WOMAN AND ART IN EARLY MODERN LATIN AMERICA
THE ATLANTIC WORLD Europe, Africa and the Americas, 1500-1830
EDITORS
W...
122 downloads
2273 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
WOMAN AND ART IN EARLY MODERN LATIN AMERICA
THE ATLANTIC WORLD Europe, Africa and the Americas, 1500-1830
EDITORS
Wim Klooster (Clark University) Benjamin Schmidt (University of Washington)
VOLUME X
WOMAN AND ART IN EARLY MODERN LATIN AMERICA EDITED BY
KELLEN KEE MCINTYRE AND RICHARD E. PHILLIPS
LEIDEN • BOSTON 2007
Cover illustration: Cristóbal de Villalpando, St. Teresa Interceding for Souls in Purgatory. 1708, Church of Santiago, Tuxpan, Michoacán, Mexico.
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A C.I.P. record for this book is available from the Library of Congress.
ISSN 1570–0542 ISBN-13: 978-90-04-15392-9 ISBN-10: 90-04-15392-6 © Copyright 2007 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Brill provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910 Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change. printed in the netherlands
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ........................................................................ List of Illustrations ......................................................................
ix xi
Introduction Kellen Kee McIntyre ....................................................................
1
PART ONE
RECONNAISSANCE: MARKING AND MAPPING THE NEW WORLD WITH THE FEMALE BODY Chapter One. The Queen of Heaven Reigns in New Spain: The Triumph of Eternity in the Casa del Deán Murals ...................................................................... Penny C. Morrill Chapter Two. Affections of the Heart: Female Imagery and the Notion of Nation in Nineteenth-Century Mexico .................................................................................... Magali M. Carrera
21
47
Chapter Three. The Virgin of the Andes: Inka Queen and Christian Goddess .......................................................... Carol Damian
73
Chapter Four. Women and Men as Cosmic Co-Bearers at Oaxtepec, Mexico, about 1553 ........................................ Richard E. Phillips
99
vi
contents PART TWO
TAKING POSSESSION: APPROPRIATIONS OF THE NEW WORLD/FEMALE BODY Chapter Five. Abused and Battered: Printed Images and the Female Body in Viceregal New Spain .......................... K. Donahue-Wallace
125
Chapter Six. Reclaiming Tlatilco’s Figurines from Biased Analysis ...................................................................... María Elena Bernal-García
149
Chapter Seven. El encuentro de Cortés y Moctezuma: The Betrothal of Two Worlds in Eighteenth-Century New Spain .............................................................................. Ray Hernández-Durán Chapter Eight. Nurture and Inconformity: Arrieta’s Images of Women, Food, and Beverage ............................ Jenny O. Ramírez
181
207
PART THREE
CONSOLIDATION: THE QUALIFYING AND TAMING OF THE NEW WORLD/FEMALE BODY WITH SIGNIFIEDS Chapter Nine. Clothing Women: The Female Body in Pre- and Post-Contact Aztec Art .................................... Lori Boornazian Diel Chapter Ten. Savage Breast/Salvaged Breast: Allegory, Colonization, and Wet-Nursing in Peru, 1532–1825 .............................................................................. Carolyn Dean Chapter Eleven. Emblems of Virtue in Eighteenth-Century New Spain ............................................ Michael J. Schreffler
221
247
265
contents Chapter Twelve. The Figure of Mary as the Cloister in Mexican Mendicant Art .................................................. Richard E. Phillips
vii
289
PART FOUR
FULFILLMENT: THE EXTENSION AND EXPRESSION OF THE FEMALE BODY IN THE NEW WORLD Chapter Thirteen. Convents, Art, and Creole Identity in Late Viceregal New Spain .............................................. Elizabeth Perry
321
Chapter Fourteen. The Sweeping of the Way: Rethinking the Mexican Ochpaniztli Festival .................... Catherine R. DiCesare
343
Chapter Fifteen. Exploring a Female Legacy: Beatriz Álvarez de Herrera and the Façade of the Casa de Montejo ................................................................................ C. Cody Barteet Chapter Sixteen. Isabel de Cisneros in Her Own Role ........ A. Lepage Chapter Seventeen. From Mujercilla to Conquistadora: St. Teresa of Ávila’s Missionary Identity in Mexican Colonial Art ............................................................................ Christopher C. Wilson Index ..........................................................................................
367
395
419
443
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I extend my heartfelt thanks to all of our contributors who were prompt, patient, and generous in their support of this project. I am indebted to all of the wonderful people at Brill Academic Publishers who worked so hard to bring this book to press. Among them: Julian Deahl who immediately understood the value of this project; our editors Marcella Mulder, Boris van Gool, Tanja Cowall, and Gera van Bedaf, who were patient and supportive to a fault; and the typesetters and designers who did such a beautiful job with the layout of the book. My writing partner, Richard E. Phillips, has been a delight to work with. The breadth and depth of his knowledge about Viceregal Latin American art and architecture continue to amaze me. And finally, I dedicate this book to my talented, funny, and wonderful husband, Eric F. Lane, whose support in this and everything else that I do is boundless. Kellen Kee McIntyre I would like to thank Dr. Nancy Moyer, Prof. Reynaldo Santiago, and Prof. Richard N. Hyslin, successive Chairs of the Art Department of the University of Texas—Pan American, and Dr. Wallace Tucker, Interim Dean of the College of Arts and Humanities, for their support of my official workload reduction for research purposes. Without this reduction, I could not have contributed to this book. I also thank the Association for Latin American Art and the Lozano Long Institute for Latin American Studies of the University of Texas at Austin for permitting us to post an announcement calling for contributors in their listserv and their weekly calendar, respectively. I thank the staff of Brill Publishers for their constant guidance and encouragement of our project. I am most grateful to my co-editor Dr. Kellen Kee McIntyre for inventing the concept behind this book, for defining its theme, and for recruiting me to assist her with this project. I also thank Eric Lane for his assistance and encouragement in completing this book. And I am grateful to Canek, Citlalli, and Alicia for their love and support. I dedicate my efforts on this volume to the memory of my parents, Frank and Marguerite Phillips. Richard E. Phillips
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
Penny C. Morrill Fig. 1.1 Fig. 1.2 Fig. 1.3
The Triumph of Love. Mural painting in the Casa del Deán, Puebla, Mexico. ca. 1580. Photo by Jorge Pérez de Lara. The Triumph of Eternity/Ecclesia. Mural painting in the Casa del Deán, Puebla, Mexico. ca. 1580. Photo by Jorge Pérez de Lara. Juno. An engraving from Francis Pomey, Pantheum mythicum, seu, Fabulosa deorum historia. Amsterdam: Ex Officina Schouteniana; Apud J. J. a Poolsum, 1757. Courtesy of the Chapin Library Collection, Williams College, Williamstown, Massachusetts.
Magali M. Carrera Fig. 2.1
Patricio Súarez de Peredo, Alegoría de las autoridades españolas e indígenas (Allegory of the Spanish and Indigenous Authorities). 1809, oil, approx. 170 × 90 cm. Museo Nacional del Virreinato, Mexico. Reproduction authorized by the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo Nacional de la Cultura (CONACULTA.-INAH.-MEX), Mexico. Fig. 2.2 Anon., Alegoría de la Independencia. 1834, oil, approx. 169 × 196 cm., Museo Casa de Hidalgo, Centro INAH-Guanajuato, Dolores Hidalgo, Mexico. Reproduction authorized by the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo Nacional de la Cultura (CONACULTA.-INAH.MEX), Mexico. Fig. 2.3 Louis Charles Routte and Jacques-Louis Copia, after LouisMarie Sicardi, La Liberté, Patrone des Français, after LouisSimon Boizot. 1795, etching, S.P. Avery Collection, Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs, The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox, and Tilden Foundations. Fig. 2.4 Petronilo Monroy, Constitución de 1857. Exhibited 1869, oil, approx. 170 × 90 cm., Museo Nacional de Arte, Mexico
xii
Fig. 2.5
list of illustrations City. Reproduction authorized by the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo Nacional de la Cultura (CONACULTA.-INAH.-MEX), Mexico. Frontispiece. Color lithograph. In Vicente Riva Palacio, ed., México a través de los siglos . . . vol. I (México City: Ballescá, 1887–1889), n.p.
Carol Damian Fig. 3.1 Fig. 3.2
Fig. 3.3
Fig. 3.4
Fig. 3.5
Anon., School of Cuzco, Coya or Ñusta. 18th c., oil on canvas, 75” × 47”, Museo Arqueológico, Cuzco, Peru. Anon., School of Cuzco, Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata. 18th c., oil on canvas, 78” × 51”, Museo Pedro de Osma, Lima, Peru. Anon., Alto Perú, La Virgen María con el cerro de Potosí (The Virgin Mary with the Mountain of Potasiama). 18th c., oil on canvas, 53” × 41 ½”, Casa Nacional de Moneda, Potosí, Bolivia. Luis Nino, Alto Perú, Our Lady of the Victory of Málaga. Ca. 1735, oil on canvas, 59 ½” × 43 ¾”, Denver Art Museum, Denver, Colorado. Anon., School of Cuzco, Virgin of the Candlestick of Tenerife with Tunic of Feathers. Ca. 1680–1700, oil on canvas, 61” × 45”, Museo Pedro de Osma, Lima, Peru.
Richard E. Phillips Schematic iconographical diagram, first floor of the cloister, Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, State of Morelos, Mexico, ca. 1553. Drawing courtesy of Prof. James Dutremaine. Fig. 4.2 Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor of the cloister. View toward the east down the south cloister walk, with the mural paintings of Sts. Paul and Catherine of Alexandria on the southwest pier. Photo by the author. Fig. 4.3 Christ Blessing the Loaves and the Fishes. Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor. West end wall of the refectory, south side. Photo by the author. Fig. 4.1
list of illustrations Fig. 4.4
Fig. 4.5
xiii
St. Peter. Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor of the cloister. First image of the pier cycle. Photo by the author. Blessed Osanna Andreasi. Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor of the cloister. Ninth pier face of the cloister arcade cycle, south cloister walk. Photo by the author.
K. Donahue-Wallace Fig. 5.1
Fig. 5.2
Fig. 5.3
Fig. 5.4
Fig. 5.5
Manuel López López, Fue muerta y destrozada. . . . 1806, etching. Courtesy of the Nettie Lee Benson Latin American Collection, University of Texas, Austin. Photo by the author. José Mota, Madre Gerónima de la Asunción. 1713, engraving. Courtesy of The Lilly Library, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana. Photo by the author. José Morales, Sor Sebastiana de la Santísima Trinidad. 1765, engraving. Courtesy of The Lilly Library, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana. Manuel López López, Desalines (sic). 1806, etching. Courtesy of the Nettie Lee Benson Latin American Collection, University of Texas, Austin. Photo by the author. José Morales, The Virgin of Guadalupe. 18th c., engraving. Courtesy of the Archivo General de la Nación, Mexico City.
María Elena Bernal-García Fig. 6.1
Fig. 6.2
Fig. 6.3
Diego Rivera. The Theatre in Mexico, a Popular History. Mosaic, 12.85 × 42.79 m., 1951–1953, Teatro de los Insurgentes, Mexico City. Detail. Drawing by the author at the site. Tlatilco. Type D1 Female and Male Figurines. Clay with paint, 1500–300 B.C.E. Drawing by the author after Thomson (1971), Fig. 14. Tlatilco. Pair of Female Figurines. Clay, 15.5 cm. high, 1500–300 B.C.E. Drawing by the author from the originals in the Museo Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.
xiv Fig. 6.4
Fig. 6.5
list of illustrations Tlatilco. Whirling Type D1 Female Figurine. Clay with red, white, and yellow paint, ca. 11 cm. high. Drawing by the author from the original in the Museo Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City. Zacatenco. Burial 19. Drawing by the author after George C. Vaillant (1931) “Excavations at Zacatenco,” Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History 32 (New York: 1931) 189.
Ray Hernández-Durán Fig. 7.1 Fig. 7.2
Fig. 7.3
Anon., El encuentro de Cortés y Moctezuma, fragment. 18th c., oil on canvas, Priv. Col. Sebastián López de Arteaga, Los desposorios de la Virgen, 17th c., oil on canvas, Museo Nacional de Arte, Mexico City. Luis de Mena, Cuadro de Castas con la Virgen de Guadalupe. Ca. 1750, oil on canvas, Museo de América de Madrid.
Lori Boornazian Diel Fig. 9.1 Fig. 9.2
Fig. 9.3
Fig. 9.4 Fig. 9.5
Capture and Sacrifice of Huitzilihuitl and his Daughter, Tira de Tepechpan (after Aubin 1848–1851). Capture of Huitzilihuitl and his Daughters, Codex Azcatitlán. Photo courtesy of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Paris. Presentation of Huitzilihuitl and his Daughters, Codex Azcatitlán. Photo courtesy of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Paris. Cihuateteo (Pasztory 1998: plate 186). The Cihuateteo on the Day 1 Eagle, Florentine Codex (after Sahagún 1950–82 4: Figs. 78–82).
Carolyn Dean Fig. 10.1
Anon., An Allegory of America Suckling Foreigners (called An Allegory of Spain and Her Treatment of Her South American
list of illustrations
xv
Colonies). Ca. 1780, oil on canvas, 32” by 23 ½”, Cuzco, Peru. Priv. Col. Photo courtesy of the Frick Art Reference Library. Fig. 10.2 Johannus Stradanus. Discovery of America: Vespucci Landing in America. 16th c., pen and ink on paper. Courtesy the Metropolitan Museum of Art [Gift of the Estate of James Hazen Hyde, 1959 (1974.205)]. Fig. 10.3 Anon., (circle of Mauricio García), The Virgin of Mercy with Three Saints (Francis of Paola, Anthony of Padua, Gertrudis). Mid-18th c., oil on canvas, 37 ⅝” × 26 ⅝”, Cuzco, Peru. Courtesy of the Brooklyn Museum [41.1275.181]. Fig. 10.4 Anon., La Virgen de la Leche. Sculpture for sale in Cuzco, Peru, 2001. Photo by the author.
Michael J. Schreffler NOTE:
Fig. 11.1
Fig. 11.2
Fig. 11.3 Fig. 11.4 Fig. 11.5
Figures 11.1.–11.5. are photographs of sections of “The Richmond Screen,” a folding screen or biombo from New Spain, late eighteenth or early nineteenth century. These sections of the original screen are in the Virginia Historical Society Collection, Richmond, catalogue number 1948.W.1108. The plates are provided as a courtesy by the Virginia Historical Society. Section with the emblems “Love Virtue for Itself ” (Ama la virtud por si misma) and “Virtue is Steadfast” (La virtud es immovible [sic]). Section with the emblems “Virtue Consists in the Mean” (La virtud consiste en el medio) and “Virtue is the Target of Envy” (La virtud es el blanco de la emvidia [sic]). Detail: The emblem “Love Virtue for Itself ” (Ama la virtud por si misma). Detail: The emblem “Virtue is Steadfast” (La virtud es immovible [sic]). Detail: The emblem “Virtue Consists in the Mean” (La virtud consiste en el medio).
xvi
list of illustrations Richard E. Phillips
Fig. 12.1
Fig. 12.2
Fig. 12.3
Fig. 12.4
Fig. 12.5
The Annunciation. 1570s or ’80s, mural painting, first floor, cloister of the Franciscan monastery of Cuauhtinchán, Puebla. Photo by the author. The Death and Coronation of the Virgin. Ca. 1563, mural painting, first floor, cloister of the Augustinian monastery of Epazoyucan, Hidalgo. Photo by the author. The Immaculate Conception of the Litanies with Saints Thomas Aquinas and Duns Scotus. Ca. 1558, mural painting, first floor, cloister of the Franciscan monastery of Huejotzingo, Puebla. Photo by the author. Schematic iconographical diagram of the first cloister of the Augustinian monastery of Acolman, State of Mexico, built after 1539, mural painted ca. 1560. Drawing courtesy of Prof. Reynaldo Santiago. The Annunciation Witnessed by Sts. Augustine and John of Sahagún. Highly damaged mural painted ca. 1560, first cloister, Augustinian monastery of Acolman, State of Mexico. Photo by the author.
Elizabeth Perry Fig, 13.1
Fig. 13.2
Fig. 13.3
Unknown Mexican artist, Virgin and Child with Saints. 17th c., Philadelphia Museum of Art, The Dr. Robert H. Lamborn Collection. Unknown Mexican artist, Coronation of the Virgin with Saints. Ca. 1770–90, Denver Art Museum, Collection of Jan and Frederick R. Mayer. Andrés López, Sister Pudenciana. 1782, Olana State Historic Site, New York State Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation.
Catherine R. DiCesare Fig. 14.1
Ochpaniztli, fol. 21r, Codex Tudela. Reproduction by permission of the Museo de América de Madrid.
list of illustrations Fig. 14.2
Fig. 14.3 Fig. 14.4
Fig. 14.5
xvii
Ochpaniztli. Reprinted from Elizabeth Hill Boone, The Codex Magliabechiano and the Lost Prototype of the Magliabechiano Group (Berkeley: 1983), fol. 39r, by permission of the University of California Press. Ochpaniztli, fol. 3r, Codex Telleriano-Remensis. Reproduced by permission of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France. Ochpaniztli. Reprinted from Diego Durán, Book of the Gods and Rites of the Ancient Calendar, eds. Fernando Horcasitas and Doris Heyden (Norman: 1971) Pl. 24. © 1971 by the University of Oklahoma Press. Ochpaniztli, plate IX of the Tovar Calendar. Reproduced by permission of The John Carter Brown Library at Brown University.
C. Cody Barteet Fig. 15.1 Fig. 15.2 Fig. 15.3 Fig. 15.4 Fig. 15.5
Casa de Montejo, Mérida, Yucatán. Ca. 1542–1549. Photo by the author. Detail: Right Tondo Bust, Lower Façade, Casa de Montejo, Mérida, Yucatán. Ca. 1542–1549. Photo by the author. Detail: Coat of Arms, Upper Façade, Casa de Montejo, Mérida, Yucatán. Ca. 1542–1549. Photo by the author. Detail: Left Jamb Bust, Lower Façade, Casa de Montejo, Mérida, Yucatán. Ca. 1542–1549. Photo by the author. Detail: Left Jamb Bust, Lower Façade, Casa de Montejo, Mérida, Yucatán. Ca. 1542–1549. Photo by the author.
A. Lepage Fig. 16.1
Fig. 16.2
Fig. 16.3
[Copy of ] Portrait of Juana de Jesús, original: Isabel de Cisneros. Ca. 1703, Convent of Santa Clara, Quito, Eduador. Miguel de Santiago, Castigo de la Virgen a Francisco Romo y su hijo. Ca. 1699–1706, Santuario de Nuestra Señora de Guápulo, Quito, Ecuador. Detail of the retable of La Virgen de la Nube. Previously attributed to Isabel de Cisneros and currently attributed
xviii
Fig. 16.4
list of illustrations to Miguel de Santiago. Late 17th c., Santuario de Nuestra Señora de Guápulo, Quito, Ecuador. Archangel St Michael. Previously attributed to Isabel de Cisneros and presently without attribution. Early 18th c., Monastery of San Agustín, Quito, Ecuador.
Christopher C. Wilson Fig. 17.1
Fig. 17.2
Fig. 17.3
Fig. 17.4
Fig. 17.5
Luis Juárez, St. Teresa Praying for the Release of a Soul from Purgatory. First half 17th c., Museo Nacional del Virreinato, Tepotzotlán, Mexico. Cristóbal de Villalpando, St. Teresa Interceding for Souls in Purgatory. 1708, Church of Santiago, Tuxpan, Michoacán, Mexico. Cristóbal de Villalpando, St. Teresa in Penitence. Late 17th–early 18th c., Sacristy of former Discalced Carmelite Monastery (today Museo de El Carmen), San Ángel, Mexico. Adriaen Collaert and Cornelis Galle, St. Teresa in Penitence. 1613, The Carmelitana Collection of Whitefriars Hall, Washington, D.C. Andrés López, Emblematic Portrayal of St. Teresa of Ávila. Second half 18th c.
INTRODUCTION Kellen Kee McIntyre
The impetus for the present volume developed out of basic need. Several years ago, armed with a broad background in both feminist and viceregal1 period art historical theory and practice, I determined to construct a graduate seminar on the representation of women in early modern Latin American art. At first I believed materials appropriate for the course would be relatively easy to come by, but I was seriously mistaken. Fortunately, I had recently heard a lecture by Richard E. Phillips in which he analyzed images of female saints on the piers of the sixteenth-century cloister at Oaxtepec, Morelos.2 Over the next couple of years, Richard and I shared insights into the topic and I was finally able to offer the course for the first time. Our collaboration resulted in a College Art Association Conference session titled “Image, Icon, Identity: Constructions of Femininity in Viceregal Latin American Art and Architecture,” held in Los Angeles in 1999. Reception by audience members suggested to us that there were other early modern Latin Americanists who were also interested in the subject. Since that time, we have made a concerted
1 The editors of this book have avoided the terms “Spanish colonial” or “colonial” art. These terms pre-condition the spectator to expect that the artistic and social forms of the colonized countries are largely derivative or imposed with regard to those of the colonizing polity. This is not the case with the tremendous creativity of local traditions developed by the regions subjected to Spanish control in the New World. The cultural contributions of Spain and the rest of Western Civilization to Latin America were of course fundamental, but they were not slavishly imitated nor monolithically imposed without great originality in their reinterpretation, negotiation, and redirection by the New World inhabitants. So instead of the outmoded terms “Spanish Colonial” or “colonial,” we follow the example of the great scholar of Mexican architectural history Robert Mullen, who titled his seminal 1997 book Architecture and its Sculpture in Viceregal Mexico without further elaborating on his choice of the word “viceregal” in his text. The adjective “viceregal” refers to the viceroys appointed by the Spanish kings to rule over their New World dominions and is therefore a preferable and historically correct substitute for such terms as “Spanish Colonial.” 2 See Ch. 4 in the present volume.
kellen kee mcintyre
2
effort to seek out research and collect essays that deal with various facets of the topic; our efforts are revealed in this volume. As we worked on the project, we noted with some surprise that although feminist art history had expanded exponentially from its inception in the 1970s with regard to ancient and European artistic traditions, not a single essay on the art and architecture of the early modern period in Latin America had made its way into the many feminist art historical publications on the period. The various essays in this publication, selected from a variety of sources, begin to correct that omission. They combine feminist approaches with interdisciplinary methodologies to expand our contemporary understanding of the art and architecture of the viceregal epoch. Feminist art historians have identified five basic methodologies, called ‘feminist interventions,’ with which to reappraise traditional art historical practice.3 I begin with the first four interventions and defer the fifth to a later position in this introduction. Of primary importance over the past three decades has been the reconstruction of the contributions of both (1) female artists and (2) patrons, and (3) the inclusion of a significant number of both in the standard art history survey texts. The feminist approach also (4) seeks to identify the institutionalized strictures that have traditionally hindered the ability of women artists to become professionals as they were historically limited or denied access to the artistically and economically nurturing environments of art guilds and academies. These four feminist interventions were identified by conventionally trained art historians with primary expertise in Western European traditions. The arts of the past century or so aside, these four approaches have not been applied systematically to the historical visual art production of cultures outside or on the periphery of this tradition. The example of Latin America, particularly during the early modern or viceregal period, is a case in point. This exclusion of viceregal Latin America from the feminist art historical discourse—that is, the identification of women artists and patrons, their inclusion in standard art historical texts, and their limited or denied access to training—runs counter to Latin American scholarship in other humanist disciplines. Groundbreaking work by researchers such as Silvia
3
Pollock (1988) 1ff.
introduction
3
Marina Arrom, Luis Martín, Elizabeth Salas, Verónica Salles-Reese and Irene Silverblatt, to name only a few, in the disciplines of viceregal history, literature, and anthropology, have produced significant feminist texts over the last twenty years.4 Many of these scholars, especially the historians, have begun to reconstruct the contributions of specific women to viceregal history and culture, yet no art historian—with the important exception of those concerned with convents of nuns throughout Latin America5 and some forms of portraiture— had published a text on the contribution of women to the development of viceregal art. It is probable that the contribution of women in general and women artists in particular during the viceregal period will never be understood fully due to the dearth of direct archival material. Indeed, as A. Lepage argues in the present volume, it is equally impossible at this stage to tease out the individual contributions of artists, male or female, in many parts of Latin America—in her study, Quito—due to the collective corporate practices of period artists. Nevertheless, few studies have combed the archival material for encoded words and practices that suggest institutionalized artistic bias toward women. The work by Kelly Donahue-Wallace in the area of women and prints remains one of the notable exceptions. As has been clearly shown in studies of Dutch, Italian, and English guild and workshop records, these documents can be as telling for what they do not say as for what they do. In addition, research into women as patrons of the arts in the viceregal period has been scant save for the studies on conventual nuns, as in Elizabeth Perry’s essay on the Mexico City Conceptionists in this volume. Historical research by Martín and others has shown, however, that individual wealthy women with considerable control over vast estates were influential in the development of other aspects of viceregal culture, such as animal husbandry and agriculture. The essay in the present volume by Cody Barteet begins to address the artistic leverage of high status female patrons, while that of Phillips on the monastery at Oaxtepec suggests that powerful native women, too, could affect period practice. Still, a more complete picture remains to be written.
4 Arrom (1985); Martín (1989); Morant (2006); Salas (1995); Salles-Reese; and Silverblatt (1987). 5 For an introduction to the literature on this topic, consult the bibliography by E. Perry, ch. 13, this volume.
kellen kee mcintyre
4
Why has viceregal art history lagged so far behind comparable humanistic disciplines in the adoption of feminist methodologies? Part of the reason lies in the bias against ‘peripheral’ art by feminist art historians trained in the Western European tradition, as mentioned above. A second factor is the comparatively tardy development of a general feminist consciousness in many contemporary Latin American countries. This is apparent yet today, where the reappraisal of the artistic contribution of women even in this past century is only beginning to emerge. And third, as Cecilia F. Klein noted just a few years ago, there had been reluctance on the part of Latin American art historians, no matter their country of origin, to apply contemporary theory purposefully to the study of viceregal art.6 Klein mentioned resistance theory and semiotics, to name only two; to her list I add most feminist art historical theory. (The situation has improved markedly since her observation, as is clearly evinced in this anthology in which feminist concerns merge with other critical theoretical methodologies.) I intentionally qualify that statement with the word ‘most,’ for it is only with the fifth feminist intervention that one can find some exception to the general observation that Latin American art historians had, until the last five years or so, tended to ignore feminist theory in the analysis of viceregal art. This fifth intervention centers on the visual representation of woman: the social and cultural construction and definition of female identity through the art document. For the sake of argument and due to the paucity of research to the contrary, let us assume that a good number of representations of women in the viceregal period were created by male artists primarily under male patronage. Yet, what can these primarily male artistic productions say about the status of women in viceregal Latin America? The editors of the present volume take the position, and it is borne out in many of the essays included herein, that Latin American artists in this period were collectively aware of a vocabulary of gender that could be tailored to deliver varying messages about the position of women vis-à-vis viceregal culture and society. Viceregal images of women can be divided into two broad categories: Secular and religious. In the secular realm are allegory and history painting, portraiture, and various forms of genre. In the reli-
6
Klein (1999).
introduction
5
gious realm are Marian devotions, depictions of female saints, and several types of portraits of nuns. Marian devotions arrived in the New World with Columbus.7 He was a devotee of the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe at a monastery near Cáceres in the province of Extremadura, Spain (not to be confused with the sixteenth-century Mexican Guadalupe). This monastery was a favored pilgrimage site and place of retreat for the Crown of Castile. Many early conquistadors, most notably Cortés and several of his followers, who arrived on the Mexican coast in 1519, were from Extremadura. As such, they were adherents of the Extremaduran Guadalupe, which by that time was a popular image venerated throughout the Crown of Castille. This eleventh or twelfth-century(?), 18” high wooden statue, attributed with many miracles, depicts a fully frontal seated Virgin who holds the Christ child on her right and a scepter in her left hand. She is dark skinned. There are a number of these in Spain, and they will multiply in the Spanish colonies; most are credited with miraculous, often healing, powers. This particular image is among the most, if not the most, potent of the type in Spain. Besides the devotion to the Extremaduran Guadalupe, Cortés brought at least two more Marian devotions with him to New Spain. He introduced the military processional banner, a medieval survival, in two variants: One displayed an image of the Crowned Virgin, the Cross on its reverse. A second banner offered an image of the Virgin, identified by Manuel Toussaint as an abbreviated image of the Immaculate Conception, an avocation of the Virgin popularized in the late fifteenth century and the one championed by the Franciscans.8 Through them this guise of the Virgin became a special Crown devotion. It was thus politically advantageous for Cortés and his followers to devote themselves to the Immaculate Conception (he made the formal request that would bring the Franciscans, the first friars, to Mexico) and to the Extremaduran Guadalupe, devotions both favored by the Crown. The third image, the Virgen de los Remedios, brought by one of Cortés’s men, became the one most closely associated with the Spanish 7 This paragraph and the next build upon research by Brading (2001); Taylor (1999); Poole (1995); Peterson (1992); Rodríguez (1995); and Dunnington (1999). 8 Cortés’s banner is mentioned by Díaz del Castillo (1956), Ch. 27, and reproduced in Toussaint (1965), pl. 14.
kellen kee mcintyre
6
conquest of Mexico. This small, sculpted Virgin, which stands about 10 1/2” high, sustains a scepter in one hand. In the other she holds an infant Christ, an obvious reference to her role as peaceful nurturer. Spanish conquistadors credited an apparition of this miraculous image with the final vanquishing of the Mexica (or Aztecs) in 1521.9 That the Virgen de los Remedios is associated with war is not unusual in Catholic devotion. From at least the sixth century, if not before, the Virgin Militant functioned as one of the most important protectors of Christian armies claiming triumph under her care. By the late 1400s, as Rose Demir convincingly argues, various images of the Virgin that stand on the crescent moon functioned as “protagonist and protector against foreign Islamic presence in Spain. Considering the anti-Muslim sentiments throughout Spain in the fifteenth century . . . the crescent moon, which by then had become a well-recognized symbol of Islam, beneath the feet of the Virgin, was seen as a . . . sign of the conquest [of Christian Spain over] Islam.”10 For the Spaniards in the New World in the following century, the Virgin continued in her dual role as patroness of both war and peace. At the same time, for many native populations she assumed the principal divine position over a pantheon of pre-contact female deities with similar dual natures. The most frequently cited example of the dual nature of Mary in Latin America is, of course, the Mexican Virgin of Guadalupe. She shares this name with the Extremaduran Guadalupe. The reasons for this coincidence have long been the subject of conjecture. Many scholars believe that soon after conquest of the Valley of Mexico, Spaniards, perhaps Cortés himself, attached the name “Guadalupe” to a hill, called Tepeyacac in the pre-contact period (now Tepeyac), just three miles northwest of the main plaza in Mexico City. It was a crucial pre-contact entry point into the Valley, sited at the crossing of three major causeways into the city, and it continued as an important entry under Spanish rule. That it was Cortés or his followers who renamed the site “Guadalupe” is plausible; it could only have served to curry royal favor. Viceroys and other Spanish author-
9 10
Salazar Monroy (1973). Demir (2005) 20.
introduction
7
ities entering the city for the first time traditionally stopped here to refresh and to apprise local authorities of their imminent entrance into the city. Tepeyac also had pre-contact ritual significance: an important female earth deity, Tonantzín, was associated with the site. She was both a war goddess and an earth mother figure, a nurturer.11 With the Extremaduran Guadalupe, the Tepeyac Guadalupe shares her miraculous appearance. Unlike the former, however, the Tepeyac Guadalupe, a painted image nearly five feet high, does not hold the Christ child. Her body sways in an s-curve, her head bends to the right and, like the Apocalyptic Woman of Revelation 12:1, the Tepeyac Guadalupe is “clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars.” She stands on an upturned crescent moon; the sun’s rays frame her in an almond-shaped mandorla. Surrounding her head are the twelve stars; they multiply and scatter over her blue mantle. An angel (a later addition), a reference to the Virgin’s Assumption, upholds the composition. In European images of the Virgin of the Apocalypse, she often stands on the vanquished apocalyptic serpent, a metaphor for the ultimate glorious victory in the battle of good over evil, the holy war. In the Tepeyac Guadalupe the serpent is absent, which on the surface might suggest that this Virgin does not refer to Mary as patroness of war. But in pre-contact cultures, especially in the Valley of Mexico, the serpent, venerated as a deity, was associated with the moon, depicted beneath the Virgin of Guadalupe’s feet. Perhaps the moon was enough for native devotees to recognize the Tepeyac Guadalupe as triumphant over the serpent. In that case, this Virgin symbolizes both the conquest in general, but also specifically the Valley of Mexico: its pre-contact insignia was an eagle with a serpent in its talons or beak, perched atop a nopal cactus, as depicted in the often-reproduced frontispiece from the Codex Mendoza of the 1540s. This emblem became the coat of arms of Cortés’s Mexico City. In a print from the seventeenth century, the Tepeyac Guadalupe actually stands atop the coat of arms.12 If she is the personification of victory in war, the Tepeyac Guadalupe is also the purveyor of peace and humility. Her head tilts right, her
11 The information in this paragraph is the result of my interpretation of research contained in Taylor (1999) and Brading (2001). 12 Peterson (1992) 39–47.
kellen kee mcintyre
8
eyes cast down, her hands press together in prayer. She is submissive and obedient, the perfect woman as defined by medieval mendicant texts. Marina Warner, in Alone of All Her Sex: The Myth and Cult of the Virgin Mary, writes: Although Jesus and Mary exemplified the virtues of poverty, humility and obedience in equal measure, and although Christians of both sexes were exhorted to imitate them, the characteristics of these virtues— gentleness, docility, forbearance—are immediately classifiable as feminine, especially in Mediterranean countries. The more fervently religious the country—Spain, for instance—the more men folk swagger and command, the more women submit and withdraw and are praised for their Christian goodness. Machismo, ironically enough, is the sweet and gentle Virgin’s other face.13
Since, like her Extremaduran counterpart, the Tepeyac Guadalupe is dark skinned, and because her physiognomy has commonly been characterized as Indian, she entreats native women to submit to the will of their husbands while admonishing the indigenous peoples to surrender, like good wives, to the will of Spanish religious and secular authorities. The Tepeyac Guadalupe and the Virgen de los Remedios, as historian William B. Taylor has pointed out, are but two of the more than sixty images of the Virgin venerated in the Valley of Mexico alone; there are hundreds of revered images scattered throughout Mexico in both Spanish villas and native villages.14 Many of these have probable connections with pre-contact goddesses and all speak to the position of women in viceregal society. Images of the Virgin with dual natures were also pervasive in the Andean region. A case in point, as Carol Damian describes in this volume, is the Virgin in the bell-shaped gown, an image intimately linked with the landscape and with concepts of fecundity and maternity, but also with war.15 Let us now turn to depictions of female saints in early modern Latin America, specifically as they are posed in Mexican retablos, or altarpieces, intended for mission churches in native villages, the pueblos. Retablos intended for main altars were famous for their elaborately carved, gilded frames and complex hagiographic programs. Characteristically, they rise to the height of the church and fill the 13 14 15
Warner (1976) 183. Taylor (1999). Damian (1995) 51–2.
introduction
9
apse wall. No sixteenth-century missions were dedicated to female saints, therefore none turn up in the central and most prominent position of the retablo, although the image of the Virgin Mary usually assumes an important place. Images of male saints, including groups of apostles, dominate retablo iconography; less than twenty percent of the images found on late-sixteenth and seventeenth-century apse altarpieces are of female saints. Each retablo employs images of female saints for specific purposes, but there seems to be no standard placement of them. Yet, they more commonly show up in positions of lesser import—at the sides or base or as diminutive images—and are thus marginalized, rarely assuming prominence over male saints. No female saint ever stands alone; each is paired on the opposite side of the retablo with another female saint of similar legend or mystical quality, or less commonly, with a male saint who shares certain traits.16 The main retablo of St. Dominic at Yanhuitlán, in Oaxaca, is a case in point. Originally constructed in 1575, its paintings are attributed to the important Spanish painter Andrés de la Concha, active in Mexico from 1568 to 1612. This fifty-foot-high, screen-fold retablo was updated in the late seventeenth century with baroque spiraling columns. In this construction, women appear at two levels. Small round panels of the Dominican St. Catherine of Siena (left) and the martyr Catherine of Alexandria (right) flank the center depiction of Christ’s Descent from the Cross on the upper level. They are predictably paired: the fourth-century Alexandrian Catherine was the namesake of the Sienese Catherine, who died in 1380. Both virgins were known for their piety, wisdom, and physical suffering; both experienced mystical marriages to Christ. The intent of their placement here high in the retablo was to inspire piety and devotion in worshippers, particularly women.17 Their relative small size, however, diminishes their import. In addition, both of these female saints were proselytizers of the faith. Catherine of Alexandria, of royal birth, was a converted Christian, highly educated and erudite. In debate she converted to Christianity fifty pagan philosophers; for this she was eventually beheaded. She was the perfect model for native women from the cacique class, the Indian petty nobility. Friars educated cacique children,
16 17
May (1996) 16. Ibid., 10.
10
kellen kee mcintyre
primarily boys, but there are references to the education of caciqueclass girls as well, for whom the Alexandrian Catherine would have been the perfect model.18 Catherine of Siena, on the other hand, was a Christian mystic who devoted her life to the care of the sick and needy. She served as an exemplar for native women of all classes who were shouldered with the burden of caring for the many sick and dying Indians—primarily children, the aged, and men—who succumbed to the waves of disease brought by Europeans to the New World in the sixteenth century. Below, in the banco or predella of this Dominican retablo, the fifthcentury ascetic Mary of Egypt, dressed in a white robe, reclines, her hands clasped to her breast. She pairs with St. Jerome; both saints were recognized for penitence, bodily mortification, and worldly renunciation. In the right panel next to him is Mary Magdalene. She and Mary of Egypt were revered as penitent whores. They were often paired together in retablos intended for native churches at a time when the mendicant friars battled what they considered the wanton sexuality of the Indians: It was key in the spiritual conquest of the New World to discourage sex outside marriage. At the same time, mendicant orders from the medieval period onward viewed woman as seductress—Eve—but through penance and prayer, she could be reborn in grace. The message is clear. The penitent Marys below represent redemption, the best of reality, the virginal Catherines above the ideal. Any native woman viewing this retablo was reassured that she could achieve an intimate spiritual association with Christ no matter what her situation or social position. The third and final type of religious female image from the viceregal period is the nun’s portrait. The two presentational modalities for the nuns’ likenesses—the feminine and the masculine—have been defined by Kirsten Hammer. Mexican artists developed the first type, collectively called monjas coronadas (crowned nuns), in the eighteenth century. While the type has no direct European antecedent, its sources are found in Spanish practice, in death portraits of nuns who sometimes wear crowns that symbolize their spiritual marriage to Christ and their profession, and in the established iconography of the Virgin
18
A famed illustration by the Franciscan Fray Diego de Valadés depicts Franciscans teaching catechism to four groups of Indians separated by gender and age in the four posas of a convento atrio, Rhetórica Christiana (1989 [1579]).
introduction
11
Mary, especially as the Immaculate Conception and the Queen of Heaven.19 In addition, these portraits depict young women who are the cream of creole society, daughters of wealthy European families at the top of the viceregal ladder. These feminized images of the monjas coronadas contrast with the ‘masculine-style’ portraits of nuns who have distinguished themselves through work accomplishments. “Writers, performers, mystics, abbesses: their images were commissioned not because an accident of birth unites them to Mary but because their strength of will makes them more like men in the framework of colonial culture.”20 This type of nuns’ portrait derives from the portraits of accomplished men, both secular and religious, who are depicted surrounded by references to worldly and spiritual accomplishments—books, symbols of military prowess, familial lineage . . . This brief overview of three types of religious images of women provides evidence that colonial artists were collectively aware of a lexicon of gender. The representations of the Virgin, the most pervasive female type in viceregal art, could be read simultaneously by both Spaniard and Indian as the goddess of war and peace, of conquest and nature. She represented the unattainable ideal. Effigies of female saints, particularly those included in retablos intended for indigenous worship, icons marginalized by virtue of their placement and their relatively infrequent inclusion in the retablo, offered practical role models for Indian women in their communities. The two types of nun’s portraits—the ‘masculine’ and the ‘feminine’— provided specific messages about the character of the individual creole sitter. “When fortitude, education, and accomplishment through determination and labor were called for, a masculine model was employed . . .; while purity, virginity, and privilege were formulated as female.”21 The present volume, which expands our understanding of the religious constructs of women in this period and also addresses women’s position in the religious and domestic realms, will revamp our contemporary understanding of the role of women in the society and culture of early modern Latin America. At this point it is necessary to explain why the title of our anthology ends . . . in Early Modern Latin America. Why was the term “early 19 20 21
Hammer (1999). Ibid. Ibid.
12
kellen kee mcintyre
modern” chosen instead of the word “viceregal”? The editors of this anthology wanted to enhance its breadth and ensure its success by including contributions from feminist scholars of Latin American nineteenth-century art. The term “viceregal” is only appropriate as a replacement for the term “Spanish colonial,” which can only cover the period of Spanish hegemony in the New World, excepting Cuba and Puerto Rico, from 1492 until the final defeat of the Spanish armies in Peru in 1825.22 But we are as committed to the study of the female presence in the nineteenth-century art of the newly ‘independent’ Spanish American nations as much as to that of the era of Hispanic dominion. Like the viceregal period, the Spanish American nineteenth century was an inchoate epoch pregnant with implications for our time, a field like the viceregal one that is ripe and begging for feminist analysis of its artistic expressions. We cannot understand the present without deconstructing the past. Also, the Latin American nineteenth century continued many of the patterns of viceregal development, including relative subjugation to the tutelage of more powerful external polities and the economics perpetrated by their corporations, with the consequent socio-cultural distortions that this caused. Inclusion of the nineteenth century illuminates and strengthens our grasp of viceregal developments and their destiny rather than distracting from them. The term ‘early modern’ is sufficiently flexible to accommodate both the viceregal and nineteenth-century periods of Latin American history in one vehicle. In the event, the essays that we include on nineteenth-century art, by Carrera and Ramírez, concern only art in Mexico, but are of an excellence that illuminates understanding of the congruent expression of the feminine in art throughout Latin America and indeed, western civilization.23 The organization of this volume is determined not by the predictable linear framework, by periods and centuries, but rather by the realization that in the early years of the conquest, and indeed throughout much of the early modern period, Spanish authorities, chroniclers, and others envisaged the Spanish colonies of the Americas in gendered terms. Proffered as the female body, the ‘New’ (virginal by implication) World was at differing times adored, pursued, courted,
22 23
The use of the term “viceregal” is justified in footnote 1. On women artists in nineteenth-century Mexico see Widdifield (2006).
introduction
13
seduced, defiled, exploited, reviled, and denounced by those (males) who encountered ‘her.’ This mentality is born out in the various forms of representations of women that are discussed in this volume, from the earliest days of the conquest through the burgeoning of Republican Mexico. Great improvisation, inaccuracy, and errors occurred in the first era of exploration and colonization, suggested in the title of Part I: “Reconnaissance: Marking and Mapping the New World with the Female Body.” The Spanish conquistadors strove to understand the land in terms of the chivalric literature of knighthood—in it love remained unrequited—that induced them to give names like ‘California’ to the landscape they encountered. They invaded the river basin in South America where they saw female warriors fight alongside the men; their only frame of reference was in Greek mythology’s Amazon women, and so they named the world’s greatest river the Río Amazonas. This first era is clumsy, groping, fantastic: Mistaken ways of trying to digest this daunting New World experience plagued the endeavor. The conquerors were to a certain extent purposefully ignorant in order to deny the indigenous peoples and the indigenous landscapes their true definition. They sought to undermine the priceless identity of each native civilization by simply lumping the folk under one disrespectful category, indios, a term that did not even remotely correspond to them, only to peoples living half a world away. Very few Spaniards sought to correct Columbus’s original misapprehension that he had found the inhabitants of India, and by failing to do so they acquiesced in the enterprise of devaluing the natives by alienating them from their diverse heritages. As a result, Spanish definitions became the conventional ones. In Penny Morrill’s essay, the very foreign imagery of the Casa del Deán comes straight out of European ideals of womanhood and as such it lacks a New World consciousness. Outside the probable indigenous execution of the murals and a few modest references to native motifs, most likely selected by the patron, it denies indigenous symbolism or meaning. This phenomenon continued throughout the viceregal period and into the early phase of nation building. A case in point, Magali M. Carrera’s essay underscores the very foreign and very European practice of allegorizing the nation as the female body, whereas, in an attempt to mark, map, and define the New World terrene, as described by Damian, the image of Mary is inscribed by native artists within the native landscape: She is the Great Goddess Earth Mother
14
kellen kee mcintyre
presented in the form of a sacred mountain. And finally in this section, Phillips analyzes the depictions of saints on cloister piers in the Dominican convento of Oaxtepec. The friars not surprisingly employed these images of saints—saints who never lived in Mexico or the New World—to imprint the New World landscape with foreign, alien signifiers in order to try to digest and exploit it. The beginning of the assimilation of this foreign imprint into a new configuration of an independent, de-colonized Latin American civilization is indicated, however, by the fact that the indigenous women at Oaxtepec encouraged the adoption of a pattern that uncharacteristically included a high number of female saints in privileged positions, which is more in accord with the power of female deities and of women in preColumbian Mesoamerican civilization. This becomes even more obvious when the advantageous placement of female effigies in the Oaxtepec cloister cycle is compared to their marginalization in contemporaneous Mexican monastic retablos as studied by Julia May and discussed earlier in this Introduction. Part II, “Taking Possession: Appropriations of the New World/ Female Body,” is more vigorous, more aggressive; in it actors try to force the reality of the New World to conform to male suppositions about the nature of the land and of women. During the first period, ‘reconnaissance,’ outposts were established in Santo Domingo and Cuba, both places where Cortés lived for several years prior to his Mexican campaign, providing the framework for later and much grander conquests.24 Cortés learned the ropes here, how to marshal resources for grander ambitions, and to put together a more comprehensive colonial system.25 His experience was mirrored in Pizarro’s early ventures in Panama that primed him for his brutally exploitive ‘successes’ in Peru.26 This escalating aggressiveness is explored especially in Donahue-Wallace’s essay, an analysis of how physical battery, abuse, and rape of women were appropriated and utilized in
24 For the Caribbean and especially its islands of Española and Cuba, colonized during the first, reconnaissance, period and serving as the hemispheric bases for the second period of consolidation in the grander realms of the mainland, see McAlister (1984), 100, and Parry (1964) 179. 25 López de Gómara (1966) 7–11; MacLachlan and Rodríguez (1980) 67–69; Gibson (1967) 26–27. 26 For Pizarro’s early career as a bridge between the first and second phases of colonization, see Kirkpatrick (1967) 47–59 and 143–46.
introduction
15
period prints to achieve the political aims of the dominant classes. In the second essay Mariá Elena Bernal-García describes how male anthropologists and scholars aggressively distorted and transformed the intended meanings and usages of the Tlatilco female figurines to fit their own sexist view of the world in the early to mid-20th century. Bernal-García ‘reclaim(s) that body’ or corpus of Tlatilco female figurines from the traditional biased interpretation that has been applied to it. It might be argued that Bernal-García’s essay is beyond the chronological purview that was set by this anthology’s title. The editors’ response is that Bernal-García addresses the phenomenon of misidentification and misappropriation endemic to the western enterprise in early modern Latin America and its continued pathology into the twentieth century, enlightening and liberating us vis-à-vis its whole line of development. Similarly, Ray HernándezDurán presents the aggressively distorted application of visual constructs traditionally associated with women and marriage to the encounter between Cortés and Moctezuma as depicted in an eighteenth-century painting as “part of an emergent American, particularly creole, (proto) national awareness and agency.” Part II ends with Jenny Ramírez’s essay on the forceful and outspoken way that painter José Agustín Arrieta appropriated the female figure to fashion allegorical and cultural statements about men’s perceptions of female associations with food, beverage, nourishment, nurture, and feeding. Part III, “Consolidation: The Qualifying and Taming of the New World/Female Body with Signifieds,” deals with attempts to comprehend and manage the New World reality in terms comparatively more sophisticated than the more primal and aggressive tactics considered in Part II. Just as a territory must be physically conquered and consolidated, its inhabitants must also be intellectually subjugated and controlled. Those enacting the consolidation must make some cognitive sense out of it all so that a plan of action can be elaborated and life can be lived with some sense of logic and order. Consolidation also involves the integration of New World and native aspects with European ones into the discourse as understanding of the New World reality becomes clearer. This section opens with Lori Boornazian Diel’s essay on negotiation over the meaning of the Female Body and its use in subjugating the environment between its prior pre-Columbian interpretation and its later postcontact representation in Aztec art. Negotiation on how to qualify and define
16
kellen kee mcintyre
the female anatomy between the indigenous and the European polarities continues in Carolyn Dean’s essay. With Michael Schreffler and the flourishing of the Mexican screen or biombo, which likewise has New World meanings and addresses the European/New World inbetween cultural identity of the criollos, we have another instance of such consolidation and qualification that involves a sophisticated allegorical and moralizing strategy, no longer primitive or improvised as it was in the essays from the previous section. Phillips’ essay on “Mary as the Cloister” finishes off Part III with the magical consecration of specific pieces of the New World land, the cloisters, as the body of Mary. In this way the New World landscape is sewn with the identity of Mary to co-opt and redirect, in a way beneficial to the Catholic power elite, the non-Christian indigenous tendencies to revere and adore the female principle inherent to the land. It also paradoxically exalts the feminine principle while denigrating the actual living and breathing human animal female, because no woman can live up to the impossible standard set by Mary, who is a virgin and a mother at the same time. Mary: Immaculately conceived in the mind of God at the beginning of time as the vessel for his salvation of humanity, free of sin, unlike all other females. So in Mary men (and women, self-destructively) can adore the feminine principle and fantasize about an ideal lover, and at the same time despise real women and their supposed vulnerability.27 And finally, in Part IV, “Fulfillment: The Extension and Expression of the Female Body in the New World,” the female identity powerfully and proactively asserts itself to define the land and the culture of the New World partly or fully on its own terms. Female creativity or female institutions thrive. Elizabeth Perry’s essay on nuns and their particularized forms of cultural display emphatically underscores the emergence of a “distinctly creole sacred identity.” Catherine R. DiCesare’s essay deals with the projection and display as a talisman of the body of the actual skinned and mutilated female victim, perceived by pre-Columbian worshippers as the definition and protector of the land that ensures its fecundity. It follows, then, that it is obviously perceived by the believers as “the extension and expression of the female body” to ensure survival and the discomfiture of enemies. It can be seen as a metaphor for the projection of fem-
27
Warner (1976), especially page 183.
introduction
17
inine power inherent in the remaining essays of Part IV. In them women or the feminine principle do not let themselves be fully constrained or contained by men. Rather, either they themselves, or society, stand up for and express the full-throated defense and declaration of the feminine principle. In the essay by Cody Barteet, Beatriz Álvarez de Herrera is neither content to linger in anonymity nor let her dynasty be defined architecturally without references to herself and to her lineage. On the other hand, although the artistic production of the Ecuadoran painter Isabel de Cisneros, as described by A. Lepage, cannot be determined, the fact that her life has been the subject of nationalistic fiction attests to her contributions to the art of the period. And finally the aggressive proactive dissemination of the missionary identity of the Spanish mystic Saint Teresa of Avila across the Latin American landscape is voiced by Christopher Wilson. The editors of Woman and Art in Early Modern Latin America see this volume not as a definitive collection on the subject, but as a vehicle from which to explore further the position in society of women and the contributions made by them to the arts and architecture of early modern Latin America.
Bibliography Alarcón, R., et al. (1996) Pintura Novohispana: Museo Nacional del Virreinato, Tepotzotlán. Vol III, Pt. 2 (Mexico City: 1996). Arrom, S. M. (1995) The Women of Mexico City, 1790–1857 (Stanford: 1985). Brading, D. A. (2001) Mexican Phoenix: Our Lady of Guadalupe: Image and Tradition across Five Centuries (Cambridge, UK: 2001). Damian, C. (1995) The Virgin of the Andes: Art and Ritual in Colonial Cuzco (Miami Beach: 1995). Demir, R. “Redefining the Crescent Moon: Symbolic Resonance in Muslim Spanish and Indo-Christian Art” (MA, University of Texas at San Antonio, 2005). Díaz del Castillo, B. (1956) The Discovery and Conquest of Mexico, trans. A. P. Maudslay (New York: 1956). Gibson, C. (1967) Spain in America (New York: 1967). Hammer, K. (1999) “Brides of Christ and God’s Laborers: Differing Gender Constructions in Colonial Portraits of Nuns,” College Art Association, Los Angeles, California, Feb. 13, 1999. Kirkpatrick, F. A. (1967) The Spanish Conquistadores (Cleveland: 1967 [1934]). Klein, C. F. (1999) “Introductory Remarks: Indigenous Artists and European Intruders: Visual Strategies of Empowerment in Colonial Mexico,” College Art Association, Los Angeles, California, Feb. 13, 1999. López de Gómara, F. (1966) Cortés: The Life of the Conqueror by His Secretary _____ (trans., ed. Simpson (Berkeley: 1966 [1552]). MacLachlan, C. M., and J. E. Rodríguez O. (1980) The Forging of the Cosmic Race (Berkeley: 1980).
18
kellen kee mcintyre
Martín, L. (1989) Daughters of the Conquistadores (Dallas: 1989). May, J. S. (1996) “Female Saints on Mexican Retables of the Early Colonial Period” Unpublished research paper written under the direction of R. E. Phillips, Virginia Commonwealth University, 1996. McAlister, L. N. (1984) Spain and Portugal in the New World 1492–1700 (Minneapolis: 1984). Monroy, S. (1973) La Conquistadora de Hernán Cortés (Puebla: 1973). Morant, Isabel, et al., eds. (2006) Historia de las mujéres en España y América Latina (Madrid: 2006) O’Neill, J. P., ed. (1990) Mexico: Splendors of Thirty Centuries (New York: 1990). Parry, J. H. (1964) The Age of Reconnaissance (New York: 1964). Peterson, J. F. (1992) “The Virgin of Guadalupe: Symbol of Conquest or Liberation?” Art Journal 51, no. 4 (Winter 1992) 39–47. Pollock, G. (1988) “Feminist Interventions in the History of Art: An Introduction,” in Vision and Difference: Femininity, Feminism and the History of Art (London: 1988) 1–17. Poole, S. (1995) Our Lady of Guadalupe: The Origins and Sources of a Mexican National Symbol, 1531–1797 (Tucson: 1995). Rodríguez, J. (1994) Our Lady of Guadalupe: Faith and Empowerment among MexicanAmerican Women (Austin: 1994). Salas, E. (1990) Soldaderas in the Mexican Military (Austin: 1990). Salles-Reese, V. (1997) From Viracocha to the Virgin of Copacabana (Austin: 1997). Silverblatt, I. (1987) Moon, Sun, and Witches (Princeton: 1987). Taylor, W. B. (1999) “Our Lady of Guadalupe and Friends: The Virgin Mary in Colonial Mexico,” San Antonio Museum of Art, San Antonio, Texas, March 14, 1999. Toussaint, M. (1965) Pintura Colonial en México (Mexico City: 1965). Warner, M. (1976) Alone of All Her Sex: The Myth and Cult of the Virgin Mary (New York: 1976). Widdifield, S. G. (2006) “The Spaces of Nineteenth-Century Mexican Women Artists,” in D. Cherry and J. Helland, eds. Studio, Space and Sociality: New Narratives of Nineteenth-Century Women Artists (London: 2006). Valadés, Fr. D. de (1989) Rhetórica Christiana (Mexico City: 1989).
PART ONE
RECONNAISSANCE: MARKING AND MAPPING THE NEW WORLD WITH THE FEMALE BODY
CHAPTER ONE
THE QUEEN OF HEAVEN REIGNS IN NEW SPAIN: THE TRIUMPH OF ETERNITY IN THE CASA DEL DEÁN MURALS Penny C. Morrill
Introduction An extensive mural cycle has emerged from beneath layers of whitewash in two formal second-storey rooms of the Casa del Deán in Puebla, Mexico (Figs. 1.1 and 1.2). The murals, painted by an indigenous artist with assistants, today look much as they would have appeared when painted around 1580, the year carved in stone on the house’s fragmentary façade.1 It clings perilously to the side of a massive rectangular movie theatre that replaced most of the residence. This remaining façade and the two decorated formal rooms on the interior are significant works in the history of early modern art and culture. The patron, Don Tomás de la Plaza, had come to New Spain (roughly coterminous with the modern nation of Mexico) from Alburquerque in Spain’s Extremadura province. He had served as a secular priest in Mexico’s southern Oaxaca province before becoming Dean of Puebla’s Cathedral in 1564.2 Founded in 1533, the city of Puebla was strategically centered on the Camino Real between Mexico City and the viceroyalty’s principal port at Veracruz.3 In 1537 the Cabildo (city council) of Puebla successfully petitioned that the Cathedral of the Tlaxcala diocese be moved from Tlaxcala to Puebla. The first bishop to reside in Puebla with the king’s authorization was Fray Sarmiento de Ojocastro, who served from 1547 to 1557.4 Thus by the time of Don Tomás’s tenure as Dean, Puebla
1 2 3 4
Kropfinger von Kügelgen (1979) 211. Schwaller (1987) 32–33. Fernández Echeverría y Veytia (1931) I, 308–309. Leicht (1986) 139.
22
penny c. morrill
had recently become not only a manufacturing, agricultural, and commercial center, but also the ecclesiastical hub of the PueblaTlaxcala region. Don Tomás’s residence was fashioned after the urban palaces that were built in Spain at Seville, Salamanca, and in Extremadura during the first half of the sixteenth century. The formal rooms with their elaborately conceived mural cycle reflected the Dean’s interests: His humanist theology, Spanish ancestry, and experiences as a priest in New Spain. Under his patronage, as demonstrated here, indigenous artists found their models for this mural program in books and prints published in the mid-sixteenth century at Antwerp or Lyons.5 This article proposes that the theme for this wall-painted sequence is built upon pre-figuration in the Room of the Sibyls and upon fulfillment in the Room of the Triumphs. The final female allegorical figure in the cycle, Eternity/Ecclesia, is the focus of this essay. Embodying eternity, she escapes the confines of earth and triumphs over Time and Death. As the personification of the Church, she is the keeper of the Sacraments. Eternity and Ecclesia are conflated in her because redemption through the Church’s sacraments is seen as the key to the soul’s eternal life. She is simultaneously endowed with the identities of the Virgin Mother, Queen of Heaven, and Juno. It is argued that this figure constitutes a break in the European symbolic tradition that had almost always represented the Triumph of Eternity with the Christian Trinity. The essay ends with a discussion of the possible precedents for this new iconography. The multiple identities embodied in the Casa del Deán’s figure of the Triumph of Eternity were, I believe, a familiar concept for both the indigenous artists and their European patron. An appreciation for
5 Proof that such trade in prints from Europe was occurring around the time that the Casa del Deán’s murals were created is provided by a 1572 inventory for a shipment of books from Spain to Veracruz’s port at San Juan de Ulúa. It included 210 dibujos large and small. The modern translation of the Spanish word dibujo into English is “drawing” while the word grabado is commonly used to refer to a print. There was no known market in colonial Mexico for master drawings, so the term dibujo in the 1572 inventory must refer to prints; see Fernández del Castillo (1982) 360–362 and 470–471. See also De Marchi and Van Miegroet (2000) 81–112.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
23
Fig. 1.1 The Triumph of Love. Mural painting in the Casa del Deán, Puebla, Mexico. ca. 1580. Photo by Jorge Pérez de Lara.
Fig. 1.2 The Triumph of Eternity/Ecclesia. Mural painting in the Casa del Deán, Puebla, Mexico. ca. 1580. Photo by Jorge Pérez de Lara.
24
penny c. morrill
woman as allegory is evident in the Last Judgment play written in Náhuatl by Fray Andrés de Olmos about 1540, a colloquy among allegorical figures that I compare to the Casa del Deán murals.
Description of the Murals In the foreground of the first mural, set before a continuous landscape, twelve young women, each elaborately costumed and carrying her own standard, parade in order on horseback. The first is identified as Synagoga, the personification of the Old Testament, blindfolded and riding on a mule. She is followed by eleven Sibyls whose prophetic gifts led to their association with Old Testament prophecies and with specific events in the life of Christ. The artist or artists wrote directly on the wall near each Sibyl, announcing not only her name but also the book and chapter numbers for the related biblical passages. These citations were taken from Old Testament prophets, the Psalms, the Gospels, or the Book of Revelation. The interplay of the printed biblical references, which replace the traditional depiction of the prophet or evangelist to embody such texts, the Sibyls on horseback, and the floating roundels that contain scenes from Christ’s life, all contribute to a rendering of space that reiterates rather than defies the two-dimensional surface. This patterned effect is reminiscent of prints from Antwerp that were ultimately derived from books like the Speculum humanae salvationis with its multiple correspondences. The landscape with the Sibyls on procession is framed by rinceaux in the friezes. Among the leaves and large blossoms are entwined putti and several rather unique versions of childlike centaurs. The artist also depicted monkeys wearing jade bracelets and earrings that playfully interlace their long tails. The most telling feature of these anthropomorphic figures is the pre-Columbian sound scroll that issues from their mouths. The lower half of the first room’s lowest register appears to have been painted out, raising questions concerning its original appearance and meaning. Seraphim wearing jade pendants occupy the spandrels and, in the arched openings, knights in armor, shown only as heads in profile, alternate with large bunches of flowers that once may have been depicted in vases or in a miniature landscape.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
25
The murals in the second room of the Casa del Deán almost defy description. Based on the Triumphs of Petrarch, the frescoes represent the patron’s immersion in Christian humanism. The personifications of Love, Chastity, Death, Fame, Time, and Eternity, taken from Petrarch’s poem to Laura, are usually shown riding triumphantly in noble chariots, with Eternity as the victor over the human condition that demands death. Petrarch’s poetic expression of earthly love converges with the ultimate realization of Christian redemption, that is, the gift of eternal life.6 In this second room of the Dean’s house, Don Tomás and the indigenous artist or artists whom he commissioned broke with tradition and depicted only five of the six Triumphs, and in a different order than is found in Petrarch’s original text. The allegorical personages in their chariots and those whom they have conquered occupy a rocky foreground save the figure of Eternity whose chariot floats above the clouds. As a setting for the Triumphs the landscape is not continuous, suggesting that the scenes that unfold behind each of the victorious protagonists were meant to contribute greater meaning to the specific figure. Above and below the Triumphs are friezes of rinceaux in which putti display cartouches containing images of animals involved in activities that are anthropomorphic (Figs. 1.1 and 1.2). Each animal and the related emblems that surround it seem to be connected to the Triumph nearest the cartouche. It is in this portion of the mural cycle in both rooms that elements of pre-Columbian imagery are especially evident and where it is likely that some form of cultural symbiosis took place.
Petrarch’s Triumphs and Spectacle Literacy The Triumphs, the ingenious rhetorical invention or concetto devised by Petrarch, greatly influenced poets and artists for several centuries. As each temporarily triumphant or ascendant aspect of the human life span is in turn vanquished, Petrarch establishes for the spectator (or reader) a conceptualization of the victory of Christian faith over death that is palpable and sensual. The poem emerges from
6
Seigel (1968) 46.
penny c. morrill
26
the classical Roman imperial tradition of the conquering general’s heroic entry, accompanied by his retinue, into the capital.7 The military quality of conquest and the notion of a ruler’s victorious entry provide a note of irony in the poem. In five of the triumphs that take place on earth, all of humanity is subject to defeat, a result of the ephemeral nature of life itself. In the end all are offered the ultimate triumph over death: Five of these Triumphs on the earth below We have beheld, and at the end, the sixth, God willing, we shall see in heaven above.8
Several biblical passages can be considered as sources for the iconography of the Triumphs.9 Ezekiel’s chariot is in concordance with the triumphant appearance to St. John of the “King of kings and Lord of lords” in the Book of Revelation. The four beasts that draw the prophet Ezekiel’s chariot and appear again in Revelation became the symbols of the four Evangelists. The most powerful biblical description of a chariot is in the Second Book of Kings when Elijah turns his power of the spirit over to Elisha: And as they still went on and talked, behold, a chariot of fire and horses of fire separated the two of them. And Elijah went up by a whirwind into heaven. And Elisha saw it and cried, “My father, my father! The chariots of Israel and its horsemen!” and saw him no more.10
These ‘historical’ precedents, both classical and biblical, were equally seductive for Petrarch’s early fourteenth-century contemporary Dante. In his Purgatorio section of the Divine Comedy, Dante recounts a miraculous vision that is considered to be the personified Church Triumphant in a chariot surrounded by the four beasts described by Ezekiel and by St. John the Evangelist.11 Petrarch’s concept of triumph was elab-
7
Strong (1984) 44. Petrarca (1962) 112. 9 Knipping (1974) 55. 10 Ezekiel 1:4–28; Revelation 4:6–8 and 19:11–16; and 2 Kings 2:9–12. The Bible edition employed for this essay is The New Oxford Annotated Bible with the Apocrypha (New York: 1977). In the sixteenth-century Franciscan monasteries of Cholula, Huejotzingo, and Tecali, all near Puebla, are mural representations of St. Francis in a chariot of fire. St. Francis is thus being identified as the new Elijah. According to Montes Bardo (1998) 287–289, Elijah prophesies the salvation of the pagans and the Last Judgment. 8
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
27
orated in the Hypnerotomachia Poliphili by Francesco Colonna, published in 1499. This exotic novel, with its vivid descriptions and illustrations, influenced the development and appearance of public processions and representations of triumphs.12 Another powerful literary generator of artistic imagery was Savonarola’s Triumphus Crucis, published in 1497. Christ, the Man of Sorrows, rides in a chariot and displays his wounds, surrounded by the instruments of the Passion. Erwin Panofsky asserted that “Savonarola seems indeed to be the first to have visualized Christ in person as a triumphator ‘all’antica.’”13 The Triumphs entered popular culture through public religious processions and triumphal entries of kings and princes. In 1443 King Alfonso of Catalonia arrived in Naples in a gilded chariot drawn by white horses and shaded by a cloth of gold. The Florentines in Naples contributed a chariot in which rode the personification of Fortuna, accompanied by the Seven Virtues on horseback. The Catalans followed, “with mock horses fastened in front and behind them, fighting a mock battle with mock Turks.”14 The sequence of triumphs devised by Petrarch evokes the dynamic of the procession itself as not only highly symbolic but also with narrative qualities. The parade passes before the viewers in the same way that the triumphs follow an order expressive of Petrarch’s loss and mourning. In a recent essay Domenico Pietropaolo has turned his attention to formal aspects of the reception of spectacles and how they might be applied to scholarly investigation of literary descriptions like Petrarch’s Triumphs. Spectacular literacy is that species of the phenomenon in which the signs are units of spectacular discourse rather than words. . . . The pragmatics of processional discourse concerns . . . a direct encounter with a community of observers and not an encounter mediated by poetic language. In the context of Petrarch’s Triumphs, which are linguistic representations of spectacle rather than spectacle itself, the observer is not external but internal to the text and ultimately coincides with the narrative voice.15
11 Dante (1950) 365–367. Bocaccio’s Amorosa Visione of the mid-fourteenth century describes a triumph based on classical sources; see Knipping (1974) 55. 12 Strong (1984) 45–6. The Library of Congress Rare Book Room has a 1499 imprint of the Hypnerotomachia . . . 13 Scribner III (1982) 66–67; and Panofsky (1969) 59. 14 Hughes (1997) 101. 15 Pietropaolo (1987) 359.
penny c. morrill
28
Pietropaolo confronts the relationship of time and space by setting forth what he terms the “three temporal dimensions of the present moment”: actuality, recollection, and expectation. As the procession moves through the street, what is past and what is anticipated are perceived simultaneously.16 Thus, when time and space intersect, the act of observing involves the construction of narrative. The single most telling aspect of the Casa del Deán murals is that all of the figures are shown on procession. The Sibyls on horseback and allegorical figures riding in chariots could have been participants in a triumphal parade or religious pageant in any major city in sixteenth-century Western Europe. Festivals and triumphal entries served social, political, and religious purposes, as in the case of Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor styled as the ‘Champion of Christianity,’ who employed them on a grand scale. “By the time of his abdication in 1556, every educated person within Europe must have been familiar with the rhetoric and imagery of Sacred Empire.”17 Love of pageantry extended to the New World, an aspect of both cultures that could be shared. In 1585 the citizens of Tlaxcala, the original seat of the bishopric that had moved twenty-four miles to Puebla, prepared for a formal visit from the viceroy. As Cathedral Dean of the bishopric of Tlaxcala-Puebla, Don Tomás de la Plaza could very well have been in attendance. Prior to [the viceroy’s] arrival the people constructed a wooden castle of several stories with quarters and vantage points for simulated warfare. Their plan was to dress as Spaniards, Tlaxcalans, and Chichimecs and to present a battle scene. When the viceroy came, they offered him the keys and requested the preservation of their fueros [rights and privileges]. An army of Indians dressed as Spaniards and Tlaxcalans accompanied this entrance. Finally, four old men, garbed as the four “kings” of conquest times [i.e. the chiefs of the four quarters of the pre-Hispanic Tlaxcalan polity] with crowns on their heads, addressed sonnets to him in Spanish.18
Every year of his tenure as Dean, for eight days in late spring, Don Tomás de la Plaza was responsible for the celebration of the feast of Corpus Christi, when the Holy Sacrament was carried through the streets in procession. All the citizens of Puebla were involved,
16 17 18
Ibid., 361. Strong (1984) 74–75, 80. Gibson (1952) 147.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
29
sweeping and preparing altars at each street intersection. The city’s Cabildo and confraternities provided financial contributions and marched in the procession, carrying torches and banners with their insignia and coats of arms. The procession began and ended at the Cathedral, where dances and comedies were performed.19 Consequently it can be asserted with little doubt that the Dean was intimately familiar with all aspects of Christian processional lore as he proved in the mural cycle that he commissioned for his home. At a much later date, but related to Don Tomas’s deanship, was the festive dedication of the Cathedral of Puebla upon its completion in 1649, presided by Bishop Don Juan Palafox y Mendoza: This afternoon, festivities planned by the Noblest of Cities began, for which the principal plaza was enclosed with scaffolding and in the center was built a Castle in which fought various troops, attacking and defending, dressed as Spaniards and Indians of various Nations, some wearing animal skins and their costumes adorned with feathers according to their tradition, who executed with skill the various skirmishes and attacks. Then two costumed troops entered on horseback, dressed as Christians and Moors with a large number of attendants on foot, all richly dressed, who performed with equal skill the team events, games, and tourneys and having concluded, a Triumphal Chariot entered the plaza, dedicated to the Virgin of the Immaculate Conception, whose sacred image was placed in the upper section and at whose feet was a choir of musicians, very well-dressed, that, to the sound of a large group of instruments, sang elegies to the sacred Mystery [i.e., the mystery embodied in God’s Immaculate Conception of the Virgin Mary], moving around the plaza until after nightfall, when the costumed troops entered for a second time carrying lighted torches and with these held in their hands, began to execute the various drills and movements, which delighted the gathering far into the night.20
Petrarch’s Triumphs were especially beguiling for artists as variations on the theme abounded: Triumphs of the Seasons, the Virtues, and of Old Testament heroes. The transmutation from image to pageant
19 Actas de Cabildo de Puebla (1996), Ficha no. 09451, Vol. 0012, Document 056, Asunto 04, 30 April 1586, fol. 0047v: Pregon para que en la procesion de Corpus Christi y su ochavario de este año, todos los obrajeros salgan con su pendon y candelas y que los oficiales de todos los oficios salgan en ella, so pena de 50 pesos de oro comun. Que se nombren a los veedores de los obrajeros para que participen en la procesion. Ademas, se indico que se aderecen las casas y puertas y que en las encrucijadas se coloquen los altares como es costumbre. 20 Translation by the author from Fernández Echeverría y Veytia (1931) II, 79–80.
30
penny c. morrill
and back to image reached its height in the sixteenth century. Tapestries, frescoed walls, pottery, stained glass, marble, bronze, and ivory sculpture, books, woodcuts, and engravings provided permanence for what had been ephemeral events.21 The festival organizers consulted the Biblia pauperum, emblem books, and humanist and classical writings to devise the complex layers of meanings that publicly unfolded in what Émile Mâle has called “a miraculous continuity of revelation.”22 The first edition of Petrarch’s Triumphs in Castilian, the language now commonly known as ‘Spanish,’ translated from the Italian by Antonio de Obregón, was published in 1512 in Logroño, Spain. Hernando de Hozes’s Spanish translation, published in 1581 in Salamanca, was shipped to the New World in 1586. Several editions of the Triumphs are on the Inquisition lists because of perceived heretical statements made in the commentaries. The 1541 Valladolid edition was banned in Mexico. For the Seville version of the Obregón translation, the officer of the Inquisition provided the specific folio on which the offending text could be found.23 While the above evidence proves that there were printed book versions of the Triumphs in the New World, it seems more likely that Don Tomás and his artists found inspiration in a prints series from Antwerp. After looking at numerous versions of the Triumphs published between 1512 and 1581, it is hard to imagine that any of these illustrated editions influenced the poblano murals. The iconography of the images in most of the sixteenth-century book editions of the Triumphs is dependent upon early Italian models, while the variations evident in the Casa del Deán seem to derive from a northern European tradition. Several Triumphs prints series, not from books, were produced around the time of the Puebla mural cycle, including those by Georg Pencz and Martin van Heemskerck. At the Augustinian monastery at Metztitlán, north of Mexico City, the sixteenth-century artists did wall paintings of a Triumph of Chastity and a Triumph of Patience, both
21
Massena (1902) 127. Mâle (1986) 233. 23 A copy of the 1512 Obregón edition is in the Hispanic Society in New York. See Kropfinger von Kügelgen (1973) 81; and Fernández Echeverría y Veytia (1931) 246, 323, 486–487, 501. 22
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
31
taken directly from prints by van Heemskerck.24 Although the murals in the Casa del Deán do not resemble the work of Pencz or van Heemskerck stylistically, the strongest argument that they were based upon a series of prints rather than on book illustrations is the fact that Don Tomás changed the order of the Triumphs and excluded Fame, making it more likely that the images were viewed separately from text.
Triumphs Leading to Eternity Launching the Casa del Deán mural cycle, the personification of Love is clothed in a simple white robe and seated in a chariot pulled by two spirited horses “whiter than whitest snow” as specified by Petrarch (Fig. 1.1).25 Love’s chariot glides across the rocky terrain, leaving for dead those whom she has conquered—a king, a soldier, a friar, and a young woman. The serene pastoral landscape, with its atmospheric blues and greens and soft linear transitions, provides a sharp contrast to the rock-strewn hard earth of the foreground. In representations of the Triumphs, the steeds for each of the chariots had become traditional: White horses for Love; unicorns for Chastity; oxen for Death; elephants for Fame; stags for Time; and the symbolic animals of the four Evangelists for Eternity. As will become evident, Don Tomás followed literary and visual traditions when they adhered to the statement he wished to make. While Cupid blindfolded played the role of Love Triumphant in many of the illustrated editions, in the poblano cycle Cupid makes his appearance instead as a tiny figure perched on the chariot behind the personified figure of Love (Fig. 1.1). The nude winged figure of Cupid is masked and armed, “a cruel youth with bow in hand and arrows at his side.”26 According to
24 Palm (1973). Palm discovered the connection between the Metztitlán murals and the van Heemskerck prints. He also opined that the Heemskerck series provided the program for the murals of the Casa del Deán: “El libro de Hadrianus Junius, médico de la cabecera del príncipe de Orania, proporciona además una segunda clave. Al reunir epigramas sobre los Triunfos de Petrarca con otros sobre las Virtudes cristianas, revela ser la fuente de Contrarreforma que sirve de programa común para los murales de Metztitlán y la Casa del Deán.” 25 Petrarca (1962) 5–6. 26 Petrarca (1962) 6.
32
penny c. morrill
Panofsky, the ubiquitous personification of Love in Italian Renaissance art and poetry acquired the blindfold as an attribute, and “[a] majority of Renaissance artists . . . began to use the Blind Cupid and the Seeing Cupid almost at random. In the illustrations of Petrarch’s Triumphs both types appear indiscriminately.” However, he continues, within the context of the Counter-Reformation—the epoch of our Mexican sequence—a distinction was made between the Blind Cupid, who represented profane, sensual love, and the Seeing Cupid, who signified that which is sacred.27 Because the Cupid in the Casa del Deán is masked rather than blindfolded, I would suggest that he represents love of the sacred. The dual nature of love enters into the question of the female figure’s identity as Venus.28 A century earlier the Florentine Marsilio Ficino, attempting to integrate the ‘pagan’ philosophy of Plato with Christian theology, conceived of love as the essential aspect of God’s interaction with humanity. “According to Ficino, amore is only another name for that self-reverting current (circuitus spiritualis) from God to the world and from the world to God. The loving individual inserts himself into this mystical current.”29 In the Neo-Platonic scheme envisioned by Ficino, the desire for a higher understanding of the sublime leads to a love that manifests itself in beauty. This beauty exists on earth as two aspects, symbolized as the “Twin Venuses,” as love that can be celestial or natural as originally identified and discussed in Plato’s Symposium.30 This NeoPlatonic conceptualization of the nature of love was a guiding principle in the development of the meaning of the figure of Love Triumphant in the Casa del Deán painting. In Titian’s Sacred and Profane Love, dated 1515, it is the nude Venus who represents love of the sublime as she gestures ‘heavenward’ with a flaming vase.31 The clothed Venus in Puebla holds a scepter in her right hand; in her left is a flaming heart, symbol of impassioned spirituality, which she raises toward the empyrean.32 This perception of love’s dual nature led in 1544 to the prohibition in Mexico of any sort of costumed dancing during the festival 27 28 29 30 31 32
Panofsky (1967) 103, 121–128. Sebastián (1992) 110. Panofsky (1967) 141. Panofsky (1967) 142–143. Panofsky (1969) 115. Ferguson (1974) 48–49; and Hall (1979) 146.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
33
of Corpus Christi. Archbishop Juan de Zumárraga set forth a treatise on the proper and reverential manner of celebrating this devotional event, including the following codicil: And something of great irreverence and shamelessness, it seems that, before the Most Holy Sacrament, men in disguise and in women’s costumes go dancing and leaping about, swaying in an immodest and lascivious manner, making a din that drowns out the church choirs, representing profane triumphs, like that of the God of Love, so immodest, and even to those persons without modesty, so shameful to see.33
In our Puebla murals, a hillside marks the transition to the next allegory, introduced by a group of female figures depicted at the corner of the room. These are the Virtues who assist Chastity in her triumph over Love, following Petrarch: With her, and arméd, was the glorious host Of all the radiant virtues that were hers, Hands held in hands that clasped them, two by two. Honor and Modesty were in the van, A noble pair of virtues excellent, That set her high above all other women; Prudence and Moderation were near by, Benignity and Gladness of Heart— Glory and Perseverance in the rear; Foresight and Graciousness were at the sides, And Courtesy therewith, and Purity, Desire for Honor, and Fear of Shame. A Thoughtfulness mature in spite of Youth, And, in concord rarely to be found, Beauty supreme at one with Chastity.34
Chastity carries a palm in her right hand in recognition of the virgin martyrs. The chariot is drawn by a pair of unicorns, an allusion to female chastity.35 Like the personification of Love, “she wore, that day, a gown of white . . .” In this very personal interpretation
33 My italics. García Icazbalceta (1968) II, 349, quoting Archbishop Zumárraga, 1544, this author’s translation: Y cosa de gran desacato y desvergüenza parece que ante el Santísimo Sacramento vayan los hombres con máscaras y en hábitos de mujeres, danzando y saltando con meneos deshonestos y lascivos, haciendo estruendo, estorbando los cantos de la Iglesia, representando profanos triunfos, como el del Dios del Amor, tan deshonesto, y aun á las personas no honestas, tan vergonzoso de mirar . . . 34 Petrarca (1962) 42. 35 Hall (1979) 231–232, 327–328.
34
penny c. morrill
of the Triumphs by Don Tomás de la Plaza, Chastity is that “Virtue, that never doth forsake the good . . .” This virtue, which “kindles pure desires within the heart,” 36 is the sacred vow of the priest, that he might overcome earthly appetites to enact his spiritual calling. The narrative of the procession in the Casa del Deán does not involve the conquest of each of the personified aspects of life, as in many of the other representations of the series. In the poblano mural Chastity does not trample Sublime Love, as is usually the case, but continues the quest for a higher spiritual and intellectual plane. The focus of this iconographic program is on the drama of life’s choices and demands, always with the promise of ultimate victory over death. Time is represented by the winged figure of Saturn with his hourglass at his side. He uses a cane to support himself while he holds up his son in the horrifying act of devouring him. As Panofsky has written, “Petrarch’s Time was not an abstract philosophical principle but a concrete alarming power.”37 In his description of the Triumph of Time Petrarch writes of Phoebus in his quadriga (chariot) with his ‘four good steeds’ moving with great speed, a reminder of the brevity of life. In the mural the chariot of Time is drawn by stags, known for their swiftness. The destructive force of personified Time is represented by his advanced age and crippled body. The cannibalistic act is the consumption of all that is created.38 From destruction comes the revelation of Truth. The fleeting passage of time forces the rejection of all that is vain. By placing Time before Death, Don Tomás has characterized life before its end. In his version of the Triumphs, Fame does not vanquish Death nor give meaning to life. It is nothing more than ‘arrant vanity’ or human pride: “The Sun, victorious o’er the human mind, / Will still revolve, and Fame will fade away.”39 Rather, it is Time that qualifies life, admonishing and unflinchingly pointing toward the truth of Salvation. The frightening skeletal apparition of Death holds his scythe aloft as he drives his team of oxen. As his chariot rolls forward, Death indiscriminately brings an end to life for people of all ages, from the poor and powerless to those who have enjoyed earthly success. The 36 37 38 39
Petrarca (1962) 41, 44, 46. Panofsky (1967) 79–80. Ibid., 76–77. Petrarca (1962) 96 and 99.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
35
Three Fates—Clotho, Lachesis, and Atropos—determine each person’s destiny and life span by cutting the thread of life from the spindle on its distaff.40 In a village set into the middle ground, a funerary cortege moves toward a circular walled enclosure. In the center of the back wall rises a tall tower embellished with signs of the cross on either side of the doorway. This tower is reminiscent of those that were constructed in the mid-sixteenth century in the towns of Tlaxcala and Tepeaca, both within close proximity to the city of Puebla, at the behest of Don Francisco Verdugo.41 These towers served as symbols of royal justice and power.
The Triumph of Eternity/Ecclesia The allegorical figure of Eternity/Ecclesia displays a queenly manner (Fig. 1.2). Her scepter in her right hand, she gestures a command to the peacocks to draw her aloft into the clouds. Behind her, as part of the chariot, lighted torches are set upon Solomonic columns. The bird’s eye view of the landscape allows the observer the same perspective as that of Eternity. Clouds barely rise above the grasscovered mountain in the foreground, while in the middle distance villages can be seen in the valley below. The mountains in the far distance are lost in a blue atmospheric haze. For centuries the Virgin as Queen of Heaven was envisioned simultaneously as the Church Triumphant. An early example of this is provided by the twelfth-century Hortus Deliciarum, in which the Virgin appears as both Ecclesia and the Queen of Heaven, surrounded by a hierarchy of bishops, friars, kings, and prophets.42 In a thirteenthcentury mosaic in Rome’s church of Santa Maria Maggiore, Christ crowns the Virgin with His right hand and holds a book in His left in which is written Veni, Electa mia, et ponam te in thronum meum. The River Jordan flows through the foreground of the scene, “symbol of baptism and regeneration; on its shore stands the hart, the emblem of religious aspiration.”43
40 41 42 43
Hall (1979) 302. Weckmann (1992) 370, 457, 594. Schiller (1971–) I, 288–299. See also Panofsky (1966) 145–146. Jameson (1895) 106–110.
36
penny c. morrill
Panofsky interprets a work that illustrates the complexity of Late Gothic Mariological symbolism, Jan van Eyck’s painting of the Madonna in the Church: In order to lend artistic expression to this mysterious and many-leveled identity of Virgin and Mother, Mother and Daughter, Daughter and Bride, Queen of Heaven and Church on Earth, an image had been devised which may be described as “the Virgin Mary in a church and as the Church.” [On her hem appear the following words:] It [meaning Divine Wisdom as diffused in the Universal Church and embodied in the Virgin Mary] is more beautiful than the sun and above the whole order (dispositio) of the stars. Being compared with the [natural] light, she is found before it. She is the brightness of eternal light, and the flawless mirror of God’s majesty.44
Building upon this visual heritage of the identification of the Virgin Mary with the Church, a tapestry from Chaumont in the Loire Valley, datable to the period 1500–10 and now in the Cleveland Museum of Art, provides the closest known iconographic antecedent to Mary as the Triumph of Eternity/Ecclesia as used in the Casa del Deán. The tapestry displays two angels who crown the Virgin as she sits enthroned in the Garden of Paradise, surrounded by a group of angelic musicians. According to the inscription on the banner in the upper right corner of the tapestry, Mary as Ecclesia has unmistakably been endowed with the additional identity of the Triumph of Eternity. Nothing triumphs by right authority Unless it is conducted by Eternity. Nothing is permanent beneath the firmament, But above us triumphs Eternity.45
Despite this iconographic development toward the Virgin as the simultaneous embodiment of the Triumph of Eternity and of the Church, in the illustrated editions of Petrarch’s Triumphs and in most depictions of the subject on cassoni or in print series, the Triumph of Eternity is evoked by the image of the Trinity or of Christ in Majesty. Contemporaneously, Titian painted a fresco in his residence of the Triumph of Faith and subsequently produced a woodcut based on the painting in 1511. Rather than casting Christ as the Man of
44 45
Panofsky (1966) 145–148. This author’s brackets. Shepherd (1961) 158–159 and 172–173.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
37
Sorrows, as in Savonarola’s Triumphus Crucis, Titian has Him riding in majesty, carrying a scepter and seated on a celestial orb, as the Eternal Christ.46 While this representation has its origins in Italy and is possibly reflective of the influence of Titian’s print, its use was widespread throughout Europe in the first half of the sixteenth century. Thus Dorothy G. Shepherd could affirm that the crowned Virgin as the Triumph of Eternity in the Chaumont tapestry of ca. 1500–10 is without precedent.47 This conceit, as Sheperd states, may have been unprecedented before the turn of the fifteenth century, but this essay asserts that it was reprised around 1580 in the murals of the Casa del Deán. It is now necessary to settle the identity of this female personification in the poblano cycle. Should she be considered the Triumph of Eternity as in Petrarch’s poem, or has she taken on another role or guise in the iconographic program of Don Tomás de la Plaza? The answer lies in visual clues, the most important being the Solomonic columns that are part of the chariot. The twelve Antique twisted columns that were placed in Old St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome were, according to legend, brought from the Temple of Solomon by the Emperor Constantine. Solomon’s Temple was the prototype for the universal Catholic Church and, on another level, was the “pre-figuration of the Heavenly Jerusalem.” Solomonic or Eucharistic architecture signifies the establishment of the Heavenly Jerusalem on earth at the end of time. The Council of Trent reinforced this view of the Eucharist, administered by the Church, bringing the faithful on earth ever closer to heaven. As Nora de Poorter observed on the symbolism embodied by the Solomonic columns, “The church itself thus becomes a forecourt of paradise. Through the power of the Eucharist . . . the believer is able to see and experience in advance the blessedness that he is destined to enjoy forever.”48 Consequently, the use of the Solomonic columns in her chariot proves that the Puebla figure, besides embodying the more common Petrarchist significance of Eternity, is also meant to be seen as the simultaneous personification of Ecclesia. It could be no other way for a cleric such as Don Tomás: Eternity, Eternal Life 46
Scribner (1982) 67; and Panofsky (1969) 59. Shepherd (1961) 172–173, cites one other related example, a manuscript illustrated with ink drawings, number 5066 in the Bibliothèque de l’Arsenal, Paris. 48 De Poorter (1978) 171–176. 47
38
penny c. morrill
is achieved by the otherwise ephemeral human being only by joining with the body of the Church, so they are tantamount and indistinguishable. And Mary is the figure for the body of the Church. This allegorical figure, Eternity/Ecclesia, triumphs over Death and Time. Her role as Mary, Queen of Heaven is validated by specific classicizing symbolic references that pervade other murals in the Room of Triumphs. She is defined by the peacocks, which draw her chariot, by the crown she wears, and by the scepter she carries. This imagery simultaneously identifies this syncretistic figure as Juno, identified by the Renaissance as the preeminent queen goddess of heaven in Antiquity and thus a trope for Mary (cf. Fig. 1.3).49 In her study of the Triumph of the Eucharist tapestries by Rubens, de Poorter emphasizes that in the Lowlands “preference was given at an early stage to Triumphs of a more didactic kind, in line with the somewhat austere allegories of the Rhetoricians. Abstract ideas, clad in allegorical forms, are seen in procession in triumphal cars, but the original idea of victory is to a large extent lost.”50 This same characterization can be applied to the Triumph murals in the Casa del Deán. The emblematic approach to this specific subject is apparent in the works that were precedents for Rubens’s tapestry designs and that happen to have been contemporaneous with the poblano cycle. A drawing attributed to Jan van der Straet, in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art and dated ca. 1590–1595, is entitled The Triumph of the Holy Scriptures and the Church. Following tradition, the chariot is drawn by the four animal symbols of the Evangelists, but the triumphal figure is a female personification of the Church, as in Puebla.51 Commissioned in 1590 by Albert and Isabella in Brussels, Otto van Veen painted six panels representing the Triumph of the Catholic Church. Ecclesia is a female personification common to all of the
49 Hall (1979) 182, 238; and Seyffert (1961) 337. On the early modern synchronization of history whereby themes from pre-Christian Antiquity are given biblical orientation, see Tanner (1993) 33–34, 54, 119–121; and Strong (1984) 68. According to de la Maza, (1968) 33, the birds in Puebla identified here as peacocks are instead geese. However, the artist who worked on the 1955 renovation of the Casa del Deán murals assured me that they represent peacocks. 50 De Poorter (1978) 199. 51 Jan van der Straet was also known as Johannes Stradanus or Giovanni Stradano.
Fig. 1.3 Juno. An engraving from Francis Pomey, Pantheum mythicum, seu, Fabulosa deorum historia. Amsterdam: Ex Officina Schouteniana; Apud J. J. a Poolsum, 1757. Courtesy of the Chapin Library Collection, Williams College, Williamstown, Massachusetts.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain 39
40
penny c. morrill
paintings. In the Triumph of Verbum Dei and Ecclesia, also known as Christ’s Investiture of the Church, the apocalyptic double-edged sword extends from the mouth of Christ as he places a book representing the Word of the Lord into the lap of Ecclesia, the crowned Queen of Heaven. Surrounded by the four writers of the Epistles—Peter, Paul, James, and John the Evangelist—Ecclesia’s chariot is drawn by the animal symbols of the four Gospel authors.52 None of these works had a direct influence on the poblano murals, but their development of symbolic references to the Church Triumphant and to the Eucharist as the essential path to redemption is reflective of the Counter-Reformation rhetoric that they share with the Dean’s opus. Among the decrees of the Council of Trent was the designation of the feast of Corpus Christi as an appropriate and solemn veneration of the Sacred Sacrament. It was also envisioned as the celebration of truth, the unique property of the universal Church in its triumph over falsehood and heresy.53 The triumphal figure in the Casa del Deán can be considered an example of a new allegorical model for Ecclesia, whose creation in the Spanish Netherlands in the mid-sixteenth century led to Rubens’s Triumph of the Eucharist. Prints of his composition were enormously influential in New Spain in the mid-seventeenth century as can be attested by the large renditions, virtually replicas, of Rubens’s work still hanging in the Cathedrals of Mexico City and Puebla.54 An illuminating text for the interpretation of the murals in the Room of the Triumphs is a Last Judgment in Náhuatl, the predominant Indian language of central Mexico at the time of the Spanish
52 Sutton (1993) 14–15. De Poorter (1978) publishes an image of a lost tapestry, Plate 76, described on page 201, dated c. 1520–30, entitled The Triumph of Faith, in which the Virgin Mary is enthroned, holding in her right hand a model of a church and in her left the cross of the Resurrection. Church equals Ecclesia and Resurrection equals Eternity, Eternal Life, foretelling the poblano personification. For the six van Veen panels, see de Poorter (1978) 199–200. De Poorter switched the titles for the Triumphs in Plates 71 and 72. For the van Veen cycle, see also Vogl (1987); and Knipping (1974) 57. For the biblical references to the sword, Revelation 1:16; 2:12, 16. 53 De Poorter (1978) 165. 54 Burke (1982) 59–63; and Toussaint (1967) 238–241. Baltasar Echave Rioja’s version of the Triumph of the Eucharist, dated 1675, is in Puebla Cathedral’s sacristy. Cristóbal de Villalpando painted another for the Cathedral of Mexico City in 1685, followed by Nicolás Rodríguez Juárez’s rendition in 1695 for the Church of El Carmen in the city of Celaya in the present Mexican State of Guanajuato.
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
41
conquest and through the colonial period. Dating before 1550, this play, now in the Library of Congress, has been attributed to the Franciscan Andrés de Olmos. Ricard states that The famous polyglot Fray Andrés de Olmos wrote . . . an auto entitled El Juicio Final. . . . It was staged in the chapel of San José de los Naturales [in Mexico City] before Viceroy Mendoza, who arrived in 1535, and before [Archbishop] Zumárraga, who died in 1548. According to Las Casas, some eight hundred actors and supernumeraries participated in it and played their parts to perfection.55
One of those parts is spoken by the Holy Church, and this allegorical figure’s lines, along with those of Time and Death, are worth relating to the meaning of their plastic counterparts in the Room of the Triumphs. The play begins with the sound of trumpets as the Heavens open and St. Michael appears: Michael: Be in deadly fear! For the Day of Judgment will descend upon you, fearful, dreadful, frightful, paralyzing! Take warning and lead a proper life. The Day of Judgment is at hand.
The trumpets sound again and Penitence, Time, the Holy Church, Confession, and Death appear onstage. As they speak about the Judgment that is imminent, the dialogue provides a closely related parallel to the iconographic program in the Room of the Triumphs. Time: I am Time. I am he who continues ever-questioning people. Our Lord God sent and established me to keep them, care for them, warn them, remind them day and night. Never do I stop speaking! I am continually shouting in their ears so that they may remember their Creator, their Maker, the Lord God. I take care that they cry out to Him; that they bless Him; that they serve Him; that they do as their Lord our God wishes. I urge them to go to His house and to praise Him; to ask for His Divine Grace. Holy Church: I am the ever-merciful mother. My beloved Son Jesus Christ has established me here for the people of the earth. I am always weeping for them, especially when some of them die. For when I shed tears, I pray to my beloved Mother, the sacred fountain of Joy, to have pity on her creatures and to give light to them. . . . My heart is sad for them. Would that they might pray to be pardoned; that they might weep and repent of their shortcomings and sins! 55 Ricard (1966) 47–48, 195. The play’s actual combined Spanish-Náhuatl title is Nexcuitilmachiotl Motenhua Juicio Final.
42
penny c. morrill Penitence: Oh mother of complete faith, all that you say is quite true! . . . Death: I am the officer of the law, the appointed one, the messenger empowered by heaven. Here on earth the power spreads forth to the uttermost limits as the rays of the sun shining forth in the heavens, and over the whole earth. Let the people of the earth remember that soon the beloved Son of God will come down to judge the quick and the dead. . . . Holy Church: I am the divine light of the only faith. I enlighten and give spiritual vision to all Christians that they may come so that I may cleanse them; for they are dizzy and stupid with sin. If they weep and are sad, then my beloved Youth, Jesus Christ, will pardon them and give them the kingdom of heaven.
The Judgment proceeds and the play ends with the entrance of the priest. Priest: . . . The Day of Judgment is coming soon. Pray to our Lord Jesus Christ and to the Virgin Mary, that She may entreat Her beloved Son Jesus Christ that you might merit and deserve the joy of Heaven— that eternal glory! Amen.56
Andrés de Olmos has cast the Holy Church not only as Mother of God but as the embodiment of “the divine light of the only faith.” The Mater Ecclesia is the ever-merciful mother whose “beloved Son Jesus Christ” has established Her, the Church, on this earth for all people. At the same time that the Holy Church takes the part of the mother who weeps for her children, the Holy Church prays to the beloved Mother. In this interweaving of roles and identities, we are reminded of Jan van Eyck’s Madonna in the Church, in which Mary is depicted in the church and as the Church. In both the painting and in Olmos’s play, the Virgin Mary shines with the radiance of divine light: “She is the brightness of eternal light, and the flawless mirror of God’s majesty.”57 And at the last it is the Virgin in Her role as Queen of Heaven and Bride of Christ who is intercessor on the Day of Judgment.
56
Ravicz (1970) 141–156. Panofsky (1966) 145–148. Dotson (1979) 427, in her definitive interpretation of Michelangelo’s mural cycle in the Sistine Chapel, points out that the Sibyls in their oracles acknowledge the central role of the Virgin who as Mother of Christ simultaneously becomes the Church, “which feeds her children, whose lap is a refuge, in whose womb is the model of life.” 57
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
43
Conclusion The narrative of the processions that make their way through the two rooms of the Casa del Deán ends in serenity and peace. What began with blindfolded Synagoga reaches its culmination in the Triumph of Eternity/Ecclesia. Panofsky wrote of this duality with its eschatological implications that “The conversion of the Synagogue . . . was the precondition of the final triumph of Christianity which was ushered in by the Last Judgment and found fulfillment in what St. Augustine calls the ‘Eternal Beatitude of the City of God.’”58 The theme for the mural cycle is built upon the concepts of prefiguration in the Room of the Sibyls and of fulfillment in the Room of the Triumphs.59 The knowledge of the future beyond human experience involves a conception of history as divinely determined. An eschatological and apocalyptic view of God’s plan can only be communicated through a ‘celestial mediator’ and then written down by the visionary who has received the divine revelation. This concept of a predetermined history can be characterized as teleological, a “drama of conflict between good and evil leading toward a definitive conclusion, an end that gives meaning to the whole.”60 The theme that unifies the mural cycle is the fulfillment of prophecy in the Triumph of the Church. In the first room of the Casa del Deán, the Sibyls foretell the events of Christ’s life on earth, ending with the Resurrection. As predicted, Christ took on human form to live and die and live again. Through His suffering and death Christ became the last sacrifice, the propitiation for the sins of humanity. Like the pagan believers who heard the Sibyls’ prophecies, the indigenous people of New Spain, following this dialectic, accepted the true God and His promise of redemption. This promise is fulfilled in the Triumph of the Church. The unity of Christ with the Mater Ecclesia is built upon the central sacramental responsibilities of the Church: the administration of Baptism and the ongoing celebration of Christ’s sacrificial omnipresence in the Eucharist. As the only true agent of redemptive grace, the post-Reformation Church Triumphant appears in the Casa del Deán mural as the Queen of Heaven in Her syncretistic guise as the Triumph of Eternity. 58 59 60
Panofsky (1969) 65. Dotson (1979) 409. McGinn (1985) 51–53.
44
penny c. morrill
The culmination of the poblano mural sequence in the Triumph of Eternity/Ecclesia reveals a shared conceptualization on the part of Don Tomás de la Plaza and the native artist to the effect that they were participants in an unfolding cosmic drama. The Church Triumphant was seen as the earthly agent that could bring the hope of redemption to Spaniard and Amerindian alike, as tortillas became sacred flesh, and wine, the sacred blood of Christ.
Bibliography Actas de Cabildo de los siglos XVI y XVII de la muy noble y muy leal Ciudad de la Puebla de los Ángeles, CD-rom (Puebla: 1996). Burke, M. (1992) Pintura y escultura en Nueva España: El Barroco (Mexico: 1992). Colonna, F. (1499) Hypnerotomachia Poliphili, ubi humana omnia non nisi somnium esse docet (Venice: 1499). Dante Alighieri (1950) The Comedy of Dante Alighieri, trans. D. L. Sayers (Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England: 1950). De La Maza, F. (1968) La mitología clásica en el arte colonial de México (Mexico City: 1968). De Marchi, N., and H. J. Van Miegroet (2000) “Exploring Markets for Netherlandish Painting in Spain and Nueva España,” Nederlands Kunsthistorisch Jaarboek 50 (2000) 81–112. De Poorter, N. (1978) The Eucharist Series. Corpus Rubenianum Ludwig Burchard, part 2, 2 vols. (London: 1978). Dotson, E. G. (1979) “An Augustinian Interpretation of Michelangelo’s Sistine Chapel,” Art Bulletin 61, nos. 2–3 ( June–September 1979). Ferguson, G. (1974) Signs and Symbols in Christian Art (Oxford: 1974). Fernández del Castillo, F. (1914) Libros y libreros en el siglo XVI, rpt. (Mexico City: 1982 [1914]). Fernández Echeverría y Veytia, M. (1931) Historia de la fundación de la Ciudad de la Puebla de los Ángeles en la Nueva España: Su descripción y presente estado, 2 vols. (Puebla: 1931). Gibson, C. (1952) Tlaxcala in the Sixteenth Century (New Haven, CT: 1952). Hall, J. (1979) Dictionary of Subjects and Symbols in Art, rev. ed. (New York: 1979). Hughes, G. (1997) Renaissance Cassoni, Masterpieces of Early Italian Art: Painted Marriage Chests, 1400–1500 (London: 1997). Jameson, A. (1895) Legends of the Madonna as Represented in the Fine Arts (Boston: 1895). Knipping, J. B. (1974) Iconography of the Counter-Reformation in the Netherlands: Heaven on Earth, 2 vols. (Nieuwkoop, The Netherlands: 1974). Kropfinger von Kügelgen, H. (1979) “Aspectos iconológicos en los murales de la Casa del Deán de Puebla,” Comunicaciones de la Fundación Alemana para la Investigación Científica 16 (1979). ——, (1973) Exportación de libros europeos de Sevilla a la Nueva España en el año de 1586 (Wiesbaden: 1973). Leicht, H. (1934) Las calles de Puebla, rpt. (Puebla: 1986 [1934]). Mâle, É. (1986) Religious Art in France: The Late Middle Ages, H. Bober, ed., and M. Matthews, trans. (Princeton: 1986). Massena, V., Prince d’Essling (1902) Petrarche: Ses études d’art. . . . (Paris: 1902).
the queen of heaven reigns in new spain
45
McGinn, B. (1985) The Calabrian Abbot: Joachim of Fiore in the History of Western Thought (New York: 1985). Montes Bardo, J. (1998) Arte y espiritualidad franciscana en la Nueva España, siglo XVI: Iconología en la Provincia del Santo Evangelio ( Jaén, Spain: 1998). The New Oxford Annotated Bible with the Apocrypha. Revised Standard Edition. H. G. May and B. M. Metzger, eds. (New York: 1977). Palm, E. W. (1973) “Los murales del convento agustino de Metztitlán.” Comunicaciones (Puebla: 1973). Panofsky, E. (1966) Early Netherlandish Painting: Its Origins and Character, 2 vols. (Cambridge, MA: 1966). ——, (1969) Problems in Titian, Mostly Iconographic (New York: 1969). ——, (1967) Studies in Iconology: Humanistic Themes in the Art of the Renaissance (New York: 1967). Petrarca, F. (1962) The Triumphs of Petrarch, trans. E. H. Wilkins (Chicago: 1962). Pietropaolo, D. (1987) “Spectacular Literacy and the Topology of Significance: The Processional Mode,” in Petrarch’s Triumphs: Allegory and Spectacle, K. Eisenbichler and A. A. Iannucci, eds. (Toronto: 1987). Pomey, F. (1757) Pantheum mythicum, seu, Fabulosa deorum historia (Amsterdam: 1757). Ravicz, M. E. (1970) Early Colonial Religious Drama in Mexico: From Tzompantli to Golgotha (Washington, D.C.: 1970). Ricard, R. (1966) The Spiritual Conquest of Mexico, ed. L. B. Simpson (Berkeley: 1966). Schiller, G. (1971–) Iconography of Christian Art, J. Seligman, trans. (Greenwich, CT: 1971–). Two volumes of the translation have appeared so far. Schwaller, J. F. (1987) The Church and Clergy in Sixteenth-Century Mexico (Albuquerque: 1987). Scribner III, C. (1982) The Triumph of the Eucharist Tapestries Designed by Rubens (Ann Arbor, MI: 1982). Sebastián, S. (1992) Iconografía e iconología del arte novohispano (Mexico: 1992). Seigel, J. (1968) Rhetoric and Philosophy in Renaissance Humanism: The Union of Eloquence and Wisdom, Petrarch to Valla (Princeton: 1968). Seyffert, O. (1961) Dictionary of Classical Antiquities, eds. H. Nettleship and J. E. Sandys (Cleveland: 1961). Shepherd, D. G. (1961) “Three Tapestries from Chaumont,” Bulletin, Cleveland Museum of Art, 48, 7 (September 1961). Strong, R. C. Art and Power: Renaissance Festivals, 1450–1650 (Woodbridge, Suffolk: 1984). Tanner, M. (1993) The Last Descendant of Aeneas: The Hapsburgs and the Mythic Image of the Emperor (New Haven, CT: 1993). Toussaint, M. (1967) Colonial Art in Mexico, trans. and ed. E. W. Weismann (Austin: 1967). Vogl, A. (1987) Der Bilderzyklus “Der Triumph der Kirche” von Otto van Veen (Munich: 1987). Weckmann, L. (1992) The Medieval Heritage of Mexico (New York: 1992).
CHAPTER TWO
AFFECTIONS OF THE HEART: FEMALE IMAGERY AND THE NOTION OF NATION IN NINETEENTH-CENTURY MEXICO Magali M. Carrera
Nationalism is not the awakening of nations to self-consciousness; it invents nations where they do not exist. Benedict Anderson Women contribute most particularly to the happiness of the State . . . In her bosom man begins to exist, in her lap he grows, is nourished and acquires his first notions of Good and Evil. Semanario Económico de México, 1813
“A nation is nothing more than a great family, and in order for it to be stable and strong it means that all of its members must be closely united with ties of interest and affections of the heart.”1 With these words, written in 1847, Mariano Otero, a young Mexican politician, reminded his countrymen that they must put aside their differences and come together through love of country in order to overcome Mexico’s tumultuous political, social, and economic disarray in the mid-nineteenth century. Otero’s use of the metaphor of family is important because it implies the concept of ‘nation’ as an intricate web of affective relationships promoting a common good. Indeed, the theme of love of country constantly echoed across visual and written texts as the kingdom of New Spain, with its emphasis on la patria, motherland (also fatherland), in service to the sovereignty of the king, became the Republic of Mexico, with its focus on la nación, “nation,” in service to the sovereignty of the people. This essay examines the gendered imagery that was associated with such affections. As Mexico attempted to define and constitute
1 Otero (1975) [1847] 45. Otero’s essay was originally published anonymously and is generally attributed to him. Dennis E. Berge (1975), an historian, believes that the authors were Mariano Otero and, possibly, Juan Bautista Morales, also a political essayist.
48
magali m. carrera
itself as a nation, sovereignty, represented by the imagery of the king’s body, was replaced by a changing set of female images. Throughout the nineteenth century, this new corporeal imagery marked the shifting of the signifying site of sovereignty and represented an ongoing search to give visual focus to nationalist affections of the heart.
The Body of the Sovereign “Vivan Nuestros Amados Soberanos Carlos Quarto [sic] y María Luisa de Borbón,” “Long Live Our Beloved Sovereigns Carlos the Fourth and María Luisa of Bourbon.” These words, supported by large wooden props, appeared on the central plaza of Mexico City in December 1796 as part of a three-day celebration to mark both the birthday of the Queen, María Luisa de Borbón, and the installation of a statue of King Carlos IV. As one would expect of this opulent and luxurious capital of New Spain, the city was elaborately decorated with banners and its numerous public and private buildings were lit with over 20,000 lights. In summarizing the event, the Gaceta de México, a monthly publication, went so far as to state: “It offered a spectacle that sweeps the imagination.”2 The culmination of the celebration, however, was the unveiling of a massive statue of Carlos IV in the city’s central plaza that presented the king, his right arm extended, riding a great prancing horse. In inaugurating this sculptural project, Viceroy Branciforte asserted that the magnificent metropolis of Mexico City had enjoyed many benefits of royal patronage and now possessed what it had previously lacked—a great image of the king placed in the center of the capital that illustrated his virtues.3 Closer examination of the circumstances of the statue, however, exposes an obvious but unexplored fact about the historical context of this equestrian visage: It was initially dedicated about three years after the King of France, Louis XIV, had been beheaded and the French monarchical system—figuratively and literally—had been dis-
2
Gaceta de México (9 December 1796) 231. Documentos varios para la historia de la Ciudad de México a fines de la época colonial (1769 –1815) (1983) nos. 1–16, “Descripción de las fiestas,” 1. 3
affections of the heart
49
membered by the French Revolution. In New Spain there was great dismay over the French Revolution and its implications as is evident in a December 1794 sermon, delivered by Fray Servando Teresa de Mier in Mexico City, which censored the treacherous ideas of Rousseau and the horror of the Jacobin regicide.4 Within this political context, the equestrian statue may be understood as a reification of the paramount trope of the ancien régime: The body of the Spanish king was assembled in New Spain as the sovereign body of the French king was disassembled. At the beginning of the nineteenth century there was continued awareness of the conceptual destruction of monarchy caused by French political thinking. This view is confirmed by the fact that in August 1801 the Gaceta de México announced that the book Histoire philosophique de la révolution de France by Antoine Fantin Desodoards [sic] had been banned because it “emanated an implacable hatred towards monarchical government, kingship, [and] the Catholic Religion. . . .”5 In addition, Inquisition records indicate that French political writings were in circulation in eighteenth-century New Spain and a list of prohibited books was regularly announced. Various individuals were denounced for owning or reading books by writers such as Voltaire and Rousseau.6 In December 1803 the commission for the equestrian statue of Charles IV was completed when a bronze version was installed that replaced the temporary wooden one which had been used for the 1796 celebration. On this momentous occasion, Viceroy Iturrigaray,
4
Brading (2001) 201. Gaceta de México (29 August 1801) n. p. Further research indicates that the Gaceta notice is probably referring to the book by Antoine Étienne Nicolas Fantin des Odoards [1738–1820], Histoire de la République française . . . (Paris: A. J. Dugour [etc.] an. VI [1798]). Also, late eighteenth-century New Spanish Inquisition records contain numerous proclamations listing banned books and pamphlets. Books by Rousseau, Voltaire, and other French philosophers were repeatedly placed on these lists. 6 Two examples for the time period under discussion include: “El Sr Inquisidor fiscal de este santo oficio contra el Fr. D. José Pastor Morales, clerigo de ordenes menores de este arzobispado . . . Por Proposiciones. Resulta contra Morelle, Durrey, Enderica, . . . (leia libros de Voltaire, Rousseau, etc, era afecto a las maximas de Francia y a su revolución, etc.),” AGN-202749, Inquisición, 1795, vol. 1361, Exp. 1 fols. 1–184 and “Relación de la causa seguida contra Dn, Antonio Castro y Salgado . . . Soltero. Por proposiciones hereticas, lectura de libros prohibidos, defensor de Rousseau, etc.” AGN-204162. Inquisición 1803 vol. 1414, Exp. 2, fols. 280–289, 309–328. 5
50
magali m. carrera
Branciforte’s successor, expounded effusively on the importance of this monument by writing In an instant, the place [central plaza] was filled with people of all classes. Their faces reflected the enjoyment they felt in their souls. They had no words to respectfully express their sincere gratitude for their great fortune. As they gazed at the statue—at his paternal smile, his tender looks—the people expressed reverent comments to each other.7
As in 1796, ostensibly the purpose of the permanent statue was to honor the king and bring his physical presence to New Spain and into the hearts and minds of New Spanish subjects. The viceroy’s words emphasized New Spanish loyalty and affection for the king. We might wonder, however, why, after more than two-and-onehalf centuries of Spanish rule, was there a need to produce such corporeal imagery of the king’s body in New Spain? In earlier centuries, the person of the viceroy was considered to embody the king’s presence in New Spain while verbal edicts and proclamations regularly declared and assured the king’s oversight.8 An examination of this reproduction of the king’s body in the context of the republican ideas spawned by the French revolution provides possible answers to this question. In his excellent study of the ancien régime’s notion of the body of the king, Antoine de Baecque asserts that the trope of the body was derived from Enlightenment thinking that selected the human body as the “proper matter for their studies and experiments, in order to calibrate the grid through which to read the microcosm and the macrocosm.” Baecque points out that “one single body perpetuated itself from Bourbon king to king, embodying the continuity of the state, a body in which all subjects could recognize themselves and in which everyone recognized their sovereign.” French revolutionary rhetoric was derived from this scientific viewpoint and political understanding as “corporeal images were at the very center of
7 “En un instante se llenó de personas de todas classes, en cuyos semblantes se veía la enagenacion de sus almas, que llenas de regocijo no les cabian en el pecho; y que, creyéndose en la presencia de su mismo adorado Monarca, manifestaban con respetuosos palabras su justa sincera gratitud á tanta fortuna. Las dulces miradas, la sonrisa filial, la afectuosa reverencia y lo que unos á otras se decian mirando á la Estatua, . . .” (1803) Documentos varios para la historia de la Ciudad de México a fines de la época colonial (1769–1815) (1983): XIV, nos. 1–12, 9. 8 See Cañeque (1999).
affections of the heart
51
the metaphoric language used to describe the revolution in progress.” Old Regime imagery had emphasized the body of the king, while revolutionary visual and written rhetoric used corporeal imagery such as the congenital deformity of the aristocrats and the impotence of the king. As a result, the king’s body was deconsecrated, represented as a sick, impotent entity that, literally and physically, had to be torn apart.9 Considered as part of a broader corporeal discourse of the ancien régime, the production of the massive equestrian statue of Charles IV may be seen as an attempt to propose absolutist stability and continuity in New Spain at a time when the conceptual tenet of the king’s body as a sign of sovereignty was highly unstable in Europe and its continuity in jeopardy. This latent discourse on sovereignty was manifested through this late-eighteenth-century equestrian imagery of Spain’s Bourbon king. More importantly, in the next century, corporeal imagery would be continued in the metaphorical visual language of Mexican nation-building. In the first decades of the nineteenth century, New Spain saw dramatic political changes as the French Revolution’s purging of the ancien régime trope spread to Spain when Napoleon Bonaparte occupied Spain and forced the abdication of King Charles IV, the renunciation and captivity of his successor, Ferdinand VII, and the appointment of Joseph Napoleon to the Spanish throne in 1807. In the period 1807–1821, elites in New Spain protested the Spanish king’s forced confinement and moved initially to be autonomous from Spain and, eventually, independent. During this time, New Spain had to confront radical questions about the definition and imagery of sovereignty: If sovereignty was no longer located in the body of the king, where was it to be located and how would it be visualized? How were loyal affections to be directed? Alegoría de las autoridades españolas e indígenas by Patricio Suárez de Peredo, an 1809 oil painting, reflects these early nineteenth-century events (Fig. 2.1). In this panel, three oval-shaped medallions and two groups of figures surround the central image of Ferdinand VII, a captive of the French. An image of the Virgin of Guadalupe floats in a white cloud above the king; the medallion to the right of the king bears the Spanish crest of Castile y León, while that to the
9
Baecque (1997) 1, 4–5, 8.
52
magali m. carrera
Fig. 2.1 Patricio Súarez de Peredo, Alegoría de las autoridades españolas e indígenas (Allegory of the Spanish and Indigenous Authorities). 1809, oil, approx. 170 × 90 cm. Museo Nacional del Virreinato, Mexico. Reproduction authorized by the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo Nacional de la Cultura (CONACULTA.INAH.-MEX), Mexico.
affections of the heart
53
king’s left illustrates the insignia of Mexico City. The abraded legend in the lower section of the panel begins with “Long Live the King” and identifies the standing figure as José Ramírez, a Spaniard and a delegate of the king. He is surrounded by Spanish soldiers and Don Juan Felipe M., an elaborately dressed Indian corregidor, or “official,” of the town of San Cristóbal Ecatepec. Don Juan stands with another unnamed figure and a third partially dressed personage who wears the feathered dress associated with the traditional indigenous costume. Overall, the painting both verbally and visually states New Spain’s continued loyalty to the confined king.10 While the painting emphasizes loyalty to the captive king, its imagery de-emphasizes the person of the king. It emphatically situates the body of the king within a new constellation of references that do not come from the absolutist vision of sovereignty. Ferdinand VII does not emerge as a singular, powerful figure. Instead he is protected by a bulwark of emblems that, with the exception of the Castile y León standard, emphasize New Spanish identity. Further, new sets of bodies are also put in this constellation with that of the King. These include Spanish and Indian subjects. Nevertheless, particularly striking, and not mentioned in the legend, is the presence of the Virgin of Guadalupe: This female body, larger in scale than that of the king, hovers over him. This leads us to question: Why is the image of the Virgin depicted in this painting and how does she relate to issues of sovereignty that New Spain was facing at this time?
The Body of the Patria “Long live religion! Long live our most holy Mother of Guadalupe! Long live Ferdinand VII! Long Live America and death to bad government!” These insurgent words, pronounced on September 16, 1810, by Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla, a parish priest of the town of Dolores, elucidate the context of the Suárez painting. Spoken seven years after the inauguration of the bronze equestrian statue, the words called for a revolution from the Napoleonic tyranny that had beset Spain.
10
For further discussion of this painting, see Acevedo (2000) 117–118.
magali m. carrera
54
Hidalgo reinforced his Grito de Dolores, as it is known, by adopting a standard emblazoned with the image of the Virgin of Guadalupe. Thus, although the Grito de Dolores demanded Ferdinand’s freedom from captivity, Hidalgo did not call on the imagery of the absolutist body of the king to visualize his declaration; rather, he called on a female image—an image unique to New Spain. Hidalgo’s use of Guadalupana imagery may be derived from two dimensions of the Virgin Mary: First, the broader historical associations of the Virgin and, secondly, her specific meanings in New Spain. In researching the wider cultural implications of the figure of Mary, Amy Remensnyder, a historian of medieval Europe, has argued that the general scholarly perception of her as a figure of nurturing and benevolence is an incomplete assessment of the iconographic constellation of the Virgin. Mary was associated directly with the twelfth-century Christian campaigns against Islam, confirmed by the fact that medieval manuscripts illustrate crusaders going into battle carrying banners that display her image. Mary, in fact, could be quite a wrathful woman, as is found in various New Testament texts. Remensnyder, concluding that this vengeful side of Mary has been less acknowledged by scholars, suggests that Mary is better understood as a boundary figure who, as described in visual and written media, triumphs over the ‘other.’11 The Virgin had this conquest/triumphant role in the subjugation of the Aztec-Mexica, as Hernán Cortés is said to have placed an image of Our Lady of Los Remedios, a renowned Marian icon in Spain, on the altar of the main Aztec-Mexica temple of Tenochtitlán to embody Spanish conquest. Eventually, Our Lady of Los Remedios would be designated patron of Mexico City, the capital of New Spain, and would become an important cult figure for the Spanishborn population.12 In the context of these broad and very deep meanings of the imagery of the Virgin and her association with aggression, it is appropriate then that this insurgent priest of Dolores, steeped in church history, chose the image of Mary to launch a revolution. Along with the conquest associations of the Virgin Mary, Hidalgo’s use of her image in the form of the Guadalupe has a second dimension that is specific to her appearance in the Americas. The tradi-
11 12
Remensnyder (2003). Brading (2001) 46–47.
affections of the heart
55
tion and cult of the Virgin of Guadalupe marked a profound change in New Spain’s understanding of itself because, unlike Our Lady of Los Remedios, Guadalupe was considered indigenous to New Spain. To understand this significance, it is important to review the simple story of the Guadalupe’s apparition. On December 9, 1531, Juan Diego, a converted Indian, was walking across a barren hill called Tepeyac. Suddenly, he heard music and was blinded by a light as before him appeared a dark-skinned woman who identified herself as the Virgin Mary, the mother of Jesus Christ. She directed Juan Diego to tell Bishop Juan de Zumárraga that she wished to have a church built on the hill in her honor. Hearing Juan Diego’s request, the unbelieving Bishop asked for proof of the validity of the apparition. Three days later, on December 12th, the Virgin reappeared to Juan Diego and directed him to pick roses from a nearby bush and take them to Zumárraga. Juan Diego obeyed, placed the roses in his cloak and carried them to the Bishop. When he opened his cloak to present the flowers, an image of the Virgin was miraculously imprinted on Juan Diego’s mantle. Now a believer, the Bishop had a small church built on the site of the apparition. While the basic elements of this story are well known, the origins and uses of this tale are convoluted and, perhaps, more interesting than the story itself. The simple fact is that Bishop Zumárraga did not provide any written description or certification of the apparition and, in reality, there are no existing primary sources from the time of the apparition. In his book The Mexican Phoenix, D. A. Brading makes his way through a maze of secondary sources—especially sermons—that started to appear more than one hundred years after the apparition supposedly occurred and from which the generally accepted story of Guadalupe is derived. Although the circuitous details of the evolution of this Virgin’s story cannot be presented here, it is important to recognize that in the seventeenth century there was an explosion of interest in this apparition that continued through subsequent centuries. Over these centuries, written sources would tie together religion and patriotism associated with the growth of a criollo, that is American-born Spaniard, sense of a New Spanish rather than an Iberian patria. For example, seventeenth-century writers would emphasize that, unlike Our Lady of Remedios, “Mary and the Mexican patria were united in the enduring imagery of Guadalupe.” Others remarked that her image stirred “that natural affection which inclines so powerfully,
56
magali m. carrera
often without feeling it, and moves us with even more vehemence on everything that is of the mother country.” In fact, by the last quarter of the seventeenth century, the words “non facit taliter omni natione,” “It was not done thus to all nations,” taken from Psalm 147, appeared in reproductions of the image of the Guadalupe. This phrase indicated the belief that New Spain held a privileged place in the supposedly special way that it was favored by this particular apparition and vocation of the Virgin over other nations.13 Such displays of exceptionalism are central stratagems of nationalism and the development of a national consciousness. By the eighteenth century the cult of the Virgin of Guadalupe gained official status. In 1737 she would be named patron of Mexico City and the kingdom of New Spain by the city council, and in 1754 Pope Benedict XIV would approve the Guadalupe as the patron of New Spain. Brading concludes that the final eighteenth-century emergence of the ‘nation’ in the discourse of these [Guadalupana] sermons, no matter how distant from any social reality, testified to the fervent patriotism . . . which helped inspire the cult of Guadalupe. . . . But from the start, the inner meaning of the Apparition story was that the Mother of God had come to Mexico, and in a special way had chosen to remain in Mexico, acting as its patron.14
Thus, in adopting the imagery of the Guadalupe on his standard, along with Her medieval associations of violence, Hidalgo was also associating his revolutionary ideas with the affections for the patria that in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries came to be associated with the Virgin. It is clear then, that Hidalgo could not have called upon the image of Ferdinand VII to endorse his proclamation because the ancién regime’s body was weakened and unable to represent potent sovereignty. Similarly, in the painting Alegoría de las autoridades españolas e indígenas, we see the king positioned not singularly but in the company of the Virgin’s female body and New Spanish subjects for the same reason (Fig. 2.1). Along with Her association with the conquest tradition and Her ties to the construct of patria, Hidalgo’s use of the image of the Virgin of Guadalupe signifies the new relationship of New Spanish subjects to Spain at a time when this nexus was
13 14
Brading (2001) 69, 111. Brading (2001) 125, 132, 168.
affections of the heart
57
being radically restructured. The body of the Virgin of Guadalupe signifies a new process in the formation of the nación. Her use in nationalist iconography also initiates the sequence of corporeal imagery of females to mark the shifting of the signifying site of sovereignty from the body of the king to a new body. Napoleon’s actions in Spain marked the transition in that country’s political culture from the ancien régime, where legitimacy of the state was based in the corporate institutions and their pact with the king, to modernity, where the legitimacy of the state is predicated on the individual and her/his contract with the nation.15 In New Spain this transition was certified in September 1813 when José María Morelos, a priest and student of Hidalgo as well as a prominent military leader of the Mexican revolution, would convoke a Constitutional Congress at Chilpancingo, Guerrero, and declare Mexico’s independence from Spain. His declaration emphatically stated that sovereignty springs from the people and established that the “twelfth of December be celebrated in all villages in honor of the patroness of our liberty, the Most Holy Mary of Guadalupe.”16 In sum, as New Spain became Mexico, the presence of the Virgin of Guadalupe in early nationalist verbal and visual discourse marked the presence of a boundary between the old regime and modernity as affections of the heart were directed away from the king toward the Virgin. This use of female imagery specified an altogether new relationship of the subject to the patria. If the male body represented the old regime, then the use of the female body may be seen as helping to undermine the icon and symbol of the absolutist state. The Virgin of Guadalupe now elicited the loyal affection toward the patria previously educed by the king. While introducing new imagery for the incipient stages of Mexican independence, the Virgin of Guadalupe, however, would not and could not become the central signifier of the Mexican nation in subsequent decades. By the late 1820s a new set of female entities make their appearance in the discourse of nationalist painting.
15 16
Anna (1998) 53–54. Morelos (2002) [1813] 189–190.
magali m. carrera
58
The Sovereign Body of the Nation At the beginning of the third decade of the nineteenth century, Mexico gained its independence from Spain through the Treaty of Córdoba and established itself as an independent state through the Plan de Iguala. The Plan de Iguala attempted to bring together diverse groups—liberal and conservative, rebels and royalists, criollos and Spaniards—into an uneasy union and declared all inhabitants of Mexico citizens.17 Establishing the founding principles of Religion, Independence, and Union, the Plan called for a constitutional monarchy in hopes that Ferdinand VII or another aristocrat would rule the Mexican empire. When it became evident that a European royal would not ascend the Mexican throne, Agustín Iturbide, a hero of the war of independence, was proclaimed Emperor Agustín I of Mexico in May 1822. Iturbide attempted “to preserve the best features of the social administrative structure of the Bourbon monarchy, believing that national unity required centralism. In claiming his role as emperor, he reverted to the imagery of the ancien régime focused on his male body as the center of national pageantry and imagery. Iturbide would be forced to abdicate in March 1823, however, because he had tried to impose this centralized system on an empire that was in fact an aggregate of provinces that sought significant autonomy and separation from centralized government. In the end, the Congress claimed that Iturbide did not possess the right to exercise authority because sovereignty belonged to the Congress as representative of the regional states.18 As Mexico moved from the independence struggle toward the creation of nation, female bodies continued to represent the shifting understanding of sovereignty. In particular, a new female figure emerged to refocus the changing relationship of the citizen to the nation, rooting it in the arousal of patriotic affection. Seen in the oil painting Alegoría de la Independencia (1834), this young and somewhat frail seated female figure is identified as Mexico through her crown of red, white, and green feathers marking Mexico’s national colors (Fig. 2.2). She wears a quiver, a reference to indigenous culture,
17 18
Anna (1998) 81–82. Anna (1998) 95–97.
Fig. 2.2 Anon., Alegoría de la Independencia. 1834, oil, approx. 169 × 196 cm., Museo Casa de Hidalgo, Centro INAH-Guanajuato, Dolores Hidalgo, Mexico. Reproduction authorized by the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo Nacional de la Cultura (CONACULTA.-INAH.-MEX), Mexico.
affections of the heart 59
60
magali m. carrera
Fig. 2.3 Louis Charles Routte and Jacques-Louis Copia, after Louis-Marie Sicardi, La Liberté, Patrone des Français, after Louis-Simon Boizot. 1795, etching, S.P. Avery Collection, Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs, The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox, and Tilden Foundations.
affections of the heart
61
and she holds the Phrygian cap on a stick, which signifies liberty through its reference to the hat worn by French insurgents that became a symbol of the French revolution. The metropolitan model for this allegorical figure of Mexico is exemplified by La Liberté Patrone des Français (Fig. 2.3). This 1795 French etching illustrates Liberty dressed in a simple tunic wearing the Phrygian cap and a French revolutionary tricolor sash around her waist.19 Allegorical Mexico, unlike our French example, is seated between two male figures: Miguel Hidalgo, who crowns her with a laurel wreath representing victory, and Agustín Iturbide, who clutches broken chains representing the break from Spain and subjugation. Such metaphorical images of Mexico as an elaborately bedecked female would be repeated in other paintings and prints throughout the early part of the century as independence from Spain became a reality.20 Always dressed in flowing robes, these figures are also often associated with a bow and arrow and a cornucopia that overflows with fruits and vegetables, denoting the natural fecundity of the land, along with tri-colored feathered costume elements such as skirts and headpieces. An eagle, a flag, drums, and an indigenous weapon, which refer to different aspects of Mexican independence as catalysts of national identity, sometimes surround the figure as well. No longer referent to the body of the Virgin of Guadalupe, these allegorical figures indicate instead that a new phase of Mexican corporeal imagery has dawned. What is particularly distinctive about these new female bodies is the seductive, somewhat erotic, dimension to their presentation. In her research on the female body in the iconography of the era of revolution and the erotic dimension of patriotism, Joan Landes offers important insights into the significance of this early nineteenthcentury female imagery in Mexico. Landes explains that with the dissolution of the ancien régime in France, female representations of Liberty, derived from ancient Greek and Roman goddesses, appeared
19
I am not suggesting that this particular print was available in Mexico during this period. A comprehensive scholarly study of foreign prints available in Mexico during the nineteenth century is not available. Given the fact that banned French writings were circulating in late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century Mexico, however, it is likely that European or French prints like the one represented in Fig. 2.3 were available. 20 Such allegorical images were derived from colonial period imagery of the Americas; see Acevedo (2003).
62
magali m. carrera
in opposition to the older order of authority, the king’s body. “[By] physically depicting incorporeal values, female imagery helped to consolidate French citizens’ loyalties to their nation and to discriminate against those considered outside the body of the Republic.” As such, the female figure of Liberty was not opposed to male politics but set against historically tainted forms of the old body politic. Liberty anchored the nation’s legitimacy, operating as a metaphor for the sovereignty of the people.21 The female virtue inherent in these images was linked to the female role in the republican family, a passive one that emphasized modesty, propriety, and respectable silence. In this domestic association, females were to be under the care of males, fathers and husbands, and, most importantly, capable of producing republican citizens. By analogy the very role of the male republican citizen was the care, maintenance, and reproduction of the nation. The female body of the nation, therefore, became an object of desire. The “repetitive presence of a seductive (metaphorical) female in the imaginary place of the nation may lure men to attach deep romantic longings to the state.” Landes concludes that the deployment of the female body was aimed at creating “new affective solidarities and political publics to express popular energies or to anticipate and forestall political dissent.”22 Republican citizenship offers men a role as guardian of the allegorical body of the nation as it incites and conceals the seduction of patriotic love. And this is the very role we see in the Alegoría de la Independencia as the guardian figures of Mexico, Hidalgo, and Iturbide crush her enemies, free her from Spanish chains, and crown her. The seductive attraction of this metaphorical image of Mexico, the need for protection of Alegoría/Mexico, are essential qualities needed to lure citizens to love, protect, and even give up their lives for the nation. In contrast, the Virgin of Guadalupe, as a sacrosanct figure, was not able to play this role. She could not take on the human traits needed to allegorize the love of nation; that is, while she might represent the construct of patria, she could not give rise to the sexual allure required for nationalist patriotism. And as a virgin, she could not be associated with allegorical Mexico’s most impor-
21 22
Landes (2001) 18, 32, 81. Landes (2001) 22, 38, 110.
affections of the heart
63
tant role: giving birth to citizens. The Virgin of Guadalupe marked the process of independence but she did not and could not have the requisite qualities to represent nation. Thus, female corporeal imagery was a critical element of expanding nationalist imagery in the early nineteenth century. However, while the Virgin of Guadalupe marked a transitional boundary, as New Spain becomes Mexico, the allegorical figures of Mexico marked the transformation of Mexico into a nation.
Locating the National Body In the following decades, as Mexico continued to experience the social, economic, and political turmoil of nationalist construction, there was an ongoing search to come to terms with the meaning of sovereignty and nation and, as a result, the image of Mexico also changed. In 1847, Mariano Otero wrote In Mexico there has not been, nor could there have been, a national spirit, for there is no nation. . . . [because a] nation is nothing more than a great family, and in order for it to be stable and strong it means that all of its members must be closely united with ties of interest and affections of the heart.23
Otero’s words, which introduced this essay, certify the continuing focus on the seductive power of national affection. His words also express the extreme frustration of this young liberal politician and political theorist with the inability of Mexico, thirty-seven years after Hidalgo’s Grito de Dolores, to stabilize itself politically and economically. While Hidalgo was attempting to gather the power of sentiment for nation for his cause against bad government, Otero recognized that independence did not automatically result in nation and that a political regeneration of the society was required. To promote these reforms the Congress proclaimed a new Constitution on February 5, 1857. Mexico was once again organized as a federal republic under a document that specified freedom of education and the press and the guarantee of individual and judicial rights. Due to continued political struggles and the subsequent French intervention to
23
Otero (1975) [1847] 45.
64
magali m. carrera
impose the regime of Emperor Maximilian, it would be another decade before this Constitution of 1857 was implemented. In this context a new image of Mexico appeared: She is Constitución de 1857 (Fig. 2.4). Painted by Petronilo Monroy, the panel was the result of a call from the director of the National Academy of Fine Arts in 1869 for national art and especially history painting.24 The panel illustrates a young woman hovering among the clouds who holds an olive branch and a stone tablet inscribed with the words “Constitución de 1857.” This 1869 figure may be seen as a counterpoint to the tumultuous conditions of Mexican politics.25 French intervention had established Maximilian as Emperor of Mexico from 1863 until his defeat and execution in 1867. Maximilian reverted to absolutist iconography and even had the 1803 equestrian statue of Charles IV reset to be part of his Paseo del Emperador, now Mexico City’s Paseo de la Reforma, as a symbolic link to the Bourbon kings.26 The negative reaction to this second attempt at monarchy was vehement. Mexican President Benito Juárez, after leading the defeat of Maximilian’s army, replayed the French Revolution’s tableau of regicide by putting the Emperor to death. He then reinstated the Constitution of 1857 and instituted a series of political, religious, and social reforms known as La Reforma. By looking carefully at the allegorical figure of La Constitución in Monroy’s painting, however, one realizes that while she bears a resemblance to the 1834 Alegoría de México through her simple tunic, this metaphorical female construction has been undressed. Gone are the feathered clothing and the other narrative attributes. The colonial and early-independence-period iconography has been discarded. Now this new allegorical figure, holding the Constitutional tablet while wearing a simple crown, has been re-dressed in a billowing white gown with red scarf. At the time of its exhibition, some critics viewed this simplified personage as inappropriate for a history painting because it lacked imagery that referenced historical narrative.27 Nevertheless, as a symbol of Mexico’s reformist constitution, 24 “Programa de la décimocuarta exposición de la Escuela Nacional de Bellas Artes de México,” 24 December 1869; in Rodríguez Prampolini (1997) I: 148–152. 25 It should be noted that this expansion of female imagery did not correspond to expansion of women’s rights. 26 Widdifield (1996) 39. 27 An excellent analysis and complex reading of this painting and its critical context is found in Widdifield (1996) 149–158.
affections of the heart
65
Fig. 2.4 Petronilo Monroy, Constitución de 1857. Exhibited 1869, oil, approx. 170 × 90 cm., Museo Nacional de Arte, Mexico City. Reproduction authorized by the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo Nacional de la Cultura (CONACULTA.-INAH.-MEX), Mexico.
66
magali m. carrera
this icon was understood as an apparition of Mexico. One critic described the figure in rather seductive terms: her face, open to thought and love; her black eyes in which sleep the rays of passion; and her mouth trembling, with promises, caresses. He concludes, “Es México, es la patria querida, es la glorificación de la razón. . . .” (She is Mexico, the beloved motherland, the glorification of reason . . .).28 Constitución, then, does not narrate a history because she is meta-historical, a continuation of the visual configuration of a deep discourse on sovereignty and the corporeal imagery of the nation as a body that seduces and enamors citizens. Her allegorical form as the Constitution of 1857 indicates the continued appropriation of the female body to mark the shifting site of sovereignty. Along with their appearance in visual culture, the affective associations of females and nation appeared in nineteenth-century literature as well. For example, politician and writer Ignacio Altamirano’s 1869 novel Clemencia tells the story of two soldiers.29 Fernando Valle, a swarthy and physically unattractive captain in the army, is a principled and honorable man who is ready to give up his life for his country. His antithesis, an army colonel, is Enrique Flores, an attractive, light-skinned man, who is conceited, dishonorable, and a cad. Both soldiers’ amorous interests are taken up by Isabel and Clemencia, beautiful cousins. Initially, the cousins have no time for Fernando, as they focus their affections on the handsome Enrique. They come to realize, however, that Enrique has deceived them and taken advantage of them. Unfortunately, this realization comes too late because Fernando dies with valor and honor, a hero and martyr for his country. Clemencia realizes that her affections should have been reserved for Fernando because true beauty is based not on appearances but on honor, valor, dignity, and love of country. In this moralizing story, Altamirano envisions Mexico like Clemencia, needing to avoid the superficial attractiveness of certain politicians who only serve the country out of self-aggrandizing interest. She should turn her attention toward the virtuous citizen who serves out of loyalty and selflessness. The novel demonstrates once again how
28 “Crónica Charlamentaria” from El Monitor Republicano, núm. 4162, México, 17 January 1869. In Rodríguez Prampolini (1997) I: 141. 29 Altamirano (1990) [1869].
affections of the heart
67
Mexico is allegorized as a woman who must be carefully guarded and guided. With the rise of President Porfirio Díaz in the late 1870s, the metaphorical image of Mexico would change yet again. Díaz sought to establish Mexico as a nation respected among nations. He wanted to bring Mexico into modernity through programs of economic and social development. There was also a realization that a “comprehensive nationalist history was the sine qua non both for the consolidation of the nation and as a proof of stability and civilization.”30 Consequently, in 1887 the first comprehensive overview of Mexican history and culture appeared as México a través de los siglos . . . edited by Vicente Riva Palacio. This five-volume work was profusely illustrated. Most interesting for this study is the frontispiece of the volumes, which again represents a young woman as the metaphorical image of Mexico (Fig. 2.5). With a bust of Liberty above her, Mexico, holding writing utensils, is seated on a throne in front of a banner showing the Aztec founding image of the eagle alighted on a nopal cactus with a snake in its mouth. Her feet rest on a low pedestal with a band of low relief. The distinctive tropical, semi-arid and arid vegetation filling the corners of the print denote the distinct geographic areas of Mexico. Within this regional staging, Mexico is surrounded by imagery that visually presents a condensed history of Mexico. Four carved relief plaques set in the metopes, the open spaces between the triglyph dividers of a Doric frieze across the back wall, identify critical episodes of national history.31 Various objects and four standing figures further elucidate these national milestones. Designating the indigenous origins of Mexico are the antique sculpted vessels, the pedestal relief, and two statuesque Indian warriors resplendent with feathered clothing, shields, spear, bow, and arrows. The metope with the profile relief image of Moctezuma, the leader of the Aztec-Mexica at the time of sixteenth-century Spanish contact, is placed in the frieze in a position farthest to the left of the throne. Next to this portrait is that of Hernán Cortés who, along with a heavily armored conquistador to the right of Mexico, represents the epoch of the Spanish
30
Tenorio-Trillo (1996) 68. For the standard terminology of the Doric frieze, including triglyphs and metopes, see Janson (2004) 125. 31
68
magali m. carrera
Fig. 2.5 Frontispiece. Color lithograph. In Vicente Riva Palacio, ed., México a través de los siglos . . . vol. I (México: Ballescá, 1887–1889), n.p.
affections of the heart
69
Conquest and the subsequent Viceroyalty. The Mexican insurgency and independence movements of the early nineteenth century are indicated by the profile portrait of Miguel Hidalgo, which appears in the frieze to the right of the figure of Mexico. The fourth standing figure may be read as a criollo, a former Spanish subject who is now a Mexican citizen. Finally, the frieze’s profile image of Benito Juárez denotes his dismantling of the French intervention and initiation of the Reforma movement. Within this frontispiece, historical episodes that would be elucidated in the five volumes of México a través de los siglos are encapsulated visually. México a través de los siglos is a history written from the present in order to secure the future. It sought to exhibit Mexico’s rich past and impending potential for modernity. The female figure of its frontispiece is related to the 1834 Alegoría as well as the 1869 Constitución by her simple costume elements. Notably different, however, is the fact that this image of Mexico neither wears a Phrygian cap nor holds a massive stone tablet; instead, she is poised with a small writing tablet and quill pen. She is Mexico, a nation ready to write her history. She is Mexico prepared to claim parity with other nations by virtue of having a deep history, that is, a complex national narrative complete with an originating indigenous culture and nationforging events such as colonization, civil war, and wars of independence as enacted by the male intercessors. Here, Mexico is invented again: Her seductive powers are intact as the allegorical nation on the stage of national history.
Conclusion At once, in place of the particular individuality of each contracting party, this act of association produces a moral and collective body, composed of as many members as the assembly contains voices, and receiving from this act its unity, its common identity, its life and its will. . . . The Sovereign, being formed solely of the individuals who compose it, neither has nor can have any interest contrary to theirs . . .32
As he read these words from Du contrat social by Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Don José Antonio de Villanueva tried to fit them into his own
32
Rousseau (1996) 52–53.
70
magali m. carrera
understanding. He looked out of his coach window as it rumbled along the rough road to Mexico City on this chilly day in late December 1794, and his lips silently repeated the words again. Don José picked up his bookmark, a small printed image of the Virgin of Guadalupe with the words “non facit taliter omni natione,” stamped on it, marked this page and slipped the book back into its regular hiding place under the coach seat. Turning his attention to the passing scenery, gazing at the rolling landscape with serpentine rivulets of dark smoke rising on the horizon indicating small Indian villages, his heart was filled with affection for his patria. He loved his motherland—its beautiful countryside, its colorful land, its wide skies, its imposing mountains, and its people. Once more, Rousseau’s words hummed in his head: “. . . a moral and collective body . . . the Sovereign, being formed wholly of the individuals . . .,” and a glimmering of their meaning shone in his mind but, more significantly, Don José felt Rousseau’s words in his heart as he continued to gaze at his patria. “How incredible!” he thought. This fictional narrative is based on Inquisition records held in Mexico’s national archive. These proceedings indicate that in May 1795 an Inquisition prosecutor brought a case against Licenciado Don José Antonio de Villanueva, a miner from the royal mines of Taxco, for owning and reading forbidden books, including “El contrato social por Juan Jacobo Rousseau.”33 The documents focus on Don José’s ‘crime’ and, of course, do not indicate his thoughts about his readings. Nevertheless, this case, along with others similar to it found in the archive, illustrates that despite Spain’s extensive efforts to prohibit and banish them, revolutionary political writings were circulating in New Spain among educated men.34 Spanish authorities had considerable concern about the implication of the ideas in Rousseau’s work and similar writings. Indeed, these worries were well founded because the absolutist understanding of sovereignty was dismantled in Rousseau’s lines and located in a new body. These words offered ideas that disassembled the known
33 El señor inquisidor fiscal del Santo Oficio contra el Lic. D. José Antonio de Villanueva, minero del real de Tasco [sic] por leer libros prohibidos . . . AGN201768, Inquisición, 1795, vol. 1326, Exp. 3, fols. 1–11. 34 Gaceta de México (29 August 1801), n. p.; AGN-202749, Inquisición, 1795, vol. 1361, Exp. 1, fols. 1–184 and AGN-204162, Inquisición, 1803, vol. 1414, Exp. 2, fols. 280–289, 309–328.
affections of the heart
71
reality of New Spain and assembled a truly new world, that is, the often fragmented and complex nation of Mexico. While new constructs of sovereignty would collide with older understandings, they continued to exploit the affective relationships formerly associated with absolutist sovereignty and its associated corporeal imagery. Nationalist affections of the heart would be visualized through female images of Mexico throughout the nineteenth century. As independence became a reality for New Spain and throughout the nineteenth century, Mexican citizens like my fictional Don José would find love of nation a powerful and alluring emotion moving them to fanatic dedication, incredible feats of bravery, and heart-wrenching sacrifices.
Bibliography Acevedo, E. (2000) “Entre la tradición alegórica y la narrativa factual,” in Los pínceles de la historia: De la patria criolla a la nación mexicana 1750–1860, eds. E. Acevedo, J. Cuadriello, and F. Ramírez (Mexico City: 2000) 115–131. ——. (2003) “Los comienzos de una historia laica en imágenes,” in Los pinceles de la historia: La fabricación del estado 1864–1910, eds. E. Acevedo, J. Cuadriello, and F. Ramírez (Mexico City: 2003) 35–53. Altamirano, I. (1990) [1869] Clemencia (Barcelona: 1990 [1869]). Anna, T. (1998) Forging Mexico 1821–1835 (Lincoln, NE: 1998). Archivo General de la Nación (AGN) Mexico City, Legajo Inquisición, 1795–1803. Baecque, A. de (1997) The Body Politic: Corporeal Metaphor in Revolutionary France, 1770 –1800, trans. C. Mandell (Stanford: 1997). Brading, D. A. (2001) Mexican Phoenix: Our Lady of Guadalupe, Image and Tradition across Five Centuries (Cambridge, England: 2001). Cañeque, A. (1999) “The King’s Living Image: The Culture and Politics of Viceregal Power in Seventeenth-Century New Spain” (PhD. diss., New York University, 1999). “Descripción de las fiestas celebradas en la imperial corte de México con motivo de la solemne colocación de una estatua equestre [sic] de nuestro Augusto Soberano el Señor Don Carlos IV en la plaza mayor” (1796), in Documentos varios para la historia de la Ciudad de México a fines de la época colonial (1769–1815), edición facsimilar XIV, 1–16 (Mexico: 1983). “Descripción del modo con que se conduxo [sic] elevó y colocó sobre su base La Real Estatua de nuestro Augusto Soberano el Señor Don Carlos IV y de las fiestas que se hicieron con este motivo” (1803), in Documentos varios para la historia de la Ciudad de México a fines de la época colonial (1769–1815), edición facsimilar XIV, 1–12 (Mexico: 1983). Gaceta de México, compendio de noticias de Nueva España, por don Manuel Antonio Valdes (Mexico: ?–1809). Janson, H. W., and A. F. Janson (2004) History of Art: The Western Tradition (Upper Saddle River, NJ: 2004). Landes, J. (2001) Visualizing the Nation: Gender, Representation, and Revolution in EighteenthCentury France (Ithaca, NY: 2001).
72
magali m. carrera
Morelos, J. M. (2002) “Sentiments of the Nation, or Points Outlined by Morelos for the Consititution,” in The Mexico Reader: History, Culture, Politics, eds. G. M. Joseph and T. J. Henderson (Durham, NC: 2002) 189–191. Otero, M. (1975) [1847] [attributed] Consideraciones sobre la situación política y social de la república mexicana, en el año 1847 [Considerations on the Political and Social Situation of the Mexican Republic 1847.], trans. and ed. D. E. Berge. Southwestern Studies, Monograph 45 (El Paso, TX: 1975). Remensnyder, A. (2003) “Our Lady of Colonization,” lecture, John Carter Brown Library, Providence, RI, December 3, 2003. Riva Palacio, V. (1887–1889) ed., México a través de los siglos: Historia general y completa . . . de México desde la antigüedad más remota hasta la época actual, 5 vols (Mexico: 1887–1889). Rodríguez Prampolini, I., ed. (1997) La crítica de arte en México en el siglo XIX, vol. I, 2nd ed. (Mexico: 1997). Rousseau, J. J. (1996) Du Contrat Social (Paris: 1996). Tenorio-Trillo, M. (1996) Mexico at the World’s Fairs: Crafting a Modern Nation (Berkeley: 1996). Widdifield, S. G. (1996) The Embodiment of the National in Late Nineteenth-Century Mexican Painting (Tucson: 1996).
CHAPTER THREE
THE VIRGIN OF THE ANDES: INKA QUEEN AND CHRISTIAN GODDESS Carol Damian
In 1532, the Spanish Conquistador Francisco Pizarro and his army of 62 horsemen and 102 foot soldiers conquered the Inka empire called Tawantinsuyu, the “Center of the Four Quarters,” with its capital at Cuzco, Peru. The Spanish Conquest ended more than one hundred years of Inka domination over the indigenous Andean population. The Inka dynasty began, according to Inka legend, with eight brothers and sisters. After achieving the dominant position of leadership and to guarantee the purity of the ruling family, the Inka Manco Ccapac, who called himself the son of the Sun God, Inti, married his sister Mama Ocllo. Inti instructed Manco Ccapac and Mama Ocllo to teach the people of the earth to worship the Sun and the Moon (Quilla) and thus prosper. Mama Ocllo, the Coya (or queen), was the woman most venerated among the Indians. She was a goddess, the descendant of the Moon. She was the queen, the wife/sister of the Inka king. They ruled in parallel duality. The Coya wore and displayed her particular attributes and insignia, as did the Inka, and was associated with the symbols of her role (Fig. 3.1). Among these were weaving implements, feathers, birds, flowers, tipi pins, and other ornaments. When the Spaniards conquered the Inka Empire, the reverence to the Inka Coya would persist in Christian images of the Virgin Mary, the Catholic Queen (Fig. 3.2). For centuries, people throughout the world have revered the Virgin Mary. But nowhere is she more beautiful and more mysterious than in Cuzco, Peru, where she is portrayed as a distinctive image that fuses Christian and Andean concepts. Around this image, the indigenous artists of Cuzco created a school of painting, the first in the so-called New World and known as the Cuzco School, where they could portray her in multiple ways, with many titles and identifying attributes, few of which are Spanish in inspiration. By the seventeenth century, these artists earned commercial fame for their paintings and their devotion to the Virgin Mary endures to this day.
74
carol damian
Fig. 3.1 Anon., School of Cuzco, Coya or Ñusta. 18th c., oil on canvas, 75” × 47”, Museo Arqueológico, Cuzco, Peru.
the virgin of the andes
Fig. 3.2
75
Anon., School of Cuzco, Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata. 18th c., oil on canvas, 78” × 51”, Museo Pedro de Osma, Lima, Peru.
76
carol damian
Although art historians traditionally describe the paintings of Cuzco as ‘syncretic,’ a combination of Spanish and Andean concepts, the actual meaning of that term is seldom explained. In this paper, ‘syncretism’ refers to the reconciliation, or attempted reconciliation, of differing beliefs as evidenced in the syncretic images of Cuzco which intertwine Andean and Christian beliefs and painting techniques. While the Spanish artists who came to Peru to train the native people were informed by European or ‘Western’ artistic techniques based upon Renaissance figurative and naturalistic imagery, native artists were unconcerned with such formal or outward appearances. For the Andean artist, with over two thousand years of a rich artistic heritage behind him or her, the most important aspect of a created object was its essence, or spirit. He sought to create a visual expression of his beliefs and that of his community through art. The images that he portrayed did not represent particular deities in the same sense as those by the European artist who created paintings of the Virgin Mary to represent her on earth. In contrast, the object created by the native artist for veneration was the deity or one of its manifestations, and it spoke through a language of signs and symbols. By deciphering the symbols found in the syncretic image of the Virgin as she was painted in Cuzco it is possible to distinguish what was Andean from what was Christian and to explain how they worked together. Identifying the Christian symbols is easy and familiar; identifying the Andean, however, is a complex process that reaches back into the pre-Hispanic past, well before the arrival of the Inka and his Queen, the Coya. Indeed, the Andean archaeological record has provided images and objects that date before 1000 BCE and continue through the period of the Inka Empire (ca. 1400–1535 CE) that help to explain the post-contact Andean veneration of Mary as a new female deity. The role of female deities in the Andes was reaffirmed in the native myths and legends recorded by the Spanish chroniclers of the early conquest period. By incorporating the imagery and symbolism associated with these female deities and other royal personalities, the colonial image of the Virgin Mary assumed new significance as an Andean, rather than a purely European/Western, deity. Her ChristianSpanish iconography coexisted with its counterpart inspired by such deities as the Earth Mother, called Pachamama, and the Goddess of the Moon, Quilla. She was also a Queen to the native peoples— an Inka Coya. She was revered on multiple levels as fertility god-
the virgin of the andes
77
dess, lunar goddess, agricultural goddess, mother, and queen. She became the perfect embodiment of an Andean cosmology that emphasized the all-encompassing unity that exists between human beings, spirits, and the land. At the same time, the Virgin Mary of Cuzco was also created to adapt to the imposition of an alien religion with its own symbols. She became a means of insuring, in a fractured world, the survival of ancient ritual. Although her Cuzqueño image may be inimitable, it is, when seen through Andean eyes, but one more link in a long chain of ritual objects and nature worship that connects the Inka past with the viceregal period. It is important to understand that complex religious organization, such as that which developed in the Andean region, produces a complexity of symbols that impedes the rigid categorization of images into exclusive models. Furthermore, the very nature of the Cuzco School defies traditional methodology based upon a chronology of clear stages of artistic development or perfectly defined styles. Moreover, there are no set definitions of how the Virgin should look for each avocation, whether painted or sculpted. In other words, not all “Virgins of the Rosary” or “Immaculate Conceptions” look exactly alike: within each ‘category’ of images of the Virgin Mary, there are many variations and combinations. The paintings of the Virgin from the School of Cuzco are complicated combinations of a multitude of iconographic themes. However, the one consistent feature that appears as a dominant stylistic and iconographic trait is the triangular shape of the Virgin’s dress as a reference to the shape of a mountain and to her role as Pachamama, the Earth Mother.* Whether the subject relates to her role as protector of the Earth, the Moon Deity, or a royal queen, the Virgin Mary is always dressed in an elaborately decorated gown of triangular form. So pervasive is this motif among Cuzco images, it appears not only on canvases but on murals and statues as well. The Virgin in her identification with Pachamama maintains the Inka people’s great reverence for nature, which they worshipped on a daily basis. Whereas in traditional Western society the world is human-oriented and grounded in the individual, the indigenous worldview regards the universe as nature-based. No differentiation between Man and Nature is made. The worship of the Earth dominates the lives of those * On female association with the earth/mountain construct in precontact Mexico, see M. E. Bernal-García, Ch. 6 this text.
carol damian
78
who revere everything in nature as sacred. In the paintings of Cuzco, then, the artist replicates the earth-mountain in the shape of Mary’s dress, and pays tribute to nature’s abundance with birds and flowers. By considering the most popular images of the Virgin as she is portrayed as the Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata, the Pastoral Virgin, the Immaculate Conception, the Virgin Spinning, or the Virgin of the Candlestick with their many variations, this constant reference to Earth Mother becomes evident. To look at the Virgin of the Andes is to look at a complex of symbols and concepts. The shape of her dress; the dress itself with its golden ornamentation and rich array of flowers and jewels; the offerings of Andean flora and fauna that accompany her; the presence of feathers as decorative additions and a host of other attributes, including the moon, contribute to the image of the Virgin of the Andes as a distinct product of her environment, natural and spiritual. Pachamama is a comprehensive deity, identified with the Earth, worshipped on numerous levels and in numerous manifestations as the protector of the crops and giver of life for over two thousand years. Pachamama and her agricultural counterparts became identified with particular iconographic attributes related to fertility rituals and astronomical and calendrical cycles. These included ritual dressing, feathers, solar radiances, birds, and offering objects. She represents the physical world, paired with (and in certain opposition to) the Sun. Thus, everything on earth and in it is, or is sustained by, Pachamama. She does not have concrete form as a human deity. Her force is contained within the earth, a rock in the field, a stream, a mountain. The Spanish writers state repeatedly that: “They worship the Earth because they say it was their mother and they had to make her form and her offerings; and they also said she was the mother of fire, and corn and other seeds and the sheep and cattle, and the chicha [a fermented corn beverage].”1 For this reason, they “worshipped the summits of all peaks and mountain passes, and offered maize and other things” to their Mother the Earth.2 One Andean legend portrays Mother Earth’s all-encompassing nature by describing the sexual/reproductive parts of her body as Lake Titicaca, her torso as Quito, her heart in Cuzco, and her mouth in Lima.3 The entire Andean world of the Inka was con1 2 3
Molina (1968) 76. Molina (1535) 59. Randall (1987) 267.
the virgin of the andes
79
tained within Mother Earth. The mountain became a metaphor for life and existence in the Andean world. The extraordinary reverence for the Earth was manifested in shrines throughout the Andean territory. From the simple paga a la tierra (pay the earth), which offers something (usually chicha) to the earth before every agricultural and significant activity, to the placement of stones and other ritual objects on roadside locations and grand pilgrimage shrines, often in inaccessible and isolated locations, worship of the Earth was the most persistent of Andean rituals. It was also the most difficult to identify, eradicate, or replace. Within a 20-mile radius of the city of Cuzco alone, the archaeologist John Howland Rowe counted 350 earth shrines mentioned in the Spanish chronicle descriptions, most of them along the ceques, the ritual lines of demarcation and procession.4 This Andean tradition of Earth worship manifests in a number of ways in the Christian art of the Andes. The images of the Virgin Mary in a wide bell-shaped dress replicate Pachamama as Earth Mother, in the form of a mountain or as the ‘body-mountain’ itself, and as she symbolizes Nature in the fertility of the pastoral landscape. The image of the Virgin as the mountain is most evident in those works that actually describe her as or in the mountain. One of the best-known paintings and a striking example to illustrate the Virgin as the Mountain and worshiped within the context of a royal Inka and Christian presence comes from Alto Peru. In La Virgen María con el Cerro de Potosí (The Virgin Mary with the Mountain of Potosiama) (Fig. 3.3), the face and hands of the Virgin are actually within the conical shape of the mountain of Potosí. In the celestial level above, God the Father, Jesus Christ, and the Holy Ghost hold a crown over the mountain peak (the Virgin’s head). Within her mountain/gown are described roads and trees and animals, with native people going about their daily activities. They are totally integrated within the landscape beneath the protection of the Mountain. The landscape is transformed into a ritual of man and nature whose compatibility is dependent upon the beneficence of Mother Earth. The Virgin Mary is intimately identified with the Andean countryside in similar paintings of numerous titles in which she dons the mountain-shaped dress strewn with flora and fauna distinctly Andean, not Spanish. 4 Rowe (1946) 183–130, and (1979) 1–80; and Zuidema (1964). Chroniclers Bernabé Cobo and Cristóbal de Molina also describe the ceque system.
80
carol damian
Fig. 3.3 Anon., Alto Peru, La Virgen María con el cerro de Potosí (The Virgin Mary with the Mountain of Potasiama). 18th c., oil on canvas, 53” × 41 ½”, Casa Nacional de Moneda, Potosí, Bolivia.
the virgin of the andes
81
This concept of ‘oneness’ with the land is symbolized in images of La Divina Peregrina (The Virgin of the Pilgrims) from Cuzco. In them, the Virgin wears a shepherd’s hat and a gown profusely decorated with flowers. For the Spaniards, the broad-brimmed shepherd’s hat identifies the Virgin as La Divina Peregrina. Sacred pilgrimage is also an essential aspect of Andean religion. The people make pilgrimages to sacrosanct locations, mountains, rocks, and caves to pay tribute to the nature spirits who dwell there and they leave offerings while pledging their servitude to the spirit of the land. The image of the Virgin of the Pilgrims combines all of these elements: agricultural protector, pilgrim, and humble servant. She wears a dress that is a tapestry of floral brocade patterns and golden details and borders. In becoming a carpet of flowers and jewels, she symbolizes the beneficence of Mother Nature. In the Andean tradition, flowers were associated with the cult to Pachamama. For the Inka, flowers were harbingers of the harvest; even men placed flowers in their hats or behind their ears during harvest celebrations. The Coya had her own specific flowers, which were offered to her on agricultural feast days. The reverence for Mother Earth is complemented by the worship of the Moon as a female deity associated with the cycles of nature and of women. Just as the Spanish incorporated the moon into images of the Virgin Mary of the Immaculate Conception who trounces the forces of evil, the Andean artist also used the moon as a symbol of ancient veneration. In numerous paintings from Cuzco, the moon has special meaning beyond that of Christian symbolism for an audience that had long worshipped the Moon Goddess. The Spanish chronicles describe the Temple of the Sun in Cuzco with its gold figure of the Sun God Inti and silver figures of the Moon. They also describe how the figure of the Moon was carried in procession during the month of November and revered as Queen, Mama Quilla. The Andean artist, far from the strict guidelines imposed by the Church in Rome, incorporated the moon in numerous images of the Virgin Mary, confusing and conflating its meaning as prescribed in European images associated with the Immaculate Conception and Assumption of the Virgin. As a result, the symbolism of the Andes enhances that of Christianity, and vice versa. The paintings of the Virgin that describe her association with the moon were popular subjects for Cuzco artists. For the Andean believer, the Virgin of the Immaculate Conception, so important an image
82
carol damian
of reverence for the Spanish, was the perfect foil for their devotion to the deity of the Moon who was also the Queen of the Inka, the Coya, and the Consort of the Sun Inti. Unchanging and precise, yet in constant flux, the moon vividly symbolized the idea of eternity for the Andean peoples. They realized that the moon also moved the tides to ebb and flow, and the deity of the Moon became the eternal mistress of the waters, the protective deity of life, and especially the patron of women in childbirth. The generalized devotion to the moon of pre-Inka societies was elevated to royal status by the Inkas who identified the lunar deity with Mama Ocllo, the wife/sister of the first Inka, Manco Ccapac, and with their reverence for her as Mama Quilla, the Moon and the Consort of Inti. The wak’a (sacred object) of the Moon was brought out from the Temple of the Sun during the month of November for the Feast of the Lord Inka.5 The veneration of the Moon as Queen coincides with the regal image of the Virgin of the Immaculate Conception and of Mary as the Queen of Heaven. Triumphantly soaring above her earthly subjects on the crescent moon, Mary was easily appropriated by the Indian artisan into an amalgamated image representing an Andean/Christian lunar goddess. The image of the Immaculate Conception as painted by indigenous artists demonstrates the manner in which Andean artists, who were taught to copy from Spanish models that were plentiful in postcontact Cuzco, incorporated their own distinctive artistry and Andean details and iconography into the subject. Although the Cuzqueño interpretation of the Immaculate Conception defines this image, indigenous artists borrowed liberally from other European avocations of the Virgin, including Mary as Queen of Heaven and the Virgin in Glory. Specific elements from each of these European sources were re-arranged and re-interpreted by the native artist to create distinctive Andean constructions of the Virgin-on-the-moon motif. These idiosyncratic images produced by artists of the School of Cuzco, especially, were given a variety of titles, including the Virgin of the Candlestick, the Virgin of the Rosary, and the Virgin of Bethlehem.
5 Molina (1535) 36. Passa-Mama means moon in Collao dialect; in Kechwa it is Quilla.
the virgin of the andes
83
In addition to the painted image of the Virgin of the Immaculate Conception, she was also represented as a dressed statue (imágen de vestir) on the crescent moon, a particularly popular form in colonial Cuzco. These statues were carried in processions and dressed for special occasions in elaborate garments. Although some of these sculpted images were European in origin, many more were produced by native artists who used European images as models. These Andean statues, like paintings of the Virgin, also incorporated Andean symbolism and meaning. Andean peoples had long used textiles and other objects as sacred additions to adorn idols, and the clothing of the Virgin Mary may indeed have become a substitute for the traditional ritual accorded the wak’as of their ancestors. In addition, symbolism associated with the placement of gold and jeweled attributes, scepters, headdresses, and other offerings on the anda, or “processional litter,” of the Virgin of the Immaculate Conception, for example, recreates the symbolic offerings of the pre-contact past. In this manner, the images of the Virgin Mary painted or sculpted by Cuzco’s colonial artists replicate the dressed and adorned statues and mummies of their ancestors. Splendidly arrayed in the finest brocades and tapestry cloths, she represents not only the Queen of Heaven, but also the native Queen of the Andean peoples. The documents of the visitas during the campaigns against idolatry of the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries describe Indians weaving a mantle for the Virgin and simultaneously one for the wak’a.6 The idolatry documents also relate that on numerous occasions wak’as were hidden beneath the litters or within the dresses of the statues. Father Pablo Joseph Arriaga recounted the Corpus Christi Procession in 1620, during which the native peoples celebrate Oncoymita, a Festival to the Sun: They have “slyly hidden a wak’a on the very platform of the monstrance of the Holy Sacrament . . . and wak’as in the hollow niches of the saints in front of the holy altar, and others below the altar.”7
6
Arriaga (1620) 68. Ibid., 70. Dr. Ávila discovered that in Huarochirí, the Feast of the Assumption was used to disguise the festival to the idols of the woman called Chupixamor and Mamayoc. This provoked him to undertake massive campaigns to search out and destroy the wak’as; see Salomon and Urioste (1991) 26. For other such surreptitious events, see also Polo de Ondegardo (c. 1559–1571). 7
84
carol damian
During the idolatry campaigns, the use of fine Inka cloth on the statues of the Virgin and saints was the subject of investigation. Father Arriaga wrote: I know a place where a cloak was made for the image of Our Lady and a shirt for their wak’a from the same cloth. They feel and even say that they can worship their wak’as while believing in God the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Thus, for the worship of Jesus Christ they generally offer what they offer their wak’as.8
The symbolism of cloth is further enhanced by its golden threads and golden details identified as Inka insignia that take on new meaning in the painting of Our Lady of the Victory of Málaga, ca. 1737, by the indigenous artist Luis Nino of Alto Perú (Fig. 3.4). She commemorates a Spanish event but is depicted in the characteristic lavish style of the Cuzco School. The Virgin stands beneath an elaborate European baroque arch decorated in sculptural relief profusely ornamented in patterns of gold. Her crown and radiant halo display the native artist’s metallurgical skills. She also wears the flat triangular gown of gold and tapestry brocade tooled in gold stencil, a technique called estofado, so elaborate that the Christ Child is lost in its patterns. The interesting semi-circular design on the bottom of her dress contains references to the moon. Its abstract form appears to have been inspired by the form of the tumi, the ceremonial knife of the Inka and pre-Inka peoples. Many of these knives have been found in tombs, most notably in those of the Chimor Civilization (which was conquered by the Inka), and relate to regal warrior status. In a colonial portrait painted by an anonymous artist of an Inka warrior princess, La Ñusta Chanan Cori Coca, the lunar-shaped knife is used as a tupu pin to fasten her cape. It is exactly like the pins that fastened the dressings of the Nasca women depicted on pottery over one thousand years before. In the Inka portrait, the princess stands beside an Inka warrior and triumphantly displays the head of her victim. The Ñusta Chanan Cori Coca is the descendant of the Inka warrior Coya, the ‘vicious’ Mama Huaco. The knife is a warrior-specific object of victory and conquest.9 As a decorative device 8
Arriaga (1620) 72. Sarmiento de Gamboa (1572) Ch XI: 45. The warrior princess of Inka legend was one of the four legendary sisters/founders of the Inka dynasty, Mama Huaco (“who was fierce and cruel”). The description of this vicious female comes from Spanish accounts to discredit the Inkas (and there are discrepancies between the 9
the virgin of the andes
85
Fig. 3.4 Luis Nino, Alto Peru, Our Lady of the Victory of Málaga. Ca. 1735, oil on canvas, 59 ½” × 43 ¾”, Denver Art Museum, Denver, Colorado.
86
carol damian
within the patterns of the dress of the Virgin of Málaga, the tumi relates to the moon and to Mary as the victorious Queen of Heaven and Queen of the Andes. When the form of the tumi is turned upside down, it resembles a flower bud, specifically the bud of the ñukchu lily, the sacred flower of the Inka. The compressed flat patterning of the entire arrangement of figural and decorative devices reveals other solar forms, including the radiant aureola behind her crown and the semi-circular crescent form above her shoulders. Within the masterful application of gold leaf and estofado patterns, the artist repeats the circular and semi-circular forms of the moon to produce a composition of great elegance and complexity. The image of the Virgin Mary in association with Pachamama and the Moon is clearly revealed through signs and symbols incorporated within the Christian iconography. With the symbolism accorded the Royal Consort of the Inka, the Coya, the Virgin Mary acquires another level of meaning. This symbolism relates particularly to respect for the Coya and her responsibilities to women, as well as to pre-Inka and Inka traditions associated with cloth and clothing. “The Coya, or Queen, took care to teach the women to spin and weave wool and cotton, as well as other tasks and occupations of their profession.”10 Descendants of the sister co-founders of the Inka dynasty, the women of royal Inka blood commanded the same respect as did the men: both were progenitors of the Inka race and responsible for the founding of the first ten ayllus (kinship groups) of Cuzco. As such they owned land and their mummies were retained as wak’as and venerated with great ceremony. In the Temple of the Sun, on either side of the figure of the Moon were the bodies of the dead queens, arranged in order of antiquity. Mama Ocllo, the mother of Huaina Ccapac, was placed in front of the Moon and face to face with her, being thus distinguished from the rest as the mother of such a son.11
identification of the sisters and their roles); however, women did play a role in Inka conquest according to Inka legend. See Dransart (1987) 62. 10 Cobo, History of the Inca Empire (1653) Book II, Ch 4:108. 11 Vega (1609) Part I, Book III, Ch XXI:182.
the virgin of the andes
87
The Inka queen and princesses (Ñustas) played their most important roles in the agricultural festivities and in the production of the sacred cloths worn by the Inka and given as offerings to the idols. They were also identified by regal insignia and dress and given titles.12 The Inka Coya wore a very specific costume, not unlike that of the Virgin Mary (Fig. 3.1). She was revered as the descendant of the Goddess of the Moon and the Consort of the Sun God Deity. The similarities accorded the ritual dressing of both the Virgin and the Coya, as well as the specific items of clothing repeatedly associated with their portrayal, are quite remarkable. The Coya wore a long dress called an anacu that was tied many times with a wide sash called chumpi. Over this dress she wore a cloak called an iliclla that was put over her shoulders. Bringing the corners together over her chest, she fastened it with a pin, tipi. The pins that were used to fasten the clothes of Inka women were very specific to each Coya in shape and size. The head was made of a small metal plate in a variety of shapes relating to a basically semi-circular form, its edges so thin and sharp that many things were cut with them. Some of these tipis had many little gold and silver bells hanging from them. The Coyas adorned their hair by wearing it long and loose or braided or bound with a band called a vincha. For their headdress they wore a piece of rich cumbi (very fine) cloth called pampacona, folded several times to a width of about 5 1/2 inches. One edge dropped down over the forehead and the rest hung over the hair down the back of the head. Across the chest, from one shoulder to another, they wore strings of certain beads, called chaquira, made of bone and seashells of various colors.13 As recorded in post-conquest portraits of the Inka Coyas and Ñustas painted in the sixteenth through eighteenth centuries and in the
12 13
Ibid., Book One, Ch XXVI:63. Cobo (1990) Book II, Ch 2:188.
88
carol damian
drawings of Guaman Poma de Ayala,14 the costume of the Inka queens appears to be quite consistent and to have survived with little change for many years. There is little reason to doubt that the costumes in the post-conquest portrayals were very different from those of the reigning Inkas of the pre-conquest and conquest periods. Their survival with little change throughout the colonial period in portraiture attests to the significance of noble Inka dress as a distinct trait of status worn with great pride for generations. Furthermore, the Inka objects on which Inka dress is depicted—the dressed statues, pottery vessels, and keros—affirm that Inka women wore dresses with capes and tipis (or tipkis, pins that actually fastened the garment and were worn horizontally) and tupus (pins that hung vertically from the capes). To view the image of the Virgin Mary as part of the structure of ideological sign systems of Inka and pre-Inka ritual objects imparts new meaning to its form and function. The Inka appropriated specific Andean symbols and developed their own vocabulary of ritual iconography. The language of Andean ritual was well established by the time of the arrival of the Spaniards. The native artist maintained its efficacy by incorporating it into Christian imagery. Images of the Virgin Mary Spinning relate to the role of the Coya as the teacher of women and to Mary as a humble domestic maiden called by God. In these paintings, Mary is dressed in a combination of noble Spanish and Inka costumes. The golden patterns of the cloth incorporate both the floral brocades of European origin and the geometric patterns of the Inka. The frame of flowers is an allusion to the rites of fertility and abundance presided over by the Coya. The young Virgin wears a headband (llautu) of golden thread around her head with a curious curl on her forehead. European images of the Virgin Mary consistently describe her hair parted in the middle. This unusual rendering of a curl in the Andean version, however, suggests the bang of hair that descends below the King’s and Queen’s royal headband. To the Spanish observer, the curl is a delightful addition of the native artist. To the native viewer, the headband and curl are royal insignia. The Child Mary is the equivalent of the Inka princess (Ñusta) and the Chosen Women (elite women in the service of the Inka). Also, for the Andean observer,
14
Guaman Poma de Ayala (1614).
the virgin of the andes
89
the golden radiances behind her head are symbolic of Inka royalty’s homage to the sun. The Child Virgin holds the spindle aloft and twirls out the thread, as Indian women do throughout the day, throughout their lives, to this day. Undoubtedly copied from Spanish models of the Virgin learning to sew, the Virgin Spinning exemplifies the significance of the weavers of the Andes, especially the Chosen Women, and the strength of their traditions. In the Andes, weaving was a ritual act for devotional purposes developed over centuries. Cloth was also a “chief article of tribute given for the service of the Inka and of religion” and “large quantities were made up for sacrifices, for in all the festivals much cloth was offered up.”15 The Spanish chroniclers marveled at the ability of the people to weave. Bernabé Cobo wrote: In ancient times, they made five different kinds of textiles. One, called abasca, was coarse and ordinary; another, called cumbi was fine and valuable; the third was made with colored feathers . . .; the fourth was like cloth of silver and gold embroidered in chaquira; and the fifth was a very coarse and thick cloth used for various rugs and blankets.16
Special attention to the clothing of the Inka and to ceremonial and offering cloth was given by the Chosen Women responsible for its production. These garments were for the Inka himself and would be worn only once, then burned. The Spanish describe storehouses and tombs full of cloth, and ancestor mummies wrapped in cloth and accompanied by folded textiles brought out to the public square on special feast days. They took special note of the elaborate costumes for every ceremony and festival. To the Andean believer, the image of the Virgin Spinning was more than that of a humble schoolgirl learning a domestic chore. Her responsibility to maintain the tradition of Andean weaving, in the service of the gods and the Inka himself, was tantamount. Images of the Virgin and Child are particularly endearing to the people of Cuzco and the Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata is among the most characteristic and beautiful (Fig. 3.2). Sentimental and maternal, her representation as a queenly figure adorned with flowers and jewels elevates the position of the Virgin to that of a queen and the Child becomes a miniature king. She holds lilies (Christian symbols of purity and the flower of the Virgin) and the rosary. Both the 15 16
Polo de Ondegardo (1571) 167. Cobo (1990) Book II, Ch 11:225.
90
carol damian
Virgin and Child wear elaborate brocade dresses with garlands of pearls secured by jeweled flower broaches. The swags of pearls are characteristic of the Virgin of Pomata. Pearls were Spanish symbols of perfection, admired as jewels of great beauty and luxury. They were also prized ornaments for Andean idols dressed by pre-Hispanic coastal peoples that were buried in elite tombs as accompaniments to the mummies. The Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata combines a number of interesting iconographic attributes: jewels, mountain-shaped gown, and, distinctively, feathers. The use of feathers in images of the Virgin Mary was particularly associated with Cuzco. They are especially linked with the Virgin of Pomata and can be found in her crown and in that of the Child Jesus. Although feathers may have adorned helmets worn by the Conquistadors, and in some Spanish images of the Virgin of the Pilgrims she dons a wide-brimmed felt hat with a feather (in the style of European pilgrimage hats), feathered crowns are not found in the royal iconography associated with the Virgin as Queen of Heaven in European representations. It is significant to note, however, that feathers, long associated with ritual in the Andes, signify royalty in Inka iconography. Feathers were used on female idols as early as the period of the Nasca civilization (circa 200 BCE–600 CE) as symbolic attributes of the fertility figures. Elaborate feather garments and headdresses clothed the mummies of Chimu royalty who continued to occupy the north coast of Peru upon the arrival of the Spanish. Their original symbolism appears to relate to birds and winged mythical creatures. The association of birds with communicators to the spirit world is a wellestablished trope in the Andean world. Birds were present as guardian figures at Chavín de Huántar (circa 400–200 BCE) where they are incised in the architectural ornamentation of the portico of the principal pyramid. Birds are important iconographic elements in the many culture areas of the Andes. They can be found on pottery, textiles, and stone and wood objects. Winged figures were guardians of the deity called the “Gateway God” (Viracocha?) in the culture of the Peruvian-Bolivian altiplano city of Tiwanaku (ca. 1100 CE). The Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata relates to the spirits and birds of the mountains. Added to the mountainous shape of her dress, the feathers also place her in a royal Inka context, affirming the Inka appropriation of Earth Mother for their own aggrandizement. The Virgin bears the attributes of Inka royalty, in particular of Mama
the virgin of the andes
91
Ocllo who taught the women how to plant and harvest the agricultural fields. Feathers, spondylus shells, and tupu and tipi pins were distinct attributes of Inka royalty and were not worn by ordinary people. Feathers had significance for the female members of the Inka nobility, especially. Furthermore, over the years and with the destruction of the Inka state religion, feathers survived in association with women. Feathers assumed the position of both agricultural and royal symbols, as appropriate for the Queen of Heaven, the new Coya, as they once had been for the Inka royalty. The Virgin of the Rosary of Pomata pays tribute to the royal lineage of Pachamama and the Inka at the same time. In this image, the combination of pearls and feathers is a synthesis of regal imagery. Vestiges of the belief system of popular and state ritual assume new authority within this specifically Andean/Christian interpretation of the Virgin. The Virgin of the Candlestick with Tunic of Feathers, one of the most extraordinary subjects of the School of Cuzco, incorporates a variety of Andean symbols within its Christian imagery, including the moon, solar rays, gold ornamented fabric, and qantu and ñukchu lilies among the flowers (Fig. 3.5). The Virgin and Child are atop a pedestal, a statue painting framed by a border of flowers and drawn curtains. The crescent moon is described in the hem of her gown. She holds a lit candle to symbolize Christ as the light of the world and as a reference to Candlemas celebrations. She wears a crown with radiances that form a halo above. The Christ child also wears a crown and is held to her breast and wrapped tightly in white lace in the manner of Andean babies. Garcilaso de la Vega found such tight bundles peculiar: They brought up their children in a strange way, both Inca and common folk, rich and poor, without distinction, with the least possible pampering. As soon as the infant was born . . . it was swaddled in shawls . . . Their arms were kept inside the swaddling clothes for more than three months, because it was thought that if they were loosened earlier, they would grow weak in the arm.17
In this painting, the Child Jesus is swaddled in white cloth; only his little hand protrudes in a gesture of peace. The Virgin is clothed in a red brocade dress and cape elaborately ornamented with gold patterns. The gown has lace sleevelets and she wears a lace veil, decoration 17
Vega (1609) Book IV, Ch XII:212.
92
carol damian
Fig. 3.5 Anon., School of Cuzco, Virgin of the Candlestick of Tenerife with Tunic of Feathers. Ca. 1680–1700, oil on canvas, 61” × 45”, Museo Pedro de Osma, Lima, Peru.
the virgin of the andes
93
inspired by Spanish noble dress. Over her gown, however, she wears a tunic of red, blue, and white feathers edged in lace. The addition of feathers to the gown of the Virgin Mary is a specifically Andean feature with regal and ritual connotations dating back two thousand years. Feathers were signs of religious authority. Father Blas Valera describes, with an accompanying drawing, the Huampar chucu, a crown of sheets of gold encrusted with semi-precious stones worn by the supreme sun priest, Vilahoma. A solar disk was inscribed on the front. A diadem of feathers from “large parrots called guacamayas was across the top, with the three feathers of the Inka insignia at the center.”18 The presence of feather crowns and feather garments in the tombs of warrior-priests and other important religious and administrative leaders affirms their significance for numerous culture areas in the Andes. Feathers adorned the imagery of anthropomorphic and fantastic deity figures from as far back as Chavín de Huántar. Feather cloths were first produced in ancient Peru by the south coast Paracas people (circa 500 BCE) and subsequently by the Nasca, Tiwanaku, Wari, Chimu, Chancay, and Inka peoples, as well as in northern Chile and northwest Argentina. Amazingly preserved in the dry desert tombs of the Andean people, feather tunics, breast cloths, loincloths, purses, masks, and fans adorned the mummy bundles and were placed as offerings in the elaborately prepared tombs of the noble elite or priestly class. There is little doubt that these cloths were used in life as well as in death, but always reserved for a specific class of people. Feathers come from a variety of coastal, highland, and jungle birds native to the Andean culture area. The feathers were collected and stitched to the natural or dyed cotton backing with horizontal threads called hileras. Feathers were also glued to masks that covered the faces of mummy bundles. There are a few examples of feather textiles decorated with gold and silver ornaments.19 The colors of feather tunics run the full color range of native birds, from reds and blues to brilliant yellows and greens. Their designs
18
Blas Valera (c. 1590) 363. Guacamayas are also described in the origin myths by Molina (1535) 8. 19 Reid (1990) 2.
94
carol damian
are primarily simple geometric color patterns (stripes and checkerboards, especially). However, some exhibit the simplified forms of birds, monkeys, deities, and snakes. The designs of feather cloths were associated with mythology and diverse ancestral personalities and their legends. The majority of these stories tell of birds and flying creatures or humans turned into birds. For the Inka peoples, feather textiles were first and foremost ceremonial decorations and tribute offerings given to the royal family and their ancestors or to the Temple of the Sun. Great quantities of feather cloths were made for the Inka nobility and collected in royal storehouses for use on special festival days, in initiation ceremonies or in death rituals. When the Spanish arrived, they discovered these storehouses filled with abundant supplies of both feathers and feather cloths: Almost all of the feathers were iridescent, with an admirable sheen which looked like very fine gold. Another kind was an iridescent golden green. And there was an immense amount of those tiny feathers which are found on the chest of the little birds that we call tominejo (hummingbird).20
The cloths were made by the Chosen Women and specific techniques and feathers determined their use and symbolic value. Certain festivals demanded special colors or patterns, similar to the patterning of Inka garments. Although the secrets of this symbolic vocabulary are now lost, the feather cloths and ornaments were always highly prized for their aesthetic beauty, while the documentation of their value and use by the Spaniards affirms their significance. The description of Don Juan de Santa Cruz Pachacuti-yamqui of a grand feast for the birth of Yahuar-huaccac Inka Yupanqui, the son of Inka Ruca, is illustrative of the Inka use of feathers: “The square and all the streets were filled with arches of feathers, and the house of Coricancha was entirely covered with rich plumes, both within and without.”21 Feathers were also used on the parasols that were held above the litters of the Inka and his Queen. Ceremonial cloth constructed with
20
Cobo (1990) Book II, Ch 11:226. Pachacuti-yamqui Salcamayhua (c. 1620) 89. See also Pizarro (1571) 242. Molina (1535) 19, describes feathers strewn before the path of the Inka; and the placement of feathers on the wak’as and image of the sun, 25. 21
the virgin of the andes
95
feathers is symbolic of Inka royalty and significant for the maintenance of Andean traditions. According to Cobo: Feather cloths were the most esteemed and valued, and this was quite reasonable because the ones that I have seen would be highly regarded anywhere. They were made on the cumbi, but in such a way that the feathers stand out on the wool and cover it like velvet. The material that they had for this kind of cloth was extensive because incredible numbers and varieties of birds are found in this land with such excellent colors that it is beyond belief.22
The Andean believer attempting to reconcile Christian ideology with ancient concepts identified with the birds of Catholic doctrine. Wings were the symbols of divine mission for the Catholic Church. The Holy Ghost as the white dove was the communicator for the Christian god. Angels, archangels, seraphim, and cherubim, with their feathered wings, were the guardians of the Christian world and residents of heaven.23 The Catholic priests taught that Lucifer was the prince of the fallen angels in revolt against God, defeated by the Archangel Michael, and tumbled from his place in heaven. Angels with feathered wings were not difficult for the Andean people to understand. Winged creatures were part of their heritage:24 the bird of the Coya was easily transferable to the symbolism of the Virgin Mary. The feather tunic covering the beautifully embroidered garment worn by The Virgin of the Candlestick with Tunic of Feathers exactly repeats the pattern found on feather tunics interred with mummies on the desert coast of Peru. Feathered garments (notably not worn by the Virgin in European representations) were the valuable property of Andean nobility and of their mummified ancestors. By dressing the Virgin in a feather tunic, she becomes the special vehicle for the Andean artist to pay homage to ancient customs of ritual and royalty. In the numerous representations of the Virgin in the Andes, indigenous artists created a locus from which to battle the trauma of conquest and the subsequent loss of identity. In these images they inflected
22
Cobo (1990) Book II, Ch II:226. There is no doubt that another interesting subject of the Cuzco School, the paintings of the Archangels with their elaborate Spanish costumes, weapons, and wings, was inspired by the Andean fascination with birds and their ease of identity with feathered creatures. 24 Las Plumas del Sol y los Ángeles de la Conquista (1993). 23
96
carol damian
pre-contact symbols and meaning—the sacred landscape, implements of war, ritual textiles, feathers—in the body of the most revered woman in Euro-Christian belief. At the same time, they preserved ancient female deities, especially Pachamama and the Moon Goddess, and recorded, to a degree, the position of royal women in pre-contact Inka society by imbuing some of the Virgin’s traditional attributes with new (that is, ancient) symbolism and by adding indigenous ritual objects and motifs to her litany of traditional ones. The Virgin of the Andes was both Inka Queen and Christian Goddess.
Bibliography Arriaga, P. J. de (1620) The Extirpation of Idolatry in Peru, trans. L. C. Keating (Lexington: 1968). Blas Valera, Fr. (c. 1590) “Relacion de las costumbres antiguas de los naturales del Piru,” Revista del Archivo Histórico del Cuzco 4 (1953) 363. Damian, C. (1994) The Virgin of the Andes: Art and Ritual in Colonial Cuzco (Miami Beach: 1994). Cobo, Fr. B. (1653) History of the Inca Empire, ed. and trans. R. Hamilton (Austin: 1978). —— (1653) Inca Religion and Customs, ed. and trans. R. Hamilton (Austin: 1990 [1653]). Dansart, P. (1987) “Women and Ritual Conflict in Inka Society,” in Images of Women in Peace and War, eds. S. Macdonald, P. Holden, and S. Ardener (London: 1987). Gisbert, T. (1980) Iconografía y mitos indígenas en el arte (La Paz: 1980). Guaman Poma de Ayala, F. (1614) Nueva corónica y buen goberno, facsimile (Paris: 1936). Las plumas del sol y los ángeles de la Conquista (1993), ex. cat. (Lima: 1993). Mesa, J. de, and T. Gisbert (1982) Historia de la pintura cuzqueña, vols. 1 and 2 (Lima: 1982). Molina, C. de (1968) “Cosas acaescidas en el Perú,” in Biblioteca de Autores Españoles, ed. F. Esteve Barba (Madrid: 1968) 76. —— (1535) “An Account of the Fables and Rites of the Incas,” in Narratives of the Rites and Laws of the Yncas, ed. and trans. C. R. Markham (London: 1873) 59. Pachacuti-yamqui Salcamayhua, Don J. de Santa Cruz (ca. 1620) “An Account of the Antiquities of Peru,” in Narratives of the Rites and Laws of the Yncas, ed. and trans. C. R. Markham (London: 1873) 89. Pizarro, P. (1571) Relación del descubrimiento y conquista de los Reinos del Perú (Lima: 1986). Polo de Ondegardo, Lic. J. (ca. 1559–71) “Informaciones acerca de la religión y gobierno de los Incas” part 2, in Colleción de libros y documentos referentes a la historia del Perú, tomo IV (2a serie), ed. H. H. Urteaga (Lima: 1917) 151–158. —— (1571) “Report by Polo de Ondegardo,” in Narratives of the Rites and Laws of the Yncas, ed. and trans. C. R. Markham (London: 1873) 167. Randall, R. (1987) “La lengua sagrada,” Alppanchis XIX: 29–30 (1987) 267. Reid, J. (1990) Feather Masterpieces of the Ancient Andean World (London: 1990). Rowe, J. H. (1946) “An Account of the Inca Shrines of Cuzco,” Ñawpa Pacha 17:1–80.
the virgin of the andes
97
—— (1946) “Inca Culture at the Time of the Spanish Conquest,” in Handbook of South American Indians, vol. 2., ed. J. H. Steward (Washington, D.C.: 1946) 183. Salomon, F., and G. L. Urioste (1991) trans., The Huarochirí Manuscript (Austin: 1991). Sallnow, M. J. (1987) Pilgrims of the Andes (Washington, D.C.: 1987). Sarmiento de Gamboa, P. (1572) History of the Incas, ed. and trans. C. R. Markham (London: 1907). Vega, El Inca, G. de la (1609) The Royal Commentaries of the Inca, part I, trans. H. V. Livermore (Austin: 1987). Zuidema, T. R. (1964) The Ceque System of Cuzco: The Social Organization of the Capital of the Inca (Leiden: 1964).
CHAPTER FOUR
WOMEN AND MEN AS COSMIC CO-BEARERS AT OAXTEPEC, MEXICO, ABOUT 1553 Richard E. Phillips
Introduction During the course of the sixteenth century, over two hundred monasteries were built in the central and southern Mexican countryside. Many of them still stand and function as parish churches, museums, or monastic establishments. They were constructed for the male Franciscan, Dominican, and Augustinian friars by their post-conquest native charges. Many of these monasteries featured large churches that accommodated hundreds of parishioners. Many also had capacious cloisters, complete with such dependencies as refectories and chapter rooms. The cloisters were almost always square and consisted of four roofed, often vaulted ranges supported by piers or columns called ‘cloister walks’ that opened onto a central unroofed garth. Most of these monasteries, including the cloisters, had at least some mural painting, and much of this painting survives on site. Where sixteenth-century paintings on cloister piers persist in central Mexico, they always represent groups of saints, one saint per pier surface opposite the viewer in the adjacent cloister walk.1 No surviving Mexican sixteenth-century pier cycle attaches nearly as much importance to female saints as that of the cloister of the Dominican monastery of the town of Oaxtepec in the modern State of Morelos (Fig. 4.1). This sequence of saints on piers was painted about 1553, some thirty-two years after the Spanish conquest.2 Given
1 Kubler (1948) 231–359, 363–72, 378, 450–94, 503–35; McAndrew (1969) 121–67; Angulo Iñíguez et al. (1945–56) 1, passim; Edgerton (2001) 5–6, 35–38, 40–60, 129–53; Sartor (1992) 95–191, 206–29; Edwards (1966) 66–112; and Phillips (1993) 16–27, 210–18, 361–77, 466–72, 478–79. 2 Kubler (1948) 348–49; Mullen (1975) 76–77; Dávila Padilla (1625) 617–18; and Santiago (1540–87) fols 35v, 40, 45v, 46. I am grateful to the then Directors of
100
richard e. phillips
Fig. 4.1 Schematic iconographical diagram, first floor of the cloister, Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, State of Morelos, Mexico, ca. 1553. Drawing courtesy of Prof. James Dutremaine.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers
101
the profound misogyny at the heart of the Dominican intellectual tradition discussed below, what caused the friars residing at Oaxtepec to permit icons of female saints next to those of male saints on the four corner piers? These images indicate that both men and women are fundamental as the symbolic cornerstones of the Catholic Church and by extension the cosmic order.3 The Dominicans would not have allowed such an allegory simply out of their own good will without substantial pressure for this affirmation of women on the part of Oaxtepec’s populace. The intent of this paper on one level is to demonstrate that the evangelization and acculturation of Mexico, and therefore the creation of what is now modern Mexican civilization, cannot be envisioned simply as the triumph of a superior Spanish and European civilization over inferior and defenseless indigenous conglomerations that led to the supposed obliteration of the native peoples’ preColumbian traditions. The Spanish, including the friars, wielded enormous but not complete power. In the first decades after the conquest of Mexico the Spanish were a tiny minority in the midst of a sea of autochthonous peoples. They had to make some concessions to gain the natives’ sometimes enthusiastic, sometimes grudging compliance. Once the intrinsic but limited puissance of the native masses in viceregal Mexico is realized and the defective model of monolithic European imposition is discarded, it is then possible to perceive indigenous women’s power to shape the cultural discourse as revealed by their influence on the Oaxtepec cloister image configuration.4
the Fondo de Microfilm of the Biblioteca Eusebio Dávalos Hurtado del Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City, Víctor E. Urruchúa Hernández, and J. J. González Monroy, for allowing and assisting me to consult Santiago (1540–87). 3 For the metaphor of the saints as columns or cornerstones of the Church as applied in Europe, see the Bible, Revelation 21, 14, Galatians 2, 9, Ephesians 2, 19–20; see also Irenaeus of Lyon (1969–82) 3:2: 160–63; Migne (1844–91) 108: 177, 111: 394, 403–4, 165: 896, 172: 316, 176: 439, 1167–68, 198: 694, 707; Panofsky-Soergel (1979) 104–05; Durandus (1906) 17, 21; Sauerländer (1972) 471–72; Transformations of the Court Style (1977) 17–18; Schapiro (1985) 20 and fig. 24; and Forsyth (1986) 76. For this same metaphor as used by sixteenth-century Mexican friars or clergy in their writings, see Motolinía (1971) 19; Cuevas (1975) 67; and Paso y Troncoso (1905–42) 8: 19. 4 This view of the Mexican colonial intercultural dynamic is in accord with that demonstrated by the eminent historians Lockhart (1992) and Burkhart (1989).
102
richard e. phillips The Oaxtepec Cloister’s Murals: Style, Function, and Constituencies
To prove this thesis, first it is necessary to establish that the Tlalhuica and Xochimilca women and men who constituted the population of Oaxtepec and its district had access to the monastery’s cloister and that they constituted the primary audience for whom the murals were painted.5 A multitude of colonial Mexican sources proves that the mendicant friars routinely conducted their parishioners on procession through cloisters. In the mid-sixteenth century the vast majority of these parishioners were Native Americans, many born before the Spanish conquest of 1521. Sometimes the colonial records even specify that the claustral processional participants were ‘indios’ or ‘naturales.’6 Among its other functions, the Oaxtepec cloister served as a processional theatre. In each of the four outer corners of the cloister is
5 The Valley of Morelos was occupied by two Nahua-speaking groups after 1200 CE, the Tlalhuicas and the Xochimilcas. Although the sources indicate that the valley towns of Oaxtepec and Cuernavaca had both been conquered by the Tlalhuicas before the latter were subsequently subdued by the Aztecs, Oaxtepec was surrounded to such an extent by Xochimilca towns that it is unclear which of the two ethnicities was really predominant there. The Aztecs from the Valley of Mexico conquered the Valley of Morelos in the middle of the fifteenth century, but they did not bring any great cultural or demographic change. The Tlalhuicas, Xochimilcas, and Aztecs were all closely related culturally under the subsuming Nahua ethnicity, and followed most of the same religious practices. See Maldonado Jiménez (1990) 26–32. 6 Fondo Franciscano 47: 151v, 132: 37v, 209, 214v, 260v. For further proofs that the native Mexican peoples were the principal intended audience and ritual users of the sixteenth-century claustral mural paintings, see Edgerton (2001) 108 and 210; and Phillips (1999) 227–50. I am grateful to Dr. Ángel J. García Zambrano for translating this essay. See also Phillips (1993) 140–404; Cervantes de Salazar (1953) 51, 54; de la Rea (1643) fols. 84v–85v; Ordinarivm Sacri Ordinis Heremitarum . . . (1556) fols. 14–14v; Estatvtos generales de Barcelona . . . (1585) fol. 17; Constitvtiones . . . Augustini (1587) fol. 12v; Fondo Franciscano 39: fols. 57–57v, 47: fol. 121v, fols. 148–154v, 48: fols. 21–29v, 49: fol. 17, 132: fols. 37v, 39v, 106, 150v–153, 207–9, 214v, 257v–260v, 139: fols 107–107v, 180: fol. 20; Fondo Lira, 10: 65. My thanks to Dr. Eduardo Matos Moctezuma, then Chief of the National Museum of Anthropology, and to the then Director of the Biblioteca Eusebio Dávalos Hurtado del Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City, Sra. Estela González, for permitting me to use the Fondo Franciscano, the Fondo Lira, and other bound viceregal collections of documents there. For proof that lay women participated in claustral processions, see Aramburu Cendoya (1966) 50–51; and Barry (1942) 54–59. For proof of Early Modern processions with secular folk to claustral stations in Europe, see . . . Liber Processionum . . . (1494) fols. 6v–11v, 39–47; Jiménez de Cisneros (1965) 2: 516, 596; Processionarium . . . (1519) fol. 126; Sigüenza (1907–9) 2: 425, 479, 540–44; Browe (1933) passim; and Heitz (1963) passim.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers
103
a large niche whose ledge functioned as a temporary altar to receive the Host, where it was incensed and revered during the course of a processional station (Fig. 4.2). The back walls of the niches still display their damaged mural paintings, meant to serve as retables for the altar ledges. The first station’s altar niche painting represents The Mocking of Christ, the second The Flagellation, the third The Way of the Cross, and the fourth The Crucifixion.7 Following the biblical narrative, the sequence of stational images at Oaxtepec is chronological, so there is no doubt as to the counterclockwise processional route, marked with Roman numerals I through IV in Figure 4.1. Normally there were only four friars resident at Oaxtepec in the sixteenth century.8 They alone could not have constituted anything like a ritually acceptable Catholic procession. The Oaxtepec processional theatre, with its four niche-altar stations of Christ’s Passion facing the four spacious cloister walks, was obviously intended for a throng, not for a few (Fig. 4.2). Further evidence that the native neophytes were the primary intended audience for the Oaxtepec cloister murals is revealed by the stylistic testimony of the paintings themselves. The indigenous or mestizo cultural upbringing of the master who painted the murals of the cloister stands out clearly in comparison to those by the European or Europeanized master of the Oaxtepec refectory only a few steps away. This Refectory Master’s representation of Christ Blessing the Loaves and the Fishes embodies the standard Renaissance, Western repertoire of gradual shading and illusionistic volume (Fig. 4.3). It stands in stark contrast to the painting of Saint Peter that begins the cloister’s pier cycle (Fig. 4.4). Peter’s patterned and flattened figure is elegantly contained in an irregular calligraphic oval that is repeated in such subsidiary elements as the oval folds of his right leg. This demonstrates that the pier cycle painter was substantially influenced by his or her preColumbian artistic heritage, because that tradition was generally
7 The author established the identity of the pier and corner niche images during field work at Oaxtepec and subsequent study of the photographs and notes in conjunction with consultation of Réau (1955–59) and Schiller (1966). 8 Acuña (1982–) 6: 211. Oaxtepec was never the site of a Dominican Chapter meeting for the whole Mexican Province, nor, apparently, was it ever used as a seminary. No such distinction is listed for the monastery in Santiago (1540–87), in Dávila Padilla (1625), or in Cruz de Moya (1954–55).
104
richard e. phillips
much more abstract and conceptual in nature than the Renaissance artistic legacy of Europe. The more conceptual an artistic tradition is, the more it tends to fit the human figure and all other objects into pre-established conventional patterns.9 The same pre-Columbian-inherited tendency toward abstraction and schematization can be observed in the figure of Blessed Osanna Andreasi on the ninth pier (Fig. 4.5).10 Her white Dominican dress, indicating where her legs and hips should be, occupies fully threequarters of her total height, meaning that the painter was not very concerned with Western European standards of credible human proportions. The pre-Columbian art of Mesoamerica, other than that created at times by the Maya, was also not bound to a set naturalistic canon of human measurements. This lack of submission to naturalism allows the cloister master to think of the bottom threequarters of the saint’s white dress in geometric terms as a kind of steep pyramid or flattened cone. This enhances the saint’s iconic impact as an abstract, geometric force or presence. The folds of Osanna’s white dress are schematic. They lack the customary gradual Renaissance modulation of shade as employed by the Refectory Master a few feet away and are therefore not comprehensive enough to detract from the geometric icon of the dress. The white pyramid is reiterated and reinforced by the second pyramid of the surrounding black Dominican cloak, whose straight, triangular edges only become curvilinear at the saint’s shoulders to provide the minimum necessary reference to human form. The whole figure has been visualized through prior convention, not as an integral human anatomy, but instead as an interlocking composition of only four silhouettes: the two pyramids of drapery, the oval face, and the circular halo. 9
For the non-Western stylistic imperatives and Kunstwollen of the Mexican preColumbian heritage as it subsisted into the viceregal era, see Robertson (1959), and Boone and Smith (2003). 10 Osanna was born in 1449, entered the Third Order of Penitence of St. Dominic in 1501, and died in 1505. Her cult was approved in 1515 but she was never canonized. One of the traditional attributes of her image is the Christ child according to Lechner (1968–76). The Dominican nun saint Rosa of Lima is often shown with the Christ child in her hands, but she lived 1586–1617, long after the Oaxtepec cycle was painted, so she could not be the saint who is depicted on pier surface 9. By a process of elimination, since a book is not a recorded attribute of Osanna Andreasi, while the Christ child is used as an attribute of both St. Agnes of Montepulciano and Osanna, then the Dominican nun holding a book on pier face 16 must be Agnes, following Timmers (1968–76); and Réau (1955–59) 3, 1: 38–39.
Fig. 4.2 Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor of the cloister. View toward the east down the south cloister walk, with the mural paintings of Sts. Paul and Catherine of Alexandria on the southwest pier. Photo by the author.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers 105
106
richard e. phillips
Fig. 4.3 Christ Blessing the Loaves and the Fishes. Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor. West end wall of the refectory, south side. Photo by the author.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers
107
Fig. 4.4 St. Peter. Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor of the cloister. First image of the pier cycle. Photo by the author.
108
richard e. phillips
Fig. 4.5 Blessed Osanna Andreasi. Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec, first floor of the cloister. Ninth pier face of the cloister arcade cycle, south cloister walk. Photo by the author.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers
109
One of Osanna’s typical symbolic attributes is the figure of the Christ child toward whom she channels her maternal love. Little children are of course much smaller than grown adults but they are not nearly as small in relation to a normal adult as the Christ child is to Osanna in the pier nine mural. Many non-Western artistic styles such as the pre-Columbian are not overly concerned with the veracity of scale that was one of the central tenets of Western art beginning with the Renaissance. When the importance of symbolism and meaning overrides the importance of realism in any given artistic tradition, figures may be depicted in larger-than-normal scale in relation to others in order to indicate their relative importance.11 Such is the case here. Osanna is in larger-than-normal scale vis-à-vis the child to indicate that she is the principal figure toward which attention is to be channeled on this particular pier within the logic of a cycle of saints representing the pillars of the Church, although within the grander scheme of Christianity she is infinitesimally as important as the Christ child is. The tiny size of the Christ child only reinforces her power for him as a kind of maternal mountain of nurturing refuge. The features of the child himself, with his dark hair and dark brown face, are characteristically Mexican. The native women on procession through the cloister certainly would have felt affirmed by this image of the protective mother and her Mexican-looking charge, whose small size only enhances the viewers’ empathetic desire to protect and cherish him. This author suspects that a Mexicanizing or indigenizing master was chosen to paint the cloister, even though a Europeanizing master did the refectory, due to the preferences of the indigenous masses to whom the Dominicans had to respond. Within the Western monastic tradition the Oaxtepec refectory was a more corporate, private space, reserved for the prerogatives of the Dominican friars themselves, while the cloister in the Western tradition was commonly shared by the regular clergy with the laity ever since early medieval times for processions.12 Consequently, the Oaxtepec cloister was
11 12
See the discussion of the ‘heirarchy of scale’ in Kleiner, et al. (2001) xxvii–xxviii. See footnote 6.
110
richard e. phillips
decorated in a style that resonated more with the natives. It is plausible that they had a say in the ultimate choice of the Cloister Master. These assertions are supported by the fact that the people of Oaxtepec and its district had a fundamental impact on the symbolic program of saints on piers that the Dominicans chose for the first floor of the cloister, as shown presently.
The Dominican Tradition and Its Redirection The images of the saints on the claustral piers serve as ciphers for several sets of complex interrelated messages that the Dominican friars wished to communicate about themselves and their religious Order. The schematic representation of the mural cycle in Figure 4.1 identifies the saints whose images were chosen to embody the pillars of the universal church. In addition, each icon represented one of three essential categories of saints into which the Oaxtepec pier cycle can be subdivided. Each saint had been either a member of the Dominican Order, the founder of a religious Order, or a saint from Antiquity (before 500 CE).13 These basic categories are indicated in Figure 4.1 with the letters D, F, and A, respectively, recorded on the piers next to the saints’ names.
13 It is nearly certain, by analogy, that the two destroyed images of the first, western range of the Oaxtepec claustral piers, faces 2 and 3, were of male saints. Besides the factor of overall agreement with the exclusively masculine third range on the east, this conclusion about the missing figures of the first range is reached by noting that the middle piers of the remaining three sides represent the three most prestigious Dominican male saints other than Dominic: Thomas Aquinas on face 8, Peter Martyr at 13, Vincent Ferrer at 18. Since the image of Francis, the founder of one of the three mendicant orders active in Mexico when these murals were painted, is on pier face 4 and because Dominic, the founder of the Dominican Order that built this monastery, is the only saint unaccounted for in the subset of major male Dominican saints on the four central piers, then logically he was depicted on the third face. We can be sure that the saints once represented on piers 2 and 3 were Augustine and Dominic because the two figures that frame the first range are Peter and Paul, the two most eminent disseminators of the faith. Francis, still visible on face 4, is equated with Peter and Paul as a proselytizer of the religion carried by his minions to the New World. Augustine and Dominic therefore completed the first range as counterparts of Peter and Paul in spreading the faith.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers
111
As could be expected in a Dominican cloister, ten of the twenty depicted saints are Dominicans. The Dominican friars who inhabited the cloister made sure to laud their Order as an especially august body in upholding the fabric of the Catholic church. The resident friars meant to imply that they themselves were the successors of the Dominican saints in a hoary pedigree that upheld the fabric of the
In the second range the feminine counterparts to Peter and Paul of the first are Catherine of Alexandria on face 6 and Catherine of Siena on face 10. They shared both their names and comparable positions within the traditional Dominican hagiography. Catherine of Alexandria was the most famous woman saint after Mary and Mary Magdalene and the preeminent of the four Virgin Patronesses of the universal Church, following Jameson (1895) 2: 458–60. Catherine of Siena was the primordial female saint of the Dominican order before the emergence of Rosa of Lima in the early seventeenth century. She is also represented opposite Dominic on the main portal of the monastery church at Tepoztlán near Oaxtepec, dating from about 1560. At Oaxtepec Catherine of Alexandria is identified, despite the destruction of two-thirds of her image, by her royal crown and the hilt of the sword by which she was martyred, following Jameson (1895) 2: 461–65 (cf. Fig. 4.2). Catherine of Siena is shown holding a crucifix and her heart, which she exchanged with that of Jesus when she betrothed him, following Réau (1955–59) 3, 1, 273–74. Between the ‘bookends’ of the Catherines are the images of one female and two male saints. On face 7 is a saint who holds a banner with a cross. The most famous saint (other than Christ) to sustain such a banner is St. George, so perhaps the image represents that military saint. This saint must bear armor, however, and it was not ascertained during field work if the saint of face 7 is so outfitted. Portly Thomas Aquinas holds his book at number 8 as the preeminent Dominican scholar. The ends of the fourth pier range are signified on analogy with those of the second, in that Agnes of Montepulciano, like Catherine of Siena opposite her a Dominican female saint, is paired with a legendary female virgin martyr saint from Antiquity, Lucy at surface #20, just as Catherine of Siena is linked with Catherine of Alexandria, following Jameson (1895) 2: 57. Under the spell of the female termini of the corner patronesses of the fourth claustral pier range are three males for the intermediate piers. At face 17 is a Dominican pope, perhaps Benedict XI, 1303–4, on the analogy of pier face 3 of the lower cloister of nearby Dominican Yautepec, following Kaster (1968–76). At number 18 is a Dominican saint with wings and a crucifix, Vincent Ferrer, following Jameson (1901) 412. At number 19 is a saint with a wallet hanging from a pike atop his staff. This is James the Greater, known in Spanish as “Santiago,” the patron saint of Spain, who appears in pilgrim garb such as this from the thirteenth century onward due to the fame of his relics at his pilgrimage Cathedral of Compostella in northeast Spain, following Réau (1955–59) 3, 2: 695. The first corner of the third range, face 11, presents a monk with a book, perhaps Benedict with his Rule. The other framing face, 15, displays a Dominican who wears an archbishop’s cloak over his monastic habit, holds a palm of martyrdom in one hand, and three oranges in the other: St. Antoninus of Florence, following Réau (1955–59) 3, 1: 123–24, and Strnad (1968–76). Between these two figures are Andrew, Peter Martyr, and Dominic.
112
richard e. phillips
church, the latest inhabitants of the Christian cloister, guaranteeing to the denizens of Oaxtepec that a religious Order that has produced so many saints is a trustworthy guide to heaven for the believer. From the information so far presented, it is obvious that the Tlalhuicas and Xochimilcas were not the sole audience for whom this cloister cycle was intended, for it lauds and boosts the greatness of the Dominican institute whose friars occupied this residence. It was also meant for the occasional important Spanish guests and Franciscan and Augustinian friars who, along with the Dominicans, evangelized the tightly packed mission field of the Valley of Morelos.14 Because of this, Saints Augustine and Francis flank St. Dominic on the western piers where visitors would first enter the cloister (Fig. 4.1). They are in turn bracketed by Saints Peter (Fig. 4.4) and Paul, the apostles of the Jews and Gentiles, respectively, who symbolize between them the totality of the universal Christian Church.15 The founders of the three mendicant orders of friars that were involved in the sixteenthcentury proselytization of Mexico—Augustine, Dominic, Francis— were thus equated with the princes of the apostles as their successors, which in turn means that the Christian mission in Mexico was intended to be seen as apostolic. None of the symbolic permutations of the cloister pier program as so far described can be characterized as a concession to indigenous pressure. However, there is another element at work here. It is the prominence of the female saints in this pier cycle, unprecedented in any other extant Mexican sixteenth-century cloister. It cannot be explained simply as the product of a voluntary decision on the part of the friars oblivious to native preferences. By way of comparison, only fourteen kilometers away at the monastery of Yautepec, Morelos, whose cloister was built and painted about 1555–59, the
14 If a Franciscan ventured east from his monastery in Cuernavaca on his way to the Franciscan-dominated valleys of Atlixco and Puebla, he could not get there in one day and could only find monastic accommodation in Dominican or Augustinian houses. Such was the case with the Franciscan Ciudad Real, who stayed with his Commissary General Alonso de Ponce at the Dominican monastery of Oaxtepec in 1586 during the course of the latter’s tour of inspection of Franciscan houses. Ciudad Real (1976) 1: 125. Doubtless they found the image of Francis on pier face 4 to be a welcome, ecumenical sight. The Augustinian friars had monasteries only eight and seventeen kilometers by modern road to the north of Oaxtepec, at Tlayacapan and Totolapan, respectively. 15 Jameson (1895) 1: 179–80; Clement (1971) 250; and Mâle (1984) 384.
women and men as cosmic co-bearers
113
corners are held by male Dominican saints, save for Catherine of Siena, who is paired with the non-Dominican Lucy on the fourth corner pier. Consequently, at Yautepec only one of the four metaphorical columns upholding the universe declares the female principle, and there is no configuration exalting women and men working together as co-sustainers of the faith as at Oaxtepec. Thirty-seven kilometers away at Dominican Tetela del Volcán, Morelos, painted about 1560–63, Catherine of Siena is the only woman in the whole claustral pier cycle. In the first cloister of the Augustinian monastery of Acolman, State of Mexico, painted about 1560, none of the saints on any of the sixteen pier surfaces is female.16 In the Oaxtepec cloister, unlike the others above, a female is paired with a male saint on each corner pier to show that each cornerstone of the Catholic church is sustained equally by both women and men (Fig. 4.1). At Oaxtepec care was taken that each range of piers begin and end with saints of the same sex, bracketing each walk and endowing it with a male or female numen. In this way the first and third sides are defined by male totems, the second and fourth by female ones. The male ranges, one and three, are unanimously male, while those patronized by female terminals are diluted by the inclusion of men on the intermediate piers. Fifteen saints are male, five are female. This relative numerical disparity of females to males at Oaxtepec is no surprise given the degree of male over female dominance in indigenous Mexican society before and after the conquest and in sixteenth-century Spain and Western Europe. Those were the two cultural heritages coming together at Oaxtepec. The fundamental question is why women were given relative prominence at all in a men’s cloister at Oaxtepec and in no other known Mexican claustral pier cycle.
16 It is important here to be very