Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
WIT Press publishes leading books in Science and Technology. Visit our website for new and current list of titles. www.witpress.com
WITeLibrary Home of the Transactions of the Wessex Institute. Papers presented at Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI are archived in the WIT eLibrary in volume 106 of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment (ISSN 1743-3541). The WIT eLibrary provides the international scientific community with immediate and permanent access to individual papers presented at WIT conferences. Visit the WIT eLibrary at www.witpress.com.
SIXTH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ECOSYSTEMS AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ECOSUD VI CONFERENCE CHAIRMEN E. Tiezzi University of Siena, Italy J.C. Marques IMAR - Institute of Marine Research C.A. Brebbia Wessex Institute of Technology, UK S.E. Jørgensen University of Pharmaceutical Science, Denmark
INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC ADVISORY COMMITTEE C.A. Booth J. Brandt T-S Chon B. Fath D.J. Hutch P.D. Jenssen S.E. Jorgensen B-L Li U. Mander N. Marchettini
J.C. Marques M.B. Neace S.N. Nielsen B.C. Patten Y.A. Pykh Y. Svirezhev A. Tadeu E. Tiezzi W.Timmermans
Organised by Wessex Institute of Technology, UK, University of Coimbra, Portugal University of Siena, Italy, In collaboration with The International Journal of Ecodynamics Sponsored by WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment Transactions Editor Carlos Brebbia Wessex Institute of Technology Ashurst Lodge, Ashurst Southampton SO40 7AA, UK Email:
[email protected]
Editorial Board Y N Abousleiman University of Oklahoma USA D Almorza Gomar University of Cadiz Spain M Andretta Montecatini Italy J G Bartzis Institute of Nuclear Technology Greece J Boarder Cartref Consulting Systems UK H Boileau ESIGEC France A H-D Cheng University of Mississippi USA A Cieslak Technical University of Lodz Poland M da Conceicao Cunha University of Coimbra Portugal A B de Almeida Instituto Superior Tecnico Portugal C Dowlen South Bank University UK J P du Plessis University of Stellenbosch South Africa D Elms University of Canterbury New Zealand
A Aldama IMTA Mexico A M Amer Cairo University Egypt J M Baldasano Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya Spain A Bejan Duke University USA B Bobee Institut National de la Recherche Scientifique Canada C A Borrego University of Aveiro Portugal C-L Chiu University of Pittsburgh USA W Czyczula Krakow University of Technology Poland M Davis Temple University USA K Dorow Pacific Northwest National Laboratory USA R Duffell University of Hertfordshire UK A Ebel University of Cologne Germany D M Elsom Oxford Brookes University UK
J W Everett Rowan University USA D M Fraser University of Cape Town South Africa N Georgantzis Universitat Jaume I Spain K G Goulias Pennsylvania State University USA C Hanke Danish Technical University Denmark S Heslop University of Bristol UK W F Huebner Southwest Research Institute USA D Kaliampakos National Technical University of Athens Greece H Kawashima The University of Tokyo Japan D Kirkland Nicholas Grimshaw & Partners Ltd UK J G Kretzschmar VITO Belgium A Lebedev Moscow State University Russia K-C Lin University of New Brunswick Canada T Lyons Murdoch University Australia N Marchettini University of Siena Italy J F Martin-Duque Universidad Complutense Spain C A Mitchell The University of Sydney Australia R Olsen Camp Dresser & McKee Inc. USA
R A Falconer Cardiff University UK G Gambolati Universita di Padova Italy F Gomez Universidad Politecnica de Valencia Spain W E Grant Texas A & M University USA A H Hendrickx Free University of Brussels Belgium I Hideaki Nagoya University Japan W Hutchinson Edith Cowan University Australia K L Katsifarakis Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Greece B A Kazimee Washington State University USA D Koga Saga University Japan B S Larsen Technical University of Denmark Denmark D Lewis Mississippi State University USA J W S Longhurst University of the West of England UK Ü Mander University of Tartu Estonia J D M Marsh Griffith University Australia K McManis University of New Orleans USA M B Neace Mercer University USA R O’Neill Oak Ridge National Laboratory USA
K Onishi Ibaraki University Japan G Passerini Universita delle Marche Italy M F Platzer Naval Postgraduate School USA H Power University of Nottingham UK Y A Pykh Russian Academy of Sciences Russia A C Rodrigues Universidade Nova de Lisboa Portugal J L Rubio Centro de Investigaciones sobre Desertificacion Spain R San Jose Technical University of Madrid Spain H Sozer Illinois Institute of Technology USA E Tiezzi University of Siena Italy S G Tushinski Moscow State University Russia R van Duin Delft University of Technology Netherlands Y Villacampa Esteve Universidad de Alicante Spain
J Park Seoul National University Korea B C Patten University of Georgia USA V Popov Wessex Institute of Technology UK M R I Purvis University of Portsmouth UK A D Rey McGill University Canada R Rosset Laboratoire d’Aerologie France S G Saad American University in Cairo Egypt J J Sharp Memorial University of Newfoundland Canada I V Stangeeva St Petersburg University Russia T Tirabassi Institute FISBAT-CNR Italy J-L Uso Universitat Jaume I Spain A Viguri Universitat Jaume I Spain G Walters University of Exeter UK
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Editors: E. Tiezzi University of Siena, Italy J.C. Marques IMAR - Institute of Marine Research C.A. Brebbia Wessex Institute of Technology, UK S.E. Jørgensen University of Pharmaceutical Science, Denmark
Editors: E. Tiezzi University of Siena, Italy J.C. Marques IMAR - Institute of Marine Research C.A. Brebbia Wessex Institute of Technology, UK S.E. Jørgensen University of Pharmaceutical Science, Denmark Published by WIT Press Ashurst Lodge, Ashurst, Southampton, SO40 7AA, UK Tel: 44 (0) 238 029 3223; Fax: 44 (0) 238 029 2853 E-Mail:
[email protected] http://www.witpress.com For USA, Canada and Mexico Computational Mechanics Inc 25 Bridge Street, Billerica, MA 01821, USA Tel: 978 667 5841; Fax: 978 667 7582 E-Mail:
[email protected] http://www.witpress.com British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A Catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-1-84564-088-0 ISSN: 1746-448X (print) ISSN: 1743-3541 (on-line) The texts of the papers in this volume were set individually by the authors or under their supervision. Only minor corrections to the text may have been carried out by the publisher.
No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher, the Editors and Authors for any injury and/ or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. The Publisher does not necessarily endorse the ideas held, or views expressed by the Editors or Authors of the material contained in its publications. © WIT Press 2007 Printed in Great Britain by Cambridge Printing. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the Publisher.
Preface
Imagine we had four planets, the first for humans, their houses, roads, schools, hospitals, churches and factories, the second for agriculture and its traditional purpose, production of food and textile fibres, the third for biomass for fuel to avoid global warming and absorb the exact same quantity of CO2 from the atmosphere as the fuel emits when it burns (zero greenhouse effect). The fourth planet would be left wild for the conservation of natural biodiversity, as taught by St. Francis of Assisi. Combining sciences and thoughts is essential for the sustainability of ecosystems as well as for understanding human life. Ecology, economics, chemistry, physics, climatology, informatics are pieces to be put together in order to compose the transdisciplinary picture of our complex world. As Herman Daly said, “the disciplinary structure of knowledge is a problem of fragmentation, a difficulty to be overcome rather then a criterion to be met. Real problems do not respect academic boundaries. We certainly believe that thinking should be disciplined in the sense of respecting logic and facts, but not disciplinary in the sense of limiting itself to traditional methodologies and tools that have become enshrined in the academic departments of neoclassical economics.” The economy and society cannot ignore the second principle of thermodynamics, the essence of Ilya Prigogine’s dissipative structure, the greenhouse effect, the biological and cultural diversities, the biophysical limits to economic growth and sustainability as a whole. The last 50 years have seen humans make incredible advances in scientific knowledge and technology, solving many problems and increasing health care and economic welfare. At the same time, people like us, who do not see science as a means for dominating the world and nature but as a path of knowledge for living in harmony with nature, feel an increasing discomfort. In other words, while science celebrates new peaks, it is clear to everyone that the quality of life has deteriorated, also in the psychological realm, with destruction of nature and high unemployment of youth, despite economic and industrial growth. Sustainability is crucial. And even aesthetics plays an important role. The word aesthetics is derived from the Greek to feel, distinguishing sensory from rational
knowledge. We must not let the wonders of the planet be destroyed by selfdestructive technological processes, but protect them by conserving their selforganisation. Ecosud proposes a bridge between scientific thought and this “environmental wisdom”, that can re-establish an interrupted dialogue between human communities and nature. This Volume contains the proceedings of the Sixth International on Conference Ecosystems and Sustainable Development that was held in Coimbra (Portugal) in September 2007. ECOSUD offers a unique opportunity and encourages the interdisciplinary communication between scientists, engineers and professionals working in ecological systems and sustainable development. The Conference objectives have evolved over the years, seeking to integrate thermodynamics, ecology and economics into “ecodynamics”. The proceedings has been arranged in the following sections: - Ecosystem modelling - Environmental management - Mathematical and system modelling - Environmental risk - Natural resources management - Sustainability indicators - Ecological areas studies - Energy and the environment - Socio economic factors - Sustainable tourism - Soil and agricultural issues - Sustainable waste management - Water resources The Editors would like to thank the members of the International Scientific Advisory Committee for their help in reviewing the papers and promoting the Conference, and the authors for their contributions. The Editors
Contents Section 1: Ecosystems modelling Simulating water conflicts using game theoretical models for water resources management S. Wei & A. Gnauck ..............................................................................................3 An eutrophication model for a lowland river-lake system A. Gnauck & B. Luther........................................................................................13 Section 2: Environmental management The UN Global Compact: moving toward sustainable development by adopting a new paradigm M. B. Neace .........................................................................................................25 Environmental monitoring during beach nourishment using relict sands (central Tyrrhenian sea) D. Paganelli, P. La Valle, M. Gabellini, L. Lattanzi, B. La Porta, A. Pazzini, M. Targusi & L. Nicoletti..................................................................35 An economic and environmental total life cycle costing methodology and a web-based tool for environmental planning of buildings S. M. Haddad, F. Haghighat & S. Alkass ...........................................................43 Section 3: Mathematical and system modelling Mathematical modelling applied to ecosystems: the Gödel’s theorem E. B. P. Tiezzi, R. M. Pulselli & E. Tiezzi ...........................................................55
A family of models to study the growth of Haloferax mediterranei in different conditions Y. Villacampa, F. García-Alonso, J. A. Reyes, R. Martínez-Espinosa & M. J. Bonete ....................................................................................................61 Lotus glaber Mill. Induced autotetraploid: new forage resource for the Flooding Pampas M. Barufaldi, Y. Villacampa, P. Sastre-Vázquez, F. García-Alonso & J. A. Reyes .......................................................................................................69 A phenological model for the soybean A. Confalone, Y. Villacampa, J. A. Reyes, F. García-Alonso & F. Verdú ..........................................................................................................81 Section 4: Environmental risk Modelling arsenic transport in a river basin: a case study in Finland Ä. Bilaletdin, H. Kaipainen, T. Ruskeeniemi & A. Parviainen ...........................91 Pollen contamination in Acacia saligna: assessing the risks for sustainable agroforestry M. A. Millar & M. Byrne...................................................................................101 Section 5: Natural resources management The Armenian forests: threats to conservation and needs for sustainable management R. Moreno-Sanchez, H. Sayadyan, R. Streeter & J. Rozelle .............................113 Contributions of biogeotextiles to sustainable development and soil conservation in developing countries: the BORASSUS Project M. A. Fullen, C. A. Booth, et al.........................................................................123 Section 6: Sustainability indicators Eco-dynamics of territorial systems: an Emergy Evaluation through time A. C. I. Pizzigallo, V. Niccolucci, A. Caldana, M. Guglielmi & N. Marchettini ...............................................................................................145
An investigation on sustainability indicators of vernacular environments: the case of Cyprus M. Oktay & O. Dincyurek .................................................................................155 Sustainability indicators for the housing market: proposals and applications L. Brandli, R. Kohler & M. A. L. Frandoloso ...................................................165 Section 7: Ecological areas studies Sustainable requalification of architectural and natural resources: the coastal village of Marzamemi S. De Medici & C. Senia ...................................................................................175 Phycological flora diversity in a coastal tropical ecosystem in the Northeast of Brazil S. M. B. Pereira, E. Eskinazi-Leça & M. F. Oliveira-Carvalho .......................185 Protecting open space at multiple scales along Utah’s Wasatch Front E. R. Buteau, R. J. Lilieholm & R. E. Toth........................................................195 GIS based land use planning and watershed monitoring as tools for sustainable development J. Alonso, J. Rey, P. Castro & C. Guerra .........................................................205 Stability and resilience in macrobenthic communities: the role of habitat disturbance C. Guerra, F. Cobo, M. González & J. Alonso .................................................215 Section 8: Energy and the environment Technological change dynamic and learning curve theory: application to the global energy system S. Kahouli-Brahmi ............................................................................................227 Efficiency analysis for the production of modern energy carriers from renewable resources and wastes K. J. Ptasinski....................................................................................................239 Environmental sustainability of CO2 capture in fossil fuel based power plants A. Franco & A. R. Diaz .....................................................................................251
Cooling needs for a warming world? Economics and governance of district cooling F. Becchis & G. Genon .....................................................................................263 Section 9: Socio economic factors The (in)validity of benefit transfer and its consequences for policy-making E. J. Bos & J. M. Vleugel ..................................................................................275 Coastal cities – urban infrastructures D. Blott ..............................................................................................................285 Petrol consumption towards unsustainable development: Iranian case study S. B. Imandoust .................................................................................................295 HIV/AIDS morbidity/mortality, access to social support and household utilization of natural resources in Ngamiland, Botswana B. N. Ngwenya & O. T. Thakadu.......................................................................303 Rural development in small mountainous settlements: case study of Bojnord region, North-eastern part of Iran M. Taleshi..........................................................................................................313 Green milieu: the milieu effects on sustainable development of watershed collaborations with a case study of the New York City Watershed Agreement J. Hoffman .........................................................................................................321 Achieving the MDG’s in Ghana: rhetorics or reality? J.-E. Gustafsson & J. E. Koku...........................................................................331 Section 10: Sustainable tourism Recreational trail planning in the context of seasonality P. Vassiljev, K. Kuldkepp, M. Külvik, A. Kull & Ü. Mander ............................353 A new method for tourism carrying capacity assessment V. Castellani, S. Sala & D. Pitea ......................................................................365 Environmental impacts caused by the tourist industry in Elafonisos Island and the Neapoli district, Greece B. S. Tselentis, D. G. Prokopiou, D. Bousbouras & M. Toanoglou..................375
Correlation between the moisture and quantity of biomass as a basis of sustainability of ecosystems (the example of plain deserts of Turkmenistan) V. Kostiukovsky .................................................................................................387 Environmentalism and sustainable development from the point of view of tourism Z. Baros & L. Dávid..........................................................................................395 Section 11: Soil and agricultural issues Application of the SWAP model for sustainable agriculture in an arid region B. Mostafazadeh-Fard, H. Mansouri, S. F. Mousavi & M. Feizi .....................407 River water qualities and types of agricultural production – a comparison between paddy farming and intensive livestock production areas S.-I. Mishima .....................................................................................................417 Emerging environmental and educational service of dairy farming in Japan: dilemma or opportunity? Y. Ohe................................................................................................................425 Effects of planting patterns on biomass accumulation and yield of summer maize L. Quanqi, C. Yuhai, L. Mengyu, Y. Songlie, Z. Xunbo & D. Baodi .................437 Section 12: Sustainable waste management A diagnostic model for M.S.W. landfill operation and the protection of ecosystems with a spatial multiple criteria analysis – Zakynthos Island, Greece T. Koliopoulos & G. Koliopoulou .....................................................................449 The environmental consequences of implementation of a council directive on landfill of waste in Lithuania G. Denafas ........................................................................................................463 Transformations in the solid and liquid phase at aqueous carbonization of oil shale ash M. Uibu, A. Trikkel & R. Kuusik .......................................................................473
Waste from the coal extraction process as raw material for the construction industry N. Quaranta, M. Caligaris, H. López, M. Unsen, M. Carrasco, R. Grether, M. Suarez & L. Beltramini .............................................................483 Use of waste powder coatings as binders for the manufacture of composite materials A. C. Abhyankar, N. R. Edmonds & A. J. Easteal.............................................493 New technology for waste fluorescent lamps treatment in Lithuania – characterisation and environmental impact I. Urniezaite, D. Jankunaite & E. Griskonis .....................................................503 Sustainable waste management in hospitals H. Daxbeck & P. Amrusch ................................................................................511 The waste prevention kit for enterprises, education, and households (WastePrevKit) R.-L. M. Hahtala, S. R. Huuhtanen, S. A. Kajaste, A. E. Karhu, S. H. Kemppainen, O. A. Linsiö & M.-M. A. Partti ..........................................521 Section 13: Water resources Assessment of seasonal variations in stream water by principal component analysis M. M. Taboada-Castro, M. L. Rodríguez-Blanco & M. T. Taboada-Castro...................................................................................533 Fostering sustainable water supply in urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana: the case of Ho Municipality J. E. Koku & J.-E. Gustafsson...........................................................................543 Author Index ...................................................................................................559
Section 1 Ecosystems modelling
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
Simulating water conflicts using game theoretical models for water resources management S. Wei & A. Gnauck Department of Ecosystem and Environmental Informatics, Brandenburg University of Technology at Cottbus, Germany
Abstract Water quality degradation and water scarcity are two serious problems in developing countries. Water management related to these problems usually involves multi-stakeholders with contradictory interests. In the absence of market and exclusive property rights, conflicts among those multi-stakeholders are unavoidable. Game theory can be an appropriate approach to simulate and resolve such conflicts. In this paper, the conflicts of multiple water stakeholders involved in water management of the Hanjiang River Basin in China are modelled as non-cooperative and cooperative games. Statistical and econometric regression models are used to formulate the payoff functions of different players. Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) and the demand-supply principle (DSP) are applied to compare the game outcomes. The results of the game simulations show that cooperation can make all the players better off, although some players may be worse off before the benefit is shared among the players by side payment. The results are not only a comparison of the different water stakeholders, but also benefit water administration for decision support. Keywords: water management, game theory, Hanjiang River, modelling and simulation, cost-benefit analysis.
1
Introduction
Water is essential for the existence of human and other species. However, water quality degradation and water scarcity are two serious problems in developing countries. It is estimated that in 2025, 5 billion out of the world’s 7.9 billion people will be living in areas where it will be difficult or even impossible to meet WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070011
4 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI basic water demand for drinking, cooking and sanitation [1]. Degradation of water quality and water scarcity usually result in conflicts of multi-stakeholders competing for scarce water resources [2], such as the disputes between the Arabs and Israelis, Indians and Bangladeshes, Americans and Mexicans, and among all the 10 Nile basin co-riparian’s [3]. The multi-stakeholders usually have contradictory or conflicting interests [4, 5], goals and strategies [2]. Wei and Gnauck [2] stated that the existing economic and regulation instruments do not work so well in solving these conflicts. The concept of considering the interests and benefits of the stakeholders are widely accepted in the world. Game theoretic analysis approach is an efficient technique to solve such conflicts since it studies the interests and benefits of the stakeholders. As for the water management, game theory was originally applied into the cost distribution in joint water resource projects i.e. waste water treatment, disposal facilities [6, 7] and water supply projects [8, 9]. Thus, the methods of equally cost allocation have been developed such as Minimum Core, Shapley value, Nash Bargaining Solution, etc. [10]. Later on many studies have focused on the application of game theory in solving water conflicts, such as pollution of transboundary rivers [5] and water allocation problems [5, 11, 12]. In this paper, the conflicts of multiple water stakeholders resulted from water quality and water scarcity are modelled using non-cooperative and cooperative games. The example is taken from Hanjiang River Basin in China.
2
Methodology and data collection
2.1 Methodology A water conflict or problem is modelled as a game or a set of games so that the problem can be analyzed and solved in the framework of game theory. The game modelling process consists of defining the conflicts, formulating these conflicts as a game, solving the game and interpreting the results. In this paper, noncooperative and cooperative game methods are used separately to model and simulate the water conflict (real or potential). In order to formulate the payoff functions of the players, statistical and econometric regression methods are used. In detail, regression models (linear regression, semilog regression, double-log regression, polynomial regression) are used to establish models of added values, water demands and waste water discharge of industries. Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) and demand-supply principle (DSP) are applied to compare the outcomes and results of the game modelling. 2.2 Data collection All the data is collected from monitoring stations, official reports, planning and Chinese yearly books. The main types of data include socio-economic data (population, industrial added value), water quantity data (water supply and water consumption of industry), hydrological data (inflow, outflow of Hanjiang River) as well as water quality data on Danjiangkou Reservoir in Hanjiang River Basin. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
5
Theory of game
3.1 Game and game theory A game is a metaphor of the rational behaviours of multi-actors in an interacting or interdependent situation, such as cooperating or coalition, conflicting, competing, coexisting, etc. [2]. An actor can be a country, a region, a group, an individual, organism, abiotic and biotic constituents and even nature proper. A game can be defined as G = {N, A, P, I, O, E}, i.e. N - Players, A - Action (Moves or Strategies), P - Payoff (or Utility), I - Information, Outcome and Equilibrium (NAPI-OE). NAPI are collectively known as the rules of a game. OE are the game results. Game theory is an approach to model and simulate interacting situations by cooperative and non-cooperative games. It studies the strategies and equilibrium or equilibria of the actors, and analyzes how they can do things better. The main task of constructing game models is to define the game rules and get the solution from game results. 3.2 Process of establishing a game model The process of setting up a game model can be summed up into the following questions: Who is involved in the conflict? What are their actions (strategies)? What is the payoff function of each player? Does every player know the payoff function of the others? Is the game a one-time game, continuous game, finite game or an infinite one? What is the equilibrium of the game if it is a non-cooperative game? Is the result better if all the players cooperate with each other? How to distribute the net benefit derived from cooperative games among the players?
4
Game theoretical models of water conflicts
Freshwater, especially transboundary freshwater has strong characteristics of public goods although it is not a real public good in economic sense. As for water use, there is a free riding problem. Every water user wants to use more water but pay less or nothing to treat water pollution. In game theory term, each player is rational and his aim is to maximize his payoff. At the end, water will be severely polluted if there is no cooperation between them. Such a kind of game is called the prisoners’ dilemma. The method to solve the game of the prisoners’ dilemma is to change the game rule and make players cooperate with each other. Cooperation may be self-organised through negotiations or it may be formed due to the forces of politics. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
6 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 4.1 A non-cooperative game model n
MaxVi = ∫ [ Bi (d ) − Ci ( p)] e −δ t dt p , d ,t
(1)
t
where Vi is the payoff of every player i, d is water demand, p is water pollution (or waste water discharge), e-δt is discount factor, Bi(d) is the benefit function of water use of every player i, Ci(p) is the cost to abate pollution (or waste water discharge) of every player i. In the model of non-cooperative game, each rational player tries to maximize his welfares by maximizing the benefit and minimizing the cost. 4.2 A cooperative game model n
MaxU = ∫ [ B (d ) − C ( p)] e −δ t dt p , d ,t
t
(2)
n
MaxU i = Vi + max ∏ [(U B / Ψ )i ]
(3)
i
where U is the total benefit obtained from cooperative game; B(d) is the benefit function of water use in cooperative game; C(d) is the cost to abate waste water discharge (or pollution); Ui is the payoff of each player i; UB is the total net benefit obtained from cooperative game; Ψ is distribution factor of cooperative benefit. In the case of a cooperative game, all the players maximize their overall welfare by maximizing the collective benefit and minimizing the collective cost. At end of game, each player usually will be better off if a side payment is made between the players.
5
A case study of conflicts involved in Hanjiang River Basin
5.1 Hanjiang River Basin Hanjiang River Basin lies in 30°08´ - 40°11´N latitude, 106°12´ - 114°14´E longitude. The river originates in the southern part of Shaanxi Province, northwest China, flows through Shaanxi and Hubei provinces and joins the Yangtze River at Wuhan, capital city of Hubei, fig. 1. It is about 1,577 km long, being the longest tributary of Yangtze River. The basin covers an area of 159,000 km2, the second largest river basin in Yangtze River catchment. On the upper reaches of the river, the U-shaped Danjiangkou Reservoir covers an area of 1050 km2. Hanjiang River Basin belongs to the sub-tropical monsoon area. The climate is temperate and moist, with an annual precipitation of about 873 mm. The average annual runoff of the watershed is 51.3 billion m3. The river itself serves as water resource for drinking, industry as well as agriculture. According to the water quality monitoring data from 1989 to 2002, water quality in the Hanjiang River conforms to water class I ~ II of Chinese Environmental Quality Standards for Surface Water (GB 3838—2002). However, water quality of the middle and WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
7
lower reaches of Hanjiang River has deteriorated in recent years and is mainly reflected by the increase of concentration of nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus. The result has been four big algal blooms in low reach of Hanjiang River since 1992. The concentration of total phosphorus and total nitrogen reached 0.17 mg/L and 2.30 mg/L respectively in Hankou Monitoring Station during the algal bloom of February 2003.
Shaanxi
He'nan
Shangluo
Nanyang
Hangzhong Hanshui River
Ankang
Shiyan Xiangfan
Hubei
Jingmen
N
Xiaogan
Tianmen Qianjiang Xiantao
Wuhan r ve Ri
t ze ng Ya
Figure 1:
Sketch of Hangjiang River Basin.
5.2 Water conflicts Involved in Hanjiang River Basin The Danjiangkou Reservoir is the water source of the Middle Route of South to North Water Transfer (MRSNWT) Project. The MRSNWT project aims at transferring water from Danjiangkou Reservoir for 20 big cities and 100 counties in Beijing, Tianjing Municipalities, and Hebei, Henan, Hubei Provinces in order to solve the sever water scarcity there. In the case of Hanjiang River, the conflicts mainly result from this water transfer project. Firstly, water transfer sets a higher standard on water quality in Danjiangkou Reservoir, which will raise cost to reduce pollutants discharged from the cities on the upper rivers and around the reservoir. Secondly, a substantial amount of water diverted will cause a reduction of runoff and water level, and thus it will change the ecological condition in the downstream of the river. Furthermore, the reductions of runoff and water level will in turn break the balance of water demand and supply of the main river, which will aggravate the conflicts of water demand and supply, and exacerbate the existing pollution (eutrophication) problem. The conflicts involved in Hanjiang River can be illustrated by fig. 2. However, this paper studies only the conflicts between industries. Industry here does not refer to a certain industry, but it is a general term for all industries. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
8 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Water Beneficial Area (Beijing, Tianjin, Heben, Henan)
Upper River Bain (Shaanxi)
Reservior Area (Huben, Henan) Middel and Low River Basin (Huben)
Figure 2:
Water conflicts involved in Hanjiang River Basin.
5.3 Game theoretic modelling approach 5.3.1 The case The industry in the City of Beijing (P1) will transfer water from Danjiangkou Reservoir (R) in Hanjiang River. Water transfer will raise the cost to reduce pollutants produced by the cities on the upper river and around the reservoir, and it will also reduce the river flow and break the interests of the industry downstream of reservoir, fig. 3. Therefore, the conflict in this study area is unavoidable. 5.3.2 Assumptions The game is finite, dynamic and with complete information; All the players are rational, and their aim is to maximize their welfare; There is no intervention of administration during game processing, but the game processing is influenced by the current policies; The industries in the same administrative regions should cooperate with each other, say C1, C2, C3, C4, C6, and C7 cooperation with each other to form one player, it is the same for C8, C9, C10, C11, C12 and C13, fig. 3; The water deficit of player 2 is zero due to his rich water resource or because he can solve the deficit by himself when there is a deficit in the non-cooperative game; WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
9
12.63% of the losses of player 2 and 3 is caused by player 1 he shares only 12.63% of the total transferable water; Player 1 can make up his water deficit if he transfers water from the Hanjiang River, i.e. cooperates with player 2 and 3; All data are authentic. 5.3.3 Defining the game The players. The player set is expressed by N = {1,2,3}. Players 1, 2 and 3 refer to the industries in the City of Beijing and the provinces of Shaanxi, Hubei and He’nan in the upper river basin, as well as the Hubei part in the middle-low river, fig. 3. Player 1 P1 C3
P2
C5 C6
Player 3
C7
P3 P4
C1 C2
R C4
C8 Player 2 C9 C10
C13 C11 C12 C14
Figure 3:
Sketch of the players, Ci refer to cities and Pi provinces or municipalities.
The strategies. Generally speaking, every player has two strategies: cooperation and non-cooperation. They can be expressed as follows: Si1 = C (4) Si = Si 2 = NC In the cooperative situation, player 1 will transfer water from Danjiangkou Reservoir and he would like to compensate other players’ losses resulting from the water transfer. Player 2 agrees with the water transfer of player 1 and player 3 is willing to reduce waste water discharge. In the non-cooperative situation, players have their different strategies. For players 1 and 2, their WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
10 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI strategies are the measures or plans to obtain sufficient water for their development in different periods of time t (year), and they are expressed by: si = Wi ∈ S i = [0 , ∞ ) , i = 1, 2 t
(5)
For player 3, his strategies are to reduce the waste water discharge, and they are expressed by: si = Pi t ∈ Si = [0, ∞), i = 3 (6) The payoff functions. In this non-cooperative game model, the payoff functions of player 1 and 2 are formulated by water demand models since their strategies are to obtain sufficient water for development. For player 3, his payoff function is formulated by the model of waste water discharge. Equation (7) expresses the payoff function of the players. f (Wi t ), i = 1 Vi = g (−Wi t ), i = 2 (7) h(− P t ), i = 3 i
where Wit: the loss of water; Pit: reduction of pollutant source, i.e. waste water discharged from industry. Table 1:
Water demands and water deficits (108 m3) in non-cooperative game.
Year 2010 2011 2012 2013 Total Table 2: Year 2010 2011 2012 2013 Total
6
Water Demand Water Deficit of Player 1 of Player1 5.39 0.26 5.10 0.24 4.83 0.24 4.58 0.25 19.90 0.99
Water Demand of player 2 46.15 46.02 45.77 45.40 183.34
Water Deficit of Player 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Water demands and water deficits (108 m3) in cooperative game. Water Demand Water Deficit Water Demand Water Deficit of Player 1 of Player1 of player 2 of Player 2 5.39 0.00 46.15 3.05 5.10 0.00 46.02 3.14 4.83 0.00 45.77 3.23 4.58 0.00 45.40 2.87 19.90 0.00 183.34 12.29
Results
Tables 1 and 2 show the water demands and water deficits of player 1 and 2 in non-cooperative and cooperative games respectively from 2010 to 2013. In the non-cooperative game, player has a total water deficit of 183.24 million m3, but player 2 has no water deficit due to his rich water resource. In the cooperative game, player 1 gets the amount of water necessary to cover his deficit, i.e. zero WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
11
water deficit, but player 2 will face a total water shortage of 1.229 billion m3 due to the water transfer of player 1, table. 2. Besides, player 3 has to reduce 395 million tons waste water discharge in order to increase water quality for player 1 from 2005 to 2008 in cooperative game, table 3. The game results of payoffs are presented in the table 4. In the table, the first number refers to different years, the second, third and fourth numbers are the payoffs of player 1, 2 and 3 respectively. The first column refers to the payoffs resulting from the non-cooperative game, and the second column is the payoffs resulting from the cooperative game. These results show that the non-cooperative game will cost player 1 a total loss of 73.85 billion RMB from year 2010 to 2013, but it yields player 2 and 3 a benefit of 61.83 billion RMB. However, comparing the overall costs and benefits, there is an overall loss of 12.02 billion RMB when each player does not cooperate with the others. The cooperative game result shows that there is an overall benefit of 12.02 billion RMB, though player 2 and 3 lose 61.83 billion RMB. Therefore, all the players will be better off if a side payment is made between them at the end of the cooperative game. These results prove that the players should cooperate with each other so as to maximize the overall benefits. Waste water discharge (108 tons) of player 3 in non-cooperative and cooperative game.
Table 3:
Non-cooperation 5.05 5.37 5.63 6.01 22.06
Year 2005 2006 2007 2008 Total Table 4:
Reducing Amount 0.64 0.79 1.07 1.45 3.95
Payoff matrix of non-cooperative and cooperative game.
(2005, −000.00, 000.00, 0.86) (2006, −000.00, 000.00,1.06) (2007, −000.00, 000.00,1.44) (2008, −000.00, 000.00,1.95) (2010, −146.29,140.36, 0.00) (2011, −163.56,152.54, 0.00) (2012, −191.88,165.33, 0.00) (2013, −236.79,154.78, 0.00)
7
Cooperation 4.41 4.59 4.56 4.56 18.02
(2005, 000.00, −000.00, −0.86) (2006, 000.00, −000.00, −1.06) (2007, 000.00, −000.00, −1.44) (2008, 000.00, −000.00, −1.95) (2010,146.29, −140.36, −0.00) (2011,163.56, −152.54, −0.00) (2012,191.88, −165.33, −0.00) (2013, 236.79, −154.78, −0.00)
Conclusions
Water resource management is vital and complex because it usually involves water conflicts of multi-stakeholders with contradictory interests, goals and strategies. Game theory is a modelling approach which can be efficiently used to WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
12 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI solve these challenges. The conflicts in the Hanjiang River Basin are caused by the Middle Road of South to North Water Transfer (MRSNWT) Project. The results of the game simulations show that a non-cooperative game will cause a collective loss of 12.02 billion RMB, while the cooperative game will yield a collective benefit of 12.02 billion RMB, though player 2 and 3 lose 61.83 billion RMB. Therefore, each player will be better off if a side payment is made among the players at the end of the cooperative game. In conclusion, this game theoretical simulating approach not only facilitates a clear comparison of the different water users, but is also beneficial to water decision makers.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
Leete, R., Donnay, F., Kersemaekers, S., Schoch, M., & Shah, M., Global population and water, UNFPA report on Population and Development Strategies Series, number 6. UNFPA: New York, 2003. Wei, S.K. & Gnauck, A., Game theoretic approaches to model water conflicts on a river basin scale. Modelling and Simulation of Ecosystems, ed. A. Gnauck, Shaker Verlag: Aachen, pp. 22-40, 2007 Wolf, A.T., Criteria for equitable allocations: The heart of international water conflict. Natural Resources Forum 23, pp. 3-30, 1999 Fang, L., Hipel, K.W., & Wang, L.Z., Gisborne water export conflict study. Proc. of the 3rd Int. conf. on Water Resources and Environmental Research, ed. G.H. Schmitz, Dresden, Germany, Vol.1, pp. 432-436, 2002 Van der Veeren, R.J.H.M. & Tol, R.S.J., Game theoretic analyses of nitrate emission reduction strategies in the Rhine river basin. Int. J. Global Environmental Issues 3(1), pp. 74-103, 2003. Giglio, R.J. & Wrightington, R., Methods for apportioning the costs of a water resource project. Water Resourc. Res. 8, pp. 1133-1144, 1972. Dinar, A. & Howitt, R.E., Mechanisms for allocation of environmental control cost: Empirical test of acceptability and stability. J. Environ. Management, 49, pp. 183-203, 1997. Heany, J.P. & Dickinson, R.E., Methods for apportioning the costs of a water resource project. Water Resourc. Res. 18(3), pp. 476-482, 1982 Young, H.P, Okada, N. & Hashimoto, T., Cost allocation in water resource development. Water Resourc. Res., 18(3), pp. 463-475, 1982. Lejano, R.P. & Davos, C.A., Cost allocation of multiagency water resource projects: Game theoretic approaches and case study. Water Resourc. Res., 31(5), pp. 1387-1393, 1995. Wang, L.Z., Fang, L. & Hipel, K.W., Water resource allocation: A cooperative game approach. J. Environ. Informatics 2(1), pp. 11-22, 2003. Wei, S.K. & Gnauck, A., Water supply and water demand of Beijing – A game theoretic Approach for modelling. Information Technologies in Environmental Engineering, eds. J.M. Gómez, M. Sonnenschein, M. Muller, H. Welsch & C. Rautenstrauch, Springer-Verlag: Berlin and Heidelberg, pp. 525-536, 2007.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
13
An eutrophication model for a lowland river-lake system A. Gnauck & B. Luther Brandenburg University of Technology at Cottbus, Department of Ecosystems and Environmental Informatics, Germany
Abstract Natural and man induced nutrient loads affect the functioning of freshwater ecosystems and restrict various water uses. In particular, internal pollution by nutrient remobilisation from sediment plays an important role in shallow water bodies. A sustainable management of such freshwater ecosystems can be achieved by using simulation models. To forecast the eutrophication process of a shallow river-lake system a modelling and simulation framework was developed including phosphorus remobilisation from sediment. Data are taken from the Lower Havel River. For water quality management decision control strategies based on the limiting nutrient concept and threshold values of LAWA are discussed. Keywords: eutrophication, water quality, modelling, phosphorus remobilisation, optimisation.
1
Introduction
Eutrophication of freshwater bodies is characterised by an increase of dissolved nutrients in water bodies, mainly phosphorus, carbon and nitrogen, by excessive growth of plants, mainly algae, and by restricted water uses due to anoxic water conditions as well as by odour problems [1,2]. The eutrophication process of freshwater ecosystems is supported by intensive man-made activities in river basins. Man-made impacts caused a shift from oligotrophic to eutrophic and sometimes to hypertrophic freshwater ecosystems. Now it has become clear, that sediments have been accumulating phosphorus over several decades so that they now function as internal phosphorus sources [3]. Compared with the amount of phosphorus in the pelagic zone of eutrophic lakes, the phosphorus content of the sediment of shallow water bodies is considerable higher. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070021
14 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Sustainable management decisions to control the quality of freshwater ecosystems can only be achieved by using powerful simulation tools. Water quality models are widespread used for managing eutrophication problems [4]. Some eutrophication models contain optimisation procedures to get optimal results [5]. For a shallow river-lake system a modelling and simulation framework to control the water quality was developed. Time series analysis methods are used for process identification [6]. By means of wavelet analysis interrelations between water quality indicators and sediment could be identified, while [7] developed a single process model describing the phosphorus remobilisation from sediment. As a second step changing water quality levels are simulated by an eutrophication simulator [8] carried out within a MATLAB environment. To get a practicable software tool for simulation and optimisation an eutrophication simulator was coupled with an optimisation tool [9,10]. In this paper, optimised simulation results are presented for important water quality indicators such as phytoplankton biomass, phosphate phosphorus, ammonia nitrogen and nitrate nitrogen.
2
Process identification
The eutrophication process is stimulated by nutrient remobilisation from sediment supported by meteorological and hydrochemical conditions. Water temperature is one of the most important driving forces in freshwater ecosystems. Therefore, correlations between water temperature and phosphate were studied by time series analysis. In particular, wavelet analysis with a Daubechies wavelet at level 5 [11] was carried out. Fig. 1 shows the details of Daubechies wavelet analysis between both indicators at level 5. 0.08
0.06 0.04 0.02
0
-0.02 -0.04
-0.06 -0.08 -0.1
-0.12
Figure 1:
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Daubechies wavelet analysis of water temperature and phosphate phosphorus at level 5.
Heating and cooling of the water is accompanied by an opposite event of phosphate phosphorus because of temperature dependencies of chemical reaction rates. This result was confirmed by residual cross correlations where highest negative values could be found at lag 0 as can be seen from fig. 2. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
15
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8 -400
Figure 2:
-300
-200
-100
0
100
200
300
400
Residual cross-correlation function of level 5.
The process of P-remobilisation can be divided into four phases (table 1). Table 1:
Phases of temperature dependency of phosphate remobilisation.
WT changes Increase of WT Diminished increase of WT Decrease of WT Diminished decrease of WT
WT gradients f'(WT) > 0, f''(WT) > 0 f'(WT) > 0, f''(WT) < 0 f'(WT) < 0, f''(WT) < 0 f'(WT) < 0, f''(WT) > 0
P dynamics Storage of phosphate Start of P-remobilisation Increasing P-remobilisation Stop of P-remobilisation
For modelling the AQUASIM software was used [12]. Fig. 3 shows the model concept.
Water column
CO2 , CNO 3 , CSP
CO2 ,CNO 3 , CSP
Transportation, TW DO, NO 3, SP
Diffusion DO, NO 3, SP Active sediment layer
Decay
Figure 3:
P - remobilisation
Model concept of P-remobilisation from sediment (SP–soluble phosphorus, DO–dissolved oxygen, NO3–nitrate nitrogen) (modified according to [7]).
The input to each river-lake segment is given by three input boundary conditions for dissolved oxygen, nitrate and soluble phosphorus. The sub-model equation is given by
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
16 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI dPSED/dt = (-1)Θ·phi·hs(-Dsp/(1-ln(phi2))(P-(PSED/(hs·phi)))/hs/2 + Θ (cpcrit-cpEA/cpcrit)·(KFe CpFe+qp)) with Θ =1, if CpEA ≤ cpcrit, and Θ = 0, if CpEA > cpcrit. The parameters are phi – sediment porosity, hs - thickness of active sediment layer (m), Dsp – diffusion coefficient of dissolved phosphorus, P – dissolved phosphorus, CpFe – iron concentration in pore water, qp - ratio P/Fe of reducible iron, KFe – iron concentration in pore water with KFe = K1(TW)/36, cpcrit – critical value of CpEA, K1(TW) = K1(20) (0.1 · lg (2) / lg(K120) · (TEMP - 20) + 1) – temperature dependent decay rate of organic material in pore water, K1(20) – standardised decay rate organic material in pore water at 20°C, CpO2 – dissolved oxygen concentraqtion in pore water with CpO2 = O2/31,998, CpNO3 – nitrate concentration in pore water with CpNO3 = NO3/14.007, CpEA – electron acceptor concentration in pore water with CpEA = 2CpO2+5CpNO3.
3
The eutrophication simulator HavelMod
To simulate the eutrophication process in shallow water bodies a stationary 1Dmodel was developed within the MATLAB environment. Fig. 4 shows the model concept. FOTOP
I
TEMP
BOD
DO
Algae
NH4-N
Zoo
PO4-P
Qin
Qout NO2-N
NO3-N
Sediment
Figure 4:
Psed
Conceptual model of the eutrophication simulator.
Model state variables are given by the water quality indicators phytoplankton (algae), zooplankton (zoo), orthophosphate phosphorus (PO4-P), ammonia nitrogen (NH4-N), nitrite nitrogen (NO2-N), nitrate nitrogen (NO3-N) as well as WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
17
by dissolved oxygen (DO) and biochemical oxygen demand (BOD). The phosphorus remobilisation process from sediment was included in the phosphorus balance equation. Detailed descriptions of model equations, parameters, site constants and system specific parameters are presented in [10]. Qin and Qout describe the discharges into and out of the river segment or lake under consideration. External driving forces are photoperiod (FOTOP), solar radiation (I) and water temperature (TEMP). Model equations are given as follows: Phytoplankton biomass A (mg CHA/l) dA/dt = Q/V·(Ain - Aout) + G - UA·A·f - FRZ·Z·A·CR - RESP·TEMP·A P-remobilisation from sediment Psed(mg P/l) dPsed/dt = phi·hs·(-Dsp/(1-log(phi2))·(P-(Psed/(hs·phi)))/(hs/2) + Θ (cpcrit - cpEA)/cpcrit·KFe·cp·qp), where Θ = 1 if cpEA ≤ cpcrit and Θ = 0 otherwise Phosphate phosphorus P (mg P/l) dP/dt = Q/V·(Pin - Pout) + FRZ·A·Z·CR·( (1 - AZP)·KSA/(KSA+A) ) + RESP·TEMP·A - G + (1/4)·dPsed/dt Ammonia nitrogen NH4-N (mg N/l) dNH4/dt = Q/V·(NH4in - NH4out) + B3·NORGin - B1·NH4 - FA1·FUP·G Nitrite nitrogen NO2-N (mg N/l) dNO2/dt = Q/V·(NO2in - NO2out) + B1·NH4 - B2·NO2 Nitrate nitrogen NO3-N (mg N/l) dNO3/dt = Q/V·(NO3in - NO3) - (1-FUP)·FA1·G + B2·NO2 Filtrating zooplankton Z (mg C/l) dZ/dt = Q/V·(Zin - Zout) + FRZ·A·Z·CR·AZP·C·KSA/(KSA+A) - MORT·TEMP⋅Z Dissolved oxygen DO (mg/l) DOout) + K2·(DOsat dDO/dt = Q/V·(DOin + (a3·G/A - a4·RESP·TEMP)·A - K1·BOD - K4/zmix - a5·B1·NH4 - a6·B2·NO2 - a7·MORT·TEMP·Z
DO)
Biochemical oxygen demand BOD (mg/l) dBOD/dt = Q/V·( BODin - BODout) + K1·BOD - K3·BOD According to [13] temperature dependencies of physical water quality variables are modelled by sinusoidal functions. The saturation concentration of DO is expressed by a third order polynomial [14].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
18 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
The optimisation tool ISSOP
A software tool ISSOP was developed in [9] to support manufacturing, organisational and logistic processes. It includes an optimisation interface of MATLAB models. The ISSOP architecture of discrete optimisation methods used is shown in fig. 5. The dialogue between external and internal models and optimisation methods is realised by a universal parameter interface. The following optimisation methods are included: CENUM – component wise enumeration, DISOPT – a quasi-gradient method, EVOL – an evolutionary optimisation strategy, SIMCARLO – optimisation by Monte Carlo method, SIMGEN – optimisation by a genetic algorithm. Other optimisation procedures can be added. Before starting an optimisation run each simulation problem is automatically transformed into the standard problem of optimisation. On the lowest level of this architecture simulation models, goal functions and internal process models are given explicitly. External static and dynamic simulation models can be implemented without any restriction. Convexity of goal functions is not necessary. The coupling of HavelMod with the optimisation tool ISSOP was realised by using the implemented universal open interface. Input variables of the simulation system are denoted by α1x1,...,αkxk, outputs are symbolised by y1,...,ym respectively. Goal functions are denoted by f1,...,fn with fi(M(α1x1,...,αkxk)) = fi(y1,...,ym) where i = 1,..., n, and arbitrary continuous functions can be used. They will be optimised simultaneously. If n > 1, the goal functions f1,...,fn are aggregated to a weighted sum S = Σ wi fi with Σ|wi|= 1 and wi are weighting factors. ISSOP uses the model variables and target values as input data and gives optimised state variables back to the simulation system.
Optimisation Methods CENUM
DISOPT
EVOL
SIMCARLO
SIMGEN
...
Universal Parameter Interface dynamic
static
Variables, States, Goal Functions Simulation Models
Figure 5:
Explicit Goal Functions
internal Amount of Purchase, Cost of Setup
...
Internal Process Models
...
The ISSOP optimisation architecture.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
5
19
Experimental area and basic simulations
The Havel River with its tributary Spree River belongs to the catchment of the Elbe River. Both rivers form a basin which is characterised by small elevation differences between source and mouth, by shallow lakes, wetlands and marshy country, as well as by high evaporation rates. Only 25% of precipitation contributes to flow. The water quality is mainly influenced by the anthropogenic activities of the urbanised area of Berlin/Potsdam. Time series of water quality data from 1997 are taken into consideration as references, while time series from 1998 to 2002 from different measuring points along the course of the rivers were used for modelling and parameterisation. For water quality simulations the river basin was divided into several segments of different length. After validation procedures the eutrophication simulator was used to carry out basic simulations for the rivers Spree and Havel. Fig. 6 shows results of simulation runs for phytoplankton and for phosphate phosphorus (fig. 7). 0,10
1997
0,09
325 345 SPK0010
Chlorophyll-a (mg/l)
0,08 0,07 0,06 0,05 0,04 0,03 0,02 0,01 0,00 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Time (d)
Figure 6:
Basic simulation runs for the urbanised area of the river basin. Orthophosphate Phosphorus (mg/l)
0,30
1997
0,28
SPK0010 SPK0020
0,26 0,24
Hv0190 Hv0200
0,22 0,20 0,18 0,16 0,14 0,12 0,10 0,08 0,06 0,04 0,02 0,00 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Time (d)
Figure 7:
Basic simulation runs for orthophosphate phosphorus.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
20 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The phosphorus dynamics is determined by two different processes: a decrease of phosphate phosphorus due to phytoplankton uptake by diatoms in spring, and an extreme increase due to phosphorus remobilisation from sediment in fall. Because of the nutrient rich water body the bioproduction is high in spring and late summer. During the first four months the growth of diatoms can be seen while in late summer cyanobacteria dominate. In late summer and fall algal blooms collapse and lead to anoxic conditions at the sediment-water interface due to high decay rates of dead organic matter with high rates of oxygen consumption.
6 Optimisation results Two control strategies are taken into consideration. The first one is based on the limiting nutrient concept of algal biomass. The second one refers to the target values of the German Working Group LAWA regulations [15]. Input variables are denoted by x1 (phytoplankton biomass), x2 (orthophosphate phosphorus) and x3 (nitrate nitrogen), output variables y1, y2, and y3 respectively. To get optimised results for the model transfer function M(α1x1, α2x2, α3x3) = (y1, y2, y3) the following goal functions are considered: 1. phytoplankton biomass f1(t) = ΣxΣt y1(x, t) → min. 2. orthophosphate phosphorus f2(t) = ΣxΣt y2(x, t) → max. 3. nitrate nitrogen f3(t) = ΣxΣt y3(x, t) → max. Corresponding to the input variables following restrictions are valid for the parameters αi (i = 1,..,3): α1 = 1, α2 and α3 vary in the interval [0,1]. The results are as follows. Weights according to the limiting nutrient concept w1 = 90.5, w2 = -1.1 and w3 = -8.4 lead to a diminished phytoplankton maximum in late summer due to optimised nitrate concentrations (fig. 8). No effect of optimised orthophosphate phosphorus concentration can be stated. Optimal averages of goal functions are f1 = 44.991 µg/l, f2 = 1.472 µg/l, and f3 = 1.54 mg/l. re fe re n ce C H A o p tim ise d C H A
CHA (mg/l)
9
0 .1 6
8
0 .1 4
7
0 .1 2
6
0 .1
5
0 .0 8
4
0 .0 6
3
0 .0 4
2
0 .0 2
1
0
Figure 8:
10
o p tim ise d o -P O 4 -P o p tim ise d N O 3 -N
0
50
100
150
200 250 tim e (d )
300
350
o-PO4-P (10-3 mg/l), NO3-N (mg/l)
0 .2 0 .1 8
0 400
Eutrophication control according to limiting nutrient concept and LAWA regulations.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
21
Weights according to LAWA w1 = 42%, w2 = -57% and w3 = -1% with results α2 = 0.03 and α3 = 0.91 lead to nearly the same behaviour of phytoplankton biomass in spring but to smaller differences of phytoplankton maxima and to low nutrient concentrations in late summer (fig. 9). Optimal averages of goal functions are f1 = 48.762 µg/l, f2 = 0.166 µg/l and f3 = 0.08 mg/l. In consequence, the LAWA strategy leads to significantly lower nutrient concentrations but to a slight increase of phytoplankton biomass. In eutrophication control by means of limiting nutrient concept results in lower phytoplankton concentrations but higher admissible nutrient inputs.
CHA (mg/l)
7
10 9
0.16
8
0.14
7
0.12
6
0.1
5
0.08
4
0.06
3
0.04
2
0.02
1
0
Figure 9:
optim ised o-PO 4 -P optim ised N O 3 -N
0
50
100
150
200 250 tim e (d)
300
350
o-PO4-P (mg/l), NO3-N (mg/l)
reference C HA optim ised CH A
0.2 0.18
0 400
Control of algal biomass according to target values of LAWA.
Conclusions
A sustainable management to control freshwater ecosystems can only be achieved by using powerful informatic tools. The use of combined simulationoptimisation procedures to manage the water quality of rivers, lakes and reservoirs is an approach promising more theoretical understanding of complicated natural processes and software engineering methods. Phosphate remobilisation from sediment can be considered as a result of some contradictory processes of matter changes. Perspectives of developments of simulation frameworks for water quality management on a river basin scale may be seen in combinations of water quality simulation models, multi-objective optimisation procedures and visualisation tools.
Acknowledgements The author is very indebted to Prof. M. Freude from Landesumweltamt Brandenburg for providing the data and to S. Wei and J. D. Alegue for technical assistance.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
22 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
[8]
[9] [10]
[11] [12] [13] [14] [15]
Uhlmann, D.: Hydrobiology. Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1975. Goltermann, H. L. 2004: The Chemistry of Phosphate and Nitrogen Compounds in Sediments. Kluwer, Dordrecht. DiToro, D. M.: Sediment Flux Modelling. Wiley, Chichester, 2000. Biswas, A. K. (ed.): Models for Water Quality Management. McGrawHill, New York, 1981. Wierzbicki, A. P., M. Makowski and J. Wessels (eds.): Model-Based Decision Support Methodology with Environmental Applications. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2000. Gnauck, A.: Time Series Analysis of Water Quality Data. In: ScholzReiter, B., H.-D. Stahlmann and A. Nethe (eds.): Process Modelling. Springer, Berlin, 1999, pp. 509-525. Hoffmann, A.: Mathematical modelling of phosphorus dynamics in rivers with special regard to phosphate remobilization from sediment. Diploma thesis, Dept. of Ecosystems and Environmental Informatics, BTU Cottbus, 1999. Gnauck A., Heinrich, R. and B. Luther (2002): Water Quality Management of a Sub-Watershed of the Elbe River. In: Pillmann, W. and K. Tochtermann (eds.): Environmental Communication in the Information Society. Internat. Soc. Environm. Protect., Vienna, pp. 524-531. Krug, W.: Modelling, Simulation and Optimisation for Manufacturing, Organisational and Logistical Processes. SCS Europe Publishing House, Delft, 2002. Gnauck, A., Luther, B., T. Wiedemann and W. Krug: Coupling of Simulators for Optimal Control of Water Quality. In: Gnauck, A. and R. Heinrich (eds.): The Information Society and Enlargement of the European Union. Metropolis, Marburg, pp. 373-380, 2003. Gnauck, A. and T. Tesche: Modelling the Sediment-Water Interaction for Riverine Lakes. Internat. Rev. Hydrobiol. 83(1998), Spec. Iss., 207-214. Reichert, P.: Concepts Underlying a Computer Program for the Identification and Simulation of Aquatic Systems. Dübendorf: Report ETH Zürich/EAWAG, 1994. Straškraba, M. and A. Gnauck, Freshwater Ecosystems. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985. Thomann, R. V.: Systems Analysis and Water Quality Management. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1972. LAWA: Beurteilung der Wasserbeschaffenheit von Fließgewässern in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland – Chemische Gewässergüteklassifikation. Kulturbuchverlag, Berlin, 1998.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 2 Environmental management
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
25
The UN Global Compact: moving toward sustainable development by adopting a new paradigm M. B. Neace Mercer University, USA
Abstract This paper examines the UN initiative that encourages a new paradigm – a networking of scientists and their organizations, global businesses, NGOs and civil society organizations to implement its Global Compact’s ten principles to move human activity toward sustainable development (SD). The ten principles encompass a holistic approach to SD focusing on contributions of global enterprises acting through government agencies, civil society, local organizations and communities, both horizontally and most importantly, vertically. Sustainability does not occur in a vacuum. SD can only happen when there is recognition of its holistic underpinning of all life, particularly human activity, in all of its dimensions and interconnectedness. After a brief review of the UN Global Compact (UNGC), several holistic models are presented and discussed with focus on global business enterprises when implementing the new paradigm of competition – collaboration, transparency, interconnectedness – a holistic philosophy for commerce and community. The models suggest an approach that has potential to create win-win-win results; or as is known in the business community – triple bottom line (TBL). Applications of the TBL models can, and are, moving organizations and communities in which they operate toward SD. Keywords: UN Global Compact, holistic SD, collaboration, interconnectedness, transparency, triple bottom line, beyond globalisation.
1
Introduction
This is a work in progress; not only in terms of UNGC’s ten principles but also for my models used in this paper - where and how they are interconnected. Both are undergoing a co-evolutionary journey. Under the umbrella of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070031
26 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI ‘Globalization,’ UNGC and models presented for discussion are evolving in a dynamic, complex world. As John Rennie Short [1] noted, globalization is bringing peoples closer apart and places further together. The UN has initiated numerous programs over the years addressing problems associated with poverty, underdevelopment, health, education, security, infrastructure – aimed at underdeveloped countries and poor of the world. These programs have had limited success for a variety of reasons including poor management, lack of coherence [2] and some hanky-panky internally. Prodigious amounts of energy and talent have been used in their creation. For example, the UN Millennium Development Goals, absorbed hundreds of hours (probably thousands) of leading scientists and policy makers from around the globe in its development, has a broad base of stakeholders including global businesses and has specific targets to reach in eight areas by 2015, yet to date has shown little progress of reaching those goals [3]. The paper will focus on how businesses can make significant contributions to UNGC goals in spite of a rather shaky UN track record. Both are going through an interesting global transition period.
2 UNGC The UNGC was inaugurated 26 July 2000. It is a clarion call for business leaders, large and small, global and local, to cooperate with UN agencies, labor groups and civil society to advance its ten principles in the areas of human rights, natural environment and anti-corruption. UN efforts in these areas, although lauded by most governments and NGOs, with successes here and there, but overall, results are less than satisfying. Some believe the battle is being lost [4]. As critiques have noted there is a need for integration, interconnectedness and collaboration across these often disparate programs. UNGC is expected to accomplish this goal using the creative, synergistic leadership of global companies [2]. Many global companies have initiated actions in these areas on their own, or as part of a part of a group professional effort, or in alliance with one or more NGOs. For examples, see: [5–8]. I will draw from these sites and others in discussing models that address the UN’s holistic concerns regarding efforts to enlist businesses and their leaders to bring creativity and innovation to the resolution of these global problems. The UN has grappled with these issues for many years, with a variety of initiatives, most often through individual programs and NGOs with limited perspectives, such as the UN Environmental Program (UNEP) and labor issues through ILO. UNGC, through its Ten Principles is an effort to synergize the talent and resources of business leaders from a holistic perspective - all inclusive with business leadership as it’s underpinning. To date over 2,500 organizations have signed on to adhere and promote the GCs ten principles. As originally drafted, there were nine principles. The tenth - regarding anti-corruption was added recently. Figure 1 outlines the ten principles. As a condition of membership all participants agree to uphold and promote the ten principles, not only individually but also in partnership with other members and communities at large. Each member must submit a WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
27
‘Communication of Progress’ (COP) every two years chronicling how they’ve upheld, made progress and promoted the principles. Failure to submit a COP can lead to an ‘inactive’ status. A benefit of being a GC member is having “rights” to use the UN symbol on products and communications. This has led to some abuses – greenwashing and ‘bluewashing’ - using the good image of the UN without accountability [9].
The Ten Principles The first two principles are derived from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: 1.
Businesses should support and respect the protection of internationally proclaimed human rights within their sphere of influence; and 2. Make sure that they are not complicit in human rights abuses. The principles 3-6 are derived from the International Labour Organisation's Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work: 3. Businesses should uphold the freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; 4. The elimination of all forms of forced and compulsory labour; 5. The effective abolition of child labour; and 6. Eliminate discrimination in respect of employment and occupation. The principles 7-9 are derived from the Rio Declaration on Environment and Development: 7. Businesses should support a precautionary approach to environmental challenges; 8. Undertake initiatives to promote greater environmental responsibility; and 9. Encourage the development and diffusion of environmentally friendly technologies; The 10th and last principle is derived from the United Nations Convention against Corruption: 10. Businesses should work against all forms of corruption, including extortion and bribery.
Figure 1:
3
The Ten Principles.
The Transition
The timing is appropriate. Business is going through a transition – redefining itself in a world of globalization where stakeholders and communities external to the supply chains are often clamorous for inclusiveness. Mission statements are broadening with adoption of TBL thinking: at minimum, more effective and efficient integration, collaboration and ‘transparency’ of value creation streams, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
28 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI particularly working on environmental and security issues. Now, issues mentioned above are on the table. This fits ‘conveniently’ with the concept of ‘beyond globalization’ [10, 11]. Global companies and Western governments (Northern Hemisphere) have ‘pushed’ free markets with the assistance of IMF, WTO and a host of economic alliances for the past four decades with some degree of success (See [12]). Yet concerns by both those on the inside and outside abound: poverty appears to be growing as does abuses to Mother Nature (For an interesting review of this situation, see [13]). Most transitions are works in progress with occasional steps backward. The UNGC is an effort to adjudicate these many issues by enlisting the global corporate world – its leadership, innovative creativity and collaborative management skills. Corporate leadership has begun, in increasing numbers, transitioning toward broader visions for their organizations, including communities they operate in, including their impacts on the environment, including security (personal and resources), including concerns for poverty and the many issues it begets. In a book that traced this transition, Elkington [14] developed the précis – Triple Bottom Line. Triple Bottom Line (TBL) is a process of synchronous venturing for economic, environmental and social equity. For example, this would include synergistic integration of market/supply chain objectives, environmental concerns (especially as they increase costs), human rights and anti-corruption initiatives benefiting bottom lines of all stakeholders working collaboratively – delivering win-win-win outcomes (e.g., browse these web sites for TBL at work: [15–17]). A major element in the transition to TBL is value transformation (Figure 2). Without a change in mind-set regarding doing one’s job, TBL as an every-day process will not occur. Figure 2 is a value transformation paradigm that is crucial for TBL success. Value transformation allows for all to sit at ‘common’ table. Value shifting to the proactive/creative level leads naturally to synergistic activities blending economics, ecology and social issues through combinations of good science, best management practices and the inclusion of local stakeholders [18–20]. The global business community plays a key role in this process: they have the knowledge, they have the skills, they understand risk (the precautionary principle), and they have the ability to create win-win-win situations – triple bottom lines. Other stakeholders at the local level play pivotal roles in the development and application of sustainable initiatives, including research, education, and formulation of regulatory policies and transforming these preparations into good science and best management practices. It’s their lives too. Business acumen is required to bring order to disorder and to do it profitably. (See Figure 3.) Building on Norgaard’s [21] plea for pluralism, as does TBL thinking, it is essential for the global business community to recognize and respect that different groups and cultures have unique approaches to their view of the world, applying different assumptions and methodologies resulting in different models
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Transformation of values. Figure 2:
29
30 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 3:
Integrated holistic TBL paradigm.
of the “same” phenomena. It is this very diversity and the synergy it creates that holds promise for progress toward a planetary system of sustainable development and some progress on UNGC’s ten principles. There is no one unifying paradigm. Planet Earth is always evolving with many paradigms— interacting, blending, competing, creating, dying—where Homo sapiens is an integral, and in fact, the dominant player in it’s evolutionary path at this point in its history. Only in this way can we truly develop holistic, interconnected, dynamic paradigms necessary for movement toward TBL operationally [9, 22, 23]. The next section focuses primarily on sustainable development, which in its broad context is holistic and includes goals of the ‘ten principles.’
4
Making sustainability operational
Limitations of present environmental policies and programs are well known; including bureaucratic ineptness and lack of will [24]; short term economicpolitical “remedies” at the sacrifice of long term biosphere reality [20, 25, 26]; application of reductionist paradigms when increasing evidence points to holistic dynamic general system [27–33]. Overcoming these issues is what the UN Global Compact is all about and why it requires expertise of global corporate leadership. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
31
A holistic perspective is required, including interconnectedness and local input. Norgaard [21], Rothschild [30] and Teilhard [33], among others, have developed holistic models demonstrating interconnections of man to his larger environment, the biosphere, and even the cosmos. Self organizing systems are ubiquitous in nature, as are economies of self organizing systems in which market structures spontaneously organize by demand for product/services and labor [34, 35]. Figure 3 expresses this integrated TBL holistic concept - a shift in values that recognizes continued development within each sector, but also the necessity for sharing and movement among the many bodies of knowledge—a transdisciplinary modus operandi, a recognition of interconnectedness and diverse cultures. Certainly no one expects to attain this level of maturity and harmony without disputation. Healthy debate and respect is necessary for real progress. In spite of our wrangles the process is under way, and evermore with global business enterprises playing a leadership role. We are not implying the battle is being won. To the contrary, even with a shifting in values and growing numbers of global enterprises taking positive actions, such as broadening their vision statements to include NGOs and local stakeholders, some authorities claim we are losing the battle [4].
5
Operationalizing a TBL platform
Figure 3 is a TBL platform. A paradigm that recognizes the necessity for networking internally and externally – information sharing, learning, feedback; and connectedness must be vertical as well as horizontal to be holistic and for sustainable development to have any opportunity of success [36]. Twenty-five years of “command and control” policies targeted at the most obvious and egregious environmental problems, by media, are complex and now only marginally productive [37]. Continued progress in alleviating biospheric problems due to man’s intrusions and consumption is proving to be complex and difficult. Assuring a sustainable and humane future requires global business leadership. Holistic and inter-vertical, new initiatives, such as the UN Global Compact are “forcing” creative strategic planning by global enterprises to the local level; e.g., community pollution prevention programs, local government partnering and business compliance assistance, developing social capital through civil society. Local stakeholders are directly involved and have the most to win or lose with the development and health of their immediate surroundings [38, 39]. Many observers of the present environmental dilemma believe a significant number of undesirable outcomes of a monomorphic elitist bureaucracy could have been avoided with local socio-cultural input and gradual withdrawal of central control [24, 38, 39, 40, 41]. Without input of local stakeholders, whether they be farmers, ranchers, small manufacturers, community leaders, global enterprises, or consumers, a sustainable strategy is impossible. No one is suggesting governments and their agencies abandon responsibility of serving their peoples. But a growing number of business leaders, professionals and scholars are suggesting gradual withdrawal of central control. In most wellWIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
32 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI educated communities with rising levels of human consciousness and awareness of the connectedness of all life forms [33] central control just doesn’t work; for example, the collapse of the Russian empire. Randhir and Lee [41] see roles of central governments as external observers, suppliers of technical know-how, nurturers of mutual trust among multi-stakeholders and assisting development of well-structured incentive systems. Government intervention achieves very little in the absence of local efforts [24]. Global enterprises have a tremendous opportunity to lead, integrate and set examples. Today, the metrics strongly suggest it is profitable to do so. Pushing environmental and social responsibility to local stakeholders, including local businesses using TBL strategies with their diverse cultures, is risky. Conceptually, this also mimics dynamic diversity of the biosphere. By their very nature freedom and diversity are unpredictable and uncertain. But that is the TBL’s stratagem’s very strength: open mindedness, broad mindedness, tolerance, continually evolving, continually collaborating and competing openly in the market place of ideas and beliefs [22, 29].
6
Conclusions
To approach a life-style that is sustainable, UNGC’s ten principles plus global business leadership will have to expand their linear-reductionist orientations to encompass a holistic view of man, Earth, and even the cosmos. Are the global enterprises of the world ready to utilize these resources in their economic and strategic planning? Are global enterprises ready to embrace fellow local stakeholders – horizontally and vertically – all integral parts of Planet Earth and its biosphere? Are they ready to create triple bottom line platforms using their leadership to bring coherence and synergism to creating a win-win-win world? The battle has just begun. Several respected scientific journalists claim that progress is modest at best and in several cases moving backwards [4]. For sustainability to move toward becoming a reality inter-vertical as well as interhorizontal general systems should be implemented as a matter of general course by global enterprises, global NGOs, local socio-culture communities. Capitalizing on self-interest, collaboration and creativity are essential, the very essence of UNGC. Global business organizations have opportunities as well as responsibilities to encourage this inclusiveness for the betterment of all, for creating triple bottom lines so all can achieve their potential in a safe, secure and sustainable world.
References [1] [2] [3]
Short, J. R., Global dimensions: space, place and the contemporary world, London: Reaktion Books, 2001. Ruggie, J. G., “The United Nations and globalization: patterns and limits of institutional adaptation,” Global Governance, Vol. 9, No. 3, 301-321, 2003. United Nations – Millennium Goals, www.un.org/millenniumgoals WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29]
33
Speth, J.G., Red sky at morning: America and the crisis of the global environment, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2004. World Business Council for Sustainable Development, www.wbcsd.org Sustainable Forest Initiative, www.sfiprogram.org The International Council of Chemical Associations, www.responsiblecare.org Cement Sustainability Initiative, www.wbcsdcement.org CorpWatch, www.corpwatch.org Henderson, H., Beyond globalisation, West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press, 1999. Rosenau, J. N., Distance proximities: Dynamics beyond globalisation, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003. World Trade Organization, www.wto.org Robins, R. H., Global problems and the culture of capitalism, 3rd ed., Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 2005. Elkington, J., Cannibals with forks: The triple bottom line of 21st century business, Gabriola Island, BC, Canada: New Society Publishers, 1998. Toyota, www.toyota.com British Pump, www.bp.com GE Ecomagination, ge.ecomagination.com Royston, M. G., Pollution prevention pays, New York: Pergamon Press, 1979. Saunders, T. and L. McGovern, The bottom line of green is black: Strategies for creating profitable and environmentally sound business, San Francisco: Harper, 1994. Schmidheiny, S., Changing course: A global business perspective on development and the environment, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1992. Norgaard, Richard B., “Environmental economics: An evolutionary and a pleas for pluralism,” Journal of environmental economics and management, (December), 382–394, 1985. Vedeld, Paul O., “The environment and interdisciplinary ecological and neoclassical economical approaches to the use of natural resources,” Ecological economics, Vol. 10, No.1, 1–13, 1994. Waldrop, M. M., Complexity: The emerging science at the edge of order and chaos. NY: TOUCHSTONE, 1992. Hess, K., Jr., Visions upon the land, Washington, D.C.: Island Press, 1992. Hawken, P., The ecology of commerce, New York: Harper Collins, 1993. Rees, W.E., Sustainable development and the biosphere, Chambersburg, PA: ANIMA Books, 1990. Burrows, B. C., A. J. Mayne, and P. Newberry, Into the 21st Century, Twickenham, U.K.: Adamantine Press Limited, 1991. Daly, H.E., Steady-state economics, 2nd ed. Washington, D.C.: Island Press, 1991. Lovelock, J., Gaia: A new look at life on earth, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 1979. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
34 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40]
[41]
Rothschild, M., Bionomics, New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1990. Stikker, A., The transformation factor, Rockport, MA: Element, Inc, 1992. Tarnas, R., The passion of the western mind, New York: Harmon Books, 1991. Teilhard, de Chardin, P., The phenomenon of man, New York: Harper, 1959. Arthur, W. B., “Complexity and the Economy,” Science, Vol. 284, (2 April), 107-109, 1999. Prigogine, I., Order out of chaos, NY: Bantam Books, 1989. Lewin, R., Complexity: Life at the edge of chaos, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992. Norgaard, R.B., Development betrayed: The end of progress and a coevolutionary revisioning of the future, New York: Routledge, 1994. deGraaf, H. J., C. J. M. Musters and W. J. TerKeurs, “Sustainable development: Looking for new strategies,” Ecological economics, Vol. 16, No. 3, 205–216, 1996. Enama, M. T., “Culture: The missing nexus in ecological economics perspectives,” Ecological economics, Vol. X, No. 2, 93–95, 1994. Neace, M. B., “Holistic sustainability: Local culture and global business – a unique opportunity,” in Management of natural resources, sustainable development and ecological hazards, eds. Brebbia, Conti & Tiezzi, Southampton, UK: WIT Press, 3-12, 2005. Randhir, T. O. and J. G. Lee, “Managing local commons in developing economics: An institutional approach,” Ecological economics, Vol. 16, No. 1, 1–12, 1996.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
35
Environmental monitoring during beach nourishment using relict sands (central Tyrrhenian sea) D. Paganelli, P. La Valle, M. Gabellini, L. Lattanzi, B. La Porta, A. Pazzini, M. Targusi & L. Nicoletti ICRAM (Central Institute for Marine Research), Rome, Italy
Abstract This paper aims to underline the importance of monitoring studies during the execution of activities, like beach nourishment using relict sands, that plan the use of innovative technology. In fact, environmental monitoring studies allow prompt intervention in the case of unexpected events or interference factors. Potential negative repercussions on the marine environment could not be estimated through characterization studies carried out ante operam. This paper reports the monitoring study carried out for beach nourishment along the South Latium coasts (Tyrrhenian sea). In this area Posidonia oceanica meadows are present. In this context, a detailed and updated cartography and the knowledge of the P. oceanica beds distribution (a “priority habitat” in the UE Habitats Directive) allowed prompt identification of potential effects on the seagrass caused by specific technical procedures of the beach nourishment, not well-known in the planning phase of the project. Keywords: environmental monitoring, beach nourishment, Tyrrhenian sea.
1
Introduction
Among the different experimented technologies to control coastal erosion, beach nourishment with relict sands is considered a useful method to protect beaches, often preferable to the coastal defence structures (seawalls, groynes, emerged breakwaters) [1–3]. Nowadays, marine sand deposits exploitation is a very common technology both in Europe and in the rest of the world. The first documented beach nourishment project took place in USA during 1922-1923 at Coney Island, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070041
36 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI New York [4], while in Italy the first beach nourishment activity with relict sands took place at Pellestrina and Cavallino (Venice, Italy), and later on along the Ostia coast (Rome, Italy) [5–8]. Relict sands are constituted by marine deposits no more in equilibrium with the actual coastal sedimentary dynamics (paleo-beaches), occurring offshore and at great depth. Because the relict sand removal does not interfere with the coastal dynamics, the dredging of great volumes of sediments does not compromise the beach equilibrium. The employment of considerable volumes of sediments, together with the high biodiversity of the Mediterranean Sea, determines that for beach nourishment activities particular attention must also be paid to marine environmental characteristic, as well as to technical and economic aspects of the Project. It is known that dredging activities involve physical and biological effects on marine environment. The physical effects are related to the substratum alterations (sediment morphology and granulometry) and to the resuspension of bottom sediments into the water column with a consequent increasing of suspended particulate matter (turbidity) [9–11]. The most relevant biological impacts are related to the benthic community and to the demersal fish assemblages, both closely associated to the sea bottom [11–19]. The increasing of suspended particulate matter, related to the increase of turbidity, could be very dangerous in case the dredging and beach nourishment take place in the presence of sensitive habitats (like Posidonia oceanica meadows, coralligenous biocoenosis, etc.) and/or of very sensitive species to abiotic parameters variations and to environmental stress (natural and anthropogenic). In this context, a particular attention is paid to P. oceanica meadows, a mediterranean endemic species, considered as a “priority habitat” in the UE Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC), and listed in the “Natura 2000” like a Site of Community Importance (pSCI). This paper reports the methodological approach used by ICRAM to plan and improve the environmental monitoring study carried out off the coast of southern Latium (Tyrrhenian sea) for a beach nourishment operations with relict sands. P. oceanica meadows are present along this coast in shallow waters (between 15-30 m depth).
2
Study area
The study area is located in the central Tyrrhenian sea, along the Latium coasts from San Felice Circeo (Latina, Italy) to Sperlonga (Latina, Italy), fig.1. The shore is predominantly characterized by sandy sediments and by a gentlesloping sea-bed (1.3-2.2 %), with the presence of submerged bars. Between Terracina (Latina, Italy) and Lago Lungo (Latina, Italy), the superficial sediments show a finning seawards of the granulometry, following the bathymetry. Locally, the presence of Posidonia oceanica, make this sediment distribution irregular [20, 21].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
37
Study area.
In the study area the presence of P. oceanica seagrass identified two Sites of Community Importance (pSCI) according to the Directive 92/43/EEC: IT6000013 “Fondali tra Capo Circeo e Terracina” and IT6000014 “Fondali tra Terracina e Lago Lungo.
3
Characterization study ante operam
ICRAM, in 2004, has been encharged by the regional authority “Regione Lazio” to carry out the environmental monitoring study on an area located in the central Tyrrhenian Sea (southern Latium, Italy), off the coast of Terracina (Latina, Italy) in order to evaluate the environmental compatibility of the planned beach nourishment activities with relict sands. On the basis of the experience developed by ICRAM in the last years in planning and realizing environmental studies related to these activities, the monitoring sampling plan and the environmental parameters to study (benthic communities, demersal fish assemblages, superficial sediments and water column characteristics) have been defined. Recently, ICRAM’s studies and experiences allowed the realization of an environmental monitoring protocol related to relict sands dredging for beach nourishment [11]. Considering the presence of two pSCI characterized by Posidonia oceanica meadows in the study area, the characterization study ante operam has also involved an appropriate assessment of implications for pSCI sites according to the Directive 92/43 ECC (article 6, 3), in order to highlight potential effects of beach nourishment on P. oceanica beds and on their state of conservation. Analysis of bibliography regarding the P. oceanica meadows distribution in the study area has revealed the presence of old data and at an unsuitable scale [22]. For this reason, ICRAM and Regione Lazio has encharged the University of Rome “La Sapienza” to map the shallow P. oceanica meadows. Data obtained on physiographical and structural descriptors of P. oceanica seagrass (bed WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
38 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI density, upper and lower limits, bed typology), were confronted with the technical aspects of the nourishment working plan (volumes and type of sediments, period of activities, closure depth). Results showed that the most relevant effects, normally expected for this activities like the increasing of turbidity (with a possible regression of Posidonia limits) and burial events (due to beach nourishment), would have not caused relevant impacts on the meadows. In fact, the temporary increase of turbidity would have been limited to the utilization of sandy sediments and to the short period estimated for these activities. Besides, the greater depth of Posidonia upper limit (13–15 meters) compared to the maximum closure depth estimated by the Project (7 m) assured the absence of over-sedimentation. Therefore, in this specific case beach nourishment carried out according to technical specifications of the Project would have not caused relevant effects on P. oceanica meadows and on their state of conservation, ensuring environmental compatibility. Anyway, considering the innovative characteristic of this technology and the presence of P. oceanica, ICRAM decided to carry out a specific monitoring study during the execution of beach nourishment in order to intervene promptly in case of unexpected events.
4
Monitoring study during the activities
Beach nourishment was carried out in May-June 2006 using relict sands (a volume of 600.000 m3 sediments) dredged from a marine sand deposit located offshore Lavinio (Rome, Italy) in water deep between 80 and 100 m. These sandy sediments were carried to the nourishment shores (in water deep approximately 15 m) by means of a trailer suction dredge. For the replenishment of sediments on the beach a pipe about 1,5 km long and 90 cm in diameter was used. Direct observations made during the monitoring study in order to evaluate the evolution and the dispersion of the turbidity plume caused by the nourishment, identified some technical procedures, not predictable in the planning phase of the Project, capable of generating significant effects on marine ecosystems. In particular, during the beach nourishment the following was observed: - the need of an anchorage zone for the dredge during the hooking phase of marine pipes for the dumping of relict sands; - some anchorage zones were located upon P. oceanica meadow; - the use of dredge engines, necessary to stand the position during the dumping operations, also due to the low depth of bottom, created a significant dispersion of fine sediments in the water column near P. oceanica beds, fig. 2. All these observations, together with the knowledge of the real technical procedures used for the dumping, allowed prompt interventions fixing some additional technical instructions in order to protect the P. oceanica beds present in coastal shallow waters. In this case, it has been possible to provide some specific indications as the identification of some potential anchorage zones for the dredge. Besides, the use of the detailed and updated cartography of
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 2:
39
With red points the real anchorage zones of the dredge during beach nourishment are reported.
P. oceanica meadows realized by the University of Rome (fig. 3) suggested to use a support ship during the nourishment to obviate the driving of propellers, necessary to stand the dredge position during this activities, avoiding the dispersion of fine sediments near the Posidonia.
5
Conclusions
In the study case reported in this paper, the environmental monitoring plan arranged for the beach nourishment operations allowed prompt identification of potential effects on P. oceanica meadows caused by specific technical procedures of the activities, not well-known in the planning phase of the Project. In particular, considering the real technical procedures using for the nourishment and by means of a detailed and updated cartography of P. oceanica beds, it has been possible to propose some additional technical instructions in order to minimize effects on Posidonia seagrass in the shallow coastal waters. Our study indicates that the use of cartography and the knowledge of the marine benthic biocoenoses distribution, mainly of P. oceanica beds distribution (a “priority habitat” in the UE Habitats Directive) represent an essential instrument for planning environmental monitoring studies related to the beach nourishment.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
40 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 3:
Distribution map of Posidonia oceanica meadows present from San Felice Circeo to Sperlonga (Latium, Central Tyrrhenian sea) (reduced scale).
In general, this paper aims to underline monitoring studies in presence of sensitive execution of the activity), above all in the case not yet well-established, that can generate environments.
the necessity to plan specific habitat (monitoring during the of use of innovative technology, unpredicted effects on marine
References [1]
[2]
[3]
Preti, M. & Albertazzi, C., Complex sand nourishment in EmiliaRomagna Region. In: “MEDCOAST‘03 - Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on the Mediterranean Coastal Environment”, Özhan E. (ed.), 7-11 October 2003, Ravenna, Italy, pp. 1639-1648, 2003. Ansaloni, I., Baraldi, E., Mauri, M., Montanari, G., A.M., Preti, M., Prevedelli, D., Rinaldi, A., Simonini, R. & Todaro, M.A., Effetti dell’estrazione di sabbie marine sulla comunità macrozoobentonica delle sabbie relitte dell’Adriatico Settentrionale. Atti del XIII° Congresso Nazionale della Società Italiana di Ecologia, Como, 8-10 settembre, 2003. Ansaloni, I., Cavallini, F., Graziosi, F., Iotti, M., Massamba N’Siala, G., Mauri, M., Prevedelli, D., Simonini, R., Montanari, G. & Preti, M., Recupero delle comunità macrozoobentoniche in seguito all’estrazione di sabbie relitte in un area al largo delle coste dell’Emilia Romagna. Atti del WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[4] [5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11] [12] [13]
[14]
41
XV° Congresso della Società Italiana di Ecologia, Torino, 12-14 settembre, 2005. Green, K., Beach nourishment: a review of the biological and physical impacts. ASMFC (Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission). Habitat Management Series, 7, pp. 1274, 2002. Cecconi, G. & Ardone, G., La protezione delle spiagge della laguna di Venezia. In “Riqualificazione e salvaguardia dei litorali: idee, proposte e confronti tra esperienze mediterranee”, A. Tervisani e V. Petrocelli (eds.), ACLI Anni Verdi - Pro Loco Bernalda (MT), Patrocinio: Regione Basilicata, Amministrazione Provinciale di Matera, pp. 58-65, 1999. Nonnis, O., Nicoletti, L., La Valle, P., Celia Magno, M. & Gabellini, M., Environmental impact after sand extraction for beach nourishment in an area off Latium coast (Tyrrhenian sea, Italy). Littoral 2002, The changing coast. EUROCOAST/EUCC, Porto - Portugal (ed.), 3, pp. 81-84, 2002. Nicoletti, L., La Valle, P., Paganelli, D. & Gabellini, M., Il ripascimento mediante sabbie relitte: studi di compatibilità ambientale nell’esperienza laziale. Atti del congresso “Processi erosivi delle coste. Fenomeni di sedimentazione e trasporto: prevenzione e risanamento”, Vieste, 30 novembre 2002, pp. 48-53, 2002. Paganelli, D., La Valle, P., Maggi, C., Nicoletti, L., Nonnis, O. & Gabellini M., Il ripascimento della spiaggia di Roma (Ostia): Studio di compatibilità ambientale per lo sfruttamento dei depositi sabbiosi sommersi. Atti dei Convegni Lincei “Ecosistema Roma”, Roma 14-16 Aprile 2004, Bardi Editore, 218, pp. 359-365, 2005. Newell, R.C., Seiderer, L.J. & Hitchcock, D.R., The impact of dredging works in coastal waters: a review of the sensitivity to disturbance and subsequent recovery of biological resources on the sea bed. Oceanography and Marine Biology: an Annual Review, 36, pp. 127-178, 1998. Newell, R.C., Seiderer, L.J., Simpson, N.M. & Robinson, J.E., Impacts of marine aggregate dredging on benthic macrofauna off the South coast of the United Kingdom. Journal of Coastal Research, 20 (1), pp. 115-125, 2004. Nicoletti, L., Paganelli, D. & Gabellini, M., Aspetti ambientali del dragaggio di sabbie relitte a fini di ripascimento. Quaderno ICRAM n. 5, pp. 159, 2006. De Groot, S.J., The physical impact of marine aggregate extraction in the North Sea. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 53, pp. 1051-1053, 1996. Hitchcock, D.R., Newell, R.C. & Seiderer, L.J., Investigation of benthic and surface plumes associated with marine aggregate mining in the United Kingdom. Final Report, Contract Report for the U.S. Department of the Interior, minerals Management Service, Contract Number 14-35-000130763 Coastline Survey Ltd Ref. 98-555-03 (Final), 168 pp., 1999. van Dalfsen, J.A., Essink, K, Toxvig Madsen, H., Birklund, J., Romero, J. & Manzanera, M., Differential response of macrozoobenthos to marine
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
42 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18]
[19]
[20] [21]
[22]
sand extraction in the North Sea and the Western Mediterranean. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 57, pp. 1439-1445, 2000. Boyd, S.E., Limpenny, D.S., Rees, H.L., Cooper, K.M. & Campbell, S., Preliminary observations of the effects of dredging intensity on the recolonization of dredged sediments off the southeast coast of England (Area 222). Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 57, pp. 209–223, 2003. Boyd, S.E., Limpenny, D.S., Rees, H.L. & Cooperm, K.M., The effects of marine sand and gravel extraction on the macrobenthos at a commercial dredging site (results 6 years post-dredging). ICES Journal of Marine Science, 62, pp. 145-162, 2005. Simonini, R., Ansaloni, I., Bonvicini Pagliai, A.M., Cavallini, F., Iotti, M., Mauri, M., Montanari, G., Preti, M., Rinaldi, A. Prevedelli, D., The effects of sand extraction on the macrobenthos of a relict sands area (northern Adriatic Sea): results 12 months post-extraction. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 50, pp. 768-777, 2005. Nicoletti, L., Belluscio, A., La Valle, P. & Ardizzone, G.D., Monitoring of Posidonia oceanica Meadow after Beach Nourishment. In: “MEDCOAST‘05 - Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on the Mediterranean Coastal Environment”, Özhan E. (ed.), 25-29 October 2005, Kusadasi, Turkey, pp. 451-460, 2005. Marzialetti, S., Gabellini, M., La Porta, B., Lattanzi, L., La Valle, P., Paganelli, D., Panfili, M., Targusi, M. & Nicoletti L., Attività di dragaggio ai fini di ripascimento al largo di Montalto di Castro (VT): effetti sul popolamento a policheti. Biologia Marina Mediterranea, 13 (1), pp. 601-605, 2006. Cristofalo, G.C., I sedimenti attuali e recenti della piattaforma continentale interna tra Monte Circeo e la foce del Fiume Garigliano. Tesi di laurea sperimentale in Sedimentologia, 1992. La Monica, G.B. & Raffi, R., Morfologia e sedimentologia della spiaggia e della piattaforma continentale interna. In: “Il Mare del Lazio”, Università degli Studi di Roma “La Sapienza”, Regione Lazio Assessorato Opere e Reti di Servizi e Mobilità, pp. 62-105, 1996. Ardizzone, G.D. & Belluscio, A., Le praterie di Posidonia oceanica delle coste laziali. In: “Il mare del Lazio”, Università di Roma “La Sapienza”, Regione Lazio Assessorato opere e reti di servizi e mobilità, pp. 194-217, 1996.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
43
An economic and environmental total life cycle costing methodology and a web-based tool for environmental planning of buildings S. M. Haddad, F. Haghighat & S. Alkass Building, Civil and Environmental Engineering, Concordia University, Montréal, Canada
Abstract This research is a translation of the international Kyoto protocol into practical steps towards effective environmental planning in the building industry. This research develops a methodology to quantify environmental impacts of building materials to be used along with standard life cycle costing evaluation (LCC) resulting in total life cycle costing (TLCC). Based on the developed methodology, the economic LCC of building materials is calculated according to the ASTM’s standard methodology, while their environmental impact is first quantified in tones of CO2, based on Global Warming Potential (GWP), and then translated into monetary value to be used in the environmental impact LCC. Quantification of studied materials emission is done with the help of “SimaPro”, a professional life cycle assessment tool, considering their total life span. Monetary value of quantified CO2 emission is then taken from actual CO2 stock markets (i.e. Point Carbon: www.pointcarbon.com). Total life cycle costing (TLCC) is then calculated from both the estimated economic and the environmental impact LCCs. The methodology aims at a number of building professionals: 1) designers, 2) material specification writers and quantity surveyor, 3) permit authorities, 4) research groups, 5) developers, and 6) manufacturers. The methodology is supported with a web-based design tool named “EconoEnviroTLCC Tool”. The tool’s main goal is to put the developed methodology into practice by building professionals to better plan to achieve sustainable buildings. The tool enables its users to evaluate LCC, environmental LCC and total life cycle costing (TLCC) of partial and/or complete building envelope elements. The tool’s results are presented in tabular and graphic formats. Keywords: life cycle costing, environmental impact, building materials, building envelope, environmental design support tool. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070051
44 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
A joint study by the World Resource Institute and other international organizations [9] shows that Global energy use has risen by nearly 70% since 1971 (an average of 2% per year) and is poised to continue its steady increase over the next decades. In the building industry area, for example, the residential sector alone is responsible for 27% of the total world’s energy consumption. The International Energy Agency (IEA) projects that global energy consumption – and annual CO2 emissions – have risen by almost 50% from 1993 levels. This has great impact on our globe and our life as a result. Over the last few years, many national and international organizations have focused on issues related to Sustainable Built Environment. Many methodologies and tools, at different scales and localities, have been developed. Such tools play a very import role in promoting sustainability in the building industry [5]. The international community has come together, represented by delegates of most countries, to put a strategy to limit the human sufferings from the human negative influence on the environment. The Kyoto protocol, a landmark on the path of saving the environment in December 1997 [7], has defined clearer roles for participating countries with more specific environmental pollution figures and deadlines that participants have to abide with. In order to promote sustainable development, some protocol articles indicated that each participating country shall implement policies and measures in accordance with its national circumstances. The protocol states that participating parties shall, individually or jointly, ensure that their aggregate anthropogenic carbon dioxide equivalent emissions of the greenhouse gases do not exceed their assigned amounts, with a view to reducing their overall emissions of such gases by at least 5% below the 1990 levels in the commitment period 2008 to 2012. Life cycle costing LCC, the method used to “Justify a certain expenditure on a project/system by proving its savings along its life span” [1], has proven its viability in many fields, including the building industry. This research develops a methodology to evaluate total life cycle costing (TLCC) (both economic and environmental) of building materials. The mythology utilises the ASTM LCC principles on the economic evaluation and the Kyoto concept of emission trading on the environmental evaluation.
2
Economic life cycle costing and environmental impact life cycle costing
In the building industry, LCC is a straight forward method of comparing, projects, buildings or systems, old or new, to determine the lowest LCC amongst several alternatives. It is a very strong tool to justify higher initial costs to prove reduction along the total life span [10]. Such reduction could not be visible unless costs such as operation, maintenance, replacement and/or environmental savings are included. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
45
The method utilizes a technique that sums all relevant costs over a designated period of time, assumed to be the expected life span. When applied on buildings, in their design, renovation or even demolition stage, LCC could take into account some or all related costs such as: property, design, material, systems and equipment, construction or demolition, operation & maintenance and disposing of all involved elements. The summation could be in either present-value (PV) or annual value (AV) terms and takes into account discount and inflation rates. Several figures that are used in LCC calculations have to be actual costs (i.e. material costs) and could be taken directly from market or supplier prices or from pricing reference manuals such as RSMeans. On the other hand, some assumptions, during the calculation process, have to be made for other included elements such as maintenance costs, period of study, tax rate, inflation rate, nominal and/or real discount rates, initial and salvage monetary value of evaluated items [1,6]. The basic calculation of LCC of a project (building or system) in present value terms (PVLCC) could be expressed in the following equation (1) and graphically represented as shown in figure 1. N
LCC PV = ∑ t =0
Ct (1 + i ) t
(1)
where: Ct = sum of all relevant costs occurring in year t, N = length of study period in years, and i = discount rate. The above equation represents the summation of several equations that apply for life cycle of each building material separately; the process that is used in this research and applied in the developed EconoEnviroTLCC Tool and represented in the equation (2) [1] below. PVLCC = IC + PVM + PVR + PVF – PVS
(2)
where: IC = initial cost PVM = present value of maintenance and repairs cost, PVR = present value of replacements cost, PVF = present value of fuel and energy cost, PVS = present value of re-sale or salvage-value. On the other hand, life cycle costing of environmental impact of building materials is hard to comprehensively evaluate. A basic concept for evaluating environmental damage, of any material or activity, depends mainly on the balance between needs and benefit to stakeholders and end users. In other words, it depends on how much benefit and damage it does to its community in general. This is based on the concept of “social willingness to pay” to remove material/component and/or minimize the damage caused by the emissions from these materials or activities (Figure 2). This concept stays meaningless unless it is translated to measurable means such as: finding the costs adhered to removing and/or preventing the emissions of a material or activity from the environment. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
- PV of salvage value (PVS)
+ PV of energy & fuel cost
+ PV of replacement cost (PVR)
+ PV of maintenance cost (PVM)
+ Initial cost (IC)
46 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Life cycle costing in present value terms (PVLCC = IC + PVM + PVR + PVE – PVS) Figure 1:
Calculation process of life cycle costing in present value terms.
where: TX = Tax, SE = Socially Efficient level of Emissions, MSC = Marginal Social Cost, MPB = Marginal Private Benefit, MPB’ = Max. Private Benefit (shifted).
BENEFIT ($)
MPB
MSC TX MPB’
SE
Figure 2:
PE
DAMAGE
Benefit-damage balancing of a building.
Assigning monetary values for environmental impact of materials/systems is a science that is still in its very early stages. There are few trials in this direction, among which the EIO-LCA [3], and the Building for Environmental and Economic Sustainability tool [2]. However, the subject of this research is to develop a total life cycle costing for buildings and building materials that account for their direct costs and the cost related to their environmental impact. The research develops a methodology and a design support tool that could be easily and successfully used by building designers and/or officials to develop several alternatives for partial and/or complete buildings to choose the most economic and environmental friendly building material based on LCC principles.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
47
A A A E
Figure 3:
3
Economic PV calculation
Env. Impact calculation
Mat. economic LCC
Material environ. LCC
Total life cycle costing calculation (TLCC)
Economic & environmental database
The monetary evaluation of environmental impact, the main subject of this study, is based on the concept of: “Cost adhered to prevent an environmental damage, or cost applied to remove it” [4]. This research develops a methodology that applies this concept and abides with the Kyoto protocol articles to establish monetary evaluation methodologies of the environmental impact of buildings and building materials. The protocol states that “some participating parties shall, individually or jointly, ensure that their aggregate anthropogenic carbon dioxide equivalent emissions of the greenhouse gases do not exceed their assigned amounts . . . etc. This concept of is translated into emission trading strategy; between countries (and companies as well) that have committed themselves to an emission ceiling as per the Kyoto protocol agreement” [7]. Any environmental impact monetary evaluation could be simply based on the concept of cost related to preventing or removing related impact(s), as mentioned above. Emerging from this concept, this research considers and applies costs adhered to removing the damage caused by CO2 in its monetary evaluation of environmental impact of building materials. CO2 emissions of building materials is simulated and quantified using an life cycle analysis tool (SimaPro) and then its monetary value is defined according the CO2 current market value that is accessible form CO2 market trading (i.e. www.pointcarbon.com).
TLLC
Economic and environmental total life cycle costing (TLCC) calculation process.
Total life cycle costing (TLCC) methodology
The Total Life Cycle costing (TLCC) that accounts for direct cost and the cost of environmental impact of building materials, are calculated as per the procedure highlighted below (figure 3): a.
Calculate economic life cycle costing in present value terms “PVLCC” (as shown above).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
48 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI b. c.
Calculate environmental impact life cycle costing “EILCC” (as explained above). The sum of both PVLCC and EILCC is the anticipated total life cycle costing (TLCC), as represented in the equation below. TLCC = PVLCC + EILCC
(3)
where: TLCC = total life cycle costing of building envelope materials (in Dollars), PVLCC = economic life cycle costing (Dollars in present value terms), and EILCC = environmental impact cost of building materials (in Dollars).
4 The EconoEnviroTLCC Tool Beyond the developed methodology, as shown above, a design support tool, named the “EconoEnviroTLCC Tool” has been designed aiming at building designers and professionals to expand the methodology and put it forward for practice. The evaluation of the available sustainable tools showed that designers are still in-need for a total life cycle costing tool that integrates between economic and environmental costs buildings and building materials resulting in a total life cycle costing evaluation [5]. Even though that there are some trials in this regard, however, none of the available tools achieved as much features as those of the EconoEnviroTLCC Tool. Above all, none has been as straight forward towards buildings and building designers/professionals as the EconoEnviroTLCC Tool. The EconoEnviroTLCC consists of several input and output modules: • Introductory module, • Project module, • Material module (economic and environmental data), • Economic LCC module, • Environmental LCC module, • Graphics module, • Administrator’s module, and • Help module. Using the EconoEnviroTLCC Tool could be summarised in the following step: Inputs steps where a user can: • Start with creating a new project where he/she can define project’s location, year, discount rate, CO2 market price (per tone) and currency of the evaluation (figure 4). • Select building envelope elements (i.e. roofs, walls, doors, . . . etc.) and define their quantities (i.e. m3 or m2). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 4:
Figure 5: •
• •
49
Creating a new project.
Selecting building envelope elements and building materials.
Select materials for each envelope element where for each selected material, a user can use default values or override them with his/her own values. These values include economic and environmental values such as: material unit price, life span, annual maintenance cost, salvage value, distance material to be brought to construction site, method of transportation and end of life scenario. All above mentioned elements affect the economic and environmental life cycle calculation; therefore, uses are advised to be careful about values they use (figure 5). Economic life cycle costing in present value terms (PVLCC) of selected materials could be seen separately (for each building envelope element) or combined for the project as a whole (figure 6). Environmental impact life cycle costing (EILCC) of selected materials could be seen separately (for each building envelope element) or combined for the project as a whole (figure 7).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
50 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 6:
Figure 7:
Figure 8: • •
Economic LCC results.
Environmental LCC results.
Total life cycle costing (TLCC) results.
Total life cycle costing (TLCC) of the whole project could be seen in a separate screen showing both economic and environmental totals (figure 8). Bar graphic presentation of a single project that compares between its economic and environmental LCC could be presented, printed or saved to file.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 9: • •
5
51
Project-to-project comparison in graphic presentation.
Bar graphic comparison could be selected to compare between several projects comparing between their TLCC, economic PVLCC and environmental EILCC in three separate graphs (figure 9). Help menu could be accessed at any time to assist users on how to use the tool.
Conclusion
The building industry, which has a large consequence on resource depletion and energy consumption, results in large negative environmental effects. Governmental, private and public organisations have worked throughout the last few years to save our environments. Their efforts resulted in developing strategies, treaties, methodologies and environmental tools. All role players in the building industry (i.e. owners, designers, manufacturers and authorities) carry a share of the responsibility in this regard. Building designers, where the starting point of building realization takes place, could be the most important players in the process. The developed methodology in this research equips building designers as well as other building professionals with the proper tool (the EconoEnviroTLCC Tool) to plan for environmentally friendly designs. The developed methodology where environmental impact of buildings and building materials are evaluated in monetary terms based on LCC standards opens the way to its acceptance internationally, where every one understands it. This research is a step, among the early ones, in the direction of evaluating the environmental impact. The outcome of this research helps not only to expand the understanding of environmental impact of building materials to all related individuals and groups, but also to increase the possibility of environmentally friendly building design planning and achievement.
References [1]
ASTM, E 917 – 99 (2000), Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Pennsylvania, United States. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
52 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [2] [3] [4] [5]
[6] [7] [8]
[9] [10]
BEESR (2003), National Institute of Standards and Technology, Building and Fire Research Laboratory, Computer program and user manual, V3.0d, May 2003. Carnegie Mellon University Green Design Institute. (2006), Economic Input-Output Life Cycle Assessment (EIO-LCA) model, official website http://www.eiolca.net (2006). Goedkoop, M. and Spriensma, R. (2001), Third Edition, Eco-Indicator 99 methodology report, PRé Consultants (June 2001), Amersfoort, the Netherlands. Haddad, S., Alkass, S. and Haghighat, F. (2003), “Sustainable Building Design and Assessment Tolls, Current evaluation and future Expectations”; Proceedings of the 31st Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering, pp. END-250, June 4-7 June, Moncton, New Brunswick, Canada. Kirk, S. J. and Dell’lasola, A. J. (1995), Life Cycle Costing for Design Professionals, Second Edition, McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York. UNFCCC (1998), Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC website, (http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/convkp/kpeng.html). World Resource Institute (1998), Power Surge: Energy use and emissions continue to rise, A joint publication by the White, J., Case, K., Pratt, D., and Agee M. (1998), Principles of Engineering Economic Analysis, Fourth Edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York. World Resources Institute, the United Nations Environment Programme, the United Nations Development Programme, and the World Bank. Zhang, K. (1998), Life Cycle Costing for Office Buildings in Canada, M.SC. Thesis, Department of Building Engineering, Concordia University (Supervisor, Dr. S. Alkass).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 3 Mathematical and system modelling
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
55
Mathematical modelling applied to ecosystems: the Gödel’s theorem E. B. P. Tiezzi1, R. M. Pulselli2 & E. Tiezzi2 1
Department of Mathematics and Informatics, University of Siena, Italy Department of Chemical and Biosystems Sciences, University of Siena, Italy 2
Abstract In the framework of evolutionary physics, we must deal with goal functions instead of state functions: ecodynamic models must be based on relations evolving in time; far-from-equilibrium thermodynamics (Prigogine) is the foundation for a new description of nature. But if energy and mass are intrinsically conservative and entropy is intrinsically evolutionary, how can entropy be calculated on the basis of energy and mass quantities (entropy paradox)? This question is still unanswered and all we can do is note that the ecodynamic viewpoint is different from that of classical physics and classical ecology. This paper is an attempt to deal with these concepts.
1
Introduction
Recently some studies in mathematical logic have examined the possibility of getting computers to understand the concept of the passage of time. Indeed, the study of real-time systems, in other words systems in which temporal evolution plays a primary role, has made interesting advances. Specifically, the properties to describe in these systems are not only qualitative, properties which classical temporal logic can express, but also quantitative. It would be interesting to develop logics that express “eternal” constraints, such as the three dimensions, on one hand, and that tackle the real meaning of evolution, and hence the importance of events and their successions, on the other. Nature is evolutionary in character. The more one seeks to comprehend her, in the etymological sense of enclosing, imprisoning, in our mental schemes, the more she creates relations and complexity, memories and creative possibilities. It WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070061
56 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI is the passing of time that prevents us from capturing the fleeting moment of global knowledge. It is also important to underline that: • Space, by its structure, is reversible; • Time, by its structure, is irreversible. In order to achieve an ecodynamic description we need to shift our attention from state functions to goal functions and to configurations of processes. Obviously the mathematical machine par excellence, the computer, cannot understand the concept of evolution, the arrow of time. As with all machines, it is indifferent to the irreversibility of time, incapable of understanding the real meaning of time. We may also underline the following two statements by Jørgensen and Svirezhev [1]: The presence of irreducible systems is consistent with Gödel’s theorem, according to which it will never be possible to give a detailed, comprehensive, complete and comprehensible description of the world. Most natural systems are irreducible, which places profound restrictions on the inherent reductionism of science. Many ordered systems have emergent properties defined as properties that a system possesses in addition to the sum of properties of the components: the system is more than the sum of its components. Wolfram [2] calls these irreducible systems because their properties cannot be revealed by a reduction to some observations of the behaviour of the components.
2
Discussion
2.1 Gödel theorem In 1931, the young Viennese Kurt Gödel published a brief memoir on “formally undecidable propositions of Principia mathematica and similar systems” which concerned the incompleteness of a large class of formal theories, including arithmetic, as well as the impossibility of proving their coherence from within the theories themselves. Gödel’s theorem [3] is often summarized as: “there is at least one formula of arithmetic that cannot be demonstrated” and with the following formula:
(∃ y)(x) : Dim(x, y)
(1)
Interpreted in meta-mathematical language, the formula says “there is at least one formula of arithmetic for which no sequence of formulae constitutes a demonstration”. Jørgensen and Svirezhev [1] and Wolfram [2] underline that Gödel’s theorem requires that mathematical and logical systems (i.e. purely epistemic, as opposed WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
57
to ontic) cannot be shown to be self-consistent within their own frameworks but only from outside. A logical system cannot itself (from inside) decide on whether it is false or true. This requires an observer from outside the system, and this means that even epistemic systems must be open. The impossibility of completely knowing the world is linked to the principle of Pascal, according to which the whole is more than the sum of its parts. This deals a heavy blow to reductionism. The mutual irreducibility of space and time makes it impossible to completely know living evolving systems. 2.2 Thermodynamic uncertainty “At the instant when position is determined, the electron undergoes a discontinuous change in momentum. This change is the greater the smaller the wavelength of the light employed – that is, the more exact the determination of the position. Thus, the more precisely the position is determined, the less precisely the momentum is known, and conversely” (Heisenberg [4]). According to the laws governing the Compton effect, p1 and q1 are related by: p1q1 ≈ h (2)
E1t1 ≈ h
(3)
Equation (3) is equivalent to eqn (2) and shows that precise determination of energy can only be had at the cost of a corresponding uncertainty in time. Another relation can be derived from the uncertainty between position and momentum. Let ν and E be the velocity and energy corresponding to momentum px, then
ν∆px
∆x
≥h
ν ∆E∆t ≥ h
(4) (5)
where ∆E is the uncertainty of energy corresponding to the uncertainty of momentum ∆p x, and ∆t is the uncertainty in time within which the particle (or the wave packet) passes over a fixed point on the x-axis [5]. Irreversibility of time is not considered, since in the quantum mechanical paradigm, time is assumed to be reversible. It is possible to link these concepts with the generalized uncertainty associated with the presence in the Universe of both conservative (space, mass) and evolutionary quantities (time, life span). In dealing with evolutionary (living) systems, we may introduce a third concept: that of Thermodynamic Uncertainty related to the intrinsic irreversible character of time. Let us say that a thermodynamic uncertainty arises from the
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
58 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI experimental existence of the arrow of time and from the experimental evidence that, during the measurements, time goes by. Since time flows during the interval of an experiment (measurement), conservative quantities (energy and/or position) may also change leading to further uncertainty. Astrophysicists have recently discovered that the mass of a star is related to the star’s life span; the greater the mass, the shorter the life span. This too may be related to the uncertainty principle. It seems that there is a sort of uncertainty relation between space and time, space being related to mass and energy, which are conservative quantities. 2.3 The role of entropy Entropy breaks the symmetry of time and can change irrespective of changes in energy, energy being a conservative and reversible quantity, whereas entropy is evolutionary and irreversible per se. The flow of a non-conservative quantity, negentropy, makes life flow and the occurrence of a negentropy production term is the difference with respect to analysis based on exclusively conservative terms (energy and matter). The situation is explained in Figure 1 “The death of the deer”: at the moment of death, mass and energy do not change, whereas entropy does. There is an entropic watershed between far-from-equilibrium (living) systems and classical systems (the dead deer or any inorganic non living system).
Figure 1:
The death of the deer.
We may conclude that in systems far from thermodynamic equilibrium (biological and ecological), entropy is not a state function, since it has intrinsic evolutionary properties, strikingly at variance with classical thermodynamics.
References [1]
Jørgensen, S.E. and Svirezhev, Y.M., Towards a Thermodynamic Theory for Ecological Systems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2004.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[2] [3] [4]
[5]
59
Wolfram, S. Cellular automata as models of complexity, Nature, 311, 419-424, 1984 and Computer software in science and mathematics, Sci. Am., 251, 140-151, 1984. Nagel, E. and Newman, J.R. Gödel’s Proof, New York University Press, New York, 1985. Heisenberg, W. Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quantentheoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik‚ Zeitschrift für Physik, 43, 172-198, 1927; English translation in Wheeler and Zurek, Quantum theory and measurement, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 62-84, 1983. Fong, P. Elementary quantum mechanics, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Massachusetts, USA, 1962.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
61
A family of models to study the growth of Haloferax mediterranei in different conditions Y. Villacampa1, F. García-Alonso1, J. A. Reyes1, R. Martínez-Espinosa2 & M. J. Bonete2 1
Departamento de Matemática Aplicada, Universidad de Alicante, Spain Departamento de Agroquímica y Bioquímica, Universidad de Alicante, Spain
2
Abstract Haloferax mediterranei is a denitrifying halophilic archaeon able to grow with nitrite as the sole nitrogen source for growth in an assimilatory process under aerobic conditions. This haloarchaeon can also reduce nitrite in a respiratory process, where nitrite is the electron acceptor when oxygen conditions are limited. Due to this capability, Haloferax mediterranei could be applied in salted water bioremediation processes with the purpose of repairing the damage caused by the excessive use of fertilizers in agricultural activities. In this paper a family of different mathematical models has been generated to allow the study and the prediction of Hfx. mediterranei growth in high salt media with different nitrite concentrations. The relation between the growth and some variables are studied, for example nitrite concentration (N), oxygen concentration (O) and the time of growth (NH). This approach will allow us to analyse future Hfx. mediterranei uses as agent for bioremediation processes. Keywords: denitrification, Haloferax, bioremediation, modelling, stability.
1
Introduction
Denitrification is the reduction of nitrate or nitrite to gaseous nitrogen oxides. This pathway occurs mainly in bacteria and is used by most denitrifiers to support respiratory growth under anaerobic conditions [17]. Denitrification produces nitrogen loss in agricultural soils, and emitted N2O destroys the ozone layer and contributes to global warming. Deterioration of quality of inland and coastal waters is a serious environmental problem. Of particular concern is the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070071
62 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI wastewater containing organic nitrogen [6]. Nitrogen compounds can be removed from wastewater by a variety of physicochemical and biological processed. However, biological nitrogen removal is more effective and relatively inexpensive, by this reason it has been widely adopted in favour of the physicochemical processes [1]. In this way, denitrification could fill an important function in waste treatment by removing excess nitrogen in local environments and by anaerobically degrading organic pollutants. Nevertheless, high salt concentrations exert adverse effects on the metabolic pathway mentioned above [5]. By this reason, extreme microorganisms (mainly halophiles) have focused the scientific attention in the last few years. Extremely halophilic archaea (haloarchaea) generally grow heterotrophically under aerobic conditions in hypersaline environments, although they possess facultative anaerobic capabilities [4]. It has been demonstrated that Hfx. mediterranei grows under anaerobic conditions using nitrate as terminal electron acceptor [8], and we observed the induction of respiratory nitrate reductase (Nar) activity in these cultures. These results agree with other studies in which nitratereducing and denitrifying activities are induced under oxygen-limiting conditions only in the presence of nitrate [17]. Recently, it has been shown that Hfx. mediterranei also grows in the presence of nitrite concentrations as high as 40 mM, although the growth is slightly slow if it is compared with the growth rate observed in rich culture media or minimal culture media under aerobic conditions [9]. Nitrite is present as a natural component of the nitrogen cycle in freshwater ecosystems, however, its concentrations are increasing in freshwater environments as a consequence of several anthropogenic sources such as effluents from industries producing metals, dyes and celluloids, urban sewage effluents and aquaculture [2]. This nitrogen source (nitrite) is very toxic to aquatic animals, microorganisms, even to humans, because nitrite is able to oxidise the iron of the hemoglobin molecule to methemoglobin. The last molecule is not able to transport oxygen causing anoxia and death [2]. Hfx. mediterranei could be applied in salted water bioremediation processes with the purpose to repair the damage caused by the excessive use of fertilizers in agricultural activities. This application could be beneficial in regions such as Comunidad Valencia or Murcia (Spain), where the water tables contain high nitrate and nitrite concentrations due to fertilization practices [7]. In this work, using the experimental data, it has been carried out several mathematical studies to predict the Hfx. mediterranei growth in high salt media with different nitrite concentrations. It has been used methodologies to generate families of mathematical models, selecting those suitable models to explain the Haloferax mediterranei behaviour under certain conditions.
2 Methodology 2.1 Physiological experiments Hfx. mediterranei (ATCC 33500T) was grown in a minimal culture medium (pH 7.3) with different nitrite concentrations (5–45 mM NO2−) as sole nitrogen source as described before [9]. The oxygen concentration [O2] was 100% when WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
63
the medium was inoculated with 5 ml of a seed culture grown with 20 mM nitrite as nitrogen source. Hfx. mediterranei was grown at 37◦C in a 2 L flask in a Biostat B fermentor (B. Braun Biotech International). The [O2] was estimated with a calibrated pO2 electrode (Metller) during Hfx. mediterranei growth. The growth was monitored by measuring the optical density (OD) at 600 nm using a Biofotometer (Eppendorf). Nitrite was quantified using the diazo coupling method [10]. 2 ml aliquots of the cultures were taken during the growth period in order to determine all cited parameters. 2.2 Mathematical studies There are several methodologies to mathematical formulation of the relations obtained from experimental data. The methodologies implemented in software such as SPLUS and SPSS share the common characteristic of determining simple and multiple linear relations in a similar manner [11,12]. It is also possible to obtain nonlinear relations so that for each execution, a type of equation is proposed, with coefficients calculated by applying the least squares method. To the automatic search among different models, we must cite [3,15], which present the Modelhss methodology, with which families of nonlinear models can be obtained in a formal language generated from different orders of vocabularies. The equations obtained in Modelhss are linear combinations of functions defined on the basis of vocabularies, and their statistical treatment is reduced to the multiple linear cases, as their parameters are linear. The methodology developed in [13] generates families of mathematical models with nonlinear parameters, and includes the study of linear models, based on the experimental data of the intervening variables.
3
Results and discussion
Previous physiological experimental analysis have revealed that Hfx. mediterranei could be an excellent model to establish new salted water bioremediation processes [9], because this haloarchaeon is able to reduce high nitrate and nitrite concentrations in presence of high salt concentrations. This ability is quite interesting from a biotechnological point of view because most of the denitrifying microorganisms are unable to develop these reactions under salted conditions [5]. We have analysed different mathematical models to predict the Hfx. mediterranei growth in cultures with high nitrite concentration, using methodologies studied in [11–16]. The followed mathematical expression has been found as the better model to predict Hfx. mediterranei growth under the cited conditions in methodology. It is proposed as a better model
C = −1.714e0.023 N + 0.003Ox + 4.259 ,
R 2 = 0.9
So it can write,
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(1)
64 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
N=
1 1 ln ( −C + 0.003Ox + 4.259 ) 0.023 1.714
(2)
It has been studied the stability of the models against perturbations in experimental data, applying the methodology implemented in [14,16]. It can be observed that for perturbations of 10% and 20% in the experimental data, the model is stable (Figure 1). In this figure is observed the variation that it is produced in the model when it has been carried out perturbations of 10% and 20% in experimental data. A
Perturbations in experimental data Figure 1:
B
Perturbations in experimental data
Stability of the models. A) the perturbation of experimental data was 10% and in B) the perturbation of experimental data was 20%.
Using the model and Eq. (2) it has been carried out an estimate of the nitrite present into the culture media during the growth at different times. These results can be observed in the Figure 2. It can be deduced that the behaviour inferred for the growth of Hfx. mediterranei in 45 mM nitrite is similar to the behaviour experimentally observed and described previously for 40 mM nitrite (Figure 3) [9]. The results obtained in (Figure 3) show that Hfx. mediterranei grows in the presence of nitrite concentrations as high as 40 mM. As can be seen in the OD curve of the figure 3, two different metabolic processes can be distinguish; i) the growth is especially slow during the first 10 days, a period of time in which the [O2] is higher than 2%. This phase of growth correspond to the aerobic nitrite reduction pathway where nitrite is used as nitrogen source for growth. When the oxygen is completely consumed, the rate of growth increased substantially, indicating that nitrite present in the culture media could act as nitrogen source and as the terminal electron acceptor under anoxic conditions. The nitrite present in the culture media was removed during the growth of Hfx. mediterranei, in fact, at the final of the stationary phase of growth (OD600 =2.2), only 20% of the nitrite present in the culture was not eliminated. As it has been described before, these metabolic pathways are usually inhibited under salted conditions. So it is possible to think that this haloarchaeon could be applied in water bioremediation
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
65
Hfx. mediterranei growth in 45 mM nitrite 120
2,5
100
50 OD 600 nm (growth) % Oxygen [Nitrite estimated] (mM)
2,0
40
1,5
30
1,0
20
0,5
10
[nitrite] (mM)
60
OD 600 nm
% Oxygen
80
40
20
0
0,0
0
200
400
600
800
0
Time (hours)
Figure 2:
The prediction of Hfx. mediterranei growth in a minimal culture medium with nitrite as the sole nitrogen source. OD at 600 nm; nitrite concentration in the culture medium; percentage of O2. Hfx. mediterranei growth in 40 mM nitrite
120
2,5
45 40
100
2,0
OD 600 nm
% Oxygen
60
30 OD 600 nm (growth) % oxygen 25 [Nitrite] (mM)
1,5
1,0
20
40
[nitrite] (mM)
35 80
15 20
0
0,5 10 0,0 0
100
200
300
400
500
5 600
Time (hours)
Figure 3:
Experimental Hfx. mediterranei growth in a minimal culture medium with nitrite as the sole nitrogen source. OD at 600 nm; nitrite concentration in the culture medium; percentage of O2..
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
66 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI processes with the purpose to repair the damage caused by the excessive use of fertilizers in agricultural activities. Besides, it has been demonstrated that Hfx. mediterranei growth can be predicted with mathematical approaches, which make easier the applications of this haloarchaeon in salted water treatments.
4
Conclusions
With the mathematical models obtained it has been able to compare and predict the experimental physiological results previously described from Hfx. mediterranei growth taken in account different parameters such as nitrogen source or oxygen concentration. The models obtained allow us to analyse and validate the experimental results carried out previously [9]. Our aim is to obtain new sets of experimental data under similar and different conditions to those consider in this article with the objective to generate new mathematical model. With this kind of studies, we contribute to the modern biocatalysts knowledge which is achieving new advances in environmental and healthy fields (using enzymatic or whole cells bioremediation).
Acknowledgements This work was supported in part by funds from AE/07/091 (MJB) and AE/07/074 (YVE) from Generalitat Valenciana. The authors thank Dr. F. Verdu and Dr Y. Villacampa for providing the mathematical models [13,15] and the stability of the models [14,16].
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
Ahn, YH. Sustainable nitrogen elimination biotechnologies: a review. Process Biochemistry, 41, 1709-1721, (2006). Alonso, A. and Camargo J.A. Toxicity of nitrite to three species of freshwater invertebrates. Environmental Toxicology, 90-94 (2006) Cortés, M. ; Villacampa, Y.; Mateu, & Usó,. J.L. ‘A new methodology for modelling highly structured systems’ Environmental Modelling Software 15, pp 461-470, (2000). DasSarma, S., and P. Arora. Halophiles, p. 458–466. In Encyclopedia of life sciences, vol. 8. Nature Publishing Group, London, United Kingdom, (2002). Kargi, F. and Uygur, A. Biological treatment of saline wastewater in a rotting biodisc contactor by using halophilic organisms. Bioprocess Engineering, 17, 81-85 (1997) Khin, T. and Annachhatre, A.P. Novel microbial nitrogen removal processes. Biotechnology advances, 22, 519-532 (2004) Legaz, F. & Primo-Millo, E. Influencia de la fertilización nitrogenada en la contaminación por nitratos de las aguas subterráneas. Levante Agrícola 318, 4–15, (1992). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[8]
[9]
[10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
[15] [16] [17]
67
Lledó, B., Martíınez-Espinosa, R.M., Marhuenda-Egea, F.C. and Bonete, M.J. Respiratory nitrate reductase from haloarchaeon Haloferax mediterranei: biochemical and genetic analysis. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1674, 50–59, (2004). Martíınez-Espinosa, R.M.; Richardson, D.J.; Butt, J.N. & Bonete, M.J. Respiratory nitrate and nitrite pathway in the denitrifier haloarchaeon Haloferax mediterranei. Biochemical Society Transactions 34, part 1, 115117, (2006). Snell, C.D. & Snell, C.T. Colorimetric Methods of Analysis, vol. 2, pp. 802–807, Van Nostrand, New York, (1949). S-Plus 2000. Guide to statistics volume 1,2. Mathsoft, Inc (2000). Spss. Inc. Software, Chicago, USA (1999). Verdu, F & Villacampa, Y. A Computational algorithm for the multiple generation of nonlineal mathematical models and stability study. Advances in Engineering Software. In Press. Verdu, F & Villacampa, Y. A computer program for a Monte Carlo analysis of sensitivity in equations of environmental modelling obtained from experimental data. Advances in Engineering Software. Vol. 33, Nº 6. pp.351-359, (2002). Villacampa, Y.; Cortés, M.; Vives, F. & Castro, M.A. ‘A new computational algorithm to construct mathematical models.’ Ecosystems and sustainable development II Ed. WIT Press (1999). Villacampa, Y; Verdu, F & Pérez, A. A Stability theory for model systems. Kybernetes. Vol.36, Nº.5-10.pp. 1-23, (2007). Zumft, WG. Cell biology and molecular basis of denitrification. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 61(4):533-616, (1997).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
69
Lotus glaber Mill. Induced autotetraploid: new forage resource for the Flooding Pampas M. Barufaldi1, Y. Villacampa2, P. Sastre-Vázquez3, F. García-Alonso2 & J. A. Reyes2 1
Cátedra de Genética y Fitotecnia, Facultad de Agronomía de Azul-UNCPBA, Buenos Aires, Argentina 2 Departamento de Matemática Aplicada, Universidad de Alicante, Alicante, Spain 3 Área de Matemáticas, Facultad de Agronomía de Azul-UNCPBA, Buenos Aires, Argentina
Abstract Lotus glaber Mill., a perennial leguminous forage plant endemic to Europe and introduced into Argentina in 1930, has adapted to the Flooding Pampas region’s ecological characteristics, successfully becoming part of the native vegetation. Given its high nutritional value and the fact that it does not cause meteorism, this plant has great potential for increasing the productivity and quality of the Pampas grazing land. In Azul, a Buenos Aires province, an L. glaber genetic improvement programme resulted in an induced autotetraploid population called Leonel, through the use of colchicine. In addition to preserving the species’ valuable characteristics, this population has a series of significant morphological modifications compared to diploid populations. This paper compares the Leonel population in terms of the length and width of its central foliolae (LCF and WCF), its area (A) and the length/width ratio (L/W) of the central foliolae of the first expanded leaf from the apex, during the following seasons: mid-winter (1), late winter (2), and late spring (3) of 2006. Variance analyses, in a completely random sample with one factor, seasons, carried out for each variable, detected significant differences (1%) in all cases. Analysis of the L/W ratio has made it possible to determine the foliolae’s forms. During the winter period, seasons 1 and 2, the foliolae took a narrowly obovate shape, while in the spring they had an oblanceaolate shape. The results obtained lead to the conclusion that there is a high level of variation in length and width, as well as the foliolae’s shape and size. Keywords: Lotus glaber Mill., induced autotetraploid, forage legume, natural pastureland, mathematical modelling. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070081
70 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Flooding Pampas region of Buenos Aires province, whose surface area totals approximately 9 million hectares, is Argentina’s principal cattle-raising region. Eighty-five percent of its livestock feeds on natural pastureland, and the rest on cultivated pastureland (Sácido [1]). In most natural vegetable communities there is a small amount of native leguminous plants that can serve as forage, and the planting of conventional leguminous crops is limited by poor soil quality (García et al [2]). Lotus glaber Mill., commonly known as narrowleaf birdsfoot trefoil, is a perennial leguminous plant suitable for forage endemic to Europe. It was introduced in Argentina in about 1930, and it spread naturally in the pastureland of Flooding Pampas. During the 1970s, it attracted interest as a forage species, given its nutritional qualities and the fact that it does not cause meteorism. Numerous authors consider it an improved natural pastureland species, of great importance for the region’s livestock breeding (Barufaldi et al. [3]). The soils this species occupies have poor fertility and drainage, moderate sodium levels and low concentrations of available phosphorus. Frequent disturbances in local vegetation, such as agricultural work, overgrazing, fires in communities of tussock paspulum (Paspalum quadrifarium), and floods, have facilitated L. glaber’s colonisation (Juan et al. [4], Miñon et al. [5]). Its growth pattern is spring-summer-autumn, growing intensely in spring and early summer, later decaying with flowering and recovering quickly in the fall after going to seed. The fodder produced has a high nutritional value that varies little throughout the cycle, even during the seed-bearing stage. L. glaber is a diploid species whose chromosome number is 2n=2x=12. Its growth is semi-prostrate to prostrate, it has a pivotal root with lateral branching, and its stalk is round at the base and squared at the section of active growth. Its inflorescence is a typical umbellate, with 2-8 flowers joined by a short pedicel to a long peduncle. Each leaf consists of five foliolae, which are generally oblanceolate, ellipticoblanceolate or narrowly obovate (Kirbride [6]). Induced polyploids have been used in some forage species such as Dactylis glomerata ssp. lusitanica, Lolium perenne, Lolium multiflorum, Secale cereale, Trifolium pratense, Trifolium hybridum, and Lotus pedunculatus, for the purpose of obtaining improved autotetraploid cultivars or to generate interspecific hybrids. In general, the induced autotetraploids in ryegrass, rye, clovers and big trefoil show better establishment, higher in vitro digestibility and forage production, and better performance in response to such adverse factors as disease, frost and drought, than corresponding diploids. In Argentina, there have been scant efforts to genetically improve L. glaber, which has resulted in poor availability of cultivars. There are few antecedents for obtaining induced tetraploid plants (2n=4x=24) through the chromosomal doubling of diploid plants, and no tetraploid cultivars are on the market. In Azul, a Buenos Aires province, an L. glaber genetic improvement programme obtained an induced tetraploid cultivar population called Leonel WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
71
(2n=4x=24), (Barufaldi et al. [7]). This population was obtained through colchicine treatment of seedlings obtained from seeds collected from naturalised L. glaber populations. The programme aimed to obtain tetraploid cultivars with enhanced productive and health aspects, selected for the Flooding Pampas’s normal grazing conditions. In addition to preserving the species’ valuable characteristics, this population exhibits a series of significant morphological modifications compared with diploid populations. In previous articles referring to this improvement programme, increased dry material was detected when compared to a control diploid population (Barufaldi et al. [8]). It could be assumed that this increase is due in part to the larger size of the foliolae in the evaluated tetraploid (“tetraploid cytotype”), compared with diploids (“diploid cytotype”). Furthermore, in another article (Barufaldi et al. [3]) the area of the central foliolae in the Leonel population was studied, and a formula was determined that allows for the estimation of the foliolae’s area, based on its width. Most morphological diversity studies focus on the classification of species and the differences within species on a broad geographical scale, with the goal of generating strategies that optimise in situ preservation and examining inter- and intra-regional morphological diversity specific to species. Moreover, the study of populations’ morphological stability is also important when requesting the registration of varieties of agricultural plant species. The programme under way has the long-term objective of achieving an improved cultivar derived from the Leonel germplasm and registering it. In Argentina, marketing the seed of a new cultivar currently requires its prior registration with the National Seed Institute (INASE). There are two agencies that authorise its distribution: the National Cultivar Register (RNC), which regulates all species; and the Taxation System (RF), which applies only to cultivars from the major agricultural species. The latter is obligatory, authorising the marketing of seeds in the Inspected category, as well as those in the Identified category. All cultivars identified for the first time are registered with the RNC. The legislation in force, Decree No. 2183/91, distinguishes between “new” and “unknown” varieties, on one hand, and “publicly known” varieties. Whoever requests registration of a cultivar must describe its morphological, phenological and health characteristics in a way that distinguishes it from other cultivars, and make a commitment to maintain the material’s genetic purity. In the case of L. glaber, required information includes data on the typical (central) foliolae, and for this purpose it is necessary to determine: 1) its shape (linear, lanceolate, linear-lanceolate, oblong, oval, or other); 2) its length; and 3) its width. If the long-term objective is to achieve a new variety and register it, the description of its morphology, among other characteristics, has a clear importance. The central foliolae’s features are useful in the characterisation of the germplasm and for genetic and evolutionary studies (Urrea and Singh [9]). This study evaluated the seasonal stability of the central foliolae of the Leonel induced tetraploid population of Lotus glaber, in regard to size and shape, for the
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
72 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI purpose of determining whether there is morphological variation within the population during different seasons
2
Materials and methodology
All experimental materials and data were utilised in the Azul Agronomy School, Buenos Aires province (36º 45´ S, 59º 50´ W and 132 msm), Argentina, during 2006. The plant material was taken from the Leonel population. During the month of March 2006, 200 seeds were left to germinate in accordance with ISTA norms. The seedlings obtained were transplanted in 2-litre plastic planters, with soil and compost; when they reached the height of 15 cm they were permanently transplanted in 5-litre plastic planters and remained in a greenhouse under optimal temperature and irrigation conditions. The samples were obtained while the plants were in a vegetative state: season 1 (winter), season 2 (late winter) and season 3, at the start of the reproductive state (late spring). For each season, 40, 61 and 50 planters, respectively, were selected at random. Three stalks were taken at random from each plant, and from each of them the central foliolae corresponding to the first developed (expanded) leaf from the apex was utilised. For each of the foliolae, measurements were taken of: 1) the central foliolae’s length in centimetres, from the foliar lamina’s point of insertion in the petiole to the foliolae’s apex, and 2) the central foliolae’s width measured in centimetres at an angle perpendicular to the central nerve of the foliolae’s widest point. On the basis of this data, the central foliolae’s area was estimated using the model Af =1.76658 A - 0.4990925 (Barufaldi et al. [3]). The central foliolae’s shape is determined by its length and width, following the classification presented by (Hickey [10]). An analysis of variance has been performed, using a completely random design with one factor – i.e., seasons – and the variables of area, length, width and length/width ratio. Furthermore, for each season considered, linear regressions between length (dependent variable) and width (independent variable) were adjusted
3
Data analysis
The results of the variance analysis, applied to a completely random design and a model with a single factor (seasons) for the variables of area, length, width and length/width ratio of the central foliolae, are presented in tables 1–4. Significant differences were detected between the three seasons for the four variables studied. The means are compared through Duncan’s test, as reflected in tables 5–8. The sizes of the central foliolae, evaluated according to their area, proved to be significantly different for the three seasons studied. The largest sizes were found in the vegetative states, corresponding to seasons 1 and 2. During season 3 – that is, at the start of the reproductive state – the foliolae were at their smallest size. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 1:
ANOVA for the variable: Area of the central foliolae. Dependent variable: Area. Squared = .229 (Adjusted R Squared = .225). Source Corrected Model Intercept season Error Total Corrected Total
Table 2:
Type III Sum of Squares
df
6,746(a)
2
224,369 6,746 22,736 253,288
1 2 449 452
29,481
451
Mean Square
F
Sig.
3,373
66,607
,000
224,369 3,373 ,051
4430,973 66,607
,000 ,000
ANOVA for the variable: Length of the central foliolae (LCF). Dependent Variable: LCF. R Squared = .077 (Adjusted R Squared = .073). Source Corrected Model Intercept Season Error Total Corrected Total
Table 3:
73
Type III Sum of Squares
df
Mean Square
F
Sig.
1,521(a)
2
,760
18,810
,000
935,759 1,521 18,191 978,768
1 2 450 453
935,759 ,760 ,040
23147,731 18,810
,000 ,000
19,712
452
ANOVA for the variable: Width of the central foliolae (WCF). Dependent Variable: WCF. R Squared = .237 (Adjusted R Squared = .233).
Source Corrected Model
Type III Sum of Squares
df
Mean Square
F
Sig.
2,259(a)
2
1,130
69,735
,000
Intercept
208,201
1
208,201
12853,395
,000
season
2,259
2
1,130
69,735
,000
Error
7,289
450
,016
Total
219,969
453
Corrected Total
9,548
452
For the LCF, the largest measurement of 1.53 cm was taken in season 3, which was significantly different from the other two seasons, which did not exhibit any differences among themselves. As for WCF, significant differences were detected for all the seasons (1, 2 and 3), with measurements of 0.68 cm, 0.78 cm and 0.60 cm, respectively.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
74 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 4:
ANOVA for the variable: length/width (L/W) of the central foliolae. Dependent Variable: L/W. R Squared = .416 (Adjusted R Squared = .413). Source Corrected Model Intercept season Error Total Corrected Total
Type III Sum of Squares
df
Mean Square
F
Sig.
41,226(a)
2
20,613
160,115
,000
2118,421 41,226 57,932 2307,855
1 2 450 453
2118,421 20,613 ,129
16455,418 160,115
,000 ,000
99,157
452
Table 5:
Duncan’s test for the variable area. Area of central foliolae Alpha 0.001
season
N
3,00
150
1,00
182
2,00
120
Subset 1
2
,5586 ,7093 ,8765
Sig.
1,000
Table 6:
3
1,000
1,000
Duncan’s test for the variable LCF. Length of central foliolae: LCF Alpha 0,001 season
Subset
N
1
183
1,3973
2,00
120
1,4463
3,00
150
1,5325
Sig.
Table 7:
2
1,00
,038
1,000
Duncan’s test for the variable WCF. Width of central foliolae: WCF Alpha 0.001 season
N
3,00
150
1,00
183
2,00
120
Sig.
Subset 1
2
3
,5980 ,6842 ,7820 1,000
1,000
1,000
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 8:
season 2,00 1,00 3,00 Sig.
75
Duncan’s test for the variable L/W. Length/Width ratio: L/W Alpha 0.001 Subset N 1 2 1,87 120 63 183 2,0885 150 1,00 1,000 0
3
2,6195 1,000
Analysis of the L/W ratio allowed for determination of the foliolae’s shapes. During the winter period, seasons 1 and 2, the foliolae were narrowly obovate, while during the spring they were oblanceaolate. These results lead to the conclusion that there is a high level of variation, in length and width, as well as the foliolae’s shape and size, during the states of vegetative development (seasons 1 and 2) and the start of the reproductive state (season 3), as can be observed in table 9. Table 9:
Measurements of variables studied for different seasons.
Seasons
Length Width
L/W
Shape
1 Winter
1,3973
,6842
2,0885 narrowly obovate ,7093
2 Late Winter
1,4463
,7820
1,8763 narrowly obovate ,8765
3 Late Spring
1,5325
,598
2,6195
oblanceolate
Area
,5586
3.1 Mathematical modelling Mathematical models have been determined for calculating the ratio of foliolae length as a function of width (length/width). Of the models studied, the best were linear models without intercept – i.e., linear regressions expressed by straight lines that pass through the origin. In all cases, the significance tests of the regressions for each season detected that the variable in question (width) made a significant contribution. Tables 10–12 show ANOVA, the estimates of the mathematical models and R2. Figure 1 shows the linear regressions without intercept for each season.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
76 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 10:
LCF Season 1: ANOVA, the estimates of the mathematical models and R2.
Mean Sum of Squares df Square Regression 355,801 1 355,801 Residual 8,339 182 ,046 Total 364,140 183 The independent variable is WCF. The equation was estimated without the constant term. Coefficients Unstandardized Standardized Coefficients Coefficients Std. B Beta t Error WCF 1,998 ,023 ,988 88,121
R ,988 Table 11:
R Square ,977
Adjusted R Square ,977
F Sig. 7765,326 ,000
Sig. ,000
Std. Error of the Estimate ,214
LCF Season 2: ANOVA, the estimates of the mathematical models and R2.
Mean Sum of Squares df Square Regression 250,427 1 250,427 Residual 4,065 119 ,034 Total 254,492 120 The independent variable is WCF. The equation was estimated without the constant term. Coefficients Unstandardized Standardized Coefficients Coefficients Std. B Beta t Error WCF 1,826 ,021 ,992 85,624 Std. Error Adjusted R of the Square R R Square Estimate ,992 ,984 ,984 ,185
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
F Sig. 7331,521 ,000
Sig. ,000
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 12:
77
LCF Season 3: ANOVA, the estimates of the mathematical models and R2.
Mean Sum of Squares df Square Regression 350,257 1 350,257 Residual 9,879 149 ,066 Total 360,136 150 The independent variable is WCF. The equation was estimated without the constant term. Coefficients Unstandardized Standardized Coefficients Coefficients Std. B Beta t Error WCF 2,508 ,035 ,986 72,683
R ,986
R Square ,973
Adjusted R Square ,972
F Sig. 5282,792 ,000
Sig. ,000
Std. Error of the Estimate ,257
REGRESSIONS 3.5 3 2.5
LFC
2 1.5 1 0.5 0 0
0.5
1
1.5
AFC Season 1
Figure 1:
Season 2
Season 3
Regressions linear of the length in the seasons.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
78 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
Conclusions
The results obtained demonstrate that there is important variation in the size and shape of the central foliolae between the vegetative period and the start of the reproductive state. The analyses of variance, using a completely random design with one factor – i.e., seasons – carried out for each variable, detected significant differences (1%) in all cases. For LCF, the largest measurement of 1.53 cm corresponded to season 3, which was significantly different from measurements in the other two seasons, which did not show significant differences among themselves. As for the WCF, significant differences were detected for all the seasons (1, 2 and 3), with measurements of 0.68 cm, 0.78 cm and 0.60 cm, respectively. Analysis of the L/W ratio allowed for determination of the foliolae’s shapes. During the winter period, seasons 1 and 2, the foliolae were narrowly obovate, while during the spring they were oblanceaolate. It has been established that in the former state the shape is narrowly obovate and in the second it is oblanceaolate. These conclusions are important because they constitute progress in the characterization of the new germplasm’s central foliolae. Subsequent studies will make it possible to complete the list of requisites for achieving a complete characterisation needed for registration. The results obtained allow us to conclude that there is a high level of variation in length and width, as well as the foliolae’s shape and size, during the states of vegetative development (seasons 1 and 2) and the start of the reproductive state (season 3).
Acknowledgement This work was supported in part by funds from AE/07/074 Generalitat Valenciana.
(YVE) from
References [1] [2]
[3] [4]
Sácido, M. (2001). Pampa Deprimida Bonaerense, Descripción, Estado Actual y Manejo Sustentable. Primer Congreso Nacional sobre Manejo de Pastizales Naturales. Santa Fe, Argentina. 9-11de agosto. pp. 26-28. García, E., Rambeaud, D. E., Serpa, G. P. & Serrano, P.M. (1994). Lotus tenuis Waldst et Kit.Un importante recurso forrajero para la Pampa Deprimida Argentina. Pergamino. Estación Agropecuaria. Boletín de Divulgación Técnica Nº 102. pp. 20. Barufaldi, M., Villacampa, Y., Sastre-Vázquez, P. and Verdú F. (2007). A systems study of lotus’s leaf area. Kybernetes. Vol 36, Nº2, pp. 225235. Juan, V.; Monterroso, L.; Sácido M. and Cauhépé (2000). Postburning legume seeding in the Flooding Pampas, Argentina. Journal of Range Managent, 53, pp. 300-304. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[5] [6] [7]
[8]
[9] [10]
79
Miñon, D., Sevilla, G., Montes, L. & Fernández (1990). LOTUS TENUIS: leguminosa forrajera para la Pampa Deprimida. Boletín técnico Nº 98. INTA EEA, Balcarce. pp. 15. Kirbride, J. (1999). Lotus Systematics and Distribution. In: Trefoil: The Science and Technology. CSSA Special Publication Number 28. pp. 1-20. Barufaldi, M., Andrés, A., Crosta, H. & Eseiza, M.(2000).Obtención de una población autotetraploide de Lotus glaber Mill. (Lotus tenuis Waldst. & Kit). Revista de Tecnología Agropecuaria INTA Pergamino, Vol. V (15): pp.45-50. ISSN 0328-7750. Barufaldi, M. S., Crosta H., Eseiza, M., Cardozo, J., Schwab, M., Scenpio, V., Egoburo. D. ( 2002) .Evaluación preliminar del efecto de la poliploidía en Lotus glaber Mill. Taller interdisciplinario sobre aspectos genéticos, moleculares y ecofisiológicos del Lotus spp. y sus simbiontes. Sección: Taller de Mejoramiento Genético y Manejo de Cultivares. Organizado por el Instituto de Investigaciones Biotecnológicas -Instituto Tecnológico de Chascomús. IIB - INTECh / UNSAM - CONICET. Chascomús, 11-13 September. Urrea, C. and S. Singh. (1991). Variation for leaflet shape in wild and cultivated landraces of common bean. Ann. Rep. Bean Improv. Coop. 34:13. Hickey, L. J. (1974). Clasificación de la arquitectura de las hojas de dicotiledóneas. Boletín de la Sociedad Argentina de Botánica. Vol. XVI (1-2): pp. 1-27.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
81
A phenological model for the soybean A. Confalone1, Y. Villacampa2, J. A. Reyes2, F. García-Alonso2 & F. Verdú2 1
Cátedra de Agrometeorología, Facultad de Agronomía de Azul-UNCPBA, Buenos Aires, Argentina 2 Departamento de Matemática Aplicada, Universidad de Alicante, Alicante, Spain
Abstract Predicting the time of soybean flowering is a critical step for crop management practices and for the development of crop models. The main objective of this study was to quantify the effect of the photoperiod and of temperature on the duration of the different phenological periods (flowering, first pod and physiological maturity), and to evaluate the response of a simple linear model for predicting phenological periods in Azul, centre of Buenos Aires, Argentina. It also used the methodology defined in the work of Summerfield et al. (Measurement and prediction of flowering in soybeans in fluctuating field environments. In: World Soybean Research Conference 4, 1989, Buenos Aires. Argentina Soybeans Association, 1989. pp. 82-87) which generates families of mathematical models with non-linear parameters and includes the study of linear models to obtain other models. Finally the sensitivity of the models to the variations produced by the experimental data was studied by applying the methodology used in Summerfield et al., Verdu and Villacampa (A computer program for a Monte Carlo analysis of sensitivity in equations of environmental modelling obtained from experimental data. Advances in Engineering Software. Vol. 33, Nº 6. pp.351-359, 2002) and Verdu and Villacampa (A Computational algorithm for the multiple generation of nonlineal mathematical models and stability study. Advances in Engineering Software. In Press). This allowed the model to be selected according to the criteria. Keywords: soybean, photoperiod, temperature, development, modelling, stability.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070091
82 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Temperature and photoperiod produce qualitative changes throughout the soybean cultivation cycle and are therefore important for its development (Hadley et al., [8]; Summerfield et al., [17]; Grimm et al., [7]). Several studies have characterised the sowing-flowering phenological subperiod of soybean cultivation with regard to its sensitivity to temperature and photoperiod (Major et al., [12]; Jones and Laing, [10]; Hodges and French, [9]; Wilkerson et al., [22]; Rodrigues et al., [14]). Sensitivity to the photoperiod varies according to the genotype. The degree of response to the photoperiodic stimulation is the main determining factor of the area of adaptation of different crops. With sensitive soybean crops, the response to the photoperiod is quantitative and not absolute, meaning that flowering will occur anyway. However, the time required will depend on the length of the day, with the induction being faster with short days than with long days. In this way, floral induction provokes the transformation of the vegetative meristems (differentiation of stalks and leaves) into reproductive (flower primordia), determining the final size of the plants (number of nodes) and thus their potential yield. Late-maturing crops are generally more sensitive to the photoperiod than early crops (Lawn and Byth, [11]; Major et al., [12]). Garner and Allard [6] concluded that in environments with a constant photoperiod, temperature has a significant influence on determining the time of flowering. There is an inverse relationship between the average temperature of a site and the number of days needed to reach the flowering stage (Pascale, [13]). The effect of the photoperiod and temperature on the flowering period of soybean has been studied using a quantitative relationship between these variables. Major et al. [12] used a multiplicative model of temperature and photoperiod to describe the time of flowering of soybean. Sinclair et al. [15] used linear and logistic models based on temperature and photoperiod to predict the date of flowering of soybean crops. Predicting the date when the phenological events of soybean occur is important for crop management and for use in growth and production models (Wang et al. [21]). Knowledge of the dates of the occurrence of phenological events allows us to manage the crop better. We also avoid the periods of stress that characterise certain environments where soybean is cultivated and we can identify the relationship with the production of dry material and grain. Use of the concept of development rate (inverse to duration) developed by Wit et al. [23] was a major advance in the prediction of the phenological behaviour of soybean crops. Hadley et al. [8] used this concept to define the development rate as the inverse of the time between sowing and flowering (1/f). In this way, if a crop has a long period between sowing and flowering (f: days), it will have a low development rate (1/f: days-1). We can then analyse the length of the period by means of the 1/f as a linear additive function of the average temperature (T) and photoperiod (F) for the period in question, using the equation:
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1 f
= a ′ + b′T + c ′F ,
83 (1)
where 1/f is the development rate, the values of T and F represent the average temperature and photoperiod between sowing and flowering, and a ′ , b′ , c′ are empirical coefficients; b′ and c′ are estimators of the sensitivity to temperature and photoperiod respectively. With genotypes that are not sensitive to the photoperiod or below a threshold photoperiod, equation 1 only includes the first two terms. This simple approach has been successfully used with soybean development prediction models for a wide range of genotypes and environments (Summerfield et al., [17]). This article aims to quantify the effect of photoperiod and temperature on the duration of the flowering period, as well as in other phenological sub-periods of the crop. To this end, families of models will be identified that allow us to predict the different phenological periods of soybean crops in Azul, in the centre of the province of Buenos Aires, Argentina.
2
Materials and methods
An experiment was conducted from 1997 to 2002 on a Typic Argiudol in the experimental farm of the Facultad de Agronomía - UNCPBA, located in Azul, Buenos Aires, Argentina (36º45’S; 59º50´W; 132m elevation). Two indeterminate cultivars (Asgrow 4656 and Don Mario 4800 RR) were sown to achieve a final density of 30 plants/m2. The temperature and photoperiod data were obtained from the Centro Regional de Agrometeorología (Regional Agrometeorology Centre) FAAUNCPBA (CRAGM-Boletines 1997-2003). The treatments used in this work were with irrigation (soil kept at approximately field capacity) and without limitations of nutrients. The water applied daily to supplement rainfall was distributed by a drip system and was calculated using the methodology recommended by the FAO (Allen et al., [1]). The field capacity value was determined using the Cassel and Nielsen method (Cassel and Nielsen, [2]). Weekly soil water content measurements were made with gravimetric samples (Gardner, [5]). Monitoring of the temporal evolution of the phenology of the different bean crop sowing dates had to be carried out visually, three times a week, using the development stages key proposed by Fehr et al. [4]. Every two days, visual observations were carried out to check the foliar expansion of four marked plants. This was carried out for each plot and for each sowing date. A leaf was regarded as expanded when its base was flat, losing the characteristic rolled appearance of the young leaf. The plants in each plot were regarded as having reached a certain stage or phase of development when 50% of the plants showed the morphological characteristics described in the key.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
84 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI In order to create the models, the following phenological phases equivalent to the key proposed by Fehr et al. [4] after sowing were analysed: •
Flowering (F): 50% of the plants with one flower open on any node on the main stalk (R1; Fehr et al., [4]). Start of pods (1V): 50% of the plants with 0.5 cm pods on any node on the main stalk (R3; Fehr et al., [4]). Physiological maturity (MF): 50% of the plants with mature pods (R7; Fehr et al., [4]).
• •
3
Models
In order to obtain the models defined on the basis of the experimental data, the methodologies defined by Spss. [16] and Verdu and Villacampa [19] were used. The former was used to seek linear models and the latter to obtain families of non-linear models in the parameters, also being able to obtain the linear models defined on the basis of Spss. [16]. The phenological stages defined by sowing-flowering, flowering-first pod and first pod-maturity were defined. For each of these stages, models were generated to study the days passed since sowing, f. Models were determined to show us their variation on the basis of the sum of the thermal time or “degree days” and the photoperiod. 3.1 Models for the Asgrow 4656 cultivar Mathematical models were developed for this cultivar that quantify the days since sowing. Of the family of models obtained, the linear model could be used for all phenological stages. The sowing-flowering stage obtained the model: (2) f = 0.1026 * Suma Temp - 0.0726 * F + 1.7 , R2= 0.9 The flowering-first pod stage obtained the model: f = 0.105 * Suma Temp + 8.639 * F - 137.924 , R2= 0.9 (3) The first pod-maturity stage obtained the model: f = 0.044 * Suma Temp - 12.975 * F + 231.823 , R2=0.9 (4) 3.2 Models for the D. Mario cultivar Mathematical models were developed for this cultivar that quantify the days since sowing. Of the family of models obtained, the linear model could be used for all phenological stages. In the sowing-flowering stage: f = 0.079 * Suma Temp + 5.77 * F - 85.98 , R2=0.9 (5) f =
3
0.079 * Suma Temp − 1.637 + ( 0.931*F -12.675 ) , R2=0.9
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(6)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
In the flowering-first pod stage: f = 0.082 * Suma Tempe + 8.79 * F -134.6347 , R2=0.9 In the first pod-maturity stage: f = 0.00557 * Sum Temp - 9.9817 * F + 166.384 , R2=0.9
85 (7) (8)
3.3 Stability of the models The stability of the models was studied by applying the methodology developed in (Verdu and Villacampa, [18]; Villacampa et al. [20]). The linear models of the Asgrow 4656 cultivar were stable when carrying out perturbations of up to 20% in the three phenological stages. The stability of the models (Eq. 2), (Eq. 3) and (Eq. 4) can be seen in Fig1, Fig 2 and Fig 3, respectively:
Figure 1.
Figure 2.
Figure 3.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
86 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The x-axis represents the percentage of the perturbation carried out on the experimental data and the y-axis represents the variation of a model as a percentage. The stability of the D. Mario cultivar was also studied. In this case, the linear models (Eq. 7) and (Eq. 8) are stable. However, the linear model (Eq. 5) corresponding to the sowing-flowering stage was not stable and only tolerated perturbations of up to 1% of the experimental data. This led to the new stable model defined in (Eq. 6) being obtained. The stability of the models (Eq. 7) and (Eq. 8) can be seen in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 respectively. In Fig. 6 it can be seen that the linear model defined by (Eq. 5) is not stable. Fig. 7 shows the stability graph for the model defined in (Eq. 6).
Figure 4.
Figure 6.
Figure 5.
Figure 7.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
87
Conclusions
The models obtained show that the phenology of soybean is highly dependent on temperature and photoperiod. Each cultivar shows a different degree of sensitivity to each of the abovementioned factors, giving different models depending on the cultivar and the phenological stage in question. The linear models are seen to be stable except for the sowing-flowering phenological stage of the D. Mario cultivar. However, a stable non-linear model was obtained. The stability was analysed using perturbations of up to 20% carried out on the experimental data. The same methodology was used to generate models for the development rate 1/f as proposed by Hadley et al. In this case, the models were not stable, meaning that the models obtained for f were regarded as more appropriate. These models allow us to predict the phenology of soybean in the centre of the province of Buenos Aires.
Acknowledgement This work was supported in part by funds from AE/07/074 Generalitat Valenciana.
(YVE) from
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]
Allen, R. G., Pereira, L. S., Raes, Smith , D , M., Crop evapotranspiration. Guidelines for computing crop water requirements, FAO Irrigation and drainage paper nº 56. FAO, 1998. Cassel, D.K.; Nielsen, D.R. Field capacity and available water capacity, In, Klute, A. (ed). Methods of soil analysis, Madison, ASA-SSSA, Monograph nº9, pp. 25, 1986. Cragm - Boletín Agrometeorológico del Centro-Sur de la Provincia de Buenos Aires.,Facultad. Agron. Azul, Buenos Aires, 1997,1998, 2002 y 2003. Fehr, W. R., Calviness, C. E., Burmood, D. T.; Pennington, J. S., Stage of development description for soybean, Glycine max (L.) Merrill, Crop Science, Madison, v. 11, pp. 929-931, 1971. Gardner, W.H., Water content In, Klute, A. (ed.). Methods of soil analysis. ASA, CSSA, and SSSA, Madison, WI, pp. 493-594, 1986. Garner, W. W., Allard, H. A., Photoperiodic response of soybeans in relation to temperature and other environmental factors, Journal of Agricultural Research, Washington, v. 41, pp. 719-735, 1930. Grimm, S.S., Jones, J.W., Boote, K.J., Hesketh, J.D. Parameter estimation for predicting flowering date of soybean cultivars. Crop Science, v. 33, pp. 137-144, 1993. Hadley, P., Roberts, E. H., Summerfield, R. J.; Mincchin, F. R. Effects of temperature and photoperiod on flowering in soya bean [Glycine max (L.) WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
88 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[9] [10] [11]
[12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]
[18]
[19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
Merril]: a quantitative model. Annals of Botany, London, v.53, pp. 669681, 1984. Hodges, T., French, V., Soyphen: soybean growth stages modeled from temperature, daylength, and water availability, Agronomy Journal, Madison, v. 77, pp. 500-505, 1985. Jones, P. G., Laing, D. R., Simulation of the phenology of soybeans, Agricultural Systems, Oxford, v. 3, pp. 295-311, 1978. Lawn, R. J., Byth, D. E., Response of soya beans to planting date in South-Eastern Queensland. I. Influence of photoperiod and temperature on phasic development patterns. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, Collingwood, v. 24, pp. 67-80, 1973. Major, D. J., Johnson, D. R., Tanner, J. W., Anderson, I. C., Effects of daylength and temperature on soybean development, Crop Science, Madison, v. 15, pp. 174-179, 1975. Pascale, A. J. Tipos agroclimáticos para el cultivo de la soya en la Argentina, Revista de la Facultad de Agronomía e Veterinaria, Buenos Aires, v. 17, pp. 31-38, 1969. Rodrigues, O.; Didonet, A., Lhamby,J.; Bertagnolli, P.; Luz, J. Resposta quantitativa do florescimento da soja à temperatura e ao fotoperíodo. Pesquisa Agropecuaria Brasileira, v.36, pp. 431-437, 2001. Sinclair, T. R., Kitani, S., Hinson, K., Bruniard, J., Horie, T. Soybean flowering date: linear and logistic models based on temperature and photoperiod. Crop Science, Madison, v. 31, pp. 786-790, 1991. Spss. Inc. Software. (1999). Chicago. EE.UU. Summerfield, R.J., Roberts, E. H., Lawn, R.J. Measurement and prediction of flowering in soybeans in fluctuating field environments. In: World Soybean Research Conference 4, 1989, Buenos Aires. Argentina Soybeans Association, 1989. pp. 82-87. Verdu, F & Villacampa, Y. A computer program for a Monte Carlo analysis of sensitivity in equations of environmental modelling obtained from experimental data. Advances in Engineering Software. Vol. 33, Nº 6. pp.351-359, 2002. Verdu, F & Villacampa, Y. A Computational algorithm for the multiple generation of nonlineal mathematical models and stability study. Advances in Engineering Software. In Press. Villacampa, Y; Verdu, F, Pérez, A. A Stability theory for model systems. Kybernetes. Vol.36, Nº.5-10.pp. 1-23, 2007. Wang, Z.; Reddy, R. V.; Quebedaux, B. Growth and photosynthetic responses of soybean to short-term cold temperature. Environmental and Experimental Botany, W. Conshohocken, v. 37, pp. 13-24, 1997. Wilkerson, G. G.; Jones, J. W.; Boote, K. J.; Buol, G. S. Photoperiodically sensitive interval in time to flower of soybean. Crop Science, Madison, v. 29, pp. 721-726, 1989. Wit, C. T.; Brouwer, R.; Vries, F. W. T. P. The simulation of photosynthetic systems. In: SETLIK, I. (Ed.). Prediction and measurement of photosynthetic productivity. Wageningen: PUDOC, 1970. pp. 47-70. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 4 Environmental risk
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
91
Modelling arsenic transport in a river basin: a case study in Finland Ä. Bilaletdin1, H. Kaipainen1, T. Ruskeeniemi2 & A. Parviainen3 1
Pirkanmaa Regional Environment Centre, Finland Geological Survey of Finland 3 Helsinki University of Technology, Finland 2
Abstract Arsenic undergoes a number of changes in response to environmental conditions such as pH, redox potential and other soluble compounds and solid phases present in the system. As exact transfer modelling requires huge amounts of data, a relatively simple calculation method is needed for large sites. A model has to contain enough essential processes, state variables etc. but it should not require too much data, and the running of the model should not be too laborious. This is especially important for modelling tools designed to assist authorities in their tentative environmental reviews. The aim of this study is to develop a statistical arsenic transport model for surface waters using monitored data and to take into account the discharge of small rivers and the sub-catchments, calculated using a runoff model. Dilution, sedimentation and chemical processes are presumable processes regarding arsenic transport. The general form of the model is an advection-dispersion model and the first order kinetics. The advection-dispersion model, separately for particle bounded arsenic and soluble arsenic, has been used to simulate the total arsenic concentration. The driving process for particle bounded arsenic is sedimentation and the driving state variable for soluble arsenic is pH. The main conclusion of this study is that by using a quite simple mass balance model it was possible to simulate arsenic transport in surface waters for risk assessment purposes. Keywords: arsenic, transport model, RAMAS, surface water, advectiondispersion.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070101
92 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
RAMAS is a three-year project (2004 - 2007) funded by the participating organizations and the LIFE Environment programme of the European Union. The acronym RAMAS arises from the project title "Risk Assessment and risk Management procedure for ArSenic in the Tampere region". The project is targeting the Province of Pirkanmaa which comprises 28 municipalities, and has 469 000 inhabitants within its area. All over the world, numerous active or abandoned mine sites and ore processing plants bear potential to contaminate their surrounding soils and waters with metals and other compounds. One of the most harmful and rather common elements is arsenic. Because arsenic in ground water and surface water poses a risk to ecosystem and human health, more detailed information is needed on the factors that govern arsenic fate and transport in the environment. Arsenic undergoes a number of changes in response to environmental conditions such as pH, and redox potential and other soluble compounds and solid phases present in the system. These factors are important as they determine the fate and biological availability of the arsenic in mine tailings, effluent discharge and affected sediments. Several transport models have been proposed for the geochemical cycling of arsenic. Exact modelling requires huge amounts of data and detailed understanding of the whole system. Since this is rarely the case, relatively simple, but sufficiently sensitive calculation method is needed for large sites. A model has to contain the most essential processes, state variables etc. but it should not require too much input data and the running of the model should not be too laborious. The objective of the work presented in this paper is to develop such a transport model. All over the world a lot of different methods to purify drinking water from arsenic have been studied, as well as, technologies removing arsenic from contaminated soils and waters (e.g. Garelick et al. [1] and Thirunavukkarasu et al. [2]). These studies provide useful information on the behaviour of arsenic in process level. Much less studies have been carried out on arsenic transport in large river basins, even though this is a severe problem in many natural and anthropogenic areas (e.g. Bright et al. [3], Hancock et al. [4], Pettine et al. [5]).
2
Study area
The study area in the Vahantajoki river basin comprises an approximately seven kilometres long watercourse, here referred to as the transport route of arsenic, originating from the Ylöjärvi mining area and ending in the Lake Näsijärvi. The transport route begins from the Lake Parosjärvi, which is located in the immediate vicinity of the former mine and the tailings area. The lake is connected to the Stream Parosjärven oja, which flows into the Lake VähäVahantajärvi and into the Stream Vähä-Vahantajärven oja and, finally, into the Lake Näsijärvi, which is the major lake basin in the region. The sub-catchments of the Vahantajoki river basin are specified using a Digital Elevation Map.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
93
The principal origin of the arsenic contamination in the surface waters of the study area is the copper-tungsten-arsenic (Cu-W-As) mine of Ylöjärvi, which was active during 1943-1966.The mining activities left behind two tailings areas of 4 ha and 17 ha, two open pits and underground galleries. It is estimated that about 4 Mt of tailings and waste rock is stored in the area. After closing the mine, the lake filled up again with water, and as a consequence part of the smaller tailings area, the open pits and the underground galleries filled with tailings were flooded, leaving a lot of arsenic, heavy metals and sulphides containing material subject to leaching of surface and groundwater. Reductive conditions are prevailing at the bottom of the lake, but two times a year seasonal temperature changes of the water mix the oxidative surface water with the deeper one, causing degradation and dissolution of the material. However, the main arsenic sources into the surface waters are the arsenic bearing sulphide minerals in the tailings areas. These minerals tend to weather and dissolve in contact with air and oxidizing rain water releasing arsenic and heavy metals into the environment.
3
Arsenic in the surface waters
The Ylöjärvi mine area provides a good reference area for developing a transport model of arsenic. The source term (the tailings area) is relatively well defined, there is long-term data on arsenic and heavy metal concentrations along the whole length of the transport route, as well as, studied information about the environmental impacts, which give some support for process level assumptions. To investigate the short-term dynamic changes in the arsenic transport a monthly monitoring of the surface waters and sediments of streams and lakes were implemented during the RAMAS Project in 2005. The conducted studies depict the gravity of the environmental impacts of the Ylöjärvi mine giving credible background information for further research and transport modelling of arsenic. Table 1 gives the arsenic concentrations in surface waters along the transport route. Table 1:
1 2 3 4 5 6
Arsenic (µg/l) at the various monitoring points of the Vahantajoki river basin. Data from the obligatory sampling under the supervision of the Pirkanmaa Regional Environment Centre reported by Carlson et al. [6] and Parviainen et al. [7].
Water sampling point Ditch from tailings to the Lake Parosjärvi Lake Parosjärvi surface Lake Parosjärvi bottom Stream Parosjärven oja 1 Stream Parosjärven oja 2 Stream Vähä-Vahantajärven oja Stream Vahantajoki alav mts Lake Näsijärvi surface Lake Näsijärvi bottom
Year 1982-1999 1975-2005 1975-2005 1975-2005 1975-2005 1975-2005 2005 2005 2005
Mean 258.8 66.6 155.3 60.2 57.9 16 7.1 2.9 23.4
Min 43 0.5 1.2 1 0.5 0.8 4 1.5 6
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Max 580 160 910 380 850 65 14 6 66
Med 250 68 130 60 31 14 6.3 3 14
N 25 58 56 68 73 73 9 8 8
94 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
RAMAS project surface water monitoring sites March – December 2005.
Monthly water samples collected by RAMAS imported new information about the dynamic changes in the arsenic transport complementing the annual, long-term monitoring data. In addition to arsenic, many other elements were analyzed from these water samples. These water samples used for the actual transport modelling of arsenic were collected from March to December in 2005 from the Lake Parosjärvi (sampling point 1), the Stream Parosjärven oja (sampling points 2 and 3), Stream Vähä-Vahantajärven oja (4), Stream Vahantajoki (sampling point 5) and Lake Näsijärvi (6) (fig. 1). Two sets of water samples were collected from each sampling point, filtered (0.45 µm) and nonfiltered. The filtered 60 ml samples were acidified with 0.3 ml of suprapure nitric acid. The non-filtered samples were used to assess the role of suspended material in the transport. The laboratory analyses were performed with graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry (AAG). The total arsenic values in this data progressively decreased from the Lake Parosjärvi towards the Lake Näsijärvi. The average concentrations of total arsenic in the sampling points were 109 µg/l in the sampling point 1 (surface), 118 µg/l in the sampling point 2, 60 µg/l in the sampling point 3, 19 µg/l in the sampling point 4, 7.2 µg/l in the sampling point 5 and 2,9 µg/l in the sampling point 6 (surface).
4
Model development
The aim of the arsenic transport model was to develop an empirical model using monitored data and to take into account the discharge of small rivers and the subWIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
95
catchments of the Vahantajoki river basin. The results of the sampling performed in 2005 were used in the study due to the limitations in the old data, which provided the total arsenic concentrations instead of the separation of dissolved and particulate-bounded fractions. The dynamical discharge values of small rivers in the study area can be calculated using the runoff model, VESISTÖMALLI, developed at the Finnish Environment Institute by Vehviläinen [8]. This model takes into account the meteorological and hydrological variables in the area. The model is based on a conceptual distributed runoff model, which is a Finnish version of the original HBV runoff model by Bergström [9], and water balance model for lake, river routing model and flood area models. Although quite rarely applied to metals, the mass-balance approach offers a useful technique for quantifying the transport of trace elements such as arsenic in surface water. In mass-balance considerations data on both hydrological conditions and chemical quality of water are taken into account simultaneously. Dilution, sedimentation and chemical processes are presumable processes controlling arsenic transport. The general form of the model is an advectiondispersion model and first order kinetics using eqn (1). The traditional advectiondispersion equation is a standard model for contaminant transport presented e.g. Kinnunen et al. [10]. In the model the river basin is divided into hydraulic elements parallel to the surface of the river basin. Hydraulic elements are considered to be homogenous and therefore differences in water quality are observed along the vertical axis of the river basin. The two basic principles of the model are the conservation of mass and the kinetic principle. The first principle implies conservation of mass even though material is changed in chemical and biological reactions from one form to another, while the kinetic principle states that the rate of change of a concentration is equal to the product of a coefficient and the concentrations of one or more variables that interact to cause the change. Estimation of parameters can be accomplished on the basis of experiments carried out in the field or in the laboratory, or parameters may be taken from the literature or estimated by calibration. c - ∂ A x ∂c = ∂ Ax D L ∂ ∂t ∂x ∂x ∂x
( Ax u c )+ S ( c,Fe,pH... ) Ax
(1)
c = concentration of arsenic t = time x = distance = area of the element Ax = dispersion coefficient DL u = advective velocity S = transformation processes The first term on the right-hand side describes diffusion and the second one vertical advection. The third term describes transformation processes, e.g. chemical transformation and settling phenomena. In this application diffusion is a minor factor. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
96 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The starting point in developing the arsenic loss model was to assume that the transformation process obeys first order kinetics with a constant reaction rate coefficient. It means that all transformation processes can be defined by one constant reaction rate coefficient (eqn 2), since almost all transformation processes in the nature can be simplified. S = − ρc
(2)
ρ = reaction rate coefficient of transformation processes In fig. 2, the advection-dispersion model (eqn 1 and eqn 2) has been used to simulate the total arsenic concentration in different sampling points in 2005. 200 175
Stream Parosjärven oja 1 Stream Parosjärven oja 2 Stream Vähä-Vahantajärven oja Stream Vahantajoki alav mts
150
-1
As [µg l ]
125 100 75 50 25 0 01/05
Figure 2:
03/05
05/05
07/05
09/05
11/05
The simulation results of total arsenic concentration in different surface water sampling points from 2005 in the Ylöjärvi mine area using an advection-dispersion model and first order kinetics.
We can see that the results of the simulation are generally moderate in different sampling points but particularly in the beginning of the transport route (sampling point 2, Stream Parosjärven oja 1) a difference between the observations and the simulated results is quite significant. Therefore a more sophisticated description of transformation processes was tested. It seemed reasonable to divide total arsenic to particle-bounded and dissolved arsenic and to consider the different processes affecting the transport of arsenic, eqn 3.
c = c p + cs WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(3)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
97
cp = concentration of particle bounded arsenic cs = concentration of soluble bounded arsenic Particle bounded and soluble arsenic are behaving independently and these fractions have their own characteristic reaction processes. Generally we can write the following eqns (4–6): S = S p + Ss
(4)
S p =− ρ p cp
(5)
S s = − ρ s cs
(6)
ρ p = particle bounded arsenic process coefficient ρ s = soluble arsenic process coefficient There was no universal equation available and, therefore, for particle bounded arsenic sedimentation process was chosen as a principle factor controlling the arsenic transport in solid phase (eqn (5)). It is known that soluble arsenic reacts chemically in many ways. Complex ions of arsenic interact with secondary iron oxides and hydroxides, and in varying degrees with many manganese and aluminium precipitates. Clay and humus are also known to be good absorbents of arsenic. In this study the different correlations between soluble arsenic and other state variables were checked, but only the correlation of pH turned out to be significant (figs. 3 and 4). Therefore the equations (7) and (8) are the following:
ρ s = f ( pH ) ρ ' s
(7)
f ( pH ) = − 1.5 pH + 12
(8)
In fig. 5 the advection-dispersion model has been exploited separately for particle-bounded arsenic and soluble arsenic to simulate the total arsenic concentration in different sampling points. The driving process for particlebounded arsenic is sedimentation and the driving state variable for soluble arsenic is pH. When comparing figs. 2 and 5 it is evident the simulation result did not get essentially better, which suggests that the system is more complex and probably several factors not considered in this exercise are affecting the behaviour of arsenic. However, the model is capable to produce a fairly good estimate of the fate of arsenic in the transport route and the present version provides a sound basis for further developing work. The final simulation equations in this study were eqns (9) and (10) for particle bounded and soluble arsenic, respectively.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
98 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 180 160
Soluble As µg l
-1
140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
pH
Figure 3:
A correlation between pH and soluble arsenic in the Vahantajoki river basin in 2005.
7.5
7.0
pH
6.5
6.0
Stream Parosjärven oja 1 Stream Parosjärven oja 2 Stream Vähä-Vahantajärven oja Stream Vahantajoki alav mts
5.5
5.0 01/05
Figure 4:
03/05
07/05
09/05
11/05
The pH values in different surface water sampling points in the Vahantajoki river basin in 2005. The pH increases down stream and the variations become less drastic and abrupt. Ax
Ax
05/05
∂c p ∂t
=
∂c p ∂ A D x L ∂x ∂x
∂ − ∂x Ax u c p − ρ p c p
(
)
∂c s ∂ ∂c ∂ = Ax D L s − ( Ax u c s ) − ( 1.5 pH + 12 ) ρ ' s c s ∂t ∂x ∂x ∂x
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(9)
(10)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
99
175 Stream Parosjärven oja 1 Stream Parosjärven oja 2
150
Stream Vähä-Vahantajärven oja
-1
As [µg l ]
125
Stream Vahantajoki alav mts
100
75
50
25
0 0
Figure 5:
5
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
The advection-dispersion model, separately for particle bounded arsenic and soluble arsenic, has been used to simulate the total arsenic concentration in different sampling points in 2005.
Summary
The main result of this model development is that by using a quite simple mass balance model it was possible to simulate arsenic transport in different circumstances. Dilution, sedimentation and chemical processes are presumable processes regarding arsenic transport. One main goal of this approach was that on a catchment scale a relevant data survey should not be too laborious and expensive. The general form of the model is an advection-dispersion model and the first order kinetics. In order to improve the model and to understand the processes of a transport phenomenon, the particle bounded and dissolved fractions were treated separately. A fit of the simulation was better than using only total arsenic. The applied driving process for particle-bounded arsenic is sedimentation and the driving state variable for soluble arsenic is pH. Using this kind of approach the basic features of arsenic transportation can be studied and relevant data for risk assessment purposes can be produced. An advantage of this model is that it does not need very sophisticated data to achieve estimates of arsenic transport for surface waters in large catchments. The present model version provides a good starting point for future development.
References [1]
Garelick, H., Dybowska, A., Valsami-Jones, E. & Priest, N., Remediation Technologies for Arsenic Contaminated Drinking Waters. Journal of Soils and Sediment, 5(3), pp. 182-190, 2005. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
100 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [2] [3] [4]
[5] [6] [7]
[8]
[9] [10]
Thirunavukkarasu, O.S., Viraraghavan, T. & Subramanian, K.S., Arsenic removal from drinking water using granular ferric hydroxide. Water SA, 29, pp. 161-170, 2003. Bright, D.A., Coedy, B., Dushenko, W.T. & Reimer, K.J., Arsenic transport in a watershed receiving gold mine effluent near Yellowknife, Canada. Total. Environ., 155, pp. 237-252, 1994. Hancock, T.C., Denver, J.M., Riedel, G.F. & Miller, C.V., Source, transport, and fate of arsenic in the Pocomoke River basin, a poultry dominated Chesapeake Bay watershed. U.S. Geol. Survey Workshop – Arsenic in the environment, Denver, CO, 2001 Pettine, M., Camusso, M. & Martinotti, W., Dissolved and particulate transport of arsenic and chromium in the Po River, Italy. Sci. Tot. Environm., 119, pp. 253-280, 1992. Carlson, L., Hänninen, P. & Vanhala, H., Ylöjärven Paroistenjärven kaivosalueen nykytilan selvitys. Geological Survey of Finland, Report S/41/0000/3/2002, 2002. Parviainen, A., Vaajasaari, K., Loukola-Ruskeeniemi, K., Kauppila, T., Bilaletdin, Ä., Kaipainen, H., Tammenmaa, J. & Hokkanen, T., Anthropogenic Arsenic Sources in the Tampere Region in Finland. Miscellaneous Publications of Geological Survey of Finland, Espoo, 2006 Vehviläinen, B., The watershed simulation and forecasting system in the National Board of Waters and Environment. Publications of the Water and Environment Research Institute. Helsinki, National Board of Waters and Environment, 17, 1994. Bergström, S., Development and application of a conceptual runoff model for Scandinavian catchments. SMHI reporter, RHO 7, Norrköping, 1976. Kinnunen, K., Nyholm, B., Niemi, J., Frisk, T., Kyläharakka, T. & Kauranne, T., Water quality modelling of Finnish water bodies. Publications of the Water Research Institute, 46, Helsinki, National Board of Waters and Environment, 1982.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
101
Pollen contamination in Acacia saligna: assessing the risks for sustainable agroforestry M. A. Millar1, 2, 3 & M. Byrne2, 3 1
The University of Adelaide, Australia CRC for Plant Based Management of Dryland Salinity, Australia 3 Department of Environment and Conservation, Australia 2
Abstract Species developed for sustainable agroforestry may pose risks to remnant populations of closely related species via genetic contamination. Genetic contamination and the production of hybrid progeny may threaten the health and long-term viability of remnant populations. Acacia saligna is a native Western Australian species complex selected for further development for agroforestry in the agricultural areas of southern Australia. A. saligna shows great morphological, ecological, biological and genetic variation, and will be reclassified into a number of subspecies. This research aimed to develop genetic markers and use them to assess the levels and distances of gene flow via pollen dispersal between two of the proposed subspecies of Acacia saligna. Pollen dispersal from the abundantly flowering subsp. saligna into the poorer flowering subsp. lindleyi was high (32%). At the same site, pollen dispersal from subsp. lindleyi into subsp. saligna was much lower (14%). Most genetic contamination from subsp. saligna into subsp. lindleyi occurred at short distances (<300 m) although inter-subspecific pollen dispersal was detected over large distances of around 1600 m. The comparative levels of inter-subspecific pollen dispersal are influenced by the relative floral fecundity of the different variants. The results indicate that small remnant populations of subsp. lindleyi will be exposed to high levels of hybridisation when subsp. saligna is planted nearby for agroforestry. The effects of inter-subspecific hybridisation in A. saligna are unknown and until further investigated it is recommended as a management guideline that isolation distances of 1600 m or more be imposed between agroforestry plantings and native populations. Keywords: agroforestry, pollen dispersal, species complex, inter-subspecific hybridisation, genetic contamination, microsatellites, paternity analysis, Acacia saligna, risk assessment, isolation distances. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070111
102 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Species developed for sustainable agroforestry may pose risks to remnant populations of closely related species when introduced nearby. These risks include direct invasiveness into natural ecosystems, supporting increased incidences of pests, disease and feral animals, and the possibility of genetic contamination in remnant natural populations [1]. Genetic contamination, or the movement of foreign genes from non-local populations into native populations, may occur in tree species via pollen dispersal [2] and may arise in natural populations when populations of a similar species or genetically divergent populations of the same species are planted nearby. If the floral phenologies of divergent populations overlap and sufficient interfertility exist between them, gene flow via pollen transfer between the populations results in intra specific, inter-subspecific or interprovenance hybridisation and the production of hybrid progeny. The likelihood and possible impact of this scenario is receiving increasing attention, due to the threat of gene flow and hybridisation between natural populations and introduced transgenic crops [3-7]. Divergent populations may be intentionally introduced throughout the range of natural populations for agriculture or agroforestry, or through revegetation programs, and unintentionally through the spread of invasive species. In the case of agroforestry, genetic divergence between natural and introduced populations may arise through the use of non-local subspecies or non-local provenance germplasm, or selection pressure applied in breeding and domestication programs [1]. If agroforestry populations (pollen source) are large in comparison to natural remnant populations (pollen sink), levels of genetic contamination and the production of hybrid progeny may be significant. Genetic contamination in natural populations results in one of two outcomes for hybrid progeny: heterosis or outbreeding depression, and the impacts of either may threaten the health and long-term viability of natural populations [2, 8]. Heterosis, or hybrid vigour, occurs when hybrid fitness is enhanced relative to the parental populations, and may result in the establishment of large hybrid populations between agroforestry and remnant populations. If hybrid fitness is maintained over the generations, the natural population may be at risk from direct competition, hybrid swamping and the impacts of small population processes such as a loss of genetic diversity. Continued hybridisation may eventually result in total genetic assimilation of the typically smaller, native population via introgression. This occurs with the repeated backcrossing of hybrids to one or both of the parental populations. The other possible outcome for hybrid progeny is outbreeding depression. This occurs when hybrid fitness is reduced relative to the parental population. In this case, the reproductive output of a native population may again be lowered to levels that threaten the population viability [9]. Pollen swamping may also be detrimental to the viability of natural populations regardless of whether hybrid progeny are produced. Seed production and recruitment within the natural population may be significantly reduced, especially in small populations [10, 11]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
103
In Australia, the majority of the once extensive woody vegetation has been cleared for agricultural production and there is an urgent need to revegetate with native perennials. Revegetation is required in order to halt the degradation of biological integrity, restore the hydrological balance and mitigate increasing levels of salinisation in the land and waterways. A number of native Australian species are being developed for use in revegetating the agricultural areas of southern Australia via agroforestry; however, there is some risk to remnant populations via genetic contamination with large-scale agroforestry. The potential for genetic contamination and hybridisation between non-local populations of native species needs to be considered to ensure that revegetation systems are environmentally sustainable and pose no further risks to biodiversity. The potential for genetic contamination from large-scale agroforestry crops must be evaluated within a risk management framework that requires comprehensive risk assessment [8, 12]. Acacia saligna is a native Western Australian species complex selected for further development for agroforestry, as a short rotation phase or coppice crop, in the low rainfall areas of southern Australia [13, 14]. A. saligna has been recognised as a species complex that shows great morphological, ecological, biological and genetic variation. The species complex has been partitioned into a number of subspecies to be formally taxonomically described. Little is known about the mating system, patterns of gene flow via pollen dispersal, and levels of genetic contamination that can be expected within and between populations of the different subspecies of A. saligna. These parameters can be estimated through paternity analysis using genetic markers such as microsatellites. Microsatellite markers are suitable for paternity analysis studies as they are highly polymorphic, codominant, considered selectively neutral, and can be amplified from small amounts of genomic DNA. As part of a larger process of assessing the risk posed by large-scale utilisation of A. saligna as an agroforestry crop to natural remnant populations of A. saligna, we developed and screened microsatellite markers for use in A. saligna [15]. The markers were then used for paternity analysis to investigate pollen dispersal patterns and levels of genetic contamination, via inter-subspecific hybridisation, for two of the proposed subspecies of A. saligna. The results of this work will be used in developing risk management protocols that ensure the environmentally sustainable use of A. saligna for agroforestry throughout southern Australia.
2
Materials and methods
2.1 Study species Acacia saligna is a leguminous bushy shrub or tree, naturally distributed over southwestern Australia where it experiences a Mediterranean climate. Trees grow to 2-10 m at maturity and live for up to twenty years under favourable conditions [16]. Trees bear hermaphroditic, many flowered, globular WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
104 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI inflorescences and produce flat pods containing small, hard, black seeds [17]. The species complex consists of four main variants to be formally described as subspecies (McDonald MW and Maslin BR ms): illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1:
Morphological variants of Acacia saligna showing mature specimens of subspecies (A) lindleyi (B) saligna (C) stolonifera and (D) pruinescens.
Acacia saligna subsp. saligna is native to the coastal areas around Perth and on the south coast; it shows the greatest biomass and floral fecundity of the four subspecies. This subspecies has been commonly used as an ornamental and in revegetation programs, and is likely to be the variant most commonly utilised for agroforestry. Acacia saligna subsp. lindleyi is the most widespread of the subspecies and occurs across the inland “wheat and sheep belt” area of Western Australia, which is the target area for revegetation. It has a spindly form with little biomass and limited terminal flowering. Acacia saligna subsp. stolonifera has a natural distribution in the forest areas to the south-west of the range of subsp. lindleyi. Subsp. pruinescens occurs over a restricted area and shows some genetic affinity with subsp. saligna. 2.2 Study site and sample collection The study site consists of a planted stand of 107 trees of A. saligna subsp. saligna within the natural distribution of subsp. lindleyi, trees of which occur as roadside remnants at varying distances from the planted stand (Figure 2). The planted A. saligna stand occupies an area of approximately 0.55 hectares at the intersection of two roads. The closest subsp. lindleyi trees are approximately 25 m from the edge of the planted stand. This remnant consists of several hundred WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
105
individuals, although the majority of these were not reproductively mature at the time of sampling. Trees extend away from the planted stand, along a road verge, in a westerly direction, where they become less abundant, eventually occurring as individuals at a maximum distance of 300 m from the stand. Further remnant subsp. lindleyi trees are present along the roadside in a south-easterly direction, where they occur sporadically in two main patches approximately 900 and 1500 m from the stand. Many of the trees in the remnant patches were juvenile and fecundity of the adult trees was highly variable.
Figure 2:
Map of the study site showing locations of sampled trees of Acacia saligna. Larger grey circles represent sampled trees of subsp. lindleyi; smaller white circles represent sampled trees of subsp. saligna in the planted stand; dark lines represent the Avon River; light grey broken lines represent roadways.
Mature phyllode material was collected from all trees of subsp. saligna within the planted stand and from 29 trees of subsp. lindleyi. Open pollinated seed was sampled from 10 maternal trees of A. saligna subsp. saligna chosen at random from within the stand and from each of the selected 29 trees of subsp. lindleyi. As seed set was poor in subsp. lindleyi, trees with the largest seed crops were chosen for sampling. All trees of subsp. saligna and the 29 maternal trees of subsp. lindleyi were mapped using a differential global positioning satellite system. Seed from each tree was extracted from dry pods and bulked, sterilised, left to imbibe overnight and planted. No seed germinated for one of the maternal trees of subsp. saligna and for two of the trees of subsp. lindleyi, so seed crops were analysed for nine and 27 maternal trees respectively. Genomic DNA was extracted from phyllodes of the adult trees using a modified cetyltrimethyl WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
106 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI ammonium bromide (CTAB) extraction method [18], with the addition of 0.1 M sodium sulphite to the extraction and wash buffers [19], and from germinated seedlings using a modified Doyle and Doyle method [20]. Two microsatellite markers developed for A. saligna and three microsatellite markers developed for A. mangium [21] produced suitable cross amplification in A. saligna. Genotypes of all A. saligna subsp. saligna trees in the planted stand and progeny arrays for nine families consisting of 11-22 seedlings (186 in total), and of 29 A. saligna subsp. lindleyi trees and progeny arrays for 27 families consisting of 1 –25 seedlings (396 in total), were determined for the five microsatellite loci. The size of PCR products was determined by automated fluorescent scanning detection using an Applied Biosystems 3730 DNA Analyser (Applied Biosystems, Foster City CA, USA). 2.3 Data analysis Paternity assignment was conducted using maximum likelihood methods implemented in CERVUS 2.0 [22]. A 95% criterion was used for assignment, with mismatch at one locus allowed. Since geitonogamous pollination is possible, assignment of paternity to the mother plant was assumed to be due to selfing. The patterns of pollen dispersal within and between trees of subsp. saligna and trees of subsp. lindleyi were evaluated by determining the distance between mother and pollen source for each of the progeny.
3
Results
Using the five loci, the majority (93.5%) of subsp. saligna progeny were assigned a most likely father from either trees of subsp. saligna or the sampled subsp. lindleyi trees. The majority of subsp. saligna progeny (86%) were sired by pollen from within the stand of subsp. saligna. Fourteen subsp. saligna progeny (7.5%) were assigned a most likely father from the sampled subsp. lindleyi trees. Most likely fathers were undefined for twelve subsp. saligna progeny (6.5%) and these were assumed sired by unsampled trees of the background population of subsp. lindleyi. The rate of pollen contamination into the subsp. saligna stand is the percentage of progeny whose paternity was not assigned to subsp. saligna trees. This inter-subspecific gene flow totalled 14% [15]. Genetic contamination rates varied among maternal trees of subsp. saligna within the stand (0 to 32%). Of the 29 genotyped trees of A. saligna subsp. lindleyi, 10 (34.5%) were assigned as fathers of one or more progeny of maternal trees in the planted stand of subsp. A. saligna. Inter-subspecific pollination events occurred over a range of distances from 5 m to 1566 m with an average pollen dispersal distance of 666 m. A high percentage of progeny (96.5%) of subsp. lindleyi trees were assigned a most likely father from sampled trees of either subsp. saligna or subsp. lindleyi. Most likely fathers were undefined for fourteen subsp. lindleyi progeny (3.5%) and these were assumed sired by unsampled trees of the background population of subsp. lindleyi. The rate of pollen contamination in subsp. lindleyi trees is the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
107
percentage of subsp. lindleyi progeny assigned a most likely father from trees of subsp. saligna and totalled 32% (126 progeny) [23]. Inter-subspecific hybridisation in subsp. lindleyi was highly variable among maternal trees (0 to 100%) although this was not related to distance from the planted stand. Of the 107 trees of subsp. saligna, 45 (42%) were assigned as fathers of one or more progeny in the sampled seed crops of subsp. lindleyi trees. Inter-subspecific pollination distances ranged from 42 m to 1607 m for subsp. lindleyi progeny.
4
Conclusions
Inter-subspecific hybridisation from a planted stand of trees of subsp. saligna was considerable for remnant roadside populations of subsp. lindleyi, and accounted for nearly one-third (32%) of all outcrossed progeny of lindleyi trees. At the same site, pollen dispersal from subsp. lindleyi into subsp. saligna was much lower (14%). These results show that genetic contamination between the subspecies of A. saligna will be an issue for the sustainable use of the species as an agroforestry crop throughout its natural range in southern Western Australia. Remnant roadside populations of subsp. lindleyi may be at risk of high levels of inter-subspecific hybridisation with introduced populations of subsp. saligna throughout the wheatbelt of Western Australia. The disparity in inter-subspecific hybridisation between the two subspecies of A. saligna is likely due to differences in the total amount of pollen produced by each subspecies. Pollen production is influenced by the size of a population and its floral density [24]. Small populations are likely to experience a relatively large proportion of pollen immigration compared to larger populations and pollen immigration will increase in remnant populations as the introduced populations increase in size. Populations with poor flowering and pollen production are also likely to experience a relatively large proportion of pollen immigration compared to populations that are more fecund. Acacia saligna subsp. lindleyi has low floral fecundity as it has a spindly form, produces relatively few terminally located flowers and shows low seed set. In contrast, subsp. saligna shows the greatest biomass, floral density, and seed set of all four subspecies [25]. The disparity in floral fecundity between the two subspecies is noticeable at the study site where it would result in trees of subsp. saligna producing substantially more pollen in comparison to trees of subsp. lindleyi. Pollen production may also be affected by the age composition of populations at the study site. All trees in the planted stand were mature and flowered profusely in 2005, while the remnant populations were comprised of trees of various ages, including many juveniles that produced relatively few flowers and little pollen. This disparity in relative pollen production would lead to a greater contaminant pollen source for subsp. lindleyi, at the same time as a greater non-contaminant pollen source for subsp. saligna, and have the effect of both increasing intersubspecific hybridisation in subsp. lindleyi and decreasing it in subsp. saligna. The disparity in relative pollen production results in greater genetic contamination in subsp. lindleyi trees despite the greater number of trees of this subspecies at the study site. While the two subspecies rarely occur in sympatry WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
108 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI under natural conditions, there is a high likelihood that large populations of subsp. saligna will be planted throughout the natural range of subsp. lindleyi for revegetation purposes. These results show that high levels of genetic contamination can be expected in remnant populations from plantings of subsp. saligna once trees reach maturity. Most genetic contamination from subsp. saligna into remnant trees of subsp. lindleyi occurred at short distances of less than 300 m although significant levels of inter-subspecific pollen dispersal were detected over large distances of up to 1566 m. Inter-subspecific genetic contamination in trees of subsp. saligna from pollen from subsp. lindleyi trees was also detected over long distances of up to 1607 m. The results indicate that while the majority of inter-subspecific pollen contamination from introduced plantings is likely to occur over short distances, substantial amounts of inter-subspecific hybridisation may occur even when introduced populations are located at least 1.5 km away. At present, the impacts of inter-subspecific gene flow and the fitness of hybrid progeny relative to parental genotypes have not been assessed for A. saligna. The impacts of outbreeding depression are highly unpredictable for given taxa, but adverse effects may occur even when levels of inter-subspecific gene flow are low [26]. Assessment of outbreeding depression in hybrid progeny in A. saligna will require fitness measurements over the entire life cycle of hybrid progeny, and extension of hybridisation studies beyond the first generation to include backcross as well as F2 hybrids. The likelihood, and the long-term genetic and ecological consequences, of introgression in A. saligna are also unknown and require investigation. This study demonstrates that introduced plantings of tree species that maintain extensive levels of long distance gene flow, may pose some risk via pollen dispersal into genetically divergent natural populations. This risk can be reduced through cultural management practices, such as restricting germplasm used for introduced populations to that with flowering times that do not overlap with those of natural populations or harvesting trees planted for agroforestry before flowering and pollen production commences. In A. saligna, the flowering times of all four subspecies are slightly different, but do overlap so the first option may be impossible to implement in the short term. Selection for early flowering genotypes in subsp. saligna, which has the earliest flowering of the subspecies, may result in reduced overlap in flowering times among the subspecies. The second option of harvesting before floral maturity may be problematic for long-lived species however A. saligna is being promoted as a short rotation coppice crop [27] thus may be harvested before trees are old enough for flowering and pollen production to commence. The most reliable short-term practice to limit pollen-mediated gene flow in of A. saligna may include isolation of agroforestry crops from small natural populations by distance or by the use of barrier or guard rows. Guard rows are comprised of an alternative species and used to surround crops to reduce the physical movement of pollen and ‘trap’ pollinators thus reducing their movement directly from the crop. The effectiveness of guard rows has not been investigated at this stage; therefore, the most effective option may be isolation. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
109
Significant levels of inter-subspecific pollen dispersal from subsp. saligna into subsp. lindleyi was detected over large and isolation distances greater than 1500 m are recommended to prevent significant levels of gene flow into natural populations.
References [1]
[2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13]
Byrne, M. & Millar, M.A., Genetic systems and issues in the development of woody perennials for revegetation. Proceedings of the Conference Salinity Solutions: Working with Science and Society, eds. A. Ridley, et al., CRC for Plant-Based Management of Dryland Salinity: Bendigo, Victoria, pp. 1-5, 2004. Arnold, M., Natural hybridisation as an evolutionary process. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 23, pp. 237-261, 1992. Armstrong, T., Fitzjohn, R., Newstrom, L., Wilton, A. & Lee, G., Transgene escape: what potential for crop-wild hybridisation? Molecular Ecology, 14(1), pp. 2111-2123, 2005. Hails, R.S., Genetically modified plants - the debate continues. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 15(1), pp. 14-18, 2000. James, R., Difazio, S., Brunner, A. & Strauss, S., Environmental effects of genetically engineered woody biomass crops. Biomass and Bioenergy, 14(4), pp. 403-414, 1998. Raybould, A.F., Transgenes and agriculture - going with the flow. Trends in Plant Science, 4(7), pp. 247-248, 1999. Raybould, A.F. & Gray, A.J., Will hybrids of genetically modified crops invade natural communities. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 9, pp. 85-89, 1994. Ellstrand, N., Gene flow by pollen: implications for plant conservation genetics. OIKOS, 63(1), pp. 77-86, 1992. Rhymer, J.M. & Simberloff, D., Extinction by hybridisation and introgression. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 27, pp. 83-109, 1996. Wolf, D.E., Takebayashi, N. & Rieseberg, L.H., Predicting the risk of extinction through hybridisation. Conservation Biology, 15(4), pp. 10391053, 2001. Young, A., Boyle, T. & Brown, A., The population genetic consequences of habitat fragmentation for plants. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 11, pp. 413-418, 1996. Potts, B.M., Barbour, R.C., Hingston, A.B. & Vaillancourt, R.E., TURNER REVIEW No. 6 Genetic pollution of native eucalypt gene pools - identifying the risks. Australian Journal of Botany, 51(1), pp. 1-25, 2003. Hobbs, T., et al., FloraSearch Species Profiles – Low rainfall farm forestry options for southern Australia. RIRDC Report, Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Adelaide, 2006
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
110 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [14]
[15]
[16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21]
[22] [23] [24] [25]
[26] [27]
Olsen, G., Cooper, D., Carslake, J., Huxtable, D. & Bartle, J., Search Project Report. NHT project number 973849, Final report for NHT Project 973849, National Heritage Trust, Western Australian Department of Conservation and Land Management, Perth Western Australia, 2004 Millar, M.A., Byrne, M., Nuberg, I. & Sedgley, M., High outcrossing and random pollen dispersal in a planted stand of Acacia saligna subsp. saligna revealed by paternity analysis using microsatellites. Tree Genetics and Genomes, submitted, 2007. Fox, J.E.D., A review of the ecological characteristics of Acacia saligna (Labill.) H. Wendl. Mulga Research Centre Journal, 12, pp. 39-55, 1995. Maslin, B., Acacia saligna. Flora of Australia Volume11A Mimosaceae Acacia Part 1, Australian Biological Resources Study, CSIRO Publishing: pp. 416-418, 2001. Byrne, M., Moran, G. & Tibbits, W., Restriction map and maternal inheritance of chloroplast DNA in Eucalyptus nitens. Heredity, 84, pp. 218-220, 1993. Byrne, M., Macdonald, B. & Francki, M., Incorporation of sodium sulfite into extraction protocol minimizes degradation of Acacia DNA. BioTechniques, 30(4), pp. 742-748, 2001. Doyle, J. & Doyle, J., Isolation of plant DNA from fresh tissue. Focus, 12, pp. 13-15, 1990. Butcher, P., Decroocq, S., Gray, Y. & Moran, G., Development, inheritance and cross-species amplification of microsatellite markers from Acacia mangium. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 101, pp. 1282-1290, 2000. Marshall, T., Slate, J., Kruuk, L. & Pemberton, J., Statistical confidence for likelihood-based paternity inference in natural populations. Molecular Ecology, 7(5), pp. 639-655, 1998. Millar, M.A., Byrne, M., Nuberg, I. & Sedgley, M., Long distance intersubspecific gene flow detected by paternity analysis in remnant Acacia saligna (Mimosaceae). Molecular Ecology, submitted, 2007. Kwak, M., Velterop, O. & VanAndel, J., Pollen and gene flow in fragmented habitats. Applied Vegetation Science, 1(1), pp. 37-54, 1998. George, N., Koojong (Acacia saligna), a species with potential as a perennial forage for dryland salinity management - genetic variation, feed quality and reproductive biology. PhD Thesis, School of Plant Biology, University of Western Australia, Perth, 2005. Edmands, S. & Timmerman, C., Modelling factors affecting the severity of outbreeding depression. Conservation Biology, 17(17), pp. 883-892, 2003. Bartle, J., Cooper, D., Olsen, G. & Carslake, J., Acacia species as largescale crop plants in the Western Australian Wheatbelt. Conservation Science Western Australia, 4(3), pp. 96-108, 2002.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 5 Natural resources management
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
113
The Armenian forests: threats to conservation and needs for sustainable management R. Moreno-Sanchez1, H. Sayadyan2, R. Streeter3 & J. Rozelle1 1
Department of Geography and Environmental Sciences, University of Colorado at Denver, USA 2 Agrarian State University of Armenia, Armenia 3 Stratus Consulting, Inc., USA
Abstract In this paper we identify the characteristics of a sustainable forest management strategy and provide specific recommendations to move toward this goal in the forests in Armenia. To provide a context for these recommendations we present brief overviews of Armenian human and physical geography and the forests in the country. Also, we highlight how several crucial issues in the forestry sector have remained unchanged from the Soviet era to the independent period and the implications of this lack of change for the evolution and current state of forests in the country. Keywords: Armenia, forests, sustainable management, Caucasian region.
1
Introduction
The forests of the Caucasian region are a hot spot of biodiversity and they contain a large number of endemic plant and animal species [1]. In this drysubtropical region, forests also play a major role in preserving favourable environmental conditions for sustainable development. This is particularly true in small countries like Armenia. The 1988-1994 war with neighboring Azerbaijan and the great social, political and economic changes that have occurred since the country gained independence at the time of the collapse of the United Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) in 1991 have created tremendous pressures on the Armenian forests [2]. Ongoing developments and policies continue to threaten the quality and extent of Armenian forests [2, 3].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070121
114 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI To reverse this trend it is important to revive the Armenian forestry culture and educate a new generation of stakeholders, scientists, resource managers, and policy makers (in Armenia and abroad) about the characteristics, historical evolution, and current extent of the forests in the country. Also, there is a need to analyze and reflect on past and current management and conservation practices, forestry regulations and laws, and the relationship of the Armenian society to the forests. This information and analysis is fundamental in understanding the reasons for change, the current state of the forests ecosystems, and in providing a framework for the development of sustainable management alternatives for the Armenian forests. In this paper we identify the characteristics of a sustainable forest management strategy and provide specific recommendations to move toward this goal in the forests in Armenia. To provide context for our recommendations, we first present a brief overview of Armenian human and physical geography and the forests of the country. Also, we highlight how several crucial issues in the forestry sector have remained unchanged from the Soviet era to the independent period and the implications of this lack of change for the evolution and current state of the forests in the country.
2
Overview of Armenian human and physical geography
Over the centuries, the Republic of Armenia enjoyed brief periods of autonomy and came under the sway of various empires, including the Assyrian, Roman, Byzantine, Arab, Persian and Ottoman. Armenia was incorporated into Russia in 1828 and into the United Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) in 1920. Independence was achieved after the disintegration of the USSR in 1991. From 1988–1994, Armenia was involved in an armed conflict with Azerbaijan over the Nagorno-Karabakh region. The early years of independence were marked by economic hardships due to disruption in flow of energy and products from former Soviet republics [4]. The constituent 11 provinces have a human population of 3 326 448 (estimate for 2003 based on the first Armenian census of 2001), which is decreasing at an annual rate of 0.07%, mostly because of emigration. Approximately one third of the total population is concentrated in the capital Yerevan (1 091 230 people). Over 98% of the population aged 15 and over can read and write [4]. The country has a total area of 29 800 km2 (comparable to the size of Belgium). Altitude ranges between 400 m to 4090 m above sea level. Armenia is situated in a dry subtropical climatic zone. Precipitation ranges from 250– 300mm to 1000 mm per year. Several distinct microclimates are created by the complicated topography. The terrain complexity and microclimatic diversity, as well as the fact that Armenia is located at the crossroads of four different floristic provinces (Old-Mediterranean, Near-east Asian, Iran-Turanian and Caucasian), produce different vegetation types with high biodiversity and high percentages of plant and animal endemism. Today the country is included in the Caucasus and Irano-Anatolian biodiversity hotspots [1]. Biomes range from a semi-desert in
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
115
the Ararat plain to sub-alpine and alpine on the summit of the Aragats Mountain. There are c. 3600 species of high-vascular plants in the country [5–7]. The dendroflora is composed of 110 tree and 152 bush species [5–8]. The country faces several environmental problems and challenges including [4]: (1) soil erosion (It is estimated that two-thirds of the country suffers from heavy to medium erosion processes); [9–12], (2) soil and water pollution from toxic chemicals, (3) irrigation and drinking water shortages, (4) pollution of Lake Sevan (the main source of drinking and irrigation water in Armenia), (5) significant deforestation rates and (6) biodiversity loss.
3
Characteristics and extent of the forests in Armenia
We use the terms ‘forest cover’ or ‘forest’ to denote high forests (natural or created through plantations) dominated by tree species. The Armenian forests are predominantly composed of complex mixes of broadleaf deciduous tree species (mostly Oak Quercus spp., beech Fagus orientalis, and hornbeam Carpinus betulus and C. orientalis) [2,13]. Table 1 presents more detailed information on the composition and extent of the forest cover at different points in time. Table 1:
The area (in hectares) and percentage of total forest cover by dominant tree species in 1941 [14], 1956 [15], 1966 [16], 1997 [17] and 1988 [18].
Dominant tree species Mix of oaks (Quercus spp.) Beech (Fagus orientalis) Hornbeam (Carpinus spp.) Pine trees (Pinus spp.) Mostly from plantations. Juniper (Juniperus spp.) Mix of other broadleaf deciduous trees (mainly hornbeam coppice Carpinus spp., lime Tilia cordata, ash Fraxinus spp. and maple Acer spp.) Total
1941 Area (ha)
1956 Area (ha)
1966 Area (ha)
1977 Area (ha)
1988 Area (ha)
80241
83294
87200
97852
120000
109201
85310
89700
89533
96600
60365
46543
46600
50976
55100
927
969
2500
1295
17700
7862
6357
4200
12714
8400
25783
10180
22800
20741
36300
284379
241753
253000
273111
334100
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
116 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Most Armenian forests are found in mountainous terrain between 500 and 2200 m above sea level. The north-eastern and south-eastern parts of the country and the eastern bank of Lake Sevan have the most favourable climatic and environmental conditions for forests growth. The forest cover is highly fragmented, approximately 62% being in the north-east, 36% in the south-east and only 2% in the central region of the country (see figures 1 and 2). The numbers in table 1 come from Soviet forest inventories. Unfortunately, these data are the most recent regarding composition and extent of the forest cover. The Soviet estimates of the total area of the forest cover have come into question and have been characterized as unreliable [19]. Hence, Streeter et al [19] recently generated estimations of the extent of the Armenian forest cover using supervised classifications of Landsat satellite images from 1987-1989 (see figure 1) and 2000-2001 (see figure 2). According to their results, in the first period the forest cover was approximately 294,135 ha compared to 246,098 ha in the second period. The transformations and current state of the Armenian forests result from decades of management policies and forest use practices by several stakeholders and economic activities. Planned industrial production or use of the forests was very limited during the Soviet and independence periods for reasons that we will elaborate on later. Today the Armenian forests can be characterized as overstocked and over-mature forests with low density, low annual growth rates, and poor regeneration.
4
Forestry in Soviet and independent Armenia
The most relevant issues that have influenced the current state of the forests in Armenia have changed little from the Soviet era through the independent period [2]. The forests are owned and managed by the Armenian state. Soviet and today’s forest laws and regulations state that the forests are to be solely dedicated to protect the environment and other resources and for recreation purposes. Forest management during both periods has been characterized by protectionist policies, limited to sanitation cuts, with no intermediate cuts, and no industrial or commercial utilization of the forest resources. These policies aim to keep the Armenian forests mostly untouched without regard for the needs of the population, and without considering that a certain level of economic use of the forest (for example production of high-value timber from precious species) could be achieved without compromising their extent or capacity to protect other resources. Protectionist policies have had important consequences. First, the forest areas inhabitants and adjacent communities perceive that the forests had little or no monetary value for enhancing their economic situation if they are to be used according to the law. Secondly, there has been no opportunity to develop experience in managing the types of forest existing in Armenia with multiple objectives such as water production, protection of soils, recreation, grazing, and high-value timber production [2]. The later is a fundamental part of a sustainable management strategy. Soviet forest inventories were characterized by the use of
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
117
Figure 1:
Forest cover estimate from Landsat images for 1987-1989 [19].
Figure 2:
Forest cover estimate from Landsat images for 2000-2001 [19].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
118 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI visual assessments, limited statistical methods, and ground truthing [2]. Since independence, Armenia has not conducted a forest inventory with national coverage [2, 3, 19]. During the Soviet period, forest education and inventory expertise were concentrated at the regional center in Georgia [2]. This left Armenia without these resources at the time of the collapse of the USSR. In 2003, the first forestry department was established in the State Agrarian University of Armenia. Today Armenia still does not have a dedicated organization to conduct forest inventories, and there is a severe shortage of professionals with forestry education and know-how [2]. The independent period (1991- to date) has been characterized by significant negative impacts on the forests ecosystems. At the time of independence (and until 1994), Armenia was at war with Azerbaijan. Right after independence, all oil, gas, and forest product imports from Russia and other former USSR republics ceased abruptly [2]. These imports used to satisfy most of the energy needs in the country and more than 90% of the demand for forest products in Armenia. The resulting energy crisis forced many small cities and local forest communities during most of the 1990s to obtain up to 50% of their household energy needs from unregulated fuelwood cuttings [2]. The conditions that existed during early independence fostered the creation and growth of a massive blackmarket economy in all sectors, but particularly in the forestry sector. To this day, almost 100% of forest product production is part of an extensive black-market economy [2, 20]. The nature of the illegal cuttings started to change in 1996–1997, when the flow of oil and gas imports returned to almost normal levels. High-grade cuttings for illegal exports to Iran, Turkey and Europe involving the best specimens of high-value timber species replaced cuttings for firewood as the main source of impact to the forests [2, 21].
5
Defining a forest sustainable management strategy
A sustainable management approach to the Armenian forests has to integrate multiple objectives and use the forests in a manner and rate which will make this resource available to future generations. It will also promote continuous economic benefit, social acceptability, sound environmental conditions for human development and the subsistence of other species. Next, we list what we consider is required to move toward this goal. (1) It is required to take a holistic view and approach to the management of the forests that include and balance economic, social, and environmental considerations. (2) To be able to achieve point one, it is necessary to have a solid understanding of the functioning, responses, and interactions of the economic, social, and environmental systems involved in the Armenian forests. (3) Sustainable forest management requires: (a) a broader concept of the management unit to include areas beyond the borders of the forest (such as landscape-scale areas defined along ecological boundaries that go beyond
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
119
political and administrative boundaries); (b) solid understanding of the functioning, responses, and interactions of the social, economic, and environmental systems at different temporal and spatial scales; and (c) consideration of a broader array of species within the management units at each temporal and spatial scale. (4) Point number three requires a higher level of cooperation, coordination, collaboration, and sharing of information among stakeholders from diverse sectors, public and private organizations, and countries. (5) Finally, an important activity to promote point four is to educate all the entities as to why and how cooperation, coordination, collaboration, and the sharing of information must take place to move toward sustainable management of resources in general, and forest ecosystems in particular. None of the above mentioned requirements are easy to achieve and there are numerous cultural, political, economic, scientific, and technological challenges that must be overcome. However, we consider that: (1) There is enough progress on the technological front to start moving toward a better integration and sharing of information; and (2) education, of the society at large and specific stakeholders and organizations, on the need and the issues involved in the points listed in the previous paragraph can have a significant impact on moving toward sustainable management alternatives for the forests in Armenia. Regarding point one, there are significant advances in the creation of standards to enable interoperability between heterogeneous data sources, computer platforms, software, and information systems (see [22] for examples in the area of geographic and health information). To address point two in regard to the forests of Armenia, a website was created to raise awareness of the location and extent of the forests (http://osweb.cudenver.edu/armenia/Index.php). This site also provides wide access to historical data, and to the latest cartographic information regarding the extent of the forests in the country. This website will be translated into Armenian in the near future.
6
Recommendations for the Armenian forests
More specifically, in order of priority we suggest that the following actions and activities are required to reduce the threats to the sustainability of the Armenian forest (see [2, 3]) and to start evolving toward sustainable management alternatives. (1) Consider other alternatives for the ownership and organization for management of the forest resources in the country. (2) Review and update forest regulations and laws to make them congruent with the new social, economic, and environmental realities in the country. (3) Increase oversight, accountability, and punishment for corruption and mismanagement in the government (i.e. better governance). (4) Educate (at all levels) the Armenian society and the forest stakeholder in particular regarding the social, economic, and environmental importance and value of the Armenian forest resources; what constitutes a sustainable management strategy for these resources; and what elements and actions are required to move toward this goal. (5) Create a forestry sector infrastructure (professional and technical education centers, support for forestry producers and communities; inventory and monitoring facilities and WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
120 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI know-how) to support forest management activities. (6) Carry out an efficient and accurate estimation and monitoring of the forest resources in the country. (7) And finally, given that most of the value of the Armenian forest resides in nonmarketable goods and services (e.g. protection of other resources, water production, recreation), study how to quantify and assign monetary compensations for these goods and services that can benefit the national and local economies. There is work being done and progress on several of these issues, but there is still much to be done. The ownership of the forests by the Armenian state is not conducive to the sustainability of this resource. Lack of economic, human and material resources, administrative red tape, poor implementation of outdated laws and regulations, plus a lack of oversight and corruption are contributing to the mismanagement and degradation of the forests. State ownership of the forests disenfranchises the Armenian society and local forest inhabitants. Economic benefits from any forestry activity must be directly and immediately channeled to local communities. According to the latest forest growth estimates, the Armenian forests can support the commercial production of high-value timber products without compromising their conservation and protection to other resources function [2]. The generation of lawful and regulated economic benefits from the forests in the country would have a large impact on the level of attention given to these resources. As a result, it will have an impact on their conservation and maintain interest in their sustainable management. Although the evolution and current state of the Armenian forests and forestry sector are the result of a specific set of cultural, political, economic, and environmental conditions, there are many issues that are common to the experiences and development in many parts of the developing world. The sharing of experiences and information is fundamental to avoid repeating mistakes that have been made in the past. It will also avoid going down paths that have proven unsuccessful in the conservation and sustainable management of the world’s forest resources.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
Conservation International. Biodiversity hotspots. URL http://www. biodiversityhotspots.org/xp/Hotspots/caucasus/biodiversity.xml Sayadyan, H. & Moreno-Sanchez, R., Forest policies management and conservation in Soviet (1920-1991) and post-Soviet (1991-2005) Armenia. Environmental Conservation, 33(1), pp 1-13, 2006. Moreno-Sanchez, R. & Sayadyan, H., Evolution of the forest cover in Armenia. International Forestry Review, 7(2), pp 113-127, 2005. CIA (Central Intelligence Agency), The CIA world factbook: Armenia, URL http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/am.html Grigoryan, A.A., Valuable Tree Species and Bushes of Armenia. Yerevan, Armenia: Hayastan Publications, 168 pp. 1979. (In Armenian). Armenian Ministry of Nature Protection, Hayastani kensabazmazanutyuny (The biodiversity of Armenia). Arajin azgajin WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[7]
[8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13] [14] [15] [16]
[17] [18]
[19]
121
zekuyc. First National Report-UNDP/GEF/ARM/97/G31/A/1G/99), Yerevan, Armenia, 140 pp. 1999. Vardanyan, Z.H., Derevya i kustarnikiArmenii v prirode i culture (Trees and Bushes of Armenia in Nature and Culture). Yerevan, Armania: Institut Botaniki NAN Armenii (Institute of Botany of NAS of Armenia), 367 pp. 2003. Abrahamyan, H.A., Hayastani Antarnery (The Armenian forests). Yerevan, Armenia: Haypethrat Publications, 68 pp. 1960. Hayrapetyan, E.M., Hoghi erozian ev lernayin hoghagorcutyuny (Soil Erosion and Mountain Horticulture). Yerevan, Armenia: Hayastan Publications, 220 pp. 1976. Hayrapetyan, E.M., Gyughatntesakan ogtagorcumic durs ekac hogheri iracman ughinery (The Ways of Land Utilization out of Agricultural Cultivation). Yerevan, Armenia: Hayastan Publications, 58 pp. 1979. Hayrapetyan, E.M., Hoghagitutyun (Soil Science). Yerevan, Armenia: Asoghik, 456 pp. 2000. Hayrapetyan, E.M., Petrosyan, H.P. & Zaqoyan, R.H., Haykakan khsh hogheri melioracian, kulturakanacumy evpahpanumy (The Melioration Cultivation and Protection of Soils of Republic of Armenia). Yerevan, Armenia: Hayastan Publications, 499 pp. 1990. Sayadyan, H.Y., Landscape diversity, planning and optimal forest cover in Armenia. Annals of Agrarian Science, 3(2), pp 38–42, 2005. Maghakyan, A.K., Rastitelniy pokrov Armyanskoy SSR (Vegetation of Armenian SSR). Moscow-Leningrad, USSR: Akademia nauk SSSR, Otdel Armenii/Botanicheskiy Institute, 76 pp. 1941. Abrahamyan, H.A. Hayastani Antarnery (The Armenian forests). Yerevan, Armenia: Haypethrat Publications, 68 pp. 1960. Hakhinyan, H.M., The main tasks of development and intensification of forest farm in Armenia and results of scientific-research works. In: Haykakan gitahetazotakan antarphordzakayani askhatutyunneri joghovacu (Collection of Materials of Armenian Scientific Research Forest Experimental Centre), Volume VII, pp. 18–47. Yerevan, Armenia: Hayastan Publications. 1973. Makhatadze, L.B., Dubravi Armenii (Oak forests of Armenia). Yerevan, Armenia: Izdatelstvo Akademii Nauk ArmSSR (Publication of Academy of Sciences of Armenian SSR), 327 pp. 1977. Khurshudyan, P.A., The forest cover of Armenia in historical past, current state and forest ecosystems vulnerability in the case of climate change. In: Armenia-Climate Change Problems, pp. 110–122. Ministry of Nature Protection of Armenia/UNDP Global Ecological Fund (GEF) (in Armenian, resume in English). 1999. Streeter, R., Moreno-Sanchez, R., Sayadyan, H. & Wyckoff, J., Deforestation in Armenia: A quantitative estimation using Landsat imagery. Forest Ecology and Management, Forthcoming.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
122 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [20] [21]
[22]
Armenian Ministry of Nature Protection, Conservation and sustainable use of the forest genetic diversity of Transcaucasus. Forest Research and Experimental Center (FREC), Yerevan, Armenia. 50 pp. 2000. Sayadyan, H.Y., Illegal logging in Armenia. Draft report, World Bank project, Ensuring sustainability of forests and livelihoods through improved governance and control of illegal logging for economies in transition, World Bank, Yerevan, Armenia, 36 pp. 2005. Moreno-Sanchez, R., Anderson, G., Cruz, J. & Hayden, M., The potential for the use of Open Source Software and Open Specifications in creating Web-based cross-border health spatial information systems. International Journal of Geographic Information Science (Forthcoming).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
123
Contributions of biogeotextiles to sustainable development and soil conservation in developing countries: the BORASSUS Project M. A. Fullen1, C. A. Booth1, et al. (see last page for other authors) Abstract Field and laboratory studies indicate that geotextile mats constructed from palm leaves are an effective, sustainable and economically viable soil conservation technique. The three-year (2005–08) EU-funded BORASSUS Project (Contract Number INCO-CT-2005-510745) is evaluating their long-term effectiveness in controlling soil erosion and assessing their sustainability and economic viability. These studies are in progress in 10 countries, both in the ‘industrial north’ (in Europe) and in the ‘developing south’ (Africa, South America and South-East Asia). This paper focuses on agro-environmental applications and potential in the ‘developing south’ (The Gambia, South Africa, Brazil, China, Thailand and Vietnam). Biogeotextiles offer potentially novel bioengineering solutions to environmental problems, including technologies for soil conservation, sustainable plant production and use of indigenous plants, improved ecosystem management, decreasing deforestation, improving agroforestry and cost-effective geotextile applications in diverse environments. Biogeotextiles may provide socio-economic platforms for sustainable development and the benefits for developing countries may include poverty alleviation, engagement of local people as stakeholders, employment for disadvantaged groups, small and medium enterprise (SME) development, earning hard currency, environmental education and local community involvement in land reclamation and environmental education programmes. These benefits are achieved through: (a) promotion of sustainable and environmentally-friendly palm agriculture to discourage deforestation, promoting both reforestation and agroforestry; (b) construction of palm geotextiles enabling development of a rural labour-intensive industry, particularly encouraging employment of socially-disadvantaged groups and (c) export of palm geotextiles to industrialized countries could earn hard currency for developing economies, based on the principles of fair trade. Keywords: soil and water conservation, bioengineering technology, socio-economic development. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070131
124 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Recent improvements have been made in soil conservation technology and over the last three decades significant advances have been made in our understanding of soil erosion mechanisms and rates under different environmental conditions. However, there have been few advances in developing innovative soil conservation techniques. Moreover, relatively little research has been conducted at the interface between soil technology and socio-economic issues in developing countries, such as sustainable development, poverty alleviation and rural employment. One technique for soil conservation is geotextiles, which can create stable, non-eroding environments that provide the time necessary for vegetation to establish and grow. If constructed from indigenous materials, geotextiles can be effective, affordable and compatible with sustainable land management strategies [1]. Despite synthetic geotextiles dominating the commercial market, geotextiles constructed from organic materials are highly effective in erosion control [2] and vegetation establishment. Furthermore, they usually have 100% biodegradability and better adherence to the soil. Moreover, in developing regions, commerciallymarketed materials are usually too expensive. Thus, the BORASSUS Project is assessing the feasibility of employing palm-leaf geotextile mats as a potential soil conservation technique. This involves the promotion of sustainable and environmentally friendly palm-agriculture and offers a potentially profitable technique to augment the income of financially deprived farmers. This contribution summarizes the aims and objectives of the BORASSUS Project and presents some preliminary (first 18 months) findings regarding the potential contribution of biogeotextiles to sustainable development in developing countries.
2
The BORASSUS Project
Biogeotextiles can potentially advance soil erosion control in complex environmental situations, for instance on building and road construction sites, in gully stabilization and reclamation projects [3] and in coastal defence. However, as yet studies do not allow quantification of the effectiveness of palm-mat geotextiles in decreasing soil erosion rates by wind or water. Several workpackages in this Project address this issue through field measurements. However, a particular field site does not always offer the range of environmental conditions that can be found elsewhere in the region. One approach to establish the effectiveness of biogeotextiles for such conditions is through controlled laboratory experiments, during which erosive processes (rainfall, runoff and wind) are simulated for representative soil and slope conditions in the absence of, and with, biogeotextiles. Laboratory simulation studies are in progress in Belgium, China and South Africa, to validate field measurements in laboratory situations. Biogeotextiles offer considerable potential to contribute to sustainable development and soil conservation. They efficiently and economically conserve soil, and preliminary evidence is presented that in developing countries, their use WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
125
will promote sustainable and environmentally-friendly palm-agriculture, labourintensive employment and earn hard currency. The European Commission is funding the BORASSUS Project (Contract Number INCO-CT-2005-510745) for three-years (2005-08) to investigate ‘The Environmental and Socio-economic Contribution of Palm Geotextiles to Sustainable Development and Soil Conservation’. In Project Year 1 the main focus has been establishing the infrastructure to successfully and efficiently conduct project objectives, which are deliverable to both ‘Developing’ and ‘Industrialized’ countries [4]. The BORASSUS team are scientifically testing the following four hypotheses: (1) Promotion of sustainable and environmentally-friendly palm agriculture will discourage deforestation and promote both reforestation and agroforestry. It will also offer a potentially profitable technique, which will provide financially-deprived farmers with supplementary income from palm geotextiles and thus contribute to poverty alleviation. (2) Construction of palm geotextiles will develop into a rural based labourintensive industry, particularly encouraging the employment of sociallydisadvantaged groups, such as women, disabled and elderly people. This will in turn contribute to the stabilization of rural populations, thus decreasing migration to urban areas. (3) Export of completed biogeotextiles to industrialized countries will earn hard currency for developing economies and promote development, based on the principles of fair trade. (4) Biogeotextiles efficiently and economically conserve soil and will be especially beneficial for complex engineering problems. Temporary application of biogeotextiles will allow sufficient time for plant communities to stabilize engineered slopes. The Project consists of 13 work-packages using a team based in Europe (Belgium, Hungary, Lithuania and the U.K.), Africa (The Gambia and South Africa), South-East Asia (China, Thailand and Vietnam) and South America (Brazil) [5]. This paper reviews the preliminary (first-18 months) project insights into the potential contribution of biogeotextile technology to sustainable development in developing countries.
3 The contribution of the BORASSUS Project in developing countries Six case studies are reported which critically evaluate the potential contribution of biogeotextiles to agro-environmental development. These are spread globally; in Africa, Asia and South America. Then studies are integrated to distil general trends. 3.1 Case studies in The Gambia: the BORASSUS Project and improved forestry management The Gambia is one of the smallest countries in Africa. Over a hundred years ago, the country was covered by dense forest, but now has lost nearly all its large WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
126 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI tracts of forest, due to clearing for agriculture and fuelwood consumption [6]. Borassus aethiopium, locally called Ruhn (Mandinka) and Ron (Wollof), was among the most important, most frequent and abundant tree species in the forest vegetation. This plant was found in all divisions of the country (Western division, North Bank, Central River, Lower River and Upper River Division). Due to human activities (i.e. indiscriminate felling of trees for timber, frequent bushfires, clearing land for agricultural purposes), the number of these trees has diminished with the decreased forest. In some communities, Borassus aethiopium has become extinct. In reforestation programmes, plans to reintroduce the ruhn palm or increase their numbers have wide acceptance. In The Gambia, some 92% of women are involved in agriculture [7]. These women farmers have an increasing interest in tree planting to generate income, diversify crops and mitigate environmental degradation. The seriousness of deforestation and the resulting environmental degradation and its socio-economic consequences were acknowledged by the Colonial administration of The Gambia. However, the various policies put in place to improve this situation proved inadequate. Consequently, the Community Forestry (CF) Scheme was introduced in 1991 to accelerate the implementation of ‘scientific’ management on state controlled forestland. This scheme stemmed from the realization by the Department of Forestry of the futility of its efforts at protecting national forest resources, without the committed and willing involvement of local communities [8]. The establishment of the BORASSUS Project in The Gambia is therefore very timely, as it will help rural communities to intensify the Community Forestry programmes and promote CF schemes in communities that have not yet embraced them. Training activities in geotextiles production using the leaves of Borassus aethiopium have been conducted in three communities: Sinchu Balia, Sanyang Fala-Kindisebelle and Durumakolong. Villagers are now aware of another potential use of the palm and have embarked on tree nursery projects for the development of large plantations of the palm. These plantations are well planned and, when fully established, will enhance reforestation, agroforestry and provide a sustainable supply of the leaves for geotextile production and food security. In order to establish these large plantations, particularly in areas where the palm is growing sparsely or absent, scientific research to examine the ‘Soil Ecology and Profile for Sustainable Borassus aethiopium Cultivation in The Gambia’ is currently been conducted and will culminate in a MSc degree in Environmental Management at the University of Wolverhampton by a Gambian candidate (Adama Cole). The Human Development Index (HDI) for The Gambia is 0.479, which gives The Gambia a rank of 155th out of the 177 countries. The GDP per capita is $1,991 [9]. The rural poor, especially women of all age ranges, several old men and some disabled people in the above mentioned communities have earned additional money through geotextile production in support of their earnings in basket weaving using Borassus palm leaves and the selling of firewood. This has improved their earning capacity and economic status. A Master’s thesis on
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
127
‘Socio-economic Impact Assessment Study of The BORASSUS Project in The Gambia’ is currently been undertaken by another Gambian (Samba Jallow). Poverty alleviation also accords with CF objectives, in which communities are charged with the responsibility of sensibly using natural resources to directly provide their own domestic needs. In the long-term, this secures: firewood from deadwood, construction material as timber, fence posts, bark for ropes, leaves and grass for roofing, food in the form of fruit, leaves, roots, herbs and animals and natural medicine from leaves, roots, herbs, bark and branches. The long-term availability of these products saves costs and directly contributes to improved standards of living, through providing energy, shelter, food and improved health. Results from the BORASSUS partners currently testing the potential of Borassus geotextile mats in complex engineering situations (e.g. the building and road construction industries and in the stabilization of eroded mountain roadsides and slopes) appear very encouraging. This development has created the impetus for the establishment of Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) in The Gambia. Such enterprises could earn much needed foreign currency from sales of biogeotextile mats to industrialized countries. Another potential foreign currency earner is the promotion of ecotourism as a result of the long-term effect of improved forestry management, initiated or encouraged by the BORASSUS Project in The Gambia. The BORASSUS Project addresses several Developmental Goals of The Gambia viz: sustainable development, poverty alleviation/reduction and rural employment. The potential of the Borassus aethiopium palm for short and longterm sustainable agriculture and economic empowerment is well recognized by local communities, especially poor rural women farmers. 3.2 Case studies in South Africa: socio-economic production of palm geotextiles and their utilization on soil and mine dam slopes for erosion reduction South Africa is confronted with two major problems: unemployment and accelerating environmental degradation. Achieving the Millennium Development Goals, particularly Goal 1 (poverty/hunger alleviation) and Goal 7 (environmental protection), remains a major challenge. The South African team is addressing both issues, i.e. to help alleviate poverty by creating employment for disadvantaged people through the manufacture of palm geotextiles and to sell these products to engineering companies for application on engineered slopes, soils and tailing dam walls to reduce erosion. The objectives therefore consist of inter-related socio-economic and scientific components. The socio-economic activity involves training poor unemployed members from disadvantaged rural communities in the production of palm geotextiles and investigating sustainability and economic viability and has been successfully completed. A rural community has been identified, in the Tshongwe area in central Maputaland, KwaZulu-Natal. Local people are very poor, with unemployment rates ~80%. Many women, however, are well versed in traditional weaving and braiding techniques, a capacity which is largely untapped. Community members participated eagerly in a training course (Figs. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
128 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 1-3) and required ~4 hours to manufacture 1 m2 of mats. When employed on a full time basis at the government-determined minimum salary, this amounts to ~€3.5 per m2, approximately five times the price of imported jute nets. Lala palms (Hyperhene coriacea) grow profusely in the area (Fig. 4) and palm leaves are readily and freely available and only require local transportation.
Figure 1:
Community members in training.
Figure 3:
“My first mat!”
Figure 2: Photo break training.
during
Figure 4: Lala palms (Hyperhene coriacea) growing wild in the Tshongwe area.
Engineered slopes often require the temporary application of geotextiles to decrease soil erosion and allow sufficient time for plant communities to establish. Two organic products are presently on the South African market: jute nets and coir mats. They are imported from India and Sri Lanka and ~175,000 m2 are utilized annually by engineering companies. Replacing these imported products by locally manufactured ones would create employment and assist erosion control. However, the benefits of replacing jute with palm geotextiles needs to be convincingly demonstrated to engineers, particularly as palm mats are more expensive. Scientific studies are quantifying interrill erodibility, by comparing runoff and sediment load in the runoff from bare soils and mine dam tailings with those covered by palm mats via rainfall simulation. This information is essential when WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
129
attempting to promote the mats to engineering companies. Rainfall simulations allow erosive processes to be investigated under controlled laboratory conditions for a large range of soils. For the study, 20 representative South African topsoil horizons and 10 mine tailings have been investigated. Results clearly document that application of palm mats significantly decreases the sediment load in runoff (Fig. 5). The extent of reduction was independent of the sediment load of the uncovered soils. Soils with different degrees of erodibility had their sediment loads reduced by similar percentages. The palm mats did not improve water infiltration, however, and even led to slightly increased runoff volumes (Fig. 6). 5000
250
4000
150 100 50 0 0
200
400
600
800
RO (cm 3); palm mats
200
SL (g); palm m ats
R2 = 0.88
R2 = 0.78
3000 2000 1000 0 0
Figure 5:
Relationship between the sediment load in runoff (SL) of bare soils and from soils covered with palm mats (n = 20, P <0.001).
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
RO (cm 3); bare soil
SL (g); bare soil
Figure 6:
Relationship between runoff (RO) from bare soils and that from soils covered with palm mats (n = 20, P <0.001).
In summary, the specific scientific and technical objectives of the South African contribution consist of addressing the overlapping issues of soil conservation/bioengineering with socio-economic rewards, thereby contributing to achieving Millennium Development Goals 1 and 7. To achieve this the price of mats manufactured from leaves of the Lala palm by disadvantaged rural communities has been established (~€3.5 m-2) and the beneficial effects of these mats on soil loss and water infiltration have been investigated. Results show that the mats effectively decrease sediment load in runoff by over two-thirds and thus have potential as a biotechnical soil conservation method effectively conserving soil on slopes. The mats, however, did not decrease runoff volumes. 3.3 Case studies in Brazil: The BORASSUS Project and the stabilization of urban gullies In São Luís City and surrounding areas (Maranhão State) in north-east Brazil (Fig. 7), deforestation has paved the way for accelerated urban expansion, which has promoted soil erosion, particularly severe gullying. This has caused the loss WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
130 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI of lives and homes [10]. For instance, between 1997-2003, gully erosion was responsible for five deaths and the destruction of 350 homes in São Luís City alone. To better understand gully evolution at Sacavém, an ongoing gullymonitoring programme was established in 2000. In turn, this has led to a local programme of gully rehabilitation, using geotextiles made of Buriti (Mauritia flexuosa) palm leaves, collected from native palm trees. The physical characteristics of the surveyed gullies are rather similar and so we present them as part of a general overview of the study area. However, there are some minor differences in soil properties between gullies (particle size distribution, particle density, bulk density and porosity). The investigated gullies are situated in São Luis City, Maranhão Island (2º19’9”-2º51’S”; 44º1’16”44º19’37”W) (Fig. 7). To date, several papers have reported the main physical characteristics, socio-economic conditions and the use of palm mats to rehabilitate gullied and degraded areas [3, 11–14]. There are two distinct seasons: a dry and a rainy season. The dry season is usually from August to November and has a precipitation deficit, with mean monthly rainfall ~30 mm. The rainy season is usually from December to July, with mean monthly rain ~250 mm, March is the rainiest month, with ~400 mm of precipitation. This is the season of most active gully erosion and poses most risk for the people who live adjacent to gullies (Fig. 8). In the historical past, the main vegetation cover of the region was tropical rainforest, although it has been subject to intense deforestation, since urban growth started during the 18th century. Nowadays the main vegetation type is secondary, called Capoeira in Brazil. This vegetation community appears when the original vegetation is cut down and is different from the original tropical forest [3, 14]. The South American (Brazilian) focus aims to: (i) understand where, how and at what rates gully erosion occurs; (ii) measure and assess urban gully erosion and identify the primary controlling factors; (iii) compare areas with and without palm mat protection; (iv) examine the relation between gully erosion and environmental and socio-economic factors; (v) rehabilitate as many gullies as reasonably possible; (vi) educate and assist local authorities and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) about using alternative geotextile technology to rehabilitate urban gullies and (vii) engage with communities affected by these potentially life-threatening features, by initiating an environmental-awareness programme to inform and educate them about gully erosion and control. The next phase is to reshape selected gullies, in Sao Luis City, and to place the Buriti palm mats on top of black earth, mixed with grass and legume seeds, in order to rehabilitate the gullies. Besides employing local people to construct the mats, we will employ them to place the palm mats and to maintain the whole reclaimed area. The final step will be to teach them how to maintain this area once the project is complete and they must sustain their achievements without external assistance. This includes planting environmentally friendly, sustainable and income generating crops.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 7:
Location of the study area.
Figure 8:
131
Araçagi gully, which threatens the lives and property of people who live adjacent.
3.4 Case Studies in China: the BORASSUS Project, soil conservation and sustainable rural development in Yunnan Province Yunnan Province has an area of 394,000 km2 and is situated in south-west China, internally bordering Tibet, Sichuan, Guizhou, and Guangxi, and externally bordering Burma, Laos and Vietnam (2108’32’’-29015’8’’N; 97031’39’’-106011’47’’E). The Province experiences a monsoonal climate, characterized by wet and dry seasons. The dry season extends from November to April, when precipitation is usually <20% of the annual total. The wet season runs from May to October, and the precipitation is >80% of the annual total. Average temperatures are 6-210C and annual precipitation varies widely, between 300-3500 mm. There are 84 rivers with drainage areas >1000 km2 in Yunnan Province. These rivers converge into the Yangtze, Pearl, Honghe, Mekong, Nujiang and Ilouwadi Rivers, respectively, and then into either the Pacific or Indian Oceans. In recent years, due to increasing population and improper land utilization, many eco-environments have suffered degradation. Over-cultivation of highlands and low vegetation cover in drought-hot river basins, contribute two major environmental problems in Yunnan. The total area of cultivated land in Yunnan is 6.42 m ha, which accounts for 16.8% of the total land area of the Province, of which cultivated highlands is 5.66 m ha and accounts for 88.2% of total cultivated land area. There are 2.21 m ha of cultivated highlands with WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
132 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI slopes of 15-250, 0.73 m ha of cultivated highlands with slopes of 25-350 and 0.88 m ha of cultivated highlands with slopes >350. These areas are very vulnerable to soil erosion and eco-environmental degradation. The total eroded area of 146,430 km2, accounts for 38.2% of the total land area of Yunnan. The average amount of water-eroded soil is estimated to average 518 m t per year (excluding landslides, debris avalanches and mudflows). Mean annual N, P, K nutrients losses due to soil erosion are estimated at 63,408, 5,537 and 65,058 tonnes, respectively, and soil water loss is 63.1 m t [15]. Although the physical environment is a major factor contributing to erosion problems, the subtropical and tropical climate interacts with the wide range of elevation and landforms to make Yunnan Province rich in bioresources. The complicated geology, geomorphology and climate provide a good environment for the growth of plants and animals. Yunnan Province is nicknamed the ‘Kingdom of Plants’. There are 13,278 species of higher plants and 1,737 vertebrates have been discovered in Yunnan. There are over 160 species of fibre plants in Yunnan, which could be exploited for soil conservation and economic purposes [16]. Palm (Trachycarpus excelsu), maguey (Agave Americana), bamboo (phyllostachys spp.), sisal (Agave houllet), ramee (Boehmeria nivea) and jute (Corchorus capsularis) are some of the main species with potential use as geotextiles. In 2001, the yield of cultivated ramee and jute was 208 t. Besides these fibre plants, there are >500 m t of rice straw produced each year [17]. Therefore, geotextile raw materials of rice and wheat straw and palm leaves are available bioresources. By the end of 2005, there were 2.52 m people with an annual per capita income <668 Yuan and 4.90 m people with <924 Yuan (€1 = 9.6 Yuan) in Yunnan Province [18]. Although Yunnan Province is rich in natural resources, many people are suffering poverty associated with serious soil fertility and erosion problems. Therefore, there is an urgent need to simultaneously find ways of using available resources to decrease soil and water losses and increase local farmers’ income. Appropriate and effective technology may be adopted by local farmers and contribute to poverty alleviation and rural socio-economic development. The Yunnan Agricultural University (YAU) team began its BORASSUS Project research in winter 2004 and has now completed one simulation experiment and one field runoff plot experiment. Some very positive results of biogeotextile mats, including wheat straw, rice straw and palm-leaf mats, on soil and water conservation and rural economic development were obtained. Biogeotextile mulch reduces surface runoff and conserves soil and water. In the simulation experiment, surface runoff and soil loss follows the diminishing order of: contour planting with rice straw geotextile mulch, contour planting and then downslope planting. In comparison with downslope planting, contour planting with rice straw geotextile mulch and contour planting decreased surface runoff by 35.4 and 30.7%; and the total amount of sediment loss decreased by 43.6 and 27.3%, respectively. In the field runoff plot experiment, effects of different treatments on soil and water conservation followed the sequence: palm geotextiles mulch <wheat straw geotextiles mulch <polythene film mulch <no WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
133
mulch. Compared with no mulching and polythene film mulch, total runoff from wheat straw geotextiles decreased by 42.5 and 36.4%, total runoff from palm geotextiles mulch decreased by 41.0 and 34.7%, total sediment loss from palm geotextiles mulch decreased by 53.4 and 47.6%, and total sediment loss from wheat straw geotextiles mulch decreased by 44.4 and 37.4%, respectively. Biogeotextile mulch conserves soil moisture and decreases soil temperature. In the simulation experiment, soil moisture contents under rice straw geotextile mulch were ≤15.3 and 14.9% higher than those of downslope planting and contour planting. In field runoff plot experiment, soil moisture contents under polythene film mulch, palm geotextiles mulch and wheat straw geotextiles mulch increased by 48.0, 32.0 and 23.1%, respectively, compared to no mulch. Soil temperature under polythene film mulch was ≤25.9% higher than that of no mulch. However, palm geotextiles mulch and wheat straw geotextiles mulch decreased soil temperature by 11.4 and 14.0%, respectively. Biogeotextile mulch improved crop growth compared to no mulch. In the simulation experiment, wheat yield increased by 30.1 and 27.9%, compared with downslope planting and contour planting, respectively. In the field runoff plot experiment, polythene film mulch promoted maize growth in the early growth stage. Compared to no mulch, polythene film mulch, wheat straw geotextiles mulch and palm geotextiles mulch increased maize yield by 30.2, 14.1 and 17.9%, respectively. Compared with polythene film mulch and no mulch, biogeotextile mulch can both decrease the loss of soil and water, but also obtain high crop yields. Thus, environmental and agricultural effects were balanced, which helps improve sustainability on sloping arable fields. Starting in March 2006, five families living in Qianchang Township (Yaoan County, Chuxiong District, Yunnan Province) with per capita annual incomes <924 Yuan have been selected to make geotextile mats, using rice straw from local rice production. So far, 3000 mats have been produced, the unit price is: 3.50 Yuan/piece. Market development for biogeotextile mats is crucial now to local farmers, because it could be an important income source, and the materials are readily available. Farmers can easily learn how to use these materials to make useful biogeotextile mats. The BORASSUS Project has contributed to agricultural education programmes at YAU. For instance, Mr. Zheng Wenjie was awarded a MSc in June 2006 [19] and research results have been subsequently published [20]. Five MSc students have been involved in this Project since March 2006. Their main tasks are investigating different crop cultivation systems on upland arable soils and evaluating the economic and environmental impacts by using rice straw and other biodegradable geotextile mats. The Project is also contributing to undergraduate (BSc) programmes in agricultural sciences. 3.5 Case Studies in Thailand: potential contributions of the BORASSUS Project to sustainable development in the highlands of northern Thailand Currently, inappropriate hill farming systems, such as shifting cultivation and intensive cropping in northern Thailand, are causing massive soil erosion and WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
134 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI leading to serious problems of soil quality degradation, decreased soil productivity, poor crop production and socio-economic and environmental problems. Particularly, severe environmental problems, such as landslides, droughts and floods, have caused much recent damage. Therefore, sustainable hill farming systems are essential for soil and environmental conservation. Contour ditch, terracing, grass strip, alley cropping and mulching techniques have been investigated and widely practiced as effective anti-erosive strategies in sloping highland agricultural systems for several decades. However, many of these practices have not been widely adopted by farmers, as they involve high investment and labour costs. The most effective strategies to control soil erosion in northern Thailand include vetiver grass (Vetiveria nemoralis A. Camus) strips, alley cropping, and contour ridge cultivation with plastic sheet and straw mulching (INCOPLAST = incorporation of plastic and straw mulch treatment) when compared to the other contour cultural practices [21]. However, disadvantages of grass strip or alley cropping are high water consumption and extra land requirements for the nonedible hedgerow crops. INCOPLAST does not always harvest rainwater effectively, due to water impedance by plastic sheets, decreased accession of rainfall to the soil profile and high runoff under high rainfall intensity [22–24]. Furthermore, in the long-term INCOPLAST may induce serious environmental problems if degradable polythene sheets are unavailable. Therefore, using biodegradable geotextiles for surface mulching on sloping land should potentially be one of the most effective methods to increase rainfall accession into the soil profile, by reducing runoff and soil loss under intense rainfall. Contributions of the BORASSUS Project to sustainable development in northern Thailand are focused on rainfed agriculture on steep slopes and aims to improve rain-fed water use efficiency and maintain soil productivity for sustainable highland crop production. Strategies to achieve these aims are using contour furrow cultivation and surface mulching to harvest water for sustainable rainfed multiple crop production in alley cropping-agroforestry systems. The main target of this sub-project is to replace shifting cultivation by a simple sustainable conservative land use system, such as geotextile mulching, furrow cultivation and agroforestry (alley cropping with hedgerows of mixed fruit trees). This should lead to increased productivity, profitability and environmental quality and contribute to the development of rainfed sustainable highland agricultural systems. Field experiments of the BORASSUS sub-project in northern Thailand have been conducted since June 2004. Using palm mats for reducing soil erosion is limited due to the lack of palm trees (Caryota mitis Lour) in the northern highlands. However, imperata grass (Imperata cylindrica) and bamboo (Arundinaria gigantea) are widely distributed and fast growing in the highlands. Using imperata grass panels and bamboo mats as biogeotextiles are expected to effectively control soil erosion and improve crop water use efficiency. Field experiments were established in Mae Cham District, Chiang Mai Province, northern Thailand in May 2004, in order to compare the effects of different soil conservation and water harvesting techniques on soil properties, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
135
soil loss and runoff, soil water storage and crop yields. The experimental plots are located in farmers’ fields at 980-1100 m altitude, on a 100% slope gradient. The three replicated treatments comprise of four conservation techniques: (i) Conventional contour planting (control), CP, (ii) contour planting and mulched with bamboo-mat geotextiles, CP-BM, (iii) contour furrow planting mulched with imperata grass panel in the furrow, CF-IM, (iv) contour furrow planting in alley cropping, CF-AL, and (v) contour furrow planting mulched with imperata-grass panel in alley cropping (CF-M-AL). The alley cropping hedgerows consisted of mixed fruit-trees (mango (Mangifera indica L.), lemon (Citrus aurantifolia) and jujube (Zizyphus jujuba Mill) and ground cover with Graham stylo (Stylosanthes guianensis). The annual multiple crops are rotations of sweet corn (Zea mays L.) followed by upland rice (Oryza sativa L.) and lablab bean (Lablab perpureus L.) during the early, mid-late and late summer rainy season, respectively. Measured data include selected soil properties, surface runoff, soil loss, soil water storage and crop yields. The results obtained during 2004-2006 showed that contour furrow planting mulched with imperata-grass panels in an alley cropping system (CF-M-AL) tended to improve soil properties, while contour planting (CP) gave the highest rates of surface runoff and soil erosion, compared to the other treatments. The highest soil water storage and crop yields throughout crop growing period were also found under CF-M-AL practices compared to the other treatments. The lowest yields were given by CP. Generally, CF-M-AL tended to be the best, CF-AL and CF-IM were the second best, while CP and CP-BM were the worst and the second worst cultural practices for soil and water conservation, multiple crop production and sustainable land use on the sloping highlands under the 2004-2005 weather conditions. Field experiments are being repeated in the 2007-2008 cropping seasons. 3.6 Case Studies in Vietnam: soil conservation technology in the northern highlands The Tam Nong study area is a typical highland area of Northern Vietnam. The district is ~100 km north-west of the national capital, Hanoi, and has a total population of 80,837, with a population density of 512.2 people per km2 [25]. This is notably higher than the national average of 231.0 people per km2 [26]. Tam Nong consists of 20 communes, of which two communes (Huong Non and Xuan Quang) are co-operating in the BORASSUS Project. Both commune areas grow paddy rice, maize and vegetables in the lowlands. In the highlands, they grow cassava, fruit trees, industrial crops and timber. Crop productivity in financial terms in the highlands is only 40% of its value in the lowlands. The main highland crops are tea, wax trees, fruit trees (longan and litchi) and timber trees. Annual crops are predominantly peanuts, soya beans and maize. Lowland crops are intensively cultivated, while the highland farmers mainly focus on traditional and indigenous farming systems. Irrigation systems provide ~90% of lowland water, while the highlands mainly utilize rainfed cultivation systems [27]. There are two main seasons: the dry season (December-April), which has WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
136 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 14-53 mm/month rainfall and 52-72 mm/month soil surface evaporation, and the wet season (June-September), which has 163-330 mm/month rainfall and 55-60 mm/month soil surface evaporation [25]. In Tam Nong District, the two major agricultural production problems which cause low crop productivity are insufficient crop water in the dry season and severe soil erosion in the rainy season [27]. In traditional cultivation practices, farmers tend not to focus on soil conservation issues on sloping land and, consequently, soil is eroded and nutrient deficient [28, 29]. Therefore, it is anticipated that the BORASSUS Project will provide effective biogeotextile technology for use on sloping land, which local farmers will produce and apply as a cheap and effective soil conservation technique. Environmental assessment and socio-economic surveys associated with agricultural production have been conducted in both the Huong Non and Xuan Quang communes. These have focused on three themes. Firstly, the social effects of geotextile mat production (Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) using socioeconomic survey and assessment; plus, secondary data collection from the local authority and several agricultural institutions). Secondly, farmer participation in using geotextiles to protect sloping land (Rapid Rural Appraisal (RRP) for understanding ecological conditions in Tam Nong and for the design of field experiments). Thirdly, field experiments on the effectiveness of biogeotextiles for retaining soil moisture, based on crop and soil analyses. Several observations can be drawn from the first year of study (July 2005June 2006). Tam Nong is an economically poor mountainous district and the productivity of highland crops is very low. With indigenous sloping land cultivation systems, farmers do not focus on soil conservation techniques, which leads to the use of highland soils for unsuitable crops. The soils are very thin and deficient in nutrients and water. Thus, it is necessary and possible to help farmers to apply methods of using biogeotextile mats on sloping land. Previous studies have shown that the productive potential of the land and crop yields in the highlands could be effectively improved if technical solutions are applied. These solutions include improving field soil quality, irrigation systems, increasing production inputs and the application of new technologies. One of the effective solutions for improving the quality of field soil is soil conservation techniques, such as soil erosion control and soil surface mulching for soil evaporation control [27–29]. From labour structure and household surveys, it is apparent that women are the main source of cultivation labour and they also participate in off-farm activities to increase their household income. Therefore, the BORASSUS Project chose two woman groups in two selected study communes for biogeotextile construction. They are very active and quickly apply the new skills acquired with this work and received additional income, due to making mats for the Project. The women participated in all field experiment activities and they will be key personnel for future project extension. The initial results of two field experiments have shown that biogeotextiles can contribute to soil conservation in the highlands. Local people use biogeotextile mats produced from different local materials (i.e. palm leaves, maize straw and WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
137
bamboo). Geotextile manufacture is time consuming, but farmers usually do this work at home in their free time. The advantage of this method is that biogeotextiles are quite stable against the strong winds of the dry season and impede evaporation of soil moisture from the experimental plots. The results of crop and soil moisture measurements through the crop growing season proved that covering soil with biogeotextile mats leads to improved soil moisture retention. In the dry season, farmers can use biogeotextile mats made from bamboo, because this material is highly effective in retaining soil moisture and there are considerable bamboo resources in Tam Nong District; in fact more than palm leaves. Farmers actively and positively participated in field experiments and obtained good crop yields of soya beans and peanuts. However, on the other farmers’ fields the crops failed, due to insufficient rain in the 2006 dry season. Ecological and socio-economic conditions in Tam Nong mean it is essential to apply soil conservation methods on sloping agricultural land, such as those used in the BORASSUS Project. In the first year of the Project, the local authority and farmers of Tam Nong participated very actively in the construction of biogeotextile mats and the implementation of field experiments. The price of one mat is 15,000-25,000 Dong VN (€0.70-1.20). Field experiments using biogeotextile mats for annual crops, such as soya bean and peanuts, proved that the BORASSUS Project technology provides successful techniques for soil moisture retention during the highland dry season. Although it was very dry in 2006, due to covering the soil with biogeotextile mats, the two field experiments were highly productive. Two field visits were arranged for the local authority and farmers from Tam Nong. Participants had the opportunity to observe differences in crop growth and soil moisture on experimental plots. All participants agreed with the positive results of the two field experiments. These results will be clarified by repeat experiments in 2007 and 2008.
4 Discussion Preliminary project results are very positive; with direct field and laboratory evidence indicating biogeotextiles can have several beneficial effects, which were repeated in Africa, South America and South-East Asia. Effects also appear consistent between selected land use systems (arable land, degraded gullied land and orchards). Consistent effects include: (a) Biogeotextiles significantly decreased soil erosion rates, which accord with preliminary results from laboratory simulations of erosion processes (in Belgium, China and South Africa). (b) Biogeotextile mats assist the conservation of soil water and decrease evaporation from soil during dry periods. As biogeotextile mats degrade, they may add organic matter to soil systems. Furthermore, X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (XRF) analysis shows both Borassus and Buriti fibres contain nutrients, which may be incorporated into soil systems as fibres degrade. Identified nutrients include magnesium (Mg), phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), manganese (Mn) and iron (Fe).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
138 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Further information can be obtained from the BORASSUS Project website (www.borassus-project.net). Full Project publications can be accessed on the University of Wolverhampton WIRE free-access web site: http://wlv.openrepository.com/wlv/
5
Conclusions
The use of biogeotextiles constructed from indigenous leaf fibres has potential as a soil conservation method. Initial investigations used palm-leaves, but these broadened to include other indigenous fibres (i.e. bamboo, imperata grass, maize, rice and wheat). Thus, developing technologies are flexible and can be adapted to local conditions. The results from the first 18 months of investigation indicate biogeotextiles constructed from indigenous bioresources effectively decreased soil erosion. If harvested correctly, these resources are sustainable and readily available in many bioclimatic regions. They are biodegradable, providing organic content matter and nutrients to the soil and their permeability makes them suitable for use with cohesive soils. There are no high-energy production procedures in the manufacturing process and they may provide a cost-effective method of conserving soil in developing countries, where farming techniques are scaled to low levels of disposable income.
Acknowledgements This work is dedicated to the memory of Dr Kathy Davies. We also gratefully thank all technical and support staff involved with this Project. All authors acknowledge and thank the European Commission for the financial support of the BORASSUS Project (Contract Number INCO-CT-2005-510745).
References [1]
[2] [3]
Booth, C.A., Davies, K. & Fullen, M.A., Environmental and socioeconomic contributions of palm-leaf geotextiles to sustainable development and soil conservation, In: Ecosystems and Sustainable Development V, Eds. E. Tiezzi, C.A. Brebbia, S.E. Jorgensen & D. Almorza Gomar, WIT Press: Southampton (UK), pp. 649-658, 2005. Davies, K., Fullen, M.A., & Booth, C.A., A pilot project on the potential contribution of palm-mat geotextiles to soil conservation. Earth Surface Processes & Landforms, 31, pp. 561-569, 2006. Guerra, A., Marcal, M., Polivanov, H., Sathler, R., Mendonça, J., Guerra, T., Bezerra, F., Furtado, M., Lima, N., Souza, U., Feitosa, A., Davies, K., Fullen, M.A., & Booth, C.A., Environmental management and health risks of soil erosion gullies in São Luís (Brazil) and their potential remediation using palm-leaf geotextiles, In: Environmental Health Risk III, (Editors) C.A Brebbia, V. Popov & D. Fayzieva, WIT Press: Southampton (UK), pp. 459-467, 2005. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[4]
[5]
[6] [7] [8]
[9] [10] [11]
[12]
139
Fullen, M.A., Booth, C.A., Sarsby, R.W., Davies, K., Bhattacharyya, R., Poesen, J., Smets, T., Kertesz, A., Toth, A., Szalai, Z., Jakab, G., Kozma, K., Jankauskas, B., Trimirka, V., Jankauskiene, G., Bühmann, C., Paterson, G., Guerra, A.J.T., Mendonça, J.K.S., Zheng Yi, Li Yongmei, Panomtarachichigul, M., Dao Chau Thu, Tran Huu Cuong, Truong Thi Toan, Jonsyn-Ellis, F., Corkhill, C., Mulholland, B., & Dearlove, M., The potential contribution of palm mat geotextiles to soil conservation and sustainable development. In: Soil and Water Conservation under Changing Land Use (Editors) J.A. Martinez-Casasnovas, I. Pla Sentis, M.C.R. Martin & J.C.B. Solanes, Universitat de Lleida Press, pp. 303306, 2006. Booth, C.A, Fullen, M.A., Sarsby, R.W., Davies, K., Kurgan, R., Bhattacharyya, R. Poesen, J., Smets, T. Kertesz, A., Toth, A., Szalai, Z., Jakab, G., Kozma, K., Jankauskas, B., Trimirka, V., Jankauskiene, G., Bühmann, C., Paterson, G., Mulibana, E., Nell, J.P., van der Merwe, G.M.E., Guerra, A.J.T., Mendonça, J.K.S., Guerra, T.T., Sathler, R., Zheng Yi, Li Yongmei, Panomtarachichigul, M. Peukrai, S., Dao Chau Thu, Tran Huu Cuong, Truong Thi Toan, Jonsyn-Ellis, F., Jallow, S., Cole, A., Mulholland, B., Dearlove, M. & Corkhill C., The BORASSUS Project: aims, objectives and preliminary insights into the environmental and socio-economic contribution of biogeotextiles to sustainable development and soil conservation, In: Sustainable Development and Planning III (Editors) A. Kungolas, C.A. Brebbia & E. Beriatos, WIT Press: Southampton (UK), pp. 601-610, 2007. International Conference on Tropical Secondary Forest Management in Africa: Country Paper - The Gambia. Nairobi, Kenya 9-13 December 2002. Bauman H., The division of work according to sex in Africa. Hoe Culture Africa, 1, pp. 289-319, 1982. Community Forest Ownership: Key to Sustainable Forest Resource Management - The Gambia Experience. International workshop on Community–Based Natural Resource Management. World Bank, Washington DC (USA). http:www.dfs-online.de/cfo.htm http://hdr.undp.org/hdr2006/statistics/countries/countryfactsheet. Mendonça, J.K.S., Relatório Final Diagnóstico da erosão urbana no município de São Luis-MA. Relatório 03-2002/02. São Luis, Universidade Federal do Maranhão, 2003. Guerra, A.J.T., Mendonça, J.K.S. & Alves, I.S., Gully erosion in São Luis City – Maranhão State, Brazil. In: Gully Erosion under Global Change, (Editors) Y. Li, J. Poesen and C. Valentin, Sichuan Science and Technology Press: Chendgu (China), pp. 13-20, 2004. Guerra, A.J.T., Feitosa, A.C., Mendonça, J.K.S., Furtado, M.S, Lima, N.F.C. & Sousa, U.V.D., The use of biotextiles to recuperate degraded areas by erosion. Revista Sociedade e Natureza, Uberlândia, 2, pp. 277283, 2005.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
140 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [13]
[14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
[25]
Guerra, A.J.T., Mendonça, J.K.S., Bezerra, J.F.R., Gonçalves, M.F.P. & Feitosa, A.C., Study of rainfall rates and erosive processes at the urban area of São Luís (MA). Revista Sociedade e Natureza, Uberlândia, 2, pp. 192-201, 2005. Sathler, R, Guerra, A.J.T., Polivanov, H. & Marçal, M.S., Erosive processes in urban areas in the Island of Maranhão. Revista Sociedade e Natureza, Uberlândia, 2, 161-173, 2005. Wang, W.F., Yunnan Soil, Yunnan Sciences & Technology Press, 1996. The Ministry of Agriculture, People’s Republic of China, China Agricultural Statistics. China Agriculture Press, 2000, 2001 & 2002. Agriculture of China Encyclopedia Editorial Board, China Agriculture Encyclopedia, Yunnan Book, China. Agriculture Press, 2001. Chuncheng Evening Daily, 8/01/2006. Zheng Wenjie, Research on the application of natural fibre geotextiles for upland red soil erosion control. Unpublished MSc thesis, Yunnan Agricultural University (China), 2006. Zheng Wenjie, Zheng Yi, Fullen, M.A & Booth. C.A., Effects of rice straw geotextiles on soil erosion and winter wheat under simulated rainfall. Chinese Journal of Soil Science, 37(5), pp. 969-972, 2006. Panomtaranichagul, M., & Fullen, M.A., Soil and water conservation under contour cultural practices on sloping land in Thailand, In: Proceedings of the ‘International Symposium of 25 years of Assessment of Erosion’ (Editors) D. Gabriels & W. Cornelis, W., Ghent (Belgium), pp. 525-531, 2003. Panomtaranchagul, M., Sukkasem, C., Peukrai, S., Fullen, M.A., Hocking, T.J. & Mitchell, D.J., Comparative evaluation of cultural practices to conserve soil and water on highland slopes in northern Thailand, In: Multidisciplinary Approaches to Soil Conservation Strategies, (Editor) K. Helming, ZALF (Zentrum für Agrarlanschaftsund Landnutzungsforschung e.V.), Müncheburg (Germany), pp. 147-152, 2001. Panomtaranichagul, M. & Fullen, M.A. 2002. Soil degradation, water and erosion controls under different contour cultural practices for rainfed highland agriculture in northern Thailand, In: Proceeding of the ‘Conference on Soils under Global Change - A Challenge for the 21st Century’, 3-6 September 2002, Constanta (Romania), pp. 627-638, 2002. Panomtaranichagul, M., Wu Bo Zhi & Fullen, M.A., Assessment of sustainable crop production on sloping land under different contour cultural practices in South China and Northern Thailand, In: Proceedings of the ‘International Conference on Innovative Practices for Sustainable Sloping Lands and Watershed Management’ (SSWM), 5-9 September 2004, Chiang Mai, Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture and Co-operatives, Bangkok (Thailand), pp. 87-98, 2004. Statistical District Office (SDO), Statistical Department, Tam Nong District (Vietnam), 2005.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[26] [27] [28] [29]
141
IFPRI (The International Food Policy Research Institute), Land Tenure and Natural Resource Management, Washington DC (USA), 2001. Hung N.V., Socio-economic analysis of using highland area: Case study in Tam Nong District. Unpublished BSc thesis. Hanoi Agricultural University (Vietnam), 2006. (In Vietnamese). Ngo, T.D. &. Tran A.P, Good exploitation and conservation of our Midland and mountain region, Agriculture Publishers, Hanoi (Vietnam), 1993. (In Vietnamese). Chu, H.Q., Overview of highland development in Vietnam: General characteristics, socio-economic situation, and development challenges. In. A.T. Rambo & R.R. Reed (Editors), The Hanoi Agriculture Publisher, Hanoi (Vietnam), pp.114-115, 1995.
Full list of authors and their affiliations M. A. Fullen1, C. A. Booth1, R. W. Sarsby1, K. Davies1, R. Kugan1, R. Bhattacharyya1, M. Subedi1, D. A. Luckhurst1, J. Poesen2, T. Smets2, A. Kertesz3, A. Toth3, Z. Szalai3, G. Jakab3, K. Kozma3, B. Jankauskas4, G. Jankauskiene4, C. Bühmann5, G. Paterson5, E. Mulibana5, J. P. Nell5, G. M. E. van der Merwe5, A. J. T. Guerra6, J. K. S. Mendonça6, T. T. Guerra6, R. Sathler6, J. F. R. Bezerra6, S. M. Peres6, Z. Yi7, L. Yongmei7, T. Li7, M. Panomtarachichigul8, S. Peukrai8, D. C. Thu9, T. H. Cuong9, T. T. Toan9, F. Jonsyn-Ellis10, S. Jallow10, A. Cole10, B. Mulholland11, M. Dearlove11 & C. Corkill12 1
University of Wolverhampton, UK Catholic University of Leuven, Belgium 3 Geographical Research Institute, Hungary 4 Kaltinenai Research Station of the LIA, Lithuania 5 Agricultural Research Council, Pretoria, South Africa 6 Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 7 Yunnan Agricultural University, Kunming, China 8 Chiang Mai University, Thailand 9 Hanoi Agricultural University, Vietnam 10 The University of The Gambia, The Gambia 11 Duchy Agricultural College, Camborne, UK 12 Centre for Manx Studies, The University of Liverpool, Douglas, Isle of Man, UK 2
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Section 6 Sustainability indicators
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
145
Eco-dynamics of territorial systems: an Emergy Evaluation through time A. C. I. Pizzigallo1, V. Niccolucci1, A. Caldana2, M. Guglielmi2 & N. Marchettini1 1
Department of Chemical and Biosystems Sciences, University of Siena, Italy 2 Provincial Administration of Modena, Italy
Abstract Environmental sustainability requires ongoing care from the public administration to improve people’s quality of life, without jeopardizing the natural resources upon which human activities are founded. The aim of this paper is to present an environmental sustainability assessment of a local territorial system based on a thermodynamic method: Emergy Evaluation. Emergy Evaluation is able to compare the value of human and natural systems on a common basis: the quantity of solar energy directly and indirectly required for a process that represents the memory of all the energy and matter that the biosphere used up to make a product available or to support a territorial system. The use of Emergy enables the calculation of some indicators (such as Environmental Loading Ratio, Emergy Yield Ratio, Emergy Density, Emergy Investment Ratio), in order to give a systemic and holistic picture of the territorial system from a sustainability point of view. By Emergy approach it was possible to distinguish if the territory plays the role of transformer of raw materials or a final consumer of refined materials. The paper proposes and compares two scenarios realized in different years (1997 and 2003), in order to monitor and overview the evolution of a local system. The territorial system analyzed is the Province of Modena which is located in the north of Italy and is characterized by dynamic productive sectors, such as food, steel and ceramic industries, and an important population density (242 inhabitans/km2). Results show an increasing trend of all emergy flows and indicators quite typical for an industrialized country. This is especially due to the higher request for goods and services from outside the boundaries of the system. Nevertheless, the total renewable flow is increased to 7.3% thanks to a higher use of energy from renewable sources, i.e. hydro and co-generation. This is due to the attention that the Administration has devoted in the last ten years. Keywords: time series emergy evaluation, environmental sustainability, thermodynamics, ecodynamics. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070141
146 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
The biosphere and its systems, both ecological and humans, are sustained by steady inflows of energy and matter. In default of these flows, systems cannot build order and their conditions might change in a lower quality state. Emergy Evaluation can evaluate these inflows of energy and matter, monitoring their change in time, to study human systems and their dynamics, from the relationships between human society and the environment. The suitability of Emergy Evaluation in understanding the relationships between humandominated systems and the biosphere is already well-known [1]. Human society feeds on quantities of energy and materials that flow through and within the boundaries of a territorial system; it draws energy directly from the environment or indirectly in the form of goods purchased from the outer economies. Energy inputs with different forms and quality (low or high quality) constantly supply local activities, and productive/transformation processes in order to provide products and services for local communities or as sources for external systems (export). Consequently, using energy flows to study a territorial system seems to be necessary to provide a common value basis for evaluating the flows in the environmental and socioeconomic system [2]. Moreover, by providing a tool (Emergy) able to monitor these energy and matter flows throughout time, it can be useful for the decision-making process as providing valuable analysis to understand the system [3]. The aim of this paper is to present an environmental sustainability assessment of a local territorial system (Province of Modena) based on Emergy Evaluation. The evaluation is based on the comparison of two scenarios collected in two different years, in 1997 and 2003. This approach is still quite rare, but it is really important in order to monitor and overview the evolution of a local system. It is well-known that environmental sustainability requires an ongoing care from public administration to improve the people’s quality of life without compromising the environment. This analysis in time series represents a novelty, because it considers the changes of residents’ behaviour in time, considering mainly the natural resources upon which human activities are founded. Local administration pays attention to the environmental issues: since the ‘90s public authorities of the Province of Modena have begun, within the system they manage, a sustainability pattern, in order to promote and to emphasize the identity of their territory [4]. The knowledge of the system where a community lives is an important step to face the issues of sustainable development. Emergy Evaluation has already been used in the past for different kinds of territorial systems, such as a national system (see e.g. [5,6]), a sub-national system (see e.g. [7]), and a productive/transformation system (see e.g. [8–11]) Starting from the analysis of the well-known Emergy indicators (e.g. Environmental Loading Ratio, Emergy Investment Ratio, Emergy Yield Ratio) and Emergy flows (e.g. renewable, R; non-renewable, N; imported energy and goods, F), we focus our attention on the ability of the system to feed its population, and how the system is able to transform energy and matter flow of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
147
low quality or grade into a higher one for itself or for export to the global economy. Moreover, we will pay attention to the goods and services that are imported and transformed with respect to those imported and consumed within the system. For this reason, we will consider two scenarios for each year of the analysis performed: both these scenarios will compare the total emergy flow that feeds the system with respect to the total emergy flow locally consumed in 1997 and in 2003. Results highlight that the flows through time are increased by about 42%; more deeply, the flow of renewable resources is increased by about 7.3%: this is due to the conspicuous increase of electric power consumption, resulting from local production of renewable sources, such as hydro-electric and cogeneration. In the period 1997-2003, the reliance on the external inflows of energy and matter has increased within the period under analysis; the imported goods and services within the boundaries of the system have increased by about 52%. Conclusions underline how the territorial system is becoming more local energy-consuming over the time considered. Future development of Modena and its dynamics need to be aimed to the optimization of energy use inside the productive texture of the Province.
2
Materials and methods
2.1 The case study: the Province of Modena The Province of Modena, located in the North of Italy, is the territory under study. It occupies an area of 2,690 km2 that is quite heterogeneous with 48% level land, 17% hill and 35% highland. In 2003 the population was estimated to be 651,996 inhabitants with a density of 242 inhabitants/km2, higher than the national average value (190 inhab./km2). The demographic trend shows an annual growth of +1% in the last ten years. Administratively the territory is divided into 47 municipalities. Modena is one of the most industrialized Italian provinces with a dynamic economy based on trade and transformation of raw materials. The main sectors are handmade manufactures, e.g. ceramics, that generate 80% of the total Italian ceramics production, and metalworking. Other minor production sectors are textiles and clothing, biomedicals and disposable, agroalimentary productions, especially devoted to cereals (wheat and maize), soya, green stuff and fruits (quite famous are the cherries of Vignola). Modena is the fourth Italian province in 2003 according to the GPD per person ranking as suggested by the Italian Statistic Bureau [12]. The analysis presented in this paper is based on Emergy Evaluation through time in order to compare the local situation during the period 1997-2003. 2.2 Emergy evaluation Emergy was introduced by H.T. Odum in the ‘80s as a tool for environmental (but not only environmental) accounting [1,2]. On the basis of a thermodynamic WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
148 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI hierarchy of energy, starting from solar energy, Odum’s research has provided a measure of the environmental work necessary to generate an item or a flow. This methodology is organised as a top-down approach, in which systems diagrams of processes are drawn in order to identify and account for all inputs and outputs from processes, that are evaluated on a common basis, i.e. equivalent solar energy [1]. Emergy is defined as the quantity of solar energy directly or indirectly necessary to sustain a given system and its level of organization. The emergy of all inputs to a system is calculated in terms of solar emjoules (sej) by means of suitable conversion factors called transformities (expressed in sej/J), or specific emergy (expressed in sej/unit) [2]. The total emergy necessary for a system (U) is classified into local renewable (R), local non-renewable (N) and imported from outside (F). This last emergy flow, also known as purchased inputs, can be divided into two main flows, the energy imported flow (F1), and the goods and services imported flow (F2). The last one (F2) can be divided in two main flows that represent inputs locally consumed (F2c) and inputs locally transformed (F2t). The first one is referred to the fraction of the total flow that enters the system and it is directly consumed inside by local communities, while the second one includes the fraction that considers the transformation of raw materials into secondary products able to feed on, in a given shares, external systems as services and goods exported. This distinction is quite important because while the former is related to the direct consumption of external inflows by local residents, the latter is related to the purchased inflows transformed inside the system and assigned for export. In this paper we will consider two scenarios for each year of analysis. This different view of the purchased inputs raises three different questions: how much is the total emergy flow that feeds the system (U), how much the territorial system needs and consumes within its boundaries (U’), and how much is transformed and directly exported to external systems (U-U’)? Indeed, we will consider two plans of the Province of Modena: the first one based on the total emergy flow that feeds the whole system (U), and the second one based on the consumed emergy flow of the system (U’). Starting from this distinction, it is possible to calculate a set of sustainability indicators that can be used to assess the relative sustainability of a system: in this context, we measure the effort that natural systems must exert in order to produce an item after it has been consumed [2,5]. The Environmental Loading Ratio (ELR) is the ratio of purchased (F) and non-renewable local emergy (N) to renewable environmental emergy (R). A high value of the ELR indicates a lack of proportion between the use of non-renewable resources with respect to renewable ones, so that environmental cycles are overloaded. The Emergy Yield Ratio (EYR) is the ratio of total emergy (R+N+F) supporting the system to the emergy of the inputs from the economic sector (F) (i.e. not provided for free by the environment). It indicates if a process can compete in supplying a primary energy source for an economy. The Emergy Investment Ratio (EIR) is the emergy of purchased inputs (F) divided by local emergy, both renewable and non-renewable (N+R). A high level of EIR represents a sort of fragility of the system because of its dependence on inputs from other economic systems. The WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
149
Emergy Flow Density (ED) is given by the emergy flow (R+N+F) supporting a system divided by its area. If this ratio is high, a large quantity of emergy is used in a certain area: this can mean a high stress to the environment, and points out the land surface as a limiting factor for future development. Emergy Evaluation in time series was applied to the Province of Modena in order to show a resource-based geography in terms of the use of ecosystems goods and services, and to calculate quali-quantitative indices and ratios for future environmental and economic policies at the local level.
3
Results and discussion
3.1 The Province of Modena in the 2003 The Province of Modena is a high energy-consuming territorial system; its reliance on energy/matters inflows is determined by the high population density, high service industry and, more in general, a high degree of economic sector development. The evaluations of these emergy flows used transformities that were based on the global empower base of 15.83 x1024 sej/yr [13]. Table 1 shows the results of the Province of Modena in 2003, as well as in 1997. The total emergy flow is equal to 6.64 x1022 sej/yr (U), and the consumed emergy flow is equal to 4.88 x1022 sej/yr (U’). This results highlight that about 27% of the total emergy flow that sustains Modena is transformed inside its boundaries and directly transferred as an export outflow to outer systems. These results point out that there is a high use of external resources with respect to those endogenous ones, with a ratio of 10 to 1. Modena and its productive/transformation system are deeply dependent on the external systems in providing raw materials inflows. Moreover, non-renewable flows (99.06%) are higher than the renewable ones (0.94%). Most of the non-renewable resources come from external systems (91.3%), while the local non-renewable emergy flow comes from ore-mining, especially for ceramics and housing productions. The demand for electric power is mainly satisfied by hydroelectrics (52%), partially considered as a renewable energy source, by cogeneration (37%), and by an energy-from-waste plant (10.8%), that determines an important and valuable energy reclaimation, even if it cannot be considered totally as a renewable source. Considering the twofold scenarios in 2003, the ELR increases by about 36%. As shown in table 1, this indicator suggests that inside this territorial system there is a high overexploitation of non-renewable resources with respect to those renewable. The EYR is very close to 1; this result underlines the high fragility of the system, tied to a massive import of energy and matter from outside. The EIR is equal to 7.45, because the total purchased inputs (F) reach the percentage 91.3%. The emergy density is a very high flow equal to 2.47 x1013 sej/yr; this value decreases to 1.81 x1013sej/yr in the second scenario. The emergy per person is equal to 1.02 x1017 sej/inhab.: it is readable as per capita consumption of resources, rather than an availability of resources. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
The Province of Modena emergy flows and indicators for 1997 and 2003. Units
Area Population Item Renewable Resources Non-Renewable Resources Local Resources Imported Emergy (energy inflows) Imported Emergy (goods and services) Total Imported Emergy (purchased inputs) Fraction of Imported Emergy locally transformed Fraction of Imported Emergy locally consumed Total Emergy flow Total Emergy consumed within the region Indicators Empower Density Emergy per Person Environmental Loading Ratio (ELR) Emergy Investment Ratio (EIR) Emergy Yield Ratio (EYR)
Expressions
km2 inhabitants
Quantity 1997 2003 2.69 x 103 2.69 x 103 608,000 652,000
Variation 7.3%
sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr sej / yr
R N L=R+N F1 F2 F = F1 + F2 F2t F2c U=L+F U’ = L + F1 + F2c
5.79 x 1020 5.22 x 1021 5.80 x 1021 7.80 x 1021 3.31 x 1022 4.09 x 1022 8.42 x 1021 2.47 x 1022 4.67 x 1022 3.83 x 1022
6.22 x 1020 5.15 x 1021 5.77 x 1021 1.02 x 1022 5.04 x 1022 6.06 x 1022 1.76 x 1022 3.28 x 1022 6.64 x 1022 4.88 x 1022
7.3% -1.4% -0.5% 30.9% 52.5% 48.1% 109.5% 32.7% 42.1% 27.3%
sej / m2 / yr sej / m2 / yr sej / people / yr sej / people / yr
U / area U’ / area U / people U’ / people (U - R) /R (U’ - R) /R F / (N + R) (F1 + F2c) / (N + R) U/F U’ / F
1.74 x 1013 1.43 x 1013 7.69 x 1016 6.30 x 1016 79.70 65.16 7.05 5.60 0.94 1.14
2.47 x 1013 1.81 x 1013 1.02 x 1017 7.48 x 1016 105.85 77.46 10.51 7.45 0.80 1.10
42.1% 27.3% 32.5% 18.6% 18.9% 18.9% 48.9% 48.9% % %
150 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Table 1:
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
151
3.2 The Province of Modena in 1997 and in 2003: a compared analysis The Province of Modena was already analysed in 1997 by Emergy Evaluation [4]. The increase in the global emergy base of reference to 15.83 x1024 sej/yr [13,14] changes all the unit emergy values which directly and indirectly are derived from the value of global annual empower. For this reason, the analysis performed in 1997 was updated with new transformities, in order to make the comparison between the two analyses. From 1997 to 2003, the total emergy flow (U) is raised by about 42%; more deeply, the renewable flows are raised by about 7.3%. In spite of this result, the share of renewable resources with respect the total emergy flow is decreased from 1.24% in 1997 to 0.94% in 2003. The non-renewable resources are decreased by about 1.4%, because the soil erosion due to ore-mining is diminished. The energy imported flow (F1) is increased by about 31%; this increase is due to the electric power and natural gas consumption that in these years rises at a great rate. There is no change in the weight of the energy purchased inputs with respect to the total emergy flow between 1997 and 2003. The goods and services imported flow (F2) is increased by about 52%. This result determines the increase of the weight of this flow with respect to the total emergy flow (U): it rises from 70% to 75%. The ELR highlights the tendency of the territorial system to use a big amount of non-renewable resources, higher than the renewable ones. The socioeconomic dynamics and the deep increase of goods and services imported contributed to this trend. The EYR has remained steady throughout the period under analysis. The EIR has increased by about 50%. This dynamic is explained by the increased reliance of the territorial system on the external resources. The emergy per person has increased by about 32%; this result is especially determined by the higher population density in 2003 with respect its value in 1997. At the end, we point out that in 1997 the flow U’ is equal to 82% of U, while in 2003 the percentage has decreased to 73%. This means that the Province of Modena has increased its ability to transform the flows directly exported. Although a great amount of the total emergy flow is exported (26% in the 2003), it constitutes an essential source for its economy.
4
Conclusions
This paper presented an environmental sustainability analysis based on Emergy Evaluation. This study aimed to give an important tool to public administration, in order to perform a sustainability pattern of a territorial system. The analysis, performed in time series (1997-2003), represents a novelty for a sub-national system assessment. It demonstrates that overall the Province of Modena continues to be a system highly dependent on external resources. The lower use of local resources, especially renewables, determines a higher environmental loading relative to the national average value. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
152 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI In this time series analysis, we point out that the Province of Modena has increased its ability to transform the flows directly exported. This result is shown by the comparison of the total emergy flow that feeds the Province of Modena (U), and the total emergy flow consumed by the same territorial system. This method supplies sustainability indicators to the policy makers, in the effort to analyse, evaluate, compare and classify the area under study and to suggest alternative ways to the policy makers.
References [1] [2] [3] [4]
[5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]
Odum, H.T. Self organisation, transformity and information. Science, 242, pp. 1132-1139, 1988. Odum, H.T. Environmental Accounting. Emergy and Environmental Decision Making. John Wiley and Sons. New York, 1996. Tilley, D.R., National metabolism and communications technology development in the United States, 1790-2000. Environment and History: 12, 165-90, 2006. Bastianoni, S., Porcelli, M., Tiezzi, E., Sustainable development models for the analysis of the Province of Modena (Italy). Ecosystems and Sustainable Development II, Advances in Ecological Sciences, (eds) Brebbia, C.A., Usó J.L., WIT press, Southampton (UK), pp.185-193, 1999. Ulgiati, S., Odum, H.T., Bastianoni, S., Emergy analysis, environmental loading and sustainability. An emergy analysis of Italy. Ecological Modelling, 73, 1994. Campbell, D.E., Brandt-Williams S.L. and Meisch, M.E.A., Environmental accounting using emergy: evaluation of the state of West Virginia. U.S.EPA, Narragansett, RI, 2005. Pulselli, R.M., Pulselli, F.M., Rustici, M., Emergy accounting of the Province of Siena: Towards a thermodynamic geography for regional studies, Journal of Environmental Management, In Press. Vassallo, P., Bastianoni, S., Beiso, I., Ridolfi R., Fabiano M., Emergy analysis for the environmental sustainability of an inshore fish farming system, Ecological Indicators, 7, 2, Pages 290-298, 2007. Bastianoni, S., Marchettini, N., Panzieri M., Tiezzi E., Sustainability assessment of a farm in the Chianti area (Italy), Journal of Cleaner Production, 9, 4, Pages 365-373, 2001. Pizzigallo, A.C.I., Granai, C., Borsa, S., The joint use of LCA and emergy evaluation for the analysis of two Italian wine farms, Journal of Environmental Management, In Press. Borsa, S., Marchettini, N., Pizzigallo, A.C.I., Pulselli, F.M., Thermodynamic optimisation of the use of natural resources: an agroalimentary production in a Chianti farm (Italy). Ecosystems and Sustainable Development V, Advances in Ecological Sciences, (eds) Tiezzi, E., Brebbia, C.A., Jørgensen, S.E., Almorza Gomar, D., WIT Press, Southampton, UK, pp. 23-30, 2005. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[12]
[13] [14]
153
ISTAT. Atlante della competitività delle province italiane. Ufficio Statistico Camera di Commercio Provincia di Modena, Elaborazione dati Istituto G. Tagliacarne su dati ISTAT, 2003. Available online on http://www.unioncamere.it/Atlante/selreg_frame800.htm Odum H.T., Brown M.T., Brandt-Williams S. Introduction and Global Budget, Folio #1. Handbook of Emergy Evaluation. Center for Environmental Policy, University of Florida, Gainesville, USA, 2000. Odum H.T. Emergy of Global Processes, Folio #2. Handbook of Emergy Evaluation. Center for Environmental Policy, University of Florida, Gainesville, USA, 2000.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
155
An investigation on sustainability indicators of vernacular environments: the case of Cyprus M. Oktay & O. Dincyurek Department of Architecture, Eastern Mediterranean University, North Cyprus
Abstract In general, vernacular environments might be described as the settings which occurred as the products of the socio-cultural, economic and especially local characteristics of the particular region by and for the inhabitants of that region. When these environments are considered, it is obvious that the main considerations of the builders and/or the owners of them were to achieve functionally proper and environmentally appropriate solutions for themselves. In this respect, the way of life, climate, topography, available material and existing building technology might be described as the formative concerns of vernacular environments in general and in Cyprus as well. On the other hand, when housing developments today on the Island of Cyprus and their problems are investigated, it might be easily perceived that most of them fail to fit to the existing environmental conditions because of the lack of consideration given to the ecosystem. As time changes, the needs, requirements and especially the way of life change. Therefore the need to transform and adapt houses, villages, cities etc to the changing and developing conditions is inevitable. However, while performing these changes it is important to investigate the vernacular houses and their settings, which were developed harmoniously with the ecosystem of a particular region and act as sustainability indicators. In brief, this study aims to investigate the particular vernacular houses and settings of Cyprus, to find out the main characteristics of them in the manner of responding to the environmental and cultural values. We intend to list these characteristics in order to provide a vision for future housing developments to achieve environmentally sustainable developments in Cyprus. Keywords: vernacular, environmental values, sustainability, Cyprus. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070151
156 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Cyprus is the third largest island in the Mediterranean Sea. Because of its strategic importance by being located on the crossroads of trade and culture it had been ruled by various civilizations. Hill describes [1] Phoenicians, Assyrians, Egyptians, Persians, Hellenics, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, Franks, Genoveses, Venetians, Ottomans and British as the rulers of the island throughout its history. Accordingly, it is possible to observe a variety in the built environment of the island, which occurs as a result of these settlers. But, there is no need to be an architect to observe the decay and demolishment in the natural and built environment of North Cyprus. Starting from a long time ago, but especially in last decade, the building development in the island has unfortunately destroyed the flora, parallel to this fauna, natural resources and cultural heritages; vernacular environments of the island. The main reasons for these unconsciously realized enterprises might be described as the ‘comfort’, ‘modern’ and luxury exploration of the people, either islanders or foreigners, as clients of these newly constructed areas. Predominantly, clients do not consider the environmental features of the island while they are looking for a new house. Their main demand is to own a ‘new, comfortable, modern looking, luxurious house’. Additionally the construction firms, the number of which cannot be easily counted these days, do not respect the culture and nature of the island while proposing new housing alternatives. Even in some cases imported house prototypes are applied. In short, there is no cultural and environmental respect in the new developments. On the other hand, vernacular environments on the island look like the built clues of how a house can be integrated with the nature, culture and environmental values. There is much to learn from them in this manner. For these reasons, the aim of this study is to investigate vernacular environments and find out their characteristics in order to provide a vision for the future housing developments to achieve environmentally sustainable developments. In this manner, cultural attributes and environmental factors might be described as the two key subjects while studying vernacular contexts in general and in Cyprus as well. Although strong cultural impacts exist on the formation process of the vernacular settings, only the environmental influences are discussed in this study in order to put forward the relation between these environments and the ecosystem of the related setting. Another reason to focus on the environmental issues is the prevalently discussed topics of today: global warming. The climate, topography and building materials used can be listed as the static features of the particular area. Although the topography and available material is same, there are changes in the weather. In this line, saving the resources became the most important duty of human beings. Therefore, instead of neglecting the environmental parameters through the design process and spending recourses for heating/cooling, lighting etc. it is important to consider them and provide an environmentally appropriate solution. On the other hand, when daily routine, economy, social intercourse and these kinds of cultural attributes are considered it is seen that they show WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
157
differentiations and variations due to the change in time. Since these changes will continue through time, it might not be possible or suitable to suggest proper solutions for the future.
2
Vernacular environments of Cyprus
In the Encyclopaedia of Vernacular Architecture of the World, Oliver [2] argues that it may be ill-advised to look for a single definition of vernacular architecture because of its variety. Nevertheless he defines this term as: vernacular architecture includes the dwellings and all other buildings of the people which are usually built by the owner or community in relation with their environmental contexts by using existing resources with traditional technologies. Besides, he adds that the forms of this architecture are built to meet particular needs. They include the values, economies and ways of living of their cultures. Moreover, Brunskill [3] defines the term vernacular architecture as that sort of building which is deliberately permanent rather than temporary, which is traditional rather than academic in its inspiration, which provides for the simple activities of ordinary people, their farms and their simple industrial enterprises, which is strongly related to place, especially through the use of local building materials, but which represents design and building with thought and feeling rather than in a base or strictly utilitarian manner. In general it might be described that, vernacular architecture represents all kinds of buildings that are produced by the native people by utilizing locally available materials with the help of simple tools and existing technology as well as deeply considering the cultural features [4, p. 12]. As can be easily understood from the definitions of ‘vernacular architecture’ it might be said that every country, city and even region as well has its own specific house type varied according to the changing environmental circumstances and cultural characteristics. By considering these, the vernacular architecture of the island could be investigated under two fields [5], which can be subjected as rural and urban vernacular. Although geographical, topographical, climatic parameters and the availability of building materials generally denote the similar characteristics, certain differences are clearly observed in the building activity of both fields [6]. Rural vernacular forms were developed according to the response of the agrarian way of life, available local building materials and climatic conditions. In spite of religious, ethnical and regional differences, the agricultural way of life and economy have been the primary determinants of shared rural values and consequent rural vernacular architecture of the island as Dincyurek [7] mentions. On the other hand, Pulhan [8] states that the traditional urban form of the island was mainly influenced by the prevailing cultures and the imported lifestyles, fig. 1.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
158 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
3
Examples for rural and urban vernacular house, Cyprus.
Sustainability indicators of vernacular environments
Although the vernacular architecture of the Island can be investigated under two topics as rural and urban, only the rural vernacular architecture is going to be discussed in this study as a correct answer to the local and environmental needs. Therefore, the environmental characteristics and the space use of the rural vernacular architecture of North Cyprus are going to be evaluated in order to find the sustainability indicators. 3.1 Climatic appropriateness Since Cyprus is an island located in the Mediterranean Sea, it has a Mediterranean climate, which can be roughly described as summers are hot, dry and long and winters are warm, rainy and short. Even from this short explanation it can be understood that the most important feature that must have precautions taken for is the heat. Therefore, these precautions can be listed as [4, pp. 49–59]: • Courtyard wall: Mostly, courtyards were defined by the high stone/adobe walls to provide privacy for the households and also to assure secure spaces from the strong winds, fig. 2. • Orientation: Orientation of the house is very important aspect for achieving the proper microclimates for spaces. The vernacular houses were mostly oriented by considering the climatic features such as sun and wind factors. Thus, houses were predominantly aligned to the south west-north east direction to provide climatic benefits. • Semi-open spaces, halls: In some cases, semi-open spaces were developed like an inner hall. These inner halls provide climatically comfortable atmosphere both for hot and cold weathers. They offer cool and shadowy WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
159
area for the severe heat of summer and a warm area for the cold winter. In some cases, arcaded semi-open spaces were developed between closed spaces (inside of the house) and open space (courtyard). As a response to climate, these arcaded façades were mainly facing towards south or south-east direction. They act as a barrier and offer shaded outdoor spaces in the summer whereas they prevent wind flow in the winter. These facades blockade the high and undesirable sun rays of summer and let low desirable rays of the winter sun reach through the semi-open space to the inside of the house, fig.3.
Figure 2:
Figure 3: •
High adobe walls of rural vernacular houses.
Section of a rural house showing summer and winter sun [9].
Cross ventilation: There were some attempts to generate cross ventilation. One of them was the addition of the upper ventilation holes on the walls. These holes were mostly small, rectangular or square openings located on higher part of the wall, which are very close to the ceiling. They were generally found on the south-west, north-west and/or north-east façades. Another attempt was making openings on the top part of the doors. These doors can be both outer and inner doors. Air flows inside the house from these rectangular shape openings and circulates. If the inner doors also have openings, this air enters through the inside to the secondary rooms. Additionally, the warm air flows outside with this circulation path. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
160 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Moreover, ventilation was achieved by the organization of windows and doors. These openings were small and predominantly placed on the southeast and north-west façades (or south and north) of the houses, opposite to each other. Other two façades use to keep close as blind walls. In some of the houses which have second floors, openings on the third and fourth façades were observed in the upper floor. Therefore, these upper stories became much cooler than the lower stories. For this reason, they used were as sleeping space during the hot summer nights, fig. 4.
Figure 4:
Examples for some attempts to achieve cross ventilation.
• Building material: Stone and adobe are the available building material for wall construction in general. As a response to the climatic features, thick walls were developed. These thick walls provide cool environment in the house during the summer and keep the inside warm in winter. • Hearth: A hearth was found in almost all of the houses. Sometimes, it is possible to observe more than one hearth in the same house. It was mainly used for both cooking and heating. • Roof: Generally, the predominant type of precipitation on the island is rain. For this reason, the roofs were developed with a slight slope. Rain water could easily be reached to the ground through this slight slope without touching the wall surface. 3.2 Topographic appropriateness The northern part of the island is divided into four natural regions; coastal strips, coastal highlands, inner highlands and central lowlands. Besides, the settlement patterns of the island are nucleated, clustered and compact [5, pp. 24, 90]. Generally, villages were settled on (see [4, pp. 60–68] and fig. 5): • Flat topography, either on the upland or on the lowland. • Sloped topography. The vernacular houses and settlements on the island are formed according to the topographic features of the sites as well. Thus, the form of the houses and the settlement pattern are determined according to these features.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 5:
161
Rural house formation considering different topographies.
3.3 Appropriateness in building material and construction techniques utilization The use of local materials with locally developed construction techniques are common in all vernacular environments. This notion is also mentioned by Aran’s [10] definition as: during the selection of indigenous building materials from natural environment, the builder is primarily concerned with whether they can be easily carried to the building site, if they can be worked by means of tools available to him, and if they can be easily joined together. In this line, commonly used materials in the vernacular houses of Cyprus can be listed as [4, pp. 69–77]: • Earth: When earth is available then the adobe can be developed as a construction technique. • Stone: When stone is accessible then stone masonry evolved. Cut and rubble stone are the types and various methods of stone masonry can be achieved with the utilization of them. • Timber: Timber post and beam forms the structural system in some cases. Windows and doors are made of this material. In some cases, where the timber is prevalent, the floor, stairs (in two-story houses) and balustrades are made of timber. Timber rafters are predominantly seen in the formation of the ceiling as well. • Gypsum: It is used as the finishing material for the roof and in some cases for the walls. Besides, it is used for decoration purposes such as shelves. • Local marble: In some cases used as floor covering material. • Reed, Straw and Mat: Used for the roof. Additionally, load-bearing in the structural system is achieved with stone, earth or both of them. 3.4 Appropriateness in space and usage Dincyurek [5, pp. 11–123] defines the basic components of the rural vernacular houses of the island as living spaces, hall, storage, kitchen, bathroom and toilet, shelter for domestic animals and others, such as well, earth oven, yards. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
162 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The activities in the rural vernacular houses mainly took place in the open air. The rural way of life and appropriate climatic conditions supported the outdoor activities in rural houses, such as cooking, laundering, and leisure [5, p. 111]. For this reason open space, or in other words a courtyard, is very important for the Cypriots. Therefore, instead of grouping spaces like open, semi-open and closed it is preferred to explain them as elements which were located in the open space (courtyard) because of the crucial importance of this space. In this respect the courtyard contains (see [4, pp. 105–121] and fig. 6):
Figure 6:
Rural vernacular house plan, [4, p. 106].
• Main house unit: It has two types of spaces: semi-open and closed. Semiopen space is the transitional space between open and closed spaces. It acts as a circulation path between different rooms. This space was widely used during both hot and cold weathers as a result of its climatically responsive identity. Thus, apart from being a circulation path it is used for several activities such as hosting guests, resting, sleeping, laundering, cooking, eating etc. The closed parts of the main house units are the rooms. These rooms are multifunctional spaces. A room can be used as a living room, kitchen, dining room and bedroom. • Sink, well and oven: Since households use the courtyard for laundering and cooking these elements are essential and widely seen in general. • Auxiliary rooms: These rooms can mainly be classified as animal shelters and storage for agricultural tools and products. They were located in the courtyards either attached to or detached from the main house unit. Besides, in some cases where the kitchen is built separately from the main house unit it can be evaluated as auxiliary room. • Toilet: It is a simple structure which is located away from the main house unit. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
163
• Bath (in some cases): They are only found in Turkish households on the island and have a distinctive dome structure [5, p. 120].
4
Conclusion
The vernacular houses and settlements in Cyprus exhibit harmony with the nature and the culture as a result of the appropriateness in the environmental characteristics and cultural attributes. There are several approaches and precautions in order to provide comfortable climatic conditions for the households. Houses are positioned and settled in relation with the topographic features of the related site as well. Locally available materials are used for constructing these houses. Moreover, when space usages are considered it is easily seen that they are developed in relation with the basic needs and requirements of the users. Open space courtyards, semi-open space halls, orientation of the houses, cross ventilation, building material, hearth and roof might be listed as the main issues affecting human comfort in these spaces. The settlements are developed either on a topography (upland or lowland) or on a slope of mountain skirts. The houses are adapted and developed in conjunction with the characteristics of the land. Since earth, stone, timber, gypsum, local marble, reed and straw are the locally available materials in nature, they are used in the construction of these houses. Therefore, these houses might be perceived as the part of the existing texture of the nature. Houses are arranged and formed according to the needs and the way of life of locals without bearing today’s aesthetic concerns. Functionality is one of the main issues in these houses. Unfortunately, these listed ideas, which can be described as sustainability indicators of vernacular settlements in the island, cannot be used to explain the recently developed houses and settlements on the Island. Mainly, they do not give any concern to relate themselves to the existing nature and culture. These types of houses can be seen in any other countries, which give the idea that they are selected from these foreign places and directly imported to Cyprus. The reflection of the climatic characteristics ends up with an increase in the usage of mechanical (heating/cooling) systems as necessities to achieve climatic comfort in houses. Since these recent houses have no relation with the environment, they do not have any consideration with the site. Instead of fitting to the site it is preferred to destroy the existing texture and make it proper to “the modern house”. Besides, local materials are used only for decorative purposes in these houses. The change in the way of life and needs cannot be neglected. In this respect, the vernacular houses cannot fit to these changing circumstances. The meaningless repetitions of existing forms and unfamiliar and unnecessary additions of foreign patterns are the common characteristics of the recently developed houses on the Island. In summary, it is obvious in this sense that there
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
164 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI is too much to learn from the vernacular environments in order to achieve sustainable developments in relation with the nature and culture of the countries and societies.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
[7] [8]
[9] [10]
Hill Sir G., A History of Cyprus, vol. I, II, III, IV, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1949. Oliver, P., (eds.), Introduction. Encyclopaedia of Vernacular Architecture of the World, vol. 1, Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. xxii-xxiii, 1997. Brunskill, R.W., Traditional Buildings of Britain: An Introduction to Vernacular Architecture, London: Victor Gollancz, pg.24, 1992. Oktay, M., Learning from Karpas Vernacular: Conceptualization of the Karpas Vernacular Architecture, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Dep. of Arch., Eastern Mediterranean University, Famagusta, North Cyprus, 2006. Dincyurek, O., The Rural Vernacular Architecture of Cyprus (Northern), Unpublished PhD’s thesis, Eastern Mediterranean University, Famagusta, 2002. Numan, I., Dincyurek, O., Pulhan, H. “Multi Cultural Influences on the Development of Traditional Urban Fabric of Nicosia.” In Proceedings of Traditional Environments in a New Millennium, defining principles and professional practice, 2nd Inter. Symposium of IAPS-CSBE Amasya, 2001. Dincyurek, O., The Adobe Houses of Mesaoria Region in Cyprus, Vol. 12., (Unpublished Master Thesis), Dept. of Arch., Eastern Mediterranean University, Famagusta, North Cyprus, 1998. Pulhan, H., Influences of the Cultural Factors on Spatial Organization of the Traditional Turkish House of Nicosia, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Dept. of Arch., Eastern Mediterranean University, Famagusta, North Cyprus, 1997. Dinçyürek, Ö., Mallick, F.H. & Numan, I., Cultural and Environmental Values in the Arcaded Mesaorian Houses of Cyprus. Building and Environment, 38, pp. 1463-1473, 2003. Aran, K., Beyond Shelter: Anatolian Indigenous Buildings, Turkey: Tepe Architectural Culture Center, 2000.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
165
Sustainability indicators for the housing market: proposals and applications L. Brandli1, R. Kohler2 & M. A. L. Frandoloso1 1 2
Universidade de Passo Fundo, Brazil Universidade Regional do Noroeste do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil
Abstract In this paper, the concept of sustainability, as applied to the housing market, is discussed and an evaluation methodology of building performance is proposed. Sustainability is presented and evaluated by dividing it in relation to the costs of a building’s life cycle, including the location characteristics, convertibility and flexibility, internal living conditions, environmental capacities in operation and environmental capacities during construction, safety characteristics, comfort and the impact of the building in the neighborhood. The paper presents the sustainability indicators and suggests the manner of collection for each one, in order to characterize the existing sustainability performance. Thus, the result is a checklist for application in the housing market. Depending on the indicator, this can be answered by the dweller, researcher and/or measured with appropriate tools. The indicators were applied to four dwellings in the south of Brazil. The results show indicator values between 55% and 69% sustainability for the studied constructions. Keywords: sustainability, buildings, performance indicators.
1
Introduction
The construction industry has been responsible for significant impacts on the environment. The building’s construction, as well as the infrastructure, consumes energy, from the raw material extraction phase through to the deposit of demolition waste. Baldwin (SPERB, [1]) affirms that environmental questions are becoming increasingly important in the context of sustainable development. As can be seen in the Bulletin CIEF [2], several researchers have already
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070161
166 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI presented methods for the environmental analysis of a building’s life cycle, characterized by the planning phase, construction, maintenance and subsequent demolition, by a process focusing on the consumption of natural resources and waste generation. In this context, this study focuses on buildings within the knowledge area of the researchers. Sustainable construction is a concept that requires the consideration of sustainable objectives in all decision processes during all phases of a buildings’ life cycle, and this research proposes a method to evaluate a building’s sustainability index. The measurement of the building performance is fundamental for sustainable development. The measurements give engineers and architects the necessary information for decision-making and enable the development of improvement actions in the sustainable performance of the built environment. According to Degani and Cardoso [3], “to know the environmental performance of the buildings its necessary analyze the interaction between the activities developed during all its cycle of life and the environment, identifying the possible environmental impacts associated”. In this way, definitions indicative of sustainability are indispensable in the evaluation of the present performance of the housing stock and inform the decisions about the new buildings that will be incorporated into this stock.
2
Evaluation of the sustainability of built environments
Several studies have been completed in an attempt to understand what constitutes the sustainability of built environments, and how this can be evaluated (Porkka and Huovila, [4]). As a result, internationally respected systematic environmental evaluation tools have been developed in Europe, Japan and the USA. Some are intended to be applicable world wide, but they do not take into account powerful local characteristics and problems. The approaches studied here contemplated the vision of sustainable sites, efficient water consumption, energy and atmosphere, materials and natural resources, internal environmental quality of the building and the process of planning and innovation (Porkka and Huovila [4]). Halac and Marchisio [5] propose five sustainability indicators, which according to the authors exceed other rules of environmental evaluation by contemplating the basic concepts of the sustainable development: environmental, social, and economic development. The indicators suggested and applied to the Campus of the Universidad Nacional Córdoba are: 1- Quantic jump and transferability: this indicator refers to the innovative character that future interventions should have in sustainability terms. The quantic jump signifies a substantial change in comparison with traditional focus and the characterization of transferable and replicable tendencies in other intervention areas.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
167
2- Ethics and social equality: this indicator refers the need to consider the ethics norms and the social justice in different kinds of architecture and city planning interventions and in the forecasts for future projects. 3- Ecological quality and energy conservation: this indicator refers to the need for the responsible use of the natural resources over the life cycle of the architectural and city planning interventions. 4- Economic performance and competitiveness: this indicator refers to the need for sustainable improvement being feasible in relation to real conditions and to be compatible to requests and demands over the project life cycle. 5- Contextual answer and esthetic impact: this indicator refers to the need to express a positive and lasting esthetic impact, as well as the innovative use of space and forms.
3 Methodology This study had as an experimental field the housing stock of the Passo Fundo city and Ijuí city (Brazil). Four housing units were selected and evaluated for their sustainability characteristics. The buildings’ characterization was accomplished by using photographic records, analysis of the architectural project and the buildings descriptive records, to establish the solar orientation, specification of constructive materials, openings, and lightning, and local visits for the climate data collection, the specification of the internal construction material.
Figure 1:
(from left to right) Buildings A, B, C located in the city of Passo Fundo and D located in the city of Ijuí.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
168 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
Attributes for the calculation of the sustainability indicators
The variables, or attributes, that translate to the buildings sustainability were proposed from the work presented by Huovila and Koskela [6], which suggests a method to evaluate the sustainability, which can be applied to any kind of stuff or constructions. This method was developed by the VTT Building Technology and adapted by Kohler and Brandli [7], defining the aspects and characteristics inside each attribute category, how the information would be collected and what is value and weight of that evaluation (Table 1). The attributes of sustainability considered were included in an Excel form, “ATRIB. and INDIC.”, and correspond to the following items: -
Legislation, utilized the Director Plan (laws of use and occupation of the urban soil of the city). The indicators data are related to the architectural project of the buildings in the study;
-
Building materials, which correspond to some phases of the construction. The materials utilized in the execution are more common in the local market, with the objective of offering more thermal, acoustic and lighting comfort to the user;
-
Location, evaluation accomplished locally, verifying the conditions in which the building is found;
-
Project Quality, indicators cited are according to the form that shows the Indicator for Evaluation of the Project Quality (SEBRAE), with that, the article, “use/function flexibility” was evaluated according to the building plant. The results correspond to the comparison of the ideal values, with the values performed;
-
Use and Maintenance, concerns the ideal consumption of water and energy by inhabitants (base levels taken from data given by the supply companies). The consumed energy in the building was calculated using apartment light bills in relation to the number of occupants in the apartment. The water usage per head per month was calculated from data collected by the building’s supply. The solid and liquid wastes were evaluated according to its density, based on hydrossanitary projects. The indicators evaluated in loco were: state of repair, durability and security;
-
Environmental Comfort, the indicator of natural lighting and ventilation were evaluated according to the city code of works. The acoustics indicator is related according to the NBR 10152 (ABNT [8]), that sets the levels of compatible noise with the acoustic comfort in diverse environments, however the comfort hygrothermic is related with the form of thermal charge; WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 1: ATTRIBUTE
Legislation
Method for the evaluation of a building’s sustainability. Source: Adapted from Kohler and Brandli [7]. ASPECT/CHARACTERISTIC
VALUATION
occupation percentage; utilization Predicted in the index; permeability percentage; city legislation – frontal recoil; left and right spacing. plan director
MAXIMUM Weight Total VALUE
10 Σ/6
Construction wall; floor; internal and external Records and local finishes; frames; coverage. survey, description material of the finishes. Surrounding characteristics
Low; average; light
Traffic conditions
Light, moderate, intense
Communication
Reasonable, good, excellent
Neighborhood effects
Circulation index; Compactness index; circulation index in garages; Wall density; flexibility of use; functionality.
Light, moderate, intense
Architectural project survey "in loco". They considered values of benchmarking for each index
Cost
1
10
Σ/4 natural illumination; artificial Survey “in loco”, illumination; hygrothermic comfort; thermal charge ventilation. calculate for each dependence, NBR 101552
1
10
Σ/4 Use/mainten- consumption; water consumption; Counts Extract ance quality liquid waste; solid waste; repair facility; durability; security Local survey
Environmental comfort
2
10
Σ/4 Project Quality
1
10 Σ/6
Location
169
2
10
Σ/3 Inherent costs in each stage of the Market's data, life cycle: project; construction; collected by the builder (CUB) and utilization. 10 in the condominium (monthly expense of operation)
1
2 Σ
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
100 %
170 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI -
Cost, the indicators data of the Project and Construction were supplied by the builder, based in values (CUB) of the month and year that the building was finalized. The cost of the building utilization is related to the expenses form, which concerns the monthly cost of the building corresponding to the research period. The values should be digitized in the red cells. To "monthly expenses" and the "cost/m² (common use)", were calculated through the applied formula and of the existing connection with the form of the facts related with the architectural project. This refers to the Project Quality Evaluation Indicators, identified with the red color. The items collected with the decibelimeter are highlighted in green and the buildings costs evaluations are represented by the blue color. To accomplish the calculations in the form "Thermal Charge" it must be brought up to date the values according to the geographical location of the city. The yellow cells are not filled, for the values are grasped automatically from linked calculations in the forms.
5
Results of the sustainability indicator
The sustainability evaluation of the buildings selected for the study showed that building A obtained the sustainability indicator value of 55%, building B obtained 58%, building C obtained 66% and building D obtained a value of 69%. An extract of the evaluation of building D, which obtained the greatest index of sustainability, is shown in Table 2. Table 3 presents the value of the indicator obtained for each attribute. Generally, the sustainability indicator of the buildings researched stayed between 55 and 69%, the ideal being a maximum of 100%. This signifies that the buildings were not planned with respect to maximum sustainability, improvements clearly being made when changes to the standard of the building and to its use have taken place. That means that there is a gradual improvement in the more recent buildings.
6
Final considerations
This research had as its main objective the characterization and measurement of the sustainability concept in civil construction, sub-sector buildings, through the application of an indicator method, considering all phases of the building’s life cycle. The results of the research aimed for a "value" of sustainability for each building analyzed, calculated from the total of all the variables evaluated, applying weightings where necessary. It must be accentuated that is necessary to make a comprehensive study of the analyses about the indicator results and the building’s characteristics. Beyond this, it is important to measure the sustainability and compare it with ideal parameters (benchmarking). These parameters should be found and defined.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 2:
171
Building D sustainability indicators. IDENTIFICAION DATA
SÃO PAULO 1000 m² 5.169,57 m² 7
BUILDING: GROUND AREA: TOTAL BUILDING AREA: PAVEMENT QUANTITY: ATTRIBUTES
LEGISLATION
CONSTRUCTION STUFF
LOCATION
FORESEEN ON LEGISLATION / IDEAL
INDICATIVES
0,00 (solo criado)
5,17
PERMEABILITY PERCENTUAL
≥ 15
12,19
%
0
FRONTAL RECOIL
≥ (0,00m a 4,00m)
5,58
m
10,00
LEFT SPACING WITH OPENING
4,28
5,58
m
10,00
RIGHT SPACING WITH OPENING
4,28
5,58
m
10,00
∑/ 6
50,00
% %
%
10,00 10,00
6 FUROS
FLOOR
PARQUET
INTERNAL FINISHING
REB. PINT. MÉDIA
10,00
EXTERNAL FIISHING
REB. PINT. MÉDIA
10,00
FRAMES
ALUMÍNIO
COVERAGE
LAJE C/ CER.
∑/ 6 Baixa
100,00
%
10,00
TRAFFIC CONDITIONS
Leve
100,00
%
10,00
COMMUNICATION
Bom
66,00
%
6,60
NEIGHBORHOOD EFFECTS
Moderado
66,00
% ∑/ 4
6,60 33,20
7,23
%
4,407 5,599
COMPACTNESS INDEX / UNITY PER PAVEM
100 % (ideal)
55,99
%
CIRCULATION INDEX IN GARAGES
5,6 % (ideal)
5,60
%
0,00
22,00 % (ideal)
4,14
%
1,882
∑/ 5
7,500 19,39
ONSUMPTIO kWh/percapita SYSTEM
WATER CONSUMPTION
ONSUMPTIO SYSTEM
Tradicional
m³/percapita Tradicional
6 FUROS
5,00
%
5,72
m³
8,00
5,00
5,00
%
5,00
%
2,50
25,00
%
2,50
REPAIR FACILITY
Médio
66,00
%
6,60
DURABILITY
Alta
100,00
%
10,00
SECURITY
Alta
% 100,00 ∑/ 9
10,00 55,60
NATURAL ILLUMINATION
Dormitório
1,594
ACOUSTIC (db)
Dormitório
HYGROTHERMIC COMFORT
Dormitório
VENTILATION
Dormitório
0,176
2,00
35,00 - 45,00
52,10
8,00
80
129,43
0,00
1,063
0,176
2,00 12,00
∑/ 4
≤ 0,0057
3,877
5,00
5,00 < 4,00
25,00
0,50 - 0,79
1
6,00 fonte demei
Rede pluvial s/ estação tratamento
CONSTRUCTION (CUB/m²)
8,300
kW
Sem reapro. água cinza e pluvial
UTILIZATION (CUB/m²)
1
125,24
SOLIDS DETRITUS
0,030 - 0,059
16,667
< 77,65
LIQUIDS DETRITUS / reutilization
PROJECT (CUB/m²)
2
7,50
SURROUNDING CHARACTERISTICS
100 % (ideal)
8,33
5,00
10,00 50,00
16,40
1
7,50
WALL
ENERGY CONSUMPTION
COST
WEIGHTOTAL
UTILIZATION INDEX
USE FLEXIBILITY/FUNCIONABILITY
ENVIRONMENTAL COMFORT
63
≤ 75
WALL DENSITY / UNITS PER PAVEMENT
USE AND MAINTENANCE
PERFORMED VALUE
OCCUPATION PERCENTUAL
CIRCULATION INDEX / QUANTITY OF PAVEM9 a 12 PROJECT QUALITY
RUA SÃO PAULO, 63 NÚCLEO CENTRAL/ZONA MISTA RESIDENCIAL 2001
ADRESS ZONE DIVISION: OCCUPATION: YEAR OF CONSTRUCTION:
0,030 - 0,059
0,0300
0,50 - 0,79
0,7600
≤ 0,0057
0,0056 ∑/ 3 ∑
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
2
12,356
1
3,000
2
16,000 68,533
8,00 6,00 10,00 24,00
172 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 3:
Sustainability indicators.
ATTRIBUTE
A
B
C
D
Legislation
7,67
7,33
9,00
10
Construction Materials
13,33
12,50
16,67
16,66
Localization
5,77
4,95
5,80
8,30
Project quality
4,54
4,53
4,37
3,87
Use/maintenance quality
11,60
12,35
12,35
12,35
Ambiental Comfort
3,00
3,00
3,00
3,00
Cost
9,33
13,33
16,67
14,66
TOTAL
55,25%
58,00%
65,86%
68,86%
References [1]
[2] [3] [4] [5]
[6]
[7] [8]
Sperb, M.R., Avaliação de tipologias habitacionais a partir da caracterização de impactos ambientais relacionados a materiais de construção. 2000. Dissertação (Mestrado em Engenharia Civil) – Escola de Engenharia, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, 2001. Bulletin CIEF. Construction Industry Environmental Forum. Disponível em: http://www.cief.org.uk/bulletins.htm Acesso em: 15 July 2005. Degani, C.M. & Cardoso, F.F., A sustentabilidade ao longo do ciclo de vida de edifícios: a importância da etapa de projeto arquitetônico. In: NUTAU 2002 -. Anais… São Paulo, 2002. CD-ROM. Porkka, J. & Huovila, P., Decision Support tools for performance-based building. VTT Building and Transport, 2004. Halac, R. & Marchisio, M., Utilizacion de indicadores de calidad sustentable en el campus de la Universidad Nacional de Cordoba Argentina. I International Conference on Sustainability Measurement and Modelling. ICSMM 06. Barcelona, 2006. Huovila, P. & Koskela, L. Contribution of the Principles of Lean Construction to Meet the Challenges of Sustainable Development. In: Proceedings IGLC- 6 – Sixth Annual Conference of the International Group for Lean Construction. Agosto, 1998, Guarujá, Brazil. Köhler, R. & Brandli, L.L., The sustainability of the civil construction perspective In: CIB W107 Construction in Developing Economies International Symposium, 2006, Santiago do Chile. CIB W107, 2006. Associação Brasileira de Normas Tecnicas. ISO 10152. Níveis de ruído para conforto acústico. Dez, 1987.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 7 Ecological areas studies
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
175
Sustainable requalification of architectural and natural resources: the coastal village of Marzamemi S. De Medici & C. Senia Department of “Analisi, Rappresentazione e Progetto nelle Aree del Mediterraneo”(DARP), Faculty of Architecture of Syracuse, University of Catania, Italy
Abstract In the last ten years, the tourist flow to the Syracuse coast in Sicily has increased, implementing a process of false economic development. This phenomenon produced the collapse of the weak infrastructures network. The south-eastern Sicilian coastal band, in particular, has been spoiled by high human pressure and uncontrolled building activity, due to seasonal tourist flows. The research starts from the analysis of a pilot-case, the coastal village of Marzamemi, in the Pachino area, in order to point out guidelines for sustainable interventions aimed to enhance the natural and architectural resources. Marzamemi is a village developed around an Arab tuna factory built in the XI Century. Massive urbanization phenomena separated the Bog’s area (“Pantano Marzamemi” Site of Community Importance) from the sea, modifying the salina’s ecosystem. The present study aims at environmental requalification through the recovery of the original bog and the integration of the natural and human components of the site, in order to restore a balance in the local ecosystem. The conservation of the landscape as well as of the historical and environmental heritage allows the transformation of the site and its integration with the main tourist routes in Sicily to be carried out. The research is intended to pursue new operating tools to manage and monitor architectural, natural and environmental resources, as well as to help start processes for conservation, exploitation and sustainable development of the whole coastal village. Keywords: requalification, sustainable tourism, architectural and natural resources.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070171
176 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Background
The tourist industry is a complex economic field, an integrated system of activities for infrastructures, production and facilities. In order to guarantee effectiveness and cheapness in management, investors often prefer huge tourist settlings and resorts [1]. This not always accords with the need to safeguard the natural and cultural heritage, producing negative effects on landscape, culture, society and economics of the involved countries. Recently the negative effects of the tourism, that can cause pollution and environmental decay, have been recognised [2]. In fact, until the Sixties the tourism was considered a “smokeless industry”, able to produce clean richness. Today there is a greater care for the environmental risks due to an uncontrolled tourist development, which is expected to produce enhancement of the natural and cultural resources, more than decay. In the last ten years, the tourist flow in the south-eastern coastal band of Sicily has been increasing, implementing a process of false economic development. This phenomenon produced the collapse of the weak infrastructures network. The coastal band of Marzamemi, in particular, has been spoiled by a high human pressure and an uncontrolled building activity close at hand to the sea, due to the seasonal tourist flows. In order to contrast this trend, it is necessary to limit the seasonal tourist concentration and to realize a facilities network able to extend the tourist supply to larger periods of time. The tourist industry can produce persistent effects on the development of other widespread economic fields. For the little coastal villages the tourism is an opportunity for development, that can replace previous local economic activities (fishing and farming). A correct tourist management should guarantee a sustainable use of the available resources on which it depends. Tourism can be sustainable only if it is integrated with the natural, cultural and human environment; it should guarantee enduring good effects on the natural resources, on the bio-diversity and on the resistance to environmental impact. The present study aims to provide tools to control the building and environmental requalification, with the reuse of the ancient farms existing in the area, the recovery of the bog’s area and the integration of the natural and human components of the site, in order to restore a balance in the local ecosystem and to guarantee the sustainable development of the coastal band. The conservation of the historical, landscape and environmental heritage allows to carry out the transformation of the site and its integration with the main tourist routes in Sicily. The research is intended for pursuing new operating tools to manage and monitor building, natural and environmental heritage, as well as to help starting processes for conservation, exploitation and sustainable development of the whole coastal band.
2
The pilot-case: the Marzamemi’s coastal village
The research analyses the Marzamemi’s coastal village [3], located in the southeastern edge of Sicily, on a rocky platform of the coast. The village is near to the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
177
town of Pachino, between the islands of Vendicari and Capo Passero. It was founded in the XI Century by the Arabians, in order to build a tuna factory (fig. 1), that, in time, became one of the most important in Sicily. The history of the village is related first to the tuna factory, and then to fishing. Along the 19th Century and in the beginning of the 20th Century, the village gains commercial importance due to the little seaport: it starts exporting fish, salt produced in the salina of the Marzamemi’s bogs and local products (including grain, cotton and wine). Until the opening of the Noto-Pachino railway in 1935, the trading of consumer goods was performed by sea.
Figure 1:
Building heritage: the Marzamemi’s historical centre.
The environmental and landscape resources are the wealth of the little coastal village. The climate is the main geographic characteristic. From the mid-Nineteenth Century to the mid-Twentieth Century the economy of the village has exploited the Marzamemi’s bog, used as a salina. The salt was used in the tuna line of work and as a good to be sold over the nation. At the end of the 19th Century the Marquis Antonio Starrabba of Rudinì reclaimed the greatest part of the zone and enhanced the cultivation of grapevine. The Rudinì wine plant (fig.2), near the Marzamemi village, in the early 20th Century was accounted as an innovative plant. Near the wine plant, a steam mill was used to produce pasta, to process the sulphur and for the ginning of the cotton. Due to the presence of these activities, many warehouses were built inside and outside the village to store wine, salt and cotton and to work the fish. In the early 20th Century, the end of these productions caused the slump of local economy, and induced inhabitants to engage in fishing of the blue fish. After the closure of the tuna factory, in the 70th of last century, the salina has been deserted and the construction growth around the historical center of the village caused the hindrance of the canals flowing from the bogs into the sea. This produced a serious impairment of the ecosystem’s balance. Starting from the mid-Twentieth Century Marzamemi became the beach of the town of Pachino: in the Morghella district were built wooden beach huts to be rented and a rotunda for dancing on the seaside. After the Second World War the village, characterised by a compact settlement on the northern side of the Marzamemi’s gulf, grew along it, on the narrow coastal band.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
178 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 2:
Building heritage: the unused buildings.
Figure 3:
Natural resources: ecosystem beach/sea.
Due to the massive urbanization and the uncontrolled increase in the tourist flows, the bog’s area in Marzamemi has been deeply transformed. In the eighties and the nineties of the last century the construction boom, consisting mostly in little buildings for holidays, produced a growth northward, above the historical centre, and southward, sparing the bog’s area by the sea. In the last ten years the Marzamemi village underwent an increasing massive bathing tourism, involving both the northern beach of Spinazzola and the southern one of Morghella (fig.3). In the summer the presence of 3,000-4,000 tourists causes serious problems, such as running water shortage, inadequacy of drainage system and chaotic traffic. This produces an excessive burden on the natural, social and cultural balance, impairing the environmental resources. A large part of the local community has an occupation in any activities related with tourism, taking advantage of new employment opportunities and investments. Nevertheless the tourist model developed in this area tends to consume the local natural resources, exposing also the buildings to risk of uncontrolled transformations due to the increasing of the real estate market value. In order to safeguard the bio-diversity through the preservation of the natural environment and, in particular, of the local wild flora and fauna, since 2005 the Marzamemi’s bog was declared Site of Community Importance (SIC), fig. 4. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
179
Though different from national parks, SICs are aimed as well to the main purpose of preserving habitat and natural species threatened by the human exploitation. The 92/43/CEE Habitats Directive founded the ecological network called “Nature 2000”, to preserve the bio-diversity. This network, that includes the areas indicated by the 79/409/CEE Birds Directive too, guarantees an effective protection for the most important European faunistic zones. Unlike parks, the management of a SIC area is more flexible and complex, since human activity is not a priori forbidden.
3
Methodology for a sustainable requalification
The research is aimed to solve both problems regarding the analytical and scientific sphere, through strategic and decisional expertise, and economical and managerial problems related to the need of resources governance. The study is based on a sequence of information and decisional steps, in order to give birth to a general conservation strategy, evaluated from the viewpoint of the intervention sustainability [4]. The proposed methodology involves many multi-disciplinary scientific contributions, in order to define suitable intervention strategies to complex objects such as wide parts of land. These strategies aim to give birth to sustainable development processes, creating a network able to establish relations between natural and architectural resources. The present paper shows the preliminary step of the study, aiming to define guidelines for the intervention, in order to govern the project solutions. The methodology is based on the assumption that the complexity of the system of natural and architectural resources, related to the variety of the politic, economic and social requests, calls for a complex process to define, control and evaluate the alternative solutions of intervention [5, 6]. This process starts from the analysis of the area, to survey the information on the existing resources and the system of relationships among building heritage, natural resources, environmental characteristics and people. The analysis step is intended to define the new activities to be settled and the alternative solutions for the re-use. This step includes a survey of the local settling demand, that will directly involve delegates of the local politic, economic and social stakeholder. At the same time, a study of the natural and building resources has been performed, analysing the conservation status and the enhancement opportunity of each. In particular, the unused buildings have been identified, separately considering the public real estate and the private, in order to define possible scenarios of re-use. The research performed a preliminary study of the natural and artificial components of the site. In fact, the settling of the “system of existing values” allows one to define the frame of bounds to the transformation of the site. The intervention choices are a result of linking the existing bounds with the ones descending from laws. Table 1 synthesize the analysis of the natural and
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
180 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 4:
“Pantano Marzamemi”- SIC.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
181
architectural resources, in order to show the characteristics of the local components that should be correlated into a network. In particular, the table shows the main exposures of the resources and the bounds to the transformation, in order to drive the intervention choices. Table 2 and figure 4 show in detail the Marzamemi’s bog SIC. The systematisation of the surveyed information and the comparison of the local needs with the available resources allow one to define guidelines of intervention. Table 1:
Analysis of the natural and building resources.
NATURAL RESOURCES
RESOURCE
MARZAMEMI’S BOG (“Pantano Marzamemi” SIC – Sites of Community Importance)
BUILDING RESOURCES
Ecosystem BEACH/SEA
MARZAMEMI’S ANCIENT VILLAGE: Regina Margherita’s Square; Principe Villadorata’s Palace; Fishermen’s houses; Mother-church; Tuna factory. RUDINÌ WINE PLANT RAILWAY: Noto-Pachino route; Marzamemi’s Station
EXPOSURE
BOUNDS TO TRANSFORMATION
Urbanization/ Pollution
Landscape/Natural environment value: the site houses natural greenery and marine bogs
Direct causes of change (decay due to the users): a) settlement of beach activities b) urbanization without infrastructures and plants
Ousting of the traditional residents due to the increasing real estate value
Increasing of the decay due to the disuse
Landscape/Natural environment value: the site still keeps components and relationships of the natural ecosystem
Constructive-Cultural value: The existing buildings are built with local materials and construction techniques Historical value: The buildings witness the local productive activities Psychological value: The buildings are a component of the image of the site in the collective unconscious
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
SPECIFIC LAWS European: 92/43/CEE Habitats Directive; 79/409/CEE Birds Directive Italian: implementation law of the Habitats Directive: D.P.R.357/1997 D.P.R.120/2003 Italian: D.Lgs 42/2004 “Law on the cultural heritage and landscape” D.Lgs 156/2006 D.Lgs 157/2006
Italian: D.Lgs 42/2004 “Law on the cultural heritage and landscape” D.Lgs 156/2006 D.Lgs 157/2006
Marzamemi’s bog.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
MARZAMEMI’S BOG (PANTANO MARZAMEMI) - id. code: ITA 090005 [surface: 27 ha] City: Pachino; Province: Siracusa; Region: Sicily Description of the site: Interesting lake coastal environment with geo-botanic value. Strips of natural greenery with psammophyl plants and vines, marine bogs and coastal rocky plants can be observed in the site. Bio-geographical region: Mediterranean region Liable Organization: Ministero dell’Ambiente e della Tutela del Territorio (Ministry of the Environment and the Territory Safeguard)
182 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 2:
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
183
The result of the preliminary step of the process is synthesised in guidelines for the requalification, as follows: To connect the area with the main tourist routes in Sicily, in particular with the cultural sites of the “Val di Noto” and the Vendicari’s natural reserve. To limit the access to the area with private cars, encouraging the use of public transportation (the unused railway should be set in motion to transport tourists). To locate attractive activities in the hinterland, in order to reduce the tourist pressure on the seaside. To limit the construction of private houses, encouraging the building recovery. To re-use unused architectural resources, in order to settle activities able to guarantee the presence of users year-round and to guarantee the safeguard of the local constructive culture. To settle activities able to produce richness and to give birth to occupation opportunities, in order to limit the emigration of unemployed workers. To re-connect the bogs with the sea, re-enabling the canals. A part of the bog’s area can also be used for the herbal purification, in order to reduce the pollution in the summer, and the whole area can be used as a public park. To encourage the performing of local traditional productive activities. Starting from these guidelines, on the basis of the settling demand surveyed in the analysis step, alternative scenarios for an intervention on a large scale will be designed. These scenarios will be graded according to their compatibility degree through multi-criteria evaluations [7], on the basis of their respect of the bounds to the transformation of the existing resources. The evaluation also allows one to define a hierarchy of preferences of the intervention solutions, on the basis of sustainability markers.
4
Conclusion
In most countries of the Mediterranean area, the coastal band is mainly subjected to a high human pressure and to following concentration of settlements, facilities and infrastructures. That is why we investigate the pilot case of Marzamemi, that includes natural and building resources, in order to qualify and quantify the activities to be settled for sustainable development. The establishment of a network of natural and artificial components is pointed to make the relevance of the site more comprehensible for the users (inhabitant and tourists). This is indispensable to involve the users in the “active” safeguard and widely shared development process. The system will also limit the damages already caused by tourism, which is currently careless of the exploited resources as well as of the ecosystem’s balance. A network of the existing resources aimed to the development of the area can also overdraw the good effects of each action, encouraging a virtuous process of cultural, social and economical enhancement. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
184 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
References [1] [2] [3] [4]
[5] [6] [7]
Batra, G.S. & Narinder Kaur, New vistas in reducing the conflicts between tourism and the environment: an environmental audit approach, Managerial Auditing Journal, 11/4, pp. 3-10, 1996. Ko, J.T.G, Assessing Progress of Tourism Sustainability, Annals of Tourism Research, 28(3), pp. 817-820, 2001. Arangio, C., Marzamemi, Ed. Telecas: Siracusa, 2001. Cantone, F., De Medici, S. & Senia, C., Reuse strategies for Sicilian architecture: the case of the “Masseria Maucini”. Proceedings of the CIB W70 International Symposium on the “Changing user demands on buildings. Needs for lifecycle planning and management”, eds. T.I. Haugen, A. Moum & J. Bröchner, The Norvegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU): Trondheim, pp. 85-93, 2006. Higgins, K., Environmental planning fore site development, ed. E&FN Spon: London, 2000. Gangemi, V., (ed). Emergenza ambiente. Teorie e sperimentazioni della progettazione ambientale, Clean: Napoli, 2001. Fusco Girard, L. & Nijkamp, P., Energia, bellezza, partecipazione: la sfida della sostenibilità. Valutazioni integrate tra conservazione e sviluppo, Franco Angeli: Milano, 2005.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
185
Phycological flora diversity in a coastal tropical ecosystem in the Northeast of Brazil S. M. B. Pereira, E. Eskinazi-Leça & M. F. Oliveira-Carvalho Departamento de Biologia, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Botânica (PPGB) da Universidade Federal Rural de Pernambuco, Brazil
Abstract The Santa Cruz Channel is located in the Estuarine Complex of Itamaracá, between the coordinates of 7°34’00’’ – 7°55’16’’S and 34°48’48’’ – 34°54’24’’W, northeast of Brazil. This channel is one of the most important productive areas of the littoral zone in the Pernambuco State. Due to the important environmental conditions, its phycological flora diversity is represented by 252 species, distributed in 108 Bacillariophyta, 80 Rhodophyta, 19 Phaeophyta and 45 Chlorophyta. Some representatives of economic value are found, such as Hypnea musciformis (Wulfen in Jacquin) J. V. Lamour., Solieria filiformis (Kuetz.) P. W. Gabrielson (carrageenan producers), Gracilariopsis lemaneiformis (Bory) Dawson, Acleto et Foldvik. Hydropuntia caudata (J. Agardh) Gurgel & Fredericq and H. cornea (J. Agardh) M. J. Wynne (agar producers). Other species, like H. opuntia (L.) J.V. Lamour, have a high ecological role in the reef bottom. Keywords: microalgae, macroalgae, biodiversity, Bacillariophyta, Chlorophyta, Ochrophyta, Rhodophyta, Santa Cruz channel, Northeast Brazil.
1
Introduction
The biodiversity comprises not only the morphological variations of the organisms but also its genetic and ecological variations [12]. In the sea is found one of the highest biodiversities of the world that is a function of the algae diversity [10]. When considering the representation of different plant groups in the marine flora in terms of numbers of species, it is important to remember that species vary enormously in number of individuals and in the size of those individuals, and that the number of species described in any one group probably WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070181
186 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI depends more on the amount of study that the group has received than on the actual diversity within the group. In the Northeast of Brazil, one of the higher biological diversity areas is the Santa Cruz Channel, located in the littoral of the Pernambuco State, due to the existence of a complex of habitats that promote the settlement of a very diversified fauna and flora [2,14]. The survey of the phycological flora and its distribution in the diverse habitats of the Santa Cruz Channel is the aim of the present paper.
2
The Santa Cruz Channel
It is located in the Estuarine Complex of Itamaracá – Pernambuco (7°34’00’’ – 7°55’16’’S and 34°48’48’’ – 34°54’24’’W), fig. 1, and is distinguished because represents the third estuarine area covered with mangrove, 2,339 ha of the State, functioning as habitat, nursery and spawn place for a variety of economic value species, such as fishes, crustaceans and mollusks. Of all the biomes, the mangrove is one of the most important ecosystems, because it is responsible for a series of products and ecological functions that influence directly the whole area [13].
Figure 1:
The representative map of the Santa Cruz Channel – Pernambuco – Brazil.
The channel acts as a connection between the continent and adjacent marine areas, occurring important physical and chemical mixing processes among them, involving the exportation of dissolved and particulate organic matter produced by the mangroves, and also migrations of juveniles and adults [2]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
187
The continental influence in the channel is caused by the arrival of some rivers being responsible for the maintenance of high levels of dissolved nutrients in the water, notably during the rainy season [6]. The salinity of the Santa Cruz Channel is found between the euryhaline-mesohaline regimes (minimum of 14,4 and maximum of 36,9). It occurs due to the constant entrance of marine waters by the two bars of the channel being, thus, the salinity variation directly related to the tide cycles, rivers discharge and pluviometric precipitation [8]. The adjacent continental shelf is plane and narrow, about 20 miles, finishing in an abrupt descending slope that occurs between 60–80 meters. In great part, the bottom is covered with biogenic carbonatic sediments, constituted mainly by fragments of calcareous Rhodophyta, presented under the form of free, branched or crustose thalli, and also by articles of the Chlorophyta Halimeda. The carbonate contents of these sediments are very elevated, always higher than 90%. In the internal continental shelf, the bottom is constituted by quartzose fluvial sand facies, densely settled by the marine phanerogam Halodule wrightii Aschersson, which individuals serve as live substrate for a diversified animal community, as well as for the epiphytic microflora, where the diatoms are distinguished [5]. Another particular aspect of the continental shelf is the presence of the reefs lines, composed of a coralline structure (corals and crustose calcareous algae) established under a sandstone foundation found, mainly, at the depth between 1,5 and 2 meters, also present, however, up to 10 meters depth [5]. These structures represent very favorable substrata to the development of the macroalgae and constitute important elements to the increase of the area productivity [11, 15, 17, 19]. The phycological material was collected at various time and locations of the Santa Cruz Channel and adjacent areas.
3
The phycological flora
3.1 Bacillariophyta In the Santa Cruz Channel area, the diatoms flora is very diversified, with the species distributed in the following families, tab 1: Biddulphiaceae (16 spp.), Fragilariaceae (15 spp.), Coscinodiscaceae (12 spp.), Naviculaceae (10 spp.), Nitzschiaceae (10 spp.), Chaetoceraceae (09 spp.), Triceratiaceae (08 spp), Rhizosoleniaceae (07 spp.), Surirellaceae (06 spp.), Achnanthaceae (04 spp.), Actinodiscaceae (03 spp.), Eupodiscaceae (03 spp.), Eunotiaceae (03 spp.) and Anaulaceae (02 spp.), tab.1. The floristic structure of the diatoms is characterized by the abundant presence of euryhaline marine species, which correspond to 34 % of the flora and are found along the channel, in the estuaries and adjacent continental shelf. Among these species, the most representatives are: Bellerochea malleus, Coscinodiscus centralis, Chaetoceros curvisetus, Odontella regia and Skeletonema costatum. The freshwater and estuarine components are little significant and found only during the rainy season, when the continental water flow in the channel is more expressive.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
188 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 1:
List of the Bacillariophyta species in Santa Cruz Channel – Pernambuco – Brazil.
Bacillariophyta Coscinodiscaceae Coscinodiscus asteromphalus Ehrenberg C. centralis Ehrenberg C. oculusiridis Ehrenberg C. radiatus Ehrenberg Cyclotella meneghiniana (Kutz.) Brébisson C. stylorum Brigthwell Melosira moniliformis (Muller) Agardh Paralia sulcata (Ehrenberg) Cleve Skeletonema costatum (Greville) Cleve Thalassiosira eccentrica (Ehrenberg) Cleve T. eccentrica var. fasciculada Hustedt T. leptopus (Grunow) Hasle & Fryxell Actinodiscaceae Actinoptychus splendens (Shadbolt)Ralfs A . senarius Ehrenberg Stictodiscus parallelus (Ehrenberg) Grove & Sturt Eupodiscacceae Actinocyclus ehrenbergii Ralfs Aulacodiscus kittonii Arnot Eupodiscus radiatus Barley Rhizosoleniaceae Guinardia delicatula (Cleve) Hasle Guinardia stolterfothii (Peragallo) Hasle Leptocylindrus danicus Cleve Proboscia alata (Bright.) Sundstrom Pseudosolenia calcaravis (Schultze) Sundstron Rhiz. imbricata var. shrubsolei (Cleve) Schroder Rhiz. setigera Brightwell Chaetoceraceae Bacteriastrum delicatulum Cleve B. hyalinum Lauder Chaetoceros coarctatus Lauder Chaetoceros compressus Lauder C. curvisetus Cleve C. didymu Ehrenberg Chaetoceros laevis Leuduger-Fortmorel C. lorenzianus Grunow C. teres Cleve Biddulphiaceae Bellerochea malleus Brigtwell Biddulphia biddulphiana Smith Biddulphia tridens Ehrenberg Cerataulus smithii Ralfs C. turgidus Ehremberg Ditylum brightwellii (West) Grunow Eunotogramma laeve Grunow Heliotheca thamensis (Shrubsole) Ricard Hemiaulus indicus Karsten Isthmia enervis Agardh Lithodesmium undulatum Ehrenberg Odontella longicruris (Greville) Hoban O. mobiliensis (J.W. Bailey) Grunow O. regia (Schutz.) Hendey Palmeria hardmaniana Greville Pleurosira laevis (Ehrenberg) Campère Triceratiaceae Triceratium alltermans Bailey T. antediluviam (Ehrenberg) Grunow T. broeckii Leuduger-Fortmorel T. dubium Brighwell
T. favus Ehrenberg T. contortum (Shadbolt) Greville T. pentacrinus Ehrenberg T. shadboltianum Greville Anaulaceae Terpsinoe americana (Bailey) Ralfs Terpsinoe musica Ehrenberg Fragiliariaceae Asterionellopsis glacialis (Castracane) Round Bleakeleya notata (Grunow) Round Climacosphenia moniligera Ehrenberg Fragilaria capucina Desmazieres & Kutz. Grammatophora angulosa Ehrenberg G. hamulifera Kutzing G. marina (Lyngbye) Kutz. G. oceânica Ehrenberg Podocystis adriatica Kutzing P. americana (Kutz.) Bailey Rhabdonema adriaticum Kutzing R. mirificum W. Smith Striatella unipunctata (Lyngbye) Agardh Thalassionema frauenfeldii Grunow Thalassionema nitzschioides Grunow Eunotiaceae Eunotia arcus Ehrenberg E. glacialis Meister E. pectinalis (Dyllwyn) Rabenhorst Achnanthaceae Achnanthes brevipes Agardh Campyloneis grevillei (W. Smith) Grunow Cocconeis scutellum Ehrenberg Raphoneis amphiceros Ehrenberg Naviculaceae Anomoeoneis serians (Brebisson) Cleve Caloneis bivittata (Pantocsek) Cleve Diploneis bombus Ehrenberg D. vacillans (Schmidt) Cleve Frustulia rhomboides (Ehrenberg) De Toni Gyrosigma balticum (Ehrenberg) Rabenhorst Lyrella lyra Ehrenberg Mastogloia binotata (Grunow) Cleve M. fimbriata (Brightwell) Cleve M. splendida (Gregory) Cleve Nitzschiaceae Bacilaria paxillifer (Muller) Hendey Cylindrotheca closterium (Ehrenberg) Reiman & Lewis Nitzschia circumsuta (Bailey) Grunow N. compressa (Bailey) Boyer N. longíssima (Brébisson & Kutz.) Grunow N. sigma (Kutzing) Wm. Smith N. sigmoidea (Nitzsch) Wm Smith N. vermicularis (Kutzing) Hantzsch Pseudo-nitzschia pungens (Grunow) Hasle Tryblionella granulata (Grunow) D. G. Mann Surirellaceae Campylodiscus biangulatus Greville C. clypeus Ehrenberg C. imperialis Greville Petrodictyon gemma (Ehrenberg) D. G. Mann Surirella fastuosa Ehrenberg S. febigerii Lewis
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
189
3.2 Rhodophyta The Rhodophyta present the higher diversity among the benthic algae, with 80 infra-generic representatives, distributed in 11 Orders, excluding the nonarticulated calcareous algae, tab. 2. Among the Orders, only 3 occur with percentages from 10%, such as Gigartinales (10%), Gracilariales (11%) and Ceramiales (49%). The representatives of the other Orders, all together, reach percentages of 29%. Among the Gigartinales, is pointed out the occurrence of species producers of carrageenan such as Hypnea musciformis, Meristotheca echinocarpum and Solieria filiformes. Among the Gracilariales, the high number of species of Gracilaria deserves attention, as well as the important representatives of agar producers, such as Gracilariopsis lemaneiformis and Hydropuntia caudata. In the area, some researches concerning the quantitative aspects of the economic value species have been realized [3, 18]. Among the Ceramiales, Order with higher occurrence percentage, are found the families Ceramiaceae (12 spp.), Dasyaceae (3spp.), Delesseriaceae (1 sp.) and Rhodomelaceae (24 spp.). In this last family, the genus Bostrychia is pointed out with 5 species, occurring in the mangroves of the area, in formations denominated “Bostrychietum”. Neosiphonia ferulacea is cited of the first time to Pernambuco State. 3.3 Ochrophyta The lower occurrence percentage among the benthic algae is among the Phaeophyceae. This result was already expected, once these organisms are typical of temperate seas, where they reach a maximum development of its thalli. In the tropical seas, the higher Ochrophyta diversity is found among the Dictyotales and, thus, in the Santa Cruz Channel area they reach the higher occurrence values, with 69%, followed by the Fucales (26%) and Ectocarpales (5%). In the Brazilian littoral, the higher specific richness of the Dictyotales is found in the northeast, represented mainly by a variety of species of Dictyopteris, Dictyota and Padina. In Itamaracá, this Order is represented by 13 infra-generic taxa, with the best occurrence verified in the genus Dictyota, with 6 representatives, tab. 2. 3.4 Chlorophyta The Chlorophyta constitute the second higher representation in specific diversity among the marine benthic algae, with 45 infra-generic taxa, classified in the Orders Ulvales, Cladophorales, Bryopsidales and Dasycladales, tab. 2. The higher diversity, at the Order level, is among the Bryopsidales that contribute with 60% of the total Chlorophyta, followed by the Cladophorales, with 27%. Among the representatives of first Order are found those typical of tropical environments, such as Chamaedoris peniculum, Ventricaria ventricosa and Siphonocladus tropicus. The Ulvales and Dasycladales present the lower occurrence percentages, that is, 9% and 4%, respectively. Among the
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
190 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 2:
List of the Rhodophyta, Ochrophyta and Chlorophyta species in Santa Cruz Channel – Pernambuco – Brazil.
Rhodophyta Stylonematales Stylonemataceae Stylonema alsidii (Zanardini) K.M. Drew Erythropeltiales Erythrotrichiaceae Erythrotrichia carnea (Dillwyn) J. Agardh Acrochaetiales Acrochaetiaceae Acrochaetium agardhiellae A. B. Joly & Cord.-Mar. A.hallandicum (Kylin) Hamel A. microscopicum (Nageli ex Kutz.) Nageli Corallinales Corallinaceae Pneophyllum fragile Kutz. Corallina oficinalis L. Jania adhaerens J. V. Lamour. J. rubens (L.) J. V. Lamour. Amphiroa fragilissima (L.) J. V. Lamour. A. rigida J. V. Lamour. Nemaliales Galaxauraceae Dichotomaria marginata (J. Ellis & Sol.) Lamark. Galaxaura sp Tricleocarpa cylindrica (J. Ellis & Sol.) Huisman & Borow Scinaiaceae Scinaia furcellata (Turner) J. Agardh Bonnemaisoniales Bonnemaisoniacae Asparagopsis taxiformis (Delile) Trevis. Ceramiales Stylonematales Stylonemataceae Stylonema alsidii (Zanardini) K.M. Drew Erythropeltiales Erythrotrichiaceae Erythrotrichia carnea (Dillwyn) J. Agardh Acrochaetiales Acrochaetiaceae Acrochaetium agardhiellae A. B. Joly & Cord.-Mar. A.hallandicum (Kylin) Hamel A. microscopicum (Nageli ex Kutz.) Nageli Corallinales Corallinaceae Pneophyllum fragile Kutz. Corallina oficinalis L. Jania adhaerens J. V. Lamour. J. rubens (L.) J. V. Lamour. Amphiroa fragilissima (L.) J. V. Lamour. A. rigida J. V. Lamour. Nemaliales Galaxauraceae Dichotomaria marginata (J. Ellis & Sol.) Lamark. Galaxaura sp Tricleocarpa cylindrica (J. Ellis & Sol.) Huisman & Borow Scinaiaceae Scinaia furcellata (Turner) J. Agardh Bonnemaisoniales Bonnemaisoniacae Asparagopsis taxiformis (Delile) Trevis.
Chondracanthus acicularis (Roth) Fredericq Rhizophyllidaceae Ochtodes secundiramea (Mont.) M. Howe Solieriaceae Agardhiella subulata (C.Agardh) Kraft & M.J. Wynne Meristotheca echinocarpum (Aresch.) Faye & Masuda Solieria filiformes (Kutz.) P.W. Gabrielson Gracilariales Gracilariaceae G. cervicornis (Turner) J. Agardh G. cuneata Aresch G. domingensis (Kutz.) Sond ex Dickie G. isabellana Gurgel, Fredericq & J. N. Norris G. mammillaris (Mont.) M. Howe Gracilaria sp Gracilariopsis lemaneiformis (Bory) Dawson, Acleto et Foldvik Hydropuntia caudata (J. Agardh) Gurgel & Fredericq H. cornea (J. Agardh) M.J. Wynne Halymeniales Halymeniaceae Cryptonemia crenulata (J. Agardh) J. Agardh Grateloupia cuneifolia J. Agardh Halymenia sp Rhodymeniales Rhodymeniaceae Botryocladia occidentalis (Borgesen) Kylin Champiaceae Champia feldmanii Diaz-Pif. Ochrophyta Dictyotales Dictyotaceae Dictyopteris delicatula J. V. Lamour. D. jamaisensis W.R. Taylor D. justii J. V. Lamour. Dicyota bartayresiana J.V. Lamour. D. cervicornis Kutz. D. ciliolata Sond. ex Kutz. D. menstrualis (Hoyt) Schnetter, Hornig & WeberPeukert D. mertensii (Mart.) Kutz. D. pulchella Hornig & Schnetter Lobophora variegata (J. V. Lamour.) Wormersley ex E. C. Oliveira Padina gymnospora (Kutz.) Sond Padina gymnospora (Kutz.) Sond. P. santae-crucis Borgesen Spatoglossum schroederi (C. Agardh) Kutz Chordariaceae Scytosophonaceae Colpomenia sinuosa (Roth) Derbès & Solier Fucales Sargassaceae Sargassum cymosum C. Agardh S. filipendula C. Agardh S. polyceratium Mont. S. vulgare var. vulgare C. Agardh S. vulgare var. foliosissimum (J.V. Lamour.) C. Agardh
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 2: Ceramiales Ceramiaceae Aglaothamnion uruguayense (W. R. Taylor) D. Aponte, D. L. Ballant & J. N. Norris Ceramium brevizonatum H. E Petersen C. diaphanum (Lightf.) Roth C. flaccidum (Kutz.) Ardiss. C. tenerrimum (G. Martens) Okamura Crouania attenuata (C. Agardh) C. Agardh Dohrniella antillarum (W. R. Taylor) Feldm.-Mas Spermothamnion gymnocarpum M. Howe Griffithsia schousboei Mont. Pleonosporium polystichum E. C. Oliveira Spyridia clavata Kutz. S. filamentosa (Wulfen) Harv. In Hook Delesseriaceae Caloglossa leprieurii (Mont.) G. Martens Dasyaceae Dictyurus occidentalis J. Agardh Heterosiphonia crispella (C. Agardh) M. J. Wynne H. crispella var. laxa (Borgesen) M. J. Wynne Rhodomelaceae Acanthophora spicifera (Vahl) Borgesen Amansia multifida J. V. Lamour. Bostrychia calliptera (Mont.) Mont. B. moritziana (Sond ex Kutz.) J. Agardh B. radicans (Mont.) Mont in Orbigny B. scorpioides (Gmelin) Montagne B. tenella (J. V. Lamour.) J. Agardh Bryothamnion seaforthii (Turner) Kutz. B. triquetrum (S.G. Gmel.) M. Howe Chondrophycus papillosus (C. Agardh) Garbary & J. T. Harper C. perforatus (Bory) K. W. Nam Digenea simplex (Wulfen) C. Agardh Dipterosiphonia dentritica (C. Agardh) Schmitz in Eng. & Prantl Halopithys schottii (W. R. Taylor) L. E Phillips & De Clerck Enantiocladia duperreyi (C. Agardh) Falkenb Herphosiphonia secunda (C. Agardh) Ambronn Laurencia sp Lophosiphonia obscura (C. Agardh) Falkenb. in Engler & Prantl Murrayella periclados (C. Agardh) F. Schmitz Neosiphonia ferulacea (Sur ex J. Agardh) S. M. Guimarães & M. T. Fujii Osmundaria obtusiloba (C. Agardh) R. E. Norris Polysiphonia denudata (Dillwyn) Grev. Ex Harv. in Hook P. howei Hollenb. In W. R. taylor P. subtilissima Mont. Gelidiales Galidiaceae Gelidium pusillum (Stach.) Le Jolis Gelidiellaceae Gelidiella acerosa (Forssk.) Feldmann & Hamel Gigartinales Caulacanthaceae Catenella caespitosa (Wither) L.M. Irvine in Parke & Dixon Cystocloniaceae Hypnea musciformis (Wulfen in Jacqu.) J. V. Lamour. H.spinella (C. Agardh) Kutz Gigartinaceae
191
Continued. Chlorophyta UlvalesGaylaria oxysperma K.L. Vinogr. ex Scagel et al. Ulvaceae Ulva lactuca L. U. fasciata Delile Ulva sp Cladophorales Anadymenaceae Anadyomene stellata (Wulfen in Jacq.) C. Agardh Cladophoraceae Chaetomorpha aerea (Dillwyn) Kutz. Chaetomorpha sp Cladophora sp Rhizoclonium africanum Kutz. R. riparium (Roth) Kutz. ex Harv. Siphonocladaceae Chamaedoris peniculum (J. Ellis & Solander) Kuntze Cladophoropsis membanacea (C. Agardh) Borgesen Dictyosphaeria cavernosa (Forrsk.) Borgesen D. versluysii Weber Bosse Siphonocladus tropicus (P.Crouan & Crouan in Schramm & Mazé) J. Agardh Ventricaria ventricosa (J. Agardh) J. L. Olsen & J. A. West Bryopsidales Bryopsidaceae Bryopsis plumosa (Huds.) C. Agardh Derbesia marina (Lyngb.) Solier Codiaceae Codium decorticatum (Woodw.) M. Howe Codium isthmocladum Vickers Caulerpaceae Caulerpa cupressoides var. lycopodium Weber Bosse C. cupressoides var. lycopodium f. disticha Weber Bosse C. fastigiata Mont. C. kempfii A B. Joly & S. M. B. Pereira C. lanuginosa J. Agardh C. prolifera (Forssk) J. V. Lamour. C. prolifera f. obovata (J. Agardh) Weber Bosse C. pusilla (Kutzing) J. Agardh C.racemosa var. occidentalis (J. Agardh) Borgesen C. racemosa var. peltata (J.V.Lamour.) Eubank C. racemosa var. racemosa (Forsskal) J. Agardh C. sertularioides (S.G. Gmel.) M. Howe C. sertularioides f. brevipes (J. Agardh) Sved. C. verticillata J. Agardh Halimedaceae Halimeda discoidea Decne H. incrassata (J. Ellis) J.V. Lamour. H. opuntia (L.) J.V. Lamour. H. tuna (J. Ellis & Sol.) J. V. Lamour Udoteaceae Avrainvillea longicaulis (Kutz.) G. Murray & Boodle Boodleopsis pusilla (Collins) W.R. Taylor, A B. Joly & Bernat. Penicillus capitatus Lam. Udotea flabellum (J. Ellis & Sol.) J.V. Lamour U. occidentalis A. Gepp & E. Gepp. Dasycladales Dasycladaceae Neomeris annulata Dickie Polyphysaceae Acetabularia crenulata J. V. Lamour.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
192 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Bryopsidales, the most representative families are Caulerpaceae and Udoteaceae, with 32% and 11% of occurrence, respectively. The genus Caulerpa, with 7 species, 4 varieties and 3 forms, besides presenting higher diversity among the Chlorophyta, has an important role for the local flora, once some of its representatives, such as Caulerpa cupressoides, C. kempfii, C. prolifera and C. racemosa, form extensive meadows in the infra-littoral region, over which develop a varied fauna and flora [4]. Among the genus Halimeda the species H. opuntia, forms 20 to 30 cm high meadows and provides articles to the biodetrital facies [1, 16]. In the mangroves, were identified the cloroficean Gayralia oxysperma, Rhizoclonium africanum and Cladophoropsis membranacea.
4
Discussion
The floristic algal diversity in coastal ecosystems depends directly on the action of a variety of environmental factors, which will establish the composition, distribution and variation of the populations. These factors can be chemical, such as the salinity and the nutrients availability; physical, as the luminosity and the nature of the substrata; mechanical, such as the waves and the tides; biological, as the grazing, the parasites and epiphytes action, and the human action itself as destroyer and modifier agent of the environment [7]. In the case of the planktonic microalgae, the physical and chemical factors are the most acting in the development and growing of the populations, mentioning the light, the nutrients availability and the salinity as the most acting. Despite these, the macroalgae also need the presence of suitable substrata. In the Santa Cruz Channel area, is assumed to have many factors that act in the algae richness and diversity. First, the environmental conditions have to be considered in the area, represented by transparent and nutrient rich waters, essentials for the photosynthesis; second, the habitat diversity, where a variety of substrata is pointed out, such as mangrove roots and steams in the internal area of the channel and reefs lines in the adjacent continental shelf. These factors act together to promote the establishment of different populations, which organisms are distributed according to the circulation patterns, transparency, salinity and occurrence of rocky and motile substrata. This diversity confirms the ecological importance of the area and intensifies the hypothesis that this place is one of the most productive of the littoral of the State. As a consequence of the phycological diversity, it is natural that also occur a high diversity among the animals, represented by 621 species, constituted by 115 zooplankton species, 134 mollusks, 161 crustaceans, 140 fishes and 71 birds [14]. These animals depend directly on this primary production source, in the various links of the food webs, existing a strong trophic interaction between the phycological flora and the many animals that live in the plankton, benthos and nekton [9]. The ecological characteristics of the phycological flora and its relations with the Santa Cruz Channel and adjacent areas are integrated in a conceptual model presented, fig. 2.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Free O2 production
Solar energy
Organic matter production
Nutrients
Algae Shelter and spawn place for vertebrates and invertebrates
Substratum
Reefs formation
Figure 2:
193
Increase of the faunal biodiversity and of the productivity of the Santa Cruz Channel and adjacent areas
Epiphytes substratum
The conceptual model of the Santa Cruz Channel based on ecological characteristics of the phycological flora.
References [1]
[2]
[3]
[4] [5] [6] [7] [8]
Bandeira-Pedrosa, M.E., Pereira, S.M.B. & Oliveira, E.C., Taxonomy and distribution of the green algal genus Halimeda (Bryopsidales, Chlorophyta) in Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Botânica, 27 (2), pp. 363377, 2004. Eskinazi-Leça, E., Barros, H.M. & Macedo, S.J., Estuarine management in Northeast Brazil: the estuarine complex of Itamaracá (Section 7). Ecosystems and Sustainable Development II, eds. C.A Brebbia & J.L Uso, WIT Press: Southampton, pp. 246-255, 1999. Guedes, E.C., Macedo, J.S.& Pereira, S.M.B., Variação estacional no rendimento de ágar-ágar e carragenano em representantes das Gigartinales (Rhodophyta) no litoral norte do Estado de Pernambuco. Anais da VIII Reunião Nordestina de Botânica, ed. Sociedade de Botânica do Brasil: Recife, pp. 83-98, 1985. Joly, A.B. & Pereira, S.M.B., Caulerpa kempfii Joly et Pereira: a new Caulerpa from Northeastern Brazil. Ciência e Cultura, 27, pp. 417-419, 1974. Kempf, M., Notes on the benthic bionomy of N-NE Brazilian shef. Marine Biology, 5(3), pp. 213-224, 1980. Koening, M.L. & Macedo, S.J., Hydrology and phytoplankton community structure at Itamaracá – Pernambuco (Northeast Brazil). Brazilian Archives of Biology and Technology, 42(4), 381-392, 1999. Lobban, C.S. & Harrison, P.J., Seaweed ecology and Physiology. Cambridge University Press: New York, pp. 1-366, 1994. Medeiros, C.; Macedo, S.J.; Feitosa, F.A.N. & Koening, M.L., Hydrography and phytoplankton biomass and abundance of northeast WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
194 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[9]
[10] [11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18] [19]
Brazilian waters. Archive of Fishery and Marine Research, 47 (2-3), pp. 133-151,1999. Neumann-Leitão, S.L. & Schwamborn, R., Interações tróficas no Canal de Santa Cruz. (Chapter 13). Gerenciamento Participativo de Estuários e Manguezais, eds. H.M Barros, E. Eskinazi-Leça, S.J.Macedo & T.Lima, Editora Universitária: Recife, pp.163-180, 2000. Norton, T. A., Melkonian, M. & Andersen, R., Algal Biodiversity. Phycologia, 35(4), pp. 308-326, 1996. Oliveira-Carvalho, M.F., Pereira, S. M. B. & Zickel, C.S. Florística e distribuição espaço-temporal das clorofíceas bentônicas em trechos recifais do litoral norte do estado de Pernambuco – Brasil. Hoehnea, 30(3), pp. 201-212, 2003. Oliveira, M. C.O., Uso de marcadores moleculares no estudo da biodiversidade. Anais do IV Congresso Latino-Americano de Ficologia, ed. Sociedade Ficológica da América Latina e Caribe: Caxambú, pp.179– 186, 1998. Paranaguá, M.N. & Eskinazi-Leça, E., Ecology of Northeastern Tropical Estuary in Brazil and Technological Perspective in Fishculture. Fish Community Ecology in Estuaries and Coastal Lagoons: Towards and Ecosystem Integration, ed. A. Ýanez-Arancibia, UNAM Press: Mexico (DC), pp. 595-614, 1985. Paranaguá, M.N., Neumann-Leitão, S., Melo, R.L.S., Coelho, P.A., Vasconcelos, A.L. & Oliveira, A.M., Management in Northeast Brazil: Faunal Biodiversity. (Section 2). Ecosystems and Sustainable Development II, eds. C.A Brebbia & J.L Uso, WIT Press: Southampton, pp. 57- 68, 1999. Pereira, B.M. & Eskinazi-Leça, E., Estuarine management in Northeast Brazil: Plant Biodiversity (Section 2). Ecosystems and Sustainable Development II, eds. C.A Brebbia & J.L Uso, WIT Press: Southampton, pp. 70-77, 1999. Pereira, S.M.B., As algas bentônicas. (Chapter 5). Gerenciamento Participativo de Estuários e Manguezais, eds. H.M Barros, E EskinaziLeça, S.J.Macedo & T.Lima, Editora Universitária: Recife, pp.49-66, 2000. Pereira, S.M.B., Oliveira-Carvalho, M.F., Angeiras, J.A.P., BandeiraPedrosa, M.E., Oliveira, N.M.B., Torres, J., Gestinari, L.M.S., Cocentino, A.L.M., Santos, M.D., Nascimento, P.F. & Cavalcanti, D.R., Algas marinhas bentônicas do Estado de Pernambuco. (Capítulo 5) Diagnostico da Biodiversidade de Pernambuco, orgs. M. Tabarelli & J.M.C. Silva, Editora Massangan/SECTMA: Recife, 1, pp. 97-124, 2000. Silva, R.L., Pereira, S.M.B., Oliveira Filho, E.C. & Eston, V. R. Structure of a bed Gracilaria spp. (Rhodophyta) in Northeastern Brazil. Botanica Marina, 30, pp. 517-523,1987. Torres, J.; Pereira, S.M.B. & Yoneshigue-Valentin, Y., Ceramiaceae (Rhodophyta) de áreas recifais do estado de Pernambuco, Brasil. Hoehnea, 31(3), pp. 201-212, 2004. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
195
Protecting open space at multiple scales along Utah’s Wasatch Front E. R. Buteau1, R. J. Lilieholm2 & R. E. Toth1 1
Department of Environment and Society, Utah State University, Logan, USA 2 School of Forest Resources, University of Maine, Orono, USA
Abstract Utah ranks among the nation’s fastest growing states, fueled by high rates of natural population increase and in-migration. During the 1990s, as the loss of open space accelerated, communities enacted policies to control growth and protect open space. In Davis County, a Shorelands Plan was adopted in 2001 to protect important wetlands along the Great Salt Lake (GSL). A year later, a 5-county Wasatch Open Space Plan was developed covering 2.7 million hectares (6.7 million acres). This later Plan identified regionally-significant open space, as well as areas important for the protection of public health, safety, and welfare. Although the Shorelands Plan provided specific land use recommendations and implementation strategies, its limited geographic scope lacked the larger contextual perspective embodied in the Wasatch Plan. Conversely, the spatial detail of the Shorelands Plan provided levels of resolution not possible in the 5-county Wasatch Plan. This paper demonstrates how the specific land use designations of the Shorelands Plan (1:24,000 scale) can be integrated within the larger scale regional connectivity of the Wasatch Plan (1:100,000 scale) in order to arrive at a spatially explicit, county-wide model for open space protection. Keywords: ecosystem services, environmental planning, development, sprawl, urbanization, wetlands protection.
1
Introduction
Mormon settlers entered Utah’s Great Salt Lake (GSL) Valley in 1846 and quickly began transforming the arid, high-desert basin into an ordered agrarian landscape. An elaborate system of reservoirs and irrigation canals fed by WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070191
196 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI abundant snowmelt from the Wasatch Mountains gave life to fields, orchards, and a rapidly growing human population. Over the next 150 years, the Basin’s population grew to over 2 million, and the Valley became a highly-fragmented matrix of urban and suburban development with remnant patches of agricultural lands and natural areas. Today, Utah has one of the nation’s fastest growing populations, with its population of 2.4 million expected to increase 44% by 2030 (U.S. Census Bureau [1]). Such rapid growth has fueled efforts to control growth and protect open space. In Davis County, located north of Salt Lake City, municipalities were concerned about the pace of growth and potential loss of GSL wetlands. In 2001, the County adopted a Shorelands Plan to guide development and protection efforts for the wetlands (Davis County Council of Governments [2]). A year later, a 5-county Wasatch Open Space Plan was prepared for the Wasatch Front Regional Council (WFRC). The Wasatch Plan covered 2.7 million ha (6.7 million ac) and identified regions of future conflict by comparing areas of likely future development with regionally-significant open space, including landscape features important for maintaining public health, safety, and welfare (Toth et al. [3]). The landscape patterns identified in the Wasatch Plan suggested a generalized pattern of open space that, if preserved, enhanced, or restored, could provide ecological and social benefits to residents. Although the Shorelands Plan provides specific land use recommendations and implementation strategies, its limited geographic scope lacked the larger contextual perspective embodied in the Wasatch Plan. Conversely, the spatial detail of the Shorelands Plan provided levels of resolution not possible at the 5county level. To bridge the gap, this paper demonstrates how the specific land use designations of the Shorelands Plan (1:24,000 scale) can be integrated within the larger scale regional connectivity of the Wasatch Plan (1:100,000 scale) in order to arrive at a spatially explicit open space protection strategy. The objectives of this paper are to: (1) identify important open spaces in Davis County, with special reference to riparian corridors as linear features that provide landscape connectivity for both human and ecological systems; (2) characterize current development patterns and identify where pattern changes could be made to preserve and enhance quality of life and ecological function; and (3) estimate the amount of land available for future development under alternative housing densities and levels of open space protection.
2
Study area
Davis County covers a land area of 68,635 ha (169,600 ac) within the GSL Valley (Figure 1). The County is bounded on the east by the Wasatch Mountains and on the west by the GSL. Major protected areas include Antelope Island State Park within the GSL, and the Wasatch National Forest along the County’s eastern edge (Figure 1). As shown in Figure 1, rapid population growth and residential development have altered much of the GSL Valley’s landscape, leaving a sliver of wetlands along the shores of the Lake. Indeed, between 1990 and 2000, the County added WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
197
51,106 new residents – an increase of nearly 30% (U.S. Census Bureau [1]). As a result, the many forested riparian corridors that once linked higher elevation flora and faunal communities with lower elevation wetlands are largely absent in Figure 1. Also at risk are the County’s remaining agricultural soils – some of the most productive in the state. Indeed, Busch et al. [4] estimated that across the broader Wasatch region nearly 44,515 ha (110,000 ac) of prime agricultural soils had been lost to development by the year 2000 – roughly one-third of the region’s total. Based on population projections and settlement patterns, the region was predicted to lose an additional 32,375 ha (80,000 ac) by 2030.
Figure 1:
Developed lands and remaining open space, Davis County, Utah.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
198 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
Methods
Integrating the Shorelands and Wasatch Plans to provide a consistent guide to open space protection required several steps. First, landscape features considered by each plan were described and evaluated in order to develop a comprehensive list of data layers important for open space protection. GIS layers of these land characteristics were then acquired at a 1:24,000 scale when possible. Most data were acquired from the Utah Automated Geographic Reference Center website (AGRC [5]). Some finer-grained soils data were obtained from the on-line National SSURGO database (USDA [6]). Once these GIS data layers were gathered, they were used to spatially depict important open space concepts from both plans. For example, overlaying current development with the open space data layers revealed various patterns of open space across the study area. Depicting Davis County at this higher level of resolution allowed us to delineate streams, irrigation canals, and buffer zones that were indistinguishable at larger scales. The ability to integrate these smaller, linear features with larger patches of open space made it possible to examine open space connectivity in detail. Finally, by looking at future population projections and growth trends, future open space patterns and preservation options could be analyzed.
4
Results
Increasing the resolution of the Davis County portion of the Wasatch Plan to match the Shorelands Plan revealed the county-wide open space pattern depicted in Figure 2. In order to spatially display options for future development under different levels of protection, landscape features important for open space were sequentially removed from the current developable area to create a series of scenarios ranging from low to high open space protection (i.e., Scenarios 1 through 11 in Table 1, respectively). A critical question for Davis County is to decide which, if any, open space layers are suited for protection. For example, the first six data layers that comprise Scenario 6 incorporate many natural landscape features considered critical to both human and natural systems. Scenarios 7 and 8 add the protection of existing agricultural lands – areas important for food security, quality-of-life, community character, economic stability, and wildlife habitat. Comparing Figures 1 and 2 reveals that many east/west corridors linking the Wasatch Mountains to the Valley floor have already been severed. As a result, many patches of remnant vegetation have been isolated, degraded, or destroyed. These connections are not only important in maintaining ecological processes in the County, but serve as well to ensure water quality and quantity (Rudd et al. [7]). Indeed, restoring riparian corridors as part of a larger effort to protect open space is particularly important in Utah, where despite the region’s arid setting, residents use over 1100 liters (300 gallons) of culinary water/person/day – the second highest level of consumption in the U.S. (UDWR [8]). Current population projections of 380,000 County residents by 2020 (Davis County WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
199
Government [9]) and a limited water supply suggest that residents will need to reduce their consumption of culinary water. Indeed, according to the Utah Division of Water Resources [8], the Weber River Basin, which passes through Davis County, will be fully utilized for culinary use by 2040. By 2050, demand is estimated at 442 million m3/year (358,000 acre-feet/year), far surpassing the Weber River’s annual supply of 324 million m3/year (263,000 acre-feet). Even under an assumed 25% reduction in use due to conservation measures, culinary water demand is expected to exceed supply by 27 million m3/year (22,000 acrefeet/year) in 2050.
Figure 2:
Current development and open space protected under Scenario 11 (maximum protection).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
200 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 1:
Scenario 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
5
Area available for development under different levels of open space protection.
Landscape features removed for protection Public lands, water bodies, existing development All above + river and stream buffers All above + flood zones All above + wetland/riparian areas and buffers All above + slopes greater than 30% All above + prime agricultural lands All above + all existing agricultural lands All above + essential wildlife habitat All above + canals, aqueducts, and buffers All above + high liquefaction soils All above + proposed and existing trails
Area remaining for new development (1000 ha) 22.2 100% 15.4 70% 14.2 64% 8.6 39% 6.1 28% 2.6 12% 2.2 10% 2.1 10% 1.9 8% 1.5 7% 1.5 7%
Discussion
The open space protection scenarios described above provide a starting point for assessing the impacts of growth on open space. These scenarios can be combined with population forecasts and assumptions of household size and housing density to estimate the area likely to be developed over the next 20 years. For example, Scenario 1 reveals that there are 22,200 ha (54,857 ac) of developable land currently available in Davis County – an area more than twice the 8,640 ha (21,350 ac) currently developed. Based on existing housing densities and population forecasts, these remaining open spaces will be converted to development by 2055. Davis County has a number of options to control growth and protect open space. For example, between 2000 and 2020, an additional 47,900 households are expected to locate in the County (ECONorthwest [10]). Under the current housing density of 0.12 ha/household (0.30 ac/household) (Table 2), Scenario 5 in Table 1 would meet projected housing needs. If, however, housing densities were to increase and policies favoring community reuse and infill were implemented, additional lands could be protected. For example, increased housing options (e.g., apartments, multiplexes, townhomes, etc.) combined with a moderate increase in single family housing density (i.e., from 0.12 ha to 0.07 ha, or 0.30 ac to 0.17 ac) would save an additional 2,520 ha (6,228 ac) of open space by 2020. Table 2 shows various housing densities and the additional land needed for development by 2020. Taking a longer view, if average lot size was reduced to 0.20 acres/household, the County would have an additional 10,234 ha (25,293 ac) of open space in 2055. The range of housing mixes and lot sizes depicted in Table 2 were developed by Envision Utah [11] based on extensive public input and study. In this paper, we demonstrate the benefit of simply increasing the density of single family housing while keeping the housing mix WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
201
the same as the determined future trend. It is important to note, however, that it would be simple to calculate the additional land area that could be saved for open space under scenarios with higher percentages of apartments and/or townhomes/duplex style housing. Table 2:
Area needed to accommodate 47,900 new households under various housing densities (ECONorthwest [10], Envision Utah [11,12]).
Housing type
Current density
Housing mix (%)
Average lot size by housing type
Weighted average lot size
Additional land developed 2000-2020
na
0.12 ha (0.30 ac)
0.12 ha (0.30 ac)
5,815 ha (14,368 ac)
0.15 ha (0.37 ac) 0.02 ha (0.06 ac) 0.01 ha (0.03 ac)
0.11 ha (0.26 ac)
5,039 ha (12,452 ac)
0.15 ha (0.37 ac) 0.02 ha (0.06 ac) 0.01 ha (0.03 ac)
0.10 ha (0.24 ac)
4,652 ha (11,495 ac)
0.12 ha (0.30 ac) 0.02 ha (0.06 ac) 0.01 ha (0.03 ac)
0.08 ha (0.20 ac)
3,876 ha (9,579 ac)
0.10 ha (0.25 ac) 0.02 ha (0.06 ac) 0.01 ha (0.03 ac)
0.07 ha (0.17 ac)
3,295 ha (8,142 ac)
Current zoning Single family
77%
Apartments
14%
Townhomes/duplexes
9%
Likely future trend Single family
60%
Apartments
26%
Town Townhomes/duplexes Low increase in single family density
14%
Single family
60%
Apartments
26%
Townhomes/duplexes
14%
Moderate increase in single family density Single family
60%
Apartments
26%
Townhomes/duplexes
14%
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
202 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Encouraging higher housing densities to protect open space would allow Davis County to protect and “re-connect” vital east/west corridors linking the Wasatch Mountains to the GSL. Depending on community needs and resources, it may be necessary in some cases to acquire land, day-light streams, or restore riparian areas to re-establish connectivity. Johnson [13] notes the importance of corridors as parts of a larger system of open space patches, explaining that “the long-term value of corridors is highly dependent on the health of the adjacent landscape and large patches of native vegetation.” Johnson continues: “the puzzle can be completed through public and private landowner partnerships, passing on to future generations the rich wildlife and scenic heritage our nation has come to cherish” (Johnson [13]). Rudd et al.’s [7] analysis of connectivity in urban green spaces found that the best alternative for green space connectivity benefiting urban wildlife included a network covering the whole study region with a high degree of connectivity. Their research demonstrated that many links were created through backyard habitat and other urban spaces. These spaces contributed significantly to an overall connected network of open space. According to Rudd et al. [7], “it is important to remember that preserving parks is only part of the solution. Without connections between them, isolation and loss of genetic diversity is imminent.” These findings suggest that it will be important to create and preserve links from the mountains to the valleys, and between all existing open spaces in Davis County.
6
Conclusions
This study integrated large- and small-scale open space plans in order to capture the advantages afforded by each. The result demonstrated how a county-wide pattern of open space could be developed with sufficient detail to allow planners to begin to identify specific strategies and sites for protection. A wide range of options are available to protect open spaces and areas important for public health, safety, and welfare (Fausold and Lilieholm [14]). These range from zoning strategies that reduce lot size and increase housing options, to residential infill and water conservation policies. By bringing different planning scales together and establishing a framework of open space patches and linked corridors, this study, which shows patterns where land use change or preservation is important, can lead to the planning decisions and lifestyle modifications that will have a positive effect on the future of Davis County. In this regard, we identified waterways as vital east/west corridors connecting otherwise isolated patches of open space. Protecting remaining riparian corridors and restoring those lost under past development would provide a host of ecological benefits, including floral, faunal, and aquatic habitat. In addition, these networks of open space could provide recreational opportunities while enhancing water filtration, soil stability, visual aesthetics, and flood control.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
203
Acknowledgements This research was supported in part by the Utah Agricultural Experiment Station and the Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station.
References [1] [2]
[3]
[4]
[5] [6]
[7]
[8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
U.S. Census Bureau. State and County QuickFacts, Online. http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/49000.html Davis County Council of Governments, Davis County Shorelands Comprehensive Land Use Master Plan, Davis County Council of Governments in Partnership with The Nature Conservancy of Utah and Envision Utah: Davis County, UT, 2001. Toth, R.E., Edwards, Jr., T.C., Lilieholm, R.J., Bell, D.L. & Buteau, E.R., Alternative Futures for Utah’s Wasatch Front: Bioregional Planning for the Maintenance and Conservation of Open Space, Final Project Report No. 2002-2, Utah Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, Utah State University: Logan. 2002. Busch, G., Lilieholm, R.J., Toth, R.E. & Edwards, Jr., T.C., Alternative Future Growth Scenarios for Utah’s Wasatch Front: Assessing the Impacts of Development on the Loss of Prime Agricultural Lands, Ecology and the Environment, 81, pp. 247-256, 2005. Utah Automated Geographic Reference Center (AGRC). State of Utah – Division of Information Technology Services, Geographic Data, Online. http://www.agrc.utah.gov U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), Soil Survey Geographic (SSURGO) Database, Natural Resource Conservation Service, National Cartography and Geospatial Center, Online. http://www.ftw.nrcs.usda. gov/ssur_data.html. 2002 Rudd, H., Vala, J. & Schaefer, V., Importance of Backyard Habitat in a Comprehensive Biodiversity Conservation Strategy: A Connectivity Analysis of Urban Green Spaces. Restoration Ecology, 10(2), pp. 368375, 2002. Utah Division of Water Resources (UDWR), The Utah Water Data Book, Online. http://www.water.utah.gov/brochures/wrdatabk.pdf Davis County Government, Population, Online. http://www.co.davis.ut.us/ discoverdavis/demographics/population.cfm ECONorthwest, Greater Wasatch Area Housing Analysis, Prepared for Envision Utah by ECONorthwest with Free and Associates, Online. http://www.envisionutah.org Envision Utah, Urban Planning Tools for Quality Growth, Envision Utah: A Partnership for Quality Growth: Salt Lake City, UT, 2000. Envision Utah, Model Codes and Analysis Tools for Quality Growth, Envision Utah: A Partnership for Quality Growth: Salt Lake City, UT, 2000.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
204 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [13]
[14]
Johnson, C.W., Conservation Corridor Planning at the Landscape Level; Managing for Wildlife Habitat (Part 190). National Biology Handbook, United States Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service, 1999. Fausold, C.F., & Lilieholm, R.J., The Economic Value of Open Space: A Review and Synthesis. Environmental Management, 23(3), pp. 307-320, 1999.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
205
GIS based land use planning and watershed monitoring as tools for sustainable development J. Alonso1, J. Rey1, P. Castro2 & C. Guerra1 1
Escola Superior Agrária, Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo, Mosteiro de Reifóios do Lima, Ponte de Lima, Portugal 2 Escola Superior Tecnologia e Gestão, Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo, Viana do Castelo, Portugal
Abstract The development of GIS based methodologies supports a program for monitoring the territorial dynamics that are occurring in the Estorãos rural watershed (NW Portugal). GIS integrates spatial databases from different research and development projects, with the purpose of understanding: (i) the relationships between land use processes and changes, and environmental management policies; (ii) the extent of environmental impacts due to forest fire as well as extending and intensifying agriculture; and (iii) the influences of natural conditions and human activities on water quality and ecosystem sustainability. The diversity of natural conditions and population dynamics, the (de)forestation, the expansion, density and typology of road networks, the processes of urbanization in the flood plain, and the rising turistic search from external actors, fundament the importance of a GIS based watershed monitoring program. These conditions and processes increase watershed management complexity, namely at a protected wetland in the bottom valley (regional protected landscape, site PTCON00020 of Natura Network 2000, and international RAMSAR site 1613) related to the structure of the landscape, and the quantity and quality of the water resources and the associated biodiversity. The challenges of sustainable land use and the growing quantity and quality of the available spatial databases, allow greater modelling capacity and data accessibility, facilitating public participation, and also aiding and better guiding political and technical actions. Keywords: spatial decision support system, watershed, geographic information systems, landscape planning and management. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070201
206 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Global impacts of earth's human population are reflected in extensive changes in the spatial patterns of land cover and land use [5, 6]. In this sense, land use and landscape dynamics result from the decisions and actions undertaken by humans in the context of: a) natural conditions; b) access to scientific and technological knowledge; c) sectorial and territorial policies; and d) historical constraints. Although Turner et al. [2] didn't include a human component explicitly in the definition of landscape ecology, this work follows a more inclusive view [3] that concerns itself not just with biophysical processes, but also with human actions that shape the landscape [1]. This study pretends an appropriate view of management interventions following the emerging concepts of “integrated land science” [4]. Despite the fact that this term is most often associated with regional or larger scales, land use planning occurs at different spatial scales [7] being applied to smaller scales, e.g. the farm level, where farmers have to plan their land use and cover considering contrasting economic and environmental requirements [7]. Landscape dynamics and land cover processes can be described in a variety of ways, regarding different models and theoretical views. In this sense, researchers are approaching these concerns from a landscape ecology perspective [9] or by using the advances in geographic information science [8, 10]. These different perspectives, when converged, assume an important role in the options made by managers and planners at different scales and information levels. In this context the landscape acts as a focus for integrating human and environmental processes [11]. Monitoring its components and changes is the basis to understanding environmental and human dynamics.
2
Environmental monitoring systems and rural landscapes
Land resource management requires merging of data and knowledge based networks from many different areas of expertise [12]. According to Matthews et al. [13], managers seek more information according to factors regarding economic competition, land use regulation, public awareness, and land ownership changes. This demand for multiple objective land use planning requires more information (in quantity and quality) to allow managers to explore and test different proposals and strategies. In this way, the development of an environmental monitoring system (EMS) can integrate valuable information of processes, structures, and environmental variables, permitting the analysis and modelling of the territory characteristics and dynamics. Rural landscapes in Europe [14], as well as in the NW Portugal, are in both homogenisation and fragmentation processes. These processes can act at multiple scales and have different intensity and dimension. An EMS can then be crucial to identify and understand the occurring changes and their relative dimensions, directing land management options and supporting technical as well as political decisions. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
207
A key factor for sustainability is to develop links across multiple levels of decision making [15, 16]. According to Joerin and Musy [25] in order to achieve the new European approaches to land management, managers need efficient information processing tools and reliable decision support methods. In this context, an EMS should: a) take into account various levels of information; b) produce cohesive and structured data; and c) report consistent results in order to conduce and fundament future decisions. An EMS supported by a GIS, returns an integrated system that can support and increase community commitment in the decision making process, leading to stronger, participated, responsible and well accepted decisions. 2.1 Monitoring rural spaces: building trust in decision processes Rural spaces are diverse and dynamic systems that produce a set of specific environmental issues, and have their own distinct development process. In densely populated Europe, very few pristine natural areas exist [26]. The resulting cultural landscapes [28] aggregate many types of semi natural ecosystems, nevertheless characterized by high species richness, that depend on human interference for their persistence [26]. Complex and pressing environmental problems tend to expose the gaps in technologies, theories and scientific knowledge [29]. In this sense, rural environments have to be faced and analysed carefully in order to prevent rushed conclusions. Monitoring these spaces can be a methodological challenge for both scientists, resulting in better data analysis methods, and technicians, for data collection and quality controls. These agri-environments are a result of cultural and natural heritage, dynamic equilibrium processes, and a set of constantly shifting ecotones. As well as in other spaces, ecological conservation has to be dynamic and has to integrate all local and regional stakeholders, in order to facilitate the negotiation precess. In these changing environments, issues like pollution control, ecosystem services and increasing biodiversity must be addressed by landscape managers [24]. In order to create these dynamic, decision making, environments, farmers and local communities should be included since the beginning of the processes. The benefits of broad-based community involvement in planning and design are widely documented [18], they include enhancing the capacity of citizens to cultivate a stronger sense of commitment, increasing user satisfaction, creating realistic expectations of the outcomes, and building trust (e.g. [19–23]).
3
Methods
A natural unit was selected that can be representative of the NW of the Iberian Peninsula, with the objective of monitoring the causes and consequences of the territorial dynamics. Watershed analysis and management are developing as tools of integrated ecological and economic studies [30], in this sense, a small watershed was selected (fig. 1) in order to facilitate the development of different and diverse studies. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
208 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1: Actors
Processes and steps
Technicians Technical advisers Political decisors Scientists
Figure 2:
Factors Land Characteristics
Technicians Scientists
Technicians Scientists Population Users Decisors
Geographic location of the Estorãos watershed.
Data acquisition characterization
Characterization
Integration analysis
Management participation
Validation quality control
Monitoring follow up
biophysical and human -Information access and quantity -Technical (in)formation -Initial investment
Land Functioning activities and dynamics -Environmental conservation -Teaching and investigation -Economic activities
Communication Edition
Promotion
participation and decision -Target groups -Information channels -Success indicators
Actors, processes, steps and factors in the creation of a GIS for landscape characterization and analysis.
The development of the EMS, merged with an information system, took into account different processes of data capture, integration of different spatial databases, scientific studies, technical reports and proposals, the development and participation in regional forums, and the technical support of management decisions (fig. 2). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
209
The process of data capture was realized over a period of several years and took into account data collected from remote sensing, geographical analysis, field surveys, and specific studies. Information was then integrated into structured spatial databases, permitting the realization of technical and scientific reports. As stated above, these spatial databases are usually constructed with information related to land use and cover, administrative limits, road networks, some other base information (e.g. geology, soils, altimetry), and derived thematic bases. In this specific case this information was complemented with others of particular interest (e.g. soil suitability, water quality networks, protection and environmental interest). Regarding the presence of a protected wetland (regional protected landscape, site PTCON00020 of Natura Network 2000, and international RAMSAR site 1613) at the valley bottom, the geographical information of this particular area was improved in terms of resolution and quantity (table 1). Table 1:
Thematic information used to construct the environmental monitoring system.
Thematic information
Source
Thematic scale
Base Geographic Information Administrative and natural limits Slope Altimetry Hidrography Solar exposures Land elevation models Toponymic information
CMPL & ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC
Watershed Watershed Watershed Watershed Watershed Watershed Watershed
Geology and Soils Geomorphology Soil types Soil suitability Land aptitude Edaphic parameters (pH, condutivity, K2O, Na, etc.)
DRAEDM DRAEDM DRAEDM DRAEDM ESA-IPVC
Watershed Watershed Watershed Watershed Protected area
Land Cover and Habitats Land cover (1958, 1990, 2000, 2002, 2004) Conservation areas MEDWET habitats
ESA-IPVC CMPL CMPL
Watershed Watershed Protected area
CMPL CMPL CMPL
Watershed Protected area Protected area
CMPL, DRAEDM & ESAIPVC
Protected area
ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC ESA-IPVC
Watershed Watershed Watershed
Infrastructures Road network Observation posts Pedestrian courses Land information system Cadastral surveys Complementary information Water quality network Sub-watersheds limits Aquatic biodiversity network CMPL – Câmara Municipal de Ponte de Lima. DRAEDM - Direcção Regional de Agricultura do Entre-Douro e Minho. ESA-IPVC – Escola Superior Agrária - Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo.
The processes of capture and organization of the information were summated to quality controls regarding their compatibility, systematic, structure, and potential end-users. Managing these complex databases corresponds to a critical phase of the process. Questions related to information, technological WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
210 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI interoperability and the consistence of the results and the management of different actors with diverse objectives, are always present and can create bias to the achievement of the project goals.
4
Results
Landscapes can be defined by their structure, function and change [27]. In this study analyses were made to identify each of these features regarding land cover change and its relation to natural conditions (e.g. geology, soils, slope). For the past few years, several studies and development projects were executed leading to a diversified group of results. These results include information about environmental risk evaluation, land planning, decision support systems, natural and demographic characteristics, and specific studies (e.g. [31–34]). These studies helped managers to improve their work by indicating integrated and sustainable alternatives for land and water quality management, environmental dynamic conservation in agricultural areas, creating new social and economic dynamics in rural spaces, and to prevent natural and human risks (e.g. forest fire and other environmental degradation phenomena) [34]. All this data and information had to be organized in a systematic way in order to (fig. 3): a) determine who inputs the data and how is it inputted into the system; b) structure a spatial database that integrates all information making it possible to cross-reference all the data that has been inputted, in order to produce reports and other scientific studies; and c) improve the connections between local stakeholders and reduce the time and the effort to know “when to do” and “where to act”. Inputs
Systematic, evaluation & analysis Environmental risk evaluation
Field surveys
invertebrates soils
Participation, decision & investigation
Land planning
Political actors and other local stakeholders
(...)
Remote sensing
land cover vegetation indices (...)
Scientists
Spatial structured Citizens
Geographical analysis
slope hidrography
Figure 3:
(...)
Natural and demographic characterization
Particular studies
Managers
Method of construction and organization of the environmental monitoring system.
For some environmental and human features, namely land cover, forest fire and erosion risk, and water quality, it was possible to create a set of spatial analyses in order to contribute to a better planning procedure (fig. 4). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
211
Uncultivated areas
Figure 4:
5
Examples of information used in the environmental monitoring system: land use and cover (top), protection areas and planning limits (left bottom), and environmental risks (right bottom).
Discussion
This environmental monitoring system (EMS) has combined a major group of valuable and reliable information, creating a capable spatial decision support system. With this spatial decision support system it was possible to: a) help the management of a regional protected area; by providing tools for improving the interaction between decision makers and the local population and guaranteeing correct and precise descriptions of the local diversity. b) promote the region and this particular area; by publishing reports, books and scientific papers, by participating in forums, conferences and other public events, and by using a web based GIS. c) promote investigation; by integrating multi-disciplinary teams from different institutions and multiobjective studies. d) develop environmental risk assessments; by conducting field experiments and laboratory tests in order to present management alternatives. e) improve the quantity and quality of data at the disposal of decision makers and the society; WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
212 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI by gathering and structuring information into “user friendly” open access spatial databases. f) help implementing policies to improve the quality of life of the general population; by producing technical reports addressing a diversified group of management and planning issues at both regional and local scales. In the future, the objectives of the project should include: a) increasing the quantity and quality of information, by improving spatial resolution and increasing thematic diversity; b) improving the mobility of the information produced; and c) improving public participation in the decision making processes. Integrating GIScience [10, 17] and information technologies in the decision making process, corresponds to a major step to better address land management issues. GIScience includes data collection and measurement, data capture, spatial statistics, data modelling and theories of spatial data, data structures, display, all analytical tools, and institutional, management and ethical issues [17], we can then underline a group of features that can integrate an EMS, empowering the outcome and help structuring all governance issues. In resume, an EMS should have: (i) a concrete group of indicators and goals; (ii) quality control methods, in order to ensure data coherence and liability; (iii) data systematic and structuring procedures; (iv) a group of studies, following data collection; (v) public discussions and reports related to specific as well as broad issues; and (vi) a decision making procedure that can be translated into management options. An EMS should then be a dynamic process that results in concrete measures for land planning and management, facilitating public participation in the decision making processes.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
Brown, D., Aspinall, R. & Bennett, D., Landscape Models and Explanation in Landscape Ecology – a space for generative landscape science. The Professional Geographer, 58(4), pp. 369-382, 2006. Turner, M.G., Gardner, R.H. & O'Neill, R.V., Landscape Ecology in theory and practice: pattern and process, Springer, New York, pp. 421, 2001. Naveh, Z., Landscape Ecology as an emerging branch of human ecosystem science. Advances in Ecological Research, ed. A. MacFadyen & E.D. Ford, Academic Press, New York, pp. 189-237, 1982. Klepeis, P. & Turner B.L., Integrated land history and global change science: the example of the southern Yucatan peninsular region project. Land Use Policy, 18, pp. 239-272, 2001. Southworth, J., Cumming, G., Marsik, M. & Binford, M., Linking spatial and temporal variation at multiple scales in a heterogeneous landscape. The Professional Geographer, 58(4), pp. 406-420, 2006.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13]
[14] [15]
[16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
213
O'Neill, R.V., Hunsaker, C.T., Timmins, S.P., Jackson, B.L., Jones, K.B., Riitters, K.H. & Wickham, J.D., Scale problems in reporting landscape pattern at the regional scale. Landscape Ecology, 11, pp. 169-180, 1996. Bouma, J., The role of soil science in the land use negotiation process. Soil Use and Management, 17, pp. 1-6, 2001. Young, K. & Aspinall, R., Kaleidoscoping landscapes, shifting perspectives. The Professional Geographer, 58(4), pp. 436-447, 2006. Turner, M.G., Landscape Ecology: what is the state of science? Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 36, pp. 319-344, 2005. Goodchild, M.F., Geographic information science and systems for environmental management. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 28, pp. 493-519, 2003. Matthews, R. & Selman, P., Landscape as a focus for integrating human and environmental processes. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 57(2), pp. 199-212, 2006. Zhu, X., Aspinall, R. & Healey, R., ILUDSS: a knowledge-based spatial decision support system for strategic land-use planning. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 15, pp. 279-301, 1996. Matthews, K., Sibbald, A. & Craw, S., Implementation of a spatial decision support system for rural land use planning: integrating geographic information system and environmental models with search and optimisation algorithms. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 23, pp. 9-26, 1999. Jongman, R.H., Homogenisation and fragmentation of the European landscape: ecological consequences and solutions. Landscape and Urban Planning, 58, pp. 211-221, 2002. Hagedorn, K., Arzt, K. & Peters, U., Institutional arrangements for environmental co-operatives: a conceptual framework. Co-operative Arrangements to Cope with Agri-environmental Problems, ed. K. Hagedorn, 2002. Gatzweiler, F., Central and Eastern European agriculture and environment: the challenges of governance at multiple levels. Sociologia Ruralis, 45(3), pp. 139-152, 2005. Goodchild, M.F., Geographical information science. International Journal of Geographical Information Systems, 6(1), pp. 31-45, 1992. Al-Kodnamy, K., Using visualization techniques for enhancing public participation in planning and design: processes, implementation and evaluation. Landscape and Urban Planning, 45, pp. 37-45, 1999. McClure, W., The rural town: designing for growth and sustainability. University of Idaho, Moscow, 1997. Sanoff, H., Designing with community participation. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1978. Sanoff, H., Visual research methods in design. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1991. Towers, G., Building democracy: community architecture in the inner cities. University College London Press, London, 1995. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
214 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [23] [24]
[25] [26]
[27] [28] [29] [30] [31]
[32] [33]
[34]
Smith, H., The citizens guide to planning. Planner's Press, Chicago, 1993. Lant, C., Kraft, S., Beaulieu, J., Bennett, D., Loftus, T. & Nicklow, J., Using GIS-based ecological-economic modeling to evaluate policies affecting agricultural watersheds. Ecological Economics, 55, pp. 467-484, 2005. Joerin, F. & Musy, A., Land management with GIS and multicriteria analysis. International Transactions in Operational Research, 7, pp. 6778, 2000. Kleijn, D., Berendsen, F., Smit, R., Gilissen, N., Smit, J., Brak, B. & Groeneveld, R., Ecological effectiveness of agri-environment schemes in different agricultural landscapes in the Netherlands. Conservation Biology, 18(3), pp. 775-786, 2004. Bell, S., Fonseca, M. & Motten, L., Linking restoration and landscape ecology. Restoration Ecology, 5(4), pp. 318-323, 1997. Price, M. & Lewis, M., The reinvention of cultural geography. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 83(1), pp. 1-17, 1993. Poore, B., The open black box: the role of the end-user in GIS integration. The Canadian Geographer, 47(1), pp. 62-74, 2003. Voinov, A. & Constanza, R., Watershed management and the web. Journal of Environmental Management, 56, pp. 231-245, 1999. Oliveira, D., Alonso, J., Santos, S., Rocha, J. e Guerra, C., Integrated Watershed Planning and Management: Methodology for the assessment of water quality under Eucalyptus (Eucalyptus globulus Labill.); International IUFRO Conference of the WP2.08.03 on Silviculture and Improvement of Eucalypts, 11-15 October, Aveiro, Portugal, 2004. Alonso, J.; Rey, J.; Santos, S.; Paredes, C., Estudos de Casos de Boas Práticas Ambientais na Agricultura, Manual de Agricultura e Ambiente, Sociedade Portuguesa de Inovação, 2005. Costa, L.; Costa, A.; Esteves, A.; Valente, A.; Fernandes, F.; Gonçalves, F.; Rodrigues, G.; Alonso, J.; Araújo, J.; Sousa, M.; Pereira, S.; Mendes, V., Proposta de Plano de Gestão e de Ordenamento da Paisagem Protegida das Lagoas de Bertiandos e S. Pedro D’Arcos. Ponte de Lima, 2001. Alonso, J.; Rey-Graña, J.; Santos, S.; Paredes, C:, e Vasconcelos, I., Sistema de Informação Geográfica para a Paisagem Protegida das Lagoas de Bertiandos e S. Pedro d’Arcos (SIG@PPLBSPA). Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo (IPVC); Escola Superior Agrária de Ponte de Lima (ESAPL), pp. 56, 2002.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
215
Stability and resilience in macrobenthic communities: the role of habitat disturbance C. Guerra1, F. Cobo2, M. González2 & J. Alonso1 1
Escola Superior Agrária, Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo, Portugal 2 Laboratorio de Hidrobioloxía, Dpto. de Bioloxía Animal, Univ. Santiago de Compostela, Spain
Abstract The diversity of fluvial ecosystems allows the detection of various changes in the natural equilibrium. These changes can be related to variations in the composition of the fluvial forest, to the chemical or physical quality of the water, or to alterations of the habitat template. The aim of this study was to understand the resilience of the ecosystem to the degradation of the habitat, resulting from the construction of a highway in a regional protected area. This resilience was measured in terms of the reestablishment of macrobenthic communities. Located at the Estorãos River (sub-watershed of the Lima River, NW Portugal), a set of three sampling stations upstream and downstream from the construction site were monitored for a period of one year, and the invertebrate communities were characterized as well as their ecological and biological traits, and the changes that occurred were classified. The observations made clearly mark the moment of the beginning of the construction process, and from the trait analysis we could discriminate between different types of pressures, namely an increment on sediment loads, and riverbed deterioration. This impact also affected the trophic relations and the food preferences of the invertebrate communities. From the analysis it is apparent that the fact that the construction was done in late winter contributed to the reestablishment of the invertebrate communities, since construction didn't affect their sensitive reproduction period. This fact permitted full recolonization of the construction site in a period of four months, reestablishing the community at the same diversity levels as the reference sites. All these aspects are in agreement with the components being analysed, but they lack information from the longer time series and more ecological components are needed to classify the resilience capacity of this type of ecosystem. Keywords: habitat disturbance, fluvial ecosystem resilience, environmental impact, macroinvertebrate communities. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070211
216 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
During the last century humanization processes and landscape change have increased, resulting in considerable spatial diversity. This poses a methodological challenge when assessing ecosystem vulnerability and resilience, with regard to changes in land use and land cover [1]. In this sense, these changes can lead to an increase in the magnitude and scale of environmental impacts, and enhance the importance and complexity of the evaluation processes. Land-use practices play a major role in the health and dynamics of aquatic ecosystems [29, 33–35]. Rivers are important vectors of stability, for landscape evolution and management, functioning as dispersal corridors for both fauna and flora. In this capacity rivers act as buffers against intense environmental impacts, favoring the recolonization of impaired areas downstream. This downstream recolonization is achieved by active locomotion processes (e.g. drift) [2], which are important ecological phenomenon in running waters [3] for understanding the colonization cycle [4], and evaluating the potential impact of certain actions. In this context discrete events can play a specific role in structuring most ecological communities, particularly stream benthic communities [5]. One of the most common approaches is to track human-induced change by the abundances of indicator taxa [12], and many studies have been conducted to relate different types of disturbance with species traits and community shaping [7]. In this context, the ecological functions of streams can be described by a multitude of general biological traits that reflect the adaptation of species or communities to environmental conditions [8–10, 30]. Community traits can act as indicators of environmental change [14–16], mapping the variations of the ecosystems and their functions. From the analysis of community traits it is possible to predict the health and fitness of an ecosystem, by measuring the environmental impact of human actions. Managers and scientists conducting field assessments of environmental impacts must isolate the effect being studied from the “noise” caused by natural spatial and temporal variation. In this sense, society has agreed many times about the objectives of ecosystem management, but narrowly defined ecosystem management is unlikely to succeed [11], and methodological measures must be implemented.
2 Methodology We have studied a set of three sampling stations located along a small watershed (River Estorãos Watershed) in the NW of Portugal, fig. 1. The watershed is characterized by a great heterogeneity of natural and human conditions [17], leading to diversified land use of the rural landscape. The construction of a major road can then be translated as severe humanization, conditioning the ecological processes in the area. Collections were taken four times from each of the sampling stations over a period of one year, matching the events that occurred before and after the construction took place. This allowed us to point out the differences between the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
217
stations over time, fig. 2. The samples were collected using a kicknet sampler, sampling all the representative habitats within the site area. To better understand the differences that occurred, we used a set of diversity measures (e.g. Simpson’s diversity index) as well as “between sites” metrics and similarity coefficients [20, 31, 32]. This process has the objective of indicating the relationships present in the field but also of evaluating these methods for future use in rapid bio-assessment of construction impaired sites.
Figure 1:
Figure 2:
Geographic location of the surveyed field stations.
Relations between the different scales of analysis, and the chain of events.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
218 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI For a more specific analysis, we used the methods presented by Tachet and other authors [18, 19, 21, 22] to analyze species traits using fussy analysis. This analysis allows us to establish the relationships between habitat loss and community adaptations. These relationships between habitat and biological communities [8, 26–28] have been referred to by Scarsbrook and Townsend [25] as a filtering effect that is reflected at community level.
3
Results
From the analysis of the invertebrate communities, it is also possible to observe a clear break, regarding Tenais station, of the diversity as well as richness levels between November and April, fig. 3. This difference appears to be related to the impacts produced by the construction of the highway, because when the construction process stopped, both values rose to a more stable level. Further analysis of species traits, fig. 4, has also revealed that while the construction site was active, the community changed, becoming more adapted to the resulting conditions of stress. (b)
(a) 1
35 30
0.95
25
0.9
20 0.85
15 0.8
10
0.75
5 0
0.7 November
January Calvário
Figure 3:
April Estorãos
July Tenais
November
January Calvário
April Estorãos
July Tenais
Representation of (a) diversity (Simpson’s diversity index) and (b) richness (total number of taxa) measures.
In this sense, the community changes appear reflected not only on the loss of taxa, but also on community characteristics. Community characteristics related to sediment loads (e.g. food [preference for fine sediment or detritus]) or habitat homogenization (e.g. substrate preferendum [preference for sand or silt]) were incremented. Due to the seasonal timing of construction and the ensuing and rapid reestablishment of the river conditions the colonization process was effective, even though there was a break between April and July, fig. 5. This break in the recolonization process could be the result of a small dam located between Calvário and Estorãos. In winter the dam is open, allowing the passage (drift) of invertebrate fauna. In summer, the floodgates are closed for entertainment purposes (e.g. fluvial beach), and the flow is very limited.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
219
Figure 4:
An example of traits evaluation by frequency analysis: respiration.
Sorensen
Common taxa 25
0.9 0.8
20
0.7 0.6
15
0.5 0.4
10
0.3 0.2
5
0.1 0
0
November
January Calvário-Estorãos
April
July
November
Estorãos-Tenais
January Calvário-Estorãos
April
July
Estorãos-Tenais
Exclusive taxa 14
Calvário vs. Estorãos
18
Estorãos vs. Tenais
16
12
14
10
12
8
10
6
8 6
4
4
2
2
0
0 November
January Calvário
April Estorãos
July
November
January Estorãos
April
July
Tenais
Figure 5: Similarity analysis regarding the comparison of the taxa composition. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
220 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The resulting bottleneck effect increases the homogenization of the downstream communities. In this case homogenization processes result in highly correlated loss of taxa between Estorãos and Tenais.
4
Discussion
Human impact on rivers and fluvial ecosystems is increasing, reducing their ecological function almost to the river channel only. In this sense, rivers are corridors that connect many different ecosystems (e.g. inland waters – sea waters; land ecosystem – water ecosystem) and their functions must be protected. The construction of a major road as well as other heavy constructions, implies severe impacts on habitats and consequently on the stability of biotic communities. These impacts can be reduced by managing the construction time frame and the opening of “ecological windows” that minimize community losses. In many ways, the importance of environmental impact evaluation and management is clear, but the need for a priori studies is often neglected. This study has demonstrated that the disturbance of ecosystems can be identified at various levels and can be related to a broad spectrum of potential sources of impact. In this sense, is important to not only predict the environmental impact of a certain action, but also to monitor the environmental changes and their reflections on the ecosystem. The stability and resilience of the aquatic communities is also affected when major disturbing events take place. In this case, after the construction of the road, the resilience of the community seemed to be sufficient to reestablish stability in a short period of time. Although this was the case, our observations indicate that the events that occurred after the construction, greatly contributed to the loss of stability and equilibrium in the invertebrate communities. In this context, the differences in summer between Calvário and the remaining stations can only be explained by an increment of abiotic pressure, resulting from man's misuse of rivers and fluvial ecosystems. Many studies have pointed the ecological consequences of constructions that covering rivers and riverbeds [6, 13, 23, 24], but can a small, almost temporary dam result in a significant community loss? In this case it seams that the observed loss of taxa, though it increased through the construction of the highway, it was related to the dam’s regulation process during summer. The resulting habitat loss, as well as the interruption of drift processes, had severe consequences to both fauna and flora communities, resulting in poorer and more unstable ecosystems. As we stated earlier, this kind of impact can and should be predicted, since it is a way to propose measures that mitigate effects and adjust construction procedures accordingly.
References [1]
Mücher, C.A., Bunce, R.G., Jongman, R.H., Klijn, J.A., Koomen, A.J., Metzger, M. & Wascher, D.M., Identification and characterization of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[2] [3]
[4] [5]
[6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[11] [12]
[13] [14]
221
environments and landscapes in Europe, Alterra, Wageninger, 119 pp., 2003 Müller, K., Stream drift as a chronobiological phenomenon in running water ecosystems. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. 5, pp. 309323, 1974 Radford, D.S. & Hartland-Rowe, R., A Preliminary Investigation of Bottom Fauna and Invertebrate Drift in an Unregulated and a Regulated Stream in Alberta. The Journal of Applied Ecology. 8(3), pp. 883-903, 1971 Elliott, J.M. & Cornett J., The ecology of Morecambe bay: IV Invertebrate drift into and from the river leven. The Journal of Applied Ecology. 9(1), pp. 195-205, 1972 Resh, V.H., Brown, A.V., Covich, A.P., Gurtz, M.E., Li, H.W., Minshall, G.W., Reice, S.R., Sheldon, A.L., Wallace, J.B & Wissmar, R.C., The role of disturbance in stream ecology. Journal of the North American Benthological Society. 7(4), pp. 433-455, 1988 Armitage, P.D., A quantitative study of the invertebrate fauna of the River Tees below Cow Green Reservoir. Freshwater Biology. 6(3), pp. 229-240, 1976 Fritz, K.M. & Dodds, W.K., Resistance and resilience of macroinvertebrate assemblages to drying and flood in a tallgrass prairie stream system. Hydrobiologia. 527, pp. 99-112, 2004 Townsend, C.R. & Hildrew, A.G., Species traits in relation to a habitat templet for river systems. Freshwater Biology, 31, pp. 265-275, 1994 Statzner, B., Dolédec, S. & Hugueny B., Biological trait composition of European stream invertebrate communities: assessing the effects of various filter types. Ecography. 27, pp. 470-488, 2004 Statzner, B., Bady, P., Dolédec, S. & Schöll, F., Invertebrate traits for the biomonitoring of large European rivers: an initial assessment of trait patterns in least impacted river reaches. Freshwater Biology. 50, pp. 21362161, 2005 Minns, C.K., Kelso, J.R. & Randall, R.G., Detecting the response of fish habitat alterations in freshwater ecosystems. Canadian Journal of Fishery Aquatic Science. 53(1), pp. 403-414, 1996 Karr, J., Rivers as sentinels: using the biology of rivers to guide landscape management (Chapter 20). Ecology and Management of Streams and Rivers in the Pacific Northwest Coastal Ecoregion, ed. Bilby, R.E. & Naiman, R.J., Springer-Verlag, New York, 1998 Boon, P.J., Impact of river regulations on invertebrate communities in the U.K. Regulated Rivers Research and Management. 2(3), pp. 389-409, 1988 Bonada, N., Prat, N., Resh, V.H. & Statzner, B., Development in aquatic insect biomonitoring: a comparative analysis of recent approaches. Annual Reviews of Entomology. 51, pp. 495-523, 2006
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
222 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [15] [16] [17]
[18] [19]
[20] [21]
[22] [23] [24]
[25]
[26] [27] [28]
De Crespin, V. & Usseglio-Polatera, P., Traits of brown trout prey in relation to habitat characteristics and benthic invertebrate communities. Journal of Fish Biology. 60, pp. 687-714, 2002 Mérigoux, S. & Dolédec, S., Hydraulic requirements of stream communities: a case study on invertebrates. Fresh water Biology. 49, pp. 600-613, 2004 Alonso, J.A., Agostinho, J., Gomes, A., Barbosa, P., Santos, S., Rey, J., Paredes, C., Valin, I. & Pereira, C., Os regimes hidrológicos, a hidrografia e o uso da água na bacia do rio Estorão e na Paisagem Protegida das Lagoas de Bertiandos e São Pedro d’Arcos. Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo, Ponte de Lima, pp. 95, 2003 Tachet, H., Richoux, P., Bournaud, M. & Usseglio-Polatera, P., Invertébrés d’eau douce: systématique, biologie, écologie, CNRS Editions, Paris, pp. 553-577, 2000 Usseglio-Polatera, P., Bournaud, M., Richoux, P. & Tachet, H., Biomonitoring through biological traits of benthic macroinvertebrates: how to use species trait databases? Hydrobiologia. 422/423, pp. 153-162, 2000 Sorensen, T., A method of establishing groups of equal amplitude in plant society based on similarity of species content. K. Danske Vidensk. Selk. 5, pp. 1-34, 1948 Dolédec, S., Olivier, J. & Statzner, B., Accurate description of abundance of taxa and their biological traits in stream invertebrate communities: effects of taxonomic and spatial resolution. Archive für Hydrobiologie. 148(1), pp. 25-43, 2000 Chevenet, F., Dolédec, S. & Chessel, D., A fuzzy coding approach for the analysis of long-term ecological data. Freshwater Biology. 47, pp. 295309, 1994 Walker, K.F., A review of the ecological effects of river regulation in Australia. Hydrobiologia. 125(1), pp. 111-129, 1985 Blinn, D.W. & Cole, G.A., Algal and invertebrate biota in the Colorado River: comparison of Pre-and Post-dam conditions. Proc. of the Colorado River ecology and dam management symposium, National Academy Press: New Mexico, pp. 102-123, 1991 Scarsbrook, M.R. & Townsend, C.R., Stream community structure in relation to spatial and temporal variation: a habitat templet study of two contrasting New Zeeland streams. Freshwater Biology. 29, pp. 395-410, 1993 Southwood, T.R., Habitat, the templet for ecological strategies? The Journal of Animal Ecology. 46(2), pp. 336-365, 1977 Southwood, T.R., Tactics, strategies, and templets. Oikos. 52, pp. 3-18, 1988 Townsend, C., The patch dynamics concept of stream community ecology. Journal of the North American Benthological Society. 8(1), pp. 36-50, 1989
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[29]
[30]
[31] [32] [33] [34] [35]
223
Ladson A.R., White, L.J., Doolan, J.A., Finlayson, B.L., Hart, B.T., Lake, P.S. & Tilleard, J.W., Development and testing of an index of stream conditions for waterway management in Australia. Freshwater Biology. 41, pp. 453-468, 1999 Thompson, R. & Townsend, C., A truce with neutral theory: local deterministic factors, species traits and dispersal limitation together determine patterns of diversity in stream invertebrates. Journal of Animal Ecology. 75, pp. 476-484, 2006 Looman, J. & Campbell, J.B., Adaptation of Sorensen’s K (1948) of estimating unit affinities in prairie vegetation. Ecology. 41(3), pp. 409416, 1960 Orth, R.J., Benthic infauna of Eelgrass, Zostera marina, Beds. Chesapeake Science. 14(4), pp. 258-269, 1973 Corkum L.D., Spatial patterns of macroinvertebrate distribution along rivers in eastern delicious forests and grassland biomes. Journal of the North American Benthological Society. 10, pp. 113-116, 1991 Bunn, S.E., Davies, P.M. & Mosisch T.D., Ecosystem measures of river health and their response to riparian and catchment degradation. Freshwater Biology. 41, pp. 333-345, 1999 Johnson, L.B., Richards, C., Host, G.E. & Arthur J.W., Landscape influences on water chemistry in Midwestern stream ecosystems. Freshwater Biology. 37, pp. 113-132, 1997
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Section 8 Energy and the environment
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
227
Technological change dynamic and learning curve theory: application to the global energy system S. Kahouli-Brahmi Université de Nantes, Faculté des sciences économiques et de gestion, Laboratoire d’économie de Nantes (LEN), France
Abstract This paper has two goals. First, to explain the sources of an energy system lock-in. Second, to analyse the factors for creating conditions for technological path-breaking. We present a comparative analysis of the respective contributions of the learning-by-doing, the learning-by-researching and returns to scale effects in explaining the technological change dynamic. Our analysis is articulated within the increasing returns to adoption hypothesis of Arthur (Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events. The economic journal 99, pp. 116-131, 1989) and is based on the learning curve theory. Global time series data of nine energy technologies, conventional and renewable, were collected. Causality analysis and econometric estimation of learning rates and scale effects were performed. The results show that learning effects have been an important source of cost decrease and thus of learning system performance improvements. They also show that the magnitude of the learning effects as well as of the scale effects depend on the technological change stage of energy technologies. Based on major results, some theoretical institutional and policy issues inherent to the energy market barriers and to the conditions for creating technological path-breaking are also assessed and discussed. Keywords: technological change, energy diffusion, two factor learning curve, returns to scale effect, energy lock-in, increasing returns to adoption.
1
Introduction
Environmental policy debates increasingly focus on issues related to energy system dynamics. For a long time, production and consumption processes have been based on fossil fuel resources, mainly oil and coal energy technologies, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070221
228 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI which have serious harmful effects on the environment and the ecosystem equilibrium. Subsequently, the major challenge of the international community is to shift from a conventional energy-based economic system to an environmentally friendly-based economic system in order to avoid ecological system degradation. However, the environmentally friendly technologies correspond to a techno-economic system that is radically different from a conventional techno-economic system in terms of structure, density, needed investment and regulatory practices (Tsoutsos and Stamboulis [1]). Therefore, the transition process which starts with the development and then the deployment of renewable energy innovations, goes beyond the simple substitution of energy technologies’ use and basically corresponds to a change in the path and direction of technological change regimes. Until now, the technological transition process supposed to have started a few decades ago, is still uncompleted and shows some serious hitches related especially to the low competitiveness of the renewable energy technologies and to the established market structure. Indeed, the actual energy system is locked-in to the conventional fossil fuel resources which benefit from important increasing returns to adoption factors (Arthur [2]) and the technological regime shift to renewable energy sources exhibits large systemic barriers. It is, thus, of interest to enhance our understanding of factors that promote the technological regime transition and create favourable conditions for path-breaking. In this paper, we use the learning curve approach to investigate these issues in the framework of technological change dynamics. We perform a comparative analysis between the conventional and the renewable energy systems in order to find out factors likely to explain the path-dependence observed phenomena and to assess conditions for technological regime transition. We are interested in nine learning systems: three correspond to conventional energy technologies and five correspond to renewable energy technologies. In addition to the learning effects, we pay special attention to scale effects estimation since they are shown to be partly responsible for the lock-in of the system. The theoretical framework of the analysis is addressed in Section 2. The model specification and the data description and source are presented in Section 3. The econometric approach and results discussion are given in Section 4. Section 5 gives the major policy directions. Finally, summary and concluding remarks are formulated in Section 6.
2
Theoretical framework of the analysis
The intensive reliance on the conventional energy sources has engendered both environmental degradation and resource scarcity. Therefore, the transition to a non-harmful and sustainable energy system based on renewable energy technologies appears as an urgent challenge. The technological transition or shift concept refers to multilevel changes involved when a given sector is moved from one quasi-stable configuration through a number of phases and translations to another quasi-stable configuration (Jorgensen [3]). Despite the accepted wisdom of the advantages of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
229
the renewable energy technologies and their exhibited performance, the transition to a sustainable energy process still faces considerable challenges due to the radical divergence between the knowledge bases supporting the two technological regimes. The major challenge is therefore to develop a new learning network associated with an appropriate selection environment that focuses on adequate technology policy definition, and is able to enhance the adoption and the diffusion of renewable energy technologies. Nevertheless, the Arthur hypothesis states that the adoption process is stressed by some increasing returns to adoption factors which are learning effects, economies of scale, network externalities, increasing returns of information and technological interdependencies. Once a given technology is produced and adopted for the first time, it acts as a self-reinforcing mechanism and brings about a new technological trajectory supported in the long-run by the possible development of a new selection environment (Arthur [2]). On the basis of the theoretical framework of Arthur [2] about the technological competing models and the increasing returns to adoption hypothesis, we aim to check if there are really increasing returns to adoption mechanisms that have supported the adoption of conventional energy resources to the detriment of renewable energy. We aim also to compare the strength of these self-reinforcing mechanisms between the two technological regimes. In our analysis the learning effects and the returns to scale are considered. Their estimation and their quantification are based on the two factor learning curve (TFLC) modelling.
3
Learning curve modelling
The purpose of the following section is to present the learning curve specification and a preliminary qualitative data description and sources. The derivation of the TFLC functional forms is based on the production and the duality theory and allow for the simultaneous estimation of learning and returns to scale effects. In the following, the learning effects are understood to be related to cumulative production and to knowledge stock accumulations issued from R&D expenditures and are assumed to be estimated separately from the returns to scale. 3.1 Model specification The following description is based on Berndt [4]. To specify the functional form of the learning curve, which will be estimated, we start by characterizing a production function for energy producer using a Cobb-Douglas specification: α
Y = A⋅l k
β
where 0 < α < 1 , 0 < β < 1 and A > 0
(1)
where Y is the output, l is the labour input, k is the capital input, and A is the technological change. The prices are constant. The total cost is:
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
230 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
C = pl l + p k k
(2)
where p l is the labour price, and p k is the capital price. The cost minimization program consists of minimizing the cost subject to the production function: α
min C = pl l + pk k subject to Y = A ⋅ l k
β
(3)
If we replace l and k by their expressions in the total cost expression, we obtain the following expression:
C=A
−
1
1
α +β
α +β
⋅Y
β α +β
⋅ pk
α α +β
⋅ pl
⋅a
(4)
α and β represent the scale effects. The main two drivers of endogenous technological change, represented by the A parameter, are the learning-by-doing and the learning-by-researching. The R&D expenditures (public and private) permit one to define the knowledge stock, which will be calculated on the basis of the following equation: (5) KS = (1 − δ ) ⋅ KS t −1 + R & D t−x
t
where KS t is the knowledge stock at time t , R&D t are the R&D expenditures
at time t , δ is the annual depreciation rate of knowledge stock and x is time lag for adding R&D to the knowledge stock. The A parameter is defined as follows: −λ −δ where λ < 0 and δ < 0 (6) A = Q KS where Q is the cumulative installed capacity and KS is the knowledge stock inherent to public and private R&D investments. λ represents the elasticity of the production to cumulative production and δ the elasticity of the production to cumulative R&D expenditures. The two parameters λ and δ therefore represent respectively the learning-by-doing and learning-by-researching rate. If we substitute equation (6) in equation (4) and if we assume that the inflationary effect of input prices can be taken into account by GNP deflator defined as: β α +β
pk
α α +β
⋅ pl
we obtain the following unitary cost function:
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI λ
δ
c = Q α + β ⋅ KS α + β ⋅Y
1 − (α + β
231
)
α +β
(7)
⋅a
The equation that will be econometrically estimated is: 1 − (α + β λ δ lo g c = lo g Q + lo g K S + α + β α + β α +β + lo g a + ε
)
lo g Y
(8) where ε is an error term, c is the per-unit cost, Q is the cumulative installed capacity, KS is the knowledge stock and Y is the power generation capacity. The learning elasticities and the scale effects are calculated as follows:
α+β =
1 − (α + β ) 1 , λ = (α + β ) ⋅ µ where ψ = α+β 1 +ψ
where
µ=
λ α+β
and δ = (α + β ) ⋅η where η =
δ α +β
(9)
3.2 Data description and sources Global time series data of nine energy technologies were collected. They correspond to eleven regions in the world. Energy technologies were divided into two groups: conventional energy technologies and renewable energy technologies. These two groups are also divided into three subsamples: mature, evolving and emerging technologies. The database was provided by the LEPIIEPE (Laboratoire Economie Politique de l'Intégration Internationale et du Développement-Energie et Politique de l’Environnement), Grenoble, France. It has been assembled in the framework of the SAPIENT project (DG Research) to inform the world energy simulation model, POLES. The time series data needed for our estimations are provided in table 1. Table 1: Data Power generation capacities Government energy R&D Public knowledge stock Business energy R&D Business knowledge stock Energy technology cost
Description of the data. Unity MWe M$98 M$98 M$98 M$98 $90/kWe
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
232 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
Econometric estimation and result interpretation
The results of the econometric estimations are addressed in tables 2 and 3. We have used the OLS multiple regression technique. Detection of the possible multicolinearity among the explanatory variables was undertaken based on the Klein [5] test and the correlation matrix shows that no evidence of multicolinearity is suggested. The homescedasticity and independence conditions of residuals are also checked out. For the homescedasticity condition, we based on the White [6] test and for the residuals autocorrelation are based on Durbin and Watson [7] test, Breusch [8] test and Godfrey [9] test. The results show that the residuals are independent and identically distributed for all regressions. For the first two estimations, which correspond to coal and lignite conventional technologies, the returns to scale range from 1.076 to 1.326 meaning that increasing returns to scale may have taken place at the outset of the development and the deployment stages. The increasing returns to scale imply that these technologies face less market constraints in terms of commercial and expansion opportunities. They are, therefore, expected to be mature technologies that have reached the large diffusion stage. However, despite their mainstream position and widespread use, these technologies have low learning-by-doing and learning-by-researching rates, which range respectively from 2.80% to 5.32% and from 1.25% to 3.08%. This is not surprising since they are situated in the last stage of a technological change process: the diffusion and large scale deployment stage. Indeed, when technology is mature a doubling of cumulative installed capacity can take place rather slowly and over a long period of time due to saturation effects meaning that the prospects of cost reduction become limited. In the same way, the R&D expenditures flows are the least important compared to flows corresponding to an energy technology in the first stage of technological development process and, as consequence, the knowledge stock increases slowly. Table 2: Index 1. Y 2. Q 3. SC
Learning and scale effects estimation for conventional energy technologies. CCT -0.246 (-9.340)*** -0.060 (-3.668)*** -0.013 (-4.990)*** 1.326 -0.079 -0.018 5.32% 1.25% 0.967 31
LCT -0.071 (-2.972)*** -0.039 (-2.348)** -0.042 (-2.510)** 1.076 -0.041 -0.045 2.80% 3.08% 0.959 31
RS LBD elasticity LBS elasticity LBD rate LBS rate Adjusted R2 Number of observations ***significant at 1%, **significant at 5%, *significant at 10%.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
NUC 0.098 (4.062)*** -0.279 (-6.103)*** -0.212 (-2.279)** 0.910 -0.254 -0.193 16.14% 12.53% 0.581 31
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
233
The third non-renewable energy technology analysed, the light water nuclear reactors, present, in contrast, decreasing returns to scale and relatively high learning rates. The results are different from those obtained for the coal and lignite conventional energy technologies because the light water nuclear reactors technology is considered to be evolving rather than mature. More accurately, high learning rates are explained by the relatively short period of time needed for the doubling of cumulative installed capacity and by the increasing rate of R&D devoted to support the development of light water nuclear reactors. Indeed, they represent 86% of the functioning park and 79% of the park under consideration and have a large prospect for development. However, the decreasing returns to scale means that despite the fact that the nuclear technology benefits from the experience effects of doubling of cumulative installed capacities and from R&D flows, it still faces serious barriers to market diffusion inherent especially to nuclear accidents and to radioactive wastes. Compared to the renewable energy technologies, it does not appear as a priority in energy policy and environmental concerns despite its considerable participation in the provision of electricity. We conclude, therefore, that differences in learning rates and returns to scale effects between the three energy technologies, which are classified in the category of non-renewable energy technologies, are mainly due to the differences in their technological change stage. Other technology properties, like the environmental or the economic characteristics can largely influence the diffusion rate of energy technologies. Table 3:
Learning and scale effects estimation for renewable energy technologies.
Index 1. Y
WND 0.068 (5.752)***
BF2 -0.879 (-1.709)
2. Q
-0.332 (-7.605)***
-1.381 (-0.908)
3. SC
-0.278 (-8.119)***
-0.718 (-1.440)
DPV 0.148 (2.461)* * -0.075 (1.735)* -0.063 (4.592)* ** 0.871 -0.065
RS 0.936 -LBD -0.311 -elasticity LBS elasticity -0.260 --0.054 -LBD rate 19.41% 4.40% -LBS rate 16.52% 3.67% Adjusted R2 0.985 0.326 0.976 Observations 31 12 31 ***significant at 1%, **significant at 5%, *significant at 10%.
RPV 0.157 (2.536)* * -0.079 (2.284)* * -0.067 (3.495)* ** 0.864 -0.068 -0.057 4.62% 3.87% 0.974 21
SPP 0.391 (-2.893)**
HYD -0.036 (-2.571)**
0.317 (5.587)**
0.718 --
-0.061 (10.115)** * -0.014 (17.545)** * 1.037 -0.064
-0.061 -4.14% 0.681 16
-0.014 4.35% 1% 0.993 31
-0.085 (-2.496)**
The estimation results of renewable energy technologies group are presented in table 3. The wind energy technology, which is an evolving technology, presents almost the same scheme evolution as the light water nuclear reactors WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
234 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI technology. The learning-by-doing and the learning-by-researching levels are high and respectively equal to 19.41% and 16.52%. However, despite the considerable growth trend of cumulative installed capacity associated with the continuous knowledge stock increase and considerable subsequent cost decrease, the wind energy technology still faces important and several market barriers in reaching a significant share of electricity resource mix. Indeed, estimated returns to scale are equal to 0.936, which implies that this technology is subject to diseconomies of scale related especially to the lack of full cost competitiveness and to the reliance on public subsidies. Therefore, wind energy technology needs more specific technology policies to go up beyond the early beginning stage of technological change and to reach the maturity stage like, for instance, large hydropower energy technology. The latter represents one of the oldest renewable energy technology developed and utilised over a long period and has a major role in the electricity sector. It has accomplished large-scale deployment schemes and it is considered, therefore, a mature energy technology. This is ensured by scale effects estimation, which shows that large hydropower technology has benefited from economies of scale. On the other hand, estimations show a low level of learning effects meaning that the technology continues to evolve but at a slower rate. In general, hydropower energy technology exhibits the same characteristics as coal and lignite energy technologies. The decentralized and the rural photovoltaic energy technologies, which are both emerging technologies, have existed for a relatively short time and have achieved a lower degree of technological change progress during the period under consideration. This is why they have decreasing returns to scale and low learning rates: returns to scale range from 0.864 to 0.871 and the learning-bydoing and learning-by-researching range respectively from 4.40% to 4.62% and from 3.67% to 3.87%. As in the precedent cases, decreasing returns to scale means that technologies under consideration face barriers to diffusion greatly caused by their high investment costs and their low competitiveness potential. The low level of learning rates is interpreted as a lack of cost responsiveness to capacity expansion and also to R&D efforts. As a result of market barriers and low cost competitiveness, the technological change dynamic of emerging technologies has been slow and they are yet to gain a noticeable share of energy mix. The solar thermal power plant technology, which is also an emerging energy technology, presents almost the same schemes as the decentralized and rural photovoltaic energy technologies: decreasing returns to scale effects and low learning-by-researching rate. Nevertheless, the learning-by-doing rate is not calculated because of the problem of wrong sign, which is current in the literature estimating learning curve. The electricity production from waste estimation results cannot be interpreted because the coefficients are not significant. In sum, results of our estimations show that the main explicative factors of the differences in learning rates and returns to scale effects between the several considered energy technologies is their technological change stage characteristic: mature, evolving or emerging. Mature and emerging technologies present both WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
235
low learning effects, but the former has increasing returns to scale due to its large scale adoption and the latter has decreasing ones because of barriers to marketbased diffusion. The evolving technologies are situated in an intermediate situation between the mature and the emerging technologies and show a relatively high estimated level of learning rates, which means that they respond positively to diffusion promotion policy and that they have important opportunities of adoption. With regard to the Arthur hypothesis, when we compare the path diffusion of the conventional energy technologies to renewable energy technologies, we can argue that the observed lock-in and path-dependence situation on the conventional fuel resources is justified by the presence of increasing returns to adoption factors mainly in the form of economies of scale which act as selfreinforcing mechanisms and prevent the technological regime shift. The relationship is, thus, significant between increasing returns to adoption factors and the adoption decision. The renewable energy technologies seem to be unable to compete with the established energy system as long as the learning process is not achieved and conditions for technological path-breaking are not conceived.
5
Major policy directions
To overcome the several barriers to entry (technological, economic, societal and behavioural and regulatory), the transition process of renewable energy technologies should be boosted from the emergence stage to its self-sustaining growth path on the basis of both technology-push and demand-pull measures. These two complementary measures permit to enhance the learning system performance. The aim of technology-push measures is to overcome such barriers and to promote generation of the knowledge flows and development of technologies which are in the early stage of technological change process, whereas the aim of the demand-pull measures is to promote technical change by creating demand and developing markets for new innovative technologies and products. The combination of the two technology policy measures permits to overcome the supply and demand market barriers to entry, but the challenge still is to put policies in place and to ensure their synergy effects. At the basic stage, the technology push measures, like the government R&D as well as the financial support schemes (subsidies, tax credit…), are initially more important. As the energy technologies mature, policies supporting demand-pull will gradually be more effective in promoting technological progress. The compatibility between technological policies and the technological progress stage of the technology is hence crucial. In this context, technology policies supporting the transition process should rely on three policy directions. First, the development of focused micro and macro learning mechanisms. Second, the encouragement of new types of players and third the definition of flexible financing mechanisms, adapted to the characteristics of individual applications and environmentally consistent economic evaluation. Kamp [10] and Weber & Dorda [11] propose a new penetration–promotion approach based on these three directions for the transition WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
236 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI to a new technological regime called the strategic niche management approach. It is mainly based on the creation of protected spaces for the development and use of new technologies to conceive conditions for interactive learning that may extend beyond the individual technologies. Weber & Dorda [11] stress that the niche market approach contributes to the articulation of radical innovations, which may affect the structure of the conventional system and enhance the market diffusion process of the renewable energy by putting together the technological development with the institutional and organizational change, which are necessary for the success of technology. The market niche strategy provides an integrated approach, which merges the technology-push measures with the demand-pull in a unique evolving system.
6 Summary and concluding remarks The paper has two goals: to explain the sources of energy system lock-in and to analyse the factors for creating conditions for path-breaking. The results show that learning effects have been an important factor for cost decrease and thus for learning system performance improvements. They also show that the renewable energy technologies analysed present a potentially important prospect of diffusion, but require initial support from the technological policies before taking full economic and environmental advantages of the technological change regime shift. At the end of this paper, it is important, however, to note that from a methodological point of view some remarks are suggested. Indeed, technology learning rates are often based on econometric estimations of relatively short time series data where all series exhibit strong trends. This can engender several problems that seriously affect the quality of estimations. First, it is possible that some estimated elasticities could be statistically insignificant or even have an unintuitive sign (Cory et al. [12]). Second, the results of regressions could be spurious and the R-squares could overestimate the relationship between the endogenous and the exogenous variables. Moreover, despite its contribution in enhancing our understanding of the technological change dynamic in energy sector, the TFLC specification is still limited especially when trying to model some special effects as endogeneity effects between the cumulative installed capacity and the unit cost. The extension of the TFLC functional form should help to take account of these observed phenomena. Refining the data and the methodology permits to avoid econometric problems and strongly contributes to enhance our understanding of the energy technologies dynamic.
References [1] [2]
Tsoutsos, T. & Stamboulis, Y., The sustainable diffusion of renewable energy technologies as an example of an innovation-focused policy. Technovation 25, pp. 753-761, 2005. Arthur, B., Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events. The economic journal 99, pp. 116-131, 1989. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
237
Jorgensen, U., Energy sector in transition: technologies and regulatory policies in flux. Technological forecasting and social change 72, pp. 719731, 2005. Berndt, E., The practice of econometrics: classical and contemporary. Addison-Wesley Publishing, Boston, MA, 1996. Klein, L., An introduction to econometrics. Prentice Hall, 1962. White, H., A heteroscedasticity-consistent covariance estimator and a direct test for heteroscedasticity. Econometrica 48(4), pp. 817-838, 1980. Durbin, J. & Watson, G. S., Testing for serial correlation in last squares regression. Biometrika 38, pp. 201-223, 1951. Breusch, T., Testing for autocorrelation in dynamic linear models. Australian economic paper 17, pp. 334-356, 1978. Godfrey, L. G., Testing fir higher order serial correlation in regression equation when the regressor contain lagged dependant variables. Econometrica 46(6), pp. 1303-1310, 1978. Kamp, L., Learning in wind turbine development. A comparison between the Netherlands and Denmark. Doctorate thesis, Utrecht University, 2002. Weber, M. & Dorda, A., Strategic niche management: a tool for the market introduction of new transport concepts and technologies. IPTS Report, 1998. Cory, K., Bernow, S., Dougherty, W., Kartha, S. & Williams, E., Analysis of wind turbine cost reductions: the role of research and development and cumulative production. AWEA's WINDPOWER conference, Burlington, VT, June 22, 1999.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
239
Efficiency analysis for the production of modern energy carriers from renewable resources and wastes K. J. Ptasinski Department of Chemical Engineering, Eindhoven University of Technology, The Netherlands
Abstract Two global problems related to the use of fossil fuels are fast depletion and environmental damage. Biomass has a great potential as a clean renewable feedstock for producing modern energy carriers such as biodiesel, methanol, and hydrogen. However, the use of biomass is accompanied by possible ecological drawbacks such as limitations of land or water and competition with food production. For biomass-based systems, a key challenge is thus to develop efficient conversion technologies. This paper presents the efficiency analysis based on the Second Law of Thermodynamics for production of energy carriers from biomass. It is shown that the exergetic efficiency of renewable energy carriers is lower than that for fossil fuels. The highest efficiency is achieved for hydrogen production from high quality feedstock that is comparable with fossil fuels. Keywords: renewable energy, biomass, second law analysis, exergy efficiency.
1
Introduction
The present world’s energy demand is met by fossil fuels, i.e. petroleum, natural gas and coal. Two global problems related to the use of fossil fuels are a fast depletion and environmental damage due to emissions of various gases as COx, SOx, and NOx. In the future our energy systems will need to be renewable and sustainable, but also efficient, cost-effective and safe. It is widely acknowledged that the solution to the global problems would be to replace the existing fossil fuels by renewable energy (e.g. solar, wind and biomass). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070231
240 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Biomass has several important advantages which can accelerate the transition to sustainable energy. Key feature are renewability, neutral CO2 impact, and unique versatility as a wide range of biomass sources can be used to make electricity and biofuels. However, the use of biomass is accompanied by possible ecological drawbacks, mainly limitation of land or water and competition with food production, Hanegraaf et al [1]. Moreover, agricultural production of biomass is relatively land intensive, and involves high logistics costs due to low energy density of biomass. Therefore an optimal utilization of biomass resources is desired. For biomass-based systems, a key challenge is thus to develop efficient biomass-to-biofuel conversion technologies. Energy systems are traditionally analyzed by energetic analysis based on the First Law of Thermodynamics. However, this type of analysis shows only the mass and energy flows and does not take into account how the quality of the energy and material streams degrades through the process. In this paper the exergy analysis, which is based on the Second Law of Thermodynamics is used to analyze the conversion of biomass to biofuels. The main purpose of this paper is to compare different biofuels for their production efficiency. The paper starts with an explanation of exergy concept in Section 2 as applied for biofuels evaluation. The following sections 3–5 present the efficiency analysis of conversion of various biomass feedstocks into biofuels such as biodiesel (Sections 3), methanol (Section 4), and hydrogen (Section 5). Finally, all biomass conversion processes are compared in Section 6.
2
Exergy concept for efficiency evaluation
Biomass cannot be directly used in modern energy systems but it must be converted into secondary energy carriers, mainly electricity and biofuels. This paper concerns the efficiency of biomass conversion into liquid and gaseous biofuels, such as biodiesel (Fischer-Tropsch hydrocarbons), methanol, and hydrogen. The main application of biofuels is in transportation but they can be also used as chemical commodity. In 2003 the EU Biofuel Directive set the target of 5.75% market share of biofuels that was recently increased to 10% in 2020. Various biomass feedstock and conversion technologies are available for biofuels production. A wide range of biomass sources, such as traditional agricultural crops, dedicated energy crops, residues from agriculture and foresting as well as organic wastes can be used. The most attractive biomass-tobiofuels conversion technologies involve thermochemical biomass conversion, mainly gasification. In this process biomass is converted at high temperature into syngas (mixture of H2 and CO) which is subsequently used to produce various biofuels. Contrary to fossil fuels, there are numerous routes biomass-to-biofuel, characterized by various feedstocks, conversion processes and final products. The question what is addressed in this paper is how to select the most optimal biomass-to-biofuel conversion routes. Exergy analysis is a relatively new method of thermodynamic analysis that has recently been applied in different fields of engineering and science, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
241
Szargut et al [2]. The exergy method takes into account not only the quantity of materials and energy flows, but also their quality as well. The main reason of exergy analysis is to detect and evaluate quantitatively the losses that occur in thermal and chemical processes. The exergy balance of a process can be represented in the following form using exergy values of all streams entering and leaving the process:
∑Ε
j
+ Ε Q + ΕW =
IN
where
∑Ε IN
j
and
∑Ε
k
∑Ε
k
+I
(1)
OUT
are exergy flow of all entering and leaving material
OUT
streams, respectively, Ε Q and ΕW are the sums of all thermal exergy and work interactions involved in a process. The difference between the concept of exergy and those of mass and energy is that exergy is not conserved but subjected to dissipation. It means that the exergy leaving any process step will always be less than the exergy in. The difference between all entering exergy streams and that of leaving streams is called irreversibility I. Irreversibility represents the internal exergy loss in process as the loss of quality of materials and energy due to dissipation and it relates to entropy production Π in the system:
I = To Π
(2)
The exergetic efficiency is defined as the ratio between useful exergy output from the process to the necessary exergy input to this process.
3
Biodiesel (FT fuels) from wood
The Fischer-Tropsch (FT) process has a lively history of about 70 years, as mentioned by Schultz [3]. In the FT synthesis, synthesis gas containing hydrogen and carbon monoxide are converted into liquid hydrocarbons: n CO + 2n H2 →
[-CH2-]n + n H2O
∆H = - 159.2 kJ/mol
(3)
The most popular feedstock to provide synthesis gas for the FT process has varied through the years. During World War II, German vehicles were fuelled with coal-derived FT liquids. Today, natural gas is the most popular feedstock for synthesis gas production. Current developments focus on using biomass to produce clean FT fuels directly usable in the present transport sector. Figure 1 shows a block diagram of a biomass gasification process integrated with FT synthesis (BIG-FT). The overall process has been modelled using the flowsheeting programme Aspen Plus which contains process models and property data, that is often used in early stages of process development. Sawdust is considered by Prins et al [4] as a feedstock which contains 9.3% fixed carbon, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
242 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 55% volatile matter, 0.7% ash and 35.0% moisture. The higher heating value of sawdust is 12.63 MJ/kg. The biomass is dried to 10 wt% moisture by indirect drying using reaction heat from the Fischer-Tropsch section. Dried biomass is autothermally gasified with air at a temperature of 900°C and atmospheric pressure. The product gas is cooled to 90°C, generating 50 bar and 20 bar steam, which are used in steam cycles for electricity production. The gas is subsequently cleaned, compressed to 25 bar and catalytically shifted in a watergas-shift (WGS) reactor. The gas is converted to gaseous and liquid hydrocarbons at a temperature of 260°C by cobalt-catalysed Fischer-Tropsch synthesis. The total single-pass H2+CO conversion is 80%. The products from the FT reactor are cooled to 40°C, so that hydrocarbon liquids are condensed from the tail gas, which contains most of the naphtha (C5-C8). Diesel (C9-C22) and wax (C23+) are recovered as liquid products. These final products would be transported to a refinery for further work-up (e.g. fractionation, hydrocracking and/or hydroisomerisation). The tail gas from the FT work-up section is incinerated in a boiler and electricity is generated by means of a condensing steam turbine. air
steam
wood
I. Drying
II. Gasification
ash electricity
scrubbing water
IV. Gas cleaning
III. Gas cooling
Steam cycle 1
V. Compression
waste Steam cycle 2
tail gas off-gas
X. Power generation
water
IX. FT work-up
VIII. FT reactor
VII. Cooling
VI. Shift reactor
liquid hydrocarbons
Figure 1:
Schematics of a BIG-FT process.
The plant converts 57 ton/h of biomass into 5.6 ton/h of liquid FT products and 4.0 MW of electricity. The net output of hydrocarbon fuel is therefore 15.2% on weight basis. The exergy analysis shows that the biomass feed contains 210.8 MW exergy and the final liquid products contain 72.9 MW with co-production of 4.0 MW of electricity The overall exergetic efficiency is calculated at 36.4%, of which the exergy content of the liquid FT fuels is 34.5% of the exergy content in the biomass feedstock, while the electricity generated in the process amounts to 1.9% of the feed. Figure 2 shows that the largest exergy losses occur in biomass gasification and generation of power from FT tail gas. The high exergy losses in the gasifier are due to large entropy generation as large wood molecules (cellulose) are WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
243
converted into small molecules: H2 and CO. The maximum thermodynamic efficiency can reach 46.2% provided gasification temperature is lowered to 700°C, C5-C8 naphtha is included in the liquid FT product, and combined cycle is used for electricity generation. However, this optimal gasification temperature is rather low from the point of view of reaction kinetics in the gasifier.
Exergy losses (MW)
60
internal losses (irreversibilities)
external losses
50 40 30 20 10
p w or ku
ge ne ra tio n
ro ps er -T
Fi sc h
po we r
re ac to r ch
co ol in g ga s
sh ift
n pr es si o co m
cl ea nu p
SG
ga s
H R
ifi ca tio n ga s
dr
yin g
0
Figure 2:
4
Exergy losses per process section for the BIG-FT plant.
Methanol from sewage sludge
At present, methanol is an important industrial chemical and may play a significant role as a synthetic fuel for the future. The important advantages of methanol as a fuel are a higher energy content per volume than the other alternative fuels and minimal changes in the existing fuel distribution network. Currently methanol is twice as cheaper as ethanol. Finally, methanol can considerably reduce automotive emissions and requires no antiknock alternatives because of its high octane number. Presently the majority of methanol is made from natural gas, but also some methanol is made from coal, Macnaughton et al [5]. Both are converted into synthesis gas, via catalytic steam reforming in the case of natural gas, and through gasification in the case of coal. The further steps of the methanol plant are usually based on the ICI technology and include steps of syngas compression, methanol synthesis and distillation of crude methanol. Generally, methanol can be produced from any organic source including biomass, and municipal wastes. Sewage sludge is a by-product of waste water purification and it contains a reasonably high fraction of organic material, which is rich in carbon - the main constituent of methanol. The second constituent of methanol, hydrogen, can be obtained from water present in wet sludge during the gasification process. Conversion of sewage sludge into methanol contributes more to sustainable technology than traditional sludge processing as dumping and incineration, Ptasinski et al [6]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
244 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI SEWAGE SLUDGE WATER MECHANICAL DEWATERING
HEAT
WATER THERMAL DRYING
(AIR)
ASH GASIFICATION
HEAT WATER GAS CLEANING
WASTE PRODUCTS
(AMINE) RECYCLE
M.WORK COMPRESSORS
METHANOL SYNTHESIS HEAT
AIR
PURGE
HEAT HEAT RECOVERY
PURGE WASTE WATER METHANOL SEPARATION HEAT
HEAT
METHANOL
Figure 3:
Schematics of the methanol-from-sludge process.
Figure 3 shows schematics of the proposed methanol-from-sludge process. The sludge from wastewater treatment contains only 1-2 wt% solids and is mechanically (up to 20 wt%) and thermally dewatered (up to 55-100 wt%). The solids contain 56% of organic materials which are rich in carbon (50.4%), oxygen (30.7%), and hydrogen (6.9%). In the gasifier a synthetic gas is produced at temperature range of 800-1000oC, containing mainly CO and H2. Next the syngas is cleaned from solid particles and gaseous components, and compressed to a pressure of 77 bar. The methanol synthesis is based on the ICI low pressure methanol process at temperature of 200oC according to chemical reactions: CO + 2H2 = CH3OH WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(4)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
CO2 + 3H2 = CH3OH + H2
245 (5)
As the conversion of syngas to methanol cannot be completed in one pass, a recycle stream is used to increase the conversion efficiency. The last step is the methanol separation from dissolved gases and from water in a distillation column. A part of the recycle gas from the methanol synthesis and gas from the methanol separation is purged and combusted in a heat recovery unit. The plant converts 50 000 tons dry solids/year into 4300 tons methanol/year at gasifier temperature of 1000oC and a dry solid content of the sludge leaving the dryer of 80 wt%. The net output of methanol is 8.6% on weight basis but on the exergy basis 22.8 MW of sludge exergy is converted into 15.4 MW of methanol exergy. The overall exergetic efficiency of this process is 56% when also the exergy of additional utilities is included. The total exergy losses are 14.8 MW that corresponds to 21 MJ/kg methanol. A breakdown by plant units of the total exergy loss is shown in Figure 4. Most of the exergy losses are associated with gasification, compression and thermal drying (7.8 MJ/kg, 6.1 MJ/kg and 3.9 MJ/kg methanol, respectively). The irreversibilities of other plant segments like heat recovery, methanol synthesis, methanol separation and gas cleaning are much smaller. The exergetic efficiency of this process is higher than that of thermal sludge treatment such as incineration. The technical feasibility of the proposed process should be demonstrated in a small-scale plant.
relativeirreversibility (%)
50 40
28.5
30 20
18.2 12.0
10 1.5 0
Figure 4:
5
36.1
2.2
1.5
n n ry sis rs tio g ing tio ve ra so he yin an nt co pa es e ica l y r f e e i Dr r s s ls sc mp at ol Ga no Ga Co He an ha th et e M M
Exergy losses per process section for the methanol-from-sludge plant.
Hydrogen from biomass and wastes
Hydrogen is one of the most promising energy carriers for the future. It can be used as a fuel in fuel cells for power generation and in the transportation sector. The concept of hydrogen economy assumes only two energy carriers: hydrogen and electricity. Currently 95% of hydrogen comes from fossil fuels but biomass has the potential to become a sustainable source of hydrogen. Biomass-to-H2 conversion technologies can be divided into two categories: thermochemical and biochemical. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
246 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI wet biomass
heat
I
oxygen
II Gasification
BFW
m. work
heat BFW
Drier
wet steam
III
Gas Cooling 1
steam
IV
Gas Purifaction
fly-ash off-gas
V Multi-stage Compression VI
heat
Steam Generation 1
steam HT-shift Reactor
VII
process heat
VIII Pressure drop
BFW
IX
Gas Cooling 2
heat BFW
X
Steam Generation 2
steam
steam LT-shift Reactor
XI
XII Water Separation
XIII
PSA
process heat waste water heat CO2 rich gas
hydrogen
Figure 5:
Schematics of the hydrogen-from-wood process.
The most widely practiced thermochemical process route for biomass-tohydrogen is gasification coupled with water gas shift, Ptasinski et al [7]. Figure 5 shows the flowsheet of the H2-from-wood process. The feed is wood which contains 78.4 wt% organic fraction, 19.8 wt% moisture and 1.84 wt% ash. The wood is first dried in the thermal drier to its final moisture content of 10 wt%. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
247
The partially dried wood enters the gasifier, where a syngas containing H2, CO, CO2 and H2O is produced at the temperature of 900oC. The syngas leaving the gasifier is cooled down, cleaned, and compressed to 30 bar. In two water gas shift reactors (400oC, and 150oC, respectively) CO is subsequently converted into H2 due to reaction: CO +H2O = CO2 + H2
(6)
1.40 1.20 1.00 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20
Figure 6:
1073K
1173K
1273K
PSA
shif t Wa ter sep .
LT -
HT -
shif t Pre ss. dro p Gas coo ling 2 Ste am gen .2
973K
Pur ifica tion Com pre ssio n Ste am gen .1
Gas ifier Gas coo ling 1
0.00 Drie r
Exergy loss per unit [MW]
Water present in the gas leaving the shift reactors is separated in a flash unit at 20 bar and 25oC whereas CO2 is separated from H2 by pressure swing adsorption (PSA). Separation efficiency of H2 is 85% and 100% purity of hydrogen is produced. This plant converts 1000 kg/h wood into 76 kg/h hydrogen and 1330 kg/h CO2-rich gas. The net output of hydrogen on mass basis is thus 7.6% only. However, the exergy evaluation shows that 4.64 MW of wood exergy is transformed into 2.54 MW exergy of hydrogen and 0.61 MW of CO2-rich gas. The overall exergetic efficiency of this process is 65.7% and H2 contributes in 71% to this efficiency. A breakdown by process units of the total exergy losses for this process is shown in Fig. 6 for different gasifier temperatures. The principal exergy losses occur in the gasifier and theses losses decrease with decreasing gasifier temperature.
1373K
Exergy losses per process section for the hydrogen-from-wood plant.
Exergy analysis of thermochemical H2 production has been performed for other biomass feedstocks, including vegetable oil and manure, which contain various moisture content: 0, and 43.6 wt%, respectively. The results reveal that the exergetic efficiency decreases with increasing moisture content in the feedstock, as discussed in the next section. Hydrogen can be produced from biomass also using biochemical processes such as fermentation and anaerobic digestion. The most promising is the combination of dark and photo fermentation. The plant using this process can WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
248 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI convert 793 kg/h of potato peels into 57 kg/h H2 that corresponds to exergetic efficiency of 29.1% [7]. Anearobic digestion is the most well-known technology for biochemical conversion of biomass into biogas containing CH4 and CO2 which can be further converted into H2 by a conventional technique such as steam methane reforming (SMR): CH4 + 2 H2O = CO2 + 4 H2
(7)
The anaerobic digestion plant Vagron [7] converts the wet organic fraction of the household waste, containing mainly kitchen and garden wastes, into a biogas containing 65% CH4 and 35% CO2 that can be further processed into H2 as shown above. The exergetic efficiency of biomass-to-H2 conversion in this process is 36.3%.
6
Discussion and conclusion
Production of modern energy carriers such as biodiesel, methanol, and hydrogen from biomass can play a major role in future because it utilizes the renewable sources of energy. Very efficient biomass-to-biofuels conversion technologies should be developed due to ecological limitations set by biomass. Exergy analysis is a convenient tool for development and optimisation of future biomass processes. Exergy is regarded as the amount of ordered energy (work) present in biomass which should be conserved in produced biofuels as much as possible. Table 1 summarizes exergetic efficiency of all biomass-to-biofuel routes considered in this paper. The exergetic efficiency for hydrogen-from-natural-gas process is also reported in this table, as a typical value for fossil fuels, Rosen [8]. All reported biomass routes have lower exergetic efficiency compared to fossil fuels. The highest efficiency is for hydrogen-from-biomass processes from high quality feedstocks, such as wood or vegetable oil. The latter feedstock, which is carbon-rich and moisture-free, can compete with fossil fuels. Table 1:
Exergetic efficiency for biomass-to-biofuel processes.
Process Fischer-Tropsch Methanol-from sludge Gasification Gasification Gasification Fermentation Anaerobic digestion SMR
Biomass feed sawdust sewage sludge wood vegetable oil manure potato peels household waste natural gas
Biofuel biodiesel methanol hydrogen hydrogen hydrogen hydrogen hydrogen hydrogen
Exergetic efficiency (%) 36.4 56.0 65.7 79.1 35.8 29.1 36.3 78.0
The conversion efficiency of all investigated biomass-to-biofuel routes can be increased by improving the operation of biomass gasifier, which shows the highest exergy losses in all considered processes. Finally, the exergy concept applied in this paper is based on thermodynamics and therefore it is very WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
249
fundamental. However, more complex sustainability criteria should be also applied in order to cover other aspects such as environmental, social, en economical.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
[8]
Hanegraaf, M.C., Biewinga, E.E. & van der Bijl, G., Assessing the ecological and economic sustainability of energy crops. Biomass and Bioenergy, 15, pp. 345-355, 1998. Szargut, J., Morris, D.R. & Steward, F.R., Exergy Analysis of Thermal, Chemical and Metallurgical Processes, Springer Verlag: Berlin, 1988. Schulz, H., Short history and present trends of Fischer–Tropsch synthesis. Applied Catalysis A –General, 186, pp. 3-12, 1999. Prins, M.J., Ptasinski, K.J. & Janssen, F.J.J.G., Exergetic optimisation of Fischer-Tropsch fuels from biomass. Fuel Processing Technology, 86, pp. 375-389, 2004. Macnaughton, N.J., Pinto, A. & Rogerson, P.L., Development of methanol technology for future fuel and chemical markets. Energy Progress, 7, pp. 232-241, 2002. Ptasinski, K.J., Hamelinck, C. & Kerkhof, P.J.A.M., Exergy analysis of methanol from the sewage sludge process. Energy Conversion & Management, 43, pp. 1445-1457, 2002. Ptasinski, K.J., Prins, M.J. & van der Heijden, S.P., Exergy analysis of hydrogen production methods from biomass. Proc. of the 19th Int. Conf. ECOS2006, eds. C.A. Frangopoulos, C.D. Rakopoulos & G. Tsatsaronis, NTUA: Athens, pp. 1601-1608, 2006. Rosen, M.A., Thermodynamic comparison of hydrogen production processes. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 21, pp. 349-365, 1996.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
251
Environmental sustainability of CO2 capture in fossil fuel based power plants A. Franco & A. R. Diaz Dipartimento di Energetica “L. Poggi”, Università di Pisa, Italy
Abstract This paper analyzes various possible options for the chemical capture of CO2 and their energy requirements, focusing attention on the introduction of the devices in well-defined power plant configurations. Capture technologies are proposed and the most suitable technology appears to be chemical absorption. Even if, in principle, this option appears interesting, under an energetic point of view it has a great impact on the thermodynamic performance of the plant, reducing drastically its efficiency. Keywords: CO2 capture, chemical absorption technologies, energy analysis.
1
Introduction
Fossil fuels retain the largest market share of the world’s electricity generation, but they are a source of CO2 emissions. These considerations have triggered discussions over the wide use of some fossil fuels, like coal, in order to see if capture and sequestration of CO2 emissions are possible. The aim of CO2 capture technologies is to remove the CO2 presents at the flue gas before it reaches the atmosphere, producing a concentrated stream that can be stored and transported. However, to capture the CO2 produced, a significant amount of energy is required. This means that power plants with capture technology require much more fuel per kWh generated, reducing net plant efficiency [1]. It also results in an increase in most other environmental emissions per kWh of electricity generated, producing a proportional amount of by-products relative to the same type of plant without capture. In addition, there is an increase in the consumption of chemicals, such as ammonia and limestone in De-NOx and De-SO2 technologies. These factors restrict the emissions reduction requirements to a not-always-available thermodynamic performance. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070241
252 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Different technologies have been proposed in order to reduce the pollutant emissions or energy conversion systems. 1. 2. 3.
Removing the source of pollution from the fuel before it is burnt. Avoiding the pollutants during combustion (in-furnace measures). Removing the pollutants from the flue gases by “end of pipe“ methods.
CO2, SOx, NOx and PM are some of the emissions related to power generation that made fossil fuels combustion “unclean”. SOX, NOX and PM represent accidental emissions of the power plants, since the level of them is about 0.1-2 mg for each kWh of energy produced, the actual technology permits good possibility of reducing their level without significant energy requirements. CO2 is a structural emission of power plants. It is well known that recent Pulverized Coal Combustion (PCC) plants are characterized by a level of CO2 emission in the range between 850 and 900 g/kWh. The level of 750 g/kWh can be reached by Ultra Super Critical power plants (USC) and with Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle power plants (IGCC). However, when using coal it is difficult to break the barrier of 750 g/kWh. Using CH4, the emissions can be reduced by a factor of two reaching levels of 350-400 g for each KWh of energy produced. Indeed CO2 emissions are inevitably connected to the energy conversion system and therefore they are not accidental. In a coal based thermoelectric power plant the level of CO2 emissions is of about 3 kg for each kg of coal. In a natural gas combined cycle power plant the CO2 emissions level is also of the same order of magnitude. This first consideration is crucial in order to define the possible capture strategies and the environmental sustainability of their utilization. For this reason a preliminary analysis of the CO2 capture energy requirements is necessary.
2
Main technologies for CO2 capture
Capture techniques can be retrofitted to existing conventional fossil fuel based power systems or integrated into new power-generation facilities. These technologies can be performed in post- or pre-combustion processes. A summary of the possible pathways and of the technologies is given in Fig. 1. Post-combustion processes capture CO2 from flue gases produced by combustion of fossil fuels or biomass. Instead of being discharged directly to the atmosphere, the flue gas is passed through devices, which capture the CO2, while the remaining flue gas, with a low CO2 concentration, is discharged to the atmosphere. Flue gas from combustion approaches atmospheric pressure, which indicates that in post-combustion processes, a large volume of gases would be treated, involving the use of large-scale equipments. Due to the low CO2 partial pressure, absorption processes based on chemical solvents are currently the preferred options for post-combustion capture. The future of post-combustion methods is based on emerging capture technologies that are not yet in such an advanced stage of development. The energy required in CO2 post-combustion capture is, in general, quite large. This energy requirement reduces significantly the overall efficiency of the process (Fig. 2). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Post-combustion CO2 Removal from flue gas Separation Task: CO2 /N2
Pre-combustion fuel decarbonization
253
Oxy-fuel Separation Task: Air - separation unit O2/N2 CO2 separation
Absorption
Adsorption
Cryogenic
Membranes
-Chemical solvents
-Pressure swing/Temperature swing
-Liquefaction/Hybrid processes/Distillation
- Polymeric/Ceramic/ Ion transport
-Physical solvents
-Solid Sorbents (Zeolites, activated carbon, silicates)
Figure 1:
CO2 capture pathways.
2.1 Absorption Three different absorption processes can be distinguished: chemical, physical and dry solid absorption. Chemical absorption processes make use of the reversible nature of the chemical reaction of an aqueous alkaline solvent with CO2. A by-product is originated, which afterwards will be heated, to break the bound between the chemical solvent and the CO2, producing a CO2-rich stream and a regenerated chemical solvent. Fig. 3 illustrates an absorption process. The main absorption parameters are the flue gas flow rate, the CO2 content in the flue gas, the CO2 removal rate and energy requirements. The energy consumption of the process is the sum of the thermal energy needed to regenerate the chemical solvent, and the electric energy required to operate pumps, blowers and compressors. Amine-based chemicals are the principal commercial chemical solvents used to separate CO2 from exhaust gases including, (MEA), diethanolamine (DEA) and methyldiethanolamine (MDEA) [4]. Furthermore, salts of strong alkalis with weak acids offer various possibilities for chemical absorption process [5]. CO2 can be also physically absorbed by a non-reactive solvent according to Henry’s law and then regenerated using pressure reduction or heat. Exhaust gases with low CO2 concentration Wout Air
Power Process
Fuel
Energy
Flue Gas
CO2 Capture
CO2 to transport and stored
Figure 2:
End-of-pipe CO2 capture.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
254 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Flue gas
STRIPPING
Pre-treatment of Exhaust gases
ABSORPTION
Clean gas
Post-treatment of Exhaust gases CO2
Low Pressure Steam/ kg CO2 avoided
Figure 3:
Chemical absorption.
The absorption capacity of organic and inorganic solvents for CO2 increases with increasing pressure and with decreasing temperatures. Therefore, physical absorption methods are not suitable for flue gas CO2 capture, since the partial pressure of CO2 is low. This kind of technology could be very efficient, but only for high-pressure CO2-rich streams, such as those in pre-combustion processes in IGCC power plants [6]. The physical solvents used are Selexol, Rectisol, and Morphysorb. Another way is represented by dry solid absorption. A solid can be used instead of a liquid as a scrubbing medium for CO2 capture. In this process, the solid sorbent does not circulate between vessels because the sorption and regeneration are archived by cyclic changes, in pressure or temperature. 2.2 Physical adsorption An adsorption process consists of two major steps: adsorption and desorption. Strong affinity of an adsorbent for removing the undesired component from a gas mixture is essential for an effective adsorption step. The stronger the affinity the more difficult it is to desorb the gas impurity and the higher the energy consumed for regenerating the adsorbent. Several modes of operation are used to release or regenerate the adsorber gas from the solid. Pressure or temperature changes are used. In Pressure Swing Adsorption (PSA), the gas mixture flows through a packed bed of adsorbent at high pressure, insulating the solid, and then desorbing the sorbed gas by lowering the pressure. In Temperature Swing Adsorption (TSA), the gases are adsorbed at a lower temperature, the solid is isolated and then the temperature is raised during the regeneration step to release the trapped gas. The main advantage of physical adsorption over absorption could be its simple, and energy efficient, operation and regeneration. 2.3 Cryogenic separation The cryogenic separation separates a gas component from a gas stream. The separation can be made producing a phase change (liquefaction or solidification) of the component that needs to be separated, thereby condensing it and removing WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
255
it as a liquid/solid from the gas mixture (Fig. 4). The condensation is fulfilled by a series of compression, cooling and expansion steps. Cryogenic separation for CO2 is only practical for a high-pressure stream with a high CO2 concentration, such as in pre-combustion capture or Oxy-fuel combustion. Cryogenic separation produces liquid CO2 that is ready for transport and storage. Quite a high-energy rate for cooling and compression is necessary. Water
POWER
CO2 + Vapour
Figure 4:
CO2
Cryogenic separation.
2.4 Membranes separation Membranes are special materials that allow either the selective transport (diffusion) or selective exclusion of a desired component [8]. The flow of gas through the membrane is usually driven by the pressure difference across the membrane. Therefore, high-pressure streams are usually preferred for membrane separation. Indeed, the low CO2 partial pressure difference that characterizes fuel gas provides a low driving force for gas separation membrane. Membranes can separate CO2 from a gas stream by size exclusion or by chemical affinity. There are many different types of materials (polymeric, metallic, ceramic) that may find application in CO2 capture. Nowadays, the removal of CO2 with commercially available membranes results in higher energy penalties on the power generation efficiency compared with standard chemical absorption processes.
3 Energy analysis of CO2 capture by chemical absorption Chemical absorption technologies are nowadays the only method that can be proposed to implement large-scale capture of CO2 from fossil-fuel energy combustion systems. Capture efficiency is higher than 90% and produces CO2 with a purity of 99%. However, the introduction of CO2 capture devices represents an important efficiency penalty on the thermodynamic performance of the power plant as well as a remarkable increase of the net cost of power generation with CO2 capture.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
256 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 3.1 Thermodynamic model to evaluate the energy required for CO2 capture The capture process can be divided in three main stages (Fig. 5): pre-treatment of the flue gas, in order to reach the desirable scrubber conditions, scrubber/stripper processes, and post-treatment of the produced CO2 stream. Energy consumption of the whole process is the sum of the thermal energy needed to regenerate the solvent and the energy required to deliver a high-pressurized CO2-pure stream.
Clean gas Capture process
CO2
Pre-treatment of Flue gases Trange(100-600)°C
SCRUBBER Trange(25-80)°C
CO2
Trange(80-140)°C
Flue gas
Figure 5:
Post-treatment of CO2 stream
STRIPPER
CO2 For sequestration
Chemical absorption flowsheet.
Electrical energy for compression, the pumping and blowing of the circulated solvent flow rate, or to operate the flue gas, are not considered in this analysis. The parameters used for the model are; the sorbent absorption capacity, depending on the CO2 concentration in the flue gas (lower CO2 concentration will require higher absorption capacity), the scrubber/stripper temperatures, depending of sorbent type, and the desirable CO2 temperature and pressure for transport and storage. The flue gases from a combustion power plant are usually quite hot, ranging from 60°C to 600°C, depending on the power system. Absorption being an exothermic process is favoured by low temperatures. Thus, it is desirable to cool down the flue gas to scrubber temperatures in order to improve CO2 absorption and minimize sorbent losses. A direct contact cooler (consisting a packet tower where the cooling fluid is water at 25°C) can be used to reduce the flue gas temperature to acceptable levels, also acts as a flue gas wash with the additional removal of fine particulates. The flue gas temperature directly affects the volumetric flow rate of gas stream. The heat duty, Q, to be removed from the flue gas at the cooler pre-treatment depends on the temperature and the mass flow of the flue gas together with the desirable absorption temperature required for the absorption, is: Q = mf cp (Tscb − Tf )
(1)
where mf is the mass flow of the flue gases, cp is the heat capacity of the flue gases, Tscb is the scrubber temperature and Tf the flue gas temperature. Since CO2 absorption might be a spontaneous reaction in order to facilitate the CO2 capture, at the scrubbing an exothermic reaction is fulfilled, thus no energy is demanded. The stripper process is the desorption process, where a high concentrate CO2 WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
257
stream is produced, the energy required for the sorbent regeneration is quite high and one of the most relevant energy consumption in the whole process. This energy is usually supplied by the low/medium pressure steam flow produced in a steam turbine and supplied by a reboiler. In any case, this required heat can be divided in three main contributions [7]. The sensible heat is the energy used for heating the scrubber solution to the stripper temperature is given by Vsen =
msol cp (Tsol − Tstrp ) mCO2 ∆H v
(2)
where Vsen is the ratio between the steam mass flow rate required and the mass flow rate of CO2, msol is the solution mass flow, cp is the specific heat of the solution, Tsol is the rich solvent hot solution temperature, Tstrp is the stripper temperature, mCO2 is the CO2 mass flow recovered and ∆Hv is the steam reboiler vaporization heat coming into the stripper at a given temperature. The recovery of CO2 from the chemical solvent needs energy to reverse the adsorption reaction. This energy reaction includes the enthalpy reaction and in the solution case, also the solution reaction of the dissolution in water, is given in eqn (3). Vdes =
∆H r ∆H sol + ∆H v ∆H v
(3)
where Vdes is the desorption ratio (kg of steam/kg CO2), ∆Hr is the reaction enthalpy, ∆Hsol is the solution reaction and ∆Hv is the steam reboiler vaporization heat coming in to the stripper at imposed temperature (all in kJ/kg steam). The CO2 recovered in the stripper must come out along with the help of a vapour stream. The mixture is composed of 1 mol vapour/mol CO2 and that the whole process occurs at constant temperature and pressure. Steam goes from the saturated vapour to the saturated liquid point at the stripper temperature, the vapour required for stripping is: Vstrp =
msteam mco
(4)
2
where Vstrp is the steam supplied for CO2 stripping (kg steam/kg CO2), msteam is the steam mass flow required from the reboiler at the stripper temperature, and mCO2 is the CO2 mass flow recovered. The total vapour required in the stripper is: VT = Vsen + Vdes + Vstrp
(5)
In order to obtain CO2 ready for transport, in the model a post-treatment at ambient temperature and 140 bar pressure is considered. After the stripper, the vapour-CO2 mixture is cooled down to 25 °C in order to separate water from the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
258 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI CO2 before the liquefaction plant. For the model proposed here, it is considered that the vapour condensation occurs in a direct contact cooler with water at 25°C. In order to liquefy the pure CO2 stream produced, a three-stage intercooler compression is used. The energy required to compress the produced CO2 to sequestration parameters for efficient transport and storage, can be estimated as: Wc =
mCO2 cp ∆T
(6)
ηc
where Wc is the compression energy, mCO2 is the CO2 mass flow recovered, cp is the CO2 specific heat, ∆T is the temperature difference in each stage, ηc is the compression efficiency in the different stages. 3.2 Energy analysis In Table 1, the energy requirements for the different CO2 chemical absorption technologies are displayed. The high energy consumption needed to capture the CO2 emissions is pointed out. Using coal as fuel, the energy requirement is of the order of 1/5-1/6 of the calorific value of the fuel. Considering a general thermoelectric plant configuration based on coal, for each kg of coal 3 kg of CO2 is produced, the energy required to remove CO2 corresponds more or less to the electric energy produced by the plant, reaching pointless solutions. This result emphasizes the perspective of CO2 capture only in case of integrated configurations. From this, we can see the necessity to promote solutions in which the capture process uses the marginal energy of the plant. Indeed, the conclusion is that the strategy cannot be applied in the same way to all the plants. Figs 7 and 8 describe two different situations. In the first, a CGAM power plant, the integration between the plant and the capture is possible without a particular penalty (mainly in terms of second law analysis). Low steam pressure coming out from the heat recovery steam generator is used for capturing the CO2 without subtracting output power to the plant. In the second case, the capture is possible only by subtracting a consistent amount of the low-pressure steam from the boiler; the result is a strong reduction of the plant output power. Under this perspective, solutions like IGCC coal based power plants can be interesting. 12 MJel
1 Kg coal 30 MJ
3 kg CO2 18 MJth
Figure 6:
6-18 MJ steam
CO2 capture energy balance.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 1:
Energy required for chemical absorption CO2 capture.
Figure 7:
Figure 8:
CGAM plant with CO2 capture.
Coal plant with CO2 capture.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
259
260 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 2:
Effect of CO2 capture on the overall plant performance.
Coal fired power plant χ 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
χm2 [kg/s] 0 1.89 3.79 5.69 7.59 9.49
(1-χ)m2 [kg/s] 21.7 19.8 17.9 16.0 14.1 12.3
ηII 0.41 0.38 0.35 0.32 0.29 0.26
Wout [MW] 30 27.8 25.7 23.5 21.40 19.25
CGAM power plant χmvs [kg/s] 0 1.50 3.00 4.51 6.01 7.51
(1-χmvs) [kg/s] 14 12.4 10.9 9.48 7.98 6.48
ηII 0.50 0.48 0.46 0.44 0.42 0.40
Wout [MW] 30 29.68 29.36 29.04 28.72 28.40
The results shown in Table 2, where a link between the amounts of CO2 captured (χ) and the required kg of steam for each kg of CO2 recovered (ms) is reported, demonstrate that the most significant reduction takes place in the electrical output of the steam turbine. This is due to the different points where the low-pressure steam used for the CO2 recovery is taken into the energy generation process. While for the gas turbine, the low-pressure steam used for the CO2 capture process does not affect the energy generation process of CGAM plant. Considering the results discussed in this section, it is clear that the future of CO2 capture should not only be based on overcoming the limitations of the existing solvents [9], and on the reduction of energy consumption for solvent regeneration and of equipment sizes, but also on the development of particular plant configurations where the marginal energy of the plant can be used for capture.
4
Conclusions
In spite of great research efforts and the great emphasis connected with the development of pollutant emission control, the concept of CO2 capture in power generation and heating processes is still in a development phase. The paper focuses attention on the connection between the capture technologies (mainly chemical absorption technologies) and the thermodynamic performance of the power plant. It is shown that the energy consumption required to capture the CO2 emissions is quite high varying from 2 to 6 MJ for each kg of CO2 emitted. Depending of the fuel used and the power plant configuration, the energy required for CO2 capture and separation processes causes a significant power plant efficiency reduction, which necessitates an agreement between the desirable amount of CO2 to be captured and the permitted energy consumption for maintaining acceptable performance of the plant. In general, it is possible to conclude that CO2 capture strategy is sustainable only if the marginal waste energy of the plant can be used; but this is not always possible.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
261
References [1] [2]
[3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9]
Hendriks, C., Carbon Dioxide Removal from Coal-Fired Power Plants, Energy & Environment, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1994. White, C.M., Strazisar, B.R., Granite, E.J., Hoffman, J.S. & Pennline H.W., Separation and capture of CO2 from large stationary sources and sequestration in geological formations-coalbeds and deep saline aquifers, J. Air Waste Manag. Assoc., 53, 645-715, 2003. Leci, C.L. & Goldthorpe, S.H., Assessment of CO2 removal from power station flue gas, Energy Convers. Mgmt. 33 (5-8), 477-485, 1992. Rao, A.B. & Rubin, E.S., A technical, economic, and environmental assessment of amine-based CO2 capture technology for power plant greenhouse gas control, Environm. Sci. Technol., 36, 4467-4475, 2002. Salvador, C., Lu, D., Anthony, E.J. & Abanades, J.C., Enhancement of CaO for CO2 capture in a FBC environment, Chem. Eng. Jour., 96, 187195, 2003. Wolsky, A.M., Daniels, E.J. & Jody, B.J., CO2 capture from the fuel gas of conventional fossil-fuel-fired power plants, Envir. Prog., 13, 214-219, 1994. Erga, O., Juliussen, O. & Lidal, H., Carbon dioxide recovery by means of aqueous amines, Energy Convers. and Mgmt., 36, 387-392, 1995. Favre E., Carbon dioxide recovery from post-combustion processes: Can gas permeation membranes compete with absorption? Journal of Membrane Science 294, 50-59, 2007. Bai, H.L. & Yeh, A.C. Removal of CO2 greenhouse gas by ammonia scrubbing, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 36, 2490-2493, 1997.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
263
Cooling needs for a warming world? Economics and governance of district cooling F. Becchis1,2 & G. Genon1,3 1
Fondazione per l’Ambiente, Italy University of eastern Piedmont, Italy 3 Turin Polytechnic, Italy 2
Abstract Energy use outlook in developed countries shows a particularly fast growing component: the demand for cooling. This demand of energy for indoor air conditioning represents a challenge for environmental policies, a potential enemy of energy efficiency and energy saving and, definitely, an issue at stake for global climate policies. The trend of energy demand for cooling purposes also brings many problems for the generation capacity and the management of peak loads. The technologies for centralized trigeneration (electricity, heating, cooling) seem promising but do not always enter the market with convincing commercial strategies. Nevertheless, the presence of district heating from cogeneration plants in large metropolitan areas (like in Turin, Italy) represent the possibility of developing district conditioning. The preliminary conclusions of the research are as follows: 1) given the assumed technology and the trend for indoor air-conditioning demand, district cooling brings net social benefits from both sides of industrial figures (global investments, maintenance and running costs) and environmental externalities; 2) some cautionary remarks are due in relation to the assumptions, sometimes questionable, about emissions rate per kWh, energy efficiency in electricity production, discount rate, market prices of alternative technologies, plumbing and networking costs. The analysis does not encompass the distribution of costs and benefits among stakeholders (among the others: electricity producers, network owners, end users), a question that is more relevant in the political local arena. Keywords: district heating, district cooling, energy efficiency, environmental cost-benefit analysis, energy externalities.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070251
264 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
In the domain of environmental policies energy planning at local level can get interesting results in terms of energy efficiency and, consequently, reduced emissions and use of natural resources. In particular, combined heat and power (CHP) reaches high levels of efficiency in energy conversion: using waste heat from power generation plants to supply thermal energy for domestic or industrial purposes, reduces the energy (and environmental) content per unit of product/service. The growing demand of energy for indoor air conditioning represents a further challenge for environmental policies, in the context of troubled Kyoto implementation. The trend brings strong implications for the generation capacity and the management of peak loads; furthermore it is deemed to produce negative environmental externalities such as air emissions from plants that produce electricity, ozone depleting gases (for the old installations, to be banned in few years), end-of-life equipment disposal, indoor noise, water use for cooling purpose in electric plants, and aesthetic impacts. In spite of the relative large diffusion of CHP for electricity and heat production, the possibility of trigeneration, which adds cold production for air conditioning to traditional CHP, is less known. Technologies for trigeneration, presented in the following paragraph, seem promising but not yet able to enter the market with convincing commercial strategies. The presence of networks for district heating from cogeneration plants in large metropolitan areas (like the south part of Turin, Italy) or commercial-industrial district, represents a possibility of developing district conditioning (DiCon): given some assumptions about the technical options for electricity production, heat is practically free and the existing network represents an irreversible (sunk) cost that can serve also for district conditioning purposes. DiCon enhances the energy efficiency of buildings and contribute to significant environmental results in terms of CO2, PM10, NOx, noise, water use for cooling purposes in the CHP plant. In a recent study [1] supported by Provincia di Torino and AEM Torino Spa, the main technological, economic and environmental constraints surrounding a virtual district conditioning project in different scenarios have been outlined. Starting from a definition of a possible catchment area, composed of communities instead of single independent homes, the simulation sets the average energy demand for cooling purposes and the consequent running condition for the polygeneration system in the different scenarios. Consequently, an economic and environmental assessment has been conducted, from the perspective of the society as a whole: commercial and financial implications for a possible real project are not considered. After a survey of the state of the art technologies for trigeneration, the paper summarizes the economic and environmental parts of the study and its interesting conclusions about potential benefits not only from the environmental side but also from an industrial perspective.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
2
265
Material and methods
2.1 The market for cool In Europe 40% of the total demand of energy comes from buildings mainly for heating and cooling purposes: 70% of this share is related to civil buildings with fossil fuels as main energy vectors. In a typical commercial building, cooling need can account for 20% of energy consumptions, with a foreseeable increasing trend in the near future. For example, domestic chillers where 5 million in 1990 in EU countries but market estimates say that the number will be 25 million in 2020 [1,3]. 2.2 Technologies for polygeneration: state of the art District conditioning consists in a centralized production of cold water (about 5-8 °C) and the supply of this fluid to the users through a pipe network. The room conditioning is operated with specific devices (panels or fan coils) located in each single room, which are fed with cold water. A first advantage with respect to small air coolers is that the centralized production can be obtained using medium and large power chillers, characterized by higher efficiency. Moreover, a positive effect on the environment can be obtained using absorption or adsorption chillers instead of the more usual vapour compression chillers. Those machines allow replacement of the most part of the electricity with thermal energy, provided through hot water, usually at a temperature between 85 °C and 120 °C. When thermal energy is available as waste energy or as by-product of a power plant, it is possible to increase the overall efficiency of the system, which means that the global emissions and resource depletions are reduced without reducing the users’ demand. Economic benefits can be also achieved. District conditioning is economically sustainable in temperate climate zones, when a district heating network already exists. In this case it is possible to use the network at high temperature, which can also be reduced with respect to the winter values, to feed thermal chillers located in users’ buildings. In those cases where the request for air cooling is large, it could be advantageous to provide the service through a specific district network, operating at low temperature. On this basis, numerous district networks are operating in Germany (for instance in Dresden, Kassel, Mannheim), U.S.A. (for instance Boston, Baltimore and Philadelphia where networks operate on areas constituted by 200 to 400 buildings, feeding commercial users, industries and universities) and Japan. From both energy and economic point of view, it is also necessary to consider that the performance (COP) of vapour compression chillers varies between about 2.9 and 4.4, depending on the scale. These indicators are defined as the ratio between the thermal energy subtracted to the indoor environment and the electricity required. It is also necessary to consider that electricity is produced in power plants, with an average efficiency of 38%. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
266 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The alternatives represented by thermal chillers are characterized by lower efficiencies (COP). In particular the COP of the absorption chillers is about 0.8, while this value is about 0.65 for the adsorption chillers. Nevertheless, it is necessary to consider that thermal energy can result as a by-product or a waste of a productive process, such as in power plants. On this basis the following considerations are formulated. 2.3 Economic and environmental aspects, actors involved The economic assessment of complex projects from the social point of view aims to reduce the information asymmetry which hinders appropriate public choices in complex markets with relevant failures (externalities, public goods). The analysis here presented has been conducted from the social point of view, beyond the private interest of the actors involved in the project (technology producers, buildings designers, energy producers and distributors, big final users such as hospitals, communities and malls). As known, firm’s and consumer’s choices and investments are addressed to profit, personal utility, market shares and other private goals; externalities and public goods, strongly relevant for the society as a whole, can not play a big role. Furthermore, it can happen that projects which present a positive global balance and are consistent with profit or utility goals cannot find a path to implementation because of inertia. Inertia appears when institutions, firms or individuals resist to changes in economic decisions: uncertainties about costbenefit structure and costs-sharing, sunk costs, information shortage, time costopportunity and psychologic costs are the main responsible of inertia. As the economic analysis will demonstrate later, it is not sufficient for a project to show positive savings in respect to “doing nothing scenario” if the distribution of costs between actors and through the time is not clear. 2.4 District cooling in a case study: introduction The virtual project here considered can be summarized as follows: a) in the absence of the project the business as usual (B.A.U. scenario) foresees air conditioning through electrical appliances and associated electricity demand (80% of domestic chillers and 20% of centralized chillers), for a catchment area that grows up to 2.2 million cubic meters, in 20 years (see Figure 1). b) the district cooling project (the project) requires initial investments, running costs and dismission costs that are compared with the corresponding costs of business as usual. c) for simplicity, cost analysis contains elements that in more sophisticated CBA are normally broken up (taxes and welfare contributions). d) main environmental externalities (CO2, NOx, PM10) are taken into account in the scenarios (project and business as usual); data about other negative externalities such as noise, water use, aesthetic impacts are not available. e) the analysis does not consider the distribution of relevant costs among different subjects (plant managers, final users, network owners and so on), with consequences that will be shortly discussed in the final part of the paper. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
267
Users' trend (cubic metres) assumed during BAU and Project scenario 2,200,000 2,000,000 1,800,000 1,600,000 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,000,000 1
Figure 1:
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Trend hypothesis for the buildings volume served each year in the BAU and Project scenario.
2.5 District cooling in a case study: project description and energy analysis The case-study considered in this project is based on the south area of Turin, where a district heating network provides heat to the buildings in this area for winter heating and in some cases for domestic water. The network is fed by a large power plant and some auxiliary boilers. The maximum heat flow is about 610 MW and the total volume of buildings is about 22,000,000 m3 In this study district conditioning has been considered available for 10% of the total volume, quota to be reached in 20 years (see Figure 1). In the analysis, the operation of district conditioning has been considered for 800 hours at the nominal power, without any time shift between the users. The specific energy request of users has been assumed as 30 W/m3 To comply the with the users’ request, about 66 MW of cold water, through thermal chillers it is necessary that the network provides 83 MW in case that absorption chillers are used or 95 MW in case of absorption chillers are used. If vapour compression chillers were used, the electric energy need would be between 40 and 60 MW, depending on the equipment size. Energy, economic and environmental analysis must be performed considering that in case a cogenerative plant is used, it also produces electricity, that can be supplied to the grid. The plants supplying heat to the district heating network are a steam turbine, a gas turbine and some auxiliary boilers. The main part of heat is provided by the steam turbine, through a steam extraction. Thus, when the plant operation moves from electric production to cogenerative mode, the electricity production decreases from 136 MW to 101 MW when also 162 MW of thermal energy are produced. In case these plants are used for district conditioning for 10% of the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
268 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI users, the overall electricity production would be 118 MW if absorption chillers are used and 115 MW if adsorption chillers are used. The primary energy requirement (fuel) is in both cases 348 MW. As a comparison, if the same amount of electricity were produced by a power plant characterized by the average efficiency of the Italian plants and the air conditioning were operated through vapour compression chillers, the primary energy requirement would be between 380 and 420 MW, depending on the size of chillers. This means that additional fuel depletion and externalities are associated with this case, with respect to the use of district conditioning. Both the economic and environmental impacts of this choice are discussed below. 2.6 District cooling in a case study: cost analysis The BAU case and the project are economically specified by a list of costs that are attributed mainly to indirect methods (cost-coefficients from the literature). The cost categories are the following. Design costs: costs of dimension setting, safety equipment, the need for space for chillers and other machineries are estimated as € 26 per installed kW for the 66,000 kW installed [4]. Initial investments: domestic (80%) or centralized (20%) electric chillers for the B.A.U. scenario; adsorption equipment for the project case. In both cases equipment costs are estimated on the basis of coefficients (€/kW) [5] Connection and plumbing costs: they include connection to the district heating network, internal piping and possible costs on the “last mile”. In case of new connections to clients, the cost of the necessary segment of network should be, in theory, attributed to district cooling only for the extra-cost due to extradiameter of pipes. Thus the assumption overestimates, precautiously, the cost of connections to new users. Maintenance costs: estimated as a percentage of the initial investment costs. Electricity consumptions quantified on the basis of the domestic market price per kWh in the B.A.U. case. For example, an average apartment (240 m3) is characterized by a yearly cost of € 200 with a price of € 0.1172/kWh. In the B.A.U. case, effective consumption by chillers is estimated. In the project case the analysis accounts for negligible absorption consumption plus the electricity crowded-out at the power plant for the mentioned trade-off. End of life: a cost of € 0.104/kg of equipment to be disposed of, assumed to occur at the 21st year of the timeline of the analysis. Externalities: physical quantities (tonnes of CO2, PM10, NOx) are estimated as follows: in the B.A.U. case, emissions per kWh are those typical of the Italian average thermal gross production. In the project scenario emissions are those specifically produced to satisfy extra-demand of thermal energy for cooling purposes, at the power generation plant which supplies energy to the district heating system in Turin. Indeed, as known, there is a partial trade-off between electricity and heat production. Monetary values come from a prudential survey of the literature on putting a value on externalities, in particular the ExternE project by the EU ad its recent updates [6]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
269
Results
Table 1 presents values (P.V.) of direct market costs and environmental externalities for the project and business as usual are presented. The P.V. result from discounting at 5% rate the yearly values in the time range of the analysis (20 years). As shown in Table 1 the district cooling project implies market costs of around 33 million Euros, in present value, distributed in the 20 years. Compared with more than 55 million Euros in the B.A.U. scenario the potential savings are relevant. The cost variables that contribute mainly to the result are initial investments (much higher in the B.A.U. case for diseconomies of scale), connections (higher in the project for obvious reasons), electricity consumption (relevant savings in the project case, due to use of waste heat for cooling instead of electricity). Furthermore, the project brings also environmental net benefits that amount to more than 5 million Euro saved, at present value, in negative externalities for 20 years: the net result comes from a direct comparison of the externalities flows in the competing cases. Figure 2 and Figure 3 show the yearly nominal values for costs and negative externalities. Shortage of reliable data about water uses for cooling purposes and indoor noise suggests they should not be included in the analysis. Table 1:
Market costs and externalities (Euro) for the BAU and Project scenario. Business As Usual present values (r=0.05)
Project present values (r=0.05)
Project vs B.A.U. present values (r=0.05)
Market Costs (Euro) Design Initial investments
302,105 28,890,733
3,233,048 9,699,145 -
Connections
2,805,650
12,450,695
Maintenance
1,162,919
1,459,745
Electricity consumptions End of life Total market costs
22,119,701 22,748 55,303,856
6,221,166 59,021
2,930,944 19,191,588 9,645,045 296,826 15,898,535 36,274
33,122,821 -
22,181,035
Externalities (Euro) CO2
3,711,133
324,676 -
3,386,457
Nox
1,164,543
94,415 -
1,070,128
795,985 n.a.
64,534 n.a.
731,450 n.a.
PM10 Water use Noise
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
Energy saving
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
Total externalities
5,671,660
483,625 -
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
5,188,035
270 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Market Costs (Mln Euro) for the BAU and Project scenario 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
BAU Project
Figure 2:
Total Market Costs: design, investments, connections, maintenance, electricity consumptions and end of life (Mln Euro) for the BAU and Project Scenario.
Externalities (Euro) for the BAU and Project scenario 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 13
14 15
16 17
18 19
20 21
BAU Project
Figure 3:
Negative externalities CO2, NOx, PM10 (Euro) calculated with damage factors per ton of pollutant emitted in EU-15 [7].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
271
Discussion
The results of the analysis are based, as always, on a set of hypotheses and simplifications. The authors have made handicraft sensitivity tests, with encouraging results (changes in the values of some crucial variables does not overturn the balance in favour of the project of district cooling). Yet, for complete information, the main critical aspects of the analysis are listed in the following points, some work in favour of the project, some against it; • the share of 80% attributed to domestic chillers in the BAU scenario could be overestimated. Centralized chillers may be interested by price falling due to economies of scale; • the presence, in the cost list, of elements that in more sophisticated CBA are normally broken up (taxes and welfare contributions) should not encompass significant biases because the simplification is assumed in costs of both scenario, leaving the balance as it is; • externalities are crucial to represent the overall social costs and benefits of a project, nevertheless their existence is practically irrelevant for market choices of firms and consumers. Policies for externalities internalization (taxes, tradable rights, subsidies, etc) are recommended; • district cooling could also be assessed as a complementary system for air conditioning: in this case DiCon would supply a basic quantity of thermal energy, leaving the satisfaction of peak loads to traditional vapour compression equipment; • The positive global performance of the project versus BAU scenario should be taken with care: apart from total cost figures it is important to know more about cost sharing among different actors: the power plant owner, the network runner, large end users (hospital, commercial building, civil buildings), small end users. As an example, the willingness to pay for connections and plumbing could make a big difference for the practical feasibility of the project.
5
Conclusions
Technologies for trigeneration seem to be in a particular phase of their product life-cycle: they are promising but not yet able to enter the market with convincing commercial strategies. Obstacles at work are the large fixed costs for the networks and indoor plumbing, the high (in absolute terms) average cost of machinery (mainly absorption-adsorption equipment) due to narrow markets and their relative low, though improving, energy efficiency: furthermore, electricity producers and distributors have no interest, in the short-middle term, to develop technologies that erode the business of electric utilities. Nevertheless, the presence of district heating from cogeneration plants in large metropolitan areas represents a possibility of developing district conditioning: given some assumptions about the technical options for electricity production, heat is practically free and the existing network represents an irreversible (sunk) cost that can serve also for district conditioning (DiCon) purposes. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
272 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI In spite of doubts about the economics of DiCon from a business perspective, environmental externalities and social benefits should be highlighted in order to assess it. In particular, the following benefits are at stake: CO2, NOx and PM10 reduction, primary energy savings, water use reduction, noise abatement and aesthetic improvements. The preliminary conclusions are as follows: 1) given the assumed technology and the trend for indoor air-conditioning demand, district cooling brings net social benefits from both side of industrial figures (global investments, maintenance and running costs) and environmental externalities. 2) some cautionary remarks are due in relation to the assumptions about energy efficiency in electricity production (which influence the emission rate per kwh), discount rate, market prices of alternative technologies, plumbing and networking costs. Furthermore, the analysis does not encompass the distribution of costs and benefits among stakeholders (electricity producers, network owners, final users and so on).
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
Il teleraffrescamento: scenari tecnologici ed implicazioni economicoambientali, Fondazione per l’Ambiente, 2004, www.fondazioneambiente.org REHVA, www.rehva.com Centre Energétique et Procédés de l'Ecole des mines de Paris, www.cenerg.ensmp.fr/english/themes/syst/ Bejan A., Tsatsaronis G., Moran M., Thermal Design and Optimisation, Wiley, New York, 1996 HIJC INC. (Houston, Texas, USA) www.adsorptionchiller.bigstep.com ExternE - Externalities of Energy, EC DG XII – Science Research and Development, 1999, externe.jrc.es Externalities of Energy: Extension of accounting framework and Policy Applications, ExternE-Pol Project 2002-2004 funded by EC, 2005, www.externe.info/exterpols.html 2005 Statistics - International Comparison, Terna Spa, 2005, www.terna.it/ita/statistiche/documenti/annuario05/07_internazionali.pdf Spurr, M., District cooling and its integration with combinet heat and power, Proc. of International Symposium on District Heating and Cooling Simulation, Reykjavik, Iceland, 1997 Spurr M. and Larsson I., Integrating District Cooling with Combined Heat and Power, IEA Programme of Research, 1996
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 9 Socio economic factors
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
275
The (in)validity of benefit transfer and its consequences for policy-making E. J. Bos1 & J. M. Vleugel2 1 2
LEI, The Netherlands OTB Research Institute, TU Delft, The Netherlands
Abstract The essence of benefit transfer is that the assessment of ecological effects of an intended project is based on information from similar studies, undertaken at other sites. Instead of performing a completely new study, which may cost a lot of time and money, key parameters from older studies are used. This approach is assumed to save valuable research time and money. In the paper it will be shown that this benefit may occur at the expense of the validity of assessments. Using these assessments for the new project may result in sub-optimal decision-making by governments and other stakeholders, like private landowners. The paper contains a meta-analysis on the validity of benefit transfer. The two basic types of benefit transfer, simple benefit transfer and benefit function transfer are being compared. It turns out that the validity of simple benefit transfer is often poor even when applied at comparable sites. This raises the question whether simple benefit transfer should be used to support policy-making regarding investment scenarios of national importance. It may be better to use benefit function transfer as an alternative, because it can compensate for differences in explanatory variables. In this way, the validity of the assessment can be increased, which may lead to ‘better’ decisions, provided that suitable benefit functions are available. Keywords: environmental economics, benefit transfer, validity, decision-making.
1
Introduction
The impact of an intended investment project, such as the development of a nature area, can be evaluated with two alternative methods of collecting data. The first option is called an in depth or full study and the second option is to take WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070261
276 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI research results from other studies and apply them in a new study. This approach is referred to as benefit transfer. There are two main ways of carrying out a benefit transfer study. The first is called simple benefit transfer and the second function benefit transfer. Our aim in this paper is to compare the validity of these two benefit transfer methods using a simple meta-analytical framework. The paper starts with an introduction of the importance of project assessment for decision-making. This is followed by a discussion of the aims of and the methodology employed in benefit transfer studies. Next, the two methods of benefit transfer will be compared. Based on these insights, suggestions will be formulated to contribute to a valid application of benefit transfer.
2
Investment projects and policy-making
Decision-making with respect to investment projects tends to be complex and extensive, because many, sometimes very diverging aims and interests have to be aligned. One of these is to protect the environment. This is especially true for decision-making on large infrastructure projects that have significant adverse effects on the environment. An assessment procedure is carried out. The result of such a procedure can be legally binding. In the Netherlands, for example, a MER (Environmental Impact Report) is obligatory for certain investment projects. It contains a non-monetary, partial analysis of the environmental consequences of a project. An integral assessment should cover economic, environmental, liveability, safety issues, et cetera. Dedicated project studies take place, which can be time and money consuming, especially if there is a major disagreement between proponents of the project and those opposing it. Opponents tend to use procedures in order to extend decision-making, hoping that this helps to delay and eventually to cancel the project. An example is the Dutch ‘Betuwelijn’ case in the 1990-ties. This concerns the construction of a dedicated high-speed freight railway line of about 100 kilometres between Rotterdam (the largest harbour in Europe and one of the largest in the world) and the German border. Instead of using the existing railway line, which crosses through many cities, most of the freight trains will be relocated to this new railway line. This would enable a reduction of environmental and safety issues in urban areas and transport of much more freight by rail. The harbour of Rotterdam and these cities would gain, but rural areas in the Betuwe–region would be intersected. This is a problem because the Betuwe–region contains important ecological and culture-historical values. A compromise had to be found, which increased the decision-making period [1], while the building costs doubled due to compensating investments (noise shielding, bypass tunnels, et cetera). In the past decade, the number of infrastructure projects has increased. At the same time, policy-makers want to reduce evaluation periods, which puts stress on researchers to speed up their work. This is why less time and money consuming ways of evaluating policy options have become interesting. The question is whether such assessment techniques enable a reliable support of decision-making on public investment projects. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
277
Environmental assessment and benefit transfer
3.1 Introduction The aim of environmental assessment is to first assess an effect in physical terms and second, to translate this impact into monetary terms. The determination of physical effects is the field of ecologists. (Environmental) economists are involved in the economic valuation of the effects, i.e. the determination of costs and benefits of a project. With respect to the economic valuation, a distinction can be made between performing an in depth study and applying benefit transfer. Performing an in depth study using techniques such as contingent valuation involves the design, testing and implementation of a survey. This way of economic valuation of environmental features is characterised by extensive costs of collecting data [2]. 3.2 The methodology of benefit transfer Benefit transfer is based on the assumption that preferences for similar environmental concerns in corresponding contexts are comparable [3]. Estimations from one site (the study site) are used for the assessment of another site (policy site). In case of assessing environmental impacts, this approach is referred to as environmental benefit transfer [4]. More specifically, benefit transfer can be defined as the use of monetary environmental values estimated at a study site for estimations of the same parameters at a policy site through market-based or non-market-based economic valuation techniques [5]. It is being applied in various natural resource policy contexts, ranging from water quality management, associated health risks and waste management, to forest management and even global ecosystems [6]. Benefit transfer is supposed to increase the efficiency of the policy evaluation process [7]. This explains why many environmental agencies in the world are attracted to this method of collecting data [8]. For instance, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) suggests the application of benefit transfer in its guidelines for CBA [9]. Subsequently, in the U.S. some prominent scenarios have been assessed by applying benefit transfer. An example is the application of benefit transfer in a cost benefit analysis of the Clean Air Act performed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. In the Netherlands, the application of benefit transfer is suggested in institutionalised guidelines for CBA when exploring possible project scenarios [10]. Two basic types of benefit transfer are being distinguished. The first is the direct or simple transfer of mean benefit estimates from study site to policy site [11]. To perform a simple benefit transfer, a researcher must make a number of subjective professional judgements such as the selection of the study site [3]. In order to reduce potential sources of measurement error associated with these judgements, a researcher should follow three criteria when considering the use of an existing study [12]:
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
278 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI -
-
The commodities of the policy site which are subject of evaluation should be comparable to those of the study site; The population characteristics of policy site and study site should be similar. This can be a hazardous case when commodities reflect non-use values: what is the relevant population for non-use of an area in the first place? A researcher has to use the welfare measurement from the study site, because he or she cannot transfer welfare measurements used in a willingness to pay context to a willingness to accept context and vice versa.
The second type is the transfer of functions rather than final benefits estimates (benefit function transfer [11]). It starts with the construction of a value function based on existing literature. Next, data have to be collected about independent variables at the policy site in order to estimate the benefit for the policy site.
4
A comparison of benefit transfer methods: pros and cons
Benefit transfer can be considered as a time and money reducing alternative for collecting economic data. Collecting economic data is especially costly when it concerns environmental goods and services such as biodiversity and amenities. When applying simple benefit transfer a researcher has to find mean values from studies that have been performed for similar cases. The search for similar values should be based on the three criteria mentioned in section 3.2. It is up to the researcher to judge whether the values of the policy site correspond sufficiently to those of the study site. In other words, whether it ultimately makes sense to compare the two sites. The key issue with benefit function transfer is that a researcher has to use an already determined relation between the variable of the commodity of interest and the corresponding explanatory variables. The problem is that in most cases a suitable function has not been determined. This is no surprise as most in depth studies primarily intend to assess mean benefits for the concerned case instead of assessing the functional relation between the environmental benefit and explanatory variables. Assessing a benefit function would only be efficient if this function could be used for several additional studies in future... In case a suitable function could be found, the next step is to collect data for the explanatory variables. This may again be a difficult step. Consider for instance benefit assessment of non-use values. An example of a non-use value is the benefit of the protection of biodiversity in a nature area that is closed for users like recreational visitors. To determine such a value it is necessary to collect social-economic data (age, income, education, et cetera). This means that the researcher has to know the population for whom these non-use values are relevant. It is very arbitrary to determine which people belong to the relevant population and who should be excluded. Hence, collecting data for a benefit function transfer might be less obvious than it seems.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
279
This means that it may take more time and money to carry out a benefit function transfer study instead of a simple benefit transfer study. What pleads in favour of benefit function transfer according to several authors, is that more information is effectively transferred [5, 8]. In particular, benefit function transfer enables a more explicit correction for explanatory variables, which means that its validity is likely to be higher, provided that proper functions are available. In other words, within the context of benefit transfer there is a tradeoff between validity and costs of collecting data. Therefore, in the following section we will address the validity of both benefit transfer methods.
5
Does benefit transfer produce valid outcomes?
5.1 An overview of validity studies In this section we will discuss the validity of benefit (function) transfer with a number of examples from the literature. As will be shown, there is a major difference of opinion about the validity of benefit transfer. There are even authors who say that the method is of no value at all. A pioneering study was the one by Loomis in 1992 [13]. The author tested the transferability of travel cost demand equations and contingent valuation benefit functions for recreational fishing in the United States. Transferring these functions from one state to another gave accurate results. However, transferring a function from a recreation site in one state to another state gave invalid estimates. It appears that specific regional aspects determine the concerned benefit in this study. Another interesting study was carried out by Bergland et al. in 1995 [8]. It estimated benefits functions for similar environmental goods by means of parallel contingent valuation (CVM) studies conducted at two Norwegian water sites. The authors tested the validity of simple benefit transfer and benefit functions transfer empirically. Neither type of benefit transfer gave valid values. Moreover, they concluded that the two benefit functions derived from the CVM studies were not related. In 1996 a first review of benefit transfer studies was carried out by Bergstrom in the U.S. [14]. Although the studies involved in this review suggest that benefit function transfer may be more valid than simple benefit transfer, the validity of neither form of benefit transfer is strongly supported by empirical tests. Bergstrom concludes that it is a challenge to determine adjustment procedures and protocols, which lead to accurate estimates. Bhat et al. [3] have examined the transferability of consumer surplus estimates (simple benefit transfer) and the transferability of benefit functions from the Southern Appalachian Mountain ‘ecoregion’ to a local site within the ecoregional level. They found that transferability of benefit estimates from recreational activities was possible in 50% of cases, whereas benefit functions could be transferred for all the activities considered in their study. The results of their study suggest that benefit transfer between sites located in a similar natural
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
280 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI area or region generates valid estimates. In order to improve the validity of benefit transfer, these authors recommend further research both in estimation procedures and accounting for explanatory variables like site attributes. The need to include site characteristics is also emphasized by Bowker et al. [15]. Moreover, these authors show that transferring benefit functions, which are derived from multi-site data is most promising as it allows for correction of differences in site characteristics. These positive findings are in contrast with those by Brouwer [5] who concludes that empirical testing of environmental benefit transfer has not lead to valid results so far. Kristofersson et al. [16] show that the validity of benefit transfer is likely to be even less than found in earlier validity studies. They suggest that validity tests are biased towards positive outcomes and therefore provide no accurate information. Finally, Brander and Florax [17] conclude on the basis of studies performed in the U.S. and the U.K. that the validity of benefit transfer is disappointing. More specifically, they found that simple benefit transfer can generate transfer errors of up to 400%. Given these insights it not surprisingly that Florax et al. [18] notice that despite the intuitive appeal of benefit transfer, its application in environmental assessment studies is very limited. The risk of using poor data is that the outcome of CBA might result in sub-optimal decision-making. In that case the cost-reducing feature of benefit transfer might be out-weighted by the social cost of sub-optimal decision-making. This may prohibit the use of benefit transfer in any phase of policy making. The problem is that there are circumstances where benefit transfer has to be applied. This especially holds for ex ante evaluations, because in this case the effects have not yet taken place. Consider for instance the assessment of recreational benefits of a to be developed site using the travel costs method. As there are no travellers to the site yet, travelling behaviour cannot be observed and travel cost cannot be determined. This prohibits the application of the travel costs method as an in depth study instrument. As in such circumstances benefit transfer has to be applied, it is important that reliable benefits assessments become available. Table 1 summarizes the earlier studies. 5.2 A spatial frontier? The studies discussed above indicate that only intra-regional benefit function transfer will yield valid estimates. Consequently, interregional, interstate-, international- and intercontinental transfers are likely to generate invalid estimates. This also means that if in a certain country no previous valuation studies have been carried out, then it is hardly possible to apply a valid benefit transfer. This case applies to the Netherlands, for instance. The current body of benefit estimates in this country largely consists of data from abroad [19]. The relatively few studies that have been assessed in the Netherlands concern mean benefit WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
281
estimates [20]. Benefit functions have not been assessed in any Dutch valuation study. As the present body of data lacks benefit functions for Dutch valuation studies, a valid application of benefit transfer in the Netherlands is hardly feasible at the moment. It follows that a more valid application of benefit transfer in the Netherlands is likely to occur when benefit functions are being assessed in order to enable benefit function transfer. Up till then, one should only perform in depth studies and not apply benefit transfer for supporting Dutch decision-making. Table 1: Study Loomis [13] Bergland et al. [8] Bergstrom [14] Bhat et al. [3] Bowker et al. [15] Brouwer [5] Kristofersson et al. [16] Brander and Florax [17]
Meta-analysis of existing benefit transfer studies. Simple Problematic Problematic Problematic N.A. N.A. Problematic Very problematic
Function Valid Problematic Problematic Intraregional is valid Possible Problematic Very problematic
Very problematic
Very problematic
5.3 Scope for improvement If we consider the observation that an in depth study may be very costly in most cases, while a benefit transfer study may lead to doubts about the validity of its results in specific cases, there is an argument in favour of combining in depth studies and benefit transfer in the same study. One of the authors [21] who followed this route applied Bayesian statistics to a set of data from 31 case studies throughout the world. This statistical tool allowed him to generate data for additional explanatory variables. A similar approach was followed by another author [22], who concluded that conventional benefit transfer based on CVM underestimated willingness to pay by about 50%. She concluded that Bayesian statistics saved on study costs, while its results are much more valid. It follows, that deriving benefit functions using Bayesian statistics can combine the best of benefit transfer and in depth, i.e. efficiency and validity.
6
Conclusions and recommendations
This paper discussed the application of benefit transfer in project assessment studies. Benefit transfer is an interesting alternative for in depth studies, because it might reduce research time and cost considerably. However, the burden of benefit transfer might come in the form of invalid assessments. If the difference between the estimated and real values becomes too WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
282 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI large, then the validity of decision making based on such estimations is questionable. In this article a comparison of the validity of two main benefit transfer methods, simple and function benefit transfer has been presented. Some authors, who criticize simple benefit transfer, recommend benefit function transfer as the most valid of two. The latter is regarded as a more accurate alternative for simple benefit transfer, because more information is effectively transferred. However, suitable benefit functions are hardly available. Studies show that socio-cultural parameters prohibit the use of regional values and estimates of such values beyond the regional level. This means that interregional, interstate or international transfers are not likely to lead to valid results. A promising alternative is a combination of a limited in depth study and a database with values from a range of international studies using Bayesian statistics. The local in depth study can then be used to validate the international assessment values. As became apparent, more research should be carried out in the following directions: - Assessment of more transferable benefit functions; - Perform comparative studies to analyse the validity and costs of both benefit transfers and in depth studies; - Combining in-depth studies with benefit transfer in order to profit from the strong points of both methods.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
[7] [8]
Boom, H. & Metze, M., Slag om de Betuweroute; Het Spel langs de Lijn, 1997. Barbier, E. B., Acreman, M. & Knowler, D., Economic Valuation of Wetlands, Ramsar Convention Bureau. Imprimerie Dupuis, S.A., Le Brassus, Switzerland, 1997. Bhat, G., Bergstrom, J.C. & Bowker, M.J., An Ecoregional Approach to Benefit Transfer, Discussion paper, 1997. Kask, S. B. & Shogren, J.F., Benefit Transfer Protocol for Long-term Health Risk Valuation; A Case of Surface Water Contamination, Water Resources Research, (30), pp. 2813-2824, 1994. Brouwer, R., Environmental value transfer; state of the art and future prospects, Ecological Economics, (32), pp. 137-152, 2000. Brouwer, R., Environmental value transfer: state of the art and future prospects, in: Florax, R., Nijkamp, P. & and K. Willis, K., Comparative Environmental Economic Assessment. Edward Algar, Cheltenham, pp. 90-114, 2002. Button, K.J. & Nijkamp, P., Environmental Policy Assessment and the Usefulness of Meta-Analysis. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, (30), pp. 231-240, 1997. Bergland, O., Magnussen, K., & Navrud, S., Benefit transfer: testing for accuracy and reliability, Discussion Paper #D-03/1995, 1995. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]
[18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
283
See http://www.epa.gov/oar/sect812/1990-2010/chap1130.pdf. Ministerie van Landbouw, Natuur en Voedselveiligheid, Kentallen Waardering Natuur, Water, Bodem en Landschap: Hulpmiddel bij MKBA´s. Eerste editie, Den Haag, 2006. Kirchhoff, S., Colby, B.G. & LaFrance, J.T., Evaluating the performance of benefit transfer; an empirical inquiry, Journal of environmental economics and management, (33), pp. 75-93, 1997. Boyle, K. and & Bergstrom, J.C., Benefit Transfers Studies: Myths, Pragmatism and Idealism, Water Resources Research, (28), pp. 657-663, 1992. Loomis, J. B., The evolution of a more rigorous approach to benefit transfer: benefit function transfer, Water Resource Research, (28), pp. 701-705, 1992. Bergstrom, J.C., Current Status of Benefits Transfer in the U.S.: a Review, 1996. Bowker, J.M., English, D.B.K. & Bergstrom, J.C., Benefits Transfer and Count Data Travel Cost Models: an Application and Test of a Varying Parameter Approach with Guided Whitewater Rafting. FS 97-03, 1997. Kristofersson, D. & Navrud, S., Validity Tests of Benefit Transfer – Are we Perfoming the Wrong Tests? Environmental and Resource Economics, (30), pp. 279-286, 2005. Brander, L.M. and Florax, J.G.M., The valuation of wetlands: primary versus meta-analysis based value transfer. In Carruthers, J.I. & Mundy, B. (eds.), Environmental Valuation: Interregional and Intraregional Perspectives. Aldershot: Ashgate (in press). Florax, R., Nijkamp, P. & and K. Willis, K., Comparative Environmental Economic Assessment. Edward Algar, Cheltenham, 2002. See the “Environmental Valuation Reference Inventory” (EVRI) at http://www.evri.ec.gc.ca/evri/english/about.htm. Ruijgrok, E.C.M., Valuation of Nature and Environment: A historical overview of Dutch socio-economic valuation studies, Platform voor Economische Waardering van Natuur, Rotterdam, 2002. Bal, F., Valuing Dutch Nature Areas: a Different Approach, Ph. D. Thesis. Martin Luther University, Halle/Wittenberg, 2002. Lehr, U., Bayesian benefit transfer in environmental evaluation, University of Hohenheim, Dpt. of Economics, Stuttgart, 2005.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
285
Coastal cities – urban infrastructures D. Blott University of Portsmouth, School of Architecture, Portsmouth, UK
Abstract Urban regeneration in Britain frequently focuses around buildings and sees the object as a potential catalyst for the making of public space. This project proposes that the starting point is public space and infrastructure, its character and connectivity determining new building proposals. The south east coast of the UK is characterised by a string of resorts that together create an urban strip approximately 160km long. However, the 19th and early 20th century recreational expansion that created it, while informing the strip’s urban morphology, can no longer singularly sustain it. In the absence of any clear successor, the connection between town, hinterland and sea has eroded. As individual seaside towns, the trappings of fading popularity obscure the very qualities that were once so attractive. As an often unrecognized ‘Strip-City’ the coastal strip is hindered by poor infrastructure, especially that for transport, promoting pockets of extreme isolation. Current regeneration is in danger of ignoring existing spatial characteristics that, historically, have been shaped by the combination of the closeness between town and sea and the ambition of 19th century engineering. Whilst developments are considered for ‘key sites’, the critical issue of spatial and infrastructural linkages – squares, parks and routes – that re-unite and re-define the urban shoreline is ignored. This paper discusses the work of masters-level architecture students, which investigates ideas for the regeneration of coastal settlements and the creation of new programmatic territories that link infrastructure and architecture, interaction and space, city and water. Keywords: architecture, urban design, coastal development, urban regeneration, urban infrastructural spaces, urban programmes.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070271
286 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
The following is not about urban transport per-se; rather, it is about the way in which infrastructure, particularly that for urban transport, can be the bedrock upon which many strands of urban design can be built. The work of the Architecture and Urbanism (A&U) Studio is now in its third year. It is one of three studios which direct the design studies of the masters-level Diploma in Architecture. Its interests are in the relationship between architecture and urban design and one of its defining characteristics has been the use of ‘live’ urban conditions in which to base year-long design projects – Study Bases – and from which to draw critical inspiration – Study Precedents. The work discussed here is the result of one year’s activities of a group of students and tutors – Coastal Cities (CC) – within this studio. The group uses as its study-base the coastal region between Southampton and Hastings, along the southeast coast of the UK, seeing within it a contextually rich variety of locations in which particular observations and local connections can be made, questions asked and strategies proposed. What has drawn the group’s attention to this area is the way it appears to represent a number of urban conditions that are both distinctly unique to the UK – the growth and decline of the 19th century seaside resort, an urban landscape that is simultaneously urbanised yet remote and generally poor levels of transport infrastructure – and globally recogniseable – the emergence of near-continuous, recreational seaside conurbations [1]. In discussing the CC group’s work, this paper summarises the rise and fall of the English seaside resort and current attempts to reverse its decline. It offers a brief critique of the UK’s southeast coastal belt and its infrastructure and discusses precedents offered by the urban conditions of another urban coastal location – Barcelona. Finally, it describes the hypothetical critical design responses made to a specific location on the southeast coast – Hastings.
2
The coastal resort
As an island nation, our relationship to the thin border between land and sea, and our fondness for the seaside town, is deeply rooted. However, when visiting a seaside town what we are most aware of is a palpable sense of nostalgia, a feeling for that which is no more, an image of the glorious town in decline. This feeling is acutely observed in Paul Theroux’s book ‘Kingdom by the Sea’ [2]. For over 200 years the seaside played a central part in English summer holidays. In the 18th century the search for health encouraged the development of the resort. During the 19th and early 20th century swifter transport, by water, rail and finally by car, made seaside towns more accessible; and by the end of this period, most seaside resorts were well established. With the implementation of the 1871 Bank Holiday Act, regular holiday weekend trips became part of the culture of all classes of society. The promenade through the big city was transplanted to the seafront as resorts around the country assumed the role of urban recreational counterpart to their industrial hubs. The architecture and engineering of this new urban paradigm, which gave expression to its promenades, piers, hotels and stations, was never afraid of being bold, quirky, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
287
exuberant and idiosyncratic. It built upon the huge speculative ambition in the early 19th century, the impact of which even filtered into Jane Austin’s unfinished novel ‘Sanditon’ [3], and it continued to develop right up to World War Two. However, from the 1960’s, mass tourism developed and expanded beyond the shores of Britain, leaving many coastal towns empty of holidaymakers and local economies in decline. In fact their fleeting return to popularity in the immediate post WW2 years of austerity provided a disincentive for them to invest in infrastructures that could have enabled them to counter the foreign travel industry that would follow. Today, perched on an eroding landscape, many seaside towns continue to suffer from under investment and inadequate infrastructure and so struggle to maintain a foothold. They are in need of creative solutions. Seaside towns are unique because of their particular climate, their remoteness, their ageing and transient populations. They exist, literally, at the edge and, as settlements along the line where land meets sea; they represent a liminal condition to which we are drawn and yet feel to be so remote [4]. To regenerate such towns requires radical solutions and urban design ideas need to look beyond conventional precedents. In recent years a number of organisations and initiatives, which concern themselves with this problem, have emerged. A week-long conference, sponsored by CABE, was held in 2002 to promote seaside regeneration. From seafood stall to new public landscaping masterplans, a whole range of projects was seen to be potentially capable of recreating a spirit of confidence and ambition. The Communities and Local Government Select Committee now recognises the uniqueness of the acute demands as well as the huge potential of seaside resorts compared to other towns. Many local authorities, regional development agencies and private corporations across the whole of the UK have created partnerships with the aim of regenerating and promoting coastal areas. Last year the newly restored De La Warr Pavilion in Bexhill hosted the 3rd Coastal Towns Conference – a gathering of public and private bodies from across the southeast coastline from The Solent to the Thames Estuary – to disseminate and discuss issues and initiatives.
3
Strip-City
From Southampton to Hastings, settlement has spread in the only way it can, as fiercely protected landscapes to the immediate north squeeze it along approximately 160 kilometres of coastline to create a near-continuous urban belt.
Figure 1:
Strip-City.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
288 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI What interests us is that formal or coordinated recognition of this coastal ribbon appears only to have recently emerged. Certainly, the South Coast Towns conference network demonstrates an emerging recognition, as does the South East England Regional Assembly’s (SEERA) demarcation of the needs of the Southeast’s coastal belt against those of other parts of the region. The South East England Development Agency (SEEDA) continues to direct considerable resources towards the region’s coastal towns and, at a more local level, networks are forming to learn from and act upon shared information. Nevertheless, a seemingly conventional view of the region’s settlement pattern sees the monocentric hub of London at the centre of a rural hinterland, dotted with selfcontained towns. Another view, however, is of numerous, sinuously connected urban and sub-urban, polycentric webs that collectively house a population greater than that of the capital. We have come to use the term ‘Strip-City’ for our chosen web – a long and thin amalgam of coastal towns, cities, suburbs, villages and protected landscapes, theme and caravan parks, marinas and water-side retail centres, promenades and piers, arcades and gardens, hotels and boarding-houses, which houses approximately 1.9 million people [5]. Many parts of Strip-City display depressed and imbalanced cultural, social, economic and demographic conditions; and all appear subject to poor levels of transport infrastructure (albeit with marked differences between its eastern and, more industrialized, western end) when compared to other conurbations in the UK. Yet, despite its size, no single rapid road or rail system links any of its main centres (see Fig 2), while road and rail journeys along its full length take two and three-quarter hours and three and a quarter hours respectively [6]. The disjointed and excluded nature of Strip City is put into sharper focus when viewed within the wider context of southeast England and northern France and their respective rapid road and rail networks (see Fig 2). In the southeast, a predominantly radial motorway system, centred on London, takes precedence over the east-west orientation of the coastal settlement – a situation much less evident on the other side of the channel. As for the UK’s only rapid rail route, linking it to mainland Europe, Strip City is removed from Ashford International by only thirty two miles (from its eastern end) but by journey times of an hour by road and forty minutes by rail [6].
4
Barcelona – study precedent
Although clearly different from any one seaside town along the southeast coast, Barcelona, when considering the scale, complexity and totality of Strip-City, offers an urban reference that is highly relevant since it demonstrates, in its urban development programme from the 1980s onward, a process of reinventing its coast in order to reintroduce the city to the sea. Furthermore, it is interesting to observe the extent to which this regeneration programme has been shaped through an alignment between urban space and transport infrastructure [7].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 2:
Figure 3:
289
Rapid rail and road.
Barcelona – Cerda Grid.
4.1 An urban system Ildefons Cerda’s proposals in 1859 to allow for the ‘Reform and Expansion of Barcelona’ represent more than just an expansion plan [8]. An engineer by profession, Cerda wished to devise a comprehensive urban system that attended to the city’s infrastructural needs at a level both specific and general, at a scale both local and universal. We recognise his ‘Eixample’ or Expansion Plan today through the distinctive gridiron (see Fig 3), creating 113m x 113m blocks and intersected by diagonal boulevards that traverse the city [8]. Ingeniously, the plan wished to provide the means to ensure a number of simultaneous urban prerogatives, defining a framework for building footprints and heights and allowing, through a range of singular and collective urban block combinations, for the provision of open spaces within and across each block. This in turn ensured some control over living densities and the ventilation of spaces. At a macro-scale, the grid provided the framework for both movement across the terrain of the city and for services beneath it. But the integrated nature of this system goes beyond civil engineering and provides the means for civic urban quality. The boulevards, created both along certain routes within the grid and diagonally across it, provided the spatial set pieces – parks and promenades – for the new city’s public realm; just as the 450 chamfered corners [8] of every block turned each intersection into a space for interaction. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
290 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 4:
Former Olympic Village – urban spatial structure.
4.2 Movement and urban space This extension of the ‘engineering’ brief has, it could be argued, established a working principle which continues to shape Barcelona’s urban development today. From Barcelonetta and the former Olympic Village of 1992 to the ‘Forum International 2004’ site, a strategic programme can be observed that utilizes infrastructure as a generator for a comprehensive spatial, social, cultural and economic urban programme. Within this programme reside the spaces that define the way the city operates. Strategically, the Olympic and Forum projects have acted as catalysts and anchors for completely transforming 8 kilometers of coast from what was effectively an open industrial sewer into the city’s ‘seaside’. But, in addition to the sheer scale of ambition and transformation, there are clear strategic principles shaping this new urban structure. Throughout, the new beaches and marinas are bordered by a ribbon of leisure and sports parks (see Fig 4), which provide not just a buffer between the new urban neighbourhoods of the city and the exposed coast, but also a generous ‘green corridor’ in which the city’s orbital road system and rail network is embedded, hidden, landscaped – accommodated. This symbiosis between urban infrastructure, space and landscape is extended also to architecture when one observes how, in the new neighbourhoods bordering the park, it is the adoption of Cerda’s grid system that defines their order, scale and spatial syntax.
5
Hastings – study base
Hastings marks the eastern limit of our Strip-City and represents a microcosm of its ills and potential. To its immediate north and east lies the landscape of the Weald. Such juxtapositions of urbanised and protected landscapes characterise much of the coastal strip and intensify the tension between conflicting interests of growth and preservation, accessibility and isolation. The town’s historical significance predates its growth as a seaside resort. It acquired strategic importance under William of Normandy and maintained a sizeable fishing fleet well into the 20th century. As a resort, Hastings grew initially as a centre of a fashionable exclusive lifestyle. With the onset of the railways, however, its growth became so rapid that it effectively moved, creating a new town of promenades, arcadian vistas, grand hotels and elegant villas, and WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
291
leaving its former fishing settlement to fend for itself. Hastings retains a great deal of heritage – a legacy of its former elegant past as a thriving resort and of an earlier seafaring tradition. But despite promoting these historical assets the town has witnessed substantial decline over the last four decades. In attempts to redress this trend, a regeneration programme, which focuses on ‘education, business, broadband communication technology, transport and urban renaissance’ [9] is being orchestrated by SEEDA who have convened a development company – Sea Space – set up by the Hastings and Bexhill Task Force. Architects MBM (masterplanners, coincidentally, for Barcelona’s Olympic Village) have developed an urban masterplan for the two towns. Architectural competitions have been held, attracting names such as Foreign Office Architects, and Foster Associates. Greenwich, Brighton and Sussex universities have been involved in setting up new further and higher educational facilities there. This has led to significant building projects in the town. Large sites have been bought for development and regeneration programmes are underway for outlying housing estates. In the light of its precedent studies, the CC group wished to question those aspects of the regeneration programme which appeared to put faith in the creation of new buildings to provide urban regenerative impetus, rather than new urban spaces tied to new infrastructures. The group’s design projects, exploiting its academic removal from various firmly and justly held positions and imposed constraints, wished to explore the question of infrastructure and connectivity, transport and communication, seeing Hastings as a location within a larger cultural, political and geographical context – that of the Strip City – not as a series of architectural objects but as an urban landscape of movement and interaction.
6
The projects
Seven connected programmatic territories were investigated (see Fig 5), designed as contained urban spaces that sought to use the character of the seafront, radically readdress the town’s existing points of arrival and transform the edge along which town and water meet. Two of them are described here. 6.1 Environmental islands Behind the promenade, opposite the town’s pier, the land rises sharply before leveling out onto an area of playing fields – a ‘green island’. To the pier’s west runs a neglected covered walkway, incorporated into the sea defense wall. The scheme rests on a rejection of the coastal defense philosophy represented by this wall and proposes an offshore reef that opens up a new territory between it and the existing edge (see Fig 6). The placement of the reef creates two small bays, each one providing for a different leisure programme – nature and sport. Acting as a threshold between the two a combined linear building and raised route leads out from the inland green ‘island’, replacing the pier, accommodating a new hotel and spa and connecting one island to the other. The linear structure performs the role of the seaside pier and offers to hotel guests and promenaders WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
292 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI alike, the opportunity to look back at the town. Beneath the hotel, vehicular access is provided, connected to a sunken through road along the original seafront that allows this part of the promenade to become a linear park. Between the new pier and the west bay a canopy covers a range of outdoor sports facilities. These terminate at a long pool that runs back into the spa, lying beneath and extending out from the raised walkway between the hotel and the reef. From the hotel to the east, a series of boardwalks extend out to the dunes that make up the bay on this side. While the hotel structure provides the main architectural component in this scheme – the pier – the canopy and reef express the scheme’s environmental and engineering premise. Both provide a continuation of the environmental programme by supporting photovoltaic cells and wind turbines respectively, which power the complex. The historic idea of the resort that wishes to extol the healthy virtues of the sea is pursued through the creation of an entirely new landscape that is as radical, in its wish to give form to 21st century environmentalism as was the town’s 19th century transformation.
Figure 5:
Combined projects – highlighting the two described.
Figure 6:
Environmental islands.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
293
6.2 Coastal communities At the western end of the town a field marks the site of the former lido, which was still attracting thousands of visitors until the 1940s. At one end the main road turns in from the beach and allows direct connection between site and sea. This scheme explores the possibilities for higher living densities as a way of responding to high housing demand in the southeast, and a means to create the right circumstances for greater investment in transport infrastructure and using this to generate a spatial ‘gateway’ to the western end of the town. By seeing Strip-City as a location worthy of urban intensification, the scheme seeks to define a set of principles for urban housing development that is generically responsive to the uniqueness of coastal locations. Strategically, two alternative routes that run parallel to the coast – Boulevard and Park – are countered by a democratic response to seaside development, which orientates housing perpendicular to the shore (see Fig 7). The Boulevard forms a northern built edge to the site from which housing runs south toward the beach, cut through by the Park on its way, which connects it to the local facilities contained therein, and makes a clear distinction between housing immediately next to the sea and that which is set further back, between Park and Boulevard. New urban spaces at the east and west end of the site, directly addressing main coastal and London line stations, acquire significance by defining the points at which Boulevard and Park split and converge. Between the two, the Boulevard creates an urban spatial quality and scale that can accommodate the main road, the scale and mass of housing and the activities generated by the ground and first floor mixed uses. The Park, which runs at a lower level on this sloping site, creates a contrastingly informal vista through the development and is focused around a continuous body of water, fed by an existing stream. At the Park’s eastern end the water has a recreational use, so reinstating the lido memory. To the west, water and park gradually take on an environmental programme, filtering ‘grey water’ and providing ‘soft’ coastal protection.
7
Conclusion
Urban ambition and inventiveness characterised the way in which towns such as Hastings transformed themselves when faced with the overwhelming demands of industrialized tourism. The decline that has befallen most seaside towns stems in part from a process of retreat over the past half-century from the idea of transport infrastructure as a useful regenerative force for urban design (as witnessed in Barcelona) to the singular degenerative question of whether or not urban transport is profitable [10]. This is not to say that agencies such as SEEDA are in any way lacking in determination, and we have seen how countless regeneration programmes for coastal settlements have emerged in the last decade. Nevertheless, the demands faced are no less challenging than those of the 19th century and rely for their success upon a coherent view of urban movement and spatial connectivity. The studio’s studies have approached the subject of urban regeneration from a position that uses the spatial, cultural and infrastructural linkages – squares, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
294 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI parks and routes – as the starting point. They consider the needs of the town sufficient to demand urban redefinition that is radical but which utilizes its reciprocity with the sea – its one constant resource – and a drive towards making that resource accessible.
Figure 7:
Coastal communities.
Each design scenario attempts to explore the limits of the land-sea edge condition and to use the possibilities offered by the simultaneous but conflicting requirements of openness to and shelter from the sea. It is this fundamental conflict between the sea’s ability to attract and to threaten that encapsulates the uniqueness of the coastal town. In such towns we are presented with the biggest of urban spaces – one that ends at the horizon. That space defined the scale of the 19th century promenade – a place for urban spectacle and movement – and it could define the spatial syntax of the 21st century seaside town.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
Maas W, Costa Ibirica, Actar, 52-69, 1999 Theroux P, The Kingdom by the Sea, Penguin, 46-47, 199, 326-328, 1983 Pevsner N & Nairn I, The Buildings of England, Penguin, Sussex, 62-64, 1965 Theroux P, The Kingdom by the Sea, Penguin, 199, 1983 Based upon 2001 census records for all local authorities within defined area AA-advised journey times and National Rail, 2005 Montiel JC, Clos O, Zafon JL, Gual C, Buhigas M, Barcelona in Progress, 2004, Lunwerg Gausa M, Cervello M, Pla M, Barcelona: A Guide to its Modern Architecture, Section A, 2002, Actar Sea Space publication, Hastings and Bexhill Renaissance, 2004 Theroux P, The Kingdom by the Sea, Penguin, 326-328, 1983 WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
295
Petrol consumption towards unsustainable development: Iranian case study S. B. Imandoust Payam Noor University, Iran
Abstract One of the most important economic problems in Iran is petrol consumption. In fact, one litre of petrol in Iran is cheaper than one bottle of drinking water. Every year the government pays a large sum of money for imported petrol as well as petrol subsidies. Thus people consume it in an inefficient manner and petrol smuggling is a very popular job especially near boundaries. In the current Iranian year (21st March 2006–20th March 2007) about seventy million litres of petrol were consumed daily in Iran (the biggest petrol importer in the Middle East). This research reports the trend of petrol consumption during the last two decades and studies different scenarios for making decisions about petrol pricing and consumption. Finally some suggestions are presented for correcting the petrol consumption pattern. Keywords: petrol consumption, unsustainable development, petrol pricing.
1
Introduction
One of the most important threats against sustainable development in Iran is energy subsidies. About 17.5% of GDP (gross domestic production) is allocated to energy subsidies every year. More than 25% of GDP is allocated to total subsidies in Iranian economics. The petrol price in Iran is about 9 cents per litre, so people consume it in a uneconomic manner. Official data shows during the last five years petrol consumption increased 10% yearly. In the current year about 70 million litres have been consumed daily by Iranians [1]. From the environmental point of view this level of petrol consumption caused high levels of air pollution especially in big cities and because of that Tehran (capital of Iran) is one of the most air polluted cities in the world. Because of its cheap price smugglers have high motivation for petrol smuggling. Although Iran is the fourth WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070281
296 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI biggest petroleum producer in the world it simultaneously imports petrol from abroad. For example in the financial year 2006-07 about 4 billion US dollars of petrol was imported by the Iranian government, in other words Iran is the biggest petrol importer in the Middle East. Among 12 Middle East countries, 31% of energy production is consumed in Iran. In fact, all refinery production has the lowest price in Iran compared to other countries. Figure 1 demonstrates the trend of daily petrol consumption in Iran during the last 30 years [2].
8000
Daily petrol cosumption 1000 litre
7000 6000 5000 Series1
4000
Series2
3000 2000 1000 0
1
3
5
Figure 1:
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
29
31
Petrol consumption trend 1976-2006.
Figure 1 shows about seventy million litres of petrol have been burnt per day during the year 2006, it means during 30 years the petrol consumption increased by a factor of seven (1976–2006). At the beginning months of 2007 petrol consumption was beyond seventy million litres per day (unofficial announcement).
2
Petrol consumption in the OPEC countries
Petrol is one of the most important refined products in the world and about 98% of it is consumed in the transport sector. Because of economic and population growth during the last decade petrol consumption has rapidly increased among WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
297
OPEC countries. Table 1 demonstrates petrol consumption during 1999-2005 (1000 barrels per day). Although Indonesia and Nigeria have more population than Iran (218 and 132 million) the Iranian people's consumption is the biggest amount among other OPEC members [3]. Table 1:
Petrol consumption in OPEC countries (1000 b/d), 1999-2005.
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
% Change 05/04
43.1
42.3
41.3
41.0
40.0
41.3
47.2
14.2
INDONESIA
198.8
213.6
220.8
235.5
252.0
282.1
300.8
6.6
IRAN
213.2
225.0
256.8
298.1
336.1
375.3
413.5
10.2
IRAQ
69.1
77.2
83.4
84.8
68.9
78.8
80.6
2.4
KUWAIT
39.4
36.3
40.3
42.3
44.0
46.7
49.1
5.2
LIBYAN
38.2
42.2
42.4
45.5
46.6
49.6
54.1
9.1
NIGERIA
85.2
105.7
127.8
134.9
136.6
146.1
164.3
12.5
QATAR SAUDI ARABIA UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
11.0
11.7
12.5
15.8
13.4
14.3
16.7
17.3
269.8
273.3
282.3
301.2
311.2
330.7
350.3
5.9
37.3
45.5
55.5
65.8
72.5
72.0
75.3
4.5
219.5
239.2
245.8
234.5
222.9
232.4
240.1
3.3
ALGERIA
VENEZUELA
Source: OPEC annual statistics. Table 1 shows a 10% increase in 2004-05 for Iran. Among different areas in the world, North America, with 45.4% is the biggest and Africa with 2.7% has the smallest share for petrol consumption. Nowadays the share of petrol consumption in North America has decreased because of high economic growth in China and India.
3
Previous research about petrol consumption
Fortunately I have found precise scientific research about the economic aspects of petrol in Iran that has been carried out by academic persons but unfortunately the governmental officials did not pay attention to these efforts properly. It seems uneconomic considerations have played a first role in this issue. One of the best studies has been done by Khataie [4]; he estimated demand and elasticity of petrol from the period of 1981–2003 and forecast the future of petrol WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
298 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI consumption using the ARDL (Autoregressive distributed lag modelling approach). As the basis of his study the petrol demand model was introduced as follows: CG=f (RPG, POP, TK, Y, A)
(1)
CG=total demand of petrol RPG=real price of petrol POP = population TK=number of cars Y=national income A= average life of car in Iran
dCG ≥0 dPOP
dCG dCG dCG dCG ≥0 ≥0 ≤0 ≥0 dY dA dRPG dTK
(2)
Thus for the period 1981–2003 with the use of the ARDL approach the demand equation is estimated as follows: CG=11085 - 18.5 RPG + 0.0056TK -6037 D84
(3)
D84 is a dummy variable and demonstrates a decrease of oil income in the year 1984. Because the other parameters were not significant the researcher deleted them. As the equation shows there is a weak negative relationship between real petrol price and total petrol demand. Thus, if the government increase the petrol price the demand level will not change drastically. But the number of cars affects the petrol consumption positively. Abounoori [5] utilised a logarithmic function for estimating the petrol demand function with a OLS (ordinary least squares) approach. He estimated the following equation: Log Clit=9.37+.0575 log Veh+.0188logNI-0.121 log PP+0.851 log POP (4) where Clit=petrol consumption Veh = number of vehicle NI=national income PP=real petrol income POP=population From an economical aspect in this equation the parameters are elasticity coefficients. So we can conclude that petrol demand has a low sensitivity ratio with price. Thus, if government raise prices people will not change their demand significantly. This is because of a lack of appropriate public transport in big cities.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
299
Moreover every year one million new cars are added to previous cars with a high average of consumption, most of the cars in Iran have four cylinders and burn more than ten litres of petrol per kilometre. In Iran only a few companies produce cars and all of them belong to the government so no competition exists; they have been supported by the government during the last two decades. They have provided low quality cars with high average petrol consumption and people have to buy their products. Although petrol is cheaper than in other countries, the car is more expensive. Figure 2 compares real and nominal petrol prices in Iran during 1967–2006. 900
800
700
Price(Rial/litre)
600
500 Nominal Real
400
300
200
100
19 67 19 70 19 73 19 76 19 79 19 82 19 85 19 88 19 91 19 94 19 97 20 00 20 03
0
Year
Figure 2:
Real and nominal petrol prices (Rial/litre) 1967-2006 [6].
I should mention here because of structural inflation in the Iranian economic system, we have a big gap between real and nominal petrol prices. As can be seen in figure 2 the real petrol price has not varied very much but simultaneously WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
300 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI the nominal price in most years has risen drastically. The vertical axis presents the price of petrol in Iranian currency (Rial) per litre (9300Rials=1$). In fact in recent years the real price has decreased although the variation is small. If we compare figures 1 and 2 we can easily conclude that the nominal price and petrol consumption move in the same way, thus we can say petrol is an inelastic commodity in Iran.
4
Different scenario for petrol pricing
Nowadays petrol pricing is the most critical issue that the Iranian government and parliament are facing. After long discussions between government officials no clear results have emerged about petrol price. In fact most economists and some parliament members believe that the price should be modified slowly until arriving at the real world price. But the government officials reject that and argue about the inflationary effect of this policy. In the next part of the paper a different manner that can be considered will be noticed. 4.1 First scenario: continuing of present situation This means petrol should be imported and distributed without efficient management and at the present 9 cents per litre. Naturally if we follow this policy inefficient consumption, smuggling, air pollution, traffic jams, no motivation for producing low average car… will go on. Yet people remain happy and enjoy the cheap price. 4.2 Second scenario: rising price As it was proven by previous researches as well as in figures 1 and 2, with the increase of price, demand will not decrease significantly unless price increases drastically. This causes high inflation and decrease of car demand so unemployment also increases. On the other side petrol consumption, smuggling, air pollution will be reduced. 4.3 Third scenario: quota system for internal production and world price for imported petrol If we can separate high income consumers and low income consumers, this policy works otherwise the price gap will create artificial profit. On the other side, most of the old and high average cars belong to low income people. So this policy affects them and an unjust distribution will arise. But it reduces consumption, smuggling and simultaneously creates motivation for low average car, regulating car engines. 4.4 Fourth scenario: quota system for internal production without import Data shows the average petrol production in nine refineries is about 43 million litres daily. This amount of production can be enough only if private cars use 2.5 WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
301
and public cars 25 litres per day. Simultaneously public cars should use CNG as a fuel so double-burn cars should substitute the old cars as well as taxis. This policy reduces petrol consumption and air pollution but most probably black market for petrol will appear. 4.5 Distribution of wise card for efficient management Recently a wise card has been sent to car owners throughout the country, they help to control consumption and calculate real data. Although many experts are doubtful of this approach the policy has not started practically. Many people announced that they had not received their wise card and nobody knows what will happen in the future. Will this policy work or not? Time itself will show us the truth.
5
Conclusion
The trend of petrol consumption in Iran pushes the country towards unsustainable development. More than 70 million litres of petrol have been burnt daily and have caused air pollution, traffic jams, wasting time and money, eye and lung diseases. Moreover a big share of the national income is allocated to imported petrol from abroad. On account of official data during the last two decades, the nominal price is always raised but consumption also had the same situation. Different factors made this situation, for example lack of easy and efficient public transportation, population growth, existence of old and high average cars and cheap petrol price. For improving this situation many efforts should be considered. First petrol price should approach the real world price. Second public transportation should be constructed and expanded as soon as possible. Driving and producing the old and high average cars should be banned. Finally if we expand electronic services via the internet for bill payments, shopping, registration etc, this affects traffic as well as petrol consumption.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
Moradi, H., Petrol price modification. Economic Development Monthly (Farsi), 10, pp.6-8, 2007. Petroleum ministry of Iran, Iranian national company of refinery products distribution, statistics office, 2006. OPEC, www.opec.org Khataie. M, Analyze of elasticity and demand of petrol in Iran, Iranian Economic Research Quarterly (Farsi), 25, pp. 23-46, 2006. Abounoori, A., Estimation of petrol demand in Iran. Economic Research Journal (Farsi), 28, pp. 205-229, 2006. Petroleum ministry of Iran, Iranian national company of refinery products distribution, statistics office, 1966-2006.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
303
HIV/AIDS morbidity/mortality, access to social support and household utilization of natural resources in Ngamiland, Botswana B. N. Ngwenya1 & O. T. Thakadu2 1
University of Botswana, Harry Oppenheimer Okavango Research Centre, Botswana 2 Agricultural Education and Communication, University of Florida, USA
Abstract The dynamics of household response to AIDS impacts are complex and differ according to the severity of illness, multiplicity/frequency of death occurrences, availability and access to support structures as well as survival strategies embedded in the context of culture and biodiversity. This paper focuses on household responses to AIDS related stressors and utilization of natural resources by communities involved in Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM) projects in Ngamiland, in north western Botswana. The study involved two single village and two multi-village community trusts. Data were collected through a simple random sampling of 121 households obtained from the 2001 national population census enumeration areas. The results showed that households in CBNRM villages have diverse sources of livelihoods such as farming; basket making and government assistance, sale of grass and reeds, fishing and remittances. More than half of sampled households had orphans, 68% had a continuously ill person (CIP) in the last five years, and, of these, 63% had died within the past year. Affected households received support primarily from the extended family, neighbours, church groups and friends. The study concludes that, in Ngamiland, access to external/formal and internal/informal social support mediates HIV/AIDS related morbidity and mortality, and helps households cushion the environmental impacts of AIDS by acting as a buffer against selection and over utilization of natural resources. Keywords: HIV/AIDS, CBNRM, natural resources management, social support.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070291
304 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Natural resources represent a central component of rural livelihoods. Impacts of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in Botswana society cut across natural and non-natural resource based livelihood systems. To date, the environmental dimension of HIV/AIDS morbidity (and mortality) has received limited attention. Numerous case studies have been conducted on the linkages between HIV/AIDS and natural resources management in Kenya, Namibia, South Africa [6, 8], Uganda [12], Malawi [4, 10] and elsewhere [1]. Furthermore, Hunter and Twine [7] and Erskine [5] have not only established the impact of HIV/AIDS on natural resources management, but also provide insights on how to mitigate its effects [11]. This paper builds on the few studies that assess the impacts of HIV/AIDS on natural resources utilization and access with particular reference to Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM) in Botswana. CBNRM projects in the country constitute an important national strategy for combating poverty in rural communities – by creating employment – and for promoting sustainable use of natural resources [9]. In addition, CBNRM programmes offer a workable opportunity to address HIV/AIDS impacts on natural resources (water, forest, soil, wildlife, land, fisheries, veld products and conservation issues) [13]. In Botswana, HIV/AIDS prevalence varies from as low as 15% to as high as 40% in some districts [3]. National figures however; camouflage the severity of impacts on specific livelihood systems (such as CBNRM). Disaggregated data can only be obtained through systematic assessment of micro impacts in particular communities and livelihood systems, without necessarily down playing macro effects of the epidemic. 1.1 Objectives of the study The overall aim of the study was to assess the prevalence of HIV/AIDS morbidity/mortality in relation to utilization of natural resources in CBNRM communities in rural Botswana. The specific objectives of the study were to: 1. 2. 3.
2
Assess the prevalence of HIV/AIDS related mortality and morbidity in CBNRM areas in Ngamiland. Investigate sources of support for affected households to mitigate the impacts of the disease. Investigate the impacts of the disease on access to, selection and utilization of natural resources in CBNRM communities in Ngamiland.
Study setting
The study was based in Ngamiland district in the north-western part of Botswana. The Okavango Delta, a Ramsar wetland of international importance, is also located in Ngamiland. The Okavango Delta is rich in biodiversity which WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
305
is essential to the livelihoods of populations inhabiting the area. There is a high concentration of CBNRM activities in Ngamiland: for instance, there are twentyone CBNRM community based organizations (CBOs) trusts in Ngamiland covering at least sixty-three villages in the district. Also, Ngamiland CBNRM CBOs are among the highest income generating institutions. Also, the district is home to some of the oldest CBNRM trusts in the country operated by one single joint venture partner since inception. Although rich in natural and CBNRM institutional capital capable of impacting positively on livelihoods, several factors disadvantage Ngamiland. HIV/AIDS prevalence in the district is high and there is a low concentration of both HIV/AIDS service NGOs/CBOs (to complement government programs) and poor formal HIV/AIDS service delivery infrastructure compared to the rest of the country. There is high prevalence of HIV infection, for instance, amongst the 25-49 year age group (36% and 29% in Ngamiland South and North respectively) [3]. This suggests that the epidemic targets the most productive age group, which contains those who are the main participants in CBNRM related economic activities. The district is ideal, therefore, for assessing household HIV/AIDS related stressors with regard to access, selection and utilization of natural resources. Table 1:
Villages and sampled household.
Name of Trust Mababe Zokotshama Community Development Trust Sankuyo Okavango Community Trust
Kopano Mokoro Community Trust
Village Mababe
No. sampled Households 22
Sankuyo Seronga Gudigwa Eretsha Boro 2 Xaxaba Xharaxao
15 34 12 7 12 10 9 121
Total
2.1 Sampling and data collection methods The study involved eight villages, two single village community trusts, namely, Sankuyo Tshwaragano Management Trust (STMT) and Mababe Zokotshama Community Development Trust (MZCDT), and two multi-village community trusts: Okavango Community Trust (OCT) and Okavango Kopano Mokoro Community Trust (OKMCT) (Table 1). A simple random sampling of 12% of households was carried out based on the 2001 national population census enumeration areas. A total of 121 households were sampled from Sankuyo (STMT), Mababe (MZCDT), Seronga, Eretsha and Gudigwa (OCT villages) and Boro 2, Xaxaba and Xharaxao (OKMCT). This was a cross-sectional survey in which data collection was through face-to-face administration of structured interviews. Household heads or mature household representatives were interviewed in situations where the de facto head was unavailable or WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
306 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI incapacitated. Informal interviews were used to collect additional information about HIV/AIDS and CBNRM issues from health care officials and CBNRM/CBO project leaders/facilitators.
3 Study findings 3.1 Socio-economic profile and access to HIV/AIDS information A total of 121 respondents from sampled households were interviewed, of these 38.8% were male, 61.2% female, over half never married (52.9%) and 21.5% were living together, 16.5% married, 2.5% divorced and 6.6% widowed. The average age of the respondents was 42.6 years. Household size varied from 0-5 members (45%); 5-10 (38%) and 10+ (16.5%). Overall, the level of human capital development of respondents tends to be low because 43.0% have had no schooling, 25.6% had primary education, 29.8% secondary and 1.9% tertiary. As expected, most respondents had heard about HIV/AIDS, were knowledgeable about how the disease is transmitted and could correctly identify how a person can get infected. CBNRM communities have access to HIV/AIDS information (through radio, health clinics, community meetings, and workshops). People also were conversant about what to do when ill including what to do to reduce sexual re-infection and maintaining a healthy life style. 3.2 Primary sources of livelihoods Households in CBNRM communities have diverse sources of livelihood. The importance of natural resource and non-natural resource based livelihood activities in these communities tends to fall within the primary–secondary continuum. In any given seasonal/food calendar, some activities are carried out sequentially, others are done simultaneously. The sources of income in sampled villages include farming (51.2%); cash employment from CBNRM joint partnerships (40%); basket making and government assistance (25%) respectively; poling, sale of grass or reeds (15%); fishing, sale of traditional beer and receipt of remittances (12%). However, residents of single village CBNRM communities such as Sankuyo and Mababe tend to benefit most from joint venture formal employment. Respondents were asked to rank order sources of income. The first most important source of income was formal employment (80%), CBNRM employment (64.6%), farming (54.7%), poling and sale of traditional beer, (50%), basket making (24%), receipt of government social welfare assistance (16%), and thatching grass, hawking and remittances. This was followed by remittances (77.8%), fishing (43.8), thatching grass/reeds (37.7%), poling (35%), basket making (32%), farming (26.4%) and CBNRM employment (21.7%) respectively. The third most important sources of income were fishing (50%), basket making (44%), government assistance (43.3%) and farming (18.9%) (Table 2). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 2:
Formal employment Cash employment form CBNRM Farming Fishing Basket making Poling Sale of crafts Sale of traditional beer Thatching grass/reeds Hawking Remittances Government assistance
307
Rank ordered sources of income. % 1st Most important 80
% 2nd most important 13.3
% 3rd Most important 6.7
64.6
21.7
8.7
54.7 6.3 24.0 50.0 50 12.5 12.5 11.1 16.7
26.4 43.8 32.0 35.0 6.0 30 37.5 7.5 77.8 4.0
18.9 50.0 44.0 15.0 4.0 2. 0 5. 0 12.5 11.1 43.3
N 45 23 53 16 25 20 5 10 8 8 9 30
3.3 Morbidity, mortality and access to support 3.3.1 Orphans The presence of orphans has been used as proxy indicator of death of parents most likely due to AIDS. More than half of households in CBNRM communities had absorbed orphans, ranging from 1 to 6. The incidence of orphanhood differed from one village to another due to differential HIV infection rates. In Botswana, orphans registered with the Orphan Care Desk Office (which is located in the Social and Community Development Department (S&CD)), receive assistance. In the study area, at least 67.9% received a supplementary food basket and psychosocial support from social workers. Other sources of material and emotional support came from the extended family (64%), neighbours (32.7%), Trust (26%) and social welfare groups (12.8%). Contrary to expectation, support from extended family was rated as helpful (78%), neighbours (55%), followed by friends (28.6%) and church groups (26.3%). 3.3.2 Morbidity, mortality and access to health services Approximately 68.4% of households had a continuously ill person (CIP) in the last five years. Slightly more than half of CIP patients were males. The number of CIPs in these household varied from one to numerous, for instance, 38% had one CIP, 17% two, 10% had three, 7% had four and 6% had five and above. Villages of Eretsha and Xaxaba appear to have been most affected, followed by Xharaxao and Seronga. The majority of respondents (55%) indicated that the CIPs were primary providers. These were farmers and trust or government employees. In Mababe, Xaxaba, Eretsha and Sankuyo, more than 80% of CIPs were primary providers who worked for Trust Joint Venture partnerships. Overall, 53.4% CIPs were cared for less than one year, 21.6% for one year, 12.5% for two years, 5.7% for three years and 6.8% for four years and above. Several factors contributed to WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
308 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI variations in length of care giving period. These included the fact that about 62.9% of patients care for died within a year, 28.1% were alive, and 9.0% died after several years. Informal interviews with family members suggested that early HIV testing, acceptance and disclosure of HIV status to a confidant, family de-stigmatization, patient access to and adherence to treatment regimes such as antiretroviral drugs (ARVs) and TB treatment were important life or death determining factors. Self-disclosure was apparent since about 38.2% of caregivers knew the HIV status of their patient. Approximately 44.8% patients were HIV+, some were either on ARV or TB treatment or in the process of ARV enrolment. Although the medical model seems to predominate in HIV/AIDS intervention (prevention, care and support) country wide, villagers in the study area tend to straddle modern and traditional health care systems; the difference is a matter of degree. The villages of Maun and Gumare have officially registered associations of traditional healers and they also have primary hospitals and clinics. Diversity of treatment options, implicitly or explicitly, gives affected individuals in rural settings some flexibility. In households where there was more than one CIP over the last five years, some care givers nursed the sick people simultaneously (17.8%) while others did so sequentially (77.8%). Caring for one CIP after another regardless of the sequence of episodes disrupted household economic activities. Response strategies included abandoning economic activities to care for the patient (37%), reducing labour time (26.9%), struggling to survive one day at a time or switching to alternative activities (6.4%). However, some respondents (15.4%) indicated that caregiving did not affect household regular economic activities. Follow up interviews suggested that where a CIP has either been chronically unemployed, their illness and or demise had limited impact on household livelihood activities (especially where support from close family members was forthcoming). Only 1% of affected household sold some assets to cope with illness. 3.4 Care and support Households affected by death or illness in CBNRM communities received care and support from a range of sources. Extended family members (64.6%) and neighbours (37.7%) appear to be key social actors in providing social relief to households in distress. Church groups (33.8%) and friends (29.9%) are also important sources in the care and support continuum. Overall, support from extended family was considered helpful, followed by church groups and neighbours. Kinds of assistance provided included emotional support (79.4%), food provision and preparation (65.1%), financial support (50%), collection of water and wood (48.2%), cleaning yard and house (43.1%) and collection of medicine (29.6%). However, informal interviews suggest that many villagers maintain multiple residences. The “parallel outward” flow of the sick, dying or dead from Mababe and Sankuyo for instance, is to some extent due to ‘enclave” settlements in Maun or Seronga and or, for lack of a better concept, “multiple or dispersed WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
309
residences” across villages. ‘Enclave” settlements have emerged within existing Maun wards (kgotla) such as in Sedie or Botsabelo. These sub-groups own a residential plot/s, migrate seasonally or intermittently live and or do temporal or ‘piece jobs’ opportunistically in these localities. It appears that Mababe and Sankuyo experienced complex “parallel outward,” intra-district migration of young people. One group migrated from remote rural areas to “urban villages” such Maun, Gumare or Seronga in search of formal employment. When they became seriously ill, they are less likely to return to their home village, and if they die, they were most likely to be buried in Maun. Another group opted to stay in the village of birth and was mostly likely to be employed by safari companies in Joint Venture Partnerships. However, when they became ill, they were more likely to migrate to Maun not only to have access to better health facilities, but also to be cared for and supported by kin members living there. In both scenarios, access to kinship support networks and health care facilitates appears to stimulate and sustain outward migration flows. The strength of social and institutional ties within CBNRM communities, therefore, is an important response strategy for household under HIV/AIDS related stressors (illness or death). 3.5 Morbidity and utilization of natural resources With regard to collection and use of natural resources prior to chronic illness episodes, the majority of respondents (95.9%) indicated that they collected firewood for use, 5.5% collected it for sale during normal period and only 3.3% indicated that they sold it as a coping mechanism during illness episode. Likewise, the majority (84.3%) harvest grass for domestic use, 24.2% for commercial purpose and 8.3% sold during illness. Again food plants were also harvested for domestic use (71.9%), whereas 10% for sale and 5.8% sold during illness. With regard to medicinal plants, 28% indicated that they harvested for daily consumption and only 1.7% for sale. Informal interviews revealed that wild foods plants include Berchemia discolor Bird plum (motsintsila), Grewia sp. and Brandy bush (moretlwa). Medicinal plants are harvested to treat a wide range of health conditions (coughs and colds in children, pregnancy and child birth, old age related chronic conditions and so on). Interestingly, none of the respondents claimed harvesting medicinal plants as an income generating coping mechanism during illness. Disaggregated data however, suggest that 50% and 33% of households in Xaxaba and Xharaxao respectively, sold reeds, and 44% and 42% sold grass thatching as response mechanism for social distress. Sale of food plants was evident in Gudigwa, Seronga and Xaxaba. The latter village appears to rely on harvesting natural resources, especially grass and reeds, for both subsistence and commercial purposes, and also during normal and distressed periods.
4
Discussion
Compared to other districts in the eastern part of the country, human capital development (as measured by level of educational attainment) in Ngamiland is WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
310 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI low. It is thus not surprising that a significant proportion of respondents have no formal schooling. Chronic illness and mortality further erode the human capital base of affected households. Inevitably, death changes household composition, for instance, by increasing the number of orphaned children, reducing access to or re-allocation of experienced labour in production sectors such as CBNRM, farming, cash employment and other income generating activities. Paradoxically, death can also bring psychosocial relief in that the event free caregivers to switch from ‘invisible,’ uncounted non-market caregiving activities to ‘visible,’ quantifiable market undertakings. Also, absorbing orphans reconfigures household composition. This can have both positive and negative effects on household human and financial capital. On the negative side, if the orphan is young and requires care, extra labour demands are placed on the caregivers. However, access to support from extended family and or neighbours helps orphan-recipient households to cushion negative effects. On the positive side, absorption of older orphans could mean provision of extra labour, direct financial and material welfare benefits from government or donor agencies. Clearly receipt of remittances and government assistance, are the most important for 11% and 16% of households in the study area. A welfare benefit, such as a social pension, facilitates labour migration and female pension recipients in the household reduce the probability of a male leaving the household and have the opposite effect on women’s migration [2]. More research is needed to establish, for example, the link, if any, between social welfare programs ‘parallel outward’ migrations from CBNRM communities to ‘enclave’ settlement in ‘urban villages.’ Although respondents admit to consulting various health care systems in the village for various ailments, they are, however, quick to point out that AIDS related conditions are better handled in clinics or hospitals. Access to health systems (modern and traditional) also contributes towards minimizing the impacts of HIV/AIDS on utilization of natural resources as first line of defence. The strength of, and access to, kin and non-kin based social relationships (or social capital) matters in CBNRM villages. Sources of material and psychosocial/emotional support networks include those from formal (from government and NGOs/CBOs) and informal (extended family, neighbours and remittances). The forms of support flowing from these include gifts, childcare, home visitation and labour sharing arrangements especially by close family members and neighbours. Affected households in all villages in the study appear to have very strong social support structures to draw upon during times of distress, especially from extended family and neighbours. Variations are expected of course, with some households having more support (and therefore less vulnerable to negative effects of AIDS related mortality and morbidity) and others, less. Although seemingly mundane, these are critical elements that mediate response strategies of households under distress particularly with regard to utilization of natural resources in the Okavango Delta. Access to financial capital (cash income) through sustained cash employment helps reduce household vulnerability to negative impacts of the disease. Also, CBNRM villages in the Okavango Delta have an abundance of natural capital WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
311
(forest, reeds, grass, water, land, and fish) that is largely utilized for domestic purposes and for commercial purposes on a limited scale. Furthermore, few households sold veld products specifically as a distress response strategy, especially in Seronga and Gudigwa. Xaxaba village is inside the Delta and most residents work for safari camps, but the majority originates from Seronga, where access to waterway transport makes the village a potentially good market for reed/grass. Residents of Xharaxao and Boro 2 are also a stone’s throw away from Maun, a likely market for thatching grass (for domestic and business purposes). 4.1 Conclusion Response strategies of AIDS affected households in Ngamiland can be better understood in relation to access and utilization of natural and non-natural based resources or ‘assets’ available to a household as well as the enabling social and institutional relations. AIDS related morbidity may induce changes that are likely to shape household access, collection, utilization and conservation of key natural resources in their locality. The study has shown that social support structures and kinship networks mediate HIV/AIDS related stressors such as chronic illness and death and potentially act as a buffer against AIDS affected households from adopting response mechanisms that could have ‘erosive’ effects on natural resource access and utilization. Joint venture partnerships in CBNRM communities not only create employment opportunities, but also implicitly prevent the collapse of social support systems, for instance by providing transport for the ill, dying or dead, and social welfare provision to orphans and the elderly. Demonstrated extended family support and good “neighbourliness” in the study areas should be interpreted in the broader context of enabling social and institutional relations.
References [1] [2]
[3] [4] [5]
AIDS Brief. CBNRM Brief for Sectoral Planners and Managers. Development Alternatives, USAID. http://www.frameweb.org/ Barrientos, A. Non-contributory Pensions and Poverty Reduction in Brazil and South Africa, Department of International Development, University of Manchester. http://www/ds.ac.uk/ids/pvt/pdf-files/non-contributory_ pensions.pdf Central Statistics Office (CSO). Botswana AIDS Impact Survey (BAIS II), Ministry of Finance and Development Planning. Gaborone, 2004 COMPASS. Impacts of HIV/AIDS on Natural Resource Management in Malawi. Document 55. Blantyre, 2003 Erskine, S. Red Ribbons and Green Issues: Exploring HIV/AIDS as an Environmental Concern. Health Economics and HIV/AIDS Research Division (HEARD). University of KwaZulu-Natal, http://www.hivan.org.za/admin/documents/Red%20Ribbons%20and%20 Green%20Issues.doc. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
312 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [6] [7]
[8] [9]
[10]
[11] [12]
[13]
Freeman, P. H. CBNRM and AIDS in Bushbuckridge, Northern Province. South Africa. An Exploratory Geographic Analysis. South Africa, http://www.popline.org/doc/1564/174389.html Hunter, L., & Twine, W. Adult Mortality, Natural Resources and Food Security: Evidence from the Agincourt field site in rural South Africa. Centre for African Ecology, University of Witwatersrand, South Africa, 2005 Johnson, T. Challenges and Responses to Impacts of HIV/AIDS on CBNRM in a Trans-boundary Context. South Africa. 2002. Kgathi, D. L. & Ngwenya, B. N. Community Based Natural Resource Management and Social Sustainability in Botswana: Implications for Natural Resource Management Botswana: Botswana Notes and Record (Special Edition) 37, pp61-79. 2005 Mauambeta, D. D. C. HIV/AIDS Mainstreaming in Conservation: The Case of Wildlife and Environmental Society of Malawi. http://www.rmportal.net/library/hh_main/hh_hivaids/HiVandConservation -Mainstreaming.pdf/?searchterm=participatory%20planning. Oglethorpe, J., Gelman, N. HIV/AIDS and Conservation. Impacts and ways to reduce them. Fact sheet for the Conservation Community. http://www.frameweb.org/ Ruhweza, A. Exploring the Relationship Between HIV/AIDS and Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM). Uganda. 2001 http://www.gbf.ch/ab_received.asp?no=37&lg=EN&app=&now=2#2 USAID. Bureau for Africa, Office of Sustainable Development. AIDS Briefs for Sectoral Planners and Managers: Community Based Natural Resource Management. 2005. http://www.afrsd.org/Environment/AIDS%20Brief-all-150%20res.pdf
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
313
Rural development in small mountainous settlements: case study of Bojnord region, North-eastern part of Iran M. Taleshi Payam Noor University, Iran
Abstract More than 47% of the rural settlements (32147 units) in Iran have been spatially categorized as mountainous, which are characterized with their small size of population. This means that more than 85% of these settlements (27385 units) have a population of less than 100 households. Though lack of water and soil resources have caused these small settlements to be dispersed along the country as small villages, these have unique spatial functions, i.e. the stabilization of population and exploitation of the limited and scattered natural resources. The mountainous rural settlements of the area under study have the same environmental-ecologic conditions as discussed above. This study has proved that, during the last two decades, the destructive processes governing the ecologic conditions of the area have reached their highest level and severely worsened the soil erosion and destruction of many pastures. Thus, in 1981 only 15% of these small settlements experienced unsustainable conditions, but this increased to 57% by the year 2001. Therefore, in order to keep up the functional role of the mountainous settlements in micro and macro-spatial-levels, we need first of all to drastically change our approaches to Strategic Plans and so to development procedures at local, regional and national levels. Thus, through supporting and encouraging the rural households, sustaining the small mountainous settlements could be possible! On the other hand, the participative efforts of the villagers in the establishment of NGO must be widely promoted. Thus, establishment and support of the informal popular institutions in different parts can lead to control of the destruction of natural sources. Moreover, the realization and guarantee of the stable production and income and the right change to the provision of common services can result in stable rural development in mountainous areas. Keywords: rural development, instability, small settlements, participation, nongovernmental organizations. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070301
314 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
In the 21st charter of the 13th chapter of the Rio Conference damageable mountainous perimeters were considered by scientists, especially natural resources, economists, geographers and other related researchers. Following this scientific event, the United Nation Organization named the year 2002 as the International Year of Mountains. In the ecological environment of mountains, rural settlements, especially small ones, are set in unstable conditions, and this instability will affect rural development. In this way, an excess of unstable conditions will have a direct effect on the process of poverty and social justice. Therefore, the process of instability in small mountainous settlements in the Aladagh region at the North-east of Iran as a mountainous region is considered in this paper, followed by recommendation of appropriate strategies for rural development in these settlements.
2
Region under study
Aladagh region lies at the North-east of Iran (between 37°, 15΄ to 37°, 39΄ North latitudes and 56°, 57΄ to 57°, 35΄ East longitudes). The area is 150400 hectares with 69 mountainous settlements with a population of 55737. The most important ranges of the region are; Qarabolagh with 1517 meters height, Shalakh with 1875 meters height, at the North of the region, Sefid bodagh 2459 m, Qaraghoy 2227 m, Ajan and Shimily 2150 m, Namazkhaneh 2455 m.
3
Assessment method of mountainous settlements instability
Considerations and assessments of various available approaches in sustainability for different aspects such as environmentally sustainable development, economic sustainable development, cultural sustainable development, physical-spatial sustainable development underwent a final selection. In this approach economic and environmental-economic, socio-cultural and physical-spatial structures and relations were considered. In this study, relations between sustainability and non-sustainability on rural settlements were considered through a series of effective factors.
4
Studies of effective factors
These included: Environmental/Ecological factors: 1) Settlement elevation 2) Water balance WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
315
3) Soil erosion 4) Force major damages (flood, earthquake) 5) Pasture demolition (Crown coverage amount) 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) 8)
Socio-economical factors: Immigration Literate ration Employment percentage Population density Supporting load Income per capita Agricultural lands distribution Percentage enjoyment of rural roads
1) 2) 3) 4)
Physical-spatial factors: Average monthly trips to city Average distance between settlements and city Percentage of rural owners residing in city Percentage of enjoying services by the people
Official planning factors: 1) Ratio between infrastructure credits and total credits of the village 2) Ratio between production affairs and total credits of the village 3) Ratio between social affairs and total credits of the village In this way, all settlements in the region were considered in three categories, non-sustainable, sustainable and semi-sustainable, and finally non-sustainability conditions were studied through statistical models and correlation equations.
5
Assessment results of non-sustainability conditions in rural settlements
According to studies on environmental-ecological factors, results show that for non-sustainability in small settlements based on geological factors (land slides and quakes), more than 65% of small settlements lie on unstable geological formations and 58% of settlements have non-sustainable conditions from a land slide point of view. On the other hand, 57% of small rural settlements are nonsustainable considering water resources. Soil erosion factor as a basic factor in demolishing of renewable resources in small settlements shows that in the year 1981 only 15% of these settlements had non-sustainable conditions, while as in the year 2001 this amount increased to 57%. The demolition of landscapes in small settlements shows that in the year 1981, 25% had non-sustainable conditions, whereas in 2001 it increased to 61%. Socio-economic factors in small mountainous settlements always show that annually 2.7% of rural employees are decreased and the unemployment rate increased annually by 6.8%. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
316 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The results of income and wealth distribution show that, in 1981, only 20% of the rural population did not own any land, while as in 2001 this amount increased to 50%. On the other hand, the results recommend that only 10% of the population have 50% of resources and wealth and the remaining 90% of the population have only 50% of income. Average income of each rural family residing in Aladagh region’s small settlements is less than 100$, which in comparison with other regions of the country and South-east of Asia, and even China is so little. Considerations on physical-spatial factors show that the distance between these settlements and 2nd grade urban centers is 25 km and more than 80% of these settlements have dirt access roads. On the other hand, 90% of these settlements have non-sustainable conditions of welfare facilities. More than 87% of residential buildings are made of low quality and low durability material, such as sun-dried bricks, woods and mud, intensifying its damageability. After lots of statistical considerations, it has been approved that, basically, some parts of the effective forces had an immediate (direct) affect on nonsustainability of small settlements. These immediate factors include six key factors, such as amount of soil erosion, pasture demolition, water balance, force major damages per capita, agricultural lands distribution and income per capita. Except water balance, the other five forces have a direct relation with nonsustainability of small mountainous settlements, so that, with increase in the amount of any immediate factors, the amount of non-sustainability processes increases basically. The second group of forces and effective factors have indirect rule. In fact, these factors do not affect directly the non-sustainability, but affect the six main factors, causing non-sustainability on small rural settlements. The complex equations of direct forces with indirect factors are identified by two equations, reverse (correlation coefficient zero to -1) and direct (correlation coefficient zero to +1). According to the final analysis, circumstances of equations and effective forces have been organized. Physical-spatial factors are in the 1st line, Socio-economical factors in the 2nd line, and enjoyment of services factor as transition factor between two other groups of factors, 3rd line consists of planning factors, like civil credits, and 4th line consists of elevation factors to consider the behavior and relation between effective factors on elevation conditions of rural settlements. Statistical analysis of physical-spatial factors showed that, as the distance between the settlement and the city increases, there is more intention to migrate by the owner. On the other hand, the distance between settlement and the city has a reverse connection with average monthly trips by villagers, because as the distance decreases, the trips to the city increase. The effects of these factors (physical-spatial) on direct factors are such that the percentage of owners in the city has a reverse connection on water balance. This means, as the number of owners residing in the city decreases, water
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
317
balance acts better. More clearly, a reverse connection between migration of owners and water balance can be approved. In socio-economical factors, employment rate has a reverse connection with enjoyment of services, because increase in the provision of services in mountainous settlements will decrease the employment percentage. Therefore, present service providing regulations in mountainous settlements do not increase employment facilities. Enjoyment of services has a reverse connection with immigration. Service facilities in mountainous settlements did not prevent the immigration of villagers, and more importantly, the enjoyment factor of rural roads shows a reverse connection with per capita income of villagers as an increase in enjoying rural roads per capita income of villagers’ decreases. More clearly, there are meaningful connections between enjoyment of rural roads, employment percentage and enjoyment of services with direct factors. Always, an increase of rural roads and the enjoyment of services coefficient per capita income decreases, and this affects directly the non-sustainability of settlements. In governmental credits, the amount of production credits is in reverse connection with pasture demolition. In fact, as the amount of production credits in mountainous settlements decreases, more pastures are demolished. On the other hand, this factor is in reverse connection with per capita force major damages.
Figure 1:
Applied patterns of relation between effective variables on unsustainability.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
318 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Therefore, the complex of ruling factors show that socio-economical factors affected from the country’s planning program (inattention to small settlements and tendency towards cities) had great effects on demolition of renewable resources (such as water, soil and pasture), resulting in a decrease of ecological capacities. This decrease caused, in a way, the decrease of bearing coefficient and population stabilization in small settlements.
6
Rural development plans
To leave partially non-sustainable conditions, all aspects of rural development should be considered uniformly and epidemically. More clearly, to access an epidemical rural development in mountainous settlements, the following pivots should be considered properly and effectively: • Appropriate protection and operation of basic resources. • Education of population concerning local issues in mountainous settlements. • Appropriate foundation for strengthening and extension of participation mentality (active, continuous and epidemical participation). • Increase in profitability of present economical facilities and creating spaces for new economical activities. • Growing living quality levels in mountainous settlements. • Modification and regulation of physical-spatial network of mountainous settlements to enjoy proper facilities and services. Therefore, to compile a sustainable planning regulation in mountainous settlements and by scrutinizing considered pivots (relying on sustainable development from physical-spatial point of view), the most important rural sustainable development plans are described: Ecologically Changing low efficiency dry farms into pastures Occasional pile irrigation Preservation and protection preservation Mechanical operations (reservoir dams, etc.) Socio-habitat Creation and development of proper training-cultural activities Strengthening the villager’s active and continuous role in participation Establishing appropriate private (non-governmental) organizations Growing living quality satisfaction in villagers (sanitary, clinical, consumption pattern facilities) Economically Modification and improvement of revenue methods from basic resources (increase in profitability) Making equal opportunities for all villagers to access credits and financial facilities (distribution of civil credits) Transformation of economical structures to persuade nongovernmental and private sector participation WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
319
Creating variety in economical activities Increasing employment opportunities for non-owners in nonagricultural and natural resources activities Physical-Spatially Reclamation of residential buildings, facilities and social welfares Sounding appropriate physical-spatial relations between rural and urban settlements Leveling of rural settlements to make balanced and sustainable relations among the settlements.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]
Barow, C.G., (1955), sustainable development: Concept, Value and Practice, Journal of Environment, Vol.14; Hamilton, L.S. 1995. The productive role of mountain forests. In: Mountain at Risk (N.J.R. Allan, ed.) Manohar, New Delhi, pp.49-69 Hanley, N, (1997) Macroeconomic Measures of sustainability: A survey and A Synthesis. Discussion papers in Ecological Economics 97/3, Deportment of Economics, University of Stirling, Stirling. UK Harris. M.J (2000) Basic Principles of sustainable development. Tufts. Univer. U.S.A Hicks (1946) sustainable development, University London press Jackson, T. and Marks, N (1994) Measuring Sustainable Economic Welfare: A pilot Index. Stockholm environment Institute / New economics foundation, Stockholm. Jansky Libor (2002) Global mountain research for sustainable development, UN University. UNDP (2002) Report Word Summon Development, Johannesburg.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
321
Green milieu: the milieu effects on sustainable development of watershed collaborations with a case study of the New York City Watershed Agreement J. Hoffman John Jay College of Criminal Justice of CUNY and the CUNY Doctoral Program, CUNY, New York, USA
Abstract Local economic development literature has directed attention to the “milieu” effects of local interactions among firms and with governments on the qualitative nature of economic development. This article introduces the concept of the green milieu: a local economic development climate that is conducive to promoting sustainable economic development and encourages a local area to succeed economically over the long run while protecting its environmental base. It argues that watershed collaborations can create such a milieu. New York City’s complex watershed collaboration is analyzed for the ingredients of a green milieu and its current record reviewed for indicators of success as a green milieu. Keywords: sustainable development, local development, watershed, collaboration, environmental regulation, milieu, New York City.
1
Introduction
A green milieu is a local economic development climate that is conducive to sustainable economic development. The intellectual underpinnings of this concept can be found in the discussion of adaptation to change found in four economic literatures. Local development literature analyzes the role in development of learning and the local interactions among firms and with government. The literature of sustainable development discusses the means of moving towards sustainability. The environmental regulation literature reports on the effectiveness of collaborative approaches to our non-point pollution problems because collaborations engage stakeholders and consideration of their economic concerns into the protection process and thus enhance cooperation. In the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070311
322 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI economics of crime literature legal responsiveness theory discusses the importance of the presence of legal means to adapt to economic change to crime prevention. A green milieu would be a local economic development climate which fostered interaction among economic actors that moved the economy towards sustainable development with legal means and the promotion of equity as a development characteristic. Watershed collaborations create information networks described as a factor of production in local development literature and have the explicit goals of environmental protection, legal compliance and are necessarily concerned with economic equity. Are Watershed collaborations creating green milieus? Examination of New York City’s nine year old very complex watershed collaboration offers the opportunity to explore collaboration as a green milieu. Section one of this paper reviews literature that contributes to the concept of a green milieu. Section two discusses what the indicators of both the existence and success of a green milieu would be. Section three examines watershed collaborations as green milieus. Section four analyses the components of New York City’s Watershed Collaboration for the ingredients of green milieu. Section five reviews New York City’s Collaboration outcomes for indicators of success as a green milieu. Section six summarizes the findings.
2 Background literature Local economic development literature discusses the adaptive capacity of local areas as an influence on their economic lives. Within this discussion access to knowledge and learning by firms have been identified as local development variables (Krugman [1] Camagni [2] Helmsing [3]). Helmsing [3] draws on work in evolutionary economics to describe firms as learning machines rather than rather than producers of specific products. Local places which are a network local residents, workers, businesses, governments, and non-profit organization can also be described learning machines. Markusen [4] moves in this direction in her work on “sticky places.” or metro areas that have been able to either persist or adapt. Her recommendation that local areas foster the health of the structure that characterizes them is essentially a recommendation to develop and maintain a learning milieu. The sustainable development literature recognizes the interdependence of the economy and environment and argues for economic incentives that lead towards environmental sustainability. The literature also recognizes that individuals and organizations must have sufficient income to afford the requirements of environmental protection (UNEP [5], Daly [6], Hoffman [7]). The environmental regulation literature like that of local development has become concerned with local decision makers. Collaborative agreements involving local stakeholders have been found to be more effective than top down regulation, especially in watersheds with dispersed and mobile non-point pollution sources (NRC [8], Wondolleck and Yaffe [9], Sabatier et al [10] Richter et al [11]). Watershed collaborations are increasingly common. They may be completely voluntary or combine collaboration and regulation ([10], WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
323
Dolsak and Ostrom [12]). They are, in essence, information networks that promote communication among stakeholders with regard to both environmental and economic health. Within the economic crime literature, legal responsiveness theory discusses the availability legal means to help people adapt to economic change, like environmental regulations, as an aspect of crime prevention (Hoffman [13]). Preventing rather than punishing pollution is a concern of sustainable development. Environmental violations are not only undesirable per se, they undermine the culture of respect for law which is important to the protection of the extensive boundaries of water supplies.
3
Ingredients and success indicators of a green milieu
The regulatory and crime literature suggest that cooperative networks and legal adaptive structures can prevent resistance to increased environmental requirements. Local and sustainable development literatures suggest that localities in the process of learning to shape their interdependent economic and environmental needs can be green milieus which move towards sustainability. Such a green milieu would have the following ingredients: • Create learning networks to help economic actors adapt • Create learning networks about and incentives for environmental sustainability • Promote economic well being through legal opportunities • Provides legal means to meet environmental requirements • Foster cooperation and trust How would the effectiveness of a green milieu be assessed? Drawing on a range of sources on sustainability, ([5,6], Berke and Manta [14]) five criteria are proposed: • • • • •
4
Environmental sustainability: Maintaining and improving the environment for current and future generations Economic Sustainability: Economic development that encompasses economic welfare, equity and means of resilience for future generations Compatibility: development compatible with environmental protection Legality: provision of legal means to adapt to change Atmosphere of cooperation and trust for future development
Watershed collaborations as Green Milieus
Watershed collaborations at least nominally have the ingredients of a green milieu. They are learning networks created to help stakeholders adapt to the requirements of water protection and to promote compliance with environmental requirements. They necessarily address the economic and equity concerns of stakeholders. They must foster cooperation and trust to be effective. Environmental protection measures, whether formal rules or informal agreements, create cost pressures. Goodstein [15] writes that firms seeking to WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
324 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI comply with environmental requirements have saved money in part because they re-examined their production processes. Participants in collaborations thus gain learning and adaptation experience, enhancing the capacity of the local area as a learning machine with potential benefits to the entire economy. Watershed collaborations vary considerably in scope. Some are small, short term voluntary arrangements that might not have enough impact to create a green milieu. Others are complex agreements involving many stakeholders, wide areas, and formal institutions [6]. These hold promise for creating a green milieu. New York City’s watershed collaboration is of the latter type and is a good candidate for analysis as green milieu
5
New York City’s Watershed Collaboration as a green milieu
5.1 Background of the New York City Collaboration Some 90 per cent of New York City’s water come from its rural Catskill/Delaware (C/D) Watershed about 120 miles north of the City and west of the Hudson River. Most of the rest comes from its upstate watershed east of the Hudson River. The City’s Collaboration resulted from a 1987 rule promulgated by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that decreed that all cities of over 100,000 had to filter their drinking water. The water supply in the C/D watershed was clean enough for the City to apply for a provision in the EPA ruling that granted permission not to filter water from these reservoirs, called a filtration avoidance determination (FAD). To obtain the FAD, the City had to take steps to protect the Catskill mountain water supply and create plans to build a filtration plant for its eastern watershed (NRC [16], Galusha [17]). A filtration plant for the C/D Watershed would have cost at least $6 billion, so the City began to review and tighten its upstate watershed regulations. However, the local people mobilized to protest the regulations, in part due to resentment about the City’s prior use of eminent domain to destroy homes and villages in order to construct the reservoirs [17]. While the City owned land near reservoirs, and some of the watershed was protected by a forever wild designation, some 74% of the watershed land was privately owned. The miles of streams and reservoir boundaries could not be effectively protected and controlled through police action. Community cooperation was necessary for effective protection [16]. The City engaged in negotiations for collaboration. What evolved was a complex collaboration guided by a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) including rules and regulations and benefits for participating communities. Signatories to the MOA included the U.S. EPA, the New York City Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), New York State (NYS), the NYS Departments of Health, and of Environmental Conservation, the NYS Environmental Facilities Corporation, seven counties including five containing the C/D Watershed, 49 towns including 41 C/D Watershed towns of which 34 signed as members of a coalition of Watershed towns (CWT), eleven villages of which nine are in the C/D Watershed, and five locally active non-profit organizations (CCCD 1997 [18], MOA [19]). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
325
5.2 New York City’s Collaboration as a green milieu Three aspects of the Collaboration contribute to a green milieu: tools of environmental protection, the organizations, and spending programs (Table 1). 5.2.1 The tools of environmental protection of the Collaboration Three categories of tools of environmental protection exist: land purchase, direct regulations, and education. The City is buying land from willing sellers, especially in priority areas for water protection. The rules and regulations of the MOA such as stream buffers, shape economic activity. The City’s funds environmental education for Watershed and City students, via local conferences and though outreach activities such as booths at county fairs (Hoffman [20]). These tools all contribute ingredients of a green milieu (Table 1). The rules and regulations and the education programs stimulate creation of learning networks about environmental protection. Education enhances legal compliance. The land purchases provide income to local residents. Buying land from willing sellers rather than using eminent domain gained the City cooperation and trust. 5.2.2 Organizations of the Collaboration The Collaboration produced new organizations. Several were created to implement the Collaboration The Watershed Protection and Partnership Council (WPPC) of all signers of the MOA was created to meet annually, hear conflicts and issue reports. Two Watershed based non- profit organizations were funded by the City to assist in the implementation of MOA and to foster economic development compatible with clean water. One, the Catskill Watershed Corporation (CWC), oversees such programs as storm water prevention and septic upgrading. It oversees a revolving loan fund and community grant program and is a locus of education programs. The second is the Watershed Agricultural Council (WAC) which oversees a voluntary whole farm program designed to enroll farmers in a voluntary whole farm plan of best management practices (BMP) for water quality. The WAC oversees a forest stewardship program and programs to support the forest and agricultural economy. Also, the City DEP established a Community Affairs Division to work with local communities on the agreement. Local interest organizations formed during Collaboration include the Coalition of Watershed Towns (CWT), a group formed to protest the regulation still meets as a watchdog organization, and a network of environmental groups which participated in the negotiations and is still active [18, 20]. Two other local organizations were formed during the implementation phase. One is the “Green county mountain top” group of supervisors which meets to discuss Watershed affairs in their county. Delaware County, which has about half of the county in the Watershed, funded a Watershed Affairs Office (Hoffman [21]). These organizations are all learning networks which increase and enrich connections in the Watershed networks. When participants are government employees, they, in turn, transmit information to the business community. The CWC and WAC both work to foster economic development compatible with clean water. The WPPC brings participants together and provides a venue for the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
326 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI discussion of disputes. The CWT protests when it feels that the local communities can be damaged by some aspect of the Collaboration. The organizations of the Collaboration are engaged in activities that create a green milieu (Table 1). Table 1:
Environmental Protection Tools MOA Rules & regulations Land Acquistion by fee simple Education Organization WPPC DEP watershed affairs CWC & WAC CWT environmenatl groups Green mountain top group Delaware County Watershed Affairs Spending programs Environmental protection Infrastructure compliance subsidies Whole farm and forest stewardship conferences Economic development watershed development plan community grants revolving loan fund tourism and farm market promotion hiring of personnel Cooperation good neighbor program tax fund
Collaboration characteristics. creates learning networks
promotes promotes sustainablity of economic environment well being
provides legal means
promotes cooperation and trust
x
x x x
x
x x
x
x x x x x x x
x x x
x
x x x
x
x
x x
x x x x x
x x x x x
x x x
x x x
x
x x
x x x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
5.2.3 The spending programs of the collaboration Collaboration spending can be grouped into three categories: environmental protection, economic development and fostering cooperation. All contribute ingredients to a green milieu (Table 1). Environmental protection spending comes primarily from the City but is amplified when City funds are used in local matching grants. The City spends money for direct protection and to organizations that oversee protection programs. The major category of direct spending undertaken by the City is for infrastructure such as wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) and septic systems. In addition to the funding of the CWC, the WAC and the WPPC, the City also pays for research and assistance from Cornell University and for conservation easements to keep land in farming [21]. Spending by the City that contributes to economic development includes local hiring, the funding of a Watershed region economic development plan, a 60$ million revolving loan fund, community development grants, funds to promote the tourist economy and local products, conservation easement purchases and financing for local infrastructure such as new sewer lines The CWC kept lists of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
327
local providers of needed services to increase the likelihoods that the spending would stimulate the local economy [21]. City spending designed to foster cooperation and trust include “no strings attached” good neighbour payments to local governments and funds to support local governments in tax disputes with New York City. These spending programs create learning networks, environmental protection, local economic well being, and legal means for people to meet the regulations, thus helping foster cooperation and trust.
6
Success indicators New York City’s green milieu
6.1 Local development problems In order to understand the challenges faced by the Collaboration, the nature of the local economy at the beginning of the MOA must be understood. Dairy farms and forests dominated the rural, sparsely populated, mountainous landscape. Scattered hamlets and villages of the Watershed had typically been built along streams. . Much of the infrastructure was depreciated; including the area’s septic tanks and wastewater treatment plants. The streams themselves had often been straightened or had deteriorated borders, and could too easily carry silt to the City’s reservoirs [16,20,21]. The economy had been stagnant for decades Dairy farming had experienced the loss of its supplier base. The forever wild protection of the state constitution for the Catskill Park land and steep slopes meant that much land was not available for development. Small businesses were especially vulnerable to the competition of super stores, large farms and globalization. Many jobs were low income service and retail jobs, often in the tourist industry. There was a lot of part time work. Government jobs, primarily states and local and City, provided some stability, with regular incomes with benefits to about a fifth of the population [20,21]. Strict water regulations with expensive infrastructure requirements could have undermined the economy of this already run down area. However, City’s need for a collaborative partnership generated a Collaboration with the ingredients of a green milieu. What are the indications of success so far? 6.2 Environmental sustainability A quick summary indicator of the Collaboration’s environmental success is the EPA’s award of three successive FAD’s, continuing permission not to filter the water. A supplemental indicator is absence of incidents of water borne disease attributed to Watershed water (NYC [22]). Specific gains are many. The City has upgraded its own watershed waste water treatment plants to tertiary level treatment and has upgraded enough of the WWTP’s in the C/D Watershed to protect 97% of the Watershed’s effluent. It has restored wetlands and returned the meander to streams to prevent flooding. The City monitors and has replacement plans for local dams. Upgrades of 2000 septic systems are completed, and funds for their maintenance are committed. The voluntary whole farm program has participation by 95% of commercial farmers. City land purchases have tripled its watershed holdings, and it has a long run planting WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
328 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI program to maintain the forested land’s capacity to cleanse water. Finally phosphorous restrictions on the Cannonsville reservoir were lifted (NYC [23]). The creation of phosphorous restriction program to guide economic development by the Watershed Affairs Office of Delaware county promises will help keep that reservoir clean [21]. 6.3 Economic sustainability: development, well being compatibility A variety of indicators point to milieu successes in enhancing development and economic welfare in the Watershed. Studies of residents during the early years of the collaboration (1990-2000) found that Watershed residents, while having relatively low income and high unemployment for the region, had experienced greater improvements in median income, wage and salary growth and self employment income than control areas used in the study Also unemployment had declined more and inequity increased less than control areas [20]. A similarly controlled study of employers found a growth in both units of business and employment from 1997-2003, and that the Watershed had growth even when control areas experiencing a down turn. A negative economic result for the period was the relatively low wage growth. While the wage growth cannot be attributed to the Collaboration, milieu effects failed to overcome the factors such as international competition and location disadvantages that held wages down. [21]. Another problem not overcome by the milieu is the pressure put on property taxes of low income residents resulting from expensive home construction by higher income second home owners [20]. Long run economic stability was promoted by various milieu programs. Loans to wood working businesses support secondary markets for holders of forest land. Purchases of conservation easements help to keep land in farming. Economic diversity, which provides stability, has been aided by loans to small to medium size manufacturers, which helped stabilize them. Links to New York City customers helped farmers diversify into growing products for that market. Also, internet based businesses have opened in the Watershed in part with the help of the loan programs or local government programs inspired by the need to promote businesses compatible with water quality [21]. Compatibility of economic activity and water quality has been enhanced. Improved environmental infrastructure “cleanses” all Watershed activities. The service industry, not a major polluter, is the major source of job growth. Local officials have promoted non-polluting e- business by such means as such as subsidizing web pages and creating e-business incubators. Delaware County has a phosphorous reduction plan to guide economic activity in its part of the Watershed [21]. The voluntary farm program’s best management practices protects water quality and kept farm pollutants from the water in a recent flood (Rauter interview [24]). 6.4 Legality, cooperation and trust The legal means to abide by regulations provided to by the Collaboration have been used. Local residents have used the septic grant program and reported their septic problems. Businesses and local communities have used the loan and grant WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
329
programs to improve environmental infrastructure [20,21]. The WPPC’s forum for dispute resolution is credited with the avoidance of law suits about development on steep slopes (Harding interview [25]). Use of conflict procedures is evidence of flexibility in the structure of the Collaboration which enhances long run cooperation. The City responded to local protest and redesigned its Watershed signs. The WPPC has provided a forum for disputes about recreation rules as well as slopes. The tax fund has been used by local areas to stand up to the City on tax issues. Evidence that the periodic need to renew FAD’s enhances cooperation is provided by the City’s agreement to pay for maintenance septic tanks during one set of negotiations [20,21,23]. The many successes of the milieu have been accompanied by problems beyond those already mentioned. Local residents protested watershed police issuing traffic tickets and controversy abounds about the City’s reluctance to grant a permit to a proposed mountain top golf course. There are also worries that the land acquisition program will ruin the area for tourism.
7
Summary
There are problems in this Collaboration. Some are rooted in national and international forces and should lead Collaboration officials to lobby higher levels of government for such things as affordable housing. Others problems are amenable to local control. Some of the latter such as signage have been attended to, while others are still contributing to the learning experience of a Collaboration. On balance, the successes of Collaboration a green milieu are remarkable. The Watershed economy is healthier and more compatible with preservation of water quality than before the Collaboration began. The approach of this Collaboration in considering the economic needs of the local area and providing forums for discussion provides a model that should be studied by others, especially those with transboundary water supplies and water sources in poor communities.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
Krugman, P. What’s new about the new economic geography. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 14 (2) pp 151-66 (1998). Camagni, R. Local Milieu, uncertainty and innovation networks: towards a new dynamic theory of economic space in R. Camagni (ed.) Innovation Networks: spatial Perspectives pp. 121-45. London: Belhaven Press. 1991. Helmsing A.H. J. (Bert). Externalities, learning and governance: new perspectives on local economic development. In development and change vol.32 pp 277-308. (2001). Markusen, A. Sticky places in slippery space: a typology of industrial districts. Economic Geography, 72(3) 293-313. 1996. (UNEP) United Nations Environment Program. Our common future. Report of the world commission on environment and development. New York: United Nations. 1987. Daly H. E. and Cobb, J. B. Jr. 1994. For the Common Good. Boston: Beacon Press. 1994, p 462-4 WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
330 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]
[12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25]
Hoffman, J. Economic Stratification and Management of Water Quality: New York City’s Catskill/Delaware Watershed. Environmental Values. 14, 447-470. 2005. (NRC) National Research Council. New Strategies for America’s Water Supply. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. 1999. Wondolleck, Julia M and Yaffee, Steven L. Making Collaboration Work. Washington D.C.: Island Press. 2000 Sabatier, P. Focht, W. Lubell M., Trachterberg, Z Vedlitz, A. and Matlock, M. Swimming Upstream: Collaborative Approaches to Watershed Management. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 2005. Richter, Brian D. Mathews, Ruth, Harrision David L. and Wigington, Robert. Ecologically Sustainable Water Management: Managing River Flows for Ecological Integrity. Ecological Applications, 13(1), 206-24. 2003. Dolsak, N. and Ostrom E. (Eds.). The Commons in the New Millennium: Challenges and Adaptations. Cambridge: Mass.: MIT Press, 2003. Hoffman, J. "Legal responsiveness: a contribution to a structural theory of economic crime." International Journal of Social Economics. Vol 30 (3) pp. 255-274. 2002. Berke, P. and Manta, M. Are We Planning for Sustainable Development? An Evaluation of 30 Comprehensive Plans. Journal of The American Planning Association 66 (1):21-32. 2000 Goodstein Eban. The Trade Off Myth. Fact and Fiction about Jobs and the Environment. Covelo California: Island Press. 1999 (NRC) Nation Research Council. Watershed Management for Potable Water Supply. Washington, D.C. National Academy Press. 2000. Galusha, D. Liquid Assets. A History of New York City’s Water System. Fleishman’s New York: Purple Mountain Press. 1999. (CCCD) The Catskill Center for Conservation and Development. Summary Guide to the Terms of the Watershed Agreement. Arkville, NY: The Catskill Center for Conservation and Development. 1997 (MOA) Memorandum of Agreement 1997 http://www.nysefc.org/tas/ MOA/MOAPg1.htm Hoffman, J Census Peek: Collaboration in the New York City Catskill/Delaware Watershed: Case Study 1990–2000. Environment, Development and Sustainability July 2006 Hoffman, J. Watershed Shifts: Case Study of Employers in the Catskill/Delaware watershed 1990-2003 (manuscript under review). New York City. Waterborne Disease Risk Assessment Program Annual Report. http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/html/wdrap.html. 2005 (NYCDEP) New York City Department of Environmental Protection. 2005 Water Quality Report http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/pdf/ wsstat05.pdf 2005. Interview with Karen Rauter Communications Director of the WAC. September 2006. Interview with Bill Harding, Director of the WPPC. March 2006. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
331
Achieving the MDG’s in Ghana: rhetorics or reality? J.-E. Gustafsson1 & J. E. Koku2 1
Department of Land and Water Resources Engineering, KTH, Sweden Department of Geography and Resources Development, University of Ghana, Ghana
2
Abstract The original meaning of the concept sustainability or sustainable development might in an altruistic way have referred to building societies based on a sound environmental practice. This paper shows that the structural adjustments programs (SAP), Poverty Reduction Strategies and the Millennium Development goals (MDG’s) compel the Ghanian government to favour economic and fiscal sustainability. This neo-liberal policy has led to increasing inequalities, widening regional disparities, migration from rural areas to quickly grown up peri-urban areas basically within a huge informal sector, and unplanned capital formation and development at large, making claims to achieve the MDG’s by 2015 illusory. A way forward for Ghana should be to gradually fence off from the world market and learn from the development efforts of the Kwame Nkrumah first independent government. Keywords: environmental sustainability, international financial institutions, Ghana, Millennium Development goals, water management.
1
Introduction
The original meaning of the concept sustainability or sustainable development might in an altruistic way have referred to building societies based on a sound environmental practice. Nowadays the concept has largely been attenuated so it can be attached to almost everything; environmental sustainability, social sustainability, economic sustainability, fiscal sustainability, debt sustainability, sustainable leadership, sustainable trade, sustainable governance etc. This attenuation has the function to conceal the power relations inherited with the concept. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070321
332 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI In September 2000 the Millennium Development Goals (MDG's) to be achieved by 2015 were launched at the United Nation Millennium Summit. Among the well-known eight goals number 1 wishes to “halve, between 19902015, the proportion of people whose income is less than $1 a day” and “who suffer from hunger”, number 7 should “ensure environmental sustainability” by the means of “integrate the principles of sustainable development in country policies and programmes…reduce by half the proportion of people without sustainable access to drinking water (later at the Johannesburg 10+ sanitation has been added)… and to achieve significant improvement in lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers, by 2020”. Goal number 8 advocates to “develop a Global Partnership for development”, which should include commitment to good governance [1]. In this paper we will critically discuss the conditions to implement the MDG’s, particularly MDG’s number 1, 7 and 8 in their global context, and with Ghana as a country example.
2
The global context
In the aftermath of the Thatcherite privatisation programs in the 1980s international organizations such as the World Bank, IMF, WTO, OECD, EU etc have pushed for market testing, deregulation and privatisation of public services within a general theoretical frame of neo-liberal solutions. These have been argued to achieve increased efficiency and social developments like poverty eradication. The various privatisation policies are based on the ideological notion that almost all public services and investments are best organized as pure markets [2]. 2.1 The corporate agenda The sustainable development concept became a global ideological key-word at the Rio Conference in 1992. The conference was basically prepared by one of the most important industrial lobbyist groups, The Business Council for Sustainable Development, which today gathers more than 170 of the most important internationals. Its chairman was Stephan Schmidheiny, one of the principal owners of the Asea Brown Broveri (ABB) company. He was also in the board of the Néstle and Swatch companies and was a principal shareholder in a Chilian mine, steel and forest company. Together with around 50 other important industrialists they formed the main advisory group to the Rio de Janeiro Earth Summit general secretary Maurice Strong. With Schmidheiny as the main author the group published the book Changing Courses. A Global Business Perspective on Development and Environment [3]. All of its recommendations are based on the belief that only by allowing market forces to operate freely can sustainable development be achieved, as if market forces have a long-term perspective. The representatives for the transnationals claim themselves as the protector of the environment by advocating that trade and investments should not be obstructed by environment WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
333
and import regulations. Instead their advice for impoverished countries was to continue to produce staple commodities for the world market, which should lead to the right price for natural resources, and to co-operate with the transnationals for their new economic order, that in agreement with international financial institutions (IFIs) is labelled “Washington Consensus”. The principal mean for promoting this neo-liberal and environmentimperialistic development would be to favour an attractive investment climate by fulfilling the conditions of macro-economic stability, free and open markets, distinct property rights and political stability. If these conditions were not fulfilled sustainable development was not possible according to the Maurice Strong advisory group. This market policy orientation replaced in developing countries earlier basic needs strategies and dependant theories between the North and South as agents for social change. This corporate message has been forwarded by the global think-tank World Water Council, the most influential global advisory water institution, which organizes World Water Forums every three years. It had to the world water meeting in Den Haag 2000 worked out a “World Water Vision” as a policy document for the management of world water resources. Comprehensive criticism was addressed from peasant organization, consumer organizations, trade unions etc. These interest groups argued that the World Water Vision depreciated public utility water and sanitation management in favour of private solution all over the globe. The Den Haag meeting has been followed by an intensified discussion between proponents who consider water as a human right, and others who look upon water as an economic good. Later on this contradiction has been reflected at the International Freshwater Conference in Bonn 2001, the Rio+10 meeting in Johannesburg 2002 and the World Water Forums in Kyoto 2003 and Mexico 2006. 2.2 The failure of fiscal sustainability A way of disguising the power aspect is to present the three main concepts of environmental, social and economic sustainability of equal importance [4]. But in practice almost without exception the global and national ruling elite favours economic sustainability or economic growth as the overall goal of development. In developing countries this priority is linked to structural adjustments programs (SAP) advocated since the 1980s by the Bretton Wood institutions (the World Bank and the IMF) and other IFIs as a conditionality for economic assistance and loans giving. But in the beginning of the 21st century critical reviewers recognise that the SAP neo-liberal policy has not delivered the environmental sound and social equitable development stated in the documents and declarations. The neo-liberal policy under the SAPs emphasizes fiscal discipline, market economy and openness to the global economy. With discredited SAP programs the global international financial institutions needed something else and more appealing to conserve their influence and power. The solution became the MDG’s.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
334 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI In the international water community it is generally agreed that the MDG's cannot be achieved without a major increase in investments over a sustained period. The International Water and Sanitation Centre (IRC) estimated 2006 the total amount of funding required per year to achieve the MDG’s water and sanitation targets within the range of US $6.5 to US $75 billion dollars. UNDP Human Development Report 2006 sets this figure at US $10 billion dollars per year. Stedman writes that the UNDP estimation might seem to be a large sum, but put in a global context it represents less than five days worth of global military spending and less than half what rich countries spend each year on mineral water [5]. It has in the recent years been apparent that the private sector contradictory to what it initially claimed has failed to provide the needed investment. The Report of the Commission of Africa in 2005 concluded that the sharp reduction in infrastructure investments "was a policy mistake founded in the new dogma of the 1980s and 1990s asserting that infrastructure would now be financed by the private sector"[6]. The private sector did not compensate for the drop in public investment as it was hoped says the IMF [7]. Thus the State and therefore public investment must regain a key role to scaling up capital formation and providing capital goods and investment needed to secure human development objectives like the MDG’s. Further in a critical analysis by Roy et al [8] show that the dogmatic neoliberal policies and the SAP programs have worked against public investment in developing countries. Public capital formation in developing countries reached its peak around 1982, when it came to 10 percent as a share of GDP (both simple and weighted average). At the Millennium shift this figure had dropped to 7 percent (simple average) or 5 percent (weighted average). For sub-Saharan Africa the picture is even grimmer. From a peak in public investments all categories of 15 percent (weighted average) 1978 at the end of the era of basic need strategies it has fell to 5 percent the year 2000. Concerning the share of public infrastructure investments in Africa it has dropped from a little more than 4 percent in the beginning of the 1980s to 1.5 percent at the Millennium shift. This has forced the World Bank admit that the lack of adequate infrastructure services has direct detrimental effects on the poor’s access to clean water and sanitation and thus health [9]. Setting up the MDG’s must be seen as some kind of response against this background. They were not a result from the developing countries themselves. They were pushed primarily by the triad [the United States, Europe, and Japan] and were co-sponsored by the World Bank, the IMF and the OECD. The goals were adopted by acclamation by a resolution of the United Nations General Assembly. They were prepared in a consensus process under the governance of the triad, which departed from the UN tradition to carefully prepare important issues in democratic set up committees. According to Amin [10] it was a wellknown consultant for the CIA, who drafted the first version of the millennium goals The goals are not very radical by themselves. To “reduce extreme poverty and hunger by half” will still keep a second half of millions of poor people with WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
335
extreme poverty and hunger, even if the goals will be obtained. “To reduce by half the proportion of people without sustainable access to drinking water” has an even lower ambition than the International Drinking Water Decade 1981-1990 set up 1977 by the United Nations Water Conference at Mar del Plata. Its aim was to make access to clean drinking water for all available across the world. Moreover, as the goals were processed in a consensus they are so general that everybody can agree upon them, but devoid of any critical analysis of the poverty problem. It is plainly assumed that goals can be achieved by some improved neo-liberalism.
3
Ghana
The intention in this section is by using Ghana as a case to illustrate some of the implications and consequences of the global neo-liberal policies. This will be carried through by providing quantitative and quality information on the main natural and infrastructure assets, the social context the resource use is dependent on, especially government policies, and the functioning of the water management system, especially the privatisation process of the Ghana Water Company. 3.1 Natural resources endowment Ghana is situated in the tropical and savannah zones in West Africa. It has a land area of 239 460 sq. km, which is about half the area of Sweden. The present population is around 20 million inhabitants, which a little more than double of Sweden. Rainfall is rather abundant, but irregular and dependant on seasons. The tropical south-western part of Ghana is the wettest and receives 1 500 to 1 900 mm of rainfall per year. The driest area is the south east-coastal plain, where mean annual rainfall is less that 750 mm. The savannah area the covers the northern and eastern parts of the country receives between 1 000 mm to 1 400 mm of rain per year. Some two third of the land area is covered by the lower Volta River system, which basically coincides with the savannah area. Volta river is an international river also including a big part of Burkina Faso, but also smaller parts of Ivory Coast, Mali, Benin and Togo. The water availability in 1995 within the international basin was 2 054 cubic meter per person, which is at the limit where water managers consider societies will enter into a phase of difficulties to supply problems. In addition to the Volta river the south-western tropical part have several important regional water basins. In 1990 the water availability for the whole of Ghana was given to 3 529 cubic meters per person, which classified Ghana in a rather favourable water resources position. However according to a UN medium projection the water availability will decrease to 1 395 cubic meter per person by 2025, which will convert Ghana into a water-stressed country [11]. Except from valleys plains most Ghanian soils are old, have a rather sandy texture and strongly leached. This means that they have low capacity to retain water and poor in nutrients. Especially in the savannah zone where the organic WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
336 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI matter is low and where the practice of annual bush-fire is common the soils are deficient in nitrogen and phosphorous [12]. Thus people’s livelihood is dependent on a careful and planned agricultural development and land management. The south-western part and the most forested area of the country is endowed with rich mineral resources including gold, diamond, bauxite and manganese. For instance most gold production is mined by 11 multinational mining companies of which five of them count for 83 percent of the output [13]. There are also a growing number of small scaled local gold producers, mostly illegal, which has led to numerous conflicts with the multinationals. The most important infrastructural asset and engineering project constructed after Ghana’s independence 1957 and the life-nerve of the economy of Ghana is the Volta River dam. Already the Colonial Administration started in 1924 considering a water development project for the Volta River system. For the socialist-orientated first president of Ghana Kwame Nkrumah the Volta River project became the cornerstone for modernization starting a process of increased wealth and prosperity for all. The main engineering component was the Akosombo dam which was completed between 1962 – 1965. The construction was a collaboration between the nationalist government and the Volta Aluminium Company (VALCO), the latter jointly owned by the U.S. Kaiser Company and the Ghanian government. The project was supported by loans from the World Bank/International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD), the government of Unites States and by export credits guarantees from the United Kingdom government. Even with this loan package support the Nkrumah government had to raise from its own resources 50 percent of cost of the project, and take responsibility for the debt service. A prerequisite for the project was to provide cheap electricity for the VALCO aluminium smelting factory set up in Tema, a new planned harbour town constructed to the east of Accra. The construction of the dam impounded a huge man-made reservoir, the Volta Lake, which has a surface area of 8 500 sq. kilometres and a volume of 148 cubic kilometres. Today the international watershed is poorly forested with less than one percent forest cover. Grassland, savannah and shrubland make up 86 percent and only 0.1 percent is irrigated. A rural population of 80 000 people had to be displaced and resettled under difficult conditions. At the start 1965 the Akosombo dam was installed with 588 MW capacity. Later it has been enlarged to 912 MW, and smaller dam down-streams at Kpong with a capacity of 160 MW has been built. These two dams in the Volta River system represent 95 percent of the hydropower electricity capacity in Ghana and was the principal source of electricity up to the millennium shift. Since 1999 a couple of thermal plants with a total capacity of 660 MW is under construction at Aboardze near Takoradi in the western part of the country [14,15]. If the neo-liberal policies and SAP programs, applied for more than two decades, have been efficient and equitable one could expect progress in the environmental sustainable use of the natural resources and infrastructure assets.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
337
But the reality according to Green Dove magazine is that “land management aimed at sustainable agricultural production, exists only in theory. Available statistics indicates that about 69 percent of the total land surface of Ghana is considered prone to severe soil erosion, on of the major causes of land degradation in Ghana. According to government National Action Programme to combat Drought and Desertification, the land area prone to desertification, has almost doubled in last decade. The most vulnerable being the Northern Savannah areas with the Upper East Region being the most degraded. The consequences are low agriculture output and widespread poverty. This has led to the migration of young women and men to the urban centres to seek for jobs with women serving in a demeaning manner as porters (Kayaye) in the markets of Accra. Migration of farmers down south to seek fertile agricultural land is also on increase. The movement is leading to many problems including clashes with other farmers in the south…In addition to the reduction of the agricultural potential, erosion has caused siltation and drying up of water bodies. Most settlements are faced with this menace where buildings have their foundations exposed and hanging, posing threat to people. Occasionally these buildings have collapsed causing damage to life and property” [16]. Most rural households are managing at subsistence level and use mainly manual labour and minimal external inputs. It is estimated that the mineral fertilizer use is only 6 kg per ha for a wide variation of food crops [12]. As to control of water pollution there exists no workable monitoring system either at the national level or the basin level. In a study of the management of the Densu River basin in the western up-hill Accra region Okyre-Darkoh [17] found no monitoring data at all, and had to rely of people’s subjective perception to get some idea of the water quality situation. Lack of a proper monitoring system is crucial factor to consider by the European Union through its EU Water Initiative, which in rather general terms advocate sub-Saharan governments to apply the globally adopted Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) system of basin management [18]. In the south-western mining land conflicts and water management is a widespread and a controversial problem. The mining activities give rise to severe water pollution and mining concessions in recent years encroach upon forest reserves. Hilson and Nyame [13] states that “ the management of multinational mining corporations operating not only in Ghana, but in the developing world as a whole acquire land concessions expecting the outcome to be problem-free”. They see this attitude as unrealistic, because “impoverished informational resources bases, understaffed government departments, piecemeal regulation and ad hoc enforcement persist in most developing countries” including Ghana. Another study by Appiah [19] concludes that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) remains ambivalent about the powers vested in them to strictly apply the environmental impact assessment (EIA) regulations. Most mining companies has not undertaken any comprehensive EIA guiding their operations or mitigating measures, while the corporate will and responsibility toward the environment is mediocre or non-existent. It is just two years ago that the Minerals Commission, the EPA and a Swedish consultancy firm (Hifab) have WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
338 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI started a three years project in the mining areas and funded by the EU Commission, which aims to increase awareness of the necessity of EIA procedures and includes setting up a monitoring system of the rivers. At the Millennium shift international VALCO company, the mining multinational companies and other industrial consumers made up about two thirds of the total electricity consumption. The commercial sector (offices, shops, institutions and hotels) accounted for 5 -6 percent. Still 50 years after the construction of the Akosombo dam the VRA supplies less than 20 percent of the household energy needs. The rural areas are poorly electrified as the priority has been given to the urban elite to receive electricity for residential needs. A large number of rural households have to rely on biomass sources of energy such like fuel wood for the cooking need, which as a consequence have increased the land degradation and erosion problems. Very little compensatory measures have been taken to assist the affected communities and for them to benefit of the electricity generation by the Volta River Project. Wide-spread deforestation, erosion and the incidence of environmental health problems, particularly bilharzia, have been recognized as the most acute environmental problems within the surrounding communities of the Volta dams and lake [14,20]. The environmental health and pollution situation in the urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana is in a dilapidated situation. The Ghana Water Sector Restructuring Secretariat (WSRS) found in the beginnings of century that 53 percent of the population, but 78 percent of the poor, had no piped water. A study in 2001 found that that only 40 per cent of the urban population had access to piped water supplied by the Ghana Water Company. Some 40 percent in urban areas and 35 percent in the rural areas had access to improved sanitation facilities [21]. Only the central and old urban areas have a water supply network, which mostly reaches the wealthiest residents [22]. Tema, the city built out as a planned effort as a part of the Volta River project, has modern sewerage facilities, however discharging the sewage water untreated in the Atlantic. After advice from the World Bank the Rawlings government in 1998 separated the water supply from sewage disposal in a process called “unbundling”. Water supply was left with the renamed state owned company Ghana Water Company Ltd, while the sewage disposal was devolved to the district level. These districts either have enough human resources capacity or financial resources to take care of this responsibility. Although some small technological efforts since the middle of the 1960s have been made, there exist no workable sewage treatment plant at all in the country. A biological filter sewage plant at the University of Ghana, built in the 1980s, quickly went out of operation due to lack of spare parts, and is now partly overgrown with vegetation. Thus the state of environmental health, water supply, sanitation and waste management in Accra is currently very unsatisfactory [23]. Several times a week the press carries articles which complain of the situation [24]. The bulk of the sewage water in the city, both domestic and industrial, continues to be discharged into gutters and drains most of which empty into the Korle Lagoon in the centre of the city. In addition night soils and septic tank sludge are deposited by tanker trucks directly on the beaches. The city then gives a filthy impression, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
339
since it is characterised by choked drains, indiscriminate waste disposal and uncollected refuse in central waste containers. The Waste Management Department of the Accra Metropolitan Assembly is responsible for garbage collection and disposal, and general sanitation situation within Accra, but it is not capable to improve the present conditions. Many factors contributes to this state of affairs like; the collapse of a comprehensive planning system for the urban areas, poor conceptualisation of environmental health, sanitation and water management issues, lack of adequate treatment facilities, ignorance and irresponsibility of individuals, households, communities and administrations, lack of community action, spring up unauthorised temporary structures, continuously increasing number of squatters, lack of regular budgetary allocations, absence of governmental control etc. In sum the market-orientated neo-liberal policies applied by the Rawlings and Kufour governments have not contributed to the progress of environmental sustainability. 3.2 The social context – government policies The neglect of creating environmental sustainability is due to that the Ghanian governments within the global context favours economic and fiscal sustainability. However, this has not lead to a substantial economic growth in the per capita income. The GDP per capita stood at $390 at the Millennium shift, which is just at the level of the Nkrumah government 1957 –1966. The per capita income was at its lowest value 1983, when it was only 90 percent of the 1957 value. In 1983 the Rawlings government started the Economic Recovery Program and SAP programs under the auspices of the Bretton Wood Institutions. Thus, the recovery relying on market reforms has been slow and has been accompanied by a sharpened and skewed income distribution, regional disparities and social exclusion [25–27]. The subservience to the global economic forces is elegantly formulated in the introduction to the Ghana Vision 2020 plan, which was introduced by the Rawlings government in 1995. “The long-term vision for Ghana is that by the year 2020, Ghana will have achieved a balanced economy and a middle class country status and have a standard of living with a level of development close to the present level of Singapore. This will be realized by creating an open and liberal market economy, founded on competition, initiative and creativity, that employs science and technology in deriving maximum productivity from the use of all our human and natural resources and in optimizing the role of economic and social development, with due regard to the protection of the environment and to equity in the distribution of development” [28]. This lofty vision void of a political analysis has been accompanied by an Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper 2000 – 2002, and a Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (GPRS) 2003 – 2006. The IMF and the World Bank WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
340 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI endorsed in 1999 the elaboration of Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PSRPs) as the central mechanism to for providing concessional lending to low-income countries. The declared objective of these papers is to provide a medium-term framework to reduce poverty and generate more rapid economic growth with assistance from bilateral donors and multilateral financial institutions. The PSRPs contains rather general commitments to improve the social infrastructure like environmental health, water supply and sanitation, and it is assumed that funding for investments should be raised besides from donors and financial institutions through governments own revenues, eventual savings from getting the status of Highly Indebted Poor Country (HIPC) debt relief and private sector contribution either by the business or the NGOs. This fits well with the MDG No 8 to “develop Global Partnerships for development” and Private-SectorParticipation (PSP) approach to achieve global and local consensus developments, endorsed at the Johannesburg 10+ meeting 2002. Unchecked neo-liberal policies and the weak economy of the Ghana state keep the country within the global corporate agenda in a stage to produce staple commodities for the world market, particularly agricultural and mineral products. The Ghana Vision 2020 puts agricultural production in focus. However the agricultural sector is quite vulnerable and skewed. Some 70 percent of the population gets its livelihood directly or indirectly from the agriculture sector. It is estimated that small-holder farmers, who use mainly labour and minimal external inputs, contributes to about 80 percent of the total agricultural production. During the period 1996 – 2002 the agricultural sector contribution to GDP (in constant 1993 prices) has been within 39.5 to 40.8 percent, the service sector 31.3 to 33.0 percent and the industrial manufacturing sector 27.4 to 28.0. The agricultural sector contributed with $732 million in 2002, which is equivalent to an average of 35.0 percent share of the total foreign revenue for the 2000-2002 period. This is a decrease from an average of 44.8 percent during the 1996-1998 period, which could be explained by a rapid increase in the minerals production during the ends of 1990s. The main agricultural export commodities in 2002 were cocoa ($463), timber ($183) and pineapple ($15). Especially worrying for a lot of small-scaled cocoa producers are that the export earning share of cocoa fell from 35.1 percent in 1996 to 22.4 percent in 2002. As a basis for the government development efforts the agricultural sector just contribute a meagre 4 percent to the total government revenue in the first years after the Millennium shift [12,29]. In addition with the global trade liberalisation Ghanian farmers have been compelled to compete against cheap imports of highly subsidised products from the European Union and the United States like rice, chicken, tomatoes etc. For instance cheap rice imports from United States is not only collapsing the local rice industry, but also beginning to have a substitution effect on locally produced staple foods like cassava and maize. Adjei-Nsiah [12] writes that this is compounded by “increasing cost of inputs at the farm level due to SAP programs that have removed subsidies and increased supply cost due to the deterioration conditions of rural infrastructure. For instance, in 2002, whereas metric tonnes of urea cost about $90 free on board in Europe the same quantity cost a Ghanian WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
341
farmer about $ 308 at the farm level”. What is left for the Ghanian politicians is to become flagbearer advocating mechanization of food production, but in an ideological an organizational vacuum [30]. In the early 1990s gold overtook cocoa as Ghana’s chief foreign exchange earner. As for this staple export sector the mining companies during the SAP intensive period 1990 – 2002 paid $69 million in royalties and $19 million in corporate tax to the government according to the Bank of Ghana. This becomes on average some $7 million per year, a figure of less then 50 percent of the pineapple industry export earnings in 2002. By law 80 percent these payments goes to the government, 10 percent to the mining agencies and the remaining 10 percent to the Office of the Administrator of Stool Lands. Of this last share 10 percent is kept for the Stool Lands administration leaving the rest or $ 0.61 million for community developments to district assemblies, traditional authorities and stools of the mining areas. This extreme exploitation of a lowincome country should be compared with that the mining industry is estimated to have invested $ 250 million per year between 1983 – 1998 [13]. It should be obvious for everyone that’s this basically un-regulated and unplanned market economy to produce staple commodities for the global capitalistic market will not contribute to social equity, overall wealth building and thus poverty reduction. Development in general terms means in a planned way to modernize the agricultural sector, so that labour not any longer needed in agriculture in an orderly way will be transferred to growing manufacturing and service sectors. This is not the case in Ghana and most other low-income countries. Sutcliff [31] wrote; “ no major country has yet become rich without having become industrialized…In the long run greater wealth and better living standards under any political system are connected with industrialization”. After two decades of SAP programs and liberalized global markets the manufacturing industry in Ghana today is in distress. The country is supposed to continue the road of liberalization and hopefully improve the competitiveness of its manufacturing firms in the long run without completely destroying the manufacturing base in the short run [32]. This is an equation impossible to achieve. On the contrary, since the demise of the basic needs and planned development approach at the end of the 1970s an alarming unplanned rural exodus have taken place, which sharps regional disparities and creating huge infrastructure, environmental and social development problems in quickly growing urban and peri-urban areas. Large number of people has been driven into a petty commodity sector, surviving through a great diversity of copying strategies outside of the main national economy [33]. The applied neo-liberal anti-development policies make the Ghanaian state very weak. The official budget policy of the sitting Kofuor government, elaborated in collaboration with the IMF, is “to sustain the fundamental underpinnings of a stable and durable economy” and the implementation of prudent fiscal and monetary measures by the government since 2001.” [34]. In this policy is an inherent contradiction between the need to undertake growthWIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
342 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI enhancing expansion in expenditure and the demand for further fiscal restraint as a disinflation policy. Currently the government strives to achieve single digit inflation. In 2005 the GDP reached 97 018 billion cedis or $10.800 billion. In the same year the government total revenue and grants (including HICP Assistance) stood at 28 800 billion cedis (29,7% of GDP), while the current and capital expenditures came at 32 078 billion cedis (33.1% of GDP), leaving a budget deficit of some 4 percent of GDP. This is substantially lower than the 7 – 10.5 percent during the 1993 -2000 period. Under this budget circumstances only 4.8 percent was left for domestic public capital formation investments, and only 2.8 of GDP in the form of social security, pensions and health insurance benefits to households. In addition the government wage bill was almost 50 percent of the recurrent expenditures or 9.4 percent of the GDP [35,36], which gives little room for the government to expand public human resources capacity building needed for sustainable development. 3.3 The water management system A weak state makes public planning and management efforts difficult, and the water sector is no exception. The current reformation of the water sector was initiated in the end of 1990s as a part of Ghana poverty reduction strategy. The reformation of the sector aims to obtain a society where the whole population has access to basic social services such as health care, drinking water and sanitation. It includes the creation of a new sector policy, re-management of the sector agencies and administration, delegation of responsibilities to districts and communities and a higher degree of involvement of the private sector. With limited state capacity and the dependency of external finance and conditionalities it is not any easy task to restructure the multitude of water institutions. The Ministry of Works and Housing (MWH) is in charge of creation of policies in the water sector and the coordination between them, but the Ministries of Environment and Science, Health and Local Government and Rural Development are also involved. The Water Resources Commission (WRC) is the main institution to involved in regulation and management of the water bodies in Ghana related to the Integrated Water Resources Management approach advocated by the global financial and water institutions. Other important institutions are the Environmental Protection Agency that should regulate and enforce environmental quality laws and the Water Research Institute that is mandated to conduct research into water and water related research [37]. For the achievement of the MDG’s the organization of the water utility sector is of special interests to illustrate the close IFIs and international private sector influence on Ghanian public policies. The initial restructuring work was first carried out in working groups inside MWH, but in 1997 a Water Sector Restructuring Secretariat (WSRS) was set up in the ministry. It received the mission to supervise the transition from existing Ghana Water and Sewage Company (GWSC) structure to a Private-Sector-Participation (PSP) regime. The World Bank funded it and it advises the government on PSP issues [38]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
343
The WSRS claimed that efforts in the 1970s and 1980s to restructure GWSC and improve its operational and financial viability had failed. Therefore in a WSRS workshop in February 1995 without any trade union representation, but with numerous participation of international aid donors and global private water companies, eight PSP options were discussed and the lease option was selected. The same year, on World Bank advice, came a proposal to restructure the GWSC into a pure and profitable water supply company. This restructure materialized in 1999, when the Ghana Water Company (GWC) was set up getting the authority to supply 101 urban systems with water. At the same time the water supply systems in 110 rural communities and small towns were devolved to District Assemblies at the local government level. Also all sewerage and sanitation handling over the whole of Ghana became the responsibility of the District Assemblies. Further in 1997 a Public Utility Regulatory Commission (PURC) was established. Its main task was to set the water rate for consumers after a proposal from the utility. The IMF asked PURC to implement a plan for full cost recovery and an automatic tariff adjustment mechanism as a condition for Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility loans. In the Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper 2000 – 2002, in theory a borrowing document, but in practice written by the lending organisation, the urban water sector was scheduled to “divest urban water systems to private sector operators: issues invitation for bids”. During the whole process a number of biased western consultants were hired like Louis Berger, London Economics, Halcrow & Halcrow, WS Atkins, Stone and Webster, The Adam Smith Institute. After all this efforts the bidding process was elaborated [21]. The first pre-qualification bid process was launched in 1998, and the two largest global water companies Suez and Vivendi/Veolia were selected for a lease contract. The whole process lacked transparency from the beginning, so eventually a third company, Azurix, was accepted without being officially invited. It went around the Negotiation Office to address directly with the Rawlings government [39]. Azurix was the water division of the later scandalised U.S. energy company Enron. In 2000 the MWH made a decision to award Enron/Azurix the lease contract, but after allegations of kick-backs and media coverage, even the World Bank threatened to abolish some of its concessionary loans unless the Government of Ghana cancelled the awarded contract. The Enron/Azurix debacle increased the general awareness among a wide range of civil society organisations and the public of what was planned for the water and sanitation issues in Ghana. In May 2001 a National Forum on Water Privatisation was arranged in Accra. The Forum adopted “The Accra Declaration of the Right to Water”, a document that is widely spread in the international community [40]. It states “that water is a fundamental human right” and “that water should not be a common commodity to be bought and sold in the market place as an economic good”. It also rejected “the view that privatization (the participation of foreign transnational corporations) is the appropriate solution to the problems bedeviling our water sector”. At the Forum the National Coalition Against the Privatisation of Water (NCAP) was formed and its secretariat set up WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
344 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI in the Trade Union Congress (TUC) premise. The NCAP has since than campaigned for keeping the water supply in public hands. Before the second bid process the Ghana urban water system was divided in two project units A and B with about equal capacity, each of them expected to be operated by a foreign company. The rationale for this was that two contract should secure competition. After the pre-qualification process the French companies Suez, Vivendi and SAUR were selected together with Biwater, a British company. Due to increased national and international debate of the privatisation issue the selection procedure was delayed and the government hesitated to take a decision [41]. Finally the government and the WSRS made a retreat and changed the bidding requirements from long-term lease contract into a five years management contract. On 22 November 2005, the Ghana government [grantor] officially signed a Management Service Contract agreement with two international public-owned companies, Vitens International B.V of the Netherlands and Rand Water Service Pty, of South Africa [42]. These two company set up a joint 50-50 owned special purpose company, Aqua Vitens Rand Ltd (AVRL), which started its activities 1 July 2006. According to this arrangement GWC should monitor the performance of the contract and PURC negotiate the water rate. AVRL obligations under the contract include increasing the amount of treated water for sale, extending water service to low income areas, rehabilitating existing networks to reduce nonrevenue water, dam safety upgrades, procurement and installation of meters etc. within a five year period. For AVRL to accomplish this mission the government of Ghana was granted a loan of $103 million from the World Bank, $5 million from the Nordic Development Fund and an equity contribution of $12 million. The regional staff of the GWC has been transferred to the AVRL in a retrenchment process that at the end will reduce 4 700 former GWC staff to a few more than 1 500. The GWC Head Office is in a similar retrenchment process to slim its staff from 240 to some 60 people [43]. At the signing of the contract the civil society groups criticized the management contract and challenged the government to provide Ghanians with evidence of anywhere in the world where a management contract had been able to deliver water at an affordable rate to the poor [44]. According to the agreement AVRL is obliged to within six months of the commencement date of the contract to “produce and maintain water quality, pressure and flow rates at all discharge points”. After a bit more than half a year staff at the GWC Head Office accuse AVRL for ripping of GWC and the government, because not even a single pipeline or meter have been added to the company ‘s old stock, and that it had not introduced anything new to improve the performance of the GWC. AVRL is also criticized for the World Bank sponsored retrenchment process, and the government for paying eight AVRL managers $ 20 000 per month to replace Ghanians managers [45,46]. It should be obvious for everyone that in the PSP process of Ghana Water company it is impossible to distinguish between government and World Bank policies.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
4
345
Concluding remarks
It has been demonstrated in this paper with Ghana as a case that global corporations and the International Finance Institutions, particularly the World Bank and the IMF, have the privilege to define what is environmental sustainability and accordingly interpret the MDG No 7 phrase “integrate the principle of sustainable development in country policies and programmes” at their own will. These global actors always prioritise economic and fiscal sustainability before environmental sustainability. It should now have become common knowledge that SAP programs have focused on securing macro-economic stability and fiscal solvency by placing controls of fiscal deficits and public debts. The global powers have assigned the low-income countries to deliver staple commodities for the world market. This market-orientated policy has led to increasing inequalities, widening regional disparities, migration from rural areas to quickly grown up peri-urban areas basically within a huge informal sector, and unplanned capital formation and development at large, making claims to half the poverty by 2015 illusory. The implementation of the Bretton Wood institutions SAP programs has not left the governments of low-income countries like Ghana with much choice either than to increase the revenues or to restrain expenditures. Existing national power structure, the large informal economy, and low incomes of middle-class and poor people make increasing tax rates difficult. Thus most low-income governments have been forced to restrict public expenditures, leaving just a few percent of the GDP for domestic capital formation. The global corporate agenda is covered in rhetoric’s from the Rio summit like “Think global –Act Local”. However, this is a dangerous message, as it conceals the process of delegitimating national states and governments. With the experience from Ghana Boafo-Arthur [25] expresses this process as; “It is indisputable that the Washington Consensus and neo-liberal adherents just want to see the state making laws for the operation of the market but not participating in the market itself…The increasing distancing of the state from direct economic management, as underlined by the extra attention paid to private sector development, is bound to impact negatively on the vulnerable in the society”. It is an intriguing fact that this rhetoric has made North governments, like in the Swedish Global Development Policy 2003, to bypass national governments and focus the international aid on community development. Or stated by the words of the Swedish state secretary of international aid [47] at a meeting to discuss the UNDP Development Report 2006; “People’s are the base for priorities, not governments”. This statement is also an example of an accompanied shift from “government” to “governance” with the implication that state power has moved from democratic governments upwards to organisation like the European Union or to local network-type power centres or PSP arrangements. At local level this implies that private actors like companies and NGOs not only participate in developing policies, but also in many cases perform in implementing political decisions, for instance in the delivery of service [48]. Sometimes this shift creates confusion as when the General Director of Sida on the one hand WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
346 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI expressed that the above Swedish Global Development Policy “has the special goal to contribute to an environment that support people’s own initiative” and on the other hand when problems occur at the local level to implement the MDG’s stated that “Governments need to take responsibilities, that is what we have governments for” [49]. The Rio summit occurred in time together with the Gulf War of 1991 and the demise of the Soviet Union, which gave rise to rhetoric’s of a “new world order” and even “the end of history”. Ten years later at the Johannesburg 10+ the reality had given away to disappointment. As Bellamy Foster [50] writes “rather than improving of the decade that had elapsed, the word environment had experienced accelerated decline…Sustainable development had turned out to be about sustaining capital accumulation at virtually any ecological cost. All rhetoric ten years earlier of a ‘new world order’ and ‘the end of history’ had simply disguised the fact that the real nemesis of the global environment was the capitalist world economy”. Western-styled neo-liberal policies and governance receipts will never get the sub-Saharan countries out of the poverty trap and the environmental abuses. Ghana celebrates its 50 anniversary of independence this year. The country can learn from the planned national development efforts of the Kwame Nkrumah’s first independent government [51]. The way forward for Ghana should also be to gradually fence off from the global world market and build an environmental sustainable modern society based on regional co-operation and developing its own internal markets.
Acknowledgement The work with this paper has been supported by a grant from the Formas-Sida research councils, Sweden.
References [1] [2] [3] [4]
[5] [6] [7]
Poverty-Environment Partnership, Linking Poverty Reduction and Water Management, SEI & UNDP publication, Stockholm: 2006. Kuttner, R., Everything for Sale, The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, 1999. Schmidheiny, S., Changing Course: A Global Business Perspective on Development and the Environment, MIT Press: Cambridge, 1992. Giddings, B., Hopwood. B. & O’Brien, G., Environment, economy and society: Fitting them together into sustainable development. Proc. Of the Int. Conf. on International sustainable development research, University of Manchester: Manchester, pp. 79-86, 2001 Stedman L., Water: the development deficit. Water21, December 2006. Report for the Commission of Africa, Our Common Interest: London, 2006. IMF, Public Investments and Fiscal Policy: Washington D.C., 2004.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]
[18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
[24]
347
Roy, R., Heuty A., & Letouzé, E., Fiscal Space for Public Investment: Towards a Human Development Approach: Paper prepared for the G-24 technical meeting Singapore, September 13-14, 2006, UNDP. Development Committee, Infrastructure and the World Bank, World Bank: Washington D.C. 2005. Amin. S., The Millennium Development Goals. A Critique from the South, Monthly Review, 57(10), 2006, pp 1-15, 2006 Engelman, R. & LeRoy. P., Sustaining Water – Population and the Future of Renewable Water Supplies. Population and Environment Program: Washington, 1993. Adjei-Nisah, Cropping system, land tenure and social diversity in Wenchi, Ghana: implications for soil fertility. PhD thesis, Wageningen University: The Netherlands, 2006 Hilson, G. & Nyame, F., Gold mining in Ghana’s forest reserves: a report on the current debate. Area, 38 (2), pp. 175-185, 2006. Agbemabiese, L. & Byrne, J., Commodification of Ghana’s Volta River: An Example of Ellul’s Autonomy of Technique. Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society, 5(1), pp. 17-25, 2005. Volta River Authority (VRA), www.vra.com Editorial, Land, Degradation and Agricultural Development. Green Dove, No 37 August, 2006. Okyere-Darkoh. B., Land Use Problems and Prospects of River Basin Management in Ghana: The Case of Densu River, MSc Report No 31, Department of Land and Water Resources Engineering, KTH: Stockholm, 2001. Aziz, A., Organizations concerned about pollution of River Densu. Daily Graphic. 16 October, 2006. Appiah, D. V., Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations: The Level of Compliance by Mining Companies in the Western Mining Enclave, Ghana. TRITA-LWR Master Thesis, No 11, KTH: Stockholm, 2006. Girmay, Y., Assessing the Environmental Impacts of a Hydropower Project: The case of Akosomo/Kpong Dams in Ghana. TRITA-LWR Master Thesis, No 04, KTH: Stockholm, 2006. Report on the International Fact-finding Mission on Water Sector Reform in Ghana, ISODEC: Accra, 2002. Akuffo, S.B., Pollution Control in a Developing Economy: A Study of the Situation in Ghana. Ghana University Press: Accra 1998. Songsore, J., Nabila, J.S., Yangyouro, Y., Amuah, E., Bosque-Hamilton, E.K., Etsibah K.K., Gustafsson, J-E., & Jacks, G., State of the Environmental Health: Report of the Greater Accra Metropolitan Area 2001, Ghana University Press: Accra, 2005. E.g. Yankson, N., Sanitation plight at Nima worsens. The Chronicle, 11 October, 2006; Yeboah A.L., Celebrating in filth? Daily Graphic, 2 November, 2006.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
348 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46]
Boafo-Arthur K. A., A decade of liberalism in perspective (Chapter 1). Ghana – One Decade of the Liberal State, ed. K.A. Boafo-Arthur, Zed Books: London, 2007. Songsore, J., Regional Development in Ghana: The Theory and The Reality, Woeli Publishing, Ghana, 2003. Leith, J.C. & Söderling, L., Ghana – Long Term Growth, Atrophy and Stunted Recovery, Nordiska Afrikainstitutet: Research report no.125, 2003. Government of Ghana, Ghana Vision 2020: The First Medium-Term Development Plan, National Planning Commission: Accra, 1997. The State of the Ghanian Economy 2002. ISSER: University of Ghana, 2003. Asamoa, A., Depeasantization of Africa’s Rural Economy: The Ghanaian Case. Charities Aid Foundation: Accra, 2001. Sutcliff, R.B., Industry and Underdevelopment, Addison and Wesley: London 2001. Yankson, P.W.K., Urbanization Industrialization and National Development: Challenges and Prospects of Economic Reform and Globalization, Ghana University Press: Accra, 2006. Songsore, J., Towards a Better Understanding of Urban Change. Urbanization, National Development and Inequality in Ghana, Ghana University Press: Accra, 2003. 2006 Budget Statement, Overview of Economic Policy and the Budget for 2006. The Ghanaian Times, 12 November 2005. Review and Analysis of Government Economic Policy 2006, CEPA: Issue Paper, No 12, Accra, 2006. Executive Summary Ghana Economic Review and Outlook, CEPA: Accra, 2006. Lundgren, A & Åkerberg, H., Rainwater harvesting in the peri-urban areas of Accra: status and prospects, TRITA-LWR Master Thesis, No 13, KTH: Stockholm, 2006. Water Sector Restructuring in Ghana. The Decision, The Framework, The Issues, WSRS, Ministry of Works and Housing: Accra, 2003. Nkrumah, E. Personal communication, 2 December 2003, WSPR, Accra. www.isodec.org.gh/Papers/accradeclaration.PDF Ford, N., Crunch time over privatisation. African Business, March 2004. WSRS, www.waterforghana.org Korsah, E. Personal communication, 31 October, 2006, GWCL, Accra. Nyarkoah, M., Hackman’s water theory is bogus. Why are they lying to us? The Chronicle, 25 November, 2005. Adabre, J. & Amankwah, A. A., Uneasy Calm at Ghana Water Company. Public Agenda, 22 January, 2007. Nortey. L, Pay Water Workers Well –NCAP. Accra Daily Mail, 17 February, 2007.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[47] [48] [49] [50] [51]
349
Stymne J., Quotation, Swedish Water House Meeting; Water, Power and Poverty- How Clean Water and Sanitation Will Cut Poverty in Half by 2015. 2 February, 2007, Stockholm. Vifell, Å., Enklaver i staten: Internationalisering, demokrati och svensk statsförvaltning. Stockholm Studies in Politics 113: Sthlm University, 2006. Norrfalk M., Quotation, Swedish Water House Meeting; Water, Power and Poverty- How Clean Water and Sanitation Will Cut Poverty in Half by 2015. 2 February, 2007, Stockholm. Bellamy Foster, J., The Ecology of Destruction. Monthly Review, 58(9), pp. 1-14, 2007. Nkrumah’s legacy, 25 pages of tributes on the African of the 20th century. New African, February 2006.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Section 10 Sustainable tourism
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
353
Recreational trail planning in the context of seasonality P. Vassiljev1,2, K. Kuldkepp1, M. Külvik2, A. Kull1 & Ü. Mander1 1
Institute of Geography, University of Tartu, Estonia Institute of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences, Estonian University of Life Sciences, Estonia
2
Abstract This study involved comparing the perceived restorative value of the vegetation types in winter and summer to find out how to plan recreation trails that would have maximum restorative value in both seasons. It was found that vegetation classes do have different levels of restorative value. In agreement with the extensive body of knowledge, the park-like and savannah-like vegetation types resulted in higher scores for restorativeness. Also, the smoothness of the ground and the perceived ease of movement through the landscape seemed to positively affect the restorative value of the vegetation class. Apparent seasonal changes in the visibility and smoothness of the ground had an influence on the restorative value of some vegetation types. Views towards and away from the vegetation type tended to elicit higher scores for restoration potential than views within the type. In order to maximize the restorative value in both seasons, the recreational trails should provide views towards and away from certain vegetation types in the landscape that have smooth ground cover. Long sections of tracks within forests with a dense understorey should be avoided, although the need for variation should be given equal consideration. Because many forest types in the study area are naturally dense or develop a dense understorey, especially on the woodland edge, a consistent plan for landscape management is needed. Keywords: landscape seasonality, landscape assessment, landscape management, restorative quality of natural environments, recreation, recreation trails, woodland edge.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070331
354 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Many outdoor recreation areas are designed to be monofunctional for a set of predominant activities taking place during only one part of the year, e.g. crosscountry ski tracks for winter recreation. Hence the compatibility of recreation areas for activities in many seasons is often neglected. More broadly, seasonality can be considered to be a major problem for recreation/tourism management in general, both because of the instability of returns on investment as well as the exhaustion of infrastructure, landscape carrying capacities and natural resources [1]. However, not very much research has been undertaken in finding factors that would broaden the usability of recreation areas throughout the span of natural seasons [2]. It can be hypothesized that different vegetation types or groups of visually similar vegetation types have an influence on landscape character and thus on the people’s preferences for recreational environments, potentially becoming an important factor for the designing of facilities and recreational tracks. Although visual preference plays an important part in the formation of landscape perception (i.e. restorative experience) [3], it is not necessarily the only factor in such experiences [4]. Therefore this study uses a more comprehensive model of restorative experience described by Han [5] to determine the factors that influence outdoor recreation. In planning new recreational environments, it should also be considered that the location of the person within a particular landscape influences the character of the view. Fry and Sarlöv-Herlin [6] suggest designing paths near the edge of a woodland, which, besides having many ecological benefits, also contributes to aesthetically pleasing qualities, and increase the recreation potential of woodlands. It may be hypothesized that forest stands can be more inviting when viewed inwards from visually open landscapes or produce attractive views when looking outwards from such stand-types into the visually open landscape. It can be inferred that there is a clear need to explore visitors’ preferences concerning landscape elements for recreation track planning, and especially to consider the aspect of seasonality in the restorative value of recreational landscapes.
2
Material and methods
2.1 Study area The Haanja Upland is located in the south-eastern corner of Estonia (Fig. 1). The region covers an area of 816 km2 [7] and is the highest region in the country (the highest point, Suur Munamägi, at 317.6m above sea level, is also the highest point in the Baltic countries). The Haanja Upland has the country’s thickest and longest-lasting snow cover.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
355
Location of the study area. The detailed study area covers orographically varied terrain in the central part of the Haanja Upland.
The Haanja Upland region is a hilly/hummocky landscape that can be characterised as a large underlying moraine hill that is itself covered with a variety of different sized moraine hills, glacio-lacustrine and glacio-fluvial kames, eskers and sandy plains (around the fringes of the upland). The upland area is intersected with deep (up to 200 m) primaeval or sub-glacial valleys, mostly filled with glacio-fluvial gravels and sands. This geological structure makes the topography extremely complex: relative heights reach a difference of 50–60 m, and the steepness of slopes can be 30–35o. This very diverse relief also determines the high degree of patchiness of soil distribution and vegetation cover. The vegetation cover of the present-day patchy cultural landscape consists of an intricate mixture of forests, fields and settlement. Forests cover 62% of the total area [7]. Since the study area is located at the southern limit of the boreo-nemoral forest zone, two deciduous tree genera (Alnus spp. and Betula spp.) and two coniferous species (Picea abies and Pinus sylvestris) are the major constituents in these woodlands. Of the non-forest land, arable fields cover 7% and grasslands 29% of the area. In the valleys and depressions there are over 1000 small peatlands and 170 small lakes, which cover about 1% of the area. Only 1% of the entire Haanja Upland area can be classified as settled area [7]. However, as is typical of Estonian rural settlements, the farmsteads (about 500) are dispersed over the area. As a result, the highly natural appearance, landscape diversity and local cultural heritage of the Haanja region make it attractive for tourism in both summer and winter.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
356 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 2.2 Methodology used The study involved comparing the perceived restorative value of the same landscapes in two seasons and was conducted in two phases – the winter set was done in April 2005 and the summer set in April 2007. A self-rating method developed by Han [5] – the “short-version revised restoration scale” (SRRS) was used to evaluate the restoration potential of natural environments in terms of the different vegetation types found in the study area. The subjects were shown winter or summer landscape photographs respectively and asked to rate specific aspects of their reaction towards those images using a number of differently worded questions on a nine-point Likert scale. SRRS has a broad perspective integrating both the Kaplan and Kaplan [8] and Ulrich [9] theories of restorative environments. While similar to Hartig et al’s [10] revised perceived restorativeness scale RPRS, it also measures the restoration potential of a given environment but focuses on recovery from stress from a broader perspective, not only on the recovery from mental fatigue. It has a small number of items (two questions per dimension of restoration – emotional, physiological, cognitive and behavioural reactions), while still maintaining its validity and reliability [5]. Respondents were undergraduates of geography and biology of the University of Tartu and landscape architecture and environmental protection students from the Estonian University of Life Sciences. The winter set used 86 respondents (25 male, 61 female), whose average age was 21.4 years. Slides were viewed in groups of 7 to 20 people, in two distinctive arrangements (A and B respectively). In total, 48 persons viewed the slides in order A and 38 in order B. The summer set used 79 respondents (18 male, 59 female, 2 unspecified gender), and their average age was 20.8 years. Slides were viewed in groups of 9 to 25 people, in two distinctive arrangements of slides (C and D respectively). In total, 42 persons viewed slides in order C and 37 in order D. 2.3 Selection of visual stimuli The photographs used for the vegetation type restoration potential test were chosen according to vegetation site types characteristic to the Haanja Upland. Vegetation site types were first selected following the national habitat classification system [11], and the selection was later clarified through on-site observations and finally consolidated into 17 distinct “vegetation classes” – groups of visually similar vegetation types. Man-made types – fields and grasslands – were also included in the selection, as these determine the visually open scenes and are usually perceived as natural in character [12]. All pictures were taken at eye level in the same weather conditions throughout the summer and winter and set with the same camera lens setting and orientation towards the horizon. Flat topography in the scene was preferred, because an undulating sightline may increase the degree of aesthetic preference by conveying a sense of mystery [12, 13], and so introduce bias into the results. However, in the case of some scenes it was impossible to eliminate topographic variations completely, due to the particular topography of the test area. The WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
357
presence of obvious man-made structures in the photos was avoided, as it is known from other studies to reduce the attractiveness of a scene, often dramatically [12], leading people to rate the semiotic signs in the landscape given by the structure rather than the vegetation itself. In terms of composition, we chose pictures where there were uniform depictions of the vegetation class without dominant objects or prominent groups of objects created by Gestalt principles [14, 15]. Objects occurring in groups tend to be seen as single landscape elements, and this helps towards interpretation of the view and is one of the key factors determining the preference of views [13, 15]. Thus, making “dull and uniform” pictures enabled the measurement of reactions towards a vegetation type rather than the overall composition of the scene. It was assumed from earlier studies [6] that the restoration potential of a vegetation class would be influenced by the viewer’s position in relation to it, especially when visually enclosing vegetation (i.e. various forest stand types) is situated next to visually open vegetation such as grassland or arable fields. In addition to the uniform view from within the vegetation type, two more views were taken when possible – the view from the visually open landscape towards the vegetation and the view from within the vegetation type outwards to the visually open area. It was impossible to obtain all three view-types with each vegetation class, as 1) some visually enclosed types were seldom located next to a visually open landscape and 2) some types composed of dense vegetation at eye level were visually impervious. The above-mentioned views were grouped into the following classes: views towards the vegetation, views within and views outwards from the vegetation. A total of 35 winter and a corresponding 35 summer slides were used for this study. The sequence of slides in all four sets was random and followed two rules – neither two similar vegetation classes nor two similar view-types should be next to each other in the sequence [16]. 2.4 Questionnaire and statistical analysis The SRRS questionnaire consists of eight questions, two for each dimension of restoration (emotional, physiological, cognitive and behavioural reaction). The questions are set up to be bipolar, enabling the use of a Likert scale from 1 (lowest preference) to 9 (highest preference) to record the response. The questions on physiological response in the SRRS are set up to measure physiological arousal, the opposite of restoration, so resulting value scores must be reversed before further calculations can be carried out (see Han [5] for details). The restorativeness measure of each slide is used to evaluate the restorativeness of vegetation classes amongst each other, and different view types within each vegetation class. It is calculated as an arithmetic average of the four composite scores of emotional, reversed value of physiological, cognitive and behavioural dimensions. The four composite scores are in turn calculated as an arithmetic average of the two appropriate mean question scores within each dimension. Lastly, the eight mean question scores are found by averaging eight sets of numerical responses to the questions in the questionnaire. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
358 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Personal restorativeness scores for each slide are used to test the reliability of the respondents and for ANOVA tests aimed at detecting similarity or dissimilarity amongst summer and winter datasets and view-type datasets. The personal restorativeness score is calculated as an arithmetical average of personal responses to two questions per emotional, cognitive, behavioural and the reversed value of physiological dimensions. Two different reliability tests were carried out on the data. Firstly, Cronbach’s alpha test, which calculated the lower limit for the true reliability of the survey (a function of the number of test items and the average inter-correlation among the items, SPSS Inc. [17]) was carried out to ensure that the restorativeness scale itself was reliable. It was used to examine the relationship of the eight mean question scores within the construct of restorativeness and each of the two appropriate mean question scores within the constructs of emotion, physiology, cognition and behaviour. The second reliability test examined the intra-class correlation calculated for each respondent’s personal restoration potential scores for all slides, to determine whether the respondents’ rating pattern was consistent [17, 18]. In order to compare the restorativeness results of vegetation classes in summer and winter and also to compare the restorativeness results of view-types within vegetation classes, the ANOVA Two-Factor with Replication test was carried out. For that purpose, personal restorativeness scores from both seasons and for all view-types were combined in a single table for every vegetation class. For views with only one view-type, the ANOVA Single Factor analysis was used to compare seasonal effects. The separate scores for restoration potential calculated for each slide were consolidated in a table organised by vegetation class and three view types. The vegetation classes were sorted by values for the restorative potential of the view within the vegetation class in descending order and ranked, in order to illustrate seasonal differences even further. Finally, tables for summer and winter were combined.
3
Results and discussion
3.1 Reliability tests The statistical analysis supported the reliability of the data. The reliability measure (Cronbach's alpha) across all eight variables was 0.945 in winter and 0.932 for summer data. The reliability across four factors of emotion, physiology, cognition and behaviour (two questions per factor) were 0.965; 0.946; 0.991 and 0.997 in the winter test and 0.939; 0.864; 0.985 and 0.992 respectively in the summer test. According to the standards of the Cronbach’s alpha test, values over 0.9 are extremely reliable. This permitted the conclusion that the variation in the data originated from the individuality of respondents and the nature of the slides shown, rather than any lack of clarity in the wording of the questionnaire [17]. Furthermore, the intra-class correlation of 0.919 for winter data and 0.955 for summer data showed that despite their individuality, the respondents were rated according to a very similar pattern [17, 18]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
359
3.2 Assessment of restorativeness of vegetation types The analysis of the test of restoration potential shows that vegetation types do provide different degrees of restoration potential in landscapes, as hypothesized (Table 1). For example, in winter the restoration potential of mature thinned deciduous stands reached 7.24 for views within the stand, while the internal view of willow scrub showed the lowest restoration potential at 3.88. The summer data shows somewhat smaller differences, as pine forest with spruce understorey reached 6.55 for views towards the stand and internal view of the alder thicket showed the lowest restoration potential, at 4.50. 3.3 Seasonal comparison It is necessary to point out some obvious visual differences in the winter and summer scenes used in this study. Winter scenes showed vegetation classes under snow cover that covered uneven ground surface, fallen trunks etc. Lack of foliage and visible ground cover vegetation also enabled one to see further through the vegetation, while various bushes in the understorey were less noticeable. In the summer scenes, the massive foliage reduced visibility and rendered the understorey and silhouettes of the plants very prominent. The results of the ANOVA test (Table 1) show that roughly half of the vegetation classes did elicit different restorativeness scores in different seasons, because the corresponding F statistic was greater than the critical F needed to reject the null hypothesis. The mature deciduous stand placed first in both winter and summer, but winter scores were significantly higher than personal restorativeness scores in summer. Similarly, the pure pine forest, reed-beds on lake shores, pine forest on wet boggy sites and young spruce plantation with a view towards the stand were cases where a winter scene placed significantly better than the summer view in the ranking order, and that difference was confirmed by the ANOVA test. This tendency may be explained by seasonal differences in ground cover. The smoothness of the ground and perceived ease of movement through the scene are believed to be key factors in determining people's preference for landscapes [12]. In summer photos, high ground cover vegetation can be observed, while winter scenes show smooth ground surface under thick snow cover. Snow also covers up fallen trunks and other "bumpy" surface features. Ice covering the lake surface also renders it easy to walk on. Contrary to previous examples, there were vegetation classes where summer scenes had significantly better scores. Open field with protruding grassy remains, younger thinned deciduous forest and pine forest with spruce understorey placed considerably better in summer rankings, and the seasonal difference was confirmed by the ANOVA test. Willow scrub also showed a significant seasonal difference, although placement in the ranking order was less dramatic. The high score of restoration potential given to the mature thinned deciduous stand and pure pine forest in both seasons is consistent with a general notion expressed by Ulrich [12] and Parsons and Daniel [3] on the extensive body of
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
360 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Restoration potential (scale 1 to 9) of the vegetation classes, by different view types and their ranking order in summer (s) and winter (w), ANOVA F statistic and critical F value of the seasonal difference test and view-type difference test.
Mature thinned deciduous stand Raised bog with scattered small pines (Pinus sylvestris) Open field with protruding grassy remains Open field with smooth surface Younger thinned deciduous forest Pine forest with spruce (Picea abies) understorey
s w s w s w s w s w s w s Pure pine forest w s Reed beds on lake shores w Pine forests on wet boggy s sites w s Young spruce plantation w s Spruce plantation thicket w Spruce forest with sparse s understorey w Spruce forest with dense s understorey w Deciduous forest with dense s understorey w s Willow (Salix sp) scrub w s Birch (Betula pendula) scrub w s Alder (Alnus incana) thicket w
6.53 5.61 6.55 4.89 6.03 6.52 6.14 6.17
5.60 6.23 5.48 5.79 6.45 6.29 6.17 5.57 5.92 5.63 6.14 4.27 5.29 5.16 5.16 5.07
6.50 7.24 6.38 6.30 6.28 5.03 6.26 5.90 6.20 5.15 6.17 4.64 6.04 6.53 6.25 6.76 5.83 6.37 5.62 6.69
1 1 2 4 3 13 4 8 5 12 6 14 7 5 8 3 9 2 10 6
5.60 5.68 5.59 5.96 5.05 5.47 4.91 5.38 4.84 3.88 4.76 4.52 4.50 4.63
11 9 5.92 5.97 5.12 5.65 5.52 5.60 5.34 4.72 4.88 4.73 5.11 5.25
12 7 13 10 14 11 15 17 16 16 17 15
17.67 3.90 confirmed 0.23 3.90 not confirmed 48.40 3.90 confirmed 3.24 3.90 not confirmed 55.40 3.87 confirmed 124.00 3.87 confirmed 7.77 3.86 confirmed 5.46 3.87 confirmed 31.28 3.90 confirmed 12.30 3.90 confirmed 2.07 3.87 not confirmed 1.90 3.86 not confirmed 1.08 3.86 not confirmed 1.22 3.86 not confirmed 77.60 3.86 confirmed 1.61 3.86 not confirmed 0.59 3.86 not confirmed
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
F-crit
View-type difference
F
F-crit
Seasonal difference
F
Summer (s) / Winter (w)
Restorativeness Ranking score order
Winter
Vegetation class
Towards the type Within the type Away from the type Summer
Table 1:
9.70 3.87 confirmed 5.48 3.87 confirmed 6.05 3.02 confirmed 0.06 3.87 not confirmed
0.00 3.87 not confirmed 9.58 3.02 confirmed 10.35 3.02 confirmed 9.94 3.02 confirmed 17.75 3.02 confirmed 8.49 3.02 confirmed 8.84 3.02 confirmed
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
361
research concerning aesthetic preferences for natural vegetation, where park-like or savannah-like structures tend to produce the highest preference scores. Another notion expressed by Ulrich [12] is that people tend to prefer land cover types with a smooth surface, which favours movement across them. This would also suggest that scrub would be viewed unfavourably, as it hinders walking through it. Whether the perceived ability to walk across or through vegetation can be associated with restoration potential is another matter, however, this corresponds to the high restorative potential of mature thinned deciduous stands, scattered pine forest on wet boggy sites in winter, raised bog with scattered small pines and pure pine forest and the low restoration potential of scattered pine forest on wet boggy sites in summer, alder thicket, birch and willow scrub. In addition, the higher scores of spruce forest with sparse understorey compared to the same stand with dense understorey also seem to confirm this notion. The scenes of pine forest with a spruce understorey showed fallen tree trunks in the winter photo, as the snow was not thick enough to cover them up. Meanwhile, the summer scene did not show fallen trunks on the ground. As such, the results for the pine forest with spruce understorey are in line with the general findings concerning the smoothness and navigability of the ground surface. The better results of the willow scrub in summer are perhaps explainable by foliage bringing out the round silhouettes of the bushes that gave the scene better legibility / distinctiveness, which in turn increased preference [13]. The great seasonal difference of the open field with protruding grassy remains may be due to the content of the scene. The winter photo showed a strip of an even width of forest in the background, but the summer photo unfortunately had forests broken up in separate distinguishable clumps. This may have increased the complexity of the scene, which is known to influence landscape preference [13]. The remaining case of younger thinned deciduous forest seems to be an anomaly that the authors are unable to explain. Perhaps the white birch trunks were less prominent on the background of the white snow while green vegetation in the summer made the trunks more prominent and dramatic. According to the ANOVA test, it was not possible to reject the hypothesis that summer and winter scores are similar in the case of nearly half of the vegetation classes. In addition, the ranking order placed some of those classes, namely raised bog with scattered small pines, spruce plantation thicket, birch scrub and alder thicket, quite close to each other. In contrast, open field with smooth surface, spruce forest with sparse understorey, spruce forest with dense understorey, and deciduous forest with dense understorey all had a noticeable difference in restorativeness scores and ranking order placements, but the ANOVA test was unable to confirm that difference. These results allow one to conclude that in general, the smoothness of the ground and perceived ease of movement through the scene may have determined the results. Vegetation classes that had a thick understorey or were dense by themselves showed low restorativeness scores regardless of the season.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
362 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 3.4 The “edge effect” The hypothesis that views towards, away from and within the same vegetation type can elicit different degrees of restoration potential was supported by the data. The ANOVA test conducted separately for each vegetation class consistently showed that the restorativeness scores of different view-types of a vegetation class differed significantly. The only two exceptions to the rule where it was not possible to confirm difference in datasets were reed-beds on lakeshores and spruce plantation thickets. Moreover, a distinct pattern could be observed where views towards and away from the vegetation generally produced a higher score for restoration potential than views within the vegetation type (Table 1). This may be explained by the higher visual complexity of the scene [13], which leads to increased aesthetic preference. In terms of a practical landscape design application, we can conclude that the ideal recreational route should contain a combination of views towards and away from certain vegetation types. From the ecological point of view, when planning the management of woodland edges it is important to consider the fact that south- and west-facing edges usually develop higher species richness and structural diversity than north- and east-facing edges [6]. On the contrast, northand east-facing edges provide cool shade in the hot summer and have favourable conditions for long-lasting and thick snow cover in winter. This difference in the suitability of forest edges for recreation and ecological conservation could provide planners with an application enabling them to reduce conflicts between those two interest groups. 3.5 General discussion The recreational trails might be targeted more specifically to suit the most desirable season (be it cross-country skiing in winter or cycling in summer), but in order to maximize the restorative value in both seasons, they should provide views in towards and away from certain vegetation types on the north- and eastfacing edges of the forests in the landscape with smooth ground cover. Long sections of tracks within forests with a dense understorey should be avoided, although the need for variation should receive equal consideration. Recommendations on the design of recreational areas and routes suggest that variety in the experience is desirable [19, 20]. Thus the recreational route should also be located so the viewer could experience different vegetation types over time, passing through open areas with views of sufficient scale to enable the view to be enjoyed. Many forest types in the study area are naturally dense or develop a dense understorey, especially on the woodland’s edge. Due to their linear character, the recreational tracks create additional strands of woodland edge with better light conditions for a newly propagating dense understorey. Also, abandoned fields that have begun to grow into birch and alder scrub occupy a considerable proportion of the study area. All of this poses a challenge for landscape maintenance and design.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
363
The study subjects were all young adults, mostly female, who had an interest in landscape and nature. They were able to distinguish between vegetation types because they have been educated to do so. This may have biased the results compared with a more demographically representative sample. It would be valuable to carry out further exploration of the preferences and perceptions of different user-groups such as sportsmen or children, and other user needs such as solitude or physical challenge.
4
Conclusions
The study involved comparing the perceived restorative value of the same vegetation types in winter and summer. We found that vegetation classes do have different levels of restorative value. In agreement with the extensive body of knowledge on the topic, the park-like and savannah-like vegetation types resulted in higher restorativeness scores. The smoothness of the ground and perceived ease of movement through the landscape seemed to positively affect the restorative value of the vegetation class. Seasonal variability has an influence on the restorative value of some vegetation types. This can be explained by apparent changes in the visibility and smoothness of the ground. Views towards and away from the vegetation type tend to elicit higher scores for restoration potential than views within the type. It is possible to reduce conflicts between recreational and ecological interests in woodlands by having recreation tracks on north- and east-facing edges where species richness and structural diversity are lower, while the shade provides shelter from the hot summer sun and creates better snow conditions in winter. Recreational trails might be targeted more specifically to suit the most desirable season, but in order to maximize the restorative value and provide opportunities in both seasons, they should provide views towards and away from certain vegetation types on the north- and east-facing edges of the forests in landscape with smooth ground cover. Long sections of tracks within forests with a dense understorey should be avoided, although the need for variation should receive equal consideration. Many forest types in the study area are naturally dense or develop a dense understorey, especially on the edge of the woodland. Also, due to their linear character, recreational tracks create long strands of woodland edge with better light conditions for a newly propagating dense understorey. This poses a challenge for landscape maintenance and landscape design.
References [1] [2] [3]
Krakover, S., 2000. Partitioning seasonal employment in the hospitality industry. Tourism Manage. 21, 5, 461-471. Baum, T. and Hagen, L., 1999. Responses to seasonality: the experiences of peripheral destinations, Int. J. Tourism Res. 1, 299-312. Parsons, R., Daniel, T.C., 2002. Good looking: in defense of scenic landscape aesthetics. Landscape Urban Plan. 60, 43–56. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
364 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20]
Tahvanainen, L., Tyrväinen, L., Ihalainen, M., Vuorela, N., Kolehmainen, O, 2001. Forest management and public perceptions — visual versus verbal information. Landscape Urban Plan. 53, 53–70. Han, K.-T., 2003. A reliable and valid self-rating measure of the restorative quality of natural environments. Landscape Urban Plan. 64, 209–232. Fry, G., Sarlöv-Herlin, I., 1997. The ecological and amenity functions of woodland edges in the agricultural landscape; a basis for design and management. Landscape Urban Plan. 37, 45–55. Arold, I., 2005. Estonian landscapes. Tartu Ülikooli Kirjastus. Tartu. (In Estonian). Kaplan, R., Kaplan, S., 1989. The Experience of Nature: A Psychological Perspective. Cambridge University Press, New York. Ulrich, R.S., 1983. Aesthetic and affective response to natural environment. In: Altman, I., Wohlwill, J.F. (Eds.), Behavior and Natural Environments. Plenum Press, New York. Hartig, T.A., Korpela, K., Evans, G.W., Garling, T., 1997. A measure of restorative quality in environments. Scand. Hous. Plann. Res. 14, 175– 194. Paal, J., 1997. Classification of Estonian vegetation site types. Keskkonnaministeeriumi Info- ja Tehnokeskus, Tallinn. (In Estonian). Ulrich, R.S., 1986. Human Responses to Vegetation And Landscapes. Landscape Urban Plan. 13, 29–40. Kaplan, S., 1982. Cognition and Environment: Functioning in an Uncertain World. Praeger Publishers, New York. Bell, S., 1999 Landscape: pattern, perception and process. E&FN Spon, London. Bell, S., 2004. Elements of visual design in the landscape. Second edition. E. &F.N. Spon, London. Herzog, T.R., Black, A.M., Fountaine, K.A., Knotts, D.J., 1997. Reflection and attentional recovery as distinctive benefits of restorative environments. J. Environ. Psychol. 17, 165–170. SPSS Inc., 2004. SPSS Base 13.0 Case studies tutorial. SPSS Inc., Chicago. Palmer, J.F., Hoffman, R.E., 2001. Rating reliability and representation validity in scenic landscape assessments. Landscape Urban Plan. 54, 149– 161. Bell, S., 1997. Design for outdoor recreation. E&FN Spon, London Kaplan, R., Kaplan S., Ryan, R., 1998 With people in mind. Island Press, Washington DC.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
365
A new method for tourism carrying capacity assessment V. Castellani, S. Sala & D. Pitea University of Milano Bicocca, Department of Environmental Sciences, Italy
Abstract Tourism activities can generate both positive and negative effects on the conditions of the areas where visiting and fruition activities take place; every form of human use of natural environment causes changes to the environment conditions. Evaluation of carrying capacity of a destination has as a purpose the measurement of the threshold over which alteration due to human activities becomes unacceptable. To evaluate the consequences of tourism activities impacts it is necessary to know the characteristics of the environment where they occur and especially its resilience, which is the measure of the disturbance that the natural environment can tolerate without altering its equilibrium state. The carrying capacity concept is linked with resilience and rises from the necessity of measure which is the maximum acceptable level of impact for the environment or for one of its components and the capability of recovery of the previous condition. The purpose of this study is to suggest a model for assessing the physical carrying capacity of tourism destinations, as a tool to evaluate whether the current situation is sustainable or not and to determine if a rise in visitor numbers could affect the quality of the environment, the resources available and the quality of public services. For the assessment, all environmental aspects are separately analysed and the main environmental issues related to the daily life of residents and to tourism activities (air quality, water quality and disposability, waste management, soil use) are considered. The methodology is based on an evaluative procedure inspired by the DPSIR model, useful for underlining which are the drivers of impacts and which is the most relevant dataset to describe current and future scenarios. The innovative aspect of this study is the integration of the physical carrying capacity assessment with the evaluation of the managing capacity of environmental and public services, which can lead to depletion of ecosystem quality. Keywords: tourism, carrying capacity, destination management, DPSIR model. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070341
366 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Tourism activities can generate both positive and negative effects on the conditions of the areas where visiting and fruition activities take place; every form of human activity causes changes of environmental conditions; the purpose of the evaluation of carrying capacity of a destination is the measurement of the threshold over which alteration due to human activities becomes unacceptable for the resource recovery. To evaluate consequences of tourism activities impact is necessary to know the characteristics of the environment where they insist on and especially its resilience, which is the measure of the disturbance that natural environment can tolerate without altering its state of equilibrium. Carrying capacity concept is linked with resilience and rises from the necessity of measure which is the maximum acceptable level of impact for the environment or for one of its components and the capability of recovery of previous condition (Holling [6]). World Tourism Organization has defined Tourism Carrying Capacity as “the maximum number of persons which could visit a location within a given period, such that local environmental, physical, economic, and socio-cultural characteristics are not compromised, and without reducing tourist satisfaction” (WTO, [12]). Thus, physical (or ecological), social and economic carrying capacity can be defined as follow: • Physical (or ecological) carrying capacity is the threshold limit beyond which natural and cultural heritage of a destination are damaged by tourism; physical carrying capacity of a destination is thence determined through the analysis of its environmental components (for example, water resources quantity and availability, limits for air pollutants concentrations) and through the analysis of the facilities required by both tourists and residents: saturation limits for existing facilities (for example, sewage treatment plants, waste treatment plants) and limits for new facilities construction. • Economic carrying capacity is the threshold limit beyond which tourism growth becomes economically unacceptable; this situation may rise from two conditions: a) when tourism interfere with other economic activities obstructing their development, b) when the presence of a great number of tourists makes the destination no more comfortable and attractive and causes a contraction in tourism demand. • Social carrying capacity is the threshold beyond which social aspects of the host community are badly influenced and damage by tourism activities and life’s quality of residents is no more granted; this situation can also lead to conflicts between tourists and resident population, generating social tensions. In this paper a study of physical carrying capacity of a tourist destination is presented, applied to Oltrepo Mantovano area, in northern Italy. The innovative aspect of this study is the integration of physical carrying capacity assessment with the evaluation of managing capacity of environmental and public services, which could lead to depletion of ecosystems quality.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
367
Oltrepo Mantovano is an interesting area of application because it is a newly emerging tourism destination according to the tourism area Life Cycle Model (Agarwal [1], Butler [4], Miossec [11]) and also because protected areas of Oltrepo Mantovano have undertaken European Charter for Sustainable Tourism in Protected Areas, a process promoted by Europarc (the European Federation of Parks), with the aim of assuring environmental conservation and promoting economic and social development through a sustainable tourism strategy. Assessing carrying capacity in this area is thence an effort to provide a useful tool to decision makers (i.e. local administrators and park managers) that are now planning tourism development policy for future years, trying to promote sustainable development and prevent adverse effect on the environment.
2 Methodology The methodology is based on an evaluative procedure inspired to DPSIR model, useful to underline which are the drivers of impacts and which is the most useful dataset to describe current and future scenarios. For carrying capacity assessment, all environmental aspects are separately took into account and main environmental issues related to daily life of residents and to tourism activities (air quality, water quality and disposability, waste management, soil use) are considered. The methodology aims to integrate physical carrying capacity assessment with the evaluation of managing capacity of environmental and public services. This approach is based on the consciousness that two major types of impact can be identified in a tourist destination: those with are associated with tourism structures (hotels, roads and other facilities) and those resulting from the tourists themselves (crowding of natural sites, air and water pollution) (May [9]). The analysis of tourism sector based on DPSIR model allows one to identify main issues related to tourism activities and to address tourism carrying capacity assessment. Table 1: Drivers Pressures
State Impacts Responses
DPSIR model for tourism sector.
Construction and management of hospitality structures and facilities, presence of tourists, urban traffic. Emissions of air pollutants, use of groundwater resources, immission of pollutants in stream waters, production of solid urban waste, land use and soil erosion, energy consumption, presence of tourists in protected areas. Concentration of pollutant in air and water, groundwater availability, quantity of solid urban waste, level of urbanization, level of crowding in natural sites. Loss of biodiversity, disturb of wild species, adverse effects on human health. Promotion of sustainable tourism: reduction of water and energy consumption, reduction of waste production and increasing of separated waste collection, promotion of public transports, use of renewable energy, promotion of ecotourism activities.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
368 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Evaluation phases, used for every issue, are: Selection of the issue and characterization of the drivers related to it Selection of drivers relevant for the issue in tourism contest Identification of main pressures Development/application of specific indicators for identified pressures Set up of benchmark values, minimum and maximum, and definition of classes for the result. Selection of benchmark values is based on: a. literature b. limit values determined by European and Italian laws c. benchmarking with other situations 6. Collection of local data and data processing 7. Evaluation of carrying capacity of the issue, based on benchmarking among considered variables; for the evaluation, precautionary principle is adopted: worst case is taken into account and, if one variable is near the limit, low carrying capacity is attributed to the entire compartment. 8. Elaboration of the results to select appropriate responses for short or long term solution of main problems identified, which can be performed by public and private administrators and by tourists themselves, in a shared responsibility perspective. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
3
Results
Oltrepo Mantovano is a plain area, with low population density and little urban centres. Industrialization is not very high, but the presence of two electric power plants strongly characterises the area, both from industrial and environmental perspective. Protected areas are mainly homes near Po river with seminatives and timbers and have high ecological value: part of the areas is classified as Important Bird Areas (IBA) and there are also many endemic species (e.g. Lataste’s frog). Table 2 shows an example of a detailed scheme, developed for each compartment, applied to Oltrepo Mantovano area. The previous conceptual scheme, applied to all compartment considered, gives an overall evaluation of tourism carrying capacity in Oltrepo Mantovano. The main results are presented in table 3.
4
Discussion
Results of tourism carrying capacity of Oltrepo Mantovano, though not completely exhaustive, show that the situation is critical for some aspects, suggesting that a sustainable tourism policy for the future should take into account the necessity of some actions to prevent environmental damage and arise of problems for environmental and public services management. Issues that have a low (or very low) carrying capacity rank are groundwater disposability and air quality. This result is to take into serious account in view of a tourism development because both this issues could be seriously affected by a
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 2:
369
Methodology for air carrying capacity assessment.
DPSIR 1) DRIVERS
METHODOLOGY Analysis of datasets of emissions sources aimed to identify which sources / activities are most relevant in the area object of the investigation.
2) DRIVERS AND VARIABLES RELEVANT FOR TOURISM SECTOR
From the drivers set identified in step 1, selection of drivers which are most relevant for tourism sector.
3) PRESSURES
Selection of main pressures generated by identified driver/s.
4) INDICATORS
Selection of appropriate indicators to measure state. Indicator used by European and Italian legislation to evaluate air pollution level is the number of daily overcoming of limit concentration during a year.
5) STATE CLASSES
On the base of indicators and limit identified in the previous step, classes of carrying capacity are fixed.
6) LOCAL RESULT
Analysis of local data about indicators identified.
LOCAL RESULTS Analysis of data from Inemar Lombardy Region inventory of emission sources: main drivers for Oltrepo Mantovano are: electric power generation (electric power plants), non industrial combustion (heating) and urban traffic, which cause emissions of PM10, CO2, COV, NOx, SO2 and CO. The emission source most relevant for tourism sector evaluation in Oltrepo Mantovano is urban traffic, because electric power generation is an industrial activity, not strictly linked with local consumption and heating becomes not relevant during high tourist seasons (spring-summer). Urban traffic generates emissions of PM10, CO, COV and NOx. ARPA monitoring network registers periodically the values of concentration of PM10, CO and NO2; data of COV concentrations are not available. a) number of overcoming for PM10 concentration in Oltrepo Mantovano; limit value: 35 days of overcoming/year. b) number of overcoming for NO2 concentration in Oltrepo Mantovano; limit value: 35 days of overcoming/year. A limit for CO is not fixed because this pollutant is no longer a problem in Italy. a) nr of overcoming for PM10 <10: HIGH carrying capacity nr of overcoming for PM10 =35: LIMIT of carrying capacity nr of overcoming for PM10 >35: LOW carrying capacity nr of overcoming for PM10 35: VERY LOW carrying capacity b) nr of overcoming for NO2 <10: HIGH carrying capacity nr of overcoming for NO2 =18: LIMIT of carrying capacity nr of overcoming for NO2 >18: LOW carrying capacity nr of overcoming for NO2 18: VERY LOW carrying capacity nr of overcoming for PM10: 108 nr of overcoming for NO2: 1
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
370 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 2: 7) CARRYING CAPACITY
8) RESPONSES
Continued.
Carrying capacity assessment, based on classes identified and data collected; carrying capacity level of the entire compartment is assigned according to precautionary principle. Elaboration of the results to select responses for main problems identified
a) PM10: VERY LOW b) NO2: HIGH Carrying capacity of the issue: VERY LOW Promote public transport and tourist offers for discouraging use of private car by tourists.
raise in the number of tourists: indeed groundwater is the main source of drinking water in the area and moreover Oltrepo Mantovano is in the critical area of Lombardy Region and the difficulties of using public transport to move in the area (as the high percentage of tourists reaching the destination with private cars confirm) may cause an additional decline of air quality situation in case of increase of tourists number. Besides, carrying capacity is at limit for some other important issues, both from environmental and managing perspective: ecological status of stream waters and percentage of separated waste disposal are now sufficient, but both the natural resources and public services would be not able to manage additional load coming from the increasing of tourism impacts. Regarding current situation, main critical aspect, not directly depending from local policy management, seems to be the ratio between daily visitors and resident tourists: daily visitors, that are proved to generate more impacts on the environment and cause more consumption of resources rather than resident tourists (Beltrame et al [3]) are currently twice the number of resident tourists in Oltrepo Mantovano.
5
Conclusions
The main critical aspect associated with carrying capacity assessment of tourism destination is the complexity of providing numeric results (Bimonte and Punzo [2]). Following Manning point of view [10], this study is an attempt to quantify current state of every compartment involved in tourism management and give a quantity perspective on present and future scenarios of destination development considering environmental, social and economical indicators. The main difficulties emerging from this application of the methodology are: • necessity of setting precise values that are widely recognises as thresholds of sustainability, could be a quite controversial aspect: a good solution seems to be the use of law limits, but these are not available for all issues: in this case, further investigation, also considering local contest and expert judgement, could be required. European Charter for Sustainable Tourism in Protected Areas is a good tool for this purpose, because the process strongly encourage the involvement of local stakeholders;
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 3:
Results of assessment.
Oltrepo
Indicator
Disposability of groundwater
withdrawal / recharge (m3/g) / (m3/g) people served by sewage disposal (people served/people resident) *100
☺
Waste management
carrying
Value
capacity
Carrying capacity
<1 =1
1,35
>1
☺
100%-75% 75%-50%
75%
☺
>1
☺
<50%
potential P.E. / actual P.E.
>1 =1 <1
ecological status of stream waters classification according to title 152/99 and subsequent modifications (LIM parameter)
Energetic consume
tourism
State / classes
☺ Quality of stream water
Mantovano
mean energetic consume (municipality level) / mean energetic consume (national level) (MWh/residents) daily per capita production (kg/ residents *d)
% of separated waste disposal
☺
excellent, good sufficient
sufficient
bad, awful
☺
<1
=1
<1
☺
1,6
☺
>1
☺
1,8 - 2,2 Kg/res*d 2,2 – 2,5 Kg/res*d >2,5 Kg/res*d
☺
>45% 35-45%
39,80%
<35%
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
371
372 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 3:
Continued.
Air quality
mean number of overcoming of law thresholds / year
limit value: not over 35 days of overcoming/year for Pm10,; not over 18 days of overtaking/year for NO2
Biodiversity
loss of species, disturb number of visitors/ year
no classes, judgement of experts
hospitality density beds / 1000 residents
☺
hospitality density extension of hospitality structures/total extension of tourist area
☺
tourist buildings non hotel structures / total hospitality structures
☺
Soil use Houses not used by residents / total of houses
expert local
PM10: 108 NO2: 1
4.0005.000
☺
13,71
☺
0,001%
☺
54,20%
☺
8%
☺
Low
☺
0-100 10-300 > 300 0%-30% 30%-60% >60% >20% 10%-20% < 10%
☺
< 20% 20%-50% > 50%
☺ crowding of natural sites and paths (expert judgement)
low
mean
high
☺ daily visitors/tourists
I<1 1
>2
I>2
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 3:
Use of existing structures
[overnights / (beds*365)] * 100
☺
373
Continued. < 20% 30,76
20% - 40% over 40%
% of tourists reaching the area with private cars
Mobility
Number of private cars/residents Number of municipalities with a railway station
Tourist intensity in peak month
(overnights in august/31days) / residents
Tourist employment
Employed in tourism sector / total employed
☺
<40% >70%
40%-70% >70%
☺
0-0,3 0,59
0,3-0,5 0,5-0,8
☺
0,8-1 0,6
0,4-0,7 0-0,3
☺
I< 0,5 0,5 < I > 1
0,002
☺
3,14%
☺
I>1 no classes, judgement of experts
expert local
• •
difficulty to find data for a multi-year period; difficult to obtain exhaustive results for all considered compartment. Moreover, regarding the themes considered in tourism carrying capacity assessment, most critical issues seem to be: consumption of energy, for which there is a lack of data in Italian statistic dataset at local level, and impacts on biodiversity. Data of local energy consumption available in Italy refers to 1997, because it is the last year of national management of energy market: from 1998 in Italy there are various energy supplier, so the collection of data is now very difficult and a detailed national dataset on consumption is no more available. Besides, measuring impact of tourism activities on biodiversity requires specific study on the areas under investigation, because every situation has specific characteristics. The assessment of loss of biodiversity due to tourism activities requires one to individuate a representative species for each kind of impact, considering a multiple stress condition. These information is not yet available, so detailed monitoring campaign on flora and fauna of protected areas should be promoted and investigation on number and characteristic of tourists should be carried out to obtain more data useful to measure the disturb caused by tourism activities and to assess carrying capacity of the areas. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
374 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[11] [12]
Agarwal, S., The resort cycle revisited: implications for resorts. In C. Cooper and A. Lockwood (eds) Progress in Tourism, Recreation and Hospitality Management, Vol. 5. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons, 1994 Bimonte, S., Punzo, F., A proposito di capacità di carico turistica. Una breve analisi teorica. EdATS Working Papers Series 4, 2005 Beltrame, C., Ciarli, E., Giorgini, E., Maggi, M. Il turismo nell’area del Parco di Crea. Ires Piemonte, 2002 Butler, R. The concept of a tourist area cycle of evolution. Canadian Geographer 24, pp. 5–1, 1980 EEA, Environmental indicators: typology and overview. In: Smeets E, Weterings R (eds) Technical report 25, p 19, 1999 Holling, C.S., Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 4, pp. 1−23, 1973 Italian national water law, D.lgs 192/99. Gazzetta Ufficiale 145, 1999 INEMAR, www.ambiente.regione.lombardia.it/inemar/inemarhome.htm May, V., Tourism, the environment, and development: values, sustainability and stewardship. Tourism Management, 12(2), pp. 112–118, 1991 Manning, R.E., How much is too much? Carrying capacity of national parks and protected areas. In: Monitoring and management of visitor flows in recreational and protected areas. Bodenkultur University, Vienna, Austria. p. 306–313, 2002. Miossec, J.M., Un modèle de l'espace touristique. L'espace géographique: régions, environnement, aménagement, 6(1), pp. 41-48, 1977 WTO, Global code of ethics for tourism. Proc. of Thirteenth session of General Assembly: Santiago, Chile, 1999.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
375
Environmental impacts caused by the tourist industry in Elafonisos Island and the Neapoli district, Greece B. S. Tselentis1, D. G. Prokopiou1, D. Bousbouras2 & M. Toanoglou3 1
Department of Maritime Studies, Laboratory of Marine Sciences, University of Piraeus, Greece 2 Hellenic Ornithological Society, Greece 3 Euroxenia Hotel Management and Consulting, Rhodes, Greece
Abstract Many studies have shown that a tourist service or product is a blend of ecological, social and economic sub-systems, operable in the area of interest. Carrying capacity assessment has become an indispensable tool for formulating policy and strategies in the tourist industry worldwide. It is well known that Greece depends heavily on the tourist trade. For the Greek coastal tourist industry, the environment, both natural and man made, plays a leading role in the sustainable development of this economic activity. It is the purpose of this paper to apply novel environmental protection tools in order to estimate impacts inflicted by the tourist industry on local fauna and flora, as well as the whole well being of the physical environment.
1
Introduction
The concept of sustainable tourism is used in the context of achieving economic growth without damaging the natural and build environment as well as conserving the culture of local communities [1]. The World Tourism Organisation (WTO) defines carrying capacity as: “The maximum number of people that may visit a tourist destination at the same time, without causing destruction to the physical, economic, socio-cultural environment and an unacceptable decrease in the quality of visitors' satisfaction”. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070351
376 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Tourism can generate both positive and negative environmental impacts, depending on how well development is planned and controlled [2]. This paper investigates the level of impacts in two areas. The first district is situated on the southern part of the Peloponnesus peninsula and covers the Vatica municipality area, called Vatica. The other area is Elafonisos, a small island close to the Peloponnesus mainland 350m from the Vatika coast. Both places are well known tourist destinations with beautiful beaches, and sand dunes rich in spectacular flora. The importance of these areas for the Mediterranean ecosystem and biodiversity, is highlighted by the fact that they both belong to the NATURA 2000 network, which presents a special challenge for further tourist development of the area.
2
Tourist development and environment
Both areas of the study area, Vatica and Elafonisos, belong to the Prefecture of Laconia, with Sparta as the capital; capital of Vatica is Neapoly town.
Figure 1:
Elafonisos and Vatica [3].
In Elafonisos and Vatica, the tourism industry relies mainly on rooms to let and organized camping especially in Elafonisos. Some years ago free camping was still allowed and thus the area came to be associated with that kind of tourist service, even though that activity is now prohibited due to environmental protection reasons. Elafonisos is a very famous tourist destination but high season there is only August. Tourist development started in the 90s (after 1985) and as a result there are no large tourist developments. Tourist services are based on small enterprises and, until recently, no serious treats to the environment have been sited. However, a steady increase in the number of visitors, and the realisation that the environment WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
377
may well be in danger, have made it imperative to further study and estimate the adverse effects and propose policies and measures that will allow sustainable development in the area.
3 Basic population characteristics [4] Table 1 indicates the population in terms of inhabitants and urban settlement characteristics. Both the areas under study are considered sparsely inhabited with Elafonisos showing a very small built up area. As indicated in Table 2 the population of Elafonisos has increased considerably during the period between 1991 and 2001, a rise of about 15%. The population of Vatica municipality has reduced slightly during the same period. Table 1:
Population.
POPULATION
Area
Population
Municipality of Vies (Vatica)
7.871
Elafonisos
745
Density
215,6
37
2,25
Built up areas km2 3,5
20
36
2,48
0,3
Area (km2)
Table 2:
inhabitants/ km2
Built up Density buildings 2 /km
Mean age of built up areas 1,62 1,5
Population trends.
POPULATION TRENDS
Prefecture of Laconia Municipality of Vies (Vatica) Elafonisos
4
1971 -
1981 -
1991 90.522
2001 92.811
-
-
7.257
7.111
586
611
647
746
Tourist enterprise history [5]
As indicated in Table 3 hotel bed capacity in Laconia Prefecture has increased considerably during the period of 1995-2003. Tourist development in Vatica and Elafonisos started in the early ‘90s. In 1993, the number of hotels in Vatica was 7 whereas in 2007 rose to 6. Table 4 describes the trend in hotel units and bed availability over the years. Today, tourist capacity in beds is estimated at about 6000 in Vatica and 900 in Elafonisos. Figures give a graphical WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
378 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 3:
Tourist accommodations over the years.
TOURIST ACCOMMODATIONS: PREFECTURE OF LACONIA Prefecture of Lakonia 1995 1997 1998 2003
Hotels and similar establishments
Other accommodation
3.201 3.386 3.357 3.504
2.961 2.961 2.961 3.270
Table 4:
Bed capacity trends [6,7,8,9,10].
BED CAPACITY TRENDS: VIES AND ELAFONISOS Hotels and rooms to let tourist enterprises Vatica Elafonisos
5
1993 7 8
2000 4 8
2007 6 8
Beds 1993 -
2000 -
2004 342 -
2007 600 1100
Natural environment
In this study area two regions have been characterised as environmentally sensitive. 5.1 Elafonisos Elafonisos is a famous island for its beautiful sandy beaches. The most famous beach is called “Simos” (figure 5), which has crystal blue waters and a unique sand dune environment. The island of Elafonisos is situated within the gulf of Laconia, at its most eastern part, very close to Punta beach. Elafonisos has a triangle shape and acts as protection for the Neapoli gulf [11]. 5.2 Vatica The NATURA 2000 area in Elafonisos island (figure 4), houses an important sand dune - wetland environment, and is a continuum with sand dunes situated on the opposite side on the Peloponnesus. These wetland areas are considered to be under threat as they lie along the coast line, where most of the tourist industry activity is based. Close to the sand dunes of the municipality of Vies an important wetland called Strogili is situated (figure 2). In this area an important coastal lily (Pancratium maritimum) inhabited in the sand dunes, now considered to be under extinction. Many important fauna and flora species inhabit these Sites of Community Importance (SCI). The area of these two Natura 2000 network places is 603ha as they are entered in the 40 most important sand dune areas of Greece [12].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 2:
379
Sand dune areas and the salt marches opposite of Elafonisos. Table 5: Species
Reptiles Amphibians Birds Mammals
Figure 3:
28 2 138 11
Vatica.
Local fauna [13].
LOCAL FAUNA Threatened species mentioned in the ‘Red Book’ [14] of Greek species 13 0 27 4
Figure 4:
Elafonisos.
6 SWOT analysis on tourism industry in Elafonisos and Vatica 6.1 Strengths Unique environment. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
380 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 5:
Elafonisos: Simos beach.
6.2 Weaknesses No waste management system Situated a long distance away from an airport. The nearer airport is on Kithira island and that of Sparta is a further distance but can be accessed via a road, giving it a marked advantage compared to the one on Kithira. No organized tourist product 6.3 Opportunities As the tourist trade started after the 90s, development can be planed in a sustainable way Planning of an alternative tourist product based on local strengths and characteristics 6.4 Threats No sustainable framework for development and illegal building practices, due to slack enforcement of planning policies and constraints, may cause serious impacts on the local physical and social environment.
7
Environmental indicators
7.1 Beach impact factor With this indicator we analyse the pressures facing the coastal environment, as it describe the concentration of people visiting and using the facilities of the coastal area, and especially beaches. Most of the tourists are concentrated around the sand dunes. The camping in Elafonisos is stated very close, about 30 meters from the sea. After camping some of the sand dunes are destroyed. The only way from the camping to the “Simos” beach is through the sand dune area as the same area is used as vehicle parking. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 6:
381
Beach impact factor.
BEACH IMPACT FACTOR Municipalitie s
Beach length (km)
Vatica
4,5
Total beds
Inhabit ants
Hotel beds
Rooms to let (beds)
7.871
400
900
1300
745
50
900
950 + 700 of campin g seats
Elafonisos 7
Daily visitors
seasonal populati on
-
15.000
1600
4.500
Beach impact factor (people/km of beach) 3333 642
7.2 Waste management In Elafonisos and Vatica district, urban waste management (solid and liquid) is characterized by lack of an integrated management system, leading to inefficiencies and serious environmental threats. The situation in the area under study is depicted in Table 7 [15]. Hotels are obliged to install urban waste treatment plants in order to protect the environment from sewage leakage, especially to the sea. Other the municipalities in Greece have started building and operating such installations. Table 7:
Vatica
Waste management.
URBAN WASTE AND GARBAGE MANAGEMENT Inhabitants Urban waste Percentage Garbage treatment plant of waste management treated 7.871 No 0% Land fill*
Elafonisos
745
No
0%
Land fill*
*The land fills do not follow any of the E.U. specifications and are considered a serious environmental threat.
7.3 Water pollution No serious problems of water quality are encountered in Elafonisos and Vatica. Sea water and drinking water quality is considered good with no signs of quality deterioration. Table 8:
Blue flags [16].
BLUE FLAGS IN NEAPOLY AND ELAFONISOS
Vatica Elafonisos
1 -
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
382 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Vatica has two beaches with Blue Flag certification, indicating that serious attempts have been made to protect the environment and possibly increase competitiveness in offered tourist services. Elafonisos, on the other hand, does not have any beaches with Blue Flag certification, a result that agrees well, with other indicators, presented earlier, showing a relatively not organized tourist development. 7.4 Air pollution Neapoli and Elafonisos do not face serious atmospheric pollution since tourism is not of massive scale with relatively small vehicular traffic. 7.5 Noise pollution Noise levels usually increase during the high season months, generated by an increase in the concentration of tourists, vehicles and tourist attractions. 7.6 Visual pollution Recently serious efforts have been made in order to integrate local architectural character in new buildings and tourist infrastructure, in an effort to avoid serious mistakes of the past where speed, low cost and fast returns on investments, were the main criteria governing the building industry. One of the highlights is that due care has been paid to the design. Table 9:
Passenger arrivals and departures at Elafonisos port [17]. PASSENGER ARRIVALS AND DEPARTURES IN ELAFONISOS PORT
Months/ Passengers June July August September
Table 10:
2002 17.268 38.776 67.322 12.567
2003 40.679 41.442 44.505 13.664
2004 15.661 41.888 80.287 15.533
2005 20.674 35.497 75.467 20.072
2006 28.257 51.681 84.233 22.298
Vehicle arrivals and departures in Elafonisos port.
VEHICLE ARRIVALS AND DEPARTURES IN ELAFONISOS PORT Months/Vehicles June July August September
2002 6.185 12.348 21.692 4.569
2003 13.695 14.390 16.638 5.130
2004 6.555 17.161 31.698 6.384
2005 5.345 12.576 28.408 6.739
2006 8.481 20.305 29.243 6.254
7.7 Overcrowding and congestion Overcrowding by tourists, especially at popular tourist attractions as Elafonisos can have serious impacts on the environment. About 5000 tourists and 2000 cars WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
383
visit the island daily. Taking into account that Elafonisos has no parking management, it is no surprise to witness, at high season, traffic jams, noise and increased air pollution.
8
Conclusions
Tourist development depends on the quality of the environment and the special characteristics that may attract visitors to the area. It has been proven, beyond any doubt, that in the long term uncontrolled development has serious impacts on the natural and build environment. Environmental indictors, indicate that the transformation from a low quality, high-number (mass) tourist trade, to an alternative trade of high quality, is not easy especially when basic infrastructure units, such as waste management systems, town planning policies and building practices, government incentives etc. are lacking. It is a well known that such inadequacies have serious environmental consequences, and hinder any attempts towards developing a high quality tourist industry [18]. The increasing public interest in nature and landscape preservation is, today, considered to a major positive factor in the tourist development process. It is also well known, however, that the growing influx of visitors can exert strong pressures on fragile ecosystems [19]. Many proposals have been put forward to alleviate these side effects, and the concept of protected areas, such as national parks and reserves, are now an integral part of nature based tourism [20].
9
Proposals •
Planning is conceptually related to sustainable development [21]. It includes approaches to deal with development and economic options, to prevent environmental damage and to involve public and stakeholders in decision-making processes. It is proposed that serious efforts have to be made in the direction of formulating viable policies and developing tools for effective implementation and control.
•
Due to the increased tourist demand it is suggested that all the areas with environmental interest must be governed by special organizational bodies [22] that, take account of the long term welfare of the local community and the environment. It is unfortunate that Greece lacks the framework and the experience in managing ecologically sensitive areas, even though the NATURA 2000 network has been active for several years. It is noteworthy that Greece has been accused and in some cases prosecuted at the European Court for not developing the governing bodies described in relevant EU directives.
•
Free camping, which still takes place in areas with sand dunes in municipality of Vatica, causes serious impacts in the local flora and fauna. The development of high standard and quality organised
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
384 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI camping areas in conjunction to the prohibition of the free camping could eliminate the impacts facing the sensitive sand dune ecosystem. •
Serious attempts must be made in order to protect the local fauna and flora especially when changes to the land use in Elafonisos and Vatica districts, are made.
•
This study shows that the tourist industry in the Vatica district is far from organized and controlled. Serious attempts have to be made to ensure the development of a high quality tourist trade, based on alternative tourist products and services, mitigating the environmental consequences, highlighted above.
Acknowledgements We would like to thank for their help and collaboration: Giannis Kousoulis, Mayor of Vion (Vatica), Vasils Stathakis, Vice mayor of Vion (Vatica), Haralambos Liaros President of the community (small municipality) of Elafonisos island, Sub Lieutenant Antonis Doumanis, Neapoly Port Authority, Dimitra Tselou, economist, Citibank Plc.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
Kamamba DMK, The challenges of sustainable cultural heritage/ community tourism. Second African peace through tourism, conference, Dar El Salaam 7-12 December 2003 Lickorosh L. – Jenkins C., “An introduction to tourism” Butterwoth – Heinemann 1997 Map of Laconia, Nakas digital publications Greek National Statistics Organisation 2006 Greek National Statistics Organisation 2006 Tourist guide of Greece, 2000 ISSN 1107-9010 (in Greek) Prefecture of Lakonia, 2007 Polyodigos publications (in Greek) Municipality of Vies and Community of Elafonisos 2006 communications with questionnaires Mentis C., Elafonisos, Lafonisiotiki vivliothiki 1993 (in Greek) Municipality of Vies, general Plan, Horodinamiki, Athens 2004 Prefecture of Laconia, Domi publications (in Greek) Oikonomidou E., The Greek Coasts, Hellenic Ornithological Society 1993 RSPB Bousbouras D. 2005. Research for nature environment of Municipality Vion, including NATURA 2000 area of Malea Peninsula, Strogyli wetland and island Elafonissos. 94 pp. Municipality Vion. (in Greek). Karandinos Μ. (ed.) 1992. «The Red Data Book of Threatened Vertebrates of Greece» Hellenic Zoological Society - Hellenic Ornithological Society, 356pp. (in Greek) WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[15] [16] [17] [18]
[19] [20]
[21]
[22]
385
www.vatica.gr – “Vatika” newspaper, April 2007 http://www.blueflag.org/ 11-5-07 Neapoly Port Authority May 2007 Prokopiou DG, Tselentis BS, Bousbouras D. and Toanoglou M “Carrying capacity assessment in tourism: The case of Dodecanese archipelago” The Ravage of the planet, First International Conference on the Management of Natural Resources, Sustainable Development and Ecological Hazards, Bariloche, Argentina 2006, Wessex Institute of Technology UKUniversity of Siena, Italy 12–14 December 2006 Bariloche, Argentina Papayanis T, ‘Tourism carrying capacity in areas of ecological importance’ M. Stone & D. Smith “ An outline of Parks Victoria’s tourism Partnerships Strategy and Challenges of Sustainable park tourism in Australia” International Conference on Sustainable Tourism Bologna 2006 Wessex Institute of Technology T. Fidelis, “Integrating environmental issues into the Portuguese planning system- 10 years of emerging challenges and persistent problems” Conference on sustainable planning and development Bologna 2005, Wessex Institute of Technology Prokopiou DG and Tselentis BS ‘Proposals for sustainable development and Environmental protection for the island of Rhodes’, Rhodes 2003 (in Greek)
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
387
Correlation between the moisture and quantity of biomass as a basis of sustainability of ecosystems (the example of plain deserts of Turkmenistan) V. Kostiukovsky Albert Katz Department of Dryland Biotechnologies, Jacob Blaustein Institutes for Desert Research, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel
Abstract The life activity and sustainability of ecosystems is determined by the correlation of all of their components, organic and non-organic. The correlation between moisture income and organic components in the authomorphic ecosystems of extra-arid plain deserts of Turkmenistan is examined. The area of 332 790 sq. km of authomorphic ecosystems of Turkmenistan receives an average annual precipitation of 36 740 billion metric tons. Nearly 8000–9000 bill. m.t. of this quantity is involved in ecological processes and guarantees the life, sustainability and activity of 242,42 bill. m.t. of plant biomass (phytomass) and 4,82 bill. m.t. of animal biomass (zoomass). Consequently the proportion of these three components, water, phytomass and zoomass, is 1171:50:1. This proportion supports the existence of desert ecosystems in Turkmenistan under the significant seasonal, annual and multi-century climatic fluctuations, and may be used for planning, monitoring and rational use of natural resources Keywords: Turkmenistan plain deserts, authomorphic ecosystems, correlation, moisture, biomass, phytomass, zoomass, sustainability.
1
Introduction
Sustainability of ecosystems is determined by correlation of all of their components, organic and non-organic. Any change in any particular aspect initiates a chain of changes in all of the other ones. An example is the seasonal WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070361
388 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI and annual fluctuations of climate bringing periodical fluctuations in the dynamics of non-organic and organic elements of ecosystems, both in quantity and in quality. At the same time, sharp and sudden breaches of the existing equilibrium may lead to catastrophic consequences, possibly up to full destruction of all ecosystems. Consequently, the observation of this correlation between the various elements, components of entire ecosystems, is necessary for monitoring them and optimization of their life activity. Connections and interactions between the elements composing these ecosystems are mostly evident under extreme conditions, where one or several of those factors that ensure the continued stability of ecosystems is limited. A noticeable example of deficiency of one of these factors - moisture - is the ecosystems of arid regions. Thus, the plain deserts of Turkmenistan may be used as a model for investigation of the dependence between the dynamics of organic elements of ecosystems on the moisture, particularly of the correlation between the quantity of precipitation, biomass of plants (phytomass) and biomass of animals (zoomass). 1.1 Region of investigation The plains of Turkmenistan are situated in the central region of the Eurasian continent, at the northern part of a desert zone. More than 90% of this country consists of arid and extra-arid deserts. The average annual air temperatures here range from 12 to 18 °C (the winter minimum below - 25 °C, the summer maximum over 45 °C). The annual precipitation income ranges from 70 to 200 mm. There are a large number of sunny days (300-350 days per year), with direct solar radiation of 4000-4600 mj /sq. m. Frequent strong winds (average 3,2-4,2 m/sec, maximum more than 25 m/sec) provide high evaporation capacity of 1650-2300 mm/year [1]. Consequently, the coefficient of aridity is near 0,07 and the plains of Turkmenistan may be considered as extra-arid. The strenuous water regime manifests in significant fluctuations in the quantity of phythomass and zoomass, which allows calculation of the correlations between these three elements of ecosystems.
2
Sources of information and results
The boundary of plain deserts of Turkmenistan have been defined as the shore of Caspian sea - at the West, and the national border - at the North and East (partly coinciding with the waterway of the Amudarya river). The mountainous part of Turkmenistan defines the desert to the south, the boundary of plain deserts being the horizontal line of 300 m. above sea level, which mainly coincides with the isohiett (pluvial line) of 200 mm. of precipitation per year. The area of authomorphic ecosystems of Turkmenistan plain deserts (excepting the anthropogenic territories and hydromorphic ecosystems of salt-marshes and river valleys and deltas) has been defined as 332 790 sq. km.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
389
Circulation of moisture in ecosystems is connected closely with the geological composition of the soil. Consequently, the territory of plain deserts has been divided by this principle as sandy, stony-rubble and loamy deserts. The area of every type of desert has been defined by the analysis of the topography, geology, soil and landscape maps in scale from 1:100 000 to 1:1 000 000 and materials of space information. The results obtained have been brought to concord with the data of "Soil Cadasters of Turkmenian SSR" for the years 1960-1985. All of these types of deserts are distributed disproportionally in the territory of the plains of Turkmenistan. They are concentrated as compact areas, due to the relief and geological composition of the territory, and the intensity of water and wind erosion, etc. The sandy deserts occupy the majority of the area 242 990 sq. km. The stony-rubble ones are concentrated mainly at the North and N-W and often combine with other types of deserts. Their total area is 44 270 sq. km. The area of loamy deserts is 45 530 sq. km. The main areas of loamy deserts are connected with the valleys and deltas of constant and seasonal water streams, foothills and near-mountain plains. Many loamy islands (“takyrs”) are diffused in the falls of aeolian relief of sandy deserts. Among the above-mentioned types of natural authomorphic ecosystems, there are also ecosystems of salty marshes and river-valleys in Turkmenistan plains. These ecosystems obtain supplementary water nutrition by surface and underground flow and cannot be inspected as authomorphic ones. 2.1 Moisture income The data of moisture dynamics in the authomorphic desert ecosystems are obtained from the literature and official materials such as: “Meteorological annuals of Turkmen. SSR for the years 1929-1990” and works of Orlovsky [1], Romanov [2], Kunin [3], Kirsta [4] and others and computed correspondingly to the areas of authomorphic ecosystems. The annual average amount of atmospheric precipitation, at the territory of Turkmenistan plains increases from 70-80 mm (N) to 150-180 mm (S); from 70 to 125 mm income over 46% of the territory, from125 mm. to150 mm. income over 17 % of the area and from 150 to 200 mm over 37% of all the area of desert plains. Therefore, the average sum of annual precipitation here has been accepted for the following calculations as 110.4 mm. Due to this data, 332 790 sq. km of authomorphic desert ecosystems obtain, as average, 36,74 cu. km of atmosphere precipitation, which is near 36 740 billion metric tons of moisture. The most of this moisture (more than 80%) falls during the cold season, when evaporation is weakened and, as a result, annual evaporation from the soil surface is relatively small - near 35% of annual income (data of Meteorology Service). It means that nearly 23 881 bill. m. t. of rain water has time to penetrate into the soil before the beginning of summer drought. Nearly 11% of this moisture (4041,4 bill. m. t.) supplements the deep underground flow. The remaining quantity of moisture (19 840 bill. m. t.) is distributed inside the soil profile and is drawn into life process of ecosystems, forming their organic components. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
390 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The calculation, made on the basis of Beideman [5] for different dry land ecosystems, allowed us to define that most of this moisture is spent by plants during their life activity, mainly for transpiration (nearly 11 000 bill. m. t.), and the remaining 8000-9000 bill. m. t. of water plays the main role in the forming of organic part of ecosystems. 2.2 Formation of quantity of phytomass Regular geobotany investigations have been performed in the deserts of Turkmenistan since the end of the 1920’s. The results defining the quantity of phytomass, its distribution over the area, and its seasonal and annual fluctuations have been presented in hydrometeorology reference books, soil cadastres and in numerous scientific investigations ([6–10] and others). These data have been supplemented by materials of our field investigations, generalized and computed by conformity of the results of measurements of the areas of desert ecosystems of Turkmenistan, obtained from map and remote sensing materials. According to the above-mentioned data, the average quantity of phytomass in authomorphic ecosystems of Turkmenistan plain deserts is defined as 242,42 bill. m. t. Over the period of a year, the quantity of phytomass changes from 218,31 bill. tons in the rainy spring to 76,87 bill tons- in dry summer, which correlates with the annual fluctuations of precipitation (from 46 mm-spring to 5 mm-summer). The common picture is complicated due to “physiological drought” in winter, as a result of low temperatures (from –5 °C in the northern regions to 5-10 °C at the southern ones, with the minimum below –25 °C). The multi-annual fluctuations of precipitation and quantity of phytomass obviously correlate. The amount of precipitation in dry years (67 mm) is to 2,6 times less than in wet years (173 mm). It is reflected in the fluctuations of phythomass quantity by 2,8 times - from 119,14 bill. m. t. during dry year to 365,7 bill. m. t. during wet ones. These calculations allow us to conclude that the average quantity of productive moisture income of 8 000 - 9 000 bill. m. t. provides the formation and conservation of 242, 42 bill. m. t. of life phytomass, i.e. that 1 ton of organic material demands for its existence, as average, nearly 35 tons of water. A significant quantity of moisture is used by plants for the creation of annual growth. It composes 55,88 bill. m. t. during the year of average income of precipitation (110,4 mm), which is 23% of the regular quantity of life biomass. The quantity of dead phythomass in authomorphic ecosystems is 82,96 bill. m. t. (34,22% of the phytomass). The dead phytomass is created by the dying off of ephemerous plants and on-ground parts of ephemeroids at the beginning of the summer drought and the fall of dry leaves and shoots and dying parts of roots of trees and shrubs during the dry summer, cold autumn and winter. Part of this dead phytomass is removed during the year, part is carried off by wind and rainwater out of ecosystem, but part is conserved in the ecosystem for many years, which is the reason of why the quantity of dead phytomass is higher than the annual growth.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
391
2.3 Formation of quantity of zoomass Both the live and dead phytomass are involved into the circulation of organic material in ecosystem as compost. It is the source of the formation and existence of animal life, from the simplest single-cell organisms to higher mammals. The quantity of phythomass, its consumption by animals and also the quantity of zoomass in the authomorphic desert ecosystems at the plains of Turkmenistan has been calculated on the basis of data of [6, 11–14] and others. The calculations have demonstrated that consumption of phytomass by animals in authomorphic ecosystems in Turkmenistan plain deserts is almost 33 bill. m.t. tons during a year of average moisture. It is 10,14% of all the quantity of live and dead phytomass (325,38 bill. tons) or 59% of annual growth. This quantity provides the existence of 4,82 bill. m. t. of animal biomass, i.e. for the formation and activity of the 1 m. t. of zoomass, 6,9 m. t. of phytomass is demanded. The annual quantity of zoomass is exposed to seasonal and multiyear fluctuations reflecting the fluctuations of quantity of phytomass and precipitation. In dry years it is 2,39 bill. m. t. and in wet years - 7,26 bill. m. t. The quantity of zoomass in wet years is three times the quantity of dry years, similar to the quantity of precipitation and phytomass in wet and dry years. It is complementary evidence of direct correlation of these three values. The next process of circulation of materials in an ecosystem is formation of animal wastes. The average annual quantity of wastes is approximately 22,97 bill. m. t, including 6 bill. m. t. of solids, 1,47 bill. m. t. of liquids and 15,5 bill. m. t. of gaseous wastes. About 5 bill. m. t. of used organic material is concentrated in organisms of animals, which live more than 1 year and return to circulation with the dead zoomass. All wastes and remnants of dead organisms enter the air, soil and underground water and are used by plants for the formation of new phytomass. The cycle is complete. 2.4 Deductions The main active components of the authomorphic ecosystems of the plain deserts of Turkmenistan are connected in the following proportion: 8500 bill. m. t. of water — 242,4 bill. m.t. of phytomass — 4,8 bill. m. t. of zoomass, or, accepting the zoomass as a unit – 1171:50:1. This correlation, formed during the process of evolution, may be accepted as optimal for the conservation and stability of desert ecosystems. Fluctuations in the amount of precipitation by as much as 2,6-2,8 times lead to fluctuations in the quantity of phytomass in the same boundaries and to fluctuations in the quantity of zoomass of approximately 3 times. These fluctuations don’t result in irreversible damage of environment and degradation of ecosystems. The attribute of elasticity of ecosystems, their capability to maintain stability, is manifested also in the conditions of multi-century fluctuations of climate, noted in the works of Kostiukovsky [15], Lisitzina [16], Vinogradov and Mamedov [17] and others. These data testify that the ecosystems of the plain deserts of Turkmenistan have maintained their countenance and fullness during no less than the last 15,000 years (since the Holocene age), notwithstanding periodical alternations of the warm and cold, wet and dry periods [18–21]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
392 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
Conclusion
During the last 8000-9000 years, throughout the territory of Turkmenistan, special types of ecosystems – man-made ecosystems – were created. These ecosystems include the special character of hydrographical nets (canals, waterbodies, irrigate systems), relief (plane agricultural fields, buildings, dams, roads, etc.), special microclimate, cultural vegetation, and animal life. The area of man-made ecosystems throughout the plains of Turkmenistan has increased from 20 km - 9000 years ago (data of Kostiukovsky [15], Masson [22], Lollekova [23], Lisitzina [24]) up to 80 000 km (statistic data for 1995). Up to the end of the 19th century, the growth of man-made ecosystems cramped to a significant degree the natural hydromorphic ecosystems of river valleys, deltas and foothill plains, but almost hadn’t influenced the authomorphic desert ecosystems. The nomadic cattle-breeding tribes, widespread in their territory, tended to cramp the area occupied by wild large mammals (onagres, gazelles, saiga) excluding them from most pastures and water sources, but the role of these animals in the desert ecosystems passed to the herds of domestic cattle. During the 20th century the human pressure on the natural ecosystems became threatening in character. The consumption of water for irrigation and other agricultural and industrial aims has led, on the one hand, to the drying up of the Aral sea and hydromorphic ecosystems in the valleys and deltas of rivers and, on the other hand, to formation of salty marshes and polluted water-bodies of the waste water in place of authomorphic desert ecosystems. The creation of highways, pipelines, power-lines, passage of off-road vehicles have all resulted in the destruction of soil surface, intensification of wind and water erosion, reduction of plants and animals, pollution of air and soil. The same problems, in non-comparative large grade are typical for all types of settlements, their neighborhood and the environs of industrial and mine regions. The grazing of cattle increased in intensity, exceeding the limits of sustainability of ecosystems of desert pastures and, in some of cases, has led to the full degradation of the environment, leading to catastrophic desertification. Nearly 80% of the territory of Turkmenistan is now exposed to desertification. In such a manner, the problem of conservation of natural ecosystems and their sustainability, the regulation of human pressure, rational using of the nature is the problem of existence for human population. The monitoring of naturehuman interaction, planning of the human activity at the natural environment, nature conservation, creation of the reserves is the daily necessity. During the decision of all of these problems the discount of the keeping of proportional correlation of water regime and activity of biota as the base of sustainability of ecosystems is necessary.
References [1]
Orlovsky, N. S., Climate of Turkmenistan. Biogeography and Ecology of Turkmenistan. V. Fet and K.I. Atamuradov (eds.). Kluwer Academic Publishers: Dorderecht/ Boston/ London, pp.23-48, 1994 WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19]
393
Romanov N.N., About Short- Time Prediction of Early Frosts in Central Asia. Meteorology and Hydrology, pp.27-30, 1952. Kunin V.N., Water in the Deserts and Environment. Nauka: Moscow, 286 p., 1980. Kirsta B.T., The Disposition of Hydrology at the Western Regions of Central Asia. YlYm: Ashgabat, 295 p., 1976. Beideman I.N., Reference Book of the Expenditure of Water by Plants in the Natural Zones of USSR (geobothany and ecology characteristic). Nauka: Novosibirsk, 256 p., 1983 Productivity of the Vegetation of the Arid Zone of Asia (The Results of Soviet Investigations under International Biology Program, 1965-1974). Nauka: Leningrad, 232 p., 1977. Nikolaev V.N. The Natural Fodder Sources of Turkmenistan. Ylym: Ashgabat, 190 p., 1972. Netchaeva N. T., Antonova K.G. Biological Productivity of On-Ground mass of the Main Formations. Vegetation of Central Karakum and its Productivity. Ylym: Ashgabat, pp. 101- 109, 1970. Netchaeva N.T. Dynamics of pasture vegetation of Kara-Kum under the Influence of Meteorology Conditions. A.N.TSSR Publishers: Ashgabat, 214 p., 1958. Arnageldyev A., Kostiukovsky V.I. Ecosystems of Karakum. Ylym: Ashgabat, 311 p. 1988. Wildlife of USSR. Desert Zone. A.N. USSR: Moscow- Leningrad, vol. 2, 366 p., 1948. Nature Conservation in Turkmenistan. (4), Turkmenistan: Ashgabat, 178 p., 1978. Abaturov B. D. Mammals, as a Share of Ecosystems (Example of Herbivourous Mammals of the Hemi-Deserts). Nauka: Moscow, 286 p., 1984. Formozov A.N. The Main Peculiarities of Wildlife of the Plain Part of Central Asia. Central Asia. A.N. USSR Publishers: Moscow, pp.392-419, 1958. Kostiukovsky V. The History of Human Activity and Desertification in the Territory of Turkmenistan. Journal of Arid Land Studies Vol. 14,S, pp. 203- 206, 2004. Lisitzina G.N. The vegetation of Southern Turkmenistan at the VI- I Thousand Years B.C., by the Data of Coals. Karakum Antiquities, 3, Ylym: Ashgabat, pp.51- 56, 1968. Vinogradov A.V., Mamedov E. Landscape and Climatic Conditions in the Deserts of Central Asia in Holocene Period. The History of the Material Culture of Uzbekistan. II Fan: Tashkent, pp.32-44, 1974 Mamedov E. Fluctuations of the Climate of Central- Asian Deserts in Holocene. The Fluctuations of Moisture of Aral- Caspian Region in Holocene. Nauka: Moscow, pp.170- 174, 1980. Budyko M.I. Climate in the Past and Future. Hydrometeoizdat: Leningrad, 351 p. 1980. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
394 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [20] [21] [22] [23] [24]
Kind N.V. Paleo-Climate and Nature Environment at the Holocene. The History of Bio-Geocenoses of USSR in Holocene. Nauka: Moscow, pp. 514, 1976. Gribbin J., Lem G. The Fluctuations of Climate during the Historical Period. Climatic Fluctuations. Hydrometeoizdat: Leningrad, 102- 121, 1980. Masson V.M. First Civilizations. Nauka: Leningrad, 275 p., 1989. Lollekova O. The Local Variability in the Culture and House- Keeping of Jeitun Tribes. Ylym: Ashgabat, 178 p., 1988. Lisitzina G.N. Origin and Development of Irrigated Agriculture at the South of Turkmenistan. Nauka: Moscow, 239 p., 1978.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
395
Environmentalism and sustainable development from the point of view of tourism Z. Baros1 & L. Dávid2 1
Department of Regional and Rural Development, Károly Róbert College, Gyöngyös, Hungary 2 Department of Tourism and Regional Development, Károly Róbert College, Gyöngyös, Hungary
Abstract As a consequence of the rapid growth of the tourism sector, special emphasis is placed on destinations and tourism products connected to or based on certain physical and environmental factors. However, the negative environmental consequences of tourism are, in many cases, overemphasised to the social and/or economic elements of sustainable development. Thus, it is important to find an adequate balance of the elements mentioned above within tourism development in order to achieve an optimal way of fulfilling all requirements of sustainable development. In order to do this, a potential method is introduced by applying the Sustainability Value Map, developed originally for buildings and urban development projects, to the evaluation of sustainable tourism products. This method gives rise to further questions concerning the selection of the right set of indicators and the importance of local or regional issues. Using it as a tool, it may promote the process of holistic tourism planning and development. Keywords: environmentalism, sustainable tourism, environmental impacts, Sustainability Value Map.
1
Introduction – sustainability in tourism and its aspects
The term ‘sustainable development’, in the last decade of the 20th century, became widely used by governments, non-governmental organisations, the private sector and academia. Although, sustainable development is associated by many with issues like energy use, pollution and waste, they are now recognised as certain elements of sustainability, and the concept addresses three equally important issues: environment, economy and society [1]. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070371
396 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The concept has been applied in the tourism sector in various ways of which one gives the following definition of sustainable tourism: ‘meeting the needs of present tourists and hosts while protecting and enhancing opportunities for the future’. Thus, sustainability in the context of tourism means regulating the use of tourist resources so that they are not consumed, depleted or polluted in such a way as to be unavailable for the use by future generations of tourists [2]. This form of sustainable tourism, oriented toward the viability of tourism industry, is referred to as the ‘economic sustainability of tourism’ or ‘tourism imperative’ [1]. In order to achieve this, the primary aim of tourism development is satisfying the needs of tourists and other players in the industry. As the public has become aware of the extent of human impact on natural systems, environmental issues began to gain more ascendancy by the late 1960s and also with the rapid growth in tourism experienced in the second half of the 20th century, concerns grew about the physical environments of destinations used for tourism. The reliance of tourism upon the natural resources of the environment and the fact that its development induces changes which can be negative were realised. Accompanying the heightened awareness of environmental problems was also a realisation that the environment and development are inexorably linked. Development cannot take place upon a deteriorating environmental resource base neither can environment be protected when development excludes the costs of its destruction. In some cases, the environmental resources of tourism receive consideration, but are secondary to the growth of the tourism sector (‘product-led tourism’). A third concept called ‘environmentally led tourism’ can also be mentioned where types of tourism would be promoted that are reliant upon a high-quality environment [1]. Several forms of tourism were assumed to be ‘appropriate/responsible’ causing the least change to the tourist resource and the most likely to be sustainable, e.g. natural area tourism including a number of activities such as hiking, mountain-climbing, fishing, hunting, camping, etc. However, there is wide scepticism about the long-term sustainability of these.
2 Destination and the physical environment 2.1 The role of place The attractiveness of a given tourist destination implies the state of the physical environment, thus the variety of activities and the resultant cognition as shown in figure 1. Most tourism products and destinations are connected to certain physical and environmental factors therefore any changes in these may lead to a decrease in the popularity of and the demand for the given product as well as maintaining the quality of the product may be a special challenge for the tourism sector [3]. In some cases, such as the case for outdoor tourism activities based on the attractions of the physical environment, the basis for the product itself (the system of physical environment) can be degraded and destructed to an extremely high degree.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
397
The main factors of selection of destinations, modified after Dávid et al [4].
The most popular locations for (activity-based) tourism are usually the most susceptible (coastal and mountain areas) ones, too. Sustainability has become a focal point of interest especially in areas which, in the future, will become more susceptible or more popular destinations and as such, the increasing number of visitors (i.e. the higher level of crowdedness) will result in more serious of environmental impacts. The development of tourism requires physical resources to facilitate its expansion. Maintaining the quality of the environment, however, is usually also among the main goals of sustainable tourism as set up by various authors. Despite the confusion about what is meant to be an environmentally ‘responsible’ approach to tourism development, it is apparent that the protection of the natural resources upon which tourism is based is essential for the sustainable development of a location [5]. It is also important to realise that sustainable development is not concerned with the preservation of the physical environment but with its development based on sustainable principles of which environment is only one. 2.2 The relevance of environmental impacts of tourism With increasing numbers of people visiting a spatially diminishing and continually degraded natural world there is much scope for negative impact [6]. The negative environmental consequences of tourism include resource usage (land, water, etc.), human behaviour towards the destination environment and pollution (water, noise, air and aesthetic). The impacts of tourism and recreation on the physical environment (interaction of humans with their environment) are important because of the sheer significance of the physical environment for the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
398 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI recreation and tourism industry. In the absence of an attractive environment, there would be little tourism [7]. Tourism in natural areas impacts upon the natural environment in either positive or negative ways; it also has many social and economic consequences. Clearly, there are also social and economic impacts associated with recreational activity and tourism development [6]. It is often disregarded, however, that impact significance can depend on the type and source of impact (diversity, intensity and duration of the activities), environmental sensitivity (location), other cumulative pressures and the effectiveness of any management that is in place. Mountain environments are susceptible to disturbance due to steep slopes and thin soils and this is especially so in the high rainfall environments that span the tropics [8]. It is important to detect the effects of tourism on all aspects of an ecosystem as well as to distinguish between perceptions and actual impacts of tourism.
3
Finding a balance – visually
3.1 Finding a balance The goal of any kind of sustainable development project is finding an optimal way of fulfilling all requirements of the concept. The maximisation of one or two leads to an unbalanced way of development which might be sustainable regarding these parameters but not the rest. However, ecological aspects often gain priority within the concept. When the susceptibility of the physical environment represents an obstacle to the development of a viable tourism sector, sustainable tourism development cannot be the case. Environmental issues are continuous focal points of activity at resort and hotel developments, particularly when the development is situated entirely or partly in a natural setting. The impact of these either they are found at the edge of a natural area/national park or at areas of particularly hard risks tend to be more significant. A major study of resident perceptions on the impact of tourism on natural environments in Hawaii, North Wales and Turkey carried out by Liu et al. [9] showed the highest priority given to the protection of the environment for planning purposes. It was ranked higher than cultural benefits, social cots and even economic benefits. Thus, regarding environmental impacts, there is usually an obvious imbalance observed in many respects. First of all, negative impacts of tourism on the environment have been discussed in more details than positive. Also, social and economic aspects of tourism development projects are often disregarded to environmental ones [6]. Taken environment as whole, appreciation of the complexity of the environment as a system is often lacking. Local circumstances may support that certain environmental aspects gain higher priority of importance. Moreover, what is a well-recognised and significant impact in one region or type of environment may not be a problem elsewhere.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
399
For destination management to be sustainable it needs to address all the economic, social and environmental issues of that particular area. A number of methodologies have been put forward in an attempt to ensure that tourism activity is carried out in a sustainable way. Briefly, tourism development is sustainable only when none of the core components are neglected to others. Theories and management methods of sustainable tourism development and life-quality improvement must be applied to all types of tourism and destinations. In order to secure long-term sustainability, the accordance amongst these is indispensable. Monitoring survey and analysis of various indicators assumes the existence of a complex, long-term approach, of which primary aim is the establishment of sustainable welfare as shown in figure 2.
Figure 2:
The system of sustainable development, tourism indicators and life quality.
3.2 Adding visualisation 3.2.1. Applying the Sustainability Value Map In order to select an adequate method of integrated approach of planning, a useful tool would be the Sustainability Value Map (SVM), developed by Chris Butters, originally for buildings and urban development projects, although it can WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
400 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI also be applied to the evaluation of any other sustainable products. The SVM visualises the three core elements of sustainability and the degree of what any product fulfils its goal. A summary of the main features of SVM [10] is as follows. For each of the three main areas, eight parameters are defined, thus a product is benchmarked by 24 parameters in a complex way. The scale is set from 0 to 5 where 5 means what is seen as fully sustainable today. The values are scaled so that the outer rim, corresponding to a “horizon” of full sustainability, is clearly shown to be off. The selection of parameters is, though provisional, systematic. Considering that sustainability is a dynamic process, the model can be used in relation to time, to assess how the sustainability of the product develops from year to year. Also, by applying the same indicators, it can be a tool for comparing different projects. However, as pointed out earlier in this paper, impacts my vary locally, it is important to bear it in mind that the indicators used can and should vary to some extent depending on local conditions and on project scale. Also, as some of the components are rather complex, for a full assessment most will need a more detailed breakdown. Applying the Value Map for tourism development projects may be relevant from the point of view of key elements often associated with sustainable tourism, i.e. preservation of the current resource basis for future generations, maintaining the productivity of the resource basis, maintaining biodiversity and avoiding irreversible environmental changes. In its simplified form, it provides a checklist and framework for designers, and for discussion amongst participants in a planning process. In its detailed form, ideally, it gives a complete qualitative and quantitative picture of the condition of a project [10]. Visualisation is further promoted by having the mean value of indicators all three areas calculated, and also added to the original version of SVM. 3.2.2. Selecting the right set of indicators As pointed out by Newsome and Moore [9], the degree and extent of any negative impacts, however, will depend on where the development is located, building design and adaptation to existing natural conditions, waste treatment systems, recycling and pattern of resource consumption as well as approaches to the recreational activities that take place in association with the development. Due to both the great variety of tourism activities and that of the local endowments, questions may be raised on the relevance and general applicability of a given indicator. One might be used restricted only for certain local or regional issues. Furthermore, there is a necessity to distinguish qualitative and quantitative parameters; and finally two more questions are raised as (a) whether the selected indicator can be quantified, and (b) selecting the right set of indicators is possible at all [11]. For the latter one, an integrated approach of planning is required that takes the project scale and local endowments and the variables created on the basis of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
401
these into consideration. In a full assessment most variables also need a more detailed breakdown. 3.3.3. Examples As a first step, the SVM is used to evaluate the environmental aspects of tourism development. Taken as an example, environmental impacts of a fictitious hotel development are discussed hereby and the SVM is applied in figure 3. The average conditions of the receiving environment are well-indicated in the figure and can be marked as ‘average’ (with a sustainability value of 3.125). It can also be seen, however, that waste management, being a major issue elsewhere too, is the main problem source. Due to the large amount of volumes proceeded (average tourists tend to produce more waste than local people), the low application level of recycling, waste prevention strategies and the nature of the receiving environment here, it is an unsolved problem. Thus, the value given is well below that of other indicators as shown in table 1. On the other hand, demands for further development in fields such as noise prevention or soil prevention can now be held back as probably adequate measures have already been to taken to fulfil these goals.
Figure 3:
Environmental impacts of infrastructure and support facilities in the development of tourism.
For the evaluation, the most determinant environmental factors applied are indicated in table 1. As a next step, the relationship of the three core elements is shown in figure 4. Here, a development project is visualised where environment seems to be managed in a more or less sustainable way thus is in a generally good conditions indicated by its average sustainability value of 4. Key issues of discussing sustainable development projects are about this average. Renewable energy sources (RES) seem to be one of the keystones of discussion. A survey carried out among tourist operators in Queensland, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
402 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Australia [12] indicated positive interest in installing RES for their operation, and this is of fundamental importance to the viability of future strategies for increasing RES uptake. It is especially large hotels that tend to be affirmative on this issue may be due to their perceived market pressure to be ‘Green’. Also, according to Edgar’s [13] observation, they are more likely to consider marketing of environmental initiative as an important component for overall business strategy. However, opinions on the marketing value of RES within the tourism industry are rather mixed. Table 1:
Environmental impacts of infrastructure and support facilities in the development of tourism, derived from Newsome and Moore [6].
Activity Land clearing Noise Light pollution at night Removal of vegetation
Soil erosion Energy supply Water supply Waste disposal Transportation infrastructure Roads
Possible impact
Sust. value
Disturbance to wildlife Disturbance to wildlife Loss of habitats Shift in species composition of area Smaller population of plants and animals Weed invasion Increased fragmentation of habitats Soil loss Stream sedimentation and reduced water quality Noise from generators Pollution from fumes and oil/reduced air quality Disturbance corridors Disturbance corridors Ground water abstraction/reduced water tables Construction of dams/disrupted stream flow Need for solid landfill or removal of waste off-site Liquid treatment facilities/odour, litter
4 4 3
Nutrient, fertiliser, pesticide and oil run-off Road corridor impacts and noise from vehicles Barriers to animal movement
3
4 3 3 1
In cases, when the goals of sustainability are neither accomplishable from the point of view of the society nor reasonable from the point of view of the economy, these issues must receive more attention. At this stage, this development does not meet the demand of the local population at all. Without public involvement and the support of the local economy by fundamental financing for infrastructure among others, the outcome of this project is rather doubtful. From the point of view of tourists, it can be considered to be on a somewhat average level. In the one hand, certain aspects (accessibility) indicate a higher level of development whereas on the other, most of the components (aesthetics, security, variety) are just average.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 4:
4
403
An example of the Sustainability Value Map applied for tourism development projects.
Conclusions
The topic of sustainable tourism is still an evolutionary paradigm that is seen as a goal to be achieved for small-scale development in the supply environment and research enhancement on the niche characteristics in the demand and supply sides of the tourism system. A sustainable planning approach includes the integration of economic, environmental and socio-cultural values (i.e. holistic planning), also having it integrated to other planning processes as well as preservation of essential ecological processes. With its complexity, Sustainable Value Map provides a possibility to the advancement of sustainable tourism development. However, in order to achieve this, it has to undergo further research with several case studies of all branches of the tourism sector.
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge Chris Butters for permitting the use of the Sustainability Value Map for this research purpose. For further details, please contact
[email protected] or the authors. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
404 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13]
Holden, A., Environment and Tourism, Routledge Introduction to Environment Series, Routledge: London and New York, 225p, 2000. Burton, R., Travel Geography, Longman, 514p, 1995. Rátz, T., The role of climatic and weather factors in influencing travel behaviour (in Hungarian), Turizmus Bulletin, 10, special edition, pp. 4253, 2006. Dávid, L., Baros, Z. & Szilágyi, Zs., Dimensions and environmental problems of sport tourism (in Hungarian), Tájökológiai Lapok, 4(2), pp. 395-405, 2006. Hall, C. M. & Lew, A. A., (eds.), Sustainable Tourism: A Geographical Perspective, Addison Wesley Longman: Essex, pp!!! 1998. Newsome, D. & Moore, S. A., Natural Area Tourism, Aspects of Tourism 4., Channel View Publications: Clevedon, England, 340p, 2002. Mathieson, A. & Wall, G., Tourism: Economic, Physical and Social Impacts, Longman: London, pp!!! 1982. Ahmad, A., Environmental impact assessment in the Himalayas: An ecosystem approach, Ambio, 22(1), pp. 4-9, 1993. Liu, J.C., Sheldon, P. J. & Var, T., Resident perception of the environmental impacts of tourism, Annals of Tourism Research 14(1), pp. 17-37, 1987. Urban Ecology: Projects in Europe – visions for Oslo?; Oslo kommune Havnevesenet. http://www.arkitektur.no/files/file46226_urban_ecology. pdf Puczkó, L. & Rátz, T., Impacts of Tourism (An Introduction), Häme Polytechnic: Finland, 408p, 2002. Dalton, G. J., Lockington, D. A. & Baldock, T. E., A survey of tourist operator attitudes to renewable energy supply in Queensland, Australia, Renewable Energy, 32, pp. 567-586, 2007. Yielding, E. D., Giants versus minnows, is there a difference? Progress in Tourism and Hospitality Research. 4(3), 255–265, 1999.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Section 11 Soil and agricultural issues
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
407
Application of the SWAP model for sustainable agriculture in an arid region B. Mostafazadeh-Fard1, H. Mansouri1, S. F. Mousavi1 & M. Feizi2 1
Irrigation Department, College of Agriculture, Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran 2 Isfahan Agricultural and Natural Resources Research Center, Isfahan, Iran
Abstract Iran is located in an arid and semi-arid region of the world with average annual precipitation of about 250 mm. Due to lack of suitable water resources, many farmers are using saline river or groundwater for irrigation which causes gradual accumulation of salts in the soil. Salinity of soil and water resources is one of the major environmental factors limiting the productivity of agricultural lands and reduces land area under cultivation. For sustainable agricultural productions, appropriate irrigation management practices should be applied if the saline irrigation water is to be used for irrigation. The SWAP (soil-water-atmosphereplant) model is a physical-based model that can be used to simulate crop yield and soil salinity, among others. To collect field data to apply to this model as input and calibrate it, a field experiment planted with wheat was conducted on a silty clay loam soil, in the central part of Iran (the Rudasht region near Isfahan with an annual average precipitation of about 80 mm), with three irrigation water salinity levels of 2, 8 and 12 dS/m with/without leaching levels of 4, 19 and 32 percent with two different irrigation water managements, using factorial design with four replications. The results showed that the model is applicable in this arid region and has low sensitivity to input data of root distribution depth and irrigation water salinity and medium sensitivity to climate data, soil surface layer hydraulic characteristics, leaf area index and amount of irrigation. The model simulated wheat yield and the calibration coefficients were obtained. The results showed that the model could be used as an effective tool for sustainable agricultural production. Keywords: SWAP model, wheat, yield, Iran.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070381
408 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
During the last 3-4 decades, as the demand for agricultural productions increased the irrigated lands also increased by about 300%. This has imposed a further increase in soil salinization and a relative decrease in crop yield [8]. Soil salinity is a major environmental factor limiting the productivity of agricultural lands. This problem is not only reducing the agricultural productivity, but is also putting far reaching impacts on the livelihood strategies of small farmers [11]. Use of saline water for irrigation is a subject of increasing interest because of the increasing water requirements for irrigation and the competition between urban, industrial and agricultural sectors and moreover because of the pressure for the disposal of drainage water through reuse [7]. It is estimated that up to 20% of irrigated lands in the world are affected somehow by different levels of salinity and sodium content. In Iran about 15% of lands, that is about 25 million ha, are suffering from this problem, including 320000 ha in Isfahan province [4]. Wheat is the most important and widely adapted cereal in Iran. Although Iran has recently been self-sufficient in its annual domestic demand for wheat, but salinity of soil and water resources, especially in arid and semi-arid regions of central parts of Iran, has effectively decreased wheat productivity. Overcoming of soil salinity and sodium content problems can be achieved by managing water resources, growing salt-tolerant plants, using leaching with appropriate drainage system and applying suitable models for irrigation and drainage management. Knowledge of water flow and solute transport processes in the soil zone is essential to derive proper management conditions for plant growth and environmental protection in agricultural systems. Numerical models are widely used as helpful tools to gain insight in the processes occurring in these complex systems and to analyse optional management scenarios. One of these numerical models is SWAP (Soil-Water-Atmosphere-Plant). This model is a hydrological model which simulates transport of water, solutes and heat in variably saturated top soils in field scale [1, 12]. The model is the modified form of SWATR, SWATRE, and SWACROP models. Several researchers [2, 3, 13] have worked with this model to verify it or use it for different field conditions. For instance in India, SWAP was applied to formulate guidelines for irrigation planning in cotton–wheat crop rotation using saline ground water in alternation with canal water for sustainable crop production. The results showed that it was possible to use the saline water up to 14 dS/m alternatively with canal water for cotton– wheat rotation in both sandy loam and loamy sand soils [9]. In another research using SWAP model on an approach to explore water management options in irrigated agriculture considering the constraints of water availability and the heterogeneity of irrigation system properties the results showed that under limited water condition, regional wheat yield could improve further if water and crop management practices are considered simultaneously and not independently [5]. In Netherlands, field data were collected to evaluate the SWAP model for nitrogen leaching [13].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
409
Considering the fact that simulation models can be used as an effective tool for management of agricultural lands the objective of this study is to calibrate the SWAP model and determine its compatibility to simulate wheat yield for an arid region in central part of Iran.
2
Materials and methods
The Rudasht region (32.29/N, 52.10/E and elevation of about 1560 m above mean sea level) is located in southeast of Isfahan city, central part of Iran, with about 50000 ha of salt affected soils. In this area, because of high evapotranspiration demand, low annual rainfall of about 80 mm, shallow groundwater table of about 3 m, limitation of good quality river water and use of saline underground and drainage water for irrigation, the soils are losing their productivity continuously. To achieve the objectives of this study, a typical salt affected soil of Rudasht region (silty clay loam texture) was chosen to plant wheat. Physical and chemical properties of soil were determined as shown in Tables 1 and 2, respectively. The chemical characteristics of irrigation water are shown in Table 3. Forty field experimental plots, each 5×25 m, were used to collect data. The winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivar M-73-18 was planted in each plot. About 1.25 kg of N.P.K fertilizer was applied with irrigation water to each plot. Table 1:
Physical characteristics of soil.
Depth (cm)
Clay (%)
Silt (%)
Sand (%)
Texture
FC (%)
WP (%)
0- 30 30- 40 40- 65 65- 75 75- 90
14 46 56 56 64
54 44 40 40 30
32 10 4 4 6
Silty loam Silty clay Silty clay Silty clay Clay
28 27 31 32 30
17 17 18 19 16
Table 2: Depth (cm) 0- 30 30- 60 60- 90
Table 3: Treat. Q1 Q2 Q3
EC (dS/m) 6.8 6.2 6.5
HCO3 3.6 3.5 3.5
ρb
K (m/day)
(gr/cm3) 1.22 1.10 1.33 1.82 1.91
1.2 1.4 1.2 2.0 1.4
Chemical characteristics of soil. Cl 40.3 30.0 30.0
Ions (meq/lit) SO4 Ca+Mg 33.7 43.6 35.4 41.4 40.0 39.0
Na 35.0 28.5 36.5
pH
ESP
SAR
7.6 7.6 7.7
19.8 21.1 31.1
7.5 6.3 8.3
Average values of irrigation water quality for the irrigation season. Water source River Well Drainage
EC (dS/m) 1.7 9.0 12.5
HCO3 3.2 4.9 4.6
Cl 11.6 68.1 104.3
Ions (meq/lit) SO4 Ca+Mg 7.1 6.6 31.8 32.6 26.2 35.0
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Na 11.2 66.9 101.0
SAR 6.2 16.6 24.1
410 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The treatments consisted of three irrigation water salinity levels of 2, 8 and 12 dS/m (Q1, Q2 and Q3) without leaching (LR0) and with leaching (LR1), including leaching levels of 4, 19 and 32 percent. Two different irrigation water managements were used. They include irrigating half of the plots with the above irrigation water salinity levels from the planting to the end of the growing season (GQ) and the other half with ECiw of 2 dS/m up to plant germination and thereafter applying the above irrigation water salinity levels (GU). The factorial design with completely randomized blocks with four replications was used. The amount of irrigation water was based on cumulative evaporation from Class A pan, using pan coefficient of 0.81. For all treatments, the irrigation intervals were based on about 82 mm evaporation from the pan. To account for rainfall, the precipitation data were taken from the weather station located nearby the experimental plots. Seven irrigations were applied during the growing season. For each plot, soil samples were collected at the beginning, middle and end of the growing season. Soil samples were taken at depths of 0-30, 30-60 and 60-90 cm and were analyzed to determine bulk density, moisture content at field capacity, moisture content at wilting point, saturated hydraulic conductivity, saturation paste extract EC (ECe), Ca2+ + Mg2+, CO32−, HCO3−, Cl− and Na+ using standard methods. The plant components were collected after harvest and were analyzed using standard methods. The leaf area index was calculated at five different crop growth stages during the growing season. The SWAP model [1, 12] which was developed by researchers at both the DLO Winand Staring Centre and Wageningen Agricultural University was used to simulate yield for the field conditions using the collected data. Schematic of the SWAP model in relation to volume balance parameters for soil, plant and environment is shown in Fig. 1. The model contains five sub-models of METEO, CROP, SOIL, IRRIGATION, and TIMER. Each sub-model receives the related input data and analyzes it and sends the results to the main program. In submodel SOIL, SWAP employs Richards' equation for soil water movement. Due to its physical bases, the Richards' equation allows the use of soil hydraulic function data bases and simulation of all kind of scenario analysis. The soil hydraulic functions are described by the analytical expressions or by tabular values. Root water extraction at various soil depths is calculated from potential transpiration, root length density and possible reductions due to wet, dry, or saline conditions. The input data such as soil surface layer hydraulic characteristics, maximum air temperature, leaf area index, root depth, irrigation water amount and irrigation water salinity were obtained and applied to the above five sub-models and the model was run. The sensitivity of the model to the input parameters was determined, the model was calibrated for the field conditions and the simulation results of yield for each treatment was compared with the field measurements and the statistical correlations were calculated. Further information about the model, input data and the functions that are used in the model are given at internet address of www.alterra.nl/models/swap.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
3
411
A schematized overview of the modelled system [12].
Results and discussion
3.1 Sensitivity analyses Before applying a model, it is necessary to study the sensitivity of the model to the input parameters. The results of sensitivity analysis show the importance of each individual input parameter. After collecting the input data for the model, the sensitivity of the model to yield prediction due to the input parameters was studied. Soil, crop, irrigation and meteorological data were applied to the model and the Lane method [6] was used and the sensitivity of the model to the input data was determined. First, the model was run using the collected field data during the year 2005-2006 and the model output results were determined and the results were used as base data. Then, the model was run for the same input data again but the value of one of the input data was changed and set equal to +50 and - 50 % of its original value. This process was repeated for all input values and the results were compared with the base data and the absolute differences were determined using the following equation [6]: D=
M −I × 100 I
(1)
where D is the absolute difference between the output value and the base value, I is the base value, and M is the output value. Then, based on Lane suggestions, the sensitivity of the model to each of the input data was determined as follows. For D = 0, model is not sensitive, for 0 < D < 10, the sensitivity of the model is low, for 10 < D < 50, the sensitivity of the model is medium, and for D > 50, the sensitivity of the model is high. The results of the sensitivity of the model to some of the input parameters are shown in Table 4. The results in Table 4 shows that the model has low sensitivity to the input data of root depth and irrigation WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
412 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI water salinity and medium sensitivity to climatic data of solar radiation and maximum air temperature, soil surface layer hydraulic characteristics, leaf area index and amount of irrigation water. In Table 4, Ea is actual evaporation, Ep is potential evaporation, Ta is actual transpiration, Tp is potential transpiration and Dp is deep percolation. Table 4:
Values of the sensitivity of the model to input data.
Output Parameter Input Parameter Soil surface layer hydraulic characteristics (-50%) Solar radiation (+50%) Maximum temperature (-50%) Leaf area index (-50%) Leaf area index (+50%) Root depth (-50%) Irrigation water amount (-50%) Irrigation water salinity (+50%)
Soil salinity
Yield
Ea
Ep
Ta
Tp
Dp
Average
33
22
0
25
0
33
69
23
38
10
34
19
66
32
55
36
29
1
35
35
12
7
82
29
19
1
30
29
58
32
56
27
10
2
17
14
32
20
24
14
5
52
15
0
6
0
0
9
28
129
100
0
31
0
0
35
2
48
7
0
3
0
0
7
3.2 Calibration Different methods can be used to calibrate the model, but the researchers [2] have suggested using the yield data to calibrate the model. In this study the model was calibrated based on wheat yield data. For calibration, the following steps were taken: 1- For different treatments, input data was given to the model and model was run and the simulation results of yield were obtained. 2- The simulation yield results were compared with the actual field yield results for each treatment. 3- If the model simulation results were not close to the actual field results the crop sensitivity coefficient for yield (Ky) was changed until the difference between the model simulation results and the actual field results become equal or less than 10 %. The results of the above study for the determination of crop sensitivity coefficients for yield for model calibration are shown in Table 5. 3.3 Statistical correlation After calibration of the model, the results of model simulation for yield and actual yield were used to determine the accuracy of the model. For this purpose, the statistical analysis was applied for yield and correlation coefficient, mean WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
413
square root, absolute mean error and mean error were determined using standard methods (Table 6). The results in Table 6 show that the model is applicable to the study area which is an arid region and the model can be used as an effective tool for sustainable agricultural production. Since the model is applicable to the study area, then the model was used to simulate yield. Table 5:
Crop sensitivity coefficients for model calibration.
Treatment Q1GQLR0 Q1GQLR1 Q2GQLR0 Q2GQLR1 Q2GULR0 Q2GULR1 Q3GQLR0 Q3GQLR1 Q3GULR0 Q3GULR1
Crop sensitivity coefficient (Ky) Beginning of season Mid season End of season 0.33 1.27 0.28 0.30 1.15 0.25 0.90 3.45 0.75 0.87 3.34 0.73 0.75 2.88 0.63 0.39 1.50 0.33 1.31 5.00 1.09 1.20 4.60 1.00 0.81 3.11 0.68 0.69 2.65 0.58
Table 6:
Results of statistical analysis.
Statistical indicator
R2
RMSE
MAE
ME
Indicator value
0.68
0.71
0.39
-0.19
100
Simulated yield (%)
80
y = 3.3911x 0.7099 R2 = 0.6856
60 40 20 1:1
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Actual yie ld (%)
Figure 2:
Comparison of the actual and simulated yield for different treatments.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
414 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 3.4 Yield simulation After calibration and determination of the accuracy of the model, then it was used to simulate yield for the study area. In Fig. 2 the comparison between the model prediction and actual yield data for different treatments and also the equation of model simulation for yield is shown. The percentage shown in Fig. 2 is the ratio of yield of individual treatment to the yield of treatment that has the maximum yield. The results in Fig. 2 show there is a reasonable agreement between the model prediction and actual yield data. The results of other researchers [2, 5, 10] for different crops and field conditions also show similar results.
4
Conclusions
For sustainable agricultural productions, appropriate irrigation management practices should be applied if the saline irrigation water is to be used for irrigation. The SWAP model can be used in such irrigated area to have better irrigation management for long term agricultural production. The model was calibrated for an arid region planted with wheat and irrigated with saline water and the accuracy of the model was determined. The simulation results of the model for yield showed that the SWAP model is applicable in arid region and could be used as an effective tool for better irrigation management.
Acknowledgements This research was supported by Isfahan University of Technology and Isfahan Agricultural and Natural Resources Research Centre which is appreciated.
References [1] [2]
[3]
[4]
Ashby, M., Dolman, A. J., Kabat, P., Moors, E. J. & Ogink-Hendriks, M. J. SWAPS version 1.0. Technical reference manual. Technical document 42, Winand Staring Centre, Wageningen, 1996. Brandyle, T., Szaty, L., Gnatow, S. & Tomasz, O. Examination of SWAP suitability to predict soil water conditions in a field peat-moorsh soil. Department of Water Resources, Wageningen Agricultural University. Report No. 69, 2005. Eitzinger, J., Trnka, M., Hösch, J., Žalud, Z. & Dubrovský, M. Comparison of CERES, WOFOST and SWAP models in simulating soil water content during growing season under different soil conditions. J. of Ecological Modelling 171, pp. 223-246, 2004. Feizi, M. Considering the effect of water quality and quantity on desalinization of Isfahan Rudasht Soils. Technical Research Report, Isfahan Agricultural and Natural Resources Research Center, Isfahan, Iran. 8(1), pp. 16-34, 1993
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13]
415
Ines, A.V. M., Honda, K., Das Gupta, A., Droogers, P. & Clemente, R. S. Combining remote sensing-simulation modelling and genetic algorithm optimization to explore water management options in irrigated agriculture. Agric. Water Manage. Available at: www.sciencedirect.com, 2006. Lane, J. W., & Ferrira, V. A. Sensitivity in CREAMS: A field scale model for chemical runoff and erosion from agricultural management systems. Ed. w. g. Knisel, A model documentation. VSDA Conservation Res. Report No. 26. pp. 113-158, 1990. Ould Ahmed, B. A., Yamamoto, T., Rasiah, V., Inoue, M. & Anyoji, H. The impact of saline water irrigation management options in a dune sand on available soil water and its salinity. Agric. Water Manage. 88, pp. 6372, 2007. Poustini, K. & Siosemardeh, A. Ion distribution in wheat cultivars in response to salinity stress. J. of Field Crops Research 85, pp. 125–133, 2004. Singh, R. Simulation on Direct and Cyclic Use of Saline Waters For Sustaining Cotton-Wheat in a Semi-arid Area of North-West India. Agric. Water Manage. 66, pp. 153-162, 2004. Singh, R., Van dam, J. C. & Feddes, R. A. Water productivity analysis of irrigated crops in Sirsa district, India. Agric. Water Manage. 82, pp. 253278, 2006. Tanwir, F., Saboor, A. & Nawaz, N. Soil salinity and the livelihood strategies of small farmers: A case study in Faisalabad district, Punjab, Pakistan. Int. J. Agric. Biol. 5(4), pp. 440-441, 2003. Van Dam, J. C., Huygen, J., Wesseling, J. G., Feddes, R. A., Kabat, P., Van Walsum, P. E. V., Groenendijk, P. & Van Diepen, C. A. Theory of SWAP version 2.0. Department of Water Resources, Wageningen Agricultural University. Report No. 71, 1997. Van der Salm, C., Van der Gon, H. D., Wieggers, R., Bleeker, A. & Van den Toorn, A. The effect of afforestation on water recharge and nitrogen leaching in the Netherlands. J. of Forest Ecology and Management 221, pp. 170-182, 2005.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
417
River water qualities and types of agricultural production –a comparison between paddy farming and intensive livestock production areas S.-I. Mishima Natural Resources Inventory Centre, National Institute for Agro-Environmental Sciences, Japan
Abstract The nitrogen (N) flows in the Omoigawa and Nakagawa river basins in Tochigi prefecture, central Japan, in 2000 have been estimated. Omoigawa was characterized as a paddy rice – upland field area and Nakagawa as an intensive livestock farming area. Residual N caused by agricultural production in Omoigawa was caused mainly by chemical fertilizer application and that in Nakagawa by livestock excreta. Residual N from agricultural production per farmland area was the same (c. 110 kg N ha–1), and occupation of farmland was also the same (c. 20%). Because Omoigawa is a smaller river basin than Nakagawa, total residual N in Omoigawa was 2,093 Mg and that in Nakagawa was 2,469 Mg. Nitrogen flow in river water was divided into sewage-derived N and non-point-source-derived N, mainly from agricultural production. Nonpoint-source N in Omoigawa was 2,467 Mg and that in Nakagawa was 1,426 Mg, in spite of the smaller residual N in Omoigawa. This difference might be caused by differences in sources of residual N in each basin, and chemicalfertilizer-derived N might be more easily leached to the water environment than livestock-excreta-derived N. This difference should be considered in vulnerability assessments of water environments. However, livestock excreta N will eventually leach out too, so intensive livestock farming cannot be said to have a lower effect on water environments and be more sustainable than chemical-fertilizer-dependent agriculture. Increasing sustainability and reducing impacts will help achieve complete N cycling in river basins with minimal N input from outside. Keywords: agriculture, nitrogen cycling, nitrogen surplus, river water. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070391
418 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Appropriate nutrient use is essential for sustainable agricultural production. However, excessive agricultural N use causes various environmental problems, such as acidification and eutriphication of water and terrestrial environments. The OECD set the soil surface balance as the method to evaluate substantial of nutrient use and N surplus (or deficiency) as an agro-environmental indicator of the impact or sustainability of agriculture [1]. Although it also set the N concentration in infiltrated water as a water quality indicator (calculated as N surplus divided by water surplus [precipitation – evapo-transpiration]) [1], the relationship between N concentration in infiltrated water and the real contamination or eutriphication of ground and surface water is unclear. Hatano [2] related the ratio of farmland in catchments to N concentration of river water in grassland farming area in Japan. Nishio [3] calculated N load indices for each kind of crop in Japan and found a correlation between the sum of N load indices divided by region area and ground water N concentration in one prefecture. These reports indicate that contemporary agriculture already affects water environments in Japan. However, the relationship between river water quality and agricultural production structure in a river basin has not been reported. In this study, the relationship between amount of river water N and N surplus in 2 mid-scale river basins with different agricultural structures, and thus different causes of N surplus have been examined. Table 1:
Total area (ha) Population Farmland Planted area Paddy field Upland field Orchard Forage field Dairy cattle Beef cattle Pigs Layers Broilers
Outline of the river basins.
Omoigawa 92,800 532,502 Area (ha) Ratio 19,030 16,048 100% 11,289 70% 4,122 26% 432 3% 205 1% Head Head ha-1 5,737 0.36 14,808 0.92 37,654 2.35 1,665 0.10 471 0.03
Nakagawa Japan 123,090 37,788,025 205,125 126,926,000 Area (ha) Ratio Ratio 23,273 21,475 100% 100% 12,478 58% 55% 3,768 18% 25% 128 1% 7% 5,101 24% 13% Head Head ha-1 Head ha-1 33,960 1.58 0.38 23,969 1.12 0.58 87,673 4.08 2.00 706,250 32.89 38.67 13,839 0.64 6.00
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
2
419
Sites and estimation of N flows
The Omoigawa River basin and the upper Nakagawa River basin, in Tochigi prefecture, central Japan have been studied. Statistical and estimated data of these basins are listed in Table 1 [4]. Occupation of farmland is c.20% in both basins, although the agricultural production structures are different. In Omoigawa, livestock density is near the Japanese average and occupation of paddy fields is higher than the Japanese average. The remaining farmland is vegetable fields and orchards. Therefore, Omoigawa could be defined as a paddy farming area. In contrast, the livestock density of Nakagawa is 2 to 4 times the Japanese average, and c. 20% of farms grows forage for dairy and beef cattle. Therefore, Nakagawa could be defined as an intensive livestock farming area. Models of N flow in the river basins are shown in Figure 1. Data were sourced and estimated according to Mishima et al. [5], except for sewage discharge, leaching, and river water N. Raw sewage discharge was set as 12.0 g N day–1 per capita and N removal by sewage treatment as 49% [6]. River water flows and their N concentrations came from a river water quality database [7] for Omoigawa and the River Water Yearbook [8] for Nakagawa. Products
Feed(1) (2)
Sewage(13)
Natural in and out(9)
(7) Feed(8)
Livestock Volatilization(4)
Chemical fertilizer(6)
Manure(3) Dispose(5)
Farmland Surplus(10)
Local land (11) Leaching(12) River(14)
Figure 1:
Model of N flow in the river basin.
3 Results and discussions 3.1 Nitrogen flows in river basins The results are indicated in Table 2. In Nakagawa, N in livestock product (80.4 kg N ha–1) was nearly 3 times that in Omoigawa (27.6 kg N ha–1). This emphasizes that Nakagawa is an intensive livestock production area, where production was sustained by 58.6 kg N ha–1 of feed produced in the basin and 275.0 kg N ha–1 imported from outside. Although livestock manure containing 55.0 kg N ha–1 was applied to farmland for crop production, more livestock
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
420 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 2:
Livestock Feed (1) Product (2) Manure (3) Volatilization (4) Disposal (5) Farmland Chemical fertilizer (6) Product (7) Feed (8) Natural in and out (9) Surplus (10) Local land(11) Leaching (12) = (14) – (13) Sewage (13) River (14)
Nitrogen flows in the model. Omoigawa Mg N kg N ha -1
Nakagawa Mg N kg N ha -1
2,180 526 503 738 532
6,400 1,870 1,281 2,395 1,683
1,817 922 88 99 1,561 2,093 2,467 1,190 3,657
114.6 27.6 26.4 38.8 28.0 0.0 95.5 48.4 4.6 5.2 82.0 110.0
1,686 975 1,364 156 785 2,469 1,426 458 1,884
275.0 80.4 55.0 102.9 72.3 0.0 72.4 41.9 58.6 6.7 33.7 106.1
excreta was disposed of to local land (72.3 kg N ha–1). How to use or treat all livestock excreta is a common problem in intensive livestock production areas in Japan. In Omoigawa, manure application to farmland contained 26.4 kg N ha–1 and feed production for livestock contained 4.6 kg N ha–1, so N exchange between livestock and farmland was not as active as in Nakagawa. This was a result of the smaller livestock production and low occupation of forage fields. On the other hand, chemical fertilizer application was larger in Omoigawa (95.5 kg N ha–1) than in Nakagawa (72.4 kg N ha–1). This difference resulted from the difference in planted crops. Although paddy fields are dominant in both basins, upland field crops differ. Omoigawa has more areas of vegetable fields, which receive more chemical fertilizer than in Nakagawa, and occupation of upland fields in Nakagawa is smaller than in Omoigawa. Natural N input and output are the same in both basins. Crop production for shipment outside the basin was 15% larger in Omoigawa (48.4 kg N ha–1) than in Nakagawa (41.9 kg N ha–1), although the difference is small and the values might be said to be the same, total productivity in each basin was different. Total N input by chemical fertilizer and manure was 121.9 kg N ha–1 and total crop production was 53.0 kg N ha–1 in Omoigawa, vs. 127.4 kg N ha–1 and 100.5 kg N h–1 in Nakagawa. Therefore, the N input in both basins was the same, but total crop production was c. 2 times as large in Nakagawa. This difference was caused by forage production, which has higher productivity per area than other crops. As the result of the higher production, the N surplus on farmland in Nakagawa (33.7 kg N h–1) was lower than that in Omoigawa (82.0 kg N ha–1). Livestock production was smaller in WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
421
Omoigawa than in Nakagawa, so disposal of livestock excreta (28.0 kg N ha–1) was c. 1/3 of that in Nakagawa, but disposal was larger than manure use. Residual N in agricultural production (i.e. disposal of livestock excreta plus surplus N on farmland) was 110.0 kg N ha–1 in Omoigawa and 106.1 kg N ha–1 in Nakagawa. This residual N is loaded onto local land. 3.2 Nitrogen flow in river water and N load to local land The amount of N flow in river water on average from 1989 to 1999 was estimated to be 2 times as large in Omoigawa (3657 Mg N year–1) than in Nakagawa (1884 Mg N year–1) because of the higher N concentration in Omoigawa water (2.5–5.1 mg N L–1; 964 Tg water year–1) than in Nakagawa water (1.28–1.83 mg N L–1; 1194 Tg water year–1). Sewage discharge to the river was estimated as 1190 Mg N year–1 in Omoigawa and 458 Mg N year–1 in Nakagawa. This difference came from the difference in population in the river basins. The remaining N in river water came from local land in the basin, mainly as residual N from agricultural production, because the natural ecosystem is basically N limiting, so N discharge (i.e. background level) is very low. Nitrogen leaching from local land was 2467 Mg N year–1 in Omoigawa and 1426 Mg N year–1 in Nakagawa. Residual N from agricultural production was 2093 Mg N in Omoigawa, less than the estimated N leaching from local land. This result might be caused by the high N removal rate by sewage treatment or leaching of past high N application before 2000. For example, N application for paddy rice in Tochigi prefecture has reduced over the past 2 decades by c. 30%. On the other hand, only 58% of residual N load to local land (i.e. (12)/(11)) leached to the river. The rest would accumulate in local land, at least for now. The N load to the river from agriculture is larger in Omoigawa than in Nakagawa. The difference might be caused by differences in the causes of residual N. In Omoigawa, N surplus on farmland (1561 Mg N) was c. 3 times the disposal of livestock excreta (532 Mg N), and was caused by a large application of chemical fertilizer (1817 Mg N), because the natural input/output of N plus manure application (602 Mg N) was 1/3 of chemical fertilizer. Therefore, the N load to local land in the Omoigawa River basin can characterized as chemical-fertilizer-derived N. On the other hand, the disposal of livestock excreta (1683 Mg N) was 2 times the N surplus on farmland (785 Mg N) in Nakagawa, and farmland received more than twice as much livestock manure (1281 Mg N; 55 kg N ha–1) than in Omoigawa (503 Mg; 26 kg N ha–1). Livestock manure (1281 Mg) was 3/4 of chemical fertilizer application (1686 Mg N), so the proportion of manure-derived N in surplus would be larger than in Omoigawa. Therefore, the N load to local land in the Nakagawa River basin can be characterized as livestock-excreta-derived N. This difference in sources of N load might cause differences in N leaching from local land to river, as chemical-fertilizer-derived N is relatively easier to leach out than livestock-excreta-derived-N. Although farmland soil can accumulate organic matter including N, the N eventually becomes mineralized and starts to leach out. Maeda et al. [9] found that N leach-out from soils treated with chemical fertilizer or swine manure became the same after 4 years when N application in swine manure was twice that in chemical fertilizer. This result WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
422 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI might suggest that leaching of manure-derived N will be less than that of fertilizer-derived N, but accumulated N will leach out later. Therefore, it will be too late to do anything when an increase in N concentration in river water becomes apparent. Figure 2 indicates the dynamics of the number of livestock in the Nakagawa River basin in the last 50 years. Although broilers have been decreasing, dairy and beef cattle numbers have doubled in the last 20 years, and pig numbers have doubled in the last 10 years. This increase in intensive livestock farming could presage a large increase in N leaching from manure applied to farmland or loaded onto local land. Daily cattle Beef cattle Pig Layer
Number of cattle and pig
80*103
250*103
200*103
60*103
150*103
40*103
100*103
20*103
50*103
0
1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 Year
Figure 2:
Number of layer
100*103
0
Growth of livestock numbers in Nakagawa.
3.3 N application: vulnerability and possible mitigation methods The risk of N leaching from livestock excreta might be lower than that of leaching from chemical fertilizer if Maeda et al.’s results [9] can be substantiated. However, broad scale and substantial N reuse will reduce environmental impacts, and help achieve sustainable agriculture. In Omoigawa, excessive chemical fertilizer is applied: for example, 56 kg N ha–1 is applied on strawberries, although guidelines recommend 20 kg N ha–1. Therefore, complying with fertilizer guidelines can reduce chemical fertilizer application. Manure used in Nakagawa comes from outside the basin. The use of local manure in forage production, expansion of forage area, and an increase in selfsufficient feed would mitigate leaching, and limiting livestock numbers would WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
423
contribute to healthy and sustainable N cycling within river basins. However, an appropriate level of manure N application remains an open question. However, fertilizer guidelines are aimed at achieving crop yields or maintaining high soil fertility, not at having a low environmental impact. To assess this we would need to use mathematical models of N mineralization and leaching, such as Roth N and Soil N, or develop site-specific models and set new standards for livestock excreta application.
4
Conclusion
Woli et al. [10] regressed N surplus and occupation of farmland area and found a significant relationship between the regression coefficient (which they called an “impact factor”) and river water N concentration. In this study, although Omoigawa and Nakagawa had the same farmland occupation and residual N, the N concentration in river water caused by non-point sources, mainly agricultural production was 1.7 times as large in Omoigawa as in Nakagawa. But delay of leaching between chemical fertilizer and livestock manure will have an effect on the evaluation and delineation of vulnerable areas, and large uncertainty in N dynamics remains. Which basin is more sustainable cannot be concluded, even though N flow in Nakagawa is lower than in Omoigawa, because a huge amount of livestock excreta is disposed of. Livestock excreta should be completely consumed on farmland within each basin and chemical fertilizer usage should be reduced to the minimum needed. Continuous monitoring of soil N content, N availability, and N concentration in groundwater will be needed. Such monitoring would support low-impact, sustainable agriculture and management of river basin agriculture. The ideal sustainable agricultural production system would isolate the N cycle within a river basin and minimize N input from outside. However, such agriculture might reduce yields, so it would be necessary to balance sustainability against productivity.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
OECD, Environmental Indicators for Agriculture, pp. 24–35, 1999. Hatano R., Evaluation of nitrogen cycling in river basin by measuring nitrogen outflow to river. Sequel to predicting environmental load, ed. R. Hatano & K. Inubushi, Hakuyusha, Tokyo, pp. 43–59, 2005. Nishio, M., Analysis of the actual state of nitrogen application in an arable farming in Japan. Japanese Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, 72(4), pp. 513–521, 2001. Kanto Nosei Kyoku, Tochigi prefecture Agricultural Census 2000 CDROM, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, Tokyo, 2001. Mishima, S., Taniguchi, S. & Komada, M., Adaptation of life cycle assessment (LCA) to agricultural production on a regional scale in Japan. Ecosystems and Sustainable Development V, ed. E. Tiezzi, C.A. Brebbia, S.E. Jorgensen & D.A. Gomar, WIT Press, Southampton, pp. 671–678, 2005. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
424 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
Kunimatsu, T. & Muraoka, H., Model Analysis of River Water Contamination, Gihodo Press, Tokyo, pp. 12–14, 1989. RPWQM, http://www-gis.nies.go.jp/intro/intro.html River Association Japan, River Water Quality Yearbook, p. 340, Tokyo, 2001. Maeda, M., Zhso, B., Ozaki, Y. & Yoneyama, T., Nitrate leaching in an Andisol treated with different types of fertilizers. Environmental Pollution, 121, pp. 477–487, 2003. Woli, K.P., Nagumo, T., Kuramochi, K. & Hatano, R., Evaluating river water quality through land use analysis and N budget approaches in livestock farming areas. Science of Total Environment, 329, pp. 61–74, 2004.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
425
Emerging environmental and educational service of dairy farming in Japan: dilemma or opportunity? Y. Ohe Department of Food and Resource Economics, Chiba University, Japan
Abstract Multifunctionality in agriculture indicates the performance of various functions of positive externalities. However, unless these externalities are internalized in farming activity, they will not be sustainable over the long term. In the livestock farming arena, a program was started in Japan in 2000 whereby dairy farmers would offer farm experiences mainly to youngsters. Although this service is considered to be a by-product of dairy farming with positive externalities, this subject has received minimal attention. Therefore, this paper sheds light on how dairy farmers cope with this new situation by empirically examining national survey data on this activity, presenting study cases, and conceptualizing problems and ways to find solutions. The main findings were as follows: 1) Dairy farms providing farming experiences play a positive role in teaching about farm life, how food is produced and the stress relief provided by the rural environment, especially for compulsory school-age children at elementary and junior high schools in local communities. To cope with the rising number of visitors, minimal necessary facilities such as toilets should be prepared. 2) Farming experiences have an educational effect not only on visitors, but also on the farmers themselves. This is because farmers can discover new possibilities for agriculture, which eventually leads to a deepening realization of new environmental and educational services that benefit society. 3) However, it is often difficult for farmers to harmonize the provision of the service of a farming experience to visitors with performance of their own farming activity. Farmers often face the dilemma of whether to offer farming experience services on a voluntary basis free of charge or to sell such services as a new farm product, such as traditional milk products, in exchange for money. Therefore, it is necessary to raise the social recognition of the educational function generated by those farmers who provide farming experience services. Keywords: multifunctionality in agriculture, externality, educational function, internalization, environmental and educational services of dairy farming, farm diversification, sustainable rural-urban relationship. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070401
426 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Multifunctionality in agriculture exerts externality that benefits society and includes various sub-functions (Brouwer [2], OECD [3, 4], Pezzini [8], Van Huylenbroeck and Whitby [11], Van Huylenbroeck and Durand [12], Tabuchi and Siomi [10], Ohe [7]). Among these functions, the educational sub-function of farming has been recognized as providing a significant educational experience (Shichinohe et al [9]). It is expected that the educational function in farming plays an increasingly important role in easing stress of people caught up in the modern urban lifestyle and in complementing educational capabilities of the household and local community in terms of education on food, the rural heritage and the rural environment. Thus, an educational function is considered as a new role of agriculture in society. However, little has been investigated empirically on this educational function. Ohe [6] investigated the educational function of dairy farms and found that this function was not connected with farm size. A preceding study on educational farms showed that launching an educational farm does not require major investments in the facility compared with rural tourism activities that require investment in lodging facilities. Because of this, an educational farm is relatively easy to begin for farmers (Oshima [5]). To our knowledge, the demand side has not been examined at all. On the other hand, economic analyses on education and the educational system have increased recently. However, these studies did not focus on the educational function as a joint product of farming or other economic activities, but on the educational system in general or student behaviour related to higher education from the human capital and/or signalling theories (Arai [1]). Essentially, there has been little investigation on how to position this function into farm activity from a farm policy perspective, especially in relation to rural and farm diversification taking into account multifunctionality. Concerning the educational function in farming, dairy farming is most advanced in making this function a reality. The program for educational dairy farms started in 2000 in Japan, which means that incorporating the educational function into farming practically began through providing the service of a dairy farming experience. However, since the significance of a farming experience service is not widely known in society, its position as a farm activity has not yet been well defined. The purpose of this paper is to examine some of the issues related to this new farming activity. First, this paper provides an overview of educational dairy farms, explains what they are doing and who demands this service in what way. Second, we illustrate within an economic framework how to properly position the educational function into farm activity from two case studies. Finally, we consider the policy measures that are necessary so that the educational function of farming can take root in society.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
427
2 What is an educational dairy farm? Educational dairy farms as designated are not only operated by individual dairy farmers, but also can be corporate farms, such as public or private ranches. As of 2003, 167 farms were designated as educational dairy farms, which is about 0.5% of the total dairy farms in this country. The number of designated farms is increasing annually. To qualify, the farmers themselves or their families or employees must take part in a seminar to obtain this designation. The Japan Dairy Council certifies those farms that completed the seminar after examination of the application form. Besides attending the seminar, farms must do the following: 1) provide visitors with toilets and hand-washing facilities, 2) prepare emergency medical kits, 3) be located near medical institutions and make such institutions aware of their operation, 4) have insurance against damage to the facilities or injuries to visitors, and 5) observe safety and hygiene standards. Especially, damage insurance is of importance to both farmers and visitors in the event of personal injury or property damage. Now let us examine the details of the activities of these farms. No answer 1%(3)
Other groups 27%(113)
Elementary school 33%(137)
Individual & family 9%(39) Kindergarten & nursery school 4%(18)
College & job training school 3%(14)
Junior high school 19%(79) High school 4%(17)
Figure 1: Visior affiliations Note: As of year 2002, Japan Dairy Council. Sample size in ( ).
Figure 1:
Visitor affiliations. (Note: as of year 2002, Japan Dairy Council. Sample size in brackets.)
Figure 1 illustrates the composition of visitor affiliations as reported by the Japan Dairy Council for 2002 and shows that one third of visitors were from elementary schools and about one fifth from junior high schools. Therefore, over WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
428 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Ju n. Ju l. Au g. Se p. Oc t. No v. De c. Ja n. Fe b. Ma r.
4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Ap r. Ma y
visitor
half of the visitors were from compulsory education institutions. This means that these farms contributed to the local community in sharing an educational role in the compulsory education system.
m onth Figure 2: Monthly number of visitors Note: As of year 2002, Japan Dairy Council.
Figure 2:
Monthly number of visitors. (Note: as of year 2002, Japan Dairy Council.)
Study of food 14%(84)
Other 7%(40)
Contact with creatures & nature 50%(284)
Study of life 12%(71) Study of farming 17%(101)
Figure 3:
Purpose of visit: multiple answers. (Note: as of year 2002, Japan Dairy Council. Sample size in brackets.)
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
429
Figure 2 shows monthly attendance. The highest attendance is during the first part of the school year, that is, in May, June and July. Although we have a rainy season from June to July in Japan, visitors can experience dairy farming practices indoors. This is an advantage of livestock farming compared with crop farming. September and October is the second busiest season, while, in contrast, there are few visitors in the winter season from December onward. Thus, the early summer is the most suitable time for farming experiences. As to the purpose of the farm visit, whereas more than 50% answered that the purpose was contact with animals, less than 20% stated the study of farming as the purpose (Figure 3). This means that multifunctionality of agriculture stimulated interest for farm visits rather than farming per se. In other words, the purpose of farm visits tells us where the educational function of agriculture originates. In this respect, taking into account multifunctionality is a necessary condition to enhance the educational function of agriculture.
Making milk product: other 2%(18)
Other 18%(195)
Making milk product: ice cream 12%(131)
Feeding 15%(165) Making milk product: butter 14%(154)
Figure 4:
Milking 27%(277)
Dung cleaning 5%(57)
Suckling 7%(75)
Content of farming experience: multiple answers. (Note: as of year 2002, Japan Dairy Council. Sample size is in brackets.)
The content of the farming experience was divided into two categories: dairy operations and dairy products (Figure 4). Visitors usually are exposed to experiences in several service areas, so that there were multiple answers. Milking and feeding were common menu items among operations while making butter and ice cream were the first and the second common among products. Making dairy products is an important menu item related to experience in terms of raising interest in food as a means of food education. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
430 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The most frequent complaint was lack of sufficient toilets. This problem becomes serious when large groups visit farms because the long lines hinder smooth implementation of the farming experience. In summary, the significance of providing farming experiences in dairy farms was recognized especially by the compulsory education system. Experiences in the farm yard result in providing education on farming and food for visitors whereas the initial motivation for the farm visitors was interest in multifunctionality rather than for farming per se. Facility-wise, adequate toilet facilities should be prepared.
3
Case studies of educational dairy farms
The two dairy farmers studied here did not consider providing farming experience services as a full-time economic activity. Rather, they thought that their offering those services was a volunteer activity to benefit the local community. In this sense, it is safe to say that they aimed to establish mutual long-term trust with the local community. 3.1 Case 1: services provided free of charge Mr Y. Kameda receives mainly junior high school students in Sakado, a northwestern suburb of the metropolitan area. He does this because he wants his dairy farm to be supported and considered necessary to the local community. He believes that the educational function in the local community has become increasingly necessary to compensate for the declining function of the traditional family educational role. However, a major problem of performing this activity is that it takes many hours to complete the planned program of activities. He has not yet received any monetary reward for this service. He feels that it will be difficult to maintain the same attitude in the future because the requests to visit his farm are rising. 3.2 Case 2: services provided for a fee Mrs Y. Sudo is another example of this type of dairy farmer in Tateyama, the southern tip of Chiba prefecture. She also feels that without doubt the demand for farm visits and for farming experiences has risen in the last decade. However, she also thinks that social recognition for this service is still low. Therefore, to gain the acknowledgement that she appropriately feels is deserved, she believes that dairy farmers should outgrow the role of volunteer. For that reason, she discloses service fees and charges for the services that her farm provides. However, she does not intend to seek profit from this activity or to be a tourism ranch. In short, providing farming experience services is a new activity for farmers and farmers are still seeking how to position this new activity within each farm. However, there is no reason why the demand for this new activity will not grow because modern urban life has become more and more stressful. There should be something to ease the stress. The first factor that the two farmers have in WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
431
common is that they actively seek a new role for dairy farming in connection with their local communities. The second common point is their conviction that this new role is closely connected to the multifunctionality of farming and that the significance of this role is growing. That is why it is necessary to increase social recognition of their new activity.
4
Toward internalizing the external effect of farming experience services
4.1 Two external effects As mentioned above, educational dairy farms exert externalities on the local community. However, this situation cannot be resolved for either farmers or society by farmers simply asking payment from visitors. This is because we should take into account the relationship between farmers and the local community. We consider that this relationship contains two types of externalities that are mingled. Thus, we attempt here to clarify how to realize the internalization process by taking into account these two effects. We call them the neighbourhood effects, which are subdivided into the first effect and the second effect. 4.2 First effect: collectable by farmers The first effect is characterized by the fact that farmers do not internalize it for the local community but use it to build trust from the local community. This behaviour means that they obtain intangible compensation in the form of trust in exchange for taking care of local elementary and junior high school students from the perspective of nurturing community resources. In this sense it can be said that they try to internalize the externality by attaining trust with the local community from the long-term perspective. Then once a trustful relationship is established, even if there are troublesome episodes such as annoying complaints or complaints related to noise pollution by livestock, local residents would understand the farming activity and would not file any serious complaints. This means that transaction costs with the local community would be minimized. Thus, we can say that this offered farming experience contributes to community resources in the form of trust. Moreover, in addition to minimizing the transaction cost with the local community, there is another important point. That is the discovery of a new role for farming people and thereafter formation of a new identity for farmers. This results in improving the quality of service that farmers provide and eventually in the integration of the whole farm activity. However, in any case, these efforts by farmers will not be paid for in the short term, but will be paid for over the long term by gaining trust from the local community, which is a form of long-term insurance.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
432 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Thus, the above effect is rational economic behaviour from the farm management point of view as a going concern. These costs are internalized in any case, although there is variation in the degree of this internalization from one farm to another. However, the problem is that the cost that farmers have to carry is not limited to the costs mentioned above. That is why we should consider another effect next. 4.3 Second effect: uncollectable for farmers The second effect is also caused by the relationship with the local community. Particularly when the demand for the farming experience increases, so does the burden for farmers in terms of time spent for coordination and preparation to accept visitors. This entire process takes opportunity costs as foregone income. The issue is that farmers feel hesitant in asking for visitors to pay for these preparation costs due to their sense of neighbourliness with the local community. In other words, on the farmers’ part, excess supply of farming experience services is offered to the local community. This is a truly positive externality brought by farmers to the local community. In this sense it can be designated as an over-commitment effect to the neighbourhood or strictly speaking the neighbourliness effect. This effect has an ironic aspect; the more a sense of neighbourliness a farmer has, the more difficult the cost is to collect. Because generally those who start this activity originally have a volunteer spirit, it is difficult for them to ask the local people to cover these costs. Thus, the closer to the neighbours, the more difficult it is for farmers to collect unpaid costs. In this sense, it can be said that it is an externality that has a neighbourhood effect. This is a situation where a farmer is forced to provide over-supply on one hand and the local residents take a free ride without paying the cost on the other hand. In short, we can classify the externality created by providing farming experience services as shown below: 1. Investment in forming trust with the local community; collectable in the long run. 2. Over-supply from the sense of neighbourhood; not collectable for farmers. The composition of the two differs from one farmer to another, depending on the farmer's attitude toward this new activity. In any case, the cost that farmers do not collect in the short term includes these two types of cost. While the first behaviour to gain trust is rational as farm activity, the second neighbourhood effect is not rational, which will raise disutility for providers, although the degree will depend on their attitude toward this activity. From an economic perspective of socially optimal resource allocation, externality that is difficult to internalize by farmers is the second case. The problem here is that if the second effect becomes too large, it will eventually discourage farmers from continuing to provide farming experience service. To examine this point further we built an economic framework on how to deal with the educational function of farming, which is described in the next chapter.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
5
433
Economic framework
Here for simplicity we assume that only local residents are demanding farming experience services. Figure 5 illustrates the demand curve and the supply curve of farming experience, measuring horizontally the level of farming experience services and vertically the value of such services. Curve cp1 represents the private marginal cost of producing a farming experience service, curve cp2 is the private marginal cost when cost of forming trust from the local community is taken into account, and curve cs is the social marginal cost of the farming experience service. These curves become one identical horizontal line at the low level of farming experience service. This is because providing a farming experience service does not require any additional cost due to its characteristic of a joint product with dairy production. Therefore, to a certain extent, depicted as point k in Figure 5, even if demand increases up to this level, the price remains low. At this stage, in response to the small size of demand as depicted in demand curve d0d’0, for instance, at the point where the price is very low as shown at oc, it is easy to reach an equilibrium even with something like a small gift brought by visitors, such as home-made cookies.
¥
p1 p2 d
d1
f
b d0
e
g a
c
s
d’1
k d’0
o
Figure 5:
u
v
w
x
Farming experiences
Conceptual model of farming experience service.
However, at the stage when demand increases beyond point k, the curve begins to move upward and branches off into three curves. In these areas, the farmer begins providing full-scale farming experience services and consequently generates the positive externality as the educational function for local communities. Because of this externality, the social marginal cost curve cs is always under the private marginal cost curves cp1 and cp2. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
434 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Suppose the demand increases to demand curve d1d’1, the local society does not recognize this externality, which means that visitors do not consider the social marginal cost curve cs while farmers recognize that cost. In short, there is asymmetry of information between farmers and local visitors or residents. This information gap results in excessive demand at ox for farming experience services without paying the cost. However, the demand ox is at a socially optimal level only when the social marginal cost is borne by visitors. This is not the case in reality because farmers face the private marginal cost curve rather than the social marginal cost curve. This private marginal cost increases as production of the farming experience service increases. The reason why the curve is right and upward is that the transaction cost for providing farming experience service increases along with increases in the service offered. The transaction cost includes opportunity cost for coordination of the farming operation and visitors and for preparation while taking into account labour allocation between the farming operation and providing visitor services. As far as farming experience services are concerned, farmers must deal with coordination and preparation themselves, unlike in the case of traditional farm products where division of labour is possible through use of shipping and marketing organizations such as agricultural cooperatives. This burden results in lowering labour productivity in the dairy farming operation and eventually further raises the opportunity cost for providing the farming experience service. This is the reason that the private marginal curve moves steeply upward. Therefore, the private optimal point for farmers is at point b where it is rational for them to provide the service to ow. However, local community demands rise to ox, a point where farmers cannot refuse and then must provide the service. This is not a social optimal point because if visitors pay the amount of de, a social optimal point is attained at point e instead of b. However, that is not the case in reality, since visitors do not pay. When the amount of de is not paid to farmers by local beneficiaries due to the unrecognized social marginal cost curve cs, the private marginal cost reaches point d for the farming experience service at ox. The amount of df out of the unpaid amount of de will be able to be internalized for farmers as trust forming, and fe, the rest of the de, is difficult to be internalized due to the neighbourhood effect that makes it difficult for farmers to ask for payment. When local communities become dependent on these farming experience services, the demand curve becomes inelastic or more steeply sloped. For comparison, suppose that the inelastic demand curve crosses at point e with the social marginal cost curve cs. Then some of the unpaid portion is shifted on to the demand side, so the difference between the private optimal supply ow and the social optimal supply ox will be reduced. In this respect, inelastic demand is preferable for farmers and from the social resource allocation viewpoint as well. However, even if the difference will be reduced, the difference remains unless the demand becomes perfectly inelastic, which rarely happens in reality. Thus, whereas making the demand inelastic will be one solution for the externality, we should recognize that it is not the perfect solution. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
435
It can be said that originally the farming experience service by farmers was born as a complement or substitute for the educational capability of the family and local community, which is in decline. In view of this, the amount of the unpaid portion or the over-commitment effect fe should be as small as possible in order to ensure sustainable provision of this service. However, these activities are not yet fully recognized socially, so farmers end up providing excessive service in taking into account the neighbourhood relationship. Particularly, those farmers that provide this service tend to be highly motivated to perform volunteer work and they willingly meet this challenge. However, they face the dilemma that the greater the love of the community, the larger is the unpaid portion by excessive supply of service. Eventually it becomes difficult to continue providing the service. Therefore, to maintain this educational function and develop it sustainably, it is necessary to build a social system so that the demand side should not remain a free rider of the externality provided by farmers. To this end, first, measures should be taken to widely inform society of this educational function in farming to resolve the information asymmetry between farmers and the rest of the society, particularly the local community. Second, in taking into account the large number of compulsory education institutions that are beneficiaries, a certain part of the unpaid portion should be paid as an investment in education or be considered a necessary educational cost and be paid from the budget of the local government. Moreover, also, it will be necessary to seek a third body to assume an intermediary coordinating role between farmers and visitors to reduce the transaction cost for farmers.
6
Conclusions
This paper explored economic conditions for increasing the educational function of agriculture by focusing on educational dairy farms that provide farming experience services in Japan. The main findings were as follows: 1) Educational dairy farms play a positive role by offering farming experience especially for compulsory school-age children, such as those in elementary and junior high schools in the local community. To cope with the rising number of visitors, at a minimum, necessary facilities such as toilets should be adequately provided. 2) Farming experiences have educational effects not only on visitors, but also on farmers per se. This is because farmers can discover new possibilities in agriculture, which eventually leads to deepening and further realizing multifunctionality. 3) Regarding the relationship with local communities, the farmers were not able to demand payment for providing services because they felt a sense of closeness to the local community. The main reason for this situation of under-charge comes from the asymmetric flow of information between farmers and the rest of society. Therefore, supporting measures enhancing the social recognition of the external effect caused by those farmers who provide farming experience services should be taken into account in the future. This is the first step to nurture a new role of agriculture that contributes to a sustainable rural-urban relationship. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
436 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
Arai, K. The Economics of Education, Springer-Verlag: Tokyo, 1998. Brouwer, F. (eds) Sustaining Agriculture and the Rural Environment: Governance, Policy and Multifunctionality, Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.: Cheltenham, 2005. OECD. Multifunctionality: Towards an Analytical Framework, OECD: Paris, 2001. OECD, Multifunctionality: The Policy Implications, Paris, 2003. Oshima, J. Educational Farm in France (in Japanese), Japan Education Press: Tokyo, 1999. Ohe, Y. Evaluating Jointness of Multifunctional Agriculture: Educational Function of Dairy Farming in Japan, Aravossis, K., Brebbia, C. A., Kakaras, E. and Kungolos, A. G. (eds) Environmental Economics and Investment Assessment, WIT Press: Southampton, pp.337-346, 2006. Ohe, Y. Multifunctionality and Rural Tourism: A Perspective on Farm Diversification, Journal of International Farm Management, in press. Pezzini, M. Rural Policy Lessons from OECD Countries. Paper Presented in the International Conference, European Rural Policy at the Crossroads, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, 2000. Shichinohe, C., Nagata, K. and Jinnouchi, Y. Educational Function of Agriculture (in Japanese), Rural Culture Association: Tokyo, 1990. Tabuchi, Y. and Siomi, M. Mountainous Areas and Multifunctionality (in Japanese), Association of Agriculture and Forestry Statistics: Tokyo, 2002. Van Huylenbroeck, G. and Whitby, M. Countryside Stewardship: Farmers, Policies and Markets. Elsevier Science Ltd: Oxford, 1999. Van Huylenbroeck, G. and Durand, G., Multifunctional Agriculture: A New Paradigm for European Agriculture and Rural Development, Ashgate Publishing Ltd.: Aldershot, 2003.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
437
Effects of planting patterns on biomass accumulation and yield of summer maize L. Quanqi1,2, C. Yuhai2, L. Mengyu1, Y. Songlie2, Z. Xunbo2 & D. Baodi1 1
Center for Agricultural Resource Research, Institute of Genetic and Development Biology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shijiazhuang, P.R.China 2 Agronomy College of Shandong Agricultural University, Tai'an Shandong, P.R.China
Abstract Biomass accumulation by crops depends on both light interception by leaves and on the efficiency with which the intercepted light is used to produce dry matter. Our aim was to identify which of these processes were affected for summer maize field crops grown under different planting patterns. In this paper, the effects of different planting patterns on the radiation-use efficiency (RUE) was investigated. The experimental work was carried out in 2005 in the field located in Shandong province, north China. Three planting patterns have been applied in 2005: flat planting, bed planting and furrow planting. Above-ground biomass accumulation and grain yield of bed and furrow planting patterns were higher than that of flat planting patterns. The lower biomass production and yield in flat planting patterns was accounted for by the reduced amount of photosyntheticlly active radiation (PAR) absorbed by the canopy, which was itself the consequence of the reduced leaf area index. These results obtained in field crop conditions strengthen the idea that planting patterns greatly affect radiation-use efficiency, biomass accumulation and yield of summer maize in north China. Keywords: planting pattern, radiation-use efficiency, yield, summer maize.
1
Introduction
In field crop studies, the approach developed by Monteith [1] makes it possible to analyse biomass production as the consequence of two major processes: (i) the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070411
438 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI interception by leaves of the incoming photosynthetically active radiation and (ii) the ability of plants to transform the intercepted radiation into biomass. Environmental factors, which limit crop growth, may act through a reduction of one of these two processes, or sometimes through a combination of both. The fraction of the incoming photosynthetically active radiation that is absorbed by the canopy mainly depends on the leaf area index and crop geometry. The crop's capacity to transform the absorbed photosynthetically active radiation into biomass is called the radiation-use efficiency (RUE). It is generally estimated by the slop of the linear relationship between the above-ground biomass produced and the cumulated PAR. The physiological processes underlying the RUE have been reviewed by Kiniry et al [2], Russell et al [3], Sinclair and Muchow [4]. Sinclair and Horie [5] have calculated that increasing the leaf photosynthesis rate increases the RUE non-linearly, with the RUE reaching a maximum value at high photosynthesis rate. Other analysis has indicated that stresses that reduce the leaf photosynthetic rate should result in lower RUE. Such as the case for nitrogen, which was shown to affect the RUE of maize [6]. The current economic milieu of developing countries and its effects on the agricultural sector, particularly in the search for sustainable agricultural systems, has changed cultivation patterns as well as agricultural practices aimed at increasing productivity and improving the use of natural resources [7, 8]. Farmers in China, like their counterparts throughout the developing world, face new conditions brought about by such changes in sectoral policy as the lowering of trade barriers, limits on guaranteed prices, and reduced subsides on inputs such as seed, fertilizer, and irrigation water [9]. The need to conserve the natural resource base for agriculture is also becoming more acute. To respond effectively to these new conditions, farmers require technological options that maintain or increase productivity, reduce costs, and maintain production systems in a sustainable manner. Technological innovations must be monitored continuously to ensure that they meet these criteria. This article examines the role of a particular crop management innovation—planting summer maize on beds or furrows—in enabling farmers to meet the challenges of a changing socioeconomic and agroecological environment. In this study, three planting patterns under rain-fed conditions in north China were used to investigate the effects of planting patterns on radiation-use efficiency, biomass accumulation and yield of summer maize.
2
Materials and methods
2.1 Site and crops management The trial was conducted at agricultural experimental station of Shandong agricultural university in north China in 2005. The soil of the station is classified as clay. In 2005, three planting patterns were conducted, which were flat planting (D), bed planting (B) and furrow planting (F). For bed and furrow planting patterns, the distance between beds turned out to be 20 cm, the height of the beds was 15 cm. The width of the furrow between two beds was 20 cm. For bed WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
439
planting patterns, one row of summer maize was seeded on beds; for furrow planting patterns, one row of summer maize was seeded in furrows. The summer maize cultivar was “nongda 108”, which was very popular in north China. The maize was sown on 7 June 2005, plant densities was 6.6×104 plants﹒ hm-2. Weeds were controlled before emergence by application of Bentazon (480g l-1). Nitrogen and potassium fertilization were supplied so as to be non-limiting. 2.2 Plant samples and measurements Plant samples were taken approximately every 10 days from emergence to maturity. Leaf measurements and calculations to obtain the green leaf area index (LAI) were used by SunScan. Above-ground dry matter was determined by sampling small plots consisting of 4 consecutive plants from the central rows. The sampling areas were spaced to avoid the effects of previous samplings. The 4 sampled plants were weighted (fresh weight). Dry matter was determined after drying at 80℃ for 72 h. Grain yield and yield components were measured at maturity on an area of 8 m2 corresponding to the two central rows of each plot. The number of maize ears per hm2 and the number of rows per ear were measured. The weight of 1000 grains was estimated by counting and weighting 100 grains on 3 replicates per plot. The harvest index (HI) was calculated by dividing the dry weight of grains by the aerial dry biomass at harvest. 2.3 Canopy light interception and radiation-use efficiency In the later growing seasons of summer maize, the amount of solar radiation reaching the ground surface beneath the canopy was measured at three separate positions within each plot using SunScan every 1 h. At the same time, incoming solar radiation above the crop canopy was also monitored. The difference between the above canopy and soil surface mounted by SunScan allowed for the determination of solar radiation intercepted by the canopy. Radiation-use efficiency in the growing season of summer maize was calculated by [10] E%=
∆W ⋅ H ×100% ∑S
In the above formula, △W is dry matter weight at maturity; H=17.782KJ/g, is energy conversion coefficient; ∑S is global incoming radiation in the growing season of summer maize, which was recorded at the meteorological station of Tai'an located about 0.5 km of the experimental site. 2.4 Statistical analysis The treatments were run as an analysis of variance (ANOVA). The ANOVA was performed at α=0.05 level of significance to determine if significant differences existed among treatments means. The multiple comparisons were done for significant effects with the LSD test at α=0.05.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
440 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
Results
3.1 Leaf area index, light interception and radiation-use efficiency Mean seasonal change in leaf area index is presented in Figure 1. Leaf area index was similar for all treatments before anthesis. After anthesis, leaf-area index of bed and furrow planting patterns were higher than that of flat planting pattern, and post-anthesis green-area duration was longer under bed and furrow planting patterns. But little difference in leaf-area index between the bed and furrow planting patterns. 7 6
Leaf area index
5 4 D B F
3 2 1 0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Days after sowing
Figure 1:
Seasoning change of leaf area index.
The proportion of the incident radiation intercepted by crop increased with leaf-area index, the amount of light intercepted by canopy of bed and furrow planting crops exceeded light interception by the canopy of the flat crop (Figure 2). Max light capture occurred in the bed and furrow treatment in the latter part of the season, but in the flat planting pattern, most incident light was transmitted to the soil surface. By contrast, the more even canopy of the bed and furrow planting crops captured more light and prevented its transmission to the soil surface. The impact of this may have been a reduction in heating of the soil surface in the bed and furrow planting crops, reducing the potential for loss of soil water via evaporation from the soil surface in this treatment. Table 1 shows the radiation-use efficiency in the whole growing season of the three planting patterns, the calculated radiation-use efficiency corresponding to the furrow planting pattern did not appear to be significantly lower than that corresponding to the bed planting pattern, but the calculated radiation-use WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
441
efficiency to the flat planting pattern did appear to be lower than those corresponding to the bed and furrow planting pattern. The substantial decrease in leaf area index during the whole growing seasons of the summer maize in flat planting pattern maybe cause a large reduction of the amount of PAR absorbed by the crop, therefore radiation-use efficiency in the whole growing season was significantly lower than those of bed and furrow planting patterns.
PAR capture ratio(%)
94 92 90 88 86
D F B
84 82 80
18:00
17:00
16:00
15:00
14:00
13:00
12:00
11:00
10:00
9:00
8:00
7:00
78
Time(h)
Figure 2:
PAR capture ration in the daytime. The data was the mean value measured by SunScan on 19 Aug, 20 Aug and 22 Aug in 2005 (sunny day).
Table 1:
Radiation-use efficiency in the whole growing season of flat, bed and furrow planting patterns. Treatments
Radiation-use efficiency (%)
D 2.41b B 2.49a F 2.47a Note: Within lines, means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (P < 0.05). The same below. 3.2 Above-ground biomass production Figure 3 shows the dry matter production after sowing for the three planting patterns. In the whole growing season, the above-ground biomass produced was very close between the bed and furrow planting patterns, no statistically significant differences were found. At maturity, dry matter was between 298 and 293 g/plant for both planting patterns. In the flat planting pattern, the aboveground biomass production was reduced in the whole growing season, differences with the bed planting pattern were statistically significant (P=0.05) from the 5-visible leaf stage and onwards. At flowering, the biomass produced in WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
442 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI flat planting pattern was 15.7% lower than that in bed planting pattern. At maturity, the above-ground biomass produced in the flat planting pattern was significantly lower than that in bed planting pattern. These were coincident with radiation-use efficiency, this means that the lower biomass produced in the flat planting pattern is mainly attributable to the lower amount of PAR absorbed by summer maize.
Accumulated dry matter(g/plant)
300 250 D B F
200 150 100 50 0 15
25
35
45
55
65
75
85
95
105
Days after sowing
Figure 3: Table 2:
Changes in mean above-ground dry matter over the season. Maize yield and yield components of flat, bed and furrow planting patterns.
Treatment
D
B
F
Number of rows per ear
15.20a
15.60a
15.50a
Weight 1000 grains (g)
287.63a
327.46a
332.23a
Number of maize ears per hectare Number of grains per row Harvest index
65790a
65955a
65895a
35.43b
39.13a
38.83a
0.472b
0.514a
0.508a
9877.37b
11703.82a
11421.13a
-2
Yield (kg hm )
3.3 Grain yield and yield components Table 2 gives the grain yields and yield components for the three planting patterns. Yield and yield components differed very little between the bed and furrow planting patterns. The average grain yield was only 2.5% higher in bed WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
443
planting pattern than in furrow planting pattern. Conversely, grain yield was significantly (P=0.05) lower in flat planting pattern, the yield reduction was 15.6% and 13.5% of bed and furrow planting patterns. The number of grains per row was significantly lower in flat planting patterns than in bed and furrow planting patterns. The weight of 1000 grains, the number of maize ears per hectare and the number of rows per ear were not significantly different between any planting patterns. The harvest index was not different between bed and furrow planting patterns, but flat planting pattern was not, which suggest that planting patterns reduced grain production to the same extent as it reduced above-ground biomass production (Figure 3).
4
Discussion
In recent time, farmers have experimented with bed and furrow planting patterns not only in north China [11] but also throughout the world [12–14,16]. A major interest in these patterns is increasing water use efficiency in the growing season of crops [13,17,18]. In this article, the findings presented here show that bed and furrow planting patterns increase PAR capture ration in the whole growing season of summer maize, so decreased the evaporative loss of soil moisture from the ground surface, as a result, more soil moisture will be available for transpiration by the summer maize. This effect was ascribed to be mainly due to decreased penetration of incident radiation to the soil surface in the bed and furrow planting patterns. Bed planting offers many advantages in irrigated wheat production systems [11,14], and the authors are just beginning to determine how useful maize bed planting pattern may be for rain-fed areas, so did furrow planting pattern. We are confident that it can play an important role in environments characterized by prolonged waterlogging as a result of excessive rainfall. As this paper has attempted to demonstrate, the potential for achieving sustainable increase in crops yield in China is still considerable, especially in north China, where population is very large, land and water resource are very short. Food security will depend not only on our ability to improve yield growth, but also on our ability to improve this yield growth in such a way that natural resource base remains unharmed. Agronomy and crop management research hold some of the most exciting opportunities for sustainably improving maize system productivity in areas such as north China. This paper has given some examples of planting patterns, whose adoption may make the difference between food security and resource scarcity in the years to come. Providing farmers with viable management alternatives is the primary role of agricultural scientists. Bed and furrow planting patterns for summer maize go a long way towards achieving those goals.
Acknowledgement Funding for this project was provided by the State Key Program of Basic Research of China (“973” Project, 2005CB121106). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
444 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
References [1] [2]
[3]
[4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16]
Monteith, J. L. 1997. Climate and the efficiency of crop production in Britain. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 281: 277-294. Kiniry, J. R., Jones, C. A., O′Toole, J. C., Blanchet R, Cabelguenne, M. and Spanel, D. A. 1989. Radiation-use efficiency in biomass accumulation prior to grain filling for five grain crop species. Field Crops Res. 20: 5164. Russelle, G., Jarvis, P. G. and Monteith, J. L. 1989. Absorption of radiation by canopies and stand growth. In Plant Canopies: Their Growth, Form and Function. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, Ed. G Russell, pp21-39. Sinclair, T. R. and Muchow, R. C. 1999. Radiation-use efficiency. In Advances in Agronomy. Ed. D L Sparks (Ed.). pp 215-265. Academic Press, New York. Sinclair, T. R. and Horie, T. 1989. Leaf nitrogen, photosynthesis and crop radiation-use efficiency: A review. Crop Sci. 29: 90-98. Uhart, S. A. and Andrade, F. H. 1995. Nitrogen deficiency in maize: Ⅰ. Effect on crop growth, development, dry matter partitioning and kernel set. Crop Sci. 35: 1376-1383. Dennis, W., David, C. and Garrick, S. 2002. Evaluating the impact of irrigation and drainage policies on agricultural sustainability. Irrigation and Drainage Systems. 16: 1-14. Ian, C., Mark, W. R. and David, S. 1997. Irrigation and food security in the 21st century. Irrigation and Drainage Systems. 11: 83-101. Zhang, X. Y., Pei, D. and Hu, C. S. 2003. Conserving groundwater for irrigation in the North China Plain. Irrig. Sci. 21: 159-166. Li, Z. J., Li, F. C. and Zhao, B. Q. 1998. Studies on light and heat resource use efficiency and yield effect of wheat/corm/corn intercropping system. J. of Shandong Agricultural University. 29(4): 419-426. Wang, F. H., Wang, X. Q. and Ken S. 2004. Comparison of conventional, flood irrigated, flat planting with furrow irrigated, raised bed planting for winter wheat in China. Field Crops Res. 87: 35-42. Abu-Awwad, A. M. 1999. Effects of sand column, furrow and supplemental irrigation on agricultural production in an arid environment. Irrig. Sci. 18:191-197. Panigrahi, B., Panda, S. N. and Raghuwanshi, N. S. 2001. Potato water use and yield under furrow irrigation. Irrig. Sci. 20: 155-163. Agustin Limon-Ortega., Sayre, K. D. and Francis, C. A. 2000. Wheat and maize yields in response to straw management and nitrogen under a bed planting system. Agronimy J. 92: 295-302. Kang, Y. H., Wang, Q. G. and Liu, h. J. 2005. Winter wheat canopy interception and its influence factors under sprinkler irrigation. Agricultural Water Management. 74: 189-199. Dean, D. S., Earl, C. S. and Raymond, E. K. 2000. Irrigation management for corn in the northern Great Plains, USA. Irrig. Sci. 19: 107-114. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[17] [18]
445
Wang, R. Z. and Gao, O. 2001. Photosynthesis, transpiration, and water use efficiency in two divergent Leymus chinensis populations from Northeast China. Photosynthetica. 39(1): 123-126. Mishra, H. S., Rathore, T. R. and Savita, U. S. 2001. Water-use efficiency of irrigated winter maize under cool weather conditions of India. Irrig. Sci. 21: 27-33.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Section 12 Sustainable waste management
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
449
A diagnostic model for M.S.W. landfill operation and the protection of ecosystems with a spatial multiple criteria analysis – Zakynthos Island, Greece T. Koliopoulos1 & G. Koliopoulou2 1
Centre of Environmental Management Research, University of Strathclyde, Environmental Consultancy, Greece 2 Department of Experimental Physiology, Medical School, University of Athens, Greece
Abstract Sanitary landfills remain an attractive disposal route for municipal solid waste, because it is more economical than alternative solutions. The produced landfill emissions by waste biodegradation could be exploited after treatment as renewable resources. In this paper the experimental design of Mid Auchencarroch landfill is taken into account, which is a UK Environment Agency and industry funded research facility. The relative magnitudes of pollution load in time by landfill gas and leachate emissions are considered, making useful conclusions for the operation of future sustainable integrated waste management systems and associated regional sustainable development protecting ecosystems and public health. Keywords: landfill design, waste emissions’ topography, spatial analysis, lining of monitoring systems, integrated waste management systems, sustainable development, public health.
1
Introduction
A municipal integrated solid waste system facilitates the operation of one or more operational techniques and technologies of solid waste management systems such as landfilling, incineration, compost production, recycling, leachates treatment, waste vehicles transport etc. [2,5,6,13,20]. Sanitary landfills WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070421
450 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI remain an attractive disposal route for municipal solid waste, because, it is more economical than alternative solutions. It is accepted that the landfill biodegradation processes are complex, including many factors that control the progression of the waste mass to final stage quality [6–9]. The landfill gas and leachate generation is an inevitable result of the solid waste biodegradation in landfills and their study is necessary for future efficient designs, controlling air, soil and groundwater pollution [3,7,8,20]. This paper presents an analysis of exploitation of produced landfill emissions for regional development using proper technologies. The use of controlled batch anaerobic bioreactors accelerates waste biodegradation in short periods, avoiding any associated environmental risks due to landfill emissions [1,4–8]. Any uncontrolled dumps have to close so as to avoid any threats to the public health and to protect the ecosystems and the environmental resources. Large sanitary landfills are preferred because these provide better opportunities for potential hazard control and an increasing potential for resource recovery. Efficiently managed sustainable landfill sites can generate considerable volumes of methane gas (CH4), which can be exploited by proper landfill gas recovery installations to produce electricity or natural gas. The produced landfill gas could be exploited for energy recovery, for greenhouse heating, for biofuel use and for energy supply at several anthropogenic activities of land uses. Treated leachates, after the use of proper technologies should be used for water supply in irrigations networks and other related regional development public works, in order to minimise the use of raw resources.
2
The case study: Zakynthos Island landfill’s boundaries determination
This paper presents the decision making for efficient lining of landfill boundaries and its final location. However, efficient waste management techniques should be followed for satisfactory waste biodegradation in anaerobic landfill bioreactors like those which have been followed on Mid Auchencarroch experimental landfill project, which is located outside from Glasgow city, in Scotland [6–9]. The experimental landfill Mid Auchencarroch is a field scale facility, constructed in order to assess a number of techniques that promote sustainable landfill. Mid Auchencarroch experimental landfill is an Environment Agency, DTI and industry funded research facility. Mid Auchencarroch (MACH) experimental landfill has been capped since 1995 [6–9]. Effective diagnostic models should be used not only to evaluate current landfill projects but also to propose efficient solutions and give confrontations to associated environmental problems from landfill emissions based on any available experimental data from the literature. In this paper is examining as case study the determination of landfill location and its boundaries’ lining for the protection of any important environmental resources and ecosystems on Zakynthos Greek Ionian Sea Island in west Greece (Fig.1). It has been selected this island as is living on it the loggerhead turtle WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
451
(Caretta Caretta), which is listed as an endangered species within the EU boundaries. It is included in Annex II (priority species) and Annex IV of the Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC). The beaches of Zakynthos are hosting the last and most important concentration of loggerhead turtle, Caretta Caretta. Since its major nesting areas in Greece have been identified and are under various protective and management schemes (all included in the national list of proposed Natura 2000 sites), mortality at sea emerges as a high priority, which if not addressed might also undermine conservation efforts at nesting areas. Several environmental activities are taking place so as to protect Carreta Caretta. The latter activities are supported by several Environmental Organisations (Archelon, wwf etc.) focused on the reduction of losses of Caretta Caretta at sea, and the protection of its eggs. Moreover, on Zakynthos island there is the Mediterranean monk seal (Monachus monachus), for which the incidental entanglement in fishing gear is considered a major threat contributing to the overall decline of the species. Gulf Lagana is a protected area for the Caretta Caretta turtle. The southern gulf of Zakynthos and the Strofades are considered as protected areas where usually are visited by migrating birds, wild swans, swallows, kingfishers, and sea gulls [10,19].
Figure 1:
Map of Greece and Zakynthos Island location in West Greece.
Zakynthos is the capital and port of the island, located at the foot of Bochali hill. Zakynthos is known as D. Solomos’s and A. Kalvos’s island, who were lived on the island in past times, and they are among the great national poets and writers of Greece [14,19]. On the coasts, there are several fabulous tourist resorts with a wide variety of accommodations for tourists. On the island there are six municipalities which are the followings: Alykon, Arkadion, Artemision, Elation, Laganas and Zakynthion, Alikon, Arkadiou, Artemision, Lagana and Zakinthou. The municipality of Zakynthion covers the south east area of Zante and is the most populated of all the rest municipalities, with a population of over 14,000 inhabitants compared to about 4,000 inhabitants in the rest municipalities. The total population on the island is approximately 38600 inhabitants. The Prefecture WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
452 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI of Zakynthos is a non-profit Greek Governmental Organisation that is involved in the running of these areas to advise and assist with administration, citizenship, economic development and tourism in collaboration with the Municipalities’ Association of Zakynthos [15,19].
3
Spatial analysis
On Zakynthos Island there is a Marine Park, which is a protected area and is located along the southern coast from the promontory of Marathia’s Cape to the beach of Gerakas, including the outback of the beaches of Limni Kerì, Laganas and Kalamaki and the Strofades, two small islands 50 nautical miles southern of Zakynthos. This area presents the main characteristics of the Mediterranean Ecosystem, with sandy beaches, emerging rocks and sandy dunes, whereas in the outback there are thick pinewoods, fertile areas for the agriculture and the Mediterranean landscape with spontaneous vegetation [10,16,17]. The mountainous zone of the island covers 40% of its total surface, which consists of villages with different characteristics. The distribution of road network on the island is different from west to east and from north to south (Fig.2). To the north there are the towns of Volimes and Katastari, which are the capitals of the Municipalities Elation and Alikon respectively. To the west there are picturesque villages Agios Leon and Kiliomeno. To the south there are Agalas, Keri and other villages with many elements of traditional architecture, which retain the traditions of the island and are visited by many tourists during vacations [10,19]. However, based on the experimental elements of MACH project, which is a test bed for sequential batch landfill bioreactors and controls an enhanced degradation system there has been developed a simulation numerical model of landfill biodegradation stages and its associated emissions (i.e. simulation of gas risk, SimGasRisk) [8,9]. MACH project showed that is possible to control and enhance landfill gas, heat generation and flush potential leachate and other pollutants from the waste mass, by manipulating the whole process of landfill. Landfill concept in small depths can be used as an efficient sustainable sequential batch bioreactor [5–9]. A comprehensive spatial analysis model should be developed following the next steps. Based on SimGasRisk’s simulation numerical results for a given waste composition can be defined the advection velocity of probable landfill gas migration so as to determine useful spatial thresholds next to landfill boundaries, protecting any nearby ecosystems and environmental receptors from landfill emissions. The final lining of a proposed landfill location should take into account the latter fact protecting any nearby ecosystems; public health and anthropogenic properties. Moreover, based on the magnitudes of local average wind velocities and utilising SimGasRisk’s results could be determined threshold areas where there is influence on them by landfill gases emissions (i.e. carbon dioxide, methane etc.) so as to take the relative measures in time for the nearby land uses and their proper management [7,10,11,12,20].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 2:
453
Map of Zakynthos Island.
The current operating landfill of Zakynthos is located next to the borders of Lagana and Zakinthion Municipalities at south-east part of island. The latter existing location provokes with its emissions several problems to the nearby protective area of Laganas Gulf. However, there have been proposed three main areas for a new landfill location on the island, according to the Municipalities’ Association of Zakynthos. The latter proposed locations are the three followings: i) next to Agalas village, which is located next to the borders between the Municipalities Artemision and Lagana; ii) south at Skopos mountain; iii) next to the borders between the Municipalities Elation and Alikon or Municipalities Elation and Artemision [15,19]. The first examining location could be presented as a safe decision, due to the fact that the existence of the eastern mountainous area next to Agalas village protects all the main ecosystems’ population and inhabitants, which are located to the east of the island. This selection will avoid any annoying odours and any associated risks from landfill emissions to the nearby ecosystems and human populations. Relative measures should be taken during the final lining of the landfill location for the protection of any surrounded rivers or ground waters. The lining of a dense monitoring system in space and frequent samples of landfill emissions in time should take place next to landfill boundaries. Moreover, the second choice could be characterised safe if it assures that the selection of the final landfill location should not provoke any risks and hazards to the ecosystem of Laganas gulf. It should be away from the ecosystem area and should be constructed on the western side of the island. However, the third examining scenario of landfill location is not too favourable in comparison to the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
454 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI previous two ones. It includes the risk of probable landfill gases dispersion to the nearby villages to the east and south part of the island, provoking several probable environmental impacts to the surrounded ecosystems and human populations. The selection of landfill site location for the final solid waste disposal depends on a number of fundamental parameters which must be investigated in depth securing an acceptable situation to the surroundings of the site during its operation. The following parameters should be identified in detail in collaboration with the Local Authorities, during the selection of the final landfill site location: • Several socioeconomic and other parameters, which include the necessary landfill surface in relation to the served population; the solid waste which produced per capita; the solid waste composition and the selected waste disposal method; • Topographical parameters including topographical data of the site for its lining during its operational life cycle; • Environmental parameters assessing impacts and respective confrontation (i.e. lining landfill access roads with busy traffic which should not be closed to residences; noise protection taking into account local wind characteristics and the location either of neighbouring ecosystems or of the existence of natural resources exploitation (i.e. agro-tourism’s units, agricultural production units, irrigation works’ units etc.); • Hydrological parameters covering the regional water circulation from which one part flows to the landfill surface provoking operational problems; • Climatological parameters. Wind, rain and temperature directly affect sanitary landfill design, operation and maintenance; • Geological parameters. The permeability of the substratum should be investigated. The minimum distance between the bottom of the site and the first ground aquifer is a very important parameter to be determined. • Exploitation parameters including good access to the nearby road network, water supply, electricity, telephone, sewage facilities, fire protection equipment and other facilities. Therefore, the suitable criteria C could be outlined, in accordance with the analysis of the above parameters so as to select the optimum of landfill location minimising any threats to the nearby ecosystems. The established criteria that refer to the satisfaction of the examining parameters can be represented as C1, C2, C3, . . . , C n. Their values can be estimated through experience and could be based on the bibliography. The influence of the selected criteria is estimated through the insertion of weight coefficients: a1, a2, a3, . . . , an which can be classified as high, middle or low. The quality of the investigated site can be estimated by equation (1), when are taken into account the products of the examining criteria and the weight coefficients respectively: n
Q=
∑
ai ci
i =1
where Ci is the value of class i criterion and ai its weight coefficient. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(1)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
455
Below is calculated the mathematical expectation of the population of Zakynthos Island in 2031. The calculation of the population Pn after n years, there will be according to the following demographic formula (2): Pn = Po * (1+t)n
(2)
where P0 is the approximate population of Zakynthos island in 2001, P0 = 38,600 inhabitants. An increase 10% of population is taken for safety reasons covering additional necessities during holiday’s peak season. Hence, P0 = 42,460 inhabitants, t is the annual increase of population growth, is taken 2.5 %, n = 30 years life cycle operation of landfill from 2001 to 2031. According to equation (2), it yields: P2031 = 42,460 * (1.025)30 = 42,460 * 2.098 = 89,081 inhabitants
(3)
Taking that the production of waste is 0,8 kg per inhabitant and per day for the above examining inhabitants’ population and applying SimGasRisk simulation model, could be calculated probable air pollutants’ emissions from landfill boundaries to the nearby areas taking into account the following equations. The concentration C of an examining air pollutant along the central line of axis x from landfill boundary, taking the source of air pollutant on a height Η from the ground surface could be calculated by the following equation (4), for the examining comprehensive spatial analysis diagnostic model [7,9,11,12].
C ( x ,0 ,0 , H ) =
Q
π u σ yσ
z
1 H 2 exp − 2 2 σz
(4)
σy, σz dispersion coefficients dependent on x, and their relation is presented below. Also the concentration C of an examining air pollutant along the cross section to the central line at location (x,y) from landfill boundary, could be calculated by the following equation (5), for the examining comprehensive spatial analysis diagnostic model, taking the source of air pollutant on a height difference Η related to the location (x,y) of the receptor [7,9,11,12]. 1 y2 C ( x , y , 0 , H ) = exp − 2σ 2 y
Q πuσ yσ
z
1 H 2 exp − 2 2 σz
where Q gas emissions from the source (Kg/sec) C air pollutant concentration at location χ, y from a height Η (Kg/m3) u wind velocity (m/sec) WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(5)
456 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI x
is defined by the respective x distance on x axis, from the source of air pollutant to a nearby civic, industrial or agricultural land use receptor area, based on the particular spatial data of the examining proposed landfill sites’ areas. The selected x distance is applied on the following graphs (Fig. 3) so as to determine the respective dispersion coefficients in relation to atmospheric stability conditions A, B, C, D, E or F. y is defined as the transverse distance to the above selected x location for which is calculated the air pollutant concentration. The y distance is based on particular map data of nearby land uses next to the examining proposed landfill sites’ areas. The selected y distance is applied on the graph of σz dispersion coefficient versus distance (Fig. 3) so as to determine the respective value of dispersion σz coefficient in relation to atmospheric stability conditions A, B, C, D, E or F. σy, σz dispersion coefficients dependent on x, they are calculated based on Fig.3 graphs or by the corresponding least squares fitting curves based on Fig.3 data [15], which are presented below: σy, for A atmospheric stability condition σy = -3 10-16 x4 + 5 10-11 x3 – 4 10-06 x2 + 0.2031 x + 10.581, R2 = 0.9997; σy, for B atmospheric stability condition σy = 2 10-16 x4 – 2 10-11 x3 + 3 10-08 x2 + 0.1133 x + 36.938, R2 = 0.9973; σy, for C atmospheric stability condition σy = -8 10-17 x4 + 1 10-11 x3 – 1 10-06 x2 + 0.0922 x + 12.849, R2 = 0.9984; σy, for D atmospheric stability condition σy = 6 10-17 x4 – 1 10-11 x3 + 2 10-07 x2 + 0.0581 x + 17.218, R2 = 0.9986; σy, for E atmospheric stability condition σy = -2 10-17 x4 + 6 10-12 x3 – 5 10-07 x2 + 0.0472 x + 9.9535, R2 = 0.9979; σy, for F atmospheric stability condition σy = -4 10-17 x4 + 9 10-12 x3 – 6 10-07 x2 + 0.0333 x + 3.8686, R2 = 0.999; σz, for A atmospheric stability condition σz = -6 10-11 x4 + 3 10-07 x3 + 1 10-05 x2 + 0.1812 x – 5.1457, R2 = 0.9999; σz, for B atmospheric stability condition σz = 1 10-13 x4 – 3 10-09 x3 + 2 10-05 x2 + 0.0899 x – 1.7552, R2 = 0.9988; σz, for C atmospheric stability condition σz = -1 10-15 x4 + 1 10-10 x3 – 3 10-06 x2 + 0.0742 x – 7.5725, R2 = 0.9982; σz, for D atmospheric stability condition σz = -3 10-17 x4 + 7 10-12 x3 – 5 10-07 x2 + 0,0183 x + 12.887, R2 = 0.9965; σz, for E atmospheric stability condition σz = -1 10-17x4 + 3 10-12 x3 – 3 10-07 x2 + 0.0093 x + 11.559, R2 = 0.9899; σz, for F atmospheric stability condition σz = -1 10-17 x4 + 2 10-12 x3 – 2 10-07x2 + 0.0062 x + 6.3454, R2 = 0.9868. A, B, C D, E, F atmospheric stability categories that are selected based on meteorological conditions which are described in Table 1. where A is high unstable; B is medium unstable; C is low unstable; D neutral; E low stable and F very stable type of atmospheric stability. Source: [15].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 3:
457
σy, σz dispersion coefficients dependent on x distance between the source of air pollutant and the receptor location. Source: [15].
Table 1:
Categories A, B, C, D, E, F of atmospheric stability.
Wind velocity at 10m height from G.L. (m/s) >2
High solar radiation during day
Middle solar radiation during day
Low solar radiation during day
Cloudiness of sky, n, during night, covered (n > 4/8)
Cloudiness of sky, n, during night, clear (n < 3/8)
A
A-B
B
E
F
2-3 3-5
A-B B
B B-C
C C
E D
F E
5-6 >6
C C
C-D D
D D
D D
D D
An application of equations (4) and (5) is given below. A CO emission is examined for x = 600 m, y = 60 m distances from landfill boundary to a nearby industrial land use area with CO 6615.56 µg/s air pollutant emission and applying equations (4) and (5) for D atmospheric stability category, H = 15 m the height difference from the source of air-pollutant to the examining location and wind velocity 5.5 m/sec at 10m height above (G.L.), it yields 0.307 µg/m3 at x = 600 m distance from the source on x axis and 0.126 µg/m3 at y = 60 m transverse distance to x axis. The results which were found above both are under the health and safety limits for a human working on that location avoiding any WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
458 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI epidemiologic public health effect (limit<10 mg/m3 in 8-hour base) [4, 11, 14, 15]. The latter calculated emissions should be evaluated with any other combined produced CO emissions from any surrounded anthropogenic activities, taking the relative measures so as to minimise any associated environmental pollution to the ecosystems. Thresholds maps of air pollutants, for the examining case study, could be determined based on equations (4) and (5) evaluating the relative available spatial data; respective probable environmental impacts and the final lining of landfill boundaries on the ground surface and optimum lining of surrounded traffic and transport systems so as to protect the surrounded ecosystems and civic, agricultural zones. However, there could be lined a dense monitoring network on the particular examining landfill emissions’ threshold contours taking frequent samples in time and evaluating the measurements for additional risk assessments and probable lining of bioremediation works. Moreover, an optimum solution could be given based on detailed socioeconomic data, and annual population trends, utilising GIS, GPS database system analysis, operational research or other digital geographical tools for the lining of safe waste vehicles’ routes for waste shipment from the source to landfill site in order to minimise fuel consumption and air pollutants emissions, protecting the nearby ecosystems [13,17,18].
4
Results and discussion
The comprehensive simulation numerical models, which have been validated and they are robust, based on field measurements of experimental sites like Mid Auchencarroch one and on the bibliographical sources, should be used as diagnostic tools as it was described above. The uses of dynamic models, like SimGasRisk, are necessary so as to model and analyse biomass biodegradation for efficient bioreactor designs and control of particular produced emissions. During the lining of landfill boundaries should be taken into account the surrounded existing areas of ecosystems, land uses and other anthropogenic activities that are taking place there. The associated risk assessment spatial analysis could give a solution to the latter problem analysing the particular factors and parameters that affect on it. Hence the thresholds of migrated landfill gas could be calculated by the solution of the diffusion-advection problem, which is described by the following equation (6).
∂C ∂ 2C ∂C R = D 2 −V ∂t ∂x ∂x where C x t D V R
gas concentration by volume the distance along the migration pathway (m) is time (s) the diffusion coefficient (m2/s) velocity (m/s) the retardation factor
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
(6)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
459
Moreover, an estimation has been made for the calculation of lateral distance of biogas migration and probable explosions next to landfill boundaries, assuming that the threshold of 0.1 biogas concentration by volume will take place in 6 years since gas was migrated from landfill boundaries and taking constant the values of the advection velocity and diffusion coefficient. The retardation factor describes the interaction of ground with biogas and according to the bibliography, the retardation factor R equals to 1, in the case of landfill gas flow in the soil porous media, for other cases several experiments should be made [19]. However, the biogas diffusion coefficient D in the porous medium is related to the porosity Φ of the porous medium and to the gas diffusion of the biogas in air Do = 1.7 10-5 (m2/s), by the following equation (7) [21]:
D = Φ1.33 Do
(7)
Hence, according to the above, the solution of equation (6) yields the investigated distance, which is 33m, combining equations (6) and (7) for the next data V = 1.5 10-7 (m/s), R = 1 and D = 3 10-6 (m2/s) for Φ = 0.3 porosity of soil, Do = 1.7 10-5 (m2/s). The latter calculation is indicative for the above data and it should be verified by the particular characteristics of the proposed landfill sites’ locations at the examining areas and in collaboration with the Local Authorities. However, below is proposed a sustainable solution for the waste collection on Zakynthos Island. Two waste collection transfer stations should be located next to Katastarion and Romereon locations so as to minimise waste collection costs, based on the road network and the geographical distribution among the examining Municipalities on Zakynthos Island. Several alternative solutions could be made for the waste collection routes, in collaboration with Local Authorities, taking into account particular variations of demographic elements in time and respective municipalities’ needs during the peak period of holiday season, where there is big waste production. The examining costs could be minimised by the consumption of natural gas as green fuel for the waste collection vehicles (after treatment and upgrade of collected biogas) instead of oil unsustainable fuel.
5
Conclusions
More socioeconomic data and their trends in time should be collected in detail, especially during summer season or other holiday peak seasons, so as to determine the necessities for recycling centres’ operation; particular characteristics should be taken into account for an integrated solid waste management i.e. exact location of recycled bins in relation to socioeconomic data. Also, development of sustainable sequential batch bioreactors and simulation numerical models of biomass biodegradation are useful not only to make accurate estimations of biomass emissions but also to diagnose current sites or any proposed planning scenarios. MACH’s monitoring experimental data and its waste biodegradation simulation show that batch anaerobic bioreactor WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
460 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI design is sustainable and its sustainable principles should be applied at any landfill site so as to be stabilised in short time. Moreover, the use of efficient diagnostic spatial analysis tools is necessary so as to take the relative right pollution confrontation measures in time. According to the above will be avoided any probable environmental pollution by long term hazardous emissions in order to protect the ecosystems and our public health. More field data and case studies are necessary so that optimise landfill design principles. This will cause control of pollutants protecting the ecosystems, public health and exploitation of emissions helping local economy. The installation of a monitoring network next to landfill boundaries or at other selected critical locations would be useful so as to provide available data for: modelling waste input characteristics; spatial analysis of pollutants’ behaviour in time for a given topography; spatial risk management; communication with the responsible Local Authorities; collect necessary data for efficient lining of proper rehabilitation works; maintenance design in time and safe control-confrontation of landfill emissions. According the above, there will be an effective protection of any surrounded ecosystems on Zakynthos Island so as to minimise any probable associated risks from the relative sources of pollution.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Dr. Louise de Rome (ETSU), U.K. Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) and U.K. Environment Agency (EA) for their support of the Mid Auchencarroch experimental project. The conclusions expressed herein represent the findings of the authors and are based on their expertise and experience in this topic area and their findings in the professional literature. It does not necessarily represent the views of EA, or of the participants in the Mid Auchencarroch Experimental Project.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
[6]
D.O.E., Waste Management Paper No 27, Landfill Gas, HMSO, UK, 1989. D.O.E., Making Waste Work, White Paper, HMSO, London, UK, 1995. D.O.E., A guide to risk assessment and risk management for environmental protection, HMSO, London, UK, 1995. Friis, R.H., Sellers, T.A., Epidemiology for Public Health Practice, Jones and Bartlett Publishers, 2004. Koliopoulos, T., Koliopoulou, G., Evaluation of Iso-Butyric Acid and Acetic Acid in landfill Leachate Emissions - Mid Auchencarroch Experimental Design, Asian Journal of Chemistry, vol. 20, (in press), 2008. Koliopoulos, T., Koliopoulou, G., Evaluating Landfill Chemical Emissions - Mid Auchencarroch Experimental Design, Asian Journal of Chemistry, 19(5), pp. 3911-3917, 2007.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[7]
[8] [9]
[10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21]
461
Koliopoulos, T., Koliopoulou, G., Evaluating Biomass Temperature vs Biodegradation for Environmental Impact Minimisation: Mid Auchencarroch Experimental Landfill, Asian J. Exp. Sci., 21(1), pp. 4353, 2007. Koliopoulos, T., Koliopoulou, G., Controlling Landfill Emissions for Environmental Protection: Mid Auchencarroch Experimental Project, Asian J. Exp. Sci., 20(2), pp. 233-242, 2006. Koliopoulos, T., Fleming, G., Modelling the biodegradation of treated and untreated waste and R.A. of LFG emissions – SimGasRisk, pp.625-628, Proc. of European Symposium on Environmental Biotechnology, (ESEB), ed. W. Verstraete, Taylor & Francis, Balkema Publishers, Oostende, Belgium, 2004. KPE of Zakynthos, Information Material, Lithakias of Zakynthos, 2002. Mackenzie, D., Cornwell, D., Introduction to Environmental Engineering, McGraw Hill, USA, 1998. Turner, D.B., Workbook of Atmospheric Dispersion Estimates, HEW, Washington D.C., USA, 1969. Mpotsari, H., Operational Research, Foto Print Pubs., Athens, 1981. Museum of D. Solomos and A. Kalvos, Inform. Material, Zakynthos, 2006. Municipalities’ Association of Zakynthos Island, Inform. Material, 2005. National Marine Park of Zakynthos, Inform. Material, Zakynthos, 2005. O.E.C.D, Road Safety Principles and Models: Review of Descriptive, Predictive Risk and Accident Consequence Models, Paris, 1997. O.E.C.D, Transport et Environment, Paris, 1988. Perfecture of Zakynthos, Information Material, Zakynthos, Greece, 2006. Tchobanoglous, G., Theisen, H., Vigil, S. Integrated Solid Waste Management, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, USA, 1993. Williams, G., Ward, R., Noy, D. Dynamics of landfill gas migration in unconsolidated sands, Waste Manage Res, 17, pp. 327-342, 1999.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
463
The environmental consequences of implementation of a council directive on landfill of waste in Lithuania G. Denafas Department of Environmental Engineering, Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania
Abstract While establishing feasibilities for municipal waste management system development in Lithuania, the generation of municipal waste management fractions have been forecast, using a LCA-IWM prognostic tool. Separate collection and treatment of 22% of biodegradable waste from the total biodegradable waste amount has been proposed, based on this forecast. The next steps of the Lithuanian Municipal Waste Management System development may be the arrangement of some environmentally friendly mixed municipal waste incineration plants. Such scenarios fully satisfy the requirements of the Council Directive on Landfill of Waste and Lithuanian State Strategic Waste Management Plan concerning the reduction of landfilled biodegradable waste. The assessment of these scenarios of environmental consequences shows that in the Lithuanian municipal waste management system the emissions of greenhouse gas, human toxicity and photo-oxidants formation would be reduced significantly after the decrease in biodegradable waste landfilling. However, due to biogas and mixed municipal waste incineration the acidification and eutrophication would be increased visibly. Keywords: municipal waste, landfilling, biodegradable waste, incineration, greenhouse gas, human toxicity, acidification, eutrophication.
1
Introduction
The goal of Council Directive 1999/31/EB on landfill of waste is: to schedule the means, order and guidelines which would help to prevent or highly reduce the negative environmental impact, especially the pollution of surface water, WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070431
464 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI groundwater, soil and air, the global environment, including the greenhouse effect and the hazard to humans emerging from landfills during waste disposal and periods of landfill exploitation by applying the strong demands for waste and landfills. The minimising strategy may secure the reduction of biodegradable waste landfilling by composting and biogas, and production, material and energy recycling may achieve 75% from the total biodegradable waste mass generated in 1995 m [3]. Lithuania, as a new EU member-country, implements the Council Directive on Landfill of Waste step-by step. The State Strategic Waste Management Plan regulates that in 2010 the amount of landfilled biodegradable waste may not exceed 75% of that in 2000; the landfilled amount of biodegradable waste in 2013 – 50%, and in 2020 – 35%. [5] Lithuanian waste management regions practically match Lithuanian counties. Thus, Lithuania is divided into 10 waste management regions: Vilnius, Kaunas, Alytus, Marijampole, Utena, Panevezys, Siauliai, Telsiai, Taurage and Klaipeda (Figure 1). Modern regional landfills with leachate treatment and landfill gas collection systems are arranged for every region, according to EU requirements [6].
Figure 1:
Waste management regions in Lithuania.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
2
465
Waste generation and management – forecasts and scenarios
The forecasts of municipal solid waste generation and fractions collection for Lithuania, according to the GDP average growing scenario till 2020, had been prepared by the LCA-IWM prognostic tool [1] (Figure 2) and are presented in Figure 3.
Figure 2:
Initial screen of the LCA-IWM Waste Prognostic Tool [1]. Municipal waste fractions collection forecasts
1800000
1600000
1400000
1200000 Mixed waste Green waste Kitchen waste Plastics and composites Metal Glas Paper and cardboard
t
1000000
800000
600000
400000
200000
0 2005
Figure 3:
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Municipal waste collection forecast for Lithuania in the period of 2005 – 2020.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
466 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI If the secondary raw material collection system will is implemented from 2007, paper, cardboard, glass and plastics collection efficiency will increase. From 2010, after the implementation of the above mentioned system, the collection of biodegradable waste, predominantly consisting of kitchen waste, will be increased significantly too, and the part consisting of garden waste would remain mainly like that in 2006. During the entire investigated period the mixed municipal waste will be predominant between all collected fractions because the possible achievement of higher collection rate is undetermined. 2.1 Forecasted composition of mixed municipal waste Considering the planned separate collection of waste fractions, the composition of mixed municipal waste may vary according to the scheme, presented in Figure 4. The higher content of biodegradable fractions especially causes the higher environmental impact by implementing various waste treatment and disposal technologies [3]. Mixed municipal waste content forecasts 100%
80%
Other unburnable Other burnable Biodegradable waste Plastics and composites Metal Glas Paper and cardboard
60%
40%
20%
0% 2005
2006
Figure 4:
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Forecast of mixed municipal waste composition for Lithuania in the period of 2005 – 2020.
2.2 Proposed waste management system development scenarios During the Lithuanian municipal waste management system subsequent development feasibility studies, possible alternative scenarios for waste management regions had been formulated: • Scenario 1. The separate collection of biodegradable waste and its anaerobic digestion with biogas production would be started from 2010,
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
467
and the remaining mixed municipal waste without separately collected biodegradable waste would be landfilled in the regional landfills; • Scenario 2. The separate collection of biodegradable waste and its anaerobic digestion with biogas production would be started from 2010, the incineration of mixed municipal waste for Vilnius, Utena, Kaunas, Alytus and Marijampole regions would be started from 2013, for Klaipeda, Telsiai and Taurage regions – from 2020; • Scenario 3. The separate collection of biodegradable waste and its anaerobic digestion with biogas production would be started from 2010, the incineration of mixed municipal waste for all regions except Siauliai and Panevezys regions would be started from 2013; • Scenario 4. The separate collection of biodegradable waste and its anaerobic digestion with biogas production would be started from 2010, the incineration of mixed municipal waste for all regions would be started from 2013; Scenarios 2, 3, and 4 would completely satisfy the demands of Lithuanian State Strategy Waste Management Plan. Scenario 1 would satisfy this plan only for 2010.
3
Possible environmental consequences
The environmental consequences of the proposed municipal waste management scenarios have been assessed. Such indicators as greenhouse gas emissions, human toxicity, photo-oxidant formation, acidity and eutrophication have been evaluated. The units for the greenhouse gas emissions indicator are given as CO2 equivalents, i.e. for human toxicity – 1,4 dichlorbenzene equivalents, for acidity – SO2 equivalents, for eutrophication – PO43- equivalents. The assessment has been performed using the algorithmic system of LCA-IWM assessment model [1, 2] (Figure 5). It is specially established for environmental impact assessment in the various municipal waste management processes. 3.1 Greenhouse gas emissions The changes of greenhouse gas emissions from Lithuanian municipal waste management system in the cases of all the above mentioned waste management scenarios are presented in Figure 6. Due to the started utilisation of landfill gases (with 60% methane – one of the main greenhouse gases) their emissions by 2010 may decrease very significantly. At 2013, when the incineration of mixed municipal waste would start, the greenhouse gas emissions would be decreased. Additionally, these emissions will be diminished due to a corresponding decrease of landfilled biodegradable fractions of mixed municipal waste, (it should be noted that landfill gas utilisation doesn’t reduce the methane emissions completely). The influence of separately collected biodegradable waste treatment would be insignificant.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
468 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 5:
LCA-IWM Assessment Tool initial screen [1,2].
Greenhouse gas emissions forecasts in the Lithuanian MSW system
900000
800000
700000
t CO2 equ.
600000 Scenario 0 Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3 Current situation
500000
400000
300000
200000
100000
0 2005
Figure 6:
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
The tendencies of greenhouse gas emissions caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system during current and forecasted period till 2020.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
469
3.2 Human toxicity The possible changes of human toxicity causing emissions in the Lithuanian municipal waste management system are presented in Figure 7. Human toxicity may increase significantly in 2010 due to the start of incineration of landfill gases. Such assessment doesn’t show the real risk for the environment – the calculation of pollutant’s dispersions disproves it. Human toxicity, after 2013 started incineration of mixed municipal waste, would be decreased both due to the reduction of landfill gas emissions and reduction of leachate formation. It should be noted that the whole leachate amount could not be collected and treated. After the comparison of different scenarios we see that where the more mixed municipal waste incineration would be implemented the human toxicity would be reduced. The emissions from incineration plants would not impact on human toxicity due to the exhaust gas treatment devices.
Human toxicity caused by Lithuanian MSW system
70000
60000
t 1,4-dichlorbenzene equ.
50000
Current situation Scenario 0 Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3
40000
30000
20000
10000
0 2005
Figure 7:
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
The tendencies of changes of human toxicity indicator caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system during current and forecasted periods till 2020.
3.3 Environment acidification Figure 8 shows the possible changes of environmental acidification caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system in the case of all the mentioned scenarios. These changes are presented only from 2010 when incineration of landfill gas and biogas from anaerobic biodegradable waste treatment starts. During the incineration acidic pollutants, mostly nitrogen oxides, would be WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
470 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI emitted. From 2013, after the start of mixed municipal waste incineration, the environmental acidity would increase additionally due to the increased emissions of the same nitrogen oxides. So, not until 2010 would the Lithuanian municipal waste management system have a direct influence to environmental acidification. Acidification caused by Lithuanian MSW system 390 380 370 360 350
t SO2 equ.
340 330
Scenario 0 Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3
320 310 300 290 280 270 260 250 2010
Figure 8:
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
The tendencies of changes of acidification caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system during the forecasted period till 2020.
3.4 Eutrophication Figure 9 shows the possible changes of eutrophication caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system for all the mentioned scenarios. If the mixed municipal waste disposal starts from 2007 in the regional landfills with modern systems of leachate collection and treatment, the eutrophication level caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system would decrease significantly. However from 2010 and from 2013, due to the increase of the above mentioned nitrogen oxide emissions, the corresponding increase of eutrophication would be observed.
4 Summary and conclusions Municipal waste generation forecasts, obtained by LCA-IWM forecasting model show, that in the Lithuanian waste management system mixed municipal waste with significant bio-waste content will be dominating until 2020, irrespective of increased separate collection of secondary raw-materials and biodegradable fraction.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
471
Eutrophication caused by Lithuanian MSW system
100
t PO4 equ.
80
Current situation Scenario 0 Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3
60
40
20
0 2005
Figure 9:
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
The tendencies of changes of eutrophication caused by Lithuanian municipal waste management system during the forecasted period till 2020.
Regarding the requirements of the Council Directive on Landfill of Waste, Lithuanian State Strategic Waste Management Plan and 10 Lithuanian waste management regions with modern regional landfills, four different municipal waste management scenarios were formulated and corresponding environmental impact assessment using the LCA-IWM assessment tool had been performed. The assessment results show that: landfill gas recovery and energetically useful incineration system would reduce the greenhouse gas emissions 2.5 times, however the human toxicity due to this incineration would increase twofold; incineration of mixed municipal waste (with appropriate gas cleaning technologies) would help to avoid the major part of greenhouse gas emissions and human toxicity formed from the same landfilled waste amount; the implementation of new waste treatment and disposal technologies like landfilling with landfill gas use, anaerobic digestion of bio-waste with biogas incineration and mixed waste incineration in the Lithuanian waste management system would cause the growth of environmental acidification, mostly caused by emitted nitrogen oxides; though an eutrophication would be reduced 5 times by using modern leachate treatment facilities in the regional landfills, however the incineration of landfill gas and mixed solid waste would increase it 4-5 times due to the above mentioned nitrogen oxides emissions;
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
472 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI -
in comparison with common Lithuanian environmental impact dimensions, increased before mentioned negative environmental impact would not achieve 10%, so the implementation of both landfill gas and waste incineration may not be rejected.
Acknowledgements The performed research was partially funded by Cohesion foundation and Lithuanian government.
References [1]
[2]
[3]
[4] [5] [6]
den Boer, E., den Boer, J. & Jager, J., Waste management planning and optimisation. Handbook for municipal waste prognosis and sustainability assessment of waste management systems, ibidem-Verlag: Stuttgart, pp. 189-274, 2005. den Boer, E., den Boer, J. & Jager, J., The Use of the LCA-IWM Tool to Assess the Sustainability of Waste Minimisation. Waste matters. Integrating views. Proceedings of the 2nd BOKU Waste Conference, ed. P. Lechner, Facultas Verlags- und Buchhandels AG, Vienna, p.p. 293-302, 2007. Deliverable Report on D2.1: Draft Waste Generation Prognostic Model (Work package 2). The Use of Life Cycle Assesment Tools for the Development of Inrtegrated Waste Management Strategies for Cities and Regions with Rapid Growing Economies. LCA-IWM. – Vienna, 30.11.2003 Council Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste Resolution of the Lithuanian Republic Government No. 519 of 12 April 2002 “Concerning the Approval of the National Strategic Waste Management Plan“ Vilnius County Regional Waste Management Plan 2006-2016. Environmental Projects Management Agency, Ministry of Environment, Republic of Lithuania, 2006
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
473
Transformations in the solid and liquid phase at aqueous carbonization of oil shale ash M. Uibu, A. Trikkel & R. Kuusik Tallinn University of Technology, Laboratory of Inorganic Materials, Ehitajate tee 5, Tallinn, Estonia
Abstract The oil shale based energy sector of the Republic of Estonia is related to huge waste flows - about 5 million tons of waste ash is landfilled annually by circulating in the system tens of millions of cubic meters of transportation water saturated with different salts. Due to the distinctiveness of oil shale, the waste ash is characterized by heterogeneous and complicated mineral composition. Ash contains, depending on combustion technology (currently both pulverized firing and circulated fluidized bed combustion are used), 10–20% of free lime as the most active compound. Contacting free lime with water leads to elevated pH values (pH>13) and makes landfilling of this ash by hydraulic transportation highly problematic. It has been shown that the negative environmental impact of high alkalinity of these flows could be equilibrated by using CO2 from flue gases as a neutralizing agent. At the same time the emission of CO2 is diminished. Laboratory batch tests showed that by treating ash – water suspension with CO2-containing flue gases, the most of the free CaO can be reduced to an acceptable level. Some aspects of processes deceleration during wet carbonization of ash have been elaborated. Part of the free CaO present is not accessible due to low porosity and the formation of reaction products on the surface of ash particles. Also, lowering the pH of carbonized ash suspension influences the composition of the liquid phase by increasing leaching of some of the ash components. The behaviour of CaSO4 as one of the dominant Ca-compounds in ash has been elaborated. Keywords: CO2 mineralization, waste oil shale ash.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070441
474 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Extensive usage of low-grade solid fuels in the world energy production is accompanied by a variety of problems, including emission of greenhouse gases and safe deposition/utilization of solid wastes. Reducing CO2 emissions is an actual problem, being recognized and investigated by numerous research groups all over the world. One of the options is CO2 sequestration by mineral carbonation, considering both natural minerals (O`Connor and Dahlin, [1], Haywood et al., [2]) and alkali wastes (Teir et al., [3], Huijgen et al., [4], Anthony et al., [5], Kuusik et al., [6]) as CO2 sorbents. The other part of the problem is related to the stabilization and safe landfilling of alkaline wastes. Carbonization has been recognized to be an important weathering process affecting alkaline waste materials such as ashes from power plants (Soong et al., [7]; Back et al., [8]; Reddy et al., [9]), and MSWI bottom ash (Meima et al., [10], Ecke, [11]). The above-mentioned problems concern also the Republic of Estonia, whose energy sector is predominantly (up to 67%) based on local low-grade fossil fuel – Estonian oil shale. Compared with other fossil fuels, oil shale contains more mineral CO2 in the form of limestone and dolomite. During combustion of oil shale, high temperatures drive off CO2 from carbonate minerals and forming ash contains considerable amounts of Ca and Mg oxides (15-30%), which in certain conditions can be the binders of CO2. Since 1959 the main combustion technology of oil shale has been pulverized firing (PF); in 2004 a more suitable combustion method for low calorific fuel – the circulating fluidized bed combustion (CFBC) was also implemented. The differences between the temperature levels (higher in PF boilers and lower in CFBC boilers) for the new and old boilers influence the phase and chemical composition, as well as the surface characteristics and reactivity of ashes. The objective of this paper is to elaborate the mechanisms of processes deceleration and changes in leaching of some of the Ca compounds during wet carbonization of ashes at ambient conditions.
2
Materials and methods
Initial samples of ash were collected from different points of the ash-separation systems of CFBC and PF boilers at the Estonian Thermal Power Plant. The CFBC ash samples used for the research were named and marked as follows: intrex ash (CFBC/INT), economizer ash (CFBC/ECO), electrostatic precipitator ash – 1st field (CFBC/ESPA1). The PF ashes used were bottom ash (PF/BA), cyclone ash (PF/CA) and electrostatic precipitator ash – 1st field (PF/ESPA1). All ash samples were analyzed using chemical, grain-size and quantitative XRD methods, as well as SEM and BET methods (ash properties are discussed in more detail in Kuusik et al., [12]). XRD data was collected in powdered unoriented preparations with a Dron-3M diffractometer using Ni-filtered Cu-Kα radiation. Digitally registered diffractograms were measured within the range of 2–50º 2θ, with 0.03º 2θ step size and 3 s counting time. The diffractograms were analyzed with the code Siroquant using full-profile Rietveld analysis. A scanning WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
475
electron microscope Jeol JSM-8404 was used for surface observations and specific surface area (SSA) was determined with a BET–method at Sorptometer KELVIN 1042 (Costech Microanalytical SC). Porosity measurements were carried out with the high pressure Hg intrusion method with a porosimeter Quantachrome AutoScan-33 (pressure range 0.1-227 MPa, pore diameter range 6.5-1500 nm). The carbonization of aqueous ash suspensions with model gas, whose composition (10% CO2 and 90% air) simulated CO2 content in flue gases formed at oil shale combustion, was carried out in an absorber (diameter 55 mm, water column height 60 mm) equipped with a magnetic stirrer for achieving a better interfacial contact and a sintered glass gas distributor (pore diameter 100 µm). Distilled water or ash transportation water (TDS=7.79 g/l, Ca2+-ions previously precipitated) were used for preparing the suspensions. The solid/liquid ratio was 1/10. Experiments were carried out at room temperature under atmospheric pressure until the suspension reached a definite value of pH (10; 9; 8.5). After carbonization, the suspension was filtered and solid residue dehumidified at 105 0C; in the solid residue free CaO content and CO2 were determined. SSA and pore distribution measurements were performed for investigation of the deceleration mechanism. In order to elaborate leaching characteristics, ash (CFBC ash, CaOfree=8.0% and CaSO4=12.75%) or model mixtures (CaO and CaSO4 of analytical grade) were mixed with water. The solid/liquid ratio was 1/10 in the case of ash. For the model system the amounts of CaO and CaSO4 were calculated based on the actual contents in ash. Contents of Ca2+, Mg2+, SO42- (Spectrophotometer Spectrodirect, Lovibond Water Testing) and alkalinity were determined in the liquid phase to study leaching.
3
Results and discussion
3.1 Characterization of oil shale ashes formed at industrial scale boilers Reactivity of waste ashes towards CO2 was estimated by their chemical and phase composition (Tables 1, 2) as well as by physical structure of ash particles (Kuusik et al., [12]). XRD analysis indicated that, as compared to PF ashes, the CFBC ashes contain more calcite (4.0–14.6 and 2.0–5.7%, respectively) and less free lime (10.8–19.9 and 26.5–29.3%, respectively). Mg was found in both cases mainly as periclase (MgO). In CFBC ashes, silica compounds are mainly presented by quartz (up to 17.1%) and orthoclase-type K-feldspar (up to 12.5%), while PF ashes contain noticeably more secondary silicate – belite (up to 15.9%) and merwinite (up to 13.2%). Relatively higher content of secondary silicates can be explained by significantly higher temperatures (1250–14000C) used in PF boilers, which leads to the formation of melted phase initiating the reactions between free CaO and clinker minerals. Comparison of SEM photos of ash samples shows that particles of CFBC ashes formed at moderate temperatures (750–800OC) are characterized by an irregular shape as well as by a porous and uneven surface (Fig. 1a). The glassy
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
476 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 1:
Chemical composition and physical properties of CFBC and PF ashes. CFBC/ INT 47.59 13.65 18.87 1.23 2.61
CaOtotal,% MgOtotal.% CaOfree, % CO2, % SSA, m2/g Total intruded 0.32 volume, cm3/g dmean,µm 95
Table 2:
CFBC/ ECO 32.84 9.50 10.40 5.48 6.89
CFBC/ ESPA1 29.52 8.33 8.45 4.60 8.00
PF/BA
PF/CA
50.75 15.19 24.84 2.75 1.75
49.39 14.19 22.52 0.70 0.36
PF/ ESPA1 36.08 11.26 13.56 1.16 0.61
0.39
0.62
0.23
0.13
0.34
27
25
115
48
24
Mineral composition of CFBC and PF ashes, %.
Minerals
CFBC/ CFBC/ CFBC/ PF/BA PF/CA PF/ INT ECO ESPA1 ESPA1
Quartz SiO2 OrthoclaseKAlSi3O8 Albite NaAlSi3O8
5.6 2.7 2.7
17.1 9.4
16.8 12.5
Illite+Illite-Smectite Na,Kx(Al,Mg)2Si4O10(OH)2⋅H2O
3.1
11.2
13.8
7.3 5.2 1.4 7.0 3.6 29.9 0.8 19.9 4.0
5.8 3.0 2.0 3.8 1.6 11.1 0.5 13.3 14.6 0.8 0.7 3.6 1.9
5.3 3.7 2.3 2.7 1.2 9.5
13.5 9.4 2.3 7.9 17.8 5.4
15.9 13.2 2.2 8.7 5.8 5.4
12.3 6.5 2.8 8.5 3.3 16.8
10.8 13.5
26.5 5.7
29.3 2.5
28.1 2.0
4.3 3.6
0.9 0.9
3.1 1.1 1.6
1.0 1.6 0.8
Belite Ca2SiO4 Merwinite Ca3Mg(SiO4)2 Tricalcium aluminate 3CaO.Al2O3
Periclase MgO Melilite (Ca,Na)2(Mg,Al)(Si,Al)3O7 Anhydrite CaSO4 Gypsum CaSO4⋅2H2O Lime CaO Calcite CaCO3 Aragonite CaCO3 Portlandite Ca(OH)2 Hematite Fe2O3 Pseudowollastonite CaSiO3
2.1 2.1 1.8
3.1 6.6
3.3 1.7
12.0 3.8
6.1
b)
a) Figure 1:
SEM pictures of CFBC (a-CFBC/ESPA1) and PF ashes (b-PF/CA), magnification 2000×.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
477
phase is not formed. In the case of PF ashes, melting significantly affects the particle shape and surface properties: the particles are characterized by a regular spherical shape with a smooth surface (Fig. 1b). BET measurements (Table 1) showed significant differences in the physical structure of CFBC and PF ashes – depending on ash type, the differences in SSA were up to a factor of ten. While SSA of CFBC ashes can reach 8.00 m2/g, the SSA of PF ashes is within 0.36–1.75 m2/g, which is caused by more intensive sintering of PF ashes at high boiler temperatures. 3.2 Transformations in the heterogeneous system CO2 - ash - water: changes in the structure of ash particles Laboratory batch tests (Table 3) showed that as compared to PF ashes, CFBC ash can be carbonized more deeply with lowering the content of free lime below 1%. In the case of PF ashes as less-porous materials, some of the free CaO present is not accessible, especially with PF/CA, which has the lowest porosity. Electrostatic precipitator ashes are most easily carbonized due to their finer fractional composition (Table 1). Ash transportation water characterized by a high concentration of dissolved salts also inhibits wet carbonization of ash. If ash transportation water was used for preparing the ash suspensions, the carbonization process stopped even earlier and most of the free CaO (8.3% Abs.) remained unreacted. Pore distribution analysis of initial ashes showed that most of the pore volume of CFBC ashes (CFBC/ESPA1) is contributed by pores in the size range of 0.030.007 µm and 0.3-0.1 µm (Fig. 3a) as for PF ashes (PF/CA) the dominating pore diameter is considerably smaller – below 0.01 µm. Thereby, the PF ashes are expected to be more extensively influenced by the formation of reaction products on the surface of particles and pore plugging, which could lower mass transfer rates. The changes in porosity and pore distribution of ashes at different stages of processing were analyzed to elaborate the deceleration mechanism taking place during the carbonization process. During treatment, while ash containing free CaO went through hydration, leaching and carbonization processes, both the specific surface area and total intruded volume (TIV) of ash increased (Table 3, Fig. 2) as a contribution from reaction products. The deepness of carbonization did not influence noticeably the value of TIV (0.92-0.98 cm3/g in the case of CFBC/ESPA1) ashes. The pore distribution analysis showed that the average pore diameter of hydrated and leached ashes was in the range of 0.007-0.04 µm (Fig. 3). Carbonized ashes had average pore diameter in the ranges of 0.007-0.03 µm and 0.08-0.3µm. At deeper carbonization (pH=8.5) in the case of PF ashes (PF/CA) the amount of bigger pores (pore diameter in the range of 0.08-0.3 µm) and the value of TIV started to decline. However, there were no remarkable differences in pore size distribution of ashes carbonized up to definite pH level (Figure 3c). It seems that in the case of PF ashes as almost nonporous materials, the reaction products formed hinder
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
478 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Table 3: Ash CFBC/ INT
Initial pH=10 pH=9 pH=8.5 Initial pH=10 pH=9 pH=8.5 Initial pH=10 pH=9 pH=8.5 Initial pH=10 pH=9 pH=8.5 Initial pH=10 pH=9 pH=8.5 * pH=10 * pH=8.5 Initial pH=10 pH=9 pH=8.5
CFBC/ ECO
CFBC/ ESPA1
PF/BA
PF/CA
PF/ ESPA1
Characterization of initial and carbonized ashes. CaOfree, % 18.87 1.48 1.13 0.94 10.4 1.03 0.5 0.42 8.45 0.84 0.33 0.38 24.84 2.07 2.14 1.57 22.52 4.25 3.20 3.24 8.27 8.13 13.56 1.53 0.58 0.40
SSA,m2/g 2.61 16.54 13.05 20.56 6.89 15.35 14.76 15.02 8.00 17.16 15.00 15.88 1.75 9.58 10.27 13.18 0.36 6.26 11.27 7.20 6.16 5.01 0.61 10.71 13.20 11.45
CO2,% 1.23 13.08 13.5 15.14 5.48 11.84 13.1 13.2 4.60 10.75 11.72 12.88 2.75 13.00 15.93 17.12 0.7 10.88 13.89 13.16 10.24 10.13 1.16 9.66 11.91 12.15
TIV, cm3/g 0.32 0.73 0.63 0.72 0.39 0.64 0.63 0.57 0.62 0.98 0.92 0.94 0.23 0.45 0.56 0.51 0.13 0.32 0.63 0.32 0.22 0.22 0.34 0.71 0.91 0.87
*Ash transportation water was used for preparing suspension. CFBC/INT
CFBC/ECO
1
(a)
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Initial
Figure 2:
Hydr. Leach. Carb.
Carb.
Carb.
pH10
pH9
pH8.5
Total intruded volume, cm 3/g
Total intruded volume, cm 3/g
CFBC/ESPA1 1.2
1.2 1
PF/BA
PF/CA
PF/ESPA1
PF/CA*
(b)
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Initial
Hydr. Leach. Carb.
Carb.
Carb.
pH10
pH9
pH8.5
Changes in total porosity of (a) CFBC and (b) PF ashes during different stages of carbonization.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
479
2.5
a)
PF/CA initial ash
2.0
CFBC/ESPA1 initial ash
dV(d)
1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 1
0.1
0.01
0.001
5.0
b)
CFBC/ESPA1 hydrated
4.0
CFBC/ESPA1 CaO leached out
dV(d)
3.0 2.0
PF/CA CaO leached out
1.0
PF/CA hydrated
0.0 1
0.1
0.01
0.001
2.5 c)
CFBC/ESPA1 carbonised pH 9
2.0 dV(d)
1.5
PF/CA carbonised pH9
PF/CA carbonised pH 8.5 PF/CA carbonised* pH 9
1.0 0.5 0.0 1
Figure 3:
0.1 0.01 Pore diameter, micrometers
0.001
Changes in pore size distribution at hydration, leaching and carbonization of ashes (* - aqueous carbonization process carried out in ash transportation water).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
480 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Ca
Mg
Si
C
Figure 4:
SEM and EDAX analysis of initial ash (PF/CA) and carbonized ash (on left).
reactions with CaO. It was verified also by SEM and EDAX linescan analysis that carbonized particles were covered with a perceptible layer of CaCO3 (Fig. 4). Also, as the initial ash particles contain noticeable amounts of Ca-silicates, which participate at lower pH in carbonization reactions (Kuusik, et al., [13]), the SiO2 released can block the pores of ash particles. 3.3 Transformations in the heterogeneous system CO2 - ash - water: leaching of CaO and CaSO4 at different pH levels Ashes contain considerable amounts of free CaO (8-25%) and CaSO4 (5-30%) (Tables 1, 2) which significantly influence the composition of the liquid phase while contacted with water: the liquid phase becomes deeply alkaline (pH>12) and saturated with Ca2+ and SO42- ions. Laboratory experiments showed that the content of Ca2+ decreased significantly during carbonization due to the formation of more stable CaCO3 (Fig. 5). Also, the content of SO42- decreased to some extent (1190 and 847 mg/l, respectively) indicating possible co-precipitation of CaSO4. At deeper carbonization to pH<8 the concentrations of Ca2+ and SO42started to rise again (to 480 and 1107 mg/l, respectively). The amount of Mg2+ ions in the solution became evident and bicarbonate ions appeared. Experiments with model systems (CaSO4-CaO - H2O - CO2) confirmed the same tendencies. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Ca2+, Mg2+, SO42-, mg/l
2000
Ca2+, (Ash)
1600
SO42-, (Ash)
1200 800
Ca2+, (CaO+CaSO4)
400
SO42-, (CaO+CaSO4) Mg2+, (Ash)
0 14
Figure 5:
481
12
10 pH
8
6 Ca2+(CaO)
Changes in liquid phase composition during carbonization of aqueous suspensions of ash and model compounds.
Therefore, while using a wet carbonization method for stabilizing the ashes, it is recommended to keep final pH in the range of 8...9 – going to lower values would increase the leaching of some ash components.
4
Conclusions
The deceleration mechanism of the wet carbonization process of two kinds of oil shale ashes has been elaborated. The CFBC ashes, characterized by a porous and uneven surface as well as higher SSA values and larger pores, can be carbonized more deeply with lowering the content of free CaO below 1%. Due to low porosity and small sized pores, the PF ashes are rather extensively influenced by product (CaCO3) formation on the surface of particles. Evidently, in this case the formation of reaction products leads to the plugging of pores in extent hindering the leaching of lime and diffusion of Ca2+-ions. The carbonization process is also controlled by a liquid phase – by the pH of ash – water suspension. At lower pH values carbonization process may decelerate due to the increase in solubility of calcium carbonate and sulphate.
Acknowledgements Partial funding of this work by ESF (G6195), Nordic Energy Research and SC Narva Elektrijaamad is appreciated. The contribution of Dr Valdek Mikli in the performance of SEM measurements is acknowledged.
References [1]
O'Connor, W.K., Dahlin, D.C., CO2 storage in solid form: a study of direct mineral carbonation. 5th International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Technologies, Cairns, Australia, 2000. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
482 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
[7]
[8] [9] [10]
[11] [12] [13]
Haywood, H.M, Eyre, J.M., Scholes, H., Carbon dioxide sequestration as stabile carbonate minerals – environmental barriers. Environmental Geology, 41, pp. 11-16, 2001. Teir, S., Eloneva, S., Zevenhoven, R., Co-utilization of CO2 and calcium silicate-rich slags for precipitated calcium carbonate production (part I). Proc. of ECOS 2005, Trondheim, pp.749-756, 2005. Huijgen, W.J.J., Witkamp, G.J., Comans, R.N.J., Mineral CO2 sequestration by steel slag carbonation. Environmental Science and Technology, 39(24), pp. 9676-9682, 2005. Anthony, E. A., Jia, L., Woods, J., Roque, W., Burwell, S., Pacification of high calcic residues using carbon dioxide. Waste Management, 20, pp. 113, 1999. Kuusik, R., Veskimäe, H., Kaljuvee, T., Parts, O., Carbon dioxide binding in the heterogeneous systems formed by combustion of oil shale. 1. Carbon dioxide binding at oil shale ash deposits. Oil Shale, 18(2), pp.109122, 2001. Soong, Y., Fauth, D.L, Howard, B.H., Jones, J.R., Harrison, D.K., Goodman, A.L., Gray, M.L., Formell, E.A., CO2 Sequestration with brine solution and fly ashes. Energy Conversion & Management, 47, pp.16761685, 2005 Back, M., Vosbeck, K., Kühn, M., Stanjek, H., Clauser, C., Peiffer, S., Pretreatment of CO2 with fly ashes to generate alkalinity for subsurface sequestration. Proc. of GHGT-8, Trondheim, Norway, 2006. Reddy, K. J., Drever, J.I., Hasfurther, V.R., Effects of a pressure process on the solubilities of major and trace elements in oil shale solid wastes. Environ. Sci. Technol., 25, pp. 1466-1469, 1991. Meima J. A., van der Weijden, R.D., Taylor Eighmy, T., Comans, R.N.J., Carbonation process in municipal solid waste incinerator bottom ash and their effect on the leaching of copper and molybdenum. Applied Geochemistry, 17, pp. 1503-1513, 2001 Ecke H. Sequestration of metals in carbonated municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash. Waste Management, 23, pp. 631-640, 2003. Kuusik, R., Uibu, M., Kirsimäe, K., Composition and physico-chemical characterization of oil shale ashes formed at industrial scale boilers with CFBC. Oil Shal,e 22(4S), pp. 407-419, 2005. Kuusik, R., Türn, L., Trikkel, A., Uibu, M., Carbon dioxide binding in the heterogeneous systems formed at combustion of oil shale. 2. Integrations of system components – thermodynamic analysis. Oil Shale, 19(2), pp.143-160, 2002.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
483
Waste from the coal extraction process as raw material for the construction industry N. Quaranta1, M. Caligaris1, H. López1, M. Unsen1, M. Carrasco2, R. Grether2, M. Suarez2 & L. Beltramini2 1
Universidad Tecnológica Nacional. Facultad Regional San Nicolás, Argentina 2 Universidad Tecnológica Nacional. Facultad Regional Santa Fe, Argentina
Abstract During mineral mining, huge quantities of waste are produced. This waste is usually placed in the open air, near the deposits, with the environmental consequences this situation implies. The construction industry and its auxiliaries can receive waste and by-products. As these industries handle materials on a large scale they can include an important percentage of waste in their compositions. In the present work the feasibility of utilization by the construction industry of waste originating during the coal extraction process as a raw material was studied. The materials, as received from the mine, were characterized as usual. From analysis of the results it is concluded that the waste can be used without any additives, but subject to a previous milling process in order to reduce the bigger pieces so as to prepare adequate mixtures for the compacting process. In a previous work some waste from the process was analyzed: ashes, mud and sterile material. As the stored quantity of the sterile material is noticeably higher and its characterization shows the possibility of using it to produce dense bodies, only this residue is studied in this work. The “steriles” were ground and mixtures with different particle size distribution were prepared. These powders, with 12% H2O and without other additives, were uniaxially pressed in order to obtain samples that were heat treated at 850°C. The samples obtained had good properties related to color, edges and surface finish. They were characterized by several techniques. Keywords: waste, coal extraction, construction, recycling, ceramic bricks. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070451
484 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Waste products are such things or substances generated during a consumption or productive activity, which have not direct interest in the main activity: industries must get rid of them and be in charge of their disposal. It is not possible to continue with the present waste generation without causing a collapse of production or of the planet habitat. Under these circumstances, there are two possible and simultaneous choices: the generation reduction and the reusing or recycling. Reusing consists of redirecting the waste materials to new production processes, instead of sending them to the waste flow. Usually, some changes in the production final steps are needed in order to transform the waste into secondary raw materials for the same industry or into raw materials for others. It is important to mention that within the general classification there exist three kinds of waste: special, not special and inert [1]. The special waste products are those which, due to their dangerous or toxic properties and their concentration, need specific treatments and strict controls to prevent pernicious effects. The waste that never suffers any physicochemical change, under usual disposal conditions, is called inert waste. Non special waste is that which can go through changes and result in products that are not potentially dangerous. In this work the feasibility of utilization of waste originating during the coal extraction process as raw material for the construction industry is studied. During the process, the gross coal extracted from the mine is sent to a purification station and put on a vibrating sieve where particles bigger than 150 mm are separated to be milled. All the material is stored in silos until it is used. From there, the mineral is taken to a sieve and separated in two parts, one constituted by particles bigger than 20 mm and the other by smaller particles. The fraction of bigger particles is introduced in a dense medium consisting of pulverized magnetite and water. By gravity, a floating material composed of waste and coal and a decanted waste material, called steriles, are separated. The fraction of particles smaller than 20 mm is introduced in a cyclonic decanter that also works with a mixture of magnetite and water, but here the floating material is separated by centrifugation. The heavier material is separated through the inferior exits of the cyclone and constitutes other fractions called steriles. The decanted waste is disposed in opencast stocks in the purification plant field. In both cases, the dense medium waste content is discharged from the decanters and is taken to a tank for mud sedimentation. This mud is later disposed in opencast pools, being another waste of the process. In power plants, coal is used as fuel producing a large amount of ashes: coarse and fly ash. Coarse ashes are produced from the material melted during combustion, which is removed as liquid slag and solidifies as grains when cooled with water. This material constitutes other waste of the process. In this work the waste called steriles produced during the coal extraction process in Rio Turbio coal mine, Santa Cruz province, Argentina, is studied. The other mentioned waste was analyzed in a previous work [2]. Although, according to the previously presented classification, it is inert waste, it’s stock produces serious environmental problems in the area. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
485
Steriles stock.
Figure 1 shows a view of the purification plant from the highest point of the steriles stock, and the appearance of the deposits of agglomerated particles. Very different sizes are observed. Preliminary studies of this waste have been made, focusing on it’s utilization in the field of the construction industry, specifically in road surfaces where it was included or in other materials such as cement or concrete. The obtained results indicated that these materials must be heat treated and stabilized with lime in order to fit their physical characteristics and mechanical behaviour within the expected parameters for materials to be used as structural bases of road surfaces [3].
2
Experimental
2.1 Waste and products characterization The powders to be used as raw material for the dense bodies' production and the fired samples obtained were characterized by several techniques: optical and scanning electron microscopies (SEM), electron diffraction analysis X-ray (EDAX), X-ray diffraction (XRD), particle size distribution, permanent linear expansion and Vickers microhardness measurements. The SEM analyses were carried out through a Phillips 515 scanning electronic microscope with an X-ray detector (EDAX-Phoenix). The optical observations were made with Zeiss-Axiotech equipment with a Donpisha 3CCD camera and image scanner. The X-ray diffraction spectra of the powdered samples were obtained for 2θ values between 10º and 60º with Phillips PW 3710 equipment, with CuKα radiation and Ni filter. The operation conditions were 40kV, 20 mA. The obtained patterns were analyzed using ASTM Standard files (pcpdfwin files). The hardness analyses were made with a Vickers indenter in an HMV-2000 Shimatzu equipment, using loads of 200 g during 30 sec in all cases. The granulometric characterization was carried out by dry and wet way methods according to VN-E7-65 and VN-E1-65 Standards respectively. The waste materials, as received from the deposits, were subjected in a first step to a WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
486 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI disintegration process at 70°C which generates the coarse particulates dissociation. The particle size distribution essays were made using these powders. In a second step the waste was milled to particle sizes smaller than 600 µm, in order to select the fractions needed to prepare the bodies. 2.2 Compact samples preparation The compact bodies were obtained starting from ground steriles separated by particle size. Mixtures with 30% particles between 600 and 300 µm, 40% between 300 and 150 µm and 30% between 150 and 75µm were prepared. These powders, with 12% H2O and without other additives, were uniaxially pressed (70 MPa) in order to obtain samples of 70 mm x 40 mm x 10 mm. After adjusting parameters of preparation and treatment of those samples, pieces as big as common bricks were prepared. The samples were heat treated at 850°C for 6 hours in order to obtain sintered dense bodies. From now onwards small pieces will be called probes and the others will be called bricks. Obtained sintered bodies were prepared for characterization. Pieces of about 1 cm2 were cut, squeezed in resin and then polished with different papers and pastes (up to diamond 1 µm) in order to reach a proper surface for microscopic observations and microhardness measurements.
10 µm
50 µm
Figure 2:
3
SEM microphotographs of esteriles.
Results and discussion
3.1 Steriles characterization Figure 2 shows the morphological analysis carried out on the samples by scanning electron microscopy. As it can be observed, the particles have not, in general, uniform morphologies with the presence of crystalline cut planes, edges and angles. The bigger particles come from the joining of smaller ones, constituting agglomerates. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 1:
487
EDAX analysis of the particles.
Oxide
Na2O
MgO
Al2O3
SiO2
K2O
CaO
TiO2
FeO
%
2.3
3.3
27.2
62.5
0.9
1.1
0.6
2.1
In Table 1 the semi quantitative chemical analysis (EDAX) of the samples can be observed. EDAX reveals the Al and Si oxides are the major part, being present other oxides such as Na2O and K2O that are important during the process of sintering dense bodies, although they are in small proportion. These oxides contribute to the liquid phase formation, facilitating the inter-particles necks during the samples sintering. It can be observed that, in the calculations of compositions of these materials as percentage, the carbon present in the samples, which appears in a high proportion, was not considered. In several essays, it was determined that the carbon content was approximately 20%. The reason for this calculation is that carbon will be eliminated in the composition of the sintered dense bodies during its production, which is another objective of this study. The percentages shown in Table 1 are used to determine the probable sintering temperature of the materials, taking into account the corresponding ternary diagrams. According to these analysis results, the materials composition can be localized in the phase equilibrium diagram Al2O3, Na2O, SiO2 in the compatibility triangle defined by the oxides SiO2, Na2O.Al2O3.6SiO2 (albite), 3Al2O3.2SiO2 (mullite), and in the phase equilibrium diagram Al2O3, MgO, SiO2, in the compatibility triangle defined by the oxides SiO2, 2MgO.2Al2O3.5SiO2 (cordierite), 3Al2O3.2SiO2 (mullite). For this study the oxides with similar behaviour were considered added. In this way the K2O is added to the Na2O and the CaO is added to the MgO. The quaternary invariant point must have a temperature not higher than the temperature of the ternary invariant point of lowest temperature. Therefore, the temperature of the first liquid formation in the considered material would be lower than 1050 °C. If this last value is considered for calculations, the sintering temperature is determined to be lower than 785 °C. For this reason, the working temperature for the production of sintered dense bodies was established to be 850 °C, in order to be sure the sintering process takes place. The X-Ray pattern obtained of the waste powders is shown in Figure 3. The presence of three crystalline phases, identified as 1, 2 and 3 in the figure, is revealed. The phase 1 corresponds to SiO2-quartz (pdf 87-2056), the phase 2 to Al2Si2O5(OH)4-caolinite (pdf 83-0971), and the phase 3 to K0,2Na0,8AlSi3O8-albite (pdf 83-2215). In the results of the granulometric characterization essays, it can be observed that the essay carried out by dry way method reveals a material with bigger particle sizes than those determined by wet way method. This is due to the presence of agglomerates that are scored as particles of bigger sizes and are then disintegrated in contact with water. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
488 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 3:
XRD pattern of steriles powder.
Figure 4:
Probes and brick obtained starting from steriles (850ºC for 6 h).
3.2 Products characterization In the photographs presented in Figure 4 the samples obtained from steriles after a heat treatment at 850°C for 6 hours are shown. As it can be observed the samples show good macroscopic characteristics in relation to color uniformity, surface, edges maintenance, etc. The compact bodies color varied from dark brown in the pieces before firing to beige in the fired pieces. This is due to the carbon loss in the samples. The weight loss in the samples was 20%, approximately. This corresponds to the loss of the water, added in the powders compacting process, and of part of the carbon content of the waste. Therefore, in the fired pieces there is a remaining carbon content. Inside the samples the color is darker, this can be observed macroscopically if the samples are cut. The analysis performed by optical microscopy showed differential structures between the zones near the surface and the interior of the pieces. At a superficial level sintered particles and lower porosity are detected. This fact can be observed in Figure 5 (a). Carbon particles were not found in this zone. (a)
(b)
C particles
X500
Figure 5:
X500
Optical microscopies of the fired probes (a) zone close to the surface. (b) interior zone.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 6:
489
Optical microscopies of the fired bricks (x100) (a) zone close to the surface. (b) interior zone.
Figure 7:
Optical studies of the fired bricks (x100).
In the central area of the samples more porous zones, with low sintering degree of the structure and great presence of carbon particles are observed (Figure 5 (b)). In Figure 6, optical microscopies of the fired bricks, in the interior zone and in the zone close to the surface are observed, in a transverse section. The region closer to the surface appears lighter, with little amount of pores and carbon particles. A sinterization shell, with uniform thickness along the brick, between 1.6 mm and 2.2 mm, is observed. Surface characteristics of probes and bricks are noticeably different, in relation to pores size and quantity and the presence of cracks. The probes have greater porosity without cracks, while bricks show small isolated pores and micro cracks originated on them, as can be seen in Figure 7. These differences in the sintering degree and porosity between the zones close to the surface and the central area is more remarkable if the samples are analyzed by SEM. Figure 8 shows these mentioned different zones. As it can be seen, the sintering of the compacted particles was reached up to a distance of 600 µm from the surface, approximately. Observations with higher magnifications of the zone WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
490 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI between these two different sectors show the formation of inter-particle necks and the beginning of structural unification as an intermediate step of the process of sintering and densification of the pieces (Figure 9). The Vickers microhardness analysis of the fired bodies (probes) was made only in the denser zones close to the surface, because in the rest of the sample it was not possible to obtain clear stamps feasible to measure, due to the very low tenacity of these sectors. The obtained microhardness value, average of 10 measurements, with 10% dispersion, is Hv: 892 Kg/mm2. This value is slightly superior to the values found in literature for silicoaluminous materials as cordierite (~840Kg/mm2), and inferior to the value determined for pure quartz (~1240Kg/mm2) [6]. In the bricks, the obtained microhardness value, average of 10 measurements in the surface zone, with 6% dispersion, is Hv: 870 Kg/mm2. In the central area the measurements conditions exceed the structure tenacity. For this reason, the load and the time were lowered until measurements could be done properly. When using loads of 100 g for 20 seconds, a value Hv: 685 Kg/mm2, average of 10 measurements, with 12% dispersion, was obtained. The X-Ray patterns of the fired compacts reveal the same crystalline phases present in the original materials, proving that the thermal treatment doesn’t produce changes in the crystalline structures. 200µm
200µm
Figure 8:
SEM analysis of the fired compacts.
50µm
Figure 9:
SEM photograph of transition zone between sinterized and nonsinterized areas.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 10:
491
SEM-EDAX analysis of the bricks.
In Figure 10 the results of the SEM – EDAX analysis are presented. In this figure a transverse section of the brick is shown. On the right side, the carbon content percentages from the surface to the central area, in analysis intervals of 200 µ, are plotted. Carbon contents of approximately 30% are determined for distances from the surface greater than 2200 µ. This fact is coincident with the sinterization shell determined by optical microscopy.
4
Conclusions
It is possible to produce sinterized dense bodies from waste from the coal extraction process. This material is used as it is disposed in the stock sector, after a milling process and a proper selection of particle sizes and thermal treatments. Small sintered probes, with good superficial and mass properties (color, edges maintenance, porosity, hardness, etc) were obtained. With the aim of improving the final product quality, different working conditions leading to the complete coal elimination and the complete sinterization of the bodies will be essayed. Masonry bricks, as big as common building bricks, were also prepared. Pieces of good characteristics, with a sinterized shell of 2 mm thickness, approximately and carbon contents in the central zone similar to those of the raw material, were obtained.
Acknowledgement Support by CIC is gratefully acknowledged.
References [1]
Castells, X., Reciclaje de Residuos Industriales. Aplicación a la Fabricación de Materiales para la Construcción. Eds Días De Santos S.A. Madrid. Spain. (2000). pp 45. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
492 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
Quaranta, N., Caligaris, M., López, H., Unsen, M., Giansiracusa, C., Carrasco, F., Grether, R., Suarez, M, y Beltramini, L. IV Encuentro PROCQMA, Argentine, (2006). Publisher in CD. ISBN13:978-42-0056-7. Segovia, M., Hillar, P., Zocco, C., Carrasco, M., Proyecto ANR SC 006/2003. III Encuentro PROCQMA, Argentine, (2005). Published in CD. Osborn, E. and Muan, A., Phase Equilibrium Diagrams of Oxide Systems, Plate 3: System MgO-Al2O3-SiO2. American Ceramic Society and the Edward Orton Jr. Ceramic Foundation, (1960). Osborn, E. and Muan, A., Phase Equilibrium Diagrams of Oxide Systems, Plate 4: System Na2O-Al2O3-SiO2. American Ceramic Society and The Edward Orton Jr. Ceramic Foundation, (1960). McColm, I., Ceramic Hardness. Plenum Press Ed. NY-London. 1990. pp 260.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
493
Use of waste powder coatings as binders for the manufacture of composite materials A. C. Abhyankar, N. R. Edmonds & A. J. Easteal Chemistry Department and Centre for Advanced Composite Materials, The University of Auckland, New Zealand
Abstract Powder coatings are 100% solid dry powders that are used to coat a wide variety of substrates. They are considered an environmentally friendly coating option with no volatile emissions and minimal overspray wastage. Fines (5% of the powder manufactured) that are not fit for application are also generated during production. Reworking them into usable powder is a costly and cumbersome process and hence they are not reclaimed. For this study three powder coating thermosetting powders were selected. Composites were made by using waste powder coating powders (WPCP) and fines as a primary binder, along with secondary binders and sawdust as the reinforcing material. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) were used to characterise composite boards formed using compressive moulding. The composite boards resemble particle boards and were tested for their mechanical properties according to the prescribed standard (AS/NZS 1895.1:2004 for Reconstituted Wood Based Panels). All results confirmed that the composite boards had mechanical performances comparable with conventional commercial boards. As they are constructed wholly from industrial waste materials these particle boards are novel products, and commercialization of this industrial ecological product is envisioned. Keywords: powder coatings, waste, fines, composites, particleboards, physical and mechanical properties, SEM, thermal analysis, DSC.
1
Introduction
Powder coatings are a dry powder paint technology used to coat a wide variety of conductive substrates, ranging from metals to specially treated wood. They WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070461
494 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI are environmentally friendly coatings as there are no volatile emissions and wastage is small; even overspray material can be reused when coating application is of a single colour. Their environmental acceptability and other advantages ensure their continuing success, but there are some problems to be solved. At the applicators end, recycling of over sprayed powder minimises waste, but in a multicoloured commercial system it is often cheaper to spray to waste. In many of these installations, huge quantities of powder coatings are sprayed once, lost into the recovery system, mixed with all other over sprayed materials, and then packaged for disposal. About 5 to 15% of total powder sprayed by applicators is collected as waste. When different colours are sprayed the amount wasted is higher and is referred to as waste powder coating powder (WPCP). In addition to overspray resulting from powder application, fines generated during powder production provide further waste. At the manufacturers stage powders with a particle size less than about 10 µm cannot be sold as they currently have unsuitable application and film-forming characteristics, and reworking them into usable powder is a costly and cumbersome process. These fines are a mixture of powder coating formulations collected at regular intervals in the bag house, and about 5 % of total production is collected as such fines. Other reasons for increased quantities of waste are the incompatibility of powder coating particles taken from different batches using the same formulation and raw materials, colour matching rejects and old stock. Production failures may also add to the waste. Recent work by Graewe [1], Kilner [2], Blatter et al [3] and others have resulted in patents on the re-incorporation of fines into new manufactured powder. Some attempts have also been made to use the waste powder and fines in insulating blocks as reported by Murray [4] and as a slurry (Anon [5]) to be used as paint. However, reprocessing the fines to a suitable particle size is not economically viable, and the fines are disposed of as a waste stream. This is not an ideal solution because it is an additional cost moreover, there are environmental concerns regarding certain coating powders. The waste materials are chemically reactive polymers and as such are valuable raw material that can be utilized in developing commercial products. In this study only thermosetting powder coatings were considered. These include epoxy, polyester and hybrid powders based on lower molecular weight solid resins with different chemistries. When subjected to elevated temperatures, these coatings melt, flow and chemically crosslink within themselves or with other reactive components to form a higher molecular weight reaction product. The aim of this research was to make use of the WPCP and fines as a binder in making composite panelboards. It was envisioned that the product should be unique, commercially viable, and appealing in utilising the current annual world powder manufacturing waste estimate of 60,000 tonnes (5% of an estimated production of 1,200,000 tonnes (Wright [6]) for 2007) plus an additional 5 to 15% of the sprayed waste. Composite production and product characteristics are discussed in this paper.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
2
495
Materials
2.1 Powders as primary binder For this study three powder chemistries were used: • Polyester (carboxyl functional) powders cured with TGIC (triglycidyl isocyanurate). • Polyester (carboxyl functional) powders cured with HAA (β hydroxyl alkyl amide), referred to as Primid. • Hybrid powders (carboxyl functional polyesters cured with epoxy resins based on bisphenol A). • The fines (small particle size powders) collected from the bag house being a mixture of the powder chemistries currently in production. 2.2 Sawdust as the reinforcing matrix Sawdust (of Pinus radiata) with particle size less than 3 mm, half of which was in the range 1-2 mm, and moisture content about 5%, was the reinforcing material. The sawdust constituted 50% of the composite mixture by weight, and sawdust from the same source was used for production of all composite boards to minimise variations in product properties due to variability of sawdust characteristics. 2.3 Other industrial polymer waste as the secondary binder A VOC-free industrial liquid polymer waste of known composition was used as a secondary binder. It consisted of 50% solids by weight. It should be noted that waste polymer disposal of that material is of concern in itself. For this study a single type of liquid polymer waste was used to minimise variations in product properties from that source.
3
Experimentation
Mixing the sawdust with the binders was done manually for the first set of experiments, and different mixing methods in the second set of experiments. The efficiency of mixing as reflected in the homogeneity of the mixtures was dependent on the method of mixing. Composite boards with dimensions 310 x 250 mm were pre-formed in a wooden mould by cold pressing the composite mixture for three minutes under a pressure of 150 kPa using a 100 ton hydraulic press. The mould was then dismantled and the composite pre-form hot pressed at 160°C in a 50 ton hydraulic press for ten minutes with the use of 3 MPa pressure. A 12 mm mechanical stop was used to control the thickness of the boards. The target density was 900-950 kg m-3. The composite mixture had a moisture content of about 12%. The composites were made with sawdust: binder weight ratio of 50:50; where the binder component was a combination of the primary and WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
496 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI secondary binders. Except for the type of powder the compositions were the same for all of the boards, which were all made in exactly the same way so that valid comparisons could be made of binder, binder efficiency and the effect of the method of mixing. 3.1 Physical and mechanical properties For each board type three boards were made and cut to make test specimens with appropriate sizes whose physical and mechanical properties were determined according to the AS/NZS 1895.1:2004 standard for reconstituted wood based panels with the tests from AS/NZS 4266 series of standards. 3.1.1 Effect of powder chemistry The purpose of making boards from the four types of powder coating waste, namely TGIC cured, Primid cured, Hybrid (polyester with epoxy) powders and fines (mixed chemistry), was to establish whether all of the powder types could (or should) be utilised independently, and whether the fines alone were satisfactory binders in imparting the desired board properties. 3.1.2 Effect of mixing on board properties It is known[7] that the method of mixing raw materials can affect the properties of composites made from the raw material mixtures. To ascertain the effect of mixing procedure, the composite mixture was mixed by four methods, namely manually, and with a Mixaco mixer, screw extruder and ribbon blender. Boards were made using only the Primid powders for valid comparisons. 3.2 Composite inter-phase characterization The fibre resin inter-phase was studied using scanning electron microscopy, and differential scanning calorimetry was used to characterise the curing process for both the powders and their respective composites.
4
Results and discussion
4.1 Physical and mechanical properties All the boards were made using the same procedure (except for the method of mixing the raw materials) and the test results are tabulated and analysed below in relation to both binder efficiency and the effect of the mixing process. 4.1.1 Effect of powder chemistry From the test results (Table 1) it is apparent that the test boards meet most of the specifications for the standard board, moisture resistant general purpose board and high performance particleboard, and that TGIC and Hybrid boards showed the best properties. The board thickness was close to the target thickness of 12 mm, and the 24 h thickness swell data for the Hybrid and Fines boards are WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
497
excellent. This suggests that the boards may be suitable for use in areas where they may be exposed to dampness. Physical examination of the boards revealed that most of the wood particles in the boards were coated with the binder and thus had greatly reduced propensity to absorb water, giving low moisture content for the boards. Overall the bending strength characteristics are good. Though the bending strengths (as represented by MOR) of the Primid and the Fines boards are lower than for the TGIC and Hybrid boards, they are close to the standard and can be said to be satisfactory. The internal bond strengths are all highly satisfactory in relation to the standard specifications. The modulus of elasticity of the boards was lower than expected. 4.1.2 Type of mixing on board properties The appearance of boards (Figure 1) is directly related to the degree of homogeneity achieved by the mixing technique. The board made from manually mixed composite had patches of binder spread over the surface; the Mixaco mixer gave more homogeneity, though the board was still speckled. In the board made from screw extruder mixed composite the binder seemed to have very well coated the sawdust, resulting in a uniform appearance although the extrudate was granular and this was reflected in the appearance of the board. The board made from composite that was mixed in the ribbon blender showed the most homogeneous structure. It resulted in uniform mixing and a consistent appearance from batch to batch. 1a
Figure 1:
1b
1c
1d
Visual appearances of boards made by (a), manual mixing; (b), Mixaco mixer; (c) screw extruder; (d), ribbon blender.
The effect of the method used for composite mixing on board properties is shown by the data shown in Table 2 and Figure 2. For this set of experiments all the boards were made with Primid powders. The boards made from composite mixed using the twin screw extruder had the lowest strength (as measured by MOR), possibly because partial curing of the powder occurred as a result of a temperature increase arising from the high shear conditions in the extruder. Manual mixing and the Mixaco mixer gave relatively low MOR values of very similar magnitude due to non-uniform resin distribution. Manual mixing also gave comparatively high 24 hour water swell compared to the other boards. The boards made from composite mixed in the ribbon blender had the best overall properties.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Test results according to AS/NZS 1859.1:2004: the effect of powder chemistry on composite board properties. Sample Standard MRGP HPPB
d/mm 8-12a 8-12a 8-12a
Sd24(%) 25b 18b 12b
ρ/kg m-3 n/s n/s n/s
MC(%) 5-13 5-13 5-13
MOR/MPa 13c 13c 18c
MOE/MPa n/s n/s 2700
I/MPa 0.35c 0.35c 0.45c
TGIC Board σ
11.89 0.49
13.6 1.5
938 33
2.2 0.33
16.0 1.7
2235 181
0.60 0.08
Primid Board σ
12.31 0.18
19.7 2.1
972 30
2.3 0.21
11.6 0.6
1988 94
0.53 0.08
Hybrid Board σ
12.32 0.22
8.2 1.5
938 29
2.4 0.32
18.6 1.2
2046 233
0.61 0.05
Fines Board σ
12.42 0.16
5.0 0.6
918 27
2.8 0.26
12.1 1.0
1937 214
0.44 0.07
MRGP = moisture resistant general-purpose boards; HPPB = high performance particleboards; a = nominal thickness range; b = upper specification limits; c = lower specification limits; σ = standard deviation; d = thickness; Sd24 = % increase in thickness after 24 h water soak; ρ = density; MC = moisture content; MOR = modulus of rupture; MOE = modulus of elasticity; I = internal bond strength.
498 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Table 1:
Test results according to AS/NZS 1859.1:2004: the effect of composite mixing method on board properties.
Sample Standard MRGP HPPB
d/mm 8-12a 8-12a 8-12a
Sd24(%) 25b 18b 12b
ρ/kg m-3 n/s n/s n/s
MC(%) 5-13 5-13 5-13
MOR/MPa 13c 13c 18c
MOE/MPa n/s n/s 2700
I/MPa 0.35c 0.35c 0.45c
Manual mixing σ
11.12 0.22
13.6 1.8
844 44
3.7 0.49
9.8 1.8
1882 241
0.71 0.10
Mixaco mixer σ
11.14 0.24
9.1 1.5
832 100
3.1 0.25
10.6 1.9
1969 215
nd
Screw extruder σ
11.06 0.22
6.1 0.3
918 27
3.5 0.11
6.6 0.8
2237 205
nd
Ribbon blender σ
11.68 0.40
8.2 1.7
869 71
4.0 0.09
17.1 3.0
2864 717
1.42 0.21
nd = not determined. The other symbols are as indicated in the footnote to Table 1.
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Table 2:
499
500 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 25
MOR in MPa
20 15 10 5 0 Hand Mixing
Figure 2:
Mixaco Mixing
Extruder Mixing
Ribbon Blender Mixing
Effect of mixing method on the modulus of rupture of composite boards.
4.2 Composite inter-phase characterization 4.2.1 Scanning electron microscopy The micrograph of the fracture surface produced in the internal bond test (Figure 3a) shows that the wood component was completely coated with the binders. The sawdust particles were in a flat oriented position due to the compression exerted during board making. Figure 3b shows clearly fractured wood cells, indicating that sawdust particles were fractured rather than being pulled from the matrix. 3a
Figure 3:
3b
Scanning electron micrographs of fracture surfaces resulting from (a), internal bond strength test; (b), three point bend test.
4.2.1 Thermal analysis All of the resin powders used in this study showed similar thermal properties (Table 3), melting in the range 55 to 100°C. Glass transition temperatures (Tg) were close to 45°C for the uncured powders, and curing increased Tg to 60-70°C. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
501
Isothermal heating at 160ºC yields Tg values that are mostly close to those of the fully cured powders. The glass transition temperatures of the boards were in most cases close to Tg for the cured powders, indicating a high level of cure in the final products. Table 3:
Thermal characterisation (by DSC) of powder coating powders and fines.
Resin sample HAA powder TGIC powder Hybrid powder Fines
Tg 0 43 46 42 42
Tg1 60 69 67 57
Tg2 65 70 68 62
Tgb ~60.5 ~66 ~63 ~59
Tg 0 = Tg for the uncured powders heated from 25ºC to 250ºC; Tg1 = Tg after isothermal heating at 160ºC for 10 min.; Tg2 = Tg after cyclic heating from 25ºC to 250ºC, repeated after cooling to 25ºC; Tgb = Tg for boards after heating from 25ºC to 250ºC.
5
Conclusions
From the results of this study it is apparent that composite boards can successfully be made from waste powder coating powders and fines. The boards meet relevant standard specifications, and their morphology suggests strong interaction between the resins and the cellulosic particles. The method of mixing is important in achieving the best strength characteristics of the boards, and composite mixing with ribbon blender is the most effective of the mixing methods used. Being manufactured only from industrial waste materials, these composite boards are novel. Commercialization (Squire et al [8]) of this product will greatly reduce the amount of waste powder coating material that is disposed of in landfill.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
Graewe, R., Process for recycling powder coating waste, US Patent 6881762. Kilner, I., Process for recycling powder coating fines, GB Patent 6793163. Blatter, K., Montgomery, D., Bolm, H., Continuous method for reusing coating powder waste and coating powders thus obtained, in: US Patent 6500385. Murray, B., A Novel Approach to the re-use of Powder Coating Fines, Paper presented at Powder Coating 2002 in Indianapolis, 2002. Anon, Aqueous Powder Systems, Finishing Industry vol. 5 (1982) pp. 2122. Wright, T., Chinacoat 2006. Coatings World, December, pp. 24-26, 2006.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
502 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI [7]
[8]
Bledzki, A.K., Letman, M., Viksne, A., Rence, L., A comparison of compounding processes and wood type for wood fibre—PP composites. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing 36 (6), pp. 789797, 2005. Squire, G.N., Abhyankar, A., Watson, K.J. Product and method of manufacture, NZ Patent Application 549170.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
503
New technology for waste fluorescent lamps treatment in Lithuania – characterisation and environmental impact I. Urniezaite1, D. Jankunaite1 & E. Griskonis2 1
Department of Environmental Engineering, Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania 2 Department of General Chemistry, Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania
Abstract Treatment of waste fluorescent lamps, which are widely used all over the world, is a very important field of environmental research. Due to the presence of mercury vapour in these lamps, this kind of waste requires special attention to its disposal. This study aims to evaluate the environmental impact of fluorescent lamps and to describe the principal aspects of new technology used for their treatment in Lithuania. The main parameters in this treatment process are mercury and manganese concentrations in the treatment of residual waste of fluorescent lamps. Mercury concentration in fractionated treatment residuals was determined by complexonometric titration and the manganese concentration was determined by the atomic absorption method. The results, obtained in the study, show manganese and mercury content in fluorescent lamp treatment products and the main physical parameters of these treatment products. This study revealed that concentrations of metallic mercury and water soluble mercury salts in the examined samples are within the permitted limits. Also, this paper presents residuals X-ray analysis results. Results of this study show that the products of waste fluorescent lamps treatment can be treated as environmentally friendly, according to their solubility in water. It gives an opportunity to look for more possibilities of this product’s disposal. As the presented treatment technology is relatively new and used to treat only small amounts of waste fluorescent lamps, this technology could be modified for larger productivity. Studies of this technology should go further in the aspects of different ways of treating the disposal of products, development of technology, etc. Keywords: waste, fluorescent lamps, complexonometric titration, atomic absorption, xrd analysis, hazardous waste, heavy metals, mercury. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070471
504 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Fluorescent lamps are widely used all over the world because of their long life and efficient energy use. Therefore, waste fluorescent lamps utilization is a very important field of environmental research. Due to the presence of mercury vapour in these lamps, used lamps are recognized as hazardous waste and require special attention to their disposal. There are different possibilities for this kind of waste disposal – from recycling, recovering of some materials or even the simple, safe disposal of rare chemical elements. There are studies made on the rare earth metals recovered from fluorescent lamps. While mercury and glass cullets can be recovered from the waste lamps, luminescent materials containing rare earth elements are dumped into landfills without recovery. Recycling of the rare earth elements, such as Y, Eu, La, Ce and Tb is not considered practical due to the lack of an available method [1]. Also, experiments are made with waste phosphors collected during the recycling of end-of-life fluorescent lamps to obtain a highly enriched phosphors product as a starting material for the better extraction of rare earth elements [2]. Fluorescent lamps can be recycled by crushing the tubes and splitting them into component parts, allowing mercury and other components (mainly glass) to be recovered [3]. Lithuania still has a problem with the safe waste fluorescent lamps treatment as the current economical and technological situation in Lithuania means it is not very feasible to apply high-tech management of waste fluorescent lamps, although problem exists and special attention is paid for finding the best treatment opportunities. New waste fluorescent lamps treatment technology presented in this work is not very complex, but is effective for safe waste lamp disposal.
2
Technology
Part of the mercury present in fluorescent lamps is in the vapour phase and it is assumed to be emitted to the atmosphere immediately upon the lamp breaking. The components of the lamp (the phosphor powder, end caps, glass) also contain some bound mercury. Hereafter, the presented technology is designed to avoid mercury emissions to the atmosphere and to transfer metallic mercury into inorganic mercury salts. Technology of waste fluorescent lamps treatment was developed in Kaunas University of Technology, Department of General Chemistry, together with JSC “Multiimpex”. It was patented in 2002 as the Lithuanian patent [4]. The principal scheme of this technology is shown in fig. 1. This technology satisfies the requirements of Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Reference Document on Best Available Techniques for the Waste Treatments Industries in category of Physico-chemical treatment of solid wastes [5]. Waste fluorescent lamps are placed on the loader (3), grabbed and transported to the reactor camera (2) through the barrier of demercurizing liquid. As the loader moves, every lamp goes through a breakage device (5) and is broken. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
505
Glass breakage drops onto the plate (14) and is transported through the glass crusher (15) to the discharge loader (16), which transfers waste glass to the container (17).
Figure 1:
Scheme of industrial device for waste fluorescent lamps disposal.
Demercurizing liquid, used for mercury fixation, consists of water soluble manganese and chlorine compounds. The reactor is filled with 1m3 of reacting mixture (4). The top level of demercurizing liquid is higher than the directive plate (14). Metallic mercury vapour reacts with demercurizing mixture and forms non-soluble compounds. Demercurizing liquid goes trough the recycling pump (6) and is constantly sprayed trough the sprayers (7) into the reactor. Metallic mercury vapour from the broken lamps is present in the reactor and demercurizing liquid is sprayed until concentration of mercury vapour attenuates to the permissible limit. The big surface area of liquid drops ensures high effectiveness of mercury vapour fixation. Part of the used liquid is directed to the glass breaking device to ensure a reaction of mercury drops with the demercurization liquid and good liquid mixing. Insoluble mercury and manganese compounds, formed during this process, are collected in the hollow at the bottom of the reactor (18). Then reacting liquid is pumped back to the reservoir through the valve (19); insoluble sediments are suspended in the filter (20). Soluble mercury and manganese compounds are accumulating in the demercurizing liquid and are isolated from the liquid during its processing. This kind of industrial device can be used as a stationery treatment system or be installed in a vehicle and used as mobile treatment equipment.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
506 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
3
Materials and methods
Solid residuals from waste fluorescent lamps treatment are the target of this study. These insoluble sediments, shown in the fig. 2, contain glass breakage and a mixture of different small particles. Experimental samples were taken from the collecting filter (20) of the presented treatment device.
Figure 2:
Waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals.
Mercury and manganese concentrations in waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals are the most important parameters of this treatment process and the object of this study. Samples were separated to glass and remaining solid fraction by rinsing out and then drying at room temperature. Separated solid residuals were analysed on purpose to identify how mercury and manganese are distributed between glass and the remaining residuals fraction. Dry solid fractions were dissolved in a mixture of hydrochloric and nitric acids. Mercury and manganese concentrations were determined in both solid fractions solutes and swilling water. Mercury concentration was determined by complexonometric titration method [6] and manganese concentration was determined by the atomic absorption method [7] using a Perkin Elmer 403 AA spectrophotometer. Waste fluorescent lamps can contain synthetic minerals, mainly apatites [3], therefore X-Ray diffractometry (XRD) was used to identify the minerals present in residuals. The XRD data were collected with a DRON–6 X-ray diffractometer with Bragg–Brentano geometry using Ni-filtered CuK radiation and graphite monochromator, operating with the voltage of 30 kV and emission current of 20 mA.
4
Results and discussion
The results obtained in the study and presented in Table 1 show manganese and mercury content in waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals and the main physical parameters of the analysed samples. Manganese is present in the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
507
residuals mainly as a constituent of insoluble manganese dioxide MnO2 and soluble manganese chloride MnCl2. Insoluble mercury sulfide HgS and mercury chloride HgCl are presumed as the main mercury containing compounds in the residuals [4]. Table 1:
Results of the experiment.
Residuals components Moisture content, % Glass fraction, % Remaining fraction, % Manganese content, mg/kg: Total quantity in waste lamps Quantity in rinsing water In glass fraction In remaining solid fraction Mercury content, mg/kg: Total quantity in waste lamps Quantity in rinsing water In glass fraction In remaining solid fraction
In wet mass
In dry mass
14,69 57,73 27,59
67,66 32,34
8881 1,63 -
10408 189 10219
255,75 0,00 -
300 283 17
Results of this experiment revealed that metallic mercury and water soluble mercury compounds were not found in waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals. A major part of the mercury compounds remain on the glass fraction, but it is immobilized and cannot be spread into the atmosphere. Manganese amount in residuals is 10408 mg/kg and 98% of it is concentrated in the remaining fraction of residuals. The amount of manganese in glass fraction reaches only 189 mg/kg and in the remaining fraction is 10219 mg/kg. Mercury distribution is reverse: 94% of mercury stays in the glass fraction. It can be explained by possible mercury binding to the glass luminophor coating. The manganese and mercury amount in the water soluble part of the waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals does not exceed limits set in the soil quality standard of Lithuania HN 60:2004 [8]. Normative for manganese quantity in soil is 1500 mg/kg and measured water soluble concentration is 1,63 mg/kg. Allowable mercury amount in soil is 1,5 mg/kg, but no water soluble mercury was detected in the analysed samples. XRD analysis confirmed that minerals fluorapatite and hydroxylapatite dominate in the samples of waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals. Basic fluorapatite and hydroxylapatite diffraction reflections were identified in the diffractogram with D-spacings 0.281; 0.277; 0.271 (fig. 3). Apatites are calcium phosphate minerals that may also contain fluoride, chloride, hydroxyl or carbonate, depending upon variety. It is assumed that these minerals form from the phosphor coating that is applied to the fluorescent lamps before use [3]. It WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
508 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI can be suggested that as heavy metals can be substituted into the mineral structure of apatites, it is possible that mercury can bind to these minerals. This would explain high mercury concentration on glass fraction of the analysed residuals. 900 800 0 ,2 8 1
700
0 ,1 8 4 0 ,1 8 0 0 ,1 7 7 0 ,1 7 5 0 ,1 7 2
0 ,1 9 4
0 ,2 2 5
0 ,1 8 8
0 ,8 1 7
200
0 ,2 6 2
0 ,3 8 9
300
0 ,3 0 7
0 ,3 4 4
400
0 ,2 7 7
0 ,2 7 1
500
0 ,3 3 5
Int e ns it y ( %)
600
100 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 2θ (degrees)
Figure 3:
5
XRD spectrum of waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals.
Conclusions and recommendations
Herein, presented waste fluorescent lamps treatment technology is classified as physico-chemical treatment of solid wastes by IPPC BAT for Waste Treatments Industries [5] and is designed to avoid mercury emissions to the atmosphere and to transfer metallic mercury into inorganic mercury salts. Analysis of waste luminescent lamps treatment residuals showed different manganese and mercury distribution between glass and the remaining fraction of the residuals. Mercury is concentrated on the glass fraction while a major part of the manganese is in the remaining residuals fraction. XRD analysis showed minerals fluorapatite and hydroxylapatite present in waste fluorescent lamps treatment residuals. These minerals, formed on the glass, from the phosphor coating, can be the main mercury binding materials in the glass fraction. According to analysis of residuals solubility in the water, immobilization of mercury during the treatment process is successful and the presented waste fluorescent lamps treatment technology can be called environmentally friendly and gives an opportunity to look for more possibilities of residuals disposal.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
509
As the treatment technology studied is relatively new and used to treat only small amounts of waste fluorescent lamps, this technology could be modified for higher productivity. Studies of this technology should go further in respect of the possibilities of different ways of treatment for the products’ disposal, technology development, etc.
Acknowledgement This research work was done with the support of JSC “Multiimpex”.
References [1]
[2]
[3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]
Shimizu, R., Sawada, K., Enokida, Y. & Yamamoto, I., Supercritical fluid extraction of rare earth elements from luminescent material in waste fluorescent lamps. The Journal of Supercritical Fluids, (33), pp. 235-241, 2005. Hirajima, T., Sasaki, K., Bissombolo, A., Hirai, H., Hamada, M., & Tsunekawa, M., Feasibility of an efficient recovery of rare earth-activated phosphors from waste fluorescent lamps through dense-medium centrifugation. Separation and Purification Technology (44), pp. 197– 204, 2005. The NCBS/ Nov 01/2132/ Sustainable markets for waste glass from fluorescent tubes and lamps. Final report, January 2002. Lithuanian patent Nr. 4954, H01J 9/39. Method for processing mercury lamps and device for implementation of it / R.A. Plungė, A. Plungė, E. Griškonis. – 2002 09 25. European Commission - European IPPC Bureau, "Reference Document on Best Available Techniques for the Waste Treatments Industries" (BRef on Waste Treatments). Adopted August 2006. Lurje J.J., Chimicheskij analiz proizvodstvennych stochnych vod, pp. 160166, 1974 (in Russian). Sbornik metodik po opredeleniju koncentracij zagriazniajushchich veshchestv v promyshlennych vybrosach. – L. „Gidrometeoizdat“, 1987, p. 161-164 (in Russian). Lietuvos higienos norma HN 60:2004. Pavojingu cheminiu medziagu didziausios leidziamos koncentracijos dirvožemyje / Maximum Permissible Concentrations of Hazardous Chemical Materials in Soil. Oficialusis leidinys. Lietuvos Respublikos sveikatos apsaugos ministerija. – Vilnius, 2004.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
511
Sustainable waste management in hospitals H. Daxbeck1 & P. Amrusch2 1 2
Resource Management Agency, Vienna, Austria University of Vienna, Austria
Abstract This paper refers to the waste management optimisation in hospitals. The goal is to develop the base for selection and implementation of waste prevention measures in hospitals, as well as to take practical action towards the preparation of waste prevention concepts. The application of the input-output analysis enables the identification and quantification of weak spots and waste prevention potentials in hospitals. The input-output analysis is built by considering the consumption (pieces) from the cost control and linking it with the analysis of the most relevant articles in a database: weight, composition and change during consumption and the correct waste disposal fractions are determined. In this way, the path of an article through the hospital can be described, from the purchase to the discharge as waste, and potential weak spots can be identified. Results show which articles are relevant for the contents of individual waste fractions. Waste gets thus a face, i.e. the contribution of each article to the total amount is known and steering measures can be derived and implemented. In this way, the basis is created for an efficient waste or environmental management. The benefits for hospitals include the fact that material flow analysis enables the identification and quantification of weak spots and waste prevention potentials in hospitals. Moreover, the outcome of input-output analysis is a basis for success in terms of efficiency improvements and monetary savings. As long as the database is being continuously updated, annual changes become detectable, and success resulting from implemented measures can be quantified. Identification of specific environmental projects is possible: The projects were developed together with the personnel. The innovation of this project is defined by the direct linking and balancing of purchase data with disposal data in the hospitals. Keywords: waste, waste management, environmental management, waste prevention, material flow analysis, input-output analysis, material accounting, hospital, hospital waste, health care. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070481
512 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Input-output analyses are considered to be an important prerequisite for the implementation of concepts of waste prevention and environmental management. Generally input-output analyses are purely expressed in monetary terms, focusing on the comparison of new waste policies. For an important contribution analyzing extended relationships into more detail by means of input-output analyses, see, e.g., Nakamura and Kondo [6]. This paper aims at contributing to the methodological improvement of the input-output analyses in waste management in hospitals. Waste prevention primarily occurs at source. In order to take effective waste prevention measures, awareness about waste composition is needed. Hence, indifferent projects, the basis as well as methods for waste analysis at source are developed and enhanced and in the intervening time adopted by several hospitals. Environmental management in hospitals aims at reducing waste, qualitatively and quantitatively, not only for environmental reasons, but also due to the relevance of cost reduction. From the cost accounting perspective relevant measures of cost reduction on the purchase-side are well established, whereas waste management decision making is generally more intuitive than systematic. The output-based waste assessment and analyses does not suffice for the input-based monitoring of waste flows. Relevant solutions to qualitative problems regarding, i.e. the PVC flow in hospitals, are often not on hand due to the difficulty of unavailability of data and the lack of systematic data processing.
2
Goals
The main aim of the paper is to represent the basis for an efficient waste and environmental management as well as resource-based management of hospitals. These results will serve as an essential requirement for further concepts of waste management as well as measures to be taken with respect to further projects in hospitals waste management.
3 Methodology 3.1 Cost accounting as a starting point On the input side, the amount of purchased articles is recorded in detail within the cost accounting. The individual consumption of each article within each cost accounting interface is documented. Logically, the mass input flow can be easily traced by applying the data from the cost accounting. However, the records of the amounts consumed consider article-specific categories, such as pieces, packs, rolls, canisters, and similar. The conversion of these categories into mass flows presupposes knowledge of the articles’ weights. The data base for the determination of the articles’ weights is given by the annual consumption data. In a hospital of about 1,000 beds, approximately WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
513
10,000 different articles are annually consumed. The weight determination for all employed articles is thus possible only at a great expense. The Pareto Rule well-known from the stock management says that the vast majority of a mass flow is caused by only a fraction of the articles consumed. Based on this, the instrument of the ABC-analysis has been developed that allows for the identification of exactly those few articles. By means of the ABCanalysis, for the weight determination only those articles can be selected that account for at least 80% of the total consumption. These few articles are analysed in terms of their weight, the weight of their packaging and of their overpack. Further, any change of the article during its use is traced. Afterwards, the article and its packaging are allocated to the corresponding waste and potential recyclables fractions, in accordance to the waste management concept of the investigated hospital. This way, an ArticleWaste-Register is developed for the analysed articles [1]. Packaging materials are generally paid extraordinary attention within the waste management. The real relevance of this fraction for the waste disposal of a hospital can be identified if not only the article itself is considered during the weight analysis but also the weight of the packaging and all overpacks that accompany the article from its delivery up to its use. This way, an overview is gained over the input into a hospital, a general assessment of the waste management is enabled, and a base is created for a waste and environmental management, respectively. 3.2 Elaboration of the Article-Waste-Register The Article-Waste-Register serves to decompose the article and the packaging material in order to distribute to the available waste and recycling fractions. Thereby, variations in weight, caused by the article use, have to be considered (such as medicine taken by patients, blood samples taken). Details about weight and the composition of articles along with their packaging material can be obtained by suppliers and producers or are determined by own analysis. The analysis of changes in weight based on the utilization and determination of disposal paths requires exact information about article use and the waste management system of the hospital. The systematic registration of weights and the allocation to the relevant output flows creates a data base linking output and input flows. This Article-Waste-Register clearly attributes to each article along with its packaging material the relevant disposal paths based on the waste management concept of the hospital. In the investigated hospitals, an Article-Waste-Register was implemented for the most important articles, whereby the optimal disposal paths of the articles and their packaging material were registered into the data base. These data are summarized into the MS-SQL-based software tool „Der Connector“, by which data can be processed. In this way, data on waste and purchase-related data are interconnected providing a starting point for a variety of optimization possibilities. Thereby, the Article-Waste-Register constitutes a basis for most important articles in terms of masses. The continuous adding up of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
514 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI new articles constantly increases the registration degree of masses. Furthermore, the article analyses and description is amplified. In this way, the understanding of material flows, such as PVC or relevant hazardous substances (such as quicksilver) is possible due to the supplementation of the relevant material concentrations. 3.3 The transfer into the material and/or substance flow analysis The establishment of the link between the Article-Waste-Register with the input data deduced form cost accounting enables the assessment of the input and the theoretical output in terms of mass flows to be compared with the actual disposal flows. Thereby an input-output-analysis of flows of the hospital is created. Since the Article-Waste-Register is based on the strict compliance with the individual waste management concept of the relevant hospital, only mass flows are calculated which pile up within the general framework of the hospital. Thereby, fixed goals are determined to correctly evaluate and compare the current state of the waste management system with the measures to be taken. Due to the straight link to the cost accounting mass- and material evaluations are possible, which were only usual in monetary and quantitative terms up to now. For instance, in this way, the contribution of individual articles or groups of materials to the total waste volume can be identified and assessed. Due to the consolidation of more cost centres, evidence is given not only on the level of wards but also on the level of any arbitrary organizational unit of the hospital. In addition to the quantitative representation in the form of mass flow balances, a quantitative account by means of material flow balances (e.g., of PVC) is possible.
4
Results
The possibilities of interpreting and demonstrating input-output analyses are varied [2]. The input-output-analysis of the hospital “KHL” (1,000 beds) shows an annual article consumption of 2.4 Million kg, whereby energy sources and water consumption is not considered. In the hospital “KHL” about 10,000 different articles are purchased annually, coming up to 28 Million units. The results of the input-output-analysis show that around 20% of the articles (1,850) result in 80% of the input flows of the hospital. Considering the total water consumption, the hospital “KHL” employs about 146 Million kg of non-durable articles. After a short time almost about 60% of these articles finish in the solid waste. In total the hospital “KHL” collects 33 waste and waste materials. The sum of these fractions results in almost the half (49%) of the non-hazardous waste. On average 46% of these waste materials are lead to the recycling process through different waste fractions (e.g., paper, glass, swill), whereas the hazardous waste amounts to around 5%.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Output: 2.4 Mio. kg
Input: 2.4 Mio. kg
0.3 Mio. kg off-gas
0.2 Mio. kg external input
1.4 Mio. kg
0.8 Mio. kg
1.9 Mio. kg
solid wastes
articles 0.3 Mio. kg absorbed water
Figure 1:
515
Patient
0.7 Mio. kg wastewater
Hietzing Hospital, 2002
Graphics: Resource Management Agency (RMA)
Input-Output analysis of the Hietzing Hospital [2].
800
Packaging
46
700
Product
600
Mass, in t
156 500 400
50
300 200
672
474 298
2
100 0
Pharmaceutics
Figure 2:
Medical Supplies
Food
8
1
66
81
55
Office Consumatives
Detergents
Others
Input-Output analysis of the KHL Hospital.
About 1/3 of the input are consumed by patients to be sort out mainly into the waste water. This division is clearly reflected in the comparison of different product groups. Figure 2 shows how the attribution of articles to the relevant product groups accomplished. The main mass flow in the hospital is characterized by food (51%), whereas the percentage of medical articles is with 45% slightly smaller. The contribution of office supplies and packaging material is minor; usually the amount of packaging materials is between 10 und 15%. Consequently, the packaging material is not primarily found in the waste material fractions, but articles themself constitute the main share of waste. In this way, the relevant sensitive sections are identified to be significantly influenced by specific measures in order to reduce the amount of waste. For all the investigated waste fractions a target-performance-comparison can be done by means of the data base. Thereby, theoretically calculated values (target-performance-values) are confronted with the actual waste quantities (see Figure 3). As a consequence, weak points and possible economic measures (saving potentials) are indicated. Figure 3 displays the target-performancecomparison of non-hazardous waste, exemplified by 3 hospitals. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
516 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI In the hospital “PRE” no deviation is observed with respect to non-hazardous waste, i.e., the actual quantity exactly corresponds to the quantity arising according to the correct putting into practice of the concept of waste management. In the hospital “PRE” a very successful environmental management system was introduced 10 years ago. In contrast, in the other two hospitals deviations are considerable. The quantity of the waste disposed is substantial, showing that the implementation of the concept of waste management is improper and contains to many mistakes. In terms of kg per year, the optimization potential of the non-hazardous waste in the hospital “KHL” amounts to 500,000 kg. Hospital Waste in Comparison
kg/attendance day
3,00 2,50 2,00 1,50 1,00 0,50 0,00 SMZ-B
KHL
PRE
Current (actually occured) Target (calculated according to i-o-analysis)
Figure 3:
Target-Performance-Comparison of non-hazardous waste for three hospitals. The deviation of target and performance values indicates optimization potentials [2].
The rough analysis of waste flows supports the identification of individual waste or waste material flows. However, this information is not sufficient for taking the relevant action or developing concepts of waste management. Hence, a detailed inspection of the specific waste fractions is required. By analyzing the outcome from the Article-Waste-Register, it is possible to identify the contents of the waste fractions, as the example of non-hazardous waste of the hospital “KHL” shows. Detailed information on contents of waste fractions serves as a basis for further waste management measures or projects. In this way, data can be drawn, e.g., for the development of projects in the context of the sensible handling with medical articles, in order to reduce consumption on the input-side and to make a contribution to waste prevention. The utilization of the softeners DEHP (Diethylhexylphthalat) for PVCcontaining medical articles can have negative health impacts on patients, whereas patients have to be protected from the contact with PVC. PVC-balances are considered to be a useful basis for prioritization. For instance, the PVCWIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
517
balance of the hospital “PRE” demonstrates, which articles are mainly responsible for the PVC-flow in the hospital. Input-output analyses have been realized by this hospital since 2000. Hence, the variations in PVC-flows are measurable for recent years. On the basis of the PVC-balance sheet, the flow of PVC could be reduced by more than 60% in the hospital “PRE”. Table 1:
Demonstrates the composition and weights of non-hazardous waste components of the hospital “KHL” (excerpt). Weight [kg]
Article description Plegable towel 250x310mmC-Falzung 1-lg Waste sack orange 700x1200mm Glove - U-H Latex unsteril ungep.M Glove - U-H Latex unsteril ungep.L Infusion pres. 150cm Scrubbing-glove 1x (LB:A) beschichtet Patient sheet 60x60cm Cleaning rag 1x normal 30x40cm Glove - U-H Latex unsteril ungep.S Disposable nappy adults 1200ml XL Incontinence padding 0900ml Standard BIO Full-cream milk
Cum. % of the fraction 14% 20% 26% 30% 33% 36% 39% 42% 45% 47% 49% 52%
% of the fraction
55.932 26.760 21.180 15.570 13.845 12.730 12.283 12.137 11.122 9.602 8.734 8.602
14% 7% 5% 4% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 2% 2% 2%
PVC-hältige Artikel des PRE 0 Infusionsger.Druck 175cm O2 Sicherheitsschlauch 2m 37-1171 Kath Absaug CH 08 53cm Shore A 64 Überlaufsystem 3-fach MF1873 Filterleitung m Partikelfilter MF1622 U-H Latexfrei unsteril M Infusomatleitung f Braun Inf 8700 Kath Absaug CH 12 53cm Shore A 64 Kath Absaug CH 10 53cm Shore A 64 Spritzenpumpenleitung P MF1725 Butterfly 0,80 21 G Verabreichungssystem ohne Dorn MF1516 Urinmesssystem geschl Infusionsmischbeutel 3000ml Infusionsmischbeutel 0150ml MF1661 LL Hahn 3-Weg LL m Verlängerung 10cm Trachealsaugset Schlauchsystem f.Babylog1,1-5016A-176 Kath Absaug CH 14 53cm Shore A 64 Kath Frauen CH 16 Darmrohr CH20 Kath Frauen CH 18 ERYTHROZYT.KONZ.KIND LEUKOZ.D.0.G 1 ST Sauerstoffbrille f KdNr 1615 Beutel Universalauff unsteril 2l Infusionsmischsystem 4-teilig MF1501 Darmrohr CH25 Hahn 3-Weg LL m Verlängerung 50cm Kath Absaug CH 06 53cm Sauerstoffbrille f SglNr 1601 Medikamentenltg m P-Filter MF1642
10
20
30
40
50
60
PVC Fluss im PRE 450 400 350 300 250 200
-28%
150 100 50 0 2000
Figure 4:
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
List of PVC-containing medical articles with respect to the quantitative contribution of masses and representation of the reduction of the PVC-mass-flows by 1/3 due to substitution of the 5 marked PVC-containing articles in the hospital “PRE” (indications are given in terms of kg/a) [4].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
518 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI On the basis of input-output analyses, the hospital “KHL” was able to undertake further more than 10 project ideas with different priorities [2,3]. In summary, it can be concluded that waste management projects conducted in the hospital “KHL” within the last years lead to substantial improvements in the context of waste and environmental management preparing new grounds for sustainability and environmental protection. At the beginning we emphasize environmental work in waste management and organizational improvements, such as waste separation improvements and training. Actions set on the output-side, in contrast, focus on non-hazardous hospital waste as well as waste materials (e.g., paper, glass, plastic and metal). Recently, further optimization potentials in terms of waste management had to be identified in the wards. At present, optimization measures of the article employment concentrate on the reduction of quantities of waste, consciousness raising as well as on resource protection, whereby six priorities were identified (such as gloves, paper towels or photocopying paper) [5]. The actions taken in recent years contributed to annual cost reductions of € 79,000.- or 13% of the hospital disposal costs, respectively.
5
Conclusions
Input-output analyses, linking purchase and discharge are held to be the basis for consciously managing flows in enterprises. The quantitative and qualitative association between articles used and the occurring waste can be set up on the basis of input-output-analysis relating purchase to disposal, which is considered to be a basis for intentionally monitoring the flows in enterprises. The better flows are known, the more efficient can outcomes from the actions be controlled, assessed and predicted. The data collected (Article-Waste-Register) and the data base implemented (Der Connector) represent an efficient optimization tool in waste management. The Article-Waste-Register contains information on the composition and disposal of the relevant article. The identification of articles on the output-side allows for an efficient management of input-side acquisition activities. It was shown that it is possible to analyze material flows with a justifiable effort supported by an enterprise in the service sector. In this way, prerequisites for the accounting balance of goods and materials are created. In the investigated hospitals the methodological basis for the initiation of concrete projects of waste prevention could be created and put in practice, accordingly. The success was not only based on waste reduction, but also quality of environmental management could be enhanced. The benefits go beyond waste management issues, as also health-related advantages are pointed out, as the example on the PVC-balance as a basis for health-preventive problems points out. However, efficient waste management requires interdisciplinary collaboration, whereby interdisciplinary teams are a necessary requirement for the success of the implementation and development of concepts of waste management.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
519
References [1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
Daxbeck, H.; Neumayer, S.; Brunner, P. (1999) Entwicklung von Grundlagen zur Institutionalisierung von Stoffstromanalysen in Krankenhäusern. Projekt AKIN-B. Endbericht. Technische Universität Wien. Institut für Wassergüte und Abfallwirtschaft. Abteilung Abfallwirtschaft. Wien. Daxbeck, H.; Neumayer, S.; Kampel, E. (2004) Nachhaltige Abfallvermeidung in Wr. Krankenanstalten und Pflegeheimen. Erarbeitung von Methoden, Grundlagen und Initiierung von konkreten Umsetzungsmaßnahmen. Projekt NABKA. Endbericht. Projekt im Rahmen der INITIATIVE “Abfallvermeidung in Wien”. Ressourcen Management Agentur (RMA). Initiative zur Förderung einer umweltverträglichen nachhaltigen Ressourcenbewirtschaftung. Wien. Daxbeck, H.; Berzsenyi, J.; Stanic, L.; Neumayer, S. (2005a) Aktualisierung der Abfalldatenbank im Krankenhaus Lainz und im Preyer'schen Kinderspital für das Jahr 2003. Projekt AKTAB. Endbericht. Projekt im Rahmen der INITIATIVE Abfallvermeidung in Wien. Ressourcen Management Agentur (RMA). Initiative zur Förderung einer umweltverträglichen nachhaltigen Ressourcenbewirtschaftung. Wien. Daxbeck, H.; Brandt, B.; Berzsenyi, J.; Stanic, L.; Neumayer, S. (2005b) Identifikation der PVC-hältigen medizinischen Artikel und Erstellung einer PVC-Bilanz. Projekt VEMED - BILANZ. Projekt im Rahmen der INITIATIVE “Abfallvermeidung in Wien”. Ressourcen Management Agentur (RMA). Initiative zur Förderung einer umweltverträglichen nachhaltigen Ressourcenbewirtschaftung. Wien. Daxbeck, H.; Brandt, B.; Stanic, L.; Neumayer, S. (2006) Analyse der Möglichkeiten einer Optimierung des Artikeleinsatzes und der Altstoffsammlung zur Reduktion der Abfallmengen und Initiierung deren Umsetzung. Projekt AMOR. Ressourcen Management Agentur (RMA). Initiative zur Erforschung einer umweltverträglichen nachhaltigen Ressourcenbewirtschaftung. Wien. Nakamura, S; Kondo, Y. (2002) Input-Output Analysis of Waste Management, Journal of Industrial Ecology, Vol 6 (1) 39-63.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
521
The waste prevention kit for enterprises, education, and households (WastePrevKit) R.-L. M. Hahtala1, S. R. Huuhtanen2, S. A. Kajaste1, A. E. Karhu1, S. H. Kemppainen1, O. A. Linsiö1 & M.-M. A. Partti1 1
Helsinki Metropolitan Area Council (YTV), Waste Management, Finland Helsinki Metropolitan Area Council (YTV), Regional and Environmental Information, Finland
2
Abstract The Helsinki Metropolitan Area Council (YTV) is responsible for organising the waste management in residential building areas around the metropolitan area. In 2002 the board of YTV accepted the Waste prevention at source strategy until 2007. Therefore, a 5-year project was launched to realise this strategy and this project is funded by the EU-LIFE -programme as a WastePrevKit project from 2005 to 2007. One of the main focus points of YTV is that by 2007 there will be less waste generated per inhabitant and workplace in the metropolitan area than in 2002. The waste prevention strategy consists of several subprojects. The most resources were devoted to the waste prevention at source and to linking effectively the way of thinking materially with the general education and vocational teaching. The models for smart ways of action drawn up in cooperation with educational institutions, enterprises and the public administration help for their part in reducing waste. The models are available for use in schools, shops, the building trade, offices and daycare centres. The waste benchmarking comparison service Petra is offered in YTV’s webpages and provides a good tool for monitoring the waste amounts generated in workplaces, in educational institutions, companies and public administration properties. There are various kinds of awareness raising campaigns which are targeted at households. The webpages of waste prevention at source www.ytv.fi/fiksu are the focal point of the strategy. Keywords: waste prevention, material efficiency, education, teaching material, benchmarking.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070491
522 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
The amount of waste is growing strongly in Europe despite the strict politicowaste targets. According to OECD’s estimation the amount of MSW (municipal solid waste) will grow by 43% from 1995 onwards to 2020 [2]. The waste itself is, however, not the main problem, but the fact that over 90% of the natural resources utilised by people are immediately converted to waste during their products´ and foods´ manufacturing processes (Autio et al [3]). One of the goals of the EU’s 6th Environmental Action Programme is to ensure that the use of renewable and non-renewable resources and their related impacts do not exceed the environment’s carrying capacity. Waste prevention is on the highest level of the target hierarchy of EU waste legislation. Waste prevention should be a primary measure. It must come before the reuse of waste as material or energy or final disposal. The EU is aiming for a significant cut in the amount of waste generated with help of new waste preventive initiatives and better usage of resources, as well as by encouraging a change towards more sustainable consumption patterns. According to the waste policy of the EU we should primarily reduce the amount of waste generated in the first place and reduce its hazardousness by reducing the presence of dangerous substances in products. However, waste prevention at source hasn’t become an established term among ordinary citizens. Quite often sorting and recycling of wastes is understood as being part of waste prevention at source. YTV’s strategy concerning waste prevention at source includes the following subprojects: - Material Efficiency in General Education (Smart Primary-school kid, Smart Pupil and Smart Student, web-based teaching materials from pre-primary level up to upper secondary stage) - Material Efficiency in Vocational Education (Smart Professional, web-based teaching materials for vocational education institutions) - Smart Ways of Action (SMAC) guides and checklists for waste prevention at source for educational institutions, companies and public administration - Petra Waste Benchmarking Service for educational institutions, enterprises and public administration - It’s Smart with Less Waste –website (www.ytv.fi/eng/Fiksu/) - Special awareness raising campaigns for households
2
Strategy of waste prevention at source
2.1 Material efficiency in general education The Smart teaching materials, from preschool level up to upper secondary school, deal with the thematic of waste prevention at source with various methods suitable for each respective age and development stage of children and teenagers. The target is that by the end of 2007 each pupil will receive information on waste reduction and eco-efficiency three times during his/her entire school career: once during the pre-primary education, once in comprehensive school and once in upper secondary school. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
523
The teaching material is free of charge and available in electronic form in the net www.ytv.fi/fiksu. Pupils, students and teachers plus the other school personnel all participate in the waste reduction. Information on best practices of material efficiency is compiled in two models for schools and day-care centres. The models are also available on the Internet. Using these channels, low-waste ways of operating are easy to distribute more broadly. A wide network has been established in the metropolitan area between the YTV waste management, municipal authorities, schools and daycare centres in order to provide the target groups with information on new materials and methods about waste prevention. The project will monitor the waste flow information from school and nursery properties and register the obtained data in the waste benchmarking service Petra. Also the effectiveness of the project will be measured through questionnaires to the teachers. 2.2 Material efficiency in vocational education The so-called virtual school projects of the vocational basic education have applied the information and communication technology for supporting the learning process, both in distance and contact teaching as well as in supervising the job-embedded learning. The diversification of the teaching arrangements and methods has been the aim and also the increasing of students’ opportunities to study by utilising web-based instruction. Web-based teaching is already now an essential part of teaching in many schools (Leinonen et al [4]). The stimulating and challenging material of material efficiency for the teachers in vocational education institutions was designed with help of the results from the Ammatti–KEKE project of the Finnish National Board of Education in 2002-2005 (Ammatti-KEKE = the sustainable development in vocational training). In this the learning objectives and contents of sustainable development based on the curricula were written in to more than 20 institution-specific basic vocational qualifications at the practical level (Lundgren and Näätsaari [5]). During the project about 60 teachers from vocational education institutions participated in the planning work of the teaching material together with consultants and other experts of the field. The electronic “Smart professional” teaching materials for technical, food, nutrition and institutional catering, as well as social and health care studies are available in YTV´s Fiksu webpages www.ytv.fi/fiksu free of charge. The material packages, including exercises, for vocational studies are connected to the curriculum of the basic degree of respective fields. The aim is that the viewpoint of waste prevention at source and material efficiency is an axiomatic part of vocational studies from beginning to end. The goal is that teachers and students are able to apply the material efficient way of thinking in their own respective fields and that they recognise the environmental impact of their own actions. The material includes e.g. instructions for an environmental charting to be performed in the school. The model “Smart Ways in Educational Institutions” along with the checklists also helps to reduce waste in practice. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
524 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI The effectiveness of the project is being estimated by questionnaire studies for teachers and students for instance. The aim is that the teaching material will be used by 80 % of the area’s 25 vocational educational institutions in 2008. The resent study shows that teachers in the field of food and nutrition have most actively applied this teaching material - although the number of the respondents was quite low in 2006 (Figure 1). How often have teachers touched on the topic of waste prevention in their lessons No answer 2006 n=37 2003 n=74 2003 n=365
10 or more 5-9 times 1-4 times Sporadically Not at all 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
%
Figure 1:
How often have teachers touched on the topic of waste prevention in their lessons during 2003 and 2006. In 2003 the questionnaire was sent to all teachers of vocational education institutions in the metropolitan area (the answering %=40) incl. teachers in the field of food and nutrition (the answering %=56). In 2006, the questionnaire was sent to the teachers in the field of food and nutrition (the answering %=30).
2.3 The models of Smart Ways of Action for schools, enterprises and the public administration Five models of the Smart Ways of Action have been drawn up together with different educational institutions, industrial enterprises and representatives of the public administration. The models “Smart Ways of Action” for educational institutions [6] along with the checklists, help the personnel in reducing waste in practice. Smart Ways of Action in retail stores [7] is a tool directed particularly to the grocery and department stores for minimising the waste flows. Smart Ways of Action in the building trade [8] offers an extensive information package for construction professionals. The model of Smart Ways of Action for offices [9] is a tool to WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
525
plan material efficient working methods applicable in office work. The model designed for daycare helps the personnel of daycare centres in waste issues in the premises of the daycare centres [10]. The aim is that models generating less waste are widely known and applied. The minimum objective for reducing waste amounts generated by stores and offices was defined as 3 % from 2003 to 2006. The waste generation (total amount of solid waste per employee) in the offices providing their waste data in the Petra Waste Benchmarking reduced from 2003 to 2005. Especially the amount of waste paper and mixed waste in the offices has dropped. Figures for 2006 are not yet available (Figure 2). 300
Kg / Person
250
Combustible Waste Electrical Goods
200
Metals Wood Waste Cardboard
150
Paper Data protection paper
100
Biowaste Construction waste
50
Mixed waste
0 2003 n=98
Figure 2:
2004 n=87
2005 n=81
Total solid waste generation (kg/person) in offices 2003-2005 (Source: Petra Waste Benchmarking Database / YTV Regional and Environmental Information 1/2007).
The Smart Ways of Action (SMAC)-guides are available as pdf -files, published on the It’s Smart With Less Waste web site [11]. Each SMAC -model consists of an electronic leaflet with information and tips on waste avoidance, active links to appropriate web sites and publications, and separate checklists. 2.4 Petra - Waste Benchmarking service for schools, enterprises and the public administration The YTV’s Waste Benchmarking service Petra is meant for following up waste amounts and is a cost-free, web-based tool available in YTV’s webpages www.ytv.fi/petra [12]. The service is designed to help educational institutions, enterprises, organisations in developing their own waste management and reducing the waste amounts. With the help of this service a user is able to compare the waste amounts generated by it with other workplaces in the same field and with similar kinds of properties. With Petra it is easy to follow up how successful the preventive actions towards waste generation have been in each respective property. The aim is that the waste benchmarking system function WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
526 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI well and smoothly and is being applied extensively in the Helsinki metropolitan area. It guides effectively educational institutions, companies and communities in reducing waste. About 600 annual waste reports from educational institutions, companies and public organisations were checked and approved by the system administrator in 2006. The reports were gathered in cooperation with the Environment Centres (municipal environmental authorities) of the Helsinki Metropolitan Area municipalities (Helsinki, Espoo and Vantaa). YTV encourages organisations to prevent waste at source by awarding yearly the Saver of Natural Resources award to those organisations which have reduced their waste amount in an exemplary manner. All organisations which have passed information to Petra waste benchmarking from Helsinki region participate automatically in this competition. 2.5 Developing of a net portal The portal is an electronic data system which contains the teaching materials and other material of the project (www.ytv.fi/fiksu). A part of the portal content is also available in Swedish and English. The functionality and interactivity of the system is being improved constantly. The aim is that the net portal is practical and functional from the technical point of view. The contents of this portal are extensive and they inspire different target groups to start using it. Charts of the portal monitoring system show that in average there has been approximately 20 000 page views monthly during 2006 after modifications and changes in the portal (Figure 3). This year the amount of page views show a growing trend perhaps due to the marketing of the website. The results also show that Fiksu-portal is easily found by the search engines with waste prevention related keywords. 60000 51852 50000 37266
Page views
40000
28175
30000 20000
37223
23840 18157
24839 18259
10000 0 `09 2006 `10 2006 `11 2006 ´12 2006 ´01 2007 ´02 2007 ´03 2007 ´04 2007 Month/year
Figure 3:
Monthly page views at the www.ytv.fi/fiksu web portal during September 2006-April 2007.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
527
Buying products with a long guarantee Favouring products with less packaging No advertisements sign on the mailbox Repairing things Changing consumption habits Borrowing things instead of buying 0
Y. 2003 already done Y.2006 already done
Figure 4:
10
20
30
40
50
Y. 2004 already done Y 2007 already done
60
70
80
90
100
Y. 2005 already done Y. 2003 is ready to do
The willingness of the residents in Helsinki Metropolitan area to prevent waste versus intention (YTV´s annual poll, n~1 000/year).
Figure 5:
Awareness-raising campaign poster for households.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
528 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI 2.6 Distribution of material Training days, seminars and info spots are held in educational institutions, companies and offices of the public administration. Materials and methods are presented in different seminars both in Finland and other EU-countries. The goal is that the material will become widely known. Information on these materials is also distributed to households along with different campaigns. The inhabitants have been approached with various kinds of awareness-raising campaigns towards households (Figure 5) and the aim is that the information has lead towards choices producing less waste. The impressiveness of the project is being estimated by annual Gallup poll [13] to the residents in the Helsinki Metropolitan area (Figure 4). The resent study shows that the actions for waste prevention have not shown significant changes among the residents in 2003-2007. However the willingness to do for waste prevention has a large gap compared to the real actions taken.
References [1] [2] [3]
[4]
[5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
YTV’s Waste Prevention Strategy 2007 and background study. The Publication Series of the Metropolitan Area (PSMA) C 2002:4, Helsinki. OECD, Towards Sustainable Household Consumption? Trends and policies in OECD countries. OECD Publications, Paris, 161 p., 2002. Autio, S. and Lettenmeier, M., Ekotehokkuus – Business as Future. Yrityksen ekoteho-opas (Eco-efficiency - Business as Future. Ecoefficiency guide for a company), Teknillinen korkeakoulu, Koulutuskeskus Dipoli, 84 p., 2003. Leinonen A.M., Rannikko S. and Taivassalo M., Verkossa ja verkostoissa, toiveita ja toteutuksia ammatillisen peruskoulutuksen virtuaalikouluhankkeissa. (Expectations and execution of virtual school projects concerning basic vocational education in the internet and networks), Opetushallitus, 65 p., 2003. Lundgren K. and Näätsaari H., Kohti kestävää ammatillista koulutusta. (Towards sustainable vocational education), Opetushallitus, 195 p., 2006. YTV (2007a): Parhaat käytännöt oppilaitoksessa (Smart Ways of Action for educational institutions), URL www.ytv.fi/FIN/toissa/oppilaitokset/ etusivu.htm YTV (2007b): Smart Ways of Action in retail stores, URL www.ytv.fi/ENG/fiksu/at_work/trade/frontpage.htm YTV (2007c): Parhaat käytännöt talonrakentamissa, (Smart Ways of Action in the building trade), URL www.ytv.fi/FIN/toissa/rakennusala/ etusivu.htm YTV, Smart Ways of Action in an office, URL, (2007d) www.ytv.fi/ENG/fiksu/at_work/office/frontpage.htm YTV (2007e): Parhaat käytännöt päivähoidossa (Smart Ways of Action in daycare centres), URL www.ytv.fi/FIN/toissa/oppilaitokset/etusivu.htm
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[11] [12] [13]
529
YTV, It’s Smart with Less Waste website, URL, (2007f), www.ytv.fi/eng/fiksu YTV, Petra Waste Benchmarking Service, URL, (2007g), www.ytv.fi/petra TNS Gallup Oy (2007): Pääkaupunkiseutulaiset jäteasioista 2007. Sakari Nurmela, Itätuulenkuja 10, 02100 Espoo.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Section 13 Water resources
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
533
Assessment of seasonal variations in stream water by principal component analysis M. M. Taboada-Castro, M. L. Rodríguez-Blanco & M. T. Taboada-Castro Faculty of Sciences, University of A Coruña, Spain
Abstract Assessment of seasonal changes in surface water is an important aspect for the interpretation of hydrochemical data. Thirteen physical and chemical parameters monitored at four sampling stations along the Corbeira stream, NW Spain, were analyzed during a three-year period. The Corbeira stream drains a rural catchment (16 Km2) with low population density. The land use consists mainly of forested and agricultural land. The geological material is basic schist. A total of 51 samples were collected from each station. The principal component analysis (PCA) technique was used to evaluate the seasonal correlations of water quality parameters. Four principal components, accounting for 88.7 and 83.3% of the total variances of information contained in the original dataset for spring and winter, respectively, were obtained. In summer and autumn, three principal components accounted for 80.3 and 81.1% of the total variance, respectively. The results revealed that conductivity, chloride, magnesium, sulphate and nitrate were always the most important variables contributing to water physical-chemical properties in the stream for all seasons. The first three can be interpreted as a mineral component of the stream water. This clustering of variables points to a common origin for these minerals, most likely from an alteration of schist, whereas nitrates may be interpreted as representing influences from natural (decomposition of organic matter from soils) and anthropogenic inputs. Autumn and winter (periods with high water discharge) showed a strong influence of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and total nitrogen (Kjeldahl), respectively. This finding could be due to surface runoff. Keywords: hydrochemistry, surface water, principal component analysis, seasonal variation. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070501
534 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
Characterization of seasonal changes in surface water quality is an important aspect for evaluating temporal variations of river pollution due to natural or anthropogenic inputs of point and non-point sources. Long-term surveys and monitoring programs of water quality are an adequate approach to a better knowledge of river hydrochemistry and pollution, but they produce large sets of data, which are often difficult to interpret, and are not fully explored [1]. The problems of data reduction and interpretation, characteristic change in water quality parameters, and indicator identification can be approached through the use of the principal component analysis (PCA) and the closely associated method of factor analysis (PFA). PCA and PFA are multivariate statistical techniques used to identify important components or factors that explain most of the variances of a system. They are designed to reduce the number of variables to a small number of indices (i.e., principal components or factors), which make the data easier to understand. Details for mastering the arts of PCA and PFA are published elsewhere [2–4]. In recent years, the PCA and PFA techniques have been applied to a variety of environmental issues, including the evaluation of ground water monitoring wells and hydrographs, examination of spatial and temporal patterns of surface water quality, identification of chemical species related to hydrological conditions, and assessment of environmental quality indicators [5–11]. The aim of this study is to apply the PCA technique to evaluate the seasonal correlations of water hydrochemical parameters and to extract those parameters that are most important in assessing seasonal variations of the Corbeira water quality.
2
Material and methods
2.1 Study area The Corbeira (Fig. 1) is a small tributary of the Mero River, the principal river supplying the city of A Coruña (NW Spain). It has a catchment area of approximately 16 Km2, a river length of 10 Km and altitudes varying from 470 m.a.s.l. to 70 m.a.s.l. at its confluence with the Mero. Within the Corbeira catchment, land use is best described as rural (more forest than agricultural) and there is low population density. The underlying geology across the area is basic schist. The climate is humid temperate, and mean rainfall is in the range of 1022mm. Wet period precipitations are maximal between October and February. The dry period corresponds with the summer. 2.2 Data and statistical methods In this study, four sampling stations located in the main course and 13 physicochemical parameters obtained from each station were used for analysis.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Figure 1:
535
Map showing the area studied and the location of sampling stations.
Fifty one samples were collected from each station during a 3-year time period (between December 2003 and December 2006). The timing of sample collection was routine and not intended to capture any specific flow or rainfall events. Physico-chemical parameters were determined by following standard methods of analysis. Electrical conductivity, pH and temperature were measured on unfiltered samples using standard electrochemical techniques. After sample
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
536 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI filtration, cations were analyzed by ICP-MS, and anions and organic carbon by capillary electrophoresis. Nitrogen Kjeldahl was determined. Principle component analysis was used to reduce the complexity of the datasets and to ascribe concentration seasonal variations. The fundamental goal of PCA is to find a set of uncorrelated linear combinations that is able to explain most of the variance of the original multivariate data [12]. Using the standard statistical software SPSS 11.5, significant principal components (PCs) with eigenvalues greater than unity (i.e. PCs explaining more than the variance of one parameter) were extracted [7, 8, 13]. The Varimax criterion, which ensures maximum correlation of each parameter with one single PC, was applied for optimal rotation of the PCs. For this study, a factor correlation coefficient greater than 0.85 (or 85%) was considered significant. To distinguish the variations of each parameter for a given season, the data was divided into four distinct temporal databases (data from each season: winter, spring, summer and autumn). Therefore, four seasonal separation principal components or factors were performed.
3
Results and discussion
3.1 Seasonal correlation of hydrochemical parameters For the four seasons, high and positive correlations were observed for sodium, magnesium, potassium, calcium, chloride, sulphate and nitrate, which are responsible for water mineralization. Electrical conductivity (EC) also showed correlation with these variables, as well as DOC and HCO3, except in autumn. Water temperature (Tª) showed no correlations with other parameters in spring. A good negative correlation between Tª and mineral parameters (EC, Cl, HCO3, pH) was found in winter. This could have occurred due to the dilution effects during the winter season. Very strong positive correlations between Tª and EC, Mg, K, Cl and DOC were also found in summer. This could be attributed to the influence of baseflow in the concentrations of mineral parameters and the faster decomposition of organic matter with higher temperatures in summer. The latter could also explain the significant relation for DOC and Tª in autumn. Although DOC has good correlations with inorganic parameters in spring, summer and winter, such correlations became very poor in autumn, except for the sulphate. It is interesting to observe that DOC showed positive correlations with TKN in autumn, NO3 in winter and with both nitrogen compounds in the other two seasons. A positive correlation between DOC and HCO3 was found in spring but the correlation was negative in autumn, most likely due to the dilution effect during the autumn. Finally, pH showed a positive relation with Ca, Mg, Na, Cl, SO4 and NO3 in spring and negative in autumn. In addition, in winter pH was also correlated with Na, Cl, EC and HCO3. Good correlations also occurred with EC and HCO3 in spring. Limited correlations were obtained in summer.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Spring
-0.8
-0.8
TNK DOC NO3
Na Mg
Ca Cl SO4
-0.4 -0.6
-1
PC1
PC2
Summer
Summer
Na Mg K Ca Cl SO4 NO3
0.8
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-0.8
Cl SO4
-1
PC1 Figure 2:
TNK DOC
-0.4
NO3
-0.2
-0.6
-1
K
0 Ca
pH
-0.2
0.2
Na Mg
0
0.4 EC
TNK
Tª
0.2
Loadings (eigenvector)
0.6 HCO3
0.6
HCO3
0.8
pH
DOC
1
Tª
EC
1
0.4
pH
-0.2
-0.6
-1
Loadings (eigenvector)
0
K
-0.4
0.2
EC
Tª
0
0.4
Tª
0.6 Loadings (eigenvector)
0.2
-0.2
0.8
DOC TNK
0.4
HCO3
1
K
0.6 Loadings (eigenvector)
Na Mg
EC HCO3
pH
0.8
Ca Cl SO4 NO3
Spring 1
537
PC2
Component loadings for the first component (PC1) and the second component (PC2) in spring and summer.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
538 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Autumn
-0.4
SO4 NO3
Ca Cl
Na Mg K
pH
-0.2 -0.4
HCO3
-0.8
-1
-1
PC1
PC2
Winter
Winter
-0.4
-0.4 -0.6
-0.8
-0.8
-1
-1
Figure 3:
Ca Cl
-0.2
Na Mg
0
-0.6
PC1
K
0.2
EC
Tª
0
0.4
pH
0.2
0.6 Loadings (eigenvector)
TNK DOC
pH
0.4
HCO3
0.6
SO4 NO3 TNK DOC
0.8
Tª
1
K Ca
0.8
Cl SO4 NO3
Na Mg
EC
1
Loadings (eigenvector)
0
HCO3
-0.8
-0.2
0.2
-0.6 pH
-0.6
0.4
EC
HCO3
-0.2
TNK
0
0.6 Loadings (eigenvector)
DOC
0.2 Tª
Loadings (eigenvector)
0.4
TNK
0.8
0.6
Tª
1
K
0.8
DOC
Ca Cl SO4 NO3
Na Mg
EC
1
Autumn
PC2
Component loadings for the first component (PC1) and the second component (PC2) in fall and winter.
3.2 Identification of principal components After applying a PCA to the original database for spring, summer, fall and winter, several components were distinguished. Four principal components explaining 88.7% of the total variance for spring and 83.3% for winter were obtained. In summer and autumn, three principal components accounted for 80.3 and 81.1% of the total variance, respectively. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
539
Component loadings can be used to determine the relative importance of a variable as compared to other variables in a PC and do not reflect the importance of the component itself. They express the correlation between the original variables and the newly formed component. The component loadings of the first two retained PCs for each season are presented in Figs 2 and 3. In spring, the principal component 1 (PC1) explained 57.8% of the variance and showed high contribution of most variables: chloride, electrical conductivity, magnesium, calcium, sulphate, nitrate, sodium, and to a lesser extent, bicarbonate, potassium and dissolved organic carbon. These variables were shown to correlate (data not shown). The second component (PC2) explained 14.1% of the variance and included total nitrogen (Kjeldahl) and dissolved organic carbon, and to a lesser extent, bicarbonate and potassium. The third component (PC3) (8.7% of the variance) included TKN (positive loading) and potassium (negative participation). Finally, PC4 explained 8.1% of the total variability of the original data and was highly influenced by temperature. Similar component loading patterns were obtained for PC1 in summer (Fig. 2). That is, PC1 (which explained 58% of the total variance) was positively contributed to by EC, Mg, SO4, Ca, Cl, NO3, Na, K and DOC, whereas PC2 (which explained 12.6% of the total variance) was positively participated to by TKN, DOC and Tª and negatively impacted by HCO3. Furthermore, PC3 explained 9.6% of the variance and included Tª, pH (positive loading) and TKN (negative participation). In autumn, PC1, which accounted for 56.4% of the variance, had reliable positive contributions from Mg, EC, SO4, Cl, NO3, Ca and Na, in contrast to a significant negative contribution from pH. PC2, which represented 16.2% of the variance, was positively loaded by Tª and organic-related parameters (TKN and DOC) and negatively by HCO3. Furthermore, PC3, which accounted for 8.4% of the variance, was positively influenced by Tª and pH and negatively by TKN. In winter, PC1, which accounted for 49.9% of the total variance, was positively influenced by EC, Mg, Cl, SO4, NO3, Na, K and Ca. The second component, which explained 16.7% of the total variance, was positively correlated with DOC and negatively with pH and HCO3. The third (8.8% of the variance) included TKN. Finally, PC4 explained 7.9% of the total variability and it was contributed by pH and DOC. Vega et al. [6] and Ouyang et al. [11] had used exploratory data analysis to investigate the influence that seasonality and pollution have on the water quality of rivers. The first ones, in a study of two and half years (applying PCA to overall database), found that PC1 mostly contributed mineral parameters, similar to our results. However, PC1 in the study of Ouyang et al. [11], which applied PCA to four temporal databases (i.e., one database for each season), was largely participated by organic and physical parameters. These discrepancies could be due to characteristics of each catchment. As seen in Fig. 2, PC1 is highly participated by most variables for all four seasons, thus hindering its hydrochemical interpretation, and therefore cannot explain which parameters are more important than others in influencing water WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
540 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI physical-chemical variations within a given season. A rotation of principal components can achieve a simpler and more meaningful representation of the underlying factors by decreasing the contribution to PCs of variables with minor significance and increasing the more significant ones. Table 1 shows rotated factor correlation coefficients for the first factors in each season. In this study, parameters with correlation coefficients larger than 0.85 were taken into consideration in the interpretation. It must be noted that rotation has resulted in smaller groups of variables which can be now associated to individual rotated factors. The data in table 1 reveal that Cl, EC, Mg, SO4, NO3, Ca and Na were identified in the Corbeira stream for all four seasons, except the latter two variables in winter. On the other hand, K was an important parameter for water chemical variation in summer. In relation to organic parameters, only TKN in spring and winter and DOC in autumn contributed to water quality variation. Finally, temperature (physical parameter) just showed importance in spring. Table 1:
Rotated factor correlation coefficients for each season. Na
Mg
K
Ca
Cl
SO4
NO3
TKN
DOC
0.36 0.56 0.54 0.23
0.89 0.26 0.23 0.07
0.93 0.21 -0.1 0.02
0.55 0.08 -0.78 -0.03
0.92 0.24 -0.18 0.07
0.97 0.15 0.07 0.03
0.91 0.02 -0.24 -0.21
0.90 0.28 -0.01 0.07
0.01 0.93 0.06 -0.13
0.35 0.78 -0.09 0.10
0.98 0.08 -0.01
0.25 -0.28 -0.67
0.90 -0.13 -0.22
0.94 -0.10 -0.14
0.87 0.10 0.19
0.93 -0.09 -0.06
0.91 0.20 -0.06
0.93 0.03 0.02
0.91 -0.12 0.15
0.29 -0.17 0.83
0.66 0.42 0.16
-0.61 0.11 -0.50
0.98 0.04 -0.12
-0.13 -0.72 -0.24
0.95 -0.02 -0.01
0.97 0.02 0.06
0.71 -0.01 0.22
0.88 0.12 0.17
0.95 0.10 -0.18
0.95 0.16 0.01
0.93 0.10 0.02
-0.12 0.24 0.81
0.22 0.85 0.32
0.05 0.56 0.13 0.72
0.93 0.27 0.06 0.17
0.06 0.82 0.10 -0.06
0.72 0.35 0.32 0.21
0.90 0.25 0.24 0.03
0.84 -0.34 0.10 -0.01
0.58 0.22 0.54 -0.17
0.91 0.30 -0.02 0.16
0.97 -0.11 0.01 0.06
0.91 -0.11 0.08 0.23
0.09 -0.16 0.89 0.14
0.37 -0.4 0.05 0.72
EC HCO3
Tª
pH
Spring Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3 Factor 4
-0.05 0.00 0.03 0.98
0.67 0.08 0.52 -0.14
0.96 0.04 -0.02 -0.09
Summer Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3
0.3 0.77 -0.16
-0.26 0.74 0.20
Autumn Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3
-0.14 0.82 -0.26
Winter Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3 Factor 4
-0.13 -0.74 0.26 -0.04
These results reveal the influence of minerals (Cl, EC, Mg), inorganic (SO4, NO3) and organic parameters (TKN, DOC) in stream water quality variations. Minerals and inorganic parameters are present in all seasons. The mineral parameters may be interpreted as representing influences from natural inputs. The inorganic variables are likely the result of natural and anthropogenic sources. The natural origin of nitrates is related to the decomposition of organic matter, which is abundant in the catchment soils, whereas the anthropogenic origin is probably due to the septic tank systems and use of organic and inorganic fertilizers in agricultural areas of the catchment. These practices could WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
541
also explain the importance of TKN in spring, whereas in winter it is probably a consequence of surface runoff. In autumn, stream water showed strong influence of DOC, which could be transported with runoff caused by autumn precipitations. However, the results of this study should be interpreted with caution because most of the parameters studied could be affected simultaneously by other factors (e.g., flow) such as found Dieguez et al. [14] in a river catchment nearly to the study area.
4
Conclusions
The principal component analyses found a reduced number of principal components that explain most of the variance of the experimental dataset. A varimax rotation of these PCs revealed that chloride, conductivity, magnesium, sulphate and nitrate were always the most important variables contributing to water physical-chemical variations in the stream for all four seasons. The analyses also showed that there are other parameters (Ca, Na, K, DOC, TKN, Tª) that are important in contributing to water quality variation for one season but may not be for another. The most important parameters obtained to evaluate variations in the stream water quality studied are mineral, inorganic and organic parameters. The mineral parameters may be interpreted as representing influences from natural inputs (alteration of schist and soils of catchment). The inorganic and organic parameters could be attributed to the influence of both natural and anthropogenic inputs.
Acknowledgements This research is part of a project funded by MEC (Ministry of Education and Science, Spain)-FEDER (Project REN2003-08143) and Xunta of Galicia (Project PGIDIT05RAG10303). We thank MEC for the grant FPI (BES-2004-4927) awarded to ML Rodriguez. We are also grateful to Susana Clemente for her technical assistance.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
Dixon, W. & Chiswell, B., Review of aquatic monitoring program design, Water Resources, 30, pp. 1935-1948, 1996. Davis, J.C., Statistical and Data Analysis in Geology, ed. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1986. Manly, B.F.J., Multivariate Statistical Methods: A Primer, Chapman & Hall, London, 1986. Tabachnick, B.G. & Fidell, L.S., Using Multivariate Statistics, Allyn and Bacon, Boston, London, 2001. Shine, J.P., Ika, R.V. & Ford, T.E., Multivariate statistical examination of spatial and temporal patterns of heavy metal contamination in New WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
542 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
Bedford Harbor marine sediments, Environment Science of Technology, 29, pp. 1781-1788, 1995. Vega, M., Pardo, R., Barrado, E. & Debán, L., Assessment of seasonal and pollution effects on the quality of river water by exploratory data analysis, Water Research, 32 (12), pp. 3581-3592, 1998. Voutsa, D., Manoli, E., Smara, G., Sofoniou, M. & Stratis, I., A study of surface water quality in Macedonia, Greece: speciation of nitrogen and phosphorus, Water Air and Soil Pollution, 129, pp. 13-32, 2001. Gangopadhyay, S., Gupta, A.D. & Nachabe, M.H., Evaluation of ground water monitoring network by principal component analysis, Groundwater, 39, pp. 181-191, 2001. Bengraine, K. & Marhaba, T.F., Using principal component analysis to monitor spatial and temporal changes in water quality, Journal of Hazardous Material, B100, pp. 179-195, 2003. Ouyang, Y., Evaluation of river water quality monitoring stations by principal component analysis, Water Research, 39, pp. 2621-2635, 2005. Ouyang, Y., Tkedi-Kizza, P., Wu, Q.T., Shinde, D. & Huang, C.H., Assessment of seasonal variations in surface water quality, Water Research, 40, pp. 3800-3810, 2006. Jolliffe IT. Principal Component Analysis, Springer Series in Statistics, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1986. Haag, I. & Westrich, B., Processes governing river water quality identified by principal component analysis, Hydrological Processes, 16, pp. 3113-3130, 2002. Dieguez Villar A., Taboada Castro, M.M: & Taboada Castro, M.T., Ionic concentrations in surface waters of an agricultural catchment during storm events, Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 33(15-18), pp. 2673-2691, 2002.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
543
Fostering sustainable water supply in urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana: the case of Ho Municipality J. E. Koku1 & J.-E. Gustafsson2 1
Department of Geography and Resources Development, University of Ghana, Legon-Accra, Ghana 2 Department of Land and Water Resources Engineering, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden
Abstract This paper examines the water management situation in the Ho Municipality of Ghana. It provides an overview of the country’s draft water policy and its implications for water supply in the municipality. Also examined are households’ adaptation strategies in accessing water in the face of water scarcity and their attendant socio-economic implications. Results show that households adopt several coping strategies to access water in times of scarcity/shortage. These come in two basic forms. One entails utilisation of alternative sources, namely sachet water for drinking purposes, while water from open wells/boreholes served cooking, washing and bathing purposes. The second involves adjustment in water use at the individual level, e.g. reduction in quantity of water used for different purposes as well as the number of times one had to take a bath in a day. These practices have serious implications for health and well being of residents. To sustain water provision in the municipality, the paper calls for diversification of water supplies. This could be accomplished, for example, through linking boreholes to piped-water and also through promotion of rain water techniques to supplement existing supplies. Keywords: water supply, peri-urban, urban, water scarcity, adaptations, Ho Municipality, Ghana.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line) doi:10.2495/ECO070511
544 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
1
Introduction
The provision of safe, affordable and accessible potable water in urban and periurban areas had remained a challenge in Ghana. In recognition of the pivotal role played by water in sustaining life and health of its people, the government has implemented several strategies towards addressing the water needs of its citizens. Even though some of these strategies have yielded positive results, others have performed below expectation, depending on the implementation strategy put in place. Even in areas where initial results have been promising, the sustainability of the management strategy remains questionable.
Figure 1:
Map of the study area - Ho Municipality.
The Ho Municipality in the Volta Region of Ghana (Fig.1) of Ghana has had a long history of water shortage, despite the continued growth in its population over the past 16 years. For example, with a total population of 55,389 in 1984, the population of Ho has grown to about 235,331 in 2000 (Table 1). Consequently, such a growth has placed a compelling pressure on government to provide social amenities to meet the increasing population. Of all the social services that merit attention in Ho, provision of water appears to be the most critical. Although the area is served with piped water, frequent interruptions and shortage in supply do occur and these have often been blamed on technical and managerial lapses. However, in other instances irregular rainfall which also affect the volume of water in the Volta River, from which the main water works derive its source. Annual rainfall patterns in the Ho and its surroundings have shown seasonal fluctuations over the years (Fig.2a).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
Table 1:
545
Population distribution by gender (1984 and 2000).
Year
Total
Gender Male
Female
1984
27,494
27,895
55,389
2000
113,436
121,895
235,331
Source: Ghana Statistical Service (1984 & 2000). Population and Housing Census Summary Reports.
Annual Rainfall
Rainfall(mm)
2000 1500 1000 500
1989
1987
1985
1983
Years
1981
1979
1977
1975
1973
1971
0
(a) Jan
350
Feb 300 Rainfall (mm)
March April
250
May 200
June July
150
Aug
100
Sept Oct
50 0
Nov 1971
1973
1975
1977
1979
1981
1983
1985
1987
1989
Dec
Years
(b) Figure 2:
(a) Total Annual Rainfall Distribution (mm) in the Ho Municipal Area (1971-1990); (b) Rainfall Distribution in Ho Municipal Area (1971-1990).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
546 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI For example, rainfall data gathered between 1971 and 1990 has clearly demonstrated that apart from the major rainy season (March-July) when the greatest rainfall is received, November-February is characterized by low rainfall with figures rarely exceeding 100 mm (Fig.2b). Such situations have made the water situation more critical. Recently, the municipality has been earmarked to receive attention under the government’s new water sector reform programme, given its position as a fast growing urban centre (Table 1). The choice of Ho municipality also derives essentially from the chronic water shortage that characterises the Municipality. A major aim of the new programme is to provide safe, affordable, accessible and reliable water to people on a sustained basis. While one would like to applaud such an initiative, it is useful to plan the future with reference to what had pertained in the past. In other words, fostering a sustainable new water supply and management strategy would require a critical examination of the nature of the previous management strategies to determine existing gaps that need to be addressed in the new strategy.
2
Objective and structure of paper
This paper draws on findings from a survey conducted in the Ho Municipality of Ghana to discuss some issues of critical importance to the promotion of sustainable water supply in urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana. Although the thrust of the discussion will be on the Ho municipality and its environs, relevant references from other parts of Ghana and elsewhere will be drawn upon. This will enhance the readers understanding of the problem as it relates to the larger national context. The paper is organized under six sections. First, a brief background introduction is offered. This is followed by an outline of data sources and research methods used. A third section, which represents the main body of the paper, provides an overview of Ghana’s Draft Water Policy and its implication for the water supply situation in Ho Municipality. The fourth section examines households’ adaptation strategies in accessing water in the face of scarcity and their socio-economic implications. The fifth section discusses some alternative ways of promoting sustainable water delivery in the Ho Municipal area with focuses on the three cardinal concerns, i.e.—economic, social and environmental—which form the pillars of sustainable development. Lastly, a summary and some concluding remarks are offered.
3 Data and research methods Data for the paper were derived from both secondary and primary sources. The secondary data were generated from published materials—selected reports and journal articles that touched upon the theme of the paper. The primary data, on the other hand, came from questionnaire survey and in-depth interviews held in Ho Municipality and Sokode Gbogame (Fig.1). To facilitate the primary data collection, simple random sampling [1,2] was adopted to select a total sample size of 144 respondents from 72 households. From each household two persons including at least one female (where possible) were selected. The breakdown of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
547
this is as follows: 94 respondents from 47 households in Ho and 50 respondents from 25 households in Sokode Gbogame. The choice of simple random sampling in this case was considered appropriate, as the communities under review are homogenous in terms of the water crises they face. The sex composition of these was: 81 males and 63 females. The study design also took into consideration the fact that some of the respondents may, for some reason, not feel disposed to fill in the questionnaire themselves. The administration of the questionnaire thus took the form of interviews, as opposed to self-administration. Further, as a general guiding principle the survey was restricted to respondents above 17 years of age. The underlying reason was they were old enough to provide relevant responses to the issues addressed by the study. Lastly, in addition to the questionnaire survey carried out in the communities in-depth interviews were also carried out with some key government officials in the municipality, by virtue of their work, are well informed about the subject of the study.
4
Overview of the national water policy: implications for water supply situation in the Ho Municipality
Ghana has recently drafted a new water policy for streamlining operations in the water sector [3]. Policy recognizes the fundamental right of all people without discrimination to safe and adequate water to meet basic needs. It’s major objectives include first, provision of improved access to potable water, and second, ensuring that water resources are managed and developed in a manner, which as first priority safeguards that the entire population, particularly the poor and vulnerable, will have access to adequate and safe water supply. A number of institutional reforms to make water delivery more effective are being considered under the new policy. Key among them was to separate rural supply from the urban supply. Unlike in the past where rural and urban water supply was placed largely under the Ghana Water and Sewerage Corporation (GWSC), urban areas will now be served by the newly constituted Ghana Water Company Limited (GWCL), while rural areas will benefit from Community Water and Sanitation Agency (CWSA). By this the policy seeks also to ensure sustainable provision of and access to potable water to rural communities that will contribute towards the capital cost and ensure payment for normal operation, maintenance and repair cost of their facilities. This separation had raised questions among sections of the citizenry as to why sanitation was only tagged only to rural supplies to the exclusion of urban supplies. Some critics have therefore held that because the sanitation component is less profitable, the policy failed to incorporate into urban water delivery, which is mostly geared towards cost recovery and profits. While this criticism would remain largely debatable, one would have expected sanitation services to be incorporated in to the urban supplies since sanitation situations in some urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana are in deplorable situation. In all cases, sustainability has been given recognition as a critical issue. With respect to the rural supplies, sustainability is to be ensured through effective community ownership and management of the WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
548 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI facilities, active participation of women, public sector facilitation, sustainability and efficiency of the urban supplies is expected to result from public-private partnerships. By and large, the policy reforms as outlined above would have implications for access and delivery of water in most urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana. Households in the Ho Municipal Area have several water sources on which the inhabitants depend. Chief among them is piped water, which mainly serves the core area. But there are also other water facilities like boreholes, roof catchments, and hand-dug/drilled wells provided by the Volta Rural Water and Sanitation Project [4] as part of the Community Water and Sanitation program in the fringe communities. However, respondents identified piped water (73.7%), hand-dug wells (22.2%) and boreholes (4.2%) as major sources on which people depend for their water needs. While these sources have served domestic and other water requirements for the increasing population they hardly meet the needs of the growing population and have thus remained inadequate. Even where provision is made available through expansion in the urban supply, the probability of costs and tariffs increasing beyond the reach of the poor is high. It is generally accepted that now that people’s ability to opt for water delivery services depends on several factors among which income/economic status is a major determinant. Affordability of water under the new reforms where cost recovery is likely to override other interests would result in a situation where residents would be denied access since most of them earn low incomes. Apart from the few public servants and those business men/women, who may fall under what one might categorize as high-income group, most service beneficiaries earn very paltry incomes. The survey revealed that apart from a small proportion (34.7%) that indicated earning incomes of more than GHC 1.000.000 (Approx $100), majority earn less than 750.000.000 (Fig 3), which is equivalent to $75.
50 40 Frequency
30 20 10 0 Less than
250.000-
500.000.-
750.000-
Above
250.000
500.000
750.000
1000000
1.000.000
Income
Figure 3:
Estimated monthly income of respondents.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
549
However, it appears a significant proportion of household income is spent on water, which might have implications for future access. In this regard, a closer look at the proportion of income spent on water will be insightful as it would help assess whether poor households would continue meeting their water charges or not and the implications that are likely to arise as a result. To facilitate such an assessment, knowledge on income and expenditure on water was considered to be vital. As a result, respondents were asked to indicate how much they pay for a 50-litre container (bucket/bowl) of water drawn from publicly installed piped water. Results show for example that of the incomes earned, majority pay between GHC 150.000-300.000 for a 50-litre bucket of water. It further also showed that family sizes in the area range from a minimum of four persons to as high as fifteen, with majority (58.2%) having family sizes of between 5 and 9. Now, relating this to the generally accepted 50-litre/day water required to maintain an average person [5], would imply that for a family with a minimum size of 5 persons, GHC 22.500 will be spent on water assuming that GHC150 is charged for a 50-litre quantity of water. This could become worrisome to persons with meager monthly incomes, as it would imply spending a significant proportion of their monthly income on water, leaving as a result little for other basic household necessities—i.e. food, health etc. It also further raises questions as to whether households’ patronage of the water services can be sustained. Where households in peri-urban areas are incapable of meeting water needs for reasons relating to higher charges, the tendency to resort to unhygienic water resources becomes rife with its attendant problems. This would erode the benefits envisaged under the reform unless efforts are made to address such concerns.
5
Households’ water utilization and adaptation to water scarcity: some socio-economic and public health implications
Adaptation to resource scarcity has been a subject of discussion in recent times [6–8]. Governments and policy makers in the developing world have preoccupied themselves with scarcity/access to resource components such as land, water, forestry etc. In sub-Saharan Africa resource users have adopted ways of adapting to resource scarcity at various levels, namely—household, regional and national levels. In Ghana, the water sector is one resource area where such adaptations have found the greatest expression. In periods of water crises— whatever the cause and situation—people’s access are affected, compelling them to alter their normal water handling practices. In response to the crisis, it is common to encounter situations where people develop strategies either to have access to alternative sources of water or to economize the use of the little they have. These may entail exploration and utilization of alternative sources, altering of individual water handling practices so as to minimize waste of the resources or preserve the little available. Adjustments such as reductions in the quantity of water use per day or development of multiple use of water at the household level are illustrative of the point. In particular, the latter practice—i.e. involving WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
550 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI multiple use of water at the household level—is common in urban and peri-urban low income settlements where waste water (i.e. grey water) from washing of clothes (laundry) is used to flush water closets (WCs) instead of using clean water for such purposes. In the same vein, it is also common to encounter a situation where such waste water is used to wash plates in the first instance before using clean water to rinse it. This is meant to economize on the use of the clean water available for bathing, cooking and other purposes. Notwithstanding the above, it is equally worth acknowledging at this point that following massive health education in Ghana, there is a noticeable hygienic water handling practice amongst residents of low income settlements, where water from perceived unwholesome sources is boiled for drinking purposes. While these practices have serious implications for health and personal hygiene they nevertheless demonstrate how households behave when faced with a water crises situation. The lessons from such coping strategies, whether rational or otherwise, are useful in sensitizing health and development planners to the risks faced by such vulnerable groups. The scare water situation experienced by people in the study area as a result of the factors noted earlier had placed households under severe pressure especially when access to piped water cannot be guaranteed due to factors identified earlier. Under such circumstances, households adopt several ways of sourcing water. However, the adaptations vary in relation to the purpose for which water is required—i.e. water for cooking, washing/bathing and drinking. In the sections below, attempts will be made to explain the various adaptations as they relate to these three purposes. 5.1 Adaptation strategies for accessing water for drinking purposes Drinking water is one key requirement that households cannot dispense with. In a major rainy season (March-July) it is easy for households in the study area to access water for drinking, cooking and washing/bathing, since interruptions in supply of piped water do not occur frequently. However the same cannot be said of the dry season (November-February), when water is generally scarce. Faced with water shortages, households within the Ho Municipality adopt several strategies to cope with the scarce water situation. Among the major strategies pursued to get access to drinking water are purchase of sachet water (commonly referred to as pure water in Ghana), use of stored water, reliance on open wells and boreholes. Of these, reliance on sachet water appears to be most prevalent (Table 2). Results of the survey indicated the almost half of the respondents (44%) rely on sachet water to meet their drinking water needs; 14 % resort to the use of stored water, while a few others also rely on open wells as source of drinking water. This shows quite clearly that consumers within the municipality have rated the quality of sachet water and piped water supplied in the municipality as good. Such ratings have often been premised on perceived attributes of good water. Among the attributes of good drinking water distinguished in the water management literature are color, smell, taste and freshness [9]. These four physical properties are generally regarded as critical for selecting water for WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
551
drinking and cooking. Preference for sachet water and open wells as enumerated by the respondents is informed by the belief that they do posses such attributes. For example, asked to enumerate qualities of good drinking water, the respondents identified clarity, colorless, tasteless, treated, odorless sweet, hygienic, as major attributes of a good drinking water, which confirms the general observations noted in the literature. Therefore in periods of water scarcity when piped water which does possess the same qualities is difficult to get, they would prefer to purchase sachet water as good supplement. Table 2:
Adaptation strategies in water used for drinking purposes.
Strategies for accessing water for drinking purposes in the periods of scarcity. Reliance on Sachet water Reliance on Stored water Reliance on Open wells Borehole water No Change in strategy Others Total Source: Field Survey, 2006.
Frequency
Percent
31 14 9 2 9 6 71
44 20 13 03 13 07 100
However, it would be equally useful at this point to devote some attention to some risks associated with its consumption. The use of sachet water has recently emerged as an important sub-sector of the urban water delivery system which is in vibrant operation in urban areas of Africa, but has received little attention in research [10,11] and policy discussions. In Ghana, the sachet water (0.5 litre of water packed in plastics) popularly referred to as pure water, is consumed not only by the lower class but also popular among the upper and middle social class. In the Ho Municipality as in most urban areas of Ghana, the supply shortfall in household drinking water supply coupled with the poor quality and inefficiency of the public water delivery system has given rise to increasing dependence on sachet water for domestic consumption. Consequently, there are many sachet water producing industries located in various parts of the country. For instance in a peri-urban areas of Accra, one can identify over 100 different brands of sachet water on sale in the markets and by vendors most of whom are operating illegally without appropriate permission from quality assurance agencies such as the Ghana Standards Board. While the introduction of Sachet water industries in the water sector could be a way of supplementing existing arrangements for piped water delivery, the quality of these products has often not been monitored to ensure public health safety and good practice within the sector.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
552 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Given the increasing reliance on sachet water in urban and peri-urban areas of Ghana some scientists have carried out studies on the quality of such water in some parts of the country. Results from a few of these studies suggest that the operations of the sachet water sector merits critical attention as most of the socalled pure water sold in urban communities such as Kumasi and Cape Coast are of doubtful quality [10,11] and yet consumed by a large proportion of the urban dwellers. For example the Kumasi study which focused on bottled water, sachet water and hand-filled hand-tied bagged water showed that heterotrophic bacteria were found in all three types of water with TVCs per millilitre ranging from 1 to 460 for bottled water, 2–6·33 × 105 for factory-bagged sachet water and 2·33 × 103–7·33 × 1012 for hand-filled hand-tied bagged water [11]. Although, none of the microbial indicators of faecal contamination were detected in bottled water, 4·5% of the factory-bagged sachets contained total coliforms and 2·3% faecal coliforms, and 42·5% of the hand-filled hand-tied bags contained total coliforms, 22·5% faecal coliforms and 5% enterococci. So far, no known rigorous and systematic study of the quality of sachet water produced and consumed in the Ho Municipality and it’s surrounding has been carried out. The same can be said of the piped water supplied in the area. The above findings suggest that the quality of water delivered by private companies (i.e. the bottled and the sachet water) needs a critical examination, if public health standards are to be promoted. Table 3:
Adaptation strategies in water use for cooking purposes.
Adaptations strategies for accessing water for cooking purposes Open Well Sachet water Stored water Boiled Stream water Borehole water No change in strategy TOTAL
Frequencies 26 5 14 2 5 17 69
Percent 18.1 3.5 9.7 1.4 3.5 11.8 100
Source: Field Survey, 2006. 5.2 Adaptation strategies for accessing water for cooking purposes Consumers’ choice of alternative water sources for cooking purposes is fairly close to that pursued for drinking purposes. For example, the study revealed that households resort to boreholes, use of sachet water, and stored-water inter alia to meet their water requirements for cooking (Table 3) in times of water scarcity— i.e. the periods between November and February. Of the options noted, reliance on open wells appears to be the most prevalent. Twenty-six (18.1%) of the 69 responses had identified open-wells as an alternative water source for domestic cooking in periods of scarcity (Table 3). WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
553
Other practices such as use of storage of water (notably rain water), purchase of sachet water, reliance on boreholes amongst others are also considered. However, these do not seem to be popular compared to reliance on well water. 5.3 Adaptation strategies for accessing water for bathing/washing purposes Singh et al, [9] have discussed some attributes that consumers, notably women consider while searching for alternative water sources for washing or bathing purposes. They observed among other issues that the water qualities regarded as important for washing and cleaning generally arise from a subjective evaluation of the cleaning capacity, besides clarity of the water itself. They noted in particular that the cleaning capacity in turn is linked to the quality of ‘softness’ of water [9]. In general good quality water for washing clothes is expected to give a good lather and cause no discolouration. Similarly, water for bathing is often associated with qualities such as clarity, cleanliness as well as accessibility and availability. It comes therefore as no surprise when people prioritize surface water over groundwater for laundry purposes. The choice of water source for washing/bathing follows a pattern that is similar to that adopted for cooking discussed earlier (cf. Table 4). Results from the questionnaire survey suggest here again that dependence on open well was the most popular, representing 46.4% of the strategies pursued to assess water for bathing purposes in times of scarcity. However, the study also revealed other strategies that have been adopted at a personal level (cf. Table 4). Some of these include, bathing once a day (15.9%) and washing once a week (7.2%). Table 4:
Adaptation strategies in water use for bathing/washing purposes.
Adaptation strategies for accessing water for bathing/washing purposes Open wells Fetch water from streams Use piped water Borehole water Bath once a day Wash once a week Other Total Source: Field Survey, 2006.
Frequencies
Percent
32 3 8 9 11 5 1 69
46.4 4.3 11.6 13.0 15.9 7.2 1.4 100
While these practices appear to be less pronounced given the proportion of respondents that engage in such strategies they have serious implications for health and personal hygiene. Dependence on open wells is an age-old practice that is commonly associated with rural areas in Ghana. However, it is gradually gaining popularity in urban and peri-urban areas; given the unreliable nature of WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
554 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI potable water service provision is such areas. This observation is supported by recent studies in the New Juabeng Municipality in the Eastern Region of Ghana [12] where problems of water shortage are equally pronounced. However, it could be argued at this point that, the preference attached to open wells as an alternative source of water is indicative of some perceived benefits associated with it. The most easily identifiable reasons may relate to the fact that (i) its technology is widely-known, (ii) it is often located within easy reach of many in the communities and (iii) that it is cheaper to construct compared to other alternative modern water sources such as boreholes fitted with pumps. This not withstanding, it is important to note that the overall sustainability of opens wells requires not only its ability to yield water for the satisfaction of people’s water needs—i.e. it must be broadened to encompass basic hygienic practices that need to be adhered to guarantee a good quality of water. Regrettably, this is not the case in many communities as most wells are cited in public places in communities and open to everybody’s use, thus exposing them to the risk of biological contamination.
6
Alternative ways of promoting sustainable water delivery in the Ho Municipality
Achieving sustainable water supply in the Ho municipality calls for a sober reflection on water sources that will satisfy social, economic and environmental concerns, which are generally accepted to constitute the three pillars of sustainable development. However, current practices in water provision, not only in Ho but also in most parts of Ghana, do not seem to consider all three aspects in equal measure. In most instances, emphasis is placed on economic feasibility of water supplies to the neglect of social and environmental sustainability. In the Ho Municipality, piped water stands out as the most preferred water source, and has therefore received premium over other sources. While this water source could be justified on the grounds of it being cleaner, safer and healthier, its production and sustainable maintenance requires a much higher capital injection related to other sources. To recover costs therefore there is the tendency to raise charges in such a way as to satisfy both the producer and the consumer. The pursuit of this management strategy is often assumed to be the best to keep water producers in business. However, experience shows that this has often brought in its wake problems, since relevant social concerns such as consumer preference and continuous patronage are largely ignored. For instance, consumer’s continuous patronage of a particular water source is often weighed against affordability and also tied to income. As such in situations where households consider themselves incapable of coping with increasing charges, shifts to alternative sources becomes a more compelling option. The study demonstrated that households’ apart from piped water have considered open wells and boreholes as alternative sources of water to meet basic water requirements. In view of the scarce water situation that besets the municipality, it would seem desirable if consideration could be given to augmenting the piped water system with other sources. That is, where technical WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
555
and hydro-geological conditions would permit, one option could be to combine borehole with piped water. For example, in areas where salinity levels are considered low, boreholes could be sunk and connected to feed the piped network. This strategy has been considered in some parts of southern Tanzania as a useful way of supplementing existing piped water sources to serve households in urban and peri-urban areas [13]. Another source is the use of rainwater. Although rainwater has not been identified in the study as an important water source, it is increasingly being recognised as a vital supplement to piped water supply in urban areas [14]. Rainwater harvesting is a technology used for collecting and storing water from rooftops, the land surfaces, steep slopes, road surfaces or rock catchments using simple techniques such as pots, tanks and cisterns as well as more complex techniques such as underground check dams [15,16]. This technology is not new in Ghana. It has served as useful sources of water for rural households. However, it has largely been ignored in considering alternative water sources for urban consumption. Its promotion in Ho municipality could help supplement the piped water system. Zhu et al [14] have outlined its benefits noting amongst other things that it is convenient as it provides water at the point of consumption. Moreover, its adoption in the study area could allow family members have full control of their system (ibid), which greatly reduces operation and maintenance problems.
7 Summary and concluding remarks This paper which is sectioned into seven parts examined the water management situation in the Ho Municipality of Ghana. It provides an overview of the country draft water policy and its implications for the water supply situation in the municipality. Using this as the context it examined households’ adaptation strategies in accessing water in the face of water scarcity and some socioeconomic implications and outlines some alternative ways of promoting sustainable water delivery in the Ho. A number of issues emerged from the study. The first of interest to note is the fact that, although the municipality is served with piped water, it is fraught with water crises with frequent interruptions. This occurs not only in the wet season and sometimes in the dry season. Households in periods of scarcity have therefore had to resort to several adaptation strategies to cope with the problem of scarcity. The adaptations have come in two basic forms. The first entails consideration of alternative water sources, namely: reliance on sachet water for drinking purposes, whilst water from open wells and boreholes are used for cooking and washing and bathing purposes. The second involves adjustment in water use strategies at the individual level. These include reduction in quantity of water used for different purposes as well as the number of times one had to take a bath in a day. These coping strategies have serious socio-economic implications for individuals as well as households. For example, most of these water sources attract charges that are fairly high, relative to the low income levels of residents. In such circumstances it is most unlikely that individuals and households would be able to access adequate quantities of water to meet their WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
556 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI basic requirements. Even if adequate access would not constitute a constraint, the growing population trend in the municipality would require consideration of alternative sources that could supplement existing supplies. In light of this, it is recommended that water supply in the municipality be sustained by diversify sources to include for example linking boreholes to the piped water and also through the promotion of rain water harvesting techniques.
Acknowledgements We hereby acknowledge Sida/Formas Research Councils, Sweden for providing a grant for this study.
References [1] [2] [3] [4]
[5] [6]
[7] [8] [9] [10]
[11]
Argyrous, G, (1997). Statistics for Social Research. MacMillian Press Ltd. London, UK Nachmias, C.F and Nachmias, D.N (1996). Research Methods in the Social Sciences. St Martins Press, Inc. 1996 MoWH (2005) National Water Policy, Draft for Discussion, March 2005. Ministry of Works and Housing, Government of Ghana. Muzzu, E, (1998). An Evaluation of the Volta Rural Water and Sanitation Project in the Ho District. (Undergraduate Dissertation), Department of Geography and Resource Development, University of Ghana, LegonAccra. Gleick, P.H (2000). The worlds water 1998-1999: The Biennial Report on Freshwater Resources’ www.worldwater.org Sikana P.M. and Mwambazi, T.N (1996). Environmental Change and Livelihoods. In: Reij C, Scoones I and Toulman C (eds). Sustaining the Soil: Indigenous soil water conservation in Africa. Earthscan Publishing Ltd (UK). Nyong A. O. and Kanaroglou P. S. (2004) Domestic Water Use in Rural Semiarid Africa: A Case Study of Katarko Village in Northeastern Nigeria. Human Ecology Volume 27, Number 4 / December, 1999 Koku, J.E (2003). Tree planting, local knowledge and specie preference in the South Tongu District of Ghana. A case study. GeoJournal 57: 227239. Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Netherlands. Singh N, Battacharya, P, Jacks G and Gustafsson, J-E (2004). Women and Modern Water Supply Systems: Need for a Holistic Perspective. Water Resources Management 18: 237-248, 2004. Obiri-Danso K, Okore-Hanson A, and Jones K. (2003). The microbiological quality of drinking water sold on the streets in Kumasi, Ghana. Letters in Applied Microbiology. Volume 37 Page 334 - October 2003 Dodoo DK, Quagraine EK, Okai-Sam F, Kambo DJ, and Headley JV (2006). Quality of "Sachet" Waters in the Cape Coast Municipality of
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
[12]
[13] [14] [15]
[16]
557
Ghana. J Environ Sci Health A Tox Hazard Subst Environ Eng. 2006 Mar; 41(3):329-42. Ahari, E. (2006). The problem of Potable Water Supply in the New Juabeng Area, Koforidua. Department of Geography and Resource Development, University of Ghana Legon-Accra. (Unpublished Undergraduate dissertation.) Kjellen, M (2006). From Public Pipes to Private Hands: Water Assess and Distribution in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. (PhD Dissertation). Department of Human Geography, Stockholm University, Sweden. Zhu, K, Zhang L, Hart W, Liu M, Chen H (2004). Quality issues in Harvested Rainwater in Arid and Semi-Arid Loess Plateau of Northern China. Journal of Arid Environments 57(2004) 487-505. Appan, A (1999). Economic and Water Quality Aspects of Rainwater Catchment System. Proceedings of International Symposium on Efficient Water use in Urban Areas. UNEP Int. Environ. Tech. Center Osaka, Japan. Prinz, D. (1999). Water Harvesting Techniques in Mediterranean Region. Proceedings of the International Seminar Rainwater Harvesting and Management in Arid and Semi Arid Areas. Lund University Press Lund Sweden
WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 106, © 2007 WIT Press www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
This page intentionally left blank
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
559
Author Index Abhyankar A. C. ...................... 493 Alkass S. .................................... 43 Alonso J. .......................... 205, 215 Amrusch P. .............................. 511 Baodi D.................................... 437 Baros Z. ................................... 395 Barufaldi M................................ 69 Becchis F. ................................ 263 Beltramini L............................. 483 Bezerra J. F. R. ........................ 123 Bhattacharyya R....................... 123 Bilaletdin Ä................................ 91 Blott D. .................................... 285 Bonete M. J................................ 61 Booth C. A............................... 123 Bos E. J. ................................... 275 Bousbouras D. ......................... 375 Brandli L.................................. 165 Bühmann C. ............................. 123 Buteau E. R.............................. 195 Byrne M................................... 101 Caldana A. ............................... 145 Caligaris M. ............................. 483 Carrasco M. ............................. 483 Castellani V. ............................ 365 Castro P.................................... 205 Cobo F. .................................... 215 Cole A...................................... 123 Confalone A............................... 81 Corkill C. ................................. 123 Cuong T. H. ............................. 123 Dávid L. ................................... 395 Davies K. ................................. 123 Daxbeck H. .............................. 511 De Medici S. ............................ 175 Dearlove M. ............................. 123 Denafas G. ............................... 463 Diaz A. R. ................................ 251 Dincyurek O. ........................... 155
Easteal A. J. ............................. 493 Edmonds N. R. ........................ 493 Eskinazi-Leça E....................... 185 Feizi M..................................... 407 Franco A. ................................. 251 Frandoloso M. A. L. ................ 165 Fullen M. A. ............................ 123 Gabellini M................................ 35 García-Alonso F. ........... 61, 69, 81 Genon G................................... 263 Gnauck A............................... 3, 13 González M. ............................ 215 Grether R. ................................ 483 Griskonis E. ............................. 503 Guerra A. J. T. ......................... 123 Guerra C. ......................... 205, 215 Guerra T. T. ............................. 123 Guglielmi M. ........................... 145 Gustafsson J.-E. ............... 331, 543 Haddad S. M.............................. 43 Haghighat F. .............................. 43 Hahtala R.-L. M....................... 521 Hoffman J. ............................... 321 Huuhtanen S. R........................ 521 Imandoust S. B. ....................... 295 Jakab G. ................................... 123 Jallow S. .................................. 123 Jankauskas B. .......................... 123 Jankauskiene G. ....................... 123 Jankunaite D. ........................... 503 Jonsyn-Ellis F. ......................... 123 Kahouli-Brahmi S.................... 227 Kaipainen H............................... 91 Kajaste S. A. ............................ 521 Karhu A. E............................... 521 Kemppainen S. H..................... 521
560 Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI Kertesz A. ................................ 123 Kohler R. ................................. 165 Koku J. E. ........................ 331, 543 Koliopoulos T. ......................... 449 Koliopoulou G. ........................ 449 Kostiukovsky V. ...................... 387 Kozma K.................................. 123 Kugan R................................... 123 Kuldkepp K.............................. 353 Kull A. ..................................... 353 Külvik M.................................. 353 Kuusik R. ................................. 473 La Porta B.................................. 35 La Valle P. ................................. 35 Lattanzi L................................... 35 Li T. ......................................... 123 Lilieholm R. J. ......................... 195 Linsiö O. A. ............................. 521 López H. .................................. 483 Luckhurst D. A. ....................... 123 Luther B..................................... 13 Mander Ü................................. 353 Mansouri H. ............................. 407 Marchettini N........................... 145 Martínez-Espinosa R. ................ 61 Mendonça J. K. S..................... 123 Mengyu L. ............................... 437 Millar M. A.............................. 101 Mishima S.-I. ........................... 417 Moreno-Sanchez R. ................. 113 Mostafazadeh-Fard B............... 407 Mousavi S. F............................ 407 Mulholland B. .......................... 123 Mulibana E. ............................. 123 Neace M. B. ............................... 25 Nell J. P.................................... 123 Ngwenya B. N. ........................ 303 Niccolucci V. ........................... 145 Nicoletti L.................................. 35 Ohe Y....................................... 425 Oktay M................................... 155 Oliveira-Carvalho M. F............ 185
Paganelli D. ............................... 35 Panomtarachichigul M............. 123 Partti M.-M. A. ........................ 521 Parviainen A. ............................. 91 Paterson G. .............................. 123 Pazzini A. .................................. 35 Pereira S. M. B. ....................... 185 Peres S. M................................ 123 Peukrai S.................................. 123 Pitea D. .................................... 365 Pizzigallo A. C. I. .................... 145 Poesen J. .................................. 123 Prokopiou D. G........................ 375 Ptasinski K. J. .......................... 239 Pulselli R. M.............................. 55 Quanqi L.................................. 437 Quaranta N............................... 483 Rey J. ....................................... 205 Reyes J. A...................... 61, 69, 81 Rodríguez-Blanco M. L. .......... 533 Rozelle J. ................................. 113 Ruskeeniemi T........................... 91 Sala S. ...................................... 365 Sarsby R. W............................. 123 Sastre-Vázquez P....................... 69 Sathler R. ................................. 123 Sayadyan H.............................. 113 Senia C..................................... 175 Smets T.................................... 123 Songlie Y. ................................ 437 Streeter R. ................................ 113 Suarez M.................................. 483 Subedi M. ................................ 123 Szalai Z.................................... 123 Taboada-Castro M. M.............. 533 Taboada-Castro M. T............... 533 Taleshi M................................. 313 Targusi M. ................................. 35 Thakadu O. T........................... 303 Thu D. C. ................................. 123 Tiezzi E. B. P............................. 55 Tiezzi E...................................... 55
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development VI
561
Toan T. T. ................................ 123 Toanoglou M. .......................... 375 Toth A...................................... 123 Toth R. E.................................. 195 Trikkel A.................................. 473 Tselentis B. S. .......................... 375
Vassiljev P. .............................. 353 Verdú F...................................... 81 Villacampa Y................. 61, 69, 81 Vleugel J. M. ........................... 275
Uibu M..................................... 473 Unsen M. ................................. 483 Urniezaite I. ............................. 503
Xunbo Z................................... 437
van der Merwe G. M. E. .......... 123
Wei S. .......................................... 3
Yi Z.......................................... 123 Yongmei L............................... 123 Yuhai C.................................... 437
This page intentionally left blank
...for scientists by scientists
Steps Towards an Eco-Exergy as Evolutionary Physics Sustainability E. TIEZZI, University of Siena, Italy This book introduces the elements of a new idea of physics, an evolutionary physics, based on the intuitions and fundamental work of Chemistry Nobel Prize Winner and Professor at Brussels University, Ilya Prigogine. Intended as a scientific book, text book and as a popular scientific essay, this text will be of interest to technical, graduate and curious audiences. The main topics dealt in the book are:Epistemological Basis of Evolutionary Thermodynamics; Far from Equilibrium: Thermodynamics and Irreversibility; The Concept of Negentropy (from Boltzman to Szent-György, through Schrödinger’s “What’s Life”); Introduction to Ecodynamics: Fundamental Principles; Cross-Fertization between Evolutionary Thermodynamics and Systems Ecology; The Supramolecular Structure of Water: a Magnetic Resonance Approach; Nuclear Spin Relaxation Times-Dissipative Structures in Nature: the Bat’s Case (Biodiversity and Strange Attractors); Application of Ecodynamic Models to Sustainable Development; Biosphere Global Ecodynamic Models; Dissipative Structures and Design. It’s a question of real change of paradigm both as regards classical physics and as regards classical physical chemistry. Enzo Tiezzi is a Full Professor of Physical Chemistry at the University of Siena. A former Fulbright scholar, his research subjects have focused on magnetic resonance and have turned to complex-system environmental science. He has authored numerous texts on these subjects in Italian, English, Spanish and Portuguese. Series: The Sustainable World, Vol 15 ISBN: 1-84564-035-7 2006 176pp £58.00/US$95.00/€87.00
S.E. JØRGENSEN, The University of Pharmaceutical Science, Denmark In recent years, the economy has determined the agenda when environmental issues are concerned using cost/benefit analyses. This inevitably leads to wrong decisions because the uncertainties of the cost/benefit analyses are often magnitudes higher than that estimated by the economists. Therefore, these analyses should be replaced or supplemented by the concept of sustainability to aid the decision-making process. This book represents the first attempt to apply eco-exergy, a thermodynamic concept used to describe the development of ecosystems, to express sustainability and use it in a nonecological context Partial Contents: Introduction; You cannot escape the thermodynamic laws; Exergy; Application of Eco-Exergy in Human Activities and Ecosystems; Eco-Exergy as an Ecosystem Health Indicator; Eco-Exergy as an Ecosystem Health Indicator for Lakes; Eco-exergy as an Ecosystem Health Indicator for Coastal Areas; Eco-Exergy as an Ecosystem Health Indicator for Agricultural Systems; Eco-exergy Losses and Gains in the Society; Properties of Ecosystems; Ecological and Sustainable Management of Agricultural Systems; Ecological and Sustainable Management of Industrial Systems; A Society Based on Ecological Principles; Conclusions and Summary; Index. Series: The Sustainable World, Vol 16 ISBN: 1-84564-059-4 2006 £73.00/US$131.00/€109.50
224pp
All prices correct at time of going to press but subject to change. WIT Press books are available through your bookseller or direct from the publisher.
...for scientists by scientists
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development V Edited by: E. TIEZZI, University of Siena, Italy, C.A. BREBBIA, Wessex Institute of Technology, UK, S.E. JØRGENSEN, DFH, Environmental Chemistry, Denmark and D. ALMORZA GOMAR, University of Cadiz, Spain Beyond the specific dimension of the individual, learning is a primary characteristic of life. Shifting our attention to local systems we can consider ecosystems and traditional communities as learning ‘minds’, according with Bateson’s thought. We call environmental wisdom the explicit knowledge that emerges from long periods of co-evolution of people and nature in local systems, cast in the same lot. Environmental wisdom rises both from trial-and-error and from more subtle kinds of knowledge, involving aesthetic and intuition. It sediments as tradition or religion and deeply contribute to landscapes creation, keeping ecosystems and humans alive together. It is our belief, that in order to survive, local communities should re-connect themselves with their biological basis. As a first option we need to pay new attention to our boundaries: not to avoid contacts, exchanges, cross-fertilization with other people and other lands, but to reduce the impact of globalization and to retain cultural biodiversity. Only a network of self-centred communicating communities can provide a sufficient basis of diversity to achieve long-term sustainability. We believe we are living a moment of general crisis, a re-learning transition period that is inherently uncertain, and therefore we have to enlarge our cultural and technological basis, avoiding homogenization as the primary source of fragility.
This book contains the proceedings from the fifth International Conference on Ecosystems and Sustainable Development. With over 70 contributions divided into sections such as: Biodiversity; Conservation and Management of Ecological Areas; Environmental and Ecological Policies; Natural Resources Management; Recovery of Damaged Areas and Remote Sensing. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, Vol 81 ISBN: 1-84564-013-6 2005 776pp £272.00/US$435.00/€408.00
Trace and Ultratrace Elements in Plants and Soil Edited by: I. SHTANGEEVA, St. Petersburg State University, Russia Containing articles written by 17 scientists from 10 countries, this book describes different aspects of analytical chemistry, rhizosphere chemistry and the environmental chemistry of trace elements. It also highlights areas where collaboration between biochemists, soil scientists, analytical chemists and plant physiologists would be most productive. Contents: Biogeochemistry of Gold Accepted Theories and New Opportunities; Exploratory Multivariate Data Analysis of Soil and Plant Multi-Element Data; Metal and Arsenic Bioavailability and Uptake by Hyperaccumulator Plants; Cadmium; Phytoremediation of Lead; Processes and Factors Regulating the Behaviour and Uptake of Trace Elements in the Rhizosphere; Copper; Thorium; Scandium; Arsenic in Plants, Soils and Foodstuffs. Series: Advances in Ecological Sciences, Vol 20 ISBN: 1-85312-960-7 2004 364pp £136.00/US$218.00/€204.00
...for scientists by scientists
Multifunctional Landscapes
Multifunctional Landscapes
Volume I - Theory, Values and History
Volume II - Monitoring, Diversity and Management
Edited by: J. BRANDT, University of Roskilde, Denmark and H. VEJRE, The Agricultural University, Copenhagen, Denmark
Edited by: J. BRANDT, University of Roskilde, Denmark and H. VEJRE, The Agricultural University, Copenhagen, Denmark
The pressure on land resources in densely populated industrialized countries is now immense. Multifunctional management is therefore a prerequisite for the sustainable use of landscapes, and the only general strategy that may address the problems created by constantly growing demands on resources. Encouraging interdisciplinary discussions concentrating on a conscious and precise use of related concepts, and emphasizing the practical application of landscape sciences and management, Multifunctional Landscapes: Volumes I, II and III contain papers originally presented at the conference on this topic held in Roskilde, Denmark in 2000. These have since been peer-reviewed and revised for publication. This volume stresses the importance of establishing a new framework for understanding and interpreting landscapes and their various functions and values in space and time. The contributions included are: A Theoretical Foundation for the Study of Multifunctional Landscapes; Ecological Aspects of Multifunctional Landscapes in Historical Perspectives; and Values and Assessment of Multifunctional Landscapes.
This volume focuses on the discussion and research recommendations relating to three different aspects of future landscape research concerning planning and management. These are Monitoring Multifunctional Landscapes; Biodiversity Versus Landscape Diversity in Multifunctional Landscapes; and Complexity of Landscape Management.
Series: Advances in Ecological Sciences, Vol 14 ISBN: 1-85312-930-5 2003 292pp £99.00/US$158.00/€148.50 Find us at http://www.witpress.com
Series: Advances in Ecological Sciences, Vol 15 ISBN: 1-85312-934-8 2003 312pp £99.00/US$158.00/€148.50
Ecosystems and Sustainable Development IV Edited by: E. TIEZZI, University of Siena, Italy, C.A. BREBBIA, Wessex Institute of Technology, UK, and J-L. USO, Universitat Jaume I, Spain A two volume set containing almost 120 contributions first presented at the fourth in this influential series of meetings. Topics covered include: Ecosystems Modelling; Environmental Management; Sustainable Development Issues; Recovery of Damaged Areas; and Water Resources. Series: Advances in Ecological Sciences, Vols 18 & 19 SET ISBN: 1-85312-834-1 2003 £363.00/US$579.00/€544.50
...for scientists by scientists
Multifunctional Landscapes
Consequences of Land Use Changes
Volume III - Continuity and Change
Edited by: Ü. MANDER, University of Tartu, Estonia and R. JONGMAN, Wageningen Agricultural University, The Netherlands
Edited by: Ü. MANDER, University of Tartu, Estonia and M. ANTROP, University of Gent, Belgium Containing an overview of case studies carried out throughout Europe, the common focus in this book is on the interaction between land use practices and the biotic and abiotic environment in history. Most of the chapters therefore deal with cultural landscapes. Contributions featured include: Landscape Coherence - A New Criterion for Evaluating Impacts of Land Use Changes; Landscape Mosaics Recognition and Changes Over Time - A Methodological Approach; Continuity and Grassland Management in a Multifunctional Landscape in Middle Jutland (Denmark); Biodiversity and Land Use History of the Alpine Riparian Landscapes (the Example of the Isère River Valley, France); Changes in Nitrogen Input via Subsurface Drainage Systems into the Mulde Catchment (Germany) – A Mesoscale Approach; Ecological Networks in Estonia – From Classical Roots to Current Applications.
Representing an important step forward for regional and inter-regional development of integrated landscape ecological research in the field of land use changes, this volume includes discussion of many related problems. Partial Contents: MAIN CONCEPTS, METHODS AND MONITORING: Analysis of the Concept of Landscape Change; Landscape Classification, Scales and Biodiversity in Europe; A Swedish Countryside Survey for Monitoring of Landscape Features, Biodiversity and Cultural Heritage - the LIM Project. CONSEQUENCES OF LAND USE CHANGES: Persistence of Landscape Spatial Structure in Conditions of Change in Habitat, Land Use and Actual Vegetation Vistula Valley Case Study in Central Poland; Relationships between Farming Systems and Ecological Patterns Along a Gradient of Bocage Landscapes; Multiple-Scale Landscape Ecological Analysis in a Rural Mediterranean Region.
Series: Advances in Ecological Sciences, Vol 16
Series: Advances in Ecological Sciences, Vol 5
ISBN: 1-85312-935-6 2004 304pp £99.00/US$158.00/€148.50
ISBN: 1-85312-650-0 2000 328pp £108.00/US$167.00/€162.00
SET ISBN: 1-85312-936-4 £267.00/US$426.00/€400.95 (Over 10% saving when you buy all three volumes together)
Find us at http://www.witpress.com Save 10% when you order from our encrypted ordering service on the web using your credit card.
WITPress Ashurst Lodge, Ashurst, Southampton, SO40 7AA, UK. Tel: 44 (0) 238 029 3223 Fax: 44 (0) 238 029 2853 E-Mail:
[email protected]