TRIZ POWER TOOLS Job # 5 Resolving Problems
How to Systematically Tackle Tough Problems
TRIZ Power Tools Resolving Problems March 2010 Edition ISBN 1-934805-26-2 978-1-934805-26-8 TRIZ Power Tools by Collaborative Coauthors 591 Pages Copyright 2010 by Collaborative Authors, All rights reserved Published in the United States by Third Millennium Publishing, located on the INTERNET at http://3mpub.com For paperback or digital copies go to http://www.3mpub.com/TRIZ All proceeds from book sales are donated to Humanitarian Aid and Disaster Relief
Third Millennium Publishing PO Box 14026 Tempe, AZ 85284-0068
[email protected]
ii
Acknowledgements This book is the work of a collaborative group of coauthors.
Coauthors
Editors
Illustrators
Larry Ball
Erika Hernandez
Larry Ball
David Troness
Larry Ball
David Troness
Kartik Ariyur
David Troness
Jason Huang
Paul Dwyer
Don Rossi
S. Robert Lang
Petr Krupansky Steve Hickman
Other Authors, Theoreticians, Practitioners Whose Writings or Teachings have Impacted This Work Genrich Altshuller
Yuri Salamatov
Lane Desborough
Ellen Domb
Victor Fey
Clayton Christensen
Roni Horowitz
Eugene Rivin
Renee Mauborgne
John Terninko
Darrell Mann
Kim Chan
Alla Zusman
Sergei Ikovenko
Greg Yezersky
Boris Zlotin
Simon Litvin
Lev Shulyak
Peter Ulan
iii
iv
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Algorithm (Table of Contents) Algorithm—Introduction ................................................................................................................ 7 Discovering Problems ................................................................................................................... 11 Do You Want to Look for Hidden Problems? ........................................................................... 11 Look for Hidden Problems ........................................................................................................ 15 Base Problem and Constraints ...................................................................................................... 19 Causal Analysis ............................................................................................................................. 31 Clarify the Need for System Parts ............................................................................................. 37 Simple Causal Analysis ............................................................................................................. 43 Basic Cause-Effect Diagrams .................................................................................................... 49 Advanced Cause-Effect Diagrams............................................................................................. 69 Investigating Cause.................................................................................................................... 83 Catching Missing Knobs—Table of Knobs............................................................................... 91 Catching Missing Knobs—Relative To ................................................................................... 129 Did Easily Turned Knobs Solve the Problem? ........................................................................ 131 Jump to New System--Idealize Functions .................................................................................. 133 Pick the Functions to Idealize.................................................................................................. 139 Idealize Useful Functions ........................................................................................................ 141 Idealize Informing Functions................................................................................................... 207 Idealize Harmful Functions ..................................................................................................... 263 Evaluate Candidate Systems .................................................................................................... 287 Evolve the System-- Resolve Contradictions ............................................................................. 289 Pick High Impact Contradictions ............................................................................................ 301
Introduction
v
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Clarify the Contradiction ......................................................................................................... 305 Separation in Time................................................................................................................... 307 Separate Gradually .................................................................................................................. 407 Separate in Space ..................................................................................................................... 425 Separate Between the Parts and the Whole ............................................................................. 463 Separate by Direction .............................................................................................................. 509 Separate by Perspective ........................................................................................................... 519 Separate by Frame of Reference .............................................................................................. 533 Separate by Response of Fields ............................................................................................... 543 Separate Between the Substance and the Field ....................................................................... 551 Compensation .......................................................................................................................... 557 Iterate on Solutions .................................................................................................................. 559 Simplify the Solutions ............................................................................................................. 561 Contradiction Exercises ........................................................................................................... 563 Appendix: Working With Functions .......................................................................................... 581 Appendix: Table of Fields ......................................................................................................... 589
vi
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Algorithm— Introduction All problems are not created equal This is a book for helping inventors, scientists and service innovators to solve difficult problems. It is often hard to tell the difficulty of a problem until we attempt to solve it. Common sense or intuition is sufficient to clear most hurdles. “Recreational” problem solvers are acquainted with the endorphin rush of intuitive problem solving. There is nothing wrong with free-ranging problem solving, but we may notice that our attempts to intuitively solve a “simple” problem are sometimes hampered by unforeseen difficulties. There is a popular website which presents problems which can be solved for profit. One such problem related to a large problem in developing countries regarding the quality of air inside homes that cook and heat with unventilated stoves. Many of the fires are fueled by materials such as wood and charcoal. The problem with these materials is that they produce large amounts of particulates which compromise the respiratory system. People with damaged lungs become susceptible to many diseases that a healthy body would resist. This is especially true for young children. Many millions of children die each year from diseases related to a compromised respiratory system. The specific problem involved the use of non-edible oils which were readily available from certain plants and could be manufactured cheaply. A stove was designed to burn these oils as efficiently as possible and it was not working as well as the manufactures would have liked. The problem was that it would clog with soot very rapidly and needed cleaning after several hours of use. The challenge was to prolong the time to cleaning or eliminating cleaning completely. When I presented this problem to a number of colleagues, the immediate response was that this was a simple problem that could be resolved with known technology. I felt, likewise, that it would be easy to come up with a solution. We wondered how the company could be so naïve to propose such a simple problem and then offer so much for its solution. Without the aid of any innovation tools, I “brainstormed” various concepts and created small prototypes and tested them. First, I learned how to ignite an olive oil flame by forming a wick Introduction
7
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
into a special shape. I also built a small canister of oil which was heated to create a flammable gas. It slowly dawned on me that my “common knowledge” concerning flammable liquids had little to do with this problem which was much harder than I realized. The operation of the stove required the oil to be heated until it was vaporized. Once it was vaporized, the vapor was mixed with air in the correct proportions to burn efficiently and without soot. While the flame was clean, the oil was coking in the heating chamber and in the lines that fed the burners. It turns out that such oils vaporize and coke at the same temperatures, unlike benzene, white gas or alcohol. If you are going to use the phenomena of vaporization by heating, some fraction of the fuel will coke, wherever it is. The fact that I could not easily solve this problem was a bitter pill and I realized that we were the naïve ones. It can be deflating to admit that our “common sense” is not sufficient for such an easy problem. Our pride drives us to struggle for a time, but we eventually realize that the solution is beyond our experience and intuition. We give up, try again later or recognize that we need stronger medicine. The algorithms of this book are stronger medicine.
The Most Common Job of Inventers Of the six jobs covered in this series of books, fixing problems is the most common. Why is this? One reason is the recursive nature of solving problems. It is rare that only one improvement is required. Solutions to one problem often generate new problems that still require resolution. Most “good” solution concepts start as “sow’s ears”. Our job is to turn them into “silk purses.” Unfortunately, most of us have been taught that this is not possible. Actually, this is a clear description of what really happens during the inventing process. Another reason that fixing problems is so common is that hard problems will always arise during the evolution of any particular system. A careful study of patents for any particular system will uncover evolutionary patterns. These patterns show a particular evolutionary tendency for the system. This evolution is stopped by the inevitable contradictions that will arise as the systems evolve. The system continues further along its natural evolutionary path only after the contradiction is resolved. One further reason for the high frequency of fixing problems is that processes of creation and simplification (books 3 and 4) often generate serious problems. (The solution to these problems was not covered in books 3 and 4 but was delayed until this book). Let’s say that we have simplified a system by making use of a physical phenomenon that replaces a feedback system with a passive control system. This is often done by using a “direct acting” element that both senses and provides actuation muscle. While such a change can greatly reduce the cost of complex systems, it is also a large change that can result in poor control performance. This simplification would almost guarantee that there will be serious problems to overcome.
8
Introduction
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Not Enough Problems to Solve? Where do we look for problems and what types of problems can we solve with the tools of this book? Some people find it difficult to identify important problem to solve. If we know what to look for we can see that we are swimming in problems. All systems, by their very nature, carry burdens to the users and the environment. Only imaginary systems do not contain burdens. (In the companion book on simplifying, we spend a lot of time identifying these burdens). We often become used to these burdens and forget that we are carrying them. As we become familiar with the types of burdens that are possible, we can readily detect them all around us. One type of problem that we will specifically address in the algorithm is hidden problems. These problems are hidden for a variety of reasons. We may be so used to carrying a burden that we forget that we are carrying it. Most problem solvers are familiar with the concept of unintended consequences. A “simple change” may cause unintended problems which do not immediately appear. Consequently, a problem may be hidden when a new product or service is to be offered or an alteration is about to be fielded. Another common problem is low performance of some primary feature. Low performance usually shows up when compared to other products that perform the same function. More importantly, it shows up when the target market is not satisfied and wants improved performance in order to get their job done. Sometimes the market cannot count on the performance of a product. Perhaps the performance shifts over time or is highly variable. Some shift in performance is inevitable, but when it causes concern or anxiety in the market, it may need to be fixed. Another common problem is when the product or service causes unintentional harm to other objects or the user of the system. Production or service costs are also a problem that can be tackled with the algorithms of this book. High costs are symptoms of other unsolved problems. When these problems are solved, the costs will go down. Additional ways to reduce costs are shared in the other books which deal with simplifying systems and adding value to the product or service by determining the right product features. Cost is relative to perceived market value. We can effectively reduce costs by being able to charge more for the product or service.
Some Problems are More Important While there are many problems, should they all carry the same importance? To a large degree, market and environmental considerations determine the relative importance of problems. If a problem is blocking or hindering the target market from getting a job done, this raises the level of importance. If the environment or mankind is hurt by a product or service, this is also an Introduction
9
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
important problem to solve. The authors of this book are keenly aware of the need for scientists, engineers and other problem solvers to solve the problems that society has placed on the environment.
ARIZ ARIZ is a Russian acronym for the Algorithm for the Resolution of Inventive Problems. This is a step-by-step approach in classical TRIZ for solving what is referred to as the “mini-problem”. The mini-problem is a technical contradiction that requires resolving. The subject matter of this book is also an algorithm for the solution of problems. There are several reasons that this book departs from ARIZ. First, the logic of the algorithm is incorrect. This will be discussed later when the formation of the contradiction is described. Secondly, classical TRIZ theorists have not been big advocates of causal analysis which the authors feel is fundamental to problem solving. Third, ARIZ does not consider the tools for replacing and removing system objects to the same degree that this material does. What follows is an algorithm for solving problems. Repeat the steps of this algorithm and customize it to meet your needs.
10
Introduction
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Discovering Problems (If you are reading the PDF format—navigate the algorithms with the “Bookmarks” to the left.) I think I have a problem. I know I have a problem. I’m worried that there might be a serious problem but I don’t have any evidence. Problems come to us at varying levels of certainty. Sometimes they are painfully obvious while other times, we have an uneasy feeling. Regardless of the certainty, here we are and now we need to do something about it. There are a variety of ways that problems are made manifest. If we are proactive we can discover them by actively searching. If we do not look for them we will discover them as a natural consequence of doing business.
Do You Want to Look for Hidden Problems? When we build a good machine, we also build a bad machine. The bad machine is always operating and we may not even know it. Let’s say that we build a transmission for a food mixer. Everything seems to work well the first thousand times that it is operated. If we then open the machine and examine the pieces, we discover that many of the plastic gears have begun to wear. Perhaps some are close to failure. We did not purposely build a machine to wear gears. The gear wearing machine operates in the background each time the food mixing machine is operated. The bad machine is usually hidden when we first create the product or service. It will take time for the machine to expose its mischief. It is human nature to focus on problems that result in immediate pain. These problems cry for our focus and attention. However, waiting to discover the problem is often disastrous. Here are some examples of when you might want to discover hidden problems: —When the operation of the product could potentially cause serious injury or death. Discovering Problems
11
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
—There are maintenance agreements with the customer. They pay you to maintain the product and unanticipated repairs decrease profit. —A good market introduction is required. —It is necessary to create or restore the reputation as a trouble-free product or brand. There are many reasons that problems are hidden. We have already mentioned the issue of wear or degradation over the course of time. Another reason is that we have not anticipated that the product or process could be used in unsavory environments. Potential environments are unlimited. We may think that we understand the environment of the target market, but we must always remember those who are willing to experiment with the product in unusual and dangerous ways and in unusual places. Perhaps the most common reason that problems are hidden is that we have learned to compensate for them and we forget that the problem exists. Let us take the extreme case where the compensation is expensive and time consuming. Surely no organization would forget that such a problem exists. Expensive and time consuming problems often occur when we need to calculate the effect of a problem and then overpower the effect with something else in the system. When transportation vessels move through the air or water, there is drag which robs the system of energy. It is a constant drain. The ultimate speed of a vehicle is related to the fluid drag and the power that we need to overcome the drag. Virtually all of the fuel that is expended is due to this drag! (Think of the rivers of fuel that could be conserved if this problem were solved). How do we compensate for this and design for drag? Typically models of drag are created which are related to such things as the velocity of the object, its shape and the properties of the fluid that it is moving through. Usually, it is necessary to substantiate the model by testing in wind tunnels or in flowing water. There is a back-and-forth comparison of the model to tests until there is confidence in the model. Now that we have a substantiated model, we can anticipate the driving force that is required to overcome these drag forces. It can be used to consider different configurations of the vehicle and anticipate the drag for each concept. What we ultimately learn from the modeling and testing is how hard the drive system needs to push. When there is a need to perform these calculations often, we hire people with the skills to do this and build organizations to support them. Notice what has happened. First, we found a way to quantify drag without the need to build the actual vehicle. Second, we found a way to compensate for the drag by overpowering it. Next, we institutionalized a process to routinely calculate and overpower the drag. Finally, we created an organization which can repeatedly accomplish this. 12
Discovering Problems
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The problem with this is that very few people are working on the problem of entirely removing the base problem of drag. Most have accepted “the inevitable reality” so the next best thing is to compensate for it. By routinely grinding through a compensation process, most have forgotten that the fundamental problem of drag. The problem becomes “hidden”. While this may seem like an extreme example, think about your own industry and the number of people that are employed to model, accurately calculate and compensate for known problems. The “success” of this process has convinced companies to structure the organization around these procedures. Unfortunately few are left that are sensitized to the base problem and also feel they have the capacity to tackle it.
Do you already have a Problem? As stated, most problems come to us as a result of just doing business or living our lives. We will consider several example problems and show how we progress through the algorithm. Note that these problems come from a variety of business and technical fields. If you already have a problem, then consider skipping Discovering Problems. Following are some of the examples that we will follow in this book.
Example—Acid Container Metallic Test cubes are immersed in hot acid for long periods of time to test the corrosive resistance of the metals. The cubes are placed in a corrosion resistant container which is then placed in an oven. The action of the acid is sufficient to corrode the cubes, but there is a problem. The container that contains the cubes and acid is eventually corroded and has to be replaced. Replacing the container is very expensive since it is made from a very expensive material.
Example—Pile Driving Speed The driving speed of piles is very slow. Often expensive equipment such as cranes or barges is rented to perform the work. Personnel must be on hand should anything go wrong. All of this adds up to great expense while driving the piles. None of this is necessary for the primary function of the piles. How can the driving speed be improved? Discovering Problems
13
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Garden Rake Let us consider the situation of a common garden rake. When the rake is used to collect loose debris such as rocks and loose weeds over an uneven surface, a problem arises: The rake “leaks” some of the debris that is to be collected under the tines and several strokes are required to fully collect the debris.
Example—Tape Dispenser The cost to manufacture a common tape dispenser is too high to be competitive. What can be done to reduce the cost of manufacture?
Business Example—Year End Review The yearly performance review process is very timeconsuming, especially when you have a large number of direct reports. How can the time be reduced?
Clarify the Need to Look for Hidden Problems If no problem is known, should we search for hidden problems? The answer to this type of question is largely a matter of history and the type of offering. Could hidden problems cause severe consequences? Is the physics of the offering well understood? Have a high percentage of the offerings had hidden problems? If the answer to any of these questions is “yes” then it may be wise to search for hidden problems. On the other hand, if you are beginning with a known problem and you bypass this step, there may be a tendency to forget the need to look for further problems following the creation of solution concepts. Remember that problem solving is recursive. It is easy to forget potentially hidden problems in the excitement of finding solutions.
Method Step 1: Is the severity of failure high? Step 2: Has there been high tendency to have hidden problems in the past? Step 3: Is this system new? Is the physics well understood? Step 4: Decide whether or not to look for hidden problems. If the need for searching for hidden problems is low or the problem is already known, then continue to the next chapter. 14
Discovering Problems
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Look for Hidden Problems Map the Life-Cycle Jobs It is easy to imagine products and services at the point of use. This is the moment that these systems were created for. However, there are many more functions that the system performs and many more functions that are performed on the system. These functions need to be included in our consideration of potential problems of the system.
Method Step 1: Consider the main jobs required for and by the offering by considering each stage of the Life-Cycle Map on the following page. Step 2: Each color in the chain represents a new market. Identify the market or stakeholder by box color. Each market has a stake in the success of the product. As each market becomes more satisfied, the offering becomes more viable. Step 3: Identify the main people involved in each job (suggestions supplied on the Product Life-Cycle Map) Step 4: Identify jobs that must be done before and after.
Discovering Problems
15
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
MassTransport Loaders Forklifts Pallets Trucks Planes
MassStorage Loaders Forklifts Pallets StorageFacility
Use / Operation Already Identified On Chart
Control / Monitoring Operator MonitoringEquipment
16
Packaging Operators Packaging Machines
Testing Technicians Test Equipment
Disposition For Sale Sales People Forklifts Shelves Displays
Order Purchase Or Disposition Sales People Customer Sales Table Carts
Fueling / Energizing Operator User Technician Contractor Fueling Means Fuel
Customer Testing Customer Contractor Technician TestEquipment
Protecting System Operator SecurityOperators MaintenancePersonnel Covers
Protecting Users Operators Protection Gear
Fixing Messes Operator Technician Special Personnel MaintenanceEquipment
Maintenance Operator Technicians MonitoringEquipment Consumables
Storage Storage Location Cases Covers Nearby Objects Operator
Dealing With Failure Operator MonitoringEquipment AlternativeSystems
Repair Operator Technicians Repair – Equipment Consumables Parts
Recycling Operator Teardown Person Special Tools
Fabrication Operators Technicians FabricationMachines
Customer Transport User Contractor Transport Means
Preparation Assembly Or Setup Contractor User Technician
Protecting Others Bystanders Cleaning People Users of Other Equipment Guards
Stowing Operator Stowing Location Cases / Covers
Disposal Operators Containers Tools
Discovering Problems
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Subversion Analysis Subversion analysis is a way to overcome psychological inertia to discover new ways that a system can fail. It overcomes the inertia by setting the problem solver into the state of trying to make a “positive” change instead of discovering potential causes of a negative thing. Note that this method can be used for any stage of the Life Cycle Map.
Method Step 1: Pick a specific element of the system and assume that it has failed. Step 2: Name the different ways that it could fail—Broken, Worn, Off Speed, etc. Step 3: If you were a Saboteur, how would you cause the problem given the existing system? Find an effect which could cause the phenomenon. Use the Effects Database to perform this. Step 4: Boost the effect until it is sufficient to cause the problem. (Turn the knob to make the difference). Step 5: Repeat all steps until satisfied.
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) This tool comes from the discipline of Six-Sigma. This subject will not be covered in detail in this book as there are many thorough sources on this subject. The strength of this method is that it focuses the problem solver on the probability of occurrence and the probability of delectability, along with the severity of the problem. These three multiplied together give a ranking for how bad a potential problem is. The process for identifying these problems can be as simple as brainstorming. Consider using subversion analysis to find these problems or decompose the problem using causal analysis diagrams described later in this book. You may find it necessary to modify some of the features of FMEAs to make it compatible with the teachings of this book.
Discovering Problems
17
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
18
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Base Problem and Constraints The previous step of problem awareness would be perfectly in order if our knowledge of the product or service requirements was perfect. The awareness of a problem assumes that we understand the requirements related to the problem and can detect a deviation or potential deviation from them. This is a common, yet dangerous, assumption and can lead to further problems in the problem solving process. It is possible that there is no need to solve the problem. For instance, the product or service is operating as required in an unusual environment that it was not designed for. (This customer may represent an untapped market that has unusual expectations. Refer to the book on identifying new markets). It is also possible that the problem is greatly understated and more urgent than originally thought. If for no other reason, the problem solver should know what the target requirements are so that the required improvement is clear. It is entirely possible that the problem may be solved during this step of the algorithm. Knowing the requirements may make the problem unnecessary to solve or the solution may be obvious.
Who is the Customer ? (Main Job and Special Circumstances) If we have performed the previous jobs that innovators do (identifying markets, picking features that will excite the market, creating good upper-level requirements for the product) we will have a good idea of who the customer is. These jobs are covered in detail in two other books from this series. It is not necessary to go into such detail in order to solve problems. However, it is helpful to clarify the job and special circumstances of the customer.
Base Problem and Constraints
19
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Acid Container Step 1: What is the primary job that the customer is trying to do? The primary job is to determine the capability of various metallic materials to resist corrosive environments. Step 2: What are the special circumstances under which this job is done? The special circumstances are under a laboratory setting that may be operating for periods of time without laboratory personnel present. Step 3: What is a typical profile for this customer? The typical profile is someone responsible for buying and maintaining laboratory equipment. These people usually respond to the needs of scientists or engineers that require this type of testing capability. They may also be responding to the requests of lab technicians.
Example—Pile Driving Speed Step 1: What is the primary job that the customer is trying to do? The primary job is to create a supporting structure for building that must stand above the water and waves. Step 2: What are the special circumstances under which this job is done? The special circumstances are that the piles must be driven into the sea bed covered by water. Step 3: What is a typical profile for this customer? The typical customer is a construction company which specializes in driving piles.
Example—Garden Rake Step 1: What is the primary job that the customer is trying to do? The primary job is to gather debris in a garden. Step 2: What are the special circumstances under which this job is done? The special circumstances are to gather the debris over any type of ground or terrain. Step 3: What is a typical profile for this customer? The typical profile is a home gardener.
Example—Tape Dispenser Step 1: What is the primary job that the customer is trying to do? The end customer is typically trying to join two objects together. The majority of these objects are some form of paper or pulp products such as paper or cardboard. The manufacturer is trying to make a product that has a much 20
Base Problem and Constraints
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
higher value in the eyes of the end customer than the costs to manufacture it. Step 2: What are the special circumstances under which this job is done? The special circumstances for the end use of the product are the environment of the home or office. Step 3: What is a typical profile for this customer? The typical profile is a household member or office personnel of varying ages.
Example—Year-End Review Step 1: What is the primary job that the customer is trying to do? The customer is typically a manager who has the responsibility of measuring the performance of subordinates and motivating them through various incentives. Step 2: What are the special circumstances under which this job is done? The typical circumstances are in a typical office environment. Step 3: What is a typical profile for this customer? The typical profile is a business manager at varying levels of a company.
Clarify the Requirements Related to the Problem In this step we clarify how the market needs have been translated into product or service features and specific requirements related to the problem. Usually these have already been determined, but it is necessary to clarify these requirements here.
Example—Acid Container Define specific requirements of the system related to the identified problem. In this case, the acid corrosion system must handle all acids. It must contain 20 cubes measuring 1x1x1 inches. The whole system should cost less than $500 per year to maintain.
Example—Pile Driving Speed Define specific requirements of the system related to the identified problem. In this case, the cost of driving piles about $500/ hour. A typical pile takes 8 hours to drive in. The total cost related to waiting is $4000 per pile. We would like to reduce this to at least a quarter of the cost by driving the piles in less than 2 hours apiece. Base Problem and Constraints
21
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Garden Rake Define specific requirements of the system related to the identified problem. In this case, no more than one stroke should be required to collect all of the debris in the path of the rake. Typically three strokes are required.
Example—Tape Dispenser Define specific requirements of the system related to the identified problem. In this case, the tape dispenser must be capable of easily manipulating the tape end to extract the tape from the roll and segment it with simple movements of the hand. It is preferable, from a human factors view, that dispensing the tape should not distract the user from the main job that is being performed. Mishaps such as allowing the end of the tape to reattach to the roll should be minimized or eliminated. The act of segmenting the tape should be rapid and natural. The cost of the tape should be reduced by at least 25% of its current value.
Example—Year End Review Define specific requirements of the system related to the identified problem. The primary performance requirement that must be improved is the time taken to perform the review. It is expected that this be reduced by at least 50%. The typical review now takes 2.3 hours to perform, including data collection and all interviews. Roughly 40% of employees are highly irritated by the results of these reviews, whether the reviews are favorable or not. This percentage should not become worse. The primary measure of the review is whether the employee improves his or her performance over the coming year as a result of that which is discussed. This measure is currently 10%. This percentage should not become worse.
Clarify the Operating Environment The offering must deliver certain performance characteristics while working in a specified environment. Usually these have already been determined, but it is necessary to clarify these requirements here.
Example—Acid Container Define the environment in which this must be done. The cubes must be corroded in ovens held between room temperature and 340 degrees Fahrenheit. 22
Base Problem and Constraints
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Pile Driving Speed Define the environment in which this must be done. The piles are driven offshore in no less than 4 ft of water. The piles must be driven in inclement weather with waves up to 4 ft in height. There is no guarantee as to seabed hardness or the types of rocks, that will be encountered.
Example—Garden Rake Define the environment in which this must be done. The environment is the typical backyard. This type of rake in question is typically sold in home improvement stores.
Example—Tape Dispenser Define the environment in which this must be done. The environment is typically that found in a home or office. Temperature extremes are kept to a minimum. The tape dispenser usage can be from daily to yearly.
Example—Year End Review Define the environment in which this must be done. The environment is the typical office environment. Most reviews are held in a private location.
Clarify the Base Problem (Deviation from the Requirements) Having concluded that there is a problem or risk, we would like to capture this problem in a very short phrase that describes what we want to improve. We will use this for both the simplified causal analysis and the cause-effect charts. Let’s consider a situation where we are measuring the effect of acids on various metals. In order to investigate the corrosive effects of acid, we form cubes of the metal and place them in a container filled with acid and then heat them in an oven. After a period of time, the cubes are removed and studied. Unfortunately, the container that contains the acid becomes corroded and must be removed periodically. This operation is very expensive and we would like to reduce the cost of replacing the container. I could state the problem in long form: “The cost of replacing the container is high.” The improvement could be shortened to a single phrase: “Cost of replacement is high”. The improvement is the dependant variable in an important equation that we are about to write. In the six-sigma world, this is often referred to as the big Y. In summary, the big Y is the main disadvantage that we would like to improve. Base Problem and Constraints
23
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
In this step, we will put into practice what we have just talked about. We will isolate the main problem that we are dealing with by asking: What is the base problem? In truth, the base problem causes further problems or penalties, so we need to make a decision on how far we are going to drill down. This is a decision for the problem solver. We would like to have the problem at a level that most of the causes will be under our control.
Example—Corrosion of Acid Container Cubes are placed in warm acid to investigate the effect of various acids on the cubes. Unfortunately, the container that holds the acid and cubes is corroded. The container is made from gold and is very expensive to replace. Because the acid is so reactive and the test is performed often, the pan must be replaced frequently. Step 1: Identify the main parameter that must be improved. Y = Cost of Replacement Step 2: Write the base problem as a short statement. Usually this is stated as a knob and a setting. The cost of replacement is high.
Example—Pile Driving Speed The driving speed of piles is very slow. Often expensive equipment such as cranes or barges are rented to perform the work. Personnel must be on hand should anything go wrong. All of this adds up to great expense while driving the piles. None of this is necessary for the primary function of the piles. Step 1: Identify the main parameter that must be improved. Y = Driving Speed Step 2: Write the base problem as a short statement. Usually this is stated as a knob and a setting. The driving speed of the piles is low.
Example—Garden Rake Let us consider the situation of a common garden rake. When the rake is used to collect loose debris such as rocks and loose weeds over an uneven surface, a problem arises: The rake “leaks” some of the debris that is to be collected under the tines and several strokes are required to fully collect the debris. Step 1: Identify the main parameter that must be improved. Y = Leakage of Debris
24
Base Problem and Constraints
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: Write the base problem as a short statement. Usually this is stated as a knob and a setting. The leakage of debris is high.
Example—Tape Dispenser The cost to manufacture a common tape dispenser is too high to be competitive. Step 1: Identify the main parameter that must be improved. Y = Cost of Manufacture Step 2: Write the base problem as a short statement. Usually this is stated as a knob and a setting. The cost of manufacture is high.
Business Example—Year End Review The yearly performance review process is very time-consuming, especially when you have a large number of direct reports. Step 1: Identify the main parameter that must be improved. Y = Review Cycle Time Step 2: Write the base problem as a short statement. Usually this is stated as a knob and a setting. The review cycle time is high.
Clarify the Importance of the Penalties Because a problem is evident, it does not follow that it requires solving. We need to have an idea of how big this problem is to the market, business, mankind or nature. This is actually a very important step that is often missed by the problem solver. An effort is about to be started which may last for several months or years. A solution may be found, only to realize that nobody cares about the solution and there is little interest in implementing it. As stated previously, the base problem is one of the causes of this penalty. If we can solve the problem, the penalty should go away. We may conclude that this penalty is the base problem.
Example—Corrosion of Acid Container Step 1: Gather costs and penalties associated with these disadvantages. Yearly cost is $5000. Step 2: Is there a tangible demand for this system? Yes, there is a tangible demand. Step 3: Is there really an interested customer? Yes, there is an interested customer. Base Problem and Constraints
25
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 4: Is this problem worth pursuing? Yes, the problem is worth pursuing.
Example—Pile Driving Speed Step 1: Gather costs and penalties associated with these disadvantages. The cost of renting the equipment, fuel and wages is $1000 per pile Step 2: Is there a tangible demand for this system? Yes, there is a tangible demand. Step 3: Is there really an interested customer? Yes, there is an interested customer. Step 4: Is this problem worth pursuing? Yes,.
Example—Garden Rake Step 1: Gather costs and penalties associated with these disadvantages. The primary cost is in the time associated with doing a typical raking job and what % of the time is associated with re-raking an area. Currently, the re-raking time approaches 200% of the time normally associated with raking. Step 2: Is there a tangible demand for this system? Few people even realize that this problem exists. Step 3: Is there really an interested customer? This is highly debatable. Step 4: Is this problem worth pursuing? This is probably not worth pursuing except as an example problem for this book.
Example—Tape Dispenser Step 1: Gather costs and penalties associated with these disadvantages. 23,300,000 tape dispensers are manufactured and sold per year at a cost of 25 cents per dispenser. If the cost were reduced to 20 cents, the profit could be higher. This would save (.05)(23,3000,000) = $116,500. per year. Step 2: Is there a tangible demand for this system? Yes, there is a tangible demand. Step 3: Is there really an interested customer? Yes. Step 4: Is this problem worth pursuing? Yes
26
Base Problem and Constraints
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Business Example—Year End Review Step 1: Gather costs and penalties associated with these disadvantages. The yearly cost can be traced back to the time required to perform the reviews. Currently, it takes 3.5 hours of management preparation time per review. Two reviews are performed each year for 116,700 employees. The average cost per hour for managers is $125/hour. This comes to a total cost of (2)(3.5)(116,700)(125) = $102,112,500 per year. If this cost were reduced by 50% the savings would be $51,056,250. Step 2: Is there a tangible demand for this system? Yes. Step 3: Is there really an interested customer? Yes, there is an interested customer. Step 4: Is this problem worth pursuing? Yes, the problem is worth pursuing.
Clarify the Constraints on Solving the Problem The first requirement that we need to address are the business constraints on solving the problem. The clarification that we receive at this step will determine all else that we do! This is where we need to invoke some less-than-common sense and decide what we will limit ourselves to. Is this the type of problem that is of sufficient importance that we need to perform a full causal analysis? Or, will a simple one suffice. Should we seek to overhaul the system? Or should we simply fix what is already there with as little change is possible? Do we need twenty or thirty well evolved alternatives or is one good one sufficient? This is the step where we resolve these issues.
Example—Acid Container Step 1: How much time do we have to solve the problem? This is a yearlong research project. Step 2: What are our budget constraints? $50K Step 3: How many solutions alternatives are required? We want several good alternatives on this problem. Step 4: Will a simple causal analysis be sufficient? In this case, we will assume that a full causal analysis is warranted. Step 5: How much change to the system will we allow? In this case, we can allow a large amount of change to the system. A full overhaul may be sufficient so long as it simplifies everything. This is a long-standing problem that can be worked in the background and the impact is high on this small business. Base Problem and Constraints
27
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Pile Driving Speed Step 1: How much time do we have to solve the problem? 2 weeks. Step 2: What are our budget constraints? $5K Step3: How many solutions alternatives are required? alternatives are sufficient.
A few good
Step 4: Will a simple causal analysis be sufficient? A simple causal analysis will be sufficient. Step 5: How much change to the system will we allow? We will likely allow a medium change to the system. The costs of pile driving are significant, but the problem solvers are given little time to resolve the problem.
Example—Garden Rake Step 1: How much time do we have to solve the problem? This is a yearlong research project. Step 2: What are our budget constraints? $50K Step 3: How many solutions alternatives are required? We want several good alternatives on this problem. Step 4: Will a simple causal analysis be sufficient? In this case, we will assume that a full causal analysis is warranted. The company really needs a full overhaul of their rake product and it is long past due. Step 5: How much change to the system will we allow? In this case, we can allow a large amount of change to the system. A full overhaul may be sufficient so long as it simplifies everything. This is a long-standing problem that can be worked in the background and the impact is high on this small business.
Example—Tape Dispenser Step 1: How much time do we have to solve the problem? This is a quick-turn project that management wants an answer to in 3 weeks. Step 2: What are our budget constraints? $50 K is likely the constraint, but in this case, time will likely be the bigger issue. Step 3: How many solutions alternatives are required? A few good alternatives are sufficient. Step 4: Will a simple causal analysis be sufficient? A simple causal analysis will be sufficient. 28
Base Problem and Constraints
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 5: How much change to the system will we allow? We will likely allow a large change to the system so long as it simplifies everything.
Example—Year End Review Step 1: How much time do we have to solve the problem? Two weeks. Step 2: What are our budget constraints? No budget is available. Step 3: How many solutions alternatives are required? A few good alternatives are sufficient. Time is of the essence but the gain is hoped to be long lasting. Step 4: Will a simple causal analysis be sufficient? A simple causal analysis will be sufficient. Step 5: How much change to the system will we allow? We will likely allow a small change due to time limitations.
Base Problem and Constraints
29
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
30
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Causal Analysis All Solutions Address Causes How common is this situation? You are invited to a “brainstorming session”. Someone presents a problem and then suggests that everyone brainstorms solutions. This format is so typical that it is rarely questioned. Jumping straight from problem to solutions bypasses the very important step of identifying what is causing the problem. This is shortcutting a natural process because all solutions must ultimately address problem causes. There is no such thing as a solution which does not address problem causes. Once we deeply understand and believe this truth, we will never return to the old days of “brainstorming solutions”.
Identifying Causes Increase Solution Concepts Adding this step has another advantage: it increases the number of solution concepts. Since the typical problem has many causes, identifying and addressing these causes leads to multiple solutions. Conversely, if we do not consider the causes, it is more likely that we will focus on attributes that we are familiar with from our everyday work or life. We are trapped by our own psychological inertia. The curse of knowledge is that once we think we know something, it is easy to rely on this knowledge again and again. Let’s consider the problem of the acid container. If we were materials engineers, we could easily jump to the conclusion that we need to change the material of the container to one that is not affected by the acids or to one that is less inexpensive. This is only natural since that is what we are familiar with. Unfortunately, we are focusing on only one piece of the puzzle. When we ask what is causing the problem, we are forced to consider more than the familiar possibilities.
How Far Should We Allow Ourselves to Go? We have already answered this question to some degree, but it bears repeating. Remember when we reviewed related requirements? We also considered the constraints on the solution. We considered how much time we had; how much budget we had to work with; how many alternatives we needed to generate. So, we should have a fairly good idea how much rope we have to solve the problem. During problem solving, causal analysis and implementation need the most time. The actual time to come up with solution concepts is usually short. When it comes to performing a causal Causal Analysis
31
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
analysis, a full causal analysis can take a great deal of time. It may be necessary to perform experiments which can be very time consuming. If we have a very short fuse, or we are not that invested in the answer and just want to help someone out, we may perform a simple causal analysis. The final answer to this question is that it takes experience to know how far to go, but we can never be entirely certain that we have gone too far or far enough. There is no way to know for sure without following all solution paths.
“Root Cause Analysis” Some disciplines use the title “Root Cause Analysis”. The name “Root Cause” implies that if we keep asking “why”, we will eventually come to the root cause. For those who are six-sigma minded, remember that there is a difference between problems which are special-cause and those with common-cause. Special cause implies that the output of a process is outside of the control limits and is therefore highly unlikely. For these problems, we can often find a single root cause. However, for variation within the control limits there is a branching chain of causes. It is advisable to avoid the use of the term “Root Cause Analysis” when we are trying to understand a problem which is not special cause.
Different Forms of Causal Analysis There are several forms of causal analysis. It is common to see initiatives promoting one form or another. For instance, “Six-sigma” tends to promote process-centric (process maps) or modelcentric (statistical models) analysis. “Lean” initiatives tend to promote process-centric analysis. Most IR&D initiatives promote some form of model centric analysis which is built on physical, chemical or statistical descriptions. Numerous TRIZ software companies promote functioncentric analysis where the problem is described as a chain of interactions or functions. “FailureAnalysis” initiatives often promote Fault Trees which are attribute-centric forms of analysis. “Root-Cause” initiatives usually promote Why-Why analysis, Fishbone Diagrams or Fault Trees which are attribute-centric. Each of these forms of causal analysis has their place. They help to organize the problem and give insights into what is causing it.
Combining Different Forms Since each of the methods gives a different perspective of the problem, we will be using a combination of these methods. The combination will be referred to as a Cause-Effect Diagram. The basis of organizing this analysis will be a form of Attribute-Centric analysis similar to Fault Trees. The reason for this is that this form of analysis can be easily modified to show functions and contradictions that are central to understanding the causes of the problem. At each step of the diagram, we use models of the physics and process maps to guide us in our selection of attributes that branch. This form of analysis will also lead us to understand the alternative problem paths and why elements are required in the system. The combination of these methods will be more compact and more easily assimilated than their separate use. 32
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Contradictions The concept of resolving contradictions is one of the most useful and fundamental aspects of classical TRIZ. It is fundamental from the viewpoint of creativity because it greatly expands the solution space. Imagine that you need to fly a complex aircraft in which all of the control knobs and levers are fastened so tightly that you cannot move them. This is what many people feel like when they perform a causal analysis and discover the many knobs that would solve the problem if they could only be turned. Let’s consider a technical problem that illustrates what a contradiction is. If we would like to increase the carrying capacity of a vehicle, it is almost certain that we will need to increase its volume. Increasing the volume often increases the aerodynamic drag, thus expending more energy. This increased expenditure of energy costs more and requires more fuel and consequently more exhaust and pollution of the environment. Thus, we would like to increase the carrying capacity without increasing the cost of operation and without fouling the environment. We want to increase something without making something else worse. We have already mentioned that the knob we were trying to turn to improve the carrying capacity of the vehicle is the volume. Without explaining the exact method for how we got here, we can state the “whole contradiction” as follows: In order to carry lots of cargo, the volume needs to be large. In order to have low drag, the volume needs to be small. In classical TRIZ, the “Physical Contradiction” is contained within the contradiction statement and is as follows: The vehicle volume needs to be large and small. One way to remember the term “Physical Contradiction” is to realize that the attribute (volume) needs to have two opposing values. One might say “That’s physically impossible!” In reality, we will discover that doing both may be achievable, even when it may seem that we need to cheat physics in order to make it happen. In classical TRIZ, the “Technical Contradiction” is also contained within the contradiction statement and is as follows: While improving cargo size, drag gets worse. We will point out the physical and technical contradictions from time to time, but mainly refer to the whole contradiction as stated above. The whole contradiction helps us to understand the parameter that needs to have opposing values and it helps us to understand when the solution is good enough. We are usually tempted to compromise and make the volume larger but not “too large”. The problem with this thinking is that we now guarantee risk. Some days, the volume will be Causal Analysis
33
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
insufficient. If we are building the vehicle for public sale, we may find that the cost of operation is too high for some customers. In addition, we have created a risky situation that will be perpetuated for generations. Finally, in order to perform an artful compromise requires a lot of data and analysis. This can be time consuming. What we would like to do is to find a way to resolve the contradiction without compromising. When we learn how to do this, we will find that there are a lot more knobs that we can consider turning to solve problems. This skill is liberating to problem solvers who find that the solution space is much larger than they supposed.
Why is Exposing of Contradictions Necessary in Causal Analysis? It might be tempting to think that a causal analysis is complete when we understand the knobs and settings that are causing the problem, but it isn’t. Our understanding is incomplete until we understand why the knobs have been hard to turn. The normal tendency is think that most of the knobs are un-turn-able. In reality, they are merely difficult to turn. Additionally, some types of contradictions also alert us to alternative problems and their causes. These alternative problems can be solved in order to “bypass” the original problem. In summary, a causal analysis is not complete until it is understood why the knobs are difficult to turn. It is not complete until we understand the contradictions.
Benefits of Causal Analysis The benefits of a good causal analysis can continue for many product or service generations. The knowledge gained becomes a tremendous competitive advantage. One benefit of a thorough causal analysis is that sometimes we discover knobs that can be easily turned to solve the problem. This surprise can happen after many years of working a problem. Causal analysis is designed to find as many knobs as possible. The more knobs we discover, the more likely it is that we will also discover knobs that nobody has thought to turn before. When we first start a causal analysis, we are not certain about what is causing the problem; all we have is theories. The evidence is what ultimately establishes the truth of our theories. Before the evidence is available, we need guidance for where to look for existing evidence and what tests to run. A cause-effect diagram is an effective way to document our theories on what is causing our problem. This is especially important when working with teams of people. In summary, by the End of a Good Causal Analysis You Should Understand: —The knobs that cause the problem — How the knobs chain together —How the problem progresses in time —The contradictions that make the problem hard 34
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
—Alternative problems (Solve these instead) —How evidence matches theory
Obvious Solutions Having performed a causal analysis allows the problem solver to consider knobs that nobody has yet considered to turn. The more thorough the causal analysis, the more likely this will happen. In some cases a new knob can be easily turned without incurring any penalty. This is fortunate indeed and not that uncommon when a detailed causal analysis is performed. However, there is a caution. Some people perform a causal analysis to exclusively look for knobs that nobody has thought of. This ignores the multitude of knobs that could also be turned if it was only known how to resolve contradictions. Other solutions may be found after performing causal analysis that are not related to “easilyturned” knobs. On the other hand, simply understanding what is causing the problem may lead the problem solving team to rapid solutions.
Causal Analysis
35
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
36
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Clarify the Need for System Parts Before we jump into solving the problem, it is important to understand why each part of the subject system is required. Function modeling is useful for achieving this. It is interesting to note that most system objects are used to provide support to the main objects that do the actual work. Those parts that perform the actual work are more essential.
Draw a Function Diagram of the System Functional modeling is about objects and why they are required. The functional diagram gives a snapshot of all the elements and what they do without reference to time or sequence of operation. If you are not familiar with this subject, the appendix gives a more detailed description of working with functions.
Example—Acid Container Step 1: Break the system down into functional elements. At this point, do not include super-system elements. (This will be discussed in the next step). The functional elements of the cube corrosion system include the acid, oven and pan
Causal Analysis
Acid
Pan
Oven
37
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: Add SuperSystem elements and identify the system product. The SuperSystem elements in this case are the table, earth and cubes. The cube is the system product.
Acid
Table
Cubes
Pan
Oven
Earth
Step 3: Introduce Modification Links including useful, flawed and harmful links. Verify that all rules for forming functions have been followed (look in the appendix for this). Note that this time we have included the harmful function of pan corrosion. It is possible to discover system problems during this process because we consider the possibility of interactions between every element. Harmful and useful but flawed modification links should be included.
System Product
Useful
Harmful
Flawed
Pulls Earth
Acid
Corrodes
Cubes
Positions Corrodes Supports Table
Supports Oven
Pan
Example – Dispensing Tape Step 1: Break the system into functional elements. The functional elements of “tape dispensing” include the spindle, base, blade and person. Step 2: Add Super-System elements and identify the system product. You can tell which elements are super-system elements because you do not have the authority to eliminate super-system elements. They 38
Base
Person
Blade Spindle
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
may already exist in the environment, but you have no authority over their existence. Include only those super-system elements that interact with the system. One of these super-system elements is the system product. This is the element that the system modifies or serves. Blade The Super-System elements are the table and the tape. These elements Table interact with the system, Base but are not part of the system. The tape is the system “product”, which is a type of super-system element.
Tape
Person
Spindle
System Product
Step 3: Introduce Modification Links. Include useful, flawed and harmful links. Verify that all rules for forming functions have been followed. You can see the modification links in the figure below, e.g. the table supports the base, the spindle supports the tape and the person cuts the tape, though inconsistently. One curious function is that the tape holds itself. Recall that the tape adheres to itself as it comes off of the roll. While this might not seem clever, actually, it may have resolved a very difficult conflict at one time. Consider that an adhesive is fixed to one side of the tape. How do we move the tape about without it becoming stuck to everything in sight? How do we keep it from becoming contaminated with dust and dirt? A mediator is required to keep the tape safe. This mediator could have been supplied by some “foreign” material, but the idea of allowing the tape to protect itself satisfied the requirements, so long as the adhesive did not stick well to the opposite side of the tape. Additionally, this provides a convenient means of positioning the tape for the purpose of tearing. Following is the final function diagram of the tape dispensing system.
Holds Table
Spindle
Supports
Tape Positions
Supports
Supports
Cuts
Pulls/ Rotates
Supports Base
Blade
Person
Positions Causal Analysis
39
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Business Example—Year End Review The yearly performance review process is very time-consuming, especially when you have a large number of direct reports. Step 1: Break the system down into functional elements. The functional elements of the year-end review system include the manager, approval system reminder system and recording system. Step 2: Add super-system elements and identify the system product. No super-system elements are mentioned. The system product is the employee.
Manager
Tutorial System
Recording System
Reminder System
Manager
Tutorial System
Recording System
Employee
Reminder
System
Step 3: Introduce Modification Product System Links. Include useful, flawed and harmful links. Verify that all rules for forming functions have been followed. Human systems often have a number of interesting and surprising functions. Transaction systems, such as a checkout at a grocery store, are particularly interesting because they involve functions that we take for granted. When we ask what gets modified, it is often related to changed concepts in the mind such as who owns what. At a checkout line, for instance, the question of who owns the item changes from the store owning the item to the buyer owning the item. We say that we bought the item, but in reality the item never changes; only our concept of who owns it changes, both in the mind of the buyer and seller. In the case of the year end review, information is exchanged between the manager and the employee. We say that they inform each other. Both must contemplate, both before and after the review. This contemplation changes their perception of what has happened during the year and what is expected to happen the next year. In effect, both the manager and the employee change themselves. We could say that the manager motivates or de motivates the employee, but this would be misleading. The manager does not have direct power to do this. Information flows, and the employee then changes the “motivated” or “de-motivated” register in his or her mind. Creating this diagram reminds us that motivating the employee is the primary function of the system. We show these functions as flawed, harmful, useful or excessive depending on specific the situation at hand. In this case, we are showing an interview where the employee is poorly motivated. This could have been shown as a harmful or flawed function. 40
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Here it is shown as a flawed “contemplation” function. Following is the system function diagram.
Contemplates
Contemplates
Informs Manager
Informs
Employee
Organizes Explains Reminds Tutorial System
Reminds
Recording System
Reminder System
Exercise—Create a Functional Description of Your Choosing Create a Functional Description of a common item such as a toothbrush, a car or a musical instrument.
Causal Analysis
41
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
42
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Simple Causal Analysis For simple causal analysis or beginners, this method of causal analysis can be very illuminating. While it Y =f (X1, X2, X3…) is not rigorous in determining the chain of causes, it helps the problem solver focus on the contradictions and faulty functions. This method is particularly useful when you are in a classical brainstorming session, while relaxing in a chair or when a work colleague wants help with a problem. For many problems, this simple analysis is sufficient. Note that the simple causal analysis includes the consideration of functions and interactions. This may be a little advanced for the beginner but it is useful for advanced users that just want to use the simple analysis. Let’s take the pile driving problem as an example of how the simple causal analysis is performed.
Example—Pile Driving Speed The driving speed of piles is very slow. Often expensive equipment and personnel wait while driving progresses. How can the driving speed be improved?
Step 1: What are you trying to improve? This is written as a knob (object attribute) and a setting. In this case, the driving speed is slow.
Example—Pile Driving Speed Identify the main problem as a knob and a setting.
Driving Speed is Slow
Causal Analysis
43
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: Brainstorm the Knobs and Settings that
Driving Speed is Slow
Pile Diameter is Large
=f
Cause the Problem
Driver Mass is Low
Write these in a column as independent variables of the attribute that you are trying to improve. Each new attribute is also written as a knob and setting. The driving speed is slow because the pile diameter is large, the driver mass is low, the ground is hard and the pile is flexible, etc. Note that most of these are design parameters.
Step 3: Add Functions that Cause the Problem
Ground Hardness is Hard Pile Flexibility is Flexible
Driving Speed is Slow
=f
Driver Mass is Low
Notice that up to this point, we have only considered knob settings or attributes of the driver, the pile and the ground. There are also functions which cause the problem. The primary action in this instance is that the ground is pushing back on the pile. We can treat these functions in the same way that we treated knob settings. They may or may not cause a contradiction. The inclusion of functions is a little advanced for most beginners since functions are not taught in school. A beginner may skip this step until they are more experienced with the use of functions.
44
Pile Diameter is Large
Ground Hardness is Hard Pile Flexibility is Flexible
Functions
Ground Pushes the Pile
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 4: Turn the Knobs to Settings that Fix the Problem These are the opposite settings. Write this as a column next to the attributes that cause the problem. We must temporarily ignore what becomes worse when we turn the knob. Turn it far enough in our mind’s eye to solve the given problem (slow driving speed) for several product generations.
Driving Speed is Slow
Pile Diameter is Large
Pile Diameter is Small
Driver Mass is Low
Driver Mass is High
Ground Hardness is Hard
Ground Hardness is Soft
Pile Flexibility is Flexible
Pile Flexibility is Stiff
Ground Pushes the Pile
Ground Doesn’t Push the Pile
=f
Step 5: Form Contradictions We can now allow our critical self to suggest what we have been rebelling against all along. We Physical Contradictions
Driving Speed is Slow
=f
Breakage is High (Or Driving Depth is Deep)
Pile Diameter is Large
Pile Diameter is Small
=
Driver Mass is Low
Driver Mass is High
=
Breakage is High
Ground Hardness is Hard
Ground Hardness is Soft
=
Driving Depth is Deep
Pile Flexibility is Flexible
Pile Flexibility is Stiff
Ground Pushes the Pile
Ground Doesn’t Push the Pile
=
Pile Cost is High
=
Pile Support is Poor
Technical Contradictions Causal Analysis
45
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
need to identify what gets worse when we turn the knob far enough to improve the main parameter that we are trying to improve. Write what gets worse as another column. Note that the two middle columns give us physical contradictions. The pile diameter must be large and small; the driver mass must be high and low; the ground hardness must be soft and hard and the pile must be flexible and stiff. The last column, along with the parameter that we are trying to improve, gives us technical contradictions. While improving driving speed, breakage or depth of driving gets worse. While improving driving speed, breakage gets worse. While improving driving speed, driving depth becomes deeper. While improving driving speed the pile costs become high. This method illustrates the important point that technical contradictions are discovered in conjunction with physical contradictions. When the contradictions are created in this manner, it seems natural. This is in contrast to the classical ARIZ approach which requires the problem solver to work backward from a single technical contradiction and “unpeel the onion” to find the physical contradictions that cause it. The logic is incorrect and has slowed the development of ARIZ. This is one of the chief reasons that people find ARIZ difficult to learn. It is also the reason that it is difficult to apply to a new problem where the technical contradiction is not obvious. The moral here is to always start with a parameter that you would like to improve and then discover the attributes that control it. This will work on problems that you are familiar with and those that you are not. Note that some knobs may be turned and no problem arises. This is a good thing and one should not decide that they have done anything wrong. For instance, what if we increase the speed of the driver so that it lifts the mass back more rapidly? Nothing actually gets worse and the driving speed is greatly increased. While this type of solution is rare, a good job of causal analysis can often find these types of knobs. We might be tempted to immediately begin resolving contradictions. However, there is another tactic that we will explore next.
Step 6: Discover Alternative Problems Alternative problems are discovered by permanently turning any one of the knobs to the settings that fix the main problem. These knob settings are found in the 2nd column from the right. If we start with these permanent settings and do not attempt to resolve the physical contradiction then we have an alternative problem to the original problem. We need to somehow compensate for what we have done. For instance, let us assume that we have solved the primary problem of driving speed by using a small diameter pile. Now we have two alternative problems to solve. How can we improve breakage and how can we improve the support of the pile given a small diameter? Having two alternative problems to solve is not ideal. If we chose, instead, to increase the mass of the pile driver to solve the problem of slow driving speed then we have one 46
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
alternative problem to solve. How can we improve the breakage of the pile given a heavy driving mass? We will later consider how we may solve this problem by compensating. In other words, we fix one problem by turning a knob and then find another knob to turn to fix the problem that we have just solved. The simplified Causal Analysis is now complete. Notice that we have identified several knobs and settings that are causing the problem and also the reasons that these knobs are hard to turn. We have also identified a harmful interaction or function that occurs while driving. In further sections, we will look for ways to resolve the contradictions, compensate for the alternative problems and idealize the interactions that are causing problems.
Exercise—Corrosion of Acid Container Cubes are placed in warm acid to investigate the effect of various acids on the cubes. Unfortunately, the container that holds the acid and cubes is corroded. The container is made from gold and is very expensive to replace. Because the acid is so reactive and the test is performed often, the pan must be replaced frequently. Using what you know about corrosion, perform a simple causal analysis to identify some of the knobs, contradictions and alternative problems. Recall that “Cost of Replacement Is High” is the base problem.
Exercise—Garden Rake Let us consider the situation of a common garden rake. When the rake is used to collect loose debris such as rocks and loose weeds over an uneven surface, a problem arises: The rake “leaks” some of the debris that is to be collected under the tines and several strokes are required to fully collect the debris. Using what you know about raking, perform a simple causal analysis to identify some of the knobs, contradictions and alternative problems. Recall that “Debris Leakage Is High” is the base problem.
Exercise—Year End Review The yearly performance review process is very time-consuming, especially when you have a large number of direct reports. Using what you know about performance reviews, perform a simple causal analysis to identify some of the knobs, contradictions and alternative problems. Recall that “Review Cycle Time Is High” is the base problem.
Causal Analysis
47
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
48
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Basic Cause-Effect Diagrams The cause-effect diagram is an important tool for determining the knobs and settings that lead to the disadvantage. They help us to understand the relative importance of every cause. They expose underlying contradictions and help us to understand alternate problems to solve rather than the one we start with. In short, they help the problem solver to look at all sides of the problem. An additional benefit of cause-effect diagrams is that they help teams work together, even under emotional or contentious conditions. Once a team agrees on what is causing the problem, the course of action is clear. Consequently, the team is more likely to pull together. Also, the diagram will help to highlight the areas where team knowledge is lacking and data needs to be collected or test run. They also allow everyone a voice in understanding the problem. This can keep more vocal members from dominating the discussion. For many beginners, constructing a causal analysis diagram can be somewhat confusing. The confusion comes from applying unfamiliar rules and suggestions. These are given to keep the problem solver from falling prey to known pitfalls. Nonetheless, creating a cause-effect diagram can take considerable thought, the first few times that it is attempted. With each use, it becomes more intuitive and ultimately takes a small percentage of the total causal analysis time. Eventually, most of the time is spent in study, analysis, performing experiments, quantifying variables, observation and other activities. Not only do people become used to the rules, but most people will eventually personalize these diagrams to work better for them. The formats and software tools used to create them can vary widely. This is to be expected and actually encouraged. On the other hand, the fundamental rules should probably not be abandoned. The following sections will describe the rules and suggestions to create the basic diagram.
Causal Analysis
49
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
50
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Basic Rules to Construct Boxes Suggestion: Show the Base Problem as the Starting Box on the Causal Analysis Diagram The starting box can be placed anywhere on the diagram that you would like. Some people are used to making Fault Trees and like to start at the top. The author is used to starting at the bottom. Do what feels comfortable. Sometimes we can identify problems that are more basic than what we thought was the base problem. This is fine. Just put it further down the chain.
Example—Corrosion of Acid & Cube Container Start with the box showing the main problem. As we have already stated, the main problem is the high cost of replacing the corroded boxes. In our case, this will be located at the bottom.
Cost of Replacement is High
$5000/year
Rule: Every Box Shows a Knob and a Setting— Every Setting is “Bad” At the top of each box is a knob and setting (object attribute and the level of the attribute). Every box that is shown has a “bad” setting. In this case, the knob is “Cost of Replacement”. The setting is “High”. Note that this is a bad setting from the perspective of the problem solver. Some problem solvers become confused and start putting in good settings to indicate solutions. The solutions can be placed elsewhere on the diagram. Further confusion can be caused when people identify knob settings that they have always thought of as nominal. They don’t think of these settings as “bad”. However, if the knob could be turned could you make the base problem better or worse? If you could, then assume that the current nominal setting is “bad”. Causal Analysis
51
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Corrosion of Acid & Cube Container The knob is the cost of replacement of the container. The setting is High
Cost of Replacement is High
Setting = High
$5000/year
Rule: Quantify the Current Setting (If It is Known) We do this so that later, we can tell the relative importance of each parameter and to create the discipline to make the evidence self consistent.
Example—Corrosion of Acid & Cube Container In this case we see that the cost of replacement is $5000/year. Cost of Replacement is High
Quantify
52
$5000/year
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Determining Causes Chains of Cause—Decomposing Causes A simple approach to identifying causes is to brainstorm the causes from our experience. (As a reminder, we are not brainstorming solutions, but rather the causes). We can do this by thinking of the dependent variable that we are trying to improve as a mathematical function of several independent variables. Recall your high school algebra class: y = Cost of the Cost of the Activity of Cost /Year = f Container Container the Acid . . f(x1,x2,x3…). Let’s apply this Material functional thinking to the corrosion of the acid container. We brainstorm the independent variables as shown to the right. While this looks somewhat simple, this humble beginning can lead to useful solutions, as will be shown later.
(
Notice that some of the independent variables of the math function are dependent on each other. For instance, the cost of the container is dependent on the cost of the material. We can write the function in a form that takes into account the interdependencies. Consider the diagram to the right. The dependencies are now easily visible. This type of analysis creates a cause-effect chain of dependencies which relate back to the original problem.
Cost per Year is High
)
Frequency of Replacement is high
Cost per Replacement is High
Cost of the Container is high
Labor Cost is High
A further refinement comes when we recognize that every knob is associated with an interaction or function which causes the problem. The diagram at the right is a symbolic representation of a generic cause-effect chain. Each box in the chart represents a knob setting or a function which leads to the problem that we are trying to solve. Cause-Effect charts can be formed with the base problem at the bottom or the top or sides. The arrows signify the direction of causality. This is where we think in terms of causes. What variables and settings cause the problem? This is Causal Analysis
53
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
exactly what we did in the simplified causal analysis. Now we are going to put the knobs and settings into boxes and build a chain of causes. We will construct the diagram very carefully, concentrating on each box as we go. Every “cause” is the “effect” of something else. All Xs will eventually be considered as Ys. This could, theoretically, go on forever. We will only continue this until we reach causes over which we have little control.
Rule: Think in Terms of Equations or Models Y = f (X1, X2, X3…). The “effect” is the Frequency of Cost per dependent variable (Y) and the “causes” are the Replacement Replacement is High is High independent variables (X1, X2, X3…). Referring F Cr to the diagram shown, the effect “cost of 5 per year $1000 replacement” (Ct) is the dependent variable. We model what is happening with the equation Ct = F Cr. This means that the cost of replacement is a function of the “frequency of Cost of Replacement replacement” (F) times the “cost per is High replacement” (Cr). The Causes are placed in Ct = F Cr their own separate boxes. Note the direction of $5000 / year the arrows from the cause boxes to the effect box. The direction of the arrow indicates which boxes are the “causes” and which is the “effect”. As we move up, each cause will then be considered as an effect which has its own input causes.
Rule: All Causes are Assumed to be at the Worst Setting This may not be intuitive, but note that according to any equation, the outcome could be improved by changing the value of any variable, regardless of the value of the other variables. In the acid bath problem, making the frequency of replacement high or cost per replacement high drives the total cost to the worst possible condition. Note, in the above diagram, that we have continued to follow the previous rules by using a knob and a setting and by putting the level or setting of each knob at the bottom of the box. While it is not possible to put the whole diagram for this problem into this page, we continue in the diagram below, with this process to show how these rules are used to extend the causal analysis.
54
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rate of Corrosion is High
Pan Material is Gold
.0015 lbs/hr
Pan Plating Material Cost is Expensive
Amount of Material is High
$650/oz
1.52 oz
No equation here. This is simply a choice.
Hours of Use is High
Material Cost is High
Mc = E W $985
1500 Hrs
F = H / Rc
Frequency of Replacement is High
Cr = Lc + Mc
5 per year
Cost per Replacement is High
Labor Cost is High
$1000
$15
Cost of Replacement is High
Ct = F Cr $5000 / year
The value of thinking in terms of equations or models cannot be overemphasized. This makes it possible to find causes that nobody has considered before. When we find a cause, we have sown the seeds for a solution. One important class of solutions comes by turning the knobs and discovering that nothing gets worse. It is important to find the most knobs possible and thinking in terms of equations will help to identify many options that otherwise would not be considered.
Causal Analysis
55
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rule: If You Cannot Use an Equation, Think in Terms of Y = f (X1, X2, X3…) In order to write an equation, it is necessary to understand the “physics” of the problem. This is not an inborn skill for most people, but needs to be developed with practice and application. Models and equations are second-hand to most scientists and engineers due to their extensive training in “analysis”. To others, it is awkward and sometimes impossible. Helping people to think in terms of mathematical models is beyond the scope of this book, but it is possible to use causal analysis by using intuition. Even for engineers and scientists, it is not always possible to write an equation. Sometimes, the model is a complex simulation or the relationships are unknown. In either case, it is sufficient to “intuitively” identify the variables that we believe to be involved and their values. In other words: “If I could write an equation it would contain these variables…” However, there is a pitfall to doing this. It is easy (even for engineers and scientists) to fall back into the trap of brainstorming variables rather than looking for equations. If you do this, you will miss important parameters. Make it a habit of developing models and simple equations where possible.
Rule: Highlight Important Branches And Abandon Branches of the Diagram that Have Little Effect If we know the values of the object attributes (parameters levels or knob settings) and record these values within the boxes, we now can compare various legs of this cause-effect chart to determine which legs are not worth pursuing. For instance, the affect of the acid on the container may not be affected much by the cost of labor when compared to the cost of the actual container. If we do not know the values of the object attributes, we may need to seek out data or perform screening tests in which only one variable is changed at a time. These tests will further help in understanding the relative importance of each knob. Note from the above diagram that reducing the labor cost below $15 dollars will have little effect compared to the $985 material costs. There is no need to continue to develop this leg of the diagram. The diagram shows this crossed out. Branches that are important can be highlighted in some manner to show where to focus. I like to use thick arrows. If we could always identify a branch as being unimportant in the beginning, there would be no need to highlight any particular branch. Usually this is determined at some point further up the branch so we need some way to identify important branches. In the acid 56
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
container diagram, all of the branches are important except the one that is crossed out. Personalize the diagrams in ways that help you to see the important branches.
Suggestion: Consider Putting Models into the Diagram For convenience, large models can sometimes be written into the tools which contain the diagrams. It is possible to convert Microsoft Excel into a more powerful flow charting tool by making boxes with more attachment points and using the connectors from the AutoShapes toolbar. Now it is possible to put the mathematical models directly into the sheets. It is even possible to make the results of the calculations update the values in the boxes of the causal analysis. Another feature of Excel is that you can break up the diagram into sheets and link between the sheets to navigate around the diagram. It is the author’s opinion that using common software tools such as Microsoft Excel are preferred over flowcharting tools because they are found everywhere. Anybody can open such a file to view or modify it, making it much more transportable. This can help when deploying TRIZ in large companies.
Causal Analysis
57
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
58
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Discovering Contradictions Now we come to one of the most powerful aspects of causal analysis diagrams, discovering the contradictions that are holding back the system development. Many people ask how to reveal contradictions in their systems. This is a very effective and efficient way, especially if the problem is complex or “tangled” or if we have never encountered it before. A good causal analysis is incomplete without a good understanding of the contradictions. We will show that there is a relatively simple systematic approach to accomplish this.
Rule: Turn the Knobs as You Go When we identify a new box with a knob and setting, we should ask ourselves each time “What happens if I turn the knob to the opposite setting? Does something else get worse?” We do this by mentally placing a box by the side of the box that we are considering and showing the opposite setting in the box. If something gets worse, we draw an arrow from the box to a new box showing what gets worse. We could have done this as we built the diagram beginning with the very first box. We could have asked “If the cost of replacement is low, does something else get worse?” In this case, nothing gets worse and we move on and do not physically draw the box that we were contemplating. Because something does not get worse when we turn a knob does not mean that there is no contradiction, it only means that the contradiction is implied. There is, at least, an implied physical contradiction for each box. The reason that we do not show them is that the diagram is more compact when they are not shown. Here is what the diagram would look like if the implied knobs were turned and we left the boxes (minus the equations and a couple of boxes to save space).
Causal Analysis
59
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rate of Corrosion is Low
Rate of Corrosion is High
Pan Plating Material Cost is Inexpensive
.0015 lbs/hr
Hours of Use is Low
Pan Plating Material Cost is Expensive
Amount of Material is High
$650/oz
1.52 oz
Material Cost is Low
Hours of Use is High
Time to Corrode through is low
$985
1500 Hrs
Cube Production is Low
Material Cost is High
Amount of Material is Low
Frequency of Replacement is High
Frequency of Replacement is Low
5 per year
Cost per Replacement is High
Cost per Replacement is Low
$1000
Cost of Replacement is High
Cost of Replacement is Low
$5000 / year
Notice that only two of the contradictions show something getting worse. When the amount of material is low, the time that it takes to eat through the material is low. Also, if the hours of use are low, then we must process fewer cubes. The rest are implied contradictions that will not be shown in the future. Most people familiar with classical TRIZ would be only looking for contradictions where something gets worse. While contradictions where nothing becomes worse may not be familiar, it is presents an opportunity to create solution concepts. It may be possible to resolve the contradiction “The cost of replacement is high and low”. We will not know until we try. When we get to the section on contradictions, we will explore the different types of contradictions in more depth. 60
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
There is a natural eagerness to turn some knobs and a reluctance to turn others. This tendency limits us in the range of solutions that are possible. Let’s take a closer look at different types of knobs. Type 1: Easily Turned. With this knob, there is full control of the dependent variable and nothing gets worse when it is changed to the Driver Power required level. These are the knobs that most people are looking for when they perform causal analysis. Turning these knobs makes for great solutions, but they are usually rare in legacy problems. They are found because someone has taken the time to dig into the physics and perform a thorough causal analysis. They may have also been found by applying the Table of Knobs or “Relative To” tools. In our pile driver problem, it may be possible to increase the driving speed by increasing rate of striking the pile. In order to make this happen, we will likely need to increase the power of the driver. It is possible to increase the power without changing the striking momentum. For instance, we can greatly reduce the cycle time between strikes by increasing the power. Type 2: Little Effect. Turning these knobs through the full range of possibilities has little effect. These knobs are usually not worth considering because they have little bearing on the problem. In this case, the color or temperature of the pile will have little effect on the driving speed.
Color or Temperature of the Pile
Type 3: Something Else Gets Worse. Changing these knobs degrades another important attribute. These are your typical problems where people feel obliged to compromise. For these types of problems, a Technical Contradiction is present. In this case, making the pile sharper may improve the driving speed, but the pile is less able to bear the final Pile load if it were driven to the same depth. It is likely that the pile would Sharpness have to be driven further, thus removing the advantage we thought that we had gained in driving time. The contradiction is stated: the pile must be sharp in order to drive faster and it must be blunt in order to support vertical loads. Pile Damping Type 4: Difficult to Turn. With these knobs, it is not apparent how to turn them. No known physical phenomenon can be found, or so many knobs must be turned at once that it appears impossible. In this case, we may realize that the damping of the pile is an important factor in the driving speed. If the pile damping is high, a lot of energy is lost to heating the pile while it is being driven, thus reducing the energy available to make it drive faster. While we recognize that this is an important parameter in driving, we may not have the Causal Analysis
61
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
experience or knowledge necessary to identify a means for changing this important parameter. This knowledge may be available in another industry. Type 5: Only One Flavor or Setting. This knob cannot be turned Pile because it has only one setting. The most typical way that this Diameter happens is that an element is simply off limits for change. Perhaps you are working with a customer part and the customer has demanded that it remain unchanged to perform will with the customer’s processes. Let’s assume, in this case, that there is an artificial restriction placed on the diameter of the pile. When we form the contradiction, we will say that the pile diameter must be small in order to drive fast and it must be large because it only comes in that diameter. This is not the typical contradiction discussed in classical TRIZ literature. The pile diameter causes a problem. Problems of changing the diameter are not even considered. The change of diameter is simply not allowed. Type 6: Highly Variable Knobs. This knob cannot be turned because it is so highly variable that you never know what setting it will be at. In this case we never know Ground from day to day, or in some instances from pile to pile what the Hardness ground hardness will be. Most people are reluctant to consider changing this knob or forming a contradiction. You will note that when we come to identifying the contradictions that it is not out of bounds. While it is true that this appears to be more complicated, do not forget that there are a variety of tools at our disposal for solving these types of contradictions. Type 7: Outcome Knobs. This knob cannot be turned because it is a dependent variable and dependent on other knob settings. We are going to consider turning this knob without changing any identified dependent variables. In this case, we are going to consider changing the driving speed Driving without changing any of the dependent variables that affect it. At Speed first, this may appear illogical, but the contradiction which follows will help to explain why we do this. The driving speed must be high in order to save time and expenses. The driving speed must be low because I am not going to change any of the independent variable that affects the speed. In effect, I am saying that the driving speed must be slow and fast. As we will come to see, every box in the causal analysis diagram is a candidate for solution. We are already considering the independent variables in other boxes that input to the outcome knob. This allows us to form a contradiction for the outcome knob alone. Novel solutions will become available when we consider this. These last four knobs “something gets worse” “don’t know how to turn” “one flavor” “highly variable” and “outcome” are the least likely to be turned, but turning them often allows us to find very satisfying but unconventional solutions. We cannot say that turning every knob will solve 62
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
our problem. But, we cannot discount a knob because it does not suit our taste. We need to learn how to turn each type of knob.
Rule: Turn the Knobs Far Enough to Fix the Main Problem Some objections stop people from turning knobs as far as they should. Most would rather turn the knob part way and compromise. Unfortunately, compromise guarantees risk and leaves the problem to be solved later. We must turn the knob far enough to fix the primary problem. So, if a little medicine is good, then shouldn’t a lot of medicine be even better? We ask “why not be even more extreme?” While extreme thinking can be good, it can also get one into trouble on occasion. It is possible to excessively perform a function and suffer other problems as a result. The answer is to turn the knob sufficiently to solve the problem for several product generations. While this may not be an entirely satisfying answer, it comes to the heart of the problem of system evolution. Systems evolve because their needs change. What was excellent performance 5 generations ago may now be considered poor performance. We don’t want to address this problem again for several product generations.
Consider Extreme or Unusual Settings from the Table of Knobs On the other hand, our knob turning skills may not be as good as we think. There is often more than one way to turn a knob. We might have missed some knob-turning possibilities. The Table of Knobs (Attributes) gives a number of extreme or unusual knob settings to consider.
Example—Pile Driving Go to the Table of Object Attributes (Knobs) and consider extreme conditions for the object attributes that you have chosen. Having looked at the table, we might have considered the use of voids. The extreme case of this is many voids that allow for good driving, but later as the soil settles, it interlocks with the pile giving high load carrying capabilities.
Causal Analysis
63
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rule: Requirements Are Not Caused By Anything—Develop Alternative Problem Paths While setting up a cause-effect diagram, we will ultimately come to object attributes (knobs) which are not “caused” by anything. This may be a design parameter such as the length of something, or it may be that this attribute only comes in one “flavor”. A design parameter does not have a cause. The reason for the knob setting is because we chose it. There may be very good reasons for the settings we have chosen. In many cases the design parameter is required because if it does not have that setting, something else gets worse. We can think of this setting as a “requirement”. Neither design parameters nor requirements have causes. It makes no sense to look for a “cause” for these variables. We chose the setting because we realized that if it did not have that setting something else would get worse. Unfortunately, this setting also causes our main problem. In this type of contradiction, when we improve the main problem by turning the knob, something else gets worse. We can express the thing that gets worse by introducing an adjacent box showing the setting that would fix the original problem. This new box then causes an alternate Alternative Problem problem. This alternative Path problem path is illustrated to the right by the added boxes. Whenever we see the double boxes, we know that we have a contradiction and an alternative problem path. The alternative problem means that if we choose the knob setting that fixes the base problem, then we are left with the alternative problem. We can solve this alternative problem in a variety of ways, including compensation. For instance, the high reactivity of the acid is one of the causes of the corrosion. If it is not high, the cubes take longer to corrode. “High acid reactivity is a requirement”. We show this with a double box having the opposite value. This opposite box starts an “alternate problem” path. The implication is that if the reactivity of the acid were low (in order to help corrosion), we would need to solve a new problem having to do with a slow corrosion rate of the cubes. Alternate problems are an important part of all causal analysis diagrams. They show us what is getting worse when we try to improve something. In classical TRIZ, this is referred to as a technical contradiction. While improving the corrosion rate of the pan, the corrosion of the cubes gets 64
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
worse. This double box is the expression of a “physical contradiction”. The acid needs to have low reactivity and high reactivity. The “whole contradiction” can be stated: the reactivity of the acid must be low in order to not corrode the pan and it must be high in order to corrode the cubes. Because we start with something that must be improved and finding the things that it is a function of, when we go to solve the problem (by turning the knob) something else gets worse. This is identical to the method that we used in the simple causal analysis. When we turned the knob, something got worse, thus exposing the technical contradiction. Once again, we should note that the technical contradiction was formed by discovering the physical contradiction. This is different than is usually described in ARIZ or classical TRIZ where the technical contradiction is first found and then “unpeeled” to discover physical contradictions. This logic is not correct and has been a stumbling block for many years, retarding the development of ARIZ. Using any form of causal analysis which illuminates the “whole” contradiction and then resolving the contradictions through the many methods available is much more powerful than following ARIZ. Perhaps this will be recognized and rectified in future versions of ARIZ. Below is the diagram with a few new causes. Three physical contradictions, technical contradictions and alternative problem paths are shown. Only the top one is highlighted. The beginning of each alternate problem path is always a physical contradiction. (There is another contradiction with the pan material being made of gold. The material might have been some more exotic corrosion resistant material which would have cost even more. While this is true, it will not be addressed here for brevity). Note the double boxes (physical contradictions). Further development of the highlighted alternative problem would consider all of the causes which cause the rate of corrosion of the cubes to be low. The alternative problem path should be developed in the same manner as the original problem and with the same diligence. When the diagram is finished, it may look like we were trying to solve five different “main” problems at the same time. This is just fine because a powerful possibility is created: we may discover that multiple problems (more than two) may be solved by resolving one contradiction. These contradictions are “lynch pins”. When they are solved, everything changes. Understanding the alternative problem paths and the technical contradictions that cause them allows us to see more sides of the problem. Below is the diagram with three technical contradictions or alternative problem paths added. We have not discussed two of them. If we allowed the hours of use to be low then we would have to deal with the alternative problem of how to increase productivity of corroding the cubes. If we allowed the pan material to be of minimal amount, to reduce the cost when it corroded, then we would have to deal with the alternative problem of short time to corrode through the pan. Causal Analysis
65
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Physical Contradiction Existence of Contact
Reactivity of Acid is High
Reactivity of Acid is Low
Rate of Corrosion of Cubes is Low
Technical Contradiction Alternative Problem Rate of Corrosion is High
Pan Material is Gold
Pan Plating Material Cost is Expensive
.0015 lbs/hr
Hours of Use is Low
Amount of Material is High
1.52 oz
Material Cost is High
Hours of Use is High
Mc = E W
Frequency of
F = H / Rc
Time to Eat Through is Low
$985
1500 Hrs
Production of Cubes is Low
Amount of Material is Low
Replacement
Cost per Replacement
Cr = Lc + Mc
Labor Cost is High
is High
is High 5 per year
$1000
Cost of
$15
Abandoned Leg
Replacement
is High
Ct = F Cr $5000 / year
This concludes the construction of the basic causal analysis diagram. Practice and familiarity will help to prepare you for the more advanced diagrams that follow. It is suggested that several diagrams be constructed and used. This will make the following section more meaningful.
66
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Exercise—Pile Driving Speed The driving speed of piles is very slow. Often expensive equipment such as cranes or barges is rented to perform the work. Personnel must be on hand should anything go wrong. All of this adds up to great expense while driving the piles. None of this is necessary for the primary function of the piles. Using what you know about driving stakes, create a basic cause-effect diagram to identify some of the knobs, contradictions and alternative problems. Recall that “Pile Driving Speed Is Slow” is the base problem.
Exercise—Garden Rake Let us consider the situation of a common garden rake. When the rake is used to collect loose debris such as rocks and loose weeds over an uneven surface, a problem arises: The rake “leaks” some of the debris that is to be collected under the tines and several strokes are required to fully collect the debris. Using what you know about raking, create a basic cause-effect diagram to identify some of the knobs, contradictions and alternative problems. Recall that “Debris Leakage Is High” is the base problem.
Exercise—Year End Review The yearly performance review process is very time-consuming, especially when you have a large number of direct reports. Using what you know about performance reviews, create a basic cause-effect diagram to identify some of the knobs, contradictions and alternative problems. Recall that “Review Cycle Time Is High” is the base problem.
Causal Analysis
67
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
68
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Advanced Cause-Effect Diagrams So far, our focus with cause-effect diagrams has been to show how object attributes or knobs and their settings can lead us to understand contradictions and alternative problems. This is very useful but also somewhat narrow. Focusing on knobs, alone, does not drive us to consider alternative systems which use different objects to perform their main functions. In other words, the resulting solutions will tend to evolve the current system. This can be somewhat limiting, especially if the team is allowed the luxury of changing the system to a greater degree. Here we will consider additions to the basic causal analysis diagrams that will prepare us to make larger system changes. We will also add some new features that will aid less involved team members to understand these diagrams.
Adding Functions Most Problems can be traced to useful objects that do not perform their function as well as they should or also cause harm. What are these objects? The cause-effect diagram can be used to illuminate these objects with their attending functions and the object parameters which connect these functions. Another way to think of this is that we are going to link together flawed functions through their object attributes. Functions focus our minds on how parameters change with time. One could ask “why is maintaining this oven so expensive?” The answer to this question is “The pan is corroded by the acid and needs to be replaced”. The corrosion of the pan takes place in time. This answer describes two functions. The acid is corroding the pan and the pan is being replaced. Notice that neither of these two “causes” has shown up on the diagram yet. Everything that we have accomplished to this only point implies that a function is involved. Causal Analysis
69
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
A second reason that we need to include functions is that this focuses our minds on the objects and physical phenomena that are involved and why they are required. This is particularly important when trying to discover the knobs or independent variables associated with the dependent variable. Each object in the function has features or knobs that control the dependent variable under investigation. It is easy to forget that these knobs exist if we have forgotten that the associated objects aren’t a part of what is going on.
Rule: Adding Functions Functions are added by asking which dependent variables are changing or controlled with time. These elements would typically not be design parameters or parameters that are fixed or constant (unless they are controlled). They are changed or controlled by something else. If a dependent variable is changing with time or is a measure of change with time, then a function is involved. In the above diagram we note that the rate of corrosion of the pan and the cubes are measures of change. This tells us that we need to have two functions. The other parameters are relatively constant, so we will not require functions for them. We insert the function by mentally sliding the dependent variable downward, thus creating a space for the function. The function is then inserted in the space that the dependent variable occupied. Let’s consider the function related to the rate of corrosion. First, we slide down the box associated with the rate of corrosion being high. Existence of Contact
Reactivity of Acid is High
Pan Material is Gold
Slide down
Rate of Corrosion is High
.0015 lbs/hr
70
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
We then insert the function associated with the dependent variable and its associated independent variables.
Existence of Contact
Acid
Reactivity of Acid is High
Pan Material is Gold
Corrodes Pan
Rate of Corrosion is High
.0015 lbs/hr
Later, we will attack these functions, individually, when we go to solve the problem. We will “idealize” them. In other words, we will be questioning what the elements of our system do. We will consider removing or replacing elements or having them take on other functions. The net effect is to solve the problem and simplify the system at the same time. Let’s add applicable functions to our causal analysis of the acid and cubes problem. This is how it looks (note that some of the diagram has been rearranged to make room).
Causal Analysis
71
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Existence of Contact
Reactivity of Acid is high
Reactivity of Acid is Low
Acid
Corrodes Cubes
Acid
Pan Material is Gold
Pan Plating Material Cost is Expensive
Rate of Corrosion of Cubes is Low
Corrodes Pan
$650/oz
Rate of Corrosion is High
Hours of Use is High
.0015 lbs/hr
1500 Hrs
Amount of Material is High
1.52 oz
Material Cost is High
$985
Mc=E W Frequency of Replacement is high
Cr = Lc + Mc
5 per year
Cost per Replacement is High
Labor Cost is High
$1000
$15
Abandoned Leg
F = H / Rc Cost of Replacement is High
Ct = F Cr $5000 / year
72
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Adding Pictures The author has found that teams which are untrained in the use of cause-effect diagrams can come up to speed very quickly and make important contributions if they can just become engaged. Creating a causal analysis diagram can build a shared understanding of a problem that will unify a team making them far more effective.
Suggestion: Draw Pictures in the Boxes. While it is not absolutely necessary to perform this step, it is very helpful when working with teams. Adding graphics to the diagram helps group members to participate and follow it easily. Without such graphics, the uninitiated reader will usually fall asleep before you can finish the story. Drawing pictures helps team members to follow what is happening, even if they do not have a deep understanding of the physics behind the analysis.
Causal Analysis
73
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Existence of Contact
Reactivity of Acid is high
Reactivity of Acid is Low
Acid
Corrodes Cubes
Acid
Pan Material is Gold
Pan Plating Material Cost is Expensive
Corrodes
$$
Pan
Rate of Corrosion is High
$650/oz
Hours of Use is High
Amount of Material is High
G
old
.0015 lbs/hr
Rate of Corrosion of Cubes is Low
1500 Hrs
1.52 oz
Material Cost is High
$Mat $985
Mc=E W Frequency of Replacement is high
Cr = Lc + Mc
Cost per Replacement is High
$
5 per year
$1000
Labor Cost is High
$Lab $15
Abandoned Leg
F = H / Rc Cost of Replacement is High
Ct = F Cr
$
$5000 / year
74
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Determine Why Elements Are Required One of the most important features of this type of causal analysis is that you can determine why elements of the system are required. A high percent of elements in almost any system have supporting functions. These supporting functions are usually required because something isn’t doing its job in the system. In other words, these auxiliary functions “solve” a problem that the system would otherwise have without them. By using the following causal analysis technique, it is possible to trace back to the original problem. If we can solve the problem in another way, it may be possible to remove the need for elements in the system. In other words, we solve the problem and simplify the system at the same time. Following are the steps for achieving this.
Rule: Show Existence of the Product and Tool as Knobs Adding the functions reminds us of the elements that are involved in determining the interactions and hence, the equations. In this case, we show existence of the pan and the acid. (In order to save space, the existence knobs will not be shown for the other function). When we look at the functions in the Causal Analysis diagram, it helps remind us that existence is yet another measurable parameter of the tool and product of a function.
Causal Analysis
75
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Acid Exists
Existence of Contact
Reactivity of Acid is High
Reactivity of Acid is Low
Acid
Corrodes Cubes
Pan Exists
Acid
Pan Material is Gold
Corrodes
$650/oz
Hours of Use is High
Amount of Material is High
G
old
.0015 lbs/hr
Rate of Corrosion of Cubes is Low
$
Pan
Rate of Corrosion is High
Pan Plating Material Cost is Expensive
1500 Hrs
1.52 oz
Material Cost is High
$Mat $985
Mc=E W Frequency of Replacement is High
Cr = Lc + Mc
Cost per Replacement is High
$ 5 per year
$1000
Labor Cost is High
$Lab $15
Abandoned Leg
F = H / Rc Cost of Replacement is High
Ct = F Cr
$
$5000 / year
76
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rule: Show Causes for Existence (If Applicable) In our acid/cube example, we do not have an example of this rule. We do not concern ourselves where the acid or the pan comes from because this is not an important part of the causal analysis. We will temporarily consider another example. Abrasive wear is occurring on a bicycle chain
Air
Wear Load is High
Existence of Contact
Movement is High
Moves Dust
.02 Mile/Hr 3 lb
Dust Exists
Dust Wears Chain
Rate of Wear
Wear Coefficient is High .0003 lbm/lbf/mile
Chain Exists
Is High
.0015 lbs/hr
because of dust. The existence of the dust is one knob that is causing the problem. (We were reminded of this fact when we inserted the function.)
Rule: Turn Existence Knobs to Non-Existence When we turn existence knobs to non-existence, there will be consequences. This begins an alternative problem path. This path will show us why the element is required in the system. This will be important when we consider solutions. Most elements are required because something else in the system is not doing its job or because useful elements also create harm. Causal Analysis
77
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
It may be possible to remove elements if the need for them disappears. Solving a problem elsewhere in the system can remove the need for many elements. Below is the modified causal analysis. The right side is not shown to conserve space.
78
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Acid Doesn’t Exist
???
Acid Exists
Existence of Contact
Reactivity of Acid is High
Corrodes
Cubes
Corrosion of Cubes is absent
Pan Doesn’t Exist
Pan Exists
Acid
Pan Material is Gold
Corrodes Pan
Earth Pulls Acid
Force of Gravity is High
Rate of Corrosion is High
Hours of Use is High
.0015 lbs/hr
1500 Hrs
Frequency of Replacement is High Cubes
???
5 per year
Positions
Position
F = H / Rc Acid
Acid
Cost of Replacement is High Location of Acid is ineffective or harmful
Causal Analysis
Ct = F Cr Acid
$
$5000 / year Position
79
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rule: Identify the Problem That Made the NonExisting Elements Necessary Note that we have removed the tools from some of the function diagrams and replaced them with “???”. This is to indicate that the removed element performed a missing function. The primary function of the pan was not just to contain the acid, but rather to position the acid relative to the cubes. This function could have been performed by other means. The process of identifying elements and then removing them to see what happens continues until we can see the chain of causes for why elements are required. Along the way, we discover that some elements exist to prevent or remediate harm. We may discover that an element is required because something performs a function, but does it too weakly to be useful. In this case, the earth (through gravity), the cubes, and the acid are weakly positioning the acid. Note that the acid on top of the cubes is mostly positioned by the cube rather than the pan. If any cubes were not immersed, small pools of acid on top of the cubes would be positioned without the aid of the pan. If the force of gravity were extremely low, the acid would locate itself (through surface tension) around the cubes. We can state this more directly. The pan is required to position the acid because the cubes, gravity and the acid are not doing their jobs! Now that this element is gone, we have illuminated the possibilities for other elements in the system or super-system to perform the missing function. We may also be able to compensate for the lost function by turning a knob elsewhere. In any case, we open the possibility of solving our problem by removing or replacing elements or solving a problem elsewhere in the system.
Rule: Most of the Work is in the Thinking Some people ask “Why is constructing a diagram so important? I already know this stuff.” My experience is that the organization of what we know is very valuable. Most subject matter experts have this information floating around in their minds in unconnected ways. Typically, they are not thinking in terms of contradictions and alternative problem paths. It is precisely because we think about a subject often that we create familiar routes of thinking. The more expert a person is on a given subject, the more likely they are to assume certain things. What we assume is called paradigms. They are mental ruts that are difficult to extract ourselves from. Organizing our thinking, ironically, allows us to question these assumptions. Note that we challenge assumptions by identifying the contradictions, alternative problem paths and questioning why objects are required in our system. This brings up a final warning about creating these diagrams. It is worth the time to make sure that the logic of the diagram is very precise. One should be able to go through the diagram and feel that there are no missing branches. Missing a branch eliminates a number of solution 80
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
possibilities. Impeccable logic creates trust in the team that they are working on the most important aspects of the problem. This concludes the description of how to construct an advanced causal analysis diagram. There is much more to doing a good causal analysis than constructing a diagram. The bulk of the time will be spent away from the diagram, creating models, thinking about what is causing the problem, understanding the physics and performing tests. What we learn is eventually incorporated into the diagram.
Exercise—Pile Driving Speed Continue the basic cause-effect diagram and add functions and pictures and determine why troublesome elements are required in the system.
Exercise—Garden Rake Continue the basic cause-effect diagram and add functions and pictures and determine why troublesome elements are required in the system.
Exercise—Year End Review Continue the basic cause-effect diagram and add functions and pictures and determine why troublesome elements are required in the system.
Causal Analysis
81
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
82
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Investigating Cause Now that we have a good system for organizing our causal analysis, we will spend some time talking about the actual investigative work. These activities usually occur away from the causal analysis diagram and represent the majority of the time in causal analysis. Having a causal analysis diagram is not the goal. Actually going through the thinking and really understanding the causes of the problem is the goal. There are many pitfalls to performing a good causal analysis. It takes time and experience to become skillful investigators. Following are some suggestions for performing a thoughtful and thorough causal analysis.
Collecting Evidence If a subject matter expert is not available and the problem is not well understood, finding the cause and effect relationships can be very time consuming. Be prepared to dig into the physics and perform the necessary experiments.
Observe the Situation Firsthand The Cause-Effect process begins with a thorough look-over of the system. While this may appear obvious to some, it is amazing how often the author has skipped this step, only to be embarrassed later by someone who performs this step and notices some important, but obvious fact about the situation.
Causal Analysis
83
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Catch It in the Act Method Step 1: Devise an experiment to watch the interactions. Consider slow motion, etc. Step 2: Use redefine informing functions to find ways to look at what is happening (copies, etc.)
What’s Left Behind There is still data to collect, though the experiment has been run. Much is evidence is left behind. Sometimes how we look is the greatest invention of all.
Method Observe all pieces of the product thoroughly Look for “witness marks” of what happened Investigate microscopically Take pictures and/or draw what you see. Drawing will force you to see more than you normally do. Carefully compare what you are drawing to the actual object. Look for discrepancies. Consider measuring properties of the object such as resistance, density and hardness. Look For Discrepancies
Method Step 1: Compare the results with the expected outcome of the model. Step 2: Look for outliers Step 3: Determine whether these are artifacts of the measuring system or if they are really trying to tell you something.
84
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Negative Evidence Negative Evidence is an observation of what did not happen and where the problem does not occur. It is especially important to consider this under conditions where we expected things to happen. For example, cancer eventually leads to cells traveling to adjacent organs. But you never hear of cancer of the heart or the muscles. So what is the mechanism that prevents metastasis to these organs? The negative questions give rise to thinking that might not arise otherwise.
Method Step 1: What does not happen that would normally happen? Step 2: What continues to behave normally that should not? Step 3: Where does this problem not occur in my system…and why? Step 4: What is not there that we usually expect?
Crime Scene Analysis Method Step 1: Examine all objects carefully under magnification (microscope or magnifying glass) or with the best tools available for causal evidence Step 2: Draw what you see at macro and micro level. Try to use good art technique such as shading and perspective. Drawing forces observation. You will see more when you draw. Step 3: Compare to what you are looking at for differences. Step 4: Verify what you see with others’ observations. All Evidence must be accounted for by theories.
Compare to the Past How does the evidence compare to what you have seen in the past or to existing similar situations? This is usually based upon experience, but often there is someone around that can tell you what is unusual if you don’t know. Causal Analysis
85
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
86
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Hatching Theories Study what the Subject Matter Experts Have to Say Usually, there is a subject matter expert. If this is a legacy problem, it is likely that this expert has, also, not been able to solve the problem. (Ideally, the problem solver is also the expert). All of the pieces to the problem are floating about in the mind of this expert. Organizing this information with a cause-effect diagram is an important step to solving the problem. Based upon what we have seen or monitored, we need to change or reinforce our expectations. Our expectations are formed by how we think that the world works. That understanding can be a vague understanding or a deep model of the physics of the problem. There is really no substitute for understanding the physics of a problem. Thus, the important thing in this step is to understand the physics of the problem. What are the interactions between objects and what controls these interactions? Sometimes it is difficult to understand what causes a problem.
Method Step 1: Study what the subject matter experts have to say: —-Search Books, magazines, internet —-Talk directly to subject matter experts
When Did the Problem Show Up? Given enough experience, sometimes it is possible to determine when the problem showed up and link the occurrence with a change of objects or object attributes.
Method Step 1: Review the history of the problem—particularly if you have test data. Step 2: Determine what changes occurred at that time which might correlate to the problem
Causal Analysis
87
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Break the Event into Smaller and Smaller Steps Whether you are describing a process or a product, you are describing what happens in time. Products are a collection of objects that operate in time. The value of a process map is mostly found in the ability to break a process down into increasingly finer steps. A process map gives a snapshot of the sequence of functions with little reference to causality and may not include all of the possible elements of the system or super-system.
Example—Dispensing Tape Step 1: Describe each step of the process in functional terms. We begin by “walking the process” in time, as a series of functions. Step 2: Describe the process as a process map or storyboard. It might start with “person positions base” and then the second step could be “person positions tape” and so on. Person
Person
Positions
Positions
Base
Tape
Person / Blade
Person Positions
Cuts Tape
Tape
Step 3: For increased understanding of critical steps, break down process steps into finer detail. In this case, we break down “person/blade cuts tape” into more detailed steps. Step 4: Look for functional problems that you have not noticed before. It Person / Blade Cuts Tape
Breaks Down To
Person Unrolls Tape
Person Twists Tape
Blade Cuts Tape
may not have occurred to us before that a person usually twists the tape to start the cutting process.
88
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Mystery Phenomena If the physical phenomenon that is causing the problem is not obvious, use the following steps to determine it.
Empathy Method Step 1: Put yourself in the place of the objects that you are investigating Step 2: Follow through process from beginning to end
Subversion Analysis If you were a Saboteur, how would you cause the problem?
Method Step 1: Find an effect, no matter how weak, which could cause the phenomenon — Use the Effects Data Base Step 2: Boost the effect until it matches the evidence
Statistical Correlations Statistical correlations can be a powerful tool to determine what is influencing the problem, especially when the physics is not well understood.
Method Step 1: Use Statistical Analysis to Group and Subgroup the data. Step 2: Use statistical software and thinking to correlate known object attributes to the problem and to determine the degree of influence.
Causal Analysis
89
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
90
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Catching Missing Knobs— Table of Knobs The first pass through the cause-effect chain will identify the more obvious knobs. However, we can discover new knobs which are not as obvious. Because others may not have considered these knobs, they can sometimes be turned without harmful consequences. This table is a restructuring and reinterpretation of the parts of the “Standard Solutions” which deal with object knobs (knob resources). In its original form the “Standard Solutions” presented solution models with the conflict already removed. In the Table of Controlling Variables, the removal of the contradiction is delayed until the “Remove Contradiction” step, thus allowing for a greater number of ways to resolve the contradiction than those included in the “Standard Solutions”. Using the Table of Controlling Variables will help the problem solver uncover several unanticipated ways to control the function.
Rule: for use with Simple Causal Analysis When performing simple causal analysis, look through the table and ignore the function diagrams. Just ask if each knob will have an impact on the variable that you are trying to improve.
Example—Driving Piles Ignore the function diagrams in the table. Look through the table and identify any knob that might affect the parameter that you are trying to improve. The state of matter of the ground must be changed in order to make the ground soft. The ground must be “fluid”.
Causal Analysis
91
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Rule: for use with Causal Analysis Diagrams Causal analysis diagrams may be thought of as a linking of functions. If you have done a good job of identifying all functions then the function diagrams will help to identify the object attributes associated with each function.
Example—Acid Bath
Acid
Step 1: Pick a function from the Causal Analysis. The function of acid corroding the pan is chosen.
Corrodes
Pan Step 2: Use the table of knobs to identify knobs (potential solutions) that might be otherwise missed. Consider the parts of the function (tool, product, field and modification) that apply. New knobs were found: (1) Acid contact area. (2) Surface area of pan.
Existence Knob Consider existence of the tool, its source or its path Consider existence of the product, its source or its path Consider existence of the interaction site on the tool or product. Consider the micro-constituents that interact
Unusual or Extreme Settings Eliminate the tool, its source or its path Eliminate the product, its source or its path Identify and eliminate only the interaction site on the tool or product. Remove only the micro-constituents that interact. Contradiction often solved by transparency 92
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Number of Objects Number of Like Objects Knob Do any of the following changes affect the outcome? (With each of these, new capabilities should emerge) Number of tool objects Number of product elements Orientation of multiplied objects Combining or interacting of multiplied objects Variety of size or features of multiplied objects?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Multiply the product Multiply the tool Combine multiple objects in different orientations. should emerge.
New capabilities
Make the multiplied objects modify each other. New capabilities should emerge. Nest or stack the objects Bias some of the objects to handle different operating conditions
Causal Analysis
93
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Hybrid Combination of Objects Knob Identify another effect/tool which performs the same function. What is the feature of the new tool which would extend the capability of the first tool? Identify the cheap tool which should deliver most of the function.
Unusual or Extreme Settings Transfer the whole new tool or just the desirable feature of the new tool. Merge the tools. A new capability should emerge. Make the tools modify each other. A new capability should emerge.
94
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Location Location of Objects Knob Define the entire location envelope for the tool and product (What space can the tool and product be located in?) Move the tool about in higher dimensions. Are the fields affected? Move the product about in higher dimensions. Are the fields affected? Where are the fields more concentrated? Where are the fields of interaction less concentrated?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Move the product and tool to environments that are conducive to their operation or where the environment is much better
Interaction Zone Location Knob Locate the exact zone of the modification on the tool and product. Does changing the location affect the fields of the function?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make the interaction zone a completely benign region on the tool and product. If the action degrades either the product or the tool, make sure that the location is not important. Causal Analysis
95
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Relative Location Knob Consider the following changes: Distance Contact or separation Location of contact Mixing of tool and product Absorption of tool into product Combining the tool and product
Unusual or Extreme Settings Move the parts far away from each other Try different distances from each other Nestle one into the other Mix the tool and product Combine the tool and product. Consolidate. Look for new capabilities Combine with super-system. capabilities and room for growth.
96
Look for more consolidation, new
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Movement Path Knob Consider the following changes: CONSTANT POTENTIAL PATHS: Path in relation to potential field lines of a field. In order to perform lower work, it is necessary to move along lines of constant field potential. An example of this is moving objects horizontally rather than up High and down to avoid moving against gravity. The Work lines of constant potential in the earth’s gravitational field are arcs with constant radius from the earth’s center. To us, this looks like Low horizontal movement. For an electrostatic field Work Potential Lines between to capacitor plates, the lines of constant potential (at the center) run nearly parallel to the plates.
Line of Evolution
Linear
Curved in Plane
Curved out of Plane
Unusual or Extreme Settings Move along lines of constant field potential Move directly through lines of constant field potential Move in an entirely new dimension Movement around harmful objects or functions Rotation rather than linear paths
Causal Analysis
97
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Velocity Acceleration or Jerk Knob Consider the following changes: Velocity or relative velocity Stopping the tool or product Acceleration Rate of change of the acceleration (jerk)
Unusual or Extreme Settings Stop the tool or product Try extremely high or low rates of acceleration
98
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Structure Symmetry Knob Consider parameters or knobs which have already been identified. Are they symmetrically located? Consider symmetry or asymmetry of the tool and product
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change symmetry to another axis Make the tool or product unsymmetrical Make symmetrical
Dimension Knob Consider changing the structure dimension to the next higher dimension for useful effects and to lower dimensions for harmful effects.
Line of Evolution
Point
Causal Analysis
1-Dim
2-Dim
3-Dim
99
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Nesting—Nestling—Through Knob Consider putting objects inside each other to change the volume requirements.
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make one object go through another Nest an object completely inside another
Nested sink trap
Allow one object to invade the space of another by nestling in to its volume.
Degree of Segmentation Knob Would increasing the number of interaction sites improve the function? Can the sites be independent? Consider the affect that the following would have on the segmented pieces: Dividing into multiple copies of the original objects Size Shape Aspect Ratio
Line of Evolution
Monolith
100
Parts
Powders Mist
Mixed Media
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make the sites independent Break the original piece into sections that can be easily dismantled and assembled. Make multiple copies of the original objects. Reduce in size. Combine or make interact Change the shape of the segmented pieces Change to a powder or aerosol Decompose: Particles Combine: Grains
Grains—Dust—Molecules—Atoms—Ions—Sub Atomic Sub Atomic Particles—Ions—Atoms—Molecules—Dust—
Solidify a liquid or its constituents into particles
Voids and Capillary Structures Knob Consider the affect of the following changes to the tool or product Voids Porosity Structured capillaries Fluids in voids or capillary structures
Line of Evolution
Monolith
Cavity
Voids
Porous Capillaries
Structured Capillaries
Dynamized Voids Liquid Filled and Structured
Tube
Tire Example Causal Analysis
101
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Unusual or Extreme Settings Place a specially shaped cavity in the tool or product. Place specially shaped voids in the tool or product (honeycomb, spherical, random) Use open or closed celled porous materials Sintered powders Dried or fired clays Porcelain Sand Loose Powders Pumice Make the tool or product from structured capillary materials such as: Fabrics Fiber batting Fiber bundles (thread, string, rope…) Screen or layers of screens Capillary tubes or tube bundles Fill the porous material with special fluids or allow fluids to move through the porous material.
Thickness Knob Does the thickness of the tool or the product affect the function?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Replace solid constructions with flexible membranes Isolate objects with thin films 102
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Curvature Knob Does the curvature of the tool or product affect the outcome?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change from linear shapes to curved shapes Use rollers or balls Change from linear to rotary motion
Causal Analysis
103
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Surface Properties Surface Shape Knob How does the surface shape affect the fields of interaction?
Line of Evolution
Smooth
Protrusions
Rough
Activated Surface
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make the surface smooth if it is not already Make ridges, protrusions or cavities in the surface of the tool or product (Random or structured) Make the surface of the tool or product rough (random or structured) Use a finer and finer surface roughness
104
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Gravity Density
Elastic Force Internal & External Creep Coefficient-StrengthElasticity-ToughnessDuctility
Friction ProtrusionsRoughness-Matter State-Friction Couple-Slipperiness
Centrifugal Force
Inertia of Bodies (Note Direction)
Coriolis Force
Buoyant force
Hydrostatic Pressure Surface State
Jet Pressure
Odor & Taste Chemical CompositionSurface State
Diffusion Surface Porosity Surface State
Sound
Vibrations & Oscillations
Corona Discharge Surface ProtrusionsRoughness-Surface State
Current Continuity-Surface StateConductivity
Surface Property Knobs which Affect these Fields
Adhesive AdhesivenessMatter StateCohesiveness
Surface Tension Bulk PropertiesState-Wetted CircumferenceTemperature
Osmosis Surface Molecular Structure Surface State
Chemical Fields Chemical Reactivity -Surface StateConcentration
Waves
Ultrasound Surface State
Eddie Currents (Internal and skin) Continuity-Surface StateConductivity
Thermal Heating or Cooling Surface Protrusions or RoughnessSurface State
Thermal Shocks Surface Protrusions or Roughness-
Electrostatic Field Protrusions Roughness
Magnetic Field
Particle Beams State-Chemical Reactivity-Surface Molecular Weight
Nuclear Forces Nuclear Particle Type
Electromagnetic (Voltage) Continuity Conductivity
Radio Waves Reflectivity-State - Absorbtivity -Emissivity
Causal Analysis
Micro-waves Reflectivity-State -Absorbtivity -Emissivity
Infrared Reflectivity-State --Absorbtivity -Emissivity
Information
Visible Light Reflectivity-State -Emissivity
Ultra-violet Reflectivity-Emissivity-State -Fluorescence
X-Ray Atomic Weight
105
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Surface Properties Knob Identify the fields which deliver the modification. Consult the Table of Surface Properties to see which ones modify the fields of the function
Unusual or Extreme Settings Greatly increase the surface properties. Change to new materials or coatings if necessary.
Surface Cleanliness Knob Can contaminants (solids, liquids or gasses) find a way to the surface? (Internal or external paths)
Unusual or Extreme Settings Greatly decrease the surface contaminants until the surface is ultra-clean Greatly increase the contaminants Add a lubricant to the surface Condense a liquid onto the surface
106
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Bulk Properties State of Matter Knob Consider how the following affect the interaction or fields: State of the tool State of the Product State of the Environment Note that state of matter controls most fields
Line of Evolution Solid
Solid
Liquid
Liquid
Gas
Plasma
Gas
Rarefied Gas
Field
Vacuum
Not Existing
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the State of the tool Change the State of the Product Change the State of the Environment (Note that state of matter controls most fields)
Causal Analysis
107
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Bulk Properties of Substance Knob Identify the current fields throughout the tool or product What materials are affected by these fields? What are their bulk properties (Properties spread throughout the volume?)
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the product or tool to create the ideal bulk properties Change the bulk properties by chemically transforming, decomposing, and combining existing materials or by heat treatment. Further enhance by adding a field. Cheap Substances • • • • • • • • •
Grocery store products Powders Foam Void Loose Bodies Waste or transformed waste Garbage Water, Steam or Hydrates Air and its components
Example of Bulk Properties • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
108
Creep Coefficient Strength Elasticity Toughness Ductility Physical State Density Temperature Viscosity Coefficient of restitution Gas Constant Gamma Cohesiveness Chemical Composition Molecular Weight Ionization Potential Molecular size Ease of Ionization Rarefaction Conductivity Trans Conductance Thermal Conductivity Coefficient of Thermal Expansion Thermal Capacity Dielectric Constant Magnetic Permeability Magnetic Hysteresis Curie Point Permeability Transparency Image Splitting Properties Refractive Index
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls Gravity Density-State
Elastic Force Internal & External Creep Coeff-StrengthElasticityToughness-Ductility-Physical Centrifugal Force Density
Inertia of Bodies (Note Direction) Density-State-Elasticity Coeff. of Restitution
Buoyant Force Density-State
Hydrostatic Pressure Gas Constant-StateGamma-Temperature
Odor & Taste Chemical Composition -State
Diffusion Molecular Weight-State
Vibrations & Oscillations Coeff. of RestitutionViscosity-Density-State
Sound Coeff. of RestitutionViscosity-DensityState
Corona Discharge Ease of IonizationRarefaction-State
Current Conductivity-StateTrans-conductance
Bulk Property Knobs which Affect these Fields
Friction TemperatureViscosity -State
Coriolis Force Density
Jet Pressure Density-State
Chemical Fields Chemical CompositionConcentration-State
Ultrasound Coeff. of Restitution-
Waves Coeff. of RestitutionViscosity-Density-State
Eddie Currents (Internal and skin) Conductivity-StateTrans-conductance
Causal Analysis
Particle Beams Molecular Weight
Thermal Heating or Cooling Thermal ConductivityCoeff. Thermal
Thermal Shocks Thermal ConductivityCoeff. Thermal
Electrostatic Field Dielectric Constant
Magnetic Field Magnetic PermeabilityMagnetic HysteresisCurie Point
Micro-waves TransparencyState-Image Splitting Refractive index
Infrared TransparencyState-Image Splitting Refractive index
Surface Tension Cohesiveness-State
Osmosis Molecular Size -Ionization Potential-State
Electromagnetic (Voltage) Permeability-Conductivity Dielectric Constant
Radio Waves TransparencyState-Image Splitting Refractive index
Adhesive TemperatureState of Mater
Nuclear Forces Atomic WeightDensity Temperature
Information
Visible Light TransparencyState-Image Splitting Refractive index
Ultra-violet X-Ray Transparency-State- Molecular -Image Splitting Weight Refractive index
109
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Use of Foam Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the product or tool to a foam structure
Match or Mismatch of Properties Knob Are the tool and product alike? Do the bulk properties match each other? Consider the following and how well matched the tool and product are Thermal expansion Thermal Conductivity Electrical Conductivity Modulus of Elasticity
Unusual or Extreme Settings Match or mismatch tool and product properties, especially if they are in contact or must move or expand together Make the product and tool from the same materials
Gradients of Components Knob Consider the bulk constituents. Can they be made nonuniform? How would a material gradient affect the internal fields?
110
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Unusual or Extreme Settings Allow a gradation or mixture gradient of material constituents Allow a sharp gradation of material constituents Add a new material and allow the gradient to vary
Chemical Activity Knob Consider how chemically reactive the Product is to the Tool
Unusual or Extreme Settings Increase Chemical Activity Change to very active chemical substances Use progressively activated oxygen. Ambient Air Oxygenated Air Pure Oxygen Ionized Oxygen Ozone Singlet Oxygen Change the tool or product to an inert substance Introduce inert gasses Introduce or mix in inert substances Use a vacuum
Causal Analysis
111
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Direction Direction of Action or Fields Knob Identify the Field Gradients Identify current direction of Action or fields How does the direction of the fields affect the interaction?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Reverse the direction of action or fields. Change from linear to rotary motion. Change from rotary to linear motion. Go 90 degrees to the current direction
Relative Orientation Knob Try different rotational orientations, relative to each other. Consider differences between linear and rotary motion.
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the orientation of the tool to the product
Direction of Action Knob What constitutes the reverse of the current action? What is the action performed relative to?
112
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the relative action Perform the reverse action Place parts upside down or backward Make moving parts stationary
Movement Relative to Gradients Knob Draw the field lines and the equipotential lines Does either object move or rotate through a field gradient? What direction do they move relative to the gradient?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make objects move along equipotential lines If either object already moves along equipotential lines, changing the field slightly can make the function adjustable. How can the fields be changed? Avoid lifting.
Causal Analysis
113
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Field Structure Field Intensity or Conductance Knob Draw field potential lines and gradients How does the conductivity of the medium affect the interaction?
Decrease
Shield
Amplify
Unusual or Extreme Settings Increase or decrease the field intensity from the tool Use an intermediate substance to shield, amplify or decrease the field Change the conductivity of the mediator
Field Direction Knob Identify the field gradients and potential lines Is the field direction important? What would happen if the fields were reversed?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change to the ideal field direction.
Reverse
Reflection
Reverse the fields? Change Direction
114
Diffraction
Refraction
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Field Gradient or Concentration Knob Draw the field gradients and field potential lines as they currently exist. Consider the following: Concentration of the field Rate of change of field gradient Coherence of field Interference of field Field Scatter
Unusual or Extreme Settings
Structure
Change the gradient to the ideal
Interference
Focus
Scatter
Diffraction Refraction
Move to higher dimensions Change the dimension of the affected area of the product Use heat to change the refractive index Sharply change the field gradient to eliminate harmful functions Make the Field Coherent
Variety or Separation of Field Components Knob Can the field be broken into various components by direction, Frequency or Variety of Fundamental Fields? Identify the components
truly
useful Filtering
Expanding or Refracting
Anisotropy of Medium
Using Paint
What properties of the product or tool affect the variety of field components? Causal Analysis
115
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Transmission of frequency Absorption of frequency Reflection of frequency Anisotropy of Medium Resonance properties of medium
Unusual or Extreme Settings Break the field into various components Direction Frequency Variety of Fundamental Fields Separate out the useful components Use a different Color: Filter field or reflect only certain frequencies Change the receptivity of the product to certain field components Search the Table of Effects for ways to separate field components Move to a higher dimension to enhance the filter.
116
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Adding or Superimposing Fields Adding Fields Knob Identify substances and constructions which react strongly to the existing fields or fields which would react strongly to the existing substances. Identify other environment.
fields
in
the
Consider assisting fields or counter fields that could be superimposed into, onto or in the environment of the objects? Consult the table of Storage of Fields for consideration of residual fields.
Unusual or Extreme Settings Superimpose a counter field Superimpose an assisting field Superimpose a new field type Pre-stress the parts
Causal Analysis
117
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Conductivity of the Medium Conductivity of the Medium Knob What medium is between the tool and product? Is the conductivity of the medium adjustable? Should a different medium be used?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the conductivity of the medium by using concentrated additives Change the gradient of conductivity Change to a different medium with higher or lower conductance Shorten the flow path Decrease flow transformations Change the number of turns
118
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Making Adjustable Adjustability Knob Which of the features of the tool, product or field can be made adjustable? Consider the following:
Line of Evolution for Joints
Fixed
Joint
Multiple Joints
Flexible
Degrees of Freedom Variety of Adjustable Features Line of Evolution for Continuity of Adjustment
Invariable
Causal Analysis
Stepwise Variable
Continuously Variable
119
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make adjustable to adapt to each stage of operation. Make self-adjusting according to operating conditions. Immobile objects become mobile. Place joints in the tool or product Increase the number of joints If a parameter is already adjustable, increase the degrees of freedom. Make several controlling parameters adjustable Make an existing or new parameter continuously adjustable.
Flexibility Knob Everything is flexible. Look at the system as a collection of springs, masses and dampers. Consider the flexibility of the tool. Consider the flexibility of the product. Consider the direction of flexibility Consider the state of matter
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the flexibility of the tool. Change the flexibility of the product. Change the direction of flexibility. Make very flexible by transforming to a liquid or gas.
120
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Nearness to Critical Point Knob Does the feature have a natural critical condition or threshold, such as boiling point or Curie temperature? Can a critical condition or threshold be created for a feature which does not normally have one, such as a bi-stable condition? If the function is useful, operation near the critical condition can trigger large results. If the function is harmful, operating far away from the critical point reduces the effect.
Unusual or Extreme Settings Operate near the critical condition Operate far away from the critical point.
Causal Analysis
121
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Timing Continuity of Operation Knob Does the Tool Follow a Path? Can the Tool perform the function on the entire path, both coming and going? Is the function at full load (always operating)? Have dummy runs and downtimes been eliminated?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Make the tool perform the function on the entire path
Different Time Knob Process Map the changing conditions over time. Does the requirement for the function vary over time? Could other tools help out at another time? If the modification is performed as a step in a process, can the sequence be varied?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Change the Sequence Change the time Perform during transportation or while queued or waiting Temporarily turn the function off Introduce a temporary blocking. (Should be taken away by resources only) Make the product temporarily insensitive Temporarily move the product away 122
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Partial Modification Knob Can the modification be broken into two (or more) stages? Can the operation be broken into parallel processes?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Separate the modification into two or more serial stages Separate the operation into parallel stages Perform setup at the same time as the operation. Implies use of a previously placed tool
Addition or Subtraction of Other Functions Knob Identify other functions performed on the tool, product and field. Does uncoupling these other functions affect the interaction? Would coupling other functions such as vibration affect the outcome?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Couple or uncouple other functions such as vibration
Causal Analysis
123
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Uninterrupted Operation Knob Are all parts of the system at full load? Have dummy runs and downtimes been eliminated? What else in the system requires the same modification?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Move to uninterrupted operation Make the tool operate on other similar products Modify the tool to operate on diverse products
Storage of Action or Field Knob Identify the main fields of the function. Consult the next page for ways to store this field Is this field stored, even for an instant in the tool, product or in space? (Is there a lag between field generation and application?) Is there energy storage in oscillations? Does storage improve the function? Can storage be a mediator between the tool and product?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Store the field in the lag between field generation and application Store Energy in oscillations Make storage a mediator between the tool and product
124
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls Gravity Height of Objects Weight or Density
Elastic Force Internal & External Springs Elastic Media State
Inertia of Bodies (Note Direction) Momentum
Centrifugal Force Momentum
Buoyant Force Average Density of Buoyant Object
Hydrostatic Pressure Pressure Vessel
Odor & Taste Container
Corona Discharge Low Field Vacuum
Current Inductance Super-conducting media
Storage Property Knobs which Affect these Fields
Thermal Heating or Cooling Thermal Mass Thermal Capacity-State Electrostatic Field Capacitance-- Piezo Electric Materials
Causal Analysis
Micro-waves Separation Space Oscillating Circuits
Infrared Separation Space Hot Objects
Chemical Fields Explosives Chemical Potential
Ultrasound Oscillation Chamber-Distance of Travel--Resonance of Objects
Eddie Currents (Internal and skin) Inductance Super-conducting media
Waves Oscillation Chamber-Distance of Travel--Resonance of Objects
Particle Beams Low Field Vacuum
Thermal Shocks Thermal Mass of Two Objects ExpansionThermal Capacity--State
Nuclear Forces Radio-active Materials
Magnetic Field Permanent Magnet
Electromagnetic (Voltage) Separation Space
Radio Waves Separation Space Oscillating Circuits
Surface Tension Surface Tension Area
Osmosis Container
Vibrations & Oscillations Oscillation Chamber--Distance of Travel--Resonance of Objects
Adhesive
Coriolis Force Momentum
Jet Pressure Fluid Momentum
Diffusion Pressure Vessel
Sound Oscillation Chamber-Distance of Travel--Resonance of Objects
Friction
Information Data Fields
Visible Light Separation Space Hot Objects Fluorescence
Ultra-violet X-Ray Separation Space Separation Hot Objects Space Fluorescence Radioi
125
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Time Variation Speed Knob How are the fields changed by performing the modification at different speeds? If the modification were performed more rapidly, would other harmful functions be precluded?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Slow the function way down (hours, days, weeks, months, years) Perform the modification very rapidly to preclude harmful or hazardous functions.
Discrete or Continuous Knob If the action is continuous, is there any advantage to make it discrete? Can the Tool be Multiplied or segmented into separate pieces. Can each piece moves into action in discrete steps or into fixed positions or amplitudes. If the action is discrete, can it be made continuous?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Continuous actions move to discrete actions Multiply or segment the tool into separate pieces. Each piece moves into action in discrete steps or into fixed positions or amplitudes. Discrete actions move to continuous actions 126
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Time Variance or Pulse Knob How is the interaction affected if you could continuously vary the action in time?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Shape the curve Square pulse the action Shape the pulse. Make the pulse travel.
Pulsation or Oscillation Knob Is the interaction affected by pulsing or oscillating the tool, product or field? Can a feature or knob of the tool, product or field be oscillated? How do the natural frequencies of the tool and product affect the interaction?
Line of Evolution
Continuous
Causal Analysis
Pulsed
Oscillating
Resonating
Standing Wave
127
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Unusual or Extreme Settings Pulse
AM
FM
PWM
Oscillat
AM
FM
Phase Mod
Resonate
Filter
Dying
Pulsate or oscillate the tool Pulsate or oscillate the product Pulsate or oscillate the field Pulsate or oscillate the product receptivity Combine
Standing
Make the tool, product or field resonate Create standing waves Cancel oscillations in the tool, product or field Mismatch the product natural frequency with the tool driving frequency Increase or decrease the frequency
Vary Field Direction Knob Identify the field gradient and potential
Dynamic
Scanning
Does varying the field direction affect the function?
Unusual or Extreme Settings Vary the field direction
128
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Catching Missing Knobs— Relative To Here is yet another way to find knobs. One might ask why we need so many knobs. The discovery of new knobs is quite important. Sometimes we are able to find knobs that nobody else has found. When we turn knobs, we find new solutions. It can be appreciated that a newcomer may feel overwhelmed by the number of independent variables in each situation. Having more options is a good thing. You can have some consolation in knowing that in the end, we will most likely only turn a few knobs to find the solution. Here, we are still exploring what is available. Every knob is measured relative to something. Consider changing that “something” instead.
Example—Acid Bath By this point, we realize that there are a number of knobs involved in the acid bath problem. Step 1: Let us pick one box in particular. The hours of use are high: 1500 hours
Hours of Use is High
1500 Hrs
Step 2: Ask: High compared to what? Determine the answer to this question. Answer: Number of Cubes and the total oven time. These are new knobs. Acid Reaction Time is High
16 Hours
Causal Analysis
Cool down and warm up time is high
Hours of Use is High
Number of cubes is low
Capacity of Tray is Small
4 Hours
1500 Hrs
10 cubes
10 Cubes
129
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 3: Look through all of the boxes to determine whether there are more “relative to” knobs.
Corrosion of Corrosion of Cubes is Cubes is Present absent
???
Acid Doesn’t Exist
Acid Exists
Pan Doesn’t Exist
Pan Exists
Existence of Contact
No Contact
Reactivity of Acid is High
Reactivity of Acid is Low
Rate of Corrosion of Cubes is Low
Corrodes Cube
Earth Pulls
Force of Gravity is High
Force of Gravity is Low
Acid
Pan Material is Gold
Pan Material is Glass
Amount of Material is Low
Amount of Material is High
Corrodes
Acid
Vgol
Pan
???
Hours of Use Hours of Use is Low is High
Positions
Rate of Corrosion is High
Material Cost is Low
Rate of Corrosion is Low
$
Acid
Location of Location of Acid is Acid is effective and ineffective or safe harmful
Frequency of Frequency of Replacement Replacement is High is Low
Cost per Replacement is Low
Cost per Replacement is High
$
$
Mat
G
old
Material Cost is High
$
Ma
Labor Cost is High
$
La
Cost of Cost of Replacement Replacement is High is Low
$
$
A completed causal analysis diagram is shown below. The implied contradictions are included to underscore the point that they are also valid contradictions. Normally, these diagrams would be shown without the implied contradictions, for brevity.
130
Causal Analysis
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Did Easily Turned Knobs Solve the Problem? Once we understand what is causing the problem, we may find that there are easily turned knobs. These knobs solve the problem without causing any significant problems. If this is the case and you do not need more solutions, then you may be done with problem solving. You can move on to the implementation. In cases where there are many time constraints, this may be prudent. On the other hand, if we need a number of solution alternatives or we want to simplify the system at the same time, then we should consider going to the next step of the algorithm and begin solving the problem in earnest.
Method Turn the easily turned knobs to solve the problem.
Causal Analysis
131
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
132
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Jump to New System-Idealize Functions To Jump or not to Jump The decision to jump to a new system rather than evolving the given system is based upon the constraints for solving the problem. When we reviewed requirements we also considered the constraints on the problem solving process. We considered how much time we had; how much budget we had to work with; how many alternatives we needed to generate. From these, we have a pretty good idea how much we will be allowed to change the system. It is easy to assume that jumping to a new system will take more resources, but this is conditional. Jumping to a new system may mean removing elements and simplifying the system. Removing flawed elements from our system can be worth the additional problem solving time, even if there is little time to solve the problem. Simplification can remove several problems including the one that we are faced with. We have just done a causal analysis. We understand why everything is needed in the system. Often, objects related to the problem are only required because something else is not doing its job. It may not be doing its job because of a problem hidden in the system that has not been solved. If we solve this problem, the requirement for other elements may go away. The system becomes simpler at the same time that we are improving it. This is elegance. On the other hand there are changes that simplify, that will almost certainly require more resources. It is almost certain that changing the physical phenomenon that delivers the main function will generate many unanticipated problems. Whenever we change the physical phenomenon we sign up for all sorts of unexpected problems. It is not likely that we will really consider this if there is a short fuse. In summary, jumping to a new system can take more time and effort than evolving the given system. On the other hand, the offset in system complexity can often save time. The final answer to this question is that it takes experience to know how far to go. Even with experience, we can never know for certain if we have gone too far or far enough because there is no way to follow all solution paths. Jump to New System—Idealize Functions
133
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Jumping Requires Structured Thinking—the Ideal Final Result In jumping to a new system, we are not willy-nilly brainstorming new systems. This is an attempt to create a new system which is simpler because the new system makes better use of resources than the old or current system. A successful structured approach to jumping to new systems involves first trying to imagine what the new system would do or look like, even before we create it. In the TRIZ world, this is referred to as the Ideal Final Result (IFR). This idea of imagining a final state that meets all of the requirements and performs what it needs to with a minimum of resources is a very important thinking approach to the inventor and problem solver. The concept of jumping to a new system may seem foreign to some. Some industries require slow and meticulous change due to regulations regarding safety. An example of this is the aviation industry. Some have been taught that the best way to change systems is to evolve them slowly so that everything can be taken into account. While this may sound like sound wisdom, it is not correct. Let’s talk about why jumping makes sense. In preparation for teaching the concept of the IFR, Altshuller presents a problem posed by D. Poia. 1 “How can you bring exactly six liters of water from a river using two buckets, one of four liters, the other of nine liters? It is obvious that pouring water “by guessing” from one bucket to the other is prohibited. The problem has to be solved using the exact measuring capacity of the two buckets. I offered this problem to students at seminars before we began to study the methodology of searching for a solution. The results never differed from Poia’s conclusion. Attempts to solve the problem without our systematical approach looked like this: “What if we do this?” The correct solution appeared after many “what ifs.”” Altshuller compares this to the way that technical problems are often solved, by starting with a mental image of familiar machines and then trying many “what ifs” to improve it. Eventually, a solution is reached, but after many trials. This method ultimately leads to solutions that resemble the starting point and are often complex. He then suggests that there is a better way to solve problems that require guess work: namely, start with the solution. Altshuller then applies this to the water bucket problem.
1
Genrich Altshuller, The Innovation Algorithm, Technical Innovation Center, Page 127
134
Jump to New system—Idealize Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
“It is required that one of the buckets contains six liters. Obviously this could only be the large bucket. So, an Ideal Final Result would be to have the large bucked filled with six liters. For that, it is necessary to fill the large bucket (with a capacity of nine liters), and then pour out three liters. If the second bucket had a capacity of three—rather than four—liters, the problem would immediately be solved. However, the second bucket has a fourliter capacity. To make it a three-liter bucket requires filling it in advance with one liter. Then it becomes possible to pour three liters out of the large bucket. Therefore, the original problem is now reduced to another, much easier one: Measure one liter of water with the help of the two existing pails. This creates no difficulty because 9 – (4+4) = 1. We can fill the large bucket and then pour out four liters twice into the small bucket. After that, one liter of water will be left in the large bucket. We can now dump that one liter into the empty small bucket. The four-liter bucket now “becomes” a three-liter bucket—exactly what we need. We fill the large bucket once more to its rim, and then pour off three liters into the small bucket. Six liters of water will now be left in the large bucket. The problem is solved. Altshuller goes on to state that the pattern of starting with an ideal solution can be extended to solving inventive problems. One must start with a model of a preferred final state and then proceed by improving upon this model. “If an inventor starts by stating an Ideal Final Result, then an ideal concept is taken as the basic model. This model is now already simplified and improved. Further mental experiments will not be aggravated by a burden of habitual mental forms. These experiments immediately get the best perspective for their direction: The inventor tries to reach the highest results by the least means possible.” 2 The idea of starting with a model of the ideal solution is often used unconsciously by successful inventors. The genius of institutionalizing this method is one of the legacies of Altshuller and early TRIZ theorists. Jumping to a new system allows us to consider changing which objects we 2
Genrich Altshuller, The Innovation Algorithm, Technical Innovation Center, Page 128
Jump to New System—Idealize Functions
135
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
will allow in the system to solve our problem. Without this, we are stuck with the existing system objects. All solutions that come from this consideration are evolutionary. According to the Hierarchy of Decisions, we should first decide which objects we will include before we decide the attributes of these objects. If we do not do this, then we are beginning with a model of the current system in our minds and changes to this system will most likely be incremental. This can, unintentionally, make the system more complex and allows for less opportunity to simplify the system while we are solving the problem. Consider this an axiom of problem solving: All changes should not only fix the problem at hand but also make things simpler. We should note that there are times that our system will necessarily become more complex. This seems to break the rule that simpler. It is sometimes necessary to make the system more complex in order to make the super-system (job) simpler. On the whole, the world should be simpler when we are done.
The IFR? If you have studied TRIZ, it is very likely that you have been exposed to the concept of the Ideal Final Result (IFR). Idealizing Functions is a more generalized form of the IFR. In fact, we may equate idealizing functions to creating the IFR in functional terms. The functional IFR is actually the convergence the Ideal Final Result, Function Analysis, and the Standard Solutions. While the concept of the IFR was a great boost to inventers and problem solvers, the application has been misapplied for many years. Early TRIZ theorists and practitioners strove for a “best way” to represent the final state. As an example, Altshuller poses “the” IFR for a situation which involves painting the inside of a pipe. 3 “If, for instance, we are talking about a device to paint the internal surface of a pipe …The ideal result, in this case, must be formulated differently: “Paint comes by-itself into a tube and byitself evenly covers the tube’s internal surface.”” (Italics added). Notice that this formulation precludes other final states which are potentially more ideal. For instance, what if the pipe does not require painting at all or it comes already painted? These are also viable solution paths. One should not conclude that Altshuller did anything “wrong”. A proponent of the “one IFR” might conclude that Altshuller just didn’t go far enough in this instance. If Altshuller had only considered the condition that the painting was not required, he would then be precluding the less ideal state of the paint coming inside the tube by itself.
3
Genrich Altshuller, The Innovation Algorithm, Technical Innovation Center, page 129
136
Jump to New system—Idealize Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
This highlights an interesting question for TRIZ theorists. Is there an advantage to having multiple “ideal” paths in which some are more ideal than others? As solution paths proliferate, some classical TRIZ practitioners become uncomfortable. For one thing, we move further and further from the cherished notion of “the” solution. Some would say that this puts us back to the primitive state of having many solution paths and ultimately many options to pick from, which seems uncomfortably close to trial and error problem solving. The need for multiple solution paths comes from a practical aspect of solving problems and inventing. We cannot know what problems must be confronted as we continue down any particular solution path. For instance, it may turn out that manufacturing the tube such that it does not require painting might require a lot of research into material corrosion. We may feel confident that with our skills, the solution will ultimately be reached, but the availability of time and money resources could doom this research-based approach! It might turn out that using paint on the inside of the tube is very acceptable and will keep the initial problem at bay for many years.
Why Use Idealizing Functions to State and Improve the IFR? By their very nature, functions state changes that occur in time or results. If we use a function to describe the final state of an object’s attributes, then we are describing a “result”. It is only natural that further stating this in a more ideal way takes us to a “Functional Ideal Final Result”. What is interesting is that many of the Standard Solutions and other TRIZ tools were already stated in functional language. Suggestions for how we might find a more ideal functional part come from a restructuring and reinterpretation of the parts of the “Standard Solutions” that deal with eliminating, redefining or replacing system parts (object resources). Combining the IFR, parts of the Standard Solutions and functional nomenclature leads to the functional IFR. Thus, there was a ready supply of ways to describe the final state by the use of these idealized functions. Just as a method can be proposed to work the bucket problem backward, so a path is proposed to work towards ideal final state of an inventive situation. This is effectively accomplished in the following steps: Step 1: Identify an ideal product. Step 2: Identify an ideal modification (Step 1 and 2 give the ideal result. The path to this result is stated in the next two steps). Step 3: Identify potential ideal physical phenomena to deliver the function. Step 4: Identify an ideal tool to deliver the physical phenomena. (This completes the traditional IFR by stating a means to the ideal result.) Jump to New System—Idealize Functions
137
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 5: Idealize the Attributes of the Objects and Fields. (Now we start to consider the ideal attributes of new objects. When we added objects for the product and tool, we created mental models of these parts of the system. This added problems that now need to be addressed.) Step 6: Resolve the resulting contradictions. (This step considers the ideal distribution of the properties of the object, further solidifying mental images of the system into more ideal states). We can use these steps regardless of whether we are dealing with a useful, harmless or informing (measuring or detecting) function. In the introduction to this book, the concept of Hierarchy of Decisions was introduced. The Hierarchy of Decisions moves from abstract to concrete. One part of this hierarchy is repeated over and over, the idealization of functions. Whether we are creating a system, overhauling a system or fixing a problem with the system, we use tools to focus in on one function at a time. When we create a system, we add a function at a time. When we overhaul the system, we identify burdensome functions that must be changed. When we fix a problem, we home in like a surgeon to identify problematic functions and the associated object attributes. In each case, we are focusing on a function which we would like to make as ideal as possible. This focus on functions has the benefit of always driving the system to be as simple as possible.
What about Beginners? We have just finished a causal analysis. Perhaps obvious solutions have become apparent. It is natural want to start solving the problem by “turning knobs”. This is fine for beginners that are uncomfortable working with functions, but remember that jumping to a new system can be a very powerful way to solve problems. Since jumping to a new system involves working with functions, you should be comfortable with functions. If you are a beginner, consider studying the appendix “Working with Functions”. When you are ready, come back and start the problem solving process here, rather than resolving contradictions. Whatever systems we create in this section are further evolved when we go to resolving contradictions. This means that if we decide to skip this step and go to evolving the current system, everything will still be in order. Whatever system that we come up with needs to be evolved to a practical stage. This means that it must meet all of the requirements for the product or process.
138
Jump to New system—Idealize Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Pick the Functions to Idealize If you have decided to perform a simplified causal analysis, the number of functions will usually be limited and it is likely that all of the functions should be considered. It doesn’t take that much time to scan the tools to idealize the functions and come up with alternatives. If you have performed the basic causal analysis, no functions are accounted for. If you have made it this far then you can jump to Resolving Contradicitons. If you have performed the advanced causal analysis, we need to pick the functions that we will idealize. Consider the functions in your diagram. They will usually fall under one of the following classes. 1. Useful functions which can be broken into: a. Preventative functions b. Productive functions c. Remedial functions 2. Informing (measuring or detecting) functions 3. Harmful functions When considering useful functions, it is generally more important to prevent than to fix a problem. A productive function occurs during the main system function. It is neither preventative nor remedial. Also, functions (useful or harmful) that are closer to the system product are generally more important to fix than supporting or auxiliary functions. If the main functions are idealized, auxiliary functions are often not required.
Example—Acid Container Step 1: Identify useful or informing functions that are closer to the system product with the following priority, first preventative, second productive and third remedial. Since corrosion of the cubes is the main function that we are trying to achieve and containing the acid is an auxiliary function, we should first consider how the acid is being positioned to the cubes. Step 2: Consider harmful functions that directly impact the problem Pick the Functions to Idealize
139
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
140
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Idealize Useful Functions The first step to idealizing a useful function is to identify and isolate the final ideal state in functional terms. We start by considering useful functions first, because informing functions are actually a special case of useful functions and one major path of idealizing harmful functions is to turn them into useful functions. Once they are turned into useful functions, they may be idealized using the steps shown in this chapter. One might ask “Why idealize something that is already useful?” We idealize useful functions, because there are so many options to either avoid performing the function or there are so many opportunities to eliminate elements from our system. When we eliminate the need for an element, we also remove the need for auxiliary functions which support this function. Let’s go back to Altshuller’s example of painting pipes. If the need for painting pipes goes away, parts that directly paint and supporting equipment are no longer required.
The Ideal Product for Useful Functions Regardless of whether the function already exists, we want to identify the most ideal embodiment of the element that is being modified. Let’s say that we are trying to come up with a way for the police to stop a speeding car without harming the occupants or other motorists. If we know a way to do this, for the moment, we will ignore this and concentrate on only two elements: the product and the modification that we are trying to achieve.
Stop Car
The product is the “car” and the modification is “stop”. Now we begin setting up the IFR. Knowing only these two parts of the function allows us to ask the important question: What is the ideal product? The answer is surprising. The most ideal product is one that does not exist. (The car should not exist), hence the tool and all attending auxiliary functions are not required. Thus we come very close to the realization of the classical Ideal Final Result (IFR). We may not require the product for a variety of reasons. It may be a transmission element that we can bypass. (Is the car a transmission element? Not really.) It may be a waste element that does not require existence in the first place. (Is the car considered waste? Not really.) A slight modification of the product may make the modification unnecessary. (If the car could be easily Idealize Useful Functions
141
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
tracked, then I might not require stopping it) or the product may already come with the modification performed. (By the time that the police reach the car, the driver is compelled to not want it anymore and it is already stopped). If the product is required, then we ask the question: What minimum part must be modified. (Is it the car that we want to stop? Maybe we only want to stop a part of the car such as the engine or the occupant). If only a small part requires modification then the resources required to perform the modification can also be minimized. Finally, if the product is required, how can we get the most value for our effort? Let’s make the modification as far reaching as possible. If the product comes in natural groupings, let’s modify the whole group. If other objects nearby require the same modification then let’s modify as many things as possible. This increases the value that the user derives from performing the function. (Perhaps the police signal all cars on the road to slowly decelerate thus making the situation safer for everyone)
Identify and Isolate the Main Modification If a system is being simplified, the function may already come with a tool. If a new function is being created, the tool is not yet evident. We do not need the tool. It is a burden to our reasoning. We take nothing for granted and start with just the modification. For the moment, this is the most ideal form of the final result that we know. However, this will soon change as we consider other more desirable results. For the moment, we must be unencumbered with a tool to perform the function. The tool almost always comes with undesirable functions or features. It may even be harmful to the product or other elements in the system. For now, we will forget it and just talk about what we want to happen.
Example—Pet Feeding System I am interested in some sort of pet feeding system that protects the food from ants, roaches, birds and bacteria
142
Feeding System Stops Insects Birds & Bacteria
Stops Insects Birds & Bacteria
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
No Modification—Remove Transmission Elements The theory for this tool comes from the Laws of Evolution in Classical TRIZ. It states that: —Transmissions paths are shortened and eventually eliminated —Energy transformations are reduced and finally eliminated.
Shortened or Eliminated
—Muscle and control elements use the same field. When applying this law to the ideal product, it means that we should consider bypassing traditional or existing transmission elements and go directly to the object that requires modification. If the product of the function that we are considering is a transmission element, then we should consider whether it is required or if we can find some way to bypass it altogether.
Example—Linkage Operated System Many systems require rotary movement. Of these systems, a large number convert linear motion to rotary motion through a linkage. The actuators in these systems do not act directly on the working element. Step 1: Is the product a transmission element? (Does the product transmit, transform or convert energy?) Some elements masquerade as important functioning elements but are transmission elements instead. The current system operated on a linkage assembly to turn an object. Step 2: Bypass the transmission element. The new system directly rotates the element with a rotary actuator. The actuator works directly on the element of interest without the need for a transmission.
No Modification—Non-Existent Product It is easy to lose track of whether the product is required in the first place. If the product is harmful or even a waste product (such as sawdust or leaves) wouldn’t it make more sense to not have it around in the first place?
Idealize Useful Functions
143
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—the Collection of Leaves The collection of leaves is a common problem. Step 1: Is the product ever harmful or waste? Unfortunately, it is considered waste in many areas. (Actually, it is nature’s way of revitalizing itself. But, for this problem, we will consider it waste.)
Gather Leaves Waste
Step 2: Eliminate the product through the following methods: Method 1: Directly eliminate the product. The leaves simply don’t exist. Since we may not know how this occurs directly, it creates a contradiction: The leaves must and must not exist. Method 2: Eliminate the sources of the product. Remove the tree. This may be a solution in certain cases. Again, it may lead to a contradiction: the tree exists and doesn’t exist. Method 3: Eliminate the path that the product moves to get to the location. Remove the path to the ground. Method 4: Absorb the product so that it is not harmful or wasteful any more. Consider using absorbent materials such as fabrics, powder or batting. Something below the tree absorbs the leaves or at least hides them. Ground cover is often a good way to do this.
No Modification— Not Required All useful functions can be thought of in a remedial or preventative context. This may not seem intuitive at first, but let us consider a couple Slight of cases. A lawn mower cuts grass. Is this a remedial action? Yes, Change because it remedies the height of the grass. One could reason that if the grass were doing its job better, it would grow to an even height and then stop. While this may seem obsessive, it is nevertheless a very useful way to look at a situation from a new point of view. In order to accomplish this result a slight modification of the product is usually required.
Example—the Scaling of Fish Step 1: Why is the Function Required? What does it prevent? What does it fix? What does it make up for? Does it counter something? Follow this reasoning back through the causal relationships. If a Cause-Effect Diagram is being used, it is easier to follow the chain of 144
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
reasoning back to the problems that the function helps to resolve. Practically, this is done on a Cause-Effect diagram by considering the existence of a tool or product of a function as an object attribute that causes the problem. (Seeing the function in the cause effect diagram reminds us that existences of the elements of the function are object attributes that should be considered.) When we consider non-existence of element in the system (in the side-by-side box), we begin an alternative problem path which leads us to understand why an element was originally required in the system. It is possible to remove the need for the troublesome element and often other elements by resolving a problem elsewhere in the system. This is done by tracing back the alternative problem path. Non-existence of a function element is shown with a new function which has no tool. The tool was required to perform a function which no longer is performed because the tool is missing. One solution of the alternative problem path is to find a new way to perform the function of the missing object. This often leads to the consideration of how the function might be performed by existing elements, thus simplifying the system. Scaling removes scales and underlying tissue that may change the flavor during cooking and are also disgusting to certain cultures to eat. This is a remedial action. Step 2: A slight change to an object in the system (often the object that we are serving) removes the requirement for the main function and hence the objects that deliver the function. In other words, if something did its job better then our system wouldn’t be needed. Consider changes to cooking methods that make scales a delicacy— Now the function of scaling is no longer required.
No Modification—Comes that Way In certain situations, a modification can be performed upstream by the provider of the elements more conveniently than later. The product may be in a much more convenient form to perform the function. This is often true in a manufacturing environment such as during assembly. Pre-coated or pre-assembled parts can be more conveniently assembled. Forming and cutting operations can be more conveniently done when the material is in a more convenient form. Pre-modifying the product often leads to a contradiction. The modification must and must not be made.
Idealize Useful Functions
145
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Pipe Forming Machine Pipe forming machines feed a flat ribbon into a forming Cutting tool machine that rolls the ribbon moves with into a tube and welds it. The the tube tubes are cut to length by a saw that moves with the formed tube while it is cutting to reduce the time to cut. Faster and faster forming rates require the cutter to return more rapidly.
This results in many additional problems. Consider the ideal product. The tube must be cut before it is formed. This slows production (compared to a single ribbon) so the tube must be cut and not cut. Step 1: The product does not require the modification because it is already incorporated. The tube is partially cut by stamping the tube before rolling. A hard twist fully cuts the tube.
Little Mod—Minimum Part If we have concluded that it is not possible to avoid the requirement for the modification, then we should consider modifying the least amount of the product as possible.
Modify only Part
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Every year innocent people are hurt or killed during high speed chasses. About 40 percent of high speed chases end in crashes. How can the car be stopped? Step 1: What minimum part of the What minimum product must be modified? Produce a list part of the car Stop of alternative products which are a can be stopped? minimized subset of the main product. By asking this, we can consider all subsets of Car the original product down to the molecular level. What if we only stop the driver, the tires, the drive shaft, the engine computer or carburetor, the tire, the electrical ignition spark?
146
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Natural Groupings of Similar Objects If we have concluded that the function is required, then let us get the most out of it that we can. Here we consider extending the function to as many elements as possible by looking for natural groupings. Extending the function to more of the same elements at the same time can reduce the overall amount of resources required.
Example—Shelling Nuts The evolutionary tendency of performing functions on multiple objects is to perform them in parallel. This can involve performing the function simultaneously on a grouping of objects, especially if these groups are natural groups such as a flock of geese, a mouthful of teeth, a pallet of objects, or a box of cereal. Step 1: Does the product come in natural batches or groups? The nuts come in a bag. Step 2: Is it more ideal to modify the group simultaneously? In this case, it would much more ideal to shell the whole bag of nuts at once. There are no guarantees that modifying the whole natural group will require fewer resources. At this point, we may not know how we may accomplish this feat, but we continue in hope of finding a physical phenomenon that can do this. Crack the whole bag of nuts.
Natural Groupings of Biased Products Biased products are products that are alike in function and other material ways, but in less significant ways different than each other. Nails come in different sizes. If a hammer can effectively drive a tiny nail and a large framing nail, it is more valuable to the user. A natural grouping of nails might be related to a certain type of construction job that requires a variety of nails. During this manufacture, it is desirable to perform the function on this group, at the same time or serially with the same system.
Example—Welding Required During Manufacture of Bicycles Step 1: Are there similar products that might require the same modification during a job or task? A variety of similar alloys must be welded during the manufacture of bicycles. Idealize Useful Functions
147
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: How much variation is there in the product? If the variation is small, then there is little requirement to modify a biased product. If the variety is large, then if the ability is too narrow, the system may have limited use. The variety of aluminum alloys is not high, but we should be able to weld all of these. (This is not a good example of a natural grouping) (Better—A heard of deer—young and old, strong and feeble)
Natural Groupings of Diverse Products Diverse products are products that are so different that, while they are associated with the same function, they are typically not associated with the same tool. Natural groupings of diverse products are objects that require the same function and are found together during a task or job.
Example—Cooking Bacon Step 1: For the given function product, what other elements in the system or super-system require the same modification? generally associated with bacon.
Eggs are
Step 2: Can they also be included in the modification? Yes, Eggs can be included. The heat is there, but usually there is an over abundance of bacon fat. Remember that we have only considered the possibility of doing these together. In some cases, finding the means to do this is simple.
Summarize the Ideal Product After considering all of the above possibilities, what are the insights that you have gained? This is a branching point in the decision path for this invention. What we decide from this point will be used to make further decisions. We can always return to this point if necessary.
148
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Modification for Useful Functions After focusing on the ideal product, the second part is the ideal modification. We ask “What do we really want to have happen and what are the attributes of the ideal modification?” Since we have not yet decided what will deliver these idealized modifications to the product, we are actually composing a wish-list of what the ideal modification will look like. When we add real elements to deliver the modification, these elements often bring undesirable characteristics with them. Since we are dealing with functions that are already useful, we would like to do the most good possible. It is easy to assume that because a useful function exists, that there is not a replacement function that is even better or that we might want to reverse things and perform the opposite function. The question is: What do we really want to happen?
How do We Identify the Ideal Modification? Let’s refer back to the concept that Altshuller proposed for solving problems that require guess work. Remember that a mathematical problem was proposed. How can we return with exactly six gallons of water if we have only a four and nine gallon bucket? Mathematical problems that normally require guess work when solved forward are often more rapidly solved by starting with the solution and then working backwards. Altshuller proposed that, since solving inventive problems also requires guess work, the solution will be more rapid and satisfying if we start with the ideal solution. Altshuller proposed another, more important, reason for solving backwards. Solutions that start with mental pictures of existing machines are usually variations on these structures and end up more complex than they need to be. We must free our minds of these structures by starting afresh with an ideal solution. Altshuller called this preferred end state or solution the Ideal Final Result. The process of identifying the Ideal Final Result was begun when we considered the ideal product. Now we must consider what must ideally happen to this ideal product, given that it still is required. Since the final result is actually a modification to the product, we can continue to write the Ideal Final Result in functional terms. This can be referred to as the Functional Ideal Final Result. At this stage, we will put together several Ideal Final Results by describing the modification in ideal terms. We must remove our inhibitions and let it magically happen. Since there may be Idealize Useful Functions
149
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
many ways to describe the modification that will give new insights, we consider a variety of ways to think of the modification that allow us to make better use of resources. In the process of looking for the IFR, we will also consider the reverse modification. It is easy to become locked into thinking of the function in the way that we always have. By asking what we are performing the function relative to, we see that there are other possibilities. As a matter of practicality, the function should be described correctly in order to achieve the most good. Please refer to the appendix if there are questions on how to write functions or deal with confusing functions.
Setting the Bar for How Well the Modification Must be Performed The next set of tools help us to decide the attributes of the ideal modification. At this stage, we continue our quest to identify several ideal modifications. If I could snap my fingers, how much modification do I really want? How well, how long, etc. Since it is possible to overdo a modification causing other problems, we may need to constrain ourselves by asking this in a slightly different way. What level of modification will give us a long-lasting solution? By doing this, we recognize a truth: eventually the system will evolve to a point that it must be improved again. In the mean time, it will not be necessary to change this parameter or even consider it very much. This is different than the common way of changing systems where a parameter is just improved enough to get by. This leads to legacy problems that continue to crop up with the next version of a product. It is important to note that insights derived at this stage have the ability to influence each other. Insights gained during one activity may be upset by insights gained in other activities. Consequently, it may be necessary to jump back and forth between tools.
Describe a Variety of Ideal Modifications What are ideal final results? Describe this in a variety Mod 1 of ways. What would I want to happen if I could do it Mod 2 magically by snapping my fingers? We would like to consider several ways because each way may lead to a different physical phenomenon to accomplish the function (depending on abundance of system resources). Some of these ways may be more ideal than others.
150
If I could snap my fingers...
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: Are we changing or controlling? Which makes the most sense? In this case, we want to control the speed of the car to a set speed. This speed may not be zero and in fact, it might be dangerous to stop a car in the middle of fast traffic. Step 2: Work backward by imagining several ideal final states. Using the longhand form of the modification, consider different ways to describe the modification. Consider moving from the macro world to the micro world (atomic level and beyond).
Control the speed Control the momentum Car
Example—Blade Loss of a Fanjet Engine A jet engine fan looses some fan blades. This is sometimes referred to a blade-out condition. It can be caused when an object is ingested into the engine such as a bird. Each of the blades carries a tremendous amount of kinetic energy. When one blade goes, it often takes out other blades. The effect is explosive. Step 1: Are we changing or controlling? Which makes the most sense? In this case, we are changing. The blades start in one state and we must move to another. Step 2: Work backward by imagining several ideal final states. Using the longhand form of the modification, consider different ways to describe the modification. Consider moving from the macro world to the micro world (atomic level and beyond).
Change the level of energy (zero) Change the blade direction Blades
Example—Heating a Gas How can we describe the heating of a gas? Step 1: Are we changing or controlling? We have already described this as a change of state, thus we are changing.
Idealize Useful Functions
151
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: Work backward by imagining several ideal final states. Using the longhand form of the modification, consider different ways to describe the modification. Consider moving from the macro world to the micro world (atomic level and beyond).
Change the temperature Change the average random velocity Change the velocity distribution
Gas
Consider an Ideal Inverse Modification Sometimes it is more ideal to do the reverse of the required action or modification. For instance, it may actually require fewer resources to move a person relative to a work object than it is to change the height of a heavy work object. In order to consider reversing a modification, it is necessary to consider what the action or modification is relative to. If two objects are moving relative to each other, it is usually easy to determine what the modification is relative to. With other modifications, it may take more thought.
Example—Pouring Hot Syrup into a Chocolate Container
Pour
Step 1: What object is the modification performed relative to? The pouring is relative to the stationary chocolate form Step 2: Invert the problem by modifying the relative object. (Make it Syrup the product). Thus, instead of pouring the syrup relative to the stationary chocolate form, we spread the chocolate relative to a stationary syrup form which has been frozen. Spread the chocolate onto the syrup. Step 3: Go back and describe this in a variety of ideal ways. Note that the variety of descriptions does not add a great deal to the understanding of how this function can be accomplished in this case.
152
Spread Chocolate
Change the thickness Change the position
Chocolate
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: What object is the modification performed relative to? The slowing is relative to the road. Step 2: Invert the problem by modifying the relative object. (Make it the product). Thus, instead of stopping the car, we speed up the road so that the car and road are moving at the same velocity. Step 3: Go back and describe this in a variety of ideal ways. Note that this tends to describe some fashion of lubrication between the road and the tires which was not previously considered.
Control the Speed Road
Control the speed Control the surface speed
Road
What is the Ideal Level of Modification? Determine the actual level of the ideal modification. This level usually involves a metric of some sort. As we begin to adjust the levels of the modification, we start to chip away at psychological inertia and gain insights. Perhaps what we are doing is not the correct function. Perhaps there are functions which are more ideal. (Note that these will give more knobs in causal analysis).
Example—Blade Loss of a Fanjet Engine We continue our consideration of the loss of blades for a Fanjet Engine. We will only consider one of the ideal modifications that were named which is to change the energy level of the blade. Step 1: If I could snap my fingers, what would the ideal level be? The energy should dissipate low enough as to never reach the cabin. Essentially, the blades have zero kinetic energy relative to the aircraft.
Idealize Useful Functions
153
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: If I could snap my fingers, what would the ideal level be? Continuing with the example of a police officer stopping a speeding car, we realize that bringing the car to a complete stop may not be required or even desirable. It may be more desirable to control the maximum speed of the car. This allows us to control the situation better. For instance, if the car is already stopped, then we may want to guarantee that it is stopped for good. On the other hand, if the car is moving at a high rate of speed on a busy freeway, stopping the car might be dangerous to other cars. It may be better if the car were gradually slowed rather than stopped.
What is the Ideal Sequence of the Function? Considering the ideal sequence will continue to give us more insights into the ideal modification. As we consider when it should occur, it may affect what we believe the ideal modification should be. A powerful tool for investigating this is the process map. This can be accomplished in a variety of ways, including a storyboard or simply words in sequence. However it is done, it is nice to show the possibility of functions performed in parallel as this will be one of the considerations that we make.
154
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: Create a process map of the sequence of functions. The subject function should show up as a block in the process map. If we start at the beginning of a typical car chase, the car has just been pulled over and the officer is walking to the other car. This is the most likely time for the occupant to become scared and to speed away or “bolt”. Notice in the following process map that we could have used functional language throughout. Also, the ideal function is located wherever psychological inertia places it. That is fine to begin with. Officer Identifies Car to Pull Over
Officer Flags down the Car
Both Cars Pull Over and Stop
Officer Walks toward Car
Occupant Speeds Away
Occupant Gets Scared
Car Stops
Officers Limit Options
Officer Returns to Car
Officer Requests Help
Occupant Increases Speed
Officer Pursues
Officers “Bumps” Car (Very Dangerous)
Car Strikes Object (Very Dangerous)
Stop
Car
Step 2: Consider performing the function in different sequences. Move it earlier or later than currently performed. Try moving it so far forward that it is no longer during the normal process sequence. Consider moving it so Idealize Useful Functions
155
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
far backward that it is no longer part of the ordinary sequence. In this case, it probably does not make sense to stop the car until it has had a chance to pull over. In the less likely event that the car begins speeding away when the officer flags it down, then there may be a need to stop it at that moment. Now remember, it is possible to consider the more ideal situation where the occupant is not scared, etc. This all presupposes that we have already determined these other functions and are idealizing them on other paths. It also presupposes that we have considered other more ideal modifications and products and are working on this one specifically. The question that we are answering here is where is the most ideal place to put the function of stopping the car. Officer Identifies Car to Pull Over
Officer Flags down the Car
Both Cars Pull Over and Stop
Officer Walks toward Car
Officer Performs Duty
Stop
Occupant Gets Scared
Another possibility is that the car bolts and the officer does not pursue at all! The car will be stopped later when it is safer, or the occupant will stop the car. The occupant can see that the officer is simply standing there and not pursuing. This allows for a less panicked state which keeps speeds lower. Perhaps the fact that officers will no longer pursue has become well publicized. And it becomes common knowledge that the car is being tracked by a high observer such as a surveillance craft or satellite. The occupant then has to pursue another strategy which usually involves abandoning the car. This puts the function of stopping the car far later than normal.
156
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 3: Can the function be performed in parallel with other functions? Can the function be performed during other functions such as during transportation or while queued or waiting. Can setup be performed at the same time as the operation? Rapid setup often implies the use of a previously placed tool. Could other tools help out at another time or sequence? This creates new possibilities, for instance, the car can be disabled while it is already stopping for a traffic light or stop sign. If this can be done safely, before the occupant is aware of what is happening. This precludes the problem of speeding away, but now this raises other problems such as how other drivers will react when a car is stopped. There are also many people who would never consider speeding away and this becomes a needless embarrassment for them. It is also necessary to stop the car in such a way that the occupants and the car are out of harm’s Officer Identifies Car to Pull Over
Officer Waits for Car to Stop
Officer Walks toward Car
Stop
Officer Performs Duty
Occupant Gets Scared
way. Such may not be the case if the car is stopped on a busy street. This highlights the fact that idealizing the system may cause other problems which can be avoided now (by choosing a different sequence) or later, by fixing the system. Step 4: Create a process map of the desired function and break it down into finer detail. Some Feature of Car is Disabled
Car Slows Down
Car Comes to Full Stop
Step 5: Can the modification be broken into two (or more) stages? Does this allow for parallel processes to accomplish the main function, or does it allow for a more optimum sequencing of functions? It may be that the car is not stopped, but first limited in speed to 25 mph. The car can now pull over and remove itself from traffic with the officer following. This brings up the idea that the more ideal possibility is to be able to limit the maximum speed of the car at a distance in such a way that the driver cannot tell the difference between this and a “malfunctioning” car. Idealize Useful Functions
157
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
What is the Ideal Duration? The ideal sequence is strongly influenced by the duration of the function. Likewise, duration of the function is strongly influenced by the sequence of the function.
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: If the modification were performed very rapidly, would other harmful functions be precluded? Yes, if the car could be stopped instantly, before it was able to get out into traffic, many dangerous or harmful functions could be avoided. Step 2: How much time do we have after it is normally performed that it would be allowable to continue performing the function? If the modification were performed very slowly (hours, days, weeks, months, years) would this be harmful or could this actually help in the performance of other functions? Stopping the car permanently could be viewed as a punishment for trying to speed away. This might serve as a deterrent.
What is the Ideal Duty Cycle? Ideality requires that all objects perform as many functions as possible, as much of the time as possible. Systems that idle waste valuable resources. Consequently, it is important to consider idealizing the function by requiring the system to work all of the time.
Example—Stopping Speeding Cars Continuing with our example of stopping speeding cars, we ask whether the stopping system can be in operation at all times. Since the need to stop cars is not continuous, it would be necessary to re-describe the function in terms that can apply to objects other than cars.
158
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 1: Are there opportunities for the system to run all the time? Is this even desirable considering the current product? Ideally, objects in the system will be at full capacity. In the case of stopping speeding cars, there is no requirement to stop cars continuously. Step 2: Are there other objects in the job that require the function? Should the function be reframed to consider these other objects? Yes, it would be Car Fleeing desirable to stop a human that Occupant Occupant abandons the car. If we redefine the problem as stopping the car occupants, whether they are moving or in a car, the system becomes much more ideal. Step 3: Should the modification be performed along the entire path, both coming and going? This usually applies to machines which have repetitive motions. In this case it probably does not apply except to say that the function of stopping the cars occupants should be possible regardless of which direction they are moving, even in reverse. Step 4: Should dummy runs and downtimes be allowed? I suppose that down times are allowed if all we are stopping are the occupants. It should not be necessary to have a test run before it is used each time to stop a car.
What is the Ideal Adjustability and Continuity of Adjustment? If we haven’t already touched on this in some way, then we will deal with the subject of variability here. Lines of evolution suggest that the control of functions become more and more adjustable. At first, the process is fixed. Next it becomes adjustable to at least discrete levels. Next, the adjustment must become continuous. Next, some form of control scheme is used to adjust the function for changing conditions. The first form of control often turns the function on or off. This is often referred to as “bang-bang” control. The next form of control is referred to as open-loop control. This means that a change is sensed somewhere and the mechanism that controls the function is given a set command that hopefully puts the output in the required realm. The next form of control uses feedback which continuously or discretely controls the function. Each level of adjustment and control increase the complexity of the system. It is important here to not go overboard in assigning an ideal level of adjustability. We can over-constrain the system. This sounds too much like a compromise, but here we will Idealize Useful Functions
159
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
consider only an acceptable level of adjustment that will allow this system to operate for a long time without change. This is not much of a compromise.
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: Consider different and perhaps extreme operating environments. Decide whether or not it must be capable of adapting to these different environments. The car must be stopped in difficult weather conditions such as rain, snow, high heat, at night or day. The occupant must be stopped regardless of the position that they are in, either running or crouching low in the car. It must be capable of stopping the occupant regardless of obstacles that they hide behind such as seats, windows, car walls or trees and rocks once the occupant leaves the vehicle. Step 2: Consider adjustability to a variety of products. How much variation can we stand in the product? Consider biased products (objects which are of the same type, but have some differences in an important attribute like nails of various sizes or roses of different shades). Consider objects with much greater differences such as the difference between edible plants. Step 3: The method of stopping must work regardless of the gender or size of the occupant. It must also work regardless of the equipment that they might be operating or carrying. Step 4: What granularity of adjustment is necessary? Can the adjustment be discrete? If so, what is the discrete step size? In this case, the adjustment could be fairly granular. We would like to limit the occupant or former occupant to a variety of speeds. Step 5: Does the adjustment need to be continuous or should it require continuous feedback? The adjustment could use some form of open-loop control if the officer provides the feedback. Some form of feedback may be necessary, however to reduce the concentration burden of the officer.
What is the Ideal Use of Energy Many modern conveniences save time at the expense of energy waste. We almost always use more energy than is required because energy is cheap. The unfortunate consequence is the cumulative energy and its costs. Considering the least energy that is required to perform the function will give the innovator a very different idea of what the ideal function is.
160
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Leaf Blower Step 1: Consider the least energy 20 ft required to perform the function. In this case, the debris must be moved a horizontal distance of 20 feet and up 5 feet to be placed in a garbage can or storage receptacle. The least energy that is required to perform this function is the potential energy change. (Weight times the height). It is very small (and certainly much smaller than the energy which will be expended with a leaf blower).
20 ft
Move
Leaves
Turning Function Burden to Blessing Usually, we do not think of a raw function as having burdens. This usually occurs when the tool of the function is added. Unfortunately, there are burdens that are almost unavoidable. When we stop a car, the energy must be extracted. Regardless of the way that we do this, the energy must leave the car. This is a burden. We can turn this burden into a blessing by using this energy to perform another function. Without deciding yet how this is going to happen, we are setting ourselves up to identify a physical phenomenon that can perform a second useful function with the energy that is removed from the car. Let’s look at this example.
Example—Stopping a Car Step 1: Identify unavoidable burdens which come with a function. Energy loss comes with stopping any car. Step 2: Identify a second function which uses the burden to perform a useful function. This energy can be used to accelerate the same or a second car.
Idealize Useful Functions
Stop
Car
Accelerate
Car
161
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
When Should It Be Excluded? (The Zero Zero
Function4) The zero function is the intended absence of a function under certain conditions. We should have full control over the function when its existence would be dangerous or otherwise harmful.
Example—A Safer Gun Many are killed due to accidental handgun accidents. Children, in particular, are susceptible. Additionally, law enforcement officers sometimes become the victims of their own weapons. Step 1: Identify times when the primary functions are harmful. Harmful functions are most likely to occur when the gun is not in the hands of the owner. If a police officer is not in possession of his weapon, and a suspect has it, this is potentially very harmful. Step 2: Consider providing the zero function and means for detecting and controlling the function during these times. The Gun cannot shoot unless it is being held by the correct person.
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Is there a chance that we want to disable the possibility of stopping or controlling a speeding car? Step 1: Identify times when the primary functions are harmful. It may be harmful if the device can be used on a law enforcement vehicle. If the device is harmful to adults, children may be very susceptible to harm. Perhaps it cannot be used when children are present. Step 2: Consider providing the zero function and means for detecting and controlling the function during these times. The function will not be provided with children or law enforcement vehicles present.
4
Greg Yezersky, General Theory of Innovation Feb 2006
162
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Physical Phenomenon for Useful Functions What we know what we want to do, we are now prepared to talk about how we are going to deliver the function. We deliver functions with physical phenomena which are in turn delivered by the tool. The tool and the physical phenomena often come together, but for our purposes we will consider them separately as potential physical phenomena. As taught in school, physical phenomena are a human abstract of fields and substances arranges in special architectures that do something recognizable. When we talk about buoyancy as a physical phenomenon, we are talking about several substances and several fields that interact to cause objects to float in their surrounding fluid. We recognize that this works in water and in the air. Buoyancy can be used to do things. It is a means to an end if we want. It is rare that only one substance and/or field is involved. For those who have learned physics, they recognize that the study of physics is primarily the study of physical phenomena. This is fortunate because it helps the user to understand how to calculate the effects of the associated parameters. The decision of what physical phenomena to use to deliver a function is often ignored or taken for granted. Whenever we ignore or take for granted, we are assuming. Whenever we assume, we are subject to psychological inertia. We may not recognize that there are more ideal physical phenomena that can be used to deliver our modification to the tool. We may be ignoring free resources in the environment or in the job that can be used to simplify the system. Even though, a physical phenomenon may not be ideal, we need to additionally consider whether the timing is right to change it. This decision should not be taken lightly as changing to a new physical phenomenon can lead to a lot of headaches. If it is not time to change, this whole section can be skipped. There are many avenues for identifying physical phenomena. Many of physical phenomena are already in-use to perform the function. Some need to be transported from other industries. Once we have them, we need to sort through them to find the most ideal. In the event that we cannot identify a good physical phenomenon to meet our needs, there is always the option to go searching for new phenomena. This should only be done if absolutely necessary as it requires the heart and soul of the researcher. Means are given to look for new phenomena. This is a new area for TRIZ and the methods are experimental. Idealize Useful Functions
163
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Is it Time for a New Physical Phenomenon? This is a question that should not be taken lightly. This decision has great ramifications on the amount of work that will be required to make your product or service work. Generally speaking, when you change to a new physical phenomenon, there are many unknowns about the new phenomenon. Perhaps you are lucky and you are involved with someone that is experienced in the new phenomenon. This makes the possibility of bridging to the new phenomenon much easier. Remember that the new product or service must compete with one that has been polished for many years. Changing to a new physical phenomenon can increase the required work substantially.
Review the Evolutionary History Knowing the history of a product helps to understand the main evolutionary trends. Each product has a main evolutionary tendency. The tendency of a system to stall along this evolutionary path is largely a function of the technical problems that directly conflict with this evolutionary tendency. You have already conducted a patent search within your industry so you have a lot of information about the history. This step can take a lot of time, but the information is extremely valuable from the viewpoint of continued steps. The inventor is becoming a true expert in this field.
Example—Postal Services Consider the transport of objects for pay such as postal services. Step 1: From patents and literature, study the history of the functions that are typically involved in the job. What functions have been added over time? What main physical parameters have improved? Things improved with postal services: The purchasing of service; delivery of object to point of use; the protection of objects (container movement); the tracking of objects and informing customer; the speed of movement of objects. Step 2: From patents and literature, study the history of the technologies (physical phenomena) that typically deliver these functions. How have these technologies changed? If we look at the actual physical means of delivering objects we see a continual transition to the fastest modes of general transportation: RunnersÆ HorsesÆ CarriagesÆ 164
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
WagonsÆ Trains or BoatsÆ TrucksÆ Planes. With these transitions other improvements came in the form of speed, protection from damage and knowledge of object location.
Plot the Course of Disruptive Technologies We have already discussed disruptive technologies in some depth. If you feel that a disruptive technology is threatening you, it may be wise to look at how rapid this encroachment is occurring. This analysis takes a great deal of time, so it is usually not useful unless an imminent threat is detected.
#1 Capability #1
Market (Job) #2 Capability #2
Market
(Job)
Speed
Method Time Step 1: Each recognized market (job) is focused on a competitive parameter. Determine the competitive parameter. The progression of competitive parameters is as follows:
—Performance of the main parameter (speed, power, etc) —Reliability —Convenience —Cost Step 2: Plot this main competitive parameter for the most advanced leaders with respect to time for each market (job). This gives the capability curve. Step 3: Plot the average of the competitive parameter for all products for that market. This gives the demand curve for each market. Step 4: If the capability of the lower performing market appears to be on a course to cross the demand line of the market with the upper capability, then it is imperative that you find a way to switch to the phenomenon used by the encroaching market. It may be necessary to spin off an independent group which is given proper resources and incentives to market this new technology. This may be difficult since the new market is likely to have developed new delivery channels. The more likely approach to overcoming a disruptive technology is to use a hybrid of the new and old physical phenomenon.
Idealize Useful Functions
165
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Determine the System Maturity from Patents The maturity of systems can be determined by several means. One means is by the study of patents. This involves understanding the increase in performance of the main technical parameter related to main technical function, the level of invention and the number of patents over time. The method shown is very time consuming and should only be applied if other methods prove ineffective in showing the importance of switching to a new physical phenomenon.
Method for Examining System Maturity Step 1: Identify the technical parameter related to the main function. Quantify how this has improved over time. Step 2: Identify how the level of invention has changed over time. The level of invention is typically high when changing to a new physical phenomenon. It peaks again during the period of rapid growth as resources are made available from sales. Later, it levels off as system resources are exhausted. The level of invention is as follows: 1. No resolution of contradiction.
Technical Maturity Parameter Related to the
Infancy
Stagnation
Rapid growth
Main Function Level of Invention
Number Of Patents Per year
2. Resolves contradiction with small change. 3. Resolves contradictions with a major change. Uses a technology from the same field. 4. Resolves a contradiction. Complete change in physical phenomenon. This is usually a technology from another field. 5. New Physical Phenomenon. Has ability to change the super-system to which it belongs. Step 3: Quantify the number of patents per year.
166
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Is it Time for a New Physical Phenomenon? The main reason that we would like to know the system maturity is because it is particularly important to determine whether there is a need to change to a new physical phenomenon to perform the main modification of the system product. A new physical phenomenon typically brings fresh resources which allow continued evolution of the function or the job that is being performed. Unfortunately, it typically involves unknown risks and unfamiliarity of the side effects of the new phenomenon. An additional shortcoming of going to a new physical phenomenon is that the customer has come to accept certain levels of performance which will almost certainly not be achieved unless the transition is brought about through the use of hybrid phenomena which will be described later.
Required Conditions for a New Phenomenon If several of the below conditions are present then consider a new physical phenomenon to deliver the main modification. Condition 1: The super-system has become very specialized. In the beginning, row boats were very crude and usually created from single trunks of trees. As time went on, they evolved to specialized uses including fishing, transportation of goods and conducting warfare. These variations became very specialized with warships having multiple levels of oars. Condition 2: The super-system has reached the point of diminishing return. Are the main technical parameters improving very slowly? An example of a system that has reached the point of diminished return is the fanjet engine. The amount of fuel burned per unit of thrust is improving in the single digit range. This is largely due to the high degree of regulation in the airline industry for the sake of safety. Improvements are absorbed slowly so as to ensure that unintended affects are minimized. Condition 3: Automatic feedback is used to perform the main super-system function. By the point that systems are using massive feedback, we can usually assume that the system is running out of resources. This is because the use of feedback is costly and indicates that costly improvements are required to bring minor changes to performance. A fanjet engine is again a good example of feedback which is employed in almost every major function on the engine. Idealize Useful Functions
167
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Condition 4: Multiple conflicts must be resolved for large improvements. (Many rocks appear when we begin to drain the pond). It is typical that products and services will be filled with compromise “solutions”. Between major improvements in the product, there is a tendency to ignore risks and to live with compromises. As time goes on and the product becomes specialized, these compromises mount up until changes in the operating environment expose multiple compromises. Going back to our example of the aircraft engine, temperatures are always increasing within the engine to increase engine efficiency. This increase in temperature exposes the weakness of multiple components.
Is a Hybrid or Stand-alone Phenomenon More Appropriate? Trying to satisfy an entrenched sustaining Introduction market will be unlikely with a completely new of Hybrid physical phenomenon as some very important competitive parameter will almost certainly be Competitive compromised. The sustaining market will Parameter demand that we not depart from the s-curve of Introduction of Stand-alone the existing effect. New markets will be much Physical Phenomenon (Potentially Disruptive) more forgiving and may even welcome the weaknesses of the new physical phenomenon as strength. The new Phenomenon will gather strength as a hybrid and eventually replace the old phenomenon or it will gather strength as a stand-alone phenomenon in the new market. Clayton Christensen points out, it is possible that the new stand-alone phenomenon will develop along its own s-curve and eventually become a disruptive technology, taking away market share from the existing sustaining markets. Also, if the existing phenomenon is in the rapid growth part of the S-Curve, it will be difficult to catch up. Greater resources will keep the performance ahead of the new phenomena.
168
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Stand-alone Electric Cars Step 1: If the market is a recognized and mature market then consider a hybrid of the old and new phenomenon. Hybrid Car—Gas and Electric Step 2: If the market is an emerging or unrecognized market then consider using a completely new physical phenomena in which the native weaknesses of the physical phenomena are considered to be a strength. (Usually starts small) Electric Car for Teen Drivers — Extremely safe enclosure — Limited speeds — Restricted driving range — Full entertainment system
Idealize Useful Functions
169
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Physical Phenomenon for Useful Functions In this step, we consider which physical phenomena can perform the modification to the product that we desire. The decision of which physical phenomenon to use will come after seeing what resources are available. So, we are not making a decision at this point, but rather identifying potential physical phenomena. We create a fertile situation so that when the right tool is presented, we can see its merit. In effect, we are sensitizing our minds for the next step in which we consider the substance, object and field resources around us. Armed with the knowledge of what is possible, it will be easier to identify the value of a resource when we see it. Some of the phenomena that we consider in this stage may seem a little wild or too weak to perform the function. Remember that there are ways to tame wild phenomena. Weak phenomena can often be boosted in latter stages of the algorithm. Therefore, it is important to keep an open mind to the possibilities.
In-Use Physical Phenomena The first phenomena we should look at are the phenomena in use in the given industry. We will refer to these as In-Use. It is perfectly fine to consider these phenomena. After all, successful products have already been built using them.
“New” Physical Phenomena The second set of phenomena is those that can deliver the required function, but are not available in the given industry. While the phenomena that we discover may not be new in the sense that we have discovered them from research, they may be new to the industry. If we have determined that it is time to change form the given physical phenomenon, then these candidates may be what we need.
The Ideal Physical Phenomena Must Have a Chance to Compete The ideal resource is capable of holding its own. It must be abundant and capable of providing as many functions as possible. In the final set of tools, we consider which potential phenomena would be the most ideal. We “filter” for certain characteristics. What we have left over are the most likely candidates.
170
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
In-Use—Identify the Competitive Alternative through Observation and Questioning Here we learn about potential physical phenomena from competitive alternatives. Competitive alternatives are any systems that can potentially compete with the system that you are simplifying or creating. A newspaper is competition for the television. Car or truck transportation is competition for airline travel. The competitive alternative is what people currently use and what they would use if they didn’t have what they are currently using. Remember that this is not necessarily what you would consider to be direct business competition. For a pet watering bowl, the competitive alternative might be a large bucket. In the early stages, Southwest Airlines did not compete against other airlines; they were in competition with traveling by car. It is very tempting to go on personal experience to answer this question, but this is a trap. Often, inventors assume that they are like everyone else. There is wisdom in going to the battle to see how it is really being waged. There is no substitute for this. Don’t be satisfied with talking to a few people.
Method Step 1: Observe what the target market currently does to satisfy this function. If possible, go and watch before talking. By observing you get to the truth. What people do and what they say that they do are often two different things. Step 2: Ask how they satisfy this function and what they would do if they didn’t have what they currently use. This may give some valuable information into the history of the function. They will often offer what they did way back when... Step 3: Identify what “extreme users” currently do to satisfy this function and what they would do if they weren’t using their current means. Extreme users often have a range of experience with uncommon ways to satisfy a function. Step 4: Ask everyone that you interview where they go for the source of items and products that they need to do these jobs. This will set you up for the next step.
Idealize Useful Functions
171
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
In-Use—Observe Existing Products While competitive alternatives can be anything that others would use if they were not using our system, there may be obvious competitors in the market place. Let’s go to the store to see what these products and services are.
Example—Pet Food Container Step 1: Go to a store that would sell products that deliver the required modification. I am interested in containers that serve pet food, so I go to a pet store or the pet section of a department or grocery store. Step 2: Note brands and producers. Do the producers sell more than one product? Who are the main producers? I note that there are three main manufacturers that sell products in the category that I am interested in. Step 3: Look for product trends. The trend is to combine the food bowls with large storage containers and to keep the food at a level that is comfortable for the pet. Step 4: Read the labels. What do they claim? claims to slow down bugs.
One
In-Use—Internet Product Search Learn from the competitive alternatives (Remember that these may not be direct competitors). What jobs do they do? What functions do they perform? What Physical Phenomena delivers the functions? If you are searching for an unrecognized market and you find a major competitor then go back to the drawing board.
Example—Stopping a Speeding Car Step 1: Use an internet search-engine to determine what products are offered. “Stop-Sticks” are found on police equipment websites. They are a triangular shaped device that cost $380 per set and can be deployed by throwing them into the road way. The occupant has little time to react and often rolls over them. The sticks can immediately be pulled back to allowing pursuing law enforcement cars to pass unharmed. As an added feature, the stop sticks are replaced if damaged for up to 4 years. It takes a fair amount of training to use them. If they are thrown too early, the occupant has time to swerve, potentially into the officers throwing 172
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
them. A “marker” is used on the side of the road to time the throw. When the fleeing car passes the marker, the stop sticks are thrown out. One tricky feature is that the officer needs to be close enough to throw the sticks, which may put them into a dangerous situation. They come with 80 ft of cord to pull them out of the path or into the path of cars. This does not mean that the officer can be 80 feet away when throwing the stop sticks. An interesting feature of these stop sticks is the number of police officers killed while deploying them. The most common fatalities have to do with drivers swerving to avoid the sticks and striking officers. Others have been killed while trying to retrieve them. Sadly, they are sometimes killed by the pursuing police car. They may try to retrieve them to keep pursuing law enforcement cars from also running over the stop sticks. Another tricky feature is that pursuing officers are often very close behind the speeding car. It is difficult to convey at what point the sticks may be thrown out. The police car may also try to swerve to avoid them which endanger officers trying to deploy them. Another problem reported is the use of stop sticks on people that were not breaking the law. Another competitive alternative is tire spikes—these range from $400 to $800. These spikes spread out to as long as 25 ft. They are capable of piercing truck tires. The tines can be replaced in seconds should they become damaged. The spikes enter the tires and break free from the retainer. They are hollow and slowly deflate the tire to avoid dangerous blowouts. Another competitive alternative is the X-Net. This is a netting covered with spikes. The spikes attach to the wheels and the net is wound onto the wheel thus stopping it. It is purported to be capable of stopping vehicles in excess of 10,000 lbs. Step 2: Refine the search by noting and using nomenclature and names that are common to the industry. Stop Tech Ltd. is the company that makes Stop Sticks. Step 3: Consider cheap competitive alternatives. I could not detect any cheap alternatives. Big rocks would be too dangerous, especially for pursuing police officers.
Idealize Useful Functions
173
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
In-Use—Check for Disruptive Technologies This tool is especially important to consider when targeting a market segment that is already consuming and in which you are trying to sustain the momentum. It is easy to get caught up in calling any great innovation a disruptive technology, but be careful how this term is used. Disruptive technologies are products and services that are typically disruptive to a business practice. Ultimately, they are so disruptive that many great businesses can no longer compete. The ones that you typically have to be concerned with are those that may disrupt your business. For instance, they do not give the margins that you have come to expect. They do not intersect your supply chain. They do not satisfy the same levels of performance that your main customers have become accustomed to. They require new vendors. Often, a disruptive technology will require a whole new business model. This is the most disruptive of all. As management considers these technologies, they will seem distasteful and will reject them because they feel that they are doing this in the best interest of their company. Remember, they are held captive by their largest customers. Few resources are left over for other customers and disruptive technologies. These disruptive offerings are generally initiated in industries that are not your own, but may be closely adjacent. They satisfy someone that is not currently purchasing from you, so they seem innocent. They usually do not perform at sufficient levels to attract the attention of your main customers. This is because they are designed to perform the same functions that your products perform, only for other markets. As these offerings increase in performance, eventually, they will have the capability of satisfying low-end customers in your market. Again, this seems innocent as these low end customers are not important to your business as you move up-market to gain higher and higher margins. Slowly, these offerings will gain in performance as they are fueled by the cash coming into these markets until you find that they are cutting into your mainline customers. Often, it is too late at this point because of the resources required to change over. Developing a whole new supply chain is very impractical. History has shown that it is nearly impossible to copy a disruptive technology at this point. Vendors are often locked up while supplying the new supply chain. Consumers have loyalty to the early products. You might ask why we are not intent upon creating technologies which are disruptive to our main competitors. While it is possible to create technologies that are disruptive to other’s businesses, this strategy can only work if your company is open to destructive creation of products and to the creation of new business models, usually in completely separate business units than your legacy products. In order to disrupt existing competition, you will ultimately cannibalize yourself. Remember that these are your competitors and you are competing for the 174
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
same market. If the market of your competitor begins to move to your new product, they must also stop buying your legacy product. Most companies will find that it is usually better to try to satisfy a market that will not likely compete with your market. If you pick a non-consuming market to satisfy, there are many opportunities to create new offerings. The need to compete is virtually eliminated. You would only do this out of spite for the competitor which is not really a good business practice and will generally take you nowhere. If you are still determined to create a disruptive business for your competitor, there are more hurdles. This disruptive technology will need to compete against your biggest customers for resources. It will also be necessary to change long-held company values at the highest levels of the business. It is hard to admit that your business strategy and company values are wrong. In order to make this kind of change a lot of people have to be aligned and committed. If they are not convinced, they will likely revolt in passive ways that are hard to detect and counter. A better approach than directly disrupting your business would be to start a new business built on a learning approach with its own resources. This business will create its own business model and supply train from scratch. Finally, if you are still determined to create a disruptive technology within an existing business, you must recognize that, the business needs to have an offering which can stand on its own in some market. This is a large challenge on its own as most offerings fail due to all of the market conditions. In summary, it is usually not a good practice to try to create a disruptive technology (disruptive to you) within an existing business and customer base. The more likely place to create disruptive technologies is with new business startups. These have the ability to recognize market segments that are not being served. The reason for considering this step here is that others may be encroaching on your market and it is necessary to consider the physical phenomena that this disruptive technology is using. We do this because there is a way out of this trap and that is hybrid phenomena. Hybrid phenomena are the combination of two phenomena in such a way that the performance gained by one phenomenon compliments the other. In this way, the new phenomena can be used to better satisfy the existing market. This would be difficult to do if we made a sudden jump to the new phenomenon. When this occurs the performance is usually less than what the existing market expects. According to evolution of systems, when we move between physical phenomena, there is usually a transitional state through hybrid phenomena. A recent example of this is hybrid electric and petrol fueled vehicles. Checking for disruptive technologies amounts to looking for analogous functions in closely adjacent markets and then looking for how those functions are delivered. There are usually people in the business that have seen technologies that they would like to bring into the business. They may sense that these technologies will one day compete with them or that they could be Idealize Useful Functions
175
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
exploited with current customers, but there is little support within the businesses. History has shown that many toppled businesses have seen these disruptors coming but were unable to respond adequately. The typical response is to try to force these disruptive technologies into existing markets with disastrous results. The new phenomenon is not capable of delivering the performance that the existing market has come to expect. As mentioned, the strategy that typically works is to strive for a hybrid technology that enhances the current technology. Once established, the new phenomenon will begin to take over from the existing phenomenon, all the while satisfying existing customers.
Method Step 1: Identify technologies that exist in adjacent markets that seem to be threatening the existing business. These may be low cost alternatives or alternatives that use a different physical phenomenon to deliver the function. Step 2: Identify the physical phenomenon that is used to deliver the function. It is likely that this will later be considered for a hybrid physical phenomenon to satisfy the target market.
In-Use—Patent Searching and Study One of the best times for performing a patent search is when you 6,543,345 are searching for physical phenomena to deliver a function. During this particular step, we will be considering searching for 5,678,432 physical phenomena inside the given industry. Later, we will be 3,234,211 searching for patents outside the industry as we identify analogous situations. Not only will we better understand the possible physical phenomena that can be used, it is inevitable that other types of valuable information will be gathered along the way. Most people wait too long in the inventive process to perform a patent search. It is usually done after much time and expense to develop their invention. Often they find that someone has already patented their idea or that more useful and elegant concepts are available. This can be quite a blow! Waiting too long occurs for a variety of reasons: First, people get excited about an idea and they want to develop it without delay. It is easy to get very excited about what the future will bring. Wealth and fame are at your fingertips! There is no time to waste! The idea must put on the market before someone steals it or you lose your drive! This fear is usually unfounded and based on the idea that if we had the idea then the conditions are ripe for someone else to have it. Be patient, there are many inventions to be had if this one doesn’t pan out. Secondly, considering a patent search can invoke fear. It is like knowing that you should see the doctor while fearing that he will give you bad news. It is easy to this put off, but, like going to 176
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
the doctor, the time investment is small compared to the time that can be wasted by not acting. It typically takes a Saturday morning to do a thorough patent search which is a small investment compared to the typical development time for an invention. Even though the resulting information can be somewhat deflating, it is better to start with a realistic view. Thirdly, a patent search can appear to be beyond our capabilities. After all, people are employed full time to do patent searches! Again, this fear is unfounded. It is important to remember that you have several advantages that professional patent searchers do not have. You are motivated by the prospects of your idea. (A patent examiner is employed for money and is obligated to perform to certain minimum standards). You are not constrained by time and can afford to search to the bitter end. (Not all patent examiners are thorough and there may be time constraints on some examiners). You are more familiar with the technology than they are. (They do not have the time to become expert at the technologies that you are interested in). With a little practice, this overwhelming task can become natural and commonplace. Forth, understanding patents is difficult. Admittedly, patents have their own language. In this language, there is no legal prohibition to making up words! Patents can seem very stiff and…legal. Remember that it is in the favor of the legal profession that they look this way. We can easily convince ourselves that only patent attorneys can read patents. On the contrary, anyone can thoroughly understand a patent if they are willing to take the time. They have a repeatable structure, so you can learn the parts of the patent that you need to go to for specific information. Remember that it is much easier to learn to read patents when you are motivated by an idea. This will force you into the patent. Read it, digest it, and diagram it. Soon, you will be speaking “patenteze”. Reading and understanding your first patent may take you a half day, but the next patent will go much faster. Fifth, some feel that seeing what others have done will keep them from looking “outside the box”. Sure, there is a possibility that this can temporarily happen, but remember that this whole book is about making us uncomfortable inside the box. There are multiple opportunities to kick ourselves outside. Also, lots of additional information is learned along the way that strengthens our general understanding of physics. Understanding a broad spectrum of physical phenomena will make you a better inventor! Where we get into trouble is by studying only certain areas of physics deeply. Remaining “specialists” can have a constraining effect on our imagination. It is ok that you do not understand everything about patents when you begin your search. True, like first time car drivers, it is impossible to know what you do not know, but you have to start somewhere. If you make mistakes, remember that there are is a world of potential inventions out there. Dive in and you will find that you have more capacity than you thought! There is a wealth of information in patents that is often overlooked. Patents are structured so that others can duplicate the results of an invention. Consequently, it is necessary to give away many details. Most patents begin with a description of the typical approaches that are already Idealize Useful Functions
177
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
available. This sets the stage for why their idea is an improvement. It usually gives the history of the problem (and sometimes the industry) and also a look at alternative physical phenomena that have been used. Following this section is a description of the invention and why it is an improvement. This gives details into new physical phenomena that may have been used. It may describe how various object attributes affect the operation of the product. You may also be able to detect how the inventor overcame various contradictions. Clearly articulating the contradiction that was solved helps an inventor explain why their invention is “non-obvious to those experienced in the art”. This is the main hurdle that is required to get a patent. Next is a detailed description of the architecture of the invention. This gives valuable clues concerning the details of the physics. Finally, the claims section gives an idea to the scope of what the patent examiner thought was allowable to claim for the invention. Unless you are having problems with your computer, it takes about two hours to prepare for your first patent search. Mostly, this involves setting up links in your browser and a patent viewer. The patent viewer is important because looking at pictures conveys information much more rapidly then reading patenteze. Here is how to setup your computer browser with the necessary bookmarks to do a basic patent search: Step 1: Go to www.uspto.gov. This is the official patent website for the US government. If you take the time to familiarize yourself with this site, you will discover that a lot of effort has been made to make patent search and application easier for individuals. All of the forms are available for self application. There seems to be a bias towards helping individuals over corporations. You will particularly notice this if you submit a patent for consideration (this is called prosecuting a patent). People at the patent office sometimes bend over backward to help individuals, especially ones that have never been through the process before. Step 2: On the home page, go to “Patents”. You will find this on the left-hand side. If you click on this, a drop down will show you a several links. “Search Patents” is down the list a little. Go to this and bookmark it with a memorable name. You can also find this at http://www.uspto.gov/patft/index.html. This page is the main page for beginning patent searches. It allows for a variety of patent search formats. Step 3: Download the patent viewer for viewing patent drawings. As mentioned, viewing the patents will help immeasurable in understanding them. To access the viewer, go to http://www.uspto.gov/patft/help/images.htm. The program that you download for viewing patents is dependent upon the operating system and internet browser that you use. Follow the instructions and links for your particular operating system. If you are like most people and use the windows operating system and Internet Explorer for your browser, you can go to http://www.alternatiff.com/install/ to directly download the viewer. Remember to bookmark this page in case you need to reload the patent viewer for some reason. You will know that you have succeeded when the text appears at the bottom of the page informing you that it is installed. 178
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 4: Bookmark the definition of classifications and give it a memorable name. It is located at: http://www.uspto.gov/web/patents/classification/selectnumwithtitle.htm. Each patent is assigned a patent classification. Having a link to the classifications helps the searcher delineate between classifications. When you get to this page, you will notice that there is a numbering system which starts with items such as “apparel”. Remember that this is a very old system of classifying patents that was based upon products that were available when it was started. Scroll through this list and look for more modern classifications to appear. Click on any one of the definitions. This will take you to sub-classifications. Patents are usually assigned a classification and at least one sub-classification. When you select one of the classification numbers, you finally arrive at the definitions. Step 5: Bookmark the index of classifications and give it a memorable name. It is located at: http://www.uspto.gov/web/patents/classification/uspcindex/indextouspc.htm. When you have an invention with a common name, you can find the classification by going to this index. Everything is listed in alphabetical order. For instance, if you are working on an improvement for hand shovels, you can go to shovels and find that there are a variety of objects which are referred to as shovels. There are hand shovels, power shovels, crane shovels, loading shovels, plow shovels, etc. This is important to know because many of these systems provide exactly the same function as the one that you are considering. In effect, they provide analogous functions in different industries. It is possible that they use physical phenomena and lines of evolution that are different from your industry. These can be put to work in your situation. Also, when you later identify other analogous products, you can readily find the patents for these products by using this index. Step 6: Bookmark the Advanced Search page and study the examples for Boolean searches. (Note that you can search for phrases in parenthesizes.) Now you are ready to perform the actual patent search.
Method Step 1: Search for patents directly related to the modification that you would like to perform Step 2: Using Advanced Search, search for key words in the abstract or body of the patents. Step 3: When you finally find a patent which is close to the intended subject, identify the classification. Step 4: Search by classification, making use of the Definitions and Index of Classifications. Make sure that classification includes possible patents that cover the field that you are interested in. Idealize Useful Functions
179
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 5: When you find good representative patents, note and view all patents cited. Step 6: Now search these patents and continue the process until no new patents regarding your area of interest show up. Step 7: Search patents for physical phenomena that are unusual to your industry.
New—Intelligent Little People One of the most important tools of investigation is empathy. This is the ability to become a part of the system that we are investigating and to see it from this unique perspective. The principle of empathy is very powerful, but has a few limitations. First, we provide only one perspective from which to view the problem. Secondly, we must exist in order to view the problem. In other words, we cannot dissolve or disappear. Third, there is just one of us to interact with the system. If there were more of us to interact, this would open up new possibilities. These difficulties are largely overcome by using the principle of little intelligent people.
Example—Self cleaning air filter Step 1: Envision the system as composed of intelligent little people who can work together. They also have the capability to disappear and reappear if necessary. What do they do to accomplish the desired result? How do they intelligently act together? The little people pass the particulates from one to the next while allowing air to flow. Step 2: Consider possible physical phenomena that can accomplish this cooperation. A separate liquid moves along the surface due to a mechanical action. The liquid acts to trap and carry the particles. Lungs clean themselves using this same action.
180
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Evolution of Field Phenomena Examine the Table of Fields in the Appendix. Note that the top fields are the most abundant fields and the bottom fields are typically the least abundant. In general, systems tend to use the top fields first for muscle and then the lower fields for sensing and control. Later, the lower fields may become more abundant. When they are both abundant and controllable it makes sense that systems evolve toward the bottom fields. By examining the fields currently being used by your system, or similar systems, you can guess the fields that might be used next.
Example—Lawn Mower Step 1: What fields are currently being used to deliver this function? Currently, the blade is cut by a mechanical highpressure field that makes use of the grass’s inertia Step 2: What are the next fields that will likely be used? Oscillations. Jet pressure
New—Library of Effects The Library of Effects is table of physical phenomena that can be used to deliver functions. Once we know the modification that we desire, we can find a similar function in the table. Usually, this is a generalization of the desired function. The table usually gives many physical phenomena that can deliver the desired modification to the product.
Example—Clothes Dryer The function of the air in the dryer is to evaporate water. Step 1: Convert given function to a Generalized Function. The generalized function is to move a liquid.
Idealize Useful Functions
Evaporate Water
181
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: Find phenomena in the Library of Effects. Go to one of the sources for the library of effects. Some commercial software have this library. A scaled-down version can be found at:
Move
Liquid
www.creax.com Locate the generalized function and then consider all of the physical phenomena that can be used.
Fabric (Capillary action) Move
Liquid
New—Analogous Products—Patents Outside Your Industry An analogous phenomenon produces the same result that we want on other objects. This can be transferred to our situation with satisfying results.
Example—Removing a Sliver We would like to identify a new physical phenomenon for extracting slivers. Step 1: Identify an analogous product. What other types of objects require the same modification? A nail is analogous to a sliver.
Extract Sliver
=
Step 2: Identify the common tool for modifying this product and the minimum feature required for the modification. Search for patents related to the modification of this analogous product. A crowbar is used to extract nails. The feature that performs this modification is the claw.
182
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 3: Transfer this feature to the new situation. Consider combining this with the existing tool or transferring the minimum amount of the tool.
Mini-CrowBar Removes Sliver
New—Analogous Products—Mega Trend If we look in industries that perform a function on a massive scale, we can often discover the evolutionary trend for this function along with physical phenomena which are used to accomplish it. It is even possible to identify physical phenomena by using the patent database.
Mega - Product = ?
Example—Moving Large Amounts of Packaged Materials We would like to move sacks from a truck shipment to a location on the factory floor. Typically, this is done by hand, unloading one at a time.
Move Sack
Step 1: Identify analogous products in leading industries. These are objects which require the same function that you are considering. It may be necessary to think about the modification differently. Cans are an analogous product. Step 2: Identify trends for performing the function where a large amount of this product requires the same modification? Consider looking at patents for this analogous product. Can you identify the evolutionary trend? The Cans are moved on pallets as large groups. As more and more things are moved, they seem to be moved in large groups rather than oneby-one.
Cans
Trolley / Pallet Move Sacks
Step 3: Apply this to the product that you are considering.
Idealize Useful Functions
183
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Analogous Products— Bio-mimicry Nature has developed many analogous phenomena that can be employed to perform functions. The concept of analogous phenomena starts with an analogous product. Identifying objects in nature that require the same function will begin to lead the seeker to new physical phenomena.
Natural Product = ?
Example—Catching Chips When we grind an object, small chips are ejected. We would like to constrain these chips.
Constrains Chips
Step 1: Identify analogous products in nature. What objects in nature require or have this same function imposed? You might have to consider variants of this function. (Look for primitive natural analogies). Flying Insects are often caught in webs. Step 2: Identify the natural Tool/ Effect? As stated, the insects are often caught in webs.
Sticky filament Constrains Flying Insects
Step 3: Transfer the Effect/Tool to the new situation. A sticky filament will catch the flying chips.
Sticky filament Constrains
Flying Chips
184
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Merge or Interact With Multiplied Tools If you are aware of a physical phenomena which can perform the function there is a possibility that a completely new physical phenomenon can be identified by multiplying the common tools and then making the multiplied tools interact with each other.
Example—Common Knife Step 1: Identify an object related to a physical phenomenon that is similar to the one required. Consider a knife. Step 2: Multiply the system. Start with two. Now we have two knives.
Step 3: Can these tools be merged or interact together to create an unexpected capability? Try different orientations. Try merging the knives. The knives become scissors. Step 4: Consolidate Elements if Possible
New—Hybrid Combination of Physical Phenomena This tool if extremely useful when you are working with a demanding sustaining market and the resources of the current phenomenon are becoming limited. This is a way to move to the new physical phenomena while increasing (rather than sacrificing) performance, as is often the case when jumping to a new effect.
Idealize Useful Functions
185
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Transition to Electric Car Jumping entirely to a fully electric car would sacrifice too much.
Moves
Step 1: Begin with a common physical phenomenon that is normally used to deliver the modification. Internal Combustion Engine Step 2: Identify another phenomenon which performs the same modification. Electric Motor Step 3: What is the feature of the new tool which would extend the capability of the first tool? Torque at low speeds Step 4: Identify the cheap tool which should deliver most of the function. The Internal Combustion Engine Step 5: Combine both phenomena into a hybrid. A new capability should emerge. Try combining both as Hybrid whole tools. Try transferring just the Engine desirable feature. Consider having Moves the two physical phenomena interact with each other. Drive Train
186
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Filter for Abundant Resources The availability or abundance of resources to deliver the physical phenomena must be high. Objects and resources are already present in the environment that can help deliver the physical phenomena. We do not determine in this section whether a sufficient abundance exists. This will occur in the next section. That is why this section deals with possible physical phenomena.
Method In order for the physical phenomenon to have any chance, it should be abundant in the system. Step 1: Identify abundant fields—these are usually associated with abundant physical phenomena. Step 2: Filter the potential phenomena (previous steps) to allow only those which are abundant.
Filter for Inherent Harm (Contact) Some physical phenomena require the addition of harmful interactions. This is especially true with physical phenomena that require contact. If physical phenomena are present which do not require contact and the resources for providing this physical phenomena are abundant, then consider these over those that require contact.
Method Step 1: Filter the physical phenomena that you are considering for contact.
Idealize Useful Functions
187
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Filter for Multiple Functions A more ideal function is capable of performing multiple functions. The value of objects in a system is dependent upon two things, the number of useful functions that they deliver and the burdens that they create. In this case, we are considering the number of functions that they deliver. It is only possible to consider multiple functions if other functions in the system are already required. There is no reason to create functions to perform in order to allow a physical phenomenon to perform more functions. The secondary function that the phenomenon performs may be a supporting function but more ideally, it should be a primary function that acts directly on the system product.
Method Step 1: Search for additional functions within the system that the physical phenomenon could deliver. Step 2: Look for opportunities to use passive feedback from physical phenomena that can both sense and actuate. Examples are bi-metals. Step 3: If necessary, can the physical phenomenon deliver the function and the anti-function?
188
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Idealize Useful Functions
189
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Discovering New Physical Phenomena The discipline of invention would be incomplete without the consideration of discovering new physical phenomena. These discoveries, while taking much longer to break through, have had profound impacts on all of technology. Discoveries such as the lasers, particle beams, lithographic processes, and ultrasonic phenomena have transformed our lives. The way that we define a physical phenomenon has a large influence on how we might go about discovering new phenomena. Here, we will use a fairly broad definition of physical phenomena and then discover how this might influence how we would go about searching for new phenomena. A physical phenomenon is a unique combination of fields and substances which allows for the delivery of a function. The term “physical phenomena” is a human convention which allows us to create order from chaos. We classify what we are seeing in order to repeat it and use it for our purposes. Even the concept of a “field” (as used in the above definition) is a human convention. One might argue that 99% of all interactions in nature are the result of electron to electron interactions. Such a narrow definition of field limits classifications greatly. Here, we will consider fields to include the ones that we studied in physics courses. Let’s say that we were the first to discover capillary action. Perhaps we were the first to construct a glass tube and place it into a liquid. We might have seen the liquid move up the tube to a position higher than the liquid in the vessel that contains it. So, what did we notice? The liquid was modified. It changed its shape, height or relationship relative to the glass, etc. In other words, it performed a function because it modified one of the attributes of the liquid. This point bears repeating often: the value of a physical phenomenon is that it is the means of delivering functions. In this context, the search for new physical phenomena is actually the search for new ways to deliver functions. (This logic is not perfect in that we may find a new way to deliver a function which involves an existing physical phenomenon.) This search often begins with the thinking “If only I could find a way to…”. Perhaps we search existing Libraries of Effects and physical phenomena as well as an exhaustive search of the internet. Nothing turns up. If we are particularly serious about delivering this function in a new way, we may do something radical. We may begin an innovative quest…. The anticipation of new physical phenomena by mental synthesis is possible. One method is presented, Intelligent Little People, which allows us to mentally manipulate substances or entities. The field is generic because it is an influence that passes from little person to little person. The little people act intelligently based upon information that they receive from each other. We can then mimic what the little people do with substances and simple paired fields. 190
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Intelligent Little People One of the most important tools of investigation is empathy. This is the ability to become a part of the system that we are investigating and to see it from this unique perspective. The principle of empathy is very powerful, but has a few limitations. First, we provide only one perspective from which to view the problem. Secondly, we must exist in order to view the problem. In other words, we cannot dissolve or disappear. Third, there is just one of us to interact with the system. If there were more of us to interact, this would open up new possibilities. These difficulties are largely overcome by using the principle of little intelligent people.
Method Step 1: Envision the system as composed of intelligent little people who can work together. These people also have the capability to disappear and reappear if necessary. What do they do to accomplish the desired result? How do they intelligently act together? Step 2: What is the message that the little people give to each other. What kinds of natural fields mimic these messages? What paired substances interact strongly with these fields?
Drive Measurement and Detection to the Extreme One might argue that “new” physical phenomena are going on around us all the time. Unfortunately, we are not capable of detecting it, because it is beyond the normal range of human sensing. For example, without special filters, it would be impossible to detect the polarization of a ray of light. In order to see what is going on around us, we must look with a new perspective; we must use tools which are capable of detecting modifications to substances and fields in places and under circumstances that are extreme. Extreme circumstances would include extremely small, extremely hot, extremely cold… Whenever you drive anything to the extreme, you will likely see or experience new phenomena. Being able to see smaller things or further into space, or probe areas of the micro and macro universe or into extremely unusual environments will likely uncover unusual physical phenomena.
Method Idealize Useful Functions
191
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 1: Identify an attribute that you would like to detect to the extreme. Step 2: Create a measurement system that can detect to this level (see measurement and detections). Step 3: Measure to the extreme and see if what is observed matches theory.
Natural Analogous Effect The biological kingdom performs countless functions at large scales and small. The diversity of functions and physical phenomenon are great. What if we could only train ourselves to see things in a new way and ask ourselves hard Natural Product = ? questions? Why are eagle claws always sharp? How do bird feathers hold their shape? How can a bumble bee fly? When we are searching for new ways to deliver functions, we can look to nature to see how it delivers these functions and duplicate what it does. Nature has developed many analogous phenomena that can be employed to perform functions.
Method Step 1: Identify analogous products in nature? (Look for primitive natural analogies). Step 2: Identify the natural Tool/ Effect? Step 3: Transfer the Effect/Tool to the new situation
Drive Fields to the Extreme Another way to find new physical phenomena is by looking at physical phenomena that have been driven to the extreme. There are different ways to drive a phenomenon to the extreme. We may pair a field with a substance that is particularly susceptible to the field. We may drive the field to an extreme level. We may create a very precise degree of order to the substances or to the fields. We may drive a physical attribute of one of the substances to the extreme. In each case, we will likely discover that nature behaves in unusual ways. These unusual responses can often be used to deliver functions. Nicola Tesla was legendary for driving fields to the extreme. No electrostatic field was ever high enough for him; he always kept pushing and as a result, discovered new phenomena and fundamentally new ways to deliver functions.
Method 192
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 1: Identify fields in the Table of Fields (Appendix). These fields will be applied to a substance at the same time. Step 2: Drive the field to the extreme. This might be extreme intensity or for very short durations. Step 3: Look for new phenomena.
Drive Order to the Extreme Whenever order is driven to the extreme, new physical phenomena are discovered.
Method Step 1: Where there is little order, drive order to the extreme and look for new physical phenomena. Step 2: Where there is great order, drive chaos to the extreme and look for new physical phenomena.
Drive Attributes to the Extreme Whenever physical attributes are driven to the extreme, new physical phenomena are observed.
Method Step 1: Take an attribute of an entity and consider means in which this can be driven to the extreme. Step 2: Drive this attribute to the extreme and look for physical phenomena.
Idealize Useful Functions
193
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Chaining Physical Phenomena As a fallback to creating a completely new physical phenomenon, consider the possibility of chaining physical phenomena to deliver the function. This is especially true if substances and fields can be consolidated.
Method Step 1: Some software is capable of chaining physical phenomena to deliver a function. Step 2: If software is not available, chain a final and starting physical phenomenon together with connecting phenomena. This may be done by trial and error.
194
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Idealize Useful Functions
195
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Tool for Useful Functions The IFR is a classical TRIZ tool. First, we ask ourselves what final result should be, and then we tell ourselves that we will achieve this result without the use or addition of any object or substance to the system. This is often possible when we can get an object to perform more functions than it normally would. It is also possible if we can eliminate objects and allow something in the system to take over the function. Up to this point, we have avoided adding any tool to the system. If we have reached this point and still need to add a tool, then we must do it in the most ideal way possible. We are trying to add as little substance or objects to our system as possible. We would still like to perform our function without adding any object. If possible, existing objects and ambient fields should perform the modification. If this is not possible, only then do we consider adding objects. The best situation is a small change to the product that allows an ambient field to perform the function. According to the law of increasing ideality, the value of any object increases when the number of functions that the object does is increased and the number of harmful factors decreases. In general, this means that we would like to get the most functions possible out of each object. Each tool should take on as many functions as possible.
Parasitic Tools Parasitic tools use something which already exists in the system, super-system or environment to perform the function. When this occurs, it is actually possible to get something for nothing.
Theft of Functions If the tool must exist, we should make the most of it. The system will become more ideal with fewer elements. Thus, we must look around and see of a given tool can perform more functions than it already is.
196
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Self- Service The product in question has native fields associated with it. Can we make some small change to the product so that it performs the modification on itself? (It is likely that energy will still need to come from outside).
Example—Cutting Tape from a Roll Consider the example of a roll of tape that must be cut. Normally it is cut by a blade supported to the base element. Let us begin with the tape alone and the modification “cut”.
Cut
Tape
Step 1: Search the Table of Fields (in the Appendix) for fields that are always associated with the product? We should consider Adhesive Fields & Mechanical Fields. Step 2: What Effect or Physical Phenomena can be used to deliver this function? The Creation of directed forces by use of adhesive forces Step 3: In following steps we can try to boost this function. The adhesion between layers must create forces which grossly overpower adhesion of the tape material to itself.
Cuts
Tape
Some readers may be confused with this example as it does not seem to indicate a particular solution, but the possibility of a solution. This is as it should be in this case. Whenever we idealize functions, we are creating new candidate systems. At this point, we do not know whether they will work or not. Most of these examples discuss new systems that seem like they could work out. This one appears to be questionable. Remember that when we have a new candidate system, it may have many weaknesses. It is now our opportunity to turn this “sows ear” into a “silk purse”. We do this by going back to the reviewing the related requirements and following through the causal analysis, etc. again. Eventually, we will continue past this point in the algorithm by focusing on the object attributes and contradictions which need to be solved. Remember that in Idealizing Functions, we are creating Ideal Final Results for ourselves. We may not yet know how to realize them.
Idealize Useful Functions
197
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Parasite—Already Poorly Performed by Native Fields Sometimes, a function is already performed by some natural phenomenon but it is done very poorly or even harmfully. With a little help, we can boost these functions until they become useful.
Example—Protecting a Radio Tower from Lightening A classic TRIZ example is the radio tower which requires lightening rods to protect it. We must guide the current, but we would like to do this by using native fields.
Guide
Current
Step 1: Is the function already delivered by a super-system tool, even poorly? Yes, the air guides the current poorly. The charge comes to the ground in concentrated form Step 2: What physical phenomenon is employed to poorly deliver this function? To initiate this, the air must be locally ionized. The air then becomes conductive. As the current is conducted, there is a self concentrating effect caused by many moving charges traveling in the same direction.
Air
Guides
Current
In following steps we can ask what modifications to the fields or the tool allow the function to be boosted. These modifications may require the small addition of substances or structures which react strongly to the native fields.
Parasite—Abundant Native Fields Most objects are awash in native fields. These fields do not remain constant throughout the product life cycle. By identifying the fields all around the product, we locate tool resources that can perform the function.
198
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Cutting a Pie before Consumption Step 1: Process Map the product life through relevant life stages.
Produce Pie
Freeze Pie
Transport Pie
Step 2: Look through the Table of Cook Pie Fields at the end of this appendix. Identify which native fields the product experiences at each process step. Which of these native fields perform this function even poorly? Thermal fields can deteriorate the crust. I suppose that this is a useful Oven variant of cutting Step 3: What Effect or physical phenomena can be employed to deliver this function? Melting or Chemical Reaction are possible physical phenomena.
Cuts (Melts part)
Crust
In the next steps we can try to boost this function.
Parasite—Laundry List of Adjacent Elements In this step we consider ordinary elements about us that might be pressed into service to deliver the required physical phenomena. This method is especially effective with low level fields such as elastic, gravity pressure, etc.
Laundry List
Example—Pet Feeder—How can we stop insects? Step 1: Make a laundry list of adjacent elements, especially those which were not considered in the supersystem functional models: Pet Food—Water Bowl— Water Hose—Water in Water Bowl—Food Bowl— Cement or Ground. Step 2: What fields are associated with these objects: —Surface Tension—Water Bowl —Mechanical fields—Food Bowl & Water Bowl —Water Pressure—Water hose
Idealize Useful Functions
199
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 3: Consider ways in which elements on the list might be pressed in to service to perform the required modification. The water stops the crawling insects. Step 4: Consider decomposing elements into new components.
Water
Stops
Insects
Parasite—Use of Cheap Abundant Substances When a function can be delivered at low cost, the value of the system increases. If there is a way to use a cheap abundant substance, try to use it. If the phenomenon is weak, it may be possible to boost the phenomenon later.
Method Consider the following list of cheap substances. Could any of these be used to deliver any of the phenomena that you are considering? List of Cheap Substances: Powders—Foams—Voids—Water—Ice—Steam— Hydrates—Air—Nitrogen—Carbon Dioxide—Oxygen—Corrosion— Decay—Sand—Soil—Rocks—Waste—Waste Water—Sawdust—Waste Glass—Waste Gases—Waste Paper—Garbage—Yard Waste—Industrial Wastes—Hybrid Substances—Disassociated Forms of Any of the Above—Products of Interactions—Starting Materials—Final Products— Semi-Finished Elements
Parasite—Nearby Similar Tool Depending on how systems evolve, it is common that several elements in the system perform the same function. These objects may perform the same function on different or biased products. Sometimes, this tool can be pressed into service to perform the function on both products.
200
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Air Pump The pressurization of air is required. Step 1: Identify a similar tool nearby which performs the same function. There is an oil pump nearby which performs the function.
Nearby Pump
Pressurizes
Step 2: Combine and consolidate both elements into one system.
Oil Water
/
Parasite—Simplified Copy of the Current Tool Use of the current tool can be overkill, especially if the tool is a human. A simplified copy can often perform the same function as the full tool.
Example—Dangerous Missions Jets are often required to perform dangerous recognizance missions. The pilot controls the sophisticated aircraft. The pilot is capable of performing unexpected maneuvers during combat or if failures occur, but during a recognizance mission, these functions are rarely required. Step 1: What part of the current tool performs the function? The brains and hands of the pilot perform the current function. Step 2: Can a copy of the tool perform the function?
Computer (not pilot) Informs
Control Surfaces
Idealize Useful Functions
201
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Theft of Functions from Super-System (TRIZ Universality also ASIT Unification Tool) All systems within the super-system, including the super-system itself, are competing for functions. When we steal functions, the more closely related the function is to the function of your system, the more readily it will be accepted.
Example—Food Bowl In a pet feeding system, the food bowl is usually considered separately from the water bowl. Here we will consider how the food bowl might be able to steal another function. Step 1: List objects in the environment associated with the job at hand. Take especial note of objects with similar functions. A water bowl is also a part of the job of nourishing the dog. It also performs the function of containing a substance. Step 2: The Tool takes over all or part of another objects functions. This is not simply a combining of objects. When you are done, one of the two original objects should be “invisible.” There should be no compromise in the original functions. The water bowl and food bowl are combined Step 3: Completely new and unexpected benefits must emerge. Try different orientations and combinations.
202
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Theft from Alternative or Competing Objects Identify other objects or processes that seek to provide the same functions or do the same job. Sometimes these are not obvious alternatives. Though they may be from completely different industries, they are the true competition.
Example—Pet Feeding System Now that we have combined the water dish and the food dish, how might we steal functions or attributes from competing systems? Disposable containers are often used for food and water bowls. This is because they do not tip and they provide storage for long periods of time. Step 1: Consider objects which provide the extreme of the function as well. Disposed food containers can be used for pet drinking water Step 2: Consider taking over all or part of these object’s functions. New and exciting capabilities should emerge, as well as new synergies between the objects that could not exist before. The pet can no longer drag the food bowl around, scattering the food
Idealize Useful Functions
203
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Theft—Boost Incidental Functions Most objects in a system provide incidental functions that we rarely notice. If we can identify these incidental functions and boost them, it is often possible to create more value for our product. Sometimes it takes little more than watching people use the product or service and then noticing all of the other things that it does.
Example—SolarVoltaic Panels
House Electrical System
Step 1: Identify incidental functions that the system already performs. The solar panels incidentally protect the house.
Electrifies
PV System
Photons & Rain
Stops
Step 2: What elements in the super-system normally deliver this function? Roof Tiles. Step 3: Boost these incidental functions to take over for the other super-system elements. Look for unexpected capabilities to emerge: Solar panels double as Roof tiles
204
Idealize Useful Functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Theft—Steal Human Interactions Unless the object of the system is to directly serve humans in the system, there is usually a burdensome element to any function provided by humans to the system. When humans are eliminated from any function in the system, the system becomes less burdensome. Note that in order to oust humans, the human function must be deintellectualized.
Human
Example—Pet Feeding System Step 1: Look at the system from the viewpoint of humans that interact with the system. Are humans required to operate the system? Are humans required to maintain the system? A human is required to fill the water bowl each day Step 2: What changes to the system would allow the human to be removed from the system? What if the Feeding Human Feeding System system were to replenish the water? Replenishes Replenishes
Water
Idealize Useful Functions
205
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
206
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Idealize Informing
Subject
Functions
Informs
Observer
Informing functions have to do with measurement or detection. Measurement is actually a subclass of useful functions, but there are additional considerations that we need to take into account. First, the subject is the object being measured or detected. It is the tool of the useful function. It modifies or informs the product or observer. This seems backwards from what we would normally say in English. “The thermometer measures the water temperature”. From the English, it would appear that the thermometer is modifying the water by measuring it. In reality, the water modifies the thermometer. It changes the temperature of the thermometer which, in turn, informs or modifies the observer. This is a classic “confusing function”. The direction of the function is always from the subject to the observer. For the rest of this section, we will refer to the tool as the subject and the product as the observer. Another difference between informing functions and useful functions is that someplace in the system is a known “observer”. Unlike the typical useful function, where the only required part of the function is the product, there is a required and known observer. This puts constraints on the search for an ideal subject, informing modification, physical phenomenon and observer. Describing this in functional terms, there is a functional chain between the object that needs to be measured and the human observer that needs to be informed. For any given system, certain elements in that chain are known. For example, consider the climate control for a large building. Changes Temperature Heater
Changes Display Data
Informs
Attendant
Display
Idealize Informing Functions
Air
Changes Temperature Information
Controller
Changes Temperature Information
Data Bus
Changes Temperature Changes Voltage
A/D Converter
Temp Sensor
207
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
This system will likely have a large number of sensors measuring such things as temperature and humidity. Each sensor must eventually give a voltage signal which is measured by an analog to digital converter and placed on a data bus. The data bus then changes digital attributes in the controller which manipulates the data and displays the results to a display screen where an attendant then can be informed and respond to what is displayed. The controller also affects a heater which changes the temperature of the air. Notice that the role of subject and observer is constantly changing as we move along the chain. Each observer becomes a subject for the next observer in the chain. Depending upon the part of this chain that we have control over, we will need to make decisions concerning the modifications, physical phenomena and observers that will deliver the functions. In some cases, we may have control over the entire chain, in others; we may have control over one link. The point is that for every measurement system, there are known elements that must be linked together. This is different than useful functions in which only a final result in the product is required. The system that we have shown is the extreme case, but also serves to show that there is usually a chain of transformations that must occur between the main subject that we are trying to measure and the observer or observers. Each transformation has its burdens. We would like to have as few transformations as possible to get the job done. We would ideally like the requirement to measure the air temperature go away entirely. If there were only one temperature to measure then it would be more ideal for the air to directly inform the attendant. As mentioned, in a long chain of transformations, each observer becomes the subject for the next measurement transformation in the system. As we idealize each function in the chain we first idealize the observer. We want to know why measurement is important to the observer. If the observer does not need to know the measured attribute then it may not be necessary for measurement to occur. If measurement is required, then we want to identify the ideal subject to be measured? Perhaps it doesn’t need to be measured. This allows for the most ideal systems to be considered first. A measurement system that does not require measurement is more ideal than a system where the measurement tool is idealized. The final step is to decide how the detection or measurement will occur. In this case, the most important consideration is the chain of physical phenomena and then the actual objects that will deliver the physical phenomena. Notice that we have allowed for a chain of transformations. Ideally, we want as few transformations as possible, but we still have to allow for a chain of physical phenomena in order to be consistent with the subject and the observer.
208
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Observer for Informing Functions Up to this point, we have taken for granted that the observer is a required system object. We cannot afford to take this for granted. If we have any control on the system, we must challenge the requirement for the observer. The ideal observer is one that does not require the measurement to occur. Measurement brings many burdens to the system. Sensors provide auxiliary functions to systems which do not directly modify the system product. Consequently, they have lower functional ranking or value in the system. Paradoxically, sensors are often one of the most expensive elements in the system. If the need for measurement is removed, then we can usually remove a lot of system elements.
The Ideal Observer Doesn’t Need to Know There is something about the observer that makes measurement or detection unnecessary. Why does the observer want to know the attributes Change of the measured object? The reason can be disappointing. This is especially true in human systems. Take the example where an obsessive employer wants to monitor his employees. While this may seem extreme, it is nevertheless a very useful way to look at a situation from a new point of view. In order to accomplish this result a slight modification of the product is usually required.
Method Step 1: Identify the “required” observer and the required subject that must be measured or detected. If the system is technical, you may need to decide where you have control over the system and where you do not.
Subject
Informs
Observer
Step 2: Why does the observer require informing? Follow this reasoning back through the causal relationships. If a Cause-Effect Diagram is being used, it is easier to follow the chain of reasoning back to the problems that the measurement function helps to resolve. At this point, we are looking for a reason that has to do with the observer. What characteristics of the observer make this function necessary? Step 3: A change to an object in the system (often the observer) removes the requirement for the observer to be informed. Idealize Informing Functions
209
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
210
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Subject of Measurement The ideal subject does not require the measurement. There are a variety of reasons that measurement may not be required. If the element isn’t required in the system or doesn’t even exist, then there is no requirement for measurement.
The Ideal Subject Doesn’t Require Measurement There is something about the subject that makes measurement or detection unnecessary. As mentioned earlier, there are usually many burdens associated with measurement. The typical measurement system has many interlinking elements that wind their way back to the observer. If measurement is not required, then we can eliminate many system parts.
The Ideal Subject Comes in Natural Groups If we have decided that the measurement is necessary, then the most ideal subject is all that come in a group. If the group is a natural group, then it is even more ideal. Many subjects come in natural groups. If we can perform the function on all of them, preferably at the same time, then this can make the system less complex.
No Measurement—Non-Existent Subject Measuring and detecting objects may not be required if the objects to be measured are not required in the first place. It is usually because we have difficulty discarding the subject that there is now a need to measure them.
Example—Nuclear Waste Nuclear Waste and its storage medium must be monitored. Step 1: Is the subject ever Harmful, Waste? Yes Step 2: Eliminate Subject. No way found Step 3: Eliminate Source. No way found Step 4: Eliminate Path. No way found
Idealize Informing Functions
211
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 5: The Waste becomes useful and thus is eliminated by its usefulness: The Nuclear Waste becomes a pre-heater. As the pre-heater grows, the main reactor material is reduced
Pre-heater
Main Reactor
No Measurement—Measurement Not Required There is something about the subject that makes measurement or detection unnecessary. All measurement functions can be thought of in Change a remedial or preventative context. This may not seem intuitive at first, but consider the following. Why do we measure the temperature of air in a room? It is because the temperature tends to go out of the comfortable zone. It is not doing its job! If it were doing its job, the air would remain the correct temperature all of the time without external action. While this may seem excessive, it is nevertheless a very useful way to look at a situation from a new point of view. In order to accomplish this result a modification of the subject is usually required.
Example—Measuring Job Performance Step 1: Why is the observation required? What does it prevent? What does it fix? What does it make up for? Does it counter something? Follow this reasoning back through the causal relationships. If a Cause-Effect Diagram is being used, it is easier to follow the chain of reasoning back to the problems that the measurement function helps to resolve. This is done by considering existence of elements. Measurement of job performance is “required” because workers do not always perform in a manner that is “best” for the company. This is a remedial function. Also, it is “required” so that the company may know how to recompense the employee. This is also a preventative action to keep the employee from leaving. Both remedial and preventative functions are prime candidates for removal. By taking it for granted that these remedial or preventative actions are required companies spend a great deal of time and money on this process. Step 2: A change to an object in the system (often the object that we are serving) removes the requirement for the main function and hence the objects that deliver the function. In other words, if something did its job better, our system wouldn’t be needed. In this case, we might consider changing the system of how the company “contracts” with the employee or allowing employees to identify areas that they could better serve the company with their particular talents. It may be possible to hire employees that have already been through the gauntlet and have proven themselves to be worthy of not monitoring. In some highly countries, salary increases automatic and dependent upon competitive pay for that position. 212
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
No Measurement—Direct Acting Sensors—Operation about Critical Points A critical point is a region of operation where the properties of an object change abruptly. Most physical phenomena can be tailored to operate in the around a critical point. The boiling or melting points of a substance are critical points. Operating near critical points allows for direct acting elements. For passive control, we demand that the sensor use the same fields for sense and modulation (the subject is a combined sensor and modulating element).
Example—Fluid Temperature Feedback Consider a control system that measures the temperature of a fluid and then actuates a fluid closure element. Step1: Identify the fields associated with the parameter of the subject that is being sensed: Temperature Step 2: Identify a physical phenomenon which reacts to the parameter change. Expansion during Phase Change Step 3: Identify a critical point associated with the phenomena. Melting Point Step 4: Identify how crossing this critical point can be used to both sense and control. Expansion upon melting provides muscle to move closure element
No Measurement—Measurement / Detection Not Required Any useful function can be thought of in terms of preventing harm or fixing something. This is also true of measurement functions.
Example—Vacuum Crucible The temperature of a crucible in a vacuum furnace is constantly measured. Step1: Why is the subject being measured? Is detecting or measurement required in preparation for fixing or preventing something? The temperature is being measured to ensure that the operator knows when the crucible is about to melt. Idealize Informing Functions
213
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: What modification to the subject or other element in the system would make it so that measurement is not required? The crucible is made of a material with a high enough melting temperature that it cannot melt. Temperature measurement is no longer required.
No Measurement—Subject Comes PreMeasured The Subject does not require detection because the detection is already incorporated. Can the subject be apportioned in such a way that the required properties are already known or premeasured?
Examples—Pre-Measured Weight or Volume Medication—Pills Food—Packets Tubes—Pre-fabricated diameters (very accurate)
Examples—Pre-Measured Fields For measurement of fields, make the source of the fields come in discrete forms. Following are several examples. Sound or Vibration— Set frequencies (resonance) and duration Light—Set frequencies or duration Buoyancy—discrete volumes Pressures—Saturated liquid gas phase gives one pressure Temperature—Saturated liquid-gas phase gives on pressure Current—Use of current driver
214
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Detection of Astronomical Phenomena Astronomical objects give off many frequencies of light. These frequencies can often be separated into frequency “bands” by optical gratings. Expensive detectors can sense a variety of frequencies, but large sections of the sky need to be surveyed. How Pre-measured Frequency can the frequencies be pre-measured? By use of an optical filter, the light can be filtered to specific frequencies which show up as Filter Photo Detector anomalies or can be discretely detected with an alarm.
No Measurement—Detect or Measure the Minimum Part or Constituents Detecting or measuring a parameter of a system composed of a variety of elements allows for the possibility of simplifying by measuring the parameters for only part of the system. It is natural to directly measure the properties of the direct elements. An alternative method is to measure the properties of the constituents or derivatives of the constituents to determine the properties of the whole.
Example—Bicycle Speedometer How can the speed of a bicycle be determined? Step 1: If the subject is a single element, what minimum part of the subject must be detected? Detect the revolution of part of the wheel rather than the whole bicycle Step 2: If the subject is composed of multiple elements, identify parts of the system that could be measured, rather than measuring the whole system.
Idealize Informing Functions
Magnet
Magnetic Pickup
215
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Natural Groupings—Multiple Subject Elements Often, it is easier to detect the average parameter of many objects than it is to detect the properties of a single object. This is almost always true when detecting the properties of small things such as particles, molecules, atoms. This is especially true of the subjects come in natural groupings. In this case, we are treating all of the objects that are being measured and looking primarily for the statistics of the group.
Example—Measuring the Temperature of an Insect Step 1: Are the subjects small? Yes, insects are small Step 2: Do the subjects come in natural batches or groups, or are they hard to separate? Not usually, unless they are swarming insects. Step 3: Is it more ideal or easier to detect the group simultaneously? For instance, is it advantageous to know the average value as opposed to individual values of measurement? Measuring the insects as a group makes it easier and gives an average value which may be more ideal in some situations.
Natural Groupings—Biased Subjects In this case, we would like to measure individual subjects within a group, but we would like to accomplish this all at one time if possible.
Example—Measurement of Glass Thickness Consider the measurement of the thickness of each piece of glass in a stack of glass thickness. The glass to be measured has a variety of thickness. Step 1: Are there similar subjects that require detection? Yes, the glass comes in a variety of thickness Step 2: Would it be more ideal if the system could measure all of them at once? Yes, especially if anticipating a large number of jobs coming through from a variety of customers. It may be possible to measure a stack of glass. Knowing the distribution of the individual glass thicknesses helps us to deduce whether one of the individual pieces may be out of specification. 216
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Natural Groupings—Diverse Subjects Would it be more ideal if the subjects to be detected or measured were not similar to each other? Natural groupings should be especially considered. Here, we ask what subjects often are found with each other in a given setting.
Example—Weighing Fruit and Vegetables Consider automatic checkout of fruits and vegetables in a grocery store. Each fruit or vegetable comes in a variety of weights. Yet, the speed of weighing and assigning costs must be done rapidly. Step 1: Are there a variety of objects that require the same type of measurement or detection? Yes, there are a variety of fruits and vegetable s that require weighing. Step 2: Would it be more ideal if these objects could all be measured at the same time? An automatic checkout would be greatly enhanced if it could detect the presence of a large variety of items at the same time.
Idealize Informing Functions
Fruits / Vegetables Inform
217
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
218
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Modification for Informing Functions After focusing on the ideal observer and the ideal subject, we focus on the ideal modification. We ask: What do we really want to have happen and what are the attributes of the ideal informing? While informing functions are useful, the ideal modification for informing functions (measurement and detection) has to be thought of differently than useful functions. Since the subject that is being measured and the observer are both known, this can be confusing. What does it mean to inform ideally? We are setting the stage to think differently about the measurement.
Set the Bar for How Well the Modification must be Performed We just asked ourselves in the last section what the ideal level of the function was. If I could snap my finger, how much do I want to modify or control the subject? Here we ask a similar question. If I could snap my fingers, how would I like the function to be performed? How well, how long, etc. It is important to note that insights derived at this stage have the ability to influence each other. Consequently, the tools in this section may not be followed linearly. It may be necessary to jump back and forth between tools and conclusions gained during one activity may be upset by insights gained in other activities.
Describe the Informing
Subject
Modification in a Variety
Mod 1
of Ways
Mod 2
If I could snap my fingers...
Observer
According to the laws of system evolution, we would like detection to occur with as few energy transformations as possible. Often, there is a multi-step process that occurs between the subject and the observer. The subject being measured changes something else which changes something else which changes something else which then informs the user. Now, how do we describe this in the most ideal way possible? We would like as few transformations as possible. What are ideal final results? In some situations, the most ideal measurement is that the observer merely “looks” (smells, feels or hears) and all required Idealize Informing Functions
219
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
information is transferred. In another situation where control is required, the observer may be a system that detects a voltage. The ideal in this case is that the change in the subject being measured directly changes the voltage of the system. It is not enough to describe this in only one way. Each way may lead to a different physical phenomenon to accomplish the function (depending on abundance of system resources). What would I want to happen if I could do it magically by snapping my fingers?
Example—Human Detecting Rotational Speed of a Fan Step 1: Identify the subject and its attribute that is being measured. The subject being measured is the fan and its rotational speed. Step 2: Identify the “observer”. This may be a human or system which collects information for logging or control. The observer is a human observer. Step 3: Begin with the assumption that the modification will occur directly between the subject being measured and the observer. If this is not possible, we will come back and allow another transformation to occur. The fan must directly inform the user of its speed. Step 4: Consider the observer. What attribute do we want to change in the observer? If the observer is human, we need to pick a sense that we want to affect. If the observer is a device, then we need to identify such attributes as voltage current, etc. In this case, the attribute that I want to change is the sense of hearing. Step 6: Work backward by imagining several ideal final states. Using the Fan longhand form of the modification, Changes tone heard consider different ways to describe the Changes audible voice heard modification. Consider moving from the macro world to the micro world (atomic level and beyond). In this Human case, the human directly hears the fan and knows its speed by detecting and translating the audible sounds given off by the fan.
220
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
What is the Ideal Level of Modification? Determine the actual level of the ideal informing. This level usually involves a metric. As we begin to adjust the levels of the informing, we start to chip away at psychological inertia. We gain insights.
Method Step 1: If I could snap my fingers, what would the ideal level of informing be?
What is the Ideal Sequence of the Informing Function? Considering the ideal sequence will continue to give us more insights into the ideal informing. A powerful method for investigating this is the process map. This can be accomplished in a variety of ways, including a storyboard or simply words in sequence. However it is done, it is nice to show the possibility of functions performed in parallel as this will be one of the considerations that we make.
Method Step 1: Create a process map of the sequence of functions. Informing functions show up as blocks in the process map. It is preferable, but not absolutely necessary that functional language be used. Step 2: Consider performing the informing function in different sequences. Move it earlier or later than currently performed. Try moving it so far forward that it is no longer during the normal process sequence. Consider moving it so far backward that it is no longer part of the ordinary sequence. Step 3: Can the function be performed in parallel with other functions? Step 4: If necessary, break down sections of the map into finer detail. Step 5: Can the modification be broken into two (or more) stages? Does this allow for parallel processes to accomplish the main function, or does it allow for a more optimum sequencing of functions?
Idealize Informing Functions
221
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
What is the Ideal Duration? The ideal sequence is strongly influenced by the duration of the function. Likewise, duration of the function is strongly influenced by the sequence of the function.
Method Step 1: If the informing modification were performed very rapidly, would other harmful functions be precluded? Step 2: How much time do we have after it is normally performed that it would be allowable to continue performing the function? If the modification were performed very slowly (hours, days, weeks, months, years) would this be harmful or could this actually help in the performance of other functions?
What is the Ideal Duty Cycle? Ideality requires that all objects perform as many functions as possible, as much of the time as possible. Systems that idle use valuable resources without doing anything. Consequently, it is important to consider idealizing the function by requiring the system to work all of the time.
Method Step 1: Are there opportunities for the system to run all the time? Is this even desirable considering the current subject? Ideally, objects in the system will be at full capacity Step 2: Are there other objects in the job that require the same informing function? Should the informing function be reframed to consider these other objects? Step 3: Should the informing modification be performed along the entire path, both coming and going? This usually applies to machines which have repetitive motions. Should dummy runs and downtimes be allowed?
222
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
What is the ideal Adjustability and Continuity of Adjustment? Lines of evolution suggest that the control of functions become more and more adjustable. At first, the process is fixed. Next it becomes adjustable to at least discrete levels. Next, the adjustment must become continuous. Next, some form of control scheme is used to adjust the function for changing conditions. The first form of control often turns the function on or off. This is often referred to as “bang-bang” control. The next form of control is referred to as open-loop control. This means that a change is sensed somewhere and the mechanism that controls the function is given a set command that puts the output in the required range. The next form of control uses feedback which continuously or discretely controls the function. Each level of adjustment and control increase the complexity of the system. It is important here to not go overboard in assigning an ideal level of adjustability. We can over-constrain the system. This sounds too much like a compromise, but here we will consider only an acceptable level of adjustment that will allow this system to operate for a long time without change.
Method Step 1: Consider different and perhaps extreme operating environments. Decide whether or not the informing function must be capable of adapting to these different environments Step 2: Consider adjustability to a variety of measured objects. How much variation can we tolerate? Consider biased objects (objects which are of the same type, but have some differences in an important attribute like nails of various sizes or roses of different shades). Consider objects with much greater differences such as the range of edible plants. Step 3: What granularity of adjustment is necessary? Can the adjustment be discrete? If so, what is the discrete step size? Step 5: Does the adjustment need to be continuous or should it require continuous feedback?
Idealize Informing Functions
223
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
When Should It Be Excluded? (The Zero Function5)
Zero
The zero function is the intended absence of a function under certain conditions. We should have full control over the function when its existence would be dangerous or otherwise harmful.
Method Step 1: Identify times when the informing functions are harmful. Step 2: Consider providing the zero function and means for detecting and controlling the informing function during these times.
5
Greg Yezersky, General Theory of Innovation Feb 2006
224
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Physical Phenomenon for Informing Functions What we know what we want to do, we are now prepared to talk about how we are going to deliver the function. We deliver functions with physical phenomena which are in turn delivered by the tool. The tool and the physical phenomena often come together, but for our purposes we will consider them separately as potential physical phenomena. As taught in school, physical phenomena are a human abstract of fields and substances arranges in special architectures that do something recognizable. When we talk about buoyancy as a physical phenomenon, we are talking about several substances and several fields that interact to cause objects to float in their surrounding fluid. We recognize that this works in water and in the air. Buoyancy can be used to do things. It is a means to an end if we want. It is rare that only one substance and/or field is involved. For those who have learned physics, they recognize that the study of physics is primarily the study of physical phenomena. This is fortunate because it helps the user to understand how to calculate the effects of the associated parameters. The decision of what physical phenomena to use to deliver a function is often ignored or taken for granted. Whenever we ignore or take for granted, we are assuming. Whenever we assume, we are subject to psychological inertia. We may not recognize that there are more ideal physical phenomena that can be used to deliver our modification to the tool. We may be ignoring free resources in the environment or in the job that can be used to simplify the system. Even though, a physical phenomenon may not be ideal, we need to additionally consider whether the timing is right to change it. This decision should not be taken lightly as changing to a new physical phenomenon can lead to a lot of headaches. If it is not time to change, this whole section can be skipped. There are many avenues for identifying physical phenomena. Many of physical phenomena are already in-use to perform the function. Some need to be transported from other industries. Once we have them, we need to sort through them to find the most ideal. In the event that we cannot identify a good physical phenomenon to meet our needs, there is always the option to go searching for new phenomena. This should only be done if absolutely necessary as it requires the heart and soul of the researcher. Means are given to look for new phenomena. This is a new area for TRIZ and the methods are experimental. Idealize Informing Functions
225
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Is it Time for a New Physical Phenomenon? This decision has ramifications for the amount of work that will be required to make your product or service work. Generally speaking, when you change to a new physical phenomenon, there are many new unknowns. Perhaps you are lucky because you experienced in the new phenomenon. This makes the possibility of bridging to the new phenomenon much easier. Remember that the new product or service must compete with one that has been polished for many years. The bar is quite high.
Review the History Knowing the history of a system helps in understanding the main evolutionary trends. Each system has a main evolutionary tendency. The tendency of a system to stall along this evolutionary path is largely a function of the technical problems that directly conflict with this evolutionary tendency. You have already conducted a patent search within your industry so you have a lot of information about the history. This step can take time, but the information is extremely valuable from the viewpoint of continued steps. The inventor is becoming a true expert in this field.
Method Step 1: From patents and literature, study the history of the functions that are typically involved in the job. What functions have been added over time? What main physical parameters have improved? Step 2: From patents and literature, study the history of the technologies (physical phenomena) that typically deliver these functions. How have these technologies changed
226
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Plot the Course of Disruptive Technologies We have already discussed disruptive technologies in some depth. If you feel that a disruptive technology is threatening you, it may be wise to look at how rapidly this encroachment is occurring. This analysis takes a great deal of time, so it is usually not called for unless an imminent threat is detected.
#1 Capability
Speed #1 Market (Job)
#2 Capability #2 Market (Job)
Method Time Step 1: Each recognized market (job) is focused on a competitive parameter. Determine the competitive parameter. The progression of competitive parameters is as follows:
—Performance of the main parameter (speed, power, etc) —Reliability —Convenience —Cost Step 2: Plot this main competitive parameter for the most advanced leaders with respect to time for each market (job). This gives the capability curve. Step 3: Plot the average of the competitive parameter for all products for that market. This gives the demand curve for each market. Step 4: If the capability of the lower performing market appears to be on a course to cross the demand line of the market with the upper capability, then it is imperative that you find a way to switch to the technology used by the encroaching market. It may be necessary to spin off an independent group which is given proper resources and incentives to market this new technology. This may be difficult since the new market is likely to have developed new delivery channels. Another possibility is to consider a hybrid of the old and new technologies which enhance the existing performance.
Idealize Informing Functions
227
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Determine the System Maturity from Patents The maturity of systems can be determined by several means. One means is by the study of patents. This involves understanding the increase in performance of the main technical parameter related to main technical function, the level of invention and the number of patents over time. The method shown is very time consuming and should be applied if other methods prove ineffective in showing the importance of switching to a new physical phenomenon.
Method for Examining System Maturity Step 1: Identify the technical parameter related to the main function. Quantify how this has improved over time. Step 2: Identify how the level of invention has changed over time. The level of invention is typically high when changing to a new physical phenomenon. It peaks again during the period of rapid growth as resources are made available from sales. Later, it levels off as system Technical Maturity Stagnation resources are exhausted. Parameter The level of invention is as follows: ——1. No contradiction
resolution
of
Related to the
Infancy
Rapid growth
Main Function Level of Invention
——2. Resolves contradiction with small change ——3. Resolves contradictions with a major change. It uses technology from the same field.
Number Of Patents Per year
——4. Complete change in physical phenomenon. This is usually a technology from another field. ——5. New Physical Phenomenon. Has ability to change the supersystem to which it belongs. Step 3: Quantify the number of patents per year.
228
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Is it Time for a New Physical Phenomenon? The main reason that we would like to know the system maturity is because it is particularly important to determine whether there is a need to change to a new physical phenomenon to perform the main modification of the system product. A new physical phenomenon brings fresh resources which allow continued evolution of the function or the job that is being performed. Unfortunately, it also involves unknown risks and unfamiliarity of the side effects of the new phenomenon. An additional shortcoming of going to a new physical phenomenon is that the customer has come to accept certain levels of performance which will almost certainly not be achieved unless the transition is brought about through the use of hybrid phenomena which will be described later.
Required Conditions for a New Phenomenon If several of these conditions are present then consider a new physical phenomenon to deliver the main modification. Condition 1: The super-system has become very specialized. Condition 2: The super-system has reached the point of diminishing return. Are the main technical parameters improving very slowly? Condition 3: Automatic feedback is used to perform the main supersystem function. By the point that systems are using massive feedback, we can usually assume that the system is running out of resources. This is because the use of feedback is costly indicating that costly improvements are required to bring minor changes to performance. Condition 4: Multiple conflicts must be resolved for even minor improvements. (Many rocks appear when we begin to drain the pond) It is typical that products and services will be filled with compromise “solutions”. Between major improvements in the product, there is a tendency to ignore risks and to live with compromises. As time goes on and the product becomes specialized, these compromises mount up until changes in the operating environment exposes multiple compromises.
Idealize Informing Functions
229
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Is Hybrid or Stand-alone More Appropriate? Trying to satisfy an entrenched sustaining Introduction market will be unlikely with a completely of Hybrid new physical phenomenon. Some important competitive parameter will Competitive almost certainly be compromised. The Parameter sustaining market will demand that we not Introduction of Stand-alone depart from the s-curve of the existing Physical Phenomenon (Potentially Disruptive) effect. New markets will be much more forgiving and may even welcome the weaknesses of the new physical phenomenon as a strength. The new Phenomenon will gather strength as a hybrid and eventually replace the old phenomenon or it will gather strength as a stand-alone phenomenon in the new market. Clayton Christensen points out, that it is possible for the new stand-alone phenomenon to develop along its own s-curve. It may become a disruptive technology, taking away market share from the existing sustaining markets. Also, if the existing phenomenon is in the rapid growth part of the S-Curve, it will be difficult to catch up. Greater resources will keep the performance ahead of the new phenomena.
Method Step 1: If the market is a recognized and mature market then consider a hybrid of the old and new phenomenon. Step 2: If the market is an emerging or unrecognized market then consider using a completely new physical phenomena in which the native weaknesses of the physical phenomena are considered strength. (These markets usually start with very small sales volumes).
230
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Idealize Informing Functions
231
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Physical Phenomenon for Informing Functions In this step, we consider which physical phenomena can perform the modification to the observer that we desire. In effect, we are sensitizing our minds for the next step in which we consider the substance, object and field resources around us. Armed with the knowledge of what is possible, it will be easier to identify the value of a resource when we see it. Some of the phenomena that we may consider in this stage may seem a little wild or too weak to perform the function. Remember that such weak phenomena can often be boosted in latter stages of the algorithm. Therefore, it is important to keep an open mind to the possibilities.
Current Physical Phenomena Some of the potential phenomena will be considered “in-use”. This is an investigation of potential physical phenomena from competitive alternatives. Competitive alternatives are any systems that can potentially compete with the system that you are simplifying or creating. A newspaper is competition for the television. Car or truck transportation is competition for airline travel. Current physical phenomena are possibilities within the given industry. It is entirely possible that we should continue with these phenomena.
“New” Physical Phenomena The observer and the physical phenomenon will ultimately come packaged together. In other words, the decision of which physical phenomenon to use will come after seeing what resources are available. We are not making a decision at this point on the physical phenomenon and the object that will deliver it. Instead we are identifying potential physical phenomena that can deliver this informing function. We create a fertile situation so that when the right resources are presented, we can see their merit. While the phenomena that we discover may not be new in the sense that we have discovered them from research, they may be “new” to the industry. Informing functions create an additional challenge to identifying physical phenomena. While it is ideal to find a single physical phenomenon to inform the observer, this is not always possible. It is often necessary to create a chain of phenomena which delivers the required modification and can be realized by abundant resources. This creates a challenge. How do we identify this chain and harmonize it with abundant resources? Without software designed to perform this, we come back to a trial-and-error “what if…” situation. This subject is beyond the scope of this book. The potential physical phenomena which are suggested are sufficient for many problems and often allow for direct measurement or detection by the observer with few or obvious transformations. 232
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Physical Phenomena have a Chance to Compete The ideal resource is capable of holding its own. It must be abundant and capable of providing as many functions as possible. The final steps help us to decide between the different phenomena which might be the most ideal for our situation.
In-Use—Identify Competitive Alternatives through Observation and Questioning The competitive alternative is what people currently use and what they would use if they didn’t have what they are currently using. Remember that this is not necessarily what you would consider to be “the competition”. For a pet watering bowl, the competitive alternative might be a large bucket. In the early stages, Southwest Airlines did not compete against other airlines; they were in competition with travel by car. It is very tempting to go on personal experience to answer this question, but this is a trap. This is where many problem solvers and inventors go astray by assuming that they are like everyone else. There is wisdom in going to the battle to see how it is really being waged. There is no substitute for this. Don’t be satisfied with talking to a few people.
Method Step 1: Observe what the target market currently does to satisfy this function. If possible, go and watch before talking. By observing you get to the truth. What people do and what they say that they do are often two different things. Step 2: Ask how they satisfy this function and what they would do if they didn’t have what they currently use. This may give some valuable information into the history of the function. They will often offer what they did “way back when”. Step 3: Identify what “extreme users” currently do to satisfy this function and what they would do if they weren’t using their current means. Extreme users often have a range of experience with uncommon ways to satisfy a function. Step 4: Ask everyone that you interview where they go for the source of items and tools that they need to do these jobs. This will set you up for the next step.
Idealize Informing Functions
233
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
In-Use—Observe Existing Offerings While competitive alternatives can be anything that others would use if they were not using our system, there may be obvious competitors in the market place. Let’s go to the store to see what these offerings are.
Method Step 1: Go to a store that would sell offerings that deliver the required modification. Step 2: Note brands and producers. Do the producers sell more than one offering? Who are the main producers? Step 3: Look for product trends. Step 4: Read the labels. What do they claim?
In-Use—Internet Product Search Learn from the competitive alternatives (Remember that these may not be direct competitors). What jobs do they do? What functions do they perform? What Physical Phenomena delivers the functions? If you are searching for an unrecognized market and you find a major competitor then go back to the drawing board.
Method Step 1: Use an internet search-engine to determine what offerings are offered. Step 2: Refine the search by noting and using nomenclature and names that are common to the industry. Step 3: Consider cheap competitive alternatives.
In-Use—Check for Disruptive Technologies This thought tool is especially important to consider when targeting a market segment that is already consuming and in which you are trying to sustain the momentum. It is easy to get caught up in calling any great innovation a disruptive technology, but be careful how this term is used. Disruptive technologies are products and services that are typically disruptive to a business practice. Ultimately, they are so disruptive that many great businesses can no longer compete. 234
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The ones that you typically have to be concerned with are those that may disrupt your business. For instance, they do not give the margins that you have come to expect. They do not intersect your supply chain. They do not satisfy the same levels of performance that your main customers have become accustomed to. They require new vendors. Often, a disruptive technology will require a whole new business model. This is the most disruptive of all. As management considers these technologies, they will seem distasteful and will reject them because they feel that they are doing this in the best interest of their company. Remember, they are held captive by their largest customers. Few resources are left over for other customers and disruptive technologies. These disruptive offerings are generally initiated in industries that are not your own, but may be closely adjacent. They satisfy someone that is not currently purchasing from you, so they seem innocent. They usually do not perform at sufficient levels to attract the attention of your main customers. This is because they are designed to perform the same functions that your products perform, only for other markets. As these offerings increase in performance, eventually, they will have the capability of satisfying low-end customers in your market. Again, this seems innocent as these low end customers are not important to your business as you move up-market to gain higher and higher margins. Slowly, these offerings will gain in performance as they are fueled by the cash coming into these markets until you find that they are cutting into your mainline customers. Often, it is too late at this point because of the resources required to change over. Developing a whole new supply chain is very impractical. History has shown that it is nearly impossible to copy a disruptive technology at this point. Vendors are often locked up while supplying the new supply chain. Consumers have loyalty to the early products. You might ask why we are not intent upon creating technologies which are disruptive to our main competitors. While it is possible to create technologies that are disruptive to other’s businesses, this strategy can only work if your company is open to destructive creation of products and to the creation of new business models, usually in completely separate business units than your legacy products. In order to disrupt existing competition, you will ultimately cannibalize yourself. Remember that these are your competitors and you are competing for the same market. If the market of your competitor begins to move to your new product, they must also stop buying your legacy product. Most companies will find that it is usually better to try to satisfy a market that will not likely compete with your market. If you pick a non-consuming market to satisfy, there are many opportunities to create new offerings. The need to compete is virtually eliminated. You would only do this out of spite for the competitor which is not really a good business practice and will generally take you nowhere. If you are still determined to create a disruptive business for your competitor, there are more hurdles. This disruptive technology will need to compete against your biggest customers for resources. It will also be necessary to change long-held company values at the highest levels of the business. It is hard to admit that your business strategy and company values are wrong. In Idealize Informing Functions
235
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
order to make this kind of change a lot of people have to be aligned and committed. If they are not convinced, they will likely revolt in passive ways that are hard to detect and counter. A better approach than directly disrupting your business would be to start a new business built on a learning approach with its own resources. This business will create its own business model and supply chain from scratch. Finally, if you are still determined to create a disruptive technology within an existing business, you must recognize that, the business needs to have an offering which can stand on its own in some market. This is a large challenge on its own as most offerings fail due to all of the market conditions. In summary, it is usually not a good practice to try to create a disruptive technology (disruptive to you) within an existing business and customer base. The more likely place to create disruptive technologies is with new business startups. These have the ability to recognize market segments that are not being served. The reason for considering this step here is that others may be encroaching on your market and it is necessary to consider the physical phenomena that this disruptive technology is using. We do this because there is a way out of this trap and that is hybrid phenomena. Hybrid phenomena are the combination of two phenomena in such a way that the performance gained by one phenomenon compliments the other. In this way, the new phenomena can be used to better satisfy the existing market. This would be difficult to do if we made a sudden jump to the new phenomenon. When this occurs the performance is usually less than what the existing market expects. According to evolution of systems, when we move between physical phenomena, there is usually a transitional state through hybrid phenomena. A recent example of this is hybrid electric and petrol fueled vehicles. Checking for disruptive technologies amounts to looking for analogous functions in closely adjacent markets and then looking for how those functions are delivered. There are usually people in the business that have seen technologies that they would like to bring into the business. They may sense that these technologies will one day compete with them or that they could be exploited with current customers, but there is little support within the businesses. History has shown that many toppled businesses have seen these disruptors coming but were unable to respond adequately. The typical response is to try to force these disruptive technologies into existing markets with disastrous results. The new phenomenon is not capable of delivering the performance that the existing market has come to expect. As mentioned, the strategy that typically works is to strive for a hybrid technology that enhances the current technology. Once established, the new phenomenon will begin to take over from the existing phenomenon, all the while satisfying existing customers.
236
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Method Step 1: Identify technologies that exist in adjacent markets that seem to be threatening the existing business. These may be low cost alternatives or alternatives that use a different physical phenomenon to deliver the function. Step 2: Identify the physical phenomenon that is used to deliver the function. It is likely that this will later be considered for a hybrid physical phenomenon to satisfy the target market.
In-Use—Patent Searching and Study One of the best times for performing a patent search is when you 6,543,345 are searching for physical phenomena to deliver a function. During this particular step, we will be considering searching for 5,678,432 physical phenomena inside the given industry. Later, we will be searching for patents outside the industry as we identify 3,234,211 analogous situations. Not only will we better understand the possible physical phenomena that can be used, it is inevitable that other types of valuable information will be gathered along the way. Most people wait too long in the inventive process to perform a patent search. It is usually done after much time and expense to develop their invention. Often they find that someone has already patented their idea or that more useful and elegant concepts are available. This can be quite a blow! Waiting too long occurs for a variety of reasons. First, people get excited about an idea and they want to develop it without delay. It is easy to get very excited about what the future will bring. Wealth and fame are at your fingertips! There is no time to waste! The idea must put on the market before someone steals it or you lose your drive! This fear is usually unfounded and based on the idea that if we had the idea then the conditions are ripe for someone else to have it. Be patient, there are many inventions to be had if this one doesn’t pan out. Secondly, considering a patent search can invoke fear. It is like knowing that you should see the doctor while fearing that he will give you bad news. It is easy to this put off, but, like going to the doctor, the time investment is small compared to the time that can be wasted by not acting. It typically takes a Saturday morning to do a thorough patent search which is a small investment compared to the typical development time for an invention. Even though the resulting information can be somewhat deflating, it is better to start with a realistic view.
Idealize Informing Functions
237
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Thirdly, a patent search can appear to be beyond our capabilities. After all, people are employed full time to do patent searches! Again, this fear is unfounded. It is important to remember that you have several advantages that professional patent searchers do not have. You are motivated by the prospects of your idea. (A patent examiner is employed for money and is obligated to perform to certain minimum standards). You are not constrained by time and can afford to search to the bitter end. (Not all patent examiners are thorough and there may be time constraints on some examiners). You are more familiar with the technology than they are. (They do not have the time to become expert at the technologies that you are interested in). With a little practice, this overwhelming task can become natural and commonplace. Forth, understanding patents is difficult. Admittedly, patents have their own language. In this language, there is no legal prohibition to making up words! Patents can seem very stiff and…legal. Remember that it is in the favor of the legal profession that they look this way. We can easily convince ourselves that only patent attorneys can read patents. On the contrary, anyone can thoroughly understand a patent if they are willing to take the time. They have a repeatable structure, so you can learn the parts of the patent that you need to go to for specific information. Remember that it is much easier to learn to read patents when you are motivated by an idea. This will force you into the patent. Read it, digest it, and diagram it. Soon, you will be speaking “patenteze”. Reading and understanding your first patent may take you a half day, but the next patent will go much faster. Fifth, some feel that seeing what others have done will keep them from looking “outside the box”. Sure, there is a possibility that this can temporarily happen, but remember that this whole book is about making us uncomfortable inside the box. There are multiple opportunities to kick ourselves outside. Also, lots of additional information is learned along the way that strengthens our general understanding of physics. Understanding a broad spectrum of physical phenomena will make you a better inventor! Where we get into trouble is by studying only certain areas of physics deeply. Remaining “specialists” can have a constraining effect on our imagination. It is ok that you do not understand everything about patents when you begin your search. True, like first time car drivers, it is impossible to know what you do not know, but you have to start somewhere. If you make mistakes, remember that there are is a world of potential inventions out there. Dive in and you will find that you have more capacity than you thought! There is a wealth of information in patents that is often overlooked. Patents are structured so that others can duplicate the results of an invention. Consequently, it is necessary to give away many details. Most patents begin with a description of the typical approaches that are already available. This sets the stage for why their idea is an improvement. It usually gives the history of the problem (and sometimes the industry) and also a look at alternative physical phenomena that have been used. Following this section is a description of the invention and why it is an improvement. This gives details into new physical phenomena that may have been used. It may describe how various object attributes affect the operation of the product. You may also be able 238
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
to detect how the inventor overcame various contradictions. Clearly articulating the contradiction that was solved helps an inventor explain why their invention is “non-obvious to those experienced in the art”. This is the main hurdle that is required to get a patent. Next is a detailed description of the architecture of the invention. This gives valuable clues concerning the details of the physics. Finally, the claims section gives an idea to the scope of what the patent examiner thought was allowable to claim for the invention. Unless you are having problems with your computer, it takes about two hours to prepare for your first patent search. Mostly, this involves setting up links in your browser and a patent viewer. The patent viewer is important because looking at pictures conveys information much more rapidly then reading patenteze. Here is how to setup your computer browser with the necessary bookmarks to do a basic patent search: Step 1: Go to www.uspto.gov. This is the official patent website for the US government. If you take the time to familiarize yourself with this site, you will discover that a lot of effort has been made to make patent search and application easier for individuals. All of the forms are available for self application. There seems to be a bias towards helping individuals over corporations. You will particularly notice this if you submit a patent for consideration (this is called prosecuting a patent). People at the patent office sometimes bend over backward to help individuals, especially ones that have never been through the process before. Step 2: On the home page, go to “Patents”. You will find this on the left-hand side. If you click on this, a drop down will show you a several links. “Search Patents” is down the list a little. Go to this and bookmark it with a memorable name. You can also find this at http://www.uspto.gov/patft/index.html. This page is the main page for beginning patent searches. It allows for a variety of patent search formats. Step 3: Download the patent viewer for viewing patent drawings. As mentioned, viewing the patents will help immeasurable in understanding them. To access the viewer, go to http://www.uspto.gov/patft/help/images.htm. The program that you download for viewing patents is dependent upon the operating system and internet browser that you use. Follow the instructions and links for your particular operating system. If you are like most people and use the windows operating system and Internet Explorer for your browser, you can go to http://www.alternatiff.com/install/ to directly download the viewer. Remember to bookmark this page in case you need to reload the patent viewer for some reason. You will know that you have succeeded when the text appears at the bottom of the page informing you that it is installed. Step 4: Bookmark the definition of classifications and give it a memorable name. It is located at: http://www.uspto.gov/web/patents/classification/selectnumwithtitle.htm. Each patent is assigned a patent classification. Having a link to the classifications helps the searcher delineate between classifications. When you get to this page, you will notice that there is a numbering system which starts with items such as “apparel”. Remember that this is a very old system of classifying Idealize Informing Functions
239
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
patents that was based upon products that were available when it was started. Scroll through this list and look for more modern classifications to appear. Click on any one of the definitions. This will take you to sub-classifications. Patents are usually assigned a classification and at least one sub-classification. When you select one of the classification numbers, you finally arrive at the definitions. Step 5: Bookmark the index of classifications and give it a memorable name. It is located at: http://www.uspto.gov/web/patents/classification/uspcindex/indextouspc.htm. When you have an invention with a common name, you can find the classification by going to this index. Everything is listed in alphabetical order. For instance, if you are working on an improvement for hand shovels, you can go to shovels and find that there are a variety of objects which are referred to as shovels. There are hand shovels, power shovels, crane shovels, loading shovels, plow shovels, etc. This is important to know because many of these systems provide exactly the same function as the one that you are considering. In effect, they provide analogous functions in different industries. It is possible that they use physical phenomena and lines of evolution that are different from your industry. These can be put to work in your situation. Also, when you later identify other analogous products, you can readily find the patents for these products by using this index. Step 6: Bookmark the Advanced Search page and study the examples for Boolean searches. (Note that you can search for phrases in parenthesizes.) Now you are ready to perform the actual patent search.
Method Step 1: Search for patents directly related to the modification that you would like to perform Step 2: Using Advanced Search, search for key words in the abstract or body of the patents. Step 3: When you finally find a patent which is close to the intended subject, identify the classification. Step 4: Search by classification, making use of the Definitions and Index of Classifications. Make sure that classification includes possible patents that cover the field that you are interested in. Step 5: When you find good representative patents, note and view all patents cited. Step 6: Now search these patents and continue the process until no new patents regarding your area of interest show up. Step 7: Search patents for physical phenomena that are unusual to your industry. 240
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Library of Effects The Library of Effects is table of physical phenomena that can be used to deliver functions. Some software is capable of chaining physical phenomena to create the desired outcome from available resources.
Example—Voltage Change Due to Temperature Change of Hydrogen Gas Step 1: Start with the required change of properties of the observer due to a change of properties of the object being measured. The voltage of the observer object must change due to a temperature change of the gas. Step 2: State this in short format: Pressure changes voltage.
Hydrogen Changes Voltage
Circuit
Step 3: Convert the given function to a Generalized Useful Function. If a resource filter is available then filter for temperature fields and gas. Change voltage of a solid substance by use of a temperature field in a gas. Step 4: Find phenomena in the Library of Effects. Go to one of the sources for the library of effects. Some commercial software has this library. A scaled-down version can be found at www.creax.com Step 5: Locate the generalized function and then consider all of the physical phenomena that can be used. Note that it is harder to find a match because both the subject and the observer are already known. This is an additional constraint on the system.
Idealize Informing Functions
241
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Analogous Transformation An analogous phenomenon produces the same transformation of object attributes. This can be transferred to our situation with satisfying results.
Example—Voltage Change Due to Temperature Change of Hydrogen Hydrogen Gas Step 1: Start with the required change of properties of the observer due to a change of properties of the object being measured. The voltage of the observer object must change due to a temperature change of the gas.
Changes Voltage
Circuit
Step 2: State this in short format: Temperature changes voltage. (TÆV) Step 3: What other situations require the same transformation? Oven temperature sensing requires a change of voltage due to a change of gas temperature. Step 4: Search for patents related to this transformation. Step 5: Transfer this feature to the new situation. Consider combining this with the existing subject or transferring the minimum amount of the subject.
New—Mega-trend Analogous Observers If we look in industries that perform a function on a massive scale, we can often discover the evolutionary trend for this function along with physical phenomena which are used to accomplish it. It is even possible to identify physical phenomena by using the patent database.
Example—Voltage Change Due to Temperature Change of Hydrogen Gas Step 1: Start with the required change of properties of the observer due to a change of properties of the object being measured. The voltage of the observer object must change due to a temperature change of the gas.
Hydrogen
Changes Voltage
Circuit
Step 2: State this in short format: Temperature changes voltage. (TÆV) 242
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 3: What other situations in leading industries require the same transformation? This is where this same transformation occurs in large amounts of materials. Combustion sensors in automobiles. Step 4: Search for patents related to this transformation. Step 5: Transfer this feature to the new situation. Consider combining this with the existing subject or transferring the minimum amount of the subject.
New—Natural Analogous
Natural Product = ?
Observer Nature has developed many analogous phenomena that can be employed to perform functions. The concept of analogous phenomena starts with an analogous observer. Identifying objects in nature that require the same function will begin to lead the seeker to new physical phenomena.
Method Step 1: Identify analogous observers in nature. What objects in nature require or have this same function imposed? You might have to consider variants of this function. (Look for primitive natural analogies). Step 2: Identify the natural Observer/ Phenomenon Step 3: Transfer the Observer/Phenomenon to the new situation.
Example—Voltage Change Due to Temperature Change of Hydrogen Gas Step 1: Start with the required change of properties of the observer due to a change of properties of the object being measured. Hydrogen The voltage of the observer object must change due to a temperature change of the gas. Changes Voltage Step 2: State this in short format: changes voltage. (TÆV)
Temperature Circuit
Step 3: Where does this transformation occur in nature? Large amounts of charge are gathered during storms due, in part, to convection in clouds. Step 4: Transfer this feature to the new situation. Consider combining this with the existing observer or transferring the minimum amount of the Idealize Informing Functions
243
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
observer. Temperature variation causes movement of the gas which interacts with charged moisture, inducing a voltage in objects nearby.
New—Secondary Phenomena Rather than measuring the parameter, a second parameter can be measured which is influenced by the one that you would like to measure. Object parameters always influence each other. The temperature of an object affects its dimensions. The weight of an object affects its buoyancy. In reality, almost all parameters are measured by measuring a secondary parameter and then inferring the required measurement.
Example—Measurement of Pressure Step1: What exact parameter requires detection? Pressure Step 2: List secondary parameters that change when the main parameter changes. Physical State
Temperature
Shape Change
Step 3: Detect parameters instead.
these
secondary
Solid
Liquid
Gas
Measure the change of dimension
New—Measure a Copy or Facsimile When it is difficult to measure an attribute, attributes that you would like to measure. Following is a list of possible copies. • • • • •
Photographs Movies Paint Coverings Molds Time lapse photos • Impressions
244
• • • • •
Silhouettes Castings Resists Projections Computer Model
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Measurement of the Dimensions of an Elastic Article Traditional measuring instruments such as calipers tend to deform the article during measurement. Step 1: Measure a facsimile of the article. Measure the Silhouette
New—Successive Detection This thought tool is very similar to the concept of pre-measurement. In this step, we compare the parameter of an object to the same parameter of another object that comes only at discrete levels.
Example—Measuring the Resonant Frequency of Objects Step 1: How accurate does the measurement need to be? It needs to be within 50 Hz. Step 2: Break the levels of measurement, or the measurement of a secondary parameter into discrete levels. Create these levels in a second device. Examples are: Discrete volumes, Filters, Musical notes, Go-No-Go gages, Measuring spoons, Set of Weights. For the detection of the frequency, we will use a digital musical instrument which plays discrete notes Step 3: Compare the object being measured or detected to the discrete values. By ear, compare the musical note to the resonance. The musical note has a known frequency.
Idealize Informing Functions
245
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Resonance Resonance is an important type of secondary parameter. Many parameters can be measured by the resonance of an object or an attached object. Virtually every field can be detected by resonance. (Thermal resonance is difficult to achieve). It can occur at all levels from macro object to particles to molecules to atoms to electrons.
Example—Measurement of Resistance in a Wire and Its Connections Step 1: Identify if there is a natural resonance in the system. All electrical systems have resonance.
Resistance changes current resonance
Step 2: If the resonance is weak, are Ω there ways to boost the resonance such that a change in the measured parameter affects the resonance? Consider attaching an object and measuring the resonant amplitude, frequency or decay rate of oscillation. A capacitor and inductor can be added in series. A change in resistance will affect how rapidly the resonance decays.
New—Derivative Detection One of the most powerful ways to measure a parameter is to measure the rate of change and then integrate. (Measuring and then differentiating is also possible, but it is quite noisy). With modern computing, integration schemes are easily accomplished. It is also possible to integrate with analogue circuits.
f(t)Æf’(t)Æf”(t)
Example—Measurement of Relative Position of an Object Step 1: Measure higher order derivatives. Place an accelerometer on the object and measure acceleration. Step 2: Integrate as many times as necessary to determine the desired parameter. Integrate twice to determine the relative position of the object.
246
..
X dt =
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Detecting Multiple Subject Elements Often, it is easier to detect the average parameter of many objects than it is to detect the properties of a single object. This is almost always true when detecting the properties of small things such as particles, molecules, atoms.
Example—Measuring the Temperature of an Insect Step 1: Are the objects small? Yes, insects are small. Step 2: Does the subject come in natural batches or groups, or are they hard to separate? Not usually, unless they are swarming insects. Step 3: Is it more ideal or easier to detect the group simultaneously? For instance, is it advantageous to know the average value as opposed to individual values of measurement? Measuring the insects as a group makes it easier and gives an average value which may be more ideal in some situations.
New—Internal Field Markers When it is difficult to detect or measure a desired parameter, often it is because the materials and fields involved do not have strong interactions. Markers are a special type of additive that strongly couple with a field and are, therefore, easily detected. Often, the detection comes directly by sight, feel, smell or taste. One of the best ways to not add a material marker to the subject is to add a temporary or permanent field instead. This page considers different ways to add fields.
Example—Determining the Direction of Flow in a Pipe Step 1: Search the Table of Fields in the appendix for fields which can safely inhabit the subject. Here are the potential fields: Pressure— Surface Tension—Sound—Ultrasound—Vibrations—Current—Thermal Fields—Electromagnetic Fields—Electrostatic Fields.
Idealize Informing Functions
247
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 2: Once the subject has this added field, search the Table of Effects (physical phenomena) for ways to detect these fields. Detect Heat by touch. Solution: A heat cuff is attached to the pipe. The pipe becomes hotter in the direction of flow
New—External Field Markers Sometimes, a field will disrupt a substance enough that it should not inhabit the subject. Also, some fields are principally associated with surface phenomena and cannot inhabit the subject. Here we consider fields that reside on the subject, but are not associated with any other substances but the subject.
Example—Measuring the Rotational Speed of the Rings of Saturn. Step 1: Search the Table of Fields in the Appendix for fields which are principally associated with surface phenomena. Allow for fields which are only there momentarily. Here are the Fields: Surface Stress— Friction—Adhesion—Surface Tension—Odor-Taste—Corona Discharge—Skin Current—Electrostatic Fields—Reflected Light or Radiation. Step 2: Search the Library of Effects for ways to detect these fields. Doppler shift of reflected light allows detection of ring velocity. (Opposite sides of ring have different shift).
New—Attached Field Markers If no fields can inhabit the subject or its surface, then consider adding a substance to the subject that can be inhabited by a field with a strong coupling.
248
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Tracking Wild Animals Step 1: Search the Table of Fields at the end of the appendix for fields. For each field in the Table of Fields at the end of this appendix, identify a substance which is easily inhabited by a field which retains and exhibits the field. An antenna can be inhabited by an alternating electric current which gives off an electromagnetic field Step 2: Consider ways of attaching the substance to the subject. An emitting antenna is attached to the animal. The antenna’s field is detected by another antenna and amplifying circuit. Triangulation tells where the animal is.
New—Detached Field Markers Some of the field-substance couples in the attached field materials will disrupt the subject. If this is the case, then there may be secondary effects that the subject causes on the environment which can be measured by introducing a substance-field combination into the immediate environment and then detecting the field.
Example—Detecting Planets in Other Solar Systems Step 1: Identify a secondary effect of the measured parameter on the environment. Other Large Objects wobble due to the gravitational attraction of the planet. Step 2: For each field in the Table of Fields in the appendix, identify a substance which is easily inhabited by a field which retains and exhibits the field easily. The star maintains a thermal field and gives off light. Step 3: Consider ways to attach or mix the field into the environment and then detect the field. Detect the wobble by a slight Doppler shift
Idealize Informing Functions
249
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Internal Markers An internal marker is a substance additive that is mixed with or nested in the subject. This substance interacts with a matching field to aid detection. Remember that the ideal additive is one that does not exist. Consider these ways to produce additives that come close to not existing: 1. Especially active additives (very little is needed) 2. Concentrated additives (very little is required) 3. Temporary additives (eliminated or self-eliminated when not needed) 4. A decomposition of native materials. (Use only the part which delivers the function). It can be chemically decomposed or segmented.
Example—Detection of Refrigerant Leaks Step 1: Do the existing materials that are being measured react strongly to any field? Search the Table of Fields in the appendix. Step 2: If not, then introduce an additive (according to the rules above) internally into the substance to be measured which has a strongly coupled paired field. A luminescent material is introduced into the lubricant. A black light shows the location of the leak.
No
New—Attached Markers An attached marker is a marker which sits on the outside of the subject. This may be done to avoid the contamination or because it does not easily mix with the subject.
250
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Measuring the Position of Animals in the Wild It is difficult or dangerous to add a substance internally to the animal. Step 1: Does the subject react strongly with any field. Check the Table of Fields in the appendix. No. Step 2: if not, identify a field-substance couple that can be attached to the subject. Consider also coating the object. The animal wears a large collar with a visible number. Step 3: If problems arise, consider resolving the contradiction in subsequent steps.
30
New—Detached Marker A detached marker may be necessary if interaction with the subject and marker must be kept to a minimum. In this case, a secondary effect which the subject has upon the environment is detected.
Example—Detecting the Movement of Bacteria Step 1: Is it possible to find an internal or attached marker? No. Step 2: If the marker cannot be mixed or attached to the subject then identify secondary effects that a parameter change has on the immediate environment. The movement of the bacteria leaves waste products in the environment. Step 3: Add the marker to the environment and then detect the change in the marker. The medium is modified to react with the waste products to form bubbles.
Idealize Informing Functions
251
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
New—Intelligent Little People One of the most important tools of investigation is empathy. This is the ability to become a part of the system that we are investigating and to see it from this unique perspective. The principle of empathy is very powerful, but has a few limitations. First, we provide only one perspective from which to view the problem. Secondly, we must exist in order to view the problem. In other words, we cannot dissolve or disappear. Third, there is just one of us to interact with the system. If there were more of us to interact, this would open up new possibilities. These difficulties are largely overcome by using the principle of little intelligent people.
Method Step 1: Envision the system as composed of intelligent little people who can work together. These people also have the capability to disappear and reappear if necessary. What do they do to accomplish the desired result? How do they intelligently act together? Step 2: Consider possible physical phenomena that can accomplish this cooperation.
New—Evolution of Field Phenomena
Solid
Liquid
Gas
Field
Examine the Table of Fields in the Appendix. Note that the top fields are the most abundant fields and the bottom fields are typically the least abundant. In general, systems tend to use the top fields first for muscle and then the lower fields for sensing and control. Later, the lower fields may become more abundant. Since they are both abundant and controllable, it makes sense that systems evolve toward the bottom fields. By examining the fields currently being used by your system, or similar systems, you can guess the fields that might be used next.
252
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Method Step 1: What fields are currently being used to deliver this function? Step 2: What are the next fields that will likely be used?
New—Merge or Interact With Multiplied Subjects If you are aware of a physical phenomena which can perform the function there is a possibility that a completely new physical phenomenon can be identified by multiplying the common subjects and then making the multiplied subjects interact with each other.
Method Step 1: Identify an object related to a physical phenomenon that is similar to the one required. Step 2: Multiply the system. Step 3: Can these subjects be merged or interact together to create an unexpected capability? Try different orientations. Step 4: Consolidate elements if possible.
New—Hybrid Combination of Physical Phenomena This method is extremely useful when you are working with a demanding sustaining market and the resources of the current phenomenon are becoming limited. This is a way to move to the new physical phenomena while increasing (rather than sacrificing) performance, as is often the case when jumping to a new effect.
Method Step 1: Begin with a common physical phenomenon that is normally used to deliver the modification Step 2: Identify another phenomenon which performs the same modification. Idealize Informing Functions
253
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Step 3: What is the feature of the new subject which would extend the capability of the first subject? Step 4: Identify the cheap subject which should deliver most of the function. Step 5: Combine both phenomena into a hybrid. A new capability should emerge. Try combining both as whole subjects. Try transferring just the desirable feature. Consider having the two physical phenomena interact with each other.
Filter—Abundant Resources The availability or abundance of resources to deliver the physical phenomena must be high. Objects and resources are already present in the environment that can help deliver the physical phenomena. We do not determine in this section whether a sufficient abundance exists. This will occur in the next section. That is why this section deals with possible physical phenomena.
Method In order for the physical phenomenon to have any chance, it should be abundant in the system. Step 1: Identify abundant fields—these are usually associated with abundant physical phenomena. Step 2: Filter the potential phenomena (previous steps) to allow only those which are abundant.
254
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Filter—Inherent Harm (Contact) Some physical phenomena require the addition of harmful interactions. This is especially true with physical phenomena that require contact. If physical phenomena are present which do not require contact and the resources for providing this physical phenomena are abundant, then consider these over those that require contact.
Method Step 1: Filter the physical phenomena that you are considering for contact.
Filter—Multiple Functions The more useful functions that a given physical phenomena can provide, the better. Consider the functions that your system will perform and ask: “How many of these functions can be provided by the new phenomena? In the case of measurement, it would be more ideal of the physical phenomenon could both sense and control.
Method Filter the available physical phenomena or identify another physical phenomenon that can both sense the required object attributes and also perform control.
Filter—Passive Control If sensing and actuation are required in the same system, then it is ideal to perform both functions with the same subject. It is therefore necessary that the physical phenomenon is capable of delivering both.
Method Step 1: Identify the informing function Step 2: Identify the actuation function Step 3: Search for a physical phenomena that can perform both.
Idealize Informing Functions
255
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Filter—Deliver both the Function and the Anti-Function + The evolution of systems predicts that systems will eventually take on the antifunction in order to provide more value. The anti-function is often provided by the super-system already, but it is often forgotten because it may occur much later than when the product or process is applied. But what does this mean when we refer to measurement? Whenever measurement occurs, there is a disturbance to the system. If you dip a thermometer into a hot liquid, the liquid must change the temperature of the thermometer in order for it to register. For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. While the thermometer is being heated, the liquid is being cooled. While most measuring instruments are designed to disturb the system as little as possible, a very accurate measurement of the system may require that the disturbance be undone, preferably at the same time that the measurement is taken.
Method Step 1: Identify the useful function. Step 2: Identify the anti-function. This is function which undoes the function. Another way to form the anti-function is to consider the opposite of the useful function and then look for a useful variation of this function. Note that the anti-function of changing is controlling. Step 3: Does adding the anti-function expand or change the target market?
256
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Chain of Objects for Informing Functions The IFR is a classical TRIZ tool. First, we ask ourselves what final result should be, and then we tell ourselves that we will achieve this result without the use or addition of any object or substance to the system. This is often possible when we can get an object to perform more functions than it normally would. It is also possible if we can eliminate objects and allow something in the system to take over the function.
The Ideal Measurement Device is Parasitic Parasitic observers use something which already exists in the system, super-system or environment to perform the function. When this occurs, it is actually possible to get something for nothing.
The Ideal Observer Steals Functions from Other System Objects—Theft of Functions If we have to have the observer, we should make the most of it. The system will become more ideal with fewer elements. Thus, we must look around and see of a given observer can perform more functions than it already is.
Parasite—Already Poorly Performed by Native Fields Sometimes, a function is already performed by some natural phenomenon but it is done very poorly or even harmfully. With a little help, we can boost these functions until they become useful.
Method Step 1: Is the function already delivered by a super-system observer, even poorly? Step 2: What physical phenomenon is employed to poorly deliver this function? In following steps we can ask what modifications to the fields or the observer allow the function to be boosted. These modifications may Idealize Informing Functions
257
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
require the small addition of substances or structures which react strongly to the native fields.
Parasite—Abundant Native Fields Most objects are awash in native fields. These fields do not remain constant throughout the product life cycle. By identifying the fields all around the observer, we locate observer resources that can perform the function.
Method Step 1: Process Map the product life through relevant life stages. Step 2: Look through the Table of Fields at the end of this appendix. Identify which native fields the subject experiences at each process step. Which of these native fields perform this function even poorly? Step 3: What Effect or physical phenomena can be employed to deliver this function? In the next steps we can try to boost this function
Parasite—Laundry List of Adjacent Elements
Laundry List
In this step we consider ordinary elements about us that might be pressed into service to deliver the required physical phenomena. This method is especially effective with low level fields such as elastic fields, gravity, pressure, etc.
Method Step 1: Make a laundry list of adjacent elements, especially those which were not considered in the super-system functional models. Step 2: What fields are associated with these objects? Step 3: Consider ways in which elements on the list might be pressed in to service to perform the required modification. Step 3: Consider decomposing elements into new components.
258
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Parasite—Use of Cheap Abundant Substances When a function can be delivered at low cost, the value of the system increases. If there is a way to use a cheap abundant substance, try to use it. If the phenomenon is weak, it may be possible to boost the phenomenon later.
Method Consider the following list of cheap substances. Could any of these be used to deliver any of the Phenomena that you are considering? List of Cheap Substances: Powders—Foams—Voids—Water—Ice—Steam— Hydrates—Air—Nitrogen—Carbon Dioxide—Oxygen—Corrosion— Decay—Sand—Soil—Rocks—Waste—Waste Water—Sawdust—Waste Glass—Waste Gases—Waste Paper—Garbage—Yard Waste—Industrial Wastes—Hybrid Substances—Disassociated Forms of Any of the Above—Products of Interactions—Starting Materials—Final Products— Semi-Finished Elements.
Parasite—Nearby Similar Measurement Device Depending on how systems evolve, it is common that several elements in the system need detection or measurement. Several objects may be detected or measured by the same observer. Sometimes, this same observer can be pressed into service to perform the function on both subjects.
Method Step 1: Identify a similar observer nearby which detects or measures similar attributes. Step 2: Combine and consolidate both elements into one system.
Parasite—Simplified Copy of the Current Measurement Device Use of the current observer can be overkill, especially if the observer is a human. A simplified copy can often perform the same function as the full observer.
Idealize Informing Functions
259
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Method Step 1: What part of the current observer performs the function? Step 2: Can a copy of the observer perform the function?
Parasite—Steal Human Service to System The Master shall not serve the slave. All human interactions on the system should be performed by the system if they are necessary.
Our System
Method Human
Step 1: Identify human actions on the system. Step 2: Assume that the system performs these functions on itself
Step 3: Note that in order to oust humans; the human function must be deintellectualized.
Theft— of Functions from Super-System (TRIZ Universality also ASIT Unification Tool) All systems within the super-system, including the super-system itself, are competing for functions. When we steal functions, the more closely related the function is to the function of your system, the more readily it will be accepted.
Method Step 1: List objects in the environment associated with the job at hand. Take especial note of objects with similar functions. Step 2: The Observer takes over all or part of another objects functions. This is not simply a combining of objects. When you are done, one of the two original objects should be “invisible.” There should be no compromise in the original functions. Step 3: Completely new and unexpected benefits must emerge. different orientations and combinations.
260
Try
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Theft— from Alternative or Competing Objects Identify other objects or processes that seek to provide the same functions or do the same job. Sometimes these are not obvious alternatives. Though they may be from completely different industries, they are the true competition.
Method Step 1: Consider objects which provide the extreme of the function as well. Step 2: Consider taking over all or part of these objects functions. New and exciting capabilities should emerge, as well as new synergies between the objects that could not exist before.
Theft—Boost Incidental Functions Most objects in a system provide incidental functions that we rarely noticed. If we can identify these incidental functions and boost them, it is often possible to create more value for our offering.
Method Identify incidental functions that the system already performs. Step 1: What elements in the super-system normally deliver this function? Step 2: Boost these incidental functions to take over for the other supersystem elements. Look for unexpected capabilities to emerge.
Idealize Informing Functions
261
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Theft—Steal Human Interactions Unless the object of the system is to directly serve humans in the system, there is usually a burdensome element to any function provided by humans to the system. When humans are eliminated from any function in the system, the system becomes less burdensome. Note that in order to oust humans, the human function must be de-intellectualized.
Human
Method Step 1: Look at the system from the viewpoint of humans that interact with the system. Are humans required to operate the system? Are humans required to maintain the system? Step 2: What changes to the system would allow the human to be removed from the system?
262
Idealize Informing functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Idealize Harmful Functions If the function that you are trying to idealize is a harmful function, then begin here. It may sound somewhat counterintuitive to consider idealizing something that is actually harmful. It would seem to instantly create an oxymoron. For instance, we might find ourselves considering the “ideal pain”, “ideal wear” or “ideal product failure”. While this might sound ridiculous, we shall see that there are ways to think about this that can turn harm on its head. In the end, harm must not exist and might even become useful. There are three main ways of handling harmful functions. 1) Turn the harmful function into a useful function and then boost it. 2) Decrease the harm. 3) Eliminate elements. The first consideration involves idealizing the modification of a harmful function. We will consider that later. The second consideration will be considered as the subject of the book “Fixing It”. The third consideration deals, in this case, with eliminating the product.
The Ideal Product for Harmful Functions As with useful functions, we will first consider the ideal product. At this point, the only ideal products of harmful functions that have been identified are those that do not exist.
The Ideal Product Can’t Be Harmed Because It Doesn’t Exist With the exception of turning harm to good, the removal of elements is almost always the most ideal way to increase the value of a system. That is why we are considering this first.
Idealize Harmful Functions
263
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Non-Existent Waste Product Some products are not required in a system. They may be harmful, expended or waste products. If the product has outlived its usefulness, is waste or was never required, consider eliminating it.
Example—Disposal of Waste Oil At industrial sites, waste liquid products are often spilled, polluting ground water. This spillage is accomplished by corrosion of the vessels, clumsy handling, etc. Step 1: The product goes away of its own accord by being combined with something else which allows it to dissipate. The spent liquid is waste, waiting for recycling. Step 2: Consider ways in which the product never existed. —It is no longer manufactured —Eliminate the Source of the product —Eliminate the Path of the product —Absorb the product into another substance. Absorbent materials might include porous materials, fabrics, batting or gel. Step 3: The waste product remains or becomes useful and is eliminated by its usefulness. In this case, the waste oil is immediately burned as an energy source.
264
Idealize Harmful functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
The Ideal Modification for Harmful Functions After focusing on the ideal product, the second part of a useful function that we focus on is the ideal modification. We ask: What do we really want to have happen and what are the attributes of the ideal modification? Since we have not yet decided what will deliver these idealized modifications to the product, we are actually composing a wish-list of what the ideal modification will look like. When we add real elements to deliver the modification, these elements often bring undesirable characteristics with them. Strangely, harmful functions often follow the same format of idealizing that useful functions do. For instance, the timing of a harmful function can change it from a harmful function to a useful function. Note that we include the tool that performs the function in all of the harmful functions. A useful function can only exist if there is a tool to perform it. Now, it becomes a challenge to turn this harmful function into a useful function by using the various tools.
The Ideal Harmful Modification is Useful Our first attempt to idealize harmful functions is to change them into useful functions. This is truly making lemonade out of lemons, which is generally not the first thing that people think of. It is often easier to conceptualize the reduction of harm to zero. If one were to think of this on a sliding scale, we might see it this way.
Preventative Modifications Less ideal than modifications that do not need to be performed are added functions that prevent harmful functions. We are not talking about functions that modify design attributes, but rather adding preventative functions that are part of the system. To illustrate the difference, we may recognize that our product is harmed by a high temperature environment. We could make a design decision which increases the temperature capability of the product. This may require adding a function to the manufacturing process. This is an example of adding a function that modifies a design attribute and we will consider these changes to the system later when we are considering changing the product at the level of attributes. On the other hand, if we added the function of active cooling to the system to prevent the problem in the first place, and this active Idealize Harmful Functions
265
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
cooling was to travel with the system outside of the manufacturing process, then this is a good example of the preventative modifications that we will consider here. The reason that this is less ideal is that this can increase the complexity of the system. There may be good reasons to do this, however. By adding functions, we can sometimes reduce the complexity of the super-system or (sometimes) the system itself. If the system already has many compensating or remedial functions, we may be able to reduce the overall number of elements by applying a strategic preventative modification.
Diminishing Modifications A “Diminishing Modification” is one that reduces the effect of a harmful function WHILE the harmful function is occurring. This is occurs downstream of preventative functions and upstream of remedial functions. Diminishing Modifications are usually less ideal than preventative modifications because there is greater possibility of increasing system complexity. Again, there may be situations where adding a diminishing modification will improve the complexity of the super-system.
Remedial Modifications Least ideal of all is remedial modifications. These are modifications that fix the harmed product after the fact. This is the least ideal because it requires the addition of new system elements. It may be justified, however, by reducing the complexity of the super-system.
266
Idealize Harmful functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Useful
Useful
Harmful
Harmful
Typical Thinking is to reduce to zero
Changing to Useful
The typical approach to reducing harm to zero comes from finding object attributes which can be changes, such as size, position, duration, color and then adjusting the level of these attributes to reduce the harm. Here, we take an entirely different approach. We actually want to do something that is truly valuable with that which was harmful. This creates the possibility of eliminating elements, especially if the new useful function performs a function done by something else in the system.
Make Useful—Anti Function We are going to try to reverse the function and perform the antifunction. In this first attempt, we are going to allow for the possibility of using any method from the Table of Knobs (object attributes).
Mod
AntiFunction
Method Step 1: Identify the anti-function. Would this be considered a useful function in the system? Step 2: Now that the anti-function has been identified, we boost this function. Use any of the methods from the Table of Knobs (Appendix) to boost this now-useful function. We may need to consider modifications to other elements in the system. In the end, the system must become simpler, or the solution is not a good one.
Idealize Harmful Functions
267
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Make Useful—Reverse the Fields or Action One of the simplest ways to reverse or create the anti-function is to directly reverse the fields.
Example—Foundry Explosions Consider a situation where water escapes from cooling pipes into the refractory bricks of a smelter. The water explodes upon contact with the bricks. One of the harmful functions is that the pressurized water pushes itself out of the pipe
Pushes
Water
Step 1: Reverse the fields to perform the Anti-function. Reversing the fields means that the water in the pipe is under vacuum. The pump pulls the water rather than pushing it. Step 2: What constitutes the reverse of the current action? The water pulls itself. Step 3: What is the action performed relative to? Change that instead. It pushes relative to the hole position of the pipe. This would imply that the pipe should move instead of the water. This may be possible … Step 4: Boost the anti-function to make it completely useful. Here we reverse the pressure field and cause vacuum in the line. This is effectively done by Pulls having the pump draw the water through the Water line rather than pushing it.
268
Idealize Harmful functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Make Useful—Reframing Harmful Functions as Useful Functions This tool is a different but powerful way to turn lemons into lemonade. What we are trying to do is to reframe a harmful action so that it is now useful. This is like a criminal trying to rationalize their crime in a way that everyone thinks that it was truly a good thing that he did. “I wasn’t holding up the store, I was helping the store owner to test their security”. Virtually every harmful action has a useful context. For instance, if one part is wearing another part, we can ask ourselves “Where are the contexts where we want wear to happen?” Answers to this are in situations where we are polishing or grinding on purpose. Going back to the criminal analogy, he would say “I wasn’t wearing the surface; I was just trying to polish it!” If we reframe the harmful variation as a good one, then we can boost this function and make it truly useful.
Mod
Useful Variant
Examples: Melt —> Form Wear —> Form Break —> Disassemble Tear —> Cut Burn —> Cook Disturb —> Control Corrode —> Secure Corrode —> Form
Example—Syrup is Melting Chocolate In order to increase production of a chocolate factory, the syrup that was normally pumped into the chocolate was heated. This reduced the viscosity, allowing for larger volumes to be pumped through the existing pipes. Unfortunately, the heated syrup now distorted the chocolates.
Syrup
Distorts
Chocolate
Step 1: Cast the harmful function in a useful context—any useful context. This often takes a little practice, but the change in perspective can be very Syrup Syrup satisfying. If you are having trouble, identify situations where the harmful 1. Forms Distorts 2. Cooks action is done on purpose. In our case, 3. Changes Taste we can say that the syrup forms or cooks the chocolate. Chocolate Chocolate Step 2: Can this function take over for something else in the system, thus simplifying the system? Or, is this a new and useful function? We will consider allowing the syrup to partially form the chocolate. Step 3: Boost this now-useful function. Idealize Harmful Functions
269
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Example—Cancer Repair Cancer is normally thought of as a very harmful element in the body. What harm does it cause? Cancer causes an number of harmful effects including the replacement or invasion of healthy tissue. Step 1: Cast the harmful function in a useful context—any useful context. This often takes a little practice, but the change in perspective can be very satisfying. If you are having trouble, Cancer identify situations where the harmful action is done on purpose. In our Invades case, we can say that the cancer repairs the tissue.
Cancer
Invades
Tissue
Cancer Rebuilds
Tissue
Tissue
Step 2: Can this function take over for something else in the system, thus simplifying the system? Or, is this a new and useful function? We will consider allowing the cancer cells repair a heavily damaged organ. Step 3: Boost this now-useful function.
Make Useful—Work With Sometimes an object will perform a harmful function and a useful variant at the same time. The useful function may be formed to such a low degree that it is not recognized. Boosting the useful variant effectively eliminates the harmful.
Example—Telescope Dust Cover A telescope uses a transparent dust cover. Small irregularities in the cover distort the incoming light. The distortions could be used to correct the effect of a spherical (non-parabolic) mirror which would be cheaper to fabricate. Step 1: Is the useful variant of the harmful function performed with the harmful function, but so slightly as to not be Spherical noticed? Some of the distortions actually help Mirror to focus the light. Can this be used if it were boosted? It is possible to design the dust cover Controlled so as not to distort. In fact, in working with Distortion the reflecting mirror the light can be focused. A further refinement is to recognize how the 270
Idealize Harmful functions
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
reflecting mirror can be modified to help the situation. A spherical mirror is much easier to produce. The effect of the dust cover can allow the spherical mirror to focus the light like a parabolic mirror as in a meniscus telescope. (It should be noted that a meniscus telescope typically focuses the light off of a reflecting piece on the cover and back through a hole in the spherical mirror. Step 2: Is the anti-function performed with the harmful function but not in equilibrium? Boost the anti-function. No anti-function is detected. Step 3: Is the harmful function useful any place on the product or on other elements to the least degree? Boost this function. No useful place is noticed.
Make Useful—Aesthetic Incorporation Many forms of art require the artist to incorporate flaws which inadvertently occur during the creation of the art. A small and accidental mark on an India Ink drawing becomes the beginning a bush, etc.
Harmful Useful
Example—Cutting Plastic Tubing A plastic tube is cut. In the process, the tube is malformed where the blade begins to cut.
Malformed
Step 1: Can the flaw, caused by the harmful modification be directly incorporated aesthetically? No way is seen. Step 2: Multiply the flaw. Make different patterns with the multiplied flaw. What pattern looks the best or performs a useful function? If the pattern is repeated, it becomes a rolled cut Step 3: Can this aesthetic incorporation perform a useful function? The bevel can act to guide elements that might be attached to the tube ends.
Idealize Harmful Functions
271
TR IZ P ower T oo ls
Make Useful—Make Adjustable Almost any harmful function can be made useful if it can be made adjustable. Adjustable friction becomes traction control. Adjustable wear becomes forming.
Example—Blinding Car Lights
Light Blinds
Consider the blinding light that is seen from oncoming traffic with their high beams on.
Driver
Step 1: If the harmful function could be made to be adjustable, it might be able to perform the anti-function. What is a useful variant or a useful function on the system prod