Tropical Forestry
Tropical Forestry Volumes Already Published in this Series Tropical Forest Genetics by Finkeldey, R...
250 downloads
3023 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Tropical Forestry
Tropical Forestry Volumes Already Published in this Series Tropical Forest Genetics by Finkeldey, R., Hattemer, H. 2007 ISBN: 3-540-37396-9 Sampling Methods, Remote Sensing and GIS Multiresource Forest Inventory by Köhl, M. Magnussen, S., Marchetti M. 2006 ISBN: 3-540-32571-9 Tropical Forest Ecology - The Basis for Conservation and Management by Montagnini, F., Jordan C. 2005 ISBN: 3-540-23797-6
Reiner Finkeldey Hans H. Hattemer ●
Tropical Forest Genetics With 44 Figures and 19 Tables
Professor Dr. Reiner Finkeldey Professor Dr. Hans H. Hattemer Institute of Forest Genetics and Forest Tree Breeding Büsgenweg 2 D-37077 Göttingen Germany
ISSN: 1614-9785 ISBN-10 3-540-37396-9 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN-13 978-3-540-37396-4 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2006931487 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer-Verlag is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2007 The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Editor: Dr. Dieter Czeschlik, Heidelberg Desk Editor: Anette Lindqvist, Heidelberg Production: SPi Typesetting: SPi Cover Design: Design & Production, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
3/3152-HM
5 4 3 2 1 0
Preface
This book is intended to provide information on fundamental genetic processes in tropical forests. It is based on lecture notes by the authors prepared for postgraduate students, mainly from tropical countries, of the M.Sc. course “Tropical and International Forestry” at the Faculty of Forest Sciences and Forest Ecology, Georg August University Göttingen, Germany. The intended readership is students, researchers and practitioners interested in the genetic variation of species, in particular forest trees, living in complex forest ecosystems in the tropics. Particular emphasis is placed on the human impact on forest genetic resources in the tropics. Readers should be familiar with basics of classical and molecular genetics such as the structure and function of DNA (double-helix structure, replication), polypeptide synthesis (transcription and translation), and the transmission of genetic information during sexual reproduction (“Mendel’s rules”). This knowledge is easily available from recently published genetics textbooks; we recommend the book by Griffiths et al. (2000). The development of biochemical and molecular marker techniques and their application to species of tropical forests have greatly improved our knowledge of genetic variation patterns of “wild” plants in the tropics during the last two decades. Many examples in this book are based on gene marker techniques. We discuss the results of selected molecular studies and their implications for the development of sustainable management strategies for forest genetic resources. However, we refrain from providing details on laboratory techniques and statistical data analyses. Readers should consult the cited references or the book by Weising et al. (2005) if they require additional information in this regard. No advanced knowledge concerning modern molecular or statistical methods for the analysis of genetic variation patterns is necessary to follow the argumentation of this book. Comprehensive data on DNA sequences are becoming available for more and more plants, including forest trees. The first project aimed at sequencing the full genome of a forest tree (Populus trichocarpa) has recently been completed (Brunner et al. 2004). However, only very few genomic data are currently
VI
Preface
available for tropical forest trees; tropical forest genetics is still in a “pregenomic era.” Thus, the focus of this book in on population genetics processes in natural and managed tropical forests rather than on genomics and related, newly emerging fields of research in forest genetics.
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to Oliver Gailing for critically reading Sect. 12.5.4 to Barbara Vornam and Martin Ziehe for assistance in literature search and in word processing, and to Wolfgang Tambour for preparing Figures 7.1, 7.2, 7.5, and 12.4. July 2006
Reiner Finkeldey Hans H. Hattemer
Contents
1
Introduction – Genetics of Tropical Forests
Part A Genetic Processes in Tropical Forests 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.3.1 2.3.1.1 2.3.1.2 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.4 2.4.1
1 3 5 5 5 6 6 7 12 13 14 15 16 16
2.5 2.6 2.7
Population Genetics – an Overview Introduction The Population Variation at Gene Loci The Molecular Basis of Genetic Variation Molecular Markers Biochemical Markers – Isozymes The Gene As a Unit of Heredity The Mode of Inheritance Definition and Classification of Gene Markers Genetic Structures Within Populations Allelic and Genotypic Structures Example 2.1: Genetic Structures at an Isozyme Gene Locus in Dalbergia sissoo Variation at Uniparentally Inherited Markers Example 2.2: Diversity of cpDNA Haplotypes in D. sissoo Evolution and Evolutionary Factors Phenotypic Variation Recommended Literature
3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.3.1 3.3.1.1 3.3.1.2 3.3.2 3.3.2.1 3.3.2.2
Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants Introduction Genetic Inventories Measurement of Genetic Variation Genetic Variation Within Populations Genetic Multiplicity Genetic Diversity Genetic Differentiation Among Populations Genetic Distances Genetic Differentiation
23 23 23 24 24 25 25 27 27 27
2.4.2
17 18 18 19 21 22
VIII
Contents
3.4 3.5
28 31
3.6
Genetic Variation in Tropical Forest Species – General Trends Case Studies on Genetic Variation Patterns Example 3.1: Genetic Variation at Isozyme Gene Loci in Natural Populations of Acacia auriculiformis Example 3.2: Genetic Differentiation Among Populations of Eugenia dysenterica from the Brazilian Cerrado Example 3.3: Genetic Variation of Swietenia macrophylla Across the Brazilian Amazon Example 3.4: Genetic Variation of Endangered Australian Species of the Genus Fontainea Assessed with RAPD Markers and by DNA Sequences Example 3.5: Genetic Variation of Shorea leprosula and Shorea parvifolia in Indonesia Assessed at AFLP Loci Example 3.6: Genetic Variation of Cedrela odorata at cpDNA Recommended Literature
4 4.1 4.2 4.2.1 4.2.2 4.2.3 4.3 4.3.1 4.3.2 4.4
Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests Introduction Sexual Reproduction Sexual Types and Sexual Systems Sexual Systems Sexual Structures and Sexual Function Asexual Reproduction Vegetative Reproduction Apomixis Recommended Literature
41 41 41 42 44 47 49 50 51 52
5 5.1 5.2 5.2.1 5.2.2 5.2.2.1 5.2.2.2 5.2.3 5.2.3.1
Gene Flow and Migration Introduction Gene Flow Through Pollen Pollination and Fertilization Pollen Vectors in Tropical Forests Pollination by Wind (Anemogamy) Pollination by Animals (Zoogamy) Pollen Dispersal Assessed by Marker-Based Studies Dispersal of Rare Alleles Example 5.1: Gene Dispersal in a Clonal Seed Orchard of Teak (Tectona grandis) 5.2.3.2 Paternity Analyses Example 5.2: Gene Flow Through Pollen in Neobalanocarpus heimii and Dipterocarpus tempehes (Dipterocarpaceae) Example 5.3: Pollen Dispersal in Three Neotropical Tree Species with Different Spatial Distribution Patterns on Barro Colorado Island
31 33 33
34 35 37 39
53 53 54 54 54 54 55 60 60 60 61 62
63
Contents
5.2.3.3 Model-Based Estimates of Pollen Dispersal Example 5.4: Pollen Dispersal in Dinizia excelsa (Fabaceae) 5.2.4 Efficiency of Pollen Vectors for Gene Flow 5.3 Migration of Seeds 5.3.1 Seed Vectors 5.3.1.1 Abiotic Seed Dispersal 5.3.1.2 Biotic Seed Dispersal 5.3.2 Efficiency of Seed Dispersal 5.4 Long-Distance Gene Flow and Migration in Tropical Forest Species 5.5 Recommended Literature
64 64 65 65 65 65 66 66 67 68
6 6.1 6.2 6.2.1 6.2.2 6.3 6.3.1
69 69 70 70 72 73 74
6.3.2 6.3.3 6.4 6.4.1 6.4.2 6.5 6.5.1 6.5.2 6.6 6.7 7 7.1 7.2
Mating Systems Introduction Random Mating and Panmixis Heterogeneity of Pollen Allele Frequencies Panmixis and Hardy–Weinberg Structures Selfing and Outcrossing Rates Estimates of Selfing Rates Based on Rare Alleles Example 6.1: Estimates of Selfing Rates in Teak (Tectona grandis) Populations Estimates of Selfing Rates Based on a Mixed Mating Model Estimates of Selfing Rates Based on Nonmaternal Alleles Inbreeding and Inbreeding Depression Genetic Consequences of Inbreeding Inbreeding Depression Example 6.2: Inbreeding Depression in Eucalypts Incompatibility and Self-Sterility Incompatibility Self-Sterility Environmental Effects on Mating Recommended Literature
74 76 76 78 78 80 80 82 82 84 84 85 87 87 87
7.4
Adaptation and Coevolution Introduction Physiological and Evolutionary Adaptation Example 7.1: Viability Selection During Early Life Stages of Platypodium elegans Species Interactions and Coevolution Example 7.2: Figs and Their Pollinators Recommended Literature
8 8.1 8.2
Phylogenies and Evolution Above the Species Level Introduction The Evolution of Species Diversity in the Tropics
99 99 99
7.3
89 90 91 97
IX
X
Contents
8.2.1 8.2.2 8.3
8.4
Species Diversity in Tropical Forests Evolution Above the Species Level Molecular Phylogenies Example 8.1: A Molecular Phylogeny of Indonesian Dipterocarpoideae Example 8.2: Evolution of the Genus Inga Recommended Literature
99 101 102 103 104 106
Part B Applications of Genetics to Tropical Forestry
109
9 9.1 9.2
111 111 113
9.3 9.4 10
Fragmentation of Forests Introduction The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations Example 9.1: Genetic Impact of Fragmentation on a Rain Forest Canopy Tree Example 9.2: Connectivity of Population Fragments of a Medium-Sized Dry-Forest Tree Genetic Preconditions for Restoration and Persistence Recommended Literature
116 119 123 127
10.5 10.6
Genetic Aspects of the Management of Natural Tropical Forests Introduction Selective Logging Effective Population Density After Logging The Question of Dysgenic Selection Natural Regeneration Genetic Aspects of the Manipulation of Dynamic Processes in Natural Forests Genetic Aspects of Sustainability in Natural Tropical Forests Recommended Literature
137 140 146
11 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.4.1 11.4.2 11.4.3 11.4.3.1 11.4.3.2 11.4.3.3
Provenance Research Introduction Definitions Historical Development Provenance Tests Types of Field Experiments in Provenance Research Traits Studied in Field Trials Design, Conduct, and Analysis of Provenance Trials Collection of Material for Provenance Trials Production of Planting Stock Experimental Design
147 147 148 150 151 153 155 156 156 159 159
10.1 10.2 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.3 10.4
129 129 130 131 135 136
Contents
11.4.3.4 Choice of Experimental Sites 11.4.3.5 Number and Distribution of Locations of an Experimental Series 11.4.3.6 Observation Period of Field Experiments 11.5 Provenance Differentiation and Geographic Variation Pattern 11.6 Choice of Provenances in Tropical Forestry Example 11.1: Provenances of Eucalyptus camaldulensis and Their Growth Performance Example 11.2: International Provenance Trials in Teak (Tectona grandis) 11.7 Recommended Literature 12 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.3.1 12.3.2 12.3.3 12.4 12.4.1 12.4.2 12.5 12.5.1 12.5.2 12.6 12.6.1 12.6.2 12.6.3 12.6.4 12.7
Domestication and Breeding of Tropical Forest Trees Introduction Domestication Genetic Controlledness of Phenotypic Traits Individuals Related by Descent Pair Comparisons in the Field Response to Natural Viability Selection Linear Model of Genetic Effects on a Phenotypic Trait Phenotypic Trait Expressions Genetic Variance Components and Heritability Estimation of Breeding Parameters; Progeny Testing Progenies of Open-Pollinated Trees Progeny Tests After Controlled Pollination Methods of Selection Selection of Plus Trees Selection in Progeny Tests Selection of Clones Marker-Assisted Selection Heterosis Breeding in Forest Trees Example 12.1: Breeding Eucalypts in Aracruz, Brazil 12.8 Propagation of Breeding Products 12.8.1 Clonal Seed Orchards Example 12.2: Clonal Seed Orchards of Teak (Tectona grandis) 12.8.2 Seedling Seed Orchards 12.8.3 Mass Multiplication of Clones 12.9 Multiple Population Breeding 12.10 Breeding Strategy 12.11 Genetic Consequences of Domestication and Breeding 12.11.1 General Considerations 12.11.2 Monitoring of Breeding Projects by Use of Genetic Markers 12.12 Recommended Literature
161 162 163 163 165 169 170 172 173 173 174 176 176 177 179 179 179 182 183 183 184 186 187 188 189 189 192 194 196 196 198 201 204 205 207 209 209 210 211
XI
XII
Contents
13 13.1 13.2
13.3 13.4 13.5 13.5.1 13.5.2 13.5.3 13.6 13.7 13.7.1 13.7.2 13.8 13.9 13.10 13.11 14 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.4.1 14.4.2 14.4.3 14.5 14.5.1 14.5.2 14.6 14.6.1 14.6.2 14.6.3 14.6.4 14.6.5 14.7
14.8 14.9
Genetic Aspects of Plantation Forestry in the Tropics Introduction Plantations of Exotic Tree Species Example 13.1: The Origin of Early Plantations of Acacia mangium in Sabah Plantations of Indigenous Species Basic and Reproductive Material Production and Collection of Seed Seed Production Areas Provenance Resource Stands Seed Orchards Collection and Storage of Seed Planting Stock Production Seedlings Clonal Multiplication Establishment and Development of Plantations Natural Regeneration of Plantations Use of Breeding Products Recommended Literature
213 213 215
Conservation of Genetic Resources in Tropical Forest Trees Introduction Development of Tree-Conservation Genetics Defining Priorities Conservation Objectives Objective 1: Preservation of the Potential for Particular Trait Expressions Objective 2: Preservation of Maximum Variation Objective 3: Preservation of Adaptability Selection of Genetic Resources Inventory of Genetic Marker Loci Inventory of Adaptive Trait Expressions and Adaptive Markers Conservation Methods Dynamic Conservation in Situ Dynamic Conservation ex Situ in Man-Made Forests Conservation of Seeds in Gene Banks Vegetative Propagation for the Conservation of Forest Genetic Resources Biotechnological Methods of Preservation Regeneration of Forest Genetic Resources Example 14.1: Conservation of the Genetic Resources of Pinus merkusii in Thailand Programs for the Protection of Forest Genetic Resources Recommended Literature
237 237 239 240 241
References Index
217 218 220 222 222 223 224 226 227 227 228 229 230 231 235
241 242 243 243 245 247 250 251 253 255 256 256 257 259 264 265 267 307
Introduction – Genetics of Tropical Forests
. . . the significance of forest genetics lies not only in squeezing extra gain out of marginal investments, but more importantly in understanding the genetics of forests, in appreciating what forest ecosystems are and how they operate, and in better stewards of forest resources (Namkoong 1989).
The importance of forest ecosystems for environmental protection, global biodiversity, and human welfare can hardly be overestimated. Genetic resources are widely recognized as the basis of biodiversity and the main components of ecosystems. Conservation and utilization of genetic resources are crucial aspects of sustainable forest management practices. However, our current understanding of forest genetic resources is poor at best. Genetic variation patterns have been studied for a small fraction of forest trees only. Evolutionary processes resulting in variation within species are difficult to study for long-living organisms such as forest trees, and human impact on forest genetic resources is often subtle. Thus, it is hardly surprising that misconceptions about forest genetic resources and implications of human impact on genetic resources are commonplace. This holds specifically true for tropical forests, which deserve particular attention for the following reasons. First, tropical forests are centers of biological diversity at least at the level of species diversity. Second, human impact on forest ecosystems is particularly severe in the tropics. Alterations of land use, notably deforestation, endanger forest genetic resources in most tropical countries. Common silvicultural practices such as selective cutting systems based on target diameters threaten genetic resources in managed forests. On the other hand, many tropical countries have launched ambitious reforestation and afforestation programs. The choice of reproductive material used for plantation establishment is a matter of vital importance for the success of reforestation programs. Utilization of genetic resources (tree improvement) plays an important role in this context. This book is aimed at familiarizing readers with the fundamental principles related to genetic resources in tropical forests. We will concentrate our discussion on forest trees since trees are by definition the main structural and functional
1
2
C HAPTER 1 Introduction – Genetics of Tropical Forests
components of forest ecosystems. However, other organisms will also be considered. This holds in particular for animals interacting with trees by distributing their genetic information through the dispersal of pollen or seeds. Priority is given to species of considerable economic importance, mainly trees grown in plantations for wood production (e.g., eucalypts) and keystone species serving vital functions in particular ecosystems (e.g., figs in many Asian forests). The analysis of patterns of genetic variation is in the center of our discussion. The dynamics of genetic structures of selected forest taxa without human interference is discussed in Part A of this book. The role of the evolutionary factors for shaping genetic variation patterns within and among populations is described with emphasis on the reproduction of forest trees (sexual systems, gene flow, and mating systems). Part B is devoted to the human impact on forest genetic resources in the tropics. Both deliberate changes of genetic structures owing to tree improvement and genetic implications of other human activities, including forest destruction, fragmentation, and silvicultural practices, are considered. We describe mutual dependencies between environmental conditions and evolutionary change in primary and secondary forests as well as in plantations. Genetic processes are not seen in isolation but are discussed in an ecological context following the fundamental work of Klaus Stern, the founder of the authors’ institute (Stern and Roche 1974). Genetic variation is regarded as a key aspect of biodiversity and as the basis for evolutionary adaptability. The development of management and conservation strategies for natural and man-made forests in the tropics requires the consideration of genetic aspects. The main focus of the book is on mutual dependencies between environmental conditions in the tropics and genetic variation patterns of selected species, in particular forest trees. The species richness of many tropical forests has numerous implications in this regard.
Genetic Processes in Tropical Forests
Part A
The enormous species richness of tropical forests is mirrored by multiple strategies to ensure the survival of species in tropical forests. Survival implies adaptedness to prevailing environmental conditions, but also, at least in the long run, adaptability to environmental change. Genetic variation is the basis for evolutionary adaptive change. In this part our current understanding of the dynamics of genetic variation in time and space is reviewed for species living in tropical forests. Basics of population genetics and the concept of gene marker loci are briefly introduced to readers not familiar with the analysis of genetic variation (Chap. 2). Surprisingly high levels of genetic variation within populations have been reported for the majority of, but not all, tropical forest tree species (Chap. 3). The maintenance of genetic variation during reproduction (Chap. 4) is due to particular features of gene flow and migration mechanisms (Chap. 5), and the mating system (Chap. 6) of tropical forest trees. Changes of genetic structures due to selection are difficult to monitor for long-living organisms growing in complex forest ecosystems, but are crucial for patterns of adaptive variation (Chap. 7). Finally, evolution and genetic differentiation above the species level, i.e., within genera, families, or even higher taxonomic units, are discussed (Chap. 8).
Population Genetics – an Overview
Population geneticists spend most of their time doing one of two things: describing the genetic structure of populations or theorizing on the evolutionary forces acting on populations. On a good day, these two activities mesh and true insights emerge (Gillespie 1998).
2.1 Introduction Population genetics provides the framework for an understanding of the dynamics of genetic structures or evolution. The following considerations are neither specific for nor confined to forest species. Most aspects mentioned in this chapter are as relevant for tropical forest species as for any other higherplant or animal species. However, the population genetics approach taken throughout this book to discuss genetic processes in tropical forests requires a basic understanding of the most important fundamentals concerning genetic structures and their dynamics in time and space, and introduces the concept of genetic markers as well as the most important molecular and biochemical gene markers.
2.2 The Population The genetic information or genotype of an organism does not change throughout its lifetime. It is necessary to observe and to compare genetic information of many plants or animals in order to describe genetic variation and its dynamics in time. The fundamental units for studies of genetic variation are collectives of individuals exchanging their genetic information among each other for the sexual production of the next generation. Such units of (sexual) reproduction are defined as populations. A species rarely consists of one single population. It is usually composed of several more or less isolated populations. Isolation means the absence of mating
2
6
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
events between plants (or animals) from different populations in this context. However, an assessment of reproductive isolation usually requires a fairly detailed understanding of the reproduction system of a species. Furthermore, the definition of a population is operational only if an occasional (but rare) exchange of genetic information among populations is taken into consideration. Thus, interfertile, spatially clustered plants are often regarded as belonging to the same population, while spatially separated plants are regarded as parts of different populations. The delineation of populations is particularly difficult for immobile organisms with poorly described spatial distribution patterns and largely unknown means of gene dispersal through seed and pollen. In most cases, it is far from obvious which trees in a species-rich tropical forest belong to the same population and how big tree populations are. This has far-reaching consequences for levels of genetic variation of tropical forest trees, as will be discussed in later chapters. Analyses of spatial patterns of genotypes without a priori information on the delineation of populations or partially isolated subpopulations have recently been proposed as an alternative to the “traditional” approach of dividing the overall variation into components within and among demes or populations (Diniz-Filho and Telles 2002; Manel et al. 2003). Spatially explicit analyses of genetic variation patterns might be particularly informative for plant species occurring in low density in tropical forests; however, currently available information is mainly confined to comparatively small areas (Ng et al. 2004).
2.3 Variation at Gene Loci 2.3.1 The Molecular Basis of Genetic Variation
The genetic information of all organisms is stored as a sequence of the four bases or nucleotides adenine, thymine, cytosine, and guanine in their DNA. It is multiplied by the process of replication and translated to a sequence of amino acids by the processes of transcription (from DNA to messenger RNA, mRNA) and translation (from mRNA to polypeptides) (Griffiths et al. 2000). A cistron is a part of the DNA coding for a particular polypeptide, for example, an enzyme. From this point of view, the variation at a particular gene or gene locus can be assessed by observing differences in the DNA sequence within a cistron. The total number of “genes” is unknown for any tropical forest plant; however, it may be assumed to be at least on the order of more than 25,000 estimated for the first fully sequenced flowering plant, the herbaceous
2.3 Variation at Gene Loci
Arabidopsis thaliana (The Arabidopsis Genome Initiative 2000). The number of genes of the first sequenced tree species (Populus trichocarpa) is estimated to be even higher (http://genome.jgi-psf.org/Poptr1/Poptr1.home.html). The observation of variation at the most basic level of DNA sequences is routine for tropical trees just as for other organisms, but it is time-consuming and costly if sequences of hundreds of organisms need to be compared. To date, only a few population studies have been conducted based on the observation of variation of DNA sequences within a single or a few closely related tropical forest species (but see, e.g., Ishiyama et al. 2003). Sequencing is more frequently applied to clarify taxonomic subdivisions and phylogenies (Chap. 8). Numerous alternatives to sequencing are available. The choice of the most appropriate method depends on several factors, including available resources and the purpose of a study. A comprehensive overview of currently available molecular tools to assess patterns of genetic variation in plants has been given by Weising et al. (2005). 2.3.1.1 Molecular Markers
The most important methods to assess patterns of genetic variation within and among species rely on the amplification of short DNA fragments by means of polymerase chain reaction (PCR). PCR allows short fragments of the DNA of a target organism to be selectively amplified (multiplied) for further analyses. The sequence of two short oligonucleotides (primers), each usually between ten and 25 base pairs in length, is decisive for the amplified DNA region. The following marker types, all based on the PCR method, have gained particular importance in the study of genetic variation patterns of tropical forest trees. (Partial) Gene Sequences and Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms
Selective primers can be designed to amplify the DNA coding for a particular gene (cistron). DNA regions translated into a polypeptide (exons) and nontranslated regions (introns) of structural genes as well as regulatory genes can be analyzed. It is possible to sequence the amplified PCR products, often after a cloning step. For example, Kamiya et al. (2005) investigated the phylogeny of the species-rich genus Shorea (Dipterocarpaceae) on the basis of a (partial) sequence of the PgiC gene (Example 8.1). An investigation of genetic variation is particularly rewarding at gene loci with known or putative function and a directly observable effect on phenotypic traits responsible for the adaptation to particular environmental conditions (candidate genes). Populations can be screened for single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) without the need for repeated sequencing (Morin et al. 2004).
7
8
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
The characterization of expressed sequence tags, studies of molecular variation at the level of expressed genes, and analyses of variation at SNPs are expected to greatly improve our understanding of adaptive genetic variation and its dynamics in space and time. However, these recently developed marker types are not discussed in detail owing to the lack of published reports for tropical forest species (but see Sect. 7.2). Microsatellites (Simple Sequence Repeats)
Microsatellites or simple sequence repeats (SSRs) are short DNA fragments of usually only two or three base pairs in length which are repeated several times in a particular location of the DNA (Fig. 2.1). SSRs can be studied by the development of primers in conserved DNA regions flanking the microsatellite. The development of primers is rather costly and time-consuming (Squirrell et al. 2003). Nuclear microsatellites developed for a particular species can only be transferred to closely related species, usually within the same genus. Nuclear microsatellites are important genetic markers owing to their usually high variability and codominant mode of inheritance (Sect. 2.3.2, Chap. 3). The variation of microsatellite fragment sizes is due to a different number of repeated motifs resulting in slightly different sizes of amplified fragments (Fig. 2.2). The availability of highly variable markers is particularly useful for analyses of the mating system and gene flow (Chaps. 5, 6). Microsatellites have been developed for a number of tropical forest tree species, including Pithecellobium elegans (Chase et al. 1996a), Swietenia humilis (White and Powell 1997), Gliricidia sepium (Dawson et al. 1997), Shorea curtisii (Ujino et al. 1998), Caryocar brasiliense (Collevatti et al. 1999), Neobalanocarpus heimii (Iwata et al. 2000), and Prosopis spp. (Mottura et al. 2005). Microsatellite motifs are not only found in DNA of the nucleus, but also in DNA of chloroplasts (cpDNA; Sect. 2.3.2). Single nucleotide repeats are particularly common in cpDNA. Universal primers are available to investigate variation at cpSSRs in many different species of angiosperms (Weising and Gardner 1999) and gymnosperms (Vendramin et al. 1996).
AAGGATAAGTTAAA ACACACACACACACACAC GTTGCCTCCATTT TATGATGTATGAAT ACACACACACACACACAC CCCACCTGGTTTT TTGACGTCACACAG ACACACACACACACACACAC TCTCTCATCCACA
Fig. 2.1. Three different DNA sequences of Prosopis chilensis containing the microsatellite repeat motif AC in nine (lower and middle) or ten (upper) copies (underlined). A adenine, C cytosine, G guanine, T thymine. (From Mottura, unpublished)
2.3 Variation at Gene Loci 195
200
205
210
215
220
225
230
235
240
245
250
255
260 1000 500
1000 500
600 400 200
2000 1000
1500 1000 500
900 600 300
900 400 200
2000 1500 1000 500
Fig. 2.2. Length variation for eight Prosopis spp. trees at a microsatellite gene locus (Mottura et al. 2005) separated in an automated sequencer (ABI 3100). Each line refers to one tree. Different sizes of amplified fragments are visualized as peaks at different positions in the chromatogram. Trees with two amplified fragments are heterozygous; tree 5 is homozygous with only one amplified fragment. (From Mottura, unpublished)
Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA and Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism
Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD; Newbury and Ford-Lloyd 1993; Fig. 2.3) and amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP; Vos et al. 1995; Fig. 2.4) are genetic fingerprinting techniques resulting in more or less complex DNA patterns. Unlike most other techniques including microsatellites no previous sequence information is necessary for RAPD and AFLP studies. The presence (+ or 1) or absence (− or 0) of a DNA fragment of a particular size is scored for each sample plant investigated. This information is the basis for a matrix of size n × m (n is the number of plants investigated; m is the number of DNA fragments observed) with elements 1 (fragment present) or 0 (fragment absent). RAPDs and AFLPs are usually interpreted as dominant markers (see later). No
9
10
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
Fig. 2.3. Low variation at a random amplified polymorphic DNA marker in teak (Tectona grandis). (From Finkeldey, unpublished)
information on the function of a particular DNA fragment or its mode of inheritance is available; hence, RAPDs and AFLPs are “anonymous” markers. The RAPD technique is a simple molecular tool to assess genetic variation within and among populations which has been widely used for tropical forest plants such as Gliricidia spp. (Chalmers et al. 1992), Cedrela odorata (Gillies et al. 1997), Caesalpinia echinata (Cardoso et al. 1998), Prunus africana (Dawson and Powell 1999), and many others. The reproducibility of the RAPD technique has been under dispute (Rabouam et al. 1999). The AFLP method is more demanding with regard to laboratory equipment and experience, but allows more DNA fragments to be investigated from a single PCR reaction, and shows higher reproducibility in comparison with RAPDs. The potential of the AFLP technique to assess genetic variation patterns in tropical trees was recently reviewed by Kremer et al. (2005). AFLP studies to assess genetic variation within tropical tree species were conducted, for example, for Moringa oleifera (Muluvi et al. 1999), Calycophyllum spruceanum (Russel et al. 1999), and Acer skutchii (Lara-Gomez et al. 2005). Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism
A simple method to observe variation among DNA fragments from different plants is to digest the fragments into smaller pieces by restriction enzymes. Restriction enzymes cut DNA at a particular sequence. These recognition sequences are usually between four and six base pairs in length. The restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) technique is based on the use of restriction enzymes to observe genetic variation. For example, nuclear RFLPs
2.3 Variation at Gene Loci 220
222
224
226
228
230
232 300 200 100
200 100
300 200 100 221.05
300 200 100 222.04
400 300 200 100
200 150 100 50
200 150 100 50
Fig. 2.4. Variation at amplified fragment length polymorphisms in seven Shorea parvifolia trees after separation in an automated sequencer (ABI 3100). Only fragments in the range 220–232 bp are shown. The fragment with a size of 220 bp (arrows) is “diagnostic” for the population Berau (Borneo), since it was not observed in six other populations. (From Cao, unpublished)
were developed for Acacia mangium to assess genetic diversity and differentiation among populations (Butcher et al. 1998) and with the objective to incorporate marker-based approaches in breeding programs (Butcher et al. 2000; Butcher 2004). More frequently, the RFLP techniques is combined with a PCR step and is used to assess variation of cpDNA. For example, Tsumura et al. (1996) and Indrioko et al. (2006) (Fig. 2.5) analyzed phylogenetic relationships among Southeast Asian dipterocarps using the PCR-RFLP technique (Example 8.1), and Cavers et al. (2003) observed strong genetic differentiation among five cpDNA haplotypes of Cedrela odorata in Central America (Example 3.6).
11
12
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview M 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fig. 2.5. Polymerase chain reaction restriction fragment length polymorphisms of Indonesian Dipterocarpaceae after amplification with the primer pair TrnL–TrnF and restriction with TaqI. M marker (size standard), 1 Hopea celebica, 2 Vatica rassak, 3 V. pauciflora, 4 H. bancana, 5 Dipterocarpus oblongifolius, 6 S. javanica, 7 V. granulata, 8 Upuna borneensis, 9 S. mecistopteryx, 10 D. rigidus, 11 S. mecistopteryx, 12 H. grifithii. (From Indrioko, unpublished)
2.3.1.2 Biochemical Markers – Isozymes
The sequence of nucleotides of the DNA is converted to a sequence of amino acids of polypeptides by the processes of transcription and translation. Enzymes are the most important group of polypeptides catalyzing all kinds of biochemical reactions in the metabolism; thus, there is a close relation between enzymes and controlling genetic information according to the “one gene – one polypeptide hypothesis.” Isozymes are enzymes with similar or even identical functions. Electrophoresis of isozymes followed by biochemical staining is a simple way to observe differences with regard to their electric load and/or spatial structure (Rothe 1994; Fig. 2.6). It is often possible to directly relate the variation observed by isozyme electrophoresis to genetic variation (Bergmann and Hattemer 1998). A formal inheritance study (Sect. 2.3.2) is strongly recommended prior to the use of isozymes as genetic markers. Isozyme gene loci became the first widely used markers to assess patterns of genetic variation of tropical forest species at single gene loci. The ease of isozyme
2.3 Variation at Gene Loci
Tree: 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
A1 A2 A2A2
A2A2
A1A2
A1A2
A2A2
A2A2
A1A2
A1A2 A1A2
A1A2
A1A1
A1A2
A1A2
A2A2
A1A2 A2A2
Fig. 2.6. Zymogram showing variation of 16 Dalbergia sissoo trees from Nepal at the enzyme system alcohol dehydrogenase. The variation is controlled by a gene locus ADH-A. The inferred genotypes of the respective trees are indicated. (From Pandey, unpublished)
inventories and the comparatively low costs have made them useful tools for population genetics studies, although they were often substituted by various types of molecular DNA markers during the last decade. 2.3.2 The Gene As a Unit of Heredity
Genetics as the science of heredity dates back to the experiments of the Austrian monk Gregor Mendel (1866), if not earlier. The definition of a gene as a unit of heredity was introduced in the early twentieth century, long before the role of DNA as the material basis of genetic information was recognized. A gene in this sense is identified by the observation of segregation within progenies of particular parents. The basic idea for the identification of a gene as a unit of heredity has remained unchanged since the experiments Mendel (1866). He investigated segregation ratios in progenies after controlled pollination at simple morphological traits such as the color of petals in peas. If a plant is heterozygous at a controlling gene locus, it will transmit only one of the two different alleles to a particular progeny (the terms heterozygosity and allele are described later). Thus, segregation is expected in progenies if at least one parent was heterozygous at a controlling gene locus. It is possible to compare the observed segregation in a sample of progenies after controlled pollination with an expectation based on the assumption of a simple “Mendelian” inheritance of the trait. The controlling gene or the gene locus is identified, if the
13
14
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
differences between the observed and expected values are not significant (Hattemer 1991). Suitable statistical tests are, for example, described by Sokal and Rohlf (1998, p. 686 ff.; c2 test or goodness-of-fit test, G test). The formal identification of a genetic marker locus by an observation of segregation is possible only for environmentally stable, genetic traits. It is also advisable for the identification of gene loci based on the observation of biochemical or molecular markers. For example, Moran and Bell (1983) observed segregation at the isozyme system GOT in progenies of Eucalyptus regnans after controlled pollination and found no evidence to reject the hypothesis of the genetic control of the variation by a single gene locus. Forest trees, in particular those of the tropics, are extraordinarily difficult to cross owing to their large size, short viabilities of pollen, unknown reproductive biology, and other obstacles. Thus, the identification of a gene locus by inheritance studies is preferentially conducted on the basis of alternative approaches such as the observation of segregation in the haploid megagametophyte (the “endosperm”) of gymnosperms (Bergmann 1974) or the observation of segregation in the progenies of putatively heterozygous seed trees after open pollination (Gillet and Hattemer 1989). The first method has been used to identify enzyme gene loci in Pinus merkusii from Thailand (Changtragoon and Finkeldey 1995b); the latter approach was used to clarify the inheritance of isozymes in Pterocarpus indicus from the Philippines (Finkeldey et al. 1998). 2.3.3 The Mode of Inheritance
The analysis of variation patterns at environmentally stable, genetic traits (Chap. 3) requires an understanding of the transmission of the trait from parents to progenies and from one generation to the next. Two considerations are of particular importance in this context: the transmission of genetic information from both parents or from a single parent only, and the impact of a single or two alleles at a gene locus on the observed trait expression (the phenotype). Most of the DNA in a plant cell is located in the nucleus. Nuclear DNA (nDNA) is inherited by both parents. For diploid organisms, one set of chromosomes is transmitted by each of the two parents to their common progenies; thus, nDNA is typically biparentally inherited. In addition, DNA of plants is located in two types of plastids: mitochondria (mitochrondrial DNA, mtDNA) and chloroplasts (cpDNA). DNA in plastids, both mitochondria and chloroplasts, is usually transmitted by a single parent to its progenies (uniparental inheritance). mtDNA is mainly inherited from the female or seed parent only
2.3 Variation at Gene Loci
(maternal inheritance). The same holds for cpDNA in angiosperms. However, cpDNA of gymnosperms is typically paternally inherited, i.e., only the genetic information of the pollen parent is transferred to a progeny. cpDNA was investigated in most studies on genetic variation of tropical forest plants based on uniparentally inherited markers (Example 3.6). Maternally inherited mtDNA was studied in several animal species such as Central American frogs (Crawford 2003) and the giant panda in China (Lu et al. 2001). The different types of genetic information at any biparentally inherited gene locus are called alleles. Since two sets of chromosomes are inherited (one from the seed parent, the other from the pollen parent), each nuclear gene is represented in two copies in each progeny of a diploid species. Polyploids are not discussed in this introduction. A tree is homozygous (e.g., A1A1) at a particular locus A, if two identical alleles (both A1) were inherited from its parents. A heterozygous tree (e.g., A1A2) received two different alleles (A1 from the seed parent and A2 from the pollen parent or vice versa) from its parents. An allele is dominant, if its possession in a single copy is sufficient to express a particular phenotype. If A1 is dominant, the phenotypic expressions of trees with the genotypes A1A1, A1A2, A1A3, etc. are identical. The other alleles (A2 and A3 in the example) are recessive. If it is possible to distinguish all heterozygotes (e.g., A1A2) from all homozygotes (A1A1 and A2 A2), the alleles are defined as codominant. A simple observation of genetic structures (Sect. 2.4) is only possible at codominant marker loci. 2.3.4 Definition and Classification of Gene Markers
On the basis of the previous considerations, it is possible to define a gene marker in different contexts: ●
●
A gene marker (synonyms gene locus and marker locus) in a wide sense is an environmentally stable trait; thus, the variation is determined by genetic factors only. A gene marker in a narrow sense is an environmentally stable, biparentally inherited, codominant trait.
Although many different traits may be regarded as gene markers in a wide sense, only the molecular and biochemical markers briefly described in Sect. 2.3.1 have considerable practical importance to assess genetic variation patterns of tropical forest species. A rough classification of important, currently available marker types with regard to their mode of inheritance and their variability is presented in Table 2.1.
15
16
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
Table 2.1. Classification of genetic markers in a broad sense commonly used in studies on genetic variation of tropical forest species with regard to their mode of inheritance and their variability Variation
Uniparental
Anonymousa
Codominantb
High
Chloroplast simple sequence repeats; sequences of chloroplast DNA Polymerase chain reaction restriction fragment length polymorphisms of chloroplast DNA and mitochondrial DNA
Amplified fragment length polymorphisms Random amplified polymorphic DNAs
Microsatellites (simple sequence repeats) Isozymes
Moderate to low
a
Mode of inheritance usually unknown; interpretation as dominant markers Gene markers in a narrow sense
b
2.4 Genetic Structures Within Populations The final result from a laboratory study to assess the genetic constitution of a plant at a particular biochemical or molecular gene marker system is a specific pattern, which can be used: ●
●
●
To infer a genotype in case of gene markers in a narrow sense (e.g., isozymes, SSRs) To identify a haplotype in the case of uniparentally inherited markers (e.g., PCR-RFLPs of cpDNA) To assign a genetic fingerprint usually consisting of many anonymous marker loci to the plant (e.g., AFLPs)
Genetic structures are frequency distributions of such genetic types in populations. The most important frequency distributions to assess levels of genetic variation within and among populations are allelic and genotypic structures. 2.4.1 Allelic and Genotypic Structures
Genetic variation is assessed by an investigation of all plants or a (random) sample of plants from a population. At a gene marker in a narrow sense, the genotypes of these plants are known, and it is possible to calculate the (relative) frequency of a particular genotype Ai Aj as Pij = Nij /N,
(2.1)
2.4 Genetic Structures Within Populations
where Nij is the (absolute) frequency of genotype AiAj in the population (or sample) and N is the population size (or sample size). The frequency vector of all (relative) frequencies of genotypes is defined as the genotypic structure of the population at the respective marker gene locus. It obviously holds that // Pij = 1. i
j
Each genotype of a diploid species consists of two alleles; thus, the total number of alleles in a population (or a sample) is twice the number of plants investigated, and the frequency of a particular allele Ai can be calculated as p i = Ni / 2N,
(2.2)
where Ni is (absolute) frequency of allele Ai in the population (or sample) and N is the population size (or sample size). The respective allele Ai is counted twice in case of homozygous plants AiAi. The frequency vector of all (relative) frequencies of alleles is defined as the allelic structure of the population at the respective marker gene locus. Again, it holds that / p i = 1. i If the genotypic structure of a population is known, it is easily possible to compute the allelic structure at the respective gene locus. The frequency of allele Ai (pi) can be computed by calculating the sum of the frequency of the corresponding homozygote (Ai Ai ) and half of the frequencies of all heterozygotes where the respective allele occurs (Ai Aj , Ai Ak , . . .). However, the calculation of genotypic structures based on allele frequencies requires additional information or assumptions (e.g., Sect. 6.1.2). Example 2.1: Genetic Structures at an Isozyme Gene Locus in Dalbergia sissoo The observed variation at the isozyme gene locus ADH-A is illustrated for 16 Dalbergia sissoo trees in Fig. 2.6. Three different genotypes were observed. Six trees (nos. 1, 3, 4, 7, 15, and 16) show the homozygote genotype A2A2, tree 10 is the only tree with genotype A1A1, and the remaining nine trees exhibit the heterozygous genotype A1A2. Thus, the genotypic structure of the sample is as follows: P11=1/16=0.0625, P12=9/16=0.5625, P22=6/16=0.3750. Eleven of the 32 observed alleles (each tree has two alleles) are A1, the remaining 21 alleles are of type A2. The allelic structure may also be computed as follows: p1 = P11 + 0.5P12 = 0.0625 + 0.5625/2 = 11/32 = 0.34375, p2 = P22 + 0.5P12 = 0.375 + 0.5625/2 = 21/32 = 0.65625.
17
18
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
2.4.2 Variation at Uniparentally Inherited Markers
The uniparental inheritance of cpDNA and mtDNA implies the absence of recombination among genes. Since cpDNA and mtDNA are usually transmitted without any changes in maternal or, in the case of cpDNA of gymnosperms, paternal lineages, it is possible to interpret variation patterns observed at different loci together and to assign particular cpDNA or mtDNA haplotypes to different plants. The interpretation of genetic diversity within and among populations (Chap. 3) is conventionally based on these haplotypes rather than on variation at particular loci. Example 2.2: Diversity of cpDNA Haplotypes in Dalbergia sissoo Six to ten seeds from randomly selected, different seed trees were investigated in each of ten populations of D. sissoo in Nepal. The inventory was conducted in five regions, each represented by one natural population and a neighboring plantation. Variation was detected by the PCR-RFLP technique (Sect. 2.3.1) by restriction of the amplified fragment Trn K1/K2 with the enzymes AluI and RsaI, and by amplification of the chloroplast microsatellites (cpSSRs) ccmp6 and ccmp7 (Weising and Gardner 1999). A total of eight haplotypes with two or three haplotypes in each population were observed (Table 2.2). Haplotypes 1–3 were only observed in natural populations, while haplotypes 4–8 occurred mainly in plantations (Pandey et al. 2004). Table 2.2. Variation of chloroplast DNA haplotypes in five natural populations and five plantations of Dalbergia sissoo in Nepal. (Adapted from Pandey et al. 2004) Region
Population
Natural populations A Hetauda N B Shivapur C Hattisar D Godawari E Pipariya Plantations A Hetauda P B Surai C Thakurdwara D Attaria E Shuklaphanta N sample size
N
10 10 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Chloroplast DNA haplotypes 1
2
9 8 5 4
1
3
4
5
6
4
6
7
8
7 3 4 5
2 3
2 1 6 9
1
1 4 6 5
2.5 Evolution and Evolutionary Factors
2.5 Evolution and Evolutionary Factors Today’s biodiversity is the result of the biological evolution which started at least three and a half billion years ago on earth. The number of existing species is still unknown, since a large proportion of the species living on our planet have not yet been described. The majority of “unknown” species are insects living in the canopy of tropical forests (Erwin 1988). Current estimates of the global species diversity vary from approximately two million to 30 or even 50 million species (Erwin 1997). The long history of evolution on earth does not preclude the study of its effects in short periods. Evolution is permanently ongoing and it is possible to observe its effects even in long-living organisms such as forest trees. Furthermore, the majority of evolutionary change is within existing species and does not immediately result in the creation of new taxa. The main principle of evolution was recognized and described by Charles Darwin (1859): Biological evolution is based on heritable variation within species or populations. Darwin recognized the key role of natural selection in this context. Fundamental observations, which led to the development of the selection theory, were made both by Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace, who independently developed a similar theory, after extended studies in tropical areas (Lefèvre 1984; Sect. 8.2). Our advanced knowledge about the process of inheritance allow us to define evolution more precisely today that during Darwin’s era. Evolution is a change of the genetic (allelic or genotypic) structure of a population at one or several gene loci. Only changes improving the adaptedness of a population to particular environmental conditions were regarded as evolution by Dobzhansky et al. (1977); however, Kimura (1983) proposed including all changes of genetic structures including those at selectively neutral loci into the concept. Evolutionary factors are the causes of changes of genetic structures (Hedrick 2000). The significance of evolutionary factors for the dynamics of genetic structures of tropical forest plants is the main topic in later chapters of this book; thus, only a brief description is given here: ●
Mutation is the prerequisite for any genetic variation. Mutations are random changes of genetic information of an organism which might affect a single nucleotide (a spontaneous change of a single nucleotide resulting in a SNP; Sect. 2.3.1), the chromosomal structure (e.g., fissions, translocations, inversions), or the number of genes (e.g., duplications, polyploidy). Most mutations are detrimental or neutral for an organism. Only few advantageous mutations increase the fitness, i.e., the capacity to produce offspring.
19
20
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
●
●
●
●
Mutations are rare events; mutation rates are estimated to be in the range between 10−6 and 10−8 for most genes. However, the frequency of mutations is not uniform. For example, considerably higher estimates of mutation rates were reported for microsatellites (Goldstein and Pollock 1997). Gene flow and migration increase the genetic multiplicity of a population, if genes which were previously restricted to certain populations migrate to other populations. Transport of pollen (gene flow in a narrow sense) and seeds (migration) are the main processes involved in the dispersal of genes for most plant species (Chap. 5). By definition, gene flow and migration among populations are rare events. The mating system is decisive for the fusion of male and female gametes. Gene flow through pollen is an obvious prerequisite for mating between two seed plants. Thus, gene flow and the mating system are closely connected and are the two most important aspects of the reproduction system of a plant species. The mating system decides on the combination of alleles to genotypes. The genotypic structure of the progeny generation is influenced by the mating system, which primarily does not cause changes of allelic structures. Inbreeding due to selfing or mating among relatives is a particularly important aspect of the mating system (Chap. 6). Random fluctuations of genetic structures are described as genetic drift. Genetic drift is a consequence of limited population size and becomes stronger in small populations. The strength of genetic drift can be described as a function of the population size, although its final outcome is unpredictable. Alleles, in particular rare alleles, are likely to completely disappear from populations as a result of genetic drift, and previously polymorphic (variable) gene loci may become monomorphic (fixed). A sudden reduction of the population size for one or several generations is often described as a genetic “bottleneck.” Bottlenecks result in reduced genetic variation even after later population expansion owing to the effects of genetic drift while populations are small. Genetic differentiation among partially or completely isolated populations is expected to increase as a result of genetic drift. Selection is a consequence of the differing abilities of organisms to produce offspring (fitness). Selection does not increase multiplicity, but often contributes to the maintenance of genetic diversity by stabilizing polymorphisms, for example, owing to a selective advantage of heterozygous genotypes. In general, selection results in an improved adaptedness (Chap. 7). The basis of selection is the different survival of genotypes (viability selection) and the different contributions of genotypes to the formation of a progeny generation (fertility selection).
Population geneticists are concerned with the effect of these evolutionary factors on patterns of genetic variation within and among populations
2.6 Phenotypic Variation
(Gillespie 1998). Genetic structures result from complicated interactions between the different evolutionary factors in natural and managed populations. The role of different evolutionary factors for the creation and maintenance of the extraordinary species richness of tropical forests has been widely discussed in the past. A high frequency of selfing and restricted gene flow and migration resulting in small populations, which become differentiated from each other mainly owing to the effects of genetic drift, have been proposed as the main forces for the evolution of the enormous species richness in tropical forests by Fedorov (1966). This view was challenged by Ashton (1969), who argued in favor of more efficient means of gene flow through seed and pollen than previously thought. The evolution of species diversity is promoted by selective differentiation in partially isolated subpopulations which eventually develop reproductive barriers. The latter proposition is greatly supported by makerbased assessments on genetic variation patterns in tropical forest species (Chap. 3) and on the reproduction system of tropical forest plants (Chaps. 5, 6).
2.6 Phenotypic Variation The vast majority of directly observable traits of trees are an outcome of the interaction between the genetic constitution of a plant at a large number of gene loci (genotype, G) and the environmental conditions (E). Thus, it holds for the phenotype (P) that P= G×E, where × symbolizes the interaction between environmental and genotypic effects, which often differs from simple additivity of both components. Phenotypic traits deserve particular interest if they are important for the adaptation of plants to their environment (adaptive traits) or for the value of a tree (economic traits). Adaptive traits such as the tolerance against biotic (pests) or abiotic (e.g., draught) stress and economic traits such as volume growth are controlled by both genetic and environmental factors for most plant species. The analysis of phenotypic traits in a breeding context will be discussed in Chap. 12 in more detail. It is also described for forest trees in other textbooks (Wright 1976; Zobel and Talbert 1984; Williams et al. 2002). The majority of the gene markers described in Sect. 2.3.1 are unlikely to have strong, recognizable effects on adaptive traits or traits of economic importance. They are regarded as “neutral” or “nearly neutral” markers with regard to an adaptation to the environment; however, this does not preclude their application to monitor adaptive processes (Ziehe et al. 1999; Sect. 7.2). In line with the definition of genetic structures, the frequency distribution of particular phenotypes is defined as the phenotypic structure of a population. Direct and indirect effects of the environment on the phenotypic structure are illustrated in Fig. 2.7. Apart from the direct impact of the environment
21
22
C HAPTER 2 Population Genetics – an Overview
Migration
Genotypic structure
Mode of gene action
Phenotypic structure
Modification Viability selection
Mating system
Environmental influence on mating
Mutation
Environment
Population size Fertility selection
Gene flow
Allelic structure
Fig. 2.7. The environmental impact on phenotypic structures. (Adapted from Hattemer and Müller-Starck 1990)
on the phenotype (P = G× E), there are numerous impacts of the environment on genotypic structures. The environmental conditions influence mutation rates, are crucial for population sizes and, hence, the importance of genetic drift, cause changes of allelic structures owing to fertility selection and genotypic structures owing to viability selection (Chap. 7), and have an impact on the mating system (Chap. 6). Thus, manifold human alterations of environmental conditions do not only directly effect phenotypes of forest plants, but also change the genotypic structure of populations.
2.7 Recommended Literature The molecular basics of genetics is covered in many recently published textbooks, such as the one written by Griffiths et al. (2000). A useful and detailed description of genetic markers and their application to study plant genetics is given by Weising et al. (2005). Altukhov and Salmenkova (2002) provide a comprehensive survey on currently available markers to study genetic variation of plants. The need for inheritance studies in order to identify gene markers was emphasized by Hattemer (1991). The basics of population genetics are covered by Hedrick (2000). The book of Altukhov (2006) represents another introduction to population genetics putting genetic variation in an ecological context.
Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
. . . the main difficulty one faces in a subject like population genetics (. . .) is not the mathematics itself, or the biology itself: it is how to fit them together (p. ix in Maynard Smith 1998).
3.1 Introduction A main application of genetic markers is the observation of genetic variation patterns within and among populations. Variation at phenotypic traits is influenced both by genetic and by environmental factors. Thus, it is impossible to conclude on levels of genetic variation at single loci on the basis of the observation of phenotypes at adaptive traits or traits of economic importance, although an assessment of variance components in field trials allows the degree of genetic control of a phenotypic trait to be estimated (p. 49 ff. in Eriksson and Ekberg 2001). The application of gene markers has greatly enhanced our understanding of genetic variation of tropical forest plants.
3.2 Genetic Inventories Genetic inventories aim at describing extant patterns of genetic variation within a single or, more frequently, within and among several populations. These patterns are the result of the impact of the evolutionary factors acting on populations in the past (Sect. 2.5). On the other hand, the evolutionary adaptive potential of populations depends on genetic variation patterns (Sect. 7.2). For practical reasons, it is only possible to observe a small and very often presumably not representative set of marker gene loci for a given species. Variation at most of the tens of thousands of gene loci remains unexplored. Thus, an assessment of evolutionary adaptive potentials of populations is likely to be unreliable if it is based on the small set of loci investigated only. This holds irrespective of the type of marker loci investigated. Still, the limited variation
3
24
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
observed at marker loci is often useful to elucidate the evolutionary past of populations and species. This argument is particularly valid if genetic structures have been shaped by evolutionary factors acting on all genes in principally the same way. For example, a “bottleneck” in the evolutionary past of a population is expected to reduce genetic variation due to drift at all loci, and particular types of mating systems, for example, strong inbreeding, result in characteristic genotypic structures (Chap. 6). On the other hand, it is difficult to assess the impact of selection since its effects are restricted to the selected and associated loci (Sect. 7.2). The conclusions drawn on the evolutionary past of populations and species can be used to assess their evolutionary adaptive potential (Finkeldey and Mátyás 1999).
3.3 Measurement of Genetic Variation A detailed description of the various methods to analyze genetic variation patterns is beyond the scope of this book. The book by Nei (1987) should be consulted for a comprehensive account. Berg and Hamrick (1997) and Weising et al. (2005, p. 207ff.) present brief overviews. Only simple measures and methods frequently used to analyze patterns of genetic variation of tropical forest species are briefly introduced in this section. Statistical problems related to the estimation of genetic variation based on samples rather than on full inventories of all plants are not discussed in detail. The focus is on the population genetics interpretation of allelic and genotypic structures at gene markers in a narrow sense, i.e., nuclear, codominant markers such as microsatellites or isozymes. The most complete and comprehensive information on genetic variation patterns at a particular marker locus is the genotypic and allelic structures at that locus (Sect. 2.4); however, it is difficult to compare variation levels among loci or populations on the basis of these genetic structures. Thus, the genotypic and allelic frequency distributions are “condensed” to measures characterizing particular aspects of variation within or among populations. This is particularly important if the aim is to investigate and to compare genetic variation at several gene loci. The gene pool is the average or mean of genetic variation estimates from several single loci. 3.3.1 Genetic Variation Within Populations
The genetic variation within populations is characterized by measures of genetic multiplicity, which only take into account the occurrence of different genetic types, but not their frequencies, and measures of genetic diversity, which also consider the frequency of different genetic types (alleles or genotypes).
3.3 Measurement of Genetic Variation
3.3.1.1 Genetic Multiplicity
Proportion of Polymorphic Loci The simplest estimate of genetic multiplicity is the proportion of polymorphic (variable) loci (PPL). It is calculated by dividing the number of polymorphic gene loci (PL) by the number of all loci investigated, which also includes loci showing no variation (monomorphic loci, ML): PPL = PL / (PL + ML).
(3.1)
The PPL is often reported as a percentage after multiplication by 100. Some authors regard a locus as polymorphic only if the frequency of the most frequent allele is below 95% (or 99%). Other authors regard a locus as polymorphic if at least two types (irrespective of their frequencies) occur. Number of Alleles per Locus and Allelic Richness
Another simple measure of genetic multiplicity is the average number of alleles per gene locus. It is calculated by counting the number of alleles (ni) at each of L gene loci, summing over all loci investigated, and dividing this total number of alleles by the number of loci L. L
/n Number of alleles per locus = i = L1
i
(3.2)
Since the probability of observing a (rare) allele in a population strongly depends on sample size, comparisons of the average number of alleles among populations possibly lead to false conclusions if the number of sampled plants differs among populations. Effects of different sample sizes are taken into consideration by the computation of the allelic richness (Petit et al. 1998; Comps et al. 2001). 3.3.1.2 Genetic Diversity
The genetic diversity of a population does not only depend on the number of genetic types (alleles or genotypes), but also on their (relative) frequencies (pi , pij). Effective Number of Alleles
The “effective” number of alleles at a gene locus (Crow and Kimura 1970) has also been defined as allelic diversity v (Gregorius 1978) of a population at that locus. If n is the total number of alleles at a locus and pi are the relative frequencies of the alleles, the effective number of alleles v is calculated as follows:
25
26
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
1#v=
1 # n. / p i2
(3.3)
i
The effective number of alleles v reaches its maximum value for a given n if the frequencies of all alleles are identical (1/n). In this case, v = n. The allelic diversity v decreases with increasing frequency of one allele and consequently decreasing frequencies of the remaining alleles. The effective number of alleles of the gene pool is the harmonic mean of the v at single loci. The effective number of alleles from Example 2.1 is v=
1
/p i
2
=
i
1 = 1 . 1.82. p 12 + p 22 0.34375 2 + 0.65625 2
Expected Heterozygosity
The “expected heterozygosity” He is the most frequently used measure of genetic diversity within populations. The “expectation” is based on the assumption that alleles are randomly combined to genotypes, i.e., that Hardy–Weinberg structures are realized (Sect. 6.2.2). In this case, it is possible to calculate the frequency Pii of a particular homozygote with genotype Ai Ai as pi2 (pi is the frequency of allele Ai). The frequency of the expected homozygosity is calculated by summing over all alleles (Σpi2), the remainder being the expected heterozygosity. Accordingly, the expected heterozygosity is calculated as H e = 1 - / p i2 .
(3.4)
i
Gene pool values of the expected heterozygosity are the arithmetic mean of single locus values. The expected heterozygosity from Example 2.1 is H e = 1 - (p 12 + p 22 ) = 1 - (0.34375 2 + 0.65625 2 ) . 0.451. Observed Heterozygosity
A simple measure of genetic diversity is the proportion of all heterozygotes from all plants (homozygotes and heterozygotes) investigated in a population: n
n
n
Ho = / / Pij = 1 - / Pii . i = 1j = 1 i ! j
(3.5)
i = 1
This observed heterozygosity equals the expected heterozygosity if the population exhibits Hardy–Weinberg structures. The gene pool value of the observed heterozygosity is calculated as the arithmetic mean of Ho from single loci. The observed heterozygosity of the Dalbergia sissoo population in Example 2.1 is Ho= P12 = 1 – (P11 + P 22) = 0.5625.
3.3 Measurement of Genetic Variation
It is also possible to calculate the degree of individual heterozygosity of a single plant by dividing the number of heterozygous gene loci by the number of observed loci. 3.3.2 Genetic Differentiation Among Populations
Genetic differences between two populations are quantified by measures of genetic distance; the differences between an arbitrary number of populations are measured as genetic differentiation. 3.3.2.1 Genetic Distances
Out of a large choice of commonly used genetic distances only the minimum genetic distance according to Nei (1973) is mentioned here. For two populations k and l it is defined as 2 d min (k , l ) = 12 / 7 p i (k) - p i (l )A , (3.6) i where pi(k) and pi(l ) are the frequencies of the ith allele in populations k and l, respectively. This distance reaches its minimum value if the allelic structures of both populations are identical [pi(k)=pi(l) for all alleles i], and has a maximum value of 1 if the populations are fixed on different alleles. More commonly used distance measures such as Nei’s standard genetic distance are described by Nei (1987). If more than two populations are investigated, it is possible to compute a matrix with all pairwise genetic distances, and to use this information as a basis for the illustration of genetic differentiation patterns by means of cluster analyses (e.g., Fig. 3.4). Populations are grouped on the basis of their genetic distances by different algorithms. A simple and commonly used method for grouping in population genetics is the unweighted pair-group method with arithmetic means (UPGMA) method (Sneath and Sokal 1973). Similar methods are used to illustrate the relatedness of higher taxa in molecular phylogenies (Sect. 8.3). 3.3.2.2 Genetic Differentiation
The standard method to assess genetic differentiation among an arbitrary number of populations is the calculation of GST (or FST) (Nei 1973). The total gene diversity in a population composed of several subpopulations is calculated as HT. HT is the expected heterozygosity (Eq. 3.4) with the frequencies of
27
28
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
alleles (pi) calculated on the basis of their occurrence in the total population. The average gene diversity within populations (HS) is calculated as mean gene diversity (He) within the subpopulations. It can be shown that the difference HT – HS equals the average minimum genetic distance of Nei (see before) between all population pairs (DST = HT – HS) (Finkeldey 1994). GST (or FST) is the relative contribution to the total gene diversity which is due to differences among populations: GST = FST = DST /HT = (HT – HS)/HT.
3.4 Genetic Variation in Tropical Forest Species – General Trends Levels and patterns of genetic variation at single loci depend on numerous factors. Apart from species-specific or population-specific variability, the type of the marker(s) investigated is of crucial importance. An assessment of genetic variation levels is meaningful only if results are related to those of comparable studies. Most available data on patterns of genetic variation of tropical forest plants were based on isozyme inventories, although the number of studies using molecular markers is constantly increasing. In view of the multitude of tropical forest plants it is hardly surprising that levels and patterns of genetic variation considerably vary among species (Table 3.1). In tropical forests, plant species with low, intermediate, and high levels of genetic diversity within populations are encountered. Mean levels of genetic variation of woody plants, mainly forest trees, from different climatic regions were compared by Hamrick et al. (1992) (Table 3.2). At isozyme gene loci, the measures of genetic multiplicity (PPL; number of alleles per locus) are on average slightly lower for woody plants from the tropical region as compared with temperate and boreal species. However, this does not hold for the average expected heterozygosity (He) as the most commonly used measure of genetic variation. Thus, there is no evidence for fundamental differences with regard to levels of genetic variation of tropical and temperate trees, even though the majority of tropical trees occur in low density, while many temperate and boreal species form large, pure stands. The impact of density on levels of genetic variation was studied in more detail by Hamrick and Murawski (1991). Genetic variation of 16 uncommon tropical forest tree species (density less than 0.5 trees per hectare) occurring on Barro Colorado Island, an artificial island in the Panama Channel, was assessed at isozyme gene loci, and compared with variation levels of 16 “common” species (density more than four trees per hectare). Variation levels within uncommon species varied from low (PPL = 14.3%, He = 0.026 for Tricanthera gigantea) to high (e.g., PPL = 76%, He = 0.257 for Myrospermum fructescens). The average variation of the uncommon species is lower than the variation of more common species (Table 3.3); thus, there is evidence for losses of genetic
3.4 Genetic Variation in Tropical Forest Species – General Trends
Table 3.1. Examples of tropical tree species showing low and high levels of genetic variation within populations, respectively Species Low variation Acacia mangium Acer skutchii Moringa oleifera Pentaclethra macroloba Pinus merkusii High variation Acacia albida (=Faidherbia albida) Calycophyllum spruceanum Gliricidia sepium Pinus caribaea Pterocarpus macrocarpus Shorea leprosula Swietenia macrophylla
Country/region
Marker type He
Reference
Australia, Papua New Guinea Mexico India, East Africa Costa Rica
Isozyme
0.017
Moran et al. (1989a)
SSR AFLP Isozyme
0.112 0.067 0.074
Lara-Gomez et al. (2005) Muluvi et al. (1999) Hall et al. (1994a)
Thailand
Isozyme
0.058
Changtragoon and Finkeldey (1995a)
West Africa
Isozyme
0.442
Joly et al. (1992)
Peru
AFLP
Russel et al. (1999)
Central America Caribbean Islands Thailand
Isozyme Isozyme Isozyme
0.249– 0.349 0.238 0.26 0.246
Chamberlain et al. (1996) Zheng and Ennos (1999) Liengsiri et al. (1995)
Malaysia Brazil
Isozyme SSR
0.406 0.781
Lee et al. (2000) Lemes et al. (2003)
He average expected heterozygosity within populations, SSR simple sequence repeat, AFLP amplified fragment length polymorphism
Table 3.2. Average genetic variation at isozyme gene loci in long-lived woody species from different climatic regions. (Adapted from Hamrick et al. 1992) Climatic zone
No. of species
Average no. of populations
PPL (%)
A/L
He
Boreal – temperate Temperate Temperate – tropical Tropical
26 122 5 38
8.2 12.2 16.6 21.3
82.5 63.5 62.2 57.9
2.58 2.27 1.89 1.87
0.206 0.166 0.169 0.191
PPL proportion of polymorphic gene loci, A/L average number of alleles per locus, He expected heterozygosity
variation due to small reproduction effective population sizes resulting in genetic drift for very uncommon tree species in tropical forests. However, the average variation of uncommon tree species on Barro Colorado Island is higher than the average variation of 486 plant species investigated at isozyme gene loci and is roughly comparable to the average variation found for 115 long-lived woody perennial species, mainly trees (Table 3.3). Most of the genetic variation within a species is usually found within populations, with only a minor fraction of the overall diversity found among
29
30
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
Table 3.3. Mean genetic variation at isozyme gene loci for 16 uncommon (rare; density less than 0.5 trees per hectare) and 16 common (density more than four trees per hectare) tree species on Barro Colorado Island in comparison with average variation of 486 plants and 115 long-lived woody species. (Adapted from Hamrick and Murawski 1991) Group
No. of species
Average no. of gene loci
PPL (%)
He
Uncommon species Common species All plant species Long-lived woody plants
16 16 486 115
25.8 27.2 16.5 17.0
41.8 60.9 34.2 50.0
0.142 0.211 0.113 0.149
He expected heterozygosity
populations. The mean population differentiation (GST) for 37 tropical woody plant species included in a survey by Loveless (1992) was 0.109; thus, on average, less than 11% of the total genetic variation is due to differences among populations. This result is not confined to the majority of tropical forest plants, but has also been found in plants, in particular forest trees, of other climatic regions (Austerlitz et al. 2000). Differentiation among populations at isozyme gene loci is even lower for temperate (GST = 0.092) and boreal (GST = 0.038) species as compared with 26 tropical species (GST = 0.119) included in the review by Hamrick et al. (1992). Low differentiation at single gene loci does not preclude considerable differentiation with regard to genetic components of the variation observed at phenotypic traits of adaptive or economic significance (Kremer et al. 1997; Chap. 11). In summary, the following conclusions can be drawn from the multitude of marker-based studies on genetic variation of tropical forest trees: ●
●
●
●
Forest trees are among the genetically most variable of all organisms. This result was first obtained for a few species of the temperate and boreal zone and later confirmed for tropical tree species. The genetic variation within populations at isozyme gene loci is similar for temperate and tropical tree species (Table 3.2). Several important tropical tree species are characterized by low levels of genetic variation within populations, while other species are highly diverse (Table 3.1). It is not possible to reliably predict genetic variation levels for a particular species on the basis of its life-history characteristics. Endemic species are, on average, less variable within populations than species with a wide distribution range (Loveless 1992). Uncommon species, i.e., those occurring in very low population densities in tropical forests, are, on average, less variable than species occurring in
3.5 Case Studies on Genetic Variation Patterns
●
higher density (Table 3.3). However, the expected heterozygosity is high for many tree species even if the population density is low. The degree of genetic differentiation among populations (GST) is slightly higher for tropical forest tree species than for tree species of temperate forests. Tropical tree species with abiotic means of seed dispersal (barochorous and anemochorous species) show, on average, a much higher differentiation among populations (GST = 0.138) than zoochorous species (GST = 0.050) (Sect. 5.3). Seed dispersal by animals is usually very efficient and results in small genetic differentiation among populations of zoochorous tree species (Loveless 1992).
3.5 Case Studies on Genetic Variation Patterns Since predictions of genetic variation patterns are very unreliable for a particular species, experimental investigations on the distribution of genetic variation within and among populations are mandatory for a detailed understanding of variation patterns of a target species. Six case studies were selected as examples to illustrate genetic variation patterns in tropical forest species out of a wide variety of published reports. The case studies were chosen since they represent different: ●
● ●
Marker types: isozymes, microsatellites, random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPDs), amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs), variation of chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) Regions of the tropics (continents and climatic conditions) Species with regard to succession stage (pioneer–climax species), dispersal mechanism of seeds, abundance (rare or common), and other life-history traits
The focus is on genetic variation patterns and variation levels in forest tree populations without or with only minor human impact. Genetic effects of human disturbance of tropical forest ecosystems will be discussed in later chapters. Example 3.1: Genetic Variation at Isozyme Gene Loci in Natural Populations of Acacia auriculiformis Acacia auriculiformis A. Cunn. Ex Benth. is one of the most important Acacia species for plantation establishment worldwide. The natural distribution of the species is confined to Australia, Papua New Guinea, and a few Indonesian
31
32
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
islands (Fig. 3.1). A genetic inventory was conducted at 22 isozyme gene loci coding for 17 enzyme systems in 18 natural populations of the species from Papua New Guinea and Australia (Wickneswari and Norwati 1993). Clear differences with regard to the level of genetic variation measured as expected heterozygosity were observed (Fig. 3.1). Populations from Papua New Guinea revealed the highest level of genetic variation (average He = 0.133 or 13.3%), which is comparable to the average for long-lived woody plant species (Table 3.3). Intermediate levels of genetic diversity were observed in populations from Queensland, and low levels in populations from the Northern Territory of Australia. Similar results were also reported for other measures of genetic variation (PPL; alleles per locus; data not shown). Thus, Papua New Guinea is a center of genetic diversity of the species. Wickneswari and Norwati (1993) explained the observed patterns of genetic variation by the evolutionary history of the species. They suspect that the species survived less favorable climatic conditions in small, scattered refuges in Papua New Guinea, and expanded only recently via land bridges connecting Papua New Guinea and Australia until the end of the last glaciation. According to this hypothesis, only a few trees colonized Queensland and, later, the Northern Territory. Thus, the lower levels of genetic variation in Australia as compared with Papua New Guinea are explained by bottleneck effects (genetic drift) during recent recolonization (From Wickneswari and Norwati 1993).
Papua New Guinea
Natural distribution
Bensbach
Investigated populations
Northern Territory
Manton River
He 5.0 %
Reynolds River
0.7 %
Douglas River
7.5 %
He 14.3 %
Morehead R. Rouku 10.3 % North Mibini
18.0 %
Mibini Swamp Old Tonda Village
13.0 % 11.9 %
Mai Kussa River
12.0 %
mean (Papua New Guinea) 13.3 %
Gerowie Creek
3.0 %
South Alligator River
0.2 %
East Alligator River
2.7 %
Wenlock River
Goomadeer River
8.7 %
South Coen
9.1 %
Morehead River
9.1 %
Mount Molloy Kings Plain
5.5 % 9.4 %
mean (Northern Territory) 4.0 %
Queensland
mean (Queensland)
He 6.5 %
7.9 %
Fig. 3.1. Natural distribution and genetic variation of Acacia auriculiformis. He expected heterozygosity. (Adapted from Wickneswari and Norwati 1993)
3.5 Case Studies on Genetic Variation Patterns
Example 3.2: Genetic Differentiation Among Populations of Eugenia dysenterica from the Brazilian Cerrado Eugenia dysenterica DC. is a fruit tree species growing in the Cerrado region of Brazil. Ten populations were investigated for variation at eight isozyme gene loci (Telles et al. 2003). The species proved to be highly polymorphic with an expected heterozygosity between 0.223 and 0.377 in the populations and an average number of alleles per locus ranging from 2.4 to 3.6. However, levels of observed heterozygosity (Ho) were considerably lower than the respective values for He in all populations. Accordingly, positive fixation indices (F; inbreeding coefficients; Sect. 6.4.1) were observed at all marker loci. The overall genetic differentiation among populations was estimated as 0.154, indicating considerable genetic differences between populations. A highly significant correlation between the genetic distance (Nei 1972) and the geographical distance between populations was observed (Fig. 3.2). Two spatially isolated populations are clearly distinct from the remaining eight populations. The two genetically distinct groups should be treated as independent units for conservation (From Telles et al. 2003). Example 3.3: Genetic Variation of Swietenia macrophylla Across the Brazilian Amazon Mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla King) is one of the most important tropical timber species worldwide. Timber is harvested in plantations and logged in natural populations. Seven natural populations from the southern arc of the Brazilian Amazon basin were investigated at eight microsatellite (simple sequence repeat, SSR) gene loci. Variation was very high, with a mean number
Genetic distance (Nei)
0.25 r − 0.725 (P= 0.003)
0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0.00
0
50
100 150 200 Geographic distance (km)
250
Fig. 3.2. Comparison of genetic distances (Nei 1972) and geographic distances between ten populations of Eugenia dysenterica. (From Telles et al. 2003)
33
34
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
of 18.4 alleles per locus observed in all populations and a mean expected heterozygosity of 0.781 (Table 3.4). The inbreeding coefficient was positive and significantly different from 0 in four populations, indicating a slight excess of homozygotes relative to Hardy–Weinberg proportions (Sect. 6.4.1). The total genetic differentiation among populations was estimated as 0.097. This is only slightly lower than the average reported for tropical forest trees (GST = 0.109; Sect. 3.4) and may be regarded as a “moderate” level of genetic differentiation among populations. High levels of genetic variation were observed since microsatellites (SSRs) were chosen as marker types. SSRs are hypervariable markers showing higher levels of genetic variation in comparison with other codominant markers such as isozymes (Sect. 2.3.1). However, genetic variation in the Amazon basin was higher than in a directly comparable study on mahogany in Central America (Novick et al. 2003). On the other hand, the differentiation among populations was slightly higher among Central American populations. The significant genetic differentiation among populations in both regions stresses the importance of conserving as many populations as possible rather than of concentrating on one or a few populations in a region to be conserved in situ (Chap. 14) (From Lemes et al. 2003). Example 3.4: Genetic Variation of Endangered Australian Species of the Genus Fontainea Assessed with RAPD Markers and by DNA Sequences Fontainea oraria Jessup and Guymer is an extremely rare and endangered, dioecious, small tree species known to exist on a single site, a littoral rain forest in New South Wales (Australia) (Rossetto et al. 2000). Only ten adult plants and 52 seedlings grow on a 600-m-long strip. Sequencing of a cpDNA fragment and of the nuclear ITS2 region (Sect. 8.3) revealed a close relation to Table 3.4. Genetic variation at eight microsatellite gene loci in seven populations of Swietenia macrophylla from the Brazilian Amazon. (Adapted from Lemes et al. 2003) Population
A/L
He
Ho
F
A. Azul Cach. A Maraj P. Lacerda C. Mendes Cach. E P. Bueno All populations
8.4 10.7 9.2 9.7 10.6 10.2 7.6 9.5
0.761 0.785 0.793 0.812 0.754 0.810 0.754 0.781
0.753 0.781 0.740 0.812 0.709 0.780 0.680 0.750
0.012 0.005 0.068 −0.004 0.060 0.042 0.100 0.038
Deviationa
**
*** * ** ***
He expected heterozygosity, Ho observed heterozygosity, F inbreeding coefficient a Significant deviation from Hardy–Weinberg proportions at *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001
3.5 Case Studies on Genetic Variation Patterns
other species of the genus Fontainea and in particular to F. australis, another endangered species of the genus restricted in distribution to four sites. It was possible to distinguish all F. oraria plants (adults and progenies) by an investigation based on seven RAPD primers which amplified a total of 57 RAPD bands. The level of genetic variation at RAPD markers was similar for F. oraria and F. australis; however, variation was lower in the progenies of F. oraria as compared with the parental population. An uneven contribution of adult plants to the production of the seedlings (uneven fitness) is likely. There is evidence that a single tree dominates the production of progenies while other adults do not participate in reproduction. The example shows that even an extremely low population size does not preclude the observation of genetic variation in a species (From Rossetto et al. 2000). Example 3.5: Genetic Variation of Shorea leprosula and Shorea parvifolia in Indonesia Assessed at AFLP Loci Shorea leprosula Miq. and Shorea parvifolia Dyer are common and widespread emergents of lowland dipterocarp forest in Indonesia and other Southeast Asian countries. They are very important timber trees and are the main sources of light red meranti wood. Genetic variation was assessed by AFLP markers in 12 natural populations (six for each species) from Sumatra and Kalimantan (Borneo), and for S. leprosula in addition in one plantation from Java (Fig. 3.3) (Cao et al. 2006). Levels of genetic variation (He; Table 3.5) were estimated based on the assumption of Hardy–Weinberg structures in both populations. Variation is higher for S. leprosula in comparison with S. parvifolia (Table 3.5). Low variation was observed in both S. parvifolia populations sampled in Borneo. The population Asialog from Sumatra clearly showed the highest variation for both species. Variation levels measured as He decreased in the same order for the five locations where both species were sampled (Asialog > Pasir Mayang > Bukit Tiga Puluh National Park > Sari Bumi Kusuma > Nanjak Makmur). Considerable differentiation was not only observed among species, but also among populations. The proportion of the total genetic variation within species due to differentiation among populations is high for S. leprosula (GST = 0.20) and even higher for S. parvifolia (GST = 0.31). Populations of S. leprosula from Borneo are clearly separated from populations of the same species from Sumatra (Fig. 3.4). The cluster diagram (Fig. 3.4) suggests the origin of the planted population (Haurbentes, Java) as Sumatra. Conservation of genetic resources of dipterocarps needs to take into account the strong genetic differentiation among populations at presumably neutral AFLP loci. The presence of numerous “diagnostic” characters occurring in high frequency in only one or a few populations suggests that conservation in as
35
36
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
Sumatra
Kalimantan (Borneo)
SB
(S. lepr. S. parv.)
BB
(S. parv.)
PS
TS
(S. lepr. S. parv.)
(S. lepr. S. parv.)
NS
(S. lepr. S. parv.)
AS
TB
(S. lepr. S. parv.)
(S. lepr.)
HA
(S. lepr.)
Java Fig. 3.3. Location of sampled populations of Shorea leprosula and S. parvifolia in Indonesia. Abbreviations as in Table 3.5. (From Cao et al. 2006) Table 3.5. Genetic variation at AFLP loci in two dipterocarp species (Shorea leprosula and Shorea parvifolia) in Indonesia. (Adapted from Cao et al. 2006) Species
Population
Abbreviation
Location
PPL (%)
He
S. leprosula
Haurbentes Tering Sari Bumi Kusuma Asialog Pasir Mayang Bukit Tiga Puluh National Park Nanjak Makmur Mean Total Batu Ampar Sari Bumi Kusuma Asialog Pasir Mayang Bukit Tiga Puluh National Park Nanjak Makmur Mean Total
HA TB SB AS PS TS
Java Borneo Borneo Sumatra Sumatra Sumatra
60.71 64.29 60.71 82.14 62.50 60.71
0.186 0.146 0.174 0.258 0.178 0.177
NS
Sumatra
BB SB AS PS TS
Borneo Borneo Sumatra Sumatra Sumatra
50.00 61.93 92.86 33.93 46.43 73.21 60.71 46.43
0.151 0.177 0.222 0.115 0.124 0.221 0.151 0.127
NS
Sumatra
50.00 54.57 82.14
0.119 0.150 0.206
S. parvifolia
He expected heterozygosity
3.5 Case Studies on Genetic Variation Patterns S. lepr._AS S. lepr._HA S. lepr._NS S. lepr._PS S. lepr._TS S. lepr._TB S. lepr._SB S. parv._SB S. parv._BB S. parv._TS S. parv._AS S. parv._PS S. parv._NS
Fig. 3.4. Unweighted pair-group method with arithmetic means tree based on Nei’s standard genetic distance illustrating genetic differentiation among populations of two dipterocarps from Indonesia. Abbreviations as in Table 3.5. (From Cao et al. 2006)
many populations as possible is important. The identification of centers of genetic diversity of dipterocarps seems feasible since ordering of populations with regard to their variation (He) revealed the same trend for both species, with a single location (Asialog) clearly showing the highest diversity for S. leprosula and S. parvifolia (From Cao et al. 2006). Example 3.6: Genetic Variation of Cedrela odorata at cpDNA Cedrela odorata is an important timber species of the family Meliaceae with a wide natural distribution from Mexico to northern Argentina. A study of variation of cpDNA in Central American populations revealed five different haplotypes (Cavers et al. 2003). Populations are extremely differentiated with only three from 29 populations investigated showing polymorphism (Table 3.6); 96% of the total variation is distributed among populations (GST = 0.96). Maternal inheritance of cpDNA frequently results in strong differentiation of cpDNA haplotypes among populations. Repeated migration from South America to Central America is a likely cause of the strong differentiation. The ancestors of trees with the “northern” haplotypes 1 and 2 found in Guatemala and Mexico might have migrated to Central America early, possibly even before the land bridge connecting South America and North America was formed. The differentiation between populations with the “central” haplotype 3 and the “southern” haplotypes 4 and 5 coincides with considerable differences of climatic conditions and morphological and physiological traits. Likewise, investigations of anonymous RAPD markers revealed strong differentiation among these ecotypes. Thus, repeated colonization of Central America during eras with different climatic conditions is a likely cause for the observed differentiation.
37
38
C HAPTER 3 Genetic Variation of Tropical Forest Plants
Table 3.6. Variation of chloroplast DNA haplotypes in Central American populations of Cedrela odorata. (Adapted from Cavers et al. 2003) Population
Haplotype 1
Panama Gualaca Las Lajas San Francisco Costa Rica Horizontes Puriscal Canas Palo Verde Hojancha Jimenez Talamanca Upala Pacifico Sur Perez Zeledon Nicaragua Ometepe Masatepe Wabule La Trinidad Honduras Meambar Taulabe Comayagua La Paz Guatemala Los Esclavos El Idolo Tikal San Jose Mexico Calakmul Bacalar Zona maya Escarcega Total
2
3
4
5 5 5 1
4
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 19 20 20
1
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 4 5 5 5 20 20 20 20 99
1
1
259
106
9
The strong differentiation among populations from different regions offers good opportunities to apply molecular markers to control the origin of reproductive material (seeds or seedlings) (From Cavers et al. 2003).
3.6 Recommended Literature
3.6 Recommended Literature A comprehensive discussion of methods to analyze genetic variation within and among populations is given by Nei (1987). Short introductions to the analysis of genetic variation based on isozymes and several nuclear DNA markers, respectively, are provided by Berg and Hamrick (1997) and Nybom (2004). Weising et al. (2005, p. 207 ff) describe the analysis of genetic variation at marker loci. Older literature on isozyme variation of tropical forest trees has been reviewed by Loveless (1992). Useful reviews on genetic variation within and among plant populations at isozyme loci were also presented by Hamrick and Godt (Hamrick and Godt 1989, 1996, 1997; Hamrick et al. 1992).
39
Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
Flowering plants have evolved one of the most complex and “sexiest” life cycles on earth (Armstrong 1996).
4.1 Introduction Reproduction is an obvious prerequisite for the survival of species and populations. Reproduction in tropical forests has attracted much interest from ecologists, botanists, and conservation biologists since an understanding of the processes taking place during reproduction is fundamental for an analysis of the evolution and maintenance of the high (species) diversity in these forests (Sect. 7.2). A population is defined as a unit of reproduction (Sect. 2.2), and the recombination of genes during (sexual) reproduction implies that changes of genetic structures are particularly likely during the reproduction phase. Thus, an understanding of genetic processes during reproduction is crucial for the analysis of the temporal dynamics of genetic structures within populations, in particular for long-living organisms such as forest trees. The basic genetic principles connected to sexual and asexual reproduction in tropical forests are reviewed in this chapter. The distribution of genetic information during reproduction is discussed in more detail in Chap. 5, and the new combination of genes to genotypes by the mating system is the topic of Chap. 6. Chapters 4–6 are mainly concerned with the reproduction process in natural forests. The implications of human impact on the reproduction system of tropical forests plants and the production of forest reproductive material for enrichment planting and plantation establishment are discussed in Part B of this book.
4.2 Sexual Reproduction Sexual reproduction is characterized by the fusion of two gametes of opposing sex to a zygote. The formation of gametes is preceded by meiosis, i.e., a (sexual) cell division resulting in gametes with only half of the chromosome number as
4
42
C HAPTER 4 Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
compared with the chromosome number in somatic cells of the parental plant. The consequences of this process for genetic structures of a progeny generation derived from a parental stand (t) and the possible causes of deviations of the genetic structures in the progeny generation (t +1) from the population of adults are illustrated in Fig. 4.1. Trees of generation t produce female and male gametes. Differences in the ability to produce gametes result in fertility differences among trees (fertility selection). Male gametes (pollen) are distributed during the flowering period and external pollen from other populations is carried in the population (pollen influx). Mating preferences or incompatibilities possibly result in differences between allelic structures of the “pollen cloud” reaching a stigma and the fertilizing or effective pollen, for example, owing to differences in pollen tube growth. Viability selection starts early after fertilization and results in differences of genetic structures between fertilized ovules and fully developed seeds. Viability selection continues during seed germination, seedling growth, and throughout stand development. For practical reasons, it is not easily possible to observe the genetic structures of female and male gametes (pollen and ovules) or zygotes. Thus, changes of genetic structures are often monitored by comparing the adult population (generation t) with the mature seeds (generation t +1; comparison 1 in Fig. 4.1), by comparing the seeds with the population of seedlings, saplings, or adults (comparison 2 in Fig. 4.1; Example 7.1), or by comparing two generations of the same or, in case of long-living organisms like forest trees more frequently, of different age (comparison 3 in Fig. 4.1).
4.2.1 Sexual Types and Sexual Systems
Only gametes of opposite sex can fuse and jointly produce the zygote which will further develop by mitotic cell divisions into an embryo, a seedling, and eventually into an adult plant capable of producing gametes itself. The production of these two different types of gametes (female and male) is a requirement for successful sexual reproduction in a population. The sexual type of an organism depends on the types of gametes it produces: It is either cosexual (female and male gametes are produced) or unisexual female or male. Plants not capable of producing any functioning gametes are sterile. The determination of the sexual type of an organism is usually under strict genetic control although an environmental influence on the sexual type has been observed for some animals. The sexual type of most animals and some plants is determined by particular chromosomes (gonosomes, i.e., sexual chromosomes). Females often have two identical gonosomes: they are homogametic. Males of such species have two different gonosomes: they are heterogametic. An example of sex determination by gonosomes are the X and
4.2 Sexual Reproduction
production of and gametes
gametes
fertility selection
distribution of flowering over time pollen transport pollen influx
trees of generation t pollination
mating preferences incompatibility
comparison 1 fertilization
comparison 3
viability selection (self-sterility etc.)
mature seeds of generation t + 1
seed production
viability selection (germination, mortality) comparison 2
stand
n development
ele
ys
lit bi
io ct
via
trees of generation t + 1
Fig. 4.1. Causes for changes of genetic structures during and after reproduction in consecutive generations. (From Hattemer 1999)
Y chromosomes of humans. Females have two X chromosomes; males one X and a smaller Y chromosome. The sex of some insects mostly belonging to the Hymenoptera (e.g., bees and wasps) is determined by the ploidy level. Unfertilized, haploid eggs develop into males. Diploid, fertilized eggs develop into females (Cook 1993). Flowering plants are principally cosexual; however, the separation of sexes (dioecy) repeatedly evolved in plants (Sect. 4.2.2). Heteromorphic sex
43
44
C HAPTER 4 Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
chromosomes have been identified for a few dioecious plants, for example, in the herbaceous genera Silene and Rumex (Dellaporta and Calderon-Urrea 1993). A particular region on the LG1 chromosome has been identified as carrying sex-determining genes in papaya (Carica papaya) (Charlesworth 2004). Sex expression is regulated by hormones in many dioecious plants (Dellaporta and Calderon-Urrea 1993), but the mechanism of sex determination is still unknown for most woody plant species and for virtually all tropical forest species. A possible determination of the sex by age (or size) of trees has been described for the neotropical tree Iryanthera macrophylla. The plants of this species produce only one type of flower (female or male) in a particular reproduction period; however, Ackerly et al. (1990) found evidence that small, young trees of this species flower male, but later produce female flowers. Thus, the sex expression may not be determined by genetic factors, but by the age or size of plants, and the species may not be dioecious, but “diphasic” (Ackerly et al. 1990). 4.2.2 Sexual Systems
Since the formation of a progeny generation depends on the production of gametes of either sex, only the following combinations of the sexual types of individual plants to the sexual system of a species are possible: ● ●
●
●
●
Cosexuality: all plants produce both types of gamete (female and male) Dioecy: plants produce only one type of gamete – they are female (female) or male Trioecy: some plants produce both types of gamete (female and male), others are female or male Gynodioecy: some plants produce both types of gamete (female and male), others are female (no males) Androdioecy: some plants produce both types of gamete (female and male), others are male (no females)
Cosexuality is the archetypal and most common sexual system for plants. Two forms of cosexuality are distinguished: Hermaphroditic plants have complete flowers producing both types of gametes in a single flower. Monoecious plants produce both types of gamete in different flowers. Thus, single flowers are either male or female in monoecious species, but these flowers are produced by the same plant (Table 4.1). Different types of pollination can be distinguished for hermaphroditic species depending on the origin of the fertilizing pollen (Fig. 4.2). Autogamy is the
4.2 Sexual Reproduction
Table 4.1. Sexual systems of tropical plants with examples Sexual system
Sexual types
Examples
Cosexuality: hermaphroditism Cosexuality: monoecy
( ) in single flowers ( ) in different flowers on single plants ( ), ( )
Majority of tropical tree species, e.g., Dipterocarpaceae, Tectona, Eucalyptus Pinus, Castanopsis, and other Fagaceae
Dioecy
( ), ( ), ( ) ( ), ( ) ( ), ( )
Trioecy Gynodioecy Androdioecy
Calamus spp., Diospyros spp., most Podocarpaceae Pachycereus pringlei, Fraxinus excelsior a Rhizophora mangle, Ocotea tenera, Ficus spp.b Castilla elastica, Bauhinia pauletia, Bauhinia ungulata
a
Temperate tree species Gynodioecious figs are functionally dioecious (Example 7.2)
b
Allogamy Xenogamy Geitonogamy
Autogamy
Single flower
Selfing
Outcrossing
Fig. 4.2. The origin of fertilizing pollen for a flower for a hermaphroditic tree species. (Adapted from Hattemer et al. 1993)
fertilization of an ovule by pollen from the same flower. It is just like geitonogamy, the fertilization with pollen from a different flower of the same tree, a form of allogamy resulting in selfing (self-pollination; Sect. 6.3). Xenogamy is pollination from a different plant and results in outcrossing. Autogamy is not possible for monoecious species, and no form of allogamy, neither autogamy nor geitonogamy, is possible for dioecious species, which are, in consequence, obligatory outcrossed.
45
46
C HAPTER 4 Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
Hermaphroditism is the most common sexual system in tropical forests, followed by dioecy. Monoecious species are widespread in temperate and boreal forests, but are rarely encountered in tropical forests (Table 4.2). The domination of monoecious species in temperate forests reported for North America in Table 4.2 is also observed in central Europe: the dominating species of the families Fagaceae (Fagus, Quercus) and Pinaceae (Pinus, Picea, Abies) are monoecious. All other sexual systems (trioecy, gynodioecy, androdioecy) are extremely rare, both in tropical and in temperate forests. The sexual system of figs (Ficus spp.), which are either monoecious or gynodioecious, is explained in detail in Example 7.2. Bauhinia ungulata is pollinated by bats. It is morphologically a hermaphrodite, but seems to be functionally androdioecious. Trees produce flowers with either short or long pistils, but seeds do not develop on trees with short pistils (Ramirez et al. 1984). The floristic composition of a forest has an influence on the frequency of sexual systems since particular sexual systems are common in certain families. For example, many species of the Salicaceae [willows (Salix spp.) and poplars (Populus spp.)] are dioecious. The proportion of this family has a strong impact on the frequency of dioecy in a community of woody plants in a temperate climate. Tropical tree families with many dioecious species are, for example, the Meliaceae and the Ebenaceae. The high proportion of dioecious species in a South Nigerian rain forest (Table 4.2) is explained by the high frequency of these two families in the area investigated. The high frequency of dioecious species in species-rich forests of the central tropics is surprising in view of the low densities of many populations, since dioecious species are obligatory outcrossing. Thus, pollen vectors need to transport pollen from male to female plants for the production of sexual progenies. The advantages of outcrossing as compared with selfing (Sect. 6.4.2) are Table 4.2. Frequency (%) of common sexual systems in tropical and temperate forests. (Adapted from Bawa and Opler 1975) Location Tropics Costa Rica South Nigeria Sarawak Florida Temperate zone Ohio Ohio Arkansas Kentucky New Hampshire
Cosexual: hermaphroditic
Cosexual: monoecious
Dioecious
68 47 60 61
10 13 14 12
22 40 26 27
6 27 0 15 13
83 60 83 70 81
11 13 17 15 6
4.2 Sexual Reproduction
assumed to be the main reason for the evolution of dioecy for many originally self-compatible species of tropical forests (Bawa and Opler 1975). The frequency of sexual types in a forest is related to main pollinators (Sect. 5.2.2). Monoecious species are mainly wind-pollinated. The complete flowers of hermaphroditic species are predominantly pollinated by animals. 4.2.3 Sexual Structures and Sexual Function
The sexual structure of a population is the frequency distribution of its different sexual types. In the case of a cosexual (hermaphroditic or monoecious) species, it simply holds that P = 1, where P is the relative frequency of cosexual type from all f lowering plants. For a dioecious species, an even frequency of sexual types (P = P = 0.5) is often assumed, where P (P ) is the relative frequency of female (male) plants. The frequencies of male and female flowering plants were calculated for various dioecious species in Costa Rica (Table 4.3) (Opler and Bawa 1978). The 23 species investigated belong to 13 different families. This supports the hypothesis that dioecy evolved independently during the evolution of angiosperms in Table 4.3. Sexual structures of tree species in a tropical forest in Costa Rica. Test for significant deviation from an even sex ratio (male-to-female ratio of 1; com. X2) and test for significant heterogeneity of the sex ratio among populations (int. X2). (Adapted from Opler and Bawa 1978) Family
Species
No. of Population
No. of males
Anacardiaceae Boranginaceae
Spondias nigrescens Cordia collococca Cordia panamensis Bursera simarouba Bursera tomentosa Erythroxylon rotundifolium Bernardia nicaraguensis Trichilia anisopleura Trichilia cuneata Cecropia peltata Chlorophora tinctoria Pisonia macranthocarpa
5 6 6 9 5 1
57 127 110 114 74 30
58 85 52 95 60 14
0.98 1.50 2.11 1.20 1.23 2.14
2
23
22
1.04
NS
–
5 5 9 7 5
58 115 104 79 61
42 93 100 64 45
1.38 1.24 1.04 1.23 1.36
NS NS NS NS NS
NS NS NS NS NS
Burseraceae Erythroxylaceae Euphorbiaceae Meliaceae Moraceae Nyctaginaceae
No. of Male-to- Com. Int. X2 females female X2 ratio NS
NS
**
**
**
NS NS NS –
NS NS **
(Continued)
47
48
C HAPTER 4 Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
Table 4.3. Sexual structures of tree species in a tropical forest in Costa Rica. Test for significant deviation from an even sex ratio (male-to-female ratio of 1; com. X2) and test for significant heterogeneity of the sex ratio among populations (int. X2). (Adapted from Opler and Bawa 1978)––Cont’d Family
Species
No. of Population
No. of males
No. of Male-to- Com. Int. X2 females female X2 ratio
Polygonaceae
Coccoloba caracasana Coccoloba floribunda Ruprechtia costata Triplaris americana Allophyllus occidentalis Simarouba glauca Albertia edulis Genipa caruto Randia spinosa Randia subcordata Zanthoxylum setulosum
6 1 1 8 4
55 23 21 157 74
136 27 30 220 50
0.41 0.85 0.70 0.71 1.48
4 4 6 9 7 4
111 83 76 154 157 115
102 49 77 57 77 60
1.08 1.69 0.99 2.70 2.04 1.92
Sapindaceae Simaroubaceae Rubiaceae
Zanthoxylaceae
**
**
NS NS
– – NS
** *
**
NS NS
NS NS NS
**
**
**
NS NS
**
**
NS not significant * P < 0.05; **P < 0.01
various taxa. A significant deviation from an expected even ratio of male and female plants was observed for ten out of the 23 species (com. X2 in Table 4.3). Significantly more males than females (male-to-female ratio greater than 1 and significant com. X2) were observed for eight species. A significant excess of females (male-to-female ratio less than 1 and significant com. X2) was observed for only two species. Significant heterogeneity of the sex ratio among populations (int. X2) was observed for four species with P < 0.01. Deviations from a balanced sex ratio were also observed in populations of functionally dioecious figs (Ficus spp.) and rattan (Calamus spp.). In most cases an excess of male plants has been reported (Table 4.3). Possible reasons for an unbalanced sex ratio are: ●
●
●
Mode of inheritance of sex. Sex determination is unknown for most tropical forest plants (Sect. 4.2.1). Gametic selection favoring one sex. Pollen carrying the information for a male (or female) progeny is significantly more successful in fertilization that pollen carrying the information for the opposite sex of the progeny. Viability selection. Female (or male) plants show significantly lower survival as compared with survival rates of the opposite sex. Different resource allocation with regard to vegetative growth and investment in reproduction is
4.3 Asexual Reproduction
●
●
likely for many dioecious plants. Female plants need to supply energy and nutrients for the production of female flowers and seeds which are often embedded in large fruits. These resources are not available for vegetative growth. This possibly results in reduced viability as compared with that of male plants producing “only” pollen in male flowers. Earlier maturity of one sex, usually males, as compared with the opposite sex, or higher frequency of flowering of one sex. For example, annual flowering for males but a biannual cycle for females results in an excess of males in each flowering period. Preferential asexual reproduction of one sex. Strict genetic control of the sex results in identical sex expression of all plants from vegetative reproduction of a particular (female or male) tree.
The sexual function of a plant is the proportion of successful female gametes from all successful gametes (female and male) produced by a plant. A gamete is regarded as “successful” or effective if it has contributed its genetic information to a zygote. There are two sexual functions for dioecious species. Female plants have a sexual function of 1, since they only produce female gametes. The sexual function of males is 0, since they never produce female gametes. If the female and male gametes of a cosexual plant are successful in even proportions, its sexual function is 0.5. Observation of flowering intensities in populations strongly suggests deviations from a sexual function of 0.5 for many monoecious species. Some trees flower predominantly or, at least in a particular flowering season, exclusively male, while others flower predominantly female. Most of these investigations were conducted for monoecious temperate forest trees such as Pinus sylvestris, Fagus sylvatica, or the trioecious Fraxinus excelsior (p. 161 ff. in Hattemer et al. 1993). Clones in a Pinus sylvestris seed orchard strongly differed with regard to their male and female reproductive success (MüllerStarck and Ziehe 1984). Hermaphroditism precludes the estimation of sexual functions based on an observation of flowering, since male and female flowering cannot be easily distinguished. Thus, the variation of sexual functions in populations of tropical trees is largely unknown owing to the predominance of hermaphroditism as a sexual system in the tropical forests.
4.3 Asexual Reproduction Many plant species and some animal species have the potential for asexual reproduction. In this case, offspring is produced from tissue of a single organism by mitotic cell divisions only; meiosis and recombination do not occur.
49
50
C HAPTER 4 Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
Thus, the genotypes of asexually produced offspring are identical copies of the genotype of the original plant. Obviously, asexually produced progenies of a single plant are also genetically identical among each other. A collective of genetically identical organisms is called a clone.
4.3.1 Vegetative Reproduction
Vegetative reproduction is not only an important tool for the production of forest reproductive material such as cuttings (Hartmann and Kester 1983), but is also frequently encountered in natural and secondary forests of the tropics. The importance of vegetative propagation for tree improvement, plantation forestry, and conservation of forest genetic resources will be discussed in later chapters. The following remarks mainly refer to vegetative reproduction under natural conditions. Not all plants which are commonly vegetatively propagated by humans are capable of vegetative reproduction in natural forests. Root suckers, i.e., the development of sprouts from roots, are the most common form of vegetative reproduction in natural forests. Coppicing may be regarded as a form of vegetative growth or of reproduction; thus, coppice shoots exemplify the transition from vegetative growth to vegetative multiplication. Many tropical forest plants use vegetative reproduction as a complementary method in addition to sexual reproduction via seeds. Root suckers are an important means of reproduction for Cordia alliodora. They are particularly common in dry and semidry forests of the tropics. For example, Prosopis juliflora and other legumes in dry forests frequently reproduce by root suckers. Bamboos are another important species group which predominantly reproduces vegetatively. Flowering of bamboos is a rare event, resulting in the death of a flowering plant after seed production for many species (Janzen 1976). Bambusa vulgaris is a commonly cultivated species throughout the tropics. It very rarely flowers and the production of viable seeds has never been observed for this species (Banik 1995); thus, B. vulgaris is one of the very few taxa which exclusively multiplies vegetatively. Vegetative reproduction is not only common for tropical trees, but also for other plants growing in forests of the lower latitudes. For example, vegetative reproduction was expected in clusters of the neotropical epiphytic orchid Laelia rubescens Lindley. Clonal reproduction within clusters was confirmed by marker-based inventories, but the degree of sexual reproduction and, hence, genetic diversity within clusters was surprisingly high (Trapnell et al. 2004).
4.3 Asexual Reproduction
4.3.2 Apomixis
A sexual embryo develops in the seed of flowering plants after fertilization of the ovule and fusion of the genetic information of two gametes (female and male) to a zygote. The development of an embryo without the processes of fertilization and fusion of gametes is called agamospermy or, more commonly, apomixis in a narrow sense. Typically, the embryo develops from a somatic cell of the seed parent (apospory). In this case, it is genetically identical to the seed parent. All seeds containing an embryo from apopory from the same seed parent are clones. The development of an embryo from a macrospore mother cell after a meiotic cell division is called diplospory. The resulting embryos from the same plant are not necessarily genetically identical; hence, diplospory is not a form of asexual reproduction in a strict sense. Apospory is a method to propagate and distribute genetically identical organisms (clones) through seeds. This is particularly advantageous if pollen transport from other trees (xenogamy) is either absent or very limited, for example, owing to a large spatial distance between trees growing in low density. Seeds developing in the absence of “foreign” pollen after selfing usually show strong inbreeding depression (Sect. 6.4.2). Inbreeding is avoided and individual variation (heterozygosity) maintained if apomictic seeds are produced. The potential for apomixis is particularly advantageous for a plant if it is combined with the ability to produce sexual progenies if foreign pollen is available (facultative apomixis). For example, the walnut (Juglans regia) produces sexual offspring if pollen is available, but is capable of apomixis in the case of a lack of pollination (p. 47 in Stern and Roche 1974). Trees are usually sterile if meiotic cell divisions are disturbed owing to an unbalanced chromosome number (e.g., triploidy) since no functioning gametes are produced; however, such trees may produce viable seeds by means of apomixis. Thus, many apomictic species are polyploid; the somatic cells of those plants contain more than two full sets of chromosomes. For example, triploid Casuarina nana plants reproduce through apomixis (Barlow 1958). The West African species Pachira oleaginea (Bombacaceae) is a hermaphrodite pollinated by bats. It is a polyploid species with 72 chromosomes in somatic cells. Seeds are produced only after pollination and fertilization, but self-fertilization is possible; thus, Pachira oleaginea seems to be self-fertile although other species of the genus Pachira have an incompatibility system (Sect. 6.5.1). A sexual proembryo develops in the ovule after fertilization, but up to 15 adventive embryos start to develop almost simultaneously in the same ovule from tissue of the nucellus. The mature seeds contain only two to five
51
52
C HAPTER 4 Sexual and Asexual Reproduction in Tropical Forests
embryos. Only one or two of these develop into seedlings. In most cases, the sexual embryo dies during seed development since adventive embryos grow faster. Thus, seed production requires regular fertilization, but embryos of most mature seeds have an apomictic origin (Baker 1960). This form of seed development (“pseudogamy”) requiring pollination but resulting in apomictic embryos has also been described for fruit species of the genus Citrus. At least facultative apomixis has been described for several dipterocarps, including Stemonoporus oblongifolius (Murawski and Bawa 1994), Hopea odorata (Wickneswari et al. 1995), and the autotetraploid Shorea ovalis ssp. sericea (Ng et al. 2004). Apomixis is suggested to be an evolutionary strategy allowing the maintenance of high genetic diversity in populations of Shorea ovalis ssp. sericea (Ng et al. 2004). Apomixis in H. odorata is possibly related to the occurrence of triploid trees in this species (Jong 1976). Kaur et al. (1978) suggested that apomixis may be common not only for dipterocarps, but also for other tropical forest plants. The observation of abundant seed crops of spatially isolated trees of dioecious or self-incompatible species suggests apomixis as a likely explanation. However, marker-based studies rarely confirmed apomixis in tropical forests. In many cases, long-distance transport of effective pollen seems to be responsible for the production of outcrossed seeds even for trees’ “isolated” by distances of several hundred meters from other flowering trees of the same species serving as potential pollen donors (Sect. 5.2.3).
4.4 Recommended Literature Early studies of Bawa and Opler (Bawa 1974, 1980; Bawa and Opler 1975; Opler and Bawa 1978) on the sexual system of neotropical trees revealed the high frequency of dioecy and self-incompatibility. Kaur et al. (1978) suspected that apomixis may be widespread among tropical forest plants. This idea stipulated in-depth studies which, however, only rarely supported their hypothesis.
Gene Flow and Migration
The level of gene exchange between populations is determined by a multitude of factors, including the size, density, and shape of the donor and recipient populations, plant height and breeding system, characters of the surrounding vegetation, terminal velocity of pollen and seeds, pollen and seed prodction, and the foraging behavior of pollen and seed vectors, as well as the distance between populations. To further confound matters, many of these factors vary in both time and space (Levin and Kerster 1974).
5.1 Introduction Genetic information is transported within and among populations of tropical forest species. The main focus of the following discussion is on plants, but animals are also considered since they are important vectors for the dispersal of pollen and seeds, and since gene flow is crucial for the spatial distribution of genetic information both in plants and in animals. Higher plants and their female gametophytes, which are part of the gynoecium, are immobile; thus, the principal methods for the transportation of genetic information in plants are the movement of the male gamete (pollen), and of seeds. For some species, vegetative reproduction results in shortdistance (e.g., root suckers) or long-distance (e.g., bulbils) transport of genetic information. Seedlings are dispersed in rare cases such as in viviparous mangrove species. The terms “gene flow” and “migration” are in common use for the transportation of genetic information in plants. In a broad sense, both terms refer to any transportation of genetic information, either by pollen or by seed movement. We will use the term gene flow in its narrow sense only for the movement of pollen, and will describe the transportation of seeds as migration.
5
54
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
5.2 Gene Flow Through Pollen 5.2.1 Pollination and Fertilization
Sexual reproduction is based on the fusion of a male and a female gamete. The transportation of the male gametophyte to the female plant is required in seed plants. This requires a series of events in angiosperms: First, pollen is transported to the stigma of the same (autogamy) or a different (geitonogamy or xenogamy; Fig. 4.2) flower. The pollination is followed by the growth of a pollen tube through the style to the ovule. Then, after entering the ovule through the micropyle, fertilization of the embryo sac takes place (p. 32 ff. in Proctor et al. 1996). The genotypic structures of the progeny generation are influenced both by the dispersal of pollen and by genetic differences of the pollen with regard to germination, pollen tube growth, and fertilization success. Pollen dispersal from anthers to stigmas or, in the case of gymnosperms, to the micropyle is discussed in this chapter. Aspects related to the processes of the germination of pollen, pollen tube growth, and fertilization are covered in Sect. 6.5.1. 5.2.2 Pollen Vectors in Tropical Forests
A detailed description of pollination and pollen transport by biotic and abiotic vectors was given by Proctor et al. (1996). Prance (1985) reviewed the pollination and pollinators of Amazonian plants. Only the most important considerations related to pollen transportation in tropical forests are briefly reviewed here. Pollen is dispersed by abiotic or biotic means. Wind is the principal abiotic factor facilitating pollen dispersal; different animals are pollen dispersal agents of most tropical forest plants. 5.2.2.1 Pollination by Wind (Anemogamy)
Wind is the most important pollen vector of trees in the temperate and boreal zone. For example, the principal stand-forming species in central Europe belonging to the families Fagaceae (Fagus sylvatica, Quercus spp.) and Pinaceae (Pinus sylvestris, Picea abies) are wind-pollinated (anemogamous). Wind pollination is rare in the humid central tropics (Regal 1982); only 1–2% of plants in the central
5.2 Gene Flow Through Pollen
tropics disperse their pollen by the wind (Bawa 1990). However, this proportion increases in semidry and dry tropical forests. Tropical pines (Pinus spp.) and many other gymnosperms such as Podocarpus species are wind-pollinated (Regal 1982). Pioneers and species commonly found in secondary forests such as some Cecropia spp. are also anemogamous. Wind has been suggested as a pollen vector for some eucalypts, but these statements are not supported by experimental evidence (p. 190 in Eldridge et al. 1994). The success of pollen parents in pollinating a particular seed tree depends on numerous factors, including the spatial structure and the distance between trees, environmental factors, including the preferential wind direction, velocity, and competing vegetation acting as a “pollen filter,” species-specific criteria such as pollen morphology and pollen size, and individual characteristics, including the number of pollen produced during a flowering period. For example, there is evidence for limited pollen dispersal and preferential matings among near neighbors for the wind-pollinated Araucaria angustifolia (Sousa and Hattemer 2003; Sect. 11.4.3). A large number of studies conducted on wind-pollinated tree species in temperate forests revealed both preferential pollen transport from directly neighboring trees (e.g., for Pinus sylvestris; Müller 1977) and a large proportion of successful long-distance pollination (e.g., for Quercus macrocarpa; Dow and Ashley 1998). Observations in clonal seed orchards (Sect. 12.8.1) of wind-pollinated conifers in temperate and boreal climates proved a high frequency of contamination by external pollen (Wheeler and Jech 1992); thus, spatial isolation of clonal seed orchards from conspecific forest stands does frequently not result in reproductive isolation owing to efficient long-distance dispersal of pollen by the wind. A high frequency of matings after long-distance pollen dispersal has been suggested by Lindgren et al. (1995) for Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris). The authors assume that viable pine pollen can be transported over hundreds of kilometers before becoming effective in the boreal climate of Scandinavia. The high species diversity and, hence, the low population density is likely to be the main reason for the rarity of wind-pollination in evergreen moist tropical forests, since “wind-pollination is usually not as effective as animal pollination where inter-individual distances are large” (Regal 1982). 5.2.2.2 Pollination by Animals (Zoogamy)
Zoogamy is dominant in tropical forests, and numerous animals are involved in pollen dispersal. This is in sharp contrast to temperate and boreal forests, where fewer species are pollinated by animals, and where only certain insects play a significant role in pollination.
55
56
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
Vertebrates
Only small flying vertebrates (birds and bats) are important pollinators for tropical plants. Nonflying mammals such as opossums and monkeys have been reported to act as pollinators for a few plant species with robust flowers (Janson et al. 1981), but most flowers are severely damaged by visiting nonflying mammals. Bats
Many Bombacaceae such as the baobab (Adansonia digitata) and Ceiba pentranda (Lobo et al. 2005), but also some Parkia spp. (Mimosaceae) and Bauhinia spp. (Caesalpinaceae; Heithaus et al. 1974) are predominantly pollinated by bats. Flowers visited by bats are usually very big and white or light yellow. They open at dawn or during the night, smell strong, and produce large quantities of nectar (p. 36 in Whitmore 1975). Inflorescences either stand upright over the crown or hang from long twigs. Sometimes they are produced by modified twigs originating directly from the stem (cauliflory, e.g., the “cannonball tree” Couroupita guianensis; Fig. 5.1). The production of flowers suitable for bat pollination is energy-demanding for a tree. On the other hand, most bats fly long distances. Accordingly, they are efficient vectors for the transport of pollen over long distances. The efficiency of bats as pollinators critically depends on the behavior of each species as well as preferred resting areas (Heithaus et al. 1974; Stuart and Marshall 1976).
Fig. 5.1. Flowers of the cauliflorous cannonball tree Couroupita guianensis (Lecthidaceae). (Photo: R. Finkeldey)
5.2 Gene Flow Through Pollen
Birds
Only comparatively few small bird species act as pollinators for tropical forest plants. Hummingbirds are well-known pollinators of forest plants in tropical America. Their function is fulfilled by various other species belonging to the Zosteropidae, Dicaeidae, Nectariniidae, and Meliphagidae in other parts of the tropics. Many flowers visited by birds are bright red and big. They produce large quantities of nectar, which is the main energy source for the pollinators, but the flowers rarely have strong smells. Many inflorescences are brushlike with long filaments. The conspicuous flowers of Erythrina spp. and Bromeliaceae are pollinated by birds. Heliconia spp. (Musaceae) are frequently planted ornamentals originating from America. Their beautiful flowers are adapted to pollination by birds. Several taxa, such as species of the genus Calliandra, are pollinated by birds, bats, and possibly also insects. The production of “bird-flowers” is as energyconsuming as the production of “bat-flowers.” The size and the behavior of birds suggests that they are efficient vehicles for long-distance transport of pollen; however, the actual distances between two trees which can be bridged by birds critically depends on the sizes of their territories. Pollination by Insects
Insects are the most important pollen vectors in the tropics. Many “generalist” species visit flowers of a multitude of plants. Other pollinating insects coevolved with particular plant species. The obligatory symbiosis between figs (Ficus spp.) and their pollinators (fig wasps; Agaonidae) is a particular wellknown example of a close coevolution between tropical plants and insects (Janzen 1979a; Example 7.2). Hymenoptera
The Hymenoptera (bees, wasps, bumble bees, etc.) are an extraordinary species-rich group of pollinators. Although most bees forage on flowers of numerous plant species, they often prefer a particular species at a given time. The flight behavior of bees and hence their efficiency as pollinators depends on numerous factors, including their size, their sex (male or female; Ackerman et al. 1982), and their social or solitary life cycle. There are few uniform features of flowers which are exclusively or predominantly pollinated by Hymenoptera. The flower morphology greatly varies even within a single tree family such as the neotropical Lecythidaceae, which is predominantly pollinated by bees (Prance 1985). Some plant species attract numerous bees and wasps. For example, more than 70 different bee species were counted visiting the flowers of a single Andira inermis tree (Bawa 1990).
57
58
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
Bees prefer to fly short distances between visited flowers. Accordingly, most visits are within the crown of a single tree, and geitonogamy is expected to be common (Sect. 4.2.2). Strategies to minimize geitonogamy and hence selffertilization include the evolution of incompatibility mechanisms (Sect. 6.5.1) and a particular flowering phenology (see Example 6.1 for teak). Butterflies and Moths
Flowers mainly pollinated by butterflies typically combine bright pink or red colors with a sweet scent (Proctor et al. 1996). Nectar is usually accessible through a slender corolla. Night-active moths are attracted by a heavy sweet smell; flowers pollinated by moths are often pale. A close coevolution has been described for Heliconius spp. butterflies and vines belonging to the genera Anguria and Gurania in South America (Prance 1985). The butterflies learn the routes between plants widely scattered in the forest and repeatedly visit male flowering plants on their way. The dioecious plants depend on the butterflies as pollinators for reproduction, and the pollen is an important source of protein for the butterflies (p. 82 in Proctor et al. 1996). Moths are less conspicuous than butterflies, but they are important pollinators of many trees of the Rubiaceae, Meliaceae, Mimosaceae, and Apocynaceae and other families. Flies and Beetles
Flies (Diptera) and beetles (Coleoptera) are ubiquitous, extraordinary speciesrich groups of insects, but they play an important role in pollination of woody plants only in the tropics. Flowers predominantly pollinated by flies are often sweet-scented. Occasionally, they have an unattractive, excremental scent. Some flowers adapted to pollination by flies are adapted to “trap pollination” and “sapromyiophily,” i.e., pollination associated with decaying organic material (p. 294 ff. in Proctor et al. 1996). Long-term “imprisonment” of flies in flowers is common in several genera such as Aristolochia (Aristolochiaceae) and Ceropegia (Asclepiadaceae). The huge flowers of Rafflesia arnoldii, a flowering plant parasitic on climbers in tropical Southeast Asia, are pollinated by flies. Many angiosperms belonging to the Annonaceae and other “primitive” families are pollinated by beetles. Thus, this type of pollination seems to be archetypal for angiosperm plants. Beetle pollination has also been reported for species of the gymnosperm family Cycadaceae, and for younger families such as many palms (Palmae) (Eguiarte et al. 1993; Listabarth 1996). Flowers pollinated by beetles often attract other insects as well. Various beetles destroy flowers or inflorescences at least partially by feeding on them.
5.2 Gene Flow Through Pollen
Other Insects
Other, frequently inconspicuous groups of insects serve important functions for forest ecosystems since they are the main pollinators of keystone plant species. Tiny thrips, cicadas, and bugs belong to this group. Dipterocarps from the central tropics show the phenomenon of simultaneous mass flowering in irregular intervals. Many of them, in particular Shorea and Hopea spp. with small flowers, are mainly pollinated by tiny thrips (Thysanoptera) (Ashton 1988). Another example of the enormous diversity of pollinating insects is the climber Uvaria elmeri (Annonaceae), which is pollinated by cockroaches (Nagamitsu and Inoue 1997). Pollen Vectors: General Patterns and Trends
The species diversity of tropical forests is mirrored by a great diversity of pollination mechanisms. Some plants, for example, most figs (Ficus spp.), depend on a single animal species and evolved an obligatory symbiosis to its pollinator (Example 7.2). Other forest plants are pollinated by a great variety of animals. Pollination by birds, bats, opossums, and large bees has been described for Mabea fistulifera (Euphorbiaceae) in Brazil (Viera and de Carvalho-Okano 1996). The relative importance of different main groups of pollinators has been estimated for evergreen rain forests by Bawa (1990) (Table 5.1). Distinct patterns appear for species of the canopy and of the undergrowth. For example, birds and beetles are important pollinators chiefly for species of the undergrowth. A significant role of bees as main pollinators is evident both for canopy trees and for the undergrowth.
Table 5.1. Relative frequency of different pollen vectors in the canopy and the undergrowth of an evergreen tropical rain forest. (Adapted from Bawa 1990) Pollen vector
Canopy
Undergrowth
No. of species Bats Birds Large bees Small bees Beetles Butterflies Moths Wasps Various small insects Wind
52 3.8% 1.9% 44.2% 7.7% – 1.9% 13.5% 3.8% 23.1% –
220 3.6% 17.7% 21.8% 16.8% 15.5% 4.5% 7.3% 1.8% 7.7% 3.2%
59
60
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
5.2.3 Pollen Dispersal Assessed by Marker-Based Studies
The physical distribution of pollen can be studied by observation of the behavior of pollinators. Pollinators can be repeatedly trapped and marked, for example, with color stains, to reveal their mobility (Ackerman et al. 1982). The pollen itself can be marked by fluorescent dyes, and its distribution can be studied (Webb and Bawa 1983). Minimum pollination distances can be estimated for dioecious species as the distance between a seed-bearing female plant and its nearest male neighbor (Midgley 1989). The observation of physical pollen transport can be used to estimate the potential gene flow by pollen since transportation of pollen is an obvious requirement for successful pollination and fertilization; however, the actual gene flow by pollen also depends on the success of male gametes. Only gametes incorporated into zygotes and eventually seeds and seedlings contribute to the movement of genetic information. The measurement of actual gene flow through pollen among plants gives estimates of distances between plants in mating contact; hence, it provides crucial information for population delineation. Modern methods to estimate actual gene flow through pollen are based on the observation of genetic markers, often in two consecutive generations, i.e., adults and their progenies. 5.2.3.1 Dispersal of Rare Alleles
A straightforward method to directly assess the gene dispersal of a male flowering tree which is the only carrier of a unique allele is the observation of the distribution of this allele in progenies of surrounding trees (Example 5.1). The estimation is feasible for unique alleles at biparentally inherited, codominant loci and rests on the assumption of regular segregation in the case of a heterozygous potential pollen parent. If the potential pollen tree is homozygous for the rare allele, its success as a pollen parent can be reliably assessed by the observation of the allele in the heterozygous state in the progeny of a seed tree in the vicinity. In the case of heterozygosity of the potential pollen parent for the unique allele, only half of its progenies carry the marker allele. Example 5.1: Gene Dispersal in a Clonal Seed Orchard of Teak (Tectona grandis) A tree in a clonal seed orchard of teak (Tectona grandis) comprising 16 clones was found to be the unique carrier of a rare allele A2 at the isozyme gene locus PGM (genotype A1A2). Since no other tree in the investigated compartment of the seed orchard exhibited this allele, it is unlikely that the tree was a ramet of
Relative success of marker tree as pollen parent
5.2 Gene Flow Through Pollen 1997
40%
1996 1996 and 1997
30%
20%
10%
20
40 60 80 100 Distance from marker tree (m)
Fig. 5.2. Success of a teak (Tectona grandis) tree as a pollen parent for progenies of seed trees growing at different distances in a clonal seed orchard in Thailand. (Adapted from Finkeldey 2006)
a selected clone. The distribution of the allele in progenies of surrounding seed trees was observed in two consecutive years (1996 and 1997) and the mating success of the “marker tree” was estimated for each seed tree. It was found that the intensely flowering tree was successful as a pollen parent in its immediate neighborhood, but that the success of pollination was low or absent in seed trees growing a distance of more than 20 m from the marker tree (Fig. 5.2). The estimate of the selfing rate of the marker tree in two consecutive years (distance assumed to be 0 m in Fig. 5.2) is discussed in Example 6.1 (From Finkeldey 2006). 5.2.3.2 Paternity Analyses
The observation of unique alleles allows the paternity of progenies harvested from a tree to be assigned to a particular pollen parent; thus, it is a particularly simple case of paternity assignment, applicable only if rare, ideally unique, alleles are observed in reproducing populations. A more general approach is the exclusion of paternity on the basis of the simultaneous observation of genotypes of seed trees, their progenies, and a set of potential pollen parents at multiple gene loci. Ideally, all but one of the potential pollen parents can be excluded for a particular progeny owing to an impossible combination of its genotype, the genotype of the seed parent, and the genotypes of the potential pollen parents. A potential pollen tree is excluded as an actual pollen parent of
61
62
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
a particular progeny if the tree does not carry an allele which was paternally transmitted to the progeny at any gene locus. Obviously, the reliability of paternity exclusion procedures increases with an increasing number of observed gene loci and with increasing variability at the observed loci. Hypervariable, codominant “microsatellites” (simple sequence repeats; Sect. 2.3.1) are particular suitable tools for paternity analyses (Example 5.2). The calculation of paternity likelihoods by special software such as FAMOZ (Gerber et al. 2003) is often preferable to simple exclusion procedures. Example 5.2: Gene Flow Through Pollen in Neobalanocarpus heimii and Dipterocarpus tempehes (Dipterocarpaceae) Thirty potentially flowering trees of the dipterocarp Neobalanocarpus heimii and 248 of their progenies growing in the Pasoh Forest Reserve, Malaysia, were investigated at four microsatellite gene loci (Konuma et al. 2000). Seedlings and saplings were collected within a radius of 10 m around five putative seed parents. The putative seed parent was excluded as an actual seed parent for 16% of the progenies; thus, seeds were also dispersed by an unknown vector. Gene flow by pollen was observed on the basis of paternity exclusion procedures. The estimated minimum average distance between the five seed trees and the successful pollen parents was 524 m. All pollen parents were excluded for 71 out of the 248 progenies investigated (28.6%); thus, these progenies originated from matings with pollen parents out of the plot studied. N. heimii is mainly pollinated by stingless bees (Trigona spp.) and honey bees (Apis spp.). The results of the paternity analyses point towards the efficiency of bees to bridge large distances of, on average, more than 500 m between pollen parents and seed trees (Konuma et al. 2000). Pollen flow of Dipterocarpus tempehes (Dipterocarpaceae) was studied in two years in Lambir Hills National Park, Sarawak, Malaysia (Kenta et al. 2004). Mass flowering was observed in 1996; 1998 was a year of less-intensive flowering. A total of 277 trees in four spatially distinct subpopulations in a 70-ha area as well as 147 (from seed year 1996) and 188 (from seed year 1998) progenies, respectively, were investigated at six simple sequence repeat loci. Average selfing rates were low in both years (7% and 4% for 1996 and 1998, respectively), and mean distances of pollen dispersal were similar and lower than the estimates for N. heimii (222 m in 1996 and 192 m in 1998). Pollen flow among subpopulations was slightly higher in 1996 (44%) than in 1998 (33%). The main pollinators in 1996 were giant honey bees (Apis dorsata), while several moths were suspected of being chiefly responsible for pollen transport in 1998. These differences in the main pollinators did not result in fundamental differences of the pollen dispersal patterns and outcrossing rates; however, the mean relatedness of progenies from the same seed parent was slightly lower in 1996 than in 1998 (From Konuma et al. 2000; Kenta et al. 2004).
5.2 Gene Flow Through Pollen
Example 5.3: Pollen Dispersal in Three Neotropical Tree Species with Different Spatial Distribution Patterns on Barro Colorado Island The impact of population density and population structure on pollen dispersal was studied for three insect-pollinated species growing on Barro Colorado Island, an artificial island in the Panama Canal (Stacy et al. 1996). Paternity exclusion was conducted for each species on the basis of the observation of variation at five to nine polymorphic isozyme gene loci. All adult or subadult trees in an area of 50 or 84 ha were sampled, and seeds were collected under reproducing trees. Minimum estimates of pollen dispersal were calculated assuming that the nearest not-excluded potential pollen parent according to the paternity analysis was the “true” pollen parent. No selfing was observed for any of the populations investigated, and considerable distances between pollen parents and seed trees were bridged by the pollinators; however, the pollination patterns differed among the species studied and depended on the spatial distribution of trees. The distribution of the 25 adult trees of Calophyllum longifolium (Clusiaceae)was rather uniform throughout the area investigated (84 ha). The nearest neighbor was rarely identified as a pollen parent in the case of spatially isolated seed trees, and the successful pollen parent was separated from the seed tree by a distance of at least 210 m for 62% of the progenies investigated. If trees were widely separated, pollen flow ranged up to several hundred meters. However, cross-pollination seemed to be frequent within the only “cluster” of two directly neighboring trees, which could not be excluded as a pollen parent for 72 and 73% of the progenies investigated from the other tree in this cluster, respectively. Fourteen adults of Spondias mombin (Anacardiaceae) were counted in the same area of 84 ha. Pollination was mainly within clusters, and the nearest neighbor could not be excluded as a pollen parent for roughly 90% of the progenies investigated for this species. On the other hand, a low level of gene flow through pollen over distances of at least 300 m was also confirmed, and pollen flow from outside the area studied was confirmed by the occurrence of rare alleles in progenies which were not observed in any adult in the plot. Only five of the 30 potentially reproducing trees of Turpinia occidentalis (Staphyleaceae) in the 50-ha plot studied produced abundant seeds in the season studied (1993). These five trees occurred in two small clusters of two and three trees with a diameter of 35 and 57 m, respectively. The clusters were separated by a distance of approximately 235 m. Pollen flow was mainly within clusters, and pollen flow over a distance of more than 130 m was confirmed for only one out of 115 progenies investigated. These results point towards a considerable importance of the spatial population structure on pollen dispersal by small insects in tropical forests. Predominance of
63
64
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
pollination among near neighbors was observed mainly within clusters and small groups of trees. Pollen dispersal is more far-reaching and not restricted to nearest neighbous in the case of a more random distribution of reproducing adults in the forest (From Stacy et al. 1996). 5.2.3.3 Model-Based Estimates of Pollen Dispersal
The investigation of pollen dispersal on the basis of paternity analyses requires the availability of highly polymorphic marker systems and a full inventory of all potential pollen parents in the selected area. Alternative marker-based approaches such as the neighborhood model (Adams 1992) and the TWOGENER method (Smouse et al. 2001; Austerlitz et al. 2004) are less demanding with regard to the degree of polymorphism and the sampling design. However, estimates of pollen dispersal based on these methods rest on model assumptions which are difficult to test and often unlikely to be fulfilled. The investigation of a limited number of seed trees and of a sample of their separately harvested and investigated progenies allows the assessment of the allelic structures in successful pollen contributions. The heterogeneity among pollen allele frequencies of single seed trees is not only a suitable measure of deviation from random mating (Sect. 6.2.1), but is also used by the TWOGENER method to estimate pollen dispersal parameters. Example 5.4: Pollen Dispersal in Dinizia excelsa (Fabaceae) Pollen dispersal was estimated on the basis of an analysis of five microsatellite loci and the TWOGENER method for the Amazonian endemic tree Dinizia excelsa (Fabaceae) in Brazil (Dick et al. 2003). Single-tree progenies were harvested in a highly disturbed, fragmented landscape dominated by pastures, and in an undisturbed continuous forest. Selfing rates were slightly higher in disturbed (s =14%) than in undisturbed (s =10%) conditions. Average pollination distances were estimated to be 212 m in undisturbed forests, where Dinizia excelsa occurs in very low effective densities (approximately 0.1 trees per hectare). The estimate for average pollination distances was considerably higher in the fragmented landscape (1,264 m). Native stingless bees and beetles are the main pollinators in undisturbed forests. Introduced African honey bees (Apis mellifera scutellata) are the principal pollinators in the disturbed landscape. The different types of pollinators result in considerably modified pollination and mating patterns. African honey bees are efficient pollen vectors linking remnant trees in open areas with trees growing in forest fragments (From Dick et al. 2003).
5.3 Migration of Seeds
5.2.4 Efficiency of Pollen Vectors for Gene Flow
The examples of marker-based studies on pollen transport and pollination distances point towards the efficiency of pollinators to bridge distances of at least several hundred meters between reproducing trees in species-rich tropical forests. Similar results were observed in many other comparable studies. For example, Nason et al. (1998) reported large estimates of pollination distances for central American figs (Ficus spp.; Example 7.2). In summary it appears that pollination by animals (zoogamy) is an efficient mechanism to facilitate contacts among widely dispersed, spatially, but not reproductively isolated trees. Thus, population sizes may be large even though the population density is low for the majority of plant species occurring in tropical forests.
5.3 Migration of Seeds Regeneration and colonization of new habitats requires the movement of diaspores. These processes also involve transportation of genetic information usually by means of seed migration both for gymnosperms and for angiosperms. Diaspores are either the seeds themselves or complete fruits or parts of fruits containing seeds. The seedling develops from one or several embryos within a seed. 5.3.1 Seed Vectors
Seeds are dispersed by biotic and abiotic means. Water and wind are the principal abiotic dispersal agents. Biotic seed dispersal is facilitated by animals. Humans play an enormous role in today’s distribution of plants and patterns of genetic variation within species. 5.3.1.1 Abiotic Seed Dispersal
The diaspores of many seed plants contain structures promoting the dispersal of seeds by the wind. The name of the tree family Dipterocarpaceae refers to two wings attached to the fruits of many dipterocarps. However, some dipterocarps have more than two wings, and the wings of several species are only
65
66
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
rudimentarily developed. The hairs attached to the light seeds of many Bombacaceae promote their dispersal by the wind. Another important abiotic means for the dispersal of seeds is water. Hydrochory requires special adaptations to ensure the survival of seeds in water. Seeds of trees growing along the coastline, along rivers, and in swamp or peat forests are potentially dispersed by water. The weight of diaspores is of crucial importance for their ability to be transported by the wind. Trees with light diaspores such as Eucalyptus spp. and Casuarina spp. have a wide “seed shadow,” i.e., they disperse their seeds in a large area. Barochorous trees produce heavy diaspores and have no efficient means of abiotic or biotic dispersal; their seed shadow is narrow since diaspores are “dispersed” by gravity alone. Typically, pioneer species have a larger seed shadow than species of later successional stages. Most barochorous species belong to climax communities. 5.3.1.2 Biotic Seed Dispersal
Vertebrates, in particular birds and mammals, are by far the most important biotic seed dispersers of tropical forest plants (Loiselle et al. 1996). Endozoochorous seed dispersal requires a passage of seeds through the gastrointestinal tract of an animal. Otherwise, dispersal of seeds by animals is exozoochorous. Seed dispersal of tree species with fleshy, juicy fruits is typically endozoochorous. Exozoochorous dispersal is typical for nuts. Most bird species and both flying (bats, flying foxes) and nonflying (rodents, pigs, primates, and others) mammals disperse seeds. The seeds of the small mountain tree Dunalia arborescens (Solanaceae) are dispersed by at least 16 different bird species in Jamaica (Cruz 1981). 5.3.2 Efficiency of Seed Dispersal
The type of seed vector and, in the case of biotic seed dispersers, their behavior are crucial factors for the seed shadow of forest plants. A comparison between seed dispersal agents in temperate and tropical American forests revealed a dominance of endozoochorous seed dispersal only in the tropics. Endozoochorous, exozoochorous, and wind dispersal are of similar importance in temperate forests of North America (Howe and Smallwood 1982). In general, endozoochorous seed dispersal results in a wider dispersal of seeds as compared with that from other mechanisms since the fruits containing seeds are digested before the seeds are defecated. Endozoochorous seed dispersal may be wide but clustered, for example, under the rest trees of seed-dispersing birds
5.4 Long-Distance Gene Flow and Migration in Tropical Forest Species
and bats, and may result in nonrandom dispersal patterns (Loiselle et al. 1996). The comparatively low differentiation among populations of the rare European wild service tree (Sorbus torminalis; Rosaceae) at maternally inherited chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) has been attributed to the endozoochorous dispersal of seeds by birds resulting in frequent migration among spatially separated stands (Oddou-Muratorio et al. 2001). Limited dispersal of seeds results in complex relations between spatial distribution patterns and kinship relations. In general, neighboring trees are expected to be more closely related to each other and hence to be genetically more similar than spatially separated trees of the same population. The existence of “family structures” can be studied if spatially explicit genetic data are available. Ng et al. (2004) found a significant spatial aggregation in small- and medium-diameter classes for two dipterocarp species (Shorea leprosula and Shorea ovalis ssp. sericea) in a 50-ha plot in the Pasoh Forest Reserve, Malaysia. They explained the result by limited dispersal of both seed and pollen for Shorea leprosula, and an apomictic mode of reproduction in the tetraploid Shorea ovalis ssp. sericea. Strong genetic differentiation among populations separated by less than 10 km from each other has been found for the Amazonian tree Corythophora alta at cpDNA haplotypes (Hamilton 1999). Seed dispersal is very restricted in Corythophora alta, resulting in areas as large as 10 ha founded by a single maternal lineage.
5.4 Long-Distance Gene Flow and Migration in Tropical Forest Species Genetic structures of populations are the outcome of evolutionary processes acting over long time periods. Global changes of environmental conditions in the past did not only affect the distribution of species, but also patterns of genetic variation within species. The most fundamental global events with considerable implications for the distribution of species and their genetic variation patterns were the Quaternary glaciations. The ice ages did not only have a farreaching impact on plants in areas directly affected by growing ice sheets and glaciers, but changed the climate and the sea water levels worldwide (Sect. 8.2). The impact of glacial refugia and postglacial recolonization on genetic variation patterns has been studied for numerous temperate species (Hewitt 2000), including forest trees such as oaks (Quercus spp.; Petit et al. 2002). While it is likely that the Quaternary climatic variability had a considerable impact on the distribution of the regional flora and plant species also in the tropics (Spichiger et al. 1995; Sect. 8.2), much less is known about migration patterns of single species and the resulting genetic variation patterns in the central tropics.
67
68
C HAPTER 5 Gene Flow and Migration
Maternally inherited markers are particularly useful to analyze migration patterns of plants. The distribution of maternally inherited cpDNA haplotypes among Central American populations of Cedrela odorata is related to its migration history (Example 7.6). Strong differentiation of cpDNA haplotypes among populations has also been observed in brazilwood (Caesalpinia echinata Lam.; Lira et al. 2003). The species occurs in three spatially isolated regions, all characterized by particular cpDNA haplotypes. This pattern points towards the existence of separate glacial refugia as an explanation for the spatial isolation of distribution areas even prior to the beginning of anthropogenic forest fragmentation (Lira et al. 2003). Very restricted migration between orangutan (Pongo pygmaeus) orang-utan populations on the two different sides of the Kinabatangan river in Sabah, Malaysia, was estimated on the basis of the observation of variation at nuclear microsatellites (Goossens et al. 2005). Thus, the river is an efficient natural barrier for the gene flow for the endangered great ape. However, genetic structures point towards frequent migration between distant locations on the same side of the river, indicating relatively free and long movement of orang-utans.
5.5 Recommended Literature Gene flow in seed plants has been thoroughly reviewed by Levin and Kerster (1974), Ellstrand (1992) and, with a focus on forest trees, Adams (1992). The book by Proctor et al. (1996) describes many aspects of the reproductive biology of plants with regard to pollination. The availability of uniparentally inherited markers and hypervariable gene loci has greatly promoted experimental studies in this field as pointed out by Cruzan (1998), by McCauley (1995) for cpDNA polymorphisms, and by Chase et al. (1996a) for biparentally inherited microsatellites with emphasis on tropical forest trees. The impact of palaeoclimatic conditions on migration and patterns of genetic variation has been reviewed by Hewitt (2001).
Mating Systems
The importance of the generation and use of scientifically based information for genetic conservation is well illustrated by changes in views of mating patterns in tropical trees (Boshier 2000).
6.1 Introduction Mating is possible only between individuals producing gametes of opposite sex. The sexual system (Sect. 4.2.1) describes the possible mating events. Mating among conspecific plants requires the movement of the male gamete to the female gamete and, hence, gene flow (Sect. 5.2). Both the sexual system and gene flow are closely related to the analysis of the actual mating events in a population. The genotypic structure of a progeny generation is crucially affected by the successful mating events in a population. Random mating is a useful reference, although it is rarely achieved for plant species occurring in tropical forests (Sect. 6.2). Selfing (Sect. 6.3) and mating among relatives result in inbreeding; inbred forest trees frequently suffer from strong inbreeding depression (Sect. 6.4). The statement at the beginning of this chapter by Boshier (2000) refers to the accumulation of scientific evidence that inbreeding and in particular selfing is not the rule for tropical forest trees, as it was assumed prior to the conduct of numerous case studies on mating patterns of tropical forest trees. Most forest trees are either dioecious or self-incompatible (Sect. 6.5), and even the majority of self-compatible trees in tropical forests are predominantly outcrossed. The mating system of a species is not uniform, but can vary among different populations and among years. The impact of the population density and other environmental factors on the mating systems of tropical forest plants is mentioned in Sect. 6.6.
6
70
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems
6.2 Random Mating and Panmixis Ideally, a population consists of a group of individuals producing progenies at random, i.e., without any preferences for mating events between particular plants or groups of plants. Random mating is a useful reference even though in actual plant populations mating preferences for neighboring plants or plants with overlapping flowering periods are likely to exist. A prerequisite for random mating is the even distribution and success of male gametes in the population. Thus, all seed parents receive homogeneous pollen contributions in a population with a random mating system. The degree of the deviations from random mating can be assessed by measuring the heterogeneity among pollen contributions to single seed plants (pollen allele frequencies). 6.2.1 Heterogeneity of Pollen Allele Frequencies
The constitution of the successful paternal contributions to the progenies of a particular seed plant is its “genetically effective pollen cloud.” The term “pollen cloud” is illustrative for wind-pollinated species, but may also be used for zoogamous species. Genetic differentiation among pollen allele frequencies results from an unbalanced success of trees as pollen parents for the progenies of particular seed trees as illustrated by a fictitious example in Fig. 6.1. The pollen allele frequency of a seed tree is assessed by estimating the allelic structure of successful pollen after an investigation of a sample of its progenies (seeds). If the haploid megagametophyte and the corresponding embryo in the seed of a gymnosperm are simultaneously analyzed, the pollen contribution can be reliably assessed for each progeny (Müller 1976). Maximum-likelihood estimates of pollen allele frequencies can be obtained if progenies from angiosperm plants are analyzed (Gillet 1997). The separate investigation of progenies from several seed trees of a single population allows the differentiation among them to be assessed with methods used for an analysis of population differentiation (Sect. 3.3.2). The differentiation among pollen allele frequencies is the most important parameter used to estimate pollen dispersal with the TWOGENER method (Sect. 5.2.3). This illustrates the close affinities between gene flow and mating system analyses. Considerable differences with regard to the heterogeneity of pollen allele frequencies at isozyme gene loci appear between populations occurring in pure stands, populations occurring in intermediate density in tropical forests, and rare species distributed in low density in tropical forests (Finkeldey 2002; Fig. 6.2). Extraordinary low differentiation among pollen clouds was observed
6.2 Random Mating and Panmixis
I
II
Fig. 6.1. Mating of two trees in a population. Only conspecific trees in the forest are shown. Tree I is fertilized by only two other trees contributing effective pollen in somewhat unequal proportions; therefore, the effective number of its male mating partners is close to unity and the majority of its offspring are full-sibs. Neither can the effective pollen cloud of tree II be considered representative of that of the virtual pollen cloud of the population. The two trees share only one common male mating partner. Their effective pollen clouds are expected to be markedly differentiated
in three pure Norway spruce (Picea abies) plantations in Germany (Finkeldey 1995). Even this low level of differentiation was statistically significant at most loci in one or several populations, but no strong deviations from random mating were observed. Differentiation was slightly higher in three populations of teak (Tectona grandis) in Thailand, all characterized by comparatively high density (Finkeldey 2006). Most studies on genetic differentiation among pollen allele frequencies were conducted on Barro Colorado Island (Murawski and Hamrick 1991). Significant, but moderate heterogeneity was observed for most tropical forest species occurring in intermediate density (approximately one to ten trees per hectare). The highest differentiation among pollen allele frequencies and, thus, the strongest deviations from random mating were observed for species occurring in low density (less than one flowering tree per hectare) in tropical forests (Murawski and Hamrick 1991).
71
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems GST 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.15 0.10
>50 Ind/ha
1-10 Ind/ha
Tachigali versicolor
Platypodium elegans II
Platypodium elegans I
Ceiba pentandra
Cavanilessia platanifolia III
Cavanilessia platanifolia II
Cavanilessia platanifolia I
Brosimum alicastrum
Trichilia tuberculata
Pterocarpus indicus
Sorocea affinis II
Sorocea affinis I
Quararibea asterolepis
Beilschmedia pendula
Tectona grandis Plant.
Tectona grandis Nat. Pop.
Picea abies III
0.00
Picea abies II
0.05
Picea abies I
72
<1 Ind/ha
Fig. 6.2. Differentiation (FST = GST) among pollen allele frequencies for species occurring in different densities in temperate and topical forests. (Adapted from Finkeldey 2002)
In summary, analyses of pollen allele frequencies confirm the expectation that deviations from random mating are stronger for species and populations occurring in low density in tropical forests in comparison with populations growing in pure forests. 6.2.2 Panmixis and Hardy–Weinberg Structures
A population is panmictic if random mating is realized and if no other evolutionary factors (drift, selection, mutation, gene flow, and migration) have an impact on the genetic structures at a particular locus. In this case, alleles are randomly combined to genotypes and genotype frequencies are a simple function of allele frequencies according to the following equations (see Sect. 2.4.1 for a definition of Pij and pi): Pii = pi2
for homozygote genotypes (Ai Ai ),
(6.1)
Pij = 2 × pi × pj
for heterozygote genotypes (Ai Aj ).
(6.2)
Genotypic structures conforming to these equations are defined as Hardy–Weinberg structures. A population is in “Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium” at a particular gene locus, if the genotype frequencies at the locus can be computed according to Eq. 6.1 for homozygotes and Eq. 6.2 for heterozygotes.
6.3 Selfing and Outcrossing Rates
Numerous effects may cause significant deviation from Hardy–Weinberg structures. For example, a uniform excess of homozygotes as compared with Hardy–Weinberg structures (Pii >pi2 for all alleles i at several gene loci) is expected to result from inbreeding (Sect. 6.4). Slightly more heterozygotes than expected under Hardy–Weinberg conditions were observed at isozyme gene loci in adult trees of a subdivided population of the pioneer species Cecropia obtusifolia in Mexico (Alvarez-Buylla et al. 1996); however, homozygotes exceeded the expectation in the seeds collected after distribution, and in seeds collected from the soil. The proportion of homozygotes decreased from seedlings to juveniles and adults. Mixing of partially differentiated subpopulations owing to seed dispersal explains the homozygote excess in seeds after dispersal better than inbreeding for this dioecious species. Selection favoring heterozygotes possibly accounts for the increase of heterozygosity with age (Alvarez-Buylla et al. 1996). A similar temporal dynamics of genotypic structures with a significant excess of homozygotes in particular in seeds and young seedlings has also been reported for several other tropical tree species such as Ardisia escallonioides (Pascarella 1997), Symphonia globulifera (Aldrich et al. 1998), and Platypodium elegans (Hufford and Hamrick 2003; Example 7.1). The frequency of deviations from Hardy–Weinberg structures in populations of tropical forest trees is another indication that random mating is a useful reference, but not the rule in tropical forests.
6.3 Selfing and Outcrossing Rates Cosexual (hermaphroditic and monoecious) species produce gametes of both sexes on a single plant; thus, the pollination of a female gamete by the male gamete of the same plant is possible (Sect. 4.2.2; Fig. 4.2). The relative frequency of these selfings among all successful mating events of a single plant or a population is the selfing rate s, and its complement is the outcrossing rate t = 1 – s. The selfing rate is a fundamental aspect of the mating system of a population. Many studies were conducted to estimate selfing rates in populations of tropical forest species (Table 6.2). Most experimental studies aimed at the estimation of selfing rates were based on the observation of biochemical or molecular gene markers. Occasionally, other marker types have been used to estimate selfing rates of trees. For example, the mangrove species Rhizophora mangle is a predominantly selfing species according to a study based on the observation of chlorophyll deficiency as a color trait marker (Lowenfeld and Klekowski 1992).
73
74
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems
6.3.1 Estimates of Selfing Rates Based on Rare Alleles
Selfing can be reliably assessed if a tree is homozygous at a biparentally inherited, codominant gene locus for a unique allele Ax, i.e., if no other tree in the population carries this allele. In this case, all progenies from selfing are homozygous Ax Ax, and all progenies from outcrossing are heterozygous Ax Ay (with y = i, j, k, . . .). However, the homozygous occurrence of a rare allele in a single tree is an extremely unlikely and hence rare event. Usually, trees are heterozygous for unique variants x (genotype Ax Ay). In this case, only a fraction of the progenies from selfing can be reliably identified: All progenies homozygous for the rare allele (genotype Ax Ax) arise from selfing. If regular segregation and random fusion of gametes are assumed, the expected segregation within the selfings Ax Ay × Ax Ay is 0.25Ax Ax , 0.5Ax Ay , 0.25Ay Ay. Hence, the proportion of genotypes Ax Ax (Pxx) among a sample of progenies investigated equals one quarter of all selfings, and the selfing rate of the tree can be estimated as s = 4 × Pxx. Example 6.1: Estimates of Selfing Rates in Teak (Tectona grandis) Populations A tree heterozygous for a unique allele A2 at the isozyme gene locus PGM-A was identified in a clonal seed orchard of teak (Example 5.1). Genotypic structures of progenies harvested from this tree were observed in two consecutive years (Table 6.1). On the basis of these observations, the selfing rate was estimated as s = 4 × P22 = 4 × 0.060 = 0.240 in 1996 and s = 4 × 0.94 = 0.376 in 1997. The method was also applied to estimate selfing rates of 24 teak trees carrying a rare allele at a marker locus in natural and planted populations. Estimates of the selfing rate range from s = 0 to s = 0.62 for single trees. Population estimates based on a mixed mating model were between s = 0.07 and s = 0.17 (Finkeldey 2006). Teak flowers are complete (Fig. 6.3a). A single flower is receptive and releases its pollen during a few hours of a single day; however, flowering of an inflorescence (Fig. 6.3b) usually extends over several weeks since only a few flowers are Table 6.1. Genotypic structures at the gene locus PGM-A in progenies of a teak tree (genotype A 1A2) in a clonal seed orchard in Thailand in 1996 and 1997. (Adapted from Finkeldey 2006)
1996 1997 N sample size
N
P11
P12
P22
383 245
0.400 0.429
0.540 0.477
0.060 0.094
6.3 Selfing and Outcrossing Rates
a b Fig. 6.3. Single flower (a) and inflorescence (b) of teak (Tectona grandis). (Photos: R. Finkeldey)
receptive each day. The extended flowering of teak inflorescences reduces the probability of selfing due to geitonogamy since pollinators find only a limited number of receptive flowers available within single inflorescences and hence are forced to move among inflorescences, and possibly trees. Observations of the mating system in natural and breeding populations confirmed that teak is a predominantly outcrossing species. The existence of a system of self-incompatibility has been suggested for teak (Sect. 6.5.1), but considerable levels of selfing were observed in all populations studied in Thailand. High variation of the selfing rate of individual trees was observed. Some trees are (almost) completely outcrossing, while surprisingly high estimates of selfing rates were estimated for other trees. Significantly different selfing rates were estimated for the same tree in different seed years, suggesting an impact of the environmental conditions during flowering (temperature, activity of pollinators, etc.) on selfing rates in teak (Finkeldey 2006).
75
76
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems
6.3.2 Estimates of Selfing Rates Based on a Mixed Mating Model
Selfing is associated with characteristic changes of genotypic structures in the progenies, since it is the strongest form of inbreeding (Sect. 6.4). Thus, it is possible to estimate selfing rates on the basis of an investigation of the progenies from a sample of seed parents in a population. The estimation is based on the assumption that each progeny results either from selfing or from random outcrossing. Random outcrossing is rarely expected to be realized in particular for tropical trees occurring in low density (Sect. 6.2). Accordingly, assumptions of the mixed mating model are often violated, and results are possibly biased. This applies in particular to estimates based on single marker loci and individual seed trees. Multilocus estimates for populations are expected to be more robust against violations of model assumptions. Estimates of the multilocus outcrossing rate tm are most frequently reported (Ritland and Jain 1981). Most estimates of outcrossing rates of tropical trees were obtained from studies based on moderately variable isozyme gene markers using the mixed mating model. Population estimates of tm are shown in Table 6.2 for selected tropical trees species. If more than a single population was investigated in a particular study, the minimum and maximum estimates of tm are reported. Outcrossing rates are close to 1 (or 100%) for the majority of the tropical tree species investigated. Thus, selfing rates (s = 1 – tm) are usually low, and even self-compatible species with a mixed mating system are mainly outcrossing. Exceptions are the self-compatible Cavanillesia platanifolia (Sect. 6.6), some populations of Ardisia escallonioides (Pascarella 1997), and Pinus merkusii in Thailand. Extraordinary low estimates of outcrossing rates for Pinus merkusii were estimated in a few populations only. Overaging, degradation, and lack of flowering synchrony are likely causes for a presumably low availability of foreign pollen in these populations (Changtragoon and Finkeldey 1995a). High outcrossing rates were estimated for Pinus merkusii in a natural stand and seed orchards in Indonesia (Siregar and Hattemer 2001). 6.3.3 Estimates of Selfing Rates Based on Nonmaternal Alleles
The observation of a nonmaternal allele Ak (k ≠ i, j) in a progeny of a seed parent with genotype Ai Aj at any biparentally inherited gene locus is sufficient to exclude selfing; thus, it is possible to calculate a minimum estimate of the outcrossing rate by computing the proportion of progenies with a
6.3 Selfing and Outcrossing Rates
Table 6.2. Estimates of multilocus population outcrossing rates tm based on a mixed mating model for tropical forest tree species Species
tm
Reference
Acacia auriculiformis Ardisia escallonioides Astrocaryum mexicanum Beilschmelia pandula Bertholletia excelsa Brosimum alicastrum Calophyllum longifolium Carapa guianensis Carapa procera Cavanillesia platanifolia Cedrela odorata Ceiba pentandra Cordia alliodora Dipterocarpus cf. condorensis Eucalyptus citriodora E. delegatensis E. grandis E. kitsoniana E. obliqua E. pauciflora E. regnans E. rhodantha E. saligna E. stellulata E. stoatei Jacaranda copaia Pterocarpus indicus Pterocarpus macrocarpus Pinus merkusii
0.673–0.951 0.390–1.051 0.933–1.050 0.918 0.849 0.875 1.030–1.031 0.967–0.986 0.78 0.213–0.661 0.969 0.689 0.966 0.68–0.81 0.86 0.79 0.84 0.77 0.76 0.63 0.69 0.58–0.60 0.77 0.77 0.82 0.982 0.908 0.719– 0.959 0.017–0.843
Platypodium elegans Quararibea asterolepis Shorea congestiflora Shorea megistophylla Shorea trapezifolia Sorocea affinis Spondias mombin Stemmadenia donnel-smithii Stemonoporus oblongifolius Tachigali versicolor Trichilia tuberculata Turpinia occidentalis
0.898–0.924 1.008 0.874 0.71–0.87 0.519–0.602 0.969–1.089 0.989–1.304 0.896 0.84 0.937 1.077 1.006–1.071
Wickneswari and Norwati (1995) Pascarella (1997) Eguiarte et al. (1992) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) O’Malley et al. (1988) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Stacy et al. (1996) Hall et al. (1994b) Doligez and Joly (1997) Murawski and Hamrick (1992) James et al. (1998) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Boshier et al. (1995) Luu (2005) Moran and Bell (1983) Moran and Bell (1983) Moran and Bell (1983) Moran and Bell (1983) Moran and Bell (1983) Phillips and Brown (1977) Moran and Bell (1983) Sampson et al. (1989) Moran and Bell (1983) Moran and Bell (1983) Moran and Bell (1983) James et al. (1998) Finkeldey et al. (1999) Liengsiri et al. (1998) Changtragoon and Finkeldey (1995a) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Murawski et al. (1994a) Murawski et al. (1994b) Murawski et al. (1994a) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Stacy et al. (1996) James et al. (1998) Murawski and Bawa (1994) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Murawski and Hamrick (1991) Stacy et al. (1996)
77
78
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems
nonmaternal allele at any gene locus investigated. The estimation is a special case of paternity exclusion (Sect. 5.2.3) with the seed parent regarded as the only potential pollen parent. The reliability of the estimate increases with the number of gene loci investigated and with the variability at these loci. Thus, the method is preferably based on an investigation of several “hypervariable” loci; nuclear microsatellites (simple sequence repeats) are particularly useful to identify nonmaternal alleles owing to their codominance and high variability (Example 7.1). High outcrossing rates were estimated for a Dipterocarpus tempehes population (t = 0.93 and 0.96 in two different seed years) on the basis of paternity exclusion and taking possible genotyping errors into account (Kenta et al. 2004; Example 5.2). Comparable results were obtained for the outcrossing rate in an undisturbed natural forest of another dipterocarp, Shorea curtisii (t = 0.96); however, estimates of individual outcrossing rates were considerably lower for five Shorea curtisii tress in a selectively logged forest (t = 0.52; Obayashi et al. 2002).
6.4 Inbreeding and Inbreeding Depression Plants (and animals) are genetically related, if they have at least one common ancestor. If two related plants mate, they possibly transmit a copy of the same allele, which both of them may have inherited from their common ancestor, to their progeny. In result, mating among relatives leads to a certain probability that two alleles in the progeny are identical by descent (p. 179 ff. in Hedrick 2000); thus, mating among relatives results in an increased probability that the two alleles transmitted to a progeny are identical, i.e., that the progeny is homozygous at the respective gene locus. The same applies in the case of a progeny resulting from gametes produced by the same parent after selfing. Inbreeding is defined as mating among relatives, including selfing, which is regarded as the strongest form of inbreeding. It results in increased homozygosity as compared with matings among nonrelated plants. The increase in average homozygosity due to inbreeding depends on the degree of relatedness of the parents. 6.4.1 Genetic Consequences of Inbreeding
The average level of inbreeding in a population is frequently quantified by a comparison of the heterozygosity He expected under Hardy–Weinberg conditions
6.4 Inbreeding and Inbreeding Depression
(Sect. 6.2.2) and the observed heterozygosity Ho (see Sect. 3.3.1 for a computation of He and Ho). It holds for the “inbreeding coefficient” F F = 1 − Ho/He.
(6.3)
In case of Hardy–Weinberg structures, Ho equals He, resulting in F = 0. If the observed heterozygosity exceeds the expected heterozygosity, F becomes negative. Negative values of F cannot be explained by inbreeding but have other causes, for example, selection favoring heterozygotes at the gene locus investigated. If fewer heterozygotes were observed than expected for corresponding Hardy–Weinberg structures, F becomes positive. If positive inbreeding coefficients F are observed at several gene loci, and if the values for F are homogeneous across loci, inbreeding is a plausible explanation for the observed genotypic structures. Examples of inbreeding coefficients F observed in populations of tropical forest plants are shown in Table 6.3. Weak or no impact of inbreeding on genotypic structures is suggested by low inbreeding coefficients for Pterocarpus indicus, D. condorensis, Dipterocarpus cf. condorensis, and Swietenia macrophylla. The inbreeding coefficient was low, but significantly different from zero in four out of seven populations of Swietenia macrophylla studied (Lemes et al. 2003; Sect. 3.5.3; Table 3.4). The genotypic structures of Ancistrocladus korupensis (Foster and Sork 1997) and the five Pinanga species studied by Shapcott (1999) are strongly influenced by inbreeding. Very high selfing rates and preferential mating among neighboring, closely related trees are likely to account for the high inbreeding coefficients observed for both species.
Table 6.3. Average inbreeding coefficients F = 1 – Ho/He observed in populations of tropical forest plants Species
Plant group
Marker type
F
Reference
Ancistrocladus korupensis
Liana
Isozyme
0.455
Dipterocarpus cf. condorensis Pinanga spp. (5 species) Pterocarpus indicus
Timber tree
Isozyme
0.051
Foster and Sork (1997) Luu (2005)
Palm Timber tree
Isozyme Isozyme
0.640–0.856 0.015
Pterocarpus macrocarpus
Timber tree
Isozyme
0.099
Swietenia macrophylla
Timber tree
Microsatellite
0.038
Shapcott (1999) Finkeldey et al. (1999) Liengsiri et al. (1995) Lemes et al. (2003)
79
80
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems
6.4.2 Inbreeding Depression
The loss of heterozygosity as a consequence of inbreeding is often reflected at phenotypic traits of adaptive or economic significance. Many complex traits, including survival, growth rate, and quality traits such as stem straightness, are negatively influenced by inbreeding of predominantly outcrossing species. The negative impact of inbreeding on phenotypes and the fitness is defined as inbreeding depression. Predominantly or exclusively selfing species, including many agricultural crops such as rice and soy bean, do not suffer from inbreeding depression since inbreeding does not further reduce the level of heterozygosity for these species. Inbreeding depression can be explained by a slight superiority of heterozygotes in comparison with homozygotes at many gene loci (“overdominance hypothesis”; Ziehe and Roberds 1989) or by a strong inferiority of particular homozygotes for deleterious alleles at a few adaptive gene loci (“dominance hypothesis”; p. 220 ff. in Allard 1960). Deleterious recessive alleles seem to be a more important cause of inbreeding depression in plants than overdominance (Ritland 1996a). Most tropical forest tree species are highly variable (Sect. 3.4; Tables 3.2, 3.3) and predominantly outcrossing (Sect. 6.3; Table 6.2); thus, the observed heterozygosity is usually high, and strong inbreeding depression is expected for most trees regardless of the exact cause of the negative impact of low levels of (average) heterozygosity on fitness and phenotypic traits (Ledig 1986b). Inbreeding depression acts on numerous traits affecting fitness throughout the life cycle of plants. Inbreeding effects have been studied particularly well for eucalypts (Example 6.2) and a few other species grown in plantations. It is difficult to investigate inbreeding depression in natural and naturally regenerated forests (but see Example 7.1), but a negative effect of inbreeding on fitness is likely to be a main cause for the evolution of efficient pollen dispersal mechanisms (Sect. 5.2) and of incompatibility systems (Sect. 6.5) for many tropical forest plants. Thus, the disruption of mating contact among nonrelated, widely separated plants poses a main threat to populations since it results in increased inbreeding (Finkeldey 2002). Example 6.2: Inbreeding Depression in Eucalypts Eucalypts (Eucalyptus spp.) are hermaphroditic, self-compatible trees. A mixed mating system is typical for eucalypts. Outcrossing usually dominates, but selfing rates of 20–40% are frequently encountered (Table 6.2). Inbreeding depression of eucalypts has attracted considerable interest since it directly affects the performance of eucalypt plantations.
6.4 Inbreeding and Inbreeding Depression
Inbreeding depression during an early life stage was studied for E. delegatensis (Moran and Brown 1980). Fruits of this species remain on seed trees for several years, allowing the investigation of seed cohorts of different age. The outcrossing rate tm was estimated in 1-, 2, and 3-year-old seed cohorts on the basis of isozyme studies and a mixed mating model with the following result: tm = 0.66 (1-year-old seeds), tm = 0.78 (2-year-old seeds), tm = 0.85 (3-year-old seeds). Thus, outcrossing seems to increase and, hence, selfing to decrease with increasing age. The most likely reason for the effect is early mortality of inbred seeds. Preferential survival of outcrossed progenies is a plausible explanation for the apparent increase of the outcrossing rate. The growth of progenies from controlled selfing, open pollination, and controlled outcrossing was compared for seed parents of E. regnans in a field trial in Australia. Survival and height growth were only slightly affected by selfing during the early development of the trial, but strong and highly significant differences were observed 12 years after planting. Only 31.2% of the selfed trees survived; their average diameter was 20.4 cm. This compares with 71.9% survival with an average diameter of 24.2 cm for the open-pollinated trees. The completely outcrossed family was even superior to the trees from open pollination (Griffin and Cotterill 1988). Many studies proved strong inbreeding depression in E. grandis. Inbreeding results in inferior growth of young plants and has a negative impact on quality traits like stem form (Hodgson 1976a). Inbreeding depression in E. grandis is not restricted to selfing, but has also been described for matings among fulland half-sibs (van Wyk 1981). Its strength depends on the relatedness of the parent trees. The growth performance of E. grandis progenies from single seed trees after open pollination is correlated to the outcrossing rate tm of the seed parents estimated by a mixed mating model on the basis of isozyme investigations (Burgess et al. 1996). The mean family heights of 20 open-pollinated families with high estimates of outcrossing rates (tm) were quite uniform for 2.5-yearold plants (Fig. 6.4). Some families with low estimates of outcrossing rates reached comparable mean heights, but the mean height growth of most families with low tm was considerably below the mean for the reference populations with high tm. Thus, the mean growth rate of a family is negatively affected by a low outcrossing rate, presumably owing to inferior growth of selfed progenies. The strong inbreeding depression of eucalypts has considerable practical importance. Eucalypt plantations are established worldwide on a large scale (Eldridge et al. 1994), and the origin of reproductive material is often unknown. Most eucalypts flower and fruit prolifically and regularly even if they grow as isolated individuals or in small stands. Uncontrolled harvest of seeds from isolated trees or small stands poses a risk of producing inbred reproductive material which is expected to suffer from strong inbreeding depression.
81
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems 12 Families with low outcrossing rates
Families with high outcrossing rates
11 Mean family height (m)
82
10
9
8
7
6 0
0.2
0.4
0.6 0.8 1 Family outcrossing rate
1.2
1.4
1.6
Fig. 6.4. Family mean height of 2.5-year-old Eucalyptus grandis seedlings in relation to an estimate of the family outcrossing rate tm for 40 families with contrasting estimates of tm. (From Burgess et al. 1996)
Negative effects from inbreeding depression are particularly likely to occur if seeds are harvested from well-performing, but isolated trees or small stands close to villages for the establishment of small-scale plantations in rural areas.
6.5 Incompatibility and Self-Sterility Since most tropical forest trees are hermaphroditic, selfing by means of autogamy and geitonogamy is possible. However, selfing is the strongest form of inbreeding and is associated with strong inbreeding depression. In consequence, mechanisms preventing selfing offer considerable evolutionary advantage. The most important mechanisms acting prior to fertilization are incompatibility systems. Cosexual species without incompatibility reactions often evolve systems of self-sterility which result in early abortion of embryos after fertilization. 6.5.1 Incompatibility
The genotypes of two plants which are able to produce a common progeny are compatible. If plants belong to different biological species, they are incompatible
6.5 Incompatibility and Self-Sterility
since they cannot produce common progenies. On the other hand, incompatibility also often occurs between gametes produced by a single cosexual plant. For example, controlled pollination of Gmelina arborea (Verbenaceae) is not successful if pollen from the seed parent is used (Bolstad and Bawa 1982). This suggests that G. arborea is completely self-incompatible. Observations of the flower development after pollination suggest that teak (T. grandis Tectona grandis), another important timber species of the Verbenaceae, is also at least partially self-incompatible (Tangmitcharoen and Owens 1997); however, controlled self-pollination in teak results in low success rates (Bryndum and Hedegart 1969), and marker-based analyses of the mating system after open pollination revealed that teak is a mixed mating species (Example 6.1). Self-incompatibility is controlled by a single locus or only a few incompatibility loci (S-loci). The incompatibility usually results from the inability of pollen to germinate on the pistil of particular plants, or from inhibition of the growth of the pollen tube. The incompatibility system does not only exclude self-pollen from successful fertilization since the genetic information at the S-locus is crucial for the reaction. Two main types of incompatibility systems are distinguished (Boshier 2000). In the case of gametophytic self-incompatibility, the genetic constitution of the male gametophyte at the S-locus is decisive for the incompatibility reaction. Pollen is excluded, if it carries any of the two alleles of the seed parent. Thus, self-pollination is impossible just like pollination between two related or unrelated trees with identical genotypes at the S-locus. If two trees share only one allele at the S-locus, they are semicompatible since half of their pollen is compatible but the other half is excluded from pollination success. Obviously, all plants are heterozygous at the S-locus, and populations need at least three alleles at this locus in order to be able to produce progenies. Usually, the allelic diversity at the S-locus is very high. The genotypic information of the pollen parent at the S-locus, and not only the allelic constitution of haploid pollen, is decisive for the incompatibility reaction in the case of sporophytic systems. Two plants with identical genotypes at the S-locus are incompatible; thus, selfing is obviously impossible. Sporophytic systems are often heteromorphic with regard to flower morphology. For example, two types of flowers are observed in case of distyly. Flowers have either a long style and short stamina, or they are short-styled with long stamina. Pollen from short stamina is excluded in long-styled flowered and vice versa. Since plants produce only one of the two flower morphs, they are selfincompatible. Many other mating combinations are also excluded. Distyly is controlled by a sporophytic incompatibility system with only two alleles and complete dominance of one of the alleles. An incompatibility system is regarded as “cryptic” if selfing and other forms of “incompatible” matings are disadvantageous, but not completely excluded. For
83
84
C HAPTER 6 Mating Systems
example, cryptic incompatibility has been reported for Brazil nut (Bertholetia excelsa) (Moritz and Lüdders 1993). Cryptic incompatibility results in a strong dominance of outcrossing, if “foreign,” fully compatible pollen from other trees is available, but does not preclude the production of seeds by sexual processes in the case of the absence of foreign pollen. Incompatibility systems are very common among hermaphroditic plants in tropical forests, but the genetic control has rarely been investigated. Gametophytic incompatibility has been reported for Inga spp. (Koptur 1984) and Acacia retinodes (Kenrick and Knox 1985). Cordia pringlei and Cordia dentata are distylous (Opler et al. 1975). Other species of the genus Cordia (Boraginaceae) are dioecious (C. inermis, C. collococca, and C. panamensis), and Cordia alliodora is self-compatible, but predominantly outcrossing (Boshier et al. 1995; Table 6.2). The system of self-incompatibility is particularly complicated in cacao (Theobroma cacao). Several loci are involved; the genetic control is both sporophytic and gametophytic. Most trees in the South American region of origin of cacao are self-incompatible, but there are also self-compatible varieties (Warren et al. 1995). Bawa (1974) estimated a frequency of 54% of self-incompatible hermaphrodites among 130 species investigated in a tropical lowland rain forest in Costa Rica. Since 22% of the species in this community are dioecious, 76% are likely to be obligatory outcrossing. The remaining trees are either self-compatible hermaphrodites (14%) or monoecious (10%). 6.5.2 Self-Sterility
Postzygotic effects of selfing have been studied in detail for many conifers (p. 67 f. in Stern and Roche 1974; Savolainen et al. 1992). The flower morphology of gymnosperms does not permit the selective discrimination of particular pollen types. The early abortion of zygotes from selfing is not controlled by a single locus or a few gene loci, but is the effect of many interacting genes. Thus, self-sterility may be regarded as a very early form of inbreeding depression acting on young zygotes and embryos and resulting in strong viability selection against inbred genotypes. The dominance of angiosperms and the frequent observation of incompatibility systems in tropical forests suggest that systems of self-sterility are of lesser importance.
6.6 Environmental Effects on Mating The mating system is not fixed or exclusively determined by genetic factors within a species, but it is also influenced by environmental conditions; thus,
6.7 Recommended Literature
human impact on environmental conditions, for example, by means of forest fragmentation and silvicultural management, has considerable implications for the realized mating systems (Finkeldey 2002). Environmental variation is common both in managed and in unmanaged forests and hence the mating system is likely to vary both in time and in space. An effect of population density on the mating system is evident from comparisons of the heterogeneity of pollen allele frequencies among species occurring in different density in tropical forests (Sect. 6.2.1). In general, low population density results in strong deviation from random mating and strong differentiation among pollen allele frequencies of single seed trees owing to a restricted number of effective pollen parents contributing to the production of progenies from single seed trees. The “reproduction effective” population density has an influence on selfing rates of the self-compatible Cavanillesia platanifolia (Murawski and Hamrick 1992). The outcrossing rate of a population studied on Barro Colorado Island in Panama was very low in a year with only a few flowering trees (32% of censused trees that flowered: tm= 0.213; estimates based on isozyme variation and a mixed mating model, see Sect. 6.3.1), but increased when more trees participated in reproduction in other seed years (49% of censused trees that flowered: tm= 0.347; 74% of censused trees that flowered: tm= 0.569). The estimate of the outcrossing rate was tm= 0.661 in a reference population with higher density. No obvious impact of population density and stand structure on outcrossing rates was observed in five populations of the endemic Dipterocarpus cf. condorensis in Vietnam, but the populations varied with regard to the estimates for the effective number of pollen parents fertilizing single seed trees (Luu 2005). An impact of different spectra of pollinators on gene flow and the mating system may be assumed for species with a wide spatial distribution and species occurring in different ecosystems. However, very little is known about the consequences of different natural “pollination environments” on the mating system of tropical forest trees.
6.7 Recommended Literature The contribution of Boshier (2000) to the book edited by A. Young et al. (2000) gives a concise introduction to many aspects of plant mating systems, including inbreeding and incompatibility. The genetic consequences of inbreeding in plants were discussed by Ritland (1996a). Inbreeding depression has been reviewed with emphasis on conifers by Williams and Savolainen (1996) and with a focus on tropical forest trees by Griffin (1990). Incompatibility is discussed in detail in the book of de Nettancourt (2001).
85
Adaptation and Coevolution
The results of natural selection, the evolutionary force most responsible for adaptation to the environment, are evident everywhere, yet it is remarkably difficult to observe the time course of changes brought about by selection (p. 49 in Gillespie 1998).
7.1 Introduction Plants are able to survive and to reproduce in different environments. The longevity and immobility of trees implies that they need to withstand different environmental conditions during their lifetime. Thus, adaptation of trees to their environment is ubiquitous and necessary for survival. Adaptedness implies a high likelihood of survival and reproduction in a given environment. Adaptation is the process leading to a state of adaptedness in response to environmental variability. The adaptive potential or adaptability describes the ability to achieve a state of adaptedness to a range of different environmental conditions (p. 59 in Eriksson and Ekberg 2001).
7.2 Physiological and Evolutionary Adaptation Since adaptation is a general aspect in the life cycle of plants it is important to distinguish different strategies and levels for adaptive processes. Each plant reacts to changing environmental conditions by adjustment of its metabolism. These physiological adaptations or “phenotypic plasticity” (Schlichting 2002) of plants is eventually manifested in morphological features such as sun- and shadow-leaves. Many plants can be cloned and copies of the same genotype can be grown in different environments. This allows the phenotypic response of genotypes to different environments (their “norms of reaction”) to be assessed and compared. Clonal tests revealed large differences of physiological adaptability among genotypes for many tropical trees (Foster and Bertolucci 1994).
7
88
C HAPTER 7 Adaptation and Coevolution
Different norms of reactions are not only observed among clones, but are also the rule among genetically heterogeneous demes such as families or provenances. The use of genotypes in plantation forestry requires their adaptedness to the respective site conditions. Thus, traditional tree improvement (Chap. 12) is based on differences of the physiological adaptedness among demes compared in field trials although the “domestic fitness” rather than the natural fitness of genotypes and demes matters in applied tree breeding (p. 94 ff. in Eriksson and Ekberg 2001). Drastic environmental change results in the loss of adaptedness of particular genotypes. Preferential survival or higher reproductive capacities of “adapted” genotypes result in changes of genetic structures owing to viability selection or fertility selection. Evolutionary adaptations are caused by selective changes of genetic structures; hence, the population, and not the single plant, is the basic entity to investigate evolutionary adaptations, which can take place only in genetically diverse populations. There is no doubt that evolutionary changes of genetic structures due to viability and fertility selection contributed to the adaptation of trees to their respective environments in boreal, temperate, and tropical forests. Most tropical tree species are highly variable, and most of the genetic variation at single loci resides within populations (Chap. 3). Thus, evolutionary adaptations were not only involved in the creation of the high species diversity in tropical forests, but they continue to play an important role for the reactions of forest ecosystems to environmental change. The urgent need to conserve genetic resources of tropical forest trees (Chap. 14) is motivated by the importance to maintain evolutionary adaptive potentials in tropical forests. Selection primarily acts on single gene loci; thus, it is much more difficult to investigate in natural ecosystems than evolutionary factors affecting all gene loci in principally the same way. For example, drift results in losses of genetic variation at all loci, and inbreeding reduces heterozygosity at all biparentally inherited, nuclear genes. The dynamics of genetic structures at putatively “neutral” gene loci can be used to monitor selective processes due to associations between selected loci and marker loci (Finkeldey and Ziehe 2004). Comparisons of genetic structures at isozyme gene loci between “tolerant” and “sensitive” adult beech (Fagus sylvatica) trees in environmentally stressed forests in Germany suggest a selective response of trees to drastic environmental change (Müller-Starck 1985; Ziehe et al. 1999). The potential for drastic changes of genetic structures due to viability selection without encountering critically low population sizes is highest during early life stages of trees since most trees produce a large number of progenies. Changes of genetic structures were observed during the development of beech seedlings in greenhouses and under field conditions (Ziehe et al. 1999). Viability selection was also observed during early life stages of the tropical tree
7.2 Physiological and Evolutionary Adaptation
Platypodium elegans (Fabaceae; Example 7.1); however, the selection is mainly against inbred progenies (Sect. 6.4.2) and, thus the observed changes of genetic structures essentially result from inbreeding depression (Hufford and Hamrick 2003). These investigations suggest that it is in principle feasible to monitor adaptive processes at putatively neutral markers even in long-living organisms like forest trees. Attempts to identify single genes of adaptive significance (Remington and Purugganan 2003) and to relate genetic variation at these genes to phenotypic trait expressions in field trials and to different environmental conditions at the growing sites of populations are hampered by a large number of “candidate genes” and a poor understanding of their physiological significance for most forest trees. The knowledge of the complete genome sequence of poplar (Populus spp.) (Brunner et al. 2004) and a rapidly growing number of expressed gene sequences in other trees (e.g., Pinus spp., Cryptomeria japonica; Strabala 2004) is an important basis to significantly improve our understanding of adaptive processes in forest trees. A draft genomic sequence of Eucalyptus camaldulensis might become available in 2007 (Poke et al. 2005). The first results on sequence variation in candidate genes of putative adaptive significance have been published (Krutovsky and Neale 2005). Simple markers such as single nucleotide polymorphisms will be developed characterizing the variation in genes with putatively adaptive function in model species and related taxa (Morin et al. 2004; Sect. 2.3.1). Unfortunately, no comparable data are currently available with regard to adaptive changes of genetic structures at single gene loci for most tropical forest trees. Genomic resources will only be available for few tropical tree taxa like eucalypts (Poke et al. 2005) in the foreseeable future. Our current understanding of evolutionary adaptation in tropical forest trees mainly relies on the observation of phenotypic variation in field trials; thus, it is restricted to a rather low number of plantation species, and refers to the phenotypic consequences rather than to the genetic basics of adaptation. Many trials have proved strong differentiation among provenances, families, and clones with regard to important adaptive traits, including survival (Chap. 12). Example 7.1: Viability Selection During Early Life Stages of Platypodium elegans Genetic structures at four hypervariable microsatellite loci were observed at three different early life stages (aborted fruits, mature seeds, and seedlings from the same cohort) of progenies from 12 P. elegans (Fabaceae) trees and a population of adults. The trees grow on Barro Colorado Island, an artificial island in the Panama channel. A slight increase in heterozygosity was observed from mature seeds to seedlings at two loci. The average observed heterozygosity increased from Ho = 0.750 in aborted fruits to Ho = 0.761 in mature seeds,
89
90
C HAPTER 7 Adaptation and Coevolution
Ho = 0.768 in seedlings, and Ho = 0.797 in adult trees. This suggests a slight selective advantage of heterozygosity. The inbreeding coefficient F (Sect. 6.4.1) decreased with increasing observed heterozygosity. The outcrossing rate t was estimated for each cohort on the basis of the observation of nonmaternal alleles (Sect. 6.3.1). It increased from t = 0.75 for aborted fruits to t = 0.78 for mature seeds and t = 0.87 for young seedlings. Comparisons of genetic structures during early life stages of P. elegans revealed selection against homozygotes. However, the observed increase of heterozygosity with increasing age is likely due to the selective disadvantage of inbred progenies and not related to a direct heterozygote advantage at the observed microsatellite loci. Thus, inbreeding depression results in changes of genetic structures due to selection in particular during the phase from mature seeds to the establishment of seedlings. The observed genotypic structures in adults suggest that the selective disadvantage of inbred progenies continues and leaves an essentially completely outcrossed adult population with Hardy–Weinberg structures (Sect. 6.2.2). (From Hufford and Hamrick 2003)
7.3 Species Interactions and Coevolution Plants do not only need to be adapted to their chemical and physical environment, but also to interacting organisms. The biological environment is particularly complex for plant species in species-rich tropical forests. It consists of other higher plants, animals, fungi, and microorganisms which interact either positively (symbioses) or negatively (pests and diseases) with plants. Interactions with animal pollinators are particularly important from a genetic point of view (Chap. 5). The coevolution between tropical figs (Ficus spp.) and fig wasps (Agaonidae) is an interesting and well-studied example of a coevolution between plants and their animal pollinators (Example 7.2). The impact of pests and diseases on the distribution of forest trees and their regeneration has been suggested as one of the main explanations for the high species diversity in tropical forests (Baker 1970; Janzen 1970; Hill and Hill 2001). Breeding for disease resistance is an important goal in tree improvement (Namkoong 1991). It is based on genetic variation with regard to the susceptibility to particular diseases, which is commonly observed in forest trees. The preservation of disease-resistant genotypes is an important objective in conservation of forest genetic resources (Byrne 2000). Symbiotic associations between trees and mycorrhiza constitute an important aspect of biotic interactions in tropical forests and possibly explain the dominance of particular species in some low-diversity tropical forests (Connel and Lowman 1989). Little is known about mutual preferences between genotypes of
7.3 Species Interactions and Coevolution
plants and their mycorrhiza in tropical forests. A comparison of two orchid species revealed different preferences for particular mycorrhizal fungi. Tolumnia variegata is a generalist in its association with mycorrhiza; Ionopsis utricularoides is more specialized with regard to its fungal symbionts (Otero et al. 2004). Example 7.2: Figs and Their Pollinators The pantropical genus Ficus (Moraceae) is one of the most species-rich genera of woody tropical plants, with more than 800 species. The distribution center is in Asia, with more than 500 species. Figs are Keystone Species
Tropical figs produce fruits throughout the year and are an important diet of many animal species. Figs are an indispensable part of the nutrition of many birds and mammals such as bats and primates particularly during periods of low availability of fruits from other plants (Janzen 1979a); thus, figs are regarded as keystone species since their disappearance would have a profound impact on the structure and function of many ecosystems (Terborgh 1986). Case studies proved the crucial importance of figs for ecosystems in particular in Asia (Leighton and Leighton 1983) but not in African forests (Gautier-Hion and Michaloud 1989). Morphology of Figs and Their Pollinators
Figs evolved many different growth habits: free-standing trees, shrubs, climbers, epiphytes, and hemiepiphytes (“strangling figs”). The root systems of strangling figs germinating on a particular host tree tend to fuse; thus, many adult strangling fig trees are composed of several distinct genotypes – they are chimeras (Thomson et al. 1991). Population sizes of strangling figs are often underestimated since a single “tree” may be a small population (Hamrick and Murawski 1991). The inflorescence of figs (syconium) is fleshy and folded inside to form a cave (Fig. 7.1). Many simple, male or female flowers are inserted on the inner wall inside the cave, which is closed by apical bracts leaving a small entrance for pollinating insects, the ostiole (Verkerke 1989). Figs produce two types of female flowers: short-styled “gall” flowers and long-styled flowers. With only a few exceptions (Molbo et al. 2004) each fig species lives in obligatory symbiosis with a single wasp species, which is the sole pollinator (Fig. 7.2); thus, the number of species of fig wasps (Agaonidae) roughly equals the number of fig species. Molecular phylogenies based on chloroplast and mitochondrial genes revealed similarities between the evolutionary relationships among figs and among their pollinators, suggesting a true coevolution and a high stability of the symbiosis (Herre et al. 1996). Similar phylogenies were also found for pollinating fig wasps and associated, nonpollinating wasps (Machado et al. 1996).
91
92
C HAPTER 7 Adaptation and Coevolution
Fig. 7.1. Inflorescence (A) and single male flowers (B1), short-styled gall flowers (B2), and long-styled female flowers (B3) of a monoecious fig (Ficus spp.). (Adapted from Hill 1967a)
Fig. 7.2. Female and male Blastophaga quadraticeps, a fig wasp, the pollinator of Ficus spp. (Adapted from Barth 1982)
7.3 Species Interactions and Coevolution
The Reproduction Cycle of Figs and the Life Cycle of Fig Wasps
The reproduction cycle of figs and the life cycle of the pollinators are closely connected (Janzen 1979a; Wiebes 1979; Bronstein and McKey 1989; Fig. 7.3). Female wasps are attracted by pheromones and enter the syconia of a “receptive,” female flowering syconium, through the ostiole. They fertilize the long-styled female flowers with pollen brought from another fig of the same species and lay eggs through the style of short-styled gall flowers. Afterwards they usually die within the syconium; only a few wasps manage to leave a syconium they entered (Giebernau et al. 1996). The emerging larvae feed on the developing seeds of their gall flowers, thereby destroying it. The heterostyly within syconia allows the simultaneous development of seeds and larvae of wasps in different flowers of the same inflorescence. A new generation of wasps develops within a few weeks. Male insects appear first, fertilize the females, and die shortly thereafter inside the syconium. The male fig flowers shed their pollen only after the female fig wasps have emerged. Thus, figs are distinctly protogynous, i.e., female flowering is earlier than male flowering. The fertilized female fig wasps take up pollen actively or are passively loaded with pollen. They leave the syconium and start searching for another syconium in the “receptive” phase. The seeds continue to develop after the female wasps have left the syconium. The shape and the taste of a syconium change when the seeds are ripe. The seeds are endozoochorously dispersed by mammals and birds. Fig flower
flower receptive pollination, fertilization
Wasp gall flower developed
wasp
wasp
enters syconium
wasp lays eggs wasp eggs, larvae develop imago
imago
fertilization flowering
pollen uptake seeds
leaves syconium, flight
Fig. 7.3. The reproduction cycle of monoecious figs, and the life cycle of fig wasps
93
94
C HAPTER 7 Adaptation and Coevolution
Flower Phenology
The flowering cycle of a single fig plant is usually strictly synchronized; all syconia of a plant are in the same stage of floral development. Only a few fig species growing in a seasonal climate show a certain degree of individual asynchrony (Cook and Power 1996). Thus, emerging wasps do not find receptive syconia on the same plant but have to search for other trees of the same species. The wasps survive only for a few days outside of syconia. In consequence, asynchronous flowering of the fig plants of a population is a necessary requirement for the preservation of the pollinators (Fig. 7.4). Asynchronous flowering results in the production of fruits throughout the year. The importance of figs as a more or less continuously available energy source for vertebrates is explained by the need to produce flowers as breeding grounds for their pollinators, and hence also fruits, throughout the year. Gynodioecious Figs
The previous description of the life cycle of figs refers to monoecious species. The eatable fig F. carica and many Asian fig species are gynodioecious (Berg 1989). In these species, the cycle for the preservation of the pollinating wasps is confined to male and female flowering plants. All female flowers in these plants are short-styled gall flowers; hence, the pollinators are able to lay eggs in all female flowers, and no mature seeds develop in this type of syconia. In consequence, gynodioecious figs are functionally dioecious.
...
...
flowering phase development flowering phase
wasp flight crop abortion wasp extinction
Fig. 7.4. A hypothetical example on the phenology of figs and its impact on pollinating wasps. (Adapted from Bronstein et al. 1990)
7.3 Species Interactions and Coevolution
If a wasp enters the syconium of a solely female flowering plant, the flowers are fertilized by the pollen carried by the insect. All female flowers in these syconia are long-styled; thus, the wasp cannot deposit its eggs and seeds develop from all fertilized flowers. Since the wasp is irreversibly trapped in the syconium, it will not be reproductively successful if it enters a solely female flowering inflorescence without gall flowers (Fig. 7.5). Genetic Consequences of the Symbiosis
Self-pollination of monoecious figs is usually excluded owing to the strong protogyny and the synchronized flowering of single plants. Asynchronous development of a few syconia is observed in some species (Cook and Power 1996). It helps to preserve the pollinators, but is likely to result in selfed offspring of figs. Gynodioecious figs are functionally dioecious and hence obligatory outcrossing.
Fig. 7.5. Reproduction of gynodioecious figs. (Adapted from Hill 1967b). Further explanation in the text
95
96
C HAPTER 7 Adaptation and Coevolution
Mating preferences among figs are likely to be strongly influenced by their complicated flowering phenology, and to a lesser degree by spatial proximity as long as the distance can be bridged by pollinators. Investigations of seven monoecious strangler fig species in Central America revealed that their seeds were fertilized by a surprisingly high number of pollen parents (Nason et al. 1996, 1998). Owing to the low density of figs, the average movement of pollen was estimated to be between 5.8 and 14.2 km. Breeding units are as large as 106–632 km2, which is a considerably larger area than for any other plant species investigated (Herre 1996). The surprisingly efficient long-distance transport of fig pollen is possibly facilitated by passive wind-mediated dispersal of fig wasps flying high above the canopy (Compton et al. 2000). The wasps are likely to be attracted by volatile chemicals if they come close to a receptive fig tree. These results indicate that fig populations can be maintained in fragmented landscapes as long as the pollinators are capable of bridging the fragments; thus, even widely isolated remnants of forests may be important for the maintenance of figs and their pollinators. The potential for local adaptation of figs to specific sites is limited owing to the effective gene flow and migration by pollen and seeds. The genetic structures of consecutive-age cohorts of single seed trees are likely to be strongly differentiated from each other owing to changing pollen parents. The flowers of a single syconium are frequently fertilized by a single wasp only (Janzen 1979b). The progenies produced in such a syconium are full-sibs (Nason et al. 1998). The sex of fig wasps is, like the sex of most Hymenoptera, determined by a system of haplodiploidy. Male insects develop from unfertilized eggs and are consequently haploid (Godfray 1988). Female insects are able to control the sex ratio by facultative admittance of sperms to fertilize their egg cells (Frank 1985). Female fig wasps are fertilized before they leave the syconium; thus, the number of females entering and laying eggs in a syconium is crucial for the degree of genetic relatedness of the offspring produced. Matings between siblings are frequent since syconia are often entered by only a single wasp and rarely by more than four wasps. Inbreeding is frequent in wasp populations (Molbo et al. 2004). The very important conservation of tropical figs is only possible if their pollinators are also preserved. Minimal population sizes for the preservation of fig populations should be based on models which allow the population dynamics of the pollinators as the most important criterion to be assessed (Bronstein et al. 1990). Actual population sizes critically depend on phenology and the migration behavior of female fig wasps. Experimental results suggest
7.4 Recommended Literature
conserving even widely isolated fig trees which possibly belong to viable populations owing to the high efficiency of fig wasps as pollinators.
7.4 Recommended Literature The concept of physiological adaptation or phenotypic plasticity of plants has been reviewed by Schlichting (1986, 2002). Evolutionary adaptations and the role of genetic variation for adaptability have been analyzed by Dobzhansky (1968) and Dobzhansky et al. (1977). Plant–pollinator interactions in tropical forests were reviewed by Bawa (1990). The reproduction of figs was concisely described by Janzen (1979a).
97
Phylogenies and Evolution Above the Species Level
The wealth of species in humid tropical and subtropical forests has always fascinated botanists – and not only taxonomists but also ecologists, geneticists, and students of evolution. Much research remains to be done in these forests,. . . (p. 210 in Stern and Roche 1974).
8.1 Introduction One of the most obvious and fundamental differences between tropical and temperate forests refers to their floral diversity and in particular the diversity of tree species (Whitmore 1975). The number of tree species in a single hectare in a tropical lowland forest is often considerably higher than the number of trees native to central Europe. Public and scientific discussions are often focused on the conservation of this diversity rather than its evolution (Lugo 1988; Raven 1988; Sayer and Whitmore 1990). Conservation of biological diversity continues to deserve the highest priority in view of the undiminished speed of forest destruction in many parts of the tropics (FAO 2002; http://www.fao.org/forestry/site/fra/en). However, improved knowledge of the evolution of the high species diversity in tropical forests and its maintenance in undisturbed forest ecosystems will help us to develop sound strategies for its conservation.
8.2 The Evolution of Species Diversity in the Tropics 8.2.1 Species Diversity in Tropical Forests
The enormous floral diversity was noticed during early expeditions to all tropical regions and quickly became a field of intensive research (e.g., von Humboldt 1808). The rich biological diversity in the tropics stipulated evolutionary
8
100
C HAPTER 8 Phylogenies and Evolution Above the Species Level
thinking of researchers during the nineteenth century (Lefèvre 1984). Alfred Wallace and Charles Darwin independently developed the theory of evolution by natural selection after personal observations of the diversity of life in the tropics. Floristic diversity is not evenly distributed among continents and regions. The overall number of flowering plants is considerably higher in tropical America (approximately 90,000 species) than in Asia (approximately 40,000 species) and Africa (approximately 35,000 species; estimates from Thomas 1999). Regional centers of floral diversity are presumably related to the climatic variability throughout the Quaternary (Cook et al. 1990) and possibly represent refugial areas during eras with a less favorable climate (see later). The identification of regional centers of species diversity is of obvious importance for the development of conservation strategies (Lugo 1988; Wilson 1988; Gentry 1992). Variation of species diversity has also been described at the local level by detailed floristic inventories. Extraordinary high numbers of tree species per hectare were counted in local inventories in the Neotropics (Gentry 1986) and in tropical lowland forests in Southeast Asia (p. 5 ff. in Whitmore 197). Simulation models predict a positive correlation between levels of genetic diversity within species (Sect. 3.4) and species diversity (Vellend 2005). However, no empirical studies have been conducted in tropical forests, and it is unknown at which spatial scale correlations possibly exist. Even the type of the expected correlation is a matter of speculation: Refugial areas might be hotspots both of species diversity and of diversity within species. On the other hand, a high diversity of tree species implies low population densities for most species, and genetic variation may be lost owing to drift, if low population density results in low population sizes. Not all natural tropical forests are characterized by a high species diversity. The number of species declines with decreasing temperature in mountainous areas and extended dry seasons in marginal regions of the tropics (Richards 1981). Azonal edaphic conditions also frequently result in decreasing species diversity (Whitmore 1975). Forests with a low diversity of tree species occur even in the humid central tropics (Hart et al. 1989; Hart 1990). Biotic interactions possibly play an important role for their existence and stability (Connel and Lowman 1989). The floral diversity represents only a small part of the overall biodiversity in tropical forests. Estimates concerning the number of existing species on earth vary greatly since only a small proportion of the most species-rich group, the insects, have been described (Adis 1990). The diversity of insects in the canopy of tropical forests constitutes the biggest share of global species diversity (Erwin 1988).
8.2 The Evolution of Species Diversity in the Tropics
8.2.2 Evolution Above the Species Level
The floral diversity of tropical forests is fairly well described; however, its evolution and the mechanisms ensuring its maintenance are only poorly understood. The most important theories trying to explain the species diversity of tropical forests were reviewed by Baker (1970) and, more recently, by Hill and Hill (2001) and Montagnini and Jordan (2005, p. 27 ff.). Most of these theories are chiefly concerned with the ecological requirements for the coexistence of many species in a given area (“ecological niches”, environmental heterogeneity, disturbance) and species interactions, including competition and predation. Two hypotheses with a focus on the factors ruling the emergence of the high species diversity in tropical forests are concerned with the duration of periods of an “undisturbed” ecosystem development. A long period of “cumulative” evolution undisturbed by annual periods of unfavorable environmental conditions such as low temperatures and long dry seasons is regarded as an important prerequisite for the diversification of species. A more or less constant climate for extended periods of millions of years is likely to be even more important (“museum model”). The evolution of angiosperms in tropical forests lasted at least since the beginning of the Tertiary for approximately 65 million years.“It is likely that in some at least of the regions where Rain forest is now the climatic climax, similar vegetation has existed uninterruptedly since a very remote geological period.” (p. 14 in Richards 1981). Thus, even a slight excess of newly evolving species in comparison with presumably low species extinction rates resulted in the accumulation of many species during this long era. According to Richards (1981, p. 16), the floristic richness of tropical forests is largely due to its great antiquity. Multiple evidence suggests a strong impact of the climatic variability during the Pleistocene not only on the flora in temperate regions, but also on tropical rain forest vegetation (Haffer and Prance 2001). “Allopatric” speciation in isolated refugia during dry periods possibly increased species diversity since populations isolated from each other in separate refugia eventually developed reproductive barriers (Hill and Hill 2001); however, the size and the location of pleistocene refugia are under dispute. The fossil pollen record suggests stability and continuity of the forest cover over the Amazonian lowlands (Colinvaux and De Oliveira 2001). Sequence variation patterns at the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene in different mammals from North America and Amazonia suggest rapid population growth for the North American species after the end of the last glaciation, but no or only minor demographic expansion for small mammals in Amazonia (Lessa et al. 2003). This result also suggests only a limited impact of climatic variability on the population sizes of small mammals in
101
102
C HAPTER 8 Phylogenies and Evolution Above the Species Level
the Neotropics and hence contradicts the refugia hypothesis. However, a molecular phylogeny of the species-rich genus Inga suggests a recent speciation, possibly as a consequence of the climatic variability during the pleistocene (Richardson et al. 2001; Example 8.2). Ecological research on the dynamics of tropical forests, including their regeneration, greatly profited from the establishment and repeated analysis of intensively studied plots on Barro Colorado Island (Panama), Pasoh Forest Reserve (Malaysia; Lee 1995), and in other tropical regions (Hubbell and Foster 1992). Numerous genetics studies were conducted in these plots; several of them are described in this book (Table 3.3, Fig. 6.2; Examples 5.2, 5.3). However, the focus of these investigations was on the maintenance of species diversity, the ecological and genetic consequences of a high species diversity, and the role of species interactions in this context. The limited time for observations does not permit the evolution of species diversity for long-living organisms like forest trees to be studied. Taxonomic studies are the most important basis for the description of the biodiversity in tropical forests. The relationships among existing species as revealed by the differentiation of morphological traits of taxonomic significance offer opportunities not only to classify taxa, but also to understand their origin. During the past few decades, traditional taxonomic surveys were complemented by molecular approaches to reveal phylogenies. Early caryological studies used chromosome polymorphisms and in particular polymorphisms of chromosome numbers to infer relationships and the evolution of plants in the tropics (Mehra and Bawa 1969). More recently, molecular genetics markers based on variation of DNA became commonly applied tools not only to reveal genetic variation within species (Sect. 3.4), but also to clarify phylogenetic relations among more or less closely related taxa occurring in tropical forests (Sect. 8.3).
8.3 Molecular Phylogenies The evolutionary history or phylogeny of a group of organisms can be analyzed by investigating similarities at particular characters, which possibly reflect relatedness or a common origin. Thus, if two taxa A and B are more similar to each other than both are to taxon C, a more recent common origin and, hence, a higher degree of relatedness of taxa A and B may be assumed in comparison with taxon C. Similarities need to be measured at particular traits or characters, and the observation of different traits often results in contradicting conclusions. Various reasons can account for similarity apart from a common origin. Convergent evolution in very distantly related organisms eventually results in similarities at morphological traits in response to particular environmental conditions. Frequently cited examples for plants are a herbaceous growth habit,
8.3 Molecular Phylogenies
which repeatedly evolved from woody ancestors, dioecy (Sect. 4.2.3), or leafless plants in adaptation to a dry environment in Neotropical Cactaceae and Euphorbiaceae of the Old World. Thus, similar trait expression may not only be due to a common origin (homology), but characters may also be similar although they are not derived from a common ancestor (homoplasy). The observation of variation at molecular traits offers obvious advantages in comparison with morphological characters. This applies in particular to variation of DNA, which is not influenced by environmental conditions. Thus, some of the methods briefly described in Sect. 2.3.1 are not only commonly used to investigate genetic variation within species, but are also used to clarify differentiation among species and to elucidate evolutionary relationships by phylogenetic analyses. The observation of variation at nonrecombining chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) is of particular importance for plants. Low mutation rates of cpDNA are responsible for, in general, low variation within species, but ample and easily interpretable differentiation among species at various levels. Sequences of cpDNA were used to investigate phylogenetic relationships among plants at virtually all taxonomic levels. Variation of cpDNA is informative to study splits during the earliest evolution of land plants (Goremykin and Hellwig 2005), and also to reveal phylogenetic relations within single genera (Gernandt et al. 2005). Phylogenies are not only based on cpDNA, but also on nuclear DNA (nDNA) and anonymous markers. Commonly used nDNA sequences for phylogenetic analyses are ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions. For example, molecular phylogenies of the pioneer tree genus Macaranga (Euphorbiaceae) were based on ITS sequence data (Blattner et al. 2001) and amplified fragment length polymorphisms (Bänfer et al. 2004). The evolution and phylogeny of flowering plants has recently been reviewed largely based on molecular data (The Angiosperm Phylogeny Group 2003). Two approaches are commonly used to construct phylogenetic trees based on DNA variation (Hall 2001). The most important algorithmic methods are the unweighted pair-group method with arithmetic means (UPGMA) and the neighbor joining (NJ) method. Both are distance methods based on the computation of a matrix of all pairwise differences between samples (Sect. 3.3.2). Parsimony is the most commonly used tree-searching method. Many trees are constructed and compared. The most likely (maximum parsimonious) tree is the one requiring the lowest number of evolutionary steps, including homoplasies, to explain the data. The reliability of phylogenetic trees is often statistically tested by bootstrapping (p. 58 ff. in Hall 2001). Example 8.1: A Molecular Phylogeny of Indonesian Dipterocarpoideae The family Dipterocarpaceae consists of three subfamilies; the Asian Dipterocarpoideae is by far the most important and most diverse subfamily,
103
104
C HAPTER 8 Phylogenies and Evolution Above the Species Level
consisting of about 470 species in 13 genera. Nine genera with more than 250 species are native to Indonesia. The Dipterocarpoideae are commonly divided into two tribes (Ashton 1982). Tribe Dipterocarpae, with a basic chromosome number of x = 11, consists of the genera Anisoptera, Cotylelobium, Dipterocarpus, Upuna, and Vatica. Tribe Shoreae (x = 7) consists of Dryobalanops, Hopea, Parashorea, and the species-rich genus Shorea. Genus Dryobalanops has a basic chromosome number of x = 7, but shows intermediate characters between the tribes concerning flower morphology (sepal aestivation) and wood anatomical features (vessels, resin canals). Variation of cpDNA was studied by means of polymerase chain reaction restriction fragment length polymorphisms and chloroplast simple sequence repeats (Sect. 2.3.1). A total of 129 samples from 58 species were investigated. The African dipterocarp Monotes kerstingii (subfamily Monotoideae) was used as an outgroup to root the phylogenetic tree (Indrioko et al. 2006). No variation was observed within species. The differentiation among species at cpDNA is in good agreement with the classification based on morphological characters (Fig. 8.1). One major clade consists of Upuna, Cotylelobium, Anisoptera, Vatica, Dipterocarpus (tribe Dipterocarpae), and Dryobalanops (tribe Shoreae) in a basal position. A second clade consists of Hopea, Parashorea, and Shorea (tribe Shoreae). The genera are, in general, well resolved and strongly supported. The intermediate position of genus Dryobalanops is confirmed by the analyses. Parashorea groups with Shorea in a single big, poorly resolved clade. Both genera have close botanical affinities and the phylogenetic relevance of their distinction is questionable. Similar results were obtained by previous studies based on cpDNA variation of dipterocarps (Tsumura et al. 1996; Kajita et al. 1998; Kamiya et al. 1998; Gamage et al. 2003). Phylogenetic analyses based on cpDNA failed to consistently group the species-rich genus Shorea into well-supported clades. However, the variation at the nuclear PgiC gene locus is consistent with the distinction of different timber groups (balau, red meranti, white meranti, yellow meranti) and sections according to Ashton (1982) within genus Shorea (Kamiya et al. 2005). (From Indrioko et al. 2006) Example 8.2: Evolution of the Genus Inga Molecular phylogenies can be used to test the alternative hypotheses of speciation according to the “museum model” or recent speciation in response to environmental variation during the past few million years (Sect. 8.2.2). The slow evolution of species diversity as a result of a long period of favorable climatic conditions (museum model) is expected to result in a well-resolved phylogeny, each species distinguished from others by numerous mutations (nucleotide substitutions at the level of DNA). Recent allopatric speciation in
8.3 Molecular Phylogenies
100
67 95 63
Cotylelobium lanceolatum Upuna borneensis Anisoptera costata Anisoptera marginata 99 Anisoptera reticulata 68 Vatica bantamensis Vatica bella Vatica granulata 99 83 Vatica pauciflora Vatica rassak 94 Vatica venulosa Dipterocarpus grandiflorus Dipterocarpus oblongifolius 71 Dipterocarpus retusus 100 Dipterocarpus rigidus Dipterocarpus tempehes Dryobalanops aromatica 99 Dryobalanops lanceolata Hopea bancana Hopea celebica Hopea odorata 85 Hopea sangal Hopea dryobalanoides Hopea nigra Hopea griffithii Hopea mengarawan 66 Parashorea lucida Parashorea globosa Shorea blumutensis Shorea guiso Shorea montigena Shorea scaberrima Shorea seminis Shorea acuminata Shorea andulensis Shorea javanica Shorea johorensis Shorea leprosula Shorea macroptera Shorea mecistopteryx 69 Shorea ovalis Shorea palembanica Shorea parvifolia Shorea platyclados Shorea xanthophylla Shorea balangeran 59 Shorea selanica Shorea splendida Shorea macrophylla 55 Shorea pinanga Shorea stenoptera Shorea acuminatissima Shorea dasyphylla Shorea faguetiana 77 Shorea multiflora Shorea fallax Shorea materialis 98 60 Shorea virescens Monotes kerstingii
x=11; valvate
Dipterocarpeae
sub valvate
x=7; imbricate Shoreae
valvate
x=7
Fig. 8.1. Strict consensus tree of Dipterocarpoideae (outgroup Monotes kerstingii) Numbers at nodes indicate bootstrap values. Typical characters (valvate, subvalvate or imbricate sepal aestivation; basic chromosome number x) and tribes are indicated. (From Indrioko et al. 2006)
refugia should be reflected in few nucleotide substitutions differentiating species, and a poorly resolved phylogeny (Fig. 8.2). The genus Inga (Fabaceae; Mimosoideae) contains about 300 species growing in neotropical rain forests. Sequence variation was observed for 32 species at the ITS of nuclear ribosomal DNA and for 31 species at a cpDNA fragment. A total of 45 species representing most sections of the genus were analyzed (Richardson et al. 2001). Only a few substitutions were observed and the phylogenies were unresolved, conforming Fig. 8.2b. The result is consistent
105
106
C HAPTER 8 Phylogenies and Evolution Above the Species Level
Fig. 8.2. a A well-resolved phylogeny due to the accumulation of mutations over long periods and b a poorly resolved phylogeny due to a low number of mutations differentiating species (a–h) indicating recent speciation. (Adapted from Richardson et al. 2001)
a b c d e f g
a
h a b c d e f g
b
h
with a recent speciation within the genus Inga. Rough estimates of the divergence time suggest that speciation occurred within the last ten million years, and approximately 30% of the species diverged from their closest relative during the Pleistocene (within the last two million years). Shorea (Dipterocarpaceae) contains only slightly fewer species than Inga. The molecular phylogeny within the genus Shorea is also poorly resolved (Example 8.1), likewise suggesting comparatively recent speciation within this genus, at least in Southeast Asia. However, the diversity of tropical forests does not only result from a few species-rich genera like Inga, Shorea, Ficus, and others, but is also reflected in a large number of genera, families, and higher taxonomic units present in most tropical forests (Bermingham and Dick 2001). Thus, the species diversity of tropical forests is presumably a consequence of both their great antiquity (museum model) and recent speciation for certain taxa like Inga. (From Richardson et al. 2001)
8.4 Recommended Literature The causes of the species richness of many tropical forests were reviewed by Baker (1970), Hill and Hill (2001), and Montagnini and Jordan (2005, p. 27 ff.).
8.4 Recommended Literature
Hart (1990) pointed out that not all tropical forests are characterized by a high species diversity. Phylogenetic methods are described among other topics related to phylogeography in the book by Avise (2000). Their application to plants was reviewed by Schaal et al. (1998). An update of the classification of the orders and families of angiosperms largely based on molecular phylogenetic methods has recently been given by The Angiosperm Phylogeny Group (2003). The rationale behind molecular phylogenies and the commonly used software PAUP for phylogenetic analyses are described in the book by Hall (2001).
107
Applications of Genetics to Tropical Forestry
Part B
The majority of tropical tree species possess high genetic diversity (Sect. 3.4). The elements of their genetic systems that are responsible for the evolution of this genetic variation and its temporal and spatial dynamics under natural conditions were the topics of Part A. Part B is oriented towards application. It concentrates on both genetic implications of human activities and on planned utilization of genetic variation. Tropical forests are being cleared, burned, fragmented, logged, and overhunted at rates that lack historical precedent (Laurance and Bierregaard 1997a). The consequences of the large-scale conversion of forests to other types of land use and the fragmentation of contiguous forests require analysis and the development of guidelines for appropriate treatment of remnant forests (Chap. 9). Forestry involves logging and the silvicultural management of diverse types of forests. Silvicultural management has far-reaching consequences for the genetic system of tree species and their genetic structures (Chap. 10). Tree breeding including provenance selection (Chap. 11) aims at changing genetic structures of populations in order to increase the plantation yield. Tree improvement and planting activities in tropical forestry commenced a long time before population genetic research on the genetic system of tropical forest trees was taken up (Chaps. 12, 13). Last but not least, in view of the genetic impact of human interference, projects on the conservation of tree genetic resources are an imperative application of genetics. Genetic information is not a renewable resource. These projects require concomitant research in order to be successful (Chap. 14). In most tropical countries forest genetics plays only a minor role in forestry education. In most curricula emphasis is put on tree improvement, if subjects related to genetics are discussed at all. In courses concentrating on breeding, students become acquainted with working methods of quantitative genetic research and relevant statistical methodology. Basics of population genetics, an analysis of the genetic systems of tropical forest trees, the role of genetics in silviculture, and the conservation of forest genetic resources have conventionally been regarded as topics of minor importance as compared with tree improvement. Not too much at variance from the conditions in the temperate zones,
110
PART B Applications of Genetics to Tropical Forestry
forest genetics research is occasionally used as a synonym for the formulation of breeding goals and the conduct of breeding projects. Owing to this misconception, the fundamental importance of an analysis of the genetic system of tropical forest trees by use of population genetics methodology is overlooked. Nonetheless, tree improvement is but an application of forest genetics and must be accompanied by the conservation of forest genetic resources.
Fragmentation of Forests
9.1 Introduction Following the advance of civilization, large forests are completely eliminated and converted to other types of land use on all continents. However, small pieces of forest are left on areas that are of little use owing to their adverse topography or drainage, or other reasons. They are embedded in a largely agricultural matrix (James et al. 1998). They are also looked at as islands surrounded by a sea of modified habitats (Laurance and Bierregaard 1997a). Darby (1956) described the history of the reduction of forests in Europe and documented their increasing fragmentation on a continent-wide scale. When discussing the human impact on forests, Ledig (1992) and Ledig and Kitzmiller (1992) listed fragmentation of forests as next in line after complete destruction (see also Clarke and Young 2000). Habitat fragmentation of trees and other living organisms as an almost inevitable consequence of large-scale forest loss has emerged as a global concern. The size distribution of the fragments, their spatial pattern in landscapes, and the proportion of the area covered by forest affect both the total number of persisting species and the relation between them. Along with the forests, the distribution ranges of tree species and their populations are fragmented. Depending on the distribution pattern of species, fragmentation of forests may disrupt the range of one species but not so of others. This condition is encountered not only in the tropics but also in other climatic zones; however, in species-rich forests of the tropics it is of particular concern to ecologists and forest geneticists. Owing to the species richness particularly of tropical rain forests with a high proportion of endemics (Viana et al. 1997), the number of species being strongly affected or becoming extinct is larger than in other biomes. Owing to local rarity or pronounced clumping of species occurrence, many species may be missing from any particular fragment simply because they never occurred there (Laurance et al. 2002). The same applies to genotypes within species. Also, many species have disappeared even from larger fragments because they are sensitive to disturbance.
9
112
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
Another condition often goes along with fragmentation. Owing to raised pressure of the local human population on those remnants of forest, the trees of the same species occur with reduced overall density. They also have a patchy distribution, because the original density of trees varied with the species and with microsite variation in a heterogeneous environment. Locally, the density may be dramatically reduced. The landscape may not be completely denuded of forest but remaining trees may grow in rows along roads and watercourses or as solitary trees on pastures or abandoned fields. The question arises, to what extent these trees form possibly persistent populations in the genetic sense (Sect. 2.2). The implications of low population density and restricted population size for the reproduction system of trees were discussed in Chaps. 5 and 6. In the present chapter, the very small remnant populations of reduced density are addressed also from the management point of view. The conversion of large areas of contiguous tropical forests to other land uses leaves forest fragments of various sizes. For instance, Sanchez-Azofeifa et al. (1998) reported on deforestation in lowlands of Costa Rica, where more than 80% of the primary forests had been eliminated since 1984. During a 10-year period the annual loss rate was more than 2% and the number of forest fragments doubled, while their average size decreased from 95 to 25 ha. The total area of fragments of less than 100 km2 size or less than 1 km away from an edge in lowland rain forest in Brazilian Amazonia increased from 20.8 × 106 ha in 1978 to 50.8 × 106 ha less than 20 years thereafter (Whitmore 1998). These exemplary data indicate that fragmentation in a largely deforested country is still in progress on many spatial scales and will presumably lead to fewer and smaller fragments and to the extirpation of many plant and animal species. The genetic impact of this process will become ever more severe. While considering the genetic effects of isolation, it must not be overlooked that the amount of available habitat is greatly reduced. The smaller the fragments, the more important become edge effects that penetrate deep into the forest remnants (Laurance et al. 2002). In a case study of the decline of deciduous and semideciduous tropical forest in Bolivia, the increase in the number and in the area of both large and small fragments is documented over a 20-year period. The microclimatic edge effects such as increases in light, temperature, and wind speed affect larger part of the remnant forest (Steininger et al. 2001). The mortality among trees increases (Laurance et al. 2002). In an early paper on forest fragmentation, Curtis (1956) documented the clearing of forest in a certain part of Wisconsin, USA, during a 120-year period. This author pointed out the decrease of forest area, the initially increasing and subsequently decreasing number of fragments, their average size, their distance from one another, and their total periphery. He also described the various ecological correlates of this man-induced process. Loyn and MacAlpine (2001) analyzed different types of forest fragmentation and found their ecological impacts somewhat different.
9.2 The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations
9.2 The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations With some time-lag, the extinction of at least some tree populations or species in fragmented tropical forest is likely in view of their reproduction system. Most tropical trees are characterized by predominant outcrossing (Sect. 6.3), strong inbreeding depression (Sect. 6.4.2), and reproductive strategies relying on the presence of other tree and animal species (Ashton 1981). As already indicated, if a forest has been fragmented by human action, its tree populations are suddenly put into an environment to which they are not necessarily fully adapted; therefore, it is the formerly widespread and common plant species that suffer most from (complete) fragmentation of their populations (den Njis and Oostermeijer 1997). The remnant forests possess less biodiversity. They represent disturbed ecosystems comprising merely part of the tree species belonging to the respective forest community. The moderate numbers of individuals of the former keystone species form populations of reduced reproduction-effective size. Even if tree species were intimately mixed, a certain minimum area is required for all species to occur. Consequently, many species are locally lost if the respective fragment is small. The same is true with genotypes belonging to one species. The relict populations are in danger of lacking formerly existing genetic variants due to genetic drift and those losses are no longer compensated by the influx of external effective pollen. Isolation is likely to result in increased genetic differentiation among relict populations owing to nonadaptive changes of genetic structures. It must be emphasized that reduced genetic variation in small populations is presumably a symptom of endangerment rather than its cause (Namkoong et al. 1996; Holsinger 2000). With progressing disturbance of forest ecosystems coadapted other species of plants and of animals are eventually no longer present. Pollen vectors may not survive or may no longer visit remote forest fragments (but see Example 8.2). However, some dispersers of pollen and seed respond positively to forest clearings and to the edge effects implied by fragmentation (Laurance et al. 2002). Pollen vectors support a critical portion of the life cycle of tropical trees and must have a permanent food basis. It is interrupted, if the flower rewards are not offered all-year round. If also the seed vectors have become rare or absent, the occupation of patches of the former habitat becomes increasingly difficult for tree species. First of all, rare widely dispersed tree species will suffer from altered pollinator–plant assemblages (James et al. 1998); therefore, one has to anticipate complex, cryptic responses to fragmentation (Aldrich and Hamrick 1998). The trees in those relict forests are less adapted to the new environment, since they have evolved in obligate associations with groups of pollen and seed dispersers that either are now missing or have greatly changed.
113
114
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
The decline of dispersers is followed by the decline of the respective tree species. Changes in the guild of pollinators are not just responsible for pollen limitation and lower seed set. As an environmental factor influencing the mating system (Sect. 6.6), they also affect genetic structures of the next generation of trees. Adaptive changes of genetic structures are induced but they may require generations until the former level of adaptedness is reached; hence, population fragments are genetically vulnerable. In one example from New Zealand, a shift in the guild of pollinators was not accompanied by consistent changes in the mating systems of the partially self-fertilized tree Metrosideros excelsa (Schmidt-Adam et al. 2000). Other birds with similar behavior have presumably taken over the role of two other species of pollinators. As Whelan et al. (2000) found in several species of the protaceous genus Grevillea in fragmented Australian populations, there may be strong interactions between pollinator guilds such as vertebrates and insects depending on the natural or “preferred” mating system of trees. In the completely self-fertile species G. macleayana the proportion of self-fertilization ranged between 20 and more than 90%. In this type of species, changes due to fragmentation are expected to be less intensive. However, the majority of tropical tree species are all but fully self-fertile. Introduced honey bees eventually change the realized mating systems and the concomitant mating success under the now given conditions. These insects have largely displaced honeyeaters as pollinators from some of their food plants, thus contributing to their decline and leading to pollen-limitation in Grevillea spp. and other species (Paton 2000). The disruption of mutualisms between trees and their native pollinators is sometimes compensated by the genetic rescue of remnant trees through introduced African honey bees. They outnumbered native pollinators of the canopy-emergent tree Dinizia excelsa (Fabaceae) in disturbed Brazilian habitats and were the only pollinator of a lone pasture tree of this species, transferring pollen from large distances (Dick 2001). Almost 80% of the canopy-forming trees in Samoa have been found to depend on flying foxes as dispersers of pollen or seed. It is still unknown whether the role of these declining animal species with their vast foraging area can be filled by introduced organisms (Cox and Elmqvist 2000). Studying insect-pollinated perennials in a South African shrub community, Donaldson et al. (2002) reported complex reactions to fragmentation. Ecological characteristics of fragments rather than their size and their distance to a contiguous shrub community had a stronger overall impact on pollinator diversity and plant reproductive success; however, the conditions varied greatly between plant species possessing different reproduction systems. The remaining pollen vectors are able to transfer only reduced amounts of pollen among the trees. Eventually, the distances between trees approach the range of the feeding flights of the pollinators, so the mating contact among the trees is impeded. It may even be interrupted, if tree distances exceed the
9.2 The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations
activity radius of pollinators. Fragments have then lost their connectivity. Historically old population isolation in Caesalpinia echinata Lam. in coastal Brazilian forest has led to reduced variation in local populations and their strong differentiation at maternally inherited markers (Lira et al. 2003; Sect. 5.4). Depending on the composition and the behavior of the pollinator guild, the amount of remote pollen transferred inevitably, though not continuously, decreases with increasing distance. Consequently, also the remnant groups of trees within the forest fragments are at least partially isolated. They can no longer be considered coherent populations of the type that once prevailed on the respective sites. Reduced mating contact also within population fragments implies an increase in self-pollination. Unless there is no absolute barrier against self-fertilization, some of the arising offspring show inbreeding depression, a decline of fitness in terms of retarded or reduced fertility, reduced growth, and reduced longevity. If also the seed vectors have become less abundant, the trees in a neighborhood that are potential mating partners tend to be related. This biparental inbreeding is to be expected wherever the dispersal of pollen and seed is not fully effective. The genetic effects described are more or less severe depending on the reproduction system of the respective species. In low-density populations or low-density patches the seed shadows of individuals possibly do not overlap, so neighboring seedlings are more closely related, because they have at least their seed parent in common. This family structure is less likely to arise if seed dispersal is very efficient. An initial spatial structure eventually fades with progressing life stages owing to mortality and selection. In an ecological sense, a tree is solitary if it has no neighboring trees as competitors; however, it is not necessarily isolated in the genetic sense. Contrary to human perception, spatial distance to the nearest neighbors does not necessarily reflect their actual gene flow pattern. If a solitary tree produces seed by cross-fertilization or contributes pollen to the progeny of other trees, it is part of their population. A solitary tree that does not reproduce in either way might still possess a vital ecological function, since its flowers support pollinator movement between trees. Tall free-standing intervening trees may also serve as roosts for fruit dispersers and thus direct seeds to nearby patches (Nason et al. 1997; Galindo-González et al. 2000; Dick 2001). From the second generation following fragmentation, another source of inbreeding is likely to occur depending on the reproduction-effective sizes of population fragments. These inbreeding effects accumulate if the reproductive isolation of small fragments persists for several generations (Ledig 1992). Since not all members of a population contribute balanced numbers of gametes to the produced progeny, the effective number of individuals is reduced to less than their census number. The size of the parental pool may even drastically differ from the census number. With help of highly variable genetic markers at
115
116
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
least the effective size of the parental pool relative to the census number may be estimated. The diminished size is due to imbalances in the production of effective gametes (review by Hattemer in 2006). Stern and Gregorius (1972) have shown that in monoecious populations a further reduction is due, since the individuals may produce gametes of either sex, which represents a further source of kinship. Depending on the degree of the imbalance of gamete contributions and the sexual function of the individual trees, the effective number is more or less strongly reduced. The reproduction-effective population size has two aspects, as Kjær (1996) discussed with reference to tree populations. For instance, a population fragment of 50 trees with an inbreeding-effective size of half the census number is expected to produce the same number of inbred progeny as a panmictically reproducing population of size 25. Furthermore, a collective of 50 trees with a variance-effective number of half the census number is expected to produce progeny with the same amount of nonadaptive gene frequency change as a panmictically reproducing population of size 25. Although the assumption of panmictic reproduction raises the impression of being highly unrealistic, the panmictic population still represents a useful reference (Sect. 6.2.2). Depending on the number of progeny produced, the variation in the effective number of female and male gametes, and the proportion of self-fertilization, the two types of effective population size may differ but they are mostly less than the census number. Kjær (1996) indicated also methods of estimation. The theory of the two parameters introduced was explained and reviewed under a range of circumstances by Caballero (1994). These parameters possess relevance also for breeding and are addressed in Chap. 13. A situation where presumably both parameters are drastically reduced is described in Example 9.1. Example 9.1: Genetic Impact of Fragmentation on a Rain Forest Canopy Tree Aldrich and Hamrick (1998) and Aldrich et al. (1998) studied the Neotropical Symphonia globulifera (Clusiaceae), a late-successional, bird-pollinated canopy tree of Costa Rican rain forests. On the study site, a population had been fragmented 10–30 years before. The conditions in remnant forest patches and on pasture were compared with those in continuous forest at a control site. Seed set was low owing to low pollination, high abortion rates, and rapid removal by frugivores. Seedlings did not recruit on pasture but had higher density in remnant than in contiguous forest. The proportion of seedlings arising from self-fertilization increased from about 1% in continuous forest to 11% in remnant forest and to even 25% in pasture trees. The few pasture trees had produced more of the younger than the older progeny. This indicates a sequential reduction in the number of reproductively effective trees. A variance-effective population size of Symphonia globulifera of 17 was estimated both in continuous and in remnant forest; however, accounting for migration led to estimates of 9.4 in continuous
9.2 The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations
forest and 2.8 in fragmented forest owing to the lower seed migration rate in the latter. These estimates are extremely low. The reproductive imbalance becomes even clearer if also the respective area sizes are accounted for: the effective population size was much smaller on 38 ha of remnant forest than on only 1 ha of continuous forest. Parentage analysis by means of microsatellite markers revealed that in remnant forest by far most of the progeny were produced by a few large trees left on nearby pastures. The large reproductive success of the pasture trees was positively correlated with their increased crown size owing to the release from competition following fragmentation. This was interpreted by a shift in the foraging pattern of the humming-bird pollinators from traplining towards more pronounced territoriality, i.e., from moving among tree crowns towards moving within the same large tree crown for the sake of saving energy. The size difference between saplings and seedlings reflected their difference in age, which helped in classifying progeny individuals as seedlings or saplings. The adult trees did not show any homozygote excess (F ≈ 0; see Sect. 6.4.1 for an explanation of the inbreeding coefficient F ). Saplings in the remnant forest had but a slight excess of homozygotes. The moderate inbreeding coefficient of the saplings which was presumably due either to mating events prior to fragmentation or to viability selection since then was greatly exceeded by that of the seedlings (F = 0.21). Bats dispersed fruits of the pasture trees over a considerable distance into the remnant forest, thus adding notably to the reproductive imbalance but little, if anything at all, to the variance-effective population size and the genetic variation in the remnant forest. It must be added that the seedlings were established in a suboptimal habitat, and that they belonged to a small number of families, i.e., they were closely related or even inbred. This is consistent with statements made by Ledig (1992) on the decrease of heterozygosity to be expected in future generations assuming restricted population size. (From Aldrich and Hamrick 1998; Aldrich et al. 1998) Hall et al. (1996) have pointed out that the effective population size at a given time may be diminished by variation in flowering phenology and may thus become critical in small fragments. This expectation was supported by results of Fuchs et al. (2003) for bat-pollinated Pachira quinata (Bombacaceae). These authors found no reduction in reproductive output, because the lower percentage of flowers developing into fruit was overcompensated by the larger number of flowers produced by trees in fragments. However, they also estimated lower outcrossing rates and a lower number of sires, leading to a higher degree of relatedness of the seed produced in fragmented forest, particularly by asynchronously flowering trees. The degree of isolation cannot necessarily be judged on a geographic scale alone (Nason and Hamrick 1997). Rather, dispersal delimits the patches. It should have become clear by now that population fragments are reproductively
117
118
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
isolated only if they are separated by distances that greatly impede the transfer of effective pollen or that cannot even be bridged by pollen or seed vectors at all (Chap. 5). Their behavior and abundance ultimately maintains links among forest fragments. To some degree, low tree density expands pollinator foraging ranges and pollen dispersal distances. It has been shown that tree pollen can travel far even in fragmented terrain (Chase et al. 1996b; Dawson et al. 1997; Nason and Hamrick 1997; Aldrich and Hamrick 1998; Aldrich et al. 1998; James et al. 1998; White and Boshier 2000; Dick 2001; Example 7.2). Nonetheless, one has to assume absolute limits beyond which no effective pollen can be transferred. However, as was shown both in wind-pollinated (Starke 1996; Wang 2001) and in insect-pollinated tree species of the northern temperate zone, fragmentation may also facilitate pollen dispersal. Ballal et al. (1994) reported up to 17% influx of pollen into small population fragments of Acer saccharum close to contiguous forest. This species has a dual system of pollen transfer, because in the absence of pollinators wind-transferred pollen is sufficient for normal seed set (Gabriel and Garrett 1984). Surveying seedlings in samples from a natural park and in patches (comprising 90–646 individuals), Young et al. (1993) found no evidence of reduced genetic variation, reduced gene flow, or increased selfing in the latter, although fragmentation had taken place more than a century before. These authors explain superior diversity of population fragments by increased gene flow. Also Young et al. (1996) came to the conclusion that increased gene flow may counteract if not even compensate or overcompensate the effect of reduced population size. Nason et al. (1997) discussed the results of numerous studies of pollen dispersal in tropical trees and concluded that the absolute reach of transfer distances in species adapted to low population density in species-rich communities is several hundred meters to some kilometers (Sect. 5.2). As Wright (1931) derived from his island model, few migrants or effective pollen per generation are sufficient to counteract loss of genetic diversity and drift-related genetic differentiation. The probability of mating between trees at a certain distance in adjoining fragments is higher than expected on the basis of that distance in a contiguous population. The reason is the absence of pollen-producing trees growing in-between. Bierregaard et al. (1992) reported that in Amazonian forest breaks as little as 80 m wide may diminish interfragment movement of some insects and birds. There must clearly be a certain limit to the gapcrossing ability of any pollinators; however, this gap may be rather wide depending on several circumstances, as shown for figs in Example 7.2 and Swietenia humilis in Example 9.2. This study also shows that fragmentation-induced changes in the foraging pattern of dispersal agents and the concomitant genetic processes in a tree population can differ among fragmented habitats. Apsit et al. (2001) described another situation of substantial pollen immigration into a population fragment of the insect-pollinated Enterolobium cyclocarpum (Jacq.) Griseb. (Fabaceae). A small number of trees received pollen from many outside
9.2 The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations
pollen donors growing hundreds of meters away. Similar findings were reported by Cascante et al. (2002) studying isolated trees of Samanea saman (Mimosaceae). Isolated trees received pollen from far-distant trees; however, the styles of these trees received lower quantities of pollen and a greater proportion of the pollen tubes were arrested at the bottom of the style, presumably owing to genetic incompatibility. In spite of high reproductive capacity of the isolated trees, they received pollen from fewer pollen donors, which led to an increase in the degree of the relatedness among their progeny. Example 9.2: Connectivity of Population Fragments of a Medium-Sized Dry-Forest Tree In a Honduran study region in seasonally dry forest the population of the largely self-incompatible species Swietenia humilis (Meliaceae) is highly fragmented and comprises small forest remnants and scattered trees in pastures and along the borders of agricultural fields (Fig. 9.1). A large proportion of the trees was present prior to fragmentation; therefore, the present pattern largely reflects the previous more continuous forest. Pollination is by small generalist insects; the seeds are wind-dispersed. The species flowers for about 1 month during the dry season with some individual variation.
Fig. 9.1. Locations of Swietenia humilis trees sampled. Each tree is denoted by a dot; the 17 trees selected for progeny analysis are circled (five in Las Tablas, three in Jiote, six in Butus/Jicarito, and the isolated tree 501). No trees were sampled in the spotted enclosed area adjoining the Las Tablas site marked by U. (From White and Boshier 2000)
119
120
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
The total number of trees was 98 in the largest fragment, Las Tablas, and was smaller in Butus/Jicarito (44), Jiote (22), and Tablas Plains (7). Owing to immediate losses of rare alleles of highly polymorphic simple sequence repeats, their numbers of low-frequency alleles encountered in the trees amounted to 54, 29, 19, and 8, respectively. The simple sequence repeats provided for complete paternity exclusion except for one, so paternal assignment by exclusion was 100%. Observed maximum pollen transport distances were at least 0.6 km for Las Tablas, 0.9 km for Tablas Plains, 1.5 km for Jiote, 3.6 km for Butus/Jicarito, and 4.5 km for tree 501. The true maximum distances may have been underestimated. As impressive as reports on maximum reach of animal-mediated pollen transfer may ever , the totality of the distribution of the quantities of transferred effective pollen is crucial. Pollen flow had a contrasting pattern. Besides the predominance of near-neighbor matings within 300-m distance, a large proportion of the pollen donors grew outside each fragment in the study area. In Las Tablas, the largest fragment, 64% of the matings were between near neighbors. Within-fragment matings dominated also in Jiote (62%) and Butus/Jicarito (53%). In the smallest fragment, Tablas Plains, only 31% of the effective pollen was produced within that fragment. The lone tree 501 received less than 30% of its effective pollen from distances between 1.2 and 2.4 km but over 70% of its pollen from unidentified male partners at least 4.5 km away It turned out that restricted mating between near neighbors was due to their asynchronous flowering. The flowers of the Meliaceae are as a rule functionally monoecious, i.e., either the male or the female organs are rudimentary (Styles 1972). The male flowering period of a given tree may be much shorter, so one of two synchronously flowering trees may fertilize the other but not vice versa. This reduces the number of near potential mates over and above asynchronous flowering but opens the way to some far-distance pollen becoming effective. Both the identity and the number of pollen donors varied greatly among seed trees. The number of individuals producing seed increased with increasing disturbance in this species. In general, a large proportion of the effective pollen came from the largest fragment rather than the nearest one. Long-distance pollen flow increased with a decrease in population size of the fragments, leading to restoration of alleles lost in the original fragmentation, if not even to an increase in the level of genetic variation within the local subpopulations. This was facilitated by the ability of pollinators to move between the spatially isolated stands. The proportion of pollen flow was governed by the size of the pollen source (large crowns or many trees, respectively) rather than its distance to the seed tree. The latter was also true for a remnant tree in pasture. The levels of heterozygosity among the seeds produced in the various fragments were only little influenced by the sizes of the respective fragments. This was interpreted by
9.2 The Genetic Status of Fragmented Tree Populations
an interbreeding network of trees with sufficient gene exchange to compensate for genetic drift in the parent generation. The widely spaced distribution of Swietenia humilis did not serve as a barrier to gene flow. Consequently, the seed was also very little differentiated between the fragments. Pairwise genetic distances were not correlated with geographic distances. The authors stress the need for measuring gene flow between fragments in order to see whether reduction of the size of fragments is really followed by “theorized genetic depletion.” In view of the rather efficient pollen dispersal, moderate distances of seed dispersal rather than persistent biparental inbreeding must be responsible for the existing spatial genetic structure of the old trees. Autocorrelation analysis revealed a significant excess of relatives (presumably half-sibs) in the near neighborhood (up to 50 m) of trees. The production of seeds increased with increased degree of disturbance. Since fragmentation does not necessarily have severe consequences for the connectivity of fragments, also remnant stands have long-term conservation value. Lone trees in pastures act as focal points or stepping-stones for pollinator movement. The results for their progeny contrasted the prediction made by Murawski and Hamrick (1991) that isolated trees receive pollen from fewer donors and are more likely to deviate from random mating. The authors conclude that a system of nonspecialist insect pollinators is less susceptible to habitat disturbance but stress the hypothesis that tropical tree species possess the capacity of adaptation to fragmentation of their populations (From White et al. 1999; White and Boshier 2000). Increased atmospheric turbulence over a treeless area supports both the transfer of airborne pollen and pollinator movement. It is, therefore, dangerous to extrapolate from data on pollen transfer in undisturbed populations to draw conclusions about the impacts under fragmentation (White and Boshier 2000). The large size of breeding units of figs (Example 7.2) suggests that forest fragments isolated by several kilometers can be part of a large viable population at least of these species. As Law and Lean (1999) have shown, bats as pollinators in Australian rain forest trees were highly mobile in a fragmented landscape. Their estimated home ranges reached 1,800 ha and might cover several forest fragments. Since hand-pollinations using pollen from different fragments yielded more seed than those within the same fragment, it may be inferred that the pollen transferred by bats between fragments is more effective, since the mating partners are unrelated. The transfer of genes from other subpopulations thus contributes to the “genetic rescue” of a subpopulation as defined by Richards (2000) by increasing the probability of its survival. Unfortunately, the future density of bats in the fragmented landscape is uncertain because of increased predation by owls. In Panama, Nason et al. (1997) reported reduced reproductive success of Spondias mombin, a canopy
121
122
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
tree, from small islands. Seed viability was up to more than 30% less than in contiguous forest. The use of genetic markers is indispensable in measuring tree population size as determined by the activity range of insects, birds, and bats (Nason et al. 1997; Sect. 5.2.3). In the case of only recent fragmentation, the search for private alleles as indicators of reproductive isolation makes little sense. The fragments are expected to share most genetic variants except the rarest ones, unless they are very small and short-distance gene flow prevailed before human interference. In general, genetic divergence may be due to pre-existing spatial genetic structure (Aldrich et al. 1998). Forest fragmentation does not only affect tree populations. For instance, the decline in the number of animal species with decreasing size of forest fragments has been studied in four Malagasy forest birds. However, owing to the relatively large size of the fragments surveyed and the high migratory potential of the birds studied, human interference was not reflected in genetic differentiation of populations (Andrianarimisa et al. 2000). Autopolyploidy is expected to partially offset the risk of genetic erosion and the decay of heterozygosity. The incidence of polyploidy is high in some tropical tree families such as the Bombacaceae (Bawa 1973). It is, however, not known how many of these species are autopolyploids. Several authors presented empirical data on the inverse relationship between the size of isolated conspecific natural tree populations and the amount of their genetic variation. Nason et al. (1997) focused our attention on the differential short-term and long-term genetic consequences of bottlenecks. Under the assumption of equal initial variation in the past, smaller genetic multiplicity due to the loss of rare genes is to be expected in smaller populations. After several generations, overall genetic diversity of smaller populations is affected more strongly (Nei et al. 1975). It has to be awaited whether empirical studies will provide the evidence for these genetic changes in completely isolated fragments. These authors also analyzed the quality of pre-existing spatial genetic structure and of the spatial scale of fragmentation. Data presented by Moran and Hopper (1983), McClenaghan and Beauchamp (1986), and Billington (1991) largely confirmed the negative relationship between population size and genetic variation. However, the establishment of a strict correlation takes many generations of continuously small size of the reproduction-efficient population until the results of multiple bottlenecks become manifest in diversity, because in every generation with finite size a renewed size-dependent risk exists that genetic variants will become lost. This risk also depends on the initial frequency structure of those variants. One may derive from this that the sizes of man-made fragments of a spatially structured population are moderately appropriate predictors of their genetic variation, as was found by Young et al. (1996), Sork et al. (1998), and Aldrich et al. (1998). The findings of
9.3 Genetic Preconditions for Restoration and Persistence
Young et al. (1999) at allozyme gene loci in a perennial herb are consistent with those in trees. Further to tropical trees, an inverse relationship was also found by Hall et al. (1996) on the basis of their study of Pithecellobium elegans and by White and Boshier (2000) studying highly variable microsatellites of Swietenia humilis in recent forest fragments (Example 9.2). Little impact of fragmentation on the genetic system of another tree of the Meliaceae family, Swietenia macrophylla, was reported by Céspedes et al. (2003). Also Prober and Brown (1994) found moderately strict relationships between diversity and population size; however, after discussing incomplete isolation and other reasons, they considered the relationships surprisingly strong. Be the relationship called strong or only moderate, the tendency involved in the results is beyond any doubt. Among natural populations with more or less unknown past history, the estimated degree of determination of genetic variation by population size cannot possibly be expected to be as high as in artificial populations of model insects in the laboratory. When summarizing the results of the genetic impact of forest fragmentation, it has to be stated that there exists, of course, no empirical information on the genetic change during a full tree generation. Nonetheless, according to the estimates of various population genetics parameters, the reproduction system of some tree populations is subject to major change with regard to mating systems, gene flow, and migration. Spatial genetic structures are affected by fragmentation both on a landscape scale and on a regional scale.
9.3 Genetic Preconditions for Restoration and Persistence The attempt to precisely restore a forested area to its presumed original vegetation would certainly be all but promising. This applies even more to the genetic structure of tree populations. However, taking account of some basic preconditions for an adequate population size of tree species is helpful in making decisions. Since fragments of tropical tree populations are in a critical situation, managers have to consider the size of a population that is worthwhile for preservation and possible later enlargement. The persistence of tree populations in tropical forests over generations has certain preconditions, such as a minimum population size, since small populations are prone to extinction sooner or later. Besides the reduction of evolutionary adaptability due to the loss of genetic variation (Sect. 7.2) caused by drift, the accumulation of detrimental inbreeding effects is another genetic reason for increased vulnerability of small isolated populations. Information on the size and structure of neighboring fragments and their locations is important for making decisions on the restorability of
123
124
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
a fragment or a group of fragments (Loyn and MacAlpine 2001). Two approaches towards conceiving population sizes adequate for persistence of population fragments shall be briefly presented. If mating is assumed to be random and selection to be absent, heterozygosity is expected to decrease at a rate that depends exclusively on population size (Crow and Kimura 1970). If the reproduction-effective size of the population is 50, the decay of heterozygosity is expected to amount to just 1% per generation; hence, 50 is the minimum population size that keeps the speed of this decay equal to or below 1% at least over short periods of time. Considering the number 50 as operationally adequate is simplistic, since it does not account for other factors such as genetic load and selection that influence the dynamics of heterozygosity (Sherwin and Moritz 2000). Particularly in trees, the density and the spatial distribution of the population members play a role in setting the scene for inbreeding, as was described in Sect. 9.2. This number is still referred to as the basic rule of conservation (short-term rule). The tenfold population size of 500 individuals is not only expected to keep the decay of heterozygosity below 0.1%. It is also expected to provide for a balance between the loss of genetic variants and their origination through mutation. A population size of 500 individuals (long-term rule) is said to be required to avoid immediate loss of diversity and to ensure the long-term preservation of genetic variation and thus of evolutionary adaptability (Franklin 1980; Frankel and Soulé 1981). Experimental investigations in caged Drosophila populations showed that the loss of genetic variation in populations of 500 reproducing insects due to genetic drift is compensated by mutations; however, this finding does not take account of the identity of the genetic variants and their adaptational relevance in nature. Furthermore, the time factor has to be accounted for, since the generation period is much longer in trees than in insects. The much larger number of 500 individuals can also be seen as a gross safety measure. The 50/500 rule is weakly supported by experimental studies on feral animal species and even more so on plant species but is still frequently reported in the relevant literature (Frankel and Soulé 1981). Last but not least, the reproduction system of plants is much more complex than that of animals. It has to be stressed that besides population size, imbalances in the mating success of individual trees have to be accounted for, as was outlined in Sect. 9.2. Consequently, reproduction-effective population sizes have to be considered when applying the basic rules. Fragments of species-rich tropical forests of only a few hectares in size are likely to be insufficient for the preservation of numerous tree species, if the 50/500 rule is adopted for forest tree populations. The long-term persistence of species in tropical forests is only possible if certain additional preconditions according to a different concept are fulfilled. The estimation of minimum viable population (MVP) sizes as first conceived by Shaffer (1981) have attracted considerable interest among conservation biologists (Soulé 1987). The MVP
9.3 Genetic Preconditions for Restoration and Persistence
concept refers to two aspects of populations. One is the totality of critical factors of the genetic structure of populations above a level below which inbreeding depression and the loss of adaptive capacity would become a problem for their continued survival. The other one is the size of an isolated population of a given species in a given habitat that keeps the risk of extinction low. The MVP is to ensure at some acceptable level of probability that the isolated population persists in a viable condition for a given interval of time. Some authors have specified these parameters as 95% probability and 1,000 years, respectively. This period is rather extended at first sight; however, it is equivalent to a small number of generations of forest trees. Apart from genetic considerations, other factors such as demographic stochasticy, i.e., random fluctuations of the sizes and perturbations of the age structures of populations without associated changes in their genetic structure, may also pave the way towards extinction (Lande 1988). The long-term growth rate of a population is determined by the geometric mean of the growth rates over time. The geometric mean is less than the arithmetic mean. Consequently, the long-term growth of a population may be negative, although it presently shows positive growth. Several nongenetic factors share in the determination of the expected persistence time of small populations. Shrinking populations require constant support and management. Also deterministic effects such as the incidence of herbivores, pests and disease, competition, and the colonization by invasive nonindigenous species represent threats to persistence. The long-term conservation of forest fragments is more promising, the better the habitat quality of pollinators and frugivores as seed dispersers (Nason et al. 1997). Reduced density of fruit-eating animals in small forest fragments leads to lower recruitment of large-seeded animal-dispersed trees, although the trees bear fruit (Cordeiro and Howe 2001). If the animal disperser of a tree species is absent owing to subsistence hunting in fragmented forest, the seeds are only gravity-dispersed. This leads to a closer relationship of the seedlings under parental canopies. Therefore, defaunation also has an impact on the dynamics of spatial genetic structures in trees which will become crucial at reproduction (Pacheco and Simonetti 2000). Fragmentation of tropical forests creates conditions that are similar to a metapopulation structure. In unfragmented forests, the habitats of extinct local subpopulations can be recolonized and mating contact between temporarily isolated local subpopulations can sometimes be regained (Céspedes et al. 2003). In permanently or temporarily isolated subpopulations an increase of inbreeding is expected, and genetic drift causes local losses of genetic variation and evolutionary adaptability. Céspedes et al. (2003) concluded that metapopulation models could be used to describe the genetic structure of plants in highly fragmented landscapes. However, as Gilpin (1991) pointed out, not only the sizes of the subpopulations but also the size of the total metapopulation matter greatly. The question of MVP is then extended to the question of the
125
126
C HAPTER 9 Fragmentation of Forests
minimum number of interconnected local populations necessary for the longterm persistence of the total metapopulation. Both of these quantities are likely to be strongly reduced by man-induced fragmentation. Genetic variation decays faster in the smaller subpopulations and these are hardly the source of genetic variants that were lost in adjacent larger subpopulations (Aldrich et al. 1998). Therefore, both recolonization and gene flow originating from the larger donor subpopulations are crucial for the persistence of patterns of partially isolated population fragments (Hall et al. 1996). Habitat corridors