Time and the Crystal Studies in Dante's Rime Petrose Robert M. Durling and Ronald L. Martinez UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS Berkeley Los Angeles Oxford © 1990 The Regents of the University of California
For more than ebooks please contact me: Sociology,philosophy, History
[email protected]
Preface This volume is a collaborative effort, extending over a number of years. As is characteristic of collaborations, the boundaries of each partner's contribution are difficult to establish. Countless discussions and exchanges over the years have in many cases made it impossible to say that this or that idea came from one of us rather than the other. This mutual debt and blending of views has been, in fact, one of the great satisfactions of the project. The chapters that make up the book may be more clearly assigned, since although we have made many suggestions to each other, we have done the writing separately. Thus Durling is the main author of the Introduction, Chapters 1, 2, and 4, Appendices 1 and 4, and the Index; Martinez of Chapters 3, 5, and 6, and Appendices 2 and 3. A number of people have read the manuscript, in part or in its entirety, at various stages of its evolution and have given us generous encouragement and helpful criticism. We would like to thank especially Leonard Barkan, Harry Berger, Jr., Kenneth Durling, John Freccero, Rachel Jacoff, and David Quint. Robert McMahon's detailed criticisms of an entire early version were particularly helpful. Discussion with the members of the 1988 Stanford Dante Institute helped to clarify a number of ideas. Nancy Vine Durling has read the entire manuscript in all of its avatars, has caught many mistakes, and has made numerous helpful suggestions. The University of California at Santa Cruz has been generous with sabbatical leaves. The staffs of the libraries of the University of Minnesota, the University of California at Berkeley, and the University of California at Santa Cruz have been unfailingly helpful, as have the staff of the Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris. We are grateful also to Anne Canright, Doris Kretschmer, and Rose Vekony, all of the University of California Press, for their technical expertise and their generous support. The text of the petrose is reprinted from Le rime, edited by Gianfranco Contini (copyright 1946: Turin, Giulio Einaudi); the text of Book 2 of the De vulgari eloquentia from Opere minori, volume 2, edited by Pier ― xii ― Vincenzo Mengaldo (copyright 1979: Milano-Napoli, Ricciardi); and of Vita nuova, chapter 19, from Opere minori, volume 1, part 1a, edited by Domenico De Robertis (copyright 1984: Milano-Napoli, Ricciardi), all with the generous permission of the publishers. Portions of Chapter 2 were published in Dante Studies, volume 93 (copyright the Dante Society of America); they are reprinted with the generous permission of the publisher. The text of the Commedia is quoted from Dante Alighieri, La Divina Commedia, edited by C. H. Grandgent, revised by Charles S. Singleton (Cambridge, Mass., 1972); the text is substantially that of Petrocchi. Except as otherwise identified, translations are by the authors.
―1―
Introduction The so-called rime petrose are a group of four canzoni all written, as it seems, within a fairly short period of time—perhaps several months. They celebrate Dante's frustrated love for an unnamed and unidentified lady who is compared in each of them to a stone: sometimes a precious stone because of her beauty and her power over him, sometimes an ordinary stone because of her coldness toward him. After the often faltering sweetness of the Vita nuova and the excessive abstractness of the canzoni later to be collected in the Convivio (at least one of them can be dated 1294, "Voi che intendendo il terzo ciel movete",[1] in the petrose we find a new power and an approach to poetic form that represents an important—we believe, the decisive—departure from his earlier poems. The critical tradition has been puzzled by these poems and often embarrassed by their overt expression of sexual desire and violent feeling. In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries this embarrassment took the form of a tendency to interpret the poems allegorically; the lady was most frequently identified as Philosophy, along the lines of Dante's allegories in the Convivio. [2] Michele Barbi and Gianfranco Contini led a salutary reaction against the allegorical tendency; Contini in particular strove to free the reading of the poems from the excessive biographical literalism that resulted in endless debates as to the identity or difference of the donna pietra and the donna gentile of the Vita nuova, the "pargoletta," and other real or imagined ladies referred to in Dante's poems. Contini went to another extreme, however: although he insisted on the earthly realism of the petrose, he regarded their importance as almost exclusively stylistic—the lady was for him essentially a pretext for technical experimentation.[3] This view has become the dominant one, and most recent critics have tended to minimize the thematic seriousness of the petrose; while they see them as an important moment of preparation for the stylistic effects of the Commedia, [4] they generally accept Contini's dictum that the inspiration of the petrose is "radically fragmentary."[5] On the other hand, several recent critics have rightly insisted on this the―2― matic seriousness, but in a negative sense. For instance, Bruce Comens (1986) sees a theological condemnation of the poet's love as implicit in the poems themselves, which thus become dramatic monologues, a kind of case study in the psychology of sin. We believe that a balanced reading of the petrose requires qualification of both these views—of the first, because the poems are quite serious thematically and are much more than mere stylistic experiments;[6] of the second, because it cannot as it stands account for the positive side of the struggle with negativity in the poems or for the precision of their autobiographical references.
The Rime Petrose in Dante's Development The date of the petrose can be plausibly determined. The first poem of the series, "Io son venuto al punto de la rota," opens with an astronomical description that is sufficiently detailed to be dated: it describes the configuration of planets in December 1296, near the winter solstice. Though possible, it is unlikely that the reference was invented retrospectively, and therefore the generally accepted view, which we also adopt, is that the poems date from the winter of 1296–97.[7] Not a great deal is known about Dante's life in the last years of the thirteenth century, though our information for this period is greater than for the later ones. In 1296 he was thirty-one years old, having been born, probably toward the end of May, in 1265.[8] He had been married for some time to Gemma di Manetto de' Donati,[9] was presumably living with her, and the couple must by now have had several of their children.[10] There is evidence that Dante had financial difficulties in these years: we know that at some time during this period he became a member of the Arte dei medici e degli speziali, one of the powerful Florentine guilds, which he seems to have joined in order to qualify for political office. Between November 1295 and June 1300 we see him advancing through a series of minor political
offices that was to culminate in his election to a normal two-month term (early June-early August 1300) as one of the six priori, the executive council of the city.[11] As a public figure Dante must have been much respected, since he was later chosen to be part of a delegation to Pope Boniface VIII seeking help in settling the violent factionalism between the Whites (Dante's party) and the Blacks.[12] But Boniface had secretly favored the Blacks, and, whether from Florence or from Rome or perhaps while returning from the 1301 mission, Dante was forced to flee the armed coup in Flor―3― ence, fostered and countenanced by the pope, which was to mean that he would never see his home again: he was prominent enough among the Whites to be repeatedly singled out for sentencing in absentia and was far too proud and conscious of his worth to accept amnesty at the price of doing public penance. Thus the petrose mark an extremely interesting moment in Dante's career as a writer, when he was visibly casting about for new directions, and before the unforeseen shipwreck of all his expectations that was to yield its ultimate result in the Commedia. In this book we argue that the moment represented by the petrose is that of the first full emergence in Dante's work of what we will call his microcosmic poetics, a poetics that, as we shall see, points directly toward the poetics of the Commedia both in its positive/constructive aspects and in what, for want of a better term, we must call its problematicity. Some time after 1305, Dante decided to abandon the ambitious project of the Convivio, which he seems to have begun soon after going into exile, in favor of what was to be the Commedia. Although the Convivio remains a puzzling and perhaps misunderstood work, one thing is certainly clear: in comparison with the Commedia, it was not Dante's true poetic vocation. It was an aberration stemming in large part, as we can see from its first book, from the new exile's sense of intense wrong and from his desire to testify explicitly before men both his innocence and the sense of his earlier work. These will be powerful motives in the Commedia as well, but the Commedia represents a return to the principles that govern the petrose, though of course in terms of a much fuller project and a much more extensive knowledge of the philosophy and theology of his time. The Vita nuova is far more permeated with microcosmic thinking than has been recognized, as we try to demonstrate in Chapter 1, but Dante's grasp of the problematic inherent in his emerging approach to poetry is still preliminary in comparison with the petrose, which set forth a much fuller conception of the possibilities of a microcosmic poetics, as well as of the difficulties and ambiguities of the role of the poet. It may be helpful to list some of the striking ways in which the petrose represent a new departure for Dante: For the first time, Dante makes the natural world an explicit focus, assimilating and exploring in his poetry what were thought in his time to be valid scientific concepts, especially from astronomy and astrology.
―4― For the first time, Dante seeks to make the metrical form of his poems—their stanza forms—imitative of the cosmos: imitative not in a generic sense (as might be argued, as we shall see, for sonnet form or canzone form in general), but imitative of the particular aspect of the cosmos focused on by the individual poem. For the first time, Dante bases the themes and structure of his poetry on the parallels thought to exist between the cosmos and the human body. For the first time, Dante extends the themes and style of his poetry to include violently negative feelings. The last-mentioned aspect of the novelty of the petrose is in some respects the key to their significance. The movement we somewhat inexactly call the dolce stil nuovo had, it is true, extended the range of vocabulary and theme of lyric poetry in Italian to include
technically precise scientific and philosophical ideas and terms; in the Vita nuova, as we shall see, Dante's intense originality led to the experiment of making complex philosophical ideas the basis of the very structure of some of the poems. The dolce stil nuovo was not a stranger, either, to the idea that the passion of love could lead in a negative direction. The Vita nuova was in part an elaborate refutation of the pessimistic naturalism with which Dante's friend and rival Guido Cavalcanti viewed love, and it included the death of the lady, as well as the deathoriented narcissism of the lover, as central problems, in order to urge that love, rightly followed, led beyond death. But the dolce stil had still remained within a quite limited register of stylistic effects, dominated by a cult of sweetness and euphony that Dante shows many signs in other works of wishing to transcend. The moralizing canzoni, such as "Poscia ch' Amor del tutto m'ha lasciato," and the canzoni of the Convivio represent efforts to transcend the dolce stil primarily in terms of content, adapting its vocabulary, forms, and rhetoric to doctrinal exposition (often compared with the manner of Guittone d'Arezzo) that often involved an essentially arbitrary relation between integument and content.[13] In the petrose we are still in the realm of love poetry, but the break with the dolce stil is much more thorough; it involves style and form as well as content. In the petrose we see Dante expanding the emotional range of love poetry to a degree unprecedented before him and exploring the limits of poetic language with an extraordinary new intensity. But we must ask what is the intimate connection between the first ―5― three aspects of the new poetics and the exploration of the theme of violence. It is not simply that a cosmic poetics must include the negative in order to be complete; rather, the converse would seem to be the case for Dante already at the period of the petrose. That is, the negative aspects of his personality and his experience—impulses to violence, violent feelings of frustration, hostility mixed with desire, self-destructive impulses, feelings of subjection to the body and to mortality—are apparently so central to his experience and so powerful that the full force of a cosmic perspective is required for them to be controlled and mastered. This is no "merely stylistic" matter. As we shall see, it is a problem at the very core of Dante's activity as a poet in the Commedia as well as in the petrose. The question of the relation of the petrose to the Commedia needs to be approached with some caution. The supposition that the Commedia represents some kind of rejection of the petrose has several causes. One is the plausible enough notion that the "pargoletta" with whose love Beatrice seems to reproach Dante in Purgatorio 28 is a reference to the congedo of "Io son venuto al punto de la rota." This is of course possible, but the identification of the "pargoletta," a term used by Dante in several other poems that have no evident relation to the petrose, is entirely hypothetical. Another cause lies in the assumption that the love celebrated in the petrose is sinful—or, better, that in the petrose Dante accepts and identifies himself with the aspects of his difficult love that specifically reflect a fallen nature.[14] We should be on guard against a logical circle here: we cannot use Beatrice's reproach in Purgatorio 28 as evidence that in the Commedia Dante regarded the enterprise of the petrose as sinful simply because the idea seems plausible. Another problem is presented by the undeniable references to the petrose in the Medusa episode in Inferno 9. John Freccero (1972) established that the episode concerns the interpretive danger of reading in the letter rather than in the spirit; he pointed out numerous connections of the passage with the petrose, including the presence in them of the theme of the Medusa. Freccero's brilliant and influential article actually devotes little more than a page to the petrose, so that it is difficult to derive from it a clear statement about them; it seems to suggest that Inferno 9 identifies the petrose as the product of a poetic that devoted obsessive attention to the literal surface of the poetic text at the expense of deeper meanings, parallel to erotic fixation on the female body. It is not clear whether that is in fact Freccero's view, but in any case the idea ―6― of the petrose as mere surface would seem to be a version of Gianfranco Contini's formula: the petrose are essentially technical experiments. (Just what may be the relation between poetic surface and inner meaning in the petrose is, of course, the subject of this book.) Another problem with the idea that Inferno 9 condemns the petrose is that the petrose themselves identify and grapple with the danger of the Medusa. What view do they take of it?
Is it possible that the references in Inferno 9 are motivated not by a palinodic impulse but by the reverse? It seems to us that these and many other questions can be answered satisfactorily only when we have achieved a more adequate understanding of the petrose themselves. Only when they are seen in a clearer light will it be possible to define what in them Dante may later have wished to reject. Gianfranco Contini's approach had at least the merit of bracketing the palinodic issue and opening the door to an appreciation of the importance of these complex poems. No one doubts that the experiments with harshness and difficulty of rhyme and diction in the petrose were important technical preparation for the Commedia. [15] We believe that their importance for the Commedia goes far beyond the merely technical, so that it would be utterly implausible to suppose that Dante could later have rejected their poetics without qualification. Whatever Inferno 9 means must be much more closely specified. And as soon as one approaches the petrose on their own terms—raising such questions as the full meaning of the horoscope that opens "Io son venuto," for instance, or the metaphysical significance of the rhyme scheme of "Amor, tu vedi ben," or of the allusions to the names of Christ in the same poem—one is reminded that, as in the Commedia, there is no such thing in Dante as a technique devoid of important inner significance, no such thing as "mere" surface. As Bruce Comens (1986) properly points out (though in the context of a moralistic condemnation that we see as both narrow and premature), the form of the petrose is not at all external to their themes; rather, it is their necessary vehicle.
Microcosmic Poetics: Sources and Models The cosmic perspective of the petrose involves the poet's effort to grasp the significance of his difficult love in terms of his relation to the cosmos as a whole. This involves understanding the cosmic forces that impinge on him: he is embedded in nature, characteristically thought of, in me―7― dieval scientific terms, as the formative power of the heavenly bodies shining down on the realms below the moon. Astronomical and astrological doctrines thus play a fundamental role in all these poems. But man himself is traditionally regarded as a microcosm—as possessing a structure closely resembling that of the universe as a whole—and in both the Platonic and the Stoic traditions, health, wisdom, and salvation require the little universe of the soul to imitate the harmony of the great universe. The cosmological theme is thus intimately associated both with the need for self-understanding and with the idea that art is a primary mode in which the soul seeks to pattern itself on the harmony of the universe. We find in the petrose, then, that just as their explicit themes concern the lover's and the lady's relation to the seasons and to the motions of the planets and the fixed stars, so also in their form—as we might say, in their patterned motions—they imitate the cosmic cycles. The imitation of the heavenly bodies in the poetic form is different in each of the petrose; it is by no means generic but instead closely and intricately shaped by the themes of the individual poem, and it is always part of the poet-lover's struggle toward health. It thus constitutes one of the most interesting and significant aspects of these remarkable poems. In order to understand this imitation we must devote some attention to the "scientific" ideas on which it rests. The hundred years preceding Dante's birth had seen the assimilation of a major portion of ancient Greek philosophical and scientific thought. During the last half of the thirteenth century and into the fourteenth, there was a marked spread of interest in astronomy and the closely allied science of optics. Although in many respects Dante's scientific conceptions were old-fashioned, to some extent the emergence in his poetry of a strong interest in astronomy no doubt reflects the current excitement, and its expression, especially in the Commedia, was certainly facilitated by the growing availability of information: of treatises and astronomical tables, such as the Toledan tables (ca. 1060) and the Alfonsine tables (1272), and of equatories, analog devices for determining planetary positions. [Ptolemy's] Almagest was first translated into Latin (from the Greek) in c. 1160 by an anonymous Sicilian author, and was followed in 1175 by the very popular translation from the Arabic by Gerard of Cremona. The stimulus caused by this diffusion of astronomical theory did not have much effect on astronomical calculation and tables until about the middle
―8― of the thirteenth century, but for the remainder of that century and the whole of the fourteenth there is a flood of new tables and fresh forms of equatoria. This change must be associated with the introduction of the Arabic forms of numerals which first appear in astronomical tables c. 1260 and become standard practice by about 1320.[16]
We assume in the following that the reader has some familiarity with the traditional geocentric conception of the universe:[17] earth fixed unmoving in space, surrounded by the seven planets (in order out from earth: the moon, Mercury, Venus, Sun, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn)—which were sometimes (in the wake of Aristotle) thought of as fixed in a series of transparent spheres, sometimes (in the wake of Plato) as moving in mathematically determined orbits—the seven planets themselves surrounded by the sphere of the fixed stars. Onto the sphere of the fixed stars, which was thought to make a complete revolution once (approximately) each day, were projected from the earth such great circles as the equator, the meridian, and the ecliptic (the apparent annual path of the sun, a projection of the earth's own orbit). All change—all generation and decay—was thought to be confined to the region below the moon and to be governed by the influence of the stars and the planets, and all sublunar reality was thought to mirror to some extent the nature of the universe as a whole, to be a microcosm. Man, of course, was the microcosm par excellence. It is not our purpose to identify the direct sources of Dante's conception of the microcosmic-macrocosmic relation; variants of the doctrine appear in literally hundreds of texts available to him.[18] The most important sources of the tradition include Plato's Timaeus, [19] Macrobius's Commentary on the Somnium Scipionis, [20] and Boethius's masterpiece, the Consolation of Philosophy; Dante had clearly studied closely the latter two and probably also the first, which was available to him, though in fragmentary form, in the fourth- or fifthcentury translation and commentary by Calcidius.[21] As is now understood, the Vita nuova reveals that Dante studied Boethius—a major channel for Neoplatonic conceptions, both philosophical and artistic—much earlier than used to be thought. We believe that the Vita nuova reveals some further Neoplatonic readings, but clearly neither the Vita nuova nor the petrose reflect the extraordinary effort to master the entire system of scholastic thought that is seen in the Convivio and the Commedia. Nevertheless, the petrose certainly show that Dante had been reading intensively in the astronomical and astro―9― logical literature, beyond what is already reflected in the Vita nuova (which reflects alFargani's [Alfragano's] epitome of Ptolemy's Almagest, Macrobius, and Martianus Capella, as well as Boethius). The evidence is strong that he was by now familiar with the Timaeus; there is no question as to his knowledge of Seneca's Natural Questions; and he is clearly familiar with the general outlines of the astrological tradition stemming from Ptolemy, whether he read the Tetrabiblos itself or one of its countless epigones, such as Michael Scot's Liber introductorius. He had probably read some astronomical handbook such as Sacrobosco's De sphaera. He must have used an almanac, such as that by Prophatius, to calculate planetary positions. Whether he had read Firmicus Maternus's Mathesis or Manilius's Astronomica is very doubtful. We have not attempted to identify the direct sources of Dante's knowledge of astronomy and astrology any more than of his knowledge of the microcosmic tradition; our quotations will be drawn from the main texts of the tradition and will serve as illustrations. Plato's whimsical myth of creation in the Timaeus represents the universe as an ideally harmonious and organically unified living being. According to his influential account of the fashioning of the World-Soul (Timaeus 34b–37c), the divine workman, the demiurge, mixed in a bowl equal portions of being, identity, and difference (each already compounded of the intellectual and the physical); he then divided this mixture according to an elaborate set of proportions derived from the Pythagorean lore of the numerical basis of musical intervals: This entire compound he divided lengthwise into two parts which he joined to one another at the center like the letter X, and bent them into a circular form, connecting them with themselves and each other at the point opposite to their original meeting point, and, comprehending them in a uniform revolution upon the same axis, he made the one the outer and the other the inner circle. Now the motion of the outer circle he called the motion of the same, and the motion of the inner circle he called the motion of the other or diverse. The motion of the same he carried round by the side to the right, and the motion of the diverse diagonally to the left. And he gave dominion to the motion of the same and like, for that he left single and undivided, but the inner motion he divided into six places and made seven unequal circles having their intervals in ratios of two and three, three of each, and bade the orbits proceed in a direction opposite to one another.[22]
As the commentators have recognized, Plato almost certainly has in mind here an orrery or spherical model of the heavens (see Cornford
― 10 ― 1937 74), constructed of metal strips representing, among other great circles on the celestial sphere, the equator, the ecliptic, and the colures (the meridians) of the equinoxes. His circle of the motion of the same corresponds to the celestial equator (the projection onto the celestial sphere of the earth's equator); the motion of the circle of the Same, then, corresponds to the apparent daily revolution of the entire heaven from east to west, whose direction and rate never vary (a phenomenon we now explain in terms of the rotation of the earth on its axis). The circle of the motion of the Other, within the circle of the Same and making the figure of the Greek letter chi, corresponds to the ecliptic (the plane of the earth's orbit around the sun), along which the sun appears to make a circuit, in a year, from west to east—in other words, in the direction contrary to the daily turning of the sky (a phenomenon we attribute to the fact that as the earth revolves around the sun, our line of sight to the distant stars changes with our position relative to the sun, so that we see a slightly different pattern of stars each successive night). That Plato has the demiurge place the orbits of all the planets within the circle of the Other shows that he was struck by the fact, apparently not well known in his day (Vlastos 1975 36–51), that the orbits of all the planets visible to the naked eye diverge only slightly from one plane (that of the earth's orbit) and are visible within a band (the zodiac) extending approximately nine degrees north and south of the ecliptic. On the basis of this new scientific fact, Plato was strengthened, it seems, in his claim that the cosmos demonstrated the reconciliation of his fundamental logical and metaphysical principles (being, identity, and difference) and that the principle of identity had primacy because the daily motion of the Same swept along with it the motion of the Other. He thus had also devised a way to represent the mediated derivation of the multiplicity of the cosmos from a principle of unity, since the one circle of the Same is united with the one circle of the Other, differing only in angle and direction, and then the circle of the Other is divided into the orbits of the planets, whose changing relative positions, in conjunction with the influence of the fixed stars, account for all the variety of sublunar things. The circles of the Same and the Other are representations of particularly conspicuous celestial phenomena, and they are the basis of Timaeus's assertion that men are made according to the model of the cosmos, are microcosms. The main likeness between the world and the ― 11 ― human being is that both are incarnate souls; the human soul is a little analog of the WorldSoul. This means that the great principles that govern the cosmos—being, identity, and difference—have their counterparts in the human soul, both as logical principles underlying all forms of knowledge and as the principles of the very life of the soul. Since the visible motions of the cosmos are the expression of the life of the World-Soul, its visible circling reveals the circular and cyclical soul-life that sustains the universe. So also in the little world of man, the spherical head corresponds to the heavens: it houses the soul-motions that, at least ideally, are capable of imitating the ordered perfection of the heavens: The sight in my opinion is the source of the greatest benefit to us, for had we never seen the stars and the sun and the heaven, none of the words which we have spoken about the universe would ever have been uttered. But now the sight of day and night, and the months and the revolutions of the years have created number and have given us a conception of time, and the power of inquiring about the nature of the universe. And from this source we have derived philosophy. . . . God invented and gave us sight that we might behold the courses of intelligence in the heaven [i.e., the cycles of the World-Soul], and apply them to the courses of our own intelligence which are akin to them, the unperturbed to the perturbed, and that we, learning them and partaking of the natural truth of reason, might imitate the absolutely unerring courses of God and regulate our own vagaries. (Timaeus 47a–c [Plato 1961 1174–75])
For Plato, then, all knowledge and all moral, psychological, or artistic harmony not only imitate the cosmos and the Soul that animates it, but also to some extent partake of their nature.[23] These conceptions profoundly influenced all the traditions of ancient and medieval thought. In the rest of this section we shall examine the structure of a poem from Boethius's Consolatio Philosophiae, "O qui perpetua mundum ratione gubernas," the clearest and most recognizable instance of a form that is derived directly from the passages in Plato we have just been examining.[24] During the Middle Ages, Boethius's Consolatio Philosophiae was one of the most widely studied of all philosophical texts. Brilliantly written and shaped, this impassioned handbook of Neoplatonic doctrine had the distinction of Menippean form
(alternation of verse and prose). Moreover, many of the poems are among the best ever written in Latin, a fact that by itself would explain the great popularity of the book. The author of a number of important schoolbooks (translations ― 12 ― of Aristotle's organon and Porphyry's introduction to it, commentaries on both, compendia on arithmetic and music) as well as of theological texts, Boethius was the last important Platonic thinker to study at a philosophical school with an uninterrupted tradition, probably at Alexandria rather than at Athens (Courcelle 1948 259–261), and he was fully recognized as an authority by the schools of the high Middle Ages.[25] That the Consolatio was a major influence on Dante's thought from a period at least as early as the composition of the Vita nuova is well known.[26] "O qui perpetua mundum ratione gubernas" is the ninth poem in the third book of the Consolatio. [27] The intense crafting of this poem is supported by its exalted tone and magnificent imaginative sweep. It is placed conspicuously at the climax of the third book, in which Philosophia has at least succeeded in raising Boethius's contemplation away from his own narrow circumstances and the vagaries of Fortune to the cosmos as a whole and its creator. It comes at the moment when Boethius grasps the need for the full intellectual ascent and the need for illumination, and although Philosophia is the speaker, she speaks for him. The poem occupies the very midpoint of the work as a whole[28] and is only twenty-eight lines long, so it can be quoted here in its entirety. The O with which the poem begins represents the passionate outcry of the desiring soul caught in earthly clouds and misery: 3
7
10
14
17
O qui perpetua mundum ratione gubernas, terrarum caelique sator, qui tempus ab aevo ire iubes stabilisque manens das cuncta moveri, quem non externae pepulerunt fingere causae materiae fluitantis opus verum insita summi forma boni livore carens, tu cuncta superno ducis ab exemplo, pulchrum pulcherrimus ipse mundum mente gerens similique in imagine formans perfectasque iubens perfectum absolvere partes. Tu numeris elementa ligas, ut frigora flammis, arida conveniant liquidis, ne purior ignis evolet aut mersas deducant pondera terras. Tu triplicis mediam naturae cuncta moventem conectens animam per consona membra resolvis; quae cum secta duos motum glomeravit in orbes, in semet reditura meat mentemque profundam circuit et simili convertit imagine caelum. Tu causis animas paribus vitasque minores provehis et levibus sublimes curribus aptans in caelum terramque seris, quas lege benigna
― 13 ― 21
24
28
3
7
10
14
ad te conversas reduci facis igne reverti. Da, pater, augustam menti conscendere sedem, da fontem lustrare boni, da luce reperta in te conspicuos animi defigere visus. Dissice terrenae nebulas et pondera molis atque tuo splendore mica; tu namque serenum, tu requies tranquilla piis, te cernere finis, principium, vector, dux, semita, terminus idem. O You who with perpetual reason govern the world, Sower of earth and sky, who from eternity command time to move and, fixed, give motion to all else, whom no external causes drove to fashion the work of fluid matter, but rather the indwelling form of the highest good, free of all envy: You derive all things from the eternal example; most beautiful, You carry in mind the beauteous world, form it to like pattern, bid its perfect parts to fill it out and make it complete. You bind the elements with numbers, so that freezings may combine with flames, dry things with liquid, lest the purer fire fly up or its weight cause earth to drown. To be the mid-point of triple Nature,[29] to move all things, You attach the soul and diffuse it through adapted members; and Soul, cut in two, has globed its motion in two orbs, goes forth to return to itself, turns about the depth
17
21
24
28
of mind, and curves the heavens to a like pattern. With similar causes You bring forth souls and lesser lives, and, fitting those sublime creatures to light chariots, You sow them in sky and earth, and, by a kindly law, when they turn back to You, make them return by ascending fire. Grant, Father, that the mind climb to Your august throne, grant that it find the fount of good, grant that finding light the spirit may fix its sharpened sight in You. Shake off the clouds and weight of earthly matter and flash forth with your splendor; for You are the clear sky, You are the peaceful rest of the just, to see You the goal, the Beginning, the Mover, the Guide, the Path, the End, the Same.[30]
"O qui perpetua" was widely studied out of context because it gives a succinct summary of some of the central doctrines of Plato's Timaeus, in a Neoplatonic version that was particularly congenial to medieval Christian thinkers, treating Plato's demiurge (not given a name by Plato, and of unclear status in his account) as the one transcendent God, ― 14 ― who not only made the universe but also maintains it continuously in being. The poem was frequently used as a school text and was often the subject of commentary; in manuscripts it is often found, with commentary, without the rest of the Consolatio. [31] It is well known that Dante echoes it a number of times in the Commedia. [32] Klingner (1921) derived the form of "O qui perpetua" from the traditional three-part structure of Greek and Roman hymns:[33] epikléseis, or invocations (1–6); aretalogía, or enumeration of the deeds of the deity (6–21); and euchaí, or petitions (22–26).[34] Although most of Klingner's discussion concerns questions of doctrine and sources, in a final section he points out that lines 26–28 (from "tu namque serenum" on) have no counterpart in pagan hymns, which without exception end with the petitions, but stem rather from Jewish and Christian tradition, as in the conclusion of the Gloria (". . . miserere nobis. Quoniam tu solus sanctus, tu solus dominus, tu solus altissimus . . .") or of the Lord's Prayer.[35] The relation of the poem to the traditional pagan hymn seems to us indisputable,[36] but the division by subject matter does not quite coincide with the divisions Klingner asserts (thus the poem invites several alternate modes of division). In subject matter the three parts are as follows: the first (lines 1–9) deals with the transcendence of God and with the causes of his creating the world. God is unmoved in eternity and though fixed himself, he moves all things (this notion, as Scheible [1972 102– 104] points out, derives from Aristotle's unmoved Mover); his fashioning of the world was motivated solely by his supreme goodness (Timaeus 29e); he fashioned the world according to the eternal Ideas (29a, 37a–38a); the world is complete and perfect (33b, 37d). Actually, these lines descend through the logical hierarchy of causes. First, logically and causally prior, comes the final cause, the reason for the creation (insita summi / forma boni ); next comes the formal cause, the eternal pattern according to which the world is fashioned (cuncta superno / ducis ab exemplo ); then the focus becomes God as efficient cause ( formans ). The material cause is not omitted; it appears at the beginning of the next section (elementa ). The second part (lines 10–21) describes the structure of the world: first the relation among the elements (10–12), which are joined indissolubly by numerical proportion (Timaeus 31b–32c, 69a); second the World-Soul (13–17), incarnate in the world (13–14; Timaeus 34a, 36d–e), divided into the two motions of the Same and the Other (15; Timaeus 36b–c), by which it revolves on itself in perfect circularity and ― 15 ― so turns the heavens, which are its image (16–17; Timaeus 36d–37b); third the lesser souls sown (Timaeus 41d, 42d) in chariots (41e) through earth and sky (these are human souls), whom the inborn principle of soul, fiery (40a, 45b), causes to turn back toward the Creator (18–21; Timaeus 41c). The third part of the poem (lines 22–28) is a prayer to the Creator that the mind may ascend to the vision of him, phrased as if the ascent had three stages: conscendere sedem (to ascend to your seat), fontem lustrare boni (to find the fountain of good), in te . . . defigere visus (to fix the eye of the mind in you).[37] One may say that the first three lines of the final section take us from below all the way to the goal, while the last four resituate us as being below and needing illumination among the clouds and weight of the earthly, setting the goal as at the other extreme (clouds versus the sky beyond). But we can distinguish more
sharply: lines 25–26 treat the two extremes as separated; with requies and finis (line 27), motion toward the goal is introduced. The function of the very last line of the poem is complex. Rhetorically it is a restatement, a recapitulation of the statement of the entire poem.[38] As the poem begins with the apostrophic naming of God as Creator ("O qui . . ."), so its last line consists of a series of names for him. These names recapitulate the entire cycle of the procession of all things from God and their return to him that the poem has described. They go from God as beginning to God as end; indeed, they have a logical order beyond that: motion precedes the guide, after whom comes the path; dux is at the center of the line, at the point that represents the turning of procession into return. The last word of the line can be read in two ways, either with or without a copula—or, as we might say in English, either with or without capitalizing same: without the capital, "Beginning, mover, guide, path, goal are the same"; with the capital, "The Same [i.e., the Neoplatonic One] is beginning, mover, guide, path, goal." The last line thus represents a circle; like the poem as a whole, it is a kind of projection onto a linear sequence, a kind of straight line, of the circle of procession and return. The poem in its entirety, then, shows how the world proceeds from and returns to God, and this return has two aspects. The more obvious is the one introduced in line 21, the return of souls to God. The other aspect of return is the fact that the universe as a whole is held in unity by its yearning back toward God and its imitation of God.[39] This unity of the world is emphasized in lines 10–17, and it is the unity of a sphere: ― 16 ― first in the proportion that holds together the elements with earth at the center, fire at the circumference; then in the circular motion of the incarnate World-Soul. The same verb, converto (to turn in a circle), is used of the turning of the heavens and the turning of the lesser souls back toward the Creator. The lines on the World-Soul will repay closer examination. First of all, the World-Soul is "the mean of triple nature"—that is, the principle of Soul is (a) at the center of the world (Timaeus 34b) and (b) between the principles of Mind and of matter: it is the principle that enables them to be joined. Soul, then, holds the world together, and it does so by virtue of its own unity-in-division, its combining of the two opposing motions of the Same and the Other. These turn in perfect circularity and are the life—the unity—of the cosmos. They are the return of the cosmos to God, for the World-Soul looks always to God and is always converted toward him: mentemque profundam circuit. As God forms the world in the image (similique in imagine ) of the eternal Idea, so the World-Soul imitates God, turning the heaven into a likeness of what it sees in Mind: . . . mentemque profundam circuit et simili convertit imagine caelum.[40]
Now not only does Soul occupy the center of the world, it occupies the center of the poem as well, it holds the poem together and moves the poem, both in that it is named as the principle of motion, especially of return, and in that the poem expresses the fiery desire to return of one of the animae minores. The division of Soul into its two motions occurs at the midpoint of the poem (at secta, line 15) and in the central line of five devoted to the WorldSoul,[41] and of course the two motions are, as line 17 reminds us, made visible in the motion of the heavens (and they are joined in the central region of the heavens, preeminently at the equinoxes, where the ecliptic crosses the equator of the celestial sphere, but also in the entire region between the tropics, where the ecliptic ranges). The poem itself, then, is a model of the world; not only in theme, in structure, too, it is a microcosm. If the first section of the poem treats God as source, origin of the world, the second, Soul as holding the world stable by its return, and the third, God as goal, it becomes important that the last line of the poem begins with principium, as the first begins with the O , now both a literal instance of the circularity that is the subject of the poem (and the shape of the poem) and an omega, a long O .[42] For, as the last line shows, the poem is built on the idea of ― 17 ― God as both Alpha and Omega. Furthermore, at the end of line 27 we have te cernere finis; here at the end of the poem finis immediately precedes principium, as well as coming at the end of line 28 in terminus idem. The first and last words of the poem show a similar relation: omega (the end) and idem (the Same, i.e., God as the transcendent One, the origin); they
even form a significant sentence, The goal is the Same. Like the universe, then, the poem can be regarded as an expansion of the tautology of its first and last terms.[43] A further aspect of the poem as microcosm is the order of the terms that represent its main focuses. It originates in God, his causality being enumerated in a pattern of descent, and then, beginning in line 10, the description of the world moves from elementa to anima to mens and animus. While there is a descent from the World-Soul to the lesser souls (animas vitasque minores, 18), this sequence of terms as a whole also ascends through the principles that constitute the world (matter, soul, mind). Lines 10–28, then, imitate both kinds of return: the return of souls and minds to the Creator in its explicit argument, the stable hierarchical structure of the world in the sequence of terminology. Even the grammatical case of the various nouns contributes: we begin with accusatives (elementa, animam, animas vitasque ) for the objects of creation but move to the dative (of the recipient of a gift—menti ) when the mind prays to be granted ascent, and it contributes a slight but effective nuance that when the mind fully comes into its own the term animus appears in a genitive (of possession— animi ).[44] The clearly controlled rhetorical movement of the poem is supported by the emphatic patterns of anaphora that differentiate its three parts: First, O qui (line I), qui (line 2), quem (line 4); second, Tu (line 10), tu (line 13), tu (line 18); and third, Da (line 22), da (line 23, twice), dissice (line 25). The circular structure of the poem involves these terms also, for the anaphora tu (line 26), tu (line 27), te (line 27) leads to the last line of the poem and the idem, which, as we have seen, looks back to the O with which the poem began.[45] The function of the pattern of anaphora is complex, for if there are six complete sentences in the poem (or seven, if one counts a full stop after mica in line 26), each is introduced by a monosyllable, O, tu, or da. In fact, this articulatory sequence itself forms a complete sentence: O tu, da, and each of the articulatory monosyllables (and each anaphoric sequence) expresses the nature of one of the traditional parts of the ancient hymn as discussed by Klingner: O [qui]—invocation (epikléseis ); tu [followed by verbs expressing efficient cause]— actions of the deity (aretalogía ); and da —petition (euchaí ).[46] ― 18 ― It has long been recognized that "O qui perpetua" comes at the midpoint of the entire Consolation of Philosophy, marking the transition between a first half dominated by the traditional negative arguments of the tradition of consolatoria (the fleetingness of worldly goods and the inevitability of reverses of fortune) and a second half concerned with the positive theme of the intellectual ascent to the knowledge of God and his providence (Alfonsi 1942–43). There is an important analogy between this structure of the Consolatio as a whole and the fact that the first part of "O qui perpetua" mirrors the descent of the world from God; the second part, the return to God. Although the accents of "O qui perpetua" are exalted and entirely positive, it is precisely the principle of the descent of the divine power into multiplicity, necessarily entailing the principle of mutability—soon to be defined as the very essence of Fortuna—that accounts for Boethius's misfortune. Just as the principle of soul holds the poem and the cosmos together at their centers, "O qui perpetua" holds together the entire Consolatio; the five lines on the circling soul are the knot that binds all five books.[47] In "O qui perpetua" we have a particularly interesting instance of the Neoplatonic conflation of grammatical/rhetorical categories with metaphysical/religious ones. A chief informing principle of the poem is that imitation of the ascent in words is already a mode of practicing it. It would be misleading to suppose that the effect on the reader was thought to be merely vicarious. As Plato argued in the Timaeus, the philosophical ascent has as its goal the imitation of the harmonious cycles of the World-Soul, especially through contemplation of the heavenly cycles;[48] the imitation of the cosmic cycles in words governed by numerical proportion was clearly intended to move the soul of the reader to an analog of the cosmic harmony, in a process that unified the soul both in its rational, conceptual theoria of the heavens (the explicit subject of the poem) and in its other motions as well (see Chamberlain 1976 80–84, 91–93). This is of course the intent of the Consolatio as a whole, the motions of the soul at its center controlling the large forms of the work as a whole.
Dante's Conception of the Form of the Canzone Neoplatonic imitations of the motions of the cosmos such as the one just examined occur in texts that were indisputably known and studied
― 19 ― by Dante. As we shall see, as early as the Vita nuova Dante is striving to give the form of his canzoni a metaphysical (if not yet really cosmological) foundation. Our understanding of his conceptions is considerably enhanced by the fact that we have Dante's own discussion of the nature of the canzone in the De vulgari eloquentia, [49] which he seems to have written—and abandoned—late in the first decade of the fourteenth century, the same time span that saw the writing of the ambitious Convivio, also abandoned, it seems, in favor of the Commedia. In the De vulgari eloquentia we will find strong confirmation of our claims for the nature of the new microcosmic poetics of the petrose. The first book of the De vulgari eloquentia moves from general topics—the superiority of the vernacular to "grammar" (i.e., Latin and Greek), the origin of language, the confusion of tongues, the interrelation of the Romance languages—to the nature of the noblest Italian vernacular, the vulgare illustre latium (which Dante urges should be based on the language spoken at the most illustrious courts of Italy rather than on the language of any particular region or city). Dante apparently planned to treat the entire subject of eloquence in the vernacular, and he refers in several passages (1.xix.3, 2.iv.6, 2.viii.6) to a fourth book on the middle and low styles; but the work breaks off in the second book, in the midst of the section on the canzone, which follows a first section establishing that the vulgare illustre latium should be used only by the best poets writing on the noblest subjects in the noblest poetic forms.[50] One of Dante's aims is to claim for his own lyric poems the standing in the Italian tradition he felt they should have, and if in the course of his discussion he cites many passages from Provençal and Italian poets as representing an authoritative canon (the Italians feature Guido Guinizelli, Guido Cavalcanti, Cino da Pistoia, and a few others), it is in order to set beside them the poems of his own for which he claims authority. The eleven references to his own poems are interestingly distributed, in fact, among the main categories of his serious lyric: there are three references to the Vita nuova, three to the petrose, one to the Convivio, three to uncollected doctrinal poems, and one to a lost poem. Three canzoni are singled out by being mentioned twice: "Amor, che movi tua virtù dal cielo" (Dante 1979a 174, 216), "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore" (pp. 204, 218), and "Al poco giorno e al gran cerchio d'ombra" (pp. 212, 226). Significantly, the rime petrose are cited on an equal footing with "Donne ch'avete," the poem that Dante had identi― 20 ― fied as his first major achievement;[51] they are proudly put forward as instances of the high canzone and are clearly regarded by Dante as embodying the thematic seriousness, as well as the technical mastery, required of the tragic style. They are in no sense being repudiated or apologized for; rather, one purpose of the treatise is to assert normative rather than eccentric status for them. We believe that Dante's references to them, when read in the full context of Book 2, support our readings. For this reason, Book 2 is included, with translation, in Appendix 4. The section on the canzone, as it comes down to us, argues that the canzone is superior to the sonnet and the ballata, that it is the only form, in fact, worthy to treat the highest subjects (arms, love, virtue) in the noblest (the tragic ) style. It discusses the relation of the canzone to music, the appropriateness of the various verses (Dante excludes verses with even numbers of syllables and those with more than eleven or less than five, effectively limiting the high canzone to the hendecasyllable and the settenario ), the form of the canzone stanza, and the nature of the "tragic" style, covering both vocabulary and syntax. We will focus here on Dante's conception of the form of the canzone stanza; the important sections on the poetic qualities of "smooth" and "hairy" words will come under discussion especially in Chapter 5 (on "Così nel mio parlar voglio esser aspro"). A particularly striking aspect of Dante's discussion of the canzone stanza is his use of apparently musical terminology, which has led to serious misunderstanding.[52] All canzone stanzas, he asserts, are based on musical principles; each is "constructed to receive a certain melody" ("omnis stantia ad quandam odam recipiendam armonizata est," 2.x.2 [1979a 210]), even though it may never be set to music. In fact, in 2.viii Dante has established the independence, even the superiority, of the words of a canzone relative to the music. After asking whether the term canzone (cantio ) refers to the words or to the music, he decides in
favor of the first possibility, never even mentioning that the term might refer to the union of words and music: Nullus enim tibicen, vel organista, vel citharedus melodiam suam cantionem vocat, nisi in quantum nupta est alicui cantioni; sed armonizantes verba opera sua cantiones vocant, et etiam talia verba in cartulis absque prolatore iacentia cantiones vocamus. Et ideo cantio nichil aliud esse videtur quam actio completa dicentis verba modulationi armonizata. (2.viii.5–6 [Dante 1979a 202]) For no wind player or organist or string player calls his melody a canzone except insofar as it is wedded to some canzone; but the harmonizers of
― 21 ― words do call their works canzoni, and such words lying on the page in the absence of a performer we still call canzoni. And thus it is clear that a canzone is nothing other than the action, complete in itself, of writing words harmonized with a view to musical setting.
Here Dante clearly is not thinking of the author of the words of a poem as also the composer of an eventual musical setting. Far from it: he thinks of the musical settings as produced by musicians: their melodies (the authorship is clearly assigned) are called canzoni only when "wedded" to texts that carry the name, marriages in which the texts are clearly thought of as the male partners, the melodies as the subordinate, female ones. Likewise, and significantly, there is no mention of the musical aspect in the formal definition of the canzone that sums up this chapter: "a yoking together of equal stanzas, in tragic style, without refrain, treating one thought" ("equalium stantiarum sine responsorio ad unam sententiam tragica coniugatio," 2.viii.8 [1979a 204]). Dante's discussion of the canzone stanza does agree with what is known today about troubadour musical practice,[53] but he never even mentions the properly musical factors— intonation, melisma, high points, low points, final tones, cadences—that mark the structure of a melody as such; he never refers even to the concept of musical modes, only to repetition and change of melody (or lack of them). His reference to manuscripts of canzoni implies that it was normal for them to lack music: ("talia verba in cartulis absque prolatore iacentia cantiones vocamus" fails conspicuously to mention musical notation). The one representation Dante gives of the singing of one of his poems (Purgatorio 2.106–114) leaves us in the dark about who its composer may have been, though it makes it perfectly clear that it was not Dante. In fact in Italy there had almost certainly never been a direct connection between the writing of a canzone and the composition of its musical setting, such as there had been—in theory, at any rate—in Provence. No Italian melodies for canzoni survive from the thirteenth and early fourteenth centuries, and the leading student of the subject, though strongly persuaded of the inseparability of canzone and music, concludes that the Italians always borrowed melodies (Monterosso 1970b 808). In any case, nowhere in the De vulgari eloquentia is there any indication that Dante planned to write about the rules of musical composition. He accurately characterizes Italian poetic practice; he tells us nothing about musical practice, and there is no reason to suppose he had any particular technical knowledge of music (his terms derive rather from the rhetorical tradition). ― 22 ― Dante's references to the musical structure of the canzone stanza, then, have quite another function. In the first place, they are to be taken as characterizations of the verbal patterns, the literary-rhetorical forms, de facto and, in his judgment, de jure established as appropriate for musical setting; they retain the literary awareness of a connection between lyric poetry and song. In the second place, they reflect his conviction that the composition of verse is inherently musical in a broader sense, since it is a fashioning of words governed by numerical proportion. For this reason, and also because verse involves the tempering of opposites, such as "combed" and "bristling" words (for discussion of these terms, see Chapter 5) or sweetness and harshness (2.vii), verse is in itself a valid imitation of the musica mundana, the harmony of the universe, and probably for Dante, because of its greater intellectuality, a higher one than music itself.[54] We shall return to this point after our survey of Dante's discussion. After having ranked the various verses in hierarchical order, led by the hendecasyllable, Dante turns to the canzone stanza. Just as the canzone includes the entire art of poetry, so also the canzone stanza, he says, includes the entire art of the canzone, the term stanza itself indicating the fact: . . . hoc vocabulum per solius artis respectum inventum est, videlicet in quo tota cantionis ars esset contenta, illud diceretur stantia, hoc est mansio capax sive receptaculum totius artis. Nam quemadmodum cantio est gremium totius sententie, sic stantia totam artem ingremiat; nec licet aliquid artis sequentibus arrogare, sed solam artem antecedentis
induere. (2.ix.2 [1979a 206]) . . . this term stanza has been chosen for technical reasons exclusively, so that what contains the entire art of the canzone should be called stanza [room], that is, a capacious dwelling or receptacle for the entire craft. For just as the canzone is the container [literally, lap or womb] of the entire thought, so the stanza enfolds its entire technique; and successive stanzas are not permitted to introduce any new technical devices, but must clothe themselves in the devices set by the preceding.
In addition to speaking of the canzone and the stanza as "rooms" or "containers," Dante uses the revealing metaphor of a bundle of sticks, a fascis, in which the sticks correspond to the verses, the bindings to the factors—especially the grammatical constructions and the rhymes—that tie the lines together into a whole (2.v.8, 2.viii.1; cf. 2.iii.1, 2).[55] The basic unit of construction is not so much the individual line (though ― 23 ― that must receive its due attention) as the group of lines. In this light Dante's description of the stanza form of the canzone is more comprehensible, particularly his assertion that the principal division among stanza types is between those with only one "melody" and those involving a transition from one "melody" to another, the latter always involving the repetition of musical phrases. In poetic terms, then, what Dante is referring to by "melody" is in fact a fixed bundle, a group of lines (of fixed length): the stanza is conceived as built out of a small number of such units (from one to five), depending on whether or not any are repeated within the stanza: Quia quedam sunt sub una oda continua usque ad ultimum progressive, hoc est sine iteratione modulationis cuiusquam et sine diesi—et diesim dicimus deductionem vergentem de una oda in aliam (hanc voltam vocamus, cum vulgus alloquimur)—: et huiusmodi stantia usus est fere in omnibus cantionibus suis Arnaldus Danielis, et nos eum secuti sumus cum diximus "Al poco giorno e al gran cerchio d'ombra." (2.x.2 [1979a 210]) For some are governed by one melody progressively from beginning to end, and this without repetition of any musical phrase and without diesis—diesis is the name we give to the passage from one melody to another (which we call volta when speaking to the unlearned).—Arnaut Daniel used this type of stanza in almost all of his canzoni, and we followed him when we wrote "To the short day and the great circle of shade."
In other words, the scheme of "Al poco giorno" would be ABCDEF (the lines are all hendecasyllables, hence the capital letters; the italics indicate rhyme-words rather than rhymes); the stanza has no division and no repetition (it presents the further peculiarity, not mentioned by Dante, of rhyming only between rather than within stanzas). Other stanzas, however—most, in fact—have diesis and therefore at least one further subdivision. Dante's terminology for the subdivisions in the parts of the stanza is used today: Quedam vero sunt diesim patientes: et diesis esse non potest, secundum quod eam appellamus, nisi reiteratio unius ode fiat, vel ante diesim, vel post, vel undique. Si ante diesim repetitio fiat, stantiam dicimus habere pedes; et duos habere decet, licet quandoque tres fiant, rarissime tamen. Si repetitio fiat post diesim, tunc dicimus stantiam habere versus. Si ante non fiat repetitio, stantiam dicimus habere frontem. Si post non fiat, dicimus habere sirma, sive caudam. (2.x.3–4 [1979a 212])
― 24 ― Others, however, involve diesis: and there cannot be diesis, as we use the term, without the repetition of a melody, whether before the diesis, or after it, or both. If there is repetition before the diesis, we say that the stanza has pedes [feet]; and it is fitting for it to have two pedes, though occasionally it is given three, very rarely however. If repetition occurs after the diesis, then we say that the stanza has versus [turnings]. If there is none before, we say the stanza has a frons. If there is none after, we say it has a sirma, or tail.
In these terms the stanza of "Io son venuto al punto de la rota" has two pedes: ABC.ABC and a sirma: CDEeDFF (the last two letters are italicized to indicate repetition of the entire word). "Così nel mio parlar voglio esser aspro" also has two pedes and a sirma: ABbC.ABbC: CDdEE. "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore," however, has both pedes and versus: ABBC.ABBC:CDD.CEE; and "Amor, tu vedi ben che questa donna" is similar except that it has rhyme-words rather than rhymes: ABA.ACA:ADD.AEE (this stanza, however, would seem to depart from Dante's rule that any verse unrhymed in the first pes or versus must be answered in the second; he perhaps thought of the B and C rhyme-words, unanswered within the stanza, as instances of claves ["keys"] like those practiced by Gotto of Mantova, to whom he attributes the term in 2.xiii.5).[56] Dante apparently wrote only one canzone with (undivided) frons, a lost poem he mentions in 2.xi.5. Dante also says (z.xiii.11) that the versus may be treated as separate from the concatenatio and concluding couplet;[57] he wrote only one canzone of this type, "Io sento sì d'Amor la gran possanza." (See Figure 1 for these various stanzas; we have specified their rhyme schemes as well as line lengths for convenient reference, but Dante's discussion of the melodic divisions and subdivisions of the stanzas does not specify rhyme.)
Dante's statement that diesis requires the subdivision of one of the two parts of the stanza is not logically founded,[58] though it does reflect Italian practice, which departs here from Provençal practice. We believe that the petrose reflect Dante's characteristic tendency to establish a metaphysical—cosmological—basis for this traditional practice.[59] As Dante points out, the rules of the canzone stanza offer the greatest possible freedom to the poet: Vide ergo, lector, quanta licentia data sit cantiones poetantibus, et considera cuius rei causa tam largum arbitrium usus sibi asciverit; et si recto calle ratio te duxerit, videbis autoritatis dignitate sola quod dicimus esse concessum. (2.X.5 [1979a 212])
― 25 ― See, therefore, reader, how much freedom is allowed to those who write canzoni, and consider for what reason custom has assigned to itself such large choice; and if reason leads along the right path, you will see that it is only on account of the dignity of authorship that this freedom has been granted.[60]
It is in the disposition of the parts of the stanza, the establishing of the complex harmonies of proportion resulting from the interaction of the numbers of syllables and the number of lines from part to part, that the poet's mastery is especially shown; an entire chapter is devoted to this topic (2.xi), and another (2.xii) to the question of the proportion of hendecasyllables to settenarii. It is especially striking to the modern reader, who is used to thinking of stanzas in terms of rhyme schemes, that so far rhyme has not been referred to as in any way constitutive of the form of the stanza. Dante does think of rhyme as a unifying or binding factor, but he speaks of it as if, in the planning of the stanza, it were added to the lines after their number and order (and therefore the syntactic units they can hold) had been determined. He does not speak of it as a musical or melodic factor; there is no association between line endings and musical phrase endings (cadences or semicadences), and therefore the choice between alternate, equally permissible rhyme schemes does not affect the melodic structure of the stanza. Rather, Dante thinks of rhyme in rhetorical terms, as the rhetorical ornament of similiter desinens. In assigning the rhymes, the poet again has great freedom— virtually unlimited in frons and sirma, subject to a few rules in pedes and versus. He clearly thinks of a given "melodic" structure as capable of receiving a number of different rhyme schemes; given a first pes with the rhymes ABBC, for instance, the second pes could evidently be rhymed ABBC, ADDC, CDDA, BAAC, CAAB, and so forth; the first of these alternatives (i.e., ABBC.ABBC) is the scheme of the pedes in "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore." Dante's practice was mainly to have pedes that were duplicates in every respect, but the other alternatives are fully allowed for by his theory—as well as practiced by other poets.[61] There is no doubt some inconsistency in Dante's analysis, for if rhyme had no constitutive relation to stanza form, there would be no way of determining the division, or lack of it, of any canzone stanza whatever. In practice, and historically, rhyme is constitutive of stanza form in the vernacular, and it is precisely for that reason that Dante's exclusion of it from the numerical or spatial phase of stanza design is so significant. He is establishing ontological priorities among activities ― 26 ―
[Full Size] Fig. 1. Terminology of the Canzone (through page 29 ) that could hardly be separated in practice, and his priorities privilege the abstract, intellectualistic aspects of poetic creation, those which most clearly support the analogy with God's creation of the world. One of the most interesting aspects of the metaphors Dante uses for the construction of the canzone stanza is that they envisage the establishing of the stanzaic scheme as a kind of demarcation of space. This is ― 27 ―
[Full Size] Fig 1 (continued) perhaps more obvious in the metaphor of the room (which is, however, even more abstract than that of the bundle of sticks), since what is to occupy the room is the sententia of the poet and the provisions of his technique. The metaphor of the bundle of sticks is in a real sense closer to the literal, for if the sticks are the lines of verse that are bound together, then the bundle that is formed of these actual lines of verse literally does occupy space. The design of the bundle, then, which is prior to the writing of the lines, is the assignment of empty spaces; that is, the number of syllables in each line, the number of lines in each frons, pes, versus, or sirma, are the limits that demarcate the spaces. The activity of ― 28 ―
[Full Size] Fig. 1. (continued) designing the stanza is thus a kind of geometry, an assigning of spatial determinations to what was initially undifferentiated. Dante's terminology, from coartare (2.iii.1) to mansio to fascis to modum quo ligare (2.iii.2) to conditor (2.iii.6) to comprehendere (2.iii.8) and contenere (2.ix.2), reflects this conception, which looks back to the figure of God the geometer delineating with his compasses the space within which the world will exist.[62] It has not, we believe, been observed previously that Dante's other terms for the stanza, receptaculum and gremium, seem to be ― 29 ―
[Full Size] Fig. 1. (continued) echoes of Plato's terms for space in the cosmogony of the Timaeus, as translated by Calcidius: Quam igitur eius vim quamve esse naturam putandum est? Opinor, omnium quae gignuntur receptaculum est, quasi quaedam nutricula. (Timaeus 46a [Plato 1962 46]; emphasis added) What then shall we consider its power or its nature to be? I think that it is the receptacle of all things that come into being, as it were a kind of nurse. Decet ergo facere comparationem similitudinemque impertiri illi quidem quod suscipit matris, at vero unde obvenit patris, illi autem naturae quae inter haec duo est prolis. (Timaeus 50d [1962 48]) Let us use a comparison and say that that which receives is comparable to the mother, that which is the source to the father, and the nature that is between them to the child.
Calcidius's commentary introduces further terms: Quae quidem corpora cum sola et per se ac sine suscipiente [ex] eadem essentia esse non possunt, quam modo matrem, alias nutriculam, inter-
― 30 ― dum totius generationis gremium, non numquam locum appellat quamque iuniores hylen, nos silvam vocamus. (Plato 1962 277–278; emphasis added) For since these bodies cannot exist without a recipient or by virtue of their essence alone, he speaks of the womb of all generation, which more recent writers call hylê and we call matter, sometimes as their mother, sometimes as their nurse, and frequently as space.
Although this theme is not made explicit in what survives of the De vulgari eloquentia, it is implied by its entire analysis; and, as we will try to show, the conception is the key to the form of the petrose, in which the principle of imitation of the musica mundana pervades the poems from the most abstract level of stanza design to theme and the shape of sententia (see Chapter 5, note 9). The idea that human song imitates the cosmos is explicit in the Timaeus, of course, but Dante also knew of Plato's idea of the circling orbits of the planets as song (the idea later known as the music of the spheres) from Cicero's Dream of Scipio and Macrobius's Commentary on it, one of the most widely read books of the Middle Ages, and a principal source of Dante's knowledge of Platonic and Neoplatonic lore. Macrobius explains that human music imitates the music of the cosmos even in its strophaic forms: Hinc Plato in Re publica sua cum de sphaerarum caelestium volubilitate tractaret, singulas ait Sirenas singulis orbis insidere significans sphaerarum motu cantum numinibus exhiberi. nam Siren dea cantans intellectu valet. theologi quoque novem Musas octo sphaerarum musicos cantus et unam maximam concinentiam quae confit ex omnibus, esse voluerunt . . . ideo canere caelum etiam theologi comprobantes sonos musicos sacrificiis adhibuerunt, qui apud alios lyra vel cithara, apud nonnullos tibiis aliisve musicis instrumentis fieri solebant. in ipsis quoque hymnis deorum . . . per stropham rectus orbis stelliferi motus, per antistropham diversus vagarum regressus praedicaretur ex quibus duobus motibus primus in natura hymnus dicandus deo sumpsit exordium. (Commentary 2.3.1–6; Macrobius 1970a 103–105) Therefore Plato, when in his Republic he came to treat of the revolutions of the celestial spheres, said that a Siren was sitting on each orb, signifying that the motion of the spheres was to the gods audible music. For Siren in Greek means
a singing goddess. The theologians have explained the nine Muses to be the musical song of the eight spheres plus the one
― 31 ― greater harmony that is made up of all of them . . . and so, the theologians agreeing that the heavens are singing, they included music in their sacrifices, which was customarily made with lyre or harp or in many cases with pipes and other musical instruments. In the very hymns to the gods they demonstrated out of what two motions that first hymn sung to God by nature took its beginning, . . . in the strophe the direct motion of the sphere of fixed stars, in the antistrophe the varying returnings of the planets.
Exactly what Macrobius may have had in mind in comparing the classical strophe to the motion of the Same, the antistrophe to the motion of the Other, is difficult to say, since we cannot determine what kinds of performance of choral odes may have been accessible to him. But for Dante the basis of the analogy lies in the parallel between the recurring form of the stanza and the motion of the heavens as cyclical, as well as in the notion that the stanza is made up of contrasting or opposing motions. For, returning to the De vulgari eloquentia, diesis divides the canzone stanza into two parts governed by different melodies, different formal patterns. Diesis thus involves a transition to difference. In the stanza with diesis as practiced by Dante, there are always two pedes: that is, the stanza proceeds through a subdivision involving repetition of an identical scheme (the pes ); at the diesis the identity is abandoned and the stanza enters into its other motion, usually involving many more rhymes. In the canzone as a whole, then, the entire complex system of cycles and subcycles is repeated in each stanza, the principle of identity (the motion of the Same) thus governing and carrying forward the whole. The elements of stanza form are not of Dante's invention, but he was tireless in seeking theoretical foundations for his practice, even—or perhaps especially—when it was based on tradition. And the influence of Dante's practice (though perhaps not the influence of the De vulgari eloquentia, which remained virtually unknown until published by Trissino in the sixteenth century) reinforced certain structural possibilities at the expense of others. Dante's preferences were certainly based in part on the ontological and cosmological considerations we have outlined. After him it became normative for canzoni to consist exclusively of hendecasyllables and settenarii, for stanzas with diesis to have two pedes and a sirma, and for them to be joined by what Dante calls a pulcra concatenatio —a last element of stanza form which in the petrose has clear cosmological significance. In the De vulgari eloquentia he explains that ― 32 ― the poet is free to interweave rhymes from the first part into the second (cf., once more, the stanza of "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore"): Et quidam diversos faciunt esse rithimos eorum que post diesim carmina sunt a rithimis eorum que sunt ante; quidam vero non sic, sed desinentias anterioris stantie inter postera carmina referentes intexunt. Sepissime tamen hoc fit in desinentia primi posteriorum, quam plerique rithimantur ei qui est priorum posterioris: quod non aliud esse videtur quam quedam ipsius stantie concatenatio pulcra. (2.xiii.7 [Dante 1979a 228–230]) And some make the rhymes after the diesis different from those before it; others do not so, but interweave rhymes from the first part of the stanza with those of the second. But this is done most frequently with the first line of the second part, which many rhyme with the last line of the first part: and this seems to be none other than a lovely chaining together [concatenation] of the stanza.
The concatenation is a particular kind of echo effect, which Dante uses skillfully for a variety of purposes in different poems; significantly, in the context of the microcosmic concerns of the petrose Dante thinks of it as a kind of concrete linking of the two parts of the stanza. In the petrose, in a small way, it is like the point at which the Demiurge joins the circle of the Same to the circle of the Other.
Precious Stones The idea of stone and especially of precious stone is naturally fundamental to the rime petrose, which develop as their central motif the idea that the lady is a petra: as hard as a stone, but also as beautiful and as powerful as a precious stone. In Dante's time, precious stones are believed to have powers deriving from the star or planet that fashioned them. As one might expect, this power is thought of as radiating invisibly from them; it is hidden, but its propagation is nonetheless thought of on the model of light. Dante writes of the influence of the donnapetra as if it were a kind of light proceeding in a straight line toward him from her, against which he has no shield; often it is implicitly or explicitly identified with the lady's
gaze. In "Così nel mio parlar" the metaphorics of light is exchanged for that of combat: the lady's glance is like an arrow or a spear from afar; in the course of the poem this combat at a distance turns into hand-to-hand combat and finally into the act of love, which culminates in a return to the exchange of glances, this time the ― 33 ― prolonged—and ultimately peaceful—mutual gaze of the lovers, finally reconciled, at least in fantasy. As one would expect, the petrose give special prominence to the term petra. Petra is the only generic substantive for stone (or precious stone) used in the entire series; such generic terms as gemma, sasso, scoglio, roccia, speco, and grotta never appear. The third petrosa, "Amor, tu vedi ben," in which petra is used as a rhyme-word thirteen times, deploys the full range of Dante's use of the term. It is used generically in lines 11, 12, 18, 41, and 57, with metaphorical reference to the lady in line 62. It is used of a rock or stone (the normal word would be sasso ) in line 16, and of precious stones in lines 19 and 26, with metaphorical reference to the lady in lines 22 and 56. It is used of a specific precious stone, crystal, in line 26. In "Al poco giorno e al gran cerchio d'ombra" there is a similar range of usage: generic in lines 5, 9, 18, 26, and 34 (metaphorically of the lady in line 5), and of precious stone (metaphorically, again) in line 39.[63] In "Io son venuto" and "Così nel mio parlar," the term petra, in rhyme with itself, is used for the very first mention of the lady—in "Io son venuto," as the concluding rhyme-word of the first stanza; in "Così nel mio parlar," in the second line of the poem, in a rime riche with the verb impetra ("acquires" or "turns to stone"). For the most part, the names of specific stones or precious stones are not used in the rime petrose. The exceptions are marmo in "Io son venuto," the adjective cristallina in "Amor, tu vedi ben," and diaspro in "Così nel mio parlar." Vital to the meaning of the second petrosa, "Al poco giorno e al gran cerchio d'ombra," is the specific meaning concealed in the last, apparently generic, use of the term. In each of the petrose, then, one kind of stone is specified either explicitly or by the context. As we shall see, the stones are significantly related in terms of opacity versus transparency: crystal permitting all to be seen, but jasper, marble, and the hidden stone opaque in differing ways. They are also related rhetorically, tropically: marmo and diaspro are the proper specific terms for what they name; in cristallina petra the substantive is generic, the specification adjectival; in "Al poco giorno" the specification is suppressed, and the generic term is troped (but occulte, in a hidden way) to refer to the specific one. Moreover, Dante draws widely on the lore of precious stones (and of stones in general). In the Middle Ages occult or hidden powers were attributed to precious stones, as well as to a number of metals. These beliefs no doubt had their origin in popular superstition, but in the ― 34 ― thirteenth and fourteenth centuries they were shared by the educated; in fact they had received "scientific" explanation as a particular type of influence exerted by the heavenly bodies on sublunar substances. In other words, the "virtue" or hidden power of such a metal as gold was thought of as the concentrated power of the star, planet, or astronomical/astrological configuration that had brought it into being: in the case of gold, the sun. In the universe as conceived by the more Aristotelian as well as the more Platonic thinkers of the high Middle Ages, the heavenly bodies governed all modes of change in the sublunar world, the realm of the elements and of things made out of them, including human bodies and temperaments.[64] In the Commedia Dante was to assert that, other than the human soul, only three things had been directly created by God: the angels, the heavens, and first matter (Paradiso 29.25–36); the implication is that all else was brought into being by the heavens and their angelic movers.[65] Aristotle had asserted (Meteorologica 3.4) that minerals—stones and metals—were formed from "exhalations" underground, which were then acted on by the force of the heavens. Aquinas's commentary on the passage explains: Ita quod principium activum principale est virtus coelestis, quae dicitur virtus mineralis, a qua habent fossilia quaedam, puta lapides pretiosi, quandam virtutem coelestem et occultam: per quam occultas operationes vere exercent. (Lectio 13 [Aquinas 1875 23:531]) Thus, because the heavenly bodies are the principal active principle, through a power of theirs known as the mineralproducing power, certain minerals, for instance precious stones, have a certain hidden power: through which they actually work hidden operations.
The supposed properties of precious stones were the subject of a large number of treatises of various lengths. The shorter and more typical form consists of a simple list of the properties of individual stones, often in alphabetical order. In many cases these go back to Pliny[66] and Isidore of Seville's adaptation of him,[67] as well as to treatises supposedly by Aristotle and Theophrastus; they exist in both prose and verse, in both Latin and vernacular versions.[68] A particularly popular and widely read one, by the eleventh-century Marbodus, bishop of Rennes, discusses some two dozen precious stones in elegant and succinct Latin hexameters (PL 171; Riddle 1977). ― 35 ― The most famous literary account of the formation of precious stones is in Guido Guinizelli's canzone "Al cor gentil rempaira sempre amore";[69] we may call it the simple Aristotelian theory: Foco d'amore in gentil cor s'aprende come vertute in petra preziosa, che da la stella valor no i discende anti che '1 sol la faccia gentil cosa; poi che n'ha tratto fòre per sua forza lo sol ciò che li è vile, stella li dà valore: così lo cor ch'è fatto da natura asletto, pur, gentile, donna a guisa di stella lo 'nnamora. (11–20 [Contini 1960 2:463]) The fire of love is lit in a noble heart as is the virtue in a precious stone, for the power does not descend into it from its star until the sun makes it a noble thing; after the sun has drawn from it all that is base, its star gives it power: so a heart that nature has made elect, pure, noble: a lady, like the star, fills it with love.
Here three phases are distinguished in the production of the precious stone: the existence of a suitable material, the preparation of the material by the sun, and the descent of virtue into the stone from the star—which clearly implies the idea of the imposition of a substantial form on the prepared material.[70] The next stanzas further develop the analogy between lover and gem, distinguishing between the proud, who are like the mud (opaque to the rays of the sun and thus incapable of being prepared to receive the valore from the star), and the noble, who are like clear water (transparent and capable of form). A further stanza compares the lover, who takes his cues for action from the starlike lady, to the angels taking intention from the sight of God and turning their heavens according to it.[71] It was generally agreed that the light of the heavenly bodies, along with their motion and their changing positions, was the major principle of becoming in the sublunar realm. Even Aquinas asserted that the light of each of the heavenly bodies differed formally (i.e., substantially) from that of every other; he believed each to be unique in its species because intended to exert a distinct effect on the sublunar: Si autem lux primo die facta, intelligitur lux corporalis, oportet dicere quod lux primo die fuit producta secundum communem lucis naturam;
― 36 ― quarto autem die attributa est luminibus determinata virtus ad determinatos effectus, secundum quod videmus alios effectus habere radium solis, et alios radium lunae, et sic de aliis. (Summa theologica Ia, quaest. 70, art. 1 [Aquinas 1875 1:437])[72] For if the light made on the first day is understood to be corporeal light, we must say that on the first day light was produced according to the common nature of light; but that on the fourth day the heavenly bodies received specific powers ordered toward specific effects, as we see that the rays of the sun have effects different from those of the moon, and so on.
The simple or naive form of this doctrine has the inconvenience of making the earthly material entirely passive, attributing all imposition of form to the direct agency of the heavenly bodies (thus violating Aristotle's principle of indwelling causes).[73] An extreme version is the following by the thirteenth-century Polish optical theorist Witelo, a follower of Albertus Magnus, in the dedication of his optical treatise to William of Moerbeck (Aquinas's associate and one of the most distinguished translators of the century): Est enim lumen supremarum formarum corporalium diffusio per naturam corporalis formae materiis inferiorum corporum se applicans, et secum delatas formas divinorum et individualium artificum per medium divisibilem caducis corporibus imprimens, suique cum illis incorporatione novas semper formas specificas aut individuas producens, in quibus resultat per actum luminis divinum artificium tam motorum orbium quam moventium virtutum. ([Witelo] 1535 fol. 1)[74] For the light of the forms of the heavenly bodies is the diffusion through nature of the corporeal forms that apply themselves to the material of sublunar bodies, and, having brought down the forms of the divine individual makers into the mode of the divisible and imprinting them on bodies that pass away, through its incorporation with them it
produces ever new specific or individual forms, in which we can see, because of the active light, the divine workmanship both of the heavenly spheres and of the intelligences that move them.
Witelo is thinking of the light of the stars and planets (especially, of course, that of the sun) as actually carrying down from above and imprinting on the elements the substantial forms they bear. Somehow the visible forms of things were transmitted by light through the air. Witelo is here expressing a view close to Robert Grosseteste's "metaphysics of ― 37 ― light"—by which he was influenced—a view that helps explain the intensity with which optics was studied in this period.[75] For many reasons, the most interesting medieval mineralogical treatise is the Mineralium liber by Albertus Magnus (1890–99 5:1–55),[76] which has been translated and annotated by Dorothy Wyckoff (1967).[77] As Bruno Nardi established, in both the Convivio and the Commedia Albert is a major influence on Dante's metaphysical and cosmological ideas;[78] whether or not Dante knew the Mineralium liber, its positions are in most respects similar to those taken in others of Albert's works that Dante did know.[79] Albert seeks to give an exhaustive philosophical-scientific account of the formation and virtues of stones, precious stones, engraved gems, and metals. After his general discussions, he includes alphabetically arranged lists that subsume most of the "information" contained in earlier lapidaries. Albert used a fairly wide variety of sources;[80] he also adds comments of his own and refers frequently to his own experience. All stones, Albert says, are formed from either earth or water: from earth by conglutinatio, from water by congelatio. Transparent stones are a kind of mean between earth and water, retaining qualities of each. Albert thinks of the four elements as embodiments of the basic qualities: hot, cold, wet, dry. The transformation of one element into another involves its gradual taking on of the other's properties. Thus if water is cold and wet, earth cold and dry, he finds it logical to think of stones as formed by water's gradually taking on the dryness of earth, which accounts for its solidity: Cum enim terra ad se convertit aquam, primo virtutes terrae intrant substantiam, et alterant eam, et aquae quasi dominantes tenent eam: et tunc incipit aqua stare et terminari, et tamen adhuc perspicuitatem non omittit, et tunc deinde corrumpitur, et transit in terram, et accipit terrae qualitates, quae sunt opacum siccum. (Albertus Magnus 1890–99 5: 12) For when Earth converts Water into [Earth], first of all the power of Earth enters into the substance [of Water] and alters it, but that of Water, still dominant, contains it; then the Water begins to grow firm and be limited by a boundary, although as yet it does not lose its transparency; and then finally it is destroyed and passes into Earth, and takes on the qualities of Earth, opacity and dryness. (Albertus Magnus 1967 33; translation revised)
― 38 ― Thus if the process is fixated while the material still retains the transparency of water, we have crystal and other transparent stones. The influence of external cold is thought of as a kind of pressure: In montibus altissimis frigiditas est perpetua, quae est excellens . . . quae frigiditas exprimendo humidum apprehendit aquam a nivibus congelatam, et inducit in eam proprietates sicci, sicut est naturae frigiditatis excellentis: et ex illo sicco coagulat glaciem in crystallum vel alium lapidem perspicuum. (1890–99 5:12; emphasis added) In very high mountains there is perpetual and extreme cold . . . And this cold, by squeezing out the moisture, attacks the Water frozen by the snows, and induces in it the properties of dryness—for this is the nature of extreme cold—and then, out of that dryness, solidifies the ice into crystal or some other transparent stone. (1967 32; translation slightly revised)
This is very close in conception to Seneca's description of the formation of crystal: Aqua enim caelestis minimum in se terreni habens, cum induruit longioris frigoris pertinacia spissatur magis ac magis, donec omni aere excluso in se tota compressa est, et umor qui fuerat lapis effectus est.[81] For when water from heaven, that has very little of earth in it, has hardened through the persistence of long cold, it grows thicker and thicker, until, all the air having been expelled, it is entirely compressed into itself, and what was liquid has become a stone.
Seneca attributes the transparency of crystal to the purity of the air from which the water itself had been formed. Albert follows Aristotle's notion of transparency as a quality supremely possessed by the heavenly spheres: Aliquando autem vis terrea apprehendit aquam ita quod frigidum iam exprimit humidum, et siccum terminat materia in seipsa, manente aquae transparentia. Pervietas enim aquae non convenit eidem in quantum est frigidum vel humidum vel utramque habens qualitatem, sed in quantum convenit cum coelesti corpore. (1890–99 5:13) Sometimes, too, an earthly force attacks Water in such a way that cold expels its moisture, and dryness causes it to take on the shape of a solid, although the transparency of the Water remains unchanged. For the
― 39 ― clearness of Water does not depend on how much it contains of the qualities of cold or moisture, or both, but upon how much it has in common with the substance of the heavens [Ether]. (1967 34)
Albert criticizes four theories of the production of stones in general: three of them are erroneous—(1) that they are formed by volcanic heat; (2) that they are produced by a soul of the stone; (3) that no substantial forms are produced—and the fourth is too general (1.1.4; 1890–99 5:6–7). The same pattern appears in his critique of the theories of the "virtues" of precious stones; three are erroneous—(1) that they derive from the elements that compose the stones; (2) that in them the supernal idea or form is less submerged in matter than in other objects; (3) that they are produced by the imaginings of the movers of the spheres (i.e., the angelic intelligences)—and the fourth is too general. The fourth, general cause in each case is the influence of the heavenly bodies. On the powers of precious stones, Albert explains, "Hermes"[82] and his followers believed omnium inferiorum virtutes esse in stellis et imaginibus coelorum. Omnes autem virtutes infundi in inferioribus omnibus per circulum Alaur, quem primum circulum imaginum coelestium esse dicebant. Has autem virtutes descendere in res naturae nobiliter et ignobiliter. Nobiliter autem quando materiae recipientes has virtutes, fuerint superioribus imaginibus similes in lumine et perspicuitate. Ignobiliter autem, quando materiae fuerint confusae et foetulentae, in qua quasi opprimitur virtus coelestis. Haec igitur causam isti dicunt, quoniam lapides pretiosi prae aliis habent mirabiles virtutes: quia videlicet in substantia magis simulantur superioribus, et in lumine et perspicuitate: propter quod a quibusdam eorum stellae elementales esse dicuntur lapides pretiosi. (Mineralium liber 2.1.2 [1890–99 5:26]) that all the powers of sublunar things are in the stars and constellations. For all powers are poured into sublunar things by the circle Alaur, which they said was the first circle of constellations, but they descend into natural things either nobly or basely: nobly when the materials that receive them are more similar to the heavenly bodies in brightness and transparency, basely when the materials are confused and muddy, in which the heavenly virtue is almost drowned. And this is the reason, they say, why precious stones have marvelous powers beyond other things, for they are in substance more like the heavenly bodies in brightness and trans-
― 40 ― parency, for which reason they are called by some "elemental stars" [i.e., stars made from the four elements, not from the "fifth essence"]. (our translation)
Except that it does not mention the phase in which the material is prepared, this theory is exactly the one implied by Guinizelli's analogy. Indeed, we have just seen that Albert attributes the transparency of certain stones precisely to their similarity to the heavens. He does not deny this theory, he regards it as too general: hic non quaerimus causas agentes et moventes primas, quae forte sunt stellae et stellarum virtutes et dispositiones: hoc enim alterius scientiae proprium est: sed quaerimus causas efficientes proximas, quae in materia existentes materiam transmutant. (Mineralium liber 1.1.4 [1890–99 5:6]) Here we are not inquiring into the first active and moving causes, which may be the stars and the virtues and positions of the stars, for this is the subject matter proper to another science; but we are inquiring into the proximate efficient causes that, existing in matter, transmute matter.
Albert's explanation is elaborate; the vis mineralis, he argues, comes into being only where the appropriate materials exist in a place naturally apt to produce minerals,[83] and it functions in a way strictly analogous to that of the vis formativa in the father's seed as it shapes the embryo in the womb:[84] Dicimus igitur quod sicut in semine animalis quod est superfluum nutrimenti, descendit a vasis seminariis vis formativa animalis, quae format et efficit animal, et est in semine per modum illum quo artifex est in artificiato quod facit per artem: sic est etiam in materia aptata lapidibus virtus formans et efficiens lapides et producens ad formam lapidis hujus vel illius . . . cum materia sicci passi ab humido unctuoso, vel materia humidi passi, aptatur lapidi a sicco terrestri, et generatur in ipsa ex virtute stellarum et loci . . . virtus formativa lapidis, sicut generativa in semine a testiculis quando semen fluerit attractum ad vasa seminaria, et unaquaque materia secundum speciem propria virtus. Et hoc est quod dicit Plato, secundum merita materiae infunduntur virtutes caelestes. (Mineralium liber 1.1.4 [1890–99 5:7]) We say, therefore, that as in the seed of an animal, which is superfluous food, there descends from the seminal vessels the animal formative power, which forms and fashions the animal, and which is in the seed in the mode by which the craftsman is in the object shaped by his craft: so also
― 41 ― in materials made suitable to be stones there is a power that forms and fashions the stones and produces them in the form of this or that particular stone . . . when there is dry matter that has undergone the action of oily moisture, or moist matter that has been acted on [by dry], and there is generated in it, out of the power of the stars and of the place . . . a power that forms stones, as the generative [power] descends into the seed from the testicles when it is attracted to the seminal vessels, and in each particular material its own power according to its species. And this is what Plato says: the celestial powers are infused according to the merit of the material. (our translation)
Where there is suitable material in a suitable place, then, the stars infuse the vis mineralis, which operates purposefully (as an entelechy) through the hot and cold of the
elements as through tools. It prepares the materials and imposes on them the substantial form of the stone. Albert insists that the vis mineralis is infused into the matter, operates within it, and eventually becomes the substantial form of the stone and thus, in the case of a precious stone, the source of its power (1890–99 5:11, 26). Striking in Albert's theory is the projection onto the cosmic scale of the principles of sexual reproduction, the influence of the heavens being parallel to the pouring of seed into the womb of the earth. In essence, this is a version of the ancient myth of the hieròs gamós, the marriage of sky and earth. At another level it is interesting as an effort to devise a theory that will give a certain autonomy to earthly process, thought of as initiated by the first causes but proceeding in some sense on its own.[85] When he attempts to answer the question of why some places and not others are capable of producing minerals, Albert produces a clear statement of an analogy—very important for our understanding of the petrose —between the influence of the stars and the activity of human craftsmen: . . . stellae qualitate et lumine et situ et motu movent et ordinant mundum secundum omnem materiam et locum generabilium et corruptibilium. Virtus autem sic determinata a stellis infunditur loco generationis unicuique rei, et modo quo in naturis locorum determinatum est. Haec enim virtus et elementi et elementati omnis est productiva et generativa. Et est ista virtus loci ex tribus virtutibus congregata, quarum una est virtus motoris orbis moti. Secunda est virtus orbis moti cum omnibus
― 42 ― partibus suis et figuris partium quae resultant ex situ partium diversimodi se respicientium propter multimodam motorum velocitatem et tarditatem. Tertia autem est virtus elementaris. . . . Est autem prima harum virtutum ut forma dirigens et formans omne quod generatur, sicut virtus artis ad materiam artificiati se habet. Et secunda est sicut operatio manus. Et tertia sicut operatio instrumenti quod manu movetur et dirigitur ad finem inceptum ab artifice. Et ideo dixit Aristoteles quod omne opus naturae est opus intelligentiae. Locus enim recipit has virtutes, sicut matrix recipit virtutem formativam embrionis. Haec igitur virtus determinata ad lapidum generationem, in materia terrestri vel aquea est, in qua conveniunt omnia loca in quibus lapides generantur. (1890–99 5: 11) . . . the stars, by their [differences in] quality, light, position, and motion, move and order the world [by influencing] the matter and place of everything that can be generated or corrupted. The power of the stars, determined in this way, is poured into the place of the generation proper to each single thing, as has been explained in The Nature of Places. For this power generates and produces both the elements and elemented things. The power of a place, then, is a combination of three [powers]. One of these is the power of the Mover that moves the sphere. The second is the power of the sphere that is moved, with all its parts, and the figures that result from the varying position of the parts with respect to each other as they move more rapidly or more slowly. The third is the power of the elements. . . . Now the first of these powers, since it is the form that shapes everything that is generated, is related to the matter of the thing made as is the virtue of art. And the second is related to it as is the operation of the hand. And the third corresponds to the operation of a tool that is moved by the hand and directed to the end conceived by the artisan. And therefore Aristotle said that every work of nature is a work of Intelligence: for the place receives these powers just as the womb receives the power that forms the embryo. This power, then, determined to the generation of stones, is in the earthy or watery materials which are common to all places where stones are generated. (1967 29–30)[86]
Albert was extremely fond of this analogy between human art and the operation of the heavens, and it occurs frequently in his works.[87] Here the heavenly—angelic—intelligence (the "Mover") takes its idea from the eternal patterns of things in the mind of God, and through a power that is analogous to the virtus or habitus of art in human beings it directs the motion of the sphere, compared in its turn to the motion of the hand of a human artist. The elemental powers—the qualities hot, cold, dry, and wet—are like tools held by the hand because they act on the matter that is being shaped, as we have seen: "primo virtutes terrae ― 43 ― intrant substantiam [aquae]" (1890–99 5:12).[88] The analogy between the heavenly bodies and the human craftsman necessarily involves the converse: that the process whereby the human artist shapes his material is like the shaping influence of the revolving heavens. As we have already suggested, this is one of the fundamental principles of Dante's new poetics. Also, the petrose ask what kind of causality can be exerted by human art—whether in the shaping of the artifact or through the shaped object itself.[89] The connection of human art with the causality of the heavens is more than just an analogy, for human intelligence and the capacity for artistic creation are themselves to some extent produced by the influence of the stars and planets in the horoscope of the individual; Dante unmistakably takes this view in his invocation of the stars of Gemini in Paradiso 22.[90] Albert and Thomas both insist that human actions are not determined by the stars; still, the
passage in which Aquinas discusses the indirect influence of the stars on the mind is very revealing: Sciendum est tamen quod, licet corpora coelestia directe intelligentiae nostrae causae esse non possint, aliquid tamen ad hoc operantur indirecte. Licet enim intellectus non sit virtus corporea, tamen in nobis intellectus operatio compleri non potest sine operatione virtutum corporearum, quae sunt imaginatio, et vis memorativa, et cogitativa . . . ; et inde est quod, impeditis harum virtutum operationibus propter aliquam indispositionem corporis, impeditur operatio intellectus, sicut patet in phreneticis et lethargicis et aliis hujusmodi; et propter hoc etiam bonitas dispositionis corporis humani facit aptum ad bene intelligendum, in quantum ex hoc praedictae vires fortiores existunt; unde dicitur in secundo De anima, c. ix, quod "molles carne aptos mente videmus." Dispositio autem corporis humani subiacet coelestibus virtutibus. . . . Ideo indirecte corpora coelestia ad bonitatem operantur; et sic, sicut medici possunt iudicare de bonitate intellectus ex corporis complexione, sicut ex dispositione proxima, ita astrologus ex motibus coelestibus sicut ex causa remota talis dispositionis. Et per hunc modum potest verificari quod Ptolomaeus in Centiloquio dicit: "Quum fuerit Mercurius in nativitate alicujus, in aliqua domorum Saturni, et ipse fortis in esse suo, dat bonitatem intelligentiae medullitus in rebus." (Summa contra Gentiles 3.84 [Aquinas 1875 12:359]; see Nardi 1967a 71) However, we should note that, though celestial bodies cannot be directly the causes of our understanding, they may do something indirectly in regard to it. For although the understanding is not a corporeal power, the operation of understanding cannot be accomplished in us without the operation of corporeal powers: that is, the imagination, the power of
― 44 ― memory, and the cogitative power. . . . And as a result, if the operations of these powers are blocked by some indisposition of the body, the operation of the intellect is impeded, as is evident in demented and sleeping persons, and in others similarly affected. And that is why even the good disposition of the human body makes one able to understand well, for, as a result of this, the aforesaid powers are in a stronger condition. Thus it is stated in De anima 2.9 that "we observe that men with soft flesh are well endowed mentally." Now the condition of the human body is subject to the influence of the celestial motions. . . . So, the celestial bodies act indirectly on the good condition of understanding. Thus, just as physicians may judge the goodness of an intellect from the condition of its body, as from a proximate cause, so also an astrologer may judge from the celestial motions, as from a remote cause. And in this way can come true what Ptolemy wrote in the Centiloquium, "When Mercury is in the nativity of some one, in a house of Saturn, and is strong in his being, he gives a goodness of intelligence that sees deeply into things." (Aquinas 1956 2:17–18; translation altered)
Dante states this doctrine explicitly in Book 4, chapter 2, of the Convivio: Lo tempo, secondo che dice Aristotile nel quarto de la Fisica, è "numero di movimento secondo prima e poi"; e "numero di movimento celestiale," lo quale dispone le cose di qua giù diversamente a ricevere alcuna informazione. Ché altrimenti è disposta la terra nel principio de la primavera a ricevere in sé la informazione de l'erbe e de li fiori, e altrimenti lo verno; e altrimenti è disposta una stagione a ricevere lo seme che un'altra; e così la nostra mente, in quanto ella è fondata sopra la complessione del corpo, che a seguitare la circulazione del cielo altrimenti è disposta a un tempo e altrimenti a un altro.[91]
One of the most curious parts of Albertus Magnus's treatise on minerals is his discussion of the powers possessed by precious stones engraved with images (sigilla )—usually, in his notion, astrological images,[92] such as representations of constellations (we have seen him use the term figura for constellations, and there is no question that he thinks of them as a kind of picture outlined by the stars). He believes that the stars themselves sometimes imprint such images on stones and discusses the phenomenon at length, deciding that it is simply a special case of the imposition of form by the influence of the heavens. Albert's explanation of the fact (as he regards it) that stones engraved by men have occult powers is most interesting. The typical case is a seal representing a constellation: it must be carved at the time the constel― 45 ― lation is in force, and usually it will possess virtue only when the astrological situation of its carving is repeated.[93] Both in the intention of the carver and in the form he imposes on the stone, the constellation is the cause of the image, and it naturally will exert its influence through the human agency (carving) most fully when it is astrologically in power. The philosophical basis for this astounding notion is the doctrine of the transitivity of causal relations: Non autem dubitandum, quin omne quod est causa aliquo modo causae, est etiam aliquo modo causa causati. Si igitur vis et afflatus siderum influit quandam causalitatem artis in artifice, pro certo nisi impediatur, influet omnibus operibus artis aliquid suae virtutis. (Albertus Magnus 1890–99 5:51) And it is not to be doubted that everything that is somehow the cause of a thing is also somehow the cause of whatever results. If, then, the force and inspiration of the stars pour some influence causing art into the artisan, certainly, unless it is somehow prevented, it will pour something of its power into all the works of the art. (Albertus Magnus 1967 135; translation revised)
Albertus, Aquinas, and Dante all agree that, to the extent that artistic creation draws on fantasy, memory, and the power of association (vis cogitativa ), the three bodily faculties listed by Aquinas, it is affected by the influence of the heavenly bodies. The influence of the
heavens, moreover, does not end at birth; it extends not only to the artist's basic complexion or constitution, but also to the daily, weekly, and seasonal variations of his bodily state as affected by the heavens. As we shall see, these astrological doctrines of the influence of the heavens in shaping sublunar things, of the transitivity of heavenly causality through such privileged objects as precious stones, of the direct influence, both at birth and from day to day, of the heavens on the human temperament (including faculties directly involved in all artistic creation), and of the analogy between the influence of the heavens and the shaping activities of human craftsmen are all reflected in the rime petrose. In fact, it is not going too far to say that the petrose cannot be understood without taking these doctrines into account.
The Problematic of the Petrose The petrose grow out of the rich traditions which we have sketched thus far, to which we will frequently refer in the chapters that follow. Our ― 46 ― purpose is more than simply to recover "medieval" meanings of the poems for which modern readers need annotation. A sense of the intellectual backgrounds of the poems deepens our sense of the fundamental issues that are at stake, issues that Dante increasingly realized were for him inherent in the very activity of writing poetry. To a surprising degree, the petrose show Dante grappling with problems that anticipate those of the Commedia, particularly the need to understand and represent as fully as possible his own nature in its relation to the universe as a whole and—agonizingly—the mutual alienation between the poet and those he most wishes to reach: in the petrose, the lady; in the Commedia, the Florentines. First, two preliminary questions. The first regards the dramatic situation implied by the poems: how long has the lover been wooing the lady? Already in the first poem, "Io son venuto al punto de la rota," it is clearly implied that the speaker's love is no recent phenomenon, no new emotion born in the winter being described, for, as the central stanza puts it, although all animals' spirits are deadened by the cold, his love is increased ("e il mio [spirito] più d'amor porta"). In other words, his love preexisted the winter and is now increasing. The second poem, "Al poco giorno e al gran cerchio d'ombra," intimates the return of spring, for the lady is said to be frozen in both seasons (though it is not completely clear whether the spring in question is the one that preceded the winter of "Io son venuto"— perhaps the time of his falling in love—or the one that follows it). Similarly, the third poem in the series, "Amor, tu vedi ben che questa donna," refers to the lady's disdain for love as existing "in all seasons" (line 2). Now these indications are fairly general: they do not permit the establishment of a chronology of events, for no specific events are related. Their function would seem to be exclusively that of establishing, as the basic situation, the idea that the speaker's love for the lady has existed, and that the lady has been rejecting his advances, for an extended though unspecified period of time, perhaps as much as a year. In fact, the poems do not really imply that they are the product of successive occasions; rather, all spring from the same ideal present: they are successive confrontations of a single problem, and they rest on a coherent analysis of it.[94] Second, is the love celebrated in the petrose to be thought of as adulterous? One should consider that none of Dante's works makes the slightest reference to his marriage. For example, the issue of adultery is excluded ― 47 ― from the Vita nuova partly by the religious theme of the book and its insistence (beginning in chapter 2) that sensuality played no part in the love that Beatrice inspired. More fundamentally, Dante's marriage is not part of the fictional situation; within the Vita nuova — in the fiction of the book—it simply does not exist. In fact, it had to be rigorously excluded, unless the issue of adultery was to become explicitly a theme. Those who observe Dante in church (chapter 5) and the ladies who question him about the purpose of his love for Beatrice (chapter 18) are not thinking of him as a married man with family responsibilities (as he in fact was), and if Beatrice had so regarded him she would surely have snubbed him much sooner! In other words, although we do not always reflect on the fact as we read, the Vita
nuova must be read as if Dante had not been married. To be sure, there must have been a relation between the realities of Dante's marriage and the fictions of the Vita nuova, almost certainly a deeply significant one; but we cannot know it. It is important to see that the theme of adultery as an issue is also rigorously excluded from the petrose, although the same is not true of the theme of sexuality. It is not that the petrose assert the superiority of a lover's claim to a husband's, a frequent theme in the Provençal and Old French tradition; rather, the issue is simply excluded. Thus it will not do to assume that the love represented in the petrose is adulterous. There is nothing in the poems to justify the assertion, which could only be made on the basis of some quite unjustifiable appeal to the facts of Dante's biography. Married or not, Dante was perfectly capable of writing poems about nonadulterous love, as the Vita nuova shows. For that matter, if biography is to enter the interpretation of the petrose, it would be quite as legitimate to see them as about some real or imagined phase of Dante's relationship with his wife, who at least had a stunningly appropriate name: Gemma (a word that, both as a name and as a common noun, is absent from the poems). By the same token, it seems to us a serious mistake for modern readers to label the sexuality of the petrose as obviously reprehensible. The complexity of the poems can only emerge if we resist the temptation of a priori judgments. The problematic that emerges from the poems can be set forth as follows: The goal the lover aims for is given in the last stanza of the last of the poems, "Così nel mio parlar voglio esser aspro": Ancor ne li occhi, ond'escon le faville che m'infiammano il cor, ch'io porto anciso, guarderei presso e fiso
― 48 ― per vendicar lo fuggir che mi face; e poi le renderei con amor pace. (76–80)
In other words, the imagined goal of the lover, represented as a prolonged mutual gaze (itself the culmination of the act of love), is complete reciprocity and a complete communion of intersubjectivity. The actual situation, however, is the opposite of mutual and peaceful intersubjectivity, for the lady utterly refuses the lover's claims on her attention: lover and lady are antagonists, each actively denying the subjectivity of the other. The poems are represented as the lover's effort to express and communicate the nature of his predicament, as well as to work through it. The traditional status of love poems—that they are addressed to, and woo, the lady (this becomes explicit in the last poem)—gives us the basis of the identity of the erotic problem with the poetic one, as we shall see. Since the lover is blocked in his wooing of the lady, because she refuses and flees his love (and the petrose represent the refusal as much more radical and thorough than is customary in the troubadour and Italian traditions), the lover is in a fundamental sense alone with his desire, and he must find a way to deal with it. The petrose represent him, as it were, alone in the cosmos, confronting with his individual faculties a whole array of negative forces. The difficulty of his situation is represented at one level by the winter that is the scene of the first and third poems; yet the winter is itself the product of cosmic forces, the power of the stars. The forces arrayed against the lover range from the lady's hostility to the influence of the stars (a kind of conspiracy of the entire cosmos against him) to the destructive forces inherent in his own nature (traceable to his nativity and strongly affected by astrological influence). Against these forces the lover strives for a positive victory, and the analysis and representation of the negative forces is essential to the enterprise. The new microcosmic poetics, in short, is represented as a determined—and hopeful—response to the difficulty of the lover's situation. This poetics, then, represents the struggle between positive and negative aspects of the poet-lover's situation and of his nature. Thus it requires a certain deliberate self-division by which the poet pits the two sides of his nature against each other. He understands these two sides in terms of the Platonic analogy between the two "motions" of the World-Soul—called by Plato the motions of the Same and the Other—and the two basic motions of the human soul, roughly identifiable with rational ― 49 ― and irrational.[95] Each of the petrose is a phase of the effort to deal with negativity by allowing it scope, within the higher coherence of the poet-lover as ultimately master of
himself and confident of the positive value of his love. His love is not merely irrational desire, but it does include that component (the Other, the irrational)—ultimately, he hopes, governed and contained, like the cosmos, by the Same. In fact, each successive petrosa optimistically allows greater scope to the negative, taking greater and greater risks, both psychological and artistic. In the last poem of the sequence the negative motives—anger, frustration, violence, and self-destructiveness—must be confronted directly. "Così nel mio parlar" has two phases: a katabasis involving successive retreats into inner allegorical stages, in which the violence is increasingly identified as within the lover himself, and an anabasis in which the violence is imagined as redirected outward, turned into "playful" erotic violence, and gradually disarmed, so that the poem culminates in the prolonged gaze of mutual acceptance and reconciliation. As a symbolic or imagined working through of the problem (thus at the imaginative level a kind of victory over it), these are phases of repeated (self-)destructive division overcome, in intention at least, by reintegration. In terms of the drama between the lover and the lady, the sequence can of course have no solution other than a fantasy of reconciliation. The violence could be fully disarmed only in a reciprocal relation in which the lady would be the match of the lover in every respect. And this leads close to the core of the problem. The adoption of the microcosmic poetics—the very effort to represent in all its complexity the lover's relation to the cosmos as a whole—in itself constitutes simultaneously the choice of a certain solitude and the effort to break out of that solitude. In terms of the tradition of love poetry, this solitude is supposed to be merely provisional, a temporary deferral. But we can already see in the petrose how powerful in Dante is the sense—and to some extent the choice—of isolation within the cosmos created by poetry, how violent the need for living communication with the world. The erotic and the poetic problematics are identical: both include the paradox that the difficulty of eliciting response requires the elaboration of the poetry, but the elaboration of the poetry requires the indefinite deferral of direct interaction and therefore of response. There is also the (unanswerable) question of to what degree both aspects of the lover's situation—his impasse with the lady and his isolation within the poetic cosmos—are expressions of sexual fear. ― 50 ― In modern terms, of course, one must be struck by the absence of any but a mythicized representation of the psychology of the lady. Her refusal of the lover is depicted as so absolute that the possibility that the lover might do well to try to understand the Other better is simply excluded. There is no questioning of the status of the male subject as such: obviously Dante lived in an age when the politics of gender were far from understood. They provide the background against which the potential tragedy of the impasse must be seen. Though his insights were partial, Dante had a strong intuition into what linked his isolation, his monologism, his violent anger, and the traditions of courtly love song. The poem in which he is finally able to speak his anger at the lack of true reciprocity between the sexes, though this anger takes a most disturbing form, is a landmark in the history of love poetry. Moreover, the petrose show us one of the fundamental structures of the Commedia. To be sure, the scope of the masterpiece is immeasurably greater, including all of history as well as the entire cosmos, setting forth a profoundly original and intensely meditated analysis of the social and spiritual evils that plagued the world, as well as a fully elaborated philosophical position and a religious quest that has often been mistaken for practicing mysticism. An important core of the situation of the Commedia, however, is closely parallel to that of the petrose. First, like the petrose, the Commedia represents—and in fact springs from—a situation in the "real" world in which the speaker is almost totally blocked. In the Commedia this obstruction has two main dimensions. First, whatever the date at which the Commedia was first planned and its composition begun, a very large portion of it was written after 1313,[96] the year of the death of the emperor Henry VII, to whom Dante had looked as the savior of the political situation in Italy and the rest of Europe. From Dante's point of view, as countless passages in the Commedia and other works make clear, the dominant political tendencies of his day—especially the weakness of the Empire, the rise of the French crown, and the involvement of the papacy in temporal affairs (not to mention its corruption and the corruption of the monastic and religious orders)—were leading Florence, Italy, and the whole of Europe to disaster. Dante had worked extremely hard to further the success of Henry's effort to gain control of Italy. In the Commedia, he is divinely charged to return to the world
and write the poem; the poem thus becomes a divine intervention in history, represented in the cantos of the ― 51 ― sun and Mars (Paradiso 10–17) as parallel to the intervention at a similar moment of crisis that inspired the foundation of the Franciscan and Dominican orders. In other words, the writing of the Commedia is, as a political act, in large measure the expression of Dante's despair at the political realities and the normal avenues of political action. The second way in which the poet is blocked in the outside world—no less important than the first—is the fact that he is exiled from his native city and that his fellow citizens have repeatedly demonstrated a literally murderous hostility toward him. Significantly, in the Commedia the city of Florence is personified as a woman: in one particularly revealing passage, as a bride (Paradiso 15.97–102), in another as like Phaedra (Paradiso 17.46–48). The first pain of exile, as Cacciaguida tells Dante, is that one is barred from what one most loves: Tu lascerai ogni cosa diletta più caramente; e questo è quello strale che l'arco de l'essilio saetta prima. ( Paradiso 17.55–57)
Compare the unfailing arrows of "Così nel mio parlar voglio esser aspro," lines 9–12: ed ella ancide, e non val ch'om si chiuda né si dilunghi da' colpi mortali che, com'avesser ali, giungono altrui e spezzan ciascun arme.
An important parallel obtains between the hostility of the city of Florence and that of the donna pietra. Even though Dante's picture of the lady's hostility is no doubt poetic hyperbole, one can understand why earlier in this century Guerri and Filippini, disregarding the reliable grounds we have for dating the poems prior to Dante's exile, interpreted the lady of the petrose as an allegory of Florence (Dante 1946 149). The point is not that the situation of the Commedia can be reduced to that of the petrose, but that they share a fundamental parallel in the structure of the poet's relation to the world and to his poetry. In both, the relation with the audience he wishes to win is intensely conflicted. In both, the relation between poetry and action in the world is paradoxical. The Commedia gives us Dante the poet-prophet driven to write the poem by his despair of the world of history; confronting a hostile world, he woos the world and his city. And the poem deals with the poet's situation in the world by constructing an elaborate model of the ― 52 ― universe as he hopes it to be, a universe in which the difficulties he faces are not palliated but are inevitably taken toward their resolution, in which the ultimate victory of what the poet stands for is assured. These statements apply almost without revision to the petrose. And if the petrose show the lover moving, through a katabasis into his own self-destructive violence, to a mutual gaze of reconciliation, the Commedia gives us a protagonist who must go through an even more violent katabasis into his own and others' negativity—Hell itself—and who ascends beyond this into ever more perfect intersubjectivity (culminating, not by accident, in a prolonged gaze into the light). Thus one of the fundamental problems in the Commedia—for Dante as well as for his readers—is the blurring of the line between the representation of "reality" and religious faith on the one hand and what must be called wish fulfillment on the other. The nub of the problem can be represented in the Commedia's claim to speak for God, which Dante realizes is dangerously close to fraud. Modern readers have a further problem in that Dante's effort to make philosophically and scientifically true statements about the universe increases the difference between his model of the universe and the real one as we know it. (How aware Dante may have been of this problem is an intriguing question: to what extent did he understand that his very ability to construct so lucidly his elaborate model was inherently a sign—even a cause—of its imminent rejection?) In any case, no matter how powerfully Dante imagines the resolution of his solitary activity, whether in perfect reconciliation with the lady or in perfect communion with God, the more ambitious his poem is, the more effectively it commits him to his alternate universe, as opposed to the real one. This problem—and Dante's awareness of it—is already sharply present in the petrose. In the petrose, too, the poet's effort to achieve power over the lady is, by the choice of poetry, inevitably shifted away from
the practical goal into the alternate universe of art, in spite of the poet's fierce desire. Beginning with the petrose, Dante's poetry exists in the tension of this unresolvable paradox.
― 53 ―
1— Early Experiments: Vita nuova 19 In the second book of the Convivio, writing of the period following Beatrice's death, Dante says: . . . dico che, come per me fu perduto il primo diletto de la mia anima, de la quale fatto è menzione di sopra, io rimasi di tanta tristizia punto, che conforto non mi valea alcuno. Tuttavia, dopo alquanto tempo, la mia mente, che s'argomentava di sanare, provvide, poiché né il mio, né l'altrui consolare valea, ritornare al modo che alcuno sconsolato avea tenuto a consolarsi; e misimi a leggere quello non conosciuto di molti libro di Boezio, nel quale, cattivo e discacciato, consolato s'avea. E udendo ancora, che Tullio scritto avea un altro libro, nel quale, trattando de l'Amistade, avea toccate parole de la consolazione de Lelio, uomo eccellentissimo, ne la morte di Scipione amico suo, misimi a leggere quello. E avvegna che duro mi fosse ne la prima entrare ne la loro sentenza, finalmente v'entrai tanto entro, quanto l'arte di gramatica ch'io avea e un poco di mio ingegno potea fare; per lo quale ingegno molte cose, quasi come sognando, già vedea, si come ne la Vita nuova si può vedere. (2.12; Dante 1964 1: 180–182)
Although this passage has sometimes been taken to mean that Dante read the Consolatio and the De amicitia only after the composition of the Vita nuova, [1] it is now recognized that both texts were major influences on the "little book";[2] nonetheless, the prevailing view seems still to be that only with the Convivio does Dante's writing reflect any strongly conceptual influence from Boethius or other Neoplatonic writers.[3] We believe the evidence presented in this chapter will bring some qualification of that view: Dante means that when he first read Boethius he understood many philosophical ideas as if in a dream, and that they can be seen in the Vita nuova. As Bruno Nardi showed,[4] beginning with the Convivio Dante's works show a marked influence of Neoplatonic ideas: to mention only the most important, a qualified emanationism related to the Liber de causis and a view of the development of the human embryo and of the "origin ― 54 ― of the human soul," to use Nardi's phrase, close to Albertus's and Siger's and very different from Aquinas's. We do not propose that these ideas already appear in the Vita nuova, of course; rather, the themes and structure of "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore," as they emerge from a close examination of the poem and its divisione, seem clearly to derive on the one hand from Boethius's Consolatio, especially "O qui perpetua mundum ratione gubernas," discussed in the Introduction, and on the other, especially in the emphasis on division itself, from some of the most characteristic ideas of the Greek Christian Neoplatonists—the PseudoDionysius, widely read and commented; Maximus the Confessor, accepted as an auctor; and conceivably Gregory of Nyssa. All three of these had been translated by Johannes Scotus Eriugena. Maximus's glosses on the Pseudo-Dionysius were included in the Pseudo-Dionysian compendia produced in the thirteenth century, as were generous portions of Eriugena's remarkable Periphyseon or De divisione naturae, which included long quotations from all
three.[5] The most important and accessible of the three was of course the Pseudo-Dionysius; Dante could have read his ideas in one of the numerous scholastic commentaries, of which the most interesting are those on the De divinis nominibus. [6] Emanationist ideas were available to Dante in many texts, from Proclus's Elementatio to the Liber de causis to Avicenna to Albert (who like many others had supposed the Liber de causis to be by Aristotle). A main peculiarity of the Greek tradition introduced into the West by Eriugena, however, in addition to its insistence on the identity of grammatical/dialectical and metaphysical division, [7] is the stress placed—similar to Boethius's—on the third member of the triad monê-próodosepistrophê: the movement of the return, both of the cosmos and of the human soul, to their source. In the Pseudo-Dionysius's De divinis nominibus and in Eriugena's De divisione naturae, furthermore, Dante would have found further examples of literary structure consciously fashioned, like "O qui perpetua," on the same triad,[8] and there can be little doubt that they would have aroused a very lively interest in him.[9] In any case, there is no question about Dante's knowledge of Boethius, and his reading of the Consolatio may in fact be sufficient to account for Vita nuova 19; more speculative questions will be restricted to the notes. In the Vita nuova, Dante associates the stages of his development as a poet with the stages of his love for Beatrice. In the second chapter he relates that his debut as a poet circulating a sonnet to other Florentine poets took place because of his mysterious dream of Beatrice in the ― 55 ― arms of the god of love, and that his friendship with his "first friend" (Guido Cavalcanti) dated from Guido's reading and replying to Dante's sonnet.[10] Similarly, in chapters 18 and 19 he tells how, when Beatrice had denied him her greeting, the turmoil into which he was plunged led eventually, through a conversation with a group of ladies, to his undertaking an altogether new theme in his poems, praise of Beatrice, as opposed to the self-regarding poetry he had composed before. As Charles S. Singleton (1949 55–77) shows, this change of subject, which brings the first major structural articulation of the Vita nuova, is also an important step in the dialectic of the book, which leads, in his phrase, "From Love to Caritas." The poem in question is the first canzone in the Vita nuova (which is structured symmetrically around the central group of three canzoni), "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore." It will be the focus of our attention here, for, as we shall see, Dante was fully justified in regarding it as a major poetic breakthrough. Our approach to the poem will be through the "division" of it that Dante made in the prose of chapter 19. (Text and translation of all of chapter 19 may be found in Appendix 4.) The "divisions" of the Vita nuova, in which Dante indicates for almost all of the poems their subdivision into parts, are, as Bruno Sandkühler showed, firmly based in the thirteenthcentury procedures of commentary on scriptural and philosophical texts, which always proceed by listing topics and indicating the initial phrase of each subdivision.[11] Nevertheless, Dante's divisions have puzzled many readers, for their function, aside from what today seems a pedantic exactitude, is by no means obvious. We believe, however, that close attention to them, especially to the division Dante makes of" Donne ch'avete," will be illuminating. "Donne ch'avete" emerges, in fact, as a remarkable experiment in Neoplatonic poetic form, anticipating in many ways the structural intensities of the rime petrose. At the end of chapter 19, after what seems to many readers a tiresomely detailed subdivision of "Donne ch'avete," Dante claims a certain reticence: Dico bene che, a più aprire lo intendimento di questa canzone, si converrebbe usare di più minute divisioni; ma tuttavia chi non è di tanto ingegno che per queste che son fatte la possa intendere, a me non dispiace se la mi lascia stare, ché certo io temo d'avere a troppi comunicato lo suo intendimento pur per queste divisioni che fatte sono, s'elli avvenisse che molti le potessero audire. (19.22; Dante 1980 132)
― 56 ― This is one of a number of passages of what might be called "reticent commentary" in the Vita nuova; [12] the term might even be used to characterize the book as a whole. These passages stress the distinction between the simple and the discerning; they seem to imply the existence of a small initiated elite and to suggest that the book has an esoteric meaning.[13] There is an obvious contradiction between the circulation of the poems (cf. lines 57–58, and chapter 20, "Appresso che questa canzone fue alquanto divolgata tra le genti . . . [Dante
1980 133]), represented as intended by the poet, and the fear of its being understood that is mentioned here, a contradiction that is never resolved. In our view, this reticence is meant to whet the interpreter's curiosity. For it is striking that Dante says quite plainly that understanding the poem ("per più aprire lo intendimento di questa canzone") requires dividing it; as the previous sentence says, what is easily understood need not be divided for the reader: "però che questa ultima parte è più lieve a intendere non mi travaglio di più divisioni." In other words, the canzone is not easily understood, and the divisions are a clue to its meaning.[14] We may further observe at this point that Dante introduces the poem itself with a reference to the importance of its structure, which the division is to explain: "cominciai una canzone con questo cominciamento, ordinata nel modo che si vedrà di sotto ne la sua divisione" (Dante 1980 116–117; emphasis added). In order to follow the clues Dante has offered, we must look closely at the divisione itself and then take it to the poem. We begin with Dante's assertion that he will divide this canzone "più artificiosamente"—more carefully, more elaborately—than the preceding poems, so that it may be better understood. The prominence given the division of this poem is part of the systematic emphasis the poem receives: it inaugurates the new topic of praise (chapter 18), a major step forward in Dante's development, he says; it is the first canzone in the book; it is prepared by the major incidents of the fainting spell of chapter 16 and the discussion with the ladies of chapter 18; and its composition—at least that of its first line—is credited to some kind of divine inspiration, which Dante says came to him as he was walking beside a clear river.[15] Considering the care with which Dante has articulated the placing of "Donne ch'avete" in the Vita nuova as a whole, it should not be a surprise that its divisione has some importance as well. Dante's procedure remains constant throughout this divisione: he first announces into how many subparts he is dividing the portion ― 57 ― under examination; then he describes the content of each subpart; finally he quotes the first words, the incipits, of all but the first subpart (as we shall see, the rather insistent parallels of phrasing are not casual). Dante first divides the poem as a whole into three parts: I, a proem; II, the "intento trattato"; and III, a "serviziale" or "ancella" (the commiato ). Although he does not raise the question of the relation of the three parts to the stanzas of the poem (a point to which we will return), the incipits show that they are related to the stanzas as follows: I. Proem: stanza 1 II. Intento trattato: stanzas 2–4 III. Ancella: stanza 5 In the division of part I, four subparts are distinguished, but division does not descend below a first level; in the division of part II, however, successive subparts are subdivided. Thus while the divisione of part I suggests paratactic arrangement, that of part II is strongly hypotactic: II. Intento trattato: stanzas 2–4 A. "che di lei si comprende in cielo": stanza 2 B. "che di lei si comprende in terra": stanzas 3–4 1. "da la parte de la nobilitade de la sua anima": stanza 3 2. "da la parte de la nobilitade del suo corpo": stanza 4 a. "bellezze che sono secondo tutta la persona": stanza 4.1–8 b. "bellezze che sono secondo diterminata parte de la persona": stanza 4.9–14 i. "li occhi, li quali sono principio d'amore": stanza 4.9–12 ii. "la bocca, la quale è fine d'amore": stanza 4.13–14 The division of part II is what will mainly concern us. It has excited some discussion. Early on it was pointed out that stanzas 2 and 3 receive no subdivision;[16] Leo Spitzer called attention to the fact that in each case it is the second of two parts that is subdivided: Si constata che nella seconda parte della canzone (che comprende tre strofe) continua a suddividere sempre il secondo membro, di modo che le suddivisioni ulteriori toccano precisamente gli aspetti terreni, corporei, particolari della donna. . . . Le strofe 2a e 3a non sono suddivise, non perché contengono la cosa più importante, ma perché contengono gli as-
― 58 ― petti relativamente generici: con le suddivisioni Dante scende sempre più nei particolari. Si deve tenere presente che il modo di pensare scolastico non rinnegava ciò che era particolare, corporeo, terreno, bensì lo accettava e, partendo da esso, saliva in alto.[17]
Spitzer's suggestion for the reason behind Dante's procedure had the merit of seeking a conceptual, even philosophical basis, and it is interestingly close to the mark, even though he allowed his complacent generalization about Scholasticism to satisfy his curiosity.[18] It was Bruno Sandkühler who made explicit the basis of Spitzer's remark: parts are subdivided at levels that are lower and lower on the chain of being and of value (heaven, soul, body, whole, parts),[19] since in both Platonic and Aristotelian terms the generic is by definition at a higher metaphysical level than the particular. We may add that the subdivided parts themselves naturally become smaller and smaller: part II is three stanzas long; part II. B, two stanzas long; part II.B.2 one stanza long; part II.B.2.b, six lines; part II.B.2. b. ii, two lines. As Spitzer observed, in his division of part II Dante in each case subdivides only the second member, despite the fact that what is left undivided is in two cases (II.A and II.B.1) an entire stanza. Now we have already mentioned the insistent parallels of phrasing: again and again Dante writes, "Questa seconda parte si divide in due." And as we have seen, Dante suggests at the end of the divisione that "a più aprire lo intendimento di questa canzone, si converrebbe usare di più minute divisioni." To the best of our knowledge, no one has ever taken up Dante's suggestion.[20] If we were to do so, the divisione itself offers the clue to its completion: di più minute divisioni means more minute divisions not only in the sense of smaller ones, as at first appears, but also in the sense of more of them: più can modify either minute or divisioni. In other words, to complete the division we should follow the procedure Dante has used: he has divided the second parts, we should divide the first parts, and we should do so according to the principles we have seen him follow. Will we find that questa prima parte si divide in due? We will indeed. Let us begin with part II.A (stanza 2):
18
Angelo clama in divino intelletto e dice: "Sire, nel mondo si vede maraviglia ne l'atto che procede d'un'anima che 'nfin qua su risplende." Lo cielo, che non have altro difetto
― 59 ― 22
25
28
che d'aver lei, al suo segnor la chiede, e ciascun santo ne grida merzede. Sola Pietà nostra parte difende, che parla Dio, che di madonna intende: "Diletti miei, or sofferite in pace che vostra spene sia quanto me piace là 'v'è alcun che perder lei s'attende, e che dirà ne lo inferno: O mal nati, io vidi la speranza de' beati."
We wish a principle of division parallel to Dante's "che si comprende di lei nel cielo" / "che si comprende di lei in terra," and it is readily found: the two parts of the stanza treat what is said of her by the angels and the blessed and what is said of her by God, and the second part begins there: Sola Pietà (line 22). In other words, we now have II. A. Heaven 1. Angels and blessed 2. God B. Earth 1. Soul 2. Body But it is necessary to look more closely at part II.A.1. Can it be subdivided? First one angel is represented as speaking, then heaven, then all the santi, all the inhabitants of heaven—clearly an instance of part versus whole (i.e., Dante's criterion for dividing stanza 4). But if part II.A.1 can be divided thus, what is the point of the division? That is, what is the difference between what the single angel says and what heaven as a whole and all the blessed say? Let us look closely, for at this point the richness of Dante's idea will begin to be apparent.
18
Angelo clama in divino intelletto e dice: "Sire, nel mondo si vede maraviglia ne 1'atto che procede d'un'anima che 'nfin qua su risplende." Lo cielo, che non have altro difetto che d'aver lei, al suo segnor la chiede, e ciascun santo ne grida merzede.
― 60 ―
The single angel says that Beatrice's atto is so resplendent that it shines all the way up to heaven. Heaven as a whole asks God for Beatrice herself. Each of these parts invokes the idea of the completion of a circle of procession and return: Beatrice's atto is the result of her virtues; the use of the term risplende in line 18 is based on the idea that the atto that proceeds from Beatrice is itself a reflection of the special grace God has bestowed on her, a returning of God's light back to him. It is only a partial return of Beatrice, of course. What all of heaven asks is the return to heaven of all of Beatrice. In parts II.A.1.a and II.A.1.b, then, there is an ascent both in the nature of the speakers (first a single angel, then all heaven) and in what is said; in both cases there is the return of what has proceeded from God, but in the first instance it is partial, in the second complete. In other words, the subdivision of this first part of part II.A reveals a rather elaborate enactment of the Neoplatonic principle of procession and return, at several metaphysical levels. Dante uses the Neoplatonic term procedere both in the poem (17: "l'atto che procede d'un'anima") and in the divisione ("le sue vertudi effettive che de la sua anima procedeano "), and of course we have not done justice to the maraviglia that is asserted of Beatrice: her atto, her vertudi effettive, are marvelous because of their effect in the world, which will be the subject of stanzas 3 and 4. Thus there are two levels at which Dante sees procession and return: from God to Beatrice back to God, and from Beatrice to others back to God (as well as back to Beatrice). That the term procedere is used explicitly only of her virtues, and not of the divine procession, of which her radiance is the reflection, is an instance of the same reticence that governs Dante's division of the poem.[21] So far we have discussed only the first half of stanza 2. What of the second half, where God speaks? If the subject of what is said in the first half is heaven's awareness of Beatrice and its desire for her return, in the second half God speaks of his intention that Beatrice remain on earth for a while. The blessed are asked to suffer this decision in peace, for them a consummating telos of acquiescence in God's just will.[22] These last seven lines of stanza 2 fall into two groups: God's reply has two parts (II.A.2.a and b), the first asking the angels to accept his will, the second concerning alcun (obviously Dante himself), of whom two things are said: (i) that he is on earth and will lose Beatrice and (ii) that he will tell the damned in hell of her. Here the circular pattern of pro― 61 ― cession and return is enlarged. The poem ascends to God as speaker (all of part II.A.2), but what God says concerns (a) the postponement of return and (b) further procession, for if the angel's perspective included earth and heaven, God speaks of heaven, earth, and hell. Return is implied in (b) because no doubt Dante will return from hell,[23] but also because the last line of the stanza (Dante speaking within God's speech within Dante's poem) has heaven mentioned in hell, just as hell is mentioned in heaven, and because Dante will testify in hell that he saw the one awaited (hoped for) in heaven ("la speranza de' beati"), a return to the theme of the desire of the blessed for Beatrice's return. Only when God speaks do we get the full statement of "che si comprende di lei nel cielo," for, appropriately enough, what God says is more comprehensive, embraces not only the present referred to by the angel but also Beatrice's future and beyond, not only heaven and earth but hell as well. Return is implied, but Dante's loss of Beatrice through her death is made parallel to the loss of God, which the souls in hell have suffered through the second death, an idea that stanza 3 will develop further. Stanza 2 ends, then, both with the hope of return and with two ultimate separations or divisions: soul from body (death) and soul from God—two furthest extensions, as it were circumferential points, where the circle of progression and return may seem to break down. Finally, it is worth noting that stanza 2, encompassing the entire cosmos, has the widest range of reference of any stanza of the poem: from the angels chosen as midpoint, stanza 2 looks up to God, down to hell. In sum: II.A. "che si comprende di lei in cielo" 1. Angels and blessed a. Angel (part ): Beatrice's atto (part ) returns b. All (whole ): let Beatrice herself (whole ) return 2. God a. Acquiesce i. in my will (general ) ii. that she remain on earth (particular ) b. Dante will
i. lose her (particular ) ii. speak in hell of the hope of the blessed (more general ) ― 62 ― The upward movement within II.A.1 and from II.A.1 to II.A.2 is matched by the downward motion within II.A.2 (as in the second parts Dante has outlined). God speaks to what is below him, revealing his will for those who are on earth, including the one who will journey to hell. Beatrice's return from earth to heaven is implied in both II.A.2.a and b, just as Dante's return from hell is implied in II.A.2.b. From its second stanza, then, "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore" makes clear that it is based on the Neoplatonic idea of procession and return and that it mirrors, with all its characteristically Dantesque dramatis personae and its Aristotelianisms, the descent of God's creative power into reality and multiplicity, at each stage enacting in one respect or another the pattern of return as well as of procession. And it needs to be emphasized that Dante's theological precision here is striking; he understands how the Neoplatonic analysis (always based on the model monê-próodos-epistrophê [24] ) was applied to different metaphysical levels. The descent into particulars observed by Spitzer is associated not just with descent on the metaphysical scale of value, as Sandkühler saw, but with the fundamental principle of Neoplatonic cosmogony: its origin the utterly transcendent One, the cosmos is generated by a descent into increasing differentiation and multiplicity—that is, by metaphysical division. [25] Dante's explicit divisione refers only to the descent; his not dividing the first part in each case leaves it up to the reader to discover the principle of return that is also built into the structure of the poem. In the Vita nuova as a whole, then, Dante's use of the procedure of division, including the placing of the divisioni (before the death of Beatrice, after the poems; after her death, before the poems), is probably also to be connected with these Neoplatonic ideas and will no doubt richly repay further study.[26] Turning now to stanza 3, our first observation is that Beatrice's effect on the world is that of mediating the return of souls to God. She is an instrument, then, of reunification, and the topic of the stanza (part II.B.1), according to Dante's divisione, is precisely her vertudi effettive, her power to change others. After the three initial lines (a link with stanza 2 announcing the new topic), stanza 3 is clearly divided into two parts: Beatrice's effect (1) on cor villani (4–8), and (2) on noble hearts, alcun che degno sia (9–14): once more we find an ascending order. Each of these two parts, again, is subdivided according to a similar principle—brevity of encounter versus stare a vedere and parlarle. Thus: ― 63 ― II.B.1. "che di lei si comprende in terra" a. Her effect on ignoble hearts i. Brief encounter: their thoughts die (partial death) ii. Staying to gaze a . "diverria nobil cosa" (turn, conversion) ß. "o si morria" ( full death) b. Her effect on noble hearts i. Brief encounter: forgives all (temporary grace, virtù effettiva ) ii. Speaking with her: cannot die badly ( full salvation/return) She is an agent of reunification—or of an ultimate division. The midpoint of stanza 3, and thus of the entire poem, is of course lines 35–36. The two halves of the poem are bridged by this pair of lines, whose subject is the effect Beatrice has on those cor villani who gaze on her for more than an instant. On the human beings whom the poem is counting as lowest (apart from the damned), Beatrice's effect is a final discrimination, reached after the partial death of line 34. Either they become noble (and therefore begin the ascent of return to the Creator) or they suffer the division of body and soul. And the stanza goes on, always in ascending order within II.B.1.b.ii, to those already worthy; they become even more so, first temporarily, then permanently. The last line of the stanza means, of course, that anyone who has spoken with Beatrice is assured of salvation (just as, one presumes, those cor villani who are not converted to nobility in line 36 die both the first death of the body and the second death of the soul—damnation—which would refer back to the ending of the previous stanza). At the very end of the intento trattato—at the end of stanza 4, in the particularized praise of Beatrice's body—we descend, according to the divisione, from eyes to mouth. This is a puzzling passage, for it really does not seem possible, without the gloss, to take the last
three lines of the stanza as referring to the mouth,[27] and it is striking that this is the only second subpart in the whole division of part II for which Dante does not provide the incipit. In any case, here at the end of the body of the poem we have, according to the gloss, the collocation of beginning (eyes) and end (mouth), the latter identified with Beatrice's greeting. The love her eyes awaken constitutes the turning of the soul toward the ― 64 ― goal: saluto/salute (cf. lines 41–42). Alpha and Omega: at the furthest point of his division of the poem, Dante again refers to the entire circle of procession and return. The end of love has been referred to in the first part of the stanza, though in a larger sense: Poi la reguarda e fra se stesso giura che Dio ne 'ntenda di far cosa nova.
God's purpose, the end of his creation of Beatrice, then, is some miracle, some novo, naturally involving the return to him of some portion of his creation.[28] The term intendere is an important one in the entire context of chapter 19. It has a considerable range of meanings, from perceive to understand to mean to intend (referring to purpose). Here it clearly refers to God's purpose. When used of God in stanza 2, however, its meaning is less clear cut: "che parla Dio, e di madonna intende" (23), which has as its most obvious meaning "God speaks, referring to Beatrice"; in the light of the parallel construction in line 53, the term here implies that God has a purpose for Beatrice, an idea that is of course clear from the rest of what he says. We shall return to the related terms intento and intendimento, used both of the poet and of the poem, below.[29] Now the function claimed for Beatrice in "Donne ch'avete" (and in the Vita nuova as a whole) derives from the Christian Neoplatonic conception of man as the midpoint of creation, the summing up of the rest of creation, and at the midpoint between heaven and earth, partaking of both and for that reason uniquely capable of mediating between them, of reconciling them.[30] The rest of creation was created to serve man and suffered in his fall; its salvation depended on that of man. Man's fall necessitated the further mediation between the divine and the human, effected by Christ, who was thought of as the only perfect realization of the mediating function of mankind as well. Christ's sacrificial death is matched in importance by the metaphysical reunification he was thought to carry out.[31] Charles Singleton established that the Vita nuova as a whole is governed by the analogy between Beatrice and Christ. His analysis (1949 esp. 18–24) dwelled particularly on the parallels established in chapter 23 (at the center of the book) between Dante's dream of Beatrice's death and the Gospel accounts of Christ's death. The idea of Beatrice's mediating the return of souls-—in chiave neo-platonica, as we have tracked it ― 65 ― in "Donne ch'avete"—is of course inseparable from the analogy drawn between her death and Christ's. Her death is referred to repeatedly in "Donne ch'avete": implicitly in the desire of the blessed for her return and in the prediction of Dante's losing her, explicitly in the term cosa mortale. [32] And in the central stanza of the poem, literal death is mentioned three times: "Madonna è disiata in sommo cielo" refers to Beatrice's death, "diverria nobil cosa o si morria" to the death of the ignoble, and "non pò mal finir chi l'ha parlato" to that of the ennobled. In its symmetrical arrangement with death at the center, "Donne ch'avete" answers to the overall pattern of the Vita nuova. Furthermore, in the order Beatrice-ignoble-noble we observe the pattern of descent and return that dominates the entire poem. We just discussed the use of the term intendere of God. The same term is used of the reader's understanding of the poem, and closely related terms, intento and intendimento, refer to the subject and meaning of the poem. As we saw, the term as applied to God refers both to purpose and to reference. It is clear that the intendimento of the poem is an analog of God's intention. Translating into terms appropriate to poems, we may say that for Dante poems have meaning because they are made to an end, a purpose. How does "Donne ch'avete" define its own purpose? According to both the poem and the divisione, the poem is the fruit of the poet's pensare. It is the child ( figliuola ) of the poet's thought, and we may again look to the center of the poem to note the effect the sight of Beatrice has specifically on thought: for the unworthy, the effect is a negative one—"onne 10r pensiero agghiaccia e pere"; for the worthy, it is the opposite of freezing—being set afire, "spirti d'amore inflammati" reach the
heart. According to stanza 1, this fire is in the mind: he writes, "per isfogar la mente." Now the poem is addressed to "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore," and the prominence of the term intelletto in the first line is repeated in the first line of the next stanza: "Angelo clama in divino intelletto." This is an emphatic collocation. The status of intellect as such is at stake in the poem, as is its relation to love. It is worth noting that the first line, in addition to its usual gloss "ladies who have understanding of love," means also "ladies who have understanding from Love," in whom Love has awakened intellect. Obviously, there is a close relation among the terms intendere, intelletto, and intelligenza—for the grasping of the grand pattern of the procession of the world from God ― 66 ― and its return to him, and of Beatrice's part in it, is the work of the intellect, of the intellect fired by love: Oltre la spera che più larga gira passa 'l sospiro ch'esce del mio core; intelligenza nova, che l'Amore piangendo mette in lui, pur su lo tira. (41.1–4)
"Donne ch'avete," then, is a reflection back to Beatrice of the radiance, the divine fire, that has emanated from her, and this pattern of procession and return is an analog of the procession and return of Beatrice's own atto described in stanza 2. As Beatrice's radiance is a reflection of God's radiance and ultimately returns to him (both directly and reflected from those whom she affects), so the poem (the atto that proceeds from the poet) is a reflection of Beatrice's light and returns to her by way of the intermediaries it will find. This is the subject of the commiato: "Insegnatemi gir, ch'io son mandata a quella di cui laude so adornata" . . . non restare ove sia gente villana: ingegnati, se puoi, d'esser palese solo con donne o con omo cortese, che ti merranno là per via tostana . . .
Dante's poem will also return to God. In this way the final stanza is a coherent fulfillment of the circular pattern of the rest of the poem. It needs to be emphasized that the discovery in "Donne ch'avete" of a structure based on the principles of procession and return is not the imposition of some arbitrary pattern. The questions we have taken to the first parts were determined by the method followed by Dante himself in his division of the second parts. Furthermore, the consistency in the first parts (as, following Dante, we have subdivided them) of the ascent from the first to the second subdivision (as opposed to descent from the first part to the second part in Dante's division) is impressive, much too great to be the result of anything but conscious planning. We believe we have clearly established that the relation between the poem and the divisione is extremely close, that the divisione is no merely adventitious addition. That the Vita nuova reflects some of the major philosophical ideas in the Consolatio is, furthermore, no more than Dante suggests in Convivio 2.12, and it would be only natural to expect him to have responded intensely to—and with an effort to emulate— ― 67 ― Boethius's poems. It is well known that "O qui perpetua" remained a key text for him.[33] And the points of analogy between "Donne ch'avete" and Boethius's "O qui perpetua" are numerous. Both poems have as their subject the circle of procession and return, and both have a structure closely based on this pattern. Within the intento trattato of "Donne ch'avete" we begin in heaven and rise to God, as in Boethius's poem we begin with God. The theoria of each poem then descends into the created universe, but while Boethius's imitation of the ascent proceeds from the elements up through soul and intellect, Dante follows a descending order but at each degree enacts in some way the phase of return (in this, particularly, seeming to reveal the influence of the Greek fathers). Both poems involve two types of return, Boethius's more obviously than Dante's: the active return of souls to God and the fact that the stability of the world is itself a result of its "rest in motion"; but while Boethius focuses on the World-Soul, Dante uses the example of Beatrice's radiance. Both poems juxtapose ends and beginnings (though this is trner of Dante's comment on Beatrice's eyes and mouth in the divisione than of the poem itself);[34] both poems stress the divine intellect (in Boethius, explicitly the repository of the forms of things); and both have as a fundamental
theme the ascent of the intellect toward a vision of the relation of the cosmos to its maker, an ascent motivated by intense yearning. Dante's division of part II always into two parts obscures the obvious symmetry of its structure (and that of the entire poem) by stanzas: Stanza 1. Proem Stanza 2. Heaven Stanza 3. Soul Stanza 4. Body Stanza 5. Commiato And here, in addition to the fact that the entire structure of the poem is built on the circle of procession and return, is a particularly conspicuous analogy with Boethius's poem—in both, the principle of soul occupies the central, mediating portion of the poem,[35] and the exactly central lines state a major turning and division: in "O qui perpetua," the division of the World-Soul into the two motions of the Same and the Other; in Dante's poem, the effect of Beatrice's virtues in discriminating worthy and unworthy and in converting souls. In both poems, soul ― 68 ― is the middle principle of three levels of creation, between intellect (the angels) and body. Appropriately to Dante's more explicitly Christian approach to the theme of mediation, the principle of soul at the midpoint of "Donne ch'avete" (Beatrice's soul, not the World-Soul) includes the principles of both life and death—explicitly, the death of the ignoble, but associated through its central position in the poem with the death that holds the center of the Vita nuova as a whole.[36] We believe it is plausible that Dante's adaptation of the pattern of processio/ reditus must have been based on direct knowledge of Neoplatonic texts in addition to Boethius (though exactly which it is difficult to determine). He had certainly grasped some fundamental notions, such as the identity between logical/grammatical and metaphysical categories characteristic of Neoplatonism. In the Vita nuova, what Dante seems to have taken from his Neoplatonic readings is focused on the procession and return of God's radiance in relation to souls and on the nature of logic—aspects, in other words, that could be most readily assimilated to the fundamental Christological patterns of the book—rather than on the more properly metaphysical cycle of procession and return in the cosmos itself (though he clearly alludes to the latter by using the technical term procedere in his divisione of "Donne ch'avete"). Although he uses "O qui perpetua" as a partial model for "Donne ch'avete," his canzone—like the Vita nuova as a whole—avoids the cosmological as such. Later, Dante was to evolve a synthesis of Neoplatonic emanationism and Christian creationism parallel in certain respects to the eclecticism of Boethius's own Christian philosophy. In this regard we can see in this first experiment a continuity with some later tendencies, especially that of eschewing the notion of the World-Soul.[37] Several other questions arise at this point. The first concerns the relation between the poem and its divisione, and is closely related to the question of when "Donne ch'avete" was composed. Was the divisione written at the time of the first collection of poems into a book, as presumably most of the prose of the Vita nuova was? If so, was the poem revised then so as to fit it more closely to the divisione? Or is it more reasonable to believe that both the poem and the divisione were revised sometime later? Certain passages in the Vita nuova, of course, are most easily explained on the hypothesis of a later revision, such as the concluding promise to write of Beatrice "what has never been said of any woman," as well as lines 42–43 of "Donne ch'avete." It might seem that ― 69 ― the Neoplatonic ideas in "Donne ch'avete" and its divisione, too, could only be the result of later revision. This notion, however, is held in little favor today, largely because no sign of a later revision appears in the manuscript tradition.[38] We believe the most reasonable view to be that "Donne ch'avete" and its divisione, more or less as we have them, were integral to the first version of the Vita nuova. There are several grounds for this view, in addition to the argument from the manuscript tradition. One is the integral relation of the structure of "Donne ch'avete" to that of the Vita nuova as a whole.[39] Another is the fact that in the period immediately following the Vita nuova Dante avoided in his poetry the Neoplatonic pattern of
procession and return, which suggests that the experiment of "Donne ch'avete" (and that of the rest of the book, which really needs to be examined in greater depth along the lines of this discussion) was confined to the first period of composition of the Vita nuova and was felt by Dante, during the more intensive philosophical studies reflected in the Convivio, to be insufficiently grounded. In particular, he may well have seen that the thorny issue of emanationism required further study and reflection. This would help explain the passage in Book 2 of the Convivio with which we opened this chapter.[40] The evidence we have presented here is also relevant to the question of when Dante began thinking of a poem along the lines of the Commedia. For that work is dominated by the pattern of return, and the Paradiso becomes increasingly Neoplatonic as Dante approaches the source of all procession; indeed, the Commedia is coherent with the poetic procedures of "Donne ch'avete" as well as of the petrose, as we try to show in Chapter 6. Although it would not make much sense to suppose that Dante already had the Commedia specifically in mind when he wrote "Donne ch'avete," his demonstrated debt to Boethius in that poem and the intensity of his experimental grounding of the structure of a poem in a philosophical concept make it very likely that he had already begun to meditate on the possibilities of the idea of return as the basis of a long poem. This is to our minds the simplest and likeliest explanation of the conclusion of the Vita nuova and, perhaps, of lines 42–43 of "Donne ch'avete." In any case, "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore" is an extremely ambitious poem which Dante had every right to consider a major turning point in his development, as chapters 18 and 19 assert it to be. It is en― 70 ― tirely characteristic of the dialectic of the Vita nuova, furthermore, that the theme of praise, represented in chapter 18 as adopted almost in aporia, turns out to involve the lover in larger and larger issues. The poem may be a "giovane soave e piana," but she is a "figliuola d'amore," a daughter of the cosmic principle of love: her youthful beauty masks a great intellectual toughness and daring. ― 71 ―
2— The Solstice and the Human Body: "Io son venuto al punto de la rota" Although there is no sure indication of the order in which the rime petrose were written, it seems likely that "Io son venuto al punto de la rota" was the first, since it sets forth the situation and terms that govern the rest of them; but it may of course have been written later.[1] "Io son venuto" is perhaps the most immediately impressive of the petrose with its grandiose description of winter and its expression of the speaker's passionate opposition to the cold. It places the entire series of the petrose in relation with a well-known set of topics that goes back at least as far as Virgil's description of the peace of night and the turmoil of the despairing Dido—the tension between the impassioned lover and the rest of nature.[2] Of all the petrose, "Io son venuto" offers the fullest explicit statement of a central theme of the entire group: the relation of the lover's experience to the cosmos as a whole. It has always been recognized that "Io son venuto" is an extraordinary poem, and some of its peculiarities have been identified. It has been observed that there is a parallelism among the stanzas (Dante 1949 149–150), that from stanza to stanza there is a descent along the ladder of creation (Renucci 1958 73; see Boyde 1971 296–298). "Io son venuto" is clearly unique in the insistence with which the parallels are carried out; in other cases the comparison with nature either occupies only part of the poem (as in Arnaut's experiments) or else is not developed systematically (as in "De ramis cadunt folia" and Raimbaut). The grandeur and vividness of Dante's descriptions of winter have elicited much admiration, and Fenzi in particular has demonstrated some of the complexity of the speaker's relation to the season, which is not simply a matter of opposition.[3] But the critical tradition has been essentially oblivious to two major aspects of the poem: (1) the presence of a detailed
parallelism between the cosmos and the human body and (2) the relation of the astronomical opening to the poetics of the poem, and ― 72 ― thus to its themes at levels deeper than the immediately apparent. These aspects of the poem are very closely related, as we shall see. Our analysis of "Io son venuto" will have four parts. First we examine the description of winter in the poem, with its highly elaborate parallelisms and symmetries, and, in a preliminary way, the situation of the speaker in relation to the winter. This will lead to a detailed discussion of the powerful opening of the poem, in which we find the striking suggestion that the astronomical position described is significantly related to the configuration of the planets at Dante's birth. We will thus be led to the third major focus of this chapter, the significance of the theme of birth, which is introduced with such apparent casualness in the third line of the poem and which, we shall argue, refers to the birth of Dante's new poetics. In the last section, we shall return to our reading of the poem, with special emphasis on the theme of the human body.
1 As we suggested in the Introduction, in the petrose Dante conceived of the stanza form of the canzone as imitating the motion of the heavens. "Io son venuto al punto de la rota" seems to be the first poem in which he endeavored to embody that principle fully. The study of Book 3 of Seneca's Natural Questions (see Durling 1975) seems to have played a particularly important role in this experiment. The most important points of connection are (1) the acting out of cyclic recurrences, patterned especially on the motion of the heavens, as a principle of literary structure; (2) the idea that the life cycle of the speaker is an instance of the cyclicality governing the cosmos; (3) the prominence given the concept of the inversion of an astrological position; and (4) the parallel between the human body and the earth, extended by Dante to the rest of the cosmos. The first of these principles of course underlies all of the petrose; so also, to a certain extent, do the others, but they are most explicit in "Io son venuto." We begin with the Senecan theme of the cosmic cycles and with Renucci's observation (1958 73) that the successive stanzas of the poem describe winter in the different realms of nature, mentioned in descending order: the heavens; the atmosphere; birds and animals; plants; earth and water. Thus the poem represents—includes—the cosmos as a whole. The stanzas are rigorously parallel. Each consists of three groups of three lines each (we will call them a, b, c ) devoted to the description ― 73 ― of winter, and a fourth group of four lines (we will call it d ) devoted to the state of the lover; the four parts are parallel from stanza to stanza metrically, syntactically, and thematically.[4] It is not merely that nine lines go to the description of winter; rather, each stanza describes or alludes to one or more cycles proper to the level of nature it describes. Thus (but not exhaustively!): 1 a. the annual cycle of the sun and the daily turning of the sky b, c. the periods of Venus and Saturn 2 a, b, c. the generation of wind and precipitation 3 a. the seasonal migration of certain birds b, c. the seasonal apathy of other birds and animals 4a. the seasonal deciduousness of plants b. evergreens c. the cycle of generation of plants (flowers) 5 a, b, c. the cyclical movement of waters In each stanza, furthermore, there is a clearly discernible parallel pattern in the cycles themselves: 1a. Night rises; the sun sets. b. Venus is veiled and remote. c. Saturn is strong. 2a. The wind rises, b. approaches and clouds the sky.
c. Rain and snow fall. 3 a. Migratory birds have flown away. b. Nonmigratory birds are silent. c. Other animals are apathetic. 4a. Deciduous foliage has fallen. b. Evergreen foliage remains. c. The flowers are dead. 5 a. Earth draws up waters. b. The road is flooded. c. The ground freezes. To take part a first, in 1a there is both a rising and a setting; thereafter rising predominates (except for 4a). In part b, the emphasis is on im― 74 ― mobility. In parts 1c and 5c the emphasis is on the increasing immobility of things, but in 2c, 3c, and 4c the motion is downward. Thus, although Dante has avoided a monotonous identity of pattern, the description of winter in each stanza follows a similar pattern: (a) upward motion; (b) motionlessness or ineffectiveness of what is above; (c) descent. This pattern is that of a half-cycle, closely related to Dante's conception of the "arc of life," which Bruno Nardi showed to be parallel to the presence of the sun above the horizon and its nightly disappearance.[5] it can hardly escape notice that, just as the successive stanzas concern progressively lower realms of nature, so the high and low points of each stanza are lower and lower as we move through the poem. Starting with the heavens, our eye moves in a descending series of half-circles that implies a descending spiral. In view of the explicit theme of the poem, the explanation is not far to seek: the pattern of the parallel stanzas is an imitation of the gradually descending path of the sun as it nears the winter solstice; each day the sun rises a little later and a little farther to the south, crosses the meridian at noon a little lower in the sky, and sets a little earlier and, again, farther to the south. The last stanza introduces one of the important "scientific" notions we discussed in the Introduction, the idea that when it has been frozen for a sufficiently long time, ice turns to crystal: la terra fa un suol che par di smalto, e l'acqua morta si converte in vetro per la freddura che di fuor la serra . . .
Used of the landscape that surrounds the speaker, which we of course understand to be Italian, probably Florentine, these terms are hyperbolic or metaphorical, for crystal was supposed to be formed in the far north or perhaps in the Alps; but the reference to the doctrine is clear. Common to the passages on the formation of crystal and other stones is the idea that cold is a form of pressure exerted on things: a compound becomes stone when the cold has, as it were, squeezed out all the air (Seneca) or moisture (Albertus); Dante has "la freddura che di fuor la serra." In this context of ideas, the descending spiral of the sun, by which the cold increases, is like the turning of a great press, gradually increasing its enormous pressure to cause the compression and hardening of the waters in the last stanza.[6] The descent through nature of the five stanzas of the poem thus involves something much more interesting than a static hierarchical rela― 75 ― tion or the mechanical following out of a topos. The gradual increase in pressure from stanza to stanza derives from a carefully controlled set of gradations. For instance, the descent through the successive realms of the cosmos, since it is a movement from the outer spheres toward the center, is a movement into ever greater enclosure: the heavens enclose the whole; the atmosphere encloses the earth; the birds live in the air but animals on the ground; and so on. Particularly in the first two stanzas, the idea of enclosure is given great prominence. Now in describing the effect of winter in successively lower realms, the poem is imitating the pouring down into the sublunary of the influence of the heavenly bodies, especially, as we have seen, that of Capricorn, Saturn, and Mars. This is true both of the sequence of the five stanzas and of the structure of each stanza in itself; for in each stanza what we might call an upper part (a, b, and c ) concerns the heavens or the product of their influence, and a lower
part (d ) concerns the lover on whom all these influences are impinging. This is not merely a thematic imitation, as we have seen: the daily rotation of the heavens, which brings the sun closer and closer to solstice as it moves along the ecliptic, is imitated in the repetitive cyclic structure of the upper part of each stanza. One formal peculiarity of the stanzas is particularly interesting, the relation of the change in subject matter to the diesis, the change of "melody" of the stanza. Formally, the relation of part d, where the state of the lover is introduced, to the rest of the stanza is somewhat anomalous. In the terminology of the De vulgari eloquentia, parts a and b constitute the two pedes of the stanza, consisting of six hendecasyllables rhyming ABC.ABC; parts c and d are the sirma with concatenatio, rhyming CDEeDFF ; all but one line are hendecasyllables (line 10 is a settenario). The anomaly consists in the fact that although the diesis—the major formal division of the stanza—occurs after line 6, it is only in part d, at line 10, that the topic of the speaker's opposition to the rest of nature, which is the major shift in subject matter, is brought in. In other words, there is a dissonance between the formal and the logical organization of the stanza, since one would expect the topic to change at the beginning of the sirma. The winter encroaches, as it were, on the sirma, comes down into it.[7] This invasion of the sirma by the winter is a formal correlative of the theme of the invasion of the poet's spirit. But part d is introduced by the one settenario in the stanza, and the shortness of that settenario, ― 76 ― along with the fact that it rhymes with the immediately preceding line, and especially the emphasis with which the speaker's solitary opposition to the cold is introduced, give the turn to part d very much the feeling of the diesis, the major turn, of a stanza. The speaker achieves, as it were, only a delayed diesis, or a subdiesis; yet it is a powerful one.[8] As we said in the Introduction, Dante's new poetics involves a certain self-division. "Io son venuto" is a particularly clear case of this: in the first part of each stanza, in order to represent the forces that seem arrayed against him, the poet must identify himself with them, he must imitate them; and he does so, as one might say, icastically—that is, by means of visual representations—and, equally important, by enacting analogous motions and cycles. Then in each stanza the other pole of the lover's struggle with the season comes into focus. At the solstice, all things may seem to come to frozen immobility in a way that mirrors the paired impasse between the lover and the lady. But the rigidity of winter is only temporary; further rotation of the heavenly wheel will eventually bring spring. As a matter of fact, as Dante knew, it is in Sagittarius and Capricorn that the sun seems to move fastest along the ecliptic.[9] By symbolically acting out the descent to solstice, the poem seeks to move the lady past the solstice of her rejection, to turn her toward springtime. "Io son venuto" represents the first half of a pattern of descent followed by ascent—katabasis followed by anabasis—that will be more fully explored in "Così nel mio parlar voglio esser aspro." One of the most important aspects of the poet's opposition to the season is of course his writing of the poem itself. Part d of the first four stanzas and of the congedo represents love as a burden that the lover cannot cast off despite the season:
Stanza 1
e però non disgombra un sol penser d'amor, ond'io son carco, la mente mia . . . (10–12)
Stanza 2
e Amor . . . non m'abbandona . . . (23, 25)
Stanza 3
e 'l mio [spirito] più d'amor porta, ché li dolzi pensier' non mi son tolti né mi son dati per volta di tempo (36–38)
― 77 ―
Stanza 4
e la crudele spina però Amor di cor non la mi tragge; per ch'io son fermo di portarla sempre . . . (49–51)
Congedo
amore é solo in me e non altrove . . . (70)
Insofar as "Io son venuto" is dominated by the idea of winter, it explores, of the two motions of the heavens (those of the Same and the Other), the effects specifically due to the motion of the Other. Each stanza brings not only the description of the effects of cold as such, but also explicit references to the annual cycle of the sun and the revolutions of the other planets. The motion of the Other is opposed by the motion of the Same, which carries the entire heavens with it and produces the diurnal cycle of day and night. The poem powerfully exploits the juxtaposition of these two principles. For instance, in stanza 1, sunset and the rising of stars are phenomena caused by the diurnal turning of the heavens (i.e., the motion of the Same); the presence of Gemini in the night sky and the positions of Venus and the sun in Capricorn and of Saturn on the Tropic result from the diverse motions of the Other. In stanza 3, the striking reference to the seven gelid stars' also refers to the diurnal motion of the Same. Particularly interesting is the third stanza, where the independence of the poet's love from the turning of time is contrasted with the silence of birds and animals: Fuggito è ogne augel che 'l caldo segue del paese d'Europa, che non perde le sette stelle gelide unquemai . . . (27–29)
The migration of birds is contrasted with the fixity of the northern stars, those of the Great Bear, which are never lost, never set, over Europe. Such lesser species as migrant birds may escape the cold, but not the lover: he is fixed. The sphere of the fixed stars, in its daily turning, is kept before us in this reminder that the northern stars (unlike the sun of stanza 1) never set. At the center of the poem, then, we are presented with the fixed axis of the cosmos, just as in the outermost stanzas we see (in stanza 1) the ecliptic and the Tropic and (in stanza 5) the center of the earth, the other extreme. ― 78 ― e li altri han posto a le lor voce triegue per non sonarle infino al tempo verde se ciò non fosse per cagion di guai; e tutti li animali che son gai di lor natura, son d'amor disciolti, però che 'l freddo lor spiriti ammorta: e 'l mio più d'amor porta . . . (30–36)
The stanza is carefully gradated: from the (evasive) activity of migrant birds, to the silence of the remaining birds, to the extinguishing of the fiery spirit in the other animals. The terms apply, per antithesin, to the poet: the poet's love is not extinguished, his burden is increased; he does not flee but stays with the cold stars; there is no truce (triegua ) for him (cf. guerra in the next stanza). And—most important—he is not silent: that is, he is singing— writing the poem. Thus, the central stanza of the poem correlates love as a burden, the turning of the sky, and the poet's song—contrasted with the (absent) songs of the birds. Closely following on "e 'l mio più d'amor porta" comes the parallel (it is implicit, but strongly operative nonetheless, and it, too, is based on troubadour tradition)[10] between the poet's song and the blossoming of the world in the springtime: Passato hanno lor termine le fronde che trasse fuor la virtù d'Arïete . . . (40–41)
We have already discussed the correlation of the cycles of this stanza with the larger cycles of the speaker's life (and death). What concerns us here is the contrast/parallel between the birth of the leaves and flowers "che trasse fuor la virtù d'Arïete" and the poem itself; for it is in part the virtù di Capricorno (or of Saturn in Gemini) that is drawing forth the
new poetry. The explicit parallel in this stanza is between the foliage and the spina, the thorn of love; equally important is the implicit parallel between the foliage and the poem: the poet is now bringing forth, in this winter, more than the perhaps facile poetics of spring formerly allowed him to do. The writing of the poem itself, then, is one of the most important forms of the speaker's opposition to the universal cold. Both as lover and as poet he is the same in winter as in the other seasons. As Plato had said, and as the tradition agreed, the principle of identity is superior to ― 79 ― the principle of diversity, is in fact its source. The emphasis on the sameness of the speaker's love identifies him with the superior principle, and stanzas 3 and 4 explicitly refer to the speaker's superiority to time— ché li dolzi pensier' non mi son tolti né mi son dati per volta di tempo (37–38)
and to the possibility of immortality— per ch'io son fermo di portarla sempre ch'io sarò in vita, s'io vivesse sempre. (51–52)
In "Io son venuto," then, the poet's effort to confront the complexities of his nature and to represent them in their cosmic context is a struggle to achieve identification with the Same. Of course, the problem is not simple, for to the extent that the speaker's love is an expression of the influence of Saturn and other planets, it results from the motion of the Other, not that of the Same. Furthermore, passion and sexual desire almost by definition resist the higher principle of identity—rationality.[11] The issue is whether or not a synthesis is possible. But now we must examine the astrology of the poem.
2 The opening of "Io son venuto al punto de la rota" is well known as the first astronomical description in Dante's poetry: Io son venuto al punto de la rota che l'orizzonte, quando il sol si corca, ci partorisce il geminato cielo, e la stella d'amor ci sta remota per Io raggio lucente che la 'nforca sì di traverso che le si fa velo; e quel pianeta che conforta il gelo si mostra tutto a noi per lo grand'arco nel qual ciascun di sette fa poco ombra. (1–9) I have come to the point of the wheel where the horizon gives birth at sunset to the twinned heaven, and the star of love is kept from us by the sun's ray that straddles her so transversely that she is veiled;
― 80 ― and that planet that strengthens the frost shows itself to us entirely, along the great arc where each of the seven casts little shadow . . .
Since astronomical positions involving three or more planets do not repeat themselves more than once every few hundred years, students of Dante realized early in this century that this description might permit the poem to be dated.[12] Clearly the first three lines mean that when the sun sets, the sign (or constellation) of Gemini rises or becomes visible in the eastern sky. This places the date somewhere near the winter solstice, when the sun enters Capricorn (in Dante's time this occurred around December 14). Venus is said to be remote from us because of being "forked" or "straddled" by the rays of the sun, which must refer to a conjunction of Venus and the sun. One might suppose that the joining of the rays of Venus and the sun would strengthen the star of love, but the power of the sun is determined by the sign of the zodiac it is passing through, and it is midwinter. (Once the sun has set, of course, Venus, too, is below the horizon and so "remota" for this reason, too.)[13] The "planet that strengthens the frost" is almost certainly Saturn. Whether the moon or Saturn,[14] it would have to be opposite the sun, or nearly so, in order to "show itself entirely
to us along the great arc where each of the seven makes little shadow." The "great arc" must be the Tropic of Cancer, for in the winter night sky a planet at or near the Tropic of Cancer is at greatest visibility, rising early in the evening and crossing the meridian at or near its greatest possible angle above the horizon (at the latitude of Florence, a planet on the Tropic crosses the meridian 691/2 degrees above the horizon).[15] Saturn is much more likely than the moon for several reasons. Most important, Dante is surely describing a particularly hard winter with a long period of cold weather, not merely a brief cold spell depending on a phase of the moon. Further, the moon makes the complete circle of the heavens every month, while Saturn, the slowest of the planets, takes almost thirty years to complete its circle around the zodiac, and its positions are therefore much more unusual. The full context of the poem, as we shall see, is full of references to Saturn. We have, then, Venus and the sun in conjunction in or near Capricorn, and Saturn somewhere near the Tropic of Cancer. The precision of this description is indeed sufficient to date it: only once in Dante's lifetime did such a configuration occur—in December 1296. The exact date of the conjunction of Venus and the sun was December 24. So ― 81 ― much is generally agreed. Actually, the description implies a complete horoscope, and it is surprising that no one seems to have considered the possibility that Dante might have known and had in mind the positions of the other planets. And what exactly was the position of Saturn? Figure 2 shows the positions of all the planets on December 24, 1296, as seen from Florence an hour after sunset.[16] Several aspects of this configuration strike one immediately. First is the prominence held by Mars along with Saturn. Both in the eastern sky
[Full Size] Fig. 2. Florence, December 24, 1296, 5:30 P.M. ― 82 ―
at sunset, they will dominate the sky all night long. The very fact that Mars is in Taurus, a house of Venus, would signify to the astrologically minded a love beset by conflict.[17] Mars in Taurus is closely related to the basic conception of the entire series of the petrose; once alerted by the actual astronomical position, we may notice many references to the god of war. Furthermore, both Saturn and Mars are retrograde, that is, they seem to be moving backward on the ecliptic (toward the west rather than the east),[18] a motion that was thought to weaken the influence of beneficent planets but to be particularly threatening in the case of the malefic Mars and Saturn. One notes, furthermore, that except for Mars and Saturn all the planets, not only the sun and Venus (explicitly placed by the poem), are below the horizon, and their positive influence is therefore seriously weakened.[19] The night belongs entirely to Mars and Saturn. Finally, Jupiter, Mercury, and Venus are closely grouped around the sun, a configuration that in another sign would probably be thought extremely beneficent. As readers versed in astrology would recognize, stanzas 2–5 of "Io son venuto" refer to events that are not only characteristic of winter but were thought to be due to the influence of Saturn, the father and destroyer of all earthly beings, who presides over the sowing of crops and the reproduction of animals (including man) in his benign phase and determines their senescence and death in his harmful one. As the outermost planet, Saturn sets the limits of all things (cf. termine, line 40). The coldest and slowest of the planets, Saturn is associated with earth, water, and lead; he governs rain (stanza 2) and floods (stanza 5) and is particularly likely to cause both when on the cusp between two signs—as in December 1296. It is this planet's influence that causes human beings to be lustful.[20] The poem is filled with references to the lore of Saturn's influence on both mind and body. The themes—basic to the poem—of the paradoxical combination in the lover of cold and fire and of his hardness and tenacity of mind are traditionally associated with Saturn.[21] The references to the earth, to flood, to water and air trapped under ground, derive from the lore of melancholic sexuality and the influence of Saturn, for the slow steadiness of Saturn was supposed to influence the strong vital spirits of the melancholic, who were thought to be particularly subject to lust because of the large amount of air combined with blood in their sperm. The related association of orgasm with the eruption of underground waters mixed with vapors, which we find in stanza 5, derives from Aristotelian physiology.[22] ― 83 ― The position of Saturn in Figure 2 requires further comment. It is indeed near the Tropic of Cancer; it has just entered Gemini, Dante's natal sign, on the very day of the conjunction of Venus and the sun. To appreciate how unusual and how meaningful this event may have seemed to Dante, one must consider that the slowness of Saturn means that it lingers for a long time in each sign of the zodiac, but also that once it has left a sign it does not return for almost thirty years. The presence of Saturn in Dante's natal sign was no doubt of great significance in his eyes, and the horoscope of December 24, 1296, on this ground alone, would seem to have a special relation to his natal horoscope. But before turning in this direction, we need to substantiate more fully our claim that Dante's natal horoscope is relevant to "Io son venuto." First of all, as we have seen, the poem refers directly both to the idea of birth and to what we know Dante claimed was his natal sign, Gemini. Critics seem not to have paid much attention to the odd fact that, although there is no question that the "wheel" of the first line is, among other things, the zodiac, Dante says that he, rather than the sun, has reached the point of the wheel: Io son venuto al punto de la rota che l'orizzonte, quando il sol si corca, ci partorisce il geminato cielo
There is an implicit reference to the traditional notion of the wheel of Fortune, whose iconography portrayed individuals carried on the wheel as if fixed to it,[23] traditionally associated with the turning of the heavens and thus with time. If we take the wheel as referring to the heavens themselves (one of its main references), at which point on the wheel are we to place the speaker? Perhaps near the sun—an important suggestion of the lines, however, is that the horizon is giving birth not only to Gemini, but also in some sense to Dante himself. It may also seem odd that Dante identifies the season by the sign in or near which night, not the sun, is rising.[24] This is actually one of the keys to the poem as a whole: the reference is inverted. Inversion is a major idea governing the entire poem, which begins with allusion to birth and ends with allusion to death. At another level, the poem ends with the mention of
orgasm, which initiates gestation, and in a line that refers to Dante's natal sign, begins with birth, which ends gestation. In embodying cold instead of the warmth that is natural to her youth, the lady is herself one of the most important instances of inversion. But the most explicit reference to the idea appears in the congedo, where the ― 84 ― astrological situation of the winter is imagined as reversed: in the springtime, instead of cold, warmth rains down from all the heavens: but that is the season of Dante's birth. In the analogy between the year and a human life, the winter solstice would correspond to death. If in the macrocosm Saturn, Mars, and Capricorn cause an unusually severe winter with heavy flooding, for the microcosm of the speaker they might produce a cataclysm. Thus the solstitial inversion, the speaker's resistance to the season, the unnaturalness of a lady stony in youth, the analogy of the year and the life cycle—these themes are parallel to the idea of death as an inversion of birth. Now Saturn, the planet that sets the limits for all things, including the moment of their death, is, as Manilius points out, the planet governing inversions: his locus is the imum coeli because he has been cast down from his former eminence.[25] And of course the feast of Saturn, the Saturnalia, took place just before the winter solstice, as Dante could have known from Macrobius.[26] All the systems of inversion in "Io son venuto," then, including the insistent syntactic inversion, require us to see the astrological situation it describes as an inversion of the situation at Dante's birth. In considering what idea Dante may have had of his natal horoscope there is naturally a large element of uncertainty. In Paradiso 22, in a passage we will consider in the next section, he says that he was born with the sun in Gemini; according to Boccaccio's testimony, which there is no real reason to doubt, Dante told a Ravenna friend shortly before his death that he had been born in the month of May.[27] It is reasonable to conclude that Dante's birthday fell— or that he supposed (or even pretended) that it fell—between May 14, 1265 (when the sun entered Gemini), and the end of the month.[28] But there is no way of determining more closely on what day or at what time of day he was born.[29] This means that we cannot know the position of the moon or the ascendant, both of which were considered of major significance in any horoscope. We do not know whether Dante knew the actual positions of the planets at his birth (though the combined evidence, we believe, strongly suggests that he did: it was common for well-to-do families to have horoscopes cast for the newborn; or Dante may have cast his own horoscope retrospectively, using such an almanac as the one by Prophatius, which he probably used for the Commedia ).[30] It might seem otiose to consider the question, except for one further important fact: leaving the moon out of consideration, during the time when the sun was passing through Gemini in May 1265, the positions of ― 85 ― the other planets changed very little because the faster-moving planets, Mercury and Venus, were alternating between direct and retrograde motion (Mercury, for instance, remained for the entire period within the limits of 70.15 and 63.38 degrees longitude).[31] Thus, although the ascendant, and therefore the positions of the planets in the various hour-houses of Dante's natal horoscope, cannot be known, much else can be. If the theme of astronomical inversion in "Io son venuto" invites us to consider whether December 1296 is an inversion of the position of Dante's natal horoscope, we already know the most conspicuous element of that inversion, the position of the sun: in December 1296, near winter solstice; in May 1265, something more than half a sign away from summer solstice (this is the "altro / dolce tempo novello," when love rains down from all the heavens). The inversion would be more complete if Dante's horoscope were cast for dawn or shortly after (as opposed to sunset in "Io son venuto"). Are there other elements of inversion? We give two charts for the latter part of May, as seen from Florence an hour after sunrise (the hour is chosen for its symmetry with that in "Io son venuto"). The choice of dates is not entirely arbitrary: Dante arrives in Gemini in Paradiso 22; he leaves it in Paradiso 27. We find it plausible that the numbers are significant; in other words, we suspect that Dante's birthday falls on May 22 or 27, or else in between. Figure 3 gives positions for May 22, 1265; Figure 4 for May 27, 1265. We incline toward May 27 as the date Dante knew or supposed to be his birthday,[32] but in any case both charts are offered as examples only. What is most striking about the configuration in both charts (and this aspect changed virtually not at all during the entire period from May 14 to June 14) is that Saturn is in
Gemini, not far from its position in December 1296; but in 1265 it is close to conjunction with the sun, whereas in 1296 it is in opposition to it. It must be stressed that the positions of Saturn recur at large intervals: during Dante's entire lifetime Saturn was in Gemini during only two periods, 1265–67 and 1294–96,[33] a fact that is surely most significant for the interpretation of "Io son venuto." On May 27, 1265 (Figure 4), not only is Saturn close to conjunction with the sun, but it is also in conjunction with Mercury (in Gemini, the night house of Mercury) and in orbal conjunction with Jupiter in Taurus (and Jupiter is close to orbal conjunction with the 1266 position of Venus, if Dante made his Prophatius mistake here), whereas in December 1296 the sun is in a house of Saturn and in ― 86 ―
[Full Size] Fig. 3. Florence, May 22, 1265, 6:15 A.M.
[Full Size] Fig. 4. Florence, May 27, 1265, 6:00 A.M. ― 87 ―
conjunction with Venus, Mercury, and Jupiter, and all four are in opposition to Saturn. In both 1265 charts, the possible harmful influence of Saturn is strongly counteracted by the conjunction (or near conjunction) with a whole group of beneficent planets in strong phases, but in 1296 the beneficent planets are canceled out and the harmful ones unusually strengthened. In the relation between December 1296 and May 1265, then, we find a whole system of astrological inversion involving Saturn, the very planet of inversion;[34] the inversion is especially pronounced if May 27 is taken as the contrast, but it is still very much in evidence on May 22, or indeed on any Gemini chart for 1265.[35] Seen in relation to Dante's natal horoscope, "Io son venuto" represents something much more serious than merely an unusually severe winter. Dante would have been on very firm ground in interpreting December 1296 as extremely threatening for a Gemini of 1265.[36] The poet's war with the stars is a very real one, then, and we begin to have some insight into the prominence of Mars in the horoscope. It is particularly striking to find that Mars was retrograde[37] in December 1296; the fact provides a major confirmation of the traditional dating of the poem, because the climactic expression of the poet's determination, in stanza 5, unmistakably refers to it: "e io de la mia guerra / non son tomato un passo a retro." [38] There could hardly be a more emphatic way of differentiating the poet from the astrological influences that threaten him: though the very planet of war may turn back—retrograde—with whatever defeat or weakening that event may seem to promise, the lover will not do so. His love does not derive from the turnings of time and will not be defeated by them. But other important aspects of Dante's natal horoscope have a close relation with the horoscope of December, especially the prominence of both the planet Mercury and his "house," the sign Gemini. Dante probably considered Mercury the "lord" of his horoscope, that is, the most dominant influence, sufficiently so for him to consider himself a "child" of the planet (see Hauber 1916). Since we do not know what he thought his ascendant to be or the position of his moon, we cannot be completely sure,[39] but he clearly ascribed major importance to the influence of Gemini, both in this poem and in Paradiso 22.[40] Gemini is one of the two houses of Mercury, in which the planet was said to "rejoice"— the other being Virgo.[41] These two signs have the distinction of being the only ones that represent human beings rather than animals or objects. This fact was traditionally interpreted to mean ― 88 ― that the natives of these two signs are particularly suited for the intellectual professions,[42] and the children of Mercury were well known as scholars, writers, and interpreters.[43] As Benvenuto da Imola says, Gemini "facit homines literatos et ingeniosos" ("makes people learned and clever"—cited by Sapegno ad Paradiso 22). The Twins of Gemini were variously identified in antiquity.[44] In the most common view they are the mythical Castor and Pollux, sons of Leda, the former by Leda's mortal husband, Tyndareus, the latter by Jupiter. As Dante knew, Castor and Pollux were among the deities most popular in ancient Rome and had a close relation to Mars, the patron of Rome's founding; they were thought to appear in battle to help Rome, and their myth is of course inherently warlike.[45] Dante would have found references to them in the works of countless writers.[46] For him, the myth is connected with such major concerns, both moral and poetic, as the duality of human nature, the need for inner struggle, and the problematic of interpretation. In terms of the Commedia, of course, a pair of twins, one of whom gives up part of his immortality to save his mortal brother, is obviously the antitype of the fratricidal twins of the Earthly City (Romulus and Remus, Eteocles and Polynices),[47] children of the baleful influence of Mars.[48] The astrological importance of Gemini, as well as the importance of Mercury as the patron of learning and literary creation, can be seen in a favorite medieval schoolbook, Martianus Capella's De nuptiis Mercurii et Philologiae, which relates that the seven liberal arts were Mercury's wedding gift to his bride Philologia ("love of learning").[49] The De nuptiis claims a continuity among the arts of language, the knowledge of the cosmos, and the Neoplatonic ascent to the ultimate Truth, a continuity expressed in two allegorical journeys (Mercury's and his bride's) from the world of sense—represented with elaborate cosmological symbolism—to the beyond. Martianus's sprightly book had enormous influence; it furnished the basic outline of the trivium and quadrivium in the schools of the Middle Ages and inspired such allegorical works as Bernard Silvester's Cosmographia and Alain of Lille's De planctu Naturae and Anticlaudianus. Although the astrological as such is veiled in the De nuptiis, it is
quite important,[50] and one striking passage clearly alludes to the conjunction of the sun and Mercury in Gemini at dawn (i.e., at the ascendant) in such a way as to suggest a horoscope.[51] The particular appropriateness of Gemini is explained by Bernard Silvester, in his commentary on the De nuptiis, [52] on the basis of an interpretation of the ― 89 ― myth of Castor and Pollux that treats them as representing body and spirit—parallel, in Bernard's view, to the relation between language (Philologia, originally mortal) and reason (Mercury)—thus an instance of the union of opposites in which the cosmic harmony consists.[53] Commenting on a line from the opening hymn to Hymen, "complexuque sacro dissona nexa foves," he writes: nexa, id est iuncta, complexu, proportione, sacro quia, ad tempus, divinum mortali ut, in eternum, mortale iungatur divino; quod tibi illud de Castore et Polluce apte figurat. Pollux enim "perditio," Castor vero "extremum malum" interpretatur. "Perditio" dicitur spiritus humanus quia sicut semina terre mandata primo moriuntur ut post modum vivant, sic anima corpori iuncta. Corpus autem "extremum malum" dicitur quia, ut super Virgilium diximus, partientibus anime quod est nil inferius humano corpore occurrit. . . . Et Pollux quidem dicitur deus quia est spiritus substantia rationalis et immortalis, Castor mortalis quia corpus substantia hebes et dissolubilis. Deus mortalem mortem recipit ut suam deitatem ei conferat, quia spiritus ad tempus moritur ut corpus in eternum vivat. (Wetherbee 1972 267–268; Westra 1986 69) Joined by a sacred bond; that is, united by proportion; for divine is united with mortal in temporal life just as mortal is united with divine in eternity. This is aptly illustrated by the story of Pollux and Castor. For Pollux means "perdition" and Castor "utmost evil." The human spirit is called "perdition" because, just as seeds consigned to the earth first die that they may later come to life, so does the soul when united with the body. And the body is called "utmost evil" because, as I explained in glossing Virgil, those who have classified all existence have encountered nothing lower than body. . . . And Pollux is called a god because spirit is a rational and immortal substance, while Castor is mortal because body is a substance weak and subject to decay. The god undergoes mortal death so as to confer his deity on him; for spirit dies temporally that the body may live eternally. (Wetherbee 1972 114–115; translation slightly altered)
In another part of his commentary, Bernard again treats the myth as an instance of the reconciliation of divergent principles, identifying Pollux as the contemplative life, Castor the active life (saved from the degradation of pleasure by the other's vision).[54] As we shall see, Dante's treatment of the Twins as a main symbol of human duality, both sides of which must be preserved, is interestingly close to Bernard's.[55] In strictly astronomical terms, Dante would have found that Gemini ― 90 ―
[Full Size] Fig. 5. Montpellier, April 8, 1300, 6:15 A.M. ( See discussion on p. 364 n. 63. ) possessed a number of peculiarities. As he read in al-Fargani's epitome of Ptolemy's Almagest, of the fifteen brightest stars in the sky, no fewer than four are associated with (i.e., rise and set with) Gemini: Capella, Betelgeuse, Rigel, and, the brightest of all, Sirius.[56] As Martianus Capella, Macrobius, and Calcidius all point out, Gemini is the sign where the sun dwells longest (thirty-two days, as opposed to the average ― 91 ― thirty),[57] and it is the only sign in which there can ordinarily be two successive new moons (as Macrobius puts it, where the moon can be born twice).[58] Manilius observes that three zodiacal signs rise backwards or upside down: the successive signs Taurus, Gemini, and Cancer.[59] The Twins appear feet first above the horizon, a fact with a clear relation to the two major themes of "Io son venuto": inversion (of astrological influences, of negative into positive) and birth. Another peculiarity of the constellation Gemini is that it lies in the portion of the zodiac that crosses the Milky Way. The Twins' feet, along with the horns of the Bull, extend into one of the most thickly populated parts of the galaxy. On the opposite side, Sagittarius and Scorpio mark the other crossing of the galaxy.[60] These, according to Martianus Capella's Astronomia (8.817), are two of the ten circles one must learn to distinguish in the sky, the others being the colures of the Equinoxes and Tropics; the parallels marking the Arctic, Antarctic, temperate, and tropical zones; and the equator. On a clear night Gemini is a magnificent spectacle, close to the Milky Way and accompanied by the bright stars of Taurus, Orion, and Canis Major. Thus the scene described in the first stanza of "Io son venuto" is one of extraordinary grandeur. The prominence of Mercury and Gemini in Dante's natal horoscope, then, casts a different light on the prominence of Saturn. As the patron of science and meditation, Saturn can have an exceptionally strong positive influence.[61] The conjunction or near conjunction of Saturn and Mercury in the night house of Mercury (our example shows conjunction, but it is
only a guess), of course, would be especially appropriate for a philosophical poet. But it is clear that "Io son venuto al punto de la rota" represents Dante's effort to identify himself with the positive side of Saturn's, Mars's, and Mercury's influence—favoring moral struggle, philosophy and science, and the creation of poetry—as against the dangerous negative side.[62] These aspects of his stars will enable him, he hopes, to confront and master what in both astrological and emotional terms is the most threatening situation of his lifetime, and to make it the occasion of growth and development.[63]
3 The full significance of the topos of birth in "Io son venuto" only emerges when it is viewed in connection with the Commedia, especially the Paradiso. Birth is one of its basic patterns (see below, pages 255– ― 92 ― 258). "Io son venuto" is involved in the passage that tells us Dante considered himself a Gemini: S'io torni mai, lettore, a quel divoto triunfo per lo quale io piango spesso le mie peccata e 'l petto mi percuoto, tu non avresti in tanto tratto e messo nel foco il dito, in quant'io vidi 'l segno che segue il Tauro e fui dentro da esso. O gloriose stelle, o lume pregno di gran virtù, dal quale io riconosco tutto, qual che si sia, il mio ingegno, con voi nasceva e s'ascondeva vosco quelli ch'è padre d'ogne mortal vita, quand'io senti' di prima l'aere tosco; e poi, quando mi fu grazia largita d'entrar ne l'alta rota che vi gira, la vostra region mi fu sortita. A voi divotamente ora sospira l'anima mia, per acquistar virtute al passo forte che a sé la tira. ( Paradiso 22.106–123; emphasis added)
In his ascent through the heavenly spheres, Dante reaches the sphere of the fixed stars (to sojourn there for six cantos and perhaps six and a half hours)[64] from the sphere of Saturn—from the planet itself, in fact, whose location has been indicated fairly precisely ("sotto il petto del Leone ardente," Paradiso 21.3; i.e., somewhere near the star Regulus, known as the "heart of the Lion," cor leonis ). But Dante does not tell us to which degree of Gemini he comes, nor which of its stars he may be near.[65] Dante recognizes, he says, that all of his ingegno comes from these stars: O gloriose stelle, o lume pregno di gran virtù, dal quale io riconosco tutto, qual che si sia, il mio ingegno
Modern commentators sometimes express surprise that Dante attributes so much of his talent to the influence of his stars.[66] We should regard the lines as an important indication of the extent to which Dante regarded his ingegno as something bodily —not intellectual in the strictest sense but involving faculties that both Aquinas and Dante identify as subject ― 93 ― to planetary influences (see Introduction, pp. 43–45) and that were generally agreed to be produced originally under the power of the heavenly bodies—and (a closely related, extremely technical point) as depending on the nature of his sensitive soul as it developed in the womb under the influence of the heavens, before his intellect, properly speaking, was infused.[67] Since the passage in Paradiso 22 is explicitly about Dante's birth, his use there of such terms as pregno and nasceva has occasioned no surprise. But they deserve attention, even if in both Latin and medieval Italian nasci/nascere for the rising of a star or planet is extremely common. Dante says he owes his ingegno to the " lume pregno/ di gran virtù " of these stars: but in what sense is the light pregnant? Obviously it was pregnant with the ingegno Dante says he owes to it, in that the simple light of each heavenly body in some sense contains the diversity of the forms it imposes on the sublunar.[68] Dante's ingegno , however, is not fully formed at the time of his birth. As Beatrice points out in Purgatorio 30, it was present in him
virtualmente , potentially; the seed was planted and must be cultivated. In this sense, then, Dante was himself pregnant with his ingegno until it fully emerged. There is thus a parallel between his condition at birth and the "lume pregno di gran virtù." The passage draws a further parallel with the sun, which, as we saw in the Introduction, is the most frequently cited instance of a lux simplex virtually containing a multiplicity of forms: con voi nasceva e s'ascondeva vosco quelli ch'è padre d'ogne mortal vita.
Dante was being born literally, the sun figuratively. It is of course the combined influence of sun and sign that Dante here recognizes as the source of his ingegno . The term riconosco is significant: in acknowledging that he owes his nature to his stars, Dante gives his stars praise that might seem due to himself. Thus the passage is closely related to the discussion in Paradiso 4 of Plato's doctrine that souls return to their stars after dath: Quel che Timeo de l'anime argomenta non è simile a ciò che qui si vede, Però che, come dice, par che senta. Dice che l'alma a la sua stella riede, credendo qualla quindi esser decisa quando natura per forma la diede;
― 94 ― e forse la sua sentenza è d'altra guisa che la voce non sona, ed esser puote con intenzion da non esser derisa. S'egli intende tornare a queste rote l'onor de l'influenza e 'l biasmo, forse in alcun vero il suo arco percuote. (Paradiso 4.49–60; emphasis added)
Beatrice's clarification here is quite precise: nature, in which the influence of the heavens is predominant, gave the soul to be the form of the body.[69] An important aspect of the passage is its function as invocation: A voi divotamente ora sospira l'anima mia, per acquistar virtute al passo forte che a sé la tira[70]
—here poetic composition is explicitly said to depend on the influence of the stars. Dante represents himself as sighing—yearning—toward Gemini in order to acquire poetic power, virtute. He would seem to have to open himself to their influence, submit himself to it. Thus the relevance of Dante's invocation is not restricted to its appropriateness to his visiting his natal sign: the sphere of the fixed stars is the first agency of the diversification of God's creative power, since the undifferentiated Primum Mobile, just above it, transmits God's power simply.[71] In the context of this theme, Dante's relation to his natal sign is significant as the one example brought before us of the fact that, since all creation serves man,[72] the diversification of human bodies and ingegni is the single most important function of the sphere of the fixed stars.[73] There Dante meets Adam, the first father of the multitude of men; the meeting with the Apostles, the first fathers of the Church (that is, of spiritual men), reflects the same principle.[74] The movement to generality of causes that governs the entire cantica involves the clear association of higher causes with higher heavens. In terms of his conception of the cosmos, then, Dante's contemplative ascent to origins is an ascent to more and more general themes, indeed, to the theme of general causality itself, and it requires him to place himself in rapport with higher and higher heavenly bodies—to open himself to their influence. And as he does so he enacts ever fuller metaphors of the poetic process, in particular the one whereby the poet's shaping art is an analog of the workings of the turning heavens.[75] ― 95 ― As the italics are meant to suggest, the entire passage on Gemini from Paradiso 22 is a tissue of allusions to the first stanza of "Io son venuto." Paradiso 22 identifies the sign Gemini with a periphrasis, calling it "il segno / che segue il Tauro" (110–111); so does "Io son venuto," which calls it "il geminato cielo" (3). In Paradiso 22, the metaphor of pregnancy is used of the light of the stars of Gemini ("lume pregno / di gran virtù," 112–113), and that of birth of the sun in Dante's natal sign ("con voi nasceva," 115); in "Io son venuto," the metaphor of birth is used of the rising of Gemini ("l'orizzonte . . . / ci partorisce," 2– 3), and that of pregnancy is implicit in the repeated mention of love as a burden (especially evident in the contrast between the parturition of line 3 and the "non disgombra" of line 10).
Both, moreover, stress the relation of Gemini and the sun to the horizon. "Io son venuto" opens with Dante's arrival at the point of the wheel; Paradiso 22 twice echoes this idea, first in Dante's arrival in the sign/constellation Gemini ("e fui dentro da esso," 111), then, with a conspicuous verbal echo, in commenting on the arrival ("grazia . . . / d'entrar ne l'alta rota che vi gira," lines 118–119);[76] in both cases (in Paradiso 22 explicitly) the arrival implies the beginning of a new phase of poetic activity, and both associate the poet's birth with the inception of the new phase.[77] The emphasis on the horizon in both texts requires comment. The term carries a great deal of symbolic weight. As we have seen, a major focus of the problematic of "Io son venuto" is the paradoxical concomitance of embeddedness in nature—subjection to the power of stars and seasons—and superiority to it. This is the specifically human situation—between time and eternity—on which rests the traditional idea of man as horizon between the two, adapted by Dante in the Monarchia to the horizon between incorruptible and corruptible.[78] As we saw in Chapter 1, Dante's treatment of Beatrice in "Donne ch'avete intelletto d'amore," in which he places the stanza on her soul between those on heaven and her body, is an instance of the idea that human beings are the medietas, or nexus of unification, of the entire cosmos, which the metaphor of man as horizon expresses. It is clear not only that the term orizzonte in "Io son venuto" refers at one level to the poet himself, but also that "l'orizzonte . . . ci partorisce il geminato cielo" means that whatever is meant by il geminato cielo is coming into being at the place where the two aspects of his human nature are joined—or, in the terminology of Inferno 12.84, where the two natures are married, "dove le due nature son consorti." But that place is precisely the locus of poetic ingegno. As Dante's use of the terminology of marriage (consorti ) in Inferno 12 ― 96 ― may suggest, the locus of poetic ingegno, the place where the two sides of his nature are joined, is also the locus of his sexuality. The problematics of love and desire on the one hand and of poetic creation on the other are inextricable, after a certain point indistinguishable. Thus, if the topos of birth in "Io son venuto" refers not only to Dante's literal birth but also to the birth of his new poetics, to the coming to maturity of his poetic ingegno, this theme does not in any way diminish the importance of the other themes, least of all that of his literal birth. Far from it, for the new poetics is represented as Dante's response to a situation in which both external and internal causes threaten his life. The difficulty of his love requires him to explore the relation of his bodily nature to the universe that impinges on it; to be adequate to such an exploration, the new poetics requires him to explore the bodily foundation of his talent and his art. The two statements are virtually equivalent. The greatness of the achievement of the petrose, like the greatness of the Commedia, testifies in part to the seriousness of the crisis from which they spring. Thus the winter of "Io son venuto," which at one level is the enemy of the poet's love and even of his life, at a deeper level is seen as essential to his full maturing. It would seem that Dante saw the relation between his natal horoscope and that of December 1296 as coherent, a fulfillment of the providence that was seeing to the development of his gifts, in part by adversity and testing. There is every reason, then, to take seriously the erotic theme as well. It is no mere pretext; at issue is the possibility of integrating sexual desire with the rest of experience, including the practice of art. The point of departure is optimistic: the petrose rest on the presupposition that the two natures can be married, that love is attainable, that the war between the sexes can be disarmed, that integration of the personality and victory over its negative tendencies are possible, in large part through the mediation of art. In this connection the double tradition about the Twins—as Castor and Pollux, and as Adam and Eve—is particularly interesting. The petrose express the refusal to renounce the specifically sexual nature of the issues. Whatever the solution, it must, to use Dante's phrase in the Monarchia, "sapere utranque naturam."
4 We are now in a position to consider the fact that the successively lower realms of nature through which the eye descends in the course of "Io ― 97 ―
son venuto" are parallel to the parts of the human body:[79] the heavens are parallel to the spherical human head; the realm of the atmosphere corresponds to the apparatus of breathing; the spirit of the birds and animals corresponds to the human spirit, which dwells in the breast; and so forth. Not only is this the first of Dante's poems to include an astronomical description; it is also the first in which he adopts the analogy with the human body as a principle of structure.[80] It is a major feature of the new poetics, and clearly integral to Dante's effort to see and represent his situation fully. As is well known, medieval microcosmic tradition produced a proliferation of supposed correspondences between the human body and the world; Dante's knowledge of the traditions was undoubtedly vast, but his use of them was selective. He has nothing like the encyclopedic exploitation of every possible correlation that we find in the work of the remarkable twelfth-century abbess Hildegard of Bingen, for example, though he was undoubtedly familiar with such correspondences as those she drew between the four winds and the four limbs or the four rational powers of the soul (cogitatio, locutio, intentio, gemitus ), between birds and desires, or between the three levels of earth and the three parts of the torso.[81] His use of the analogy is actually closer to Robert Grosseteste's correlation of the head with the heavens, the breast with the air, the belly with the sea, and the feet with the earth.[82] He was familiar with the correlation of the powers of the soul with all the aspects of the sensible world[83] and with the fivefold division of beings, according to which man shares being with the stones, life with the plants, feeling with the animals, intellect with the angels, and has reason as his own distinguishing property.[84] He probably knew Bernard's convenient compendium in the De mundi universitate, describing the creation of man: Has utique corporis partes de multis singulas, de communibus exceptavit angustas: cerebrum, cor, epar, tria vitae fundamina suscepturas. In minori mundo homine Physis intelligit non errandum, si maioris mundi similitudinem sibi sumpserit in exemplum. In illo subtili mundano corporis apparatu caelum fastigio supereminet altiore. Aer, terra: terra de infimo, aer de medio circumsistunt. De caelo deitas imperat et disponit. Exequuntur iussionem, quae in aere vel in aethere mansistant potestates. Terrena quae subiacent gubernantur. Non secus in homine cautum est, inperaret anima in capite, exequeretur vigor eius constitutus in pectore regerentur partes infimae pube tenus et infra collocatae. Physis igitur, sollers ut erat artifex, cerebrum animae, cor vitae, epar appententiae, futurum destinat fundamentum.[85] (Bernard Silvester 1876 64)
― 98 ― Therefore these three small parts of the body she [Nature] distinguished from the rest: the brain, the heart, the liver, the three foundations of life. In man, the lesser world, Nature understood that she would not err if she took the likeness of the larger world as a model for it. In that subtle structure of the world's body the heavens rise above the rest with higher roof. Air and earth: earth in the lowest place, air in the middle place, have circular shape. From the heavens the divinity rules and disposes. The powers that dwell in the air or in the aether carry out its commands. The earthly things that are lowest are governed. Just so in man, it should be that the soul in the head should command, that its vigor, established in the breast, should carry out its commands, and those parts located lower—as far as the groin and below—should be ruled. Nature, therefore, skillful artisan that she was, provided the brain as the foundation of the soul, the heart as that of life, the liver as that of desire.
Bernard correlates the heavens with the head, the air with the breast and heart, the earth with liver and abdomen. In the poem that immediately follows this prose description (Bernard Silvester 1876 65–71), he develops the parallels even further, drawing directly and heavily on the Timaeus. First come the five senses, correlated with the elements (sight with fire, the eyes with the sun; hearing with air; smell with corruptior aer; taste with water; touch with earth). Then come three sections each developed to a part of the body: breast, abdomen, and genitals. The breast is the seat of the heart, and it is pyramidally shaped because it houses the vital fire;[86] the lungs surround the heart to ease its heat with moist coolness. The power of the brain is moist, that of the heart fiery. In the abdomen, the liver makes blood, which combines fire, air, and water. Bernard's description of the body ends with the genitals, entrusted with the endless fight to preserve the species: Saecula ne pereant decisaque cesset origo, Et repetat primum massa soluta chaos, Ad genios fetura duos concessit et olim Commissum geminis fratribus illud opus. Cum morte invicti pugnant genialibus armis, Naturam reparant perpetuantque genus. Non mortale mori, non quod cadit esse caducum, Non a stirpe hominem deperiisse sinunt. Militat adversus Lachesin sollersque renodat Mentula Parcarum fila resecta manu. Defluit ad renes cerebri regione remissus [87] Sanguis et albentis spermatis instar habet. Format et effingit sollers Natura liquorem, Ut simili genesis ore reducat avos.
― 99 ― Influit ipsa sibi mundi Natura superstes, Permanet et fluxu pascitur usque suo. Scilicet ad summam rerum iactura recurrit Nec semel ut possit saepe perire perit. [88] Lest the generations perish and the fountain cease, cut off, and the dissolving mass seek chaos again, so that she might continue to give birth she appointed two genii, once and for all gave over that work to twin brothers. They fight unconquered against death with their genial weapons, repair nature, and perpetuate the race. They do not permit what is mortal to die, what falls to pass away, they do not let man die off from his stock. The penis makes war on Lachesis and skillfully knots up again the thread cut by the hand of the Fates. The blood, sent down from the brain, flows down to the loins and appears as white sperm. Skillful Nature forms and fashions that liquid so that what comes into being will have a face similar to its ancestors. Nature, surviving the world, influences [flows into] herself, she remains and is fed with her own flux. For the waste touches even the highest of things, and so that she may not die altogether, she dies frequently.
The point is not, of course, that Dante is following in every detail some scheme of correspondences, whether Bernard's or another. But there is a broad similarity of outline, since both draw on the Timaeus tradition. Just as "Io son venuto" describes a descending spiral in the cosmos, so also it describes one in the body. As the influence of the heavenly bodies affects the rest of nature, so the influence of the head flows down to the rest of the body; we follow it pube tenus et infra, to use Bernard's phrase (stanza 5 does include references to the feet—walking is implied in cammino and passo —correlated with the earth in traditional analogies).[89] And a principal question needs to be raised: namely, what relation is supposed to obtain between this great cosmic parallel to the human body and Dante's own, actual human body, which inhabits this universe and moves through this landscape? The relation is clearly one of tension; but let us examine it more closely. To begin with stanza 1 here we have what is in some respects the most direct relation between the cosmos and Dante's body, even though it is introduced by the adversative però "nonetheless": in spite of the winter, his mind casts off none of the thoughts of love that burden him, since it is harder than a stone in its fixation on the image of the lady. Now, a first level of meaning, one that recurs throughout the poem, is that in its fixation on the lady his mind is resisting the force of the winter, a season contrary to love. But the matter is more complicated. First, his mind is parallel to the heavens; like the heavens, his head influ― 100 ― ences the rest of his body. Second, the lover's tenacious fixation on the image of the lady is related to the lore of the influence of Saturn, the patron of melancholy, obsessive desire, and strong vital powers. In fact, since we have brought the horoscopes of 1296 and 1265 together, we are led to the idea that the lover's ability to maintain his love in the face of the opposition of the entire cosmos derives from the qualities expressed in his natal horoscope. That his mind is "harder than stone in holding strongly an image of stone" identifies the aspect of the mind referred to as the imagination, or fantasy, a bodily faculty usually, in medieval physiology, thought to be located in the head.[90] The suggestions of this phrase are multiple. It draws on the traditional psychology of love, in which the mind knows external objects because the imagination, as impressionable as wax, takes on their form and presents this form to the intellect. Love is thus a condition in which the imagination is dominated by the image of the beloved.[91] That the imagination should become hard as stone reflects both its taking on the qualities of the beloved and the lore of the influence of Saturn (see above, p. 82). In stanza 2 the parallel is drawn between wind, cloud, and precipitation on the one hand and sadness and weeping in the human body on the other: e poi si solve, e cade in bianca falda di fredda neve ed in noiosa pioggia, onde 1'aere s'attrista tutta e piagne.[92] (20–22)
Here the opposition is explicitly confined to Love's not abandoning the speaker, though it is also clear implicitly that the speaker is not weeping. Striking and puzzling is the notion that Love draws his webs "up out of the wind." Whatever else, this clearly means that Love is not actively seeking to catch people in the winter—another version of the idea that love in winter involves opposition to the season. In stanza 3, the connection with the human breast is not limited to the references to spirit, though that is crucially important. Here, as we have already noticed, occur the most important references to fire in the poem, and unlike Bernard—and the Timaeus tradition in general—Dante does not identify the liver as the seat of passion, but rather the heart, the seat of the vital fire and of spirit:
e tutti li animali che son gai di lor natura, son d'amor sciolti,
― 101 ― però che 'l freddo lor spirito ammorta: e 'l mio più d'amor porta. (33–36)
This is the central stanza of the poem and is clearly meant to stand as an axis of its symmetries. Dante is drawing also on the traditional association of birds with desire and with love song; we have already discussed the importance of this stanza to the theme of the bringing forth of poetry. As compared with Bernard's correlations, Dante's are simpler and less rigid: with the animals we share motion and appetition because of the fiery spirit that dwells in the heart; with plants we share the most basic power of life, that of growth and nourishment, also located in the heart.[93] When in stanza 4, then, the analogy with plants is drawn, the emphasis is on the power of life. The antithesis between life and death is sharpened, and the evergreens are correlated with the possibility of immortality. e la crudele spina però Amor di cor non la mi tragge; per ch'io son fermo di portarla sempre ch'io sarò in vita, s'io vivesse sempre. (49–52)
Juxtaposed with the mention of immortality is the first explicit mention of death: . . . morta è l'erba . . . e tanto è la stagion forte ed acerba c'ha morti li fioretti per le piagge (42, 46–47)
and we note that morta/morti echoes the less explicit ammorta of the previous stanza. The evergreens are significant because they provide an analog to immortality, explicitly referred to in the last line of the stanza. The laurel, of course, was a familiar emblem of poetic immortality. The thorn of love in the speaker's heart is, as vegetable, related to the category of the stanza, but the bodily correlation seems less insistent here except for the explicit mention of the heart. As can readily be seen, these three central stanzas are closely related as referring to the breast—lungs (with the respiratory tract) and heart—though in the second and fourth stanzas the analogy with the body is perhaps more elusive than in the more sharply focused first, third, and ― 102 ― fifth stanzas. The fifth stanza in fact is the most explicit of all, as well as the most problematic: Versan le vene le fummifere acque per li vapor' che la terra ha nel ventre, che d'abisso li tira suso in alto; onde cammino al bel giorno mi piacque che ora è fatto rivo, e sarà mentre che durerà del verno il grande assalto; la terra fa un suol che par di smalto, e l'acqua morta si converte in vetro per la freddura che di fuor la serra: e io de la mia guerra non son però tornato un passo a retro, né vo' tornar; ché, se 'l martiro è dolce, la morte de' passar ogni altro dolce. (53–65)
Here Dante explicitly draws the parallel between the veins of the human body and those of the earth, between the interior of the earth and the human belly. The parallel governs the entire movement of the stanza, for the "death" of love mentioned in the last line is of course orgasm, a "flooding" or emission parallel to the emissions from the belly of the earth. As we have seen, Bernard uses the metaphor of flowing (fluxus ) to refer to seminal emission, as well as the notion that orgasm is like death; he also, using the terms influit and defluit, associates it with a metaphor of astral influence, since according to the Platonic physiology he is adopting, the seed is marrow that has flowed down the spinal column from the brain (which in turn is correlated with the heavens).[94] How detailed the sexual physiology is in "Io son venuto" may be debated, to be sure, but that the petrifaction in the stanza alludes to tumescence is indisputable.[95] The reference to the speaker's life span in stanza 4
and the mention of the death of love at the end of stanza 5 bring in the idea that orgasm literally shortens life, that the species may be preserved at the expense of the individual life.[96] This involves the possibility of the death of the speaker, which is brought into clear focus in the congedo. The landscape of stanza 5 is represented as an obstacle to movement. What is the relation of this landscape to the speaker's body, and especially to his desire for the death of love with his beloved? Crucially important here is the notion of the protagonist's continued motion against the backdrop of the winter scene, which functions on at least two levels: if he were to stop in the literal scene, he would die of the cold like the ― 103 ― grass and flowers, or at least be deadened like the animals; if he were to stop in the metaphorical scene, it would be to accept—and rest in—lust and orgasm in their mechanically (astrologically) conditioned, one might say their most brutal, form. But he goes forward in his war, which is thus directed against both the literal winter and the metaphorical winter of dehumanized lust. We must not lose sight of the fact, either, that the death of love yearned for by the speaker is not yet attainable. His love, his goals, and the state of his body are thus emphatically differentiated from the state of the cosmic projection of the human body through which he moves. As the poet says, the floods and freezings do not make him turn back. Nor, poetically, does he turn back from the theme of orgasm, for he ends the last stanza with it. Thus one of the functions of the fifth stanza is actually to contain and limit the notion of orgasm as the lover's erotic goal: e io de la mia guerra non son però tornato un passo a retro, né vo' tornar; ché, se 'l martiro è dolce, la morte de' passar ogni altro dolce.
Curiously, the terminology of defeat and death in these lines is turned into the idea and tonality of victory: with Mars retrograde, the lover may seem to go toward defeat, he is enduring the struggle and suffering of a martiro in the present, and he wishes—and fears—the little death of orgasm in the future. But in part because the physiological (and dangerous) aspect of orgasm has been externalized in the first lines of the stanza, the point is really that the poet's spirit will not be subdued by the melting and flowing of orgasm, any more than it has been by the winter. This morte is only orgasm, not death itself, and its sweetness will ultimately derive, not from the natural floodings and emissions, but from the love between the couple, their spirit. It may also be pointed out that the mention of parturition in line 3 of the poem has an obvious relevance to the goal of the lover qua lover. There is the suggestion that his love is procreative in tendency, not merely erotic in the narrow sense; thus the bringing of le fummifere acque into the poem does not imply a giving way to them. onde cammino al bel giorno mi piacque che ora è fatto rivo, e sarà mentre che durerà del verno il grande assalto. (56–58)
― 104 ― The poet's not turning back when faced with this obstacle is delayed until line 63, but it is assured. The syntax of the first clause of this sentence is worth examining: "onde cammino al bel giorno mi piacque / che ora è fatto rivo." The logically principal idea—"the road is flooded"—has been made subordinate to the qualifier—"(the road, which) pleased me in good weather." Thus considerable emphasis is gained by the strain of the construction (the sense is partly that winter has violated the pleasant landscape) and attention called to the fact that the road still pleases the speaker, he has not turned back. In other words, the positive memory (of il bel giorno ) and the positive hope (of reciprocation) dominate the poet's response to winter in all its meanings—the literal winter, the unnatural coldness of the lady, the stars as potentially lethal, the negative side of his own temperament. The congedo, however, envisages the possibility that the poet's tenacious love will result in death. He is threatened with petrifaction: Canzone, or che sarà di me ne l'altro dolce tempo novello, quando piove amore in terra da tutti li cieli, quando per questi geli amore è solo in me, e non altrove? Saranne quello ch'è d'un uom di marmo,
se in pargoletta fia per core un marmo. (66–72)
Taking it at face value, the congedo is deceptively simple: if the lady's heart, in spite of her youth, is still hard in the springtime, then the speaker will be turned to stone. There are several reasons why this should be so. One is that, as the rest of "Io son venuto" insists, it is natural for all nature, and to some extent also for man, to withdraw from love in the cold weather; the entire poem is based on the opposition of the lover's fiery passion to the rest of nature and to the perhaps natural enough resistance of the lady (natural enough in view both of her youth and of the season). But her youth is increasingly nubile, and a pargoletta might be expected to have a tender heart. In the springtime, then, all nature will incite her to love: if that fails, then his case is hopeless. Another reason is the pattern the poem has set up for the lover, that of antagonism to the season. By the logic of this opposition, unless the lady's response changes drastically, he will be cold in the warm season: if in the winter, when cold rains down from all the heavens, his head rains down love, then in the spring it will rain down a freezing influence. ― 105 ― These two kinds of logic reinforce each other effectively. They correspond to two aspects of the poet's "guerra"—his struggle against the lady's cold refusal and his struggle against the dangers within himself. Although the ending of "Io son venuto" envisages the poet's death if confronted by refusal in the springtime, the next poem, "Al poco giorno e al gran cerchio d'ombra," adopts the theme of the lady's continuing resistance (see especially lines 7–12). Thus the second line of logic has already been transcended in that poem: the poet will survive the spring. The idea of a stony lady whose influence might turn one to stone is, of course, a reference to the myth of the Medusa[97] that makes this passage even more complex and more threatening. Ovid's account suggests that the Medusa turned its victims precisely to white marble,[98] and several other elements of the myth have particular relevance as well. First, perhaps, is the presence in the story of a mirror, for Perseus was only able to kill the Gorgon by seeing her face reflected in the shield furnished him by Minerva. As Petrarch saw, there is an association in Ovid's text between the victims of the Medusa and the paralyzed immobility of Narcissus, fixated on his reflection (see Durling 1976 29–32). In this context, the suggestion of the last stanza of "Io son venuto," with its mention of flooding and of water turning to glass, includes that of a mirror. The danger referred to in the congedo, then, understood in connection with the Medusa and with Narcissus, would be that of being caught in the one-sidedness of frustrated desire, inevitably selfish and narcissistic, from which (if renunciation is excluded) only the living relation of reciprocity can release one. The idea of the donna petrosa as potentially a Medusa is, then, a basic idea in the entire sequence of the petrose, although no explicit references are made to the myth itself. The last stanza of the third poem, "Amor, tu vedi ben che questa donna," has a clear parallel with the congedo of "Io son venuto" and must be counted as the other most pointed allusion. In fact, the danger is already suggested in "Io son venuto" by the terminology of stanza 1, where the speaker's mind is said to be "più dura che petra" in its fixation, a clear parallel to the rhymeword marmo. The suggestion is that the danger of death is as much within him as outside him, as becomes clear in "Così nel mio parlar." The pattern of anaphora, so emphatic in "Io son venuto," is associated with this mode of ending the stanzas with the repetition of the rhyme-words,[99] which are of course very important in creating the powerful insistence of the poem. They are strategically chosen (in later ― 106 ― chapters we will trace their relation to the rhyme-words of the other poems in the series),[100] and they reflect the most important themes of the poem: the harshness of the lady, as well as her beauty; at the center of the poem, the tension between temporal existence and immortality; and at the closing, the danger of death. Their arrangement is symmetrical:
It is striking that while, as we have said, the poem represents (includes) the cosmos as a whole—and in the congedo the overall pattern of tracing the descending influence of the
heavens is repeated, so that the references to the heavens surround (contain) the rest of the poem/cosmos—still, the arrangement of the rhyme-words emphasizes precisely the opposite principle: the largest factors (time, eternity) are enclosed and contained by the threatening petra and marmo at the extremes.[101] Nevertheless, in the congedo, the love within the speaker is associated with the creative and procreative love that pours into the world in the spring. The congedo is in fact the best gloss on Love's spiderwebs in stanza 2: Love's nets, withdrawn upward in winter, must be the springtime influences mentioned in the congedo. There is an interesting suggestion (which is followed up in the third petrosa ) that Love's nets are a way for Love to draw man upward. But there can be no question that the freezings and floodings of the last stanza represent dangers like the Medusa. Indeed, that is precisely the point of their inclusion: "Io son venuto" and the other petrose steadfastly confront the lady's stoniness, which by that very token cannot objectively be Medusan. "Io son venuto" is built on the premise that all must and can be confronted, and one of the most powerful patterns in the poem is that by which the last stanza fulfills the first: the poem as a whole describes the descent of the influence of the heavens into the lower realms of the cosmos, and as the Twins emerge from below the horizon, so the last stanza brings up into the light the waters of the abyss. In other words, the contemplation of the poet descends through the body, and the unifying action of the poem brings up into poetry themes and feelings usually repressed and excluded from it, including cataclysm in the macrocosm, orgasm in the microcosm. We argue, then, that the opening of the poem means that the poet ― 107 ― has himself come to the point of the wheel, that is, of the cycle of his own life (not merely of the year), when a new poetics is born, which he calls the geminato cielo. Its birth is the result of the interaction of winter, of the remoteness—difficulty—of his love, and of the dual influence of Saturn, sweeping grandly across the night sky, with his temperament and spirit; it is geminato also because it requires him to understand and represent the dualities in his nature and in the planetary and other influences he feels. Dante's use of the metaphor of birth for the rising of Gemini, then, expresses a particularly rich set of interrelated factors. First, his coming to this new poetic maturity is the fulfillment of the potential ingegno that was planted in him by the stars at his literal birth; second, it requires the bringing out or up, from below, of negativities often kept below the surface, or horizon, of awareness, particularly in poetry; third, it includes the idea that the bringing forth of poems is like giving birth—a major parallel between poetics and procreative sexuality.[102] When we consider the importance in the poem of the parallels between the cosmos and the lover's body, we must say that what is being born here for Dante is the problematic of the human body itself, a major theme and structural principle in both the Commedia and the other petrose. Dante's use of the periphrasis il geminato cielo instead of the proper term (i Gemelli ) expresses yet another nexus of important ideas, involving the idea of the poem as microcosm: the new poetics—including this particular poem—represents the heavens in its explicit discourse; it also imitates them in its cyclical structure, and it exploits the microcosmic relation of cosmos and human body in a particularly rich and subtle way. The opening of "Io son venuto" thus does represent two heavens: the human head is the twin of the vault of the sky. The heaven of this new poetics, then, is geminato for several reasons in addition to the ones just given. If the literal meaning of the term refers to the influence of the sign Gemini and the planet Mercury, the poet's ingegno reflects this influence in a more than merely generic sense. For his poetry now reflects the dual nature of the Twins and the ambiguous nature of their myth: it confronts the relation of soul and body, or spirit and flesh, and—most important—it confronts negative and potentially violent feelings and strives for the victory of the higher principle. But this victory cannot involve the abandonment of the lower principle: the poet's spirit is to be Pollux to the Castor of his mortal negativities. A different form of the same idea associates himself and the lady with the male and female ver― 108 ― sion of the Twins. There can be no victory without integration, and for this reason the poetlover's intent toward the lady must include that of inducing her to confront and overcome the negativities within herself as well. This theme emerges more and more explicitly