WMD, NUKES AND NUNS
WMD, NUKES AND NUNS
A Sequel to Prophets without Honor: A Requiem for Moral Patriotism
By Willi...
23 downloads
1159 Views
1007KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
WMD, NUKES AND NUNS
WMD, NUKES AND NUNS
A Sequel to Prophets without Honor: A Requiem for Moral Patriotism
By William M. Strabala
Algora Publishing New York
© 2006 by Algora Publishing in the name of William M. Strabala. All Rights Reserved www.algora.com No portion of this book (beyond what is permitted by Sections 107 or 108 of the United States Copyright Act of 1976) may be reproduced by any process, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form, or by any means, without the express written permission of the publisher.
ISBN-10: 0-87586-446-5 (soft cover) ISBN-10: 0-87586-447-3 (hardcover) ISBN-10: 0-87586-448-1 (ebook) Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data —
Strabala, William. WMD, nukes, and nuns / by William M. Strabala. p. cm. “A sequel to Prophets without honor : a requiem for moral patriotism.” Includes bibliographical references. ISBN-10: 0-87586-446-5 (trade paper : alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-87586-447-3 (alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-87586-448-1 (ebook) ISBN-13: 978-0-87586-446-4 (trade paper : alk. paper) [etc.] 1. Political corruption—United States. 2. Iraq War, 2003—Moral and ethical aspects. 3. Weapons of mass destruction—United States. 4. Dissenters—United States. 5. Criminal justice, Administration of—United States—Case studies. 6. Christianity and politics—United States. I. Title. JK2249.S79 2006 956.7044'31—dc22 2006000116
Cover: Bottom from left: Ardeth Platte, O.P, Jackie Hudson, O.P, Carol Gilbert, O.P
Printed in the United States
“When just laws are broken by governments, nonviolent resistance is duty.” — Sister Ardeth Platte, OP
Requiescant in pace For Rev. Philip Berrigan, S.J., who institutionalized draft card burning and the Plowshares organization Sam Day, who founded the Nuke Watch publication and Rev. Paul Kabat, OMI, who was first to jack hammer a missile silo lid
Acknowledgements The author wishes to acknowledge the assistance and encouragement of: Daniel Berrigan, S.J., New York City, for awakening the conscience of America, from his jail cell. Rev. John Dear, S.J., Springer, NM, for books and jail activism stirring that same conscience. Rev. Robert Kinsey, for the Peace and Justice Task Force, United Church of Christ, Colorado. Michael Palecek, Sheldon, Iowa, for his research and inspired writing and jail time. Mary Lou Pedersen, Chicago, for her research and anti-war commitment. Rev. Darrell Rupiper, OMI, for his jail time and continuing commitment to peace and justice. Timothy J. Strabala,Ph.D., Auckland, New Zealand, for daring to edit his father’s work. William Sulzman, Colorado Springs, inspirational founder of “Citizens for Peace in Space.” Joan White, founder of Executive Editors, Denver, for her assistance with the words.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PREFACE
1
CHAPTER 1. A LOOK INTO THE PAST FROM THE FUTURE
7
CHAPTER 2. IF THIS BE TREASON
11
CHAPTER 3. ANOTHER LIE, ANOTHER WAR, ANOTHER PROTEST
27
CHAPTER 4. A QUESTION OF VALUES: WHY ARE THE NUNS IN JAIL?
33
CHAPTER 5. RENDERING UNTO CAESAR, OR BEING RENDERED?
43
CHAPTER 6. OF POPES, PROPHETS, PULPITS, PATRIOTS, PRESIDENTS AND POLITICAL PUPPETS
55
CHAPTER 7. AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH
65
CHAPTER 8. OF HUMAN ANGELS AND WOMEN MAYORS
77
Sister Ardeth Platte, OP Sister Carol Gilbert, OP Sister Jacqueline Hudson, OP
79 81 83
CHAPTER 9. NUNS AND OTHER MOTHERS WHO TEACH THEIR CHILDREN
91
CHAPTER 10. IN THE WRECKAGE OF 9/11
99
CHAPTER 11. THE POLITICAL COUP IN AMERICA TOOK PLACE IN IRAQ
103
CHAPTER 12. UH-OH: THE COUP’S THOUGHT-POLICE
111
CHAPTER 13. LETTERS HOME: WE KILLED THE FATHER TO FEED THE SON
121
CHAPTER 14. MORE LETTERS HOME: THESE FROM “BAD ASS” NUNS
127
Sister Ardeth Platte, OP Sister Jacqueline Hudson, OP
128 133
xi
WMD, Nukes and Nuns CHAPTER 15. FIGURES FROM IRAQ
135
CHAPTER 16. IRAQ: KILLING FIELD FOR THE WAR BETWEEN TERRORISTS
143
CHAPTER 17. THREE NUNS KNOCKING ON THE WEAPONS-GATE OF WMD
147
CHAPTER 18. MEANWHILE, BACK AT THE WMD RANCH
167
CHAPTER 19. AMERICA AS A TWISTED THEOCRACY
175
CHAPTER 20. OF TRAITORS AND TRADERS: PRESIDENTIAL ARMIES SWAPPED FOR PRESIDENTIAL NUKES
179
CHAPTER 21. WMD COMPANIES GET BACK IN LINE FOR SECONDS
187
CHAPTER 22. VIVE LA FRANCE, VIVE LE CARLYLE, VIVE LE U.N., VIVE SADDAM
193
AFTERWORD: REFLECTIONS FROM EISENHOWER
199
APPENDIX A. SACRED EARTH AND SPACE PLOWSHARES II
201
APPENDIX B. THE NUREMBERG PRINCIPLES
203
xii
PREFACE America’s own Weapons of Mass Destruction seem to go almost unmentioned as this nation wages war against a foe that is demonized for “perhaps” seeking to acquire WMD capability. This is a book about those American WMD and about three prophetic nuns who staged a peaceful protest at a missile silo. It’s about political immorality and the meaning of justice in a nation where it seems to be illegal to carry out non-violent protests against mass killing. The stage was set for the nuns’ action by a sequence of events that we will trace to 1991, although they have their roots in earlier diplomatic machinations. In April 1991, UNSCOM (United Nations Special Commission) established a weapons inspection policy to investigate whether Iraq was assembling weapons of mass destruction, military technology that would threaten the world. This UN commission evolved into UNMOVIC (United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission), which sent a second wave of inspection teams. (In 1994 UNMOVIC oversaw the destruction of SCUD missiles and other WMD faculties that the US did not want Iraq to have. It was expelled by Saddam Hussein afterwards.) Just prior to that, in January 1991, President G.H.W. Bush had sent US troops into the oil-rich nation of Kuwait. According to the US, this was a war conducted to liberate that tiny nation from an Iraqi invasion intended to occupy Kuwait for its oil. Even though Iraq had huge oil reserves of its own, Saddam supposedly had decided to capture the oil reserves of his neighbors and monop-
1
WMD, Nukes and Nuns olize the common oil geology. However, it turns out that the tiny but oil-rich Kuwait was enhancing its supply to the US by drilling slant wells under the Iraq border and was drawing oil from a shared geological formation. After invading Kuwait, Saddam was then poised threateningly on the border with Saudi Arabia, another strategic oil supplier for the US. Given Saddam’s apparently aggressive move, Bush was able to induce the nation of Saudi Arabia (which is Islamic, but not Arab) to grant him permission to establish a military base on its territory. The President repeatedly said the war “was not about oil”; he did not make it very clear, though, what else it might be about. Neither did he make it clear why the US repulsion of Iraqi troops stopped short of Baghdad and the overthrow of Saddam Hussein, who had once been a CIA asset recruited by Bush. More than ten years later, on September 11, 2001, four commercial airliners were hijacked; two of them were crashed into the World Trade Center towers and one into the Pentagon in suicide missions. (The fourth hijacked plane crashed on the ground before reaching its objective.) These acts were labeled terrorism and were considered acts of war by the administration of President G.W. Bush. The majority of the hijackers were officially identified as Saudi nationals; however, they were apparently not acting on government orders and so there was no nation against which to declare war. The news soon reported that the ringleader of the plot was Osama bin Laden, who headed a group called Al Qaeda (The Cell). He was said to be angry that American infidel troops were defiling sacred Muslim soil by their continuing presence in Saudi Arabia. Then it was learned that Al Qaeda and bin Laden had trained in Afghanistan and had been sheltered by the Taliban government that had come to power after the Soviet-backed government there had failed. Congress granted Bush war powers to invade Afghanistan, which he did by making territorial arrangements with Pakistan, another Muslim nation. The Taliban evaporated, but bin Laden escaped the American net. US revenge unrequited, G.W. Bush seems to have used the opportunity to target other Islamic nations. His focus fell on Iraq. His rhetoric suggested Saddam Hussein was complicit in the 9/11 plot and that the next foe in the “War on Terrorism” would be Iraq. The reason given was that Iraq was importing uranium oxide from Niger, in Africa, and therefore had the capability to build nuclear weapons, that is, “Weapons of Mass Destruction.” WMD became a popular new buzzword and Iraq became the new whipping boy.
2
Preface Several continents away, in the fall of 2002, three Dominican nuns cut through a chain link fence around a nuclear missile silo in Colorado and declared that they had discovered the WMD Bush was looking for. So much for UN inspectors. Their protest was staged to show the world who was the real threat when it came to the use of WMD. The three women were arrested and jailed for “sabotaging national security” by objecting to the war that was already being prepared against Iraq. In March, 2003, after “pacifying” Afghanistan, President G.W. Bush went on to invade Iraq from the same base in Pakistan. The declared purpose of the war was to find and neutralize the WMD on Iraqi soil that constituted a threat to the security of the US and the rest of the West. Not to mention Iraq’s closer neighbors. But no such weapons could be found. A new justification had to be found. Washington then emphasized that Saddam Hussein was a tyrant to his own people and his neighbors, and it would be better to force a regime change and impose “freedom and democracy.” In February of 2002, the CIA paid Joe Wilson, former ambassador to Iraq, to travel to Niger to check out a report for Vice President Cheney that Iraq was buying uranium oxide to make nuclear weapons. (The report came from the Italian Intelligence Service and has since been determined to have been based on forged documents.) By March of 2002, Wilson reported to the CIA that “it was highly doubtful that any such transaction had ever taken place” (The New York Times, July 6, 2003). Ten months later, in January of 2003, President Bush cited in his State of the Union message a British dossier on the matter and repeated the charges publicly that Iraq was buying uranium from Africa. In March, Vice President Cheney said on the TV show Meet the Press that Saddam was “trying once again to produce nuclear weapons.” In July 2003, Joe Wilson publicly contradicted Bush and Cheney, telling the New York Times that “If the information was ignored because it did not fit certain preconceptions about Iraq, then a legitimate argument can be made that we went to war under false pretenses.” In reaction, the White House leaked the news to the media that Joe Wilson’s wife, Valerie Plame, was a CIA agent, and suggested that CIA reports by her husband were unreliable. The story was written by columnist Robert Novak, July 14, 2003. The CIA charged that this leak was a breach of national security under the Intelligence Identities Protection Act of 1982. As events turned out:
3
WMD, Nukes and Nuns 1) The UN inspection sanctions begun in 1991 had already eliminated all WMD technology from Saddam’s arsenal. No WMD of any type were found by the conquering US troops. 2) The importation of uranium by Iraq was apparently a fabrication based on forged documents but, because it was endorsed by British intelligence, it was hyped by Vice President Dick Cheney to promote public support for the war. 3) As personal punishment for contradicting the president, Joe Wilson’s wife, Valerie Plame, was exposed as a CIA agent and Wilson was painted as relying on personal and dubious information. At length, feeling persecuted by the Bush administration, Wilson told the Los Angeles Times (Oct. 29, 2005): “More important, they did it as part of a clear effort to cover up the lies and disinformation used to justify the invasion of Iraq. That is the ultimate crime.” 4) The ensuing cover-up of Cheney’s deceit led to charges of national security violations by his office. One Cheney aide, Lewis “Scooter” Libby, has been indicted for lying to the investigators about the national security breach. 5) The truth of the war against Iraq revolves around WMD: who has them, and whether they are ethical in the context of the Geneva Conventions governing the conduct of war. The nuns point the finger at the US. This book explores the injustice of the US federal courts which sent the nuns to jail for their virtue in opposing the ramp-up to the war in Iraq, and the killing of many thousands of human beings — including thousands of America’s own young men and women. As heroic as their sacrifice is, their lives were needlessly cut down by the sword of Bush-invented “religious patriotism,” as this book will show. This book also reveals the corporate sources of the weapons of mass destruction (WMD) that were delivered to Saddam Hussein in the 1980s. Certainly, he then exceeded his tacit American license to kill, which arguably gave Washington the excuse for the war now at issue The corporate sources of those WMD had close ties to two Bush presidents. They placed WMD in Iraq’s hands when Saddam was a CIA “asset” and before he became “the enemy.” Years later, those presidents found it necessary to remove their own secretly-placed WMD technology by means of two wars in order to obliterate evidence of their personal connections to Saddam Hussein’s non-existent nuclear WMD. At the center of the presidential cabal by two Bush presidents is the investment bank called the Carlyle Group.
4
Preface The book lays bare the truth of a classic behind-the-scenes struggle between politics and the morality of an unjust war reflecting from the lives of those who support it. It exposes truths that few Americans will understand or believe, but for which — out of a simplistic version of patriotism that has been equated with morality — they are willing to kill and die. It shows, therefore, how the world was dragged into war even as three gentle nuns were punished for their resistance to such crimes and the lies that hide the truth about the Iraq war. The purpose of this book and the motives of its heroes and villains cannot be understood without first reviewing the relevant law, as constituted in part by the Nuremberg Principles adopted by treaty under article VI of the US Constitution. The most pertinent articles of Nuremberg state: Principle I: Any person who commits an act which constitutes a crime under international law is responsible therefor and liable to punishment. Principle II: The fact that international law does not impose a penalty for an act which constitutes a crime under international law does not relieve the person who committed the act from responsibility under international law. Principle III: The fact that a person who committed an act which constitutes a crime under international law acted as a Head of State or responsible government official does not relieve him from responsibility under international law. [For a complete review, see Appendix B.]
These principles were part of the Nazi War Crimes Tribunal adopted into the Geneva Conventions after the close of World War II and became the law of the land in the US under Article VI of the US Constitution, which declares: “This Constitution and the laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof and all treaties made or which shall be made under the authority of the United States shall be the supreme law of the land and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the Constitution or laws of any state to the contrary nothwithstanding.” For its part the Geneva Conventions, which are US law, declare the use of weapons of mass destruction or the threat to use them is a war crime. As such, logic leads to the conclusion that the law has been broken both by the federal courts and by the chief executive of the United States under his presidential oath to defend the constitution and uphold the laws of the land. It will warn people who do not believe in evolution of the species about the devolution of American democracy into a theocracy. It will show the public
5
WMD, Nukes and Nuns how and where and why its train of morality has been hijacked for political purpose and religious power-mongering. This book will reveal scandals illustrating how two presidents named Bush suborned even the nation’s latest nuclear secrets to war-profiteering for the commercial benefit of a company that they and their political cronies still own. Specifically, this book will show that the same Bush-owned company provided Saddam Hussein with WMD technology, and then used the Iraq War to remove Saddam and destroy evidence of the Bush complicity in its own brand of WMD treachery. It will show how billions of dollars were involved and why millions of people died for a selfish few men in power; and it will show how the scandal of the UN’s Oil-for-Food program lined the pockets of men who held White House positions. In the end this book will render, for judgment by the reader, the contrast between these immoral outrages and the peaceful, moral efforts of three nuns who protested — to both sides — the consequences of WMD policy. It will ask why they languished in jail for trying to prevent a terrible crime against humanity, perpetrated in Iraq at the hands of the US, while those who promoted the war by lies about CIA’s intelligence operations remain free and merely indicted — if it can be proven — for lying. If, in 2020, any Americans look back on the George W. Bush presidency and try to make sense of what happened to their country, these pages will help elucidate the story. And the moral that emerges from this tale will become clear.
6
CHAPTER 1. A LOOK INTO THE PAST FROM THE FUTURE It is unlikely that in the year 2020 anyone will be alive who cared why three nuns in the year 2002 were arrested and falsely convicted of sabotaging the national security of the United States of America. By then, if a free world still exists, it will be clear that there was, of course, no such sabotage. By 2020, a wrinkled George W. Bush might still be wearing his mindless smirk at his Texas ranch. He will likely be as unrepentant as ever for the damage he has wreaked within the world, using the pretext of revenge for 9/11 and fear of other nations’ WMD. “What nuns?” he might say. “What nucular [sic] treaties?” By 2020, most of the members of the jury that convicted the nuns will be gone, without ever having come to recognize that they voted to convict despite the fact that the colonel in charge of the missile silo said that the nuns had done nothing to impede the use of the missiles, and thus had not compromised national security (as defined by our holding the means to unleash nuclear Armageddon). By 2020, Judge Robert Blackburn may have suffered some pangs of conscience for manipulating the case against the nuns in favor of a government proclaiming its right to hold WMD even as it went to war over another nation’s non-existent WMD. By 2020, the judges of the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver likely will be unable to recall why, except for reasons related to their federal paychecks, they refused to recognize that the nuns were far less a threat to national security than the people who planned the attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
7
WMD, Nukes and Nuns By 2020, the strutting federal prosecutor, John Suthers — whose nunhunting exploits in the Bush political jungle earned him the position of Colorado attorney general — perhaps will have satisfied his ambitions enough to pause and reflect; but he is unlikely to be humble enough to recognize that his bullying deliberately over-reached the moral basis of what Common Law, as he learned it at Notre Dame University, is all about. By 2020, the three nuns in question will likely have died but will be very much alive in the heaven where such holy and persecuted people live forever in peace. By 2020, the public will have long since forgotten the confused logic and ego-puffery of the born-again ad-man Rush Limbaugh, who announced on November 3, 1988: And now the liberals want to stop President Reagan from selling chemical warfare agents and military equipment to Saddam Hussein; and why? Because Saddam “allegedly” gassed a few Kurds in his own country. Mark my words, all of this talk of Saddam Hussein being a ‘war criminal’ or ‘committing crimes against humanity’ is the same old thing: Liberal hate speech. And speaking of poison gas…I say we round up all the drug addicts and gas them.
That, of course, was before Limbaugh was revealed to be a closet drug addict whose crime went unpunished, and before the US went to war with Saddam — twice. In his own words, the ultra-conservative Limbaugh blabbed to the world that America was selling WMD technology to Iraq as far back as the ReaganBush years, when dictators like Saddam were cultivated for the sake of their efficiency in eliminating objections to self-serving American policies. While neither of the Bush presidents has publicly expressed support for Limbaugh’s WMD idiocy, over the years they did—through their political influence—supply Saddam with poison gas WMD. If the observers from 2020 hearken back to 2005, they will find that the same wild WMD policy supported by Limbaugh was carried out by two Bush Presidents over the years. Vice President Dick Cheney’s aide Lewis “Scooter” Libby resigned in November 2005 after lying about WMD and the issue of Iraq’s trafficking in uranium for WMD, as noted in the preface. (This claim was the primary reason given by the Administration to justify the invasion of Iraq.) In the fallout, Bush’s stubbornness in keeping the US on a war footing wiped out his ability to respond to domestic needs. His untenable fiscal policies raise broad questions about his clique’s short-term and long-term goals. With a $600 billion tax break for the rich, they put the nation into a fiscal box; the box
8
Chapter 1. A Look into the Past from the Future got tighter with the war in Iraq, which cost another $300 billion. The rebuilding of Baghdad drained another $100 billion. When Hurricane Katrina wiped out New Orleans (in part because flood control funds to beef up its dikes had been diverted for the sake of the war), there was no money to cover the emergency. Bush wildly pledged $200 billion “or whatever it takes” to make the shredded Gulf Coast whole again. But months later, New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin was publicly bemoaning the fact that while money had been found to rebuild cities in Iraq, promises were all he had when it came to rebuilding his city. “It blows me away,” he told CBS News on December 5, 2005. The irony is that when Bush came to office, he inherited from democratic President Clinton a budget surplus. Bush promptly broke Clinton’s piggy bank and created a drain on the economy of more than a trillion dollars — most of it spent on spilling blood in Iraq and applying the bandages. To understand the Iraq War, the people of 2020 will have to learn that such callousness and even the will to create human suffering for the sake of political goals was a part of America at the dawn of the third “Christian” millennium. But one thing will remain: the festering sores of the WMD of nuclear nations. The US seems to be on track to spread the war in Iraq to its neighbors (e.g., Iran, Syria, Libya) and the possibility of peace in the Middle East will have been once again deferred to somewhere over the American rainbow. The public most likely will have no idea why the government and courts sought to imprison nuns and priests and protesters for their peaceful resistance to the WMD of nuclear nations. On the other hand, perhaps those who tire of a war without end may be curious enough to ask questions, such as: Who really owned WMDs at that time? Who was a threat to America’s security? Who unilaterally voided nuclear treaties? Who put the US on a first-strike pre-emptive war footing? Who lied? Who profited from a war designed around the body-bags of 2,000+ American lives? Who once set up Saddam Hussein as a CIA “asset” to wage war against Iran and then double-crossed him?
9
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Who made money from the Food-for-Oil scheme that was ostensibly intended to keep the Iraqis from starving? Who deleted from the files the names of the hundreds of companies the United Nations had turned up, indicating Iraq’s sources of WMD technology? Who indeed did all these things, if not two presidents named Bush and their intimate political associates? And yet, who went to prison? The nuns. Who died? Thousands of American men and women, not to mention tens of thousands of Iraqis and others. The events of 2005 necessarily trace their history back through the 10th Circuit decision of March 17, 2005, which denied the appeal on behalf of the nuns. That court with a shrug of its federal shoulders affirmed the condemnation of the lower court because a world war based on WMD weighed more heavily in the scales of justice and security than did the challenge of three simple nuns for the sake of peace. The ruling turned the findings of the anti-Hitler Nuremburg trials upside down. The system broke its own laws regarding citizen responsibility for the actions of their government. In 2005, even as the last of the three nuns is released from jail after serving out her term, Saddam Hussein has yet to be found guilty of any crime. Of what might he be guilty? To explore these issues and questions, we will go back to the 8th District Court in Denver, Judge Robert Blackburn presiding. As he affirmed the sacrosanct nature of WMD by sentencing three nuns, those nuns told him to his face that they would pray for him — as they do for the world—saddled as it is with WMD.
10
CHAPTER 2. IF THIS BE TREASON “For my part, I think it is a less evil that some criminals should escape than that the government should play an ignoble part.” — Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes
“Dangerously irresponsible.” That was how US District Judge Robert Blackburn described three blackgarbed nuns in his Denver courtroom on July 25, 2003, as he poised his gavel for the final blow. His words came less than two years after what has come to be known as “9/11.” In the weeks before, the nuns had chosen to wear in court their prisonprovided fluorescent-orange jumpsuits — the color intended to signal that these women were guilty of something. The nuns thought the suits appropriately broadcast the injustice of their predicament to the world. Now, as sentence was to be pronounced, the nuns dressed themselves in traditional black habits, perhaps to signal the kind of “death sentence” they expected, or perhaps to accept the sentence in their proper identity rather than in a costume designed for real criminals. (Before proceeding, Judge Blackburn asked a man in the gallery to remove his hat. Unheard by the judge, the man remarked he didn’t think he was in church.) Blackburn’s description of the nuns, delivered with a judiciary scowl, applied to the way in which the nuns had gone about “discovering” weapons of mass destruction (WMD) in Weld County, Colorado. After all, they had cut through a fence to “discover” such WMD. And this was just weeks before Pres-
11
WMD, Nukes and Nuns ident George W. Bush launched the second Bush war of “shock and awe” against Iraq in order to discover Iraq’s WMD. The judge’s words (“dangerously irresponsible”) were preamble to the imposition of sentences ranging from 30 to 41 months for “sabotaging the nation’s security.” They had done so by cutting a chain-link fence and defiling with blood, poured from baby bottles, the sanctuary of America’s security: a WMD site. At the time the nuns took their action (prior to the invasion of Iraq), theirs was a case that really amounted to the misdemeanor offense of trespassing at a missile silo that happened to contain WMD. But, if WMD are so egregiously evil that Bush cited them as the primary reason for war against Iraq, then it would appear to be a citizen’s responsibility, not a crime, to call attention to their presence on US soil. This contradiction never even slowed down the pro-war court. In the wake of the 9/11 events, the government chose to equate the trespass of the nuns and their prayers for peace with sabotage and treason. And so the US charged the nuns with an offense designed to defrock the moral principle for which their black robes stood. After all, nuns or not, they were guilty of a sin against the nation and of violating its WMD. The nuns both understood but were perplexed by the schizophrenia of US policy. Bush told the world and the nation that it was necessary to find and eliminate WMD in Iraq because they threatened the world, and that he would go to war to create peace and freedom from the scourge of WMD. He said this after 50 years of American policy that had threatened the world with the US form of nuclear WMD doom. He said this after a history of supplying Iraq with the very WMD technologies now deemed evil enough to cause war. These were the thoughts reverberating in the mind of the nuns. But neither Bush nor his father nor any of their policies was on trial here; the nuns were. Blackburn steered the whole trial in that direction, and he boiled it down to a conclusion about three “dangerously irresponsible” nuns. His shaping of the arguments washed away the basic fact that they were innocent of “sabotage.” The record shows he had even declined to answer a question from the deliberating jury about the issue of sabotage, ordering them to follow his instructions. This trial was about what the nuns did to jeopardize national security. These were the facts:
12
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason On October 6, 2002, three nuns, dressed in hazardous waste suits bearing the legend “Citizens Weapons Inspection Team,” cut through a chain link fence at nuclear missile silo N-8 in northern Colorado. They wore the suits to mimic the UN teams who had previously scoured Iraq for weapons of mass destruction that President George W. Bush insisted were still hidden there. The trio also wore T-shirts emblazoned with the ironic words, “We found them.” Indeed they found them in the US just as, by contrast, the US failed to find any WMD in Iraq — even after waging war and turning the country inside out. The purpose of their escapade, according to the nuns, was to show Americans where the real weapons of mass destruction were hidden and from where the real threat of war by WMD emanated. Naively, they hoped their action would stop the war against Iraq that President Bush was then calling for. Of course, it did not. “When we went to this site,” says Sister Jackie Hudson, “we went to symbolically stop a crime from happening and to uphold international law.” Bush, who had earlier abrogated the 1972 disarmament treaty, claimed he was upholding international law by going to war over the same issue. By contrast, the nuns’ defense team could not even get the judge to allow a defense based on international war-conduct treaties such as the Geneva Conventions. Atop the silo concrete, designed to withstand anything but a direct hit by a nuclear bomb, the nuns rapped with household hammers on rails strong enough to handle the pounding of locomotives and missile exhaust. They left behind a rosary, symbolic of their prayers seeking divine help against the nuclear horrors poised beneath their feet. They splashed their own pre-bottled blood in the form of a cross on the silo’s 25-ton lid. They poured the blood from baby bottles, symbolic of new life. With the push of a preemptive attack button, that bloodied lid could rocket on the rails like an anchored Frisbee to clear the silo’s throat for a missile launch. Any such launch, of course, would destroy the protective perimeter fence — the same fence the breaching of which by the nuns constituted their “breach of national security.” The event was thick with such irony. The hammers used by the nuns were symbolic of the Biblical exhortation by Isaiah to beat swords of war into plowshares of peace. The blood was symbolic of the nuns’ prediction that blood was otherwise about to be spilled, and
13
WMD, Nukes and Nuns that men women and children were about to be killed in Iraq — all because of the WMD hidden in this silo. The date of October 6 was also symbolic, being the first anniversary of the US invasion of Afghanistan, an event that spilled the blood of many innocent men, women and children as “collateral damage” in the hunt for bin Laden. After cutting a hole in the silo fence, the nuns — members of the Dominican order noted for preaching — prayed and sang and waited for their inevitable arrest for trespassing. Waiting with rosaries in hand were Sisters Ardeth Platte, 66; Jackie Hudson, 68; and Carol Gilbert, 55. One of the rosaries, confiscated by the military, became an exhibit in the sabotage trial — yet another bit of irony. This was not the first confrontation the nuns had forced with the military. In the spring of 2001, all three were arrested for pouring blood and hammering on warplanes at an Air Force base in Colorado Springs during an open house. After they spent a week in jail, the charges were dismissed, ostensibly because the damage was negligible but more for public relations reasons. It wouldn’t do to treat nuns like criminals. The nuns called their incursion beyond the silo fence Sacred Earth and Space Plowshares II. All three are members, by virtue of their actions, of the anti-nuclear Plowshares movement formed in 1980 by eight peace activists, including the Berrigan brothers and Father Carl Kabat, OMI. In 2000, Kabat climbed over a silo fence in the same WMD missile field that sprawls over Colorado, Wyoming and Nebraska. The complex contains more than 120 Minuteman III missiles with triple warheads. According to Kabat, a former science teacher, each carries ten times the nuclear clout of the Hiroshima bomb. In 2001 Kabat was sentenced by Magistrate Boyd Boland to 83 days (time served). Upon his release, Kabat served an additional year in federal prison for breaking parole by leaving Illinois without permission. In all, Kabat has served more than 15 years of his life for engaging in such peaceful protests. Along with Philip Berrigan, the nuns and many others view him as a prophet and a role model, though, like Kabat, they are quick to say they are followers of Christ, first of all. Two other activists, Daniel Sicken and Oliver Coe, trespassed in 1998 at missile silo N-7, a sinister neighbor to N-8 chosen by the nuns. US District Judge Walker Miller sentenced Sicken to 41 months in prison and gave Coe 30 months.
14
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason To the attack of the nuns, armed with household tools and baby bottles, the military responded with the same reactive force that an alien enemy invasion would have met at the site. Battle-equipped troops in armored personnel carriers with machine guns locked and loaded smashed through huge stretches of the chain link fence in a choking cloud of dust. Barrels leveled point-blank, they valiantly surrounded the nation’s “dangerously irresponsible” foes. At trial, the nuns were charged and sentenced with destruction of the fence as an item of government property essential to national security, even though almost all of the fence damage was caused by the military itself. However, the main charge was obstructing national security, an offense which is found within the US Code that also covers sabotage. Under the obstruction charge, the nuns faced up to 20 years in prison. In motions to dismiss, Walter Gerash and Susan Tyburski, noted Denver defense attorneys, said that the charge was out of proportion to the actions of the defendants, as shown by testimony of military officers in charge of the silo. During the course of the trial, Gerash and Tyburski elicited testimony from the silo’s military officers that the nuns had done nothing that would have interfered with the use of the silo, even if the weapons had needed to be launched. However, utilizing the public impact of the 9/11 mass murders and the USA PATRIOT ACT that was bulldozed through Congress immediately in the wake of that disaster, District Attorney John Suthers prevailed with his contrived national security obstruction charge. Although Suthers was a Catholic, trained by nuns and educated at Notre Dame, he insisted for the record that “this case has been about…upholding the rule of law.” The judge did not allow the defense attorneys to argue that upholding the law included the obligation by the federal government to honor the treaties about the conduct of war. The argument about treaties that prohibit the use or threat of use of WMD, such as the missiles the nuns protested, was ruled out of bounds. At that time, President Bush was in the process of terminating long-established ABM (Anti-Ballistic Missile) treaties that had been ratified as being part of US law under Article VI of the Constitution and establishing the US right for pre-emptive nuclear strikes. Despite this gutting of America’s cherished rights on behalf of “the rule of law,” Suthers stated: “The defendants have demonstrated a blatant disregard for the laws of the United States. No other country on earth provides as many avenues for peaceful and lawful protest as does the United States. But the defen-
15
WMD, Nukes and Nuns dants insist on unlawfully entering onto highly sensitive government installations, damaging government property, and interfering with government operations.” He seemed thereby to shrug off the assertions by his own witnesses that no harm had been done to national security. The post-9/11 jury, left ignorant of Constitutional law by Judge Blackburn, was eager to put somebody behind bars. The jury bought his story and the nuns became the scapegoats. Using national security as a springboard, federal prosecutor Robert Brown, a disciple of Suthers, successfully made the case for sabotage and treason, and he gained a conviction. In court he praised nuclear weapons as a key deterrent in the Cold War and said they were vital to the nation’s continued defense, implying that nuclear weapons had won the Cold War for the US. The suggestion was that the nuns’ action was an attempt to sabotage such wonderful results for domestic security. No mention was allowed that those same WMD violated US law under its own treaties, or that the WMD were causing the beginning of a world war in Iraq. “It would be nice if nuclear weapons had never been invented,” Brown told the jury; “but they work.” (He was referring to the Cold War.) In other remarks he suggested the nuns should have obtained a parade permit, as if such a thing might have been granted under their right to free speech. History shows that anti-war demonstrators at the Republican convention in New York City in 2004 were arrested wholesale even though they did have legal permits. The right to exercise First Amendment freedoms was already gone. The nuns were not easily convicted, however. The jury sent out a question asking Judge Robert Blackburn whether the charge amounted to sabotage. Blackburn merely repeated his obtuse instructions, declining a direct answer to a direct question. He did not want to call it sabotage, even though the charge of obstructing national security and sabotage are both items that fall under the same title of law by which the nuns were being prosecuted. However, the media spoke and wrote of “sabotage”. When the guilty verdict came in, Blackburn was left with a sentencing dilemma. The punishment under the sabotage law was severe (up to 20 years) but the actual offense and damage done were negligible. The public flooded his office with letters calling for probation, something that by law Blackburn could not give. Local newspaper columnists and editorials called for leniency, at least.
16
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason Blackburn’s Denver courtroom and the court building’s plaza overflowed with national and international reporters and with sympathizers from around the world. None of them thought that sabotage or treason or even obstruction of national defense had been proven. Yet the jury had been swayed in that direction under the Suthers-Blackburn orchestration. Supporters of the nuns understood that they had trespassed only to prove a point about who really held weapons of mass destruction and who really was guilty of a war crime. In that sense, the nuns felt victorious. Unfortunately, not many among the general public know, even after the trial, that to possess and threaten to use weapons of mass destruction such as nuclear bombs is a crime under international law. The public knows little about the Geneva Conventions on conduct of war, and the principles declared by US Supreme Court Justice Robert Jackson at the Nuremberg trials in 1945. (Blackburn’s all-encompassing in limine rulings made sure neither the public nor the jury would be exposed to such knowledge.) When it came time for sentencing, Blackburn noted, “Whatever sentences I impose will be wrong. Some will criticize them roundly as too harsh, perhaps, and others as too lenient.” With the word “wrong” hanging on his lips, he proceeded to do what must have been, by his half-admission, wrong: he sent the nuns to federal prison. His lame lament came as a product of his own pre-trial rulings that left the three nuns with no defense at all and no way to explain their motives and action to the jury under international law. Referring to Judge Blackburn’s thirty-two-page ruling, a supporter of the nuns, Bill Sulzman, said the judge’s commentary “makes disdainful comments about the defendants, motions and actions. One is left with the conclusion after reading the full document that Judge Blackburn thinks there is no difference between a piece of pie in a military mess hall, a military sleeping bag or a nuclear bomb. All are equally legitimate ‘national defense’ materials.” Sulzman heads an international peace activist group based in Colorado Springs known as Citizens for Peace in Space. Here is what Judge Blackburn’s in limine motions ordered: 1. That defendant Jackie Hudson’s motion to dismiss due to international law preemption is denied. [She claimed that law from the Nuremberg trials of World War II, imposed by US Justice Jackson, requires citizens of any nation to resist policies and actions that are wrong, such as the building or maintaining of weapons of mass destruction.]
17
WMD, Nukes and Nuns 2. That defendant’s motion to dismiss on the grounds that the government has failed to apply or misapplied the intransgressible Laws of War that control and prohibit any threat or use of the Minuteman III at issue at N-8 (site) is denied. [This barred the use of an international law defense.] 3. [The claim] that defendant’s motion to dismiss is required because any threat or use of Minuteman III, N-8, constitutes ipso facto the most egregious crimes: i.e., crimes against peace, war crimes, crimes against humanity or genocide is denied. [This barred the defense from claiming that to threaten the use of nuclear weapons is a war crime because of their power to kill indiscriminately.] 4. That motion by defendant, Jackie Marie Hudson, to dismiss Count 1 of the indictment is denied. 5. That defendant Ardeth Platte’s motion to dismiss for reasons that defendants had a right, duty, privilege or justification to nonviolently expose, inspect and symbolically disarm a fundamentally illegal and criminal first-strike high-alert weapon of horrific mass destruction, the Minuteman III, N-8, is denied. [This bars the use of the Nuremberg Principle that a citizen must act to resist policies and orders of the state known to be immoral or criminal.] 6 & 7. That Defendant Ardeth Platte’s motion to dismiss the sabotage and depredation of property charges is denied. [The judge agrees that the proper charge is sabotage and not trespassing. He also affirms that she will be tried for actions against the national security: Judge affirms that she will be tried for actions against national security, read: sabotage.] 8. [In line with the above rulings, the judge granted the prosecution’s motions] that the government’s motion in limine to prohibit Defense of Choice of Evils, justification or international law defense, provided furthermore that without an antecedent offer of proof accepted by the Court, there will be no jury voir dire examination; there will be no opening statement; there will be no evidence; there will be no jury instructions and there will be no final argument as to any defense based on necessity or violation of international law that impugns, inter alia, the lethality, legality, morality or political wisdom of the Minuteman III missile system, including but not limited to the variously described defenses: necessity; duress; choice of evils; privilege; justification; Nuremberg; mistake of law; international law violations; jus cogens violations; peremptory norms of international law violations; war crimes violations; customary international law violations; nonderogable jus cogens norm of customary internal law violations; international law violations; US. Army field manual violations; International Court of Justice judgment violations; treaty violations; United Nations Charter violations; Vienna Convention violations; Restatement of foreign relations law violations; and, 9. That the request for the items of discovery identified by the defendants in Jackie Marie Hudson’s motion to discover and inspect under Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure (Brady, Giglio and Kyles V. Whitney) is denied.
If Judge Blackburn had any real qualms about imposing a fair sentence on the nuns, they were self-created when he crafted the above set of hanging-judge rulings. In effect, he stripped the nuns of every defense to plead their case and deprived them of a fair trial.
18
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason Their high motives were to have no mitigating influence. He tied the jury’s hands in reaching any decision except that dictated by the prosecution: that they broke a law by trespassing onto the American public’s property (which by containing WMD constituted an illicit and illegal action by the prosecuting government). The court faced a predicament with the nuns. If the judge had allowed them a fair trial, on motives that mitigated the evidence, the result would have been to indict all the world’s nuclear powers for war crimes of a WMD nature. To provide a hearing that might result in the release of such peaceful rebels could lead to the incrimination of the US federal government itself for WMD war crimes. Such a result could logically lead to calls for the US, Iraq, Israel and all the world’s nations to dismantle the WMD to which the nuns objected and which Bush banned under pain of war in Iraq. Such a judicial decision is out of the question because it strikes down national policy formulated around nuclear WMD. It is interesting to note that two years prior, in the case of Carl Kabat, another judge made similar rulings that vitiated any possible defense. In that case, prosecutor George Gill (a member of Suthers’ staff) declared that “free speech stops at the wire” (a reference to the silo fence). In a single sentence this obscure bureaucratic attorney blazed new counter-Constitutional law without benefit of Congress, and this was allowed by the judge and stamped into legal precedent by the deliberately underinformed jury. Nobody, including the media, took note; and the Republican-lobotomized American public still does not realize how it degrades their rights under the constitution. Why? In the end, the general public’s outrage over 9/11 influenced the case of the nuns. The public, grasping for culprits, was in a hanging mood and so were the federal courts. This fitted the scheme of Suthers and Brown. The nuns admitted to trespass at a WMD site but in the end, trespass was not the charge levied by the government; so the jury could not convict them of that charge. Neither could the judge — given his own adverse ruling — sentence them for trespass. Lacking that lesser and obvious charge, the jury reasoned the nuns had to be guilty of what was left on the courtroom butcher block: obstructing national security.
19
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Any scruples over the militarization of America were forgotten in the heat of the public dismay over the attacks on New York and the Pentagon by what appear to have been Muslim fanatics. In that context, there was little sympathy for the idea of US restraint, or moral responsibility. There was instead a rage and an impulse to kill everything Islamic. Meanwhile, frustration with Washington’s failure to “get” Osama bin Laden preyed on the minds of the judge and jury in the case of the nuns, because it was heavy on the minds of the general public. Blackburn handled his juridical discomfort by delivering sentences that even the defense attorneys described as “less than what they expected.” Platte got 41 months, Gilbert got 33 months, and Hudson got 30 months. (By the end of 2005, all three had been released from prison.) Suthers and Brown, who knew they had loaded the case against the nuns, seemed relieved; they had got away with a miscarriage of justice and violation of constitutional principles. Of the sentences, Brown said, “I think it was fair.” Suthers said it was “eminently fair and reasonable.” Judge Blackburn said he based the terms on a previous silo-trespass case (Sicken and Coe), taking refuge behind a 1998 precedent rather than considering the case’s own merits as they existed in 2003. In earlier and truer moments of fairness, Suthers had offered the nuns a pre-trial deal in which they would plead guilty only to damaging government property (the fence) and would be set free. The nuns had refused because they did not think they were guilty of anything except exposing the government’s own international war crime of threatening the use of WMD over the course of four decades. This ran counter to public opinion at a time when America was being told that radical Muslims had used the Koran to justify the 9/11 attack, so that all Muslims were guilty. To be confronted by nuns who did not respond to Islamic hatred for America with America’s own brand of Christian hatred was intolerable at some unspoken level of patriotism. Thus, the nuns quickly found out that America loved its own WMD but were tricked into hating the Muslims and Iraq because they supposedly were trying to gain access to equivalent technology and power. In American minds, the 9/11 catastrophe, which was in context a low-tech WMD attack, had already proved the “evil” of everything Islamic and everything that was not fundamentalist Christian. It created a “we are good and they are bad” mindset.
20
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason It is apparent from the case of the nuns that the US judicial system does not test for truth or morality; it is an adversarial contest in which someone wins and someone loses, according to the rules of the system contrived by the whims of a judge. Restrictions imposed by the court can hamper a defendant’s ability to present evidence in its favor, thus stacking the deck for the other side. That proved to be the case with the nuns. They wished only to point to America’s own WMD and invoke the judgment of the people in God’s name and for the sake of humanity’s future. They based their objections on the morality underpinning their Christian faith and Geneva Convention law. Sadly, few in the American public saw through the political propaganda that colored the courts and jury process, so very few recognized that nobler course of judgment. Suthers told the Rocky Mountain News, “When you’re looking for a stage, plea bargains don’t work very well. You have to have a trial.” Frustrated with the refusal of the nuns to take bail and to plea bargain, Suthers got revenge by convicting them with the aid of Judge Blackburn of a crime they did not commit. In 2005, Suthers departed the federal scene to become Colorado’s attorney general. For his part, Judge Blackburn delivered his sentences with a forked tongue. While calling the nuns “dangerously irresponsible,” he justified WMD and even a war based on WMD, using World War II as an example. “The Revolutionary War founded this great nation,” he said. “The Civil War ended slavery, the Second World War put an end to the despot Hitler and, arguably, the war in Iraq put an end to a brutal dictator and his regime.” His irrelevant comments were greeted by groans from the pro-nun observers in the court’s gallery. At the same time, Blackburn said the nuns deserved shorter sentences than the prosecution sought (5–8 years). He cited the fact that they did no significant damage to the silo. He also recognized they had spent their lives in “prodigious” good works and had the support of the local and even the international community. The case caught the attention of newspapers and TV nationwide and attracted some media from abroad to the Denver Federal Courthouse. On April 10, 2003, The Denver Post published the following sympathetic editorial for the record:
21
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Nuns’ Case Calls for Mercy Three Roman Catholic nuns were justifiably convicted this week of obstructing the national defense and damaging government property. But is it really necessary to imprison them for up to 30 years? That’s the maximum sentence US District Judge Robert Blackburn can issue under sentencing guidelines. He will sentence the women July 25. Certainly the US government has better uses for prison cells than housing three nuns who were seeking to make a statement about war, not terrorize their countrymen. Prison and jails are overcrowded. Stuffing the felonious nuns into a federal prison at taxpayer expense does little good. The nuns arrived at the N-8 Minuteman III missile silo last October, exactly one year after the United States and its allies launched an attack against the Taliban in Afghanistan. The date was symbolic. They cut through two gate chains and a fence to (again symbolically) tap hammers on the old railroad tracks used to transport the missile [lid]. They then sprayed their own blood in the shape of six crosses onto the 110-ton concrete silo dome. The nuns began to sing and pray, no doubt waiting for someone to show up and arrest them. After all, you can’t make a real statement these days unless you are arrested. Military personnel arrive an hour — that’s 60 minutes — after an alarm went off. (That’s one of the more troubling revelations in this case. (What if real terrorists had gained entry to the site?) The officers pointed guns at the nuns. A Humvee crashed through a fence when the women didn’t obey an officer’s orders. While the protest was symbolic, the nuns’ actions were unlawful. That’s not in dispute. “In the United States, you have the right to protest government policy in a variety of ways,” US Attorney John Suthers said after the guilty verdict was delivered by a federal jury. “But if you violate the laws, you’ll face the consequences. We will continue to prosecute all acts of civil disobedience.” As well he should. But we hope Judge Blackburn shows some leniency when sentencing the three. They’ve already served six months in jail, which one described as “sacred time, but difficult sacred time.” That should be enough. Others have been sentenced to less for doing worse. The nuns, for their part, aren’t expecting leniency. And if it’s not granted, it seems they’re comfortable with whatever final verdict they ultimately draw. “We will not be found guilty under God’s law,” Sister Carol Gilbert shouted to the jury. In a nation founded in large part on the principle of separation of church and state, no zealot is entitled to substitute her or his personal interpretation of “God’s
22
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason law,” for the rule of law is derived from elected representative bodies. But secular law, like divine law, is sometimes best tempered with mercy.
The Denver Post’s editorial was not as perceptive as it was crafted to seem. John Suthers said he would “continue to prosecute all acts of civil disobedience.” Yet he never presented the case to the court as one of civil disobedience, a misdemeanor. The editorial writer ignored that point, preferring to agree with a guilty verdict for sabotage of national security, certainly not a misdemeanor, even while calling for mercy. In sum, the Post editorial missed the point. The case of the nuns did not require mercy; it required justice in the first place, as Jim Spencer, columnist for The Denver Post, wrote on July 17, 2003, for the public record: It’s called downward departure. It’s a fancy term that means making the punishment fit the crime. Federal Judge Robert Blackburn needs to do it July 25 when he sentences three nuns convicted of protesting against nuclear weapons. In April, a jury found Sisters Ardeth Platte, Carol Gilbert and Jackie Marie Hudson guilty of obstructing national defense and damaging government property for hammering on a missile silo in northern Colorado. The nuns’ prior civil disobedience, combined with their latest convictions, puts them in the category of dangerous felons as far as federal sentencing guidelines are concerned. The guidelines call for these women, who have devoted their lives to promoting peace and nonviolence, to serve six to eight years in the penitentiary. If this constitutes homeland security in post-Sept. 11 America, the watchdog needs dentures. When they’re not protesting for peace, the nuns teach in poor neighborhoods, helping the least of us. Locking them up is like locking up Mother Teresa. It’s just wrong. So it falls to Judge Blackburn to do what’s right. He’s got the power to depart from the sentencing guidelines. To do it, a judge must decide that special circumstances exist, said Sam Kamin, an assistant professor of law at the University of Denver. “The judge basically has to say that this isn’t what Congress intended when it approved the guidelines,” Kamin explained. In the nuns’ case that statement makes John Suthers, the US attorney for the Colorado region, look brain dead. Suthers’ office plans to formally respond to the nuns’ request for downward departures today, a spokesman said. But the government’s position all along has been that these peacemakers aren’t blessed. “They have been prosecuted in the past for similar acts and sentenced to short periods of incarceration, which have not served as a deterrent,” Suthers said. Suthers apparently sees symbolic protests as security threats. He thinks taxpayers need to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars to keep the nuns off the streets. I propose that the politically posturing prosecutor write the check out of his publicly financed salary. He obviously has too little on his plate and not much more in his head.
23
WMD, Nukes and Nuns The crimes committed here involve three old women cutting through a fence and whacking a few hammer blows on a missile silo of reinforced concrete several feet thick. What happened posed no more threat to national security than refusing to recite the Pledge of Allegiance or sing The Star Spangled Banner. As for costing the government money, I’m betting Suthers put more of a hurt on the federal purse prosecuting the nuns than the nuns put on the missile silo. Platte, Gilbert and Hudson spent several months in jail awaiting trial. Time served, combined with some community service, makes sense. The nuns should be required to pay to repair the fence they cut. They might even need to pay for the time soldiers spent responding to their protest. But six to eight years in prison for Hudson, who is 68, Platte, who is 67, and Gilbert, who is 55, mocks justice. Denver University’s Kamin said that only extraordinary circumstances justify downward departures from sentencing guidelines. Devoting your life to peace in a war-torn world qualifies not only as extraordinary, but as exemplary. No matter, Kamin said, federal judges don’t like to depart from the guidelines because the decision to do so is automatically reviewable and reversible. Judges, he added, don’t like to be reversed. They ought to like turning peaceniks into prisoners even less. Federal judges — in this case Blackburn — have wide discretion to decide what factors demand departure from the guidelines. The ability to get around the sentencing guidelines exists because the folks who wrote the guidelines knew the guidelines were not one-size-fits-all. They sure don’t fit these convictions. The nuns never hurt anyone. They never will. They’re sort of like angels. If the whole world adopted their sacrifice and respect for humanity, terrorism and war would cease. So would crime. It would be heaven on earth. Unless Judge Blackburn departs from the sentencing guidelines, the United States will show its angels hell on earth. “You could make an argument that lack of discretion [in sentencing] looks ridiculous because you have people here who aren’t a threat,” Kamin said. “You could also argue that anyone who puts nuns in the pen for six years runs a kangaroo court,” Spencer concluded.
In fact, as Blackburn gaveled the sentencing trial to a close and was retreating to his chambers, cries of “kangaroo court” were heard from the gallery. In a twist of irony, just three days before the nuns were sentenced, five Russian military officers were invited to tour inside a missile silo near Chugwater, Wyoming, where they visited up close the very missiles that at one time were pointed at them. How this squares with the government’s overwrought concerns for national security in the contrasting case of the nuns is impossible to explain.
24
Chapter 2. If This Be Treason The Soviet enemies, for whom the weapons were intended, were invited to tour the heart of national security, while three non-violent citizens of America were being sentenced for cutting a fence with intentions to protect both sides from their suicidal WMD threats. Here is the story filed for the public record by Denver Post’s northern bureau reporter, Coleman Cornelius: Russians Tour Nuclear Silo with a Stoli Toast Tuesday, July 22, 2003 — Chugwater, Wyo. — Five Russian military brass climbed out of helicopters on the Wyoming prairie Monday, strode to a chain-link fence guarded by US airmen with M-16 rifles and quickly gained clearance to a nuclear-missile facility originally designed to cow them. Then, in a visit that symbolically upended residual Cold War hostilities, highranking officials with the Russian Strategic Rocket Forces toured a Peacekeeper missile silo undergoing deactivation. “It’s part of an overall process of transforming the relationship between our two countries from one of post-Cold War rivalry to one of working cooperatively,” said Brig. Gen. Frank Klotz, commander of the 20th Air Force. In the silo, about 60 miles north of Cheyenne and 60 feet underground, the Russians saw the inner workings of the United States’ most destructive nuclear missiles. This inconspicuous missile site, visited most often by cattle and antelope, holds the first of 50 Peacekeeper missiles that will be dismantled by 2005 as the two nations redesign their relationship. The missiles, each of which can carry 10 nuclear warheads, are all buried in southeastern Wyoming. Air Force leaders hosting the trip entered the US military when Russia was part of the “evil empire” and the chief reason for amassing US nuclear might, said Col. John Faulkner, group commander at F.E. Warren Air Force Base, which maintains intercontinental ballistic missiles in Colorado, Wyoming and Nebraska. But Sunday night, Air Force hosts toasted their Russian equivalents with Stolichnaya vodka during a steak dinner in Cheyenne. And Monday morning, they toured part of the US underground arsenal that more than four decades ago was designed to deter similar forces in Russia. The military leaders discussed shared concerns about terrorism, rogue nations and worldwide political instability, said Col. Kenneth Van Sickle, vice commander of the 90th Space Wing. The Russians, who did not speak to reporters, learned about the deactivation schedule for Peacekeeper missiles, which will help the United States comply with mandates of the 2002 Moscow Treaty, an arms reduction agreement signed by President Bush and Russian President Vladimir Putin. The visitors also heard about the 150 Minuteman III missiles that remain on alert under the Western prairies, and remain a concern among peace activists,
25
WMD, Nukes and Nuns including three Catholic nuns who will be sentenced in Denver on Friday for breaching a missile site. Gen. Col. Nikolay Solovtsov, commander of the Russian Strategic Rocket Forces, did not descend into the silo Monday. But he wiped the dirt-smudged nose of Airman First Class James Clouse as the young enlistee clambered up a ladder. “Son, you’re dirty. That’s good,” the Russian general told Clouse, 21. He performs missile maintenance. “I was like, yes, sir,” Clouse said later. “It was pretty cool.” On Monday night, the visiting Russians were scheduled to have another taste of the West: They were set to dine on barbecued beef, beans and coleslaw then to attend a bull-riding performance at Cheyenne Frontier Days, one of the region’s biggest and best-known rodeos. That same Monday night in their Georgetown dungeons, the three nuns who never entered a missile silo, had baloney sandwiches.
Judge Blackburn’s sentence turned out to be lenient. It was influenced perhaps by the flood of letters received. But his leniency quite likely was influenced as well by the three defense attorneys who had defended the nuns for free. Scott Poland, who was Platte’s counsel, told the Rocky Mountain News, “These are three elderly ladies — if they don’t mind my saying that — who are about as harmless as any three human beings that I could imagine.” Susan Tyburski, also on the defense team, noted that the main damage to the silo fence came from the military itself when they crashed their vehicles through it. She noted that the part which was cut by the nuns would have cost only a few dollars to repair. Walter Gerash was perhaps the most eloquent in asking Blackburn to be lenient. He cited historic protests in American history. These included the Boston Tea Party, the Underground Railroad that helped slaves escape to the North, and the feminist movements of the 20th century. Gerash noted these were all violations of unjust laws as they existed at the time. Calling the nuns “human angels,” he noted that their protests at the missile silo were in the same tradition of such historic events. “Now it’s coming out that perhaps the American people haven’t been told the whole story about the intervention in Iraq,” said Gerash, who served in World War II. In tears, he noted that “our Gis are being killed now, almost every day.” In that regard, he said the actions by the nuns at missile silo N-8 were “prophetic.”
26
CHAPTER 3. ANOTHER LIE, ANOTHER WAR, ANOTHER PROTEST In the long view, what transpired in Blackburn’s court in 2003 was based on a chain of lies from the White House that originated in the struggle for absolute military supremacy. In today’s context that means the goal of being the sole power having access to WMD. Blackburn himself presumably had no specific knowledge of the lies or their indirect connection to the nuns, because he had blinded the court to those issues. What was the fundamental lie? It consisted of 16 words buried in State of the Union Speech delivered by President George W. Bush in January 2003 to the US Congress: “The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa.” The lie couched in those fatalistic words, planted by Vice President Dick Cheney, is manifold in its origins and impact: 1) The British intelligence was based on documents passed along by the Italian Intelligence Service that Cheney by then knew were forged. 2) Cheney ignored a report given to the CIA and State Department by Joseph Wilson the previous year, debunking the Italian memo about the purchase of uranium from Niger, because it didn’t support the Bush administration’s excuse for invading Iraq. Wilson says he undertook his special CIA investigative mission about Iraq’s WMD threat at the request of Cheney, channeled through the CIA. 3) That the Cheney-Bush lie about Iraq’s WMD capability was deliberate is proven by the fact that columnist Robert Novak in his article “Mission to
27
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Niger” (July 14, 2003) described the Italian documents as forged. Obviously, that piece of information was leaked by the White House to Novak. At the same time, the White House also leaked to Novak that Valerie Plame, the wife of Joe Wilson, was a CIA “agency operative” on weapons of mass destruction. 4) The leak to Novak was motivated by the need for the Bush administration to justify its invasion of Iraq. If Novak was told all of these things, then his arm’s-length source, Cheney, knew them too — long before he fed the president the WMD lie to use in his speech. The convenient source to use was British intelligence. Bush can deny that he was aware of the deception, of course. And while Cheney’s aide Lewis “Scooter” Libby was indicted for lying about the deception, no determination in that regard was made about Cheney himself. But, of course, Lewis could not have been apprised of such vitally important facts without Cheney (and Bush) being apprised of them, too. Congress gave the Administration approval to declare war only because Cheney’s office manipulated them by planting this deception in the president’s speech. The nuns, of course, heard those words. They knew of America’s decadeold program through the United Nations to extirpate WMD from Iraq’s territory. They also knew that the kinds of WMD which were the target of Bush’s verbal war were held in abundance by Bush himself in places such as the prairies of Colorado. They reasoned that if it was wrong for Saddam Hussein to have them, it was wrong for Bush to have them; and they wanted the public to understand that point before the nation went to war. For calling attention to the contradiction, the nuns were imprisoned as traitors and the nation proceeded to invade Iraq. The nuns operate with slogans as basic as “Thou Shalt Not Kill.” However, their prison terms have robbed them of precious time in their lives to make the rest of society and its leaders understand and live up to such a simple, ancient moral imperative. They tried, in a peaceful way, to impeach the American public and found it to be as immune to moral precepts and as unimpeachable as the White House is for high crimes and misdemeanors. In December of 2005, Dominican Sister Ardeth Platte was freed from federal prison after serving 41 months in the slammer. Her compatriots in crime, Sister Jackie Hudson and Sister Carol Gilbert, were released earlier. The federal
28
Chapter 3. Another Lie, Another War, Another Protest government took away several years of their lives for trying to prevent the very war catastrophe that has befallen the United States since they went to jail. Basically, the nuns were convicted under the USA PATRIOT Act (Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism” Act (of 2001). As President Nixon said many years ago in the Watergate crisis before he resigned, “mistakes were made.” His statement was, as history shows, the closest Nixon could bring himself to apologize to the electorate that sought to impeach him for a lie about how he tried to manipulate his election. Later, that same American public sought to impeach William Clinton for a lie about his personal morals. He, too, apologized, and perhaps more straightforwardly than Nixon. There is no sign that the public can expect any admission by the Bush administration regarding what lies they have told to the world. These events are but didactic preludes to the conviction of the nuns as felons for telling the truth about WMD. However, the nuns expect no apology from the unimpeachable American public for false imprisonment, because there has been no apology from its leaders. At the same time, whatever crimes against humanity Saddam Hussein may be charged with, they do not include possession of WMD. The American public, which persistently falls for Washington’s lies, waged war against Saddam and the nation of Iraq under pretenses falsified by their own leaders. And they persisted in killing Iraqis and in sacrificing their own sons and daughters in an unjust conflict even after they belatedly found out they had been deceived. Finally, in October of 2005, Saddam Hussein was brought to trial in Iraq for using WMD weapons and technology provided years prior by George Herbert Walker Bush (when he was CIA chief and later vice president and then president). Until 1990, Saddam was considered a CIA asset in the Middle East, and the elder Bush was all too eager to use Saddam to take revenge on the Iranians for their earlier Tehran hostage-taking. As the record shows: — Hussein used chemical WMD and other technology that had been provided by the CIA in attacks against Iraq’s Kurdish citizens after they attempted to assassinate him. The technology came from Bush-controlled private companies.
29
WMD, Nukes and Nuns — America bombed thousands of Iraqi men, women and children throughout all the years between Operation Desert Storm and the war waged by Bush Jr. Daily bombing runs were made in the so-called “No Fly Zone.” Iraq’s own air force was not allowed to operate in its sovereign air space. — The bombing was carried out by both Bush administrations, and the interim Clinton presidency, under the presumed auspices of various resolutions force-fed to the UN by the US. Most foreign nations felt the US took military air actions which exceeded both the spirit and intent of the “No Fly” sanctions. — In addition, the US bullied the UN into prohibiting Iraq from providing for its people by selling its oil on the open market. This was a US-inspired effort to starve the Saddam-controlled economy and thereby force Saddam Hussein to surrender the weapons of mass destruction. These WMD included SCUD and other missile delivery systems under the nuclear, chemical or biological WMD classification. As a result of the oil embargo, thousands of men, women and children were left with no food and no medicine. Enter the UN, trying to soften the inhumanity of its US-inspired sanctions. — The UN organized the “Oil-for-Food” program so that Iraq could sell enough oil to at least feed its people and provide health care under the pains of the embargo. That program was quickly corrupted by European and American companies seeking to make illicit profits through kickback schemes that included Saddam Hussein himself. Some of those companies were controlled by Bush family interests. (See chapters 17 and 21.) — While the US was bombing Iraq, Hussein finally agreed to allow UN inspection teams into Iraq to look for and destroy WMD. They did so for several years, until Saddam kicked them out in 1994. While they found and destroyed a few items of minor consequence, nobody was sure whether all the nascent WMD capabilities were gone. After all, you cannot prove a negative. — The doubt stemmed from the fact that the 12,000-page report (which Hussein provided to the UN concerning the nations and companies and agencies that had provided his WMD technology) was redacted to eliminate the names and sources of that technology. Further, it was unknown whether Hussein had other unexpurgated documents that might connect the White House to the source of the WMD technologies being cited as the reason for going to war. — Worse than two Bush administrations hiding corporate connections to WMD technology in Iraq, is the more recent leakage of nuclear technology to third-world nations such as Pakistan. This amounts to a kind of behind-the-
30
Chapter 3. Another Lie, Another War, Another Protest scenes swap of nuclear bomb trigger technology for political allegiance as a means of conducting the Afghan and Iraq wars. (See Chapter 20.) In America, apparently, it is morally acceptable to build and possess WMD, but that same privilege is not acceptable for anyone but very close allies. Consider this report from the New York Times of September 14, 2005: On the verge of America’s invasion of Iraq, four left-wing activists went into the vestibule of their suburban Army recruiting center [this was in Ithaca, New York, where Cornell University is located] and poured vials of their blood, about four ounces each, onto the walls, windows and an American flag. In an unusual move, the protesters are now facing federal prosecution and harsher penalties after a jury deadlocked in state court. The group, which calls itself the St. Patrick’s Day Four because the protest took place on St. Patrick’s Day in 2003, faces charges including damaging government property and conspiracy to impede an officer of the United States. Their (second) trial is to begin Monday in federal court in Binghamton. The case did not automatically end up in federal court. The protesters were first charged with felony criminal mischief in Tompkins County, which includes Ithaca, the place where the protest took place. The district attorney there, George M. Dentes, offered a plea bargain under which members of the group would receive no jail time if they pleaded guilty to reduced charges. The protesters — Daniel J. Burns, 45; Clare T. Grady, 46; her sister, Teresa B. Grady, 40; and Peter J. DeMott, 58 — refused. “It’s a clear attempt to raise the stakes for those contemplating civil disobedience around the country,” said William P. Quigley, a law professor at Loyola University. He is a friend of the defendants and their legal adviser.
The case of the St. Patrick’s Day Four, tried in a county court on rather trivial charges, ended in a hung jury. This is interesting because it shows that when such trials are brought to the grassroots level and all the issues are explained to the jury, there is much more reluctance to convict people for acting on the basis of conscience and morality. In one word, there is justice. Like the St. Patrick’s Day Four, the three nuns in Denver were offered a plea bargain that would have spared them federal jail time, but they refused on moral principle. In their case, the charges were subsequently overblown to the status of national sabotage. Lies from Washington to mislead the public have been abundantly documented: After JFK’s assassination, President Johnson lied to America and got his declaration of war against communist North Vietnam from Congress. LBJ died before the truth about the Tonkin Gulf manipulations and America’s own provocative actions under Operation 34-A became known. However, even before
31
WMD, Nukes and Nuns LBJ’s lie was exposed, its effects unleashed a draft-card-burning revolution on campuses nationwide that contributed to ending the war, although Nixon never ceded that point even as he resigned from office. Somehow America, as unrepentant followers of Nixon, forgave itself and the world moved on to another generation willing to swallow the incredible proposition of the continued need for war — this one illegal and secretive, but just as deadly. America went through Iran-Contra and the Reagan-esque lie: the president claimed not to know that laws, passed specifically to stem his unilateral war-making powers, were being broken by executive-appointed agents (e.g., Lt. Col. Oliver North) in the basement of his own residence, the White House. Flip another page of war history and we have President George W. Bush lying about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction to get Congressional approval for going to war with Iraq under the War Powers Act. It wasn’t long before the lie about WMD, made by Bush in his State of the Union message to Congress in 2003, became apparent. However, until the lie was exposed, the public’s protests against the war were mild. The 9/11 tragedy was used to sway the nation as a whole to throw all its emotional energy into the rush for revenge and an outpouring of defensive rhetoric, easily mistaken for patriotism. John Negroponte, then ambassador to the UN and later to Iraq, confirmed that there were WMD in Iraq. (In February 2005 he was named the first director of US national intelligence.) Apparently, he was either mistaken or he lied. There was an insider backlash against the Iraq invasion: These included Joseph Wilson, former ambassador to Iraq; Paul O’Neill, Treasury Secretary; and Richard Clarke, National Security Advisor. But overall the conservative reaction to the truth was one of denial and hostility. To the dismay of the nuns, both the US (headed by a president who calls himself a Christian) and the Muslim side (proclaiming Allah’s power) continue to operate on lies that stimulate fear, hatred, and violence. Yet, who can accept that the God of either religion blesses WMD or the killing of noncombatants for secular purpose and political and economic power? As the nuns see it, by public acceptance Bush’s lies become the lies of the entire American public. His misdeeds are stamped, like his silo bombs, “made in U.S.A,” and so is every campaign and every death in his war.
32
CHAPTER 4. A QUESTION OF VALUES: WHY ARE THE NUNS IN JAIL? Why were the nuns jailed? Why is the world at war? Successful democratic government is the process of keeping the voting public confused about the truth and then getting them to blame your opponents. These two questions explore the definitions of morality and patriotism, and the struggle between the two, in the context of two divergent cultures. Those too lazy to think it through over-simplify that contest between two cultures and economies and call it mutual hatred. Today the stakes of the contest are higher than ever, mixed with the economics of oil, political dominance and corrosion of Islamic and Western culture by an America driven by its own short-term interests and a superficial Christian re-enactment of the Crusades. Many verses of the Koran, and many verses of the Bible, can be cited to support each religion’s notion of peace and justice. Many more verses conveniently support the use of sword and scimitar in the name of the Divine. That is always the problem when church and state lie in bed together. Whether we consider that the conflict started with the European conquest of the Holy Land, or the Muslim conquest of Constantinople, the task before humanity now is when, and how, it can be brought to a lasting conclusion. The three nuns, who impute a kind and forgiving God to every religion, are guilty of getting in the way of a historic political and economic power struggle in which religious sentiment is stirred up to silence critics by fomenting patriotic
33
WMD, Nukes and Nuns passions. They are guilty of trying to change the course of history in a way that would allow for a kinder, gentler future. They were imprisoned for exposing hypocrisy and crimes. They are guilty of waging peace without weapons, of trying to supplant WMD with reason. Within a few months of America’s declared war victory in Iraq, even the media “embedded” with the US military in Iraq began to catch on to the big lie. Saddam had no weapons of mass destruction to be removed. The prime reason that had been offered for going to war turned out to be false. Furthermore, if George W. Bush actually had feared that there were such WMD, it is because companies with which he and his father were associated had sent the technology to Iraq many years prior. In essence, the lie was a cover up to mask his own complicity in a crime that he placed at Saddam’s doorstep. The US had invented WMD in the first place, nuclear, chemical and biological, had huge stockpiles of them, and even had them ready for instant preemptive use. So much for the Geneva Conventions. The nuns’ value system simply held that nobody should have or want WMD. All policies of church and state that take human life are immoral, because murder on any scale and for whatever reason, including “security,” is wrong. On this score, the nuns have the strongest of moral allies in Pope John Paul II, who once said in a homily: “to kill in the name of God is blasphemy.” They also knew that to use 9/11 to corral public support for a war with a nation that was not part of that atrocity, like Iraq, only compounded that horrid immorality. The nuns would seem to have former President Jimmy Carter on their side. Carter expressed his thoughts in a CBS interview in November 2005, when he said the Iraq war represents a significant departure from previous moral values in America. Carter spoke with Early Show’s co-anchor, Rene Syler, on the occasion of the publication of his latest book, Our Endangered Moral Values. (Many of Carter’s points corroborate those made in Prophets Without Honor: a Requiem for Moral Patriotism, by William M. Strabala and Michael Palecek, Algora, 2002). In part, Carter told Syler: “We need to understand what this administration has done; why we went to war in Iraq when obviously all the reasons they gave were false; and let the people understand: Was it a deliberate distortion of the facts as they knew them? Or were they mistakes made honestly? Who was culpable, if anyone? Going into Iraq was ill-advised and unjust and unnecessary.”
34
Chapter 4. A Question of Values: Why Are the Nuns in Jail? Carter believes the decision to go into Iraq was made long before the 9/11 mass murders. He said: “I think it was made long before President Bush was elected president. [The fact that] the people who believed that America should be the dominant force in the world — unilaterally, acting militarily if necessary —is another basic change in the principles that have always guided our country and made us great. “So going to war without our country being directly threatened is a new policy that’s radically changed the basic moral values and ethical standards of the United States of America,” Carter concludes. Bush maintains that he is so Christian that he gets his Christo-centric political messages directly from God, and thereby justifies his righteousness in the matter of the Iraq war. Bush’s spiritual channel is reported by Rupert Cornwell, Washington correspondent for Britain’s The Independent. In his article of October 7, 2005, Cornwell claims that Bush privately confided his divine mission at his first meeting with Palestinian leaders in June 2003. Cornwell bases his claim on advance knowledge about a BBC series that was to be broadcast in October of 2005. That series would have substantiated the Bush claim to having received divine messages. However, the BBC’s independent stance has been under pressure in recent years, especially in regard to reports on the Middle East, and the broadcast was canceled (despite the fact the BBC had issued a press release on October 6 announcing the “major three-part” series which was to start on October 7). The series had the title, Israel and the Arabs: Elusive Peace. The nub of the revelatory series was to be this: Palestinian Minister Nabil Shaath after a meeting in June 2003 said Bush had told him and others in the delegation that God had given him (Bush) “a mission” to invade Iraq and Afghanistan as well as the task of creating a Palestinian state.” If the program had aired, it would have included the Bush comments as quoted by Minister Abu Mazan, “I have a moral and religious obligation. So I will get you a Palestinian state.” (That quote comes by way of an article in the Media Guardian by Tara Conlan.) The White House, through its official spokesman Scott McClellan, said the President had “never made such comments.” He acknowledged, however, that he had not been present at the June 2003 meeting in question. Subsequently BBC said, “The denial by the White House put some program editors off. It probably played a big part in some of the decisions not to run the story.”
35
WMD, Nukes and Nuns US journalist Bob Woodward was not as timid. In his book about Bush and the Iraq war, Plan of Attack, which was approved in manuscript form by the White House before publication, Woodward asked Bush if he ever sought political advice from his presidential father. Bush responded by saying he got his advice from his “heavenly father.” Whether or not this was a ploy designed to pander to the Christian Right, it suggests that, in Bush’s megalomania, he believes it was God who told him to invade Iraq. In fact, as documented by Frontline in a broadcast January 11, 2006, Bush claims to have received a divine mission while he was governor of Texas — after he had “accepted Jesus” in order to overcome his alcoholism. On that program Bush held up his “handbook” on how government should be run: a Bible. He also said, “I believe that God wants me to be president.” “We serve one greater than us.” “Our rights are derived from God.” “I support faithbased programs.” Of course, this fits in with the biblical passage of Romans 13 that suggests God creates governments to punish evil (it stops short of saying that Bush gets to judge who is evil). Bush claims to be carrying out God’s will. These example show that there exists in the White House an unholy cocktail of religious, political and military policies which embody the unconstitutional danger of commingling religious and secular powers in one deceptive executive. Here is yet another example from the religious side of the equation: On October 17, 2005, Robert C. Morlino, Bishop of the Catholic diocese of Madison, Wisconsin, was appointed by the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of the US Army to the Board of Visitors of the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation (WHINSEC). WHINSEC was formerly known as SOA (the School of the Americas), the CIA-inspired agency that trained the “Death Squads” responsible for the killing of nuns, priests, and many others in Central America during the Iran-Contra scandal, for example. WHINSEC still trains South American teams at Fort Benning in tactics similar to those used to assassinate Archbishop Oscar Romero in El Salvador. For his part, Bishop Morlino said of his appointment, “I am enthusiastic about the opportunity to support our military and our brothers and sisters, neighbors in the Western Hemisphere, by standing up for the truth about morality and justice.”
36
Chapter 4. A Question of Values: Why Are the Nuns in Jail? As an officer of both church and state, Morlino seems to sanctify and forgive the war- making that has made the US a political leper. At the same time, by ignoring the need for protest, he appears to condemn the moral stand of three nuns who have a teaching role that is as legitimate and historic within the church as Morlino’s. It took the revelation of sexually shocking conduct by US military personnel at Abu Ghraib to awaken the conscience of Americans back home. But, how is it that the abuse of POWs rouses disgust and protest, while the ongoing destruction and the slaughter of combatants (and unarmed civilians) seeking to throw out an occupying force raises no scruples? President Bush went to great lengths to explain that the nude display of prisoners is contrary to American values, without reference to the fact that he had been trying to kill them, fully clothed, before they were captured. What is the moral position of America in regard to Iraq? Is it more humane to kill or maim people than to take pictures of their genitalia? Is such action more degrading of human values than murder by war? There are Muslims who have also dragged naked through their streets the remains of non-combatant Americans and displayed them hanged and rotting from a bridge; but it is the US that invaded their country, not the other way around. How can a president say he is sorry about such treatment of Iraqi prisoners in the wake of a war that he declared and that causes such atrocities and counter-atrocities? Both sides, the nuns might say, need to get back to the morality of their religions and then reflect it in their politics. Until the Abu Ghraib scandal, the US media published or aired little that would throw question on the validity of the war. The media salved its conscience by merely displaying the Abu Ghraib photos; and the White House and the Pentagon were satisfied, too, to convict two non-coms and let the matter fade. In the end, it does not matter whether Bush knew there were no weapons of mass destruction left in Iraq. It does not matter whether there was good or bad “intelligence” on the WMD matter. Like his father before him, Bush went to war because the power of oil in the Middle East, on which America depended, was in the balance, and any rationale was good enough, especially if it seemed Christian in origin. Quite separate from the declaration of support for the war that Bush extracted from the Congress, which he deceived, the decision for war was made in July 2002. This is clear from the revelation of the “smoking gun” memo attributed Britain’s M16 director, Richard B. Dearlove, nine months before G.W.
37
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Bush invaded Iraq. This was about the time the nuns were planning their “invasion” of the Colorado missile silo. The Dearlove memo describes a meeting between British Prime Minister Tony Blair and President G.W. Bush: There was a perceptible shift in attitude. Military action was now seen as inevitable. Bush wanted to remove [Saddam] through military action, justified by the conjunction of terrorism and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the policy. The NSC [National Security Council] had no patience with the UN route, and no enthusiasm for publishing material on the Iraqi regime’s record. There was little discussion in Washington of the aftermath after military action. It seemed clear that Bush had made up his mind to take military action even if the timing was not yet decided. But the case was thin. Saddam was not threatening neighbors, and his WMD capability was less than that of Libya, North Korea or Iran. We should work up a plan for an ultimatum to Saddam to allow back in the UN weapons inspectors. This would also help with the justification for force. The Attorney General said that the desire for regime change was not a legal base for military action. There were three possible legal bases: self defense, humanitarian intervention or UNSC authorization.
This memo proves that it didn’t matter to Bush whether or not Saddam still had WMD after the UN inspections. It did not matter whether his defecting aides knew the policy trumped the intelligence. All that mattered was that WMD and 9/11 would be a sufficient excuse to get the war started; and anything that contradicted that policy should be discredited. Bush’s right-hand man Cheney took care of those tactics. Meanwhile the nuns, operating on the basis of longstanding facts and not inside information about a war that was secretly gestating in Washington, were inspired to take actions that easily could be construed as unpatriotic and made to look like sabotage when the events of 9/11 had been distorted to smear Iraq and foment popular support for the idea of going to war. It did not matter that the nuns took their action before the Iraq war started. It was inevitable that this, or something like it, was coming. What did matter is that the nuns took action after the USA PATRIOT Act had been passed in the heat of passion over the World Trade Center, and the mood of the country was one of fear and vengeance. As Al Franken noted in his book The Truth, Bush won reelection by use of fear about another 9/11 attack. Rather than worrying about lies from the White House, the public was expected to worry about nuns who pointed out embarrassing aspects of US conduct based on that fear. Sojourners Magazine in its 2002 November-December issue interviewed two former CIA analysts about Bush’s WMD lie. Here is a transcript of portions of
38
Chapter 4. A Question of Values: Why Are the Nuns in Jail? that interview with Ray McGovern and David MacMichael by Rose Marie Berger and Jim Rice: Sojourners: In the build-up toward the war in Iraq, the Bush administration made allegations that are proving more and more to be demonstrably false. Were they just misunderstandings of intelligence data, or were we being sold a bill of goods? Was it an honest mistake? CIA (McGovern): No, by no stretch of the imagination was it an honest mistake. We were able to tell very early last fall that there was very little substance to the main charges with respect to weapons of mass destruction…. There was little possibility of substantiating Dick Cheney’s claim that Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program. That, of course, is the mushroom cloud that scared Congress into ceding its power to wage war. Sojourners: Why is that significant? CIA (McGovern): In my experience — and that includes more than 40 years in this town watching these kinds of things very closely — it’s the first time that I’ve seen such a long-term, orchestrated plan of deception by which one branch of government deliberately misled the other on a matter of war and peace. There have been a lot of indignities over the years, but here was a very calculated plan, proceeding from a “Mein Kampf” type of document. The first objective was to deceive Congress into approving the plans. They succeeded masterfully. They had their war, and they thought that in the wake of the war, with Iraqis opening their arms to us, that no one would really care whether there were, in fact, weapons of mass destruction. They were absolutely quite wrong on that. People do care, as one by one our servicemen and women are killed in a war fought on false pretenses. CIA (MacMichael): The use of deception to frighten Congress and secure its consent for the October resolution reflects the way our government has been functioning in the area of war and peace for more than half a century. Congress has effectively resigned its power in these areas to the Executive. This has been done over and over again, most notably in the case of Vietnam, of course, and the response of Congress has been nearly always to pass what is, by my definition, a plainly unconstitutional act, the War Powers Act. It’s not so much necessary to frighten or convince Congress, because Congress doesn’t work that way. It is necessary to confuse and gain public acceptance for this. Sojourners: There is legal, constitutional, and, I’m sure, moral difference between intentionally misleading the public in the State of the Union address and intentionally deceiving Congress over matters of war. Do you think those deceptions amount to high crimes and misdemeanors? CIA (MacMichael): It’s rather more serious than misleading about dalliances with interns. CIA (McGovern): I have lost a whole bevy of progressive liberal friends by being strongly in favor of the impeachment of Bill Clinton. I was of that mind because he lied under oath. That’s enough for me. When a president of the United States lies under oath, he should be impeached, in my view.
39
WMD, Nukes and Nuns One of the key aspects of this whole situation is that we have a domesticated press. The press is not where it should be, and even though they don’t like to be lied to, the proof will be whether the press will press this case with respect to weapons of mass destruction, deceiving us into war. Sojourners: Let’s get to the issue of credibility. National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice, for example, and Vice President Cheney — claim to have no culpability, no knowledge of the fact that the allegations about Iraqi weapons of mass destruction were thoroughly discredited before they were made public. Are they telling the truth? CIA McGovern: In the course of all this controversy, it [WMD] became something of a red herring, because the information not only was forged, but it was substantively implausible on its face. Namely, Iraq had no need for more yellow cake uranium from anywhere, and Niger, the country in Africa from which it was [supposedly] sought, could not possibly supply Iraq with this uranium. Why? Because it [Niger] doesn’t control it [the uranium]. It’s controlled by an international consortium run by the French. And every ounce of that uranium is accounted for. [This squares with the report made by Joe Wilson.] I go back to Yul Brynner’s famous line in The King and I — “It’s a false lie.” How did they handle this false lie? They handled it by deflecting attention from the fact that the real sin with this false lie was committed back in September and early October of 2002, when that false lie was [knowingly] used as the most persuasive evidence that Saddam Hussein was about to get nuclear weapons in his hands. It was a PR masterpiece. That was where the damage was done. That’s where the constitutional crisis comes in. With respect to the sixteen words in the State of the Union, Condoleezza Rice said, “I told my people, if they want an authoritative statement about Iraq and nuclear weapons they have to go to the most authoritative assessment available.” What she was saying was, “Use the National Intelligence Estimate.” In this case, the supreme irony is that the NIE had already been cooked to the recipe of Dick Cheney’s speech on August 26 of 2002, in which he claimed that Iraq was already embarked on a new reconstitution program for its nuclear weapons. Why did the Director of Central Intelligence permit spurious information about this alleged attempt by Iraq to seek uranium in Niger, why did he let it get into the estimate, his most authoritative product to the president? He allowed it, under great pressure from Dick Cheney and from others, to creep into the estimate. The estimate, of course, is what they used as the basis to brief Congress in the crucial weeks before the vote on October 11 to give the president permission to wage war. Sojourners: In sum, the intelligence was being used to support policy, not to shape it? CIA McGovern: That’s correct. That’s the unpardonable sin for an intelligence analyst. That is a violation of our ethic. It’s a violation of honesty, and it’s a violation of the orderly process of government.
The above assessment by the CIA confirming that Bush’s team intended to go to war with Iraq even before the Dearlove memo justifies the concomitant
40
Chapter 4. A Question of Values: Why Are the Nuns in Jail? protest actions taken by the nuns and all of those imprisoned for similar actions — regardless of whether they knew about specific impeachable crimes. The Sojourners piece confirms similar contentions made by Ambassador Wilson, journalist Bob Woodward, security Chief O’Neill and the Pentagon’s Clarke in their books. It even confirms (on a more modern footing) the rulings by US Justice Robert H. Jackson, who headed the Nuremberg Trials in 1945, the issue of what is or is not a war crime, and how the body republic, in addition to its leaders, is to be held responsible. Under Principle One of Nuremberg, which became the law of the land by treaty, even in the US: “Any person who commits an act which constitutes a crime under international law is responsible therefor and liable to punishment.” In addition, Nuremberg’s Principle Seven states: “Complicity in the commission of a crime against peace, a war crime, or a crime against humanity as set forth in Principle Six is a crime under international law.” Possessing and threatening the use of weapons of mass destruction are among the war crimes listed under Principle Six of that law. (See Appendix B.) When they conducted a citizens’ inspection of Missile Silo N-8, the three nuns, therefore, were simply carrying out their responsibility under the Nuremberg law, and alerting their fellow Americans that they collectively could be considered guilty of a war crime if they did not protest the US WMD. To avoid convicting by inference the federal government of breaking its own laws, federal judges such as Blackburn, in the case of the nuns, have consistently excluded from consideration by juries all motives of the accused based on such Nuremberg Principles — even though those principles are linked to the long-recognized Geneva Convention treaties that address the topic of indiscriminate killing by WMD such as poison gas. (Nuclear weapons in addition to indiscriminate killing by massive blast give off highly poisonous and long-lasting gases such as radon.) The judges avoid the hard decision by saying, in effect, that international law does not apply to cases such as the nuns’. Their conclusion flies in the face of the Article VI of the US Constitution, which states: “This Constitution and the laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof and all treaties made or which shall be made under the authority of the United States shall be the supreme law of the land and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the Constitution or laws of any state to the contrary nothwithstanding.”
41
WMD, Nukes and Nuns The judges appointed by the federal system consistently have been sidestepped and violated this part of the constitution by their in limine rulings, just as Blackburn did in the case of the nuns. Why? If the judges did not divorce treaties and international law from contravening domestic laws, they would jeopardize the entire US military system, which relies on nuclear WMD to (supposedly) protect the security of America and thus assures America of its political and economic predominance in the world. That’s why judges also are forced to find reasons for excluding the right of defendants to plead for a fair trial on the basis of conscience and high motive. It is at this point that the legal hair splitting begins. There is in law a Latin creature known as mens rea, translated as “the mind of the thing.” Under this concept, judges and prosecutors can construe that cutting through a fence and pouring blood on concrete and iron contain in their essence something as awful as treason and sabotage that go beyond simple moral motive. To reach this conclusion, all other motives and all other supporting law must be discarded. In any game of cards, this is called stacking the deck, or cheating. Cheating in court or by the court is a crime unto itself, but as often-convicted protester Kabat says, “It’s not real. It’s theater.” That’s why he and the nuns and others like them feel compelled to stage a bit of their own kind of theater. President John Quincy Adams gave a prophetic speech at the July 4 Independence Day celebration of 1821, when he said: “The true American goes not abroad in search of monsters to destroy. America well knows that by once enlisting under other banners than her own, were they even the banners of foreign independence, she would involve herself, beyond the power of extrication, in all wars of interest and intrigue, of individual avarice, envy and ambition. [Though] she might become the dictatress of the world, she would no longer be the ruler of her own spirit.”
42
CHAPTER 5. RENDERING UNTO CAESAR, OR BEING RENDERED?
The three religious women sentenced today acted symbolically in their missile silo protest and did no serious damage. I’m disappointed that the sentences handed down this afternoon were not equally restrained and symbolic.
Those were the effete and belated words of Denver’s Catholic Archbishop Charles Chaput on the only occasion when he took public note of the nuns’ action. He uttered these words only in response to queries from the Denver press. All the while the three nuns were in the Georgetown jail, 30 miles from his palatial residence, Chaput never visited them or wrote letters of support or preached from his Immaculate Conception Cathedral pulpit to the conservative war-loving Catholic faithful about Christ’s mission of peace that the nuns exemplified. Chaput blithely skipped over the central issue that the nuns were raising, that of the moral issues inherent in the war over WMD. Later, as the nuns saw day after day of their lives wasted in jail, Chaput made headlines by proclaiming that it was sinful for Catholics to vote for politicians such as Sen. Kerry who supported a woman’s right to abort unwanted fetuses. That instruction grossly crossed the line between his church authority and interference in an election. Where did this sudden dogma come from, just prior to Bush’s re-election? Matthew Fox, a Dominican priest banished from the church at the instigation of Germany’s Cardinal Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, knows the answer. As he related on a recorded message to a gathering of Catholic activists in July 2005, Fox says the directive came from the Pope himself after Bush visited the Vatican
43
WMD, Nukes and Nuns and complained in private audience that America’s Catholics were not following the Church’s dogma on abortion. Shortly after Bush’s visit to the Vatican and before the US election, Fox says, all the bishops in the US received a papal instruction from Ratzinger that they should inform the parish priests of a policy to refuse communion to all Catholic candidates who were “pro-choice.” That, of course, described presidential candidate John Kerry. Of course, it also violates the spirit behind the notion of separation of church and state. Fox goes on to say that Catholics in the “close” states of Ohio, Michigan and Iowa subsequently voted in numbers never before seen for Republican candidates. In other words, the Vatican through Ratzinger forced compliant bishops such as Chaput to interfere in the election process in an unprecedented fashion. It made Bush who, for most of his life was an indifferent Christian, seem to be as Catholic as the Pope. This manipulation of the vote in states where the candidates were nearly tied (via a papal memorandum from an “inquisitorial” pope) may be said to have changed history and caused the death of hundreds of thousands by way of war. Bush’s hypocrisy is reflected in the prism of the war in Iraq: life is sacred while in the womb, but not once the baby’s hands were large enough to fire a gun. According to him, killing unformed babies is sinful but killing fully-formed, grown-up babies is not, especially if they are Muslim. In fact, Texas has a record of executions of criminals that is one of the highest in the nation. When Bush was governor, 131 convicts were put to death without compunction. Since he has been president, more than 3,000 Americans have been killed in the war with Iraq, not to mention tens of thousands of Iraqi men women and children. From his Manhattan apartment, the octogenarian rebel Rev. Daniel Berrigan refuses to let America’s bishops check-and-raise, as if state-sanctioned death and WMD were a game of poker. He wrote a pungent bit of poetry entitled The Catholic Bishops Approve Bush’s War. It read: Lest I merge with mountains that surely will fall, their decrepitude my own; Lest I walk shod in blood of Abel, crying from the earth:
44
Chapter 5. Rendering unto Caesar, or Being Rendered? “My tantamount, my brother, my undoer” Lest I the Christ disavow, and Him who shackled there I drag through sludge of cowardice and dismay; Lest weighed, I be found wanting, no guest of heaven, a ghost, and no egress from foolish trumpery of time; Lest I disappear, down, down the 110th escalation of pride, and truncated, eyeless, soulless, be found unfit for armed might, for rubble and America; Lest I be sifted like wheat or chaff and under a pall (the appalling flag) am borne away piecemeal to broken doorways of shoal or limbo, the divergencies not large, nor mine to choose; Lest I…
The poem ends as if cut short in Berrigan’s soul like the lives lost at the World Trade Center and in the insane war that followed. As Berrigan was pointing out, the Catholic Church by its silence with regard to war protests took the same dubious “neutral” stance that it had adopted over the years in the dozens of cases when clerics were punished by the courts for nonviolent civil disobedience for the sake of peace. Even now the
45
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Church is taking the same neutered stance that the Vatican took in World War II in the case of Hitler, protecting its own institutional assets. Today, as the millennium churns in blood, the nuns, like the Berrigans and dozens of their oft-jailed associates, have been left to practice what the church preached and are left to be punished for their actions by the Pilate-like courts. Berrigan’s closing words, “Lest I…” suggest how wrong it is that WMD should remain the centerpiece of US policy worldwide. They suggest how warped is the morality of bishops such as Chaput, who thinks it heroic to save life in the womb so that it may be destroyed in the baptism of war. The importance of individual morality is countered by the moral dereliction of the church’s leaders in favor of the political correctness of war. Both cannot be correct nor can they be reconciled in any sense. Although their Dominican superiors still hold the three nuns in good standing with the Catholic Church community and even praised their actions, no one from the male church officialdom in the US offered to provide legal defense or bothered to attend the trial of the nuns. In fact, Chicago’s Francis Cardinal George had the opportunity to create at least a “teaching moment” when he was in Denver at the time of their trial, but he didn’t walk through the door his own pope had opened. Pope John Paul II had told President Bush in a private audience that WMD were immoral, in the Vatican’s view, and that the war contemplated against Iraq also was immoral. That message was repeated by the papal nuncio to top officials of the Bush Administration in Washington. This message was ignored, and the war went forward. Perhaps the official papal objections were ineffective because for years the Catholic Church had been derelict in its duty to object to the jailing of priests, nuns and laity who staged public protests over the immorality of war and the threat of nuclear weapons. The Church ignored the assassinations of bishops, nuns and priests in Central America and even sacked some of its progressive members for opposing murderous dictatorships illicitly backed by the Reagan White House. Whatever the case, the three nuns in 2002 took the Pope at his word, while the male hierarchy took the easier course. The weaponry that the nuns pointed to are ensconced in the soil of Chaput’s diocese, and it is a bishop’s duty as “shepherd of the Sunday flock” to provide moral guidance on such weighty matters.
46
Chapter 5. Rendering unto Caesar, or Being Rendered? Chaput did nothing of the sort. He was too busy opposing death by abortion to oppose death by war. Protestant minister Rev. Jesse Jackson raised a pertinent thought years ago when he expressed the notion that churchy politicians worry more about what violence they do to the unborn than they do to those same embryos once they are adults. Years prior, in the matter of missile silos designed to kill the world’s adult fetuses, a Catholic priest out of the Denver archdiocese, Bill Sulzman, was stricken from the bishop’s list of practicing priests because he raised the issue about the morality of the WMD silos within that archdiocese. Today, still celibate and still thinking like a dedicated priest, Sulzman leads a group known as Citizens for Peace in Space, in Colorado Springs, where he also works with the homeless. His self-appointed ministry lies geographically at the heart of the US Space Command and NORAD, the lead agencies for promotion of war by the political muscle of missiles and WMD. His work is beginning to attract the attention of international peace groups and officials, even within the United Nations. He has been a speaker at several international conventions on the subject. He has never been excommunicated, but he doesn’t care about that, one way or the other. On November 5, 2005, three of Sulzman’s associates, Esther Kisamore, Barbara Huber and Doug Gale, were subjected to Bush-era justice and freedom. In the space of just one day, their trial for protesting at the Petersen Air Force Base (August 5, 2005) resulted in a denial for an extension, the selection of a jury, trying of the case, a guilty verdict, and sentencing. Operating the assembly-line hammer of justice was municipal judge Spottswood Williams. The reason for such haste was the Iraq war, which the trio was protesting. It seems the witnesses against them were military people about to be sent to Iraq, and it was essential that they testify before departure. This dereliction of moral stewardship even in the courts comes from the top, and is endorsed by America’s politicized Catholic Church and even more conservative Christian cults with voting-booth influence over the White House. On the opening day of the nuns’ trial in Denver, Francis Cardinal George of Chicago was in town to give a speech to University of Denver intellectuals on the subject of “Bridges to the Future: American History and Values in Light of September 11 th .” Bishop Chaput made the introduction. Among Cardinal George’s credentials, he was selected in 2001 to preach a retreat in Rome for the College of Cardinals and the Pope himself — a singular honor. That was before 9/11. What he had to say on that occasion remains unknown.
47
WMD, Nukes and Nuns The trial of the nuns would seem to be a significant event related to the Denver University seminar topic, yet for political reasons the cardinal passed up the opportunity to associate with the cause of the nuns. It could not have been an accidental oversight or a problem of schedule on the part of the cardinal: two weeks before his visit to Denver, a former seminary classmate of the cardinal and a friend of the nuns wrote Cardinal George a letter suggesting that he could exert a positive influence over those “bridges to the future” by either testifying at the trial of the nuns or at least by sitting in the courtroom gallery. “In case you have the inclination to visit the imprisoned,” the letter concluded, “the trial for the nuns starts at 10:30 a.m., March 31, New Federal Courthouse, 901 19th Street (downtown Denver) Judge Blackburn, Courtroom 8.” The letter was never acknowledged. The Denver Post summed up what the cardinal had to say at the Denver University seminar on the day of the trial: “War May Pit Religions.” A subhead explained the obvious “Head of Chicago Archdiocese Fears Shattered Alliances, Persecution.” Religion writer Eric Gorski wrote the following article about the Cardinal’s remarks: The escalating war with Iraq has the potential to pit religions against each other and serve as a destabilizing event globally for years to come, the leader of the nation’s second-largest Roman Catholic diocese said Monday night in Denver. Cardinal Francis George of the Archdiocese of Chicago, speaking to more than 600 people at the University of Denver, warned of undermined relationships with allies and the possible persecution of Christians overseas, particularly if the war drags on and fails to meet objectives. George, 66, spoke as part of “Bridges to the Future: American History and Values in Light of September11.” [This is] a year-long program sponsored by the University of Denver and Colorado State University that includes lectures, panel discussions, and performances. Pope John Paul II has strongly opposed the Iraq war, saying there is no legal or moral justification for the military action. The pope and other Catholic leaders lobbied for a diplomatic solution. George, who previously led Catholic dioceses in Yakima, Washington, and Portland, Oregon, joined Chicago’s top Christian, Jewish and Muslim leaders in urging President Bush in December to avoid war with Iraq. Those beliefs don’t always mesh with those of the Catholic laity. In a survey conducted by the Pew Foundation on Religion and Public Life in the days leading up to the war, 62 percent of Catholics said they supported war.
48
Chapter 5. Rendering unto Caesar, or Being Rendered? George said Monday that he prays US forces don’t get bogged down in a Vietnam-like conflict in which the public’s support erodes. He raised the likelihood of a “loss of ability to shape the world on our terms” — the price, he said, for hurting long-standing relationships with the United Nations and traditional allies. He said security concerns will demand more curtailing of individual freedoms. Most of all, George cautioned that the war, despite the Bush administration’s insistence, already is being viewed as Christians and Jews united against Islam. He said the US government has tried to differentiate between “good Muslims” and bad Muslims” — those who practice their faith and terrorists who betray it with violence. “But it is not for us to determine what Islam is to be, nor for us to determine what any religious community is to be,” George said. “So the very interpretation can be resented and misinterpreted, and if in fact it does become a religious conflict, then we will all suffer.” He said the result could be greater persecution of Christian minorities in Pakistan, Indonesia, northern Nigeria and the Sudan. “The Iraqi war is a very uncertain and possibly destabilizing factor — if not in the immediate future, then in the next century, as the consequences make themselves known,” George said.
The consequences of the war have since made themselves known all too harshly both as political and religious reality. Disturbing nuances in the cardinal’s stance include the following: 1) The cardinal speaks of “our allies” as if the Church were politically aligned and supportive of what seems to be the conservative Christian side of the war taken up by Bush. 2) The cardinal speaks about the war as blocking society’s ability to “shape the world on our terms.” Is the Catholic Church part of that “our system” which is now shaping the world by war? 3) The cardinal says “it is not for us to determine what any religious community is to be.” This, of course, is a statement designed not to offend righteous Muslims. But if he means it, who is left to make such moral determinations except those politicians whose goals appear to be so contradictory to those we used to attribute to the Church? Conclusion: the Catholic Church in America is fully aligned with the military-industrial complex and with current conservative political values, including the necessity of war with the Muslim world and the war in Iraq. The Catholic Church wants nothing to do with moral protesters of war, despite the late pope’s direction. And political interference between church and state applies even more so to the conservative non-Catholic Church.
49
WMD, Nukes and Nuns This is not surprising, given the fact that George is a member of the ultraconservative and secretive society within the Catholic Church known as Opus Dei (which means “work of God”). As Catholic outcast Matthew Fox puts it, Opus Dei is “the ideological preference of the rich and the powerful.” Fox, a Dominican preacher, posted his own 95 Theses (à la Martin Luther) on the cathedral door of then-Cardinal Ratzinger in Germany. Because it was Ratzinger, as head of the Vatican’s Office of Holy Inquisition, who had condemned Fox for his heresies, Fox took special delight in mimicking Luther to mock the cardinal. In any case, the work of God, to evaluate the new Pope Benedict XVI (Ratzinger) and Bishop Chaput and Cardinal George, no longer includes taking a stand on fundamental issues of morality when to do so would offend the current political powers. The interests of the Church have become linked to the secular world order. The other American cardinals are similarly silent. From the Protestant side, Bill Moyers, former spokesman for the LBJ administration and former host of the PBS program NOW, seems to concur with that conclusion about the church. In a 2005 speech to the Union Theological Seminary entitled “Reckoning with the God Squad,” Moyers’ views in regard to Church-State relationships reinforce those expressed by Jimmy Carter. Moyers says, in part: Our democratic values are imperiled because too many people of reason are willing to appease irrational people just because they are pious. Republican moderates tried appeasement and survive today only in gulags set aside for them by the Karl Roves, Bill Frists and Tom DeLays…As I look back on the conflicts and clamor of our boisterous past, one lesson about democracy stands out above all others: bullies. Political bullies, economic bullies and religious bullies cannot be appeased. They have to be opposed with a stubbornness to match their own.
That is the kind of stubbornness that the nuns have displayed in their actions, but without the political impetus or the institutional religious support. They needed only moral motivation. Moyers, a Texas Baptist, continues: Let’s go back to 9/11 four years ago. The ruins were still smoldering when the reverends Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwall went on television to proclaim that the terrorists attacks were God’s punishment of a corrupted America…Critics said such comments were deranged, but millions of Christian fundamentalists and conservatives didn’t think so.
He suggested that, from the other side, Osama bin Laden was reading his holy book to justify his own murderous actions.
50
Chapter 5. Rendering unto Caesar, or Being Rendered? The motives behind the war are complex and probably include far more than meets the eye. However, one dimension is that of a conflict between two irreconcilable cultures, one that looks to American eyes like a repressive theocracy and the other an aggressively-Christian democracy, each bent on bestowing its values on the other, by war, if necessary. In that vein, Moyers goes on to say: We know you can go through the Bible and construct a God more pleasing to the better angels of nature. We also know that the “violence of God” tradition remains embedded deep in the DNA of [every] monotheistic faith. Inside that logic you cannot read part of the Bible allegorically and the rest of it literally. If you believe in the virgin birth of Jesus, his crucifixion and resurrection and the depiction of the Great Judgment at the end of time, you must also believe that God is sadistic, brutal, vengeful, callow, cruel and savage. [He is] a God that slaughters.”
Thus Moyers links the God of the Bible, the God of the church, the God of the White House, and the God of war with the God of American voters. Moyers does not exempt the Muslims from his criticism for the grief they have brought to the world when he says: Yes, the Koran speaks of mercy and compassion and calls for ethical living. But such passages are no match for the ferocity of instruction found there for waging war for God’s sake. “Those who believe fight in the cause of Allah, and those who reject faith fight in the cause of evil. (4:76).” So the holy warriors came [as] an airborne death-cult, their sights on God’s enemies [who were] regular folks, starting the day’s routine one minute and in the next engulfed by a horrendous cataclysm. Having lost faith in all else, zealots have nothing left but a holy cause to please a warrior God. They win if we become holy warriors, too; if we kill the innocent as they do; strike first at those who had not struck us; allow our leaders to use the fear of terrorism to make us afraid of the truth…allowing others to tell us what’s in God’s mind.
Moyers then suggests where this attitude has led America: Suddenly we were immersed in the pathology of a holy war as defined by both sides. You could see this pathology play out in General William Boykin. As a member of the US military, Boykin had taken up with a small group called the Faith Force Multiplier whose members apply military principles to evangelism with a manifesto summoning warriors “to the spiritual warfare for souls.” In uniform, Boykin attended evangelical revivals preaching that America was in a holy war as “a Christian nation.” [He said] America’s adversaries will be defeated “only if we come against them in the name of Jesus.” So General Boykin explained how it was that the candidate who had lost the election in 2000 nonetheless wound up in the White House. President Bush, he said, “was not elected by a majority of the voters, he was appointed by God.” Not surprising, instead of being reprimanded for evangelizing while in uniform, General Boykin is now Deputy Undersecretary of Defense for Intelligence.
51
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Moyers adds that it also is not surprising that despite Pat Robertson’s call for the assassination of a foreign head of state, Robertson’s “Operation Blessing” was one of the first groups to receive taxpayer funds from President Bush’s “Faith-Based Initiative” for relief work on the Gulf Coast. “We can’t wiggle out of this,” Moyers says. “We’re talking about a powerful religious constituency that claims the right to tell us what is on God’s mind and to decide the laws of the land according to their interpretation of biblical revelation and to enforce those laws on the nation as a whole. For the Bible is not just the foundational text of their faith; it has become the foundational text for a political movement.” Moyers says the US is not yet a theocracy, but he adds, The radical religious right has succeeded in taking over one of America’s great political parties [the Republican Party] driving American politics, using God as a bettering ram on almost every issue. The corporate, political and religious right has converged, led by a president who, in his own disdain for science, reason and knowledge, is the most powerful fundamentalist in American history. Radicals on the Christian right are now the dominant force in America’s governing party…They are culpable in upholding a system of class and race in which, as we saw last week (Hurricane Katrina) the rich escape and the poor left behind. And they are on a crusade against government “of, by, and for the people” in favor of one based on Biblical authority. The Grand Old Party has become God’s Own Party — its ranks made up of God’s Own People, “marching as to war.”
Moyers notes that the descendants of the religious Puritans of New England found a haven for the cause of conscience because they no longer would be subject to what Jefferson called “The loathsome combination of church and state.” Under the Jeffersonian regimen, Moyers says, “Americans could be loyal to the Constitution without being hostile to God, or they could pay no heed to God without fear of being mugged by an official God Squad.” Moyers seems to suggest that such political/religious mugging is now taking place in America against its Constitutional superstructure. The analysis provides a clue as to why many Christian clerics are afraid to discuss the immorality of the Iraq war with their war-mongering faithful, even though the late Pope John Paul hoisted the standard of opposition. That is why bishops such as Sheridan of the Colorado Springs diocese merely note through office spokesmen, “Popes always have to say they are against war.”
52
Chapter 5. Rendering unto Caesar, or Being Rendered? Given such concessions to the Establishment, the Catholic Church in America and most of its mainstream Christian brethren have become totally secularized. Institutionally they have fallen in line with America’s national and international policies for the sake of the Sunday collection plate. In fact, there is no more separation of church and state; American politicalmilitary policy has become Church policy. About this mix, Jonathan Turley, professor of law at George Washington University, wrote the following for the Los Angeles Times (October 17, 2003) that connects to the nuns: It has lain dormant in the darkest recesses of American law for 125 years, but this month Attorney General John Ashcroft introduced critics of the [Bush] administration to his latest weapon in law enforcement. In a Miami federal court, the attorney general charged the environmental group, Greenpeace, under an obscure 1872 law originally intended to end the practice of “sailor-mongering,” or the luring of sailors with liquor and prostitutes from their ships. Ashcroft plucked the law from obscurity to punish Greenpeace for boarding a vessel near port in Miami. Not only is the law being used to prosecute one of the administration’s most vocal critics in an unprecedented attack on the First Amendment, but it appears to be part of a broader campaign by Ashcroft to protect the nation against free speech, a campaign that has converted environmentalists into “sailor-mongers” and nuns into terrorists. Ashcroft’s jihad against free speech, however, is not limited to environmentalists. Consider the case of three Dominican nuns. Last year, Sister Ardeth Platte, 66, Sister Jackie Hudson, 68, and Sister Carol Gilbert, 55, participated in a peaceful demonstration against nuclear armament. As part of the protest, the three nuns cut through a chain link fence around a Minuteman III missile silo. There is only a light fence because the missile is protected by a 110-ton concrete cap that is designed to withstand a nuclear explosion. The nuns proceeded to paint crosses on the cap and symbolically hit it with hammers. They then knelt, prayed, sang religious songs and waited for arrest. The most the government could allege in terms of damage was $3,000. However, the Ashcroft Justice Department wanted more than compensation and a common misdemeanor. It charged the nuns with obstructing national defense, which subjected each to a potential 30-year prison term. When the government pushed the court to impose sentences of as much as eight years, the judge refused. However, the judge found, as alleged by the government, that the three nuns had put military personnel “in harm’s way.” Accordingly, he imposed on them sentences ranging from 2 ½ years to 3 ½ years.
The nuns have shown the Church how un-Christian it is while its politicians are busy trying to show the nation how “Christian” nuclear weapons and war can be. It is likely the nuns understand the moral issues better than either their national leaders or their church leaders do.
53
CHAPTER 6. OF POPES, PROPHETS, PULPITS, PATRIOTS, PRESIDENTS AND POLITICAL PUPPETS “It is blasphemy to kill in the name of God.” — John Paul II
In ten words, that statement condemns the President, Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein while removing God from an immoral political war. That is exactly what the three nuns tried to do. Even so, it seems to be easy for many within the non-Catholic and secular public to think ill of nuns who “invade” the sacred political sanctuaries of military facilities, as if the nuns were pagan druids of an unpatriotic conspiracy against national security. When it is politically convenient, the public clamors for separation of church and state within their political sanctuary. But when that same public has been bombarded with media impressions and political “spin” that lead them to desire genocide, it will close its ears to the minority voice calling for peace. It will willingly invoke a murderous god, even in their Sunday pulpits. As Bill Moyers pointed out in a speech to the Union Theological Seminary, one depiction of the warlike God in Christian theology would seem to make him “sadistic, brutal, vengeful, callow, cruel and savage.” In context, he suggested that American politicians were using their Christian God in the brutal sense rather than the one of love. Religious zealots tend to see their God as a genie who must respond to their wishful prayers. And so it is for millions of Muslims of the Middle East who view the events of 9/11 as justified by Allah. As Moyers also notes of the 9/11 terrorists, “They
55
WMD, Nukes and Nuns came in the name of God. They came bent on murder and martyrdom. Yes, the Koran speaks of mercy and compassion and calls for ethical living. But such passages are no match for the ferocity of instruction found there for waging war for God’s sake.” The nuns try to avert such war and do not worship a vengeful god. Their mentors, the Berrigan brothers, have always referred to WMD as “Lord Nuke.” Under the morally schizophrenic view of Bush Christians, the possession of nuclear, chemical and biological weapons is a war crime only when it comes to “nationalists” of other nations, but for “patriotic” Americans it is a legitimate means to ensure peace and freedom. Pat Robertson is a Yale-educated conservative preacher who makes a living by blending politics and religion on TV for consumption by those millions of viewers who voted for President G. W. Bush and his strike-first military policies. But he is more than that — he is a former contender for the Republican Party presidency of America, and he recommends from his TV pulpit the assassination of foreign heads of state. In a message sent August 22, 2005, from his Christian Broadcasting Network show, The 700 Club, Robertson suggested that Hugo Chavez, the democratically-elected leader of Venezuela, should be assassinated. It seems the socialistic president had spoken ill of President Bush and his policies in Iraq. It seems that Chavez had suggested that the US had mounted an attempted coup in Venezuela, the world’s fifth-largest exporter of oil, and had intentions to assassinate him. Even if we have somehow come to accept that such assassinations are business as usual for the CIA, it seems an odd goal for a “Christian” preacher to espouse. Robertson violated the Christian commandment against killing by saying this on national TV: You know, I don’t know about this doctrine of assassination, but if he [Chavez] thinks we are trying to assassinate him, I think that we really ought to go ahead and do it. It’s a whole lot cheaper than starting a war and I don’t think any oil shipments will stop….We have the ability to take him out, and I think the time has come that we exercise that ability. We don’t need another 200-billion-dollar war to get rid of one, you know, strong-arm dictator. It’s a whole lot easier to have some of the covert operatives do the job and then get it over with.
Then, in January of 2006 he suggested that God was punishing Israel’s Prime Minister Sharon with a stroke for giving away “God’s land” in the Middle East peace process.
56
Chapter 6. Of Popes, Prophets, Pulpits, Patriots, Presidents and Political Puppets Robertson’s comments reveal several things about the commingling of politics and religion which has infiltrated both Bush administrations: 1. The conservative Christians believe, or claim to believe, they are following the word of God as set down by President G.W. Bush’s “mission” to wage war in Iraq. 2. They, like Bush, shift the burden of guilt for the Iraq war to Muslim radicals from outside of Iraq. They mis-use the Bible to justify the war. 3. By referring to Venezuela oil shipments, Robertson inadvertently exposes the lie of President G.H.W. Bush when he said the war to liberate Kuwait from Iraq was “not about oil,” and he exposes the lie of President G.W. Bush that the invasion of Iraq was about WMD. Religion and cultural beliefs are used to rally the troops for this war, whereas the leadership’s actual objectives have to do with economic power and world supremacy. Just like the Crusades. 4. Robertson, by whipping up emotions and encouraging millions of Americans to “take out” even democratically-elected leaders if they dare to criticize US policy, is promoting the kind of religion-sponsored suicide-murder that we blame Muslim extremists for fomenting elsewhere. In other words, he promotes worldwide war in the name of Christianity, and then extracts from his TV program viewers, now in a state of irrational passion, millions of dollars in donations. Robertson’s call for assassination and his God-curse on Sharon was an embarrassment for the White House. Now, if Hugo Chavez was “taken out,” by either a sanctioned or unsanctioned killer, Washington could not credibly duck the blame. The White House PR office scrambled to sever itself from Robertson, saying, in effect, that the US has not had a policy to “take out” dictators anywhere in the world ever since President Ford exercised the moral leadership to end such policies. Afterward, Venezuela’s President Chavez (no doubt an “evil” man in the mind of Robertson’s audience) not only turned the other cheek, but offered medical and oil aid to the US following the Hurricane Katrina disaster. For that matter, so did Cuba’s Fidel Castro, whose nation often suffers from the same hurricanes that afflict the US. Both offers were arrogantly rejected in favor of more deficit tithing by American taxpayers toward the American budget. Into this mix comes a woman named Cindy Sheehan, who lost a son in Iraq and asks the White House the question, “Why?”
57
WMD, Nukes and Nuns She wanted, like the rest of the nation, to hear from Bush directly why her son had to die, months after Saddam Hussein was deposed and captured. She received only more presidential arrogance, and more refusals to discuss the rationale (much less the morality) of the war. To mothers such as Sheehan, the administration’s affirmation that “we don’t kill the leaders of enemy states” is contradicted by the actions it has taken to remove Hussein. Instead of the old-fashioned coup of a quick bullet, he is to have a fair trial followed by beheading. As of the end of 2005, tens of thousands of Iraqis and more than 2,000 Americans have died, and it’s not over yet. Two days after Robertson’s ill-considered remarks, he took the dodge of saying he had been “misquoted.” Then he claimed: “I didn’t say ‘assassination.’ I said our special forces should take him out. ‘Take him out’ could be a number of things, including kidnapping.” Thus, he gave Americans his version of a Christian choice: to kill or to kidnap an elected leader who did not match their definition of “Christian.” Bush gave Americans a similar choice: they could line up behind any of a number of lies, as long as they lined up in favor of his war. Robertson said his earlier remarks about assassination were made “out of frustration.” Possibly, some Islamic religious leaders are frustrated, too. Does that make killing right for either side? The nuns would say “no.” The blending and adulteration of concepts such as freedom, peace, justice, war, free enterprise, democracy, capitalism and God always wears the cloak of patriotism. Without war, “patriotism” becomes an abstract and boring virtue. Without victory over an enemy, there is no heroism, no future reverence. All that is left is the fog of peace, leaving no sense of accomplishment. That kind of mixed-up Christian-patriotism, now bubbling within society, is illustrated in a single day by a series of newspaper stories in Denver: 1) The front page of the Rocky Mountain News for the day after Easter Sunday, March 27, 2005, shows a picture of a woman attending Easter Sunrise services at Red Rocks Amphitheater wrapped in an American flag — as if Easter and Jesus Christ had some special connection with America. 2) Within the same issue is a centerfold display of a Catholic chaplain baptizing a US Army captain before he goes into battle in Iraq. The accompanying story describes how that same chaplain blesses the weapons and vehicles of soldiers in the name of God as if they were religious items. When all the captains are dead, will they be saints? When all the vehicles are destroyed, will they become sacred relics, like I-beams from the World Trade Center or splinters from the cross on which Christ was crucified?
58
Chapter 6. Of Popes, Prophets, Pulpits, Patriots, Presidents and Political Puppets 3) In that same issue is a story confiding that President Bush on Easter Sunday attended church services at Fort Hood, Texas. Again, this suggests to the American public that the war in Iraq and its military machine is honored by the resurrected founder of Christianity and is therefore a holy war, a crusade that exceeds the anti-Muslim fervor of the wars a millennium ago. There is more proof of America’s emerging military-political-capitalistic theocracy. It is found in a true-life story that involves a patriotic church congregation and a war hero who lied to Congress, went unpunished, and is thriving today as a war-mongering fascist on the nation’s radio network. The story is very unnerving. On Sunday, September 22, 2002, just as the first blood-red autumn sun was sinking over the Rocky Mountains, hundreds of parishioners of the Faith Bible Chapel in Arvada, Colorado, gathered at their new and sprawling churchschool complex. These evangelical fundamentalist believers, assembled in their tax-exempt multi-million-dollar cocoon along a five-lane urban highway, gathered en masse to buy a book written by Lt. Col. Oliver North. As few of his young Christian audience knew, North was leader of the Iran-Contra CIA operation that ravaged Central America and the Middle East in the 1980s: North had helped to direct the flow of money from drugs from Central America so that the CIA could buy and sell guns to reinstate dictatorial regimes in nations such as El Salvador and Guatemala and Nicaragua. This also enabled the CIA to funnel guns for sale to Iraq and other Middle East nations, who are now engaging in a war of terrorism with America. This activity, which Washington deemed politically and militarily necessary, was illegal — the US Congress had passed laws against military or financial intervention in Central America (the Boland Amendments) No one reminded the Arvada church members that North was a drug runner, a perjurer, and one who had skimmed at least $17,000 in government funds to improve his own property in the process. No one reminded the Arvada church members that North had lied to Congress under oath, but suffered only a fine and a suspended sentence because he had operated out of the Reagan-Bush White House basement while Regan was napping. No one reminded them that North had dutifully broken laws at the direction of a president who defied Congress. None of them knew, or they chose to ignore, that North was responsible for the deaths of tens of thousands of Central Americans. None of
59
WMD, Nukes and Nuns them knew or cared that North’s guns-and-drugs scheme, barracked by the Reagan administration in the White House, was used to bargain with Middle East terrorists for the release of kidnapped Americans far into the 1980s. They didn’t know that North had arranged secret airports for secret planes flying drugs and guns and money between Central America and the US (using landing zones in Arkansas, where Bill Clinton was a compliant governor twenty years ago) for the purpose of killing people who were trying to gain their freedom from their US-backed dictators. One of those dictators was the thirdgeneration of the Somoza family in Guatemala. All they knew about North was that he was a highly decorated hero of the Vietnam War, and that he had now written a book, printed by a Christian publishing house, to make more money from his exploits for the good of such unholy patriotism. And so, on September 22, 2002, as the sun sank slowly in the west, the assembled evangelical believers listened to (and then gave Protestant genuflection to) the man who said that patriotism required they wage war against Iraq. Relying on his Vietnam medals, North was touting his self-serving book of “fiction” on the subject of patriotic war heroes like himself, in order to make that hash of war, Christ, Pentagon and White House look like American apple pie. Apparently, this political message of violence was considered a fit topic for a religious audience — much more so than the peaceful protest of nuns. Ten days prior to North’s “victory tour” selling war books to church audiences, the public sidewalks leading past this church’s entrances had been lined in promenade fashion with hundreds of tiny American flags, placed there in an anniversary remembrance of the 9/11 mass murders. Those mass murders are now being “solved” by murdering masses of other people in Iraq, a nation that had nothing to do with the attacks in Manhattan or the Pentagon. Outside the Faith Bible Chapel on that autumn day was a lone picketer carrying a sign that read: “Why Does This Church Support Col. North, IranContra, Guns and Drugs?” It was a logical question that should have disturbed church members who think they have high moral standards, and who must abhor illegal use of guns and profiteering from the sale of illegal drugs. Did they even bother to reflect on the distinctions between what is sinful, what is illegal, what is immoral and what is political interest or patriotic? Did they understand the killing that they indirectly supported?
60
Chapter 6. Of Popes, Prophets, Pulpits, Patriots, Presidents and Political Puppets The answer came quickly to the lone picketer: A curious young woman stopped her car in the driveway, rolled down her window and asked what the sign meant. “What’s that?” She apparently had never heard of the Iran-Contra scandal. Perhaps in her early 20s, she was not familiar with the political angst of a whole nation — indeed, of a whole world — just two decades prior. The young woman wrinkled her brow in puzzlement, parked her car, and — presumably — went to get a personally signed copy of North’s “novel” which he claimed honored the memory of some unidentified wartime compatriot. The book sold thousands of copies at dozens of politically-conservative church functions. North enjoyed a 58-city tour, making the most of his freedom of expression under the First Amendment. It is odd that instead of a God of peace and love, the Christian view of God can be manipulated by military and political “pulpiteers” to promote profits from killing. It is odd that North, a white and supposedly a Christian, should be considered a hero for calling UN Secretary General Kofi Annan in a TV interview an “enemy” of America — supposedly for giving comfort to Saddam Hussein. It is frightening that North is still being treated like a hero, after opening the CIA drug-importing channels from Colombia that led to the rise of Pablo Escobar, the Cali Cartel and Manuel Noriega. Two archbishops and numerous priests and nuns of the Catholic Church were killed in Central America for opposing North’s Iran-Contra actions in the guns-for-drugs barter. Yet, a significant segment of the conservative Christian Church adores him and his brand of politics. North was more recently in Iraq as an “embedded” media correspondent for the war, and still commands the bloody-flag-draped attention of the American public. Here’s the legacy of the North-Reagan scandal: 1) America’s political and military policies are under the control of religious conservatism akin to Britain’s King George III, who was head of church and state in Great Britain at the time of the American Revolution. 2) The Christian Church, on both its Catholic and Protestant sides, allows itself to be used for what North and his presidential patron promote while ignoring their duty to recognize the righteousness of three jailed nuns in their cause against WMD. Here is the scariest part of all, where the world’s future is concerned: in 1998, Pope John Paul II told an audience in war-torn Nigeria (which is 50
61
WMD, Nukes and Nuns percent Muslim and 50 percent Catholic), “It is blasphemy to kill in the name of God.” The scary part is that no one pays any heed. In 2002, just before Bush invaded Iraq, the Pope repeated his warning to President G. W. Bush through a cardinal emissary. Bush ignored it and so did most American bishops, including Francis Cardinal George, who did not want to rock the boat. More recently, the Executive Assistant and Director of Communications, Peter J. Howard, S.T.L., blithely commented, on behalf of Bishop Sheridan in Colorado Springs (home of NORAD and the Space Command), that “war is not intrinsically evil” (from private emails of February 2005). A Rome-educated lay theologian who is Bishop Sheridan’s spokesman, Howard arrogantly presumes to note that—the contrary words of his pope notwithstanding— “All wars involve evil, but the [Catholic] Church has never taught that every war is unjustified. Therefore, war is not intrinsically evil, although certain wars can be unjust....The Vatican is naturally going to oppose all war, but it never revokes the heads of state to make that decision.” His logic begs the question: If a given war is unjust, is it evil? Howard’s pope has already given him and the world the answer. Indeed, did not John Paul II rebuke or revoke Bush by instructing that the Iraq war, specifically, was unjust? Just as he had said that the earlier slaughter in Nigeria’s civil war was unjust? Wasn’t one of the most troubling aspects of the Iraq war the fact that it was sold to Congress and the world public on the basis of “bad” intelligence regarding the non-existent uranium flowing into Iraq from Niger? How is such war “not intrinsically evil?” The Pope, even in the days of his final infirmity, seemed to understand these issues. However, some of his bishops embedded in the heart of America’s war-making machine cannot afford to recognize the contradictory facts of war fought in the name of God. Have the bishops become politicians? There are other frightening and irrational facets to the separation of church and state story. One is the way in which the so-called Christian fundamentalist churches support a bizarre pro-Israel, anti-Jewish position in this world for the sake of righteousness at the time of final judgment. Within less than a month of North’s sales pitch in Arvada, 60 Minutes (October 6, 2002) aired a segment revealing such fundamentalists to be antiSemitic, in spite of — or perhaps because of — their patriotic faith in God and their literal interpretations of the Bible and Armageddon and Final Judgment.
62
Chapter 6. Of Popes, Prophets, Pulpits, Patriots, Presidents and Political Puppets The TV segment started by showing a Jewish-Christian co-celebration, conducted in a certain “evangelical church in Colorado,” supporting the Jews in their never-ending battle with the Palestinians. This coming-together was viewed as supporting the Jews in the American-Israeli war against Palestinian Muslims as part of the Christian God’s work and will. The evangelicals (70 million strong, according to Jerry Falwell) believe that the current war in the Middle East is the beginning of the fulfillment of the prophecy in Revelations about the second coming of Christ. These fundamentalist Christians temporarily support the Jews, the program pointed out, because they believe that God originally gave the Jews what is now left of Palestine, and the West Bank. Thus, they support American military efforts to back Israel and kill their Muslim enemies. This, of course, is where Middle East and American politics and religions intersect nonsensically, and introduce in distorted format America’s so-called Christian beliefs. The fundamentalist belief, which is entwined in Bush’s WMD politics, supports the notion that once the Jews are restored to the Promised Land, then the Messiah will come again and convert to Christianity any Jews remaining. Those Jews who resist will be destroyed as infidels by the power of Christ in that second coming. What of the Palestinians? The instrumentality of war and politics (US policy in the Middle East) as determined by fate, controlled by God and now unfolding, will dispose of them in Gehenna (hell). The same fate presumably awaits the Muslims and Hindus and Sikhs and Buddhists and all others who do not share the fundamentalist Protestants’ beliefs. In other words, these 70 million American fundamentalists support the current US foreign policy in the Middle East (Israel vs. Palestinians and all Muslims) because they think war is a means of fulfilling the hallelujah prophecy by which they will be saved in heaven at the Final Judgment, when Muslims, Jews, pagans and everyone else will be cast into hell — along with liberal Catholics. Is this part of the thinking of the present Bush Administration, or is it part of the recruiting drive that motivates born-again patriots to go fight the nonChristians in Iraq? The election of 2004 showed that the Republican Party and George Bush would not have won without the support of the conservative Christian coalition.
63
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Such miscegenation of politics and religion is borne out by a boast that Falwell made on 60 Minutes: He claimed that 100,000 letters from evangelicals across the nation caused the Bush White House to back down in the spring of 2002 from its demands that Ariel Sharon withdraw from Ramallah and Bethlehem, the very cradle of Christianity, and turn it over to the Muslims. Other Christian clerics, like the Rev. Dr. George Regas of the All Saints Episcopal Church in Pasadena, California, take a more moderate view. On October 31, 2004, he delivered a sermon called, “If Jesus debated Sen. Kerry and President Bush….” Without telling his parishioners how to vote, he “challenged them” to go into the voting booth “taking with them all that they knew about Jesus, the peacemaker… and then vote their deepest values.” As Regas tells it, he soon received a shocking message from the Internal Revenue Service which warned him that “intervention in a political campaign could cause you [your church] to lose your tax exempt status.” Apparently, someone representing the Bush Administration considered that Regas was campaigning against Bush, or was enough of an irritant to require shutting up. This church-state clash was not reported in the national media until the Bob Schieffer’s CBS news broadcast of November 16, 2005. As Schieffer pointed out, the Christian conservative political regime in the White House was snooping in the pulpits of the nation in violation of the doctrine of separation of church and state. His inference from the IRS action was that governmental agencies are wielding clubs, threatening churches and the Church as a whole, at the behest of the White House, without regard for the US Constitution and the nation’s tax laws. As Regas responded, “I often preached sermons that touched upon what some would characterize as political issues. Many of the political issues that we confront today coincide with deeply held, core religious beliefs: issues relating to marriage, family, community, and yes, even war and foreign policy. It seems to me that fundamentally moral issues, such as peace and the alleviation of poverty are indisputably the province of church pulpits — regardless of which politicians are debating on a Sunday that happens to fall in an election cycle.” The contrasting sagas of North and Bush and Regas and the nuns illustrate the dangers inherent in the confused amalgam of church, state, freedom, patriotism, morality, war and peace in America — and why young Americans are dying in Iraq and nuns are in jail, but no presidents are.
64
CHAPTER 7. AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH Pontius Pilate pondered before deciding whether to have Christ crucified, “What is truth?” Did the nuns actually commit a wrong act? Were they, indeed, guilty of sabotage that borders on treason? If they were in the right, surely they would not have been sent to jail? Air Force officers who operated the silo complex testified that, despite their demonstration at the silo, the nuns never put the nation’s security in jeopardy. Yet they went to jail as if they had. Nothing but a fence was damaged, and the only blood spilled was their own, voluntarily. No harm, no crime. On the other hand, the government’s lie about WMD in Iraq launched a thousand cruise missiles and resulted in the sacrifice of thousands of American lives and tens of thousands of Iraqi lives for a cause that was proved to be false. Was that lie promulgated and was the war conducted in Iraq to remove incriminating evidence? To induce regime change? To obtain the power and the revenues that Iraq’s oil represented? To remove a potential threat to Israel? For religion? All these and many other motives have been suggested. Whatever the results as far as oil and other interests are concerned, Saddam Hussein’s regime has been overthrown. What never will change is that he was once Washington’s man, armed years prior by another Bush president when he was CIA director. The question, then, must be: was Bush wrong? Several of his top aides, now reviled as outcasts, and even one respected journalist, indicate that he was.
65
WMD, Nukes and Nuns When Bush invaded Iraq in March of 2003 with “shock and awe,” he stated two main goals: to unseat Saddam’s regime and to get US forces to find weapons of mass destruction in order to justify the invasion after the fact. Obviously, if Saddam had gone “bad,” no one could sleep at night knowing he had access to WMD. He must be a threat to world peace. Bush and his father had given him weapons and now Bush wanted them back. But Bush’s army never found WMD, nuclear or otherwise in Iraq and it was nearly a year until the troops found Saddam himself. When the nuns were arrested on October 6, 2002, they stated: We hope in the light of that world to name things what they are, to unmask the lies, abuses, and racism hidden in the rhetoric of patriotism, security and moral superiority. We reject the US Space Command Vision for 2020 to dominate space for military operations; to exploit space as a US 4th frontier, making all other nations vulnerable to US conventional and nuclear attacks; to integrate space force for war fighting; to abuse the Aleutian Islands and other lands with interceptors and spy satellites and to waste more billions and billions of dollars and more human and material resources, causing the destruction of earth and the desecration of space. [For complete statement, see Appendix A.]
Some top aides, who presumably stood for the truth while they were within the Bush administration, now are treated as if they no longer speak the truth because they presume to speak a truth contrary to Bush’s party line. They include former US ambassador to Iraq Joseph Wilson; former Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill; former National Security Advisor Richard Clarke. Wilson, who issued a report in 2002 indicating that Iraq was not importing uranium oxide from Niger, was discredited for exposing the lie in Bush’s 2003 State of the Union message to Congress. Bush, supported by contrived information from Vice President Cheney, used the trumped-up uranium story to consolidate support for the invasion of Iraq. Bush needed just such an inflammatory reason to build a case for invading Iraq. It has now become public knowledge that Wilson’s wife (Valerie Plame) was a CIA agent in charge of tracking nuclear matters; that to discredit her work and the opinion of Joe Wilson, the Bush administration exposed Plame as a CIA agent. This violated a US national security law. It also endangered the lives of many agents associated with Mrs. Wilson’s activities. An investigation into that breach of national security was at first stonewalled and then swept under the carpet. Publicly, President Bush has said that anyone in his administration leaking security information would be sacked. Later, as the finger of suspicion pointed
66
Chapter 7. And Nothing but the Truth to his own advisor, Carl Rove, Bush cray-fished by saying such charges would have to be proven first. In September 2005, Judith Miller of The New York Times was released from her contempt-of-court prison cell in exchange for revealing that her source for a story she had been developing was Scooter Libby, chief of staff for Vice President Dick Cheney. She spoke out and won her release only after Libby released her from a promise of journalistic confidentiality. Libby has since been indicted for lying under oath about a national security matter. As of the end of 2005, Bush’s own top aide, Karl Rove, remains unindicted but is still under scrutiny. It seems doubtful that anyone of substance in the Bush administration will be fired for violating a national security law, given the violations that Bush himself has committed by way of family corporate interests, especially where release of nuclear technology is concerned (See Chapter 20). Not long after Wilson blew the whistle, former cabinet member (and National Security Council member) Paul O’Neill announced that the Bush administration had become “the deaf leading the blind” on the subject of Al Qaeda. O’Neill resigned at about the time Bush invaded Iraq. Then Richard Clarke, who headed the counter-terrorism office of presidents G.H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, and G.W. Bush, charged in his book, Inside America’s War on Terror, that the current Bush administration had pushed the vigilance against terrorism and Al Qaeda to the “back burner,” offering the war on Iraq as a substitute. Clarke’s testimony before the 9/11 Commission has been torpedoed by the Bush administration as being self-serving. In the meantime, Bob Woodward, former Washington Post hero of Watergate, published a book confirming what Clarke was saying. That book, based on interviews with President G.W. Bush, had been reviewed and given the White House imprimatur, just as Clarke’s had been. The problem is, nobody is sure what the truth of the matter is, and that’s the way the Bush administration likes it. When the United States of America was founded, nearly everyone in this country believed in God and those testifying before a court of justice had to swear on the Bible “to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help me God.” In recent times, belief is far less uniform and the witness oath in the courts omits all reference to God and all use of the Bible. Today’s court oath carries about as much weight as a Boy Scout pledge to be thrifty, brave, clean and reverent. The gravity of the oath depends upon what is at stake for the person
67
WMD, Nukes and Nuns raising the right hand. Perjury, if it occurs in any court, is now recognized as simply a convenient lie, punishable to the extent of the judge’s discretion. Lies from the White House would then seem to be nothing but political “spin” without reference to what the truth is. The judge in any case is an interpreter of the law enacted by those who appointed him and the people who pay his salary. The judge is the law, and morality no longer has anything to do with the truth. The question is, as the late Morton Margolin of the Rocky Mountain News used to ask at election time from his news desk, “Who judges the judges?” As Rev. Carl Kabat, says, “[Courts] are legal theater…trials put on by the state to sanction by jury the presupposed verdict of the state and the judge. The judges in such cases don’t give a damn about the whole truth. They take care only to allow enough one-sided truths to create the appearance of a just verdict so that they won’t be reversed. When they rule in favor of the government, they never are.” However, in the case of the nuns. On October 1, 2004, the Appeals Court Tribunal asked enough pointed questions about the deficiencies of the prosecution’s case to suggest that a reversal of Blackburn might be possible. The opposite has since happened and the truth was crushed by the gavel. Kabat, by the way, was convicted of a “crime” similar to that of the nuns and was tried under the purview of the same US attorney, John Suthers, but by a different federal judge within the Denver district. Kabat’s case happened prior to 9/11. He crawled over a missile silo fence in Weld County in 2000 and damaged nothing. He pounded with a household hammer on the silo lid and its metal appurtenances (railroad tracks). Wearing a clown’s suit to poke fun at the government, he spilled some of his own blood. He was then arrested at gunpoint by a squadron of military police and turned over to the local sheriff’s department for disposition. The disposition of misdemeanor trespass, which might have been settled in county court, was taken over by federal authorities because Kabat was a previously convicted peace felon. Kabat’s protest was directed against nuclear weapons (WMD) which, according to the official policy of the government that arrested him, were supposedly being eliminated in compliance with a senate-ratified 1972 treaty. Unfortunately, G.W. Bush unilaterally revoked that treaty. As co-founder of the Plowshares Movement, Kabat had a history (he served 14 years for multiple offenses) of similar peaceful transgressions. He was an associate of the Berrigan brothers, who protested the Vietnam War. (In fact,
68
Chapter 7. And Nothing but the Truth the Berrigans started the trend on college campuses to burn draft documents when Philip Berrigan declared draft cards to be “human hunting licenses.”) The problem for Magistrate Boyd Boland in the Kabat case was that, if he allowed Kabat’s motives to become known to the jury, he would likely not be convicted. And if he were found innocent, then the government itself would necessarily be exposed as guilty of a war crime by threatening the use of a WMD — in contravention of the decades-old Geneva Conventions. Boland knew Kabat was prepared to admit that he trespassed into the government’s weapons sanctuary. He also knew that Kabat was prepared to prove: 1) That the missile silo contained weapons of mass destruction which, under the Geneva Conventions, constitutes a war crime. Under the same conventions to use or even threaten to use weapons of mass destruction is a war crime. 2) That Kabat had a duty under the Nuremberg Principles, established through American jurisprudence after World War II (and thereby becoming the law of the land) to inform the public and to resist an evil that the state was forcing upon its citizens. The Nuremberg Principle declares: “Individuals have international duties which transcend the national obligations of obedience…Therefore [those individuals] have the duty to violate domestic laws to prevent crimes against peace and humanity from occurring.” To get around this conflict of law, Boland agreed with the government prosecutors that Kabat’s motive had no bearing on the case. It was simply a case of whether or not Kabat had trespassed. It the end it not matter whether Kabat could prove motive that neutralized the offense, because the judge and prosecutors would not allow such testimony. It did not matter whether the law could be a basis for defense. The magistrate simply barred all such testimony at the entry level of the trial, creating a foregone verdict. What Boland discarded in the process was nothing less than the Sixth Article of the US Constitution, which states, “…all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the constitution or laws of any state to the contrary notwithstanding.” Boland also erroneously rejected the Nuremberg Principles, failing to consider them part of American jurisprudence. By proxy through Kabat’s case, this low-level magistrate was nullifying ex post facto the Nuremberg proceeding against the war crimes of the Third Reich. His purpose in doing so was to avoid
69
WMD, Nukes and Nuns establishing the US government as being guilty of war crimes similar to those of Hitler’s regime. Finally, Boland’s ruling nullified the First Amendment in its aspects of free speech in Kabat’s attempt to speak out about government crimes. Under these conditions, the jury had no alternative but the guilty verdict. In this context, the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth went down the judicial crapper, as would the case of the nuns a couple of years later. Of course, Kabat’s attorneys wanted to appeal, but Kabat, ever the selfappointed martyr for a cause, did not. With that decision he passed up an opportunity, perhaps, to make new law in an area of his life’s keenest interest. His best friends and advisors whispered that he was either a saint or stubborn to the point of self-crucifixion. For trespass, Kabat got 83 days (time served), although he subsequently had to serve a year in jail for breaking his probation in Illinois. As it turned out, Kabat was precedent for what happened to the nuns. The case of the nuns, who were friends of Kabat through the Plowshares Movement, came up after 9/11 but just before the US invaded Iraq. It was similar in nearly every respect to the Kabat case, except the nuns used pliers to cut through a missile silo fence, thus “destroying,” as Suthers contended, a vital part of the country’s national defense: a fence. The nuns, like Kabat, were first turned over to the local sheriff’s department for disposition. Their misdemeanor trespass was then taken over by the FBI, and the nuns became the captives of federal marshals, as happened to Kabat. As members of the Plowshares Movement, the nuns had a “criminal” history, with some time served for similar offenses that had been regarded as negligible. They too, were associates of Philip Berrigan. The nuns considered their action to be a prophecy against the second war then gathering force against Iraq. Like Kabat’s prophecy, and like Bush’s war, it focused on WMD. For what should have been the misdemeanor of trespass, the nuns were tried for sabotage and obstructing national defense described by defense attorneys as excessive. However, the US attorney and Judge Robert Blackburn acceded to the government’s plea to proceed with such excessive charges because of public pressures flowing from 9/11.
70
Chapter 7. And Nothing but the Truth Thereby, America’s legal wrath against bin Laden became focused against the nuns. America needed a culprit and so the nuns got a “fair trial” and then were, in a sense, hanged. The core of the whole truth that the nuns wanted to present was that the United States, which by then had gone to war, was in possession of the very weapons it ostensibly decried as illegal under international law and UN resolutions. The core of the whole truth was that the nuns had proved the administration’s own political and moral contradiction. In the end, they had to be convicted of sabotage to divert public attention from the embarrassment of the truth: America was at war in Iraq over a “crime” of which the entire nation was guilty in Colorado and Wyoming and Nebraska. (All these states reelected Bush.) The core of the whole truth was that Blackburn wrongfully influenced the jurors by his instructions and rulings so that jurors could only be allowed to think that the nuns were a menace in making their peaceful objections to WMD. This coincided with the ironic assumption that the government was right for killing thousands of people in Iraq over the WMD issue in order to restore freedom American-style. To provide the cover of fairness for the trial record, Blackburn, like Boland before him, allowed the defense in a pre-trial hearing to present an “antecedent proof acceptable to the court” (offer of proof). If accepted, it could be brought before the jury to justify the behavior of the nuns. However, upon hearing what two expert witnesses had to say, Blackburn summarily rejected their plea for such antecedent proof. The whole truth was not to be allowed in his court. WMD, as the prosecution argued, were good things necessary for the nation. The antecedent proof included pre-trial testimony from Professor Francis Boyle, who teaches international criminal law at the University of Illinois. Among his credentials, Boyle successfully proved that the sabotage by terrorists of the airliner over Locherbie, Scotland, was mass murder, not an act of war under international law. In the case of the nuns, Boyle told the judge and the prosecutors that any threat of use of the Minuteman III at silo N-8 is a crime against peace, a war crime and a crime against humanity under binding US and international law. He said that was true because N-8 and all like it are high-alert, first-strike 300kiloton nuclear weapons of mass extermination which does not discriminate between civilians and combatants.
71
WMD, Nukes and Nuns In other words, they constitute war crimes under the Geneva and Nuremberg protocols. However, the judge did not allow any of his testimony to be heard by the jury. More truth on the side of the nuns, which was never to reach the jury’s ears, was offered by Ved Nanda, professor of international law at the University of Denver on February 23, 2003. The prosecutor seemed shaken when Nanda said that the US threat by Bush to attack Iraq was real and in violation of basic US and international law. He added that the US has not excluded use of the Minuteman III missile in Iraq and threat of its use was thereby imminent. His conclusion was based on the fact that in late January the Los Angeles Times had broken the story that President Bush and the Pentagon had validated first-strike policy for use of nuclear weapons in Iraq. Imminent threat, as the prosecutor and the judge knew, is a war crime. Nanda concluded that the nonviolent and symbolic action by the nuns was reasonable, given the “very dangerous” circumstances. When the expert opinions of these highly qualified witnesses were rejected by the bench, it eliminated another chance for the jury to consider the whole truth. It eliminated the chance that the nuns would get a fair trial and it assured their convictions as saboteurs of the nation’s security. On the subject of national security and the nuns, Denver Post columnist Diane Carman put on public record these remarks April 6, 2003: Nuns’ Faith Finds Chink in US Armor With thousands of US troops poised to overtake Baghdad with shock, awe and whatever else is necessary to subdue the 5 million Iraqis who live there, the question before the US District Court in Denver last week was whether three nuns armed with wire cutters, hammers and their own blood constituted a threat to the national security of the United States of America. The questions were: Were the nuns trying to sabotage the mighty US government? Did they undermine our national defense? Did they damage the most powerful military on earth? Not allowed inside the courtroom was the other issue: Whether at least in principle the nuns might have a point. So with worldwide attention focused on them, the women in blaze-orange prison suits sat before a jury and a smiling judge in a red bow tie and made their case. Carol Gilbert, 55, Jackie Hudson, 68, and Ardeth Platte, 66, admitted to several facts for the prosecution.
72
Chapter 7. And Nothing but the Truth Yes, they said, they did carefully snip through the chain-link fence on the site of the Minuteman missile silo near Greeley on the morning of Oct. 6, 2002. They chose the date because it was the anniversary of the start of the war in Afghanistan. Yes, they cut the chain on a gate to enter the property, but they were careful not to damage the lock. A link on a chain or a fence can easily be fixed, Gilbert said. She’d done it many times herself back home in Baltimore. Yes, they did in fact flail away with their household hammers on the rusty railroad tracks that are installed for transport of weapons on the site. And yes, absolutely, they spilled containers of their own blood into shapes of crosses on the tracks and on the wall (lid) of the missile silo. “I’ve been tested. I don’t have AIDS,” Gilbert told the court. “We brought the blood in baby bottles.” Then, with the bloody crosses drying in the autumn sun, the nuns sang a song about the sacred earth and chanted, “Oh God, teach us how to be peacemakers in a hostile world.” After about 40 minutes of this, several soldiers driving Humvees crashed through the fence and, with their weapons drawn, surrounded the grayhaired women and handcuffed them. Oh, there was one other thing in the federal government’s case against the nuns: a rosary Sister Gilbert had left behind. It is Exhibit Z. Despite the barrage of objections from the prosecutor on relevance, the softspoken Dominicans took every opportunity to explain their intent on that day. They are people of conscience, they said. They have taken vows that require them to bear witness. In their church under God, poverty, hunger, homelessness and weapons of mass destruction are abominations. “Any nuclear weapon, even by its very existence, is a crime of genocide,” Gilbert said on the witness stand. “In Germany, when they put the Jews on the trains and gassed them, it was legal. Nobody was breaking a law. Yet we all wonder how the people of Germany could have allowed Hitler to do this.” Now, the US has nuclear missiles on high alert, poised to kill indiscriminately, and the nuns believe it was their duty — under Nuremberg Principles, international law and the tenets of their powerful faith — to stand in opposition to them (the missiles). “I believed I had to go there to stop a crime against humanity,” Gilbert said. “I knew this little hammer wasn’t going to stop the Minuteman missile, but I could say to my God, ‘This is not in my name. I’m not responsible.’” The sisters have long been part of Jonah House, a community founded in 1973 by former Jesuit priest Philip Berrigan. (Note: he was a Josephite, his brother Daniel was Jesuit) Berrigan became famous for protesting the Vietnam war and demonstrating for nuclear disarmament. He spent 11 years in prison for acts of civil disobedience. He died in December. His widow, Elizabeth McAlister, attended the trial of the nuns. In their closing arguments, the lawyers for the sisters reminded jurors that military officers had testified that the women had not jeopardized national defense or harmed the nuclear missiles at the site.
73
WMD, Nukes and Nuns The prosecutor spoke again of the willful destruction, the bloody crosses, and the affront to law, order and military security. Diminutive Sister Platte thanked them all — the jurors, the judge, the prosecutor, even the FBI agents. She talked about faith, peace and humanity amid war and death. She talked about trying to live a life that’s pure and true and holy. And then the defense of the three nuns in blaze orange prisons suits rested. Some say it was a charade. Some say it was a sacrilege. Some say it was idealism run amok. For the sisters, it is what gives life meaning. They took a stand for peace. They forced the US government and the world to pay attention. This week’s verdict won’t matter. They won.
Winning is what federal prosecutors and judges are most concerned about because it sets precedent; and precedents are either partial to or opposed to their fascist, hang-em-high point of view. Winning, when the verdict is forced by the judge upon the jury to convict, hides the truth from the public. It cheats justice. That there was malice and intent to rig the outcome from the bench is also shown by the prosecution’s effort to prevent the nuns from being called by their professional title, “sister,” in court. (No such discourtesies are attempted in cases where doctors or professors are involved.) Blackburn and Suthers, a Catholic, made sure of it here, however, to avoid any sympathy from the jury. In the end Blackburn delivered to the government he works for a sure-fire conviction. But to the extent that he works for the people of the United States, he failed. He did so by failing to uphold the Sixth Article of the US Constitution and his oath of office to defend the Constitution. Blackburn gave blessing to his government for state-sanctioned murder in Iraq, a policy directed by a president bound on revenge even after his UN weapons inspectors had succeeded in eliminating the chance that any WMD remained there. Blackburn tried to hide his juridical duplicity by quoting St. Paul’s passage in the Bible that the Christian should be subservient to the state. That passage, of course, was written when the Roman centurions were in charge. About the nuns and their self-assigned inspection, US Attorney John Suthers still pretends he does not see their point. Defense attorney Anabel Dwyer had spelled it out for him in a pre-trial letter dated January 22, 2003.
74
Chapter 7. And Nothing but the Truth Dear Mr. Suthers and Mr. Brown: I feel sure you are aware that only non-violent exposure, declaration, inspection and disarmament can end an illegal and criminal threat or use of weapons of mass destruction. This includes our own nuclear weapons. As you know, Carol Gilbert, O.P., and Jackie Marie Hudson, O.P., and Ardeth Platte,O.P., conducted a surprise inspection of a United States 300-kiloton nuclear weapon, the Minuteman III, N-8. They found it on high alert and symbolically disarmed it. The Sisters non-violently exposed on-going horrific United States war crimes and yet you prosecute them for such reasonable and courageous acts? They acted lawfully on our behalf. We ask you to release the Sisters now. We all need the services of such knowledgeable, strictly non-violent inspectors. As lawabiding citizens, we must fulfill our common obligation to pursue complete nuclear armament in good faith.
The letter was ignored. However, the federal prosecutors, having faced unprecedented public resentment over the excessive prosecution of the nuns, apparently learned a lesson. A year after the nun-saboteurs were imprisoned and Kabat had been convicted once again and jailed for separate actions, sympathizer Carol Carson cut her way into a Weld County missile silo. She acted alone, with no witnesses. To avoid giving her any publicity, the federales allowed her case to be tried in county court. Because she pled guilty, there was no publicity. In October 2004 she was fined $300 and the case was closed. The media blinked. In the case of the nuns, after the pre-trial hearing (when Suthers turned prosecution of the case over to Assistant DA Robert Brown), Suthers commented to one of their supporters, in an elevator, that he didn’t understand why the nuns, except for the purpose of rousing more public sympathy, refused to take his offer of free bail. “Because,” the supporter replied, “They haven’t committed a crime.” Clearly, the prosecutor and the federal government, on up to the White House never will understand the moral of the story.
75
CHAPTER 8. OF HUMAN ANGELS AND WOMEN MAYORS In his closing argument, Walter Gerash, one of four attorneys who helped defend the nuns pro bono, called them human angels. Judging by his wet cheeks, the words were neither empty rhetoric nor flattering hyperbole. A former US attorney general, Ramsey Clark, also was a defense counsel of record; Gerash’s statement was wrapped in flag, history and the righteousness of genuine morality. The three Dominican nuns for years had preached a gospel-by-example of doing good and resisting evil, as St. Paul commanded in one of his epistles. For resisting evil, they stood in danger of being convicted as saboteurs and a danger to national security. Gerash, a 78-year-old liberal firebrand, told the jury that the women, under vows of poverty, chastity and obedience for all of their adult lives, had behaved like guardian angels in human form. Their prophecy and their warning was against the very kind of evil that Bush himself pretended to decry: weapons of mass destruction. The trial’s backdrop was a classic study in moral contrasts: At the time of the trial, Bush was about to declare war and kill people so he could search Iraq for WMD. The nuns had declared peace, and prayed for the world — seeking a solution to the WMD problem that required no search and no killing. Bush was allowed to spill the blood of countless victims with impunity. The nuns were jailed for spilling their own blood in a symbolic prayer of peace. Bush was praised by society. The nuns were punished by his government.
77
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Bush claimed he was fighting “evil,” and that his war would discover WMD in Iraq. He found none; but he created what, to use his own vocabulary, is the “evil” of an unnecessary war. The nuns found the “evil” of WMD in America. They were punished for it. Where did they come from, these nuns? What were their motives? What inspiration drove them? They didn’t look like angels; more like gray-haired grandmas. There was nothing ethereal about them except for the softness of their smiles and the prickling penetration of their dewy eyes. But for the golden crosses at their throats, they didn’t look like nuns, either. Instead of ankle-length black habits and stiff, funny-looking white coifs and bonnets, they wore faded cotton-print blouses that might have come from the Goodwill store, and modest skirts or baggy slacks with battered tennies. No lipstick, no hairdos, no earrings, just the cosmetics of sincerity and the perfume of honesty. In the courtroom they chose to wear the fluorescent-orange prison jump suits provided by the state, to make a point with the jury about the unjust charges against them. This rankled the prosecution, who would have preferred to see them wear street clothes, the better to depict them as common criminals. At their sentencing, the nuns switched to black shawls and long black skirts, not unlike the robes worn by the judge himself. As sister Gilbert explained, they “dressed as women in black to identify with women around the world who stand in silent vigil for peace.” They stood in silence in the courtroom, at that point. The prosecution was also uncomfortable with the fact that the nuns had refused to take public recognizance bonds. By staying in jail during the trial preliminaries, the district attorney knew they got more sympathy from the newspaper and TV news public, and made the government look like schoolyard bullies. While pretending to extend the usual courtesies and respect that most of society extends to nuns, the prosecution raised the issue of whether or not they should be addressed as “sister” in court, or simply by their miss-so-and-so names. The defense urged that “sister” was a proper term of professional deference, such as that accorded a nurse, or doctor or general or professor, and won their point, although “sister” was generally avoided by the judge and prosecutors.
78
Chapter 8. Of Human Angels and Women Mayors Sister Ardeth Platte, OP Something is wrong. You can tell it from the life story of Ardeth Platte. How does a highly educated woman, a devoted nun, an idealistic high school principal and deeply moral mayor-pro-tem of Saginaw, Michigan, find herself declared a traitor to her country? Especially after she helped the state of Michigan become free of nuclear weapons two decades ago? Ardeth Platte was born April 10, 1936, in Westphalia, Michigan, the second of two children, at the peak of the Great Depression when families everywhere were oppressed by the economics of the times. She came from a close-knit family with strong ties to “many cousins.” Her father served in World War II. Ardeth attended Catholic schools, graduating high school in 1953 as valedictorian. After a year in college, she entered the community of Dominican sisters in Grand Rapids, Michigan, taking her first vows in 1956 and her final vows of poverty, chastity and obedience there in 1959. By then she had obtained her baccalaureate and teacher’s certificate. Sister Platte’s teaching career began at the junior high level and progressed to Catholic high schools in several cities in Michigan. “During the summers of 1964-1966 I helped administer an Upward Bound Program at Aquinas College,” Platte says. “Students were in the lowest socio-economic brackets and needed higher grades for college.” From 1966-1971, Sister Platte was principal of St. Joseph High School in Saginaw, Michigan. At the same time, she was coordinator of Adult Education Night School, the School for Dropouts and Retrieval Program and Family Education. In 1973, she was elected to the City Council of Saginaw, Michigan, where she was Mayor-pro-tem (1983). During parts of this period, Platte and Gilbert organized statewide opposition to nuclear weapons that were being deployed on Michigan soil at Wurtsmith AFB in Oscoda on Lake Huron and at K.I. Sawyer AFB in Guinn, near Lake Superior in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Then, until 1995, Platte says, “Sister Gilbert and I worked on other justice issues: poverty, nuclear power plant in Midland, criminal justice issues, racism and discrimination issues, fair housing, environmental issues, death penalty coalition, and so on.”
79
WMD, Nukes and Nuns From 1978 to 1995, the two nuns were “missioned to Baltimore’s Jonah House — a non-violent, faith-based community of civil resistance to nuclearism, the arms race, war and killing,” Sister Platte says. Jonah House was co-founded by ex-Josephite priest Philip Berrigan, who was the first to burn Selective Service records with home-made napalm during the Vietnam War, and by fellow activist John Bach. Berrigan’s initiative triggered the practice on campuses nationwide of burning draft cards in objection to the war in Vietnam, especially because the FBI’s manhunt for Jesuit priest Dan Berrigan made him a national hero in the headlines. In 1980, the Berrigan brothers and six others formed the Plowshares movement. Those six others included Oblate priest Carl Kabat, Dean Hammer, Elmer Maas, Anne Montgomery, Molly Rush and John Schuchardt. Collectively, they poured their blood over missile nose cones at a GE factory in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania. It was there they used the mantra of the prophet Isaiah who spoke of forming plowshares from swords. From within her community of nuns and outside associates, Platte says, “We commit to growing our own food, living a simple life style, feeding the people made poor, giving retreats, continuing our prayer, study, theological and Scripture reflections, actions directly opposing weapons of mass destruction, nuclear weapons, and war. We participated in all forms of non-violent direct actions.” Of her record of resistance, Platte says, “I could not recount the arrests; the sentences over the years since Vietnam. “Our [Platte’s and Gilbert’s] major full-time commitment to do nonviolent civil resistance to the weapons of mass destruction began in 1983-1985 in Michigan as we organized Faith and Resistance Retreats to close two Strategic Air Force Bases that had nuclear cruise missiles for deployment on B-52s. Michigan was sixth in the US with numbers of nuclear weapons deployed. We ‘witnessed’ at these two bases until all weapons were removed, the bases were closed and Michigan was nuclear-weapons free. “During these years we also did actions of civil resistance at the Nevada [A-bomb] test site; Offutt Air Force Base; the White House; ELF [Extremely Low Frequency site for Trident missiles] at Clam Lake, Wisconsin; and in Upper Michigan. Wurtsmith AFB in Oscoda, Michigan, was closed and was transformed to civilian use in 1993. K.I. Sawyer AFB was closed and transformed to civilian use in 1995,” Platte says.
80
Chapter 8. Of Human Angels and Women Mayors Platte and Gilbert also “continued our quest for disarmament by moving closer to Washington, D.C. We moved to Jonah House in Baltimore in March of 1995. [From there] our regular non-violent actions took place at the Pentagon, White House, NSA [National Security Administration], DOE [Department of Energy] World Bank, etc. We have also done actions at the naval submarine base and Electric Boat in Connecticut, at the US Mission to the United Nations in New York, and Andrews AFB.” Among the anti-nuclear Plowshares actions in which Platte, Gilbert and Hudson participated and which brought arrests, are: Weep for Children Plowshares in 1996 in Groton, Connecticut. (The occasion was the launching of the 18 th Trident-loaded nuclear submarine. The nuns spilled their own blood and wielded hammers.) Gods of Metal Plowshares in 1998 at Andrews Air Force Base in Prince George County, Maryland: (The occasion was an air show at which Father Frank Cordaro of Des Moines was also arrested for spilling blood on warplanes and applying hammers.) Sacred Earth and Space Plowshares in 2000 at Peterson AFB, Colorado Springs. (The occasion was an air show that coincided with the anniversary of the first Plowshares action in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania. Charges against the three Dominican nuns were dismissed for hammering on an F-18 fighter plane’s wing and spilling blood. Another object of their symbolic wrath was a ground satellite receiver.) As Platte puts it, “We wanted to show connections in the ‘kill chain’ of outer space, air and land.” Sacred Earth and Space Plowshares II at Minuteman Missile Silo N-8 in Colorado. (The occasion was to protest the emerging war in Iraq that was focused on Weapons of Mass Destruction.) In this action, Platte, Gilbert and Hudson inspected, exposed and symbolically disarmed a WMD. Platte calls all of her actions “my missionary ministries,” and she prays for the time when she can “return to my communities as a more giving and loving person.” Sister Carol Gilbert, OP Sister Carol Gilbert, a constant companion of Sister Ardeth Platte in the Dominican community since their focus on nuclear weapons, is not a former mayor of any city, but she has virtues and intelligence that would qualify her to be one.
81
WMD, Nukes and Nuns What she chooses instead is to be mayor of the kind of morality that her lawyer describes as angelic. Her choice has directed her, by forces beyond her control, to federal prison at Alderson, West Virginia, where she served a term that the president of the United States should have served, except that the US takes a schizophrenic position on WMD. Carol Gilbert was born in 1947 in Traverse City, Michigan. She was first in a family of two children. The Gilbert family was hard-working middle-class. She grew up to be a Dominican nun, teacher, liturgist and poet. As Denver Post reporter Eric Gorski describes “with her bookish glasses, she looks like the junior high teacher she once was.” In response to mailed questions, the answers Sister Gilbert returned from her jail cell show a gentle person of great humility but deep purpose and with little time for trivia. She would rather answer one-by-one the flood of letters she receives than spend much time talking about her accomplishments. “My time is limited,” she pleads. “The mail is overwhelming.” Then she writes her life story in terse notes, in the kind of script one might expect from a teacher who probably instructed her students that neatness and legibility of thought are part of your grade. “I was a junior high school teacher from 1969 to 1977 in various Michigan schools. Alternative Learning Center in Saginaw, Michigan, from 1977-1979. From 1979 on, I’ve been with Ardeth and she has the dates, places, and actions from memory. I don’t.” The dates, places and actions outlined above by Sister Platte show how totally involved Sister Gilbert has been in the integrity and peacefulness of creation and how closely she has worked with her convent comrades toward those goals. Her notes were written on the back side of a memorandum that announced the three Dominican sisters had been awarded The Nuclear Free Future Award in Munich, Germany, by the International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War. (See Chapter 14.) Sister Gilbert describes in her newsletter, entitled Ponderings from the Eternal Now, the pitiful “wages” prison inmates at Alderson accrue for their work ($5.25$18.00 a month “unless one works for the prison industry, UNICOR, for slave wages”). She mentions in a subsequent note that the women at Alderson prison sew the military jackets of the kind President Bush wore on his Thanksgiving appearance in Iraq.
82
Chapter 8. Of Human Angels and Women Mayors From this meager income, prisoners like her must pay $50-$70 for a pair of tennis shoes, for example, or $7.00 for a lock to secure personal possessions, which otherwise are stolen. To keep warm in the winter requires $20.00 if you want a scarf, mittens and hat. Long underwear (men’s) costs $8.00. “Fans, alarm clocks, watches, sunglasses — all must be purchased. Wash is done in the main laundry, but only the clothes they issue are so washed. In the housing units: Wash=$0.40, Dry=$0.40, Laundry soap=$2.00-$6.00. [It is not clear who takes the profit on these sales, but the movie “Shawshank Redemption” comes to mind.) One of the most telling, immoral and degrading parts of prison life for women, flowing from this system of penology by economic dominance, is described by Sister Gilbert: “Of course, selling one’s body for pay is the last resort for some of these women. This gives you an idea of how the poor remain poor…If any fines or restitution are owed, money is taken monthly from these wages. Life can be unbearable for these poor women…Makes one wonder what the difference is between the Prison-Industrial-Complex and the Military-Industrial-Complex.” Sister Jacqueline Hudson, OP Jackie Hudson was born in 1934 in Saginaw, Michigan, second in a family of two children. Situated near Lake Huron, Saginaw’s main industry was fishing — which in the Great Depression was anything but prosperous. Her father had attended seminary as a young man, and as the head of a Catholic household years later he said the rosary with his family every evening. Jackie says she often accompanied her mother on marketing trips with nuns to the local farms so that they could buy eggs and produce for the convent. In those days, nuns did not drive because, unlike priests, they had no vehicles. For 25 years, Sister Jackie taught piano and vocals to youngsters before venturing into the rough-and-tumble world of peace activism. Her early cause was devoted to orchard farm workers in Western Michigan. When nuclear cruise missiles arrived in Michigan in 1983, she joined Gilbert and Platte in protesting their evil presence on Michigan’s Great Lakes shores. When military strategy took the nuclear weapons away from the Michigan bases, Platte and Gilbert moved to the Jonah House in Baltimore, MD. Hudson directed her attention to Poulsbo, Washington, a locale that was home to a naval
83
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Trident submarine base. There she drove a transit bus and tuned pianos to support herself. The trio was reunited in 2000 for a common cause at Peterson Air Force Base in Colorado Springs. It was the anniversary of the first action taken by the founders of Plowshares, twenty years before, at a GE missile plant in Pennsylvania. At a public air show near Pikes Peak, the nuns sprinkled blood on fighter jets of the type that had been dropping bombs made of depleted uranium on Bosnia. Along with Platte and Gilbert, Hudson and two other nuns were held for a week in jail until federal authorities decided what to do with them. No significant damage had been done to the aircraft. Charges were dismissed and they were released. The real reason, Gilbert says, was to avoid publicity of the base’s Star-Wars nature. As fate would have it, the nuns received some support by way of lodging arrangements from fellow activist Bill Sulzman, whose anti-WMD work had caused his dismissal from the Denver diocese years prior. On hand at that time as Sulzman’s guest was Carl Kabat, who was free on bond facing trial in Denver for his trespass action the year before at missile silo N-7 in Colorado. Two years later (as Phil Berrigan lay dying in Baltimore), the nuns returned to Colorado to cut through a chain-link fence at missile silo N-8. This time, the nuns were treated as saboteurs. After being judged guilty on April 7, 2003, of sabotaging America’s national security, and after seven months in the holding cells of the mountain town of Georgetown, Colorado, the nuns decided to take the offer of personal recognizance bonds to settle their affairs in order to visit friends and supporters before sentencing and to spread their message. An interview by Diane Carman, columnist for The Denver Post, explains for the public their thinking on May 4, 2003: Nuns Glad to Trade Comfort for Jail Time The sisters have a confession to make. While Ardeth Platte, Jackie Hudson and Carol Gilbert are comfortable with their vow of poverty, they are not above savoring a few luxuries. The glorious feeling Wednesday night [April 30] of laying their heads on clean, white pillowcases in a quiet house with the light out after seven months in the Clear Creek County jail was, well, almost sinful. The Dominican nuns will have nearly three months of such exquisite comforts before they are incarcerated again. On July 25, they will be sentenced to federal prison for obstructing national defense and damaging public property. “We will joyfully accept the consequences of our civil resistance,” Platte said.
84
Chapter 8. Of Human Angels and Women Mayors The sisters admit to have been surprised by the guilty verdict last month. That snipping a hole in the chain link fence surrounding a Minuteman III missile, praying and making crosses with their own blood could be considered acts of sabotage seemed ridiculous. “I believe under the laws of the land and international law, we are not guilty,” Gilbert said. “There’s no question,” Platte said, “if we had a legal trial, we would have been acquitted. We had a political trial. We are political prisoners.” But the guilty verdict has not left them defeated. “You can jail the resister, but you can’t jail the resistance,” Platte said. In fact, as with the Tibetan Buddhist nun, Ngawang Sangdrol, the longest-held political prisoner in modern China, prison may turn out to be the ultimate pulpit for Hudson, 68; Platte, 66; and Gilbert, 55. While imprisoned in their basement cell in Clear Creek County, they received thousands of letters from supporters around the world. “In one week, we got letters from South Africa, Ireland, Italy, France, Nicaragua, Honduras, Australia and New Zealand,” Hudson said. And they wrote almost as many back, with friends posting messages on websites and in news-letters everywhere. They also became so close to their fellow inmates and guards that there were tears and hugs all around when the women left. “Like Nelson Mandela, who befriended the person who jailed him,” Platte said, “we offered our lives there as one little sample of what the world can be.” But just exactly what is this world they seek? The sisters preach and live a philosophy of nonviolence, simplicity, community, economic justice in which “all 6.3 billion people of the world have their basic human needs met,” and environmental sensitivity “where we are friends of creation.” They pray. They teach. They raise food in a garden, and then give it away. So you wonder, at a time when war supposedly has never been more popular, more exhilarating to Americans, are they simply out of touch? “I really don’t believe that a majority of people in America or in the world support war deep in their hearts,” Gilbert said. “Given the response we’ve had from all over the world, something does not quite jibe.” Americans, they say, have been duped. “Our society lives on sound bites,” Hudson said. “Many Americans are simply misinformed. I’ve read polls that say a majority of people believe that Saddam Hussein had everything to do with 9/11. People actually believe those were Iraqis flying those planes.” Gilbert reached across the table in an instinctive gesture of friendship. “I’m sorry to have to say this to you, but the major news media in this country are in collusion with the government in promoting this war.”
85
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Regardless of their beliefs and the devotion to conscience that brooks no compromise, the prospect of up to eight years in federal prison is still daunting to the women. “We have to take it one day at a time,” Platte said. “But sacrifice is essential. To sacrifice means to make sacred. We are trying to make our cause sacred.” The martyr Archbishop Oscar Arnulfo Romero called it “the planting of seeds,” said Hudson, who is the eldest of the three. “The seed must die to bring new life to others. It’s unseeable to us. But we know it will be there. It’s a matter of faith.” That John Suthers, US attorney for Colorado — “he’s a Roman Catholic,” Hudson said, “a graduate of Notre Dame” — celebrated their conviction disturbs them. They pray for him, just like they pray for President Bush. But they have no doubt about their righteousness. “While we were in jail, we heard from the master-general of the Dominican Order in Rome,” Gilbert said. “He wrote us a magnificent letter. He talked about our ‘powerful preaching’.” So I wondered, as the women relaxed in the comfortable convent house in northeast Denver and prepared for what could be a life sentence in prison, would you do it again? “Absolutely,” said Platte, “absolutely. This is not just a whim,” she said. “This is a life.”
Both while they were in jail and out on bail before sentencing the nuns were interviewed extensively by the media. Some “sound bites” from those interviews offer insight as to their motives. They contrast sharply with the course mapped out by President Bush. Karen Abbott of the Rocky Mountain News filed this report for the public on April 2, 2003: A Catholic nun wept Tuesday as she told federal jurors why she and two others cut fences and painted crosses in blood at a nuclear missile silo in northeastern Colorado in October. The crosses were a symbolic protest. The Minuteman III nuclear missile, in an underground silo, is real, and the nuns wanted Americans to know how destructive it could be. “We want to bring about a lasting peace…total disarmament, all over the world,” said Dominican Sister Ardeth Platte in a breaking voice. “We want the people of this world to live. If we have to spend the rest of our lives in prison,” Platte said, “we will.” The three gray-haired nuns in orange jail jumpsuits are on trial for damaging federal property and injuring, interfering with, or attempting to injure national defense material — all federal crimes. Platte, Carol Gilbert and Jackie Marie Hudson admit they deliberately went to the nuclear missile silo in northeastern Colorado. They cut gate chains and chainlink fence panels, banged on the silo’s 110-ton concrete lid with household hammers, painted crosses in blood, sang about the sacredness of life and prayed.
86
Chapter 8. Of Human Angels and Women Mayors Prosecutor Robert Brown told jurors as the trial opened Tuesday that the US nuclear missiles in underground silos are vital to the nation’s defense. “They are weapons that have kept anyone from firing a missile at this country for over 40 years,” Brown said. “It’s called deterrence.” “It would be nice if nuclear weapons had never been invented,” Brown said, “but they work.” Defense attorney Walter Gerash said the nuns were moved to commit their symbolic actions by their religious beliefs. “Now, is that bad?” he asked jurors. He accused federal prosecutors of charging the nuns with much more serious crimes than actually occurred, interfering with their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and freedom of religion. The nuns admit they trespassed, Gerash said, “but they aren’t charged with that.” How, he demanded, does painting crosses in blood interfere with the national defense? Defense attorney Susan Tyburski said the nuns were careful to cause as little physical damage as possible — for instance, cutting only one link in each gate chain, which could be replaced easily for about $2.00. Cleaning up the blood, she said, would cost only about $200. Defense lawyers said the government must prove at least $1,000 in damage to convict the nuns of damaging government property. Military personnel who apprehended the nuns were ordered to crash through the fence to get to them, Tyburski said. “The military actually caused more destruction,” she said.
After a 7-month wait, time which they chose to spend in jail, on Friday, July 25, 2003, the three rebels heard the gavel of Judge Robert Blackburn fall as he sentenced them to federal prison terms ranging from 41 to 33 to 30 months, respectively. The Denver Post’s columnist, Diane Carman, captured the drama of the moment in a Sunday column: Underneath his punctilious demeanor, Judge Robert Blackburn was plainly exasperated. The three elderly women before him were incorrigible. Dressed in black with black veils, black socks and shoes, they were engaged in a silent protest, responding to his question with simple nods of the head. They smiled beatifically and their lawyers read to the court their messages of love. One of the lawyers even called them “human angels.” What should the judge do with these blasted women? Carol Gilbert, Ardeth Platte and Jackie Hudson are convicted felons. They’re also Dominican nuns who pray for the judge every day.
87
WMD, Nukes and Nuns They don’t fit the standard profile of habitual offenders in the US District Court. But when Assistant US Attorney Robert Brown read their considerable criminal records dating back to 1980 into the record Friday, it was clear that at least under the law of the land, they qualify. It’s the law of the land they don’t accept. They do accept responsibility for their symbolic acts, though. They snipped through a chain-link fence surrounding a Minuteman III missile site in northern Colorado, spilled their blood in the shape of crosses, banged on the facilities with small hammers, and chanted prayers. They admit they did it. They just refuse to say it was wrong. As Blackburn said in his soliloquy before he pronounced their sentences for obstructing national defense and injuring federal property, this was “a no-win situation.” Amen. In front of the downtown Denver courthouse was a crowd of demonstrators. They paraded peacefully, chanting and banging drums. A woman dressed as the Statue of Liberty stood in the middle of the crowd, her lamp drooping, her eyes closed, her mouth taped shut. Correspondents from as far away as Germany stood on the sidewalks, videotaping their reports. The judge was unmoved. He accused the women of “exploiting gender, their vocation and their religion” in their pitiable defense, and then he did his best to gratuitously outdo them before he imposed sentence. He cited endless statutes and court cases by number, fulminated on legal philosophy and the profound contribution war has made to our culture, and tossed around enough references to scripture and Christianity to prove he could exploit sanctimony with the best of them. And just when the peacenik supporters who had packed two courtrooms and remained riveted to every word of the three-hour proceeding were shaking their heads and muttering, anticipating the worst, the judge surprised them. No, he didn’t let them go. He just didn’t give them the max. Walter Gerash, the theatrical defense attorney who represented Hudson, said he was surprised. “I expected the women to get seven, eight and nine years,” he said. Hudson got 30 months, Gilbert got 33 months and Platte got 41 months. “They shouldn’t have been charged in the first place,” Gerash said, but with time served and good behavior he figured they’d serve 1½, 2 1/4 and 3 years, respectively. “It could have been a lot worse,” said attorney Scott Poland, who represented Platte.
88
Chapter 8. Of Human Angels and Women Mayors But as a standard for justice, that’s not saying much. The nuns were prosecuted because they were insubordinate to the almighty US government. By the government’s own inflated calculations, they did a grand total of $3,080.04 in damage. Not for an instant did they threaten the defense capabilities of the country or hamper the ability of the military to deploy the nuclear warhead. They demonstrated to make a point. They believe weapons of mass destruction — all of them — are immoral. For this, we will pay for their incarceration in federal prison for years. The prosecution, the defense and the judge all cited historic events to justify their arguments. Here’s one they didn’t mention: In 1968, the Chicago Eight were arrested and charged with multiple counts of conspiracy to incite riots, inciting riots and obstructing police officers outside the Democratic National Convention in Chicago. Their subsequent trial was a freak show with anti-war pronouncements, profane outbursts, protests and challenges to the judge. Bobby Seale was bound, gagged and jailed for contempt of court. Demonstrators chanted and picketed the proceedings for days. In the end, five of the protesters were convicted. The longest sentence imposed was five years. Some of them served only a few years. Two years later, their convictions were overturned on appeal. The sentences were dismissed. They all went free. The country survived. I’d venture to say if the nuns had been released it would have made it this time, too.
Now that the nuns are in federal prisons, the nation can come down from its color-coded security alerts and breathe easy. (The nation hasn’t even noticed that since the sentencing of the nuns on July 25 and the middle of November, the Homeland Security Department has not flashed any colored lights of warning about security level hazards.) In the meantime, the attorneys for the nuns have consolidated their appeals on the grounds that the US attorneys Brown and Suthers did not prove damage to national security, and that the judge erred by failing to direct the jury’s attention to the testimony of two military witnesses in charge of silo N-8 who testified under cross examination that the action of the nuns never interfered with national security operations or harmed the silo in any significant manner. In explaining the appeal, Gerash said that Col. Frank Gallegos and other officers testified (in Gerash’s words) that “the hammering and the crosses and the cutting of the fence did not impede national defense or the ability of the silo crew to launch the missiles if necessary.”
89
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Gerash went on to explain that under military rule 29 of the US Code applicable to the case, “if there is insufficient evidence (to prove the impedance) then the court must dismiss the charge.” Instead, Gerash claims, Blackburn ruled that the defense had not proved that the officers most directly in charge of the silo complex security were “expert witnesses,” even though they were brought in as witnesses for the prosecution. Further, Gerash says, Blackburn wrongly ruled that the damaged fence was an essential part of the country’s nation’s defense material and that the court erroneously accepted from the prosecution an inflated estimate of damage done by the nuns. If the Appeals Court grants the motion for reversal of these errors, the nuns could go free, Gerash says. He wishes the nuns had waited for the outcome of the appeal before opting to accept their prison terms, because he is confident of a reversal. “I think it [the charge] was outrageous,” Gerash says. “It [the trial and the judge’s ruling] was a legal fraud. They [the prosecution] introduced no evidence that they [the nuns] injured national defense. It [the testimony of the colonels] was just the opposite. All you have to do is look at the transcript.” That transcript is now in the hands of Denver attorney Cliff Bernard who is handling the appeal. [That appeal hearing was held October 1, 2004. The nuns lost in March 2005.]
90
CHAPTER 9. NUNS AND OTHER MOTHERS WHO TEACH THEIR CHILDREN “Teach your children well…” — Crosby, Stills & Nash
Some people say that fathers teach about life and death while mothers teach about love. How childless yet nurturing nuns fit into this idealized ebb and flow of life, love and harsh reality raises a question easily answered. Nuns are the spiritual and moral mothers of children they did not bear, but to whom they can impart a spiritual sort of life that is just as important as the flesh-and-blood side. Those nuns who are less-subservient and more critical of the male-dominated war system preach this moral difference by carrying their protests to the sites of WMD which threaten to kill everyone’s children. They decry the warping of the communal conscience — apparently to no avail. The war-dominated US system responds by jailing them. The war-dominated US system doesn’t tolerate impudence and neither will the courts that are dominated by the system. And that is how the strands of maternal influence are removed from the interwoven fabric of church and state and families that live in both the secular and religious spheres of that system. The same thing happens in Islamic cultures. Within that negative framework, these spiritual mothers preach and protest against the use of the weapons of war by both sides, pointing out the horrible consequences of this societal disconnection. War is raw rage and suffering. That is why its survivors return to peace both physically and emotionally
91
WMD, Nukes and Nuns shocked. Victory in war is no excuse for the inhumanity of war; and the political “need” for killing cannot make war civilized or just. Such civility would seem to be the raison d’etre for the Geneva Conventions. With the advent of the nuclear weapon, the Geneva question is whether a nuclear bomb is “one big bullet” aimed at a million people, and therefore is just as permissible under Geneva as a billion bullets from a million rifles, or machine guns, or even the fragments of grenades. Certainly, WMD by their nature do not distinguish between civilians and civilians in uniform or between front lines and city boundaries. Such issues are still on America’s conscience in 2006 — or, at least, they should be. The same issues must be on the minds of the three nuns, Cindy Sheehan and President G.W. Bush at Crawford, Texas, as American and Iraqi lives are blown apart in Iraq. Those issues are also on the mind of Noam Chomsky, who wrote for the Independent/UK on the occasion of the 60th anniversary of the Hiroshima horror in 2005: The recent explosions and casualties in London are yet another reminder of how the cycle of attack-and-response could escalate, even to a point horrifically worse than Hiroshima or Nagasaki. The world’s reigning power accords itself the right to wage war at will, under a doctrine of “anticipatory self-defense,” that covers any contingency it chooses. The means of destruction are to be unlimited. There have been efforts to strengthen the thin thread on which survival hangs. The most important is the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), which came into force in 1970…. The NPT has been facing collapse, primarily because of the failure of the nuclear states to live up to their obligation to…eliminate nuclear weapons.... The United States has led the way in [this] refusal.
And America under G.W. Bush undertook on such thin-threaded policy the war against Iraq’s non-existent nuclear weapons in order to preserve its own ownership of the very same kind of WMD. One of the sad outcomes is that the war encourages the free-lance Christian crusaders who follow Robertson or Falwell to do violence for the sake of their idea of God, and in a war that was launched on a lie, at that. As “politically correct” Christians do so, they leave behind the righteous and moral part of the nation that three nuns are trying desperately to preserve. For his part, Chomsky tells the world that “the thread has almost snapped in the years since Hiroshima, repeatedly.” He cites the Cuban missile crisis and former-defense secretary Robert McNamara’s characterization of that event as coming “within a hair’s breadth of nuclear disaster.”
92
Chapter 9. Nuns and Other Mothers Who Teach Their Children Among his conclusions, Chomsky says: “The probability of apocalypse soon cannot be realistically estimated, but it is surely too high for any sane person to contemplate with equanimity. While speculation is pointless, reaction to the threat of another Hiroshima is not.” Chomsky’s worry is not without foundation at a time when America is trading nuclear secrets for political suasion in Pakistan.” The probability of such an apocalypse is exactly what three imprisoned nuns were trying to prevent. In the bloody political wash of current events, Americans must decide whether to “stay the course” or look to their moral compass for a more promising way forward. Then there are birth-mothers who think like the nuns do about the war in Iraq; real mothers who have lost children in that war; real mothers who have belatedly joined the nuns in protest; real mothers who have felt the sting of those weapons in brutal action. Take the case of Cindy Sheehan, the mother of a young man named Casey who was killed in 2004 while serving in Iraq. Sheehan, of Vacaville, California, camped for several weeks in the summer of 2005 near the ranch vacation home of President George Bush at Crawford, Texas. She set up a roadside tent village called Camp Casey, and vowed to stay there until the president explained to her, one-on-one, when he would withdraw US troops from Iraq. Bush brushed that request aside, saying he had already talked with her and several other families who had suffered losses in Iraq. At the same time, he defended her right of free speech and protest and the right to appeal to her president, but told reporters that he needed to keep a “balanced” approach in the unfolding national crosstalk about the war. He said he needed his own privacy to keep that balance, and that was why he was on vacation. He indicated that if he talked one-on-one with every individual he would lose that balance and the time needed for presidential decisionmaking (about making war). He soon answered Sheehan’s question with the Republican motto that seems to be his blanket answer to everything: “stay the course.” Bush’s decision about the immediate future, however, seemed as easily made as the one to invade Iraq in the first place. By 2005 he was a “lame duck” president — not eligible for re-election and therefore not subject to any further judgment in the polling booth. Given that immunity from public sanction, he called Sheehan’s suggestion for withdrawing the troops at this time a mistake. (He has done likewise with similar suggestions from some Congressmen.)
93
WMD, Nukes and Nuns Sheehan’s protest created media attention and a stir of emotions deep in the heart of Texas. The emotions got so deep that Bush’s neighbors complained of clogged roads. Some voiced worries about the safety of their children traveling such roads on school buses. Ironically, they expressed no worries about the safety of their draft-age children, nor did they sympathize with the concerns of mothers of grown-up children-become-warriors in Iraq. Sheehan’s cause did not die on a dead-end road at the Texas White House. She took it to the Potomac White House gates, where the media picked up the signals from the Oval Room spin doctors. From Sheehan’s more desperate statements, they spun a web of subversive purpose to discredit her, just as the trials of the nuns were designed discredit them. In any case, Sheehan struck a chord with earlier CIA peacenik targets such as Rev. Darrell Rupiper who, but for Jimmy Carter’s debacle in the desert, might have secured the release of America’s Tehran hostages. Rupiper passes along the internet words of Robert Jensen, a journalism professor of the University of Texas at Austin, who acknowledges he is “not of the church.” “We know,” Jensen says, “there can be no difference between how we treat those we love and those on the other side of the world, whom we will never know and never touch.” Basing his comments on the agony of Sheehan over the loss of her son, Jensen continues. “If our lives and the lives of the ones we love have value — if, by virtue of being human, we have a claim to life and dignity in living — then everyone must have that same claim.” “Somewhere in Iraq right now, there is a mother looking into the grave of her child. We live in the most powerful…the most affluent nation in the history of the world…born of violence and maintained by violence. We can choose to be part of that violence, or we can choose to help create a different world…We can imagine a better world — a world in which no one suffers merely to protect our power and affluence.” However, Bush refused to concede anything about his views on the Iraq war or troop withdrawal except to “stay the course.” Like the Iraq war itself, the Sheehan episode is full of ironies. Here was a president taking a vacation in the middle of a war against terrorism — one which Bush chose to expand into Iraq without any real basis. No president in time of true war ever took a six-week vacation. That alone sends a tacit message to the public: that we need not take the war against terrorism seriously. What kind of war is it, when the president has not and cannot declare war on an identifiable enemy except a religion which has
94
Chapter 9. Nuns and Other Mothers Who Teach Their Children no boundaries? That’s why the people of Texas cared more about the traffic disruptions Sheehan created than they about the terrorists or the continuing killing of American men and women in Iraq. Another irony is that no clerical representative of any American Christian Church, as of August 1, 2005, has supported the Camp Casey protest as a means to make the point that the US war in Iraq is immoral. Perhaps that is because the role of the church has been taken over by the presidential pulpit of the war on terrorism. In fact, the moral power of the Christian Church itself has become subsumed into the religious-political fabric of America and all of its wars. That war was first announced by Bush to be a “crusade” — as if the White House and Pentagon had become God’s Christian arm for slaying the infidel heathens. The White House has assumed the medieval Divine Right of kings to wage war and kill at will on behalf of their kingdoms. The very purpose of the Constitution, with its dictum separating the church and state into two distinct influences, was to keep presidents from becoming kings in the image of George III of England. The only difference between today’s war in Iraq and the days of the Crusades a millennium ago is the nature of the weapons used and the massive scale on which innocent bystanders are indiscriminately slaughtered — “collateral damage” of a type supposedly outlawed by Geneva Conventions — and the opposition of three nuns, along with mothers like Cindy Sheehan. Nuremberg was perhaps the last time America adhered to the Geneva Conventions governing war and peace; now, Americans seem to be proud of a criminal, violent-minded president who rejects such treaties and undoes what Congress has ratified. Nuns, popularly viewed as pious virgins confined to cloistered convents or used as teachers of children, know that such military thinking adds to the chaos and violence in the world. They learned enough history to see that it was America which had invented the mother of all WMD and they looked for a way to persuade America to recognize and renounce the aggressive stance and the disdain, the disrespect for human life that WMD represent. Like concerned mothers, they predicted that America’s conduct would lead to war, and they ended up in jail. Right now, the nuns and mothers are upset that those whom they educated did not learn their lessons. Three nuns understood that it was America who had inspired even its political foes to possess and use WMD, even in the form of airliners in the case of
95
WMD, Nukes and Nuns the World Trade towers. The nuns realized that it was the height of hypocrisy for the world’s self-proclaimed landlord to wage war on the feigned moral ground of forcing “freedom,” American style, upon a nation on the other side of the globe. As the saying goes, “A person convinced against his will remains an enemy stronger still.” Has it occurred to anyone that war cannot create freedom and justice and peace except the unjust peace of death? A newsletter from Sister Ardeth Platte dated January 2004 reflects the way nuns like her would raise us as children: Let us take back our civil rights: In the United States one of every 37 of us has been imprisoned some time. The prison industrial system is collapsing under the Ashcroft-Bush style of “patriotism.” Will we allow them to stop our dissent by fascist and police-state tactics? Will we be complicit in empire building, globalization, preemptive strike policies, permanent war making and obscene corporate profiteering? Homeland insecurity: 1) Disregarding international law. 2) Rejecting the Kyoto Treaty. 3) Pulling out of the ABM treaty. 4) Abrogating the Land Mine Treaty and Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty. 5) Building the Missile Defense System. 6) Continuing the dominance and exploitation of space program. 7) New nuclear weapon construction. 8) Increasing War Department spending. 9) Arrogant stances against United Nations and other countries. 10) Rejecting the International Criminal Court. 11) Nuclear Posture Review. 12) US as number one debtor nation. 13) Worldwide malnutrition starving and homelessness. 14) Lack of basic humane living conditions. 15) Rampant disease and little care or treatment. 15) Billions of people living on $1-2 a day. 16) Environmental devastation of water, land, air and space. What is our hope? Ban nuclearism, war and killing…Let us make our country a model of nonviolence, compassion, simpler lifestyle and beatitude living.
96
Chapter 9. Nuns and Other Mothers Who Teach Their Children These are the darker aspects of the American culture the nuns tried to put on display by their actions. Their view puts a philosophical finger on what happened and why at the World Trade Towers. The events of 9/11, when Muslim extremists found a way to turn everyday equipment into WMD, convinced Americans that if the extremists had had access to “intentional” WMD, they would have used them to make the same deadly and self-destructive point that America did in 1945. And so the war of terror among otherwise intelligent human beings is renewed. Incredibly, President G. W. Bush uttered the word “crusade” the very day after the Twin Towers were leveled. His utterance confirmed fears in Muslim lands that the West is still out to capture them, and rekindled all the associated animosity between two cultures. Just as incredibly — and exploiting American public outrage and frustration over the failure of the hunt for Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan — G. W. Bush declared that Iraq was the center of the threat from WMD. Somebody, some nation, had to pay for 9/11. That nation was to be Afghanistan first and then Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. In America, anyone who objected was considered to be an ally of Osama bin Laden. Few Americans understood that the satanized-Saddam had been armed by former president G. H.W. Bush when he was CIA chief in the mid-1970s, as reported in the book Prophets Without Honor. To this day, few ordinary Americans realize that Saddam was further armed by then Vice President G.H.W. Bush who used Saddam as a CIA “asset” for striking back at Iran for the Tehran hostage taking. Almost nobody cares that Iraq, fighting Iran during the IranContra scandal, received its poison gas WMD from Florida-based companies owned by a Bush-run cartel. Today in Iraq and America, the younger generation in particular has no idea what has been happening behind the scenes of history. All they know is hatred of the other side, because of the pain that theocracies inflict on each other. As the German poet Johann Wolfgang von Goethe put it: “There is nothing more frightening than ignorance in action.” These, then, are the conditions under which the militaristic male-dominated world operates and presumes to teach its children. Nobody but three nuns seems really to see that World War III already have started in a new, splintered and incoherent fashion. How else to explain the violent and politically-sanctioned events that have taken 180 million lives since
97
WMD, Nukes and Nuns WW II? Who besides the three nuns sees that the world is now working its way to WW F (Final)? Into this fray, from the feminine side and with no weapons but their minds, souls and long skirts are three nuns who understand the human tragedy of all weapons systems and their political-military-economic consequences. Their interest is to prevent war and the killing of children — and adults — on all sides. Accordingly, three religious and celibate mothers, of the kind who teach children that love nurtures life, drew attention to the location of dozens of WMD on the day of their arrest. The nuns found WMD in Colorado several months before America committed billions of dollars to send troops abroad to begin the deadly and fruitless search for them in Iraq. At issue for the future of the world is whether the children of any land will be taught that the morality of any system, to be civilized, must be life-affirming, as these nuns and mothers such as Cindy Sheehan understand so well.
98
CHAPTER 10. IN THE WRECKAGE OF 9/11 “Violence does not and cannot exist by itself. It is invariably intertwined with a lie. —Solzhenitsyn
Many sad things came to pass following the violence of the World Trade Towers. The book Prophets Without Honor, written about US-Middle Eastern intrigue over WMD prior to the World Trade disaster, was an overlooked prophecy about 9/11. Likewise, already forgotten are ex-GI and priest-prophet Philip Berrigan, who was arrested and jailed dozens of times for his peaceful demonstrations in favor of abolishing nuclear weapons. He died at age 79 in 2002. Even so, the next generation will inherit unknowingly the benefits of what he and three nuns set in motion long before 9/11. Their living prayer has been that the combined strength of politics, morality and technology might find a way to immunize the world against weapons of mass destruction. If that is ever done, then their lost prayer and sacrifice for peace will have been found. The book Prophets Without Honor was banned in 2002 by the US military in the Fort Benning-controlled town of Columbus, Georgia, where thousands of anti-war protesters gather each year. Under government pressure, book sellers as significant as Barnes & Noble were convinced not to promote the book. One community relations bookseller in Columbus lost her job after committing to host that book event. Even though the major media were notified of this trampling of First Amendment rights (which should be a keen concern to journalists), the media failed to pick up the story. It would seem we have already lost
99
WMD, Nukes and Nuns the right to feel secure in saying anything critical of WMD or the USA PATRIOT ACT. Neither those holding power nor the citizens who yield that power to their leaders are concerned about the unjust imprisonment of prophets and the obstruction of First Amendment rights at the individual level. Collectively, these are greater threats to America as a nation than a dictatorial leader in a far-away land, but there is no war being waged to remove these threats. Since 9/11 ever-greater threats to the lives of individual Americans have been launched by our own elected leaders. The war in Iraq has claimed more American lives than the mass murders at the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. And as everyone knows, Iraq had nothing to do with those 9/11 events. The 9/11 attacks killed nearly 3,000 people, making it the largest single act of mass murder perpetrated by means of treachery. It was larger even than the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, which was an act of war perpetrated by a nation in response to a perceived threat. America’s war in Iraq has killed perhaps 100 times more people than the terrorists killed in Manhattan and the Pentagon on 9/11. Does that make us “even”? If you go by body count, the answer is yes. But by running up the score in the process of misplaced retribution, Bush has created more foes who themselves call for revenge and who have no other weapon but suicide. America is promoting the pattern of strike/counter-strike so familiar in Israel and Palestine. For that reason, there is no viable exit strategy for America. Afghanistan and Iraq have been devastated by “ugly Americans” in the worst sense of the term. All Americans, now, whether of good will or nil, are hated as occupiers of those faraway lands. Who can blame them except vengeful Americans? Thus the killing, which the White House said would bring peace, can only foment more killing. As Alexander Solzhenitsyn noted in his Nobel Lecture of 1972, “violence does not and cannot exist by itself; it is invariably intertwined with the lie.” If the nuns and other voices of peace and reason had prevailed, there would have been no need to “get even.” In the 9/11 case, there could have been trials for mass murder at the World Court level as there was for the Lockerbie, Scotland, airline assassinations. But America has rejected the authority of the World Court and even the United Nations. Otherwise, Osama bin Laden might not have become such a
100
Chapter 10. In the Wreckage of 9/11 popular figure protected by his adherents. But US politicians and militarists do not look at the world through any lens but that of war. The bellicose G.W. Bush administration diverted hundreds of billions of dollars to war efforts when dollars were needed to prop up America’s own failing domestic economy, repair its ghettos and restore the city of New Orleans and the surrounding region. Now, more dollars are being drained and the nation’s debt ceiling is being raised to make war reparations. Fiscal irresponsibility may yet bring down the tower of the world economy in a pan-caking collapse more calamitous than that of the World Trade Towers. With events still un-spooling beyond control in the Middle East, nuclear WMD are still right where the nuns and their colleagues said they were. These prophets include the Berrigans, the Kabats, and individuals such as Darrell Rupiper, who was negotiating the release of the Tehran hostages, just days before the CIA’s plan resulted in the military debacle in Iran’s desert. Just days before the botched raid, Rupiper’s Iranian student friend was beaten to death in Omaha by the CIA while Rupiper was in Tehran. Rupiper served time in federal prison and for years after was harassed by the CIA who treated him like a traitor. Other moral leaders include Fr. Larry Rosebaugh and Fr. Roy Bourgeois, who peacefully infiltrated Fort Benning with a tape recording of Archbishop Oscar Romero in El Salvador (assassinated by the CIA). It is at Fort Benning and the School of the Americas (Columbus, Georgia) that the US did much of its training of terrorists, terrorists who were expected to unleash merciless brutality in Central America on Washington’s orders. Romero was assassinated while saying mass. Rosebaugh and Bourgeois served time in federal prison. In all, this informal community includes hundreds of anti-nuclear pickets who were arrested and jailed, even before the USA PATRIOT Act came into play. Frank Cordaro and Michael Palecek both served time under federal sentence for protests as non-threatening as stepping across a line drawn by the military at the gates of their bases. It even includes a Congressional Medal of Honor holder, Charles (Angelo) Liteky, a former Catholic chaplain who went eyeball-to-eyeball with General Abrams over body counts and bounties for GIs in Vietnam. When Liteky sided with Bourgeois, he surrendered his Medal of Honor at the Vietnam War Memorial. He is the only recipient in history to do so.
101
WMD, Nukes and Nuns This kind of exemplary conduct never was the exclusive domain of male prophets. Many of these gently-in-your-face individuals are women of special courage. Their actions are not uniqu