LONDON MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY LECTURE NOTE SERIES Managing Editor: Professor J.W.S. Cassels, Department of Pure Mathematics and Mathematical Statistics, University of Cambridge, 16 Mill Lane, Cambridge CB2 1SB, England The titles below are available from booksellers, or, in case of difficulty, from Cambridge University Press. 34 36 39 46 50 59 66 69 74 76 77 79 83
86 87 88 89 90 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 103 104 105
106 107 108 109 110 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 121 122 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135
136 137 138 139
Representation theory of Lie groups, M.F. ATIYAH et al Homological group theory, C.T.C. WALL (ed) Affine sets and affine groups, D.G. NORTHCOTT p-adic analysis: a short course on recent work, N. KOBLITZ Commutator calculus and groups of homotopy classes, H.J. BAUES Applicable differential geometry, M. CRAMPIN & F.A.E. PIRANI Several complex variables and complex manifolds II, M.J. FIELD Representation theory, I.M. GELFAND et al Symmetric designs: an algebraic approach, E.S. LANDER Spectral theory of linear differential operators and comparison algebras, H.O. CORDES Isolated singular points on complete intersections, E.J.N. LOOIJENGA Probability, statistics and analysis, J.F.C. KINGMAN & G.E.H. REUTER (eds) Homogeneous structures on Riemannian manifolds, F. TRICERRI & L. VANHECKE Topological topics, I.M. JAMES (ed) Surveys in set theory, A.R.D. MATHIAS (ed) FPF ring theory, C. FAITH & S. PAGE An F-space sampler, N.J. KALTON, N.T. PECK & J.W. ROBERTS Polytopes and symmetry, S.A. ROBERTSON Representation of rings over skew fields, A.H. SCHOFIELD Aspects of topology, I.M. JAMES & E.H. KRONHEIMER (eds) Representations of general linear groups, G.D. JAMES Low-dimensional topology 1982, R.A. FENN (ed) Diophantine equations over function fields, R.C. MASON Varieties of constructive mathematics, D.S. BRIDGES & F. RICHMAN Localization in Noetherian rings, A.V. JATEGAONKAR Methods of differential geometry in algebraic topology, M. KAROUBI & C. LERUSTE Stopping time techniques for analysts and probabilists, L. EGGHE Groups and geometry, ROGER C. LYNDON Surveys in combinatorics 1985, I. ANDERSON (ed) Elliptic structures on 3-manifolds, C.B. THOMAS A local spectral theory for closed operators, I. ERDELYI & WANG SHENGWANG Syzygies, E.G. EVANS & P. GRIFFITH Compactification of Siegel moduli schemes, C-L. CHAI Some topics in graph theory, H.P. YAP Diophantine analysis, J. LOXTON & A. VAN DER POORTEN (eds) An introduction to surreal numbers, H. GONSHOR Lectures on the asymptotic theory of ideals, D. REES Lectures on Bochner-Riesz means, K.M. DAVIS & Y-C. CHANG An introduction to independence for analysts, H.G. DALES & W.H. WOODIN Representations of algebras, P.J. WEBB (ed) Homotopy theory, E. REES & J.D.S. JONES (eds) Skew linear groups, M. SHIRVANI & B. WEHRFRITZ Triangulated categories in the representation theory of finite-dimensional algebras, D. HAPPEL Proceedings of Groups - St Andrews 1985, E. ROBERTSON & C. CAMPBELL (eds) Non-classical continuum mechanics, R.J. KNOPS & A.A. LACEY (eds) Commutator theory for congruence modular varieties, R. FREESE & R. MCKENZIE Van der Corput's method of exponential sums, S.W. GRAHAM & G. KOLESNIK New directions in dynamical systems, T.J. BEDFORD & J.W. SWIFT (eds) Descriptive set theory and the structure of sets of uniqueness, A.S. KECHRIS & A. LOUVEAU The subgroup structure of the finite classical groups, P.B. KLEIDMAN & M.W.LIEBECK Model theory and modules, M. PREST Algebraic, extremal & metric combinatorics, M-M. DEZA, P. FRANKL & I.G. ROSENBERG (eds) Whitehead groups of finite groups, ROBERT OLIVER Linear algebraic monoids, MOHAN S. PUTCHA Number theory and dynamical systems, M. DODSON & J. VICKERS (eds) Operator algebras and applications, 1, D. EVANS & M. TAKESAKI (eds) Operator algebras and applications, 2, D. EVANS & M. TAKESAKI (eds) Analysis at Urbana, I, E. BERKSON, T. PECK, & J. UHL (eds) Analysis at Urbana, II, E. BERKSON, T. PECK, & J. UHL (eds) Advances in homotopy theory, S. SALAMON, B. STEER & W. SUTHERLAND (eds)
140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170
Geometric aspects of Banach spaces, E.M. PEINADOR & A. RODES (eds) Surveys in combinatorics 1989, J. SIEMONS (ed) The geometry of jet bundles, D.J. SAUNDERS The ergodic theory of discrete groups, PETER J. NICHOLLS Introduction to uniform spaces, I.M. JAMES Homological questions in local algebra, JAN R. STROOKER Cohen-Macaulay modules over Cohen-Macaulay rings, Y. YOSHINO Continuous and discrete modules, S.H. MOHAMED & B.J. MULLER Helices and vector bundles, A.N. RUDAKOV et al Solitons, nonlinear evolution equations and inverse scattering, M. ABLOWITZ & P. CLARKSON Geometry of low-dimensional manifolds 1, S. DONALDSON & C.B. THOMAS (eds) Geometry of low-dimensional manifolds 2, S. DONALDSON & C.B. THOMAS (eds) Oligomorphic permutation groups, P. CAMERON L-functions and arithmetic, J. COATES & M.J. TAYLOR (eds) Number theory and cryptography, J. LOXTON (ed) Classification theories of polarized varieties, TAKAO FUJITA Twistors in mathematics and physics, T.N. BAILEY & RJ. BASTON (eds) Analytic pro -p groups, J.D. DIXON, M.P.F. DU SAUTOY, A. MANN & D. SEGAL Geometry of Banach spaces, P.F.X. MULLER & W. SCHACHERMAYER (eds) Groups St Andrews 1989 volume 1, C.M. CAMPBELL & E.F. ROBERTSON (eds) Groups St Andrews 1989 volume 2, C.M. CAMPBELL & E.F. ROBERTSON (eds) Lectures on block theory, BURY-HARD KULSHAMMER Harmonic analysis and representation theory, A. FIGA-TALAMANCA & C. NEBBIA Topics in varieties of group representations, S.M. VOVSI Quasi-symmetric designs, M.S. SHRIKANDE & S.S. SANE Groups, combinatorics & geometry, M.W. LIEBECK & J. SAXL (eds) Surveys in combinatorics, 1991, A.D. KEEDWELL (ed) Stochastic analysis, M.T. BARLOW & N.H. BINGHAM (eds) Representations of algebras, H. TACHIKAWA & S. BRENNER (eds) Boolean function complexity, M.S. PATERSON (ed) Manifolds with singularities and the Adams-Novikov spectral sequence, B. BOTVINNIK
171
Squares, A.R. RAJWADE Algebraic varieties, GEORGE R. KEMPF Discrete groups and geometry, W.J. HARVEY & C. MACLACHLAN (eds) Lectures on mechanics, J.E. MARSDEN
172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183
184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191
192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199
200 201
202 203 204 207
Adams memorial symposium on algebraic topology 1, N. RAY & G. WALKER (eds) Adams memorial symposium on algebraic topology 2, N. RAY & G. WALKER (eds) Applications of categories in computer science, M. FOURMAN, P. JOHNSTONE, & A. PITTS (eds) Lower K- and L-theory, A. RANICKI Complex projective geometry, G. ELLINGSRUD et at Lectures on ergodic theory and Pesin theory on compact manifolds, M. POLLICOTT Geometric group theory I, G.A. NIBLO & M.A. ROLLER (eds) Geometric group theory H, G.A. NIBLO & M.A. ROLLER (eds) Shintani zeta functions, A. YUKIE Arithmetical functions, W. SCHWARZ & J. SPILKER Representations of solvable groups, O. MANZ & T.R. WOLF Complexity: knots, colourings and counting, D.J.A. WELSH Surveys in combinatorics, 1993, K. WALKER (ed) Local analysis for the odd order theorem, H. BENDER & G. GLAUBERMAN Locally presentable and accessible categories, J. ADAMEK & J. ROSICKY Polynomial invariants of finite groups, D.J. BENSON Finite geometry and combinatorics, F. DE CLERCK et at Symplectic geometry, D. SALAMON (ed) Computer algebra and differential equations, E. TOURNIER (ed) Independent random variables and rearrangement invariant spaces, M. BRAVERMAN Arithmetic of blowup algebras, WOLMER VASCONCELOS Microlocal analysis for differential operators, A. GRIGIS & J. SJOSTRAND Two-dimensional homotopy and combinatorial group theory, C. HOG-ANGELONI, W. METZLER & A.J. SIERADSKI (eds) The algebraic characterization of geometric 4-manifolds, J.A. HILLMAN Invariant potential theory in the unit ball of Cn, MANFRED STOLL The Grothendieck theory of dessins denfant, L. SCHNEPS (ed) Singularities, JEAN-PAUL BRASSELET (ed) The technique of pseudodifferential operators, H.O. CORDES Hochschild cohomology, A. SINCLAIR & R. SMITH Combinatorial and geometric group theory, A.J. DUNCAN, N.D. GILBERT, J. HOWIE (eds) Groups of Lie type and their geometries, W.M. KANTOR & L. DI MARTINO (eds)
London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series. 202
The Technique of Pseudodifferential Operators H.O. Cordes
Emeritus, University of California, Berkeley
AMBRIDGE
UNIVERSITY PRESS
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, Sao Paulo
Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK
Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521378642
© Cambridge University Press 1995
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1995
A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library ISBN 978-0-521-37864-2 paperback Transferred to digital printing 2008
To my 6 children, Stefan and Susan Sabine and Art, Eva and Sam
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 0. Introductory discussions
1
0.0. Some special notations, used in the book 0.1. The Fourier transform; elementary facts 0.2. Fourier analysis for temperate distributions on 0.3. The Paley-Wiener theorem; Fourier transform for
1
3
In
general uE D'
0.4. The Fourier-Laplace method; examples 0.5. Abstract solutions and hypo-ellipticity
9
14
20 30
0.6. Exponentiating a first order linear differential operator
31
0.7. Solving a nonlinear first order partial differential equation
36
0.8. Characteristics and bicharacteristics of a linear PDE
40
0.9. Lie groups and Lie algebras for classical analysts
45
Chapter 1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators 1.0. Introduction I.I. Definition of pdo's
52 52
52
1.2. Elementary properties of ipdo's
56
1.3. Hoermander symbols; Weyl pdo's; distribution kernels
60
1.4. 1.5. 1.6. 1.7.
The composition formulas of Beals The Leibniz' formulas with integral remainder Calculus of 1pdo's for symbols of Hoermander type Strictly classical symbols; some lemmata for application
Chapter 2. Elliptic operators and parametrices in Mn 2.0. Introduction
64 69 72
78 81 81
2.1. Elliptic and md-elliptic Vdo's 2.2. Formally hypo-elliptic pdo's
82
2.3. Local md-ellipticity and local md-hypo-ellipticity
87
2.4. Formally hypo-elliptic differential expressions 2.5. The wave front set and its invariance under yxlo's
91
84
93
Contents
viii 2.6. Systems of ,do's
Chapter 3. L2-Sobolev theory and applications 3.0. Introduction
3.1. L2-boundedness of zero-order do's 3.2. L2-boundedness for the case of 6>0 3.3. Weighted Sobolev spaces; K-parametrix and Green inverse 3.4. Existence of a Green inverse 3.5. Hs-compactness for ftpdo's of negative order
97
99 99 99 103
106 113
117
Chapter 4. Pseudodifferential operators on manifolds with conical ends 4.0. Introduction
118 118
4.1. Distributions and temperate distributions on manifolds
119
4.2. Distributions on S-manifolds; manifolds with conical ends 4.3. Coordinate invariance of pseudodifferential operators 4.4. Pseudodifferential operators on S-manifolds 4.5. Order classes and Green inverses on S-manifolds Chapter 5. Elliptic and parabolic problems 5.0. Introduction 5.1. Elliptic problems in free space; a summary 5.2. The elliptic boundary problem
123
129 134 139 144 144
147 149
5.3. Conversion to an &n-problem of Riemann-Hilbert type
154
5.4. Boundary hypo-ellipticity; asymptotic expansion mod av
157
5.5. A system of fide's for the Vj of problem 3.4
162
5.6. Lopatinskij-Shapiro conditions; normal solvability of (2.2).
169
5.7. Hypo-ellipticity, and the classical parabolic problem
174
5.8. Spectral and semi-group theory for ado's
179
5.9. Self-adjointness for boundary problems 5.10. C*-algebras of tpdo's; comparison algebras
186
Chapter 6. Hyperbolic first order systems 6.0. Introduction 6.1. First order symmetric hyperbolic systems of PDE
189
196 196 196
6.2. First order symmetric hyperbolic systems of fide's on
n .
6.3. The evolution operator and its properties
200
206
Contents
ix
6.4. N-th order strictly hyperbolic systems and 210
symmetrizers.
6.5. The particle flow of a single hyperbolic pde
215
6.6. The action of the particle flow on symbols 6.7. Propagation of maximal ideals and propagation of singularities
219
Chapter 7. Hyperbolic differential equations 7.0. Introduction 7.1. Algebra of hyperbolic polynomials 7.2. Hyperbolic polynomials and characteristic surfaces 7.3. The hyperbolic Cauchy problem for variable coefficients 7.4. The cone h for a strictly hyperbolic expression of type e°
226 226 227 230
235 238
7.5. Regions of dependence and influence; finite propagation speed 7.6. The local Cauchy problem; hyperbolic problems on manifolds Chapter 8. Pseudodifferential operators as smooth operators of L(H) 8.0. Introduction 8.1.
223
241
244 247 247
,do's as smooth operators of L(H0)
248
8.2. The 11DO-theorem
251
8.3. The other half of the gbbO-theorem
257
8.4. Smooth operators; the V -algebra property; 'Wdo-calculus
8.5. The operator classes 'S and 'IVL
261 ,
and their
symbols 8.6
8.7
265
The Frechet algebras y"x0, and the Weinstein-
Zelditch class
271
Polynomials in x and ax with coefficients in 'TX
275
Characterization of qtX by the Lie algebra Chapter 9. Particle flow and invariant algebra of a semistrictly hyperbolic system; coordinate invariance 8.8
279
of OpWxm.
282
9.0. Introduction
282
9.1. Flow invariance of V10
283
9.2. Invariance of Vsm under particle flows
286
9.3. Conjugation of Optpx with eiKt , KE Opy)ce
289
9.4. Coordinate and gauge invariance; extension to S-manifolds 9.5. Conjugation with eiKt for a matrix-valued K=k(x,D)
293
296
Contents
x
9.6. A technical discussion of commutator equations
301
9.7. Completion of the proof of theorem 5.4 Chapter 10. The invariant algebra of the Dirac equation 10.0. Introduction
305
10.1. A refinement of the concept of observable 10.2. The invariant algebra and the Foldy-Wouthuysen transform
314
10.3. The geometrical optics approach for the Dirac algebra P
310 310
319
324
10.4. Some identities for the Dirac matrices 10.5. The first correction z0 for standard observables 10.6. Proof of the Foldy-Wouthuysen theorem
329
10.7. Nonscalar symbols in diagonal coordinates of
350
10.8. The full symmetrized first correction symbol zS 10.9. Some final remarks
356
334 343
367
References
370
Index
380
P R E F A C E
It is generally well known that the Fourier-Laplace transform converts a linear constant coefficient PDE P(D)u=f on Rn to
an equation P()u ()=f"(), for the transforms u , f- of u and f, so that solving P(D)u=f just amounts to division by the polynomial The practical application was suspect, and ill understood, however, until theory of distributions provided a basis for a logically consistent theory. Thereafter it became the Fourier-Laplace method for solving initial-boundary problems for standard PDE. We recall these facts in some detail in sec's 1-4 of ch.0. The technique of pseudodifferential operator extends the Fourier-Laplace method to cover PDE with variable coefficients, and to apply to more general compact and noncompact domains or manifolds with boundary. Concepts remain simple, but, as a rule, integrals are divergent and infinite sums do not converge, forcing lengthy, often endlessly repetitive, discussions of 'finite parts' (a type of divergent oscillatory integral existing as distribution integral) and asymptotic sums (modulo order -oo). Of course, pseudodifferential operators (abbreviated ado's) are (generate) abstract linear operators between Hilbert or Banach spaces, and our results amount to 'well-posedness' (or normal solvability) of certain such abstract linear operators. Accordingly both, the Fourier-Laplace method and theory of ipdo's, must be seen
in the context of modern operator theory. To this author it always was most fascinating that the same type of results (as offered by elliptic theory of ipdo;'s) may be
obtained by studying certain examples of Banach algebras of linear operators. The symbol of a ipdo has its abstract meaning as Gelfand function of the coset modulo compact operators of the abstract operator in the algebra.
On the other hand, hyperbolic theory, generally dealing with a group exp(Kt) (or an evolution operator U(t)) also has its manifestation with respect to such operator algebras: conjugation with
Preface
xii
exp(Kt) amounts to an automorphism of the operator algebra, and of the quotient algebra. It generates a flow in the symbol space essentially the characteristic flow of singularities. In [Ci], [C2] we were going into details discussing this abstract approach. We believe to have demonstrated that ado's are not necessary to understand these fact. But the technique of pdo's, in spite of its endless formalisms (as a rule integrals are always 'distribution integrals', and infinite series are asymptotically convergent, not convergent), still provides a strongly simplifying principle, once the technique is mastered. Thus our present discussion of this technique may be justified. On the other hand, our hyperbolic discussions focus on invariance of ido-algebras under conjugation with evolution operators, and do not touch the type of oscillatory integral and further discussions needed to reveal the structure of such evolution operators as Fourier integral operators. In terms of Quantum mechanics we prefer the Heisenberg representation, not the Schroedinger representation. In particular this leads us into a discussion of the Dirac equation and its invariant algebra, in chapter X. We propose it as algebra of observables. The basis for this volume is (i) a set of notes of lectures given at Berkeley in 1974-80 (chapters I-IV) published as preprint at U. of Bonn, and (ii) a set of notes on a seminar given in 1984 also at Berkeley (chapters VI-IX). The first covers elliptic (and parabolic) theory, the second hyperbolic theory. One might say that we have tried an old fashiened PDE lecture in modern style. In our experience a newcomer will have to reinvent the theory before he can feel at home with it. Accordingly, we did not try to push generality to its limits. Rather, we tend to focus on the simplest nontrivial case, leaving generalizations to the reader. In that respect, perhaps we should mention the problems (partly of research level) in chapters I-IV, pointing to manifolds with conical tips or cylindrical ends, where the 'Fredholm-significant symbol' becomes operator-valued. The material has been with the author for a long time, and was subject of many discussions with students and collaborators. Especially we are indebted to R. McOwen, A.Erkip, H. Sohrab, E. Schrohe, in chronological order. We are grateful to Cambridge University Press for its patience, waiting for the manuscript. Berkeley, November 1993
Heinz 0. Cordes
Chapter 0. INTRODUCTORY DISCUSSIONS.
In the present introductory chapter we give comprehensive discussions of a variety of nonrelated topics. All of these bear on the concept of pseudo-differential operator, at least in the author's mind. Some are only there to make studying Ado's appear a natural thing, reflecting the author's inhibitions to think along these lines. In sec.! we discuss the elementary facts of the Fourier transform, in sec.'s 2 and 3 we develop Fourier-Laplace transforms of temperate and nontemperace distributions. In sec.4 we discuss the Fourier-Laplace method of solving initial-value problems and free space problems of constant coefficient partial differential equations. Sec.5 discusses another problem in PDE, showing how the solving of an abstract operator equation together with results on hypo-ellipticity and "boundary-hypo-ellipticity" can lead to existence proofs for classical solutions of initialfor boundary problems. Sec.6 is concerned with the operator eLt ,
a first order differential expression L Sec.'s 7 and 8 deal with the concept of characteristics of a linear differential expression .
and learning how to solve a first order PDE. Sec.9 gives a miniintroduction to Lie groups, focusing on the mutual relationship between Lie groups and Lie algebras. (Note the relation to i,do's
discussed in ch.8).
We should expect the reader to glance over ch.0 and use it to have certain prerequisites handy, or to get oriented in the serious reading of later chapters. 0. Some special notations. The following notations, abbreviations, and conventions will be used throughout this book. (a)
xn
(b)
(x) = (l+Ix12)!/2
(2n)-n/2
,
ox = xndx1dx2...dxn = xndx
(1+1
,
!
12)!,2
,
.
etc.
0. Introductory discussions
2
(c) Derivatives are written in various ways, at convenience: For u=u(x)=u(x1,...,xn) we write u(a)=aXU=axlax2...u = a a =aatlax",...a n/ax nu. Or, ulx =ax u, ulx to denote the n-vector j
J
with components ulx , V"u for the k-dimensional array with compoJ
nents
ulxi xi
z
'
For a function of (x,i;)=(xl
..
'.'fin)
"
it is often convenient to write u(a)=aaXU. (d) A multi-index is an n-tuple of integers a=(a1,...an) We write laI=lall+...+lanl al=all...an! ((3)=(R )...( ), a a xa= xl 1...xn n etc., IIn={all multi-indices} ,
,
,
.
(e) Some standard spaces: &n = n-dimensional Euclidean space Bn=directional compactification of Ien (one infinite point «x added
in every direction (of a unit vector x). (f) Spaces of continuous or differentiable complex-valued functions over a domain or differentiable manifold X (or sometimes only X=1en): C(X) = continuous functions on X ; CB(X)= bounded continuous functions on X; CO(X)= continuous functions on X vanishing at a ; CS(X) = continuous functions with directional limits; CO(X) = continuous functions with compact support; Ck(X)= functions with derivatives in C, to order k, (incl. k=oo). CB00(X)="all derivatives exist and are bounded". The Laurent-Schwartz notations D(X)=CO(X), E(X)=C°(X) are used. Also S= S(Jk)= "rapidly decreasing functions" (All derivatives decay stronger as any power of x). Also, distribution spaces D', E', SO. (g) LP-spaces: For a measure space X with measure dµ we write Lp(X)=Lp(X,dµ)={measurable functions u(x) with luIp integrable} for lsp
Y
.
.
L(X) (i) Classes of linear operators (X= Banach space) (K(%))= continuous (compact) operators; GL(X) (U(H)) = invertible (unitary) operators of L(X) (of L(H), H=Hilbert space); Un U(Mn). :
For operators X- Y, again, L(X,Y), etc. (j) The convolution product: For u,v E LI(len) we write w(x)
=(u*v)(x)=xnfdyu(x-y)v(y) (Note the factor xn
(2n)-n/2).
(k) Special notation: " X CC Y " means that X is contained in a compact subset of Y .
0.1. The Fourier transform
3
(1) For technical reason we may write limE-Oa(E)
= alE..O
(m) Abbreviations used: ODE (PDE) = ordinary (partial) differential equation (or "expression"). FOLPDE (or folpde)= first order linear partial differential equation (or "expression"); 'pdo=
pseudodifferential operator. (n) Integrals need not be existing (proper or improper) Riemann or Lebesgue integrals, unless explicitly stated, but may be distribution integrals By this term we mean that either (i) the integral may be interpreted as value of a distribution at a testing function-the integrand may be a distribution, or (ii) the limit of Riemann sums exists in the sense of weak convergence of a sequence of (temperate) distributions, or (iii) the limit defining an improper Riemann integral exists in the sense of weak convergence, as above, or (iv) the integral may be a 'finite part' (cf. 1,4). (o) Adjoints: For a linear operator A we use 'distribution adjoint' A and 'Hilbert space adjoint' A*, corresponding to trans-
pose AT and adjoint vely. For a symbols
AT=A*,
in case of a matrix A=((a.k)), respectia* (or a+) may denote the symbol of
as specified in each section. (p) supp u (sing supp u (or s.s.u)) denotes the (singular) support of the distribution u. the adjoint 'tpdo of a(x,D)
,
1. The Fourier transform; elementary facts. Let u E L1(&n) be a complex-valued integrable function. Then we define the Fourier transform u^= Fu of u by the integral (1.1)
with x =x. =
(1.2) Note that u^
(1.3)
x E &n ,
u^(x) = J
an existing Lebesgue integral. Clearly,
u^ (x) I s
IIu11L1
=
n9lxlu(x)l
is uniformly continuous over In : We get
u^ (x)-u^ (y) I s 2f¢t s NIX-111 llullL1 +
I
R1
where the right hand side is <E if N is chosen
for
<E/4,
0. Introductory discussions
4
) Moreover, we get u^E CO(&n), i.e.,
and then Ix-yi< a/(2NIIuiI L
limlxI.00u^(x)=0, a fact, known as the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma.
To prove the latter, we reduce it to the case of u E CO(&n): 00 The space CO is known to be dense in LI By (1.1) we get .
(1.4)
Iu^ (x)-v^ (x) I s IIu-vilL1 < e/2
Hence lim
IXI
OOv^ (x)=0 implies
I u^ I
x is chosen according to Iv^I < e/2
,
as v E CO ,
IIu-vuIL1<E/2.
I u^ -v^ I+ I v^ I< e whenever
s .
But for v E CO the Fourier integral extends over a ball ICI s N only, since v=0 outside. We may integrate by parts for (1.5)
=_f
IxI2u^(x) =-J0
=-(Av)^(x)
with the Laplace differential operator e _=1a 2
Clearly we
have tv E CO C LI as well, whence (1.1) applies to AV , for
(1.6)
Iv^ (x) I s
11 AV ll
L
1/1X12
0
as IxI
completing the proof. The above partial integration describes a general method to be applied frequently in the sequel. (1.6) may be derived under the weaker assumptions that vE C2, and that all derivatives v(a), Ials2
,
are in LI (cf. pbm.5). On the other hand, there are simple
examples of u(4 LI such that u^ does not decay as rapidly as (1.6) indicates. In particular, uE L' exists with u^(4 L'
(cf.pbm.4).
This matter becomes important if we think of inverting the linear operator F:LI - CO defined by (1.1), because formally an inverse seems to be given by almost the same integral. Indeed, define the (complex) conjugate Fourier transform F:LI -> CO by Fu = (Fu)
(1.7)
,
or, u"= Fu
,
u" (x) =
where
f
u E LI (len)
.
Then, in essence, it will be seen that F is the inverse of the operator F. More precisely we will have to restrict F to a (dense) subspace of LI, for this result. Or else, the definition of the operator F must be extended to certain non-integrable functions, for which existence of the Lebesgue integral (1.7) cannot be expected. Both things will be done, eventually.
0.1. The Fourier transform
5
It turns out that F induces a unitary operator of the Hilbert space L2(&n): We have Parseval's relation: (1.8)
JRn4IxIu^(x)12 = fRnoxlu(x)12
,
for all u E_= L'
(,n) ,2 (e)
Formula (1.8) is easier to prove as the Fourier inversion formula, asserting u^'=u`^=u for certain u: We may write
(1.9)
Q
_1
glxu^ (x)v^ (x) = N
N
e
ix 7. ( .-1. ) j -"j qIx.
-N
assuming that u,vE LI(&n) , with the 'cube' QN {lx.IsN,j=1,..,N} some integer N>0. Indeed, the interchange of integrals leading to (1.9) is legal, since the integrand is L'(QNxinxlen)
Note that
fNeistdt = 2sis sN
s340
,
= 2N
,
s=0, allowing
-N
evaluation of the inner integrals at right of (1.9). With f A A _ f Af 911 , and it = - IN , A = N n,, , (1.9) assumes the form
fQN 41xu^ (x)v^ (x) =
(1.10)
where cp(t) = (2/n) 1/2 sin t
,
j t340, continuously extended into t=0.
For vE C(Rn), as N-- , the function will converge independent of Thus one expects the inner integral at
to
.
right of (1.10) to converge to
j=
since
P sin t dt/t = n/2
(1.11)
0
Legalization of this argument will confirm Parseval's relation, since the right hand converges to the right hand side of
(1.8), as N-. With uE L' and vE Co (setting cen(t)=ikp(t.)) write (1.12)
f Rng1xuv
To show that the inner integral at left goes to 0 as N->oo
it is
more skilful to use the integration variable O=1;/N, dt=NndO. For n=1
,
fsin NO
f101sb + fjolab
= I0 + I. .
Here we get (with w(O) =
JI01 sOIIv'III N((w(O)cos(NO)le=&b + The latter gives 100 s
(11vIILW+ 11v' 11L00)
,
f1OjZbcos(NO)wl0(O)dO).
with a constant c, only
depending on the volume of supp v, i.e., it is fixed after fixing v . The estimates imply the inner integral to go to 0, uniformly
6
0. Introductory discussions
as xE lgn. For uE L'
the Lebesgue theorem then implies the left
hand side of (1.12) to tend to 0, as N-- , for each fixed vE CO For general n the proof is a bit less transparent, but remains the same: Split the inner integral into a sum of integrals over a small neighbourhood of 0 and its complement. In the first term use differentiability of v; in the second an integration by parts. We now have a 'polarized' Parseval relation, in the form
(1.13)
RngIxu^ V.
ngxuv
for u E L1 , v E
,
COO
For u E LIf1L2 pick a sequence ujECO with IIu-ujIILl - 0,
11u-uill L2 0,
as is possible. Then, since uj-ulE CO C L2 (1.13) with u=v=uj-vj implies Iluj^-u1^IIL2=IIuj-u11IL2 0, j,l - . In other words, uj and ,
uj^ both converge in L2 Clearly, uj u^. Indeed, initially we showed uniform convergence over &n, while the V -limit z=lim u .
satisfies (u^
f (u^ -z)cpdx=0 for
,(p)=f z pdx for all cpE Cc". This yields
all such cp, hence u '=z (almost everywhere), since CO is dense in
V. Substituting u=v=uj in (1.13), letting j-3, it follows that (1.8) is valid for all u ELI(1L2 confirming Parseval's relation. Clearly (1.13) also holds for all u,vE L'(lL2. We use it to prove the Fourier inversion Let n=1. For vE L'("IP, u=X[ 0,x0 ]' some xo>0 apply (1.13). Confirm by calculation of the integral that ,
(1.14)
(2n)1/2u^(x) =
(e-ixxo_
1)/(-ix) = hxo(x)
x # 0
,
,
hence xo
(1.15)
v(x)dx = gIxv^ (x)hxo (x)dx
0
The Fourier inversion formula is a matter of differentiating (1.15) for xo under the integral sign, assuming that this is legal Consider the difference quotient:
xo+b (1.16)
JgIxv^(x)eixxo sin 6x
v(x)dx =
(20)-I
xo -b
Assuming only that v (1.17) limn-0(26)-nfQ
v^ both are in LI
,
xo ,s
v(x)dx =f9lxv^
(Actually, our proof works for n=1 be extended to all xo
,
,
and general n
,
it follows indeed that (x)eixxo=
xo .
> 0 only
(v^ )I (xo ), xoE 2n. ,
but can easily
One must replace the deri-
vative d/dxo by a mixed derivative an/(axol...axo n).
)
Indeed,
0.1. The Fourier transform
7
letting 6-0 in (1.17) we obtain (1.15), using that sin(6x) /(Sx) - 1 uniformly on compact sets, and boundedly on & , as 6-0 If v is continuous at x0 then clearly the left hand side of (1.17) equals v(xo) giving the Fourier inversion formula, as it is well known. For n=1, if v has a jump at xo then the left hand side of (1.17) equals the mean value (v(xo+0)+v(xo-0))/2 exists, if only Again for n=1 a limit of (1.16), as .
,
(1.18)
limaloo
v^ (x)pix
,
-a the principal value, exists (cf. pbm.6), without requiring VA E-= L'
We summarize our results thus far: Proposition 1.1.
The Fourier transform u^ of (1.1) and its com-
plex conjugate u" =(u^)
have u^
,
u" E CO(1Qn)
relation (1.8)
.
.
are defined for all u E L1(&n)
,
and we
For u E L1(In)1L2(In) we have Parseval's
If both u E L1(In) and u^ E L1(1en) hold, then we
have u^" (x) = u"^ (x) = u(x) for almost all x E In
It is known that the Banach space L1(&n) is a commutative Banach algebra under the convolution product (1.19)
u*v = w , w(x) = fOyu(x-Y)w(Y) = f41Yv(x-Y)u(Y)
Indeed, (1.20)
IIwIIL1=JIw(x)Idx s xnfdxfdyIu(x-Y)IIv(Y)I = KnIIuIIL1IIvIIL1
Prop.1.2, below, clarifies the role of the Fourier transform F for this Banach-algebra: F provides the Gelfand homomorphism.
Proposition 1.2.
For u,v E L'
(1.21)
w^ (
let w = u*v
.
Then we have
E &n
) = u^
Proof. We have fpiye
fgixe
The substitution x-y=z , dy=dz thus confirms (1.21), q.e.d. The importance of the Fourier transform for PDE's hinges on Proposition 1.3.
(1.22)
If u(P) E L1 for all (3s a then
u(a)^
h
E &n
.
8
0. Introductory discussions
Proof.Partial integration gives
fdxe
(with vanishing boundary integrals), implying (1.21), q.e.d. Given a linear partial differential equation (1.23)
P(D)u = f
,
where fE L1(&n), Dx =-iax j
P(D) =
ja sN
ax
a Da
one might attempt to find solutions by
,
J
taking the Fourier transform. With proper assumptions (1.21) gives (1.24)
Assuming that e = (P(X))' exists, (1.24) will assume the form
(1.25)
u"
e,
which by prop.1.2 (and Fourier inversion) is equivalent to (1.26)
u(x) = fgIye(x-y)f(y)
.
Presently, (1.26) can only have a formal meaning, since noror u(4 LL, in practical applications. However, as to be discussed in the sections below, the Fourier transform may be extended to more general classes of functions and to generalized functions. Then (1.26) yields a powerful tool for solving problems in constant coefficient PDE's (cf. sec.4).
mally (1/P)(4 L', or f (4 L'
,
Problems. 1) For n=1 obtain the Fourier transforms of the functions a) (a2+x2)-1, a>O; b) (sin2ax)/x2, a>O; c) 1/cosh x a_ ax 2
2) For general n obtain the Fourier transform of
,
a>0
3) Obtain the Fourier transform of f(x) = (1+IxI2)-v, where v>n/2 (Hint: A knowledge of Bessel functions is required for this problem). 4) Construct a function f(x) E L1(&n) such that f^(4 L1
5)The Riemann-Lebesgue lemma states that f^E CO whenever f E L1 Is it true that even f (x) = O((x)-E) for each f E L1 with some 8>O ? 6) Combining some facts, derived above, show that, for n=1, every piecewise smooth function f(x) E L1(&) has a Fourier transform satisfying f(x) = O(1/x) as Jxj is large, and satisfying ,
(1.27)
(f(x+0)+f(x-0))/2
=limfa91yelxyf^(y)
,
x E It
Here 'piecewise smooth' means, that & may be divided into finitely many closed subintervals in each of which f is C1 changing its value at boundary points.
,
possibly after
0.2. Fourier analysis for temperate distributions
9
2. Fourier analysis for temperate distributions on &n We assume that the reader is familiar with the concept of distribution, as a continuous linear functional on the space D(In) = CO(&n) . A linear functional f:D - C is said to be continuous if (f,gj)-.0 whenever (pj-0 in D. The latter means that (i) fj K independent of j, (iii) E D, j=1,2,..., (ii) supp cpjE KCC &n ,
sup{I cp(a)(x)I: xE &n} - 0, as j->oo, for every a. The space of dist-
ributions on In is called D'=D'(&n). The space Llloc(&n) of locally integrable functions is naturally imbedded in DI by defining
(2.1)
(f,(p) = ff(x)g(x)dx
for fE L11oc
,
The derivatives f(a)=aaf of a distribution f E D' are defined by (f(a),(P)
( 2 . 2 )
= ( - 1 )
I a l ( f
,
( , ( a ) )
,
q E D
the product of a distribution f E D' and a C"O(&n) function g by (2.3)
(gf,lp) = (f,g(q)
pED.
,
Thus Lf is defined for any distribution
fE D,(Rn) and linear dif-
ferential operator L=Yaaact with coefficients aa() E C,(&n) While the value f(x) of a distribution at a point x is a meaningless concept, one may talk about the restriction fl!a of fE D.(&n) to an open subset S2 and its properties: First of all, the space DI(S2) of distributions over a consists of the continuous lin,
ear functionals on D(c)=CO(SZ), with continuity defined as for &n. For fE D,(&n), the restriction fID(St) defines a distribution of D'(a), denoted by f192. Thus, for example, it is meaningful to say
that fE DI(&n) is a function (a Ck(f)-function, etc.) in an open set 0C &n - it means that fISz has this property. For a distribution fE DI (a) on an open set the derivatives and product with gE COO(S2) is defined as in (2.2)
,
(2.3)
The support supp f (singu-
.
lar support sing supp f) of fE D' is defined as the smallest closed set E (intersection of all closed sets E) such that f=0 (such C00 that f is ) in the complement of E .
The concept of Fourier transform can be generalized to distributions on &n, with multiple benefit: Some non-L'-functions will get distributions as Fourier transforms. Certain distributions will get functions as Fourier transforms. The Fourier inversion formula and many assumptions (limit interchanges) will simplify.
0. Introductory discussions
10
We used the Fourier integral of (1.1) only for uE L'(&n). It is practical to introduce a growth restriction for uE D'(&n) if we want u^ to be a distribution again. Later on (sec.3) we also , but it no longer will be a distdefine u^ for general uE D'(&n) ribution in D'(&n). We follow [Schwl] here, but [GS] in sec.3. The growth restriction is imposed by requesting that uE D' allows an extension to a larger space of testing functions called S. Here S - the space of rapidly decreasing functions- consists of all cpE C"O(&n) such that for all multi-indices a and k=1,2,...,
(2.4)
sP(a)(x) = 0((X)-k) (x)-k
- the derivatives of y decay faster than every power Note that, equivalently, we could have prescribed that for every a one (and the same) of the following conditions be satisfied: (x)ku(a)(x) (for every k=1,2,..), or xOu(a)(x) (for every (3),
(2.5)
or
(AM) (a) (for every 0), is 0(1)
CB , or CO
,
or L2
,
or is o(1)
,
or is
or LP (for some l sps )
,
Indeed, for a given a one of these conditions may be weaker or stronger than the other. However for all a simultaneously all conditions are equally strong. One must use Leibniz' formula to handle interchanges of as and multiplications (cf. lemma 2.8). The above at once gives the following: Theorem 2.1. We have SC L1(&n), so that u^ of (1.1) (and u") are defined on S. Moreover, for uE S, we have u^, u"E S, and
(2.6)
(u^ )" (x) = (u" )^ (x) = u(x) , x E In
.
The Fourier transform and its conjugate therefore define bijective linear maps S -S , inverting each other. Proof. Using repeated partial integration and get
fdxe
=iIaI+ISIa
(2.7)
hence
(xRu(a))A
In fact, we get xsu(a) E L'
,
for every a,(3
,
by the equivalence
0.2. Fourier analysis for temperate distributions (2.5)
,
for u E S
.
11
Therefore the right hand side is in CO
,
so that u^E S
,
for
again by the equivalence (2.5). Thus we get u^ E S for all u E S Similarly for """ . Also, the Fourier inversion formula holds for u E S and the left hand side of every a,(3
,
.
,
(1.17) equals v(x). This implies (2.5), also by taking complex conjugates. The bijectivity then follows at once, q.e.d. Following Schwartz we introduce distributions with controlled growth at infinity - so called temperate distributions - over sz=&n
as continuous linear functionals over S. The space of all temperaso that a functe distributions is denoted by S'. Clearly, S DD tional u over S induces a functional over D - its restriction uID. ,
Definition 2.2. A sequence of functions cpj ES is said to converge to 0 (in S) if for every multi-index a and k = 0,1,2,... the sequence (x)kcpj(a)(x) converges to zero uniformly for all x E In Definition 2.3. A linear functional u over S is said to be conti-
nuous if cpjE S
,
(p,-.0 in S implies (u,gj) - 0
Temperate distributions are distributions. More precisely speaking: For uE S' the restriction uID determines u uniquely, and uIDE D' (1n). To confirm this we must prove: Lemma 2.4. a) If cpjE D, (Pj-> 0 in D, then we also have cpj- 0 in S. b)
For cpE S there exists a sequence cpjE D such that q)-pj->0 in S
From lemma 2.4 it follows that for WE S' the restriction v= uID is continuous over D : If cpj-0 in D , then c.->0 in S (by (a)),
hence (v, p) =(u, (pj) -0. Hence vE D' . Furthermore, if u, wE S' have uID=wID=vE D', then for gE S let (p. be a sequence of (b) above.
Get u-wE S' , (u-w, c-cpj) -0. Hence 0=(u-w, (pj) _(v-v, cpj) -+( u-w, (p) , implying that (u, cp) =(v, (p) for all y e S, or u=v, so that indeed uE S' is uniquely determined by its restriction v=uIDE D'
.
Proof of lemma 2.4. (a): IfkgjE D, cpj-0 in D then supp Tea) C K= In, while the functions (x) are bounded in K. Thus the uniform convergence (x)kcp.(a)(x)-,0 in pn follows from the uniform conver7 gence j(a)(x)-0 in I and weCoO(&n) have y.- 0 in S, proving (a). To prove (b), let X(x)EE satisfy x(x)=l near 0. For a qE S define cpj(x)=T(x)x(x/j), j=1,2,... so that qjE D. Setting w.(x)=1-x(x/j), get p.=g-c.=Tw.=0 in Ixlsl for large j. Note, ,
,
x)
is a linear
combination of ORY ' j=(x) kcp(') wj (Y) ,
(3+y =a
where sup{IOPY'j(x)I:x E &n} s sup at right goes to 0 as 1-- (i.e.,as j-co).
Also, sup{Iwj(Y)I}=j-IYIsup{w(x):xE 2n}s c. Thus Vj->0 in S, q.e.d.
0. Introductory discussions
12
Note that polynomials, and delta functions S(a)(x-a) are examples of temperate distribution. However, ex (4 S(le) (pbms.2,3).
To generalize F we still require the following. Corollary 2.5. The transforms F and F both have the property that
cjE S
,
Tj- 0 in S implies Fcpj- 0 FT j- 0 in S
It is sufficient to prove this for F. Again we need an equiin S' valence like (2.2), now for the property :
j=1..... Then 'ypj- 0 in S Proposition 2.6. Let q E S equivalent to each of the following conditions: .
,
(x)kgpj(a) (2.8)
0
,
or Apj(a) a 0
or (xs(pj)(a)
,
'
is
0
or k=0,1,2,..., in one (and
for all multi-indices a ,
the same) of the norms of CB(1n) or Lp(&n)
,
1spso .
For the proof cf. lemma 2.8. Using prop.2.6, lemma 2.5 is a matter of (1.2), and (2.7). hence Indeed, if pj- 0 in S we have IlxRcpj(a)IILI-> 0 j ,
,
(xaq)j^ ) (P) IICB_ 0 , implying (pj^ - 0 , For a given u E S'
(2.9)
,
q.e.d.
observe that u^
qES
(u^ ,p) =
, defined by ,
defines a functional in S', since q.- 0 in S implies p^- 0 in S (by cor.2.5) hence (u,cp^) - 0 If U E LI(2n) then it follows that u E S' (cf. pbm.3). In that case we have ,
(2.10)
.
ix
(u,cP^) =
(p E S
=
by Fubini's theorem, since the integrand is L'(12n). Thus, for uE L', (2.10) implies that the functional (2.9) coincides with that of the Fourier transform u^ of (1.1). Accordingly, for a general u E S' we define the Fourier transform u^ as the functional of (2.9) and the conjugate Fourier transform uv by
(2.11)
(u" ,(P) = (u,cp°)
,
(P E S
.
It is clear at once that we have Theorem 2.7. The (conjugate) Fourier transform coincides with the
0.2. Fourier analysis for temperate distributions
13
(conjugate) Fourier transform previously defined for L1-functions (cf.(1.1), and (1.7))
(2.12)
. We have the Fourier inversion formula
(u^ )` = (u` )^
= u , for all u E S'.
E S' Also, for u E S' we have and (2.7) holds as well. Prop.2.6 and (2.2) follow from the (evident) lemma, below. Lemma 2.8. a) We have (using Leibniz' formula and its adjoint) ,
(2.13)
(xau) (R) = IC
with finite sums and constants caRY b) We have (2.14)
Ixals(x)lal
,
and (x)ksc
xau(1) = Ed
,
a(3Yxa-Yu(R-Y)
,
(xa-Y u) (R-Y)
,
aRY
daRY
k laIsk
(x011 with a constant c k
c) We have
(2.15)
(lull
Lp
s II(x)-kll
Lp
II(x)kull
Loo
,
Ispn/p
d) We have
(2.16)
Ilull
lscll (1+Ixl )n+1u^ II
scIIU^ II L
=C
L
E
L
lalsn+l
II (U
(a)
"o s c
)^ II
L
c
Ilxau^ II
7,
lalsn+l
I
lalsn+l
IN
L
(a) II
L
Problems: 1) Show that the following functionals define distributions in D'(&n): a) (f,(p)=q(a)(x°), for given multiindex a and x°
E &n; b) (f,(p)=
J
(p(x)dS, dS=surface measure
;
c) (p.v.X,cp)=
Ixl=1
Ixarl
rp(x)dxX (for n=1). 2) Obtain the first partials of the
distributions of pbm.1. 3) Show that distributions f.E DI(I) are defined by (f+,T)=lime-0,s>0 -J cp()xE. Relate f+ with p.v.X of pbm.1. 4) The distribution derivative satisfies Leibniz' formula and its adjoint (cf. [C,],I,(1.23)). 5) Show that a distribution f E D'(R) with f(a)E C(st), lalsk is a function in Ck(S). 6) Let L1po1
be the class of all uE L'1oc(Rn) with (x) -kuE L' (i") for some k= k(u). Show that Lpo1C S'. 7) Show that p(x)=
aax' E Lpo1C S'.
asm
Also that CB(&n)C Lpol, and LP(&n)C Lpol, lspso. 8) Show that eax
0. Introductory discussions
14
E D'(2), but eax
O. 9) Let Tpol be the class of all
S', as Re a
k aE C00(2n) with a(a)(x)=O((x) a), for some kaE Z, for every a. Show
that differentiation and multiplication by aE Tpol leaves S' invariant. That is, for uE S' , aE Tpol, aE 2+ we have auE S',
u(a)E
S'. 10) Obtain the Fourier transform of the following distributions (If necessary, show, they are in S'): a) xa, a E 2+; b) S
xo
(P),
E Zn +
;
c) eiax , aE 2n. 11) Obtain (p.v.1)^, for the dis3F
1
tribution of pbm.1. 12) Define a distribution x E S', using the same kind of 'principal-value integral' as in pbm 1. 13) Obtain the Fourier transform of a Calculate (p.v.sln-h X)^ 2n-periodic C00(2)- function a(x). Hint: Use that a(x) has a uni2n
formly convergent Fourier series a(x)=y00 ameimx, am
ae-iz°xdx 0
14) Let f(x)=sin xJ
. Show that fE S' and evaluate f^.
3. The Paley-Wiener theorem; Fourier transform of a general uE D'. The support of a distribution uE D' was defined as smallest closed set Q with u=O in 1\Q. We now consider u with supp u0 a. A simple but important remark is that a compactly supported distribution uE D'(fz), as linear functional over D(fz), admits a natural extension to the larger space E=C00(c). (The notation was introduced by Schwartz again.) Indeed, for a given X(x)E CD(f) with x(x)=1 near supp u, define the extension of (u,.) to E by
(3.1)
(u,(p) = (u,x(p)
,
for all q) E E(a) = C,(fz)
.
This defines an extension: if yE D(fz) , then (1-x)TE D(fz), and supp (1-x)TC supp (1-x) is disjoint from supp u, hence (u,(1-x)(0= 0, or, (u,(p)=(u,x(p). The extension is independent of the choice
of X. If OE D(Q) has the property of x then r-x=0 near supp u,
(3.2)
(u,Ocp) = (u,xq))
,
for all q> E E(c)
.
The class of all distributions uE D'(fz) with compact support is commonly denoted by E'(fz). We have seen that E'(fz) is naturally
identified with a class of linear functionals on the space E(fz). Proposition 3.1. The set El(fl) of all (above extensions of) compactly supported uE D'(fz) coincides with the set of continuous lin-
0.3. The Paley-Weiner theorem
15
ear functionals over E(n) (i.e., the functionals u over E(at) such
that jE E, q .-'O in E implies (u, (pj) ->0) . Here ypj-0 in E means that Tj (a)(x) - 0 uniformly on compact sets of f, for all a .
Clearly the extension (3.1) to E of uE D' with supp u Cc n is a continuous linear functional over E, in the above sense: If ypjE E, (pj- 0 in E , then xroj* 0 in D, as a consequence of Leibniz'
formula. Vice versa, for a continuous linear functional u over E the restriction v=uID is a distribution in D', since cpjE D, Tj-0 in D trivially implies Tj-. 0 in E. Prop.3.1 follows if we can show that supp v CC st. Suppose not, then a sequence of balls Bj may be constructed such that um0 in Bj, while every set KCC st is disjoint from all but finitely many of the B. Construct T.E D ,
supp W C Bj with (u,(pj)=1
.
Observe that cpj-> 0 in E while ?u,(Pj)
=1 does not tend to zero, a contradiction.
Q.E.D.
For a compactly supported distribution on &n we always have a Fourier transform in the sense of sec.2, i.e.,we get E'(len)C S':
Theorem 3.2. All compactly supported distributions over mn are temperate. Moreover, for uEE'C S', u^ is a Co function given by
(3.3)
u^ (x) =
fne
(u,ex)
,
ex(
) = e ix
with a distribution integral, given by the third expression (3.3). In fact, the function u^(x) is entire analytic, in the n complex variables xj, in the sense that v(z)=(u,ez),
ez(x)=a-izx,
is meaningful for all zE Cn, (not only &n), and defines an extension of u^ of (3.3) to Cn having continuous partial derivatives in the complex sense with respect to each of the variables zl,...,zn. Note that formula (3.3) is meaningful only by virtue of our extension (3.1) of u E=-El to all of E .
Proof. For uE D'(En), supp u CC &n, the natural extension to E may be restricted to S again to provide a continuous linear functional on S, since "(pj- 0 in S " implies "q)j->0 in E". Hence uE S'. The function v(z) indeed is meaningful for all zE Cn. Existence of av/azj is a matter of the continuity of the functional u over E: For a fixed z h E Cn, form the difference quotient ,
(3.4)
we = (v(z+eh)-v(z))/E = (u,(ez+Eh ez)/e)
For the directional derivative Vhez
(3.5)
,
E > 0
of ez at z , we get
V. = (ez+eh ez)/E - Ohez
0 in E
Indeed, this only means that aXVE, 0 uniformly on KCC 2n, as rea-
0. Introductory discussions
16
dily verified for
Continuity of u then implies
limE-0,Ex0wE _ (u,Vhez)
(3.6)
,
confirming that v(z) is analytic for all z. Formally we then get
(3.7)
(u^ ,q)) =
rP(U)) =
(u,e
f91
with v(x) as defined, where the interchange of limit leading to the second equality remains to be confirmed. Clearly (3.7) implies u^=v, i.e., (3.3) and thm.3.2 follows. For the interchange of limit show existence of the improper Riemann integral f g in the sense of convergence in E: For KCC in we must show that
in E, as k-. Here Sk is any sequence of Riemann sums, with maximum partition diameter tending to 0 as k-'o. Also, that f
as K runs through a sequence Kj with LX.=&n,
R n \K
again, with convergence in E. Again, convergence in E just means local uniform convergence with all derivatives. One confirms easily the local uniform convergence in the parameter x since the function e,(x) = e-'x is continuous. Similarly for the x-derivatives, again continuous in x and This, and the fact that the x-derivatives of the Riemann sums are Riemann sums again, indeed allows to confirm the desired convergences. Q.E.D. As examples for Fourier transforms of compactly supported ,
.
distributions we mention those of the delta-function and its derivatives. As seen in 2,pbm.5 we get 60(a)^= i1alxnxa In fact, this is an immediate consequence of (3.3), above. We observe that the entire analytic function u^(z) of (3.3), as a function of complex arguments z has a growth property which characterizes the Fourier transforms of compactly supported distributions. The result is called the Paley-Wiener theorem. .
,
Tn
Theorem 3.3. An entire analytic function v(z) over is the Fourier transform of a compactly supported distribution uE D'(&n) if and only if there exists an integer k > 0 and a real i>O such that
(3.8)
v(z) = O((z)ke'11Im z1)
for all z ETn ,
(z)=(I+Ilzj12)1/2
Moreover, the constant I may be chosen as the radius of the smallest ball lxlsr containing supp u Furthermore, uE D(&n) if and only if (3.8) holds for all k with rl=max{lxi: xE supp u} .
0.3. The Paley-Weiner theorem
17
Proof. For u E E' we must have (3.9)
I(u,(P) I s c sup{ IyP (a) (x) I: x E K
Ialsk }
for some c, k, and some compact K J supp u and all TEE E. Otherwise
for every c=k=j and Ixlsj there exists T=q E E with (u,T.)=1 ">" holds in (3.9). Or, I(pja)(x)Is for all lalsj 2,... implying uniform convergence Tja)(x)- 0 ,j-*oo ,
Ix1sj ,
,
,
and j=1,
a contra-
diction, since 1=(u, c).) does not tend to 0. We get u^(z)=(u,Xzez) x(t)=1
xz=X(IzI(IxI-i)) where xEC00(R)
, x decreasing. It follows that supp X. C } so that (XZez)(a)(x)= O(e'1IImzI+1(z)k). Combining this {IxI511+ with (3.9) we get (3.8) with the proper constant i Next assume uE C0(f). We trivially get (3.9) with k=0 and K= ,
t , =0, t>1
supp u CC n, since uE L1. Similarly for u(a). Accordingly, for all a we get
1zau^(z)I=I(u,e(a))I=O(e1IIm
z1),
hence (3.8) for all k.
Vice versa, (3.8) for all k implies xavllnE L'C S'. Then v" is given by the conjugate Fourier integral. We have u=(vl&n)`E CO, and even u(a)E CO, i.e., uE Coo(&n). To show that supp uCC in write (3.10)
u(x) = J
If 0 E In is given arbitrary then we also may write (3.10) as u(x) =
(3.11)
Indeed, this is a matter of Cauchy's integral theorem, applied for a rectangle in the complex i;j-plane with sides Re tj=±A, In =0 or Oj. In such a rectangle the integrand elx'v(i;) is holomorphic
as a function of ti for constant other variables, so that the complex integral over the boundary vanishes. For A-- the integrals over Re tj=±A, O
for example. The integration pathes have length 0i and the integrand is O((A)-2e(1-x)IOI). The integral (3.10) may be written as n-fold iterated integral over It. The above proceedure allows the transfer of the integration from R to the line { j+i0 Next let us estimate (3.11): (3.12)
u(x) =
xjE I}
O(e1101-xO)
setting k=n+1 (it holds for every k), and using that (1+i0) z M. The 'Q(.)- constant' is independent of 0. Hence we can set 0=tx, The exponent is <0 as 1xI>1, and t>0, for u(x)=O(etlxl(11-Ixl)),
0. Introductory discussions
18
u(x)=0 follows. Thus supp uC {IxIsi}, uE D, if (3.8) for all k. Finally, if (3.8) holds for some k, let X(x)E=- D, supp x C
{jxIs1}, x(x)2:0, fx(x)¢x=1. For e>0 let XE(x)=nx(E). Note that
x
(
Moreover, for any cpE S get
)=x^ (ei;)-+x^ (0)=1, as
qe^-w+0
in S. Since supp XEC {IxjsE} we have (3.8) for xE^(t) with rf rep-
laced by a for all k. Hence the product v(z)xE^(z) satisfies (3.8) with ti replaced by T1+e again for all k. It follows that vxe^=ue^
with uEE D, supp uEC {jxjsri+E}. Also (uE,(P}=(uE^ ,Cpl}=(v,xe^V") (v, q)-) _(u, q) , for all qE S. The latter implies that supp uC xI2M+e}, all a>O. It follows that uE E, supp uC {IxIsr1}, q.e.d.
Let Z denote the space of all entire analytic functions v(z) =v(z1,...,zn) in n complex variables such that for k=0,1,2,..., and some rjz0 we have (3.8) satisfied. We shall say that a sequence
vj E Z tends to 0 in Z if (i) estimates (3.8) hold with constants Nn}-0,
independent of j, and (ii) mj=Max{Ivj(x)I: x E
as
Corollary 3.4. The Fourier transform F: u -, u^ establishes a linear bijection D H Z which is continuous in either direction, in
the sense that u
0 in D holds if and only if uj^-> 0 in Z
.
Proof. After thm.3.3 we focus on continuity only. If uj-> 0 in D
then supp uj C {jxIsa} for a independent of j
.
This yields (3.8)
with r)=a independent of j, by thm.3.3. Inspecting the first part
of thm.3.3's proof we also find the 0(.) constant independent of J. Vice versa, if in Z, then (3.8) with r) independent of j implies supp uj° C But (3.8), for real z=x, implies vj= O((x)-k), uniformly in x and j, for every k. Thus conclude from cdn.(ii) that jlxav1I,
1-> 0, as j-. -. For the inverse Fourier trans-
0, so that indeed
form uj=vj^ we get 1Iuj(a)ii
in D.
Q.E.D.
L 00 _>
Following [GS] we now define a Fourier transform of a general distribution f E D'(111) regardless of growth at infinity, as a continuous linear functional f^:Z-'Q. Here of course "f^ contin-
uous" means that "(f^ ,(pj) -'0, whenever qj->0 in Z". We define f^ by (f^ ,(p) = (f,(p^)
(3.13)
,
for all p E Z
,
taking into account that p^
E D for T E Z This definition is compatible with the earlier ones. Indeed, we have Z C S in the sense that for uE Z the restriction ulin determines u uniquely and is contained in S . Moreover, Z is dense ,
in S, since Z=D^
, and D is dense in S while F and F
are continu-
19
0.3. The Paley-Weiner theorem
ous maps S->S. Also T j-0 in Z implies cp.-> 0 in S. For uE S' the restriction u1Z determines u and we have ulZE V. Hence get a natural imbedding S' 4Z' . For uE S' C Z' we earlier defined (u^ , (P) _(u, V ) for TE S. The restriction u^IZ gives our present functional,q.e.d. for uE D' in general is not a distribution, Notice that u^ as defined in sec.2. It is a linear functional on Z , not on D . Recall that for a function f E LIloc(R) with f=0 in x
,
f-(r;)= f glxe lxtf(x)
(3.14)
,
Im t < -c
0
where the integral exists and defines a holomorphic function in the complex half-plane Im i; <-c (we have modified the standard
definition, by a factor i). The inverse transform then is given by
f(x) =
(3.15)
-oo+iy
+«'+iy plteixif
(i;)
with a complex curve integral along the parallel Im = y <-c We now will identify f- with the Fourier transform f^E Z' of the distribution fE D'. For cpE D , supp T C {jxjsi} , we know that q is entire analytic, satisfying (3.8). For y<-c we have
(3.16)
Im =y
f- (t) q), (t) dt = P91xf (x)
f eixtg. (t) dt _ (f,g)
Imt=y
The integral dxdIl;I exists absolutely, hence the interchange, by
Fubini's theorem. Also, we get
= fR
f
,
at right, by the pro-
perties of the (analytic) integrand. Then (3.16) follows from Fourier inversion for functions in D. Or, f^E Z' may be written as
(3.17)
(f^
t)) =
f f- (t)cp(z)dt
,
cpE Z
Im?=y where we must choose y < -c with c of (3.14) (for f) Thus for a function fE LIloc(R) of exponential growth and =0 in x<0 the Fourier transform f^ is given as the complex integral (3.17) involving the Laplace transform f- of f .
Problems. 1) Obtain the Laplace transforms of the following functions (Each is extended zero for x<0). a) xk k=0,1,..., b) eax; c) cos bx ; d) eaxsin bx ; e) sin In each case, discuss the .
Fourier transform - i.e., the linear functional on Z. 2) Obtain the inverse Laplace transform of a) ; b) log(1+Z ). (In each case specify a branch of the (multi-valued) function well defined in a half-plane Im z < y .) 3) For uE D'(ien) with supp uC {xix0}=
0. Introductory discussions
20 In
and ecx'uE S', for some c, show that u^ may be defined by a complex integral like (3.17), with u replaced by ut with respect to (x2,...,xn). 4) The convolution product w=u*v, so far defined for u,vE L'(&n), by (1.19), may be defined for general distributions u,vE D'(&n) under a support restriction -for example (i) if supp U= 1n, supp v general, or (ii) if supp vC {xlzo}, supp v C {jxjscx,}
One then defines (w,(p>=ffdxdyu(x)v(y)T(x+y),
.
with a distribution integral (for precise definition cf.[Schw1], or, Show that (1.21) is valid for this convolution product as well, assuming in case (ii) the cdns. of pbm.3 for u,v. 5) Let TA be the space of all entire functions x(z) satisfying (3.8) for some k. Show that XPE Z, for pE Z , XE TA . Moreover, setting show that fE Z' allows definition of a product XfE Z' (xf,(p)=(f,xcp), (pE Z All polynomials p(x) belong to TA . 6) Show ,
.
that (1.22) is valid for general distributions
u E D'(&n)
4. The Fourier-Laplace method; examples. We now will discuss the 'Fourier-Laplace method' for 'free space'-problems of the following constant coefficient operators: (4.1)
A ==lax 2
(the Laplace operator)
(4.2)
A + k2
(the Helmholtz operator)
H = axo - A = at - A
(4.3)
(4.4)
= axo2 - A = at A
(4.5)
+m2
(the heat operator)
,
,
(the wave operator)
(the Klein-Gordon operator)
.
The last 3 operators act on the n+1 variables x0=t, (x1,...,xn)=x. The first two act on x only, distinguishing xo from the others. The discussion around (1.23)-(1.26) was a formal attempt to solve constant coefficient PDE in free space (in all In). We found e= ()' for a P(D), of special interest. Now we are prepared to implicate this technique, called the Fourier-Laplace method. Certain initial-boundary problems may be converted into free space problems: (a) An initial-value problem for (4.3),(4.4), or ,
0.4. The Fourier-Laplace method (4.5)
21
seeks to find solutions u of P(D)u=f in some half-space,
say, t=xo>O, where f is given in ta0, together with initial data of u at t=0. Such problem may be written as a free space problem by extending u=0 and f=0 into t0, u=0 as x1=0, then consider the odd extensions of u and f to &n: v(xl,...,xn)=u(x), x1>0, =-u(-xl,x2,...,xn), x,<0, similarly g extending f. It follows that Av=g in Rn, again converting the half-space Dirichlet problem of A to a free space problem over I
.
Similarly for the Neumann problem, using even extensions. Technique (a) works as well for a more general initial surface t=0(x) x(-= &n. Both techniqes may be combined to reduce cer,
tain initial-boundary problems to free space problems. The above will emphasize the power of the Fourier Laplace method. (4.1)-(4.5) are a crossection of popular PDE's. We control parabolic and hyperbolic initial value problems, elliptic boundary problems and initial-boundary problems in half spaces, etc., with Green's (Riemann) functions, using results on special functions. From now on interprete the equation P(D)v=g , xE Rn, as a PDE involving distributions v,gE D'(1n). The Fourier transform exists without restrictions: Using 3,pbm.6, we get P(x)v^=g^ , where v^, g^E Z'. If eE D'(&n) solves P(D)e=(2n)n/2S we get P(x)e^=1. In the cases corresponding to (4.1)-(4.5) (4.6)
P(x) =-Ix12
,
=k2-Ix12
,
=it+x12
,
we get, respectively, =Ixl2-t2
,
=m2+Ix12-t2,
where t=x0 again. Generally, P(x) (4 Liloc' except for (4.3) and (4.1), n2t3, due to zeros of P. Some pbm's of sec's 2,3 (and, more generally, [C,],II) discuss distributions p.v.a associated to a
Llloc' P(x)z=1 may have many solutions zE D' (or E Z'). For (4.3)-
(4.5) we will be interested in z=e^, P(x)z=1, with supp eC {to}, because then supp a*gC {t2-0} whenever supp gC {tao}, so that u= (e*(g+h))I{t2-0} will solve the initial-value problem for P(D)u=f
ta0, we started with in (a) above. Indeed, a proper z exists: In pbm's I and 3 of sec.2 we defined p.v.1 , and f+ all 3 distinct, xf=1. Only f has its inverse Fourier transform =0 for x<0. ,
22
0. Introductory discussions
D,(Rn+1) solving For (4.3)-(4.5) we will construct such eE supp e C {t2-0}, using the setup of sec.3, pbm.3: P(D)e--%r2_xn+I6 ,
Such e, if ecxeE S', will have a Fourier transform in x=(xi,..) and a Laplace transform in xo=t. Accordingly we must seek an inverse Laplace transform of an inverse Fourier transform of a suitable solution z of Pz=1, or vice versa, in appropriate variables. Our proofs will be sketchy, in part, due to overflow of details. The lemma below is convenient, due to spherical symmetry of P. Lemma 4.1. Given a spherically symmetric function f(x)=co(Ixi) LI()e+,rn-1dr). where w(r) E Then the transforms f^ and f, are spherically symmetric as well: f^(x)=f"(x)=X(Ixl), where X(r) and co(r) are related by the Hankel transform A , v=2 1. In detail we have ,
r(n-1)/2X(r) = Hn/2-1(r(n-1)/2(o(r)) (4.7)
r(n-1)/2w(r) = Hn/2-1(r(n-1)/2X(r))
.
where (4.8)
H (X(r))(p) =
fV pr Jv(rp) ?(r) dr
, Re v > -2
0
with the Bessel function J v(z) . The second formula (4.7) is valid L1(&+,rn-1dr) if in addition X E .
T paxe-ix
Proof. For an orthogonal nxn-matrix 0 get Jxe-i(O
T
X)
T
Thus f^ has the same
w(IOTxI) = folye
symmetry:
with some X(p). We may set
RIXe-ipx w(r)=Kn f rn-1w(r) f e-irpz, dS 0 where the inner integral I is over the unit sphere Izl=1. Evaluate
(4.9)
f^
Il;I
, 0 , ... , 0)=f
this inner integral by converting it to an integral on the n-1-dimensional ball IXI2 sl, setting z=(z1,?,). We know that dS= With a contribution from the upper and lower hemisphere where z,= 1-72
, writing dX=an-2dodl, o=IXI, etc., we get 1
I=2
on-2 1662dEcos(rp)=tan-1 f 6n-2cos(rp) 0
A substitution a= sin 0 of integration variable yields x /2
(4.10)
1 = 2an-1
d9 sinn-20 cos(rpcos 0) 0
23
0.4. The Fourier-Laplace method (n-1)/2 ,
2 with an-1 ='((n-1)/2)
the area of the n-l-dimensional unit sphere. Using Poisson's formula ([MOS],p.79) we get fn /2
(4.11)
cos(rpcosO) sine-28 d9 =2n/2-2V.(n21)Jn/2-1(rp)
0
Substituting into (4.10) and I into (4.9) confirm (4.7). No change a-ix in (4.9) is replaced by elx . Thus lemma 4.1 follows. if Recall also (1.26), now under the aspect of 3,pbm.4. In details, the convolution product v*w of two distributions v,wE D'(&n) may be defined by setting (with a distribution integral)
(4.12)
(v*w,(P) = fv(x)w(y)g(x+y)dxdy = (v(ga,V) , V(x,y)=T(x+y)
for all q)E D(&n)=Cp(&n)
,
if v and w satisfy the support condition
(4.13) Ka (supp v x supp w)fl{jx+yIsa} is compact for every a>0
.
Here supp v and supp w are regarded as subsets of in of the variables x and y, respectively (cf. [Schwl] or [C1], 1,8). The distribution v=e*g is defined for e as constructed above whenever g E E' for (4.1)-(4.3) and gE D'(1en+1) , g=o as t<0 for (4.4) and (4.5) since condition (4.13) holds under these assumptions. Moreover, P(D)v=g follows, leading to a solution of the free space problem, and the related initial-boundary problems. ,
,
Now let us attempt a detailed construction of the proper e. Ia) Consider the operator A of (4.1), i.e., the potential
equation Au=f. For n2:3 the function -IX is Lpol, hence a distribution in S'. This is a homogeneous distribution of degree -2 Hence e is homogeneous of degree 2-n . It is also spherically symmetric. Conclusion: , with a constant cn. Clearly e E Lpol The constant cn may be evaluated by looking at e(x)=cnIxI2-n
.
cnfAW(x)1x12-ndx =cnlims-0
(2n)n/2g(0)=(e,Ag)= =cnan(2-n)T(0) (4.14)
.
dSicpdrr2-n
f
r=e
It follows that
en(x) =(n2)w 1xI2-n n
n- n 2
n
For n=1 we first define a distribution (4.15)
e^=-p.f.XZ
=
!I (p.v.1
involving the distribution derivative and p.v.X of pbm.l,sec.2.
We confirm that e^ solves -xz e^ =l . Using a=e^ (4.16)
e(x) _jxI .
one finds that
0. Introductory discussions
24
For n=2 we can define (cf.[C1],II,(2.11), for 1=2) (4.17)
a"(x)=-p.f.IX :=-Lj=1( x Zxjloglxl)Ix.7=-2A((log Ix2
again with distribution derivatives. However, it is easier to con-
firm directly that e(x) = x1loglxl
(4.18)
is a spherically symmetric L11oc-function satisfying Ae=b (just evaluate the integral (Ae, q) _(e, A(p) , using partial integration). Ib) Consider (4.2), i.e, the Helmholtz equation (D+X)u=f also known as the time-independent wave equation if X=k2>0, and as the resolvent equation of the Laplace operator A if XE C, X#k2
.
In the latter case get a^(x)=(X-1xI2)-1E C°n Lpol. An evaluation We get of e(x) is possible, using lemma 4.1, as long as ns3 .
(4.19)
IxI1-n/2
e(x) =
Pn/2X
J
Jn/2-1(Plxl)
For larger n this integral ceases to exist. However, it still will exist as improper integral in the sense of distributions A that is, as limAO where the limit exists in weak convergence ,
0
of D' (i.e., (lim.,(p) = lim(.,(p)
). For odd n the Bessel function Jn/2-1 may be expressed by trigononmetric functions. For example,
in case n=3 we get J1/2(z)
Or,
e(x) = VnII J-- 24 sinpixl
(4.20)
0
We may write X = x2 sinpr = 2
00
,
picking the root x with In x>O eirpxdP
KPp sinpr =41 -00
e(x) =-7
(4.21)
.
= 2 ixlxl
Then Hence
e'xlxl/lxl
(4.21) may be confirmed, noting that e=eiicr/r solves (A+X)e=2n6
For x=k real is not Ltioc (4.22)
P(x)=k2-lx,2
vanishes at the set Ixl=k, and
Then look at p.f.(P(1x)). Or else, observe that
lim£.,0,s>0 ek+is(x) = e(x)
,
ex(x) as e(x) in (4.21)
in the sense of distributions. This implies that (4.23)
a+(x) _ -Ve±iklx1/IxI
0.4. The Fourier-Laplace method
both will solve (A+k2)e=(2n)3/26
25
The proper sign may be chosen
.
by imposing a 'radiation condition' at - . For general n2:2 we still may evaluate the integral (4.19).
Using a formula by Sonine and Gegenbauer (cf. [MOS], p.105) we get (4.24)
e(x)=-(
1XI
)n/2-1Kn/2_1(KIxI)
x > 0
,
with the modified Hankel function Kv(z). Again get (4.24) more directly, observing that e(x)=y(Ixl) solves (A+X)e=0, hence y(r) solvn-1, we obtain es the ODE y"+n-1y'-x2y=0. Substituting y=rvb, v
the modified Bessel equation S"+rS'-(1+j.)5=0, showing that the only spherically symmetric solutions of (A+X)u=0 in S' are the multiples of (4.24). A partial integration shows that fe(A+X)tpdx= g(x) for all TEED , fixing the remaining multiplicative constant. II) In the case (4.3) of the heat equation Hu=ut Au=f we may use (4.24): Applying FX1 to P for the second and third polynomial (4.6) gives the same result, if we set ?=k2=-x2=it. That is, x= e-in14Jt,
Re x >0, in (4.24) will define F-'(.) , and we then must obtain the inverse Laplace transform. It is more practical, however, to first obtain Ft Note
has inverse Laplace transform 04(t)-
8(t)=(it+a)-1
ta0, =0, t<0
,
2ne-at,
f e-ate-ittdt. For e'=F- 1(P) get
calculating
0
(4.25)
(2n)1/2e-t1x1 2
e' (t) =
Recall that (e -
as ta0
,
,
e' (t)=0
as t<0
,
.
x 2/2)"=e- xjz/2 (in n dimensions), by a complex
integration. Also for the function ga(x) = g(ax) we get
(4.26)
g0" (x) = a ng" (x/a)
,
a E &+
,
as shown by an integral substitution. Choosing a--V_2t we thus get (4.27)
e(t,x) _()
_I X12
ta0
11
=0
t<0
This is the well known fundamental solution of the heat opera tor. It is not L1(Rn+1). Use it to solve the initial value problem (4.28)
Hu = ax u-Au = f
,
x0a0
,
u(x0,x) = q(x)
,
0
where f,p are given
Setting u and f zero in t<0 to
26
0. Introductory discussions
obtain functions v and g we get Hv = g + 6(t)(9p(x) = h
(4.29)
Thus v=e*h , or, (4.30)
u(t,x)=xn+lftstgltgTye(t-t,x-y)f(y) + xn+1r
J9Tye(t,x-y)w(y).
III) Now we look at (4.4), or, the wave equation u = (at - O)u = f
(4.31)
We apply the Fourier-Laplace method as for (II): The function
P =
(4.32)
-t'
IxI
21x7
{t+Ixi - tIxI}
has inverse Laplace transform (in t) given by
(4.33)
2i Ix
(e-
itjxl_ itlxl
)=
sin( x t)
V2n
1xI
,
ta0
(and zero for t<0). Looking for F;1 of the function (4.33) we cannot apply a Fourier integral, since the function (4.33) is not L1.
First set n=2. Writing FXlw=w° for a moment, we have
(4.34)
(e,cp) =
(cos2rt (Plt) = (f,mlt)
using that (cos Ixlt)lt = -Ixl sin IxIt
, roE D(Rn)
,
r=IxI
Now the inverse Fourier
.
integral of f= cos2rt may be calculated as improper Riemann
integral limAjl xIsA , although still that function is not LI Using (4.7), (4.8) - where v=2
j,(,)=V2
z , for n=3 - we get
,
00
f°=w(IXI)
w(r)=(V_2n)(N(_2
)
f '(r) sin r13 cos2pt dp
.
Or,
0
w(r) = r
= r{
(4.35)
Psin rp cos pt
sgn(t-r) - 2}
.
p
=r fco(sin p(t-r) - sin p(t+r)) P
Conclusion:
e(t,x) =li atH(t-IxI) , as t>0
,
=0
,
as t<0
,
n=3
with the distribution derivative at and the Heaviside function H(t)=1, tZ0 , H(t)=0 t
,
0.4. The Fourier-Laplace method (4.36)
27
, t>0 , u=p , ult=V at t=0
ultt-Au=p
into a full space problem we get vltt Av = S'(t)Clp(x) + 6(t)W(x) + g = h
(4.37)
where v and g are u and f extended zero for t<0 e*h we get the solution of (4.36) in the form ,
u(t,x) =4iJ (4.38)
.
Evaluating
yf(t-lx-yl,y)
lx-ylst
+ 4n at(t,Ilzl=1T(x+tz)dSZ) +
4n Jlz1=1V(x+tz)dSz
(4.38) is known as the Kirchhoff formula.
For general n2t2 let j=[n21] . As in (4.35) write (e,y)) _
+t or fj=tcPs,1t (with p=lxl) for V-(f j,((at)j(p)where fj=±sPn° even (odd) J. The inverse Fourier integral of fj exist at least as
limAJ lxlsA' (4.39)
we apply lemma 4.1 as above. For odd n we get
fj°(t,x)=wj(t,lxl)
,
wj(t,r)=*r v P7V(rp)ls'n cos pt}
for even n this will be of the form (4.40)
fj°(t,x)=wj(t,lxl)
v
wj(t.r)=tr
J JV(rp){cos pt} dp 0
with a convergent improper Riemann integral. More precisely, in (4.39) and (4.40) we have "(-1)1cos pt " as j is odd, and "(-1)lsin pt " as j is even, with 1=[Z] Our distribution e then is given by (4.41) below, with a distribution derivative at .
(4.41)
e(t,x) = (-1)JV-2natwj(t,lxl)
Now we must consult different formulas on Bessel function integrals where as a general reference we quote [MOS] (or [MO]). Case (a): n even, j odd. Then j=[n21]-2-1=v, 1=, n=0(mod 4). We use a Weber-Schafheitlin integral ([MOS] p.99, last formula). Since v=j is odd, we have for t>r the formula (4.42)
I = f Jv(rp)cos pt dp= (rz-t2)-1/2cos(vsin-1(r))=4Pj_1(F)' 0
with a certain polynomial Pj-1(t) of degree j-1. Note that the integral enters (4.41) under the derivative at so that a=0 for ,
0. Introductory discussions
28
tr-
For r
t>lxl
by the same
r-j(t+ tx-rx)-j
formula. Summarizing: For n=0(mod 4) we get
e(t,x) _-r 821+1(Z1(t,r))
,
with
(4.43)
Z1(t,r) = r 21Q214P, t>r
t
,
-rL)21+1
(t+
=0(-i)1 m(22m1)T2m(1_i2)1-m
where Q21(2) =
Case (b): n even, j even. We still have j=v=?-1, 1=2, n=2(mod 4) Use formula 3 on p. 51 of [MO]. The result is as in (4.43) with
Z1 (t,r) = r n/2Q21-14P (4.43)b Q 21
-1 (t) =
,
t>r , =-p (t+ t -
1(_1)l-m( 21 )t 2m+1(i_T2 )1-m-1
_-0
t
,
) 21
,
n!2>0,
1
4
2m+1
while for n=2 (i.e.,[nn-1] 1=0) we n2 set Q2i_1=0 =j, n=2j+1, 1='-', j=21+1, n=3(mod 4). Case (c): n,j odd, .
2
00
Let I= f Jv(rp)cospt
=v 2 f Jj-112(rp)J-112(tp)dp. Use formula 2,
p.50 of [MO] with (a,b)=(r,t), (v,n)=(1+?,1). Get v-n=2, I=O, t>r,
(4.44)
I=N"" 2r
1.3.5... (21-1)xF,
246
2.1
2
2
r
t
2r
where the hypergeometric function (hence Q21(z)) 1 (11 2Fi(1+-1;2;z)=1-1(21+1)z+li =](21+1)(21+3)2r + x
(4.45)
...
is a polynomial in z of degree 1=n43. Combining (4.39) and (4.44), (4.46)
e(t,x)
=(_i)1+1xr 21-1x21+1 t IQ21(r)H(r ,)} t
Case (d): n odd, j even, j=n41, n=2j+1, 1=
_ r-lxl
__n
1--n4
,
, n=i(mod 4)
.
Now we
need I= f Jv(rp)sinpt r = n2 f Jj_i,,2(rp)Ji/2(tp)dp . Again use 0 Get the formula of case (c), now with
(4.47)
I=V7(t)3.5..
2r r 2.4
21+1
2t-2 2F, (1+1,1-1;3;tx 2 2 r )_`/
21-1(t, r
t
and 1=0 for t>r , with a polynomial Q21-1(z) of degree 21-1. Hence (4.48)
e(t,x) _ (-1)lnr 21at1{Q21-1(r)H(r-t)}
n41
,
r=IxI
IV) Finally, look at the Klein-Gordon equation (4.5), n=3 only
29
0.4. The Fourier-Laplace method
(4.49)
utt Au + mz u = f
(p+mz ) u =
Equation (4.32) now assumes the form
p = Xz ltz ={t+a. - tip}
a(x)- m2+ x
FesintVx m x VTP m For n=3, v=2, j=n21-1 use (4.7),(4.8) on x(IxI) of (4.51), for 00
)p3/2/Vg -+W dp
Vrw(r) = nVt f J1/2(rp)J1/2(t
(4.52)
0
This integral diverges, just as for m=0. Applying a formula of Sonine (1880) and Gegenbauer (1884) (first on p.104 of [MOS]), for s>O , we get (µ,v)=(2,2 E) (a,b)=(t,r) m=z ,
,
,
foo
(4.53)
+p )
J1/2(rp)J1/2+E (t
0
p"I
pJ m
',
1-E
limn
Js-1 (MV-t2
IF
with existing weak limit in D'(13)
.
Or,
e(t,x) = nm limE->O,E>O{H(t-IxI)JE-l(m t2 rz)/ t-E
(4.54)
Recall, for v=s-1 we have Z/2) E-1
(4.55)
Jv(z) = r(s)
-
z 2 0 r( +m+E
6>0
m+
The second term, at right, goes to -J1(z), as E-0, uniformly on K and weakly in D'. For a cE D write (e, (p) =T, +Tz , by the decomposition (4.55). Then Tz - -nm(Jl (m tz -rz )/ t2-rz ,(p) , Ti M &n
,
2n lime-Of
rd(t)
(tt x )1-E
, where r(E)=E(1+c,E+ ...). Hence
Ixlst
T1=2n lime.,O{f (4.56)
dxdt t+rx (tEr)E =2n lim
=-2n1imE-Of1xlstdxdtat{r+t x }(t-r)E =-2nfH(t-r){ In other words, TI=n(-:-.a tH(t-r),g)
(4.57)
fdtdr{(t-r)E}t
IxIst
.
e(t,x) = r tH(t-Ixl) -
}tdtdx
Result:
J1(m tz-xz)
30
0. Introductory discussions
5. Abstract solutions and hypo-ellipticity. In sections 1,2,3,4 we have deployed the Fourier-Laplace method of solving certain problems involving constant coefficient PDE's under sufficiently simple initial boundary conditions. The focus was on the Fourier transform. In a distribution setting it
reduces the problem of solving P(D)v=g to the division problem speaP(x)v^=g^, providing an 'inverse' for P(D) in the form king roughly. In later chapters, this type of inverse construction will be extended to variable coefficients - and more general boundaries, but the central role of the Fourier transform is maintained, and the inverses obtained have similar features. On the other hand, the theory of constructing an inverse of an abstract operator between two linear spaces is well studied, in present times. It will be ever present in the background of our discussions. The role of certain Hilbert spaces- L2-Sobolev spaces - in theory of 1pdo's will have to be studied. Theory of (bounded and unbounded) Fredholm operators in Hilbert spaces will be crucial for elliptic i,do's, as well as compactness properties.
Often existence of a generalized solution to a PDE (a boundary problem) can be derived by purely abstract arguments. But then theory of pdo's may have to be used to derive properties of such solution -even differentiability, and that we have a solution in the classical sense. Let us discuss an example. For an open domain czC &n, consider the Hilbert space H=L2(n) with norm and inner product (5.1)
(u,v) =
The Laplace operator A=
1lull2 = (u,u)
, u,v E H
ax 2 defines a linear map CD(cZ)-C'(S)C H 7
which may be interpreted as an unbounded operator H0 of H with domain dom H0=Co(st), using that C0(a) is a dense subspace of H
In fact, H0 is hermitian and negative, i.e., we have (5.2)
(u,H0u) real and s0
,
for every u E dom H0
.
This implies that H0 has self-adjoint extensions. A distinguished such extension H , called the Friedrichs extension, may be constructed using a rather simple form-closing principle (cf.
[Ka1],[RN],[Wm1],[Yo1], or [C2],I, thm.2.7 ). To express the above in different terms: H is also a linear
0.6. Exponentiating a fast order operator
31
H We have (5.2) for H instead of HO, but H is maximal with respect to this property: No proper extension of H still satisfies (5.2). This maximality has important consequences: Any operator H satisfying (5.2) must be hermitian. A maximal such operator must be self-adjoint- it possesses a spectral measure, as we will not discuss here. Moreover, it follows that the unbounded operator K= 1-H is invertible in the following sense: There exists a continuous operator R E L(H), called K 1 = (1-H)-1, such that R:H-> dom H C H is a bi-jection inverting the linear map K:dom H -> H . Accordingly, due to existence of the inverse R, it follows that the linear equation (5.3)
(1-H)u = f
,
f E H ,
admits one and only one solution u E dom H C H , for every f E H After this abstract discussion we now ask: Does u of (5.3),
a function of H whose existence is shown by a chain of abstract arguments, solve the differential equation u-Au=f ? Also, does u satisfy any kind of boundary condition? The corresponding question is meaningful not only for A but for any smooth differential expression a(x,D) defined in sa such that the corresponding operator L0: C0 ->C0C H satisfies (5.2).
For general a(x,D), with the Friedrichs extension L of LO
,
the unique uE dom. LC H solving (1-L)u=f, for given fE HC L'loc(n) C Du(st) is a distribution solution of u-a(x,D)u =f, since
(u,c)-a(x,D)"cp) = (u,g)-((Lu) that (Lu,T)=(u,a(x,D)p), gE D(st)=CO(st)
q,ED(R), using
Question: (a) If, in addition, we have fE C"(c), will u be smooth - and a classical solution of u-a(x,D)u=f? (b) If, in addi-
tion, st has a smooth boundary r, and fE COO(clLE') , will also u be C0O(szlf), and will it satisfy boundary conditions?
For a(x,D)=A both questions have a positive answer. In particular, u must satisfy the Dirichlet condition u=0 on r. The same remains true if a(x,D) is elliptic and of second order (cf. ch.5). Generally, if a(x,D) is hypoelliptic the answer to (a) will be
positive. An answer to (b) is given in V,4. We speak of a concept called boundary hypoellipticity, in that respect. 6. Exponentiating a first order partial differential operator.
In this section we discuss the formal linear operator e, G
32
0. Introductory discussions
with a first order differential expression (a 'folpde') (6.1)
G
=1 b3a+ j
=
p
, j= aa/a x
J
with real Co coefficients bj(x) j=1,...,n, and complex-valued p()E C, all defined in some domain S2 C &n. By definition eG will ,
be the solution operator of the initial-value problem
(6.2)
atu=au/at =Gu , xES2 , to 0 , u=u0 , t = 0
,
C00
i.e., u(x,t)=eGtuo(x), uoE (12), is the unique solution of (6.2). The single first order PDE atu=Gu becomes an ODE along certain curves, called characteristic curves, defined as solutions of a system of ODE's, the system of characteristic equations, (6.3)
t'
= 1
xI = -bj(x)
,
,
j = 1,...,n
,
" " = d/ds
for (t(s),x(s))=(t(s),x1(s),...,xn(s)) with real-valued functions t,xj of a parameter s. The first equation (6.3) gives t-s=c=const. Thus set t=s, reducing (6.3) to the autonomous system (for xj(t)) (6.4)
-bj(xl,...,xn)
,
j = 1,...,n
d/dt .
,
Since the functions bj(x) are real-valued and Coo it is clear that the orbits (i.e. the curves in Sz, given by the parametric repre-
sentation x=x(t), for x(t) solving (6.4)), provide a family of nonintersecting smooth curves covering the entire domain R . A solution x(t) with x(0)=x0 will exist in a maximal interval Ost
where either t0=oo or x (t) E St\K for tE [ tK, t0 ) for every compact set KC Sz with some tK
.
In particular t0=co whenever for every
t1>0 a compact set Kt C Sz can be found such that the 'apriori
estimate' x(t)E Kt x(t) solves (6.4)
,
as 0stst,, can be verified from the fact that
and x(0)=x0. An orbit may degenete to a point,
or, may be closed -i.e., x(t) may be periodic. The relation between (6.2) and (6.3) is this: A function uE
C1, defined for (t,x) near (t° ,x° ), x°E S2, solves the PDE (6.2) if and only if along every solution curve (t,x(t)) of (6.3) the composite function u(t,x(t))=y(t)
solves the ODE
(6.5)
Y(t)=p(x(t))
dt = Y(t)q ,
Indeed, atj(t) _ -b.(x(t)) implies that
EbJulx )(t,x(t))
(6.6)
J
j
Hence if u solves (6.2), we will get (6.5) along every curve x(t)
0.6. Exponentiating a first order operator
33
for which the composition u(t,x(t)) is defined. Vice versa, if u(t,x) is a function defined and C1 near (t°,x°) such that p(t) satisfies (6.5) for every curve x(t) solving (6.4) in some neighbourhood of x°
Then u(t,x) solves (6.2) near (t°,x°).
.
Let u(O,x)=uo(x) be given for all xE St. Then a unique solution u(t,x) of (6.2) may be constructed as follows: At each x°E $1
construct the solution x(t) of (6.4) through x°, defined for a maximal t-interval (t-,t+), tt=t(x°). Define y(t)=p(x(t), and p(t)= u0(x°)exp{ f y(r)dt}, tE (t-,t+). Then set u(t,x(t))
(t) along
0
the curve x=x(t), tE (t-,t+), and do this for all such curves.
Assume that we have t+=tao for every x° E 12. Then the map x° x(t°,x°) defined by following the orbit through x° from t=O to t=
t° defines a diffeomorphism v,to :S2
n. Indeed, this map S2-S2 is 1-1
-
by construction, and it may be inverted by solving the reverse initial-value problem (follow x(t) through x° for a t-interval of length t° in negative t-direction). The map vt is Coo by standard results of dependence of solutions of an ODE on initial values. We thus obtain a 1-parameter family F = {vt : tE &} of diffeomorphisms vt St - St having the group property :
(6.7)
,
V
to nt
= nt+t
,
t' t E 1e
,
since following the curves for t+t units has the same effect than following first for t then for t units.- Such a group of diffeomor-
phisms is commonly called a flow. The flow defined by (6.4) is called the characteristic flow of the PDE (6.2) In this terminology we have proven: Theorem 6.1. Assume that all solutions of the characteristic sys-
tem (6.4) extend for tE
Then the
problem (6.2) has a uni-
que solution u(t,x)E Coo(&xn), for uoE C00(SZ), where u is given by (6.8)
ft(pov-t)(x)dt}
u(t,x) =
0
Indeed our above description of u(t,x) translates to (6.8). In particular the diffeomorphism vt is inverted by v-t, hence u is defined for all x E 12 and all t and (6.8) follows. ,
Note that (6.8) establishes an abelian group {etG
linear maps etG:C"O(S2)-C00(St) (6.9)
, defined by
etGuO(x) = u(t,x)
We also have
,
u0 E C'(c)
,
t e & .
:
tE le} of
0. Introductory discussions
34
etG
(6.10)
:
CO(Sc) - CO(SZ) ,
tE&
The relation between equations (6.2) and (6.4) remains invariant under a coordinate transform of 11, i.e., the characteristic
equations (6.4) go into those of the transformed equation (6.2). Accordingly theorem 6.1 also holds for a folpde G defined on a
differentiable manifold a with local representation (6.2) and assuming that characteristic equations locally given by (6.4) our condition remains satisfied - that all solutions of x'=-b(x), ,
regardless of the choice of initial value x°E n , extend into an infinite time interval, passing of x(t) between charts of different coordinates being permitted. Now we want to address the problem of finding a more concrete condition for the assumption of thm.6.1 that all solutions of the
characteristic system (6.3) extend indefinitely. Assume that a carries a Riemmannian metric ds2=EhJkdxJ,dxk, under which it is complete. Let d(x,x0) denote the distance from x to x0 on n . Proposition 6.2. Assume that the principal part tensor (b3) of the expression G of (6.1) satisfies the estimate (6.11)
Ib(x)I = {(Ehjkb3bk)(x)}1/2 = 0(1+d(x,x0)) , x E 11
,
with some fixed x0E n. Then all x(t) of (6.4) extend to -oc
.
Proof. By well known results on continuation of solutions of ODE'S it suffices to get an apriori estimate. Let x(t) solving (6.4) be
defined for tE [t0,t1] ,
x(to )=x°
.
y(t) is Lipschitz continuous in t (6.12)
Idy/dtl
s
Let y (t)=1+d(x° ,x(t)). We know and that
{Ehjkxj'xk'}1/2 = Ib(x(t))I = O(y(t))
,
noting that (6.11) trivially holds for each fixed x0 E n if it is valid for only one x0. Now (6.12) implies log y(t) =O(t-t0), or (6.13)
x(t) E {d(x,x0) s
ec(t-to)
-1 }
.
Since n is complete, the sphere (6.13) is compact for t=t1, and we have shown that x(t) stays in it. This proves the proposition. Now we look at G and eG in a Hilbert space H=L2(n,dµ), with (6.14)
(u,v) = fnuvdµ
,
IIu!I=
as inner product and norm, dµ denoting a positive Co measure on Q, C00 . We still assume that the chalocally of the form dµ=Kdx, 0<x(=-
0.6. Exponentiating a fast order operator
35
racteristic flow F is defined: All solutions of (6.4) extend indefinitely. Clearly the restriction GO=GICO(st) may be interpreted as unbounded operator G0 of H with domain dom G0 = CO(n).
Assume G skew-selfadjoint: with real-valued bj , p we have + ip
G = Ebjaj + 1/2 x- I(xbJ)
(6.15)
lx
Ij then G0 with domain CO(n) clearly is skew-hermitian: We have 00 (u,GOu) + (G0u,u) = 0
(6.16)
If u(t,x) solves (6.2)
,
, u E dom G0 = CO(ft)
for some u0E CO(sz), (6.10) implies that C00(1),
u(t,.)E D(st), for each fixed t. The y(t)=Ilu(t,.)III E (6.17)
and
dy/dt = (u,ult) + (ult,u) = (u,GOu) + (GOu,u) = 0 , tE t
Accordingly,
(6.18)
IletGuOII
= IIu(t,.)II = I1uOII = const., for all u0E Co(st).
This shows that the operator etG: CO(ft)-+CO(ft) defines an isometry
in the norm of H . Clearly this is an invertible isometry, using the group property of etG. Let us first assume that p of (6.15)
vanishes. Then v(x)=etGu0, for some fixed t, is of the form (6.19)
v(x) = (u0ox)(x)w(x)
,
x(x) = v-t(x)
,
with a real-valued positive Co°-function w(x) independent of u0, by (6.8), with p=(2x)-I(xbj)
.
1
x
From (6.18) and (6.19) we conclude
.
rf
(6.20)
11v112
=
I(u0w)(x(x))12dµ = .IIu0(x)12ds = IIu0II2,u0E Co.
With new integration variables y=x(x) in the first integral we get (6.21)
f11Iu0(x)I2(w2(x)(dµovt)/dµ
- 1) = 0
,
for all u0E Co(st).
But (6.21) implies that (6.22)
w(x(x)) = {(d1iov_t)/dµ}I/2
For p general, etGuO(x) will carry an additional exponential factor. All other functions remain the same. We have proven Proposition 6.3. For a skew-selfadjoint G (6.15) assumes the form Jt
(6.23)
etGuO() = ((u0,v_t){a1Lov_t/a1'}I/2)(x)exp{i
pov_z(x)dT}, 0
defining an invertible isometry COO-COO the sense of the norm of H
0. Introductory discussions
36
00
Then eGt:co->C 0 admits a continuous extension to H, a unitary
operator. We get a group {U(t)=(eGot)closure : tE &} of unitary operators, strongly continuous in t. Its infinitesimal generator (6.24) G1=dU/dt(0)
, dom GI={uE H: lim£-,o
U(£)E-u =G1u exists in H}
is a skew-selfadjoint realization of the folpde G , extending G0. eGot=CO
is dense in H. G1 is This realization is unique, since dom the closure of G0, and iG0 is essentially self-adjoint. Finally consider a dissipative expression G (i.e. GO+G*sO). G must have the form (6.15) with real-valued bj but complex p satisfying In p(x)a0, xE S. Hence (6.16) now assumes the form
(u,GOu)+(GOu,u) _ -Jdµ(Im p)lul2 s 0 , u E C,(a)
(6.25)
Under this assumption the map etGO
,
still of the form (6.23), is
a contraction under the norm of H, for t2t0, i.e., IleGtllsl, t2!0.
This follows by repeating the above argument. 7. Solving a nonlinear first order partial differential equation. In this section we are going to consider the Cauchy problem for a single first order partial differential equation (7.1)
F(x,u,p) = 0 , p = ulx = (ax u, ...
ax u) n
1
,
where F is a given real-valued Co'-function of the 2n+1 real varia-
bles x=(xi,...,xn) , u , p=(pi.... ,pn). For simplicity assume F
defined in
S2xlex1n, with some domain RC ten. Our main application
will be the characteristic equation (8.3), in sec.8, below. There F=aN(x,p) is independent of u and a homogeneous polynomial in p. The Cauchy problem seeks a solution of (7.1) satisfying an initial condition at some n-i-dimensional submanifold rC tt. Let I' be given by x=x(s), s=(si,...,sn-i)E EC &n-i, with ax/6s=((axj/asl)) of rank n-1. Require as initial condition that (7.1')
u(x(s)) = w(s) is given for s E E
.
Then differentiation of (7.1') for s) determines all tangential derivatives of u at r, while (7.1) gives an implicit relation for normal derivative of u. It is natural to assume that the n equations resulting for pj=ulxj locally admit precisely one solution, so that ulx is fully determined along the hypersurface E.
37
0.7. Solving a first order PDE
Thus it is convenient to assume not only u=w(s) but also p= given for sE E. Of course certain conditions on w(s),p(s) must ulx express the fact that p=ulx. In other words, we assume given x = x(s)
(7.2)
,
p = p(s)
, u = w(s)
,
E E
s
,
with ax/as of maximal rank n-1, while x(s), w(s), p(s) satisfy lp -aslx = aslw
(7.3)
,
s E E
,
1 = 1,...,n-1
(called the strip condition) and F(x(s),w(s),p(s)) = 0
(7.4)
,
s E I
.
A (2n+1)-tuple of functions (7.2) satisfying (7.3) is called an ((n-1)-dimensional) strip: The plane in (x,u)-space through the point (x(s),u(s)) with normal vector p(s) is tangential to the n-l-surface (x(s),u(s)) by condition (7.3). If in addition (7.4) holds, then we talk about an integral strip of (7.1). Instead of asking for a function u(x) satisfying (7.1) and (7.1') it is more convenient to ask for a solution of (7.1) extending a given n-i-dimensional integral strip (7.2). That is, (7.5)
u(x(s)) = w(s)
,
uIx(x(s)) = p(s)
,
s E I
.
Thus the Cauchy problem for (7.1) seeks to find u(x) satisfying (7.1) and (7.5) for a given 'initial integral strip' (7.2). We shall see that this reformulation already holds the key for a solution of the problem, while in fact only w(s) may be freely chosen in many cases, perhaps up to a finite choice of p(s). In sec.6 we already solved this problem for a linear equation (6.2). In the present more general setting the system of characteristic equations (6.3) or(6.4) must be replaced by the following: (7.6)
x =Flp(x,u,p), u =PFIP(x,u,P), p =-Flx(x,u,p)-pFlu(x,u,p),
with 'aF'_'''
This is a system of 2n+1 first order ODE's in 2n+1 unknowns x(t), u(t), p(t). The coefficients of (7.6) are Cw in x, u, p, independent of t, hence there exists a unique local solution .
defined for ltI<S for sufficiently small S, satisfying (7.7)
x(0) = x0
,
u(0) = u0
,
p(0) = p0
for arbitrary x0E St, u0E &, p 0 E 2n. The solutions may be extended as long as they stay inside szxIx&n. Their orbits fill SZxXxin as a
nowhere intersecting family of curves. Generally we assume that
0. Introductory discussions
38 (7.8)
Flp(x,u,P) # 0
(x,u,p) E 1 x & x In
,
.
Then the orbits are nondegenerate C° curves. Moreover, x=x(t) defines a nondegenerate Cc'--curve in x-space ien.
We claim that (x(t),u(t),p(t)) also may be interpreted as a 1-dimensional strip in (x,u)-space, along which F is constant. u=u(t) defines a Co curve E in (x,u)-space; at That is, x=x(t) (x(t),u(t))E 'E, the plane through that point with normal p(t), i.e7 ,
(7.9)
u - u(t) = Lj=1p(t)(x-x(t))
= P(t)-(x-x(t))
defines a plane tangent to EE at (x(t),u(t)). Indeed the vector
clearly lies in the plane (7.9). We get
(x (t),u
d/dt(F(x(t),u(t),p(t)) = Flxx + Fluu
+ Flpp
(7.10)
FIxFIP + FIu(pFIP) - FIP(Flx + PFIu) = 0 confirming that F is constant along the strips discussed. A characteristic integral strip is defined to be a 1-dimensio-
nal strip as described above,with the additional property that (7.11)
F(x(t),u(t),p(t)) = 0
along
8 .
For the construction of a solution of the Cauchy problem (7.1) and (7.5) we start from a given n-l-dimensional integral strip (7.2). For each (x(s),w(s),p(s)), sE E, we obtain the unique characteristic integral strip through (x,w,p). That is we construct (7.12)
x(s,t) = x(s1,...,sn-1,t)
w(s,t)
,
,
p(s,t)
s E E
,
solving (7.6) and the initial conditions (7.13)
x(s,0) = x(s)
,
w(s,0) = w(s)
,
p(s,0) = p(s)
The functions (7.12) exist only for (s,t) E no (7.14)
no = {(s,t)
:
s E E
,
Itl
with a suitable function ti(s) > 0
,
,
,
s E E
with
< t1(s)}
defined over E
.
Suppose the function x(s,t) can be inverted near t=O.Since we assume ax/as of maximal rank this means that ax/at=x at r, is ,
linearly independent of the ax/asj. In other words, the projection of the characteristic strip through (x(s),w(s),p(s)) onto x-space must never be tangent to r. Under this condition we call r an
0.7. Solving a fast order PDE
39
admissible initial integral strip. The implicit function theorem then implies that x(s,t) is invertible whenever the initial strip is admissible, and tl(s) is choosen sufficiently small. Let X(x)= (s(x),t(x)) denote the inverse. We claim that a solution of the Cauchy problem (7.1), (7.5) is defined by setting u
(7.15)
=
w,X
,
i.e., u(x) = w(s(x),t(x))
.
so that u(x)=u(x(s))=w(s) From (7.15) we get u(x(s,t)) = w(s,t) Differentiating this for sj and t , using (7.6) and the strip conditions (7.3) , we get Indeed for x e l' we have t = 0
,
.
.
(7.16)
p151
ulxjaslxj = asl = ulxjatxj
pjatxj
= atw =
(s,t) E I
,
i Since the Jacobian ax/a(s,t) is invertible, (7.16) implies that (7.17)
p(s,t) = ulx(x(s,t))
(s,t) E E
.
as xE r hence ulx(x(s)) =p(s). Hence we have (7.5) Also we know that F(x(s,t),w(s,t),p(s,t))= 0. Thus (7.15) and (7.17) imply that the PDE (7.1) is satisfied by u of (7.15) Thus indeed we solved the Cauchy problem. Next let us assume that u(x) satisfies (7.1) and (7.5) for an admissible strip (7.2) . We then may consider the system In particular we again get t=0
,
,
(7.18)
x
= Flp(x,u(x),ulx(x))
,
n'n = d/dt
of n first order ODE's in n unknowns x(t). Let y(s,t) solve (7.18) and the initial cdn's y(s,O)=x(s). Let K(s,t)= u(y(s,t)), q(s,t)= ulx(y(s,t)). We will show that y,K,q solves (7.6) with the same w(s,t) initial conditions as our constructed x(s,t) p(s,t) so that we must have x=y , K=w , p=q , for all sE I ltl
,
,
our previously constructed solution (7.15) of (7.1) and (7.5)
,
so
that we have uniqueness of the solution of this Cauchy problem. Indeed, from (7.18) get y =Flp(y,x,q), assuming u E C2. Also, F(x,u(x),ulx(x))=0 since u solves (7.1). Differentiating we get ,
(7.19)
Flx(x,u,ulx) + Flu(x,u,ulx) + Flp(x,u,ulx)ulxx = 0
.
In (7.18) let x = y(s,t). Then q= ulxx(y)Flp(y,K,q) =-Flx(y,K,q) - Flu(y,x,6)q so that indeed the system (7.6) for y,K,q follows We have proven the result below.
40
0. Introductory discussions
Theorem 7.1. Let r = {x(s) : s E E} be an n-l-dimensional C"-surface in In with local parametric representation, rank as/ax = n-1.
Then for every admissible integral strip (x(s),w(s),p(s)) over r the Cauchy problem (7.1),(7.5) admits a solution uE C°°(SZo), with
some neighbourhood r& of r. The solution is unique within C' (SL ). Remark 7.2. Suppose an n-l-dimensional surface r={xE c:ip(x)=V(x0)}
and F(x,p(x),Vlx(x))=O on r. Then, if x= is given, where VIx#O x(s) represents (some part of) r, we find that w(s)=p(x(s)), p(s)= ,
Vlx(x(s)) defines an n-l-dimensional integral strip of F. Suppose this strip is admissible. Then thm.7.1 yields a solution cp(x), de(x)=yrlx(x) on r. It folfined near r, such that p(x)=p(x), and l
at least locally. lows that r also is given in the form T = c This construction will be useful in sec.8, where we ask whe,
ther a characteristic surface always may be given as a surface of constancy of a solution cp of the characteristic equation (8.3).
However, a closer inspection shows that, for an equation (8.3) the above integral strip is never admissible: We get y=const on r , hence the surface normal is a multiple of iplx(x(s))=p(s) for all s
On the other hand, the projection of the characteristic integral strip at x(s) has direction x'=Flp(x(s),p(s)). Also, since F(x,p) =aN(x,p) of (8.3) is homogeneous of degree N in p , we get p.x' _ p.Flp(x(s),p(s))= NF(x(s),p(s))= 0 along a characteristic integral strip. Accordingly, x' must be in the tangent space of x(s), since it is perpendicular to the surface normal. 8.Characteristics and bicharacteristics of a linear PDE. The conventional approach to the concept of a characteristic (hyper-)surface for a differential expression (8.1)
a(x)Da a
L = a(x,D) = I
aTsK
is the Cauchy-Kowalewska theorem, discussing existence of a unique analytic solution for a PDE with analytic coefficients satisfying analytic initial data. The result directs the attention to certain surfaces along which data cannot be prescribed freely. The concepts also make sense for real-valued solutions of a PDE with real coefficients. However, one has to work with two different sets of assumptions: Either assume real Co coefficients or complex analytic coefficients. The latter case is mostly analogous to the real Co case, and will not be discussed in detail.
41
0.8. Characteristics
Accordingly we assume that L of (8.1) has complex C" coefficients, but that the coefficients of the principal part polynomial (8.2)
a
la =N
0
aa
are real-valued C°°(S), for a domain nC &n, up to a common factor O#yE C00(n) (here assumed 1). The characteristic equation of L is
aN(x,Cplx) = 0
(8.3)
,
with the gradient Tlx of T. Clearly (8.3) is a single first order PDE for the unknown (real-valued) function T(x)EE C00(tt).
In sec.7 we discussed solving such PDE. Since F(x,p,u)=aN(x,p) is independent of u, the characteristic system reduces to x
(8.4)
=
a system of 2n first order ODE for 2n unknowns x(s), F;(s), where we wrote (s) instead of p(s). The equation for u' of (7.6) is p'= NaN(x,(plx)=0, due to (8.3), using Eulers relation for the homogeneous function of degree N in plx). (7.6) splits into this equation and (8.4) to be solved separately. The integral strips are given as solutions of (8.4) together with g(s)=const. A system of the form (8.4) is commonly called a Hamiltonian system. The graph of a solution T of (8.3) is fibered strips x(s) (s) solving (8.4), cp=const.: Through any point (x°,g(x°)) on the graph there is a unique characteristic integral strip
with x(O)=x°
(x(s),c)(x° where
,
(0)=9Plx(x°
solves (8.4). In sec.7 we have seen how solut-
ions of (8.3)
may be composed of such strips. Moreover, since g is constant along such strips, it is clear that they stay on the same level surface of cp Thus also the level surfaces of solut.
ions are fibered by characteristic integral strips of (8.3). A characteristic (hyper-)surface r of the differential expression (8.1) is defined as a surface of constancy of a solution T of the characteristic equation (8.3), with PIx'O. To be precise we require that for every x°E I' there exists a solution T = q) x
(8.3), defined in B={Ix-x°l0 .
Actually one may define somewhat more generally by dropping the assumption that c(x) solves (8.3) near the surface t , and requiring (8.3) on the surface t only. It is clear from the above that a characteristic surface r is fibered by characteristic integral strips: There is precisely
of
42
0. Introductory discussions
one strip through each point x E r . These strips are called bicharacteristic strips of the expression L We speak of a simply characteristic surface r of the exprescplx(x)#0 sion L of (8.1) if r is given by cp(x)=0 with g(x)=0 .
,
,
aN(x,cplx(x))=0 on r , as above, and in addition aN1,(x,T,x(x))#0 on r . For a simple characteristic (surface) it is no loss of ecn-
erality to assume that p(x) solves (8.3) near r . Indeed, we may assume that (x°,c)lx(x°))#0, and then solaNI
ve aN(x,T;)=0 for ' . Get a function p, (x,n") with pi (x°
cplx(x° )" )=
gplx.(x°), where p =(p2,...,pn). The plane perpendicular to the integral strip through x°
is noncharacteristic near x°. In that pla-
ne 10 set w(x)=cp(x), p" (x)=cplx(x)- , with our given T(x) solving (8.3) on r near x° . Also set pi =p, (x,p" ). We get an admissible integral strip, and a solution w(x) near x°. We have w(x)=cp(x°) on the strip through x°. Also, w(x)=p(x)=cp(x°) on rn E0. Hence also
w(x)=q(x°)=c on the intersection with r of a small ball around x°. Thus w(x) indeed solves (3.3) and is constant on r near x°. A characteristic surface r along which Fly= aNI (x,Tlx)=0 will be called a multiple characteristic. An example of an expression with multiple characteristics is the heat operator (example b), below). For hyperbolic equations one tends to avoid multiple characteristics, introducing the concept of strictly hyperbolic expressions (cf. VII,2). An expression L having no multiple real characteritics is said to be of principal type (VII,2). As mentioned initially, characteristic surfaces are important for the initial-value problem of (8.1): For a given (hyper-) surface rC &n and given 'data' V. defined on r and f defined near r we ask for existence of u (defined near r such that (8.5)
Lu = f near r, u(a)= aau = 1pa, x(= r ,
for all lal s N-1
The bicharacteristic strips, on the other hand, will be recognized as carriers of singularities of solutions of Lu = f, (cf. ch.6, ch.9). The key result is our version of Egorov's theorem (V1,thm.5.1), accessible only after a study of i,do's. Solving (8.5), it is clear that not all functions 1ya may be prescribed arbitrarily. Assuming r and 1pa smooth, let v(x) be a
smooth transversal vector, defined (locally) near r, and never tangential to r, let us start prescribing arbitrarily the functions u=1p0 , Dvu = 1U1 , , DNu = 1IrN-1 , on r , where
...
(8.6)
43
0.8. Characteristics This will determine all u(a)
lals N-1, on r, as tangential deri-
:
vatives of the Vj: For some local parametric representation x=x(k) 'xn-1) of r the derivatives u(a)(x), xE T, become linear expressions in the derivatives a.yPj. Accordingly, Lu=f, along IT,
translates into a linear equation of the form pDNu
(8.7)
Now if q E C1 with (8.8)
+ Fpaaa j = f yd 0 is constant on F we find that
Tlx
= (TIxj/DvT)Dv + Tj
,
j = 1
,
...
n
,
ax7
with vector fields Ti satisfying T,T = 0 Substituting (8.8) into (8.1) one finds that p in (8.7) is given by .
(8.9)
(Dvq))-N
p=
I
a
-N aa(x)cplxa(x)
If p(x)p60 on t then (8.7) may be solved for DNu in some neigh-
bourhood of T. Moreover, we may apply Dv to the resulting equation for an infinite number of new relations of the form Dmu= linear exv pression in derivatives of lower order, allowing recursive calculation of all Dvu on F. Clearly this allows construction of a unique solution of (8.5) by its Taylor series, assuming that an analytic solution exists. The recursion may be used for estimates proving convergence of the Taylor series and existence of an analytic solution, if the coefficients are analytic. This sketches a proof of the Cauchy-Kowalewska theorem mentioned initially. Moreover the importance of the concept of characteristic surface is clear from the result below, the proof of which is evident, after the above.
Proposition 8.1. The function p(x) of (8.9) vanishes identically on t if and only if r is a characteristic surface. We get p#0 on t if and only if I' is nontangential to any characteristic surface.
To provide more detailed information on characteristic surfaces and bicharacteristics we return to some examples, mainly of sec.4. a) L = t
(8.10)
(of (4.1))
:
The characteristic equation
cpIx2
= Lj=1 'pIx2 = 0
has only constant real-valued solutions, since it requires TIxmo.
Real characteristic surfaces do not exist. However, A has constant (i.e., analytic) coefficients. The Hamiltonian system (8.4) may be regarded as a set of ODE for complex-valued analytic functions. There exist solutions of (8.10) in the n complex variables x1,..., Setting such q constant will give xn, defined in a domain of Tn .
0. Introductory discussions
44
surfaces in Cn, called complex characteristics. Notice that the Helmholtz operator (4.2) has the same principal part, hence the same real or complex characteristics as the operator A . b) L=at-A, in the n+1 variables x0=t, x=(xl,...,xn), (i.e., (4.3)) The characteristic equation is (8.10) again. But we now have one more variable t=x0. Thus (8.10) requires that cp(t,x) is independent of x, but it may depend on t. It follows that the characteri-
stic surfaces all are hyperplanes of the form t=const. Complex characteristics of more general kind may be constructed, of course In sec.4 we solved a modified Cauchy problem, of the form
(8.11)
Lu = f
,
t a t0
,
u = tV at t = t0
for f, WE Co. Only one condition at t=to
,
(instead of 2) is needed
to make the solution of this characteristic Cauchy problem unique. The real characteristics of L all are multiple characteristics: For c(t,x)=t-t0 we have cpjx (1,0), hence a2(glx)=a2101110=0c) L = at - A , (i.e., ex'le (4.4)) , again discussed in n+1 independent variables (t,x) The characteristic equation is .
(8.12)
WIt2 =
=
W1x2
=1 T1.
2
Being only interested in the surfaces T=const., for (WIt,WIx)#0 we may reduce the number of variables: (8.12) implies WIX 0 unless fIt#0.
Hence T=0 may locally be solved for t. Writing t=J(x), get
(8.13)
j=1 JIx,
2
2
= JIx
= 1
This equation is often referred to as the equation of geometrical optics, or the eiconal equation. The bicharacteristic strips (so-
lutions of (8.4), in this case) are straight lines x=at+b with constant a,bE Rn Ia1=1, and constant . The base curves of the bicharacteristic strips are the light rays of geometrical optics. The Cauchy problem (8.5) is well posed for the wave operator along non-characteristic surfaces (cf.sec.4 and ch.7.). Again the Klein-Gordon operator (4.5) has the same principal part and characteristics as the wave operator, and a similar Cauchy problem. d) L is an elliptic operator, with Coo-coefficients. That is, we have O. Again the characteristic equaas xE cz, E n, tion (8.3) implies cplx=0 assuming T real-valued. Real characteristics do not exist. Complex characteristics again may be defined only if the as are analytic in xl,...oxn . ,
e) L = P(D) is a constant coefficient hyperbolic operator (cf. VII,!), with respect to some given real vector h# 0. As a conse-
0.9. Lie groups and Lie algebras
45
quence of VII, prop.1.5. the principal part PN(U) also is a hyperbolic polynomial: We have PN(h)#0, and the algebraic equation for fixed real , has N not necessarily distinct real roots X., j=1,...,n . The characteristic equation is of the form PN((plx)=0. For simplicity let h=(0,...,0,1), as always may be achieved by a linear transformation of independent variables. Then the characteristic equation decomposes into the N equations (8.15)
with
TIxn = tj(roIx1,...,(' Ixn-1)
t
0
the real solutions of
=
for
,
_
In the presence of multiple roots we cannot expect that the
tj depend smoothly on 1If smoothness can be arranged then each of the N equations (8.15) will give its own family of characteristic surfaces and bicharacteristics. Thus one may expect N different types of characteristics for an N-th order expression. The N different types of real characteristics do exist if the N roots
are all distinct, for=(1
0)#0. Then
the t. will be smooth. In this case P(D) is called strictly hyper-
bolic (cf. VII,2). We shall see in ch.7 that the Cauchy problem (8.5) is always well posed, even for variable coefficients, if L is strictly hyperbolic. For constant coefficients the Cauchy problem of a general hyperbolic L is well posed (cf. [Gai], [Hri]). 9. Lie groups and Lie algebras, for classical analysts. Let us discuss the relationship between a Lie group G and A, its Lie algebra, using a form suitable for analysis minded readers.
Generally, G may be represented on some GL(1N) (we will not show this, although the tools are developed). For simplicity let G be a Lie subgroup of GL(1N), as will be true for all our applications. A path ip(t), Itl
the path gV(t) starts at g and (gi(t))'=0'(t) with matrix product. Let y:U- G, or explicitly, y=y(u), y(0)=e, be a charted neighbourhood of e, with an open set UC 1v, v=dim G, OE U. For a gE G the function yg=gy(u), uE U, defines a charted neighbourhood of g. The 'partial derivative' ylu is defined as directional deri7
vative along the coordinate line uk=const, k#j, uj=t (i.e., of) Similarly for ygluj
.
0. Introductory discussions
46
In these coordinates the tangent space at e=y(O) (i.e., the corresponding Lie algebra A) consists of all a=(a3) E &v, representing the matrix Aa = 2aJylu j(0). We get 1-1-correspondences Av= A H {Aa:aE Av} H {a(g):aE &v} with the vector field a(g) def i-
ned by using the same aE my in the local coordinates yg at g :
a(g)=jajyglu (0)
.
- i.e.,
a(g) defines a global folpde La on G
J
a(yg(u))=La(yg(u)), with La, in coordinates y(u), near e, given by
La D Y.A30
( 9 . 1 )
1
(u,O))Y(u)a/aul, where 9(u.v)=Y(Y(u)Y(v)), j
j
similarly for general g with yg . Again A **IL a:aE Av}
,
aE A appears in 4 forms, as a v-vector (a3), a matrix Aa folpde La on G , or again as a(g)=2ajygluj (0)=gAg
so that ,
or a
.
For aE A define a smooth curve V(t) in G as solution of
3 = a(p(t))
(9.2)
,
t near 0
,
V(O) = e
Locally, (9.2) constitutes a system of v ODE's of order 1, with real C"-coefficients. Its Cauchy problem (9.2), even at to instead 0, is uniqely solvable. In fact, (9.2) amounts to y1'=Aa V(0)=e, with the above Aa, and matrix multiplication. This is trivially ,
solved by the exponential function y,(t)=exp(Aat)=F`oAajtj/j!
. By a
continuation argument get yi(t)=exp(Aat)E G , and (9.2) for tE I In particular, {yi(t)} defines a subgroup of G. We summarize:
Proposition 9.1. For each tangent vector aE A=Te(G) there is a iparameter subgroup P(t)=Pa(t), tE 1, defined as unique solution of the Cauchy problem (9.2), with a(g)wLa of (9.1). Corollary 9.2. The connected component GeCO of the unit element e is generated by all the above 1-parameter subgroups, and even by {Va(t): aE A , 0st5s}
,
for any fixed s>0
.
Indeed, any gE Ge may be connected to e by a path r , and F may be replaced by a 'polygon' with sides translates of 'lines' Ostsr's for fixed aE A. This shows that, indeed, g= Va(t),
,
Va 1 (E1)Va (E2) .... Va (Em) 2 M
,
for finite M and sjss.
47
0.9. Lie groups and Lie algebras Corollary 9.3.
(9.3)
We have A t
Va(t) = e a
=
A,,3/j!
,
Aa = Va.(0)_EalY luj(0)
A
The subgroup Ge is generated by all e at, aE A, OO Completing the structure of A, we define a bracket operation: Consider the commutators [Aa,Ab]= AaAb-AbAa and [LaLb]=LaLb LbLa of the matrices and (matrix-valued) first order expressions, resp. Get y(u)y(v)=y(9(u,v)), near u--v=0, with 0(u,v) of (9.1). Differentiating this conclude that [y lu (0),Ylu (O)]= 2jcjlYlu (0) 1
r
r
, with
xjl = 9rlu v (0,0)-9rlu (0,0) . Accordingly, v 7 1 1 j
(9.4)
is 1ajbl)
[AaAb]=Ac , c = (cr)=(
again belongs to the tangent space of G C GL(IN) at g=e. Next, [LaLb] is a first order expression: LetipdI()=11aO v (u,0)Y(u) jl k
The matrices pj(u), ql(u) commute for uE U, hence (9.1) yields
(9.5)
[LaLb]= j71(Pjglluj-gjplluj)au1
At u=O get pj=aJe qj=b3e , 0(O,v)=v , hence 0 1Iv (0,0)=Olk Thus k {q+}lu.(0)={ij (9.6)
}Ylu.(0)+E{bkPllvku,(0,0).
We get
j(pjgllu-gjplluj) _ 7,(ajbl-bjal)Ylu=b1Aa-alAb
with our above Aa, using the symmetry dllu
v k=01lvjuk, at u=v=O.
Accordingly, [La,Lb]Y(0)=I(b1Aa-a1Ab)Ylu1-AaAb AbAa [Aa,Ab]=LcY(0) The argument may be repeated at general gE G , using Yg(u) instead Y(u). One finds that [La,Lb]Yg(0)=Lcyg(O) for all gE G , with c of (9.5) . Accordingly Ac **L , under our 1-1-correspondence. ,
c
This induces a bracket operation in the Lie algebra A, given by
(9.7)
[a,b] H[Aa,Ab]= Ac H[LaLb] = Lc
,
c of (9.5)
.
[.,.] has the usual properties, skew-symmetry, and Jacobi identity. Next we assume given a Lie matrix algebra - i.e., a linear subspace A of some L(IN ) containing all of its (matrix-) commutaProp.9.1 and cor.9.2 tors [A,B]=AB-BA, A,BE A. Assume dim A = v .
0. Introductory discussions
48
then suggest a direction of approach for generation of a corresG should contain ponding Lie group G - a Lie subgroup of GL(in) all matrices eAt, tE &, AE A, and all their finite products. It should be closed under matrix multiplication and inversion. Here :
we are only interested in connected Lie groups (i.e. might get only the component of 1 of a larger group). In fact we will look at the minimal such set - all finite products of eAt, AE A, tE k Observe that Vt = eAteBt , for A, B E A , no longer defines a 1-parameter group, unless A and B commute. For general A, B we will prove the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula: For small Iti ,
Vt = eC(t)
(9.8)
,
where C(t) E A
is a convergent power series in t (cf. lemma 9.5, below). As a first step in this direction: Proposition 9.4. Vt satisfies the differential equation (""'="dtit) (9.9)
Vt'
- (A+eAtBe-At )Vt
,
where the coefficient A+eAtBe-At E A is a convergent power series.
Proof. (9.9) follows trivially by differentiation. Also, the family Bt = eAtBe-At satisfies the differential equation
Bt' = adA Bt
(9.10)
B0 = B
,
,
with the linear operator
(9.11)
adAB = [A,B]
,
adA E L(L(&N) )
Therefore,
(9.12) Bt
eadAtB = L4=Q. (adA) JB = B+[ A, B] t+[ A, [ A, B] ] 22 +...
showing that Bt E A
,
hence A+Bt E A
,
,
q.e.d.
We will prove (9.8) in the following form. Lemma 9.5.
For A , B E A , define C=C(t) = log(eAteBt) by setting
C(t) = X(t)-X(t)2/2+X(t)3/3 t...+(-1)kX(t)k/k t.... (9.14)
with
X(t) = eAteBt-1 = (I+At+A22,+...)(1+Bt+B22l+...) -1
.
Then we have a convergent power series expansion (9.15)
C(t) = log(eAteBt) _
1C.t3
,
Itl< (log 2)/(IIAII+IIBII)
where C(t) and all coefficients Ci belong to the Lie algebra A
49
0.9. Lie groups and Lie algebras In particular,
(9.16)
C1= A+B
C2= 2 A, BI
,
,
C3= 2[A,[A,B]]+
2[B,[B,A]]
The coefficient Cj is a finite linear combination of terms which are applications of (together j-1) operators adA or adB to A or B. Proof. We use a proof of D.Djokovic [Dj] (we owe to G. Hochschild) Let C(t)=log(eAteBt) , defined as composition of
the logarithmic power series and X(t)=' 1XjtJ
matrix coefficients cj1 of C(X) = log X = >
Note that the
.
1(-1)iXJ/j are con-
vergent power series in the N2 complex variables xjk , where X=((xjk))j,k=1,...,N whenever IIX(t)II<1. The latter holds for I
eIIAIItellBIIt_1=e(IIAII+IIBII )t_1<1
i.e.,
,
(IIAII+IIBII )t < log 2
.
Thus cjl are complex differentiable functions of the N2 complex variables xjk , which in turn are power series of t . This implies complex differentiability of the function C(t) for t as in (9.15). So C(t) is a convergent power series and (9.15) follows. We are only left with showing that the coefficients Cj belong to A . The first coefficient (cf. (9.16)) is easily verified by direct computation. For the general case we will show that C(t) solves an ODE ((9.18), below) which leads to a recursion for the Cj. ,
(Cm),Ck
We calculate that (eC)'e C = = 1=0 N(-!k,)l
(
1)n-m
1 (Cm),Cn-m (n-m)'m.
1
X00
x-n
=ten=1 n!=1(-1)
1
m
Ik
Here, (Cm)'= I_Oh C'Cm-k-1 (_1)n m-1(m+1)CkC,Cn-k-1
= min=01-k=0 CkC'Cn-k-1Zk
=k(-1)n-m-l(m+n
1) _
7t1- =0CkC'Cn-k-1
n-k-1= (_1)n-1-k(n-1) =0
(n)(Cm),Cn-m
I -II
1 namn
n-m(m)(C n m)'C n-m
the inner sum equals Tn
=
7
k
, where Zk =
, by induction. We get T n =
4_01
CkC'Cn-k-l(-1)n-1-k(nk1 )
(9.17)
' 1n!(ad C)n-IC' = (eC)'e-C = Vt'Vt 1 = A + eCBe-C
_ (ad C)n-IC' whence
Thus
50
0. Introductory discussions
ad using (9.9) and eC=eAteBt=Vt. With (9.12) we get eCBe-C= e C B The left hand side of (9.17) may be written as f(adC)C' with the power series f(ey)=
1n-1/n! =(ex-1)/x . Notice that
is a power series too. Applying it to (9.17) yields the desired differential equation ad (9.18) CO = g(adC)(A + e C B)
Expanding both sides of (9.18) we get Cl-
' 1(n+l)Cn+ltn
while the right hand side may be written in the form g(L1 tkadc )A + h(
k
tkadC )B
h(x)=g(x)ex
,
k
The coefficient of the k-th power of t , at right, is a finite linear combination of a finite number of applications of adC to j
A or B , where js k . In fact, the sum of all j in each such term equals k . We know that C1E A . If we assume by induction that C1,...,CkE A, it follows that (k+l)Ck+l E A , hence Ck+IE A
Also
Ck+l must be a linear combination of k applications of adA and adB to A or B , as stated. The proof is complete. Corollary 9.6.
and let A(u)=
Let All... ,A, be a basis of A (as a linear space), "J=1Ajuj
, ujE 1 . There exist v power series
fk(u,v) k=1,...,v in 2v variables u,v convergent for IuMvI« 0 with some e0>0 such that fk(u,v) = uk+vk + ... , k=1,...,v , and eA(u)eA(v) = eA(f(u'v))
(9.19)
juI,IvI<s0 ,
.
eA(u)eA(v) _ Proof. As in the proof of lemma 9.5 we conclude that eC(u,v) where C(u,v) is a convergent power series in u and v as IIA(u+v)ll
0.9. Lie groups and Lie algebras
51
its unit element I equals the Lie-algebra A . And, vice versa, if we depart from a general Lie-subgroup G of GL(&N), then define A as the linear space of all directional derivatives of curves in G starting at I and then, with this A, defining the above group G(A) , we get G = G(A) ,
.
First let us establish a coordinate chart for a neighbourhood of the identity I E =-G . With the notations of cor.9.6 define (9.20)
Y (u) =
eu' A, +u?. A2 ...+u, A,=
A(u)
ul<s
0
where EO>O is kept fixed. Then y(u) defines an invertible map of the ball BED {lul<E} onto a set UIC G containing I, and y(0) = I For general GE G similarly YG(u) = y(u)G defines a map of B. onto a subset UG C G with G=YG(0) E UG . Introduce a topology on G by using all the "balls" yG(BE) 0<ESE0, GE G as a basis. Then each ,
set UG is an open neighbourhood of G . Let UG fl UG, eA(u0)=eA(v0)Z
9.6 we get Z =
,
Z=GG'-1E G
,
eA(f(u-v)) 0 0
for some u0
,
v0 E BE
Then . Using cor.
, assuming E0 properly chosen.
Notice that f(u,v) = 0 can be solved for v near u=v=0 giving a function v=v(u) , v(0)=0 since the Jacobian flv(0,0)=I is invertible. It follows that also flu(u0,-v0) is invertible, so ,
,
f(u,-v)=f(u0,-v0) may be solved for v giving an analytic map vv(U) v(u0)=u0 , provided that u0, v0 are sufficiently small,i.e., that e0 is chosen sufficiently small. Conclusion: ,
Z = eA(f(u0,-v°) =eA(f(u,-v(u)) =eA(u)e-A(v(u)) for u close to uO.
Or, YG() = YG,(v(u)) for small lu-u0l showing that the map
YG'-1°YG : YG 1(UG(l;JG')
->
YG'-1 (UG"JG, )
is analytic. Thus indeed,
this imposes a manifold structure (and a topology) onto G making
it a Lie Group. Every finite product Thai , BiE A may be connected to I, by the path 17etBi, Osts1, hence G is connected. Evidently, the tangent space of G at I (i.e.,the space of all directional derivatives of curves in G starting at I) coincides with A . Thus, indeed, we established a 1-1-correspondence between the connected Lie subgroups of GL(2N) and the Lie subalgebras of L(&N),
Chapter 1. CALCULUS OF PSEUDO-DIFFERENTIAL OPERATORS
0. Introduction.
In this chapter we deal with the details of pseudo-differential operator calculus. We follow a presentation in a lecture of 1974/75 [CP], inspired by the local approach of Hoermander [Hr:],
dealing with operators on Rn, for didactical reasons. Replacing asymptotic expansions of [CP] by Leibniz formulas with integral reminder of 1.5 is an improvement we learned from R.Beals [Bi] who uses 'weight functions' more general than our (x)()ml of (3.2). Still asymptotic expansions are needed, and will be studied in 1.6. We will discuss 4 different representations of ido', referenced as a(x,D)=a(M1,D), a(Mr,D), a(M1,Mr,D), and a(Mw,D), the first two corresponding to the left and right multiplying of Kohn and Nirenberg [KN], and the others to a representation of Friedrichs [Fr3], and the Weyl representation. The reader who dislikes the infinitely repeated formal discussions has our sympathy. For other approaches to the same subject cf. ch.7 where the 4do's of certain symbol classes are identified as operators on H=Lz(&n), smooth under action of certain Lie
subgroups of U(H). Or else, cf. [ C1] and [C2], where regular and singular elliptic boundary problems are approached with tools of C*-algebras, avoiding entirely the ado-calculus. The calculus presented generalizes formal calculus of differential operators. We get a collection of Frechet algebras containing differential operators, with formulas for product and adjoint like Leibniz formulas, containing generalized inverses (so-called Green inverses) of their elliptic and hypo-elliptic operators, as seen in ch.II. The algebras are 'graded': Each of their operators has a differentiation (m,) and a multiplication (m:) order. We will get the same Fredholm theory in Sobolev spaces as *
provided abstractly, using C -algebras, in [C,],III,IV.
1. Definition oftpdo's. In this section (and occasionally later on) we will write a(M) for the multiplication operator u(x)-a(x)u(x). More generally, for
52
1.1. Definition
53
a pseudo-differential operator generated from a 'symbol'
E
C00 (1e3n),
with
ten
, we will write a(M1,Mr,D) to indicate
an order of operation: Multiplication corresponding to the x-(y-) variable is carried out to the left (to the right) of the differentiation D of the a-variable, hence "M " (hence "Mn') "(cf. cor.2.3). 1
C'(&3n) satisfying
Introduce the space ST of all ( 1 . 1 )
)x(k).((x,Y))X(1)IaI+I1Isk,
0((
with nondecreasing x(k),X(l)
,
(1.2)
j)
IYIs1
k,1=0,1,..., such that
= limj.(?(j) - j) = -0°
Here, and in all of the following, we use the abbreviation
(z) = (1 + IzI2)1/2 (particularly ((x,y))=(1 + x2 + (1.4)
,
z E 1em
y2)1/2) Another useful shorthand:
Ox = (2n)-n/2dx ,
0 _ (2n)-n/2d
measures over ten. The functions of ST are called symbols. For aE ST define a linear operator A=a(M1,Mr,D) called pseudodifferential operator (t,do) with symbol a by setting, with integrals over ien, (1.5)
(Au)(x) =
J4j
u(y)
y
The precise meaning of (1.5) is clarified in thm.1.1, below.
Theorem 1.1. The right hand side of (1.5) is well defined, for uE S, xE &n, in the following sense: The integral f ¢y exists as improper Riemann integral, for >en. It supplies a C(2")-function I. For fixed xE &n, I(x,.) E L'(&n), and f A defines a function v=AuE S=S(&n). Moreover, the map A:S-'S is continuous S->S.
Proof. Clearly
Jyiy
exists as descri-
u(y)
bed, since the exponential is bounded, while is of polynomial growth in y,for fixed x, so that a useful -estimate one uses the identity (1.6) ei (x-Y)
(x-Y)
=
m=0,1,2,..., with the Laplace operator Ay =
. A partial inte-
32 J
7
gration for fdy is applied over a finite ball. The boundary terms
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
54
die out, as the ball tends to In, by (1.1) and uE S. This yields -2m
(1.7)
JAlY
In the following we shall say that a given expression is 'in the span' of another given set of expressions, if it is a finite linear combination with complex coefficients of these expressions. For example, the integrand of (1.7) is in the span of ei (x-Y)(Da a)(x,Y,t)u(R)(Y)
(1.8)
,
Ial + I1I s 2m.
Note that we get
(1.9)
Pap
using (1.1) and the decay of uE Sfr, where q may be arbitrary. Thus
(1.10)
I(x,T) = 0( (
)K(2m)-2m J((x,Y))"(0)(Y)-q
dy ).
.0) to A substitution y = (x) y- , dy = (x) ndy brings 'f 11 in (1 c=rr1J(Y)%(0)-q (1.11) (x) ,(0)+nffJ(Y)1(0)(1+(x)2lyl2)-q/2s c(x)X(O)+n, Therefore
(0)+n
(1.12)
and, with (1.2), it now is evident that (1.13)
J a
P1
exists as an improper Riemann integral
for all x.The estimate
x(2m) - 2m < -n-Ial
(1.14)
holds for large m. It insures that I(x,.)E L'
,
for all fixed X.
For a=o this proves the first assertion of the theorem. Let us clarify the dependence of (1.12) on the function u
Lemma 1.2. We have
(1.15)
II(x, )I s cllullk ( )K(2m)-2m(x)X(o)+n
0 with c depending on m and aE ST, but not on uE S, where the norms (1.16)
IIulik = suPlalsk,xE
R"' II(
x)ku(a),LOD
of S are used. This lemma is clear, since Iu(a)(x)IsIIuIIk(x)-k, xE In, Ialsk,
55
1.1. Definition
estimates u(a) by IxI-q, as the only way, u enters (1.12). Let us prepare a few other simple lemmata for thm.1.1. ST, for Lemma 1.3. For a E ST we get aaSY=DaDYDYaE ST and any polynomial P=P(x,y,l;). With x,a. of(1.2) for a, corresponding
functions for aaPy and P- a are is (j+ a + 3 I) , ?. (j+ Y I) , and is (j+L) , X(j+M), resp., with the -degree L and (x,y)-degree M of P. The verification of Lemma 1.3 is left to the reader. Lemma 1.4. The integral at right of (1.5) defines a Cc°-function
of x denoted by v . Moreover, the derivatives v(a) may be calculated under the integral signs of (1.5). Proof. Notice that is in the span of (1.17)
a + y =
By lemma 1.3 we have aDXa(x,y,l;)E ST. For an induction proof one only must show existence of the first derivatives and differentiability under the integral sign for 101=1. Let qE L'1L (B), supp cp
CC & . Using (1.12) and Fubini's theorem (twice) we get .
Jdxjq(xj)JdjdY (1.18) f
DO = -iaxj
where we set cp
X
[a,t]
,
the characteristic function of [a,t]. The
inner integral at right of (1.18) may be calculated explicitly. A differentiation of (1.18) for t will give the desired result.
Lemma 1.5. For aEST and every multi-index y we have
(1.19)
fdjdy
u(y)
r
_ (-1)YfdjdY u(y)
Proof. By the second identity (1.6), (1.19) is a matter of partial integration, carrying the differentiation from the exponential to
But the interchange of
fd
and fdy is generally im-
possible, so that we will require the argument, below. 1) It suffices again to assume jYl = 1, by lemma 1.3. 2) A conclusion as in lemma 1.4 may be used to verify that fdjdyaj{u(Y)ei(x-Y)a(x,Y,U)}=fda jfdyu(Y)eit(x-Y)a(x,Y,)
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
56
3) The right hand side of (2) is zero, because boundary integrals vanish, by (1.12). Thus (2) yields (1.19) for IyI=1, q.e.d.
Proof of thm.l.l (continued). Let v = Au, u E S, as defined by (1.5). Lemma 1.4 implies (1.21)
xav(p)(x) = f41JoY
where the right hand side is in the span of 6+s=a, a+t=(3.
(1.22)
(x-Y) = in (1.22) we may integrate by Using Dxel parts, in the inner integral, to obtain expressions in the span of
fd (1.23)
6+s=a, a+T=p, X+µ+v=a Note We also applied lemma 1.5 and another partial integration that IF.-µIskEIs IaI, and ITI+IvIS ItI+IaI=lpi Hence lemma 1.2 and lemma 1.3 give an estimate of (1.22) by
fd
(1.24)
Accordingly xav(p)(x) also is bounded by (1.24). Applying this for all IaI s 1 for some integer 1, we get ,
(1.25)
Iv(p)(x)I s
)x(2m+IPI)-2m
cO(x)n+k(1)-lllulik
,
Here m , 1 are integers, but m must be chosen large enough to insure existence of the integral in (1.25), by (1.2). Also, co
and k depend on the choice of m,l and p, but not on u. Using (1.2) it follows that for 10 there exists k, c0 independent of u with
(1.26)
s 0OIIulik , u E S
IIAuII1 0
Clearly this amounts to continuity of a:S-'S and thm.1.1 is proven. 2. Elementary properties of y,do's.
Theorem 2.1. Let (2.1)
(u,v) = f n u(x)v(x)Ax , u,v E S
Then we have, for all a E ST , (2.2)
(a(M1,Mr,D)u,v) = (u,a(Mr,Ml,-D)v)
,
for all u,v E S
,
1.2. Elementary properties
57
with A"=a(Mr,Ml,-D), the 4do with symbol a Proof. Clearly a-(=- ST as aE ST. The statement is a matter of inte-
L1(&2n), vE S, by lemma 1.2.
gral interchanges. Get Hence (v,Au)
foJoyfpix ... =
f oyfRi f 41x ...
_
(u, A" v)
,
for A = a(M1,Mr,D) , with a 3-fold application of Fubini's theorem and a substitution (y,x,-l;) of variables, q.e.d. A" will be called the distribution ad joint (or dual) of the operator A, (to be distinguished from the 'formal Hilbert space ad joint' A*, formed with the inner product (u,v) = f uvdx ). Note: *
A = a(Mr,Ml,D)
(2.3)
Since A=a(M1,Mr,D) is strongly continuous S-'S, by thm.1.1, an extension B : S' - S' of A : S - S is given by
(2.4)
u E S'
(Bu,c)) = (u,A (p)
,
(P E S
,
with (u,cp), the value of uE S' at TE S. In other words, we may regard the ',do either as operator S-S or, S'-S'. Thm.2.1 gives AC B. Generally we will not distinguish in notation between the operators A and B but will regard a 'pdo as an operator A:S'-'S' with ,
AIS mapping to S. In fact, 'pdo's more or less will be regarded
like differential expressions in [C2],II with domain to be fixed.
Theorem 2.2. ST is an algebra of complex-valued functions under pointwise addition and multiplication, with (real) involution a-a; Proof. Evidently ST is closed under "+", """, and scalar product. Note that DaDyDY(ab) is in the span of (2.5), by Leibniz' formula: (2.5)
xy
(Da'DR'DY'a) (Da"DR11DYlob) x y i
,
a'+a"=a , l'+0"=(3
,
Y'+Y"-Y
.
In (1.1) we may assume the same x and X, for a and b. Using (1.2)
write x(j) = j - a(j)
,
?(j) = j - t(j)
and estimate the products of (2.5) by
,
t(j)
o(j)
(2.6)(x) IaI+ IRI-a(la' I+IR' I )-a( ICE" I+IR")( (x,y)) I? I-t( IY' I)-t( IY"I ) {t(1)+t(j-l)},
{a(1)+a(j-l)} , t'(j)=Min
Then define al(j)=Min lsj
le. j
We get the estimates (1.1) for c with x'=j-a', X'=j-t' instead of
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
58
x,X. In particular we also get x'
00
->
%' - 00 , q.e.d.
,
Corollary 2.3. The symbol algebra ST contains all a of the form (2.7)
asN
ba(x)ca(y),a
where ba , ca E COO(&n) satisfy the estimates
A a(x) = 0((x) P) , Dc(x) = D((x)p)
(2.8)
with a constant p , independent of x (2.9)
A = a(Ml,Mr,D) =
,
a ,
R
.
x e &n
,
Then we get
ba(M)Daca(M)
a differential operator.
Proof.
(2.10)
The Fourier transform
u^ = Fu and its inverse u" = F lu
u" () = J91x
uES
u°(x) = JF1
satisfy (c.f. 0,(1.22)). (2.11)
FDjF-1 =
Mj
,
j = 1,...,n.
Theorem 2.4. Let a,b E EST be independent of y and x, respectively. Then the 1pdo's A = a(Ml,D) and B = b(MrD) may be written as ,
=fdye
(2.12) (Au)(x)=
for u E S , with the Fourier transform (2.10). Proof. The first formula is clear,,f using (2.10). Also, (2.13)
(Bu)(x) _
f4eix
JP1y a '
where the inner integral
is in L1(&n) , by lemma 1.2 (In this case I is independent of x). Hence we may write (Bu)(x)=I"(x). We know that Bu E S Therefore (Bu)^=(I`)^= I as proposed, q.e.d. .
,
Theorem 2.5. For a,b EST let
We have
c EST , and c(Mi,Mr,D) = a(Mi,D)b(Mr,D)
(2.14)
Proof. From Theorem 2.2 we conclude that c EST. Using (2.12), A(Bu)(x)=
ff
u(y)
u E S , q.e.d. = (c(Mi,Mr,D)u)(x) For a symbol a E ST consider the bilinear form ,
1.2. Elementary properties
59
(2.15) (v,Au)= (v,a(Mi,Mr,D)u)=
f9Ix fpig fyiy=f
for u, v E S . We have seen that
9I
JJTx9Iy
.Note that a
temperate distribution k E S'(&2n) is defined by (2.16)
(k,w) = J
w E S(&2n)
JoxPzy
By the techniques of sec.1 we get
(2.17)
(k,w) =
J<)
-2mf
P1xPlyei (x-Y) (1-Ox)m(aw)
For large in this is in the span of (2.18)
inner
(x,Y)
,
IPI+IYIs2m,
where (1.1),(1.2) give existence of the integral J. But J is (x,y)-continuous and O(((x,y))%(0)). Thus (J,DXW) define DXJE S'. We shall call k, defined by (2.16), the distribution kernel of A=a(M1,Mr,D), aE ST. Note kE SI(1e2m) is uniquely determined by
, u,v E S .
(v,Au) _ (k,v(gi)
(2.19)
Formally, with distribution integrals, we may write (Au)(x) = fk(x,y)u(y)piy
(2.20)
,
(A"u)(x) = fk(y,x)u(y)yiy
Proposition 2.6. We have (2.21)
k(x,y) = kA(x,Y) = a`'(x,Y,x-Y) = a'(x,Y,a)Ia=x-Y
in the following precise sense: The inverse Fourier transform aof with respect to its third (its 2n+1-st...3n-th) argument is a distribution in S'(13n) which may be written as a conS,(R2n), tinuous family pa =a3'(x,y,(x-y)+a) of distributions in
(2.22)
(P(Y,V) =
fdxdypO(x,Y)V(x,Y)
, 'VIE S(R2ri)
in the form
(2.23)
(8'',q)) = fdo(pa,V(,) , 'W0(x,Y)=T(x,Y,o+x-y) , AE D(13n) C(&n,S,(R2n))
with a distribution integral in (2.22) defining p0E while (2.23) is a Riemann integral with continuous integrand, of compact support. Then the distribution kernel k coincides with the distribution p0 of (2.22) for a=0 .
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
60
Proof. Clearly a family p0E C(&n,SI(it2n)) is defined by setting
(2.24)
)'W(x,y) , PE S(&2n)
(P0,V) =
Indeed, we get pa in the form (2.17) with a replaced by aei6 Then a look at (2.18) (with this a) shows that (p(,,p) E
C0(ln)
We get fdo(p6,ypa)=
,(P)
confirming (2.23), where we have used a linear substitution of integration variable, and some Fubini-type interchanges. Q.E.D. The distribution kernel's singular support will be of interest in the following. In sec.3 we introduce restricted symbol classes with the property that the kernel k=ka for such a symbol a has 1e2n:x=y}.
singular support contained in the 'diagonal' {(x,y)E For general a e ST this is not true: Consider E ST. Then sing supp ka coincides with the set {(x,y):Ix-yI=1}, as follows from prop.2.6 0,lemma 4.1 and 0,(4.42). In the following let ST1={aE ST: aaa=0} be the set of aE ST independent of y. Following a general convention the class of all ,
pdo's A=a(M1,D) with symbol in a class P will be denoted by OpP . 3. Hoermander symbols: Weyl ydo's; distribution kernels. For differential operators A of the form (2.9) it appears that there are many representations as y,do's, due to the fact that
Leibniz' formula may be used to convert a product Daa(M) to a sum of products aa,(M)Da' and vice versa. In fact, it is clear that a differential operator (2.9) always may be rewritten in the form ,
(3.1)
A = b(M1,D) = b1(Mr,D)
,
only. with unique symbols bE ST and b1E ST depending on x, The same will be true for a iyido A=a(M1,Mr,D), if a satisfies stronger inequalities. In fact, a generalization of the Leibniz formulas will be developed, either involving a Taylor expansion type reminder, or an asymptotically convergent infinite series, as discussed in sec.'s 4 and 5. Later we will use only one representation A=a(M1,D) for all y,do's (also written as A=a(x,D)), following a general convention. But it will be convenient to have more
1.3. Hoermander symbols
61
general forms available. The restricted symbol class SSC ST below will have other desirable features: The distribution kernel kA of A, for an aE SS, (cf. sec.2) will have sing supp kAC {x=y}. OpSS will be an algebra. Also, as seen in 11,5, a 'pdo in OpSS will not increase the wave front set of a temperate distribution.. Apart from the representations A=b(M1,D), and A=c(Mr,D) resulting for A=a(M1,Mr,D)E OpSS, a third representation, of the form A=e((M1+Mr)/2,D)=e(Mw,D) is useful, with a third symbol e , and e(M1+Mr)/2,D)=f(M1,Mr,D) with e(Mw,D) will
be called the Weyl representation of a pdo. b(M1,D) and c(MrD) are referred to as the 'left (right) multiplying representations'. Let SS denote the class of functions a E COO(R3n) such that
(3.2)
o(()m,+S(IaH+IRI)-p' I?I(x)m2-P2IaI(y)m3-P3IRI)
DaaDyDya =
with real constants mj,pj,i satisfying (3.3)
0 < pj s
1
,
j=1,2,3, 0 s S < pl
.
Also, by SSm'p'S we denote the class of all aE ST satisfying m2 ,m3) , p=(pi p2 ,p3) , 6 , where only the first condition (3.3) will be required, and no longer S
(3.2) for a given m=(mt
since aaa=0. We then will set m3 =0, p3 =1 , or omit m3
,
p3 , writing
m=(ml,m2) and p=(pl,p2) as 2-component vectors only,ignoring the trivial estimates (3.2) for 5#0. We will mostly be concerned with y*, since it will be found that OpSS = Opih. We also define
fl {yi1'm,P,S
: m E 12 } = s(12n)
P,6 _ - U {'m,p,S : m E It2
}
Hoermander [Hr2] has introduced a class SP,, of local symbols consisting of C00(axln)-functions, with a domain 11C In using inequalities similar to (3.2). He defines SP,s by the estimates (3.4)
E In
,
x E K
for all a, on all sets KCC 11. A iydo A=a(x,D), similar to a(M1,D)
is defined for C0(11)-functions u by the first formula (2.12).
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
62
Accordingly we shall refer to symbols in the classes SSm'P'b , Vh,,p,b as Hoermander type symbols SP,6 , SS , q* ,
From (3.2) it follows that
Im, I+Im: I)
(3.5)
recalling that pj Z 0. This implies (1.1), with K(k)= m1+bk, ?(k)= Im2I+Im3I . Moreover, (1.2) holds whenever 6 < 1 . Accordingly,
SS CST
(3.6)
Lemma 3.1. Let a
SSm 'p- '6-
,
SSm,p,o CST
E SSm'P'b
,
as 6 <
1
.
, b E SSm,P1'S', then we get a + b E
, a b E SSm 'P^ '6^
, where
(3.7) mj=Max{mj,mj}, 6-=6-=Max{6,6'}, mj=mj+mj, pj=pj=Min{pj,pj} Moreover, U {SSm'P'b:mj E 2}=SS001P'6 is an algebra under pointwise
addition and multiplication. All statements remain true if SS , in all expressions, is replaced by ih. The proof uses Leibniz' formula. It is left to the reader. Remark: Note that SS and bah are not algebras. In particular the
condition 6 < p1 needs not to hold for sum or product of two symbols with summands or factors of different p and O. Thm.3.2 below is central for the calculus of ydo's. Its proof will be given after some preparations, discussed in sec.5ff. Theorem 3.2. Let a E SSm'P'b, with m,p,b satisfying (3.3) . There exists a unique b E ohm .P b- and b1 E1yihm .P-,swith (3.8)
m1 = ml , m2 = m2+m3
.
P1 = P1
.
6- = b
,
p2 = Mini P2'P31
such that (3.1) holds for A=a(M1,Mr,D). Moreover, there also ex-
ists a unique b2E 0 m (3.9)
with m , p- , b- of (3.8) such that
A = a(Ml,Mr,D) = b2((Ml+Mr)/2.D)
Observe that c=b2((x+y)/2,1;)E ST, whenever b2 EE hm,p,b, 6<1, by an
estimate similar to (3.5). Thus c(M1,Mr,D)=b,((M,+Mr)/2,D) is well defined, but need not be in SS. We will find, later on, that, with m,p,b satisfying cdn.(3.3), the classes {a(Ml,D)}, {a(Mr,D)}
{a(Mw,D)}, where a E Vhm,Pb, are identical. Note that, for C = a((M1+Mr)/2,D), we get from (2.3) that .
(3.10)
C* = a((M1+Mr)/2,D)
1.3. Hoermander symbols
63
Note that, for C = a((M1+Mr)/2,D), we get from (2.3) that C* = a((M1+Mr)/2,D)
(3.10)
This points to one of the advantages of the Weyl type ipdo: If the
symbol a is real then the operator C above is formally selfadjoint On the other hand the 'left multiplying type' a(M1,D) has other advantages: If
a polynomial in l;, the resulting differ-
ential operator a(M1,D) is in the conventional form -coefficients at left from the differentiations. Recall, for Weyl type ?4do's, (3.11) a(Mw,D) =a((M1+Mr)/2,D) =c(Ml,Mr,D),
The restricted class SS produces useful distribution kernels: Theorem 3.3. Let a E SS. Then the distribution kernel k E S'(&2n) of A=a(M1,Mr,D) has its singular support contained in the diagonal {(x,y)E R2n: x=y} = O of R2n. Moreover, for fixed x (fixed y), the distribution k(x,.) (k(.,y)) equals a function in S(ln) outside any neighbourhood of x=y , and uniformly so for xE K (yE K) K any compact set (in fact, we have (y)alaXaYkIscaRYE as xE K as yE K , Ix-YIZE))Ix-YI-F ((Y)(1laXaYkISCapYE '
Proof. Referring to prop.2.6, and the discussion in [C,],II, note that a(x,y,.) E M hence & (x,y,.)E Sos (cf.[C,],II,thm.4.3). This implies the statement. Offering details (and independence from 00 [C,]), let wE CO(I2n ), w=0 near e. Then supp w has positive distance from O, and Ix-yI -mE C00(supp w). By (1.6), with a partial integration, one may bring (2.16) to the form (3.12)
(k,w) =
J0JfR1x91Y
From (3.1) we get
(3.13)
4ma(x,y,l;)
O((,)m, -2mp, ((x,Y))m:+m3
=
)
,m
If m is large enough then the integrand will be L1(R3n)
,
so that
the integrals may be interchanged, for (3.14)
(k,w)= fkwoxgly
,
k(x,y)= fs
(3.14) has convergent Lebesgue integrals, if m is large. Moreover,as m gets larger and larfrger, the formulas (3.15)
aaayk(x,Y) =
f41
aaaP els(x-Y)A a(x,Y,U)/Ix-YI2m
give the derivatives of k(x,y) (k is independent of m; the inte-
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
64
that sing supp k C 0 . Very similar arguments will show that etc. Q.E.D. y alaIayklscaRYE, as x E K , jx-ylze ,
4. The composition formulas of Beals.
Proposition 4.1. For aE (4.1)
C0*(&2n)
a(Mr,D) = p(M1,D)
, bE C0OO(&3n) we have the formulas ,
b(M1,Mr,D) = q(M1,D)
with p,q E S(&2n) given by
iyrla(x-Y,t-j)
(4.2)
,
q(x,t)=JPlY9ll1e
Proof. Focus on the first relation (4.1), typical for the second. For u E S and a E C0OO(I2n) we get (4.3)
a(Mr,D)u(x) =
Jdyaz'(Y,x-Y)u(Y)
with '"y" indicating the inverse Fourier transform with respect to
the 2-nd (set of)variable(s) of by integral interchange. Write ay(y,x-y)=aa(x-(x-y),x-y)=c(x,x-y), i.e., c(x,z)=a'(x-z,z)= fg eil'za(x-z,T;). Clearly cE Cam(&2n), c=0 for large lxj, c(x,.)E S, for fixed x. Hence cE S(B2n); we may define p(x,U) fgtzc(x,z)e
ll;z
E S(>Q2n), and get c(x,z)=py(x,z), c(x,x-y)=pr(x,x-y). Accordingly, (4.4)
a(Mr,D)u(x) = J41yp (x,x-Y)u(Y) =
(x-Y) u(Y)
JR
Clearly the right hand side of (4.4) equals p(M1,D)u(x). Also, (4.5)
which becomes (4.2), after an integral substitution -t=rl
,
q.e.d.
Proposition 4.2. Let A=a(M1,D), B=b(M1,D) with a,bE C0"O(&2n). Then
given by
Then C=AB=c(M1,D), A*=a*(M1,D) with c(x,i;),
)e-iyq (4.6)
a*(x,s)
=
In prop.4.2 A* denotes the formal Hilbert space adjoint of A, as in (2.3), here of the form A*=a(Mr,D). Thus the second formula follows from (4.1) and (4.2). For the product AB write
(4.7)
(ABu)(x) =
Jo,t OYglrlgz
eirl(y-z) u(z)
65
1.4. Beals composition formulas
We may write a 4n-fold integral, the integrand being L1(R2n). Use (4.8)
and continue (4.7) as follows.
(4.9)
=
e1T1(x-z)
a
f
u(z)
Denoting the inner integral by c(x,il), (4.6) follows, q.e.d. In the trivial case of CO symbols formulas (4.1),(4.2),(4.6) and the calculation of the symbol achieve the transition M1 **M r
,
of operator product and adjoint. We will show that the formulas remain in effect for symbols in ST and STS if the Riemann integrals in (4.2) and (4.6) are replaced by a type of distribution integral we call a finite part - it resembles a concept of Hadamard [Hdl]. Let us still look at the Weyl-representation for Co°-symbols.
Clearly (3.10) gives a(Mw,D) =a(Mw,D), a formula like (4.6), but much simpler - it does not involve integrals. But the formula for the symbol of a product, now involves a 4n-fold integral: Proposition 4.3. Let a,b E C"(&n) (4.10)
,
C = c(M1,Mr,D) = P(Mw,D)
and c E C0OO(I3n). We have
Q = a(Mw,D)b(Mw,D) = q(Mw,D)
where p , q E S(R2n) are given by the formulas
(4.11)
q(x, )=f
(x-Y+z/4, -rl+t/4) b (x-Y-z/4, -n-t/4) a-i ('1z-tY) .
Proof. For (4.10)i depart from (4.3), writing c' (w+z/2,w-z/2,z) , with w=(x+y)/2, z=x-y. Defining p(w,l;)=d'(w,l;) =JFizd(w,z)e 12t, get Cu(x)=fslyp (x
,x-Y)u(Y)=P(MW,D)u(x). Again
pE S(1Q2n); interchanges are trivial, confirming (4.10)i-(4.11)i
For the second formula one writes Qu(x) = (ABu)(x) = fr(x,z)u(z)ylz
,
(4.12)
r(x,z) = Again write r(x,y)=s(w,v)=r(w+v/2,w-v/2), w=(x+z)/2,v=x-z,and get Q=q(Mw,D), with along lines used before. Then show that q assumes the form (4.11) after an integral
66
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
substitution. No trouble with integral interchanges. qE S follows. Now we start with the discussion of a more general singular integral called the finite part (integral) since it resembles Hadamard's finite part (cf. also [Ci],II).This will be a distribution integral using partial integration, based on identities like (1.6)
(4.13)
a-iY'"
(Il)-2N(1_Ay)Ne_in
=
(Y)-2M(l_01)Me in
_
valid for all nonnegative N,M. Using (4.13) and some (legitimate) partial integrations, the first formula (4.2) assumes the form
in
)Ne
(4.14) =
f
aN(z,t)=(l-OZ)Na(z,t)
Using the other identity (4.13) we get, similarly, (4.15)
f 9jYPTqe
1(Y) -2M(l-0I)M(('il) (1-0I)M((,1)-2NaN(x-y,t-rl))
Here the expression (4.16)
is in the span of
IaI+IPI s 2M
.
If M and N are chosen sufficiently large then the right hand side of (4.15) is meaningful, as a Riemann or Lebesgue integral, even if we only require that aE ST1. Indeed, the expressions (4.16) are
0((l)-2N(x_y)X(2M)( _l)x(2N)) , with x,a, of (1.1), so that the integrand of (4.15) is 0((Y) -2M( x_y) a. (2M) (11) -2N(1; _,1) x (2N)). We assume xa0, x.20 in (1.2): they may be replaced by Max{0,x}
,
Max{O,a.},
X=0((x) k+(y) X)
also satisfying (1.1),
( 1. 2 ) . Thus (x-y) ; similarly for -i. Existence of the integral (4.15) follows from (1.2). The integrals in (4.2)2,(4.6),(4.1l) are treated similarly, using (1.1) with identities like (4.13), and partial integration. Note that all these integrals are of the form fdsdaeis w(s,a)
(4.17)
,
with an integral over &2m, and wE
If W(=-
(4.18)
,
asaaw(s,Q)
=
0((s)X(IaI)(a)%(jPj))
Cm(12s)
satisfies
X(k)-k + -oo , k - oo
we define the finite part(integral)p.f.f dsdae's w(s,a) as follows:
Use identities like (4.13) and formal partial integrations as above until an integrand in L1(R2m) is reached. Then define p.f.f as the Lebesgue integral of that integrand. That is,
1.4. Beals composition formulas
67
p.f.fdsdae'saw(s,a) =fdsdaeisa(a)-2M(1-Os)M((s)-2N(1_A(3)Nw(s,a){
(4.19)
dsdaeisa(s)-2M(1-A0)M((a)-2N(l_A5)Nw(s,a))
=f
for sufficiently large M,N, where it yet has to be shown that this definition is independent of N,M and the choice of first or second expression,at right.The latter will follow from the lemma,below.
Lemma 4.4. Let w E ST1(&m) (i.e., satisfy (4.18)), and let (4.20)
wj(s,(J) = w(s,(J)Xj(s)Xj(a)
,
j = 1,2,...
,
with Xj(s) = X(s/j) , where X E C00(e) equals 1 in Isi s 1 If the two expressions at right of (4.19) are denoted by I(w) _ IN,M(w) and JN,M(w) = J(w)
,
respectively, then we have
limjIN,M(wj) = IN,M(w)
(4.21)
,
limjooJN,M(wj) = JN,M(w)
for all sufficiently large N and M. Proof. If wj is substituted for w in IN,M (or JN,M) then Leibniz' formula may be used to obtain I(wj) for example, as sum of terms ,
2Masaaw(s,a),IaI+IYI52N,IPI+IOIs2M.
If N,M
are chosen such that the integral IN,M(w) exists,i.e., ?(2N) - 2N < -n
(4.22)
,
X(2M) - 2M < -n ,
then each integrand is of the form X(a)(s)X W )(a)O(((a)(s))-n)
This implies that all integrals tend to zero, except for a=4=0 using that cja)(s) = j-IaIX(a)(s/j) On the other hand, the integral for a = 0 converges to I(w) since cj(s)- 1 , sE &m q.e.d. .
,
,
The lemma below will be useful to differentiate finite parts under the integral sign.
Lemma 4.5. For a symbol w E ST1 the function
p.f.f¢y is C-(&2n)
,
and we have
h(P)(x,
)
= p.f.fOTY> 1
iyyl
The proof is a calculation: Just use (4.19), with M,N suitable
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
68
for both above finite parts. Then confirm that the differentiation may be taken into the Lebesgue integrals,and also commutes with the two Laplacians there. Observe w E ST1 implies that STS
for arbitrary X, IA E & ,
x°
, °E
n .
Lemma 4.6. If in prop.4.1 we require only aE STI , bE ST , then the integrals in (4.2) still exist as finite parts, and define
Co functions p,q , with all derivatives of polynomial growth:
(4.23)
N
p(R)(x,
a,P)
,
)
Moreover, we have (4.1) satisfied in the sense that, for u E S
Proof. For a,b E Co we may differentiate p,q of (4.2) under the integral sign, getting p,q in the span of the expressions
(4.24) J91y91rle l
a(R)(x-y,
-r0
,
J91y911le-11aXayaOb(x1y1U)
y+S=a.
,
For general aE ST1, bE ST again construct sequences bj= bxj(y)xj(U), as in lemma 4.4. Let aj be substituted for a, and the partial integrations of the finite part be executed in (4.24).
As j-.oo get limits with integrands =0(((Y) (r;) ) -2N ( (x-y) ( -rl) %(2N)) , in the first case, and in the second, letting k=Ial+l0I. We were setting N=M, and x(k)=X(k), as always in the following. We get, with r = 2X(2N+1cI+IOI),
(4.25) and the same formula for q. Here pj, qj denote the p,q for aj,bj. The estimate O(...) in (4.25) also holds for pj, uniformly, since the aj satisfy uniform estimates (1.1). Clearly (4.1), in the form above, is true for uE S and aj, bj, pj, qj. For j-- get the desired relation for p and also for q, by a similar conclusion, q.e.d. We leave it to the reader to confirm that the corresponding statements are true for prop.'s 4.2 and 4.3. Summarizing: Theorem 4.7. If the symbols a,b of prop.4.1, symbols a,b of prop. ST1, ST ; STI STI 4.2 and a,b,c of prop.4.3 are chosen in ,
,
ST1, STI, ST, respectively, instead of in C" then the integrals in (4.2), (4.6), (4.11) still exist as finite parts. They define Co functions p(x,l;), res-
pectively, which are of polynomial growth in together with * * all their derivatives. Moreover, (4.1) , AB=c(M1,D) , A =a (M1,D)
69
1.5. Leibniz formulas with integral remainder and (4.10) still hold for u E ES
in the sense of lemma 4.6.
By silent convention we omit the finite part label at the integrals and write the composition formulas for symbols (which we shall call Beals formulas) in their forms (4.2), (4.6), (4.11), even for symbols in ST and ST1. Note that we are not getting the estimates (1.1) back for the symbols p,q, etc. Instead we obtained the weaker estimates (4.23) of polynomial growth. It is of interest to ask for subsets of ST1, for example, characterized by stronger inequalities, such that the composed symbols p, c, a q again satisfy the stronger
estimates. As a comparatively large such class we introduce
(4.26) ,pt = frt. _ {aE
(x) rtL' ),for all a,(3}
Here the pair m = (mi,mz) will be called the order of the symbol a and Ptm C pt will denote the class of all symbols of order m. ,
Theorem 4.8. Let 1I 11 "'r, 4% denote the classes of all a(Ml,D), a(Mr,D), a(Mw,D), respectively, with aE y,t. Then we have qT1 qT W =qT=OPVt, with transition formulas between representations of AE W given by thm.4.7. Moreover, LI' is an algebra under operator
r
multiplication containing its Hilbert space adjoints. The order m of AE LPl' (defined as order of its symbol) is independent of the representation used. Orders add when operators are multiplied. Thm 4.7 gives formulas for symbols of adjoints and products. For a proof we check earlier arguments. The stronger conditions imply the algebra property. Details are left to the reader. 5. The Leibniz formulas with integral remainder. The Leibniz formulas express a product P(D)a(M) of a differential polynomial P(D) and a multiplication a(M) by a C° function a as a finite sum of terms a.(M)P.(D), with multiplication and differentiation in the other order. Similarly a(M)P(D), (P(D)a(M)) We have a(x,D)b(x,D)=c(x,D), (a(x,D))*=a*(x,D), for differential operators a(x,D), b(x,D), with finite sums c(x, (5.1)
) = 0
7,(-i)'01/9! a(g(x, e
)
)
Other formulas express p,q of (4.2), or of (4.11), in that case. In the following corresponding formulas will be derived for
.
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
70
-Pdo's. We focus on symbol classes 0m,P,B of Hoermander type. Actually the formulas follow for symbols in ST or ST1, and the tool of derivation is the ordinary Taylor formula with integral remainder. There will be a finite sum, as in (5.1), but also a remainder term, as in Taylor's formula. Unless the symbols belong to SSmp,b, 6
(5.2)
I OsN
pN (N+1)
a(O)(x,U)(-T1)O/O!
+
,
PN
1
I (-r1)0/0!P0,N IOI=N+1
' PO,N = 0
Substituting (5.2) into (4.2), (4.6), (4.11) one obtains the following typical collection of Leibniz formulas. Other formulas, for similar symbol transitions, follow just as easily. Theorem 5.1. Let a,b E ST1, c E ST , and let the symbols arl(x,), cl(x,) , cw(x,) , pl(x,) , pw(x,) a*(x,) be defined by ,
arl(Ml,D) = a(Mr,D)
(5.3)
,
cl(Ml,D) = c(Ml,Mr,D) = cw(MH,D)
,
pl(Ml,D) = a(Ml,D)b(M1,D) , pw(Mw,D) = a(Mw,D)b(Mw,D)
a(Ml,D)
,
= a (M1,D)
We have the following Leibniz formulas (with integral remainder):
arl(x,) = Lj=0(-iaxa)Ja(x,)/7! + (N+1)PN (5.4) 1
PN(x,) =
di(1-i)NIN!p.f.
91YF1Tle-iyr!(-iaX
N+1a(x-Y,- Tj);
a
0
cl(x,) =-J=II/j!{(-iay a )N+1c(x,Y, )}x=y + (N+1)PN
,
(5.5) 1
PN(x,U) =
dt(1-s)NINIp.f.f plyAe-iyr!(iay
0
cw(x, )=`7=01/j! (ia
a
N+1c(x,x-Y, -T1);
ay)Jc(x+Y/2,x-Y/2,)j
+ (N+1)pN
(5.6) 1
PN =
J
0
di (1-i)/N! p.f.f
p1(x,5)= (5.7)
01/j! (-ia
P1YAe_iy1(idya
N+1c(x+y/2,x-Y/2,-il);
ay)1(a(x,)b(Y,i1)jx=Y,=1 +(N+1)pN
1.5. Leibniz formulas with integral remainder
(5.7) pN (5.8)
1
0
_
(1-t)N/N! di p. f.
pw(x, )= =0,
pN M
1
0
ly"(-iay
ay-aX a,l)J(a(x,
-t) Ndt
e
71
b(Y,Y1) Ix=Y,
+pN,
21(zrl-yt)(2(asaK-ataa>> i N+1 a(s.a)b(t,K),
M=N+1, s=x-y,
a finite part integral.
(5.9)
(N+I)pN ,
a
with PN as in (5.4) , with a replaced by a Note that the term pN has been used in all formulas,to denote the remainder, without implying equality in different expressions.
Proof. In each case the equation at once is confirmed formally, by substituting (5.2) into (4.2), (4.6), (4.11), and using that
iy = ay(1 )"
(5.10)
=
(2x)n/2ayO(Y)
in the distribution sense. A partial integration must be used with (ax ay)1/1! =
(5.11)
aXay/8
I
e
1
For cw we must apply (5.2) onto the product ab, in 2n variables. The detailed derivation is technical and repeats the same steps over and over. Focus on (5.7), the others follow similarly. Using (5.2) in (4.6)1, (with c(x,x) called pl(x,x)) we get the terms
(5.12)
p.f.fgypiri e-i"1(-1)e/O!
For a,b E C0*(&2n) this is easily transformed into
=(-i) (5.13)
10
,
91Y9lT1 ay(e
=(-i)I0I/O!JP1YPlrl with N sufficiently large, but with the n-partial integrations
reversed to the status M=O. This still gives a well convergent integral, as long as a,b are Co . Recall that bN = (1-Ax)N b Here the ii-integral may be evaluated. It gives the Fourier
transform ((Y1)-2N)^=((,q)-2N)' =EN, the unique fundamental solution in S' of (1-A)-N. An expression for EN in terms of modified Hankel functions is known (cf. (0.24) for N=1; the method works for gene-
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
72
s>0.) EN decays exponentially, as lxI-goo. Without ral Hankel functions one confirms easily that EN equals a function
in S, for 1xIa1. (c.f. [C1],II). Hence (5.13) is continued as =(-i)'°1/91 (5.14)
(-1)'01/01
confirming the first expression of (5.7), using (5.11), and for Cp functions only. For the remainder term, we look at
p.f.ff91y51rl a-iY11 (5.15)
_
iyrl
91Y91r1 a
(1-z)Ndia(e)(x,
0
1(l-i)Ndi
0
P1YP1r1
0
as a matter of Fubini type integral exchanges. Write (-rl)°e iyr) _ (-i)IOIaye-1Y11 and carry out a partial integration, for ,
n
r
0
(5.16)
[l
iai
IT
f
_,.... ,a%
(0)(x-Y,)
,
0
completing the discussion of (5.7), for a,b E COOO
For general a,b E ST1 one now may use sequences aj, bj E CO, as in lemma 4.4, and arrive at (5.7) by passing to the limit j
-> -,
using lemma 4.4 and a formula similar to (4.25). Details are left to the reader. In particular the occurrance of the factor r, in the argument of a does not influence the derivation. ,
6. Calculus of Vd2o's for symbols of Hoermander type.
The Leibniz' formulas with integral remainder of sec.5 may be of little use, unless we restrict symbols to the class SS of
sec.3. For symbols in SS or h the formulas of thm.5.1 imply corresponding asymptotic expansions of arl' cl' cw' p1' pw' a* The key is an estimate of the remainders pN of (5.4)-(5.9). , c E SSm",p"," b E y>hm, 1, 61 P with the 3 sets of paramaters satisfying (3.3). Then the remainTheorem 6.1. Let a E E - =0
S,
ders pN of (5.4) through (5.9) satisfy the following estimates:
73
1.6. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators oPPPl(
For (5.4):
)m.-(N+1)(p.-b)
(x)mz-(N+l)pz )
=of( )m."-(N+1)(p'"-b") (x)m2"+m3"-(N+1)p3°`.
For (5.5): For (5.6):
)m. "-(N+1)(P' "-b")
o((
X)M2 "+m3 "-(N+1)p-)
p-=Min{p2 ",p3 J"} .
For (5.7):
0
f(l;)m1 +m1 '-(N+1)(P.-b') (x)m2+m2'-(N+1)p2)
For (5.8): pN(x,U) = pj = Min{pj,p'}
,
b^ = Max{b,b'}
For (5.9): Same as for (5.4) Moreover, these remainders will be symbols of Hoermander type, of the order indicated by the above formulas. That is, PN E A'm-(N+1)(p-be'),p,b ,e'=(1,O)
for (5.4) and (5.9),
PN E 4* (MI "-(N+1) (P "411) M2 "+m3 "-(N+1 )p3 "), (P'
(6.1)
pN as for (5.5), with p3" replaced by p" PN E 4*m+m'-(N+1)(p-b'e'),p^,b^ replaced by b^,for (5.8)
,
P ),b ,
'
for (5.5),
for (5.6)
,
and the same with 6'
for (5.7)
.
Here we must require that b^< p,^, in case of (5.7) and (5.8). Then both orders of pN will tend to --, as N - - .
The proof proceeds similar as in sec.4. In each case we supply estimates, uniformly in s, of the integrand di only. For example, to estimate PN of (5.4), it suffices to consider
p.f.fdydrl a-h
(6.2)
1a(6)(x-Y,x-T1)
=fdydTl e
again with aN (1-AX)N a, for sufficiently large M,N. Use (3.2) for (6.3)
=o f dy(x-Y) mz -pz 1111 (Y) -2M l
fdll( -iTl) m. -p. 19 1+6 101(,n) -2N)
Here we also employed the estimate
(6.4)
((Tl)-R)(a)
=
o((Tl)-R-Ia
which is easily derived. Then apply the well known inequality
.
74
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
(6.5)
(x) s(x-Y)s
=
0((Y)IsI)
,
valid for sE 1, to estimate (6.3) by (x) MI -PZ 10 I (
) m, - (PI -6) I 0 I
confirming the estimate for the remainder pN of (5.4). Similarly for the other 5 estimates.Also we may apply Lemma 4.6 to the remainder of (5.4), for
(6.6)
pN(R)
f 0(1 )N/NIf I1YAe iYn(-ia
-a
N+1a(a) (x-Y, -TI
)
Then the above estimate may be repeated for
(6.7)
)m,-(N+1)(P'-b)-P IaI+OIl1(x)m2-(N+1)p:-PZ IPI),
PN(a) = 0((
which confirms (6.1) for the first remainder. Again similarly for the other five remainders, q.e.d. Theorem 6.2. Under the assumptions of thm.6.1 the symbols arl' a* of thm.5.1 are in yah provided that, for cl, cw, pl, pw, the product symbols pl , pw we still require that 6^ < p, (which is automatically true if (m,p,S) = (m',p',S') ) More precisely, we get arl, a* E 0 cwEyhm ,P-,s m,p,S ,
.
Cl,
with m =(m, ,m2+m3) Apm+m',p^,S^
,
P =(PI ,P2
with p^
,
)
,
p2 =Min(p2 ,P3)
,
P1
, Pw E
6A as in thm.6.1.
The proof of thm.6.2 is a consequence of (6.1). Note that thm.6.2 contains the (so far unproven) thm.3.2 as a special case. Indeed, the symbol b of thm.3.2 is given by our cl c(Mr,Ml,D)=(c(Ml,Mr,D)*
while b1 may be obtained by writing b1(M1,D), taking adjoints. b2 coincides with ow of thm.6.2.
For uniqueness of b, b1, b2 note that a ,do A=a(M1,Mr,D) vanishes if and only if its distribution kernel (2.16) vanishes. For set w(x,y)=u(x+y)v(x-y), u,vE S. (2.16) yields
f
dsdteitta(s,t )u(s)v(t)=f dsd; a(s,, )u(s)vr'* (( ) =0 for all u,v E S.
This implies a=0. Thus the Weyl representation is unique. Similarly for the left (right) multiplying representations. Similarly thm.6.2 implies the following result.
Theorem 6.3. Each sethoo,p,b forms an algebra under operator multiplication, containing its Hilbert space adjoints, whenever p,S satisfy (3.3). The algebra product a°b may be defined by anyone of the representations a H a(M1,D), or, a H a(Mr,D) , or a H a(Mw,D). That is c=a°b satisfies c(Mx,D)=a(Mx,D)b(MM,D), x=l or x=r or x=w.
75
1.6. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
The proof, in essence, is an application of (5.7), (5.8), and (5.9), as modified by thm.6.2. Details are left to the reader. In the following we tend to use the left multiplying representation A=a(Ml,D), and then will use the more conventional notation A=a(Ml,D)=a(x,D). For a class X of symbols let OpX={a(x,D): aE X}. For a class Y of ,do's let symbY be such that Op(symbY)=Y. For a symbol aE 11hm,p,s
1,2,...,
ajE yt j
,
and a sequence of symbols aj, j=0,
,
m+ =(mi,m2), mk-.-oo, as j-oo, k=1,2, we will
m ,p,S
say that a has the asymptotic expansion
a =
(6.8)
0
aj (mod Vh_.)
=0 aj
,
written as
(or simply "(mod S)"
,
if both orders of the symbol pN=a-e=0 aj tend to -oo, as N- (that
is,more precisely, if rNE h N j-
,
, with µN=(µN,µ2), where µ ,P,5 k=1,2). It is seen at once that µJ=mj+1 is the best possible
choice for µj . Also we must have m=m°
.
Using this terminology we find that all formulas (5.4)-(5.9) imply corresponding asymptotic expansions For example, (6.9)
(mod 0_,O)
a
as aE 0M OP 16, 6
It is clear that the asymptotic sums in (6.8) or (6.9) are not in general convergent infinite series. For future applications it is important that, for an v sequence aj of symbols of order mi--00,
an asymptotic sum may be constructed, by the lemma, below.
Lemma 6.4. Let ajE j=0,1,..., where p,5 needs not satisfy (3.3), but is independent of j with and where mJ=(mi,m2) ,
(6.10)
mk>mk>mk>
...
,
as jaoo
,
There exists a symbol a Ehm,p,S (6.11)
sN = a - 4=0 aj
k=1,2
such that
m = m0
E yh N M ,p,b
N=0,1,2,...
.
Proof. Indicating first the idea of the proof, let (6.12)
s 1/2
,
o )=l
,
as jxI+1fl z
1
.
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
76
and let x=1-wE CD . Assume Os w,x sl in &2n j-- , to be For an increasing seqence {tj} , tjE I determined later, define
Assume wE C°°(1e2n)
,
w(x/tj,/tj)
(6.13)
Conclude that w.=0, as Thus is finite near
/2. Since t.->oo the sum in (6.13) is well defined. We get
a - f -laj
(6.14)
J=O
= -Lj=oxjaj + > N wjaj
where the first term at right is C0(22n), and satisfies (3.2) for any choice of parameters m,p,S. For the second term we get
(6.15)
IwjajIscj(1;}ml
(x)
sup{( )8 i(x)0, is JxJ+1i 12ttj/2}
By choosing tj sufficiently large the supremum in (6.15) can be made less than 2-3/cj . Using this in (6.15) , and then substituting (6.15) into (6.14) we get with 9S =md -m
9'Z
=mz -lZP
.
)mi
(6.16)
a - Lj=pai = 0((
(x)
Writing (6.16) for N+1, we notice that the highest term aN , at left is of the same order as the right hand side. Thus we get the first estimate (3.2) contained in (6.11). To get the other estimates we improve the choice of tj. For a
given a,4 and N let No=Max{jaI+I3I,N+1}. Write
(6.17)
- j=0a.
=a-`zX I-
,
and,
J
0
aXo sN =
Observe that o.E yah0,p,6, for every p,S with (3.3), and 0=(0,0). Thus also a.w4E1yah j and (6.15) follows for aaap(wja.) instead m ,p,S ml-1+Sjaj-piipi of-w a. with c., mN-1, mz-1 replaced by cj,a,, 13 3 m2 -p2jal respectively, with a constant cj,a,p depending on j, ,
a,s only. The first sum in (6.17) is CO and satisfies (3.2). The second sum is finite; its terms satisfy the proper estimate. To control the last sum, tj must be chosen according to (6.18)
(x)6'Z
s 2-j, as jaj+jPjs j.
This amounts to finitely many estimates, for each t, hence the selection is possible. In each term of the last sum we get I-1+1131 sN0sj, by construction of N0. Thus get the proper estimate,q.e.d. Lemma 6.5. Let {bj1:1=1,2,...} be sequences with the assumptions
77
1.6. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
of lemma 6.4, for j=1,2,... Also, let bj1E 1hm-(j+1)µ,p,S' µaO, so that the asymptotic sums bj = 2;=0 b
E 0 m_jIl,p,6 again
jk
form a sequence of symbols with the assumptions of lemma 6.4. Then
(6.19)
0 bjk
-7=0
=O4=0bk, j_k
=
(mod O_
where infinite sums are asymptotic. Equality in (6.19) is under-
stood only up to a term in yah_.. Proof. All symbols bjl ,j+l=k , are in the same class yahm-kµ,p,S hence their sum is in that class. Thus the asymptotic sum at right is meaningful. Denote the left and right hand side of (6.19) by b '
and b'
, and write bN =
fj,k=ob.k
,
b'N =
b 1 71 j+lsN j
.
Note that
bN - b'N is a finite sum of symbols of order m-Nµ hence itself is of that order. Moreover, b' - b'N is of order m-Nµ , while b-bN =b -
4 =0bj + 4=0(bj - Vk=0bjk)
again is of that order. Hence
b-b' _ (b-bN) + (bN_b'N) + (b'N-b') is of order m-Nµ , for all N = 0,1,2,... It follows that b-b' E 0_0. , q.e.d. .
Lemma 6.6. An asymptotic expansion (mod S) of the form (6.8), with a E yhm,p,o
,
aj EOyh
, m = m0
,
etc. may be differentiated
mj,p,s
term by term . That is, (6.8) implies
a(P)=Oaj(a) (mod S
(6.20)
The proof is evident: All remainders rN are symbols, their derivatives also are symbols, of orders tending to --, as N-- . Problems. 1) A polycylinder C=S'x)en-l is described analytically by
its universal cover
1n=2x1n_ 1={
(x, , x° ) : x, E 1, x° Etn- l } :Write C°°(C) )
={uE C°O(&n) : u periodic (2n) in x, }, S(kn_l),j=0,1,..,uniformly
with
S(C)={uE COO(C) :
aX u(x, , . E
in x}. Show that a tpdo A=a(x,D)E OpVt0
periodic (2n) in x, may be regarded as a map S(C)-
COO(C), given by Au(x)=
with u j(x° )= 2a
_ooel3xl
2n fa-ljx' u(x,,x° )dx,
x°
)uj
and the Fourier transform
0
""" with respect to x° regarded as a 4d o on
.
&n-1
2) The operator A=a(x,D) of pbm.1 may be with operator valued symbol, acting on
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
78
1n-1
functions on Rn-1 with values in C'°(S'): For
A(x° ,t") :COO(S' ) ,C
00
(S' ) by A(x" t" )u(9)=eljea(O,x" ,
define
j , where
2n
uj=
u(9)dO. Then write v(x")=u(.,x")
e-1
f oweix"t"
,
)v ( "),for VE S(Rn-1,COO(S' ))
and Av(x")
S(C). Show that,
for a symbol aE 9pto (and even for aE STS ) this operator A maps S(2n-1,C"(S'))
S(IIn-1,C,(S')), and continuously so when we equip + S(C)=S(1n-1,C°°(S')) with the Frechet topology of all norms must be 2nII(x")ku(a)Il 0 , k=0,1,..., aE IIn. (Recall that L
periodic in xi . ) 3) Investigate linear operators C00(S' B=A(x"
as
of pbm.1: Let Bu(xi )=;. fdyi el3(x' -y' )bj(X, )u(y,) , with
a sequence of functions b.(x,) , j=O,t1,t2,..., bounded in j and 2n-periodic (and C°°) in xi . First assume that bj(xt) is independent of j for j>>1 and j<<-1. Then B=b , (M)+b2 (M)H+K, with the Hil2n
bert transform H on S' (i.e., Hu(xi )=
dy, cot(x, -yi )/2 u(y,)
0
with a principal value integral) and with an operator K of finite
rank. Next assume that the limits limj.apj(xi)=Pt(xi) exist. Try for conditions still insuring the above form, whith more general K
4) Investigate the operators Bi
2)-1/2 and B2 =Dx Bi
2 -DX
in
the sense of pbm.3. 7.Strictly classical symbols; some lemmata for application. For many discussions, notably elliptic and hyperbolic theory it proves unnecessary to carry along the complicated classes of Hoermander developed for hypoelliptic theory. Let us introduce
,pm
= pm,(1,1),0 ,
setting p1 = p2 = 1
,
6 = 0
.
UCr = U
'_O, = n "m ,
m,
Symbols in y,cO,
,
and corresponding
operators in Opi,coo will be called strictly classical . Note that
(7.2)
'm C VIM C VSM C yitm
with the classes pt of (4.26) and 1,1
,
ps of ch.VIII.
The lemmata below are simple consequences of our calculus of
79
1.7. Strictly classical symbols Iyido's in sec.6. We are preparing them for later application.
It is clear that the classes Vtm and VCm , for finite at, are Frechet spaces under the collections of semi-norms, respectively,
x, E&n}
sup {ja(")(x, )fi(x)-m2
(7.3)
,
a,l EIIn
and
(7.4)
(a) a(P
sup
a,p EIIn
)I(x)-mZ+IaI(
)(x,
Similar sets of semi-norms for the classes t*m,p,b of sec.3 are suggested by the estimates (3.3),of course. Recall that a subset M of a Frechet space is called bounded if each semi-norm of a defining set remains bounded on M. Clearly
a bounded set of Pm is bounded in Vtm For a bounded set M of "m the set aE M} is bounded in ,tm -lal -ICI. Abounded set in
cur (Vtm ) is bounded in 4Cm, (Vt.,,) whenever
j=1,2.
Lemma 7.1. For bounded sets A={a}C cm, B={b}C yiam, the collection (7.5)
C
{c E 1ycm+m'° c(Ml,D)=a(Ml,D)b(Ml,D)
is bounded inm+m
a E A , b E B}
and the sets A* ={a*} of symbols of adjoints
and P = {p E i1cm : p(MrD) = a(M1,D)
Similarly , if
,
,c is replaced by it
Lemma 7.2. Let a E pcm , b e iycm,
.
,
a E A } are bounded in wcm in all the above.
Then we have , with e
a(M1,D)b(M1,D) - (ab)(M1,D) E OpyrCm+m'-e '
(7.6)
a(M1,D)
Also, if A = a(M1,D) (7.7)
E Opcm-e
a*(M1,D) - a(M1,D)
,
E
- a(Mr,D)
B = b(M1,D)
[ A, B] = AB - BA
Opicm-e
then
E Opyicm+m' -e
Moreover, if a, b range over bounded sets of lycm and VCm
respec-
tively then the symbols of the expressions in (7.6) and (7.7) 'c m-e, Vcm+m respectively. form bounded sets of Vcm+m'-a, V. m-e'
In fact, this is correct if we do not necessarily require that AC
yicm, and B C
Vcm,
are bounded, and a E A , b E B , but only that
respectively, for the 4 relations in (7.6), and (7.7),
(i ) {a0} bounded in tpCm-e,
,
and {b°} bounded in 1 cm-e.
,
80
1. Calculus of pseudodifferential operators
(ii) {a(8)} bounded in 4cm-e
(iii) {a(9)} bounded incm-e
(iv)
{a(e)} bounded in
,
Vcm-e'
and {a(0)} bounded in Vcm-e2
,
and {b(e)} bounded incur,-e,, and {b(0)} bounded in gym,-e2. For (i) ,...,(iv) the conditions are required for all 101=1
.
Remark 7.3: Using the 1-1-correspondence a « A=a(M1,D) between yucm and Opyscm, for x=c,t, one may transfer the Frechet topology of the
spaces 1xm onto their corresponding sets Op1xm. Then we may speak of bounded sets in Optcm for example. ,
Proof. Clearly (7.6) and (7.7) are consequences of thm.6.1, noting
that Wcm '*m,e,0' On the other hand all statements about bounded ness of sets follow by just going again over the proofs leading to thm.6.1, keeping in mind the boundedness of sets in Frechet spaces. For example, regarding boundedness of the set C of (7.6) it is sufficient to show that the constant of O(.) in thm.6.1, regarding (5.5), as well as the corresponding constants for the derivatives pN(a) of thm.6.2 of that remainder, all depend only on the bounds of the Frechet norms of a and b, in their bounded sets. This needs only be done for one N, say, for NO. Or even, one could estimate the first expression (4.6) of the Beals formula for the product symbol, in its finite part integral form (4.19), of course, using the principles of the proof of thm.6.1. Actually, going over that estimate again it becomes evident that indeed only bounds of expressions (6.2), for the symbols a and b, and corresponding bounds for the explicit symbols (7.8)
nm(x, ) =
mI (x) m2 E '4'am
and existing definite integrals over in
(7.9)
f(x) -rdx
,
r>n
as well as binomial and multinomial coefficients occur. We will not go over all the details again .
Chapter 2. ELLIPTIC OPERATORS AND PARAMETRICES IN In
In this chapter we focus at the main feature of our algebras They contain (generalized) inverses of some of their ope6 rators - called (md-)(hypo-)elliptic. For historical reason such an inverse is called parametrix or Green inverse. Speaking algebraically, we deal with inverses modulo some 2-sided ideal, either the class', of integral operators with kernel in S(12n) (K-parameOpWhp
:
metrix), or the operators of & with finite rank (Green inverse). Integral operators with kernel in S(&2n) are compact operators of L2(&n), as well as in every Sobolev space (cf.III,5). Thus a K-parametrix (Green inverse) of A will be an inverse mod K(H) (a Fredholm inverse) as well, under proper assumptions, giving normal solvability of the equation Au=f (cf. [C,],App.Al). For Oplhm p S 'elliptic' usually will be 'md-elliptic', amounting to ellipticity 'at and at jxI=co'-i.e., "d-" and "m-" ellipticity. This is parallel to discussions in algebras of singular integral operators ([Ci],[Cz]): For operators of order 0 'md-
elliptic' simply means that the symbol is #0 at 1x1+1V_o . An md-elliptic operator of order m will have a K-parametrix of order -m and existence of a K-parametrix of order -m is in ,
fact necessary and sufficient for md-ellipticity of AE Op'hm,p,S. However, it is possible for a non-md-elliptic operator to have a K-parametrix of order >-m. One such class of operators - the formally and-hypo-elliptic operators - is studied in sec.2.
The ellipticity concept can be localized, in the x-variable as well as in the 5-variable, and 'local parametrices' may be constructed under various assumptions. In particular, (formal hypo-) Rn ellipticity (for all ) over an open set 92 C implies hypo-ellipticity in the proper sense: All distribution solutions of Au=f are Coo(sl) whenever fE D' is Coo(ci) (cf. sec.3 and 4). For proper discussion of such facts we introduce the wave front set WF(u) of WE D' (sec.5), and show its invariance under spplication of ado's. In sec.6 we discuss (left)(right) md-ellipticity of a matrix of pdo's, together with certain partial inverses.
81
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
82
1. Elliptic and md-elliptic pdo's. Historically a parametrix is an integral kernel with a singularity similar to that of a Green's function, which can be used to invert a differential operator, up to an integral operator with continuous or smooth kernel (c.f. E.E.Levi [Lvl], D.Hilbert [Hbl]). Hoermander [Hr2] used the term 'parametrix' for a local inverse up to an infinitely smoothening operator, for a ipdo. Here we will use
a type of global parametrix with similar properties. Let A,B be lpdo's with symbol in ST. We shall say that B is a K-parametrix of A if we have AB-lE Opyh-o. , BA-1E Op%ph-,O. Clearly then A and B are
K-parametrices of each other. We speak of a left (right) K-parametrix B of A if only the second (first) condition holds. A symbol aE Phm,p,6C 1ph will be called md-elliptic (of order
for all sufficiently large
m) if (i)
and (ii)
the function b=1/a, well defined for large
equals some
symbol in Vh-m,p,S' for large jxI+1g1. Then the yxio A=a(x,D) also
will be called md-elliptic. We will see that md-ellipticity is a property of the operator, insofar as, for an md-elliptic A=a(M1,D) =b(Mr,D)=c(Mw,D) all 3 symbols a,b,c will be md-elliptic. Proposition 1.1.
A symbol a E 1phm,p,8 C Vh is md-elliptic if and only if, with constants c,c'>O, we have
(1.1)
I
a
c(a)m (x)m2
,
as IxI+IsI a c'
,
Proof.If a is md-elliptic we get b=1/a for large and bE hence (x)m` ), using I,(3.2). This implies -m,p,S' (1.1). Vice versa, if a symbol satisfies (1.1) then a(x, w-0, as C w-1, as defi nes a CC°(&2n)-function satisfying the first estimate I,(3.2). By lemma 1.2, below, it satisfies all estimates I,(3.2), q.e.d.
Lemma 1.2. Let Oy6aE COO(Sc). Then (1/a)is in the span of
(1.2)
j)/a)]/a
{[IIi (a(,CE3
:
Ya3 = a
,
f3 _ (3
}
This lemma follows by induction. Proposition 1.3. For aE iphmIp,SC 0, let A=a(M1,D). Let A also be given as A=b(Mr,D)=c(Mw,D)=d(M1,Mr,D), with symbols b,cE lphm p,g and dE SSm 'p 'b C SS. The following conditions are equivalent: (i) b is md-elliptic
;
(ii) c is md-elliptic
;
(iii)
is md-elliptic (of order m ). (iv) A is md-elliptic.
)
83
2.1. Elliptic and md-elliptic operators
This follows from calculus of do's: The symbol a may be expressed as an asymptotic sum of b or c or d and their derivatives. We get modulo terms of lower order. Thus (1.1) holds for all or for none of these functions, q.e.d. Proposition 1.4.(a) AE Opyah is md-elliptic if and only if A* is.
(b) The product AB of two md-elliptic operators AE Opwhm,P,a, B E OpVhm,,P1b again is md-elliptic (of order m+m') ,
Again this follows from calculus of ,do's. Recall that a differential operator A =
ac`Da is called
IaJSN elliptic at x0 if its principal symbol (1.3)
a
aa a
N
is #0 for x=x0 and all E Rn with
In that respect notice
prop.1.5 below, which also motivates our terminology. Proposition 1.5. A differential operator A=a(x,D)E Opy1hm,P,S
,
m=(N,m2) is md-elliptic (of order (N,m2)) if and only if a p(x)m"
(1.4)
,
for all x , and all
1
and also, with suitable constants p, c>O,
(1.5)
for all x,g with lxi a c
Ia(x,l;)I a
.
Proof. Note that 'jxI+ii large' means that 'either lxi is large or is large' (or both). The first points to (1.5), the second, for a differential operator A = a(M1,D) translates into (1.4), N-1( x) m,) . using that the terms al
all are
By (1.5) md-elliptic differential operators are elliptic in &n. (x)-m-A even is 'uniformly elliptic' in ien. (1.4), in effect, is another ellipticity, with variables Theorem 1.6. An operator AE OptNhm.P.b
x,
,
reversed.
admits a K-parametrix in
Optph of order -m if and only if A is md-elliptic.
Proof. If A and B are K-parametrices of each other then the relation AB=1 and the uniqueness of the left representation implies 1= modulo terms of order -Ee, e=(1,1), E>O. Thus it follows that jabi a1/2, as ac, for large c. Accordingly, jal
a2 b ap( )m' (x)m' ,
IxI+I
I
ac, p>O, using that b is of order -m
m'). Thus A is md-elliptic (order m). Vice versa, let A=a(M1,D) be md-elliptic. Using a recursion and I,lemma hence,
84
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
6.4 we will construct a K-parametrix for A. First, let b1 be a symbol such that ab1=1 for large by definition of md-ellipticity. If B1=b1(M1,D) then AB1-1=e1(x,D)
where order
e1 is of
Next set b2=e1/a, for large
correc-
ted to be C00(1 2n). Setting B2=b2(M1,D), get AB2+E1=e2(x,D)=E2 of
order -2a, where, again, we used lpdo-calculus for AB2. Together,
we get A(B1+B2)=1+E1-E1+E2=1+E2. It is clear now how to iterate: Next set b3=-e2/a, and B3= b3(M1,D), AB3+E2=E3=e3(M1,D), with e3 of order -3o, and A(B1+B2+B3)=1+E3, etc. Let B =7, Bj denote an
asymptotic sum. Then B-f=1Bj is of order -(N+1)a, by definition.
Also A(-1Bjj is again of order -No. Thus AB-1 is of order -No, for every N = 1,2,.... It follows that AB-1 must be of order --. Or, B is a right parametrix of A. Similarly construct a left parametrix B" of A. Get B =B AB=B (mod Opph-0), q.e.d. Finally, in this section, we show that Op4h-o,05(2n) = Lemma 1.7. The class Opih_.0 of ado's of order -oo coincides with
the class 'f of all integral operators (1.6)
Ku(x) = fk(x,y)u(y)gIy
,
u E S
with rapidly decreasing kernel k E S(&2n) Proof. We have seen before (cf. I,(2.16)) that the distribution kernel k of a yxlo is given as (1.7)
k(x,y) = a4'(x,x-Y) =
For aE ih-oo S(le2n) (1.7) is a well defined integral. The Fourier transform and b(x,y)- b(x,x-y) are isomorphisms S -S , q.e.d. 2. Formally hypo-elliptic yxlo's.
In sec.1 we found that a ipdo A of order m has a K-parametrix of order -m if and only if it is md-elliptic. It is possible, how-
ever, for A E C Wh to have a K-parametrix in OpWh m 1P'6 P'S with mj a-mj without being md-elliptic. Let aE iph C Wh. We shall say that a (or A=a(x,D)) is m,P,S
85
2.2 Formally hypo-elliptic operators formally and-hypo-elliptic if for
and (ii)
a=O((l;)
we have (i)
), with some m'=(m1
(x)m2
ml
), and (iii) for
all a,(3 the functions a((cc)/a satisfy the estimates
(2.1)
)-P'
a(a)/a = of(
In this case we shall call m'=(m1
m'
) an -inverse order of a
The symbol a is formally and-hypoLemma 2.1. Let a E m,PSC ph (ii) elliptic if and only if (i) a and a(c)/a are the functions of (i), for all a,(3, extend to symbols in 0m',p,S and Vh respectively, where .
,
ma
, (3
P,S ma',p
(2.2)
=
Proof. Trivially the condition of the lemma is stronger as that of the definition, because (2.1) is only the first I,(3.2), defining hma,p,p'S. We must show that also aXa
satisfy I,(3.2).
This follows from the lemma below easily proven by induction. Lemma 2.2. For all a,(3,x,X we have
00
span of the products
(2.3)=1(a(
)/a)
in the
3=163=a+k=103=(3+x , r=1,2,...
,
Again formal md-hypo-ellipticity is independent of the choice of left (right) multiplying representation. Proposition 2.3. Let A=a(M1,D)=b(Mr,D) with a, b E 0m,P,6C Vh Then A (or a) is formally md-hypo-elliptic if and only if b is Proof. From formula I,(5.4) we conclude that
(2.4)
j(i)191/9!
a is formally md-hypo-elliptic then the asymptotic sum (2.5)
c =
'01/e! a(e)/a e
is well defined, assuming that 1/a has been suitably modified for I xI +I
I < r!, to be C (&
2n )
This follows from lemma 2.1. Moreover,
the highest term in the sum (2.5) is identically 1, implying that the symbol c is md-elliptic of order 0 , by prop.l.1. One confirms easily that ca = b (mod iph_,O). Indeed, from (2.5) we get (2.6)
c -
/0! a(0)/a
E 1ih_(N(P'-S),Npz),P,S
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
86
This may be multiplied by the symbol a (2.7)
ca
a(9) E
,
using lemma 2.1, for N=0,1,2,....
m-Np+NSe',p,S
In other words, we get ca = b (mod 1ph_,,) , using (2.4), as stated.
Using I,lemma 6.6, (2.4) may be differentiated, for (2.8)
(mod
8(i)I0I/0l a(6+a)
Then, repeating the above conclusion we see that
(2.9)
b/a
,
a/b E 0 0,P.o
E'iph
b(P)/a
Again, the functions (2.9) must be modified on some KCC I2n independent of a,P, before they are symbols as stated. (2.9) implies
1/b = (1/a)(a/b) E hm',P,S
b(R)/b=(b(a)/a)(a,b) E 0 «,(3
m
,p,S
so that b is formally md-hypo-elliptic. Vice versa, if b is formal-
ly md-hypo-elliptic then a may be obtained as asymptotic expansion in terms of the derivatives of b. The above conclusion may be repeated to show that also a is formally md-hypo-elliptic, q.e.d. Proposition 2.4. (a) AE OplphMIP16C Op1ph is formally md-hypo-ellip-
tic if and only if A*, its adjoint, is. (b) If A=a(M1,D),B=b(M1,D) E UmOpylhm,p,8C Opyah are formally md-hypo-elliptic then so is AB. (c) The formally md-hypo-elliptic symbols of (b) form a group under pointwise multiplication, for each p,S. (d) An md-elliptic symbol of 1phmIP.SC 0 is formally md-hypo-elliptic, inverse order -m. Theorem 2.5. A formally md-hypoelliptic A=a(M1,D)E Oplphm,p,S ad-
mits a K-parametrix B=b(M1,D)E Opom"p'S, for suitable m'a-m. Proof. As in the proof of thm.1.6 we focus on construction of a right K-parametrix. First set b1=a, and B1=b1(x,D). By assumption b1E 1phm,,PS, and the product formula yields .
(2.10)
AB1-1=E1=e1(M1,D)
,
e1= Ie ,0(_i)
e
a(e)bl(0) (mod
By lemma 1.2 the term a(e)bl(0)=a(e)(1/a)(e) is in the span of {(a(())/a)rI(a('j) /a)
:
YaJ=6}
.
Lemma 2.1 yields a(e)bl(e)E
Vh-Np+NSe',p,S' I0I=N. Accordingly el E y't2_p+Se',p,S has order less than (0,0), as in thm.1.6.
Next, in the recursion, define b2=-el/aE lphm'-p+Se',p,g Try to verify that B2=b2(M1,D) satisfies AB2=-E1+E2, with E2=e2(x,D),
e2E 1ph_2p+6e' , p , S
Indeed we get
2.3. Local md-ellipticity (2.11)
AB2+E1=e2(M1,D)
A term a(e)(el/a)(e) (2.12)
{
,
e2 =
10
for 101 = N
87
f0a(0)(el/a)(0) (mod
h-,0)
is in the span of
(a(e)/a) el(a) II.(aWj)/a)
:
a + I P3 = N }
again by lemma 1.2. Using lemma 2.1, confirm the proper conditions e2. Evidently the recursion of thm.1.6 works again, q.e.d. 3. Local md-ellipticity, and local md-hypo-ellipticity.
Recall that (formal) md-(hypo-) ellipticity of a symbol aE is a condition for large If a is modified in a set KCC R2n these conditions are not disturbed. y,h
,
city y
A parallel, though slightly different concept of md-elliptiintroduced in [C l],for the operators of some C -subalge-
bras of L(L2(&n)). Similar algebras are studied in [C2] for general noncompact manifolds c. Their operators also have symbols now defined over the boundary of a compactification of the cotangent
bundle T*S1 - for 11=1n for (x +
=o, at the 'boundary' of
R2n
The generators of such an algebra are yxio's as studied here. In [C1], ch.IV, a compactification Pnxien of RnxIn=R2n appears.
The symbol of an operator A in the algebra, called A, for a moment ffi=d(1QnxPn)=Pnxpn\R2n of PnxPn. is only defined at the boundary Then AE A is called md-elliptic if its symbol is #0 on M. md-ellipticity is necessary and sufficient for AE A to be invertible modulo operators of finite rank. The algebra A is generated by the special pdo's a(M) and b(D), where a,bE COO(R2n) are bounded and have
a(a)=o(1), bO)=o(1), as lxl-oo, for all a. len just is the smallest compactification such that all such a,b extend to C(P). This result on C*-algebras of pdo's offers some guide lines on the question of local md-ellipticity. Within A we speak of mdellipticity of AE A in a subset MC ffi if its symbol is #0 near M .
For fixed p,S consider AP,b, the closure of p'hO,P,b within
CB(R2n).
The maximal ideal space of this function algebra is a compacPP,6 tification of R2n - again the smallest to which all functions of ffiP,b=dPP s=PP,b\R2n again. Vh0,P,6 extend continuously. We set is md-elliptic if and only if Proposition 3.1. A symbol aE m,P,6 (the continuous extension to 2P,s of) the function b(x,l;) =
m, (x) mZ
00,P,S does never vanish on the set fP,6
The proof follows from (1.1) and prop.1.4, and md-ellipticity
88
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
of (gy)m' (x)m'=
Vhm,p,b, using ospjst and Sao
.
Remark: A result of III,1 below implies that OpiihO'p's, for bsp,
is an adjoint invariant subalgebra of L(L2(&n)). The results on A sketched above, may be also derived for the norm closure Ap'o of OpPh0,p b, assuming pj>O, 0<6
Following the above lead, a symbol aEm,p,b will be called md-elliptic in a set MC 2p'b if (the continuous extension to &p,b) of is #0 on M. We reformulate this definition, avoiding reference to values of b: Definition 3.2.
Vhm,p,b is called md-elliptic in MC ffip'b if there exists a neighbourhood N of M in Bp,b with (1.1) in 2n for every KCC N. A symbol aE 0m,p,b is called formally mdKfl it hypoelliptic in M if (i),(ii),(iii) of sec.2 are valid in Kfl I2n
KCC N, with N as above. Again we call m' the inverse order of a The first part of def.3.2 is equivalent to our first definition of local md-ellipticity, because a continuous function is 340
at a point p if and only if it is bounded away from 0 near p. Def.3.2 still contains a reference to MC ffip'bC Bp'b. Also, Bp,b is of Stone-Cech type - its subsets are too general for our purpose. It seems practical to get restricted to a special kind of subsets M : The functions s(x), Ph0 generate a subalgep,b bra B of A for p sl, ba0. The maximal ideal space of B is a b, compactification of &2n again- it equals BnxBn, with the directional compactification Bn of Rn (cf. sec.5 or IV,1, below). Bn consists of &n and the ' infinite' set { oac° : x° E Rn x° I =1 } . The function s=(sl...sn)(x) provides a homeomorphism I B1={xE Rn,IxI<1}. 3n is characterized by the property that s(x) extends to a homeomorphism B"H Bi={jxjs1} The inclusion is an isomorphism, .
its dual is a surjective map t:B]BnxBn . Henceforth we will apply def.3.2 only for sets MC ffip'b of the form M=L_1M' with M'E a(BnxEn) Then we may choose the neigh.
bourhood N of def.3.2 in the form N=L-1N' where N' is a neighbourhood of M' in BnxBn. ffir,d does not enter the estimates of def.3.2. Thus we refer to M', N' only, i.e., in def 3.2 replace ffip,b by
M°=a(BnxBn), changing notation from M',N' to M,N. An aE h 0,p,6 needs not to extend to C(I0), but for symbols of differential operators and their parametrices we have that property in W below:
I° = a (BnxBn) = IQnxaBn U aBnxaBn U aBnxln the first term at right denoting WC ffi°
xE ien,
E aBn}=w. The set
will be called the wave front space, in view of an applica-
89
2.3. Local md-ellipticity
tion in sec.5. If M is a subset of W then we will drop 'md-' and refer to a symbol (formally hypo-) elliptic in M. For M of the form M=XxaBn, with XC 2n the operator A=a(x,D) and its symbol a are called (formally hypo-) elliptic in %, in agreement with conventions for differential operators. For more general MC W another notation is in common use: Such sets are called non-characteristic sets of the operator A and symbol a (cf. [T12], [Tr1], [Hr3]). The union Xp BnxaBn of the first two terms in (3.1) and Ms= asnxien, the third term, are called the principal and secondary symbol space, resp. For MC ffis we speak of m-(hypo-)ellipticity. In [CP] a symbol aE Vhm p,sC Vh (formally) md-(hypo-) elliptic over Htp BnxaBn was called (formally) d-(hypo-) elliptic. "md-(hypo-)
elliptic over Mp "just amounts to the conditions of (formal hypo-) aol ellipticity in some instead of a set IxI+IIaq. If a symbol is md-(hypo-) elliptic over M C M°=a(BnxBn), for ,
an open set M, then one may expect a local parametrix for the corresponding lpdo A=a(x,D). We mainly will consider the case MC W, noting that the case MC ffis may be treated similarly, reversing x, Instead of a local parametrix as in [Hr:] we construct a global i,do inverting mod C00in some set M of (formal hypo) ellipticity. Let be a symbol in Vhv,p,sC ph, for some vE &2. A sym.
bol aE 0 m,p,6 will be called formally md-hypo-elliptic with res pect to q if for xI+I xj some fl>0, we have (i) ay60 in supp cp ,
(iii) the restriction of a(R)/a to the set extends to a symbol in Vh m R ,P,S with ma'P of (2.2). If m'=-m we will call a md-elliptic with res(ii) TE 1hv+m',p,6 supp T
'
,
,
pet to T. Clearly a (formally) md-(hypo-) elliptic symbol is just a (formally) md-(hypo-)elliptic symbol with respect to T=1. be (formally) md6 (hypo-)elliptic with respect to T. Then we have ejE hv-m',p,S j=1,2, where m'=-m in the elliptic case such that A=a(x,D), Ej= Theorem 3.3. Let Tr= lphv P16
ej(x,D), (D1=cp(x,D)=y(M1,D),
(3.2)
AE1 = (D1 + K1
and let aE lPhm,p
,
(D.
=cp(Mr,D)
2
satisfy the relations
E2A = 02 + K2
,
,
K1,K2 E Op'tih-oo
.
Proof. 'Elliptic' just means m'=-m, hence needs no special consideration. We look at E1 only, taking adjoints for E2. With E2=B we once more go through the construction of the right parametrix of by (ii). Write thm.1.6 (or 2.5). Set b0=a, getting b0E v+m',p,S' (3.3)
AB0=(1+c0(x,D)
,
c0= J
J11
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
90
where the asymptotic sum c0E hm+v+m'-p+6e',p,6' The next correction will be b1=-c0/a. Dividing (3.3) by a we get bl as an asymptotic sum of terms in the span of (a(0)/a)(a)(9)
(3.4)
It follows that bl E 0v+m'-p+Se' (3.5)
AB1=-c0(x,D)+C1(x,D)
,
101 Z1
I
and that
c1=-
j(-i)101/0!a(0)(c0/a)(9)
This then leads into the recursion bN =-cN-1/a (3.6)
BN = bN(x,D)
ABN =-cN-1(x,D)+cN(x,D) , CN 1.f-1(-0101/0!a(0)bN(0)
N=1,2,...
with
,
.
We show that, successively, bN, cN are of proper order
B. well defined, while the orders of C I
N
tend to
As instrument in this proof we use the lemma below. Proposition 3.4. Each symbol bN ,N=1,2,... of terms in the span of the expressions (3.7)
is an asymptotic sum
nj=!(x((33/a) : LjOal=L40PJ=101
where 101 a N , for bN
E
,
.
Clearly prop.3.4 yields bNE 0v+m'-N(p-Se')' hence cN abN+l v+m+m'-N(p-Se') has orders tending to -oo. The asymptotic sum 0bN b E E O v+m',p,6 is well defined and gives the desired e1=b.
Thus thm.3.3 is reduced to prop.3.4. We prove prop.3.4 by induction: It is true for N=1. (3.6) gives (3.8)
bN+l = -
j(-i)101/9!(x(0)/a)bN(e)
.
If bN is as in prop.3.4 we may reorder the double series by I, lemma 6.6, and get an asymptotic sum of terms in the span of (3.9)
(a(e,)/a)bN(e')
19112:1
where bN runs through all terms (3.7) is of the form (3.7)
,
for 101=N. Each term (3.9)
q.e.d. for 191Z N+1 We now apply thm.3.3 to a locally (hypo-)elliptic symbol: ,
,
Proposition 3.5. Let the symbol aE yMIP' 6C h be (formally hypo-)
elliptic in an open set MC W, and let TE yihv, p , 6 , T=_0 for (x,) O_ K with KCC NC BnxEn
,
as in def.3.2. Then the symbol a is (formally)
91
2.4. Formally hypo-elliptic expressions
md-(hypo-) elliptic with respect to q (so that thm.3.3 applies). Also apply thm.3.3 to the (formally) d-(hypo-) elliptic case:
Proposition 3.6. If aE 0m,P,b is (formally) d-(hypo-)elliptic, then it also is (formally) md-(hypo-)elliptic with respect to any n function where xE C (& ), x=1 for sufficiently large x=o in a spere ICI s rl, for sufficiently large i1>O. The proof for both prop's is immediate. It already was seen
that (formal) d-(hypo-)ellipticity amounts to (formal) md-(hypo-)
ellipticity for large IxI only, not for Problems. 1) Discuss md-ellipticity on a cylinder in the setting of 1,6, pbm's 1-4. Require the operator family C
00
(S') invertible for
i xA I + I ° I
L2(S' ), that
')II=
large; also, in the norm (III of MI-pt IaI+olII), a,(3 II
O((x^)mz-Pz
E IIn, as in I,(3.2)-(3.3). Discuss construction of a K-parametrix
B with 1-AB, 1-BAE4V (!fit as in 11,0, but with L(L2 (S' ))-valued kernels). 2) Show that the abovetf(with operator-valued kernel) contains noncompact operators of L2(S'x&n-1), but that KE Xwith kernel in K(L2(S')) is compact. 3) For mutual K-parametrices A,B, as in pbm.1, a K(L2(&n-1))-valued symbol may be defined for each, AB= I+K and BA=i+Kz, K.E. If and only if these symbols are invertible the operators A and B are Fredholm operators of 4) The generators [Cz ],VIII,(2.2) of the C *-algebra C there -i.e., L2(S'x&n-1)
on our polycylinder C=S'xRn-1, the multiplications by a(x)E COO(e) (2n-periodic in xi), and the operators A , ax A , axzA, ..., A = (1-A)-1/2 (on C) all are pdo's as in pbm.1 (verify!). Discuss the relation of pbm.3 above with [Cz],VIII,thm.2.6. 4. Formally hypo-elliptic differential expressions. Let a be a domain of &n, and let L = a(x,D) =
(4.1)
a (x)D'
IaTsN
a
be a differential expression with Co coefficients shall call L (or its symbol
:
(i) a(x,l;) (ii)
(iii) a(() /a
30 0 ,
as x E K ,
ICI Z 11
as x E K ,
for
i, p, such that
every compact set K C c there exist constants Mi,
(4.2)
E C'(S2). We
a a )formally hypo-elliptic if
,
ICI a 'n
,
as x E K , ICI a 1
.
(ii) is superfluous if L is locally of order >0 - i.e., L is
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
92
of order Nx near x, with 0
, by (iii).
This yields (ii) locally, with M,=-Nxp, because aa(x) is bounded away from zero, locally, for suitable a. This also shows that M,= -p Min Nx s-p usually may be assumed negative For a constant coefficient L=a(D) of order >0 formal hypoel:
lipticity is equivalent to hypo-ellipticity in the sense of the definition in ch.0, sec.5. This was shown by Hoermander [Hr1],p.101. On the other hand there exist hypo-elliptic expressions with variable coefficients which are not formally hypo-elliptic. Here we use our parametrices of sec.3 for the following: Theorem 4.1. A formally hypo-elliptic differential expression is of (ii) can be chosen <0 (as true for L of locally positive order) then L-X is hypoelliptic for all XE M Proof. The second statement follows from the first, because for M,<0 we get hypo-elliptic. If M,
.
liml
uniformly on KCC
l
a
for
,
the theorem is best looked at in the light
of invariance of the wave front set of sec.5, below. We actually will use thm.5.4, below. Assume uE D'(cz'), fE C00(SZ'), for some
open Sz' C S2, and let Lu=f in Sz' . We must show that uE COO(Sc') . Fix a point x0E Sz', and balls B(x0,6)
,
B(x0,26) with center x0, radius
6, 26, closures C Sz'. Let TE Co, T=1 near x0, supp T C B(x0,6)
Define a global extension
a as follows: Let
XE C0"O([0,25)), x=1 in [o,6], x=o in [2O,00), 0stx(t)s2O. Define (4.3)
(4.4)
and that
a(x0+(x-x0)x(Ix-x0I)
,
)
,
a0E PcN.O C Vh(N,0),(P,1),O
for x, E in
,
a0 is formally d-hypo-elliptic in the latter space, with
inverse order M=(M1,0). By prop.3.6 a0 is formally md-hypoelliptic with respect to a suitable X(U), x=0 near 0 x=1 near -. By thm. ,
3.3 construct EE OphM
,O
with Ea0(x,D)=x(D)+K, KE Opih-o,. Clearly
a=a0, as xE B(x° ,6), hence cpa = cpa0, for all
assuming the
left hand side zero whenever a is undefined. Accordingly
(4.5)
cpf = cpLu = Lcpu + [cp,L]u = L0((pu) + [cp,L0]'yru
with another cut-off p, supp V C B(x,26), 0
=1 in supp [cp,L0]
93
2.5. The wavefront set Note that yfE CO(&n)C S, while puE E'(&n)C S'. Thus guE HS, for
some s, and h=[q,LO]VuE Ht, for some t. Clearly, h=O near x°, 0 since cp=1 near x causing the commutator to vanish. We get x in sing supp Eh , using the complement of sing supp h . Hence x° thm.5.4, below. Applying the operator E to (4.5) we get ,
(4.6)
epu+ (1-x)(D)qu + Kcpu = E(pf - Eh .
Here EcpfE S, since cpfE S. Also KfuE S, since TuE S', and K has or-
der (--,-oo) . Also, w=1-xE CO(&n)C S, thus w(D)cpu f 9Tyw' (x-y) ((Pu) (y) E S, the distribution integral existing, due to a E S, puE S'. Also Eh is C" near x°, hence Tu is C" near x0. Since T=1 near x0
we find that also u is C" near x0 Since this construction may be done for every x0 E fz' the theorem is proven. We made extensive use of hypo-ellipticity in [C,],II,IV. Hypo-ellipticity of L-?. especially of L.-ti is required to make the Carleman alternative work, as well as in general the construction of e.s.a.-realizations in [C:],II. .
,
,
5. The wave front set and its invariance under.Vdo's. We define the wave front set WF(u) of a distribution uE D'(sz) over a domain cC &n as a subset of the wave front space W=OT(fa)
,
already discussed in sec.3, for the special case ft=&n. For a gene-
ral fcC &n we define 1(fz)=fzxaznC &nxa16n=0r(&n)
.
It is common practice to interpret this space as T=fzxSn, i.e.,
(5.1)
T = W(c) = {(x,i;)
:
x E sz
,
E &n
,
ICI = 1 }
.
Similarly, for distributions on a differentiable manifold a one defines LT(n) as the "co-sphere bundle", i.e. the bundle of unit spheres in the cotangent space, with respect to a suitable smooth of a Riemannian metric. It is clear then that the unit vector pair as t - - , with x E =-n just indicates the direction tx where the real point (x,«1) is to be found. In other words, for a manifold sz the wave front space is properly defined as the subset ,
W of the symbol space $1(R)
,
as defined in [C2] ,VI, p.161.
One defines WF(u) as a subset of W by its complement WF(u)c= W\WF(u), as follows. Specify two types of cut-off functions called cp(x), and respectively. For x0E sz a cut-off cp is a C func-
tion, cpa0, y=1 near x°. For a "direction" o0E a>sn given by °E &n with 1°1=1 a cut-off
is a C(Zn) -function, "0, x=1 near
x=0 outside some neighbourhood of °, and, 'Wl&nE C"(&n). Also, x
94
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
One equals some homogeneous function of degree 0 for large where x=0 near 0,
may think of a C(I)-function
=1 near oo
,
µ=1 near l;°
s
We define: (x0, 0)E WF(u)c (i.e., is not in WF(u)) , ,p , such that, with the Fourier transform 11^61
if there exist cp
,
ES
(5.2)
zero outside S2, a Note that Tu admits a natural extension to I distribution in S' hence has a Fourier transform in S'. ,
,
WF(u)c if and only if there exist resp., such that the ipdo C=1p(D)g(x)
Proposition 5.1. We have cut-offs cp,1p, near x and E OpipcO'-OO takes u into S
ip(D)cp(x)u E S
.
The proof is evident,since C=F-11pFg, and because the inverse
Fourier transform F-1 is an isomorphism of S onto itself. From the definitions of WF(u) and s.s.u we conclude:
Proposition 5.2. The singular support s.s.u of uE DI(n) is the projection of WF(u) to the first component Sz of W=S2xa18n s.s.u = {x: there exists F; such that (x,l;)E WF(u)}
(5.3)
.
Indeed, if xE (s.s.u)c, then a cut-off cp can be found with cpuE C0C S, so that (Tu) E S, -i.e. every WF(u)c. Vice versa if for some x every Wf(u)c, then (cu)^E S (i.e., guE S) fol-
lows for suitable T: The unit sphere is compact, and for 11;1=1 we
can find ((p"u)^ip"E S. A finite collection 1pj=,pj has supports cove-
ring the sphere, so that 1pj=vj/yvj is a partition of unity. Let be a cut-off near x with cpp
=cp
(P_
for all j (i.e. T 0 =1 on supp
(p- ), then ((p-u)^1pj E S, by prop. 5.3. Hence (cp u) (Jipj)E S. But it is possible to arrange for w--Y, y,jal outside a large sphere, and
have (o homogeneous of degree zero there. Adding a suitable C,(iQn)-
functions x we get w+xa1 in &n, and ((x+x)-1E T, the space of Coo(len)-functions with derivatives of polynomial increase. Thus (cp u)^ w+ E S, hence (y- u)^ E=- S, since 1-w/(w+x)=x/(x+w)E Co, and Coo
near x, or xE (s.s.u)c, q.e.d. C. Hence cp uE S, uE We have used the proposition below, also useful later on:
((p u)^E
95
2.5. The wavefront set Proposition 5.3. If we have ((pu)^tpE S , with a pair of cut-offs
q, 1p and a distribution u, and if qi cp=cp, for a cut-off qi , then we also get (qf u)^ V E S . Proof. We know that ((pu)^,p E S is equivalent to p(D)q>(x)u E S
and similarly for qi instead of T (5.4)
.
Write
'cp(D)cp u = ip(D)cp(x)gi u = qi ip(D)p(x)u + [1p(D),gi (x)]pu ,
where the first term,at right, is in S For the second term we use the asymptotic expansion of the calculus of ydo's : We get .
(5.5) p[W (x),cV(D)]=p(x,D), p=-
(0)(x) (mod S)
X01i9lp(0)
>0
Each term of p is =0, hence p(x,D)E O(-oo). The last term of (5.4)
also is in S, due to p(x,D)*=-[1p(D),gi (x)]cp(x)E O(-oo). Theorem 5.4. Let u E ES' in some 1phm,p,s
,
and let A = a(x,D) be a ido with symbol
, with the usual inequalities 0sO
(5.6)
Q.E.D.
and s.s.Au C s.s.u .
,
Proof. We are using As and O(s) of ch.III, here,
for convenience.
It is sufficient to prove the first inclusion (5.6), by prop.5.2.
We must show that
WF(u)c implies
WF(Au)c. For (x,t)
E WF(u)c we have 1p(D)gp(x)uE S with suitable cp,ip. It is found that
(5.7)
p(D)cp(x)Au = AV(D)cp(x)u + [C,A]u , C = 1p(D)cp(x)
,
where the first term at right is in S, since A takes S to S. uE S' is in some Es, sE 22, since S'=Uts. [C,A] is of lower differentiation order than A (and of multiplication order -o). In order to get the desired property for Au , we will iterate the proceedure as follows. Construct sequences of cut-off functions
such that q
(5.8)
)
Cju E S
,
j = 0,1, ...
, where Cj = 1pj(D)gpj(x)
.
Proposition 5.5. We have C0C =CC0 =C0 (mod O(-oo)), CjCj+1= Cj+1Cj= Cj+1 (mod O(-0°)).
(5.9)
Proof. We have CCO = 1p(D)cp(x)tpO(D)gO(x) = ip0(D)cp0(x) + +
1p(D)[cp(x),VO(D)]q)O(x)
Hence it is enough to show that But we have
the last term, called V for a moment, is in O(-oo)
.
96
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
(5.10) V*=z(x,D)
S),
,
where again all terms of the asymptotic sum vanish identically Accordingly V* E O(-oo) , hence V E O(--) . This shows that CC0= C (mod O(-oo)) On the other hand, Similarly for CiCj+1 .
.
C0C = V0(D)T0(x)V(D)T(x) = 140(D)cp0(x) + VO(D)[TO(x),V(D)]T(x)
Let W be the last term. Consider the asymptotic expansion of W* W
=p(x,D)
,
(mod S)
le
which again implies W* E O(-oo) since all terms vanish, q.e.d.
Using prop.5.5, we may write CNAu = CN-1CNAu (mod S) = CN-1ACNu + CN-1[CN,A]u (mod S)
(5.11)
=CN-2CN-I[CN,A]u (mod S) = CN-2[CN-1'[CN,A]]u (mod S)
_ ... = [C,[C0,[C1..... [CN-1,[CN,A]]] ...]]u (mod S)
.
Here the N+2-fold commutator has multiplication (differentiation) order -- (ml-(N+2)(pl-O)) Accordingly the right hand vector of .
(5.11) is in HM'c., for every M, as N gets large. Thus CNAuE HM'co,
as N>NO(M). The q)k,Vk may be constructed such that
(Pk=1 in a fixed neighbourhood N of x (and similarly for Vk and a neighbourhood N' of ) . Thus we can find cut-offs cp" , 1p" with cp" qpk=f" "Vk=V" , for
all k . Using prop.5.5 we thus get (5.12)
C Au = C"CNAu E HM',, ,
for every M
C Au E S = fl Hs
This completes the proof of.thm.5.4. Corollary 5.6.
Let AE Opyih be formally md-hypo-elliptic with res-
pect to a symbol q' (5.13)
Morever, if q) (5.14)
.
Let uE S', and let Au=f, and cp(x,D). Then
WF(f) C WF(u)
,
and WF(4i) C WF(f)
.
(i.e., if A is formally md-hypo-elliptic),then WF(u) = WF(f)
.
The proof is an evident consequence of thm.5.4 and thm.3.3.
2.6. Systems of operators
97
6. Systems of ipdo's.
It is often convenient to consider a vxµ=matrix (6.1)
A = ((Ajl))j=1,..,v,l=1,..,FL
,
Ajl= ajl(M1,MrD)
of pdo's where we generally assume that aj1 E SSm'P'b C SS, m,p,b independent of j,l. Introduce a matrix-valued symbol and write aE SSm'P'b, and A=a(M1,Mr,D). In the present section, we will use all symbol class notations, such as ST, yah, hm,p,d also for vxµ-matrices to indicate that the entries are in the corresponding symbol class. The operator A of (6.1) will act on spaces of µ-vector-valued functions or distributions. All formulas of the pdo-calculus of ch.I remain valid, except those involving a commutator, such as I,(7.5). For md-ellipticity we focus on square (µxµ-) matrices of Idols We call A=a(x,D)E Opyahm,p,b (and its symbol a) md-elliptic if
E0 11m,P,6
(6.2)
is md-elliptic. A symbol aE SS (and its operator A) will be called
md-elliptic if
is md-elliptic.
Lemma 6.1. A square-matrix-valued symbol aE 1h is md-elliptic m,p,b if and only if for with some T>0 the matrix ,
a square-matrix-valued symbol bE
Vh-m
p,b
such that
as
Trivially the Hilbert space adjoint of an elliptic pdo and the product of 2 elliptic pdo's are elliptic again. We can expect a theorem like thm.1.6 for square matrices, and even a more general result for rectangular matrices. For the latter let us define as follows: If for a pair of (vxµ- and µxv-) symbols aE hm,p,b , bE Vh-m p,b ,resp., we have (for some 1>0) (6.3)
1 = ((6j1))j11=1,.,v' for all
then we will call a right md-elliptic and b left md-elliptic
rj
.
We then must have v:5µ. a is elliptic if and only if it is left and
right elliptic. b is then called a right inverse symbol of a, etc. be (right) (left) and-elTheorem 6.2. Let a vxµ-symbol aE m,p,b liptic, and let bE yh-m,p,b be a (right) (left) md-inverse symbol. There exists a (right) (left) K-parametrix E=e(x,D), eE 4h-m,p,6'
of the pdo A=a(x,D) such that
(6.4)
E'U (-m.-p.+6,-m2 -p2 ),p,6 '
2. Elliptic operators and parametrices
98
Vice versa, if a (right) (left) parametrix of A of order -m exists then A (and a) will be (right) (left) md-elliptic. We prove thm.6.2 like thm.1.6, constructing a right or left K-parametrix. If both exist they coincide mod O(-o3), as usual.
Many 'hypo-elliptic' arguments work as in the scalar case. For matrix-valued symbols there is another interesting case of constant rank for large to consider: Assume the matrix and that, moreover, aE yahmp,, allows a decomposition a = a0+a1
(6.5)
,
a1E 0m',p16 , m'<m ,
where a0 allows a 'partially md-inverse symbol' b0E 11h-,,,,b
the sense that
,
in
is a gxv-matrix with for large
(6.6)
where
is a vxv-projection matrix of the same rank as and
i.e.,
Clearly (6.6) and rank p0=rank a0 imply im p0 projects onto im a0, hence 1-p0 vanishes on im a0, i.e, (1-p0)a0=0. Introduce Then get g0-q02= also is a b0a0-b0a0b0a0=b0a0-bOp0a0=b 0(1-p0)a0=0, so that projection. Evidently rank g0(x,t)=rank p0(x,t), im p0 = im b0 Generally, if b=b0+b1, where b1E yh-m',p,S, with -m'<-m , we will call the symbols a and b partially md-inverse to each other. .
Theorem 6.3. Assume that aE and bE Vh-m,p,S are partially md-inverse symbols of each other (where p>0 pl>S). Let p=ab , q=ba Then and let A=a(x,D) B=b(x,D) P=p(x,D) Q=q(x,D) ,
,
(6.7)
,
AB - P = r(x,D)
,
,
.
,
BA - P = s(x,D)
,
where the symbols are vxv-matrix-valued and µ.xµfor some e>0 matrix-valued, respectively, and are in `Vh_Ee,p,S
,
The proof is calculus of ,do's. We cannot expect better para metrices making r or s of order -- , with improved B, etc. Matrix-symbols also occur in VI,IX,X, under different aspects
Chapter 3. L2-SOBOLEV THEORY AND APPLICATIONS.
0. Introduction. In this chapter we consider ipdo's as linear operators of
a class of weighted L2-Sobolev spaces over in . We specialize on L2-spaces and neglect LP-theory, because 'ydo's in general are
not continuous operators on LP-Sobolev spaces, for p#2 . To be more precise, general L2-boundedness theorems for xdo's are true for A=a(x,D)E OpiPh0,p,6
,
assuming pa0, 0s6!-.pi, 6341, but corres-
ponding LP-boundedness statements are false, except for p'=1. There is an extensive theory in LP-spaces of Sobolev and other
types (cf. Beals [B
Coifman-Meyer [ CM] , Marshall [ Mri ] , Muramatu [ Mml] , Nagase [Ng, ], Yamazaki [Ymi ]). 41,
In sec's 1, 2 we prove the L2-boundedness theorem, for 6=0, respectively. This result often is quoted as CalderonVaillancourt theorem. In sec.3 we look at weighted L2-Sobolev and 0<6s1
,
norms. Our class of spaces Rs=HS1,s: is left invariant by the Fourier transform, just as many of our ydo-classes. A y,do of order m=(mi,m2) is a bounded map Hsa Hs-m , for every s. For every m E 12 an order class O(m) is introduced - the operators S-S extending to operators in L(H ,H ) 0(m) is a Frechet space s s-m for all s under the norms of L(Hs Hs-m) ; O(0) and O(-)=U O(m) are algebras. A pdo of order m belongs to O(m). .
A refined Fredholm theory holds for (formally) md-(hypo-) elliptic Ado's. Such an operator admits a Green inverse- the equivalent of the integral operator of the generalized Green's function. This is discussed in sec.4. In sec.5 we prove that ado's of negative order (m,<0, mz<0) are compact operators Hs-CHs, for all s. 1. L2-boundedness of zero-order y,do's.
We refer to the class Vt0=lh(0,0),(0,0),0
of symbols here,
as introduced in I,(4.26), and discuss the following result. Theorem 1.1. An operator A=a(M1,D) E Oppt0 is bounded in H=L1(1n). and belongs to L(H). More precisely: The restriction AJH maps
99
100
3. L2-Sobolev theory
This result is quoted as the Calderon-Vaillancourt theorem (c.f.[CV1]). For independent proofs c.f. [CC], and VIII,thm.2.2, below. The very short approach below is due to Beals [B3]. Proof. Construct a partition of unity for &n, as follows. With the cube Qr {Ixjl0 in Q312. Define ncpa)-1/2.
cpa(x)=cp(x-a), aE 2n, and Wa a(
Clearly then
(3E2
(1.1)
Va E CD({xE &n:lx-aI<2,j=1,...,n})
a1Va2(x)=1
,
Va s 0
Given some symbol a E iVt0 we define (1.2)
Aa = aa(x,D)
We first show that AaE L(H). Since the Fourier transform is unitary we may show Ba FAaF1E L(H). But for aE ipt0, supp aC {Ixlsp}
FAF-lu(11) = J41Xe ixr1JR1
(1.3) = fol
u(U)J41x
Joie as
-T1.S) u(S)
(
with "I" with respect to x written as "u", and trivial integral interchanges. The integral operator at right of (1.3) is L2-bounded by Schur's lemma We get the operator bound
(1.4)
f
,Jdtla``(t-q,t)I
sup
:
,T1 Elen}
In particular, (
-''1) 2Nav( -l1,
)
= J
x a(x, ) (l-Ax)Neix(
-Tl)
=J1xaN(x, )eix( -q) , with aN = (1-Ax)Na
which implies
D((-rl)-2N IIaNIi
(1.6) hence
(1.7)
IIAIIL2
s
c IIaNII
,
2N > n ,
where c depends only on N , n and p . We need an improved estimate for the operators (1.8)
Aap = Aa'Wl3(M) = aap (M1,Mr,D)
aap=Va(x)WR(Y)a(x,)
101
3.1. L2-boundedness of zero-order operators
Taking the Fourier transformed operator A^ for A=a(M1,Mr,D) again, we get with a(x,y,l;) vanishing for (x,y) outside KCC &2n ,
fl-ixil
(1.9) A^u=FAF-lu(T1)=
JFTKely'{u(x)
Integrals interchange readily, as uE S. Therefore,
(1.10)
A^ U(T1) =
f91K U(K) fo1 alk
With the methods used to derive (1.6) one finds that = IIaNNII Loo
aNN = (1-Ax)(1-Ay)Na Note that (1.11) implies
f
(1.12)
0((K_,,) -2N)
IIaNNII LOO
Here it is important to observe that the "O(.)-constant" depends only on n,N, and the volume of the compact set K, the latter since an L1-norm has to be estimated by the corresponding Lc norm. Also,
-2N(-K) -2N= f
-2N, and f ((t) (2s-t) )-2Ndt
-(T1-x))
ItIfIsl + ItIJIsl = I1+I2
,
where 1
c(s)-2N,
c=f(t)-2Ndt
2
For the integral I1 the inequality implies 12s-tI22Isl-ItI2lsI so that the integrand is bounded by (s)-2N(t)-2N
,
i.e., we get
the same estimate as for 1 This shows that indeed (1.12) holds. 2 Next we transform the operator as follows. .
,
Aa(3
Aapu(x) = f91 JR1Y((1-A
)
M
eii;(x-Y) u(Y)
(1.13)
=amap(M1,Mr,D)u(x)
,
)M
am CEP
where the partial integration is justified as in sec.l.
Proposition 1.2. We have (1.14)
supp aap contained in the set Ix-als2n
,
IY-PI12n}
Moreover,
(1.15)
Ilaa(3NNIILo 5 c(a-R)-2M max
:Ia152M, ItI52N}
3. L2-Sobolev theory
102
where the constant c depends only on n, M. and N Indeed, (1.14) is trivial, by construction of the Va , while (1.15) is a calculation, using that (x)(K)/(x)=0(1) for all x .
Combining (1.12) and (1.15) we get
(1.16)
2sc
IlAapll L
(a_I)-2M[ [a]]2N,2M '
2N > n ,
with [[a]]k,l = max {Ila(a)IIL :
(1.17)
Itlsk
,
lalsl}
where c depends only on n,N,M. Choose the set K as product of the balls with center a,(3, radius 2n, its volume independent of a,(3.
For u,vE CO(Rn), ua eau, va=1av, 2M>n, we get
(1.18)
l (u,Av) l=
a S(ua,AaRvt) I S cl IIualIlIvnII(a-R)-2M a
I
s c2{ with
Iluall2 ;Ilvpll2} 1/2 = c2llull llvll
inner product (.,.) of H, where cj=cj[[a]]2M,?3N
j=1,2, with cj' depending only on n,M,N. In (1.18) we used (lull =
XIIuaII2, by construction of Va, and Schur's lemma in discrete form for 12-boundedness of (((a-(3)-2M)), 2M>n. Clearly (1.18) implies thm.1.1: Set u=ukE CO(Rn) where uk-> AvE S in H.
Moreover, we also have proven the useful corollary, below. Corollary 1.3. There exists c>0 only depending on n such that (1.19)
IIa(x,D)IIL2(,n) s c[[a]]NN, N=[n/2]+1 with [[.]] of (1.17).
Revisiting our above proof we notice that the same arguments apply for an A=a(M1,Mr,D) with aE SS00 (i.e., m=0, p=0, 6=0). 00 0 The Aa, are of this form anyway. Instead of (1.16) (1.17) we get '
,
(1.20)
2sc
IIAaPII
(a-p)-2M
L
[[[a]]] 2N,2N,2M
with (1.21)
[[[a]]]j,k,1 = max
:IaIsj,ItIsk,IkIsl}
.
LOO
Thus we have Corollary 1.4. All operators A=a(M1,Mr,D)
with a E SS
L2(len)-bounded. Moreover, we have
(1.22)
IIAIIL2 s c[[[a]]]N,N,N
'
N = [n/2]+1
.
0,0,0
are
103
3.2. L2-boundedness for positive delta
2. L2-boundedness for the case of O>0
.
Note that thm 1.1 gives L2-boundedness of all do's in the Hoermander classes 00.p,0 , with pj z 0 , but that it does not apply to the case S >0 . The theorem below asserts L2-boundedness for general m=0, and pjz0, plab, OsS<1. It was first proven in [CV Other proofs may be found in [ Ka2] , [ CM] . We discuss a proof after a scheme in [B3] which again is relatively short. 21.
Theorem 2.1. A pdo A=a(x,D) with symbol a Eiih06e',6 induces a bounded operator of H=L2(&n)
'
0<6<1
.
Proof. We use cor.1.4 and the following decomposition. For a partition wj, j=0,±1,±2,..., like Va but for n=1, i.e., (2.1)
wj(t) = w(t-j)
,
supp w C {It Is2}
,
yjwj2 = 1
,
wja 0
set xj=wj(log
i.e, Clearly xj has support near 2j. Since we get xj=0, as j<-1. The partition of unity Exj2()=1 has supports in concentric spherical shells:
supp xj C {2(3-2)/b s q) s 2(3+2)/s}
(2.2)
.
For A=a(x,D) with a satisfying our assumptions, we write
(2.3) (u,Av)=lj1(ujAjlv1). Aj1=xj(D)Axl(D). uj=xj(D)u, vj=Xj(D)v. We apply Schur's lemma once more to show that the matrix ((2-EIj-1I)) is 12-bounded, and prove an estimate of the form (2.4)
IIAj1IIL2
s c2 EIj-lI
,
j,l E Z
,
for some E>0
.
Then the argument following (1.18) will give boundedness of A We prove (2.3) for Ajl"=FAj1F-1 instead of Aj1 again. Here Get pj1=O unless Ajl"=Pjl=pji(M1,MrD) with 27-2s(x)6s2j+2
(2.5)
,
21-2s(Y)O 21+2
.
Repeating once more the partial integration of (1.13) we may write Pjl=pjl(Ml.Mr,D)
(2.6)
.
pj1=(x-Y)-2M((l-O )M pjl)(x.Y.
)
where e(x,Y)=(Y)26/(x-Y)2
_ and bM(x,
) = q)-21 (1-Ox)Ma(x,U)
3. L2-Sobolev theory
104
Notice that bME 00 ,Se',b again, for every M=O,1.....
.
Proposition 2.2. We have IIbM(-D,Mr)xi(Mr)II s c , with c independent of 1 for each fixed M=0,1,2..... Applying the Fourier transform we may prove IIbM(x.D)xl(D)II so that s c instead. Note also that O,6e',6 ,
.
E
E 00'6e'
.b
,
.
Proposition 2.3. The family gl(x,T)=c1(2-1x,210 is bounded in Vt0 Indeed,
21(lal-IRI)ci(R)(2-1x.210 g1((3)(x, )=
(2.7)
= 2l(lal-1pl)0((210 s(IPI-lal))
with 0(.) independent of 1. Also, x1(21 )=0 except if (210 6 differs from 21 by a factor between 1/4 and 4. Since qi contains the factor x1(21 ) we conclude from (2.7) that ql(Q)=O(1), with 0(.) independent of Thus cor.1.3 gives the uniform L2-bound for gl(x,D)=Q1 Note that Q1=VibM(x,D)xi(D)Vl-1, with unitary V1:u(x) .
2-In/2u(2-lx), so that IIQIII=IIbM(x.D)xl(D)II, proving prop.2.2.
Applying prop.2.2 for M=0 get IIAj1IIsc, c independent of j,l.
For (2.4) it suffices to look at Ij-lIZk0 with suitable fixed k0. Proposition 2.4. For Ij-llak0=5S (2.8)
e(x,y) s c 2 EI3-lI
,
,
and s=
6(1-6) we have
as (x,y) belong to the set (2.5)
with c independent of j,l. For the proof we use the estimate (2.9)
(x-Y) z I (x) - (Y) I
easily derived by an elementary calculation. We get (2.10)
O(x.Y) s (Y)2S/I(x)-(Y) I2= v. 41/Ivz 23l-'U, 21r'
I2,
with vj satisfying 4svjs4 and rj=1/6>1. For 2iI3-1IZ32, i.e., li-li a5S=k0 the right hand side of (2.10) is bounded by c41/4TIjsc41(1-3)=c4-hllj-lI, as j>l, and by
c4l/41l=C4-(r1-1)lI7-ll,
as j
latter symbol defines a uniformly bounded operator family, while,
3.2. L2-boundedness for positive delta
105
in supp k , we have (2.8), hence it seems that (2.4) should follow. For a real proof however we argue as follows: First show that
(2.11)
a as yO/O s c k+j=1R1
( Y) - 3 (x-Y) -k- I a l
Indeed, for IaI+It1=1, writing aaayv=j
for a moment, we get a(3= (log O)ias=26 (log( y) )iap-2 (log(x-y) )kR in the span of P and -SSlap
with T=( y) , S=(x-y) . For any " , t E,P+rj + (p4ap )(R
ment gives
,
and I E + I rl =1 we get (
in the span of rlK(a3,p3) im(y),63), where K(a,3)=
Sap, L(a,f3)=TaP, with product over all partitions a=jai+
31+76 3
t3 )ts 11 =
where we may set R=S,T,O. An induction argu-
, with multiindices
aj, (3 j , y j ,
,3
Finally note that aaT=O
as a#0. Thus we may assume ly3 =0, 2Ia3I=IaI. Let YIP3I=k, Y1631=1
and note that (x) (01') /(x) =0 ((x) - I a I) , as used earlier. Hence the above products are O(S-IaI-k T-1), where k+l=I(3I, implying (2.11).
Now we again recall the above unitary map V1. Look at (2.6), rewritten as
for M=1 , describing a symbol of Pjl (2.12)
,
p 1(x,y, ) =
The operator Wj1=V1-1Pj1V1 then has symbol (2.13)
From prop.2.3 we get describing a bounded set in Vt0. Notice that of (2.13) describes a bounded set E13-ll, with respect to the norm (1.22), while a[[[w.,]]]N,N,Nsc2 so that cor.1.4 gives (2.3). Indeed, axayaywjl is in the span of (2.14)
1U(v)
where -(x,y)=e(21x,21Y), wj(x)=X(21x),
, x+µ=a , X+v=P ,21x)
Note that aaaRE/E=21(Ia'1+1p1)(aaaI0/O)(21x,21y). For boundedness
in supp wjlxwe show that 21/(21y) yand 21(21x-21 y) are bounded, by (2.11). In supp wjl get 21/(21y)sc21/21/6sc. Also, 21/(21x-21y)s c21/12j/6-21/61, as near (2.10). With similar argument (and 1=1/6) sc21-13, as 1<j, so sc in both cases we get sc2l(1-r1) for 1>j, and In other words, the first factor of (2.14) is bounded. We already know the last factor bounded, since riE Vt0. For the second
3. L2-Sobolev theory
106
we get 6Xw=2IIL I1O((21x)-IRI)s121R1(1-hj), bounded for 1>j, but not for 1<j. The third factor is bounded by c2 61j-1I. Together we get the estimates for (2.4), via cor.1.4 , but only for 1>j .
For j
does not involve the support
restriction (21x)6, 2j, while prop.2.3 remains intact if that res-
triction is replaced by (21x)s21-5 a jxjs /4-5-4-1 . This means that we may replace the factor wj(x) in wjl by wj(x)0(x), using a cut-off z=0 for jxI2:2-6, =1 near 0. For j<
after (2.11) also remain intact with the new x-restriction. This completes the proof of thm.2.1. We also get Corollary 2.5. Under the assumptions of thm.2.1 there exists a constant c depending on n and S only such that for 0<6<1 we have
(2.15)
IPI)II
IIAllsc
with the L2-operator norm IIAII
IaIs2,I,Is[Z]+1}
:
L LOO
.
The proof is evident. Note that a result like cor.1.4 is easily derived for the case 6>0, following the above guide lines. 3. Weighted Sobolev spaces; K-parametrix and Green-inverse.
Define the spaces Hs (3.1)
Hs1 ,s2
'
for s=(si ,s2 ), as the classes
He = {uE S' : ns(x,D)u E H
where H = L2(&n)
,
and ns(x,) _ (x)sZs'E acs
.
For u,vE Hs we
introduce a norm and an inner product by
(3.2)
(u,v)s=(nsu,nsv)L2
,
Hulls=lInsulIiz
,
11$ = ns(x,D)
Note that the strictly classical 'pdo Its is invertible, as an
operator S -> S
(3.3)
,
or S'
s1= nS
-> S'
, with inverse
= n_s(Mr.,D) =
(D)-sl (M)-s2 E Op4c_s
In particular 11s is md-elliptic of order s
(3.4)
ns-1
,
and,
- r1s E OPVC-s-e
by calculus of ipdo's. From (3.2) conclude that II5:H5-*H is an isome
try Hs - H. In particular, Hs is a Hilbert space, for all sE It'
.
107
3.3. Weighted Sobolev spaces
We refer to the spaces Hs as (weighted L2-) Sobolev spaces over &n. In the special case s2=0 we obtain the ordinary (unweighted) L2-Sobolev spaces, commonly known as Hs - now with sE I First we discuss properties of unweighted Sobolev spaces, for the moment also called Hs sE & : For details (and a more general discussion involving L1'-norms) cf.[Ci],III, or [GT]. Write .
(3.5) As=(D) s , Hs={uE S' :AsuE H}
(u,v)s=(Asu,Asv)
,
hulls=IIAsull
,
1) Using Parseval's relation (0,(1.8)) we may write (3.6)
2s
Ilulls2 = JR1 Iu^
with the Fourier transform u^=FuE Lebesgue integral. In particular, He = {u E S'
(3.7)
where f exists as a
LIloc(&n),
L2(&n,(,)2sdU)}
: u^E
2) The spaces Hs form a decreasing set of subspaces of S' containing S, as s increases from -- to +- . Moreover, hulls is an increasing function of s, either on &, or on a half-line (--,a) 3) For s=k , a nonnegative integer, we get (3.8)
Hs = {uE S'
:u(a) E H
for all lalsk}
with distribution derivatives u(a). The norm hulls is equivalent to
llullk = {
(3.9)
l
This follows from (3.6)
(3.10)
llullk = Jdfslu^
a1sk
llu(a) ll2} 1/2
:
l2(1+7)2k
= l
(k)
ask a
afsk
[aJfd2alu" () 12
Ilu(a) ll2
with the multinomial coefficients (k) = k!/(a1(k-lal)1) .) 4) We have Sobolev's lemma For s > n/2 the space Hs is (compactly) imbedded into the space CO(&n) of all continuous functions over &n vanishing at infinity. We have the inequalities :
(3.11)
s csllulls
Hull
,
. )1/2 cs = ( J(S)-2sd
,
LOO
and (3.12) Iu(x)-u(Y)lsss(lx-Yl)Ilulls
,
6s=(2Jsin2(1t/2)(
)-2sd)1/2
3. L2-Sobolev theory
108
Moreover, if even s >n/2+j
for some integer j >0
,
then we
,
have a compact imbedding Hs-C03(&n) defined as the space of all uE CO such that also u(a)EE CO , for all lags j , and inequalities lalsj of the form (3.11), (3.12) are valid for all u(a) ,
.
,
Sobolev's inequality ( 3 . 1 1 ) follows by showing that the Fou-
is LI for u E Hs, s>n/2 (a matter of Schwarz' inequality). (3.12) is derived by estimating the Fourier transform rier transform u^
(cf.[C1],III ). The compactness of the imbedding is a consequence of the Ascoli theorem: Equicontinuity of Hs-bounded sets follows. The imbedding Hs-'CO., as s>n/2+j, follows from (5) below. 5) For u E Hs we have u(a)E Hs-lal
(3.13)
and
,
Ilu(a)Ils-IaI 5 llulls
This is a consequence of the inequality (3.14)
Ilu(a)lls - IaI=JIu^
JlU.
5 using that 6)The spaces
(3.15)
He = (1{Hs
:
sE &}
,
H-,, = U{HS
:
sE &}
,
have simple locally convex topologies (cf.[C1], ch.III). The space H. is contained in COOO(&n) , but contains S , while H-. contains E', but is contained in S'. All inclusions mentionned are proper. 7) Hs and H-s are mutually adjoint under the pairing (3.16)
(u,v) = (Asu,A-sv) = fuvdx
, uE Hs , vE H-s
defined by the second expression, involving the inner product of H=L2, using that As:H5-. H and A-s:H-s-a. H define isometries. Returning to weighted Sobolev spaces
H5--H
5I,sz
of (3.1) we
note analogously the following properties of Hs (i) We have
(3.17)
Hs = {uE S'
:
II cull
with the operator s*=(D) s' (M) 52 =ns(Mr,D)
.
:
II s*ull
,
Moreover, the norms
(3.2) and (3.18) below are equivalent. (3.18)
llulls = Il s*ull = II(D) S' (M)S' U