2002
Trends in International Migration
«
Trends in International Migration
This report analyses recent trends in migration movements and policies in OECD countries as well as in selected non-member countries. It includes a detailed description of the flows and channels of immigration and the nationalities of the migrants concerned. It highlights the contribution of immigration to increases in the total population and the labour force and describes the changes that have taken place in the sectoral distribution of foreign workers. It also underlines the growth of employment-based migration and the measures implemented by some OECD countries to facilitate the recruitment of skilled and highly skilled foreign workers. The report notes that the control of flows remains a high priority on the agenda of migration policies, as does the extension of co-operation with countries of origin. Particular attention is given to the integration of immigrants, and notably of youth, into the labour market and society as a whole. In addition to this overall analysis, the reader will also find in this publication: – Two sections on migration in East and South-East Asia, and recent developments in migration movements in and from central and eastern European countries. – A special chapter devoted to a comparative analysis of recent studies of labour shortages and the needs for immigrants in OECD countries. – Country notes describing in detail recent developments in migration flows and policies. – A statistical annex containing the most recent available data on foreign and immigrant populations, foreign workers, migration flows and naturalisations.
This book is available to subscribers to the following SourceOECD themes: Social Issues/Migration/Health Emerging Economies Transition Economies Ask your librarian for more details on how to access OECD books on line, or write to us at
[email protected]
Trends in International Migration
OECD's books, periodicals and statistical databases are now available via www.SourceOECD.org, our online library.
www.oecd.org
ISBN 92-64-19949-7 81 2003 06 1 P
SOPEMI 2002
-:HSTCQE=V^^Y^V:
SOPEMI 2002
© OECD, 2003. © Software: 1987-1996, Acrobat is a trademark of ADOBE. All rights reserved. OECD grants you the right to use one copy of this Program for your personal use only. Unauthorised reproduction, lending, hiring, transmission or distribution of any data or software is prohibited. You must treat the Program and associated materials and any elements thereof like any other copyrighted material. All requests should be made to: Head of Publications Service, OECD Publications Service, 2, rue André-Pascal, 75775 Paris Cedex 16, France.
SOPEMI
Trends in International Migration Continuous Reporting System on Migration
ANNUAL REPORT 2002 EDITION
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT Pursuant to Article 1 of the Convention signed in Paris on 14th December 1960, and which came into force on 30th September 1961, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) shall promote policies designed: – to achieve the highest sustainable economic growth and employment and a rising standard of living in member countries, while maintaining financial stability, and thus to contribute to the development of the world economy; – to contribute to sound economic expansion in member as well as non-member countries in the process of economic development; and – to contribute to the expansion of world trade on a multilateral, non-discriminatory basis in accordance with international obligations. The original member countries of the OECD are Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States. The following countries became members subsequently through accession at the dates indicated hereafter: Japan (28th April 1964), Finland (28th January 1969), Australia (7th June 1971), New Zealand (29th May 1973), Mexico (18th May 1994), the Czech Republic (21st December 1995), Hungary (7th May 1996), Poland (22nd November 1996), Korea (12th December 1996) and the Slovak Republic (14th December 2000). The Commission of the European Communities takes part in the work of the OECD (Article 13 of the OECD Convention).
OECD CENTRE FOR CO-OPERATION WITH NON-MEMBERS The OECD Centre for Co-operation with Non-members (CCNM) promotes and co-ordinates OECD’s policy dialogue and co-operation with economies outside the OECD area. The OECD currently maintains policy cooperation with approximately 70 non-member economies. The essence of CCNM co-operative programmes with non-members is to make the rich and varied assets of the OECD available beyond its current membership to interested non-members. For example, the OECD’s unique co-operative working methods that have been developed over many years; a stock of best practices across all areas of public policy experiences among members; on-going policy dialogue among senior representatives from capitals, reinforced by reciprocal peer pressure; and the capacity to address interdisciplinary issues. All of this is supported by a rich historical database and strong analytical capacity within the Secretariat. Likewise, member countries benefit from the exchange of experience with experts and officials from non-member economies. The CCNM’s programmes cover the major policy areas of OECD expertise that are of mutual interest to nonmembers. These include: economic monitoring, structural adjustment through sectoral policies, trade policy, international investment, financial sector reform, international taxation, environment, agriculture, labour market, education and social policy, as well as innovation and technological policy development. Publié en français sous le titre : Tendances des migrations internationales RAPPORT ANNUEL
© OECD 2003 Permission to reproduce a portion of this work for non-commercial purposes or classroom use should be obtained through the Centre français d’exploitation du droit de copie (CFC), 20, rue des Grands-Augustins, 75006 Paris, France, tel. (33-1) 44 07 47 70, fax (33-1) 46 34 67 19, for every country except the United States. In the United States permission should be obtained through the Copyright Clearance Center, Customer Service, (508)750-8400, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923 USA, or CCC Online: www.copyright.com. All other applications for permission to reproduce or translate all or part of this book should be made to OECD Publications, 2, rue André-Pascal, 75775 Paris Cedex 16, France.
FOREWORD This twenty-seventh annual report of the OECD Continuous Reporting System on Migration draws in large part on 32 written contributions from national correspondents (see the list at the end of this report), and on the summary of their discussions at their last annual meeting (December 2001). The 2002 Edition is divided into three parts and a Statistical Annex. Part I describes overall trends in international migration. It focuses on the magnitude, the nature and the direction of flows, as well as the presence of foreign workers in the labour market and in the various sectors of economic activity. Special attention is also given to changes in the countries of origin of immigrants. Two additional sections describe in detail migration in East and South-East Asia together with migration movements in and from Central and Eastern Europe. Part I is completed by an overview of migration policies, in particular those relating to the control of flows, the fight against irregular migration and illegal employment of foreigners, as well as the integration of immigrants in host countries and international co-operation between sending and receiving countries. Part II is devoted to a comparative analysis of recent studies of labour shortages and the needs for immigrants. The available studies confirm the existence of labour market tightness, especially for skilled employment. The report highlights the diversity of methods used by OECD countries to evaluate current and future labour shortages, with a special focus on the needs for IT workers as well as social and medical personnel, and teachers. Labour market tightness also exists for some low-skilled jobs. However, not all OECD countries are necessarily considering an increase in labour-related migration as an answer to the problem of labour shortages. The report also shows that it is important to improve the way present and future generations are prepared and trained to meet the needs of the labour market. Part III is composed of country notes describing recent developments in migration flows and policies in twenty-nine OECD countries and selected non-member countries (The Baltic States, Bulgaria and Romania). This volume is published under the responsibility of the Secretary-General of the OECD.
3
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
This report analyses recent trends in migration movements and policies in OECD countries as well as in selected non-member countries. It includes a detailed description of the flows, the different channels of immigration and the nationalities of the migrants concerned. It highlights the contribution of immigration to increases in the total population and the labour force and describes the changes that have taken place in the sectoral distribution of foreign workers. It also underlines the growth of employment-based migration and the measures implemented by some OECD countries to facilitate the recruitment of skilled and highly skilled foreign workers. The report notes that the control of flows remains a high priority on the agenda of migration policies, as does the extension of co-operation with countries of origin. Particular attention is given to the integration of immigrants, and notably of youth, into the labour market and society as a whole. In addition to this overall analysis, the reader will also find in this publication: • Two sections on migration in East and South-East Asia and recent developments in migration movements in and from Central and Eastern European countries. • A special chapter devoted to a comparative analysis of recent studies of labour shortages and the needs for immigrants in OECD countries. • Country notes describing in detail recent developments in migration flows and policies • A statistical annex containing the most recent available data on foreign and immigrant populations, foreign workers, migration flows and naturalisations.
4
© OECD 2003
TABLE OF CONTENTS GENERAL INTRODUCTION .........................................................................................................................................................
13
Part I MAIN TRENDS IN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION A.
MIGRATION AND POPULATION TRENDS ..........................................................................................................................
17
1. Trends in migration movements and changes in the foreign population................................................................ 2. Immigration and population growth in OECD countries ............................................................................................
17 52
IMMIGRANTS AND THE LABOUR MARKET .......................................................................................................................
58
1. 2. 3. 4.
The contribution of foreigners to the labour force is increasing ............................................................................... Participation rates of foreigners by gender and place of birth: persistent imbalances......................................... Sectoral breakdown and trends in the employment of foreigners. .......................................................................... Foreigners are more vulnerable to unemployment than nationals..........................................................................
58 59 61 67
RECENT TRENDS IN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION IN ASIA AND CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE ...................
70
1. Recent developments in migration flows within East and South-East Asia ............................................................ 2. Trends in migration flows in Central and Eastern Europe .........................................................................................
71 78
D. AN OVERVIEW OF MIGRATION POLICIES..........................................................................................................................
85
1. Policies for regulating and controlling flows ................................................................................................................ 2. Reinforcement of legislation concerning the fight against irregular migration and illegal employment of foreigners ..................................................................................................................................................................... 3. Policies for the integration of immigrants .................................................................................................................... 4. Migration and international co-operation ....................................................................................................................
85
B.
C.
88 91 95
Part II LABOUR SHORTAGES AND THE NEED FOR IMMIGRANTS: A REVIEW OF RECENT STUDIES INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................................................
103
A.
MEASURING CURRENT LABOUR SHORTAGES.................................................................................................................
103
1. Trends in national statistics on the number of registered vacancies by sector of employment and occupational category ............................................................................................................................................. 2. Causes of labour shortages ............................................................................................................................................ 3. Labour reserves exist but it would be difficult to mobilise them rapidly ...............................................................
104 104 105
THE ROLE OF MIGRATION IN ADDRESSING FUTURE LABOUR MARKET NEEDS......................................................
106
1. Demographic challenges ................................................................................................................................................ 2. Special studies on the economic need for migration .................................................................................................
106 111
STUDIES ON LABOUR SHORTAGES AT MICRO-LEVEL AND THE NEED FOR IMMIGRANT WORKERS ...................
113
1. Sector-level studies on the need for immigrant workers ........................................................................................... 2. Studies on labour shortages by occupation ................................................................................................................ CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................................................................
114 115 117
B.
C.
5
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
Part III RECENT CHANGES IN MIGRATION MOVEMENTS AND POLICIES (COUNTRY NOTES) Australia ............................................................................. Austria ................................................................................ The Baltic States ............................................................... Belgium .............................................................................. Bulgaria .............................................................................. Canada ............................................................................... Czech Republic ................................................................. Denmark............................................................................. Finland ............................................................................... France................................................................................. Germany............................................................................. Greece................................................................................ Hungary.............................................................................. Ireland ................................................................................ Italy ..................................................................................... Japan...................................................................................
129 135 140 145 149 153 159 164 169 173 179 185 189 194 199 205
Korea.................................................................................. Luxembourg ...................................................................... Mexico................................................................................ Netherlands ...................................................................... New Zealand ..................................................................... Norway ............................................................................... Poland ................................................................................ Portugal.............................................................................. Romania............................................................................. Slovak Republic................................................................ Spain .................................................................................. Sweden .............................................................................. Switzerland........................................................................ Turkey ................................................................................ United Kingdom ............................................................... United States ....................................................................
210 214 218 222 226 230 235 239 243 248 253 258 263 269 272 278
STATISTICAL ANNEX INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................................................ A.
283
SOURCES AND COMPARABILITY OF MIGRATION STATISTICS ......................................................................................
283
1. Sources of migration statistics ....................................................................................................................................... 2. Measurement of migration flows ................................................................................................................................... 3. Stocks of migrants and characteristics of the immigrant population........................................................................
283 285 287
STATISTICAL SERIES.............................................................................................................................................................
288
LIST OF SOPEMI CORRESPONDENTS ....................................................................................................................................
371
B.
6
© OECD 2003
Table of Contents
List of Charts, Tables and Boxes Part 1 MAIN TRENDS IN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION Maps I.1 I.2 I.3
Foreign population in the European regions, 2001 ....................................................................................................... Foreign-born population in the Australasian regions, 2001 ......................................................................................... Foreign-born population in North American regions, 2000..........................................................................................
47 48 49
Charts I.1 I.2 I.3 I.4 I.5 I.6 I.7 I.8 I.9 I.10 I.11 I.12 I.13 I.14 I.15 I.16 I.17 I.18
Inflows of foreigners in selected OECD countries, 1980-2000 ...................................................................................... Permanent or long-term immigration flows into selected OECD countries by main categories in 2000................ Change in inflows of migrants by country of origin to selected OECD countries, 1990-1999 and 2000 .................. Stocks of foreign and foreign-born populations in selected OECD countries, 2000 ................................................. Stocks of foreign and foreign-born populations by region of origin in all OECD countries, latest available year......... Foreign and national populations by age group and by sex, latest available year .................................................. School performance of children according to their place of birth and the place of birth of their parents ............ Percentage of foreigners in total population in selected OECD countries and measurement of regional disparity, 2001................................................................................................................................................. Cumulated percentage of the foreign and total population by regions, 2001 ........................................................... Components of total population growth in selected OECD countries and in the European Union, 1960-2000 .... Natural increase and net migration rates in OECD countries, 2000 ............................................................................ Foreign births in 2000 ........................................................................................................................................................ Changes in foreign and total employment during economic recoveries in selected OECD countries .................. Atypical employment by nationality in selected European OECD countries, 2001.................................................. Proportion of foreigners in total unemployment related to their proportion in the labour force..................................... Unemployment rate of youth unemployment according to nationality in selected OECD countries, 2001................. Percentage of long-term unemployment according to nationality.............................................................................. Naturalisation rate in selected OECD countries, 1990-2000.........................................................................................
18 22 31 39 41 43 46 50 50 53 55 56 62 64 68 69 70 94
Tables I.1 I.2 I.3 I.4 I.5 I.6 I.7 I.8 I.9 I.10 I.11 I.12 I.13 I.14 I.15 I.16 I.17 I.18 I.19 I.20
Entries of temporary workers in certain OECD countries by principal categories, 1992, 1997-2000....................... Inflows of asylum seekers in OECD countries in 2001................................................................................................... Stock of foreign students in selected OECD countries, 2000 ....................................................................................... Transferees within companies in selected OECD countries, 1995-2000 ..................................................................... Cross-border workers in selected OECD countries, 1985, 1990, 1995 to 2000 ........................................................... Share of immigrants whose official language in their country of origin is the same as in the country of residence, 2000 .............................................................................................................................................................. Relative importance of the top 5 countries in the total immigration flows and stocks of foreigners in selected OECD countries ............................................................................................................................................. Intra-European mobility of EU citizens, latest available year...................................................................................... Stock of nationals from Nordic countries in other Nordic countries, 2000 ................................................................. Foreign or foreign-born population in selected OECD countries, 1995 and 2000..................................................... Foreign and national adult populations classified by level of education in selected OECD countries................. Change in total population in OECD countries, 1950, 2000 and 2050 ......................................................................... Foreign or foreign-born labour force in selected OECD countries, 1995 and 2000 ................................................... Participation rate and unemployment rate of nationals and foreigners by sex in selected OECD countries, 2000-2001 average.............................................................................................................................................................. Employment of foreigners by sectors, 2000-2001 average ........................................................................................... Self employed by nationality, 2001 ................................................................................................................................. Employment in education, IT and health professions according to citizenship in selected OECD countries, 2001..... Theoretical calculation of the number of jobs to be created to absorb the discrepancy between national and foreign unemployment rates in selected OECD countries, 2001 ......................................................................... Real GDP growth in selected Asian countries and in Australia, 1996-2001 ................................................................ Unemployment rates in selected Asian countries and in Australia, 1996-2001.........................................................
© OECD 2003
24 27 28 29 29 33 35 37 38 40 45 57 59 60 63 65 66 68 72 72
7
Trends in International Migration
I.21 I.22 I.23 I.24 I.25 I.26
Total fertility rates in selected Asian countries, 1980, 1990 and 1999......................................................................... Stocks of foreign workers in selected Asian countries, 1996-2001............................................................................... Stocks of students in degree-granting institutions in the United States, 1954/55, 1974/75 and 2000/01................ Top five nationalities of citizens from Central and Eastern Europe residing in selected OECD countries, 2000. Foreigners residing in some Central and Eastern European countries, by major nationality, latest available year..... Main regularisation programmes of immigrants in an irregular situation in selected OECD countries, by nationality......................................................................................................................................................................
73 73 75 80 81 90
Annex: Probability of foreigners aged 15 to 64 to be out of the labour force according to duration of residence and selected individual characteristics........................................................................................................................
101
Boxes I.1 I.2 I.3 I.4 I.5 I.6 I.7 I.8 I.9 I.10 I.11
Migration statistics: definitions and comparability....................................................................................................... The GATS negotiations on service provision ................................................................................................................. Origin of new immigrants and language skills (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants)........................................... School performance of children of foreign origin (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants)...................................... Integration in urban areas (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants)............................................................................ Immigrants age too… (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants) ................................................................................... Young foreigners and the labour market (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants) ................................................... Linguistic competence and integration into the labour market (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants) ............. EU enlargement and impact on migration from the CEECs ......................................................................................... Unaccompanied minors: an increasing phenomenon and matter of concern (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants) ........................................................................................................................................................................ Seminar on the Integration of Young Immigrants in the Labour Market (Brussels, 6-7 June 2002), (Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants) ............................................................................................................................................
19 30 33 46 51 57 69 71 85 87 93
Part II LABOUR SHORTAGES AND THE NEED FOR IMMIGRANTS: A REVIEW OF RECENT STUDIES Charts II.1
Projections of the working age population (15-64) in selected OECD countries.......................................................
108
Tables Annex II.1 II.2
Employer surveys of labour shortages............................................................................................................................ Projections of occupational labour demand in OECD countries .................................................................................
124 126
Gains and losses in high skilled labour through migration..........................................................................................
109
Boxes II.1
Part III RECENT CHANGES IN MIGRATION MOVEMENTS AND POLICIES Tables III.1 III.2 III.3 III.4
8
III.5 III.6 III.7 III.8 III.9
Permanent and temporary migration programme outcomes, 1998-2001 and planning levels for permanent settlers for 2002, by category, Australia .......................................................................................................................... Current figures on the components of total population change, on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force in Austria ............................................................................................................................................... Components of population changes since 1990, Baltic States..................................................................................... Current figures on the components of total population change, on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force in Belgium ............................................................................................................................................. Current figures on the foreign flows and stocks in Bulgaria ......................................................................................... Immigrants by category, 1998-2001, Canada .................................................................................................................. Current figures on flows and stocks of migrants, Czech Republic ............................................................................... Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, Denmark ........................................... Current figures on flows and stocks of total population, Finland................................................................................
130 136 140 146 150 154 160 165 170
© OECD 2003
Table of Contents
III.10 Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, France................................................ III.11 Current figures on the components of total population change, on migration flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, Germany........................................................................................................................... III.12 Total labour force and immigrants who were granted a green card following the 1998 regularisation programme in Greece, by region of residence ................................................................................................................................................. III.13 Current figures on migration flows and stocks of foreign population, Hungary......................................................... III.14 Current figures on migration flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, Ireland ............................. III.15 Current figures on foreign population, Italy ................................................................................................................... III.16 Inflows of foreigners by status of residence, 1997-2000, Japan .................................................................................... III.17 Current figures on migration flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, Japan ................................ III.18 Foreign workers in Korea by category, 1997-2000 ......................................................................................................... III.19 Current figures on the components of total population change, on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, Luxembourg ......................................................................................................................................... III.20 Mexican emigration to the United States, 1911-2000 .................................................................................................... III.21 Foreign-born population living in Mexico in 2000, by region of origin ....................................................................... III.22 Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign, foreign-born or allochtonous population and labour force in the Netherlands............................................................................................................................................................. III.23 Persons accepted for residence, by main category of admission and by country of birth, 2000-2001, New Zealand....................................................................................................................................................................... III.24 Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign population, Norway ............................................................................ III.25 Current figures on migration flows and stocks of foreigners in Poland....................................................................... III.26 Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force in Portugal.......................................... III.27 Current migration figures in Romania.............................................................................................................................. III.28 Current migration figures, Slovak Republic.................................................................................................................... III.29 Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force in Spain .............................................. III.30 Current figures on flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force in Sweden .......................................... III.31 Current figures on the components of total population change, on migration flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, Switzerland ..................................................................................................................... III.32 Immigration to Turkey, 1998-2001.................................................................................................................................... III.33 Current figures on migratory flows and stocks of foreign population and labour force, United Kingdom............. III.34 Employment-based immigration, by preference, fiscal years 1997-2000, United States.........................................
174 180 186 190 195 201 206 207 211 215 218 220 223 227 231 236 240 245 249 254 259 264 270 273 281
Statistical Annex 1. Summary table on the sources of migration statistics .......................................................................................................
285
Boxes III.1 III.2 III.3 III.4 III.5 III.6 III.7 III.8
Longitudinal Survey of Immigrants to Australia............................................................................................................. An overview of the structure and approach of Canada’s immigration programme ................................................... Main determinants of labour market outcomes for immigrants and their descendants in Denmark..................... New definition for allochtonous in the Netherlands..................................................................................................... Illegal trafficking of women to Western Europe ............................................................................................................. On the situation of Roma minority in the Slovak Republic (from Joint Assessment of Employment Priorities in the Slovak Republic) ..................................................................................................................................................... The 2000 and 2001 regularisations in Spain ................................................................................................................... The new quota system in Spain .......................................................................................................................................
132 158 168 224 247 251 255 256
Statistical Annex 1. Definitions of migration flows and immigrant populations developed by the United Nations................................... 2. Migration systems ...................................................................................................................................................................
284 288
9
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
TABLES OF THE STATISTICAL ANNEX A. A.1. A.1.1. A.1.2. A.1.3. A.1.4. A.1.5. A.1.6. A.2.
Cross national tables
Foreign and/or foreign-born population: stocks and flows Inflows of foreign population into selected OECD countries....................................................................................... Outflows of foreign population from selected OECD countries .................................................................................. Inflows of asylum seekers into selected OECD countries ............................................................................................ Stocks of foreign-born population in selected OECD countries.................................................................................. Stocks of foreign population in selected OECD countries ........................................................................................... Acquisition of nationality in selected OECD countries.................................................................................................
292 293 293 294 295 296
Foreign or foreign-born labour force: stocks and flows
A.2.1. Inflows of foreign workers into selected OECD countries ............................................................................................ A.2.2. Inflows of seasonal workers in selected OECD countries............................................................................................. A.2.3. Stocks of foreign and foreign-born labour force in selected OECD countries ...........................................................
297 297 298
B. Tables by country of origin B.1.
Foreign and/or foreign-born population: stocks and flows
B.1.1. Inflows of foreign population by nationality B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1.
AUSTRALIA ....................................................... AUSTRIA ........................................................... BELGIUM........................................................... CANADA ............................................................ CZECH REPUBLIC ............................................ DENMARK......................................................... FINLAND ........................................................... FRANCE............................................................. GERMANY ......................................................... GREECE............................................................. HUNGARY ......................................................... IRELAND ...........................................................
299 300 300 301 301 302 302 303 303 304 304 305
B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1. B.1.1.
ITALY ................................................................. JAPAN ................................................................ LUXEMBOURG .................................................. NETHERLANDS ................................................ NEW ZEALAND ................................................. NORWAY ............................................................ PORTUGAL ........................................................ SWEDEN ............................................................ SWITZERLAND .................................................. UNITED KINGDOM .......................................... UNITED STATES ...............................................
305 305 306 306 307 307 308 308 309 309 310
311 311 312 312 313 313 314
B.1.2. JAPAN ............................................................... B.1.2. LUXEMBOURG ................................................. B.1.2. NETHERLANDS .............................................. B.1.2. NEW ZEALAND ................................................ B.1.2. NORWAY ......................................................... B.1.2. SWEDEN ......................................................... B.1.2. SWITZERLAND .................................................
314 315 315 315 316 316 317
318 318 319 319 320
B.1.3. B.1.3. B.1.3. B.1.3. B.1.3.
NETHERLANDS ............................................... SWEDEN ........................................................... SWITZERLAND ................................................. UNITED KINGDOM ......................................... UNITED STATES ..............................................
320 321 321 322 322
323 323 324 324 325 325
B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4.
NETHERLANDS ............................................... NEW ZEALAND ............................................... NORWAY ........................................................... SWEDEN ......................................................... UNITED STATES ...............................................
326 326 327 327 328
B.1.2. Outflows of foreign population by nationality B.1.2. B.1.2. B.1.2. B.1.2. B.1.2. B.1.2. B.1.2.
AUSTRALIA ....................................................... AUSTRIA ............................................................ BELGIUM........................................................... DENMARK......................................................... FINLAND ........................................................... GERMANY ......................................................... HUNGARY ........................................................
B.1.3. Inflows of asylum seekers by nationality B.1.3. B.1.3. B.1.3. B.1.3. B.1.3.
AUSTRIA ........................................................... BELGIUM .......................................................... CANADA ........................................................... FRANCE ............................................................ GERMANY ........................................................
B.1.4. Stock of foreign-born population by country of birth
10
B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4. B.1.4.
AUSTRALIA ...................................................... AUSTRIA ........................................................... CANADA ............................................................ DENMARK ........................................................ FINLAND .......................................................... HUNGARY ........................................................
© OECD 2003
Table of Contents
B.1.5. Stock of foreign population by nationality B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5.
AUSTRIA ........................................................... BELGIUM ........................................................ CZECH REPUBLIC ........................................... DENMARK ........................................................ FINLAND ........................................................ FRANCE ............................................................ GERMANY ...................................................... HUNGARY ........................................................ IRELAND .......................................................... ITALY .................................................................
B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5. B.1.5.
JAPAN ............................................................... KOREA .............................................................. LUXEMBOURG ................................................ NETHERLANDS ............................................. NORWAY ........................................................ PORTUGAL ....................................................... SPAIN ................................................................ SWEDEN .......................................................... SWITZERLAND ................................................ UNITED KINGDOM .........................................
333 334 334 335 335 336 336 337 337 338
339 339 339 340 340 340 341 341 341 342
B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6.
JAPAN ............................................................... LUXEMBOURG ................................................ NETHERLANDS................................................ NORWAY .......................................................... PORTUGAL ....................................................... SPAIN ................................................................ SWEDEN .......................................................... SWITZERLAND ................................................ UNITED KINGDOM ......................................... UNITED STATES ..............................................
342 342 343 343 344 344 345 345 345 346
347 347
B.2.1. UNITED STATES ..............................................
348
349 349 350 350 351 351 352 352 352 353
B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2.
353 354 354 354 355 355 356 356 357
329 329 330 330 331 331 332 332 333 333
B.1.6. Acquisition of nationality by country of former nationality B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6. B.1.6.
AUSTRALIA ....................................................... AUSTRIA ............................................................ BELGIUM .......................................................... CANADA .......................................................... DENMARK ........................................................ FINLAND .......................................................... FRANCE ........................................................ GERMANY ......................................................... HUNGARY ........................................................ ITALY ................................................................
B.2.
Stocks of foreign or foreign-born labour force
B.2.1. Immigrant labour force by place of birth B.2.1. AUSTRALIA ....................................................... B.2.1. CANADA ........................................................... B.2.2. Stock of foreign labour by nationality B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2. B.2.2.
AUSTRIA ........................................................... BELGIUM........................................................... CZECH REPUBLIC ............................................ DENMARK......................................................... FINLAND .......................................................... FRANCE ............................................................. GERMANY ......................................................... HUNGARY ......................................................... ITALY.................................................................. JAPAN.................................................................
KOREA............................................................... LUXEMBOURG ................................................. NETHERLANDS................................................ NORWAY ........................................................... PORTUGAL ....................................................... SPAIN ................................................................ SWEDEN ........................................................... SWITZERLAND ................................................. UNITED KINGDOM .........................................
Notes related to Tables Migration flows in selected OECD countries ............................................................................................................................. Inflows of asylum seekers............................................................................................................................................................. Foreign-born population .............................................................................................................................................................. Foreign population ....................................................................................................................................................................... Acquisition of nationality ............................................................................................................................................................. Inflows of foreign workers............................................................................................................................................................. Inflows of seasonal workers.......................................................................................................................................................... Foreign and foreign-born labour .................................................................................................................................................
358 360 361 362 364 365 367 368
11
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
Overview of migration trends and foreign population in OECD countries Migration flows
Stock of foreign and foreign-born population
Annual average 1990-94 1995-99
Inflows of foreigners (Thousands) United States Permanent immigration Temporary immigration1 European economic area (EEA)2 Japan Australia Permanent immigration Temporary immigration Canada Permanent immigration Temporary workers4
Thousands 2000
1 209 1 357 1 614 244
747 1 893 1 352 251
850 2 741 1 4263 346
99 104
87 154
92 224
236 64
204 69
227 86
2000
Asylum seekers (Thousands) European economic area United States Canada Central and Eastern Europe Australia
1990
2000
Stock of foreign population EEA7 Japan
20 381 1 686
4.6 0.9
5.4 1.3
Stock of foreign-born population United States Canada (1991 and 1996) Australia
28 400 4 971 4 517
7.9 16.1 22.8
10.4 17.4 23.6
Acquisition of nationality Thousands (Annual average)
Net migration (for 1 000 inhabitants) Australia Canada5 United States European economic area (EEA)6 Japan
% of total population
4.3 .. 3.3 3.1 –0.03
5.1 5.4 3.3 1.7 –0.04
5.4 5.1 3.1 2.5 0.3
516 136 30 3 9
326 105 26 13 9
427 57 36 26 12
1990-94
1995-99
2000 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0
900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 United States EEA8
Canada
Australia
Japan
1. Excluding visitors, transit migrants, foreign government officials and students. Accompanying dependents are including. 2. Austria, Greece, Italy and Spain are not included. 3. 1999 for Denmark. 4. Inflows of foreign workers entering Canada to work temporarily (excluding seasonal workers) provided by initial entry. 5. Fiscal years (July to June of the given year) (Statistics Canada). 6. Data relate to 1999-2000 average instead of 2000. 7. Excluding Greece. 1999 for France instead of 2000. 8. Excluding Greece and Ireland. Sources: Refer to the notes at the end of the Statistical Annex; Statistics Canada; Labour Force Statistics, OECD, 2002.
12
© OECD 2003
GENERAL INTRODUCTION The 1990s and the beginning of the new millennium confirmed the increasing role of migration in the context of economic globalisation. An overview of migration trends during this period shows that, while the United States, Canada and Australia remained the major settlement countries, Europe also faced significant migration flows. Within the OECD zone, Europe in fact experienced the most pronounced increase in immigration at the beginning of the 1990s and welcomed the largest numbers of asylum seekers. The increase in recent years of asylum applications in certain Central and Eastern European countries, and to a lesser extent in southern Europe, will undoubtedly contribute to reinforcing this trend in the future.
Economic globalisation has been accompanied by the growing importance of migration flows and the number of asylum seekers
Compared to the situation at the beginning of the 1990s, the proportion of foreigners or immigrants in the total population in 2000, as well as in the active population, increased in most OECD countries, especially in the United States and Australia and, to a lesser extent, in Canada, Japan and Korea. This trend was also strong in the European Economic Area, where the increase in foreign residents has more than compensated for the fall in the foreign population, due to naturalisations, estimated at a yearly average of 550 000 people.
Migration plays a growing role in contributing to the population growth of host countries…
Geopolitical changes of the past decade, in particular the liberalisation of movements of persons from Central and Eastern Europe, have enlarged the geographical frame of reference for international migration. Moreover, an increasing number of immigrants from Asia, subSaharan Africa and Central and Latin America, have fuelled the flows heading to several OECD Member countries. For example, one can observe the growth of migration flows originating from China, the Philippines, Romania and, more recently, from the Ukraine, Brazil, Ecuador, Argentina, Senegal, Cape Verde and South Africa. Despite the persistence of traditional flows, the emergence of new flows has modified the distribution by nationality of the foreign population in several host countries. The dispersal of same-origin migrants across host countries has also tended to increase. This was the case, for example, for nationals from the former Yugoslavia who are long-term residents in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, and more recently, in Italy and the Scandinavian countries. Moroccan citizens first arrived in France, then went to Belgium and the Netherlands and, more recently, have emigrated to Italy and Spain. Chinese nationals were present in a greater number of OECD Member countries.
… which registered important changes in the countries of origin of their migrants
13
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
14
In 2000 and 2001, the growth of employment-related migration and family reunification flows has continued. Illegal immigration has also persisted
In 2000 and, on the basis of the data available, in 2001, the growth of inflows continued in many OECD countries, most particularly in the United States, Canada, Australia, Japan and southern Europe. Employmentrelated migration (and especially that of skilled temporary workers) continued to increase. This was also true for asylum flows and inflows related to family reunification. The persistence of illegal immigration underscores the difficulties faced by host and sending countries in controlling migration flows. In 2002, most OECD countries were not able to avoid an economic slowdown, resulting from the downturn in the advanced technology sectors and the consequences of the September 11 terrorist attacks in the United States. It is nonetheless difficult to measure the impact of these events on international mobility and to predict whether there will be an eventual reversal of migration flows.
The management of migration flows and cooperation with sending countries remain a high priority in migration policy…
Every type of migration policy has been implemented during the past two years. OECD countries have adopted a more restrictive attitude towards the entry and residence of foreigners and some countries have tightened requirements for family reunification procedures (e.g., Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands). These policies were enacted in parallel with those giving more importance to selection procedures for new immigrants, especially to those for skilled workers (e.g., in the settlement countries as well as in the United Kingdom, France and Norway). Measures to accelerate the processing of asylum applications and to discourage clearly unfounded applications have gained in importance. The fight against illegal immigration and the illegal employment of foreigners has been reinforced on two fronts: firstly, with tighter border controls, workplace inspections and identity checks within countries. Secondly, measures involving international co-operation with sending countries were undertaken to provide for their readmission of illegal immigrants. In some cases, these were strengthened with new bilateral labour agreements. At the same time in some Member countries, regularisation programmes have included not only undocumented migrant workers (e.g., Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain), but also their family members (e.g., the United States) and rejected asylum seekers who are long-term residents and/or difficult to deport (e.g., Switzerland, Luxembourg). The integration of immigrants and foreigners remains a major issue for most OECD Member countries.
… alongside the integration of immigrants in the society and labour market of the host country.
This year’s report pays particular attention to this question of socioeconomic integration, especially throughout the first section with a series of specific boxes. These boxes shed light on the linguistic competencies of newly arrived immigrants and the determining role of their command of the host country’s language on their labour market integration. Other boxes address the school performance of foreign children and children of foreign background; the employment situation of young migrants and the need to improve their professional skills; and urban revitalisation of declining neighbourhoods, where many migrants are concentrated. The section also examines the fight against racism and discrimination in housing and hiring practices (which mostly penalise young migrants) as well as the situation of aging migrants and the institutional and economic difficulties some of them face upon retirement. Finally, in several OECD Member countries, the increase in inflows of non-accompanied minors raises additional questions regarding the management of migration flows. These cases constitute serious humanitarian emergencies and
© OECD 2003
General Introduction
require the countries affected to create special reception centres and allocate additional resources to care for these children temporarily, while deciding either to accept them into the community or help them return to their home country. *** The second section of this report presents a survey of recent studies on labour shortages and the role of migration in attenuating this situation. Economic growth in the late 1990s, coupled with increasing concerns about aging populations, led many Member countries to envision using migration to ease labour shortages. While untapped resident labour reserves exist, they vary in size from country to country. Moreover, it is not clear whether these reserves can meet the immediate needs of the labour markets concerned and evidence shows that they cannot be mobilised rapidly.
The special chapter of this year’s report is devoted to labour shortages and the resort to immigration
This survey highlights the diversity of methods used by some OECD Member countries to evaluate current and future labour shortages. Even though workers with skills and qualifications linked to new technologies are scarce, especially in information and communication technologies, other shortages exist. Demographic changes, which have led to aging populations and the increase in related health care needs in most OECD countries, have affected the demand for social and medical personnel. Shortages have also been identified among teachers and professionals in the biomedical and food industries. Labour market tightness also exists for low-skilled jobs in agriculture, manufacturing, construction, catering, tourism and domestic services.
Available studies confirm the existence of labour market tightness, especially for skilled employment…
Faced with labour shortages that may reflect more structural issues, some countries are not necessarily considering an increase in foreign labour recruitment. Other countries, though, are emphasising solutions to labour shortages using larger scale selective labour immigration policies (even if only on a temporary basis) with the goal of obtaining more significant long-term benefits from migration.
… but not all OECD countries are necessarily considering an increase in labour-related migration
The report also shows that immigration alone will not resolve labour market failures, given the fact that selective labour migration policies present limited solutions. Recommendations include: encouraging and pursuing current efforts to make use of underutilised resident labour supplies; examining more effectively sectoral and regional labour market needs; and continuing to study the long-term consequences of an increase in labour-related migration.
It is important to prepare and train current and future generations since immigration solutions have their limits
*** The third part of this report includes country notes on the recent developments in migration flows and policies.
15
© OECD 2003
Part 1
MAIN TRENDS IN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION The part concerning the main trends in international migration is presented in four sections. The first (I.A) looks at changes in migration movements and in the foreign population of the OECD member countries. The second Section (I.B) focuses on the position of immigrants in the labour market. The third (I.C) sheds particular light on two regions – Asia and Centr al an d Eastern Euro pe . T his is followed by an overview of migration policies (I.D), which reviews policies to regulate and control flows, along with the full range of measures to enhance the integration of immigrants and developments in cooperation at international level in the area of migration. In addition, the issue of the integration of immigrants into host-country societies is highlighted in theme boxes to be found in Part I. A.
MIGRATION AND POPULATION TRENDS
Over the past two decades, trends in migratory flows and in the levels of foreign and foreign-born po pulations in OECD member countries have reversed course on several occasions. These reversals have resulted from major regional geopolitical upheavals in Central and Eastern Europe, but in Asia and Africa as well. They are also tied in with the important changes – both legislative (amendments to the conditions of entry and residence of foreigners, naturalisation, and so on) and economic – that have taken place in a number of host countries. These changes have resulted in broad contrasts in the dynamics of migratory flows, the main sending countries and the profiles of immigrants. 1.
Trends in migration movements and changes in the foreign population
During the 1980s and early 90s, immigration flows intensified, spurred both by the opening up of Eastern Europe and the rapid economic development of a number of Asian countries. The trend was © OECD 2003
reversed in 1992-93, in part because of efforts by the main receiving countries to tighten controls over migratory flows. From that time on, and until at least 1997, entries of foreign nationals dropped significantly despite the persistence of family migration and arrivals of asylum seekers, due in part to the closing of other channels of immigration and a new flare-up of regional conflicts. The resumption of immigration in the OECD countries, which has been perceptible since the late 1990s, was confirmed and tended to gather pace in 2000 and 2001. It results primarily from greater migration by foreign workers, both temporary and permanent. Conditions for recruiting skilled foreign labour have been eased in most of the OECD member countries in order to meet labour market needs, especially in the new technologies and health care sectors. In 2002, under the combined effects of the technology bust and the 11 September terrorist attacks in the United States, OECD-area countries were unable to escape recession. That recession, even if it may be only short-lived and of moderate intensity, has nonetheless helped to ease the tightness of labour markets and to limit business recruitment requirements, including the need for skilled workers. Even so, it is difficult to gauge the impact of tho se even ts on the international mobility of persons, or to predict whether they will reverse the trend in immigration flows. a)
Migratory trends very clearly on the rise
In 2000 and the first half of 2001, the increased inflows that had been observed since 1996-97 continued in a great many OECD countries (see Chart I.1). This phenomenon, more pronounced in the non-European OECD countries, still remained moderate within the European Union as a whole, since EU immigration rose by only 3.2% between
17
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.1. Inflows of foreigners in selected OECD countries, 1980-2000 Thousands, per 1 000 inhabitants and per 100 foreigners Inflows of foreigners,1 1980-2000
Inflows of foreigners in 2000 Thousands, per 1 000 inhabitants and per 100 foreigners
Thousands UE2
USA and CAN3
USA3
DEU
GBR
2 000
849.8 648.8
Thousands
450 400
1 600
350 300
1 200
250 200
800
150 100
400
50 0 1985
1990
JPN
CAN
1995 FRA
2000
AUS
US A DE U GB R JP N IT A5 CA N FR A AU S NL D CH E BE L AU T NZ L SW E NO R IR L DN K PR T HU N LU X FI N CZ E
0 1980
Per 1 000 inhabitants
24.5
400
16
350
14
300
12
250
10
200
8
150
6
100
4
50
2
0 1985
1990 Nordic countries4
NLD
1995 CHE
2000
LU X CH E NZ L AU T DE U CA N BE L IR L GB R NO R NL D AU S IT A5 SW E DN K US A JP N FR A FI N PR T HU N CZ E
0 1980
BEL
Per 100 foreigners6
140
22 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
120 100 80 60 40 20 1985 NZL
1990
IRL
PRT
1995 HUN
2000 LUX
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 1980
18
AUS AUT BEL CAN CHE
1985 Australia Austria Belgium Canada Switzerland
1990 CZE DEU DNK FIN FRA
1995
Czech Republic Germany Denmark Finland France
NZ L CA N US A AU S
1980
JP N IT A5 IR L GB R NO R NL D HU N FI N DE U AU T BE L DN K PR SWT E LU X CH E FR A CZ E
0
Note: Data for the United Kingdom are from the International Passenger Survey; for New Zealand, data are based on arrival cards. For Australia, Canada and the United States, data relate to new permanent immigrants; for France and South European countries, data are issued from residence permits. For all other countries, data are based on Population Registers. 1. The host countries have been split into 4 groups according to the volume of inflows in 2000. No series are available for Austria, Czech Republic and Italy. 2. Belgium, Denmark, Germany, France, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Sweden, and the United Kingdom. 3. Excluding immigrants legalised in the United States under IRCA regularisation programme. 4. Excluding Iceland. 5. Including foreigners who benefited from the 1998 regularisation programme. 6. For Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States, inflows in 2000 are related to the stocks of foreign-born residents (1996 Census for Canada). Sources: National Statistical Offices (for more details on sources, refer to the notes at the end of the Statistical Annex).
2000 GBR HUN IRL ITA JPN
United Kingdom Hungary Ireland Italy Japan
LUX NLD NZL NOR PRT
Luxembourg Netherlands New Zealand Norway Portugal
SWE USA
Sweden United States
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
1999 and 2000. It was in the United States, Canada and Japan that growth was particularly strong. The left-hand side of Chart I.1 shows the trend in foreign migrant inflows since 1980. The host countries are divided into four groups, in decreasing order of the volume of their 2000 inflows. The righthand side of the chart shows the volume of inflows in absolute terms, and as a proportion of the total population and the stock of foreigners in each country. In the United States, the change in inflows was s pe ct a cu la r be t w e e n 1 9 9 9 a n d 2 0 0 0 . N e a r l y 850 000 new permanent immigrants were admitted in 2000, up more than 30% from the previous year. Th is dynamic is in clear contrast to what had happened in the three previous years, and the main explanation for it is the fact that major efforts were made to reduce the number of pending applications. For 2001, it is expected that over a million permanent entries will have been recorded, which would constitute an all-time high, excluding the figure s for 1990 and 1991, which in corporated amnesties under the IRCA programme.
Box I.1.
Growth in the inflows of foreigners was just as sharp in Japan, where 346 000 persons settled in 2000, up almost 23% from the previous year and the highest level in decades. The significance of this is heightened by the fact that it came at a time when the Japanese economy was gripped by the recession that began in August 2000, with unemployment at an unprecedented level (5% in 2001). Much of this increased inflow is attributable to returns of descendants of Japanese, mostly from Brazil, and to entries of Chinese and Philippine citizens. In Canada, the rise in permanent immigration, perceptible in 1999, continued and gathered pace in 2000, since 227 000 persons settled in Canada that year, or nearly 20% more than in 1999. The figure for 2001 will be even higher, probably exceeding 250 000 entries. In the early 1990s, similar levels had been reached (256 000 in 1993) and had constituted all-time highs. The Canadian authorities have stated their determination to increase immigration gradually, so that inflows amount to roughly 1% of the total population, which for 2001 was estimated at over 30 million.
Migration statistics: definitions and comparability1
International migration statistics are patchy, of varying degrees of reliability, and subject to problems of comparability. These difficulties stem largely from the diversity of migration systems and legislation on nationality and naturalisation, which reflect the individual history and circumstances of each country. For example, in settlement countries (Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States), immigrants are classified by their place of birth (“foreign-born”), while in the other OECD member countries the criterion of nationality is applied (“foreigners”). Some international organisations, in particular the UN, have recommended adopting a common defi ni ti on of the concept of i nternational mi grant, but impl ementi ng these recommendations is fraught with numerous difficulties. The main sources of information on migration vary across countries, which poses difficulties for the comparability of available data. Some countries (notably northern European ones) keep population registers, while others base their statistics on records of residence and work permits issued to foreign nationals or, in the case of workers, on information provided by social security systems. There are also data from censuses, and from surveys on the various characteristics of the population. In some cases, other sources may be used, such as specific surveys on migrants, border-crossing records, disembarkation cards, studies on staff mobility in multinational enterprises, etc. Despite these difficulties, this report and, more generally, all OECD activities in the field of international migration are aimed precisely at improving the availability, comparability and reliability of data. These activities are based largely on a network of national correspondents in thirty four countries (see the list of correspondents in the Annex) and seek to enhance analysis and understanding of migration issues in the light of the socioeconomic challenges facing OECD member countries. 1. For further details on migration statistics, see the Statistical Annex. 19
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
Certain countries in southern Europe that do not necessarily possess comprehensive and accurate statistics on inflows also noted a significant rise in immigration in the late 1990s. This is the case of Portugal, for example, but also of Spain and Greece, both of which had instituted unprecedented legalisation campaigns, involving in all more than a million and a half people in just a few years (see below, Section I.D on migration policies). In 2000, immigration also increased appreciably in several other OECD member countries, including the Netherlands (+16.6%), the United Kingdom (+13.6%), Finland (+15.2%), Ireland (+11.6%), France (+10.3%) and Australia (+9.7%). In contrast, the trend was more moderate in other European countries characterised by sharply rising immigration in the late 1990s (as in Italy and Belgium). Inflows of foreigners declined in Germany, Austria and a number of Nordic countries (Norway and Sweden in particular). In Germany, in 2000, about 649 000 new immigrants were recorded – down by half from the level reached in 1992 and well below the yearly average for the latter half of the 1990s. Even so, in absolute terms, Germany was still the secondranking host amongst the OECD member countries. The OECD countries can be divided into two groups, according to recent trends in migratory flows. First is a group of countries in which immigration flows peaked significantly in 2000, continuing a more or less buoyant trend. This was the case of Japan, as mentioned above, but also of many European countries for which the rise in flows was more moderate in 2000, such as Belgium, the Netherlands, Portugal, Ireland, Italy and the United Kingdom. For all of these countries, the number of foreigners taken in was the highest in twenty years. Other countries which would appear to have reached a “maximum” in 1998 or 1999 can also be put in with this group, namely Austria, Luxembourg, Norway and France. The latest statistics available for the United States and Canada would suggest that those countries will also have hit record high inflows in 2001.
20
In reality, only a handful of countries for which data are available over a long period truly stand out in that the record immigration flows of the late 1980s or early 90s remain unequalled to this day. Those countries are Germany, Australia and Switzerland, in addition to the Nordic countries, except for Norway. Elsewhere, however, the trend in inflows of foreigners appears to be more stable, and immigration is far from its record levels. In Germany and Sweden,
there has even been a steady decline in entries of foreign citizens. This observation needs to be qualified, however, for certain countries (Australia and Germany) by the fact that temporary labour migration has been trending firmly upward (see Section I.A.1.c below). If inflows of foreigners have been rising in most of the OECD member countries, the same is actually t r u e o f o u t fl o w s ( se e t h e S t a t i s t i c a l An n e x, Table A.1.2). Without calling the previous findings into question, the trends in the net migration of foreigners and the foreign-born appear to be more moderate, at least in countries for which detailed statistics are available. However, net migration of foreigners dropped by nearly 27% in Germany between 1999 and 2000, while increasing, for example, by more than 22% in the Netherlands over the same period (see Section I.A.2.a below for an analysis of total net migration). Recent migration trends have brought little change to the ranking of the main immigration countrie s, th ough some differences have widened slightly (see the right-hand part of Chart I.1). For example, in 2000, the United Kingdom took in some 30 000 persons more than Japan, and 150 000 more than Canada. On the basis of absolute values, however, the United States (849 400) and Germany (648 800) continued to be the two main immigration countries. For France, Australia, the Netherlands and Switzerland, the number of persons taken in ranged from 120 000 to 87 000. Italy confirmed its positio n betwe en Can ada and Japan with 271 000 entries in 2000. If these legal inflows are compared to the total foreign or immigrant population at the beginning of the year, the ranking changes somewhat. Japan then ranks first, ahead of Italy and Ireland, with ratios of between 20.5% and 19%, followed by the United Kingdom, Norway, the Netherlands, Hungary and Finland, for which the ratios range from 16% to 10%. It is particularly hard to predict whether these trends will continue, given that in 2001 economic activity suffered a numbe r of cyclical shocks. However, the partial data available for 2001 seem to confirm the rise reported in 1999 and 2000. In southern Europe, it can be expected, on the basis of demographic trends and labour requirements, that migration pressure will persist in the coming years. In the medium term, settlement by recent waves of migrants may generate further inflows of immigrants to these countries for family reasons, thereby making © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
them more significant immigration countries. At the same time, the other OECD countries, despite the economic turndown, have not rescinded the easing of conditions for the admission of skilled foreign workers, suggesting that the rise in employment-related migration in the late 1990s will not be jeopardised for long. The case of Germany, which plans a radical overhaul of its immigration legislation in response to labour market needs, and that of Canada, which has proclaimed its determination to make active use of immigration to preserve its medium- and long-term economic and demographic dynamics, are just two examples of this. Nevertheless, controlling migration flows remains a priority common to all OECD countries, with special emphasis on curbing illegal immigration and the growing number of asylum seekers. On the whole, migration flows, classified by main categories, have been marked over the last two years by the continuing preponderance of family-linked immigration, greater numbers of asylum seekers and, above all, an increase in employment-related migration. b)
An increasingly contrasting breakdown by category of inflows
Previous editions of Trends in International Migration have highlighted changes in the breakdown of immigration flows by category since the early 1990s. In particular, family-linked immigration (accompanying family members and family reunification) has increased in Australia, the United States, France and Sweden, while immigration for employment has risen in Canada and the United Kingdom and the refugee category has grown in the Nordic countries. Recently, however, the rise in worker migration has been the most salient feature in most of the receiving countries. These trends are not uniform, however, and they reflect the effects of the migration policies, active or not, implemented by the countries in question. Some countries explicitly give priority to foreign workers (Australia, the United Kingdom and Switzerland), while others, such as Canada, seek a more stable distribution amongst categories. A number of other OECD countries, because they apply policies that are more restrictive, give implicit priority to non-selective migration arising from family reunification or requests for asylum (France and the Nordic countries). © OECD 2003
Even if it varied sharply from one country to another, the family component still dominated in several OECD countries in 2000; this was especially so in France, the United States and Canada (see Chart I.2). The share allotted to this category continues to grow in some countries in which other official channels of immigration still remain limited. In France, family-related immigration rose by 22% as compared to 1999, reaching 78% of inflows – the highest level ever reached. As a percentage of total entries, France takes in more family members than any other OECD country. In the Nordic countries, this component of migration is also on the rise. It should also be noted that family members who get permanent resident status are often granted the right to work. In 2000, it was in Sweden and Norway that refugees accounted for the largest share of total immigration flows (at respectively 41% and 38%). This share was also large in Denmark (24%), even if the percentage was down somewhat on 1999. It must be made clear, however, that the data in Chart I.2 refer only to asylum seekers who obtained refugee status during the year in question and do not include asylum seekers wh ose applications we re still pending. Inflows of workers increased in 2000 in all of the countries considered, except for Norway. They rose by only 3% in France, but by 18% in Denmark, 25% in the United Kingdom, 29% in Sweden and 88% in the United States. Labour migration accounted in 2000, in the selected countries, for the highest percentage of total inflows in Australia, Portugal, Switzerland and the United Kingdom, the proportion exceeding 50% in the first three of these countries. The case of Australia is remarkable in that changes in the conditions for entry caused inflows of foreign workers to increase by more than 16% over the previous year, while entries associated with family reunification and refugees declined by 7% and 17% respectively. This trend testifies to the Australian authorities’ determination to encourage migration that is apt to be of short- or medium-term benefit to the economy. Portugal’s case is quite different, illustrating the situation of a country in which the migratory phenomenon is a recent one. T he ma ke- up o f flo ws is de stin ed t o ch an ge , however, as newly settled workers send for their families. Similar patterns can be seen in other southern European countries, such as Italy and Spain.
21
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.2.
Permanent or long-term immigration flows into selected OECD countries by main categories1 in 2000 Percentages of total inflows Family reunification
Workers Refugees
Note: Countries are ranked by decreasing order of the percentage of workers in total inflows. Categories give the legal reason for entering the country. A worker who has benefited from the family reunification procedure is regrouped into this latter category even if he has a job in the host country while entering. Family members who join a refugee are counted among other refugees. 1. For Australia, Canada, the United States, Norway and Sweden, data concern acceptances for settlement. For Denmark, France, Portugal and Switzerland, entries correspond to residence permits usually delivered for a period longer than one year. For the United Kingdom, data are based on entry control at ports of certain categories of migrants (excluding EEA citizens). For Australia, “Workers” include accompanying dependents who are included in the category “family reunification” for all other countries. 2. Data refer to fiscal year (July 1999 to June 2000). Category “Workers” includes accompanying dependents. Excluding citizens from New Zealand who don't need a visa to enter the country. 3. Passengers, excluding EEA citizens, admitted to the United Kingdom. Data only include certain categories of migrants: work permit holders, spouses and refugees. 4. Data refer to fiscal year (October 1999 to September 2000). Excluding immigrants who obtained a permanent residence permit following the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA). 5. Entries of EU family members are estimated. Excluding visitors. Among those who benefited from the regularisation programme, only those who received a permit under the family reunification procedure are counted. The “family” category also includes spouses of French citizens and scientifists and parents of French children and those who have family relationship in France, who received the new permit “vie privée et familiale”. 6. Excluding Nordic and EEA citizens. Sources: National Statistical Offices.
Australia2 Portugal Switzerland United Kingdom3 Canada Denmark United States4 France5 Norway Sweden6 0
c)
20
40
60
80
100
Growth in employment-related migration
One of the most significant trends in recent years has been the rise in permanent, but especi al ly t e mp o r ar y, mi gr a t io n f o r e m pl o y me n t purposes. In 2000, this trend continued and was accentuated despite the economic slowdown in the second half of the year. It is the result of a combination of several factors involving the intensity of the expansion phase that marked the latter half of the 1990s and the dawn of the 21st century, as well as the development of the information technology sector, for which in some countries there is a shortage of skilled and highly skilled workers (see Part II below).
22
In this context, there is heightened competition between OECD member countries to attract the human resources they lack, and to keep those individuals who might be tempted to emigrate. Accordingly, in the late 1990s a large number of countries changed their laws to facilitate the entry o f skil le d fo re ig n w o rk er s. T he se le g isla tiv e changes are set forth in detail in the 2001 edition of the report on Trends in International Migration.
In 2000 and 2001, far from abandoning their easing of restrictions, a number of member countries introduced new regulations further encouraging the mobility of highly skilled workers (see Section I.D below on migration policies). One example is the United Kingdom, which created a new type of visa allowing highly qualified persons, selected on the basis of a point system, to enter the United Kingdom to seek work. A similar programme was also instituted in Norway. The same is also true of Canada, which in June 2002 amended its point-based selection system so that candidates likely to find a stable place in the labour market are identified more clearly. In Germany, the quota of 10 000 computer spe cialists introdu ce d under the Gre en Card programme was extended (20 000 visas are available until 2003). In addition, the German government voted in favour of a thorough reform of the immigration legislation to facilitate the entry of highly skilled workers who have been offered jobs paying more than € 75 000 a year. Under a second entry procedure, skilled workers will go through a point system-based selection process modelled on the Canadian system. Unlike the first procedure, this © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
second channel of entry will be subject to a quota, but it will not require that applicants already be in possession of a job offer. The special measures that the OECD countries have implemented for IT and telecommunications specialists led to the recruitment of 8 700 persons in Germany between August 2000 and August 2001, nearly 2 600 in France in 2000 (4 000 in 2001) and more than 2 700 in Canada under the pilot programme for computer specialists. In the United States, nearly 163 000 H1B visas were granted in 2001, many of which in the information and communication technologies sector, out of a quota of 195 000. Even though the quota was not filled for the first time since 1997, the numbers were still up significantly from 2000, when 115 000 H1B visas had been issued – despite the fact that new exemptions (admissions not subject to the quota) had been introduced, e.g. to recruit staff for research centres and universities. While specialists in the new technologies have been the primary beneficiaries of the recent easing of visa requirements, the measures have applied to other categories of skilled workers as well, and more particularly to doctors, nurses and nurses’ aides. While in most countries it is the employers who find and recruit qualified computer experts, the situation differs in the health care sector. Equivalency issues and knowledge of the host country’s language are crucial to employment in this sector, which is fully or partially controlled by government. The OECD member countries have adopted different recruiting strategies, most of them trying to attract nurses and doctors from countries awarding professional credentials that are recognised, and where the official language is the same as the host country’s. For its part, Norway has endeavoured to recruit health care professionals from other European countries, but candidates must learn Norwegian before they can be accepted in the country. The United Kingdom and France recently signed bilateral agreements with Spain, which trains a greater number of nurses, to facilitate the mobility of Spanish nurses. The language issue, and the working conditions on offer, have so far limited the scope of these initiatives. The Netherlands has looked to its former colonies as a special source of qualified health care professionals, although there is concern in some circles over the brain drain effects on small countries like Surinam. In contrast to the computer sector, where this phenomenon is not considered © OECD 2003
important, international recruitment of doctors and n u r se s ha s be e n cr it ici se d. S ou t h A fri ca h a s opposed the active recruitment of its health care workers by a number of countries, and the United Kingdom’s National Health Service has pledged officially not to recruit medical staff in countries likely to suffer shortages of such personnel. The reasons for labour shortages in the IT and health care sectors differ significantly: in IT, they result from the sector’s dynamic growth, whereas in the realm of health care they are often a reflection of poor working conditions and supply and demand policies that have been administered at a governmental level for twenty years. In many countries, the problem is not so much a shortage of nurses as a shortage of nurses willing to work under the conditions being offered them. The rise in labour migration does not concern skilled workers alone, and some OECD member countries make extensive use of unskilled foreign labour, chiefly in agriculture, building and civil engineering, and domestic services. This is especially true in Italy, Spain, Portugal, Greece and the United States. In some countries, a substantial proportion of these foreign workers are undocumented. Vi sas f or se aso n a l wo r ke rs a re a lso ve ry common, and on the increase in several member countries, including Germany (263 800 seasonal workers hired in 2000), Switzerland (49 300) and the United States (33 300, see Table I.1). The increase was especially significant in Germany and Switzerland, where the numbers were up by respectively 14.5% and 9% on 1999. Other European countries are also developing programmes to recruit seasonal foreign workers, namely Italy (24 500 persons in 2000), Spain (21 200 permits available in 2001), Sweden (19 400 persons in 2000), the United Kingdom (10 100 persons in 2000), Norway (9 900 persons in 2000) and France (7 900 persons in 2000). Over the long run, however, France and Switzerland stand out insofar as the number of seasonal visas granted in both countries declined throughout the 1990s. For the most part, these workers are employed in agricultural jobs. Some countries, including Korea and Japan, issue a large number of temporary work visas to trainees, generally employed in industry. In both these co untries, this entry category h as risen sharply, to respectively 104 800 and 54 000 persons in 2000. For their part, Australia, New Zealand and the United Kingdom issue “Working Holiday Maker”
23
Entries of temporary workers in certain OECD countries by principal categories, 1992, 1997-2000 Thousands 1992
Australia Skilled temporary resident programme (Offshore and onshore)1 Working Holiday Makers (Offshore) Total Canada2 Total France Employees on secondment Researchers Other holders of an APT3 Seasonal workers Total Germany Workers employed under a contract for services Seasonal workers Trainees Total Italy Seasonal workers Japan Highly skilled workers Trainees Total Note:
1997
1998
1999
2000
14.6 25.9 40.5 (40.3)
31.7 50.0 81.7 (19.7)
37.3 55.6 92.9 (26.0)
37.0 62.6 99.7 (28.0)
39.2 76.5 115.7 (32.3)
70.4 (254.8)
75.4 (216.0)
79.5 (174.2)
85.4 (189.9)
93.7 (227.2)
0.9 0.9 2.8 13.6 18.1 (42.3)
1.0 1.1 2.6 8.2 12.9 (11.0)
1.2 1.0 2.2 7.5 11.8 (10.3)
1.8 1.0 3.1 7.6 13.4 (12.2)
2.2 1.6 3.8 7.9 15.4 (11.3)
115.1 212.4 5.1 332.6 (408.9)
38.5 226.0 3.2 267.7 (285.4)
33.0 207.9 3.1 244.0 (275.5)
40.0 230.3 3.7 274.1 ..
64.8 263.8 3.0 331.6 ..
..
..
..
18.7
24.52
108.1 .. ..
93.9 49.6 143.5
101.9 49.8 151.7
108.0 48.0 156.0
129.9 54.0 183.9
1992
Korea Highly skilled workers Trainees4 Total Sweden Grants of temporary permits (mainly seasonal workers) Switzerland Seasonal workers Trainees Total United Kingdom Long-term permit holders (one year and over)5 Short term permit holders5 Working Holiday Makers Trainees6 Seasonal agricultural workers7 Total United States8 Highly skilled workers Specialists (visa H-1B) Specialists (NAFTA, visa TN)9 Workers of distinguished abilities (visa O) Seasonal workers (visa H-2A) Industrial trainees (visa H-3) Total
1997
1998
1999
2000
3.4 4.9 8.3
14.7 90.4 105.0
11.1 64.2 75.4
12.6 98.4 111.0
17.7 104.8 122.5
.. (0.2)
.. (0.4)
.. (0.4)
15.0 (0.3)
19.4 (0.4)
126.1 1.6 127.8 (39.7)
46.7 0.7 47.4 (25.4)
39.6 0.7 40.3 (26.8)
45.3 0.8 46.1 (31.5)
49.3 1.1 50.3 (34.0)
12.7 14.0 24.0 3.4 3.6 57.6
21.7 20.7 33.3 4.7 9.3 89.7
24.8 23.8 40.8 .. 9.4 98.8
30.5 21.9 45.8 .. 9.8 107.9
55.2 30.4 38.4 .. 10.1 134.1
110.2 12.5 0.5 16.4 3.4 143.0 (116.2)
.. .. .. .. .. .. (90.6)
240.9 59.1 12.2 27.3 3.2 342.7 (77.5)
302.3 68.4 15.9 32.4 3.5 422.5 (56.8)
355.6 91.3 21.7 33.3 3.2 505.1 (107.0)
© OECD 2003
The categories of temporary workers differ from one country to another. Only the principal categories of temporay worker are presented in this table. The figures in brackets indicate the number of entries of permanent workers. |: Break in series. 1. The data cover the fiscal year (from July to June of the indicated year) and include accompanying persons. From 1996/1997 on, the data are on and offshore and include Long Stay Temporary Business Programme. 2. Total of persons issued employment authorisations to work in Canada temporarily excluding persons issued employment authorisations on humanitarian grounds. Persons are shown in the year in which they received their first temporary permit. Figures have been revised from 1996 on. 3. Beneficiaries of provisional work permits (APT). 4. Refer to the note for Korea (Part III of this report) to explain the huge increase in figures. 5. Both long-term and short-term permits are now dedicated to highly skilled workers or those where skills are in short supply. Most of short-term permit holders are entertainers and sports people. 6. The new data-recording system does not allow to identify the trainees separately any longer. 7. Students in full time education aged between 18 and 25. 8. The data cover the fiscal year (October to September of the indicated year). A person is counted as many times as he/she enters the country over the course of the same year. The data may well therefore be overestimated. 9. The figures include family members. Sources: Australia: Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (DIEA); Canada: Citizenship and Immigration Canada; France: Office des migrations internationales, Annuaire des migrations; Germany: Bundesanstalt für Arbeit; Italy: Ministry of Labour; Japan: Ministry of Justice; Korea: Ministry of Justice; Sweden: Ministry of Labour; Switzerland: Office fédéral des étrangers; United Kingdom: Department of Employment; United States: United States Department of Justice, Statistical Yearbooks of Immigration and Naturalization Service.
Trends in International Migration
24
Table I.1.
Main Trends in International Migration
permits which enable foreign students from certain countries to come work in those countries for a number of months. In 2000, some 76 500 young people entered Australia under the programme, up 22% from the previous year and triple the number of entries in 1992. The United Kingdom admitted 38 400 working holiday makers and New Zealand 13 000. All categories of temporary labour migration in f a c t i n c r e a se d b e t w e e n 1 9 9 9 a n d 2 0 0 0 ( s e e Table I.1). For all categories combined, the rise was 24% in the United Kingdom, 21% in Germany, about 18% in Japan and 10% in Korea. In all, it was the United States that recorded the most entries of temporary workers (505 100 in 2000), but the statistics include multiple entries. In reality, it was probably Germany that issued the most temporary work permits in 2000 (331 600 permits), and in Australia that temporary labour migration was greatest in relation to employment-related migration. d)
Continued intensification of asylum-seeker flows
In OECD countries, refugees and asylum seekers do not arrive in quite the same way. Refugees generally arrive within the framework of government programmes negotiated either with specialised international organisations or with countries that are sheltering the refugees. Asylum seekers, on the other hand, most often apply for refugee status (which they do not necessarily obtain) upon arrival at the border, or after they are already inside the potential host country. In addition, OECD countries authorise certain persons, for humanitarian reasons, to remain either temporarily or on a more permanent basis. From the mid-1980s until the early 90s (see Statistical Annex, Table A.1.3), applications for asylum rose appreciably, sometimes spectacularly (as in Austria, Canada, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, the United Kingdom and the United States). Faced with an increasing number of asylum seekers, OECD countries reacted by speeding up the processing of applications, and by introducing restrictive measures, one of them being the extension of visa requirements to a larger number of countries (see Section I.D on migration policies). Most OECD countries also decided to restrict asylum applications, except for special cases, to persons from countries that have not signed the United Nations Conventions on refugees and on © OECD 2003
human rights, provided they have not previously passed through a country that is a signatory. In spite of these measures, and after declining generally in the early 1990s, flows of new asylum seekers began rising again in most OECD countries from 1997 onwards, due to the combined effect of numerous regional conflicts and continuing entry restrictions. Between 2000 and 2001, the total number of asylum requests filed in OECD member countries resumed dynamic growth, rising by approximately 9.5%. In the European Union, however, applications for asylum declined, in contrast to the pattern of the four previous years. These overall trends in fact mask shar p dispa rities acro ss ho st cou n trie s between 2000 and 2001. In 2001, and in decreasing order, it was the United Kingdom, Germany, the United States, France and Canada that received the greatest number of asylum requests (see Table I.1). The United Kingdom recorded 92 000 applications for asylum in 2001, or about 4 000 more than Germany. The United States took in 86 400 asylum seekers, or rou ghly twice as many as F rance (47 300) an d Canada (44 000). Th e rise in a pplication s for asylum between 2000 and 2001 was also spectacular in other countries, even if the absolute numbers involved remained modest. Examples are to be found in Central and Eastern Europe, and especially the Slovak Republic (up 426% to 8 150 applications in 2001) and the Czech Republic (up 106% to 18 000 applications in 2001) and, to a lesser extent, Romania, Bulgaria and Hungary. The aggregate number of applications for asylum in Central and Eastern European countries rose by about 76% between 2000 and 2001. The changing regional geopolitical situation, the tightening of controls in these countries and the more restrictive conditions for asylum in European Union countries all contributed to this trend. A number of countries do stand out, however, with substantial declines in applications for asylum be twe en 200 0 an d 200 1. T he y ar e t he Un ite d Kingdom (with 6 900 fewer applications recorded), the Netherlands (11 300 fewer applications), Italy (14 700 fewer applications) and Belgium (18 100 fewer applications). Analysis of trends in asylum requests over the 1990s highlights significant differences among
25
Trends in International Migration
the main receiving countries. Some have experienced a steady increase in applications (United Kingdom, Ireland, Czech Republic), while others seem to have been affected more temporarily. This is particularly the case for Belgium, Switzerland and Italy, and to a lesser extent – because they still take in substantial numbers of asylum seekers – France, Canada and Austria. For their part, Germany, the United St ates and Swe de n re flect a differen t dynamic, in that the number of asylum requests recorded in 2001 was significantly lower than the levels seen in the very early 1990s. Following the terrorist attacks perpetrated in the United States on 11 September 2001, one might have expected a wave of asylum requests, from Asia Minor in particular. But analysis of quarterly statistics contradicts that hypothesis. In fact, a compariso n o f th e to ta l n um be r of n e w ap plica tio n s recorded in the fourth quarter of 2001 with the corresponding figures from a year earlier shows a slight drop (of 3%). This trend appears even more striking in that asylum requests had risen in the first three quarters by an average of 13%. This trend seems to have continued in early 2002, since recorded applications were down on 2001 by 10% for the first five months of the year. If inflows of asylum seekers are expressed as a proportion of the total foreign population (see Table I.2), it is the Slovak Republic that ranks first (with 29%), far ahead of the Czech Republic, Ireland, Norway and Hungary, where the proportions range from 7.5% to 9%. In the United States and Australia, there were no more than three new asylum seekers per thousand of the foreign-born population in 2001. In Japan, the ratio is even significantly lower. As a percentage of the total population, inflows of asylum seekers are especially great in Austria, in Norway, in Switzerland, in Sweden, the Belgium and the Netherlands.
26
In terms of nationalities, the greatest number of requests recorded in the OECD countries in 2001 came from Afghans (roughly 53 000), followed by more than 50 000 requests from Iraqi citizens, 32 000 from Turks, nearly 29 000 from citizens of the former Yugoslavia and 21 000 from Chinese. The breakdown by original nationality varies sharply, however, from one host country to another (see the Statistical Annex, Table B.1.4). Australia, Denmark and the United Kingdom took in mostly Afghans and Iraqis; Germany, Switzerland and Sweden took in mostly Iraqis, citizens of the former Yugoslavia and
Turks; France took in mainly Turks and citizens of the Democratic Republic of Congo; the Netherlands took in mostly Angolans; Canada took in mainly Pakistanis, Sri Lankans and Chinese; while the United States took in primarily Mexicans, Guatemalans and Salvadorans. Not all asylum seekers obtain refugee status, within the meaning of the Geneva Convention, or in some other form (humanitarian refugee) – far from it (see Table I.2). Approval rates, computed on the basis of applications reviewed for the first time in 2001, were in fact low, and very variable from one host country to another. Approval rates are generally under 30%, but they can be much lower, as in France, where scarcely 12% of the applications examined are approved. Of the ten main receiving countries, the approval rate is highest in Canada, where it is 47%. However, the percentages also vary according to the nationalities concerned. Of the main nationalities of persons seeking asylum in the OECD countries, Afghans are most often granted refugee status (54% of the applications examined in 2001), followed by Iraqis (40%), citizens of the former Yugoslavia (25%), Iranians (22%), Chinese (19%), Russians (16%) and Turks (15%). e)
Migration: a multi-faceted panorama
Along with the traditional “big three” of family immigration, refugees and asylum seekers, and employment-related migration, the main trends of which were presented above, some more specific forms of mobility are developing. Aside from tourist visits, which strictly speaking do not constitute migration, and the seasonal movements mentioned earlier, examples include transfers of staff within multinational firms, cross-bo rder commu ters, temporary movements of skilled workers to provide services, the mobility of students, and retired persons electing to live abroad. Student mobility was discussed in a special chapter of the previous edition of Trends in International Migration. It is tending to increase with the expansion of trade and is part of the globalisation process: first, because language skills are increasingly essential for positions of responsibility and skilled jobs; and second, because cultural experience acquired abroad is frequently viewed as an additional advantage by employers. Apart from the direct financial benefit that enrolment fees bring to institutions of higher education, foreign students constitute a potential reserve of highly skilled © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.2. Inflows of asylum seekers in OECD countries in 2001
United Kingdom Germany United States France Canada Netherlands Austria Belgium Sweden Switzerland Czech Republic Norway Denmark Australia Ireland Italy Hungary Spain Slovak Republic Greece Turkey Poland Bulgaria Romania New Zealand Finland Luxembourg Mexico Japan Portugal EU Central and Eastern Europe North America OECD
Thousands
2000-2001 % change
Per 100 foreigners1 at the beginning of the year
Per 1000 inhabitants (2000)
Those with status recognised (as a % of all decisions taken in 2001)2
92.0 88.4 86.4 47.3 42.7 32.6 30.1 24.5 23.5 20.8 18.0 14.8 12.4 12.4 10.3 9.8 9.6 9.2 8.2 5.5 5.0 4.5 2.4 2.4 1.7 1.7 0.7 0.4 0.4 0.2
–7.0 12.5 51.7 22.0 19.6 –25.8 64.8 –42.5 44.4 17.9 105.6 36.4 19.9 4.2 –5.6 –60.1 22.5 16.3 426.2 78.4 .. 3.1 38.3 74.7 23.4 –47.9 10.8 .. 59.1 –4.5
3.9 1.2 0.3 1.4 0.9 4.9 4.0 2.8 4.9 1.5 9.0 8.0 4.8 0.3 8.2 0.7 7.5 1.0 28.8 .. .. 10.6 .. 3.4 0.2 1.8 0.4 0.1 – 0.1
1.5 1.1 0.3 0.8 1.4 2.1 3.7 2.4 2.7 2.9 1.8 3.3 2.3 0.6 2.7 0.2 1.0 0.2 1.5 0.5 0.1 0.1 0.3 0.1 0.5 0.3 1.6 – – –
26 25 30 12 47 15 4 27 27 36 1 33 52 29 4 20 5 6 – 18 47 5 70 5 19 38 22 34 23 23
388.1 45.1 129.1 612.3
–2.5 75.9 39.3 9.7
1. As a per cent of stocks of foreign-born citizens for Australia, Canada (1996), New Zealand and the United States. 2. Persons who obtained the refugee status plus those who were granted a “humanitarian” status as a per cent of total decisions taken in 2001 (including otherwise closed). Sources: Refer to notes for Table A.1.3 at the end of the Statistical Annex; United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
labour that is familiar with the rules and practices prevailing in the host country. A number of OECD countries, including Switzerland, Germany and Australia, and more recently Canada, have relaxed the rules for foreign students wishing to change their visas in order to enter the labour market after completing their studies. In some OECD member cou ntries, th e number of foreign students is very high. This is especially true in the United States, but also in the United Kingdom and Germany, which respectively hosted 475 000, 223 000 and 187 000 foreign students in 2000, in all fields and at all levels of © OECD 2003
study combined (see Table I.3). France and Australia each had over 100 000 foreign students as well. The proportion of OECD member country nationals, however, varies substantially from one country to another (22.4% in Australia and 25.2% in Poland, versus 60.6% in the United Kingdom, 72.8% in Switzerland and 75.4% in Ireland). These disparities are due partly to the geographical locations of the host countries and their histories of migration, but also to strategies to attract foreign students (grants and scholarships, possibilities of entering the labour marke t, et c.) a nd spe cialised pro grammes in certain fields of study. The OECD countries are
27
Trends in International Migration
Table I.3.
Stock of foreign students in selected OECD countries, 2000 Thousands and percentages
Thousands
United States United Kingdom Germany France Australia Japan Spain Canada Belgium Austria Switzerland Italy Sweden Turkey Netherlands Denmark Portugal Hungary New Zealand Ireland Norway Poland Czech Republic Finland Korea Mexico Slovak Republic Iceland Total OECD Source:
Of which: from an OECD country (%)
475.2 222.9 187.0 137.1 105.8 59.7 40.7 40.0 38.8 30.4 26.0 24.9 20.8 17.7 14.0 12.9 11.2 9.9 8.2 7.4 7.0 6.1 5.7 5.6 3.4 2.4 1.6 0.4
37.6 60.6 53.1 30.2 22.4 36.1 61.6 42.9 58.5 70.1 72.8 46.4 72.3 9.8 57.2 38.2 25.5 .. 29.2 75.4 56.9 25.2 51.8 35.6 28.4 .. 41.5 82.1
1 522.7
43.9
Database on Education, OECD.
taking in an ever-increasing number of foreign students. The total stock of foreign students in the OECD area rose by nearly 15% between 1998 and 2000. The trend has been absolutely spectacular in Belgium and Sweden. The increase was also substantial in Hungary (+48%), Spain (+40%) and New Zealand (+39%).
28
In North America the mobility of retired people has been a long-standing feature, and in some states like Florida and California the elderly are over-represented. Large numbers of Canadian senior citizens migrate to the southern states of the USA, Mexico, Costa Rica and the island states of the West Indies, in some cases only seasonally. 1 This trend is much less advanced in Europe, though it is on an upward path and the mobility of retired people is increasingly assuming an international dimension. For example, it is estimated that of the
nearly 6 million European citizens resident in an EU country other than their own, around 900 000 are aged over 60. Most of them are French, British, German or Belgian, and have settled chiefly in Spain, Portugal, Greece and, to a lesser extent, France. This migration of senior citizens would be more pronounced with the inclusion of return flows to home countries, notably Ireland and Portugal. Easier pension transfers and, in the case of Europe, the introduction of the Euro, but above all the retirement between now and 2010 of the babyboomers (probably more mobile than previous generations), are likely to accentuate this trend, though today it is still marginal. The other types of mobility mentioned above relate to workers – more specifically, skilled workers. In particular, transfers of staff within multinational companies have increased appreciably over the past decade or so. These international movements are generally linked with new relocated investment and their purpose is to start up a new subsidiary or to supervise the transfer of know-how from the parent company. But this mobility is not one-way. It may also be from subsidiary to parent, for the purpose of repatriating specific competencies or training local personnel to take over from the expatriate managers. More generally, in these big international corporations, expatriation is seen as a key element of human resource management. Acquisition of multicultural corporate experience is thus becoming an essential requirement for access to managerial posts. In Asia, movements of skilled workers are mostly transfers within multinational corporations. Japanese companies have invested heavily in that part of the world, relocating their activities in order to remain competitive. Expatriated Japanese nationals perform a large share of the management duties in these relocated enterprises. In the United States, inflows of foreign workers due to transfers of staff within multinational corporations almost tripled between 1995 and 2000 (see Table I.4). In 2000, about 300 000 work permits in this category were issued. A similar trend, over a longer period, is observable in nearly all OECD countries. Cross-border workers are not statistically recorded as migrants. Yet they continuously affect the equilibrium of the employment areas in which they work. This is certainly the case in the European Economic Area where, according to the estimates available, there are over 500 000 cross-border © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.4. Transferees within companies in selected OECD countries, 1995-2000 Thousands
Canada1 France Japan Netherlands United Kingdom United States (visa L1)
1995
1996
.. 0.8 3.1 .. 14.0 112.1
.. 0.8 2.8 1.6 13.0 140.5
1997
2.1 1.0 3.4 2.3 18.0 ..
1998
1999
2000
2.8 1.1 3.5 2.7 22.0 203.3
2.9 1.8 3.8 2.5 15.0 234.4
3.6 2.2 3.9 .. 16.0 294.7
1. Including Mexican and American intracompany transferees who entered under the NAFTA agreement. Sources: Canada : Citizenship and Immigration Canada; France : Office des migrations internationales (OMI); Japan : Ministry of Justice, Immigration Service; Netherlands : Employment Office; United Kingdom : Labour Force survey; United States : US Department of Justice.
workers out of a total of 34 million persons employed in the border zones. 2 Cross-border employment would therefore account for about 1.5% of total employment in these regions. In 2000 Switzerland alone admitted nearly 150 000 cross-border workers, more than half of them French (see Table I.5). Luxembourg also admits a great many Belgian, French and German workers. Belgium takes in an estimated 20 000 French cross-border workers and over 6 000 Netherlands nationals. Germany, given its central location in Europe, takes in a large number of workers resident in France, the Netherlands, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Switzerland and Luxembourg. Certain estimates put the crossborder workforce in Germany at nearly 100 000. Although intra-European mobility is still low and develo ping slowly, a marked growth of crossborder employment is observable.
International mobility of skilled workers in s e r v i c e p r o v i s i o n is a n o t h e r f o r m o f la b o u r m i gra tio n t ha t is i ncr ea sin g ste ep ly. T he movements are usually for short periods, though they may extend to several months or recur at freque nt intervals. Lo wer transport costs and technical specialisation account for this trend. The General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), signed by more than 130 countries, provides for the introduction of simplified procedures to assist the temporary mobility of professionals in certain se cto rs ( se e Box I.2) . H owe ve r, t he sta tistics generally combine these movements with those of entrepreneurs (business trips), making them very hard to identify. Ultimately, the development of electronic communication may curb service worker migration as new forms of distance working are introduced.
Table I.5. Cross-border workers in selected OECD countries, 1985, 1990, 1995 to 2000 Thousands
Austria1 Germany2 Luxembourg3 Switzerland
1985
1990
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
.. .. 16.1 111.6
.. .. 33.7 180.6
.. .. 55.5 151.0
.. .. 59.6 147.0
.. 16.3 64.4 142.2
2.1 9.7 70.8 142.5
4.0 8.8 78.4 144.8
5.2 9.4 87.4 156.0
1. Stock of non-EU cross border workers who hold a residence permit on 1st July of the given year. 2. Flow data (including renewals of permits). 3. Annual average. Sources: Austria: Federal Ministry of the Interior; Germany: Ministry of Labour; Luxembourg: National Statistical Office; Switzerland: Office fédéral des étrangers.
© OECD 2003
29
Trends in International Migration
Box I.2.
The GATS negotiations on service provision
The General Agreement on Trade in Services, which entered into force on 1 January 1995, identifies four types of international service trade called “modes of supply”. Mode 4 is the one concerning the temporary movement of natural persons. It therefore corresponds to temporary migration for purposes of employment. This may concern unincorporated entrepreneurs, employees of multinationals or foreign firms, or even businesspersons travelling on business. Permanent migration and job search are excluded, although the official definition of service suppliers does not specify a maximum length of stay. The fourth mode of service supply was introduced into the GATS negotiations at the insistence of several developing countries, including India. A new round of negotiations on trade in services began in 2000 and should finish at the end of 2005. member countries of the World Trade Organization were able to put forward requests for amendments until 30 June 2002. Six proposals concerning Mode 4 have been put forward by Colombia, India, Canada, the European Commission, Japan and the United States respectively. The proposals put forward by the developing countries concern the risks of brain drain and mobility of medium- or low-skilled service suppliers. The developed countries have a more ambivalent stance on Mode 4 since while anxious to protect their labour markets, they are under pressure from firms to facilitate access to foreign labour. The amendments requested by those countries concern, in particular, the definition of service suppliers, easing of access to foreign markets and the introduction of a GATS work permit.
f)
Traditional flows and new migration movements
Chart I.3 presents a comparison for selected OECD countries of the structure and changes of inflows from the principal countries of origin. Two distinctive trends can be observed in 2000. The first is the predominance of one or two origin countries. The second is the emergence of new migration flows.
30
I n 2 00 0 t h e f i v e ma i n s e n d in g c o u n t r i e s accounted for over 70% of total flows to Hungary and Japan, but less than one-third of the flows to Denmark and the Netherlands. The predominance of just a few origin countries in migration flows can be attributed to different causes, depending on the country concerned: geographical proximity, historical and cultural ties, or a large presence of refugees and asylum seekers. Geographical proximity would account for the high proportion of Poles in Germany, New Zealanders in Australia, Germans in Austria, French in Belgium and Luxembourg, Mexicans in the United States, Russians in Finland, Albanians in Italy and Chinese in Japan. At any given time, one in four of the main sources of outward migration is a co untry that has a co mmon border with the receiving country. The existence of historical and cultural links applies particularly to Britons in Australia (and the other way round), Moroccans and Algerians in France, Angolans, Cape Verdeans and Brazilians in Portugal and Indians in the United
Kingdom. Finally, the priority given to refugees by Sweden, Norway and Denmark explains the continuing inflow of migrants from countries that are the scene of persistent regional or local conflicts. All told, these three causes account for about one-third of the inflows to the receiving countries under review. Parallel with the continuing traditional flows, n ew migration movements are e me rging (se e Box I.3) for which the cultural and linguistic links to the country of origin are more tenuous. Chart I.3 shows average inflows over the 1990s (dotted) together with those for the latest available year (in blue), making it possible to compare these two trends. For a given host country, when an area not coloured blue is shown, this indicates that the share attributed to this country of origin in overall flows is lower for the latest available year than it was on average during the 1990s. For e xample, while Mexico contin ues to be th e leading so urce of emigration to the United States, the proportion of Mexicans in overall flows has fallen by more than 25%. A similar trend is observable for Vietnamese and Britons in Australia, Estonians in Finland, Surinamese and Turks in the Netherlands, Koreans in Japan and Portuguese in Switzerland. The trend is even more pronounced for nationals of countries of the former Yugoslavia moving to Denmark, Norway, Sweden and Switzerland.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Chart I.3.
Change in inflows of migrants by country of origin to selected OECD countries, 1990-1999 and 2000 2000 top ten countries of origin as a per cent of total inflows1
1990-1999 annual average2
Australia 0
5
10
15
20003
Austria 20
0
25
New Zealand (21.9)
5
10
15
Belgium 20
25
0
5
10
15
20
25
0
5
10
15
20
20
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
5
10
15
20
25
30
Germany (7.7)
France (8.1)
United Kingdom (9.2)
Turkey (7)
Netherlands (7.2)
China (6.8)
Fed. Rep. of Yug. 6.4)
Morocco (5.7)
South Africa (5.7)
Croatia (4.4)
United Kingdom (3.2) Germany (3)
India (4.6)
Bosnia Herzeg. (4.1)
Philippines (3.2)
Poland (3.5)
Turkey (2.8)
Fed. Rep of Yug. (2.2)
Hungary (2.5)
United States (2.8)
Fiji (1.9)
Slovak Rep. (1.9)
Italy (2.6)
Chinese Taipei (1.7)
Romania (1.9)
Spain (1.4)
Vietnam (1.5)
Czech Rep. (1.4)
0
5
10
15
20
Portugal (1.3)
25
0
20
0
5
10
Canada 0
5
10
15
20
Finland
Denmark 15
5
10
15
China (36.7)
Iraq (1.9)
Russian Fed. (2.5) Sweden (0.7)
India (26.1)
Norway (1.2)
Pakistan (14.2)
Turkey (1.1)
Estonia (0.7)
Philippines (10.1)
Sweden (1)
Fed. Rep. of Yug. (0.3)
Korea (7.6)
Germany (1)
Iraq (0.2)
Sri Lanka (5.8)
Somalia (1)
United States (0.2)
United States (5.8)
Iceland (0.8)
United Kingdom (0.2)
Iran (5.6)
United Kingdom (0.7)
China (0.2)
United Kingdom (4.6)
Former Yug. (0.7)
Germany (0.2)
Russian Fed. (3.5)
United States (0.6)
0
5
10
Somalia (0.2)
15
20
0
5
15
20
0
5
France4 0
5
10
10
15
20
0
15
20
0
Germany 10
Hungary
Morocco (16.9)
Fed. Rep. of Yug. (87.8)
Romania (6)
Algeria (12.4)
Poland (72.2)
Former Yug. (1.7)
Turkey (6.6)
Turkey (47.1)
Ukraine (1.6)
Tunisia (5.6)
Italy (34.9)
China (1)
United States (2.6)
Russian Fed. (27.8)
Germany (0.7)
Haiti (1.8)
Romania (18.8)
Russian Fed. (0.4)
China (1.8)
Greece (17.6)
Slovak Rep. (0.3)
Portugal (1.7)
United States (16.8)
Vietnam (0.3)
Switzerland (1.4)
Ukraine (15.3)
Israel (0.2)
Sri Lanka (1.3)
France (15.3)
United Kingdom (0.1)
0
5
0
5
10
15
20
0
15
20
0
5
Italy 10
10
15
10
15
15
20
47.4 (90-98) 38.9 (99)
0
5
25
0
5
10
15
20
10
15
20
25
30
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Luxembourg
Japan 5
10
20
20
Albania (31.2)
China (75.3)
France (2.3) Portugal (2.2)
Morocco (24.7)
Philippines (74.2)
Romania (20.7)
Brazil (45.5)
Belgium (1.3)
China (15.4)
United States (24.3)
Germany (0.6)
Philippines (12.2)
Korea (24)
Italy (0.6)
United States (7.2)
United Kingdom (7)
United States (0.3)
Poland (7.1)
Thailand (6.6)
Netherlands (0.2)
India (7)
Chinese Taipei (4.4)
Spain (0.2)
Tunisia (6.8)
Canada (4.2) Germany (4.2)
Bangladesh (6.6)
0
© OECD 2003
5
5
10
15
20
0
5
10
15
20
25
31
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.3.
Change in inflows of migrants by country of origin to selected OECD countries, 1990-1999 and 2000 (cont.) 2000 top ten countries of origin as a per cent of total inflows1
1990-1999 annual average2
Netherlands 0
5
10
15
20003
New Zealand 20
United Kingdom (5.9)
0
5
10
Norway
15
20
United Kingdom (6.2)
5
10
15
20
5
10
15
20
Iraq (4.5)
Germany (4.9)
China (4.9)
Sweden (3.5)
Turkey (4.5)
Australia (3.7)
Denmark (1.9) Somalia (1.5)
Morocco (4.2)
Japan (3.6)
United States (3.4)
India (2.3)
Germany (1)
France (2.2)
South Africa (2.1)
Russian Fed. (0.9)
Suriname (2.1)
Fiji (1.4)
United Kingdom (0.8)
Belgium (2)
Samoa (1)
United States (0.7)
China (1.8)
Fed. Rep. of Yug. (0.7)
Italy (1.5)
Iran (0.6)
0
5
0
5
10
15
20
0
5
15
20
0
5
Portugal 10
10
15
20
0
15
20
0
5
10
15
20
25
0
5
10
15
20
25
Sweden 10
Switzerland
Angola (2.5)
Iraq (6.6)
Germany (12.5)
Cape Verde (2.1)
Norway (3.9)
Former Yug. (6.7)
Brazil (1.7)
Finland (3.6)
France (6.6)
Guinea-Bissau (1.6)
Denmark (2)
Italy (5.4)
Spain (1.1)
Germany (1.5)
Portugal (4.9)
United Kingdom (0.8)
United Kingdom (1.3)
United Kingdom (3.7)
Germany (0.8)
Bosnia-Herzeg. (1.2)
United States (3.3)
France (0.7)
Iran (1.1)
Turkey (2.8)
Sao Tome/Principe (0.6)
United States (1.1)
Austria (2)
China (0.4)
Russian Fed. (1)
Spain (1.7)
0
5
10
15
20
0
20
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
5
United Kingdom5 0
5
10
15
10
15
20
United States
United States (47)
Mexico (173.9)
Australia (31.3)
China (45.7)
India (19.9)
Philippines (42.5)
South Africa (19.5)
India (42)
New Zealand (13.7)
Vietnam (26.7)
Pakistan (12.4)
Nicaragua (24)
Philippines (11)
El Salvador (22.6)
Canada (10.7)
Haiti (22.4)
Japan (9.6)
Cuba (20.8)
Poland (5.5)
Dominican Rep. (17.5)
0
32
0
5
10
15
20
Note: The top 10 source countries are presented by decreasing order. Data for Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States refer to inflows of permanent settlers by country of birth, for France, Italy and Portugal to issues of certain types of permits. For the United Kingdom, the data are based on entry control at ports of certain categories of migrants. For all other countries, figures are from Population registers or Registers of foreigners. The figures for the Netherlands, Norway and especially Germany include substantial numbers of asylum seekers. 1. The figures in brackets are inflows in thousands in 2000. 2. Annual average flows for the period 1990-1999 except for Denmark, Germany and Hungary (1990-1998), Finland, Portugal and the United Kingdom (1992-1999). 3. 1999 for Denmark, Germany and Hungary. 4. Entries from the EU are not counted, except permanent workers (including entries from the EEA since 1994) who are included through declarations made by employers to the authorities. 5. Passengers, excluding European Economic Area nationals, admitted to the United Kingdom. Data only include certain categories of migrants: work permit holders, spouses and refugees (excluding residents returning on limiting leave or who previously settled). Sources: National Statistical Offices. For more details on sources, refer to the introduction to the Statistical Annex.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Box I.3.
Origin of new immigrants and language skills Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants
One aspect of the increase in migration, over and above the traditional movements, is an inflow of immigrants whose cultural and linguistic links with the host country are weaker. These new populations have serious difficulties in integrating into the labour market and into society as a whole. Even though there is still a strong element of self-selection in migration, the percentage of immigrants whose mother tongue is the same as the official language of the host country (see Table I.6) is small in most OECD countries. This does not apply so much to the United Kingdom, Portugal, Australia and New Zealand, where migrant inflows are very large, either because of a colonial past as regards the first two of those countries, or because of selection as regards the other two. France is a special case, too, and the proportion there is 6% or 73% depending on whether or not the Maghreb countries are considered to be French-speaking. The Nordic countries, whose languages are little used around the world and which take in large numbers of refugees, are a good deal more affected by linguistic problems. In the United States, the Hispanic immigrant presence is such that it is able over the medium term to influence linguistic practice in that country (in 2000 nearly 11% of households stated that Spanish was spoken at home rather than English and 7% used other languages). In multilingual countries like Canada, Belgium and Switzerland, the mother tongue of immigrants is likewise becoming an additional issue of migration policy. In part this is why Quebec has negotiated with the Canadian federal authorities the right to select immigrants and manage migration flows to the province. The fact of coming from a country where one of the official languages is the same as that of the host country does not necessarily guarantee proficiency in that language. Many persons from the Indian sub-continent and from francophone Africa have a very poor command of English and French. Besides, Chiswick et al. (2002) show that in the case of Australia, language skills depend very much on the migrants’ category upon entry, as refugees, for example, have a lower command of English. These differences tend to decrease after three and a half years of residence as regards the migrants’ ability to speak English and, albeit to a lesser extent, their reading and writing skills in English. A large number of OECD countries have introduced special language training programmes for immigrants (see Section I.D on migration policies). In some countries participation is compulsory, and several countries plan to make citizenship, residence and permit renewal conditional on passing of a language test.
Table I.6.
Share of immigrants whose official language in their country of origin is the same as in the country of residence, 2000 % of total immigrants (among top 10 countries of origin)
United Kingdom Australia Portugal New Zealand Belgium Canada Luxembourg Switzerland Austria Sweden Finland Netherlands United States France Norway Korea Denmark Germany Hungary Italy Japan Source:
© OECD 2003
85.5 73.8 69.1 66.3 48.0 47.1 46.8 42.5 18.9 15.5 13.0 12.6 9.6 6.1 – – – – – – –
Percentages are calculated on the basis of data for top ten countries of origin of immigrants as they are stated in Table B.1.1 of the Statistical Annex.
33
Trends in International Migration
The emergence of new countries of origin, shown in Chart I.3 by a blue area next to the shaded part, is visible in the case of Filipinos in Italy, Brazilians in Japan, Ukrainians in Hungary and South Africans in Australia and the United Kingdom. Table I.7 illustrates the emergence of new migration flows. A specific indicator has been constructed for this purpose. It is calculated by dividing, for each host country considered, the five main sending countries’ share of total inflows for 2000 by their share of the total of foreigners or foreign-born. Thus, a value of 1 for a given sending country means that its share in inflows is the same as its share in the number of foreigners as a whole. This is the case for Indians in the United Kingdom and Brazilians in Portugal. If the value is greater than 1, this can be due either to immigrants from an emerging source country, or to previous waves of immigration which though persistent have had little impact on the total number of foreigners from this country. In the case of Australia and the United Kingdom, for example, the indicator is especially high for South African nationals since their share of inflows is over three times their share of the total number of foreigners. The presence of New Zealanders in Australia and Poles in Germany is not the result of a recent wave of immigration, but probably indicates size able n ew in flo w s a cco mpan ie d by l arg e r outflows. Thus the indicator in the range of 3 in these two cases corresponds to an old wave of migration that has a significant to-and-fro component and/or a high turnover.
34
Three sending countries stand out particularly for the year 2000. These are China, India and Iraq. The same finding was reported in the previous edition of Trends in International Migration, so there is now confirmation of the emergence of new migration flows from these countries. Iraq systematically figures in flows to the Nordic countries (mainly Denmark, Norway and Sweden) with an indicator of over 2, meaning that its nationals are represented at least twice as much in immigration flows as in the total stock of foreigners. But 2001 brought a reversal of the trend, with Afghan nationals figuring increasingly in the flows of asylum seekers (see above Section A.I.1.d.). Chinese and Indian nationals figure prominently in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States, although their shares of total immigrant numbers there are already high, reflecting both the continuing nature of the flows and their acceleration. The preponderance of these two nationalities of origin is in itself remarkable. Part of
the explanation probably lies in the heavy flows of ICT specialists to those countries during the period under review. Two other nationalities of origin came to the fore in 2000. Large numbers of South African nationals emigrated to Australia and the United Kingdom, and there were sizeable flows of United States nationals to France, Japan and, to a lesser degree, the Netherlands. Comparatively large numbers of Australians and New Zealanders emigrated to the United Kingdom. There was also quite a large flow of Russians to Germany, chiefly Aussiedler (Russians of German ethnic origin), confirming the continuation of East-West migration. Lastly, the big inflow of Japanese nationals to New Zealand should be noted. In 2000, nationals of Japan were represented 7.6 times more in entry flows than in the stock of foreigners. It may be asked whether the emergence of new source countries of immigration points to a diversification of nationalities of origin or more simply to a renewal of migration trends. An argument could be made for both cases. For countries like Switzerland, the Netherlands and the United States, the number of nationalities present in 50% of the immigration flow rose steeply during the 1990s, clearly indicating a diversification of sources. The number rose from 2 to 15 for the Netherlands, from 2 to 10 for the United States, and from 4 to 8 for Switzerland. By contrast, in the case of the Nordic countries, which are very responsive to requests for asylum, it would be more appropriate to speak of a renewal of flow sources. Finally, in the case of traditional immigration countries like Belgium, France and Germany, migration remains concentrated on a few nationalities that preponderate in both stocks and inflows of foreigners. g)
The case of areas of free movement between OECD countries
Within the OECD area there are three zones of free movement in which mobility and residence of nationals of the countries concerned are not officially restricted in any way. These zones are the European Union, the Nordic countries and the Trans-Tasman area formed by Australia and New Zealand. There is also the special case of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which greatly facilitates temporary mobility of professionals and other skilled workers between the United States and Canada. © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.7.
Relative importance of the top 5 countries in the total immigration flows and stocks of foreigners in selected OECD countries Main immigrants’ countries of origin in 2000
Top 5 nationalities (according to the 2000 volume of inflows)
Stocks of Inflows foreigners of foreigners in 19992 in 20001 % of total stock % of total inflows (A) of foreigners (B)
(A)/(B)
Top 5 nationalities (according to the 2000 volume of inflows)
Australia New Zealand United Kingdom China South Africa India Total (in thousands)
21.9 9.2 6.8 5.7 4.6 92.3
8.1 27.5 3.6 1.7 2.4 4 419.0
2.7 0.3 1.9 3.4 2.0
Austria Germany Turkey Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia Croatia Bosnia Herzegovina Total (in thousands)
Belgium France Netherlands Morocco United Kingdom Germany Total (in thousands)
8.1 7.2 5.7 3.2 3.0 68.6
12.0 9.6 13.6 2.9 3.8 897.1
0.7 0.8 0.4 1.1 0.8
Canada China India Pakistan Philippines Korea Total (in thousands)
Denmark Iraq Norway Turkey Sweden Germany Total (in thousands)
9.2 5.8 5.2 4.9 4.8 20.3
4.4 4.8 14.8 4.1 4.8 256.3
2.1 1.2 0.4 1.2 1.0
France Morocco Algeria Turkey Tunisia United States Total (in thousands)
17.8 13.0 6.9 5.8 2.7 95.2
15.4 14.6 6.4 4.7 0.7 3 263.2
1.2 0.9 1.1 1.2 4.0
Hungary Romania Former Yugoslavia Ukraine China Germany Total (in thousands)
39.9 11.3 11.0 6.4 4.5 15.0
39.9 11.1 8.5 5.5 5.9 143.8
Japan China Philippines Brazil United States Korea Total (in thousands)
21.8 21.5 13.2 7.0 6.9 345.8
Netherlands United Kingdom Germany Turkey Morocco United States Total (in thousands) Norway Iraq Sweden Denmark Somalia Germany Total (in thousands)
© OECD 2003
Inflows of foreigners in 20001 % of total inflows (A)
Stocks of foreigners in 19991 % of total stock of foreigners (B)
(A)/(B)
11.6 10.6 9.6 6.6 6.3 66.0
.. 18.2 .. .. .. 748.2
16.2 11.5 6.2 4.4 3.4 227.2
4.6 4.7 .. 3.7 .. 4 971.1
3.5 2.4 .. 1.2 ..
27.6 7.7 7.2 3.3 2.7 9.1
24.6 9.2 12.2 1.4 3.1 87.7
1.1 0.8 0.6 2.4 0.9
Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia Poland Turkey Italy Russian Federation Total (in thousands)
13.0 10.7 7.0 5.2 4.1 673.9
9.8 3.9 28.8 8.4 1.1 7 319.6
1.3 2.8 0.2 0.6 3.7
1.0 1.0 1.3 1.2 0.8
Italy Albania Morocco Romania China Philippines Total (in thousands)
11.5 9.1 7.6 5.7 4.5 271.5
9.2 11.9 4.1 3.8 4.9 1 252.0
1.2 0.8 1.8 1.5 0.9
18.9 7.4 14.4 2.8 40.9 1 556.1
1.2 2.9 0.9 2.6 0.2
Luxembourg France Portugal Belgium Germany Italy Total (in thousands)
21.1 20.4 12.0 5.9 5.7 10.8
11.8 35.8 9.1 6.6 12.6 159.4
1.8 0.6 1.3 0.9 0.5
6.4 5.3 4.9 4.6 3.7 91.4
6.1 8.3 15.5 18.4 2.2 651.5
1.1 0.6 0.3 0.2 1.7
New Zealand United Kingdom China Australia Japan India Total (in thousands)
16.1 12.7 9.6 9.4 6.0 38.8
31.3 5.6 8.1 1.2 3.0 698.6
0.5 2.3 1.2 7.6 2.0
16.1 12.6 7.0 5.5 3.6 27.8
3.2 14.1 10.7 2.7 3.8 178.7
5.0 0.9 0.6 2.0 1.0
Portugal Angola Cape Verde Brazil Guinea-Bissau Spain Total (in thousands)
15.9 12.9 10.5 10.2 7.0 15.9
9.3 22.9 10.9 7.4 5.8 190.9
1.7 0.6 1.0 1.4 1.2
Finland Russian Federation Sweden Estonia Federal Republic of Yugoslavia Iraq Total (in thousands) Germany
0.6 .. .. ..
35
Trends in International Migration
Table I.7.
Relative importance of the top 5 countries in the total immigration flows and stocks of foreigners in selected OECD countries (cont.) Main immigrants’ countries of origin in 2000
Top 5 nationalities (according to the 2000 volume of inflows)
Stocks of Inflows foreigners of foreigners in 19992 in 20001 % of total stock % of total inflows (A) of foreigners (B)
(A)/(B)
Top 5 nationalities (according to the 2000 volume of inflows)
Sweden Iraq Norway Finland Denmark Germany Total (in thousands)
19.7 11.5 10.6 5.9 4.3 33.8
6.2 6.4 20.3 5.1 3.2 487.2
3.2 1.8 0.5 1.1 1.4
Switzerland Germany Former Yugoslavia France Italy Portugal Total (in thousands)
United Kingdom United States Australia India South Africa New Zealand Total (in thousands)
16.3 10.8 6.9 6.7 4.8 288.8
5.6 2.5 6.7 2.3 1.5 2 208.0
2.9 4.4 1.0 3.0 3.2
United States Mexico China Philippines India Vietnam Total (in thousands)
Inflows of foreigners in 20001 % of total inflows (A)
Stocks of foreigners in 19991 % of total stock of foreigners (B)
14.3 7.7 7.6 6.2 5.6 87.4
7.5 24.2 4.2 23.9 9.9 1 368.7
1.9 0.3 1.8 0.3 0.6
20.5 5.4 5.0 4.9 3.1 849.8
29.5 4.9 4.4 3.3 3.2 31 107.9
0.7 1.1 1.1 1.5 1.0
(A)/(B)
1. 2000 except for Denmark, Germany and Hungary (1999). 2. Stocks of foreign-born population for Australia, Canada (1996 Census), New Zealand and the United States (2000 Census); 1998 for Denmark, Germany and Hungary; Stock of US citizens in France is issued from 1990 Census. Sources: National Statistical Offices (see notes for Tables A.1.1, A.1.4 and A.1.5. at the end of the Statistical Annex).
The Treaty of Rome (1957) recognises the principle of free movement for nationals of EU countries wishing to reside or work within the area formed by the signatory states. More recently, measures have been taken to facilitate intra-European mobility. These include a directive on free movement of nonworkers, students and retired persons, and a series of directives on mutual recognition of skills and access to certain public service jobs previously reserved for nationals. Nevertheless, intra-European mobility is still low, especially having regard to the differences between EU labour markets. Intra-European migration involves less than 0.2% of the total population of the Union, whereas movements between the nine major census areas in the United States concern 1.5% of those regions’ total population. The low mobility within Europe is partly attributable to linguistic and cultural barriers, but it is also due to structural rigidities in the labour markets of individual EU countries. In fact, though higher than intercountry migration, inter-regional mobility within EU counties is quite low as well, with 1.2% of people in work changing residence in 1999.
36
In 2002 the Commission launched an action plan for mobility and skills, one of the aims of which is to facilitate geographic mobility between now and
2005 by removing the remaining administrative and legal barriers, increasing the portability of supplementary pension rights of migrant workers, and improving the existing regimes of skills recognition in the regulated professions. The number of EU nationals in immigration inflows has risen slightly in recent years, however. Table I.8 shows movements of EU citizens, by nationality, for fourteen EU countries. The last line in the table shows the proportion of foreigners from other EU countries in the total population. The five countries with the highest proportion of EU nationals in their foreign population are Luxembourg (89%), Belgium (62.2%), Spain (42.7%) and France (36.6%). Ranking EU countries by the proportion of EU citizens in overall inflows produces very similar findings, and indicates other destinations as well. In the years 1998-99, the proportion was around 70% for Luxembourg, 51% for Portugal, 48.5% for Belgium, 47.5% for the United Kingdom and 39% for Spain. The remaining EU countries have considerably lower proportions of other EU citizens in their inflows, ranging from around 28% in the case of Denmark to 6% for France. Over 40% of EU citizens living in another country were in Germany, as against 20% in the United Kingdom. Compared to © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.8.
Intra-European mobility of EU citizens, latest available year
Immigration flows by nationality in per cent of total inflows of EU citizens
% in row
United Kingdom
Spain
Denmark
Netherlands
Sweden
Greece
Austria
Germany
Finland
France
Italy
1999
1998
1999
1998
1998
1998
1998
1998
1998
1998
1999
1999
1998
1999
0.5 16.4 2.0 2.7 1.0 26.6 8.5 1.0 1.3 6.7 – 25.1 1.3 1.7 5.2 100.0
1.2 3.7 0.9 6.9 1.0 15.7 22.0 0.4 0.7 7.6 0.3 – 18.7 2.3 18.7 100.0
0.9 – 1.4 22.1 1.5 28.3 11.0 2.2 1.2 9.3 0.7 4.7 4.2 2.0 10.8 100.0
0.1 1.2 3.8 4.2 2.4 22.0 13.3 18.3 2.8 14.2 0.0 3.6 9.8 4.4 – 100.0
1.5 5.8 1.4 4.9 3.3 12.1 31.9 0.2 0.9 8.9 0.1 6.4 – 2.4 20.4 100.0
2.1 1.9 – 7.6 5.0 9.6 20.9 1.5 1.7 6.8 0.0 1.2 6.4 18.4 16.8 100.0
1.8 9.7 2.0 – 2.5 10.3 23.8 3.4 2.7 6.9 0.1 3.7 5.8 3.3 23.8 100.0
1.1 1.1 13.4 4.2 35.9 7.2 13.7 2.4 1.6 3.5 0.0 0.8 3.4 – 11.8 100.0
3.6 3.2 3.6 6.6 4.1 14.7 26.2 – 1.0 9.1 0.1 0.3 0.9 7.1 19.5 100.0
– 1.4 1.7 4.2 2.6 5.1 52.7 4.0 0.9 10.4 0.3 3.2 2.4 3.4 7.6 100.0
8.8 1.5 1.8 4.8 2.1 11.3 – 13.0 2.0 25.8 0.5 10.9 6.1 2.5 8.9 100.0
1.8 1.1 4.5 3.8 – 7.0 12.4 2.0 1.7 4.9 0.0 0.3 3.1 44.6 12.9 100.0
1.0 6.7 1.4 3.1 1.1 – 10.7 1.4 2.0 13.8 0.3 31.9 9.2 2.5 15.1 100.0
4.6 3.5 2.1 4.5 2.0 19.6 24.2 7.3 1.6 – 0.1 3.6 10.6 3.0 13.3 100.0
4.2 2.6 2.4 5.8 3.1 15.0 11.5 9.9 2.0 16.4 0.3 7.7 6.2 3.5 9.5 100.0
Total
Belgium
Austria Belgium Denmark Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Ireland Italy Luxembourg Portugal Spain Sweden United Kingdom Total EU citizens
Portugal
EU citizens by nationality
Luxembourg
Receiving country
2.5
0.9
8.4
20.5
6.7
2.4
6.0
2.5
0.9
3.6
40.6
0.5
1.8
2.8
100.0
In per cent of total inflows of foreigners
69.7
50.9
48.5
47.5
38.8
27.7
24.4
23.4
22.9
20.2
20.1
19.2
6.1
..
26.2
Stocks (in 1998): EU foreigners (% of total foreigners)
89.0
26.3
62.2
18.5
42.7
20.5
28.0
33.9
..
13.0
25.1
18.7
36.6
13.7
..
EU foreigners (% of total population)
31.0
0.5
5.5
0.7
0.7
1.0
1.2
2.0
..
1.2
2.3
0.3
2.0
0.3
..
Source:
Eurostat, New Cronos database.
the situation prevailing in 1997, in 1998 the United Kingdom received far more immigrants from EU countries (up 15.5%), while Luxembourg, Portugal and Belgium received markedly fewer. The proportion of intra-European immigration also rose in Finland, Greece and Sweden; in Denmark and Austria it remained virtually unchanged. The analysis of intra-European mobility by nationality shows great diversity, largely reflecting cultural and linguistic affinities (Germans in Austria, French and Dutch in Belgium, Finns in Sweden and Swedes in Finland). Historical ties also play a role in this mobility, as is the case of Portuguese and Italians in France and of Italians in Austria. In 1954 the Nordic countries (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden) concluded an agreement that led to the creation of the Nordic passport© OECD 2003
free area. Nationals of third countries have to meet the entry and stay requirements of the Nordic country in which they wish to settle. In 1996, when Denmark, Finland and Sweden joined the Schengen system, Iceland and Norway, which are not EU members, negotiated co-operation agreements with the Schengen Member States, but the Nordic passport-free area was maintained. Up until the early 1990s most of the migration within the area was to Sweden, the Nordic country with the most buoyant economy. Annual inflows of Nordic nationals averaged some 12 000 persons, half of them Finns.3 Most of the Finnish immigrants in Sweden were young and low-skilled, wh ereas today’s immigrants tend to be “white collar”. The Danes and Swedes preferred to migrate to Norway. Although its pattern has changed, notably with the
37
Trends in International Migration
Table I.9.
Stock of nationals from Nordic countries in other Nordic countries, 2000 Thousands and percentages
Citizenship/Host country
Denmark
Finland
Norway
Sweden
Denmark Iceland Finland Norway Sweden
– 5.9 2.1 13.0 10.8
0.6 .. – 0.6 7.9
19.4 3.9 6.0 – 25.2
25.6 4.1 98.6 32.0 –
Total of the above % of total foreigners
31.8 12.3
9.1 9.9
54.5 29.6
160.2 33.6
Sources: Population Registers.
entry of some of the Nordic countries into the European Union, Nordic migration still takes place on a large scale. In 2000, Nordic citizens represented over a third of the foreigners residing in Sweden and a little under 30% in Norway (see Table I.9). Norwegians predominate in Denmark, Swedes in Norway, and Finns in Sweden. Since 1920 there has been no restriction, so to speak, on mobility between New Zealand and Australia. In 1973 the two countries signed the Trans-Tasman Travel Arrangement, which authorises their citizens to move between New Zealand and Australia and reside and work in either country without the need for any permit. Migration between the two countries is in fact very sensitive to changes in the economic climate and dominated by the mobility of New Zealanders. Specifically, the number of New Zealanders in Australia increases during periods of economic growth and decreases during recessio ns. Ove r th e past t en y ea rs, h o we ve r, n e t migration of Ne w Z ealan ders to Australia has increased continuously, rising from less than 3 000 in 1991/92 to +30 000 in 1999-2000. In March 2001 an estimated 450 000 New Zealanders were residing in Australia, of whom 251 000 had been there for more than 12 months. For purposes of comparison, the ce nsus figure fo r Australian s re sident in Ne w Zealand in 2001 is only 56 300. In February 2001, Australia and New Zealand amended the terms of the Trans-Tasman Arrangement, which now stipulates that New Zealanders must obtain a residence permit if they wish to receive certain types of welfare benefit in Australia.
38
The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), in effect since 1994, allows Canadian and Mexican professionals to come and work temporarily in the United States (TN visa) if they have a
formal offer of employment. Labour certification (proof that the visa applicant is not taking a job away from a US worker) is not required. The application can be made at the border and the visa issued on the spot. There is no quota for Canadian nationals, but the number of Mexicans that can apply for the TN visa is limited to 5 500 a year. In January 2004 this limit will be abolished together with the clause on pay offers (these must be comparable to current pay levels in the United States). Consequently, migration of Mexican professionals to the United States can be expected to increase. In 2000, nearly 89 900 Canadian professionals (60 700 in 1999 and about 93 000 in 2001) and a little under 2 500 Mexicans entered the United States with TN visas. Migration of Mexicans and Americans to Canada under the TN system is on a much smaller scale, totalling no more than 10 100 persons in 2000. But the flow can be expected to increase in the years ahead. Finally, there is the very specific case of Puerto Rico, which formally is a free state associated with the United States. Puerto Rican citizens can circulate freely in the United States and have a special status that confers all the rights and duties associated with American citizenship, except the right to vote in presidential elections. According to the 2000 census figures, Puerto Rico has a population of 3.6 million, plus about 3.4 million Puerto Ricans living in the United States. The latter represent 9% of that country’s Hispanic immigrant population and a little over 1% of the immigrant total. h)
The foreign or immigrant population is increasing and diversifying…
In Australia, New Zealand and Canada, immigrants account for a large share of the resident population: 23.6% in 2000 for Australia and 19.5% for © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
New Zealand, and over 17% in 1996 for Canada (see Chart I.4). In the United States, according to data from the 2000 CPS, the number of foreign-born persons amounts to 28.4 million or 10.4% of the total population. Between 1995 and 2000 the immig r a n t p o pu la t i o n t h e r e i n c re a se d b y n e a r l y 5.5 million. In Canada, in the interval between the last two censuses (1986-96), the immigrant population rose by one million. In Australia, between 1996 and 2000, immigration increased the population by more than 600 000.
Chart I.4.
The foreign presence in the total population varies widely across the European OECD countries. In 2000 it was very large in Luxembourg (37.3%) and in Switzerland (19.3%). In the other traditional immigration countries the foreign presence ranged from 4% in the United Kingdom to 9.3% in Austria. The proportion was close to 9% in Germany and 8.5% in Belgium, as against 5.6% in France and 4.2% in the Netherlands. In the northern European countries the proportion of foreigners in the total population ranges from
Stocks of foreign and foreign-born populations in selected OECD countries, 2000 Percentages of total population Foreign-born population
Foreign population % of total population 40 Luxembourg (37.3) 35 30
Australia (23.6) New Zealand (19.5) Canada (17.4)
25 20
Switzerland (19.3)
15 11 United States (10.4) 10 9
Austria (9.3) Germany (8.9) Belgium (8.4)
8 7 6 France (5.6) Sweden (5.4) 5 4
Denmark (4.8) Netherlands (4.2), Norway (4.1) United Kingdom (4.0) Ireland (3.3)
3 2 1 Mexico (0.5) 0
Greece (2.7) Italy (2.4), Spain (2.2) Portugal (2.1), Czech Rep. (2.0) Finland (1.8) Hungary, Japan (1.3) Slovak Rep. (0.5), Korea (0.4) Poland (0.1)
Note: 1996 for Canada, 1999 for France, Hungary, the Netherlands and Norway. Sources: National Statistical Institutes. For more details on sources, refer to the notes for Tables A.1.4 and A.1.5 at the end of the Statistical Annex.
© OECD 2003
39
Trends in International Migration
4.1% in Norway to 5.4% in Sweden. It is much lower in Finland, being only 1.8%. In the new immigration countries of Southern Europe the foreign presence, although still comparatively small, has grown appreciably in recent years. In 2000 it represented over 2% of the total population in Greece, Italy, Spain and Portugal. In Spain, following the recent rounds of regularisation, the proportion of foreigners may have reached or even exceeded 3% in 2001. Despite the recent developments mentioned in this report (see below), in the OECD countries of Central and Eastern Europe and Asia the foreign presence is still
Table I.10.
extremely small. It is about 1.3% in Japan and Hungary, but no more than 0.5% in the Slovak Republic, Korea and Poland. The trend of stocks of immigrants or foreigners varies across countries and depends on migration policy, migrant inflows and outflows, the demographic dynamics of foreign populations, and the number of naturalisations, which reduces the stock of foreigners commensurately. In most OECD countries the number of foreigners or immigrants has risen during the past five years (see Table I.10).
Foreign or foreign-born population in selected OECD countries, 1995 and 2000 Thousands and percentages Foreign population Thousands
Austria Belgium Czech Republic Denmark Finland France (1990-99) Germany Greece (1994-99)1 Hungary (1995-99) Ireland Italy Japan Korea Luxembourg Netherlands Norway Portugal Slovak Republic Spain Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom
1995
2000
724 910 159 223 69 3 597 7 174 106 140 96 991 1 362 110 138 725 161 168 22 500 532 1 331 1 948
758 862 201 259 91 3 263 7 297 238 127 127 1 388 1 686 210 165 668 184 208 28 896 477 1 397 2 342
Annual growth over the period (%)
Data source
0.93 –1.08 4.85 3.03 5.83 –0.97 0.34 17.69 –2.39 5.65 6.96 4.36 13.83 3.59 –1.64 2.77 4.33 5.32 12.38 –2.14 0.98 3.75
R R R R R C R LFS R LFS P R R R R R P R P R R LFS
Foreign-born population Thousands
Australia (1996-2000) Canada (1996) Mexico New-Zealand United States
40
1995
2000
4 164 4 971 .. .. 23 000
4 517 .. 406 699 28 400
Annual growth over the period (%)
2.06 .. .. .. 4.31
Data source
E C C C LFS
Note: For details on sources, refer to the notes for Tables A.1.4 and A.1.5 at the end of the Statistical Annex. 1. Population aged 15 and over. Sources: C: Census; E: Estimates by the national Statistical Institute; LFS: Labour force survey; P: Residence permits; R: Population register or register of foreigners.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Chart I.5.
Stocks of foreign and foreign-born populations by region of origin in all OECD countries, latest available year Percentages Oceania 2% North America 3%
Unknown1 10%
Africa 5%
Europe 36%
Central and South America 18%
Asia 26%
Notes: For Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States, data relate to the foreign-born population. For all other host countries, they relate to foreigners. 1. Data are not available for all nationalities/countries of birth. Sources: Calculations are made on the basis of Tables B.1.4 and B.1.5 of the Statistical Annex (including some unpublished data related to nationalities/ countries of birth not included among the Top 15).
During the 1990s the foreign population grew very considerably in Austria, Germany and Switzerland, mainly because of increased inflows from Central and Eastern Europe. In the United States the number of foreign-born persons rose by more than 40% between 1990 and 2000. Between 1995 and 2000 the highest average annual growth rates for the foreign population were in Greece, Korea and Spain. Growth rates were also very high (over 5% a year) in Italy, Ireland and the Slovak Republic. Belgium, France and the Netherlands were notable exceptions, mainly because of the comparatively large number of naturalisations in those countr ie s. In S we den th e sto ck of fo re ign er s a lso decreased between 1995 and 2000, chiefly owing to naturalisations and the return of Finns to their home country. Chart I.5 shows the distribution of all foreigners and immigrants by region of origin. The largest share is found in Europe (36%), followed by Asia (around 26%). The African and Asian continents, which respectively account for 13% and 59% of the world’s po p u la t io n , a r e th e re f o r e v e r y m u ch u n d e r© OECD 2003
represented in the foreign populations of OECD countries, while Europe (13% of the world’s population), is still heavily over-represented, although its share of total immigration flows is declining noticeably. Generally speaking, the size of the foreign population, broken down by nationality (see Statistical Annex, Tables B.1.4 and B.1.5), varies in each host country in accordance with migration tradition, the facilities already in place, employment opportunities and geographic proximity of the country of origin. In the OECD countries of Europe the proportion of European immigrants increased during the 1990s with the opening of eastern borders. The same trend is perceptible in the new immigration countries of Southern Europe and certain countries of Cen tral and Easte rn Europe. By contr ast, the proportion of European nationals in the foreignborn population has been decreasing in the United States and Canada, but also in Australia and New Zealand. In 1986, Europeans represented 62% of the foreign-born population living in Canada, ten years later the proportion was down to 47% and it is still falling.
41
Trends in International Migration
In recent years, there have been large-scale movements of Asian persons, notably Chinese and Indians, outside their traditional areas of migration (i.e., Japan, Korea, Australia and, to a lesser extent, the United States and Canada for the Chinese; the Commonwealth countries for the Indians). The immigration statistics for the United States somewhat mask this phenomenon because of the very large presence of Latin Americans, who form an expatriate community of nearly 15 million persons in that country, but in a number of European countries the Asian inflow is very visible. Chinese form the fourth largest foreign community in Hungary, the fifth in Italy and the eighth in Spain. The foreigners and foreign-born persons resident in OECD countries include member country nationals. Although statistical analyses rarely single them out, their number is relatively high. Nearly 45% of the foreigners and immigrants in OECD countries, taken together, come from a member country. This compares with over 70% in Belgium and Luxembourg. In Switzerland, Germany, Sweden and Australia the proportion is over 50%. It is also high in the United States (48%) because of the Mexican presence, but very much lower in Japan (5%) and the Slovak Republic (11%). The recent accession of six more countries to the OECD (the Slovak Republic in 2000, Hungary, Poland and Korea in 1996, the Czech Republic in 1995 and Mexico in 1994) has accentuated this trend. In 2000, Turks topped the ranking by nationality of foreigners resident in European OECD countries with more than 2.6 million persons. They were followed by nationals of the former Yugoslavia (about 1.8 million), Italians (1.5 million) and Moroccans, just ahead of Portuguese (about 1 million). After Turks and nationals of Maghreb countries, Americans make up the largest non-European community in the EU. Mexica ns form the largest expatriate community in the OECD area, with over 8 million persons in the United States alone. Demographic characteristics of the foreign or foreign-born population
42
The demographic structure of the foreign or foreign-born population differs from that of nationals in its age and gender composition. But specific features vary considerably across countries and in fact depend on the nature of migration flows, in particular the size of the family component, and on
the dates of migration waves and the features of the main groups of migrants themselves. In some of the major immigration countries in Europe, such as France, but also Belgium and Switzerland, and to a lesser extent Sweden and the Netherlands, the age structure for foreigners is relatively close to that for nationals and the sole distinction is that foreigners are under-represented in the 65 and over age groups (see Chart I.6). Longstanding migration and the fact that immigrants have tended to settle permanently in these countries partly explain this finding. Under-representation in the higher age groups, moreover, may be due to the numbers of naturalisations. In Austria and Germany the recent waves of migration, following the opening up of Eastern Europe (see Part I.C), have injected a younger element into the age structure of the foreign population, at a time when low fertility rates give the age pyramids for nationals there the typical aspect of an ageing population. More recent countries of immigration, such as those of Southern Europe and some of the Nordic countries (Finland and Norway), present a distinctive age structure for their foreign population. There is a clear preponderance of groups of working age (25-34, 35-44 and to a lesser extent 15-24), and very marked under-representation of older groups. This pattern is also visible in the United Kingdom. The findings are more mixed in the countries of settlement (Australia, Canada and the United States). The scale of family reunion helps to ensure that the proportion of elderly people in the immigrant population is little different from that for nationals (in fact it is appreciably higher in Canada). Apart from a few exceptions, women are underrepresented in the foreign or foreign-born population (see Chart I.6). In Switzerland, Portugal and Germany, where employment-related immigration remain s pre do min ant, th e disparity betwe en foreigners and nationals is considerable (over 5%). But some other countries, the United Kingdom and Canada, stand out with a higher percentage of women in the foreign population. A similar finding can be made for some Nordic countries, where refugees and asylum seekers make up a substantial proportion of total flows and where employment-related movements often involve women, especially in the health care sector. © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Chart I.6.
Foreign and national populations by age group and by sex, latest available year Percentage of total foreign or national population
Nationals
Foreigners
France (1999)
Germany (1998)
Women
Share of women among: Foreigners: 46.9% Nationals: 51.7%
Women
Men 75+ 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
15 10 5 0 % of total population of each group
Men 65+
21
60-64 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 21-24 15-20 10-14 5-9 0-4
5
10
15
15
10
5
Netherlands (2001) Women
Share of women among: Foreigners: 47.3% Nationals: 50.7 %
Women 80+ 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
5
10
15
15
10
Sweden (1998)
5
Share of women among: Foreigners: 41.7% Nationals: 52.0%
0 5 10 15 % of total population of each group
United Kingdom (1999) Men
Women
Men
80+ 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
15 10 5 0 % of total population of each group
© OECD 2003
Men
80+ 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
Women
Share of women among: Foreigners: 50.6% Nationals: 50.6%
0 5 10 15 % of total population of each group
Portugal (1998) Men
15 10 5 0 % of total population of each group
Share of women among: Foreigners: 44.7% Nationals: 51.9%
55-59
80+ 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
5
10
15
15
10
5
Share of women among: Foreigners: 53.0% Nationals: 50.6%
0 5 10 15 % of total population of each group
43
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.6. Foreign and national populations by age group and by sex, latest available year (cont.) Percentage of total foreign or national population
Natives
Foreign-born
Australia (2000)
Canada (1996)
Population aged 15 and over Women
Population aged 15 and over Women Men
Men 80+ 75-79
Share of women among: Foreign-born: 49.8% Natives: 50.9%
65+
70-74 65-69
Share of women among: Foreign-born: 51.8% Natives: 51.2%
60-64 55-64
55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44
25-54
35-39 30-34 25-29 15-24
20-24 15-19
15 10 5 0 % of total population of each group
5
10
15
60
50
40
30
20
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 % of total population of each group
United States (2001) Women
Share of women among: Foreign-born: 50.0% Natives: 51.2%
Men 80+ 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
15 10 5 0 % of total population of each group
44
5
10
15
Lastly, Table I.11 reflects differences in levels of education between nationals and foreigners or immigrants aged between 15 and 65, as observed in 2000-2001. In a number of OECD countries, over h alf t he fo re ig n po pu la tio n h a s no t pu r sue d education beyond the first cycle of secondary school. The proportion is as much as around 67% in France. With the exception of Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain, foreigners seem on average to have lesser levels of education than nationals. But
1. Foreign-born and native populations for Australia, Canada and the United States. Foreigners in the Netherlands are defined as foreignborn with one parent at least who was born abroad. Sources: New Cronos database (Eurostat) for European countries except for France (1999 Census data published by INSEE); Labour force surveys, figures compiled by the Australian Bureau of Statistics and by the US Bureau of the Census; 1996 Census data from Statistics Canada.
the gap is less significant in the main countries of settlement, which apply a selective policy on immigration (Canada, for example). Similar observation also concern children of foreign origin (see Box I.4). The duality of migration flows by level of education stands out sharply in the case of some member countries where foreigners or foreign-born persons are over-represented at both the highest
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.11.
Foreign and national adult populations classified by level of education in selected OECD countries1 2000-2001 average, percentages Lower secondary
Austria Belgium Czech Republic Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Hungary Italy Luxembourg Netherlands Norway Portugal Slovak Republic Spain Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom Canada2 United States3
Upper secondary
Third level
Foreigners
Nationals
Foreigners
Nationals
Foreigners
Nationals
41.8 54.4 22.6 21.2 26.9 66.7 48.5 40.3 18.6 55.0 49.4 50.8 15.7 69.5 14.5 44.6 29.1 33.6 30.1 22.2 30.1
21.4 39.9 13.7 20.0 26.7 34.9 15.1 48.9 30.5 55.8 33.6 32.6 14.4 79.6 15.7 62.4 22.4 10.5 18.8 23.1 9.3
43.5 24.5 48.5 51.1 45.6 19.6 36.1 41.2 52.2 32.1 28.7 27.6 44.1 19.8 68.6 25.9 40.3 42.6 29.1 54.9 24.7
64.3 32.0 74.8 53.9 40.7 42.3 60.4 34.1 55.7 34.4 50.6 42.8 53.2 11.0 73.8 15.5 48.0 64.4 53.3 60.3 33.7
14.7 21.2 28.9 27.7 27.6 13.7 15.4 18.5 29.1 13.0 21.9 21.6 40.2 10.7 16.9 29.5 30.6 23.8 40.8 22.9 45.2
14.4 28.2 11.4 26.1 32.6 22.7 24.5 16.9 13.8 9.8 15.7 24.6 32.4 9.4 10.4 22.1 29.7 25.1 27.9 16.6 57.1
1. The educational attainment classification is defined as follows: lower secondary refers to pre-primary education or none, primary or lower secondary; upper secondary refers to upper secondary education or post-secondary non tertiary education; third level refers to tertiary education. Data refer to individuals aged 25 to 64. 2. Foreign-born and native populations aged 25 to 44. Lower secondary refers to below grade 9, upper secondary refers to grades 9 to 13 and third level refers to some post-secondary education plus university degrees. 3. Foreign-born and native populations aged 25 and over. Lower secondary refers to less than high school diploma, upper secondary refers to high school diploma and third level refers to some college or more. Sources: Labour force survey, data provided by Eurostat; Statistics Canada; US Bureau of the Census.
and lowest levels of education. This is particularly the case in the United Kingdom and Canada, but also in Austria and the Nordic countries. The main immigration countries in Europe (Belgium, France, Germany, Switzerland) show signs of the older waves of migration in the 1960s and 1970s, largely made up of low-skilled labour employed in the manufacturing sector. If the above figures are compared with the 1999-2000 averages (see 2001 edition of Trends in International Migration), it will be seen that the proportion of foreigners with tertiary education has risen by more than one and a half percentage points in the United Kingdom , reflecting increased inflows of high-skilled workers. Education levels of foreigners have also risen in Italy and Austria. But in Portugal and Greece they have declined during the past two years. This is not sur pr isin g, give n the gr owth o f e mplo ymen trelated migration of low-skilled workers to these countries. © OECD 2003
i)
… but remains very concentrated around urban areas
An initial analysis of regional data shows that patterns of foreign population distribution vary substantially across host countries. The disparities are due in part to current migration policies and the extent to which they encourage the dispersion of new immigrants throughout the country, but also to the economic structure of the country concerned (concentrated or dispersed job catchment areas, administrative and/or economic activities concentrated around a centre). Maps I.1, I.2 and I.3 show the distribution of foreign populations by large regions in Europe, as well as in the United States, Canada, Mexico, Australia and New Zealand. In some European member countries of the OECD (see Map I.1), the regional concentration of the foreign population can be high, particularly in capital regions. For instance the percentage of foreigners in the total population is almost 27% in the London area and 26% in the Brussels area, 14.5% in Stuttgart and
45
Trends in International Migration
Box I.4.
School performance of children of foreign origin Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants
Access to education is one of the most important determining factors concerning integration into the labour market, as school performance among children of immigrants may be influenced by lack of language skills or unfavourable social and economic conditions. This may raise serious long-term issues in terms of integration of immigrants into the host society. The PISA study (www.pisa.oecd.org) has analysed and compared the school performance of children born abroad of foreign parents (non-native or immigrant children), of native pupils of foreign-born parents (first generation) and of native children with at least one parent native-born (natives) (see Chart I.7). In most OECD member countries, immigrant children lag behind native-born children in terms of reading skills, as well as mathematics and science (not reported), although the discrepancies tend to be slightly lower in the latter two cases. The test score differences are particularly significant in Switzerland and Luxembourg and to a lesser extent in Austria, Belgium and Germany. Conversely it is quite low, if not negligible, in Canada, Australia and New-Zealand. The improvement in education attainment between non-natives and first generation students is particularly striking in the United Kingdom, illustrating either a change in the origin of foreign children or an improvement in the school performance across generations. Belgium and Denmark are the only two countries where the recorded combined reading test score is lower for first generation than for immigrant students. Country-specific studies shed light on the complexity of this pattern. For example, according to research in the United Kingdom poor performance is not necessarily found in areas where there is a high concentration of immigrants but is often more directly affected by the school environment. Research for the United States finds that immigrant children are as likely as those native-born to enrol in primary schools but less likely to go on to high school. Research for Canada suggests that immigrant children consistently out-perform native-born children. Strong motivation among immigrant families to succeed in their new host country could be one explanation. Most OECD countries are aware of the importance of this issue and thus provide special training, including language training, to foreign children. Nonetheless, as previously shown, difficulties in integrating into the school system also concern first generation children, for whom the educational disadvantage factors are much more difficult to identify and to cope with. Although institutional and historical situations differ from one country to another, it seems that much can be learned from the relative success of traditional settlement countries such as Australia, Canada and New-Zealand.
Chart I.7.
School performance of children according to their place of birth and the place of birth of their parents Natives (natives with at least one parent born in the country) First generation (natives with both parents born abroad) Non-natives (born abroad of foreign parents)
Combined Reading Scores Luxembourg
Canada 550
Mathematics Scores Luxembourg
Australia
Denmark
450
New Zealand
Belgium
United States Norway
46
New Zealand 350
Sweden
Switzerland
United Kingdom 450
Belgium
350
Germany Austria
Australia
550
United Kingdom
Denmark
Canada
France
Germany
Sweden
Austria Switzerland
United States Norway
France
Source: PISA Study, OECD, 2001.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Map I.1. Foreign population in the European regions, 2001
Percentage of total population More than 9% From 4.5% to 9% From 1.5% to 4.5% From 0.5% to 1.5% Less than 0.5% Average 4.4%
Note: Population aged 15 and over, except for Denmark, Luxembourg and Switzerland for which data cover the whole population. For those three countries data are not broken down by region. Data are not available for Iceland and Poland. Source: Eurostat and OECD Territorial Statistics and Indicators.
© OECD 2003
47
Trends in International Migration
Map I.2.
Foreign-born population in the Australasian regions, 2001
Percentage of total population More than 20% From 13% to 20% From 8% to 13% Less than 8% Average: Australia: 23.1% New Zealand: 19.5%
Source: 2001 Census, Australian Bureau of Statistics and Statistics New Zealand; OECD Territorial Statistics and Indicators.
almost 17% in Vienna. And this percentage is at least double the national ave rage in the Paris area (13.9%), Prague (1.2%), the Balearic Islands and Madrid (5.7% and 3.1% respectively). The other OECD member countries under review (see Maps I.2 and I.3) display similar patterns, but with the particular drawing power of other important economic areas such as British Columbia in Canada, California and Florida in the United States, Sydney in Australia or Auckland in New Zealand. Italy is also interesting in that the foreign population is noticeably concentrated in the leading industrial areas to the north of the country. The maps also reveal more specific concentrations, in particular around the borders (e.g. France an d th e Un it ed St ate s), alo ng th e co ast (e.g. Australia) or, in the case of Germany, between the eastern and western parts of the country.
48
Chart I.8 shows regional disparities in the distribution of the foreign population. The horizontal axis gives the percentage of foreigners (or immigrants in the case of host countries) in the countries under
review, while the vertical axis measures regional disparities in the distribution of the foreign population. Patterns are sharply contrasted from one country to the next. Typical patterns are found in the following countries: in Europe, Spain (small share of foreigners in the total population and large regional disparities) contrasts with Germany and Austria (large number of foreigners and relatively small regional disparities); the Netherlands (share of foreigners in the total population around the European average and very small regional disparities) contrasts with the United Kingdom (share of foreigners in the total population slightly higher than the European average and very large regional disparities); and finally Belgium has a large number of foreigners and very large regional disparities. Other countries have less clear profiles. Ho we ver, some can be gro upe d to get he r, for instance Greece, Finland and Norway, with a relatively low number of foreigners and small regional disparities. Conversely the Czech Republic, which takes in few foreigners, has very marked regional disparities.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Map I.3.
Foreign-born population in North American regions, 2000
Percentage of total population More than 15% From 7% to 15% From 3% to 7% From 1% to 3% Less than 1% Average: Canada: 17.4% United States: 11.0% Mexico: 0.5%
Sources: 1996 Census, Statistics Canada; 2000 Census, US Census Bureau; 2000 Census, INEGI; OECD Territorial Statistics and Indicators.
In the case of the United Kingdom, Belgium and the Czech Republic, regional disparities are considerably attenuated if the capital region is excluded from the analysis. The same applies to Spain if the analysis excludes the Balearic Islands (region with the highest percentage of foreigners). The difference is indicated in Chart I.8 by an arrow connecting the point which includes all regions to the point which excludes the region with the highest foreign population density. In the four host countries under review (Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States), the immigrant population is highly concentrated in the major coastal cities, particularly in
© OECD 2003
Australia and Canada but also, in the case of the United States, in entire regions that have had massive recourse to immigrant labour. Compared with the United States and Canada, however, Australia and New Zealand have a more uniform regional distribution of the immigrant population. Chart I.9 breaks down the previous findings using a generic indicator of foreign population dispersion. Regions are classed in ascending order according to the number of foreigners they contain. The vertical axis shows the cumulative percentage of foreigners. The horizontal axis shows the cumulative percentage of the
49
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.8.
Percentage of foreigners in total population in selected OECD countries and measurement of regional disparity, 2001 Coefficient of variation (%) 100
Coefficient of variation (%) 100 United Kingdom
90
Calculations including all regions. Excluding the top region where foreign/foreign-born population is the denser.
Spain
80
90
80 Czech Rep.
Belgium
70
70 United States Canada
60 Italy Greece 50
France Sweden
Germany
Australia 50
Finland Hungary
60
Austria New Zealand
Norway
40
40 Netherlands
30 0
5
10
15
30 20 25 Foreign population (% of the total population)
Notes: Foreign-born population for Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States (indicated in blue). 1996 for Canada, 2000 for the United States. Sources: Labour Force surveys, figures provided by Eurostat; Censuses of the population (Australian Bureau of Statistics; Statistics Canada, New Zealand Statistics, US Bureau of the Census).
Chart I.9.
Cumulated percentage of the foreign and total population by regions, 2001 Netherlands United States
Australia United Kingdom
Spain
Foreigners (%) 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
50
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80 90 100 Total population (%)
Note: Population aged 15 and over except fot the United States (total population). Sources: Labour force surveys (Eurostat and Australian Bureau of Statistics); Census 2000 (US Bureau of the Census).
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
total population. A theoretical curve following the first bisector would show a uniform regional distribution of foreigners (i.e. the share of foreigners in each region matches the region’s demographic weight). Conversely, the further the curve is from the first bisector, the more dispersed the foreign population.
to be found in Spain, for instance, where Murcia, the Balearics and the Canary Islands are intermediate regions (i.e. not the most densely populated in terms of immigrants) where the percentage of foreigners is well above the national average. This can be seen on Chart I.9 as sharp changes in the slope of the curve.
In the case of the United Kingdom, France and the United States, the curve is very far from the first bisector (see Chart I.9). In particular, Inner and Outer London jointly account for almost half of the foreign population, whereas their combined demographic weight does not exceed 13%. Conversely, there is less contrast between the regional distribution of the foreign/immigrant population and that of the native population in the Netherlands but also in Germany, Australia and New Zealand. In Australia, for instance, the five most densely populated areas (around Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide) jointly account for almost 60% of the population and 77% of the immigrant population. In the United States, the immigrant population is more concentrated. Over 60% of immigrants live in the five most densely populated states (California, Texas, New York, Florida, Illinois), which only account for just over one-third of the total population. Other more atypical patterns are
Economic conditions and local manpower needs are certainly among the principal determinants of migrants’ choice of location. At the same time family and community links, as well as the geographical proximity of the country of origin, could be considered significant influences. This would partly explain, in the case of the United States, the concentration of Asians in the Hawaiian archipelago, Mexicans in California and Texas, and Cubans in Florida. The same applies to Canada, for the Asians in British Columbia and the French in Quebec, as it does to France and Spain, for the North Africans in Corsica and the South of France and in the region of Andalusia. The high concentration of immigrants in certain areas poses particular difficulties in terms of the accessibility of public services, the availability of housing and more generally the social integration of new arrivals (see Box I.5). In order to alleviate these
Box I.5. Integration in urban areas Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants The major economic and social changes that have occurred in the metropolitan areas – inner cities and suburbs – of most OECD countries since the 1950s have created new difficulties for immigrants as regards integration. In a number of OECD countries, local and national authorities are confronted with special problems caused by the concentration of immigrants in deprived neighbourhoods and labour market areas that are not sufficiently dynamic, even in periods of high growth.1 In some cases the result has been the development of ethnic enclaves. This is particularly true of North America, but the phenomenon is also becoming increasingly frequent in the European OECD countries and especially the new immigration countries (Greece, Portugal, Spain). Some specialists maintain, however, that the concentration process can help to further the economic integration of immigrants through the development of community and ethnic activities and, in the medium term, to generate a process of spatial assimilation in which immigrants move from their enclaves to more affluent urban areas. But social integration is still uncertain in this type of scheme. Uneven geographic distribution of the immigrant population is not necessarily the result of segregation. It may derive from a process of self-selection, with new arrivals preferring to be among their community and close to the places that can give them the special assistance they need (integration classes, specific social services, etc.). For instance, in 2000, more than 47% of new immigrants to Canada chose to settle in the urban community of Toronto. Central governments are tending to leave the responsibility for immigrant integration to regional and municipal authorities, but they generally provide a limited amount of financial assistance. In several OECD countries, local authorities have asked for a new division of responsibilities in the management of migration flows and for larger fund transfers from central government. 1. See Immigrants, Immigration and Cities. Exploring the Links, OECD, 1998. 51
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
problems, certain countries that receive many applications for political asylum have introduced variously coercive measures that have the effect of dispersing asylum seekers across the territory (e.g. Germany, the United Kingdom and Sweden). Nevertheless, policies such as these have a limited impact, essentially because they only concern one category of new arrivals and do not affect the foreign population already installed. Canada and Australia have recently developed more general measures to encourage new immigrants to settle in less densely populated areas where foreigners are under-represented. 2.
Immigration and population growth in OECD countries
Migration plays a significant role in the annual population growth of many OECD countries. First of all, the presence of a foreign or foreign-born population contributes to the natural increase in the population (excess of births over deaths). The higher the fertility of foreign women relative to indigenous women, the more significant this contribution is. Secondly, when net migration is positive, the population of the ho st coun try gro ws by the same amount. a)
Growth in the total and foreign populations
Chart I.10 shows the respective contributions of net migration (nationals and foreigners) and of natural increase (excess of births over deaths) to total population growth in the countries of the European Union and other OECD countries over the past three decades. In nearly all the European OECD countries migration made the major contribution to population growth during the 1990s. But this has not always been the case. In the early 1960s, natural increase was clearly the bigger contributor, notably in the countries of Southern Europe but also in the Nordic countries. During the next two decades, natural increase and net migration followed opposite trend paths, as shown in Chart I.10 for the European Union.
52
For some years now, however, several European OECD countries would have seen their total population fall, were it not for an inflow of new immigrants. This has been the case in Germany since 1986, but also in Italy since 1993 and in Sweden since 1997. Among the EU countries, France is the exception in that its rate of natural increase is substantially positive and has never fallen below 3. In that country the
contribution of births to total population growth remains higher than that of migration and has risen steadily since 1993. This can be explained by the fact that the fertility rate in France is higher than the European average (1.89 childre n per wo man 4 against 1.53 for the EU in 2000) but also, somewhat more artificially, by the large number of naturalisations granted. In 2000, the trend that had prevailed for several decades in the countries of the European Union seems to have turned around. The natural rate of increase rose significantly and, with the benefit of large immigration flows, the EU population grew by about 4 on the previous year. The other OECD countries present a different picture. In Australia, Japan, Mexico, New Zealand and the United States, but also in Poland and the Slovak Republic, the natural rate of increase contributed at least as much and generally much more to popula tion growth than net mig ration (see Chart I.11). In Turkey and New Zealand the differential was particularly wide. In the United States, despite a marked decline in the natural rate of increase in the 1960s, the fertility level remains high (2.06 children per woman in 2000) and contributes greatly to the population growth rate, which is roughly three times higher than that of the EU. Can ada appears to be a case apart, with a decline in net immigration and in fertility as from the late 1980s. It should be noted, though, that the two demographic components contribute equally to Canadian population growth, which remains buoyant (about 8 in 2000). To sum up, the long-period (1960-2000, by region and by country) and cross-sectional (2000, by country) data show that the migration component makes the larger contribution to total populatio n g ro wth in man y OECD co un tr ies. T his is particularly the case in countries where fertility levels are low (Austria, Germany, Greece, Italy and Spain). In settlement countries like Australia, Canada and the United States, which continue to receive large numbers of immigrants each year, the predominance of family-linked immigration and the younger age structure of the new arrivals have a marked effect on the natural increase rate over the medium and long terms. In net emigration countries like Mexico, Poland and Turkey, and to a le sse r e xte n t N e w Ze a lan d, na tu r al in cre a se continues to be the determinant of population growth. The same is true of the United States and a few European countries, like France and the © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Chart I.10.
Components of total population growth in selected OECD countries and in the European Union, 1960-2000 Per 1 000 inhabitants at the beginning of the year
Natural increase rate Per 1 000 20
Net migration rate
Total population growth
European Union (15 members)1
Per 1 000 25
France
20
15
15
10
10
5
5 0
0
-5
-5
-10
-10
-15 1960
65
70
75
Per 1 000 20
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
75
Germany
80
85
90
95
-15 2000 Per 1 000 20
Ireland
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
-5
-5
-10
-10
-15 1960
65
70
75
Per 1 000 20
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
75
Italy
80
85
90
95
-15 2000 Per 1 000 20
Spain
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
-5
-5
-10
-10
-15 1960
65
70
75
Per 1 000 20
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
Sweden
75
80
85
90
95
-15 2000 Per 1 000 20
United Kingdom
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
-5
-5
-10
-10
-15 1960
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
-15 2000
53
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.10.
Components of total population growth in selected OECD countries and in the European Union, 1960-2000 (cont.) Per 1 000 inhabitants at the beginning of the year Natural increase rate
Per 1 000 25
Net migration rate
Total population growth
Australia
Per 1 000 25
Canada
20
20
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
-5 1960
65
70
75
Per 1 000 25
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
Japan
75
80
85
90
95
Per 1 000 30
New Zealand
25
20
20
15
15 10
10
5
5
0 -5
0 -5 1960
-5 2000
-10 65
70
75
Per 1 000 25
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
Poland
75
80
85
90
95
-15 2000 Per 1 000 30
Switzerland
25
20
20 15
15 10
10
5
5
0 0 -5 1960
-5 65
70
80
85
90
95
2000 1960
65
70
Turkey
Per 1 000 25
75
80
85
90
95
-10 2000 Per 1 000 25
United States
20
20
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
-5 1973
54
75
78
83
88
93
1960
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
-5 2000
1. Excluding Portugal and Greece for all years and the United Kingdom from 1999 on. Source: Labour force statistics, OECD, 2001.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Chart I.11.
Natural increase and net migration rates in OECD countries, 20001 Per 1 000 inhabitants at the beginning of the year Taux de migration nette (pour 1 000) 3 Suède Suisse Grèce Autriche 2 Allemagne Portugal Danemark
Taux de migration nette (pour 1 000) 10 Espagne Luxembourg
7.5
Irlande
2.5
Australie
Pays-Bas
5
Canada
Italie Allemagne Rép. tchèque
2 Norvège
Royaume-Uni
1 France
Islande États-Unis
0 -1
0
France
0 Hongrie
Belgique
1
3
Finlande Rép. Japon slovaque 0 1 2 3 4 Taux d’accroissement naturel (pour 1 000)
Turquie
0
Pologne
-2.5
-2.5 Nouvelle-Zélande
-5 -5
0
5
10
Mexique
-5 15 20 25 Taux d’accroissement naturel (pour 1 000)
Note : Les données sur le solde migratoire sont des chiffres résiduels calculés à partir des estimations annuelles de la population et des données sur les naissances et les décès. 1. 1996 pour la Turquie ; 1998 pour le Portugal et le Royaume-Uni ; 1999 pour la Grèce, la Hongrie et l’Islande. Source : Statistiques de la population active, OCDE, 2001.
Netherlands, where the birth rate has declined less. In those last two countries, long-term settlement of immigrants and their families has helped, through foreign births, to enhance the contribution of natural increase. b)
Foreign births: a brake on demographic ageing
In a number of European OECD countries, births to foreign nationals and persons of foreign origin account for a sizeable percentage of total births. In many cases this percentage is higher than the proportion of foreigners in the total population. Foreign births contribute to the natural increase in the population and can therefore act as brake on demographic ageing. This outcome is not inevitable, however, and depends essentially on a continuing succession of migration waves. A prolonged halt to new immigration would reduce these beneficial effects considerably, given that the fertility rate of foreign women tends to converge with that of nationals. It is difficult to obtain comparable data on foreign births, as the term “foreign” may apply to the child or to the parents. If it applies to the parents, the number of foreign births will vary according to whether the criterion adopted is the nationality of © OECD 2003
both parents, of the mother or of the father. Generally, since fertility is studied in relation to women, the nationality of reference chosen is that of the mother. In Belgium, Germany, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Switzerland, foreign births are those of children having foreign nationality. In France and Sweden, foreign births are those to female foreign nationals. In Japan they are births to parents both of foreign nationality. In England and Wales they are births to women born outside the United Kingdom. Data based solely on births to foreign mothers are not a measure of the total number of births linked to the presence of the foreign population or the population of foreign origin. In general, the legislation on naturalisation, depending on how liberal it is, either accelerates or slows the process of absorption of foreigners into the national population and thus reduces or increases the number of foreign births. The proportion of foreign births is high in some OECD countries (see Chart I.12). In 2000 this was the case in Luxembourg (49%) and in Switzerlan d (22.5%). However, in the United Kingdom (England and Wales only), Austria and Germany, foreign births
55
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.12.
0
5
10
15
Foreign births in 20001
Foreign births
Foreign births
(% of total births)
(% of total births) relative to stocks of foreigners (% of total population2)
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Luxembourg
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
Portugal
Switzerland
Italy
United Kingdom3
United Kingdom4
Austria
France
Germany
Austria
France
Sweden
Sweden
Germany
Norway
Netherlands
Belgium
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Finland
Portugal
Switzerland
Italy
Norway4
Finland
Hungary
Hungary
Belgium
Japan
Japan 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
0.0
Note: For Finland, France and Sweden, foreign births are births to a foreign mother, for Japan, to foreign parents. For England and Wales and Norway, foreign births refer to those to mothers and both parents born outside the country respectively. For Canada, foreign births refer to those to foreign-born mothers who have been granted immigrant status. For all other countries, foreign births are those of children of foreign nationality. 1. 1997 for Sweden; 1998 for France; 1999 for Belgium, Finland and the Netherlands. 2. Population aged 15 and over in the case of the United Kingdom. 3. Data refer to England and Wales. 4. The share of foreign births is relative to the share of the foreign-born in the total population (aged 15 and over in the case of the United Kingdom). Sources: Data on births are from civil registers; data on population are from population registers for all countries except for France (1999 Census), the United Kingdom (Labour Force Survey), Portugal and Italy (residence permits).
accounted for no more than 10% of total births. Italy, Finland and especially Japan and Hungary all have significantly lower levels, this being largely due to the relatively small share of foreigners in the total population.
OECD countries from the late 1960s, and longer life expectancy, have led to a very marked acceleration of the population ageing process in virtually all OECD countries. However, this applies more to Europe and Japan than to North America.
In 2000, Portugal had the highest proportion of foreign births relative to the percentage of foreigners in the total population (over 2); the share was also high in Italy and in the United Kingdom. The proportion was particularly low (less than 1) in Japan, where immigration is mostly temporary, and Belgium, where Europeans account for a large share of non-naturalised immigrants.
According to demographic projections by the United Nations, the populations of the European Union and Japan are expected, between 2000 and 2050, to fall by 10% and 14% respectively, representing in all some 55 million persons (see Table I.12). For the United States the projections point to an increase in the total population, but with a rise in the proportion of elderly persons and in the dependency ratio (i.e. the number of persons aged 65 and over as a percentage of the population of working age, 20-64). These projected developments have serious implications for the sustainability of pension and benefit systems and for labour market equilibrium (see Part II).
c)
56
Ageing populations and migration
The combination of the demographic effects of the baby booms that marked the immediate postwar period, the fall in fertility rates that began in
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.12.
Change in total population in OECD countries, 1950, 2000 and 2050 EU 15
United States
Japan
OECD countries1
83 600 127 000 109 200
683 300 1 125 300 1 275 300
8.1 20.3 43.1
13.1 21.0 40.8
Thousands
Total population 1950 2000 2050
296 400 377 200 340 300
157 800 283 200 397 000 Percentages
Dependency 1950 2000 2050
ratio2 15.5 27.9 55.7
13.3 15.6 26.8
1. The dependency ratio is calculated without taking into account figures for Greece, Iceland, Luxembourg, Mexico, Switzerland and Turkey. 2. Population aged 65 and over as a percentage of active age population (20-64). Sources: Total population: World Population prospects: the 2000 revision, United Nations; dependency ratio: OECD.
A number of research projects run by the OECD have considered the economic and fiscal impact of coming demographic trends (OECD 2001, 2000, 1998, Visco 2001). The research generally concludes that decisions are required over the medium and long terms to tackle the populatio n challenge and preserve balance in the social protection systems, which are linked with determination of the length of working life, the level of contributions and benefits and also with productivity gains. The studies also
show that it is not possible to use immigration to alleviate the effects of population ageing. Quite apart from the unrealistic increases in entry flows this would imply (see United Nations 2000), experience has shown i) that it is impossible to fully control the level of net migration and the age structure of inflows and outflows; ii) that the higher fertility attributed to foreign women declines very rapidly with the length of stay; 5 and iii) that the foreign population is also ageing (see Box I.6).
Box I.6. Immigrants age too… Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants Reliance on temporary work-related immigration, a solution much advocated in the 1960s, has proved to be counter-productive. Not only did immigrants fail to return to their home countries when economic conditions deteriorated after the oil shocks of the 1970s, but there are also many who, after 30 years of work abroad, will not go back for their retirement. Today the presence of foreign retirees is still limited, but it is likely to expand greatly in the coming decades, especially in countries that had massive recourse to foreign labour in the 1960s and 1970s (Belgium, France, Germany, Switzerland). The German Ministry of the Interior has estimated that in 2010 there will be nearly 1.3 million foreign retirees in Germany and about 2.8 million in 2030. This poses major problems of integration for which the host societies are as yet ill prepared. Apart from the very specific case of hostels for immigrant workers (in France more than one-quarter of the places available in these hostels are occupied by workers aged 56 and over), the special housing facilities and the persons working in the senior citizen sector are not necessarily ready to cope with an increasing number of elderly immigrants. The difficulties are not only institutional, and immigrants themselves are not always aware of the problems they will have to face when they reach retirement age. Many of them have limited financial resources and are not homeowners. The idea that members of the family will take care of them when they are old, as is generally the custom in the country of origin, is in many cases a false one, given that host society regulations, notably where housing is concerned, do not permit this traditional form of inter-generational assistance. In the case of wives of immigrant workers of this generation there is even more cause for concern, since they are particularly exposed to the risk of isolation and most of them have hardly any money because they have never been in gainful employment. 57
© OECD 2003
Trends in International Migration
Even if it cannot be expected to have more than a marginal impact on the predicted imbalances in age structure, immigration can for a while help to prevent population decline. But for this to happen, a number of OECD countries will have to introduce major changes in their migration policy so that it will, among other things, contribute to labour market adjustment and equilibrium of demographic dynamics.
B.
IMMIGRANTS AND THE LABOUR MARKET
The second half of 2001 was marked by a turnaround in activity in the majority of OECD countries, ending a period of strong growth that had begun in the first half of the 1990s. In contrast with what had been observed during the previous expansionary phase, and particularly in a number of European OECD countries, economic growth was accompanied during the second half of the 1990s by a sharp increase in job creation. Between 1993 and 2000, more than 40 million jobs were created in the OECD member countries as a whole, while the average rate of unemployment fell by more than 1.5 points from 7.9 to 6.3% over the entire period. That trend was even more noticeable in the European Union, where the unemployment rate fell by over 27% between 1993 and 2001. Because of the economic slowdown, employment growth was however appreciably slower in 2001, reaching just 0.4% in the OECD area. In a number of OECD countries, however, labour markets are still affected by major imbalances involving, in particular, a high level of structural unemployment, persisting long-term unemployment and the scale of youth unemployment. Even, moreover, in countries where significant progress has been made in recent years, there are still large pockets of nonactivity. Employment rates among elderly workers and the unskilled, in particular, are often still low, while in several OECD countries women are continuing to experience difficulty in entering the labour market (see Employment Outlook, OECD, 2002), as are foreign and immigrant workers. Even so, under the combined effect of the upturn in immigration flows for employment purposes and demographic forces, immigrants are accounting for a growing share of the total labour force. 1.
58
The contribution of foreigners to the labour force is increasing
Over the last five years, the number of foreign and immigrant workers has increased in the majority
of OECD countries, and especially in the countries of southern Europe, Japan and Korea, as well as in certain Nordic countries (see Table I.13). Only in Germany and Switzerland did the foreign labour force diminish over the period in question. In 2000, the number of foreign-born members of the labour force was particularly large in the United States (some 17.4 million) and, to a lesser extent, in Canada (2.8 million in 1996) and Australia (2.4 million). In Germany, there are nearly 3.4 million foreign workers, compared to 1.6 million in France and 1.2 million in the United Kingdom. Classified accordin g to the pro po rtion of foreigners in the total labour force, four groups of countries, of comparable size, could be distinguished in 2000. The first group was made up of countries in which the proportion exceeded 10%, and comprised Luxembourg, the United States, Australia, Canada and Switzerland. The second group consisted mainly of former European immigration countries such as Austria, Germany, Belgium, France, the United Kingdom and Sweden. In these countries, foreign labour accounted for between 4 and 10% of the labour force. A third group of countries, where foreign workers accounted for between 3 and 4% of the labour force, was made up mainly of countries where immigration was more recent and was rising steeply; these included Greece, Ireland, Italy and Norway, while the Netherlands could also be put in this group. In a final group of countries, foreign workers were particularly few in number (less than 3% of the labour force). This group included Japan and Korea, and also Spain, Portugal, Hungary, the Czech Republic, the Slovak Republic, Denmark and Finland. Despite these differences in level, the share of foreign workers has grown over the last five years in all the OECD countries, with the exception of Germany, France, the Netherlands and Switzerland. On the whole, this classification mirrors the share of foreigners in the total population, with a few differences due to the relative importance of the family component in migration flows across countries. Allowance has, however, to be made for temporary immigrat io n fo r e mplo y me n t pu rpo se s, wh ich va rie s significantly across countries and is tending to increase more rapidly than permanent immigration by foreign workers (see above). Assessments differ markedly, moreover, in a number of countries, especially the countries of southern and central Europe, according to the statistical sources used (work permits, employment surveys or population census). © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.13.
Foreign or foreign-born labour force in selected OECD countries, 1995 and 2000 Thousands and percentages Foreign labour force Thousands
% of total labour force Source data
Austria Belgium Czech Republic Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Hungary Ireland Italy Japan1 Korea Luxembourg2 Netherlands Norway Portugal Slovak Republic Spain Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom
1995
2000
1995
2000
366 327 .. 54 18 1 566 3 505 71 21 42 100 88 52 65 281 59 21 4 121 186 729 1 011
377 366 28 78 34 1 571 3 429 163 30 60 246 155 123 77 298 75 104 4 227 205 717 1 220
9.7 7.9 .. 2.0 0.8 6.3 9.1 1.7 0.5 3.0 0.5 0.1 0.3 39.1 3.9 2.7 0.5 0.2 0.8 4.2 18.6 3.6
9.8 8.4 0.5 2.8 1.3 6.1 8.8 3.8 0.7 3.5 1.1 0.2 0.6 42.0 3.7 3.2 2.2 0.2 1.4 4.8 18.3 4.2
LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS WP LFS LFS WP R LFS LFS LFS LFS WP LFS LFS WP LFS
Foreign-born labour force Thousands
% of total labour force Source data
Australia Canada (1996) United States
1995
2000
1995
2000
2 139 2 839 14 083
2 365 .. 17 384
23.9 19.2 10.8
24.5 .. 12.4
LFS C LFS
Note:
Data based on Labour force surveys cover labour force aged 15 to 64 with the exception of Australia (labour force aged 15 and over). Data from other sources cover the labour force aged 15 and over. 1. Foreign residents with permission for employment. Excluding permanent and long-term residents whose activity is not restricted. Overstayers (most of whom are believed to work illegally) are not included either. 2. Resident workers (excluding cross-border workers). Sources: C: Census; E: Estimates by the National Statistical Institute; LFS: Labour force survey; R: Population register or register of foreigners; WP: Work permits.
Regularisation operations (see below Part I.D) reflect, a posteriori, the extent of illegal employment of foreigners. They also emphasise the scale of the phenomenon in certain OECD countries. While it is, by definition, impossible to know the number of undocumented foreign workers, it is probable that taking them into account would substantially alter the above estimates. In Japan, for example, the number of foreign workers varies in the ratio of one to five, depending on whether or not the number of foreigners who remain in Japan after their residence permits have run out are taken into account. In the case of the United States, and according to the latest census
© OECD 2003
figures, it is estimated that there are some 8.5 million foreign-born persons in an illegal situation. 2.
Participation rates of foreigners by gender and place of birth: persistent imbalances
D e s pi t e t h e re ce n t im pr o ve me n t in t h e employment situation in the majority of OECD countries, there are still big differences between nationals and immigrants when it comes to labour market integration. The figures for 2000-2001 confirm the finding already contained in the previous two editions of the annual report Trends in International
59
Trends in International Migration
foreign or immigrant women was under 50% in Belgium, Australia, France and the Netherlands, illustrating how difficult it is for foreign women to enter the labour market in these countries. Even lower rates are to be found among certain communities where female participation rates are also low in the country of origin, this being the case of the Turkish and North African communities and of people from the Middle East and Afghanistan.
Migration, namely that foreigners or immigrants generally have lower participation rates than nationals, and that there are big differences in this respect between men and women (see Table I.14) and depending on the nationalities in question. The participation rates of foreign women are systematically lower than those of men, the genderbased disparity even exceeding 30 points in some host countries, examples being Italy, Greece and Be lgium. The abo ve observation u su ally also applies in the case of nationals, but in some countries the gap between male and female participation rates is at least twice as big for immigrants as it is for nationals. In France, for example, the male participation rate for nationals is 12 points higher than for women, whereas the gap is 28 points where foreigners are concerned. In Finland, the differences by gender are even more marked, reaching 4.9 and 23%, respectively, for nationals and foreigners. Similar large gaps are to be found in Denmark and the United States. In 2000-2001, the participation rate for
Table I.14.
In a number of OECD countries, foreign or immigrant men have higher participation rates than nationals, this being true in particular in host countries where employment-related migration predominates, as in the countries of southern Europe (Italy, Greece) and Hungary. In the Netherlands, on the contrary, and in the countries of northern Europe (notably Sweden and Denmark) which traditionally receive a lot of refugees, foreigners have appreciably lower participation rates than natives. Another finding is that the participation rates of foreign-born men are higher than those of nationals in the United
Participation rate and unemployment rate of nationals and foreigners by sex in selected OECD countries, 2000-2001 average Participation rate Men
Austria Belgium Czech Republic Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Hungary (2001) Ireland Italy Luxembourg Netherlands Norway Portugal Slovak Republic Spain Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom Australia1 Canada (1996)1 United States1
60
Unemployment rate Women
Men
Nationals
Foreigners
Nationals
Foreigners
78.9 73.3 78.7 84.1 79.4 75.1 78.9 76.2 67.6 79.2 73.6 74.0 84.9 84.6 79.0 76.9 77.3 78.0 89.2 83.1 75.0 73.8 80.7
85.1 72.4 87.8 71.2 83.1 76.6 77.6 89.2 77.8 77.0 87.7 79.7 69.5 82.1 81.5 79.4 85.4 63.1 89.5 75.6 67.0 68.4 85.6
62.4 57.0 63.3 76.2 74.6 63.3 64.7 49.0 52.2 55.9 46.6 47.7 67.2 76.8 64.0 63.2 50.9 74.2 73.3 68.4 59.1 60.2 71.4
63.3 41.0 56.3 53.0 60.2 48.6 50.7 56.0 51.8 56.2 50.7 57.7 49.0 67.2 65.3 51.8 59.1 60.3 68.6 55.8 48.2 52.9 61.7
Nationals
3.9 4.6 7.1 3.6 10.0 7.1 7.2 7.2 6.4 4.1 8.0 1.2 1.9 3.7 3.1 19.8 9.3 5.5 1.3 5.5 6.7 10.3 4.9
Women Foreigners
8.4 14.2 7.6 12.2 24.2 17.1 13.4 7.6 .. 5.1 7.4 2.5 4.7 5.3 8.4 26.2 12.9 16.1 4.3 9.8 6.6 9.9 4.4
Nationals
3.9 7.0 10.1 4.9 11.2 10.7 7.8 16.2 4.9 3.8 13.9 1.7 2.9 3.4 5.1 18.6 19.8 4.6 2.6 4.4 5.8 9.5 4.1
Foreigners
8.6 16.5 12.9 7.2 29.9 23.9 11.7 17.6 5.5 6.2 21.3 3.8 7.0 4.5 9.6 17.0 17.2 13.0 6.4 7.9 6.9 11.6 5.6
Note: Data cover the labour force aged 15 to 64 with the exception of Australia and Canada (15 and over). 1. The data refer to the native and foreign-born populations. Sources: Labour force surveys, figures supplied by Eurostat (second quarter 2000 and 2001) and by Australian Bureau of Statistics (August 2000 and August 2001); 1996 Census, Statistics Canada; Current Population Survey March Supplement (2000 and 2001), US Bureau of the Census.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
States, in contrast with the situation in Australia and Canada. The participation rate usually depends on individual characteristics such as age, level of education, professional experience and family structure. Where foreigners are concerned, it also depends on the length of stay, it being apparent that people who have been resident in a host country for more than 10 years are better integrated in the labour market than those who immigrated more recently. Some 40% of foreigners living in the United Kingdom for between one and 10 years are not active, whereas the proportion falls to under 30% for those who have been resident for more than 10 years. For France, the percentages are 54 and 67%, respectively. In the United States, the participation rate rises from 68.8 to 76.8% depending on whether people have been there for more or less than 10 years. However, these figures mask differing situations in the sense that in the United States, and to a lesser extent in France, virtually all of the variations observed are attributable to the increase in the female participation rate, which is not the case in the United Kingdom. These findings are confirmed by a multivariate analysis (see the annex at the end of Part I), which incorporates possible changes in the individual characteristics of the people who make up each of the groups considered (for example, people resident for at least one year but less than 10, as opposed to those who have been resident for more than 10 years). 3.
Sectoral breakdown and trends in the employment of foreigners.
Char t I.13 com pa res th e tre nd in fo re ign employment and total employment since the start of the economic upturn (first half of the 1990s). In the former European immigration countries (Belgium, France, Germany, Netherlands, United Kingdom), employment growth can be seen, initially, to have mainly benefited nationals. After between 4 and 6 years, however, foreign employment increases sharply, despite the strains that have by then appeared on the labour market, and the acceleration in growth due in particular to the development of ne w te chn ologie s. T he same so rt o f catch-u p phenomenon is also apparent in Australia, even if the said process would not appear to be totally confirmed in that country at the end of the period in question. © OECD 2003
In the ne w immigration cou ntrie s such as Ireland, Italy, Portugal and Spain, but also the United States, the trend is very different in the sense that foreign employment has been on an upward slope since the beginning of the economic upturn. In these countries, foreign employment is growing under the impetus of new entries of foreign workers and not, as in the previously mentioned countries, as a result of former immigrants re-entering the labour market. In a detailed analysis in the Employment Outlook (OECD, 2001), it was concluded that foreign employment is more sensitive to cyclical fluctuations. It is true that immigrants are often harder hit by unemployment during periods of recession because of their individual characteristics (skills, professional experience, length of stay), their concentration in the sectors most exposed to the effects of the economic situation (construction and civil engineering, hotels and catering) and also, in some cases, because of certain forms of discrimination. During expansionary phases, mobilising the foreign labour force makes it possible to meet the increase in demand for labour and helps to reallocate native labour into sectors that are more dynamic and more highly thought of socially. This phenomenon is an example of the theory of labour market segmentation, which has it that activities low down on the social scale are very unattractive and reveal chronic labour shortages which foreign workers are willing to make good. In countries where the geographic and sectoral mobility of the native population is limited, foreign labour can also give added flexibility to the labour market and thereby facilitate its development. Dissemination of foreign jobs in the service sector… Table I.15 gives an overall view of the sectoral breakdown of foreign labour in the OECD countries in 2000-2001. It is noticeable, in particular, that foreigners are over-represented in certain sectors, meaning that they account for a larger proportion of employment in those sectors than they do in the total labour force. In the majority of OECD countries, that over-representation occurs in secondary sector activities. In Germany, Japan and Italy, for example, more than one-quarter of foreign employment is concentrated in mining and manufacturing. Foreigners are also over-represented in the construction sector in Austria, Belgium, France and the countries of southern Europe, and in Australia and the United States as well.
61
Trends in International Migration
62
Chart I.13.
Changes in foreign and total employment during economic recoveries in selected OECD countries Index: Trough = 1001, 2 Foreign employment
Ireland
370
Portugal
370
340 310 280 250 220 190 160 130 100 70 2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Belgium
150
Italy
370
340 310 280 250 220 190 160 130 100 70 1994 1
Total employment
340 310 280 250 220 190 160 130 100 70 1995 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Netherlands
150
340 310 280 250 220 190 160 130 100 70 1995 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
United Kingdom
150
1994 1
140
140
140
130
130
130
130
120
120
120
120
110
110
110
110
100
100
100
100
90 1994 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Germany
120
90 1993 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
France
120
© OECD 2003
115
110
110
110
105
105
105
100
100
100
95
95
95
90
90 1994 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Australia
120
115
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
4
5
6
7
8
9
7
8
9
United States
1992 1
2
3
4
5
1990 1
1.
2
3
4
5
6
Data for Australia and the United States refer to the foreign-born population. 2. The troughs in activity are determined by estimations of the business cycle produced by the OECD (Economic Research Cycle Institute in the case of Australia). In the case of Ireland, Netherlands, Portugal and Spain, the troughs in activity correspond to the greatest disparity between actual and potential GDP, estimated by the OECD. Sources: Labour force surveys, figures provided by Eurostat, the Australian Bureau of Statistics and the US Bureau of the Census.
90 1994 1
3
90 1992 1
115
2
150
140
90
Spain
370
6
7
8
9
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.15. Employment of foreigners by sectors, 2000-2001 average Percentages of total foreign employment Mining, Wholesale Agriculture Manufacturing Construction and and fishing and Energy retail trade
Hotels and restaurants
Austria Belgium Czech Republic Denmark France Germany Greece Ireland Italy Japan Luxembourg Netherlands Norway Spain Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom
1.3 1.2 – – 3.1 1.5 2.8 – 4.5 0.4 0.8 3.8 – 7.8 – 1.2 –
26.5 23.0 24.9 16.2 18.0 32.8 17.5 17.6 28.9 60.0 10.0 22.3 17.8 10.4 23.3 22.5 13.2
12.2 8.5 11.3 – 17.4 9.2 27.1 8.1 11.1 2.2 15.9 4.0 5.6 13.0 – 9.9 4.4
12.9 13.8 27.3 11.9 11.4 12.3 11.0 9.3 9.7 8.3 14.1 13.1 13.3 11.7 9.2 15.5 11.5
10.7 8.3 5.2 9.5 7.4 10.6 9.5 11.9 7.9
Australia2 Canada2 United States2
2.1 2.4 3.5
17.9 19.6 18.0
7.8 5.0 7.7
16.5 24.1 22.0
Education
Health and other Households community services
Admin. and ETO
Other services
8.9 7.2 6.4 15.9 7.4 6.0 9.9
2.2 3.6 – 5.9 3.0 2.5 – 6.4 2.8 .. 2.4 3.6 8.0 4.1 9.6 5.2 7.9
6.1 6.9 – 18.5 4.8 6.8 – 8.9 4.6 .. 6.4 9.4 20.0 1.7 14.8 11.6 13.9
– 1.0 – – 6.5 0.5 18.1 – 10.8 .. 3.6 .. – 15.7 – 1.2 1.5
4.2 9.0 – – 2.5 2.2 – – 2.4 .. 9.5 2.6 2.9 – – 2.3 4.1
23.3 24.7 19.7 30.1 25.8 21.4 10.3 32.1 17.4 29.1 28.3 34.0 24.2 19.1 30.6 24.8 33.2
6.0
6.2
1
3
1
5.7
10.0 24.6 10.0
3.2 .. 1.9
3.3 3.8 2.0
26.9 20.4 29.3
1
Note:
The numbers in bold indicate the sectors where foreigners are over-represented (i.e., the share of foreign employment in that sector is higher than the share of foreign employment in total employment). The sign “–” indicates that the figure calculated was not statistically significant. 1. The “Hotels and restaurants” category is included in the “Wholesale and retail trade” category. 2. The data refer to the foreign-born population. 3. The “Education” category is included in the “Health and other community services” category. Sources: Labour force surveys, figures supplied by Eurostat and by the Australian Bureau of Statistics; Ministry of Labour (Japan); 1996 Census, Statistics Canada; Current Population Survey March Supplements, US Bureau of the Census.
Th e diss e min a t io n an d c o n ce n tr a ti o n o f foreigners in the services is also very obvious. In Canada and the United States, foreigners employed in retailing account, respectively, for 24 and 22% of all foreign jobs. In Spain, some 16% of foreign jobs are in the hotel and catering trade and almost as many in services to households. In Denmark and Norway, 18.5 and 20% of employed foreigners work in the health sector, while in Sweden nearly 10% of foreigners are employed in education. The lowest percentage of foreigners is usually to be found in public administration owing to regulations that reserve the majority of jobs for nationals. With the exception of Spain and, to a lesser extent, the Netherlands and the United States, relatively few foreigners work in agriculture. However, that observation has to be qualified because the survey data on which these estimates are based are not always well adapted to reflecting the seasonal activities © OECD 2003
and temporary migration that predominate in the agricultural sector. … that does not, however, automatically mean an improvement in job quality The fact that the breakdown of foreign and native employment is becoming more similar indicates that the process of labour market entry for foreigners is on the increase. In the European OECD countries, for example, with the arrival on the labour market of young, second-generation immigrants who usually have a higher level of education than that of their parents, labour supply among young foreigners is gradually moving towards jobs matching the “national profile”, i.e., which are not of the same nature as those filled by first-generation immigrants. This optimistic finding is, however, partly offset by an analysis of the characteristics of the jobs filled
63
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.14.
Atypical employment by nationality in selected European OECD countries, 2001 Percentage of total employment according to nationality Foreigners
% 60
Proportion of temporary jobs
Nationals
Proportion of part time jobs
% 35 30
50
10
25
40
Proportion of secondary jobs
% 12
8
20 30
6 15
AT: Australia BE: Belgium CH: Switzerland
0
DE: Germany DK: Denmark ES: Spain
FR: France IT: Italy LU: Luxembourg
NL: Netherlands NO: Norway PT: Portugal
IT
0 D K N O D E FR SE
2
IT AT ES
IT AT
ES PT SE N L D K FR U K N O D E C H BE
0
5
N L U K C H BE LU
10
D K FR
4
10
N O C H SE N L U K AT BE D E ES
20
SE: Sweden UK: United Kingdom
Sources: Labour force surveys (2nd quarter 2001), figures provided by Eurostat.
by foreigners. The 2001 edition of the Employment Outlook (OECD, 2001) showed, for example, that foreign employment is on the whole more concentrated than native employment in the lowest sociooccupational categories (blue-collar jobs). This is particularly striking in Austria, France and Japan. The jo bs br e a kdo w n i s re l at iv e ly s pe ak in g m o re balan ced, h o wev er, in Can ada a nd Au str alia, whereas in the United Kingdom there are relatively more white-collar workers in the employed foreign labour force than in total employment.
64
Chart I.14, which shows the share of “atypical” jobs by nationality in a number of OECD countries, partly confirms the specificity of foreign employment. In all the countries considered, the probability of being in a temporary job is appreciably greater for foreigners than for nationals, the gap being all the greater the more widespread temporary work is in the country in question. It is at its widest in Spain, Portugal and the Netherlands. In some countries, however, this observation is influenced by the preponderance of traineeships for young, first-time labour market entrants, this being particularly true in Germany, Switzerland and, to a lesser extent, the United Kingdom. In most of the countries considered,
a relatively larger proportion of foreigners employed part time say that they want to work full time. In contrast with what has just been said as regards temporary jobs, foreign workers do not appear to be employed part time to a disproportionate degree. As far as having a secondary activity is concerned, it is apparent that relatively speaking more foreigners are found to have at least two jobs, but the differences remain fairly small by comparison with the total employed labour force. France is the exception in this respect in that a significantly smaller proportion of foreigners have second jobs in that country. Self-employed foreign workers In a number of OECD countries, setting up a company or building up an individual activity are the most usual ways for foreign workers to enter the labour market. Because very few foreign workers are able to be self-employed in agriculture – unlike nationals – the arguments that follow do not take agricultural activities into account. Self-employed foreign workers are relatively numerous in the Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Spain, Ireland, the United Kingdom and the United States (see Table I.16). In other member coun© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.16.
Self employed by nationality, 2001 Thousands and percentages
Stock of foreign self-employment (Thousands)
Austria Belgium Czech Republic Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Hungary (2000) Ireland Italy Luxembourg Netherlands Norway Portugal Spain Sweden Switzerland (2000) United Kingdom United States1
24.6 51.7 7.3 7.1 3.0 119.3 285.5 15.5 3.8 11.6 42.5 4.8 32.1 3.7 14.9 52.7 16.1 76.2 144.6 1 707.2
Foreign self-employment as a % of total self-employment
5.2 8.7 1.0 3.2 1.0 4.7 7.4 1.1 0.7 4.1 0.7 36.4 3.6 2.3 1.4 1.8 3.9 12.4 4.7 13.5
Foreign self-employment as a % of total self-employment in non-agricultural activities
7.8 9.1 1.1 3.1 1.5 5.8 8.2 1.6 0.7 5.3 0.8 41.2 3.8 3.2 1.9 2.2 4.4 14.5 4.9 14.3
% of foreign self-employment in non-agricultural activities relative to their share in total labour force
0.8 1.1 1.8 1.2 1.1 0.9 0.9 0.4 1.0 1.2 0.7 0.9 1.0 1.0 0.9 1.2 0.9 0.8 1.1 1.2
1. The data refer to the foreign-born population. Sources: Labour force surveys (2nd quarter 2001), figures supplied by Eurostat; Current Population Survey March Supplement, US Bureau of the Census.
tries, on the other hand, foreigners are under-represented in non-salaried employment, this being the case in Greece, Austria, Italy and Switzerland. That being said, the actual situation differs a great deal from one country to another. One of the classic arguments used in economic theory to explain the relatively large numbers of foreign entrepreneurs is based on the selective nature of migration, the suggestion being that immigrants are more dynamic and less reluctant to take risks than natives. There is, however, little available empirical evidence to confirm this argument in those terms. Another argument, which is in fact the converse of the one above, emphasises the case of foreigners who have specific difficulties in securing salaried jobs, though not on account of their intrinsic qualities. The said difficulties can be attributable to discrimination or result from inadequate access to information or to share capital. In such cases, foreigners are relatively more inclined than nationals to create their own jobs. The development of economic activities aimed specifically at immigrants’ communities of origin (ethnic businesses) is a third explanation for the relative magnitude of non-salaried activities among foreign workers. Such activities can include the © OECD 2003
provision of traditional or specific services, notably in the field of health, education and the hotel/caterin g t ra de, o r th e y can inv o lve str en g th en in g merchandise trade with countries of origin. The case of the United States and the United Kingdom is often quoted, but mention may also be made of Germany and Luxembourg where more than 30% of foreign entrepreneurs are in the hotel and catering sector. Community-type activities often extend beyond the somewhat restricted framework of the ethnic community and sometimes even foster integration in the host society. The Italian, Turkish, Indian and Asian culinary specialities that are now an integral part of our eating habits were, for example, largely introduced by immigrants. Much the same is true as regards traditional oriental medicines and African and Latin American music. In contrast, the complexity of the legislation in force in host countries, coupled with the difficulty of obtaining credit, can sometimes curb the propensity of foreigners to set up companies. Lastly, some of the professions can be hard for foreigners to enter because of the institutional provisions involved (certification procedures, for example, in the medical professions) or the specificity of the knowledge required (legal professions).
65
Employment in education, IT and health professions according to citizenship in selected OECD countries, 2001 Thousands and percentages Austria
Belgium
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Norway
Switzerland
United Kingdom
United States
Teachers, college and university1
Total Foreigners
25.3 –
16.5 2.4
97.5 5.1
110.7 8.7
78.9 –
19.4 –
16.7 1.6
8.7 –
307.7 34.7
1 241.9 242.5
Teachers, except college and university2
Total Foreigners
116.0 2.1
243.5 6.1
677.1 16.3
985.6 22.5
993.7 3.1
323.5 4.3
30.5 –
156.6 19.8
929.2 37.9
5 824.1 344.8
3.0
3.3
2.8
2.8
0.3
1.6
4.3
13.0
5.9
8.3
Percentage of foreign teachers Information and Technology professionals (IT)3
Total Foreigners
17.3 4.1
68.9 4.0
316.9 16.3
355.6 16.1
16.9 –
146.7 5.2
43.0 2.2
138.4 27.0
498.7 36.8
3 124.8 587.5
Other Information and Technology specialists4
Total Foreigners
59.2 2.3
17.5 –
190.6 5.0
379.9 25.5
261.1 –
147.1 3.1
20.5 –
21.1 3.7
278.5 13.2
393.3 57.1
8.3
6.0
4.2
5.7
0.4
2.8
4.3
19.3
6.4
18.3
Percentage of Information and Technology foreign specialists Health professionals5 (except nursing)
Total Foreigners
41.7 –
60.7 4.4
310.5 6.8
458.9 13.0
281.9 3.7
65.3 –
23.4 2.4
61.3 10.0
238.6 30.9
1 364.4 257.5
Other health professionals6
Total Foreigners
133.4 9.6
175.7 5.0
622.3 8.9
1 136.2 57.5
508.4 4.4
403.7 5.6
97.6 4.5
233.0 38.5
934.9 60.4
7 448.6 907.3
6.3
4.0
1.7
4.4
1.0
1.4
5.7
16.5
7.8
13.2
Percentage of foreign health professionals
Note: The sign – indicates that the figure calculated was not statistically reliable. 1. Category 231, ISCO-88. 2. Categories 232 to 235, ISCO-88. 3. Category 213, ISCO-88. 4. Categories 312 and 313, ISCO-88. 5. Category 222, ISCO-88. 6. Categories 223 (nursing and midwtfery professionals), 322 and 323, ISCO-88. Sources: Labour force surveys (2nd quarter), figures supplied by Eurostat; Current Population Survey March Supplement, US Bureau of the Census.
Trends in International Migration
66
Table I.17.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Some OECD member countries have specific immigration programmes to attract foreign investors, but these usually involve limited numbers because of the scale of the financial guarantees required. In 2000, for example, Canada received 1 390 foreign investors, each worth at least C$ 800 000, plus a little over 1 600 entrepreneurs. In the case of Australia, nearly 7 250 people, each with at least A$250 000 to invest, entered the country in 2000-2001 in the Business Skills category. Foreign specialists increasingly sought after Recent strains on the labour market, or strains that are anticipated because of future population trends, have prompted several OECD member countries to relax their policies regarding the recruitment of foreign, and especially skilled workers (see Part II of this report). The said trends more especially concern jobs in the information technology and communications sector, as well as in health and education. Several countries have introduced programmes aimed at attracting computer scientists (Germany), doctors (United Kingdom) and foreign university professors (United States). Sometimes these programmes also target people with intermediate-level qualifications, such computer and electro nic techn icians, nur se s o r secon dary le vel teachers. Table I.17 shows the number of foreigners in the health, education and computer science professions in 2001 in selected OECD countries. It shows that the numbers recorded are not necessarily in the professions most sought after in the present economic situation. With the exception of the United States, no more than a few dozen computer, health and education specialists have been recruited in absolute terms, but in some cases they do account for a far from negligible share of total employment in the professions considered. This is the case as regards health workers in Switzerland and the United Kingdom in particular. Also of interest is the fact that, in France, foreign employment concerns university professors just as much as computer engineers. In Germany, foreign employment concerns health professionals (notably nurses and midwives) more than computer specialists. In the United Kingdom, there are more foreign teachers in secondary level education than there are doctors or nurses, while in the United States there are approximately twice as many foreign specialists in the health sector as there are in computer sciences. © OECD 2003
4.
Foreigners are more vulnerable to unemployment than nationals
There are a great many reasons why foreigners are on the whole more vulnerable to unemployment than nationals. In almost all European OECD countries, the share of foreign or immigrant workers in the total number of jobless is larger than their share in the labour force (see Chart I.15). The latter chart shows that it was in Sweden that the ratio was highest over the period 2000-2001, but it was also high in Finland, Denmark, Belgium, the Netherlands, as well as in Portugal and France. In each of these countries, the proportion of foreigners amongst the jobless was at least twice what it was in the labour force. Between 1999-2000 and 2000-2001, the relative share of foreigners in unemployment rose very sharply in Italy and appreciably in Sweden, Spain and France. In the Netherlands, the United States, Switzerland and Portugal, on the other hand, it fell. One way of assessing the scale of the effort needed to offset the specific problems foreigners or immigrants face on OECD country labour markets is to calculate the number of jobs it would theoretically be necessary to create to bring the foreign unemployment rate into line with that of nationals, assuming no change in the latter. This would have the effect of bringing the ratio shown in Chart I.15 down to a value equal to 1 for each of the countries considered. The results for 2001 are shown in Table I.18. What emerges is that, even in countries where foreigners are hard hit by unemployment, such as Belgium, Finland, Sweden and France, the theoretical number of jobs to be created is in fact relatively small. In the Netherlands, where the unemployment differential between foreigners and nationals is big, the overrepresentation of foreigners among the jobless would in fact be eliminated by creating 6 500 jobs for foreigners, which represents barely 0.1% of the labour force. Even in France and Belgium, where the situation may seem problematic, the objective is no doubt within reach. In France, more than 800 000 jobs were created between 1998 and 2000 (as against 160 000 in Belgium), but in theory the creation of some 170 000 jobs for foreign workers (32 000 in Belgium) would suffice to bring foreign unemployment down to a level comparable to that among nationals. Achieving this objective in the medium term nevertheless means thinking about strengthening active measures in favour of employment, developing specific measures and also stepping up the campaign against discrimination.
67
Trends in International Migration
Chart I.15.
Proportion of foreigners in total unemployment related to their proportion in the labour force 2000-2001 average
3.0
3.0
2.5
2.5
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.5
1.0
1.0
0.5
0.5
Sw
ed
en
d
k
an nl
Fi
D
en
m
iu lg
Be
ar
m
s
l
nd
N
et
he
rla
e
ga tu
nc
Po r
nd
Fr a
er itz
Sw
ni
te
la
tri
a
m do
ng Ki d
Au s
an y
g
m er G
xe
m
bo
ur
nd
ay
la
w
ly Ita
or
Ire Lu
U
ak
N
n ai
C
ov Sl
ze
R
ep
ch ubl ic R ep ub lic
e ec
Sp
re G
tra
Au s
a
at
ad d
St
an C
te ni U
lia
0 es
0
Note: Labour force aged 15 to 64 years. Foreign-born population for Australia, Canada and the United States. August 1999 for Australia; 1996 for Canada; 2001 for Hungary. Sources: Labour force surveys (Eurostat, Australian Bureau of Statistics and US Bureau of the Census); 1996 Census (Statistics Canada).
Table I.18. Theoretical calculation of the number of jobs to be created to absorb the discrepancy between national and foreign unemployment rates in selected OECD countries, 2001 Number of jobs to be created for the unemployment rate of foreigners to equal the one for nationals (Thousands)
Austria Belgium Finland France Germany Netherlands Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom United States
17.5 31.7 4.9 167.9 183.7 6.5 19.4 23.1 44.9 46.9
Number of jobs to be created as a % of total labour force
0.5 0.7 0.2 0.7 0.5 0.1 0.5 0.6 0.2 0.03
Sources: Labour force surveys (Eurostat); Current Population Survey March Supplement, US Bureau of the Census.
68
Unemployment among foreign women (see Table I.14) is usually higher than for men, except in Germany, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, the Slovak Republic and the United Kingdom. The differential is especially wide in Greece and Italy and, to a lesser extent, France. The differential between the
rate of unemployment among nationals and among fo reig ne rs a lso ten ds to be mo re ma rke d for women than for men. Foreign women are therefore both less active participants on the labour market and distinctly more vulnerable to unemployment in almost all the OECD countries (see Box I.7). This
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Box I.7. Young foreigners and the labour market Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants For young foreigners, labour market integration is extremely problematic in a number of OECD countries, and particularly the European OECD countries. Chart I.16 shows, in fact, that unemployment among young people is systematically higher than for the population as a whole (15-64), the exception being Germany because of the scale of its apprenticeship system. It also seems that young foreigners have a lot more difficulty entering the labour market than do young nationals, though this finding does not apply in Italy, Norway and the United States and needs to be qualified in the United Kingdom and Spain. In some OECD countries, such as Ireland, Luxembourg and the Netherlands, unemployment is low overall, with fewer than 6% of young foreign members of the labour force being in search of employment. In France, Denmark and Belgium, on the other hand, the figure is over 20%. In the case of Denmark, the differential between the unemployment rate for young nationals and young foreigners is as high as 13 percentage points, illustrating how hard it is for young immigrants to enter the labour market in that country. The problem of labour market integration for young foreigners has to be looked at from the economic standpoint, i.e. from the point of view of labour supply and demand. On the supply side, it is clear that some of the young people looking for jobs lack both the skills and, in some cases, the linguistic ability that are essential prerequisites for finding a job. In some cases, a further barrier to labour market entry can be non-recognition of the diplomas and training received abroad. On the demand side, the emphasis has to be placed jointly on the role of government, employment intermediaries and firms. In several OECD countries, public sector jobs are still broadly speaking closed to foreigners, even though the authorities encourage private sector firms to recruit young foreigners or young people born abroad. The authorities also need in some cases to clarify the rules and legislation aimed at combating all forms of discrimination, particularly as regards recruitment. Public employment services and recruitment agencies should, for their part, expand training schemes to make their staff aware of the existence of discrimination and make firms more alive to the need to give young immigrants or young people of immigrant origin a chance. In practical terms, what is needed is multidimensional and coordinated action aimed at strengthening the links between the different actors: young people, government, the education system, public employment services, firms and associations.
Unemployment rate of youth unemployment according to nationality in selected OECD countries, 2001 Percentage of labour force Young foreigners (15-24)
Young nationals (15-24)
Total labour force (15-64)
35
30
30
25
25
20
20
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
he
la
Ita
ly Ire
rla
bo et N
xe
m
er Lu
iz Sw
nd
g ur
nd la
an y m
tri
ay w or
er G
Ki
U
ni
te
d
N
do
m
ng
lg
iu
en Be
nc
ed Sw
k Fr a
ar m en D
nd
35
s
40
a
40
m
45
e
45
Au s
Chart I.16.
Source: Labour force surveys, figures provided by Eurostat.
© OECD 2003
69
Trends in International Migration
Percentage of long-term unemployment according to nationality1 2000-2001 average2
Chart I.17.
Foreigners
Nationals
50
50
40
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0 e
iu
C
ze
ep
ch
R
Be
lg
ly
ec
Ita
re G
a
at
ad
St d
U
ni
te
tra
an C
Au s
m
60
ub li G er c m an y Sp ai n Fr an N et he ce rla nd s U S w ni ed te d e n Ki ng do m A Lu ust ria xe m bo Sw u itz rg er la n Fi d nl an d
60
es
70
lia
70
1. Data for Australia, Canada and the United States refer to foreign-born and native populations. 2. Population aged 15 to 64 with the exception of Australia and Canada (15 and over). Sources: Labour Force surveys (Eurostat, Australian Bureau of Statistics and US Bureau of the Census); 1996 Census (Statistics Canada).
ph eno meno n is, h oweve r, le ss marked in the settlement countries (Australia, Canada and the United States), where the discrepancy between the unemployment rates of those born abroad and those born in the country is considerably lower than that observed between foreigners and nationals in Europe. Foreigners are also strongly represented in th e figu re s for lo n g-term unemployment (see Chart I.17). In Sweden, for example, almost 45% of foreign jobless have been unemployed for over a year, compared with less than 30% in the case of nationals. This is also true, though to a lesser degree, in Australia, Belgium, Canada, France and Switzerland. In the recent immigration countries of southern Europe (Spain, Greece and Italy), where it is migration for employment purposes that predominates, foreigners figure less prominently than nationals among the long-term unemployed.
70
The disparities between unemployment rates for foreigners and nationals (see Table I.14) and the fact that, depending on their nationalities, foreigners are not all affected by unemployment to the
same degree, are attributable in particular to economic trends and the nature of the jobs held by foreigners. They also depend on the demographic structure of the foreign population and how long ago the different waves of migration arrived in the various host countries. Migrants’ profiles also determine how employable they are. Variables such as age, gender, nationality, skill level, professional experience and the length of stay in the country play an important role in explaining the degree of vulnerability to unemployment. Knowledge of the language of the host country also contributes importantly to integration in the labour market and in society as a whole (see Box I.8).
C.
RECENT TRENDS IN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION IN ASIA AND CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE
The 2001 edition of Trends in International Migration focused on Asian Migration to OECD countries. In the current report, particular is accorded to migration flows within Asia. The trends presented below concern © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Box I.8.
Linguistic competence and integration into the labour market Theme box on the Integration of Immigrants
Proficiency in the language of the host country is an essential factor in the successful integration of immigrants into the labour market. This facilitates communication at the workplace and is a condition of access to the information network (access to job vacancies, social exchanges, labour laws…). The acquisition of linguistic skills is dependant on numerous elements, such as the length of stay, age at the time of migration, the level of educational attainment of the migrant and his/her parents, whether or not there is a large ethnic group in the area of residence or whether there is any link between the mother tongue and the language of the host country. (see for example Dustman, 1994, in Germany; Carliner,1995, in the United States; Chiswick and Miller, 2000, in Canada; Shields and Price, 2001, in the United Kingdom; Chiswick, Lee and Miller in Australia). Since the pioneer work of Reimers (1983) and Grenier (1984), up to the more recent studies undertaken by Chiswick and Miller (2002), most studies identify a significant and positive impact, on a comparable scale, of the effects of linguistic competence on employment and the conditions of pay.1 However, all things being equal, it must be noted that immigrants capable of expressing themselves, who are able to write and understand the language of the host country, will receive a salary of at least 10% higher than those who lack these competencies. This result is confirmed if we take into consideration the bias of selective recruitment and the problems of evaluating linguistic ability. In the case of Israel, several studies present estimations of salary differences of over 20% (e.g. Berman et al., 2000; Chiswick, 1998). Besides, mastering the language of the host country seems equally to facilitate access to the labour market as well as positions of responsibility (Minns, 1999; Miller and Neo, 1997; Koussoudji, 1988). Linguistic competence exerts, nevertheless, an impact of a certain importance according to gender (i.e. notably in the case of women – Shields and Price, 2001; Beiser and Hou, 2000; Chiswick and Miller, 1999), depending on the origin of the immigrants (e.g., more notably for Cubans and Portoricans than for Mexicans in the United States – Reimers, 1983), according to level of education (i.e. illustrating a phenomenon of complementarity between education and linguistic competence – Chiswick and Miller, 2002), relative to the place of residence (i.e. higher in urban areas than in rural zones – McManus, 1990) or relative to the size of the ethnic group (i.e. decrease in importance when the ethnic group is a large one; MacManus, 1990). Finally, some authors find that familiarity in speaking the language is more important than competency in reading and writing (Chiswick, 1991), while some place a high emphasis on the role of writing (Gonzales, 2000; Dustman, 1994) other recognise the cross-effect (e.g. the necessity of reading and speaking well – Chiswick and Miller, 1999). 1. Hayfron (2001) in the case of Norway as well as Cornelius and Tsuda (2002) for Japan are, to our knowledge, the only two studies which do not find a link between the linguistic competence of immigrants and their labour market performance. The representative element of the data used in these two studies must, however, be viewed with caution.
several countries of East and South-East Asia and are based on information collected within the framework of the Annual Workshop on international migration and the labour market (Tokyo 4-5 February 2002). This workshop was organised by the Japanese authorities with the participation of the ILO and the OECD. Concerning migration in Central and Eastern Europe, the focus is on trends in migrations flows from and in this region as well as on the impact of the EU enlargement on migration. 1.
Recent developments in migration flows within East and South-East Asia6
a)
Background and major recent trends
The fragility of East and Southeast Asian economies was revealed in the aftermath of the terrorist © OECD 2003
attacks on the World Trade Center in New York on September 11 2001. Just as they appeared to be recovering from the effects of the 1997 Asian financial crisis, these economies were once again thrust into an en viron me nt of declining regional an d global demand. There are, of course, significant variations but most Asian economies had resumed growth by 1999 and several, including Hong Kong, Singapore, Korea and Malaysia had achieved rapid growth by 2000 (see Table I.19). Then came a rapid reversal. In 2001, Singapore was in its first recession since independence; Hong Kong, too, experienced negative growth and Japan, which had never really recovered from the collapse of its bubble economy in 1989, was in full recession. Even Chinese Taipei, which had avoided the worst effects of the Asian financial crisis, appears to be entering a period of slower growth. Only Korea may be on a more sustained course to recovery.
71
Trends in International Migration
Table I.19. Real GDP growth in selected Asian countries and in Australia, 1996-2001 Percentages
Chinese Taipei Hong Kong (China) Japan Korea Singapore Indonesia Malaysia Philippines Thailand China Vietnam Australia
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
6.1 4.5 3.5 6.8 7.7 8.0 10.0 5.8 5.9 9.6 9.3 4.0
6.7 5.0 1.8 5.0 8.5 4.5 7.3 5.2 –1.4 8.8 8.2 3.5
4.6 –5.3 –1.1 –6.7 – –13.2 –7.4 –0.5 –10.8 7.1 4.4 5.4
5.4 3.0 0.7 10.9 6.9 0.9 6.1 3.3 4.4 7.8 4.7 4.5
5.9 10.5 2.4 9.3 10.3 4.8 8.3 4.0 4.6 8.0 6.1 3.4
–1.9 0.1 –0.4 3.0 –2.0 3.3 0.4 3.4 1.8 7.3 6.8 2.4
Sources: Asian Development Bank, Key Indicators of Developing Asian and Pacific Countries, 2002 and OECD Economic Outlook, No. 71, June 2002.
Even during the brief recoveries in economic growth in the aftermath of the Asian financial crisis, unemployment proved persistent and rose markedly in the renewed downturn in 2001. It is now at all-time highs in the recent histories of Hong Kong, Singapore and Chinese Taipei with no suggestion of a reversal in the immediate future (see Table I.20). The structural adjustments that these tiger economies and Japan are undergoing that have seen an export of labourintensive manufacturing and an increasing reliance on high-tech industries, underlies this persistence of unemployment. While labour deficits emerge in modern sectors, labour surpluses increase in more traditional sectors. The East and Southeast Asian economies under consideration are all characterized by movements both into and out of their respective territories. It is altogether too simple to conceptualize economies into sending and receiving areas. All have inflows as
Table I.20.
well as outflows, although the composition and relative volume of the flows vary. For example, the Philippines can be considered as a country of emigration par excellence with over 7 million of its citizens living or working overseas, but that country, too, also imports highly skilled migrants to assist in certain key sectors of the economy. In 1999, there were almost six thousand foreign workers in the Philippines, the majority of whom were Japanese executives, a tiny number compared with the number of emigrants but nevertheless significant for the local economy. Indonesia also follows this general pattern, while Thailand and Malaysia both import and export large numbers of workers and Japan, Korea, Chinese Taipei, Singapore and Hong Kong are all economies of net immigration. Any population movement in Asia has to be placed in its demographic context of declining fertility in the region. Fertility levels have fallen
Unemployment rates in selected Asian countries and in Australia, 1996-2001 Per cent of total labour force
Chinese Taipei Hong Kong (China) Japan Korea Singapore Indonesia Malaysia Philippines Thailand China Vietnam Australia 72
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2.6 2.8 3.4 2.0 3.0 4.9 2.5 8.6 1.1 3.0 5.9 8.2
2.7 2.2 3.4 2.6 2.4 4.7 2.6 8.7 0.9 3.1 6.0 8.3
2.7 2.7 4.1 6.8 3.2 5.5 3.2 10.1 3.4 3.1 6.9 7.7
2.9 2.9 4.7 6.3 4.6 6.4 3.4 9.7 3.0 3.1 6.7 7.0
3.0 3.4 4.7 4.1 4.4 6.1 3.1 12.0 2.4 3.1 6.4 6.3
4.4 6.7 5.0 3.5 5.0 – 3.7 – – 3.6 – 6.7
Sources: Asian Development Bank, Asia Recovery Information Centre and OECD Economic Outlook, No. 71, June 2002.
© OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.21. Total fertility rates in selected Asian countries, 1980, 1990 and 1999 Births per woman
Chinese Taipei Hong Kong (China) Japan Korea Singapore Indonesia Malaysia Philippines Thailand China Vietnam
1980
1990
1999
2.5 2.0 1.8 2.6 1.9 4.3 4.2 4.8 3.5 2.5 5.0
1.8 1.3 1.5 1.8 1.7 3.0 3.8 4.1 2.2 2.1 3.6
1.6 1.0 1.5 1.6 1.5 2.6 3.0 3.3 1.9 1.9 2.3
Sources: Asian Development Bank, Key Indicators of Developing Asian and Pacific Countries, 2001.
precipitously in Japan and most of the Chinese culture areas (see Table I.21). With the exception of China itself, these areas tend to be the destinations for migration as economies come to terms with very slow growth in their labour forces. Conversely, those countries with higher fertility tend to be areas of origin of migration. The stock of foreign workers has increased steadily throughout the 1990s in Japan, Hong Kong, S i n g a p o r e , C h i n e s e Ta i p e i a n d K o r e a ( s e e Table I.22). Among these countries, only in Korea can an “Asian financial crisis” effect be seen, with a sharp reduction in the number of foreign workers during 1998. The situation among those economies lower down the development hierarchy is different.
Table I.22.
There, the crisis effect was more marked in population migration with the numbers of foreign workers declining in Malaysia and Thailand as well as in Indonesia. Here, however, considerable caution needs to be used in the interpretation of the available figures. In contrast to Japan and the tiger economies, data-gathering systems are not as well developed in those Southeast Asian nations. More important, is the fact that the long land and sea borders, so common in that part of the region, are difficult to control adequately and it is easy for people to cross from one country to another without detection. Undocumented movements account for a very significant proportion of total international migration among the large countries of Southeast Asia and it is difficult to know to what extent the figures provided represent the real situation. The summary figures on foreign workers in Asian countries have been subdivided as far as possible to indicate three sub-classes: the legal and highly skilled; the legal unskilled; and the undocumented unskilled. These data are not available for all countries and again it must be emphasized that differences in definition and coverage make ready comparison deceptive. Nevertheless, general trends can be identified with respect to the various categories. It should be pointed out that for Hong Kong there is a class of immigrant that is virtually unique among the countries under consideration. This covers one-way permit holders from China who are granted residence rights in the Special Administrative Region (SAR). Essentially, this category refers to a family reunification or settlement programme with
Stocks of foreign workers in selected Asian countries, 1996-2001 Thousands
Chinese Taipei Hong Kong (China)1 Japan2 Korea2 Singapore Indonesia3 Malaysia2 Philippines3 Thailand2 China3 Vietnam3
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
– 164.3 610 210.5 – 24.9 745.2 4.3 1 033.9 80 –
245.7 171.0 630 245.4 – 24.4 1 471.6 6.1 1 125.8 82 –
255.6 180.6 660 157.7 – 21.3 1 127.7 5.3 1 103.5 83 –
278.0 193.7 670 217.4 530.0 14.9 818.7 6.0 1 089.7 85 –
326.5 216.8 710 285.5 612.2 16.8 799.7 – 1 102.6 – 30
– – – 330.2 – – 805.0 – – 60 –
Note: Official estimates. 1. Foreign domestic workers only. There are no stock figures for the highly skilled workers. 2. Includes estimates of undocumented workers. 3. Foreign experts, primarily professionals, highly skilled workers and teachers. Source: National Statistical Offices.
© OECD 2003
73
Trends in International Migration
the majority entering the city under this category as either minor children or spouses of Hong Kong men. Their number is currently set at 150 a day. It is worth reiterating that many of those who leave Asian economies as immigrants or as more or less permanent settlers are highly skilled. Almost one third of the emigrants from Hong Kong to Australia and one seventh of immigrants arriving in Canada in the early 1990s were holders of a university degree. The fact that many choose not to become permanent immigrants but become either return migrants, migrants to third country destinations or transnational circulators after obtaining a new citizenship does not invalidate the essentially longer-term intent of this migration flow. While these groups will not be entirely ignored in the following discussion, the focus will be more on highly skilled worker and student flows. b)
Flows of highly skilled workers: must we speak about brain drain?
During the second half of the 1990s, Asians made up between one third to two fifths of settler arrivals to Australia and a significant trend has been the substantial shift towards skills and business migration and away from family-based criteria. Canada was the pioneer of managing its migration through a points-based system of selection and now takes over a quarter of its total intake from just two countries, China and India. The United States, while still maintaining its emphasis in its immigration on family reunification, has adjusted its intake to increase the proportion of independent, qualified and business immigrants.
74
Quite apart from these trends in long-term immigration policy an equally significant shift has been towards admitting increasing numbers of workers to North American countries and Australia under some form of temporary admission programme. In the United States, the numbers admitted under the H-1B programme, introduced in 1992 with an annual ceiling of 65 000. The ceiling was increased to 115 000 in 1999 and then again to 195 000 between 2001 and 2003 showing the marked growth in importance of this channel. China, India, Japan and the Philippines accounted for almost two thirds of the 65 000 intake in 1999, with India accounting for the vast majority. Migrants who enter with a H-1B visa are entitled to remain in the United States for up to six years. Australia, too, appears to have shifted towards a greater reliance on temporary entrants who may, in
the late 1990s, have reached over 400 000, or 2-3% of the resident population. While destination countries have increased their intake of the highly skilled through shifts in settler intake and by developing shorter-term entry programmes, the countries of origin can consider the loss of personnel not to be in their best interests. The so-called “brain drain” has tended to be seen as negative for countries of origin. It has to be considered however in the context of “brain gain” and “brain exchange”. It is important to bear in mind that the total number of highly skilled who are moving in, among and from Asian countries is quite small relative to the total populations of the economies concerned and even relative to the available pool of skilled labour itself. Nevertheless, the movement of small numbers of highly qualified people can have a significant impact on particular sectors of the labour market and on social and economic development, particularly in the context of an increasing competition for skills in the globalised economy. The debate can perhaps be best illustrated by examining the movement of students from Asian economies to tertiary institutions overseas. The United States has for long been the principal destination with 30% of the 34 232 foreign students in 1954/55 coming fr om Asian co u nt rie s. By 2 000 /01, th e re we re 547 867 foreign students registered in degree-granting institutions in the United States, with seven of the leading eight sources of the students being Asian countries (see Table I.23). Nearly 21% came from China and India alone. Taking the example of Chinese Taipei, it can be seen that relatively few students returned during the early period of student migration overseas in the 1960s and 1970s. The numbers of those returning accelerated throughout the 1980s until the mid-1990s when government subsidies for return were removed and many returnees, coming back on their own account, may not have registered. Thus, the more recent data are not strictly comparable. Nevertheless, it seems clear that, by the 1990s, development in Chinese Taipei had reached the level where significant numbers of students returned and fewer chose to leave in the first place, being able to receive a quality education at home. Only 937 students returned to Chinese Taipei in 1980 compared with some 6 510 in 1994 and the return rate in 1988 was estimated at around 32%, three times the return rate in 1980. While many highly skilled migrants may have returned to Chinese Taipei, or to Korea, return rates © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.23. Stocks of students in degree-granting institutions in the United States, 1954/55, 1974/75 and 2000/01 Top 15 countries of origin as ranked in 2000/01 Thousands
China India Japan Korea Chinese Taipei Canada Indonesia Thailand Turkey Mexico Germany Brazil United Kingdom Malaysia Hong Kong (China) Other countries Total Source:
1954/55
1974/75
2000/01
– 1.7 1.6 1.2 2.6 4.7 – – 1.2 0.8 – 0.7 – – 6.9
– 9.7 5.9 3.4 10.3 8.4 – 6.3 – 4.0 – – 2.8 – 11.1 31.4
59.9 54.7 46.5 45.7 28.6 25.3 11.6 11.2 11.0 10.7 10.1 8.8 8.8 8.1 7.8 199.1
21.4
93.3
547.9
Institute of International Education, Report on International Educational Exchange, 2002 and various years.
for countries at lower levels of development such as Malaysia and China appear to be much lower. Perhaps about 14% of Chinese students to the United States returned during the period 1978-1999. Whether these countries will follow a similar path to the tiger economies and see greater numbers of returnees over time remains to be seen. The Asian financial crisis did affect the numbers of students going overseas, however, with reduced government grants and personal finances among the middle classes bringing about either a reduction or very slow growth in the number of students from Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia. Paradoxically, the rate of creation of domestic talent, or the increase in the proportion of the highly educated so necessary for development, may be related to the possibilities for emigration that exist from an economy. People deliberately choose to pursue education specifically because it will give them a greater chance of emigrating. Thus, some loss of skilled personnel may be in the best interests of an economy as it is a factor in the generation of overall human capital. Where the loss, however, is greater than either the supply or the net exchange, then negative consequences may be more apparent, giving rise to the interesting idea that there may be an “optimal level of emigration”. Be that as it may, ILO studies suggest that two-way skill mobility, that © OECD 2003
is, the exchange of brains, make an economy more attractive for foreign investment than in cases where there is no emigration of the educated at all. The loss of skilled personnel cannot be seen, however, simply in economic terms; there are significant social impacts. For example, the loss of large numbers of nurses from the Philippines has almost certainly led to a deterioration in health services in that country. Over 70% of the annual number of 7 000 nurses who graduate each year leave the Philippines and there are an estimated 30 000 unfilled positions in government and private sectors, particularly in rural areas. Centres for the training of brains are evolving within the Asian region itself. Japan traditionally has been a magnet for students from other Asian countries, particularly China in the early years of the last century, and universities in Hong Kong and Singapore have emerged as centres of excellence in their respective regions. Satellite campuses of core western universities are proliferating throughout the region and a series of centres in China are emerging as significant destinations for students. For example, there were 78 812 foreign students in Japan in 2001, up from 51 047 in 1997, some 44 711 in China in 1999, 23 000 in Malaysia in 2000 and 7 300 in Chinese Taipei in 2000. The majority of these students come from other Asian countries. Thus, the creation of brains is increasingly occurring within the region. A key policy issue will be how to retain this talent within the region. c)
Flows of unskilled workers
In terms of numbers, unskilled workers make up the largest number of migrant workers in the Asian region. There are two principal components; documented workers, or those moving through formal legal channels to fill specific jobs under contract, and undocumented workers. It should be emphasized, however, that in both of these streams, the documented and the undocumented, educated, even skilled people may be moving to undertake unskilled jobs (for example the case of domestic workers to Hong Kong). Asian economies have emerged as labour-deficit areas over the last 10-15 years and several have seen a transition from areas of net-emigration to areas of net-immigration. The pattern of the legal importation of workers over the second half of the 1990s has been o n e o f s u s t a i n e d g r o w t h i n C h i n e s e Ta i p e i , Hong Kong and Japan and of growth punctuated by the Asian financial crisis in Korea, Malaysia and
75
Trends in International Migration
Thailand. In the latter cases, the stock of legal workers declined somewhat from 1997-1998 but resumed an upward course quite quickly in Korea and Malaysia. The official data suggest that the number of legal migrants stabilized in Thailand, but at a considerably lower level than before the crisis. The onset of the recession in 2001 h as se en lo wer n umbers of unskilled workers in Chinese Taipei but not in Hong Kong. In early 2002, there are reports of large numbers of Indonesians being expelled from Malaysia, either those who are found to be illegally in the country or those whose contracts have expired. Malaysia would like to reduce its dependence on workers from Indonesia who can easily “disappear” into the local population and increase recruitment of workers from a greater diversity of sources. Given Malaysia’s geography, and the demography of neighboring countries, any such policy would not appear to have a high probability of success. Many of the high-tech industries that East Asian economies are promoting, for example, also require substantial numbers of unskilled workers who are involved with packaging and dispatch of high-tech products. These activities are low-paid, involve long hours are boring and involve hard work that an increasingly highly educated local labour force is unwilling to undertake.
76
Several of the East and Southeast Asian countries are still significant suppliers of unskilled workers through official labour recruitment programmes, both government and private. The Philippines, Indonesia, Thailand and China all fall into this category. China sends workers to some 181 countries and territories, plus large numbers to regional fishing fleets. In November 2001, China had 460 000 workers abroad who were involved with contracts worth USD13.3 billion in 2001. The Philippines is the country of origin of workers par excellence, with some 866 590 workers overseas in 2001, up from 837 020 in 1999. The numbers of Filipinos employed in Asia, however, actually declined over this period, with m arke ts in Eur ope a nd t he M iddle Ea st compensating for these losses. Remittances from these workers that pass through official channels were estimated to have exceeded USD 6 billion in 2000 although this figure was down from a record USD 6.8 billion in 1999. Thailand, perhaps because of its greater reliance on Asian markets, particularly Chinese Taipei, saw a slight decline in the number of workers overseas from 202 416 in 1999 to 193 041 in 2000. Thai workers overseas remitted some USD 1.5 billion in 2000. As emphasized earlier, a
considerable amount of the monies remitted passes through informal channels as do many of the workers themselves. d)
Foreign workers in an irregular situation
The total numbers of undocumented workers are much more significant in the countries of Southeast Asia than they are in East Asia. Also, the data on those who entered illegally or who entered legally and overstayed their visas or changed their designated terms of entry are likely to be much more reliable for economies in the latter region than for Southeast Asian countries. The numbers of illegal entrants to Hong Kong, primarily from China, who were caught and deported declined markedly from 14 892 in 1998-99 to only 4 397 in 1999-2000 – a far cry from the tens of thousands of would-be entrants to the city of just a few decades ago. The creation of widespread opportunities in the Pearl River delta region and continued tight control along the border have all but eliminated irregular migration as a major policy concern in the SAR. In Singapore, too, the number of illegal immigrants apprehended declined sharply from 23 000 in 1998 to 16 500 in 2000. The principal reason given for the decline is the Asian financial crisis although, like the relationship between Hong Kong and Shenzhen, the creation of intervening opportunities for migrants across the causeway in Malaysia surely played a part. In Chinese Taipei, on the other hand, rising illegal migration from China appears to be a growing problem. It is estimated that just over half of all those who enter legally into Korea as trainees “disappear” into the wider labour force and become overstayers. Korea, the worst affected of the original tiger economies, saw a sharp reduction in undocumented workers from 148 048 in 1997 to 99 537 in 1998 following an amnesty for illegal workers that allowed them to leave the country without paying a fine. As the Korean economy resumed rapid growth the number of undocumented workers, too, accelerated markedly from 1998 to reach 250 756 in November 2001. Estimates of up to 1.43 million illegal migrants have been made for Malaysia before the onset of the financial crisis. Official estimates of illegal migration in Malaysia are based on annual apprehensions that are difficult to translate into stock estimates. Since 1997, however, the numbers of those appreh e n d e d u n de r t h e O ps N y a h e x e r ci se s h a v e increased and it would seem doubtful that the © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
number of those eluding capture and residing illegally in Malaysia had declined. The social distance between certain Indonesian groups, such as the Minangkabau of Sumatra, for example, and ethnic Malays in peninsular Malaysia is much less than between the Minangkabau and the Javanese of the capital, Jakarta. In both peninsular Malaysia and East Malaysia, there are virtually invisible minorities from neighboring countries. Similarly, in Thailand, the data on the numbers of undocumented workers appear to be distinctly “spongy”. Under the new Prime Minister, Taksin Shinawatra, a concerted effort has been made to register undocumented workers and by the end of October 2001, 562 527 workers had registered for legal work permits, although it was estimated that a further 300 000-400 000 undocumented workers remained in the country. Despite statistics to show that 319 629 workers were arrested in 1999 and 444 636 in 2000 these apprehensions do not seem to have decreased significantly the numbers of undocumented workers in the country. e)
Main themes of migration policies
Two generalisations can be advanced in terms of policy response in the Asian region: first, that the responses have been various depending upon the priority of each economy and, second, that there is little evidence to suggest that any policy intervention has been effective in controlling numbers or managing migration in desired directions over anything but the immediate short term. Clearly, policies vary dependin g on whe ther the y are directed towards receiving workers or sending workers overseas. If we examine policies directed at receiving migrants, of the countries participating in the discussions only Australia could be said to have a well-developed policy that essentially achieves its objectives. The Australian policy is well described in Hugo but, because of its settler tradition, cannot be used as a model for the majority of Asian countries at this stage of their development. Apart from Hong Kong’s policy to allow the entry of one-way permit holders from China, no Asian country actively seeks immigrants sensu stricto or extends the benefits of citizenship to foreigners. Those few examples, such as Singapore’s policy to bring skilled and semiskilled workers from Hong Kong in the early 1990s or Thailand’s assimilation of long-term migrants from Vietnam in the late 1990s, were all limited target and short term. Singapore and, from February 2002, Hong Kong both have investor programmes that grant © OECD 2003
permanent residence to those willing to invest large sums of money in the economies. In the case of Hong Kong, some USD 830 000 is required, a considerably larger sum than investor programmes in Canada or Australia. Policies in Asian economies are designed essentially to deal with workers, not immigrants. And the worker policies implemented are still strongly biased towards the unskilled, leaving vague or unstated any policy towards the attraction or retention of the highly skilled. Within Asia, the general approach is to welcome an d e nco urage h igh ly skille d migrants bu t to discourage or closely control unskilled workers. Policies for the latter often stipulate ceilings on intake, sectors in which foreign workers can be employed and terms and conditions of employment. Japan only laid down the basic principle for a migration policy as recently as August 1999 and even then it only addressed skilled migrants leaving unskilled workers for future careful study. The policies can be project-specific or of limited life. For example, the policy to allow workers into Hong Kong for the construction of the airport indeed terminated with the completion of the project in March 1999 and the General Labour Importation Scheme, introduced in May 1989 to allow employers to bring in up to 14 700 workers was wound down after a review in 1995. Local legislators and union leaders were instrumental in opposing the scheme in the face of rising domestic unemployment. In other economies, policies are aimed fundamentally at dealing with undocumented migrants. Thailand has seen the evolution of a series of policies that attempted to regularize the number of foreigners already working illegally in the country. From virtually a total ban on foreign workers, Thailand has moved through identifying particular parts of the country, and particular sectors of the economy, where foreigners would be permitted to work, to the present policy that is countrywide and that includes 10 general types of business occupations. Chinese Taipei, Japan, Malaysia, Korea and Singapore all have policies that have been implemented at one time or another to deal with the issue of undocumented migrants. Policies to return migrants forcibly to their home areas appear to have had little more than short-term impact and can be expensive. Again, amnesties have met with limited success. The substitution of newly unemployed domestic labour for foreign labour is unrealistic as the domestic employed are often to be found in other parts of the country from where foreign labour is employed and,
77
Trends in International Migration
more importantly, the domestic unemployed are unwilling to undertake the kinds of jobs that foreign labour is willing to do. Policies like the current Thai policy, that seek to register all those already working in the country without threat of deportation, are more realistic. The likely impact of that policy on the volume and direction of future migration is, however, unknown. It seems probable that, as in the case of skilled migration, countries need to plan for the exchange of unskilled migrant workers, facilitating their circulation between origins and destinations. Three other types of migrant worker policy are relevant to the region. The first relates to emigrant worker policy or attempts by countries of origin to seek out markets for their workers. In the wake of the Asian financial crisis, for example, Thailand sought to find countries that could absorb the newly unemployed. Vietnam plans to increase its export of workers, skilled and unskilled, to 100 000 by 2005 and provide a special fund for their training and loans for prospective migrant workers. The second type of policy refers to the protection of migrants: to ensure that they are accorded the same rights and privileges as local workers and to guar ante e t hat the y are n ot discriminate d against because of citizenship or ethnicity. To achieve this objective, countries need to become pa rt y t o in te r n a tio n a l co n v e n ti on s a im e d at protecting migrant workers and their families, the elimination of child labour and the suppression of trafficking. Clearly, these objectives are of greater importance to countries of origin of migrants but their implementation lies in the hands of destination countries. The Philippines, in particular, has worked extensively, though not always successfully, through international forums to reach agreements on the protection of the large number of its workers overseas.
78
The third and last type of policy deals with issues of return and reintegration. Migrant workers accustomed to regular employment or high wages relative to their areas of origin may face problems of adaptation and re-integration when they either return, or are returned, home. They may not find employment or remuneration at levels similar to those overseas and their overseas experience may not be relevant, recognized or even applicable. Although the cases of forced return may pose greater problems of readjustment than for those
who have returned voluntarily, both can and do experience difficulty. It is not only the migrant worker who returns home; those from settler societies, too, go back to retire after a working life in Australia, Canada or the United States. 2.
Trends in migration flows in Central and Eastern Europe
Many OECD member countries count among their population a significant number of immigrants from Central and Eastern Europe (CEEC) and other countries of the Community of Independent States (CIS). The pending membership of certain CEECs to the European Union is raising concern over increasing flows from the CEECs and towards member countries of the European Union. However, this apprehension seems unjustified as demonstrated by the majority of studies analysing the prospective migratory flows as a result of the enlargement of the European Union (see the 2001 Edition of Trends in International Migration, p. 72). Moreover, certain CEECs have progressively become countries with significant immigration flows. Ten years after the political changes in Central and Eastern Europe, we can take stock of migration trends in the region (see for detailed presentation of trends in migration flows in Central and Eastern Europe the 2001 Edition of Trends in International Migration, pp. 68 to 76). Analysis is complicated by the difficu lty o f co lle ctin g re li able da ta in cou n tr ie s undergoing far-reaching economic and administrative reforms, and also by the diversity of economic and social conditions in the region, including the countries of the former Yugoslavia and the CIS. This diversity accounts to a considerable degree for the nature and scale of East-West movements and those within and towards the region. The following analysis brings out a number of trends with regard both to East-West movements and to the characteristics of flows within the zone. The political and economic changes in 1990 led to sizeable migration movements and to concerns over the possibility of large-scale population transfers. These concerns have not been materialised. Although emigration flows continue, notably towards Western Europe, it would appear that the Central and Eastern European countries (CEECs) are becoming the theatre of much more complex movements than a straightforward westward flow towards the European Union and North America. © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
a)
Development of emigration flows towards the European OECD countries, the United States, Canada and Australia since 1990
Shortly after the opening of the borders, EastWest migration flows motivated by economic, political or ethnic reasons intensified. Throughout the 1990s, flows of ethnic minorities into Western Europe largely went to Germany (around 220 000 Aussiedler came from Poland, Russia and Romania annually between 1991 and 1995). Since 1996, there has been a constant decrease an d th e 95 000 eth nic German s wh o arrived in 2000 were almost uniquely coming from the former Soviet Union. Similar movements were recorded in Turkey (more than 120 000 Bulgarian nationals), Finland (around 20 000 persons of Finnish origin from Russia and Estonia since 1989) and Hungary (more than 100 000 Hungarians from Romania, the Slovak Republic, the Ukraine and Voivodina since 1990). However, total entries of permanent immigrants from CEECs, as a percentage of total immigration flows, have fallen since 1991 in Denmark, France, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and Sweden. The fall in emigration to OECD countries in most cases is very marked for Polish, Romanian and Bulgarian citizens. More recently, there has been a decline in the number of immigrants from the former Yugoslavia. The nature of emigration also seems to be changing. Its chief feature is now short and frequent movements related to (seasonal) employment opportunities. The largest emigration flows during the 1980s were from Poland (with some 800 000 people leaving the country, chiefly for Germany) and Romania (300 000 Romanians left, chiefly to Hungary and the United States). With the exception of inter-German migration, flows from other countries in the region were on a lesser scale. These movements largely concerned ethnic minorities: around 500 000 people of German ethnic origin (Aussiedler) and Hungarian minorities were involved here. A number of countries in Western Europe and North America have been longstanding hosts for most of the communities of Central and Eastern Europe (see Table I.24). Links with established emigrant communities may accordingly explain the direction, nature and size of the post-1989 EastWest flows. Among the OECD European member countries, Germany is the principal host country for nationals © OECD 2003
of the CEECs, the former Yugoslavia and the former Soviet Union with a total of 1.45 million. They represented 20% of the resident foreign population in 2000. They are also quite numerous in Austria (around 370 000, or nearly 70% of the resident foreign population), and to a lesser degree in Italy (around 305 000, or nearly 22% of the total). In 2000, a very large number of nationals of the former Yugoslavia reside in Western Europe (nearly 1.2 million in Germany, more than 334 000 in Switzerland), as are the Poles (nearly 300 000 in Germany, over 50 000 in France). In Australia, among the top five groups of immigrants born in Central and Eastern Europe, those from the former Yugoslavia are estimated around 210 000 followed by the Poles (68 000). In Canada, the latter are the most numerous (almost 194 000), followed by residents originating from the former Yugoslavia and Russia. In the United States, immigrants born in the former USSR represent the first nationality (almost 400 000), followed by th e Po le s an d th e fo rme r Yu go slavia (se e Table I.24). The decline in the number of migrants from the CEEC, the former Yugoslavia and the former USSR in some OECD countries is mainly due to the number of immigrants originating from the region who have acquired the nationality of the receiving country. Table I.25 shows that in Hungary, more than 91% of new acquisitions of Hungarian nationality are citizens from Romania, the former Yugoslavia and the former USSR. In Germany, this percentage is around 71% and includes, in addition, citizens from Poland and Romania. Sweden has registered a large proportion (42%) of acquisitions of nationality from citizens originating from Bosnia Herzegovina, the former Yugoslavia, Romania and Poland. Among the new acquisitions of nationality in Italy, citizens from Romania, Albania, Poland and the former USSR represent almost one fourth of the total. Of the officially recorded emigration flows from the Baltic States, those to the OECD countries are increasing as a proportion of the total, although not in absolute terms. Poland is a major destination fo r migrants from Lithuania; Finland , Germany and the United States for Estonia; the United States, Germany and Israel for Latvia and Lithuania. However, overstayers by nationals of the Baltic States are apparently numerous, particularly in some European countries, and hence the actual distributions could be very different. For example, whereas between 1991 and 1999 fewer than 30 Lithuanians
79
Trends in International Migration
Top five nationalities of citizens from Central and Eastern Europe residing in selected OECD countries, 2000
Table I.24.
Thousands Foreign citizens from Central and Eastern Europe in some European OECD countries Austria (foreign workers)
Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia Bosnia Herzegovina Croatia Former Yug. Rep. of Macedonia Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreign workers (as a % of total labour force)
Czech Republic
75.6 37.4 24.6 4.2 242.2 58.6
Ukraine Slovak Republic Poland Russian Federation Bulgaria Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia Poland Croatia Bosnia Herzegovina Russian Federation Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
Italy
48.6 15.3 7.6 4.1 3.8 127.0 62.5 1.3
Sweden
Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia Poland Bosnia-Herzegovina Croatia Russian Federation
50.2 44.3 17.1 13.0 4.0 201.0 64.0 2.0
662.5 301.4 216.8 156.3 115.9 7 296.8 19.9 8.9
10.5
Hungary (1999)
Romania Former Yugoslavia Ukraine Slovak Republic Russian Federation
Germany
Netherlands (1999)
Albania Romania Former Yugoslavia (others) Poland Former Yug. Rep. of Macedonia Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
142.1 Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia 68.9 Bosnia Herzegovina 40.0 Poland 31.4 Russian Federation 22.0 Croatia 1 388.2 21.9 2.4
7.2 6.1 5.6 3.3 1.6
Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
651.5 3.7 4.1
Switzerland
20.2 16.7 22.8 7.5 5.7 477.3 15.3 5.4
Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia Former Yug. Rep. of Macedonia Bosnia Herzegovina Croatia Poland Total foreigners Above countries (% of total foreigners) Total foreigners (% of total population)
190.7 55.9 44.3 43.6 4.0 1 384.4 24.5 19.3
Immigrants born in Central and Eastern Europe in some OECD countries Australia
Former Yugoslavia Poland Former USSR Hungary
Canada (1996)
210.0 68.3 54.9 28.0
Total of foreign-born 4 517.3 Above countries (% of total foreign-born) 8.0 Total foreign-born (% of total population) 23.6
Poland Former Yugoslavia Former USSR Hungary Former CSFR
United States (1990)
193.4 122.0 108.4 54.2 41.2
Total of foreign-born 4 971.1 Above countries (% of total foreign-born) 10.4 Total foreign-born (% of total population) 17.4
Former USSR Poland Former Yugoslavia Hungary Romania
389.9 388.3 141.5 110.3 91.1
Total of foreign-born 19 767.3 Above countries (% of total foreign-born) 5.7 Total foreign-born (% of total population) 7.9
Sources: Australia: estimates made by the Australian Bureau of Statistics; Austria: work permits; Censuses for Canada and the United States, residence permits for Italy and population registers for the other countries.
were recorded as having settled in the United Ki ngd om, during the year 2000, m ore than 1 351 were deported.
80
Germany is traditionally the most important destination for emigrants from Poland and the inflows have increased during the last ten years. More than 62% of all legal immigrants in Greece in 2000 were from Albania (131 600), making Greece the biggest
receiver of immigrants of one single CEEC nationality. Germany is also a very important destination for migrants from Russia (27 800), Bosnia Herzegovina (10 300) and the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (87 800). Italy appears as another popular destination for migrants from the CEECs in 2000: Albanians (31 000), followed by Romanians (20 100), Poles (7 000) and Ukrainians (5 300). People from Russia are the main immigrant group in Finland in 2000 as © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
Table I.25. Foreigners residing in some Central and Eastern European countries, by major nationality, latest available year Bulgaria (2000)
CIS EU Europe (other) Middle East Asia Africa America Central Europe Australia Others Total % of total population
Czech Republic (2000)
Thousands
%
34.9 18.5 10.1 10.1 6.3 5.9 3.3 2.6 0.1
34.5 18.2 10.0 10.0 6.2 5.9 3.3 2.6 0.1
9.4
9.3
101.3
100.0 1.2
Ukraine Slovak Republic Vietnam Poland Russian Federation Germany Bulgaria Belarus Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia China Others Total % of total population
Poland (1999)
Hungary (1999)
Thousands
%
50.2 44.3 23.6 17.1 13.0 5.0 4.0 3.8 3.7 3.6 36.4
25.0 22.0 11.7 8.5 6.5 2.5 2.0 1.9 1.8 1.8 18.1
201.0
100.0 2.0
Thousands
%
Romania Former Yugoslavia Germany China Ukraine Slovak Republic Russian Federation Poland Vietnam Bulgaria Others
48.6 15.3 8.5 7.7 7.6 4.1 3.8 2.5 2.2 1.3 26.8
38.2 12.0 6.7 6.0 6.0 3.2 3.0 2.0 1.7 1.0 21.1
Total % of total population
127.0
100.0 1.3
Romania (2000)
Thousands
%
Ukraine Russian Fed. Vietnam Belarus Germany Fed. Rep. of Yugoslavia United States Armenia Bulgaria France Others
7.0 4.4 3.3 2.3 1.9 1.6 1.4 1.3 1.2 0.8 17.5
16.4 10.4 7.6 5.4 4.5 3.8 3.2 3.1 2.8 2.0 40.9
Total % of total population
42.8
100.0 0.1
Slovak Republic (1997)
Thousands
%
8.2 7.1 7.0 5.3 5.0 3.3
11.8 10.2 10.0 7.6 7.2 4.8
Czech Republic Ukraine Poland Former Yugoslavia
Others
33.6
48.5
Total % of total population
69.4
100.0 0.3
Republic of Moldova China Turkey Italy Greece Syria
Thousands
%
5.8 3.5 2.8 2.0
23.3 14.1 11.3 8.2
Others
10.7
43.1
Total % of total population
24.8
100.0 0.5
Sources: Data for Poland is estimates on the basis of the Ministry of the Interior’s Registers; figures for Romania correspond to the number of persons who hold a temporary residence visa (valid for at least 120 days). For the other countries, data is issued from population registers and is the number of foreigners who hold a permanent or a long-term residence permit.
they accounted for 27% of total entries of immigrants. The next largest groups were Swedes at 7.7% and Estonians at 7.2%, while all other individu al na tio n alit ies acco u nt ed fo r con side rabl y smaller percentages. b)
Trends in intra-regional migration
One of the characteristics of migration movements in Eastern Europe is the persistence of significant intra-regional flows. Some trends stem from the liberalisation of trade in 1990 and border readjustments (movements of ethnic minorities), while others highlight the economic dimension of migration flows within the region (movements of labour, irregular flows). © OECD 2003
As in the case of East-West migration flows, those within the CEECs, brought about by the opening of the borders in 1990, were initially composed of persons with family links with the host country and the movement of ethnic minorities. These were largely Hungarian (originating from Romania and the Slovak Republic), Polish (from Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Siberia) and Bulgarian (from the former Soviet Union). The readjustment of the borders in the region (in the former Yugoslavia, CSFR and Soviet Union) also led to population movements. The split of the Czech and Slovak Republics in 1993 led to substantial e xch anges ( aroun d 20 000 people entered the Czech Republic from the new Slovak Republic between 1994 and 1999, and 8 000 moved in the other direction). Emigration of Russian
81
Trends in International Migration
nationals continues to be observed today in the Baltic countries. H ungary reports an increase in inflows of Hungarian ethnic minorities. The flows reached a high level in 1999, particularly for people from Romania and the Ukraine. The increase may be explained by the apprehension that Hungary will shortly introduce the admission rules applied in the EU, which are restrictive for Romanian and Ukrainian nationals. Roma minorities are present in most countries in the region and flows both to Western Europe and within Central Europe were very substantial once borders opened; they have since fallen considerably overall. At the same time, countries such as Finland sa w n u mb e r s o f Ro m a m ig r a n t s r i se i n 1 9 9 9 (1 500 from Slovakia and 300 from Poland). A number of countries (the Czech Republic, the Slovak Republic, Bulg aria an d H un ga ry) ar e co n duct ing activ e programmes to integrate Roms socially and economically, often with funding under programmes by the European Union (PHARE) and/or the Council of Europe. Such investments may, over the long term, mean that they settle permanently. But Roms are frequently marginalised and their living conditions are deplorable. They often live on the edges of larger towns (Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, the former Yugoslavia, and the Czech Republic) or in villages entirely inhabited by Roms (Bulgaria, Romania).7 In the majority of cases, Gypsies have a level of education much lower than the rest of the population and are more vulnerable to unemployment. A degree of rejection by the rest of the population renders the success of active policies targeted towards this group more difficult. As a result, these minorities are still much inclined to emigrate.
82
Annual intra-regional migrant flows are generally modest, varying between around a hundred persons in Bulgaria to a few thousand in the Czech Republic. Hungary, however, attracted well over 10 000 immigrants from other CEEC countries in 1999. Part of these movements appears to be triggered by historical ties. The greater part of migrant movements from the Slovak Republic and within Europe were to the Czech Republic, although the movements of Czechs have decreased dramatically after the split of the Federation in 1993. Likewise, in the Czech Republic, in 1999, the biggest group of migrants were Slovaks, followed by Ukrainians; Russians took a fifth place (after Vietnamese). In
Hungary, similarly to previous years, most immigrants in 1999 arrived from neighbouring countries – predominantly Romania – and most of them were ethnic Hungarians. In 2000, around 61 000 Bulgarians of Turkish origin emigrated to Turkey. Likewise, the return migration of the so-called “Russian speaking population” – Russians, Belarussians, Ukrainians – although diminishing, remains the dominant component of emigration flows from the Baltic States. In the case of Latvia, after a decline from 80% to 70% during 1998, the proportion fell to 67% in 1999; in the case of Lithuania, the corresponding figures were 60%, 55% and 48%. Detailed data on the ethnic composition of Estonia’s emigration flows were not made available in 1997 and in 1999; in 1998, those leaving for either Russia, Belarus or the Ukraine accounted for approximately 60% of the total. The inflow of persons to Poland underwent a noticeable change in 2000. The number of arriving foreign visitors declined, breaking with a long lasting past trend. This is mainly caused by a decline in the number of short-time visitors arriving from borderlands of relatively well-off countries (Germany, the Czech Republic and Slovakia) for whom Poland is an attractive shopping destination. This more than offsets a growing numbers of petty traders and occasional irregular workers coming from Belarus and the Ukraine where the economies are weak. However, the number of long-term arrivals of citizens from Belarus and the Ukraine grew strongly by 28% and 17%, re spe ctively. Cit ize ns fro m CEECs form, together with Vietnamese, the bulk of the long-term arrivals in Poland. In CEECs, the main groups of residing foreigners originate from the CIS region, accounting for a large percentage of the total foreign population (see Table I.25). However, while citizens from CIS countries are currently the largest group of permanently residing foreigners, their share is expected to decrease, reflecting the decline in foreign trade and economic relations with the CIS countries. In the Czech Republic, Ukrainian and Slovak citizens accounted in 2000 for 25% and 22%, respectively, whilst Germans accounted for less than 3%. Czech and Ukrainian citizens accounted for 23% and 14% respectively in the Slovak Republic. The share of Roman ians an d forme r Yug oslavia citizen s in Hungary accounted in 1999 respectively for 38% and 12% of the total foreign population. © OECD 2003
Main Trends in International Migration
c)
Trends in asylum seekers
Border openings gave rise to important movements of asylum seekers, which was later increased by the conflict in the former Yugoslavia. The movement of refugees from the former Yugoslavia peaked between 1992 and 1993, but still continues to Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Norway and Canada. Many migrants from Kosovo have since returned home. Within Central and Eastern Europe itself, there is currently an increase in the transit flows of people coming from outside the region and seeking to enter Western Europe. A substantial part of this is irregular migration. These flows eventually leading to Western European countries were at the root of significant changes in the process of dealing with examination of a s y lu m r e qu e st s i n m o s t We s t e r n c o u n t r ie s between 1993 and 1997 and in 2001. Important differences exist between countries as to the nationality of asylum seekers from Central and Eastern Europe and the CIS. In Belgium, for example, the number of applicants from Russia has increased significantly in the last two years. In Finland, most applications came from Poland, the Slovak Republic and Russia. Sweden saw an increase in the number of applications, from 11 300 to 16 300 in 2000, the bulk of the increase (3 800) being on account of Bosnians. In Norway the bulk of the asylum seekers from Croatia, Bulgaria and Russia appear to have been lured by travel agencies specialising in “asylum tours”. Such agencies advertise generous benefits for asylum seekers in Norway, easy-to-get well-paid jobs and long processing times that guarantee at least a year’s lawful residence. Almost all Bulgarian asylum seekers in 2001 came in chartered bus tours in the time span of a few weeks between the end of June and the beginning of July. Their applications were deemed to be unfounded, and by the end of September all of them had been returned to their home country. The authorities thereby sent the signal, in particular to the people of Central and Eastern Europe, that although Norway may need foreign labour and although labour immigration may be encouraged, the asylum route is not the way to go for job seekers. The applications of Bulgarians and Croatians have since been processed in an accelerated procedure. Most applications are rejected, and more accurate information about the prospects for a successful asylum application is distributed through local media. In Austria there is a marked difference in the procedures for refugee intakes from Kosovo and Bosnia Herzegovina. While Bosnians had hardly © OECD 2003
registered as asylum seekers