Modern Birkhauser Classics Many of the original research and survey monographs in pure and applied mathematics published by Birkhauser in recent decades have been groundbreaking and have come to be regarded as foundational to the subject. Through the MBC Series, a select number of these modern classics, entirely uncorrected, are being re-released in paperback (and as elooks) to ensure that these treasures remain accessible to new generations of students, scholars, and researchers.
Bans Triebel
Theory of Function Spaces
Reprint of the 1983 Edition Birkhauser
Prof. Dr. Hans Triebel Mathematisches Institut Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat Jena
07743 Jena
Germany hans.triebel@uni jena.de
ISBN 978-3-0346-0415-4 e-ISBN 978-3-0346-0416-1 DOI 10.1007/978-3-0346-0416-1
Library of Congress Control Number: 2010924183
2000 Mathematics Subject Classification 46E35, 46-02, 46E15, 35J40 Originally printed in German Democratic Republic © 1983 Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft Geest & Portig, K.-G., Leipzig Published with kind permission of Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft Geest & Portig, K, G., Leipzig for sales in non-socialist countries in 1983 as volume 78 in the Monographs in Mathematics series by Birkhauser Verlag, Switzerland, ISBN 978-3-7643-1381-1 Reprinted 2010 by Springer Basel AG
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in other ways, and storage in data banks. For any kind of use, permission of the copyright owner must be obtained. Printed on acid-free paper Springer Basel AG is part of Springer Science+Business Media www.birkhauser.ch
Preface Function spaces have a long history. They play an important part in both classical and modern mathematics. Spaces whose elements are continuous, or differentiable, or p-integrable functions are of interest for their own sake. They are also useful tools for the study of ordinary and partial differential equations (although they have some shortcomings for that purpose). Since the thirties more sophisticated function spaces have been used in the theory of partial differential equations, in the first place the Holder spaces and the Sobolev spaces. Later
on (culminating in the fifties and in the sixties) many new spaces were created and investigated, e. g. Besov spaces (Lipschitz spaces), Bessel-potential spaces (Liouville spaces, Lebesgue spaces), Zygmund classes, Hardy spaces (real ndinmensional version) and the space BMO. In the sixties and seventies, deep new tools were discovered: interpolation theory and the methods of the socalled "hard analysis" (Fourier analysis, maximal inequalities, etc.). The main aim of this book is to present a unified theory of function spaces of the above-mentioned types from the standpoint of Fourier analysis. (In [I] we tried to give a corresponding representation of some of the above types of spaces on the basis of interpolation theory.) Although many results have been proved very recently, the theory seems now to be at a stage which justifies the writing of a book about this subject. The two books [F] and [S] of the author may be considered as forerunners. But they are more or less research reports written at a moment when some of the most important
problems of the above theory were unsolved (in contrast to the present situation). However, we do incorporate some material from [F] and [S]. In this sense, this book also may be considered as a new and thoroughly revised edition of some parts of [F] and [S]. The heart of the book is Part I, in particular Chapter 2. In this chapter we give a systematic study of the spaces BP q(Rn) and FP ,(-R,,), where s E R1, O-p- -, and 0 -< q oo, on the n-dimensional Euclidean space R,,, which is based on methods of Fourier analysis. These two scales BP,q(Rn) and FP M(R11) contain as special cases all the above-mentioned classical spaces (local versions in the case of the Hardy
spaces and the space BMO). The preceding Chapter 1 deals with entire analytic functions on R. and sequences of those functions which belong to L?,(R,,) and Lp(Rn, lq), respectively. This theory is of interest in itself, but it is also useful for Chapter 2 (the technique of maximal functions is used from the very beginning). Chapter 3 concerns the theory of the spaces BP q(Q) and FP q(Q) on bounded smooth domains Q in R. Finally, in Chapter 4 we extend the well-known theory of bound-
ary value problems for regular elliptic differential equations in Holder spaces and in Lp-spaces (where 1 -< p to the spaces By q(Q) and FP M(S2) on domains. In Part II we discuss briefly further types of spaces: homogeneous spaces BP,q(Rn) and F',,,(R.) with the Hardy spaces (n-dimensional real version) and the space BMO as special cases; weighted spaces of the above type on Rn and on domains; and corresponding spaces on the n-torus. We sketch a few applications to degenerate elliptic differential equations and to some problems for multiple trigonometric series. In connection with weighted spaces we give a brief introduction to the theory of the Beurling ultra-distributions. The styles of Part I and Part II are different. In Part I we give detailed proofs of the main assertions, whereas we restrict ourselves in Part II to formulations, hints and references. In many cases we remark that with the help of the indicated modifications one can carry over corresponding proofs from Part I. The main asser-
6
Preface
tions of Part I are those which are needed for the study of the spaces BP q(Q) and FP ,(.Q) on domains Q and their applications to regular elliptic boundary value problems. In many cases proofs of other assertions (also in Part I) are only outlined or omitted. It is clear that Part II is chiefly directed to specialists who work in that field of research. On the other hand, we hope that Part I is not only of interest to specialists in the theory of function spaces, Fourier analysis, and partial differential equations, but also to mathematicians, physicists, and graduate students, who use function spaces as a tool or who wish to have some information about this subject. Of course, it is not the aim of the book to give an exhaustive treatment of the theory of function spaces in the widest sense of the word. We are primarily interested in demonstrating the power of Fourier analysis (in particular of Fourier multiplier theorems and of the technique of maximal functions) in connection with the above-mentioned spaces. This branch of the theory of function spaces was established at the end of the sixties and the beginning of the seventies. Above all we have in mind the papers by C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2] and by J. Peetre [2, 4, 6] and Peetre's book [8] (of course, these papers have their own forerunners: in particular, maximal functions have a long history, cf. e. g., E. M. Stein [1]).
The reader is expected to have a working knowledge of functional analysis as presented in the classical textbooks (including the standard facts of the theory of distributions). A familiarity with the basic results of the spaces of differentiable functions, L7,-spaces and Sobolev spaces would be helpful. In this connection we refer to A. Kufner, 0. John, S. Fucik [1]. In recent years several books have appeared which deal with function spaces
of the above type from diverse points of view. Beside the classical book by S. L. Sobolev [4] and the cited books by E. M. Stein [1], J. Peetre [8], A. Kufner,
0. John, S. Fucik [1] and the author [I, F, S], there are books by R. A. Adams [1], S. M. Nikol'skij [3], 0. V. Besov, V. P. Il'jin, S. M. Nikol'skij [1], W. Mazja [1], and A. Kufner [1]. Furthermore, we refer to L. Hormander [2], J.-L. Lions, E. Magenes [2] and E. M. Stein, G. Weiss [2]. The book is organized on the decimal system. "Theorem 2.2.2/1" refers to Theo-
rem 1 in Subsection 2.2.2., "Theorem 2.2.3." means the theorem in 2.2.3., etc. All unimportant positive constants will be denoted by c (with additional indices if there are several c's in the same estimate). [I], [F], and [S] refer to the books of the author, cf. the list of references. I take the opportunity to express my gratitude to Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft Geest & Portig K.-G. in Leipzig for producing this book and for giving it a perfect typographical format. Jena, Summer 1982
Hans Triebel
Contents 1.
FUNCTION SPACES AND ELLIPTIC DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
1.
Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions Introduction . . . . . . . . . . Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . Distributions . . . . . . . . . .
1.1. 1.2.
1.2.1. 1.2.2. 1.2.3. 1.2.4. 1.3. 1.3.1. 1.3.2. 1.3.3. 1.3.4. 1.3.5. 1.4. 1.4.1. 1.4.2. 1.4.3. 1.5. 1.5.1. 1.5.2. 1.5.3. 1.5.4. 1.6. 1.6.1. 1.6.2. 1.6.3. 1.6.4. 2.
2.1. 2.2. 2.2.1. 2.2.2. 2.2.3. 2.2.4. 2.2.5. 2.3. 2.3.1. 2.3.2. 2.3.3. 2.3.4. 2.3.5. 2.3.6. 2.3.7. 2.3.8.
2.3.9. 2.4. 2.4.1. 2.4.2. 2.4.3. 2.4.4. 2.4.5.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
LP Spaces and Quasi-Banach Spaces . . . . . Maximal Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . . Admissible Borel Measures . . . . . . . . . Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type A Maximal Inequality . . . . . . . . . . . Inequalities for the Lebesgue Measure . . . . . Inequalities for Atomic Measures . . . . . . . . Inequalities for Admissible Borel Measures . . . A Representation Formula . . . . . . . . . Lp-Spaces of Analytic Functions . . . . . . . Definition and Main Inequalities . . . . . . . Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Further Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fourier Multipliers for Lp-Spaces . . . . . . Definition and Criterion . . . . . . . . . . A Multiplier Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . Convolution Algebras . . . . . . . . . . Further Multiplier Assertions . . . . . . . . Lp(lq)-Spaces of Analytic Functions . . . . . Definition and Basic Properties . . . . . . . Maximal Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . . A Multiplier Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . Further Multiplier Assertions . . . . . . . . .
.
12 12 13 14 15 15 15 17 19
20 20 22 22 23 24 25 25 26 28 28 29 29 29
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
33 33 33 33
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
35
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Function Spaces on R. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles On the History of Function Spaces . . . . . . . . . The Constructive Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Criterion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Decomposition Method, the Principle . . . . . . . . Approximation Procedures . . . . . . . . . . . . Definition and Fundamental Properties . . . . . . Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Elementary Embeddings Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
31 32
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
38 40 43 45 45 46 47 50
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
51
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
52 57 58
.
.
.
.
61
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . The Spaces F! ,,(_R.) An Orientation and Some Historical Remarks . Maximal Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . A Fourier Multiplier Theorem . . . . . . .
11 11
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Lifting Property and Related Equivalent Quasi-Norms . . . . . . Diversity of the Spaces and Fp q(R,) . . . . . . . . . . Interpolation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Real Interpolation for the Spaces BP q(R.) and Fp,q(R) with Fixed p Real Interpolation for the Spaces BBp,p(R.) . . . . . . . . . . . . Complex Interpolation: Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Complex Interpolation: Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
62 62
64 66 66 68
8
Contents
2.4.6. 2.4.7. 2.4.8. 2.4.9. 2.5. 2.5.1. 2.5.2. 2.5.3. 2.5.4. 2.5.5. 2.5.6. 2.5.7. 2.5.8. 2.5.9. 2.5.10. 2.5.11. 2.5.12.
Some Preparations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Complex Interpolation for the Spaces Bp q(Rn) and Fp q(Rn) Fourier Multipliers for the Spaces FP q(R5) . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
68 69 73 77 78 78 79 80 85 86 87 89
The Spaces Lp (Rn, lq) : Complex Interpolation and Fourier Multipliers . . . . Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . An Orientation . . . . . . . . . . . . Nikol'skij Representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Characterizations by Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lizorkin Representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discrete Representations and Schauder Bases for Bp,q(Rn) . . . . . . . . . The Bessel-Potential Spaces H ,(R.,,) and the Sobolev Spaces W P (R,,) . . . . . The Besov Spaces Ap q(Bn) and the Zygmund Spaces (23(Rn) . . . . . . . . 91 The Local Hardy Spaces hp(Rn), the Space bmo(R,,) . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 Characterizations by Maximal Functions of Differences . . . . . . . . . . 101 . . . Characterizations of the Spaces Fp q(Rn) by Differences . . . . . . Characterizations of the Spaces Fp q(Bn) by Ball Means of Differences . . . . 105 Characterizations of the Spaces Bp q(Rn) by Differences; the Spaces Ap q(R5) .
.
and CJ3(R,)
2.5.13. 2.6. 2.6.1. 2.6.2. 2.6.3. 2.6.4. 2.6.5. 2.6.6. 2.7. 2.7.1. 2.7.2. 2.8. 2.8.1. 2.8.2. 2.8.3. 2.8.4. 2.8.5. 2.8.6. 2.8.7. 2.8.8. 2.9. 2.9.1. 2.9.2. 2.9.3. 2.9.4. 2.9.5. 2.10. 2.10.1. 2.10.2. 2.11. 2.11.1. 2.11.2. 2.11.3. 2.12. 2.12.1.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
The Classes o%R, and flip Properties of the Classes DRp Properties of the Classes @RH .
.
.
.
Fubini Type Theorems . . . Fourier Multipliers . . . . . Definitions and Preliminaries .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Convolution Algebras .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
The Classes &Rp,q
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Embedding Theorems . . . . . . . . Embedding Theorems for Different Metrics Traces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pointwise Multipliers . . . . Definition and Preliminaries . . . . . . General Multipliers . . . . . . . . Multiplication Algebra s . . . . . . . . . The Classes Pp.a(R5) . . . . . . . . . . Special Multipliers for Bp,q(Rn) . . . . . Two Propositions . . . . . . . . Characteristic Functions as Multipliers . . Further Multipliers . . . . . . . . . . . Extensions . . . The Spaces BP q(R,, ) and FP q(Rn) . . . . The Case min(p, q) 1 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
The Case 0
The Case q -p .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . Diffeomorphic Maps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Main Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dual Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Case 1 --p < . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Case 0
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
109 114 117 117 120 120 124 127 128 129 129 131 140 140 140 145 146 149
154 158 165 166 166 167 170 171 172
173 173 174 176 176 178 180 182 182
Contents 2.12.2. 2.12.3. 3.
3.1. 3.1.1. 3.1.2. 3.1.3. 3.2. 3.2.1. 3.2.2. 3.2.3. 3.2.4. 3.3. 3.3.1. 3.3.2. 3.3.3. 3.3.4. 3.3.5. 3.3.6. 3.4. 3.4.1. 3.4.2. 3.4.3. 4. 4.1.
4.1.1. 4.1.2. 4.1.3. 4.1.4. 4.2. 4.2.1. 4.2.2. 4.2.3.
g
Characterizations via Gauss-Weierstrass and Cauchy-Poisson Semi-Groups Characterizations via Spline Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Function Spaces on Domains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preliminaries, Motivations, and Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Motivations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Problem of Inner Descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Localization Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definitions and Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
C°°-Domains
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A Special Multiplication Property .. . . . Inner Descriptions, Equivalent Quasi Norms
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
. .
The Spaces Bg(Q) and FSP 4(Q)
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Definitions . . . . . . Quasi-Banach Spaces . . Elementary Embeddings Main Properties . . . . Embeddings . . . . . Pointwise Multipliers . . Traces . . . . . . . . Extensions . . . . . . Equivalent Quasi-Norms Interpolation . . . . . Further Properties . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Regular Elliptic Differential Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definitions and Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Properties of Elliptic Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Properties of Regular Elliptic Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Priori Estimates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction and the Spaces FP Q(R') . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Priori Estimates, Part I: R,+, constant coefficients, Dirichlet problem . . . A Priori Estimates. Part II: R+n, constant coefficients, general boundary problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4.2.4.
A Priori Estimates. Part III: Bounded domain, variable coefficients, general
4.3. 4.3.1. 4.3.2. 4.3.3. 4.3.4.
boundary problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . Boundary Value Problems . . . . . Introduction and Hypothesis . . . . . . . The Basic Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . The Main Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . Boundary Value Problems in Zygmund Spaces
II.
FURTHER TYPES OF FUNCTION SPACES
5. 5.1.
Homogeneous Function Spaces Definitions and Basic Properties
5.1.1. 5.1.2. 5.1.3. 5.1.4. 5.1.5. 5.2. 5.2.1. 5.2.2. 5.2.3.
Introduction (to Part II) The Spaces Z(R.) andZ'(R,,)
.
.
.
.
Definitions . . The Spaces Fm Q(R) Basic Properties . . Further Properties . Maximal Inequalities Fourier Multipliers . Equivalent Norms .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
183 184
188 188 188 189 190 191 191
192 193 194 195 195 197 199 200 202 203 206 206 208 209
212 212 212 213 215 216 217 217 220
224 227 230 230 232 233 235
237 237 237 237 237 239 240 240 240 241 241
10
Contents
5.2.4. 5.2.5.
The Hardy Spaces Hp(R,,), the Spaces BMO (R,,) . . . . . . . . . . . Miscellaneous Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ultra-Distributions and Weighted Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions . Ultra-Distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction (to Chapters 6 and 7) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paley-Wiener-Schwartz Theorems for Ultra-Distributions . . . . . . . Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type . . . . . . . . . . . Admissible Weight Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Some Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Basic Inequality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LP_ Spaces of Analytic Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definition and Main Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weighted Function Spaces on Rn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Maximal Inequalities, Fourier Multipliers and Littlewood-Paley Theorems
6.
6.1. 6.1.1. 6.1.2. 6.1.3. 6.1.4. 6.2. 6.2.1. 6.2.2. 6.2.3. 6.3. 6.3.1. 6.3.2. 7. 7.1.
7.1.1. 7.1.2. 7.1.3. 7.2. 7.2.1. 7.2.2. 7.2.3. 7.2.4. 8.
8.1. 8.1.1. 8.1.2. 8.1.3. 8.2. 8.2.1. 8.2.2.
The Spaces L. (Rn, e(x), 11) . . . . . The Spaces Lp(R.s, Q(x), lq) . . . . . The Spaces Lp(R5, Q(x)) . . . . . . . Weighted Spaces of Type B8p 9 and Fj,q
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weighted Sobolev Spaces . . . . Characterizations by Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weighted Function Spaces on Domains and Degenerate Elliptic Differential Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weighted Function Spaces on Domains . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction and Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inner Descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Degenerate Elliptic Differential Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definition and A Priori: Estimate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Mapping Property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
9.1. 9.1.1. 9.1.2. 9.1.3. 9.1.4. 9.2. 9.2.1. 9.2.2. 9.2.3. 9.2.4.
Periodic Function.Spaces . . . . . . . . Introduction and Definitions . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . Periodic Distributions on Rn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Function Spaces on T,, Periodic Function Spaces on Rn . . . . . Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Main Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . Fourier Multipliers and Maximal Inequalities . Periodic Sobolev Spaces . . . . . . . . . The Problem of Strong Summability . . . .
10. 10.1. 10.2. 10.3.
Further Types of Function Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . Anisotropic Function Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generalizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . Abstract Spaces and Spaces Related to Orthogonal Expansions
9.
.
.
.
.
.
.
References .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
243 244 245 245 245 245 247 248 249 249 250 251 252 252 252
254 254 254 255 256 257 257 257 258 258 260 260 260 261 262 263 263 263 264 264 264 264 265 266 266 266 267 267 267
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
269 269 270 271
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
273
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Index .................................... 283
I.
FUNCTION SPACES AND ELLIPTIC DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
1.
Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
1.1.
Introduction
The Chapters 1 and 6 deal with analytic functions f(x), defined on the Euclidean n-space R,,, in the framework of Fourier analysis. The basis is the Paley-Wiener-
Schwartz theorem, which says that any tempered distribution f in R,,, whose Fourier transform has compact support, is an analytic function (more precisely: entire analytic function of exponential type). Let S' be the set of all complexvalued tempered distributions on R,,, and let Ff be the Fourier transform of I ES'. If u is an arbitrary Borel measure on R,,, then
i
Rf I/(x)IPd,u)P
(1)
has the standard meaning, 0 < p {
(usual modification if p = oo). If 92 is a compact
lit
subset of R. then we shall be concerned with the spaces (2) LPu={I I IES', suppF/C0, 111 1 Lp,,.Ilzw}. Let III I LPII = III I L.,11 and LP = LPµ if u is the Lebesgue measure. If I E L;, then inequalities of the following types are known: (i) If {xk}k-1 is an appropriate set of points in R,, (e.g.lattice points, where the length of the mesh is sufficiently small) then 1
k=1
I(xk)IP)P"III
I LPIl,
0
(3)
(modification if p
(ii) If 0-
IID"I Lgil =CIII I LpII .
The admissible sets {xk}k=1 in (3) and the constant c in (4) depend on Q (and p, q, a) but not on I. Inequalities of type (3) and (4) have a long history and played (and play) a central role in the theory of function spaces. (3) is essentially due to M. Plancherel, G. Polya [1], cf. also R. P. Boas [1, pp. 197-199]. (4) has been
extensively used by S. M. Nikol'skij [1, 3] (at least if pal). Of course, (3) and (4) are special cases of the estimate IIDh! Lq,vli=cIlf I Lp, II,
IELPU, 0
(5)
where v and p are Borel measures on R. Such estimates will be denoted as inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij type. The problem is the following: If 92, p and q are given, under which conditions for ,u and v does there exist a constant c (depending on a) such that (5) holds for all 1 EL;,,,? Chapters 1 and 6 are concerned with inequalities of type (5) and with the study
of the spaces L. If one looks for natural conditions for v and ,u such that (5) holds, then one is faced from the very beginning with a serious problem. Let, for example, dv = du = e(x) dxwhere e(x) is a weight and dx refers to the Lebesgue measure. The theory presented in this chapter is applicable to weights e(x) of at most
12
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
polynomial growth, e.g. t1(x) - (1 + xj)x where r is an arbitrary real number. On the
other hand, inequalities of type (5) and related spaces LP u do not make sense if e.g. Q(x) = elxl or e(x) = e-lx'!. What about weights P(x) which grow more rapidly than any polynomial but less than elxl, e.g. elxl0 with 0
a natural assumption for general admissible weights is closely related to the socalled Denjoy-Carleman non-quasi-analyticity condition. But the theory of
the usual distributions is inadequate to weights for type elxlfl with One needs the (in many respects more natural) Beurling ultra-distributions. However we prefer not to develop the (natural but complicated) theory of ultra-distributions
in Part I of this book, and postpone this task to Chapter 6. As justification for this strategy we recall that Chapters 2, 3, and 4 (and this is the heart of the book) are concerned with t.uiweighted spaces and for that purpose, the usual
distributions are quite sufficient. Although there are no problems in dealing with weights of at most polynomial growth in the framework of the (usual) tempered
distributions, we shall concentrate our attention on the (unweighted) Lebesgue measure and related Borel measures. e.g. atomic measures in the sense of (3). The periodic counterpart of (4) deals with inequalities for trigonometric polynomials. In Chapter 9 we shall be concerned briefly with this subject. Finally we mention that inequalities of type (4) have been considered extensively for the classi-
cal orthogonal expansions (Jacobi, Hernlite. Laguerre polynomials). A unified treatment (from an abstract point of view) and many references may be found in R. J. Nessel, G. Wilmes [2]. Cf. also S. M. Nikol'skij [3]. R. J. Nessel, G. Wilmes [1], J. Peetre [8] and [F]. Finally we wish to mention that a brief survey of spaces of type Lx ,, (in particular with 0
Preliminaries
1.2.1.
Distributions
It is expected that the reader is familiar with the theory of distributions, cf. e.g. L. Schwartz [1], K. Yosida [1] or L. Hormander [2]. We recall some notations and results.
Let R. be n-dimensional real Euclidean space. The 'general point in R,, is
denoted by x = (x1, ... , xn). Let S = S(Rn) be the Schwartz space of all complexvalued rapidly decreasing infinitely differentiable functions on I?n (usually we write S instead of S(R,,), there being no danger of confusion because all functions and distributions in this chapter are defined on R, and n is fixed once and for all. Similarly for the other spaces below.) The topology in the complete locally convex space S is generated by the norms
pv(4,)=sup (1+Ix1)ly I DI&)I, xERn kIn ' all
where T E S. Furthermore, DS = Ox11
... axnn
'V=1,2,3....
(1)
has the usual meaning: z = (at, ..., an) n
is a multi-index, ag = 0 are integers and l a; _ aj. Let S' = S' (R be the set 1=1 of all tempered distributions on Rn, i.e. the topological dual of S, equipped with
1.2. Preliminaries
13
the strong topology. If TES, then n
(F9) (x) _ (27t)
2 f e-ax6q2 (
)
Rn
xERn
(2)
denotes the Fourier transform Fop of T. Here x _ xj j is the scalar product j=1 in R. of x = (x1, ... , xn) E R. and E Rn. The inverse Fourier transform F-1q' of T is given by n
(F-19,) (x) = (27r) 2 f e1
q
xERn
Rn
.
(3)
One extends F and F-1 in the usual way from S to S'. Recall that F yields an isomorphic mapping from S onto itself and from S' onto itself. Similarly F-1. Furthermore, F (more precisely: the restriction of F to L2(Rn)) is a unitary operator from L2(Rn) onto itself. Here, L2(Rn) is the usual L2-space on Rn with respect to the Lebesgue measure.
Finally we recall the famous Paley-Wiener-Schwartz theorem. An analytic function / of n complex variables will be denoted by /(z), where z = x + iy, x E Rn and
Y E R. If I (x) with x E Rn can be extended to an analytic function of n complex variables, then this extension will also be denoted by f (z). Theorem 1. The following two assertions are equivalent: (i) 92 ES and supp F92c{y I IyI -_ b},
(ii) q(z) is an entire analytic function of n complex variables and for any A>-O and any there exists a constant cA,E such that m(z) 1 `cx,E (1 + Ix1)-x e(b+E)!YI
(4)
holds for all z=x+iy with xERn and yERn Theorem 2. The following two assertions are equivalent: (i) f ES' and supp Ff c{y I Iyi mob}, (ii) /(z) is an entire analytic function of n complex variables and for an appropriate real number A and for any a>-O there exists a constant cE such that /(z)ICc
(5)
(1+IxI)Ae(b+E)Ivl
holds for all z = x + iy with xERn and yERn. Remark. It is clear how to understand these two theorems: If (i) of Theorem 2 holds, then J ES' is a regular distribution &), which can be extended to an analytic function /(Z), which satisfies (5). Vice versa, if (ii) of Theorem 2 holds, then the restriction of /(z) to Rn satisfies (i). Similarly for Theorem 1. Proofs may be found in L. Schwartz [1, p. 272], L. Hormander [2, Theorem 1.7.7] and K. Yosida [1, VI. 4]. The formulation in Hormander's book looks more
handsome but the above version is the direct counterpart of a corresponding theorem for ultra-distributions, cf. 6.1.4.
1.2.2.
L, ,-Spaces and Quasi-Banach Spaces
If It is a Borel measure on Rn and 0
Ilf Lp,u II = ( f I/(x)I1' dy)!P
(1)
Rn
and Ilf
I
Lm,µll = -ess sup I I(x) I xERn
(2)
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
14
If 0
valued functions on R, such that lit I Lp,ull <-. Again, we write Lp,, instead of Lp,,(R,,) if there is no danger of confusion. If ,a is Lebesgue measure, then we put L. = L.,,, and Ilf LpII = II/ Lp,,.II Let A be a (real or complex) linear vector space. Ila All is said to be a quasinorm if IIa I All satisfies the usual conditions of a norm with the exception of the triangle inequality, which is replaced by I
I
I
Ilai+a2 I All =c (Ilai I All+Ila2 I All)
(3)
More precisely: There exists a constant c such that (3) holds for all a1 EA and all a2 E A. Of course c 31. (If c =1 is admissible, then A is a normed space.) A quasinormed space is said. to be a quasi-Banach space if it is complete (i.e. any fundamental sequence in A with respect to ll, All converges). It is well-known that LP,,, with 0
if p=1). then 1q is the set of all sequences {bk}k=o of complex numbers such that
If 0 < q
1
Ilbk 11gII
=(k=0Ibkl)
<00
(4)
(modification if q = 00). Of course, lq is a special Lq,µ space with respect to an appropriate atomic measure a. In particular, lq is a quasi-Banach space (if q } 1, a Banach space). For the sake of simplicity we write llbk I lgll instead of the more correct notation ll{bk}k-o I
IgII
Let 0
ll/kl LV(lg)Il =I Il/k(') IgII Lp I = I
(f
Rn k-0
1
Ifk(x)I q) g dx)p
(5)
1
Illk I lq(Lp)II = 1111/7,(') I LpII lq
(kE0
-
(f I fk(x)I ' dx) P) g
(6)
Rn
(modification if p = - and/or q = oo). Let Lp(lq) = Lp,(Rn, lq) be the set of all sequences {fk} such that Illk I Lp(lq)ll <°°. Similarly lq(Lp)=lq(Lp(Rn)) (again we omit Rn if there is no danger of confusion). Lp(lq) and lq(Lp) are quasi-Banach spaces (Banach
spaces if p } 1 and q 1). 1.2.3.
Maximal Inequalities
If I (x) is a complex-valued locally Lebesgue-integrable function on Rn, then (Ml) (x)=sup
CBI
f It(y)I dy
(1)
B
is the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function, where the supremum is taken over all balls B centered at x. We have (M/) (x) = I f (x)I
for almost every x E Rn
(2)
(with respect to the Lebesgue measure). If B in (1) stands for arbitrary balls with x E B, or for cubes with x E B, or for cubes centered at x, then the corresponding maximal functions can be mutually estimated from above and from below with
1.3. Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type
15
the help of constants which are independent of I (x). In other words, the theorem below holds for any of these maximal functions. Assertions concerning maximal functions and historical remarks can be found in E. M. Stein [1, § 1].
Theorem. Let 1
LP(lq)11-_C Ilfk I
(3)
LP(lq)II
holds for all sequences {fk(x)}k_o of complex-valued locally Lebesgue-integrable functions on R5. Remark. This fundamental theorem is due to C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [1]. If fo(x) =I(x) and/j(x) =0 for j =1, 2, ... , then one obtains the scalar case of (3), AIM! j LPjj-Cjj f I Lrjj,
1
where
(4)
The case p=- is trivial, because (MI) (x)sijf ; L-11. On the other hand, (4) is not valid if p=1. As for proofs and further comments we refer again to E. M. Stein [1] and C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [1].
1.2.4.
Admissible Borel Measures
As has been said in 1.1., the study of the general spaces LP µ from (1.1/2) is postponed to Chapter 6. In the present chapter we restrict ourselves to the Lebesgue measure and related Borel measures. In this subsection we explain what kind of Borel measures we have in mind.
Let Z be the lattice of all points k = (k1, ..., E R,,, where the components k1, ..., k are integers. If h::-0 and kEZ,,, then we put Qk={x l xER,,, hkj`xj
which there exist two positive numbers ci and c2 such that (2)
C1 :_5 9 (Qk) - C2
holds for every cube Qk, where kEZ,,. Remark. The definition shows that j EKh has a lattice structure. Besides Lebesgue measure, atomic measures are of special interest: p(Qkh) =µ({xk}) = 1,
where
xk EQk
(3)
is a fixed point in Qk, e.g. xk =hk. If y is given by du =x(x) dx, where dx indicates Lebesgue measure and x(x) stands for a non-negative weight function, then (2) reads as follows: 0
In particular, weights of type x(x)=min (1, IxIx) with dnO and x(x) =max (1, JxJ-Q) with 0 n a < n are admissible.
1.3.
Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type
1.3.1.
A Maximal Inequality
Section 1.3. follows closely [F, 1.3]. If Q is a compact subset of R, then we put S°={9p199ES,
Recall that
suppF99cQ}. Furthermore, M is the maximal function from 1.2.3.
(1)
16
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
Theorem. Let 0 be a compact subset of Rn and let 0 < r < . There exist two positive numbers c1 and c2 such that sup V9, (x
-n 1+IzIr
zERn
)
c1 sup
(x-z)I
4
zERn
-
c2 [(M
(x)]r
(2)
1+IzJr
holds for all T E S-Q and all x E Rn.
Proof. Step 1. Let y'ES such that (Ftp) (x)=1 if xEQ. If gESn then we have Fp = Fc F V and q' = F-1 (F97 Fy'). By well-known properties of the Fourier
transform it follows that T(x) =c f 4'(y) v(x-y) dy
(3)
Rn
If one replaces x in (3) by x - z, then differentiation yields 8x1
(x-Z)
I
=c f 9,(y) ax (x-z-y) dy Rn (4)
=c' f Im(y)I (1+Ix-y-zl)-' dy Rn
Here c and c' are positive numbers, and A may be chosen arbitrarily large. Of course,
one can replace
L91
8x1
on the left-hand side of (4) by 7T. We divide both sides of n
this modified estimate by 1 + Izi r and use the inequality n
1+Ix-yI r c (1+Ix-y-zl'), xERn, yERn, zERn 1+IzIr Then it follows that sup ow (x-z)I
zERn
1+IzIn
csup
f
zERn Rn
r
Iw(y)I n
(1+Ix-y-zl)-Xdy,
1+Ix-y1 r
where x can be chosen arbitrarily large. Then we have 1'7(p (x-z)I { lq(x-z)I su p zEB
n
Izr
csu p
n
zER,
(5)
1+IzIr
Step 2. We need an auxiliary assertion. Let g(z) be a complex-valued continuously differentiable function in the closed unit ball B={yI IyI <1} in Rn. If O.r
Ig(z)i -c [sup I vg(w)I+( f Ig(w)Ir dw) j , wEB
B
zEB,
(6)
holds for all functions g(z) with the above properties. But (6) is an easy consequence of the mean value theorem: g(z)I =c [win g(w)I+sup I v (w)I] WEB wEB
c ( fB
g(w)Irdw.v)r +c sup I
wEB
og(w)I
1.3. Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type
17
If Ba is an arbitrary closed ball of radius 6 - 0 in R, then there exists a constant c such that for all S . 0 and for all functions g(z), which are continuously differentiable in B6, n
Ig(z)1-cb sup Ivg(w)i+cb r WEB6
I
(B6f Jg(w)1'dw)ZEB6,
(7)
holds. We assume that Ba={y I IyIS}. If we replace g(z) in (6) by g(bz), then (7) follows from (6). Step 3. If g(z)=qq (x-z), where q' is as in Step 1, then (7) yields Im
n r
(x-z)l =cb sup 1 v9? (x-z-y)1 +cb Ivlsa
1
f 19n (x-z-y)I' dy)r
(
(8)
1Y1 u6
Let 0 < 6 51. The the last integral can be estimated from above by n
1
1
f 19, (x-u)1'du)r -_ c (1+Izir) [(M I9,I') (x)]' , lulsizl+l where M is the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function from (1.2.3/1). We put this
estimate into (8) and divide both sides by 1 + Izj . Taking the supremum with respect to z E Rn, we obtain sup Im (x-n)I _cS sup I om (x%z)I +cS r[(M 1991') (x)]r.
zEBn
1 + Izl r
zERC
(9)
1 + Iz1 r
Recall that 651 and that c in (9) is independent of 6, q' and x. Substituting (9) in (5) and choosing 6 sufficiently small, we obtain sup 1 ,79, (x%z)l zEB,y
1+IzIr
c [(M 19,I9 (x)]'
xERn
,
(10)
,
where c is independent of 99 and x. Now (2) follows from (5), (9) and (10). Remark. The proof is a simplified version of a corresponding assertion in [F, 1.3.2]. However
we wish to emphasize that some key ideas in the above proof are due to J. Peetre [6]. Cf. also C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2], where the technique of maximal functions of the above type has been developed.
1.3.2.
Inequalities for the Lebesgue-Measure
Our goal is the proof of inequalities of type (1.1/5) for admissible Borel measures
v and A in the sense of Subsection 1.2.4. In this section we restrict ourselves to functions /E S' (in order to avoid technical difficulties). The extension to /ELva will be treated in Section 1.4. Furthermore, it is convenient to begin with Lebesgue
measure. Recall that Da stands for
alai
8xi1
... 8xn
,
where a = (al, ... , an) is a
multi-index, i.e. al, ... , an are non-negative integers, and Ial =
n
j=1
af.
Proposition. Let 92 be a compact subset of Rn and let 0
holds for all (P E S. 2
Triebel, Function engl.
(1)
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
18
Proof. Step 1. We prove that
ImILWII-_cIlgILpll, 0
(2)
If 1=p=-, then (2) is an immediate consequence of (1.3.1/3) and Holder's inequality. If 0
YERn
Taking the suprenium with respect to xERn, we obtain (2). Let O
I Lgll = ( f w(x)i4 dx)
I
Rn
i q (f Im(x)Ip dx) =c I!m Rn
(3)
p
1
(sup m(x)I) xERn
I LPII
This proves (1) for a = (0, ... , 0). Step 2. First we remark that Daq E Sn holds for cp E Sn and an arbitrary a. Consequently, iteration of (1.3.1/2) yields ID°`9, (x) I
P
ER.
D¢g (x nz)i -ei 1+ IzI T
where 0 < r < oo. If 0- _P
slip (x-n)I e2 [(MITIr) (x)Jr n 1+ Izlr l
,
then we choose 0 < r < p (with r =1 if p = oo). It fol-
lows that IID°TI Lpll`cII(MITI')r ILpu=r- IIMI9,11' 1Lp(t
The maximal inequality (1.2.3/4) yields 1
IID°PILPII
r
(4)
This proves (1) with p=q. The general case follows from (4) and (3). Remark 1. The constant c in (1) depends on 0, p, q, a and the dimension n. The following consequence of (1) will be of interest later on: Let 0
IID
I
LgII
4)
(5) jig, I LPII
holds for all b-0 and all ipESB, with Bb={y I IyI - b}. The proof of (5) is simple. If
99(x)ESB6
then 99(b-'x) ESRi, because
(FT(b-' . )) ($) =bn(Fq) (be)
(6)
If we put ql(b-1x) instead of T(x) into (1), then this modified estimate yields (5). More sophisticated estimates of c in (1) have been given by R. J. Nessel, G. Wilmes [1].
Remark If 15psgs-, then (5) is the famous Nikol'skij inequality, which has been extensively used in the theory of function spaces by S. M. Nikol'skij and the Russian school, cf. S. M. Nikol'skij [3] and 0. V. Besov, V. P. Il'jn, S. M. Nikol'skij [1]. There exist many modifications and generalizations: Nikol'skij inequalities for trigonometric polynomials and for orthogonal polynomials, extensions to O< p s q-__ and to general measures and weights, abstract generalizations etc. References and detailed descriptions may be found in S. M. Nikol'skij [3] and R. J. Nessel, G. Wilmes [1, 2].
1.3. Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type
1.3.3.
19
Inequalities for Atomic Measures
Let ,u be an appropriate atomic measure in R. Our aim is to prove the counterpart of (1.3.2/1), where L7, andL5 are replaced by L.,,, and L4,,. respectively. For that purpose it is sufficient to show that the quasi-norms II,p I Lpll and 1h I Lp,,,ll are equivalent, gg E S'' (recall that Dagg E Sn if T E Sr'). The lattice Zn and the cubes Qk have the same meaning as in 1.2.4.
Proposition. Let 0 be a . compact subset of R. and let 0
1
ci
1
4,(xk)IP)P --h P Ilm Lpll `=c2 ( Im(xk)IP)p
(1)
I
kEZ,y
kEZn
holds for all h with 0
if p=-).
Proof. Step 1. We prove the right-hand side of (1). We may assume that h =1. If x E Qk and T E Sn, then
lm(x)1= Im(xk)I +ch sup I vq(z)I `Im(xk)I +ch sup I v (z)I
,
(2)
zEQk
where c and c' are independent pf h and T. If p
then (1.3.2/ 1) with p = q =
yields Ilm
I L-11 =sup 1m(xk)I +chllm 1 L-1 k
where c is independent of h and T (but depends on S?). If h is small, then we get the right-hand side of (1). If p < oo, then (2) yields
f Im(x)IP dx
Rn
R,,, jx-z1uc'
k
I oc(z)IP dx.
(3)
Let 0
f Im(x)IPdx:chn2] 1m(xk) IP+chP fI(MIm1") (x)!' dx
R
R
k
(4)
p
chn I vq(xk)IP+C hP I119?1' I LPII' k
r
chn 2, Iy(xk)IP+c'hP f Im(x)IP dx k
R,,,
If h is small, then we obtain the right-hand side of (1). Step 2. In order to prove the left-hand side of (1) with p T(xk)I
Im(x)I +ch
sup I om(z)I ,
x-zI15c'
xEQk
we start with
,
instead of (2). Then we obtain (3) and (4) with hn
Icp(xk)IP on the left-hand sides k
and f I(x) I P dx instead of hn Y T(xk) Ip on the right-hand sides. This proves the leftR,,,
k
hand side of (1.). The left-hand side of (1) with p = oo is trivial. Remark. Of interest is the number h°. It depends on Q and p. The restriction h0 1 is unimportant. One can prove the following assertion: if Q cQb = {y I 1,j- Y' 11 u b ; (i =1, ... , n)}, y° = (y`i..... yn) E.R. then hen b; cf. [F, pp. 31, 33, 487 and 1.3.5.
20
1.3.4.
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
Inequalities for Admissible Borel Measures
The lattice Z,, and the set Kh of Borel measures in Rn have the same meaning as in 1.2.4. Special elements of Kh are the Lebesgue measure and the atomic measures of the last subsection, cf. (1.2.4/3). Let h0=h0(Q, p) be the positive number from Proposition 1.3.3 and Remark 1.3.3. Let h(Q, p, q) = min (h0(Q, p), h0(S1, q) ), where
Theorem. Let Q be a compact subset of R and let Op < q c -. Let v E Kh and ,aEKh, where 0
IID"w I LQ,vii`c IIq, LP,,.II I
holds for all q; E Sn.
Proof. Step 1. If 9 ESc is given, then we choose xkEQk and ykEQk such that m(xk)I =maak Iq(z)I,
I m(yk)I =min Iq(z)I
Let p
LP,,IIP= f Iq,(x)IP
dv:c1
Rn
2] Im(xk)1" kEZn
C2 I I99(yk)IPC3 f IT(x)IP dy=e3II9, I L,4IP kEZn
(2)
Rn
Of course, the trick in this estimate is the possibility of switching over from {xk}kEZn to {yk}kEZ,m on the basis of Proposition 1.3.3 (equivalent quasi-norms for different choices of {xk}kEZn in (1.3.3/1) ). Similarly if p = -. Step 2. In particular, (2) yields that IIq I LP,, II and IIq' I LPII are equivalent on S12 (i.e. 119, I LP,II can be estimated from above and from below by 1199 I LPII with the
help of constants which are independent of q?ES'). Similarly, IIDagq I LQ,,,II and IIDaq I LgiI are equivalent. Now, (1) follows from Proposition 1.3.2. Remark 1. As has been mentioned in Step 2, we obtain as a special case of (1) the following improvement of Proposition 1.3.3: Let S2 be a compact subset of B. and let 0-
(3)
holds for all 99 ESn (equivalent quasi-norms on SQ).
Remark 2. Formula (1) coincides with (1.1/5) if %ESn, provided that v and p satisfy the above hypotheses. Later on, we extend (1) to Lp u =L p, cf. Theorem 1.4.1.
1.3.5.
A Representation Formula
In order to shed some light upon the lattice structure of the preceding inequalities, cf. (1.3.3/1), (1.3.4/3), and Theorem 1.3.4, we prove a representation formula for ggES'. We specialize Q by considering
Q=Qb={YIIy;I=b; (j=1,...,n)}, b>-0.
(1)
Furthermore, the characteristic function of Qb will be denoted by xb(x). Let Z,a be the lattice from 1.2.4 with the lattice-points k=(k1, . . . , k).
1.3. Inequalities of Plancherel-Polya-Nikol'skij Type
21
Proposition. If Q=Qb is given by (1) then any q'ESQ can be represented by n
,r 2
2
( )
}
( k/ ) (F1X5) (_k)
kEZ, 4'
kEZ
(bk) j=1n sin(bxj-kF) bxi-kjr
xER
(2)
"
(absolutely convergent series).
n
Proof. Step 1. I f x = (x1, ... , xn) E Rn and k = (k1, ... , kn) EZn, then xk =
xjki is the usual
9=1
scalar product in R. As a smooth function, Fop can be developed in Qb in an absolutely convergent multiple trigonometric series. Hence,
(Fq,) (x)=Xb(x) 2 ake
-i 'kx b
with
kEZ,y
irkx
ak=(2b)n f (F9') (x) e b dx eb
n
=(2b)- (2)2 [F1(Fq,)]
(.1t)=()2
b-'gq(b k), kEZn.
This proves the first representation in (2) if one takes into consideration that a-1 E- kx
F-1(Xb(x)
b
(y)=(F-1Xb)(Y-
)
i
b k)
Step 2. In the one-dimensional case, i.e. Qb = [- b, b], we have 1
(F-1X5) (x) _
1
(2n) 2 f e1ZYdy = (_ 12 b
-bxbx
/
-b
,
x E R1.
In the n-dimensional case it follows by multiplication that n
r \ 2 2 (F-1X5) (x- k)=()n b
n sinbxj_kjr (bxi- kin)
(3)
=1
where x = (271, ... , xn) E B. and k = (k1, ... , k,) EZ,,. Now the second representation follows from the first one and (3). The absolute convergence of the series in (2) is clear, because
k2 Remark 1. Formula (2) shows that the function p(x) is known if one knows its values at the lattice points b k, where kEZn. This provides a better insight into the lattice structure of the
inequalities in the preceding subsections. Furthermore, one can understand that has
r b
in
Remark 1.3.3: Let b
r
this is true if (by our assumption); (1.3.3/1) holds for all functions of Se5 and h> b . Then we can choose xk in such a way that g7(xk)=0 for all kEZn, cf. (3) with k=0. This is a contradiction. More careful arguments, which cover all 0
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
22
Remark 2. If 1
and 1 k'
Iq, I b k/// I
I
then we have the following addendum to (1.3.3/1) : The norms IIT 1
are mutually equivalent on
I Lp11
with Sl =Qb. A proof may be found in
0
[F, 1.4.6]. As far as the lattice-constant b is concerned, this is the best possible result, cf. Remark 1.
1.4. 1.4.1.
L,; Spaces of Analytic Functions Definition and Main Inequalities
Let K,1 be the set of Borel measures defined in 1.2.4. Definition. Let ,u E K,, and 0
LP ={fIfES',suppFfcD,IllILp,,11
(1)
If ,u is Lebesgue measure, then we put Lp N = Lp. Remark 1. The definition of II/ L,,,111 has been given in 1.2.2. Furthermore, we recall that S'=S'(R.). These are the spaces from (1.1/2). As we shall see II/ I Lp,u11 is a quasi-norm and LP µ is a quasi-Banach space if h-0 is sufficiently small. I
Theorem. (i) Let Q be a compact subset of R and let 0
Lp
c Ilf
i
(2)
LPII
1+Izlr
holds for all f ELp.
(ii) Let 0 be a compact subset of R. and let 0 < p --q ---. There exists a positive number H, which depends on Q, p, and q, with the following property: if vEK,z and ,u E Kh with 0
c such that II D`f I Lq,vII = C If
I
(3)
Lp,,
holds for all f E LP/,.
Proof. Step. 1. We prove (2). If p=oo, then (2) is obvious. Let 0
that
{y 13x with xEQ and Ix-y1=1}cB.
We apply Theorem 1.3.1 to fa(x) and obtain Ifs (x-n)I _c[(M
Ifalr) (x)]r -e'[(M iflr) (x)]r ,
xERn ,
zERn,
(4)
1+Izlr where c and c' are independent of x and z. We have q(Sx) s(x) p(x) in S if 5.10 and YES. Consequently, f a f in S' if 610. Proposition 1.3.2 wfth q=-, a = (0, ... , 0) and q =16-16, shows that {16}o<6<1 is fundamental in L,,. By standard arguments
1.4. Lp-Spaces'of Analytic Functions
23
it follows that /EL- and la(x) /(x) (uniform convergence) if 6 j 0. Hence letting S y 0 we see that it is meaningful to take the supremum in (4) over all z E R,,. We have 1
1
sup
n 1+Izlr
I
LP
C, 111(m I/1')
I L.11 =c JIM III' I LPII' r
where p >1. By (1.2.3/4) it follows that r IIzERri sup
I/
LP
C 111/I'
I LPII' =c lit
I
LPII
r
1 + IzI r
This proves (2).
Step 2. We prove (3). If B is the above ball, then we choose H = h(B, p, q), where h(B, p, q) >-0 has the same meaning as in Theorem 1.3.4. If /ELP,,, then /aESB has the above meaning. We apply (1.3.4/1) to 99 =/a to obtain IIData 1 LQ,11
II/a I Lp,pII _-C' III
(5)
I Lp,,II .
Similarly as in the first step, it follows that D°/a(x) --D"/(x) if 610 (pointwise convergence) and D'/ EL.,. Now (3) is a consequence of (5). Remark 2. There exist functions q, E S with T(0) =1 and supp Fq9 c {yI IyI s 1}: Let (FT) (x) >0 if IxH <1 and (FT) (x) =0 if xI n 1. Then
l
99(0)=(F-1Fgp) (0)=(2z)
2
I (F49) (x) dx-0 .
R,n
A normalization of q' yields a function with the desired properties.
Remark 3. Let p=q and a=(0, ... , 0) in (3). Then it follows that (1.3.4/3) holds for all TELp,', (equivalent quasi-norms). In particular, we have
0
(6)
where H=h(B, p, p) has the above meaning. Remark 4. By the above arguments, (1.3.2/5) holds for all T ELP with S2=Bb.
1.4.2.
Basic Properties
If Sn is given by (1.3.1/1), then the topology in S" is generated by the norms (1.2.1/1).
Theorem. Let.Q be a compact subset of R. and let 0
holds. Furthermore, LP is a quasi-Banach space and S-Q cLP cS' (topological embedding).
(2)
Proof. Step 1. Formula (1) coincides with Remark 1.4.1/3, in particular, 11t is a quasi-norm. We prove (2). If g2ESo then n+1 1q,
I LpII`II(1+IxI) P
TI
L-11 `pn(m),
N=1+In±1
I LP ,II
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
24
cf. (1.2.1/1). This proves the left-hand side of (2). For the right-hand side, note that if f ELp and gPES, then If (9,)1=I ff(x) q(x) dxI=1111 L-II Ilw Lill I
Rn
-c llf I Lpll 11(1+Ixl)9Z+' w 1 L-11-c Ilf I LpII pn+1(w) , where c is independent of f (we used (1.4.1/3) with q = oo and a = (0, ... , 0)). This proves the right-hand side of (2). Step 2. In order to prove that Lp is a quasi-Banach space we must show that any fundamental sequence in Lp converges. Let be a fundamental sequence in L. By (1.4.1/3) with q = and a = (0, ... , 0), it follows that {fj}T=1 is a fundamental
sequence in Lm. Hence /,-../ in Lw and, consequently, /-.j in 8'. Hence Fly-Fl in S' and this proves that supp Ff c Q. On the other hand, it follows by standard arguments that f E Lp and II f j - f I Lpll --0, if j -- -. Hence /EL p and f j -- f in L.. The proof is complete. 1.4.3.
Further Properties
If 1 s =, then LP from Definition 1.4.1 is a Banach space. Hence, one can study standard problems in the framework of the Banach space theory: the topological dual, separability, Schauder bases, isomorphism properties, density of subsets etc. In [F, pp. 39-49] we dealt with some of these problems. We recall here some results without proof.
Dual Spaces. Let 12 be a compact subset of R,, and let - 2 = {x I - x EQ}. Let 1
- + p7 =1. We ask for a representation of g E (LP)' by 1
1
P
g(/) = f /(x) g(x) dx, Rn
IIg
I (LP )'II -'IIg I L,,Il
(1)
Here, "
means that the two norms are equivalent to each other. We have g(/)="F-lg(F/) and suppF-'g=-suppFg. (2) This shows that only the restriction of Fg to -S2 is of interest in (1). Hence, we ask whether
1
1
1
+; =1
(3)
in the sense of (1). This is a rather sophisticated [F, 1.4.5]. We quote tworesults: (i) If 12 is a rectangle in R,, and if 2 p s m, then (3) holds; (ii) If 12 is a ball and 1
(3) is not valid. The latter negative result is based on the following well-known assertion by C. Fefferman [2]: the characteristic function of a ball is not a Fourier multiplier in LP if Density. In connection with (1.4.2/2) the problem arises whether is dense in L. In some cases, one can give an affirmative answer, cf. [F, 1.4.4]. Let Co be a bounded domain (bounded open set) in B,,, and let Q=w be the closure of co. We say that co has the segment property if there exist N open balls Kj and N vectors yj E R. such that N
U KjcQ, (12f1Kj)+tyjcw, O
j=1
If co is a bounded domain with the segment property, Q = , and O
hence also Sn) is dense in L.
Isomorphism Properties and Sehauder Bases. In connection with Proposition 1.3.5 one can ask whether (1.3.5/2) can be extended to q'ELP with 12=Qb. We recall some results from [F, 1.4.6] : if 1
1.5. Fourier Multipliers for LP-Spaces
25
in LP) ; furthermore, LP is isomorphic to 1,,, and ((F1X5) x-
n b k ))kEZn
is an unconditional
Schauder basis of analytic functions in LP . That LP is isomorphic to lP has also been proved in [I, pp. 239/240]. The last assertion is true for arbitrary compact subsets 11 of R..
1.5.
Fourier Multipliers for Lp-Spaces
1.5.1.
Definition and Criterion
Fourier multipliers for function spaces play an important role in this book. If Q is a compact subset of Rn and if 0
Definition. Let S2 be a compact subset of R. and let 0-
for all f ELP .
(1)
Remark 1. For the sake of simplicity we write F-1MFf =F-1[M - Ff]. If / ELP and F-1MEL1 (=L1(R,t)), then F-1MFf is well-defined: by (1.4.1/3) we have 1 EL., and hence (F-1MF1) (x) =c f (F-1M) (y) f(x- y) dy , x E R , (2) Rn
makes sense, where c is an appropriate positive number. One can criticize the above definition, because we assume that a Fourier multiplier for LP belongs from the very beginning to FL1, the Fourier image of L1. However in the framework of the theory of the spaces LP, this restriction is not very severe. A more detailed discussion of this somewhat sophisticated question may be found in [F, 1.5.1 and 1.5.6].
Proposition. Let Q and T be compact subsets of Rn. Let 0
oo and P = min (1, p).
There exists a constant c such that IIF-1MFf I LPII=c IIF-1M I LDII If
I LpII
(3)
holds for all f EL; and all F-1MELP.
Proof. By (1.4.1/3) we have F-1MEL1. Hence, (2) makes sense. If then (3) follows immediately from (2). Let 0
(4)
where c is independent of xE R5. We have supp Mc T and, by (1.4.1/3), F-1MELW. Hence, for any fixed xER,,, (5) (F-1M) (Y) f (x-y)ELp (as a function of y) and
supp F ((F-1M)
M+supp Ff
=supp M-supp Ff cT-Q. Here we used
supp Ff (x- )_ -supp Ff (-x)= -supp Ff
(6)
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
26
and the notation -A={ -4EA},where A is a set in R. Hence, by (5) and (6), we have
where xER.. Now (4) is a consequence of (2) and (1.4.1/3) with q=1 and 0
follows from (4). Remark 2. By (1.4.1/3) we have F-1MEL1 in any case. Hence M(x) =FF-1M is a continuous
bounded function on R. with supp M(x) cl'. Because supp F/c9, it is clear that only the values of M(x) with xEI'fQ are of interest. This justifies the restriction to Fourier multipliers M(x) with compact support.
1.5.2.
A Multiplier Theorem
If s is a real number, then (1) H2={/I/ES',11/IH,11=II(1+1x12)2 (F/) (x)IL211
11/
H211=IIF-1 (1+Ix12)2 F/ I
I
(2)
L211
We recall that 8
8
F-1 (1+1x12)2 F/=F-1 [(1+1x12)2 . F/(x)]
Furthermore, H2 are special Bessel-potential spaces (Liouville spaces, Lebesgue spaces), which will be studied later on. Sometimes these spaces are also denoted by W2 = H2 (Sobolev-Slobodeckij spaces, at least if s = 0). If s = m = 0, 1, 2, .. then W2 is the usual Sobolev space, I W2= //ES',II/I W211=(2] IID1/IL2112)2
.
jaj57M
(3)
We shall not discuss the properties of these spaces because they are very special (almost classical) cases of the spaces which are treated in Chapter 2. But we wish to mention that s in H2 is a smoothness index: as s increases, then the functions belonging to H2 become smoother, cf. (3). Of course, H2acH21 if 8e>s1 and H2=L2.
Theorem. Let Q be a compact subset of R. and let 0-
1)
2
v1, _
/
11 F-1MF/ I LPII -_c II M I HiII If I LPII
(4)
for all /ELP and all MEH2. Proof. Step 1. Let us assume that (4) is valid for all ME H-2' with
supp McQ1={y 13xEQ with Ix-yl -_ 1}
.
(5)
Let VESwith supp ecQ1 and e(x)=1 if xEQ. If MEH2' is an arbitrary function, then
F-1MF/=F-1VMF/, /ELp
(6)
1.5. Fourier Multipliers for L,-Spaces
27
By our assumption, (4) with ?pM instead of M is valid. Finally we remark that IIpMIH2II-_ cJIM IH211,
(7)
where c depends only on V (and not on M). This is a well-known fact, which is a special case of more general assertions proved in Chapter 2. But (4) with pM instead of M, (6) and (7) prove (4) for all ME H2'. Step 2. In this step we prove the following assertion: if 0
ap, then
there exists a constant c such that IIFMILpII`cJIM IHZII holds for all f EH2. Let
(8)
Ko={xIIxI-1}, Kj={xI2j-1=IxI=2j} for
j=1,2,3,...
(9)
Then we have (10)
IIFMI LLIIp=2] II(FM)(x)Ipdx j=o Kj
2 'n
2p 2
j=o
(f I(FM) (x)I2dx)2 Kj
11p
=c
r I2'ap(KjII(FM)(x)12dx)2J j=oL 2
<=c'
j=o
22'8 f I (FM) (x)12 dx Kj
I H2IIp
This proves (8). Step 3. Let MEHZ with swap and supp Mc 521, cf. (5). If p=min (1, p), then (8)
yields F-1MEL, . Now (4) follows from Proposition 1.5.1 and (8). The proof is complete. Remark 1. In Step 2 we proved a bit more than stated : If 0
_
IIFMIL,,
jn
1pp
1_ 1
uc(12 (p
21(!I(FM)(x)I 2dx)2, Kj
j=o
cf. 1.5.4.
Remark 2. The above theorem is comparatively simple, but it reminds us of the famous Michlin-Hormander multiplier theorem for the LP spaces, 1
IIDIM I L2II2)2 111
1
LpII
(12)
where c is independent of M and I. Remark 3. As in Remark 1.3.2/1 we add a homogeneity consideration. Let 0
0. If I ELp then we have f(b-'x) ELP, where w=B1, cf. (1.3.2/6) (which holds for any 9 and the argument given there. Let M(x) E H2 with s >op, where ap has the same meaning as in the theorem. Iteration of (1.3.2./6) (extended to S'(R,,)) yields (F-1MFf) (x) ={F-1[M(b .)
(Ff(b-1 .)) ('))} (bx) .
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
28
Now, by (4) with to instead of 0 and
instead of /we have
n
IIF-iMFI I LPII =b P IIF-'[M(b ') (Ff(b-1
I LPII
n
cb
(13)
IIM(b') I H2 II -II/(b-1') I LPII=cIIM(b') I H2 II Ii/ I LPII
where c is independent of b and f ELP. 1.5.3.
Convolution Algebras
If I EL, and gEL1 then the convolution f*g is defined by (f*g) (x) = f / (x - y) g(y) dy
(1)
Rn
If c is an appropriate positive number, then (1) can be rewritten as f*g= cF-1[Ff Fg], and one can define f*g by the last formula for more general distributions f and g if F-1 [Ff Fg] makes sense. Proposition. Let Q be a compact subset of Rn and let 0
Remark 2. Let 0=Ba={y I IyI mob} with b>0. If /ELP and 9ELP, then we apply (2) to f(b-1x) and g(b-lx) instead off and g, respectively, cf. Remark 1.5.2/3. Elementary transformations of coordinates, cf. also (1), show that there exists a constant c such that IIf *g I LPII
scbn ("
1) III I LpII IIg I LPII
(3)
holds for all b -0, all f ELP and all gELP .
1.5.4.
Further Multiplier Assertions
Improvement of Theorem 1.5.2. In 2.3.1. we define the spaces BsU,v=Bu,v(Rn). where sER1, 0<uso,, and 0
where opf has the same meaning as in 2.3.1., and it is not hard to see that the right-hand /1 1 ide of (1.5.2/11) is an equivalent quasi-norm in B2,PP
2
. Hence (1.5.2/11) can be re-formu-
ated as follows. If 0
(P I B22
(1)
Estimates of this type are known, cf. J. Peetre [1, pp. 9-11] and [F, pp. 60/61]. With the help and p =min (1, p), then of this inequality, Theorem 1.5.2 can be strengthened: if 0
IIF-'MFI I LPII
cII1i1
for all /ELP and all MEB0 v
I
P111111 LPII
1.6. Lp(lq)-Spaces of Analytic Functions
29
Discrete Multiplier Assertions. Until now we have not used the lattice structure of the spaces LP , cf. (1.4.1/6) and (1.3.3/1). If D is a compact subset of R,, and 0
Qa={Yllyjlta; (9=1,...,n)}.
r
Co 0
and
Let M E L. and Mk = (F-IM) (aa k with k EZn. Then M(x) is a Fourier multiplier in Ly (in a somewhat wider sense as in Definition 1.5.1, ef. [F, pp. 51/52]) if and only if there exists a constant c such that 1
1
(
`kEZn
I
t
o Mk-tf (a l) 1P)p Sc
(
\ki
( 1a
1
(3)
k) pJ
(modification for p = .o) holds for all /ELP. Proofs and explanations may be found in [F, 1.5.2]. In [F] we started with (3) and proved (1.5.1/3) and (1.5.2/4) afterwards.
Non-Multipliers. The question arises whether (1.5.2/4) and (2) are sharp. If 125ps
then u, =
n 2
.
In [F, 1.5.7] we proved the following assertion : if 1
2,q which is not a Fourier multiplier S2 =Qb with b >0, then there exists a function ME B2
for L. 1.6.
Lp(lq)-Spaces of Analytic Functions
1.6.1.
Definition and Basic Properties
We recall the abbreviations introduced in 1.2.2. In particular, Ilfk I Lp(lq)II has the meaning of (1.2.2/5). Definition. Let 0-<:p,_5_ and 0 < q s -. If Q = {S2k}k=o is a sequence of compact subsets of R,,,,then D (1) f={fk}k=ocS' , supp FfkcQk if k = 0, 1, 2.... Lp(lq)={f I and Il fk I Lp(lq)II - -} . Remark. As in the preceding sections we omit R in the notation of the spaces, i.e. we write LP (lq) instead of LP (R,,, lq). In contrast to Definition 1.4.1 we restrict ourselves from the very beginning to Lebesgue measure.
Theorem. Under the hypotheses of the above definition, Lp (lq) is a quasi-Banach space with the quasi-norm Ilfk Lp(lq)II. Proof. It is obvious that II fk I Lp(lq)II is a quasi-norm. Furthermore, by Theorem 1.4.2,
any space LPk is complete. Then it follows by standard arguments that LP (lq) is complete too. 1.6.2.
Maximal Inequalities
Let 0 = {Dk}k o be a sequence of compact subsets of B0. Let dk =
sup
Ix - yJ
XEnk, yE.ok
be the diameter of Q. We always assume that dk>-0, i.e. S2k contains at least two different points.
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
30
Theorem. Let 0
Lp(lq)
C IIfi
I
(1)
Lp(lq)II
i+Idkz r
holds for all f ELP(lq), where f = {fk} .
Proof. Step 1. Let ykEQt and hk(x)=e-'xykfk(x), where xyk is the scalar product of x E R. and yk E R. Furthermore, {fk} E Lp (lq). Then we have (Fhk) (x) = (Ffk) (x + yk).
Hence, supp Fhk c Qk - yk . If (1) holds for {fk} E LP (lq), then we have a corresponding inequality for (hk), where Q
is replaced by {Qk-yk}k_O and vice versa. Hence, we may assume that OEQk. Then it is sufficient to consider the case Qk = Dk = {y I IyI -- dk}. Step2. We must prove (1) with Qk=Dk={y I IyI =dk} and dk=0. If {fk}ELL(lq), then AELpk. If 9k(X) = fk(dk1x), then =1 } . (Fqk) ( ) = dk(Flk) (dkx) and supp Fgk c {y I Hence, by the arguments in the first step of the proof of Theorem 1.4.1, we have I
1
qk (x - z)I
n
c[(MIgklr) (x)]r ,
zERn, zERn ,
and
lk(x - z)I
xERn',
e[(Mllklr) (x)!r ,
zERn ,
(2)
1+dkzlr where c is independent of x, z, and k=0, 1, 2.... Here we used the fact that (Mh(c ')) (E) = (Mh) (ce),
If q-<-, then it follows that -z)I I Lp(lq) sup Ilk zERn
c> O. 1
1
cjI[(M Ilklr) (.)] r
Lp(lq)II =cIIM Ilklr I Lp(lg)II r r
1+IdkzIn
Because 0
zERn
I
.
r
and 4 >- 1. We apply Theorem 1.2.3 to r
1
Ilk('-z)I
cIIIlk I' ILp(lg )II r =cIllk I Lp(lq)II
n Lp(lq)
r
1 +dkzl
r
This proves (1) with Qk=Dk={y I IyI
1
k li [(M I ik(')I r) (x)] r
1+Idkzl r
c[(M sup lk(')I Ir) (x)]r, k
zERn,
zERn..
(3)
1.6. Lp(lq)-Spaces of Analytic Functions
31
Hence, skP supP
Ilk
-z)I Lp
n1
C JIM I SUP Ilk(.) I
Ir
k
II
I +Idkzlr
I Lp 11 r r 1
Now we apply (1.2.3/4) with skp I/k(x)Ir instead of l(x) and
2?
r
>-1 instead of p.
This proves (3) with q=- and the proof is complete. Remark. In contrast to 1.6.1. we restricted p in the above theorem top < . The case p = q = is trivial. What about the case p = -, 0
In other words, the above theorem cannot be extended top=-, 0
1.6.3.
A Multiplier Theorem
The spaces II ; have been defined in 1.5.2. Theorem. Let 0
-+ , then there 2 min (p, q)
exists a constant c such that
III''-hMkF/k I Lp(lq)II -_ c sup IIMi(da') I II2II
(1)
' II/k I Lp(lq)II
holds for all systems {/k(x)}k_oELp(lq) and all sequences Proof. First we remark that F/k] is well-defined: By nk (1.5.2/8) we have F-'MkEL1. Furthermore, /kELp, and hence by (1.4.1/3), /kELm. Remark 1.5.1/1 shows that F-'MkF/k makes sense. Next we want to prove that F 'MkFlx (n - z) c sup Ilk (x - z) I II Mk(dk-) sup F-'MkF1k=F-1[Mk
I II?
1+Idkzlr
zERa
(2)
zERn1+Idkzlr
holds where 0 < r < min (p, q) and x Z + r . Here c is independent of x and k (and
the functions Mk and /k). By (1.5.1/2) and the above remarks we have I(F-1MkFfk) (x - z)I t c J I (F- 'Mk) (x-z-y) II lk(y)I dy
(3)
Rn
c sup u E Rn.
But
ilk(u)I
n
(I(F-1Mk) (x-z-y) I (1+ I dk (x-y) r) dy
J 1+Idk (x-u)I 'n
n
n
n
1+ I dk(x-y)Ir
Substituting this estimate into (3) and dividing both sides by 1 + Idkzlr , we find that sup zERn
n
I(F-'MkF/k) (x - z)I n
1+Idkzlr
-=csuP I lk (x - z)In f I(F-'Mk) (y)I (1+Idkyl r)dy zERn1+IdkzIrRn
(4)
32
1. Spaces of Entire Analytic Functions
Using (F-1Mk(dk )) (y)=d; (F-1Mk) (dk ly) and x r +2 , we then obtain n
n
f I (F-'Mk) (y)I (1+Idkyl') dy=Rnf I(F-1Mk(dk')) (y)I (1+IyI') dy Rn sc [ f (1 +IyIx)2I (F-1Mk(dk')) (y)12dy12 `c'IIMk(dk-) I H2II Rn
Putting this estimate into (4), we obtain (2). Now (1) is an immediate consequence of (2), Theorem 1.6.2 and the trivial estimate I(F-1MkF/k) (x)Issup I(F-1MkFfk) (x-z)I ZERn
1+Idkzl'
Remark. The scalar case of (1) is related to (1.5.2/13). However (1.5.2/13) holds also for p=oo and the restrictions for s=x are more natural, cf. also the following subsection.
1.6.4.
Further Multiplier Assertions
The number op in Theorem 1.5.2 and in (1.5.4/2) is natural. The vector-valued counterpart is 1
(mm n
(1, p, q)
l
2/
(1)
This number is smaller than the critical number n
1 + in Theorem 1.6.3. 1 2 min (p, q) The reason for this awkward difference is the use of the technique of maximal functions:
it spoils some constants and this has the above effect, of. the proof of Theorem 1.6.3. However,
a combination of Theorem 1.6.3, a Fourier multiplier theorem of Michlin-Hormander type
for Lp(lq) with 1-p<-, 1- q-oo, and complex interpolation yields the desired result: the assertion of Theorem 1.6.3 is valid for all x>-up,,, cf. 2.4.9.
2.
Function Spaces on R.
2.1.
Introduction
As we mentioned in the preface, this chapter is the heart of the book. We give a thorough description of the two scales and of spaces on R,,. On this basis we switch over later on from R,2 to smooth bounded domains Q in R,,, study the spaces B7,,q(Q) and F,,q(Q) (Chapter 3), and apply the results to regular elliptic boundary value problems (Chapter 4). The spaces B',, and F'P q contain many well-known spaces as special cases: Besov-Lipschitz, Holder, Zygmund, Sobolev, Bessel-potential, Lebesgue and Hardy spaces, and also spaces of functions of bounded mean oscillation. All these spaces have their own defini-
tions, but we give for them (and their generalizations Bp,q and F q) a unified approach via decomposition methods in the framework of Fourier analysis. The advantage is clear: one deals with all these apparently rather diversified spaces from a common point of view. The disadvantage is that the formal definition of B' q and FSP,q looks somewhat complicated at first glance. In order to provide a better understanding of what happens we give in Section 2.2. some (more or less heuristic) motivations. We also add a few historical comments and list the above-mentioned spaces. The rigorous definition of B' ,,(R.,,) and F' is given in 2.3., where the chapter starts in earnest. The rest of the chapter (which
is the main part) deals with properties of these spaces. 2.2.
The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles
2.2.1.
On the History of Function Spaces
In this Section 2.2. "function space" always means a normed or quasi-normed space of functions and distributions on R,,, which is (with the usual technical terms)
unweighted, isotropic and non-homogeneous. The historical remarks below and the list of spaces given in 2.2.2. deal mostly with spaces of such type. There is hardly any doubt that this type of space was and is the backbone (in the widest sense of the word) of the theory of function spaces from the very beginning up to our time. Corresponding spaces, defined on bounded smooth domains in R,,, will be considered in Chapter 3. Also, in Part II, we deal briefly with their homogeneous, periodic and weighted counterparts. A lot of other spaces, which have attracted much attention in recent years, remain outside the scope of this book, e. g. Lorentz spaces, Campanato-Morrey spaces, Orlicz spaces, Orlicz-Sobolev spaces etc. An excellent survey of the realm of function spaces in this wider sense has been given by A. Kufner, O. John, S. Fucik [1]. Cf. also the books mentioned in the Preface.
The history of function spaces (in the above restricted sense) can be divided into three periods. The first (basic) period starts at the beginning of our century and ends in the mid-thirties. During that time, the classical basic spaces Lp of p-inte-
grable functions and Cm of m times differentiable functions were thoroughly investigated (here m = 0, 1, 2.... ; we set C° = C; definitions of all the spaces
mentioned here may be found in 2.2.2.) The Holder spaces C' with 0-<s*
integer and the Hardy spaces H 7 , with 0- p-- belong to that period and antici pate the second (constructive) period. Originally, the Hardy spaces were introduced 3
Triebel, Function engi.
34
2. Function Spaces on Iin 67-75
systematic period
constructive period
basic period P 1P
Fig. 2.2.1 (45 means the
(complex)
year 1945 etc.)
in order to characterize the boundary values of analytic functions in a disk in the complex plane. The close connection between the Hardy spaces and the methods of Fourier analysis was quite clear from the beginning. The second (constructive) period starts with the papers by S. L. Sobolev [1-3] in 1935-1938, where the spaces that are nowadays called the Sobolev spaces WP`, with m = 0, 1, 2. ..., were introduced. A new too], the theory of distributions, was discovered and new techniques and results (e. g. embedding theorems) were used successfully in order to investigate
partial differential equations. The second period is characterized by more or less speculative constructions of many new spaces with the help of explicit norms (and quasi-norms) on the basis of the above classical spaces. This period culminated at the end of the fifties and in the sixties, and flourishes also in our time. First of all we must note the direct descendants of the above-mentioned classical spaces (which include the Holder spaces, Hardy spaces and Sobolev spaces) : (i) The Zygmund spaces (or classes) Cps. These are extensions of the Holder spaces
C' to values s=1,2,3.... The beginning is marked by A. Zygmund [1], who
discovered the remarkable fact that sometimes second differences 4hf of functions f (cf. 2.2.2. for the definition) are much more useful than first differences 41f. (ii) The Slobodeckij spaces W,, with 0-<s* integer. These constitute an attempt to fill the gaps between the Sobolev spaces LWi,, WP, ... in the spirit of the Holder spaces: use of the first differences 4hf. A second, and even more convincing, reason for the introduction of the spaces W. with fractional s is the fact that these spaces are necessary for the description of the exact traces on hyper-planes in R,, of functions belonging to Sobolev spaces. These spaces were introduced simultaneously by N. Aronszajn [1], L. N. Slobodeckij [1] and L. Gagliardo [1].
(iii) The Besov (or Lipschitz) spaces PA. The combination of the above ideas (Zygnrund's proposal to use second differences 4,/ instead of first differences .,'f, and the replacement of the sup-norm in the Holder spaces by the L9-norm .1
in the Slobodeckij spaces) yields essentially the spaces 4p,q, defined by 0. V. Besov [1, 2]. However two points should be emphasized. Firstly, there was from the very beginning a close connection with problems in approximation theory. We shall return to that point in 2.2.5. Secondly, the spaces AP,,, (sometimes called Nikol'skij spaces) had been investigated in the early fifties by S. M. Nikol'skij [1]. (iv) The Bessel-potential (or Lebesgue or Liouville) spaces HP, where s is real. This
is another attempt to fill the gaps between the Sobolev spaces L5, Wp, WP, .... because HP = W'n if no = 1, 2, 3.... Instead of derivatives and (first and higher) differences (as in the above spaces) the spaces ' are defined via Fourier transforms. This seemed to be reasonable after L. Schwartz discovered in the late forties the im-
portance of the Fourier transform in the framework of the theory of distributions.
2.2. The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles
The spaces
35
' were introduced by N. Aronszajn, K. T. Smith [1] and A. P.
Calderon [1].
(v) Finally we mention the space BMO of functions of bounded mean oscillation,
cf. F. John, L. Nirenberg [1], and the n-dimensional real version of the Hardy spaces Hr, due to E. M. Stein, G. Weiss [1]. Besides these spaces, many extensions, generalizations, and modifications have
been treated extensively during the last 20 years: anisotropic spaces, weighted spaces, spaces with dominating derivatives, Lorentz spaces, Campanato-Morrey spaces, Orlicz spaces, Orlicz-Sobolev spaces etc. The third (systematic) period begins in the sixties and overlaps heavily with the constructive period. This inflation of the number of spaces demands simple and far-reaching methods which will enable us to deal with function spaces (either in the above restricted or in a wider sense)
from the point of view of a few general principles. The first remarkable success was achieved in the framework of the abstract interpolation theory of Banach spaces and its applications to function spaces (E. Gagliardo, J. L. Lions, E. Magenes,
J. Peetre, A. P. Calderon, 1960-1964). A thorough description of the theory of function spaces from the standpoint of interpolation theory and detailed references
have been given in [I], in particular in Chapter 2. Starting with simple spaces (e. g. L, Cm, WP) one obtains on the basis of general abstract procedures (interpolation methods) a lot of new spaces (e. g. A,q and H,) in a systematic way. The disadvantage of this method is that one needs "endpoint" spaces. At the end of the sixties and the beginning of the seventies, new methods (and essentially improved old methods) of Fourier analysis and of the theory of the so-called maximal inequalities gave a new impetus in the theory of function spaces (J. Peetre,
E. M. Stein, C. Fefferman in 1967-1975, detailed references will be given later on). With the help of these new far-reaching powerful techniques one can deal with all the above-mentioned function spaces in (i)-(v) (cf. also Fig. 2.2.1) from unified point of view and on the basis of very few general principles. All these spaces
are contained in the two scales BP q and FP, q, which are defined in the framework of methods of Fourier analysis. (In the case of the Hardy spaces H, and BMO one needs the so-called "local" versions, h1, and bnm, respectively. H and BMO are special homogeneous spaces of the type Fpq, of. Chapter 5.) Remark. References concerning the spaces B8 q and Fp,q will be given in 2.3.5. Of course, the above historical remarks about the "constructive" function spaces are very rough. Definitions of these spaces are given in the following subsection. In 2.3.5. we describe how the "basic" and "constructive" spaces are related with Bp q and Fy q. More detailed historical references concerning the "basic" and "constructive" spaces may be found in the note sections of S. M. Nikol'skij [3], A. Kufner, 0. John, S. Fu6ik [1, in particular Chapter 8] and [I, in particular Chapter 2]. The theory of the "constructive" spaces (and also of the "basic" spaces) has been treated extensively from several points of view in the books by R. A. Adams [1], 0. V. Besov, V. P. Il'in, S. M. Nikol'skij [1], A. Kufner, 0. John, S. Fucik [1], S. M. Nikol'skij [3], E. M. Stein [1], E. M. Stein, G. Weiss [2] and [I]. Systematic treatments in the framework of interpolation theory or Fourier analysis may be found in J. Peetre [8], [I], [F] and [S].
The Constructive Spaces We summarize the spaces from (i)-(v) of the preceding subsection as constructive
2.2.2.
spaces: We use the notations introduced in 1.2.1. and 1.2.2., in particular R,,, L1,(Rn) with If and O- p=oo (for the sake of clarity we add now the suffix Furthermore, as in those subsections, D" stands for derivative, F and F-1 denote the n-dimensional Fourier transform and its inverse on I
respectively. 3.
36
2. Function Spaces on B.
First we introduce C(R,,) as the set of all complex-valued bounded and uniformly continuous functions on R. If m = 1, 2, 3, ..., we define Cm(Rn)={f I DafEC(R,,) for all
IaI - m}.
(1)
Let C°(Rn) = C(R,,). Here Da are classical derivatives. Of course, Cm(Rn.) endowed with the norm 111
1 Cm(Rn)II = 2] IIDaf I L_(Rn)Il 1a1sm
is a Banach space. Concerning the space C(R,,) (and o'onsequently also for the spaces Cm(R,,,)) one has at least two other candidates: (i) the space of all bounded and con-
tinuous (but not necessarily uniformly continuous) functions on Rn and (ii) the completion of S(Rn) in C(Rn). The first space is larger and the second one is smaller
than C(R,,). There are some reasons (which will not be explained in detail at this moment) that C(R,,) is the best choice. After some "basic" spaces in the sense of 2.2.1. have been defined, we come to the constructive spaces and the Holder spaces. First we describe the spaces and the (in Remark 1, below) we give the necessary explanations. (i) The Holder spaces C8(Rn). If s is a real number, then (2) s = [s] + {s} with [s] integer and 0s {s} < 1 .
If s>-0 is not an integer, then C8(Rn)={f /EC[8](Rn) 111
1
(3)
,
C8(Rn)II =IIf I C[8](Rn)II + 2] lal=[8]
IDaf(x) -Daf(y)I
sup x$y
Ix-yi{8}
xER,y,YERn
(ii) The Zygmuftd spaces @8(Rn). If s is a real number, then
s=[s]-+{s}+ with [s]- integer and 0<{s}+- 1.
(4)
Furthermore, if I (x) is an arbitrary function on Rn and h E R, then (4U)(x) =f(x+h) -f(x), (d/)(x) = dn(di, 1f)(x) where 1 = 2, 3, ...and x E R,,. If s >- 0 then C8(Rn)
(5)
=U Y I IEC[8]-(R.), if I @8(Rn)II=IIf I C[8] (Rn)II sup hI -{8}+ II dhDaf I C(Rn)II <-) .
+I
(6)
O+hER,,
(iii' The Sobolev spaces W '(R,,). (R,,). If 1
1a1sm
(7)
Furthermore, W°r(Rn)=L,(Rn). (iv) The Slobodeckij spaces Wz,(Rn). If 1=p<- and 0<s+ integer, then WP(Rn)={f I IEW['](Rn), III WP(Rn)II =IIf I WP8](Rn)II I
i
f IDaf(x)-Daf(y)Ip
+ lal-[81
\ R n XR
n
Ix-yln+{8}p
(8)
2.2. The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles
and l -- q
(v) The Besov (or Lipschitz) spaces A' ,9(Rn). If s > 0, 1-- p As,q(Rn)=1f I fEWPS] (Rn), IIf I AP,s(Rn)II
37
(Rn)II
I WP 3]
1
+
(
Ial=[S]
IhI-{8]+glIA2DaII Lp(R.)II° Rn
then
(9)
1
d IhI
If s>0 and l p
(10)
II
(vi) The Bessel-potential (or Lebesgue or Liouville) spaces H,(Rn). If s is a real number and 1
d
H°p(Rn) _ {l I f ES'(R4), III I H' (Rn)II = II F-' (1 + Ix12) 2 Ff I LL(Rn)II < oo}.
(vii) The local Hardy spaces hy(Rn). If T(x) is a test function on Rn (i.e. an infinitely
differentiable function on Rn with compact support) with q?(0) = 1, then we put (pt(x) = T(tx) with x E Rn and t >-O. If 0-
hp(Rn) = {f I /ES'(Rn), III I h2,(Rn)II'=II sup IF-19,tF/I ILL(Rn)II
(viii) The space bmo(Rn). If f(x) is a locally Lebesgue-integrable function on R. and if Q is a cube in Rn, then /Q =
IQI
J
(13)
f(x) dx
Q
is the mean value offt I (x) with respect to Q. bmo(Rn) =
I f (x)
locally Lebesgue-integrable on R, ,
= sup IQI1 IQIt1
if
I/ I bmo(Rn)Il
(14)
f I/(x)-/eI dx+ sup-i IQI Q Q lei
Remark 1 (Technical explanations). Daf in (3) and (6) are classical derivations. On the other handDaf in (7)-(10) must be interpreted in the sense of distributions. In other words, /C Wv, (.n) means that the distribution / and all its derivatives Daf with Iat are regular and that they belong (interpreted as functions) to Lp(Rn). Similarly in (8)-10). We recall that F-1 (1 + 1x12)2 F f 8
8
then F-1 (1+Ix12)2FIE ES'(Rn) and one asks in (11) whether this is a regular distribution belonging to L5(Rn). Similarly, F-197tF/ in (12) means (F-1[ggt Ff]) (i). If ERn is fixed, then one takes in (12) the supremum of I (F-1[Tt Ff}) I with respect to t. Then one asks whether the result, considered as a function of seER,,, belongs to Lp(Rn). Finally, sup in (14) means that the suprein (11) means F-1 [(1+Ix12)2
1.5.1.If
IQI51
mum is taken over all cubes in Rn with I Q I 51, where I Q I is the volume of Q (similarly for sup ). 1Q1 -1
Remark 2. The definition of hp(Rn) is somewhat complicated. If f ES'(R,) then F-1ggtFf satisfies the hypotheses of the Paley-Wiener-Schwartz theorem, cf. Theorem 1.2.1/2. Hence, (F-1TtF/)($) is an analytic function with', respect to ZERn for every fixed t>0. Hence makes sense for any ERn and any f ES'(Rn). Furthermore, because sup
0-0t<1
38
2. Function Spaces on R.
92(0) =I we have
F-iq'tFf f in S'(Rn) if ty0. This shows that F-4 Fl is an approximation of f
(15)
by entire analytic functions. We return to problems of this type in2.2.4. As we shall see later on, is independent of the chosen test function qt(x). If q' and p are two test functions with q9(0) =V(0) =1, then the corresponding quasi-norms (norms if are equivalent to each other (the notion of a quasinorm has been explained in 1.2.2.). The definition (12) is due to D. Goldberg [1, 2]. It is the local (or better, non-homogeneous, in our language) version of the Hardy spaces H5(R,z).
C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2] have shown that the Hardy spaces Hp(R) (n-dimensional real version) which have been mentioned in 2.2.1. can be defined by (12) if one replaces sup
by sup. But t-0
0-t- I
is a homogeneous space and, as has been mentioned in 2.2.1., we wish
to work with non-homogeneous spaces. This is the reason why we prefer h. p(R,c) (later on, in Chapter 5, we return briefly to Hp(R,,) and homogeneous spaces, ef. 5.2.4.). Concerning BMO and bmo we have the same situation. bmo is a non-homogeneous space and BMO is a homogeneous one. The definition of BMO(R,) is the same as in (14) if one replaces f ! bmo(RJJ by If
i BMO(R,)JJ=su
p p-- Q J/(x)-fql d,,,
(16)
where the supremum is taken over all cubes Q in R,,. Remark 3. We mention some results which will be proved later on: if
1
(17)
If 1p-< and 0<s* integer then Wz,(R.) =A ,p(R.) and C'(R5,) =c '(Ra) . If 1
(18)
Wp(R..)=Hp(R..).
(19)
This justifies some assertions which we have made above: C-'(R,,) extends C3(R.) from 0<s$
integer to all values s>0 (it should be mentioned that Cm(R.) *
if m=1, 2.... ).
Furthermore, the scale H'p(R,c) contains the Sobolev spaces Wp (R,t) as special cases. Finally,
the Slobodeckij spaces WP
are special Besov spaces. This justifies the corresponding
lines drawn in Fig. 2.2.1.
Remark 4. We restricted p in (9) and (10) to 1
This is convenient at the moment,
but not necessary. Later on we include also values p<1.
2.2.3.
The Criterion
First we recall of the notion of a quasi-norm and a quasi-Banach space, explained in 1.2.2. The spaces which have been described in (i)-(viii) in 2.2.2. are Banach spaces, with the exception of if 0
(1)
in S'(R"). This means that we exclude from the very beginning the spaces Lp(R") with 0
which cannot be interpreted as subspaces of S' (Rn). Our task is to find simple
2.2. The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles
39
and convincing criteria and methods in order to select a sufficiently rich family of subspaces of S'(R,,) in the sense of (t). Hence, we can pose the question: Which of the spaces (1) are good. how do we find them and how do
(2)
the define them?
First of all, one must say what is meant by "good" spaces. This is a matter of taste. There are at least two different points of view concerning a criterion for a "good" space: (i) Simple definition. (ii) "Good" properties. What is meant by "simple definition" is quite clear. L2,(Rn) and Cm(Rn) (maybe
also WP(Rn)) have a simple definition. On the other hand, the definitions of Ap,q(Rn) and hp(R,,) look (at least at the first glance) complicated. Which properties
are "good" ones again depends on the task under consideration. Our point of view here is that we are looking for spaces which are useful in the theory of partial differential equations (in particular, elliptic differential equations). For instance,
the spaces Lp(R,,) with 1
L.,(R,,) and C(R,,) (and also Cm(Rn) with in = 1, 2, 3....) give rise to trouble. In order to give the last remarks a more precise meaning, we consider a (normed or quasi-normed) space A. which is continuously embedded in S'(Rn). Let Am={f I D'fEA if O-lal-m}. IllIAmII=
1a)sm
JD/ All.
Of course, Daf must be understood in the sense of distributions. Let A be the Lapla-
cian and let E be the identity mapping. From the standpoint of elliptic differential operators it seems to be reasonable to ask whether -A+E yields an isomorphic mapping from A2 onto A (and more generally, from Am+2 onto Am). For instance (as we shall see later on) A=Lp(Rn) with 1
22 liD°f I AII =cII(-A+E) f I All--c'
(1;/!!
All+il 8x' All)
(3)
holds for all /EA2. In particular, "mixed" derivatives DI can be estimated by "pure" derivatives. If one uses other elliptic differential operators, then it follows that corresponding assertions should also be valid for higher derivatives. One could take this as a "good" property and as a criterion we are looking for. However, a more qualitative formulation is desirable. If _ W E Rn and if a = (a1... n
an) is a multi-index, then ¢ = jI i;' by definition. It is not hard to see that the abovej=1
mentioned generalization of (3) yields
I All sc F-1 (1+
gym)
Ff i A
(4)
for every a with Ial = 2m and every /E A2m. The positive number c in (4) is independn
ent of /E A22m (and a). Let ma(d) _a 1 + m
1
. Then (4) can be reformulated
j=1
in the following way: there exists a positive constant c such that F-lmaFf
II
I All:elif 1 All
(5)
40
2. Function Spaces on R
holds for every a with Iaj m2m and every f EA. If mO=ma(d), then we have
sup (1+ D'' Dam( )I
(6)
EERn
for any multi-index 9. This describes the qualitative behaviour of 7na(E), which fits very well with the topology in S(R,,), cf. (1.2.1./1). Thus it seems to be reasonable
to take the class of all infinitely differentiable functions m(x) which satisfy (6) for every multi-index j as the qualitative generalization of the above functions M.W.
Definition. The quasi-normed space A is said to have the weak Fourier multiplier property if, for any complex-valued infinitely differentiable function on Rn, which satisfies (6) for every multi-index fl, there exists a positive constant c such that IIF-1mF1 I All `cII/ I All
(7)
holds for any f EA. Remark 1. A function m(g) with (7) is called a Fourier multiplier for A. The above definition is close to the well-known Michlin-Hormander multiplier theorem for with 1-
Criterion. The space A has the weak Fourier multiplier property. Remark 2. This is the criterion we are looking for. As we shall see, all "constructive" spaces listed in (i)-(viii) in 2.2.2. satisfy this criterion (including L7,(R,,) with 1-p-m). On the other hand the remaining spaces L,,(R,,) and with k=0, 1, 2, ... do not have the weak Fourier multiplier property. A proof of this assertion may be found in [S, pp. 21-23]. What about the weaker property (3) for these exceptional spaces? If n u2, then again the answer is negative. We refer to J. Boman [1], K. DeLeeuw, H. Mirkil [1], O. V. Besov [3] and D. Ornstein [1]. Cf. also the footnote of the editor of the Russian edition of [I, p. 407].
2.2.4.
Decomposition Method, the Principle
In the preceding subsection we have given a criterion for "good" spaces (from our point of view). The next task is to find a general method for the construction of such spaces. On the one hand such method should be as simple as possible, while on the other it should be sophisticated enough to cover all the spaces from 2.2.1. and 2.2.2. as far as they satisfy the Criterion 2.2.3 (cf. Remark 2.2.3/2). Spectral Decomposition. In order to provide a feeling for what happens we start
with some considerations in the framework of spectral theory of self adjoint operators in Hilbert spaces. Let H be a complex separable Hilbert space endowed with the norm Let T be a positive-definite self-adjoint operator in H with the spectral decomposition
T j = f tdE(t) I, 0
where {E(t)}t,0 stands for the spectral measure of T. Then T8/= f t8dE(t) f with 0
2.2. The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles
41
are the usual fractional powers of T. More generally, 9,(T) /= f p(t) dE(t) / . 0
If a>-1, then IIT81112= f t28dDDE(t) /112HIIE(1) /112+ 2] a2ia11xla;-1,aj)(T) /112
,
j=
(1)
where x[aj-1
aj) is the characteristic function of the interval [aj-1, ai). Furthermore, "" means that the right-hand side of (1) can be estimated from above
and from below by the left-hand side with the aid of positive constants which are independent of / (belonging to the domain of definition of T8). In this sense, (1) is a characterization of II T'/Ii by means of spectral decompositions. Let us consider two examples. Let
H=L2(Rn) and
(T/)(x) = (1 + Ix12) /(x)
(2)
.
Then it is easy to see that (T(T) /)(x) = T (1 + Ix12) /(x). An immaterial modification of (1) yields IIT81 I L2(Rn)II2^ a4jsllx;a)(.) j=0
I L2(R.)112
(3)
,
where x,!a)(x) is the characteristic function of {x I aj-1 = Ix1
.. .
weight 1 + 1x12. We consider a second example. Let H = L2(Rn) and (V/)(x) = (- zl +E) /(x) ,
(4)
and xoa)(x) is the characteristic function of {x I xl < 11. Roughly speaking, (3) is a decomposition of /(x) with respect to its "weight properties", expressed by the
where d is again the Laplacian and E stands for the identity. The operators T and V in (2) and (4), respectively, and their functions g are related to each other by
V=F-1TF, q(V)=F(T)F,
(5)
where F and F-1 have the same meaning as before, cf. 1.2.1. In particular, the counterpart of (3) is given by 11v8/ I L2(Rn)112^'
a4j8IIF-lxP(a)F/
j=o
(6)
I L2(Rn)112 1
2
a4ja 1 (F-1x7(a)pl) (.)12)2 I L2(Rn)
This is a decomposition of / with respect to its "differentiability properties" (expressed by - /I +E). In particular, s is a smoothness index. Now we take the idea of a decomposition of smoothness in the sense of (6) as motivation and return to our original task. Because we wish to include all spaces from 2.2.1. and 2.2.2. (as far as they fulfil Criterion 2.2.3.) we are forced to generalize the above L2-setting. (6) involves an l2-norm (with respect to j) and an L2(Rn)norm, where one can change the order (first L2(Rn) and then 12 or vice versa). If one replaces 12 by lq and L2 by L, then one obtains the following two generalizations of (6) : IIaj8F 1x,`a)F/ l4(LP)II I
IIa78F-1X j(a)F/ I L(l4)II ,
and
(7) (8)
where we used the abbreviations introduced in (1.2.2/5) and (1.2.2/6). Furthermore, Both (7) and (8) are quasi-norms. we again recall that
42
2. Function Spaces on R.
Now one would try to define a space A consisting of all f such that the quasinorm (7) is finite. Similarly with (8) instead of (7). In order to discuss such a possi-
bility we ask some questions: (i) Since the Fourier transform is involved it seems reasonable that at least the Schwartz space S(R,,) be a subspace of A (continuous embedding). (ii) The number in the above arguments has been chosen arbitrarily. In
particular, the spaces in (6) are independent of a. Thus it seems reasonable to ask whether A is also independent of a 1 (of course. one would expect A to depend on s, p, q; similarly if one replaces (7) by (8)).
In order to discuss question (i) we take for sake of simplicity n =1 (onedimensional case). If f ES(R1) such that (Ff)(x) = 1 for jxj =1 then we have (F-1xoa1Ff)(x) = (F 1Zoa))(x) = c sin x
x
c $ 0.
This shows that fIA if 0=p-_ 1 (also if one replaces (7) by (8)). This calculation X(P), shows that it would be reasonable to replace xoa), and more generally
by smooth
functions qj. Such a replacement has several advantages. Let us assume that (Pi is a test function (i.e. a function from S(R,,) with compact support). In that case F-1p;Ff makes sense for any f ES'(R.) (and belongs also to Furthermore, by the Paley-Wiener-Schwartz theorem (cf. Theorem 1.2.1/2) (F-199iF1)(x) is an analytic function. In other words., if one replaces {xra)}?*o in (7) by an appropriate
sequence {qj};-.o of test functions then the question of whether the so-modified quasi-norm is finite makes sense for any f (similarly for (8)). A detailed discussion of the above problem (ii) yields the same result: the characteristic functions 40 are not smooth enough to guarantee that A is independent of a in. some cases. Hence it will be reasonable to replace the resolution of unity
1=(x). xE Rn j=o
,
(9)
by a smooth resolution of unity, xER,,..
(10)
j=o
The problem is the following: on the one hand we wish to preserve the above decomposition of differentiability properties of f of. (6) and the attempted generalizations (7) and (8). On the other hand, we are forced to replace the non-
smooth resolution of unity (9) by the smooth resolution (10). The best possible choice which fits with both requirements is the following. Let 00) (with a:--1) be the set of all systems {q (x) }-o c S(R,,) satisfying (10) such that Jsupp(Toc{xI Jx;--a}, if j-1, 2, 3.... supp g;jc{x I aj-1-- I sup ail-I IDag5(x)i
(11) (12)
X E R,a
There exist systems with these properties. If {qj}Eo(a) is a fixed system then we replace x(¢) in (7) and (8) by 99j, respectively, and define spaces {f i fES'(R..) , 1jai8F-1TjFf I le(L,)II
(13)
{f I /ES'(R,) , (Iai8F-1c1Ff I LL(l5)II.oo} .
(14)
It is easy to see that p = q = 2 yields essentially (6) with 2s instead of s. In other words: (13) and (14) are generalizations of (6) which have the advantage of cir-
2.2. The Historical Background, Motivations, and Principles
43
cumventing the troubles raised by the characteristic functions in (7) and (8). Again one would ask the above questions (i) and (ii), and furthermore, one would ask whether the spaces in (13) and (14) are independent of {upf}E0(a). One has affirm-
ative answers for all --<s<-, 0
0
the above-mentioned exception) satisfy Criterion 2.2.3. This will be proved later on.
For the moment we take the underlying method as the basis of our further considerations. Principle. The space A from the Criterion 2.2.3. will be constructed by measuring
the decomposition {F-1TjFf};_0 of the differentiability properties of /ES'(Rf,) via the quasi-norms (1.2.2/5) and (1.2.2/6) in the sense of (13) and (14). Thus we have established one criterion (the weak Fourier multiplier property
from 2.2.3.) and one principle (decomposition of differentiability properties of tempered distributions IES' (Rn)) in order to construct a sufficiently rich family of function spaces which contains the spaces from 2.2.1. and 2.2.2. as special cases (as far as they satisfy Criterion 2.2.3.). Remark 1. Perhaps at first glance it seems a little astonishing that (13) and (14) make sense even if p<1. We recall that Lp(R.) with p-1 is a bad space from the standpoint of Fourier analysis. However the situation is similar to that in (2.2.2/12), where we defined the local Hardy spaces Both F-1gpjFf in (2.2.2./12) and F-1opjF1 in (13), (14) are analytic functions in R,,; and hence they do not have the nasty local singularities that a function f (x) E Lp(R.) with p< 1 may have (e. g. f (x) = Ixl -n near the origin). The basic idea in (2.2.2/12) and in (14) is similar: By (2.2.2/15), F-'ipFf is an approximation of f ES'(R,,) by analytic functions, meas-
ured in an Lp(L,.)-quasi-norm. On the other hand, (14) is a decomposition of f ES'(B,,) by analytic functions measured in an Lp(lq)-quasi-norm.
Remark 2. What about the exceptional case p = -, 0 G q G oo in (14) ? In that case, one must modify (14) somewhat, cf. 2.3.4. After this modification, the corresponding spaces with p=-
and 1
from (2.2.2/14) is a special case.
Remark 3. We mention an interesting special case of (14). If s = 0, 1
coincides with Lp(R,,). This is essentially the famous Littlewood-Paley theorem for Lp(Rn). On the other hand, this assertion sheds also new light upon (14), which may also be considered as a generalization of this theorem. Remark 4. The spaces in (13) and (14) are described as non-homogeneous (or local) spaces.
In Chapter 5 we deal with their homogeneous counterparts (including the modifications in the sense of Remark 2), which contain as special cases the usual Hardy spaces Hp(B ) and
2.2.5.
Approximation Procedures
In 2.2.2. we characterized smoothness of functions (as elements of function spaces) by the classical means of derivatives D" and differences dh (at least in the spaces (i)-(v) in 2.2.2.). Since the fundamental thesis of D. Jackson in 1911 it has beena well-known fact that smoothness of functions can also be expressed by approximation procedures. We discuss briefly this possibility because it offers new insights into the structure of (2.2.4/13) and (2.2.4/14), which hold a key position in our approach.
Let T={x I -rrsxs r} be the 1-torus where the endpoints -r. and n are identified. In other words, we deal temporarily with 27r-periodic functions. Let c'N be the set of all trigono-
44
2. Function Spaces on R.
metric polynomials N
PN(x)= 7_ akeikz k=-N
xET.
(1)
Of course, N>O is an integer. If 0
dN= inf (f 11(x)-PN(x)IPdx)P? PNE51y T
(2)
We assume that f (x) is p-integrable on T. By Weierstrass' theorem it follows that dNlO if NOf course, dN is monotonically decreasing. Of interest is how rapidly dN decreases. What we have
in mind is a characterization of functions which guarantees that N=1
N,Qdq<_, s_0, 0
(3)
We -wish to have a one-to-one relation between smoothness properties of functions and assertions of type (3).
Now we try to translate the one-dimensional periodic case to J. What is the counterpart of a trigonometric polynomial? A trigonometric polynomial in T can be characterized as an integrable function on T with only a finite number of its Fourier coefficients being diffe-
rent from zero. In other words, an integrable function on T is a trigonometric polynomial if and only if the set of its non-vanishing Fourier coefficients is compact. But this formulation makes sense in Rn, too, if one replaces the Fourier coefficients by the Fourier transform. Hence, by the Paley-Wiener-Schwartz theorem, cf. Theorem 1.2.1/2, we are looking for approximations by functions
9ES'(R.), suppFgc{yIIyN}.
(4)
The counterpart of (2) reads as follows: (5) dN=inf!I/-9 I LP(R,)II , where f ES'(R,,) f1 Lp()?n) with 0
by (5)). It is easy to see that it is sufficient (and convenient) to deal only with N=2j in (5), where j =0, 1, 2, ... A second reason for that "dyadic" procedure is the structure of (2.2.4/13) and (2.2.4/14) (this will be clearer just now). Then (3) (with (5)) can be reformulated (and slight-
ly generalized) in the following way. If 0
(6)
supp Faj c {y I IyI =2j+1}} .
Ifs > 0, 0
the restrictions 0
--1) I , 1
cf. Theorem 2.5.3. The approxi-
mation procedure (7) is meaningless if s<0, in contrast to (2.2.4/13) which makes sense for all
- - <s < -, 0
0
this sense we modify (6) by 0p(Rn)= {b I b={bj(x)}j=0 ,
supp Fb0c{y I IyI =2},
bjES'(Rn)
supp Fbjc{y 12i-1-_IyIs2j+1} if
(8)
j=192,3.... },
where 0
3bElp(Rn)
with i bk= f k=0
II23ibj
1 lq(Lp)II - -) -
in
S'(Rn) ,
(9)
45
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
If a=2 in (2.2.4/11) and (2.2.4/12) then bk=F-1pkFl is a special decomposition. Now it does not come as a surprise that (2.2.4/13) and (9) coincide for all parameters - - <s < -, 0
I
Lp(lq)IJ, cf. (1.2.2/5). Detailed formulations
and proofs will be given later on.
2.3.
Definition and Fundamental Properties
2.3.1.
Definition
In Section 2.3. we give the definition of the spaces Bp,q and F', in the sense of the Principle 2.2.4 and the formulas (2.2.4/13) and (2.2.4/14) (this subsection),
and we prove some fundamental properties, including an affirmative answer concerning the problem raised in Criterion 2.2.3. However the main result of this section is the maximal inequality proved in 2.3.6., which plays a key role in the further considerations of this chapter. We use the notions from 1.2.1. and 1.2.2. For the sake of clarity we now write S(R,,)
and S'(R,n) (instead of S and S') for the Schwartz space and the space of tempered distributions on R,,, respectively. Furthermore, we replace Ilk I Lp(lq)II from (1.2.2/5) by II/k I Lp(R,, l9)IJ and II/k I lq(Lp)II from (1.2.2/6) by II/k I lq(Lp(Rn))II
Definition 1. Let 0 (Rn) be the collection of all sytems 99 = {qgj(x)}!=o c S(Rn) such
that (1)
supp g9oc {x I I x I =2} ,
{supp q'j c {x 12j-1-_ IxI < 2j+1}
if j =1, 2, 3, ... ,
for every multi-index a there exists a positive number cQ such that 2h'l JDag9j(x)I:ca for all j=0, 1, 2, ... and all xER.
(2)
and
for every xERn.
99j(x)=1
(3)
j=o
Remark 1. First we remark that rh(R,) coincides with c(a) from 2.2.4. if a=2. In this sense, is not empty. Let 05p(x) E is a smooth resolution of unity. Next we prove that with supp +yc{x
2SIxI-2} and
Let pj(x) =y (2 -jx) I
y(2-kx))
V(x)>-0
if
y2 =IxIsV2
(4)
if j=1,2,3.... and To(x) =1-
Then it is easy
j=1
111 k=
to see that q7={g7j(x)}j=o E'P(Rn)
Definition 2. Let - - s < oo and 0
(i) If 0
(5)
(ii) If 0
I /ES'(R4), IIf I Fp (Rn)II I Lp(Rn, l9)II
46
2. Function Spaces on R7z
not so for the spaces
and Fp,q(Rn) itself (this will be proved in the next subsection).
This justifies our notation. Remark 3. In comparison with the discussion in 2.2.4. we fixed a=2 from the very beginning. On the basis of the considerations in 2.3.2. it is not hard to see that the above space Bp,q(Rn) can also be defined via (2.2.4/13) with a -l and {ggj(x)}j=oEO(a). Similarly for Fy,q(R.n). In this sense the spaces defined by (2.2.4/13) with - -<s< _, O
Remark 4. What about p = in (6) ? One can show that in this case (6) does not make sense. In particular, a corresponding space is not independent of 99E0(.R ). However the proof of the last assertion is complicated and we refer for details to [S, 2.1.4], where we proved a "non-multiplier" theorem. Later on, we introduce spaces Fo,,q(Rn) with 1
2.3.2.
Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Elementary Embeddings
The notion of a quasi-norm has been described in 1.2.2. We say that two quasinorms 11aI11 and IIa112 on a given linear vector space A are equivalent to each other if there exist two positive numbers c1 and c2 such that and 11-112 = c2I1aI11 for every a E A. Iall1 c1IlaI12 Proposition 1. Let 9 = {q
E fi(R8) and
_ { y f(x)
(i) If -00<s<-, 0
I
E fi(lm).
B,,q(R8.)II'P and III I B,,q(Rn.)I1Ware
equivalent quasi-norms on BP,q(Rn). (ii) If 0
Proof. Step 1. We prove
(i).
It is easy to see that both jlf
I FP,q(Rn)Ilw
1 BP,q(Rn)11 ' and
B,,q(Rn)11'"' are quasi-norms. In order to prove the equivalence of these two quasi-norms we apply (1.5.2/13). We recall that H2 = W!(Rn) are the usual Sobolev spaces if m=1, 2, 3, ... , nornied by (1.5.2/3). If 1s_1-0, then we have ggi(x)= llf
1
= q'Ax) 2] Pi+r(x), where j = 0, 1, 2.... Consequently, r=-1
1
F-1
.
(1)
If we replace f, M and b in (1.5.2/13) by F-tVf+rFf, q'i and d2i, respectively, where
d=0 is an appropriate number, then we obtain
F-'gciFF-11Vi+rFII Lp(Rn)Il =cIIgg7(d2'') I W!(Rn)IIIIF-1,1Vj+rFf I Lp(Rn)II , (2)
where c is independent of j. Of course, we assume that m is sufficiently large. Now
it follows from (2.3.1/2) and (2.3.1/1) that 11Ti(d2'')
I
W2'(Rn)Il <=c
for
j=0, 1, 2....
(3)
Hence there exists a positive constant c such that IIF-1wiwj+rF! I Lp(Rn)II
=c1IF-1
i+rFf I Lp(Rn)II
(4)
for j = 0, 1 , 2.... and r = -1, 0, 1. But this proves that li f I BP,q(Rn)I) q' can be estimated from above by ell/ I BP q(Rn)Ilw. Hence these two quasi-norms are equivalent to each other. Step 2. The proof of part (ii) is the same if one replaces (1.5.2/13) by (1.6.3/1).
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
47
Remark. If one extends (2.3.1/6) to p = - and 0 - q - oo, then the corresponding assertion of part (ii) of the above proposition (with p = - and 0
In the following proposition, Al c A2 always means that the quasi-normed space
Al is continuously embedded in the quasi-normed space A2, i.e. there exists a constant c such that IIa I A2I1`clla I A111 holds for all aEA1. Proposition 2. (i) Let 0
BP,4t(Rn)
if
0-
(5)
Fp,go(Rn)eFp,gt(Rn)
if
0
(6)
BA-`4.(R,,) c Bp,41(Rn)
if
RP,4o(Rn)
(ii) Let 0-0. Then and
0--P--
(7)
F qu(Rn)CF8, q,(Rn,) if 0-_p-<-. (iii) if 0
(8)
BP,min(P,4)(Rn) C FP,4(Rn) c B P,max(P,q)(Rn) .
(9)
Proof. Step 1. (5) and (6) are simple consequences of the Inonotinicity of the l1-spaces, cf. (1.2.2/4). Similarly, (7) and (8) follow from 1
1 `1g141
Ibk1g1\41
(5,2 skg1 k=0
sup 2(s+')k k
c sup 2(s+e)k b11
I bkl
l=0
k
and (5) or (6) (modification if q1= 00).
Step 2. We prove (iii). If /ES'(Rn) and T={g2k(x)}k_cEO(Rn) then we put ak(x) = 23k(F-1(PkF/)(x). We shall use the generalized triangle inequality for Banach
spaces. If 0
i4
Ilak I lp(Lp(Rn))II -_ IIak
I Lp(Rn, lq)II =
L+ Iaklq I Lp (Re)
k=0
4 1
=(
k=O
II Iaklq I
Lp(Rn)II)q =Ilak I l4(Lp(Rn))II . q
If 0
flak
I lq(Lp(Rn))II -II f l akI p dx 11411 p Rn
P 1
f IIIaklp lgll dx)p =Ilak I Lp(Rn, lq)II=flak 11'(Lp(Rn))II I
Rn
P
We used the abbreviation (1.2.2/4). 2.3.3.
Basic Properties
The notion of a quasi-Banach space has been introduced in 1.2.2. The topology The topological dual of the locally convex space S(Rn) is generated by S'(Rn) of S(Rn) is equipped with the strong topology. If A is a quasi-normed space, then S(Rn) c A always means continuous (topological) embedding. Similarly
Ac
48
2. Function Spaces on R.
Theorem. (i) B-' ,,(R,,) is a quasi-Banach space if --<s<-, 0
(1)
for 0
space if 1--p<- and 1--q---), and the quasi-norms IIf I Fp,q(Rn)II1 with (pEI(R,,) and IIf I Fp,q(Rn)II'o with y,EO(Rn) are equivalent. Furthermore,
S(R,,) c F,,q(Rn) c S'( Rn)
(2)
for --<s<-, 0
Proof. Step 1. The equivalence of the quasi-norms in (i) as well as in (ii) has been proved in Proposition 2.3.2/1. Furthermore, in order to prove (1) and (2) we may restrict ourselves to (1) with q=oo. This follows from Proposition 2.3.2/2. Step 2. We prove the left-hand side of (1) with q = -. Let / E S(Rn) and 99 = {92k(x) }k=0
EO(R,,). We recall that F yields a one-to-one mapping from S(Rn) onto itself, in particular pN(F99) from (1.2.1/1) with N=1, 2, 3, . . . generates the topology of S(Rn). If L, M and N are sufficiently large natural numbers, then IIf
I B*',W(Rn)Ilw-sup 218IIF-1TkFf I LP(Rn)II k
sup
2k8II(1+Ix!2)2LF-19'kFf
k
I L_(Rn)II
= sup 2k8 IIF-1 (1 + (- d)L) 99kF/ I L_(Rn)I L.
c' II (1 +IxJ)M (1+(-4)L) Ff i L-(Rn)II -_ c'pN(F/)
Here, c and c' are appropriate positive numbers. Step 3. We prove the right-hand side of (1) with q = =. If T E O(R,,) is the above system, then we put xk(x)=q9k_1(x)+gpk(x)+Tk+1(x) if k=0, 1, 2, ... (with q _1=0). Then we have xk(x) =1 if x E supp Tk. If I E BP,,,(R,,) and V E S(Rn), then /(e) denotes the value of the functional/ of S'(Rn) for the test function V. We obtain 2] F-19'kF/(FxkF-1'W) k=0 (3)
k=0
IIF-'TkF1 i L_(Rn)II
IIFxkF-1y,
I L1(Rn)I
Recall that both F-19gkF/ and FxkF-1lp are analytic functions. Hence, the last estimate makes sense. We wish to use (1.3.2/5) with a=(0, ... , 0), q=and b=2'. The approximation procedure from the proof of Theorem 1.4.1 shows that (1.3.2/5) is applicable to F-1q? F/. Hence, k IIF-192kF/ I L_(Rn)II =c2PIIF-1g2kF/ I LP(Rn)Ii
Putting this estimate into (3) we find that I/(V)I `cIIf I Bp,-(RC)II
k=0
- 8k+k 2PIIFxkF-1Y1 I L1(Rn)II
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
49 _
The last sum can be estimated from above by IV I
B1,1
n
+p(Rn)II
r. By Step 2, the
n
left-hand side of (1) holds for B4,11'(Rn). Consequently, if N is a sufficiently large natural number, then we have l/(V)I `ell/ I B',m(Rn)Ih PN('V)
(4)
for any p ES(Rn). This proves that B',_(R.) is continuously embedded in S'(Rn). Hence, (1) and (2) are proved. Step 4. Bp,q(R,,) is a quasi-normed space. We prove the completeness. Let {ft}i=1 be a fundamental sequence in BP,q(Rn) (with respect to a fixed quasinorm in Bp,q(Rn)). Then (1) shows that {/,}F=l is also a fundamental sequence in S'(Rn). Because S'(Rn) is complete we find a limit element f ES'(Rn). If qq= ={pk(x)}k=oEO(Rf), then F-1 F/1 converges to F-lg7kFf in S'(Rn) if 1---. On the other hand {F-1gkFfl}1-1 is a fundamental sequence in Lp(Rn). By Theorem 1.4.1 it is also a fundamental sequence in L (R8). This shows that the limiting element of {F-1gkFfa}I-1 in Lp(Rn) (which is the same as in coincides with F-1gvkFf. Now it follows by standard arguments that f belongs to B,,q(Rn) and that / converges in Bp,g(Rn) to I. Hence, Bp,q(Rn) is complete. Similarly for F,5q(Rn).
Step 5. We prove that S(R,,) is dense in F-p,,(R,,) if O
0-
N
/N(x) = _Y F-1wkFl . k =0
Of course, fNEFp,q(Rn) Consequently, 1
q
III-IN I
Fp,q(Rn)11'P =c
k=N r=-1
2a1q I F-1gpkpk+ _Fll q
Lp(Ra)
and by Theorem 1.6.3. and (2.3.2/3) 1
IIl-lN I F,,q(Rn)IIq<-c
I
(k 28kgIF-t91kF1lq)q I Lp(Rn)
(5)
Lebesgue's bounded convergence theorem proves that the right-hand side of (5) tends to zero if N---. Hence, fN approximates f in F'p,q(R,,). Next we apply the smoothness procedure from Step 1 of the proof of Theorem 1.4.1. Then (fN)aES(Rn) approximates /y in Lp with Q={y I lyl 2k+2}. But this is also an approximation of /,y in Fp q(Rn). This proves that S(Rn) is dense in F',q(Rn). A similar argument is valid for Bpq(Rn) with 0
is not dense in B; ,q(R.), Bp,-(.R,,)
and Fp,-(R,) if 0
4
Triebel, Function engl.
50
2. Function Spaces on Rn
2.3.4.
The Spaces
We mentioned several times that an extension of (2.3.1/6) to p = - does not make sense if 0
with 1
Definition. If --<s<. , 1
ll
I f ES'(R,),
3 {/k(x)}k=o cL (Rn)
such that (1)
/_ jF-'TkF/k in k=0
if I Fm,q(1ln)Ilro=ice
S'(R,) and II2s1/k I L.(Rn, lq)II<°°l J
II23k/k
I L.(Rn, lq)II ,
(2)
where the infimum is taken over all admissible representations of fin the sense of (1). Remark 1. Recall that F-1g9kFlk=F-1[99kF/k] and II ' 2.3.1. and (1.2.2/5),
lq)lI has the same meaning as in
I
1
II28k/k I L..(Rn, lq)II = SUP XERry
k=0
2skgl/k(x)Iq, q
(3)
Remark 2. There is no difficulty in extending (1) and (2) to 0
If 0
Proposition 1. If --((<s<-, 1
3{/k(x)}k=ocLp(Rn)
such that
l`/=
(4)
S F-1pkFlk in
and II28k/k I Lp(Rn, lq)II1'<
k=0
Furthermore, inf
II28k/k
I Lp(Rn, lq)I(11
(5)
is an equivalent norm in Fp,q(Rn), where the infimum is taken over all admissible representations of fin the sense of (4).
Proof. If /EFj,,q(Rn), we choose fk= 2] F-1pk+rF/ (with ip_1=0). Then it follows that/ r=-1 belongs to the space on the right-hand side of (4) and that (5) can be estimated from above by till I FP,q(Rn)IJ'p. In order to prove the reverse statement we use the lq-valued Lp(Rn)Fourier multiplier theorem of Michlin-Hormander, cf. (2.4.8/7) and Remark 2.4.8/1. If / is given by the right-hand side of (4) then it follows from that theorem that II2skF-19,kF/ I Lp(Rn, lq)II ScII2sk/k I Lp('Iln, lql]
I
where c is independent of {/k}. Taking the infimum on the right-hand side we obtain the desired assertion.
Hence (1) and, its generalization to p instead of - in the sense of (4) is only of interest for limiting cases, and - seems to be the most interesting one. By Theorem 2.3.3 (ii) the Schwartz space S(2 ) is dense in F),q(Rn) if --<$<-, 0
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
51
(2.3.3/2). If (Fp,q(Rn))' is the topological dual of Fp,q(R,,) then we have by the usual interpretation (which will be explained in more detail in 2.11.1.) S(Rn) I (FP,q(Rn))' c S'(Rn)
Proposition 2. If - oe <s < oe and 1 S q
then
(F ,q(Rn)) =r-,q'(Rn) 1
1
q
q
(6)
with -+-=1. Remark 3. This is a special case of Theorem 2.11.2 (recall that F,,'w(Rn)=B,oo(Rn)). Consequently, the spaces F.',,q(Rn) from the above definition can be interpreted as the dual
spaces of the Banach spaces
again with
1
4
1
+q,=1 I . In particular, Fmq(Rn)
from(1) is a Banach space, endowed with the norm (2), it is independent-of the choice of q' EO(Rn),
and the norms (2) are equivalent to each other for different qi's. Our method concerning the spaces Fo,,q(Rn) from (1) is the following: properties, which have been proved for the spaces O
2.3.5.
An Orientation and Some Historical Remarks
As we mentioned in 2.1., the main aim of Chapter 2 is the thorough study of the spaces BB,q()?n)
and FF,q(Rn) from Definition 2.3.1/2 (and Definition 2.3.4). Our standpoint is to collect suffilciently many properties in order to deal successfully with regular elliptic boundary value problems in corresponding spaces B,,q(Q) and F,,q(Q) on smooth bounded domains Sl in R. (Chapters 3 and 4). This was our point of view in 2.2.3. Concerning the spaces on Rn this led us to Criterion 2.2.3. An affirmative answer for the spaces Bp,q()?n) and FF,q(Rn) will be given in 2.3.7. Of course, for our task we need a lot of other properties for the spaces on Rn, which will be proved step by step in this chapter: several types of equivalent quasi-norms, interpolation assertions, embeddings, traces on hyperplanes, Fourier multipliers, pointwise multipliers, diffeomorphism properties etc. The maximal inequality from 2.3.6. plays a key role in all our later considerations.
The Spaces from 2.2.2. Another aim will be to prove that the "basic" and "constructive" spaces from 2.2.1. and 2.2.2. are special cases of the two scales Bp,q and Fp,q, insofar as they satisfy Criterion 2.2.3. By Remark 2.2.3./2, Remark 2.2.2/3 and the list in 2.2.2. we must consider: the Holder-Zygmund spaces P.8(R) with s>0; the Bessel-potential spaces H'p(Rn) with 1 0, 15p
In order to provide orientation we formulate some results which will be proved, later on. We have: 3
(Rn)=8;,,..()?n)
s>0,
H,(Rn)=F ,2(Rn)
if 1
Ap,q(Rn)=Bp,q(Rn)
if
s>0, 15p-oo, 15q
kp(Rn)=I''P,2(Bn)
if
OGp<00,
bmo(Rn)=F0,2(Rn) 4*
if
(1)
(2)
00,
(3) (4) (5)
2. Function Spaces on R.
52
Concerning the proofs we refer to 2.5.6., 2.5.7., 2.5.8. and 2.5.12. In other words, after (1)(5) and (2.2.2/17)-(2.2.2/19) have been established, we shall know that all "basic" and "constructive" spaces from 2.2.1. and 2.2.2. which satisfy Criterion 2.2.3. are special cases of the spaces BPq(Rn) and .F ,q(Rn). Remark. Bp q(Rn) and FP q(Rn) are non-homogeneous spaces. In Chapter 5 we deal briefly with their homogeneous counterparts BP q(Rn) and FP,q(R). Then (4) and (5) read as follows, HP(Rn)=F'P,2(Rn)
01p<m,
if
(6)
BMO(R,,.)=,P0,2(Rn)
(7)
where HP(Rn) and BMO(Rn) are the usual (real n-dimensional) Hardy spaces and the space of all functions of bounded mean oscillation in the sense of Remark 2.2.2/2, respectively.
Historical Remarks. We add a few historical remarks and references as far as the spaces B, q(Rn) and FP q(Rn) are concerned. The definition of BP,q(Rn) with 15p5c is due to J. Peetre [2] (with a forerunner in L. Hormander [2] if p=q=2). A systematic treatment of his results has been given in J. Peetre [8] (in this book, in particular in the notes at the end of the chapters, one can find further references and comments). The definition of the spaces with 1
In particular, S q=Fy q(Rn), where £P q are the spaces introduced in P. I. Lizorkin [4]. The surprising extension of By q(Rn) to p<1 is due to J. Peetre [4]. In J. Peetre [8, pp. 225227] one can find a vivid description of how he discovered that possibility. In particular, he em-
phasizes that there was a forerunner by T. M. Flett [1] (based in turn on classical ideas of G. H. Hardy and J. E. Littlewood). The key paper by C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2] gave also a new impetus to the theory of the spaces FP q(Rn,). On the basis of the technique of maximal functions, J. Peetre [6] observed that the definition of the spaces FP q(R,,) can be extended to 0
Furthermore, (3) was known from the very beginning (after the spaces B, q(Rn) had been defined via Definition 2.3.1/2). Further references may be found in [I, pp. 179 and 190]. (1) has been proved in H. Triebel [9] (the homogeneous case is due to B. Grevholm [1], cf. also J. Peetre [3]). (6) is essentially due to J. Peetre [5, 6], cf. also H. Triebel [13] for a more general case and [S, p. 167]. The proof of (4) follows the same line, cf. also Bui Huy Qui [1]. Finally, (7) (and similarly (5)) is proved in H. Triebel [13] and [S, p. 170].
2.3.6.
Maximal Inequalities
Maximal inequalities play a fundamental role in our later considerations. It is not complicated to re-formulate (1.4.1/2) and (1.6.2/1) in the language of the spaces B,,q(Rn) and E .q(Rn), respectively. However the, corresponding assertions are not sufficient for our later purposes. We need some essential generalizations. Definition 1. If L is a natural number then cRL(R,,) is the collection of all systems = {(pj(x) }/_c c S(R,,) of functions with compact supports such that (1)
C(9,) = sup xERn
x1L
IaInL
'jD*9,0(x)j +
sup xERn,-{0}
(t xHL+ jxj-L) 2] jD1q'j(2gx)j <°° Io
L
j=1,2,3
Remark 1. D"gpj(2jx) means that the derivative Da (with respect to xERn) is applied to the function gj(x) =ggj(2jx). An important example of such a system 99 can be obtained if one starts with appropriate functions ipc(x) and ip(x) and puts 92j(x) =y,(2-ix) if j= 1, 2, 3.... Of course, for every natural number L, cf. Definition 2.3.1/1. (P(Rn)
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
53
Definition 2. If L is a natural number, OP = {OPj(x)}Ir=o EckL(Rf), f E S'(Rn) and a>-0,
then 4i f) (x) = sup
I
YERn
(F-i 1F/)(x-y)I
x E Rn
1 + I2'yj5
(2)
(maximal function), )=0, 1, 2, .. . Remark 2. In any case, (F-1piFf)(x) is an analytic function, cf. Theorem 1.2.1/2. Hence, (2) makes sense if one does not exclude (rye f)(x) _ o. In order to discuss the last possibility we remark that for x E Rn and z E Rn, (F-'OP5Ff)(x- z- y) I 1+12i(z+ y) la YERn
47 1) (x-z)= sup
1 + 12'(z+y)Ia
1+ 2iyIa
The last factor can be estimated from above by c(1 + j2izla), where c depends only on a. Consequently, (3) (94"1)(x- z)5c(1 +I2'zla)(ry /) (x) . This shows that either (OP 5/)(x) < for all x E R or (rye /)(x) = m for all x E Rn. Of course, (ry*f)(x)
depends on a. But in later considerations, the value of a is not of interest (a must be sufficiently large later on). This is the reason why we omitted the index a on the left-hand side of (2).
Remark 3. There is no difficulty in later considerations in replacing the supremum with respect to x E Rn- {0}, reap., B,,, in (1) by an Lp-quasi-norm. In that case, p = 2 is closely related to the class cR in C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2, p. 183]. That class C plays a crucial role in the n-dimensional real variable theory for the Hardy spaces which has been developed in C. Feffer-
man, E. M. Stein [2]. The above class &tL(Rf) is the counterpart of eR in our framework. Generalizations of a L(Bf) for more general classes of B ,,q-FP q type (including anisotropic spaces, homogeneous spaces, spaces with dominating mixed derivatives etc.) have been given
in [F, 2.2.2]. {rye is the counterpart of the "tangential" maximal function u**(x) in C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2, p. 166]. This maximal function u**(x) proved very useful in the real variable characterization of the Hardy spaces Hj,(Rn), cf. (2.2.2/12) and Remark 2.2.2/2. The above modification (2) of this idea in the framework of the homogeneous spaces of Fp q type is due to J. Peetre [6, p. 125]. Further modifications for more general spaces of BP q-Fs.q type have been given in [F, 2.3.1].
We use the above abbreviations: (Ibk I lj has the meaning of (1.2.2/4) (with the usual modification if q=-) and 11/k I lq(Lp(R,))(( has been defined in (1.2.2/6) (including the limiting cases if p = and/or q = co), cf. also the beginning of 2.3.1. Finally, C(ry) is given by (1). Proposition. Let a >- 0 in (2) be fixed. Let - oo < s < oo and let L be a natural number
larger than 191 +3a+n+2. (i) If 0
sup (q%k*/)(x) 11g11
0-ci<1
c sup C(q) 0
holds for all systems ry = {ryk(x)}k=o E
l}2k8(ry,i*/)(x) 1
lgll
(4)
all families of systems TT = {g7k(x)}k=0 E
E& L(Rn) with 0«<1, all /ES'(Rn) and all xERn. (ii) If 0
sup (ryk*/) (') I lq(Lp(Rn))II -_ c sup C(TT)II 2k8(OPk/)(.) I lq(Lp(Rn))Il (5) 0-cr-c1
0-cT<1
holds for all systems OP = {OPk(x)}z=o E 0(Rn), all families of systems OPT = {(x)}0 E EcRL(R5) with 0-< -r-< 1 and all / E S'(Rn).
54
2. Function Spaces on R,,
Proof. Step 1. First we prove a pointwise inequality for the maximal functions with supp'ooc {x t JxJ 4}, supp Vic {x 12j-2- IxI :E52J+2} if j =1, 2, 3, ..., (6) (7) ¶k(x)=l if x E supp qqk and k=0,1,2.... We recall that {99k(x)}7=o E O(R )5 cf. Definition 2.3.1. It is not hard to see that there exist systems {y,k(x)}k=o with the required properties, where L is completely immaterial. We have ck* f and 9''f. Let r be fixed, 0 < r < 1. Let {vpk(x) }k-o
E-1-pkFf=
F-1L979p1FF-19"1F1I,
1=0
/ES'(Rn),
where only finitely many summands on the right-hand side are different from zero. If * indicates the convolution, then it follows that (F-194Ff)(x-z)I
I
(8)
f J (F-19,k 4: F-1'Vt)(y)I I (F-19,iFf)(x-z-y)I dy,
c
1=0 Rn
where xER. and zER,,. The last estimate makes sense because F-1TI * F-1ytE ES(Rn) and F-ttpjFf is an entire analytic function and, consequently, a regular distribution of at most polynomial growth. By (2) we have I(F-19,1F1)(x-z-y)I s(1+I21(y+z)Ia)(9gif)(x)
We note that 1 + I21(y+z) l 2ka
with Ik,t
c (1 + I21yla)(1 + I21zla). Now (8) yields °°
I(F-lq Ff)(x-z)I
C
1+12kzIa
f
2(k-t)8 1+I2tzla
1=0
1+I2kzIa 2
t.
f)(x) Ik.l
(10)
I(F-1,pk s: F-1o1)(y)I (1+ I21yla) dy
Rn
(9)
We estimate Ih,l: I(F-1qk
Ik,t=2-kn f
* F-1'pt)(2-ky)I (1+121-kyla) dy
Rn
{2-kn+alk-11 f
I
(F-1q,hT, * F-1'Vt)(2-ky)I (1 +Iyla) dy
Rn
I
a+ +ti
S c2-kn+alk-ll
r * F- 1 . )(F-19k II(1+'I 2 ) where x is an arbitrary positive number. Next we recall that +vt)(2_k
I I12(Rn)II
(y)=2-k,a(F-19)(2-ky)
(F-19(2k.))
furthermore, the convolution g * h of two smooth functions is given by
(9 * h)(x) = f 9(y) h(x-y) dy Rn
Now it is not hard to see that [F-1(9'k(2k .)) *
=2-2kn f (F-194)(2-kz) ' Rn
=2-kn(F-14'k
(12)
F-1('Vt(2k.))](y)
* F-1'Vt)(2-ky)
(F-1'Vt)(2-ky-2-kz) dz
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
55
We put this calculation into (11) and replace a+2 +x by an even number N with
a+2 +2zN-a+2 . Ik
Then [F-1 (Tic (2k .)) * F-1(,pt(2k
1=c2alk-tI 11(1 +I-IN)
=c2alk-1I IIF {(1 +
I L2(Rn)II
[F-1 (
c'2alk-11 II,,Tk (21 .)pt (21 -)1
W2 (R8)II
where Wz (Rn) is the Sobolev space, normed by (2.2.2/7). By (6) the function yt(2kx) vanishes outside of {y 121-k-2 I yI = 21-k+2} (modification if 1 = 0). On the other hand,
if x belongs to that set then (1) yields Lc2-L1t-kIC(g1)
IDa99k(2kx)I
(13)
,
Assuming that L _tN, we obtain 2(a-1)j1-kl ITV, (2k .) I W2 (Rn)II Ik,t=cC(99T) =cC(99T) 2(a-L)Il-kI II vt (21 . 2k-1 .) I W2 (Rn)II
c'C(TT)
c"C(qT)
21(a+N+! -L)Il-kl
IIV, (21 ') I Wz (Rn)II
(a+N+ sn -L)It-kI 2
where c" is independent of 1, k, 9) and TT. We return to (9). The factor in front of 2(181+a)Ik-11. Now take the supremum 2l8(gpl f) Ik,t can be estimated from above by with respect to z E R. on the left-hand side of (9) to obtain
j
(14)
(x)
t=0
where c is independent of fES'(Rn), xERR, k, r, pEO(Rn) and
IsI +2a+N+2. Let L>a. If 1=_q=oo, then
Step 2. We prove (4). Let
1
2k8 sup 0
k*/)(x)=c sup C(4 r)( 0
2(9+8-L)I1-k1g218q(991 /)g(x)4
(15)
l=0
with a -0 and L :-a+e (modification if q - co). Now (4) is an immediate consequence.
If 0
cgC(9,T)q 1=0
2q(6-L)I t-k1218q(g,i /)q (x)
(16)
Hence, we have the same situation as in (15). This proves (4) for q< 1, too. Next we
prove (5). If 1-_p=-, then the triangle inequality gives II2k8
sup 0
c
sup C(pT) 0
I Lp(Rn)II
(17)
12(Q-L)It-klII2'8(97/)(') I Lp(Rn)II
The next steps are the same as in (15) and (16), respectively. If we begin as in (16) (with p instead of q). The rest is the same. This proves (4) and (5) provided
L-IsI+2a+2 +a+2 +2=IsI+3a+n+2
.
(18)
2. Function Spaces on B.
56
Theorem. Let - - < s < -. (i) Let 0--- in (2) and if the natural number L from n (18) is larger than Isl +3 +n+2, then there exists a positive number c such that p 11211 sup Octet
(mk*f)(') I lq(LP(Rn))I! `c sup C((pr)II/ I BP,q(Rn)1!4' 0cr<1
(19)
holds for all systems ry={ryk(x)}k=oEO(Rn), all families of systems ryr= {ryk(x)}k=oEa9L(Rf) with 0
(ii) Let 0
L from (18) is larger than Isi+3 number c such that 11211
sup
0
n in (2) and if the natural number min (p, q)
min (p, q)
(ryk*f)(.) ! LL(Rn, lq)I!
+ra+2, then there exists a positive
c sup C(qr)!I f I FP.q(Rn)I)
(20)
0-cr<1
holds for all systems ry={ryk(x)}k-oEO(Rf), all families of systems
ryr={wk(x)}k=oEAL(Rn) with 0
if f E FP.q(Rn) and a>
lq)!!=c1!2k8F-1rykFf
min (p, q)
I Lp(Rn, lq)f
(21)
in (2), where c is independent of ry E O(Rn). Re-
call that the right-hand side of (21) coincides with !!f I Fy q(Rn)l!', cf. (2.3.1/6). However, (21) is an immediate consequence of Theorem 1.6.2. with dk=2k+2 (cf. Definition 2.3.1/1), a=q- and fk=F-1rykFf. r
Step 2. We prove (i). By (5) it is sufficient to show that (22)
lwkf I LP(Rn)i!=c!!F-1rykFf I LP(Rn)II it
if f E BP,q(Rn) and a - in (2), where c is independent of q? E O(Ra) and k = 0, 1, 2, .. . P
If p
then (22) is trivial :
!!rykf 1 Lm(Rn)1!=IIF-1rykFf I L-(Rn)II
If 0
then it is easy to see that ry can be approximated in the norm In particular,
C(ry, L)=li+01 C(TE, L),
C(ryE-rys, L)---0 if
e40 and 8)0
(and similarly, if we start with a family ryrof systems such that sup C (ryr, L+1)Now 0
we assume that ryEI(Rn) is as in the statement of thetheorem and that {99r}ocrc1 is an arbitrary family with sup C (ryr, L+ 1) < . We apply the above approximation procedure to (14) 0
with {ryE,k}x.oE&tL(Rf). This shows that the pointwise limit of (ryF;ki) (x) exists and hence so
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
57
does the pointwise limit of (F-1Te,kF/)(x) (which by modulus is less than or equal to (qie k/) (x)).
By (3), this convergence is also valid in a weighted L. space (the weight is an appropriate polynomial). Hence, (F-1q,E*kF/)(x) converges also in if sl0 and we take the limit as the definition of F ' F/. Then (14) holds for any family of systems rpT={epk(x)}k_o with
sup C (99r, L+1)
2.3.7.
A Fourier Multiplier Theorem
Our next aim is to prove that the spaces B-,,J(R,,) and FP q(Rn) from Definition 2.3.1/2 (and also from Definition 2.3.4) satisfy Criterion 2.2.3, of. also the program which has been described in 2.3.5. We recall Convention 2.3.3, which will be used consistently in the sequel.
Definition. Let m(x) be a complex-valued infinitely differentiable function on R.
Let -o<s<- and 0
with 0
Then m(x) is said to be a Fourier multiplier for A if there exists a positive constant c such that IIF-1mF1 I All =cIIf I Al;
(1)
holds for all f EA. Remark 1. F-1mFf=F-'[mF/] makes sense for any /ES'(R,t) if 7n(x) and all its derivatives have at most polynomial growth. In order to avoid technical difficulties we assume for the present that m(x) alway has this property (later on we shall relax this assumption essentially via limiting procedures).
Remark 2. If i =FPo,q(R,,) with 1 and a Fourier multiplier for the spaces from Definition 2.3.4.
then (1) gives the definition of
Let N be a natural number. For the sake of brevity we introduce IirnlIv= sup sup (1+IxJ2)2 ;Damn(x)l . ]a] sN XERn
(2)
Theorem. Let --<S<- and 0
exists a positive number c such that IIF-1niFf I Alltz- cIImllNll/ I All
(3)
holds for all infinitely differentiable functions m(x) and all /EA. Proo/. Let A=Fp5q(Rn). We use (2.3.6/20) with 92={9?k(x)}7^eE0(R,,). We have
F-1gkF[F-1mF/]=F-1TkmF/ . Now (2.3.6/20) with q:k=mTk. and the obvious fact that I (F kF/)(x)I n y ields (3) with N- si+3 + n +2 . Simil arl y if A = Bp,q( Rn).
(4)
1
min (p, q) Remark 3. The estimates for V are very rough:
V,js1+3+n+2 NHJsj+3
mm
( 7>> 4)
for B8,s(R,),
+n+2 for
Fn . q(Rn)
(5)
(6)
58
2. Function Spaces on R.
Later on we obtain substantial improvement on the basis of Theorem 1.5.2 and (1.5.4/2) for the spaces BP,q(Rn), and on the basis of Theorem 1.6.3 (and the interpolation theory which will be developed in Section 2.4.) for the space F°p,q(Rn). Roughly speaking, instead of the unnatural right-hand sides of (5) and (6) we shall deal with the numbers a from Theorem 1.5.2 (for BP,q(Rn)) and op,q from (1.6.4/1) (for FP,q(Rn)). For details we refer to Subsection 2.4.8. In particular, the parameter 181 in (5) and (6) can be cancelled. The latter fact is also an easy
consequence of the simple lifting property from 2.3.8. by which it follows that the set of all Fourier multipliers for FP q(Rn) is independent of s (similarly for BP,q(Rn)). On the other hand,
the above simple proof of the theorem makes it clear that sufficiently general and strong Fourier multiplier assertions can be obtained via maximal inequalities. The right-hand sides of (5) and (6) (and also the numbers aP and op,q) tend to infinity if py0. This effect (in connection with Fourier multipliers) is known, cf. J. Peetre [6] and (for more general spaces) [F, p. 96], cf.
also C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2, p. 191] as far as the Hardy spaces are concerned, which by (2.3.5/4) and (2.3.5/6) are closely related to spaces of FP,q type.
and 1
Next we use (Fq q(Rn))'=Fm q(Rn) with
(7)
+j;=1, cf. Proposition 2.3.4/2. By Theorem
2.3.3, the set S(Rn) is dense in Fi,q (Rn). Then it follows easily from (7) that any Fourier multiplier for Fj,q.(Rn) is also a Fourier multiplier for F",q(Rn).
Corollary. The spaces BP,q(Rn) with FP,q(Rn) with F.,q(Rn) with satisfy Criterion 2.2.3.
0
and
<
Proof. This follows immediately from the above theorem and Remark 4. Remark 5. In [S, p. 32] we proved the following assertion: if a Banach space A has the weak Fourier multiplier property in the sense of Definition 2.2.3 (hence, it satisfies Criterion 2.2.3),
then there exists a natural number N and a positive number c, such that (3) holds for all m(x) and all tEA.
2.3.8.
Lifting Property and Related Equivalent Quasi-Norms
In order to show the usefulness of Theorem 2.3.6 and Theorem 2.3.7 we prove the so-called lifting property and some related assertions. If a is a real number, then the operator IQ is defined by Q
(1) Ia/=F-1 (I+ X11)' Ff, fES'(Rn) . It is well-known that Ia is a one-to-one mapping from S'(Rn) onto itself. Furthermore, the restriction of IQ to S(Rn) is a one-to-one mapping from S(Rn) onto itself. Obviously, IQI, =I,,+,,. We shall say in the sequel that "IQ maps A0 onto A1" instead of "the restriction of I. to A0 maps A0 onto Al".
Theorem. Let -oo<s
59
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
is an equivalent quasi-norm on B8,q(Rn). Furthermore,
jllaf I BP-q (Rn)jj
and
2: I!Dal I Bn,q (Rn)II
II/
Ialsm
aml
BP,q
7=i axj
BP,q (Rn)
(2)
are equivalent quasi-norms on BP,q(Rn). (ii) Let 0-
lalsm
and
IIDa/ I FP,q (Rn)II
lit
I FP.q (Rn)Ii+
aml j=1
I
axj
FP,9 (R,,)
(3)
are equivalent quasi-norms on F1,q(Rn). Proof. Step 1. First we prove the mapping properties of I. If 9' _ {Tk(x) )k=o E q(R,,), then e = {v!k(x).)k=o Eo2L(Rn), where L is an arbitrary natural number and yk(x) _ a
= 2-ka (1 + IxI2) 2 99k(x), cf. Definitions 2.3.1/1 and 2.3.6/1. If /E Fs1,,q(Rn), then Theorem 2.3.6 and the obvious estimate I(F-1ykFf)(x)I --'Ipk f(x) yield a IIIL/
F'n,q (Rn)II =II2(8--)kF-1(1 + 1.12) 2 91kF1 I LP(Rn, lq)II
I
(4)
=II28kF-1VkFf I LP(Rn, lq)Ij =cl!/ I F,,q(Rn)ll
This proves that Ia maps F'',,q(Rn) into FP-Q (Rn). If gEFP,q (Rn), then we have by the same argument f =I_a qEF' q(Rn) and ll/ I FP,q(Rn)II `C119 I FP-'q"q (Rn)Il =CIIIaf I FP-1q"e (Rn)ll
(5)
Because, Ia is a one-to-one mapping in S'(Rn), it is also a one-to-one mapping from F'r,q(Rn) onto FP-Q (Rn). By (4) and (5), IIIQf
1
F'r-Q (Rn)II is an equivalent quasi-
norm in F ,,q(R.). This proves the first part of (ii). The proof of the first part of (i) is the same. Step 2. We prove that the quasi-norms in (3) are equivalent on F'p,5(Rn). If x= (x1, ...,
xn) E Rn, we put xa = if xj 1, where a = (Oct, ... , an) is a multi-index. It is an easy j=1
m
consequence of Theorem 2.3.7 that xa(1+Ix12) 2 is a Fourier multiplier for any space FP,q(Rn), provided that Ial Vim. Consequently, if f EF, q(Rn), then we have lalsm
IIF-1x2F1
IIDa/ I FP Q (Ba)ll =
lalsm
m
m
lal?m
I Fr,4 (Rn)II
IIF-1x2(1+Ixj2) 2FF-1 (1+IxI2)2 Ff I Fv,q (Rn)!I
(6)
eIIImf I F'p- (Rn)li `c'll/ ! FP,q(Rn)II . am
Next we assume that f E F'- (Rn) and axf E Fp,v (Rn) for j =1, ... , n. We wish to 1
show that f belongs to F',,q(Rn). In the next step we shall prove that there exist Fourier multipliers ei(x), ... , e,,(x) for FP.Q (Rn) (in the sense of Theorem 2.3.7) and a positive number c such that 1
n
j=1
!!t
ej(x) xrc (1+Ix12)2
for all xERn
(7)
(if m is even, then ej(x) __ 1 has the desired properties ; if m is odd, then the situation is a bit more complicated). Again by Theorem 2.3.7, (1 + 1x12) 2
r1 + L
1
j=1
ej(x)xr l
= M(x)
2. Function Spaces on R.
60
is also a Fourier multiplier for FP-Q (Rn). Consequently, FP,q(Rn)Il <=c - C'
JIF-1
F-1M(x) FF-1
m (1+xI2)2Ff I F8p,q
(Rn)I(
[1+I ej(x) xrl Ff I F'p.Q (Rn)
7-1 c"Ilf I F'p- (Rn)II + c" 1n IIF-1ei(x) xjLFf I FP,q (Rn)Ii
j=1
We have xrFf =cF
m
Hence, the multiplier property of ej(x) yields
If I FP,q(Rn)II __ C(f I Fv,q (Rn)II +c
j=1
Gm; 8xi FP,g (Rn)
I
(8)
Now (6) and (8) prove that the quasi-norms in (3) are equivalent in FP,q(Rn). In the same way one proves that the quasi-norms in (2) are equivalent in B',q(R,,). Step 3. We prove that there exist Fourier multipliers ei(x), ... , en(x) with the
property (7). If m is even, we choose ej(x) -1. Let m be odd and n = 2. Let St ={xER9 I x1>-0, x2I=tx1},
S9 ={xER, I x1<0, 1X21 -tIx,I},
t =O. Let Ti(x) be an infinitely differentiable function in R,,-{O} with 99j(x)_-O,
\x
O(x)=l if xESi and supp qcS,, where j=1, 2. Let y,(x) be a non-
negative infinitely differentiable function in R2 with e(x) = 1 if fix; ? 1 and 0 ( supp V.
Let of (x) = a(x) [9'1(x) - w2(x)]
In a similar way one constructs a function P2(x). It is not hard to see that e,(x) and e2(x) have the desired properties. This method can be extended to n = 3, 4, 5, .. . If h E Rn then the translation operator Th is defined by (Thf)(x) = f (x+h)
for any regular distribution. Th can be extended in the usual way to S'(Rn): f Recall that if f ES'(Rn) and T ES(R,L), then we put FThf=e"LxFf
and F-1(e;1:x/)=ThF-1/,
(9)
cf. (1.2.1/2) and (1.2.1/3) and the usual extension procedures from S(R,,) to S'(R,,). In particular, if T = {Tj(x) }T=o E O(Rn), then
(F-1pfFThf)(x)=Th(F-1gjFf)(x)=(F-1q'1Fl)(x+h)
.
(10)
Proposition. Let --<s<-and0
Remark 2. Both the above theorem and the proposition can be extended to FW,q(R,L) with In the case of the proposition this follows simply by duality, cf. Proposition 2.3.4/2. As for the theorem, a proof can be based on Remark 2.3.7/4.
2.3. Definition and Fundamental Properties
2.3.9.
61
Diversity of the Spaces BP4q(Rn.) and
The diversity of the spaces A ,q(Rn) and H,(R,t) from 2.2.2. attracted much attention in the history of these spaces, cf. 0. V. Besov [2], K. K. Golovkin [2] and M. H. Taibleson [1, I, Lemma 2]. Cf. also S. M. Nikol'skij [3, 9.7] and [I, 2.12] . Thus it is'natural to ask the same question in our more general framework. Theorem. Let 0
and 0
B"
(ii) Let 0
if and only if so=si, qo=q1 and po=p1 (iii) Let 0<po<= and 0
and po=qo=pl=q1<=. Proof. Step 1. The "if"-part of the theorem is obvious because FP,1,(Rn) =B°r,v(B,,). We prove
the "only if"-part. Step 2. Let V(x) ES(Rn) be an appropriate function with supp Fy, c {x I i s Ixl 52}. If Vj(x) V(21x), then supp F?pj c {x 121 s I xl 52i+1}, cf. (1.3.2/6). Then it follows from the Definitions 2.3.1/1 and 2.3.1/2 (and appropriate choices of V and {q1}EO(Rn)) that in
I LP(Rn)p=2 p I!w I LP(Rn)I!
BP,q(Rn)II =IYj I
liy,j
(1)
if j =0, -1, - 2, ... and 2
IlVi I Br,q(Rn)II 1Vj I F8,q(Rn)( =28' II,v(2'.) I LP(Rn)II =28 p )II=v I LP(Rn)II
(2)
if j =1, 2, 3, . . . Now we assume that two spaces, on the one hand BPo,go(Rn) or FPo,go(Rn) and on the other hand Bp,,q,(Rn) or FPl,gl(Rn) coincide. Then (1) yields po=p1 and (2) (afterwards) so=si.
Step 3. Let xc = (1, 0, 0, ... , 0) and let V(x) ES(Rn) be an appropriate function with supp 1 P c {x
Ix -xol s 1}. Let x' _ (x2, ... , xn). If f is defined by N
(Ff)(x) = Z ajp (x1- 21, x') , j=1
aj complex numbers,
then we have 1
q
IIf I FP,q(Rn)II = IIF-1VI LP(Rn)II
2: 28101 ajl q,
j=1 (modification if q==), of. also formula (3) below. Consequently, qo=qi if FP,go(Rn) =Fg1 g1(Rn).
This assertion and Step 2 prove (ii).
Step 4. In order to prove (i) and (iii) we may assume that so=si=0 and po=pi=p. This follows. from Step 2 and the lifting property from Theorem 2.3.8. Let V be the same function as in the previous step. Let N
(F/) (x) _ Y_ e22x ip (xi-2j, x') j=1
If
is an appropriate system, then we have (F-14,1Ff)(x)
=F-1(e 2'v11V(y1-21, y'))(x)
=ei21(x1+2j)(F-1,)(x1+21,x')
,
(3)
of. (1.2.1/3). Consequently, 1
Ill
Bp,q(Rn)II ".I]F-1V I LP(Rn)II Nq
IIf
FP,q(Rn)II ^'IIF-1y, I Ly(R1.)II Nq
(4)
and 1
(5)
62
2. Function Spaces on R.
Now (i) follows from (4). Finally, if then (4) and (5) yield q1=p. Hence Fp,p(R.)=Bp,p(R.) =Fp,q,()?,i). Then we obtain from (ii) that q0=p. This proves (iii).
Remark. The Besov spaces A4,q(R,) and the Bessel-potential spaces from 2.2.2. are always different (with the exception of p = q = 2). This classical result, which has been treated in the above-cited papers, is a special case of the theorem, cf. (2.3.5/2) and (2.3.5/3). Furthermore, in [I, 2.12] we proved that the spaces Ap,q(R.) and H, with p $2 are not only different from a set-theoretical point of view, but they differ also in their isomorphic structure as Banach spaces. For details we refer to [1, 2.12]. A corresponding result for the more general spaces Bp,q(R.n) and Fps,q(R,a) would be desirable. Finally we mention that the above theorem with - m s - and 1
2.4.
Interpolation
2.4.1.
Preliminaries
Interpolation methods are of some interest for our later considerations. But the central ideas of this chapter are independent of the results of this section. On the other hand, we shall occasionally use some interpolation formulas which are proved in this section. A reader who is not interested in interpolation theory may skip this section, provided he is ready to consult the corresponding results later on, when they will be needed from time to time. Furthermore, we shall not develop the abstract interpolation theory (with the exception of the few remarks below about the real method in quasi-Banach spaces). We prefer to give direct proofs for the main assertions of this section which are not based on general interpolation assertions.
Interpolation methods. As far as concrete interpolation procedures are concerned there exist essentially two methods: The real interpolation method by J.-L. Lions and J. Peetre, and the complex interpolation method by J.-L. Lions, A. P. Calder6n and S. G. Krejn. An extensive treatment of these abstract methods (and many references) has been given in [I], cf. also J. Bergh, J. Lofstrom [1]. Originally, both methods were developed in the framework of Banach space theory. However it is not difficult to see (and well-known nowadays) that the real method (or at least some of its crucial assertions) can be extended immediately to quasi-Banach spaces (concerning the notion of a quasiBanach space of. 1.2.2.). Below we give a brief description of the real method for quasi-Banach spaces and we prove the so-called interpolation property. In contrast to the real method, the complex method cannot be extended immediately from Banach spaces to quasi-Banach spaces. Recently, A. P. Calder6n, A. Torchinsky [1] discovered a modification of the usual complex method, which can be applied
to some concrete quasi-Banach spaces in the framework of Fourier analysis, in particular to the above spaces B,,g(Rn) and FP q(Rn). This modified concrete complex method (and not the usual abstract complex method) will be described in 2.4.4.-2.4.7. (including a weak interpolation property). The real method. The general background of an interpolation method is the following: let 'fC be a linear complex Hausdorff space, and let AD and Al be two complex quasi-Banach spaces such that AD c X and Al c X Recall that " c " indicates a linear and continuous embedding. In particular, the algebraic operations
(addition of elements and multiplication by complex numbers) are the same in
2.4. Interpolation
63
A0, A1, and `l( (as far as they make sense). Let Ao+A1 be the set of all elements a E'C which can be represented as a = ao + a1 with aoEAo and a1 E A1. If 0 < t < and aEAo + A1, then Peetre's celebrated K-functional is given by K(t, a)=K(t, a; A0, A1)=inf (Ilao I A0II +tIIa1 I A1II),
(1)
where the infimum is taken over all representations of a of the form a=ao+a1 with aoEAo and a1EA1.
Definition. Let 0 < 0 < 1. If 0 < q < oo then 1
(2)
(t-°K(t,a)]4dtl q
(A0,
A1)°,q={a I aEAo+A1, Ila I (A0, A1)°,gll=1 f o
/I
If q = oo, then (A0, A1)°,-={a I aEAo+A1, Ila (A0, AI)°,,.II= sup t-°K(t, a)
(3)
Remark 1. These are the well-known real interpolation spaces. One can.prove that (A0, A1)°,q is always a quasi-Banach space. In our concrete cases, which will be treated in the following subsections, this will be clear from the very beginning, because we shall only deal with the spaces and F,,q(Rn).
Remark 2. One can replace the complex spaces A0, Al and 2C by corresponding real spaces. This is immaterial for the real interpolation method.
Proposition (Interpolation property). X, A0 and Al have the above meaning. Let T be a linear operator mapping 'M into itself such that its restriction to Ak yields a linear and bounded mapping from Ak into itself, where k = 0 or 1. Then the restriction of T to (A0, A1) °,q (where 0 < 0 < 1 and 0 < q - oo) yields a linear and bounded mapping from (A0, A1)°,q into itself.
Proof. It is easy to see that (A0, Ai)°,g is a linear space. Hence, the restriction of T to (A0, A1)e,q is a linear operator. Let (4) II Tak I AkII `=IITIIk Ilak I Akli for all akEAk
if k=0 or 1. If a=ao+a1 with aoEAo and a1 EA1, then Ta= Tao+ Tat and (1) gives K(t, Ta)inf (11Tao I A0II+tIITa1 I A1II)
(5)
IIT110 inf (Ilao I A0II+tIITI11 IITII51 Ila1 I A1II) 11 T110 K(tIIT111 11 T110 1, a)
where the infimuun in (5) is taken over all representations a=ao+a1 (we assume that IITIIo>-0). By a simple transformation of coordinates we have IITa I (A0, A1)°,q II`IITII0'-°IIT111 °IIa I (A0,A1)°,gll .
(6)
In particular Ta E (Ao, A1)e,q. The proof is complete. Remark 3. We proved slightly more than we stated. If II Ta I (A0, A,)e,gll SIITII°,q Ila I (A0, A1)°,gI)
then (6) shows that IITII°,gSIlTllo-°IITII° . By a limiting argument this is also valid if IITII0=O.
(7)
Remark 4. The following elementary remark will be useful later on. Let 7C be the above linear complex Hausdorff space and let Ac c Bo c 2C and Al c B1 c JC, where A0, A1, B0 and B1
2. Function Spaces on R.
64
are quasi-Banach spaces. If 0<19< 1 and 0-
(8)
This follows easily from (1), (2) and (3).
2.4.2.
Real Interpolation for the Spaces
and
with Fixed p
The basis for the real interpolation theory for the spaces B,,q(Rn) and FP,q(Ra)
is Theorem 2.3.3, which shows that the Hausdorff space X from 2.4.1. can be identified with
Theorem. Let 0<0-<1, 0
-<so< -<s1< s0+s1 and s=(1-0)80+081. then
(i) If 0
BA,q1(Rn))Cc,q= B$,q(R,,)
(1)
(ii) If 0
si
s
>
Fp,gi(Rn) &,q=B.g(Rn)
(2)
Proof. Step 1. First we prove that (BP -(Rn), BD,m(Rn))©,4C B,,q(R,)
We may assume that
(3)
Let q<-. We have
(0,-)= U
2k(8o-8j))
and Jet-')ghq(t, f; B'-)
BA .,e(Rn))
dt t
0
e
k=0
(4)
2-egk(so-80Kq(2k(sn-s,), f; BP ..(R.), Bp`...(Rn))
c is an appropriate positive constant and f E B' (Rn) +BP,,,(R,,). Let f = fo+f1 with foEBBp,,,(Rn) and f1EBpm(Rn). If {q1j(x)}j=oEO(R,,) then (2.3.1/5) yields (5)
2180IIF-1gPkF1 I Lp(Rn)II c2k8oflF-1TkFf0 I Lp(Rn)II
+c2k(8o-81)2k81lI F-199kF11 I LP(Rn)II
`C Ilfo B ._(Rn)II The infimum with respect to all representations f =f0+f1 yields the K-functional in (4). Consequently, BS1;,..(Rn)II+c2x'(8°_81)Iif1
I
I
2] 2gk8IIF-1wkFf I Lp(R,)IIq
k=0
can be estimated from above by the left-hand side of (4). This proves (3). A small modification yields a corresponding result for q = oo.
Step 2. If 0--r-:q, we prove that B,,,(Rn)C(BP,r(Rn), BP,r(Rn)).9,q.
Again we assume that s0>s1. Because s=:-81, Proposition 2.3.2/2 gives K(t, f; BPr(R,,), Bs'r(Rn))Setllf I BBn,r(Rn)II Sc'tllf I B,,q(Rn)II
(6)
2.4. Interpolation
65
In particular, 1
(ft_eK(t,/; BP r(R0), BP,r(Rn)) dt
`cll/ I BP,q(Rn)II
(7)
I
0
(modification if q = 00). Furthermore, I - J t-°4K4(t, f; BP,r( L0), BP,r(Rn)l i
t
dt (8)
2-°Qk(so-80Kq(2k(so-ail,
2E; C
k=0
/; Bp r(Rn), Bp,r(R0))
If again q' = {(pj(x) }j--o E q(R0), then we put (for the sake of brevity) j =11 F-ipjF/ I
Lp(R0)II. We use the representation /=/0+/1 with k
lo=
2]F-1g5Ff
j=0
and f1=
F-igjF/ i=k+1
The properties of the system p and the scalar case of Theorem 1.6.3 (cf. also Remark 1.5.2/3) show that k+i
11/01 BP r(Rn)IIr j=0
2j8r;
11/11 BP
2'8fr>
j=k
If we use this special decomposition, then (8) yields 4
('k+i
1--c E 2gk8 12] 2sor(j
I
k=0
Let so
x0
s
r q
r + a =1 we have
q
k+1
20(8-so)
1
(Y=O
j
a k+1
2(so-xo)a
2
(=o q
20(1 -81)
(2(8i
kT0
_C
(9)
s1. By Holder's inequality with
k=o
+C
l
j=k
Lj=0
x1
c-c
2eir(j-k)
r
k=j-1
Ci G 274sf j=0
j=k
20(s-xo)+c
2xo4j jq j=0
2xigjpf)
Q
j=k
2xa i j=0
(10)
/I 7,2gk(s-x1)
k=0
1 BP,q(Rn)IIq .
(7), (8) and (10) prove (6) (if q = 00, then the above calculations must be modified in the usual way).
Step 3. In order to prove (1), we use Remark 2.4.1/4 and the embeddings from Proposition 2.3.2/2. If r-- qo and r _-q1, then (3) and (6) yield BP,q(Rn) C (BP r(Rn), B-';,(Rn))s,q C (BP go(Rn), BP q,(Rn))s,q C (BP,m(R.), BP,,o(R.)) s,q c BP,q(Rn)
This proves (1). Finally, (2) follows in the same way from (1) and (2.3.2/9). 5
Triebel, Function engl.
66
2. Function Spaces on R.
Remark 1. The proof is essentially a modification of a corresponding proof in [I, pp. 124/125].
Remark 2. If 1
Real Interpolation for the Spaces B,,,p(Rn)
Theorem 2.4.2 is essentially sufficient for our later purposes (as far as the real method is concerned). The number p in Theorem 2.4.2 is fixed. One can raise the question: what about real interpolation formulas if spaces with different p's are involved? This problem is of interest for several reasons, but it is harder than the corresponding problem with fixed p's, which we treated in 2.4.2. In the Banach space case, i.e. 1
Theorem. Let --<sc<°, -_<S1<-00<po<' and 0
P
po
+
-Pt ,
(1)
then
(Bpo,po(R.), B8p1,p1(Rn))e,p=Bp,,(Rn) .
(2)
Remark 1. In [S, pp. 72/73] we outlined a proof of (2) which is based on abstract interpolation methods and on (Hpo(Ra), Hpi(R.))e,p=Hp(B..) ,
(3)
are the Hardy spaces from Remark 2.2.2/2. The interpolation formula (3) is due to C. Fefferman, N. M. Riviere, Y. Sagher [1], cf. also N. Al. Riviere, Y. Sagher [1] and W. R. Madych [1]. One can prove that a corresponding result holds for the local Hardy where
spaces hp(R,) from (2.2.2/12), i.e. (hpa(R.), hp1(Rn))o,p=hp(R.) ,
where again 0<po-<
(4)
1-0On0 the basis of (4) and the ' 0
P
Po
Ps
so-called retraction method of interpolation theory one can carry over many interpolation formulas from the Banach space case (considered in [I, 2.4]) to the more general case treated here. A description of this technique in the above framework may be found in [S, pp. 72-74]. Remark 2. However, in order to prove (2), it is not necessary to use the far-reaching retraction
method of interpolation theory and the deep formulas (3) or (4). As in 2.4.2. one can give a direct proof of (2). For that purpose one modifies Step 1 of the proof of the theorem in [I, p. 121] in the same way as we modified the proof in [I, pp. 124/125] in connection with Theorem 2.4.2. But in contrast to 2.4.2. one needs a new interpolation method, the so-called Lmethod, cf. [I, 1.4]. We do not go into detail.
2.4.4.
Complex Interpolation: Definitions
The rest of Section 2.4. deals with a complex interpolation method for the spaces BP 9(Rn) and Fp,,(R,,), and an application to Fourier multipliers for Fp,9(R71). Furthermore, we discuss briefly corresponding problems for the spaces LP (R,,, 11) from 1.6.1. As has been mentioned in 2.4.1., the complex method under consideration
here is not the classical method by J. L. Lions, A. P. Calderon and S. G. Krejn, which is restricted to Banach spaces.
2.4. Interpolation
67
Let A = {z 10 < RV z < 1 } be a strip in the complex plane. Its closure {z I 0 n Re z 51) is denoted by A.We say that /(z) is an S'(R5)-analytic function in A if the following properties are satisfied: (i) For every fixed z E A we have f(z)ES'(R5),
(ii) (F-19,Ff)(x, z) is a uniformly continuous and bounded function in
for every g2ES(Rn) with compact support in R, (iii) (F-1,pF1)(x, z) is an analytic function in A for every g2ES(Rn) with compact support in R,, and every fixed x E Rn. We recall that (F-1g?Ff)(x, z) is an entire analytic function in R. with respect to x if z E A is fixed, of. 1.2.1.
Definition 1. Let--<so<00, --<ss<00,
and 0
(i) If 0<po-_ 00 and 0
(1)
I F(Byo,g0, BPi,g1)II -max sup II/(i+it) I BPj,gj(Rn)II
(ii) If 0<po<- and 0
_ (/(z) I /(z) is an S'(Rn)-analytic function in A, f(it)EF?,,q,(Rn), f(1+it)EFP1,gt(Rn) for every tER1i I1(z)
(2)
I F(Fvo,g0, FPi,g1)II =max sup II/(l+it) I FZ,gt(Rn)II j=0,1 tER1
Remark 1. This is the substitute of the well-known construction by A. P. Calder6n [2] in the case of Banach spaces, cf. also [I, p. 56]. In the classical case (which is restricted to Banach spaces) /(z) is a vector-valued analytic function in A (with values in a Banach space). The idea of using 8'(B,)-analytic functions is due to A. P. Calder6n, A. Torchinsky [1, 11, p. 135]. Cf. also L. Paivarinta [1] and H. Triebel [15, 16]. Our treatment follows closely H. Triebel [19].
--<81<00, 0
Definition 2. Let
and 0<0<1.
(B,8,-,
.(-R.), BP ,q,(Rn))© ={9 3 f(z)EF(BPo,go(Rn) BSP,,4,(Rn)) with g=f(0)} , =inf 11f(e) I F(B'o,4o, B'P,,gs)II , (B'o,40(Rn), II9
(3)
(4)
where the infimwn is taken over all admissible functions /(z) in the sense of (3).
(ii) If 0<po<°° and 0
={91 3f(z)EF(FPo,q.(Rn),FP,q,(Ra)) II9
with
g=f(0)},
(FP,,go(Rn), FP,,q1(Rn))®II =inf 11j(z) I F(FPa,ga
(5)
(6)
where the infimum is taken over all admissible functions /(z) in the sense of (5). Remark 2. The classical complex method is denoted by [ , ]©, in contrast to our notation (- ,- )0, of. A. P. Calder6n [2] or [I, p. 58/59]. If the above numbers po, p1, q0 and q1 are larger than or equal to 1 (i.e. in the Banach space case) both methods makes sense and the question arises whether they coincide or not. In many cases the two methods yield the same spaces, but in some limiting cases the two methods yield different results, of. Remark 2.4.7/2. 5.
68
2. Function Spaces on Rn
2.4.5.
Complex Interpolation: Properties
In 2.4.7. we shall prove that the interpolation spaces from Definition 2.4.4/2 coincide with some of the spaces Bp q(Rn) and FP q(Rn), respectively. Then it will be clear that the spaces
from Definition 2.4.4/2 are quasi-Banach spaces. One can ask the same question for the spaces from Definition 2.4.4/1.
Proposition. Let --<so<-, - <s1<-, 0
(ii) If 0<po<m and 0
direct proof (without using the full theorem 2.4.7) of the fact that the interpolation space from Definition 2.4.4/2 are quasi-Banach spaces.
2.4.6.
Some Preparations
Our main goal is the proof of Theorem 2.4.7. For that purpose it is convenient to start with some preparations.
(I k
Lemma 1. Let {ak}7=0 be a sequence of positive numbers. Let bk=ak
where k=0, 1, 2, ... If Osx<1, then bk=2
(21-1)1
(aa)''.
\m=0
am
\-x I (1)
Proof. We may assume that i ak=1, the general case following from a homok =0 geneity argument. We choose a sequence of integers K1, K2, ... such that - K1 i=-K2-
. -;L--O and Km
l=0
a1--2_m
Km-1
and
l=0
(with the usual interpretation
-1
al<2-m if m=1, 2, .. . al = 0). If Ko -1 = oo, then
a=u
Sm_1-1
., Sm_1-1 k=0
bk =
m=1 j=Km
bj
2mx
m=1
j=Sm
aj =
2mx2 -m+i m=1
This proves (1).
Lemma 2. Let A={z I z complex, 0
f g(it)Fuo(O, t))(f Ig (1+it)Ir µ(O, t) dt)(2)
with O=Re z forany analytic function g(z) in A which is uniformly continuous and bounded in A. Furthermore, if 0
R,
2.4. Interpolation
69
Proof. (Outline). If r=1, then (2) is known, cf. A. P. Calderon [2, 9.4 and 29.4] or [I, pp.65 and 67]. µo(0, t) and µ1(O, t) are the Poisson kernels for the strip A. The key inequality of that proof reads as follows, log g(z)I-_ f log Ig(it)I µo(0, t) dt+ f log Ig(1+it)I µ1(0, t) dt . (4) R1
R1
We multiply (4) by r, in other words we replace in (4) by Now the same proof as in [I, p. 67] yields (2). Lemma 3. (i) If all notations have the same meaning as in Definition 2.4.4/2 (i), then Ilg
(Bpo,go(Rn), BP;,qjRn)©II
I
=inf (sup II/(it) tERl
sup II/(l +it) I Bv,,q,(Rn)II°) ,
Bso,9o(Rn)II'-®
I
(5)
tER1
where the infimum is taken over all admissible functions /(z) in the sense of (2.4.4/3).
(ii) If all notations have the same meaning as in Definition 2.4.4/2 (ii), then Ilg
I
(F'0,P ,JR.), FPj,q,(Rn))ell
(6)
=inf (sup II/(it) I F'po,go(Rn)II1-° sup II/(1 +it) I tER,
tER1
where the infimum is taken over all admissible functions j (z) in the sense of (2.4.4/5). Proof. We prove (5). The proof of (6) is the same. It is obvious that the right-hand side of (5) can be estimated from above by the left-hand side, cf. (2.4.4/4) and (2.4.4/1). In order to prove the reverse inequality we replace f(z) in (2.4.4/3) and (2.4.4/4) by az-®/(z), where a is a positive number. Then it follows that Ilg
max [atsup II/(l+it)
I (BPO,go(.n),
tER1
1=0,1
I BPt,gi(Rn)II]
If II/(1+it) I B/j,gl(Bn)II=O then a .m yields the desired result. Otherwise, we choose a=sup 11f(it) I Bg°o,go(Bn)I] (sup II/(1+it) tER,
tER1
2.4.7.
(Rn)IU
I
Complex Interpolation for the Spaces BP,q(Rn) and FP,q(Rn)
Theorem. Let --<so<-, --<s10
11-0 + O
P
Po
P1
1 _1-O O q
q0
(1)
q1
then
(BPa,go(Rn), B",qJRn))e = BP,q(Rn)
(2)
(ii) If 0<po<°° and 0
',
Fps,gt(Rn))®=FdP.q(Rn)
(3)
Proof. We prove (3). The proof of (2) is essentially the same, but simpler in some details. Furthermore, we assume that q0 < - and q1 < . If either qo = oo or q1= then one has to modify in the usual way. Step 1. We prove that (Ftio,go(Rn), FPi,gi(Rn))®CFp,q(Rn)
Let f(z)EF(FPo,go(Rn), FP,q,(Rn)) and
(4)
of. 2.4.4. and 2.3.1.
In the sense of Definition 2.3.1/2 and Definition 2.4.4/2 we put gk(x, z) _
70
2. Function Spaces on R.
=(F-1pkF/(z))(x), where k=0, 1, 2, ... Let 0zrzmin (po, p1, q0, q1). Then q -
P
j= f I2k789k(x, 9)Iq) Rn k=0
f
dxl =
Rn k=O
J
L
r
P
r
P
(12k89k(x, O)I r)
l
r) q rdx] J
P
r
(5)
where the spaces involved 1q and LP (Rn) are Banach spaces. We use (2.4.6/2)
r
r
with 2k8gk(x, z) instead of g(z) (where xER. is fixed). Let ak(x) =
f 19k(x, it)Ir uo(O, t) dt
1 1-O
(6)
R1
and
bk(x) =® .' I9k(x, 1 +it)Ir µ1(O, t) dt .
(7)
R,
Then (1) and elementary applications of Holder's inequality yield
lr
r L k=0
r
(I 2k,, gk(x, 9)Ir)rJq=[ k=O
(2k8raO(x)bk(x))r r(i - O)
- ' 2kk80go akr (x)
g (8) `4,r
)q0
O
2k8tgtbkr (x) k=O
k=O
By (6) and a well-known inequality for integrals we have II{2k°rak(x)}k=0
lgoll=l 1 O r
Jf R,
t) dt
II{i2kaogk(x, lt)lr}k=OI
-'r 1
qo
1- O / R1
µo(O, t) dt
2kgugo19k(x, it)Iq° 0
Similarly for the second factor on the right-hand side of (8). Hence, (5) and (8) give
(1 - hJ) P
f
f
1
1 - (1
Rn
R1
r
1
r
(E 2k8°q°1gk(x, it) Q-)'
u,)(0, t) dt
k=O r
r
1
1
f1 R1
gt o
2k81gt 19k(x, 1 +it)Igl
'U0, t) dt
r
P
dx
111
We use (1) and Holder's inequality for integrals (the counterpart of (8) with p's instead of q's) and obtain that r 1-O
PO
j- f Rn
Xf Rn
r
1
2k8ogo19k(x, it)Iq°) 1 - Rnf (jk=0
40
/.(O, t) dt
1
1
ql r
f
Ri.
k=
`
µ1(O, t) dt
r
dx
J 1
(0 2k8,gt I9k (x, 1 +it)Ig)
-7P°
Pt
r
O
r
Pt
r
dx
I
(9)
2.4. Interpolation
71 r
Po
f
Recall that
1Po
r dx1
I R,
is a norm. Hence, (9) can be estimated from above by P.
r
1
.1
I
1
R1
1(E 2k-q0 jgk(x,
/
k=o
Rn
J r
q,
1
X
f [Rnf (
1-®
r
r dx1P0lU0(0,
it)igolgo
2ksigi l yk (x, 1 +it) 1q,
p,
t))
r
r
rdxlPtyj(0,
t)
dt)
RI
Now we use (2.4.6/3) to obtain
I=sup
I Lpo(Rn, lgo)II' - e sup 12k81gk (. 1 + it) I LP,(R8,lq,)II
I12k8ogk(.. it)
tERi 11/(z)
(10)
tER, I
F(Fro,go' Fp,,q,)I i
cf. (2.4.4/2) and (2.3.1/6). However, (5) and (10) prove (4).
Step 2. We prove that FP,q(R.) C (F8r°o,go(1?
(Rn))e
F8'
(11) 1
Let gEfp.q(Rn), {-Pk(x)lk_oEO(Rn) and
gk(x)=F-1g,kFg.
Let TPk(x)=
l=-1
4k+t(x)
if k=0, 1, 2.... (with T_1=0). In particular, 't'k(x) =1 if xEsupp q'k. Finally we recall of the maximal function gk
x- y)i
xERn,
gk(x)=sup zERn 1+12kyla
(12)
n
from Definition 2.3.6/2, where we assume that a::-
-.Obviously, g (x) 0
min (p, q) if gk(x) does not vanish identically. If z E A, we put
(13)
Ca(2)
k
F 1 kr 2e,(z)k
/(z) k=0
t=0
where
g
12t8gt*(x)Ir)
Ii2t8gi'
Lp(R8, lq)Ile'Wyk<(a)(x)
(1_z+z)(l) so-zst
l(z)=sq 92(Z) =P t `
C3(z) =1
1-z
z
p0 +P1 L --Z -p (po
-q (11-z
z
q0 +qt/ ,
z
+p1
1-Z
(14) z
e4(z)=q (qo +q1
Theorem 2.3.6. shows that 11218g1* I Lp(R8, lq)II is finite. First we wish to show that /(z) is an S'(R,)-analytic function in A in the sense of 2.4.4. The estimates below will show that the series (13) converges at least in S'(R8), in particular, /(z) ES'(R,,)
for every z E A. Because gk(x) E Lp(Rn) it follows from (1.4.1/3) that gk(x) is a bound-
ed and uniformly continuous function in Rn. Then gh (x) has the same properties. Now it is not complicated to see that the properties (ii) and (iii) from 2.4.4. for an S'(Rn)-analytic function are satisfied. Furthermore, (1) and (14) yield
l(0)
F-'1PkFgk= k=0
F-1gkFg=g .
k=0
(15)
2. Function Spaces on Rn
72
Next we prove that 11i(it) I FPO,go(Rn)II=cII9I FP,q(Rn)II .
(16)
where c is independent of g and of t E R1. The proof will also show that (13) converges in S'(Rn) (appropriate modifications). If [ ... ]k denotes the corresponding brackets in (13), then F-1ykF[ ... Jk(x, z) = 2e,(z)kII2l89i I Lp(R4,
lq)IIe3(z)
Pa(z)
/
(17)
k
X f (F-'Vk) (y) 9'k'(7) (X - y) 1 2] Rn \l=0
I2lggi (x _ y) I q) q
dy.
By (12) we have B3(z)
(k
I9k`(Z) (x - y)I
q
I2189i (x _ y) I q)
t=0
Repa(z)
`c9x
/ k( Ree4(2)(x)
q
(1 + I2ky
2leggi q(x))
l=0
Now (17) yields
IF-1VkF[...3k (x, z) I _ 2Ree (z)kMI2l89i I Lp(Rn, lq)IIReQ'(z)9k Reea(Z) Rep3(z)
(18)
fI
X (21 2l81gi'1(x))
(F-t s)(y)I (1 + I2kyla)IRee1(z)I+IRee2(z)I dy
Rn
1=0
We may assume (without loss of generality) that yk(y) =y,1(2-k+1y) if k= 1, 2.... Then (F-1'ok)(y)=2(k-i)n(F-1y,1)(2k-iy). In particular, the integral on the
right-hand side of (18) can be estimated from above by a constant which is independent of k and z E .J. Let z=it with t E R1. We distinguish two cases, k q , then we can replace I Re e2(it) -_ 0 and Re e2(it) - 0. If Re e2(it) 0, i.e. 1=0 Po q0 in (18) by From this it follows that 1=0
II2"oF-1y,kF[...]k(' , it)
I Lp0(Rn, lgo)II -_ cII218gl I Lp(Rn, lq)II
(19)
By Theorem 2.3.6, the right-hand side of (19) can be estimated from above by II9
I FP,q(Rn)II From Theorem 1.6.3 we obtain that (20)
IIf(1t) I F8o,ga(Rn)II`dII9'I FP,g(Rn)II
In a similar way one can prove that I1f(1 +it) I FP1,q,(Rn)II
Re e2(it) _< 0, i.e. q0
.
(21)
cjI9 I FP,q(Rn)II
and (11). Now we assume that
(20), (21) and (15) prove gE (I'1$P0,g0(Rn),
Let
al = 218Qgl g
and
qo q --P)=-q,, Re e2(1t) X=q q (q0
Po
apply Lemma 2.4.6/1 to obtain Rep2(il) k
bk=2k8Q9r g (2] 21g(x)
g
We
Po
qo
(22)
l=0
and go
4
b.=c(
k=0
2ksgg*q) k=0
P po.
(23)
2.4. Interpolation
73
If one uses (22) and (23), then (19) is a consequence of (18). The rest is the same
as in the case Re e2(it)=0. This proves (11) in any case. Now (4) and (11) prove (3). Remark 1. As we remarked in (2.3.5/4), FP92(Rn) =hp(Rn) are the local Hardy spaces. Restricted to that case, (3) yields
p
O
0
than or equal to 1, then both complex methods, the classical method [ , ]© and the above
)p make sense. If 1<po<-, 19(Rn),
.[FPO, 9o(Rn), F)1,4s(Rn)]©=F,,q(Rn)
where the parameters have the same meaning as in the above theorem. In these cases, the two methods yield the same result. On the other hand (25) [BPm(Rn), BP.(Rn)]e=Jk JR.), 1
where
for the above method is (26)
(BBpW(Rn),
Hence, in this limiting case, the two methods yield different results.
2.4.8.
Fourier Multipliers for the Spaces Fz,,4(R,t)
We proved in Proposition 2.4.1 the interpolation property for the real method. The question arises whether the above complex method has a corresponding pro-
perty. Unfortunately, the situation for this method is more complicated than for the real method, and we have no direct counterpart of Proposition 2.4.1. In the few subsequent applications we shall prove the interpolation property from time to time under additional hypotheses on the underlying operators. One of the most interesting applications will be described in this subsection, namely, an improvement of Theorem 2.3.7, which deals with Fourier multipliers and FP,9(R,,). Fourier multipliers for the spaces BP,q(R,a) will for the spaces be treated extensively in Section 2.6. Thus we restrict ourselves for the moment to the spaces If 0-
ap,9=n (min
(1, p, q)
1
2
()1
74
2. Function Spaces on R.
ef. (1.6.4/1). We recall that H2'(Rn) are the special Bessel potential spaces from 1.5.2. If x = ni =0, 1, 2, ... then H2 (Rn) = W2 (Rn) are the well-known Sobolev spaces. By (2.3.5/2) we have H2(Rn) = F2 2(Rn) = B2,2(Rn). Let ,V(x) ES(Rn) and gp(x)ES(Rn) with
xI-2,
suppVcfyl iyl--4}, V(x)=1 if
0=T(x)=1, suPP4'C(yI4-IyI`4j, T(x)=1
2=lxl{2.
if
(2)
(3)
J
We introduce, for the sake of brevity, Ilm
1197(-) m(2k .)
I h2(Rn)II =ll+Vna I H'(Rn)II + sup
Proposition. (i)
If 0-
there exists a constant c such that
I H(1? )Il
(4)
then n+ 2 min (p, q)'
IIF-im F/ I FP,q(Rn)II `cllms I h2(Rn)Il If FP,q(Rn)II
(5)
holds for all functions m(x)EL_(Rn) and all /EFP,q(Rn).
(ii) If 1-
and
then there exists a constant c
such that (5) holds for all functions v?(x)EL.(Rn) and all /EF-,q(Rn). Proof. Step 1. Let {pk(x)}k_OEO(Rf), cf. 2.3.1. By (2.3.1/6) we have IF-1mF/ I FP,q(Rn)II =jj2-"F-1rngkFf I L7,(Rn, lq)lI
If k=1, 2, ..., then 2`F-1??1TkF/=F-1m(.) T (2-k .) F[F-1pk2skFf] (6) (modification if k = 0). Application of Theorem 1.6.3 with/k = 2'kF-1gkFl and Mk(y) _ =m(y) qp(2-ky) (modification if k=0) yields (5). Step 2. In order to prove (ii) we recall of the following Fourier multiplier theo-
rem of Michlin-Hormander type: if 1
(7) 1
c sup 1821.1-n
f
I D'mk(x)I2 dx)
/
25IxIu2Rk-0
II/k
I LP(Rn, lq)II
holds for all systems {mk(x)}k=ocL_(Rf) and all systems {/k(x)}k-o of measurable
functions in Rn, where the supreinum is taken over all R:0 and all multi-indices a with 0 Joel 1 + [I] (of course, of interest are only the systems {mk} and {/k} for which the right-hand side of (7) makes sense and is finite). A proof of (7) has been given
in [I, pp. 161-165] as usual, [-I is the largest natural number which is less than or equal to ). If q' has the above meaning, cf. (3), then (7) can be reformulated as
2
11F-1mkFlk I Lp(Rn, lq)ll 1
c sup 1=0
jig,(-) m1(2j .) H2(Rn)112) 2 I
(8)
II/k
I Lq,(Rn, lq)11,
2.4. Interpolation
75
where the suprelnuul is taken over all integers j and where x =1 + {I}. But the same proof as in [I, pp. 161-165] shows that (8) is also true if x is an arbitrary number with x 2 (if one starts with such an assumption, then the proof in [I, pp. 161-165] is even more transparent than in the original version). Let fk = 2'kF-1 gkFf
and mi(x)=rn(x) T(2-ix) if k=0, 1, 2, ... and 1=1, 2.... Then (8), (6), and (3) yield (ii) (the term with k=0 is covered by Theorem 1.5.2).
Remark 1. The scalar case of (7) is the famous Michlin-Hormander multiplier theorem, n
cf. L. Hormander [1]. Also the scalar case of (8) with r. -2 is known, cf. J. Peetre [1] and the
remarks in A. P. Calderon, A. Torchinsky [1, II, p. 168]. Concerning vector-valued Fourier multiplier theorems for L9,(R0, lq) with I
Theorem. If 0
- oo < s < oo and x
vp,q, then there exists a constant
c such that IIF-1mFf I FP,q(Rn)II `==cIIm
h2(Rn)II If F,q(Rn)II
(9)
holds for all m(x)EL-(Rn) and all f EFP,q(Rn).
Proof. Step 1. The idea is to interpolate the two parts of the above proposition.
We start with a preparation. We assume that (9) is valid for every function m(x) ES(Rn) with compact support. Then it follows by a limiting argument that (9) is also valid for every m(x) EHZ(Rn) with compact support (F-ImF/ is defined via this limiting procedure). Let m(x) be an arbitrary function with Im I h;(Rn)II <00. Let A(x) ES(Rn) with supp Ac {y IyJ = 2} and A(x) =1 if xI -_1. Then (9), with A(ex) m(x) instead of m(x), is valid. But IIA(e
) m(') I h2(Rn)II `=cliin I h2(Rn)Ji
where c is independent of s 30. Again by a limiting argument it follows that (9) is valid. Step 2. Let vi(x) ES(Rn) with a compact support. Let a(x) E S(Rn) and #(x) ES(Rn) be two functions with 0=a(x)-_ 1, suppac{y I yI=2},
0(x)1, supp fl c (y)IyH2}. and k=1
#(2-kx)+a(x)=1
if
xERn.
The function tp(x) and 99(x) have the,same meaning as in (2) and (3). Let A be the closure of the strip A = {z I 0 < Rez < 11 from 2.4.4. If x E Rn and z E A, then we put 5(z)
m(x, z)
=[F-1 (1 + IEI2) 2
+1 k=1
Fam](x) SV(x)
(10)
e(z)
[F-1 (1+IEi2) 2
Ff(-) m(2k')]
(2-kx)
T(2-kx)
,
where e(z) =x -xe(1 - z) -x1z with the positive numbers xo, x1 and X. If O is a given
number with 0
(11)
76
2. Function Spaces on R.
It is clear how to understand (10): the operator e(z)
e(2) F_1
F=F-1
2 I''] acts on j(y) m(2ky), and the result is taken at the point 2-kx, etc. Now it is easy to see that 2
/(z) -F-1m( , z) F/(z)
maps an S'(R,,)-analytic function in A into an S'(R.n)-analytic function in A, cf. 2.4.4. (by our assumption, the sum in (10) is finite). Furthermore, m(x, O)=m(x) . Finally, (4) yields !Im(, it) I hz (Rn)II=cIIm I h (Rn)II and
(12) (13)
I hi1(R..)II `ellm I h2(Rn)II ,
where c is independent of t E R1.
Step 3. Now we assume that we have the two multiplier assertions, IIF-1MFf I FP,,q,(Rn)II `eII1
FP31
h2`(Rn)II IIf-I
1,q,(Rn)II
(14)
with 1=0 or 1. Then (13) yields I
F",g,(Rn.)II =cllm I hi(Rn.)II Ill i FP1,q,(Rn)II
(15)
with I= 0 or 1. Now we can apply Theorem 2.4.7(ii). For that purpose we replace fin (15) by an appropriate S'(Rn)-analytic function /(z) in A with /(O) = f. If the parameters have the same meaning as in Theorem 2.4.7, then (12) yields IIF-1mFf I Fp,q(Rn)II `c(Im I hx2(Rn)II If FSP1,q1(Rn)II I
(16)
Step 4. Now it is easy to prove the theorem. By part (ii) of the above proposition we may assume that min(p, q) =1. Then we choose two couples (po, qo) and (p1, q1)
as indicated in Fig. 2.4.8. Let 30 = s1 = s. Then we apply parts (ii) and (i) of 1
q 1 1
1
(1 1). P7 G7
j
1
P
Fig. 2.4.8
the above proposition to F''O,go(Rn) and FPS q,(R%), respectively, i.e. xo=2 +r
+e in (14), where -,0 is an arbitrary number. Then (16) and x1= 2 + min (p, q) yields (9) with n 2
nO min (p1, q1)
If p = q then p1= q1. We have n
n
x=e+2 +--n
1-O
O =1 -1- 0 and
Pi P
PO
p PO Let p041 and then 040 (i.e. pi-0). Then we see that any number x-oP,q is admissible. Similarly if q--p.
2.4. Interpolation
77
Remark 2. The theorem is an essential improvement of Theorem 2.3.7. and (2.3.7/6). The quesn
tion arises whether ap q is natural. If 12 in part (ii) of the proposition and in the theorem cannot be improved. The case min (p, q) s 1 is more sophisticated.
We refer to H. Triebel [19, Remark 11], where we discussed this problem in detail. That paper was also the basis for the above treatment.. Fourier multiplier theorems for the spaces F8p,q(Rn) have also been proved recently by L. Paivarinta [3].
2.4.9.
The Spaces LP(Rn, lq): Complex Interpolation and Fourier Multipliers
The spaces LP(Rn, lq) =LP(1q) have been introduced in Definition 1.6.1, where we now prefer to indicate "Bn" in agreement with our notations in this chapter. Our main aim is to improve Theorem 1.6.3 in the sense of 1.6.4. Let (mostly for the sake of simplicity) Qk= {yI IyI52k} where k=0, 1, 2.... Then one can extend the complex interpolation method from 2.4.4., Theorem 2.4.7 and the considerations in 2.4.8. from the spaces FP,q(Rn) to the spaces LP(Rn, lq). In particular, the proofs of the counterparts of the Theorems 2.4.7 and 2.4.8 go through without any substantial changes. Thus we restrict ourselves to the formulation of the corresponding definitions and results, cf. also H. Triebel [15, 16] and L. Paivarinta [1]. The strip A has the same meaning as in 2.4.4.
Definition 1. If 0
(i) /k(x, z) with k = 0, 1, 2.... is a uniformly continuous and bounded function in .R XA. Furthermore, fk(x, z) with k =0, 1, 2.... is an analytic function in A for every fixed x E R, . (ii) We have supp (F/k)
z) c{y I IyI52k+1}
(1)
for k=0, 1, 2, ... and for every fixed zEA. (iii)
92
I F(L o(Rn, lqo), LP (Rn, 1,,))II = max sup II/k(', l+it) I LP1(Rn, lgl)II <°°
111(z)
(2)
1=0,1 tER1
Remark 1. This is the counterpart of an S'(Rn)-analytic function in A and of Definition 2.4.4/1 (ii). At first glance one might wish to replace 2k+1 in (1) by 2k. But this is unimportant, and we shall indicate below the reason for this choice. One can prove that F(LPOsa
(Rn lqo), L Pi' (R, 1,,))
is a quasi-Banach space, cf. Proposition 2.4.5.
Definition 2. Let 0
with
9(z)={9k(x, z)}x=oEF(L o(Rn, 1qo), L (Rn, lqi))
(3)
suPP (F9k) (. , O) c{y I IyI 52k}
(4)
and fk(X) =gk(x, O) for k =0, 1, 2.... Let .Q
Ilf
D
I (L o(Rn, lqo), I.P (Rn, lgi))0II =ice II9(z) I F(L o(Rn, lpo), LP (Rn, lgi))II ,
(5)
where the infimum is taken over all admissible systems g(z).
Remark 2. This is the counterpart of 2.4.4/2 (ii). The assumption (4) strengthens (1) (with gk instead of fk) if z =0.
78
2. Function Spaces on B.
Theorem 1. Let 0
Po
Pi
and
q
qo
q1
(6)
then
(L o(gln, 1q0), Lp (R.,
p(Bn, le)
(7)
Remark 3. This is the counterpart of Theorem 2.4.7 (ii). One can use the same proof. The small difficulties with the factor 2 come from the counterpart of (2.4.7/13). Next we strengthen Theorem 1.6.3 in the sense of 1.6.4. All notations have the same meaning as in Theorem 1.6.3 with the above specialization of Stk. In particular H'2= H2(1? ) are the Bessel-potential spaces. Furthermore, up g, has the meaning of (1.6.4/1) or (2.4.8/1).
Theorem 2. If 0
up Q, then there exists a constant c such that IIF-1MkF/k I L,(]?,,,
sup!JM,(2i')I H2(Ba)II Iltk I Lp(Rn., l9)JI
(8)
holds for all systems {fk(x)}k=oELP(R,,, lq) and all sequences {Mk(x)}k=ocH2(Bn)
Remark 4. The proof of this theorem is essentially the same as the proof of Theorem 2.4.8.
It is based on Theorem I above. The restriction x>op, is more natural than the corresponding restriction in Theorem 1.6.3. Later on we shall use this improvement. In contrast to Theorem 1.6.3, the case q= - is excluded (but this depends probably only on our method).
2.5. 2.5.1.
Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations An Orientation
The spaces Bpq(Rn) and Fp,9(Rn) are constructed on the basis of Principle 2.2.4, in particular (2.2.4/13) and (2.2.4/14). We specialized the number a in (2.2.4/13) and (2.2.4/15) to a=2, cf. Definition 2.3.1/2. However on the basis of Theorem 1.6.3 (and its scalar counterpart) it is easy to see that any choice of a>-1 yields the same two scales B' ,,(R,,) and F' ,,(R.) (for all admissible parameters s, p, and q in the sense of Definition 2.3.1/2). Furthermore we proved that all these spaces satisfy Criterion 2.2.3, cf. Corollary 2.3.7. Hence our spaces are meaningful in the sense of the considerations in 2.2.3. and 2.2.4. What about the approximation procedures front 2.2.5., which we described as a further possibility in order to study smoothness properties of functions and distributions? In 2.5.2. and 2.5.3. we shall see that the corresponding spaces, cf. e.g. (2.2.5/7) and (2.2.5/9), coincide with the spaces BP,Q(R.) and (under some restrictions on the para-
meters). In 2.2.2. we gave a list of constructive spaces and claimed in Remark 2.2.2/3 and in 2.3.5. that these spaces coincide with special spaces BP Q(R,,) and This also will be done in this Section 2.5. The Bessel-potential spaces Hp(R,,) (which include the classical Sobolev spaces) will be treated in 2.5.6.
Subsection 2.5.8. deals with the local Hardy spaces h,(R.) (and also with
brrro(R,,)). Concerning the Besov spaces AP9(R,,,) and the Holder-Zygmund spaces Lx(R.n) we describe two rather different approaches. In 2.5.7. we discuss briefly
the spaces and (28(R,,) from the standpoint of interpolation theory. This approach is very convincing and comparatively easy. The disadvantage
is that one needs some statements of the abstract real interpolation method (and we promised in 2.4.1. to use interpolation methods only occasionally). A more direct, but also essentially more complicated approach (which covers also the cases p -I in contrast to the interpolation method in 2.5.7.) is contained in 2.5.12. The Subsections 2.5.9.-2.5.13. are crucial for subsequent considerations.
79
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
2.5.2.
Nikol'skij Representations
If 0.
r(Rn) = {b I b = {bk(x)}k=o, bk(x) E S'(Rn) n Lp(Rn) ,
supp Fboc{y I IyI-2}, suppFb;c{y 12j-1--lyI-_2i+1} if j=1,2,3,...}, cf. (2.2.5/8). If {9'k(x)}k=oEO(Rn) and /EB',q(Rn), then {F-1(pkF1}k=0E'8p(Rn), of. 2.3.1. This is a typical example which will be useful.
Theorem. Let 0
(i) If
By,q(Rn)={f /ES'(Rn), 3{bk}k=oE58p(Rn)
such that (2)
E bk(x) in S'(Rn), II28kbk I lq(Lp(Rn))11 <°°} .
k =O
Furthermore, inf II28kbk I lq(Lp(Rn))II
(3)
is an equivalent quasi-norm in BP q(Rn), where the infimum is taken over all admissible representations.
(ii) If 0
FM(Rn) _ {1 I /ES'(Rn), 3 {bk}k=oE p(Rn)
such that (4)
2] bk(x)
in
S'(Rn),
II28kbk
I Lp(Rn, lq)II < oo} .
k =O
Furthermore, (5)
inf II28kbk 1 Lp(Rn, lq)II
is an equivalent quasi-norm in F',q(Rn), where the infimum is taken over all admissible representations. Proo/. If {Tk(x)}k=0EP(Rn) and /ES'(Rn), then we have
E bk(x) in S'(R5)
k =0
with bk(x) = F-1rpkF/. This shows that every / E B' q(Rn) can be represented by the right-hand side of (2) and that (3) can be estimated from above by II/ I B',q(Rn)II Similarly for F,,q(Rn). Conversely, if /ES'(Rn) is given by 2] bk(x), {bk}k=OE k=0
p(Rn), Il28kbk I lq(Lp(Rn))II
then we have 1+
F 1TkF/= G+ F 1(PkFbk+r r=-1 (with b_1=0). The rest is now the same as in the proof of Proposition 2.3.2/1, including the fact that If I Bp q(Ra)II can be estimated from above by (3) (multiplied with an appropriate constant). Similarly for FP q(Rn), cf. Step 2 of the proof of Proposition 2.3.2/1. Remark. Further representations of this type may be found in [S, pp. 43-45]. Representations of the above type have been used extensively by S. M. Nikol'skij and 0. V. Besov in connection
with the spaces B',q(R,). A comprehensive treatment and many references may be found in S. M. Nikol'skij [3, 5.5 and 5.6] (cf. also [1, 2.3]). However in comparison with the original
80
2. Function Spaces on R.
Nikol'skij-Besov approach there is a difference. S. M. Nikol'skij and 0. V. Besov use the class
91,(B,)from (2.2.5/6) (with 15p5oo) instead of (R,) from (1). The above approach may be characterized as a "decomposition of f by entire analytic functions of exponential type", while the approach which is based on 52i,(R,,) is an "approximation of f by entire analytic functions of exponential type". It will be studied in detail in the next subsection.
2.5.3.
Characterizations by Approximation
We discuss the problem raised in 2.2.5. and start with some more or less classical assertions. Let /EL9(R5) with 1 and let
k=0,1..2,...,
Ep(2k, f) =inf IIf -g I Lp(Rn)II ,
(1)
where the infimuin is taken over all 9ELp(Rn) such that supp Fgc {y I IyI <=2k} (in particular, g is an entire analytic function of exponential type). As we pointed out in 2.2.5., (1) is the counterpart of the best approximation of a periodic function by trigonometric polynomials. Let 1
lit I BPq(R.)I!*=lit I Lp(Rn)II +[
q
28kgEp(2k, f)q)
(2)
k =0
where 1 _=:-::p s -, 1 s q s - and s: --O (modification if q = -). Then it is a well-known
fact in the theory of Besov spaces that (under the above restriction on the parameters) (2) is an equivalent norm in BP,q(R,,) and that Bp,q(Rn)={f I fES'(Rn), lit
Bp,q(Rn)II*<°°}
I
.
(3)
Cf. S. M. Nikol'skij [3. 5.5 and 5.6] or [1, 2.5.41. The restriction s >0 is natural. The norm in (2) with s<0 is equivalent to lit I LL(Rn)II.This shows that (3) cannot be true if s<0. Hence, the "approximation approach" (cf. the end of 2.5.2.) is in contrast to the "decomposition approach" from 2.5.2. In restricted to order to extend (2), (3) to the spaces F,,q(Rn) we introduce the class Wp(Rn), cf. also (2.2.5/6). If 0 -
Bp,q(Rn)={f I IES'(Rn), 3a={ak}k=oE y,(R.) such that f = lim ak(x) in S'(R,,) and
k--
III
Bp,q(Rn)lla=llao I
where again s>0, 1 t p Furthermore,
oo, 1
(4)
(5)
I Lp(Rn)II +,I121(f-ak) I tq(Lp(Rn))II
q:-!5 -. Concerning the notations, of. 1.2.2 (and 2.3.1).
lit I BP,q(Rn)IIx=infIIf IB,,q(Rn)Ila,
(6)
where the infimum is taken over all admissible systems a in the sense of (5), 4s an equivalent norm in Bp,q(Rn). We remark that f =kim ak(x) in S'(R5) follows from III I B,,5(R)I°°° under the above restrictions for the parameters. However, we wish to extend (5) to values p < 1, and there the situation is different. In that cases there arises also the somewhat delicate question about the nature of f E B ,,q(Rn),
in particular, how to understand III -ak I Lp(Rn)II etc. We postpone this prob-
lem and discuss it in Remark 1 after the proof of the theorem. In the proof
itself we temporarily take it for granted that Ax) ELp(Rn) makes sense in a natural
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
81
way for all spaces under consideration. Finally we recall of the important numbers 1 1 1 _ 1 op-n (min (p, 1) 2) and °p,q=n (min (p, q, 1) 2 where 0
dp=22
1
and dp,q = n (
(min (p; 1)
I
min (p, q, 1)
-1)
(7)
.
(8)
If 0-dp, then
Theorem. (i)
B,,q(R.)={f f ES'(Rn), 3a={ak}7=OEtp(Rn) such that f = lim ak in S'(Rn) _m k__
IIf
B',,q(Rn)IIa=IIao I
,
(9)
I Lp(Rn)II +M28k (f-ak) I lq(Lp(Rn))II <-} .
Furthermore, IIf
j
B*',q(Rn)II X =inf II/
i
(10)
BsP,q(Rn)lla ,
where the infimum is taken over all admissible systems aE2tp(Rn), is an equivalent quasi-norm in BP ',(R.). then (ii) If 0
F,,,(R.)={f f ES'(Rn), 3a={ak}T_oEWp(Rf) such that f = lim ak in S'(Rn) ,
(11)
k__
IIf
Fsi,,q(Rn)Ila=llao I Lp(Rn)II +II28k (f-ak) I L,(Rn, lq)II
.
Furthermore, (12)
Fp,q(Rn)I; X =inf If I F, q(Rn)IIa ,
IIf
where the infimum is taken over all admissible systems aEWp(Rn), is an equivalent quasi-norm in Fp,q(Rn).
0 -dp, then we prove that there exists
Proof. Step 1. If 0 - . : : : p
a constant c,0 such that IIf
I BP,q(Rn)II X
ell/
(13)
I B',q(R.)Il
holds for all f EBp,q(Rn). If {ck(x)}7_oEO(Rf) and f EBp,q(Rn), then L.
ak(x) = I F-1pjFf --f in S'(Rn) if 1=0
k-- .
Furthermore, ak(x) E S'(Rn) (1 Lp(Rn) and supp Fak c {y I
Etp(Rn). If l -p=o, then
2k8IIf-ak I LP(Rn)I1 =2ks
1=k+1
Iyl
2k+1} . Hence, {ak}k=o E
F-1T1Ff I Lp(R,) II
(14)
2-j828(k+j)II Fi -199k+jFf I Lp(Rn)II
j=1
If 1- q
the triangle inequality yields 112k8
(f-ak) I lq(Lp(Rn))II
j=1 6
2-i8II28kF-199kF1 I lq(Lp(R5))II `cIif I Bp,q(Rn)II
Triebel, Function engl.
(15)
2. Function Spaces on R,,
82
If 0
j=1
2-i8 28(k+j)gI F 1Tk+jFl I LL(Rn)Ilq
(16)
.
Summation over k yields (15). If 0
i=1
2-j8P28p(k+j)IIFi -1Tk+jF/ I Lp(Rn)IIP
(17)
.
If q=p or q
BP,,(Rn)II
and (15) prove (13).
Step 2. If 06p,q, then we prove that there exists a constant c>-0 such that (18)
F8,q(Rn)II "-ell/ I FP,q(Rn)II
III
holds for all f EFBP,q(Rn) If 1=q=s, then the counterpart of (14) reads as follows, 1
(2k8Q 11(x) - ak(x)I q1 k=0
2 2-is ( 2 28(k+j)7 FI -192k+jF/)(x)I q
1\k=0
j=1
///
(19)
1
=c (S 2skgl(F-1TkFl)(x)Igl
g
\k =0
(modification if q = oo) . If 0 < q < 1, we have
2] 2k8q II(x)-ak(x)q
k=0
2-jsq j=1
2s(k+j)gI(F-19,k+jF/)(x)Iq
(20)
k=0
=C 2] 28kq I
(F-192kF/)(x)lq
.
k =O
Taking the Lp(Rn)-quasi-norm of (19) and (20), we obtain (18).
Step 3. If 0
6p,q, we prove that there exists a constant c>0 such that III
(21)
I Fp,q(Rn)II =r-III I Fp,q(Rn)Ila
holds for any admissible system aE9p(Rn) in the sense of (11). Let (otherwise one has to modify the calculations in the same manner as above ; this will not be described here in detail). Let f be given by the right-hand side of (11). If again {cpk(x)}k=oEO(Rn), then we have (F-191kF/)(x)lq=
F -1TkF(ak+j-ak+i-1)(x)
Ig
I
IF-192kF(ak+i-ak+j-1)(x)lq
and, as above,
n
/ II28kF-19'kF/ I Lp(Rn, lq)II = ( f Rn k=0
1
i
28kq
qJ
dx)p
q
P
2s(k+j)q IF-1 YkF(ak+j- ak+j=1 y_-i 2- sjp f[ Rn k=0
1)(-)Iq
J
l 1
j=W
2-8jp II2s(k+j)F-1-PkFi (ak+j-ak+j-1) I Lp(Rn, lq)IIP) 1
1
gdxp
(22)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
83
(of course, ak=0 if k<0). We assume, without loss of generality, Tk(x)=gpl(2-k+1x) if k =1, 2, 3, ... In order to apply Theorem 2.4.9/2 we remark that supp (ak+j - ak+j-1) C {y j y1 - 2k+j+1} and I4k(21 +, .) I H2(Rn)II =IIw1(2i+1 .) I H'2(Rn)II
`c2+ 2)
,
(23)
where c is independent of j. Now Theorem 2.4.9/2 yields I2s(k+j)F-199kF(ak+j-ak+j-1) I Lp(Rn lq)II -_c2'j(x2 - n) II2s(k+j)(ak+j-ak+j-1) I LP(Rn, lq)II
(24)
where x>up,q (here we use for the first time that q<-). Substituting (24) into (22) we obtain 1
11281E-199kFf
I LP(Rn, lq)II`c
7--1
2'"
P 2-s)P)II28k (ak-ak-1) I LP(Rn, lq)II I
=cII28k (f - ak) I LP(Rn, lq)II +cllao I Lp(Rn)II ,
(25)
provided that s>x-2 >dp,q. This proves (21), where c is independent of the cho-
sen system a= {ak}k_o. Similarly for the other pairs p and q. Hence, the proof of part (ii) is complete.
Step 4. If 0
ap, then we prove that there exists a constant c>0 such that !I/
(26)
I BP,5(Rn)II ncllf I BP,q(Rn)II X
for any admissible system a E ip(Rn) in the sense of (9). The proof follows the same lines as in Step 3. In the counterpart of (22) we need only the scalar case of Theorem 2.4.9/2, i.e. (1.5.2/13) (including p = oo). Instead of (25) we obtain (for 0
2 +-
C
' 2-s)P II28(k+j)(ak+j-ak+j-1)
2j=-1
(27) I LP(Rn)IIP
where x>ap. If again 0
{C
j=-2
2
I lq(LP(Rn))IIP
j(x n -s)P
II2sk (ak+1-ak) I lq(LP(Rn))IiP
provided that s > x - >ap. This proves (26), where c is independent of the chosen 2 system a={ak}k=o. Hence, also the proof of part (i) is complete. Remark 1. We return to the postponed problem of how to understand tELP()?n) in the proof (and also in the formulation of the theorem) if p<1. Let tEB8,q(Rn). By (1.3.2/5) (and a completion argument) it follows that IIF-1ckFt I Li(Rn)IIuc2k°PIIF TkFl I LP(Rn)II ,
(28)
where c is independent of k. If s -d p, then (28) yields BP,q(Rn) C'B'_g P(Rn) CL1(Rn) 6*
(29)
84
2. Function Spaces on Rn
The last inequality follows easily from Ill I L1(Rn)II s
Y_IIF-199kFf
k=0
(30)
I L1(Rn)Il cllf I B'1,q(Rn)II
for T -O and O< q s -. Hence in that cases, i.e. s >- ap, every / E B7,q(Rn) is a regular distribution.
Of course, this is also valid if 15p-_- and s-0, because Bp,q(Rn)cLp(R.), ef. (30) with p instead of 1. By (2.3.2/9) and ap,gzap, we have the same argument for the spaces F8 q(Rn) with s lap q. Let again p<1 and f EBp,q(Rn) with s-699. If {Tk(x)}k=oEI(Rn), then it follows by (30) that ak(x) from Step 1 converges not only in S'(Rn) but also in L1(Rn) to / if k ---. By an argument of type (14) one obtains that {ak(x)}k=p is also a fundamental sequence in L'(Rn). Let g(x) ELp(Rn) be the limit element. However, the limit elements in L1(Rn) and Lp(Rn) must coincide a. e. Hence /=gCLp(Rn). This justifies the calculations in Step 1 and Step 2. What about Step 3 and Step 4? Let p<1 and let f be an element of the right-hand side of (9). Then
it follows that /ELp(R,,) and that ak converges not only in S'(Rn) but also in Lp(Rn) to /. In order to justify the a. e. pointwise estimate of F-199kF1 in Step 3 and in Step 4, we remark
that y
-c
-1
F-'kF(ak+j-ak+j-t) I L1(Rn) IIF
199k
I L1(Rn)Illiak+j-a,k+j-1 I L1(Rn)IJ
However, IIF-1Tk I L1(Rn)II is uniformly bounded. Then (28) yields
F-199kF (ak+j-ak+7-1) I L1(Rn) Sc
2(k+i)ap lak+j-ak+j-
j
1
R )II I Lp(a
Now it follows that F-1g9kFai converges in L1(Rn) if 1--- and the limit element must be F-199kFl. This justifies the calculations in Step 4. Similarly in Step 3, because the space on the right-hand side of (11) can be estimated in the same way as in (2.3.2/9) by the space on the right-hand side of (9).
Remark 2. We. used Theorem 2.4.9/2 and obtained a sharp and natural result. If one uses the weaker Theorem 1.6.3 then one has for the spaces FP,q(R.) with min (p, q)<1 a weaker
result (the case - -p > 1, - >-q - I can be treated by the known multiplier theorem from Proposition 2.4.8 (ii)). On the other hand, Theorem 1.6.3 covers the case q=- (in contrast to Theorem 2.4.9/2). If we use Theorem 1.6.3, then we obtain the assertion of part (ii) of the above theorem under the restriction n min (p, q)
(of course, only qis of interest). This follows immediately from Step 2 and Step 3 of the above proof. This result has been proved in [S, 2.2.3]. Remark 3. In a formal way (without the justification in Remark 1), the calculation in Step 1 and Step 2 go through if s-0. What about the values 0-s=ap, reap. 0<snEap,q? If 0
FS=_c$0 and IIF-199xF6 I Lp(Rn)II =c ( f I
[F-1991(2-k+1 )](x) IP dx)p
Rye
=c2kn( f I(F-1991) (2k+lx)Ipdx)P
=c'2kn(1 P)=c'2 kap,
Rn
where k=1, 2, 3.... (again we used 4pk(x)=991(2-k+1x) for {99k(x)}k=QEP(Rn)). This shows that the calculations in Step I do not make sense if 0
cannot be interpreted in general as a regular distribution which belongs also to Lp(Rn).
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
2.5.4.
85
Lizorkin Representations
In the definition of the spaces Bsp q(R,,,) and F, q(Rn) in 2.3.1. we used balls and differences
of balls as the underlying decomposition of R. Now we introduce cubes and corridors. Let
Kk={xIIxjl<2k if
j=1,...,n)-{xIxjI521-1
if
j=1, ...,n}
(1)
where k =1, 2, 3.... and
Ko={xI Ixjlsl if
j=1,2,...}.
(2)
We subdivide Kk with k =1, 2, 3.... by the 3 n hyper-planes {x I xm = 0} and {x I xm = f 2k-1 },
where m=1, .. , n, in congruent cubes Pk, (cf. Fig. 2.5.4). If k is fixed, we obtain T =4n-2n cubes which are numbered by t=1, ... T in an arbitrary way. Let Pot = K0 if X2
1
2
8
4
1
Al
Pk,t
Fig. 2.5.4.
T. Of course T
Rn= U Kk= U U Pk,t . k=0
k=0 t=1
Let Xk and Xk t be the characteristic functions of Kk and Pk t, respectively, k=0, I.... and
t=1,...,T.
Theorem. Let - -s- and 1
BP,q(Rn)=1fIiES'(Rn),II/IBp,q(Rn)IIgk I
2skgljF-1xkFfILr(R.)II44 1
l
={l I /ES (Rn), II/ I Bap,g(Rn)II B=1
2skgIIF-1Xk,tF1
Y_
k=0 t=1
I
(3)
Lp(Rn)IIq)4
(modification if q==), where III I Bp,q(Rn)II x and III I Bp,q(B )II B are equivalent quasi-norms in
Bap,g(Rn)
(ii) If 1q<-, then Fp,q(Rn)l I /ES'(Rn), III I F,,q(Rn)l 1
2.,kq(F-1XkF1)
k=0
)1q)
I Lp(Rn)
(4)
2. Function Spaces on R.
86
={t I fES'()?n), IIf
I
FBP,q(Rn)II B
21gl(F Xk,tFf) (')1" I LP(Rn) U= 0 0 t=1 where lit I FPRn)II q( K and It I FP,q(Rn)II B are equivalent norms in Fp q(Rn). I
Proof. (Outline). The proof is based on the following fact: {xk(x)}k=o is a Fourier multiplier for LP(Rn, lq) if 1 -0 such that II F-IxkFfk I LP(Rn, lq)II clltk I LP(Rn, lq)II
(5)
for all systems {fk(x)}k=oELP(Rn, lq). Similarly for {xk,t(x)}k=0,1,2,... This assertion is not t=1,..., T
covered by Proposition 2.4.8 (ii). It follows from a vector-valued .Fourier multiplier theorem
in P. I. Lizorkin [1, p. 241] (the one-dimensional case may also be found in N. Dunford, J. T. Schwartz [1, II, 11.11, Lemma 24]). If one accepts (5), then the proof of (ii) is essentially the same as the proof of Proposition 2.3.2/1. In order to prove (i), one needs only the scalar case of (5). In that case, the number q is immaterial. Remark. An extension of the theorem to values p s 1 is not possible. This follows from (1.3.5/3), cf. [S, p. 56]. Part (i) of the theorem is essentially due to P. I. Lizorkin, cf. also S. M. Nikol'skij [3, 8.10.1] (including the comments at the end of that book) and [I, 2.11.2]. On the other hand, representations of type (4) have been used by P. I. Lizorkin [1, 4] as a definition of corresponding spaces. If Ep,q are the spaces introduced in P. I. Lizorkin [4], then it follows immedia-
tely from the above theorem that Ep,q=FgP,q(Rn)
2.5.5.
1
if
,
1
Discrete Representations and Schauder Bases for
Let PO = K0 and Pk,t with k =1, 2, 3, ... and t =1, ... , T be the cubes from the previous subsection. Let again xo and Xk,t be the corresponding characteristic functions of P0 and Pk,t,
respectively. Let ok,t be the centre of Pk,t. Let Z. be the lattice from 1.2.4. with the lattice n
points m = (m1, ... , mn). Finally, we recall that xy =
xjyi denotes the scalar product of
x = (xi, ... , xn) E R. and y = (yi, ... , yn) E Rn. We combine the representation (2.5.4/3) of B,,,q(R.) with Proposition 1.3.5 and Remark 1.3.5/2. The idea is to apply (1.3.5/2) and the equivalence assertion in Remark 1.3.5/2 to F-1xk,tFf. We omit details and refer to [S, 2.2.5]. The result is the following.
Theorem. Let -=<s<=, 1
t=
1f
amF-i(e-iT
I
Xo) + 2
am.,k,tF-1(e-j7,2-k+2xmxk,t)
(1)
k=1 1=1
mEZn
(convergence in S'(Rn)) with
mEZn
1
T
1
IamIP)p+r 1k=1t=i mEZn
q
J
(modification if q==). Furthermore, (2) is an equivalent quasi-norm in Bp,q(Rn).
87
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations (ii) f ES'(R,,) belongs to B , q(Rn) if and only if it can be represented as 22k xj sin xj ixak t + bm,k,te xj-7Lmj ] j=1 2 7=1 x;7rm7 k=1 t=1 mEZ Fbm sink
(3)
(convergence in S'(Rn)) with
1
(
r
Ibm[P)P+I mEZn
k(8_nl
T (
2]
k-1t=1 mEZn
12
q4
P/bm,k,,jP)P J
(4)
(modification if qFurthermore, (4) is an equivalent quasinorm in B8M(Ra). Remark 1. Let lq(lp) be the set of all sequences {ct j}17=1 of complex numbers e1 j with
l-1 j.1
P1
4
1
P
4
where 0
and 1
with
Of course, HP(Rn)=Lp(Rn) if 1<
=o
mk,iFfi, Lp(Rn, 12)
f
c sup (R21n1-n
dx``)
2 uJx]u2R
j,k_o
IDRmk,7(x)12
(1)
2
Ilk I Lp(Rn, 12A
holds for all systems {mk,i(x)}k,;=ocL.(R,,) and all systems {fk(x)}k=o of measura-
ble functions in Rn, where the supremum is taken over all R-0 and all multiindices a with O-1 al --I+ Remark. This is the 12-version of HSrmander's famous multiplier theorem. A proof of (1) has been given in [I, pp. 161-165]. The lq-version of (1) (restricted to the "diagonal case", i.e. mk,j =0 if k+j) has been formulated in (2.4.8/7).
Theorem. (i) If --<s
(2)
where Ijf H'(R,,)II is an equivalent norm in F',2(Rn).
(ii). If m =1, 2, 3, ... and 1 p < oo, then HP(Rn)=WP(R,,,)={f /ES'(Rn),LIf1Wy(Rn)II*
atmf
i=1
Lp(Rn)
(3)
(4)
are equivalent norms in HP (R,,).
Proof. Step 1. Let us assume that FP,2(Rn)=Lp(R,,) with 1
(including Step 2 of the proof of that theorem and the Michlin-Hormander multiplier theorem for Lp(Rn) with 1
1
(5)
(equivalent norms). Let / E Lp(R,,) and {Tk(x) }7-o E 0(Rn). Let rnk,o = 9?k and rnk,i =
= 0 if k = 0, 1, 2, ... and j =1, 2.... We, apply (1) with f o = f and I j = 0 if j =1, 2, ...,
and obtain 11F-1q'kFf I Lp(Rn,12)II `CII/ I LP(Rn)jI
Hence f E FP,2(Rn) and Lp(R,,) c FP,2(Rn). In order to prove the converse assertion, we assume that f EFP,2(Rn). Let 1
+Vk(x)
s=-1
Tk+.(x)
(with T_ 1 = 0)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
89
if k=Q, 1 , 2.... We have pk(x)=1 if xEsupp Tk. Let nao,i= o and mk,7=0if k=1, 2,
3.... and j=0, 1, 2, ... We apply (1) with /k=F-1gkF/. Then F-1
i=o
Vljg1F/ I Lp(Rn)
cIIF-19,kFf I Lp(Rn, l2)II
and consequently, III
I Lp(Rn)II =cljf I Fp,2(Rn)j
This proves /ELL(R,,) and Fp,2(Rn)cLp(Rn). The proof is complete. 2.5.7.
The Besov Spaces A;,q(Rn) and the Zygmund Spaces e8(Rn)
In connection with the Besov spaces Ap,q(Rn) from (2.2.2/9), (2.2.2/10), and the Zygmund spaces (23( Rn) from (2.2.2/6) we have to prove (2.3.5/3) and (2.3.5/1). Furthermore, we must show that the Slobodeckij spaces W ,(R,) and the Holder spaces C8(Rn) are special cases of Asp,,(R.) and e,(Rn), respectively, in the sense of (2.2.2/18). All these problems will be solved in the framework of 2.5.12., where we give characterizations of B8p,5(R,) in terms of the differences
dh (and derivatives D°). This direct approach covers also the values p. 1, and the abovementioned results are only special cases. But it is desirable to deal separately with the above problems and to ask for simple proofs. The best way (in the opinion of the author) is to use interpolation theory. This shows also in a very elegant way that the Besov spaces A8,q(Rn) can be obtained by real interpolation from the Sobolev spaces WP (Rn) and that the Zygmund spaces (s(Rn) can be obtained by real interpolation from the spaces Cm(Rn), where m=0, 1, 2, ... , cf. (2.2.2/1). The real interpolation method has been described in 2.4.1. The disadvantage of this approach is that it requires some assertions from abstract interpolation theory in Banach spaces, in particular from the interpolation theory of commutative semigroups of operators in a given Banach space. A reader who is not familiar with interpolation theory (or who is not ready to consult the quoted references) may skip this subsection. As we mentioned previously, the formulas in question, i.e. (2.3.5/3), (2.3.5/1) and (2.2.2/18), are also consequences of the considerations in 2.5.12. This situation allows us to restrict ourselves to an outline of the proof of the theorem. Let Cm'(Rn) with C()?n) =C0(Rn) be the spaces from the beginning of 2.2.2. Let Wp(Rn) with Lp(Rn) = W ,(R.) be the Sobolev spaces from (2.2.2/7). Here m =0, 1, 2.... and 1-p - .
We extend the definition of Wp (Rn) with m=0, 1, 2.... to p=1. Proposition. If 1--p - -, then and
BP(R,,) C Lp(Rn) C BP,m(Rn)
(1)
B_", (B.) cC(Rn) CB°,W(Rn)
(2)
Proof. Step 1. Let {pk(x)}%-oEO(Rn), cf. 2.3.1. If 15p: - and f EBP,i(Rn), then we have
If Lp(Rn)II = 11
k=0
F-1TkFf I LP(Rn)
k=0
III'' -191kFf Lp(Rn)II =11 / I B°p,i(Rn)II
(3)
This proves the left-hand side of (1). Let p= o. By (1.4.1/3) (first derivatives), it follows that every (F-1ipkF/)(x) is bounded and uniformly continuous in R. Then (3) yields /EC(.R ). This proves the left-hand side of (2). Step 2. Let I ELp(Rn) with 15p=-. We have (F_142kF1)(x)= f (F-i9'k)(y)/(x-y)dy, xER,. (4) Rn
We may assume that qk(x) =q2i(2 -k+lx) if k=1,2,3.... Then (F-lWk)(y)
=2(k-1)n(F-19p1)(2k-1y)
-
90
2. Function Spaces on B.
Now (4) yields IIF-19TxFl I Lp(Rn)II<=III I Lp(Rn)II f I(F-1Pk) (y)I dy=cllf I LP(Rf)II Rn
This proves the right-hand sides of (1) and (2).
Theorem. (i) If s-0, 1--p
(5)
es(Rn)=Bm,m(Rn)
(6)
Proof. (Outline). Step 1 . If j=1, ... , n then {Gj(t)}pstis defined by (Gj(t) l) (x) =l(x1, ... , xj-1, xj+t, xj+1, ... , xn)
It is easy to see that G1(t), ... , Gn(t) are n commutative strongly continuous semi-groups of operators in Lp(Rn) with 1-p < and in C(Rn) (here we need that the functions from C(Rn) are uniformly continuous). Concerning strongly -continuous semi-groups of operators, and in particular the corresponding interpolation theory, we refer to [I, 1.13]. If D(Aj) denotes the domain of definition of the infinitesimal generator Aj of {G1(t)}pst<m, then we have D(Aj) _{/ I /ELp(Rn), al ELP(Rn)},
if 1--P---, and D(A1)={f I tEC(Rn), ax7EC(Rn)}, respectively, j =1, ... , n (cf. also [I, Lemma 2.5.1]). If m is a natural number, then we obtain by iteration that Km= n D(A11 ...A ) psj1 +...+jnsm ={f I DafELp(R,,)
where
Ial-m}=WP(Rn) if
1
and
Km={/ 1 Da/EC(Rn)
where
0C1=m}=Cm0?n) ,
respectively. In [I, 1. 13. 6], we developed the real interpolation theory for the spaces Km in an abstract setting. If we apply the results to the above concrete cases, then we obtain immediately (7) (Lp(Rn), WP(Rn))e,q=Apq(Rn) if and
(C(Rn), Cm(Rn))e,.,=c m(Rn) ,
(8)
respectively (cf. also [I, p. 189]), where 0 <0 < 1 and 1-q - , and also many equivalent norms in the corresponding interpolation spaces. Special cases of these equivalent norms establish (2.2.2/18), i.e. W8p(Rn) =A ,p(Rn)
and C1(Rn) =P_S(Rn)
(9)
if 0 <s * integer and 1-p < . Step 2. If m=1, 2, 3, ..., then (1) and Theorem 2.3.8 yield and
Bp1(Rn)cWp(Rn)cBy-(&) if 1=p<_
Bm1(Rn)cCm(Rn)cBZm(Rn) Now (10), Theorem 2.4.2 and Remark 2.4.1/4 show that Bpe,(Rn)=(BP,1(Rn), Bp"t,1(Rn))e,gc(Lp(Rn), W (Rn))e,q c (BP,Po(Rn), By m(Rn) )e,q = BP q (Rn)
(10)
(11)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
91
where 0
(12)
Similarly,
(0(Rn), Cm(Rn))e,m= B `(R,)
(13)
Comparison of (7) and (12) gives (5), and comparison of (8) and (13) gives (6). Remark. Similar proofs have been given in [I, 2.5.1 and 2.7.2] and in [S, 2.2.9.].
2.5.8.
The Local Hardy Spaces hz,(R,,), the Space
The spaces h1,(R,,) and bmo(R,) have been defined in (2.2.2/12) and (2.2.2/14), respectively. It is our aim to prove (2.3.5/4) and (2.3.5/5). Then it follows from (2.5.6/2) that (2.2.2/17) also is valid. In other words, after the two theorems of this subsection have been established, all assertions of Remark 2.2.2/3, i.e. (2.2.2/ 17)-(2.2.2/19)) and (2.3.5/1)-(2.3.5/5) will have been proved. One can prove the main result of this subsection, i.e. hp,(R,) = Fp,2(Rn) if 0
directly or via a corresponding result for the Hardy spaces H.,(R,z), cf. Remark 2.2.2/2. The spaces H7,(Rn) are more fashionable, but they do not fit in the framework of the non-homogeneous isotropic spaces, so we prefer the direct approach (later on in 5.2.4. we return to Hp(Rn)). We use the following Fourier multiplier theorem for hp,(R,) with 0
sup (1+Ixl)111 IDam(x)1 xERn
for every multi-index a. 1/ 0 < p < 00, then there exists a constant c such that (2)
11F-1mFf 1 hp(Rn)II =cIlf 1 hp(Rn)I1
holds for all f Ehp(R,), cf. also Bui Huy Qui [1]. In other words, the space hp(R,) has, for every p with 0
lations and proofs) pointwise products by scalar products, absolute values by H-norms, etc. A typical example is Proposition 2.5.6, where we formulated a Fourier multiplier assertion for Lp(R,, l2). Now we extend this assertion to hp(R,, 12), where 0
1
2
Ilfk I hp(R,, l2)II"=
sup
0
(G k=0
I
(F-1itFfk) (.)12)
Lp(R,)
I
(3)
In the sequel we omit the index 71 in (3). Then the 12-valued counterpart of (1), (2) reads as follows. Proposition. Let {mk,f(x)}k,i=o be a sequence of infinitely differentiable complex-
valued functions in R,, such that 1
sup (1+Ixi)'' (EIDamk,?(x)I2)2
xERn
k,9=0
(4)
92
2. Function Spaces on R.
for every ululti--index a. If 0--p--, then there exists a constant c such that
F-1[,
mk,iFfiJ hp(Rn, 1,.7)
(5)
`clJfk 1 hp(Rn, 12)11
Remark 1. This is the somewhat weaker counterpart of Proposition 2.5.6 for the spaces LP(Rn, 12) with 1
was formulated in [S, p. 165] (where we wrote Hp(R,Z, 12) instead of HP(R., 12)). It is the due to C. Fefferman, E. M. 12-version of a Fourier multiplier theorem for the spaces Stein [2, pp. 188-190]. Cf. also A. P. Calderon, A.'Torchinsky [1, II, p. 167], where a more (and generalizations of Hp(R,)) has been proved, general Fourier multiplier theorem for and H. Triebel [13] (that paper contains the 12-version of the Calderon-Torchinsky Fourier multiplier theorem).
Theorem 1. If 0
(6)
(equivalent quasi-norms).
Proof. Step 1. The functions f (x) E S(R,,) with compact support are dense in FP,2(Rn) and dense in hp(R,,), cf. Theorem 2.3.3 (ii) (including (2.3.3/2)) and D. Goldberg [1] (and Bui Huy Qui [1]). By the above proposition, it follows in exactly the same way as in Step 2 of the proof of Theorem 2.5.6 that IIf
hp(Rn)II
-JJF-1rkFf
(7)
I ]tp(R., 12)II
with {rpk(x)}7-oEb(R8) (equivalent quasi-norms).
Step 2. We recall that rl(O)=1. Then it follows from (3) with fk=F-1ggkFf and (7) that 11f
hp(Rn)1=e11F-1gkF/ I Lp(Rn, 12)11=ell/ I Fp,2(Rn)II
(8)
with c>-0. Step 3. We prove the converse assertion of (8). By (3) and (7) we have 1
2
If hp(Rn)II- c
sup k=0 0-t-1
I
(F-1rl(t .) mk(.) Ff) (.)12
LP(]?.)
(9)
Recall that 11(x) (as the counterpart of the function rp from (2.2.2/12)) has compact support. Hence 11(tx) 99k(x) * 0 implies I xl - 2k, tl xl - c, and consequently t-_c2-k if k=1, 2, ... Because tt 1 we obtain for all k (including k=0) sup I (F-1,7(t ) mk(-) Ff)(x)I
0-t-1 sup f (F-lrl(t .))(u) (F-1rkF/)(x-u) duI tsc2-k Rn sup f (F-11])(v) (F-1TkFf)(x-tv) dvj I
I
tsc2-k Rn I(F-1tpkFf)(x-tv)I c sup
(1+IvJ°)-1
vERyi
tac2-k
where a is an arbitrary positive number. We used (F-1,1(t .)) (u)=t-1(F-1v1)
(1-1u)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
93
and the transformation of coordinates v=t-lv. If (Tk/)(x) is the maximal function from (2.3.6/2), then su p I (F-1 ri (t ')
91 k (')
I (F-1TkFk) (xa tv)
F/)(x) = c su p
I+2 lt2
i
tsc2-k C' sup VERn
(10)
I(F-19kFf) (x -v)I _c'(9kf)(x)
1+12kvla
We substitute (10) in (9) and obtain by Theorem 2.3.6(ii) that III
I hP(Rn)II -cllT / I LP(Rn, l2)II Ec'Iif I
(11)
Fpo,2(Rn)11
Hence, by (8) and (11), the quasi-norms III I h,(R,,)II and III F,,2(R..)II are equivalent I
on the functions /ES(Rn) with compact support. (6) follows by completion, cf. Step 1.
Remark 2. Formula (7) is a Littlewood-Paley theorem for hp(Rn). The counterpart of (6) for the Hardy spaces HP(R,j is (12) 0
A. Torchinsky [1, 11] has been given in H. Triebel [13]. The above proof is a modification of a corresponding proof in [S, pp. 167-169]. However we wish to emphasize that the first proof of (6) is due to Bui Huy Qui [1], cf. also Y. Meyer [1].
Theorem 2. The following equality holds: bmo(R.)
(13)
(equivalent norms).
Proof. (Outline). The spaces F° have been defined in 2.3.4. By (2.3.4/6) and (6) we have (14) (h1(Ra))'=(Ff,2(R..))'=F°,2(R..) D. Goldberg [1, p. 36] proved (hi(R))'=bmo(R.) . (15) Now (13) is a consequence of (14) and (15).
Remark 3. The equality (15) is the non-homogeneous counterpart of the famous assertion (H1(Rn))' = BMO(Ra) .
(16)
which is due to C. Fefferman [1], cf. also C. Fefferman, E. M. Stein [2]. The space has been described in Remark 2.2.2/2. The homogeneous counterpart of (13) (cf. (12) and 5.2.4.) reads as follows: (17)
Remark 4. Finally we mention the following assertions, which have been proved in [S, p. 125/ 126] and in D. Goldberg [1, pp. 33, 36]. Let V(x) be an infinitely differentiable function on R,,, such that V(x) =V(-x) , V(x)=O if jxi S1 and V(y) =1 if jyjz2. Let rj=F-lyXF, x
9=1,...,n,
94
2. Function Spaces on B.
be the non-homogeneous Riesz transforms. Then h1(R5) _{l I /ES'(Rn), IIl h1(Rn)II*=III Ls(Rn)II + II ,/ I Li(R5)II j=1
(18)
and
bmo(R5)={919ES'(Rn), 3{9o,gs,...,gn}cL-(R5)such that g=go+; 1
-1
rjgi(19) 111111
where ]If I h1(Rn)II* and n IIg
I bmo(R5)II*=inf I llgk I L-(R5)IJ k=0
(the infimum is taken over all admissible representations of g in the sense of (19)) are equivalent norms in h1(R5) and bmo(R5), respectively.
2.5.9.
Characterizations by Maximal Functions of Differences
The rest of Section 2.5. (including this subsection) is the basis for subsequent considerations. First we introduce some notations. If I (x) is an arbitrary function on R. and h E Rn, then
(A' )(x) =f(x+h) -/(x), (A'')(x) = A'(dn '/)(x) , (1) where 1=2, 3.... These are the well-known differences of functions which play an important role in the theory of function spaces, cf. the spaces in 2.2.2. and 2.5.7. Let I ynI be the volume (surface measure) of the unit sphere yn = {x I x E Rn, IxI = 1} and let I F5I be the volume of Fn= {x I x E Rn, 1= IxI 2}. If M is a natural number and r - O, then (sT'g)(y) =
f (dryg)(2J) dy
I ynI
(2)
yn
is the spherical mean value of the differences of g with respect to the sphere of radius r centered at the origin. Here, dy denotes the surface element of yn, and y E Rn. Similarly,
f ('mg)(y) =1 F.J J (d ng)(y) dh
(3)
rn
is a truncated volume mean value of the differences of g. Furthermore, we introduce the maximal functions (SMg)(x)= sup (1+Ir-1yI5)-1 I (8Mg) (x-y)l
(4)
(VMg)(x)= sup (1+Ir
(5)
YER5
'yla)_1
YERn
and
I (Cfg) (x-y)I ,
a -1
(Dn g)(x)= sup
(1+- -
I (Am g) (x-y)I ,
(6)
VERn
where x E Rn, r
0 and h E R. with h * 0. The other symbols have the above meaning,
the positive number a in (4)-(6) will be determined later on. Finally, let
G1,=n+3+3n and G1,,q=n+3+
p where 0 -< p-- and 0-< q
-.
3n min (p, q)
(7)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
95
Theorem. (i) Let 0-2Gp+s
and if a-n p
in (4)-(6), then the following five quasi-norms are equivalent quasi-
norms in B,,q(Rn), +ll28kS,Mkf
I lq(Lp(Rn))II ,
II
Lp(Rn)II
If
Lp(Rn)II +1128k Sup S,-kf I lq(Lp(Rn))II I
Lp(Rn)II +II28kVMkf I lq(Lp(Rn))II
Lp(Rn)II +1128k Sup VM_kf I lq(Lp(Rn))II , T2
III
+II28k sup DM khf
Lp(R, )II
II
hErn
n
(11)
(12)
I lq(Lp(Rn))II
oo and s -Gp,q. If M is an integer with M 2Gp,q + s and
(ii) Let 0 < p < oo, 0 < q
if a::-
(10)
,
in (4)-(6), then the following five quasi-norms are equivalent
min (p, q) quasi-norms in F,,q(Rn),
Of I L9(Rn)II +II28kSMkf I Lp(Rn, lq)II +II28k
III I Lp(Rn)II If I Lp(Rn)II III
II
I
(13)
Sup SM-kf I LL(Rn, lq)II
,
1Sr-2
+112skVMkf
Lp(Rn)II
+II28k
Lp(Rn)II
+II28k
I Lp(Rn, lq)II
,
Sup 1'M-kf I Lp(Rn, lq)II
15x52
sup DMkhf I Lp(Rn, lq)II
n
(14)
(15) (16)
(17)
Proof. We prove in Step 1=4 that (13) and (14) are equivalent quasinorms in Fy,q(Rn). In Step 5 we prove that (17) is an equivalent quasinorm in FP',,(R.). The proof of the other assertions of the theorem is essentially the same. Step 1. Let f E FP,q(Rn) and supp Ff c {y I IyJ =1 }. Let (
1
q'(x)=lxlmlvml J (e
iyx -1) Mdy
(18)
Vn
and cpk(x) = q7(2 -kx) if k = 0, 1, 2, .
.
. Here yx is the scalar product of y E yn and x E R".
Furthermore, m is a positive number and M is a natural number. {q'k(x)}k_0 satisfies (2.3.6/1) if a=0 and
m=L+a, M=3L+o.
(19)
We use the maximal function from (2.3.6/2). Recall that F-1 ((elyx -1) 9) = d1Fg Iteration of this formula and (4) yield (Tkf)(x)=2km(S2 . . By later considerations and Remark 2.3.6/4 it will be clear that ((pkf)(x) makes sense as a function on R. If we replace iyx in (18) by iryx, where r is a positive number, then 2-k on the right-hand side of (20) must be replaced by r2-71. Now Theorem 2.3.6 and Remark 2.3.6/4 prove that
k = 0, 1, 2, .
II2km sup S 15x52
-mFf) I Lp(Rn, lq)II=cIIf I F$,q(Rn)II
(21)
96
2. Function Spaces on R,,,
provided that L=[Gp,q] (the largest integer which is less than or equal to G,.,). By the lifting property from Theorem 2.3.8 and our assumption about the support
of F/ it follows that
F'Q(Rn)II is equivalent to I/ I FP,q(Rn)II (this
is essentially an application of Theorem 2.3.7). If g = F-1
and s=in=
= [Gp q] + a, cf. (19), then we have 11231
sup SM k9 I Lp(Rn, iq)II `CJI9 I 1
(22)
where c is independent of gEFP 1(Rn) with supp Fgc {y j yJ =1}. By (19) it follows
that M=3[Gp,q]+a=2[Gp,q]+8.
Step 2. Let /EF,q(R,) and supp Ff c {y I yJ =1}. Let {?Pk(x)}z_oEO(Rn)> where we assume that Vk(x) = o(d2-kx) if k =1, 2, 3.... Furthermore we suppose that supp y,c {y I d1= Iyj =d2}, where d1 and d2 are positive numbers, and d>-0 is an appropriate number (the function Vo is uninteresting by our assumption on supp F/). Let b(x) be a continuous function on Rn such that b(x) +0 if x E supp V. If bk(x) =b(d2-kx) (with the same d as above), then
(F-'wkF/)(x)I =1(F-1 bk FF-1bkFf)(x)
=f
(23)
(F-1bkFf)(x-y) dy
(F-1 bk) (y) k
n
x- y)I (F -1b 1 kF
c, sup
/)kyl(a
f (F_I b (d-12ky) 2(1+2ky)
where a is a positive number. As we shall see, (F-1bkF/)(x) makes sense as a function on Rn if we choose b(x) = 1
f (e'x'-1)Mdy.
(24)
7Y.1 Yn
If the above positive numbers d1 and d2 are sufficiently small, then (e'xV-1)M= =(ixy)M (1+o(1)) if xEsupp v. If M is an even natural number, then b(x)+0 if xEsupp V. If M is an odd natural number, then the integral of (xy)M over yn vanishes. However, the integral over the next term in (ixy)M(1+o(1)), which is of type (xy)M+1 does not vanish. Hence, b(x) satisfies the above hypotheses. Furthermore, (Fi -1bFf)(x) =T-' IY.I
f (4 /)(x) dy
(25)
Yn
makes sense if /(x) belongs to L5(Rn) with 1:e co. If 1=p0, then FP,q(R,,) c Lp(R,,). If 0
cL1(Rn) if s >n (p -1 Under the above assumptions for 8 and p, this is satisfied. Similarly for (F-1bkF/)(x). This also justifies (23) (the right-hand side of (23) is finite. This follows from Fsp,1(Rn) c C(R,,), which holds by the above restrictions for s, cf. 2.7.1.). The last integral in (23) is independent of k. Thus (23) and the coun-
terpart of (25) with bk instead of b yields (F-lykF/)(x)I `c(Sd2-kf)(x) ,
(26)
where c is independent of k. By the above considerations, the numbers d1 and d2 are
small. Consequently, d is also small. We may assume that d=2-1, where 1 is an
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
97
appropriate natural number. Because the term with Y'o is not of interest, it follows
that
=cII28ks2 k/
I .F ,q(Rn)11
IIf
Lp(Rn, lq)II
(27)
Now (22) and (27) prove that (13) and (14) without the term II/ I LL(Rn)II are equivalent quasi-norms on f EF'p q(Rn) with supp Ff c {y I Iyi =1;} (under the hypotheses for p, q, s and M).
Step 3. Let f EF,,q(Rn) be an arbitrary element, where 0
suppVoc{yIIyj`=2} and
o(x)=1
if
IxI:1,
then Step 1 and Step 2 yield IIF-1 (1-lpo) F/ I F,,q(Rn)II -112 kS2
kF-1
(1'-V.) F/ I Lp(Rn, lq)II
(28)
Consequently, IIf
I FP,q(Rn)II scflF-1V0Ff Lp(Rn)II
(29)
+cII28kSM kF_1,poF/ I Lp(Rn, lq)II +cII2,kS2 kf I Lp(Rn, lq)II
First we estimate the second term on the right-hand side. By Proposition 2.3.2/2 (and its proof) we have IIZBxSMkF-1voF/ I Lp(Rn, qIIp`=c
2(8e)kp118
k=0
kF-1VoF/ I Lp(R,)IIT(30)
with s>0. We recall that a> , so (1.4.1/2) yields p
I
Lp(Rn)IIp-.II
(' -y)I Lp(Rn)II p YERn
cI
$ kF-1voF/
(31)
I Lp(Rn)IIp
Simple calculations give I (_5
kF-1fVoF/)(x)I `=c
sup
IaI=M Iz-yI52-kM
ID1(F-1VoF/)(y)I
2-km
(32)
So if we put this estimate into (31) and then apply (1.4.1/2) and (1.4.1/3) to D°F-1y0Ff, we obtain IISMkF-1'VoFI I Lp(Rn)IIp`c
I
2-kM1)lD"IF-1,VOF/)
IQI=M
`=c,2-ka1PIIF-1iV0F1
I Lp(Rn)IIP
I Lp(Rn)IIp .
Substituting this estimate into (30) and noting that s+e<M, we obtain II28kS2 kF-1+soF/ I Lp(Rn, 1q)IIp`c1IF-1woF/ I Lp(Rn)Ilp .
(33)
By (29) we have II/
I Fp,q(Rn)II
`cIIF-1 OoF/
Lp(Rn)II
+II28kSM k/
I Lp(Rn, lq)II
(34)
In order to estimate the first term on the right-hand side of (34) we remark that IIF-1V'oFf I Lp(Rn)II
=IIF-1yoFF-too(2-') Ff I Lp(Rn)II
with 1=2, 3.... To apply (1.5.2/13) with +Vo as multiplier we calculate 1(x-n) II+Vo(21.)
7
I H'(-_c2
Triebel, Function engl.
2
2. Function Spaces on R.
98
where
1 __1
ap = n
x
(min (p, 1)
2
Hence,
IIF-1+V0Ff i Lp(Rn)II -_
where a>Qp=n (
1
`min (p, 1)
IF-1'tpo(2-1
c21aIIF-1yo(2-1.) Fl I Lp(Rn)II
(35)
-1). On the other hand
.)1i f I Lp(Rn)ll
(36)
cIlf I Lp(Rn)II +cIIF 1 (1-7Vo(2
.)) F/ I Lp(Rn)II
`=CIII I Lp(R.)II +c'2_81II l I FP,q(Rn)II
We put (36) in (35). Because sya we may choose 1 in such a way that IIF-17VoFI I LL(Rn)II`=Cell/ I Lp(Rn)II +EIII I FD,q(Rn)II,
(37)
where E is a given positive number. If we choose E sufficiently small then (34) and (37) yield III
I
Fsp,q(Rn)II -CIII I Lp(Rn)II +cII28kS2k/ I Lp(Rn, lq)II
(38)
Step 4. Again let f EF,,q(Rn) be an arbitrary element, where 0-
sup S _kF-1TVoF/ LL(RR, 1q)IIp-_cIIF-JV0FI I Lp(Rn)IIP .
I5T 2
(39)
In order to prove this assertion we replace sup and ,t k in the middle term of (31) yERn
by sup sup and 2-k, respectively. Similarly, on the left-hand side of (31). 15zu_2YERn
Then we apply (32) with SZ;'_k instead of SMk. The result is independent of 2 and can be estimated'as above (maximal inequality for D°(F-1y0Ff)). Now it follows that III
I L,(Rn)II
+II281 sup S 2-k/ I LL(Rn, lq)II
sup SM_kF 1Y'oFl I L7,(Rn, lq)II =III I Lp(Rn)II +CII28k 15zs2
+c1I28k sup S'-kF-1 (1-1"o) F/ I L,(Rn, lq)II 15s-_2
By (39) and (22) the right-hand side of the last inequality can be estimated from above by III
I Lp(Rn)II
+cIIF-1 oeFl Lp(Rn)II
+cIIF-1 (1-'Vo) Ff I Fp,q(Rn)II
This in turn can be estimated from above by c'II / FP,q(Rn)II, cf. Remark 2.5.3/1 as far as III I Lp(Rn)II is concerned. Hence, I
III
I Lp(Rn)II +II28k sup S'2_k/ I Lp(Rn, lq)II `=clll I Fv.q(Rn)II
(40)
1szs2 Now (40) and (38) prove that (13) and (14) are equivalent quasi-norms on F8p q(Rn)
(under the above assumptions for p, q, s and M).
Step 5. Similarly one proves that (15) and (16) are equivalent quasi-norms on F'p,q(Rn) and that (8)-(11) are equivalent quasi-norms on BP,q(Rn) (under the above
restrictions for p, q, s and M). We prove that (17) is an equivalent quasi-norm on Fp,q(Rn). Similarly it follows that (12) is an equivalent quasi-norm on BP QLRC). Let f E F8p q(Rn) with supp Ff c {yI yI
1}. We replace ip(x) in (18) by I xI -m (e1yx -1)M,
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
99
where 7, E r.. Then the calculations of Step 1 produce the following counterpart of (22) : II2sk sup D.-'I khf j Lp(RC, lq)II - cII/ I FP,5(Rn)II hErn
(41)
On the other hand, the left-hand side of (41) can be estimated from below by Lp(Rn, lq)II, and this is equivalent to IIf Fp,q(R,b)II (we recall that
II28kVNkf
I
I
supp Ff c {y j IyJ =1 }). Hence, the left-hand side of (41) is equivalent to IIf I F"q(Rn)II if supp Ff c {y I I yI 1 }. The rest is the same as in Step 3 and Step 4 and the proof is complete.
Corollary 1. (i) Let 0., p s *o, 0-q 5 - and s zGp. If M is an integer with M >s and if a >- in (4)- (6), then (8) - (12) are equivalent quasi-norms in Bp q(Rn).
P n (ii) Let O-Gp,q. If M is an integer with M>s and if a> min (p, q) in (4)- (6), then (13)-(17) are equivalent quasi-norms in FP q(Rn).
Proof. We have to prove that the unnatural restriction M>2Gp,q+s in part (ii) of the theorem can be replaced by the natural restriction M>s. Similarly for part (i) of the theorem. We prove the above claim for the quasi-norm (13). In an analogous way, one proves correspond-
ing assertions for the quasi-norms (8)-(12) and (14)-(17). We needed M>2Gpq+s only in Step 1 of the proof of the theorem. This shows that it is sufficient to deal with the following
inequality: if M>s, then there exists a constant c such that 1I21k8M kl I Lp(Rn, lq)II =cII2skS2-k 1f JLp(Rn, lq)II +cllf I FP,q(Rn)II
(42)
for all f EFp q(Rn) (under the above hypotheses for s, p, and q). If P(z) is an appropriate polynomial then the following identity holds for complex numbers z,
(z-1)M-2M1 (z2-1)M+(z-1) M+1P(z)
(43)
In particular,
(ein _1)M=2M (e2sng-1)M+(e;ni-1) v+1p(e;n)
(44)
E R. and h E Rn. If we apply (44) to F1 and if we take the inverse Fourier transform of the result, then we obtain where
(L1
/) (x)=2
(x)+dv+1
(d -jhl)
(-'al/ (x+lh)) ,
(45)
where 2' is a finite sum (the counterpart of P(z)). Using (2) and (4) we then have
(SMkf)(x)S,yf
(46)
for all xERn and all k=O, 1, 2, ... If 0-g51, then 2"
2skq(SMkf)q
(x)
S2(3_ M)q
2' 2skq(SMkf)q (x) +c
k=0
k=1
k=1
2sk(SM k i f)q (x)
and because M>s 1
1
qsc k=0
2skq(SMkf)q (x))
with
2skq(SMk if)q (x)) k=0 (2
R(x) = sup (1 + Ix-y!a)-'I/(y)l YERn 7*
+CR(x)
(47)
2. Function Spaces on R.
100
Similarly for 1
2 F-199kFf. Then k=0
R(x)Sc i 2ka(9,k f)(x) k=0
Because s -a, it follows that II R(x) I Lp(Rn)II scIII I Fp,q(Rn)lI
This estimate and (47) establish (42). The proof is complete.
Remark 1. The relation between (43), (44) on the one hand and (45) on the other hand is very useful. It goes back to K. K. Golovkin [1, 3] who used it (and many generalizations) extensively.
Remark 2. The scheme of the proof of the theorem and also of the above corollary can be extended immediately to other mean values of differences. Of interest is the following possibility. Let, e.g.,
K ={x I xi+...+xn_15xn, be a truncated cone. Then one can introduce truncated cone mean values of differences M9)(y) =
(
ff(dih9)(y) dh I KnI
%n
and the corresponding maximal functions
(K9)(x) = sup (1 + Ir-lyla)-1 I (CM9) (x-y)I yERn
The numbers r, M and a have the same meaning as above, cf. e.g. (2) and (4). The above theorem and its corollary remain valid (as do the corresponding proofs) if one replaces S2 -k and S,_k by KM k and KM-k, respectively. Furthermore, one can replace 1'n in (12) and (17) by K. This possibility may be of interest in connection with "inner" characterizations of the spaces Bp q and FP q on domains.
Remark 3. On the basis of Theorem 2.3.8 one can replace some differences dM in the above theorem and corollary by derivatives. We do not go into detail. In connection with other equivalent quasi-norms we describe this possibility more explicitely in the following subsection. There we shall also give some references. n
Corollary 2. (i) Let O 8B(p,q) and if M is an integer with M -s, then Lp(R.)II+II2sk
III
I
sup DM kht I lq(Lp(Rn))II
(48)
]hIs2
is an equivalent quasi-norm in By q(R.). n
(ii) Let 0 -zp < -,i 0 min (p, q) in (6). Then there exists a positive number sF(p, q) with the following property. If s-sF(p, q) and if M is an integer with M>-s, then III
I Lp(Rn)II+II2sk sup DMkh/ I Lp(Ra, 1011 Ih152
is an equivalent quasi-norm in Fp q(R,).
(49.)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
101
Proof. We prove (ii) (the proof of (i) being the same). By the above theorem and Corollary 1, it is sufficient to prove that there exists a constant c such that II2sk sup DM khf I Lp(B, lq)Il5cll2sk sup DM khf I Lp(R,,, lq)II Ihis2 hErn
for all f
(50)
Let 8F(p, q)?Gp,q. Then
(2sx sup D21 khf)(x)52sk _ ( D khf)(x) sup 1=0 2-l-Ihtn2-1+1 IhI52
s
2-st2s(k+1)(
1=0
(51)
sup D21 k-thf) (x) hErn
If C is the constant in the generalized triangle inequality for the Lp(B,,, 1,)-quasi-norm, it follows that II28k sup D21 khf I Lp(R., l4)II SC IhI;S2
(2-SC)' II21k sup DM khf I Lp(R,,,
hErn
1=0
lq)II
If 2-'C<1, we obtain (50). The proof is complete.
2.5.10. Characterizations of the Spaces F,,q(Rn) by Differences
The theorem of the last subsection is very important for later considerations. On the other hand there also arise many questions. One may ask whether one can replace the maximal functions in (2.5.9/13), (2.5.9/15) and (2.5.9/17) by 8Mf, Crf, and dh f, respectively (cf. (2.5.9/2) and (2.5.9/3)). Furthermore, one would try to q in Theorem 2.5.9(ii) by a more replace the somewhat artificial restriction natural one (the corresponding problem for the number M has been solved in Corollary 2.5.9/1 in a satisfactory way). This subsection deals with equivalent quasi-
norms for F'where only the differences dM (and not their maximal functions) are involved. Similar problems for F'p q(Rn), with mean values of di in the sense of (2.5.9/2) and (2.5.9/3), are treated in the next subsection. Corresponding considerations for the spaces B'p,4(Rn) are given in 2.5.12. The differences dh f have the
same meaning as in (2.5.9/1). n min (p, q)
Theorem. Let 0
I
If M is an integer such that
F,,q(Rn)II`M') =IIf I Lp(Rn)II
( ( Ihl-8 lSup
i q l
I LP (R.)
(1)
l(de f) (-)I
0175
RJn
4
ERn
and (2)
IIf I Fp,q(Rn)II(M')=IIf I Lp(Rn)II 4
+ (fii -8Ql (d" f) (.)Iq
I
)
I
Lp(Rn)
are equivalent quasi-norms in FP q(Rn) (modification if q = oo).
Proof. Step 1. First we prove that there exists a constant c such that Ill I F,,q(Rn)IJ at)=CIIf I Fv,4(Rn)II
(3)
2. Function Spaces on Rn
102
holds for all / E F',,q(Rn). Let f E FP,q(Rn). By Theorem 2.5.3 (and Remark 2.5.3/1) the term / I Lg,(Rn)II in (1) can be estimated from above by If I F1,,q(Rn)II. Furthermore, under the above restrictions for s, any / E Fp q(Rn) is bounded and continuous on Rn, of. 2.7.1. (this remark is useful, but not absolutely necessary for the calculations below). We have I dh l g
eERl
h! -8q oup I(,jf)(.)Ig
,
Rn
lhln
Lp(Rn) (4) 1 f)(-)Ig)q
ne
21aq
sup 0
LP(Rn)
I(L
Let {g1k(x)}k=0EO(Rn), cf. 2.3.1. Let qk(x)=0 if k= -1, -2.... Then, if 0
k=
sup
I(4ff) (x)I5
0
(5)
2k8q
n+=-°°k=-°
We used the fact that (Zb1)q-Zbq if Split
Then
m=
into
m=0
sup 0
and
1(4h'F-19,k+mFf)(x)Ig
0
--2_k
. First let m <0 and Ihj
I (4t'F-1q,k+mFf)(x)I --2-kM
I(D'F-1q,k+.,Ff)(y)I
2]
sup
:
(6)
Ix-yI5c2-k lal=M
where c is an appropriate positive constant. Let (gkl)(x) be the maximal function from (2.3.6/2). By (1.3.1/2), a homogeneity consideration similar to the one in Remark 1.3.2/1, and a completion argument, it follows that
«I=M,
ID°(F-1q,k+mFf)(y)1=c2(k+m)M(q,k+mf)(y),
(7)
where c is independent of k+m and yE R,,. Putting this estimate into (6), we have sup
2k8q
m=--k=
I
(dn'F-19,k+mFf)(x)I g
0
-Cm=-° G k=G
(8) 2kag2-kMg2(k+m)Mq(ggk+mf)g (x)
C,
9=0
24Q(qq91)g (x)
In the last estimate we used the fact that M -s and we introduced j=k+gn. Let m-- 0 and IhI 2-k. Then (4h F-1q,k+mFf)(x)I -- c2l(q,k+mf)(x)
where a has the same meaning as in (2.3.6/2). Let s7a} 2kaq
m=0k= C L: L: m-0 k=
sup 0
n
min (p, q)
. Then
I (dn F-1q,k+mFf)(x)I g (9)
-
2s(k+m)g(q,k+f)q (x) 2_m(s-a)q
j_0
2y"(99 l)g (x)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
103
The sum of the left-hand sides of (8) and (9) yields the righthand side of (5). Consequently, we have by (4) and (5) (and the estimates (8) and (9)) 1
1 jh;-8 sup Fn
1(,1,11/)
Ie!
dh (')Iq
Ln(Rn) `cll28Jq f I Lp(Rn, lq)II .
Ih!
(10)
eE Rn
If 1
from above by cllf ; Fp,q(Rn)II. This follows from Theorem 2.3.6(ii), as proves (3).
Step 2. We prove that there exists a constant c such that (11)
it I F , q(Rn)I! -cII/ I Fp,q(Ra)II `
holds for all f EF',,,q(R,,). For this purpose we recall Theorem 2.5.3(ii) and Remark 2.5.3/2 (as far as the case q=- is concerned). In other words, it is sufficient to find a sequence {ak}r_oE91P(Rn) such that /= line al, in S'(Ra) and
k-
i!2sk(/-ak) 1 Lp(Rn, lq)II =c[/ I
(12)
If f EE ,q(Rn) (with the above restrictions on the parameters), then / is in any case a regular distribution (either f ELv(R.n) if 1=p<- or f EL1(Rn) if p<1, cf. Remark 2.5.3/1). Now we use a classical construction from approximation theory (and in particular in connection with the classical Besov spaces A q(Rn)), which can be found in S. M. Nikol'skij [3, 5.2.1]: let yn = {x I xE Rn, IxI =1 } be the unit with supp Fake {y I Iyl sphere. One finds for any f EFp,q(Rn) a system 52k+1} and (-1)x_1 (cak(x) -/(x))
= f g(r) f (4,,"fk,,,f)(x) d;,rn-1 dr, 'n
(13)
where g(r) is a non-negative rapidly decreasing function on [0, =), which is independent of f(x) and k. Furthermore, M is an arbitrary natural number. Although the proof is comparatively simple, we shall not go into detail and refer instead
to S. M. Nikol'skij [3, 5.2.1]. In any case, ak--f in S'(Itn) is ensured under the above hypotheses. If 1. has the same meaning as in 2.5.9., then 0
lak(x)-1(x)1 tc
x=--Tnf
(4;
t)(x)! dy (14)
+Cr.=11 2-'"Tnf
_17krx,,/)(x)I dy
where a is a positive number which may be chosen arbitrarily large. If 0 --C q-:=- 1
and ass. then m k=0
2$kq Iak(x) -/(x)iq 5C G
k=0 r.=--
+Ck=O I x=1 tC
28kq( f 1 (,2Nk+x,,/)(x)I dy)q
r.
)akq-xaq( f
I(-4'k+i)(x)1 dy)q
Fn
28kq( f I (4°f k,,f)(x) dy)q d' = - -'
Pn
.
(15)
104
2. Function Spaces on R
If 1
f I(42 k,l)(x)I dY)qc f I(4'k.,/)(x)Igdy.
rn
Fit
We put (16) into (15), take the q-power and apply the L9-quasi-norm. The result
is (12), which establishes (11). If 0
(17)
C
k=
2ekq( f I(42 klf)(x) q dy)q sup I(42 k(x)Iq(1 rn Ern
By Holder's inequality, we have 2akq Iak(x)-/(x)Iq k=0
1-q
c
28kq f (421ky1)(x)Iq dY)q (k=- 28kg sup I(4Mkyf)(x)IqTyEr
i
Taking the -power, applying the Lz,-quasi-norm, and using Holder's inequaq lity again we obtain I28k (f-ak) I LP(Rn, lq)II -_ e(II/ I F,,q(Rn)II
M')q
(I f I
FP,q(Rn)IIM')1-q
(19)
,
(because I/ I LP(R,,)II on the left-hand side both terms on the right-hand side contain that term). Then it follows from Theorem 2.5.3(ii) and (3) that
cf. (1) and (4). We can add the term
IIf
c(IIl I FP,q(Rn)II
I FP,q(Rn)II
M1)q Iii
I Fs
P,q(Rn)II1-q
This proves (11). The theorem is now an easy consequence of (3) and (11). Remark 1. If one compares (1) and (2) with the classical norms (2.2.2/9) and (2.2.2/10) for the Besov spaces AP,q(R,j, the question arises whether one can replace some differences in (1) and (2) by derivatives. The basis for such a possibility is Theorem 2.3.8. We describe n
an example. Let s min (p, q) and n a
s=a+m with
(20)
I
G IIDal I LP()?n)II+ G
jal sm
IaIsm
( f IhI-°gl(4i Da/) Rn
( )Iq-)q I LP(Rn)
is an equivalent quasi-norm in Fsp q(R ). The smallest number M is either 1-l or
2+[ min (p, q)
(21)
n min (p, 4)
2.5. Equivalent Quasi-Norms and Representations
105
Remark 2. We mention a simple consequence of (2) (and also of (1)) which seems to be of some interest. If 1
H8(Rn.) =FP,2(Rn) cFP,m(Rn),
(22)
where H8p(Rn) are the Bessel-potential spaces. Hence, it follows from (2) (with q=oo) that )I ILP(Rn)II cII11 HP(Rn)II
II sup Ihh _8 I(Ahf) hERn
if 1
holds for all of /).
(23)
s-n
- and M<s (of course, c in (23) is independent
P
Remark3.As we mentioned in (22), HP(R,,)=FD,2(Rn) with 1
163]. A formula similar to 2O (with I 1< p--,
n q=2, s<-and
1
may be found in P. 1.
Lizorkin [2, p. 240]. Equivalent norms in Fp,q(R,,) with 1
to the above considerations (including the one in 2.5.11.) and to P. I. Lizorkin [2] have been studied by G. A. Kaljabin [2, 5]. We refer also to H. Triebel [12,14] (the above theorem is an im-
provement of H. Triebel [14, Theorem 1]). Finally we mention that inequalities of type (23) have been studied by C. P. Calderon, E. B. Fabes, N. M. Riviere [1] (cf. also C. J. Neugebauer [1], where corresponding inequalities for Besov spaces with fractional differences are considered).
2.5.11.
Characterizations of the Spaces FP,q(Rn) by Ball Means of Differences
Theorem 2.5.10 is useful and sheds light upon the structure of the spaces FP q(Rn) if s
n -min (p, q)
On the one hand, this restriction for s is too strong for
our later purposes while on the other, it cannot be essentially relaxed. Another ques-
tion of the same type is connected with Theorem 2.5.9: is it possible to replace V2-kf in (2.5.9/15) by the truncated ball means of differences T2 kf from (2.5.9/3) and what are the