Developments in Paleoenvironmental Research VOLUME 1
Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques
Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques Edited by
William M. Last Department of Geological Sciences, University of Manitoba
and
John P. Smol Department of Biology, Queen’s University
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS NEW YORK, BOSTON, DORDRECHT, LONDON, MOSCOW
eBook ISBN: Print ISBN:
0-306-47669-X 0-7923-6482-1
©2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York, Boston, Dordrecht, London, Moscow Print ©2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht All rights reserved No part of this eBook may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, without written consent from the Publisher Created in the United States of America Visit Kluwer Online at: and Kluwer's eBookstore at:
http://kluweronline.com http://ebooks.kluweronline.com
DEDICATION Dedicated to Prof. B. E. Berglund, whose edited volume Handbook of Holocene Palaeoecology and Palaeohydrology has guided researchers for over 15 years.
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Preface The Editors Aims & Scope of Developments in Paleoenvironmental Research Book Series Editors and Board of Advisors of Developments in Paleoenvironmental Research Book Series Contents of Volumes 1 to 4 of the Series Safety Considerations and Caution List of Contributors
1. An introduction to basin analysis, coring, and chronological techniques used in paleolimnology. William M. Last & John P. Smol
xiii xiv xv xvi xvii xx xxi
1
Part I: Basin Analysis Techniques 2. Applications of seismic sequence stratigraphy in lacustrine basins. Christopher A. Scholz
7
Introduction Seismic sequence stratigraphy applied to lake basins Theoretical considerations of the seismic reflection method Practical considerations, instrumentation and scales of observation Sequence stratigraphic interpretation of lacustrine seismic reflection data Summary Acknowledgments References 3. Ground-penetrating radar applications in paleolimnology. Brian J. Moorman Introduction Ground-Penetrating radar theory Data acquisition Data processing and interpretation Applications Summary Acknowledgments References vii
23
viii 4. Shoreline and basin configuration techniques in paleolimnology. Dorothy Sack
49
Introduction Coastal landform nomenclature Shoreline identification Shoreline reconstruction Water body delineation Chronologic considerations Paleoclimatic reconstruction Other applications Conclusions and future outlook Summary Acknowledgments References
Part II: Core Acquisition, Archiving, and Logging Techniques 5. Sediment core collection and extrusion. John R. Glew, John P. Smol & William M. Last Introduction Aim of good core recovery Nature of lacustrine sediment Nature of the sampling process Effects of frictional and deformational forces on the sediment sample Major types of sampling equipment Open-barrel and gravity corers Box corers and dredges Piston coring devices driven by rods Cable-operated piston corers Chamber-type samplers Freeze samplers Vibracorers Other corers and modifications Percussion or hammer corers Modifications to gravity coring equipment Pneumatic corers Core catching devices Extruding and subsampling equipment Summary Acknowledgements References
73
ix
6. Coring and drilling equipment and procedures for recovery of long lacustrine sequences. Suzanne A. G. Leroy & Steve M. Colman
107
Introduction Coring and drilling technology and operation from lake surfaces Adaptation from ODP technology and the development of a new drilling rig Drilling systems Drilling platforms and positioning Procedure recommendations Inventory of drilling equipment A brief comparison of the techniques Environmental protection and safety issues Conclusion Summary Acknowledgements Appendix 1: Contact addresses References 7. Sediment logging techniques. Bernd Zolitschka, Jens Mingram, Sjerry van der Gaast, J. H. Fred Jansen & Rudolf Naumann
137
Introduction Brief history of use and development of logging techniques Core logging devices Conclusion and future directions Summary Acknowledgements References
8. Logging of magnetic susceptibility. Norbert R. Nowaczyk
155
Introduction Different methods of logging magnetic susceptibility Examples Summary Acknowledgements References
Part III Chronostratigraphic Techniques
9. Chronostratigraphic techniques in recent sediments. P. G. Appleby
171
x Introduction Origins of fallout radionuclides Sediment records of fallout radionuclides Simple dating models Vertical mixing Numerical techniques Radiometric techniques Discussion Summary Acknowledgements References
10.
chronostratigraphic techniques in paleolimnology. Svante Björck & Barbara Wohlfarth
205
Introduction Methods and problems Radiocarbon-dating different fractions of the sediment as a chronostratigraphic tool Dating of long (old) stratigraphies High resolution dating and wiggle matching dating versus absolute dating techniques of lacustrine sediments Concluding remarks Summary Useful www addresses Acknowledgements References
11. Varve chronology techniques. Scott Lamoureux
247
Introduction Methods Summary and future directions Acknowledgements References
12. Luminescence dating. Olav B. Lian & D. J. Huntley Introduction The mechanism responsible for luminescence Dating and estimation of the paleodose Thermoluminescence dating Optical dating Evaluating the environmental dose rate
261
xi Sample collection and preparation What types of depositional environments are suitable for luminescence dating? What can lead to an inaccurate optical age? Summary Acknowledgements References 13. Electron spin resonance (ESR) dating in lacustrine environments. Bonnie A. B. Blackwell
283
Introduction Principles of ESR analysis Sample collection ESR analysis ESR microscopy and other new techniques Applications and datable materials in limnological settings Summary Acknowledgements References 14. Use of paleomagnetism in studies of lake sediments. John King & John Peck
371
Introduction Recording fidelity of geomagnetic behavior by sediments Field and laboratory methods Holocene SV records Magnetostratigraphic studies of Neogene lake sediments Excursions, short events and relative paleointensity Conclusions Summary References 15. Amino acid racemization (AAR) dating and analysis in lacustrine environments. 391 Bonnie A. B. Blackwell Introduction Racemization and epimerization Sampling protocols AAR analysis AAR dating Dating and aminostratigraphic correlation in lacustrine environments Paleoenvironmental analyses in lacustrine environments Summary Acknowledgements References
xii 16. Tephrochronology. C. S. M. Turney & J. J. Lowe
451
Introduction Mechanisms of tephra horizons Detection of tephra horizons Extraction of tephra shards Correlation and dating of tephras: building a tephrochronological framework Applications of tephrochronology Summary Acknowledgements References Glossary, acronyms and abbreviations
473
Index
537
xiii PREFACE The explosive growth of paleolimnology over the past two decades has provided impetus for the publication of this series of monographs detailing the numerous advances and new techniques being applied to the interpretation of lake histories. This is the first volume in the series and deals mainly with the acquisition and archiving of cores, chronological techniques, and large-scale basin analysis methods. Volume 2 (Last & Smol, 2001) examines the physical and geochemical parameters and methods; Volumes 3 and 4 (Smol et al., 2001a, b) provide a comprehensive overview of the many biological techniques that are used in paleolimnology. A fifth volume that is currently being prepared (Birks et al., in preparation) examines statistical and data handling methods. It is our hope that these monographs will provide sufficient detail and breadth to be useful handbooks for both seasoned practitioners as well as newcomers to the area of paleolimnology. These books should also be useful to non-paleolimnologists (e.g., limnologists, environmental scientists, archeologists, palynologists, geographers, geologists, etc.) who continue to hear and read about paleolimnology, but have little chance to explore the vast and sometimes difficult to access journal-based reference material for this rapidly expanding field. Although the chapters in these volumes target mainly lacustrine settings, many of the techniques described can also be readily applied to fluvial, glacial, marine, estuarine, and peatland environments. The 16 chapters in this volume are organized into three major parts. The four chapters in Part I provide an overview of the most common, large-scale basin analysis methods. Part II summarizes the suite of sample acquisition, archiving and logging techniques routinely used in paleolimnology. The third and largest part of this book includes eight chapters summarizing chronostratigraphic techniques. Following this is a comprehensive glossary and list of acronyms and abbreviations. Many people have helped with the planning, development, and final production of this volume. In addition to the hard work provided by the authors of these contributions, this publication benefitted from the technical reviews furnished by our scientific colleagues, many of whom remain anonymous. Each chapter was critically examined by two external referees as well as the editors. In order to assure readability for the major target audience, we asked many of our graduate students to also examine selected chapters; their insight and questioning during the reviewing and editorial process are most gratefully acknowledged. The staff of the Environmental, Earth and Aquatic Sciences Division of Kluwer Academic Publishers are commended for their diligence in production of the final presentation. In particular, we would also like to thank Ad Plaizier, Anna Besse-Lototskaya (Publishing Editor, Aquatic Science Division), and Rene Mijs (former Publishing Editor, Biosciences Division) for their long-term support of this new series of monographs and their interest in paleoenvironmental research. Finally, we would like to thank our respective universities and colleagues for support and encouragement during this project.
xiv THE EDITORS William M. Last is a professor in the Department of Geological Sciences at University of Manitoba (Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada) and is co-editor of the Journal of Paleolimnology. John P. Smol is a professor in the Biology Department at Queen’s University (Kingston, Ontario, Canada), with a cross-appointment at the School of Environmental Studies. He co-directs the Paleoecological Environmental Assessment and Research Lab (PEARL). Professor Smol is co-editor of the Journal of Paleolimnology and holds the Canada Research Chair in Environmental Change.
xv AIMS AND SCOPE OF DEVELOPMENTS IN PALEOENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH SERIES Paleoenvironmental research continues to enjoy tremendous interest and progress in the scientific community. The overall aims and scope of the Developments in Paleoenvironmental Research book series is to capture this excitement and document these developments. Volumes related to any aspect of paleoenvironmental research, encompassing any time period, are within the scope of the series. For example, relevant topics include studies focused on terrestrial, peatland, lacustrine, riverine, estuarine, and marine systems, ice cores, cave deposits, palynology, isotopes, geochemistry, sedimentology, paleontology, etc. Methodological and taxonomic volumes relevant to paleoenvironmental research are also encouraged. The series will include edited volumes on a particular subject, geographic region, or time period, conference and workshop proceedings, as well as monographs. Prospective authors and/or editors should consult the series editors for more details. The series editors also welcome any comments or suggestions for future volumes.
xvi EDITORS AND BOARD OF ADVISORS OF DEVELOPMENTS IN PALEOENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH BOOK SERIES
Series Editors: John P. Smol Paleoecological Environmental Assessment and Research Lab (PEARL) Department of Biology Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] William M. Last Department of Geological Sciences University of Manitoba Winnipeg, Manitoba R3T 2N2, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] Advisory Board: Professor Raymond S. Bradley Department of Geosciences University of Massachusetts Amherst, MA 01003-5820 USA e-mail:
[email protected] Professor H. John B. Birks Botanical Institute University of Bergen Allégaten 41 N-5007 Bergen Norway e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Keith Alverson Science Officer IGBP-PAGES International Project Office Barenplatz 2 3011 Bern Switzerland e-mail:
[email protected]
xvii CONTENTS OF VOLUMES 1 TO 4 OF THE SERIES
Contents of Volume 1: Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. An introduction to basin analysis, coring, and chronological techniques used in paleolimnology. William M. Last & John P. Smol Applications of seismic sequence stratigraphy in lacustrine basins. Christopher A. Scholz Ground penetrating radar applications in paleolimnology. Brian J. Moorman Shoreline and basin configuration techniques in paleolimnology. Dorothy Sack Sediment core collection and extrusion. John R. Glew, John P. Smol & William M. Last Coring and drilling equipment and procedures for recovery of long lacustrine sequences. Suzanne A. G. Leroy & Steve M. Colman Sediment logging techniques. Bernd Zolitschka, Jens Mingram, Sjerry van der Gaast, J. H. Fred Jansen & Rudolf Naumann Logging of magnetic susceptibility. Norbert R. Nowaczyk Chronostratigraphic techniques in recent sediments. P. G. Appleby chronostratigraphic techniques in paleolimnology. Svante Björck & Barbara Wohlfarth Varve chronology techniques. Scott Lamoureux Luminescence dating. Olav B. Lian & D. J. Huntley Electron spin resonance (ESR) dating in lacustrine environments. Bonnie A. B. Blackwell Use of paleomagnetism in studies of lake sediments. John King & John Peck Amino acid racemization (AAR) dating and analysis in lacustrine environments. Bonnie A. B. Blackwell Tephrochronology. C. S. M. Turney & J. J. Lowe Glossary, Acronyms and Abbreviations Subject Index Contents of Volume 2: Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments: Physical and Geochemical Methods. An introduction to physical and geochemical methods used in paleolimnology. William M. Last & John P. Smol
xviii Recognition and analysis of bedding and sediment fabric features. Alan E. S. Kemp, Jean Dean, Richard B. Pearce & Jennifer Pike Image analysis techniques. Timo Saarinen & Gunilla Petterson Textural analysis of lake sediments. William M. Last Inorganic geochemical methods in paleolimnology. J. F. Boyle Mineralogical analysis of lake sediments. William M. Last Fluid inclusions in paleolimnological studies of chemical sediments. Tim Lowenstein & Sean T. Brennan Application of mineral magnetic techniques to paleolimnology. Per Sandgren & Ian Snowball Sediment organic matter. Philip A. Meyers & Jane L. Teranes Paleolimnological methods and applications for persistent organic pollutants. Jules M. Blais & Derek C. G. Muir Near-Infrared spectrometry (NIRS) in paleolimnology. Tom Korsman, Eigil Dåbakk, Mats B. Nilsson & Ingemar Renberg Fly-ash particles. Neil Rose Application of stable isotope techniques to inorganic and biogenic carbonates. Emi Ito Carbon and oxygen isotope analysis of lake sediment cellulose: methods and applications. Brent B. Wolfe, Thomas W. D. Edwards, Kristina R. M. Beuning & Richard J. Elgood Nitrogen isotopes in palaeolimnology. Michael R. Talbot Glossary, Acronyms and Abbreviations Subject Index
Contents of Volume 3: Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments: Terrestrial, Algal, and Siliceous Indicators. Using biology to study long-term environmental change. John. P. Smol, H. John B. Birks & William M. Last Pollen. K. D. Bennett & K. J. Willis Conifer stomata. Glen M. MacDonald Plant macrofossils. Hilary H. Birks Charcoal as a fire proxy. Cathy Whitlock & Chris Larsen Non-pollen palynomorphs. Bas van Geel
xix
Protozoa: testate amoebae. Louis Beyens & Ralf Meisterfeld Diatoms. Richard W. Battarbee, Laurence Carvalho, Vivienne J. Jones, Roger J. Flower, Nigel G. Cameron, Helen Bennion & Stephen Juggins Chrysophyte scales and cysts. Barbara A. Zeeb & John P. Smol Ebridians. Atte Korhola & John P. Smol Phytoliths. Dolores R. Piperno Freshwater sponges. Thomas M. Frost Siliceous protozoan plates and scales. Marianne S. V. Douglas & John P. Smol Biogenic silica. Daniel J. Conley & Claire L. Schelske Sedimentary pigments. Peter R. Leavitt & Dominic A. Hodgson Glossary, Acronyms and Abbreviations Subject Index Contents of Volume 4: Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments: Zoological Indicators. Zoological indicators in lake sediments: an introduction. John. P. Smol, H. John B. Birks & William M. Last Cladocera and other branchiopod crustaceans. Atte Korhola & Milla Rautio Midges: Chironomidae and related Diptera. Ian R. Walker Coleoptera and Trichoptera. Scott A. Elias Oribatid mites. Torstein Bryozoan statoblasts. Donna R. Francis Ostracoda. Jonathan A. Holmes Freshwater molluscs. Barry B. Miller & Michael J. S. Tevesz Fish. W. P. Patterson & G. R. Smith Glossary, Acronyms and Abbreviations Subject Index
xx SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS AND CAUTION Paleolimnology has grown into a vast scientific pursuit with many branches and subdivisions. It should not be surprising, therefore, that the tools used by paleolimnologists are equally diverse. Virtually every one of the techniques described in this book requires some familiarity with standard laboratory or field safety procedures. In some of the chapters, the authors have made specific reference to appropriate safety precautions; others have not. The responsibility for safe and careful application of these methods is yours. Never underestimate the personal risk factor when undertaking either field or laboratory investigations. Researchers are strongly advised to obtain all safety information available for the techniques they will be using and to explicitly follow appropriate safety procedures. This is particularly important when using strong acids, alkalies, or oxidizing reagents in the laboratory or many of the analytical and sample collection/preparation instruments described in this volume. Most manufacturers of laboratory equipment and chemical supply companies provide this safety information, and many Internet and other library resources contain additional safety protocols. Researchers are also advised to discuss their procedures with colleagues who are familiar with these approaches, and so obtain further advice on safety and other considerations. The editors and publisher do not necessarily endorse or recommend any specific product, procedure, or commercial service that may be cited in this publication.
xxi LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS P. G. Appleby Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Liverpool P. O. Box 147 Liverpool, L69 3BX, UK e-mail:
[email protected] Svante Björck Department of Quaternary Geology Lund University Tornavägen 13 SE-223 63 Lund, Sweden e-mail:
[email protected] Bonnie A. B. Blackwell Department of Chemistry Williams College Williamstown, MA 01267 USA e-mail:
[email protected] Steve M. Colman U.S. Geological Survey 384 Woods Hole Rd Woods Hole, MA 02543, USA e-mail:
[email protected] John R. Glew Paleoecological Environmental Assessment and Research Lab (PEARL) Department of Biology Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] D. J. Huntley Department of Physics Simon Eraser University Burnaby, B.C., V5A 1S6, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] J. H. Fred Jansen Netherlands Institute for Sea Research P.O. Box 59 NL-1790 AB Den Burg (Texel) The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected]
xxii John King Graduate School of Oceanography University of Rhode Island Narragansett, RI 02882-1197, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Scott Lamoureux Department of Geography Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] William M. Last Department of Geological Sciences University of Manitoba Winnipeg, Manitoba, R3T 2N2, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] Suzanne A. G. Leroy Department of Geography and Earth Sciences Brunel University Uxbridge UB8 3PH, Middlesex, UK e-mail:
[email protected] Olav B. Lian Department of Geography Royal Holloway, University of London Egham, Surrey, U.K. TW20 0EX e-mail:
[email protected] J. J. Lowe Centre for Quaternary Research Geography Department Royal Holloway, University of London Egham, Surrey, TW20 0EX, UK e-mail:
[email protected] Jens Mingram GeoForschungsZentrum Potsdam PB 3.3 – Sedimentation and Basin Analysis Telegrafenberg, D-14473 Potsdam, Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
xxiii Brian Moorman Earth Science Program University of Calgary 2500 University Drive N.W. Calgary, AB, T2N 1N4, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] Rudolf Naumann GeoForschungsZentrum Potsdam PB 4.2 - Material Properties and Transport Processes Telegrafenberg, D-14473 Potsdam, Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Mats B. Nilsson Department of Forest Ecology Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences SE-901 83 Umeå, Sweden e-mail:
[email protected] Norbert R. Nowaczyk GeoForschungsZentrum Potsdam Projektbereich 3.3 “Sedimente und Beckenbildung” Telegrafenberg, 14473 Potsdam, Germany e-mail:
[email protected] John Peck Department of Geology University of Akron Akron, OH, 44325-4101, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Dorothy Sack Department of Geography 122 Clippinger Labs Ohio University Athens, OH 45701 USA e-mail:
[email protected] Christopher A. Scholz Department of Earth Sciences Syracuse University Syracuse, New York, 13152, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
xxiv John P. Smol Paleoecological Environmental Assessment and Research Lab (PEARL) Department of Biology Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] C. S. M. Turney School of Archaeology and Palaeoecology Queen’s University Belfast, BT7 1NN UK e-mail:
[email protected] Sjerry van der Gaast NIOZ, P.O. Box 59 NL-1790 AB Den Burg (Texel), The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected] Barbara Wohlfarth Department of Quaternary Geology Lund University Tornavägen 13 S-223 63 Lund, Sweden e-mail:
[email protected] Bernd Zolitschka Geomorphologie und Polarforschung (GEOPOL) Institut für Geographie Universitaet Bremen Celsiusstr. FVG-M D-28359 Bremen, Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
1. AN INTRODUCTION TO BASIN ANALYSIS, CORING, AND CHRONOLOGICAL TECHNIQUES USED IN PALEOLIMNOLOGY
WILLIAM M. LAST (WM_Last@UManitoba. ca) Department of Geological Sciences University of Manitoba Winnipeg, Manitoba R3T 2N2, Canada JOHN P. SMOL (SmolJ@Biology. QueensU. Ca) Paleoecological Environmental Assessment and Research Lab (PEARL) Department of Biology Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario K7L 3N6, Canada Paleolimnology, the interpretation of past conditions and processes in lake basins, is a multidisciplinary science whose roots extend back nearly two centuries. Despite this long history of development, the science has seen a surge of interest and application over the past decade. Today paleolimnology assumes a pivotal role in paleoclimatic and global change investigations, many fields of environmental science, and hydrocarbon and mineral resource exploration and exploitation. Associated with this dramatic increase in research activity involving lake sediments, there has been an equally rapid advance in the techniques and methods used by paleolimnologists. The objective of this volume is to provide a state-of-the-art summary of the major field methods, chronological techniques, and concepts used in the study of large-scale lacustrine basin analysis. This and the other techniques volumes in this series build on the foundation provided by previous compilations of paleoenvironmental techniques, such as Kummel & Raup (1965), Bouma (1969), Carver (1971), Berglund (1986), Gray (1988), Tucker (1988), Warner (1990), and Rutter & Catto (1995), many of which continue to serve as essential handbooks. However, the development of new and different methods for studying lake sediments over the past decade, as well as advancements and modifications to old methods, have provided impetus for a new series of monographs for this rapidly expanding topic. Three additional books from this series deal with other components of paleolimnology. Volume 2 (Last & Smol, 2001) focuses on the vast array of physical, mineralogical, and geochemical parameters that can be applied to the interpretation of lake histories. Volumes 3 and 4 (Smol et al., 2001 a, b) address the great range of biological techniques that have been 1 W. M. Last & J. P. Smol (eds.), 2001. Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
2
WILLIAM M. LAST & JOHN P. SMOL
and continue to be such an important aspect of many paleolimnological efforts. Although chapters in each of these books discuss the quantitative aspects of lake sediment interpretations, a separate volume on statistical and data handling approaches in paleolimmnology is currently in preparation (Birks et al., in preparation). Our intent with this series of volumes is to provide sufficient methodological and technical detail to allow both practitioners and newcomers to the area of paleolimnology to use them as handbooks/laboratory manuals and as primary research texts. Although we recognize that the study of pre-Quaternary lakes is a very rapidly growing component in the vast arena of paleolimnology, this volume is directed primarily towards those involved in Quaternary lacustrine deposits and Quaternary environmental change. Nonetheless, many of the techniques and approaches are applicable to other time frames. Finally, we anticipate that many of the techniques discussed in these volumes apply equally well to marine, estuarine, and other depositional environments, although we have not specifically targeted non-lacustrine settings. This volume contains 16 chapters divided into three parts. As illustrated in Figure 1, the three main components of paleolimnology addressed in Volume 1 are: (i) methods used in the field collection and archiving of sediment cores, (ii) techniques for establishing chronology of the recovered stratigraphic sequence, and (iii) concepts and techniques that can be applied to large-scale lake basin analysis. Following this short introduction, Part I outlines several of the most commonly used basin analysis methods. Often these largescale basin configuration and subsurface remote sensing techniques are a requisite first step for the paleolimnologist, applied prior to sample collection or core site selection. In
AN INTRODUCTION TO BASIN ANALYSIS ...
3
the 1970’s, application of seismic reflection technology to marine settings instigated a major paradigm shift in the traditional science of stratigraphy. These seismic sequence stratigraphy concepts and techniques are now routinely applied in lacustrine basins as summarized by Scholz. In the second chapter of Part I, Moorman discusses ground-penetrating radar (GPR), another geophysical method for lake basin sub-bottom profiling, which offers great promise for paleolimnologists working within freshwater systems. Lake basin geomorphology has traditionally formed the cornerstone for many paleolake investigations extending back to the century. In the final chapter of this section, Sack provides an overview of geomorphological techniques that have been and continue to be of critical importance to many aspects of lake basin research. The four chapters in Part II of this volume summarize the suite of sample acquisition and archiving techniques routinely used in Quaternary paleolimnology. Collecting continuous, undisturbed sediment cores from the upper, highly-fluid portion of a lacustrine sequence presents many technical difficulties. Glew et al. review the wide variety of coring devices that have been implemented to overcome these problems. Paleolimnologists interested in retrieving longer records from extant lakes or in acquiring cores from very deep lacustrine basins similarly face a considerable range of drilling and multiple-entry coring systems as compiled and described by Leroy & Colman. Once a suitable core or series of cores has been collected from a lake, it is desirable to gain as much information about the sediment as possible before actually subsampling and physically altering the recovered sequence. Zolitschka et al. consider the many new logging instruments now available to paleolimnologists that are capable of carrying out rapid, quasi-continuous, non-destructive, high-resolution analyses of the sediment’s physical properties. In the final chapter of Part II, Nowaczyk summarizes the different methods of logging magnetic susceptibility, a sediment parameter that provides not only a valuable tool for core-to-core correlation, but also gives the researcher an indication of sediment composition, provenance (source), and depositional setting. The third and final part of this book deals with techniques that can be used to establish the chronostratigraphic framework of a recovered lacustrine sequence. Age dating of Quaternary deposits is a large and diverse field, which has resulted in many publications. In the first chapter of Part III, Appleby reviews the models and methodologies involved in dating and techniques. The single most the recent (~ ( 150 year) record in lakes: widely used chronostratigraphic tool for paleolimnologists, 14C dating, is summarized in the chapter by Björck & Wohlfarth. Because annually laminated lake deposits are particularly important for high-resolution paleolimnological studies, a considerable effort has been made to establish varve-based chronologies in many lake regions. Lamoureux gives a succinct overview of the construction of varve chronologies, and the methods for assessing the accuracy and consistency of varved records. Optical and thermoluminescence dating techniques, discussed by Lian & Huntley, have been applied extensively to aeolian deposits, but may also provide important chronological control in glacial lake sequences and in nonglacial lakes in which suitable organic matter for 14C analysis is not present. Electron spin resonance (ESR) dating, reviewed by Blackwell, can provide absolute dating over a substantial time range (~0.5 ka to 5–10 Ma). Because of the wide variety of materials that can be dated with this technique, ESR holds considerable promise for establishing the chronology of older Quaternary and late Tertiary lacustrine deposits. King & Peck summarize the chronostratigraphic use of temporal variations in the Earth’s magnetic field
4
WILLIAM M. LAST & JOHN P. SMOL
(geomagnetic secular variation or SV) and magnetostratigraphy. Blackwell provides a comprehensive review of amino acid racemization (AAR) dating and aminostratigraphy, which have been shown to be powerful tools for Quaternary chronostratigraphy and correlation. The geologically instantaneous deposition of atmospheric particles following a volcanic eruption allows tephrochronology to achieve a degree of precision unmatched by nearly any other chronostratigraphic method. In the final chapter of this section, Turney & Lowe discuss some of the recent advances in this technique and outline the methods of identification and correlation of tephra deposits and the establishment of a regional tephrochronological framework. Although we have assumed readers will have a basic knowledge of earth and environmental science jargon, we have included a comprehensive glossary and list of acronyms and abbreviations to assist with the large and perhaps unfamiliar vocabulary. This is followed by a subject index. Some related aspects are not covered in this volume. As we write this, the “lakes of Mars” are common headlines in the popular scientific press. The arsenal of remote sensing tools and techniques that are required for this type of extraterrestrial paleolimnology are not included in this volume (e.g., Warton et al., 1995). Due to space limitations, we have not included summary chapters on traditional field mapping and outcrop description techniques (e.g., Daniel, 1986), which are often part of a Quaternary scientist’s bailiwick. Electrical resistivity methods and several other geophysical mapping and delineation techniques are not specifically discussed, nor do we address any of the large number of “down-hole” petrophysical logging devises that have been occasionally used in Quaternary and preQuaternary paleolimnology, although selected aspects of these topics are covered in several chapters and this topic is also dealt with in Volume 2 (Last & Smol, 2001). As in many other areas of environmental earth science, the continued development of our understanding of the histories of lake basins will depend on the interaction of specialists in a wide range of disciplines. The tools and investigative techniques these specialists bring to bear on the task of characterizing the sediments and fluids within these basins are continuing to advance at a rapid pace. The applications and research avenues fronting paleolimnology are immense, but so are the potential analytical and logistical problems. One of the greatest challenges facing the next generation of paleolimnologists is to maintain the integrated multidisciplinary approach to the study of lake sediments that has evolved over the past decade. We see no evidence that the accelerated rate of progress that this field has enjoyed will be slowing down in the near future. Many new approaches and applications are certainly soon to be discovered, and will hopefully be covered in subsequent volumes of this series. References Berglund, B. E. (ed.), 1986. Handbook of Holocene Palaeoecology and Palaeohydrology. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 869 pp. Birks, H. J. B., S. Juggins, A. Lotter & J. P. Smol, In preparation. Tracking environmental change using lake sediments. Volume 5: Data Handling and Statistical Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands. Bouma, A. H., 1969. Methods for the Study of Sedimentary Structures. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 458 pp. Carver, R. E. (ed.), 1971. Procedures in Sedimentary Petrology. Wiley Interscience, New York, 653 pp.
AN INTRODUCTION TO BASIN ANALYSIS ...
5
Daniel, E., 1986. Geological survey mapping. In Berglund, B. E. (ed.) Handbook of Holocene Palaeoecology and Palaeohydrology. John Wiley & Sons, New York: 195–201. Gray, J. (ed.), 1988. Paleolimnology: Aspects of Freshwater Paleoecology and Biogeography. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 678 pp. Kummel, B. & D. Raup (eds.), 1965. Handbook of Paleontological Techniques. W. H. Freeman and Company, San Francisco, 862 pp. Last, W. M. & J. P. Smol (eds.), 2001. Tracking environmental change using lake sediments. Volume 2: Physical and Geochemical Methods. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 504 pp. Rutter, N. W. & N. R. Catto (eds.), 1995. Dating Methods for Quaternary Deposits. GEOtext 2, Geological Association of Canada, St. John’s, NF., 308 pp. Smol, J. P., H. J. B. Birks & W. M. Last (eds.), 2001a. Tracking environmental change using lake sediments. Volume 3: Terrestrial, Algal, and Siliceous Indicators, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 371 pp. Smol, J. P., H. J. B. Birks & W. M. Last (eds.), 2001b. Tracking environmental change using lake sediments. Volume 4: Zoological Indicators, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands. Tucker, M. E. (ed.), 1988. Techniques in Sedimentology. Blackwell Scientific Publications Ltd., Osney Mead, Oxford, UK, 394 pp. Warner, B. G. (ed.), 1990. Methods in Quaternary Ecology. Geoscience Canada Reprint Series 5, St. John’s, NF., 170pp. Wharton, R. A., J. M. Crosby, C. P. McKay & J. W. Rice, 1995. Paleolakes on Mars. J. Paleolim. 13: 267–283.
This page intentionally left blank
2. APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHY IN LACUSTRINE BASINS
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ (
[email protected]) Department of Earth Sciences Syracuse University, Syracuse NY 13152, USA Keywords: lakes, lacustrine basins, sequence stratigraphy, reflection seismology, seismic stratigraphy, basin analysis, seismic profiling, lacustrine sedimentation
Introduction Sedimentary basin studies in lakes routinely require the imaging or remote characterization of the subsurface, prior to the collection of sediment samples by sediment coring or drilling. Acoustic techniques such as echosounding, sub-bottom seismic reflection profiling, and multibeam or swath bathymetry mapping are commonly employed for lake-bottom and subbottom characterization. Over the past several decades, the proliferation of digital seismic reflection technology is in part responsible for modernizing the discipline of stratigraphy and subsurface analysis, including greatly expanding our understanding of lacustrine basin evolution. Whereas the stratigraphic sciences were formerly dominated by compilations of one-dimensional data sets such as outcrop stratigraphic columns, well-logs or sediment cores, abundant two-dimensional seismic profiles and 3-D seismic volumes now permit the rendering of complex structural and depositional features in the subsurface. This technological transformation has enabled the refinement of stratigraphic concepts initially introduced by Sloss and coworkers (e.g., Sloss, 1963), and which culminated in publications by Vail and colleagues from the oil and gas industry that present the fundamental concepts of seismic sequence stratigraphy (e.g., Payton, 1977; AAPG Memoir 26 and subsequent publications). Their efforts were based largely on basin-scale industry seismic reflection profiles acquired on marine passive margins, but now many researchers have demonstrated that the main concepts of sequence stratigraphy are largely independent of scale and environment. These concepts are now routinely applied in non-marine settings (e.g., Shanley & McCabe, 1998), including lacustrine basins. This chapter presents a brief overview of principles of the seismic reflection technique, a discussion of practical applications on different scales, and concludes with a summary of the unique aspects of seismic sequence stratigraphy in lacustrine systems. Prior to the 1980s digital seismic technology was mainly the domain of large corporations that could afford expensive computer processing power. The proliferation of inexpensive desktop computer technology now makes digital acquisition, processing and 7 W. M. Last & J. P. Smol (eds.), 2001. Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
8
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
sophisticated interpretation procedures accessible to many in academic settings. Whereas analysis of seismic reflection data recorded on analog paper profiles was previously the norm, rapid interpretation and extensive subsurface mapping can now be carried out entirely on computer workstations, with little need for paper reproduction. Seismic sequence stratigraphy applied to lake basins Basin evolution of lacustrine systems encompasses several spatial scales of observation, and a wide range of geological time. Whereas investigations of the Earth’s oldest tectonic lakes consider millions of years of geologic time, many current studies are focused on lakes in existence only since the late Pleistocene or early Holocene (e.g., Tiercelin, 1999). The small size of many lake systems and the lack of energetic geostrophic currents in most lake basins are the most obvious differences between marine and lacustrine sedimentary basins. Additionally, most lakes are inherently closed sedimentary systems, whereas some marine depositional systems may recover or lose sediments from adjacent basins. Because basin physiography is often compressed in lake basins relative to ocean basins, sedimentary facies changes may be abrupt, both laterally and vertically. The hydrologic controls on lake levels are often in a delicate state of balance in many lacustrine basins, particularly those in the tropics or in arid settings. For instance in Lake Malawi, in the southern part of the east African rift, nearly 90% of the water lost from the lake annually is evaporated off its surface, whereas only about 10% of the total water loss is through the lake’s outlet. This produces seasonal fluctuations of 1–2 m in this enormous lake, and long-term changes in water level are measured in the hundreds of meters over time frames of hundreds to thousands of years (Owen et al., 1990). Consequently, the stratigraphic response to environmental or geological change is often highly amplified in these lacustrine basins compared to marine systems. This sensitivity to external forcing produces depositional systems that can be superb high-resolution archives of environmental change, yet in some instances the stratigraphic record from lake basins may be highly punctuated, when considered over long periods of geological time. Theoretical considerations of the seismic reflection method Seismic methods Reflection seismic techniques are routinely employed in the search for oil and gas and were initially introduced more than 80 years ago (Dobrin & Savit, 1988). Past refinements of the methodology in the early years were prompted by opportunities associated with the energy industry and most recent innovations in 3-D seismic technology stem from efforts related to hydrocarbon exploration. Many research volumes and scientific journals are dedicated to reviews of the techniques, and many handbooks (e.g., Sheriff & Geldart, 1995) present a comprehensive treatment of the principles and practice of the seismic method. Marine seismic methods evolved rapidly following World War II, and are now routinely used in coastal and continental margin studies, as well as in lake surveys. The seismic reflection method uses acoustic waves to remotely image the stratigraphic contrasts in sediment physical properties, manifested in sediment lithology. Reflectivity
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
9
across a lithologic interface is quantified as the contrast in acoustic impedance, the product of saturated bulk density and P-wave velocity of the adjacent sediments (e.g., Sheriff & Geldart, 1995; Dobrin & Savit, 1988). The seismic response to the layered earth reflectivity is produced when a percussive source signal is imparted into the earth, and energy reflected from lithologic boundaries is recorded on the Earth’s surface. In the case of lake surveys, source energy is generated by a towed source array, that may consist of a transducer, boomer plate, sparker, airgun or similar sound-generating device. In the case of land surveys, receiving signals are recorded by ground accelerations, and in the marine or lacustrine case by passage of a pressure wave past a hydrophone. Swept frequency pulse or CHIRP systems (e.g., Schock & LeBlanc, 1990) are now commonly used in many marine and lacustrine studies. Rather than employ a percussive source, the swept frequency pulse system generates a prolonged pulse over a range of frequencies that is later correlated to replicate an impulsive spike. Advantages of CHIRP systems are their lower electrical power demands compared to impulsive sound sources, and their ability to return data of variable resolution using a broad bandwidth pulse. Repetitive firing of the seismic source along a given vessel transect yields profiles that are composed of hundreds or thousands of discrete seismic traces. Single channel seismic profiling methods Single-channel seismic (SCS) reflection techniques assume that source and receiver positions are coincident or nearly so, such that the seismic rays travel along a normal incidence pathway from source to reflecting horizon and back to the receiving array. The operational aspects of this technique are simple and straightforward, and usually involve a towed source and receiver array close to one another, and both towed close to the stern of the research vessel. Whereas SCS surveys are operationally and logistically simple to deploy, they provide only the most fundamental subsurface information. Sources of coherent noise that develop from water bottom or interbed multiples may be difficult to extract from primary reflections, and overall signal-to-noise ratio may be modest compared with data acquired using multichannel methods. No seismic velocity information is derived from SCS data. Multichannel seismic profiling methods Multichannel (MCS) or common midpoint (CMP) seismic reflection profiling involves the deployment of long receiver arrays to concentrate raypaths and produce an “acoustic lens” over successive reflecting points in the subsurface (Fig. 1). This requires considerable post-acquisition seismic processing, including resorting numerous returning signals or traces from the shot domain to the common midpoint domain (e.g., Fig. 1). Following the application of the “normal moveout” correction of traces that are offset from the source in order to bring arrivals from the same horizon to similar arrival times, traces are summed or “stacked”, resulting in significantly enhanced signal/noise over the common reflecting point. Additionally, MCS data yield information on the seismic velocity structure of the subsurface, which permits time-to-depth conversions of seismic reflection profiles. Desktop computers now have the processing power necessary for completing processing on all but the largest of pre-stack MCS data sets. The procedures for acquiring and processing marinetype MCS are highly refined, and are identical for marine and lake surveys (see Sheriff &
10
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
Geldart, 1995; Dobrin & Savit 1988 for additional discussions). In general, the limiting factor in the deployment of MCS operations on lakes is the size of the air compressor systems required for delivering high-pressure air to large airgun arrays. Consequently, MCS operations generally require deployments from larger research vessels. Seismic stratigraphic interpretation methods The application of seismic methods to stratigraphic problems greatly expanded following the proliferation of digital seismic methods and the resulting improvements in the fidelity of subsurface records. The stratigraphic analysis of seismic reflection profiles uses the characterization of stratal relationships, in the form of reflection terminations, to identify breaks and changes in the sedimentary record of a basin. Principal stratal relationships and their importance in deciphering basin histories are described in Table I, and can also be applied to basin studies in lacustrine basins, as is demonstrated in Figures 2–4. Several assumptions are made in seismic stratigraphic analysis. Foremost among these is that seismic reflections have chronostratigraphic significance, and that discrete reflections represent time lines from which relative stratigraphic and structural histories within the basin can be derived. Early sequence stratigraphers reached this conclusion empirically, following the examination of many thousands of kilometers of marine seismic profiles. We adhere to a similar assumption in our sequence stratigraphic analyses of lacustrine basins.
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
11
12
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
13
Practical considerations, instrumentation and scales of observation The ages of modern lake basins span several orders of magnitude. In many areas that were inundated by continental ice sheets during the last glaciation, lakes have only been in existence for ~ 10 ka, whereas deep tectonic lakes such as Lakes Baikal and Tanganyika are likely more than 10 ma in age (Cohen et al., 1993; Mats 1993). Consequently, the sediment fills of lakes of different sizes and ages will differ dramatically, and thus demand markedly different tools for thorough subsurface investigations. Presented here are discussions of three different survey approaches useful for: 1) “basin-scale” surveys of the largest of the world’s tectonic lake basins; for 2) sedimentary facies scale studies requiring “intermediate resolution” seismic methods; and 3) high-resolution seismic tools for detailed site surveys and analyses of the late-Quaternary. Deep basin-scale studies The world’s oldest and most deeply subsided lakes are typically of tectonic origin (Herdendorf, 1990; Johnson, 1984) and may contain sediment fills that are measured in thicknesses of many kilometers. For instance the maximum sediment fill of the Lake Baikal Rift is estimated to be more than 9km (Scholz et al., 1998) and the basin is thought to be more than 25 M.Y. in age (Mats, 1993). Similarly, Lake Tanganyika in the east African rift is also a lacustrine rift basin, and has a sediment fill of more than 5 km and is thought to be 9–12 M.Y. in age (Cohen et al., 1993). In order to image through several kilometers of lacustrine sediment, seismic imaging tools that are routinely employed in marine basins using large research vessels are necessary. Although small, specialized lake seismic vessels are used under some circumstances, (e.g., Rosendahl & Livingstone, 1983), larger “ships of opportunity” are commonly the most practical approach for such surveys. Imaging to depths of several kilometers in the subsurface requires large acoustic sources and long receiver arrays. In general, large airgun arrays (totaling more than several hundred cubic inches), such as are used in marine surveys, provide the best subsurface penetration. Maximum receiver offsets (or total length of hydrophone streamer arrays) are used that are of the same order of the desired or anticipated maximum depth of penetration. For instance, Figure 5 shows a seismic image from Lake Baikal that used a 3000 m-long streamer with 48 channels to recover the crystalline basement reflection at a two-way travel time of about 5 seconds. Lower frequency sources (4–50 Hz) commonly yield much improved penetration of the sediment column, but with a significantly diminished vertical resolution than higher frequency sources. Multichannel seismic acquisition programs will commonly yield images of the lake subsurface through soft sediment as well as through great thicknesses of lithified material down to bedrock or crystalline basement rocks. First order depositional sequences can be observed in such data sets (e.g., Fig. 4), representing major changes in tectonic conditions or profound drainage basin alterations. The ability to penetrate considerable thicknesses of section comes with a major trade-off in seismic resolution. A rule-of-thumb for estimating the thickness of the minimum resolvable bed (vertical resolution) is 1/4 of the wave length of the signal (e.g., Sheriff & Geldart, 1995; Dobrin & Savit, 1988). For instance, an industry “standard” seismic source array, with a bandwidth of ~8–50 Hz, will typically yield a maximum vertical resolution of ~25 m with normal seismic velocities at mid-
14
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
basinal depths. Whereas major unconformities can be observed on such profiles, it is rare for detailed information about depositional facies to be easily extracted from such lowresolution images (e.g., Fig. 5). Sedimentary basins that have total sediment thicknesses of less than 500 m do not necessarily require such low frequency source arrays to image the complete sedimentary section.
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
15
Multichannel seismic techniques offer enhanced signal-to-noise ratios compared to single-channel seismic systems, and in particular permit the suppression of coherent noise on seismic records. Pre-stack processing routines offer a variety of approaches to suppression of unwanted noise, and for enhancing the geologic signals in the data (e.g., Yilmaz, 1987). Information on the basin seismic velocity structure is also obtained from MCS surveys, and can be extremely useful for constraining true basin geometries and lithofacies characteristics. Velocity information is commonly required for siting deep scientific boreholes and for producing accurate reconstructions of complex structures in the subsurface. The operational deployment of MCS systems can be complex, however, and such programs are typically undertaken only on large lakes with the support of well-equipped research vessels. The calibration of deep basin scale MCS data requires the collection of data from deep penetrating scientific boreholes or oil wells. Such boreholes are usually drilled only in conjunction with major scientific drilling programs or during hydrocarbon exploration. In the case of oil field or deep scientific drilling, down-hole geophysical tools are used to help characterize subsurface lithologies, and these data can be used to tightly calibrate or constrain coincident seismic profiles. Many of the world’s largest lakes have been surveyed using MCS techniques, including the East African Rift Valley Lakes (e.g., Rosendahl, 1987), Lake Baikal (e.g., Hutchinson et al., 1992), and Lake Superior (Cannon et al., 1989). The focus of these studies has been on basin evolution, long time-frame studies of paleoclimates, and on deciphering long-term tectonic histories. Sedimentary fades scale studies using intermediate resolution seismic reflection tools Projects focused on the characterization of sedimentary facies variations within lake basins are carried out using seismic sources with a higher frequency range than the large airgun source arrays described above. For instance instruments with a bandwidth of ~50– ~ 1000 Hz, which include small airguns and sparkers, can penetrate through all types of unconsolidated materials including mud, coarse sands and gravel. Sparkers often produce the best compromise between depth of penetration and resolution for facies evaluation (e.g., Back et al., 1998). However sparkers can be hazardous to handle, and require a conductive medium for shooting. Thus when used in freshwater lakes, sparker sources must be deployed in a container or bag containing salt water. Under ideal conditions, small airgun source arrays can also penetrate as much as 1–2 km into the subsurface (Fig. 6). Such sources, when combined with a digital single-channel seismic systems, are very effective at constraining facies geometries in most modern sedimentary environments. At a peak frequency of ~250Hz and a mean seismic velocity of <2000m/sec, the vertical resolution of intermediate-resolution seismic systems is ~l–2m. Surveys using this instrumentation are of significant utility on a wide variety of lake basins, and are useful for characterizing depositional architecture, for neotectonic studies and for Plio-Pleistocene paleoclimate studies. Ground-truth calibration of seismic data sets of this type involves the shallow drilling of scientific boreholes to depths of hundreds of meters into the subsurface. Whereas both single-channel and multichannel receiver geometries can be employed in
16
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
these surveys, the ease of deployment of SCS systems makes this type of approach most common in lake environments. High-resolution seismic tools High-resolution seismic tools use high-frequency transducers, electromagnetic plates (boomers) or swept-frequency sources (CHIRP systems) to generate signals that penetrate from a few 10’s of meters to a few hundred meters into the subsurface under ideal circumstances. Such systems are the tool of choice for siting soft-sediment cores intended to sample late-Quaternary sediments. Because the source bandwidth of such systems may range from ~1 kHz to ~6–12 kHz depending on the specific instrumentation, it is possible to resolve sedimentary features and horizons with a vertical resolution as fine as 10– 20cm (Fig. 7). Although very effective at imaging fine-grained and water-saturated muds, they are generally unable to penetrate or image coarse sand or gravel deposits to any significant degree. Operationally, such sources are almost always used in SCS mode, and are commonly deployed from relatively small research vessels, or even from inflatable boats. Power requirements vary with the specific source, but small portable generators generally provide satisfactory electrical power to drive high-resolution seismic systems. Calibration of high-resolution seismic data can be accomplished with standard wire-line deployable oceanographic or limnological core samplers. Measurements of bulk sediment density and seismic velocity (see chapter on physical properties studies) can be used to
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
17
create synthetic seismograms, and in many instances precisely link core information directly to seismic data. Sequence stratigraphic interpretation of lacustrine seismic reflection data Marine versus lacustrine controls on depositional sequences Depositional sequences are thought to be the stratigraphic building blocks of all sedimentary basins (Vail, 1987). Sequences differ from geological formations, in that they are chronostratigraphically constrained packages of sediments or sedimentary rocks, that are bounded at the top and the bottom by unconformities, whereas formations are lithologically distinctive groupings of strata that are, in some cases, time-transgressive. Seismic reflection data are a tremendous benefit to stratigraphic interpretation, because these data permit observations of distinct subsurface stratal geometries in two dimensions, which is the key to establishing the sequence-based stratigraphic framework of the basin. The main controls on the formation of depositional sequences in sedimentary basins are eustasy (sea- or lake-level change), subsidence, and sediment supply (e.g., Vail, 1987). In addition to these three main controls, other factors such as pre-existing slope or basin morphology (Sarg & Pratson, 2000), and sediment compaction and flexural isostasy (Reynolds et al., 1991) may also significantly modify the structure and geometry of depositional sequences. Whereas the three primary controls or variables are essentially independent in marine systems, they are connected to a high degree in lacustrine basins, which are effectively closed depositional systems. For instance in marine basins, sediment supply and sea level are largely unrelated over most periods of the Phanerozoic. However in lake
18
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
basins, lake levels and sediment influx will likely be tightly coupled through regional climate and hydrology, although not necessarily in a direct, linear relationship. Global water level fluctuations in the oceans are controlled by glacio-eustasy, and local sea level changes in marine basins are controlled by subsidence, crustal rebound, sedimentation (e.g., delta progradation) or one of the other controlling factors listed above. In lacustrine basins, maximum potential lake levels are ultimately controlled by basin sill depth, which can be altered by tectonic or erosive events (Scholz et al., 1998). Where the outflow point or sill depth of a lake is situated in a geologically dynamic location, catastrophic changes in lake level can result. Lake hydrology, which is dominantly controlled by the balance between precipitation and evapotranspiration/evaporation in the catchment/lake, will control lake levels on shortduration time frames (e.g., Scholz et al., 1998). When hydrology and sediment input are factored together, lake basins can be classified between either underfilled or overfilled endmember models (Carroll & Bohacs, 1999).Lake basins that are underfilled by a combination of water and sediment may produce rapid lake level responses, whereas overfilled basins, where most of the water leaves the system through the lake outlet, may experience long-term lake level stability. Because the sedimentation rates of lake systems tend to be considerably higher than marine systems, high-frequency cyclical processes are far easier to observe directly in seismic records from lake basins than in records from most marine settings. For example, sedimentation rates of l–10cm/ka are common in marine settings, yet the combination of the muted response for the marine system to the climatic cycles, with the slow sedimentation rates, yields seismic images that generally do not resolve climate cycles that develop at orbital (Milankovitch) frequencies. However the stratigraphic response to climate forcing is commonly amplified in many lacustrine systems, inducing enormous fluctuations in lake level or in sediment input. Given that overall lacustrine sedimentation rates are an order of magnitude (or more) higher than in marine systems, it is possible to directly observe orbital scale climate cyclicity in intermediate- or high-resolution seismic reflection records (e.g., Scholz, 1995; Lezzar et al., 1996). Figure 8 illustrates a series of stacked sublacustrine fans from Lake Malawi where ~40–100m-thick packages of sublacustrine fan deposits alternate with deep-water hemipelagic sediment. This geometry is thought to be generated by l00ka climate cycles in the Pleistocene, in response to fluctuating lake levels in Lake Malawi (Scholz, 1995). Indicators of lake level change in seismic reflection records Seismic reflection records commonly record strong evidence for changing lake level conditions. Examples of specific indicators of past lake levels include erosional truncation surfaces, beach berms, and low stand progradational delta deposits. Unconformities in the form of erosional truncation surfaces may indicate areas and episodes of subaerial exposure within a sedimentary section. Whereas erosion can develop subaqueously in large marine basins because of contour currents or through major downslope disturbances, such erosional areas are limited to localized slides and slumps lacustrine basins. In localities where erosional truncation surfaces can be mapped around the rim of a basin with a dense set of seismic reflection records, a valid case can be made for an extended period of low lake conditions (e.g., Fig. 9).
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
19
20
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
Perhaps the best indicator of instantaneous low lake or paleoshoreline conditions are progradational low stand delta deposits (Fig. 3). The “roll-over” transitions from topset to foreset strata on a delta clinoform packages are commonly interpreted to indicate the “depositional shelf break”, which generally forms just lakeward of the frontal distributary mouth bar in most lacustrine deltas. The classic clinoform geometry can thus be used to establish a record of low lake levels, especially when several deltas advancing into a lake yield comparable geometries in similar water depths and stratigraphic levels in the subsurface. The several tropical lakes mentioned above are among the largest and oldest lakes in the world, and it is these ancient lakes at the lower latitudes that seem prone to dramatic shifts in lake level. Many Alpine and glacial lakes of Europe and North America have been investigated using seismic reflection methods (e.g., Mullins et al., 1996; Giovanoli et al., 1982; Houbolt & Jonker, 1968). In general, these lakes existed only since the terminal Pleistocene deglaciation. Whereas lake levels in these systems rose and fell dramatically during deglaciation, they are generally overfilled systems that have had relatively stable water levels for much of the Holocene, at least compared to the highly reactive lakes of the lower latitudes. Summary Seismic sequence stratigraphy provides an approach to lacustrine basin analysis that is useful at many scales of observation. As has been observed in the case of marine systems, hierarchies of depositional sequences can be observed using different types of imaging tools, each of which offers different types of geological information. Deep-penetrating multichannel seismic imaging provides extensive information on ancient basins, and the sequences observed in these records provide histories of basin evolution and tectonism. Intermediate-resolution seismic systems and mid-range seismic sources, such as small airguns and sparkers, permit observations and analyses of depositional facies architecture in lake basins. High-resolution seismic tools are ideal for late-Quaternary studies, for imaging fine-grained and unlithified sediments, and for locating ideal coring sites for Holocene and late-Pleistocene sediment sampling in lakes. Seismic sequence analysis in lacustrine basins is similar to the approach taken in marine basins; the stratigraphic framework is established by mapping unconformities using reflection terminations and stratal relationships observed on two-dimensional seismic reflection profiles. Because stratigraphic forcing mechanisms, however, behave somewhat differently in lake basins, care must be taken to avoid model-driven interpretations based on principles developed wholly from the classic marine examples. For instance, changes in available accommodation space in marine systems are measured on scales of less than 100–200 m in marine basins, and the frequency of glacio-eustatic sea level change is typically measured on a time frame of tens of thousands of years. In lake basins however, the amplitude of lake level change may be measured in hundreds of meters in large basins, and shifts of this magnitude occur on century-to-millennial time frames. Depositional slopes may be steep in some tectonic lake basins, and the resulting facies transitions are commonly abrupt. Classic components of the marine-based sequence model, such as transgressive systems tracts, may thus be exceedingly thin and difficult to image seismically in lacustrine systems. Whereas glacio-eustasy is a common controlling process in the evolution of marine basins,
APPLICATIONS OF SEISMIC SEQUENCE …
21
even adjacent lake basins may be controlled by radically different climate regimes and hydrologies. Consequently the development of lake basin sequences may be highly variable in space and time.
Acknowledgments Over the past several years my ideas on lacustrine sequence stratigraphy have matured through discussions with numerous colleagues, including, M. de Batist, M. Soreghan, H. T. Mullins, D. J. Reynolds, J. Neal, F. Anselmetti, K. Lezzar, A. Cohen, J. J. Tiercelin, K. Bohacs, and A. Carroll.
References Back, S., M. De Batist, P. Kirillov, M. R. Strecker & P. Vanhauwaert, 1998. The Frolikha Fan; a large Pleistocene glaciolacustrine outwash fan in northern Lake Baikal, Siberia. J. Sed. Res. 68: 841–849. Cannon, W. F., A. G. Green, D. R. Hutchinson, M. W. Lee, B. Milkereit, J. C. Behrendt, H. C. Halls, J. C. Green, A. B. Dickas, G. B. Morey, R. H. Sutcliffe & C. Spencer, 1989. The North American Midcontinent Rift beneath Lake Superior from GLIMPCE seismic reflection profiling. Tectonics 8: 305–332. Carroll, A. R. & K. M. Bohacs, 1999. Stratigraphic classification of ancient lakes; balancing tectonic and climatic controls. Geology 27: 99–102. Cohen, A. S., M. J. Soreghan & C. A. Scholz, 1993. Estimating the age of lakes: An example from Lake Tanganyika, East African Rift system. Geology 21: 511–514. Dobrin, M. B. & C. H. Savit, 1988. Introduction to Geophysical Prospecting. McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York, NY, United States, 867 pp. Giovanoli, F., G. Eberli, P. Finckh, W. Finger, Q. He, C. Heim, K. Kelts, G. Lister, C. Peng, C. Sidler, X. Zhao & K. Hsu, 1982. Zubo 80, a 200 m core in the deepest part of the alpine Lake Zuerich, Switzerland; geophysical investigations. Eleventh international congress on sedimentology. Hamilton, ON, Canada: Aug. 22–27, 1982, International Congress on Sedimentology 11: 129. Johnson, T. C., 1984. Sedimentation in large lakes. Ann. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 12: 179–204. Herdendorf, C. E., 1990. Distribution of the world’s large lakes. In Tilzer, M. M. & C. Serruya (eds.) Large Lakes. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 3–38. Houbolt, J. J. H. C. & J. B. M. Jonker, 1968. Recent sediments in the eastern part of the Lake of Geneva (Lac Leman). Geologie en Mijnbouw 47: 131–148. Hutchinson D. R., A. J. Golmstok, L. P. Zonenshain, T. C. Moore, C. A. Scholz & K. D. Klitgord, 1992. Depositional and tectonic framework of the rift basins of Lake Baikal from multichannel seismic data. Geology 20: 589–592. Lezzar, K. E., J.-J. Tiercelin, M. De Baptist, A. S. Cohen, T. Bandora, P. Van Rensbergen, C. Le Turdu, W. Mifundi & J. Klerx, 1996. New seismic stratigraphy and late-tertiary history of the north Tanganyika basin, East African Rift system, deduced from multichannel and high-resolution reflection seismic data and piston core evidence. Basin Research 8: 1–28. Mats, V. D., 1993. The Structure and development of the Baikal rift depression. Earth-Science Reviews 34:81–118. Moore, T. C., Jr., K. D. Klitgord, A. J. Golmshtok & E. Weber, 1997. Sedimentation and subsidence patterns in the central and north basins of Lake Baikal from seismic stratigraphy. Geological Society of America Bulletin 109: 746–766.
22
CHRISTOPHER A. SCHOLZ
Mullins, H. T., E. J. Hinchey, R. W. Wellner, D. B. Stephens, W. T. Anderson Jr., T. R. Dwyer & A. C. Hine, 1996. Seismic stratigraphy of the Finger Lakes; a continental record of Heinrich event H-1 and Laurentide ice sheet instability, in Subsurface geologic investigations of New York Finger Lakes; implications for late Quaternary deglaciation and environmental change. Special Paper, Geological Society of America 311: 1–35. Owen, R. B., R. Crossley, T. C. Johnson, D. Tweddle, I. Kornfield, S. Davison & D. H. Eccles, 1990. Major low levels of Lake Malawi and their implications for speciation rates in cichlid fishes. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci. B 240: 519–553. Payton, C. E., 1977. Seismic stratigraphy; applications to hydrocarbon exploration. American Association of Petroleum Geologists Memoir 26: 477–502. Reynolds, D. J., M. S. Steckler & B. J. Coakley, 1991. The role of the sediment load in sequence stratigraphy; the influence of flexural isostasy and compaction. J. Geophys. Res. B 96:6931–6949. Rosendahl, B. R., 1987. Architecture of continental rifts with special reference to East Africa. Ann. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 15: 445–503. Rosendahl, B. R. & D. A. Livingstone, 1983. Rift lakes of East Africa, new seismic data and implications for future research. Episodes 1983: 14–19. Sarg, J. F. & L. Pratson, 2000. Erosional surfaces in sedimentary sequences and the impact of basin slope and relief on lowstand depositional geometry. (Abstract) AAPG 2000 Annual Convention. p.A131. Schock, S. & L. R. Leblanc, 1990. CHIRP sonar; new technology for sub-bottom profiling. Sea Technology 31: 35–43. Shanley, K. W. & P. J. McCabe, 1998. Relative role of eustasy, climate, and tectonism in continental rocks. Special Publication, SEPM (Society for Sedimentary Geology), no. 59. Scholz, C. A., 1995. Deltas of the Lake Malawi Rift, East Africa, Seismic Expression and Exploration Implications. AAPG Bulletin 79: 1679–1697. Scholz, C. A, T. C. Moore, D. R. Hutchinson, K. D. Klitgord & A. Ja. Golmshtok, 1998. Comparative Sequence Stratigraphy of Low-Latitude versus High-Latitude Lacustrine Rift Basins: Seismic Data Examples from the East African and Baikal Rifts. Palaeogeogr, Palaeoclim, Palaeoecol 140: 401–420. Sheriff, R. E. & L. P. Geldart, 1995. Exploration seismology. Cambridge University Press, GBR, 592 pp. Sloss, L. L., 1963. Sequences in the cratonic interior of North America. Geological Society of America Bulletin 74: 93–113. Tiercelin, J.-J. (ed.), 1999. Proceedings of the second International Congress of Limnogeology, Brest France, May 1999. Vail, P. R., 1987. Seismic stratigraphy interpretation using sequence stratigraphy, in atlas of seismic stratigraphy. Bally, A. W. (ed.) AAPG Studies in Geology #27, vol. 1, pp. 1–10. Yilmaz, O., 1987. Seismic data processing. Soc. Explor. Geophys., Tulsa, OK, United States, 526 pp.
3. GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS IN PALEOLIMNOLOGY
BRIAN J. MOORMAN (
[email protected]) Earth Science Program University of Calgary 2500 University Drive Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4, Canada Keywords: ground-penetrating radar, GPR, geophysics, sub-bottom profiling, bathymetric mapping
Introduction Application of ground-penetrating radar to mapping lake basins
One of the initial requirements for many paleolimnological studies is a bathymetric map and an estimation of the distribution, thickness, and stratigraphy of the sediments underlying the lake. This aids in locating coring sites and conducting the overall basin analysis. Of the two main geophysical methods suitable for sub-bottom profiling, namely ground-penetrating radar (GPR) and sonar, GPR offers the ability to survey in the winter through an ice cover, simplifying surveying and coring. Sonar systems require the transponder to be in direct contact with the water. Ground-penetrating radar also offers the advantage of providing fully digital data that makes the process of data manipulation and interpretation simpler and easier. Modern GPR systems are compact and light-weight enough to be easily operated by one or two persons on foot or from a vehicle. The biggest limitation of GPR for surveying lakes is the large impact salinity has on reducing the depth of penetration of the signal. Ground-penetrating radar is not suitable for imaging through saline water. This section of the book will include a discussion of the theoretical concepts underlying GPR operation and the application of GPR for paleolimnological research. Groundpenetrating radar is widely utilized for a wide variety of geoscience applications from imaging permafrost and glaciers, to delineating groundwater contamination. Accordingly there are many configurations of GPR systems and survey designs. The GPR concepts and system configurations applicable to paleolimnology and lake basin analysis will be discussed here. 23 W. M. Last & J. P. Smol (eds.), 2001. Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
24
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
Instrumentation There are currently a number of different GPR systems on the market that are suitable for surveying lakes. They all have slightly different configurations, however, as shown in Figure 1, they are all comprised of five main components 1) control unit, 2) transmitter, 3) receiver, 4) antennas, and 5) interface, data storage, and display module. The control unit receives the survey parameters from the interface and generates the timing signals for the transmitter and receiver. It also receives the data from the receiver and does the initial processing before sending it to the storage device. In some systems the interface, data storage, display and control unit are all incorporated into one unit. In other systems, the control unit is separate and a laptop or palmtop computer is employed to enter the survey parameters, store the data, and provide real-time data display. On the command of the control unit, the transmitter generates the electromagnetic pulse that is emitted through an antenna connected to it. The transmitter/antenna pair determine the centre frequency and bandwidth of the signal that is sent into the ground. An antenna identical to that attached to the transmitter is attached to the receiver. This antenna intercepts reflected energy and sends it to the receiver where it is amplified, digitized and sent to the control unit. The time versus received energy graph is called a trace. Data are collected at
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
25
frequent intervals along a profile, such that the traces can be plotted side by side, creating a pseudo-section through the ground. In higher frequency system (e.g., greater than approximately 300 MHz) the antennas can be shielded from unwanted externally generated electromagnetic (EM) energy. If the antennas are shielded, standard wire data cables can be used to connect the transmitter and receiver to the control unit. At lower frequencies the antennas are larger and it is difficult to effectively shield them, thus they are susceptible to the EM noise produced by the electrical signals being sent down a wire communications cable. Thus, fibre optic cables are frequently employed when the antennas are not shielded. Ground-penetrating radar systems generally have resistively loaded dipole antennas with fixed frequencies. As such, GPR systems are designed such that antennas can be easily switched and multiple sets of antennas can be tested at the study site to determine the optimal frequency to utilize in a given setting. In general, GPR antenna frequencies vary from 12.5 MHz up to 1000 MHz. History The history of GPR is a relatively short one, and can be divided into four stages of development. The first stage was characterized by initial equipment experimentation. The first application of EM energy to finding metal objects is attributed to Hulsmeyer (1904). Lowy (1911) developed a technique that would give an indication of the depth of subsurface interfaces, but the use of radar for mapping through geologic materials was first carried out by Stern (1930). Over the next three decades there was very little activity in the field, mainly due to lack of application identification. It was not until the 1960’s that interest in radar technology for subsurface imaging applications started to take hold. The second stage of development saw the custom construction of systems built for specific purposes. Early systems were designed for applications such as measuring ice thickness (Behrendt et al., 1979; Bently et al., 1979; Bryan, 1974; Evans, 1963; Steenson, 1951), mapping bedrock structures in underground mines (Cook, 1973; 1975; 1977; Dellwig & Bare, 1978), and finding the location of hidden pipes and utilities (Caldecott et al., 1988; Morey, 1974; 1976; Osumi & Ueno, 1988). Some work was done on measuring the depth of shallow water (Austin & Austin, 1974; Ulriksen, 1982); however, the study of glaciers and ice caps, salt, coal, and hard rock mines dominated this early work with GPR. The third stage of development was issued in with the development of the first commercial analog GPR system (Lerner, 1974). In the 1970’s the activity level dramatically increased, with a variety of applications identified. However, the moderate system performance of early commercial systems and the lack of digital data processing capabilities limited their utility. These systems tended to be large and heavy creating logistical problems for their use. In the mid 1980’s the first digital GPR system was introduced by Sensors and Software of Mississauga, Ontario, beginning the fourth and most recent stage of development. This system had a higher system performance, enabling deeper depth of penetration, and it generated digital data which was suitable for computer processing and manipulating. During the 1990’s GPR has become a standard tool for a variety of geologic, geotechnical, and
26
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
environmental applications. The current systems have fast data processors and data transfer systems, robust designs, and are small enough to be carried in a boat, on a sled or in a backpack (Fig. 2). Ground-penetrating radar theory Signal propagation The strong relationship between the physical properties of geologic materials (including water) and their electromagnetic properties enables the identification of physical structures in the subsurface using electrical methods (Davis & Annan, 1989; Dallimore & Davis, 1987; Delaney & Arcone, 1982; Scott et al., 1978). The large contrast between the EM properties of water and those of sediment makes GPR a particularly effective method for mapping lake basins. Most geologic materials (in bulk form) are considered as semi-conductors, or dielectrics, thus they can be characterized by three electromagnetic properties: electrical conductivity, electric permittivity, and magnetic permeability. The electrical conductivity of a material is a measure of its ability to transmit a DC current and is inversely proportional to the voltage drop experienced across a given distance for a given DC current. Magnetic permeability is defined as the ratio of the magnetic flux induction to the magnetizing force. The magnetic susceptibility of a material is a function of the permeability. Electrical permittivity is the
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
27
ratio of the capacitance of an electrical condenser filled with a dielectric to the capacitance of the same condenser when evacuated. The movement of electromagnetic energy within the subsurface is governed by the propagation constant of the material it travels through. The basic propagation constant of electromagnetic waves in free space is defined as:
where is the frequency in radians, is the magnetic permeability of free space and is the electric permittivity of free space. In the ground, electromagnetic propagation is complicated by the electrical conductivity of the material it travels through. The calculation of the propagation constant becomes:
where and are the magnetic permeability, the electric permittivity, and the DC electrical conductivity of the material, respectively, and i is As the magnetic permeability of most sediment and water is of minor consequence in GPR applications (Telford et al., 1976), the value for free space, is usually used. The electric permittivity is of great importance in GPR applications and is usually expressed in the form of the relative permittivity or dielectric constant:
where is the complex dielectric constant and is termed the dielectric constant and is the loss factor. Thus the electromagnetic propagation factor in the subsurface can be expressed as: where is the dielectric constant factor, is the dielectric loss factor, and is the DC conductivity loss factor. This equation demonstrates how the DC conductivity and the complex dielectric constant are both important in determining the amount of energy which will be dispersed in a given material. This is especially important if the lake you are profiling has a salinity greater than about 10 mS/m (see section on Depth of Penetration). The dielectric constants for a variety materials are given in Table I. The rate at which electromagnetic energy is dissipated in the ground is measured by the attenuation coefficient, which is defined as:
where and c is the speed of light in free space, With the conductivity and the dielectric constant being the dominant influence on the attenuation coefficient A-CUBED (1983) gives an estimation of the attenuation using:
or
28
where is measured in in Table I.
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
The rate of attenuation in a variety of materials is given
Signal reflection Ground-penetrating radar principles are similar to those of reflection seismic, in that a pulse of energy is sent into the subsurface, and a portion of it is reflected back to the surface by interfaces between different materials. In contrast to seismic, GPR energy is electromagnetic, not vibrational, and the interfaces are dielectric, not sonic velocity interfaces. Most ground-penetrating radar antennae are poorly focused. In water, the energy is transmitted with a near radial geometry (Davis & Annan, 1989). This results in several simple ray paths which the energy tends to follow, travelling between the transmitter and the receiver (Fig. 1). After the transmitter has emitted a signal, the first energy to arrive at the receiver is the direct air wave. This is the first because it travels directly from the transmitter to the receiver, through the air (at near the speed of light). As the travel time of the direct air wave is easily calculated and stays relatively constant, its arrival time is often used as a marker for static correction. The next return is the direct ground wave. It travels directly from the transmitter to the receiver through the top skin of the subsurface. The next returns are the reflections from the dielectric interfaces. They arrive in order of their depth (top
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
29
first). The radar waves may also be refracted, however wide-angle reflection and refraction soundings have shown that refracted returns are not usually generated in normal profiling mode (Arcone & Delaney 1982). Due to the complexity of refracted radar waves, detailed analysis has yet to been done on refracted waves as it has in refraction seismic. The three variables that affect the strength and arrival time of returns are: the strength of the reflections, the propagation velocity of the radar waves, and the rate of attenuation of the signal. Just as light is reflected from an interface between two substances with different refractive indexes, a portion of the energy in a radar energy pulse is reflected from an interface between two materials with different dielectric constants. The percentage of the incident energy that is reflected is proportional to the difference of the dielectric constants. Reflection coefficient (R) for vertical incidence between two perfectly dielectric materials is given by:
where and are the dielectric constants of the two media (A-CUBED, 1983). The reflection coefficient for several common interfaces is given in Table II. Due to the length of radar waves, the reflection coefficient from thin layers is also proportional to the frequency of the energy and the thickness of the layer. In materials that are very heterogeneous, small objects (which act like point reflectors) and thin layers are the cause of a great deal of backscatter. This can be used to characterize the material, however, it is often considered as geologic noise. Annan & Davis (1977) and A-CUBED Inc. (1983) discuss this extensively in relation to the range of GPR systems. Lake-bottom multiples (also known as secondary reflections) were observed on some profiles beneath the lake bottom (Fig. 3). They are easy to distinguish from sub-bottom reflectors because they have the exact same shape as the lake bottom reflector, and arrive after double the travel time of the bottom reflector. In the example shown in Figure 3, some of the sub-bottom features are also displayed in the lake bottom multiple. Generally, the lake bottom multiples arrived substantially after the deepest reflections, such that there was no interference between primary and secondary reflections. There is only potential for interference in lakes where there is extremely good sub-bottom penetration or the water depth is very shallow. For example, with silt underlying a lake, the ratio
30
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
of depth of penetration to water depth would have to be greater than 3:1 before interference between the primary and secondary reflections would occur. In a 7 m deep lake the secondary bottom reflection will arrive at the same time as primary sub-bottom reflections from 14 m beneath the lake bottom. In shallow portions of lakes (i.e. less than 2 m deep) the potential for interference from lake bottom multiples increases, however lacustrine sediments tend to be much thinner near the lake edges. The three main types of GPR reflections generated from the bottom of a lake or from within the sub-bottom sediments are: 1) continuous line, 2) hyperbolic curve, and 3) chaotic. A continuous line reflection is found to result from a continuous, horizontal to sloping interface. A-CUBED Inc. (1983) describe in detail the reflections expected from simple single interfaces and closely spaced multiple interfaces. Hyperbolic reflections are produced by small bodies (i.e. around the size of the radar wavelength around cm in diameter) which have a considerably different dielectric constant than the surrounding material. These act as point reflectors. Meckel & Nath (1985) discuss the character of hyperbolic returns from targets of different size and related horizontal resolution. Boulders and bedrock pinnacles on a lake bottom have been found to generate hyperbolic returns. Chaotic reflections are produced by thin discontinuous layers and very small point reflectors (i.e., considerably less than the wavelength of the radar e.g., in the order of 10 cm for 100 MHz antennas). Some of the causes of chaotic reflections have been found to be coarser clasts in diamicton, joints in bedrock, the disrupted layering in disturbed sediments. Signal velocity and depth determination The velocity at which electromagnetic energy travels in the ground is important in determining the depth of reflectors. In free space electromagnetic energy travels at the speed of light, In the subsurface it travels at a fraction of the speed of light, usually in
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
31
the range 0.01–0.16m ns–1 . Both the dielectric constant and the DC conductivity strongly influence the propagation velocity of a medium:
An estimate of the propagation velocity was also determined by A-Cubed (1983) to be:
A more detailed analysis of the specific effects that the dielectric constant and the electrical conductivity have on the attenuation and velocity of electromagnetic energy at a given frequency is given by Olhoeft (1978). The typical propagation velocity of radar energy in a variety of materials is given in Table I. The propagation velocity in water tends to be fairly constant and the typical values shown in the table are generally employed to calculate water depth. When it comes to measuring the thickness of lake-bottom sediment layers, velocity determination becomes more important as the propagation velocity in sediment can vary considerably. The propagation velocity can be determined in three ways: 1) direct water depth measurements and core depth logging, 2) common-mid point (CMP) velocity surveys (Fig. 4), where the velocity is calculated from the direct arrivals and reflections off horizontal interfaces (Fig. 5a), and 3) point-source reflection analysis, where the velocity is determined using the shape of diffraction patterns produced when profiling over point-source reflectors (Fig. 5b) (Moorman & Michel, 2000). The same geometry applies to the reflection patterns generated by a point-source reflector in a profile, and a horizontal interface in a velocity survey. The travel time equation is:
where x is the antenna separation in a velocity survey or the lateral offset from the pointsource reflector in a profile, V is the propagation velocity, is the one-way travel time at zero separation/offset (Telford et al., 1976), can be rearranged to calculate velocity:
The later two methods are generally more effective for determining velocities for the upper layers in settings with relatively strong and simple reflections. As the travel time to a certain depth is dependent on the velocity of all of the layers above, the spatial variability of sediments can influence the shape of underlying reflection patterns. Variability in the propagation velocity throughout a profile often need to be taken into consideration when interpreting the shape of reflections. An example of this is schematically illustrated in Figure 6. Once the velocity is determined, a depth scale can be constructed. Generally GPR software will automatically generate a single depth scale for a profile. In settings where the velocity changes dramatically with depth or along the profile, it may be required to manually construct a depth scale for different units within the profile.
32
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
Where the subsurface structure is simple, it is currently possible to automatically correct for velocity changes as well as geometric errors by employing migration software. However, this is labour intensive, imperfect and, in all but the simplest situations, requires far more velocity information that can be easily acquired in a GPR survey. When the velocity varies in two dimensions (i.e., laterally and with depth) migration is much more complicated. Thus, the minor errors in depth and shape of reflections in GPR profiles are usually manually corrected for in the interpretation process or left in the data. Depth of penetration The depth to which GPR can image below the surface is dependant on three main factors: 1) the number of interfaces that generate reflections and the dielectric contrast at each interface, 2) the rate at which the signal is attenuated as it travels through the subsurface, and 3) the centre frequency of the antennas. As the GPR pulse arrives at each interface, a portion of it is returned to the surface and the rest continues into the next layer. As
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
33
34
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
the number of interfaces increases, the proportion of energy that propagates to depth is reduced. In addition, the greater proportion of energy that is reflected back to the surface at each interface, the less energy that is available to propagate deeper into the ground. In sediment, localized dielectric contrasts can create chaotic reflections. This limits the depth of investigation because the reflections of interest get masked by the clutter of the chaotic returns. The conductivity of the material that a GPR signal is travelling through has a major influence on the depth to which the signal will penetrate. As the conductivity increases, the material acts more like a conductor than a semi-conductor. The conductive currents in a material are an energy dissipating mechanism for an EM field. In this case, energy is irreversibly extracted from the EM field and transferred to the medium it is in. Figure 7 illustrates the impact conductivity has on the potential depth of penetration. The frequency used is also of importance since the resolution of the system and the rate of signal attenuation is proportional to the frequency (Fig. 8) of the GPR system. With lower frequencies, the wavelength is longer and as a result there is less attenuation due to conductive losses and less scattering from the chaotic reflections from small clutter. The main disadvantage of using very low frequencies is that the resolution decreases, such that the thickness of small layers can no longer be measured and small objects are not detected. A practical consideration is that, as the frequency decreases, the length of the antennas increase in size and become more difficult to work with. In fresh-water lakes it is reasonable to expect a depth of penetration of 20–30 m and then a propagation of several metres into the sub-bottom, depending on the material type (Sellman et al., 1992; Moorman & Michel 1997).
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
35
Feature detection and resolution The three main factors that determine where an object or a thin layer of material will be detected are the size of the object or layer thickness, the frequency of the GPR system, and the propagation velocity of the medium. Higher frequency antennas generate shorter waves and thus have finer resolution and can detect smaller objects. The propagation velocity of the medium is important because the size of the wavelet in the subsurface is not only determined by the frequency of the antenna that created it, but also the velocity at which it propagates through the subsurface. If a pulse is forced to slow down in a medium with a slower propagation velocity (e.g., water), the pulse is compressed to accommodate the slower velocity. The precise vertical resolution can be determined by surveying two reflectors that intersect at a gentle angle (Sheriff, 1985), however wave theory suggests that the greatest vertical resolution that can be expected is 1/4 of the size of a wavelet (Sheriff & Geldart, 1982). The size of the wavelets that are recorded on a GPR profile is a function of the pulse width of the original transmitted pulse. The pulse width produced by the 100 MHz and 50 MHz antennae and the resultant maximum theoretical resolution in various geologic materials is displayed in Table III. The horizontal resolution is a function of the spacing between traces and the footprint of the radar pulse. When surveying lakes, the footprint is the area over which the GPR pulse is reflected from the lake bottom. The wavelength, radiation pattern and, water depth determine the size of the footprint. For common dipole antennas, Annan (1992) provides a
36
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
way to estimate the footprint using:
Where A is the long axis diameter of the oval footprint, d is the distance (or depth), and is the dielectric constant of the medium (80 for water). The short axis of the oval footprint is roughly half the length of the long axis. For example, at a depth of 20 m, in water, the effective footprint of a 50 MHz pulse has a mean diameter of approximately 10 m. This is a little smaller than the footprint of an acoustic subbottom profiler (Sellmann et al., 1992). Data acquisition Effective data acquisition is dependant on a well designed survey and effective implementation. There are two main elements in designing a GPR survey, the GPR system parameters and the profile parameters. Both of these sets of parameters are adjusted depending on the site conditions and the information desired. Survey design-system parameters Most of the GPR systems currently on the market allow for the adjustment of many of the system parameters enabling the optimization of the system for the specific survey environment. The main system parameters that can be adjusted include: operating frequency, time window, sampling interval, stacking, antenna spacing, and antenna orientation. The frequency of antennas chosen influence the exploration depth that is possible, the resolution of the data, and the amount of clutter that is present on the profiles. As the frequency is lowered, the depth of penetration is increased and the amount of clutter present in the profiles decreases; however, the ability to detect and resolve smaller objects decreases.
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
37
In limnological surveys, the maximum depth of the lake and the electrical conductivity of the water are the major influences on the required frequency. Generally, 12.5 MHz to 100 MHz antennas are employed to survey lakes. The time window is the duration over which the system records the returns at each position. This and the propagation velocity determine the depth to which data will be recorded from. It is generally recommended that it should be set appreciably larger than the maximum possible depth of interest. It is better to collect too much data than to find that a reflector of interest runs off the bottom of the plot. The sampling interval determines how well the received wave form is digitally represented. The sampling interval required to effectively represent the shape of the wave form is a function of the frequency and the propagation velocity. Setting the interval too large degrades the vertical resolution of the data. Over sampling results in excess data file sizes and slower computing and plotting time. However, with the current computer technology, over sampling is not a significant issue. Trace stacking involves the GPR automatically taking repeat measurements at each station, and averaging the traces. This increases the signal to noise ratio by suppressing the unwanted, random, non-geologic noise. Because each trace takes so little time to acquire, having larger numbers of stacks only slightly effects the length of time it takes to complete data acquisition at each station. However, depending on the amount of noise present, there is a limit to the number of stacks required before no further improvement in the data is achieved. The separation between the transmitter antenna and receiver antenna controls the geometry of the travel path of the radar pulse, the power reaching the target of interest, and the amount of energy travelling directly from the transmitter to the receiver (referred to as the direct air wave and the direct ground wave). A large antenna separation results in a time compression of the near surface reflections. This is generally not a significant issue when profiling lakes, since the water column takes up the upper portion of the profile. If the two antennas are too close together, the large pulse of energy contained in the direct air wave and direct ground wave can saturate the receiver electronics and decrease its ability to detect the full range of data received within a few metres of the surface. To attain the optimal amount of energy reaching the target of interest, the antenna spacing can be refined using the relationship from Annan (1992):
where d is the depth of the target and is the dielectric constant of the medium. However, when profiling lakes, the spacing is not as crucial since the water column simplifies the radiation patterns anound the antenna and slightly focusses the energy directly beneath the antenna. As a result, the antenna spacing is often kept within the 1–3 m range with the specific separation determined by the logistical constrains of the survey. The final system parameter that can be adjusted is the orientation of the antennas. Most GPR antennas currently being produced commercialy are polarized and thus the relative orientation of the antennas can influence the polarity of returns. The elongation of the EM field radiated out from the transmitter antenna means that, depending on the antenna orientation, there is more spatial averaging in one direction over the other. However, the
38
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
impact of antenna orientation on the overall data quality is relatively small, thus survey logistical requirments often determine antenna orientation. Survey design-profile parameters The profile parameters that need to be taken into consideration when designing a GPR survey include station spacing along the survey profile, spacing between profiles, and the type of survey grid desired. Ensuring that the station spacing is close to enable interpretation of the profile is very important when designing a survey. Station spacing is a function of the frequency used, the dielectric constant of the material, and the complexity of the subsurface. If the lake bottom and sub-bottom structure are horizontal, it is not as crucial to ensure that the traces are close together; however, sloping reflectors are much more difficult to interpret if the station spacing is too large (Fig. 9). The relationship between frequency and station spacing in GPR surveying of lakes is illustrated in Figure 10. The layout of profile lines can take two forms: a rectilinear grid where the distance between profiles stays constant, or a series of vectors from the shore of the lake. The rectilinear grid takes longer to complete but since all of the profiles intercept at right angles, it tends to be easier to interpret the three dimensional structure from the profiles. The vectors can be completed faster since the end of one profile (where it reaches the shore) is the start of another profile. However, the interpretation tends to be trickier. When there are dipping reflectors in the lake sediments (e.g., deltaic foreset beds), it is best to profile parallel to their dip direction. This produces the most realistic representation of the sloping horizons. The profiles should also be close enough that the footprint of the GPR overlaps from one profile to the next. Along with the size of the footprint, the complexity of the lake bottom will influence the profiling detail required. The acquisition mode (e.g., on an ice platform or from a boat) strongly influences the details of how that detail is achieved. If the GPR survey is conducted on an ice platform, where the system is towed by hand or behind a vehicle, positioning and velocity control are relatively simple. When surveying from a boat on open water, position control is more complicated. Acquisition mode There are two main ways to conduct GPR surveys of lakes, towing the system over an ice cover or surveying through the bottom of a boat. Thus, this enables GPR to be used for surveying lakes for a large portion of the year. When surveying on an ice cover, the GPR system can be towed behind a slow moving vehicle or a person walking. Since motorized vehicles generate a certain amount of EM noise, and are a large radar target, the radar system must be at least 5 m behind the vehicle, depending on the type of vehicle. Depending on the GPR system employed, and the system parameters chosen, data can be collected at up to several kilometres per hour. The data can be collected at a constant rate and thus variations in the speed at which it is towed will affect the trace (i.e., station) spacing, or recent systems offer odometer wheels that trigger the GPR to collect a trace at regular distance intervals.
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
39
The stratigraphy of GPR profiles collected on an ice platform are more complicated due to the additional layer of ice being imaged. However, the very fast propagation velocity of the GPR pulse through ice generally results in the ice layer having little influence on the character of the GPR profile. This is especially true if the ice thickness is relatively constant. When the thickness of ice varies dramatically, such as on rivers, GPR can be used to measure the thickness of the ice (Annan & Davis, 1977; Delaney et al., 1990). When surveying on open water, the antennas are placed in a non-metallic flat bottom boat, such as an inflatable rubber boat. This allows the antennas to be in close contact with the water without experiencing interference from the boat. Experience has shown that the antennas work fine through a one-inch wood floor. A metal floor on a boat will completely
40
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
attenuate the signal before it reaches the water. To avoid interference from the boat’s motor, sometimes it is necessary to tow the GPR system in one boat 5 m or so behind another boat. Some initial attempts have been made to perform GPR surveys by slinging the antennas beneath a helicopter and flying the profile route of the lake (e.g., O’Neill & Arcone, 1991). However, there are still a number of technological issues that must be addressed. Since the antennas are not in contact with the surface of the lake, a large proportion of the energy in the pulse is lost in the reflection from the lake surface. This limits the depth of penetration through and beneath the lake. Data acquisition speed is generally too slow, as it is difficult to fly helicopters at a very slow speed. As well, the considerable interference from the helicopter must be eliminated. No matter what mode of data acquisition is used, survey positions must be acquired if the data are to be transferred onto a map. When working on an ice platform, standard survey techniques can be easily employed. Mapping the position of profiles is trickier when you are in constant motion in a boat or helicopter. However, with the advent of differential global positioning systems (DGPS) and other rapid acquisition high precision techniques, this problem is becoming inconsequential. Data processing and interpretation Processing techniques Compared to seismic data, relatively little processing is generally done to GPR data. A gain function is usually applied to the data to emphasize the weaker returns. There are a number of gain functions that can be applied depending of the data quality and the profile elements that you want to emphasize (e.g., automatic gain control (AGC), spherical and
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
41
exponentially compensation (SEC) gain, user defined gain function). An example of the effects of different gain functions are displayed in Moorman & Michel (1997). Temporal filtering involves filtering along the time axis of each trace. This can involve high-pass, low-pass filters or frequency filters such as Fourier analysis. These filters involve reduction or elimination of certain unwanted returns along each trace. For example by running mean along each trace, high frequency noise can be reduced (Moorman & Michel, 1997). As with temporal filtering, spatial filtering is employed to remove unwanted spatial variations. One technique is to perform a running mean of data points at the same time across traces. This type of trace to trace running mean is used to emphasize horizontal reflections while de-emphasizing sloping returns. Other types of spatial filters can be applied to emphasize sloping reflections such as trace-to-trace differential filters. There are also a number of more advanced filtering techniques such as migration that are occasionally employed to solve a specific problem with the data set. However, these more complicated filtering techniques are generally too time consuming to be regularly applied to all data sets. Feature identification Feature identification is primarily accomplished by examining the reflection characteristics (e.g., continuous line, hyperbola, or multiple discontinuous chaotic reflections). By comparing the reflection character to known examples, one can construct a radar stratigraphic facies interpretation of the data (Fig. 11). Radar stratigraphic examples have been published from a few environments to date (e.g., Beres & Haeni, 1991; van Heteren et al., 1994; Smith & Jol, 1997). In some applications, by studying the pulse polarity, you can determine the relative magnitude of the dielectric constant on either side of an interface (Arcone et al., 1995; Moorman & Michel, 2000). However, this probably has limited use in studying lake basin sediments. Along with identifying features of interest, the interpreter must be alert to the potential for the incorporation of unwanted returns into the GPR profile. Because the energy is being radially emitted from the antenna, in areas of very uneven topography there is the potential of recording a reflection from a feature that is not beneath the antennas, but off to the side or even nearby on the surface. These are called offline reflections. This is most evident when the profile is parallel to a very steep lake bottom slope (i.e., greater than 45°). When the slope is greater than 45°, lake bottom reflections will not be directed back to the receiver, but off to the side. Similarly, if the profile runs near to a steep slope, unwanted offline reflections may be recorded from the slope off to the side. An example of the chaotic noise that can be generated from offline reflectors is illustrated in Figure 12. The refraction of a propagated signal can clutter a profile with misleading returns. Fortunately, with the antenna separation generally being so close, this is seldom an issue. Channeling of the emitted pulse in the ice cover can also lead to anomalous data. Since the dielectric constant of ice is much smaller that water, if the ice is thick enough reflections from within the ice off to the side of the profile may be recorded. As the propagation velocity of ice is about 5 times faster than that in water, a reflection 5 m off to the side
42
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
43
within the ice could technically arrive at the same time as a reflection 1 m down the water column. Multiple reflections from the lake bottom are frequently observed on GPR profiles and have the potential to mask some of the sub-bottom data. However, this is usually not a problem unless there is extremely good penetration into the sub-bottom (Moorman & Michel, 1997). In general, GPR data are relatively straight forward to process and interpret. The lake bottom produces a continuous line reflection or hyperbolic reflections. The biggest problem arises when not enough energy reaches the lake bottom to produce a reflection that is detectable at the surface. Depending on the thickness of the lake sediments and the scale of the structures within it, sedimentary structures may be able to be identified on a GPR profile. As with any geophysical investigation, the geophysical data should be verified with direct measurements. This is especially true for the identification and thickness of lake bottom sediments. Water depth measurements are less likely to be in error since the dielectric structure of lakes remains constant and the propagation velocity of water varies little. Applications The application of GPR to paleolimnology is still in its infancy. The bulk of the research on investigating the application of GPR to paleolimnological problems has been initiated in the last ten years. To date, the research has focused on four areas: bathymetry, sediment thickness and structure, peat stratigraphy, and floating ice thickness. Since the early work of Annan & Davis (1977) and Kovacs (1978), it has been apparent that GPR is an effective tool for mapping the depth of fresh water lakes. Using a 120 MHz system, Trumen et al. (1991) found that water depth in a reservoir could be mapped with confidence. When the GPR profiles were correlated to measured depths, an value was calculated to be 0.989. Kovacs (1991) showed that GPR was more effective at mapping bathymetry than sonar when the water depth was shallow and when the weed concentration was high. Sellman et al. (1992) & Delaney et al. (1992) demonstrated that 100 MHz GPR has a resolution similar to a 7 kHz acoustic survey for measuring water depth, and that the GPR was far superior for imaging the bedding structure. Using 50 MHz antennas, up to 30 m of water could be mapped, with up to 7 m of penetration into the bed (Sellman et al., 1992). A number of authors have reported mapping the distribution and thickness of lacustrine sediments (Delaney et al. 1992; Moorman & Michel, 1997). Smith & Jol have under taken extensive work on mapping the structure of modern and ancient deltaic deposits (e.g., Jol & Smith, 1991, 1992; Smith & Jol, 1997). Lowe (1985) reported being able to discern multiple layers of lacustrine sediments and tephra up to 10 m depth. Various trials have been undertaken showing the capabilities of GPR for mapping the thickness and stratigraphy of organic deposits in ponds and bogs (Worsfold et al., 1986; Warner et al., 1990; Hanninen, 1992; Doolittle et al., 1992; Mellett, 1995). Depending on how much the physical properties vary with depth, GPR results varied from just detecting the bottom of the peat to differentiating the actual peat stratigraphy. As ice enables radar pulses to propagate with little attenuation, GPR has been shown effective for imaging the thickness of lake, sea and river ice (Arcone et al., 1997; Kovacs, 1978; Kovacs & Morey, 1979, 1985, 1992). As the dielectric contrast between ice and
44
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
water is much greater than that of ice and air, O’Niell & Arcone (1991) found that lake ice thickness could be detected from a helicopter. A number of technical issues complicate the collection of good quality data, however, in some situations, it is feasible. Summary From the research conducted to date, it appears that GPR has the potential to become a valuable tool in paleolimnological investigations. By carrying out gridded surveys over a lake, the bathymetry and the lake bottom sediment distribution, thickness and structure can be mapped with relative ease. Operating on foot, on lake ice several kilometres of data can be collected per day. Towing the GPR behind a vehicle or boat enables even faster data collection. Currently, the bathymetry of lakes up to 30 m in depth can be mapped with GPR. Up to seven metres of sediment have been imaged beneath lakes. In the future it is anticipated that these values will improve, as GPR systems performances continue to improve. The new GPR systems currently being released are pointing the way towards very simplified GPR mapping. Whether this will include simplified lake surveying will depend on market forces. Since the simpler a system is made use, the less flexible it is. Simple lake profiling will require a market demand for such a system. Further development of airborne GPR surveying is required before a final determination can be made on how effective airborne systems can be for mapping bathymetry and lake bottom sediments. Acknowledgments The author gratefully acknowledges the advice and guidance of Dr. Fred Michel, and the field assistance of Deborah Kliza, Lynn Moorman, Mark Elver, and Amy Lyttle while working in the Arctic. Much of the field work was supported by The Northern Science Training Program and the Polar Continental Shelf Project. These two organizations are gratefully acknowledged. Valuable discussions with Les Davis of Sensors and Software Inc. are also greatly appreciated. References A-CUBED, 1983. General State of the Art Review of Ground Probing Radar. A-CUBED, Mississauga, Ontario, 89 pp. Annan, A. P., 1992. Ground Penetrating Radar Workshop Notes. Sensors and Software Inc., Mississauga, Ontario, 56 pp. Annan, A. P. & J. L. Davis, 1977. Radar range analysis for geological materials. GSC Paper 77–1B. Current Research Part B: 117–124. Arcone, S. A. & A. J. Delaney, 1982. Measurement of Ground Dielectric Properties Using Wide-angle Reflection and Refraction. U.S. Army Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratories, Hanover, New Hampshire, 11 pp. Arcone, S. A., D. E. Lawson & A. J. Delaney, 1995. Short-pulse radar wavelet recovery and resolution of dielectric contrasts within englacial and basal ice of Matanuska Glacier, Alaska, USA. J. Glaciology 41: 68–86.
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
45
Arcone, S. A., N. E. Yankielun & E. F. Chacho, 1997. Reflection profiling of arctic lake ice using microwave FM-CW radar. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing 35: 436–443. Austin, G. L. & L. B. Austin, 1974. The use of radar in urban hydrology. J. Hydrology 22: 131–142. Behrendt, J. C., D. Drewry, E. Jankowski & A. W. England, 1979. Aeromagnetic and radar ice sounding indicate substantially greater area for dufek intrusion in Antarctica. American Geophysical Union Transactions 60: 245. Bentley, C. R., J. W. Clough, K. C. Jezek & S. Shabtaie, 1979. Ice thickness patterns and the dynamics of the Ross Ice Shelf, Antarctica. J. Glaciology 24: 287–294. Beres, M., Jr. & F. P. Haeni, 1991. Application of Ground-penetrating-radar methods in hydrogeologic studies. Ground Water 29: 375–386. Bryan, M. L., 1974. Ice Thickness Variability on Silver Lake, Genesee County, Michigan: A Radar Approach, Advanced Concepts in the Study of Snow and Ice Resources. United States Contribution to the International Hydrological Decade: 213–223. Caldecott, R., M. Poirier, D. Scofea, D. E. Svoboda & A. J. Terzuoli, 1988. Underground mapping of utility lines using impulse radar. Institute of Electrical Engineers Proceedings F. Communications, Radar and Signal Processing 135 part F: 343–361. Cook, J. C., 1973. Radar exploration through rock in advance of mining. Transactions of A.I.M.E., Society of Mining Engineers 254: 140–146. Cook, J. C., 1975. Radar transparencies of mine and tunnel rocks. Geophysics 40: 865–885. Cook, J. C., 1977. Borehole-radar exploration in a coal seam. Geophysics 42: 1254–1257. Dallimore, S. R. & J. L. Davis, 1987. Ground probing radar investigations of massive ground ice and near surface geology in continuous permafrost. GSC Paper 87–1 A. Current Research Part A: 913–918. Davis, J. L. & A. P. Annan, 1989. Ground-penetrating radar for high-resolution mapping of soil and rock stratigraphy. Geophysical Prospecting 37: 531–551. Delaney, A. J. & S. A. Arcone, 1982. Laboratory Measurements of Soil Electric Properties between 0.1 and 5 GHz. U.S. Army Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratories, Hanover, New Hampshire, 7 pp. Delaney, A. J., S. A. Arcone & E. F. Chacho, Jr., 1990. Winter short-pulse radar studies on the Tanana River, Alaska. Arctic 43: 244–250. Delaney, A. J., P. V. Sellmann & S. A. Arcone, 1992. Sub-bottom profiling: a comparison of short-pulse radar and acoustic data. In Hanninen, P. & S. Autio (eds.) Fourth International Conference on Ground Penetrating Radar. Geological Survey of Findland Special Paper 16: Rovaniemi, Finland: 149–157. Dellwig, L. F. & J. E. Bare, 1978. A radar investigation of North Louisiana salt domes. Photogrametric Engineering and Remote Sensing 44: 1411–1419. Doolittle, J. A., M. A. Hardisky & S. Black, 1992. A ground-penetrating radar study of Goodream palsas, Newfoundland, Canada. Arctic and Alpine Research 24: 173–178. Evans, S., 1963. Radio techniques for the measurement of ice thickness. Polar Record 11: 406–410. Hänninen, P., 1992. Application of Ground Penetrating Radar and Radio Wave Moisture Probe Techniques to Peatland Investigations. Geological Survey of Finland, Rovaniemi, Finland, 71 pp. Hulsmeyer, C., 1904. German Patent Number 165546. Jol, H. M. & D. G. Smith, 1991. Ground penetrating radar of northern lacustrine deltas. Canadian J. Earth Sci. 28: 1939–1947. Jol, H. M. & D. G. Smith, 1992. Geometry and structure of deltas in large lakes: a ground penetrating radar overview. In Hanninen, P. & S. Autio (eds.) Fourth International Conference on Ground Penetrating Radar. Geological Survey of Finland Special Paper 16, Geological Survey of Finland, Rovaniemi, Finland: 159–168. Kovacs, A., 1978. Remote detection of water under ice-covered lakes on the north slope of Alaska. Arctic 31: 448–458.
46
BRIAN J. MOORMAN
Kovacs, A., 1991. Impulse Radar Bathymetric Profiling in Weed-infested Fresh Water. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Cold Regions Research & Engineering Laboratory, Hanover, New Hampshire, 19 pp. Kovacs, A. & R. M. Morey, 1979. Remote detection of a freshwater pool off the Sagavanirktok River Delta, Alaska. Arctic 32: 161–164. Kovacs, A. & R. M. Morey, 1985. Electromagnetic Measurements of Multi-year Sea Ice Using Impulse Radar. U.S. Army Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory, Hanover, New Hampshire, 26 pp. Kovacs, A. & R. M. Morey, 1992. Estimating sea ice thickness from impulse radar sounding time of flight data. In Pilon, J. A. (ed.) Ground Penetrating Radar. Geological Survey of Canada Paper 90–4, Geological Survey of Canada, Ottawa: 117–124. Lerner, R. M., 1974. Ground Radar System. United States Patent #3831173. Assignee: Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Lowe, D. J., 1985. Application of impulse radar to continuous profiling of tephra-bearing lake sediments and peats: an initial evaluation. New Zealand of Geology and Geophysics 28: 667–674. Lowy, H., 1911. German Patent Number 254517. Meckel, L. D., Jr. & A. K. Nath, 1985. Geologic considerations for stratigraphic modeling and interpretation. Seismic Stratigraphy-Applications to Hydrocarbon Exploration. AAPG Memoir 26. American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, Oklahoma: 417–438. Mellett, J. S., 1995. Profiling of ponds and bogs using ground-penetrating radar. J. Paleolim. 14: 233–240. Moorman, B. J. & F. A. Michel, 1997. Bathymetric mapping and sub-bottom profiling through lake ice with ground-penetrating radar. J. Paleolim. 18: 61–73. Moorman, B. J. & F. A. Michel, 2000. Glacial hydrological system characterization using groundpenetrating radar. Hydrological Processes 14: 2645–2667. Morey, R. M., 1974. Continuous sub-surface profiling by impulse radar. Conference on Subsurface Exploration for Underground Excavation and Heavy Construction. American Society of Civil Engineers, 213–232. Morey, R. M., 1976. Detection of subsurface cavities by ground penetrating radar. Highway Geological Symposium 27: 28–30. Olhoeft, G. R., 1978. Electrical Properties of Permafrost. Third International Conference on Permafrost: Edmonton, Alberta. National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa: 127–131. O’Neill, K. & S. A. Arcone, 1991. Investigations of Freshwater and Ice Surveying Using Short-pulse Radar. U.S. Army Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory, Hanover, New Hampshire, 22 pp. Osumi, N. & K. Ueno, 1988. Detection of buried plant. Institute of Electrical Engineers Proceedings F. Communications, Radar and Signal Processing 135 part F: 330–342. Scott, W. J., P. V. Sellmann & J. A. Hunter, 1978. Geophysics in the study of permafrost. Third International Conference on Permafrost: Edmonton, Alberta. National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa: 93–115. Sellmann, P. V., A. J. Delaney & S. A. Arcone, 1992. Sub-bottom Surveying in Lakes with Groundpenetrating Radar. U.S. Army Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratories, Hanover, New Hampshire, 18 pp. Sheriff, R. E., 1985. Limitations on resolution of seismic reflections and geologic detail derivable from them. Seismic Stratigraphy-Applications to Hydrocarbon Exploration. American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa Oklahoma: 3–14. Sheriff, R. E. & R. E. Geldart, 1982. Exploration Seismology, Volume 1: History, Theory, and Data Acquisition, Cambridge University Press, New York, 253 pp. Smith, D. G. & H. M. Jol, 1997. Radar structure of a Gilbert-type delta, Peyto Lake, Banff National Park, Canada. Sed. Geol. 113: 195–209.
GROUND-PENETRATING RADAR APPLICATIONS . . .
47
Steenson, B. O., 1951. Radar Methods for the Exploration of Glaciers. Pasadena, California. California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California. Stern, W., 1930. Principles, methods and results of electrodynamic thickness measurement of glacier ice. Zeitschrift fur Gletscherkunde 18: 24. Telford, W. M., L. P. Geldart, R. E. Sheriff & D.A. Keys, 1976. Applied Geophysics: Cambridge. Cambridge University Press, New York, 455 pp. Truman, C. C., L. E. Asmussen & H. D. Allison, 1991. Ground-penetrating radar: a tool for mapping reservoirs and lakes. J. Soil and Water Conservation 46: 370–373. Ulriksen, C. P., 1982. Application of impulse radar to civil engineering. Published Ph.D. Thesis, Lund University of Technology, Lund, Geophysical Survey Systems, Inc. Hudson, New Hampshire, 179 pp. van Heteren, S., D. M. Fitzgerald & P. A. McKinlay, 1994. Application of ground penetrating radar in coastal stratigraphic studies. GPR ’94, Volume Proceeding of the Fifth International Conference on Ground Penetrating Radar. University of Waterloo, Kitchener, Ontario: 869–881. Warner, B. G., D. C. Nobes & B. D. Theimer, 1990. An application of ground penetrating radar to peat stratigraphy of Ellice Swamp, southwestern Ontario. Can. J. Earth Sci. 27: 932–938. Worsfold, R. D., S. K. Parashar & T. Perrott, 1986. Depth profiling of peat deposits with impulse radar. Can. Geotech. J. 23: 142–154.
This page intentionally left blank
4. SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION TECHNIQUES IN PALEOLIMNOLOGY
DOROTHY SACK (
[email protected]) Department of Geography Ohio University 122 Clippinger Labs Athens, Ohio USA 45701 Keywords: coastal geomorphology, paleolake geomorphology, lacustrine landforms, closed-basin lakes, paleolake shorelines, shoreline mapping, paleolake level, lake morphometry, late Pleistocene paleolakes, the Great Basin
Introduction Background and rationale
This chapter considers methods and techniques by which data from the geomorphic evidence of paleolakes are collected, analyzed, and utilized. From a historical perspective, landform evidence can be viewed as one of the foundations of paleolake studies because (1) the identification of abandoned shoreline landforms is often the first indication noted for the existence of a former expanded water body (e.g., Whittlesey, 1850; Stansbury, 1852; Russell, 1885; Taylor, 1897; Schewennesen, 1918; Meinzer, 1922), and (2) many of the early researchers emphasized the geomorphic evidence of paleolakes (Beckwith, 1855; Gilbert, 1871, 1890; Russell, 1885; Leverett, 1897; Goldthwait, 1906; Leverett & Taylor, 1915; Street-Perrott & Harrison, 1985). Nevertheless, because landforms are either deposits of sediment (broadly defined) or remnant features from which sediments have been eroded, the disciplines of geomorphology and sedimentology are closely related and those early paleolake workers typically augmented their primarily geomorphic work with sedimentologic and stratigraphic observations (Smith & Street-Perrott, 1983). The presence of geomorphology in physical paleolimnological research has varied through time. Following the initial dominance of landform evidence in the paleolake literature of the mid-19th to the early 20th century (e.g., Russell, 1885; Gilbert, 1890), the role of sedimentology and stratigraphy grew in the first half of the 20th century becoming at least as important as the geomorphic aspect (e.g., Thompson, 1929; Blackwelder & Ellsworth, 1936). Starting about 1950 the geomorphic component of paleo49 W. M. Last & J. P. Smol (eds.), 2001. Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume I: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
50
DOROTHY SACK
lake research began to dwindle for two major reasons, one from outside and the other from inside the discipline of geomorphology. From sedimentology and stratigraphy came new developments in lithostratigraphy, soil stratigraphy, and chronostratigraphy, and a surge in their application to paleolake research (Hunt et al., 1953; Broecker & Orr, 1958; Bissell, 1963; Morrison, 1964; Sack, 1989). Internally, many geomorphologists began turning away from topics involving longer term landscape evolution as they became increasingly disillusioned with the Davisian historical-evolutionary approach, which had been dominant in much of geomorphology for decades (Davis, 1899; Strahler, 1950, 1952; Sack, 1992a). At least in North America the use of geomorphic methods in paleolake research reached its nadir in the 1970s when process, as opposed to historical, geomorphology dominated that field. Since 1979, geomorphic analysis in paleolake studies has been rebounding, accompanied by advances in surveying and geographic positioning technologies as well as renewed interest among geomorphologists in Quaternary science. Perhaps because of these historical trends within 20th century paleolake studies, geomorphology has occasionally been portrayed as an unimportant (Morrison, 1965a, 1966), less important (Street-Perrott & Harrison, 1985), or even nonexistent (Frey, 1988) subfield of paleolimnology. Whether done consciously or unconsciously, such portrayals do paleolimnologists a disservice because in addition to providing present evidence of an ancient lake, geomorphology is one of the past environmental factors that influenced the existence, extent, and changing size of the paleolake. In other words, geomorphology is an essential aspect of paleolake studies because it is involved as both a cause and an effect of the water bodies. Compared to other evidence of past water levels, such as that available from core stratigraphy, relict shorelines give a much more direct and precise indication of paleolake extent because they were created at the interface between the water surface and the land. The preservation of abandoned shorelines as distinguishable landforms at the earth’s surface is crucial for documenting the actual size and shape of a paleolake, that is, for reconstructing its hydrography, and for deciphering its hydrographic changes through time. These changes have traditionally been portrayed diagrammatically with hydrographs, which show reconstructed values of water level, surface area, or volume on the ordinate plotted against time on the abscissa (Fig. 1) (Gilbert, 1890; Antevs, 1945; Crittenden, 1963; Oviatt et al., 1992; Currey, 1994b). Hypsographs illustrate the variation in surface area with changing water levels. The predominant rationale for many paleolake studies conducted in the last decades of the 20th century is paleoclimatic reconstruction. The existence, extent, and changing extent of a lake, however, are influenced by geomorphic (including structural) as well as climatic factors (Eardley et al., 1957; Currey, 1994a, 1994b; Mason et al., 1994; Sack, 1994). For example, at the most basic level, adequate climatic conditions will not result in a lake if there is no basin of topographic closure. Through orographic and other effects, drainage basin topography influences the amount of precipitation falling and potentially reaching the lake as surface runoff (Snyder & Langbein, 1962; Wilkins, 1997). Lake level changes are caused by variations in climate but also by such geomorphic factors as stream capture, outlet incision, or spillover from adjacent basins (Lewis & Anderson, 1989; King, 1993; Pengelly et al., 1997; Sack, in press). Even the amount of lake level rise resulting from an increase in hydrologic input depends on lake basin configuration and whether or not the lake has fluvial
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
51
outflow (Street-Perrott & Harrison, 1985). Because the lacustrine response documented in a reconstructed paleolake hydrograph reflects both the geomorphic and the climatic history of the drainage basin, an accurate reconstruction of the paleoclimate depends on properly distinguishing the climatically influenced and geomorphically influenced aspects of the hydrographic response. Open- versus closed-basin lakes Whether a lake basin is hydrographically closed (closed-basin lake) or open (open-basin lake) is a fundamental and useful distinction in paleolake studies. Because a closed-basin lake has no outflowing stream, changes in its water input-to-output ratio are expressed as lake level and especially lake surface area fluctuations (Benson & Paillet, 1989). A discrete shoreline is potentially created each time the water level restabilizes at a new position. In contrast, considerably less paleohydrologic data are generally available from the shoreline record of open-basin lakes, which respond to changes in the water balance by varying the amount of discharge over the topographic threshold. Variations in this essentially fluvial outlet discharge can be accomplished by adjustments in flow velocity and width with very little change in depth (McCarthy & McAndrews, 1988; Tinkler et al., 1992). As a result, compared to closed-basin lakes, open-basin lakes typically experience much less drastic changes in water level and surface area, making it much less likely that a waterbalance change will be recorded and preserved as a distinctive element in the paleoshoreline record. In general then, closed-basin paleolakes represent significantly better sources of paleohydrologic data than do lakes which were hydrographically open during most of their existence. Closed-basin lakes are more common in arid than in humid climates because the water surplus in humid regions causes most closed-basin lakes in that environment to reach their
52
DOROTHY SACK
thresholds, overflow, and become open-basin lakes (Langbein, 1961). With additional time those outlets will be lowered by fluvial erosion, and the overflowing lakes will eventually be replaced by through-flowing streams. Water can also pond in the closed basins of arid lands, but because arid climates have higher evaporation and lower precipitation values than humid climates, lakes in desert basins are much less likely to reach the point of overflow and self-destruct. As a result, closed basins and closed-basin lakes are more numerous in arid than in humid climates (Langbein, 1961). Despite high evaporation losses on the desert floor, ephemeral and intermittent lakes (i.e., playas or playa lakes) can form there because there are at least intervals during which desert-basin precipitation exceeds evaporation loss, assuming negligible groundwater flux. Paleolimnological evidence of these shallow lakes is overwhelmingly sedimentologic rather than geomorphic. More persistent lakes exist in arid basins where the modest annual input from direct precipitation is augmented by considerable surface runoff from the surrounding drainage basin. Although basin floor evaporation rates remain high, having more water move through the lake-basin system allows a larger and more permanent lake to be maintained. In order to supply this surface runoff the catchment must experience, over the long term, an excess of precipitation over evaporation. In other words, although the lake basin lies in an arid climate, part of its drainage basin must have a humid climate. This situation occasionally exists in very large catchments, such as that of Lake Eyre, where arid-region lakes are maintained by surface inflow from distant humid regions (Bowler, 1986). In many other cases, humid enclaves are found within arid regions because of elevation and orographic effects (Fig. 2). These part-arid, part-humid, or “hemiarid” (Currey, 1994b), closed-basin-lake-promoting settings of high relief result from hypertectonism in otherwise arid environments (Currey, 1994a). Because of its numerous hemiarid basins and generally more arid climate subsequent to the most recent (very late Pleistocene) deep-lake cycle, the North American Great Basin provides some excellent geomorphic evidence of past lakes, and this chapter draws heavily from work done in that region. Nevertheless, preserved segments of paleolake shorelines exist on every continent and in many different circumstances, and methods of collecting and analyzing data from the geomorphic evidence of paleolakes have been derived, tested, and applied in a variety of settings. Coastal landform nomenclature Coastal geomorphology is the geomorphic subfield that considers, at least in principal, landforms and landforming processes found along both marine and lacustrine coasts. Most lacustrine coastal, that is, lacustrine shorezone, landforms have an equivalent or approximately equivalent marine counterpart referred to by the same name. More than any other subfield of geomorphology, landform terms from coastal geomorphology seem especially prone to incorrect usage. The coastal bar, for example, a submerged depositional feature, is probably the most misused term in all of modern geomorphology. It is rarely found among relict paleolake landforms. Because of this terminology problem the more basic and common lacustrine coastal depositional landforms are distinguished in Table I. The modern problem may exist partly for historical reasons since coastal terms were sometimes used differently in the 19th century literature than they are today.
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
53
54
DOROTHY SACK
Shoreline identification Finding relict shorelines preserved at the earth’s surface in a nonmarine setting constitutes indisputable evidence of a previously expanded lake (Allison, 1945; Reeves, 1969; Bowler, 1971). Indeed the lack of relict shorelines has been used to argue against the existence of hypothesized deep lakes (Quade, 1986). In many cases preserved geomorphic evidence of shorelines is easily recognized even by casual observers (Russell, 1876; Currey, 1980); at other sites it is more difficult to discern due to either weak construction or poor preservation of the landforms. The construction of well-developed coastal landforms requires water depths greater than about 2 to 4m (Cowardin et al., 1979), shorezone characteristics amenable to sediment erosion, transportation, and deposition by lacustrine waves and currents (Currey, 1994b), and an interval without large and rapid fluctuations in lake level. Table II lists some of the principal factors that contribute to the obliteration and preservation of paleolake shorezone landforms. Subaerially exposed paleolake shorelines are most commonly identified from ground observations and the stereoscopic study of aerial photographs (Petty et al., 1996), but other useful means include direct aerial observations (Grove et al., 1975) and topographic map interpretation (Thomas, 1963). Because of its small scale, satellite imagery has only rarely played a role in shoreline identification (Löffler & Sullivan, 1979). In some cases, submerged wave-cut terraces may be discernible on seismic profiles (Lister et al., 1991). The base of wave-eroded cliffs or bluffs and the crest of wave-deposited landforms approximately mark the elevation of the water plane that formed those features. Preserved shoreline segments, therefore, display a lateral continuity in elevation that gives them a distinctively horizontal appearance (Fig. 3). This lateral horizontality is heightened by the tendency of coastal landforms to have a smoother, that is, less crenulate, appearance in
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
55
planimetric view than many other landscape elements. Largely by virtue of this lateral horizontality, well-developed and well-preserved paleolake shorelines often stand in stark visual contrast to the more vertical, contour-crossing trends which tend to be created by endogenic geomorphic processes and the gravity-driven subaerial geomorphic processes, such as stream erosion (Fig. 4). Where lacustrine landforms are small and less well preserved this horizontal nature can often still be discerned in the field, from the air, or on air photos under favorable, low-angle light conditions especially if the landforms consist of a vertical series of erosional bluffs (Gale, 1915; Blackwelder, 1933). Evidence from nonlacustrine landforms, such as an alignment of either small eolian dunes or the apexes of segments of adjacent alluvial fans, also help direct the eye to the position of a relict shoreline. Geomorphic differences between coastal landforms and noncoastal landforms with which they might be confused were well described by Gilbert (1885, 1890) over a century ago. Where morphologic evidence alone is not sufficient to identify the remnant of a shoreline with confidence, sedimentologic evidence is consulted. In some cases black and white, color, or color infrared air photos reveal grain size variations, or consequent permeability and vegetation differences, between a shoreline and the surrounding landscape through the photographic recognition elements of texture, tone, and color (Avery & Berlin, 1992). Most typically, however, a possible shoreline postulated in the field or from air photos on the basis of form is tested with field-derived information on grain size, sorting, and sedimentary structures (Coventry, 1976; Gassé & Street, 1978). In addition, the combined use of geomorphic, sedimentologic, and stratigraphic methods enables researchers to identify buried or partially buried shorelines. This, of course, requires sufficient stratigraphic
56
DOROTHY SACK
exposure to reveal the distinguishing form and internal composition of coastal depositional landforms buried by subsequent coastal, subaqueous, or subaerial sediments (Blackwelder & Ellsworth, 1936; Currey et al., 1983; Sack, 1999). Shoreline reconstruction Once identified, individual preserved shoreline segments are characterized in order to facilitate correlation with other isolated segments in the basin that may represent the same lake level. Physical attributes commonly used for correlating such preserved pieces include elevation, topographic profiles, and distinctive deposits (Russell, 1885; Tackman et al., 1998). Relative and numeric age determinations, which are also employed in intrabasin segment correlation, are discussed in the context of hydrograph construction in a subsequent section. Chronostratigraphic techniques are the specific topics of other chapters in this volume. Early paleolake investigators clearly realized the importance of shoreline elevation measurements and collected these data relative to contemporary lake levels, railroad lines, and other shorelines of interest using barometers, transits, and spirit levels (Russell, 1885; Gilbert, 1890; Lawson, 1893; Upham, 1895; Goldthwait, 1910; Gale, 1915). The same
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
57
principles remain in use today (Cowan, 1985; Lewis & Anderson, 1989; Tackman et al., 1998), but measurement accuracy, precision, speed, and ease have been enhanced through technical improvements in barometers and the development of electronic optical surveying instruments. An increase in coverage by topographic maps and in the number of vertical geodetic control points have also helped to improve elevation estimates and surveyed measurements. In addition, global positioning system (GPS) technology has become available for acquiring elevation data, and quite accurate results can be achieved through differential GPS, provided the site has clear access to satellites. Depths to submerged shoreline features may be obtained through echo sounding (Lewis & Anderson, 1989). Using elevation to correlate shoreline segments requires an understanding of possible height variations in a single shoreline around a basin. Although the base of erosional cliffs or bluffs and the crest of depositional shoreline landforms mark the approximate level of the formative water plane, some inherent differences in the height occur along a single shoreline because of variations in such factors as wave environment, sediment supply, shoreline configuration, and whether the segment is erosional or depositional (Gilbert, 1890; Eardley et al., 1957; Dulhunty, 1975; Coventry, 1976; Currey, 1982; Tackman et al., 1998). Lateral variation in shoreline height also stems from postlacustrine processes, such as erosion of or deposition onto relict shorelines, or through neotectonism, which includes faulting and hydro- or glacio-isostatic rebound. Measured topographic profiles and cross sections may reveal the break or change in slope that marks the mean position of the paleowater plane, and have been helpful in sorting out water-level changes responsible for complex vertical suites of several closely spaced shorelines (Gilbert, 1890; Goldthwait, 1906; Allison, 1952, 1954; Bowman, 1971; Burr & Currey, 1988; Stine, 1990; Avouac et al., 1996). Water body delineation An accurate depiction of water body size and configuration derives from shoreline mapping, which relies on the techniques of shoreline segment identification and correlation discussed above. In fact, most mapping proceeds with shoreline identification, correlation, and delineation occurring interactively. By necessity, early paleolake mappers relied exclusively on field observations (Russell, 1885; Gilbert, 1890; Upham, 1895; Leverett, 1908; Meinzer, 1922), often making their own topographic base maps along the way. The value of vertical aerial photographs in paleoshoreline mapping was realized virtually as soon as they became available (Allison, 1940; Dennis, 1944), and, together with accurate topographic base maps on which to trace the shorelines (Gale, 1915; Leverett & Taylor, 1915; Davis, 1983), they remain the most important tool in shoreline mapping (Fig. 5) (Löffler & Sullivan, 1979; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979; Currey, 1982). For most environments shorelines are easier to delineate while viewed stereoscopically on air photos than from field observations alone (Crittenden, 1963), but to ensure the highest accuracy, wherever possible shoreline mapping is accomplished with the combined use of air photos, topographic maps, and fieldwork (Sack, 1995). Geologic mapping of areas previously inundated by expanded water bodies aids in reconstructing the existence and extent of paleolakes (Feth, 1961). Geologic maps are especially valuable sources of information regarding the nature and history of paleolakes
58
DOROTHY SACK
when they depict relict shorelines and portray Quaternary units to the same level of detail as bedrock (e.g., Oviatt, 1989, 199la, 1991b; Sack, 1990, 1993). Shoreline mapping provides more than just a visual indication of the paleolake perimeter at different stillstands; it supplies information on neotectonism, the hydrologic status of the former water body, and details of its hydrography. Elevation changes found along the length of a once approximately level, isochronous shoreline enable researchers to assess the amount and pattern of isostatic rebound that has affected the shoreline since its formation. In most hemiarid lake basins the rebound signature is primarily hydroisostatic, especially generated from the larger paleolakes, such as Lakes Bonneville and Lahontan in the Great Basin (Gilbert, 1890; Crittenden, 1963; Mifflin & Wheat, 1971; Currey, 1990; Bills et al., 1994). Differential glacioisostatic rebound, however, is the stronger influence on shorelines of paleolakes that were located closer to the margin of Quaternary ice sheets, such as the
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION ...
59
Laurentian Great Lakes or the lakes of southern Manitoba (e.g., Farrand & Drexler, 1985; Larsen, 1985b; Tackman et al., 1998). Compared to isostatic deflection, faulting causes more abrupt changes in the elevation of an isochronous shoreline (Currey, 1982). Whether a given paleolake overflowed its initial basin or not is often discernible through shoreline mapping. By studying shoreline position with respect to passes and the nature of the adjoining topography, reconstructed shorelines help researchers determine if adjacent closed-basin lakes coalesced into a single large closed-basin lake, if one closed-basin lake overflowed through a connecting stream channel into another closed-basin lake, or if a lake experienced an interval of overflow to fluvial systems reaching the sea (Gale, 1915; Allison, 1954; Eardley et al., 1957; Snyder & Langbein, 1962; Morrison, 1965b; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979). Mapping the reconstructed perimeter of a former standing water body onto a topographic base creates a valuable resource from which can be derived qualitative and quantitative data regarding the three-dimensional configuration of the paleolake. It must be remembered, however, that the modern topography of a former lake basin will differ to some extent from the topography and bathymetry present during the paleolake interval because of intervening erosion, deposition, and neotectonism. This spatial reconstruction of the paleolake and the morphometric variables derived from it, therefore, are actually best estimates of the paleolake and its attributes. Some kinds of lake basin configuration information, especially when derived for multiple shorelines within the same basin, lead to hypotheses regarding the nature and distribution of various lacustrine sediments and subenvironments (Currey, 1990). For example, a reconstructed shoreline map will show if the lake displayed a relatively simple planimetric outline or if it had multiple arms connected by narrow straits which might have restricted the circulation of water and sediments (Currey, 1990). Likewise, the map may indicate whether the lake was composed of a single basin or of multiple subbasins that were separated from each other by various sills, implying a complicated history of spillover and subbasin integration (Benson, 1978,1994; Davis, 1983; Last & Slezak, 1986). The location of major inflowing streams should also be evident from the map. Many quantitative variables describing the size and shape of a paleolake and its drainage basin can be measured from topographic maps of reconstructed shorelines (Table III). These are the same morphometric variables used to describe modern lakes and their drainage basins (Hutchinson, 1957; Håkanson, 1981), thus quantitative comparisons can be made among ancient and modern lakes as well as among various paleolakes, or different levels of a single paleolake. Not surprisingly, such fundamental variables as maximum lake depth, lake surface area, and drainage basin area are historically among the first data to be reported for a given paleolake, and they remain the most frequently cited attributes. As discussed in more detail below, the ratio of a closed-basin paleolake’s surface area to the area of the rest of its drainage basin provides a very important means for linking the physical paleolake record with paleoclimatic attributes (Snyder & Langbein, 1962; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979). Chronologic considerations In addition to the three-dimensional spatial data needed to reconstruct a lake’s size and shape, relict paleolake shorelines contain some evidence relevant to when they were occupied by the water plane. Thus, from a suite of relict shorelines it is in some cases possible
60
DOROTHY SACK
to determine not only when a lake existed and how large it became, but also how it changed in size and shape over time. Inferences regarding the relative age of paleolake shorelines have been made from various kinds of shoreline geomorphic evidence at least since the work of Gilbert (1885,1890). By virtue of longer exposure to postformational subaerial and/or subaqueous processes, older shorelines commonly experience greater amounts of weathering, erosion, and burial than younger shorelines in the same physical environment. As a result, an older age is inferred for shorelines displaying greater soil development, thicker rock varnish, lower slopes, more rounded profiles, greater dissection by streams, and less lateral continuity, which can be quantified by the shoreline preservation index (Gilbert, 1890; Gale, 1915; Blackwelder, 1933, 1954; Thomas, 1963; Dulhunty, 1975; Petersen, 1984; Sack, 1995; Avouac et al., 1996; Wilkins & Currey, 1997). Conclusions concerning the relative age of paleolake shorelines also derive from cross-cutting relationships with other landforms
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
61
(e.g., King, 1993), stratigraphic relationships (e.g., Coventry & Walker, 1977), and archaeological evidence (e.g., Bowler, 1971; Giraudi, 1989). A slightly different temporal variable, the relative duration of a lake at a given level, is sometimes inferred from the size of a shoreline’s coastal landforms (Gilbert, 1890; Blackwelder & Ellsworth, 1936; Street-Perrott & Harrison, 1985; Teller & Last, 1990). Everything else being equal, shorelines composed of wide terraces and massive coastal depositional landforms, which are often referred to as well-developed shorelines, have been interpreted as reflecting a long duration of water plane occupation, with more poorly developed shorelines reflecting shorter occupations by the water plane (Gilbert, 1890; Dulhunty, 1975). The presence of very well developed coastal landforms may suggest shoreline formation during an open-basin interval of threshold control (Gale, 1915). Relative duration deductions made on the basis of comparative landform size, however, are made very cautiously since several factors besides water-level duration may contribute to the total amount of geomorphic work performed at a shoreline. In other words, “everything else” is typically not equal. These factors include a host of climatic, sedimentologic, and geomorphic variables that influence the size, frequency, and effectiveness of the waves which strike a given shoreline segment as well as its preservation potential (Gilbert, 1890; Dulhunty, 1975; Komar, 1976; Pethick, 1984; Bowler, 1986; Stine, 1990; Petty et al., 1996; Wilkins & Currey, 1997). Numeric age estimates are made from various materials found directly on or within relict coastal landforms, including wave-cut caves (Broecker & Orr, 1958; Thompson et al., 1986; Benson & Thompson, 1987). Conventional and accelerator mass spectrometer (AMS) radiocarbon ages of shorezone materials are most typically obtained from wood fragments, shells, and tufa (Feth & Rubin, 1957; Broecker & Orr, 1958; Bedwell, 1973; Scott, 1988; Oviatt & Nash, 1989; Oviatt et al., 1992), but age estimates of postlake organic matter, including varnish on shoreline clasts (Dorn et al., 1990) and dung from wave-cut caves (Jennings, 1957), have also been radiocarbon dated. Uranium-series dating techniques have been applied to shoreline tufa and shells (Broecker & Kaufman, 1965; Szabo et al., 1996). Optically stimulated luminescence and cosmogenic isotope dating methods have expanded the roster of datable materials to include coastal clastic sediments and erosional terraces. Numeric age estimates from multiple relict shorelines within a paleolake basin reveal considerable detail about how the lake fluctuated over time. For those basins that have them, dated shorelines constitute the principal benchmarks for reconstructing the paleolake hydrograph. Age estimates derived from nonshoreline lacustrine deposits, including deeper water sediments collected by coring, provide additional useful data but, except for desiccated intervals, less specific information regarding the elevation of the paleowater plane. Although a hydrograph may show changes in either lake surface elevation or area versus time, elevation remains the more commonly used variable (Fig. 1) (Currey & Madsen, 1974; Farrand & Drexler, 1985; Larsen, 1985a; Oviatt et al., 1992; Oviatt, 1997). One reason for this is that geomorphic preservation is not always sufficient to allow complete basinwide delineation of shorelines, and therefore measurement of surface area, with confidence. Ideally, hydrographs portray original shoreline elevations, which might differ from modern values because of neotectonism, and which might vary substantially around the basin due to differential isostatic deformation. Correcting the modern elevation of a preserved shoreline segment for postlacustrine isostatic deformation may be relatively simple or very complicated depending on how much is known about the neotectonic and outlet history
62
DOROTHY SACK
of the lake (Currey & Oviatt, 1985; Hansel et al., 1985; Lewis & Anderson, 1989; Sun & Teller, 1997; Tackman et al., 1998). In diagram form, many paleolake hydrographs give the impression of precision, certainty, and authority beyond what the data warrant (Currey, 1990). Because of the estimated nature of the temporal and reconstructed spatial data, however, hydrographs are best regarded as sets of working hypotheses which are subject to corrections and further refinement. Paleoclimatic reconstruction Once reconstructed, the history of a paleolake’s oscillations can be used to help interpret aspects of the regional paleoclimatic history. Lacustrine hydrographs, however, depict water-level variations over time regardless of their origin. Most major water-level changes in open basins are determined by threshold dynamics rather than by climate change. Threshold dynamics include outlet incision, changes in outlet elevation due to blockage or neotectonism, and outlet switching, which can be caused by blockage of the old outlet, blockage removal at the new outlet, or differential isostatic rebound between the two (Petty et al., 1996; Pengelly et al., 1997; Sun & Teller, 1997; Tackman et al., 1998). In addition, when an outlet channel is broad or when a small rise in lake level opens additional outlets, threshold control dampens the impact of non-outlet hydrologic factors, including climate change, drainage basin change by stream capture, and receipt of outburst overflow from upstream lakes and glacial meltwater channels (McCarthy & McAndrews, 1988; Lewis & Anderson, 1989; Tinkler & Pengelly, 1995). Reconstructed hydrographs of open-basin paleolakes, therefore, usually indicate the paleoclimatic regime in only a general way. The absence of external threshold control, on the other hand, leaves closed-basin lakes free to fluctuate in response to hydrologic changes of any origin. These include climatic as well as any non-outlet geomorphically induced hydrologic events that might occur, such as spillin from adjacent or upstream lakes, spillover to adjacent closed basins, and drainage basin changes by stream capture (Eardley et al., 1957; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979; Smith & Street-Perrott, 1983; Sack, in press). Not all closed-basin lakes experience these geomorphic events, which are sometimes minor when they do take place, and spill to or from adjacent closed basins is ultimately climate-driven. Hydrographs of closed-basin lakes, therefore, predominantly reflect the climatic signal, with geomorphic events affecting the magnitude and duration of the climatically driven trends or appearing as short-term water-level rises, falls, or stillstands (Gassé & Street, 1978; Cerling, 1986). Paleoclimatic reconstruction is more fruitfully accomplished using data from closed- rather than open-basin paleolakes because the former have fuller records of water-level fluctuations and stillstands, and those are more likely to be climate-driven. “Existing, as they do, in balance between factors of input and output, the fluctuations in water level of closed lakes are often viewed as indexes of climatic variation” (Langbein, 1961:7). Although lake level data are convenient to use when constructing hydrographs, they are not the most appropriate data for making climatic inferences from the paleolake shoreline record. This is the case because the fundamental variable that actually connects a change in the hydrologic input to the response of the closed-lake system is lake surface area. Assuming no outflow to the groundwater system, closed-basin lakes respond directly to variations in hydrologic input by adjusting their surface area to the size at which evaporation
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
63
losses from the lake surface just balance the hydrologic input (Gale, 1915; Eardley et al., 1957; Langbein, 1961; Benson & Paillet, 1989). The elevation at which a given surface area is attained is determined by the three-dimensional shape of the lake basin, and the hydrographic responsiveness of a basin can vary substantially with changes in basin slope along the perimeter of the lake (Langbein, 1961; Street-Perrott & Harrison, 1985; Benson & Thompson, 1987; Benson & Paillet, 1989; Currey, 1994b; Mason et al., 1994). Paleovalues of precipitation, evaporation, and runoff have been estimated from closed paleolake basins using the ratio, or pluvial hydrologic index,
where AL is the reconstructed paleolake surface area and AB is the area of the rest of the lake’s drainage basin (Broecker & Orr, 1958; Snyder & Langbein, 1962; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979). Early in the twentieth century Meinzer (1922) had used paleolake surface area as a percentage of drainage basin area to compare the hydrologic productivity of three western North American late Pleistocene lake drainage basins. Broecker & Orr (1958) connected the ratio of closed-basin lake area to drainage basin area more directly to climatic variables by considering the equilibrium situation of constant surface area. Steady surface area results when annual evaporative loss from the closed-basin lake surface equals the annual input of direct precipitation onto the lake plus runoff from the drainage basin. This water balance is represented by the equation
where R is runoff into the lake from the tributary drainage basin, PL is precipitation onto the lake, and EL is evaporation from the lake. By expressing R in terms of precipitation and evaporation over the tributary drainage basin, PB and EB, respectively, equation (2) may be rewritten
or Reconstructed paleolake shorelines are necessary for measuring both AL and AB, and thus provide a critical link to the paleoclimatic variables. Although these equations do not generate unique values of the paleoclimatic variables, they have been used to estimate the most probable combinations of precipitation, temperature, evaporation, and runoff needed to maintain various late Pleistocene lakes, and reasonable estimates have been made on a regional basis (Broecker & Orr, 1958; Snyder & Langbein, 1962; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979; Street-Perrott & Harrison, 1985; Sack, 1994). Other applications Relict shorelines of known age are useful for scientific endeavors besides paleoclimatic reconstruction. Because of cross-cutting relationships with other Quaternary landforms or sediments, dated shorelines furnish maximum- and minimum-limiting age control on a variety of geomorphic and geologic events, including faulting (Fig. 5) (Petersen, 1984),
64
DOROTHY SACK
basaltic eruptions (Hoover, 1974; Oviatt & Nash, 1989), slope failures (Van Horn, 1975; Currey, 1982), and others. They have figured prominently in studies of landscape evolution (Sack, 1992b, 1995). Because of their original horizontality, geophysicists employ now-deformed paleolake shorelines to quantify isostatic rebound, reconstruct deflection histories, and constrain estimates of upper mantle viscosity and lithospheric thickness (Crittenden, 1963; Passey, 1981; Nakiboglu & Lambeck, 1983; Currey, 1990; Bills et al., 1994;Lambert et al., 1998;Seppa & Tikkanen, 1998;Tackman et al., 1998). Paleoecological applications of the shoreline record can result from understanding the overflow history of a paleolake (Hubbs & Miller, 1948; Mifflin & Wheat, 1979). In addition, lake size and shape influence the accumulation of pollen and other biological and geochemical material, therefore paleoenvironmental interpretations derived from those deposits must consider the impact of paleolake morphometry (Punning & Koff, 1997). Conclusions and future outlook Geomorphology plays an essential role in paleolimnological research because it is involved as both a cause and an effect of the ancient water bodies. Geomorphic research, moreover, is not conducted in a disciplinary vacuum. Geomorphologists continue to combine landform, sediment, and stratigraphic evidence in their analyses of the paleolake shoreline record. Study of the relict landform evidence of Quaternary lakes is necessary for reconstructing their paleoshorelines, which reveal actual positions of the water plane. Many morphometric attributes of a paleolake can be determined once the paleoshorelines are delineated onto a topographic base map (Table III). Thus far, the most important of these variables is paleolake surface area, which provides a direct tie to the paleoclimate once geomorphic factors affecting lake level are accounted for. During the second half of the 20th century, the landform evidence of paleolakes has generally received less attention than the evidence available from sediment cores. A growing interest among geomorphologists in Quaternary science, advances in surveying and geographic positioning technologies, and the development of optically stimulated luminescence and cosmogenic isotope dating methods, however, are generating renewed interest in paleolake geomorphology. Attention to the geomorphic evidence should continue to increase with further technological advances. A future surge in paleolake geomorphic research is expected once detailed chronologies have been worked out for more and more paleolakes, and researchers find new ways to analyze the landform evidence. Dated shorelines have already proven themselves to be valuable in a variety of applications, ranging from climate reconstruction through landscape evolution to geophysical modelling. With further refinement in shoreline dating techniques, such applications will undoubtedly become increasingly refined and increasingly useful. Summary In addition to providing relict shorezone landform evidence that documents the existence and changing extent of ancient lakes, geomorphology is one of the environmental factors that helped to determine the existence and changing extent of paleolakes. Because geomorphology acts as both a cause and an effect of lakes, it is truly a fundamental aspect
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
65
of paleolimnological research. Many paleolake studies are conducted for the purpose of contributing to paleoclimatic reconstruction. Because changing water levels reflect both the geomorphic and the climatic history of the drainage basin, an accurate reconstruction of paleoclimate from paleolake data requires recognizing the geomorphically and climatically influenced aspects of the lacustrine hydrographic response. Climatic factors alone are not responsible for the formation and evolution of a lake. The existence of a lake requires a topographic basin in addition to the appropriate mix of climatic variables. The topography of the drainage basin, moreover, affects precipitation values and the amount of surface runoff reaching a lake basin. Compared to lakes that have outflowing streams, closed–basin lakes fluctuate much more readily in size in response to changes in the hydrologic input-to-output ratio, and therefore represent significantly better sources of paleohydrologic data. The surface area of a closed-basin lake is controlled by precipitation onto the lake, evaporation from the lake, drainage basin precipitation, and drainage basin runoff. The three-dimensional shape of the closed lake basin determines the lake level at which an equilibrium lake area is attained. Paleovalues of climatic variables can be estimated by comparing paleolake area with drainage basin area. Thus, the ratio of a closed-basin paleolake’s surface area to the area of the rest of its drainage basin provides a very important means for linking the physical paleolake record with paleoclimatic attributes. Lake basin and drainage basin geomorphology influence lake formation and behavior, but the water body, in turn, has waves and currents that erode, transport, and deposit earth material into distinctive shorezone landforms, such as wave-cut terraces, wave-cut cliffs, beaches, barriers, spits, and tombolos. Preserved portions of relict shoreline landforms are the principal, surviving geomorphic effect of paleolakes, and they play a crucial role in paleolake studies. Because relict shorelines were created at the interface between the water surface and the land, they are direct evidence of paleolake level and of the location of the paleolake perimeter. Reconstructions of how closed-basin paleolake level and surface area changed through time require detailed knowledge of paleoshoreline position and age. Relict shoreline segments are most commonly identified on aerial photographs and from geomorphic and sedimentologic observations in the field. Isolated shoreline segments within a single basin can be correlated using elevation measurements, topographic profiles, distinctive deposits, and relative and numeric dating techniques. Careful mapping of paleolake shorelines onto a topographic base relies on the techniques of shoreline identification and correlation, including field checking, and creates a valuable source of qualitative and quantitative data regarding the three-dimensional configuration of the former water body. Once reliable age estimates are obtained for them, delineated shorelines constitute the principal benchmarks for reconstructing a paleolake hydrograph. Paleolake hydrographs are the culmination of considerable research time and effort, and give the impression of precision, certainty, and authority, but they are best considered works in progress that are subject to correction and refinement as more field data are gathered and as further technological innovations occur. Acknowledgments I thank W. M. Last and J. P. Smol for inviting me to participate in this volume, and all reviewers of the manuscript for their time and thoughtful comments.
66
DOROTHY SACK
References Allison, I. S., 1940. Study of Pleistocene lakes of south central Oregon. Carnegie Inst. Washington Yearbook 39: 299–300. Allison, I. S., 1945. Pumice beds at Summer Lake, Oregon. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 56: 789–808. Allison, I. S., 1952. Dating of pluvial lakes in the Great Basin. Am. J. Sci. 250: 907–909. Allison, I. S., 1954. Pluvial lake levels of south-central Oregon. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 65: 1331. Antevs, E., 1945. Correlation of Wisconsin glacial maxima. Am. J. Sci. 243A: 1–39. Avery, T. E. & G. L. Berlin, 1992. Fundamentals of Remote Sensing and Airphoto Interpretation. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River (N.J.), 472 pp. Avouac, J.-P., J.-F. Dobremez & L. Bourjot, 1996. Palaeoclimatic interpretation of a topographic profile across middle Holocene regressive shorelines of Longmu Co (western Tibet). Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 120: 93–104. Beckwith, E. G., 1855. Explorations for a route for the Pacific Railroad, of the line of the fortyfirst parallel of North Latitude. In Reports of Explorations and Surveys to Ascertain the Most Practicable and Economic Route for a Railroad from the Mississippi River to the Pacific Ocean 1853–4. Congr. Doc., 33rd Congress, 2nd Sess., Senate Exec. Doc. No. 78. Bedwell, S. F., 1973. Fort Rock Basin: Prehistory and Environment. University of Oregon, Eugene, 159 pp. Benson, L. V., 1978. Fluctuation in the level of pluvial Lake Lahontan during the last 40,000 years. Quat. Res. 9: 300–318. Benson, L. V., 1994. Carbonate deposition, Pyramid Lake subbasin, Nevada, 1: Sequence of formation and elevational distribution of carbonate deposits (tufas). Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 109: 55–87. Benson, L. V. & F. L. Paillet, 1989. The use of total lake-surface area as an indicator of climatic changes: Examples from the Lahontan basin. Quat. Res. 32: 262–275. Benson, L. V. & R. S. Thompson, 1987. Lake-level variation in the Lahontan basin for the past 50,000 years. Quat. Res. 28: 69–85. Bills, B. G., D. R. Currey & G. A. Marshall, 1994. Viscosity estimates for the crust and upper mantle from patterns of lacustrine shoreline deformation in the eastern Great Basin. J. Geophys. Res. 99: 22, 059–22, 086. Bissell, H. J., 1963. Lake Bonneville: Geology of southern Utah Valley, Utah. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 257-B. Blackwelder, E., 1933. Lake Manly: An extinct lake of Death Valley. Geog. Rev. 23: 464–471. Blackwelder, E., 1954. Pleistocene lakes and drainage in the Mojave region, southern California. Calif. Div. Mines & Geol. Bull. 170: 35–40. Blackwelder, E. & E. E. Ellsworth, 1936. Pleistocene lakes of the Afton basin, California. Am. J. Sci. 231:453–463. Bowler, J. M., 1971. Pleistocene salinities and climatic change: Evidence from lakes and lunettes in southeastern Australia. In Mulvaney, D. J. & J. Golson (eds.) Aboriginal Man and Environment in Australia. Aust. National Univ. Press, Canberra: 47–65. Bowler, J. M., 1986. Spatial variability and hydrologic evolution of Australian lake basins: Analogue for Pleistocene hydrologic change and evaporite formation. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 54:21–41. Bowman, D., 1971. Geomorphology of the shore terraces of the late Pleistocene Lisan Lake (Israel). Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 9: 183–209. Broecker, W. S. & A. Kaufman, 1965. Radiocarbon chronology of Lake Lahontan and Lake Bonneville II, Great Basin. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 76: 537–566. Broecker, W. S. & P. C. Orr, 1958. Radiocarbon chronology of Lake Lahontan and Lake Bonneville. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 69: 1009–1032.
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
67
Burr, T. N. & D. R. Currey, 1988. The Stockton Bar. Utah Geol. & Min. Surv. Misc. Pub. 88-1: 66–73. Cerling, T., 1986. A mass-balance approach to basin sedimentation: Constraints on the recent history of the Turkana basin. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 54: 63–86. Coventry, R. J., 1976. Abandoned shorelines and the late Quaternary history of Lake George, New South Wales. J. Geol. Soc. Aust. 23: 249–273. Coventry, R. J. & P. H. Walker, 1977. Geomorphological significance of late Quaternary deposits of the Lake George area, N.S.W. Aust. Geog. 13: 369–376. Cowan, W. R., 1985. Deglacial Great Lakes shorelines at Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario. Geol. Assoc. Can. Sp. Paper 30: 33–37. Cowardin, L. M., V. Carter, F. C. Golet & E. T. LaRoe, 1979. Classification of wetlands and deepwater habitats of the United States. U.S. Fish & Wildl. Serv. FWS/OBS-79/31, 103 pp. Crittenden, M. D., Jr., 1963. New data on the isostatic deformation of Lake Bonneville. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 454E. Currey, D. R., 1980. Coastal geomorphology of Great Salt Lake and vicinity. Utah Geol. & Min. Surv. Bull. 116:69–82. Currey, D. R., 1982. Lake Bonneville: Selected features of relevance to neotectonic analysis. U.S. Geol. Surv. Open-File Report 82–1070, 30 pp. Currey, D. R., 1990. Quaternary palaeolakes in the evolution of semidesert basins, with special emphasis on Lake Bonneville and the Great Basin, USA. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 76: 189–214. Currey, D. R., 1994a. Hemiarid lake basins: Geomorphic patterns. In Abrahams, A. D. & A. J. Parsons (eds.) Geomorphology of Desert Environments. Chapman & Hall, London: 422–444. Currey, D. R., 1994b. Hemiarid lake basins: Hydrographic patterns. In Abrahams, A. D. & A. J. Parsons (eds.) Geomorphology of Desert Environments. Chapman & Hall, London: 405–421. Currey, D. R. & D. B. Madsen, 1974. Holocene fluctuations of Great Salt Lake. Am. Quat. Assoc. Abstr. 3: 74. Currey, D. R. & C. G. Oviatt, 1985. Durations, average rates, and probable causes of Lake Bonneville expansions, stillstands, and contractions during the last deep-lake cycle, 32,000 to 10,000 years ago. Geogr. J. Korea 10: 1085–1099. Currey, D. R., C. G. Oviatt & G. B. Plyler, 1983. Lake Bonneville stratigraphy, geomorphology, and isostatic deformation in west-central Utah. Utah Geol. & Min. Surv. Sp. Study 62: 63–82. Davis, J. O., 1983. Level of Lake Lahontan during deposition of the Trego Hot Springs tephra about 23,400 years ago. Quat. Res. 19: 312–324. Davis, W. M., 1899. The geographical cycle. Geogr. J. 14: 681–504. Dennis, P. E., 1944. Shore-lines of the Escalante Bay of Lake Bonneville. Proc. Utah Acad. Sci., Arts & Letters 19/20: 121–124. Dorn, R. I., A. J. T. Jull, D. J. Donahue, T. W. Linick & L. J. Toolin, 1990. Latest Pleistocene lake shorelines and glacial chronology in the western Basin and Range province, U.S.A.: Insights from AMS radiocarbon dating of rock varnish and paleoclimatic implications. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 78:315–331. Dulhunty, J. A., 1975. Shoreline shingle terraces and prehistoric fillings of Lake Eyre. Trans, r. Soc. S. Aust. 99: 183–188. Eardley, A. J., V. Gvosdetsky & R. E. Marsell, 1957. Hydrology of Lake Bonneville and sediments and soils of its basin. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 68: 1141–1201. Farrand, W. R. & C. W. Drexler, 1985. Late Wisconsinan and Holocene history of the Lake Superior basin. Geol. Assoc. Can. Sp. Paper 30: 17–32. Feth, J. H., 1961. A new map of western conterminous United States showing the maximum known or inferred extent of Pleistocene lakes. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 424-B: 110–112. Feth, J. H. & M. Rubin, 1957. Radiocarbon dating of wave-formed tufas from the Bonneville basin. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 68: 1827.
68
DOROTHY SACK
Frey, D. G., 1988. What is paleolimnology? J. Paleolim. 1: 5–8. Gale, H. S., 1915. Salines in the Owens, Searles, and Panamint basins, southeastern California. U.S. Geol. Surv. Bull. 580: 251–323. Gassé, F. & F. A. Street, 1978. Late Quaternary lake-level fluctuations and environments of the northern Rift Valley and Afar region (Ethiopia and Djibouti). Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 24: 279–325. Gilbert, G. K., 1871. On certain glacial and postglacial phenomena of the Maumee Valley. Am. J. Sci. 1:339–345. Gilbert, G. K., 1885. Topographic features of lake shores. U.S. Geol. Surv. Fifth Annual Report: 69–123. Gilbert, G. K., 1890. Lake Bonneville. U.S. Geol. Surv. Monograph 1, 438 pp. Giraudi, C., 1989. Lake levels and climate for the last 30,000 years in the Fucino area (Abruzzo–central Italy) — A review. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 70: 249–260. Goldthwait, J. W., 1906. Correlation of the raised beaches on the west side of Lake Michigan. J. Geol. 14:411–424. Goldthwait, J. W., 1910. Isobases of the Algonquin and Iroquois beaches and their significance. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 21: 227–248. Grove, A. T., F. A. Street & A. S. Goudie, 1975. Former lake levels and climatic change in the Rift Valley of southern Ethiopia. Geogr. J. 141: 177–202. Håkanson, L., 1981. A Manual of Lake Morphometry. Springer-Verlag, N.Y., 78 pp. Hansel, A. K., D. M. Mickelson, A. F. Schneider & C. E. Larsen, 1985. Late Wisconsinan and Holocene history of the Lake Michigan basin. Geol. Assoc. Can. Sp. Paper 30: 39–53. Hoover, J. D., 1974. Periodic Quaternary volcanism in the Black Rock Desert, Utah. Brigham Young Univ. Geol. Studies 21: 3–72. Hubbs, C. L. & R. R. Miller, 1948. The zoological evidence. Bull. Univ. of Utah 38: 17–166. Hunt, C. B., H. D. Varnes & H. E. Thomas, 1953. Lake Bonneville: Geology of northern Utah Valley, Utah. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 257-A. Hutchinson, G. E., 1957. A Treatise on Limnology, 1. J. Wiley & Sons, N.Y., 1015 pp. Jennings, J. D., 1957. Danger Cave. Univ. Utah Anthropol. Papers 27, 328 pp. King, G. Q., 1993. Late Quaternary history of the lower Walker River and it implications for the Lahontan paleolake system. Phys. Geog. 14: 81–96. Komar, P. D., 1976. Beach Processes and Sedimentation. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 429 pp. Lambert, A., T. S. James & L. H. Thorleifson, 1998. Combining geomorphological and geodetic data to determine postglacial tilting in Manitoba. J. Paleolim. 19: 365–376. Langbein, W. B., 1961. Salinity and hydrology of closed lakes. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 412, 20pp. Larsen, C. T., 1985a. A stratigraphic study of beach features on the southwestern shore of Lake Michigan: New evidence of Holocene lake level fluctuations. Illinois State Geol. Surv. Env. Geol. Notes 112, 31 pp. Larsen, C. T., 1985b. Lake level, uplift, and outlet incision, the Nipissing and Algoma Great Lakes. Geol. Assoc. Can. Sp. Paper 30: 63–77. Last, W. M. & L. A. Slezak, 1986. Paleohydrology, sedimentology, and geochemistry of two meromictic saline lakes in southern Saskatchewan. Geographie Phys. Quat. 40: 5–15. Lawson, A. C., 1893. Sketch of the coastal topography of the north side of Lake Superior with special reference to the abandoned strands of Lake Warren. Minn. Geol. & Nat. Hist. Surv. Annual Report 20: 181–289. Leverett, F., 1897. The Pleistocene features and deposits of the Chicago area. Chicago Acad. Sci., Geol. & Nat. Hist. Surv. Bull. 2, 86 pp.
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
69
Leverett, F., 1908. Ann Arbor folio. U.S. Geol. Surv. Folio No. 155. Leverett, F. & F. B. Taylor, 1915. The Pleistocene of Indiana and Michigan, and the history of the Great Lakes. U.S. Geol. Surv. Monograph 53, 529 pp. Lewis, C. F. M. & T. W. Anderson, 1989. Oscillations of levels and cool phases of the Laurentian Great Lakes caused by inflows from glacial Lakes Agassiz and Barlow-Ojibway. J. Paleolim. 2: 99–146. Lister, G. S., K. Kelts, C. K. Zao, J. Yu & F. Niessen, 1991. Lake Qinghai, China: Closed-basin lake levels and the oxygen isotope record for ostracoda since the latest Pleistocene. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 84: 141–162. Löffler, E. & M. E. Sullivan, 1979. Lake Dieri resurrected: An interpretation using satellite imagery. Z. Geomorph. 23: 233–242. Mason, I. M., M. A. J. Guzkowska, C. G. Rapley & F. A. Street-Perrott, 1994. The response of lake levels and areas to climatic change. Clim. Change 27: 161–197. McCarthy, F. M. G. & J. H. McAndrews, 1988. Water levels in Lake Ontario 4230–2000 years B.P.: Evidence from Grenadier Pond, Toronto, Canada. J. Paleolim. 1: 99–113. Meinzer, O. E., 1922. Map of the Pleistocene lakes of the Basin-and-Range province and its significance. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 33: 541–552. Mifflin, M. D. & M. M. Wheat, 1971. Isostatic rebound in the Lahontan basin, northwestern Great Basin. Geol. Soc. Am. Abstr. 7: 647. Mifflin, M. D. & M. M. Wheat, 1979. Pluvial lakes and estimated pluvial climates of Nevada. Nevada Bur. Mines & Geol. Bull. 94, 57 pp. Morrison, R. B., 1964. Lake Lahontan: Geology of southern Carson Desert, Nevada. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 401, 156 pp. Morrison, R. B., 1965a. New evidence on Lake Bonneville stratigraphy and history from southern Promontory Point, Utah. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Paper 525C: 110–119. Morrison, R. B., 1965b. Quaternary geology of the Great Basin. In Wright, H. E., Jr. & D. G. Frey (eds.) The Quaternary of the United States. Princeton University Press: 265–285. Morrison, R. B., 1966. Predecessors of Great Salt Lake. Utah Geol. Soc. Guidebook Geol. of Utah 20: 77–104. Nakiboglu, S. M. & K. Lambeck, 1983. A reevaluation of the isostatic rebound of Lake Bonneville. J. Geophys. Res. 88: 10, 439–10, 447. Oviatt, C. G., 1989. Quaternary geology of part of the Sevier Desert, Millard County, Utah. Utah Geol. & Min. Surv. Sp. Study 70, 41 pp. Oviatt, C. G., 1991 a. Quaternary geology of the Black Rock Desert, Millard County, Utah. Utah Geol. & Min. Surv. Sp. Study 73, 23 pp. Oviatt, C. G., 1991b. Quaternary geology of Fish Springs Flat, Juab County, Utah. Utah Geol. Surv. Sp. Study 77, 16 pp. Oviatt, C. G., 1997. Lake Bonneville fluctuations and global climate change. Geology 25: 155–158. Oviatt, C. G. & W. P. Nash, 1989. Late Pleistocene basaltic ash and volcanic eruptions in the Bonneville basin, Utah. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 101: 292–303. Oviatt, C. G., D. R. Currey & D. Sack, 1992. Radiocarbon chronology of Lake Bonneville, eastern Great Basin, USA. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 99: 225–241. Passey, Q. R., 1981. Upper mantle viscosity derived from the difference in rebound of the Provo and Bonneville shorelines: Lake Bonneville basin, Utah. J. Geophys. Res. 86: 11, 701–11, 708. Pengelly, J. W., K. J. Tinkler, W. G. Parkins & F. M. McCarthy, 1997. 12,600 years of lake level changes, changing sills, ephemeral lakes and Niagara Gorge erosion in the Niagara Peninsula and eastern Lake Erie basin. J. Paleolim. 17: 377–402. Petersen, J. F., 1984. Equilibrium tendency in piedmont scarp denudation, Wasatch Front, Utah. In Morisawa, M. & J. T. Hack (eds.) Tectonic Geomorphology. Allen & Unwin, Boston: 209–233. Pethick, J., 1984. An Introduction to Coastal Geomorphology. Edward Arnold, London, 260 pp.
70
DOROTHY SACK
Petty, W. J., P. A. Delcourt & H. R. Delcourt, 1996. Holocene lake-level fluctuations and beach-ridge development along the northern shore of Lake Michigan, USA. J. Paleolim. 15: 147–169. Punning, J.-M. & T. Koff, 1997. The landscape factor in the formation of pollen records in lake sediments. J. Paleolim. 18: 33–44. Quade, J., 1986. Late Quaternary environmental changes in the upper Las Vegas Valley, Nevada. Quat. Res. 26: 340–357. Reeves, C. C., Jr., 1969. Pluvial Lake Palomas northwestern Chihuahua, Mexico. New Mex. Geol. Soc. Field Conf. Guidebook 20: 143–154. Russell, I. C., 1876. On the formation of lakes. Pop. Sci. Monthly 9: 539–546. Russell, I. C., 1885. Geological history of Lake Lahontan, a Quaternary lake of northwestern Nevada. U.S. Geol. Surv. Monograph 11, 288 pp. Sack, D., 1989. Reconstructing the chronology of Lake Bonneville: An historical review. In Tinkler, K. J. (ed.) History of Geomorphology. Unwin-Hyman, London: 223–256. Sack, D., 1990. Quaternary geology of Tule Valley, west-central Utah. Utah Geol. & Min. Surv. Map 124, 26 pp. Sack, D., 1992a. New wine in old bottles: The historiography of a paradigm change. Geomorphology 5: 251–263. Sack, D., 1992b. Obliteration of surficial paleolake evidence in the Tule Valley subbasin of Lake Bonneville. Soc. Sed. Geol. (SEPM) Sp. Pub. 48: 427–433. Sack, D., 1993. Quaternary geologic map of Skull Valley, Tooele County, Utah. Utah Geol. Surv. Map 150, 16 pp. Sack, D., 1994. Geomorphic evidence of climate change from desert-basin palaeolakes. In Abrahams, A. D. & A. J. Parsons (eds.) Geomorphology of Desert Environments. Chapman & Hall, London: 616–630. Sack, D., 1995. The shoreline preservation index as a relative-age dating tool for late Pleistocene shorelines: An example from the Bonneville basin, USA. Earth Surface Process Landf. 20: 363– 377. Sack, D., 1999. The composite nature of the Provo level of Lake Bonneville, Great Basin, western North America. Quat. Res. 52: 316–327. Sack, D. Fluvial linkages in Lake Bonneville subbasin integration. Smithson. Contr. Earth Sci. 33, in press. Schwennesen, A. T., 1918. Ground water in the Animas, Playas, Hachita, and San Luis basins, New Mexico. U.S. Geol. Surv. Water-Supply Paper 422, 152 pp. Scott, W. E., 1988. Transgressive and high-shore deposits of the Bonneville lake cycle near North Salt Lake, Utah. Utah Geol. Surv. Misc. Pub. 88-1: 38–42. Seppa, H. & M. Tikkanen, 1998. The isolation of Kruunuvuorenlampi, southern Finland, and implications for Holocene shore displacement models of the Finnish coast. J. Paleolim. 19: 385–398. Smith, G. I. & F. A. Street-Perrott, 1983. Pluvial lakes of the western United States. In Porter, S. C. (ed.) Late Quaternary Environments of the United States. Univ. Minnesota Press, Minneapolis: 190–212. Snyder, C. T. & W. B. Langbein, 1962. The Pleistocene lake in Spring Valley, Nevada, and its climatic implications. J. Geophys. Res. 67: 2385–2394. Stansbury, H., 1852. Exploration and Survey of the Valley of the Great Salt Lake of Utah. Congr. Doc., 32nd Congress, U.S. Senate Sp. Session, March 1851, Exec. Doc. 3. Lippincott, Grambo & Co., Philadelphia. Stine, S., 1990. Late Holocene fluctuations of Mono Lake, eastern California. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 78: 333–381. Strahler, A. N., 1950. Davis’ concepts of slope development viewed in the light of recent quantitative investigations. Ann. Assoc. Am. Geog. 40: 209–213.
SHORELINE AND BASIN CONFIGURATION . . .
71
Strahler, A. N., 1952. Dynamic basis of geomorphology. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 63: 923–938. Street-Perrott, F. A. & S. P. Harrison, 1985. Lake levels and climate reconstructions. In Hecht, A. D. (ed.) Paleoclimate Analysis and Modeling. J. Wiley & Sons, N.Y.: 291–340. Sun, C. S. & J. T. Teller, 1997. Reconstruction of glacial Lake Hind in southwestern Manitoba, Canada. J. Paleolim. 17: 9–21. Szabo, B. J., C. A. Buch & L. V. Benson, 1996. Uranium-series dating of carbonate (tufa) deposits associated with Quaternary fluctuations of Pyramid Lake, Nevada. Quat. Res. 45: 271–281. Tackman, G. E., D. R. Currey, B. G. Bills & T. S. James, 1998. Paleoshoreline evidence for postglacial tilting in southern Manitoba. J. Paleolim. 19: 343–363. Taylor, F. B., 1897. Notes on the abandoned beaches of the north shore of Lake Superior. Am. Geol. 20: 111–127. Teller, J. T. & W. M. Last, 1990. Paleohydrological indicators in playas and salt lakes, with examples from Canada, Australia, and Africa. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 76: 215–240. Thomas, R. G., 1963. The late Pleistocene 150 foot fresh water beach line of the Salton Sea area. S. Calif. Acad. Sci. Bull. 62: 9–17. Thompson, D. G., 1929. The Mohave Desert region, California. U.S. Geol. Surv. Water-Supply Paper 578. Thompson, R. S., L. V. Benson & E. M. Hattori, 1986. A revised chronology for the last Pleistocene lake cycle in the central Lahontan basin. Quat. Res. 25: 1–9. Tinkler, K. J. & J. W. Pengelly, 1995. Great Lakes response to catastrophic inflows from Lake Agassiz: Some simulations to a hydraulic geometry for chained lake systems. J. Paleolim. 13: 252–266. Tinkler, K. J., J. W. Pengelly, W. G. Parkins & J. Terasmae, 1992. Evidence for high water levels in the Erie basin during the Younger Dryas chronozone. J. Paleolim. 7: 215–234. Upham, W., 1895. The glacial Lake Agassiz. U.S. Geol. Surv. Monograph 25, 658 pp. Van Horn, R., 1975. Largest known landslide of its type in the United States: A failure by lateral spreading in Davis County, Utah. Utah Geol. 2: 83–88. Whittlesey, C., 1850. On the natural terraces and ridges of the country bordering Lake Erie. Am. J. Sci. 10: 31–39. Wilkins, D. E., 1997. Hemiarid basin responses to abrupt climatic change: Paleolakes of the TransPecos closed basin. Phys. Geog. 18: 460–477. Wilkins, D. E. & D. R. Currey, 1997. Timing and extent of late Quaternary paleolakes in the TransPecos closed basin, west Texas and south-central New Mexico. Quat. Res. 47: 306–315.
This page intentionally left blank
5. SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
JOHN R. GLEW (
[email protected]) & JOHN P. SMOL ( SmolJ@Biology. QueensU. Ca) Paleoecological Environmental Assessment and Research Lab (PEARL) Department of Biology Queen’s University, Kingston Ontario K7L 3N6, Canada WILLIAM M. LAST ( WM_Last@UManitoba. CA) Department of Geological Sciences University of Manitoba Winnipeg, Manitoba R3T2N2, Canada Keywords: corers, sediments, piston corers, gravity corers, freeze corers, vibracorers, pneumatic corers, samplers, equipment, paleolimnology
Introduction For many workers in the field of paleolimnology, the retrieval of an unmixed, continuous sediment core marks the first step in a lengthy process. Collecting the core is, in many ways, the most critical part of the paleolimnological process, as any errors or problems encountered during core collection can rarely be corrected “after-the-fact”. The success of the entire project, and all the subsequent, time-consuming analyses, depends on this first step: the recovery of a good sample. Retrieving good cores can be difficult and will always be considered by some as a rather unpredictable ‘grey area’ of the work. This is because coring operations often require skills and familiarity with equipment that are unlike those required for much of the other laboratory-based aspects of the work. Adding to this are the other factors associated with any kind of field work, such as incomplete knowledge of the sampling site, depth of water, nature of the sediment, as well as the effects of prevailing weather, the logistics of moving and setting up equipment in remote sites, and so forth. All these factors work together to make such operations seldom routine, even for the most experienced paleolimnologist. “Paleolimnological coring” is a broad term and some of what is covered in this chapter would not necessarily be referred to as “coring” in other technical fields, including operations such as in situ freezing and sidewall sampling, etc. This is the result of the adoption 73 W. M. Last & J. P. Smol(eds.), 2001. Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
74
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
of a variety of techniques from other disciplines. These techniques have been used by some paleolimnologists to augment or replace conventional coring, and the inconsistencies in naming the devices and techniques likely reflect the different origins of the equipment. Hence, the proliferation of paleolimnological coring equipment over the last five decades or so has resulted in a “mixed bag” of somewhat standardized devices that often have their origins in such fields as civil engineering, mining, soil science, ice drilling, groundwater investigations, and the marine sciences. Our goal is to provide the reader with an overview of the major generic categories of equipment used for the retrieval of relatively short to moderate length (<10m long) unconsolidated lake sediment cores, and to provide our opinions on the advantages and disadvantages of each type. The goal of this chapter is not to summarize all available apparatus and techniques used for lake sediment coring. Such a compilation would require enough pages to fill a large book, and is certainly beyond the scope of this chapter. Several reviews and monographs have been completed on lake sediment coring (e.g., Cushing & Wright, 1965; Wright et al., 1965; Bouma, 1969; ASTM, 1971; Acker, 1974; Kézdi, 1980; Wright, 1980, 1991; Håkanson & Jansson, 1983; Aaby, 1986; Murdoch & Azcue, 1995; Colman, 1996), and the reader is referred to these compilations for more details. Moreover, new coring devices, or more often modifications of existing coring apparatus, are constantly being proposed. A companion chapter in this volume deals with drilling equipment and the recovery of long sedimentary sequences (Leroy & Colman, this volume). Our overall view is that no one type of sediment corer is applicable to all types of studies and conditions. We do, however, believe that virtually every lacustrine sediment sequence can be sampled in an effective manner, as long as the proper equipment and techniques are used. To do this often requires a number of different coring devices, depending on factors such as the type of sediment and the temporal resolution required by the investigators. In addition, a number of other conditions exist that determine the design and operation of the corer. Water depth is probably the most significant of these factors. On dry lake beds or in playa lake environments, the sediment surface may afford easy access and can be inspected and sampled with the simplest of equipment. For subaqueous limnological sampling, the sediments become more remote as water depth increases, and may ultimately require fully automated equipment to sample them.
Aim of good core recovery The first requirement of sediment coring is to recover an undisturbed sample, typically including the sediment/water interface (i.e., a representative sample of the material that makes up the lake bed). The requirements of an undisturbed sample, or sediment core, were outlined by Hvorslev (1949) as meeting three criteria: (1) no disturbance of structure; (2) no change in water content or void ratio; and (3) no change in constituent or chemical composition. Meeting these criteria is often difficult and many of the features that are key design elements of the equipment described here represent approaches to solving problems associated with recovering undisturbed samples.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
75
Nature of lacustrine sediment Lake sediments can vary greatly in density and consistency. The genesis of the sediment, the processes by which the material is transported to the lake, its pathway through the water body, and the diagenetic processes acting upon it as it is incorporated into the lake bed are all significant factors. From a sampling point of view, the most significant factor is the variation in mechanical shear strength that occurs with depth. Material at the sedimentwater interface in the offshore areas of lakes often has such a high-water content and low strength that it is more liquid than solid (often more than 90% water content), whereas more deeply buried material or sediment in the nearshore and shoreline areas of a lake can be well compacted and consolidated. Offshore sedimentation in lake basins can, under favourable conditions, approach a nearperfect example of the law of superposition. In such a situation, accumulating material from one period of time is systematically overlain by progressively younger material in a timestratigraphic sequence. Often, the single largest change in the character of the accumulating sediment is that of increased bulk density due to a gradual decrease in porosity, a consequence of increasing lithostatic pressure as the sedimentary sequence thickens. This gradual change from material of high water content, with bulk densities approaching at the top of the sediment column to more compact material having higher bulk density lower in the sequence is so great that, in practice, no single technique or piece of equipment is able to sample both adequately. These differences have resulted in the development of a group of samplers that are able to recover the soft and high-water content surface materials, and a second group that has greater penetrating ability and can recover deeper, more compact, high strength sediments. In limnological sampling, these two groups are often referred to simply as “short” and “long” cores. In practice, short cores are considered to be anything that samples down to about one meter from the sediment-water interface, including the surface sediments and the base of the water column, and long cores are those usually recovered sequentially (e.g., 1 meter lengths) and may not necessarily sample the material at the sediment-water interface without significant disturbance. Nature of the sampling process When considering the removal of sediment from the lake bed in a way that lifts the sample intact to the surface, two main categories of physical forces have to be taken into account. The first group of forces are such things as frictional forces that relate to the cohesion and density of the sediment (Fig. 1). The second group are those relating to the sampling mechanism or, in a broader context, the sampling system (Fig. 2). Into the latter category fall all the motions attributable to the environment in which the sampler is working (e.g., wave-coupled motion on a recovery line, dynamic imbalance as the device is lowered through the water, the weight distribution as the device is lowered and enters the sediment, as well as the effects of closing the device and withdrawing it). All these have some effect on the overall efficiency of the device, its ability to penetrate and recover sediment, and the degree to which the sample is disturbed. Although the motion of a core tube driven into the sediment by any means is fairly simple, its actual motion and the forces that relate to it are worth reviewing, as they will help in understanding why particular features incorporated in many of the devices outlined
76
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
here are important. The following summary relates specifically to core tubes (cylinders) driven vertically into the sediment, although the principles relate equally to other types of apparatus. Diagrammatically, the arrangement of forces outlined in Figure 1 are simplified and, in practice, not easy to separate. In the simple case of a gravity corer, the lowering of the core tube into the sediment transfers the weight from the suspended line to the lake sediment; in this situation the transfer is seldom uniform. First, there is a combination of motions illustrated in Figure 2 that affect the motion of the corer as it is suspended in the water column and as it enters the sediment. Secondly, a set of forces relating to the entry of the sampler into the sediment itself replaces those outlined in Figure 2. These forces are those related to the shear strength of the sediment and the hydrostatic pressure of water transmitted along the penetrating surfaces of the core tube. These can be considered as frictional forces acting on the side walls of the core tube ‘X’ in Figure 1 and are significant in terms of core penetration. If the sediment into which the core tube is being driven is of uniform consistency, the resisting forces acting on the tube increase proportionately to its surface area (tube length) in contact with the sediment. As the frictional force X approaches that of the applied driving force W, the descent of the core tube slows to a point where it may be considered stationary.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
77
Effects of frictional and deformational forces on the sediment sample Cores taken with open-barrel type equipment (see below) are frequently shorter than the penetrated depth. This is referred to as core shortening, or incorrectly as core compaction or core compression, and is defined as the length of the recovered core being shorter than the depth penetrated by the core tube. Analysis of many shortened cores reveal the geometry illustrated in Figure 3 where the stratigraphic elements of the core are usually thinned progressively down-core. This may occur more in some stratigraphic units than others (e.g., high water content units would be more affected). The process by which this thinning occurs has been the subject of speculation in the past, the most enigmatic aspect being the fate of the ‘lost’ material and the process involved in its removal (e.g., Crusius & Anderson, 1991; Cumming et al., 1993). Early work carried out by Emory & Dietze (1941) and Emory & Hulsemann (1964) found that, although the retrieved core was shorter than the penetrated sediment, the loss of water was insignificant. The cored section conformed to that illustrated in Figure 3, where the upper layers were represented in an undisturbed form and the lower strata were thinned progressively down the core (i.e., the boundaries between layers being closer together in the core than in the undisturbed sedimentary structure). This
78
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
has sometimes been attributed to compression, although subsequent analysis (Piggot, 1941) of the test material determined that true compression (i.e., reduction in volume of a given mass with increased pressure) had not occurred and instead each layer was present, but in smaller amounts. Therefore, although sometimes referred to as core compression, it is actually sediment that has been lost by being pushed laterally outwards ahead of the tube (i.e., it is lost before it enters the tube; Fig. 4). To understand how this takes place, one has to further examine the conditions that are outlined in Figure 1. The kinetic energy of the corer is expended in two ways as the core tube penetrates the sediment (Hvorslev, 1949). First, frictional wall forces are present on the outside and inside of the tube for frictional forces on the inside and outside of the tube, respectively); secondly, deformational forces (Y) occur at the leading edge of the tube as material is displaced to allow the core tube to penetrate. Both forces increase as penetration progresses but for different reasons (Fig. 1). The frictional forces increase simply as a function of tube length (i.e., the surface area of the tube in contact with the sediment). The deformational forces (Y), on the other hand, increase because the sediment at depth is more compact (having less water content) and offers greater resistance to deformation. This increase in compaction with depth also increases the frictional forces (X) to some extent, but this increase is considered negligible for purposes of this explanation. In the initial coring stages, while the penetration of the core tube is only a few centimeters into the sediment, the frictional forces are low, and little resistance is offered to additional material entering the tube as it descends. The deformation forces (Y) at this point are confined to the immediate area adjacent to the leading edge of the tube.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
79
As penetration of the tube into the sediment increases, the frictional forces (X) increase proportionally. The deformational forces at the tube edge (Y) increase as denser sediment is encountered with depth, but are not much greater than in the initial stages. The combined forces, X and Y, increase the entry resistance of the material into the tube, creating a bulbshaped pressure wave below the core tube (Fig. 4) that radially moves material away from the core axis. This combined force is responsible for the progressive thinning of the material by plastic deformation ahead of the descending tube (Piggot, 1941). If the resisting forces (X) are high enough on the inside of the tube then the shear strength of the material about to enter will be overcome, and it will be deflected completely by the pressure wave that will now act as a solid surface with respect to the sediment it encounters. In the majority of cases where short cores in soft sediment are concerned, the plasticity of the material results in partial displacement of the sediment. Under these conditions, material passing into the
80
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
core tube is deformed (thinned) conforming to the radius of the pressure wave existing in front of the core tube, thus resulting in the situation illustrated in Figure 3. In this way the overall shortening of the core is accomplished by plastic deformation of the sediment before it enters the tube (Hongve & Erlandsen, 1979; Evans et al. 1986; Blomqvist, 1985, 1991). In reality, sedimentary deposits that consist of layered material may exhibit differing shear strengths at microscopic scales and express directional variability (anisotropy) in the way they deform. The presence of overlying lake water penetrating with the core tube into sediments that have less water content introduces further dynamic changes (Pratje, 1935; Piggot, 1941; Emory & Dietz, 1941; Hvorslev, 1949). Dynamic measurements carried out on sediment behaviour as the core tube is being driven indicate that, even under constant drive rates, the entry of material into the tube is not smooth but follows a stick-slip (i.e., intermittent) motion. This is likely the result of the small-scale variability in shear strength of the layered material being pressurized below the core tube. Although a detailed analysis of these forces is beyond the scope of this chapter, their effects should be considered when one examines the operating features of the coring devices covered in the next section. Major types of sampling equipment The equipment described in this chapter is arranged in general order of complexity, with the simplest types first and noting the key features of each. Although some categories overlap, the equipment is classified in the following order: (1) Open-barrel and gravity corers (2) Box cores and dredges (3) Piston corers driven by rods (4) Cable-operated piston corers (5) Chamber-type samplers (6) Freeze samplers (7) Vibracorers (vibra-drilling) (8) Percussion or hammer corers (9) Modified gravity corers
(10) Pneumatic corers (11) Core catching devices (12) Extruding equipment
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
81
Open-barrel and gravity corers Some examples of open-barrel and gravity corers are the Kajak-Brinkhurst (K.B.) types (Kajak et al., 1965; Brinkhurst et al., 1969), HON-Kajak type (Renberg, 1991), Glew (1989, 1991), Axelsson-Håkanson (1978), Hongve (Wright, 1990), Limnos (Kansanen et al., 1991), and many others. Theory of operation Open-barrel corers, sometimes referred to as open-drive samplers, are the simplest type of coring devices and under many conditions the easiest to use. In its simplest form of operation, a tube (open at both top and bottom) is driven vertically into the sediment. At the end of the drive, the top of the tube is closed and the tube recovered. Sediment is retained in the tube by the sealing of the top before withdrawal (thereby sealing the hydrostatic head), by the cohesion of the sediment in the core tube, or by closing the bottom of the core tube. Driving the tube into the sediment may be accomplished in a variety of ways. If the sediment is relatively soft, the tube can be pushed in and withdrawn by hand using drive rods connected to the top of the core tube. More compact sediment may require that the tube be mechanically driven in (and out) with either a hammer or a weight or advanced by hydraulic pressure (Acker, 1974; Brink et al., 1982; Barendregt & Vreeken, 1983; Missen, 1986). Percussion or hammer corers are described more fully in a subsequent section. In most sediments, the mass of the device itself can be used to drive the core tube into the sediment (e.g., gravity corer). Other than directly driven corers, which are operated from the surface by connecting rods and therefore limited to relatively shallow water conditions (e.g., <40–50m), most open-drive samplers are gravity corers. Of these, there are two basic types of devices: closeon-contact types and messenger-operated types. As their name implies, close-on-contact types close automatically once the core is driven into the sediment. An automatic device of this type may seem to be the most efficient, particularly when samples are required to be taken from deep water; however, the close-on-contact types have some deficiencies as outlined below. The seal at the top of the tube must remain open while the tube descends into the sediment. Once the sample has been taken, the sediment must provide an efficient barrier to any flow of water into the top of the tube. The action of the seal is usually flow- or loadactuated. In the case of the flow-actuated seal, the sealing mechanism operates essentially as a one-way valve, which senses the flow direction of water through the core tube. In this case, two major problems affect sediment recovery. First, the flow-through mechanism operates to some degree as a proportional flow device (i.e., low flow will only open the seal a small amount and greater flow volume will be required to open it fully). At some low velocity (threshold velocity) the seal will close completely, restricting further entry of material into the core tube. Furthermore, the energy required to keep the seal open will produce a pressure differential and create a pressure wave below the lower end of the core tube as it descends. This pressure wave, often referred to as a bow wave, may be large enough to deflect low-density sediment radially away from the core axis, and potentially lose (“blow away”) the surface sediments (Crusius & Anderson, 1991; Cumming et al., 1993; Stephenson et al., 1996) or mix the sample material (Fig. 5). This leads to difficult
82
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
design requirements of the seal, which must minimize flow restriction within the core tube at very low flow-through rates, but must seal completely when flow stops. Load-actuated closing mechanisms are ones that hold the seal open on the device as the corer is lowered. Once the device begins to enter the sediment, the relaxation of the line tension causes the mechanism to close. Problems associated with this type of mechanism relate to its sensitivity and the tendency of such an arrangement to close prematurely. This results from the fact that tension on the recovery line can be zero when the core tube is still penetrating the sediment. In some designs, the seal can be allowed to float (not seal tightly) during the penetration, and will only be secure once the tension is reapplied during recovery, as in the original Kajak design (Fig. 6), or with a Hongve (Wright, 1990) or Boyle (1995) sampler. However, such an arrangement still reintroduces the problems encountered in flow-through devices, as noted above (Fig. 5). Messenger-operated gravity corers The most common solution to the problems described above regarding close-on-contact and flow-through-type devices is to hold the core tube open until it is closed by the operator from the surface by means of a messenger. In its simplest form, the messenger is a weight
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
83
captive on the recovery line that is released at the surface and is free to fall down the line and contact the coring device on the lake bottom. Messenger-operated coring equipment incorporates some kind of release that uses the energy of the descending messenger to close the top seal on the core tube. Probably the most significant disadvantage of most messenger-operated devices is that the operator must be able to determine when the corer is on the bottom and ceased penetration in order to close the device. This can be a problem in highly organic and loose sediments, especially in deep waters, although even these types of sediments can often be effectively cored using these devices, with some practice. In addition, the recovery line must be kept under a certain amount of tension to enable the free transit of the messenger. Neither of these conditions is easily maintained as operating depths increase (e.g., greater than about 50m). However, adaptations made to gravity corers can alleviate this problem to some extent. The coring device may be equipped with a support frame or a buoyant upper section to maintain its stability, as well as a mechanism to sense when the core tube has been driven to its limit and to trigger an actuating device to then close the core (Glew, 1995).
84
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
Disadvantages with the messenger-triggered devices relate to the operator’s ability to determine with certainty when the equipment is at the sediment surface. The ability to determine the position of the device, freely suspended in the water column or penetrating the sediment, and whether the device is open or closed, is often referred to as “feel”. In water depths usually between 5 and 50 meters, feel is not usually a problem unless excessive drifting and wave motion are present. To some extent, the line length at these intermediate depths is effective in decoupling such minor motions of waves and drifting. In very deep water, the dynamic aspects of the recovery line in the water tend to mask the motion of the device itself, resulting in the loss of feel. In very shallow water (e.g., <3 m), the moderating effects of the line are insignificant in damping out surface motion such as lateral drift and wave action, often impairing control of the corer. The main advantage of gravity coring is that it is a simple and rapid method of recovering relatively short cores. The core tubes themselves can be easily removed and replaced, and the core sample can be extruded and subsampled in the field. Recovery of relatively small volumes of sample and limited penetration (especially in stiff sediments, such as clays or silts) are likely the most significant shortcomings of the open-barrel gravity corer, as size and weight are compromising factors in the design of any such device. Increasing the core tube diameter and increasing the weight of the corer go some way in overcoming these problems, but some limitations should be considered. Core aspect ratios (i.e., core length to core diameter) become problematic when they are about 6:1 or less. This is because the typical shear strength of lacustrine sediment will allow it to flow out of the core tube during lifting if the column of sediment approaches such low aspect ratios. For this reason, smaller diameter core tubes retain sediment more securely than larger diameter tubes. On the other hand, if the tube is too narrow, its recovery of sediment may be incomplete because of excessive internal friction, as previously described. For larger diameter cores, greater penetrating depths require greater weight. One solution to the sample volume, weight, and core length problem is to use corers that carry multiple core tubes or barrels (Brinkhurst et al., 1969; Tratt & Burne, 1980). The main disadvantage of this approach is that the penetrating resistance is significantly higher for multiple tubes than for single tubes, and that multiple-tube corers are mechanically more complex. Typically gravity corers with weights between five and ten kilograms and core tube diameters of between 40 and 100 mm can efficiently recover cores in the order of 30 to 70 cm long, and sometimes up to 1 m. If the corer is designed with alow centre of mass and is symmetrical about the vertical axis, these devices probably represent the most efficient and reliable type of sampling equipment under a variety of conditions. Increasing the weight and core size can extend the penetration range of gravity corers, but their mechanical operation and ease of handling is compromised. Box corers and dredges Box corers operate on the same principle as gravity corers in that they can be driven into the sediment by means of extension rods or by gravity. Some of the earliest types of quantitative sediment samples were of this type (such as the Ekman or Birge-Ekman grab sampler, Murdoch & Azcue, 1995; box corers, Bouma, 1969; etc.). The main differences among these types of corers and those described in the previous section are in their size range; box dimensions for samplers used in lakes are often in the size range of 15 cm x 15 cm and 20 cm
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
85
deep or larger (for example, limnologists sometimes use samplers primarily developed for marine systems, with dimensions in the range of of sediment surface), and the sample retention is accomplished by bottom closure of the box rather than sealing of the top of the chamber. In order to do this, sliding or rotating jaws close off the bottom of the box after it enters the sediment (Jenkin & Mortimer, 1938; Jenkin et al. 1941). The hinged or sliding mechanism associated with the jaws and the physical size of the box in most types of box corers limit the depth of penetration of such devices (10–20cm being typical, although deeper penetration is possible with some types of heavy equipment). In addition, the force required to close the jaws once the device is embedded in the sediment is considerable, and the reactionary force generated on closing can seriously disturb the surficial sediments inside the box (Blomqvist & Boström, 1987). In spite of such disadvantages, these devices can potentially recover large volumes of surface and shallow subsurface sediment with little disturbance under favorable conditions (Flower et al., 1995). In recent decades, some of the most successful marine samplers have been large-scale box corers, such as the USNEL (United States Naval Electronics Laboratory) box corer (Hessler & Jumars, 1974). Piston coring devices driven by rods Piston corers were initially developed in the 1920s and were used to sample unconsolidated sediment ahead of drilled holes (Olsson, 1925). In this type, the piston corer was attached to and operated by the same drill rods assembled for advancing the drill. Piston corers developed specifically for limnological work were introduced in the 1950s (Livingstone, 1955; Vallentyne, 1955; Brown, 1956). These devices operated in a similar way to the original Olsson (1925) corer, except that this corer was designed to obtain only short sections of sediment (<1 m). They were of lighter and simpler construction, utilizing a cable to control the piston instead of rods and core casing. Such an arrangement saves considerable weight and therefore enables the equipment to be used from small boats or improvised platforms. Because a stable platform is required for piston coring, an icecovered lake surface, when available, is often the preferred method. Wright (1991) offers many suggestions to help paleolimnologists obtain good piston cores. Theory of operation The typical piston corer consists of three major components: the piston and cable assembly, the core tube, and the drive head and drive rods (Fig. 7). Core tubes contain a close-fitting adjustable sliding plug or piston. In the driving or closed position (Fig. 7A), the piston is secured at the lower end of the tube by the rods used to drive the device to the sample depth. In this position, the piston keeps the core tube closed and deflects material as it penetrates the sediment. At the selected sampling depth, the drive rods are retracted through the core tube and are locked in the drive head (Fig. 7B), leaving the piston at the bottom of the core tube. A number of mechanisms have been devised to do this, such as the cone clamp (described in Hvorslev, 1949), a latch (Vallentyne, 1955) and a square rod with pegs (Wright, 1967). The piston is independently restrained by a cable passing through the core tube and the drive head to the surface, and secured at its upper end by a winch, clamp, or other means. With the rod string locked to the drive head, the rods and the core tube are driven down past
86
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
the piston that is prevented from descending by its restraining cable (Fig. 7B). With the drive completed, the piston is at the top of the core tube against the drive head (Fig. 7C), and the tube is filled. The cable is then locked to the drive rods to prevent any downward motion of the piston and contained sample when the device is lifted to the surface. The original Livingstone (1955) corer, inspired by Kullenberg (1947), had no internal rod to hold the piston in place; rather the piston was retained by its tight fit and was released by a sharp push. Vallentyne (1955) introduced an internal rod with a latch to lock it after retraction, but the latch sometimes failed. Wright (1967) replaced the round rod with a square rod, with pegs and slots in the head to permit a firmer lock. Advantages of rod-driven piston corers The chief advantage of the device is related to the operation of the piston and the seal it maintains between the internal surface of the core tube. As the core tube is advanced into the sediment, the frictional forces that, in an open-barrel-type configuration would cause the core to be drawn down with the tube, are countered by the seal of that stationary piston. In
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
87
this type of arrangement, soft sediment cores can be recovered with no displacement in the core tube. The only disadvantage is the increased mechanical complexity of maintaining an efficient seal between the piston and the core tube wall, and providing the precise control required when driving and recovering the device. Most piston coring devices have simple piston and drive-head mechanisms that permit small core tube diameters (30–50 mm), enabling them to penetrate compact sediment with relatively small applied driving forces. Smaller tubes, although easier to push, encounter excessive internal frictions in the core, and recovery may be incomplete. As much as 40 m of sediment have been recovered with a piston corer of 5-cm diameter, in 1 m sections, in the same cased hole (H.E. Wright, Jr., personal communication). Disadvantages of rod-driven piston corers Like all rod-operated sampling devices, the practical limitations imposed by the length of the connecting rods make these types of “Livingstone” piston corers applicable mainly in relatively shallow water conditions. The mechanical limitations of the strength and stiffness of the material from which the rods are made and the type of couplings used to assemble them determine the ultimate operating depth. Although the use of rigid support casing can partially alleviate these operational limitations, the application of these devices becomes increasingly more difficult in water depths greater than about 30 m, but coring with appropriate lifting equipment and rigid casing is possible in water depths of ~50 m. Probably more than any other rod-operated sampling device, the Livingstone-style piston corer is susceptible to shortcomings associated with the rod-string and the piston cable. This is because close mechanical coordination must be maintained between the rodstring and the piston control cable, and any misalignment of these two components can result in mechanical failure. The cable can be damaged or broken and the piston lost or misaligned when the compressional forces on the rod string are excessive and the position of the piston with respect to rods is not accurately determined. Problems associated with the drive head, and the method used to transfer the driving force through it, are also common and not easy to solve. In some mechanisms (Vallentyne, 1955) a latching arrangement requires the rod string to be retracted past a spring-loaded element that locks the rod string to the drive head. In other arrangements, such as the square rod type piston corer (Wright et al., 1965), the rod string is retracted and then rotated into a locked position. In both cases, the precise depth (determined by the length of the rod string) must be known and the subsequent manipulation of the rod string is made based on it. Such operations, when carried out under less than ideal field conditions, are difficult. Cable-operated piston corers Some of the problems encountered with deep-water piston coring operations can be overcome by use of a Kullenberg-type corer. Originally designed for marine work, where the operational water depths preclude any remote manipulation or direct control from the surface, the Kullenberg (1947) corer represents a type of device that relies on a driving weight that is allowed to free-fall through a fixed distance to drive the core tube into the sediment in a single stroke. The core tube is equipped with a piston that is restrained by
88
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
a cable fixed to the core head. The driving weight that is initially restrained by a latch mechanism on the head is held in position by an outrigger cable and weight assembly that is freely suspended alongside the core tube. On reaching the sediment surface, the tension on the outrigger line is removed and the latch opened, allowing the weight to fall and drive the core tube past the restrained piston into the sediment. Kelts et al. (1986) describe a modified Kullenberg-type corer which is more appropriate for lake work. One of the disadvantages of Kullenberg-type corers is that the uppermost sediments are typically lost. Moreover, the corer is heavy and often requires significant infrastructure for its operation. Chamber-type samplers Chamber-type samplers (e.g., Hiller corers, Russian peat corers) were developed as an alternative to vertically driven core samplers. They are often used to recover undisturbed subsurface material, such as peat and similar fibrous sediments. In these devices, the sample is cut and enclosed in a rotating chamber of half-cylindrical form. This chamber takes material adjacent to the drive axis in a rotational motion against the fixed plate. The operation of the chamber sampler avoids some of the systemic problems associated with other subsurface samplers, most notably those employing vertically driven core tubes and their potential for incomplete recovery. Theory of operation The chamber corer (Fig. 8) is driven vertically into the sediment in the closed position with drive rods. In the closed position, the half-cylinder that comprises the rotating member is locked against a faceplate that forms one side of the chamber. To take the core sample, the half-cylinder is rotated in a direction away from the plate by applying torque to the drive rods; the asymmetric projection of the faceplate providing the reactionary element against which the cylinder can be rotated. After the half-cylinder has pivoted approximately 180°, it is locked with the sample now enclosed in the chamber. Once locked in this position, the device is then withdrawn to the surface. At the surface, the chamber can be rotated backwards to expose the half-cylinder of sediment supported by the faceplate (Fig. 8). Advantages of chamber corers An advantage of this type of sampler is that it can recover discrete subsurface samples from selected depths, bypassing the overlaying material in the same way as the piston corer described earlier. Unlike the vertically driven core samplers, however, the action of the chamber is essentially that of a sidewall sampler acting horizontally against the sediment, thus eliminating any distortions to the sample associated with vertically driven coring devices. An additional advantage is that the recovered sample is easily removed from the chamber (it is not extruded) as the chamber is opened by rotating the half-cylinder in the reverse direction. This allows researchers to inspect the sediment material directly on site.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
89
Disadvantages of chamber corers Disadvantages of the chamber sampler lie chiefly with its large cross-sectional area, both in the driving and recovery configuration, and in the large torque forces transmitted by the rods when taking a sample. This becomes particularly significant as the length of the rod-string is increased and the degree of rotational control is reduced due to wind-up induced torsion of the rods. In addition, the asymmetric design of the chamber sampler tends to promote uneven forces on the stationary components, particularly the chamber pivots. Nonetheless, many researchers report good success with this type of sampler, even when working with long rod-strings. The inability to efficiently seal the sample chamber tightly due to its longitudinal closure against the plate and the necessity of opening the device in a horizontal position generally makes it unsuitable for the sampling of the uppermost portions of the sediment profile or in soft sediments with high water contents. Freeze samplers Theory of operation In sampling materials that are very susceptible to disturbance and mixing, such as those that exist at or close to the sediment-water interface, or that contain gases that might disrupt the core profile during the coring process, in situ freezing of the sediment profile has proven to be a successful sampling method. The technique of solidification by freezing was first used to recover cohesionless sands and gravels with high and irregular void ratios (Hvorslev, 1949). In this type of sampling, the material was frozen in place, and then subsequently
90
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
cored and recovered in the frozen state. For subaqueous sampling of soft sediment with high-water content, a different technique is used. Limnological freeze coring utilizes a low-temperature metallic surface that is lowered into the sediment and held in position long enough to freeze the surrounding sediment on to it (e.g., Shapiro, 1958; Huttunen & Meriläinen, 1978; Renberg, 1981). The device is then recovered, and the frozen sample is removed. The equipment used for freeze-coring consists of a weighted chamber with an outer freezing surface that may be cylindrical or flat (Fig. 9). A wedge-shaped design is often desirable, as it tends to produce the least amount of disturbance to the sediment profile (Renberg, 1981). The chamber is filled with a freezing medium that reduces the outer surface temperature well below that of the freezing point of water. The medium most commonly used is dry ice (solid carbon dioxide) mixed with an accelerating liquid (alcohol). Other cryogenic liquids have been used, such as liquid nitrogen, but these must be used cautiously. The reaction pressurizes the chamber that is vented to the atmosphere or into the water. After being lowered through the water column and into the sediment, it is held in position long enough to allow sediment to freeze to it (typically about 10 minutes, but this depends on the physical size of the device). The chamber is then recovered with the frozen sample (commonly 5 to 10cm thick) adhering to the outside surface. Advantages of freeze corers The main advantage of the freeze sampler is its ability to spatially preserve material that is suspended in the water column at or close to the sediment-water interface, providing the chamber is fixed in a stationary position. It is a simple device that under certain conditions is easy to use, especially where the sampler can be held in a stationary position (for
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
91
example, when operating from winter ice cover). Provided the adjacent sediment is not disturbed as the device is lowered, sediment can be recovered easily. If the sampler is designed to expose a large freezing surface, an additional advantage of this method is that a potentially large volume of sediment can be collected. Several high-resolution studies have been accomplished using this technique. Disadvantages of freeze corers The problems associated with freeze coring are primarily those associated with the conditions required to hold the device in a fixed position in the sediment for the required period of time (e.g., 10 minutes), and the logistics of transporting the quantities of dry ice and alcohol to the sampling site and transporting the frozen sample from the field site. Adaptations have been developed that address some of these problems. For example, Renberg & Hansson (1993) developed a freeze corer that separated the dry ice/alcohol container from the freezing wedge. Once the corer penetrates the sediment, an electric pump circulates alcohol through the chamber. This device overcomes the problem of icecrust formation (water freezing to the corer during lowering through the water column) and allows for the collection of a thin freeze wedge. Lotter et al. (1997) further modified this design by including a tripod to stabilize the device at the sediment surface, and a hydraulic system for controlled lowering of the corer into the sediment. Verschuren (2000) developed a freeze corer especially designed for warm-water systems (e.g., tropics) by dropping dry ice pellets steadily into the corer to replace those that have sublimated. Freeze cores may not be totally suitable when paleolimnological analyses require precise estimates of water content. Stephenson et al. (1996) identified this potential problem when they compared contaminant inventories using different types of sediment samplers. Freezecored sediments had higher water contents than tube-cored sediments, possibly due to ice crystal formation, and thus resulting in lower contaminant inventories. Subsampling the frozen prism of sediment may also present some problems in the field, as a uniform detachment from the device can be difficult due to the uneven melting or mechanical force required to remove it from the freezing face. Transportation of frozen sample material from the field to the laboratory may also present logistical problems. Vibracorers Theory of operation Vibracoring, a technique originally developed in the 1960s for use in marine coastal and shelf oceanographic investigations (Bouma, 1969; Sanders & Imbrie, 1963), has enjoyed considerable popularity as a paleolimnological tool during the past several decades. The ease of operation and portability have made it the equipment of choice for many paleolimnologists (e.g., Smith, 1998; 1992; Thompson et al., 1991) who are attempting to collect moderate length (1 to ~15m), undisturbed cores of unconsolidated sediments in material that may be difficult to sample (e.g., profiles containing sand lenses). The basic principle of operation of today’s modern vibracorer, first described by Lanesky et al. (1979), is straightforward. As the name implies, a vibrating device (most commonly a
92
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
concrete vibrator powered by a small gasoline engine, but earlier versions of the technique used a variety of other devices; Dokken et al., 1979) is mounted on a core tube (usually aluminum irrigation pipe) which imparts high-frequency, low amplitude standing waves along the length of the tube. This vibration liquefies a thin (1–2 mm) layer of water-saturated sediment at the base of the core tube. The liquefaction and resulting loss of strength allows the core tube to penetrate downward through the sediment column with little or no vertical application of force. Various modifications of the basic design of Lanesky et al. (1979) have been suggested to allow sampling of moderately deep lakes (40–50 m; Smith, 1998; 1984, and recently even deeper (B. Beierle, pers. comm.), and to provide better portability (Smith, 1987), penetration ability (Thompson et al., 1991), and sediment recovery (Reddering & Pinter, 1985). Advantages of vibracorers Vibracoring technology has solved many of the problems inherent in attempting to acquire moderate length (>1 m) cores of unconsolidated sediment that is difficult to core using piston or other corers (e.g., due to difficulties in penetrating material, such as sand) within the confines of a limited budget. The system is relatively inexpensive to construct and employs components that are readily available in most urban centers (e.g., cement vibrator and cable, gasoline engine, cable winches, tripod, ladder, etc.) or fabricated in a machine shop. Likewise, the core barrels are inexpensive, commonly available (5cm or 7.5cm diameter aluminum irrigation pipe), and can be cut in whatever predetermined length is required for ease of transport. The technique can be used in a wide variety of environments (e.g., on land, on a raft, on an ice cover; through shallow water or through relatively deep water), and the equipment is light enough to be relatively mobile and easily handled by two persons. Because vibracoring works on the basis of inducing fluidization in the material, it can be used to sample a wide variety of sediment types, including sands, silts, diamicts, and clays, provided they are water saturated. We have even had success acquiring cores of greater than 3 m from partly consolidated, coarsely crystalline salt. Fluidization of the sediment and loss of shear strength means that the corer usually advances under its own weight without the necessity of applying significant downward force. Under optimum conditions, sediment penetration and core acquisition can be quite rapid; Smith (1987,1984) reports penetration rates of up to 4 m per minute. Similarly, because little or no vertical force is required, the diameter of the core barrel need not be small. In fact, better penetration rates and better recovery ratios are reported with wider core tubes (i.e., 7.5 cm versus 5 cm; Thompson et al., 1991; Smith, 1987). Finally, the sample is retrieved as a continuous sediment sequence, uninterrupted by overlapping or missing sections at core tube breaks. Disadvantages of vibracorers The most commonly reported limitations of the vibracorer technique are poor penetration and recovery in some types of sediment and compaction. Vibracoring depends on the core barrel oscillation briefly causing a loss of sediment bearing strength due to temporary fluidization at the base of the tube becoming thixotrophic. This liquefaction requires that the sediment be water saturated. Although coring of non-saturated but moist sediment is
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
93
possible (Smith, 1984), it is slow and difficult, with poor recovery ratios. Likewise, some types of sediment, even if they are water saturated, do not exhibit thixotropy. The optimum sediment type for vibracoring is sandy silt and muddy sand (Burge & Smith, 1999; Esker et al., 1996; Imperato, 1987; Sly, 1981; Wright et al., 1965). Both coarser and finer grained sediment types are more difficult to core. Gravelly sediment, poorly sorted clayey diamict, and compact clay are extremely difficult to core with this technique (Thompson et al., 1991; Smith, 1984), as they are with other corers. Interbeds of organic litter (peat, twigs, needles, logs) dampen the core tube vibration and make penetration difficult. Desiccation horizons, such as are commonly found in the stratigraphic sequences of playas and lake basins that have periodically dried, can also interrupt coring. Alternatively, in cases where the nonthixotropic and/or organic debris layers are thin enough to allow the vibracorer to be pushed or pounded through, the “difficult” sediment can form a plug in the nose of the tube which prevents further sediment from entering the barrel even though the stratigraphic section is being penetrated by the device. Lanesky et al. (1979) suggested the use of a piston within the core tube to help alleviate this problem and improve recovery, however this requires an additional connecting rod or wire which must be fixed at the surface. Imperato (1987) outlines a method of applying a high-pressure water jet in advance of the core barrel to improve core penetration in these difficult sediments. As pointed out above, core shortening and compaction of the recovered core relative to the thickness of the stratigraphic interval are problems common to many sampling devices. However, compaction rates with vibracoring can be severe. For example, Thompson et al. (1991) report compaction of nearly 60% (Fig. 10). Molnar & Smith (1993) maintain that compaction values are normally about 10 to 40%. Dott & Mickelson (1995) identify compaction of up to 50%. The average core compaction reported by Smith (1987) using 5 cm diameter core tubes is over 40%. Other corers and modifications In the previous sections of this chapter, the coring devices have been grouped by mode of operation. Many of these basic types, however, have been modified and a comprehensive classification of these would be too large to include here. Some basic adaptations are included in this section that are in common use. Most adaptations are designed to increase the operating range or capacity of the device. For example, equipment originally designed for shallow water sampling may be modified to operate in unrestricted depths by use of automated closing mechanisms, or small-capacity samplers may be combined to increase the volume of recovered material. The coring devices discussed below represent some examples of such modifications. Percussion or hammer corers One of the most common modifications to open barrel gravity and some piston corers is the addition of some form of driving weight on top of the device to increase penetration of the core tube (e.g., Gilbert & Glew, 1985; Reasoner, 1986, 1993; Nesje, 1992). In this mode of operation, the corer is lowered into the sediment where it penetrates initially
94
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
by its own weight. At this point the driving weight (sometimes referred to as a “hammer”) can be lifted from the top of the corer and then released to drive the core tube into the sediment. In some arrangements, the recovery line is used as a guide, passing through the weight, and a second line is attached to the driving weight. To operate this efficiently, tension must be maintained on the recovery line and precise control of the weight lifting line must be exercised in order not to interfere with it. In deep water, the operation of two closely parallel lines in such an arrangement is not practical due to their tendency to twist together. An alternative arrangement utilizing a single line requires that the driving weight be mounted on a rigid guide (or jar staff) or similar mechanical support. In order that the force of the weight be controlled effectively, the recovery line itself is operated to lift and release the weight. A number of factors serve to distinguish the percussion (hammer) driven cores from a single drive-type-gravity corer, particularly when considering the potential for disturbance of soft sediments (see Chapter 4 in Hvorslev, 1949, for a detailed examination). The mechanical arrangements of percussion corers are such that they usually preclude the use of messenger closing, so a one-way flow through valve is usually fitted at the top of the core tube. These may perform poorly where large instantaneous pressure changes occur, typical when driving or recovering a core using these techniques. In addition to the open-barrel percussion types, some piston corers have been modified to extend the penetration depth of the core tube. An additional complication in this type of adaptation is in maintaining the fixed position of the piston during the drive. If a solid ice cover is available, anchoring to the ice is an option.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
95
Modifications to gravity coring equipment Parachute-controlled devices In deep water and in situations where control of the coring device may be difficult, one method of providing the device with artificial stabilization is to use a parachute or drogue at the lower end of the recovery line (Cushing et al., 1997). This provides the descending sampling device with a controlled rate of fall through the water column and a degree of vertical stability as it enters the sediment, conditions that would be provided for by the operator in shallow water. The advantage with this type of modification is that it can be added to existing equipment with little or no change in the basic operating mode. However, some provision must be made to keep the stabilizing parachute canopy away from the operating device once on the sediment to prevent it from interfering with the subsequent recovery. This can de done by the inclusion of a float to keep the parachute above the corer when stationary, or a rigid frame that folds to provide minimum resistance when the device is lifted to the surface. Deep-water automatic gravity corers A similar modification for operating shallow-water messenger-equipped samplers in deep water is an arrangement that employs a float to stabilize the lower end of the recovery line (in the same way as the parachute attachment noted above) and a messenger release mechanism that senses the tensional force on the line (Glew, 1995). In this way the float assembly acts like an operator on the surface of a shallow lake; once the line tension is reduced, the messenger is released to close the corer. Small devices designed to be operated in shallow water can be effectively deployed in water depths of hundreds of meters. Pneumatic corers One of the limiting factors of the piston corers described in the previous section is the use of extension rods. A number of piston-type corers have been devised that do not require rods, the driving force being supplied by inertial weight in the case of the Kullenberg (1947) corer or pneumatic cylinders in the case of the Mackereth-type sampler (Mackereth, 1958, 1969). The Mackereth sampler The Mackereth (1958,1969) corer is a pneumatically driven piston corer designed to recover long cores (e.g., 6m) in an uninterrupted manner. Because of the large forces required to drive the core tube in this way, the sampler is anchored to the sediment surface by a bell chamber that forms the base of the device. Operation of the corer takes place in two stages. First, the corer is lowered to the sediment surface and water is pumped out of the bell chamber. This action allows the overlaying water pressure (hydrostatic pressure) to force the chamber into the sediment ensuring a rigid platform from which the core can be driven. Second, compressed air is injected from the surface by a compressor into the driving
96
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
cylinder forcing the core tube past the piston into the sediment in a way similar to that of the rod-operated piston corer (Fig. 11). Air is injected until the core tube is fully driven, at which point the air is automatically bled into the bell chamber. As the bell chamber is pressurized, its buoyancy retracts it and lifts the core tube from the sediment. This is accomplished because the volume of the chamber is of sufficient capacity that when it is air-filled it makes the entire device buoyant and therefore self-recovering (Fig. 11). The main disadvantages of the Mackereth corer is that it requires an air compressor and other infrastructure, and so is not very portable. Corers have also been known to become trapped in lake bottoms due to high frictional forces from the sediments. Care must also be taken with this sampler, as when it is released from the sediment, it can reach the water surface at high velocity, break the water surface, and potentially cause injury.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
97
Core catching devices Core catchers or core retainers are devices that mechanically prevent loss of sediment sample during core retrieval. These are often seen as optional additions to the various corers described in this chapter. The simplest type of core retainers used for general work are the spring-type devices that consist of a plastic or metal insert that is mounted inside the lower end of the core tube. A variety of shapes exist that have been named after their designers, such as Denison, Emery-Dietz, and Joukowsky (see Hvorslev, 1949). All operate in generally the same way, as they are shaped to conform to the inside diameter of the tube as the core is being driven, but fold or collapse to block sample material from sliding back out of the tube when it is withdrawn. For sampling soft sediment, the mounting of this type of core retainer is problematic; first, because it increases the cross-sectional area of the tube and results in greater driving resistance, and second, because the potential for the retainer to disturb the sediment as it enters the tube is significant due to the pressure required to keep the spring retainer open. A number of designs incorporate mechanical arrangements that can seal the retainer and actuate it only when the core is pulled back on recovery. Such mechanisms greatly increase the cross-sectional area of the core barrel as they require an external shoe and core liner. For the above reasons, core retainers are rarely used for short core sampling of soft sediment, although sampling of such material would benefit from equipment that could close the end of the core tube (e.g., the Limnos corer; Kansanen et al., 1991). A number of such core-retaining devices have been developed. These serve to close the core tube and support the core sample as it is lifted though the water column. They operate by sliding down the outside of the core tube as it is pulled from the sediment, and close the lower end as it clears the sediment surface. Such devices do not interfere with the inside diameter of the core tube and allow free entry of the tube into the sediment. They do, however, require careful adjustment with respect to tube length, as effective closing is dependent on the final position of the retainer at the end of the tube. Extruding and subsampling equipment Extruding equipment We have thus far emphasized the recovery of relatively undisturbed cores. In many respects, core extruding and subsampling equipment is as important as the coring devices themselves in as much as this equipment must be capable of taking full advantage of the intact nature of the cored material. Once the core is brought to the surface, some reliable method must be available to either preserve it and transport it back to the laboratory for analysis, or subsampling the core on site. For most work involving high-water-content surface cores that are recovered with a portion of the overlaying water column, there is little chance of transporting the core to the laboratory without some significant disturbance. For this reason, these cores are routinely subsampled on site. Even for long cores that are destined to be subsampled in the laboratory and core samples that are robust enough to be transported intact, the extrusion process on site is considered important, as it provides an important
98
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
check on the performance of the corer and an opportunity for a “first-look” at the core and for some preliminary logging. Cores of the highly fluid near-surface sediments provide the greatest challenges to the design of extruding and subsampling equipment because of the low strength of the material. Any stratification of the deposit can easily be destroyed by mixing of the sediment during post-collection handling. One method of subsampling short sediment cores is to equip the corer with a segmented tube, such as the one on the Limnos corer (Kansanen et al., 1991). In this arrangement, the segments can be rotated horizontally to subsample the core. Vertical extrusion of the sediment using equipment such as the Glew (1988) extruder (see below) is also a very effective way of sampling even the most watery surface sediments. Another promising technique is to use a gel-forming compound, such as Zorbitrol Plus TM (a polyamide commonly used in clean up of biohazardous laboratory spills; available from Ulster Scientific Inc, New Paltz, NY), to stabilize the water in the core barrel immediately above the sediment-water interface, thereby facilitating transport of the undisturbed sample from the field to the laboratory (D. Livingstone, pers. commun.). For most other types of equipment, the sample is extruded in a vertical position. The main requirement for an extruder for short near-surface cores is that it can: (1) provide support and containment for the sediment being sampled; (2) repetitively and efficiently subsample accurate volumes of material; and (3) be set-up and operated easily in field situations.
Types of extrusion mechanisms used for core subsampling Two types of extruders are described here: a common vertical-type extruder used primarily for high-water content sediments (e.g., Glew, 1988), and horizontal-type extruders used for the extrusion of long cores.
Vertical-type extruders Vertical-type extruders have three key components: 1) a mechanism for securely holding the core tube in a vertical position; 2) a ram or mandrel that is used to push through the core tube to expel the core (in some arrangements the ram is fixed and the core tube is drawn down over it); and 3) a plate or tray onto which the extruded sample can be drawn off, separated, and placed in bags or other containers. Of these three components, the ram poses the greatest design problems as, in most applications, it must be adjusted to the core length (which cannot be predicted a priori) and subsequently incremented accurately. In addition, it must function well in field environments in the presence of water, mud, and sometimes ice that can compromise the mechanical action. One of the simplest types of vertical extruders is illustrated in Figure 12. Incremental extrusion (Fig. 12) is accomplished by pushing the core tube assembly over the ram. With element A locked to the ram and B unlocked, downward motion of the core tube assembly is limited to distance X (set by set-screw C). Locking of B and resetting A against set-screw C repeats the extruding setting X. Locking A and releasing B allows the following increment to be extruded (Fig. 12).
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
99
Long core (horizontal) type extruders This type of extruder differs from the vertical device used with short cores of highly fluid near-surface sediments in as much as it is not required to incrementally move the core sample for subsampling, because longer and deeper subsurface cores tend to be more compact. Instead, the devices are typically designed to extrude the entire core in a single motion, transferring it from the core tube to a split core tube used as a tray or transporting box for inspection and shipment from the field (Fig. 13). The actuating mechanisms for long-core extruders range from straight mechanical jacking to pneumatic pumps and hydraulic devices, some generating large forces and high pressures within the core tube. Only two types of basic motion exist however: those operating to draw the tube over the ram and those employing a traveling ram (Fig. 13). Of these types, the fixed ram type presents the least sample disturbance as the emerging core is stationary with respect to its supporting surface. Traveling ram mechanisms can provide the same type of support to the core if the supporting surface is moved with the ram.
100
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
With all types of extrusion, there is the potential for smearing or distortion of the sediment along the core tube wall. This can be minimized by using a close-fitting extruding plug, and is considered to be small when compared to distortion that may occur during the initial drive of the core. Alternatively, the core may be transported from the field in the core tube and split in the laboratory by cutting the tube longitudinally. This can be carried out on all types of core tubes, as well as with frozen sediment. Because this procedure is carried out in the laboratory, it has the disadvantage of not providing a check or “first look” at the sample material while at the sampling site. The advantage of this approach is that the core is being handled under more controlled conditions. Sediment handling Subsequent handling of the core material after acquisition depends upon the nature of the study, type of logging to be done, type and “urgency” of analyses anticipated, distance to the laboratory and/or storage facilities, etc. For large, multiple-investigator, multipleproxy, multiple-core research projects, considerable preliminary planning must be done and a suitable protocol established in order to properly and efficiently preserve and archive the sediment, as outlined, for example, in Todd et al. (2000), Colman (1996), Tiercelin et al. (1987), and Hsu & Kelts (1986). Although post-collection handling schemes are highly individualized, in general, if the core is not extruded in the field, care should be taken to properly label the tubes with respect to site location, top and bottom, and other necessary orientation information, and to plug and seal the ends of the core barrel to prevent physical loss and chemical alteration. Clearly, such factors as maintaining the core material
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
101
at relatively constant and cool (but not freezing) temperatures (e.g., 4°C), avoidance of strong magnetic fields, and minimum agitation must be considered during temporary storage in the field and transport to the laboratory. Once the core is extruded, it is normally split longitudinally and visually logged, photographed, and subsampled immediately. Usually about one half of the core is re-sealed in plastic and/or foil and stored at low temperature for future reference and use, with the other half being used for description and subsampling. Long-term storage schemes must take into account the avoidance of warm temperatures, light, and loss of moisture from the core, factors that significantly alter many of the important paleoenvironmental components of the core. In the case of multiple-proxy and multiple-investigator projects, it is important to have already established a well-devised subsampling strategy before the core material is acquired. In addition to following an appropriate subsampling protocol, it is also desirable to anticipate and undertake as soon as possible any mechanical and other non-visual logging techniques, such as magnetic susceptibility, GRAPE (gamma ray attenuation porosity estimator), sonic velocity logging, resistivity measurements, etc. Colman (1996) and subsequent chapters in this book summarize many of these post-collection logging techniques.
Summary
Collection of lake sediment cores that are of sufficient quality (e.g., length, resolution) to adequately answer research questions may pose some challenges to paleolimnologists. Nonetheless, a wide spectrum of reliable and well-tested sampling and extruding devices have been developed and modified that are applicable to almost all paleolimnological requirements. This chapter focused on collecting relatively short sediment cores. Probably the simplest and least expensive coring device available to the paleolimnologist is the gravity corer, which uses the weight of the corer to enter the sediment. If employed correctly in appropriate settings, such devices can provide excellent profiles of recent lake sediments, even if the water content of the sediment is very high. However, careful attention must be paid to the design of these corers to insure complete recovery and to avoid, for example, turbulence ahead of the core tube creating a bow wave. Box corers and dredges can effectively collect large amounts of surface and shallow subsurface sediments. Freeze coring has been employed in a large number of high-resolution studies of recent lake sediments, as this approach freezes a crust of sediment to the core surface in situ. Rod-operated piston corers are very commonly used devices, and have become standard pieces of equipment for many paleolimnologists wishing to sample several meters of relatively soft sediment. Openchamber corers have the advantage of being relatively easy to use, and allow the investigator to easily inspect the sediment profile at the coring site. Vibracoring is especially effective in sampling sandy and silty sediments, whereas other types (e.g., pneumatic corers, percussion corers) can be employed for specific tasks and other problem sampling jobs. In many cases it is advantageous to extrude the core and subsample at the sampling site; considerable progress has been made in the development of extruding systems that can be used to effectively subsample sediment profiles at a resolution determined by the investigator.
102
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the enormous contribution made to the field of sediment sampling by Juul Hvorslev (1895–1989) who, in cooperation with the Harvard School of Engineering, the American Association of Civil Engineers, and the U.S. Corps of Engineers, produced the seminal work “Subsurface Exploration and Sampling of Soils for Civil Engineering Purposes”, over 50 years ago. While advances in technology have revolutionized much of our science, the body of information incorporated in this work still remains the standard reference. Research in our labs, as well as the development of some of the coring equipment designed at PEARL, was funded by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada. We are very grateful for many helpful comments and discussion from H. Wright, Jr., D. Livingstone, A. Lotter, V.P. Salonen, S. Leroy, P. Teasdale, B. Beierle, S. Lamoureux, T. Karst, B. Cumming, N. Michelutti, S. Dixit, and other members of our labs. Opinions vary widely on some aspects of the pros and cons of various corers, and the opinions expressed in this chapter are our own.
References Aaby, B. & G. Digerfeldt, 1986. Sampling techniques for lakes and bogs. In Berglund, B. (ed.) Handbook of Holocene Palaeoecology and Palaeohydrology. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Chichester: 181–194. Acker, W. L., 1974. Basic Procedures for Soil Sampling and Core Drilling. Acker Drill Co. Inc., Scranton, Pennsylvania, 246 pp. ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials), 1971. Underwater Soil Sampling, Testing, and Construction Control. ASTM Special Technical Publication 501, ASTM, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 241 pp. Axelsson, V. & L. Häkanson, 1978. A gravity corer with a simple valve system. J. Sed. Petrol. 48: 630–633. Barendregt, R. W. & W. J. Vreeken, 1983. A coring device suitable for paleomagnetic sampling of unconsolidated subsurface deposits. Can. Geotech. J. 20: 843–848. Blomqvist, S., 1985. Reliability of core sampling of soft bottom sediment — an in situ study. Sedimentology 32: 605–612. Blomqvist, S., 1991. Quantitative sampling of soft-bottom sediments: problems and solutions. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 72: 295–304. Blomqvist, S. & K. Boström, 1987. Improved sampling of soft bottom sediments by combined box and piston coring. Sedimentology 34: 715–719. Bouma, A. H., 1969. Methods for the Study of Sedimentary Structures. Wiley-Interscience, New York, 458 pp. Boyle, J. F., 1995. A simple closure mechanism for a compact, large-diameter, gravity corer. J. Paleolim. 13: 85–87. Brink, A. B. A., T. C. Partridge & A. A. B. Williams, 1982. Soil Survey for Engineering. Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK., 378 pp. Brinkhurst, R. O., K. E. Chua & E. Batoosingh, 1969. Modifications in sampling procedures as applied to studies on the bacteria and tubificid oligochaetes inhabiting aquatic sediments. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 26: 2581–2593. Brown, S., 1956. A piston sampler for surface sediments of lake deposits. Ecology 37: 611–613.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
103
Burge, L. M. & D. G. Smith, 1999. Confined meandering river eddy accretions: sedimentology, channel geometry and depositional processes. In Smith, N. D. & J. Rogers (eds.) Fluvial Sedimentology VI. International Assoc. Sed. Spec. Pub. 28, Blackwell Science, London: 113–130. Colman, S. M. (ed.), 1996. Continental Drilling for Paleoclimatic Records: Recommendations from an International Workshop. PAGES Workshop Report, Series 96–4, 104 pp. Crusius, J. & R. F. Anderson, 1991. Core compression and surficial sediment loss of lake sediments of high porosity caused by gravity coring. Limnol. Oceanogr. 36: 1021–1031. Cumming, B. F., J. R. Glew, J. P. Smol, R. Davis & S. A. Norton, 1993. Comment on “Core compression and surficial sediment loss of lake sediments of high porosity caused by “gravity coring” (Crusius and Anderson). Limnol. Oceanogr. 38: 695–699. Cushing, E. T. & H. E. Wright, 1965. Hand operated piston corers for lake sediments. Ecology 46: 380–384. Cushing, S. J. Desjardins & J.-M. Fillion, 1997. Parachute-assisted gravity sediment corer (Algonquin Corer). J. Paleolim. 18: 307–311. Dokken, Q. R., R. C. Circé & C. W. Holmes, 1979. A portable, self supporting, hydraulic vibracorer for coring submerged, unconsolidated sediments. J. Sed. Petrol. 49: 658–659. Dott, E. R. & D. Mickelson, 1995. Lake Michigan water levels and the development of Holocene beach-ridge complexes at Two Rivers, Wisconsin: stratigraphic, geomorphic, and radiocarbon evidence. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 107: 286–296. Emery, K. O. & R. S. Dietz, 1941. Gravity coring instrument and mechanics of sediment coring. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am. 52: 1685–1714. Emery, K. O. & J. Hülsemann, 1964. Shortening of sediment cores collected in open barrel gravity corers. Sedimentology 3: 144–154. Esker, D., R. E. Sheridan, G. M. Ashley, J. S. Waldner & D. W. Hall, 1996. Synthetic seismograms from vibracorers: a case study in correlating the late Quaternary seismic stratigraphy of the New Jersey inner continental shelf. J. Sed. Petrol. 66: 1156–1168. Evans, H. E., D. C. Lasenby & P. J. Dillon, 1986. The effect of core compression on the measurement of zinc concentrations and anthropogenic burdens in lake sediments. Hydrobiologia 132: 185–192. Flower, R., D. T. Monteith, A. W. Mackay, J. M. Chambers & P. G. Appleby, 1995. The design and performance of a new box corer for collecting undisturbed sample of soft subaquatic sediments. J. Paleolim. 14: 101–111. Gilbert, R. & J. Glew, 1985. A portable percussion coring device for lacustrine and marine sediments. J. Sed. Petrol. 55: 607–608. Glew, J., 1988. A portable extruding device for close interval sectioning of unconsolidated core samples. J. Paleolim. 1: 235–239. Glew, J., 1989. A new trigger mechanism for sediment samplers. J. Paleolim. 2: 241–243. Glew, J., 1991. Miniature gravity corer for recovering short sediment cores. J. Paleolim. 5: 285–287. Glew, J., 1995. Conversion of shallow water gravity coring equipment for deep water operation. J. Paleolim. 14: 83–88. Håkanson, L. & M. Jansson, 1983. Principles of Lake Sedimentology. Springer-Verlag, New York, 316 pp. Hessler, R. R. & P. Jumars, 1974. Abyssal community analysis from replicate box cores in the central North Pacific. Deep Sea Res. 21: 185–209. Hongve, D. & A. H. Erlandsen, 1979. Shortening of surface sediment cores during sampling. Hydrobiologia 653: 283–287. Hsü, K. J. & K. R. Kelts (eds.), 1984. Quaternary Geology of Lake Zurich: An Interdisciplinary Investigation by Deep-Lake Drilling. E. Schweizerbart’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Contributions to Sedimentology 13, 210 pp. Huttunen, P. & J. Meriläinen, 1978. New freezing device providing large unmixed sediment samples from lakes. Ann. Bot. Fennici 15: 128–130.
104
GLEW, SMOL & LAST
Hvorslev, M. J., 1949. Subsurface Exploration and Sampling of Soils for Civil Engineering Purposes. American Society of Civil Engineers, Waterways Experiment Station, Corps of Engineers, U.S. Army, Vicksburg, Mississippi, 521 pp. Imperato, D. P., 1987. A modification of the vibracoring technique for sandy sediment. J. Sed. Petrol. 57: 788–789. Jenkin, B. M. & C. H. Mortimer, 1938. Sampling lake deposits. Nature 142: 834–835. Jenkin, B. M., C. H. Mortimer & W. Pennington, 1941. The study of lake deposits. Nature 147: 496–500. Kajak, Z., K. Kacprzak & R. Polkowski, 1965. Chwytacz rurowy do pobierania prób dna. Ekologia Polska Seria B 11: 159–165. Kansanen, P. H., T. Jaakkola, S. Kulmala & R. Suutarinen, 1991. Sedimentation and distribution of gamma-emitting radionuclides in bottom sediments of southern Lake Päijänne, Finland, after the Chernobyl accident. Hydrobiologia 222: 121–140. Kelts, K., U. Briegel, K. Ghilardi & K. Hsu, 1986. The limnogeology-ETH coring system. Schweiz. Z. Hydrol. 48: 104–115. Kézdi, Á., 1980. Handbook of Soil Mechanics, Volume 2: Soil Testing. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co., New York, 258 pp. Kullenberg, B., 1947. The piston core sampler. Svenska hydrog.-biol.Komm.Skr. Tredge Seien Hydrografi, Bd. 1: 1–46. Lanesky, D. E., B. W. Logan, R. G. Brown & A. C. Hine, 1979. Anew approach to portable vibracoring underwater and on land. J. Sed. Petrol. 654–657. Livingstone, D. A., 1955. A lightweight piston sampler for lake deposits. Ecology 36: 137–139. Lotter, A. F., I. Renberg, H. Hannsson, R. Stöckli & M. Sturm, 1997. A remote controlled freeze corer for sampling unconsolidated surface sediments. Aquat. Sci. 59: 295–303. Mackereth, F. J. H., 1958. A portable core sampler for lake deposits. Limnol. Oceanogr. 3:181–191. Mackereth, F. J. H., 1969. A short core sampler for sub-aqueous deposits. Limnol. Oceanogr. 14: 145–151. Missen, J. E., 1986. A portable device for continuous sampling in soft sediment. Monash University, Department of Geography, Working Paper No. 22, 18 pp. Molnar, T. M. & D. G. Smith, 1993. Gamma-ray logging of vibracore holes. J. Sed. Petrol. 63: 758–760. Murdoch, A. & J. M. Azcue, 1995. Manual of Aquatic Sediment Sampling. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, 219 pp. Nesje, A., 1992. A piston corer for lacustrine and marine sediments. Arct. Alp. Res. 24: 257–259. Olsson, J., 1925. Kolvborr, ny borrtyp für upptagning av lerpov (Piston sampler, new sampler for obtaining samples of clay). Teknisk Tidskrift 55: 17–20. Olsson, J., 1936. Methods for taking earth samples with the most undisturbed natural consistency. Congress on Large Dams (Washington, D.C.) 4: 157–161. Pierce, J. W. & J. D. Howard, 1969. An inexpensive portable vibracorer for sampling unconsolidated sands. J. Sed. Petrol. 39: 385–390. Piggot, C. S., 1941. Factors involved in submarine core sampling. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 52:1513–1524. Pratje, O. 1936. Bohrungen auf den ostpressischen Hafen (Borings in the East Prussian bays). Natur und Volk 66: 587. Reasoner, M. A., 1986. An inexpensive, lightweight percussion core sampling system. Geogr. Phys. Quat. 40: 217–219. Reasoner, M. A., 1993. Equipment and procedure improvements for a lightweight, inexpensive, percussion core sampling system. J. Paleolim. 8: 273–281. Reddering, J. S. V. & R. Pinter, 1985. A simple, disposable core catcher for vibracoring tubes. J. Sed. Petrol. 55: 605–606.
SEDIMENT CORE COLLECTION AND EXTRUSION
105
Renberg, I., 1981. Improved methods for sampling, photographing and varve-counting of varved lake sediments. Boreas 10: 255–258. Renberg, I., 1991. The HON-Kajak sediment corer. J. Paleolim. 6: 167–170. Renberg, I. & H. Hansson, 1993. A pump freeze corer for recent sediments. Limnol. Oceanogr. 38: 1317–1321. Sanders, J. E. & J. Imbrie, 1963. Continuous cores of Bahamian calcareous sands made by vibrodrilling. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 74: 1287–1292. Shapiro, J., 1958. The core-freezer — a new sampler for lake sediments. Ecology 39: 758. Sly, P. G., 1981. Equipment and techniques for offshore survey and site investigations. Can. Geotech. J. 18: 230–249. Smith, D. G., 1984. Vibracoring fluvial and deltaic sediments: tips on improving penetration and recovery. J. Sed. Petrol. 54: 660–663. Smith, D. G., 1992. Vibracoring: recent innovations. J. Paleolim. 7: 137–143. Smith, D. G., 1998. Vibracoring: a new method for coring deep lakes. Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclim., Palaeoecol. 140: 433–440. Stephenson, M., J. Klaverkamp, M. Motycka, C. Baron & W. Schwartz, 1996. Coring artefacts and contaminant inventories in lake sediment. J. Paleolim. 15: 99–106. Thompson, T. A., C. S. Miller, P. K. Doss, L. D. P. Thompson & S. J. Baedke, 1991. Land-based Vibracoring and vibracore analysis: tips, tricks, and traps. Indiana Geol. Survey Occasional Paper 58, 13 pp. Tiercelin, J.-J., A. Vincens, C. E. Barton, P. Carbonel, J. Casanova, G. Belibrias, F. Gasse, E. Grosdidier, F. Melières, R. B. Owen, P. Page, C. Palacios, H. Paquet, G. Peniguel, J.-P. Peypouquet, J.-F. Raynaud, R. W. Renaut, C. Seyve, M. Vandenbroucke & G. Vidal, 1987. Le demi-graben de Baringo-Bogoria, Rift Gregoro, Kenya: 30 000 ans d’histoire hydrologique et sédimentaire. Bull. Centres Rech. Explor.-Prod Elf-Aquitane 11: 249–540. Todd, B. J., C. F. M. Lewis, D. L. Forbes, L. H. Thorleifson & E. Nielsen (eds.), 2000. 1996 Lake Winnipeg Project: Cruise Report and Scientific Results. Geol. Survey Can. Open File 3470, 842 pp. Tratt, M. H. & R. V. Burne, 1980. An inexpensive and efficient double-tube hand coring device. BMR J. Austr. Geol. Geophys. 5: 156–158. Vallentyne, J. R., 1955. A modification of the Livingstone piston sampler for lake deposits. Ecology 36: 139–141. Verschuren, D., 2000. Freeze coring soft sediments in tropical lakes. J. Paleolim. 24: 361–365. Wright, H. E., Jr., 1967. A square-rod piston sampler for lake sediments. J. Sed. Petrol. 37: 975–976. Wright, H. E., Jr., 1980. Cores of soft lake sediments. Boreas 9: 107–114. Wright, H. E., Jr., 1990. An improved Hongve sampler for surface sediments. J. Paleolim. 4: 91–92. Wright, H. E., Jr., 1991. Coring tips. J. Paleolim. 6: 37–49. Wright, H. E., E. J. Cushing & D. A. Livingstone, 1965. Coring devices for lake sediments. In Kummel, B. & D. Raup (eds.) Handbook of Paleontological Techniques. W. H. Freeman and Company, San Francisco: 494–520.
This page intentionally left blank
6. CORING AND DRILLING EQUIPMENT AND PROCEDURES FOR RECOVERY OF LONG LACUSTRINE SEQUENCES
SUZANNE A. G. LEROY (
[email protected]) Department of Geography and Earth Sciences Brunei University Uxbridge UB8 3PH Middlesex, UK STEVE M. COLMAN (
[email protected]) U.S. Geological Survey 384 Woods Hole Rd Woods Hole, MA 02543 USA Keywords: drilling rig, lake, continuous sedimentary sequences, drilling platform, equipment, coring
Introduction
Three types of palaeoclimatic records form the primary basis for most long global palaeoclimatic reconstruction: marine deposits, ice cores and lacustrine sediments. Compared to the other two, lacustrine palaeoclimatic records are still underdeveloped. Drilling and coring projects focused on palaeoclimatic records derived from lake sediments would benefit from a more collaborative approach with the development of relevant new technologies more like their marine (ODP, Ocean Drilling Program) and ice-core (GISP, Greenland Ice Sheet Project, and GRIP, Greenland Ice Core Project) analogues. At scientific workshops, discussions have emerged on existing drilling equipment — and their limitations — for retrieving long continuous sections of soft sediments from lakes and the difficulty of obtaining published information. What information exists is mostly informal and not widely available. In order to address this deficiency, recommendations for various scientific and technical aspects of lake drilling, including site choice policy, archiving of cores, dissemination of results and analytical methods have recently been published in a Past Global Changes (PAGES, a core project of the International Geosphere-Biosphere Programme, IGBP) report (Colman, 1996; also freely available from http://www.pages.unibe.ch/publications/reports/Contidrill). In addition, the chapter by Glew et al. (this volume) discusses the retrieval of relatively short sediment cores. In order to drill deep lakes (typically more than 30 or 50 m water depth but there is no fixed definition) such as Lake Titicaca (maximum depth: 284 m), Lake Baikal (max. depth: 107 W. M. Last & J. P. Smol (eds.), 2001. Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments. Volume 1: Basin Analysis, Coring, and Chronological Techniques. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
108
SUZANNE A. G. LEROY & STEVE M. COLMAN
1640 m) and Lake Malawi (max. depth: 700 m), and to recover long continuous undisturbed sediment cores, international collaboration and the development of new technologies are required. PAGES sent a questionnaire world-wide in order to inventory existing drilling systems capable of obtaining long lake records (deep lakes and/or long sedimentary records) (Leroy, 1996). In addition, a new technology, the GLAD800 drilling rig, is currently being tested under the auspices of the International Continental Drilling Program (ICDP). This program is a multinational program to further and fund geosciences in the field of Continental Scientific Drilling (http://icdp.gfz-potsdam.de). One of its interests is deep lake drilling to obtain sedimentary records relevant to all possible geological timescales. Coring and drilling technology and operation from lake surfaces For the purpose of this paper we consider mostly operational issues in coring and drilling from lake surfaces. Surface sediments in lakes (sediment currently being deposited) offer significant advantages for calibrating palaeoclimatic proxy signals from known modern depositional environments. The coring or drilling method used must be tailored to individual situations owing to of the wide variety of types of lakes and character of lacustrine sediments. In the f