In order to identify in Equation (1.17) each physical component of the field, let us note first that, obviously, the total incident field on the jth cylinder has been generated by sources located outside this cylinder (at infinity for the incident plane wave and inside the other cylinders for the complementary part). Thus, it must satisfy inside this cylinder a Helmholtz equation and cannot have any singularity. This property allows us to deduce that the total incident field is contained inside the first sum of Equation (1.17). Consequently the second sum represents a scattered field of the jth cylinder. The question that now arises is whether this second sum represents the totality or only a part of the field scattered by the jth cylinder. In the first case, the first sum represents the total incident field on this cylinder (and only the total incident field on this cylinder). In the second case, the first sum represents not only the total incident field on the cylinder but also a part of the scattered field. Causality properties provide the answer to this question. The field scattered by the jth cylinder must propagate away from it. It emerges that the only Fourier–Bessel functions that satisfy this condition are those containing Hankel functions of the first kind. Indeed, the asymptotic expression at infinity of Hankel functions of the first kind is given by [10]: H q(1) (k0 next rj )
2 p p exp i k0 next rj q pk0 next rj 2 4
(1.18)
and they satisfy, at any order q, the radiation condition at infinity. So the second sum of Equation (1.17) does indeed represent a field scattered by the jth cylinder. Conversely, an arbitrary term of the first sum cannot represent a scattered field because, from Equation (1.12), Jm(s) is given by: Jm (s) H m(1) (s) H m(1) (s)
(1.19)
– – with H m(1) complex conjugate of H m(1)(s). Obviously, Equation (1.18) shows that –(1) H m (s) does not satisfy the radiation condition at infinity. As a consequence, the first sum in Equation (1.17) actually represents the total incident field illuminating the jth cylinder, and the second sum represents the field scattered by the same cylinder. Now let us calculate the contribution in the total incident field of the incident plane wave (source), as given by Equation (1.2). With this aim, let us express the amplitude of this field at an arbitrary point P of space (Figure 1.2) in the form: Ezi (P) exp(i k.OP )
(1.20)
where the incident wavevector k has components (k0next sin inc, k0next cos inc). Expressing OP as the sum of OOj et OjP yields: Ezi (P) exp(ik(OO j O j P )) exp(ik0next r j sin(inc u j )) exp(ik0next r j(P) sin(inc u j (P))) (1.21)
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
9
r j, j denoting the polar coordinates of the origin Oj of the local coordinate system in the general system xy (Figure 1.2). Using Equation (1.21) and the following expansion [10]: exp(ij cos(u))
∑ (i)m Jm (j) exp(imu)
(1.22)
mZ
it emerges that: E zi(P) exp(ik0next r j sin(inc u j ))
∑ exp(iminc)Jm (k0 nextrj (P)) exp(imj(P))
(1.23)
m∈Z
Bearing in mind that Jm (s) (1)mJm(s), m can be replaced by m in Equation (1.23), enabling us to obtain an expression that can be compared directly with the first sum of Equation (1.17): E zi(P) exp(ik0next r j sin(inc u j ))
∑ ()m exp(iminc)Jm (k0 nextrj (P)) exp(imj(P))
(1.24)
m∈Z
Equations (1.23) and (1.24) provide the development of the source incident field in Fourier–Bessel series in the coordinate system linked to the jth cylinder. Coming back to Equation (1.17), it becomes possible to distinguish the coefficients of the Fourier–Bessel series associated with the source field from those associated with the field scattered by the other cylinders. They will be denoted by source rods aj,m and aj,m , respectively, their sum being equal to aj,m. Equation (1.24) allows source us to identify aj,m : asource (1)m exp(ik0 next r j sin(inc u j )iminc) j ,m
(1.25)
Finally, the three components of the field in the ring surrounding the jth cylinder can be expressed respectively by the following Fourier–Bessel series: • The source term (incident plane wave): Ezsource (rj , u j ) ,j
∑ asource j , m J m (k0 next rj ) exp(imu j )
(1.26)
mZ
• The field scattered by the other cylinders toward the jth cylinder: Ezrods , j (rj , u j )
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
∑ a rods j , m J m (k0 next r j ) exp(imu j )
mZ
(1.27)
10
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
• The field scattered by the jth cylinder: Ezd, j (rj , u j )
∑ b j , m Hm(1) (k0 next rj ) exp(imu j )
(1.28)
mZ
It has been established that the total field in the ring can be expressed from source rods three series of coefficients: aj,m (known), aj,m (unknown) and bj,m (unknown). Now let us demonstrate a vital property of the field scattered by a cylinder. The expression of the field scattered by the jth cylinder in the ring around this cylinder given by Equation (1.28) extends in fact to the entire space surrounding this cylinder. This fundamental property is very intuitive: the field scattered by the jth cylinder is produced by sources located inside this cylinder and thus can be defined in the entire space around the cylinder. In order to give a mathematical demonstration of this property, let us rewrite Equation (1.3) in the form: 2 Ez k02 er , ext Ez (k02 er , ext k02 er ( x , y)) Ez
(1.29)
Bearing in mind that the incident field satisfies the Helmholtz equation 2Eiz k20r,ext, Ezi 0 and subtracting this equation from Equation (1.29), it can be derived that the field Edz scattered by the entire set of cylinders, defined at any point of space as the difference between the total field and the source incident field (the incident plane wave), satisfies the equation: 2 Ezd k02 er , ext Ezd (k02 er , ext k02 er ( x , y)) Ez
(1.30)
Hence, the scattered field at any point P of space outside the cylinders can be expressed using Green’s theorem: Ezd ( P)
i 2 k H (1) (k n PM )(er , ext er ( M )) Ez ( M ) dx dy 4 0 ∫∫ 0 0 ext
(1.31)
with x and y coordinates of M in the general coordinate system. Notice that the integral on the right-hand side of Equation (1.31) can be restricted to the set of cylinders since r,ext r(M) vanishes outside these cylinders. Consequently, the scattered field can be represented as a sum of integrals on the cylinders: Ezd ( P)
Ezd, j ( P)
ik02 (er , int er , ext ) 4
∑
j1, 2 ,… , N
∫∫
Ezd, j ( P)
(1.32)
H 0(1) (k0 next PM ) Ez ( M ) dx dy (1.33)
j th cylinder
The field Edz,j can be identified as the field scattered by the jth cylinder. Equation (1.33) clearly shows that it can be defined in the entire space and satisfies outside
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
11
the jth cylinder the Helmholtz equation: 2 Ezd, j k02 er , ext Ezd, j 0
(1.34)
As a consequence, the expression of the field scattered by the jth cylinder given by Equation (1.28) extends to the entire space surrounding this cylinder, and from Equation (1.32), the total scattered field is obtained by summing the fields scattered by the entire set of cylinders: N
Ezd ( P) ∑
∑ b j , m Hm(1) (k0 next rj ) exp(imu j )
(1.35)
j1 mZ
1.2.4 FIRST SET OF EQUATIONS: CAUSALITY PROPERTY CYLINDER
FOR
EACH
We have given an expression for the field surrounding a given cylinder (Equation (1.17)) that separates the total incident field on this cylinder and the field scattered by the same cylinder. These two fields are linked by causality, and this link can be expressed mathematically through the use of a scattering matrix: b j S ja j
(1.36)
In this equation, we have introduced the infinite column matrices aj and bj with components aj,m and bj,m, and Sj is a square matrix of infinite dimension. When the cylinders have circular cross section s, the scattering matrix can be calculated in closed form by writing the boundary conditions on the periphery of a cylinder. Equation (1.3) being valid in the sense of distributions, the electric field and its normal derivative are continuous across this boundary (this property can also be proved from the continuity of the tangential components of the electric and magnetic fields). Using the expansions of the electric field inside and outside the cylinder given by Equations (1.15) and (1.17), then identifying the Fourier coefficients on both sides for rj R, it can be deduced that: a j , m Jm (k0 next R) b j , m H m(1) (k0 next R) c j , m J m (k0 nint R)
a j,m
d ( Jm (k0 next rj ))
c j,m
drj
b j,m r j R
d ( Jm (k0 nint rj ))
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
drj
(1.37)
d ( H m(1) (k0 next rj )) drj
r j R
(1.38) r j R
12
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
Eliminating coefficients cj,m between Equations (1.37) and (1.38), it turns out that: Jm (k0 next R) b j , m H m(1) (k0 next R)
d ( Jm (k0 nint rj )) drj
Jm (k0 nint R)
drj
r j R
d ( Jm (k0 nint rj )) drj
d ( Jm (k0 next rj ))
Jm (k0 nint R)
r j R
a j,m
d ( H m(1) (k0 next rj ))
r j R
drj
r j R
(1.39) Note that the variable rj in this equation can be replaced by a variable r independent of the cylinder. Indeed, since the cylinders are identical, this relation of causality is independent of the particular cylinder considered. Thus, all the matrices Sj defined by Equation (1.36) are diagonal and equal to the matrix S defined by: Jm (k0 next R) Sm , m H m(1) (k0 next R)
d ( Jm (k0 nint rj )) drj
Jm (k0 nint R) rj R
d ( Jm (k0 nint rj )) drj
Jm (k0 nint R) rj R
d ( Jm (k0 next rj )) drj
rj R
d ( H m(1) (k0 next rj )) drj
rj R
(1.40) and Sn , m 0
if n ≠ m
(1.41)
Obtaining the scattering matrix for noncircular cylinders is much more difficult because this calculation is no longer analytic. In this case, numerical techniques can be employed instead, for example the FDTD method, a finite element method, or the method of fictitious sources. The primary advantage of the scattering matrix method is that the use of a classical way of considering scattering is restricted to a single cylinder rather than to the entire set of cylinders. When the cylinders do not have the same radii, or the same permittivities, the scattering matrices cease to be identical, but they nevertheless remain diagonal if the cylinders are circular. The extension of the method to the p-polarization case is straightforward: the only change is in the calculation of the Sj matrices.
1.2.5 SECOND SET OF EQUATIONS: INTRODUCING THE COUPLING BETWEEN CYLINDERS First let us give the intuitive physical background of the introduction of the coupling phenomena between cylinders. The total incident field contains two components: the source term (known) and the field scattered by the other cylinders toward the jth rods cylinder (unknown). The latter, represented by coefficients aj,m , is nothing but the field scattered by all the other cylinders toward the jth cylinder. Now, the field
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
13
scattered by an arbitrary cylinder is given by the second series of Equation (1.17); rods therefore, we can deduce easily that it is possible to express the coefficients aj,m in terms of the set of coefficients bl,m with l j. However, we must overcome a mathematical problem: the incident field on the jth cylinder is expressed in a local coordinate system linked to this cylinder, while the fields scattered by the other cylinders are expressed in the local coordinate system associated with those other cylinders. To solve this problem, the fields will be expressed in a unique coordinate system, that associated with the jth cylinder. With this aim, an adequate mathematical tool is provided by the Graf formula [10]. This formula gives in a mathematical form a very intuitive result: the field scattered by the l th cylinder toward the j th cylinder satisfies around this last cylinder a Helmholtz equation and does not possess singularities. As a consequence, it can be expressed in the form of a Fourier–Bessel series involving exclusively Bessel functions of the first kind. This formula can be written using the notation of Figure 1.3 as: if rj(P) rjl OjOl, H m(1) (k0 next rl ( P)) exp(imul (P)) ∑ exp(i(m q)ulj )H q(1) m (k0 next rjl ) Jq (k0 next rj ( P)) exp(iqu j (P)) (1.42) q∈Z
y rj (P)
P
j (P )
Oj inc
j l
l
j rj rl =
rj r
Ol j
O
FIGURE 1.3 The coordinate systems.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
x
14
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
Equations (1.17) and (1.42) enable us to express the field scattered by the lth cylinder toward the jth cylinder in the coordinate system of origin Oj. Thus, if rj(P) rjl R: Ezd,l ( P) =
∑ bl , m ∑ exp(i(m − q) lj )Hq(1−) m (k0 next rjl )Jq
m ∈Z
q∈ Z
(k0 next rj ( p)) exp(iq j ( P ))
(1.43)
or, by exchanging indices m and q: Ezd,l ( P) ∑ bl , q ∑ exp(i(q m)ulj )H m(1) q (k0 next rjl ) Jm (k0 next rj ( P)) q∈ Z
m ∈Z
exp(imu j ( P))
(1.44)
By summing the contributions of the scattered fields Edz,l, with l j, we must rods reconstitute the component Ez,j on the jth cylinder, given by Equation (1.27). The identification leads to the following relation: a rods j,m ∑
∑ bl , q exp(i(q m)ulj )Hm(1) q (k0 next rjl )
(1.45)
l ≠ j q∈ Z
source of the source field (Equation (1.25)) to the coeffiBy adding the coefficient aj,m rods cients aj,m , it is possible to express aj,m in terms of the coefficients bl,q of the fields scattered by the other cylinders:
a j , m (i)m exp(ik0 next r j sin(inc u j )iminc) ∑
∑ bl , q exp(i(q m)ulj )Hm(1) q (k0 next rjl )
(1.46)
l ≠ j q∈ Z
In matrix form, Equation (1.46) can be written a j Q j ∑ Tj ,l bl
(1.47)
l≠ j
where Qj is a column matrix with mth component Qj,m given by: Q j , m (1)m exp(ik0 next r j sin(inc u j )iminc)
(1.48)
and Tj,l is a square matrix with (m, q)th component Tj,l,m,q given by: T j ,l , m , q exp(i(q m)ulj ) H m(1) q (k0 next rjl )
(1.49)
Equation (1.47) is a set of N matrix equations relating the 2N column matrices aj and bj.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
15
1.2.6 FINAL EQUATION Equations (1.36) and (1.47) constitute a set of 2N matrix equations with 2N unknown column matrices aj and bj. A single matrix equation can be obtained by multiplying both sides of Equation (1.47) by Sj S, Equation (1.36) being used for simplifying the left-hand side. We thus obtain b j ∑ STj ,l bl SQ j
(1.50)
l, j
or, in a more explicit form: I ST1,2 ST1,3 I ST2,3 ST2,1 ST I 3,1 ST3,2 … … … … … …
… … b1 SQ1 … … b2 SQ2 … … b3 SQ3 … … … … … … … …
(1.51)
In this way, we get an infinite linear system of equations, I being the infinite unit matrix. In order to limit the size of the system, matrices S, Tj,l, Qj and bl are truncated by restricting the values of m and q between M and M, the final size of the system being equal to N(2M + 1). The field at infinity can be deduced easily from the column matrices bl. With this aim, the expression of the field scattered outside each cylinder (right-hand side of Equation (1.28)) is transformed to the unique coordinate system xy. The change of coordinate system from the local system linked with a cylinder to xy can be done by applying Graf’s formula [10]: if r rj, H m(1) (k0 next rj (P)) exp(imu j (P ))
∑ exp(i(m q)u j )Jqm (k0 next r j )H q(1) (k0 next r ) exp(iqu)
(1.52)
qZ
with r and being the polar coordinates of a point P in space in the xy coordinate system. Thus it turns out that at a large distance from the cylinders: Ezd (P) ∑ bq H q(1) (k0 next r ) exp(iqu)
(1.53)
qZ
where the bq coefficients (not to be confused with the bj column matrix defined before) are: bq
∑ ∑ b j , m exp(i(m q)u j )Jqm (k0 next r j )
j1,N mZ
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(1.54)
16
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
The field at infinity is obtained by using the asymptotic form of the Hankel function at infinity, given by Equation (1.18). Equation (1.53) then becomes: Ezd ( P) g( )
exp(ikr )
(1.55)
r
with: g( )
p 2 p exp i ∑ bq exp iq exp(iqu) pk0 next 2 4 q ,
(1.56)
The bistatic differential cross section, which represents the intensity of the field at infinity, is given by: D(u) 2p|g(u)|2
(1.57)
When all the materials (cylinders and exterior) are lossless, the energy balance criterion (also called the optical theorem) can be expressed in the form: 2p
∫0
|g(u)|2 du 2
p 2p Re exp i g(inc p) 0 k0 next 4
(1.58)
This theorem can be valuable for testing the validity of a numerical code, although like casting out nines, it does not provide a rigorous verification of validity.
1.3 COMBINATION OF SCATTERING MATRIX AND FICTITIOUS SOURCES METHODS 1.3.1 INTRODUCTION In this section, we present a method that combines the scattering matrix method (SMM) described in Section 1.2 with the method of fictitious sources (MFS) in order to deal with more complicated structures. Although the basic ideas can be generalized to 3D cases, we will consider only 2D cases for simplicity. Note that the SMM presented in Section 1.2 cannot deal with structures in which the set of cylinders is embedded inside a jacket consisting of a dielectric medium that is itself surrounded by another external medium (Figure 1.4). This limitation can be made to disappear by using the results of the present section. The MFS method [11] can solve the problem of scattering from arbitrarily shaped scatterers. The space is divided into different regions in which the field is represented as the field radiated by a set of fictitious sources with unknown intensities. These intensities are obtained by matching the fields at the boundaries of the regions using a least squares technique. Returning to Figure 1.4, the basic idea of the method proposed in this section is to use the SMM in order to build a set of functions that correctly represent the
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
17
ui Ωe Ωi
0 ne
2 1 ni
3
y
x
FIGURE 1.4 Description of the problem: a set of cylinders inside a jacket (shaded region).
field inside the jacket. These functions are then used to solve a fictitious sources problem on the boundary 0 of the jacket. Combining the SMM and MFS methods offers the advantages of both rigorous methods and enables us efficiently to address new classes of problems, such as a finite dielectric body riddled by galleries.
1.3.2 SETTING
OF THE
PROBLEM
The cylindrical scatterer is delimited by its external boundary 0. The exterior of 0 is the domain e, filled with a medium of optical index ne (ne may be complex, and we define ke k0ne). The interior of 0 is the domain i. It is filled with a medium of optical index ni (shaded region in Figure 1.4; ni may be complex, and we put ki k0ni ). The domain i also contains cylinders with boundaries j ( j 1, 2, 3, . . .), filled with arbitrary media. The structure is illuminated by an incident field coming from the exterior (this assumption is made for clarity, but the method also can deal with an excitation from inside 0 with very little change). This incident field is also assumed to be z-independent. For instance, it can be a plane wave, or the field emitted by one (or several) line source(s) placed outside 0. It is well known that in this case the problem can be reduced to two independent problems: the s-polarization case where the electric field is parallel to the z axis, and the p-polarization case where the magnetic field is parallel to the z axis. Each of these cases leads to a scalar problem in which the unknown u is the z component of either E or H: u Ez (for s-polarization) or u Hz (for p-polarization). We denote by ui the incident field, and by ud the scattered field, in such a way that the total field is: u ui u d u u int
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
in e (outside 0 ) in i (inside 0 )
(1.59)
18
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
1.3.3 THE METHOD
OF
FICTITIOUS SOURCES (MFS)
The MFS is a versatile and reliable method to deal with many scattering problems. It relies upon a simple idea: the electromagnetic field in the various domains of the diffracting structure can be expressed as a combination of fields radiated by suitable electromagnetic sources. These sources have no physical existence, and this is why they are denoted as fictitious sources. They are located in homogeneous regions and not on the interfaces. In other words, one can consider that they generate electromagnetic fields that taken together faithfully reproduce the actual field and as such form a convenient basis for this field. From a numerical point of view, proper bases are those capable of representing the solution with the fewest possible functions. Obviously, the quality of the bases is closely linked with the nature of the sources and their location. The freedom in the choice of the sources provides a great adaptability to various complex problems. The MFS has been developed in our laboratory in the last decade from both theoretical and numerical points of view [11–15]. Almost at the same time and independently, other groups have worked on the same basic ideas [16–21], but their approaches are slightly different from ours. In fact, one of the first attempts at using this method is probably due to Kupradze [22]. The method has been developed and applied to a large collection of problems, and a good review can be found in [23]. It is not our intention to depict here all the details of the MFS, and it will be sufficient for our present purposes to give an outline of the general principles. Let us consider the same situation as in Figure 1.4 but without the inclusions: the interior region i is thus filled with a homogeneous material of optical index ni (Figure 1.5). Let us introduce a set of Ns fictitious sources Se,n (n 1, 2, …, Ns) Ωe ud ui
S i,n
S e,n
0 Ωi u int
FIGURE 1.5 The sources Se,n (represented by dots) radiate the fields Fe,n(r) used to represent the scattered field ud in e, whereas the sources Si,n (represented by stars) radiate the fields Fi,n(r) used to represent the total field uint in i.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
19
located at Ns points re,n in i, which are supposed to radiate in a homogeneous space filled with a medium of index ne. Let us denote by Fe,n(r) the field radiated by the source Se,n. By construction, the fields Fe,n(r) satisfy Maxwell’s equations in e, and a radiation condition at infinity. If the coefficients ce,n are conveniently chosen, a linear combination ∑nce,n Fe,n(r) can thus be regarded as an approximation d u (r) of the diffracted field ud(r) in e, where ce,n can be understood as the complex amplitude of the source Se,n. So we obtain an approximation for the field in e: def N s
u d (r ) ∑ ce , n Fe , n (r ), n1
in e
(1.60)
and thus: Ns
u(r ) ui (r ) ∑ ce , n Fe , n (r),
in e
n1
(1.61)
In the same way, we imagine another set of fictitious sources Si,n (n 1, 2, …, Ns) located at Ns points ri,n in e and supposed to radiate in a space filled with a medium of index ni. Let us denote by Fi,n(r) the field radiated by the source Si,n. The functions Fi,n(r) satisfy Maxwell’s equations in i and can be used to get an approximate expansion uint(r) of the total field uint(r) in i: def N s
u int (r ) ∑ ci , n Fi , n (r ), n1
in i
(1.62)
where ci,n can be understood as the complex amplitude of the source Si,n. Note that the nature of the sources can be chosen arbitrarily. In our case, we choose infinitely thin line sources parallel to the z axis: Se,n(r) 4i (r re,n) and Si,n(r) 4i (r ri,n). In that case, they radiate the fields: Fe, n (r ) H 0(1) (ke |r re , n |)
(1.63)
Fi , n (r ) H 0(1) (ki |r ri , n |)
(1.64)
The determination of the coefficients ce,n and ci,n is accomplished by matching the boundary conditions on the cylinder surface 0. For a given function (r), let us denote by D (r) the value of its normal derivative on 0. The exact solution satisfies ui (r ) u d (r ) u int (r ) 0 Dui (r ) Du d (r ) pDu int (r ) 0
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
on 0 on 0
(1.65)
20
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
where p is a polarization-dependent constant equal to p 1 p (n / n )2 e i
in s-polarization case in p-polarization case
(1.66)
The coefficients ce,n and ci,n that give the best approximation for the fields given by Equations (1.60) and (1.62) are those that match the boundary conditions most satisfactorily. They are obtained by minimizing the two expressions V1 and V2 derived from Equation (1.65) and defined on 0: Ns Ns i (r ) V u c F ( r ) ∑ e, n e, n ∑ ci , n Fi , n (r) 1 n1 n1 Ns Ns V Dui (r ) c DF (r ) p c DF (r ) ∑ ∑ e, n e, n i,n i,n 2 n1 n1
(1.67)
This can be done in several ways. The simplest is to use a point-matching method that enforces the vanishing of these two expressions on sample points on 0. In this way, we can get a system of 2Ns equations for the 2Ns unknowns ce,n and ci,n. From our numerical experiments, it has emerged that it is preferable to use an overdetermined system and to solve it in the least-squares sense [24]. Thus, for a given computation time, we obtain a better approximation for ud and uint. Of course, the efficiency of the method depends on the locations and the number Ns of the fictitious sources. It can be shown that the precision of the method is related to the least-squares remainder obtained in the last step. This remainder can thus be used to quantify the quality of the solution, and this quantity is quite helpful in the numerical implementation. The interested reader will find more details in [11]. We have also developed some tricks in order to place the sources automatically. The general idea used in these tricks is to increase the density of sources in regions where the radius of curvature of 0 is lower. An example is given in Figure 1.6. The cross section of the cylinder 0 mimics a rounded F letter (first letter of Fresnel Institute), and it is given by the parametric equation z (t ) x (t ) iy(t )
∑
n5, 5
cn exp(in 2pt )
(1.68)
The values of the coefficients cn are given in the caption to Figure 1.6. We use Ns 200 sources in each region e and i, and 2Ns sample points on 0. This cylinder of index ni 1.5 lies in a vacuum (ne 1) and is illuminated with an incidence angle inc 45° by a plane wave of wavelength 0 2 and unit amplitude. Note that, contrary to Section 1.2, the angles are measured with respect to the x axis. Figure 1.7 gives the intensity D() scattered at infinity in the direction . Let us recall the definition of D() already given in Section 1.2. Due to the asymptotic
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
21
5
y axis
0
inc
−5
−5
0 x axis
5
FIGURE 1.6 Cross section of the cylinder and the two sets of sources. The profile is given by Equation (1.68) and the values c5 0.1134 i0.1310, c4 0.0297 i0.3238, c3 0.4117 i0.0973, c2 0.1260 i1.4149, c1 2.3936 i2.4031, c0 0.5714 i0.5000. c1 1.5568 i0.1876, c2 0.1212 i0.0197, c3 0.8158 i0.2155, c4 0.2772 i0.1039, c5 0.1532 i0.0102.
1000
Intensity at infinity D ()
s -polarization p -polarization 100
10
1
0.1 0
30
60
90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 Diffraction angle
FIGURE 1.7 Scattered intensity at infinity for both polarizations.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
22
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
8 6 4
y axis
2
0
inc
−2 −4 −6 −8
−8
−6
−4
−2
0 x axis
2
4
6
8
FIGURE 1.8 Modulus of the total field in p-polarization.
behavior of the Hankel function, the scattered field at infinity can be written from Equations (1.60 and 1.63) as: u d (r ) g(u)
exp(ike r )
(1.69)
r
and the intensity scattered at infinity is D(u) 2p|g(u)|2
(1.70)
Finally, Figure 1.8 shows the resultant field map in the vicinity of the scatterer.
1.3.4 IMPLEMENTATION
OF THE
SCATTERING MATRIX METHOD (SMM)
We apply the SMM to the N cylinders j, as shown in Figure 1.9. In order to lay the groundwork for section 1.3.5, we assume that the medium outside the cylinders has index ni defined in section 1.3.2. Contrary to our assumption in Section 1.2, we do not suppose here that the cylinders have a circular cross section. All the developments done in Section 1.2 are still valid, and the only difference is as follows. For any cylinder j, we consider a circle j with center Oj, in such a way that the cylinder is completely inside j (Figure 1.10). Via Equation (1.35), the SMM
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
23
Line source
ni
2 1
n2
3
n1 n3
FIGURE 1.9 A set of N 3 parallel cylinders in a medium with index ni, in which case the incident field is created by a line source. yj
j xj
Oj
y
j
x
O
FIGURE 1.10 Circle j surrounding the cylinder j and local coordinate system.
provides the set of coefficients bj,m that enables us to write the total field u everywhere outside the circles j: N
u( P ) u i ( P ) ∑
∑ b j , m H m(1) (ki rj (P)) exp(imu j (P))
(1.71)
j1 mZ
The consequence is that everywhere outside the circles j, the total field u and also its derivatives are known closed form from Equation (1.71).
1.3.5 HYBRID METHOD USING MFS AND SMM Let us come back to the original problem described in section 1.3.2. This problem can be solved by a slight modification of the method of fictitious sources described in section 1.3.3. Indeed, the scattered field can still be expressed as in Equation (1.60) using the same fictitious sources Se,n (line sources that radiate Fe,n(r) fields expressed as Hankel functions exactly as in Equation (1.63)). However, in that case, the Fi,n(r)
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
24
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals Si,n
ni
0 2 1 ni
3
FIGURE 1.11 Posing of the problem in order to get the functions Fi,n(r).
functions used to expand the field in i (inside 0) must be changed. Let us consider the problem depicted in Figure 1.11. The inclusions j are immersed in a medium with index ni (the boundary 0 of the external scatterer is suppressed). We keep the same line sources Si,n as in Section 1.3.3. The new function Fi,n(r) is the total field when the structure of Figure 1.11 is excited by the source Si,n. By solving this problem using the SMM as proposed in Section 1.3.4, Fi,n(r) can be expressed by the series provided by Equation (1.71). In other words, Fi,n(r) (n 1,2, … ,Ns) is a set of solutions for the total field inside 0 that are available in closed form and that can be used to expand the field in i following Equation (1.62). Using Equation (1.71), we can compute the value of Fi,n(r) and its normal derivative on 0 and get the righthand sides of Equation (1.67) to be minimized. This minimization gives the coefficients ce,n and ci,n, and we finally get the expressions of the total field in closed form everywhere using Equation (1.61) in e and Equation (1.62) in i.
1.3.6 NUMERICAL EXAMPLE Let us now illustrate the capabilities of the method by applying it to a concrete example. As in section 1.3.3, the cross section of the cylinder 0 is a letter F, but now with sharp edges. The reason for this choice is only to prove that the method also works pretty well in that case, which is more difficult to solve than a cylinder with rounded boundaries. All the coordinates of 0 corners in the (x, y) plane have integer values that can be deduced from Figure 1.12. The profile 0 is described by a series identical to Equation (1.68), but in this case we use a large number of cn coefficients (n 100, 100) in order to get a quasi-polygonal shape. This scatterer of index ni 1.5 lies in vacuum (ne 1). There are also four inclusions inside 0. The elliptical inclusion has principal axes with half dimensions equal to 1 and 0.5; its center is placed at coordinates (1, 4); its principal axes are rotated 45° away from the (x, y) axes; and it is made of infinitely conducting material. The rectangular inclusion is
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
25
10 8 6 4
y axis
2 0 −2 −4 inc
−6 −8 −10
−10
−8
−6
−4
−2
0 2 x axis
4
6
8
10
FIGURE 1.12 Modulus of the total field for a scatterer with four inclusions.
placed in the region 1.5 x 0.5 and 2 y 0 and is filled with vacuum. One of the circular inclusions has its center in (2,1) and a radius of 0.5, and it is filled with vacuum. The second circular inclusion has its center in (3,4), a radius of 0.5, and it is filled with a lossy material of optical index 0.5 2i (typical value for a metal in the optical range). This structure is illuminated with an incidence angle inc 45° by a plane wave of wavelength 0 2 and p-polarization. In that case, the number of sources in each region e and i is chosen to be Ns 500. The total Hz field map is shown in Figure 1.12. Note that the present version of our numerical code does not allow the computation of the field inside a circle that includes elliptical or rectangular bodies. This is why dark areas appear around these two inclusions.
1.4 DISPERSION RELATIONS OF BLOCH MODES In this section, we develop useful theoretical tools to understand and design the properties of devices based on photonic crystals. We summarize the properties of the propagating Bloch modes in infinite photonic crystals and pay special attention to the propagation of energy. Our aim is to predict the behavior of the finite structure from the knowledge of the properties of the infinite crystal. We then apply these tools to understand how a photonic crystal can behave as a homogeneous material with an optical index smaller than one (to illustrate ultrarefraction) or even with a negative optical index (to illustrate negative refraction). We consider
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
26
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals y
x
FIGURE 1.13 Finite-size two-dimensional photonic crystals made of a finite number of cylinders. The structures could be illuminated by an external beam. The coordinate system used is also represented.
two-dimensional photonic crystals made of a finite number of dielectric cylinders placed in a vacuum. The cylinders are assumed to be infinite along the z-axis (the coordinate system is defined in Figure 1.13).
1.4.1 INFINITE STRUCTURE We first review the properties of the allowed electromagnetic propagating modes in the infinite photonic crystal. Of course, if there are no such propagative modes for a frequency range we have detected a bandgap. We assume that the crystal fills the whole space and that there is no incident field. To be consistent with the previous parts, we consider two-dimensional problems. Consequently, two fundamental cases of polarization exist and the examples are given for the s-polarization case; that is, when the electric field is parallel to the cylinder axes. If the periodicity of the structure is defined by the vectors d1 and d2, then for any integer values of l and m: er (r ld1 md 2 ) er (r )
(1.72)
where r(r) is the relative permittivity. It is now well known that the allowed propagative modes in photonic crystals are Bloch modes (as for electrons in crystals). As in the previous parts we assume an exp(it) time dependence and use the usual complex amplitudes for harmonic fields. Thus, for any Bloch mode, the z-component of the electric field can be written in the form: uk (r ) exp(ik r )v(r )
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(1.73)
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
27
0.6
0.5
d /
0.4
0.3 ky
M (/a,/a)
0.2 kx
0.1
Γ
X
0.0 Γ
M
X
M
FIGURE 1.14 Dispersion relation of the Bloch modes in a photonic crystal made of dielectric cylinders with permittivity r 9 lying in a vacuum. The circular cross section of the cylinders has a radius equal to 0.475. The cylinders are arranged on a square lattice with periods d d1 d2 1.27. The field is s-polarized. The small insert represents the reduced first Brillouin zone.
where v(r) is a periodic function: v(r ld1 md 2 ) v(r )
(1.74)
and k is the Bloch wavevector, which is usually assumed to be real. Several methods are now available for calculating the dispersion relation (k) of the Bloch modes [7, 25–27]. Irrespective of the method used, one can obtain a dispersion diagram of the sort found in the literature, such as that shown in Figure 1.14 (the parameters of the structure are given in the figure caption). On this diagram, the normalized frequency d/(2c) d/0(d ||d1|| ||d2||) represented as a function of the Bloch wavevector k, whose termination point makes a path along the edges of the irreducible portion (see insert) of the first Brillouin zone of the crystal considered. For our purposes it is convenient to give a more complete representation of the dispersion relation as shown on Figure 1.15. Again the normalized frequency is plotted as a function of the Bloch wavevector, but now the full area of the first Brillouin zone is taken into account explicitly. Note that the diagram in Figure 1.14 is nothing but the intersection between the surfaces of Figure 1.15 and vertical planes passing through the edges of the irreducible portion of the first Brillouin zone (represented by the lines in the (kx, ky) plane).
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
28
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals 0.60 0.55 0.50 0.45 0.40
d/()
0.35 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0.00 0.0
2.0 1.5 0.5
1.0
1.0
0.5
1.5
Kx
2.0
Ky
0.0
FIGURE 1.15 Three-dimensional dispersion diagram. The parameters are identical to those of Figure 1.14. The lines in the (kx, ky) plane represent the reduced first Brillouin zone.
We consider now the frequency region just above the second bandgap. Figure 1.16 is an enlarged view of the dispersion relation in this region. Two bands represented by two surfaces on this figure exist: one that ascends and another that descends when the Bloch wavevector components increase. Let us now consider a harmonic problem, that is to say at a given frequency. The Bloch modes that can exist are given by the lines of intersection between the surfaces and the horizontal plane corresponding to this frequency. In our example we consider the plane corresponding to the value 0 2.545 (passing through the boundary between the two differently shaded regions on the surfaces of Figure 1.16). If we represent these intersections in the (kx, ky) plane and complete the diagram using the symmetries of the reciprocal lattice we obtain the constant frequency dispersion diagram of Figure 1.17. In order to study the transport of energy inside the crystal, let us recall a fundamental result linking the dispersion relation and the energy propagation [28,29]. For a given Bloch wave, we denote by Ve the averaged velocity of the energy flow (the average is taken over a lattice cell):
Ve
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
∫∫cell (Poynting vector) dr ∫∫cell (energy density) dr
(1.75)
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
29
0.53 0.52
d/()
0.51 0.50 0.49 0.48 0.47 0.46 0.0
2.0 0.5
1.5 1.0 K
1.0
1.5
x
0.5
2.0
Ky
0.0
FIGURE 1.16 Enlarged view of the three-dimensional dispersion diagram. ky
y
2.0
1.0
x −2.0
−1.0
Dispersion curves
1.0
2.0
kx
−1.0
−2.0
FIGURE 1.17 Constant-frequency dispersion diagram for 0 2.545. The arrows indicate the direction of the energy velocity for two specific Bloch waves.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
30
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
and by Vg the group velocity of the same Bloch wave, deduced from the dispersion relation (k) by: Vg grad k (v)
v v xˆ yˆ kx k y
(1.76)
The result is that Ve Vg
(1.77)
Thus, in Figure 1.17 the direction of Vg is perpendicular to the curves and points toward the ascending side of the sheets. Note that, of course, the direction of average phase velocity is given by k and its modulus is /||k||. Thus it can be completely different from the group velocity.
1.4.2 FINITE-SIZE PHOTONIC CRYSTALS We now show how we can use the dispersion relations of Bloch modes to predict or to design the properties of photonic crystal based devices. The key point is that the tangential component (in this case, the x-component) of the Bloch wavevector is conserved at the boundaries of a slice of photonic crystal. This result is rigorously satisfied for an infinite slice of photonic crystal along the x-axis [29,30]. Consider a crystal with finite thickness modeled as a stack of N grids. The structure is still infinite along the x-direction. Thus, each grid is equivalent to a grating, and we denote by d the period of this grating along the x axis. We assume that this crystal is illuminated by an incident plane wave: ui ( x , y) exp(iax iby)
(1.78)
As is well known, the total field u(x, y) is a pseudoperiodic function of x [31] with pseudoperiodicity coefficient ; that is: ua ( x d , y) exp(iad ) ua ( x , y)
(1.79)
In this case, it is possible to find a relationship between the allowed Bloch wavevector in the infinite photonic crystal and the pseudoperiodicity coefficient . A detailed explanation of this link is given in Reference [30]. Here, we only give the conclusion and a more intuitive interpretation. From Equation (1.73), a Bloch mode (in an infinite crystal) is characterized by the fact that the elementary translations ld1 md2 only give rise to phase shifts on the fields. As regards the grating case (crystal with finite thickness), the phase shift due to the first translation along the x-axis is automatically taken into account by the pseudoperiodicity. Equations (1.73) and (1.79) match when (1.80) k a x
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
31
Now, we assume that this crystal is illuminated by an arbitrary incident electromagnetic field. For instance, it can be excited by a localized source. Then, the relevant field component can be written as a Fourier integral: u ( x , y) ∫
uˆ (a, y) exp(iax )da
(1.81)
By splitting the integration interval ], [ into subintervals [(n (1/2))(2/d), (n 1/2))(2/d)], a simple change of variable leads to the alternative expression: u ( x , y) ∫
p/d
p/d
ua ( x , y)da
(1.82)
where the integrand ua ( x , y)
∑ uˆ ( a m 2dp , y ) exp ( i ( a m 2dp ) x )
(1.83)
m
is a pseudoperiodic function of x with pseudoperiodicity coefficient . Consequently, the study of the general field u(x, y) reduces to the study of its pseudoperiodic components u(x, y) for all values of in the first Brillouin zone [/d, /d] of the x-periodic problem. Then we are led to the geometric construction shown in Figure 1.18. The large circle is the constant frequency dispersion diagram of the surrounding medium (with radius /c, for example, for the vacuum) while the other curves represent the constant frequency dispersion diagram for the photonic crystal considered. Let us suppose that an incident plane wave illuminates a slice of this photonic crystal. We assume that the interfaces of the slice are perpendicular to the y-axis. If the angle of incidence of the plane wave is such that its wavevector ki is in the direction given by the solid line arrow (see Figure 1.18), then the tangential component of this wavevector is given by the vertical dashed line. Thus the two Bloch modes that can be excited in the crystal are given by the intersection of this line with the constant frequency dispersion diagram. Given the ascending nature of the surface corresponding to the central feature in Figure 1.18 (see Figure 1.15) the energy flows in the directions shown by the solid-line arrows (starting from the dispersion curves) in this case. Notice that to predict the field behavior in the illuminated crystal, we consider only the propagating Bloch modes. One should be aware of the empirical aspect of this hypothesis that neglects the evanescent solutions [32]. One knows that similar assumptions in grating theory can lead to erroneous results. Nevertheless, we will see that this method gives an interesting intuitive description of the energy flow in the crystal that proves to be in good agreement with our rigorous numerical checks.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
32
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
ky i
K
Circle: vacuum dispersion curve
kx
Crystal dispersion curves
FIGURE 1.18 Geometrical construction based on the conservation of the tangential components of the wave vector. The large circle with radius k0 /c represents the constant frequency dispersion diagram of the vacuum. The angle of incidence of the plane wave is 6.4° (represented by the arrow coming from the top of the figure). The two Bloch modes that can be excited are deduced from the conservation of the tangential component of the wave vector (vertical dashed line). The arrows represent the direction of the associated energy flows.
Figure 1.19 shows a map of the electric field modulus resulting from a rigorous numerical simulation using the scattering matrix method. A finite size photonic crystal made of 483 cylinders is illuminated by a limited Gaussian beam coming from the top of the figure. The exact definition of this incident field is: u i ( x , y) ∫
A(a) exp(iax ib(a)y)d a
(1.84)
with ()2 k02 2, and with a Gaussian amplitude: A(a)
(a a )2 W 2 0 exp 4 2 p W
(1.85)
The mean incidence angle 0 of the beam is such that 0 k0 sin 0. The parameter W appearing in Equation (1.85) is directly linked to the incident beam width.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
33
50 40 30 20 10 0 −10 −20 −30 −40 −50 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
20
30
40
50
FIGURE 1.19 Map of the electric field modulus for a photonic crystal made of 483 cylinders with the parameters of Figure 1.14. The crystal is illuminated by a Gaussian beam with mean angle of incidence 0 6.4° and W 10. The lines show the locus of the maximum of the beams.
The fringes above the crystal are due to interferences between the incident beam and the reflected beam on the first interface. The beam inside the photonic crystal propagates in the exact direction given by the previous geometrical construction. If we interpret this diagram in terms of Snell-Descartes laws, it corresponds to an effective optical index smaller than one. Let us now increase the angle of incidence such that the tangential component of the wavevector is given by the vertical dashed line in Figure 1.20. Then the two Bloch modes that can be excited are given by the intersections with the constant frequency dispersion diagram, but now the surfaces accessed ascend as one approaches the center of the diagram (see Figures 1.16 and 1.17), and the energy propagates as represented by the arrows. Figure 1.21 shows the electric field modulus map when a finite size photonic crystal is illuminated by a finite size beam and again inside the photonic crystal the energy propagates in the direction given by the geometrical construction. The refracted beam in the crystal behaves as in a homogeneous medium with negative optical index, which leads us to call this phenomenon negative refraction. Notice that for these Bloch modes the average energy velocity is almost the opposite of the average phase velocity and with a slight change of angle of incidence
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
34
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
ky
Ki
kx Crystal dispersion curves
FIGURE 1.20 Same as Figure 1.18 but with 0 40°. 50 40 30 20 10 0 −10 −20 −30 −40 −50 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
FIGURE 1.21 Same as Figure 1.19 but with 0 40°.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
20
30
40
50
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
35
these two velocities can be exactly opposite. This and the fact that negative refraction can be observed make the link with the so-called left-handed material, or double negative material, and also material with negative refractive index [33–37]. These are artificial materials that consist of periodic metallic structures (and can also be considered as metallic photonic crystals). These structures are actually the subject of intensive research and controversy. Several properties, such as their ability to focus even the evanescent waves to make a perfect lens, have been studied [35,37,38]. Their realization in the optical domain will be difficult because of the losses of the metals for optical wavelengths. Here, dielectric photonic crystals could be a valuable alternative. Note that negative refraction has been observed experimentally in a very nice experiment by Kosaka et al. [39].
1.5 THEORETICAL AND NUMERICAL STUDIES OF PHOTONIC CRYSTAL PROPERTIES 1.5.1 ULTRAREFRACTION WITH DIELECTRIC PHOTONIC CRYSTALS Ultrarefractive properties of photonic crystals have been suggested in previous papers [40]. We show here that the formalism described in the previous sections is well suited to determine the parameters that enable one to engineer devices based on this phenomenon (for instance, an ultrarefractive microlens). The aim is to design an artificial material whose effective index is less than 1 and if possible close to zero. This means that the constant-frequency dispersion diagram should follow a circle 2 k x2 k y2 k02 neff
(1.86)
That is, a small circle centered on the origin in the (kx, ky ) plane. In order to obtain this property, let us decrease the frequency associated with the horizontal intersection plane of Figure 1.16. The parameters of the photonic crystal are still those defined in the caption for Figure 1.14. Figure 1.22 shows the constant-frequency dispersion diagram for two wavelengths close to the kx ky 0 limit of the sheet of Figure 1.16. The curve for 0 2.56 is very close to a circle, and in this case the effective index given by Equation (1.86) is neff 0.086. Notice that even if the crystal behaves as a homogeneous material, the physical situation is very different from that generally studied in homogenization works where one considers quasi-static limits [41,42]. Since the index contrast with other materials is very large, new optical elements can be proposed. For instance, let us design a microlens composed of 295 rods of the same photonic crystal. The width of this lens is equal to 64 (i.e., 250), and the radius of curvature of the concave face is R 50. When illuminated by a Gaussian beam of width W 40 at normal incidence, the transmitted field focuses at a point situated at f 53 from the concave face (Figure 1.23). Notice that the same lens built from classical material (optical index greater than 1) is
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
36
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
0.4
0.3 ky
0 = 2.545
0.2
0 = 2.56
0.1
0.0 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
kx
FIGURE 1.22 Same as Figure 1.17 for two different wavelengths. Only the central region is presented.
divergent. On the sides of Figure 1.23, the field is principally due to the diffraction by the edges of the lens. A direct application of geometrical optics gives the focal length: f
1 R 54.7 1 neff
(1.87)
which agrees well with the actual value f 53 and demonstrates the very good similarity between the crystal and an isotropic homogeneous material. If the constant-frequency dispersion diagram does not look like a circle, then there is no clear focusing of the light.
1.5.2 ULTRAREFRACTION WITH METALLIC PHOTONIC CRYSTALS In this section we describe a theoretical and numerical work concerning a two-dimensional approach to the design of directive antennas. One of the aims is to obtain antennas that are much more compact than classical solutions. Another interesting feature is that these antennas can be excited by a single feeding device (patch, monopole). Such antennas could be useful for microwave telecommunications. The antenna presented here uses a metamaterial that is a composite stack of metallic grids and foam layers. This metamaterial is analyzed using the techniques
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
37
10 0 −10 −20 −30 −40 −50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
20
30
40
50
FIGURE 1.23 The microlens is illuminated in normal incidence configuration from the top by a Gaussian beam in s-polarization.
that we have developed in Section 1.4. Near the band edge, this material behaves as a homogeneous medium with low optical index (much less than unity). Under proper conditions, the energy radiated by a source embedded inside the structure is concentrated in a narrow emission lobe. Based on this analysis, we have built a device working in the microwave domain: a ground plane is covered by the metamaterial, with a monopole source embedded inside. The experimental measurements are in good agreement with the theoretical predictions [43]. How can we apply the results of Section 1.4 to the design of directive sources? The aim is to realize a device that radiates energy in a very narrow angular range. Our objective is to embed a localized source inside a metamaterial (that is in fact a photonic crystal) and to restrict the radiated field inside a small angular range centered around the yˆ direction. Equation (1.81) implies that in the homogeneous medium outside the crystal any radiated field can be expressed as a sum of plane waves. In this sum, directive radiation requires that the plane waves with significant amplitude should correspond to small values of (let us assume [max, max]). Then, from Equation (1.80), the allowed Bloch modes of the photonic crystal should lay inside the region kx [max, max]. In Figure 1.24, we represent the dispersion curve of the homogeneous medium outside the crystal. We assume that this medium is vacuum and this curve is the circle defined by k2x ky2 k02. The angular range around the vertical direction provides the value of max. This means that the
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
38
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals Allowed propagation directions outside the metamaterial ky Vacuum dispersion curve circle with radius kx2 + ky2 = k02
Dispersion curve of the meta material radius k0 neff −max
max
kx
FIGURE 1.24 Schematic construction linking the propagation direction outside a photonic crystal with the Bloch wave vector.
curves corresponding to the Bloch modes in the constant-frequency dispersion diagram should lay inside the region between the two dashed lines in Figure 1.24. We are now concerned with the problem of finding a photonic crystal whose constant-frequency dispersion diagram is entirely included in this region. This property can be obtained by using a metallic photonic crystal. It is well known that a periodic set of parallel metallic wires has filtering properties for low frequencies and for s-polarization. This means that there exists a full bandgap for low frequencies. For frequencies slightly higher than the cutoff, the constant-frequency dispersion diagram is then a small curve in the (kx, ky) plane. The structure is modeled as a stack of metallic grids made of infinitely conducting wires. The infinitely conducting metal is indeed a reliable approximation in the range of wavelengths of interest. Let us now turn to a model directly linked with the experimental study that we have done. In the experimental structure, we found it convenient to make the grids by etching a thin copper plate. Consequently, the cross section of the wires is not a circle but a rectangle. After optimization of the parameters in order to match fabrication constraints and to get interesting properties around 14 GHz, it appears that convenient parameters are the following: the cross section of the metallic wires is 0.014 cm wide along the y axis and 0.071 cm wide along the x axis, dx 0.58 cm, dy 0.63 cm. This study is achieved using the SMM. Figure 1.25 shows the modulus and the lines of equal phase of the total field radiated by the structure made with 40 6 of these wires above a ground plane located at y 0. The source is a wire antenna parallel to the z axis and placed in the middle of the metamaterial with a working vacuum wavelength 0 2.07 cm. The most striking fact is the very slow variation of the phase inside the metamaterial, which is a proof that the effective index in this material is quite small. Notice that the phase of the emitted field is nearly constant on planes parallel to the emitting surface. The radiation pattern exhibits a narrow lobe (Figure 1.26) with a half-power beamwidth of 2 3.8°.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
39
80 60 40 20 −100
−50
0
50
100
150
−100
−50
0
50
100
150
80 60 40 20
FIGURE 1.25 Field modulus (top) and lines of equal phase (bottom) of the field radiated by the 2D antenna.
90 120
60
30
20
150
30
10
0
180
0
FIGURE 1.26 Radiation pattern for the device of Figure 1.25 (dB scale). The half-power beamwidth is 2 3.8°.
1.5.3 NEGATIVE REFRACTION GALLERIES
BY A
DIELECTRIC SLAB RIDDLED WITH
Metamaterials and negative refraction are the subjects of considerable attention due to their attractive potential applications, such as the controversial perfect lens proposed by Pendry [35–38]. In the microwave range, some solutions are proposed that use metallo-dielectric arrays of split-ring resonators and wires [34]. For
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
40
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals 0.8
d/2c
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
X
Γ
J
X
FIGURE 1.27 Dispersion diagram of a hexagonal photonic crystal for both s-polarization (heavy lines) and p-polarization (lighter lines).
applications in optics, the losses inherent to metals are unavoidable. As shown in Section 1.4, dielectric photonic crystals can also produce negative refraction. In the same way as before, we can use the dispersion diagrams of Bloch modes in order to find suitable parameters. Let us consider the case of a dielectric slab periodically drilled with air holes. According to the notation of Section 1.3, the permittivity of the slab is n2i 12; the radius of the holes is 0.294; and they are placed with hexagonal symmetry. The distance between the centers of two neighboring holes is equal to d 0.68. The dispersion diagram of this photonic crystal is plotted in Figure 1.27. The oblique straight line is the light line ck0. This line intersects the second s-polarized band for d/(2c) 0.337, that is, 0 2.02. Figure 1.28 shows the constant frequency dispersion diagram at this wavelength. The curve is almost a circle and simulates a homogeneous material with optical index neff 1, at least for propagative waves. Let us now consider a finite structure: a finite slab whose faces are defined by x 13.944 and y 2.6996 (see Figure 1.29) is drilled with 364 circular air holes. The structure lies in vacuum and is illuminated by a Gaussian beam coming from the top with an incidence angle 0 30° (see Equation (1.84)) and W 5. Figure 1.29 shows the resulting field map and the negative refraction inside the crystal. In order to show the focusing capabilities of such a device, let us assume that the structure is excited by a point source located at (x 0, y 5.4). The resulting field map is shown in Figure 1.30. It is clear that a focus spot appears below the crystal. Obviously, this lens is not perfect: the transmitted energy is weak, and the width of the focus spot is exactly 0 /2. The improvement of this aspect would require a control of the evanescent waves in order to restore their amplitude in the image.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
41
ky
3
2
1
0 0
1
2
3
4
kx
FIGURE 1.28 Constant frequency dispersion diagram at 0 2.02 for the photonic crystal in s-polarization (solid line), and for the vacuum (dashed line). The arrows give the direction of Vg in both cases. 15
10
5
0
−5
−10
−15 −15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
FIGURE 1.29 Modulus of the total field. Above the slab, the black line shows the locus of the maximum of the Gaussian incident beam. Below the slab, it shows the locus of the maximum of the transmitted field. Above the slab, the structure of the field is due to the interference between the incident and the reflected fields.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
42
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals 15
10
5
0
−5
−10
−15 −15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
FIGURE 1.30 Modulus of the total field when the slab of Figure 1.29 is illuminated by a point source.
1.6 CONCLUSION It has been shown that the scattering matrix method is a valuable tool for the numerical study of finite-size photonic crystals. It is especially efficient when the shape of the objects is circular (2D crystals) or spherical (3D crystals) because in those cases half of the calculation (determination of the scattering matrices) can be made in closed form, contrary to the classical general methods. Another feature of the method is that it is based on a detailed physical analysis of the multiscattering phenomena occurring between the objects, the Graf formula being the mathematical tool that conciliates the rigor and the simplicity. In this chapter, the solution is obtained through the inversion of a matrix, the size of which increases with the number of objects. Thus, there is a limitation on the number of objects that can be handled. For 2D photonic crystals, a number of cylinders of the order of 1,000 can typically be treated using a simple personal computer. Nevertheless, it is possible to avoid a direct inversion by using iterative methods (see for example Reference 3). The combination of the scattering matrix method with the method of fictitious sources permits a significant extension of the domain of application of the first method. For example, it permits dealing with the case in which the set of cylinders is surrounded by a jacket. Thanks to this extension, it is possible to deal with some important applications of photonic crystals: in particular, photonic
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
43
crystal fibers and microstructured optical fibers surrounded by a jacket and photonic crystal slabs. Finally, it has been shown that the notions of Bloch waves and their corresponding dispersion curves allows one to understand and predict the surprising phenomena generated by photonic crystals. Nowadays great attention is paid to phenomena arising near the edge of the photonic bandgaps, such as ultrarefraction and negative refraction. In these phenomena, it is necessary to distinguish the notions of phase and group velocities. It is very important to know whether or not the dielectric photonic crystals that generate negative refraction phenomena are left-handed materials and if they can amplify the evanescent waves. Indeed, a positive answer to this question could lead to a breakthrough: the realization of lenses more powerful than classical lenses in the visible region.
REFERENCES [1] Lord Rayleigh, On the influence of obstacles arranged in rectangular order upon the properties of a medium, Philos. Mag., 34, 481–502, 1892. [2] W.C. Chew, L. Gürel, Y.M. Wang, G. Otto, R.L. Wagner, and Q.H. Liu, A generalized recursive algorithm for wave-scattering solutions in two dimensions, IEEE Trans. on Microwave Theory and Techniques, 40, 716–723, 1992. [3] M. Defos du Rau, Electromagnetic diffusion in heterogeneous dense media: presentation of a hybrid model for the study of heterogeneous materials, PhD dissertation, Bordeaux University, Bordeaux, France, 1997. [4] A.Z. Elsherbeni and A. Kishk, Modeling of cylindrical objects by circular dielectric and conducting cylinders, IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, 40, 96–99, 1992. [5] D. Felbacq, G. Tayeb, and D. Maystre, Scattering by a random set of parallel cylinders, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 11, 2526–2538, 1994. [6] D. Felbacq, Theoretical and numerical study of light scattering by a set of parallel rods, PhD dissertation, University of Aix-Marseille III, Marseille, France, 1994. [7] N.A. Nicorovici, R.C. McPhedran, and L.C. Botten, Photonic band gaps for arrays of perfectly conducting cylinders, Phys. Rev. E, 52, 1135–1145, 1995. [8] M. Vlassis, R.C. McPhedran, and N.A. Nicorovici, Radiation modes of multiple core fibres, Opt. Comm., 129, 256–272, 1996. [9] H.A. Youssif and S. Köhler, Scattering by two penetrable cylinders at oblique incidence: Part 1. The analytical solution, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 5, 1085–1096, 1988. [10] M. Abramovitz and I. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions, Dover Publications, New York, 1970. [11] D. Maystre, M. Saillard, and G. Tayeb. Special methods of wave diffraction, in P. Sabatier and E.R. Pike, eds., Scattering, Academic Press, London, 2001. [12] G. Tayeb, R. Petit, and M. Cadilhac, Synthesis method applied to the problem of diffraction by gratings: the method of fictitious sources, Proceedings of the International Conference on the Application and Theory of Periodic Structures, J.M. Lerner and W.R. McKinney eds., Proc. SPIE 1545, 95–105, 1991. [13] G. Tayeb, The method of fictitious sources applied to diffraction gratings, Special Issue on Generalized Multipole Techniques (GMT) of App. Computational Electromagnetics Soc. J., 9, 90–100, 1994.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
44
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
[14] F. Zolla., R. Petit, and M. Cadilhac, Electromagnetic theory of diffraction by a system of parallel rods: the method of fictitious sources, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 11, 1087–1096, 1994. [15] F. Zolla and R. Petit, Method of fictitious sources as applied to the electromagnetic diffraction of a plane wave by a grating in conical diffraction mounts, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 13, 796–802, 1996. [16] Y. Leviatan and A. Boag, Analysis of electromagnetic scattering from dielectric cylinders using a multifilament current model, IEEE Trans. Ant. Prop., AP-35, 1119–1127, 1987. [17] A. Boag, Y. Leviatan, and A. Boag, Analysis of two-dimensional electromagnetic scattering from a periodic grating of cylinders using a hybrid current model, Radio Science, 23, 612–624, 1988. [18] A. Boag, Y. Leviatan, and A. Boag, Analysis of diffraction from echelette gratings, using a strip-current model, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 6, 543–549, 1989. [19] A. Boag, Y. Leviatan, and A. Boag, Analysis of electromagnetic scattering from doubly-periodic nonplanar surfaces using a patch-current model, IEEE Trans. Ant. Prop., AP-41, 732–738, 1993. [20] C. Hafner, The Generalized Multipole Technique for Computational Electromagnetics, Artech House Books, Boston, 1990. [21] C. Hafner, Multiple multipole program computation of periodic structures, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 12, 1057–1067, 1995. [22] V.D. Kupradze, On the approximate solution of problems in mathematical physics, original (Russian): Uspekhi Mat. Nauk, 22, 59–107, 1967. English translation: Russian Mathematical Surveys 22, 58–108, 1967. [23] D. Kaklamani and H. Anastassiu, Aspects of the method of auxiliary sources (MAS) in computational electromagnetics, IEEE Ant. and Prop. Magazine 44, no. 3, 48–64, June 2002. [24] W. Press, B. Flannery, S. Teukolsky, and W. Vetterling, Numerical Recipes in Fortran: The Art of Scientific Computing, (2nd ed.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1992. [25] R.D. Meade, A.M. Rappe, K.D. Brommer, J.D. Joannopoulos, and O.L. Alerhand, Accurate theoretical analysis of photonic band-gap material, Phys. Rev. B, 48, 8434–8437, 1993. [26] A. Moroz, Density-of-states calculations and multiple-scattering theory for photons, Phys. Rev. B, 51, 2068–2087, 1995. [27] B. Gralak, S. Enoch, and G. Tayeb, From scattering or impedance matrices to Bloch modes of photonic crystals, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 19, 1547–1554, 2002. [28] P. Yeh, Electromagnetic propagation in birefringent layered media, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 69, 742–756, 1979. [29] B. Gralak, Etude théorique et numérique des propriétés des structures à bandes interdites photoniques, PhD dissertation, Université d’Aix-Marseille III, Marseille, France, 2001. [30] B. Gralak, S. Enoch, and G. Tayeb, Anomalous refractive properties of photonic crystals, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 17, 1012–1020, 2000. [31] R. Petit, Electromagnetic Theory of Gratings, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1980. [32] D. Felbacq and R. Smaâli, Bloch modes dressed by evanescent waves and the generalized Goos-Hänchen effect in photonic crystals, Phys. Rev. Lett., 92, 193902, 2004. [33] V.G. Veselago, The electrodynamics of substance with simultaneously negative values of and , Sov. Phys. Uspekhi, 10, 509–514, 1968.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Scattering Matrix Method Applied to Photonic Crystals
45
[34] R.A. Shelby, D.R. Smith, and S. Schultz, Experimental verification of negative index refraction, Science, 292, 77–79, 2001. [35] J.B. Pendry, Negative refraction makes a perfect lens, Phys. Rev. Lett., 85, 3966–3969, 2000. [36] P.M. Valanju, R.M. Walser, and A.P. Valanju, Wave refraction in negative-index media: always positive and very inhomogeneous, Phys. Rev. Lett., 88, 187401, 2002. [37] N. Garcia and M. Nieto-Vesperinas, Left-handed materials do not make a perfect lens, Phys. Rev. Lett., 88, 207403, 2002. [38] D. Maystre and S. Enoch, Perfect lenses made with left-handed materials: Alice’s mirror? J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 21, 122–131, 2004. [39] H. Kosaka, T. Kawashima, A. Tomita, M. Notomi, T. Tamamura, T. Sato, and S. Kawakami, Superprism phenomena in photonic crystals, Phys. Rev. B, 58, 10096–10099, 1998. [40] J.P Dowling and C.M. Bowden, Anomalous index of refraction in photonic bandgap materials, J. Mod. Opt., 41, 345–351, 1994. [41] R.C. McPhedran, N.A. Nicorovici, and L.C. Botten, The TEM mode and homogenization of doubly periodic structures, J. Electrom. Waves and Appl., 11, 981–1012, 1997. [42] D. Felbacq and G. Bouchitté, Homogenization of a set of parallel fibers, Waves in Random Media, 7, 245–256, 1997. [43] S. Enoch, G. Tayeb, P. Sabouroux, N. Guérin, and P. Vincent, A metamaterial for directive emission, Phys. Rev. Lett., 89, 213902, 2002.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Multipole Methods 2 From to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling Lindsay C. Botten, Ross C. McPhedran, C. Martijn de Sterke, Nicolae A. Nicorovici, Ara A. Asatryan, Geoffrey H. Smith, Timothy N. Langtry, Thomas P. White, David P. Fussell, and Boris T. Kuhlmey
CONTENTS 2.1 Introduction ................................................................................................48 2.2 Multipole Theory for Finite and Infinite Structures ..................................51 2.2.1 General Framework ......................................................................51 2.2.2 Field Representation ......................................................................52 2.2.3 Rayleigh Field Identity ..................................................................55 2.2.4 Field Coupling and Continuity Conditions....................................58 2.2.5 Field Problem of Microstructured Optical Fibers ........................60 2.2.6 Infinite Periodic Structures ............................................................62 2.2.7 Gratings..........................................................................................68 2.3 Multipole Modeling of Photonic Crystal Fibers ........................................73 2.3.1 Background ....................................................................................73 2.3.2 Guiding Mechanisms and the “Finger Diagram” ..........................73 2.3.3 Implementation of the Multipole Method ....................................75 2.3.4 Effective Index-Guided Modes......................................................76 2.3.5 Air-Guided Modes ........................................................................80 2.4 Radiation Dynamics and the Local Density of States................................82 2.4.1 Background ....................................................................................82 2.4.2 2D Green Tensor and LDOS ........................................................83 2.4.3 2.5D Green Tensor and LDOS ......................................................86 2.5 Bloch Mode Analysis of Composite PC Devices ......................................92 2.5.1 Background and Nomenclature ....................................................92 47
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
48
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
2.5.2 2.5.3 2.5.4 2.5.5
Formulation of the Eigenvalue Problem........................................95 Calculation of Band Diagrams and Band Surfaces ......................97 Classification of the Eigenvalues ................................................100 Defect Mode Modeling of Extended Photonic Crystal Devices ........................................................................................104 2.5.6 Interfacing Photonic Crystal Media and Fresnel Coefficients ..................................................................................105 2.5.7 Recursively Combining PC Stack Segments ..............................107 2.6 Modeling of Photonic Crystal Devices ....................................................108 2.6.1 Background ..................................................................................108 2.6.2 Straight PC Waveguides ..............................................................109 2.6.3 Resonant Filters and Junctions ....................................................110 2.6.4 Mach–Zehnder Interferometer ....................................................114 2.7 Discussion and Conclusions ....................................................................116 Acknowledgment ..............................................................................................119 References ........................................................................................................119
2.1 INTRODUCTION The scattering of waves of all types (electromagnetic, acoustic, matter, etc.) is one of the fundamental problems of physics. The field has a long and rich literature with contributions from many prominent physicists. Lord Rayleigh [1] was one of the early initiators of a systematic mathematical analysis of wave scattering and was the first to derive a rigorous solution to the problem of wave scattering from cylindrical structures — a theory that spawned a class of methods that has been particularly successful. These methods are variously referred to as Rayleigh or multipole methods, with the latter term reflecting the structure and basis of the field expansions that are strongly tailored to the geometry and the form of the scatterers. Consequently, such methods have received wide attention because of their computational efficiency and accuracy as well as their analytic tractability. This class of methods dates back to the classic 1892 paper by Rayleigh [2], in which he developed a method for solving electrostatic problems for lattices of spheres or arrays of cylinders. At the time, Rayleigh was aiming to demonstrate the limits of the validity of the Lorentz–Lorenz equation — a fundamental equation of optics that provides a bridge between the microscopic/atomic model of materials, and the continuous model of a homogeneous isotropic dielectric through which an electromagnetic wave propagates. Through the multipole model, Rayleigh showed that the Lorentz–Lorenz equation was a dipolar approximation and was able to exhibit higher order corrections. The essential feature of any multipole method is the application of an ingenious field identity that relates the regular field in the vicinity of any scatterer to fields radiated by other scatterers and external sources. While its origins lie in
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
49
electrostatics and periodic systems, the technique has evolved to become an important tool for dynamic problems in a range of fields involving both finite and periodic systems — in particular, in electromagnetism, solid state physics, and solid mechanics. Largely, however, its widespread computational application has occurred only since the mid-1970s when computers of sufficient power allowed its full potential to be realized. Among the milestones of the method is the work of Ignatowsky (1914) [3] who considered the scattering of plane waves from two-dimensional gratings, and Wait [4] who first generalized the treatment to three dimensions in 1955. The multipole method has been used extensively in solid-state physics through the work of Korringa [5], and Kohn and Rostoker [6], who separately formulated what is now known as the KKR method and used it to calculate the band structure of solids. Applications of this approach to electromagnetism also have been developed [7]. A key feature of the application of multipole methods to periodic systems is the appearance of lattice sums, namely sums of multipole terms, evaluated at each lattice point of the structure, characterizing the scattering contribution of the entire lattice to each multipole term. Their evaluation is an important and highly subtle aspect of the method, with difficulties in their evaluation arising through the occurrence of conditionally convergent series. Thus, there has been much research devoted to the development of efficient and accurate methods for their calculation. Among the pioneers of this field is Twersky [8], who derived the first closed form expressions for grating lattice sums. Unlike the earlier Ewald summation methods [9], the accuracy of which can be questionable, Twersky-type methods may be accelerated by a range of techniques [10] to yield well-conditioned and accurate sums. Our group has also demonstrated relationships [11] between the lattice sums of a two-dimensional (2D) array and a one-dimensional (1D) grating that are computationally advantageous, and that can be extended to higher dimensions and different lattice geometries. Our particular interest in multipole methods derives from recent research in photonic crystals [12–14], including microstructured optical fibers [15–17], the study of the radiation properties of sources embedded in such structures [18], and the design of complex/composite devices (e.g., splitters, couplers, interferometers, etc.) constructed in photonic crystals [19]. Such structures form a strongly scattering environment due to the high material contrast and the scale and geometry of the structure. Accordingly, approximate methods, such as the Born approximation, and the coherent potential approximation, are not applicable, while the Feynman diagram method is computationally too cumbersome. Because of this, the electromagnetic research community has developed a wide range of modeling tools including the plane wave method [20], the finite-difference time domain (FDTD) method [21], differential and boundary integral methods [22], the finite element method [23], and multipole methods [24–27]. The bulk of these are omnibus, computational methods that handle the full generality of problems. For particular geometrical configurations and symmetries, however, a technique such as the multipole method has much to offer, in that it can analytically preserve symmetry, and exploit the natural basis of functions for the scatterers (e.g., cylindrical
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
50
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
harmonic functions for cylindrical scatterers). Accordingly, this can yield important physical insight into the scattering processes not otherwise possible with purely numerical methods. The implementation of the method is both efficient and accurate, and can avoid numerical artifacts by explicitly embedding the symmetry of the structure within the formulation. The sole proviso is that one is able to construct a suitable basis of multipole functions for the particular scatterer geometry. This chapter is built around the role of the multipole method in three paradigm applications: • Microstructured optical fibers, in which we show that the multipole theory answers fundamental questions about the symmetry of modes and facilitates the most accurate calculations of losses in such fibers (Section 2.3) • Studies of the radiation dynamics of 2D and 3D sources embedded in finite 2D photonic crystals, for which the multipole method analytically avoids problems in the calculation of the local density of states (LDOS) associated with the divergence of Green’s function at source points, and leads to highly accurate and efficient calculations of the LDOS and the Lamb shift (Section 2.4) • Scattering matrix methods for solving propagation problems in extended photonic crystal devices that exploit the natural Bloch mode basis, yielding design tools that are accurate and efficient, and that simultaneously provide substantial insight into the propagation mechanisms by mapping the analysis onto familiar concepts of thin film optics (Sections 2.5 and 2.6). The last of these applications is based on transfer matrix methods that model the structure as a stack of gratings, the scattering matrices for which rely on efficient and accurate computation using multipole techniques. Throughout this chapter we work with cylindrical structures, and in Section 2.2 we provide an integrated tutorial on the multipole method, commencing with the analysis of a single scatterer and its extension to a finite cluster. We treat the problem in both 2D and 3D, and go on to develop the theory for calculating the modes of microstructured optical fibers (MOFs). We extend the theory of finite clusters to allow for a 2D (line) source and further extend this in Section 2.4 to consider a point dipole source, thus enabling the study of the radiation dynamics of PC clusters. Section 2.2 also develops the multipole theory of periodic structures considering 1D cylinder gratings and the 2D crossed layers that constitute a woodpile PC, and focuses on the calculation of the plane wave scattering matrices that underpin the later Bloch mode analysis of PC devices. Section 2.3 builds on the theoretical introduction and goes on to survey some of our recent work in the area of photonic crystal fibers including the implementation of the method, guiding mechanisms in both air-cored and conventional dense-cored MOFs, the calculation of losses, and the development of the phase diagram that characterizes modal cutoff.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
51
Section 2.4 is concerned with the calculation of the local density of states in 2D and 2.5D photonic crystals. Here, the term 2.5D refers to a 3D (point) source located in a 2D photonic crystal (with infinitely long scatterers). We show the strong suppression of the local density of states (LDOS) for both polarizations in 2D photonic crystals for gap wavelengths, while for the 2.5D modeling the achievable suppression of the LDOS, relative to its free space value, is more modest. Section 2.5 builds on our experience with diffraction grating formulations to develop transfer matrix methods for computing Bloch modes in PC devices. The nature of the resulting eigensystem is closely analyzed, and important modal reciprocity and orthogonality properties are derived. Fresnel reflection and transmission scattering matrices, the analogues of the Fresnel coefficient of thin films, are introduced to characterize propagation across an interface and are used to build the general theory of propagation in extended PC devices that closely mirrors the corresponding theory in thin film optics. Finally, in Section 2.6 we make use of the tools of Section 2.5 to design a range of compact and efficient PC devices including the “folded” directional coupler, an efficient Y-splitter, and its application to the design of a Mach–Zehnder interferometer. A feature of this section is its focus on the key role of the photonic crystal in their design.
2.2 MULTIPOLE THEORY FOR FINITE AND INFINITE STRUCTURES 2.2.1 GENERAL FRAMEWORK The purpose of this section is to develop a general framework that enables us to handle the gamut of field problems for cylinder photonic crystals and finite photonic clusters, in both two and three dimensions, using the multipole method. In particular, we outline, in a systematic and integrated manner, the key steps that allow us to formulate the solution of a diverse variety of scattering problems in a unified framework. Before commencing the detailed derivation of the theory, we begin by setting in place some of the key nomenclature used in this chapter. In the 2D problems we consider, the cylinder axes are aligned with the z axis; however, we also allow alignment parallel to the x axis to form a woodpile structure comprising crossed 1D grating layers. We must also allow for general conical incidence characterized by an incident wave vector k0 (k0x, k0y, k0z), with k0z 0. In z-invariant environments in which both the structure and the field sources are two dimensional (i.e., infinitely extended in the z-direction) we may prescribe the z-dependence of various physical quantities to be exp(ik0zz). The complete geometry is defined by the dielectric function (r). In the context of a plane wave of wavelength l incident from free space with polar angle w and azimuthal angle c, we may set k0 kf (sin w cos c, sin w sin c, cos w) where kf 2p/l v/c is the free space wavenumber, assuming a harmonic time dependence of exp(ivt). In source-free regions, the Maxwell curl equations can be used to express the transverse components of the electromagnetic field (i.e., those perpendicular to
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
52
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
the cylinder axes) in terms of the longitudinal field components Ez and Kz [28]. Thus, Et
i [k E k f zˆ K z ], k⊥2 0 z z
Kt
i [k e(r )zˆ Ez k0 z K z ] k⊥2 f
(2.1)
2 with k2 k2f (r) k2 k0z . For convenience, we introduce a rescaled magnetic —— field K Z0H, where Z0 m0/0 377 is the free space impedance. With this transformation, Kz has the dimension of an electric field. Then, by writing each of the longitudinal components in the form
Ez V E exp(ik0 z z ),
K z V K exp(ik0z z )
(2.2)
it can be shown using Maxwell’s equations that the scalar “potentials” VE and VK each must satisfy a Helmholtz equation [2 k⊥2 (r )]V 0
(2.3)
where k2 k2f (r) k20z . Here, (r) denotes the relative permittivity, which is related to the refractive index n(r) by (r) n 2(r). Equations (2.2) give the general form of the longitudinal fields in an environment in which the structure is z-invariant and the field sources (and resulting fields) have a harmonic longitudinal dependence exp(ik0z). In Section 2.4, which looks at the effect of a photonic crystal environment on the emission from line or point sources, it is necessary to generalize the field representation to take into account both structural invariance in the z-direction and the z-variation of the source. In this case, we must express Ez and Kz in a Fourier integral form
Ez (r , z ) ∫ V E (r , k0 z )eik0 z z dk0 z ,
K z (r ,z ) ∫ V K (r , k0 z )eik0 z z dk0 z
(2.4)
thus allowing us to treat scattering problems involving localized sources.
2.2.2 FIELD REPRESENTATION Here we develop the representation of the electromagnetic fields in the scattering problem involving a finite cluster of nontouching cylinders (Figure 2.1[a]), with the physical structure, sources, and fields being invariant in the z-direction. We begin in a simple manner, deriving the fields in the vicinity of a single cylinder Cl in order to understand the physical origin of the various terms. In the region exterior to Cl (Figure 2.1[b]), the field quantity V (i.e., either—— V E or—— V K) satisfies 2 e 2 e 2 2 the Helmholtz equation [ (k) ]V 0, where k k f e k20z denotes the transverse wavenumber applicable to the (exterior) background region of
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
53
A Cl r
rj
rl
s rs
Cext
o (a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.1 (a) The geometry of a cluster of cylinders, (b) the integration contour for Green’s theorem in Equation (2.6).
refractive index ne. This leads us to introduce the Green function satisfying the inhomogeneous equation [r2 (k⊥e )2 ] G0 (r; r ′) d(r r ′)
(2.5)
the solution of which is G0(r; r ) iH0(ke |r r |)/4. Here, and throughout this chapter, we will denote the Hankel functions of the first kind Hn(1) by Hn, to simplify the notation. Applying Green’s theorem to the domain A of Figure 2.1(b) bounded by the perimeter Cl of the cylinder and the exterior boundary Cext
∫ A [V (r ′)r2′G0 (r; r ′) G0 (r; r ′)r2′V (r ′)] dAr′
∂ ∂ V (r ) ∫ V (r ′) G0 (r; r ′) G0 (r; r ′) V (r ′) dsr′ ∂A ∂r ′ ∂r ′
(2.6)
we see that V(r) can be expressed as the sum of two line integrals, respectively, around Cl and Cext. With the field point r located in A between the two boundaries, we note that when the source point r Cl then |r rl| |r rl|, while for r Cext then |r rl| |r rl|. This has a profound effect on the representation of the Green function when expanded using Graf’s addition theorem [29] to change the origin of coordinates to rl, the center of Cl. That is, G0 (r; r ′)
1 4i
n
1 4i
∑
∑
H n (k⊥e |r rl |) Jn (k⊥e |r ′ rl |)ein[arg(rrl )arg(r′rl )]
(2.7)
Jn (k⊥e |r rl |) H n (k⊥e |r ′ rl |)ein[arg(rrl )arg(r′rl )]
(2.8)
for r Cl, and G0 (r; r ′)
n
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
54
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
for r Cext. Accordingly, the contributions to V(r) due to the integrals around the inner (Cl) and outer (Cext) contours are expanded respectively, in multipole e series comprising outgoing wave (Hn(k |r rl|) exp(in arg(r rl))) and standing e wave (Jn(k|r rl|) exp(in arg(r rl))) terms. Thus, Vl E (r ) Vl K (r )
∑
[ AnE ,l Jn (k⊥e |r rl |) BnE ,l H n (k⊥e |r rl |)] ein arg(rrl )
(2.9)
[ AnK ,l Jn (k⊥e |r rl |) BnK ,l H n (k⊥e |r rl |)] ein arg(rrl )
(2.10)
n
∑
n
While at first sight the results of Equations (2.9) and (2.10) may appear obvious and little more than the general solution of the Helmholtz equation, the above analysis is significant in that it points to the local and global representations of the field. Firstly, the representations (2.9) and (2.10) are valid provided that Cext contains only a single cylinder (or source). From this we may deduce that a sufficient condition for the validity and convergence of what we call the local expansions about Cl is that r lies in an annulus bounded by Cl and the largest contour Cext that does not intersect with any other source or cylinder. Secondly, the derivation identifies the respective sources of the field — with outgoing (Hankel H) waves emanating from Cl and with standing (Bessel J) waves being sourced on Cext. As we now show, this generalizes immediately to give rise to what is known as the Wijngaard expansion [30] — the global representation of the field that converges everywhere in the domain A. We thus consider the field problem of Figure 2.2 associated with a set of Nc cylinders located at positions rl and an explicit z-invariant line source at rs. Again using Green’s theorem, this time with the area A defined by the c interior of the region bounded by A C0 ∪ Cs ∪lN1 Cl (Figure 2.2), we deduce Nc
V E (r ) ∑
∑ BnE ,l Hn (k⊥e |r rl |)ein arg(rr ) W E (r) S E (r) l
(2.11)
l1 n
together with a corresponding expression for VK. Here, W E (r )
∑
n
AnE , 0 Jn (k⊥e |r|)ein arg(r )
(2.12)
is the field due to sources exterior to C0, and SE(r) is the contribution to the field due to the line source, where S E (r )
Cs
G0 (r; r ′) ∂ V E (r ′) V E (r ′) ∂ G0 (r; r ′) dsr′ ∂r ′ ∂r ′
(2.13)
and Cs is a circle that encloses the actual source. Note that the contour Cs need not be concentric with the source point. Evaluating the line integral in Equation
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
A
CI
55
C0
Cs
FIGURE 2.2 The integration path for Green’s theorem for a cluster of cylinders and a source. Also shown is the annular region about Cl in which the local field expansion of the form (2.9) converges.
(2.13) gives, in general, a multipole representation of the form S E (r )
∑
n
BnE , Se H n (k⊥e |r rs |)ein arg(rrs )
(2.14)
where rs is the center of the circle that contains the source. Thus, the contribution to the field due to an explicit source is indistinguishable from the contribution due to the scattered radiation from any cylinder.
2.2.3 RAYLEIGH FIELD IDENTITY The derivation of the field identity requires the matching of the local field expansion in the vicinity of cylinder l with the field due to the outgoing sources on all other cylinders j and the explicit sources s. That is, we set
∑
n
[ AnE ,l Jn (k⊥e |r rl |) BnE ,l H n (k⊥e |r rl |)]ein arg(rrl ) Nc
∑
∑
j1 n
r j )
BnE , j H n (k⊥e |r r j |)]ein arg(r
(2.15)
W E (r ) S E (r ) (2.16)
an expression that is valid inside an annular region extending from the perimeter of cylinder l to the nearest source or cylinder. It is thus necessary to express all
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
56
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
field and source expansions (2.11) in a basis of functions associated with a coordinate origin at the center of cylinder l. We express r rj (r rl) (rj rl) and implicitly take the field point r to be in the vicinity of the surface of cylinder l, thereby assuming that |r rl| |rj rl|. This change of coordinate origin necessitates the use of Graf’s addition theorem in the form [29] H m (k⊥e |r r j |)eim arg(rrj )
∑
p
H pm (k⊥e |r j rl |)ei ( pm ) arg(rj rl )
J p (k⊥e |r rl |)eip arg(rrl )
(2.17)
Thus, in the vicinity of cylinder l the regular part of the field due to all the other cylinders is
∑
n
Nc
AnE ,l Jn (k⊥e |r rl |)ein arg(rrl ) ∑
∑
j1 n
j ≠l
BnE , j H n (k⊥e |r r j |)e
in arg ( rr j )
(2.18)
Using Graf’s addition theorem, we deduce AnE ,lj
∑
m
lj B E , j , H nm m
i ( nm ) arg ( r j rl ) lj H e where H nm (2.19) nm (k⊥ |r j rl |)e
An identical form to (2.19) also applies to explicit multipole source(s) which, in such formulations, are equivalent to additional cylinder(s). Accordingly, the contribution to the regular field in the vicinity of cylinder l due to the presence of either a cylinder j, or an explicit source j, may be expressed in matrix form as A E ,lj Hlj B E , j
lj ] where Hlj [ H nm
(2.20)
Here the notation X [Xn] defines the vector X with elements Xn. Similarly, variables with two subscripts, as in (2.20), define a matrix. Similarly, the explicit external source contribution BE,Se to the regular field, in the vicinity of cylinder l, is obtained by applying Graf’s addition theorem to (2.14) for r rs (r rl) (rs rl). That is,
∑
m
AmE ,lSe Jm (k⊥e |r rl |) eim arg(rrl )
where AmE ,lSe
∑
n
lSe H nm BnE , Se
(2.21)
The exterior field WE(r) (2.11) that originates at the outer boundary, and is defined with respect to the global coordinate system, needs to be recast in the natural basis of cylinder l. Again, we apply Graf’s theorem to change the origin of the field expansion, this time using Jm (k⊥e |r|)eim arg(r )
∑ Jmn (k⊥e |rl |)ei (mn) arg(r ) l
n
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Jn (k⊥e |r rl |)ein arg(rrl )
(2.22)
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
57
and proceed to equate the field representations in the global and local bases
m
n
∑ AmE ,0 Jm (k⊥e |r|)eim arg(r ) ∑ AnE ,l 0 Jn (k⊥e |r rl |)ein arg(rr )
(2.23)
l
to derive the new coordinates arising from the change of basis. That is, i ( mn ) arg( rl ) l 0 ], J l 0 J e where Jl 0 [ Jnm nm mn (k⊥ |rl |)e
A E, l 0 J l 0 A E ,0
(2.24)
The field identity, which is commonly referred to as the Rayleigh identity, is obtained by matching the local field expansion to the global Wijngaard expansion (2.16); i.e., A E ,l ∑ A E ,lj A E ,lSe A E ,l 0
(2.25)
j ≠l
∑ Hlj B E , j HlSe B E ,Se Jl 0 A E ,0
(2.26)
j ≠l
A similar expansion also applies to the magnetic field component. Combining these, we obtain the vector form of the Rayleigh identity A l ∑ Hlj B j HlSe B Se Jl 0 A 0
(2.27)
j ≠l
where A0
E ,0 A K ,0 A
B0
,
E ,0 B K ,0 B
,
Al
E ,l A K ,l A
and
E ,l B K ,l B
Bl
l0 J 0
and Hlj
lj H 0
lj H
0
,
H
lSe
HlSe 0
lSe
0 H
,
and
J
l0
Jl 0
0
Note that in (2.27) the source terms have been labeled as BSe rather than as BS to emphasize that the source is exterior to the cylinders. Finally, combining the equations (2.27) for all l, we derive the full vector form in which (2.27) becomes A HB HSe B Se JB 0 A 0
(2.28)
where A [A l ],
B [Bl ],
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
H [Hlj ],
HSe [HlSe ]
and
JB 0 [J l 0 ]
58
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
and where [HlSe] and [J l0] denote partitioned column vectors with components HlSe and J l0, respectively.
2.2.4 FIELD COUPLING AND CONTINUITY CONDITIONS Previously, we emphasized that a circular boundary can be regarded as a source of outgoing waves (Hankel H functions) for points outside it, and of regular standing waves (Bessel J functions) for points inside. Accordingly, as shown in Figure 2.3 the “outgoing” waves that are sourced at the boundary are caused by either of two fields that impinge on the boundary: (a) standing waves (i.e., Bessel J functions) from outside or (b) outgoing waves (i.e., Hankel H functions) due to possible sources inside the boundary. With this formulation in mind, we may characterize the action of the fields at this boundary in terms of cylindrical harmonic reflection and transmission matriˆ l and Tˆ l . The labels and classify the matrices as either ces denoted by R exterior or interior forms respectively. Accordingly, on the exterior to the boundary, we express outgoing field coefficients (Bel ) as the sum of a reflection ˆ l A l ) of the exterior standing wave impinging on the interface and a trans(R e l mission (Tˆ Bil) of an outgoing field sourced from within the boundary. Similarly, the field inside the cylinder may be written as the sum of the transmission of the exterior standing wave component transmitted through the boundary and a reflection from the boundary of the interior source. Thus, Bel Rˆl Ael Tˆl Bil
(2.29)
Ail Tˆl Ael Rˆl Bil
(2.30)
Here the subscripts e and i indicate that the respective field quantities are associated with regions exterior, or interior, to the boundary. Note that the Bel and Ale are
FIGURE 2.3 The fields at the surface of a cylinder Cl.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
59
precisely the Bl and Al of (2.27). See the treatment in [31–33] for a complete derivation of these reflection and transmission matrices. ˆ l is a partitioned Now, suppressing the subscripts, we observe that R matrix ˆ EE ,l ˆ EK ,l l R R Rˆ KE ,l KK ,l R ˆ ˆ R
(2.31)
This implies that, in general, the electric and magnetic fields are coupled rather than independent. However, note that this coupling occurs via the application of the boundary conditions (2.31), rather than through the Rayleigh identity (Section ˆ ab,l, Tˆ ab,l are diagonal, with the 2.2.3). For circular inclusions, all matrices R elements derived by solving the field continuity equations for the four tangential field components Ez, Kz, Eu, and Ku. In general, the field components Ez and Kz are ˆ EK and R ˆ KE do not vanish. However, in the case coupled because the matrices R of in-plane incidence, when k0z 0, for all types of cylinders (i.e., perfectly conducting, dielectric, finitely conducting), or for arbitrary k0z in the special case of perfectly conducting metal cylinders, for which the tangential components of the ˆ EK R ˆ KE 0, and thus the general conical problem electric field vanish, R decouples [34] into the two disjoint E|| and H|| polarizations (also called TM and TE polarizations, respectively). For noncircular inclusions, Equations (2.29) and (2.30) still hold, this time respectively on the inscribing and circumscribing circles of the lth inclusion. To ˆ ab and T ˆ ab in this case, a full integration of the wave equaderive the elements of R tion is required — typically numerically [35]. The resulting forms are no longer diagonal, but instead are dense. In forming the field identity, only (2.29) is of immediate interest. In vector form, combining the results for all cylinders, it becomes ˆ TB ˆ Si B RA
(2.32)
where BSi refers to the sources inside the cylinders. For a single source contained within a particular cylinder p, BSi [BlSidlp], all the source multipole coefficients are zero except for those corresponding to the source inside the cylinder p. Also, ˆ l) and Tˆ diag(Tˆ l) are block diagonal matrices of the matrices R ˆl Rˆ diag(R l ˆ and T , respectively. For the field problem associated with the solution of problems in radiation dynamics (see Section 2.4) which involves explicit sources exterior and interior to the scatterers, the solution of (2.28) and (2.32) yields the relevant identity ˆ )1 (RH ˆ SeB Se TB ˆ Si ) B (I RH
(2.33)
which is exploited in Section 2.4. Note that in this equation there is no explicit exterior driving field, i.e., A0 0. Also, in the case of the radiation dynamics
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
60
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
modeling, the single source is either an interior source or an exterior source, and hence only one of the two terms in the right-hand side of (2.33) can be nonzero for any given problem.
2.2.5 FIELD PROBLEM
OF
MICROSTRUCTURED OPTICAL FIBERS
Here we discuss how the theory developed in Sections 2.2.2–2.2.4 applies to microstructured optical fibers (MOFs) — also known as photonic crystal fibers or holey fibers. The results of this analysis are discussed in Section 2.3. There are two main types of MOFs: one type consists of pure silica, with a solid core and a cladding that has a regular pattern of air holes that run the length of the fiber. Typically, the holes are hexagonally packed so that they form a finite photonic crystal having the cross section shown in Figure 2.4(a). For this type of MOF, the light is guided through the core by total internal reflections, somewhat similar to the guiding mechanism in conventional fibers. The second class of MOFs has an air core (Figure 2.4[b]), through which the light is guided only by Bragg reflections due to the photonic crystal cladding. From a theoretical point of view, a MOF can be regarded as a finite set of infinite parallel cylinders, for which we set up a field problem in order to determine the modes of the structure. More precisely, we seek the values of k0z that yield a nontrivial solution of the homogeneous wave equation (2.3), i.e., in the absence of either explicit sources or exterior driving fields. We begin with a MOF surrounded by a jacket and note that this cladding boundary acts as a source of standing (Bessel J) waves that arise due to reflections of outgoing fields originating on the cylinders. The modeling of a MOF using the multipole method requires two types of systems of coordinates: a global system having the origin at the center of the fiber, and local systems attached to the centre of each cylinder. In the case of a solid core MOF the key equation of our formulation is (2.28), but with BSe 0
Λ d
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.4 The cross section of a MOF with a hexagonal arrangement of holes. (a) Solid core MOF, (b) air core MOF.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
61
(i.e., without any exterior source). Thus, each cylinder l gives rise to outgoing waves, which are respectively represented in the global and local systems of coordinates for the electric field component Ez as
∑ BnE 0l Hn (k⊥e |r|)einu ∑ BmEl Hm (k⊥e |r rl |)eim arg(rr ) l
(2.34)
m
n
Applying Graf’s addition theorem to the Hankel functions on the right-hand side of Equation (2.34) in the vicinity of the jacket boundary where r rl, we may write [29] H m (k⊥e |r rl |)eim arg(rrl )
∑
n
H n (k⊥e |r|)ein arg r Jnm (k⊥e |rl |)ei ( nm ) arg rl
(2.35)
and, in turn, express (2.34) in the matrix representation B E 0 l J 0 l B El
i ( nm ) arg rl 0 l ], J 0 l J e where J 0 l [ Jnm nm nm (k⊥ |rl |)e
(2.36)
Here, J0l can be regarded as the matrix of a transformation that changes the representation in the local basis associated with cylinder l into the global representation. Note also that in this nomenclature the addition theorem (2.35) can be expressed as H m (k⊥e |r rl |)eim arg(rrl )
∑
n
0 l H (k e |r|)e in arg( r ) Jnm n ⊥
(2.37)
The sum of all outgoing electric fields sourced on the cylinders represents the total electric field incident on the jacket. In global coordinates, this has the functional form VJE 0 (r )
∑
n
BnE 0 H n (k⊥e |r|)ein arg(r )
(2.38)
where, in vector form, Nc
Nc
l1
l1
B E 0 ∑ B E 0 l ∑ J 0l B El
(2.39)
Combining this form (2.39) and the analogous expression for the magnetic field, leads to the vector representation of the outgoing multipole field that is incident on the jacket B0
N c J 0 l l1 0
∑
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
0 l J
0
El B Kl B
Nc
∑ J 0 l B l J0 BB l =1
(2.40)
62
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
where J0B represents a 1 Nc partitioned vector [J 0l], the components of which are 2 2 block diagonal matrices J 0l diag(J0l, J0l). We complete the procedure by observing that the regular field sourced by the jacket arises because of the reflection of the outgoing radiation (B0) from the cylinders (2.40). Accordingly, from Equation (2.30), we deduce that A 0 Rˆ 0 B 0
(2.41)
ˆ 0 is the interior (cylindrical harmonic) reflection matrix for the jacket. where R The MOF field identity then follows by combining Equations (2.28), (2.32) with no interior source, (2.40), and (2.41) to derive the homogeneous equation [I Rˆ (H JB 0 Rˆ 0 J0 B )]B 0
(2.42)
For an infinite cladding, corresponding to the absence of a jacket, we simply set ˆ 0 0 and derive R ˆ )B 0 MB (I RH
(2.43)
The nontrivial solutions of (2.42), or the derived form (2.43), correspond to the modes of the MOF. To locate the modes, we seek those values of k0z for which the determinant of (2.42) or (2.43) vanishes. Then, for each root k0z the multipole coefficients of the corresponding mode are determined from the singular value decomposition of the matrix in (2.42). A detailed discussion of the implementation of the multipole method is contained in Section 2.3.3.
2.2.6 INFINITE PERIODIC STRUCTURES We now detail the application of the multipole method to periodic structures consisting of regular two-dimensional lattices (arrays) of parallel cylinders. With the lattice specified by basis vectors a1 and a2, the location of the center of unit cell l (l1, l2) is written as rl l1a1 l2a2. In the case of the simplest such structure, that is with a single cylinder centered in each unit cell, the regular field incident on each cylinder must be equal to the sum of the outgoing fields from all the other cylinders in the lattice. Thus for a particular cylinder l in the lattice, it follows that in the local coordinate system of cylinder l, the electric field multipole coefficients satisfy AnEl ∑ ∑ Hnljm BmEj j ≠l
(2.44)
m
Combining (2.44) with its magnetic field counterpart then yields A l ∑ Hlj B j j ≠l
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(2.45)
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
63
O′ rl ′
l ′′
O rl l ′′
FIGURE 2.5 Two supercells showing the position of a cylinder l (l , l).
This form is identical to that of (2.27), with the exception of the interior or exterior source terms. Before dealing with this problem further and, in particular, the characterization of the periodicity, we generalize the treatment to consider a lattice of identical unit cells, each of which comprises a common, finite set of identically placed cylinders (Figure 2.5). For such composite structures, it is common to refer to the unit cell as a supercell. The characterization of the geometry of this structure requires two vector bases: 1. A basis of lattice vectors {a1, a2} that generates the supercells with the vector rl defining the position of the center of supercell l (l 1, l 2) given by rl l 1a1 l 2a2. 2. A local basis within each supercell, where the vector Rl determines the position of cylinder l relative to a reference point in each supercell (typically the center of the supercell). Thus, each cylinder l is characterized by the pair l (l , l), which denotes the cylinder belonging to supercell l (associated with rl ) and having a local position Rl within the l supercell. The position of cylinder l relative to global coordinate origin is thus rl rl Rl. One of the supercells is designated as the primary supercell and is labeled with a superscripted 0, corresponding to the choice l 0 with the global coordinate origin set at the center of this supercell. Each cylinder l within the primary supercell (l 0) is matched by a corresponding cylinder l (l , l) in each of the supercells l 0. Because the structure is infinite and periodic, the field, and thus the multipole coefficients, must satisfy the constraints A El A El ′′ eik0 rl ′ ,
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
B El B El ′′ eik0 rl ′
(2.46)
64
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
imposed by the Bloch condition, V(r rl) V(r) exp(ik0 rl). Note that in (2.46) we have simplified the notation for the primary supercell quantities by referring to AE(0,l) and BE(0,l), respectively, by AEl and BEl. To obtain the field identity equivalent to (2.44) for a unit cell with multiple cylinders, we consider a fixed cylinder l (l , l) and partition the sum on the right-hand side of (2.44) into two parts: 1. Over the periodic replicates j (j , l) of the local cylinder l (l , l) in supercells j l , 2. Over cylinders j ( j , j) for all j l and in all supercells j (including j l ). Using the Bloch condition (2.46), the multipole source coefficients arising in these two sums are BmEj BmE ( j′,l ′′) BmEl ′′ eik0 rj′
for j ′ ≠ l ′
BmEj BmE ( j′, j′′) BmEj′′ eik0 rj′
for j ′′ ≠ l ′′
and
Thus, the field identity (2.44) reduces to AnEl ′′
∑
m
Snl ′′l ′′m BmEl ′′
∑ ∑
m j′′ ≠ l ′′
Snl ′′j′′m BmEj′′
(2.47)
where Snl′′l ′′ ∑ H n (k⊥e |r j′ |)e−in arg(rj′ ) eik0 rj′
(2.48)
j′ ≠ 0
Snl′′j′′ ∑ H n (k⊥e |r j′ R j′′ Rl ′′ |)ein arg(rj′
+ R j ′′ −Rl ′′ ) ik0 r j ′
e
(2.49)
j′
are the lattice sums discussed below. Note that in deriving (2.48) and (2.49) we have used the fact that the difference of two lattice vectors is itself a lattice vector, hence replacing (rj rl ) by rj and making the appropriate adjustments to the summation indices, i.e., changing them from j l to j 0. More generally, this shows the invariance of the lattice sums with respect to the transformations of the subgroup of discrete translations from the lattice symmetry group. Also, the derivation of the lattice sums in Equations (2.48) and (2.49) has relied solely on Bloch’s theorem with no presumption of the dimensionality of the lattice. In the case of 2D arrays, the summation over j is two dimensional, resulting in what we will refer to as array sums.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
65
For diffraction gratings that are considered in the following section, the summation runs over a one-dimensional lattice and leads to grating sums. The quantities Sll n (2.48) are referred to as the global lattice sums and are an essential feature of the application of multipole methods to periodic systems. For lattices with complex unit cells with more than one cylinder, the global lattice sums need to be augmented by the relative or shifted lattice sums (2.49). Note that for j 0 we have |Rj Rl| |rj |, and thus by applying the addition theorem for Hankel functions (2.17), we can express the relative lattice sums (2.49) as a series in terms of the global lattice sums (2.48) (e.g., [36]): Snl′′j′′
∑
m
Sml′′l ′′ Jn−m (k⊥e |R j′′ Rl ′′ |) ei ( nm ) arg( R j′′Rl ′′ )
(2.50)
The construction of both global and relative lattice sums relies on the existence of a suitable addition theorem (e.g., Graf’s theorem) for the basis of functions (e.g., cylindrical harmonics in this case) in which fields are expanded. In general, the global sums are sums of multipole source terms over the entire lattice (with the exception of the primary supercell) and characterize the field of a phased array of multipole sources at the origin of the primary cell. In passing, we mention an alternative and widely used definition of the global sums that appears in the literature in arg ( r j ′ ) ik0 r j ′ Snl′′l ′′ ∑ H n (k⊥e rj′ )e e
(2.51)
j′ ≠ 0
and which is related to the form (2.48) used throughout this chapter by ~ ll (1)nSnll. Sn While it is beyond the scope of this chapter to give a comprehensive description of the computation of the lattice sums, we nevertheless outline the techniques involved and refer interested readers to the references [10] and [36–38]. In what follows, we consider global array (2D) sums (2.48) (which for simplicity we denoted by SnA Snll) and discuss the difficulties in their evaluation caused by convergence problems in the defining series, the terms of which are summed over the direct lattice (2.48). For this series, Cauchy’s integral test shows that the SnA are conditionally convergent for all orders n. To overcome these difficulties, we have devised two summation methods. The first converts the sum over the direct lattice to an absolutely convergent sum over the reciprocal lattice, the convergence of which may be accelerated by successive integrations [10,37]. The second technique is based on the observation that a 2D array may be regarded as an infinite stack of 1D gratings, leading to the representation of the array sum in terms of a grating sum [8] and exponentially convergent correction terms [11,36]. The derivation of the former method commences with the comparison of the spatial and spectral domain forms of the quasiperiodic Green’s function [10,37], i.e., G (J)
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
i 4
∑ H0 (k⊥e |J rj |)eik r 0
j
j
(2.52)
66
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
and G (J)
1 A WS
∑ l
eiQl J
(2.53)
Ql2 k⊥e 2
respectively, where J is an arbitrary vector inside the circle inscribed within the primary Wigner–Seitz cell, AWS is the area of the unit cell, Ql Kl k0, and {Kl} are reciprocal lattice vectors corresponding to the direct lattice vectors {rj} [10,37]. We apply Graf’s theorem to (2.52) and identify the array sums (2.48) in the result G (J)
i i H (k e j) 4 0 ⊥ 4
∑
n
SnA Jn (k⊥e j)ein arg(J )
(2.54)
Here, the first term represents the source due to the central cylinder, while the terms in the series describe the multipole sources of order n, with the array sums giving the contribution of all the other cylinders of the array. Next, we use the Bessel series expansion for the exponential in (2.53): eiQl J
∑
m
i m Jm (Ql J)eim arg(Ql ) eim arg(J )
(2.55)
and by means of Poisson’s summation formula we may show that (2.54) and (2.53) are equal [10,37]. We then identify the coefficients of equal powers of exp[i arg(J)] to obtain the expressions for the array sums SnA Jn (k⊥e J) H 0 (k⊥e J)dn 0
4i n1 A WS
∑ l
Jn (Ql j) Ql2
k⊥e 2
ein arg(Ql )
(2.56)
Note that in (2.56) J is an arbitrary vector inside the primary Wigner–Seitz cell. While the series in (2.56) converges absolutely as O(Ql2.5), its convergence may be accelerated by integrating over j, exploiting the identity [znJn(z)] znJn1(z), to increase the order of the Bessel functions and thereby increasing the rate of convergence to O(Qlm2.5) after m such integrations. Hence, our summation method [10,37] is far superior to Ewald’s method [9] in both accuracy and speed of convergence. The derivation of the second summation method is based on relationships between the global array and grating sums [11]. The index j in the definition of global array sums (2.48) represents a pair of integers so that j (p, q), and j 0 means (p, q) (0, 0). The terms corresponding to q 0 are associated with cylinders located on a particular line of the array that can be regarded as a grating. Consequently, for an array defined by the vectors rpq pa1 qa2, with a1 (D, 0), we may rewrite (2.48) in the form [11] SnA
∑
( p, q ) ≠ ( 0 , 0 )
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
H n (k⊥e |rpq |)ein arg rpq eik0 rpq SnG Sn (
)
(2.57)
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
67
where SnG
∑ Hn (k⊥e |rp0 |) ein arg(r
p0 )
eipa0 D
(2.58)
p≠0
Sn ∑ m q q≠0
∑
p
in arg ( rpq )
H n (k⊥e |rpq |) e
eipa0 D
(2.59)
with m exp(ik0 a2), a0 k0x. Here, D is the array constant, in the direction of a1, of an array of supercells. The grating sums SnG of Equation (2.58), which are conditionally convergent for all orders n, have been studied by Twersky [8], who using Sommerfeld’s integral representation of Hankel functions and Euler’s summation formula obtained an absolutely convergent sum over the reciprocal lattice, in terms of elementary functions. The correction factor Sn in (2.59) converges exponentially [11] so that the summation method (2.57) is computationally advantageous. It is also much faster than the previous method (2.56), which relied on accelerated convergence techniques, and can be extended to higher dimensions and different lattice geometries. Returning now to the field problem, we express (2.47) in vector form A El ∑ Slj B Ej ,
lj ], where Slj [ Snm
and
j
lj S lj Snm nm
(2.60)
Note that an identical expression holds for the multipole coefficients of magnetic field. Then, combining the corresponding equations for the electric and magnetic fields in a matrix form we derive A l ∑ S lj B j
or
A SB
(2.61)
j
the Rayleigh identity for the periodic system. In (2.61), Slj diag(Slj, Slj) is a 2 2 block diagonal matrix, and S [Slj] is a rectangular matrix of partitions Slj. The band diagram of a lattice of parallel cylinders may then be generated from the solution of a propagation problem that derives from (2.61) and the boundary conditions B RA derived from (2.32) in the absence of sources. That is, ˆ )B 0 MB (I RS
(2.62)
e and the resolute of the Bloch The matrix M is a function of both wavenumber k vector in the plane perpendicular to the axis of the cylinders. In the case of a strictly 2D problem, this vector is k0, while for a 2.5D problem with specified z-dependence of exp(ik0z z), the Bloch vector resolute is k0 k0 k0zzˆ. Accordingly, the propagation problem is solved by prescribing the Bloch vector k0 or k0, as appropriate, and determining the eigenvalue ke that render M in (2.62) singular. Once a zero of the determinant is found, we may use a singular value decomposition to determine the null vectors B which characterize the modes.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
68
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
2.2.7 GRATINGS With the Rayleigh identity and lattice sums now established for infinite periodic media, we turn our attention to the theory of gratings (1D and 2D), the scattering action of which we characterize by plane wave scattering matrices. Here, we consider a layer of supercells in the xz plane, which in the case of a 1D cylinder grating (with cylinder axis parallel to the z-axis) is generated by the lattice vector a1 Dxˆ. Throughout this section we take the cylinders defining the reference origin in each supercell located with centers at rj j Dxˆ . In the calculation of the lattice sums, the summations over j in Equations (2.48) and (2.49) run over the 1D array of supercells. We will also use two representations for the reciprocal lattice vectors Qs (s Z ) namely, Qs Qts Qys yˆ Qs Qzs zˆ
(2.63)
The first form is necessary in plane wave expansions and, in particular, in the solution of the diffraction problem in which transverse field components are matched at the interface between free space and the grating region. The second form is necessary in the prescription of the multipole representations of the longitudinal field components Ez and Kz in the grating region, for which the z-dependence is exp(iQzsz). The focus of our calculations is the solution of an inhomogeneous scattering problem, driven by incident plane wave fields respectively from above and below: E Einc E z Ds eiQys y Ds eiQys y ei (Qxs xQzs z ) ∑ inc K D K K z Ds s s
(2.64)
where Qs Qts Qys yˆ ,
Qts (Qxs , 0, Qzs ) (Qxs , 0, Qz ) k0 t
2ps xˆ , s ∈ D (2.65)
—— —— Here, k0t (k0x, 0, k0z), Qys k2 Q2ts, and k kfve denotes the background wavenumber. In the case of a single grating layer driven by a plane wave of wavelength l incident on the grating with polar and azimuthal angles w and c, respectively, the vector Q0 takes the form k0 k(sin w cos c, cos w, sin w cos c). Here, however, we are concerned with not just one plane wave but a general incident field that may comprise an arbitrary linear combination of all plane waves with direction sines (Qxs /k and Qzs /k) that belong to the family defined by k0. Later, in Section 2.5 dealing with photonic crystals, we will adopt a different interpretation regarding the transverse resolute k0t as the transverse resolute of the Bloch vector.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
69
The derivation of the field identity in terms of multipole coefficients follows along similar lines to that for Equation (2.25) but without the explicit source term and this time in the context of a periodic array (2.61). We thus write A l ∑ S lj B j J l D J l D
(2.66)
j
in which the final two terms are multipole representations of the plane wave driving fields (from above and below) and are analogous to the term J l0A0 in Equation (2.27). To see this, let us consider a grating with a unit cell comprising Nc collinear cylinders centered at Rl rlxˆ and write (for cylinder l) ei (Qxs xQys yQz z ) eiQxsrl eiQz z ei[Qxs ( x l ) r
Qys y ]
(2.67)
Then, expanding the last exponential in terms of Bessel functions of the first kind we form ei[Qxs ( xrl )Qys y ]
∑
n
(1)n Jn (Qs sl ) ein (us wl )
(2.68)
where Qs (Qxs, Qys, 0), us arg(Qys iQxs), Sl r Rl, and wl arg(Sl), from which we obtain the cylindrical harmonic representation of the backward and forward going plane waves ei (Qxs xQys yQz z ) eiQz z
∑
n
l Jns Jn (Qs sl )einwl
(2.69)
l l where Jl [Jns ], Jns (1)neinuseiQxsrl. The matrices Jl are then used to change the basis of the incoming plane waves D from above and below to their cylindrical harmonic representations J l D J l D where J l diag(Jl, Jl) and D [(DE)T (dK)T]T. Finally, combining Equations (2.66) for all cylinders into a single matrix equation in the same manner as on previous occasions, we arrive at
A SB JD JD
(2.70)
in which J is a column vector formed from the J l. Using Equation (2.70), we derive the field identity ˆ )1Rˆ (JD JD ) B (I RS after the boundary conditions have been applied.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(2.71)
70
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
Equation (2.71) expresses the outgoing multipole field B generated by the incident plane wave field D. From this, we may reconstruct the plane wave fields radiated by the grating and, in turn, form the plane wave scattering matrices. The sketch of the derivation given here is necessarily brief and we refer the interested reader to [36] and [39] for a comprehensive treatment. This derivation of plane wave quantities begins with the Cartesian form of the free space Green’s function G0 (r , r ′)
1 2D
∑
s
1 i[Qts .(r−r′)+Qys | y− y′|] e Qys
(2.72)
Following an application of Green’s theorem [36,39] we may compute the outgoing fields above and below the grating in terms of the multipole source coefficients B. Thus, we may show that the outgoing fields are E z Kz
f E f E ∑ s eiQys y s eiQys y ei (Qsx xQz z ) K fsK s fs
(2.73)
where f f
D D
2 1 K Q B D y K
(2.74)
f E∓ , K [K,l], a row vector of matrices K,l In Equation (2.74) f K∓ f iQxsrl ,l diag(K,l, K,l), K,l [K,l (1)neius. Also, Qy sn ], and Ksn e diag(Qys), Qy diag(Qy, Qy), and Qy diag(Qy, Qy). In Equation (2.74), K performs a change from the basis of cylindrical harmonics to the basis of plane waves, analogous to the change from the plane wave to the cylindrical harmonic basis performed by the J. We also observe that Equation (2.74) comprises two terms — an undeviated incident beam D and a diffracted/scattered field caused by the presence of the grating. Combining Equations (2.71) and (2.74) yields f f
I
K D 2 ˆ ˆ 1 Q y (I RS) R[J J ] D K D
(2.75)
The final step is to convert to the more usual TE/TM system of plane wave modes where the term “transverse” refers to the fields being transverse to the plane of
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
71
grating. Here, we follow the nomenclature of Smith, et al. [40], in which the TE and TM plane wave modes are, respectively, R sE (r )
yˆ Qt ,s Qt , s
eiQt ,s ⋅r ,
R sK (r )
Qt , s Qt ,s
eiQt ,s ⋅r
(2.76)
On this basis, the standard representations of the electric and magnetic fields are 1/2 {F E eiQy ,s y F E e iQy ,s y }R E Et ∑ [j s s s s s
j1s/2 {FsK eiQy ,s y FsK eiQys y }R sK ]
(2.77)
zˆ K t ∑ [j1s/2 {FsE eiQy ,s y FsE eiQy ,s y }R sE s
1/2 {F K eiQy ,s y F K e iQys y }R K ] s s s s
(2.78)
with js Qys /k. Equations (2.77) and (2.78) apply both above and below the grating. Following the derivation in [40] and using the subscripts 1 to denote fields above the grating and 2 to denote fields below the grating, we convert the Cartesian form (2.75) into a TE/TM form F 2, F1,
S
F 1, F2,
where Fj,
E F K± F
(2.79)
and S has the form s s K LJ K sLJa k S T1 I 2 X X T k D K aLJs K aLJa
(2.80)
ˆ S)1R ˆ , k2 k2 Q2 Q2 Q2 , and T is a In Equation (2.80), L (I R z xs ys transformation that reflects the symmetry relationships between electric and magnetic quantities that are imposed by Maxwell’s equations. The matrices Ja and Js (respectively Ka and Ks) are linear combinations of the matrices J (respectively K). Here Ja and Js represent a change of basis from plane waves into cylindrical harmonics, while Ka and Ks represent the inverse transformation. The indices s and a refer to a generalization of the symmetric and antisymmetric problems discussed in [36]. If the grating is up-down symmetric, then the terms KsLJa and KaLJs vanish and the system decouples completely. That is, the solution of the diffraction problem is reduced to two independent problems (whose matrices are of half the dimension of the original) — the symmetrized and antisymmetrized solutions that correspond to a grating, embedded into which (through the center line) is a
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
72
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
magnetic or electric mirror. While the plane wave diffraction problem is best formulated in terms of TE and TM modes, the multipole scattering problem as developed in [39] is best handled in terms of principal Cartesian field components parallel to the cylinder axes. These two representations are related by the matrix X. We next turn to 3D photonic crystals. One such device is the woodpile photonic crystal, which is a structure consisting of layers of cylindrical rods with a stacking sequence that repeats itself every four layers. Within each layer, the rods are parallel and separated by a constant distance D. The distance between successive layer centers is also constant, and the rod axes in adjacent layers are orthogonal. To obtain a periodicity of four layers in the stacking direction, rods separated by one intermediate layer are offset by a distance of D/2 in the direction perpendicular to the rod axes (see Figure 2.17[b]). In order to obtain reflection and transmission scattering matrices for the woodpile structure, we first derive the scattering matrices for the basic unit, namely a pair of crossed gratings, and then use a well-established algorithm [36] to form a stack of such crossed pairs. The plane wave diffracted orders in a pair of crossed gratings are a doubly infinite set indexed by pairs ( p, q) corresponding to diffraction in the plane of each grating. Here, q enumerates the diffracted orders of the grating with generators parallel to the z axis, while p enumerates the orders of the orthogonal grating. For either grating, there is dispersion in only one direction. Thus the 2D scattering matrix for a single grating is essentially a block diagonal matrix with each block being the scattering matrix for a 1D problem indexed over, say, channels q and driven with incidence parameters corresponding to channel p of the orthogonal grating. The scattering matrix for the bottom grating is computed by a change in coordinates x z, y y, and z x, in which the rod axes of the bottom layer are parallel to the new z axis. This is a subtle and intricate process, and the reader is referred to [40] for details. We can also derive terms for the reflection and transmission scattering matrices for both a single layer of parallel rods and a structure consisting of a pair of crossed gratings. Let R and R , respectively, denote reflection scattering matrices for incidence above and below the grating, and let T and T denote the corresponding transmission scattering matrices. Clearly the matrix S of Equation (2.79) can be expressed in the form T R′ S ′ R T
so that
F 2 F 1
T R ′ F 1 ′ R T F2
(2.81)
In the 1D case, a comparison between Equations (2.79), (2.80), and (2.81) can thus be used to yield explicit expressions for the transmission and reflection matrices [40]. There is an analogous method for the 2D case of a pair of crossed gratings. We have to replace the scattering matrix S with the corresponding scattering matrix for the crossed pair. Equation (2.81) provides the basis for the Bloch mode transfer matrix method (Section 2.5), which provides an efficient method for calculating the band structure of 1D and 2D PCs.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
73
This concludes our development of the underlying multipole theory for photonic crystal structures, providing the essential and integrated theoretical foundation for the study of applications in three paradigm areas — propagation in microstructured optical fibers (Section 2.3), radiation dynamics of photonic clusters (Section 2.4), and a Bloch mode analysis of composite PC devices (Section 2.5). In the subsequent sections various extensions to the theory will be made. In all cases, however, this will be undertaken in the context of the particular application.
2.3 MULTIPOLE MODELING OF PHOTONIC CRYSTAL FIBERS 2.3.1 BACKGROUND Photonic crystal fibers (PCFs), or microstructured optical fibers (MOFs), consisting of an arrangement of dielectric cylinders running down the length of an optical fiber have generated much interest in recent years. These fibers in their various forms and geometries have a number of potential applications in nonlinear optics, high-power laser delivery, dispersion compensation, and tunable optical devices. Since in many cases the ideal geometry of a MOF involves circular dielectric or air cylinders in a homogeneous background, the multipole method provides an efficient and accurate technique for modeling such fibers. In addition, it handles finite collections of scatterers exactly. It does not discretize the problem using a grid and so is not affected by numerical convergence problems or the use of periodic boundary conditions that afflict plane wave and other methods that can introduce errors such as the numerical birefringence of modes. By virtue of solving for the propagation constant b k0z as a function of kf , the method’s handling of material dispersion has advantages over techniques (such as plane wave eigenvalue methods) that solve for kf as a function of b. Furthermore, the method is capable of yielding the geometric loss of MOFs accurately (see Section 2.3.3). The most common MOFs have circular air holes in a silica background, arranged in a number of rings about a core region that can be formed by either a missing hole or a larger hole, as shown in Figure 2.4. Although guiding is still possible if the holes are arranged irregularly around a solid core region [41], we consider here the case where the holes form a regular hexagonal pattern characterized by a hole separation of and diameter of d. The dimensionless ratios d/ and l/ are used widely to describe MOF geometries.
2.3.2 GUIDING MECHANISMS AND THE “FINGER DIAGRAM” The multipole method and associated Bloch techniques provide several useful tools for a thorough study of MOFs. We begin by considering the properties of the holey cladding region surrounding the core. The cladding essentially provides a mirror for reflecting light back into the core, one of two requirements for the existence of an optical fiber mode. The second condition for a mode is that a phase condition is satisfied. In conventional fibers the mirror is a result of total internal reflection at the core–cladding interface, and thus the calculation of modes essentially involves only
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
74
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
the phase condition being satisfied. The cladding of a MOF can behave as a mirror in a number of different ways. If the longitudinal propagation constant b is such that total internal reflection occurs between the core region and the cladding, in which the average refractive index is between that of air and glass, guidance is similar to that in conventional fibers, and light can be guided in a solid core (“effective index guiding”). However, for a MOF with an air-core, this condition cannot be satisfied, and reflection is provided by Bragg reflection from the regular arrangement of cylinders in the transverse direction. Since this case is much more sensitive to propagation conditions, one must first identify the parameters for which the cladding behaves as a Bragg reflector before searching for modes that satisfy the required phase relation. A third confinement mechanism, similar to that in antiresonant reflecting optical waveguide (ARROW) structures is not discussed here [42,43]. In Section 2.5, we describe the application of the Bloch method for computing band diagrams for conical incidence on an array of cylinders. Although the refractive index difference between the air holes (nc 1) and the (typically) silica background (ne 1.45) is insufficient to achieve a full bandgap for transverse propagation, bandgaps open up for conical incidence. Locating the bandgaps of the holey MOF cladding requires traversing kf b parameter space and assessing whether propagating states exist. For each b, the perimeter of the irreducible part of the Brillouin zone is traversed for all frequencies, to produce, in effect, a transverse band diagram for every b, which we refer to as a finger diagram. Strictly speaking, one would have to include the entire irreducible part of the Brillouin zone and not just its perimeter. However, in practice band minima and maxima occur only on high symmetry points or lines. Accordingly, it is unlikely for the interior of the Brillouin zone to limit the extent of the bandgap, and thus it is sufficient to compute the finger diagram using only the perimeter of the Brillouin zone. See Section 2.5.3 for a discussion of the computation of band and finger diagrams using the Bloch transfer matrix method. The results of such a scan are shown in Figure 2.6 for a hexagonal lattice of air holes with d/ 0.696 in a background of index ne 1.39. The plot color density is proportional to the number of propagating states, and thus complete bangaps are represented by the white fingers in which the mirror condition is satisfied. The region of interest for air-guided MOF modes lies near the intersection of the light line for air kf b and the bandgap fingers. If the same cladding were used to surround a solid-core, effective index guiding MOF, one would expect to find guided modes in the region kf vc b kf ve bounded by the air and silica light lines marked on Figure 2.6. Thus the finger diagram is of most benefit when studying bandgap guided modes. At this point we discuss one other feature of the finger diagram. Note that at each frequency there is a maximum value for b. This b is associated with the fundamental space filling mode (FSM), the mode with the largest propagation constant that can propagate in the cladding for a given frequency [44]. Therefore, we know that any MOF modes that we find with larger b must be confined, since the field cannot propagate through the cladding. These modes, which can be found between the FSM and the light line for the background medium, rely for their confinement on
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling 18
75
11.5
16 11
12
k0Λ
k0Λ
14
10 8 6
FSM
e
lin
ht
10
ig rl
ai
Effective index ine mode region htl lig a ic l i Air core mode region s
8
10.5
10
12 14 Λ
16
18
9.5 9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
Λ
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.6 (a) The “finger” diagram for a hexagonal air hole lattice with dD/ 0.696 and background refractive index n 1.39. (b) The air core mode region with the light line (dashed) and the modal dispersion curve (solid) displayed.
total internal reflection. Modes that are located in the finger diagram in one of the white fingers, are confined by Bragg reflection. In the following sections we describe some typical applications of the multipole method to studying both index guiding and photonic bandgap (PBG) guiding microstructured optical fibers.
2.3.3 IMPLEMENTATION
OF THE
MULTIPOLE METHOD
In Section 2.2.5, the Rayleigh identity was derived for a finite array of dielectric cylinders under conical incidence. The application of this to MOFs is relatively straightforward. Since there are no external sources, we must simply search for solutions to the equation det(I RH) 0 (2.43) by fixing the frequency of the light and scanning over the complex propagation constant b. As discussed in more detail in Section 2.3.4, the propagation constant is in general complex, with the imaginary part indicating the modal loss. This contrasts with conventional optical fibers where the propagation constants of the bound modes are real. The difference is that in conventional fibers the cladding can be taken to be infinite to a good approximation, so that the field strength in the outer cladding is essentially zero. In contrast, in MOFs the size of the cladding is determined by the position of the holes and is finite. Therefore there is always a finite probability for the light to traverse the cladding region leading to modal losses. This argument is sufficiently general not to rely on the specific guiding mechanism and is thus applied to the study of both index guidance and photonic bandgap guidance. Because the propagation constant is a complex quantity, the search for the modes can be time consuming and requires an algorithm capable of finding all the zeros of the determinant of (2.43) in a region of the complex neff plane. The algorithm should be economical in function calls, as each evaluation of the determinant is
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
76
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
computationally expensive for large structures. Since the zeros are usually very sharp, a highly accurate first estimate of the zero is necessary for most simple root-finding routines. More specific algorithms for finding zeros of analytic or meromorphic functions have good convergence for simple structures (with six cylinders, for example) but fail for more complex structures, even with good initial guesses. Our present approach to root finding seems computationally efficient. We first compute a map of the modulus of the determinant over the region of interest and then use the local minima of this map as initial points for a mixed zooming and modified Broyden algorithm (an iterative minimization algorithm, guaranteed to converge for parabolic minima) [45]. The initial scanning region has to be chosen in accordance with the physical problem studied: if the fiber is air-cored and air-guided modes are sought, we choose Re(neff) 1, whereas if the fiber has a solid core we usually choose to search for modes in a region where Re(neff) lies between the optical indices of the background and the fundamental space filling mode (FSM) (Section 2.3.2). Note that for a given propagation constant, the FSM is the mode of lowest frequency that can propagate in the bulk photonic crystal (that comprises the cladding) and thus nfsm defines the lower bound for the search. In the latter case, for small Re(neff), there may exist hundreds of modes that are of little interest because of their high losses. We therefore often concentrate on a smaller neff scanning region near the highest index of the structure. A scanning region for Im(neff) that gives good results in almost any case is 1012 Im(neff) 103. For large MOFs with reflection and/or rotational symmetry, the mode calculation time can be reduced significantly by applying a knowledge of the mode symmetries determined by the symmetry properties of the MOF structure [46,47]. This can be achieved because only multipole coefficients for inclusions lying in the minimum sector [46] need be specified; those for holes outside the minimum sector can be obtained by multiplying by the appropriate geometric phase factor. The resultant reduction in the order of matrix I RH in (2.43) depends on the type of mode that is addressed. For the most common six-fold symmetric MOFs, the matrix size is reduced by a factor of 6 for nondegenerate modes and by a factor of 3.5 for degenerate modes, leading to considerable reductions in processing time.
2.3.4 EFFECTIVE INDEX-GUIDED MODES The guiding mechanism for effective index-guided modes is somewhat similar to that of conventional fibers. As discussed, in the finger diagram they are located between the light line for silica and the FSM. Since the existence of these modes does not rely on the periodicity of the inclusions in the cladding, they are quite robust. Here we discuss some of the key properties of these modes. 2.3.4.1 Number of Modes Consider the structure of Figure 2.4(a). As already mentioned, because the cladding formed by the successive layers of holes around the solid core is of finite
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
77
width, tunneling losses through the cladding are unavoidable. All modes carried by the MOF are hence leaky. In fact, it can be shown that there is a discrete infinity of such leaky modes, with Equation (2.43) being satisfied for each of these. The fraction of power lost through these effects per unit length, the confinement loss, is given by the imaginary part of the effective index through:
L
20 2p Im(neff ) 106 ln(10) l
(2.82)
with the wavelength l in m. However, most of these modes are not localized in the core but have field distributions extending over the entire cladding region. This is not dissimilar to the situation of conventional step index fibers with a finite cladding, for which there are a limited number of modes that are guided in the core but a large number of cladding modes. In the case of MOFs, because the core and cladding regions are not separated by a well-defined boundary, it is a much more delicate problem to distinguish the “core modes” from the “cladding modes”. The distinction between core modes and cladding modes is a fundamental problem and is linked to many others. Indeed, generally only those modes that are guided in the core are technologically relevant. It is well known that in step index fibers, truly guided core modes become leaky modes of the core — which become confined by the cladding if the latter is of finite diameter — after they have been cutoff. This cutoff of a mode can be seen as a transition between two states of the one mode, one being confined in the core and the other in the cladding. Hence, the precise definitions of core modes and cladding modes can be seen as being equivalent to the definition of the cutoff of modes. Several approaches to such a definition have been suggested, relying on the fraction of power being carried in the core [48], the behavior of losses versus the width of the cladding [49], or the value of a mode’s effective index neff compared to the index associated with the cladding’s fundamental space filling mode (bFSM/k0)[44]. The latter argument relies on an analogy between MOFs and step index fibers but assumes the cladding to be infinite: if the propagation constant of a mode is smaller than the largest propagation constant allowed in the cladding, the mode can couple to propagating modes of the cladding and is no longer confined in the core. The first two arguments are closely related and are more specific to claddings of finite size. If a mode is confined in the core, leakage through the cladding occurs through tunneling and its losses should decay exponentially with increasing cladding width, while its modal diameter should be dictated by the physical size of the core. Once it is no longer confined in the core, the mode becomes confined by the cladding/jacket boundary. The modal diameter is then dictated by the size of the cladding (and will be largely independent of the size of the core), and one can show that losses decay following an approximate power law with increasing cladding width (the leakage being no longer due to tunneling but to imperfect reflection at the cladding/jacket boundary).
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
78
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
It appears that all of the above definitions are largely equivalent and give close agreement for the cutoff wavelengths. Studying the number of core modes using any of these definitions shows that at any wavelength and regardless of the diameter on pitch ratio d/, only a finite number of modes are guided in the core. More surprisingly, it also has been shown that below a critical value of d/, only one mode, the fundamental mode, is confined in the core, with all other modes of the MOF being cladding modes regardless of the wavelength. Figure 2.7 shows the “phase-diagram” for the second mode of solid core MOFs obtained using the multipole method and the definition of cutoff relying on loss properties above and below cutoff [49]. The solid curve in Figure 2.7 represents the locus of the cutoff of the second mode in the MOF parameter space of normalized wavelength and normalized diameter of holes. For normalized wavelengths below the solid curve, the second mode is confined and MOFs are hence multimode. For wavelengths above that curve, the second mode becomes a cladding mode, and the fundamental mode is the only mode confined in the core. The cutoff curve of the second mode intersects the l/ 0 axis at d/ 0.406. For normalized diameters smaller than this, the second mode remains a cladding mode regardless of the wavelength; the fiber is thus said to be endlessly single-mode [44]. 2.3.4.2 Properties of the Fundamental Mode In most applications, single-mode behavior is sought, so that the only relevant mode is the fundamental mode. The fundamental mode of solid core MOFs, such as that depicted in Figure 2.4, is degenerate and has field distributions resembling 0.406
10
Single mode fiber
/Λ
1
0.1 Multimode fiber 0.01
0.001
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
d /Λ
FIGURE 2.7 “Phase-diagram” for the second mode of solid-core silica/air MOFs with a hexagonal array of circular cylinders. Insets: Power density distribution of the second mode in the confined (right) and unconfined (left) states.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
79
that of the HE11 mode of step index fibers. Note that if the symmetry of the MOF structure is broken by design or because of the fabrication process, this degeneracy is lifted and the fiber becomes birefringent. At short wavelengths and for large holes it is very well confined within the core, and losses tend to be negligible even with few rings of air holes. At longer wavelengths or with smaller holes, the field distribution of the fundamental mode starts to extend into the cladding and losses can increase very rapidly. Figure 2.8, resulting from multipole simulations, shows the limit above which losses of the fundamental mode become larger than 1 dB/m for MOFs with different numbers of rings of holes. Above each curve, losses are larger than 1 dB/m for the given MOF. In the vicinity of that curve, the losses tend to be a very steep function of wavelength, and MOFs basically become unusable for wavelengths above the curve. The equivalent curves for the second mode are shown as well; they closely follow the second mode cutoff. The similarity between the abrupt change of losses of the second mode near its cutoff and the steep change of losses for the fundamental mode led to a suggestion that the fundamental mode has a cutoff as well [49]. However, recent work using the newly developed fictitious source superposition (FSS) method [50] for computing defect modes in structures with infinite cladding has shown that the fundamental mode has no cutoff. Using this technique, we have been able to demonstrate that the effective index of the mode satisfies neff nfsm, with neff approaching nfsm asymptotically with increasing wavelength. Because neff nfsm, the field in the cladding remains evanescent and the mode is guided with no cutoff. Even though the fundamental mode has no cutoff, the existence of the transition region, found from the properties of MOFs with finite
10
/Λ
1
0.1
(8) (8)
(6) 0.01 (4) 0.001
0
0.1
(4)
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
d/Λ
FIGURE 2.8 1 dB/m loss curves for the fundamental (solid curves) and second (dashed curves) mode for MOFs with different numbers of rings (in brackets) around the solid core for l 1.55 m. The dotted curve represents the phase diagram from Figure 2.7.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
80
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
cladding [51], is genuine and may be interpreted as the wavelength interval over which the spatial extent of the fundamental mode increases significantly. Because of the relatively large index contrast between air and silica, the chromatic dispersion of the fundamental mode of MOFs is dominated by waveguide dispersion, which can be controlled largely through the proper design of the fiber. Indeed, spectacular dispersion properties that are not feasible with conventional fibers have been demonstrated in [52–55]. However, since most of these dispersion properties appear in regions of parameter space where the fundamental mode starts leaking into the cladding, it is often crucial to take into account confinement loss when designing MOF dispersion properties [55,56].
2.3.5 AIR-GUIDED MODES In Section 2.3.2 it was shown that application of the Bloch method to the cladding structure of an air-core MOF can be a very useful tool for identifying the regions where air-guiding is likely to occur or specifically where the cladding behaves as a strong reflector. The presence or absence of a fiber mode in this region of kf b space is determined by a number of other factors, such as the size and shape of the core, both of which determine the phase condition that must be satisfied by the mode. In addition, since the finger diagram in Figure 2.6(a) is calculated for an infinite hexagonal lattice of cylinders, whereas the fiber cross section is finite, there is still considerable loss due to leakage through a finite number of rings of holes even if the parameters lie in a white band of Figure 2.6(a). The marked curve in Figure 2.6(b) gives the dispersion relation for the fundamental mode of a MOF with four rings of holes in the arrangement described above. It is seen to extend into the region where cladding modes do exist; this is because the mode calculation was performed for a structure with a finite number of holes, for which the cladding reflectivity is a smooth function of wavelength. This should be contrasted to the band diagram calculations, in which the use of suitable lattice sums implies an infinite system. The dispersion curve is located on the high frequency side of the light line, so that neff b/kf 1. This means that the guiding mechanism cannot possibly be total internal reflection. Of course, an effective index less than unity is not unphysical since this relates to a phase index rather than a group index. As mentioned in Section 2.2.5, the multipole method is well suited to estimating the loss in MOFs with a solid core. The calculation can, of course, also be applied to the air-core fibers that we are considering here, with Im (neff) again indicating the confinement loss through (2.82). However, it has been shown by West et al. that this is not the dominant loss mechanism in these fibers [57]. Rather, the losses are mostly associated with the coupling between the core mode and modes that reside on the interface between the core and the cladding. The importance of Re (neff) is not affected by this observation. However, a discussion of all these issues is outside the scope of this chapter. The spatial variations of the magnitudes of the longitudinal components of the electric and magnetic fields are shown in Figure 2.9, together with the
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling |Ez l
81
|Kz l 0.2
40 0.15
20 0
0.1
–20
40
0.25
20
0.2
0
0.15 0.1
–20 0.05
–40
0.05
–40 –40
–20
0
20
40
–40
–20
0
Sz
20
40
Sz 0.6
40
0.5 20
1 0.5
0.4 0
0
0.3 0.2
–40
0.1
y
–20
40 20 0 –20 –40
–40
–20
0
20
40
–40
–20
0
20
40
x
FIGURE 2.9 Longitudinal field components of fundamental air-guided mode and longitudinal Poynting vector Sz for six-ring MOF. The fiber has a central core diameter d / 2.27, while the diameter of the holes in the photonic crystal is d/ 0.696. The wavelength of the incident radiation is l/ 0.593, and the background has a refractive index 1.39.
z-component of the Poynting vector. Since the latter of these is quadratically dependent on the fields, it is better confined than either Ez or Hz. Nevertheless, there is a significant flux leakage into the regions between the central hole and the first ring of smaller holes and the region between the first and second ring of holes. The results reported here require the solution of the multipole coefficients for each cylinder, with the accurate characterization of the field around the large central hole requiring additional terms in the multipole series used in the implementation (characterized by M0, the symmetric truncation order) [33]. Since we have independent coefficients for the electric and magnetic fields, the resulting matrix M, defined in (2.43), has dimension 2[Nc(2M 1) (2M0 1)] for an Nc 1 hole system. Here M0 is the truncation order of the central hole, and M is that for all others. For the six-ring structure considered here, with M 5 and M0 19, the matrix M has dimension 3642 [33]. The dimension of the matrix can be reduced, however, by using symmetry considerations, as discussed in Section 2.3.3. Nevertheless, even with these reductions in matrix size, the computational demands are near the limits of standard workstations, and the quality of the bandgap confinement that can be modeled on such systems is still somewhat less than desirable.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
82
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
2.4 RADIATION DYNAMICS AND THE LOCAL DENSITY OF STATES 2.4.1 BACKGROUND The notion of spontaneous emission was introduced in 1917 by Einstein [58] in his derivation of Plank’s black body radiation formula. Subsequently, it was realized that the coefficient of spontaneous emission rate A is not a constant but depends on the environment in which the radiation sources or atoms are embedded [59,60]. Indeed, the variation of A is particularly strong in photonic crystals [61]. For example, for wavelengths in a bandgap, the density of states is strongly diminished, leading to a reduced rate of spontaneous emission. Some new quantum phenomena have also been predicted: the localization of super-radiance near a photonic band edge [62], the control of the spontaneous emission rate [63] and the nonMarkovian character of radiative decay [64] have been reported. The key parameter that determines the radiative dynamics of sources is the spatially resolved or local density of states (LDOS) for light, r(r, v) [18]. According to Fermi’s golden rule, the spontaneous emission coefficient A is proportional to the LDOS r(r, v) and, in general, is a function of not only frequency but also position. This is a generalization of the usual density of states that depends on frequency only. The spatial dependence at a frequency v is associated with the spatial dependence of the eigenfunctions at this frequency and needs to be included because the size of the individual emitters (atoms) is much smaller than the wavelength of light. Consequently, if this eigenfunction has a node at a particular position, the electric field for an emitter at this position vanishes as well, and r(r, v) 0. Therefore, at a given frequency in a band, the spontaneous emission rate may be increased close to antinodes of the field and decreased near the nodes. Although the calculation of the LDOS is entirely classical in that it derives from the solution of a classical electromagnetic problem, its main applications are associated with quantum problems. In general, the LDOS can be calculated from the imaginary part of Green’s tensor [65] r(r ; v)
2v Im Tr[G E (r , r ; v)] pc 2
(2.83)
where c is the speed of the light, and GE(r, rs; v) is the electric field Green’s tensor for a source at rs and observation point at r. The Green tensor G xx G E Gyx Gzx
Gxy Gxz Gyy Gyz Gzy Gzz
(2.84)
is a 3 3 second rank tensor [66]. The elements in column u represent the comE E E ponents of the electric field vector (Gxu , Gyu , Gzu ) generated by a dipole source radiating parallel to the u x, y, or z axes, respectively. © 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
83
In what follows, we consider the calculation of the LDOS in 2D corresponding to a z-invariant structure and a line source, and in 2.5D, defined as a 2D z-invariant structure with a 3D (point) source.
2.4.2 2D GREEN TENSOR AND LDOS For the strictly 2D problem, our source is an infinite line antenna located at rs and we take k0z 0. We consider cylinders of refractive index nl located in a background of refractive index ne. For in-plane incidence, the solution of the problem decouples into the two principal E|| and H|| polarizations, which enables the form of the Green tensor to be simplified as follows [67]. For E|| polarization, it reduces to a form involving only a single nontrivial scalar GE Gzzduz, where u x, y, z, while for H|| polarization it reduces to a 2 2 tensor G xx G E G yx 0
0 0 0
Gxy Gyy 0
(2.85)
In Section 2.2.3, we have already given the field identity (2.33) for the cases of exterior and interior sources. In this we note differences in the way in which the source terms enter the identity: in the case of an exterior source, the source term enters directly, while for an interior source it enters indirectly through the transmission of the source field across the boundary of the cylinder. In turn, this affects the representation of the source coefficients that we present immediately below. We begin by noting that source term SE in (2.14) for an E|| polarized line source is given by S E (r )
1 H (k |r rs |) 4i 0 f
(2.86)
where rs is the position of the source, n ne for an exterior source, and n nl for a source inside the cylinder l. Then, after applying the procedure described in Sections 2.2.2 and 2.2.3, we derive an identity of the form (2.33) for the electric field only. From Graf’s addition theorem applied to (2.86), we can find the explicit expression of the source multipole coefficients for the cylinder l. In the case of an exterior source, we obtain an expression of the form (2.14), while for a source inside cylinder l, we apply Graf’s addition theorem in the form 1 1 H (k |r rs |) H 0 (k f l |(r rl ) (rs rl )|) 4i 0 f l 4i 1
∑ H (k |r rl |)Jm (k f l |rs rl |)eim arg(rrl )eim arg(rsrl ) 4i m m f l
∑ BmE ,lS Hm (k f l |r rl |)eim arg(rr ) i
m
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
l
(2.87)
84
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
Accordingly, the source multipole coefficients for the cylinder l are 1 H (k |r rl |)eim arg(rs rl ) , for sources outside the cylinders 4i m f e s (2.88) 1 Jm (k f l |rs rl |)eim arg(rs rl ) , for a source inside the cylinder l 4i
BmE ,lSe BmE ,lSi
Finally, by calculating the multipole coefficients BE using an analogue of Equation (2.33) for this polarization, the field may be reconstructed using Equation (2.11) and the LDOS from Equation (2.83). The real part of Green’s tensor diverges when the source and field points coincide (according to the definition of the LDOS). Accordingly, care is required in its numerical evaluation and, as we see, the multipole method is ideally suited for this type of calculation since the divergent behavior can be avoided analytically. To exemplify the method, we consider a cluster of hexagonally packed circular air voids with common radius al /D 0.48 in a background of dielectric constant e n2e 13. Note that throughout this section the symbol D denotes the lattice constant of the hexagonally packed clusters. The corresponding infinite structure has bandgaps for 1.94 l/D 2.31 for E|| polarization and for 1.94 l/D 2.83 for H|| polarization and thus exhibits a full bandgap in the wavelength range 1.94 l/D 2.31. The cluster is constructed as a sequence of concentric shells of air voids with a central cylinder placed at the origin. Note that this differs from the MOF geometries from Section 2.3.5, which have a defect in the center. For display purposes, we plot a normalized form of the LDOS, namely r (r , v)
pc 2 r(r , v) 2v e2
(2.89)
where the normalizations have been chosen such that in free space ~ v) 0.25. In Figure 2.10 we show a density plot of r~ as a function of r(r, position for E|| polarization and for two wavelengths — a gap wavelength l/D 2.25 in Figure 2.10(a), and a propagating band wavelength l/D 3.0 in Figure 2.10(b). Note that in the bandgap, the LDOS is small everywhere in the interior of the structure. In the middle of the central unit cell, r~ is approximately 107 times its value r~ 0.25 in the background medium. Thus the emission by a line antenna located in this region is drastically reduced. Outside the cluster, the LDOS rapidly approaches its free space value. In a pass band, as in Figure 2.10(b), the LDOS does not decrease inside the cluster but fluctuates around the value of 0.25 in the uniform background. In Figure 2.11(a) we plot the LDOS along the y-axis for clusters of Nc 19, 61, and 127 cylinders for a wavelength of l/D 2.25. Note that the LDOS decreases, on average, exponentially inside the cluster, though oscillations are clearly visible. As we increase the size of the crystal, the positions of the maxima and minima of the LDOS remain approximately the same because they are
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling 8
8
0 −2
4
85
0 −2
4
−4 0
−6 −8
−4
−10 −8
−8
−4
0
4
−4 0
−8
−4 −8
8
−6
−10 −8
−4
(a)
0
4
8
(b)
FIGURE 2.10 (a) Density plot of log10 r~(r, v) for E|| polarization versus position at l/D 2.25 (stop band) for E|| polarization. (b) As for part (a) but for l/D 3.0, corresponding to the pass band.
0 log10 [ (y,)]
log10 [ (y,)]
0 −2 −4 −6 −8 −10
−6
−2
2
6
10
−1
−2 −10
−6
−2
2
y/d
y/d
(a)
(b)
6
10
FIGURE 2.11 (a) Normalized LDOS r~(r, v) along the y axis at l/D 2.25 in the stop band for E|| polarization. The dotted curve corresponds to a cluster with Nc 19 cylinders, dashed for Nc 61, and solid for Nc 127. The right panel (b) is the same as in (a) but for l/D 3.0, Nc 19 (dotted line), and Nc 127 (solid line).
determined by the cylinder positions. The horizontal straight line indicates the free space LDOS of r~ 0.25. The LDOS rapidly approaches this free space value as we leave the cluster. Figure 2.11(b) is the same as Figure 2.11(a), but for the pass band wavelength l/D 3.0 and for a cluster of Nc 19, 127 cylinders. The LDOS now oscillates inside the cluster and approaches the free space value for points exterior to the cluster. For H|| polarization, the source term SK(r) in (2.14) is S xK (r ) S yK (r )
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
e H (k |r rs |) sin arg(r rs ) 4 1 f e
e H (k |r rs |) cos arg(r rs ) 4 1 f e
(2.90)
86
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
for orientation of the source along the x- and y-directions respectively. After applying the procedure described in Section 2.2.2 we derive the field identity in the form (2.25), where the explicit expressions for the source multipole coefficients BK,Se and BK,Si for the orientation of the source along the x-axis are BmK ,lSe
e [ H (k r )ei ( m1)uls H m1 (k f e rls )ei ( m1) uls ] (2.91) 8i m1 f e ls
BmK ,lSi
l [ J (k r )ei ( m1)us Jm1 (k f l rs )ei ( m1) us ] 8i m1 f l s
(2.92)
In Equations (2.91) and (2.92), (rls, uls) rs rl. For the source dipole oriented parallel to the y axis, the dipole source multipole coefficients for BK,Se and BK,Si have the form BmK ,lSe BmK ,lSi
e [ H m1 (k f e rls )ei ( m1)uls H m1 (k f e rls )ei ( m1) uls ] 8
l [ J (k r )ei ( m1)us Jm1 (k f l rs )ei ( m1) us ] 8 m1 f l s
(2.93) (2.94)
Figure 2.12 displays the H|| polarization equivalents of the E|| polarization results shown in Figure 2.10. The general features of the two cases are similar: a reduction of the LDOS for the gap wavelength in Figure 2.10(a), while for a wavelength in the pass band in Figure 2.10(b), the LDOS oscillates around the free space value. Note, in addition, that for H|| polarization, the LDOS is discontinuous across the cylinder boundaries, as illustrated in Figure 2.13, which shows a cross section as in Figure 2.11.
2.4.3 2.5D GREEN TENSOR AND LDOS The 2.5D Green tensor applies to a dipole point source that radiates in 3D, embedded in the 2D scattering geometry of a 2D photonic crystal [68]. The whole scattering problem can again be formulated in terms of Ez and Kz components of the field in a similar way to that described in Section 2.2.2. The free space electric and magnetic fields [69] for a dipole oriented in the direction u (where u is a unit vector) are ik R (u ⋅ ) e f G E ( R) u 2 2 , k f 4 pR
1 e f (u ) ik f 4 pR ik
G K ( R)
R
(2.95)
where n is a piecewise constant function n(r) — the refractive index of the medium in which the source is located. Also, R |R| and R r zzˆ , with
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling 8
87
8
0
0 −2
4
−2
4
−4
−4 0
0
−6 −8
−4
−6 −8
−4
−10
−10 −8
−8
−4
0 (a)
4
−8
8
−8
−4
0 (b)
4
8
FIGURE 2.12 The same as Figure 2.10 but for H|| polarization.
1 log10 [ (y,)]
log10 [ (y,)]
0 −2 −4 −6
−6
−2
2
0 −1 −2
6
−6
−2
2
y/d
y/d
(a)
(b)
6
FIGURE 2.13 The same as Figure 2.11 but for H|| polarization. Note that the LDOS is discontinuous across the surface of the cylinders.
r (x, y, 0). The source term in (2.95) is then written as a Fourier integral (i.e., a spectral decomposition in terms of cylindrical waves [69]), eik f e R i 4 pR 8p
∫ H0 (ke |r rs |)e
ik0 z z
dk0 z
(2.96)
—–— ——– where ke k2f ve2 k20z and, without loss of generality, we may assume that the source is located on the plane zs 0. Then, we substitute (2.96) into (2.95) to form GE/K(R), the z-component of which allows us to infer the source terms SE/K (2.14) from GzE/K ( R) ∫
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
SeE/K (k0 z )eik0 z z dk0 z
(2.97)
88
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
We thus derive [68] the z-components of the source terms (2.14) as follows S xE (r ) S xK (r ) S yE (r ) S yK (r )
k0 z ke 8pk 2f ne2
H1 (ke |r rs |) cos arg(r rs )
ke H (k e |r rs |) sin arg(r rs ) 8pk f 1 k0 z ke 8pk 2f ne2
H1 (ke |r rs |) sin arg(r rs )
(2.98)
ke H (k e |r rs |) cos arg(r rs ) 8pk f 1
SzE (r )
ike 2 H (k e |r rs |) 8pk 2f ne2 0
SzK (r ) 0 for the source orientation u along the xˆ, yˆ, zˆ directions, respectively. The transverse components of the source field can be found using (2.1). After applying the procedure [68] described in Section 2.2.2, we form the field identity (2.27), where the multipole source field coefficients in the field identity have the form k02z BzE,m,lSe 1 H (k e r )eimuls (k f ne )2 m ls BxE,,mlSe ByE,,mlSe
ik0 z ke H (k e r )ei ( m1) uls H m1 (ke rls )ei ( m1) uls 2(k f e )2 m1 ls k0 z ke
H (k e r )ei ( m1) uls H (k e r )ei ( m1)ls m1 ls 2(k f ne )2 m1 ls
(2.99)
BzK,m,lSe 0 BxK,m,lSe
ke H (k e r )ei ( m1)uls H m1 (ke rls )ei ( m1) uls 2i m1 ls
ByK,m,lSe
ke 2
H (k e r )ei ( m1)uls H (k e r )ei ( m1) uls m1 ls m1 ls
for sources outside the cylinders. In Equations (2.99), (rls, uls) rs rl denotes the position of the source relative to the center of cylinder l. For interior sources, these terms take the same form with the replacement of ne by nl (for cylinder l) and Hm by Jm. The unknown B coefficients are again found by solving the field identity (2.33), enabling the field reconstruction (2.11) for the spectral components k0z.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
89
The full fields are finally obtained by the inverse Fourier transforms (2.4). These integrals need to be evaluated in the complex k0z-plane using a suitable contour [68] to avoid numerical convergence problems. This is because the integrands have poles on or near the Re(k0z)-axis due to bound modes in the range kf min (nl, ne) Re(k0z) kf max(nl, ne). Causality is enforced by deforming the contour above these poles for Re(k0z) 0 and below for Re(k0z) 0. The contour can then be returned to the Re(k0z)-axis when | Re(k0z) | kf max(nl, ne). The process of computing the LDOS may then be summarized as follows. For each of the three source orientations, u xˆ, yˆ, zˆ , we must solve the problem of generating each of the three columns u of the Green tensor. For a given u and k0z we generate the source coefficients according to Equations (2.99) and solve the field problem for B (2.27) from which we reconstruct the total field. We then integrate this over k0z to generate the relevant column of the Green tensor. Finally, with three field problems solved, we may compute the LDOS from (2.83). The 2.5D Green tensor has been applied to the calculation of the 2.5D LDOS (2.83) in the 2D macroporous silicon photonic crystal (2D MSPC) [70]. Fabricated by electrochemically etching hexagonal arrays of cylindrical air-pores with an aspect ratio (pore height to pore diameter) of 100–500 in silicon (ne 3.4), the 2D MSPC is an essentially ideal 2D PC system. The specific sample modeled is composed of four concentric hexagonal rings of air-voids (Nc 61) of radius al /D 0.45 enclosed by an air-jacket of radius a0 /D 5.0 in a fiber-like arrangement. Although a complete understanding of the LDOS results requires modal field patterns, a qualitative understanding is provided by the band structure. The outof-plane band structure (k0z 0) for the underlying lattice of the 2D MSPC is characterized in Figure 2.14. We note that this figure is similar to the finger diagram (Figure 2.6). However, the parameters of the structure are quite different; in particular, the high refractive index contrast between silicon and air considered here leads to an in-plane gap, whereas the low contrast in Section 2.3 only leads to narrow out-of-plane gaps (the “fingers”). The in-plane band structure (k0z 0) has a narrow E|| bandgap in the frequency (normalized) range vD/2pc [0.405, 0.445] within a wide H|| bandgap in the frequency range vD/2pc [0.303, 0.495] to form a complete in-plane bandgap. The out-of-plane band structure is determined by a projection effect because the in-plane component of the wave vector ———— — 2 k k2f n e2 k0z needs to satisfy the Bragg condition. As k0z increases out-ofplane, the frequency of modes increases to compensate, resulting in a backward sloping band structure. To the left of the light line (k0z kf) lie the radiation modes that are oscillatory in air and resemble in-plane modes at the projected wave vector. To the right of the light line (k0z kf) lie bound modes that are evanescent in air. These modes are largely confined to the silicon background by total internal reflection. For a given frequency, the integral over k0z is represented by a horizontal line across the diagram. This amounts to a rough summation over in-plane modes at and below the frequency. While there is no complete gap, a pseudogap covers the widest range of k0z at the top of the complete in-plane bandgap; as we see below, the structure affects the LDOS most strongly at this frequency.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
90
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals 0.6
Evanescent-modes
Oscillatory-modes
0.5 pseudo-gap d / 2c
0.4 0.3 0.2
Light-line
0.1 0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
d / 2c
FIGURE 2.14 Out-of-plane band structure for the 2D MSPC. The pseudogap is formed by the out-of-plane trajectories of the edges of the E|| bandgap. The dashed lines indicate the |out-of-plane trajectories of the edges of the H|| bandgap. Radiation modes lie to the left of the light line, while bound modes lie between the light line and the fundamental spacefilling modes. The horizontal line indicates where the pseudogap covers the widest k0z range.
The spatial dependence of the 2.5D LDOS in the 2D MSPC at the top of the complete in-plane bandgap is plotted in Figure 2.15(a). The integral over k0z washes out the more dramatic positional variations seen in the 2D LDOS, and the 2.5D LDOS is basically the same in each unit cell inside the two outermost rings. At the center of the central air-pores, the 2.5D LDOS is suppressed by one order of magnitude and increases smoothly toward the pore wall. The dependence on cluster size is shown in Figure 2.15(b). Limited by a pseudogap, the suppression of the 2.5D LDOS inside the air-pores saturates rapidly with cluster size. This is again in contrast to the behavior of the 2D LDOS, for which the suppression grows exponentially with cluster size (i.e., the LDOS decreases exponentially with cluster size), in view of the existence of a complete bandgap. The frequency dependence of the 2.5D LDOS at the cluster center is plotted in Figure 2.16(a). Suppression grows with frequency inside the in-plane bandgaps as the corresponding out-of-plane pseudogaps cover a widening range of k0z values. Maximum suppression of one order of magnitude is reached at the top of the complete in-plane gap. At frequencies immediately above the gap, the 2.5D LDOS is a factor 20 larger as in-plane modes now exist (see Figure 2.14). This asymmetric frequency dependence about the upper edge of the in-plane bandgap is the signature response of point source spontaneous emission in a 2D PC. Wubs and Lagendijk [71] noted that the LDOS for a point source in a finite structure that is periodic in 1D or 2D can be separated into a radiation component, which is detected outside the structure in the plane of periodicity, and a bound component, which is detected at the ends of the structure. The radiation component is
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
91
0.5 4 0.25 log10[ / 0 ]
y/d
2 0 −2
0 −0.25 −0.5 −0.75
−4
−1 −4
−2
0
2
−4
4
−2
x/d
0
2
4
x /d
log10[/0 ] (a)
(b)
0
1
−1
0.5
log10[/0 ]
log10[/0]
FIGURE 2.15 (a) 2.5D LDOS across the plane of the 2D MSPC at the top of the complete in-plane bandgap, normalized to its free-space value, r0 v2/p2c3. (b) Cluster size dependence: 2.5D LDOS along the x-axis with Nc 1 (dash), 7 (dot), 19 (dash-dot), and 61 (solid).
−2 −3
0 −0.5 −1 −1.5
0.2
0.3
0.4 d/2c (a)
0.5
0.6
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
d/2c (b)
FIGURE 2.16 (a) 2.5D LDOS vs. frequency in 2D MSPC at cluster center (x, y)/D (0.0, 0.0). Total 2.5D LDOS (solid), radiation component (dash). (b) 2.5D PLDOS for u zˆ at the center of the cluster (solid) and in silicon background (x, y)/D (0.5, 0.0) (dash). Solid vertical lines indicate E|| bandgap, and dashed vertical lines indicate H|| bandgap.
also included in Figure 2.16(a). Determined by small k0z values, the radiation component is naturally more affected by the periodicity of the structure and undergoes more dramatic variations. Fortuitously, the pseudogap of the 2D-MSPC almost completely covers all radiation modes at the top of the complete in-plane gap. As a result, the radiation component of the 2.5D LDOS is heavily suppressed by a factor of 5000. In-plane modes are encountered above the top of the in-plane gap, and the radiation component rises rapidly. The sudden burst into the radiation component about the top of the in-plane gap is perhaps the most striking effect of a 2D-PC on spontaneous emission.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
92
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
While the LDOS gives the spontaneous emission rate averaged over dipole orientation, the projected LDOS (PLDOS) is for a particular dipole orientation and can be obtained by contracting the Green tensor with the dipole unit vector u (i.e., an inner product with u). The 2.5D PLDOS for u zˆ is plotted in Figure 2.16(b). No longer averaging over orientation, variations in the 2.5D PLDOS are stronger than in the 2.5D LDOS. As the 2.5D PLDOS for u zˆ is determined by the Ez component of the fields, the result is closely tied to the in-plane E|| band structure and the associated modal field patterns. Suppression begins to grow inside the H|| gap because the modes of the second E|| band, which lies between the bottom of the H|| bandgap and the bottom of the E|| bandgap, have nodes at the center of the air-pores and are not contributing to the 2.5D PLDOS. The 2.5D PLDOS then jumps sharply higher at the top of the E|| bandgap as the first modes encountered have antinodes at the air-pore center.
2.5 BLOCH MODE ANALYSIS OF COMPOSITE PC DEVICES 2.5.1 BACKGROUND AND NOMENCLATURE The modeling of photonic crystals and composite devices fabricated from photonic crystals is challenging, not only because of the strongly scattering environment that is a consequence of the geometry and scale of the structure, but also because of the high contrast optical materials that are used. Over the years, a range of computational methods have evolved to model PC structures including finite difference time domain (FDTD) methods [21], plane wave methods [20], beam propagation methods [72], transfer matrix methods [73], layer KorringaKohn-Rostoker (KKR) methods [7,36], Wannier function methods [74], and finite element methods [23]. Although these methods lead to accurate results, the bulk of them are entirely numerical in their approach and do not readily provide insight into the essential underlying physics of propagation. Despite the importance of this, it is only recently that real efforts to develop tools that can answer such questions have begun to emerge. Of particular interest are the methods based on Bloch modes, transfer matrices, and related techniques, that are now generating significant interest (see [40,74–81]). It is in this area that our group has been particularly active, developing the Bloch mode scattering matrix formalism and applying this semianalytic approach to the modeling of photonic crystals. In such methods, the photonic crystal lattice is regarded as a periodically stratified medium (in the vertical direction, see Figure 2.17) in which each 1D or 2D layer is a grating that is periodic in the transverse plane. In this, the unit cell of the transverse period(s) may range from a simple cell that includes only a single scatterer (i.e., cylinder) to a complex supercell that has a number of cylinders suitably arranged to define a photonic crystal device. The fields at the upper and lower interfaces of each grating layer are represented in plane wave expansions characterized by the transverse component of the Bloch vector. For a 1D grating,
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling y
93 y
f −a
Pa
a2
f +a x
a1 f −b
Pb
(a)
a2 a1
x
f +b
(b)
FIGURE 2.17 (a) Geometry of the unit cell defined by the fundamental translation vectors a1 (D, 0) and a2 for the Bloch method calculations. The phase origins Pa and Pb of the fields f a and f b above and below the grating, respectively, are shown. (b) The fundamental translation vectors for a woodpile structure.
the plane wave expansion at the interface y yj takes the form V f( j ) (r )
xs 1/2 fs( j )eixs ( yy j ) fs( j )eixs ( yy j ) eias x s
∑
(2.100)
———– where as 2ps/D a0, xs k2 a2s, with D denoting the lateral or transverse period of the structure (which can be a superlattice) and with a0 k0x denoting the transverse component of the Bloch vector, and where k denotes the wavenumber in the background (i.e., k kfne). In (2.100), the expansion has been normalized with the inclusion of the factor xs1/2 to enable energy fluxes (for propagating orders) to be computed from the square magnitude of the associated amplitude. The action of each grating layer, in turn, is characterized by reflection (R) and transmission (T) scattering matrices with, for example, Rpq denoting the amplitude of the field reflected into the pth channel (or diffraction order) corresponding to unit amplitude incidence in channel q. The reflection and transmission scattering matrices may be computed with a variety of techniques including differential and integral methods, finite element techniques, and the multipole method, which has been an important feature of our work. As is elaborated in the following section, the reflection and transmission scattering matrices that characterize the layer then allow us to define a transfer matrix (T) that relates the fields on either side of the layer. Finally, the vertical periodicity of structure and the associated Bloch condition lead to an eigenvalue problem for the transfer matrix T, the solution of which yields the modes (both propagating and evanescent) of the structure. The strength and utility of the method lie in its use of the natural Bloch mode basis of functions to describe the properties of photonic crystals. If we consider a plane wave incident upon a photonic crystal, the incident field excites a field within the PC that can be expanded as a superposition of Bloch modes. In most
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
94
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
practical situations, however, only a single, or at most a few, propagating Bloch states actually contribute to the far field of the device. This, in turn, can reduce the complexity of the treatment of the multiple scattering problem, in many cases transforming the analysis of the PC structure to that of well-known devices that arise in thin film optics, e.g., generalizations of the Fabry–Perot interferometer. In this section, we outline the rigorous theoretical framework of the method. We go on to study various applications of the method in Section 2.6. The use of plane wave scattering matrices and transfer matrix methods in the determination of band structures dates back to the work of McRae [82] in low energy electron diffraction. In recent years, the method has been extended [40,75,76] to determine band structures and to enable the use of Bloch mode methods in structures that exploit defect modes. Our analysis begins with the reflection and transmission scattering matrices, computed by the multipole method, for a constituent grating layer (Figure 2.17), relative to some phase origin denoted by the superscript 0. This layer may be a one-dimensional structure, such as a single grating, or a composite multilayer grating, or a two-dimensional structure, such as a woodpile, which comprises crossed gratings. The grating layers are taken parallel to the xz plane and are characterized either by the direct lattice basis vector a1 for a 1D structure or by a pair of basis vectors {a1, a3} for a 2D structure. Accordingly, the summation indices in the general plane wave expansions (2.77) and (2.78) are either one- or two-dimensional, summing over the set of all vectors in the reciprocal lattice, viz. {s1b1} and {s1b1 s3b3}, where {bj} denotes the basis of the reciprocal lattice vectors corresponding to the direct lattice vectors {aj}. This, in turn, is reflected in the structure and dimension of the scattering matrices introduced in (2.79). For incidence from above and below, let these be denoted by (R0a, T 0a ) and (R0b, T 0b ), respectively, with the superscript 0 referring to a particular phase origin. A lattice is then formed by stacking individual layers, offsetting each from its predecessor by the basis vector a2. Following the treatment in [40,75], the reflection and transmission matrices relative to the phase origins shown in Figure 2.17(a) are 0 0 T R a b QP T a Rb PQ 0 0 Ra T b Ra T b 1
Q diag(Q
2
1
1
1
, Q 2 ), P diag(P 2 , P 2 )
(2.101)
for a two-dimensional grating. In (2.101), the matrices Q and P respectively translate the phase origin in the transverse and vertical directions in accordance with the out-of-plane lattice vector a2. Here, both Q and P are written as block diagonal matrices to handle the E|| and H|| field components. Naturally, each of the diagonal blocks contains identical elements, i.e., {(eiQt,sa2)} and {(eiQ||,sa2)}, respectively, for the matrices Q and P, which are used to shift the phase origins for the scattering matrices respectively for incidence from above and below to the
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
95
points Pa and Pb of Figure 2.17. For a one-dimensional grating, the corresponding expressions are T a Ra
Rb Tb
0 T a
QP
R0 a
Rb0
1
Q diag(Q
PQ, Tb0
2
1
1
1
,Q 2 ), P diag(P 2 ,P 2 )
(2.102)
where Q diag(eiQ t, sa2), P diag(eiQ||,sa2), Qt,s (Qxs, 0, Qzs), and Q||,s (0, Qys, 0).
2.5.2 FORMULATION
EIGENVALUE PROBLEM
OF THE
In the notation of Section 2.2.7 and Figure 2.17(a), we may express the outgoing fields in terms of the incoming fields fa Ra fa T b fb ,
fb T a fa Rb fb
(2.103)
The Bloch condition requires that fields in an infinite lattice satisfy V (r a j ) exp(ik0 ⋅ a j )V (r ) for a lattice vector aj. This, in turn, requires that f b mf a where m exp (ik0 a2). For a general lattice in which there is no explicit symmetry to exploit, we solve (2.103) to generate the eigenvalue equation in terms of the interlayer transfer matrix T
Tfa fb mfa ,
f j f j
where f j
and
T R T 1R a b b a T 1 T b Ra
Rb T b1 T b1 (2.104)
In (2.104), the subscripts j a, b respectively denote the interfaces above and below the layer and also designate the reflection and transmission scattering matrices for incidence from above and below. Since the scattering matrices from which the transfer matrix T is calculated explicitly embed both the wavenumber k and the transverse component of the Bloch vector k0t in their calculation through the solution of a diffraction problem for a single layer, it follows that T T(k, k0t). This therefore leaves the component of the Bloch vector in the direction of translation, i.e., k0 a2, to be determined from (2.104). While Equation (2.104) formally defines the modes, this particular formulation of the problem is not well conditioned, particularly for matrices of large dimension that arise when working with 2D crossed structures such as woodpiles. The essential difficulty is associated with the inversion of the
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
96
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
matrices Tj, the elements of which decay with increasing plane wave order toward the edge of the matrix [39,75,76]. One technique for addressing this ill-conditioning [75], developed for 2D lattices of high symmetry (e.g., square, rectangular and hexagonal lattices), involves symmetrizing and antisymmetrizing the original eigenvalue equations. In the case of the square symmetric lattice, this leads to a modified eigenvalue equation 1 g, S I (Ra T a )(Ra T a ) 2c m m1 1 (f a f b ), c g 2 2
S1Tg
(2.105)
While (2.105) overcomes the conditioning problems of the original T-matrix method, its applicability is restricted to lattices of high symmetry where symmetrization of the eigenvalue equations is possible. Accordingly, we outline a general technique developed independently in [39,76]. Following the treatment in [39], we introduce the R-matrix that relates the electric and magnetic fields on both sides of the layer by e a eb
R k R12 11 1/2 a X1/2 X kb R21 R22
(2.106)
Here, X1/2 diag(X 1/2, X 1/2), and the vectors of plane wave coefficients for the total electric and magnetic fields are given by ej X 1/2 (fj fj ) and kj X1/2 1 (f j f j ), with X j or X diag(j, j ), respectively, for the cases of 1D and 2D gratings. Explicit forms for the partition elements of the X and R matrices are given in [39] and may be derived by substituting the representations for ej and kj in terms of the fj into (2.106). With these, the cross-layer transfer equation (2.104) may be recast as g b Mg a
(2.107)
where I R 11 I R11 g j fj , I I
and
R R R1 11 I 12 M 22 I 0 0
R21
0
(2.108) The quasiperiodicity f b mf a imposed by the Bloch condition in turn requires that g b mg a , resulting in the eigenvalue problem Mga mga. This form, however, is little more than a reformulation of the original method (2.104) and is thus no better conditioned, specifically because the problems afflicting the inversion
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
97
of the matrices Tj also arise in the inversion of R12. However, the use of the R-matrix nomenclature has simplified the structure of the resulting eigenvalue equation and allows us to convert easily a problem involving an ill-conditioned matrix into one that is well conditioned. While this can be done in two ways [39,76], we deal here with only one, defining a derived matrix R D 12
M′ (I zM)1
D
D[ R12 ( R22 R11 )]
R12 DR21
(2.109)
where D {R12 z2R21 z(R22 R11)}1. The matrix M has eigenvalues (1 zm)1, where m is an eigenvalue of M, and hence the eigenvalues of M can be inferred from those of M . While z is chosen to avoid singular behavior, the values z 1 generally suffice. An alternative treatment, analogous to the symmetrization process that led to (2.105), leads to the introduction of an alternative derived matrix M (zM z1M1)1, whose form can be calculated algebraically and which is free of conditioning problems. Setting z 1 leads to a matrix whose eigenvalues (m 1/m) 1/(2c) occur in precisely the same form as those of [75].
2.5.3 CALCULATION
OF
BAND DIAGRAMS AND BAND SURFACES
Crucial to the study of photonic crystal devices is the capacity to compute the band diagram of the underlying lattice and dispersion diagrams for defect states. The most widely used tool for such calculations is the plane wave method for solving the operator eigenvalue equation [14] 1 v2 H(r ) H(r ) 2 H(r ) c e(r )
(2.110)
For a given choice of Bloch vector k0, the eigenvalue equation (2.110) is discretized into a plane wave basis to yield an algebraic eigenvalue problem that is solved for the permissible frequencies v of the modes, which, in turn, are characterized by the eigenvectors. By scanning k0 over the Brillouin zone, we can generate a band surface diagram. In a similar manner, by scanning the Bloch vector k0 around the exterior of the irreducible part of the Brillouin zone, we may generate photonic band diagrams in their usual form. While the capacity to select explicitly the value of the Bloch vector serves to facilitate the computation of band diagrams, it simultaneously introduces a serious drawback for working with dispersive media having material constants that depend on frequency — the eigenvalue output of the numerical problem. It is in dealing with this problem that transfer matrix methods show their strengths, building into the problems from the outset the actual material constants for the chosen frequency. The scan of the Brillouin zone thus commences with the choice of frequency and transverse component of the Bloch vector and produces, from the solution of an algebraic eigenvalue problem (2.104), the out-of-plane component of the Bloch vector.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals 0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
kd /2
kd/2
98
0.4
0.2
0.2 Γ
M a2
y
Y b2 Y
a1
x
Γ (a)
M
Γ
M
K
y
ky M
a2
b1 kx
a1 x
M
b2 k y M K kx
Γ (b)
b1
FIGURE 2.18 (a) Band diagram for the square lattice (cylindrical rods of radii a/D 0.3 and refractive index n 3.0, E|| polarization); (b) band diagram for the hexagonal lattice (cylindrical rods of radii a/D 0.3 and refractive index n 3.6, E|| polarization). In both cases, the Wigner–Seitz cell, the first Brillouin zone, and irreducible part of the first Brillouin zone are shown.
The downside of this approach is some complication in the drawing of the band surfaces and band diagrams. In what follows, we discuss the use of transfer matrix methods in band diagram calculations that, for brevity, we restrict to 2D lattices characterized by lattice basis vectors a1 and a2 and reciprocal lattice vectors b1 and b2, normalized such that bi aj 2pdij (Figure 2.18). Any point in the directed lattice may thus be written r h1a1 h2a2, and correspondingly any point in the first Brillouin zone of the reciprocal lattice can be specified by k0 j1b1 j2b2 for j1, j2 [1/2, 1/2]. To build up the band surface, we must consider a sequence of diffraction problems associated with the lattice composed of layers of gratings generated by a1 and translated by a2. For a given frequency v kc and Bloch vector component parallel to the plane of the grating k0g k0 a1 2pj1, we must run our grating code to produce scattering matrices that lead to the transfer matrix, the eigenvalues m of which yield j2 arg(m)/(2p). Iterating in both frequency (or wavenumber k) and j1 then leads to the construction of the band surface diagram. Of course, the basic grating could have been alternatively chosen as that generated by a2 or, for that matter, any grating generated by an arbitrary choice of Miller indices. The only requirement is that we can devise an efficient procedure by which we can scan the first Brillouin zone to search for propagating eigenstates. In the case of high symmetry lattices, it is usual to plot band diagrams that are generated by traversing the perimeter of the irreducible part of first Brillouin zone. In the case of a square symmetric lattice (Figure 2.18[a]) with direct lattice vectors a1 (d, 0) and a2 (0, d), the corresponding reciprocal lattice vectors are b1 (2p/d, 0), b2 (0, 2p/d), and the perimeter of the irreducible part of the first Brillouin zone is designated as YM with three segments respectively parameter– ized as Y: k0 0b1 j2b2, YM: k0 j1b1 b2/2, M: k0 j(b1 b2)/2.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
99
To expedite the calculations, we need to choose one or more grating configurations that exploit the lattice symmetry and generate the band diagram using only a sequence of frequency scans. Two preferred configurations are the normal incidence and Littrow mounts which, in the language of lattices and photonic crystals, correspond to periodic (Brillouin zone center) and antiperiodic (Brillouin zone edge) boundary conditions. In the case of the Y segment, we see that the grating generated by a1 (i.e., the grating whose plane is parallel to a1), sets k0g k0 a1 0, thus enabling this segment to be generated with a frequency scan corresponding to periodic boundary conditions. For the YM segment, we ask what grating, characterized by some generating vector a, is ideal in the sense of reducing k0g k0 a j1b1 a -12 b2 a to a suitably convenient value. Indeed, it is clear that the choice of a a2 will yield k0g p, and so the YM segment can be generated with a frequency scan with a constituent grating (a2) operated in an antiperiodic configuration. Finally, for the M segment, we can set k0g 0 by choosing a grating plane a a1 a2 because this is perpendicular to the vector b1 b2 that generates the M segment of the band diagram. The constructions needed for the band diagram of a hexagonal lattice may be derived in a similar manner. From Figure 2.18(b), we see that the M segment is parallel to b2, which is orthogonal to the generator a1 of the primary grating. Thus, the M segment of the band diagram can be generated by a frequency scan based on the primary grating operated at normal incidence, i.e., with a periodic boundary condition. In turn, the MK segment is parallel to a1 and thus is orthogonal to b2. Hence, a grating generated by a lattice vector parallel to b2 operated with a periodic boundary condition can generate the MK segment of the band diagram. Finally, we observe that the K segment is parallel to a2 and orthogonal to b1. However, in a hexagonal lattice the two directions b1 and b2 are equivalent, and thus the entire MK segment can be generated by a single grating operated in normal incidence. Figure 2.18(b) illustrates the band structure of this lattice by plotting the frequency of propagating states for each point on the perimeter MYM of the irreducible Brillouin zone. Two bandgaps are visible as shaded regions in the figure. The occurrence of bandgaps and propagating states may be visualized in various ways appropriate to a range of different applications. In the case of air-cored microstructured optical fibers (MOFs), in which the light is guided axially through the air hole by photonic bandgap effects, we are interested primarily in locating a complete bandgap of the bulk crystal that simultaneously corresponds to a guided mode. Here, it is convenient to characterize the bulk crystal by a projected form of the band diagram, i.e., the finger diagram (Figure 2.6). The finger diagram derives from a three-dimensional dispersion diagram with axes corresponding to frequency v, axial propagation constant b, and a traversal of the in-plane Brillouin zone. The actual 2D finger diagram involves a projection onto the vb plane to form a density plot in which the intensity of the coloration is proportional to the number of propagating states. Figure 2.19 shows a projected band diagram for an infinite woodpile [40,83]. The vertical axis is proportional to the wavenumber, while the horizontal axis
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
100
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals 0.8
y
x
z
kd /2
0.6 0.4 0.2 0
M X
Γ Γ
X
M
Γ
k0 (a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.19 (a) Two unit cells of a woodpile structure. (b) The two-dimensional projection of the band structure for a woodpile: cylindrical rods have radii of 0.1 m and index 3.6. The pitch is 0.711 m, and the separation between layers is 0.21 m. (Reprinted with permission from G.H. Smith, et al., Phys. Rev. E, 67, 056620, 2003.)
traverses the irreducible part of the projected Brillouin zone, as shown in the inset. For the woodpile, the projected Brillouin zone is a square and, from symmetry arguments, one need consider only the irreducible octant labeled XM in Figure 2.19. The projection is from the k0z direction, which derives from the solution of the eigenvalue equation, again with the coloration set proportional to the number of propagating states. The completely white regions correspond to an absence of propagating states.
2.5.4 CLASSIFICATION
OF THE
EIGENVALUES
A necessary precursor to the modeling of photonic crystal devices using Bloch mode expansions is a thorough understanding of the modes and their properties. Accordingly, in this section, we focus on the classification of the modes and the derivation of key properties such as orthogonality relations. The outline here is necessarily brief, and we refer readers to [81] for a detailed treatment. The eigenvalues m of T (2.104) may be partitioned according to the direction of mode propagation. The evanescent or nonpropagating states (i.e., those eigenvalues associated with bandgap states) have |m| 1 and are readily classified according to their magnitudes. Those with |m| 1 are regarded as forward propagating, while those with |m| 1 are backward propagating. The classification of the propagating states for which |m| 1 is more subtle and must be ascertained from the direction of energy propagation, i.e., the direction of the y-component of the group velocity vg,y dk/dk0y F, y/(kD), where e F ,y
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
H H f f
I iI f p p iI p I p f
(2.111)
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
r
c−2
101
M1 +
M2
c2
M3
t D
FIGURE 2.20 A typical three-segment photonic crystal device showing the component regions M1, M2, and M3, three lateral supercells of the model, a constituent grating bounded by dashed lines, and the field quantities used in Equations (2.135) and (2.136).
denotes the net vertical (y) energy flux through the unit cell, and D denotes the (positive) energy density per unit cell. The sign of F,y thus determines the propagation direction, and we interpret F,y 0 as a forward propagating state and correspondingly F,y 0 as a backward propagating state. In (2.111), the derivation of which [38,40] involves a Poynting vector integral, the flux comprises terms that arise from both the backward and forward plane waves {f} that comprise the Bloch mode (2.104). The components of these vectors are associated with the diffraction orders of the E|| /H|| fields, the terms of which may be either propagating or evanescent. In (2.111), for the woodpile and other 2D layers, Ip diag(Ip, Ip,) and Ip– diag(Ip–, Ip–,) with Ip [drsr], I p– [drs(1 r)], and r taking the values 1 and 0 respectively for propagating (i.e., js real) or evanescent (i.e., js imaginary) plane wave orders s. For 1D layers operated in a principal polarization, the form of (2.111) is unchanged, although the dimensions of the vectors differ since they comprise coefficients of only the electric or only the magnetic field. In this case we have [75] e F ,y
H f
H f
I p iI p
iI p f
I p f
(2.112)
Lattice symmetry further constrains the form of the forward and backward modes. In the case of up-down symmetric structures such as 2D arrays formed from a rectangular lattice of 1D cylinder gratings for which Ra Rb and Ta Tb, it is easily shown [75] that the eigenvalues m and m1 are paired, respectively corresponding to eigenvectors [fT fT]T and [fT fT]T. For simplicity in what follows, we restrict the discussion to a study of twodimensional photonic crystal devices [79,81,84,85,86] operated in either of their principal polarizations. In preparation for the Bloch mode modeling of extended photonic crystal devices of the type displayed in Figure 2.20, we consider a segment of a 2D photonic crystal comprising a number of cylinders per unit cell. The structures that we model, i.e., waveguides, splitters, couplers, interferometers, etc., are devices that rely on defect modes of the bulk crystal. Accordingly, we must choose the period of our supercell to be sufficiently large to ensure effective
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
102
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
isolation between adjacent periods to avoid undesirable cross-talk between adjacent supercells. In such circumstances, the calculations become independent of k0x, the lateral component of the Bloch vector, and it is convenient to choose k0x 0. With the modes partitioned into forward/backward sets, the transfer matrix can be diagonalized T FLF1 ,
F F′ , F F F′
0 L 0 ′
(2.113)
a result that encapsulates the entire set of eigenvalue equations TF FL. The columns of the matrix F are the eigenvectors of T, and L is a diagonal matrix, the entries of which are the corresponding eigenvalues m. In light of the mode partitioning, the columns of the matrices F, F are formed from the f components of the eigenvectors, respectively, for the forward and backward modes, with and being diagonal matrices that contain the corresponding mj. 2.5.4.1 Formal Properties of Bloch Modes For structures of the kind that we are considering here, namely those that can be constructed from general lattices of multicylinder gratings, the physical concepts of reciprocity and energy conservation introduce other important constraints on the modes. The origin of such properties requires a careful analysis, which we now summarize [81]. Firstly we consider reciprocity, a geometrical constraint that is independent of material properties and constrains the transfer matrix to be symplectic [87], thereby pairing the forward and backward modes. Its derivation in 2D follows from an application of Green’s theorem
V f
n
∫ (Vg 2V f V f 2Vg )dA ∫ Vg
Vf
Vg ds n
(2.114)
around a supercell layer for fields Vf and Vg, each satisfying the same Helmholtz equation (for a given k), and which on the upper ( j a) and lower ( j b) boundaries of the grating layer are expressed in plane wave expansions V f( j ) (r )
∑ xs 1/2 [ fs( j )eix ( yy ) fs( j )eix ( yy ) ] eia x s
j
s
j
s
(2.115)
s
From this it follows that the bilinear product gTj Qpwfj is invariant under translation by a grating layer, i.e., gTa Qpw fa gTb Qpw fb
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
where
0 Q Qpw Q 0
(2.116)
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
103
the skew-symmetry of which, i.e., QTpw Qpw, follows from the corresponding antisymmetry of the cross-product inherited from Maxwell’s equations. In (2.116), Q denotes the reversing permutation derived from the identity matrix I by reversing the order of the rows. The layer independence of the bilinear product, together with the transfer matrix relations fb Tfa and gb Tga, allows us to show that T is symplectic [87], i.e., TT Qpw T TQpw TT Qpw
(2.117)
Because TT and T1 are related by a similarity transformation TT QpwT1Q1 pw (from (2.117)), the eigenvalues of TT, i.e., m, and T1, i.e., m1, must be paired. The eigenstates are thus arranged into forward and backward propagating pairs, respectively associated with eigenvalues m and 1/m, and in turn this relates the eigenvalue partitions of L (2.113) according to 1. The second of the constraints follows from energy conservation and hence is appropriate only for lossless systems, in contrast to reciprocity, which is universally applicable. Its derivation follows from the application of Green’s theorem V V f g 0 ∫ (V f 2Vg Vg 2V f )dA ∫ V f Vg n n
ds
(2.118)
to a grating layer within the photonic crystal, the area integral of which vanishes only for lossless systems. This, together with the quasiperiodicity of the field, means that the bilinear product gHIpwf is conserved. That is,
g aHIpw fa
g bHIpw fb
where
I p Ipw iI p
iI p
I p
(2.119)
Note that with g f, the bilinear form gHIpwf is simply a generalization of the forward flux F,y fHIpwf (2.111) of the plane wave field. The conservation of the bilinear form (2.119) together with the transfer relations fb Tfa and gb Tfg leads to a new conservation relation satisfied by the transfer matrix, namely T HIpw T Ipw
or
T H Ipw T1Ipw1
(2.120)
– and m With TH and T1 related by a similarity transformation, the eigenvalues m must also be paired. Combining this with the pairing relations implied by the symplectic nature of T, we see that the eigenvalues must always occur in a –, m1, m –1}. quadruple {m, m In our subsequent treatment of propagation of light in extended photonic crystal devices, it is convenient to work with modes that are normalized in such a way that they enable physical quantities to be expressed in their simplest and
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
104
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
most amenable forms. This requires that the modes represented by the columns of F be scaled appropriately. Following the treatment in [81], we may derive the respective modal reciprocity and modal orthogonality relations FT QpwF Q bm ,
0 I Q bm I 0 I m
FHIpwF Ibm ,
(2.121)
iIm
Ibm
(2.122)
Im
iI m
from the diagonalized form of T (2.113) and the conservations relations (2.117) and (2.120). In (2.122), the matrices Im and Im– are diagonal with unit entries on the diagonal respectively only for propagating and nonpropagating Bloch modes. It thus follows that the plane wave and modal “flux” matrices, respectively Ipw and Ibm, are isomorphic. The second of the results in (2.122) expresses the orthogonality of the modes — a result that we exploit in Section 2.5.6.
2.5.5 DEFECT MODE MODELING CRYSTAL DEVICES
OF
EXTENDED PHOTONIC
The extended devices that we wish to model comprise an arbitrary number of PC segments — a semi-infinite input and output segment at each end and a finite number of intermediate segments, each having a finite number of layers. For simplicity, the analysis that we present here is for a three-segment device — see Figure 2.20, which is structurally similar to Fabry–Perot interferometer — which can be easily generalized to an arbitrary number of layers by recursion [81]. In each of the regions Mn, n 1, 2, 3 (labeled from top to bottom), the field can be expanded in terms of forward and backward Bloch modes, the amplitudes of which are given by vectors c n. Relative to the respective phase origins at the top and bottom of the segment (comprising Ln layers) for each of the forward (c n ) and backward (cn ) propagating modal fields, the field at some interface l [0, Ln] can be expressed as a plane wave expansion, the forward and backward components of which are represented by vectors of plane wave coefficients f n (l) where f (l ) F F′ n n ( L l ) n l n fn (l ) c n Fc n (l ) n c n n F′ fn (l ) Fn n def
(2.123)
with def c n (l ) L (l )c c n (l ) n n c n (l )
where
l n
Ln (l )
0
( Ln l ) n
0
c n c n
, c n
(2.124)
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
105
The importance of working with appropriately normalized modes becomes apparent when we wish to transform the forward flux expressed in the plane wave basis to a more useful form in the modal basis. Exploiting the normalized form (2.122), the forward flux at any level l in medium Mn can be converted from the plane wave representation to the equivalent modal form by en (l ) fnH (l )Ipw fn (l ) c nH (l )FnHIpwFn c n (l ) c nH (l )Ibm,n c n (l )
(2.125)
where Ibm,n denotes the flux matrix with respect to the Bloch mode basis of medium Mn. In turn, en (l ) c nHLHn (l )Ibm,nLHn (l )c n
H H c cn n
I m L iI n m
iImLn cn Im
c n
(2.126)
Naturally, the resulting expression for the flux (2.126) is independent of layer l, the proof of which relies on the eigenvalue pairings discussed in the previous section. Note also that as the length of the segment Ln → , the flux approaches 2 2 mm |c m | |c m | , the difference between the forward and backward fluxes computed over only the propagating states m. For small separations, however, evanescent mode terms can play a significant role and typically must be taken into account for Ln 5.
2.5.6 INTERFACING PHOTONIC CRYSTAL MEDIA AND FRESNEL COEFFICIENTS Having established the formal properties of the modes and their representation in matrix form, we can turn now to the study of propagation of Bloch modes through photonic crystal structures formed from stacks of identical layers (see Figure 2.20). The interfacing of two semi-infinite PC media requires the application of field continuity conditions at the matching boundary and is best represented by interface reflection and transmission matrices, which are the matrix analogues of the familiar scalar Fresnel coefficients in optics. For the sake of both brevity and simplicity of nomenclature, we demonstrate this with a simplified geometry comprising up-down symmetric layers arranged in a square or rectangular lattice. In this case, the forward and backward modes are related by F n F n and F n Fn . The generalized Fresnel reflection and transmission coefficients are derived by matching the fields along the interface between the two PC media, Mn and Mm. Here, we consider an incident field of modal amplitudes c n incident from above within a semi-infinite region Mn giving rise to a reflected field with modal amplitudes cn in Mn and a transmitted field c m in Mm. Assuming a common background medium in which each of Mn and Mm is formed, the application of the continuity conditions simply reduces to equating the forward and backward components of
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
106
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
the plane wave fields on the matching interface. Thus, F F n n c c n n F F n n
F m c , m F m
or
Fn c n Fm c m
(2.127)
T T where cm [cT m 0 ] . Solving these equations, we deduce that the generalized Fresnel matrices Rnm and Tnm, respectively defined by cn Rnmc n and c T c , are given by m nm n
R nm (Fn− )1 (I − R m R n )1 (R m R n )Fn
(2.128)
Tnm (Fm )1 (I R n R m )1 (I R n2 )Fn
(2.129)
1 denotes the reflection scattering where in (2.128) and (2.129) Rj Fj (F j) matrix of a semi-infinite crystal of material Mj from free space [75,81]. With the modes normalized according to (2.121) and (2.122), it can be shown [81] that the Fresnel scattering matrices satisfy reciprocity relations that are elegantly expressed in terms of scattering matrix symmetry, i.e., RTnm Rnm and TTnm Tmn, and energy conservation relations that follow the form of the plane wave scattering matrix conservation relations, e.g., H I H H R nm bm,n R nm Tnm I bm,m Tnm I bm,n iR nm I bm,n iI bm,n R nm (2.130) H I H H R mn bm,m Tnm Tmn I bm,n R nm iTmn I bm,n iI bm,m Tnm
(2.131)
The Fresnel matrices given in (2.128) and (2.129) exploit the complete basis of modes, the dimensions of which are determined by the dimension of the plane wave basis used in computing the plane wave scattering matrices for each grating layer. While it is necessary to have a common dimension for all plane wave quantities, it can be advantageous to be able to restrict the basis of modes that is used in field calculations, particularly in those situations in which comparatively few modes dominate the propagation problem. The system of equations (2.127) then needs to be considered in a least squares sense, the solution of which relies on the modal orthogonality relations (2.122). To derive this, we begin with the equation Fncn Fmcm, which expresses field continuity at the matching interface, and seek to minimize the norm of the difference of the left- and righthand sides. In a manner analogous to Galerkin’s method, we project the total field equation onto one of the modal bases and the field derivative equation onto the other basis. We commence by premultiplying both sides of the equation by FH n Ipw to derive FnHIpwFn c n Ibm,n c n FnHIpwFm c m
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(2.132)
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
107
projecting the system of equations onto the modal basis for Mn. Premultiplying through (2.132) by [I I] then allows us to extract the field derivative equation cn c +n J nH K nm cm
(2.133)
with Knm GH n JpG m, G n F n F n , and Jq Iq iIq–. In the definition of Jq, the quantities Iq and Iq– refer to the relevant components of either of the constituent matrices of the matrix Ipw (2.119) for plane waves or its Bloch mode equivalent Ibm,n (2.122) applicable to the region Mn. Correspondingly, projecting the field matching equations onto the modal basis for Mm by premultiplying through Fncn Fmcm by [I I]F H m Ipw, we derive the total field equation H c J K (c c ), which is the pair to (2.133). Finally, combining these m n m nm n leads to expressions for the Fresnel reflection and transmission matrices
R nm (I Bnm )1 (I Bnm ),
H (I B )1 Tnm 2 J m K nm nm
(2.134)
H H according to c n Rnmc n and c m Tnmc n . In (2.134), Bnm Jn KnmJmKnm, takes the role of an impedance matrix, the dimension of which is bn bn where bn is the dimension of the truncated modal basis for region Mn. Thus, Rnm and Tnm respectively have dimensions of bn bn and bm bn. Both the symmetry and energy conservation relations continue to hold analytically, a consequence of the normalizations of the modes in (2.121) and (2.122).When the modal bases are not truncated and the reflection and transmission matrices are square and have order identical to that of the cardinality of the set of plane waves used in the calculation, the expressions in (2.134) reduce readily to those in (2.128) and (2.129), again due to the mode energy normalization (2.122) and the completeness of the basis. In conclusion, we observe that all of these results hold analytically, independent of field truncation errors, when the individual layer scattering matrices are computed using the multipole method. It is shown in [38] that the multipole method preserves analytically the corresponding reciprocity and energy properties in the plane wave basis, and it is demonstrated in [81] that this scattering matrix formulation carries these results through into the Bloch mode basis.
2.5.7 RECURSIVELY COMBINING PC STACK SEGMENTS Having characterized the single layer propagation problem (Section 2.5.5) and shown how the interfacing of adjacent layers may be characterized with Fresnel matrices (Section 2.5.6), we now formulate the solution of the propagation problem in Figure 2.20. We consider an incident field with Bloch mode amplitudes d incident from M1 onto the M1 M2 interface giving rise to a reflected Bloch mode field r in M1 and a transmitted Bloch mode field t in M3. In region M2 comprising L L2 layers, the field is expanded in terms of forward and backward Bloch modes, with respective amplitudes c 2 (with phase origin on the M1 M2
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
108
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
boundary), and c2 (with phase origin on the M2 M3 boundary). The field matching equations respectively on the M1 M2 and M2 M3 boundaries are then written as r R12 D T21L2 c2 ,
c2 T12 D R 21L2 c2
(2.135)
c2 R 23L2 c2 ,
t T23L2 c2
(2.136)
derived from a consideration of the reflection and transmission of Bloch fields at each boundary and the propagation of the field within M2. After solving (2.135) and (2.136), we may then infer the reflection (R) and transmission (T) scattering matrices for the three-segment structure from r RD and t TD. We thus derive R R13 R12 T21L2 R 23L2 (I R 21L2 R 23L2 )1 T12
(2.137)
T T13 T23L2 (I R 21L2 R 23L2 )1 T12
(2.138)
forms that are clearly generalizations of the Airy Formulae for a Fabry–Perot interferometer. Naturally, this result is easily generalized for multisegment PC devices comprising more than three layers [81].
2.6 MODELING OF PHOTONIC CRYSTAL DEVICES 2.6.1 BACKGROUND With the Bloch mode “toolkit,” relying on multipole methods for computing scattering matrices, now in place, we go on to discuss their application to the study of two-dimensional photonic crystal devices. Such devices rely on a 2D photonic bandgap for lateral confinement and guiding of light within a dielectric slab. Devices based on these structures have generated a great deal of interest recently because of their compact size and their ability to control the propagation of light on the wavelength scale. The Bloch mode calculation methods that use the multipole scattering matrix methods described in this chapter have proven to be very efficient for studying certain types of PC devices. In particular, devices incorporating multiple sections of identical waveguides are dealt with in an efficient manner using the transfer matrix methods described in Section 2.5 because the scattering matrices need be calculated only once for each distinct grating type. A number of numerical examples of the Bloch mode method applied to PC devices have been published elsewhere, so rather than simply reproducing the results here, we investigate in more detail some specific properties of three PC devices that have already been studied. The first two of these devices, the “folded directional coupler” (FDC) [84,85] and the coupled Y-junction [85] operate in an identical manner, and are treated together in Section 2.6.3. In Section 2.6.4 we
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
109
discuss the recirculating Mach–Zehnder interferometer [86] and present an analogous design using conventional optics. Although most of the discussions in this section do not rely explicitly on the Bloch mode or multipole methods, the Bloch mode method is a powerful tool that aids in the development of such simple models. By treating structures as grating stacks, we can use many of the tools developed for thin film optics to develop a better understanding of the underlying physics.
2.6.2 STRAIGHT PC WAVEGUIDES Many PC-based devices can be modeled as a sequence of waveguides of varying widths and lengths coupled together. Each of the devices discussed in this section is of this type. With the tools already developed earlier in this chapter, it is a straightforward procedure to calculate the transmission properties of simple waveguide structures. To model a straight photonic crystal waveguide, we choose a grating layer consisting of multiple cylinders per unit cell, with each supercell typically consisting of 11–21 cylinders. Removing one or more cylinders from each supercell results in a periodic array of straight waveguides when the grating layers are stacked to form a 2D crystal. The supercell period D is chosen to be large enough that the waveguide(s) in one supercell do not affect the waveguides in the neighboring supercells. The multicylinder supercell is treated as a single element of a grating with period D, and the techniques used in Section 2.5 can be applied. Recall that eigenvalues m with magnitude | m| 1 correspond to evanescent (nonpropagating) modes, whereas propagating modes have |m| 1. Waveguide modes appear as propagating modes at frequencies within the bandgap of the perfect photonic crystal. Mode dispersion curves are then easily calculated by extracting the longitudinal propagation constant (in the direction of the waveguide, i.e., k0 a2) from m exp(ik0 a2) for a range of wavelengths. When studying structures formed from finite lengths of waveguide, it is often sufficient to include only the propagating modes when calculating transmission or reflection properties. In this situation, the Bloch mode transmission and reflection matrices are greatly simplified, and it is often possible to derive scalar analytic expressions to describe the properties of the structure [47]. To exemplify this, we consider a finite single mode waveguide through an L layer 2D PC, bounded on either side by free space. The Airy transmission matrix (2.138) then reduces to T F2 (I R 22 )L2 (I R 2 L2 R 2 L2 )1 (F2 )1
(2.139)
after deriving the following forms for the relevant Fresnel matrices: 2 1 1 T23 F 2 (I R2), T12 (F2 ) , and R23 R21 R2 (F2 ) F 2 . Then, provided that the single mode guide is sufficiently long (typically L
5), the term 2L mLwwH, approaching this form in the limit as L → . Here, wT [1 0 0 … 0], and the limiting form of L2 is of unit rank. In such circumstances, only the propagating mode needs to be considered, and Equation (2.139) may be simplified using the Sherman-Morrison formula [88] to invert the rank one
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
110
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
perturbation. Using energy conservation relations (2.131), a simplified form of the transmitted flux may be derived [79] eF , y
1 |r|2 |N_D|2 |1 r 2 m 2 |
(2.140)
In (2.140) m is the eigenvalue of the single propagating mode and r is the (1, 1) element of R2, its complex reflection coefficient. The denominator of (2.140) characterizes the resonance, while the numerator (1 | r |2) expresses the net energy propagation of a unit flux forward mode and a backward mode of flux | r |2 generated by reflection at the rear surface. Coupling of the incident field into the primary mode is given by an overlap integral N_D, where N_ denotes row 1 of (F2 )1. As is evident, such an analysis can provide accurate asymptotic results as well as real physical insight into the propagation characteristics of the structure being studied. In this and subsequent examples, the semianalytic expressions often require numerical input of the propagation constants for various waveguide modes, which are simply calculated using the procedure described above.
2.6.3 RESONANT FILTERS AND JUNCTIONS A large number of photonic crystal based optical devices have been demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally in recent years. Many of these devices are simply photonic crystal analogues of conventional optical devices, and as such they do not fully exploit the unique properties of the photonic crystal. One such property is the total reflection of light from a photonic crystal slab regardless of incident angle when operating at frequencies within a bandgap. In the case of a realistic 2D photonic crystal slab, this is only an approximation as light can be coupled into radiation modes above and below the slab. Although we do not explicitly treat out-of-plane losses here, the properties discussed are generic, and realistic device designs could be proposed to minimize these effects. Figure 2.21 shows two basic PC devices that can be studied efficiently using the techniques of this chapter. The device in Figures 2.21(a) and 2.21(b) is a folded directional coupler (FDC) — a notch-rejection filter with a very high-Q response [84]. A similar device is the symmetric coupler, or coupled Y-junction, shown in Figures 2.21(c) and 2.21(d). This exhibits very high transmission over a large bandwidth [85], a property that is used to design a PC-based Mach–Zehnder interferometer in Section 2.6.4 [86]. Both devices in Figures 2.21 are modeled as three distinct waveguide sections, M1–M3, where M1 and M3 are semi-infinite stacks of identical gratings and M2 is a stack of identical gratings. In the case of the FDC, the input waveguide and output waveguides in M1 and M3 support single modes denoted by |cL and |cR, respectively. Section M2 consists of two waveguides and thus supports two modes — one symmetric (|c), and one anti–symmetric (|c) — across much of the bandgap. The coupled Y-junction consists of a single mode input waveguide in M1, triple waveguides in M2, and a pair of output waveguides in M3. Although the triple and double waveguide sections in the structure of Figures 2.21(c)
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
M1
111
L
L
M2
M3 R
(a)
(b)
c
(c)
(d)
FIGURE 2.21 (a) Geometry of the FDC and (b) schematics of the propagating modes in each of the three sections. All of the cylinders are identical, and the shading is to emphasize the three distinct waveguide sections. (c) Geometry of the coupled Y-junction and (d) schematics of the propagating modes of even symmetry. The photonic crystal is a square lattice of cylinders with refractive index n 3, period d, and radius 0.3d in a background of air.
and 2.21(d) can both support an antisymmetric propagating mode, the symmetry of the device relative to the input waveguide means that only modes of even symmetry can be coupled. Thus, the junction can also be considered to support a single input mode |cc; two symmetric modes, |c1 and |c3, in M2; and a single output mode, |c in M3. There is thus a direct mapping between the modes in each section of the FDC and those of the equivalent sections of the junction. In a full Bloch mode analysis of the two structures, both the propagating and evanescent Bloch modes are included in the calculations, with the coupling between the Bloch modes at an interface given by the generalized Fresnel reflection and transmission matrices Rnm and Tnm defined in Equations (2.128) and (2.129). In a typical calculation using the complete basis, the Bloch mode basis and the plane wave basis have the same dimension, and thus the Bloch mode calculation includes a large number of evanescent modes. Often, however, it is sufficient to include only the propagating modes by truncating Rmn and Tmn to the dimensions of the propagating modes in each region.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
112
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
The devices in Figure 2.21 each have two interfaces, so we require six Fresnel matrices, R12, R21, R23, T12, T21, and T23, to describe fully propagation from M1 to M3 using Equations (2.128) and (2.129). The truncated orders of each of these matrices are determined by the number of propagating modes on either side of the relevant interface. For instance, R12 describes modes incident and reflected in section M1 (which only supports a single mode) and hence R12 is characterized by a scalar. For the same reason, R21 and R23 are 2 2 matrices. Since T12 describes transmission of the single mode in M1 into the two modes of M2, it must be column vector with two rows (i.e., a 2 1 matrix). Similarly, T21 and T23 are 1 2 matrices (i.e., row vectors). While the transmission properties of the FDC and coupled Y-junction are described accurately by the propagating mode treatment, the computing requirements are only moderately reduced because it is still necessary to include the full basis of plane waves to represent the propagating Bloch modes. A further approximation can be used to derive a semianalytic expression for both the FDC and the Y-junction transmission [85]. To do this, we use approximate relationships between the modes of each region to write down simple forms for the Fresnel matrices. For instance, the input mode of the Y-junction, |cc, can be approximated by a superposition of the modes in the triple guide region, as – |cc (|c1 |c3)/2, and similar expressions can be found for the modes of the output waveguide. Ignoring any back reflection that may occur when the single input waveguide interfaces to region M2, we can then write down expressions – – for the matrices R12 [0] and T12 [1/2 1/2]T. The remaining Fresnel matrices are found using similar arguments and substituted into Equation (2.129) for the three-layer structure where propagation through the central layer is represented by the matrix , which is similarly truncated to a 2 2 diagonal matrix of eigenvalues mj exp(ibjd), where j 1, 2. Finally we express the propagation constants of the two modes in M2 in terms of the average propagation constant – and define b (b1 b2)/2 and b (b1 b2)/2 for the Y-junction and similar expressions for the FDC by replacing the subscripts (1, 2) with (, ). This last approximation is valid when the mode splitting in M2 is relatively small. After some manipulation, the complex reflection and transmission amplitudes r and t can be written as r
cos2 (bL ) exp (2ibL ) , 1 sin 2 (bL ) exp (2ib) L
t
i exp (ibL ) sin(bL )(1 exp (2ibL )) 1 sin 2 (bL ) exp (2ibL ) (2.141)
Thus, the transmitted and reflected intensity can be expressed as eR r2
1 B , eT t2 , 1 B 1 B
where
B
4sin 2 (bL ) cos 2 ( bL )
cos 4 (bL )
(2.142) so that eR eT 1. Although the two devices presented here have identical expressions for their transmittance, they were designed to have very different properties. As shown in © 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
113 1
109
0.8
103
0.6
10–3
0.4
10–9
0.2
T
1015
10–15 3.015
3.02
3.025 /d (a)
3.03
3.035
1
109
0.8
103
0.6 T
1015
10−3 10−9 10−15
0.4
cos2(L) sin2(∆L) cos4(∆L) B = 4cos2(L)sin2(∆L)/cos4(∆L) Transmission = B/(1+B)
3
3.05
3.1
3.15
3.2
0.2
3.25
/d (b)
FIGURE 2.22 (a) Transmission of the FDC shown in Figure 2.21(a) (right axis) plotted as a function of normalized wavelength and values of the various terms in Equation (2.142). (b) Transmission of the coupled Y-junction shown in Figure 2.21(b) (right axis). The other lines show the same functions as are plotted in Figure 2.21(a) for the different waveguide parameters.
Figure 2.22(a), the FDC operates as a high-Q notch rejection filter, whereas the junction is designed for a maximum high-transmission bandwidth (Figure 2.22[b]). The transmission properties of these devices can vary widely with changes in the waveguide separation or the length L. To identify each of the features in a typical transmission spectrum, we need to consider the effects of each of the terms in Equation (2.142). In Figure 2.22, the trigonometric functions are plotted as a function of wavelength along with the value of B and the device transmittance, calculated from Equation (2.142) for both the FDC and the Y-junction of Figure 2.21. From this figure and Equation (2.142), it can be seen that eT → 0 when B → 0, and eT → 1 when B → , where each of these cases corresponds to one of the trigonometric functions vanishing. The relative positions of these zeros determine the sharpness, or otherwise, of the resonances of B, and, in turn, the overall response of the –L) and cos4(bL) occur close device. In the case of the FDC, the zeros of cos2(b together, resulting in B changing from 0 to over a very short wavelength range © 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
114
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
and leading to the high-Q resonance observed in the transmission function. Similarly, the parameters of the Y-junction design are such that B is large across a considerable wavelength range resulting in a wide bandwidth of hightransmission. From these examples we see that the Bloch mode analysis from Section 2.5 is very useful for investigating photonic crystal based devices. The key insight from this analysis is that, by working in the basis of Bloch functions, photonic crystal based devices can be analyzed in a manner similar to that for conventional guidedwave devices. It is then easily seen that the different responses of these two device classes are associated with, for example, a perfectly reflecting cladding. Apart from this, however, their responses can be understood in the same way.
2.6.4 MACH–ZEHNDER INTERFEROMETER A third photonic crystal device to which the multipole and Bloch methods have been applied is a Mach–Zehnder interferometer (MZI). In its simplest form, an MZI consists of an input beam, or waveguide, and two beam splitters, or Y-junctions — the first to divide the input into two beams and the second to recombine the beams after each has propagated along a different path. A basic free-space MZI is illustrated in Figure 2.23(a), where the input beam passes through a beam splitter (Y1) and then each propagates along a different path and is recombined by the second beam splitter (Y2). If the two paths are identical, the beams interfere constructively at the output port and a strong signal is detected. If, however, the path lengths of the two beams are different, the beams no longer combine constructively at the output, and some of the light is lost as radiation perpendicular to the measured output beam. In [86], we studied the MZI of Figure 2.23(b) consisting of single mode input and output waveguides, and efficient coupled Y-junctions. Using a simple modal model and full Bloch mode calculations, it was shown that such a device exhibits unusual recirculating behavior caused by reflection of light that would normally be radiated and lost in a conventional MZI. These reflections occur because the PC cladding surrounding the MZI does not allow light to radiate, and hence any light that is not coupled into the output port must be reflected back into the arms of the interferometer. With particular choices of path length L and/or wavelength, it is possible to design a recirculating MZI of this type with a considerably sharper phase response than a conventional MZI. The semianalytic expression derived for the recirculating MZI transmission is expressed as a function of the phase difference between the two arms w and the variable x bL w/2 where b is the propagation constant of the single waveguide mode. In this form, the transmitted intensity is given by eT
4sin 2 (x) cos2 (w /2) /sin 4 (w /2) 1 4sin 2 (x) cos2 (w /2) /sin 4 (w /2)
(2.143)
Observe that this expression can also be written in the form of Equation (2.142) where B is replaced by BMZ 4sin2(x) cos2 (w/2)/sin4(w/2). This observation that the FDC, the Y-junction, and the recirculating MZI all can be represented by an
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
115
In
50/50 beamsplitters Out
(a)
L
(b) m1 In
h
50/50 beamsplitters Out h
(c)
m2
FIGURE 2.23 (a) Conventional Mach–Zehnder interferometer using mirrors and beam splitters to separate and recombine the light. (b) Geometry of a photonic crystal based recirculating MZI using coupled Y-junctions to separate and recombine the light. (c) Conventional MZI modified to exhibit recirculating transmission characteristics.
expression with the same form may at first be a little surprising. However, this occurs because at some level each of the devices can be considered as a generalization of a Fabry–Perot resonator consisting of two interfaces that behave as selective mirrors separated by a cavity in which the light bounces back and forth. In the cases of the FDC and the Y-junction, the interfaces occur where one or more waveguide sections terminate. For the MZI, the Y-junction design behaves as an almost perfect symmetric junction over the operating bandwidth, and so each junction can be thought of as a distributed mirror that reflects modes with odd symmetry and transmits modes of even symmetry. Thus the MZI also displays Fabry–Perot-like resonant behavior. One feature of the recirculating MZI that is of particular interest is the phase response when bL p/2, 3p/2, 5p/2 …, for which eT
4cot 4 (w /2) 1 1 4cot 4 (w /2) 1 tan 4 (w /2) /4
(2.144)
This quartic response in tan(w/2) is considerably sharper than the quadratic response of a conventional MZI [86], and hence could be used to improve the switching characteristics of Mach–Zehnder interferometers in both linear and nonlinear devices.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
116
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
The recirculating properties of the PC MZI described here occur because light that is not coupled into the output waveguide is reflected back into the interferometer. The same result can be obtained in the free-space MZI illustrated in Figure 2.23(a) by placing reflectors in the path of the beam that is usually radiated. Such a design is illustrated in Figure 2.23(c), where the additional mirrors are labeled m1 and m2. When the beam splitters are characterized by complex reflection and transmission coefficients r |r|exp(ifr) and t |t|exp(i(fr p/2)) where |r|2 |t|2 1/2 and arg(t) arg(r) p/2, the transmission intensity is given by Equation (2.143) where x k0(L 2h) fr w/2, k0 2p/l, w is the phase difference and L is the length of the arms. With a choice of parameters such that k0(L 2h) fr p/2, 3p/2, 5p/2, …, the quartic phase response of Equation (2.144) is obtained. The examples discussed here illustrate that the multipole and Bloch mode methods not only provide an efficient numerical tool for studying the properties of a many 2D photonic crystal devices, but they also give insight into the underlying physics of the devices allowing simple models to be developed. In turn, these simple semianalytic expressions are an important tool for efficient device optimization and design.
2.7 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS This chapter has been built around three major themes in photonic modeling: (a) the systematic and integrated development of the multipole method (Section 2.2) as a key technique for modeling finite and infinite periodic structures (based on cylindrical scatterers); (b) the direct application of the multipole method in the study of two paradigm applications, namely the emission properties of sources embedded in photonic crystal clusters and propagation in microstructured optical fibers; and (c) the development of design tools based on the Bloch mode scattering matrix techniques and their application in the design of photonic crystal devices, our implementation of which has relied on multipole methods. In the investigations described in Sections 2.3 and 2.4, the multipole method has worked outstandingly well, at various times leading to results either not possible with other methods or not achievable with comparable accuracy or efficiency. Its strengths, of course, lie in the application of a basis that is well tailored to the geometry and symmetry of the structure and that provides rapidly convergent field expansions that underpin its use in accurate and efficient computational methods. Its weakness lies in the limitations of the structures that can be modeled because only for particular highly symmetric geometries is it possible to construct the necessary basis of multipole functions. In some circumstances, it is possible to adapt the method in a hybrid manner to handle arbitrary geometries. One particular example is the adoption of a numerical technique [35] that enables cylinders of arbitrary cross section to be handled. This technique integrates the wave equation (using a differential method) between the circles that inscribe and circumscribe the boundary and proceeds to encapsulate the electromagnetic properties of the scatterer in terms of an exterior
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
117
multipole reflection matrix — which is dense, in contrast to the diagonal matrices that arise when dealing with purely cylindrical geometries. In the case of microstructured optical fibres comprising a large number of identical cylinders, the significant computational time required for this initial step can be amortized over the multipole calculation for the entire structure with little overall reduction in efficiency. Despite retrofits of this type, however, multipole methods can never tackle the range of problems that are accessible to general purpose techniques. They are clearly special purpose methods and should be used in this context, exploiting the analytic flexibility and the computational advantages they afford for those structures for which they are applicable. In future work, we envisage extending our use of these methods to handle various 3D systems and anisotropic media. The Bloch mode toolkit, elaborated in Sections 2.5 and 2.6, has proven to be physically intuitive and analytically tractable. Of critical importance is the implicit concept of a photonic crystal as a stack of gratings (1D or 2D). From this emerges the key quantity R , the scattering matrix that characterizes the reflection from a semi-infinite photonic crystal. This quantity, which is the photonic crystal analogue of the Fresnel reflection coefficient in thin film optics, encapsulates the mode structure of the bulk PC and underpins the modeling of PC devices in a manner analogous to that adopted for their conventional guided wave counterparts. The quantity R is also important in underpinning the modeling of genuinely infinite structures that are often important in dealing with fundamental issues (e.g., existence of cutoffs, symmetry questions) that, in general, are not otherwise addressable. Typifying the style of questions that can be dealt with is that of the symmetry of modes in coupled photonic crystal waveguides — for which it can be shown that the fundamental may be either odd or even, in contrast to conventional directional couplers in which the fundamental mode is always even. The result [89] follows naturally from a simple model of coupled resonators (with infinite cladding) and an asymptotic analysis that is applicable to the long wavelength regime in which the properties are dominated by the sole propagating (specular) grating order. This physically intuitive analysis [89] reveals that PC directional couplers indeed have quite different properties than conventional couplers — with the fundamental mode being either odd or even depending on the separation of the guides, the characteristics of the bandgap, and the phase on reflection off the bulk photonic crystal — a result that cannot be derived using alternative approaches. In addition to its intuitive and tractable qualities, the Bloch mode method is also computationally easy to implement — with our particular implementation comprising a combination of Mathematica [90] functions and Fortran — with the applications suite implemented in the former, thus exploiting the excellent programming language and numerical linear algebra library, and with the multipole based grating scattering matrices (that define the transfer matrix) being implemented in the latter, with the two linked together using the MathLink toolkit [90]. While scattering matrices can be computed using a variety of techniques, the multipole method has been central to most of the applications that we have studied. The sole proviso for its use is that adjacent layers do not interpenetrate, thus allowing the use of plane wave expansions of fields at matching interfaces. This requirement, strictly speaking, is a
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
118
Electromagnetic Theory and Applications for Photonic Crystals
sufficient but not a necessary condition. Provided that the extent of the interpenetration is not too severe, plane wave expansions are still valid on the matching interfaces — a situation that is directly related to the Rayleigh controversy of diffraction grating theory [91] concerning the validity of plane wave representations for outgoing fields within the grooves of diffraction gratings. For noninterpenetrating cylinder gratings, however, the multipole technique is arguably the preferred method as the formulation is analytically elegant and structurally embodies key properties such as reciprocity and energy conservation analytically within the formulation. These properties may be verified effectively to within machine precision and are analytically inherited by the Bloch mode method making it both analytically tractable and easy to validate numerically. Nevertheless, in those circumstances when the multipole methods can no longer be used, a range of alternative techniques including differential, integral, and finite element methods may be employed. The Bloch mode scattering matrix method for modeling PC devices displays real computational advantages over general purpose techniques (e.g., FDTD methods) when handling extended devices that comprise many identical gratings because the propagation problem in a long segment can be handled with only a single set of modes. That said, however, there is no performance advantage to be gained when dealing with structures such as waveguide tapers that vary from layer to layer. The choice of the diffraction grating paradigm naturally imposes a supercell on the structure, thus modeling the behavior not of a single device but of an infinite parallel array of devices. The utility of the method is thus limited to gap frequencies, which, of course, is where photonic crystals are at their most useful, and further necessitates that the supercell be chosen sufficiently large to avoid cross-talk between adjacent structures. The most important feature of the Bloch mode techniques, however, is their capacity to provide physical insight into coupling and propagation problems in photonic crystal devices. This is achieved through the use of the natural Bloch mode basis and the introduction of Fresnel reflection and transmission matrices that characterize the interaction of fields at an interface between two PC devices, thereby enabling the formulation of the propagation problem in a manner that is essentially a generalization of the theory of thin film optics. Its structure also enables various asymptotic simplifications. In particular, the orthogonality properties enable the modal basis to be truncated to include only the most significant modes, while simultaneously preserving key properties such as energy conservation analytically within the formulation. This feature is quite significant in that it leads to the identification of an impedance matrix that may be of potential use in the characterization and optimization of devices based on photonic crystals. The combination of these features suggests that it may be possible to incorporate the successful design paradigms of thin film optics into the new context of photonic crystal devices. This is certainly an exciting possibility that merits further investigation. We conclude by noting that while the Bloch mode modeling theory in Section 2.5 has been presented in the context of cylindrical photonic crystals, it is readily extensible to general 3D systems, thus allowing the analysis of PC devices in 3D photonic crystals and photonic crystal slabs.
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
From Multipole Methods to Photonic Crystal Device Modeling
119
ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was produced with the assistance of the Australian Research Council under the ARC Centres of Excellence program.
REFERENCES [1] J.W.S. Rayleigh, The Theory of Sound, Dover, N