152 × 230
Edmund Barton GEOFFREY BOLTON
ALLEN & UNWIN
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
i
152 × 230
This project was generously supported by the National Council for the Centenary of Federation
Copyright © Geoffrey Bolton 2000 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of one chapter or 10% of this book, whichever is the greater, to be photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it) has given a remuneration notice to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL) under the Act. Allen & Unwin 9 Atchison Street St Leonards NSW 2065 Australia Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100 Fax: (61 2) 9906 2218 E-mail:
[email protected] Web: http://www.allenandunwin.com National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry: Bolton, G.C. (Geoffrey Curgenven). Edmund Barton. Bibliography. Includes index. ISBN 186508 409 3. 1. Barton, Edmund, Sir, 1849–1920. 2. Prime ministers—Australia—Bibliography. I. Title. 994.041092 Set in 10.5/14.5 pt Trump Mediaeval by DOCUPRO, Canberra Printed and bound by Griffin Press, South Australia 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
ii
152 × 230
Contents
Acknowledgements Introduction: Encountering Edmund Barton 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Mr Micawber’s son Young Australia ‘Mr Speaker’ ‘My bristles are up’ Slow progress Federation becalmed Federation reviving Leader of the Convention Barton versus Reid Federation triumphant Prime Minister: Foundations Life at the top The road to resignation Mr Justice Barton Death of an elder statesman Reputation
iv vii 1 17 38 61 83 104 127 143 166 193 223 251 279 301 326 338
Notes Bibliography Index
348 370 376 iii
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 37 22
f: (02) 9438 37 33
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
iii
152 × 230
Acknowledgements Acknowledgements
In compiling a list of acknowledgements of the support and help received during the writing of this bibliography, I am constantly worried that I shall omit someone obviously deserving recognition. If there is any such omission I apologise profoundly and hope that there will be a second edition in which amends may be made. This project has been generously supported by an ARC Large Grant and by a grant from the Centenary of Federation Committee towards the distribution of Barton’s biography to secondary and tertiary institutions. In addition, the National Library of Australia awarded me a Harold White Fellowship in 1998 which proved invaluable in providing time for writing together with access to many important primary sources. I am most grateful to those responsible for making these awards and also to the referees whose testimonials were instrumental in the process. The University of Queensland, Edith Cowan University and Murdoch University have each, in turn, provided accommodation and support during the gestation of this book and I hope that the finished product will repay that support. Kevin Blackburn, Dirk Moses, Helen McCulloch and Marion Brooke all gave good service as research assistants. I received valuable assistance from Patricia Pyne in Canberra, who undertook the extensive preliminary trawl of the National Library, and my friend iv
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
iv
152 × 230
Acknowledgements v
and collaborator of many years, Terry Owen. Chester Andruskewicz made a distinctive contribution in the later stages of research. Birgit Gabriels is excellent at wordprocessing. I’ve gathered information and advice from many sources. Sir Edmund and Lady Barton’s four grandchildren, Bettina RankinReid (Mount Keira), Ann McIntosh (Bellevue Hill), David Barton (Bayview) and Edmund Barton (Essex, England) have been generous and helpful commentators. In the early stages of my research I benefited from conversations with Father John Parsons, who has also researched Barton and defended him against accusations of idleness. Penny Pemberton shared her knowledge of the Australian Agricultural Company. Tom and Maureen Campbell have been wonderfully hospitable and Tom, as biographer of Sir George Dibbs, has exchanged much good conversation and information with me. In following Barton’s track in rural New South Wales, I was helped by my old friends Eric and Shirley Andrews in Newcastle and by David Rowe. At the Berrima District Hospital and Family History Society my path was smoothed by Ron and Betty Mumford, Linda Emery and Leah Day. Theo Barker at Bathurst and the Lithgow Historical Society helped with aspects of Barton not covered in the Sydney press. Clive Beauchamp has also helped. During recent years I have discussed Barton with many friends and colleagues and have inflicted sections of the manuscript on several. Brian de Garis, Derek Drinkwater, John Hurst, Stuart Macintyre, Allan Martin, Jenny Mills, Graeme Powell, Margaret Steven, Katharine West and the late Jules Zanetti have all contributed improvements and insights. These mutual support systems are beyond the calculations of economic rationalism, and I value them. In the process of publication it has also been a pleasure to work with (and to try the patience of) John Iremonger at Allen & Unwin and his colleagues Emma Cotter and Karen Penning. Once again, my wife Carol and our family have been a sure source of loving support. It seems appropriate to dedicate this book to Jed McArthur-Bolton, Bleys McArthur-Bolton and Ariel AtkinBolton, Australians of the twenty-first century. Geoffrey Bolton Claremont, 2000
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
v
152 × 230
vi EDMUND BARTON
A NOTE ON ILLUSTRATIONS The photographs in this book, as well as the cartoons from the Bulletin and Melbourne Punch, are all reproduced by courtesy of the National Library of Australia.
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
vi
152 × 230
Introduction: Encountering Edmund Barton EDMUND BARTON Introduction
E
first seriously entered my life on the evening of 13 September 1952 at the Port Hotel in Derby, Western Australia. An inexperienced post-graduate student, not quite 21 years old, I had for the past three months been researching the history of the Kimberley pastoral industry and thought that a spare Saturday night might usefully be spent yarning at the bar with some old-timer about his experiences. I soon found my old-timer. He was a station cook, 73 years of age, battered and leathery with years of outback living; Russel Ward would have been proud of him. We talked while I sipped my beer and he drained his crème de menthe from five-ounce glasses and, presently, he said: ‘Do you know what was the greatest moment of my life?’ No, I said, I didn’t, but I’d like to hear. I thought he might relate some epic of droving or some anecdote of Gallipoli or the Somme. But he told me that when he was eighteen years old he was a kitchen-hand at Petty’s Hotel in Sydney, and that night after night Edmund Barton would bring some of the delegates from the federal convention to dinner after a session. ‘I seen them all,’ he told me, ‘Reid, Deakin, Forrest—I seen them all. But the prince of them all was Edmund Barton.’ This encounter impressed me. As a well-trained graduate of the University of Western Australia I knew about Barton, of course. The previous year, 1951, had been the half-centenary of Federation. There DMUND BARTON
vii
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
vii
152 × 230
viii EDMUND BARTON
had been a parade through the main street of Perth, one item in which was a float on which various well-known local actors in frock coats sat around a table imitating the Founding Fathers, their speeches rising in passion as they worked through the refreshments with which somebody had thoughtfully provided them. Postage stamps had been issued with the portraits of Barton and Sir Henry Parkes. And I had bought and enjoyed John Reynolds’ recently published biography of Edmund Barton and knew that the federal movement promoted him in its propaganda as ‘Australia’s noblest son’. Barton was, however, essentially an urban, middle-class politician, and it came as a surprise to find an old bushie in the Kimberleys, a character who was neither urban nor middle class, praising Barton so emphatically more than half a century after Federation. I made up my mind that one day I would find out about Barton. This curiosity, it seemed, was shared by few other Australians. No later biography has appeared to supplement Reynolds’ pioneering study, although a good deal more manuscript material has been lodged in the National and Mitchell Libraries, and Martha Rutledge contributed an excellent 5000-word entry on Barton to Volume 7 of the Australian Dictionary of Biography. Far from dominating the official mythology of his nation as Washington does in the United States or Nehru in India, Barton is less remembered than, for instance, Sir John A. Macdonald in Canada or Louis Botha in South Africa. A schoolteacher friend of mine tells me that 20 years ago he asked a class of fifteen-year-olds whether they could name the first American president and the first Australian prime minister. Nearly everybody named Washington, nobody knew about Barton. In 1994 he repeated the experiment with a similar class and found a noteworthy change. Hardly anybody knew about either man. This neglect invites two possible explanations. One is that Barton was not really important. He might be seen as a compromise figurehead behind whom more purposeful talents such as Deakin and Forrest manoeuvred to promote their favoured policies. Such an interpretation would draw support from the nickname ‘Tosspot Toby’, reflecting Barton’s indulgence in food and drink. It might also be argued that he was Commonwealth prime minister for only two
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
viii
152 × 230
Introduction ix
years and eight months, during part of which time he was overseas, and that his decision to retire to the less conspicuous responsibilities of the High Court rules him out of consideration as a serious statesman. (On the other hand he remains, with the exception of Robert Menzies and perhaps Andrew Fisher, the only one of Australia’s 25 prime ministers to quit office at the moment of his own choosing.) Inescapably Barton’s biographer has to reckon with the possibility that he was an amiable and fortunate second-rater who reached the history books by accident. A second explanation lies in the eddies of fashion in historical writing. During the 1970s the Federal Constitution came under attack as a relic of the horse-and-buggy era, a botched compromise lacking the appeals to noble sentiment which prefaced the constitutions of the United States and the former Soviet Union. After a quarter of a century of largely futile attempts at constitutional reform, most critics today are prepared to concede some respect for the generation of politicians who at least managed to put together a workable constitution and secure its acceptance by a majority of voters in every part of Australia; but it has taken the approaching centenary of the Australian Commonwealth to bring the process of Federation more sharply into focus. Understandably, however, much research is concentrating on the grassroots of the federal movement. We really know astonishingly little about the motives of the people who voted for or against Federation. We know a good deal about the process by which the constitution was created, largely thanks to the work of J. A. La Nauze and L. F. Crisp, and we know something of what the politicians said when they went on the campaign trail or corresponded with one another. But the uncharted country crying out for discovery by historians includes the growth of national sentiment among ordinary Australian men and women. Many of today’s practising historians are moved by a moral imperative to give voices to the obscure and the disadvantaged who have previously been overlooked in the reconstruction of Australia’s past. Writers of ‘history from below’ tend to mistrust political history as a genre dealing with the transactions of powerful elites, and political biography as liable to uphold the myth of ‘the great man in history’. Barton at first appearance conforms to a conventional
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
ix
152 × 230
x EDMUND BARTON
stereotype. A middle-class male from the professional classes, of English parentage and English sympathies, conformist, overweight, and comfortable in the Establishment, he seems a prime representative of a dominant class and gender which have come under searching challenge in recent decades. Nor is his image enhanced by the circumstance that most of his surviving portraits show the public face of a statesman posed for the eye of posterity. He lacked the memorable idiosyncrasies of a George Reid or a Billy Hughes. Can such a figure be made interesting or relevant to the Australians of our generation? It’s worth a try. The features which many of us now deplore in the political culture of Barton’s era—the faith in nationalism as an energising force for a community, the belief in European racial superiority, the exclusive masculinity of the governing classes—were not unique to Australia but were entrenched in most of the civilised world. To ignore or berate the public figures of a hundred years ago because they were insensitive to issues which we now consider important is to invite similar derision from the scholars and readers of a hundred years hence. Barton and his contemporaries should be assessed in the context of the possibilities open to them in their time. It mattered that Australians in the 1890s should decide whether they wished to remain a scatter of British colonies to the south of Asia or whether they should embark on the unprecedented experiment of creating a single nation in a continent. It mattered, if Australia federated, that a federal constitution should be devised of sufficient flexibility to allow for change and growth during the next century and beyond. In the political processes required to achieve these objectives it was important for the Australian people to find representatives who would devote time and energy to those aims, negotiate the necessary agreements and compromises, and speak to the public in words that carried conviction. Barton was one of the politicians who accepted this responsibility. Eventually he was thought by his colleagues to have shown such devotion to the cause that he deserved to be the leader under whom the rest would serve. Such examples of practical cooperation are not common in politics. How did Barton become the necessary man? In exploring this question we shall see how an easygoing Sydney
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
x
152 × 230
Introduction xi
politician became possessed by the one great enthusiasm of his life; how, although only one of many who contributed to the federal cause, he came to be seen as its actual and symbolic leader; and how, having passed the peak of his form, he had the timely wisdom to step aside from political leadership. I do not intend to present Barton as a hero, believing with Brecht that happy is the land that has no need for heroes. But I see in him an example of a peculiar capacity—John Monash and John Curtin are other Australian examples which come to mind—for flawed and fallible individuals to lift their performance in moments of crisis and so to make a lasting contribution to public welfare. (This peculiar capacity is not limited to Australia; I think of Truman and many others.) Australians are often, and deservedly, cynical about their politicians. It is worth remembering the occasions when their elected representatives have behaved constructively.
The materials for Barton’s biography presented problems. Plenty could be found about his public activities during the Federation era and the period of his prime ministership. The Barton papers in the National Library of Australia could be supplemented by correspondence with Parkes, Deakin and many other leading political figures. Australia in the Federation years also boasted a diverse and lively press. Cities and large country towns supported several newspapers in which the speeches, activities and personal foibles of politicians were reported in detail. Barton’s private life was harder to approach. Unlike Alfred Deakin he kept no confessional diaries voicing spiritual yearnings, and very little family correspondence has survived. Barton and his family deliberately guarded their privacy. Barton himself was well aware that he had taken part in significant events in Australian history. At some point after leaving politics and going to the High Court he and his wife systematically went through their past correspondence, carefully preserving letters which they thought of permanent interest, but destroying almost all personal and family material. This happened probably around 1909 when they moved from ‘Miandatta’, their North Sydney residence of twelve years, to a sma ller house. The rema ining correspondence was further
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
xi
152 × 230
xii
EDMUND BARTON
winnowed by Barton’s executor and son-in-law, David Maughan, before the Barton papers were deposited in the National Library in 1929. Even then certain material referring to the family’s personal affairs remained under restricted access until a few years ago. Oral history cannot do much to help. Very few people who remembered him were alive in the 1990s, and these only from the perspective of small children. Fortunately John Reynolds recorded some interviews when he was researching for his biography of 1948. Barton’s grandchildren have offered me every cooperation—but large gaps remain in the record. I have not found out how it was that Barton lost his money in the 1893 financial crisis. I have very little first-hand evidence about the swings of temperament which were covered by his normally calm, good-humoured and formal exterior. Least of all have I found out nearly enough about the point of view of Jeanie Barton, from all the evidence the one woman in his life. She was evidently an intelligent woman, who played the piano, wrote with a good hand, and with little preparation held her own in upper-class society in London, but she has left remarkably little trace of her own thoughts and feelings. For example, I could find nothing about her relations with her sister and brother after her marriage and departure from Newcastle. It was only within months of completing this biography that I was shown by Dr David Barton a cache of letters from his grandfather to his father. From these it appeared that the sister remained on close visiting terms with the Bartons throughout their marriage. She may well have been a source of support for Jeanie during the many times that she was left alone with the children because of her husband’s public commitments. But this is no more than informed conjecture. There is much else in the lives of Jeanie and Edmund Barton which remains unknown, because they were good at minding their own business. I have done what I could with the materials at my disposal, but while I believe I have given a more complete portrayal of Barton than any previous attempt, I would be the first to admit that important questions are left unanswered. Nevertheless after several years in close proximity with Edmund Barton he retains my respect—an outcome not always experienced by biographers—so
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
xii
152 × 230
Introduction xiii
that my account of him aims at balancing justice and affection. A propaganda campaign marking the centenary of Federation took up my schoolteacher friend’s point that many Australians know nothing of their first prime minister. My hope is that this book will do a little towards demonstrating that Edmund Barton was and is worth knowing.
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
xiii
152 × 230
This page intentionally left blank
PDF OUTPUT c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\PRELIMS p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
xiv
152 × 230
1
Mr Micawber’s Son EDMUND BARTON Mr Micawber’s Son
T
were probably painted in 1827, in the last years of Georgian England. Her profile suggests a spirited and pretty eighteen-year-old, his a man in his early thirties, both facing the future cheerfully and confidently. They were about to marry and go to New South Wales, that raw convict colony established less than 40 years earlier on the other side of the world, but already in some eyes a land of promise. It would never have occurred to Mary Louisa Whydah or to William Barton that by the end of the century a son of theirs would become the first prime minister of a united Australia. They had no intention of settling permanently. William Barton was the youngest son of a London perfumier, a member of a merchant family with interests in the East Indies. Born in 1795, he had not prospered greatly despite the careful mentoring of an elder brother, until in May 1827 the opportunity came of appointment as accountant to the Australian Agricultural Company. Formed three years earlier as a result of lobbying by the Macarthur family, the Company was one of the first attempts to mobilise British investment by capitalising on the promise of an expanding wool industry to acquire large tracts of Australian land. With £1 million behind it the Company was willing to pay the handsome salary of £500 a year for a smart young executive to go to New South Wales as accountant and secretary. William Barton’s family supported his application. He had a seven-year contract, but he would be best HE MINIATURES
1
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
1
152 × 230
2 EDMUND BARTON
served, wrote his elder brother, by a stay of at least fourteen years in a land flowing with milk and honey. In this hopeful frame of mind William and Mary Louisa were married in June 1827 and embarked upon the Frederick for the five-month voyage to Australia. First impressions of Sydney were propitious. They were immediately received into the first rank of society; Governor Darling invited them to a ball and supper for the King’s birthday; and their first child was born, named William, like his father. But in December 1828 the Company closed its Sydney office and moved its establishment to Port Stephens, 150 kilometres northward. In this remote and underdeveloped peninsula, swampy and ill-drained, 600 officials, workmen and convicts laboured to build a pastoral empire on land unsuited for sheep. ‘It was, in effect a new colony settled by Englishmen with no colonial experience.’ After the first manager’s dismissal, discipline slackened and quarrels flared. In this remote and alien environment, so different from his familiar London, William Barton went somewhat to pieces, covering his anxiety by displays of inappropriately grandiose behaviour. The Bartons came to a barely completed brick and adobe cottage which William endeavoured to landscape like an English gentleman’s residence, with an ornamental wall and a flourishing vegetable garden. He remained professionally competent, beavering away at various practices which he thought were costing the Company money, but his temper became erratic and unpredictable, especially after the arrival in December 1829 of a new local manager for the Company, Sir Edward Parry. Only five years older than Barton, Parry owed his appointment largely to his reputation as a successful Arctic explorer. Barton seems to have expected that he would be content as a figurehead while his diligent accountant managed the Company’s affairs. Parry quickly made it plain that he was in charge, but the Parrys and the Bartons remained on civil terms for about a year. One summer afternoon Lady Parry, out driving in her dog-cart with her maid beside her, passed young Mrs Barton’s cottage, and seeing her with her two small children, invited her to come for the drive with her, leaving the maid to walk the two kilometres home. That evening William Barton penned a furious letter to the Parrys protesting against the insult to his wife
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
2
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 3
in asking her to sit where the maid had been sitting. Soon after followed a letter from Mary Louisa, asking the Parrys not to trouble themselves over her husband’s ‘ridiculous note’, but it was of no use. Relations soured irrevocably between Parry and Barton. A series of squabbles over petty issues culminated in March 1831 when a convict sent by Parry to Barton’s house complained that Barton drove him away by throwing gravel-stones at him. Parry had Barton suspended from his duties, prosecuted for assault, and evicted from his house before ordering him and his family to return to England. Acquitted of the stone-throwing shortly before his departure, Barton arrived in England in December eager to report his side of the story to the Company, only to find that the directors had already decided to terminate his contract, following advice from Parry. Settling his family in lodgings in Bloomsbury, Barton waged a paper war against the Company for two years, but to no avail. Early in 1834, by now with four children, the Bartons departed once more for Sydney. Barton sued Parry for malicious prosecution, and was awarded the contemptuous damages of one farthing. With little capital, William was now driven by determination to triumph over his critics by proving himself a successful businessman. In August 1834 he established a public bazaar in a former hotel in Macquarie Place. It was a kind of ancestor of the modern shopping centre, where goods could be warehoused and retailers might rent trading outlets under the same roof. Barton himself was advertising Londonbuilt one-horse carriages and hoped to attract others in the same line of business as well as sellers of furniture and musical instruments. By April 1835 the Sydney Bazaar had added books, stationery, toys, millinery, haberdashery and baby linen to its stock, but a few weeks later it closed. Undeterred, Barton in June was advertising a brand of repeater rifle useful for inland settlers ‘in the present crisis’ (presumably Aboriginal resistance) as well as continuing to deal in vehicles. In the midst of these ventures he hit on his longest-lived vocation. At the end of July he began advertising himself as an agent for the transfer of shares in banks and other companies. By publishing Australia’s first list of stocks and shares
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
3
152 × 230
4 EDMUND BARTON
he secured his niche in financial history as the nation’s pioneer stockbroker. At first this could be only a sideline because there were as yet few public companies with negotiable shares. Early in 1836 Barton was busy with the formation of the Australian Fire and Life Assurance Company. He was interim secretary but somehow failed to become a member of the permanent directorate. Could it be that his peers judged him a lightweight, ineffectually scrabbling on the margins, or did he lose friends through the protective selfimportance which had coloured his relations with Sir Edward Parry? At any rate the man was unsinkable. Later in 1836 he was offering himself as a house and land agent, but his stockbroking activities continued, and in 1838 he published The Particulars of Joint Stock Institutions in New South Wales. Unhappily all this activity failed to translate itself into steady income, and during 1838–39 Mary Louisa Barton, although by now the mother of six children with a seventh on the way, was obliged to run a school for day and boarding students. During the next few years New South Wales enjoyed a pastoral boom. Borrowing from former Australian Agricultural Company colleagues, William Barton began investing in land: 104 acres and a cottage at Five Dock in outer Sydney, 640 acres in the St George basin, 736 acres near Bathurst, 1120 acres at Sugarloaf, four town lots at Muswellbrook. Early in 1842, with unabated optimism he set up as an auctioneer in Pitt Street, dealing mainly in property but with a share auction every Wednesday—just in time for a calamitous slump. In April 1843 he went bankrupt, one among many, and the trustees took hold of his possessions, even the two cows, four pigs and poultry on the Five Dock estate. Once again Mary Louisa went schoolteaching. Within twelve months William was able to settle with his creditors and resume his stockbroking, but to judge from the infrequency of his newspaper advertisements during the next five years he was learning caution in promoting bright new ideas. The family continued to increase and by 1846 numbered seven daughters and three sons. Perhaps because of pressure of numbers the Bartons left the central part of Sydney where they had lived
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
4
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 5
since returning from England, and took a house in Hereford Street, Glebe, a developing suburb about five kilometres to the south-west. Here Mary Louisa became pregnant for the eleventh time, and here on 18 January 1849 she gave birth to her fourth son. Six months later he was christened Edmund, a name not previously used in the family. Perhaps he was named after the explorer Edmund Kennedy, recently killed by Aborigines on his Cape York Peninsula expedition. The child Edmund arrived at an improving moment in the family’s fortunes. In 1849 William Barton re-emerged as a real estate agent and dealer in shares and by 1851 the family was back in central Sydney, with William’s office at the Sydney Harbour end of George Street and the family in Cumberland Street—for the Rocks was still a respectable neighbourhood. That was the year when the discovery of gold in the gullies north of Bathurst launched New South Wales and Victoria on an unprecedented boom. Sydney’s population increased from under 45 000 in 1851 to 56 000 in 1861 and, although Melbourne dramatically outstripped the older city, Sydney did well enough to change from a straggling port at the fag-end of the convict era to a prosperously thriving mercantile centre. As Sydney’s only specialist sharebroker William Barton could hardly avoid benefiting from these changes. Whereas his earlier business had been mainly in banking, gas lighting and steam navigation shares, the 1850s saw growth in gold and coal mining companies. Of course the expanding economy attracted competition and before long Barton was no longer leader in the field, but even so he had never done better. Mary Louisa may still have felt the need for added financial security, for instead of taking the opportunity to devote herself exclusively to her large family she continued running a ladies’ college in Macquarie Street. Perhaps she was one of those uncommon nineteenth-century married women who, having established a professional career, was able to continue enjoying it. By 1853 William was at last able to inform his brother in England that he was living comfortably and saving, but had given up his intention of returning to England and meant to remain in New South Wales. He had taken more than twenty years to acclimatise, but his children, especially the younger of them, would grow up thinking of themselves as Australian.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
5
152 × 230
6 EDMUND BARTON
So it was that, in comparison with his older sisters and brothers, Edmund Barton was to enjoy a childhood of moderate financial security. Probably also emotional security, as the baby in a large family with a majority of girls; for although soon after Edmund’s third birthday a brother was born, Sydney Fitzgerald Barton, he survived only nine months. His loss may have strengthened Edmund’s position—‘Toby’, as the family called him from an early age—as the cherished youngest child. From such beginnings Toby would soon have developed the charm on which so many people commented in later life, as well as the quickness to perceive and understand the point of view of others; a quickness which sometimes shaded into his least attractive characteristic, too great a readiness to appear to agree with those viewpoints. Possibly also it was a youngest child’s experience which led to the adult Edmund Barton’s over-fondness for his food and drink, as well as a somewhat happy-go-lucky attitude towards money. One story survives from his childhood. The very tall Bishop Barker, making polite conversation with small Toby Barton, asked him what his father called him. ‘Damned young scamp,’ replied Toby, ‘’cause I put my finger in the inkpot and was writing over his writing to make it big.’ With a family which was long remembered as ‘one of the most literary in Sydney’ and his mother an experienced teacher and woman of character, it would also have helped that he showed signs of being a very intelligent little boy who took readily to schooling. After two years at the nearby Upper Fort Street primary school, attached to the garrison church at St Philip’s, he was sent to Sydney Grammar School, probably at its re-opening in 1857 and certainly by the time he was ten in 1859. By that time each of his five eldest sisters had married and left home. Remarkably, none lived in Sydney; one had gone to London, three to Brisbane, and the other married first a physician and then a journalist who lived several years in Ceylon (Sri Lanka) before settling in Melbourne. Of those who remained at home, Alice, four years his senior, was his favourite, whom he would remember as ‘the flower of the flock’. She was destined in 1865 to make what seemed the best match of all, when she married an Oxfordshire squire, Edward Hamersley, and went to live in an English manor-
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
6
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 7
house; but the dampness of the Thames Valley would promote a tubercular condition, and she would be dead by 30. Ellen, a year younger, was even less fortunate. She died aged fourteen in July 1860 of injuries sustained in a fire eighteen weeks earlier. It has been impossible to discover the circumstances of the fire, but the trauma for the family must have been considerable. Of the sons, the eldest, William, was at 30 a dim figure, unmarried, junior partner in his father’s firms, and dabbler in goldmining investments. The third son, Henry, made hardly more impression. There was nothing dim or unimpressive about the second son, George Burdett Barton. A clever youth, he entered the University of Sydney in 1853 at sixteen, intending to follow a legal career after taking his degree. Shortly before he was due to graduate, George quarrelled with the professor of classics, John Woolley, pursued the dispute provocatively in the newspapers, and was expelled from the university. This was to be the pattern of his life. Gifted, handsome, energetic, apparently fit for early success, he so often timed his rebellious gestures for the moment when they would wreak the maximum of harm on his worldly prospects. He was a role model for Edmund to avoid, but at this point of their lives George’s cantankerousness may have benefited his younger brother. Somehow the family found the means to send George to London to qualify in law at the Middle Temple. By 1859 his progress disappointed old William Barton, who was moved to write to his son attributing his lack of success to idleness. This provoked a tremendous rejoinder, 40 handwritten pages in length. It was his deafness, George argued, coupled with a prolonged bout of depression, which explained his slow progress. He turned the attack on his father, accusing him of neglect: I acknowledge that from my earliest years you have treated me with understanding kindness . . . Punishment, unfeeling or unreasoning, I have never received from you . . . but . . . You have neglected to give me that training and cultivation at home in the absence of which the best of youngsters run great risks . . . I cannot recall to mind that you have ever spent five minutes in conversation with me of any kind, certainly not in
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
7
152 × 230
8 EDMUND BARTON
conversation of that kind which every Father should unremittingly hold with his Son.
Old William Barton, said George, had never taught him to look after his health or to take exercise or to cultivate a moral sense: But I have another and more practical reason for moralising in this vein. In your last letter you mention Edmund’s success at the Grammar School and add ‘You, too, began well. I trust that he will not flag as he proceeds.’ Now, observe this. If by good fortune his health continues unimpaired he will not flag as he proceeds, he will go on as he has begun . . . But, if he is allowed, as I was allowed to become the victim of disease, you will have a second time to mourn the disappointment of your hope . . . Let my fate, then, be a lesson to you for your profit. Mark out on his Chart the rocks on which I have split and I shall not have suffered in vain. Let him learn early what I have learned late. Do not allow him, the Benjamin of your heart, to remain in ignorance of those things on which his welfare, for Time and for Eternity entirely depend. Cultivate his Body—Cultivate his Mind—Cultivate his Soul.
In his mid-sixties William Barton was neither of an age nor of a temperament to pay much heed to the insights of an angry 23-year-old son; but someone in the family must have thought the letter worth keeping. George qualified and returned to Sydney in 1860, but instead of practising law, drifted into journalism. In 1864 he was one of the founders of Sydney Punch, a weekly intended to repeat the success of its London namesake. Next year he married, and a secure future seemed open to him in the form of a government appointment worth £500 a year. With his habitual poor timing George chose that moment to publish in Punch a satire on the government entitled ‘Jupiter and Ganymede’. The premier was not amused, and the government appointment was cancelled. After another two years in Sydney, George went off to New Zealand in 1868 for further turbulent experiences in law and journalism. Meanwhile the younger William Barton faded out of life in 1863—after convulsions lasting four days, according to the death certificate— and Edmund became more and more the hope of the family.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
8
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 9
Whether or not because of George Barton’s advice, Edmund did well at Sydney Grammar School. Despite a dilapidated fabric and tight finances the school met high academic standards, with particular strengths in Latin and Greek, taught by the headmaster, an Oxford graduate. Here a lifelong love of classics was kindled in Edmund Barton. Henceforward he carried in his head the resonances of a great culture far removed from colonial Sydney or from the Regency England of his father’s reminiscences. Sydney Grammar also gave him a great liking for cricket, an enthusiasm shared by his best friend, Dick O’Connor. Two years younger than Barton, Richard Edward O’Connor was descended from a family notable in the 1798 Irish rising, but his own father was a highly respectable parliamentary clerk. Although Barton and O’Connor did not overlap at Sydney Grammar, they apparently met in those years, and friendship followed. For the rest of their lives O’Connor would be the only friend who continued to call Barton ‘Ted’. Having been captain of the school in 1863 and 1864, a position which went automatically to the dux, or academically most gifted boy, Edmund Barton in 1865 matriculated into the University of Sydney with such excellent results that the Senate awarded him a special prize. At university he specialised in classics, with minors in mathematics, physics, French and English literature. The latter was taught for a while by his brother George, whose influence may well have stimulated nationalist ideas in the young Edmund. For in 1866 George Burdett Barton published Literature in New South Wales, surely one of the first blasts of the trumpet on behalf of Australian creativity. ‘Unless a radical change takes place in the temper of the people, the prospects of an independent literature are extremely dim . . .’ George went on: We shall thus be left to rely helplessly upon the productions of another land, as we do at present, we shall produce nothing of our own beyond slavish imitations . . . This is not a prospect which any lover of his country can regard with pleasure . . . Patriotism has not yet developed itself amongst us; and the history of the world has shown that where there has been no patriotism, there has never been a literature.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
9
152 × 230
10 EDMUND BARTON
These were the accents of the young Australia which Edmund would represent in his political career. It was Edmund’s good fortune that in his second year a new professor of classics arrived, Charles Badham, with an international reputation and a great talent for tutoring. Disappointed in his Oxford career because of an unorthodox theology and a sometimes untimely wit, Badham at 54 was a great catch for Sydney. He had edited several of the works of Plato, who with his mentor Socrates and his pupil Aristotle was seen as setting the basic questions of Western political philosophy. Badham was particularly renowned as a textual critic skilled at identifying the original words and intentions of ancient writers. The fastidious use of language required in such exercises resembled the analytical approach used by judges and senior counsel in interpreting the wording of laws. Badham must have been a profound influence for a student such as Barton whose later career would be so much bound up with the framing and interpretation of legal and political concepts. Although he championed the humanities against public men such as Governor Robinson, who thought all higher education should have a strictly practical bent, Badham was no cloistered academic. He gladly talked to working men’s institutes and other public groups, and would if necessary have served as a school inspector in the interests of communicating between the university and the community at large. According to one of his students: ‘His speeches at the Commemoration were looked forward to by the undergraduates, were listened to with attention, and were punctuated with applause.’ Barton responded to his teaching, winning the Lithgow scholarship in his second year and the Cooper in his third. In 1868 he graduated with first-class honours in Classics and was awarded a special University prize for the substantial sum of £20; over $2000 by the standards of 2000. Two years later, in May 1870, he took his Master of Arts degree, which in those easygoing times was largely a formality, if an expensive one. While an undergraduate, Barton took up rowing, and in 1870, a trim 21-year-old weighing just over 60 kilograms, he was a member of the Sydney four beaten by the University of Melbourne. Next year in the Sydney regatta he was one of the Osprey crew who won an
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
10
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 1 1
event from Circular Quay to Lavender Bay, around Fort Denison and back. Cricket remained his main enthusiasm, though he was remembered as no more than a fair batsman and an appalling fieldsman. Probably his best work for the University club was done administratively. He served on the grounds committee in 1869 and the general committee for several years from 1868, including two spells as acting chairman and two as honorary secretary. When the team visited Melbourne over the Christmas of 1870 to lose narrowly to the rival university, Barton came in at number seven, making four in the first innings and five in the second. The following year when Melbourne returned the visit, the home side won by nine wickets, Barton’s contribution being a modest four singles. These games were major social events, with a German band to play in the intervals, and champagne toasts at the end of the match. The visiting team received free rail passes from the host government, and both sides were invited to theatres and choral societies. Prophetically the Argus editorial praised such events for their value in bringing the colonies of Victoria and New South Wales closer together. During 1869 and 1870 Edmund Barton intermittently kept a diary. In its pages he comes across as a pleasant, sociable young man, on good terms with his parents and enjoying many friendships. He notes reading Macaulay and Blackstone, but writes more of cricket and fishing. One of his fishing mates was a thickset young Treasury clerk four years older than himself, George Reid, with whom he went to the races, cruised on Sydney Harbour and exchanged comic Valentines. In March 1869 Reid took him to the School of Arts debating society, where Barton ‘tried to speak and made a fool of himself’; but he persevered, hardly imagining how much oratory lay ahead for Reid and himself. Many years later Reid recalled: ‘I never met a more deficient beginner as a speaker than he was. I often used to encourage him, as a very young man, to get on his feet and speak . . . but he did not take to it kindly.’ His dissipations were mild, although on a spring night following a rowing celebration he wrote: ‘Drank much beer, which together with more drunk coming home from Fred Fitzhardinge made too much. Accordingly played some pranks’, with the inevitable sequel:
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
11
152 × 230
12 EDMUND BARTON
‘Very bilious and seedy. Didn’t go to Regatta.’ He had a not uncritical eye for a pretty girl. After dancing with a Miss Austen known as ‘the Belle of Balmain’, he commented: ‘A fair girl with good features, but indifferent light blue eyes and little brain, as far as I could tell.’ On occasion he could be a combative young male. At the May Ball at Government House (where, oddly by today’s standards, his father accompanied him), as there were 800 present Edmund ‘was wise enough not to dance much in such a mob’ but stood up resolutely to a ‘snob’ who accused him of pushing past his girlfriend. ‘Snob’ was Barton’s severest term of criticism in those years. Then at Easter 1870 the University cricket team visited Newcastle, where the University made 69 and 97. In the second innings Barton was the second highest scorer, making fifteen runs. Newcastle was all out for 38 in the first innings but recovered to win by three wickets. During this weekend Edmund’s friend Dick Teece introduced him to two middle-aged ladies, a Mrs Coulter, accompanied by her daughter, and Miss Home, with her niece. Both girls were pretty. ‘Janet Coulter is a jolly little cuss and sings like a bird,’ Barton remarked, but it was her friend for whom he fell: ‘And Jeanie Ross is beautiful and she sings and is a dear.’ He lost no time, because the day concluded with ‘Tea at Miss Home’s. Jolly. And walk after. Jollier.’ The next day there was a wine party given by the mayor and mayoress. The competitive young Barton suspected that their son had an eye on Jeanie, but she took no notice, and it was Edmund who walked the young ladies home. For the rest of the week he saw her every day, and when it was time to return to Sydney he spent a sleepless night with what he called ‘the blue devils’. He sent her a copy of that classic mid-Victorian statement on gender relations, Tennyson’s ‘Princess’, and correspondence followed. It was arranged that Jeanie would come to Sydney late in May. He was only 21, and she not quite nineteen, but they were ready to commit themselves. On 26 May he wrote: Walked with Jeanie and had a serious talk with her speaking fully about my circumstances and prospects. Her admirable character displayed itself more completely to me. The knowledge
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
12
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 1 3
of my poor and wretched situation and of my small estimate of my chances, seemed to make her more tender than before . . . How I love that Girl!
When he took her to the Opera he saw ‘no one fit to hold a candle to her’. All was well too with his parents: ‘Jeanie seemed quite in love with the old people.’ Her own parents were dead. Jane Mason Ross (always known as ‘Jeanie’) was the London-born daughter of a Scottish engineer, David Ross, and his wife Euphemia. With their three children they emigrated to Newcastle, where David Ross was credited with building some of the port’s earliest coal-handling equipment. Having lost money in mining investments he turned publican, becoming licensee of the Albion Inn in Blane Street (now Hunter Street West), ‘quite a famous hostelry’, according to a local historian, ‘catering for visitors from Sydney and the country districts . . . It was an old-fashioned cottage type of building . . . standing well back from the roadway, with a wide verandah in front’. Many years later some old Newcastle hands thought they saw a prophecy of Federation in the gilt inn sign, which depicted a man trying to break a bundle of sticks across his knee with the motto ‘Union is Strength’. Widowed early, Ross brought out his wife’s sister, Ellen Home, to look after his young family. Tradition remembers her as ‘a very terrifying disciplinarian and stern unbending Presbyterian’. The same family source also asserts that she made her brother-in-law give up the hotel, but if so it can only have been shortly before his death in 1868. His obituary describes him as ‘contractor’. Gossips took care to inform Edmund that Jeanie’s father had been a publican, but he was unmoved. This was the girl he meant to marry. In any case the family’s respectability survived challenge. David Ross had served two terms as alderman, and his Presbyterian funeral was attended by 300 mourners. Jeanie herself played the organ at St Andrews Church. The only, the critical, impediment to marriage was that Edmund had first to make a career. Having no aptitude for commerce or primary industry, he found the law the most likely option for a young man with a good manner and vocabulary. In 1868, after taking his first degree, he entered the
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
13
152 × 230
14 EDMUND BARTON
chambers of Burton Bradley, a solicitor who had previously supervised his brother George, and who was to remain a friend for many years. Two years later, encouraged by Bradley’s good opinion and requiring training in both branches of the legal profession, he read with G. C. Davies, a successful but unremarkable barrister. In 1872 he was duly called to the New South Wales Bar. His first case thrust him into strong courtroom drama. He was retained as junior counsel defending a murder charge against a 20-year-old from ‘a most respectable family in England’, known as Lester or Froude. As accomplice to an older man, Nicholls, Lester waylaid at least two unsuspecting travellers whom Nicholls killed, and helped to dump the bodies in the Parramatta River. Crowds attended the trial of this sensational case. When the pair were found guilty they collapsed in the dock, Lester in floods of tears, so that four policemen had to hold them up while they were sentenced to hanging. Probably this case confirmed Barton’s aversion to the death penalty except in extreme circumstances. Criminal law was never his favourite branch of the profession, but in the years of his debut he needed any case that was going. Law was an overcrowded profession, and Edmund had neither influential friends nor relatives to smooth the path for him. His brother George’s career offering a rather bleak example of the pitfalls awaiting a young journalist, he must persevere with the law and become the maker of his own fortune. Nor could he count on the family support which sustained him during childhood and youth. Shortly before his sister Alice married and departed for England his parents moved to suburban Woollahra. Theirs was a suddenly depleted household, with only the two bachelor sons Henry and Edmund remaining. Mary Louisa re-established the ladies’ school in Woollahra, while old William Barton still practised as a stockbroker. He tended to plume himself as the founder of the profession in Sydney, but he was past 70 and left the running of the business to a partner. So much was he left behind by his younger colleagues that when the Sydney Stock Exchange was formally established in 1871 no one thought to invite him as a founder-member, although he joined some time later. Except for increasing trouble with his eyes, he seemed physically indestructible. It was otherwise with Mary Louisa, although she was fourteen years
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
14
152 × 230
M r M i c a w b e r ’s S o n 1 5
younger. Around 1870 she began to show signs of cardiac trouble. Having lived long enough to see her youngest son qualify as a barrister, she died on 4 May 1872, at the age of 63. This was the end of the household of which she had been the mainstay. Within a year the house at Woollahra was sold, the widower had gone to a married daughter in Brisbane, and his two sons moved into separate lodgings. Mary Louisa Barton’s had been the strength that held the family together. Even at 60 her energy was unabated. With her eleven children grown up she had taken on a widowed daughter’s little girl when her mother and stepfather went to Colombo, and when George’s wife in Dunedin succumbed to postnatal depression, she was off to New Zealand, taking the eight-year-old granddaughter with her, to put things to rights. A son-in-law remembered her as the most intelligent woman he ever met. With her teacher’s competence she undoubtedly provided much of the direction and the encouragement for Edmund’s impressive academic achievement. She must also have seemed a centre of emotional security, and it is significant that Edmund’s first and only serious courtship was with a young woman who in several important respects resembled her. Many years later, when he had become a national figure and prime minister, an old acquaintance wrote: ‘To this day he is awkward in the presence of ladies and blushes like a school girl. He has no small talk, no boyishness.’ Nobody ever accused him of philandering. As a father figure William was less satisfactory, even though he may have shared and encouraged many of the family’s cultural interests. Unlike George, Edmund apparently neither defied nor confronted him. At least once when William was very old Edmund defended him in extravagant language against George. Yet beneath this deference to the patriarch Edmund must have realised that the dignified facade was essentially a front to cover uncertainties and inadequacies. The same concern not to expose a father’s nakedness would be seen in his later relationship with senior figures such as Parkes. Probably it came to serve as a metaphor for the Australian relationship with Britain: the younger country should never show open rebellion or defiance, but should go on managing its own affairs on the unspoken assumption that the senior’s authority was an
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
15
152 × 230
16 EDMUND BARTON
inheritance to be respected but no longer an effective instrument of control. More than most parents, William Barton was already a man of yesterday. Whereas the parents of most of Edmund’s contemporaries would have seen themselves as early Victorians, evangelical, progressive, fascinated with technological improvement, William Barton was born in the eighteenth century and his character was formed in Regency London. In reminiscent old age he could touch an even more distant past, and would tell how his first employer, old Mr Barwise, wore to his dying day the powdered and pigtailed hair, the buckles and the silk stockings of the reign of George II. Something of that rationally benevolent, mildly sceptical, classically eloquent Georgian ambience filtered through to Edmund Barton. Alfred Deakin, whose mystical spiritualism was so remote from such a temperament, once compared Barton to Charles James Fox. This was apt enough. Both were corpulent, warm-hearted, sociable humans, fine orators, able but erratic in the conduct of business. Deakin may also have been recognising Barton’s strong grounding in Greek and Roman classics, and this may have suggested another comparison. The classical tradition was not merely the possession of Britain alone. The generation of late eighteenth-century Virginians and New Englanders who made the American Revolution and created the United States were deeply influenced by classical education. They brought to the task of nation-building an acute consciousness of Greek and Roman precedent. That same Greek and Roman precedent would become one of the subliminal influences in the shaping of an Australian nation. It was a result of Edmund Barton’s upbringing that, encouraged by his parents and taught by Badham, he would carry the resonances of this tradition inside himself while remaining always and unmistakably Australian.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
16
152 × 230
2
Young Australia Young Australia
F
OR FIVE years before his marriage in 1877, Edmund Barton’s life was divided between a succession of Sydney boarding houses and lengthy periods on circuit in the country. Jeanie and he must have exchanged dozens of letters but only a few survive. In October 1872 he was exercising all his considerable charm on Miss Home in Newcastle, asking for an extension of time for one of Jeanie’s visits to Sydney: ‘We are having the Equinoctial gales now: I’m sure the sea won’t be fit to travel in for some good many days.’ The aunt consented with some pleasant remarks on Edmund’s good heart and ability. It was as well, for with the breaking up of the family household Edmund relied on Jeanie for emotional warmth. ‘It is sweet to me to have someone’s sympathy when I stupidly despond at Fortune’s scurvy tricks’, he wrote in February 1873:
. . . and I know you are just as fond of my sympathy as I of you, and we both know that every pecuniary trouble is a hindrance to the accomplishment of our united happiness, while every little windfall is a help to its achievement.
Unhappily, few briefs came the way of the young barrister, and a month later he was despairing: . . . my prospects are worse than ever . . . you do not know the depth of my poverty, and the slenderness of my chances. You 17
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
17
152 × 230
18 EDMUND BARTON
deserve someone ten thousand times better than to waste your young years waiting for me to reach a goal which seems more distant every day.
But resilience kept breaking in: ‘. . . the University cricket club is keeping me busy’, he wrote, but added ‘I have so little in legal work that I am not neglecting my duty’. Cricket was indeed his main relaxation. After graduation he continued to play for the University club. His scores during 1872 were still modest—seven run out in one game, and eleven in a total of 119 in another—but he was confronting opponents such as Bannerman, Murdoch and the Gregory brothers. Sometimes he kept wicket. His finest hour came in 1873 when the University faced the nineteen-year-old Fred Spofforth, not yet deemed ‘the demon bowler’. Spofforth took nine wickets, seven by knocking down the stumps; Barton was the only batsman he did not dismiss. He was also a hardworking official. For three years (1872–74) he was club delegate to the New South Wales Cricket Association, and for five (1872–76) a member of the grounds committee, taking a leading part in negotiations which resulted in December 1873 in a university grant for improving the pitch. At the 1873 general meeting he was one of those who spoke against a proposal to admit graduates of other universities to the club. The debate can be seen as an early example of Barton’s preference for trusting local experience over the imported product, and the proposal was heavily defeated. Like many a young person since, Barton found valuable experience in public speaking, negotiations and committee work through sporting club activities, as well as establishing a network of friends and acquaintances who as graduates were entering the professional world. The 1870s were the first decade in which a majority of white adult Australians were native-born, and on the local scene the alumni of Sydney University were mature and numerous enough to make some impact on the public life of New South Wales. But this impact lay in the future, and meanwhile Edmund Barton had a living to earn. Jeanie Ross would wait seven years for her wedding. Edmund could not afford it earlier. Gradually his career advanced. By early 1875 he had chambers at 103 Elizabeth Street and was living in
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
18
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 1 9
Cumberland Street in the Rocks, not far from his old family home. Much of his time was spent on circuit in country districts. Travel in the mid-1870s was still primitive. It was only in 1876 that the railway over the Blue Mountains was extended as far as Bathurst, and this meant a lot of travelling by coach, jolting over rough roads, with accommodation at half-civilised country pubs. Such northern towns as Grafton and Lismore were visited by sea. These journeys brought Barton into contact with judges on circuit, some like the elderly Sir Alfred Stephen, vigorous and stimulating in conversation, others merely loquacious. So Barton gained his introduction to the rural New South Wales which he would have to canvass intensely more than twenty years later in the campaign for Federation. He was still surviving on tight margins, obliged from time to time to borrow a few pounds from his father and his brother Henry, an accountant no better off than himself. Edmund thought of seeking a steady salary in callings as various as parliamentary draftsman and crown prosecutor on the western district circuit, and actually secured a few months as acting crown prosecutor at Bathurst late in 1875. Following this experience he was asked back as counsel in the Bathurst quarter sessions in 1876 and 1877, and won some success as a defence lawyer. In March 1877 he secured the acquittal of an Aboriginal named Murray accused of horse stealing, an offence carrying a gaol penalty of up to ten years. In September he successfully defended a local storekeeper against a charge of wrongful dismissal. Fortified in his professional self-confidence he became less eager to seek the security of government employment, because such a post would be incompatible with his growing ambition to enter politics. When opportunity unexpectedly beckoned, it came, as previously his courtship and engagement had come, as a result of his cricketing activities. It arose out of one of the quaintest experiments in Australian politics. In Britain the graduates of the ancient universities of Oxford and Cambridge each enjoyed the right of sending two members to the House of Commons, and when new universities such as London came into being in the nineteenth century a seat was created for them. The New South Wales parliament legislated for a similar Legislative Assembly constituency for graduates of the
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
19
152 × 230
20 EDMUND BARTON
University of Sydney when their number reached 100 and, in 1876, the time arrived. Some graduates put forward William Windeyer. He was a very able lawyer, the first graduate to take a master’s degree, who had already served several years in parliament and shown an active and thoughtful interest in educational matters. He was however over 40, and a number of younger men did not agree with him, considering that Windeyer looked on the seat as his prerogative. The cricket club stalwarts were among the core of this faction (though, surprisingly, Barton’s staunch friend O’Connor was a Windeyer supporter). His cricketing friends invited Barton, then on circuit inland, to stand. Considering that at that time members of parliament received no salary it was a hazardous move, but Barton’s income had recently been improving a little, and he accepted. Three weeks of spirited campaigning followed. Both candidates were able and liberal-minded. Both, but Barton especially, wanted to improve the system of scholarships and secondary education so that university education might be accessible to the less well off. The choice largely turned on personalities, and here Barton was on the defensive. ‘Of Mr BARTON we know nothing’, complained the Sydney Morning Herald. In his policy speech, held in the unlikely environment of the Pitt Street Temperance Hall, Barton put up an able and witty defence. True he was young, but time would remedy that, and many eminent politicians, including Windeyer himself, had entered politics in their mid-twenties. Then he turned to another criticism which would dog him throughout his public career: Again he was told that he was not fitted to represent the University because there was about him a want of energy. He did not know what that assertion amounted to, and he was not aware whether the persons making this statement had studied his career from boyhood to the present time; but if they had they would yet have occasion to repent of their statement.
In a middle age punctuated by a sufficiency of good dinners, Barton’s alleged ‘want of energy’ could be glibly explained; but it was interesting to find the accusation made of him when he was only 27. Like many very clever young people, Barton took pains not to appear over-studious, cultivating the leisured manner; but like
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
20
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 2 1
very clever young people also he found that he could master large quantities of material in a short space of time, and this ability probably encouraged him to procrastinate. He tended to swing between periods of lassitude and periods of intense concentration. He usually managed to meet his commitments, sometimes brilliantly, but it was a worrying trait in the eyes of more systematic souls. The election took place in the Great Hall of the University on 8 Septemb er 1876. Following English custom, the Cha ncellor, Sir Edward Deas Thomson, who acted as returning officer, called for nominations. Windeyer and Barton were both proposed, and supporting speeches made. Thomson called for a show of hands and declared Windeyer the victor. As always happened on such occasions, the losing candidate called for a poll, (as any graduate was eligible to vote), which lasted six hours. At the end of the day Windeyer was the winner, but only by a margin of 49 votes to 43. The candidates exchanged well-turned compliments, and then it was back to the law for Barton. Windeyer was returned unopposed at the general election late in 1877. Barton was absorbed in preparations for his wedding, at last confident in his ability to support a wife and family. The marriage was celebrated on 28 December 1877 at the manse of the bride’s family Presbyterian church, St Andrew’s, Newcastle. It was unfortunately the hottest day of the season: ‘A dry scorching wind was blowing almost continuously, bringing up disagreeable clouds of sand and dust from all directions.’ It was unlikely that the bridal couple minded. It was Jeanie’s last day as a Presbyterian. Staunch adherent of the Kirk though she was, her aunt told her that she must adhere to her husband’s religion (not that Edmund, in his easygoing Anglican conformism, would have forced the issue). She left more than her church behind her; in later life Jeanie Barton prided herself that no trace of Scots dialect could be discerned in her accent. The next few years saw major family change. Early in 1878 Edmund and Jeanie set up house in Stanmore, then an outer suburb of Sydney. They did not have long to themselves. In that August Henry Barton died, a 36-year-old bachelor. About the same time the family agreed that old William should return from Brisbane and live
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
21
152 × 230
22 EDMUND BARTON
with Edmund and Jeanie in a larger house in Pitt Street, Redfern. Nearly 86 years of age, blind and suffering from renal disease, he died on 6 May 1881. He lived long enough to welcome the birth of two grandsons, Edmund Alfred in April 1879 and Wilfrid in October 1880 (the Bartons favoured Anglo-Saxon names for their sons) and also to know of Edmund’s eventual success in becoming a member of parliament. Once again Barton’s cricketing activities had something to do with the outcome. He was still on the University club committee in 1878 when, expansively for a newly married man of small means, he presented a trophy for the player with the best batting average. In 1879, when the rich amateur Lord Harris brought an England XI to tour the Australian colonies, Barton was nominated by New South Wales as umpire in Sydney. The England side brought as the other umpire an inexperienced young Victorian bowler, George Coulthard. On the first day, Friday 7 February, the England XI made 267 in the first innings and, having got New South Wales out for 177, enforced the follow-on. By 4.00 pm on the Saturday afternoon about 10 000 spectators were present, including several bookmakers dismayed at the prospect of an English win, and a considerable number of what the press described as ‘roughs and larrikins’ (but also the fifteen-year-old ‘Banjo’ Paterson). The hopes of New South Wales rested on Will Murdoch, who had carried his bat for 82 in the first innings. With the second innings score at one wicket for eighteen, Murdoch was given run out by umpire Coulthard. As Murdoch returned to the pavilion he was greeted by a mighty roar of ‘Not out! Go back!’ The Australian captain, Dave Gregory, demanded that Coulthard should be taken off. At this point an English fieldsman was heard to say: ‘What can you expect from the sons of convicts?’ At this the mob erupted on the ground. A few punches were swung, but as Lord Harris himself wrote: ‘Beyond kicking me slyly once or twice the mob behaved very well, their one cry being ‘‘Change the umpire!’’ ’ It took the police half an hour to escort the England side safely off the ground, and as Gregory still refused to play, Harris appealed to Barton and asked if he could claim the match according to the laws of cricket. Barton replied: ‘I shall give M
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
22
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 2 3
it to you in two minutes if the batsmen do not return.’ He persuaded Gregory to change his mind, but the crowd kept taking possession of the ground and rendered play impossible for the rest of the day. It rained incessantly for the rest of the weekend, so that on Monday the New South Wales team was all out for 49 on a murderously sticky wicket. Lengthy controversy resulted, from which Barton was one of the few to emerge with credit. His mediating style brought him into the public eye, and this soon had its political reward. In August, Windeyer was appointed to the Supreme Court bench and resigned as the University’s parliamentary representative. Several candidates were thought likely to come forward but, in the end, Barton was opposed only by Dr Arthur Renwick, an energetic physician with a strong interest in public health. The election was conducted in a spirit of amiable competition. The two candidates shared the same views, declaring themselves in favour of free trade, reformed land laws, free, secular and compulsory education, and the extension of the railway system into central Sydney. Both wanted the government to increase the University’s endowment. The contest lay largely between advocates of a medical school and those with other priorities. Barton’s youth and lack of means were still seen by some as an impediment. Professor Badham, a Renwick supporter, hinted gently at the problem: Mr Barton was a young man, much and worthily esteemed, but he had not yet won his spurs. The world was before him, and there was a degree of risk he would be buffeted about and his judgment warped when his private interests were involved in some important public matter.
Prophetic words, as Barton would learn in later years as attorneygeneral; but for the present he rejected them vigorously: It has been said that he is not independent, and that he desired to enter the Assembly to obtain a position from the Crown. This was not the case . . . The Crown had already offered him a position, which he had declined in order that he might be free to seek to represent the University.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
23
152 × 230
24 EDMUND BARTON
A show of hands at the election meeting decided in Barton’s favour. This was confirmed at a poll by a margin of 73 votes to 45. On 31 October 1879 Edmund Barton Esquire, Master of Arts, took the oath of allegiance as member of the Legislative Assembly for the University of Sydney. He showed a cool nonchalance in that he put in his appearance four days after the beginning of the parliamentary session at which the Legislative Assembly was notified, according to the Sydney Morning Herald, of the return of Mr Edwin Barton. The Herald evidently still knew nothing of him. Barton entered a legislature which had been in existence for 23 years. Although drawing on the centuries-old traditions of Westminster, the New South Wales parliament, housed in a former hospital financed by the colonial thirst for rum, had early developed a character of its own. Where politics in Britain had evolved into a classic two-party system, Liberals versus Conservatives, a similar clarity was hard to establish in the more mobile society of postgoldrush New South Wales. The quality of a member of parliament was judged by his ability to win for his district or suburb a generous outlay of government money on railways, telegraphs, post offices, schools and other public works. Some found they could exercise pressure best as Independents and made a virtue of their lack of commitment. Others attached themselves to the shifting factions formed around dominant personalities, their loyalties determined by various blends of regional, commercial, religious and personal sympathies. By the time Barton entered parliament, two great survivors, Sir Henry Parkes and Sir John Robertson, were acknowledged as the master politicians. Both were over 60. Parkes, an English workingclass migrant, was a cunning tactician and a resilient leader, with a strain of grandiosity which fed dreams of statesmanship but also, unhappily, aspirations as country gentleman and poet; as one English observer wrote: ‘His debts, his poetry are powerless to sink him.’ Robertson cultivated a more earthy Australian persona, his picturesque profanity enhanced by a cleft palate and a strong head for liquor. In reality he was no philistine, but unlike Parkes he did not wear his culture on his sleeve. Having sparred in the Legislative Assembly for 20 years, the two white-bearded veterans formed a
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
24
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 2 5
coalition in December 1878, with Parkes as premier and Robertson leader in the upper house. Supported by a handsome majority, they brought four years of stability to New South Wales politics. The Parkes–Robertson coalition required no major change of political faith for either party. Apart from a few remnants of the pastoral and landowning conservatives surviving in the Legislative Council, an upper house whose members were nominated for life, most prominent politicians described themselves as ‘liberal’. Like the Liberals in Britain they put their faith in free trade, that doctrine of low tariffs which suited primary producers and the importers of Sydney, and looked askance at experiments in Victoria aimed at developing manufacturing behind the screen of protective duties. Colonial liberalism in its New South Wales form consisted largely of supporting reforms which would allow a society of migrants and their children the means of self-betterment. Children were entitled to literacy and primary education, and their parents should have the opportunity of acquiring yeoman independence through cheap land. Unfortunately, both generous aims left plenty of scope for disagreement. Sectarianism bedevilled the education question in every Australian colony, but nowhere more than in New South Wales. Many, though not all, Catholics feared that a State school system founded on religious impartiality would in fact produce godless children rejecting the influence of their faith and clergy. As elsewhere in Australia, many church schools were established in competition with the government schools. To avoid duplication and inefficiency, the New South Wales government in 1866 set up a Council of Education to administer and fund all schools, government or denominational. Rules were designed to check oversupply and ensure minimum standards. Parkes was the architect of this compromise. The Catholic bishops were never happy with it, and their mistrust of Parkes deepened when he took a strident anti-Irish line after the attempted assassination of Queen Victoria’s son, the Duke of Edinburgh, in March 1868. Although Parkes tried to cultivate Catholic allies during the 1870s, the rift never healed. Pressure mounted as rapid population growth stimulated demand for more schools. A vocal lobby demanded that New South Wales should follow
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
25
152 × 230
26 EDMUND BARTON
Victoria’s example and cease funding denominational schools. In rebuttal a new and vigorous Catholic archbishop, Roger Bede Vaughan, went on the attack against the State schools. By 1879 it was clear that Parkes, with a strong majority behind him, would have to resolve the dilemma. He declared for free, secular and compulsory education, following the Victorian precedent and leaving the church schools to battle for their own resources. The land laws were as central to Robertson’s being as education was to Parkes. Robertson was famed as the author of the 1861 Act which enabled intending farmers to select lands at £1 an acre on pastoral leases or other unimproved Crown land before official survey took place. This early example of dual title was anathema to the pastoralists, who in some districts used every trick in the book to thwart the ‘free selectors’. They bought the freehold of safe watering points, thus locking up the surrounding country. They purchased blocks in the names of their infant children or other dummy nominees, or else found themselves blackmailed by ‘free selectors’ who took up choice areas on pastoral land to hold the squatter to ransom. Even in districts where bona fide farmers established themselves, it often ended with one successful operator buying out his neighbours and sometimes turning grazier. Robertson’s Land Act was not the unmitigated failure that its critics made out, but it was no advertisement for the yeoman ideal. Change was difficult nonetheless, because successive governments found the windfall gains from land sales too useful in buoying up New South Wales revenue and thus avoiding any need to increase tariffs or impose direct taxation. Increasingly the critics fretted that it was unwise to sell off the national estate to meet current expenses, but Robertson remained convinced that his system was near-perfect. All he required of the coalition was minor amendments, extending the period of occupancy before selectors might sell their land and easing their conditions as compensation. In his first parliamentary session in 1879–80 Barton as member for the University of Sydney thought it appropriate to act as an Independent. He supported the coalition over Parkes’ 1880 legislation to end State aid for church schools and to establish free, compulsory and secular education, believing with many Australians
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
26
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 2 7
of his generation that this would bring opportunity to all children. In his maiden speech he rebutted Archbishop Vaughan’s alarmist comments on the State school system: I must say that I do strongly resent the statement that the system under which I have grown up is calculated to produce infidelity, immorality, or lawlessness . . . but if the prelate descends to make statements like this, and supplements them by saying that he is ready to shed his blood in defence of the views he propounds and goes on almost to express the wish to be disembowelled, it is right that I, who have been educated under the system so sweepingly condemned, should say a word or two in its defence . . .
Those educated in the State schools and the secular University of Sydney, said Barton, were ‘upright and God-fearing citizens’. For Barton the government did not go far enough, and he later supported an opposition resolution to reduce school fees, and protested against inequalities in the career path of teachers. On the other hand, his first speech took the form of criticising the land laws as discriminating against genuine free selectors in favour of graziers, and in 1880 he opposed a government proposal for a tax on wool because of its effect on export markets. Instead, in the manner of many novice politicians he preferred to cut government spending. Altogether he made a judicious start to his parliamentary career, speaking not too often and with careful preparation, although probably few of his colleagues appreciated his habit of garnishing his speeches with Greek and Latin quotations. Among the overdue issues tackled by the Parkes–Robertson coalition was electoral redistribution. To match recent increases in population the government proposed almost to double the size of the Legislative Assembly. At the same time, however, the University seat would be abolished as an anomalous piece of privilege. Barton of course argued against this potential check to his political career, but in vain. Fortunately the expansion of parliament meant that many seats were looking for members. Rural constituencies lacking prominent citizens with time or money to spend on politics sometimes found it convenient to look for a bright young city lawyer
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
27
152 × 230
28 EDMUND BARTON
who might represent their interests. One such was Wellington, a farming community between Bathurst and Dubbo, but their member John Shepherd never came near them, and after unfavourable publicity in a notorious divorce case, dropped temporarily out of politics. The local solicitor, Will Chauncy, was Barton’s close friend, and probably through his influence Barton replaced Shepherd. In November 1880 he was returned without opposition on the nomination of two local aldermen. ‘The proceedings’, we are told, ‘were very orderly’. The Parkes–Robertson coalition was returned with what appeared a secure majority. It seemed as if the opposition would be as weak and divided as it had been in the previous parliament. Its leading figure, Michael Fitzpatrick, a retired public servant, was experienced and persistent, but carried the handicap of being a Catholic who disagreed with his clergy on the education question. (When he died in September 1881 he was denied Catholic burial rites.) More significantly for the future, the 1880 elections brought into the Legislative Assembly a number of new men who gave general support to the coalition but were not committed for the long term. The most striking debut of all was made by George Reid, at 35 already portly and heavy-moustached, who in the four-member constituency of East Sydney topped the poll ahead of Dr Arthur Renwick and Sir Henry Parkes. Reid’s successful campaign showed rare tactical skill, as well as a readiness to challenge Parkes for forgetting his humble origins. Two others who in time would follow Reid in attaining the premiership were William Lyne, a tall, lean Tasmanian, once an overlander and later a successful breeder of Lincoln sheep, commencing a long career as a member for the Riverina free-selector community; and John See, a Clarence River yeoman thriving in Sydney as produce merchant and shipping owner, and thus credited with financial shrewdness. The younger generation was beginning to move into position. During 1881 and 1882 Barton, even in the eyes of an admirer, did not ‘take a brilliant part in Parliamentary proceedings’. He spoke a dozen times on a miscellany of subjects. Still a spokesman for the University, he secured the abolition of compulsory examinations for Master of Arts candidates. He favoured the opening of museums and
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
28
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 2 9
the Art Gallery on Sundays, the provision of public recreation areas for sporting activities, and the reform of the liquor laws (on which he spoke with authority, urging that wine-shops should not be closed down, even though ‘in some of them an inferior article was sold’). He took a generally humane view on legal issues, supporting the commutation of the death sentence on a schoolmaster who raped an eleven-year-old girl, insisting on the need for proper legal representation of criminals, and criticising the ‘disregard of the rights of women’ in the English laws which held that a woman could not divorce her husband for adultery though a man might divorce his wife. And the Australian nationalist in him gave strong support to the preservation of Captain Cook’s landing place in Botany Bay as ‘an act of patriotism’. But he took no part in the great debate of 1881 on Chinese immigration or in the increasing barrage of criticism of the land laws during that year, which caused Reid to break conclusively with the coalition and go into opposition. Barton’s family responsibilities absorbed some of his energies. With the birth in April 1882 of a daughter, Jean Alice (known as ‘Muffie’), there were now three small children in the household. In addition old William Barton died intestate, and his affairs proved unexpectedly difficult to disentangle. Edmund’s legal practice continued to expand, with retainers coming from nearly a dozen country solicitors. Among his clients he numbered the colliery estates of the deceased Mr Justice Hargrave, whose son Lawrence was already deeply engrossed in experimenting with models for a heavier-thanair flying machine. Barton was a keenly interested spectator of some of Lawrence Hargrave’s experimental trials. In his quixotic persistence in pursuing a goal which many thought unattainable, Hargrave may have provided a role-model for the Barton who would take up the quest for Federation a few years later. He was no longer so absorbed in the University cricket club, but in 1882 he was elected a member of the Senate, the University’s governing body, and with one short interval retained that position till his death. The sociable relaxation previously found in cricket was provided by membership of the newly established Athenaeum Club. Modelled on the London club of the same name, the Athenaeum sought its membership among men of affairs, academics and creative
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
29
152 × 230
30 EDMUND BARTON
artists of broad intellectual interests. Its foundation members in 1881 included J. R. Fairfax, the proprietor of the Sydney Morning Herald, and Dr Andrew Garran, its editor, Lucien Brient, news editor of the Daily Telegraph, and J. F. Archibald of the Bulletin among the journalists, the merchant William (‘Good Iron Mac’) McMillan, and William Bede Dalley from politics. Barton was elected in the following year. A few years later followed his friend O’Connor. The Athenaeum was to be a pleasurable environment for Barton for many years, eventually too pleasurable, although it was not yet possible to say of Barton, as Alfred Deakin later wrote: ‘At no time and in no sense intemperate, his genial, affectionate nature made him so companionable that he spent many hours in his club chair which could have been more profitably spent in his chambers or his study.’ Parliament resumed in August 1882 after an unusually long recess caused by Parkes’ absence on an overseas tour hobnobbing with the great in Britain and North America. The opposition chose the respected merchant Alexander Stuart as their leader, but it was Reid who was their cutting edge. Parkes and Robertson, he claimed, ‘had not the same keen sympathy with the masses of the people they once had’. Confronted with Reid’s denunciation of the land laws, Robertson responded by bringing in a bill to consolidate the existing legislation, though without addressing any of the mounting criticisms against it. Stuart moved into attack, arguing that the land laws bred dishonesty, set class against class, and handed over large areas of land to great financial corporations. Reid followed, demanding a comprehensive inquiry into the working of the land laws. Barton supported him, using his personal observations while travelling the country on circuit to argue that ‘something must be done to place the Land Laws on a more equitable, smooth working basis’, otherwise ‘even more evils would result in the future’. As it happened he was not in the Assembly when Robertson forced a snap division on the issue, but it did not matter. The coalition was beaten by 43 votes to 33. Parliament was dissolved on 17 November 1882 and Parkes appealed to the electorate. In the four-member constituency of East Sydney, Reid was ready for him, having drawn up a ticket of four candidates pledged to reform of the land laws. Barton was second on the
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
30
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 3 1
ticket, together with John McElhone, an obstreperous populist independent who represented the Catholic vote, and George Griffiths, a stock and station agent with no parliamentary experience and a man of few words. In those days elections took nearly a fortnight, with polling in different electorates on different days. East Sydney, the first to go to the polls, was commonly regarded as the premier constituency of New South Wales, and required campaigning on a far more massive scale than Barton had needed among the gentlemanly voters of the University or the docile citizens of Wellington. There was a strong element of theatre in election contests, especially in large urban constituencies. Parliamentary candidates could expect to confront audiences of hundreds or even thousands, almost entirely male. Without any form of media technology it was expected they would speak at length, for an hour or even longer, discussing the issues of the day with enough point to hold their audiences by sheer force of oratory. Eloquence was not enough, however, for speeches would often be interrupted by hecklers, and a politician’s popularity depended to some extent on his skill at repartee in handling interruptions. A hostile gathering might boo or groan so noisily as to bring a speech to a premature end, while a speaker who won over his hearers might be greeted with tumultuous cheers lasting several minutes. The political arena of the 1880s was no environment for the faint-hearted. At the nomination meeting on Tuesday 28 November an immense crowd, estimated as not far short of 14 000, attended the hustings in Hyde Park. ‘There was a considerable amount of excitement,’ reported the Herald, ‘but good humour prevailed on the whole.’ Renwick and Parkes spoke first to a mixed reception; then, after Griffiths made a short speech it was Barton’s turn. He struck a new note: Mr BARTON, who was received with loud cheers, said that if anything could increase the encouragement he had received in his candidature it would be the splendid reception that has been accorded him on this occasion. (Cheers). He felt that it needed no apology for an Australian to come forward and propound what he believed to be intelligent views.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
31
152 × 230
32 EDMUND BARTON Edmund Barton at the time of his first election for East Sydney, 1882. (The Bulletin, 2/12/1882)
An Australian speaking to Australians, Barton took his audience through the land laws, the liquor laws and the need for civil service reform. He urged the provision of technical education and a new art gallery, and in conclusion reverted to the Australian theme: ‘He appealed to the electors . . . because at this juncture they wanted countrymen of their own who believed in the future of the country (Cheers).’ Reid followed with some rousing knockabout comedy, and
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
32
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 3 3
McElhone continued in the same vein. Thus fortified, the candidates embarked on two days of intensive campaigning across East Sydney, considerably to the detriment of Barton’s voice. The poll was declared on Thursday evening, the 30th. The Herald’s description was vivid: Shortly before 6 o’clock, by which time many thousands of people had assembled in front of the hustings, a very heavy shower of rain fell, but in spite of this the crowd seemed to increase rather than diminish. So great was the assemblage that its movements were in appearance like the waves of the sea, and so enormous was the pressure on one occasion when the crowd surged towards the hustings that the timber barrier, which had been put up to keep the people back, was snapped like matchwood, and the police behind almost overturned. Now and then a fight occurred, but . . . the combatants were obliged to pummel each other in a space so small that when one or other of them fell he was in considerable danger of being smothered.
The returning officer thrust his way forward and announced the result. Once again Reid topped the poll with 3044 votes, followed by Barton 2948, Griffiths 2367, McElhone 2307. Parkes, Renwick, and their supporter Alderman Green were defeated. Mr REID proposed, and Mr BARTON seconded, a vote of thanks to the Returning-officer and, this having been accorded by the crowd, three cheers were given for the Queen, and the proceedings terminated.
Young Australia, in the persons of Reid and Barton, had challenged the older generation in the first constituency of New South Wales, and won a striking victory. A wily and tenacious campaigner like Parkes did not give up easily. According to his own account, ten electorates invited him to stand as solace for East Sydney’s rejection. Within four days he was returned unopposed for Tenterfield. Several of his cabinet were defeated, albeit narrowly, and at Mudgee Sir John Robertson, although successful, had to take second place to an unknown, a
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
33
152 × 230
34 EDMUND BARTON
gangling 25-year-old journalist named Adolphus George Taylor. Parkes blamed the sectarian issue for his setback. The Catholics, already antagonised by free, secular and compulsory education, were further alienated by his reforms to the liquor laws. These, by introducing ‘local option’ and thus pleasing the temperance lobby, went against the interests of the many publicans who were IrishAustralians. At the New Year, when all the results were in, Parkes wrote to the governor, Lord Augustus Loftus, on the day before the Legislative Assembly was due to meet, offering his ministry’s resignation. He told Loftus that although the public had returned a majority opposed to Robertson’s land legislation, there was an equal or greater majority against Stuart’s land policy: In Parliament the feeling of Members is so largely in our favour that I incline to the option that if we were to wait for an adverse motion, the Opposition would fail to carry such a motion. But . . . we desire to be relieved from office as speedily as may be consistent with a due regard for the public exigencies.
Parkes’ words suggest strongly that he expected that Stuart, many of whose supporters were new and untried, would not be able to put together a viable ministry. In the ensuing confusion parliament might yet turn to the old maestro to take charge. Reid saw that in order to consolidate Stuart’s following it would be necessary to force a vote in parliament on the first pretext. This meant challenging the re-election of the Speaker. In recent decades the British House of Commons had come to regard the Speaker as a figure above party who, once chosen, remained in office unchallenged until death or resignation. This convention did not catch on in the Australian colonies because Australian legislatures were much smaller than the House of Commons, so that governments were obliged more often to rely on the Speaker’s casting vote. In an age without payment of members, the speakership was a coveted, well-rewarded and dignified office. It was nevertheless unusual for a respected Speaker to be opposed, once in office, and the current Speaker, Sir George Wigram Allen, had been more than seven years in the chair. Although dignified and discreet, Allen was not a strong
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
34
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 3 5
Speaker, and was considered a partisan of the Parkes–Robertson coalition. At a meeting of opposition members two hours before the opening of parliament, Reid persuaded his colleagues that Allen must be opposed. After rapid consultation Edmund Barton was put forward. He was an adroit choice. Unlike Reid, he had not gained a reputation for hard-fighting partisanship. His contributions to debate were always thoughtful, their scholarly polish roughed up a little by healthy relish for sport, sociability and a clear sense of Australian identity. It may have cost Barton a pang to oppose a senior such as Allen, old enough to be his father, a rich lawyer and landowner (he owned a good deal of Barton’s birthplace, the suburb of Glebe), mildly philanthropic, a patron of the University cricket club and the Speaker who had sworn Barton in as a new member little more than three years ago. But he showed no hesitation in accepting, and at the opening of parliament on 3 January 1883 a motion to reinstate Allen as Speaker was beaten by 51 votes to 47. Barton was then selected unanimously. At not quite 34 years old he was the youngest presiding officer ever chosen by an Australian legislature. Barton was lucky. Reid’s choice of him as running-mate in East Sydney gave him unprecedented public exposure, just as Reid nudged him towards his bid for speakership. The luck came Barton’s way only after a decade of apprenticeship during which the diffident novice lawyer, unsure of his future, had gained substantially in experience and confidence. His ability and education had been reinforced by ten years of mixing with all sorts and conditions of Australians in Sydney and in the bush, and his inner balance fortified by a happy marriage following a supportive upbringing. He could confront crowds of thousands on the cricket ground or the hustings with the same genial self-possession as he showed in the sociable talk of the Athenaeum Club. It was now time for him to step forward on the public stage as, in his own terms, an unapologetic Australian. The Sydney Bulletin, then in the vigour of its nationalistic youth, read the omens boldly: Sir George Allen represents the school of politicians which studied to rule Australia by imported and adopted methods. But
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
35
152 × 230
36 EDMUND BARTON
the day has dawned when Australia shall be governed by Australians, and the preference shown by a majority of the present Assembly for Mr Edmund Barton is the first gun which marks the commencement of the war between the new system and the old. Mr Barton represents the Young Australian party— the party of progress, of downright plain-speaking, of vigour preferred to fuss, of talent before wealth, of energy before conventional immobility.
And the editorial ended prophetically: ‘. . . the triumph of Young Australia in its own house cannot be long postponed.’ There were good reasons why the triumph of young Australia had been long delayed. Australia for much of the nineteenth century can be best understood as an archipelago of city-states—Sydney, Hobart, Brisbane, Melbourne, Adelaide—each with its own hinterland, and each founded at different periods by a different crosssection of British and Irish stock. The jealousies which divided the colonies were as potent as their ties in common. During the 1850s Victoria and Queensland were severed from New South Wales, and in 1863 South Australia took over the Northern Territory. Although the boundaries separating the Australian colonies were lines drawn on blank maps by clerks in the Colonial Office in London, they assumed reality as New South Wales, Queensland, South Australia and Tasmania competed to catch up with fortunate, golden Victoria, and Western Australia languished in backward convictism. By the 1870s Victoria, anxious to protect fledgling industries nourished by gold, was imposing tariffs, and the other colonies except New South Wales gradually followed. Parochialism flourished. A broader vision never quite died, however. Even before the Australasian colonies gained self-government, the advantages of cooperative federation were urged by Earl Grey, a British politician whose misfortune it was to state sensible truths so disagreeably that they went unregarded. In later years, as the colonies began to raise loans on the London money market, the British saw a federated Australia as a safeguard against the risk that an individual colony might default—as happened long afterwards in 1932 when the radical premier of New South Wales, Jack Lang, during the depths of the Great Depression, suspended interest payments to British
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
36
152 × 230
Yo u n g A u s t r a l i a 3 7
bondholders, and the Australian Commonwealth intervened. But the views of Britain counted for very little in making Australians federation-minded. Within Australia Henry Parkes at intervals urged that some formal mechanism for mutual consultation was necessary for the Australian colonies to confront common problems. As early as 1867, perhaps stimulated by the confederation of Canada in that year, he persuaded the New South Wales parliament to accept a bill for a federal council. ‘I do not startle your imagination,’ he said then, ‘by asking you to look for the footsteps of six young giants in the morning dew.’ But the young giants were not yet ready. Federation, it was said, remained a word ‘as soothing as the sound of church bells in the distance, and equally unprovocative of action’. In 1880–81 an intercolonial conference on the question of Chinese immigration once again enabled Parkes to secure endorsement of the idea of a federal council, though without the timetable or funding for its introduction. Though the politicians moved slowly, an Australian national consciousness was coming into being, as the Bulletin’s comment on Barton’s victory showed. His election as Speaker brought him to the fore in the very year that events in Australia’s vicinity were to kindle the federal idea.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
37
152 × 230
3
‘Mr Speaker’ ‘Mr Speaker’
B
ARTON WAS now maturing into the public face of his next 20 years in politics. Clean-shaven except for legal sideburns (he experimented briefly with a moustache, never a beard), he was beginning to put on weight, his oarsman’s muscles no longer exercised in a sedentary life. His first two years as Speaker covered a period of political stability. Parkes soon went away on another lengthy overseas journey and in his absence the opposition languished. This gave a breathing-space to Stuart’s largely inexperienced ministry. Its ablest member, the attorney-general, William Bede Dalley, was in poor health and sat in the Upper House. The treasurer, George Dibbs, although nearly 50, retained the salty vigour of a man whose career was spent in seafaring and stevedoring. Gaining publicity as a redoubtable opponent of Parkes over the employment of Chinese labour in coastal shipping, he was the hero of a libel case which had earned him a short term in gaol; but he was as well the survivor of more than one bankruptcy, and inherited a seriously deteriorating trend in public finance. Reid made an able start as minister for public instruction, but early in 1884 he was forced to go to a by-election and, for the only time in his career, suffered a narrow defeat which kept him out of politics for eighteen months. The contentious ministry of lands went to an ex-premier, James Farnell, who addressed the free-selection question by appointing two retired pastoralists as a commission of
38
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
38
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 39
inquiry. They unearthed, as expected, a sorry tale of perjury and inefficiency resulting from the Robertson land acts. On the basis of their report the Stuart government prepared legislation guaranteeing pastoralists security of leasehold over part of their land while leaving the remainder open for closer settlement. Despite stonewalling by Robertson and his allies the new Land Act was proclaimed in 1884. Unfortunately, by putting an end to land auctions while the new legislation went through, the Stuart ministry deprived itself of a major source of revenue, and this was soon to cause problems. Barton presided over these debates successfully. Even the Daily Telegraph, a supporter of the Parkes–Robertson coalition, admired the energy with which he quickly imposed order on proceedings. This good first impression continued throughout the year, with journals as diverse as the Bulletin and the Sydney Morning Herald praising the watchful vigour, firmness and tact with which he maintained order. The New South Wales Legislative Assembly, partly because of the lack of firm party discipline, was a notoriously rowdy and unruly body whose members were known sometimes to resort to fisticuffs. Members such as McElhone or the land speculator Robert Wisdom (himself a disappointed aspirant to the speakership) indulged themselves uninhibitedly unless brought to heel by a resolute and well informed presiding officer. Barton, with his experience of turbulent cricket crowds, quickly gained a mastery over the House. Imperturbable, well read in precedent, and patient, he was soon perceived on all sides as impartial and fair. More than any of the old stagers, it was a new member who caused him most trouble. Adolphus George Taylor of Mudgee was a raw and challenging example of Young Australia, his style very different from Barton’s. Eight years younger than Barton, the lanky Taylor was a formidably self-educated country youth frustrated by poverty from pursuing a legal career. After an insubordinate employment history as pupil-teacher and artilleryman he found his niche as a country editor before making a striking debut in the Legislative Assembly. At a public meeting in March 1883 he claimed that he had seen 35 members of the House drunk while it was in session. His outraged colleagues howled for a retraction, and Barton had his work cut out ensuring that proper procedures were followed
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
39
152 × 230
40 EDMUND BARTON
before Taylor made his apology. Unabashed, Taylor himself appeared in the House several times the worse for liquor, careless in his invective but seldom too drunk to argue subtle and time-consuming points of order. He was a nuisance, but an able and well-informed nuisance, and Barton occasionally found himself upholding Taylor’s objections. Barton quickly went about reinforcing the Speaker’s authority. He consciously followed the model of the House of Commons, where the arrival of a large phalanx of Irish nationalists in 1880 had raised the parliamentary temperature and led to the strengthening of the Speaker’s powers. Barton persuaded the New South Wales legislature informally to adopt the House of Commons practices which empowered the Speaker to draw attention to irrelevant and repetitious debate and to move for the suspension of incorrigible offenders. He placed great stress on the impartiality of the Chair, refusing while Speaker to lobby ministers for favours for his constituency (which, as East Sydney was a four-member seat, was no cause for grievance), and introducing the practice of making an explanatory statement to the House if he had to deliver a casting vote. On the whole members accepted the changes, though with some misgivings about how they might be used by a Speaker more partisan than Barton. He looked after the interests of his staff. Within two months of taking office he lodged a complaint because the estimates of government expenditure for the forthcoming year had not been submitted to him, and succeeded in getting some salary increases for staff on the supplementary estimates. In 1884, with the passing of a new Civil Service Act, he made sure that the Speaker had the same status as a cabinet minister over staffing matters. Consistency then required that the Speaker should have the same salary as a minister, increasing from £1200 to £1500. In committee Barton himself moved that the figure should remain at £1200, but the majority of his colleagues considered that the duties of his post were too onerous to require such a quixotic gesture, and they supported the rise by 35 votes to 22. One of the strongest supporters of the rise was A. G. Taylor, who said the amount should be £2000. This did not prevent him from becoming disruptive later the same evening, so that Barton suspended him from the House for a week.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
40
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 41 Personal Service. Mudgee Taylor gets the ugliest bailiff he can produce to serve his writ on the Speaker. (A reference to Taylor v. Barton.) The bailiff is, of course, A.G. Taylor himself. (The Bulletin, 28/6/1884)
Arguing that the Speaker lacked power to impose such a penalty, Taylor twice attempted to take his seat during the ensuing week, and each time was removed by the sergeant-at-arms at Barton’s command. Taylor then took legal proceedings against the sergeant-at-arms for assault and against Barton for exceeding his authority. In December 1884 the Supreme Court of New South Wales found that the Speaker indeed lacked power to suspend members for more than a single sitting. With government backing Barton launched an appeal to the Privy Council, evidently confident that the authorities in London would have a sounder judgment of the powers needed to maintain parliamentary decorum. Barton possessed a public manner and style which enabled him easily to take over from the sage and senior Wigram Allen as a spokesman for Parliament on ceremonial occasions. In this role he had a good deal to do with a distinguished visitor, the Earl of Rosebery, who with his wife Hannah (née Rothschild) visited Australia between November 1883 and January 1884. Two years older than Barton, Rosebery had been at the right hand of the veteran British prime minister William Gladstone when he came out of
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
41
152 × 230
42 EDMUND BARTON
retirement in the dramatic ‘Midlothian campaign’ which swept his Liberals back to office in 1880. Regarded as the rising star of his party, Rosebery was much more interested in the British colonies than most of the Liberals, and undertook his visit as part of a world tour for first-hand experience of the major members of the Empire. Although sometimes seen as aloof and patrician at home, Rosebery in Australia was geniality itself, an interested and intelligent observer of all he saw. He enjoyed the Athenaeum Club so much that he bought premises in Castlereagh Street and leased them to the Club on ‘very reasonable terms’ so that the facilities could be upgraded. Apart from a memorable fishing party on Sydney Harbour hosted by Dibbs, and a ‘very merry’ private lunch hosted by the mayor of Sydney, Barton was with Rosebery on a number of formal occasions, culminating in a major parliamentary dinner on 10 December 1883. Rosebery’s Sydney visit coincided with a major constitutional event. Representatives of the six Australian colonies, New Zealand and Fiji were meeting to discuss closer cooperation, perhaps even the long-delayed concept of a federal council. This followed Queensland’s single-handed attempt earlier in 1883 to annex the eastern half of New Guinea, a no man’s land where Australian commercial interests were growing. The gesture was meant as a pre-emptive strike to fend off annexation by Germany or France, but in London the Gladstone government, preoccupied with the European balance of power, refused to support the brash colonials. Nor was Downing Street sympathetic with Australian disquiet because France was using New Caledonia as a convict colony, thus at once stirring recollections of Australia’s own clouded past and nourishing an uneasiness about France which persisted into a nuclear future. Such recalcitrance stimulated Queensland and Victoria into urging the need for a unified Australasian voice which might spur the laggardly British into greater activity in the South Pacific; and thus the delegates came to meet for ten days at the beginning of December 1883. Reynolds conjectures, not unreasonably, that ‘Barton’s practical interest in Australian Federation took a definite form at this period’. As he was not a government minister Barton could not be a delegate—the New South Wales representatives were Stuart as premier,
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
42
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 43
and his senior cabinet ministers Dibbs and Dalley—but he attended proceedings as Stuart’s guest before proceeding at 4.30 pm to his duties in the Legislative Assembly. He would have observed the leading part played by the new premier of Queensland, Samuel Walker Griffith, who had gone through the University of Sydney a few years ahead of him. Griffith, already a renowned legal draftsman, steered resolutions through the Convention asking the British government (subject to the approval of the colonial parliaments) to authorise the creation of an Australasian Federal Council with two delegates from each participating government. The council would meet every two years to discuss cooperation over legal and criminal matters, to frame common policies over fisheries beyond territorial waters, and above all to agree on policies over relations with the Pacific islands. All the delegates agreed to what seemed a strikingly constructive advance in mutual cooperation. When, on 10 December 1883, Barton took the chair at the crowded parliamentary dinner in honour of Rosebery and the remaining delegates to the Convention, his remarks in proposing Rosebery’s health did not dwell on federation. He commented on the aptness of Rosebery’s presence ‘when the representatives of civilised Australasia were here met in conference . . . upon matters of national and world-wide moment’, and forecast that the outcome must have its impact on the development of the British Empire. The bulk of his speech looked at two issues much in debate in Britain at that time, education and local government, and explored the ways in which Australian experience might be instructive for Britain and vice versa. It was left to Rosebery to declare: ‘. . . if you have any sort of federation, we have some sort of united voice to answer . . . the broad voice of united Australia which is entitled to respect not merely in Great Britain but in the civilised world. (Cheers)’. He also proclaimed, amid more cheers, that ‘the destiny of Australia was to be the trustee of the Pacific’. It was the visiting British aristocrat, and not the native Australian who thus defined the vision of Australian federation. In future years Rosebery did not forget Barton, if only because in opening his speech he was able to begin with the phrase ‘Mr Speaker’; an ambition previously denied him because, having inherited his title while still under age, he had never
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
43
152 × 230
44 EDMUND BARTON
been able to sit in the House of Commons. Perhaps it was Rosebery’s speech rather than the Convention which set Barton thinking federally. At this stage of his career Barton was still speaking and behaving like a man who gave priority to the British connection. He expressed no public dismay when the Federal Council scheme immediately ran into difficulties following an indiscreet speech by the Victorian premier, James Service, who at the banquet marking his return to Melbourne bragged of how Victoria and Queensland had dragged a torpid New South Wales into the federal agreement. More substantially, the politicians of free-trade New South Wales began to fear the loss of control over their economy if they linked federally with the protectionist Victorians, who had already suggested that the Federal Council might be funded from land revenue—a source of income more precious in free-trade New South Wales than anywhere else in Australia. Parkes, too, on returning from overseas, turned against the Federal Council as inadequate for its purpose, a mere impediment to a stronger federation. When in October 1884 the Federal Council Bill came before the Legislative Assembly it was rejected by a one-vote margin. This meant that when the Federal Council came into being in 1885 it lacked New South Wales as well as South Australia and New Zealand—though Fiji joined. Barton as Speaker was not required to vote, but he later declared himself ‘an uncompromising opponent of the Federal Council Bill which the other colonies were endeavouring to ram down the throat of New South Wales’. The federation he would favour would be one that would involve a grea t scheme—milita ry and fisca l—which would strengthen the link with the mother country. And he was prepared to work to such an end; but would never consent to the establishment of a tag and rag federation.
In his suspicions of Victorian fiscal policy he was but one of a large number of New South Wales politicians, among them Parkes, Stuart and Dibbs, not to say old parochials like Sir John Robertson with his constant gibing at the ‘cabbagepatch’ Victoria. It was in
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
44
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 45
his emphasis on Australian federation as strengthening the British Empire that the Barton of the mid-1880s distinguished himself. Early in February 1885 news reached Sydney of the death of the archetypal British hero, General Charles Gordon, slain at the taking of Khartoum by the forces of the Sudanese nationalist leader, the Mahdi Muhammed Ahmad. The Gladstone government in Britain was severely criticised for failing to send a relief force to Khartoum in time, and its first reaction after narrowly surviving a vote of censure was to seek reinforcements for the Sudan. Australian opinion was much moved at Gordon’s fate, and on 12 February 1885 the New South Wales cabinet voted to offer two battalions for service with the British forces in the Sudan. Like most public figures, Barton warmly supported this initiative and, on the evening of 20 February, he appeared on the platform of a monster public meeting convened by the mayor of Sydney to set up a patriotic fund. He was one of a bevy of prominent citizens, not cabinet ministers, whose presence denoted community backing for the government; among them the Chief Justice, Sir James Martin, the president of the Legislative Council, Sir John Hay, a prominent Catholic layman, Sir Patrick Jennings, and Barton’s predecessor, Sir George Wigram Allen. Almost the only absentee was Sir Henry Parkes, who in three strong letters to the Sydney Morning Herald denounced the proposal as unconstitutional and immoral. Before an audience estimated at 12 000 Barton proposed the establishment of a patriotic fund for the assistance of the wives and families of the soldiers embarking on the campaign. Challenging any of the small number of dissenters in the audience to hiss at this resolution, he pulled out all the patriotic stops: When the time of trouble comes and we do not stand shoulder to shoulder with our fellow subjects of Great Britain can we expect them to do so for us? Is the good old country always to be succouring us and not to expect succour from us?
It was an eloquent and full-blooded piece of oratory, quoting Henry V and ending with the thought that no man would be so mean as to disregard the orphan and the widow. It was very far
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
45
152 × 230
46 EDMUND BARTON
from the irreverent view of the Bulletin that the Sudan issue had nothing to do with Australia, although in fact Barton said little to justify the campaign: ‘Probably there is not a man in this assembly who has any fascination for the foreign or colonial policy of England.’ The Anglo-Australian tie overrode all else. There can be no question that Barton held these views passionately and sincerely. He seems never to have reflected on the irony that Parkes, the English-born seeker after acceptance by English celebrities, opposed the Sudan intervention while he, a self-defined nationalist who at that time had never been outside Australia, held so devotedly to a vision of British loyalty. Parkes did himself no harm by his opposition to the campaign. Apart from patrolling and maintaining Sudan’s only railway, the New South Wales contingent saw very little action during its three months in the Sudan. When at the end of July the troops returned to a civic welcome Barton was again in demand as an orator, and the Bulletin ridiculed him gently for proposing the toast of the armed forces ‘whose victories have been countless and whose defeats have been as glorious as the victories of others’. The demand for patriotic rhetoric of this kind was waning as New South Wales came to realise that the government which had ventured so boldly into martial activity was proving far less decisive in managing the public finances. Revenue from land sales had been falling heavily since the scrapping of the Robertson system, and no compensatory sources had been tapped. By the second half of 1885 the deficit was nearly £1 million. The Stuart government uneasily approached a general election which must be held in the second half of 1885. Stuart himself had been laid low by a stroke in October 1884, and although he resumed office seven months later his leadership was enfeebled and the opposition, reinforced by Parkes, emboldened. By September it was clear that Stuart must resign. Lachlan Brient, the energetic young news editor of the Daily Telegraph, wrote privately to Barton, sounding him out about his political intentions. Barton candidly admitted that it was not his intention to be permanently shelved in the Speaker’s chair, though he might re-nominate in the new parliament. Without pushing his own claims to lead a party, he was
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
46
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 47
sure ‘that it would be dangerous to confide again in certain political hacks who have all but monopolised power in the past’; among them, presumably, Parkes and Robertson. When Stuart resigned in October, his most senior colleague, George Dibbs, was invited to form a ministry and asked Barton to join as attorney-general. After a Sunday morning interview Dibbs formed the impression that Barton ‘preferred the easy dignity & certain emoluments of the Speakership to the worry & uncertainty of office’. That evening Dibbs showed his proposed cabinet list to Brient, who predicted failure and urged Dibbs to serve under a new leader ‘who had not inherited the sins of a defunct Govt., but somebody who could ‘‘peacock’’ both sides of the House & come into office with clean hands & a clear course of action open to him’. This pointed at Barton. Although Dibbs said he was strongly inclined to fall in with Brient’s idea, he could not easily drop ‘the greatest ambition of his life’, and next day formed a ministry without Barton. It was the first, but not the last, time that Barton was seen as a potential premier capable of drawing support from several groups. Barton was well out of the Dibbs ministry. At the elections later in October Dibbs was handicapped by his record as treasurer. He was defeated by Parkes in his suburban constituency of St Leonard’s, and had to seek refuge in Murrumbidgee. In the East Sydney electorate Barton stood as an Independent, stating that although he hoped to be reappointed as Speaker without opposition he might become a backbencher once more, and the voters were entitled to know his views. These boiled down to honest administration of the as yet imperfect land laws, a strong push for water conservation, support for immigration and resolute opposition to following Victoria down the road of tariff protection. This last pledge would return to haunt him before long. His style was becoming less rarefied; he was developing a skill at repartee with hecklers and was an invited speaker when the trade unions held their eight-hour day banquet. He must have campaigned convincingly, as he was returned at the top of the poll with 3903 votes, finishing more than 500 ahead of the next successful candidate, George Reid. It was a heartening victory. Forty-eight new members were returned whose allegiance could
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
47
152 × 230
48 EDMUND BARTON
not be predicted and in mid-November Sir John Robertson convened a meeting of sympathisers in the congenial surroundings of a picnic at Clontarf. Barton was invited, although an Independent, and Robertson and Parkes drank his health and pledged their support for him as Speaker. He was proposed by Reid, and duly returned unopposed, but it soon became evident that his duties would be more onerous than previously. When Robertson moved a vote of no confidence in the Dibbs ministry it emerged that the two sides in the Legislative Assembly were almost evenly balanced. This was a sure recipe for parliamentary turbulence. With the deficit now over £1 million, Dibbs resigned four days before Christmas. It looked as if the path was open for a revival of the Parkes–Robertson coalition, only this time with Robertson as premier. But when Robertson formed his ministry Parkes made excuses to stand aside. A few weeks later, when the new government proposed a property tax as a means of curbing the deficit (now estimated at £1.7 million), Parkes led his half-dozen followers into the ‘No’ lobby, thus bringing down the ministry. For some days negotiations followed for a coalition between Robertson and the Dibbs party, under Dibbs’ respected senior colleague Sir Patrick Jennings. They failed to reach agreement, but when, at the end of February 1886, Jennings formed a ministry with Dibbs once more treasurer, Robertson and his faction supported them over essentials, leaving Parkes leading the opposition. Although few realised it at the time, these manoeuvres were a preliminary to the crystallisation of New South Wales politics into a regular two-party system. Under the stimulus of the economic downturn many voters were starting to think more kindly of tariff protection, especially manufacturers and their employees. Twenty members of parliament, mostly newcomers, were prepared to urge protection. The crisis was their opportunity. Jennings persuaded parliament to accept in principle increased stamp duties, land and income taxes, but more controversially proposed a 5 per cent duty on imports for a three-year period. This gave Parkes his opportunity to trumpet protest at the threat to the colony’s immemorial freetrade principles. The winter of 1886 was to witness some of the rowdiest scenes ever known in the Legislative Assembly. Unfortunately, early in 1886 Barton’s authority had met a check
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
48
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 49
from an unexpected source. When the New South Wales Supreme Court declared at the end of 1884 that Barton had exceeded his authority in suspending A. G. Taylor for a week, the decision to appeal against the decision to the Privy Council must have been taken with the expectation that even such a well-read bush lawyer as Taylor would be put in his place by Britain’s highest tribunal. Taylor was not deterred. He decided to argue his case himself against the English senior counsel retained by the New South Wales government. Funding the journey from the sale of his stamp collection, he took his wife and mother with him, travelled steerage and found lodgings during a dreary winter in a poor quarter of London’s East End. Few of the Australian community in London gave him much encouragement or assistance, but the Privy Council complimented him on his presentation of his case and in February 1886 found in his favour. The standing orders on which Barton, and before him Wigram Allen, had relied were ultra vires. Taylor handled his triumph with rare composure. He refused to pursue his advantage and sue for damages before a jury because any such award would come out of public money, and he declined to be interviewed by an influential London journal because he did not ‘wish to offend English readers by airing his thorough-paced Republicanism’. Readers of the Bulletin enjoyed the story of the young colonial who, singlehanded, successfully challenged the Establishment. For Barton it must have been mortifying that his endeavours to uphold the orderly parliamentary traditions of Westminster in New South Wales had been overthrown by none other than Britain’s highest court of appeal. The episode showed the colonial parliament did not possess the same powers as the House of Commons. A national Australian parliament must be stronger. Staunch admirer of British institutions though he was, Barton now had good grounds for doubting the wisdom of British authority. He had a torrid time of it during the next parliamentary sittings. In June when Jennings introduced the new tariff Parkes and his followers stonewalled until tempers were thoroughly frayed. The old offenders such as McElhone and Wisdom were reinforced by several vociferous newcomers, notably the lawyer John Shepherd, who had preceded Barton as MLA for Wellington and regarded him with
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
49
152 × 230
50 EDMUND BARTON
professional jealousy. Repeatedly warned by the Speaker for using terms such as ‘corruption’ and ‘gaol birds’, Shepherd taunted Barton with giving the House ‘lectures on procedure’ during a debate which lasted so long into the night that members had to be discouraged from placing bedding on their benches. Worse followed a fortnight later. When the Tariff Bill reached the committee stage Dibbs, as leader of the House, decided on Thursday 8 July to force through the legislation at a single continuous sitting. The opposition responded by filibustering. They contended that standing orders required the daily adjournment of the House so that the Speaker might initiate a new session at the customary hour of 4.30 pm. When this did not happen on the second day of debate they claimed that the sitting was illegal, misbehaving so continuously that the chairman of committees cleared the galleries of spectators: One member sat on the table and shouted: ‘There is no House’ and ‘We are a rabble!’ Another crowed like a cock and a third threw himself on his back and cried ‘Damn the chair!’ And when Jennings walked to the table to speak, Parkes rushed up to him, shook his fist in his face, and exploded: ‘You d—-d bugger—you Fenian—who are you?’
By 9.00 pm Trickett, the chairman of committees, though a former cabinet minister and seasoned parliamentarian, could take no more, and Barton had to come in twice to restore order. After 56 hours of debate, Parkes and his followers, knowing themselves outnumbered, walked out at midnight on Saturday in protest against conducting business on a Sunday, and by 1.00 am the clauses were passed and the remaining members could go home. Trickett was not fit for work for some days afterwards and resigned because his health would not bear any further strain. After this episode Barton’s authority was never quite the same. He was probably correct in rejecting the opposition’s argument that it was necessary for the Speaker formally to open the Assembly each day, but as a result Parkes and his followers attacked him as a partisan of the Jennings ministry, moving an unsuccessful motion of censure on him on 14 July. It failed, but in future weeks objections to his rulings became more frequent. On a party vote the Legislative
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
50
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 51
Assembly upheld Barton’s decision to permit a continuous sitting, but this did not prevent the opposition from attempting to rescind this decision in September. In the same month, having previously complained about Barton’s discipline (‘How are we to characterise things in this chamber unless we have the free use of adjectives?’), Parkes moved for the reduction of the Speaker’s salary to its old level of £1200, but there was no quorum present and hence no vote on the issue. The next day he tried again, but the motion was rejected by 23 votes to 10. Despite these pinpricks Barton continued to deal even-handedly between the ministry and the opposition, but it came as no surprise when he was absent through illness for several days in October, mostly eye trouble which his medical advisers attributed to want of rest. The speakership was losing its savour. In earlier years the office provided him with useful financial security, for although he continued to practise as a barrister he calculated that the £1500 earned as Speaker made up almost two-thirds of his income. He felt sufficiently committed to the Speaker’s chair to shift his family in 1884 to 213 Macquarie Street, within easy walking distance of Parliament House, although the move was probably prompted also by the arrival in that year of a fourth child, Arnold Hubert. By 1886, however, the situation at the Sydney Bar was changing through the promotion of several senior members to the judicial bench. As early as March 1886 one journal speculated that Barton might wish to return to full-time legal practice, and the Bulletin published a little doggerel advising him against giving up a safe income as Speaker. In the debates over his salary in September a sympathiser claimed that Barton could make £3000 a year at the Bar. Late in 1886 he made a calculation that his earnings at the Bar averaged just under £850 during the past four years, showing steady improvement to peak at £1114 in 1885, though he could practise only when parliament was not sitting. Stronger encouragement came early in October in a letter from his old mentor Burton Bradley, under whom he had served his articles as a solicitor. Bradley stressed the opportunities awaiting Barton as a barrister: ‘. . . although you prefer killing yourself in political life it is the company, their habits and principles,
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
51
152 × 230
52 EDMUND BARTON
to which you are exposed, that impede your progress at the Bar and I am sure that your father would agree with me.’ His father might just possibly have given him a more substantial reason for no longer needing his income as Speaker. During his brief flush of prosperity in the 1850s William Barton had resumed his old habit of investing in suburban land. He acquired 145 acres (58.7 hectares) in the Georges River district south of Sydney, a smaller outer suburban lot north of the Harbour, and property in the Newcastle district. By the time he moved to his daughter in Brisbane in 1874 he was in debt to the Bank of New South Wales to the tune of £723 without realistic hope, at nearly 80, of earning further income. In that year when the Bank pressed him for payment he wrote a pathetic muddled letter tendering his lands as his only remaining asset. At one point in his letter he seemed to be offering his lands as security for the debt, but at another he could be seen as asking the Bank to accept them in quittance of his liabilities. The Bank took the latter assumption, valuing the lands at £400 towards satisfaction of the debt. There the matter rested until William died intestate in 1881. Edmund does not appear to have been aware of these transactions until some time subsequently. With Sydney’s rapid suburban growth in the 1870s and 1880s William Barton’s investments at last increased dramatically in value. The Bank thought the time ripe for subdivision and sale, but when Edmund and his siblings became aware of this development they brought a lawsuit against the Bank, arguing that the land had merely been lodged as security and could be redeemed on the payment of the original debt of £723 with accumulated interest. In May 1885 the case came before the Chief Judge in Equity, Sir William Manning. He found in favour of the Barton family. It looked as if at last something might have turned up out of William’s Micawberish schemes. The Bank of New South Wales was unhappy with the verdict and appealed to the Supreme Court, but at the end of 1886 it would have been reasonable for Edmund to hope that the higher tribunal would confirm Manning’s judgment, with promising effect on his financial future. Besides, his tenure as Speaker was not secure. Despite Parkes’ praise of him in 1885 as a highly satisfactory appointment, his
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
52
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 53
behaviour as opposition leader during 1886 was far from friendly, and there was an increasing chance that Parkes might soon be premier once more. Jennings, a gentle and easygoing soul, was weary and distressed with the parliamentary turmoil, although his government still commanded a fair majority. In January 1887, having quarrelled with Dibbs over an administrative question, he resigned office. The governor, Lord Carrington, heard from many sides that Barton should be the next premier. Years later Barton himself asserted that he could have come into office at that time with a majority of 30 behind him; presumably on the lines of Lachlan Brient’s coalition. But Sir Patrick sorrowfully told Carrington that Parkes was the only man. He agreed to form a government provided that, after obtaining supply from parliament, he could call another general election. With this uncertainty looming Barton delayed no longer. On 20 January he informed the Legislative Assembly of his intention to resign as from the end of the month. Parkes, with victory in his grasp, could afford to be magnanimous. He praised Barton as a worthy example of native-born talent, and offered him nomination to the Legislative Council and a place in the new cabinet as vice-president of the executive council. Barton, who considered it inappropriate for an ex-Speaker to remain in the Legislative Assembly, accepted the seat in the Upper House, but refused to join the Parkes ministry because he did not agree sufficiently with its policies. But Barton’s duties were not quite finished, as the irrepressible A. G. Taylor stood up to argue that the sitting was illegal. Barton explained that by asking a question Taylor was acknowledging the legitimacy of the session and asked him if he wished to dissent from his ruling; and Taylor replied that he would not think of dissenting. However on the following day Taylor insisted on pressing a point disagreeing with one of Barton’s rulings. The motion was lost by 7 votes to 54. On this note Barton ended his term as Speaker. As Reid recalled years later: ‘his firm methods . . . were greatly missed. His successor, who was equally anxious to do his duty, lacked his judicial temperament and his tact.’ From his point of vantage in the Legislative Council Barton must have smiled wryly when a few weeks later A. G. Taylor was nominated
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
53
152 × 230
54 EDMUND BARTON
as Deputy-Speaker and chairman of committees. He was almost successful. ‘The bear-garden of Macquarie Street’, as the New South Wales parliament was dubbed, provided a good example of the tendency for Australians to undervalue their parliaments because of the rowdy and undignified behaviour of politicians. It was probably no coincidence that while legislators brawled and scuffled many Sydney citizens during the 1880s took alarm at the larrikin ‘pushes’ in the poorer quarters of Sydney, whose misdirected energies gave offence to the respectable. Parkes’ return to power in January 1887 took place against the background of the notorious Mount Rennie case, when four teenagers were inefficiently hanged and others sentenced to long prison terms for a pack rape. Fear of an entirely different form of working-class turbulence underlay some of the reactions to the republican minority who came to the fore in Sydney during 1887. Until that time many by no means radical Australians took it for granted that their country would evolve into a republic. At the beginning of 1886 three of the five premiers—Dibbs in New South Wales, Service in Victoria, and Adye Douglas in Tasmania—were all republicans, as well as several judges. Most saw the republic as a long-term prospect, to be achieved without the trauma of a war of independence. The republicanism of 1887 seemed much more radical, even socialist in its thrust, and Parkes and Barton were brought together in reaction against it. When the mayor of Sydney convened a meeting to celebrate the golden jubilee of Queen Victoria’s reign it was taken over by republicans who carried what was called ‘a disloyal amendment’. A second meeting was called for the evening of 10 June, with a carefully selected invitation list including many of the colony’s notables. Republican sympathisers managed to swamp this meeting too, which broke up in a major brawl. The platform party (among them Barton) withdrew to the mayor’s vestibule, there to draw up a loyal manifesto: We, the undersigned, moved by feelings of indignation at the riotous conduct of a disloyal minority, insignificant in numbers, do hereby agree to unite and band together for the maintenance
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
54
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 55
of order and the vindication of the loyal attachment of the people to the Laws, Institutions, and Throne of the British Empire.
The excitement soon subsided, and a third meeting, more efficiently stage-managed, secured the necessary expression of loyalty; but the episode is interesting in showing that Barton, a former Speaker, was seen as a sufficiently outstanding figure in the community to put his name beside the premier, Parkes, the leader of the government in the Legislative Council, and the present and former chief justices. But he did little to capitalise on his standing. Once free of his obligations to attend parliament daily as Speaker, Barton took his legislative duties lightly. In three sessions covering two years after his appointment to the Legislative Council, he attended no more than 29 of the 130 sitting days and voted in only 17 of more than 100 divisions. He made only one speech in 1887, supporting the introduction of payment of members. Yet he was still sought after. In May 1887, when Parkes needed to replace his attorney-general, he offered the post to Barton, who once more refused because of disagreement over policy. Parkes also offered to put Barton’s name forward for a knighthood, but Barton refused, sensibly for a man who had neither the seniority nor the wealth for the status. An attorney-general was found in the 29-year-old Bernhard Ringrose Wise, a barrister of only four years’ standing and a member of parliament only four months, but a young Australian of a brilliance challenging Barton’s. Son of a reforming judge who died young, Wise had a first-class English education at Rugby and Balliol College, Oxford, presiding over both the Athletic Club and that noted debating society, the Oxford Union. Many of his colleagues did not know what to make of this phenomenon who voiced radical views in a poshPommy accent; some mistrusted him. He and Barton regarded each other with the polite edginess of potential competitors. In July 1887, when Dibbs announced his conversion to protection and began work on the formation of a party, Barton stood aside. In 1888, although reinforced by the appointment of his close friend Richard O’Connor to the Legislative Council, he remained an inactive member, speaking only three times. One speech dealt with a
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
55
152 × 230
56 EDMUND BARTON
constitutional point. The others commented on the Parkes government’s legislation to restrict Chinese immigration. Understanding working-class fears of cheap labour, Barton supported the bill but argued that, once admitted, Chinese should be subject to no further discrimination through taxation or any other respect. This throws an interesting light on the politician who would be remembered later for introducing the White Australia policy. During 1888 also Barton was much preoccupied with the ongoing saga of his father’s estate. The Bank of New South Wales appealed against Sir William Manning’s finding in favour of the Barton family, because the precedent on which Manning relied had been subsequently overturned on appeal to the Privy Council in London. In June 1888 the Supreme Court of New South Wales ruled that the Privy Council’s decision overruled Manning’s judgment and, consequently, William Barton must be deemed to have made over his land to the Bank in 1874 in return for a reduction of £400 in his debt. Although his elder brother George was now back in Sydney, newly widowed and making little progress in an attempt to re-establish a legal practice (though Parkes was shortly to appoint him editor of that valuable collection of documents The Historical Records of New South Wales), it was to Edmund that the family turned in this crisis. This involved him in correspondence with his five surviving sisters as well as George, until, some grudgingly, others readily, they contributed to funding an appeal to the Privy Council. It was a lost cause. When the case came before the Privy Council in July 1890 their Lordships threw out the Bartons’ case without even hearing their evidence. The earlier precedent decided it all. As in A. G. Taylor’s case the highest court in the British Empire was rebuffing a cherished enterprise of Barton’s. It was scarcely wonderful that, with all his loyal sentiments towards Britain, Barton in future felt little reverence for the wisdom of the judicial committee of the Privy Council. Other family matters also claimed attention. Before resigning as Speaker Barton had moved his family to the Southern Highlands, renting a large house called ‘Fairholme’ close to the railway station at Burradoo. The move was prompted by doctor’s orders, as the eight-year-old eldest son had an asthmatic condition which country air might help. Jeanie and the children remained there a year, with
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
56
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 57
Edmund commuting at weekends. The children thrived with space to run around, but their education suffered, so late in 1887 the Bartons took a house at Mittagong called ‘The Hill’. This was part of the Oaklands Estate, a property owned by Henry Southey who ran a school to which the two elder boys were sent. For the rest of his life the younger Edmund Barton retained agreeable memories of the eccentric headmaster who cut classes to take the boys panning for gold. But, he recalled, ‘Neither of my parents cared to prolong an arrangement by which my father was so much separated from his family and deprived of the comforts of a home’, and there was a fifth child, Oswald, born in January 1888. They returned to Sydney, and after a short period in Elizabeth Bay Road, Edmund, without consulting his wife, rented a house on the North Shore in what is now Balgowlah, west of Manly. The house, ‘Calahla’, was in Woodland Street, which for more than a kilometre ran downhill to an arm of the harbour. In 1888 there were only three other homes and a dairy farm in the street. It was an idyllic environment for the children, but less so for their mother, who was not only a considerable distance from shops and transport, but who would also have found it difficult to retain servants so far from central Sydney. There was, of course, no bridge across the harbour, so that for her visits to central Sydney Jeanie Barton was dependent on the hourly ferry service from Manly, more than two kilometres from ‘Calahla’. There was no scheduled service after 5.00 pm. If residents wanted to travel later, they had to make up a sufficient number of passengers. The men, we are told, formed a ‘hot potato club’ for refreshment on winter nights ‘with sausages, hot pies, and the like . . . Of course a good stock of beer and spirits was always at hand.’ ‘My mother felt the isolation very much,’ remembered her son, ‘and although we kept a horse and trap it was never known by what boat he was arriving. There was no telephone in those days and the result was he frequently spent the night in town.’ These commuting problems played up to Edmund Barton’s growing fondness for the Athenaeum Club. From these years grew his reputation as an inveterate clubman, one of the most devoted
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
57
152 × 230
58 EDMUND BARTON
members of the Athenaeum. It was, remembered his younger colleague, A. B. Piddington: a real club, most clubs nowadays being restaurants with residential accommodation. The Athenaeum was a place where a young man could hear first-class minds discussing all things under the sun. Robert Louis Stevenson graced its reading room and Mark Twain its dining.
Barton, O’Connor, Lyne, and Wise were among the politicians who enjoyed the Athenaeum, and Barton was long remembered for a moment of financial crisis in the Club’s affairs when he urged that members should all do their best to help the Club ‘drink itself out of debt’. This is another of A. B. Piddington’s stories, and although Piddington wrote as a whole-hearted admirer, his recollections bear some responsibility for the lingering tradition that Barton drank too much. One of his stories relates that when Speaker Barton broke his ankle, while laid up for a fortnight he invited W. J. Taylor, a Coonamble lawyer, to stay with him. Taylor found the regime too much for him, because it began with rum-and-milk before breakfast and proceeded by way of sherry at 11.00 am and beer or stout at lunch, to a late afternoon whisky before a well-wined dinner at 8.00 pm. After liqueurs around 10.00 pm ‘the real and serious business of the day began—a steady irrigation of the alimentary canal with spirits and soda. By one or two in the morning it was considered time for all frugal souls to be in bed’ but next morning the day’s round was beginning with rum-and-milk, and Barton, ‘rosy and genial’, was confiding: ‘The fact is, Taylor, that when I was laid-up my doctors insisted on the strictest moderation in the use of alcohol, and I don’t mind admitting that it seems to suit my constitution wonderfully!’ It is an apt story for ‘Tosspot Toby’, told in an era when men admired those with a good head for liquor, but can we rely on it? Presumably Jeanie and the children were at Burradoo when this alcoholic marathon took place; but she was a wife who fussed devotedly over her husband’s illnesses, and was unlikely to have left him alone with a broken ankle. Edmund seems to have been
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
58
152 × 230
‘Mr Speaker’ 59
one of those not uncommon Australian men who, having been a good son to his mother, a faithful husband and father and professionally successful, relaxed and expanded in male company. Even if Piddington’s account is exaggerated, the story reflects a durable myth which was beginning to gather about Barton’s reputation. Undeniably after periods of stressful hard work such as the later stages of his speakership, Barton was given to equally thorough relaxation. More than the food and the drink it was the yarning sociability of the Athenaeum which he found seductive. Between his club and the hours he spent as a good family man, public life took a third place among his priorities when there was not a grand cause to inspire his enthusiasm. At one point in 1889 his attendance even at the University of Sydney Senate became so irregular that he was automatically disqualified from membership. Yet such was his popularity and reputation that the Chancellor, Sir William Manning, immediately wrote asking him to accept reappointment. A convincing explanation for Barton’s swings of mood is offered by a medically qualified and experienced grandson, Dr David Barton: I have come to the conclusion that he suffered a bipolar disorder, the modern term of manic depressive psychosis. This would explain the wide fluctuation in his behaviour and many of the illnesses he suffered. The disorder is familial and it would explain the behaviour of William Barton, also George Burdett Barton, in the extravagances of behaviour they showed . . . Edmund’s flight from one extravagant house to another at times when he could ill afford it, is typical . . . So is his capacity to work at ferocious pace with little rest in spasms and appear lazy and indolent at other times. His reputation for eating and drinking too much . . . suggests that this was a feature of depression . . . He was never described as an alcoholic—food was the factor and overeating is a compensatory mechanism . . .
Barton’s often formal public manner and disciplined politeness might be seen as controls adopted, consciously or otherwise, over a variable temperament. Barton did not have the name of being an introspective man,
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
59
152 × 230
60 EDMUND BARTON
and yet as he approached the age of 40 he must have pondered his future. With great intellectual gifts and a generosity of spirit which made for popularity, he was maturing into a figure of statesmanlike appearance. A fine head of hair was turning a distinguished irongrey. The sidewhiskers which he had sported at the time of his election as Speaker had gone, and in an age of hirsute males he stayed cleanshaven. This gave some prominence to a mouth, inherited from his father, which Alfred Deakin once unfortunately described as ‘fish-like’, although observers did not find it so: At first glimpse one might have thought that for all its massiveness it was not a strong face. It was certainly a bewildering one which looked, on close inspection, as if the upper structure of a powerful skull had been cemented on the strong jawpiece of a slightly smaller skull. There was determination there and sometimes there was passion and anger in the strange, black wide-apart eyes. It was also the face of a controlled man.
Those eyes were his best feature and gave mobility to slightly heavy features. He suggested a presence of remarkable potential, and yet at 40 he had no very impressive record of public achievement. Had he died in 1888 he might not have made the pages of the Australian Dictionary of Biography. He was not lazy, but without a challenge to stir his interests he seemed to lapse into procrastination and good-fellowship, even at times into lethargy. Then he found his challenge in the movement for Australian federation.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
60
152 × 230
4
‘My Bristles are Up’ ‘My Bristles are Up’
I
F IN December 1888 Lord Rosebery (instead of accepting nomination to the somewhat unlikely post of first chairman of the London County Council) had revisited Sydney on the fifth anniversary of his speech encouraging Australian federation, he might have felt disappointment. The Federal Council had struggled into being, but it lacked the membership of New South Wales and New Zealand, Fiji dropped out, and South Australia came in only on a temporary basis at the third meeting in 1889. Its early meetings achieved little beyond streamlining various legal processes and agreeing on the regulation of pearling and fisheries. It had no executive powers and no budget with which to attack such an important question for the Australian colonies as cooperation for defence. Following the German annexation of north-eastern New Guinea in 1884 and a Russian invasion scare in 1885, not to mention persistent unease about the populous nations of East Asia, defenceminded Australians looked for a security greater than that provided by six small amateur colonial forces, even though backed by the power of the Royal Navy. The British government undertook to send out an expert to make recommendations about Australia’s defence needs, which would almost certainly require formal cooperation between the colonial governments. If the Federal Council was inadequate for the responsibility it must either be strengthened (as
61
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
61
152 × 230
62 EDMUND BARTON
Victorians tended to argue) or a more effective replacement must be devised. Without New South Wales this seemed difficult. Though constitutional progress between 1883 and 1888 was slow, Australians were advancing rapidly to a sense of shared cultural identity. They were becoming a people ahead of becoming a nation. It was not just that in those years young writers such as Paterson and Lawson were finding an audience among readers of the Bulletin and young artists were using a run of unusually clement Melbourne summers to discover those fresh ways of portraying Australian light and colour which we now style ‘the Heidelberg school’. In sport Australian cricketers had recovered from the unpleasantness of Lord Harris’ visit to become the recognised opponent against which England’s best must measure themselves. When Trickett won the world’s sculling championship, when Melba sang at Covent Garden, they were identified not as the possession of any particular colony but as Australian. The Australian Natives’ Association, founded in Victoria in 1871 as a debating and friendly society for Australian-born young men, after a quiet beginning expanded vigorously in the 1880s. Within Australia lines of communication were strengthening. The telegraph spanned the continent in the 1870s. In the early 1880s an enthusiasm for transcontinental railways on the North American scale resulted mostly in paper plans, but by 1883 Melbourne and Sydney were linked and the Victorian premier was using the opening ceremony to preach the virtues of federation. By 1888 it was possible to go by rail, though circuitously and with several breaks of gauge, from Port Augusta to Rockhampton. Shearers and miners on horseback or bicycle built up nation-wide trade unions, and employers in retaliation organised across colonial boundaries. Melbourne capitalists invested in every corner of the continent. Growing businesses such as Broken Hill Proprietary and Burns Philp (both originating in 1883) stretched their activities across several borders. In the remote Kimberleys overlanding cattlemen and miners were completing the last chapter in the invasion of Aboriginal Australia. For the first time Australian society and the Australian economy were maturing to a point where it might be possible for an orator to speak of a nation for a continent. In January 1888, during the celebrations for the centenary of
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
62
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 63
British settlement, Parkes attempted to reclaim national sentiment by proposing that the colony of New South Wales should be renamed ‘Australia’. This was too much for the other colonies to swallow—a better name, said one wit, would be ‘Convictoria’—but at least it showed that national identity was a live issue for debate. The centenary year 1888 passed nevertheless without significant progress. During this year politics in New South Wales continued to polarise into a recognisable two-party system. Those who supported the Parkes government continued to uphold free trade as their creed. Their opponents, mainly rural spokesmen wanting to protect local produce against inter-colonial competition, and representatives of working-class seats concerned to preserve jobs, were gradually cohering into a protectionist party. After two years as premier of New South Wales Parkes, at nearly 74 years of age, was showing a high-handedness which may have masked a flagging of his prodigious stamina. Some of his restive followers eventually rebelled in January 1889 over a contentious patronage issue, and on a snap division the government was beaten by four votes. This need not have been a resigning matter, but as Parkes candidly admitted, the ministry ‘courted defeat’. Dibbs as leader of the opposition prepared to form a ministry. On 17 January 1889 he asked Barton to serve as attorney-general, and this time Barton accepted. It was the day before his fortieth birthday. Meanwhile, however, William McMillan, a prominent businessman who had come into parliament in 1887 as a Parkes supporter, moved a virtual motion of no confidence in the Dibbs government, which was carried by a three-vote margin. Dibbs could not carry on, and with Barton asked the governor to dissolve parliament and call an election, remaining in office in a caretaker capacity. A hard-fought election lay ahead. Barton, as a nominated member of the Upper House, was exempt from the contest, but he took a vigorous part in campaigning for protectionist candidates in Sydney and the suburbs. According to press reports, prolonged and enthusiastic cheering greeted him wherever he went. His speeches laid at least as much stress on the shortcomings of the Parkes government as on the merits of protection, and this was perhaps
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
63
152 × 230
64 EDMUND BARTON
wise because he was open to the charge of having undergone a wonderfully rapid change of heart on the tariff question. The Herald remembered that little more than three years previously Barton stood at the 1885 elections as a convinced free-trader, and Reid sharpened his wit on the converts to protection: . . . we must look upon them with all the pity that attends a premature birth. (Cheers and laughter.) His hon. friend Mr Barton must have kept his secret well, for unless he had changed during the last week his best friends believed him to be a free-trader. He was one of the premature births. (Cheers.)
Although a frequent critic of Parkes, Reid was staying faithful to free-trade principles, and his taunts gained an added sting because of his old alliance with Barton. As Barton himself acknowledged: ‘Mr Reid, whose friendship seemed to have given his sarcasm a double row of teeth—(laughter)—and himself used to be called the twins of East Sydney.’ In his streetwise and tough-minded way Reid had nourished Barton’s career on more than one occasion. Personal friendship remained, but for the next decade and a half they would usually be on opposing sides in politics. It was Reid, and not Barton, who had the better of the argument in the inner-city electorates. Working-class voters were not persuaded that manufacturers profiting from tariff protection would pass on benefits such as increased wages or an eight-hour working day, and the free-traders were generally victorious. It was a different story in the provincial cities and the rural districts, and by midFebruary it was evident that the free-traders would win by a greatly reduced margin, 71 members against 66. In his short spell as attorney-general Barton had little time to prove ministerial capacity, but he added to his stock of experience. With Dibbs absent on the campaign trail it fell to him, supported by William Lyne and a colleague, to make arrangements for the payment of public servants during the period of the elections after the Legislative Assembly failed to grant supply for their salaries. He was also one of two commissioners representing the governor at the official opening of the new session of the Legislative Council, and gave a lucid and
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
64
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 65
well-argued defence of Dibbs for holding on to office. But on 7 March 1889 Dibbs had to resign and Parkes was premier for the fifth time. Barton’s service as attorney-general gave him the final qualification required for taking silk, and in March 1889 he became a Queen’s Counsel. He could command higher fees, and his practice was thriving. He specialised mainly in commercial cases, finding his way deftly around the intricacies of contract law, and on at least one occasion was asked to act as umpire arbitrating an industrial dispute. Without dipping into capital he was earning enough to maintain his wife and five children at a standard of living which ran to a French tutor for Muffie (though as the tutor was a doctor’s widow who later became William McMillan’s second wife, this may have been another example of the Bartons’ open-handedness to friends in need). In these years he was operating from a secure enough financial basis to please himself whether and to what extent he took part in politics. The 1889 general election sealed the process by which political parties were becoming institutionalised in New South Wales. Parkes ruled with the diminished authority of a leader chosen by the Free Trade Party, not, as in the past, the master architect of a coalition of factions. He found it hard to consult with his new and much less docile team of ministers, of whom the most substantial was the treasurer, William McMillan. Reid declined to serve under Parkes, remaining a formidable and troublesome backbencher. In August, when the Free Trade and Liberal Association held its first formal party conference, Parkes stayed aloof, and it was Reid who emerged as its leading figure. As a counter-demonstration the Protectionists called a four-day conference of their own on 1 October. Barton presided over more than 200 delegates. After opening the conference with an hour-long speech he missed the afternoon session, and was 20 minutes late in the evening; but he then made another speech lasting more than an hour and was loudly cheered at its conclusion. He made such an excellent impression that at one point he had to react nimbly to head off a move that he, and not Dibbs, should lead the party. This was an idea which continued to surface from time to time, with the squatter-politician William Abbott especially persistent; but Barton never gave it any encouragement.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
65
152 × 230
66 EDMUND BARTON
Admittedly his keynote speech was stronger on form than content. He claimed that the Protectionists were the true heirs of liberalism and allies of the working class but, as the Sydney Morning Herald pointed out, said little about the tariff: ‘The subjects selected for discussion are Electoral Reform, Local Government, Payment of Members, Light Railways, Differential Railway Rates, Liberal Mining Laws, and the establishment of a Department of Agriculture.’ Several of these items were also on the Free-Trade agenda. With a newly-formed coalition of farmers, manufacturers, workingclass representatives and Catholic voters, it was safest for a Protectionist speaker to stick to generalities. And it would have suited Barton to play down the differences between the two major parties at a moment when federation at last seemed to be emerging into the realm of practical politics. The initiative came, as so much of the early impetus for the federal movement came, from Andrew Inglis Clark, attorney-general of Tasmania. A terrier-like Scottish Australian a few months older than Barton, Clark as a young man was attracted to the American model of republicanism; not such a handicap in Tasmanian politics as it would be in the conservative twentieth century. By the late 1880s, having attended the third meeting of the Federal Council, he was alive with ideas for improving the federal machinery. Early in the winter of 1889 he met Barton and found in him a fellow enthusiast. They talked about the desirability of New South Wales joining the Federal Council. They agreed that there were many legal problems—Clark instanced joint stock company law, bequests covering property in more than one colony, and patent law—which could be handled much better at federal level. It is noteworthy that the two lawyers discussed such practical matters rather than nationalism or defence. Clark urged Barton to use his influence to bring New South Wales into the federation. Recognising Barton’s lack of enthusiasm for the Federal Council as then constituted, he wrote him a follow-up letter assuring him: ‘No one is wedded to the present Constitution and the scope of its authority. I am confident both are open to review and that the other colonies would be glad to make modifications to clear the path for N.S.W.’ And he undertook to make a case to Sir Henry Parkes.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
66
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 67
Parkes was already stirring into action. A few days before Clark wrote his letter, the premier was conversing with the governor, Lord Carrington, when the issue of federation came up. Parkes boasted: ‘I could confederate these colonies within twelve months.’ ‘Then why don’t you do it?’ asked Carrington. Forthwith Parkes wrote an invitation for talks to the Victorian premier, Duncan Gillies. His government would invite parliament to nominate four delegates to discuss federation, Parkes and McMillan from the ministry and Dibbs and Barton from the opposition. Gillies responded coolly, finally replying in August that if New South Wales was serious about promoting colonial unity it should first join the Federal Council. The Victorians calculated that, with South Australia joining the Federal Council, New South Wales could be ‘compelled to crave admission’ or be left as odd man out. Parkes stalled for time, knowing that in July Major-General Bevan Edwards had arrived from Britain to carry out the long-awaited analysis of Australia’s defence needs. When in October Edwards recommended that the armed forces of the Australian colonies should be brought under a common authority, Parkes, although never previously a zealot about defence, seized his opportunity. He travelled up to Queensland, the colony most aware of its Pacific frontier, and easily persuaded the leading politicians in Brisbane that the defence factor called for a renewed federal effort. Parkes now had his psychological moment. According to a myth cherished in the vicinity of Tenterfield, the federation movement began there on the evening of 24 October 1889. Returning by rail from Brisbane, Parkes made a stop-over to visit his old constituents and used the occasion to make a keynote speech at the Tenterfield School of Arts. Evoking the Bevan Edwards report, Parkes raised ‘the great question . . . whether the time has not come now for the creation on this Australian continent of an Australian Government as distinct from the local Governments now in existence’ with an executive responsible to ‘a parliament of two Houses, a house of commons and a senate, which would legislate on all great subjects’. He urged a convention of delegates appointed by the parliament of each colony, and concluded by quoting the Queensland poet Brunton Stephens:
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
67
152 × 230
68 EDMUND BARTON
Not yet her day. How long ‘not yet’? There comes the flush of violet . . .
‘Reports of this speech,’ claimed Reynolds, ‘. . . stimulated the first real public interest in the question of Federation.’ According to Sir Robert Garran, ‘even in cold print next morning it rang like a trumpet call’. Cooler moderns have pointed out that the Tenterfield speech was not excessively publicised, the Sydney newspapers concentrating on the speed of Sir Henry’s express train. But Parkes himself wrote to Lord Carrington: ‘I think I have made history in the last six days.’ Barton at least was impressed. As soon as he read reports of the Tenterfield speech he wrote to Parkes pledging full support for the federal cause. Within a few days Parkes invited Barton for an hour’s talk, and Barton accepted, agreeing that ‘a Federation to be effective must be armed with the most complete powers of a General Executive and Parliament in matters of National (I use the word by way of distinction from Provincial) concernment’. He told Parkes that he did not think any important member of the opposition would raise obstacles. Barton’s support was crucial for Parkes, since without it federation could be seen as a fetish of the Free Trade Party, leaving the Protectionists scope to harvest support as the party which looked after industries and jobs in New South Wales. Dibbs, the leader of the Protectionists, although a republican, was sceptical about federation. Barton, as a leading Protectionist urging the removal of tariff barriers within Australia, ensured that the federation movement would be from the start bipartisan. For him this was a more congenial role than parrying the increasingly pointed taunts of George Reid about his desertion from the ranks of the free-traders. He first advocated federation as practical politics at a meeting called on 2 November, to set up a branch of the Protectionist Party at Lithgow. Having made his prepared speech, Barton added a postscript arguing that no question was as important as the federation of Australia. This was an issue which must be placed above party: ‘Free Trade inside her own federation and Protection against the world.’ This dress rehearsal in the provinces gained much less
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
68
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 69
publicity than Parkes did a few nights later when, at a meeting at his suburban constituency of St Leonards, the old premier sketched a plan for an Australian constitution with two houses of parliament, a court of appeal and an Australian Privy Council. But it was still necessary to claim the federation movement as bipartisan, and on the night of 8 November the Australian Natives’ Association called a well-attended meeting in the Sydney Town Hall. The first speaker, Joseph Hector Carruthers, was a promising young backbencher from the Free Trade Party. He moved that ‘in the opinion of this meeting it is desirable that the Australian colonies should federate as soon as possible’. Barton seconded with an oration which won considerable praise. Taking up a point which Parkes had left unclear, he urged that by leaving the tariff question to be decided by federal parliament, Protectionists and free-traders alike could support the movement. No one supposed that the great ideal could be consummated except after a deal of conflict, and he believed that the ultimate issue should be the result of leisurely debate. Because the Federal Council was ineffective it ran the risk of becoming a laughing-stock like the weak Confederation which had preceded the creation of the United States of America in 1789. A proper Australian federation would nourish Australian aspirations far better; ‘a man did not take mutton broth when he could get turtle soup’, said the epicure Barton. He then spelt out his attitude to two major issues which were sometimes linked to proposals for a federated Australia. One was republicanism, which should be set aside for the time being as a divisive side-issue: ‘This country as a federated Australia would have perfect legislative independence.’ In the unforeseeable future circumstances might lead Australia to separate from Britain ‘though it was to be hoped that their friendly relations would be maintained to the end of time’, but at present, federation would ‘give longer life and greater strength to the present relationship with the mother country’. Nor was he taken by the conservatives’ dream of an Imperial Federation with Britain at the centre of a parliament with representatives from all the members of the Empire. Although the scheme had once attracted him, he put it aside as impractical:
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
69
152 × 230
70 EDMUND BARTON
. . . there should be absolute equality of the peoples to be federated all over the world; they were of such various races and degrees of experience for self-government, and of such various degrees of aptitude for self-government that it would be scarcely possible to weld them together with equality of electoral rights or rights of citizenship.
In late nineteenth-century Australia there were few to gainsay such arguments. The audience received them enthusiastically, and it only remained for Sir Henry Parkes to drive home the point that the appearance of Carruthers and Barton on the same platform proved that Federation was a cause above party pettiness. The motion was carried without dissent. Difficulties soon emerged. Some of Barton’s colleagues found it hard to reconcile the promise implicit in federation of an Australiawide common market with the Protectionist aim of imposing tariffs to shield New South Wales industries and jobs against competition from elsewhere, including the rest of Australia. Parkes too came under fire from several members of his cabinet. They were already unhappy with his inveterate tendency to play his cards close to the chest, and were annoyed that Barton, an opposition frontbencher, had been consulted about federation ahead of them. In consequence, when it was finally agreed that two New South Wales representatives should travel to Melbourne in February 1890 to confer with the next meeting of the Federal Council, there was no realistic hope that Parkes would pick Barton as his companion. Instead the choice fell on the treasurer, William McMillan, who favoured federation but could be relied on to keep a careful eye on his wayward leader. Parkes had his triumph nevertheless. At the Melbourne meeting delegates from the other colonies agreed unanimously to his resolution in favour of ‘early union . . . under one legislative and executive Government’. At a banquet given by the Victorian premier Parkes responded to the toast of ‘A United Australasia’ with a memorable speech: ‘The crimson thread of kinship runs through us all . . .’ he declared. ‘We know that we represent a race . . . for the purposes of settling new colonies, which never had its equal on the face of the earth.’ Young Alfred Deakin, observing the performance, could
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
70
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 71
not withhold his admiration, but added, ‘He had always in his mind’s eye his own portrait as that of a great man, and constantly adjusted himself to it.’ On this occasion Parkes indeed touched greatness. All the colonies were now committed to a National Australasian Convention, even New Zealand and Western Australia. The doubters in New South Wales could not repudiate this initiative, even though some grumbled that Parkes and McMillan had no mandate to commit themselves to negotiating federation. The Convention was scheduled for Sydney in March 1891, with each colony sending seven delegates (although in the event New Zealand sent only three). In New South Wales four members were to be chosen from the Legislative Assembly and three from the Legislative Council. On 7 May 1890 William Suttor, squatter, author and representative of the Parkes government in the Legislative Council, proposed a motion to this effect, naming himself, Barton and the ex-premier Sir Patrick Jennings as nominees from the Upper House. Old Sir William Manning and other cautious members responded that no decision should be taken until they knew what happened in the Legislative Assembly, and this was readily agreed. The resulting delay was longer than expected, partly because of the competing claims of other business such as major strikes in the shearing sheds and on the waterfront, but also because of inept tactics by the Parkes government. If the Assembly nominated two members each from the government and the opposition Dibbs, as leader of the opposition, could not be overlooked; but he was a sceptic about federation, and one of Parkes’ colleagues was suggested in his stead. The Legislative Assembly rebelled against this interference with its prerogatives, and eventually Parkes, McMillan, Dibbs and the Speaker, Joseph Abbott, were chosen to go to the Convention. It was late September before debate resumed in the Legislative Council, and this gave time for doubters to rally. Some concentrated on the government’s lack of mandate for federation. Louis Heydon considered that New South Wales would be ‘committing a most idiotic blunder’ in entering into partnership with the rest of Australia, adding: ‘Sir Henry Parkes has no right to act as if he carried this colony in his waistcoat pocket.’ The debate was adjourned to
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
71
152 × 230
72 EDMUND BARTON
8 October to enable Barton to reply, and when he did it was one of his major speeches. He traversed once more the arguments in favour of a common market as the best means of developing national resources and enabling northern Australia to be worked without the need for cheap alien labour. He argued again the case for federation as in itself desirable, without leading either to imperial federation or republicanism. The State governments would not be reduced to insignificance, since they would still control such major areas as education, health, irrigation and public works. And, contradicting Heydon’s fears, he assured his colleagues that New South Wales could fully take part in the shaping of a federal constitution without being bound to the consequences. They would have the opportunity of scrutinising every clause before they decided if New South Wales wished to join. Unspoken was a commitment that if Barton had a hand in bringing about federation, it would be by a thorough and far-reaching process of consultation rather than Parkesian high-handedness. The Legislative Council was persuaded, but new problems immediately arose over the choice of delegates. Several members argued that they should make the selection by ballot from among all their number instead of accepting the Parkes government’s nominees. James Hawkins, a political veteran with a radical past, said that Barton and Jennings took their parliamentary duties too lightly, neither having attended the Legislative Council more than five or six times during the current session, and should be replaced by more diligent members. Barton retorted that he had in fact attended 23 times, and argued that federation was an important enough issue to require an open vote. By a majority of one, however, members preferred Dr Andrew Garran’s view that by holding a ballot they would affirm the status of federation as a parliamentary movement. Having made its point the Legislative Council then endorsed the three original nominees, Suttor receiving 31 votes, Barton 27 and Jennings 21. There followed a good deal of desultory debate about the New South Wales government’s power to amend the constitution once drafted. A 16 to 13 majority supported Barton and Garran, against the Parkes government’s ministers, in devising a formula of words which would enable amendments to be suggested without
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
72
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 73
implying acceptance or rejection of the whole constitution. In this way New South Wales committed itself to participate in the federal experiment. During the summer of 1890–91 Barton prepared himself for the Convention by three months of incessant study, probably at the expense of his legal practice. (It may have helped that the Athenaeum Club was closed for repairs after a fire in October.) Barton was not the only politician in training for the Convention, as Griffith in Brisbane, Inglis Clark in Hobart, and Charles Cameron Kingston in Adelaide were each trying their hands at designing a federal Constitution. By 12 February Inglis Clark was far enough advanced to send copies of his draft to Parkes and Barton. Kingston’s version, leaving more power to the States, was in their hands before the end of the month. Parkes, who confessed ‘I have some dread of literary Constitutions’ did not find time to study these drafts. Consequently Barton, although he circulated no drafts, came to the Convention as by far the best briefed of the New South Wales delegates, and the only one able to match Griffith, Clark and Kingston in familiarity with the outlines of a potential Australian Constitution. These outlines drew on the earlier models of the United States and Canada and foreshadowed the essentials of Australia’s twentiethcentury Constitution. There should be a governor-general representing the monarch as head of state, a Senate representing the States, a House of Representatives elected on a population basis, and a federal Supreme Court of at least ten judges as the highest court of appeal and constitutional interpretation. The Canadian Constitution was seen as leaving too little authority to the provinces and by contrast the Australians preferred to nominate specific powers to the federal government with the States controlling the residue. This left the federal government’s areas of responsibility open for debate. Defence, tariffs and trade were the irreducible minimum, but there would be some bread-and-butter issues such as posts and telegraphs, and Kingston’s list added industrial relations. In the upshot it was Parkes who, as premier of the host colony, took it for granted that he should present the initial resolutions for discussion by the Convention. At the end of February, he circulated them in draft to Barton and the
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
73
152 × 230
74 EDMUND BARTON
other delegates, whom he then called together for a meeting at his private house. Their draft was to set the debate rolling. The New South Wales working party gave most thought to the relations between the two houses of parliament. As in the existing colonial parliaments, governments should survive or fall according to their ability to command a majority in the popularly elected lower house. To ensure that the other States did not feel swamped by Victoria and New South Wales the Senate should consist of an equal number of members from each province. Where Inglis Clark proposed that Australia, following the practice at that time in the United States, should have senators chosen by the State parliaments, the New South Wales group insisted that the Senate should be elected directly by the voters. The democratic effect of this change was weakened by proposing that senators should be elected for a term of no less than 21 years, one-third retiring every seventh year; a recipe for slow turnover of membership and an inbuilt tendency towards conservatism, but preferable to the Canadian Senate whose members were nominated for life. It was clear that this issue would require much more thinking through. The New South Wales working party also suggested adding to the federal government’s powers the right to pass legislation facilitating the development of waste lands in the tropics and elsewhere. When Parkes took these recommendations to his fellow premiers (augmented for the occasion by Inglis Clark and Kingston) in a private meeting at the start of the Convention, they cut out this contentious idea. They also removed any reference to a specific term of office for senators and dropped the quota of ten judges for the Supreme Court, but otherwise accepted the resolutions as a basis for debate. On the wet and windy morning of Monday 2 March 1891, about three dozen delegates converged on Sydney’s Parliament House for the Convention. Perhaps reflecting the weather they were a sombre assembly, ‘recognising probably’, speculated the Herald, ‘the fact that they were engaged in making history’. They did not make much history that morning as they met only for an hour to sign the roll and elect Parkes as president and Griffith as vice-president. A banquet that evening in the Sydney Town Hall with ladies present (including Jeanie Barton) did a good deal to lighten the atmosphere.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
74
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 75
By the second day strangeness had worn off and the delegates were reported as feeling at home with one another. They fenced a little around such questions as the president’s casting vote, with Barton arguing from his experience as Speaker that the president should exercise a casting vote in such a way as to keep questions open for further consideration; but eventually it was decided that if a vote resulted in a tie it should be taken as negative. On Wednesday morning (4 March) Parkes brought forward the resolutions drafted by the New South Wales party and amended by the premiers, and serious debate began. Griffith, as vice-president, came first. He would be in effect the pilot of the Convention, and in terms of leadership experience, legal capacity and intellectual dominance he stood unchallenged. At 46 he was at the turning-point of his career. The ‘lean, impatient idealist’ who courted the working class and outraged the sugar planters by putting an end to the traffic in indentured Kanakas, who had seemed to a shrewd observer ‘full of fun and very frank’, was giving way to an icy and unabashed pragmatist. He had recently entered into a coalition with his arch-rival the capitalist Sir Thomas McIlwraith, would shortly restore the Melanesian labour trade, and in the very weeks of the Convention left his colleagues in Queensland confronting a major shearers’ strike with armed police and military. The shearers flew the Eureka flag and talked of a republic, but Griffith was intent on fostering another kind of Australian nationalism where conflict would be resolved under the rule of law. At Sydney in 1891 he and his fellow delegates faced the challenge of creating a Constitution based on the rule of law but responsive to the generous emotions of popular nationalism. As much because of his temperament as his ideas, Barton would help to effect that reconciliation. Since eight or nine members had yet to turn up, including the entire Western Australian delegation, the early sessions of the Convention lasted only for about two hours each day, with one prominent member giving an overview of the issues he thought important. Taking the initiative, Griffith pointed out with impressive lucidity that the central federal question was the relationship of the Senate as States’ house with a House of Representatives
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
75
152 × 230
76 EDMUND BARTON
chosen on the democratic criterion of ‘one-vote-one-value’. If the Senate’s powers were weaker than those of the Lower House, the smaller States would feel over-ridden by Victoria and New South Wales; but if the two houses were co-equal this could be seen as negating the majority will. As a good Queenslander Griffith favoured a strong Senate, but above all he insisted on the need for clarity on this point. Next day Alfred Deakin rose to refute him. At 34 the youngest member of the Convention by several years, Deakin was already old in political experience. He had served in the Victorian parliament for more than eleven years, seven of them as a highly innovative and successful cabinet minister. His credentials as nationalist and democrat were good. In London in 1887 at a ministerial conference he had stood up for Australia’s interests boldly against the august British prime minister Lord Salisbury, where Griffith and other Antipodeans had behaved more compliantly. Now as a good democrat he argued that in cases of conflict between the two houses of parliament the Senate should yield to the House of Representatives. As Victoria had the biggest population of any Australasian colony Deakin had less to lose by taking such a line than a Tasmanian or South Australian. Although he put his case with charm and eloquence he did not carry all his hearers with him. It was Barton who moved the adjournment of the debate so that on the next morning (6 March) he might reply on behalf of States’ rights. At the beginning, according to a reporter, Barton ‘was calm and dignified, speaking with extreme slowness, as if he wished to give the delegates ample time to weigh over and comprehend his utterances’. He began with the uncontroversial theme of an Australian common market, suggesting that if necessary the diverse tariffs of the various colonies could be amalgamated gradually over time; a typical example of his ‘softly, softly’ approach and one which would eventually help to bring Western Australia into the federation. It was only when he came to the question of States’ rights that his speech warmed up. No scheme of federation could work, Barton argued, without the goodwill of the contracting parties. This meant conserving the rights of the several States. Hence the Senate should
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
76
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 77
have full power, even a veto on money and taxation bills, and should be popularly elected. Illustrating his theme, he raised a question avoided by previous speakers, the site of the federal capital. This issue necessarily had financial implications, but unless the Senate had power of veto in detail it would be practically helpless to influence the outcome. He nevertheless stressed that a government enjoying a majority in the House of Representatives should be able to carry on in office without the Senate’s favour. Finally he strongly urged that the Australian Supreme Court should have full power to enforce its decrees throughout Australia, and—it would be a favourite theme with him—should become the final court of appeal, without further recourse to the Privy Council in London. He admitted that the British had refused this power to Canada but, as the Herald reporter put it: ‘Mr Barton is brave, and urges that the power is one which we should ask, even if we never expect to get it.’ Barton’s speech made a marked impression on the Convention. The South Australian ex-premier, Sir John Downer, who followed him, complimented him highly and endorsed his views; it was the beginning of a lasting friendship. During the ensuing week all but nine of the delegates spoke, most endorsing Barton’s concept of States’ rights, although the Victorians remained largely opposed to equal powers for the Senate and cheered when in his summing up Parkes came down on their side. When the Convention went into committee to consider the detailed wording of the resolutions this was the issue that had most potential for breaking up the meeting. Before the moment came to grapple with it Barton, who was playing a prominent part in the organisation of business, raised a different matter. He persuaded the Convention to adopt a new resolution providing that no new State could be formed by subdividing or uniting any part of the existing colonies without the consent of both the federal parliament and the appropriate State legislature. In thus safeguarding the existing boundaries of the colonies he may have been earning the goodwill of Griffith, who as vice-president was precluded from pushing special interests, but who as premier of Queensland was facing lively separation movements from the north and centre. On 16 March, their tempers by no means soothed by a weekend voyage on the Hawkesbury, the delegates met to debate a proposal
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
77
152 × 230
78 EDMUND BARTON
by Sir John Downer giving the Senate a veto on money bills. Earnest debate followed. Parkes implored Downer not to press the issue. Munro, the Victorian premier, threatened to walk out if the Senate veto were approved. Late in the afternoon Barton moved the adjournment of the debate, thus allowing tempers to cool overnight and also positioning himself as first speaker in the morning. It was a critical moment. In championing the Senate, Barton said he ‘did not intend to make a fighting speech, carrying the olive branch rather than the sword’. However they framed their constitution, he said, they would have to rely on the discretion and good sense of those who had to work it. Having rebuked the undignified spirit of those like Munro who refused to work for compromise, he asked the Convention to find a middle way between too much and too little power for the Senate while preserving the principle of no taxation without representation. ‘Taken right through’, wrote the Herald, ‘Mr Barton’s speech was most temperate and conciliatory in its tone, and had a marked effect in quieting the atmosphere of the Convention.’ Old Sir George Grey from New Zealand, Griffith and William McMillan all supported the appeal for compromise and it was agreed to leave the question undecided while the delegates formed themselves into sub-committees. Only one delegate, Queensland’s Macrossan, with the prophetic foresight of a dying man, predicted that senators would vote according to party allegiance rather than State loyalty so that ‘the idea of the larger states being overwhelmed by the voting of the smaller states might very well be abandoned . . .’ This crisis negotiated, the time was now ripe for detailed analysis. Barton moved on 18 March for the formation of three committees: a constitutional committee, with two members from each delegation, and two subordinate committees on finance and judiciary which would report to it. Griffith was chosen chairman of the constitutional committee, with Parkes, Barton, Deakin, Inglis Clark and Downer all among its members. This was clearly the most important of the three working groups and it was here that the compromise was hammered out that the Senate might affirm or reject money bills, but could not amend them (although it might make suggestions for change to the House of Representatives). Barton’s part in resolving this issue,
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
78
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 79
or his part in the rather more heated discussion over calling the new nation ‘the Commonwealth of Australia’ cannot be traced since the committee worked in camera. (He certainly favoured the term ‘Commonwealth’ as ‘the noblest word ever invented to designate a free state’.) Deakin, writing to a friend on 25 March, complained: ‘Barton is an able but lazy man who has attended our Committee irregularly and with frequent absences.’ This is consistent with complaints made about Barton at other times. He was always one to skip the duller stretches of committee work, reserving his effort for major occasions. But Deakin also named Barton, with Griffith and Inglis Clark, as useful forces for compromise. It may be that Barton’s enthusiasm for defending the Senate cooled somewhat when he failed to persuade the committee that the Upper House should be popularly elected; instead they went back to the United States model of a Senate with members nominated by each State parliament. Yet it was no reflection on Barton’s performance that he was not chosen by the constitutional committee as one of the three-man drafting party charged with putting together the finished version of the Constitution. Griffith as chairman was essential; Inglis Clark and Kingston had prepared the first drafts circulated in February. They aimed at having a printed draft in readiness by 26 March, the Thursday before Easter. This would be distributed confidentially to their colleagues on the committee and during the long weekend the drafting party would make the final push towards a complete document. They would secure privacy by working aboard the Lucinda, the Queensland government steamer on which Griffith had travelled from Brisbane. Then Inglis Clark succumbed to influenza and, at the last moment on the Thursday morning, Barton was invited to replace him on the Lucinda. It was a lucky break for Barton, though at the time it must have played havoc with his family’s Easter arrangements. By Good Friday morning, nevertheless, he was with the others travelling from Port Jackson to the Hawkesbury estuary, where despite rough weather they found anchorage ‘in a most lovely place called Refuge Bay’. In addition to the drafting party Griffith also invited Sir John Downer, Victoria’s Sir Henry Wrixon and his own legal colleague from Queensland, A. J. Thynne. As La Nauze comments, ‘The party represented all
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
79
152 × 230
80 EDMUND BARTON
the colonies except Western Australia and New Zealand whose delegates did not include a practising lawyer.’ There was also one favoured unofficial guest, young B. R. Wise (who was seasick). Throughout Friday evening, Saturday and Sunday morning the drafting party laboured intensively in the gentlemen’s smoking-room in the upper fore-cabin; thirteen hours non-stop on the Saturday. It was naughty, but understandable, for the frustrated Inglis Clark to describe the cruise as a ‘picnic’, though no doubt Griffith and Barton allowed themselves an occasional whisky to solace the labours of composition; Kingston, who was not a drinking man, found no scope for his besetting weakness in the all-male environment of the Lucinda. Griffith chose his words significantly in describing Barton’s role: Mr Barton . . . devoted himself to that work as strenuously and industriously as any man with whom I have ever had the pleasure of working, and I venture to say that I have done a good deal of hard work in my time.
One hopes that Alfred Deakin was impressed by testimony from such a source. The Lucinda returned to Sydney Harbour on Sunday, picked up the convalescent Inglis Clark, and the drafting was finished in time for the printer that evening. To Clark’s disappointment the High Court was not entrenched in the Constitution, as in the United States, but was left for establishment by the Commonwealth parliament. Nor (and here Barton must have shared his disappointment) would appeals to the Privy Council be abolished. Griffith, like the majority of the Australian legal profession at that time, had too great a respect for British judicial tradition to consent to such a radical step. In the upshot the High Court would be the final court of appeal except in matters affecting the public interests of the Commonwealth or the States, which might go to the Privy Council. On Easter Monday the drafting group submitted their work to the full constitutional committee, who approved it without major changes. It was this draft Constitution, more lucidly and tautly phrased than earlier versions, which Griffith would steer through the full Convention during its final week.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
80
152 × 230
‘My Bristles are Up’ 81
The Lucinda draft survived virtually intact. The compromise about the Senate’s powers was accepted by a 2 to 1 margin, the limitation of appeals to the Privy Council more narrowly. A brisk debate developed over the qualifications of voters for the House of Representatives, as Griffith resisted a motion for the introduction of one-man-one-vote as interfering with the powers of States such as Queensland which still had plural voting. Barton defused the situation by pointing out that the Convention need not impose a formula. At the outset federal elections could take place under existing State laws, but there would be nothing to prevent the Commonwealth legislating uniform qualifications for all Australian voters, as in fact would happen when Barton was prime minister. He failed to persuade the Convention to resolve to this effect, because some delegates such as the Queenslanders were touchy about yielding this power and others feared that the Commonwealth might legislate to reduce voting rights. One or two minor snags arose; Dibbs, for instance, made a mischievous attempt to insist that the federal capital should be Sydney. By 9 April the Convention was ready to adopt a constitution which in every essential respect was the Australian Commonwealth Constitution of 1900. This document would go to the parliaments of the various colonies so that they might submit it for the approval of the people. It was easy for Griffith to move this proposal and for the Convention to accept it, harder to see how it would be carried into effect. Without having experienced the weeks of concentrated thought that went into the framing of the Constitution, politicians and voters in the Australasian colonies could not be expected to share the federal vision. Few knew the continent in all its diversity; so keen an advocate of federation as Barton himself had never been out of New South Wales apart from rare visits to Melbourne and Brisbane. Local interests conflicted. New Zealand was separated from the other colonies by the Tasman Sea, and gave its Maoris a stronger place in politics than the lowly status accorded Australia’s Aborigines. Western Australia was marginalised by an even longer sea voyage, and having just attained self-government at the end of 1890 would be reluctant to surrender this belated privilege. Queensland was beset by separation movements based on Townsville and
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
81
152 × 230
82 EDMUND BARTON
Rockhampton whose outcome would affect the shape of any federation. Like New South Wales, Queensland was also in the throes of industrial strife which would soon bring Labor into politics, and for many working-class representatives the struggle for better pay and conditions took priority over a distant ideal of federation, which might only help the bosses to combine more efficiently. Rivalry between New South Wales and Victoria itched as Sydney began to overtake Melbourne as Australia’s largest city. It would require a patient process of argument and education to overcome all these impediments to the making of an Australian Commonwealth. Nevertheless the Convention was a success. Its members had confronted most of the major problems of federation and had produced an agreed Constitution. They had not voted en bloc as delegations but set the model of how an Australian legislature might work. Undeniably Sir Samuel Griffith was the leading architect of this success. Barton’s reputation too was greatly enhanced by his constructive role in facilitating business, by his energetic participation in the drafting committee, and above all by the two well-timed speeches in which he swayed the mood of the Convention and set his colleagues thinking on many of the solutions which eventually made federation practicable. As with many of the other delegates, the experience of close and lengthy contact with some of his ablest contemporaries from all parts of Australia and New Zealand broadened his views and sharpened his ideas. His enthusiasm fuelled by the Convention, Barton sought a more active role in public life. ‘My bristles are all up over Federation’, he wrote to Piddington shortly after the Convention. Soon his opportunity would arise but nearly a decade would elapse before the goal was reached.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
82
152 × 230
5
Slow Progress Slow Progress
E
the Convention dispersed the opponents of federation were mobilising. On 15 April 1891 old Sir John Robertson chaired a meeting of the electors of East Sydney. Dibbs was on the platform and Reid the lead speaker. He said that the New South Wales delegates had allowed the other colonies to drive too hard a bargain. The compromise over the Senate’s powers was no compromise at all, but a surrender to the junior colonies, and the governor-general’s role was too loosely defined. He also claimed that the other States could gang up to take territory from New South Wales. Barton thought Reid showed ‘extreme ignorance of his subject’, and on 24 April at the Aquarium Hall, Manly, refuted his arguments in what seems to have been one of his best speeches. Taking his audience step by step through the draft Constitution he showed that the governor-general’s powers were in fact carefully defined and that the break-up of existing States without their consent was not possible. As for the Senate, it was impossible to predict how the balance of population between States would be in the future and, in any case, the sole right of initiating taxation remained with the House of Representatives. There would inevitably be disagreements between the two Houses but, remarked Barton in a phrase still relevant a hundred years later, ‘deadlocks and collisions were the price which nations paid for Liberty’. VEN BEFORE
83
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
83
152 × 230
84 EDMUND BARTON
Barton’s speech brought him congratulations from across Australia. Deakin called it ‘masterly’. Griffith thought Reid’s statements wild and wrote to him about them, producing a rather tart exchange of correspondence. Winthrop Hackett, editor of The West Australian, liked Barton’s speech but still felt that he would have his work cut out to convince New South Wales. As for the West, Forrest was almost alone in favour of federation, ‘the public feeling against amounting to frenzy’. Reid returned to the attack during May. The Victorians, he claimed, would use intercolonial free trade to poach traffic from the New South Wales railways. They and the Queenslanders might even have designs on New South Wales territory. Some of this was scaremongering, aimed at boosting Reid’s reputation as guardian of New South Wales interests and future premier, against his federalist competitors, Parkes, McMillan and Barton. He was especially concerned that Parkes would hijack the Free Trade Party in the interests of federation and divert it from its historic role of keeping tariffs and costs low. This concern was realistic. During these weeks Parkes was sounding out Barton, and possibly others, about the formation of a ginger group promoting federation, to be known as ‘the Australian Unionists’. Its members would be drawn from both freetraders and protectionists, prepared to agree that ‘the fiscal battle . . . should be fought out on the wider and higher stage of a new political life’. So constituted, ‘the Australian Unionists’ had the potential to become a new political party, and before the end of May Parkes was openly urging this to Barton. The days had passed when a faction leader like Parkes could abandon old allies to broker a new combination. Although a Herald editorial claimed a few weeks earlier that the fiscal question was fading out of public life, Parkes’ colleagues in the Free Trade Party could not be expected to see things in the same light, especially with the advent of a Labor Electoral League challenging both the old parties. Events left the old premier behind. When parliament resumed on 19 May Parkes intended making a federation bill the first item of regular business. Reid with his talent for the pre-emptive strike moved an amendment to the address-in-reply, affirming support for federation on just principles but condemning the shortcomings of the draft Constitution. Reid’s motion was defeated, but Parkes
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
84
152 × 230
Slow Progress 85
was taken aback, and in what Barton later termed ‘an error of judgement’ decided to postpone the federation bill. Sensing weakness, Dibbs at once launched a motion of no confidence. Reid and a few free-traders supported it, and it was lost only on the Speaker’s casting vote. Parliament was dissolved and an election scheduled for June 1891. Federation, which Parkes hoped would crown his career, in fact hastened his ultimate fall from power. Barton resigned from the Upper House in order to contest his old seat of East Sydney in the Legislative Assembly. He was labelled a protectionist, but the choice facing the voters was somewhat complex. Parkes persisted in setting up a ‘Free Trade and Federation Organizing Committee’ to fight the elections and as its four candidates for East Sydney the committee endorsed a ticket of two free-trade federationists (William McMillan and Sir Henry’s son Varney Parkes) and two protectionists (Barton and the mayor of Sydney, W. P. Manning). This had the effect of squeezing out Reid, one of the Free Trade sitting members, and guaranteed that the election would be robustly fought, even by the standards of the time. Barton campaigned on the slogan of ‘Federation first, protection afterwards’, opposed to both Dibbs and Reid. He asked his audience ‘whether they would leave to their children a grand, free nation, or the obloquy of having made it part of a large island’. Andrew Garran, editor of the Sydney Morning Herald, thought that Barton gave the federal movement ‘valuable intellectual and moral aid. He has shown how when face to face with a great occasion an earnest politician can lay party claims and limitations aside’. Stung by Reid’s criticisms, Barton insisted that the Convention bill was still open to change, and dismissed Dibbs with the quip: ‘When Mr Dibbs says he has ‘‘no policy to disclose’’ one is led to doubt whether the policy is absent or the courage to disclose it. Mr Dibbs is a daily conundrum. What can we do but give him up?’ Barton’s campaign attracted audiences of between 500 and over 1000. On nomination day, however, when those present were invited to choose members by a show of hands, the verdict was for Reid, McMillan, Varney Parkes and a Labor candidate named Grantham. Barton called for a poll, as was customary, and this produced a different result. McMillan, although severely heckled during his campaign, topped
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
85
152 × 230
86 EDMUND BARTON
the poll. Barton came next, followed by Varney Parkes, and Reid was lucky to secure fourth place. It seemed a heartening endorsement of the federation idea. Party alliances following the election were far from clear. ‘You will require all your presence of mind during the coming chaos,’ a friend wrote to Barton. Labor did unexpectedly well, returning 35 members who held the balance of power between 47 free-traders and 51 protectionists. But the Labor men were split almost evenly between free-traders and protectionists and the party had not yet developed its tradition of strict caucus solidarity. Having successfully wooed Labor support with a package including federation, an arbitration system and electoral reform based on one-man-one-vote, Parkes decided to stay in office, but his tenure was precarious. His competent but conservative treasurer, McMillan, chafed at the Labor alliance and within two months would resign from cabinet. Reid led an openly mutinous squad of free-traders. Barton’s stance seemed ambiguous. He had served in the 1889 Dibbs ministry and was termed a protectionist but the Herald, analysing the new parliament, classed him as a Parkes supporter. When Dibbs, apparently disregarding Barton’s advice, at once moved a motion of no confidence, Barton made a lengthy speech agonising about the choice between his respected colleague Dibbs and Parkes, whom he believed more likely to get the federation legislation through. In the upshot he voted with Parkes. In an era of loose party discipline he could play this waiting game without injuring his prospects with either major party. Parkes thought it worthwhile early in August 1891, following McMillan’s resignation, to try to entice Barton into his cabinet, and once more Barton refused, though he promised warm support to the early introduction of a federation bill. Because of the differences of opinion within cabinet Parkes was slow to bring down the promised legislation, and in September the opposition seized the initiative by moving that protective duties should be imposed on imports that competed with local manufactures. Barton moved an amendment to the effect that, because federation would bring a uniform tariff to Australia, the financial needs of New South Wales should govern the methods of raising revenue ‘rather than the rigid doctrines of
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
86
152 × 230
Slow Progress 87
any system of political economy’. This amendment was carried with the support of the Labor members, and the Parkes ministry survived another few weeks. The final blow fell in October 1891. Among the measures designed to please Labor was a bill regulating employment in coal mines. One of its clauses called for ventilation for each miner at the rate of 100 cubic feet of pure air. Labor successfully moved for an increase to 150 cubic feet. But only one-third of the members of the Legislative Assembly were present when this amendment passed (among them Barton, who opposed it). On 15 October McMillan moved for the re-committal of the relevant clause and another prescribing a maximum eight-hour working day. Parkes supported him, but the Labor members were outraged and a confused and acrimonious debate ensued. In his prime Parkes would have manoeuvred his way out of the crisis, but he was old and tired and, at some point in the debate, he drafted a letter of resignation from the premiership and from the Legislative Assembly. There followed one of the legendary scenes of Australian political history. Parkes called Barton into the ministers’ room and showed him his letter of resignation. As Parkes later told the story, Barton talked him out of quitting. ‘He said: ‘‘Oh don’t do that: what is to become of Federation?’’ I answered, ‘‘You are young and strong, you must take up Federation.’’ ’ Twenty years later B. R. Wise elaborated on the story: M
And he added, in reply to Mr Barton’s question, ‘Why this should be asked of him’, that ‘He himself was unable to carry it through because his health was so precarious that, whatever might be the result of that night’s proceedings, it was absolutely necessary for him to retire from Office and probably from public life. He was living in dread of a paralytic stroke. It was his intention to retire at once; and the conduct of the federal movement must devolve upon Mr Barton.’
The latter accepted the mantle of leadership thus informally cast upon his shoulders. Wise wrote his account after consultation with Barton, and later historians have followed him in identifying this as the moment
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
87
152 × 230
88 EDMUND BARTON
when Barton’s destiny as leader of the federal movement was sealed. To a generation brought up on the Old Testament—probably to Parkes himself—the scene suggested the aged Moses, within sight of the Promised Land which he was destined not to enter, handing over the leadership of Israel to the vigorous young Joshua. But Barton’s credentials as leader of the federation movement did not depend on Parkes’ blessing. In the eyes of the press and the public he was already known as the keenest of federationists, one who asserted ‘the super-eminent importance of the object of federation over any other issue’. It may simply be that William Barton’s son knew how to behave discreetly in the presence of old gentlemen behaving grandiosely. Or, judging by events later that evening, it may be that Parkes and Barton’s conversation was more down-to-earth. Aged and fatigued though he was, Parkes may have hoped that Barton would throw himself into the creation of a federal party in the legislature in which there would be room for an elder statesman like himself, nominated for life to the Legislative Council. His conduct during the remainder of the debate suggests that Parkes had some such possibility in mind. At one point, having slapped down a cheeky young Labor member with much of his old sharpness, Parkes could not resist hinting: If I were out of this House to-morrow I should be just the same Henry Parkes as I am now; but my voice in this country would be just as great—probably greater . . . Possibly my influence for good would be much greater if relieved from office and a seat in this House.
It was a convincing valedictory, received with applause. Shortly after midnight Barton moved the adjournment of the debate. This was a favourite manoeuvre of his when time was needed for the cooling of tempers and the negotiation of compromises, but on this occasion it may have been prearranged with Parkes, since the premier at once said that he would treat the defeat of Barton’s motion as one of no confidence. As Barton was not even a member of the government party there was no need for Parkes to take this line unless he was deliberately forcing the issue—perhaps in the hope that Barton
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
88
152 × 230
Slow Progress 89
would be asked to form the next ministry? The amendment was rejected by 41 votes to 49 amid considerable excitement, and the last Parkes ministry was at an end. The newspapers saw Barton as a potential premier. The Herald reported rumours that the governor, Lord Jersey, would send for him. Lachlan Brient in the Daily Telegraph resurrected a favourite theme, urging a coalition between the two non-Labor parties under ‘one of the active party men, but one occupying rather a neutral position— say Mr Barton’. When the governor sent for Dibbs, as leader of the opposition, Parkes at once lost all enthusiasm for a move to the Legislative Council. Unlike Moses, he was beginning to have undignified second thoughts. He remained in the Legislative Assembly, and his last years would be spent scrabbling for the power which he had abdicated, lashing out against the younger generation, against Reid who usurped the Free Trade Party and against Barton who supplanted him in the federation movement. It did not suit Dibbs to form a cabinet with Barton on the loose as an Independent and although some thought that Barton’s recent friendliness to Parkes might have disqualified him, Dibbs invited Barton to serve as attorney-general. After four days Barton refused. Astutely, Dibbs then offered the position to Sir Julian Salomons, an outspoken antagonist of federation. Salomons would accept only an honorary cabinet post as vice-president of the executive council, and this left it open to Dibbs to renew his overture to Barton. Alert to the risk that the new government might be dominated by enemies of federation, this time Barton accepted. He made it a condition that he would be allowed to promote the cause of federation. He also secured an agreement that the new government would not propose protective duties exceeding an average of 10 per cent, hoping that this would prevent the creation of local vested interests likely to oppose federation. And countering the anti-federal element in Dibbs’ team, his close friend and ally Richard O’Connor entered the ministry as minister for justice and solicitor-general. Remembering how recently Barton had dismissed Dibbs as a conundrum, the press and the political world were startled. The Telegraph, crediting Barton with influence over the Labor members, thought he would be ‘a tower of strength’ to the Dibbs government,
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
89
152 × 230
90 EDMUND BARTON
but added: ‘Has Mr Dibbs abandoned the idea of internal protection, or has Mr Barton bidden farewell to federation?’ The Herald feared that he had made ‘a calamitous mistake’. More than 20 years later, reflecting on his decision, Barton commented: ‘I have often doubted the wisdom of the course I took in accepting office, but on the outlook of the time I think there was in it less visible danger to the Federation movement than in any other which was possible.’ The economy slid into depression. The export price of wool, the main staple of New South Wales, had dropped steadily since 1886. The British money market was jittery about overseas investment since Barings, a major financier in South America, had collapsed in 1890, and Australian securities were tainted by wild over-speculation in the Melbourne land boom. The parlous condition of government finances made it inevitable that tariffs would have to be increased to raise revenue: ‘I had to acknowledge then, that finance must take precedence over Federation, for it demanded immediate settlement.’ Barton was also weighing up his long-term strategy: There was a majority in the House against the Federal Bill of 1891 (probably against any sort of Federation) and to have rushed that measure forward would have ensured its defeat. The only resort was to work steadily towards parliamentary suggestions of amendments, a second convention to consider them, and finally a popular vote . . . There were, of course, some who strewed tacks in my path, and I certainly had to pick my way.
Of his new cabinet colleagues, Dibbs kept his bargain honourably. O’Connor, John See, the treasurer, and Henry Copeland, minister for lands (‘a very rough diamond indeed’), supported Barton. Suttor, the minister for education, was undecided, William Lyne, minister for public works, was unenthusiastic, and Thomas Slattery, minister for mines, distinctly obstructive. In these circumstances Barton had a very clear view of the process necessary to keep the federation movement alive, although neither he nor any of his colleagues seems to have appreciated how long it would take. Many believed that Barton would not be able to promote federation while a member of a government intending to increase tariffs on the produce of the other Australian colonies. It was customary
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
90
152 × 230
Slow Progress 91
for newly appointed cabinet ministers to go to a by-election, as having accepted an office of profit under the Crown. Usually, although not invariably, this was a formality. All the Dibbs ministry except Barton were returned unopposed. But East Sydney was a traditional stronghold of free trade, and leading members of the Free Trade Party such as Bernhard Wise and George Reid thought that Barton might be vulnerable because of his shifting record on the tariff issue and his independent stance in the last parliamentary session. A candidate was found in William Grantham, the Labor man who had polled respectably at the general election in June. For the fourth time Barton took to the campaign trail in East Sydney. He began on 30 October with a packed meeting at the Masonic Hall. At the end John Norton, editor and proprietor of Truth, emphatic and erratic democrat, and a remarkably skilful gutter journalist, moved ‘that this meeting neither approves of nor condones Mr Barton’s inclusion in the Ministry’. He was met with groans and hooting, with cries of ‘Chuck him out!’, and Norton’s motion lapsed for want of a seconder. It was not the last time that Norton would snap disconcertingly at Barton’s heels. The election campaign lasted a week. Grantham plugged away doggedly at Barton’s readiness to hold back on federation in the interests of tariff protection, and the Herald seemed to share these misgivings. But Barton’s meetings were large and enthusiastic and, although the turnout was not as great as it had been in June, he was returned by a margin of 2778 votes to 1112. Barton was perhaps fortunate that Reid, his ablest critic, was away for the last few days of the by-election campaign, having gone to Wangaratta to get married. On 17 November Reid was chosen leader of the Free Trade Party, the only nominee for the post after Wise stood down. He assured his party that he was not opposed to federation, but only in the form embodied in Parkes’ proposal. This statement left room for compromise in future, but it mollified neither Barton nor Parkes. Reid at once tried to unseat the Dibbs government with a motion of no confidence framed in terms designed to attract Labor support. In the result the Labor group split in half between its protectionist and free-trade wings. The Dibbs government survived by an eightvote margin, enough to give promise of running a full term.
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
91
152 × 230
92 EDMUND BARTON
Barton found his position demanding. After twelve years in parliament he could pass as a veteran politician, but for practically all that time he had operated on the sidelines as a rising backbencher, as Speaker, as a member of the Legislative Council. Yet his reputation was impressive enough for some to speak of him as a potential premier. A man of his temperament and classical background probably remembered how it had been said of the Emperor Galba, ‘omni consensu capax imperii nisi imperasset’ (‘everyone thought he would be a good ruler until he got the job’). It was challenging to be a senior minister in a partisan government, up against a leader of the opposition like Reid, who knew his strengths and weaknesses thoroughly, and was much more experienced and agile in the cut and thrust of debate. Barton was a good formal speaker when prepared, presenting his arguments with an impressive and forceful logic tempered by humour. He was less good at impromptu repartee and when under-prepared lapsed into verbosity. In the current parliamentary session he could leave Dibbs and See to take the lead in steering the tariff increases through parliament but he would have the main responsibility for a major electoral reform bill essential for keeping Labor support. This bill would confirm ‘one-man-one-vote’, break up the Legislative Assembly into single-member constituencies, and put an end to the practice of spreading general elections over three weeks, so that a candidate beaten in one electorate could seek refuge in another. Much of the preparatory work would have to be done by Barton himself, since he had inherited a permanent head of the attorney-general’s department of notoriously slack habits, ‘Bobby Mainwaring, with only one talent—that of putting letters into the wrong envelopes’. Barton summed up the easygoing office routine in a piece of doggerel: From 10 to 1 From 2 to 3 That from 3 to 4
There’s nothing done; We begin to see There’ll be nothing more!
But he was too soft-hearted to address the difficulties of ousting Mainwaring in favour of a more active replacement, and relied instead on his own efforts and O’Connor’s. However, by April 1893
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
92
152 × 230
Slow Progress 93
he was able to claim reforms in the department which would save the taxpayer £10 000 a year. Barton’s promotion to the ministry called for a more convenient address than ‘Calahla’. Late in 1891 the family moved to Manly when Edmund, feeling sorry for a friend’s widow who had a house to rent, once again committed himself without consulting Jeanie. For so tactful a man Edmund was surprisingly obtuse in some matters. Although less isolated, the house was near the top of a steep hill and was too small for the family, whose number was increasing to six (Leila Stephanie, the youngest child and second daughter, was born in August 1892). Jeanie continued to speak her mind on the subject, inspiring her husband to draw up a mock advertisement in which he sketched:
MRS BARTON’S MODEL ADVERTISEMENT Wanted, an elegantly furnished Residence, built of stone and marble, Cottage style preferred: square-built but of the Queen Anne order, with a touch of Elizabethan and a dash of Swiss. Must contain not less than 20 rooms, but must at the same time have extensive panoramic views from all windows and be in an elevated breezy position. A perfectly flat and level situation with an ample fall for drainage will be indispensable. Must be well in the country, but not more than 10 minutes’ walk of the General Post Office and handy to all trams, omnibuses, trains and ferries. No place with less than half a mile of water frontage will be looked at, but the enervating sea breeze must be entirely absent. Facilities for lawn tennis, riding, shooting, boating and fishing must be combined. A steam launch, a yacht, a carriage and pair and assortment of tricycles must be part of the furniture. There must be a tower but no stairs, and the dangerous appliance called a lift will not be entertained, while the roof must be flat and easily accessible. Flower and kitchen garden and orchard required, grounds not to be less than
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
93
152 × 230
94 EDMUND BARTON
20 acres, such as one man can easily keep in order and at the same time have plenty of leisure for grooming, driving, managing the yacht and launch and catching bait. Rent not to exceed £75 per annum, taxes paid.
Jeanie must have found the teasing affectionate, as years later when they were burning old letters she insisted on preserving the ‘advertisement’ as a keepsake. It provides one of the rare glimpses into the Bartons’ home life in those years. The political scene was admittedly preoccupying. As many an incoming government has claimed before and since, the Dibbs ministry discovered that the financial situation was worse than its predecessors had admitted. The quickest, indeed the only way of improving the revenue without the radically controversial measure of income tax, was an increase in tariffs on a wide variety of imports. This was consistent with protectionism, but hit at imports from the other Australian colonies, and exposed Barton to criticisms from free-trader sources as an insincere federationist. When the financial statement was introduced in December 1891 Reid, from the first an aggressive leader of the opposition, brought down a motion of censure attacking the raising of the tariff issue before the one-man-one-vote principle was secured. Reid hoped to bring the Labor members back into line behind his Free Trade Party, but they were almost evenly split over the tariff issue, and the motion failed. After several weeks of debate, including two marathon sittings of 36 hours each, the government pushed through its tariff with a comfortable majority. Business confidence continued to falter during the early months of 1892 and in February rumour-mongering provoked a run on the Savings Bank of New South Wales, stemmed only by Dibbs’ repeated insistence that the bank was solvent. Against this darkening economy it was hard to argue that federation legislation should take priority. Instead, Barton exercised his talent for mediation in another direction. Following the maritime strike of 1890 a royal commission
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
94
152 × 230
Slow Progress 95
chaired by Dr Andrew Garran was set up to report on industrial relations. Barton appeared before it while a backbencher in May 1891, speaking with the experience of one who had been appointed not long since as referee for a dispute in the Newcastle coal-mining industry. On this occasion he succeeded in brokering an agreement which both parties found acceptable, if not entirely satisfactory. This confirmed his belief that parties in industrial disputes should refer the issue to a conciliation tribunal comprising representatives of both sides. If the dispute remained unsettled it should then go to arbitration under the chairmanship of a judge who should be a specialist in industrial relations. Without waiting for the royal commission’s report to be tabled, Parkes while premier brought in legislation embodying the ideas which Barton and others had put forward. After Parkes left office the Dibbs government inherited this legislation, and it fell to Barton to pilot it through the Legislative Assembly. It received bipartisan support though Reid moved that arbitration should only be resorted to if both parties appeared, whereas the Labor members favoured compulsion. As passed, the legislation took Barton’s position that arbitration should be voluntary. Its adequacy would soon be tested. Seeking further to please the Labor Party, Parkes had also introduced a bill abolishing plural voting, so as to establish the principle of ‘one-man-one-vote’, and providing for a redistribution of parliamentary seats. Barton announced that the government had decided to postpone the redistribution, in the hope of winning approval for the major reform of one-man-one-vote and the cleansing of the electoral rolls to remove the names of dead or absent voters who might be impersonated. He successfully fought the measure through the Legislative Assembly, but although O’Connor argued stalwartly in the Upper House it was narrowly rejected there. Admittedly, electoral reform and the Conciliation bill were both designed to secure Labor support, but Barton himself had both measures much at heart. He was working at full stretch, especially in the last weeks of March when Dibbs was absent through ill health, and it was with perceptible relief that Barton welcomed the end of the session. In April 1892 Dibbs decided on a sea voyage to England, partly for health reasons but also to shepherd New South Wales interests
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
95
152 × 230
96 EDMUND BARTON
on the London money market. Barton was pitched into the acting premiership for over four months. At first he appeared to thrive on it. The Catholic Freeman’s Journal commented that ‘the awful austerities of Lent do not appear to have materially affected the acting Premier’s fair, round form’. Half a century later John Reynolds picked up an old tune from the Sydney music halls: Ta ra ra ra boom de ay Georgie Dibbs has gone away Toby Barton’s here to stay Ta ra ra ra boom de ay!
In fact Dibbs was to return in September, embellished by a knighthood which sat oddly on his republican shoulders. Barton had cabled Dibbs: ‘Don’t accept knighthood if avoidable. Refusal would lift party, ruin opposition, and justify your mission.’ Dibbs insisted on using his own discretion—Queen Victoria, he later explained, had personally offered it, and he could never refuse a lady—and Barton was left to face public meetings and refute claims that Dibbs had gone to England for the title. Dibbs also upset his colleagues by proposing to negotiate directly with the French about Pacific policy on the basis that if they ceased convict transportation to New Caledonia they could be given a free hand in the New Hebrides (Vanuatu). Like many Australian nationalists Barton was a staunch upholder of the Anglo-Australian presence in the South Pacific, and he sent Dibbs a stiff cablegram of protest. ‘My colleagues,’ grumbled Dibbs to the governor, Lord Jersey, ‘carp by wire at my movements here in a very unsatisfactory manner. Barton promised to write a few lines by each mail, but I have not seen a line.’ But he sent a smooth reply and the affair fizzled out. His wayward leader was the least of Barton’s troubles. Too much of his time was spent interviewing seekers after government patronage whom with greater experience and tough-mindedness he might have fended off. To the Articled Clerks’ Association he complained: ‘Projects of law reform are put aside every session as long as there is a bridge to be got or a little local bill to be put through.’ More fatefully for the future, his Conciliation and Arbitration Act was to
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
96
152 × 230
Slow Progress 97
be found wanting at its first major test in a stagnant economy. In June 1892, noting the triumph of the Queensland pastoralists over the shearers’ union, the mine-owners of Broken Hill repudiated a three-year-old agreement with the unions recognising the closed shop and payment of hourly wages. In the face of falling silver and lead prices they hoped to increase productivity by introducing employment by contract. Predictably the Trades and Labour Council called a strike. Management played with a high hand, refusing to enter negotiations under the terms of Barton’s legislation and demanding that the government should send in the military to keep order. This called for careful judgement. More than most outback mining centres, Broken Hill was hard to control. The quickest line of approach from Sydney was by sea to Adelaide and thence by rail, and if law and order were seriously challenged it would take several days to rush in reinforcements. Barton withstood the request. ‘Any emergency will be dealt with promptly,’ he told the mine-owners, ‘but undue causes of irritation must be avoided. From what we learn there is every expectation that the miners will exercise proper self-control.’ Fifty police were despatched, but the government refused to send more or to authorise the use of special constables. The strike dragged on through July and August, with neither side resorting to conciliation. On 25 August the mines were re-opened using non-union labour. Brawls and punch-ups flared between unionists and contract workers, and the strike leaders hardened their rhetoric. Even if half the reports of violence reaching the Sydney newspapers were exaggerated, enough remained to show that unionists were intimidating ‘scabs’. It was, in Brian Dickey’s words, ‘a desperate business . . . keeping law and order in a frontier community that probably possessed few if any of the factors of social solidity to be found even in Sydney’. Having convened parliament at the end of August Barton found himself under pressure from conservatives to uphold the magistrate at Broken Hill and from Labor members to remove him. The unionists were also unrealistically demanding the removal of O’Connor, minister for justice, and this probably helped convince Barton of their recalcitrance. On 7 September Barton announced that another 100 police would be sent to Broken Hill, and next day he instructed the crown prosecutor, W. H. Coffey, to
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722 f: (02) 9438 3733
e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
97
152 × 230
98 EDMUND BARTON
proceed to Broken Hill in the expectation that some of the strike leaders would be arrested for conspiracy. Coffey arrived to a deteriorating situation. On 9 September a train carrying non-union labourers was shot at and stoned as it passed through Broken Hill goods station, and the police carried fixed bayonets as they escorted the newcomers through the streets. Six days later seven of the strike leaders were charged with conspiracy. The news stimulated great protests, including a demonstration in Sydney by six or seven thousand workers organised by the Sydney Trades and Labour Council. By now a refreshed Dibbs was back from overseas and Reid launched a motion of no confidence, which he had been deferring until the premier’s return. Reid’s attack was complicated by two other motions of censure against the Dibbs ministry. One criticised the premier for travelling overseas at public expense without parliamentary approval. This was unlikely to succeed, as there were vindicating precedents. The other condemned the government’s conduct during the strike, and although the Labor members could be expected to vote for this, Reid and his followers could not afford to seem too supportive of an increasingly unpopular strike. Barton continued to assert the government’s neutrality. His instructions to Coffey were moderation itself: strive to be absolutely even-handed, do not hurry or embarrass the accused, adhere strictly to the common law, accept moderate bail, do not try to resurrect ancient or disused laws (as Griffith had done during the Queensland shearers’ strike). He had brought conspiracy charges against delinquent company directors—one of whom, Francis Abigail, a former cabinet minister under Parkes, was gaoled for five years— and in equity must prosecute trade unionists who appeared to overstep the law. Dibbs was in fighting form, and all three censure motions were voted down, although Reid’s failed by only four votes. But Barton was not out of trouble yet. Late in September Coffey reported that the accused unionists would surely be acquitted if they were tried at Broken Hill, because a jury must consist of shopkeepers and tradespeople, who would be open to pressure and boycotting. Barton directed that the trial be held at Deniliquin, the next town on the court circuit. Coming on top of his original decision to prosecute, this intervention permanently
FINAL PAGES c: ALLEN & UNWIN r: DP2\BP3217W\MAIN p: (02) 9438 3722
f: (02) 9438 3733 e:
[email protected]
92 CHANDOS STREET ST LEONARDS NSW 2065
98
152 × 230
Slow Progress 99
damaged him in the eyes of the labour movement. His democratic sympathies, they said, had been suborned by the conservative environment of his cronies in the Athenaeum Club. These criticisms intensified after a jury of eleven farmers and a woolscourer christened the new Deniliquin courthouse by acquitting two of the accused unionists of conspiracy and finding five guilty. They were sentenced to terms of imprisonment up to two years. In a gesture reflecting Dibbs’ mordant sense of humour they were all released after seven months in honour of a royal wedding. In Labor folklore it was Barton who was excoriated as ‘the only man in the Dibbs cabinet at that time who insisted and persisted in putting that strike down by force’. ‘When we appealed for help and sympathy,’ claimed one miner, ‘. . . his answer was a large body of armed police with bayonets, a thirst for our hearts’ blood, and balls to smash our bones.’ Such memories lost none of their vividness for being not quite accurate. Yet it is hard to see Barton as a catspaw of the employers. He consistently urged conciliation and withstood their appeals for tough measures. Even in November, as the men returned to work, he was still trying to bring about a conference between employers and workers, and the mine-owners, ungenerous even in victory, were refusing and demanding that the police should stay. It may be that the dispute at Broken Hill had passed the point of crisis by the time that Barton, having awaited Dibbs’ return, ordered the conspiracy prosecutions. After holding his hand so long, he might have sat through the remainder of the strike without further antagonising Labor. This would have required the kind of foresight that can be achieved only by hindsight. He was sorely troubled by the dilemma and at the Athenaeum Club was uncharacteristically unapproachable and silent while the strike lasted. It was never easy for Barton to accept that there were some situations in which