ADVICE TO PROSPECTIVE AUTHORS
Educational Studies in Mathematics is an international journal of research and scholarship in mathematics education. It aims to illuminate issues of principle, policy and practice in the field, and to promote the development of coherent bodies of theorised knowledge which can be brought to bear on these issues. Its intended readership includes those involved in teaching and studying mathematics education and those with responsibilities for professional leadership, as well as active researchers and scholars in the field. The journal seeks to publish articles that are clearly educational studies in mathematics, make original and substantial contributions to the field, are accessible and interesting to an international and diverse readership, provide a well founded and cogently argued analysis on the basis of an explicit theoretical and methodological framework, and take appropriate account of the previous scholarly work on the addressed issues. Submissions that demonstrate all these qualities are at a considerable advantage. Authors are advised to make the relevance and significance of their contribution clear in the introduction to their article and its conclusion. Although the work reported in a submission may well be located in a particular local or national context, it should be of interest to a wider audience, and written up in a way which makes it comprehensible to them. The editors recognise that many different forms of research and scholarship can contribute to the aims of the journal, and that these will draw on differing perspectives and approaches. But, in treating a particular area or aspect of mathematics, a submission should show critical awareness of other possible approaches. In particular, authors will be expected to be familiar with work already published in the journal, and to acknowledge, or build on it as appropriate. Equally, it can help readers who may be relatively unfamiliar with the topic and wish to learn more, if some reference is made to appropriate published sources which offer an authoritative overview of the area under consideration. Whatever approach a submission adopts to evidence and argument, it will be evaluated in terms of appropriate criteria of rigour, intended to ensure that the analysis is well founded and that it develops a resourceful and convincing argument. In engaging directly with a body of evidence, a submission should make explicit the Educational Studies in Mathematics 51: 1–2, 2002.
2
THE EDITORS
theoretical and methodological framework within which this evidence has been gathered and analysed. Both editors and readers of the journal appreciate conciseness, as long as it is not at the expense of clarity. Articles exceeding 20 journal pages in length are unlikely to be published unless they are of unusual significance and an extended presentation is clearly necessary to do justice to the material. Submissions that successfully distil the essence of an argument into 10 pages rather than 20 are particularly welcome, as this both focuses the particular communication and enables the journal to make a greater range of material available to its readership. T HE E DITORS
JO BOALER
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY: USING THEORY, RESEARCH AND ‘WORKING HYPOTHESES’ TO BROADEN CONCEPTIONS OF MATHEMATICS KNOWING1
ABSTRACT. What proficiencies are brought to bear when students work on mathematics problems? And to what extent may these be captured by knowledge categories? These are questions that I consider in this article, as I explore notions of competency, that go beyond knowledge to include the mathematical ‘dispositions’ that students bring to problems and the ‘practices’ with which they engage. This exploration will draw from two frameworks that have recently been introduced in the US. In addition, I consider the ways in which research knowledge is conceived and developed, reflecting upon the important role of theory and the potential of ‘working hypotheses’ for connecting with practice in new ways. KEY WORDS: dispositions, knowledge, mathematical practices, research, theory and practice
1. I NTRODUCTION
It is some years now since the day I received an important envelope in my mailbox in London, carrying the ESM postmark. I opened it nervously, knowing that the contents would tell me whether the first article I had written for publication, had been accepted. To my delight it was and that time marked not only my own beginning relationship with the journal, but with the scholarship of mathematics education. I was a masters student at the time, and unsure whether I could contribute to the world of academia. Educational Studies in Mathematics 51: 3–21, 2002. © 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
4
JO BOALER
I had submitted my paper to ESM, on the advice of one of my university professors, who told me it was one of the most important journals in mathematics education. Publishing in ESM was a wonderful way to begin my writing career, as the editor at that time, Leen Streefland, was supportive and encouraging in helping me prepare my article for publication. Since then ESM has continued to play an important role in my work, providing a forum through which I learn from research and ideas produced all around the world; indeed its international scope is one of the aspects I most appreciate about the journal. It was with great pleasure then that I received an invitation to write this paper, as part of the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the journal. I was asked to do so, as a current user of the journal, someone who publishes in ESM and uses it in teaching and research. I have therefore chosen to reflect upon some ideas that I am working on now, that ESM has helped stimulate, problematise and nourish, through articles that have appeared. I will consider in this short paper, what it means to have a broad conception of knowing – for research and for mathematics – reflecting upon the contribution of a selection of ESM articles as I do so.
2. U SING THEORY TO ADVANCE KNOWLEDGE
The task of researchers and scholars in mathematics education, as in other academic fields, is to create new knowledge. This is no small endeavour and it carries with it critical responsibility to be open to new ideas, perspectives and ways of thinking. For if scholars do not entertain broad ways of thinking, then scholarship is in danger of closing in, and of moving only in concentric, or ever decreasing circles. Theory is critical to the production of research knowledge, and to educational work more generally. Researchers in mathematics education have been receptive to the important role played by theory, with many classic studies drawing upon theoretical frameworks carefully; combining different theories from within and outside education; and even contributing to the development of new theories (see for example, Dubinsky, Sfard, Tall). But careful use of theory is not a hallmark of all educational research and the ways in which theory may be used to enhance our knowledge of mathematics teaching and learning seems worthy of some careful reflection and explicit teaching (Boaler, Ball and Even, 2003). Stephen Ball contends that the value of theory is that it: can separate us from ‘the contingency that has made us what we are’ (. . .) Theory is a vehicle for ‘thinking otherwise’ (. . .) It offers a language for challenge, and modes of thought, other than those articulated for us by dominant others. It provides a language of rigour and irony rather than contingency. The purpose of
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
5
such theory is to de-familiarise present practices and categories, to make them seem less self evident and necessary, and to open up spaces for the invention of new forms of experience. (Ball, 1995, p. 266)
One of the roles of theory, as Ball notes, is to protect us from the limits of our own experience, which inevitably narrow our thinking. Theoretical frameworks encourage researchers to pursue new ideas, prompting selections and explorations of data that our experiences would not initiate. Theory also serves as an interpretive tool, helping researchers to understand particular interactions that take place, by positioning them – providing dimensions along which ideas may be located and examined. McDermott and Lave (2002), like Ball, urge the careful use of theory as a way of prevailing against ideological subjection and dogma: We cannot trust ourselves to think our way to ideas that we need to change our lives. We need help. One kind of help is to work on rich texts that force us systematically to relocate our work with the work of others. (McDermott and Lave, 2002, p. 46)
But researchers in mathematics education do not only need to use theory, they need to select theoretical frameworks carefully. McDermott and Lave allude to the importance of theory in tackling big issues of social justice and equality, in producing work that may ‘change lives’ (p. 46). They argue that narrow frameworks may not give us the perspective to question prevailing practices with which we are familiar and which it is hard to see beyond. In 1990 Yves Chevallard took up a similar issue in ESM, criticizing research in mathematics education for its narrowness. He claimed that: research in mathematics education must certainly broaden its outlook, and take into account determinants which it has so far flippantly ignored. It is also its duty, nevertheless, to investigate patiently, even punctiliously, the relationship between the individuals’ experience and conduct and the socially determined contexts in which they emerge. (Chevallard, 1990, p. 24)
Chevallard spoke to the importance of broadening the questions mathematics educators had been asking, the variables considered, and the frameworks employed, as well as drawing connections between different frameworks. Whereas Ball warned against the dangers of becoming atheoretical, Chevallard’s article reminded us that the singular adoption of particular theories or frameworks can also be narrowing. The vast majority of early inquiries in mathematics education drew from the same, or similar perspectives and frameworks, and many would acknowledge that this helped our field to gain strength and to develop a clear identity. It also allowed knowledge to cumulate in careful ways. Researchers who studied students’ mathematical conceptions, for example,
6
JO BOALER
worked collectively across a number of countries to map out progressions of subject understanding in a few key areas (for example Hart, 1981; Dickson, Brown and Gibson, 1984). But the field has now diversified (Lerman, 2000), and researchers draw from many different methodologies and frameworks. This has prompted some crises in identity (Sierpinska and Kilpatrick, 1998), and increased demands for new researchers entering our field who need to learn about previous work, but it also paves the way for many new and important inquiries in the future of mathematics education. This point was well illustrated in an article that appeared in ESM in the mid nineteen-nineties. At a time when constructivism had become a dominant paradigm in mathematics education, displacing previous theories of learning, Robyn Zevenbergen (1996) wrote an article in which she questioned the limits of constructivism, claiming that it had attained an unhealthy dominance within the field. She was particularly concerned about its inability to “theorise adequately the marginalisation of significant numbers of students” (1996, p. 96). In this important essay Zevenbergen illustrated the role of theoretical breadth, of the use of multiple theories to counter dominant hegemonies. One of Zevenbergen’s main propositions was that success in mathematics is not simply a matter of cognitive processes, and that “students from certain social and cultural groups are more likely to be constructed as effective learners of mathematics because of their congruency with the social context of formal schooling” (p. 105). Zevenbergen drew from sociological theory to argue this powerful idea, encouraging researchers to locate understandings of students’ engagement and success within a broad sphere, that extended beyond students’ interactions with curricular materials. This idea emerged through the careful juxtaposition of different theories, including constructivism and cultural capital (Bourdieu, 1982, 1986), as Zevenbergen explored their differences and the insights they gave. Ball, Chevallard, Lave, McDermott, and Zevenbergen, all concern themselves with an extremely important issue – that of breadth of thought and of openness. They remind us that theoretical perspectives play an important role, prevailing against ideology and dogma. They also remind us that theories must be employed with care and reflectivity, in order to preclude a form of narrowness that comes from the unquestioning acceptance of dominant paradigms. Chevallard and Zevenbergen urge mathematics educators to look beyond single frameworks, remaining open to the different ways that theories from within and outside mathematics education may illuminate some pressing and enduring questions in our field, such as those of social inequality. The different authors speak to the importance of a
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
7
research knowledge that is broadly conceived, enhanced by theoretical reflexivity. But what does it mean to be aware of diverse epistemological perspectives, to show appreciation for them and to draw upon them? If one surveys the landscape of mathematics education research it is possible to find many examples of scholars who have embraced different epistemological positions and produced important new knowledge because of such openness. In the past, mathematics education researchers drew largely from psychological frameworks and theories, but contemporary researchers are increasingly demonstrating the insights that may be learned from additional frameworks. Central among the frameworks now drawn upon are sociology (Ensor, 2001; Dowling, 1996; Morgan, 2000); sociocultural theory (Kieran, Forman and Sfard, 2001; Lerman, 2001); politics (Skovsmose, 1994; Valero, 1999; Vithal and Skovsmose, 1997); mathematics (Ball and Bass, 2000); philosophy (Ernest, 1991, 1999); history (Joseph, 1992) and anthropology (Chevallard 1992; Artigue, 1999). In these different accounts the researchers draw from varied disciplinary perspectives and make use of methodological frameworks that are associated with them. But scholarship is anything but simple, and whilst we may agree that breadth of thinking is critical to the evolution of ideas, and that different frameworks should be considered and employed, we must also be wary that mathematics education is a relatively new and young field and that too much breadth and diversity will cause a scattering of focus and preclude opportunities for consolidation and identity (Sierpinska and Kilpatrick, 1998). Indeed work that starts from the findings of previous research, and builds from such findings, to provide depth and texture, such as the history of work on misconceptions and cognitive change contributes significantly to our understandings. Over time we must hope that journals continue to support both types of work, as our field diversifies and grows. Indeed research journals, such as ESM, play an extremely important role in providing an avenue of communication for different theories, as well as arguments about the use of theory. Over the years ESM has continued to encourage breadth and openness of thought through the publication of articles such as Zevenbergen’s that challenge dominant ways of thinking, as well as through its encouragement of different genres of article; different modes of research; and different frameworks of analysis. 3. R ELATIONS OF KNOWLEDGE AND PRACTICE
The ways in which theory may support work in the scholarship of mathematics education is an important question for our field, but an equally
8
JO BOALER
important question to consider is the ways in which theory may impact the practices of mathematics teaching and learning. Educational researchers, unlike some other scholars, are working in an applied field and our work is judged, in part, by the extent to which it is able to impact – indeed improve – educational practice. It is in this area that scholarship in education is most often found to be lacking. Greeno, McDermott, Cole, Engle, Goldman, Knudsen, Lauman, and Linde (1999) provide an interesting perspective on this issue. Greeno and his colleagues suggest a new conceptualisation for knowledge and theory in education. They provocatively claim that we remove the boundaries between knowledge and “domains of practical activity” (1999, p. 303) suggesting that a means of doing so would be to engage teachers, researchers and students in new participation structures, in which they work together to produce new research knowledge. Such structures are not, themselves, provocative, but Greeno et al. propose that “expert knowledge is better seen as a working hypothesis that must enter a community of practice and jostle apparent knowledge until it takes root in a reorganization of what people can do with each other” (1999, pp. 301–302). Drawing from both Dewey (1916) and Mead (1899), they offer a different conceptualisation of knowledge as a “set of working hypotheses that would be tested against their consequences for the body politic” (p. 333). Thus some of the knowledge produced by educational scholars should be judged against the extent to which it impacts practice. This view is echoed in a National Academy of Education report (NAE, 1999) from the US that suggests that educational research, in future, should be judged not only on its appeal to other academics, or its potential to improve education, but on its impact. The report proposes a change for educational funding, with priority given to those studies that aim to impact practice, on which researchers and practitioners work collectively to frame problems of practice, and their solutions. The National Academy of Education group recommends that educational research is reorganized with new kinds of support, review, participation and evaluation, all organized to enable the collaboration of different ‘communities’ such as researchers, practitioners and developers of materials. They support a kind of research that they call ‘problem solving research and development’ – characterised by researchers and practitioners identifying problems of practice together and working together to solve them. In doing so they challenge an assumption that research knowledge should be developed as general principles that should then be conveyed to teachers and other education professionals. They replace this vision of research and dissemination with one in which the development of knowledge, understanding and educational improvement takes place as one
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
9
process, shared by specialists in research, development and educational practice. The proposal to re-conceptualise knowledge as a set of working hypotheses, tested against their ability to impact practice, is an interesting one for a journal such as ESM. Greeno et al. do not suggest that such knowledge should replace discipline based knowledge that is valued for its own sake, but they argue for an expansion of the ways research knowledge is developed and valued in our field. I began this article with discussion of the ways knowledge may be enriched by theory – this is another call for the enrichment of knowledge, this time by practice, and it raises an interesting question for journals such as ESM. Perhaps now, on the anniversary of its 50th birthday, at a juncture where there are serious dichotomies between research knowledge and the practices of education, it is time for ESM to give its authors new directions that could change the way research knowledge is developed and used. These could include instructions for authors to reflect upon the ways their research findings may be used in different settings, and the means by which they will be communicated to, and taken up by practitioners to improve students’ educational opportunities. This does not mean that new knowledge would not be valued for its own sake, or that there would be no place for conceptual essays in ESM. But perhaps researchers could be urged to consider their findings as ‘working hypotheses’ and explore the ways in which their knowledge may enter different communities and “jostle apparent knowledge until it takes root in a reorganization of what people can do with each other” (Greeno et al., 1999, pp. 301–302)? Whether this is feasible, desirable, or possible, is a question that seems worthy of consideration. The expansion of research knowledge – to benefit fully from theory, and to connect in new ways with practice, is an issue that has been furthered by a few important contributions in ESM, that call for a prevailing openness in our conceptions of knowledge. But it is knowledge of mathematics itself, rather than research knowledge, that has gained the greatest attention of ESM authors. Indeed the question of what it means to know mathematics, and be proficient in its use, is one to which researchers of mathematics education have contributed a great deal. I will end this paper with some consideration of the domain of mathematics itself, as explorations of the ways mathematics knowledge may be opened, expanded, and enriched have an important role to play in our work as researchers of mathematics education, as I shall argue below.
10
JO BOALER
4. E XPANDING CONCEPTIONS OF MATHEMATICAL KNOWING AND DOING
Many articles over the years have reported on research that has considered how mathematics is learned – which approaches are effective, for whom and why. This work is at the centre of our field and is extremely important. A related question, that has also received considerable attention, concerns the nature of mathematics knowledge – what is it, and how is it, or could it, be held? I have spent time in this article considering research knowledge and the ways it may be expanded by the contributions of theory and practice. I turn now to the question of mathematics knowledge, and consider the ways that recent work may benefit our conceptions of knowledge, expanding and opening these to encourage insights into the relations of mathematics knowing, doing and believing. Ball, McDermott, Lave, and others all stress the importance of thinking openly about educational issues, using theory to protect against narrow interpretations constrained by personal experience. The issue of openness is also critically important for those who consider the nature of mathematics knowledge, particularly because the prevailing dogma about what it means to know and be proficient in mathematics is extremely narrow in most countries (Boaler, 2002a). Indeed, one could argue that it is the narrowness with which mathematics is regarded that has maintained a system of educational failure, in which only a few ever attain mathematical proficiency or fluency. In the two countries in which I have worked – the UK and the US – mathematics is believed by many students to be a collection of disconnected, standard procedures (Boaler, 2002a; Schoenfeld, 1992). In many schools, homes, and departments of education, test success is held as the ultimate goal, and students of mathematics often come to believe that their goal is to memorise numerous different, unrelated procedures, so that they can reproduce them when they are given different test questions. This scenario can lead to a limited test-knowledge, or worse, as students often fail even to be successful on tests, as they find that memorised procedures are insufficient when faced with questions that require that they also know when different procedures should be selected (Brown, 1981; Boaler, 1997, 2002a). Research in mathematics education has contributed a great deal to our understanding of these problems, and various authors in ESM have been particularly helpful in exploring the boundaries of mathematics knowing. In the nineteen-seventies and eighties there was important work, and agreement about different forms of knowledge that may be developed, that have been variously characterised as conceptual and procedural (Hiebert,
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
11
1986), or relational and instrumental (Skemp, 1976). These characterisations of knowledge have been important, and they have resonated with many teachers and scholars. But recent articles in ESM capture some different, important aspects of mathematical work that seem to elude a knowledge characterisation. Indeed when we step outside of knowledge domains, it seems that our field may lack agreed frameworks for understanding mathematical activity. As an example consider an excellent article by Noss, Healy, and Hoyles (1997). In this research paper authors describe the ways in which they developed a particular ‘microworld’, which was designed to “help students construct mathematical meanings by forging links between the rhythms of their actions and the corresponding symbolic representations they developed” (p. 203). In this article Noss, Healy, and Hoyles examine the ways in which students make connections between visual and symbolic forms of functional relationships. They argue, importantly, that students often develop a disconnected sense of algebraic formulations – regarding algebra as an end-point, rather than a problemsolving tool. The authors therefore designed a computer environment in which the only way to manipulate and reconstruct objects was to explicitly express the relationships between them. In doing so they helped the students view and use algebra as a representational tool, in the service of the expression of mathematical connections and relationships. Noss, Healy, and Hoyles (1997) argue that the act of making connections is important because mathematical meanings derive from mathematical connections. Thus they link mathematical connections to the knowledge and understanding they may promote. But it seems to me that the act of observing relationships and drawing connections, whether between different functional representations or mathematical areas, is a key aspect of mathematical work, in itself, and should not only be thought of as a route to other knowledge. In Leone Burton’s article of 1999, she reported upon a study in which she interviewed 70 research mathematicians, probing the ways that they viewed and used mathematics. One of the key aspects of their work that the mathematicians highlighted was also the act of making connections – as one of them reflected:
The behaviour that I observed I couldn’t find anything about it in the standard literature. Then I found a connection with a very ancient problem in gravitational mechanics and I found some old computational work from the 1960’s and the behaviour they found was almost identical but even richer than the behaviour I was finding. So whilst I was understanding more and more about my problem, I was also seeing how it was linking into this huge area of the 3-body problem . . . That was really nice. I think that is pretty common in maths. Things do connect when you don’t expect them to. (Male lecturer). (Burton, 1999, p. 136)
12
JO BOALER
Andrew Wiles achieved one of the most significant mathematical breakthroughs of our time in his proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem. Biographical accounts of his work (e.g. Singh, 1998) highlight the significance of the connections Wiles was able to draw between different mathematical theories; indeed it was the connections that he and other mathematicians drew that laid the path for the eventual proof. Frey, a German mathematician, set the ball rolling when he claimed that “if anyone could prove the TaniyamaShimura conjecture then they would also immediately prove Fermat’s Last Theorem”. Ken Ribet and other mathematician’s worked hard to complete the connection between the Taniyama-Shimura conjecture and Fermat’s Last Theorem, but could only prove “a very minor part of it” (Singh, p. 201). But, as Singh recalls: Fermat’s Last Theorem was inextricably linked to the Taniyama-Shimura conjecture. (. . .) For three and a half centuries Fermat’s Last Theorem had been an isolated problem, a curious and impossible riddle on the edge of mathematics. Now Ken Ribet, inspired by Gerhard Frey, had brought it center stage. The most important problem from the seventeenth century was coupled to the most significant problem of the twentieth century. A puzzle of enormous historical and emotional importance was linked to a conjecture that could revolutionize modern mathematics. (Singh, 1998, p. 202).
Wiles subsequently went on to prove the Taniyama-Shimura conjecture, thereby proving Fermat’s Last Theorem, a breakthrough that derived from the connections drawn. Burton and Singh both write about the work of mathematicians, focusing upon the act of ‘making connections’. But what is this aspect of mathematical work? And has its character – as an action or mathematical practice – rather than a form of knowledge or knowing – contributed to its relative lack of attention in curriculum materials and teaching? For the act of making connections is not something students need to know, it is something they need to do. One could imagine a student with a broad knowledge of mathematical procedures and even a conceptual understanding of the relations between procedures, who still would not choose to draw connections between different mathematical ideas, relations or representations as they work. Students may think of mathematics as a set of connected ideas, they may even be able to describe and reflect upon the connections, but the act of linking one mathematical area to another, in order to solve a problem, is an action that extends beyond knowledge. Students with a deep understanding may draw connections as they work, as knowledge and practice are intricately connected, but the act of doing so is not defined by the knowledge they possess. This raises the question of whether mathematics education researchers have focused too centrally upon knowledge categories, neglecting various mathematical actions, such
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
13
as those to which Burton; and Noss, Healy, and Hoyles, draw our attention, that are so critical to mathematics work. Before pursuing this question further I will consider another example of research, published in ESM, that highlights another aspect of mathematical work that eludes knowledge categorisation. In 1996 Marty Simon drew our attention to what he calls a mathematical ‘ability’ – that of considering a mathematical problem, with the various constraints and variables described, not as a static state, but a dynamic process. Simon gives as an example a girl who is considering whether she can make an isosceles triangle if only two angles and the included side are specified. The girl immediately represents such a triangle and justifies it saying “Well, I know that if two people walked from the ends of this side at equal angles towards each other, when they meet, they would have walked the same distance” (1996, p. 199). Simon argues that such reasoning is not inductive – the girl did not generate several triangles and notice a pattern. Nor is the reasoning deductive – she did not make a conjecture and create a need for a deductive proof. Rather she saw the isosceles triangle not as a static figure with particular dimensions, but a “dynamic process that generates triangles from the two ends of a line segment”. This dynamic mental model, as Simon points out, enabled her to reason about two ideas, that she connected – the relationship between the base angles of a triangle, and the relative length of the legs of the triangle given particular angles. Simon describes this mode of work as “seeking a sense of how the mathematical system works” or developing a “feel for the system” (p. 198) and refers to this process as “transformational reasoning” (1996, p. 197). Simon, like Burton, Noss, Healy, and Hoyles, describes a particular action – of viewing mathematical relationships as a dynamic state. This action, like that of noting relationships or drawing connections, also eludes knowledge characterisation, and Simon refers to it as a particular type of reasoning. Ben-Zvi and Arcavi (2001) analyze the work of students who were learning to use exploratory data analysis in a technological environment. In their descriptions of the students working Ben-Zvi and Arcavi highlight the importance of what they call ‘habits’ such as questioning, representing, concluding, and communicating. Ben-Zvi and Arcavi stress the importance of enculturation as an act of teaching, with teachers inducting students into statistical work, so that they may learn a variety of ‘thinking processes’ and ‘problem solving strategies’. Their focus in this paper also extends beyond the knowledge that students need to explore data, to some important mathematical actions, such as “looking globally at a graph as a way to discern patterns and generalities” (2001, p. 38).
14
JO BOALER
The different research projects I have considered all describe critical mathematical actions that extend beyond knowledge – but when we consider how such actions are characterised or defined, things look a little hazy. Some authors have offered broader notions of knowledge arguing that these different actions are indicative of different forms of knowledge. In a special issue in 1999, for example, (Tirosh, 1999), a range of authors described different categories of knowledge such as implicit, explicit, formal and visual knowledge, as well as knowing that, knowing why and knowing how. These notions extend traditional conceptions of knowledge, enabling researchers to account for broader aspects of competent performance, but it seems that the different actions people employ are not defined by this knowledge. Other scholars have described the kind of actions I have reviewed as mathematical processes, with names such as reasoning, and communicating (Schoenfeld, 1985, 1992; NCTM, 2000). At this time there is little agreement about the nature, or form of mathematical actions, such as visualising, or connecting, and this may be part of the reason that these critical aspects of mathematics work are frequently overlooked in curriculum planning and assessment. In these different characterisations of the mathematical work employed by students and mathematicians we also gain an important sense of some mathematical traits that supported the work, including creativity, interest, and inquisitiveness. Indeed it is hard to believe that such characteristics could be separated from the work of drawing connections or regarding relations dynamically. Yet these characters are similarly elusive and difficult to define – sometimes being considered as mathematical ‘beliefs’, at other times ‘habits of mind’ (Cuoco, Goldenberg and Mark, 1996). Such habits, or beliefs are also given little attention when policy makers and schools make decisions about curriculum materials, and teaching strategies. This lack of attention, I would argue, has been encouraged by the separate study, and labelling, of characteristics such as mathematical knowledge, ‘processes’ and ‘habits of mind’. Thus scholars and teachers have often focused upon knowledge as though it develops independently of belief, action, or disposition. This is particularly true of studies of students’ knowledge – scholars of teacher knowledge have focused to a greater extent upon the intrinsic relationships between teacher knowledge and belief (see, for example, Even and Tirosh, 1995; Cooney, 1999; Thompson, 1992) whereas it is still relatively commonplace for studies of student learning to focus only upon knowledge developed. Two groups in the United States, comprising mathematics educators, teachers, mathematicians and policy makers, recently produced different conceptualisations of what it means to know and use mathematics that
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
15
seem helpful in furthering our understanding of the different relations of mathematical knowledge, beliefs and actions. First the National Research Council (NRC) convened a group of experts, led by Jeremy Kilpatrick, to review and synthesize relevant research on mathematics learning, from pre-kindergarten to the end of grade eight (Kilpatrick, Swafford and Findell, 2001; for a concise account of this work see Kilpatrick, 2001). As part of this work, the group provided a conceptualisation of successful mathematics learning, that they called ‘mathematical proficiency’. The different, interwoven, aspects of proficiency they proposed, are: conceptual understanding – comprehension of mathematical concepts, operations and relations procedural fluency – skill in carrying out procedures flexibly, accurately, efficiently, and appropriately strategic competence – ability to formulate, represent and solve mathematical problems adaptive reasoning – capacity for logical thought, reflection, explanation, and justification productive disposition – habitual inclination to see mathematics as sensible, useful, and worthwhile, coupled with a belief in diligence and one’s own efficacy. (Kilpatrick et al., 2001, p. 116)
This representation of proficiency seems important, particularly in its inclusiveness, and its bringing together of knowledge, aspects of mathematical work, and disposition. Practices such as making connections, and viewing mathematical representations dynamically, could be included as examples of ‘strategic competence’, whereas characteristics such as creativity, and inquisitiveness may be included under ‘productive disposition’. The utility of this framework will become clearer in time, as researchers, teachers and others work with the ideas, but it seems that it has the potential to do something very important – expand public conceptions of mathematics knowing and turn attention to the aspects of mathematical proficiency that need to accompany knowledge. A second group of mathematicians and educators in the US, led by Deborah Loewenberg Ball, recently designed a proposal for future research directions in mathematics education. This proposal (RAND mathematics study panel, 2002) is intended to guide government agencies in their distribution of research funds. The proposal has many interesting features, including a call for strategic accumulation of research in focused areas, and collaborations of different groups working on problems together. Most interesting for this discussion is the choice of one of the three proposed research directions for the future as that of ‘mathematical practices’. The group recommends this area as a way of adding texture and understanding
16
JO BOALER
to the notion of mathematical proficiency, and they describe mathematical practices in the following way: This area focuses on the mathematical know-how, beyond content knowledge, that characterizes expertise in learning and using mathematics. The term ‘practices’ refers to specific things that successful mathematics learners and users do. Justifying claims, using symbolic notation efficiently, and making generalizations are examples of mathematical practices. (RAND, 2002, p. xi)
The group, of which I was a part, was in agreement that the field would be significantly advanced by focused work on these practices – considering what they are, how they are learned, and how they are used, in the service of employment, recreation and mathematical inquiry. Examples of mathematical practices that the group highlighted for study include justification, representation, and reconciliation. The actions of making connections (Noss, Healy, Hoyles, 1997; Burton, 1999), and seeing mathematical relations as a dynamic process (Simon, 1996) could also be taken as candidates for study in this area. The notion of practices, central to situated theory (Lave, 1993; Wenger, 1998), has been extremely generative in mathematics education, as researchers have begun to look beyond students’ cognitive processes, to the norms of classrooms (Cobb, Wood and Yackel, 1992) and the learning practices that are encouraged and that shape knowledge in different classroom systems. The notion of mathematical practices attends in similar ways to the repeated actions in which people engage, but its main focus is not the learning of mathematics, but the doing of mathematics – the actions in which users of mathematics (as learners and problem solvers) engage. I have found the notion of mathematical identity – the idea that students develop relationships with their knowledge – to be extremely useful in my own analyses of learning (Boaler, 2002b). The idea of identity builds directly from studies of practice, as researchers have found that students develop identities through the practices with which they engage. Lave (1993) and Wenger (1998), for example, both claim that learning is a process of engagement with practices: Engagement in practice – in its unfolding, multidimensional complexity – is both the stage and the object, the road and the destination. What they learn is not a static subject matter but the very process of being engaged in, and participating in developing, an ongoing practice. (Wenger, 1998, p. 95)
As students engage in classroom practices, and in mathematical practices, they develop knowledge and they develop a relationship with that knowledge. Their mathematical identity includes the knowledge they possess, as well as the ways in which students hold knowledge, the ways in which they use knowledge and the accompanying mathematical beliefs and work
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
17
practices that interact with their knowing. A focus on mathematical practices, as with classroom practices, seems generative in helping researchers understand the identities students develop, and the different ways they know and use mathematics. Authors in ESM have contributed a great deal to our understanding of the subtleties of mathematical proficiency, and the various mathematical practices employed by learners of mathematics. Special editions of the journal on proof and reasoning (see for example, ESM, 1993, 14, 4 and ESM, 2000, 44, 1–2), and constructing meaning from data (ESM, 2001, 45 (1–3)), provide good examples of such work. The notion of practices, as well as that of mathematical proficiency, may provide useful frameworks for consideration of the different aspects of mathematical work that have been delineated. The journal’s close attention to what it means to do mathematics, is in some senses not surprising, as Hans Freudenthal, one of the founding fathers of ESM, contributed a great deal to our understanding of mathematics as a problem solving act, a way of modeling and making sense of realistic situations (Van Oers, 2002). (See, for example, ESM 15, 1/2, for reflections on the ‘legacy of Hans Freudenthal’). It is critical for our field that such work continues, and that we learn more about the nuances of mathematical proficiency that include and go beyond, knowledge. Such work certainly stands as an example of theoretical development that counters the dogmatism and ideology to which S. Ball, Lave and McDermott draw our attention. For if scholars do not consider the extent and nature of mathematical proficiency, in its broadest terms, we may be reduced to the dominant ideology that pervades public rhetoric, in which mathematical proficiency is equated with the reproduction of isolated mathematical procedures. But whilst it is appropriate to commend the breadth of knowledge that has emanated from research, communicated in ESM and elsewhere, it is also sobering to reflect upon the gulf that exists between the understandings of mathematical proficiency communicated in ESM, and that which is communicated in many mathematics classrooms across the world. Greeno et al., as well as the National Academy of Education report from the US, provide some interesting proposals for ways of changing the situation and for building bridges between research and practice. These proposals include giving researchers the task of translating their findings into practical action and giving funders the task of prioritising research that takes place across academic and practitioner communities. I would add to those suggestions, a critical role for journals, such as ESM, in encouraging research that has a theory-practice dimension and giving potential authors
18
JO BOALER
new questions to consider regarding the links with, and impact upon practice, when submitting papers for publication.
5. C ONCLUSION
I was invited, in writing this paper, to reflect on the ways that ESM contributes to my work, as part of the celebration of the 50th volume of the journal. In exploring the ways that knowledge is produced and conceived – in the domains of research and mathematics – I hope to have acknowledged the critical contributions of ESM articles, in my own thinking and, more importantly, the development of our field. Articles such as those by Chevallard and Zevenbergen play an essential role in promoting theoretical awareness and reflexivity, inviting us to consider the frameworks we use and questions we raise in our research. Such articles have been extremely influential in my own work and in my teaching of future researchers, particularly masters and doctoral students. In considering the ways our field conceives of mathematical knowledge, or proficiency, I have cited just a small selection of articles that have been instructive in expanding my understanding of mathematical work. The new knowledge produced in such work feeds my ongoing research work with students and teachers in schools and my teaching and professional development work with beginning and experienced teachers. It is interesting to consider how the world would be different, how proficient students may be, if teachers, parents and policy makers, paid greater attention to the different aspects of mathematical proficiency that researchers have defined and that have been communicated in ESM. The different articles I have mentioned, along with many others, give us a glimpse of such a world, and ESM as a journal, has been instrumental in keeping such a vision alive.
N OTES 1. This is an invited paper, celebrating the occasion of ESM’s reaching its 50th volume.
R EFERENCES Artigue, M.: 1999, ‘The teaching and learning of mathematics at the university level: Crucial questions for contemporary research in education’, Notices of the AMS 46(11), 1377–1385.
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
19
Ball, S.J.: 1995, ‘Intellectuals or technicians? The urgent role of theory in educational studies’, British Journal of Educational Studies XXXXIII (3), 255–271. Ball, D. and Bass, H.: 2000, ‘Bridging practices: Intertwining content and pedagogy in teaching and learning to teach’, in J. Boaler (ed.), Multiple Perspectives on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, Ablex Publishing, Westport, CT, pp. 83–104. Ben-Zvi, D. and Arcavi, A.: 2001, ‘Junior high school students’ construction of global views of data and data representations’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 45, 35–65. Boaler, J.: 1997, Experiencing School Mathematics: Teaching Styles, Sex and Setting, Open University Press, Buckingham. Boaler, J.: 2002a, Experiencing School Mathematics: Traditional and Reform Approaches to Teaching and Their Impact on Student Learning (Revised and Expanded Edition ed.), Lawrence Erlbaum Association, Mahwah, NJ. Boaler, J.: 2002b, ‘The development of disciplinary relationships: Knowledge, practice and identity in mathematics classrooms’, For the Learning of Mathematics 22(1), 42–47. Bourdieu, P.: 1982, ‘The school as a conservative force: Scholastic and cultural inequalities’, in E. Bredo and W. Feinberg (eds.), Knowledge and Values in Social and Educational Research, Temple University Press, Philadelphia, pp. 391–407. Bourdieu, P.: 1986, ‘The forms of capital’, in J. Richardson (ed.), Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education, Greenwood Press, New York, pp. 241–258. Brown, M.L. (ed.): 1988: Graded Assessment in Mathematics Development Pack: Pupil Materials, Macmillan, Basingstoke, UK. Burton, L.: 1999, ‘The practices of mathematicians: What do they tell us about coming to know mathematics?’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 37, 121–143. Chevallard, Y.: 1990, ‘On mathematics education and culture: Critical afterthoughts’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 21(1), 3–28. Cobb, P., Wood, T., Yackel, E. and Perlwitz, M.: 1992, ‘A follow-up assessment of a second-grade problem-centered mathematics project’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 23, 483–504. Cooney, T.: 1999, ‘Conceptualizing teachers’s ways of knowing’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 38, 163–187. Cuoco, A., Goldenberg, E.P. and Mark, J.: 1996, ‘Habits of mind: An organizing principle for mathematics curricula’, Journal of Mathematical Behavior 15, 375–402. Dewey, J.: 1916, Democracy and Education, MacMillan, New York. Dickson, L., Brown, M.L. and Gibson, O.: 1984, Children learning Mathematics: A Teacher’s Guide to Recent Research, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Eastbourne, UK. Dowling, P.: 1996, ‘A sociological analysis of school mathematics texts’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 31, 389–415. Ensor, P.: 2001, ‘From preservice mathematics teacher education to beginning teaching: A study in recontextualizing’, Journal for Research in Mathematic Education 32(3), 296–320. Ernest, P.: 1991, The Philosophy of Mathematics Education, Falmer, New York. Ernest, P.: 1999, ‘Forms of knowledge in mathematics and mathematics education: Philosophical and rhetorical perspectives’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 38(1-3), 67–83. Even, R. and Tirosh, D.: 1995, ‘Subject-matter knowledge and knowledge about students as sources of teacher presentations of the subject matter’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 29(1), 1–20. Greeno, J.G., McDermott, R.P., Cole, K., Engle, R., Goldman, S., Knudsen, J., Lauman, B. and Linde, C.: 1999, ‘Research, reform, and aims in education: Modes of action in
20
JO BOALER
search of each other’, in E.C. Lagemann and L.S. Shulman (eds.), Issues in Education Research: Problems and Possibilities, Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco. Hart, K.M. (ed.): 1981, Children’s Understanding of Mathematics: 11–16, John Murray, London, UK. Hiebert, J.: 1986, Conceptual and Procedural Knowledge: The Case of Mathematics, Lawrence Erlbaum, New Jersey. Joseph, G.G.: 1992, The Crest of the Peacock: Non-European Roots of Mathematics, Penguin, Harmondsworth, UK. Kieran, C., Forman, E.A. and Sfard, A.: 2001, ‘Guest editorial. Learning discourse: Sociocultural approaches to research in mathematics education’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 46(1-3), 1–12. Kilpatrick, J., Swafford, J. and Findell, B. (eds.): 2001, Adding it up: Helping Children Learn Mathematics, National Academy Press, Washington, DC. Kilpatrick, J.: 2001, ‘Understanding mathematical literacy: The contribution of research’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 47(1), 101–116. Lave, J.: 1993, ‘The practice of learning’, in S. Chaiklin and J. Lave (ed.), Understanding Practice: Perspectives on Activity and Context, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 3–34. Lave, J. and McDermott, R.P.: 2002, ‘Estranged Learning’, Outlines 1, 19–48. Lerman, S.: 2000, ‘The social turn in mathematics education research’, in J. Boaler (ed.), Multiple Perspectives on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, Ablex Publishing, Westport, CT, pp. 19–44. Lerman, S.: 2001, ‘Cultural, discursive psychology: A sociocultural approach to studying the teaching and learning of mathematics’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 46(1-3), 87–113. Mead, G.H.: 1899, ‘The working hypothesis in social reform’, American Journal of Sociology 5, 369–371. Morgan, C.: 2000, ‘Better assessment in mathematics education? A social perspective’, in J. Boaler (ed.), Multiple Perspectives on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, Ablex Publishing, Westport, CT, pp. 225–243. National Academy of Education: 1999, Recommendations Regarding Research Priorities: An Advisory Report to the National Educational Research Policy and Priorities Board, NAE, New York. National Council for Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM): 2000, Principles and Standards for School Mathematics, NCTM, Virginia. Noss, R., Healy, L. and Hoyles, C.: 1997, ‘The construction of mathematical meanings: Connecting the visual with the symbolic’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 33, 203– 233. RAND Mathematics Study Panel: 2002, October, Mathematical Proficiency for all Students: Toward a Strategic Research and Development Program in Mathematics Education (DRU-2773-OERI), RAND Education and Science and Technology Policy Institute, Arlington, VA. Schoenfeld, A.H.: 1985, Mathematical Problem-Solving, Academic Press, New York, NY. Schoenfeld, A.: 1992, ‘Learning to think mathematically: Problem solving, metacognition, and sense making in mathematics’, in D.A. Grouws (ed.), Handbook of Research on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, MacMillan, New York, pp. 334–371. Sierpinska, A. and Kilpatrick, J. (eds.).: 1998, Mathematics Education as a Research Domain: A Search for Identity. An ICMI study, Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
EXPLORING THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICAL ACTIVITY
21
Simon, M.: 1996, ‘Beyond inductive and deductive reasoning: The search for a sense of knowing’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 30, 197–210. Singh, S.: 1998, Fermat’s Enigma: The Epic Quest to Solve the World’s Greatest Mathematical Problem, Anchor Books, New York. Skemp, R.: 1976, Relational understanding and instrumental understanding, Mathematics Teaching December, 65–71. Skovsmose, O.: 1994, Towards a Philosophy of Critical Mathematics Education, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht. Thompson, A.: 1992, ‘Teachers’ beliefs and conceptions: A synthesis of the research’, in D. Grouws (ed.), Handbook of Research on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, Macmillan, New York, pp. 127–146. Tirosh, D.: 1999, ‘Forms of mathematical knowledge: Learning and teaching with understanding’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 38(1-3), 1–9. Valero, P.: 1999, ‘Deliberative mathematics education for social democratization in Latin America’, Zentralblatt fur Didaktik der Mathematik 98(6), 20–26. Van Oers, B.: 2001, ‘Educational forms of initiation in mathematical culture’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 46, 59–85. Vithal, R. and Skovsmose, O.: 1997, ‘The end of innocence: A critique of ethnomathematics’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 34, 131–157. Wenger, E.: 1998, Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning and Identity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Zevenbergen, R.: 1996, ‘Constructivism as a liberal bourgeois discourse’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 31, 95–113.
Mathematics Education, School of Education, 485 Lasuen Mall, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305-3096
STEPHEN LERMAN∗ , GUORONG XU and ANNA TSATSARONI
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH: THE ESM STORY1
ABSTRACT. In this paper we present an analysis of the articles in Educational Studies in Mathematics since 1990. It is part of a larger project looking at the production and use of theories of teaching and learning mathematics. We outline the theoretical framework of our tool of analysis and discuss briefly some of the methodological difficulties we face. We then present our findings from the analysis of the journal and we also give one example of how we ‘read’ an article, illustrating the rules whereby criteria are applied. KEY WORDS: analysis of specialised texts, educational research communities, intellectual fields of knowledge production, mathematics education research, mathematics education research publications, pedagogical models, sociology of educational knowledge, theoretical frameworks in mathematics education research
1. I NTRODUCTION : T HE POLITICS OF KNOWLEDGE PRODUCTION , PUBLICATION AND DISSEMINATION
As Educational Studies in Mathematics comes to its 50th volume one can expect that there have been many changes in the sorts of articles published within its pages through the time since Volume 1. After all, “Educational research is located in a knowledge-producing community” (Usher, 1996, p. 34). The award of research grants, the choice of candidates for doctoral supervision, the examination and award of doctorates, and of course the acceptance or rejection of articles in refereed journals such as this, are judgements made by people. Over time the values and styles and the openness, Educational Studies in Mathematics 51: 23–40, 2002. © 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
24
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
or otherwise, to new (or old) theories of these gate-keepers of the community change as the people move on or develop their own ideas. As mathematics education researchers (here in collaboration with a sociologist of education) we are engaged in a social science, which is always a hermeneutic activity, although some sociologists of scientific knowledge might say similar things about the natural sciences. Each editor/reviewer/examiner has her or his own interests and concerns, and her or his own trajectory of development as researcher, and these experiences are reflected in how one reads research, what one considers valid, and therefore what one allows to enter through the gates of this particular academic discipline. Of course the review of articles by three people with moderation subsequently by the editor, and the examination of PhDs by more than one examiner, will have the effect of slowing down the rate and softening the edges of change. To talk about changes over time in a field of research in terms of changes in the priorities, understandings and interpretations given by people in positions of power is, at the same time, to acknowledge a number of other aspects: the structures and social relations constituting the field as well as, perhaps, the changing strength of the boundary separating this sub-field from other research subfields within education research; changes in the relations between education research and other fields within the overall arena of research production; the wider picture of power and control relations which affect the (relative) autonomy of the intellectual field of knowledge production, establishing certain forms of social relations between, on the one hand, the official policy agencies and, on the other, agencies and agents in the field (in our case of mathematics education) of knowledge transmission, dissemination, use and reproduction (Bernstein, 1990; Morgan, Tsatsaroni and Lerman, 2002). It is also crucial to acknowledge that mathematics education research, and education research more generally, are usually located in departments of education in HE institutions, their principal purpose resulting from the training of future and in-service teachers and their overall project which historically has been a commitment to the improvement of education is affected by the overall political context (cf. Dale, 2001). This for example is evident today in the competing demands of having to act as a career academic and as a teacher educator. This picture is further complicated once we consider that educational publishing which is a crucial agency in the process of validation, authorisation and dissemination of research productions, has multiple dependencies resulting from: its symbolic control function (specialisation in discursive resources which shape consciousness); its location within the cultural field but driven/constrained by economic imperatives; and its hierarchical loc-
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
25
ation in the division of labour – as not only diffusers but also shapers of knowledge, in the sense that they influence what counts as developments or changes within sciences (Bernstein, 1990, pp. 133–145). All the above affect the degree of authorial agency, the author as intellectual researcher and as somebody who balances the priorities/demands of the journals, the official policy or research accounting procedures, while keeping her/his credibility amongst teachers (Nixon, 1999). Furthermore, developments towards electronic publishing might further change the relations between publications, publishing and its publics. A systematic study of the changes in priorities and productions, values and styles, within a research community over time would enable the posing and examination of a whole range of questions that might otherwise be amenable only to anecdotal speculation, questions such as: – what have been the changes in the theories used by researchers in mathematics education over the years; – which theories remain in use, which have largely disappeared, and which have re-appeared; – do researchers draw more on theory than before, or less, and are the theories implicit or explicit; – what has been the ebb and flow of empirically based studies over the years; – do research theories manifest in teacher education and in school texts, and if so what transformations or recontextualisations have they gone through; and what are the principles of selection of theory(ies) in such texts and contexts? – how are new researchers ‘trained’; – what are the relations between mathematics education research and other research communities, including mathematics, science education, and educational research more generally; – what are the relations between the mathematics education research community and official decision-makers in different countries? – what are the relations between the research community(ies), its publications and the kinds of readerships constituted? Hidden behind the possibility of framing and attempting to answer these questions are some important methodological issues that would need to be addressed in such a study, for example: – what tools will be used in such an analysis; – what structure for analysis should be adopted, and what would lead to its change and development; – what are the criteria by which judgements are made?
26
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
and so on. We have embarked on a study2 of theories, and research orientations in mathematics education the first stage of which is an analysis of a sample of papers from Proceedings of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (PME), from Educational Studies in Mathematics (ESM) and from the Journal for Research in Mathematics Education (JRME) from 1990 to the present.3 In Morgan et al. (2002) we discussed two issues regarding the field of mathematics education research: its status within educational studies and hence within the general field of intellectual production; and the way its knowledge is organised, its internal structure (p. 450). Our study is mainly focused on the latter, whilst recognising that the former is expected to be always inscribed in the latter. As it develops, we will be particularly concerned to examine how the shifts between different models of pedagogy occur as changes in the orientation, structure and boundaries of the field of mathematics education knowledge production changes (p. 451). This will be one of the results of the whole study. At this stage we can only make general comments about our findings. Thus the main focus of this article will be a report on our analysis of the output from ESM in this period. We will be attempting here to answer the following main question: How is the field of mathematics education research shaping up, as represented in the journal? This overall question will be approached in terms of the following sub-questions: 1. What are the topics, issues, priorities and emphases addressed by authors, and what changes have there been on these over time? 2. Who are the addressors and the addressees of the journal articles? What changes have there been in the perceived addressees over time? 3. What are the relations of mathematics education research with other fields in educational and social inquiry? 4. What are the field’s relations to official agencies and how has this changed over time?
2. M ETHODOLOGICAL ISSUES
In this article we will present only a brief sketch of methodological aspects of the project (for further elaboration on methodology see Tsatsaroni, Lerman and Xu, 2003). Whilst the choice of years of publications to analyse is to some extent arbitrary, it is based on two factors: we wanted to bring the analysis up to the present day; and we are most interested in the years since the entry of more social theories into the field (see Lerman, 2000). Given the size
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
27
of the task, even just analysing the two journals ESM and JRME and the Proceedings of PME over 12 years it was necessary to make a systematic selection. In relation to ESM we have chosen to examine every article from every second ‘book’ (using the term ‘volume’ or ‘issue’ risks confusion). We consider that, in terms of randomness, the articles published bear no relation to each other or to authors’ names, except for the Special Issues. In these cases, we conjecture that the only category affected would be the topic since methodologies, theories and all the other elements of our analysis will vary across these articles as much as in any other book. We have also examined the Special Issues separately for topic. Were there time, we would have liked to look back across the whole 50 volumes of ESM and we expect that the changes would be quite substantial. We can expect less changes over a 12 year period, but our project’s focus is the field of mathematics education research more generally than just that represented by one journal. At a later stage the project will also involve examining a selection of teacher education texts over the same period in order to be able to comment upon the process of recontextualisation taking place in the community. To this stage we have developed a tool4 of recording and analysing the specialised texts of the research community. We have not used any existing methods of textual analysis but we have tried to construct a tool ourselves, drawing broadly on Basil Bernstein’s work and using in particular his latest work on intellectual fields and knowledge structures (Bernstein, 1999, 2000). For example, we have a view about the field as a series of positions, as a horizontal knowledge structure. We would therefore view new theories as, in general, positioned alongside other theories and not replacing them, as we might expect in the development of theories in science. This tool has changed, and continues to change, as we interrogate more articles and find our categories inadequate or requiring modification. A key factor has been the development of justifications for judgements, what Bernstein (2000) calls recognition and realisation rules, for what makes us place an aspect of an article in one category or another in an explicit manner. We are concerned that this project should be an empirical, descriptive study and at the same time to generate a language capable of showing the effects of that which it describes. Certain structural features, drawn from a variety of places, have been used to construct the tool. Firstly, we have made a distinction between an orientation towards the theoretical or towards the empirical, according to which domain has been privileged. Articles in the first category may move to the empirical to illustrate the theory, but in this category the intention of the article is to present and perhaps to develop theory. Similarly, articles
28
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
that are orientated towards the empirical may well draw on theory, but their orientation is towards describing and perhaps informing school practice, policy, or other site of practice. In the first category we will then analyse how theory is used, whether it is supported or modified, and whether theories from other fields are used. In the second category we will look at what is the focus of the empirical, whether school practice, researchers’ practice, etc., and what methodology, data collection and analysis have been used. We also look at the relationship between theory, where the authors have drawn on theory either explicitly or implicitly, and the empirical, in the sense of whether the theory informs the empirical, is informed by the empirical, or there is a dialectic between them. Subsequently, we explore the question of whether the author(s) overtly adopt a particular position, such as feminist, post-modern, or other, and we identify the addressees of the article. We then examine the pedagogical model projected/promoted in the paper of the authors, where one has been identified. Here there are three subquestions derived from Morgan et al. (2002). The first is whether the orientation is towards a knowledge mode or towards pupils, the knower mode (see also Lerman and Tsatsaroni, 1998 and Maton, 2000). The second sub-question concerns the strategy (cf. Dowling, 1998; cf. Brown, 1999), and whether the authors look towards what is present or absent in students’ texts and whether they make localised to specialised comments. The third sub-question concerns the nature of the boundary between the everyday and specialised mathematics discourse and whether the boundary is presented as strong or weak. Finally, we ask three questions in order to locate the article within the field: what is the position within the official education discourse, i.e. towards the policy-makers; what is the position vis à vis the mathematics education research field; what is the position vis à vis other fields of knowledge production? We anticipate further restructuring of the analysis as the research proceeds. Nevertheless, we feel that the work we have done enables us to make some interesting comments in relation to how the field is shaping up through looking at the articles in this journal. One key reservation must be made, however. Researchers, in choosing a forum for the dissemination of their research, make assumptions about the type of audience constituted by the participants at a conference or the readers of a particular journal, and their particular interests and orientations (Burton and Morgan, 2000). They are likely to orientate their style accordingly. From the analysis of one journal, here of ESM, we cannot comment in an informed way on how researchers do change their writing for different perceived audiences; we
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
29
may be able to do so after the analysis of all three fora, ESM, PME and JRME, is completed.
3. ESM SPECIAL ISSUES
The topics of the Special Issues since 1990 are listed in Table I. The journal does not solicit Special Issues from the community, other than a general invitation for proposals. In the words of the former Editor-in-Chief: My experience was that once such a proposal had been made (by a member of the community), it generally got accepted after some discussion and revision. . . The high success rate of proposals reflects the fact that they generally came from very experienced people in the field, often drawing on special conferences or working groups which had been taking place, and therefore focusing on themes where there were likely to be interesting new things to say. It also reflects an attitude amongst the ESM editors which I would describe as one of openness to different approaches, as long as there is some clear sense of intellectual discipline behind them. (Ruthven, 2002, personal communication, our addition in italics)
In this sense, although ESM and other journals (as well as conference papers, research funding, etc.) clearly play a crucial role in the development of the field it does not drive what appears, either in the journal in general or in the Special Issues. Nevertheless, the comments above regarding the proposers indicate a tendency to perpetuation of mainstream themes and issues, whilst also facilitating the wide dissemination of work in those domains. A significant event in this period has been the formalising of the relationship between PME and the journal through the publishing of Special Issues, beginning with the one edited by Jones, Guttierez and Mariotti, (2000) that are products of Working Groups at conferences and in one case a development of a plenary panel, edited by Kieran, Forman, and Sfard (2001). A link such as this between a conference and a journal marks an important moment in the development of the field that will need to be evaluated at a later stage in our project. What can we say about the field from the topics of the Special Issues? Most present examples of substantial bodies of work within the community. Some of them have a specific purpose, to bring new ideas into the field. We can note in particular those edited by Lerman (1996), Boero (1999) and Kieran, Forman, and Sfard (2001). We can ask of these particular volumes when they are bringing a new approach to the practice of mathematics teaching and when to research. When talking about research we can ask whether the focus is on theory or on other aspects of research.
30
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
TABLE I Special Issues since 1990 Year
Vol.
No.
Topic and editors
No. of papers
23 23
1 5
4 6
24 24
1 4
25
1–2
1994
26
2–3
1995
27 28 29
4 3 2
1996
31
1–2
1997
33
2
Classroom Dynamics (Colette Laborde) Constructivist Teaching: Methods and Results (Ernst von Glaserfeld) Design of Teaching (Alan Bell) Aspects on Proof (Gila Hanna and Niels Jahnke) The legacy of Hans Freudenthal (Leen Streefland) Learning Mathematics: Constructivist and Interactionist Theories of Mathematical Development (Paul Cobb) Assessing Mathematics (Leone Burton) Mathematics and Gender (Gilah Leder) Advanced Mathematical Thinking (Tommy Dreyfus) Socio-Cultural Approaches to Mathematics Teaching and Learning (Stephen Lerman) Computational Environments in Mathematics Education (Richard Noss)
1990 1991 1992
1993
1998 1998/99 1999 38
1–3
39
1–3
2000
44
1–2
2001
45
1–3
46
1–3
48
2–3
Forms of Mathematical Knowledge: Learning and Teaching with Understanding (Dina Tirosh) Teaching and Learning Mathematics in Context (Paolo Boero) Proof in Dynamic Geometry Environments (Keith Jones, Angel Gutierrez, Maria Alessandra Mariotti) Constructing Meanings from Data (Janet Ainley and Dave Pratt) Bridging the Individual and the Social: Discursive Approaches to Research in Mathematics Education (Carolyn Kieran, Ellice Forman and Anna Sfard) Infinity – The Never-ending Struggle (David Tall and Dina Tirosh)
5 6 8 6
6 7 5 8 4
10
12 6
7 7
8
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
31
We can ask further questions of those that refer to practice, and indeed of all the Special Issue volumes, whether that orientation is to a topic in mathematics, to pupils, or to teaching. It is not always easy to classify uniquely by these questions as the volumes may address a number of these orientations within the range of papers included in the volume. We can see a strong focus on content across the years, from Aspects of Proof in 1993 to Infinity in 2001, as well as a focus on pupils’ learning and on teaching. In terms of our sub-questions, we can notice that there is an absence of an engagement of the mathematics education research community with other agencies, in terms of policy or politics. There is no discussion of curriculum, and there is one issue on assessment. Mathematical pedagogy appears to be the main interest of the research community, as evidenced in the Special Issues. We will want to comment on the relations between the community and official agencies but we will do so below. As a final comment, we note the recent increase in the number of Special Issues and in the number of articles in them. The PME books play a major part in this, but what it indicates about the state of the field is of interest. For example, some commentators have called for more unification of the work in the community and these volumes may play a part in this. Whilst reflecting on-going research, by drawing together research perspectives and methods and by posing further research questions these volumes also influence future research. On the other hand, it might indicate an increased pressure on researchers to move on from presenting a paper at a conference to seeing it published in a (refereed) journal.
4. A NALYSIS OF ARTICLES
As researchers we are particularly interested in and challenged by the methodological problems in this research. In our description of our findings we struggle with the criteria by which we categorise aspects of the articles, as we mentioned above. There is no space here fully to describe the rules we have developed for each category. We will, however, give just one example at the end of the overview to demonstrate our methodology. We will also not describe all the categories that our research tool investigates, for lack of space. We will focus on areas we think of most interest to readers. 4.1. Theories Our analysis shows that just over two thirds of all articles in ESM have an orientation towards the empirical, with a further 9% moving from the
32
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
theoretical to the empirical, and this has changed little over the years. A little less than three quarters are explicit about the theories they are using in the research reported in the article. Again this has not varied across the years. The theories that are used have changed. We can notice the following: – The range of theories or approaches used has developed over the years. Discourse analysis, hermeneutics, philosophy of mathematics, psychoanalytical theories and the sociology of Bourdieu and of Bernstein have all appeared in the last 6 years of our analysis. We will revisit the issues of theories below, when we consider the relations between the field of mathematics education research and other intellectual fields. – Below we will make a distinction between psychology and mathematics, on the one hand, as theories traditionally drawn upon by authors, and social theories on the other (see Lerman, 2000). Whilst social theories have been used (including social constructivism, Vygotskian theories, symbolic interactionism and others) throughout the period, we now see a much higher percentage drawing on these theories, from 9% average from 1990 to 1995, to 34% from 1996 to 2001. – As is perhaps appropriate given the anniversary being marked in this issue, Freudenthal’s ideas have received an increased interest in the last 3 years. In our analysis of how authors have used theories we have looked at whether, after the research, they have revisited the theory and modified it, expressed dissatisfaction with the theory, or expressed support for the theory as it stands. Alternatively, authors may not revisit the theory at all, content to apply it in their study. We have found that more than three-quarters fall into this last category, just over 14% revisit and support the theory, whilst less than one percent propose modifications. No authors in our sample ended by opposing theory. This pattern has not changed over the years. 4.2. Topics We have analysed the topics addressed in three ways: by sector of education (primary, secondary, etc.); by mathematics topic; and by whether its focus is towards teaching, that is, content, or learning, including its acquisition and assessment. Secondary/high school age is the predominant interest of authors published in ESM, with 44% of all articles in the sample, primary/ elementary being the topic for 37%, with a further 9% addressed the overlap of primary/ elementary and secondary/high school age. Students at Univer-
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
33
TABLE II Analysis of mathematical topics Topic Problem solving Number concept Arithmetic computation Estimation Fraction Ratio and Proportion Probability Algebra Geometry Proof Function and graph Advanced maths Statistics
Number
Percentage
21 8 6 3 5 5 5 8 12 2 8 7 5
19 7 5 3 5 5 5 7 11 2 7 6 5
sity are the focus of 8% of papers, with only a slight tendency towards an increase in this focus in recent years. Otherwise the pattern is consistent across the period. The spread of mathematical topics is very wide, as may be expected. The topics, totals and percentages appear in Table II. Of interest is the evidence that problem solving has the largest focus, followed by geometry. Most of the articles on problem solving appeared between 1994 and 1998, during which there were no special issues on this. With regard to focus we used the following categories: researchers’ practice; student teachers’ practice; policy; and school practice, with a further category for other focuses if they appeared. School practice is further split between agent/person, as teacher or pupil, and content, with content being sub-divided again into Bernstein’s three message systems, termed transmission5 , acquisition6 , and evaluation. There are very few articles in our sample of ESM from 1990 focusing on researchers’ practice although there is a small increase in frequency since 1996. Similarly there have been very few articles focusing on student teachers’ practice and an even smaller number on policy. The main two categories have been pupils as agents, an average of 34% of articles, and acquisition, an average of 34%. Teachers as agents had an average of 14% and transmission just 6%. Apart from the Special Issue on assessment, only two articles appeared in our
34
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
sample focusing on evaluation. The emphasis on pupils from a content point of view has increased in the last 6 years but emphasis on acquisition has remained constant. 4.3. Addressees An analysis of addressees is not an easy matter and requires careful consideration of criteria for classification. At this stage, we have used the authors’ own references, usually in the discussion or conclusions section, regarding to whom the research speaks. We have drawn on four categories here that have arisen purely pragmatically: researchers; researchers and teachers; researchers and teacher educators; and researchers and policy-makers. Almost three-quarters are addressed to researchers and teachers, almost a fifth to researchers alone, the remainder being almost all to researchers and teacher educators. The two categories, of researchers and teachers and of researchers, appear more frequently in the last 3 years. It is interesting to speculate why it is that most are addressed to researchers and teachers, given that it is probably the case that few teachers, other than those undertaking higher degrees or carrying out research, read the journal. It is also interesting to note how few articles are addressed to policy-makers. 4.4. Relations with other fields In this question, which relates to issue 1, theories, discussed above, we have examined what resources researchers draw upon in their research as it appears in publication. We emphasise the latter because it is not uncommon to find a substantial and informed review of literature in an article, in which the range of theoretical resources drawn on by others are noted, but then for the authors not to use any theory themselves, at least explicitly. One might suggest that an element of accepted style for publication may account for this phenomenon. As we discussed above, research in mathematics education is a horizontal knowledge structure, we might also say it is a region (Bernstein, 2000) in that it is a field that looks inwards to theoretical fields (psychology, sociology, anthropology etc.) and outwards towards practice. New theories and perspectives often develop from drawing upon different intellectual fields from those used before, or alternative aspects of those fields. Thus, they do not replace former theories but sit alongside them, what has been described elsewhere as: “the addition of a new language, an additional segment, rather than greater generality and integrative potential” (Morgan et al., 2002, p. 450). We might suggest that there is a connection here with creating identities, making a unique space from which to speak in novel ways, but we would need another study to substantiate and instantiate this claim. The relationships between mathematics education research
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
35
and other fields are complex but it is vital to attempt to identify these fields (see e.g. Higginson, 1980 for an attempt to describe how the fields relate to each other and to mathematics education research). Following Kilpatrick (1992) we will take psychology and mathematics as having a long history as intellectual fields at the heart of the discipline and map other intellectual resources as they have appeared in our sampling. We thus listed the theoretical fields drawn upon by authors, based on their explicit references in Table III. We can say that there has been a substantial increase in the number of fields in 1998, 1999 and 2000, it is too early to say whether this trend will continue, as 2001 shows a slight dropping off. As we have mentioned before, it appears that quite a range of social and sociological theories are being used increasingly by authors. 4.5. Relations with agencies As we mentioned above, there are very few articles in our sample that have addressed policy issues and addressed them to policymakers as well as the research community, one in each of 1994, 1998, and two in 2001. The relations between policymakers, or the Official Pedagogic Recontextualising Field (OPRF) as Bernstein (2000) calls it and the mathematics education research community and its activity within the intellectual field of knowledge production and within the Unofficial Pedagogic Recontextualising Field (UPRF) varies substantially across the world. In some cases, as presently in the UK, the UPRF appears to have very little or no influence on the OPRF, in that they appear to make their own selection of research on which to draw for their policies. We conjecture that the international nature of ESM leads to few articles being offered or accepted that are location-specific. We have found the same phenomenon in our analysis of PME proceedings. We conjecture, further, that although JRME is also an international journal it tends to be US-focused, so that authors generally see themselves as addressing one community and will therefore not shy away from attempting to engage with the OPRF in the pages of the journal. We have yet to carry out that stage of our project.
5. M ETHODOLOGY – RECOGNITION AND REALISATION
We will take, as an example, one article at random and indicate the rules by which we allocate classificatory criteria. We invite readers to follow and critique those rules. The article was published in volume 28 and the authors are Ma Tzu-Long Yang and Paul Cobb (1995). Looking first at theory, the authors are explicit about their use of Vygotskian theory (p.
36
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
TABLE III Theoretical fields Year
Theoretical fields other than educational psychology and/or mathematics
1990 1991 1992
Attribution theory, science education
1993 1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
Symbolic interaction Ethnomethodology Didactical situations Vygotsky Cognition in self-referencing systems Poststructuralism Hermeneutic phenomenology Vygotsky Feminist theory Transactional theory of stress Historical research Vygotsky Sociology (Bourdieu) Philosophy of mathematics Ethics Vygotsky Metaphor Transitional phenomena (Winnicott) Sociology (Bernstein) Situated cognition Gestalt Vygotsky Philosophy of mathematics Cognitive science Sociology (Bernstein) Discourse theory Psychoanalysis Vygotsky Embodied cognition Sociology (Ricoeur) Educational theory – Grounded Theory Situated cognition Vygotsky Process of psychological curtailment Educational theory – Collaborative Action Research Social psychology Discourse theory Ethnomethodology Situated cognition Vygotsky Motivation theory Embodied cognition
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
37
4) and their finding inspiration in Bishop’s work on enculturation (p. 3) in particular. It is a paper orientated to the empirical in that it looks to a study of Taiwanese and USA children to create theories for differences in competence in arithmetical thinking (p. 4). Its focus is on school practice and, further, looks at pupils’ cognition. Theory informs the empirical as the researchers develop sociocultural explanations for the differences the two studies reveal (pp. 27–30). The authors address teachers, in providing implications for classroom practice (p. 31) but also researchers in their emphasis on what is revealed by their theoretical orientation (p. 29). Finally, the authors draw on an intellectual resource beyond mathematics education research as we defined it, that is, beyond mathematics and psychology, Vygotskian theory, and they do not seek to modify or critique it. They do not engage with official fields. We categorise the location of their research as using theory. 6. S UMMARY
Finally, then, what can we say about “How is the field of mathematics education research shaping up, as represented in the journal”? We might suggest that the field exhibits a weak grammar, in that we can see a proliferation of new specialised languages, creating new positions within the field. As seen in ESM, the field of UPRF is active and developing, but it does not engage with the OPRF; we could say that, as represented in ESM over these years research sees itself as agent committed to UPRF development but not to OPRF. Researchers use a growing range of intellectual discourses as resources, are generally explicit about the theory they use, and they generally do not critique those theories. The focus is, in the main, towards learners, either from a curriculum point of view or a pedagogic point of view, and authors address the research community and teachers, although we have no explanation for the latter, other than, as argued earlier, in terms of the location, the purpose and the context in which mathematics education research is being carried out. An orientation towards social theories of one kind or another is increasing. As many of these languages or theories are drawn from the field of sociological inquiry, broadly speaking, one can hypothesise that the new positions created in the field will be supporting more radical pedagogical forms; they will be orientated towards developing more democratic and participatory forms of teaching, and will be concerned with empowering – i.e., giving ‘voice’ to groups of students (or teachers) thought to be silenced within the official pedagogic discourse – rather than focusing on the elaboration of their object of study (Bernstein, 1990; Maton, 2000). Although much more work is needed to support this
38
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
conjecture, perhaps, we can also venture the hypothesis that this might be an additional explanation of why this research community – as presented in the journal – has seen its task as one of supporting and guiding teachers rather than, for example, the policy makers. Furthermore, the journal seems to be explicitly reactive to the interests and concerns of researchers in the mathematics education community and does not seem to direct changes and developments. The impression is of a journal which aims to relay rather than construct ‘voices’. By allowing different positions from within the field of mathematics education research to appear, as published work, it constitutes a space where authorial voices can be re-presented. However, it might be argued that this space of freedom, which constitutes researchers as authors and readers and teachers as readers, might serve as well, on the one hand to reproduce the hierarchies between what Bernstein (1990) calls producers and reproducers of discourse and, on the other hand, to establish and legitimate itself as a mainstream academic journal. Indeed, the absence of active encouragement or initiative towards opening up debates might support such a reading. What other characteristics of the research culture get to be promoted (eg. the number of writers authoring a paper/changes within this period/emerging culture of research teams) given the current political context in which a distinction and hierarchy is developing between research and non-research active academic identities, is hard to say (cf. Hey, 2001) since we can obtain only limited information from a textual analysis alone. Without information as to what is rejected, and with what criteria, we cannot fully appreciate what is really produced. Finally, while acknowledging that the changes in reviewers over the years will have had its, perhaps, immeasurable effects on how the journal, and the field, appear in this 50th volume, we should also give thought to the claim that “. . . most academics remain deathly silent about the conditions of their own production” (P. Rabinow, quoted in Hey, 2001, p. 27) and to the claim that “[u]ntil we can bring to the surface and publicly discuss the conditions under which people are hired, given tenure, published, awarded grants and feted, ‘real’ reflexivity will remain a dream” (R. Gill, quoted in Hey, 2001, p. 67). We hope that the study reported here can help towards achieving greater reflexivity.
N OTES 1. This is an invited paper, celebrating the occasion of ESM’s reaching its 50th volume. 2. The project, which commenced in October 2001, is supported by the Economic and Social Research Council in the UK, # R000 22 3610. Its full title is: “The production of
DEVELOPING THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS EDUCATION RESEARCH
3. 4. 5.
6.
39
theories of teaching and learning mathematics and their recontextualisation in teacher education and education research training”. For other kinds of data to be collected, such as data from interviews with editors of Journals see reference in Note 2, above. See http://www.sbu.ac.uk/cme/Paperforpeercomment.doc Note the term is intended to be general and does not distinguish between forms of pedagogy. ‘Transmission’ teaching is often taken as conveying a pejorative meaning when compared to pupil-centred styles: we are using ‘transmission’ in a more general sense to represent a focus on what the teacher is doing, not to engage in any debate on preferred styles. Similarly, acquisition is to be taken as a general term for the range of styles of learning.
R EFERENCES Bernstein, B.: 1990, Class, Codes and Control, Vol. 4, The Structuring of Pedagogic Discourse, Routledge, London. Bernstein, B.: 1999, ‘Vertical and Horizontal Discourse: an Essay’, British Journal of Sociology of Education 20(2), 157–173. Bernstein, B.: 2000, Pedagogy, Symbolic Control and Identity: Theory, Research, Critique, Rowman and Littlefield, Maryland. Brown, A.J.: 1999, ‘Parental participation, positioning and pedagogy: a sociological study of the IMPACT primary school mathematics project,’ Collected Original Resources in Education 24(3), (7/A02-11/C09). Burton, L. and Morgan, C.: 2000, ‘Mathematicians writing’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 31(4), 429–453. Dale, R.; 2001, ‘Shaping the sociology of education over half-a-century’, in J. Demaine (ed.), Sociology of Education Today, Palgrave, Basingstoke. Dowling, P.: 1998, The Sociology of Mathematics Education, Falmer, London. Hey, V.: 2001, ‘The construction of academic time: sub/contracting academic labour in research’, Journal Education Policy 16(1), 67–84. Higginson, W.: 1980, ‘On the foundations of mathematics education’, For the Learning of Mathematics 1(2), 3–7. Kilpatrick, J.: 1992, ‘A history of research in mathematics education’, in D.A. Grouws (ed.) Handbook of Research on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, MacMillan, New York, pp. 3–38. Lerman, S.: 2000, ‘The social turn in mathematics education research’, in J. Boaler (ed.) Multiple Perspectives on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, Ablex, Westport, CT, pp. 19–44. Lerman, S. and Tsatsaroni, A.: 1998, ‘Why children fail and what mathematics education studies can do about it: The role of sociology’, in P. Gates (ed.) Proceedings of the First International Conference on Mathematics, Education and Society (MEAS1), Centre for the Study of Mathematics Education, University of Nottingham, pp. 26–33. Maton, K.: 2000, ‘Languages of legitimation: the structuring significance for intellectual fields of strategic knowledge claims’, British Journal of Sociology of Education 21(2), 147–167.
40
STEPHEN LERMAN ET AL.
Morgan, C., Tsatsaroni, A. and Lerman, S.: 2002, Mathematics teachers’ positions and practices in discourses of assessment, British Journal of Sociology of Education 23(3), 443–459. Nixon, J.: 1999, ‘Teachers, writers, professionals. Is there anybody out there?’ British Journal of Sociology of Education 20(2), 207–221. Tsatsaroni, A., Lerman, S. and Xu, G.: 2003 A sociological description of changes in the intellectual field of mathematics education research: Implications for the identities of academics. Paper presented at American Educational Research Association, Chicago, April. Usher, D.: 1996, ‘Textuality and reflexivity’, in D. Scott and R. Usher, (eds.), Understanding Educational Research, Routledge, London, pp. 33–51. Yang, M.T.-L. and Cobb, P.: 1995, ‘A cross-cultural investigation into the development of place-value concepts of children in Taiwan and the United States’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 28(1), 1–33.
Faculty of Humanities and Social Science, Division of Education, 103 Borough Road, London SE1 0AA, UK, ∗
Author for correspondence: E-mail:
[email protected]
DEREK FOXMAN1 and MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN2
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS USED BY 11-YEAR-OLDS IN DIFFERENT ATTAINMENT BANDS: A REANALYSIS OF DATA FROM THE 1987 APU SURVEY IN THE UK
ABSTRACT. This paper describes the reanalysis of data obtained in 1987 on the mental calculation strategies used by a sample of 11-year-olds in the course of a national survey of schools in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. The mental skills test was administered to pupils in a one-to-one situation and the reanalysis made use of classifications of mental strategies developed in the past decade in international research. These pupils were a subsample of the main sample of about 10 000 who took a written test of mathematics in the survey, 247 taking both tests. The scores on the written test were used to distribute these pupils into three bands of attainment in order to compare the frequency and effectiveness of the strategies used by pupils of different levels of attainment. Eight of the reanalysed questions are discussed, each of them involving one of the four basic arithmetic operations. Some are purely numerical and in others the numbers are in a context. Top band pupils mostly preferred sequential strategies which leave one of the numbers in the calculation complete, while the Bottom band generally preferred to split complete numbers and operate separately on the components of the numbers thus partitioned. The most popular strategy for Middle band pupils in several questions was the standard algorithm used mentally. Complete number strategies were the most successful for pupils in all three bands. Possible implications for the National Numeracy Strategy in Britain are discussed. KEY WORDS: addition, attainment bands, children’s mental strategies, context, division, mental calculation, multiplication, subtraction
I NTRODUCTION : T HE ORIGIN OF THE REANALYSED DATA According to Anita Straker (1999, p. 43), “The ability to calculate mentally lies at the heart of numeracy”. This tenet has been written into the National Numeracy Strategy currently being implemented in primary schools in Britain and now progressing into secondary schools. The importance of mental calculation in the development of early numeracy has long been a tradition in several continental countries, but in Britain, some 20 years ago, the government appointed committee of inquiry into the teaching of mathematics in schools (often known as the Cockcroft Committee after its chairman Dr W.H. Cockcroft) stated in its report (DES, 1982) that mental calculation had been neglected for some years in classrooms and should return. However, the results of national and international surveys in the dozen Educational Studies in Mathematics 51: 41–69, 2002. © 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
42
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
or so years following the publication of the Committee’s report suggested that schools were not focusing on calculation skills. International surveys of the 1980s and 1990s continued to show that number was a weak area in England relative to several continental countries (e.g. Foxman, 1992). Furthermore, national surveys of the mathematics performance of 11- and 15-year-olds, carried out in 1982, the year the Cockcroft Report was published, and again in 1987, found that scores in calculation on written tests declined in that interval. These national mathematics surveys were carried out by the National Foundation for Educational Research (NFER) on behalf of the Assessment of Performance Unit (APU) a Unit at the then Department of Education and Science (DES). The Unit was established in the mid-1970s and commissioned surveys in several core subject areas of the curriculum from independent research agencies. It was terminated when the National Curriculum and its associated programme of testing were introduced in 1988. The APU mathematics team developed a variety of assessments; accounts of the surveys and tests used can be found in the APU reports (see, for example Foxman et al., 1985, 1991). The 1987 APU surveys included tests of mental calculation skills administered in a one-to-one situation by experienced teachers who were therefore able to ask the children about the methods they had used to carry out calculations and record them. The evidence of a decline in the calculation scores of both 11- and 15-year-olds between 1982 and 1987 suggests that the mental calculation methods used by pupils in the 1987 surveys were untaught, and probably unknown to many teachers. Some of the results of the APU mental skills tests of both age groups were included in the final APU report (Foxman et al., 1991), but many of the responses to questions were left unclassified. We thought that some of these might now fit into the classificatory schemes developed by researchers in the 1990s decade (e.g. Beishuizen et al, 1997; Fuson et al., 1997; Thompson, 2000a). The NFER archives yielded the original interview data on the 256 age 11 pupils who took the mental skills test, all but nine of whom had also taken a written test of concepts and skills. This article is based on the data from the 247 11-year-olds who took both a written test of concepts and skills and the mental skills test. The article has four main purposes; to explore further the data from the 1987 APU survey in relation to:
• the mental methods used by 11-year-olds at a time when the methods were almost certainly untaught, and relate them to categories of response developed in the past decade;
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
43
• the methods used by pupils in different attainment bands, with the bands established by their scores in the written tests of concepts and skills, a measure independent of the mental test score; • a comparison with Dutch research findings on the differential effectiveness of mental calculation methods; • implications for the teaching of mental strategies.
1. T HE ADMINISTRATION OF THE MENTAL SKILLS QUESTIONS IN THE
1987 APU SURVEYS All the APU mathematics surveys included a number of practical tests that were administered orally by about 30 experienced teacher-assessors in one-to-one sessions with pupils. These teachers were nominated by the Local Education Authorities in which their schools were situated and trained to administer the tests by the NFER research team at a residential briefing conference lasting two and a half days. All the practical tests were untimed so that pupils were given as much encouragement as possible to demonstrate what they knew and could do. The one-to-one situation with its oral delivery of questions provided opportunities for controlled interaction between assessor and pupil. This interaction, especially the ‘probe’ question “How did you get your answer”, provided rich information on the methods pupils used to tackle the questions asked. The sample of 247 11-year-olds is likely to have been reasonably representative of the populations included in the surveys. However, the practical test subsamples were not drawn from the main sample on a totally random basis for practical reasons: very small schools with fewer than six pupils in the age range and schools situated in relatively remote areas were not included. The mean score and standard deviation of the subsample were close to those of the main sample of about 10 000 pupils, but there was an imbalance in the gender representation: there were 133 boys and only 114 girls. Assessors were provided with a ‘script’ for each topic that included instructions about what to say to the pupil and how to present materials and questions. The questions were printed in a booklet that contained one question per page, and an interviewee was asked to read out each question before being asked to do the calculation. Pupils were told by the assessor: I’m going to give you some questions that I want you to work out in your head. The questions are in this booklet. After each one I’m going to ask you how you worked out your answer – that’s not because you have got it wrong (or got it right), I’m just interested in how you worked things out. Here is the first question. Please read it to me and then work out the answer.
44
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
When pupils had given an answer they were asked how they had worked it out. Assessors recorded the responses in as much detail as possible. Sometimes pupils who had given an incorrect answer realised their error when describing their calculation; in such cases it was the second answer that was counted in the tally of correct responses. The original analysis recorded in the final report of the APU mathematics team (Foxman et al., 1991) left about 50 per cent of responses unclassified; the present reanalysis reduced this proportion to about 15 per cent. 1.1. The formation of the three attainment bands In the analyses described below pupils were assigned to attainment bands according to their scores on written tests of concepts and skills. In the 1987 survey all the 11-year-olds in the main sample of about 10 000 pupils took one of 20 different written tests of concepts and skills. Each of the concepts and skills tests comprised about 50 short response items from 3 of the 12 subcategories of content. (The 12 subcategories were organised in five main categories: Number, Measures, Geometry, Algebra, Probability and statistics. The total survey pool consisted of about 600 items.) In order to take account of their differing difficulties the tests were linked so that test scores could be placed on a common scale with a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15. (See Appendix 2.1 of Foxman et al., 1991 for details of the survey test design). The written test scaled scores of the 247 pupils taking the mental skills test ranged from 68 to 128. Mental Skills test scores (out of 10) of sample pupils correlated 0.67 with their written test scaled scores. A third of the Total sample was about 82 pupils. Each Third had approximately that number of pupils but the boundary between Thirds was arranged to be at a point of change in the written test scaled score as shown in Table I. TABLE I Written test scaled score ranges for each third of the sample Third Top Third Middle Third Bottom Third
Written test scaled score 107–128 95–106 68–94
n 81 80 86 247
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
45
2. T HE CLASSIFICATION OF MENTAL STRATEGIES IN THE REANALYSIS
In the 1980s, research on mental calculation strategies focused first on addition and subtraction with numbers under 20 (Carpenter, 1985). The 1990s saw an extension to strategies with larger (two-digit) numbers up to 100, research that was useful for the reanalysis of the APU data. For instance, Beishuizen et al. (1997) and Fuson et al. (1997) published rather similar classification schemes, based on research respectively in Holland and the USA, which we will use as a framework (Table II). We have added Thompson’s (2000a) strategy labels used in a recent publication for British teachers. Beishuizen’s strategy labels (Table II) are short acronyms introduced for ease of coding. The sequential strategy of Jumping in tens in either direction from any point in the number sequence is called N10 (meaning: N=Number; N+10 or N–10). Splitting off tens and units according to their place value and adding or subtracting them separately is called 1010 (meaning: 10+10 or 10–10). These are the two main mental calculation strategies for larger numbers, as the aforementioned research pointed out. We will use Fuson’s et al. (1997) full names Sequence-tens for N10 and Separate-tens for 1010, as they express concisely and precisely the fundamental difference in dealing with the tens (or hundreds) in larger numbers. Variants illustrated in Table II are N10C using Compensation, and 10S which begins with the tens like the split method 1010, and then handles the units sequentially. The latter strategy 10S is also called a ‘mixed method’ (Fuson et al., 1997; Thompson, 2000a). The strategy 10S is a special case as it could be considered as a transition between 1010 and N10 (Beishuizen and Anghileri, 1998; Beishuizen, 2001), when carried out as a correct adaptation of the 1010 impasse in the subtraction 4–6 (cf. Table II). However, it is often not the result of such an adaptation, but due to a misunderstanding or confusion when both units are subtracted (invalid: –4, –6; cf. Table II; cf. Fuson et al., 1997, p 152). A last type is A10 (Adding-on to a nearest ten) which is used a lot in the strategy Complementary Addition, and is quite popular in the UK as an alternative to Subtraction. Dutch research has given a good deal of attention to mental calculation strategies under the influence of the ‘realistic mathematics education’ movement. This emphasized that mathematics learning should always start from informal strategies which are promoted both by realistic context problems and by mental calculation (Gravemeijer, 1997; Treffers and Beishuizen, 1999). A similar philosophy can be found in the schools
46
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
TABLE II Mental addition (38+26) and subtraction (64–26) strategies up to 100 Beishuizen
Thompson
Examples of strategies
N10
Sequencing (Jump method)
38+20 → 58; +6 → 64 64–20 → 44; –6 → 38
N10C
Compensation
38+30 → 68; –4 → 64 64–30 → 34; +4 → 38
A10
Complementary addition
38+2 → 40; +20 → 60; + 4 → 64 26+4 → 30; + 30 → 60; + 4 → 64 (answer: 4 + 30 + 4 → 38)
10S
Mixed method
30+20 →50; +8 →58; +6→ 64 60–20 →40; +4 →44; –6 →38 (invalid: 40–4 → 36–6 → 30)
1010
Partitioning (Split method)
30+20 → 50. 8 + 6 → 14. 50 + 14 → 64 60–20 → 40. 4–6? Carry 10 from 40 →30; then 4–6 becomes 14–6 →8. 30+8 → 38 (often invalid: 4–6 →2. 40+2 → 42)
participating in American research projects stimulating children’s own methods of mental calculation (instead of teaching traditional algorithms), like those following the ideas of Carpenter et al. (1998) or Fuson et al. (1997). In the APU data of 1987, which revealed mostly untaught mental calculation strategies (cf. Introduction), we sought confirmation for two Dutch research findings in the 1990s: 1. Jump methods are more fluent and successful than Split methods which are more time-consuming and vulnerable to errors (Beishuizen et al., 1997). This could be due to a more crucial role of working memory in longer mental calculation procedures (Adams and Hitch, 1998). The Split method comprises more steps than the Jump method (cf. Table II) as some intermediate answers have to be stored in short term memory. The Split method therefore poses a heavier cognitive demand than the Jump method, whose sequential steps each operate directly on the answer of the previous step and so provide more fluency to the calculation (Wolters et al., 1990). 2. Interviews with Dutch pupils revealed that the more able preferred Jump methods while the less able preferred Split methods. To the less able, dealing with split off tens and units separately instead of ‘one
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
47
big sum’ seemed an ‘easier way’ to operate on two-digit numbers. See Beishuizen and Anghileri (1998) and Beishuizen (2001) for a description of this research. In order to draw more general conclusions about the efficiency of strategies in the reanalysis of the APU data, we have used two broader contrasting concepts: Complete Number approach and Split Number approach (Foxman and Beishuizen, 1999). We introduced these concepts to underline the way in which mental strategies differ from written calculation procedures. For instance, following Dickson, Brown and Gibson (1984, p. 271) one of the contrasting characteristics of mental strategies according to Plunkett (1979) is that: “They usually are holistic, in that they work with complete numbers rather than separate tens and units”. In our reanalysis the Complete number approach includes strategies like Sequence-tens or N10 as well as Adding-on or A10, while Split number categories encompass Separate sequential or 10S strategies in addition to Separate-tens or 1010. The concepts of Complete and Split number strategies were formulated originally in relation to the addition or subtraction of two numbers. We have extended these notions to the classification of Multiplication/Division strategies, which played a role in some of the APU questions. Some examples are given below. In the case of Question number 6 (cf. Table III), “How much would I pay for 4 tapes costing £1.99 each?”, there is a clear contrast between the response of multiplying 4 times the Complete number £1.99 (rounded up to £2, then followed by Compensation) and that of multiplying the Split numbers £1 and 99p separately (sometimes rounding up the 99p to £1) and then combining the subtotals. It is very obvious that the distinction Complete-Split applies here as well (cf. Table X). In the case of Question 11, 16 × 25, the usual calculation strategy is to leave one of the numbers complete (16 or 25) and then multiply it separately by the tens and units of the other number. We classified this under a Complete number approach, as we did with using the number relation that 4 × 25 is 100 (and with some other strategies counting in 25s or 50s). A smaller group of pupils used a Split number approach by splitting up both numbers (followed by some crisscross multiplications, cf. Table IX). Quite a lot of these pupils lost the idea of the original whole numbers, and this strategy was given the label Separate Digits as a variant of Separate Tens (cf. Table IX). In their publications most researchers use the same kind of classifications for mental calculation strategies as we have described above. The terms used may differ but they have a recognizable comparable meaning. For instance, in a study of the mental computation strategies employed by Japanese students, Reys et al. (1995, p. 318) used the following names for
48
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
the categories Sequence-Tens (N10) and Separate-Tens (1010): ‘Hold one addend constant’ and ‘Group by tens and ones’. Ruthven (1998, p. 20) in his evaluation study of mental and calculator strategies of pupils in former so-called CAN schools in the UK, uses ‘Mental Cumulation’ and ‘Mental Distribution’ for similar categories of strategies. We have tried to link our strategy labels to other international classification schemes as described above. As mentioned in the Introduction many of the responses to the APU questions in the original report were unclassified. For the reanalysis we set out to recode as many of the responses as we could by applying the recently developed categories described above. We began with test Question 2 (64–27) because this type of subtraction problem is used a good deal in contemporary research (cf. Fuson et al., 1997) and so many coding examples were available. After independent recoding of all 247 protocols for Question 2 we reached an initial intercoder agreement of about 80 per cent. Following the same procedure, with much discussion of examples, and sometimes debate, we made our way again through the questions (cf. Table III), finishing with nearly 100 per cent conformity for every question. Any remaining responses upon which we could not reach agreement were added to the Other/Unclassified category. Most calculations were worked from left-to-right, a prominent characteristic of mental methods. Some answers, however, were clear-cut cases of right-to-left working which followed standard written algorithm procedures or ‘ciphering in the air’. So we have mental strategies following a formal Algorithm on one hand, and mental strategies following an informal Complete or Split number approach on the other hand. We called the latter ‘informal’ strategies because (we assume) they were ‘untaught’ in British classrooms in 1987. In the USA they are described in their project schools as ‘invented strategies’ (Carpenter et al., 1998, p. 4) or ‘categories of children’s methods’ (Fuson et al., 1997, p. 131). Within the broad categories Complete and Split we labelled the variety of more specific mental strategies as discussed above, and we ordered them from high to low level in terms of number of steps, etc. (cf. Tables and descriptions in Section 3). This article is concerned with the eight questions in the test which required two numbers to be combined using one of the basic arithmetical operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication or division (Table III). The other four questions were of a different nature. We think that the reanalysis of these eight APU questions in Section 3 gives a representative picture of the mental skills at the end of British primary school in 1987.
11 12
6 7 8 28 81
44 52 48
48 94
73 78 72
91 77 83
25 86
34 48 51
93 70 56
12 63
27 33 22
86 38 42
90 61 60
1 2 5
26 + 7 64 – 27 I buy fish and chips for £1.46. How much change should I get from £5? How much would I pay for 4 tapes costing £1.99 each? How many 18p stamps can you buy for £1? I catch a bus at 9:43 am and arrive at my stop at 10:12 am. How long does the journey take? 16 × 25 238 + 143
Total sample Top third Middle third Bottom third n = 247 n = 81 n = 80 n = 86 % % % %
No. Question
Percentage success rates in the total sample and within each third
TABLE III MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
49
% TOTALS n
8 17
20+ (6+6=12)→32; +1→33 20+ (6+7=13)→33
100 247
64 25 5 7
4 36 24
100 81
67 22 7 4
7 15
7 47 12
100 80
59 30 6 5
10 20
3 28 29
% sample using strategy in total bands sample T M
26+10→36; –3→33 26+4→30; +3→33 26, 27, 28. . .→33
Examples
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Complete number: Compensation Bridging tens Counting Split number: Near doubles Addition facts
Strategies
Q1 26 + 7
100 86
65 22 1 12
7 15
1 34 30
B
90 247
92 93 92 53
90 95
100 99 81
91 81
91 94 100 67
83 100
100 100 50
93 80
96 92 80 75
88 94
100 100 91
86 86
91 95 100 40
100 92
100 97 85
% success rate of those using strategy in total bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q1
TABLE IV
50 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
51
3. T HE REANALYSIS : F REQUENCY OF USE AND SUCCESS RATE OF STRATEGIES WITHIN ATTAINMENT BANDS
The relative difficulties of the eight questions can be seen in Table III where they are placed in order of presentation to the children. The table shows that five of them had success rates in the Total sample between 44 and 61 per cent, including all four of the questions involving numbers in context. The questions with the highest and the lowest success rates were purely numerical. The easiest questions were the two additions, 26 + 7 and 238 + 143, which were, respectively, the first and last questions to be asked of the testees. Table III also compares the success rates within the Thirds of the Total sample. Apart from Q11 (16 × 25) the success rates in the Top Third were above 70 per cent; those in the Middle Third were, on average, about 21 percentage points less and in the Bottom Third 18 percentage points less than in the Middle Third. The high success rate of the question placed last in the test could indicate that a large proportion of pupils in the Total sample had been able to focus on the questions throughout. However, assessors were instructed to terminate tests if any pupil showed signs of distress and this was implemented for some nine pupils who therefore did not provide responses to varying numbers of questions from number 8 onwards. These nonresponses were counted as such in the analysis and not subtracted from the total taking particular questions. In the tables that follow, for each of the eight questions, we summarize the proportions of pupils using Complete and Split strategies in the Total sample and within each Third. Also provided for each question is the proportion that described a mental picture of the standard written algorithm for the operation concerned (labelled ‘Algorithm’ in the tables). 3.1. Addition and subtraction questions: 1, 2, 5, 8, 12 3.1.1. Numbers only: Questions 1, 2 and 12 Question 1: 26 + 7 This was the easiest of the questions, achieving a success rate of 90 per cent overall. It was presented first in the test in order to promote confidence in the pupils. Because it was so easy there was little differentiation between the Thirds in either the proportions using particular strategies or in their success rates. Nearly all classified strategies were effective. The Complete number strategies comprised low level Counting, used mostly by the Bottom and Middle bands (but also by 12 per cent of the Top band), and higher level Compensation and Bridging tens, selected more
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Separate tens (1010)
Split number: Separate sequential (10S)
Complementary repeated addition (N10/A10)
Complete number: Compensation (N10C) Sequence tens (N10)
Strategies
Q2 64 – 27
% TOTALS n
60–20→40; +4→44; –7→37 60–20→40; –7→33 60–20→40; –7→33; – 4 → 29 60–20→40; 7–4→3; 40+3 (ans 43) 60–20→40; 4–7→–3; 40–3 (ans 37)
64–30→34; +3→37 64–20→44; –7→37 64–7→57; –20→37 27+10+10+10→57; +7→64 27+3→30+10+10+10→60; +4→64 (ans:10+10+10→30; +7 or +3+4→37)
Examples
100 247
35 27 30 9
17
10
8
9 18
100 81
49 20 26 5
9
11
6
12 31
100 80
34 19 45 3
14
5
8
10 16
% sample using strategy in total bands sample T M
100 86
22 41 19 19
27
14
9
5 8
B
61 247
79 33 75 27
27
44
63
82 84
77 81
85 56 81 80
71
44
80
100 88
70 80
85 27 78 50
27
25
83
88 85
38 86
58 26 63 19
13
50
38
75 71
% success rate of those using strategy in total bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q2
TABLE V
52 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
53
frequently by Top band pupils. Of the few who chose to use the standard Algorithm, most were in the Top band. Question 2: 64 – 27 Five of the eight questions had middling overall success rates around 50 per cent, ranging from 44 percent to 61 per cent. Question 2 was at the top of this range. Few pupils used Complementary addition (N10 and A10), although this is a common procedure in calculating the change in a money purchase situation (see Question 5 below). They made small jumps of +10+10+10 which contrasts with the larger jumps of 20 or 30 made by those using Sequence tens (N10) or Compensation (N10C). The explanation for this may be a matter of differential experience and automatisation. Sequence tens, a Complete number strategy, was selected most frequently by the Top band pupils (31 per cent of the band) and least frequently in the Bottom band (8 per cent of the band). Compensation, a higher level variant of Sequence tens, was used less frequently, but again more by the Top band (12 per cent) than by the Bottom band (5 per cent). Middle band children used the Algorithm mentally more frequently (45 per cent) than those in either of the other two bands (Top 26 per cent; Bottom 19 per cent). They maintained success rates as high as those in the Top band when they selected either Complete number strategies or the standard Algorithm, but not when they used Split number strategies. Split number methods for solving 64 – 27 were used in a variety of ways, in particular for the critical step of handling the units. The main contrast we have made was the Separate sequential strategy (10S) as a higher level adaptation of the Separate tens strategy (1010) which produced incorrect solutions more frequently, in particular by invalidly subtracting 4 from 7 in the units. A few pupils produced high level solutions using negative numbers or decomposition (e.g. [50+14]–[20+7]) but these were rare and were therefore not given a separate category in the classification scheme. Bottom band pupils favoured Split strategies, Separate tens being the most used in the Bottom band (27 per cent) and least in the Top band (9 per cent). The success rates of Bottom band pupils were lower than those of the other bands for all selected strategies except for the mixed strategy, Separate sequential. However, Bottom band pupils using the Complete number strategies Compensation or Sequence tens were much more successful than those using other strategies. In addition the use of the Algorithm proved to be moderately successful in this band. Question 12: 238 + 143 Question 12, the final question in the test was the second easiest, achieving
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Digits left-right
Complete number: Sequence hundreds /tens Split number: Separate hundreds /tens
Strategies
Q12 238 + 143
% TOTALS n
20
200+100→300; 30+40→70; 8+3 →11; 300+70+11→381 1+2→3; 3+4+1→8; 8+3→11 (carried 1); →381
100 247
3 37 51 10
17
3
238+100→338; +40+3 →381
Examples
100 81
7 32 57 4
10
22
7
100 80
1 30 65 4
16
14
1
% sample using strategy in total bands sample T M
100 86
0 48 31 21
23
24
0
B
81 247
100 85 87 25
85
84
100
94 81
100 96 93 67
100
94
100
86 80
100 88 88 33
92
82
100
63 86
– 76 74 17
75
76
–
% success rate of those using strategy in total bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q12
TABLE VI
54 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
55
an 81 per cent success rate overall. As such it was a useful check on the number of pupils who had remained focused on the task to the end of the test. It encouraged the use of the standard Algorithm and Split number strategies particularly (51 per cent and 37 per cent of the Total sample respectively), and few chose Complete number approaches (3 per cent). This contrasts with the other easy addition, Question 1, where the opposite distribution of strategies resulted, presumably due to the different sizes of the numbers involved. The few pupils who used the Complete number strategy Sequence hundreds /tens were almost entirely in the Top band: the Split number approach is more popular for such addition problems (Thompson, 1994). Of the two Split number strategies, Separate hundreds /tens responses were equally divided between Top and Bottom bands. Methods specific to this question, Digits left-right, where pupils verbalised only the digits of numbers in the tens and hundreds, but in left to right order, a characteristic of mental calculation – the opposite of the order of working used in the standard written Algorithm – were more prevalent in the Bottom band. The standard Algorithm (used mentally: digits operated on from right-to-left) was probably used so frequently for this question, especially in the Top and Middle bands (57 and 65 per cent respectively) because it was an easy 3-digit addition problem that did not cross the hundreds barrier. 3.1.2. Addition and subtraction questions: Numbers in context: Questions 5 and 8 Question 5: I buy fish and chips for £1.46. How much change should I get from £5? This question had a very similar overall success rate (60 per cent) to the purely numerical subtraction, Question 2 (64 – 27). However, there was a contrast in the methods used to calculate their respective answers: as an everyday money context calculation Question 5 naturally invited the informal ‘shopkeeper’s method’, using Complementary addition to obtain the answer. One third of the Total sample used this strategy for Question 5, whereas only 8 per cent did so for Question 2. Mental calculation methods, whether Complete or Split and used by 83 per cent overall (Table VII), were overwhelmingly employed in this question as compared with the standard Algorithm (10 per cent). To what extent this was due to the familiar everyday context or to the numbers involved or to a combination of these factors, cannot be derived from the evidence here. For example, would a calculation such as comparing, say, £5.37 with £1.46, have induced more use of the algorithm?
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Subtraction and adding-on
Split number: Separate subtractions
Sequential subtraction
Complete number: Complementary addition
Strategies
% TOTALS n
£5 – £2→£3: £2 – £1.46p→54p (ans £3 +54p→£3.54) £5 – pounds £1→£4: £1–46p→54p (ans £4.54) £5 – £1→£4: 46p up to £1→54p (ans £4 + 54p →£4.54)
£1.46+ 4p→£1.50; + £3.50→£5 (ans £3.50 + 4p → £3.54) £1.46 + 4p + 50p→£2; + £3→ £5 (ans £3 + 50p + 4p → £3.54 £5 – £1→£4, –46p→£3.54 £5 – £1→£4; –46p→£3.64
Examples
Q5 I buy fish and chips for £1.46. How much change should I get from £5?
100 247
59 24 10 7
24
26
33
100 81
76 15 7 1
15
38
38
100 80
53 25 15 8
25
18
35
% sample using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M
100 86
48 31 8 13
31
21
27
B
60 247
76 36 52 22
36
63
85
83 81
87 58 83 100
58
84
90
56 80
74 40 33 33
40
43
89
42 86
61 22 57 9
22
44
74
% success rate of those using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q5
TABLE VII
56 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
57
The Complete number strategies, Complementary addition and Sequential subtraction, were used most frequently by Top band pupils (76 per cent) while, of the few pupils who used the standard Algorithm, the strategy was most preferred by those in the Middle band (15 per cent). These patterns of use were very similar to those found in the responses to Question 2. The Split number strategy Separate subtractions was most popular in the Bottom band (31 per cent). In general, success rates declined through the Thirds from Top to Bottom. The only exception was for the standard Algorithm where there was a rise from Middle to Bottom, but only a few pupils selected this strategy. Perhaps the most important statistic to note in Table VII is that when pupils in the Bottom band used Complete number methods they achieved much greater success (61 per cent) than those who adhered to Split number methods (22 per cent). However, within Complete methods Complementary addition was more effective than Sequential subtraction, as the examples given in Table VII illustrate.
Question 8: I catch a bus at 9.43 am and arrive at my stop at 10.12 am. How long does the journey take? There was a good deal of similarity in the results of the two subtraction questions 5 and 8 with numbers in context. Question 8 attracted few pupils to use the standard Algorithm but invited many Complementary addition strategies (62 per cent). Within these latter strategies there were small differences in calculation procedures as depicted in Table VIII. For those using A10 we see more chunking (+17, +12) with 10:00 as a natural break point, while the few who used N10C (N10) calculation procedures counted on in steps of +10 like the Complementary repeated addition seen in Question 2 (Table V). Compensation was used in some Rounding and N10C responses. A few Complementary addition solutions suffered from the misconception that there are 100 minutes in an hour and were coded as Other/Unclassified. A quarter of the pupils (26 per cent) followed a Split number approach. They used Separate additions and/or subtractions on the hours and minutes which mostly resulted in invalid answers of over one hour as shown. As for previous questions, there was a general decline in frequency of use of Complete number strategies from Top to Bottom thirds and the opposite incline for Split number strategies. Complementary addition (A10) was the most popular Complete number strategy, around a half of the Top and Mid Third pupils and a quarter of the Bottom band using it with considerable success. Again it is noteworthy that it was the only successful strategy for
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Separate subtraction
Split number: Separate addition
Complete number: Complementary addition (A10) Complementary addition (Rounding with Compensation) Complementary addition (Other) Sequence Tens (N10C, N10)
Strategies
% TOTALS n
9 to10=1hr; add 17 and 12 (ans 1hr 29mins). Took 9 from 10 & 12 from 43 (ans 1hr 31mins)
9:43+2→9:45; 45+12–2 (ans 40 mins) 9.43+10+10+10→10.13; –1 (ans 29 mins)
9:43+17→10:00; +12→10:12 (ans 29 mins) 9:45+15→10:00; +12→10.12;+2 (ans 29 mins)
Examples
Q8 I catch a bus at 9.43 am andarrive at my stop at 10.12 am. How long does the journey take?
100 247
63 26 2 9
9
100 81
82 9 4 5
4
5
12
7
17
2
15
10
6
53
40
100 80
65 26 3 8
8
18
10
4
6
45
% sample using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M
100 86
42 42 0 15
13
29
0
10
8
24
B
48 247
74 5 20 0
10
2
76
7
38
91
72 81
82 29 33 0
33
25
80
0
50
95
51 80
78 5 0 0
17
0
71
33
40
89
22 86
51 0 0 0
0
0
–
0
14
86
% success rate of those using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q8
TABLE VIII
58 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
59
the Bottom band pupils; any other method they attempted to use resulted in almost complete failure. 3.2. Multiplication and division: Questions 11, 6 and 7 3.2.1. Numbers not in context Question 11: 16 × 25 This was one of the two multiplication questions, the other, number 6, being contextualised. It was, by some distance, the most difficult of the questions with an overall success rate of 28 per cent. The unclassified category was quite large (25 per cent) because there were many non-responders to this question. The results illustrated the lack of understanding of multiplication of a large proportion of pupils, particularly in the Bottom band, and to some extent, in the Middle band. In fact, as stated above, only those pupils who used Complete number methods achieved reasonable results, and the highest proportion of these were in the Top attainment band (76 per cent success rate). However, nearly a quarter of Bottom band pupils (22 per cent) also used a Complete number method, nearly a half of them (47 per cent) obtaining the correct answer while hardly any of those using other methods did so. Split number methods and Unclassified/No responses were found mostly among Middle and, especially, Bottom band pupils. 3.2.2. Multiplication and division: Numbers in context Question 6: How much would I pay for 4 tapes costing £1.99 each? Question 6 invited use of a Complete number Rounding multiplying and compensation strategy because of the money context with the amount just one penny below £2. About one third of the pupils (35 per cent of the Total sample) did so by rounding up to £2, multiplying by 4 and then compensating for the rounding, a Complete number strategy. However, 11 per cent rounded the pence only and this strategy was categorised as a Split number strategy. The pattern of frequency of use and success rates of the main strategies, Complete, Split and Algorithm was similar to other questions: Complete number strategies were used more frequently by Top band pupils and least in the Bottom band, and the standard algorithm was used more frequently by Middle band pupils, another pattern that has so far been fairly consistent. Top band pupils were more successful than those in other bands, whichever strategy they used. The only slight difference from previous patterns of results was that Bottom band pupils using Complete number strategies were more successful than those in the Middle band who did so. Thus, the success rate for Complete number strategies were largely maintained
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Separate digits
Split number: Both numbers split
Counting in 25s or 50s One number complete
Complete number: Use of number relations
Strategies
Q11 16 × 25
% TOTALS n
10×20=200;10×5=50; 6×20=120 6×5=30. (incorrect add 390) 5×6=30 & 20×10=200; (ans 230) 5×6=30 & 20×1=20; (ans 50)
16=4×4; 4×25=100; 4×100→400. 16×25→8×50→4×100 →400 2×25=50; count in 2s to 16→8×50 6×25 =150 &10×25=250; →150 + 240 =400 16×20=320 &16×5=80; →320 + 80 = 400. 16×2=32 & 16×5=80; → 32+80=112
Examples
100 247
38 16 21 25
12
4
5 20
13
100 81
57 12 25 6
6
6
2 35
20
100 80
36 11 30 23
8
4
8 18
11
% sample using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M
100 86
22 23 10 44
21
2
6 9
7
B
28 247
65 20 9 2
0
20
62 44
100
48 81
76 10 10 20
0
20
100 61
100
25 80
59 11 8 0
0
33
67 29
100
12 86
47 0 11 0
0
0
40 13
100
% success rate of those using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q11
TABLE IX
60 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Split number: Multiplying split number & compensating Multiplying split number & adding
Complete number: Rounding, multiplying & compensating Doubling or adding
Strategies
% TOTALS n
4×£1 and 4×£1–4p (ans £7.96 or £8.96) 4×£1; + 4×90p + 4×9p (ans £7.96 or £7.66). 4 ×£1;+99p+99p+99p+99p (ans £6.06)
4×£2→£8; –4p (ans £7.96) £1.99+£1.99→£3.98; +£3.98 (ans £7.96)
Examples
Q6 How much would I pay for 4 tapes costing £1.99 each?
100 247
100 81
60 23 10 6
14
24
38 34 9 18
10
4
3
11
57
35
100 80
30 28 18 25
23
5
4
26
% sample using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M
100 86
24 51 1 23
35
16
2
22
B
44 247
77 25 48 11
19
38
63
78
73 81
86 47 88 20
45
50
67
87
34 80
58 23 29 20
22
25
33
62
27 86
76 16 0 0
7
36
100
74
% success rate of those using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q6
TABLE X
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
61
Complete number total Split number total Algorithm Unclassified/No response
Split number: Multiplying split number
Repeated addition
Complete number: Rounding, multiplying & compensating Multiply number facts Doubling
Strategies
% TOTALS n
5×10→50p, 5× 8→40p; 50+40 →90p (ans 5). I added 10s to 100, 8s to 100; ten 10s in 100, that’s the most (ans 10)
5×20 is £1 and it leaves 10p (ans 5). 3×18 + 2×18 (ans 5). 2×18→36; ×2→72; +18→90p. (ans 5) added 18+18+18+etc. to £1 (ans 5)
Examples
Q7 How many 18p stamps can you buy for £1?
100 247
49 12 16 23
12
100 81
64 9 19 9
9
4
1 21
1 14 12
38
21
100 80
40 10 23 28
10
9
3 16
13
% sample using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M
100 86
42 17 7 34
17
23
0 6
13
B
52 247
62 57 79 12
57
37
100 57
77
78 81
77 86 87 14
86
67
100 82
84
48 80
47 38 83 23
38
57
100 31
50
33 86
44 53 50 3
53
25
– 40
82
% success rate of those using strategy in total attainment bands sample T M B
Percentage of strategy use and success rate within the total sample and each third of the total sample (T = Top, M = Middle, B = Bottom) for Q7
TABLE XI
62 DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
63
through the attainment bands from Top to Bottom, in sharp contrast with the success rate for Split number strategies and in even sharper contrast with the performance of those using the Algorithm.
Question 7: How many 18p stamps can you buy for £1? Question 7 invited more Complete number strategies (52 per cent) than previous questions, probably because of the everyday estimation context and because 18p is not a large number. This Multiplication/Division question produced as wide a variety of higher level and lower level strategies as was noted above with Addition/Subtraction questions. This was probably because the relatively easy number 18p induced fewer Split number strategies (12 per cent overall). Some of these resulted in correct and others in wrong answers due to misconceived separate operations on tens and units (cf. Table X). As indicated by Foxman (2001) there was some uncertainty about Algorithmic responses to this question: no assessor described a response which went through all the stages of long division. The responses treated here as the Algorithm were trial multiplications (5 × 18) – the first long division step. This was the response assessors attributed to 16 per cent of the pupils. The Unclassified category now includes responses such as ‘100 ÷ 18 is about 5’, which we originally classified as the Algorithm, but have decided that there is insufficient information to label them as such. The Unclassified category contains as much as a fifth of the Total sample (21 per cent). This number also includes some who guessed the answer, a response that may have been induced either by the wording of the question or, possibly, because the first step in the operation of division encourages an informed guess which should have been tested by multiplication. The patterns of use and success rate for Question 7 within attainment bands was again similar to those of previous questions. This included the greater use of the Algorithm by the Middle than the other two bands, although marginally so in this case. One slight difference compared with previous questions was that Bottom band pupils utilised Complete strategies as much as those in the Middle band. However, this was due mainly to their greater use of the lower level strategy Repeated addition (23 per cent of Bottom band; 4 per cent of Top band), the Top band pupils favouring the higher level Multiplying complete number (38 per cent Top band; 13 per cent Bottom band). Both Top and Bottom band pupils used the latter strategy effectively (success rates 84 and 82 per cent respectively). Another slight difference was the greater success of Bottom band than Middle band pupils in using a Split number procedure.
64
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
3.3. Summary of strategies utilised Each of the questions in the APU test encouraged the application of particular strategies adapted to the structure of the calculation and the specific numbers involved, but some more general approaches can also be identified. The most general category labels we have used relate to the Complete/Split number distinction. This contrast has been applied to the responses of eight of the questions in the test: numbers 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11 and 12. All of these questions involved calculations in which two numbers could be combined by using one of the four basic operations – addition, subtraction, multiplication or division. There was, of course, also the option for pupils to use the relevant standard written algorithm mentally. A more specific but still general strategy is one in which one of the numbers involved in the calculation is replaced by another which simplifies the calculation (rounding) and an adjustment then made to the answer obtained (compensation for the rounding). This procedure was used by some pupils in five of the questions: numbers 1,2 6, 7 and 8. Finally, question 11 invited flexible use of number relations – an opportunity taken up mainly by pupils in the Top band.
4. D ISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
We present first a summary of tendencies we see in the APU data within the three attainment bands (Section 3). This is followed by a discussion of these main conclusions. 1. There was a strong tendency in most questions for Complete number strategies to be used most frequently by Top band pupils and least by Bottom band pupils. 2. There was a strong tendency in most questions for Split number strategies to be used most frequently by Bottom band pupils and least by Top band pupils. 3. There was a strong tendency in most questions for Complete number strategies to be more successful than Split strategies and the use of the standard Algorithm for a calculation within all attainment bands. The Algorithm was the next most successful. 4. There was some tendency in most questions for the Algorithm strategy to be used more frequently by Mid band pupils and least by Bottom band pupils. 5. There was a tendency for Rounding and Compensation strategies to be used much more by Top band than Mid and Bottom band pupils, when number characteristics invited these efficient short-cut strategies.
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
65
6. There was a strong tendency for questions in context to encourage the use of mental strategies, whether Complete or Split, more than the use of the Algorithm. Pure number problems invited more Algorithm responses. The first three conclusions differentiate the two main mental strategies, Complete and Split. They show that, in 1987, pupils in Britain already used a great many informal or ‘invented’ mental calculation strategies in which the more efficient Complete number strategies, sequential jumping in particular, are dominant. This profile is close to Dutch research findings later in the 1990s (Beishuizen et al., 1997), but seems to differ markedly from often reported practice in the USA. For instance, Fuson et al. (1997, p. 158) describe how in their various project schools in the USA “children predominantly used methods in which multiunits were added or subtracted separately”. A possible influence on eliciting Split number methods might be the use of structural apparatus, as Beishuizen (1993) found in his research in Holland. This use was probably not so extensive in British classrooms in 1987 (Foxman et al., 1991, Chapter 6, p. 33). This APU reanalysis adds another argument to keep the contrast between Complete and Split number strategies on the research agenda. It raises the same questions as those posed in Beishuizen’s et al. (1997) research (cf. Section 2): • Why is the sequential (N10) jumping strategy more efficient than the splitting (1010) strategy? • How to explain (Beishuizen, 2001) that pupils learn the ‘Sequencetens’ (N10) strategy, or change from the ‘Separate-tens’ (1010) to the sequential (N10) strategy without being taught? • The most relevant question for the practice of mathematics teaching: why it is that many weaker pupils have a preference for a Split number approach? It underlines the current work in Holland on how to make sequential strategies available to less able pupils with support of the empty number line as a new model (Beishuizen, 1999; Menne, 2001). Since the introduction of the National Numeracy Strategy (NNS) in Britain in 1999, much more attention to mental calculation strategies has been given. Some findings in the APU data, however, could be useful to improve the NNS implementation. For instance, we agree with Thompson’s (2000b) critique of the NNS guidelines, that mental strategies for two-digit numbers are given a lot of attention, but in a rather confusing way. Jump and Split strategies are not regarded as distinctive categories, but considered under one global label ‘Using multiples of 10’, which needs a further differentiation. For instance, the question 64 – 27 contains many examples
66
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
that could be used to give teachers a better background information about the typical characteristics of these different mental strategies. The more frequent use of the standard Algorithm by Mid band pupils might be explained by differences in attitude of pupils at different points of the ability scale. More able pupils may prefer informal and shortcut strategies, because they have the insight and are not afraid to try them (cf. Hope and Sherrill, 1987). Mid band pupils probably felt safer with the taught algorithms, because they guaranteed success (at least for addition and subtraction – the multiplication algorithm was much more problematic for the majority). On the other hand, many Bottom band pupils may have been uncertain of the Algorithm, and so resorted to informal Split number strategies which seemed to them an ‘easier’ alternative (cf. Beishuizen et al., 1997, Section 2). On a higher level than many Complete and Split number methods, which could be said to have a rather standard character, insight in number relations is used for shortcut strategies such as Rounding and Compensation (£1.99 → £2, question 6; 18p → 20p, question 7) and the Use of number relations (16 × 25 → 4 × 4 × 25 → 4 × 100 = 400, question 11), which were very successful (cf. Section 3). However, they were used frequently only by Top band pupils. Foxman (2001) reporting similar APU data for 15-year-olds, found that a greater use of those flexible strategies had developed with age. But how could we improve their use much earlier in primary school? Ruthven (1998) evaluated whether schools, having followed a Calculator Aware Number (CAN) curriculum aiming at flexible use of calculators and mental strategies, had stimulated their use postproject in comparison with non-project schools. By asking pupils to solve context questions as in the APU test – for instance a similar ‘stamps’ problem (5 × 19p) – Ruthven found that both higher and lower attaining pupils in the post-project schools made more use of mental strategies. These “pupils had been encouraged to develop and refine informal methods of mental calculation from an early age” (p. 38), which offers a positive perspective to schools following a mathematics curriculum with more room for flexible mental calculation. The conclusion that questions set in context encouraged the use of more informal mental strategies underlines the role of comprehension of mathematical problem structure (for an adequate strategy choice), as advocated by ‘word problem research’ (Verschaffel and DeCorte, 1997) and ‘realistic mathematics education’ (Treffers and Beishuizen, 1999). For instance, Complementary addition was used much more in the money context of question 5 (£1.46 from £5) than with the pure numerical question 2 (64 – 27). This alternative strategy for the operation of subtraction, however,
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
67
presupposes a good insight in the structure of the problem. The contextualised question 8 (bus journey 9:43 to 10:12) illustrates this principle in an even stronger way (cf. Table VIII). Again Complementary addition is used a lot and mostly adequately. The opposite is true for pupils using the Split number approach where handling the hours and minutes separately results in many unrealistic answers like “1 hour 29 minutes”. These pupils apparently also lacked an adequate comprehension of the structure of this everyday timetable problem. These examples from the APU data illustrate why context questions can be such valuable tools in interactive mathematics teaching (Treffers and Beishuizen, 1999). They invite more informal strategies and more snapshots of children’s inadequate use of calculation strategies, which can give the teacher more clues on how to address them (cf. Anghileri, 2000). They also provide a more natural means for teachers to explore how different answers given by children in their class to the same problem are arrived at and discussing which one is correct.
R EFERENCES Adams, J.W. and Hitch, G.J.: 1998, ‘Children’s mental arithmetic and working memory’, in C. Donlan (ed.), The Development of Mathematical Skills, Psychology Press, Hove, UK, pp. 153–173. Anghileri, J.: 2000, Teaching Number Sense, Continuum, London. Beishuizen, M.: 1993, ‘Mental strategies and materials or models for addition and subtraction up to 100 in Dutch second grades’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 24(4), 294–323. Beishuizen, M.: 1999, ‘The empty number line as a new model’, in I. Thompson (ed.), Issues in Teaching Numeracy in Primary Schools, Open University Press, Buckingham, pp. 157–168. Beishuizen, M.: 2001, ‘Different approaches to mastering mental calculation strategies’, in J. Anghileri (ed.), Principles and Practices in Arithmetic Teaching – Innovative Approaches for the Primary Classroom, Open University Press, Buckingham, pp. 119–130. Beishuizen, M. and Anghileri, J.: 1998, ‘Which mental strategies in the early number curriculum? A comparison of British ideas and Dutch views’, British Educational Research Journal 24(5), 519–538. Beishuizen, M., Van Putten, C.M. and Van Mulken, F.: 1997, ‘Mental arithmetic and strategy use with indirect number problems up to one hundred’, Learning and Instruction 7(1), 87–106. Carpenter, T.P.: 1985, ‘Learning to add and subtract: An exercise in problem solving’, in E.A. Silver (ed.), Teaching and Learning Mathematical Problem Solving – Multiple Research Perspectives, Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, pp. 17–40. Carpenter, T.P., Franke, M.L., Jacobs, V.R., Fennema, E. and Empson, S.B.: 1998, ‘A longitudinal study of invention and understanding in children’s multidigit addition and subtraction’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 29(1), 3–20.
68
DEREK FOXMAN AND MEINDERT BEISHUIZEN
DES (Department of Education and Science): 1982, Mathematics Counts (Cockcroft Report), HMSO, London. Dickson, L., Brown, M. and Gibson, O.: 1984, Children Learning Mathematics – A Teacher’s Guide to Recent Research, Cassell, London. Foxman, D.: 1992, Learning Mathematics and Science – the second International Assessment of Educational Progress in England, National Foundation for Educational Research, Slough. Foxman, D.: 2001, ‘The frequency of selection and relative effectiveness of different mental calculation methods – some evidence from the 1987 APU surveys’, in C. Morgan and K. Jones (eds.), Research in Mathematics Education Volume 3 – Papers of the British Society for Research into Learning Mathematics, British Society for Research into Learning Mathematics, London, pp. 37–54. Foxman, D., Ruddock, G., Joffe, L., Mason, K., Mitchell, P and Sexton, B.: 1985, A Review of Monitoring in Mathematics 1978 to 1982, Assessment of Performance Unit, Department of Education and Science, London. Foxman, D., Ruddock, G., McCallum, I. and Schagen, I.: 1991, APU Mathematics Monitoring (Phase 2), School Examinations and Assessment Council, London. Foxman, D. and Beishuizen, M.: 1999, ‘Untaught mental calculation methods used by 11-year-olds’ Mathematics in School, November 1999, 5–7. Fuson, K.C., Wearne, D., Hiebert, J., Murray, H., Human, P., Olivier, A., Carpenter, T. and Fennema, E.: 1997, ‘Children’s conceptual structures for multidigit numbers and methods of multidigit addition and subtraction’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 28(2), 130–162. Gravemeijer, K.: 1997, ‘Mediating between concrete and abstract’, in T. Nunes and P. Bryant (eds.), Learning and Teaching Mathematics – An International Perspective, Psychology Press, Hove, UK, pp. 315–345. Hope, J.A. and Sherrill, J.M.: 1987, ‘Characteristics of unskilled and skilled mental calculators’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 18, 98–111. Menne, J.: 2001, ‘Jumping ahead: an innovative teaching programme’, in J. Anghileri (ed.), Principles and Practices in Arithmetic Teaching – Innovative Approaches for the Primary Classroom, Open University Press, Buckingham, pp. 95–106. Plunkett, S.: 1979, ‘Decomposition and all that rot’, Mathematics in Schools 8, 2–5. Reys, R.E., Reys, B.J., Nohda, N. and Emori, H.: 1995, ‘Mental computation performance and strategy use of Japanese students in grades 2, 4, 6 and 8’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 26(4), 304–326. Ruthven, K.: 1998, ‘The use of mental, written and calculator strategies of numerical computation by upper primary pupils within a ‘calculator aware’ number curriculum’, British Educational Research Journal 24(1), 21–42. Straker, A.: 1999, ‘The National Numeracy Project: 1996–99’, in I. Thompson (ed.), Issues in Teaching Numeracy in Primary Schools, Open University Press, Buckingham, pp. 39–48. Thompson, I: 1994, ‘Young children’s ideosyncratic written algorithms for addition, Educational Studies in Mathematics 26, 323–345. Thompson, I.: 2000a, ‘Mental calculation strategies for addition and subtraction – Part 2’, Mathematics in School January 2000, 24–26. Thompson, I: 2000b, ‘Is the National Numeracy Strategy evidence-based?’, Mathematics Teaching no. 171, June 2000, 23–27.
MENTAL CALCULATION METHODS OF AGE 11 PUPILS
69
Treffers, A. and Beishuizen, M.: 1999, ‘Realistic mathematics education in the Netherlands’, in I. Thompson (ed.), Issues in Teaching Numeracy in Primary Schools, Open University Press, Buckingham, pp. 27–38. Verschaffel, L. and DeCorte, E.: 1997, ‘Word problems: A vehicle for promoting authentic mathematical understanding and problem solving in the primary school?’, in T. Nunes and P. Bryant (eds.), Learning and Teaching Mathematics – An International Perspective, Psychology Press, Hove, UK, pp. 69–97. Wolters, G., Beishuizen, M., Broers, G. and Knoppert, W.: 1990, ‘Mental arithmetic: Effects of calculation procedure and problem difficulty on solution latency’, Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 49, 20–30. 1
London University Institute of Education (DF), 59 Minster Road, London, NW2 3SH, England Telephone/Fax: +44 (0)20 7435 3962, E-mail:
[email protected] 2
Leiden University, the Netherlands (MB), Abel Tasman Place 6, 2253 KA, Voorschoten, The Netherlands, Telephone: +31 (0)71 576 2585, E-mail:
[email protected]
BARBARA JAWORSKI
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN UNIVERSITY MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
ABSTRACT. Data from observations of first year university mathematics tutorials were analyzed to elicit characteristics of teaching using a tool, the teaching triad, developed in earlier research. Analysis explored elements of ‘sensitivity to students’ and ‘mathematical challenge’ in the observed teaching. Initial analyses suggested teaching to consist mainly of tutor exposition and closed questions embodying little challenge for the student. More finely grained analyses provided insights into pedagogic processes relating teaching actions, processes and strategies and their learning outcomes, and providing alternative perspectives on sensitivity and challenge. The research, distinctively, shows approaches to analyzing teaching that start to address tutor-student interactions related to cognitive construction of mathematics (here abstract algebra) by undergraduates within the social dimensions of the tutorial setting.
I NTRODUCTION TO THE UMTP AND THE TEACHING TRIAD The Undergraduate Mathematics Teaching Project (UMTP) is a study of mathematics teaching in first year tutorials at one university. It is rooted in theory about teaching relating to analyses of mathematics teaching in secondary schools with a focus on teaching activity and the associated thinking of teachers in planning for students’ mathematical activity (Jaworski, 1994; Steinbring, 1998). It focuses particularly, in the tutorial setting, on tutor-student interactions and on tutor’s accounts of their teaching and thinking about teaching. I use the word ‘teaching’, rather than ‘tutoring’ to emphasize the principal motivation of this research which is to understand more about mathematics teaching in its widest sense. Data from tutorial interactions provide opportunity to analyse the teaching-learning interface and to gain insights into teaching epistemology, particularly relationships between mathematics and pedagogy. Data from teachers’ accounts (from one-one interviews and from group meetings of teachers and researchers) provide insights into teaching intentions and hence to the mathematical pedagogy of the teachers. This research fits into a tradition of seeking to characterize mathematics teaching at secondary and undergraduate levels. Educational Studies in Mathematics 51: 71–94, 2002. © 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
72
BARBARA JAWORSKI
TABLE I Elements of the teaching triad Management of Learning
ML
Sensitivity to Students
SS
SSA SSC
Mathematical Challenge
MC
ML describes the teacher’s role in the constitution of the classroom learning environment. This includes organizing classroom groupings; planning tasks and activity; establishing norms and fostering ways of working SS describes the teacher’s knowledge of students’ thinking, attention to their needs and the ways in which the teacher interacts with individuals and guides group interactions. SS has been shown to relate to both affective (e.g., offering praise, encouraging students to participate, including students in dialogue) and cognitive (e.g., judging appropriate questions, inviting explanation, fostering negotiation and inquiry) dimensions of students’ mathematical development. MC describes the challenges offered to students to engender mathematical thinking and activity in tasks set, questions posed and metacognitive encouragement.
1. to gain better understandings of teaching processes and their potential contribution to students’ learning of mathematics. 2. to gain insights into how teaching develops or can develop and implications for teacher education. This paper reports the use of a model, the teaching triad, derived from analyses of secondary mathematics teaching, to analyse data from a study of undergraduate teaching. The teaching triad comprises three elements related to the teaching of mathematics: they are management of learning (ML), sensitivity to students (SS) and mathematical challenge (MC). These elements are closely interlinked and interdependent as has been shown in previous research (Jaworski, 1994). The use of the triad as an analytical tool follows such use in analyses of secondary mathematics teaching (Potari and Jaworski, 2002). Analysis of the data from undergraduate teaching categorises tutorial teaching in relation to the elements of the triad and reassesses the meaning of these elements. The triad has also been used to analyse the activity of mathematics teacher-educators in the teaching of mathematics teachers (Zaslavsky and Leikin, 1999). Brief descriptions of the elements of the triad are given in Table I.
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
73
TABLE II The concept of harmony Harmony
Of SS with MC
Where sensitivity and challenge fit together well to enable students to engage with mathematical ideas and progress in mathematical thinking.
Earlier research has focused particularly on interactions where sensitivity seems to support effective challenge (or not) – i.e., where MC is successful (or not) in engaging students with mathematical ideas in a way that enables progress in their mathematical thinking. When such success is recognizable, we have suggested that SS and MC are in harmony (Table II), and have provided examples of both presence and lack of harmony in teacher-student interactions (Potari and Jaworski, 2002). The methodology of the UMTP was reported in detail in Jaworski, Nardi and Hegedus (1999). The study involved a collaboration between three mathematics educators (the researchers) and six university mathematicians (the tutors). Briefly, we collected qualitative data from weekly observation of tutorials between tutors and their students (mathematics undergraduates), from interviews with the tutors soon after each observed tutorial, and from periodic meetings of the 9 participants during one university term, a third of the academic year. From interview data, detailed analyses provided insights into teaching issues. These included teachers’ decisions and their relation to students’ learning of the particular mathematics that was the focus of tutorials (largely analysis and abstract algebra, with some topology and probability). Later, analyses of tutorial data were undertaken, using the teaching triad as one mode of analysis, to gain more detailed insights into tutor-student interactions and their relation to issues in pedagogy. Discussion in this paper relates to analysis of tutorial data. Further details of the analytical processes are given below.
T HEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES Pedagogic knowledge in mathematics teaching Shulman (1987) identified 7 aspects of teaching knowledge that contribute to teachers’ operation in classrooms. Three of these are subject content knowledge, pedagogical knowledge, and pedagogical content knowledge. Subject content here is mathematics; we are interested in how teachers’ pedagogic approaches to teaching are related to their focus on mathematics
74
BARBARA JAWORSKI
and aim to enhance understandings of pedagogic content knowledge – knowledge that crosses the boundaries of mathematics and pedagogy (see, for example, Even and Tirosh, 1995, 2002). Much of the research concerning pedagogy and mathematics has focused on mathematics teaching in schools and relates to the professional knowledge of mathematics teachers in school classrooms (e.g., Jaworski, 1994; Simon, 1995; Steinbring, 1998; Skott, 2001). Like these studies, the UMTP seeks to gain insights into pedagogic practices, processes and issues, here at university level, as tutors work with students on mathematics. Palfreyman (2001, p. 6) quotes Moore who writes The tutor is not a teacher in the usual sense: it is not his job to convey information. The student should find for himself the information. The teacher [sic] acts as a constructive critic, helping him to sort it out, to try it out sometimes, in the sense of exploring a possible avenue, rejecting one approach in favour of another. (Moore, 1968, p. 18)
Such a statement begs many questions about subject and pedagogy, and indicates assumptions implicit in the system; for example, that part of a teachers’ job “in the usual sense” is “to convey information”; teacher as “constructive critic” is by implication ‘unusual’. Conveying information, and constructive criticism are elements of pedagogy. How such elements are related to mathematics and to students’ learning of mathematics is of central interest in research on mathematical pedagogy. Relating to student cognition in the learning of mathematics The difficulties that students face in learning mathematics at university level has been explored in recent research (e.g., Tall, 1991; Nardi, 1996). Such exploration is connected to a body of cognitive theories that start to characterize mathematical thinking at undergraduate level. These are largely related to the construction of mathematical knowledge, often drawing on the work of Piaget (e.g. Dubinsky’s APOS theory – Dubinsky, 2000). They offer a range of cognitive concepts and constructs that begin to explain learners’ construction of mathematics and some of the associated difficulties: for example, notions of concept image and concept definition (e.g., Tall and Vinner, 1981); the reification of mathematical knowledge and its relations to metaphor (e.g. Sfard, 1994); and the theory of cognitive obstacles developed, for example, by Sierpinska (e.g. Sierpinska, 1994). The learning of particular topics in mathematics at undergraduate level, such as calculus, linear algebra and abstract algebra has also been a focus of research. For example, research into learning of abstract algebra (a mathematical focus of this paper) suggests that students have difficulty in conceptualizing cosets of groups, and relating them to notions of conjuga-
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
75
tion (e.g., Dubinsky et al., 1994; Burn, 1998; Nardi, 2001). Such analyses link mathematics (e.g., groups, cosets, conjugation) with cognition – conceptualization and coming to know (e.g., in relation to concept images and cognitive obstacles). Relating cognitive and social perspectives Seeing learning as the construction of mathematical concepts and the forms of mental representations that result is characteristic of much of this research on undergraduate mathematics. Since the intention of teaching is that it will create learning (Pearson, 1989), the focus of analysis on teaching and pedagogy in the UMTP is related to these areas of research on mathematics learning. It is possible to see teaching, also, in terms of cognitive construction in which teachers design teaching situations and respond to students according to their own mental schemata on teaching. However, we see teaching more broadly as a social practice, a product not only of the constructive activity of the individual teacher but a complex nexus of social inter-relationships within which pedagogy and learning develop. Thus, analysis of the teaching/learning interface involves a blend of cognitive and social theory. Micro-analyses focus finely on the discourse of interactions and macro-analyses link fine detail to wider social factors affecting learning and teaching. Kieran, Forman and Sfard (2001) write: Whether one speaks about learning in terms of discourse, activity, culture or practice, the focus is on the change generated by interpersonal interactions, and this . . . results in a picture which is more complex and closer to life than in traditional cognitivist studies. (p. 7)
As many such cognitively focused studies have provided insights into learning, we are challenged therefore to take account of both constructivist and sociocultural perspectives of learning – “to deconstruct the dichotomy, and not to unify the halves” (Kieran, Forman and Sfard, 2001, p. 10). In the UMTP we see a dialectical relationship between thinking and communication. Wenger (1998) speaks of “modes of belonging”, including engagement, imagination and alignment. We engage with ideas through communicative practice, develop those ideas through exercising imagination and align ourselves, critically, “with respect to a broad and rich picture of the world” (p. 218). Learning is presented as a “process of becoming”. Wenger states, “It is in that formation of identity that learning can become a source of meaningfulness and of personal and social energy” (p. 215). Teaching in mathematics tutorials fits into a wider tutorial culture within this university encompassing perspectives quoted above (Moore, 1968) and others discussed below. It fits into the ways of being of particular tutors and students and the negotiated ethos of particular relationships. ‘Modes of
76
BARBARA JAWORSKI
belonging’ and ‘processes of becoming’ are central to relationships within these cultural layers, and the learning processes of students and their tutors. Our analyses of tutorial interactions offer interpretations of learning or teaching as “particular moment[s] in the zoom of a lens” (Lerman, 2001). In micro-analysis we zoom in to fine details of interactional discourse; in macro analysis we zoom out to consider a range of social factors of which the discourse is a part. T UTORIAL DATA AND ITS ANALYSIS The tutorials we observed involved usually one tutor and two students and lasted one hour. One researcher sat quietly in the background, watched, listened, made (field) notes – a hand-written record of what was said and written by tutor and students – and recorded the tutorial on audio tape. Immediately after the tutorial, the researcher reviewed the field notes and wrote a number of related questions that would form the basis of a semistructured interview with the tutor, often the same day. Phase I of analysis used the interview data to characterize teaching approaches and referred to tutorial data for extra information and for validation. Phase II, an analysis of tutorial data, was undertaken to enhance understandings of tutorial teaching from the first phase and to find out whether the triad was a helpful tool for analysis. We analysed data from tutorials of all six tutors during Weeks 2, 5 and 7 (out of 8); i.e., from 18 tutorials spread across the time of the project. We cross-referenced these analyses to tutors’ accounts of their teaching in the associated interviews. Thus we linked analyses of discourse from tutorial interactions between tutor and students with discourse from interviews between tutor and researcher. Analysis involved first the production of a tutorial protocol, a factual summary of the data, from each tutorial recording. These protocols were coded to categorize teaching: descriptive codes emerged from reading and re-reading each protocol and checking backwards and forwards to rationalize the developing codes. We noted the most commonly occurring codes as indicating patterns in the data. Most prevalent were codes relating to tutor explanation (exposition of some aspect of mathematics), tutor as expert (offering of key methods of solution, or proof, or mathematical tricks or routines that are perceived to be part of what one tutor expressed as the “mathematical armoury” that students need) and forms of tutor questioning. The next stage of analysis was to re-code the tutorial protocols using the teaching triad. Accordingly, each line of the protocol was re-examined and wherever possible one or more of the three elements of the triad (ML,
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
77
SS, MC) was associated with it as in previous analysis using the triad. The findings were striking. Although there were frequent occurrences of ML and SS, very little data was coded as MC. We asked, “where is the challenge?” (Jaworski, 2001). Was there no challenge to find, or were the protocols or the triad too blunt as instruments to reveal challenge? In order to address these questions, we went back to the full data of the recordings to do a more finely grained analysis. Certain parts of tutorials, providing evidence of patterns in the coding, were transcribed and then subjected to micro- and macro-analysis to gain insights into the detail of the teaching as in earlier research (Potari and Jaworski, 2002). These analyses are exemplified below.
T YPICAL PATTERNS OF INTERACTION AND AN EXEMPLARY EPISODE The lecture-tutorial culture in mathematics in this university requires students to tackle problems set in a lecture and give written solutions to their tutor for comments. Tutors’ marking of the solutions often forms the basis of tutorial activity which is designed to address students’ work and thinking, particularly difficulties. The following episode from a tutorial on abstract algebra has been chosen to illustrate a typical pattern in such activity. See episode 1 below. Descriptive codes are indicated in the transcript and used in the microanalysis which follows. From his marking of students’ solutions concerning Lagrange’s theorem, it seemed to the tutor that students believed the converse of this theorem; i.e. that since, given a finite group G, where o(G) means the order of G, if H is a subgroup of a finite group G then o(H) is a factor of o(G), then also, for any factor of o(G), we can find a subgroup whose order is that factor.
He wanted all students to appreciate that this converse is not true, as evidenced in the associated interview protocol: Researcher: You mark their work. How does this form your tutorial agenda? Tutor It tends to be that all of them have made the same mistakes, so it helps to form a scheme of help, e.g. noticing that they all believed the converse of Lagrange’s theorem to be true. Then, once this general scheme is formed, you have to tailor it individually, e.g. noticing that a particular student is writing left cosets for right and that gives her odd results. [Coded: TEACH; REC STU PRO; KNOW STU]
78
BARBARA JAWORSKI
The phrases ‘scheme of help’, ‘this general scheme’ and ‘tailor it individually’, are indicative of the tutor’s pedagogic thinking and intentions for students’ learning. The episode shows how the tutor ‘tailors’ his approach for two students, using as an example the group A4 . Since the set of all even permutations of degree n forms a group An of order 1 /2 n!, called the alternating group of degree n (Ledermann, 1961, p. 77), A4 is of order 12. Students had been unable to produce a subgroup analysis for A4 . The first stage of analysis here involved a line by line scrutiny of the dialogue to describe the observed teaching. This resulted in codes associated with transcript statements as was mentioned above. The following categories can be seen: • Initiation-Response-Feedback patterns (IRF) (Sinclair & Coulthard, 1975) (e.g., lines 7, 8, 9) • Closed questioning (Pimm, 1987) (e.g., lines 1, 3, 5, 7) • Lengthy teacher explanation (e.g., lines 9, 12, 16, 17) • Minimal student participation (e.g., lines 2, 4, 6, 8, 13, 15) • Teacher expertise and apparent dominance of thinking (e.g., lines 9, 12, 16, 17) These are the characteristics of a tutor-dominated interaction with little encouragement for students’ participation beyond short responses that provide feedback to the tutor to suggest that students are following his argument, e.g., at line 13. Whether or what students are thinking is not explored beyond these responses. Analyses as a whole show that a considerable part of activity in tutorials can be characterized in the form described. Of course details change: different bits of mathematics cause different problems for different students, and different tutors interact with their students in idiosyncratic ways. For example, the pauses in the dialogue above are short compared to those of another tutor, who usually waits a much greater length of time (20– 30 seconds in some cases) for his students to say something, and much longer than some tutors who wait hardly any time at all. “Answering own questions” (AOQ) is one coding category of tutor activity, in which, quite commonly, a question is asked by the tutor, and almost immediately the tutor supplies the answer (e.g. line 12). It is a rhetorical form in which the question is an almost seamless part of tutor exposition of the concept. Tutors use closed questioning and IRF sequences to maintain a dialogue in which the tutor’s mathematical ideas appear to be addressed. Such (micro-)characteristics emerge from analysis of tutorial interactions of which the above episode is just one example. How do they accord with what the tutor sees herself or himself to be doing or trying to achieve? What insights can we glean into how a tutor transforms thinking about
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
Figure 1. Transcript for Episode 1.
79
80
BARBARA JAWORSKI
Figure 1. Continued.
teaching into practice in the tutorial. Before the episode I indicated that one of the interview quotations had been coded as follows: [TEACH; REC STU PRO; KNOW STU]. These were some of the most commonly occurring codes in our analyses of interviews. They characterize the tutor’s words (e.g., “scheme of help”, “this general scheme” and “tailor it individually”) as being about planning for teaching, recognizing students’ problems, and knowledge of students. They relate to the tutor’s pedagogic thinking in diagnosis of students’ difficulty, design of activity such as the use of an example to address perceived difficulties and challenge students’ conceptions, and (implicitly) the further challenge to make sense of the tutor’s explanation in their own study. These are the macro-characteristics of the episode drawing on factors in tutorial culture and tutor thinking. The word ‘challenge’ is used deliberately in the statements above as a lead into analysis using the teaching triad.
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
81
C HARACTERISING ELEMENTS OF ACTIVITY OR DIALOGUE USING THE TEACHING TRIAD AND ADDRESSING JUDGMENT AND RESEARCH ETHICS
Unlike many episodes in the data from secondary teaching, with which the triad has been used previously, this episode was hard to code using the triad at a line-by-line micro-level. There seemed to be no observable elements of challenge, and sensitivity was hard to locate. The tutor’s choice of approach – exposition – can be characterized largely as ML (management of learning). It allowed the tutor to air the key ideas quickly and students seemed to follow his reasoning. At the micro-level, considering lines 1 to 8, we might suggest that the tutor’s expository approach involved some elements of judgment that students were following his argument and making sense of the mathematics involved, and indeed that this encompassed some degree of affective and cognitive sensitivity (SSA/C). Lines 10 to 13 and 14 to 17 repeat these management patterns. In such terms, this approach could be regarded as an efficient way of dealing with the particular student difficulties. An alternative analytical position here is that the interactions lack cognitive sensitivity; they result in a process of funnelling towards the tutor’s ideas (Bauersfeld, 1988) that encourages a dependence on the tutor, rather than a scaffolding process that genuinely fosters the students’ own thinking (Williams and Baxter, 1996; Potari and Jaworski, 2002). Encouraging students themselves to articulate the mathematical argument would have taken longer than the exposition but the act of doing so – arguably embodying greater sensitivity – could have challenged their reasoning skills, reinforced their understanding of subgroup properties and provided the tutor with insights into their perceptions of group structure. At a macro level, mathematical enculturation might be seen as a tacitly agreed basis of interaction – the university expects students to develop into good mathematicians. Students are expected to know Lagrange’s Theorem. It is important, mathematically, that they can find all the subgroups of a given group and that they perceive the difference between theorem and converse both in the particular case and more generally. The tutor’s use of example and corresponding explanation might be seen as a good management strategy, enabling students both to be shown how to analyse a group for its subgroups and to become aware of truth relations between a theorem and its converse. In this we might discern a (tacit) element of challenge. Students are confronted with a challenge to their perceptions, and it is up to them to go away and make sense of it.
82
BARBARA JAWORSKI
Whichever of the above interpretations or judgments we find most credible, it appears here that the tutor takes on the management role of ‘conveyor of information’ rather than that of ‘constructive critic’ (Moore, 1968) and that this role encompasses only minimal sensitivity or challenge. The researcher analyzing this text has tried hard to ‘stretch’ notions of sensitivity to ensure that any attention to students’ thinking and development has been acknowledged. Value judgments have to be recognized in this analysis, made long after the event and without consultation with the tutor. Such consultation could have led to the tutor himself recognizing factors and issues (and perhaps limitations) in this pedagogic approach, and possibly to enhanced pedagogic awareness. However, this research focused on observing and characterizing teaching, and on highlighting issues in teaching. Use of the analytical process to work with tutors on developing teaching, that is, to include a more overtly developmental dimension to the research, would have needed either a different kind of initial agreement between tutors and researchers or an evolution of the research towards a more developmental focus. Although we found in interviews that certain tutors asked for the researcher’s comments on their teaching, we were very careful to be seen not to be judgmental of the teaching observed. There are important ethical questions here for research of this nature, since the analysis offered here clearly takes us into such judgments, albeit at a distance from the event and with care for the anonymity of the people involved. A N ALTERNATIVE PATTERN OF INTERACTION AND ITS ANALYSIS USING THE TEACHING TRIAD
The pattern described in the episode above can be seen in varying manifestations in many of the observed tutorials. The episode that follows is chosen as an example of an alternative approach rather than as signaling another common pattern of interaction. There were a number of such alternatives, each idiosyncratic to the tutor and to some extent to the particular students, but with a common characteristic, that sensitivity and challenge were more obvious in the interactions. Unusually the tutor here was also the lecturer of the Abstract Algebra course, so he had, himself, set the problems on which the students worked, including a question about quotient groups. He refers to a theorem he had proved in the lecture, leaving students with the challenge of tackling its converse. Here, the lecturer/tutor is working with two students, one of whom is ill (S1) and does not say much. S2, according to the tutor is a very able student. The tutorial protocol for the episode reads as follows:
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
83
Tutorial Protocol: Tutor asks S2 a ‘why’ question. S2 explains at the board. Tutor offers advice and asks questions when S2 gets stuck. S1 offers suggestions. When S2 has finished his proof, tutor explains a quicker method he [the tutor] would have used. [The ‘why’ question was coded as QE – enquiring question.]
The actual statement of the problem given in the lecture is not available. However, we know it involved an equivalence relation on a group defined by elements being ‘representative of the same coset’. At the beginning, the tutor refers to written work given to him by students before the tutorial. The transcript was coded initially using a descriptive coding similar to that of Episode 1 as can be seen in the transcript that follows. The episode, while largely managed by the tutor, splits into 3 parts with part (b) different in style from parts (a) and (c). a) [Statement 1] in which tutor, in expert mode, creates the problemsolving environment, stating the problem, and clarifying its context and parameters; b) [Statements 2–25] in which we see tutor-students interaction: one student, mainly, constructs a solution with support from tutor instructions [5, 9], questions [7, 22], comments [12, 14, 16, 18], prompts [20, 22, 24], and expert input [16]. At points, tutor and student seem to think together [17, 19, 25]; c) [Lines 26–27] in which we see the tutor in expert mode, explaining and demonstrating. Alongside the transcript is a coding using the teaching triad – question marks indicate tentativity of interpretation. Micro-analysis using the teaching triad Management of Learning (ML) Statements that are judged managerial because they suggest particular approaches or ways of thinking include: • Go on, go for it [tutor invites S2 to the board . . . [3] • well exactly, we’re aiming for a k1 k2 , so why not instead swap them round [24] • So you’ve got that out, and that is absolutely fine, but, I’d have been happy with this . . . and that’s all I was expecting . . . so that would have done. So that was all really I wanted . . .; which is a good point to remember. [26] Others which are a part of a broader exposition could be construed as ML, but this is an interpretation related to characteristics of the tutor’s tone of voice and mode of delivery. These include
84
BARBARA JAWORSKI
Figure 2. Transcript for Episode 2.
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
Figure 2. Continued.
85
86
BARBARA JAWORSKI
Figure 2. Continued.
• So let’s try proving these two things. [1] • I said in lectures, although you may not remember, . . .[1] • you haven’t really written much up there yet that requires, uses, normality. The fact that er H is normal means that k2 l’ can be written in a different way [16] Some of the tutor statements that have been described as TE or TEx could be characterized as ML. For example: • One wants to show that for a congruence . . . – well its an equivalence relation, – that satisfies (he writes on the board) g1 ∼ k1 and g2 ∼ k2 → g1 g2 ∼ k1 k2 ; and g ∼ k → g−1 ∼ k−1 [1] • You’ve got two cosets – that coset’s the same as that, that coset’s the same as that; so g1 Hg2 H = k1 Hk2 H, and these cosets multiply to give that [g1 g2 H] and these cosets multiply to give that [k1 k2 H] [i.e. g1 g2 H = k1 k2 H] and that’s all I was expecting. [26] The argument here would be that the tutor needs to demonstrate what he means by particular advice that he is offering. These examples are not very different from the exposition patterns exemplified in Episode 1. When do we see exposition as contributing helpfully to managing students’ learning, and when is it rather a tutor’s own rehearsal of the topic? It is impossible to be categoric, and much depends on particular circumstances. However, exposition seems at best the weakest form of ML. Sensitivity to students: Affective (SSA) Affective sensitivity relates to the student’s confidence and well-being; the development of a ‘comfort zone’. It is encouraging, reassuring, supportive and comforting. Statements include the following:
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
87
• namely the converse, er, you forgot about (students laugh). [1] • S2 and tutor say this together [4] • So you’ve got that out, and that is absolutely fine [26] Tutor now quickly explains the proof as he would have proved it [27] We see here comments that generate rapport; tutor reinforcing what the student is saying by uttering the same statements; reassuring the student that what he has done is acceptable; and offering a demonstration of the alternative that the student might have provided. It needs to be recognized that affective sensitivity might be devoid of challenge or even suppress challenge. However, if challenge is offered without affective sensitivity the comfort zone of the student might be too fragile for the student to take up a challenge. An unstated characteristic of sensitivity which may be inferred here is that the tutor does not offer his own approach to the problem (tempting as this might have been during the student’s lengthy exposition) until after the student has expressed his own thinking. Sensitivity to students: Cognitive (SSC) Cognitively focused sensitivity is related to the subject of cognition for the student, in this case the mathematics of equivalence relations on group structures. The following are examples: • you might want the same h as [5] • well what’s a general element of the left hand side downstairs look like? [7] • well you know now that [14] • S2: so that g1 T; Yes S2: l” from this Together: is k1 h” [19] Each statement here relates to some aspect of the mathematical construction in which the student is engaged; some are suggestions, others questions, some involve speaking the mathematics with the student. Essentially they seem to support the students’ mathematical sense-making through focusing attention on certain aspects of the mathematics, or prompting particular mathematical directions. They demonstrate sensitivity here by responding to the student’s thinking at the particular stage of his reasoning, rather than directing the reasoning. There is some evidence of the student’s building on the tutor’s input in the case of normality at line 21. Again, it might be argued that the student’s approach is not the best way of thinking about the particular mathematics, and a challenge from the tutor might be more helpful in redirecting thinking or enabling another quality of thinking. Such possibilities have to be judged carefully by the tutor as interactions take place. One advantage of the kind of interaction encouraged in this episode is that it allows the tutor insights into particularities
88
BARBARA JAWORSKI
of students’ thinking, so that judgments, such as where to challenge or to hold back, can be made from a more overtly knowledgeable position. In this case, the tutor has decided to encourage the student to complete his argument, but then to offer an alternative when it seems the alternative might fit more readily with the student’s cognitive position. Mathematical challenge: (MC) We can argue that the situation itself here involves challenge: i.e., the invitation to the student to work at the board and present his argument. For some students this might be a challenge to which they cannot respond, so again, the tutor has to judge what makes sense for any student, a characteristic of sensitivity. Observations show, however, that encouraging students to offer their own arguments at the board is a regular part of the pedagogy of this tutor and an accepted part of his tutorials. Perhaps the main challenge of the episode comes at the beginning where the tutor requires the students to work on the extension to the problem they have tackled: • One wants to show that for a congruence . . . – well its an equivalence relation, – that satisfies (he writes on the board) g1 ∼ k1 and g2 ∼ k2 → g1 g2 ∼ k1 k2 ; and g ∼ k → g−1 ∼ k−1 [1] Other challenges are more localized and judged relative to the exposition of the student; for example: • Why do you think those cosets at the end are equal? [1] • well what’s a general element of the left hand side downstairs look like? [7] • you haven’t really written much up there yet that requires, uses, normality. [16] Some of these statements were offered as examples of cognitive sensitivity, which demonstrates the difficulty, sometimes, of separating these elements. This is a pointer towards a harmonious interaction in which challenge and sensitivity complement each other to support student conceptualization; e.g., as in the case of normality. If the tutor says “Why do you think those cosets at the end are equal?”, he refers to particular cosets that the student has mentioned, i.e., for which the student already has a mental image, so that the particular (challenging) question fits with the student’s current concept formation. This notion of ‘fit’ is an important part of constructivist theory of concept formation, and the resulting ‘intersubjectivity’ that seems essential if student and tutor are to understand each other at a level that encourages fruitful interaction (Glasersfeld, 1987; Jaworski, 1994; Steffe and Thompson, 2000).
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
89
Macro analysis As already indicated, the teaching strategy of inviting a student to work at the board was a familiar practice in the tutorials of this tutor. In one interview he acknowledged it might feel threatening to a student, but that students had come to realise that he would provide helpful support.
I do promise to help; or will help . . . they actually know I’ll start them off. They won’t just be stood at the board and me twiddling my thumbs. I might, after a few seconds, like 30 seconds, or something like that, or perhaps even less if they’re looking panicky, I would suggest, er, “Well, OK, write down, what’s the first line? What’s it mean to say that?”
So, the intervention of the tutor (lines 2–25) is a considered approach to encouraging students’ participation in the mathematics of the tutorial. It incorporates a teaching strategy that not only addresses the tutor’s mathematical issues, but does so in a way that the students are seen, overtly, to be involved in the thinking. So, in this episode, we see in a pedagogical overview, tutor perception of student difficulty, tutor inviting and providing opportunity for student involvement in thinking, and enculturation of the novice into mathematical practice managed by the tutor. Pedagogical particularities include tutor and students engaging in mathematics together; tutor questions, suggestions, direction at various points during student activity at the board; and tutor as expert, offering another viewpoint with a more efficient approach. While it was difficult to discuss harmony in relation to the earlier episode, here some justification for harmony has been offered. The student accepted the tutor’s challenge to work at the board. Moreover, he did so relatively successfully. He engaged with the mathematics in a non-trivial way, and can be seen to have gained cognitively from the interaction. Thus sensitivity and challenge seem to be in harmony suggesting an effective teaching situation. We need also to acknowledge that S2 is supposedly an ‘able’ student. The rapport between tutor and students has been built over successive tutorials as the tutor has used and developed the use of the board as an approach to tutorial interaction. While there is plenty of evidence of tutor explanation and expertise in leading the tutorial, the tutor does not seem to over-simplify the mathematics or their approaches to dealing with it. This might in itself be seen as challenge, or indeed as tutor sensitivity in a recognition that these students can handle this approach.
90 Episode 1
BARBARA JAWORSKI
Sensitivity
Challenge
Diagnosis of difficulty; choice of
The example chosen.
example; ‘scheme of help’, step by
Material for students to take away step approach ‘tailored individually’ and work on understanding. to students. 2
Perception of difficulty; providing
“Why” questions; requirement to
opportunity for involvement in
think; requirement to offer an
thinking; teacher input in interaction explanation/proof; tutor to reduce threat.
interjections during interaction.
Figure 3. Comparison of the two episodes.
T HE OUTCOMES OF ANALYSES Figure 3 shows a brief comparison of the two episodes relating characteristics of sensitivity and challenge discussed above. Although representative of patterns elicited from the data, as discussed, these episodes are nevertheless just two very brief, incomplete examples of teaching and learning. Analyses have highlighted characteristics that are valuable to recognize in initial investigations into what mathematics teaching at this level can or could involve. They do not start to offer insights into what teaching should involve, but they open up possibilities for exploring such pedagogic concerns. Mathematically speaking, the two episodes emphasized important aspects of mathematics that needed to be learned and understood. Both were in the area of abstract algebra, embodying notions of proof and proving, and differing degrees of symbolization. Tutors were aware of what students need to learn, and used a variety of approaches to fostering this learning. Both tutors judged the needs of students and tailored their teaching to address students’ difficulties. Across tutorials, the degree to which such pedagogic thinking was explicit or advanced varied from one tutorial to another. In terms of building pedagogic knowledge and understanding, this analysis has allowed us to • Recognize and acknowledge valuable elements of the teaching approach (including ML and SSA/C); • Recognize places/ways in which MC is present or lacking; • Seek potentially harmonious outcomes in terms of SS and MC and hence probe into the nature of effective teaching.
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
91
In the final section below, I go on to consider briefly how these factors can contribute to knowledge of teaching more broadly, and its development.
D EVELOPING KNOWLEDGE OF TEACHING Considering still the two episodes, and relating teaching approaches to students’ developing cognition in mathematics we see the following: • Proof was exemplified in each episode. In Episode 1, students were shown aspects of proof; in Episode 2 they engaged in aspects of proof; • Symbols and symbolic forms were used in both episodes. In 1, the tutor said and wrote the symbols; in 2 both tutor and students said and wrote symbols. • Sensitivity and challenge were found in both tutors’ thinking and planning. However, Episode 2 demonstrated more clearly the interplay of sensitivity and challenge in interaction. In abstract algebra there are known levels of difficulty relating to symbolisation, layers of abstraction, and approaches to proof. Certain abstract objects, such as cosets are known to cause conceptual difficulty (e.g., Nardi, 2001). Statements such as Let’s say we want g1 g2 ∼ k1 k2 and this means saying that g1 H = k1 H and g2 H = k2 H; then this means saying that g1 g2 H = k1 k2 H [Statement 1, Episode 2]
are extremely complex and the concepts hard for students to accommodate: for example, as in seeing g1 H as the result of combining one element g1 with all elements of one subgroup H and working with the resulting coset as an object in relation to other such objects – e.g. in multiplying cosets of a normal subgroup. While cognitive studies explore what it means for the learner to make relational sense of such complexity, pedagogic studies ask what approaches a teacher might design through which pedagogy can support cognition. The teaching triad addresses this last question. The notion of sensitivity acknowledges attention to students’ difficulties, ways of thinking, needs and abilities; to affective and emotional factors as well as cognitive factors. The notion of challenge addresses ways in which student are brought face to face with the mathematical ideas of which they have to make sense. In struggling at the board, in Episode 2, S2 has to deal publicly (i.e., in front of his tutor and another student) with the ideas and symbolism of subgroups and cosets, to tackle the concept of ‘normality’, to tackle approaches to proof. The tutor contributes according to his own judgments of sensitivity in supporting, nurturing, enabling and challenging the students’ mathematical construction. He follows the students’ approach, although
92
BARBARA JAWORSKI
he judges it to include elements that could reasonably have been assumed. Students need to learn what to assume and what they have to prove. What teaching approaches can engender such understanding? In this case the tutor, subsequently, offers his own shorter, more elegant proof which the students can then compare with what they have constructed. It would have been quicker for the tutor just to offer his own version than to encourage a student’s own articulation of it. Also, it is possible that the student may have felt that it was unreasonable to have struggled with his own version when the tutor knew a preferred version. However, it is part of the teacher’s judgment as to what would be most beneficial for a student’s learning more globally, as well as in the particular instant. In Episode 1 the tutor led students step by step through his own reasoned argument, his “scheme of help” for these particular students at this time. Factors in what made this an ‘appropriate’ scheme of help were not explored with the tutor in this particular case. Tutors’ remarks more generally have indicated that, sometimes, time is a crucial factor in what is possible, or students’ needs in preparing for examinations. Perhaps the tutor is limited in pedagogical conception. We see here a range of factors that affect teaching decisions. The triadic analysis exemplified in this paper has demonstrated a means of searching out the finer details of teaching decisions to document practices and processes and reveal issues in teaching: in other words to characterize teaching. By looking closely into what teachers do and think, and the way their thinking and decisions are related to their knowledge – of students, of mathematics and of pedagogy – we can start to develop understandings of the interpretation of such knowledge into practice in real situations. Such understandings then offer possibilities for teachers in reconsidering their approaches and for educators in designing programmes to enable teacher and teaching development. As the UMTP progressed there was evidence of tutors engaging more overtly with pedagogic issues, and reflecting on their teaching, both from interviews and from group meetings. This accords with findings in the use of the triad with secondary school teachers (Potari and Jaworski, 2002). Our work in this developmental sense is, as yet, in its infancy, but it seems reasonable to look forward to further uses of the triad that take characterization of university teaching into teaching development. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I appreciated the discerning comments of two anonymous reviewers of an earlier version of this paper, and should like to thank them for the help they provided in restructuring the paper. This research was supported by a grant
SENSITIVITY AND CHALLENGE IN MATHEMATICS TUTORIAL TEACHING
93
from the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), R0000222688, and conducted together with Elena Nardi and Stephen Hegedus. As author, I take responsibility for all views expressed.
R EFERENCES Bauersfeld, H.: 1988, ‘Interaction, construction and knowledge: Alternative perspectives for mathematics education,’ in Grouws, D.A. and Cooney, T.J. (eds.), Perspectives on Research on Effective Mathematics Teaching, National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, Reston, Va. Burn, R.P.: 1998, Participating in the Learning of Group Theory, Primus, Volume VIII number 4. Dubinsky, E., Dautermann, J., Leron, U. and Zazkis, R.: 1994, ‘On learning fundamental concepts of group theory,’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 27, 267–305. Dubinsky, E.: 2000, Towards a Theory of Learning Advanced Mathematical Concepts, Paper presented at ICME9, the 9th International Congress on Mathematical Education, Tokyo. Even, R. and Tirosh, D.: 1995, ‘Subject-matter knowledge and knowledge about students as sources of teacher presentations of the subject matter,’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 29(1), 1–20. Even, R. and Tirosh, D.: 2002, ‘Teacher knowledge and understanding of students’ mathematical learning,’ in English, L. (ed.), Handbook of International Research in Mathematics Education, Laurence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ, pp. 219–240. Glasersfeld, E. von: 1987, ‘Learning as a constructive activity,’ in Janvier, C. (ed.), Problems of Representation in the Teaching and Learning of Mathematics, Erlbaum, Hillslade, NJ. Jaworski, B.: 1994, Investigating Mathematics Teaching: A Constructivist Enquiry, Falmer, London. Jaworski, B.: 2001, ‘University mathematics teaching: Where is the challenge?,’ in Van den Heuvel-Panhuizen, (ed.), Proceedings of the 25t h Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, Vol. 3 pp. 193–200. Jaworski, B., Nardi, N. and Hegedus, S.: 1999, Characterizing Mathematics Teaching – A Collaboration between Educators and Mathematicians: A Methodological Perspective, Paper presented at the British Educational Research Association Conference, Brighton, September. Kieran, C., Forman, E. and Sfard, A.: 2001, ‘Bridging the individual and the social: Discursive approaches to research in mathematics education. A PME special issue,’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 46. Ledermann, W.: 1961, Introduction to the Theory of Finite Groups, Oliver and Boyd, London. Lerman, S.: 2001, ‘Cultural and discursive psychology: A sociocultural approach to studying the teaching and learning of mathematics,’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 46, 87–113. Moore, W.G.: 1968, The Tutorial System and its Future, Pergamon Press, Oxford. Nardi, E.: 1996, The Novice Mathematician’s Encounter with Mathematical Abstraction: Tensions in Concept-Image Construction and Formalization, University of Oxford: Doctoral thesis.
94
BARBARA JAWORSKI
Nardi, E.: 2001, ‘Mathematics undergraduates’ responses to semantic abbreviations, ‘geometric’ images and multi-level abstractions in group theory,’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 43, 169–189. Palfreyman, D.: 2001, ‘The Oxford tutorial: Sacred cow or pedagogical gem?,’ in D. Palfreyman (ed.) The Oxford Tutorial: ‘Thanks, you taught me how to think’, Oxford Centre for Higher Education Policy Studies, New College, Oxford. Pearson, T.A.: 1989, The Teacher: Theory and Practice in Teacher Education, Routledge, London. Pimm, D.: 1987, Speaking Mathematically, Routledge, London. Potari, D. and Jaworski, B.: 2002, ‘Tackling the complexity of mathematics teaching: Using the Teaching Triad as a Tool for Reflection and Analysis,’ Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education 5(4), 349–378. Sfard, A.: 1994, ‘Reification as the birth of metaphor,’ For the Learning of Mathematics 14(1), 44–55. Shulman, L.S.: 1987, ‘Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reform,’ Harvard Educational Review 57(1), 1–22. Sierpinska, A.: 1994, Understanding in Mathematics, Falmer Press, London. Simon, M.: 1995, ‘Reconstructing mathematics pedagogy from a constructivist perspective,’ Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 26(2), 114–145. Sinclair, McH. and Coulthard, R.M.: 1975, Towards an Analysis of Discourse: The English used by Teachers and Pupils, Oxford University Press, London. Skott, J.: 2001, ‘The emerging practice of a novice teacher: The roles of his school mathematics images, Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education 4(1): 3–28. Steffe, L.P. and Thompson, P.W.: 2000, ‘Interaction or intersubjectivity? A reply to Lerman,’ Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 31(2), 191–209. Steinbring, H.: 1998, ‘Elements of epistemological knowledge for mathematics teachers,’ Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education 1(2), 157–189. Tall, D.: 1991, Advanced Mathematical Thinking, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht / Boston / London, England. Tall, D.O. and Vinner, S.: 1981, ‘Concept images and definition in mathematics with special reference to limits and continuity’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 12, 151–169. Wenger, E.: 1998, Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning and Identity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Williams, S.R. and Baxter, J.: 1996, ‘Dilemmas of discourse-oriented teaching in one middle school mathematics classroom,’ The Elementary School Journal 97(1), 21–38. Zaslavsky, O. and Leikin, R.: 1999, ‘Interweaving the training of mathematics teachereducators and the professional development of mathematics teachers,’ in Zaslavsky, O. (ed.) Proceedings of the 23rd Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Agder University College, Institute for Mathematics, 4604 Kristiansand, Norway
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS ET AMELIORER SA PRATIQUE1
RÉSUMÉ. Une grande majorité des écoles primaires néerlandaises utilise le suivi des élèves développé par le Citogroep pour signaler le progrès des élèves entre 6 et 12 ans et gérer leurs apprentissages à partir de données empiriques. Ce suivi fonctionne dans ce sens comme un outil de pilotage de l’enseignement différentié et de l’amélioration des pratiques d’adaptation dans les classes et au niveau de l’école. Une telle évaluation formative et autorégulatrice centrée sur la gestion de longs processus exige un ensemble complexe de connaissances et d’aptitudes. Cela explique bon nombre de problèmes auxquels se heurtent les professeurs dans leur pratique, en particulier dans le cadre du soutien des élèves les plus en retard. Ces problèmes nous ont poussés à développer une panoplie d’outils adaptés à leurs besoins ainsi que des activités de formation ‘sur le tas’, ancrées dans l’évaluation formative pratiquée à l’école. Nous présentons dans cet article la structure, les principes et les outils de cette gestion de (l’amélioration de) l’enseignement différentié, exposons les problèmes structurels qui émergent dans la pratique et développons par-là les idées clés de notre approche expérimentale de formation. ABSTRACT. A large majority of primary schools in the Netherlands uses the followup of students’ progress developed by Citogroep to signal the progress of 6–12 years old students and monitor their learning based on empirical data. This follow-up thus works as a steering tool for promoting differential pedagogy and improvement of practices of adaptation in classes and at the school level. This kind of formative and self-regulating evaluation focused on the management of long term processes requires complex knowledge and skills, which explains the many problems facing teachers in their practice, particularly in supporting the least advanced students. These problems incited us to develop a broad range of tools, adapted to the needs of teachers, and activities to be used in their workplace, anchored in the formative evaluation practiced in their schools. In this article we present the structure, the principles and the tools of our management of the improvement of differential pedagogy, and by revealing the structural problems that emerge from practice we develop the key ideas of our experimental approach to teacher education.
1. I NTRODUCTION
L’évaluation dans le cadre de l’enseignement a toujours été une source de controverses en fonction de sa conception et de son usage. Il en est de même en ce début du 21ème siècle où deux conceptions et deux usages de l’évaluation semblent élargir le fossé qui existe par tradition entre les enseignants d’un côté et les parents, administrateurs et fonctionnaires pubEducational Studies in Mathematics 51: 95–116, 2002. © 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
96
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
lics de l’autre. Les responsabilités des enseignants les poussent à évaluer dans leur classe pour taxer la qualité des apprentissages et des acquis et comprendre les processus de différentiation et les problèmes qui émergent dans le groupe. C’est sur la base de ces données qu’ils corrigent et adaptent leurs instructions en fonction des connaissances et compétences développées par la pratique. Cette évaluation personnelle des professeurs dans leur classe met en jeu l’agencement et les modalités d’un enseignement différentié au niveau de l’école. Toute équipe scolaire doit en effet trouver un consensus sur un système de différentiation qui tient compte des différentes dimensions de l’enseignement: les objectifs et contenus, les trajectoires d’apprentissage, l’approche pédagogique, l’organisation, les critères de qualité etc. Cette équipe doit définir alors une ‘philosophie’ et une ‘politique’ de différentiation qui garantit une certaine cohérence dans les mesures individuelles d’adaptation dans les classes. Dans ce sens, l’évaluation formative dans les classes s’inscrit dans une pratique d’auto évaluation et de régulation de l’équipe scolaire au niveau de l’école. Parents, administrateurs et politiciens préconisent dans leur rôle de ‘clients’, ‘gestionnaires’ et ‘garants’ de l’enseignement une évaluation régulatrice externe qui garantit la qualité des apprentissages et des acquis, à partir de critères et de conditions de gestion clairement définis. Cette double finalité et ce double usage de l’évaluation sont actuellement au centre du débat dans bon nombre de pays et cause des tensions plus ou moins polysémiques entre les enseignants, les parents, les administrateurs et les autorités publiques (Gauthier, 2000; Michel, 2000). Cette tension est particulièrement sensible aux Pays Bas. Le gouvernement met en effet la dernière main à un long processus de décentralisation et instaure un système de régulation de l’enseignement primaire qui prescrit l’usage d’un suivi des élèves dès l’entrée des enfants à l’école primaire. Ce mode de régulation est typiquement néerlandais dans la mesure où il donne un maximum d’autonomie aux écoles en garantissant un minimum de cohérence au niveau national. C’est dans ce contexte de la politique éducative que le secteur primaire du Citogroep a développé un suivi des élèves (Janssen, 2002). Son utilisation dans 95% des écoles soulève un certain nombre de problèmes qui s’expliquent par la difficulté d’interprétation de données empiriques sur de longs processus d’apprentissage (Kraemer, 2001). Ces problèmes nous ont poussés à intégrer le suivi des élèves dans un ‘système de soin différentié’. Ce système comprend tous les instruments dont les enseignants ont besoin au cours du processus de soutien des élèves. Nous avons de plus entrepris le développement d’une approche de formation continue ‘sur le tas’ ancrée dans l’utilisation de notre suivi comme instrument de pilot-
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
97
age de l’amélioration de la pratique. Les cycles de formation alternent les sessions collectives de recherche, réflexion et discussion avec des leçons expérimentales individuelles dans les classes à partir des constructions qui émergent du travail collectif. Cette formation favorise ainsi le développement d’une ‘nouvelle culture d’évaluation’ mise en question par le comité international du programme de la CIEAEM54 (Giménez et al., 2002). Cet article justifie les activités expérimentales de formation développées par la section de mathématiques du secteur primaire du Citogroep. Nous introduisons d’abord notre suivi des élèves en esquissant le cadre politique de l’enseignement différentié et en distinguant trois niveaux complémentaires d’évaluation. A partir de ce cadre et des perspectives innovatrices néerlandaises, nous précisons les fonctions de ce suivi dans notre système de soin différentié, par rapport à celle des outils complémentaires de ce système. Ceci nous mène à expliciter les principes et idées directrices de notre approche de formation en partant des problèmes des utilisateurs de nos outils dans leur pratique d’adaptation. Le cycle d’activités présenté ensuite concrétise ces principes et idées et soulève trois thèmes de réflexion exposés en conclusion.
2. C ONTEXTE POLITIQUE NÉERLANDAIS
La loi de l’enseignement de base de 1985 a engagé les enseignants et les écoles primaires néerlandaises dans un processus de changement selon une logique de politique éducative déterminée par la constitution. Cette logique équilibre les responsabilités des enseignants et des services publics. Elle donne aux écoles une grande liberté d’adaptation des innovations aux conditions locales et garantit en même temps une certaine cohérence dans ces adaptations par un système de régulation typiquement néerlandais. C’est dans ce contexte et ces conditions de politique innovatrice que le Citogroep a développé de nouveaux instruments d’évaluation. Ces instruments permettent aux enseignants, aux équipes scolaires et aux services publics de piloter le changement à leur propre de niveau de responsabilité. Nous introduisons dans ce paragraphe le suivi des élèves comme outil de pilotage des adaptations dans les classes et au niveau de l’école par le biais du cadre constitutionnel et législatif et des trois types d’évaluation complémentaires pratiqués aux Pays-Bas.
98
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
2.1. Cadre constitutionnel et législatif du pilotage Le système éducatif néerlandais est très particulier par la façon dont il fait coexister enseignement public et enseignement privé en leur reconnaissant une valeur égale. La liberté d’inspiration et d’organisation de l’enseignement, inscrite dans la constitution, permet à d’innombrables groupes de parents de donner à leurs enfants une instruction en accord avec leurs idéaux et leurs convictions. Elle permet par contre-coup aux enseignants d’adapter les contenus et la structure de leur enseignement à la ‘philosophie’ de leur école. C’est la loi de 1985 sur l’enseignement de base qui, dans ce cadre constitutionnel, a introduit une forme de régulation du changement typiquement néerlandaise: le pilotage à la base. Cette loi prescrit le développement interrompu de chaque élève entre 4 et 12 ans et par-là un enseignement différentié, adapté aux besoins et potentiel de croissance de chaque élève. L’article 11 de cette loi introduit le plan scolaire intégral comme l’outil de régulation de l’innovation. Chaque école doit y mentionner, entre autres, ce que l’équipe scolaire veut enseigner, les mesures d’organisation, les mesures destinées aux élèves qui rencontrent des difficultés, le contrôle de l’effectivité de ces mesures ainsi que l’évaluation du progrès des élèves. Interprété dans le cadre de réflexion de Michel (2000, pp. 22–24), l’article 11 ‘pilote’ l’innovation de l’enseignement par la base et ne ‘réforme’ pas le système éducatif par le sommet. La loi stimule une réflexion systémique des professeurs et de l’équipe scolaire sur les contenus et la structure de leur enseignement en leur donnant une grande liberté d’adaptation des innovations aux conditions locales. D’autre part, le législateur prend à sa charge la régulation de ce processus par le biais de l’inspection qui veille à un minimum de cohérence et garantit ainsi la réalisation des objectifs nationaux.
2.2. Trois formes d’évaluation à trois niveaux de pilotage Dès l’application de la nouvelle loi, la section primaire du Citogroep a entrepris le développement de nouvelles formes et instruments d’évaluation qui répondent aux besoins des enseignants et des fonctionnaires de l’éducation. Nous distinguons trois dynamiques de changement à trois niveaux de l’enseignement et donc trois formes d’évaluation et types d’instruments unis par la même logique politique et innovatrice (van der Schoot et van Dam, 2000): – L’évaluation dans la classe des processus d’apprentissage et des acquis des élèves (micro-niveau: suivi des élèves – de 6 à 12 ans –, entretiens diagnostiques, épreuves d’entrée et épreuves d’orientation);
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
99
Figure 1. Cycle d’activit´es de soin.
– L’évaluation de la qualité et du rendement de l’enseignement au niveau de l’école et de la communauté scolaire locale (meso-niveau: suivi des élèves et auto-évaluation interne); – L’évaluation du niveau et des résultats de l’enseignement aux PaysBas (macro-niveau: sondages périodiques à mi-chemin et à la fin du primaire). Comme nos activités de formation partent des deux premiers types d’évaluation, nous présentons ci-dessous l’instrument de pilotage utilisé par les professeurs et les équipes locales: le suivi des élèves du Citogroep. 2.3. Suivi des élèves comme instrument de pilotage de l’enseignement différentié Les écoles sont libres d’utiliser les instruments d’évaluation de leur choix. La grande majorité des écoles utilise aujourd’hui notre suivi Calcul-mathématique pour rendre compte de la progression de leurs élèves, organiser la différentiation des apprentissages à partir des résultats et évaluer transversalement et/ou longitudinalement la qualité de l’enseignement au niveau de l’école dans les perspectives du plan d’activités. Dans ce cas, l’évaluation prend la forme d’une auto-évaluation. Elle donne les repères indispensables pour analyser les problèmes, définir les priorités et expliciter les mesures d’amélioration à entreprendre dans un nouveau cycle de changement.
100
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
Figure 2. Outils des enseignants.
3. F ONCTION DU SUIVI DANS LE CADRE D ’ UN SYSTÈME DE SOIN DIFFÉRENTIÉ
C’est à la demande explicite des professeurs que nous avons intégré notre suivi des élèves dans un système de soin différentié. Les résultats des épreuves du suivi leur permettent d’estimer deux fois par an (avec une marge minimale d’erreur) le niveau de compétence et les acquis de leurs élèves. Comme ils appliquent la même échelle de mesure d’un degré à un autre (voyez la figure 6), ils peuvent aussi comparer ce niveau d’année en année et déterminer ainsi le progrès accompli par les élèves au cours de leur scolarité primaire. Cette caractéristique essentielle du suivi a provoqué chez les professeurs le besoin de développer des points de repère afin d’interpréter correctement les données empiriques de leur évaluation et de mieux gérer les différences mises à jour par les épreuves. Ces épreuves forment en fait le point de départ et le point d’arrivée d’un cycle d’activités (Figure 1) que nous avons formalisé dans ce que nous appelons un système de soin. Dans cette section nous présentons les caractéristiques essentielles de ce système ainsi que les outils développés pour la pratique. Le schéma de la Figure 1 visualise les phases du cycle d’activités, celui de la Figure 2 – les instruments utilisés par les professeurs au cours de leurs activités.
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
101
3.1. Signaler et identifier Les élèves font chaque année deux épreuves: une en janvier-février, l’autre en mai-juin. Un système de registration permet de déterminer le niveau de progression de chaque enfant et d’identifier les élèves qui ont besoin d’une attention plus particulière à cause de leur ‘retard’ ou de leur ‘avance’ par rapport au reste du groupe. Ce signalement et cette identification sont ancrés dans la normalisation de l’échelle de mesure, réalisée à partir des résultats d’un échantillon national d’élèves suivis au cours de leur scolarité primaire (Eggen et Sanders, 1993).
3.2. Analyser et détecter les mesures d’adaptation Cette phase essentielle du cycle d’adaptation pose le plus de problèmes dans la pratique. Un grand nombre de professeurs manque en effet de points de repères qui sont nécessaires pour interpréter les informations que donnent les épreuves sur la nature et le niveau des acquis des élèves, les relations complexes entre ces acquis et leur influence sur le cours et la qualité des apprentissages à long terme. Un de ces processus est le développement de stratégies et procédures de calcul mental et d’estimation tout au long de la scolarité primaire. Nous essayons de pallier ces besoins en éditant les résultats de nos propres analyses sous la forme de profils de compétences (Janssen, 2002), de guides de progression (Janssen & Kraemer, 1995, 1997) et de descriptions détaillées des phases de la progression dans nos Livres de soin (Kraemer, 2002; sous presse). Ces livres proposent, en plus, des leçons diagnostiques qui permettent aux professeurs de se familiariser avec la façon de penser et d’opérer des élèves faibles et avec la didactique de soutien que nous suggérons.
3.3. Soutien adapté et évaluation de ses effets Chaque manuel de calcul-mathématique utilisé dans la pratique des écoles a son propre système de soutien différentié. Ce système permet d’adapter les apprentissages de la grande majorité des élèves, mais les mesures suggérées sont moins appropriées pour soutenir et stimuler les élèves les plus faibles. Ce constat nous a poussé à développer des activités de soutien ancrées dans notre analyse didactique de leur progression, mesurée par les épreuves du suivi. Ces activités sont organisées dans un programme longitudinal de soutien centré sur l’acquisition d’un number sense (McIntosh, Reys & Reys, 1992) à la mesure de ces enfants (voir les livres de soin: Kraemer, 2002, sous presse).
102
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
3.4. Fonction du suivi Le modèle cyclique de l’enseignement de Simon (1995) nous a guidés dans la conception et l’élaboration de ce système de soin. Si nos enseignants ont tant de mal à interpréter les données des épreuves du suivi et à envisager des mesures d’adaptation à partir de ces données, c’est parce que ce suivi est conçu pour gérer les apprentissages à long terme et à plusieurs niveaux et rythmes de développement. Il exige donc un cadre de référence beaucoup plus affiné et complexe que les repères utilisés pour planifier un cycle de quelques leçons, gérer les interactions et le travail individuel au cours de ce cycle et ajuster les objectifs, instructions et activités après chaque leçon. Dans ce contexte, notre suivi a trois fonctions principales. Il signale les différences au cours de la progression des élèves et permet ainsi aux enseignants de se faire une idée plus précise du cours des apprentissages dans le temps, des phases cruciales de ces apprentissages et des problèmes auxquels se heurtent certains (groupes d’) enfants au cours de la progression suggérée par les manuels utilisés. Ces informations permettent aux enseignants de remettre en question l’idée qu’ils ont des apprentissages en mathématiques et des contenus de ces apprentissages. C’est la deuxième fonction de notre suivi qui, en liaison avec la première, donne enfin la possibilité d’envisager de nouvelles formes et activités de travail à partir de nouvelles références plus adaptées aux exigences de l’enseignement différentié. Notre suivi signale en conclusion les différences, stimule la construction d’un nouveau système de références et libère ainsi les enseignants des opinions et des routines qui bloquent la conception d’alternatives à leur propre niveau de professionnalisation.
4. I DÉES DIRECTRICES DE NOTRE APPROCHE DE FORMATION
Notre approche de formation part des fonctions de l’utilisation du suivi exposées ci-dessus. Elle repose sur quatre principes que nous explicitons brièvement dans cette section à partir du cycle de formation de la Figure 3 que nous illustrerons par la suite. L’idée de départ consiste à organiser des cycles de formation qui intègrent les aspects essentiels de l’amélioration de la pratique à partir de l’évaluation des apprentissages et des questions qu’elle soulève. Nous exposons ci-dessous quatre activités clés d’un tel cycle de formation.
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
103
Figure 3. Activit´es cl´es d’un cycle de formation.
4.1. Construire de nouveaux repères Il est impossible de gérer les différences sans données empiriques qui montrent ce qui fait la différence entre les enfants au cours de leur développement et ce qui stimule et entretient la tendance de leur croissance. C’est pourquoi chaque cycle de formation est ancré dans l’analyse de données collectionnées par les enseignants. Il s’agit d’observations personnelles, de protocoles d’entretiens diagnostiques avec plus ou moins d’élèves, de solutions de problèmes posés à des élèves à deux ou trois degrés de l’école, et bien sûr des données du suivi. Un objectif essentiel de ces activités est de comprendre les principes d’une analyse centrée sur les apprentissages à long terme et sur une différentiation structurelle de ces apprentissages. Un autre objectif est de développer une forme d’évaluation au jour le jour et par cycle de leçons qui affine l’évaluation à long terme avec le suivi des élèves. 4.2. Apprendre à regarder, penser et opérer comme le font les enfants Ce qui bloque l’interprétation des données et ainsi aussi la conception de mesures adaptatives est la difficulté pour beaucoup d’enseignants de se mettre ‘dans la peau des enfants’. C’est-à-dire de regarder, de penser et d’opérer comme eux dans les situations journalières de calcul-mathématiques en appliquant leurs notions, représentations et outils de travail. ‘Je ne peux pas regarder dans la tête des enfants’ est la remarque typique
104
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
Figure 4. Quatre indicateurs du niveau de compr´ehension et de solution des e´ l`eves.
des professeurs dans ce contexte. Nous pouvons briser cette barrière en observant les solutions des élèves sous le microscope pour découvrir les différences caractéristiques qui expliquent bon nombre de problèmes de communication au cours des interactions quotidiennes (voir van Hiele, 1973). Cette exploration mène à la reconstruction de quatre indicateurs du niveau de compréhension et de résolution des élèves (Figure 4): la représentation que se fait l’élève du problème posé, le raisonnement qu’il suit et qui guide sa stratégie et ses procédures de solution et le langage qu’il utilise pour présenter, expliquer et défendre son approche et sa solution. Ce type d’activités enthousiasme les professeurs car ils apprennent petit à petit à reconnaître des constellations typiques et à les associer au niveau de compréhension et de solution de leurs propres élèves. Mais surtout – parce que nous reconstruisons ensemble et à partir des données de chacun le ‘paysage mathématique’ que construisent les (groupes d’) élèves d’un même degré, les frontières de ces paysages et les défis à leur horizon (comparer avec Fosnot et Dolk, 2001a; 2001b). Nous remplaçons ainsi, de session en session, les anciennes références par des alternatives et des options testées individuellement dans la pratique et reconsidérées et organisées ensuite par une réflexion collective sur les expériences de classe. 4.3. Chercher la source des problèmes en soi et dans la culture de l’école De telles activités invitent les professeurs à porter leur regard sur leur propre comportement. Elles ouvrent ainsi la porte d’une exploration cri-
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
105
tique de ce qui, en eux, influence ces comportements. Nous pensons aux représentations, suppositions, croyances, opinions et ‘histoires’, construites dans le passé à partir de faits réels et qui figurent depuis comme des vérités. Inspirés par l’approche systémique de Senge (2000), nous utilisons ce qui irrite et frustre les enseignants au cours de leurs activités expérimentales pour mettre à jour ces filtres qu’ils ne contrôlent pratiquement plus et qui modèlent leurs perceptions et leurs interprétations des ‘faits divers’ de leur vie scolaire. Ce type d’activités est d’autant plus délicat qu’il engage les professeurs à mettre en question une grande partie des opinions qui ‘justifient’ leurs routines et à construire eux-mêmes des alternatives fondées sur de nouvelles références et expériences. Orienter ainsi la discussion et la réflexion sur les opinions et routines personnelles met bien sûr la culture et les traditions de l’équipe scolaire et de l’école en question. Les données de l’auto-évaluation peuvent alors orienter les objectifs et les contenus de nouvelles activités de formation plus centrées sur le travail au sein de l’équipe scolaire. 4.4. Amélioration de la pratique par une coopération entre chercheurs, formateurs et enseignants Apprendre à adapter les apprentissages aux acquis des élèves pour favoriser un développement ininterrompu est une entreprise difficile et de longue haleine. Elle implique un tel investissement pour les écoles et exige des compétences si variées qu’il nous semble indispensable de créer un cadre de travail délimité dans l’espace et dans le temps. C’est pourquoi nous préconisons la formation de ‘cercles de qualité’ (Kraemer, 1998). Nous pensons à des réseaux locaux d’enseignants et de membres des services et instituts d’encadrement (chercheurs, professeurs de formation et conseillers pédagogiques) dans lesquels les participants travaillent à leur propre rythme et niveau de compétences. Ils sont tous engagés dans un même processus d’amélioration locale de la pratique qui intègre la recherche d’adaptations concrètes à la formation professionnelle de chaque participant. La pratique de tous les jours est l’objet de recherche et de formation et forme en même temps le cadre naturel d’expérimentation (comparez avec Simon, 1995; Hiebert et Stigler, 1999). Nous avons exploré les quatre principes de formation cyclique sur le tas à petite échelle, dans notre école expérimentale de La Haye et au cours d’un cycle expérimental de formation à Sittard, dans la région du Limbourg. L’évaluation actuelle de ces expériences oriente le développement d’un premier cycle de formation qui sera proposé au cours de 2003. Dans la section suivante, une description de quatre activités expérimentales va concrétiser les principes exposés ci-dessus.
106
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
Figure 5a. Cinq des 18 questions de l’entretien diagnostique du degr´e 2.
5. C YCLE D ’ ACTIVITES DE FORMATION : UN EXEMPLE
Le cycle de formation présenté ci-dessous illustre les principes de notre approche de formation. Nous explicitons dans chaque phase du cycle les objectifs, les activités et les constructions des professeurs qui introduisent de nouvelles questions et les engagent dans un nouveau défi. 5.1. Construire des points de repère qui ont du sens Une manière défiante et efficace d’engager les enseignants consiste à les inviter à s’entretenir avec quelques élèves de leur classe sur quelques questions des épreuves du suivi (Figure 5a). Dans cet exemple l’analyse du protocole de l’entretien avec Patrick et Liane (Figure 5b) permet en premier lieu aux participants d’explorer les différences en reconstruisant les indicateurs de niveau présentés plus haut dans la Figure 4 (représentation mentale de la situation, raisonnement suivi, langage utilisé, stratégie et procédures suivies). De ce travail émergent des opinions et suppositions sur les acquis, les fausses conceptions, les lacunes et les perspectives de progrès chez Patrick et Liane. Les participants apprennent à les expliquer et à les justifier en associant les unes aux autres les informations cachées dans les solutions
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
107
Figure 5b. Extraits du protocole d’un entretien diagnostique au degr´e 4 en janvier/f´evrier.
de Patrick et de Liane. Les discussions dévoilent une certaine cohérence dans leur attitude et leur comportement. Elles permettent aux participants de prendre conscience de la qualité et des limites de leur propre compréhension des mathématiques et du progrès des apprentissages dans ce domaine des nombres et du calcul mental jusqu’à cent. Les différences d’interprétation et d’opinion soulèvent des doutes qui nous permettent d’introduire le profil de compétence de la Figure 6 comme moyen de contrôle de sa propre taxation du niveau de Patrick et de Liane à partir des données empiriques du suivi. 5.2. Explication du graphique L’axe vertical symbolise l’échelle normalisée, les segments verticaux plus ou moins longs les questions de l’entretien. Les numéros gras sont les questions du protocole utilisées ici. La projection de l’origine de chaque
108
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
Figure 6. Profil de comp´etences a` partir des donn´ees empiriques du suivi des e´ l`eves.
segment sur l’échelle donne le niveau de compétence nécessaire pour résoudre 5 questions sur 10 de ce type correctement (paramètre de difficulté). La projection de l’extrémité des segments donne à son tour la compétence exigée pour résoudre correctement 8 questions sur 10 de ce type (paramètre de maîtrise). En traçant les lignes horizontales à partir du niveau actuel de progression de Patrick (52), de Liane (73) et de celui de l’élève moyen (61) les participants distinguent les questions et contenus que maîtrisent ces élèves (tous les segments en dessous de leur niveau), ce qu’ils construisent en ‘ce moment’ (les segments coupés par la ligne horizontale) et ce qui dans cette phase n’a pas encore de sens pour eux (tous les segments au-dessus de leur niveau). Ils peuvent alors contrôler les relations qu’ils ont établies entre les questions et leurs contenus ainsi que leurs suppositions sur les acquis et les lacunes. De tels profils ancrent dans ce sens les repères qualitatifs des participants dans les repères empiriques du suivi. La conclusion de cette première phase est que Patrick fait, comme chacun le pensait, partie du groupe des élèves les plus faibles du degré 2 et que Liane, elle, fait partie des meilleurs élèves de ce degré. Elle maîtrise tous les types de questions, à l’exception des deux derniers (les soustractions du type de la question 18). La question qui émerge de ces premières activités est bien sûr celle du soutien de Patrick et des élèves qui opèrent à son niveau à partir de ce qu’ils comprennent et appliquent correctement ‘en ce moment’ et dans les perspectives du programme scolaire de leur degré.
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
109
Figure 7. Profil hypoth´etique de Patrick.
5.3. Mieux comprendre la force mathématique et les limites des élèves ‘faibles’ en reconstruisant leur tendance de développement En analysant les protocoles, les participants ont exploré les concepts, idées, représentations, raisonnements, stratégies, procédures de Liane et de Patrick. Ils ont délimité avec eux grossièrement le champ de différentiation au degré 2. Il s’agit maintenant de mieux comprendre les possibilités et les limites des élèves comme Patrick en reconstruisant la tendance de développement à leur âge à partir des données d’entretien avec d’autres élèves qui opèrent à des niveaux intermédiaires (entre celui de Patrick et celui de Liane). Les participants établissent dans ce but des profils hypothétiques de compétences, tels que celui de la Figure 7. Ils lient les données de ces profils les unes aux autres et explorent ainsi les changements plus ou moins subtils au niveau de la conception des nombres, de l’organisation de ces nombres et des opérations avec ces nombres. En travaillant ainsi, les participants reconstruisent ‘pierre par pierre’ le paysage mathématique qu’inventent et organisent les élèves, réinventent et affinent les outils mathématiques qu’ils fabriquent et explorent leur utilisation dans les situations courantes des leçons. Une telle reconstruction de la tendance de développement provoque en général de nombreuses remarques sur les différences entre les élèves telles que les professeurs les vivent dans leur classe. Les anecdotes qu’ils racontent à propos des problèmes que soulèvent ces différences portent alors l’attention sur les routines qu’ils ont développées pour tenter de les résoudre. Elles ouvrent ainsi la porte de l’introspection de la phase suivante.
110
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
5.4. Identifier en soi la source de problèmes persistants C’est l’ambiance ‘ouverte’ de travail qui invite les participants à prendre le risque d’observer ‘en eux’ ce qui pourrait expliquer les problèmes qui ‘reviennent’ constamment et qui les mènent toujours dans les mêmes impasses. Nous avons ‘provoqué’ l’exemple d’introspection de la Figure 8 à partir d’une leçon expérimentale donnée par chaque participant dans sa propre classe. L’objectif était triple: a) inventorier les stratégies et procédures de multiplication plus ou moins formelles utilisées par les élèves dans leur résolution du problème posé; b) organiser ces stratégies et procédures dans une séquence de progression à partir de l’expérience de la session précédente; c) décrire un problème typique et persistant lié à la gestion des interactions au cours de telles leçons et découvrir ce qui ‘en soi-même’ pourrait expliquer la persistance de ce problème. Yvonne est une enseignante très consciencieuse qui s’est engagée totalement au cours de ce cycle. Son entretien ‘avec elle-même’ a beaucoup frappé ses collègues, car ils ont reconnu dans son comportement et sa réflexion leurs propres habitudes, rationalisations et frustrations. Ce que nous avons retenu de cette réflexion est la difficulté de prendre le temps qu’il faut pour comprendre ce qu’expose un enfant et de contrôler cette compréhension. Mais aussi le besoin d’apprendre à apprécier la valeur de chaque construction en en comprenant sens dans le processus long de développement en question. Dans ce sens, de telles introspections stimulent la curiosité des professeurs et les engagent à développer les références, les connaissances, les compétences et les formes de travail dont ils ont besoin pour exploiter au maximum les constructions de chaque élève. Les activités de la dernière phase du cycle donné en exemple sont centrées sur cet objectif. 5.5. Apprendre à adapter en jetant un pont entre Patrick et Liane Dans cette dernière session du cycle nous faisons un lien entre les remarques de la session précédente et un fragment du protocole de l’entretien avec Patrick réservé dans ce but. Patrick est en effet un de ces élèves dont parle Yvonne et qui provoquent (toujours) les mêmes réactions du professeur et du reste de la classe. Ses explications prennent en général beaucoup de temps puisqu’il utilise surtout des procédures de comptage difficiles à comprendre par son utilisation très personnelle des doigts comme modèle de calcul. Le dernier travail collectif de la Figure 9 consiste à jeter un pont entre l’approche ‘bizarre’ de Patrick et la stratégie de calcul mental de Liane qu’attendent les professeurs à ce degré: soustraire en complétant. Les questions posées permettent aux participants de réfléchir sur les principes didactiques qu’ils appliquent journalièrement, la trajectoire
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
111
Figure 8. Introspection d’Yvonne avec elle-même.
Figure 9. Qu’est-ce qui lie Patrick a` Liane?
d’apprentissage qu’ils suivent avec leurs manuels et les matériaux qu’ils utilisent pour orienter les élèves et soutenir le processus de développement et de formalisation graduelle des procédures de calcul mental. Les participants reconstruisent en fait le chemin qui mène à l’idée d’utiliser une ligne ‘vide’ pour modéliser différentes stratégies et procédures de soustraction à partir du sens que l’on peut donner à ces soustractions (Figure 10). C’est ainsi qu’ils apprennent à apprécier les ‘inventions’ les
112
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
Figure 10. Modelage de deux strat´egies et proc´edures de solution a` partir de deux interpr´etations du probl`eme des maisons.
plus rudimentaires et à les exploiter dans la ligne de pensée des enfants et des auteurs de leurs manuels. Les adaptations qui émergent de telles activités sont ‘testées’ dans la pratique. En rapportant leurs expériences au début d’un nouveau cycle d’activités, les participants peuvent reconsidérer les hypothèses et opinions de départ et s’engager dans de nouvelles explorations pour affiner les repères, les connaissances et les principes développés jusque là. C’est par de tels cycles d’activités que les participants développent petit à petit un nouveau cadre de référence et une panoplie plus ou moins large d’outils qui donnent confiance et leur font accepter les risques de défier chaque élève à son niveau.
6. R ÉFLEXION FINALE
L’exemple d’activités illustre les deux principes clés de notre approche de formation: – utiliser un suivi des élèves pour ancrer les observations diagnostiques des participants dans des données empiriques et pour orienter et régulariser l’adaptation des objectifs et des contenus intermédiaires de la progression; – centrer les activités de formation sur a) une meilleure compréhension et appréciation des constructions et du progrès des élèves, b) explorer les facteurs en soi qui entretiennent les routines et bloquent ainsi le changement et c) développer et intégrer progressivement de nouvelles
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
113
attitudes, opinions et modes de travail de plus en plus adaptés aux besoins et au potentiel de croissance des enfants. C’est dans ce sens que nous considérons le suivi des élèves comme un instrument indispensable de pilotage de l’innovation et de l’amélioraton de la pratique. Nos experiences de formation soulèvent trois points de réflexion à ce propos. 6.1. Intégrer les formes d’évaluation de la pratique à partir d’une réflexion systémique sur la gestion des apprentissages L’impression que donne notre suivi dès son application dans les écoles est que c’est un instrument fiable, facile à intégrer dans l’organisation de la classe (des écoles) et qui confirme les évaluations des professeurs au jour le jour. Cette impression explique l’enthousiasme des professeurs tant qu’ils utilisent ce suivi ‘á côté’ de l’évaluation, telle qu’ils la pratiquent par tradition (observations, entretiens et corrections journalières, épreuves périodiques des livres utilisés, etc.). Le suivi fonctionne en effet dans cette phase comme un ‘révélateur externe’ des différences que les professeurs ‘connaissent’ déjà par leur ‘évaluation interne’. Les données des épreuves n’influencent pas les décisions d’adaption, mais justifient plutôt les mesures prises à partir de l’évaluation de tous les jours. Dans ce sens, le problème clé de l’utilisation d’un suivi comme instrument de pilotage est l’intégration de toutes les formes d’évaluation en tenant compte des rôles et des besoins des professeurs dans les différents contextes de la gestion des apprentissages ainsi que de la complémentarité des formes et outils d’évaluation. Quelles données allons-nous utiliser pour nos rapports mensuels ou trimestriel aux parents et pour adapter notre programme? Celles des épreuves périodiques du livre ou celles du suivi? Cette question pratique des professeurs de notre école expérimentale nous a signalé ce besoin d’intégration. Elle en soulèvent mille autres que l’équipe scolaire ne peut traiter avec bon sens que par une réflexion systémique sur les aspects clés de l’enseignement différentié, à partir des problèmes auxquels se heurtent les professeurs dans leur pratique et de leurs besoins les plus urgents. Un suivi des élèves est, certes, un instrument indispensable pour gérer les apprentissages à longs termes. Mais les professeurs ne transforment pas automatiquement leur pratique d’évaluation et de gestion des apprentissages par son utilisation. Créer un espace et un temps de formation est selon nous la condition sine qua non pour réaliser cet objectif en engageant les professeurs dans une formation continue centrée sur le développement personnel de chaque participant.
114
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
6.2. Mieux comprendre les exigences d’un enseignement qui défie en réfléchissant sur ses propres apprentissages C’est à partir de ce constat que nous engageons les professeurs dans un processus de réflexion sur et de recherche dans leur pratique et d’investir par-là dans leur propre formation. L’idée centrale est d’apprendre à problématiser la question complexe de l’adaption des objectifs et contenus du programme et de développer soi-même, en dialogue avec ses collègues, un cadre de référence, une façon de penser et des méthodes et outils de travail applicables dans les situations les plus courantes de la pratique. Par notre approche active et systémique de formation (Senge et al., 2000) nous défions dans ce sens les professeurs à rationaliser leur pratique comme ils sont sensés de défier leurs élèves à mathématiser le monde dans lequel ils vivent (Freudenthal, 1968). La formation reflète autrement dit les exigences d’apprentissages défiants et qui stimulent les acteurs à prendre leur propre part de responsabilité. Elle permet ainsi aux professeurs de mieux comprendre leurs responsabilités essentielles envers leurs élèves. 6.3. Pas de standards sans données empiriques La politique actuelle de décentralisation de l’enseignement et de régulation des innovations incite de plus en plus de pays à formuler des standards que devraient réaliser le plus grand nombre d’élèves dans le plus grand nombre d’écoles. Notre comparaison des résultats scolaires (dans le cadre des sondages périodiques du niveau de l’enseignement) avec les standards néerlandais formulés par les enseignants, professeurs de formation et consultants scolaires signalent que ceux-ci sousestiment systématiquement le niveau de difficulté des objectifs que 70 à 75%% des élèves devrait réaliser selon eux à la fin du primaire. Ils estiment par contre plus ou moins correctement les standards qu’ils formulent pour la minorité d’élèves très en retard et très en avance. Cette constatation jette des doutes sur le sens de formuler des standards à partir des opinions des responsables de l’enseignement et des experts des services d’encadrement (ou sur la base d’une consultation plus large) sans références empiriques sur la progression réelle des enfants au cours de leur scolarité obligatoire. Ceci nous pousse à préconiser une discussion sur les orientations d’un enseignement adapté aux exigences de la vie actuelle à partir d’une vue d’ensemble sur ce qu’apprennent et appliquent les élèves actuellement entre 4 et 16 ans à différents niveaux de compréhension et d’aptitudes. Nous manquons de tels repères pour justifier pleinement la différentiation des objectifs et contenus au cours du cycle primaire et pour orienter les élèves dans la voie qui correspond le mieux à leurs affinités et leurs talents.
EVALUER POUR MIEUX COMPRENDRE LES ENFANTS
115
N OTES 1. Cet article est une adaptation de la conférence plénière de l’auteur à la 54ème Rencontre de la Commission Internationale pour l’Etude et l’Amélioration de l’Enseignement Mathématique à Vilanova i la Geltrú (Catalogne, Espagne), 13–19 juillet 2002.
R EFERENCES Eggen, T.J.H.M. et Sanders, P.F. (eds.): 1993, Psychometrie in de Praktijk (Psychométrie dans la Pratique), Cito Instituut voor Toetsontwikkeling, Arnhem. Fosnot, C.T. et Dolk, M.: 2001a, Young Mathematicians at Work. Constructing Number Sense, Addition, and Subtraction, Heinemann, Portsmouth, NH. Fosnot, C.T. et Dolk, M.: 2001b, Young Mathematicians at Work. Constructing Multiplication, and Division, Heinemann, Portsmouth, NH. Freudenthal, H.: 1968, ‘Why to teach mathematics so as to be useful? Educational Studies in Mathematics 1(1), 3–8. Gauthier, P.-L.: 2002, ‘Du bon usage de l’évaluation’, dans Revue Internationale d’Éducation. L’évaluation des systèmes éducatifs, N◦ 26, juin. Sèvre: Centre international d’études pédagogiques, pp. 15–18. Giménez, J., Keitel, C., Hahn, C., Luelmo, J., Paola, D., Santos, L. (Comité du programme de la CIEAEM54): 2002, Documento de debate: Un reto para la educación matématica: reconciliar lo común con la diversidad. http://www.upc.es/info/cieaem54/cieaem-cas/2anunci.htm Janssen, J.: 2002, Leerlingvolgsysteem 2002 (Suivi des élèves 2002), Citogroep, Arnhem. Janssen, J., Schoot, F. van der, Hemker, B. et Verlhelst, N.: 1999, Balans van het RekenWiskundeonderwijs Einde Basisschool 3. Uitkomsten van de Derde Peiling in 1997 (Balance de l’Enseignement des Mathématiques à la Fin de l’école Primaire. Résultats du 3ème sondage de 1997), Citogroep, Arnhem. Janssen, J. et Kraemer, J.M.: 1995 et 1997, Leerlingvolgsysteem. Rekengids 1 & 2. (Suivi des élèves. Guide de mathématiques), Citogroep, Arnhem. Hiebert et Stigler: 1999, The Teaching Gap, Free press, New York. Hiele, P.M. van: 1974, Begrip en Inzicht, Muusses, Purmerend. Kraemer, J.M.: 1998, Kwaliteitscirkels in Haaglanden. Interne Nota. (Cercles de qualité autour de La Haye. Notice interne), Citogroep, Arnhem. Kraemer, J.M.: 2001, ‘Desafíos de la enseñanza de las matemáticas en la escuela primaria holandesa’, dans G. Giménez (coord.), P. Abrantes, et L. Bazzini, Comisión CIEAEM, Grup 100, C. Keitel, J.M. Kraemer et S. Romero, Matemáticas en Europa: Diversas perspectivas, Graó., pp. 51–71. Kraemer, J.M.: 2002, Leerlingvolgsysteem. Hulpboeken voor Groep 3 tot en met 5. (Suivi des élèves. Livres de soin pour les Degrés 1, 2 et 3), Citogroep, Arnhem. Kraemer, J.M. (sous presse), Leerlingvolgsysteem. Hulpboeken voor Groep 3 tot en met 5. (Suivi des élèves. Livres de soin pour le Degrés 4), Citogroep, Arnhem. McIntosh, A., Reys, B.J. et Reys, R.E.: 1992, ‘A proposed framework for examining basic number sense’, For the Learning of Mathematics 12(3), 2–8. Michel, A.: 2000, ‘Évaluer pour piloter’, dans Revue Internationale d’Éducation. L’évaluation des Systémes éducatifs, N◦ 26, juin. Sèvre: Centre international d’études pédagogiques, pp. 19–29.
116
JEAN-MARIE KRAEMER
Schoot, F. van der et Dam, P. van: 2000, Professionnalisation de l’évaluation aux PaysBas. Revue Internationale d’Éducation. L’évaluation des systémes éducatifs, N◦ 26, juin. Sèvre: Centre international d’études pédagogiques, pp. 73–81. Senge, P., Cambron-McCabe, N., Bryan Smith, T.L., Dutton, J. et Kleiner, A.: 2000, Schools that learn, A fifth Discipline Fieldbook for Educators, Parents, and Everyone Who cares about Education, Doubleday, New York. Simon, M.: 1995, ‘Reconstructing mathematics pedagogy from a constructivist perspective’, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 26(2), 114–145.
Centre National d’Évaluation en Éducation, Citogroep, Pays-Bas
RONNIE KARSENTY
WHAT DO ADULTS REMEMBER FROM THEIR HIGH SCHOOL MATHEMATICS? THE CASE OF LINEAR FUNCTIONS
ABSTRACT. A qualitative study was designed to investigate adults’ long-term memory of mathematics learned in high school. Twenty-four men and women, aged 30 to 45, were requested to recall mathematical concepts and procedures during individual interviews. This article reports findings regarding the subjects’ attempts to draw graphs of simple linear functions. In general, these findings support the idea that retaining high school mathematical content strongly depends on the number, level, and total length of mathematics courses taken by the student. Diverse responses to the task of drawing a graph of a linear function such as y=2x, were documented and categorized. In many of these responses, the basic mathematical communal notion of linear graphing was replaced with personal on-the-spot constructing of ideas. Detailed analysis of three cases is presented, based on recall theories that explain the mechanism of recalling in terms of reconstruction vs. reproduction. KEY WORDS: adults, functions, graphs, long term memory, qualitative methods, recall theories
1. T HE LONG - TERM MAINTENANCE OF KNOWLEDGE LEARNED IN SCHOOL :
A ROAD ( ALMOST ) NOT TAKEN
The educational community is a rather multifaceted one. Different sectors in this community – parents, teachers, researchers and other members – do not always see eye to eye, to say the least. However, if there is something that educators do share, I suppose that it is the basic aspiration that makes us send our children to twelve years of schooling: We all want our children to be ‘educated’, to know things about the world, to broaden their horizons. Bearing in mind this naive but probably most agreed-upon goal, it is quite surprising that of the immense existing body of school research, only a minute portion is dedicated to questions of knowledge maintenance after school. Although the scarcity of research in this field was referred to more A short version of this paper was presented at the 2002 PME 26 conference in Norwich, UK: Karsenty, R. and Vinner, S.: 2002, ‘Functions, many years after school: What do adults remember?’, in A.D. Cockburn and E. Nardi (eds.), Proceedings of the 26th Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, Vol.3, University of East Anglia, Norwich, pp. 185–192.
Educational Studies in Mathematics 51: 117–144, 2002. © 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
118
RONNIE KARSENTY
than twenty years ago by memory researchers Bahrick (1979) and Neisser (1978), their call for innovative ecological memory studies was, in regard to this specific issue of knowledge learned in school, not widely answered. The following citation from Bahrick (1979) expresses his dissatisfaction with the state of affairs at the time, and it is still quite relevant today: It is disappointing that nearly 100 years of research have not yielded much progress toward specification of the conditions under which information, once acquired, can be maintained indefinitely. [. . .] Much of the information acquired in classrooms is lost after the final examinations are taken, but beyond the general advice to practice and rehearse frequently, we have little to offer those who wish to minimize or prevent such losses. (Bahrick, 1979: 297)
Nevertheless, some research on long-term memory for knowledge learned in school does exist. Semb and Ellis (1992, cited in Semb et al., 1993), who reviewed studies concerning this issue, pointed out that some of these studies were difficult to trace, due to the fact that they appeared in disciplinespecific journals. Indeed, if the small aggregate of relevant research is to be sorted by disciplines, we might find that for certain school subjects there are few studies, at most, which address the issue of how much is remembered of those subjects in the after-school years. In regard to mathematics, a unique work is that of Bahrick and Hall (1991). This large-scale quantitative study was designed to identify variables that affect losses in recall of high school algebra and geometry contents, throughout the life span. A major finding of this work was: When the acquisition period extends over several years, during which the original content is relearned and used in additional mathematics courses, the performance level at the end of the training is retained for more than 50 years, even for participants who report no significant additional rehearsal during this long period. In contrast, those whose acquisition period is limited to a single year perform at near-chance levels. . . (Bahrick and Hall, 1991: 30)
Bahrick and Hall also found that grades in courses, as well as standardized test scores, have minor influences on the rate of loss, although they reflect differences in the original degree of knowledge. The rate of loss is most affected, as emerges from the citation above, by variables concerned with the amount and distribution of practice. This conclusion is in agreement with findings from several memory studies in other disciplines of knowledge (Semb et al., 1993), and we will return to it later on. However, Bahrick and Hall’s work does not tackle the following question directly: what do adults remember from their past mathematical studies? The performance of Bahrick and Hall’s research participants (about 1700 in number) was measured by psychometric means (i.e., correct/incorrect answers). For obvious reasons, a statistical study of such a large scale does not usually involve cognitive analysis of answers to open-ended questions.
THE CASE OF LINEAR FUNCTIONS
119
Since cognitive analysis could potentially reveal phenomena that remain unnoticed by psychometric analysis (Karsenty and Vinner, 1996; Cooper and Dunne, 2000), it seems that a qualitative study, scrutinizing adults’ responses to mathematical tasks, could add to the general picture in the issue of maintenance of high school mathematical content. Thus, the research reported herein concentrated on a small group of adults, in order to allow an in-depth analysis. The analysis was based in part on theories of recall, which will be described in the next section. 2. T HEORIES OF RECALL : A BRIEF REMINDER
The ways in which people recall different contents have long been an attractive subject for researchers. However, almost all of the traditional memory studies were held in research laboratories, and hence referred mostly to contents that could be acquired in laboratory settings (e.g., words, scripts, lists of various kinds). The well-acknowledged classic work of Bartlett (1932) laid the foundations of this field. In Bartlett’s famous research, subjects were requested to recall a story they had read, within several time intervals. After meticulous examination of the discrepancies between different versions of the story, and based on other experiments, Bartlett suggested that recalling is a mechanism of reconstruction rather than reproduction. These terms will now be explained briefly. Reproduction means that specific details from the past are coded in memory, in such a way that enables the eliciting of ‘copies’, however pale or dim, in the present. Prior to Bartlett’s publication, most theories of recall focused on the idea of reproduction, as can be recognized from various titles given to these theories: ‘copy theories’, ‘trace theories’ and ‘reappearance hypothesis’ (see Neisser, 1967). Bartlett rejected these theories, suggesting that recall is performed through a process of reconstruction: This means that attempts to elicit past experiences tend to yield an altered version, that might be different from the original one in a substantial manner. For example, when requested to repeat a story, people are likely to produce an interpretation, though they may be unaware of doing so. Thus, some details might be omitted, others emphasized or even added. According to Bartlett (1932), reconstruction is controlled by schemas, which he defined as active organizers of past experiences. More recent memory researchers, such as Neisser (1984), basically agree with Bartlett’s ideas, although they suggest some refinements and modifications. Brewer and Nakamura (1984), for instance, talk about partial reconstructive recall. Yet, the context of many discussions about the nature of the recalling mechanism, is what Brewer (1986) called personal memory, or, to use Tulving’s (1972)
120
RONNIE KARSENTY
original distinction, episodic memory1 . These terms refer to the recall of events and occurrences personally experienced by an individual. Theories of recall are less frequently applied to depersonalized knowledge, much less to knowledge learned in school. In this article I would like to offer a glimpse into adults’ attempts to recall mathematical material, in a way that suggests that a mechanism of reconstruction might take place. Moreover, I intend to show that such a reconstruction, idiosyncratic as it might be, sometimes follows a certain inner logic that is used in the absence of accessible relevant details.
3. T HE STUDY: C HARACTERISTICS AND METHODS
3.1. The type of research conducted The research presented here is defined, according to Stake’s classification (1994, 1995), as a collective case study. This category of qualitative research refers to studies in which a certain number of cases are thoroughly examined in order to highlight a particular issue. In contrast to an intrinsic case study, in which the focus of interest is on the specific case uniquely, a collective case study is usually defined as instrumental, that is, the analyses of cases are meant to serve as a vehicle for enhancing a more general understanding in regard to some phenomena or theory. However, as Stake (1994) notes, the primary purpose of case studies, even when they are collective and instrumental, should be to gain a better understanding of the cases themselves. This study was therefore designed in light of two complementary objectives: to learn as much as possible from each single case, but also to obtain a more general picture in regard to all cases. This dual intention affected the case selection procedure, as will be described below. 3.2. Target population and case selection The study took place in Israel, and was restricted to Israeli high school graduates who had passed the Israeli Matriculation Exam in mathematics, which is an external, nation-wide test, taken at the end of high school. The first decision that had to be made in regard to subjects’ selection was the sector from which to choose candidates: Clearly, an attempt to represent the whole range of high school graduates would have been unfeasible, since the number of cases was to be relatively small. Therefore it was decided to focus on adults with post-secondary education. The implied assumption was that the voices of subjects holding college or university
THE CASE OF LINEAR FUNCTIONS
121
degrees might define ‘the upper bound’ of people’s recollections in regard to mathematics. The second methodological decision concerned the issue of accessibility. The main research method was an extensive interview. Such a procedure is, on the subject’s part, not only time consuming, but also – and this might be even more crucial – emotionally demanding. Hence it could not be expected that randomly chosen adults would cooperate with a researcher unknown to them. It became clear that some degree of personal acquaintance between the researcher and the subjects was a prior condition to the study’s implementation. After examining different social circles in which I had some involvement, I decided to select subjects from the population of a small village near a city where I was living at the time. This village was founded twenty years ago, and the adult residents – approximately 200 in number – came from all over the country and had attended different high schools in their youth. Members of this community can be seen as representing the higher-educated sector of the society in Israel. Restricting the study to volunteers between the ages of 30–452 who were not mathematics graduates or mathematics teachers, led to a group of 105 candidates. Then, in light of the dual objective mentioned above, personal data about the candidates were gathered, in order to maximize diversity when choosing subjects. The goal was to achieve, within the limited sector I focused on, a wide spectrum of cases that would consequently enable a broader view, based on investigating potentially different past mathematics learners. Three factors were considered: gender, level of mathematics taken in high school3 and current profession4 . After mapping these characteristics in a sampling table, a subject was chosen randomly from each non-empty cell. The final number of subjects was 24. Of these, 12 were men and 12 women, 12 took mathematics in the low-level track and 12 in the intermediate or high level tracks (see note 3). All subjects had post-secondary education, mostly from colleges or universities, and they were all engaged in professional careers in areas such as law, medicine, psychology, art, business, high school teaching and other. 3.3. Research methods Each subject participated in an individual session, which lasted between 2 to 3 hours. A lion’s share of this time was dedicated to a semi-structured interview, consisting of two parts. The first part was dedicated to affective aspects, later analyzed within a framework I called “the personal mathematical profile”. In this article I will not refer to this affective part of the research. Some results can be found in Karsenty and Vinner (2000). Detailed results will be published elsewhere.
122
RONNIE KARSENTY
In the second part of the interview, subjects were asked to solve mathematical tasks involving basic concepts and procedures. With a list of nine questions as a starting point, the conversation was constructed spontaneously according to the flow of ideas expressed by the subject. If interesting themes emerged, usually further unplanned questions were posed in order to follow the subject’s line of thought. Moreover, it is important to emphasize that the interview was interactive, as the interviewer occasionally responded to the subject’s answers. Responses were either in the form of feedback when necessary (e.g. if it became clear that the subject would not continue without it), or brief reminders, instruction, or hints in case the subject was ‘stuck’ in the process of recall. The intention was to investigate if and how a certain memory could be elicited through a certain trigger. The interviews were recorded and later transcribed. Of the data collected in the research, I will report here on results concerning the subjects’ attempts to draw graphs of simple linear functions, as documented during interviews. These results are presented in the next section.
4. R ECALLING GRAPHICAL DESCRIPTIONS OF SIMPLE LINEAR FUNCTIONS
4.1. Two levels of reporting subjects’ reactions to the task Subjects were requested to draw a graphical representation of a simple linear function. In most cases the function was y=x. However, in some cases the function was different, for instance in the case of Ilan5 , who mentioned the function y=2x during a previous answer, and thus was asked to draw it, in the natural flow of the interview. Usually, the discussion with each subject around the issue of drawing the given function did not end quickly. In fact, of all the tasks presented during interviews, this one produced some of the richest and most comprehensive data. In many cases, after the subject gave a spontaneous answer, and was asked to explain this answer, the discussion evolved in one (or a combination) of the following ways. Either the subject thought some more and changed or refined the original answer, or the subject justified the answer in a way that evoked further questions in regard to other functions. In addition, as the discussions involved mild interventions, in the manner explained above (see section 3.3), this process yielded some further interesting responses. In light of the extensive data, introducing results is a complicated and problematic issue, to be considered carefully. Since reporting different elements in each of the 24 discussions was unfeasible, it was decided to report the results in
THE CASE OF LINEAR FUNCTIONS
123
Figure 1. Shaul’s sketch for the function y=2x.
two levels. First, the spontaneous answers will be introduced, grouped into categories. This level of report gives a general picture about what people remember on the surface. Then, three cases will be reported and analyzed in detail, including the evolution of ideas during discussions. This level of report is intended to exemplify processes of reconstructing memory. 4.2. Research results (1): Subjects’ spontaneous responses to the task of graphing a linear function The initial attempts of all subjects to draw the function y=x (or some other linear function) were grouped into six categories, described below. C