Essential resources for training and HR professionals
Essential resources for training and HR professionals
Praise for...
706 downloads
3163 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Essential resources for training and HR professionals
Essential resources for training and HR professionals
Praise for the Second Edition of
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning “No other book in the last decade has been more important for the workplace learning field. The second edition is even better, incorporating new wisdom learned in the crucible of real-world practice.” —WILL THALHEIMER, PH.D., president, Work-Learning Research, Inc.
From left to right: Roy Pollock, Calhoun Wick & Andrew Jefferson Photo by Terence Roberts
THE AUTHORS Calhoun Wick is the founder and chairman of the Fort Hill Company. He is recognized nationally as a consultant, educator, and researcher on improving the performance of managers and organizations. Roy Pollock serves as chief learning officer for Fort Hill. Andrew Jefferson is president and CEO of Fort Hill. They authored the award-winning first edition of The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning as well as Getting Your Money’s Worth from Training and Development. The Fort Hill Company specializes in helping companies earn a better return on their investments in training and development. Over the past ten years, Fort Hill’s 6Ds methodology and learning transfer management systems have helped many of the world’s leading companies ensure that learning gets transferred and results improve. The company is based in Wilmington, Delaware.
“The Six Disciplines brings together many of the most important principles of corporate training in an easy-to-understand, highly visual format. Readers will find this book filled with examples, models, and practical tools you can use to create high-impact learning solutions in your own organization.” —JOSH BERSIN, president and chief executive officer, Bersin & Associates “Wick, Pollock, and Jefferson have a well-proven formula for moving learning from an academic exercise to business results. Their 6Ds offer all leaders specific and concrete things that they can do to turn learning into results.” —DAVE ULRICH, professor, Ross School of Business, University of Michigan, and partner, The RBL Group “I introduced The Six Disciplines to GE’s Global Learning Council and I am very glad that I did. The Six Disciplines gives us a common language and a common process that work very well in GE.” —JAYNE JOHNSON, director, Global Leadership Development, General Electric “The 6Ds model provided a powerful framework for designing high-impact learning programs that helped to shape our approach to learning and to align our learning leaders across the organization. The second edition adds insights and tools that make this edition even more relevant, practical, and valuable.” —ROBERT SACHS, Ph.D., vice president, Learning and Development, Kaiser-Permanente “Embracing the Six Disciplines has allowed us to develop truly innovative high-impact leadership programs that have changed the trajectory of our firm.” —CAROL BONETT, vice president, leadership development officer, Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC
ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT
The SIX DISCIPLINES of Breakthrough Learning
“Simply put, this book is a critical read for anyone who wants to ensure that the time and money spent in development produces results.” — TERESA ROCHE, vice president and chief learning officer, Agilent Technologies
SIX DISCIPLINES The
Wick Pollock Jefferson
2nd
Edition
of Breakthrough Learning
SIX DISCIPLINES The
of Breakthrough Learning
When the first edition of The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning was published, it quickly became the new standard for companies who were serious about increasing the return on their investment in learning and development. This thoroughly revised, updated, and expanded edition of The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning reveals how training, OD, and HR professionals can enhance their contributions to the success of their organizations. The book is filled with practical, proven-to-work guidelines and examples that show clearly how to design, deliver, and document comprehensive learning experiences that improve leadership and management, sales, customer service, marketing, and other business functions. The authors—experts in the field of learning and development as well as business— explain the theories and principles that undergird the 6Ds approach and provide practical methods, tools, roadmaps, and checklists for bridging the “learning-doing” gap. The book’s guidelines are illustrated with dozens of case studies from successful companies on the cutting edge of results-driven educational performance.
2nd
Edition
How to Turn Training and Development into Business Results
Discover more at www.pfeiffer.com
Calhoun Wick, Roy Pollock, and Andrew Jefferson
The 6Ds encompass the entire process of converting learning into improved performance, from pre-course communications to the impact of the learning transfer climate. Designed to be used by a broad spectrum of professionals, the book’s knowledge can be applied to virtually any learning and development program. Most important, The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning focuses on business and performance outcomes—the new “finish line” for learning and development.
fm.indd viii
6/17/10 3:53:24 PM
More Praise for The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning “Learning professionals who apply The Six Disciplines in their day-to-day work will deliver undeniable value to any organization.” —NICOLE ROY-TOBIN, CHIEF LEARNING OFFICER, FINANCIAL ADVISORY SERVICES, DELOITTE SERVICES, LLP “Applying The Six Disciplines catapulted us from a respected training and development function to true business partners. In this second edition, these trusted and credible authors bring even greater clarity and context to the 6Ds. I highly recommend this book.” —DIANE HINTON, PLASTIPAK ACADEMY GOVERNING BOARD LEADER, 2010 CORPU EXEMPLARY PRACTICE AWARD FOR BUSINESS ALIGNMENT, PLASTIPAK PACKAGING, INC. “The Six Disciplines is the definitive ‘how-to’ guide that provides practical, useful howto templates and lots of examples that can meet any type of training measurement requirement. Now there is no excuse not to get started.” —J. SCOTT BOSTON, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT TALENT MANAGEMENT & MCKESSON CENTER FOR LEARNING, MCKESSON CORPORATION “The Six Disciplines is truly a masterpiece of useful advice and guidance for leveraging results from training and development. It is by far the best book ever written on the topic and will no doubt exert an enormous positive influence.” —GEOFF RIP, STRATEGY DIRECTOR, INSTITUTE FOR LEARNING PRACTITIONERS (AUSTRALIA), AND PRESIDENT, CHANGELEVER INTERNATIONAL “In today’s world, great learning and development professionals can be defined in three words . . . effective business consultants. If you want to be viewed as a strategic partner whose learning and development solutions align to and impact business results, this is a must-read.” —GARY WALJASPER, HEAD OF ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT, THE PRINCIPAL FINANCIAL GROUP
fm.indd i
6/17/10 3:53:21 PM
“I wondered why companies using The Six Disciplines framework stand out as top performers. Now I know. The second edition is filled with even more good examples, design concepts, and useful tools.” —SUE TODD, PRESIDENT AND CEO OF CORPORATE UNIVERSITY XCHANGE “I recommend this book to any trainer, be it a novice or an expert, as it forces them to look at the training delivery more holistically as an end-to-end process much beyond the classroom.” —DORAIRAJ SELVAN, PH.D., SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, TALENT TRANSFORMATION, WIPRO TECHNOLOGIES, BANGALORE, INDIA “The second edition of The Six Disciplines contains a treasure trove of powerful ideas for facilitating the transfer and application of new learning into the workplace. Few have done more than Cal Wick and his colleagues to bridge the gap between the growing body of academic understanding of the ’transfer problem’ and still-reluctant learning and development practitioners.” —ROBERT TERRY, PH.D., MANAGING DIRECTOR, ASK EUROPE “This is a must-have for the shelf of all professionals who are charged with bringing change to their organization and actually seeing a return on investment!” —BEVERLY KAYE, FOUNDER & CEO, CAREER SYSTEMS INTERNATIONAL; COAUTHOR, LOVE ‘EM OR LOSE ‘EM; AUTHOR, UP IS NOT THE ONLY WAY “As businesses evolve and adapt in response to greater global complexities, those organizations that focus on the transfer and application of learnings and insights into business results will stand apart. The Six Disciplines offers a mindset and approach to the next iteration of learning as a competitive advantage.” —ANDREW WOJECKI, PH.D. “The Six Disciplines describes and illustrates six principles practiced by companies that earn the highest returns by efficiently converting learning into business results. A truly valuable book!” —KEN BLANCHARD, COAUTHOR, THE ONE MINUTE MANAGER AND THE SECRET The Six Disciplines transcends generations, learning styles, culture, and technology as an enduring and practical way to assure that learning matters to the business. —MARYANN BILLINGTON SENIOR PARTNER, KORN/FERRY LEADERSHIP AND TALENT CONSULTING
fm.indd ii
6/17/10 3:53:22 PM
ABOUT THIS BOOK
This book is for everyone who is a provider, sponsor, purchaser, or consumer of corporate training and development. It describes a proven set of processes and tools that achieve a breakthrough in corporate education and that significantly improve the return on the investment that companies make in learning and development.
Why Is This Topic Important? Staying competitive in today’s business climate depends on know-how, human capital, and the ability to learn quickly at both the individual and organizational levels. Companies invest heavily in training and development—more than $50 billion annually in the United States alone—in an effort to improve their leadership, efficiency, quality, customer service, and so forth. There is compelling evidence that these investments can and do pay dividends. There is equally compelling evidence, however, that the business benefit of learning and development can be much greater than most organizations currently realize. Substantial value is being left on the table in the form of “learning scrap”—training and development that is never transferred to the work of the organization in a way that improves performance.
fm.indd iii
6/17/10 3:53:22 PM
What Can You Achieve with This Book? This book describes and illustrates six disciplines that together represent a breakthrough in corporate training and development: (1) define business outcomes, (2) design the complete experience, (3) deliver for application, (4) drive learning transfer, (5) deploy performance support, and (6) document the results. By practicing these six disciplines, you will be able to design, deliver, and document learning and development programs that produce greater business impact and higher returns on investment.
How Is the Book Organized? In the Introduction we provide a brief overview of the six disciplines of breakthrough learning. We then dedicate a full chapter to each discipline, exploring it in-depth and providing recommendations and tools to maximize its contribution. Insights from exceptional business and learning leaders, as well as case studies, are used to illustrate key concepts. At the end of each chapter, we provide checklists for implementation and action items for both general managers and learning leaders, because maximizing the return on investment from learning and development requires a true partnership between line management and learning professionals.
The Instructor’s Manual for the second edition of The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning is available free online to qualified college and university instructors. If you would like to download and print out a copy of the guide, please visit: www.wiley.com/college/wick.
fm.indd iv
6/17/10 3:53:23 PM
About Pfeiffer Pfeiffer serves the professional development and hands-on resource needs of training and human resource practitioners and gives them products to do their jobs better. We deliver proven ideas and solutions from experts in HR development and HR management, and we offer effective and customizable tools to improve workplace performance. From novice to seasoned professional, Pfeiffer is the source you can trust to make yourself and your organization more successful.
Essential Knowledge Pfeiffer produces insightful, practical, and comprehensive materials on topics that matter the most to training and HR professionals. Our Essential Knowledge resources translate the expertise of seasoned professionals into practical, how-to guidance on critical workplace issues and problems. These resources are supported by case studies, worksheets, and job aids and are frequently supplemented with CD-ROMs, websites, and other means of making the content easier to read, understand, and use.
Essential Tools Pfeiffer’s Essential Tools resources save time and expense by offering proven, ready-to-use materials—including exercises, activities, games, instruments, and assessments—for use during a training or team-learning event. These resources are frequently offered in looseleaf or CD-ROM format to facilitate copying and customization of the material. Pfeiffer also recognizes the remarkable power of new technologies in expanding the reach and effectiveness of training. While e-hype has often created whizbang solutions in search of a problem, we are dedicated to bringing convenience and enhancements to proven training solutions. All our e-tools comply with rigorous functionality standards. The most appropriate technology wrapped around essential content yields the perfect solution for today’s on-the-go trainers and human resource professionals.
w w w. p f e i f f e r. c o m
fm.indd v
Essential resources for training and HR professionals
6/17/10 3:53:23 PM
fm.indd vi
6/17/10 3:53:24 PM
THE SIX DISCIPLINES OF BREAKTHROUGH LEARNING
fm.indd vii
6/17/10 3:53:24 PM
fm.indd viii
6/17/10 3:53:24 PM
Y THE SIX DISCIPLINES OF BREAKTHROUGH LEARNING How to Turn Training and Development into Business Results SECOND EDITION
Calhoun Wick Roy Pollock Andrew Jefferson Foreword by Al Switzler Afterword by Jim Kouzes and Barry Posner
fm.indd ix
6/17/10 3:53:24 PM
Copyright © 2010 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Published by Pfeiffer An Imprint of Wiley 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741
www.pfeiffer.com
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400, fax 978-646-8600, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, 201-748-6011, fax 201-748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permissions. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. Readers should be aware that Internet websites offered as citations and/or sources for further information may have changed or disappeared between the time this was written and when it is read. For additional copies/bulk purchases of this book in the U.S. please contact 800-274-4434. Pfeiffer books and products are available through most bookstores. To contact Pfeiffer directly call our Customer Care Department within the U.S. at 800-274-4434, outside the U.S. at 317-572-3985, fax 317-572-4002, or visit www.pfeiffer.com. Pfeiffer also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Page 361 constitutes a continuation of the Copyright page. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Wick, Calhoun W. The six disciplines of breakthrough learning: how to turn training and development into business results / Calhoun Wick, Roy Pollock, Andrew Jefferson; foreword by Al Switzler.—2nd ed. p. cm. Prev. ed. entered under title. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-470-52652-1 (hardback) 1. Organizational learning. 2. Employees — Training of. I. Pollock, Roy V. H. II. Jefferson, Andrew McK. III. Title. HD58.82.S59 2010 658.3'124 — dc22 2010014180 Acquiring Editor: Matthew Davis Production Editor: Michael Kay/Susan Geraghty Editor: Rebecca Taff Editorial Assistant: Lindsay Morton
Manufacturing Supervisor: Becky Morgan Graphic Design: Michael Aspengren Cover Design: Michael Aspengren Editorial Assistance: Kathleen Myers
Printed in the United States of America HB Printing 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
fm.indd x
6/17/10 3:53:25 PM
CONTENTS
Foreword
xiii
Introduction: The Six Ds
1
D1 Define Business Outcomes
19
D2 Design the Complete Experience D3 Deliver for Application D4 Drive Learning Transfer
65
109 161
D5 Deploy Performance Support
213
D6 Document Results 255 Coda
319
Closing Thoughts: Learning Is the Master Skill 329 Jim Kouzes and Barry Posner References Index
333
345
About the Authors
359 xi
TOC.indd xi
6/17/10 3:44:47 PM
To our clients, for allowing us to work with them and learn from them in their pursuit of excellence; to our employees, for making it happen; and to our families, for encouraging us to pursue our dreams.
TOC.indd xii
6/17/10 3:44:48 PM
FOREWORD
B
ecause you’re holding this book, I know that you’ve had experience with training and learning. You’ve no doubt experienced both the positives and negatives. On the positive side, you’ve been in courses where you learned insights and skills that, when you applied them to real issues, helped you achieve important results. If you’re like me, you cherish those experiences. And, if you’re like most people, you’ve also seen the negatives—training experiences where powerful learning occurred, but then . . . nothing: no application, no follow through on commitments, and, not surprisingly, no results. This negative aspect of the learning and training industry is widespread, deep, and broad. And these problems are not just known by executive management, HR management, and trainers; they are seen and felt by millions who sit through training classes but don’t see the value. Action plans and good intentions fade like mirages; no one seems to care. And after years of such experiences, they conclude that too much of training is a waste of time and money. It is something you endure so some box somewhere can be checked. But there is hope. And you hold in your hand an essential key to the solution. The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning by Cal Wick, Roy Pollock, and Andy Jefferson is a readable, memorable, and practical approach to maximizing the positives and overcoming the negatives in learning and development. These authors, who are themselves experienced trainers and managers, truly understand that corporate learning is about changing people’s behavior to produce desired xiii
FOREWORD.indd xiii
6/17/10 3:40:12 PM
xiv
Foreword
outcomes for the organization. This book contains a wealth of information, ideas, examples, and steps to help you achieve that goal. This new second edition includes dozens of new examples, citations, and research studies that make it even more valuable. There was a time, not so long ago, when learning and organization development professionals dismissed the idea of linking interventions to corporate results. We felt our job was to develop people because it was the right thing to do. Period. But we were wrong. Helping people develop and grow is still the right thing to do; but it must also deliver results. As the authors explain, business leaders are charged with investing corporate resources in the way that produces the best possible outcomes for the organization’s key stakeholders—customers, employees, and shareholders. In today’s intensely competitive business climate, no organization can squander time or money on activities that fail to produce value. That means that, as learning professionals, we have to set our sights on a “new finish line.” We need to continue to train people well. But in addition, we need to be sure that newly trained people actually behave differently on the job and that their new behaviors lead to demonstrable improvements in the results our companies are trying to achieve. Anything short of that is ultimately entertainment and therefore expendable. As I read this new edition, I was impressed with the many tools, steps, and insights that are included. Here are a few points I’d like to highlight: • The six disciplines make sense; they are theoretically sound. Cal, Roy, and Andy are mature researchers, have spent years in the trenches, have identified the obstacles, have shared very useful real-world cases, and have shared specific strategies. I could clearly see the evidence that they have studied and how they have helped hundreds of companies achieve breakthrough learning. Seldom is a book so well conceived and so complete. • This book is a large and powerful tool box. These authors are eminently pragmatic. So beyond the sound theory and the sage perspective, they share and explain checklists, scorecards, assessments, and action points for learning leaders and for line leaders. There are diagnostic tools and advice about traps to avoid. • And there are wonderful ah-ha’s and chuckles. Of course, what is an epiphany and what is humorous will vary from one individual to another. But I had my share of both, and I know you will also. The second edition of The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning is a remarkable book. I am certain it will continue to make a powerful contribution to the entire training industry, as did the first edition.
FOREWORD.indd xiv
6/17/10 3:40:12 PM
Foreword
xv
I am also convinced that the investment you and your team make in reading, discussing, and applying the concepts in this book will make a positive and measurable difference in connecting training and learning to the business results that matter. The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning will allow you to make a muchneeded contribution more often, on a grander scale than ever before; it will help you be one of those influencers who are changing the world for the better. June 2010
FOREWORD.indd xv
AL SWITZLER, Best-selling author of Crucial Conversations Provo, Utah
6/17/10 3:40:13 PM
FOREWORD.indd xvi
6/17/10 3:40:13 PM
THE SIX DISCIPLINES OF BREAKTHROUGH LEARNING
FOREWORD.indd xvii
6/17/10 3:40:13 PM
FOREWORD.indd xviii
6/17/10 3:40:13 PM
INTRODUCTION: THE SIX Ds The training you provide must contribute—visibly and substantially—to fulfillment of customers’ business strategies. —VAN ADELSBERG AND TROLLEY
T
hroughout our careers, we have been convinced of the strategic importance of learning and the contribution that corporate training and development programs can and should make. But we have also been deeply concerned that their actual impact is frequently far less than their true potential. Ten years ago, we started on a mission to understand—and to find ways to remove—the impediments to learning realizing its full potential and strategic contribution. We have worked with hundreds of organizations, large and small, and thousands of different programs. We have been privileged to be part of breakthrough learning programs—initiatives that helped propel their companies to a higher level of performance and that delivered results of undeniable value. But we have also observed programs that produced minimal or even negative impact, most often for the lack of learning transfer. New skills and knowledge were taught, but never applied to the actual work of the organization. When we compared the differences between these two extremes, we found that breakthrough learning is the result of a disciplined and systematic approach, executed with passion, excellence, and a commitment to continuous improvement. There is no “magic bullet”—no one, simple fix that transforms corporate learning from the periphery to central strategic importance. Seven years ago, we distilled the critical practices that characterize high impact initiatives into the 6Ds (Figure I.1), which we described in The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning (2006). 1
intro.indd 1
6/17/10 3:43:02 PM
2
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE I.1.
THE 6Ds THAT TURN LEARNING INTO BUSINESS RESULTS
Case in Point I.1 The 6Ds at GE Jayne Johnson, director, Leadership Education, for GE Global Learning, Crotonville, introduced the Six Disciplines to GE. “Part of my role in leading the Global Learning Council is to share best practices among the group. I read the Six Disciplines book and fell in love with the methodology. It just makes so much sense to start with the outcome in mind and work backwards. The concepts really resonated with me, so I introduced the Six Disciplines to the Global Learning Council by having one of the authors come out to Crotonville and conduct a session for us. Looking back now, I’m very glad that I did, because the 6Ds lives on across GE Global Learning. “GE is very much a metrics-driven organization, very results-oriented. The 6Ds gave us a common language to reinforce all our efforts and ensure that we are making an impact with the courses we run. Before we knew about the Six Disciplines, whenever somebody went to one of our classes, we had them put together an action plan based on all the things they had learned and wanted to implement upon their return home. “Once they left our grounds here in Crotonville, we really had no idea what they did with it. Occasionally, we would check in, but there was no consistency. So, what the Six Disciplines did was give us a more consistent and thoughtful approach to ensuring that participants continue to think about what they committed to do in the class and as a result, we have a higher percentage of people following-through on them. The Six Disciplines gave us a common language and a common process that makes so much sense. It works very well in GE.”
Since the first edition of this book, learning organizations in many leading companies have adopted the 6Ds as the organizing principles for their training and development efforts. They have found them to be a powerful mnemonic and a common language to leverage best practices across their learning organizations (see Case in Point I.1).
intro.indd 2
6/17/10 3:43:03 PM
Introduction
3
This new edition of The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning has been extensively revised. We have incorporated new research and examples of best practices from innovative companies on the leading edge of getting better results from learning. We have also incorporated many of the new tools and guides we developed in conjunction with the 6Ds Workshops. What follows is a brief introduction to each of the Six Disciplines. Each begins with a “D” to make them easier to remember and apply. While implementing the principles of any one of the 6Ds individually will enhance results, the greatest improvement is achieved when all six are used together; there is synergy among them. In the remainder of the book, we dedicate a full chapter to each discipline, exploring it in depth and providing examples and tools to maximize its contribution.
Define Business Outcomes A fundamental premise of this book is that human capital is the single most important source of competitive advantage in today’s increasingly knowledgebased economy. Competitive pressure requires organizations to continuously improve the quality of their products and services and the efficiency with which they are delivered. Maintaining competitive advantage through human capital requires ongoing investment in employees’ development, both so that they stay current in a rapidly changing world and so that they stay with the company. According to James K. Harter, Ph.D., Gallup’s chief scientist for workplace management, one of the best predictors of retention is whether an employee feels he or she has opportunities at work to learn and grow (Robison, 2008). Corporate-sponsored learning represents an investment that companies make to enhance their human capital and so ensure their future. Companies expect that investment to pay dividends in terms of greater effectiveness, improved productivity, enhanced customer satisfaction, better commitment, higher retention, and so forth. That means that all company-funded learning opportunities—whether classroom-based training, e-learning, informal learning, executive coaches, tuition reimbursement, and the like—ultimately serve a business purpose. We should say at this point that, throughout the book, we use “business” and “corporate” to refer to the larger organization that sponsors learning and development initiatives. These are meant to also include government agencies and not-for-profit enterprises. Although they are not “businesses” in the usual sense, continuous learning is nevertheless essential for these organizations to fulfill their missions, and it must be managed in a business-like manner to be effective. Whether or not the organization is expected to produce a profit, the fundamental
intro.indd 3
6/17/10 3:43:04 PM
4
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
rationale—and management’s expectation—is that performance will in some way improve following a training and development program or other learning opportunity (see Figure I.2). In other words, as workplace learning professionals, “We are not in the business of providing classes, learning tools, or even learning itself. We are in the business of facilitating improved business results” (Harburg, 2004, p. 21). The extent to which organizations are willing to fund learning, and the regard in which it is held, depend on the extent to which learning initiatives deliver on management’s expectations for improved performance. Therefore, the First Discipline—and perhaps the most critical—is to clearly define the business outcomes expected from each and every learning initiative. We do not mean learning outcomes or learning objectives. Most programs already have well-defined learning objectives that articulate what participants will learn or what they will be able to do by the end of the program. Those are still necessary for designing the instruction, but they do not answer the fundamental questions that business leaders are interested in: • How will this initiative benefit the business? • How will we know? FIGURE I.2.
MANAGEMENT EXPECTS TRAINING TO IMPROVE PERFORMANCE
el op me nt
Effectiveness
New (and Higher) Level of Performance
Current Level of Performance
Before
intro.indd 4
g Trainin
v De d an
After
6/17/10 3:43:07 PM
Introduction
5
Whereas learning objectives explain what participants will know or be able to do at the end of the program, business outcomes specify what they will do on the job, and the benefits to the business. Clearly defining the expected business outcomes has many advantages: • It makes learning a more strategic function, since the relationship to the mission of the organization is clear. • It increases the motivation to learn in adults by answering the “what’s in it for me?” question. • It increases the likelihood of investment by making the business value explicit. • It calls attention to the shared responsibility of learning and line managers; onthe-job results can only be obtained with their support and reinforcement. Enterprises that have implemented D1 across their learning organizations have discovered that they achieve much greater buy-in, not only from management, but also from program participants themselves. Getting clear about D1— the desired business outcomes—makes designing a more effective intervention easier. It is also prerequisite to effectively documenting the results (D6). Finally, having clearly defined outcomes allows learning organizations to win: They can unambiguously demonstrate their value because they know what success means to the business. In the chapter on D1 we underscore the importance of making sure that there is open, transparent, and readily apparent alignment between needs of the business and the goals of learning initiatives. We provide guidelines for distinguishing between learning and business outcomes and for distinguishing between performance problems that can, and cannot, be improved by training. We include tools and guidelines for having the dialogue with business leaders needed to ensure linkage. We underscore the benefits of understanding the value chain of learning, of mapping the intended impact, picking the right problems, and managing expectations.
Design the Complete Experience A second theme running through this book is that converting learning into business results is a process, not a one-off event. Learning organizations need to be much more explicit and deliberate about the process by which learning is transformed into results than has been the norm in the past (see Figure I.3). Process improvement requires considering all of the factors that affect the outcome and singling out those that have the most profound influence for special
intro.indd 5
6/17/10 3:43:08 PM
6
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE I.3.
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT NEEDS TO DESIGN THE COMPLETE EXPERIENCE
© Sidney Harris/Condé Nast Publications/www.cartoonbank.com.
attention. The Second Discipline of breakthrough learning, therefore, is to design the complete experience. The emphasis here is on complete, which means including what happens before and after the formal periods of instruction as part of the design. Historically, instructional design systems and corporate learning organizations focused primarily on “the course”—the period and method of instruction—with relatively little attention paid to what happened before and, especially, after the instruction. The research results are clear, however. The program’s “surround”— what happens before and after training—is as important as the instruction itself in determining the outcome. The “transfer climate” in the participant’s workplace has a particularly profound impact; indeed, it can make or break the value of any learning program.
intro.indd 6
6/17/10 3:43:10 PM
Introduction
7
The Second Discipline—designing the complete experience—recognizes that, from the participants’ points of view, the learning experience begins long before the formal course. It ought also to continue long afterward, until they have improved their performance and produced results (see Figure I.4). The Second Discipline demands a new paradigm: The learning organization is responsible for optimizing the learner’s total experience—not just what happens in the classroom (or its virtual, electronic, or informal equivalent). Maximally effective programs approach learning holistically and systemically; they pay special attention to the impact of the participant’s manager and the work environment on learning transfer and results. Designing learning initiatives that comprise all the factors that influence the results—including those outside the traditional scope of training and development—is more important now than ever; learning organizations are increasingly being funded on the basis of the business value they generate (or fail to generate). In the chapter on D2, we examine what makes up the “ complete experi- The real finish line for learning ence” and which elements most impact is the delivery of business learning transfer and the creation of busiresults. ness value. We suggest methods and tools to optimize outcomes, some of which challenge conventional thinking. We argue that learning organizations need to redefine what it means to “finish a course.” The participants’ work is not done when they reach the end of an online module or the last day of class; the real finish line for learning is the documented delivery of business results. We show that improving the transfer climate and providing post-instructional performance support are particularly rich opportunities for a breakthrough. FIGURE I.4. THE COMPLETE LEARNING EXPERIENCE ENCOMPASSES MUCH MORE THAN THE PERIOD OF INSTRUCTION
The complete learning experience hear about program
invitation or sign up
preparation
instruction: “the course”
learning transfer and practice with support
achieve results/ mastery
Historical focus of training and development
intro.indd 7
6/17/10 3:43:10 PM
8
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Designing for the complete experience allows learning organizations to realize their full promise of delivering value to the organization. Since training and development programs take time and cost money, everyone benefits when they are planned and managed in a way that maximizes the likelihood of success.
Deliver for Application The Third Discipline that characterizes high-impact learning programs is that they are delivered to facilitate application. That is, their instructional designers begin with the end in mind—what participants are supposed to do differently and better—and then consciously select learning strategies that help participants bridge the learning-doing gap (see Figure I.5). Delivering for application means selecting what to teach and how to deliver it most effectively based on the desired business outcomes and the behaviors needed to achieve them. It means using instructional approaches, technologies, and supporting strategies that accelerate learning transfer and application on the job. At the core of the Third Discipline is the principle that learning creates value only when it is applied; therefore, the way in which learning is delivered should reflect and facilitate the way in which it will be used. In Chapter D3, we look at innovative ways that progressive learning organizations are bridging the learning-doing gap by making the relevance of the FIGURE I.5. THERE IS ALWAYS A GAP BETWEEN LEARNING AND DOING; THE GOAL OF D3 IS TO BRIDGE THAT GAP
© 2008 Fort Hill Company. All rights reserved.
intro.indd 8
6/17/10 3:43:11 PM
Introduction
9
material clear; showing how each element is connected to real business issues; motivating application by answering the “what’s in it for me?” question; and helping participants prepare and plan for on-the-job application. We review insights into what makes learning memorable and provide tools to map the chain of value and monitor the perception of the program’s utility.
Drive Learning Transfer Because companies invest in learning to address business needs and opportunities, learning objectives are, in effect, business objectives. They should be treated as such. In any well-managed company, systems are in place to set, measure, monitor, and reward achievement of business objectives. Historically, however, Learning objectives are, in there have been no such mechanisms for effect, business objectives. learning-transfer objectives (see Figure I.6). Program participants were allowed to set them and forget them. Small wonder relatively few were achieved. “Talk to any group of laymen or professionals about what’s broken in the current learning and development process, and most will tell you it’s the lack of serious posttraining follow-through” (Zenger, Folkman, & Sherwin, 2005, p. 30). Learning transfer is the process of putting learning to work in a way that improves performance. The Fourth Discipline that characterizes high-impact learning organizations is that they drive the transfer of learning back to the work of the enterprise. They do not leave it to chance or individual initiative. Instead, they put in place systems and processes to actively encourage and manage the FIGURE I.6.
LEARNING TRANSFER IS THE WEAKEST LINK IN MOST TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS
Copyright © Grantland Enterprises; www.grantland.net. Used with permission.
intro.indd 9
6/17/10 3:43:13 PM
10
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
transfer process. The Fourth Discipline includes making sure that participants set (or are assigned) the right objectives, that they transfer their learning to the work they do, and that their managers hold them accountable for doing so. In the chapter on D4, we introduce the concept of learning scrap and the high cost of doing nothing to ensure learning transfer. We explain the elements that define the transfer climate and determine the results that training ultimately delivers. We review what it takes to improve performance and discuss breakthroughs in the management of the learning transfer process made possible by technology. Finally, we provide case examples of how supporting learning transfer enhances the value of already effective programs.
Deploy Performance Support Companies that are serious about getting a return on their investment in learning and development understand that the job isn’t finished until the new knowledge and skills are successfully applied in a way that improves performance. They recognize that getting better at anything requires practice and that when trying anything new, people need support and coaching (Figure I.7). FIGURE I.7. TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS CREATE GREATER VALUE WHEN THEY INCLUDE BOTH ACCOUNTABILITY AND SUPPORT
Business Value Created
Accountability Plus Support
intro.indd 10
Accountability Only Support Only
6/17/10 3:43:16 PM
Introduction
11
To maximize the probability of delivering meaningful business outcomes, highly effective learning organizations practice the Fifth Discipline: They deploy various forms of ongoing performance support after the instruction. They work with senior leaders to develop a culture in which managers understand that they have a responsibility to support learning. They “put their money where their mouths are” by reallocating some of their resources from pure instruction to instruction plus performance support for transfer and application. In the chapter on D5, we make the analogy between product support and performance support for learning transfer. We explore the three sources of support—materials, systems, and people—and provide examples. We discuss the need to balance accountability and support and the new demands this places on the learning organization and line management. We focus special attention on the participant’s manager, because he or she has a profound impact on whether learning is applied or scrapped. We confront head-on the reasons that managers don’t coach more to support the use of training and we provide specific steps to make the transfer climate favorable for results.
Document Results The bottom-line questions that must be answered about any learning and development initiative are these: Did it make a positive difference? Did it achieve the results for which it was designed? Was it worth it? The Sixth Discipline is to document results in a relevant, credible, and compelling way that justifies further investment and supports continuous improvement. Evidence of results is needed to justify continued investment in any business iniLearning organizations should tiative. Learning is not exempt from this be models of continuous requirement, especially in a time of finanimprovement. cial exigencies. In today’s business climate, companies must continuously improve the effectiveness and efficiency of all their business processes to remain competitive. Learning organizations should be models of continuous improvement. But continuous improvement is possible, and continued investment is warranted, only when there is unequivocal evidence that the initiative generated value. The requisite data are those that document outcomes of importance to the business—not just activity (people trained, courses taught), learner satisfaction (reaction), or even the amount learned (see Figure I.8). The Sixth Discipline—documenting results—is essential to support a cycle of continuous learning, innovation, adaptation, and improvement. The results of
intro.indd 11
6/17/10 3:43:17 PM
12
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE I.8. THE OUTCOMES OF INTEREST TO THE BUSINESS ARE ON-THE-JOB BEHAVIORS AND RESULTS
Timeline from Learning to Results Training or other structured learning
Acquisition of new skills and knowledge
Transfer learning to work
Most common measures of training
Improved performance / business outcomes
Measures that really matter to the business
one program are the raw material for the next cycle of defining outcomes, designing experiences, delivering, driving, deploying, and documenting. A never-ending cycle of reinvention and renewal ensures that corporate education keeps pace with the changing competitive environment, workforce, and business needs. In the chapter on D6, we discuss why learning organizations must document results. We differentiate between metrics needed to manage the learning organization and actual results that matter to the business. We provide guiding principles for program evaluation and advice on what to measure, how to collect and analyze the information, and, especially important, how to market the results.
Summary Learning programs are investments that a company makes to enhance the value and effectiveness of its human capital. Management has a fiduciary and ethical responsibility to ensure that those investments produce a return: results that improve performance and competitiveness. We have identified Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning—the 6Ds— that characterize high-value, breakthrough learning and development initiatives (see Figure I.9). Learning organizations that have adopted the 6Ds as their operating principles and that have practiced them diligently have increased the contribution that learning makes to their company ’s success (see Case in Point I.2). As a result, 6Ds learning organizations have enjoyed a corresponding increase in the recognition and support they receive.
intro.indd 12
6/17/10 3:43:18 PM
Introduction
FIGURE I.9.
13
THE SIX BREAKTHROUGH LEARNING DISCIPLINES
• Link program objectives to business needs • Describe what participants will do differently • Agree on definition of success
• Recognize transfer as a critical part of the process • Treat learning objectives as business objectives • Put in place systems and processes to support transfer
• Include all four phases of learning
• Make relevance and utility of content clear
• Plan and manage learning transfer process
• Provide time for practice with feedback
• Redefine finish line as on-the-job results
• Engage participants’ managers • Provide job aids and performance support systems • Ensure availability of feedback and coaching
• Use methods that make learning memorable
• Measure what matters to sponsors (D1 outcomes) • Use insights to drive continuous improvement • Market the results to key stakeholders
In the following chapters, we explore each of the Six Disciplines in depth and provide practical tools and advice for their implementation. Each discipline is illustrated with case examples and insights from corporate leaders. Our experience in helping companies implement the 6Ds has renewed our optimism about people, learning, and organizations. We have been privileged to work with talented and creative learning and line professionals and to see breakthrough results; we believe that we are at the beginning of a true renaissance in corporate education. We are confident that you will extend the principles articulated in this book to achieve even greater success. We look forward to hearing your stories.
intro.indd 13
6/17/10 3:43:18 PM
14
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Case in Point I.2 The 6Ds at Kaiser Permanente Founded in 1945, Kaiser Permanente is the nation’s largest not-for-profit health plan, serving 8.6 million members. In the rapidly changing field of health care, training and development are especially important to help Kaiser Permanente achieve its mission of providing quality care for its members and their families and contributing to the well-being of its communities. Robert Sachs, Ph.D., is vice president of learning and development. He introduced the Six Disciplines at Kaiser Permanente because of “the focus on outcomes, the whole idea of creating impact, and the concept of designing the complete experience. It isn’t just what happens in the instructional walls—whether it was a classroom or e-learning or whatever—that matters, but how you get people ready and how you help them translate what they learn into results. “Historically, we’re a pretty decentralized organization, so we probably went about doing our learning in just about every imaginable way. The 6Ds provided a framework that was easy to understand and comprehend and teach so that people could apply it. Both the vision and strategy were that we all would use this common framework to think about our work. “I’ve got a group that does a fair amount of instructional design for our core learning programs, and so they began to modify their instructional design framework and methodology to incorporate the Six Disciplines. It’s hard to make the impact totally tangible from the dollar and cents standpoint because a lot of what we have applied this to so far has been general leadership training. But we are clearly getting people who are actively following through with tangible effort to translate things that they take away from a program into real action. “We’ve done some work on ROI, and there is still opportunity to refine our measures of business impact, but we do see people being more effective at managing their teams, cutting down the amount of time that it takes to work on issues of employee relations, and making meeting times more efficient and effective as a result of applying some of the skills they’ve gotten in their programs. We also see people taking on more strategic issues and broadening their strategic relationships. Those have been some of the tangible results and outcomes.” Alan Jang, senior manager of the learning solutions team, said, “In order for learning solutions in Kaiser-Permanente to be successful, meaning achieving measurable results that impact the business, we had to create a new finish line for training. Training doesn’t end at the end of the course; it should also include follow-through and support. The [Six Disciplines] give us the framework to do that” (quoted in Chai, 2009).
intro.indd 14
6/17/10 3:43:19 PM
Introduction
15
Action Points For Learning Leaders • Evaluate the extent to which you are practicing the Six Disciplines. • Select a program for which you are responsible that has strategic importance and great potential contribution. • Score the selected program using the 6Ds scorecard (Exhibit I.1). • Decide which discipline, if strengthened, will produce the greatest improvement the quickest (“low-hanging fruit”). • Use the relevant chapters of this book and your organizational knowledge to develop a plan. • Present your findings, the target, your plan, and rationale to the relevant management team. • Ask for the resources and cooperation needed to implement your recommendations. • Evaluate the results and repeat the process to drive continuous improvement. For Line Leaders • Think about critical business needs that can be addressed (at least in part) by a learning and development program; then complete the worksheet in Table I.1. • In the first column, labeled “Critical Business Needs,” write the most pressing business opportunities or challenges that training can help address. • In the second column, labeled “Conditions of Satisfaction,” describe the results you require to consider the program a success—what people will do better and differently and the business impact this will have. • In the third column, “Acceptable Evidence,” describe the information you will need to be sure the program is working. What kinds of data will you consider credible and relevant? • Show the completed worksheet to your head of learning and development. Ask whether it is possible to deliver the results desired. Then work together to make it happen. • If you are already investing in learning and development (through an internal unit or external vendors) use the 6Ds Scorecard (Exhibit I.1) to identify the most promising areas for improvement. Ask your learning leader to do the same and compare your results. • Use the relevant chapter(s) of this book to jointly develop a plan for improvement.
intro.indd 15
6/17/10 3:43:19 PM
16
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Exhibit I.1 6Ds Learning and Application Scorecard Use this tool to evaluate the readiness of a program to deliver results. For each of the items below, check the box that best describes the program using the following key:
The program design covers the entire process from invitation to on-the-job application and measurement of results.
1 2 3 4 5
3.
The relevance of each section to the business is explicitly stated; application is stressed throughout, as is the expectation for action.
1 2 3 4 5
4.
A robust process and sufficient time are provided for participants to set strong goals, plan for action, and prepare communications to others.
1 2 3 4 5
5.
After the program, participants are reminded periodically of their objectives and their opportunity to apply what they learned.
1 2 3 4 5
6.
Participants’ managers are actively engaged during the post-program period. They review and agree on objectives and expect and monitor progress.
1 2 3 4 5
7.
Participants continue to learn from each other after the program. Materials and advice are available to help them accomplish their goals.
1 2 3 4 5
8.
Participants can easily engage coaches for feedback, advice, and support. The group is tracked and supported during the application (post-program) phase.
1 2 3 4 5
9.
On-the-job results are measured based on desired outcomes identified prior to the program.
1 2 3 4 5
An active continuous-improvement process is used to strengthen the preparation, program, and learning transfer.
1 2 3 4 5
10.
Deliver
2.
Drive
1 2 3 4 5
Deploy
The business needs are well understood. Anticipated on-the-job results of the training are clearly defined and measurable.
Document
1.
Design Define
1 = Not at all 2 = To a small extent 3 = Somewhat 4 = To a large extent 5 = To a very great extent
Total Score:
Scoring Instructions:
Add the numeric value (1 to 5) of all boxes selected. The maximum possible score is 50. Use the table below to assess the readiness of the program to deliver valuable follow-through results.
Points > 45 33–44 < 32
Assessment Excellent likelihood of measurable results and return on investment from program. Action: Continue disciplined approach to learning; strengthen lowest-scoring items. Moderate likelihood for positive results, but return may be less than optimal. Action: Strengthen weakest items to raise score to > 44. Valuable results and adequate return on investment is less likely. Action: Revise program in a systemic way.
© 2008, Fort Hill Company. Used with permission.
intro.indd 16
6/17/10 3:43:20 PM
Introduction
TABLE I.1. Critical Business Needs (That Training Can Help Address)
intro.indd 17
17
THE LEARNING FOR RESULTS WORKSHEET Conditions of Satisfaction (What Will Be Different if the Program Is a Success?)
Acceptable Evidence (What Data Are Needed to Show the Program Is Working?)
6/17/10 3:43:20 PM
intro.indd 18
6/17/10 3:43:20 PM
DEFINE BUSINESS OUTCOMES Management must always, in every decision and action, put economic performance first. It can only justify its existence and its authority by the economic results it produces. There may be great non-economic results: the happiness of the members of the enterprise, the contribution to the welfare or culture of the community, etc. Yet management has failed if it fails to produce economic results. . . . It has failed if it does not improve, or at least maintain, the wealth-producing capacity of the economic resources entrusted to it. —PETER DRUCKER
I
n the final analysis, organizations invest in training and development and other corporate-enabled learning initiatives for one and only one reason: to improve the performance of individuals and, thereby, the organization as a whole. Effective learning contributes to the success of the enterprise in many ways: directly— through enhanced job performance—and indirectly—through better retention, recruitment, employee commitment, and so forth. Organizations seek to facilitate learning as a purposeful business activity to ensure their own success and the success of their people. Learning agility and speed are essential to remaining competitive, perhaps even viable, in an increasingly knowledge-driven global economy. According to Warren Bennis, Distinguished Professor of Business Administration at USC’s Leadership Institute: “It isn’t about ‘treating people nice;’ it’s about helping develop people to be at their very best, because that’s the only way that companies are going to succeed. It’s human capital that is the basis for competitive advantage” (Bennis, n.d.). As one of the most famous CEOs at Proctor & Gamble, Richard “Red” Deupree, put it: “If you leave us our buildings and our brands but take away our people, the company will fail” (quoted in Dyer, Dalzell, & Olegario, 2004, p. 159). 19
CH001.indd 19
6/17/10 3:22:11 PM
20
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Thus, the true measure of success for corporate training and development initiatives is the extent to which they enhance the value of the organization’s human capital and help it achieve its mission. That is a new and more demanding standard. In the past, “delivering a great training program was sufficient. But not anymore. Global competition, market pressures for performance, and the recent economic downturn have moved the finish line. There is a new criterion for training success: improved performance on the job” (Wick, Pollock, & Jefferson, 2009). Delivering great learning experiences is still important, but only as part of a process that delivers great outcomes for the business. And the only way to know whether the learning organization has achieved its goal is to agree in advance on the outcomes that matter most and the definition of success. Thus, the First Discipline (D1) of breakthrough learning is to clearly define, in partnership with line leaders, the desired business outcomes. In this chapter we underscore the importance of shifting the focus of training and development from learning outcomes to business outcomes and we provide tools and guidance for making the transition. Topics include: • • • • • • • •
Begin with the end in mind Express outcomes in business terms Pick the right problems Translate needs into deliverables Avoid training traps Manage expectations A checklist for D1 Action points for learning and line leaders
Begin with the End in Mind One of the habits of highly effective people is that they begin with the end in mind (Covey, 2004, p. 96). The same principle applies to highly effective learning organizations. Corporate training and development initiatives should always be a means to an end, not ends unto themselves. The specific “end” to be achieved depends on the nature and drivers of the business and its opportunities, challenges, and environment. Regardless of the specific objective to be achieved, however, all corporate learning is aimed at improving the performance of the business in some way (see Case in Point D1.1 and Figure D1.1). Thus, helping employees learn to deliver more effective leadership, reduce accidents, provide superior customer service, accelerate product development, enhance teamwork, give more effective
CH001.indd 20
6/17/10 3:22:13 PM
Define Business Outcomes
21
Case in Point D1.1 Learning as a Business Strategy One company that really understands the strategic nature of learning is Ingersoll Rand. As Rita Smith, vice president of enterprise learning, puts it: “We’re here for only one reason: to help drive business outcomes. We need to understand the business strategy, key strategic drivers, external threats, and financial metrics. We literally need to be bilingual, speaking the languages of both learning and business” (Smith, 2008). Ingersoll-Rand’s CEO, Herb Henkel, sees learning as a key strategic lever, so much so that he has made it an integral part of the strategic planning process: “When we go through the strategic planning process, we come up with ideas, strategies, and visions of where we’re going to be. Then we decide what to invest in to get the things we want. So I look at how many dollars we spend on bricks and mortar; how many on developing new products; and how much training we need to be able to meet our goals. Built into the planning process is the assumption that there will have to be some kind of training. So we consider it no different than we would anything else in terms of investment decisions” (quoted in Bingham & Galagan, 2008).
presentations, and so forth, are all undertaken with the ultimate goal of improving the company’s financial health and performance. The effectiveness of a learning intervention, then, is the extent to which it helps the organization achieve the “end in mind.” It follows that effectiveness can only be assessed—and success declared—if the goals of the intervention are clearly defined at the outset and those goals are aligned with and contribute to organizational effectiveness. Goals Are Prerequisite for Success In the absence of clearly defined, business-relevant objectives, learning organizations can never “win” in their quest for recognition and resources. Sporting events are fun to watch because everyone knows the rules and what “winning” means. Races have clearly marked finish lines. Other competitions have established goals and scoring. No one would pay to watch a football game if the rules were decided after the game or if winning were based on which team enjoyed themselves the most. No one would invest in stocks in the absence of accounting principles and bottom-line measures of success. Similarly, an effective commission plan drives sales behavior because it spells out how salespeople can increase their financial rewards. Contracts include specified performance levels to avoid future disagreement about deliverables. The
CH001.indd 21
6/17/10 3:22:15 PM
22
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D1.1. EFFECTIVE TRAINING PROGRAMS ALWAYS KEEP THE BUSINESS OBJECTIVE IN MIND
evidence required to support a specific therapeutic claim is agreed upon with the FDA in advance of clinical studies. Management by objectives works when individuals meet with their managers to define goals that are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. The objectives for a learning and development initiative should be no different. Management and the learning organization need to work together to define the “Conditions of Satisfaction” early in the development process (see Case in Point D1.2). The promised results and the way in which they will be measured
CH001.indd 22
6/17/10 3:22:15 PM
Define Business Outcomes
23
Case in Point D1.2 Conditions of Satisfaction When we asked Richard Leider, award-winning coauthor of Whistle While You Work and Claiming Your Place at the Fire, about the importance of defining objectives, he told us that it was vital and went on to explain: “We teach leaders how to create what we call COS—conditions of satisfaction. What are your conditions of satisfaction? What is it that we are supposed to do differently after this and by when? What is it that you want delivered by when? Or created by when? “You could call it accountability, but when leaders lead, they are customers. For leadership development, the line leader is a customer. She makes a request; she puts out certain conditions of satisfaction. And so this whole notion of leader as customer translates into the training, and therefore the follow-up practice; leaders have certain conditions of satisfaction for training. “So often leaders are not clear about their conditions of satisfaction. There is a certain language and a certain rigor that leaders need to learn in order for meetings and training and transactions to be effective. It really clears up all that murkiness. You could say it is common sense; well, the fact is—look where the breakdowns are.”
should be agreed to as part of the design, not as an afterthought. The point is that learning and development can never compete successfully or truly claim success if the goalposts are not set out, fixed in position, and agreed to in advance. Only then do those responsible for implementation have the opportunity to excel. Business results must be the touchstone for defining learning and developBusiness results must be ment objectives, the “ true north ” the touchstone for defining against which programs are designed, learning and development implemented, and measured. Any other objectives. organizing principle is likely to get the initiative off course, because as David Campbell put it: “If you don’t know where you are going, you will probably end up someplace else” (Campbell, 1974). That learning and development programs should be designed with the end in mind hardly seems like a revelation. For at least twenty years, virtually all instructional design models—ADDIE and its many derivatives—have stressed the importance of starting with analysis and defining learning objectives. Similarly, “focus on outcomes” is the first standard of the International Society for Performance Improvement’s Human Performance Technology (International Society for Performance Improvement, 2002, p. 1). Fifteen years ago, the Robinsons
CH001.indd 23
6/17/10 3:22:17 PM
24
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
published the first edition of Performance Consulting, which recognized that the real responsibility of professionals in human resources, learning, and organizational development roles was “enhancing people’s performance in support of business goals” (Robinson & Robinson, 1995). Yet our experience across dozens of companies and hundreds of programs suggests that, to this day, most learning initiatives do not go far enough in defining their ultimate purpose. Most are still content to define objectives “at the end of this program” when in fact, “It is not sufficient that people attend a training program and acquire skill; what ultimately matters is that these individuals apply the skills on the job so that their performance improves and the business benefits” (Robinson & Robinson, 2008, p. 2). In other words, the “finish line” for learning is not at the end of the program, but much later, on the job, after learning transfer. The Robinsons’ quote sums up the distinction between the practice of D1—defining business outcomes—and the more common practice of defining learning outcomes, which often fail to make the link to the ultimate purpose explicit. Effective programs define their objectives in terms of on-the-job behaviors and business results; less effective programs merely define what will be learned or covered. Susan Burnett, currently senior vice president for talent and organizational development at Yahoo!, explains: “One of our strategic conclusions at Deloitte was that we needed to design and deliver outcome-based learning (see Case in Point D2.3). What I tell my team is that you have to change the conversation you have with your business partners. If you talk about what kind of training they need, you’re going to get a laundry list. It’s got to be all about the business outcomes; that’s the power of the Six Disciplines—it starts there. “If I ever write a book, it’s going to be about why learning and development organizations get so disconnected from the business and how to fix it. I often feel that this is a profession without a professional process” (Burnett, personal communication, 2009). The Six Disciplines define a process to keep learning connected to and focused on the business—a process that starts by getting crystal clear about purpose and outcomes.
Express Outcomes in Business Terms Throughout this discussion, we will repeatedly emphasize that goals for learning initiatives need to be expressed as “business outcomes.” Drucker’s famous dictum with which we began this chapter is uncompromising: Management’s responsibility is to ensure that every investment a company makes generates economic value. Business is, in the end, about financial return.
CH001.indd 24
6/17/10 3:22:18 PM
Define Business Outcomes
25
While Drucker was writing about for-profit companies, leaders of non-profit and government organizations must also ensure that every expenditure they approve contributes to the goals of the organization, even though these do not include “profit” as such. Training in leadership, ethics, diversity, and so forth are laudable (have merit) in their own right, but they must also pay dividends (have worth) in terms of lower operating costs, greater productivity, enhanced employee commitment, improved consumer confidence, and so forth. Programs that help participants improve their personal performance also pay dividends in greater job satisfaction, motivation, discretionary effort, and retention. What we are saying is that every corporate-sponsored learning initiative must (ultimately) produce a positive financial return, directly or indirectly; it is the only acceptable justification for continued investment. That may strike some readers as crass and mercenary, especially those who believe that helping people develop and grow is the “right thing to do.” We agree that it is the right thing to do and a corporate obligation. At the same time, we are convinced that the ability to define and deliver business benefit is the only way for learning and development to prove its value. The best defense against having the training budget cut is to show convincingly that doing so ultimately hurts the bottom line and reduces the probability of organizational success. “Learning is essential only to the degree that it contributes more to performance than other allocations of scarce resources” (Danielson & Wiggenhorn, 2003, p. 20). Results Can Be Measured We should pause here to address a common misperception. A frequent excuse for failing to define the expected results of learning and development is that “they cannot be measured.” A comment supposedly made by Jack Welch to that effect is often cited as proof. What he actually said was “We will not measure our learning systems in the same way that we do other business initiatives. To do so would only trivialize them” (quoted in Baldwin & Danielson, 2000, emphasis added). We do not deny that it can be difficult to isolate and quantify the specific contribution of training. Many factors influence business results: overall economic climate, success of marketing, competitors’ actions, new market entrants, and, in many businesses, even the weather. But those same factors also confound the evaluation of sales, marketing, and other business activities. Those functions are nevertheless held accountable, and rewarded for, delivering on their promises. That something is difficult to measure with precision, or that it is influenced by numerous other factors, is no excuse for not defining and evaluating outcomes.
CH001.indd 25
6/17/10 3:22:18 PM
26
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
As we will discuss more fully in D6, the fundamental “claim” or promise of training is that “ if you give the learning organization money and your employees’ time, we will help improve their performance.” Such a claim requires evidence to back it up. By analogy, consider health claims. When a pharmaceutical company develops a new drug, it must specify the drug’s claims—what it supposedly treats or cures. The company must then provide the regulatory authorities in the countries in which it wants to market evidence that shows beyond a reasonable doubt that the drug does, in fact, do what it claims to do. Data must be obtained from real patients in real time. How well a drug works in real patients, however, is influenced by many other factors—lifestyle, concurrent diseases, stage of illness, and genetic background (Figure D1.2). Patients don’t necessarily follow the directions correctly and the outcomes may be quite hard to measure. No matter. If a company wants the rights to market a drug, it has to design and execute an evaluation that unequivocally supports its claims, these difficulties notwithstanding. Before the Food and Drug Administration was established, patent medicine purveyors made any claim they wanted. The result was the “snake oil salesman” who made extravagant claims in order to sell quack remedies to the gullible— remedies that would supposedly cure whatever ailed them. To avoid promulgating such unsupported remedies in education, a consortium of the American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, and the National Council on Measurement in Education prepared the “Standards for Measurement is an integral Educational and Psychological Testing.” part of human endeavor. The standards require that measures (and by inference, human resource programs based on those measures) be reliable and valid predictors of the value to individuals and organizations. The standards acknowledge the difficulty of reliably defining and measuring the outcome of educational programs, but they are clear that such difficulty does not provide an exemption. The same is true in business. “Experience with several CEOs and top teams, and regular discussion with their advisors, convince me that the rejection of measures in learning is a dead end. Measurement is an integral part of human endeavor, and its power can’t be cancelled out by high-sounding sentiment” (Bordonaro, 2005, p. 229). To claim that the effects of learning and development cannot be measured is wrong-headed and potentially dangerous; if the positive effects of learning and development cannot be measured, then presumably neither can the negative effects of reducing or eliminating it. Failure to routinely document the business value of training and development undoubtedly contributes to the practice of making training budgets among the first to be cut in periods
CH001.indd 26
6/17/10 3:22:19 PM
Define Business Outcomes
27
FIGURE D1.2. MANY FACTORS BESIDES TRAINING AFFECT BUSINESS RESULTS JUST AS MANY FACTORS BESIDES A DRUG AFFECT MEDICAL OUTCOMES Regulators adverse rulings
Suppliers
Competitors mergers / acquisitions
higher costs shortages
sales tactics
approval time consolidations
new products
negotiating power
new regulations
pricing
Business Results consolidations
advertising
training
targeting negotiating power
public relations
impact of economy
retention commitment
sales effectiveness
engagement
Buyers
Sales/Marketing
Human Capital
Drug
Physician
Patient
active ingredient
accuracy
dosage form
weight compliance
thoroughness
formulation side effects
genetics
expertise
age
communication
Medical Outcome other medications
lifestyle
stage of illness
complications
caretakers
Environment
CH001.indd 27
concurrent maladies
Illness
6/17/10 3:22:19 PM
28
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
TABLE D1.1.
COMPARISON OF LEARNING OBJECTIVES AND BUSINESS OUTCOMES
Traditional Learning Objectives
Business Outcomes Objectives
Timing
End of course
On-the-job
Focus
Abilities and capabilities
Behaviors and results
of belt tightening. The discipline of always starting with business outcomes is an important safeguard against this eventuality. Because it defines the conditions of success as outcomes that matter to management, they will be more reluctant to give them up. Business Outcomes Versus Learning Objectives Making the shift from defining learning objectives to defining business outcomes is, on the one hand, a subtle change for the learning organization, but it has profound implications. Defining business outcomes differs from the traditional practice of defining learning outcomes in two important dimensions: timing and focus (Table D1.1). The vast majority of course objectives that we see are learning objectives that define capabilities—what participants will know or be able to do at the end of the course of instruction. In contrast, the business-centric outcomes we advocate focus on performance—what participants will do on the job—their behaviors and the results they will generate (Table D1.2). That distinction is crucial, because learning only creates value when it is transferred and applied to the work of the individual and the organization. “High-quality learning and training do not necessarily translate into business results. Enterprise learning must be driven with the end in mind: the business results to be achieved” (Vanthournout & others, 2006, p. 17). Defining learning objectives is still an essential part of the instructional design process, but they are subordinate to the business objectives; they are a means to the end, not the ultimate objective. Being explicit about the business outcomes that a learning program is intended to achieve has many advantages: • It makes explicit the business value of the time and money that will be invested. • As such, it garners greater support from both managers and participants. • It helps management prioritize training in the same way it weighs other investments (see Case in Point D1.1).
CH001.indd 28
6/17/10 3:22:21 PM
Define Business Outcomes
29
• It answers the “what’s in it for me?” question for participants and therefore satisfies one of the principles of adult learning: the need to know Why? • It highlights the need for managerial involvement, since managers control the environment in which transfer and application must occur. • It provides alignment with the business and a clear criterion against which to evaluate potential approaches: Is this the best way to achieve the result? • The outcomes are stated in a way that makes how to measure them apparent. “The minute that the trainer or researcher takes on the performance perspective, the whole thought process becomes that of an organizational stakeholder or organizational systems expert. . . . The performance perspective creates rational performance goals and the matrix of connections of variables and levels within the organization needed to ensure the appropriate actions and performance” (Swanson, 2003, p. 122). It’s Not Just About Money Defining outcomes in business terms does not, however, mean that every outcome must be stated in financial terms or that ROI is the only measure of interest to business leaders. Such reductionism is not always necessary or desirable (as we TABLE D1.2. EXAMPLES OF BUSINESS OUTCOMES VERSUS LEARNING OBJECTIVES
CH001.indd 29
Learning Objective
Business Outcome
Be able to describe the leadership styles and development stages of the situational leadership model and match the appropriate style to a developmental stage
Increase the productivity of your team and your managerial effectiveness by correctly utilizing the situational leadership model
Be able to apply the Six Sigma DMADDI model to a business process
Reduce the number of errors in the order entry process by applying Six Sigma tools and processes
Be able to explain each of the 6Ds and give an example of their application in corporate learning
Reduce the amount of learning that goes unused by applying the 6Ds to learning program design and execution
Demonstrate how to give effective feedback to a direct report
Increase employee commitment by giving more frequent and more effective feedback
Show how to use reframing to overcome customers’ objections
Increase sales by discovering and addressing customers’ objections
6/17/10 3:22:22 PM
30
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
will discuss in greater detail in D6, documenting results). Suffice it to say here that “business outcomes” include a wide range of potential metrics in addition to financial measures, such as increased customer satisfaction, greater employee commitment, enhanced leadership effectiveness, more productive sales approaches, improved work quality, and so forth. While these are not direct financial measures, business leaders understand that they are key contributors to financial performance and are often leading indicators of future business success. Indeed, business leaders may not want, or give credence to, efforts to more directly monetize the outcomes of training (Redford, 2007). A study at Ashridge Business School, for example, found that line leaders were actually more flexible about what defined acceptable outcomes than were learning leaders (Charlton & Osterweil, 2005). The authors concluded: “Sponsors may not be as wedded to proof of financial ROI as many HR professionals assume” (p. 13). If a clear causal link has already been established between certain behaviors (for example, better coaching of subordinates) and financial returns (lower employment costs as a result of greater retention), then it may be less expensive, more useful, Sponsors may not be as and more credible to document increases wedded to proof of financial in the desired behaviors rather than to ROI as many HR professionals apply an abstract financial transmogrifiassume. cation. Charles Jennings, head of global learning at Reuters, agrees: “A customer services manager will not care about ROI, but they will want to understand how learning improves customer satisfaction” (quoted in Redford, 2007). By “business outcomes” we mean verifiable outcomes of relevance to the business of the organization. We mean defining a goal of the program as, for example, “participants’ direct reports will receive more frequent and more effective coaching” rather than “participants will be able to demonstrate the SBA approach to providing feedback.” The former is concrete, measurable, and linked to business needs. The latter could be tested and measured, but that misses the point. The issue is not whether the new approach was learned and even demonstrable, but whether it is used in the participant’s daily work in a way that benefits the organization. “New skills and knowledge alone do not add value; they must be applied, then nurtured until improved performance can be counted on consistently to produce an important job result” (Brinkerhoff & Apking, 2001, p. 4). A program that will increase customer satisfaction is worthy of investment; a program that delivers only attendee satisfaction is not. Learning and development’s task is not completed until learning has been transferred and applied in a way that produces results; the measure of its success is in business terms.
CH001.indd 30
6/17/10 3:22:22 PM
Define Business Outcomes
31
“Effective training occurs when it is fully transferred and when performance achieves or exceeds business goals” (Wall & White, 1997, p. 169).
Pick the Right Problems The essence of military success is to concentrate the right resources on the right battlefield at the right time. The essence of success for a learning organization is to concentrate the right resources on the right issues at the right time. The more limited its resources, the more important it is for a learning organization to focus on those issues and opportunities that have highest potential return. But how do you know which are the right issues? There are five keys: • • • • •
Understand the business Understand the current situation Do your market research Translate needs into desired outcomes Enforce priorities
Understand the Business There is no substitute for understanding the business. For training and development to add value, learning leaders need to understand the fundamental nature of the business in which their organization is engaged. That is not to say that they have to be experts in finance, or business strategy, or marketing, or manufacturing. They do not all need to rush out to earn MBAs. But they do need to have a clear sense of how their organization fulfills its mission, makes money, and differentiates itself in the marketplace. In their book, What CEOs Expect from Corporate Training, Rothwell, Lindholm, and Wallick (2003) list the seven competencies that CEOs expect from workplace learning professionals. “Business knowledge” heads the list. Business leaders want learning professionals who understand business in general. But what they really want is learning professionals who understand their specific business, who can clearly and succinctly explain the business model of their company or division and its most important business drivers and challenges. They want learning leaders who understand what keeps the business leaders up at Business leaders want learning night, the human capital limitations to professionals who understand growth, and therefore how learning and business. talent development can best help the company achieve its goals.
CH001.indd 31
6/17/10 3:22:23 PM
32
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Plastipak Academy received Corporate University Xchange’s Exemplary Practice Award for Business Alignment in 2010. According to Academy Leader Diane Hinton, “Plastipak Academy’s success is built on our reputation as a business function that drives real business results through targeted learning solutions. We talk about business issues with leaders, not just in the context of learning and development. And, we emphasize collaboration throughout the learning development and implementation process, leveraging leader involvement and learning transfer to achieve business results.” Test yourself. Can you answer the questions in Exhibit D1.1? If so, congratulations, you are in touch with your business. If not, or if you struggled with some of the questions, then you have the opportunity to improve your performance by deepening your understanding of your organization’s business. How can you deepen your knowledge about the business and thereby enhance your value as a business partner? There are ample learning opportunities on the job and in the course of your work. The first and critical requirements are interest and curiosity. Once you become genuinely interested in how the business works and curious about the kinds of questions in Exhibit D1.1, you will find plenty of
Exhibit D1.1 Self-Test of Business Knowledge Answer the following questions about your business: 1. The most important source of our revenue is:
2. The most important driver of our growth is:
3. The core elements of our strategy are (list):
4. Our main competitor is:
5. The greatest threat we face is:
6. The greatest human capital challenge we face as a company is:
CH001.indd 32
6/17/10 3:22:23 PM
Define Business Outcomes
33
information and opportunities to deepen your understanding in business plans, reports, and conversations with business leaders. Boudreau (2010) makes the point that the more that HR leaders are able to explain what they do using the business models that line managers use intuitively, the better they will be understood. An example would be relating managing a talent pool to an inventory management model. Business leaders understand the kinds of tradeoffs that must be made in setting inventory levels for various products or raw materials; there are direct parallels to managing the talent inventory. Likewise, business managers understand process management and process improvement models in manufacturing; explaining the parallels to the learning process will help them appreciate why treating learning as an isolated event will always sub-optimize the results. An example of such a model is given in Figure D1.3. It illustrates the concept that there are only two fundamental paths to improving business results: (1) increase revenue (sales volume); and (2) increase productivity (reduce the cost of providing products and services). For example, sales training that generates more effective sales behaviors contributes to the sales volume path. Safety training that reduces time lost in accidents contributes to productivity through lower costs and greater output. It is important to note that it is not the training as such that contributes to the organization’s success, but the actions that flow from training. Indeed, training itself actually increases cost and lowers productivity unless it is transferred to work and translated into productive behavior. Improved actions and changed behaviors necessarily precede business impact (Figure D1.4). This sequence of events is relevant to both defining outcomes (D1) and documenting results (D6). A change in behavior will be the first evidence that the program is having the desired effect. It is therefore a leading indicator of business impact. FIGURE D1.3.
PATHWAYS TO IMPROVING BUSINESS RESULTS
Profits
Increase Sales Volume
Market Development
CH001.indd 33
Market Penetration
Increase Productivity
Decrease Input Costs
Increase Output
6/17/10 3:22:24 PM
34
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
On the other hand, a program that fails to change behavior is unlikely to deliver results and needs to be examined to understand the root cause(s) of the breakdown. The flow of causality is from left to right, from training to behaviors to results (Figure D1.4). Therefore, learning and development programs must be planned in the opposite direction, from desired results, to the behaviors required to produce them, to the kinds of learning experiences and exercises needed to create the capability to perform optimally (Figure D1.5). To design highly effective learning interventions, you need to know the behaviors—in particular, the high-leverage or vital behaviors—that have the greatest impact on the desired results (Patterson, Grenny, Maxfield, McMillan, & Switzler, 2008, p. 28). A key task of the analysis phase of the ADDIE, TDQAS, and other instructional design approaches is to identify the critical knowledge, skills, and abilities required to perform required tasks and then use these to inform the design process. Training, of course, is only part of the process of learning and adopting new and more effective behaviors. In D2, we will talk about the importance of designing the whole experience to optimize the behavioral change. In D3, we will discuss how delivery affects learning transfer, and in D4 and D5, how the transfer climate regulates the conversion rate of learning to performance. FIGURE D1.4. LEARNING AND DEVELOPMENT PRODUCES RESULTS THROUGH NEW AND MORE EFFECTIVE BEHAVIORS BY THE PARTICIPANTS
Successful training and development
More effective or efficient actions/behaviors
Improved business results
FIGURE D1.5. DESIGN LEARNING PROGRAMS STARTING WITH BUSINESS OUTCOMES AND THE BEHAVIORS REQUIRED TO ACHIEVE THEM
Experiences needed to produce them
CH001.indd 34
Required changes in actions/behaviors
Desired business outcomes
6/17/10 3:22:25 PM
Define Business Outcomes
35
The point here is that learning interventions ultimately contribute to the business by making it more efficient (increasing productivity, reducing waste) or by making it more effective (driving revenue growth) and that the intermediate step in either path requires a change in behavior to new and better ways of doing things. Which path and which behaviors are most critical depend on the organization’s business model, climate, and state of development. Therefore, it is essential to understand the current circumstances. Understand the Current Situation Once you understand the “big picture” business fundamentals of your enterprise, you are in a position to take the next step, which is to discover the highest value needs or opportunities that training and development could help fulfill. It is important to invest this effort upfront. Successful companies invest substantial time and effort to discover their customers’ most important unmet needs. In the Innovator’s Solution, Christensen and Raynor (2003) explain: “When customers become aware of a job that they need to get done in their lives, they look around for a product or service that they can ‘hire’ to get the job done.” Therefore, “companies that target their products at the circumstances in which customers find themselves, rather than the customers themselves, are those that can launch predictably successful products” (p. 75). In effect, line organizations “hire” learning and development to do a job they need done. The more fully the learning and development group understands the challenges that line managers face—the business ends they are trying to achieve—the better they will be able to deliver solutions that the organization values and rewards with continued investment. Indeed, Swanson (2003) argues that neglect of front-end analysis is one of the most common causes for training transfer failure. Which improvement targets offer the greatest potential for return is very much time- and situation-specific. They depend on a company’s history, environment, market, competitors, product life cycle, cost structure, and so forth. Circumstances change. The most pressing business needs or opportunities this year are likely to be different than last year’s. Therefore, the best investment of learning resources (the programs that will deliver the highest value) are also likely to have changed. Corporate learning organizations need to continually scan the environment and adjust their offerings if they are to remain relevant. In a well-run business, the largest shares of available advertising, sales, marketing, and other resources are committed to those product lines with the greatest potential for growth and profitability. Learning organizations should follow suit, deploying the greatest portion of their resources to opportunities and issues
CH001.indd 35
6/17/10 3:22:26 PM
36
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
that are “mission critical.” That may require taking resources away from—or even discontinuing—programs of lesser importance. Making such hard and vital resource allocation decisions is the essence of strategic management. But how do you decide which opportunities are most promising? Do Your Market Research Companies decide which customer needs offer the most attractive opportunity for their products and services through market research. Multiple sources of data are consulted. Studies, interviews, and focus groups are conducted to understand what customers want, how much they are willing to pay, how they will judge success, and how they should be segmented and targeted. Defining customer needs for learning and development initiatives should follow a similar approach. Since most key customers for learning and development are internal, the needs analysis should be faster and less expensive than for a consumer product, but for a major program it should be no less thorough. Two sources of information are available to identify the most valuable training interventions: “explicit knowledge” contained in business plans and reports, and the “tacit knowledge” of leaders, managers, and employees. Both will be needed to make an informed decision. You should begin by reviewing all of the “explicit” published information (strategic plans, business plans, task forces’ or consultants’ reports, and so forth) before taking busy managers’ time for interviews or focus groups. There are three reasons for this. First, it demonstrates your respect for business leaders’ time and the pressures they face. You should never waste a manager’s time asking him or her to go over things you could have easily read for yourself. Second, you will be afforded more respect—and probably more time—if it is clear that you have done your homework and have generated ideas of your own. Third, with the business plan as background, you will be able to ask more intelligent and penetrating questions and thus reach a deeper level of understanding than if you simply show up and ask to be enlightened. Get a copy of the business unit’s plan and read it carefully. Review any other relevant company documents, such as a strategic plan, consultant’s report, and competitive analysis. Read actively with an inquisitive mind. • • • • •
CH001.indd 36
What is the business unit trying to accomplish? What are the business leaders’ key objectives and initiatives? What do they list as the competitive threats or downside scenarios? What keeps them up at night worrying? What are the causes of suboptimal performance that education could help resolve?
6/17/10 3:22:26 PM
Define Business Outcomes
37
• Where are there inefficiencies or inconsistencies that waste significant amounts of time and money? • Where could an effective training or development program reduce the risk and improve the likelihood or magnitude of the success? The goal is to understand the business’s greatest unmet needs and opportunities and to formulate your own ideas about where learning could add value, rather than just waiting to be told. Understanding the business plan allows you to be proactive, to move from “order taker” to strategic business partner and performance consultant. Once you have reviewed the available documents and formulated some ideas about key needs, it is time to get out and speak with line leaders. Suggested interview guidelines are given in Exhibit D1.2. Avoid the temptation to interview only other learning leaders or the heads of human resources; the information you gather will be insufficient. However well-informed and well-intentioned they may be, they are one step removed from the action. Likewise, you cannot rely on a single manager’s point of view (see “Inadequate Input” below). You have to talk to the people who are in the arena, the people whose careers depend on delivering results. That’s crucial, because learning organizations that achieve real alignment and deliver against the needs of the business enjoy strong support, even in the face of financial exigencies (see Case in Point D1.3). Translate Needs into Desired Outcomes The goal of your discussions with business leaders is to define the desired outcomes in areas in which learning can help close a critical gap or seize a valuable business opportunity. Since the original publication of The Six Disciplines, thousands of learning professionals have used the Outcomes Planning Wheel (Figure D1.6) to help guide and structure discussions with line leaders about training needs. This simple, four-step approach works well both for prospective discussions with leaders about potential training solutions, as well as to respond to a request for training. We have modified it slightly from the original based on our experience and suggestions from readers and clients. The Wheel is simple to draw—on a flip chart, for example—to help facilitate a group discussion, but also works well one-on-one, even over the phone. Although the questions are numbered and initially approached in order, answers to one question often belong in another quadrant or lead to follow-up questions. Be flexible and modify the flow as necessary to get the information you need; do not feel slavishly bound to the form.
CH001.indd 37
6/17/10 3:22:27 PM
38
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Exhibit D1.2 Interview Guidelines for Discovering Business Needs Preparation • Do your homework; read the relevant business plans, reports, and related materials. • Schedule your interview with the business leader in advance; state the objective and time required. • Know what you want to get out of the interview before you begin. The Interview • Follow the classic sales opening: meet and greet, state the value, propose an agenda, check for agreement. • Start on time and end on time. • Use open questions, check for understanding by restating; probe for the deeper issues. • Summarize what you understood from reading the plan and check your understanding: “From what I was able to read, it seems like the most important things you are trying to accomplish are X, Y, Z. Did I summarize that correctly? What have I missed?” • Identify the main gaps between current and desired performance. Are there areas in which people lack key skills or capabilities that will make it difficult to achieve the objectives? What one improvement in terms of people’s skills or behaviors would most help the leader achieve his or her objectives? • Are there new initiatives, opportunities, or strategies that will require new knowledge or skills to execute? • Use the Outcomes Planning Wheel (Figure D1.6) to help identify the links among overall business needs, desired behaviors, confirmatory evidence, and conditions of success. Follow-Up • Immediately following the interview, summarize the discussion in writing. • Include the answers to the four questions of the Outcomes Planning Wheel as an efficient way to set out your understanding of the linkages between the results desired and the capabilities needed to achieve them. • Send a thank-you note to the person you interviewed and include a copy of your summary (“Thank you very much for your time. I found our discussion very helpful and enlightening. I attach a brief summary of the key points. Please let me know if I missed or misunderstood anything.”). • The purpose is four-fold: • Summarizing your notes will encourage you to reflect on what you have learned and better cement it in your memory. • The document will be a useful reference as the planning process proceeds. • Your summary acknowledges that you valued the leader’s time and input. • Finally, sharing your summary with the person you interviewed provides him or her with the opportunity to correct any oversights or misunderstandings, which will help you create a superior solution.
CH001.indd 38
6/17/10 3:22:27 PM
Define Business Outcomes
39
Case in Point D1.3 Learning to Effect Change Health care is a rapidly changing industry. The pace of change places unprecedented demands on its leaders. Skills and approaches that were successful in the past are no longer adequate; new leadership competencies and insights are needed. Ray Vigil, the chief learning officer for Humana, Inc., believes strongly that the leadership development strategy must be an integral part of the overall business strategy; it must begin with the end in mind. Because these conditions have been met at Humana, the Leadership Institute is viewed by the top management as an important enterprise-wide tool with tremendous positive business impact. “The CEO wanted to take a very traditional company and move to a consumer-centric point of view, approaching problems and the industry very differently, so that we produced competitive advantage by a disruptive change strategy in the way we go to market. But historically, leaders in health care have not had the same kind of leadership development focus that other industries have had. So the big challenge we had initially was how to take a management team that had been successful with very traditional functional skills and get them to realize that they needed to embrace a very different vision; they had to develop the capability to work across the enterprise, not just in their function. “Our CEO had been working with the senior leadership team to develop an enlightened view and a strategy for becoming a consumer-centric company. While leaders understood the strategy intellectually, they were having difficulty understanding what they had to do differently. “Most people would say, ‘Gee, if you understand something, it ought to be obvious that you take action on it.’ But I think it is a very big challenge for people to execute a strategy that is very different from the mindset and skills that brought them success in the past. “From the beginning, when our CEO said, ‘I know I need a chief learning officer,’ I interpreted that to mean that he had a business strategy that was going to require a great deal of change leadership, and he needed a learning strategy to complement the business strategy. I was able to convince my team that we needed to think about what we were doing in a strategic sense. We needed to really drill down on where the CEO wanted to take the business and what it was going to take to get us there. What did the future state look like? How do you implement and execute that strategy with the human capital we have? “We devised something we called the touch-point program to identify the key intersections, the key leverage points with the organization that could make a difference. We identified the key stakeholders and made them part of the design team. They helped us design the whole process, including the evaluation and after-action review. When it came time to implement, everybody was shocked that there was such great acceptance, but that was because we had identified the key leverage points and through the touch-point campaign had incorporated their interests and thinking into the program. Because we started with an outcome of use and what the end state was supposed to look like, we were able to integrate all the pieces into a coherent strategy and an integrated experience for the participants.”
CH001.indd 39
6/17/10 3:22:28 PM
40
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D1.6. OUTCOMES PLANNING WHEEL
4.
1.
What are the specific criteria of success?
What business need(s) will be met?
3.
4 1 3 2
What or who could confirm these changes?
2. What will participants do differently and better?
© 2010 Fort Hill Company. Used with permission.
As you move from a reactive training role into one as a performance consultant, remember that many business leaders are used to simply “ordering” training and have not thought deeply about the questions at the heart of the Outcomes Planning Wheel. You will need to ask some probing and clarifying questions to achieve the mutual level of understanding necessary to develop a truly effective program. You may even encounter resistance from some managers who may feel challenged or threatened by your interest in trying to understand the real rationale behind “we need a program.” The best approach we have found is to assure the leader up-front that you have the company’s best interest in mind and that the reason for the interview is to maximize the probability of success by saying something like: “Because training
CH001.indd 40
6/17/10 3:22:28 PM
Define Business Outcomes
41
will consume participants’ time and company money, I want to be sure we deliver the best possible results for you. I’d like to ask you a series of questions to be sure I understand the business drivers behind the request and the outcomes you really want from the training. That will help us design the best and most cost-effective solution.” Throughout the conversation, practice active listening. Stop and check for understanding periodically: “Let me be sure that I have understood you correctly. [Restate the needs, behaviors, etc. as you understand them]. Is that correct?” Likewise, do not be afraid to admit you do not understand something: “Could you explain what you mean by . . . .” “Help me understand . . .” is a very useful phrase that can be used to genuinely seek understanding, but also as a graceful way to point out inconsistency or confusion, as in: “Help me understand how the training course you have requested is linked to your business needs.”
The Four Questions There are four key questions to the Outcomes Planning Wheel. Each is discussed in turn below. 1. What Business Need(s) Will Be Met? The first question is about the business needs that will be met (or opportunities realized) if the course is a success. The goal is to gain clarity about the real business issue or opportunity behind the request for training. This is critical not only to inform the design of the program, but to make sure that training is an appropriate part of the solution (see “Training Traps” below). Being able to tightly couple training to specific business needs increases the buy-in of the participants and their managers. Learning organizations that have adopted the 6Ds find that they enjoy greater support for their programs when they include the business purpose in the course description rather than when they simply list the topics covered or learning objectives. For example: “This course will help you increase the productivity of your team by . . .” or “This program will help you increase sales by . . . .” You will probably have to ask a series of clarifying questions to get to a definition of business need that is specific enough to be actionable. A manager’s first answer to this question often simply asserts the need for training, “We need a training program on the order entry system,” as opposed to stating the business need behind the proposed solution or what issue the training program is meant to resolve. The challenge in such cases is to help the client reframe the question: “to transition from a focus on the solution to a focus on business and performance results” (Robinson &
CH001.indd 41
6/17/10 3:22:29 PM
42
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Robinson, 2008, p. 171). You need to probe for the ultimate, measurable, businessrelated outcome behind the proposed training: “Can you help me understand what is behind your request for training? If the training is successful, how will the business benefit? For example, will we experience fewer errors, greater speed, lower cost, or something like that?” The perceived need for training usually originates because management believes that something is not happening that should be (“the sales clerks are not asking customers about related supplies”) or that something is happening that should not be (“too many mistakes,” “inappropriate behavior,” and so forth). Your goal is to draw out the underlying perception and why it is a problem: the cost or lost opportunity for the organization. A second common situation is for the initial answer to define the desired result, but in terms too general to be useful, for example, “We need to increase sales.” In this case, you need to probe for details, for the intermediate steps or aspects of the process that require attention: “You have been very clear about the urgent need to increase sales. Can you say more about the specific aspects of the sales process that you feel we most need to address or improve?” 2. What Will Participants Do Differently and Better? This second question is designed to help identify the vital behaviors or actions needed to effect the desired results. The core concept is the quip often ascribed to Einstein: “One definition of insanity is to continue doing the same thing and expect a different result.” In other words, people have to do something in a different way to produce a different result: Just ‘knowing” or “understanding” is not enough. Participants have to put their new knowledge and skills to work in ways that are different, better, and more effective than what they were doing previously. The learning organization needs to know what the desired behaviors are in order to design effective instruction and help create a positive “transfer climate” (see D4) that supports those behaviors on the job. Ask the client to describe the desired changes in behavior: “If the training is a success, and we were to watch how people perform their jobs afterward, what would we see them doing that is different and better?” Another useful approach is to ask about the behaviors of top performers: “What do the top performers do that lesser performers don’t? If the training is successful, more people should do what the top performers do. What would that look like?” 3. What or Who Could Confirm These Changes? The goal of this third question is to start the dialogue about how to validate whether or not the training is producing the desired outcomes. The core concept is that the only way that learning organizations can succeed is if they know how
CH001.indd 42
6/17/10 3:22:30 PM
Define Business Outcomes
43
success is defined by the customer. The latter phrase is in italics because, as we will explain in greater detail in D6, it is the customer who ultimately decides whether the initiative was a success or failure. Engaging the customer (which, in business, usually means the department that is paying the bill) in a discussion of what could be measured facilitates the discussion of what should be measured and how success will be defined (Question 4, below). The right time to have those discussions is in the project definition phase since it affects everything else—from designing the complete experience (D2) to documenting the results (D6). The initial discussion of Question 3 should be a shared brainstorming session. “How can we be sure the training is working? That is, if we get the training and the transfer climate right, the participants’ performance should begin to improve. Who will notice these changes first? How can we find out whether people are really using what they learned? What else will change or be measurable?” You may need to “prime the pump” here by offering some suggestions to help your client think about potential outcomes and how they could be confirmed. Examples include: • If we were to actually observe participants doing their jobs, would we be able to see the change? What would we look for? • Who would notice a change as part of their normal interactions with the participants, for example, customers, managers, or direct reports? Who could we ask? • Would any of the business metrics that we track routinely (sales, quality, customer satisfaction, and so forth) change? Which? It turns out that while there are a very large number of potential outcomes, there are only a small number of types of outcomes and ways to assess them. Use Table D1.3 to help guide your brainstorming. In the early stages of the conversation, the goal is to explore a number of options for measuring the outcome. However, sometimes the changes that the customer wants to see (for example, change in turnover) will take so long to become evident that the impact of training will be obscured by other factors. In such cases, encourage the client to help you identify “leading indicators.” Leading indicators are the earliest evidence that things are going in the right direction. Your follow-up discussion might sound like this: “We agreed at the beginning of our discussion that improving retention is a long-term business need and goal. The problem with relying solely on that to measure the impact of training is that we won’t see a significant change in retention rates for months. By then it will be hard to figure out whether it was the training or something else. What could we measure sooner that would give us an indication that the training is having the desired effect? A survey? Employee commitment scores? 360-degree feedback?”
CH001.indd 43
6/17/10 3:22:30 PM
44
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
TABLE D1.3.
MAJOR CATEGORIES OF POST-LEARNING OUTCOMES AND WAYS TO DOCUMENT THEM
Type of Outcome
Potential Data Sources
Potential Data Collection
Change in behavior
Participants themselves Participants’ managers Customers Trained observers
Survey Interview Observation
Improved opinion by key stakeholders
Customers Direct reports Managers Others
Satisfaction survey Interviews Focus groups
Improved business metrics
Company IT system Independent tracking resource
Data extraction Data purchase
Improved work product
Samples of work
Expert review or observation
Identifying and assessing leading indicators is important to get an early read on whether the training is having the desired effect and to support continuous improvement of subsequent classes. 4. What Are the Specific Criteria of Success? Once you have listed all the possible outcomes that might be measured, it is time to agree on what will be measured and when, and how much of a change is required to consider the program a success. It is vital to get agreement on the “conditions of satisfaction” in advance since these are the deliverables section of the contract between the learning organization and line management. The discussion of Question 4 should be primarily a selection process, winnowing down the possible choices identified in Question 3 to the critical few. It should include a high-level discussion of how they will be measured; for example, will self reports suffice? Your goal is to come to agreement with the business leaders on the key outcomes and acceptable approaches to documenting results, not to develop a detailed evaluation plan—that is the work of D6. For example, suppose that the ultimate business need is to reduce employee turnover, and that you and the sponsor have agreed (as the research shows) that a leading indicator of intent to stay is a good working relationship between the employee and his or her supervisor. For a management training program, then, you might define the specific measure of success as: “On a survey three months
CH001.indd 44
6/17/10 3:22:31 PM
Define Business Outcomes
45
after the program, at least half the direct reports of attendees agree that their relationship with their manager has improved.” For other kinds of programs, the criterion for success might be a change in a tracked business metric (quality index, customer satisfaction, average sales), while for others, a manager’s evaluation of the participant’s performance might be an adequate measure of success. There is no one right answer. The goal of Question 4 is to come to agreement on what the program is supposed to achieve in terms that the customer considers relevant and credible and which the learning organization believes it can achieve given the resources available and the level of support for learning transfer. Defining the criteria of success should be a “give and take” discussion. The learning organization should not blindly accept impossible targets—since sooner or later it will be called to account. While committing to specific levels of achievement may feel uncomfortable and foreign to learning professionals, it is, as Basarab (in press) points out, the norm in business. Sales leaders have to commit to achieving specific levels of sales, marketers to specific market share, CEOs to profitA clear set of business ability and growth targets, heads of outcomes from training manufacturing to lower cost or higher enhances the credibility of the quality. A known target allows the learnlearning organization. ing organization to optimize the learning experience and to implement continuous improvement. And, perhaps most important, a clear set of business outcomes from training enhances the credibility of the learning organization, earning it a real seat at the table and its long-sought goal of being embraced as a true business partner. Create Co-Ownership Once the desired business outcomes have been clarified, there is one more critical question to discuss: “Besides training, what else needs to be in place to achieve these results?” This is a critical question to raise because training is never the whole answer. To get a lasting change in behavior requires coaching and encouragement from managers; support when people run into difficulties; and recognition and reward systems that are aligned with the desired actions. As Mosel pointed out more than fifty years ago: “It is top management, through the organizational climate or reward structure it creates, that is really doing the training, regardless of what the training staff does. The training administered by the training staff ‘sticks’ only if it coincides with what top management is teaching every day” (Mosel, 1957, emphasis in original). Use the final “what else” question to begin to educate the sponsor on the extent to which factors in addition to training (see D4: Drive Learning Transfer)
CH001.indd 45
6/17/10 3:22:31 PM
46
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
influence the success or failure of the effort. “We can certainly teach people how and why these behaviors are important and we will put in place systems to support and document them. But what else needs to happen to support and encourage these behaviors on the job? I’m thinking about everything from coaching to tools to reward systems.” Another useful way to help clients think about the post-training environment is to ask: “What currently gets in the way of people performing in the desired fashion? What barriers can we reduce or eliminate to increase the probability of success?” Your goal is to help the sponsor realize that the business is co-responsible for the success or failure of any training initiative. You need them to commit, as their part of the “contract,” to creating a supportive transfer climate. Training needs clearly defined business outcomes to succeed, but it also requires a supportive environment and the cooperation of management. Enforce Priorities Once you begin to think proactively about the areas in which learning could contribute to the success of the business, you will discover many potential programs that could make a meaningful difference. By no means should all of these be pursued. Learning organizations—like other business functions—need to pick their targets carefully. No company has sufficient resources to pursue every market opportunity; no learning and development group can take on all the potential places in which performance could be improved through training. The danger of trying to pursue too many opportunities simultaneously is that you under-resource all of them with the end result that none make a meaningful contribution. It is better to execute a small number of important initiatives well than to execute a large number badly. The general rule of thumb is that the more limited your resources, the more discriminating you must be, directing your efforts where they are likely to produce the greatest return. Targeting your resources on opportunities that have the greatest potential necessarily means saying “no” to some requests. Learning organizations cannot—and should not—attempt to satisfy every training request or pursue every opportunity, especially when saddled with fixed or shrinking resources. There needs to be a rigorous and defensible basis for moving ahead with some opportunities and denying or delaying others. In this regard, a learning advisory council or steering committee can be very helpful: Senior executives, from multiple business units and corporate functions, should regularly meet and provide input on what needs to be done (and win implicit buy-in in the process). They will help push programs through the approval and budgeting process and provide timely and accurate feedback
CH001.indd 46
6/17/10 3:22:31 PM
Define Business Outcomes
47
on program effectiveness. Educational programs will carry significant weight if they are supported by the advisory board and board support will increase the credibility of the entire executive education function. (Saslow, 2005, p. 45)
Three factors must be weighed in the prioritization process: • The upside potential. This is the positive business impact that will be realized if the program achieves the business outcomes for which it was created. • The downside costs of killing or delaying a program. These might include lost opportunity, adverse legal or regulatory exposure, inadequate leadership pipeline, and so forth. • The probability of success. A program might well have significant potential upside, but if line management is unwilling to invest the time and resources necessary to create a favorable transfer climate, then the probability of achieving the projected results is low and the expected payback should be significantly discounted. To help ensure that such factors are taken into consideration, some companies, such as Randstad, use a business unit sign-off form than prompts managers to think about the magnitude of the problem and the value of resolving it (Bersin, 2008b). One of our biopharmaceutical clients requires business units to force rank potential training opportunities in terms of their potential business value. Regardless of the specific mechanism used, the key is to have a process that involves business leaders in making sure that scarce training resources are focused on the highest-value opportunities.
Avoid Training Traps The human development field is rife with traps for the unwary. In our consulting practice, we encounter too many learning organizations that have succumbed to one or more of the many potential pitfalls (Case in Point D1.4). Some of the most common pitfalls are listed below, with suggestions on how to avoid them, because nothing is more tragic than to have designers, facilitators, and technicians pour their energy and creativity into a program that doesn’t lead to valued results. It’s what Peterson and Nielsen call “fake work” and it is tragic because it is just as hard as real work and because it consumes time, resources, and people’s careers, even though it doesn’t actually advance the organization’s mission (Peterson & Nielsen, 2009, p. 4).
CH001.indd 47
6/17/10 3:22:32 PM
48
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Case in Point D1.4 Detailed Roadmap to Unclear Destination A major corporation consulted us about how they could increase the impact of a soon-tobe-launched management development program. We started through the Outcomes Planning Wheel. We asked: “What’s the driving business issue? How will the company benefit by having someone attend the program? What will participants do better and differently as a consequence of attending?” There was an awkward silence. The chief of learning turned to the program director. The program director deferred to the instructional designer. “That’s a good question,” they all said. But no one had the answer. They had a detailed plan—practically to the minute—of what was going to happen during the course. They knew which leadership models they were going to use. They had purchased a custom simulation and hired big-name speakers. They had a list of learning objectives—what knowledge participants would acquire—but no one could explain how these were linked to the business of the business. They were about to launch the program to hundreds of mid- and upper-level managers, but no one responsible for putting it together could explain the key business drivers or how attendance would increase productivity, generate new revenue, or otherwise create value for the company. This was a very smart, dedicated, hard-working, professional, and talented team, yet they had fallen into the trap of focusing so hard on the “how” that they had lost sight of the “why.” Their experience suggests just how easy this is to do and why learning and line leaders alike must keep coming back to the business rationale and define the intended outcomes in business terms.
How can such a thing happen? Why do even savvy learning organizations get off track? Our experience suggests that there are five key training traps that must be avoided: • • • • •
Training as cure-all Having a program to have a program Confusion between means and ends Laudable intent Inadequate input
Training as Cure-All Not every performance problem is amenable to training. One of the most common reasons that training fails to deliver satisfactory results is that the problem
CH001.indd 48
6/17/10 3:22:33 PM
Define Business Outcomes
49
being addressed was not one that could be solved by training in the first place (Phillips & Phillips, 2002). If the productivity of customer support personnel is low, for example, because the computer system they use is slow and unreliable, no amount of training will noticeably improve the situation; better results will be achieved by expending resources to upgrade the software, equipment, or both. If, on the other hand, productivity is low because support personnel do not know how to use the software efficiently or take advantage of shortcuts, then the right training with the right performance support will produce significant improvement. Unfortunately, many managers’ knee-jerk reaction to any performance issue is “We need a training program,” without really analyzing the root causes of the problem. Any number of deficiencies can result in suboptimal performance; training can only address performance issues related to a lack of skills or knowledge (Stolovitch & Keeps, 2004, p. 11). Mager and Pipe (1997) suggested that the acid test is: “Could they do it if their lives depended on it?” If the answer is yes, “then you can forget training as a potential solution. After all, ‘teaching’ people what they already know how to do isn’t going to affect the performance discrepancy” (p. 93). If people know how to do something correctly, but they aren’t, then their poor performance stems from a lack of motivation, unclear expectations, insufficient feedback, or other managerial or systems failures (Exhibit D1.3) and training is not the solution. Learning professionals, in their roles as performance consultants, need to be sure that they have investigated and eliminated other causes of poor performance first. “Training is expensive to design and deliver; it should be the last, not the first, intervention the HRD professional and the organization should consider in order to improve employee performance” (Broad & Newstrom, 1992, p. 5). Nothing is more demoralizing to the learning organization, more frustrating to participants, or more damaging to learning’s reputation than to take on a training assignment that is doomed to failure because the real problem is a breakdown in management or systems. We have become increasingly concerned about the misuse of training to try to solve all manner of unrelated performance problems; it is giving learning a black eye. In our workshops, we ask learning professionals what percent of their programs fail because training was not the right solution to the problem. Estimates are consistently 10 to 25 percent, and in one company, 40 percent. That suggests that somewhere between one-tenth and one-quarter of all training programs are doomed to failure because the real issues have not been identified or addressed. Training is being used as a sop by management to give the appearance that something is being done. No wonder there is often cynicism about the effectiveness of training. Workplace learning professionals must not let themselves be used as patsies.
CH001.indd 49
6/17/10 3:22:34 PM
50
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Exhibit D1.3 Causes of Poor Performance That Can Be Solved Without Training UNCLEAR EXPECTATIONS ❑ If employees do not know exactly what is expected of them, make sure performance standards are made clear. Suboptimal performance is often due simply to inadequate understanding of what is wanted.
LACK OF FEEDBACK ❑ If employees have not received unambiguous feedback on their current performance, see that they get it. Training is sometimes used to avoid providing direct feedback on sub-par performance. Even if people understand what is expected, they need feedback on their performance in order to improve it.
LACK OF INCENTIVE ❑ If there is no positive recognition or reward for doing things right, see that there is. Training cannot solve a motivation problem. Being recognized for a job well done is a powerful motivator. Yet an astounding number of employees say they have not received any positive feedback for months on end.
LACK OF CONSEQUENCES ❑ If there aren’t currently any negative consequences for not performing, make sure there are. If there are no consequences for not performing in the desired fashion, most people will take the path of least resistance, and attempting to train them to do otherwise is a fool’s errand. One poor learning professional in one of our workshops had been asked to put together a half-day program on hardhat safety because workers were not wearing their hardhats on the job site. We asked what happened if they were on site without a hardhat. The answer was “nothing”—which was the problem—not a lack or knowledge or skill.
INADEQUATE TOOLS, NO ACCESS TO NEEDED INFORMATION, OVERLY COMPLICATED PROCESSES, AND SO FORTH ❑ If there are other obstacles to satisfactory performance—such as inadequate tools or insufficient access to information—these have to be addressed directly; they cannot be resolved by training. Use training only to address issues stemming from inadequate knowledge or skills that cannot be solved by simple job aids or other performance support.
CH001.indd 50
6/17/10 3:22:34 PM
Define Business Outcomes
51
So what do you do when you are asked to create a training program when you know that training is not the right solution to the problem? You follow Stolovitch’s advice and say immediately, “I can help you solve your problem” (Stolovitch & Keeps, 2004, p. 16). Because you can, even though it won’t be by providing training. Indeed, if you can show, through skillful questioning and analysis, that the problem is not a lack of knowledge or skills—and therefore one that can be Even when training clearly is solved more effectively and less expenpart of the solution, it is never sively with a non-training solution—you all of the solution. have helped your client, the company, and the learning organization a great deal. If, on the other hand, the first words out of your mouth are, “I am not sure that training is the right solution,” you may be right, but you may be seen as negative and uncooperative, and the manager may just go hire a training vendor to provide the wrong solution anyway. You will have missed an opportunity to educate your client and to help your organization and yourself. Remember that even when training clearly is part of the solution, it is never all of the solution. In the next chapter (D2), we will consider the criticality of designing the complete experience, which includes all four phases of learning, together with the performance support systems and environmental factors that determine whether or not a program delivers its objectives. Because learning and development is increasingly being held accountable for demonstrating meaningful business impact, learning organizations must become adept at avoiding assignments for which training is not the answer. We Need a Program When the main purpose of having a program is “to have a program,” the initiative is in trouble from the start. This problem typically begins when someone in upper management decrees that the company needs to have a program on something or other (see Figure D1.7). That isn’t itself a problem when the impetus is a real business need that can be addressed by training, such as insufficient skills in marketing, leadership, or sales. But programs also spring from causes that are less results-driven, such as the need to “have some training” as part of a meeting, a business book extolling the latest theory, a consultant, a conference, a competitor’s program (especially if it attracted media attention), or a pointed question from the board (“What are you doing to accelerate innovation?”). Whatever the inciting event, the assignment is passed down the line as, “The boss wants us to put together a program on X.” Well-meaning subordinates
CH001.indd 51
6/17/10 3:22:34 PM
52
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D1.7.
TRAINING TRAP 2: WE NEED A PROGRAM
© 2010 by Randy Glasbergen; www.glasbergen.com. Used with permission.
scramble to fill the order. Experts are consulted; vendors are vetted; models and theories are debated. After the expenditure of much time and energy, a “custom” curriculum is designed; logistics are planned; speakers are hired. The only detail that has been overlooked is the business driver: What results are expected beyond “having a program?” How will “having a program” benefit the business? What outcomes are we trying to achieve? It is very easy, especially in large organizations, for the program—which usually means “the event”—to become an end in itself. When this happens, success becomes defined as the number of attendees and the scores on endof-event evaluations. But neither of these drive the organization forward nor justify the cost. The higher in the organization that the idea for the program originated, the less likely that it will be challenged. “Having a program” will become an unquestioned organizational imperative. Jack Welch is reported to have said that one of the problems with being CEO is that “You ask for a cup of coffee and they go out and buy Colombia.” If the CEO wants a program, what human resources or organizational development staff member is going to have the temerity to ask: “Why?” or “What’s the payoff for the company?” Yet those are exactly the kinds of questions that must be asked if learning and development is going to succeed.
CH001.indd 52
6/17/10 3:22:35 PM
Define Business Outcomes
53
Susan Burnett, senior vice president for talent and organizational development at Yahoo!, told the story of being interviewed at The Gap: “When I was being interviewed, the CEO said, ‘I want Merchant University.’ And I said: ‘Why?’ If I had not had that conversation, I would not have known.” (See Case in Point D1.5.)
Case in Point D1.5 Good News, Bad News When Susan Burnett became senior vice president of talent and development for Gap, Inc., she got some good news. “I came in on the day they were finalizing the budget and sat down with my new boss. She showed me the budget and she said, ‘Hey, I have some good news for you. The learning team got $6 million in incremental funds to produce Merchant University, Design Academy, and a new on-boarding process.’ I said, ‘OK, cool, six million dollars, that is great. But why does the business need these programs? What business results are we supposed to produce for Gap, Inc?’ “And so I interviewed people, talked to managers. I am voraciously interested in how the business works and how we make money—always have been. It comes from years of line management. So here was the perfect opportunity. I was a new leader, in a new business, and I needed to really understand the drivers for success. “I learned about Gap’s business strategies for growth, operations, and people. As I talked with the executive team and their leadership teams, I learned that Gap’s transformation would come from building new leadership capabilities in our people and new organizational capabilities in product development, supply chain, and IT. I learned that the merchant job was central to our brand’s success, and that Gap had invented the role of the merchant in the late 1980s, evolving from buyer to merchant leader. I also saw that the current reengineering of the product pipeline would require the reinvention of the merchant role again. And I learned that turnover of our new employees and our key merchant talent was unacceptable. “I was excited that my learning organization would have the opportunity to make a big difference in achieving Gap’s business objectives. We could stem the new employee turnover tide with an awesome hiring-to-on-boarding process that improved productivity and performance in the first ninety days. We could accelerate understanding of the new merchant role, the new concept to customer pipeline, and build the new merchant general management capabilities desperately needed by our business.” But then she discovered the bad news. The learning team was not connected to the priorities of the business. They were working hard to produce legacy programs, but they were not working on the real business issues. They were not connected to the business strategies and core changes the new leadership was driving. As a result, “I got a proposal for Merchant U that wasn’t connected to the transformation the business needed for success. I also saw that my team didn’t have the critical business relationships and connections that would get them the information they needed. It was a recipe for failure.”
CH001.indd 53
6/17/10 3:22:36 PM
54
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
The stronger the command-and-control culture of a company, the more likely everyone will exert best efforts to fulfill a program request without ever stopping to ask, “Why?” The result will be a learning initiative that lacks grassroots support because there is no clear line of sight to the mission and goals of the business. Line managers will grumble among themselves about the cost or wasted time, but most will go along with it in order to save their powder for bigger battles. A conspiracy of silence develops; the discussions of the program will all take place in what Connolly and Rianoshek (2002) call “pretense” mode—everyone saying the right things but no one addressing the real concerns. And the poor learning organization—having done its best to fulfill what it thought it was asked to do— will not understand why its contribution is not valued as highly as the management rhetoric suggested. Programs created for the sole sake of “having a program” are doomed. The antidote is to establish D1 as a guiding principle across the organization: No program, regardless of who requests it, will be executed without a clear rationale based on expected business outcomes. That will help create a climate in which it is normal to question the business justification for every proposed program and in which only those initiatives for which there is a compelling business need are executed. Confusing Means and Ends Just as “having a program” is inadequate as a rationale, “having given a program” is inadequate as an outcome. Many corporate learning organizations still report the number of people taught, hours of instruction, the number of e-learning courses completed, and so forth as if they were results. Learning management systems have contributed to the problem by making it easier to collect, generate, slice, and dice such data and turn them into PowerPoint slides and graphs. But such statistics are measures of activity, not productivity. They are measures of inputs, not outputs. The well-known human resources consultant Dave Ulrich related a meeting he had with the chairman and top human resources leaders from a large bank. “The training person said that 80 percent of employees have done at least forty hours in classes. The chairman said, ‘Congratulations.’ I said, ‘You’re talking about the activities you’re doing. The question is: What are you delivering?’” (quoted in Hammonds, 2005). The true goal of learning and development—and the standard against which it will increasingly be measured—is the extent to which it contributes to a company’s prosperity and competitiveness. The activities involved—courses, hours, instructors, coaching, podcasts, blog entries, and all the rest—are the means to an end, not the end itself. They are important for the learning organization
CH001.indd 54
6/17/10 3:22:36 PM
Define Business Outcomes
55
to track for the internal management of the function, but they are not the business outcomes for which the unit was created and funded. Confusing means with ends is hardly peculiar to learning and development. In any initiative, it is easy to become so focused on activities that the original purpose is lost. That is, “having lost sight of our objectives, we redoubled our efforts.” Activities are seductive; they are observable, quantifiable, and easy to measure, graph, and report. But they do not equate to value added. Writing about corporate change initiatives, Schaffer and Thomson (1992) said: “At the heart of these programs, which we call ‘activity centered,’ is a fundamentally flawed logic that confuses ends with means, process with outcomes.” A focus on activity rather than results leads to a situation in which “The performance improvement efforts of many companies have as much impact on operational and financial results as a ceremonial rain dance has on the weather” (p. 2). The fault is management’s, or, as the comics character Pogo said: “We have met the enemy and he is us.” For years, learning and development organizations have been treated as pure cost centers rather than contributors to productivity. The result has been undue emphasis on efficiency (cost containment) rather than efficacy (cost benefit), on activity (programs or hours of training) as opposed to results (increased sales, greater efficiency, better leadership, more effective marketing, higher quality service, and so forth). Training departments, consultants, and vendors do not promise specific results because, historically, they haven’t been required to. As long as companies are willing to pay for activity, only a fool would offer more. This is in stark contrast to the standards for line departments. If a sales manager requests funds to increase the size of the sales force, she must be able to demonstrate how this will be translated into more sales, not merely more sales calls. A sales manager is measured and rewarded for achieving the promised increase in revenue, not merely for increasing the size of the sales force. Similarly, if the head of manufacturing requests funds to retool a plant, he had better be able to justify the investment in terms of increased productivity, lower costs, higher quality, and so forth; and he had better deliver on those promises. That is the way business works; activity alone is not rewarded. Teresa Roche, CLO for Agilent Technologies, understands this. Together with the prestige of being asked by the CEO to lead a high-profile, transformational leadership program came increased pressure and accountability for producing results. Roche said she welcomes the scrutiny. “If I’m going to be given something to work on and somebody is investing dollars and I’m being held to account to that, I wouldn’t want it any other way,” she said (quoted in Prokopeak, 2009). Practicing D1 and D6 religiously—requiring that business outcomes be specified for every program and then documenting them—will allow learning
CH001.indd 55
6/17/10 3:22:36 PM
56
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
organizations to avoid the means versus ends pitfall. Doing so ensures that learning organizations are subjected to the same rigorous scrutiny to which a well-run business subjects its line operations, and that they are recognized and rewarded for producing results. It is a manifest disservice to both learning professionals and shareholders to apply a lower standard to evaluate educational programs than is applied to other business processes. Laudable Intent A fourth pitfall for learning organizations is programs that are positioned on the moral high ground. Challenging the value of a diversity, safety training, or leadership development program is akin to questioning the value of motherhood, patriotism, or equality. Managers who value their careers are reluctant to challenge politically correct programs that have laudable intent. The result is that learning and development initiatives on such topics are rarely subjected to the same kind of rigorous review and debate as other expenditures of comparable magnitude. Marketing plans, for example, are closely scrutinized and frequently challenged. The debate about a marketing program is not about whether it is good or necessary to do marketing, but rather about whether the proposed plan is the best possible approach and whether it is likely to deliver the promised results. There should be equally candid discussions about learning programs in leadership, diversity, total quality, or other areas of laudable intent. Such debate should not be about the merit of such ideals, which is a given, but should rigorously explore how well the program serves or will serve the organization and whether the approach is likely to produce the desired outcomes. If a program is not producing the desired results—no matter how politically correct or laudable—it should be scrapped and replaced (see Case in Point D1.6). Learning organizations that practice D1—keeping the focus always on the desired business outcomes— encourage discussion about the organizational goals for every program and the best means of achieving them. Inadequate Input We continue to be surprised by the number of major learning programs that are implemented without adequate input in otherwise well-managed companies. Some are developed entirely within the human resource or training organization and are put into practice with little or no input from line leaders. While it is true that human resources, organizational development, and learning organizations have deep expertise in their respective disciplines, they are not the consumers of
CH001.indd 56
6/17/10 3:22:37 PM
Define Business Outcomes
57
Case in Point D1.6 It’s Your Ship When Captain Michael Abrashoff took command of the USS Benfold, one of his early actions was to cancel the diversity training program—not because he did not believe that diversity was critical to the success of the Navy, but because the current program was not achieving the outcomes for which it was intended: reducing racial tensions and sexual discrimination and improving teamwork. Because he was focused on the business outcomes, he wasn’t content just to have a program that everyone attended. When it was clear that the program wasn’t producing the required results, he eliminated it. “I could have been fired for that, but in my view it was common sense that a program that produced such awful results was clearly ineffective. I had no intention of allowing anything ineffective on Benfold” (Abrashoff, 2002, p. 170). Instead, he replaced it with something more effective. A program should not be exempt from having to deliver results just because it has high ideals and laudable intent; indeed, because their inherent merit is so great, such programs should probably receive increased scrutiny to be sure they are achieving their lofty goals.
the program, nor are they directly accountable for the bottom line. Their perspective on the business is different from that of line leaders; they have less hands-on experience managing hard business metrics. If they consult only among themselves, they may design a program with strong learning objectives but only weak links to the essential business outcomes. Equally dangerous is relying on only a single source of information about the performance gaps and their causes. The Outcomes Planning Wheel (Figure D1.6) we provided has proven useful in facilitating discussions with business managers about performance needs and the outcomes desired. We do not mean to imply, however, that you should rely on just one point of view. A manager’s perspective is different than that of the people who actually do the work. The Robinsons (2008, p. 80) recommend consulting a minimum of two different sources for information such as employees, managers, customers, business documents, or operational data. The success of training—or any other intervention, for that matter—depends on truly understanding the problem you are trying to solve. It is therefore vital to invest the time and effort to gather the data you need to gain a comprehensive view of the business outcomes sought and the skills and behaviors required to achieve them. The payoff is that programs that are clearly linked to business strategies will enjoy strong support from senior line leaders and earn the learning organization a true “seat at the table” (see Case in Point D1.7).
CH001.indd 57
6/17/10 3:22:37 PM
58
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Case in Point D1.7 Linking Learning and Strategy Plastipak Packaging is a global, $2 billion manufacturer of rigid plastic containers. Driven by the goal of enabling company leaders to manage the challenges and opportunities of rapid growth, the company launched Plastipak Academy in 2006. Its mission: deliver targeted learning solutions aligned with current business needs, equipping leaders enterprise-wide to grow the business. To change the paradigm about the role of learning, Academy leader Diane Hinton and her team have worked hard to hold conversations with senior managers that differ from what they typically expect from a learning unit. The goal is to ensure that learning at Plastipak is driven by business needs and strategy. As she explained: “We ask about their business challenges—not their training needs—to identify strategic priorities. For example, to jumpstart our needs assessment process, Mary Singos interviewed our company’s top twenty-six leaders about their business challenges during one-hour, one-on-one, gut-level conversations. She crystallized each dialog into need statements that the leader checked for accuracy and rated on business impact and priority. “We then compiled and presented the analysis—or the ‘voice of our leaders’—as a total picture of organizational needs and threats to each member of the executive steering team, one-on-one. With the executives’ guidance on priorities, we developed learning proposals for the top four business challenges that emerged. We solicited sponsorship from the executive(s) who ‘owned’ them. And in one case, we were able to forge a collaborative partnership between two executives who shared a similar challenge, but who previously held very different views on the solution. “The result is that we have moved the learning dialog from ‘training needs’ to ‘business needs.’ That has enabled us to establish a governance structure with executives who now collaborate to identify, set, and fund priorities. “Top leaders increasingly approach us or refer others to us to help them meet their pressing business needs. Our reputation for proactively doing the right things and doing them well has earned us a true ‘seat at the table.’ “For example, William C. Young, our president and CEO, requested that I be present during the annual corporate strategy meeting because, as he said, ‘I want the Academy to play an integral role in communicating and driving these changes.’ Mr. Young openly expresses the opinion that Plastipak Academy is a strategic lever bringing competitive advantage.” That is the kind of recognition to which all learning organizations should strive, but one that can only be earned by being business outcomes driven.
CH001.indd 58
6/17/10 3:22:38 PM
Define Business Outcomes
59
The International Society for Performance Improvement (ISPI) has defined human performance technology (HPT) as a systematic approach to solve practical problems of performance by the individuals and groups in organizations. The Society’s governing principles reinforce the importance of getting sufficient input to clearly define desired outcomes and performance gaps before designing interventions. The principles include: • A focus on outcomes • A systematic approach to the assessment of the need or opportunity • A systematic analysis of the work and workplace to identify the cause of factors that limit performance The HPT process begins with a comparison of the present and the desired levels of individual and organizational performance to identify the performance gap. A cause analysis is then done to determine what impact the work environment (information, resources, and incentives) and the people are having on performance. Once the performance gap and the causes have been determined, the appropriate interventions are designed and developed. (International Society for Performance Improvement, n.d.)
One way to ensure adequate input is to create a steering committee that includes both business and learning leaders to provide oversight and insight. Bersin (2008a) identified “alignment with the business strategy” as one of the six practices of highly effective development. At BNY Mellon, the top ten executives meet quarterly to review how leadership development is supporting the company’s business initiatives (Bersin, 2008a). At Sony, senior business leaders serve on Sony’s Talent Management Council, which helps design and evaluate Sony’s Integrated Leadership Curriculum. An executive from the council also attends the virtual wrap-up session in which participants report the business impact of working on their leadership goals. Many companies use senior leaders as instructors in strategic programs. Involving senior leadership in forging the strategy and also in the rollout ensures that the program has legitimacy and remains focused on business outcomes.
Manage Expectations Expectations matter. When you buy a product, you do so expecting certain benefits. As the saying goes: “People do not buy quarter-inch drills; they buy the expectation of quarter-inch holes.” Whether or not buyers are satisfied with their
CH001.indd 59
6/17/10 3:22:38 PM
60
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
purchases depends on whether or not their expectations were met. The same applies to training and development. Management doesn’t (or shouldn’t) buy courses; they buy the expectation of improved performance. Therefore, learning organizations need to be mindful of, and manage, the expectations of their customers Management doesn’t to ensure that they are in line with what can be buy courses; they buy the realistically delivered. Indeed, the Kirkpatricks expectation of improved have proposed that “return on expectations” is performance. the ultimate measure of training effectiveness (Kirkpatrick & Kirkpatrick, 2009, p. 89). Those who decide how much to invest in learning and development do so based on their anticipation of the value it will deliver: The greater the investment of time and money required, the higher the expectation. The higher the expectation, the more compelling the evidence of value created will need to be for the purchasers to feel they have gotten their money’s worth. Think about your own behavior: Your expectations of a $49 entrée are different than they are for a $9 one. You would hold the former to a much higher standard than the latter, would you not? The challenge for learning and development—as for anyone selling a product or service—is to promise enough to get the order, but not so much that it cannot be delivered. And the only way to find the right balance is to agree in advance on the expected business outcomes and definition of success.
Better Than Nothing As odd as it sounds, training programs have to be better than nothing. That’s because companies can choose to do nothing—not to invest, either because the cost of resolving the problem exceeds the expected benefit or because they have lost confidence in training’s ability to deliver meaningful business results. Learning and development organizations must demonstrate that they deliver substantially more value than no training at all. If they don’t, then “no training at all” will continue to be the option of choice in times of fiscal restraint (see Case in Point D1.8). So the final reason to always define business outcomes is to make it clear to management that investing in training and development is better than doing nothing.
CH001.indd 60
6/17/10 3:22:39 PM
Define Business Outcomes
61
Case in Point D1.8 No Evidence, No Funding When Nigel Paine took over as the director of training for the BBC, he discovered that the company was investing £1.5 million a year in executive education of one sort or another (Paine, 2003). But when he searched all the available records, he could find no evidence of a return on the investment. People who attended such programs did not necessarily advance more quickly, stay with the firm longer, or generate more business value. There seemed to be no rationale for why some employees were sent to training programs and others were not, no explicit expectations of what would be gained, no follow-through. Therefore, he placed a moratorium on all spending for executive education. Needless to say, there was a great hue and cry among providers, both internal and external. But when challenged, no one could present credible evidence that their solution provided more value than the alternative—doing nothing. One and a half million pounds is real money, even for an organization the size of the BBC. An investment of that magnitude will and should be scrutinized. Management has a fiduciary responsibility to be sure that an investment in learning and development is the best possible use of the money and that the resources could not be more profitably deployed elsewhere. This is a key point with respect to the first discipline of defining outcomes: Learning and development programs compete for resources not only with alternative educational providers and formats, but also with other departments and other uses for the money. Canceling a £1.5 million expenditure, for example, drops £1.5 million straight to the bottom line. Learning and development leaders need to show, credibly and compellingly, why shareholders are better served by investing money in learning and development rather than reporting it as profit and paying it out as dividends. In short, they need to show why training (which is expensive) is better than doing nothing (which, at least from a cost point-of-view, is free).
Summary The first, crucial, and frequently overlooked step in successful learning and development is to define the desired outcomes in business terms. Successful learning organizations prioritize the business needs that training can address and concentrate their resources on those that will have the greatest impact and probability of success. In collaboration with the key stakeholders, they define the rationale for the program in terms of the business outcomes to be delivered, not just the learning objectives to be achieved. They agree with the sponsors on the measures
CH001.indd 61
6/17/10 3:22:39 PM
62
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
of success before they design the complete program. This first critical discipline— defining business outcomes—is the keystone for the success of the entire training initiative. If program designers fail to clearly articulate the desired business outcomes, no amount of effort in subsequent stages can fully compensate; the future of the program, and perhaps the company itself, is put at risk. Use the checklist for D1 to ensure that training is the best solution and that the objectives for the training and development are stated as business outcomes. CHECKLIST FOR D1 ✓ ❑
Criterion The Overall Program
❑
The proposed training and development address a performance issue related to lack of knowledge or skill.
❑
Non-training solutions have been explored or tried and rejected.
❑
Environmental factors that will affect successful implementation (such as accountability, consequences, coaching, etc.) have been identified and discussed.
Each Program Objective ❑
Is clearly linked to a high-priority, high-value business need or opportunity.
❑
States the actual performance that will be achieved (as opposed to knowledge, ability, or capability).
❑
Specifies to what extent this performance standard will be met and by when.
❑
Uses business terms, concepts, and language.
❑
Clearly indicates how success could be measured.
Action Points For Learning Leaders • Never offer a program simply because you were asked to offer a program. • Always ask, “Why? What is the expected benefit to the company?” • This is vital: If you do not clearly understand the business need and the linkage between the training and filling the need, you cannot design an effective intervention. • Stand your ground when you believe training is the wrong solution. • Be a performance consultant; use the power of your expertise to help managers see there are better alternatives for achieving the desired result. • Read and understand the business plan. Be proactive in identifying areas in which learning and development could contribute. • Test your ideas with discerning line leaders. Make them your allies.
CH001.indd 62
6/17/10 3:22:40 PM
Define Business Outcomes
63
• Once you have decided to address an appropriate need with training, use the Outcomes Planning Wheel to help negotiate a clear “contract” with management that specifies in advance the objectives, methods, and how success will be determined. • Create co-ownership of results by helping managers understand that training will fail unless accompanied by concomitant changes in systems, managerial engagement, incentives, and so forth. • Review all the programs for which you are responsible to be sure each has objectives that are credibly linked to business imperatives. • Be proactive in managing the training portfolio. • Replace marginal programs with more strategic ones. • Propose to management realignment or even reduction of resources if appropriate. For Line Leaders • Review the key learning and development initiatives in the business unit for which you are responsible. • Are they clearly aligned with the most pressing needs of the business? • Are there critical needs that are not being addressed? • Are resources being spent on low-value programs that could be profitably redirected to higher-value initiatives? • If you conclude that the current learning and development initiatives are not aligned with the most important needs of your business, you and the learning leader share the responsibility for ensuring that they are. • Write down the business need that you would really like to see learning and development address and the results you want. • Then schedule a discussion with the head of learning and development. • Ask whether it is possible to address your needs with training. (Keep in mind that many performance issues in business are the result of systems or process problems that cannot be solved by training or that can be solved more quickly and less expensively in other ways. If the head of your learning organization is any good, he or she will tell you whether it is realistic to try to achieve the results you want through training.) • Work through the Outcomes Planning Wheel (Figure D1.6) with your learning and development partner. • Agree on the behavioral changes that are needed to achieve your objective and how they can be confirmed. • Ask learning and development to propose a plan for achieving these results. • Review it critically, using the 6Ds Scorecard (Exhibit I.1). • If appropriate, rebalance your learning and development portfolio to redirect resources to the initiatives with the greatest potential payoff.
CH001.indd 63
6/17/10 3:22:40 PM
CH001.indd 64
6/17/10 3:22:41 PM
DESIGN THE COMPLETE EXPERIENCE If you can’t describe what you are doing as a process, you don’t know what you’re doing. —W. EDWARDS DEMING
I
n a rapidly changing and highly competitive world, learning speed and learning agility are important sources of competitive advantage. In a special report sponsored by the ASTD, eLearning Guild, and Chief Learning Officer magazine, Clark and Gottfredson (2008) concluded: “The ultimate source of adaptive capacity, competitiveness, and self-preservation . . . [is] the ongoing ability of an organization to learn and apply its knowledge.” While learning encompasses much more than training and development, the accelerated and focused learning that organizations achieve through formal learning programs is a vital component of staying competitive. Given the strategic importance of learning and the magnitude of the annual investment in training and development, it is vital to maximize the value it generates and, thus, the return on that investment. Maximizing the output of training and development requires managing learning as a process rather than as an event. That means designing the complete learning experience, not just the instruction. In this chapter we examine what it means to manage the entire learning process holistically and systematically — to actively plan and infl uence what happens before as well as after the traditional boundaries of corporate education—and the benefits that accrue by doing so.
65
CH002.indd 65
6/18/10 3:44:21 PM
66
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Topics include: • • • • • •
Many factors influence outcomes A new paradigm The four phases of corporate learning Checking the process A checklist for D2 Action points for learning and line leaders
Many Factors Influence Outcomes Learning doesn’t happen in a vacuum. What each person takes away from a given learning experience is shaped by many things, including his or her expectations, attitude, prior knowledge and experiences, learning style, aptitude, and emotional state. Similarly, numerous factors influence the extent to which people subsequently transfer and apply their knowledge. These include opportunity, encouragement, reinforcement, and early successes or failures (Figure D2.1). Since the success of corporate learning and development programs (that is, the generation of meaningful business outcomes) requires both learning and learning transfer, the design of any such initiative must comprehend the entire process—not just what happens in the classroom, e-learning sessions, or simulation. Research has shown that what occurs before and after the formal period of instruction is as important, if not more important, than what happens during the course itself (Broad, 2005, pp. 82–93; Saks & Belcourt, 2006). FIGURE D2.1. MANY FACTORS INFLUENCE THE LEARNER’S EXPERIENCE, IMPACT LEARNING TRANSFER, AND AFFECT RESULTS Motivation Prior experience
Expected value
Learning Learning style
Personal relevance
Emotional state
CH002.indd 66
Support/ reinforcement Opportunity to use
Reminders
T R A N S F E R Early successes
RESULTS
Competing priorities
Recognition/ reward
6/18/10 3:44:23 PM
Design the Complete Experience
67
A New Paradigm We need, therefore, a new paradigm about the scope of the learning organization’s responsibility: one that goes beyond “delivery of programs” to “delivery of results,” beyond “instructional design” to “experiential design,” one that includes all of the factors that influence outcomes. The concept of paradigms (accepted “truths”) and their power to shape thinking was popularized by Thomas Kuhn in his classic The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962). While paradigms are essential for what Kuhn called “normal science” and efficient day-to-day problem solving, there comes a point at which prevailing paradigms no longer fit the facts, are counter-productive to progress, and need to be discarded. We believe we have reached that point in learning and development. The classroom and the computer screen are boxes, both literally and figuratively. As long as learning professionals and business managers confine their thinking to “inside the box,” they place artificial limits on both the potential and the ultimate return of learning programs. Writing in the Journal of Organizational Excellence, Teresa Roche, CLO of Agilent Technologies, explained: “At Agilent, every department is expected to innovate, learn continuously, and deliver bottom-line results. Global Learning and Leadership Development knew it could not fulfill these expectations simply by delivering traditional programs in traditional ways—no matter how high the end-of-course ratings. To reap the full benefits of corporate training investments, it needed to broaden its perspectives about when, where, and how learning occurs” (Roche, Wick, & Stewart, 2005, p. 46). Broad and Newstrom (1992) took an important first step in this direction when they introduced a transfer matrix that defined three periods—before, during, and after the training—and three learning partner roles—the manager, the trainer, and the trainee (Table D2.1). The matrix challenged learning organizations to think more broadly in terms of what influences learning transfer and when. It specifically called attention to the way in which learning transfer—and subsequently, results—are influenced by what happens before and after the program and by players other than workplace learning professionals. TABLE D2.1.
THE ROLE-TIME TRANSFER MATRIX Time
Role
Before
During
After
Manager Trainer Trainee
CH002.indd 67
6/18/10 3:44:24 PM
68
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Further research has shown that additional roles—for example, the learner’s work group—also influence outcomes (see D4). The support or lack of support from managers, peers, direct reports, executives, and others influences participants’ attitudes toward learning and its subsequent use, as does the overall climate and culture of the organization (Broad, 2005, pp. 29–30; Holton, Bates, & Ruona, 2000). The key point here is that the participant’s learning experience encompasses much more than what is included in traditional instructional design. Those who ignore these realities of learning in a corporate environment do so at their own peril; they put the success of the program in jeopardy. The International Society for Performance Improvement (ISPI) has, since its inception, emphasized the need to think holistically and systemically about human resources interventions. Its principles for human performance technology state: “Taking a systems view is vital because organizations are very complex systems that affect the performance of the individuals that work within them. . . . A systems approach considers the larger environment that impacts processes and other work” (ISPI, 2002). Isolated initiatives rarely solve business issues because business issues are inherently systemic in nature (Senge, 1990, p. 7).
A Four-Phase Process The process of turning learning into business results has four phases (Table D2.2). Broad and Newstrom (1992) labeled the first three “before,” “during,” and “after” training in their transfer matrix (Table D2.1). The problem with using “before,” “during,” and “after” is that it reinforces the event paradigm; it implies that “real” learning only takes place during the formal instruction period (during “the course”) and that what happens before is just “warm-up” and afterward merely a footnote. In actuality, all four phases are necessary for a program to be truly successful. More programs fail as a result of inadequate learning transfer (the third phase) than inadequate knowledge acquisition as such (see D4). Indeed, the most challenging aspect of converting training into results is getting the learning out of the instructional setting and onto the job, or—as we like to say—“the real work begins when the course ends.” To underscore the criticality of all four phases, many organizations are moving away from the “before, during, and after” terminology. For example, Pfizer refers to the three phases of its Advanced Transition Program as “on-ramp,” “ residential, ” and “ on - the - job application ” (Blee, Bonito, & Tucker, 2005, pp. 261–264). Standard Chartered Bank’s Leadership Essentials and Leading for Performance and Sony’s Integrated Leadership Curriculum have begun using the terms Phase I, Phase II, and Phase III, as have other writers (e.g., Zenger,
CH002.indd 68
6/18/10 3:44:25 PM
Design the Complete Experience
TABLE D2.2.
69
THE FOUR PHASES OF LEARNING
Phase I—Prepare Phase II—Learn Phase III—Transfer Phase IV—Achieve Descriptor Preparatory Reading and Other Assignments
Structured Learning/ Instruction/ Course
Learning Transfer and Application on the Job
Old term
Before
During
After
What’s included:
• Needs analysis • Participant selection • Course design • Evaluation plan • Invitation • Marketing • Meeting with manager • Background reading • Online exercises • Assessments
• Classroom, virtual, or online instruction • Discussions • Simulations • Exercises • Role play • Action learning
• Goal setting • Action planning • Follow-through • Debrief with manager • Teaching others • Deliberate practice • Reporting progress • Reflection • Collaboration
Stop, Assess, and Recognize Achievement
• Self-evaluation • Third-party assessment (manager, peers, direct reports, etc.) • Change in performance metrics • Improved work product • Recognition
Folkman, & Sherwin, 2005) to emphasize that these are simply stages of a continuum—an ongoing, coordinated learning process. Likewise, many learning organizations specifically eschew the term “prework” for the learning that needs to take place in Phase I. They argue that the very name “pre-work” suggests that it is not “real work,” that it is optional and unimportant. On the contrary, in optimally designed programs, completing the Phase I learning exercises is essential to participate fully and to extract maximum value from the rest of the program ( Jefferson, Pollock, & Wick, 2009), hence the concern for finding a less pejorative term than “pre-work” to describe the first phase of the learning-to-results process. In the first edition of The Six Disciplines, we defined three phases of learning. Our experience over the past five years has persuaded us that there are really four phases of the complete experience, with the final phase being a point at which to pause, assess, and recognize achievement (Table D2.2).
CH002.indd 69
6/18/10 3:44:26 PM
70
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
There are two key concepts to Phase IV: (1) that it represents a defined end point for a given cycle and (2) that it assesses and celebrates achievement. While assessment is typically thought of as separate activity, apart and distinct from the learning process, anyone who has ever prepared for a performance-based competition or taken a final examination in school knows how powerful such assessments are as a motivation to learn and to practice. You also know from your personal experience how much your learning was shaped by how the competition would be judged or by what was going to be included on the final examination. Including an assessment of what has been achieved as Phase IV of the complete learning process increases the probability of success because it focuses attention and energy on the outcomes of interest. “First, the fact that outcomes will be ‘inspected’ (evaluated, measured, monitored, or assessed) heightens the attention that all stakeholders—performers, managers, performance consultants, and others— give to carrying out their roles in the performance improvement intervention” (Broad, 2005, p. 115). Defining a specific time and method at which achievement will be assessed is a departure from current practice in most corporate learning. In sharp contrast to advanced degree and professional certification programs, an assessment is rarely a feature of corporate education. Peter Gilson, former chairman of Swiss Army Brands, Inc., described typical practice: “As a young corporate executive, I attended dozens of development programs, but no one ever once followed up with me to see what I The most information ever had done with what I learned. The most informacollected was how I rated the tion ever collected was how I rated the instructor” instructor. (personal communication, 2006). In the absence of clear expectations and the knowledge that achievement will be recognized, it’s small wonder that a great deal of corporate training is never applied. Participants should never be left in doubt about how they and the program will be assessed. Ken Blanchard related the story of how, when he was a young assistant professor, he used to give the students a copy of the final examination on the first day of class. Other faculty objected, but Ken persisted, arguing that since the final examination represented what he felt was most important for students to take away from his course, then it only made sense to let them know that from the beginning and energize and focus their learning accordingly. The other reason to include this fourth phase as part of the learning process is that assessment itself is a learning exercise. Assessments reinforce learning by requiring participants to retrieve and process information some time after the original learning occurred. A well-designed assessment provides vital feedback to learners on what they have achieved as well as what they still need
CH002.indd 70
6/18/10 3:44:27 PM
Design the Complete Experience
71
to work on. Just an honest self-assessment of achievement can be a valuable learning exercise. After much debate, we decided to describe the fourth phase as the “endpoint” of a given cycle. We do not want to imply that learning should ever stop, or that the quest for performance improvement should ever end. But we were persuaded that the benefits of putting a “stake in the ground”—of declaring a specific goal line for each learning program that everyone can strive for— outweighed any downside. Everyone in business understands that annual goals do not mean the business closes down at the end of the fiscal year; the cycle starts again immediately, as it should with learning. But anyone who has been around toward the end of a fiscal cycle knows how having specific targets and a timeline motivates action. The drive to achieve a goal—even when there is no monetary reward involved (completing a marathon, for example)—is a powerful intrinsic motivator for most people (Pink, 2009). Failing to define an end point for a learning cycle denies people the satisfaction of reaching a milestone and the benefits of stopping to reflect on what they have achieved. For these reasons, we believe that defining an end point at which participants’ achievements will be assessed, recognized, and celebrated should be part of the design of the complete learning experience (see Figure D2.2). FIGURE D2.2. THE FOUR PHASES OF LEARNING NECESSARY TO IMPROVE PERFORMANCE
Effectiveness
New (and Higher) Level of Performance Achieve Transfer Learn Current Level of Performance Prepare
Before
CH002.indd 71
After
6/18/10 3:44:27 PM
72
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
In the subsequent discussion, we use the neutral terms Phase I, Phase II, Phase III, and Phase IV. Although these are not very catchy or memorable monikers, they have the advantage of being broadly applicable to a wide range of program types, delivery formats, and objectives. We will append descriptors like “prepare, learn, apply, and achieve” as necessary to provide clarity and links to earlier works. For each phase, we examine the evidence of its importance and provide suggestions for strengthening it as part of D2—designing the complete experience.
Phase I: Prepare What participants take away from a learning and development program, what they transfer to their work, and the results they are ultimately able to achieve are all strongly influenced by what happens during Phase I, long before formal instruction—the traditional bastion of training—begins. This is true even for programs that have no specific Phase I assignments. Participants’ prior education and experience form the foundation on which to build new capabilities (National Research Council, 2000); their expectations of the program—and their managers’ expectations of them—influence their receptivity to new ideas and approaches.
Expectations Influence Outcomes Participants do not arrive at corporate educational programs like blank sheets of paper. They come with opinions, biases, and expectations. They may have read about the program online or in a course catalog; they may have heard about it from colleagues. These early exposures begin to shape their opinions about the program’s probable value and therefore their willingness to devote time and energy to it. Their assumptions about its value are also strongly influenced by their managers’ level of interest or indifference and by their experience with training programs in the past. Such preconceptions affect the outcomes in surprisingly powerful ways. A classic experiment done at MIT illustrates just how powerful, and how easily swayed, this effect is (Kelley, 1950). Students were asked to rate a discussion led by a substitute instructor. Each student was given a brief biography of the instructor prior to class. Unbeknown to the students, there were two different versions of the sixty-three-word biography, identical except for two words: one described the instructor as “very warm,” the other as “rather cold.”
CH002.indd 72
6/18/10 3:44:28 PM
Design the Complete Experience
73
At the end of the class, the students were all given the same questionnaire and asked to evaluate the session. As Ori and Rom Brafman write in Sway (2008), “Upon seeing the results, you’d think the students were responding to two completely different instructors. Most students in the group that had received the bio describing the substitute as ‘warm’ loved him. . . . Although the second group sat in exactly the same class and participated in the exact same discussion, a majority of them didn’t really take to the instructor” (p. 73). If just two words can sway the experience of learning that much, it is clear that participants’ preconception of the expected value of a corporate learning program—prior to any actual experience of the course itself—will strongly influence their experience in the program and their post-program opinion of its value. Tharenou (2001) showed that expectations—especially regarding the practical utility of the program—strongly influence an employee’s decision to participate in voluntary training. It follows that participants’ going-in expectations also impact their willingness to fully engage in learning exercises like simulations, role plays, online learning, and discussions. You know this from your own experience. Your Expectations strongly willingness to go to a movie, try a new resinfluence an employee’s taurant, or attend a conference is strongly decision to participate. influenced by what you have read or heard about it from colleagues and friends. Taken together, the research suggests that learning organizations will benefit by devoting more effort and attention to creating positive “going-in” expectations among participants because, to a surprising degree, such opinions become selffulfilling prophesies. To a great extent, participants get out of a program pretty much what they presume they will. If they expect it to be a high-value, worthwhile learning experience, then that is usually what they experience. If they expect it to be a waste of time, it almost always is, at least for them. As the MIT study illustrates, two participants who participate in the same program but with different expectations will have different experiences and leave with different perceptions of the value they received (Figure D2.3). This phenomenon is so strong that learning and development planners ignore it at their peril. That is not to say that a great course cannot convert the skeptics, or that a truly awful program will not disillusion even “true believers.” But it is much easier to achieve the desired business outcomes when participants enter programs motivated to learn because they expect the content will help them with their jobs and because they know they will be held accountable for producing results. Thus, part of the Second Discipline involves managing the expectations created in Phase I—well ahead of what has traditionally been considered the start of a training program.
CH002.indd 73
6/18/10 3:44:29 PM
74
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D2.3. EXPECTATIONS INFLUENCE HOW DIFFERENT PARTICIPANTS BENEFIT FROM THE SAME PROGRAM
INPUT
OUTPUT
Learner 1:
Learner 1:
High expectations; strong manager support
“Great program, real impact. I use something I learned everyday.”
Learner 2: Low expectations; manager indifferent
SAME PROGRAM
Learner 2: “Waste of time, impractical, don’t expect to use.”
Phase I learning also includes background reading, online exercises, assessments, and other assignments that help accelerate and enrich the learning that takes place in Phase II, the formal or structured learning experience. Strengthening Phase I Because what happens in Phase I impacts the ultimate value created by learning and development, strengthening Phase I is an important aspect of an overall improvement effort. Three actions are key: raising expectations, engaging managers, and accelerating learning by getting together the right people with the right background knowledge at the right time in their careers.
CH002.indd 74
6/18/10 3:44:29 PM
Design the Complete Experience
75
Raise Expectations Whether participants perceive training as something essential for their success, as a reward, as a punishment, as a mini-vacation, or as a waste of time influences how seriously they approach it and therefore the likelihood of its success. Learning organizations can enhance expectations by applying marketing principles. Marketing departments spend a great deal of their time and money managing their product’s positioning and brand promise—what customers think of when they hear the product’s name and what they expect when they purchase it. Strong brands like Coca-Cola, Crest, Lexus, and iPhone have strong positions. Their key benefits come immediately to mind and shape perceptions of value, price, and alternatives. A brand’s reputation positively or negatively influences buying decisions and customer satisfaction. So does training’s brand. Effective marketing organizations know what their target customers value and use all the communication channels at their disposal to associate their brands with what customers desire most. The goal is to create a positive association between the brand and something that the customer desires, and then to embed that association deep in customers’ psyches. Developing a strong “brand” for training—one that is perceived as integral to the business and essential to one’s career—will enhance the ability of the learning organization to contribute to the business (see also D6: Sell the Sizzle). But what do employees desire from training? The principles of adult education, as well as studies of why employees attend training, indicate that adults are motivated to learn things that they believe will be of practical benefit in their lives and careers. Yet most course descriptions emphasize the features of the program—how long it is, what will be covered, the learning objectives, and instructional method—but rarely the benefits—how it will help the participant and the organization. Thus, defining business outcomes (D1) not only informs program design, but also helps communicate (raise expectations of) the value of attending. There is a big difference in perceived value between a program advertised as one in which “you will learn effective time management techniques” (a feature statement) and the same program billed as one that will “enable you to get more done in less time, with less stress, leaving more time for the things you enjoy” (a benefit statement). We once, only half in jest, suggested renaming a confined space safety course as “how to get home to your loved ones alive.” The point is that people buy expected benefits; they do not buy features. “Too many people state the features of their offering and expect the buyer to join People buy expected benefits; the dots and understand the value or benthey do not buy features. efit” (Dugdale & Lambert, 2007, p. 163).
CH002.indd 75
6/18/10 3:44:30 PM
76
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
To get buy-in and garner support for learning programs, you need to be explicit about the “why”—the benefits that will accrue to the participants. The power of making the business benefit explicit was demonstrated in a workshop we did in Asia for one of the Fortune 10 companies. Following the workshop, one of the participants re-wrote all of the course descriptions in her division to emphasize the business and personal benefits (outcomes) rather than just the features. As a result, interest in the programs from potential participants and support for attendance from their managers increased noticeably, even though the programs themselves had not changed at all—only the way in which they were positioned and described. Improve the Invitation Another good opportunity to positively influence the par-
ticipants’ expectations is through the invitation process. Many invitations to attend corporate training and development programs read more like a jury summons than an opportunity to participate in something of value. One client we worked with (who shall remain nameless) ran a top-quality, intensive development workshop for its highest-potential employees. Candidates for this highly selective program were invited only after a rigorous vetting process. Nevertheless, something went badly amiss in the invitation process. Not only did the participants have no idea what an honor it was to be invited, but some actually thought they were there for remediation! Review the way in which people are invited (or directed) to attend programs in your organization. Are the benefits to the participants clear? Does the invitation come from a person in authority they know and respect? Does it raise their expectations that they will gain something of value by attending and, at the same time, does it communicate the high expectations the company has of them? Or does it appear to be just another impersonal email from some faceless bureaucracy? Consider more enticing ways of communicating the invitation, especially for strategically vital programs. Some companies use a personal invitation from a senior leader. At McKesson, for example, the executive vice president of human resources personally calls each participant in the Leaders Teaching Leaders Program to confirm his or her commitment and participation (Boston, Allred, & Cappy, 2009). Others are even more creative: UBS Bank repurposed a marketing video, redubbing it to create a high-energy invitation to a key leadership program. The invitation to attend is one of your early opportunities to “sell” participants on the benefits; it is an important element of Phase I that helps set the tone for the learner’s complete experience. If you don’t want your program to be viewed as just another boring task, don’t promote it that way. Secure Management Support Visible support from management greatly
increases the probability of success. It’s especially important in Phase I because employees at all levels are pressed for time. Overwhelmed by competing priorities,
CH002.indd 76
6/18/10 3:44:31 PM
Design the Complete Experience
77
they look to their managers for indications of what is most important and then apportion their efforts accordingly. If they perceive that a program has strong managerial support, it will receive more effort and attention. If their managers appear indifferent or skeptical about the value of the training, then participants will give it the minimum possible amount of time and effort. Participants’ direct supervisors, in particular, have a profound effect on whether or not training produces results. That effect exerts itself before instruction ever begins (discussed in Exhibit D2.1 below). This should come as no real surprise, given the overall impact that a person’s direct supervisor has on his or her work priorities, experience, and job satisfaction. Kouzes and Posner (2007) said it well: If you’re a manager in an organization, to your direct reports you are the most important leader in your organization. You are more likely than any other leader to influence their desire to stay or leave, the trajectory of their careers, their ethical behavior, their ability to perform at their best, their drive to wow customers, their satisfaction with their jobs, and their motivation to share the company’s vision and values (p. 338, emphasis in the original).
Exhibit D2.1 Managers and Phase I of Learning When polled about which time-role combination had the greatest impact on learning transfer, trainers themselves agreed that the manager’s involvement in Phase I—prior to the formal coursework—was the single most powerful influence on whether the training ultimately would be transferred and applied (Broad & Newstrom, 1992, p. 54). This perception has been confirmed by many others. For example, Brinkerhoff and Montesino (1995) found that participants who had discussions with their managers before and after training reported significantly higher levels of skill application and felt more accountable for applying new learning. Feldstein and Boothman (1997) compared high- and low-performance learners and identified eight factors that characterized high-performance learners. Half of these factors were related to the influence of the manager. For example, 75 percent of the high-performance learners reported that their supervisors had expectations of improved performance following training, whereas only 25 percent of low performers did. In a follow-up study, a system was implemented to increase the pre- and post-course interaction with managers. The result was that both the learners and their managers reported much higher rates of transfer. At American Express, “high improvement” learners were four times more likely to have had a one-on-one conversation with their managers than the “no improvement” group (American Express, 2007). The bottom line is that managers directly impact the outcome of training—and that that influence begins in Phase I.
CH002.indd 77
6/18/10 3:44:31 PM
78
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
They did not say it, but they could have easily added, “and their expectations with respect to training and development.” If a person’s manager shows no interest in his or her development, or worse, clearly begrudges the time that he or she will spend in a program, that telegraphs a strong message that jades the participant’s opinion and reduces his or her willingness to participate before the program even begins. Therefore, ensuring that participants know, feel, and believe in management’s support starting in Phase I is vital to maximizing the return on educational investments. Credible support is easier to recruit and sustain if the First Discipline—defining the expected business outcomes—is followed. Line managers are more willing to have their people attend training programs, and are more supportive of learning transfer, when they perceive a strong alignment between the needs of the business and the training curriculum. Bersin (2008b) found that alignment and management support were the two key factors that determined organizational impact (p. 82). As such, he encouraged learning organizations to assess the degree of alignment of both individual programs and the learning function as a whole with the needs of the business. Louis Carter, founder and president of the Best Practice Institute, conducted a study of organizations that achieved sustainable results from leadership development. Support and participation of senior management was the highest-ranking success factor (Carter, Ulrich, & Goldsmith, 2005, p. 421). Critical senior leadership behaviors for success included: • • • •
Allocating funds for the initiative Modeling behavior consistent with strategy Integrating the initiative into the strategic plan Facilitating education or training (p. 444)
Support needs to go beyond mere words. If a learning and development program is to be effective in bringing about organizational change, then the most senior and most visible leadership must model its precepts. Senior managers need to complete the program themselves, embrace its principles, use the recommended approaches to management, and incorporate concepts from the program in their day-to-day activities. If they do not, they seriously undermine the program’s impact and credibility (see Case in Point D2.1). Participants are very adept at sensing whether or not programs have the wholehearted support from the leaders in the organization. The karmic seeds of success or failure are planted before the program is even launched by the extent to which it enjoys management support that goes beyond mere rhetoric; managers of attendees must be prepared to support the program by their actions. And one of the most effective actions they can take is to have a short, focused, structured
CH002.indd 78
6/18/10 3:44:32 PM
Design the Complete Experience
79
Case in Point D2.1 When the Video Doesn’t Match the Audio A biotechnology firm we worked with had sustained dramatic growth for a number of years. Managers had been rapidly promoted as the business grew, but with very little formal management training and, because of the pace of growth, limited on-the-job experience and mentoring. As a result, most middle managers led by the seat of their pants, mimicking the entrepreneurial style of the founder. Then the company encountered market turbulence and missed its forecast significantly. Its stock dropped precipitously and the senior leadership realized that the lack of professional management was a serious impediment to continued prosperity. So they had human resources design and implement a five-day program to help managers increase the effectiveness of teamwork, foster innovation, improve efficiency, and create ownership for results through delegation. The senior management team strongly endorsed the program and made stirring speeches about its importance for the future of the company. When it came time to attend, however, they were “too busy” to attend the full program. They asked organizational development to put together a special half-day “executive edition” that included neither preparatory work nor follow-through. The result was predictable. The senior managers never mastered the material. They therefore failed to incorporate the processes or terminology into their own leadership. So, for example, while middle managers were exhorted to expand creative thinking by conducting brainstorming sessions in a particular way, their own managers failed to do so. In fact, many actions by the company’s senior leaders were directly contrary to the program’s concepts and principles. Needless to say, the program failed to create the hoped-for change or generate a return on investment. Indeed, the “do as I say, not as I do” attitude of the senior leaders not only undermined the program’s effectiveness, but it generated cynicism among middle managers about both the senior leadership and the value of training and development.
discussion with their direct reports in Phase I, in advance of the formal instruction (Jefferson, Pollock, & Wick, 2009). If senior managers are unwilling to make the commitment to provide this level of support, the whole premise of the program needs to be reexamined. The learning leadership must question whether they have truly defined their company’s most pressing needs and developed a program that addresses them. Launching a program in the absence of strong management supLeave no doubt in port undermines its probability of success participants’ minds about and potentially damages the reputation of what is expected. the learning organization as a whole.
CH002.indd 79
6/18/10 3:44:32 PM
80
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Redefine the Finish Line An important objective of Phase I should be to leave no doubt in participants’ minds about what is expected of them. They should come to the course with the clear understanding that the privilege of attending an educational program carries with it the responsibility to apply it to improve their performance (Figure D2.4). Follow-through on training and development should be part of what Bossidy and Charan (2002) call a “culture of execution,” because “Without execution, the breakthrough thinking breaks down, learning adds no value, people don’t meet their stretch goals, and the revolution stops dead in its tracks” (p. 19, emphasis added). A quantum jump in performance would result if everyone who attended a training program knew that he or she would be expected to execute against the learning transfer goals and achieve results, just as he or she would against other business objectives. When employees are afforded an opportunity to learn, expectations regarding their subsequent performance go up (Jefferson, Pollock, & Wick, 2009). If their performance remains unchanged while expectations rise, their performance rating relative to expectations will actually decline (Figure D2.5). And yet learning organizations continue to inadvertently reinforce the mistaken notion that attendance is sufficient and that when the instruction ends, the participant’s work is done. In fact, the real work of turning learning into results is just beginning.
FIGURE D2.4. THE OPPORTUNITY TO ATTEND TRAINING RAISES EXPECTATIONS FOR IMPROVED PERFORMANCE
© Charles Barsotti/Condé Nast Publications/www.cartoonbank.com. Used with permission.
CH002.indd 80
6/18/10 3:44:33 PM
Design the Complete Experience
81
FIGURE D2.5. EXPECTATIONS GO UP AFTER A TRAINING PROGRAM. IF PERFORMANCE REMAINS THE SAME, THEN PERFORMANCE RELATIVE TO EXPECTATIONS DECLINES
Performance Relative to Expectations
Negative variance
Before Training
Performance
Expectations
Performance
Expectations
Positive variance
After Training
After Jefferson, Pollock, and Wick, 2009. Used with permission.
The problem starts with the agenda, which, for the vast majority of learning programs—whether classroom, virtual, or online—includes only Phase II. A more accurate representation of the process would be a timeline that includes all four phases of the complete experience (Figure D2.6). Indeed, we have taken the position that: “We should never again speak of a three-day, one-week, or even three-week agenda. Every program should be at least three months long” because for most kinds of corporate training, it takes at least that long to establish new habits and produce results (Wick, Pollock, & Jefferson, 2008). The paradigm that “the course is the thing” is further reinforced by the last agenda item for most programs. It typically says something like “program ends,” giving the misleading impression that participants have completed their
CH002.indd 81
6/18/10 3:44:34 PM
82
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D2.6. A PROGRAM TIMELINE THAT RESETS EXPECTATIONS BY SHOWING THE COMPLETE LEARNING EXPERIENCE
Begin 1
2
3
Weeks 4
5
6
7
8
End 9
10
11
12
13
Meet with manager Complete preparatory work Participate in course Follow up with feedback providers, coach, manager
Transfer and apply learning to work Assessment of results Plan continued improvement
responsibilities simply by “showing up.” That notion is driven home by the habit of handing out certificates and mementoes and awarding credit at the end of the class or the e-learning program. Recognizing how counterproductive this practice is—since at the end of instruction the organization has sustained the cost but not received any benefit— more enlightened organizations have begun moving the finish line from the last day of class to the documentation of results (see Case in Point D2.2). The real work of turning learning into results begins when the formal instruction ends. In subsequent chapters we discuss specific ways to facilitate learning transfer and application (Phase III). These approaches are more effective when the expectation for putting learning to work has been clearly established from the onset, in Phase I. It is essential, therefore, to reset participants’ expectations so that “successful course completion” is understood to mean achieving sustained performance improvement, not just reaching the end of instruction. Get the Right People into the Room A key difference between teaching adults and teaching children is that adult learners bring much richer and more varied experiences to their education. These experiences are a powerful framework on which to build and a source of practical examples and real-world knowledge.
CH002.indd 82
6/18/10 3:44:34 PM
Design the Complete Experience
83
Case in Point D2.2 Resetting the Finish Line Home Depot conducted a series of large-scale learning events to help its store managers run more efficient and effective operations. At the end of the three-day forum, participants were presented with a very handsome crystal trophy. The president of Home Depot Canada, Annette Verschuren, realized that doing so sent entirely the wrong message. The award should not be for attendance, but for implementing ideas or practices that actually improved store operations. So, in her unit at least, store managers received their trophies only when they could document at least one action they had taken as a result of attending the Store Managers’ Forum that demonstrably improved their store’s performance—a nice example of redefining what it means to complete a course from the end of instruction to actual implementation and results. Another fine example comes from Bill Amaxopoulos, leadership program manager for the Chubb Group of Insurance Companies. Bill has moved to a phased approach in which attendees and their managers must attend pre-course webcasts together and commit to follow-through activities. Then, on a three-month post-course webcast, each participant summarizes his or her goals from the program and subsequent accomplishments. They receive credit for completing the course only after they participate in the follow-up assessment call.
Thus, helping participants build on their experiences and share “lessons learned” are important precepts of adult education. The very richness and variety of experience represented in any given class, however, presents a significant challenge for corporate learning professionals. In high school or even college, educators can assume a much more homogenous set of experiences and educational backgrounds. In corporate education, however, groups frequently include learners who differ widely in age, years’ experience, educational background, work histories, and, in an increasingly global marketplace, even mother tongue. Although this diversity offers fertile ground for discussion and insight, it also increases the difficulty of delivering an effective learning experience for each participant. Designing the complete learning experience, then, includes defining the background that participants need to have to benefit from the program, as well as the learning experiences they need in Phase I to establish a common foundation. In academic universities, upper-level courses have clearly established prerequisites for enrollment, such as, “Students must have successfully completed Calculus 101.” This is much less frequent in corporate universities and executive education programs—perhaps for fear of limiting enrollment. The downside of
CH002.indd 83
6/18/10 3:44:35 PM
84
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
having no prerequisites, however, is that the program must necessarily be taught at the “one-size-fits-all” level, with the result that it may fit no one perfectly—too elementary for some and too advanced for others. Recognizing this dilemma, a number of companies are moving toward courses offered in a coordinated sequence. This approach allows their learning organizations to offer introductory courses to those new to a role or function, as well as advanced programs that explore topics in greater depth. One company uses a pyramid icon in its course catalog to illustrate where each course fits in the sequence from basic to expert. Pfizer’s Learning Center structured its leadership development programs into series of courses called Leading Edge for first-time managers, followed by the Advanced Transition Program when they are promoted to a leader of leaders (Kontra, Trainor, & Wick, 2007). Unilever developed a five-part leadership series, and Sony’s four-level Integrated Leadership Curriculum was modeled after The Leadership Pipeline (Charan, Drotter, & Noel, 2001). Such approaches are consistent with Deloitte’s strategic conclusions about corporate learning (see Case in Point D2.3). Dividing learning and development into sequential programs with prerequisites allows corporate educators to better meet the needs of their learners and to take advanced programs to higher levels of excellence. Prerequisites to advanced programs might include not only other courses but also specific work experiences, such as having led a project team or managed those who manage others. The shift toward holding learning organizations accountable for outcomes, rather than just activity, should encourage us to define and set prerequisites more often, since allowing the wrong people to attend a program dilutes its effectiveness and reduces the value it generates. Get Everyone on the Same Page Learning is also strengthened when Phase
I includes specific assignments or experiences that help bring everyone to a common level of understanding and background. In our opinion, every program should have some required preparation, be it reading, e-learning, simulations, assessments, teleconferences, or other learning experiences. Chris Jenkins, learning and development manager for U.S. Bank Wealth Management Group, concurs. He feels so strongly about the importance of preparation and follow-through that he thinks programs that don’t include them shouldn’t be given at all. Preparation allows instructors to go further and faster. It makes discussions and group exercises richer and more meaningful. But the amount of preparatory work assigned must be weighed against the time available. If there are too many assignments to complete, or more reading than can reasonably be done by managers who already have more than full-time jobs, the value of the preparation will be diminished.
CH002.indd 84
6/18/10 3:44:35 PM
Design the Complete Experience
85
Case in Point D2.3 The Deloitte U.S. Firms’ Six Strategic Conclusions Over 40,000 professionals of Deloitte LLP and its subsidiaries (Deloitte U.S. Firms) provide audit, consulting, financial advisory, risk management, and tax services to selected clients. Needless to say, continuous learning and development are essential for the organization’s professionals to remain current and provide the high-quality service and advice for which Deloitte is famous. To assist the Deloitte U.S. Firms’ talent development organization in helping its people stay always one step ahead, the organization applied its rigorous strategic planning process to its own learning agenda. The process generated Six Strategic Conclusions that are being used to guide the Deloitte U.S. Firms’ learning and development efforts: 1. Outside-In (External focus) Learning and development are designed to anticipate and deliver the key capabilities valued now and in the future by external constituencies including clients, regulatory bodies, and the talent market. Business objectives inform talent development; business leaders are actively engaged in setting the agenda. 2. Customized Learning solutions are customized to individual learners’ needs and career aspirations. Programs are tailored for different levels of proficiency as well as industry, sector, professional level, and job role. 3. Leading-Edge Learning design and delivery incorporate the latest research, technology, and innovation. The focus is “action learning” rather than “passive listening.” Learning continues beyond the classroom and is sustained with performance support tools. 4. Integrated Learning programs provide connection points and networking opportunities. Assignments and talent deployment take into account individual development needs and career interests. Business leaders, managers, and counselors drive follow-through on learning programs. 5. Outcome-Driven Desired outcomes and measurement plans are documented before program design begins and include knowledge and skills acquisition, learning transfer and application, and business impact. Client satisfaction with capabilities and industry evaluations of effectiveness are the ultimate measures of learning’s success. 6. Synchronized All the “moving parts” support, rather than conflict with, one another. Communication and collaboration among businesses, service lines, industry groups, and talent development ensure consistency and avoid duplication of effort.
CH002.indd 85
6/18/10 3:44:36 PM
86
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
The time pressures that discourage participants from doing Phase I preparation must be counterbalanced by incentives for completing it and by persuasion regarding its value. For example, if participants are expected to complete reading or other assignments in Phase I, it is incumbent upon the instructors to make explicit use of them in Phase II—ideally in such a way that those who did not do the assignments wish they had. If Phase II is structured in such a way that completing the preparatory work makes the program much more valuable (or if the lack of preparation becomes embarrassingly obvious), the whole organization soon learns this. Subsequent groups will be better prepared, having heard the word to be sure to do the homework. This is not unlike the reputation that specific courses and professors acquire in college. (“She is a great professor, but you’ll be sorry if you go to class without doing the reading!”) Preparing learners to maximize course time in Phase II should not be confined simply to reading assignments. The range of learning opportunities is far richer. Think beyond traditional reading assignments to more experiential learning. For example, have participants interview customers and record their perceptions, spend time in manufacturing or in customer service, interview leaders of other divisions about successes or failures, visit a competitor’s store, or work with the competitor’s products. Take advantage of technology and have participants work through an online simulation, assessment, or other e-learning module. Look for experiences that stimulate their curiosity and imagination or shake them out of their current comfort zones. One organization we worked with challenged its marketing managers to spend two hours on the phone as a customer service representative trying to explain incentive programs. It was a real eye-opener: they came away with a whole new perspective and a commitment to design programs that were easier to convey. There are so many potentially interesting and innovative Phase I learning opportunities that the challenge is not to get carried away. A leadership transition program at one company had eight different Phase I assignments that included reading a whole book, completing several online assignments, and conducting a halfdozen interviews. Needless to say, when surveyed, very few participants indicated that they had done all of the assignments. Phase I learning plans need to respect the time pressures of today’s business environment; every minute spent needs to add value. Do not, for example, ask people to read an entire business book. Few have the time, and the perceived magnitude of the task alone will deter some from starting. Identify the key sections that will be discussed and assign these only. Phase I work, no matter how relevant and well-focused, produces no learning unless it is done. Therefore, designing the complete experience includes designing incentives to help ensure that preparation is completed and its importance is appreciated. Here again managerial support is vital. The managers of participants need to be aware of what preparation is expected and buy into its importance.
CH002.indd 86
6/18/10 3:44:36 PM
Design the Complete Experience
87
Ideally, they ought to meet with their direct reports before they attend to discuss the preparatory exercises, goals for attending the program, and expectations for outcomes. As a step in this direction, many companies now require the manager to approve attendance at educational programs. Some, like Ingersoll Rand, go further and encourage the participant and manager to sign a learning “covenant” in which both agree, in advance, on the key learning objectives and how progress will be assessed. This is analogous to performance management (management by objectives) for business goals. In the learning covenant, the manager also makes a commitment: to provide ongoing advice and support as needed to achieve the agreed-on goals. Where such contracts are taken seriously, the results of the program are enhanced. We know of at least one company that feels so strongly about the importance of a Phase I discussion between managers and participants that if participants arrive at a key program without a learning contract co-signed by their manager, they are put on a plane and sent home. Needless to say, they only had to do that once. Diane Hinton and Mary Singos of Plastipak Academy have customized a complete process and tools for supervisor involvement that begins in Phase I. Called “High-Impact Learning and You” it includes an overview, exercises, and job aids for both participants and supervisors to help them understand their roles and derive greater value from training investments. Supervisors are expected to take four key actions: 1. Create a line of sight on the impact map linking skills to business goals for their team and the specific associate who will attend the training. 2. Prepare the associate by hand-delivering the training packet and meeting to discuss the marked-up impact map and the learner-prepared “My Roadmap to Results” to agree on learning targets for driving key results. 3. Hold a fifteen-minute, post-training meeting to plan actions for moving from learning to results. 4. Support new skill application on the job through ongoing coaching and feedback. There is also a role for technology in Phase I. Many 360 - degree feedback and other assessment instruments are available online. Pfizer, for example, has participants in its Advanced Transition program complete a unique online leadership assessment survey to establish a baseline for transition performance (Blee, Bonito, & Tucker, 2005, p. 261). Standard Chartered Bank uses an online learning transfer management system (Friday5s) to help ensure completion of Phase I learning in its leadership programs. The system provides automated reminders about the preparatory assignments far enough in advance
CH002.indd 87
6/18/10 3:44:36 PM
88
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
to facilitate their completion. Reminders have proven especially useful for assignments that cannot be done at the last minute, such as having participants define learning objectives jointly with their managers, interview a senior leader, or listen to customer service calls. In programs without such reminders, some participants inevitably postpone their preparation until the last minute—about as productive as trying to read War and Peace the night before the final in a Russian literature class. In courses that use online Phase I support systems, participants are asked to record the insights from their preparation in a shared learning space. Instructors are able to access the database to review the results and select relevant examples for use in Phase II of the program. The shared visibility (the author of each entry is identified) provides clear accountability; everyone involved with the program can see who did, and who did not, complete the required preparation. The social networking aspect of this shared preparation helps build a sense of collegiality prior to the program. It also provides instructors with group-specific examples they can use to add relevance and credibility to the content.
Phase II: Learn We discuss Phase II (“the course” or structured learning period) in more detail in the next chapter (D3: Deliver for Application). In terms of planning the complete experience, the critical issues are to: • Ensure congruence between the learning experiences in Phase II and the ultimate business outcomes sought. • Build on and reinforce the preparatory work of Phase I. • Use instructional approaches that are appropriate to the required behaviors and skills. • Honor principles of adult learning. • Prepare managers and others essential to support learning transfer so that they fulfill their roles. • Ensure that participants are prepared and able to apply what they have learned. • Make the transition between Phase II and Phase III strong and seamless. When these conditions are met, it is possible to construct a value chain that links each learning topic and exercise through the intermediary steps to the ultimate business objective of the training (Table D2.3). Brinkerhoff and Gill (1994) originated the concept of developing such impact maps; they have proven to be an invaluable tool for delivering high impact learning (Brinkerhoff & Apking, 2001).
CH002.indd 88
6/18/10 3:44:37 PM
Design the Complete Experience
89
TABLE D2.3. EXAMPLE OF A VALUE CHAIN SHOWING THE LINKS BETWEEN A PHASE II EXERCISE AND THE DESIRED BUSINESS OUTCOMES Learning Experience • Multi-round, multi-player simulation of market dynamics in response to changes in pricing • Debrief of results and why they occurred • Repeat of simulation to see if lessons were learned
Ultimate Business Purpose
Capabilities Created or Enhanced
On-the-Job Behaviors
Leading Indicators
• Ability to project price-volume ratios and impact on profitability • Ability to anticipate competitors’ reactions and think through subsequent impact • Understanding of how pricing affects market value
• Fully analyze impact of price reductions on profitability in both short and long term • Anticipate competitors’ likely reactions • Think two or three moves ahead instead of one
• Improved • Improved profitability pricing decisions • More strategic use of pricing • Better balancing of price and volume • Higher gross margins
Strengthening Phase II The key opportunities to strengthen Phase II learning are to enhance the linkage between the instruction and the business goals and to ensure that the methods of instruction are congruent with the performance ultimately desired. One way to construct an explicit chain of inference is to ask a series of if–then statements beginning with the end in mind and working back to the kind of learning exercises needed. That is: • If this is the ultimate business outcome we are trying to achieve, then what do employees need to do to achieve it? • If they are supposed to do these things, then what knowledge, skills, and abilities must they have? • If they are to become proficient in a required skill, then what sort of learning experiences and practice do they need?
CH002.indd 89
6/18/10 3:44:37 PM
90
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
• Finally, if these are the kinds of learning experiences required, then which are best accomplished in Phase I, which in Phase II, and which in Phase III? This approach to selection of course content and instructional method has a number of advantages. It ensures that the ultimate business objective is the criterion for weighing what to include and what to leave out. It helps ensure alignment between exercises and the desired behaviors and ways of thinking. In other words, if the goal is to improve strategic planning and if strategic analysis is identified as a requisite skill, then merely listening passively to lectures on planning is incongruous with the objective. To become proficient at analysis, participants need to have the opportunity to practice their analytical skills with expert guidance and feedback. Adults are motivated to learn when the relevance is clear. Moreover, when learning and development programs are designed this way—with business outcomes always as the end in view—it is much easier for participants to see their relevance. The latter is important. As we shall expound on in the discussion of D3, adults are more motivated to learn and do so more effectively when the relevance of what they are learning is clear (Knowles, Holton, & Swanson, 2005). To improve training’s effectiveness, make the rationale for each learning exercise readily apparent. It should be possible to explain the decision for including each topic or exercise to learners, managers, sponsors, and other stakeholders in a short series of “so that” statements: “Your success and the company’s depend on making sound strategic pricing decisions. We included a business simulation so that you would have the opportunity to practice analyzing strategic alternatives, see the results of your decisions, and get expert feedback so that you will be better able to analyze strategic alternatives on-the-job.” Phase II is the best understood and most well-studied phase of corporate learning. There are numerous books and research studies on instructional design. Getting the instruction right is essential, but it is only one element of the complete learning experience. Its effectiveness is strongly modulated by what occurs beforehand and afterward and how well it is aligned with the needs of the business and learners.
Phase III: Transfer What happens (or fails to happen) in Phase III is the main arbiter of whether business results are achieved. Thus, enhancing the third phase of learning—learning transfer and application—has tremendous potential to enhance the overall
CH002.indd 90
6/18/10 3:44:38 PM
Design the Complete Experience
91
effectiveness of corporate education. No matter how great the learning experience was in Phase II, it generates no value unless it is used (Figure D2.7). Therefore, planning and facilitating Phase III learning transfer is in everyone’s best interest: the individual, the learning and development organization, the participant’s manager, and the company as a whole. It deserves much greater attention than it has received in the past. The Real Work Begins When the Course Ends It may seem odd to include “learning transfer” as a phase of the learning process. However, as we will show below, it is, in fact, the most important part of the learning process and one that makes a crucial difference to the success of any learning intervention. Geoff Rip, president of ChangeLever International, makes the point that so-called learning transfer is really a form of action learning in which people continue to advance their understanding, skill, and knowledge by applying the nascent learning from the instructional phase to real-life problems and objectives. According to Rip (personal communication, 2010), “This phase of learning is essential to the achievement of competence or proficiency since it takes significant practice and feedback to develop complex skills and for new behaviors to become habituated. We need to stop thinking of ‘learning transfer’ as just transferring what was learned, but as a critical step in creating learning and achieving learning objectives, which has profound implications from a design perspective.” Because transfer is a critical component of the overall learning pro-
FIGURE D2.7. PHASE III LEARNING TRANSFER IS THE WEAKEST LINK IN MOST LEARNING PROGRAMS
Copyright © Grantland Enterprises; www.grantland.net. Used by permission.
CH002.indd 91
6/18/10 3:44:39 PM
92
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
cess, we feel strongly that learning professionals need to take greater ownership of Phase III and exert more influence on the post-course environment. The literature on transfer of learning is clear: The post-course environment has a profound effect on whether learning gets translated into results. Newstrom (1986) was one of the first to study the barriers to effective learning transfer. Of the top nine he found, only three were related to the content and delivery of the course, while more than half were related to the post-course environment and support (Table D2.4). The single greatest barrier to learning transfer was lack of reinforcement on the job. Similarly, of the eleven reasons that training fails cited by Phillips and Phillips (2002), seven were related to the post-course environment: • • • • • • •
Training regarded as an isolated event Participants not held accountable for results Failure to prepare the job environment to support transfer Management reinforcement and support missing Failure to isolate the effects of training Lack of commitment and involvement of executives Failure to provide feedback and use information about results
More recently, studies by Cromwell and Kolb (2004) and at American Express (2007) and Pfizer (Kontra, Trainor, & Wick, 2007) have reaffirmed the impact of the post-course environment on the effectiveness of learning transfer and the ultimate success of the training and development effort.
TABLE D2.4.
IMPEDIMENTS TO TRAINING TRANSFER
Rank
Barrier
1
Lack of reinforcement on the job
2
Interference from immediate (work) environment
3
Nonsupportive organizational culture
4
Trainee’s perception of impractical training program
5
Trainee’s perception of irrelevant training content
6
Trainee’s discomfort with change and associated effort
7
Separation from inspiration or support of trainer
8
Trainee’s perception of poorly designed or delivered training
9
Pressure from peers to resist changes
Source: Republished with permission, Emerald Group Publishing Limited. www.emeraldinsight. com/jmd.htm
CH002.indd 92
6/18/10 3:44:40 PM
Design the Complete Experience
93
The importance of the post-course period should come as no surprise. The value of revisiting a topic at intervals (the spacing effect) “is one of the oldest and best documented phenomena in the history of learning and memory research” (Bahrick & Hall, 2005). Likewise, research on superior performance across a wide range of human endeavors has long identified the pivotal role of practice in achieving expertise (Ericsson, Charness, Feltovich, & Hoffman, 2006; Ericsson, Krampe, & Tesch-Romer, 1993; Ericsson, Prietula, & Cokely, 2007). These findings have been recently popularized by Colvin in Talent Is Overrated (2008), Gladwell in Outliers (2008), and Coyle in The Talent Code (2009), all of which demonstrate convincingly that deliberate practice contributes more to mastery than does “natural ability.” Given the well-known importance of the immediate post-training period to the overall success of learning and development, why haven’t corporate learning organizations done more to manage this critical phase? We believe there have been three main impediments: 1. The prevailing paradigms that treat training as an event and focus most of the instructional design on what amounts to event planning 2. The post-course period as “no-man’s land” between the learning organization and day-to-day management, with neither accepting clear ownership for learning transfer and results 3. The difficulty of (and historical lack of systems for) managing the process for large numbers of dispersed learners. These issues will be addressed in greater detail in the chapters on D4 (Drive Value is generated only Learning Transfer) and D5 (Deploy when the learning is applied. Performance Support). We touch upon them here as the rationale for why Phase III needs to be included in planning the complete experience and why learning organizations need to dedicate more resources to influencing this vital, but neglected, aspect of the process of turning learning into results. Strengthening Phase III Corporate education is not an event, like a play or a concert or a three-day cricket match. It is a business process that is expected to yield business results over time. Like every process, it has inputs and outputs. Significant inputs—investments of time and money—are consumed in the Phase I preparation and the Phase II
CH002.indd 93
6/18/10 3:44:40 PM
94
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
coursework. Value is generated only when the learning is applied in a way that produces improved performance. For a program to be considered a success, the output—in terms of value created by improved productivity—needs to be sufficiently greater than the status quo (that is, had no training occurred) in order to repay the investment in facilities, trainers, planning, travel, opportunity cost, and so forth (Figure D2.8). Treat Training as a Process, Not an Event Transfer and application (Phase III) should
not be thought of as something that happens after a program; it is part of the program, an integral and irreplaceable action-learning element of the process. Since it is the only part of the process that generates value (rather than consumes it), transfer is essential to repay the investment; it must not be left to chance or individual initiative. The entire learning process, including follow-through, must be managed from beginning to end like any other business process critical to an organization’s success. The program is not finished until the learning has been transformed into results.
FIGURE D2.8. THE COST OF CREATING AND DELIVERING A TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM MUST BE OFFSET BY IMPROVED PRODUCTIVITY AND BUSINESS RESULTS
Output (returns)
Input (investments) Planning costs, materials, management time, salaries
Preparation
ROI
Facilities and travel, instructors’ salaries, participants’ salaries, opportunity costs
Coursework
Improved productivity
Application Learning transfer
CH002.indd 94
6/18/10 3:44:41 PM
Design the Complete Experience
95
Accept Responsibility for Phase III The second reason that Phase III, despite its importance, has not been part of program design is that no one “owns” it, in the sense of being held accountable for the outcome. Line managers, having themselves been acculturated to think of learning as an event, assume they have fulfilled their obligation by authorizing their direct reports to attend training. They mistakenly believe that it is the training department’s responsibility to be sure that learning generates results. Most managers greatly underestimate their impact on the outcome. Learning organizations, on the other hand, realize that they have no direct authority over participants once they return to their day-to-day jobs. They therefore have (erroneously) concluded that they are not responsible for what happens after Phase II either. The fact is, learning transfer is an essential phase of the complete learning experience, and the learning organization cannot claim that the training was a success until it has been successfully transferred to the work of the enterprise. Conversely, line managers cannot hold the training department accountable for results unless they do their part to support transfer, application, and assessment. The whole process succeeds or the whole process fails. In other words, managers and learning professionals co-own and are co-responsible for turning learning into business results, whether they realize it or not. While it is true that the learning organization has no direct authority over participants’ work activities or managers’ actions, that does not mean that they are not without influence. Bill Amaxopoulos, leadership program manager for the Chubb Group of Insurance Companies, put it well: “Maybe we can’t control the environment people return to, but we owe it to them to have a major influence over that environment.” And since learning organizations are increasingly being judged by business outcomes, it is in their own best interests to optimize Phase III. Companies that have embraced the Six Disciplines work actively to put systems, processes, and procedures in place so that line management and the learning organization share the responsibility for driving learning transfer. Learning organizations cannot “wash their hands” of responsibility for Phase III and still be successful. Adopt New Systems and Approaches The third reason that Phase III learning has been left largely unplanned and unmanaged is that until recently there were no practical methods to facilitate, monitor, and support the process. As we will discuss in chapters D4 and D5, new approaches and technologies, from teleconferencing to social networking to learning transfer management systems, have greatly reduced this impediment. The main barriers now to embracing Phase III as the greatest opportunity to enhance learning are outdated mindsets and misperceptions, rather than reality.
CH002.indd 95
6/18/10 3:44:41 PM
96
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Provide Performance Support Consumer products companies recognize that customer support is an integral part of the “whole product” experience. Good customer support contributes to customer satisfaction and repeat purchases. So they invest in instruction manuals, troubleshooting guides, online help sites, and personnel to ensure that customers can use their products effectively and well. Learning organizations strengthen their contributions to their businesses when they provide analogous forms of information and support. Participants are very likely to have questions or encounter difficulties when they first attempt to apply what they have learned. If they can obtain answers or assistance quickly and easily, they will be more likely to continue to try to utilize their new knowledge and skills. If they run into a problem and can’t get help or have a question but can’t find an answer, they are likely to become frustrated, give up the effort, and revert to pre-training behaviors. Specific suggestions for implementing ongoing guidance and support are discussed in D5: Deploy Performance Support. The point to be made here is that support during the learning transfer period needs to be a conscious part of the overall design. It should be planned and executed with the same care as has been traditionally afforded to instruction.
Phase IV: Achieve Phase IV completes the learning cycle. Participants’ achievements in applying what they have learned are assessed and recognized; opportunities for continued growth are identified. Indeed, “to achieve” means “to bring to a successful conclusion, to accomplish.” It follows that achievement is only possible when there is a clear standard for performance and when that performance is assessed in some way. This is the true finish line for learning. Program participants should be informed at the outset how and when their achievements will be assessed. There are three solid reasons for including assessment as part of the overall learning design: 1. It makes expectations explicit. 2. It establishes a clear goal line for the learning experience. 3. Assessment is, itself, a learning experience. Assessment Makes Expectations Explicit Employees want to know what is expected of them. In a study we did with AstraZeneca, for example, there was a direct correlation between clarity of
CH002.indd 96
6/18/10 3:44:42 PM
Design the Complete Experience
97
expectations and job satisfaction (Figure D2.9). Lack of clear expectations is a frequent cause of poor performance (Mager & Pipe, 1997, p. 34) and a source of frustration and employee dissatisfaction. Yet relatively few learning programs are really clear about what is expected of parEmployees want to know ticipants in terms of job performance. In the what is expected of them. absence of clear expectations and assessment of whether those expectations have been met, it should be no surprise that much of training goes unused. By analogy, consider what would happen to a company that set no targets for its sales people and never bothered to keep track of who sold how much. The fact is that measures drive performance, or as the saying goes, “what you measure is what you get.” Knowing that there will be accountability for demonstrating achievement causes participants to take the learning more seriously and give greater effort to applying it to their work. To achieve the desired results, however, the assessment has to be relevant in method, content, and timing. Assessment Sets a Clear Goal Line The second reason that evaluating achievement should be part of the complete experience is that it demarcates a clear finish line for a training cycle and establishes explicit conditions of satisfaction. The importance of having a clear finish FIGURE D2.9. CHANGE IN JOB SATISFACTION WHEN EXPECTATIONS WERE MADE CLEAR
% of respondents
60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Less satisfied
CH002.indd 97
More satisfied
6/18/10 3:44:42 PM
98
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
line and accountability for learning is familiar to anyone who has ever audited a class. When you audit a class (take it without exams, assignments, or credit), you inevitably give it short shrift when the work piles up and deadlines are tight at the end of the semester. Since there is no assessment in a class that you audit, it is human nature to spend your time on the courses for which you will be held accountable. Corporate universities, by failing to assess achievement, are in effect allowing all their students to audit all their courses. In academic universities, however, you do not receive credit for just auditing a class. In most corporate universities, you do; all you have to do is show up. The problem is that employees are held accountable and are routinely assessed for other aspects of their work. Not surprisingly, those receive a much greater share of their effort, time, and attention, just as graded courses do compared to pass-fail or audited courses. Even setting aside the accountability aspect of assessment, having a challenge with a clear goal itself is motivating for most people (Pink, 2009). Think of the hours that people spend doing crossword puzzles or playing solitaire or video games in which the only objective is to “win” by reaching some arbitrary goal, which carries no reward other than the intrinsic satisfaction of having reached it. Why do we deny participants the satisfaction of knowing they have achieved the goals for which the program was created? Assessment as Learning Finally, the assessment process itself fosters learning in at least two ways: it requires retrieval, which improves recall through the spacing effect, and it provides feedback on performance, which is essential for improvement. Retrieval Practice An interesting and well-known aspect of human learning is
that the more often information is retrieved from memory, the easier it is to recall subsequently. Retrieval of information is a first and critical step in converting new knowledge and skills to action. Therefore, educational practices that enhance retrieval (remembering) facilitate learning transfer and performance improvement. Various kinds of assessments, and even just preparing for assessments, reinforce learning and improve recall by requiring learners to retrieve and process the information again after the original learning occurred. The effect is even more powerful when the retrievals are spaced out in time (see review by Thalheimer, 2006). Thus, assessment, especially when it takes place after some time has elapsed, itself helps reinforce and solidify learning. Moreover, most people, faced with an upcoming assessment, review the material or rehearse the skill in their minds, thus further reinforcing the learning.
CH002.indd 98
6/18/10 3:44:43 PM
Design the Complete Experience
99
Feedback Feedback is essential to improve performance. In the absence of feed-
back, it is impossible to know whether you are doing something right or wrong, whether you are improving, and what you need to do to get better. It is a vital Real experts seek out component of developing expertise: constructive, even painful “Real experts seek out constructive, even feedback. painful feedback” (Ericsson, Prietula, & Cokely, 2007). But not everyone is prepared to voluntarily seek such feedback. Here again, there is value in defining a specific time and process for assessing achievement; it provides participants with much-needed feedback on how well they have mastered the skills and material and what they need to continue to work on in the next cycle. Nature of the Assessment For assessment to achieve the goal of supporting learning in Phase IV, it must measure the behaviors, skills, and results that the program was intended to foster. Just as instructional methods must be selected based on desired outcomes, so must assessment methods. In the 1950s, Benjamin Bloom and colleagues developed a taxonomy for educational objectives (Table D2.5). The important point for this discussion is that assessment at any given level does not predict performance at higher levels. In other words, testing participants’ ability to recall specific facts, terms, concepts, or strategies tells you very little about their ability to actually apply those concepts. If the goal of a learning program is to have people apply their knowledge to deliver a more effective sales presentation, then the assessment must specifically test application in an appropriate scenario. Unfortunately, the vast majority of assessment questions—especially in e-learning programs—are at the lowest cognitive domain (recall) even when they are intended to assess application, analysis, or higher level skills: In general, the single most useful improvement you can make in writing test items is to write them above the memorization level . . . the vast majority of test items are written at the memorization level. In contrast, the vast majority of jobs require performance that is above the memorization level. This disconnect between testing practice and job performance is what often leads management to question the value of training and turns testing into a misleading indicator of performance. E.g., “How come you passed the course but can’t do the job?” is a common summary of the problem (Shrock & Coscarelli, 2007, p. 157, emphasis in the original).
For assessments to be valid and support the desired learning, they must evaluate the actual behaviors, skills, and results desired. In general, the principles of
CH002.indd 99
6/18/10 3:44:43 PM
100
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
TABLE D2.5.
TAXONOMY OF COGNITIVE DOMAINS
Level
Domain
Definition
Examples
6
Evaluation
Form judgments about the value or worth of information, products, ideas, or quality of work and be able to defend the basis of the opinion.
appraise, compare, contrast, criticize, defend, justify, support, validate, judge
5
Synthesis
Put information together in a different way or new pattern to produce something unique or original.
categorize, compile, compose, create, design, devise, formulate, predict, produce
4
Analysis
Break information into parts. Differentiate among facts, opinions, assumptions, and conclusions. Identify errors in logic.
break down, deduce, diagram, differentiate, distinguish, illustrate, infer, outline, point out, relate, subdivide
3
Application
Use previously acquired knowledge in a new way or to solve problems in a new situation
change, compute, demonstrate, develop, modify, operate, organize, prepare, relate, solve, transfer, use
2
Comprehension
Demonstrate a level of understanding by restating, organizing, comparing, translating, interpreting, or stating main ideas
convert, estimate, defend, distinguish, discriminate, explain, generalize, summarize, infer, paraphrase, predict
1
Knowledge
Ability to recall previously learned facts, rules, terms, strategies, etc.
define, describe, identify, label, list, match, name, select, state
After Bloom, Englehart, Furst, Hill, and Krathwohl, 1956.
an effective program evaluation apply to individual assessments; they must be relevant, credible, compelling, and efficient (see D6: Document Results). Assessments of individual achievement may be part of the overall program evaluation, but they need not always be. For example, a well-designed selfassessment—one that allows each participant to gauge his or her success in applying the course principles and that provides feedback to guide further improvement— would support Phase IV learning, whether or not the results were ever used as part of the program evaluation. So would a structured feedback session between manager and employee or a teleconference in which each participant recounts his or her achievements, stumbling blocks, and plans for further development. Phase IV means defining an end point at which to assess and recognize individual achievement, whether or not these are part of program evaluation (see below and D6).
CH002.indd 100
6/18/10 3:44:44 PM
Design the Complete Experience
101
The most important thing is that there be an assessment. A cycle of learning is truly complete only when it includes a point at which the participant’s achievements in “putting learning to work” are assessed and recognized. Assessment provides participants with a clear goal to strive for, definitive expectations for improvement, and feedback on their progress, all of which help increase the amount of learning that is transferred and all of which contribute to meaningful results.
Staple Yourself to the Learner Finally, you need to ensure that the learner’s complete experience will be “all of a piece” and constitute a coherent experience (see Case in Point D2.4). We have found the concept of “stapling yourself to the learner” to be a useful exercise in this regard.
Case in Point D2.4 Leadership Development with Impact One learning leader who truly understands the importance of designing the complete learning experience and delivering relevant results is Larry Mohl, CLO of Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta. Children’s Healthcare is one of the nation’s finest and fastest-growing providers of healthcare for children, treating more than half a million patients a year. Children’s rapid growth, combined with a focus on quality, in the face of the fi nancial pressures and complexity of today ’s health care environment, create a need for a steady supply of leaders with leadership and business skills in addition to their medical knowledge and expertise. To meet this challenge, Larry and his team created the Center for Leadership. At the onset, they defined clear and challenging measures of success for the Center that included: • Improved personal leadership • Competency improvement • Readiness for new or expanded role • Enhanced leadership pipeline • More internal promotions and “ready now” leaders • Operational impact • Efficiency, standardization, new or improved capabilities and services, etc. • Financial impact • Operational impacts on cost, revenue, and funding
CH002.indd 101
6/18/10 3:44:44 PM
102
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Case in Point D2.4 Leadership Development with Impact (continued) Indeed, Larry accepted that continuing funding for the Center would be contingent on demonstrating progress against each of these four key conditions of success. To meet the need, the Center for Leadership designed four successive programs to address the new challenges leaders face as they advance through the leadership pipeline: supervisor certification, management certification, management acceleration, and executive experience. An example of a “complete learning experience” is the Executive Experience. This twelve- to eighteen-month-long program includes a holistic initial assessment; five sequential workshops with follow - through support: personal coaching, and action learning projects to continue learning during the intervals; and a rigorous final analysis using the success case methodology to document results and identify opportunities for continuous improvement. The Center’s holistic approach to development has been an outstanding success. Larry and his team have been able to document significant progress in all four key measures of success, from improved leadership ability, a stronger pipeline and more internal promotions on the one hand, to enhanced revenues, cost savings, and expanded services on the other. Larry shared the following insights: “To be successful, you have to build credibility with senior executives. That means you have to promise real results on the most pressing needs of the organization, measure what matters, and drive relevant impact. You have to be willing to show management both the good and the bad so that you can engage them in problem solving. “Most people have a difficult time connecting the dots between what they are learning, how it is being applied, and how it is impacting the operation. You’ll have to work to dig out the results and make them credible. Get a finance person on your core team and build both emotional and rational value. “Finally, don’t wait for the ‘big presentation’ to tell your story! Continually connect the dots between people, program, and impact and ask participants to do the same.”
The idea grew out of a landmark article by Shapiro, Rangan, and Sviokla (1992) in Harvard Business Review. They argued that the only way to really understand your customer’s experience (and how to improve it) was to figuratively “staple yourself to an order.” That is, physically follow an order through all the steps in your company to see how many times it was handled, how often it was set aside, how hard it was to find its status, where mistakes occurred, and so forth.
CH002.indd 102
6/18/10 3:44:45 PM
Design the Complete Experience
103
FIGURE D2.10. CHECK THE PROGRAM DESIGN BY IMAGINING YOURSELF STAPLED TO A LEARNER THROUGHOUT
The application of this idea to learning and development is to imagine yourself stapled to a learner as he or she goes through all four phases of learning (not just the detailed agenda of Phase II), from the invitation until assessment of progress weeks or months later (see Figure D2.10). At each stage, ask yourself: If I were the learner, • Would I understand what is expected of me? • Would I understand how this relates to other systems, slogans, and corporate initiatives? • Is it clear how the learning initiative relates to my work? Would I be able to use what is being taught? • Can I see the benefit for me personally? Why are they asking me to do this? • Could I connect each exercise to things I already knew or learned on the job or in other parts of the program? • What would influence my opinions and actions at this point in the process? • Where would I turn for help if I needed it? • What does my manager think? Does she support it? How would I know? • What is expected of me? How will I be evaluated? Will anyone know or care whether I use this stuff ? Whenever we have done this exercise with a client, they have discovered opportunities to make improvements that strengthened the overall experience and impact.
Summary The Second Discipline practiced by the most effective corporate learning organizations is that they include the complete learning experience in their plans—from
CH002.indd 103
6/18/10 3:44:45 PM
104
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
how the program is positioned in the invitation, to the preparation expected in Phase I, the instructional methods of Phase II, the accountability and support of Phase III, and how achievement will be assessed and recognized in Phase IV. Their program plans include how the contribution of all the key players—both inside and outside the learning organization—will be encouraged and coordinated. Designing the complete experience goes well beyond the traditional scope of corporate learning professionals. It will require learning new skills and abandoning long-standing paradigms. It is, in our experience, the only way to achieve a real breakthrough. Adopting this holistic approach to learning and learning transfer dramatically increases output and both the perceived and real value of educational efforts. Redefining the finish line as the delivery of results, rather than of the last day of class, is an invigorating challenge that offers substantial rewards. Use the checklist for D2 to ensure that the program design contemplates the “complete experience.”
The complete experience goes well beyond the traditional scope of corporate learning.
CHECKLIST FOR D2 PHASE I—Prepare
CH002.indd 104
✓ ❑
Element
Criterion
❑
Selection
The selection or enrollment process makes sure the “right people are on the bus”—meaning those with appropriate job experience and responsibilities to benefit from the program.
❑
Invitation
The invitation is clear and compelling. It explains the rationale for the program, summarizes its content, and sets expectations for its subsequent use. Ideally, the invitation comes from an influential and committed sponsor.
❑
Preparation (participants)
There is meaningful preparatory work—reading, exercises, simulations, performance feedback, etc.—that will help maximize the time spent in the learning program itself.
❑
Preparation (participants with managers)
A pre-program meeting with the participant’s manager is strongly encouraged (ideally, required). Guidelines and worksheets for that meeting are provided.
❑
Preparation (managers)
Managers are provided an overview of the program, its objectives, and the business needs being addressed, as well as step-by-step guidelines for fulfilling their role in maximizing results.
6/18/10 3:44:47 PM
Design the Complete Experience
105
PHASE II—Learn Element
Criterion
❑
Use of Phase I Learning
The preparatory work is utilized extensively in the program— so much so that those who did not complete it are at a disadvantage (or ideally, are not allowed to attend).
❑
Value Chain
There is a clear understanding among the design team and facilitators of how each component relates to the desired behaviors, capabilities, and expected business outcomes. These links are made explicit to the learners.
❑
Relevance
Relevant examples, stories, simulations, discussions, and so forth are included to help learners see how the material applies to their jobs. Current practitioners and/or prior graduates of the program are used to help underscore its utility.
❑
Practice
The agenda provides adequate time for learners to practice the desired skills or behaviors with supervision and feedback.
❑
Process Check
End-of-course evaluations include assessment of whether learners perceived the utility and relevance of the program and feel prepared to use it to advantage in their work.
PHASE III—Transfer ❑
Performance Support
Resources are committed to ensuring that learners can get help in applying new skills and knowledge. The design includes the production of job aids or other materials and systems to support on-the-job application.
❑
Manager Involvement
Participants and managers meet following the course. Guidelines are provided for that meeting. On-going manager involvement is facilitated.
❑
Accountability
Processes are in place to periodically remind participants of their obligations, hold them accountable for progress, and recognize superior effort and accomplishment.
❑
Process Management
There are a process and systems in place to allow learning professionals to monitor, support, and manage the learning transfer process.
PHASE IV—Achieve
CH002.indd 105
❑
Recognition
Significant improvements and accomplishments are recognized in a meaningful way.
❑
Assessment
An end point is defined weeks or months after the instruction. There is a plan in place to assess achievement and participants know what it is. Significant improvement and accomplishments are recognized.
6/18/10 3:44:48 PM
106
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Action Points For Learning Leaders • Review the programs for which your group is responsible to ensure that the designs truly encompass the complete experience from the learner’s point of view. • Use the “staple yourself to the learner” exercise, or a similar approach, to affirm that all four phases of learning and all six Ds have been included in the planning. • Be vigilant for mixed messages—where what is taught in the program and what is practiced in the business are inconsistent or where one phase does not support another. Such inconsistencies discourage participants from trying to transfer their knowledge and, if glaring, lead to cynicism. • Emphasize to general management the importance of their support in all four phases of the program. Explain how partnerships between line management and training and between learners and their managers are necessary to achieve optimal return on investment from learning and development programs. • Pay particular attention to Phase III plans. This period has been traditionally ignored and offers the greatest opportunities for improvement. • Be sure there is a long-enough period between instruction and assessment to allow participants to demonstrate improvement or achieve significant results. For Line Leaders • Ask learning and development to show the links between the instructional design and the business requirements for all-important programs. • Review them to be sure that the business objectives, the kinds of behavioral improvements expected, and the learning exercises link logically to one another. • If such linkages cannot be drawn or are suspect, the learning plan should be reconsidered. • Ask line managers what they are doing to ensure that development programs are reinforced so they “stick.” • Devise systems to hold line managers accountable for their roles in obtaining results from learning and development. • Measure and reward managers’ active engagement in the process.
CH002.indd 106
6/18/10 3:44:48 PM
Design the Complete Experience
107
• Ensure that “the video matches the audio.” That is, be certain that what management says, what managers do, and what the system rewards are in alignment. If not, you are wasting time and money in training. • Make sure that there is a process to assess, recognize, and, ideally, reward and celebrate achievements that result from learning well applied. • Make the necessary changes in the environment to support what is being taught and to maximize the impact of learning and development.
CH002.indd 107
6/18/10 3:44:49 PM
CH002.indd 108
6/18/10 3:44:49 PM
DELIVER FOR APPLICATION The real question is what can you do on Monday? What can you do Monday six weeks from now, six months from now? —LEO BURKE
T
he value delivered by a corporate educational program is proportional to the amount of new knowledge and skills that are applied to the work of the organization. Unused knowledge is like unplanted seed; it will never bear fruit. Therefore, the job of corporate learning and development is not merely to impart knowledge, but to be sure that it is put to work so that its benefits can be harvested. A key factor that influences application of knowledge is the way in which it is taught. Hence, the Third Discipline of creating breakthrough learning programs is to structure them so that they deliver for application. That is, so that they employ instructional methods that help bridge the learning-doing gap, honor adult learning principles of relevance and utility, and provide adequate time and guidance for goal setting and application planning. In this chapter we focus on those aspects of learning delivery that enhance the application of new knowledge and skills to the work of the individual and organization. Our goal is to complement more extensive works on instructional design by calling attention to the issues we frequently encounter in corporate learning and development programs despite the availability of well-honed instructional design models. Topics covered include how to: • Narrow the learning-doing gap • Motivate learners • Make relevance clear 109
CH003.indd 109
6/17/10 3:25:43 PM
110
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
• • • • • • •
Improve perceived utility Provide know-how Make learning memorable Prepare and plan for transfer Communicate what happened A checklist for D3 Action points for learning and line leaders
Narrow the Learning-Doing Gap There is always a gap between the learning environment and the environment in which knowledge and skills must be put to work. Differences include time pressures, novelty of the problems, magnitude of the consequences, complexity of the situations, distractions, ability to recall, and many others. The challenge for corporate educators is to help learners successfully bridge the gap between knowledge acquisition in a learning program and knowledge application on the job (see Figure D3.1). The size of the gulf between learning and doing is influenced by the way in which new skills and actions are taught. Relevant examples, active learning, simulations, practice sessions, and other application-focused delivery techniques narrow the gap, making it easier for participants to connect learning to their FIGURE D3.1. THE LEARNING ORGANIZATION’S CHALLENGE IS TO DELIVER TRAINING IN WAYS THAT BRIDGE LEARNING TO DOING
CH003.indd 110
6/17/10 3:25:46 PM
Deliver for Application
111
work. Passive listening, endless PowerPoint slides, poorly designed e-learning, and assessments focused solely on recall widen the gulf, with the result that fewer participants make the transition and achieve results (see Figure D3.2). Medina (2008) recently reviewed the literature on brains and learning and in his engaging book, Brain Rules, propounded twelve “rules” about how the brain functions. He summed up his findings this way: “What do these studies show, viewed as a whole? Mostly this: If you wanted to create an educational environment that was directly opposed to what the brain is good at doing, you would probably design something like a classroom” (p. 5). For participants to generate business results by applying what they learn in a corporate educational program, three conditions must be met: • They must perceive value for the effort required. • They must have learned how. • They must be able to retrieve the relevant information and strategies. The goal of the Third Discipline, Deliver for Application, is to be sure that participants leave Phase II of learning programs with the motivation and ability to apply their new knowledge. Methods to achieve these outcomes are discussed below.
FIGURE D3.2. THE WIDER THE GAP BETWEEN LEARNING AND DOING, THE FEWER PARTICIPANTS MAKE THE LEAP AND ACHIEVE RESULTS
Learning
Doing Work
Copyright © 2010 Fort Hill Company. Used with permission.
CH003.indd 111
6/17/10 3:25:47 PM
112
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Motivate Learners Motivation to learn is a sine qua non for effective education; it’s vital to learning through coursework and it is vital to continued learning through application on the job. And what motivates most adults to learn is the expectation of future benefits that they value—in other words, “What’s in it for me?” Program participants will be more motivated to learn and, ultimately, more motivated to apply what they learn, if they are Motivation is vital to learning. convinced that doing so will produce an outcome that they personally value. The specific benefits that each individual values is a matter of personal preference. From a very early age, human beings exhibit a strong intrinsic motivation to learn (National Research Council, 2000); mastery of a concept or skill is its own reward. In the context of corporate training programs, however, most employees are motivated to learn and use skills that will make their work demonstrably easier or faster, improve their working environment, and increase their chances for promotion, recognition, and so forth. As Richard O’Leary, director of Human Resources and Diversity for Science and Technology at Corning, explained to us: “A design criterion should be that the program feels integrated with how you get results. Make sure you are designing learning that people have a hunger for because it helps them solve what they think is the problem” (personal communication, 2004). Victor Vroom of the Yale School of Management developed the Expectancy Model as a way to explain what motivates employees (Vroom, 1964/1995). Vroom proposed that a person is motivated when he or she believes that effort, performance, and outcomes are linked and when the outcome is of personal value to him or her (see Figure D3.3). One element is expectancy—the strength of the belief that making an effort will produce better performance. In terms of training and development, the more I believe that learning the material and using it on the job will improve my performance, the stronger my motivation will be to make the effort to do so. For example, a participant will be more motivated to attend training and modify her sales approach if she expects that it will help her achieve significantly higher sales than if she believes that it will make only a small, incremental difference. The second element in Vroom’s motivation model is instrumentality—that is, the perception of how closely linked (instrumental) improved performance is to realizing an outcome or reward. Obviously, I will be more motivated to try to improve my performance if I believe performance is instrumental in winning a promotion than if I am convinced that promotion depends entirely on politics.
CH003.indd 112
6/17/10 3:25:48 PM
Deliver for Application
113
FIGURE D3.3. MOTIVATION DEPENDS ON THE BELIEFS THAT EFFORT WILL IMPROVE PERFORMANCE AND THAT PERFORMANCE WILL LEAD TO REWARD AS WELL AS THE PERSONAL VALUE ASCRIBED TO THE REWARD
Motivation
Valence I value the reward
Effort
Expectancy
Instrumentality
I believe this will improve my performance
I believe improved performance will be rewarded
Performance
Reward
Finally, valence is the relative worth that each individual places on the expected outcome. Other things being equal, the more a person values the outcome, the greater his or her motivation will be to learn the skills and behaviors necessary to achieve it. It is important to note here that intrinsic rewards—for example, the personal satisfaction of solving a problem or achieving mastery—may be valued as highly as, or even more highly than, extrinsic rewards (Pink, 2009). Thus, motivation is the product of three factors: how much the person values the potential outcome, how closely he believes the outcome is tied to performance, and how much he believes that the effort required will produce improvement. In general, the greater the strength of each element, the greater the overall motivation will be. We say “in general” because if any one element is completely missing—for example, if I place no value on the outcome, or I don’t believe I am capable of improving my performance—then I will not be motivated, even if two out of the three conditions are met. Maximizing participants’ motivation to learn, then, requires satisfying three conditions: • Addressing learning programs to outcomes that people value • Persuading them that the recommended approach is tightly coupled to improved performance • Convincing them that their efforts will be rewarded
CH003.indd 113
6/17/10 3:25:48 PM
114
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
While learning professionals largely control the first two conditions, rewards and recognition are the province of the participants’ direct supervisors. That is why in D1 we recommended raising the question: “Besides training, what else needs to be in place to achieve these results?” It is much easier to motivate people to learn and apply their learning when they value the outcomes from doing so and there is a process to ensure that successful efforts are identified, recognized, and in some way rewarded. Motivation is especially important in corporate training and development programs because Meaningful change inevitably such programs are, in the end, change initiainvolves some discomfort. tives. They are intended to help people change from the way they currently do their jobs to an approach that is more productive for themselves and for the company. Meaningful change inevitably involves some discomfort and requires sustained effort. Compelling answers to the “What’s in it for me?” (WIIFM) question are needed to motivate people to put forth the required effort. WIIFM has been called the “universal radio station” because everyone listens to it (see Figure D3.4). When FIGURE D3.4. LEARNERS WANT TO KNOW WHAT’S IN IT FOR THEM
© Robert Weber/Condé Nast Publications/www.cartoonbank.com. Used with permission.
CH003.indd 114
6/17/10 3:25:49 PM
Deliver for Application
115
people understand “what’s in it for me,” they are more receptive to new ideas, more motivated to learn, and more willing to soldier through the discomfort that accompanies any significant change. Therefore, the first task of delivering for application is to be explicit about the value that participants can expect if they attend the program and apply its teachings. The promised benefits need to be believable and achievable—a task made easier if the objectives have been clearly linked to business priorities in the first place. Participants will want to attend the program if both its benefit and relevance are clear. Beverly Kaye, founder of Career Systems International and a thought leader in the area of employee development and retention, put it this way: To ensure that people get the maximum value from learning and development, we need to engage their hearts as well as their heads. We design and deliver every program so that when participants walk out the door they feel empowered and prepared to take action with a “can-do” attitude. We intentionally work to get participants’ adrenalin going. We engage their hearts so they have a passion to apply what they learn. They leave with an understanding that no one can take charge of their development and job satisfaction but themselves. So learning about taking charge of your own development is more than a cognitive exercise.
Make Relevance Clear For adults, relevance and motivation to learn are closely linked. A key principle of adult learning is that learners want to know why they are being asked to learn something—how the material relates to them, their role, their division, and their business—before they are willing to learn and then use it (Exhibit D3.1). “Research indicates that the need to know affects motivation to learn, learning outcomes, and post-training motivation to use learning” (Knowles, Holton, & Swanson, 2005, p. 201). It is not surprising, therefore, that perceived lack of relevance is one of the major barriers to the transfer of learning (Kirwan, 2009; Newstrom, 1986). Jim Trinka is the technical training director for the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration and co-author of A Legacy of 21st Century Leadership: A Guide for Creating a Climate of Leadership Throughout Your Organization. When we asked him why such a high percentage of his trainees utilize what they learn, he told us: I think it’s the ease with which we can connect what’s in the training program to what they’re going to do on the job. It’s easy to make those connections, so I like to call it connecting the dots. It’s easy for an instructor to connect the dots
CH003.indd 115
6/17/10 3:25:50 PM
116
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
from what the information and content in the course is to what the controller or technician is going to have to do every day on the job. And because that connection is easy, there is a great belief among the developmental or student controllers that they are actually going to use the information they are getting. Everything that we teach them, they will have to know in their careers. We don’t teach things that don’t have any applicability. We keep all that out. So it’s all 100 percent usable content. That’s why you get 100 percent transfer.
Exhibit D3.1 Some Relevant Principles of Adult Education Many of the principles of “delivering for application” reflect the principles of adult learning as summarized by Knowles, Holton, and Swanson in their classic The Adult Learner (2005). Human beings continue learning throughout their lives. Adult learners, however, have specific needs and preferences that must be addressed for maximum effectiveness. Specifically: • Adults are practical and place high value on relevancy. • In a work setting, they may not be interested in knowledge for its own sake. • Adults want to see a reason for learning something. They want to know, “What’s in it for me?” • The relevance of theories, concepts, examples, and exercises needs to be immediately apparent; concrete examples of application help. • Adults are goal-oriented. • They prefer a problem-centric rather than content-centric approach. • They want to know how the class will help them attain their personal goals. • Adults learn from experience. • Include opportunities (simulations, role play, practice sessions) to apply their new knowledge and practice skills in a safe environment. • Provide feedback that reinforces the correct actions and provides insight into missteps. • Adult learners need to be shown respect. • Adults bring with them a rich tapestry of experiences and knowledge that should be honored and drawn upon. • Treat learners as equals and encourage them to share their wisdom and opinions in class. • Never ridicule or “talk down to” participants. • Adults are autonomous and self-directed. • They need to be actively involved in the learning process, assuming responsibility for group discussions, presentations, and so forth. • Instructors of adults are most effective when they act as facilitators—guiding participants to their own knowledge and conclusions—rather than supplying them with facts.
CH003.indd 116
6/17/10 3:25:50 PM
Deliver for Application
117
Further evidence for the importance of relevance comes from the analysis of tens of thousands of post-program evaluations at Hewlett-Packard. Peggy Parskey, who was then global learning process manager, worked closely with Michael Ross of Performance Challenges Corporation to build a model using several multivariate techniques (including multiple regression and cluster analysis). The model captures higher-order reaction constructs, predicts overall assessment from three specific metrics, and presents the data in a powerful and easily interpreted way (see Figure D3.5). The strongest predictor of a program’s overall perceived quality was one facet of each of the following factors: achieved objectives (learning experience), recommend to peers (learner impact), and enhance job performance (utility). FIGURE D3.5. IN HEWLETT-PACKARD’S DATA, THREE FACTORS—UTILITY, LEARNING EXPERIENCE, AND LEARNER IMPACT—PREDICT THE OVERALL ASSESSMENT OF VALUE Training techniques
Instructor style, method, pace
Learning experience
Recommend to peers Instruction satisfaction
Achieved objectives
Learner Impact
Index average
Content satisfaction
Logistics satisfaction
Utility
Skill/concept relevance
Enhance job/role performance
Motivated to apply
KEY BSC measures
Predicts overall quality
Primary indicator
Copyright © 2003 Hewlett-Packard. Used with permission.
CH003.indd 117
6/17/10 3:25:51 PM
118
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Three ratings contributed to the utility score: • The relevance of the skills and concepts • The extent to which learners expected the program to enhance their performance • Whether the learners were motivated to apply what they had learned Hewlett-Packard tracked the utility scores for each course offering in real time. Any program that scored low on perceived utility was targeted for special attention. Low perceived utility, of course, does not necessarily mean that the program was not useful or relevant. But it does mean that somehow the relevance and applicability of the material were not effectively communicated to the participants, or that they were not the right audience, or that there was some other problem. The rationale for singling out courses with low utility ratings for special attention is that if participants leave a program with a poor opinion of its utility, it is very unlikely that they will make the effort to transfer the learning or produce positive results on the job (Parskey, personal communication, 2005). In other words, if the course content is not relevant as perceived by the participants, then they won’t be motivated to learn or use it. Other aspects of the program—instruction, venue, learning exercises—no matter how brilliantly executed, cannot compensate for a lack of perceived utility.
Improve Perceived Utility To improve the perceived utility of a program—and hence the motivation for learning and learning transfer—be explicit about the business needs that the program is designed to address (D1) and use business-relevant examples to illustrate the connections between the content and the work of the company. This requires that instructors understand the business needs in depth. What are the key business drivers? How does the company actually generate value? What are the major challenges it faces from competitors, a changing market, regulation, internal inefficiencies, and so forth? What is its vision? What are the expectations of its leaders? A firm grasp of these core business issues greatly enhances an instructor’s effectiveness and ability to make the content relevant for participants. It is also essential for his or her credibility. The importance of credibility explains why using senior executives as faculty is one of the fastest-growing trends in executive education (Bolt, 2005, p. 11): they have instant credibility and a deep grasp of the issues. While internal instructors should, in theory, have a deeper grasp of the company’s specific business challenges than external facilitators, it is not always
CH003.indd 118
6/17/10 3:25:52 PM
Deliver for Application
119
possible or practical to use only internal trainers. External instructors and experts can introduce fresh insights, new perspectives, and new approaches that are important to keep a company from becoming too insular. But it is impossible for instructors from outside the company to be conversant with the details of the multifarious product lines, operating divisions, and business units. One creative solution to this dilemma is to team-teach by pairing external content experts with internal managers who can provide the business context and company-specific examples. This approach achieves the best of both: deep content expertise as well as credible examples of work situations that are immediately recognizable and relevant to the participants (Connolly & Burnett, 2003). Another rich source of relevant examples is the participants themselves: “for many kinds of learning, the richest resources for learning reside in the adult learners themselves” (Knowles, Holton, & Swanson, 2005, p. 66). Consistent with the principles of adult learning, the key is to honor and build on the experience participants bring to the program. Design exercises that draw upon the experiences of the group members to generate examples that are immediately relevant and applicable to their work environment.
Provide Know-How For learning to produce performance improvement, participants have to know more than just new information; they have to know how to use it in their work. Delivering for application means using instructional approaches and exercises that require participants to practice the kind of thinking and actions they will need on the job. For example, if the objective is to improve the ability of the participants to handle objections, then they need to be given the opportunity to For learning to produce practice their skills during the program improvement, participants and get feedback on their performance. have to know how to use it. It is not sufficient for the instructor to just talk about it. Marc Lalande, president of Your Learning GPS, illustrated the point this way: “I was a ski instructor for fifteen years. Teaching skiing in the classroom with PowerPoint was never an option.” Yet, in today’s time-pressed business climate, interactive exercises and practice are often the first things jettisoned because they “take too much time.” Lalande feels strongly that such reasoning represents false economy. Indeed, when he was head of training for a pharmaceutical company and was asked to shorten a program, he would tell the sponsors: “You can eliminate anything you want from the
CH003.indd 119
6/17/10 3:25:52 PM
120
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
agenda except the time for practice and role play. If you remove that, you might as well cancel the program” (Lalande, personal communication, 2010). Link Instruction, Behaviors, and Business Outcomes Delivering for application requires forging a clear and logical value chain that links each learning experience to the on-the-job performance required, and the required performance to the ultimate business outcomes. Brinkerhoff and Gill (1994) developed the “impact map” as a way to think about and illustrate the links between learning and business results. We prefer the term “value chain” as it is more familiar to business leaders. Michael Porter defined a value chain as the sequence of value-adding activities by which a company creates competitive advantage (Porter, 1985). The value chain for learning illustrates the sequence by which learning contributes to business success. A simple three-link chain is shown in Figure D3.6. The requisite skills and behaviors are identified in D1 by the needs-analysis and first two quadrants of the Outcomes Planning Wheel. The task for instructional designers, then, is to select the instructional strategies that will optimize the ultimate business outcomes. That seems painfully obvious. And yet, if you were to actually map the value chain of many corporate training programs, they are as illogical as Lalande’s remark about teaching skiing by PowerPoint; there is often an obvious disconnect between the stated purpose of the instruction and the methodology employed (Table D3.1). There may be a place for an orientation lecture, but ultimately, people have to hit the slopes to learn to ski, just as they need to practice new skills to succeed in business.
FIGURE D3.6. SIMPLIFIED VALUE CHAIN LINKING LEARNING ACTIVITIES TO BUSINESS OUTCOMES
Desired Business Outcome
CH003.indd 120
Skills and Behaviors Required
Learning Modalities
6/17/10 3:25:53 PM
Deliver for Application
TABLE D3.1.
121
A FACETIOUS EXAMPLE OF A DISCONNECT BETWEEN METHOD AND OBJECTIVE
Outcome Sought
Skills and Behaviors Required
Learning Modalities
Safe and enjoyable downhill skiing for beginners
Ability to start, stop, and turn effectively
Have students sit passively listening to an illustrated lecture
Safely enter and leave chair lift Correctly identify trail and difficulty markers Obey safety rules Be aware of and courteous to other skiers And so forth
A useful check on the degree to which the program has been designed to “deliver for application,” then, is to complete a value chain for the proposed course, looking for congruence between objectives and methods. Remember to include all four phases of learning in the learning modalities column; not just the formal instruction period (Table D3.2). Note that value chains grow increasingly more detailed as they progress from the high-level business objectives to specific behaviors to learning strategies. Any given outcome usually requires multiple skills and behaviors, each of which typically requires several different instructional methods and opportunities to learn and practice. For planning purposes, it may be helpful to insert columns on either side of the behaviors to allow a more detailed breakdown of the outcomes and requisite skills and actions (see Table D2.3). An obvious question is: Is it worth the time and effort to map the linkages in this way? Our answer is unequivocally, “Yes”; the ultimate success of a training program depends on getting the instructional strategy right. Being able to clearly explain how a given exercise relates to the business purpose helps participants understand its relevance and, by so doing, increases their motivation to learn and apply its lessons. Margolis and Bell (1986) presented a compelling case for introducing every learning exercise with the rationale from the learner’s perspective (see Case in Point D3.1). The learning and performance consulting group at Farm Credit Canada— Canada’s leading agricultural lender—has extended the use of value chain mapping in two important and innovative ways (Bartlett, personal communication, 2010): • They include a performance map in the summary letter that is sent to a business sponsor as follow-up to a discussion about a potential training opportunity. The map helps to summarize and confirm the links between the core strategies,
CH003.indd 121
6/17/10 3:25:54 PM
122
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
the business scorecard, the desired behavioral outcomes, and the recommended approach to training. • Performance maps are also included in the descriptions of courses in the Field Development Program to make it clear to participants and their managers how the course relates to the organization’s key strategies and performance scorecard. Mapping the congruence between requisite behaviors and learning modality helps avoid the overwhelming temptation to start with the method (for example, a podcast) and try to make the content fit, or see what slides are already on file and work backward from there. As consultant and author John Izzo facetiously remarked: “It’s easier to find a new audience than to write a new talk.” To avoid the latter temptation, UBS Bank instituted a “PowerPoint Free Zone” rule in its leadership development program for managing directors. Not even senior TABLE D3.2. PORTION OF A VALUE CHAIN LINKING LEARNING AND OUTCOMES FOR A SALES MANAGEMENT PROGRAM Business Outcome Sought
Skills and Behaviors Required
Learning Modalities
Increased sales as a result of more effective sales management
Correctly identify a sales representative’s development stage and use most effective situational leadership style to manage
Preparatory reading about situational leadership Instructor-led discussion of model Guided practice identifying stages in videos On-the-job practice and reflection Self-assessment on use of model
Effective use of the situation, behavior, impact coaching model
Preparatory reading about model Instructor-led discussion of model Practice giving feedback to peers in program, observed by expert coach On-the-job practice and reflection, with access to coach Assessment of coaching effectiveness by direct reports
CH003.indd 122
6/17/10 3:25:54 PM
Deliver for Application
123
Case in Point D3.1 Tell Me Why Corporate training exercises are (or at least should be) designed with the end in mind— that is, how the exercises relate to building the requisite skills to achieve the business goals. But while that linkage is clear to the instructional designers, it is often lost on the participants. If they are unable to make the link between the exercise and their job responsibilities, they will not be motivated to take it seriously, participate, and learn from it. A significant contributor to the disconnect is the way in which exercises are typically introduced, whether in the classroom or online. The tendency is to go immediately to the “how” without explaining the “why,” what Margolis and Bell (1986) call the “administrative approach.” A typical example in the classroom would sound something like this: “In the next ten minutes, I am going to break you into small groups. . . .” or in e-learning: “In each of the following scenarios, pick the best next step.” The problem with introducing exercises in this way is that participants begin thinking immediately about whether they will have enough time and whether they like or hate this kind of activity, rather than about its purpose and potential payoff; the thread to the purpose is lost and so are the participants. Margolis and Bell recommend that every exercise be introduced in a four-step process (pp. 61–70): 1. 2. 3. 4.
Explain the rationale. Explain the task. Define the context. Explain what is to be reported.
“This sequence follows the logic of learning and the logic of motivation. . . . The introduction/rationale is a statement that answers a fundamental question for the learner: ‘Why should I enter into this task or experience?’ . . . The rationale [should be] always stated from the learner’s perspective, not the trainer’s or the organization’s perspective” (pp. 62–63). An effective explanation of the task (step 2) is constructed so that the participants produce a product that aids their learning. The explanation should always include an action verb such as identify, list, rank, solve, and so forth, and usually a phrase that defines the quantity and quality desired, such as the five most important. Margolis and Bell explain the third step as follows (p. 65): “The definition of context explains how learners will accomplish the task. The context for the task involves three elements: • The size of the working unit (individuals or subgroups); • The composition of the subgroups, if they are used; and • The amount of time allotted for completing the task.” (continued )
CH003.indd 123
6/17/10 3:25:55 PM
124
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Case in Point D3.1 Tell Me Why (continued) The fourth and final step—explain what has to be reported—is simply a matter of telling participants what they are responsible for reporting to the group as a whole once their subgroup has completed its task; it need not include administrative details, which have a tendency to confuse rather than clarify. Reporting out continues and enhances learning by allowing participants to review and summarize their discussions and by giving the instructor the opportunity to comment, embellish, and amplify key concepts and principles. “The cardinal principle to remember is to give the rationale for the activity before describing the task, how it is to be done, and what will be reported. This approach puts into practice a fundamental precept of adult learning: ‘Adults need to know why they need to learn something, before undertaking to learn it’ ” (Knowles, Holton, & Swanson, 2005, p. 74).
executives were allowed to bring their canned presentations. Although initially there was trepidation on the part of the presenters, both they and participants agreed that interaction was much greater and the outcome was superior to typical corporate presentations. In general, the closer the instructional environment mimics the actual work environment, the easier the content is to recall and apply (reviewed by Thalheimer, 2007). For this reason, Eli Lilly, for example, maintains a teaching facility for Good Manufacturing Practices complete with its own warehouse (for practicing forklift driving and safety) and a production line (for teaching and practicing sterile technique, cleaning procedures, and so forth). Some Examples The key point is that there is no one best method of instruction. Debates about the value of classroom versus e-learning versus virtual or other forms of instruction are meaningless without specifying what needs to be learned and what performance is required. As the National Research Council’s report How People Learn noted: “Asking which teaching technique is best is analogous to asking which tool is best—a hammer, a screwdriver, a knife, or pliers. In teaching as in carpentry, the selection of tools depends on the task at hand” (p. 22). Learning professionals should be “method agnostic.” That is, we should recommend the method, duration, and structure only after the business objectives and performance goals (D1) are clear. We do not have the space here, nor is it our intent, to write a treatise on instructional methods and their application. Numerous texts are available that
CH003.indd 124
6/17/10 3:25:55 PM
Deliver for Application
125
cover these topics in depth, for example Gagné, Briggs, and Wager (2004) and Smith and Ragan (2005). Instead, we have chosen to provide a few current examples and some caveats from our experience with corporate training programs. Skill Practice When the business objective of training requires that participants
become proficient in a particular skill, there is no substitute for practice with feedback. That requires some sort of simulated environment such as a role-play exercise, computer simulation, mock interview, or the like. Even then, a training program can only help participants reach a basic level of proficiency; true mastery requires ongoing practice with assessment and feedback on their performance on the job. For most people, having to demonstrate a task or technique in front of an audience or instructor is an uncomfortable—and therefore unpopular—exercise. So, while such skill practice is valuable, perhaps even indispensable for learning, it is not likely to generate positive reactions. One of the dangers of relying solely on learner reaction data (so-called Level 1 measurement) for evaluating programs is the evidence that participants tend to rate comfortable, easy, and ineffective teaching methods higher than they rate challenging, instructive, and effective ones (see Case in Point D6.2). One technique to ensure relevance and transferability, as well as providing time for practice, is by using “real play.” Participants bring real issues to the program and these are then used as the scenarios for role play and practice (see Case in Point D3.2). Simulations The best-known examples of delivering learning to maximize
application are flight simulators. First developed by E. A. Link to train pilots to
Case in Point D3.2 Real Play Versus Role Play An example of the application of D3 at a leading biopharmaceutical company is the concept of “real play” instead of role play. The senior training manager responsible for management development explains: “ The goal of ’ real play ’ is to reduce ’ death by PowerPoint ’ and increase the application of the feedback skills taught in our sales leadership program. Participants bring real personnel issues they are facing to the session. During the program, they rehearse applying the course principles to these real problems. The response to real play has been very positive. Participants report that the training is very relevant and that they feel much better prepared to apply the skills they have learned.”
CH003.indd 125
6/17/10 3:25:55 PM
126
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
fly by instruments, they were vital in accelerating the training of pilots during the Second World War. Current simulators are so sophisticated that commercial pilots can qualify to fly new models entirely in the trainers; they can also lose their licenses if they violate FAA rules while flying the simulators during recertification. In many ways, the simulators are actually superior to actual flight experience because they can be programmed to mimic any number of critical conditions that would be impossible or too dangerous to practice in a real airplane (engine fires, icing, landing with jammed landing gear, and so on). Of course, such simulators cost tens of millions of dollars, but they indicate what is possible in terms of matching the learning situation to the conditions in which the learning must be applied. As such, there is growing interest in and application of simulations to business training. A welldesigned simulation requires the same kind of Simulations are powerful, thinking (analysis, synthesis, pattern recognition, engaging, dynamic, and and so forth) and decision making that needs to effective. be applied to real business issues. Simulations compress time, allowing learners to complete business cycles in hours rather than months or years, so that they can see the longterm effects of their decisions. Simulations require active engagement and decision making, as opposed to merely passive listening, which boosts the retention of the lessons learned. Active involvement is one of the most frequently cited factors in making learning memorable. Akerman, Ekelund, and Parisi (2005) summarized the advantages of business simulations as follows: • Simulations increase executive business acumen and financial literacy. • Simulations build competency, alignment, and commitment around complex corporate strategies, business models, and initiatives. • Simulations are a powerful, engaging, dynamic, and effective way to reach executive audiences (p. 28). The challenge is to find simulations that teach skills applicable to real work and not just “gamesmanship.” Simulations can also be helpful in simplifying situations to highlight the effects of specific actions. To be effective, simulations need to be context-specific enough for participants to easily transfer the learning to their actual work roles; if participants cannot see the connection between the simulation and their business challenges, it will fail to produce the desired results. For this reason, many companies are now having custom simulations created to address their unique business challenges and educational objectives.
CH003.indd 126
6/17/10 3:25:56 PM
Deliver for Application
127
Regardless of the specific simulation or technology employed, a skillfully facilitated debriefing is essential to draw out the lessons learned from the exercise and illustrate their application to the real work of the participants and enterprise. “The goals are two: to make sure the participants clearly understand the relationships between their simulated decisions and market changes on the business result, and also to clarify the key learning points from the simulation” (Akerman, Ekelund, & Parisi, 2005, p. 35). Finally, action plans and support for learning transfer are required to ensure that the learning from the simulation is put to work in a way that leads to business value. Case Studies Case studies are a popular approach to executive education, but
they also can be used effectively in a broad range of other corporate training initiatives. Case studies can help draw out principles and illustrate the impact of decisions in the context of real problems. Like simulations, they have the advantage of requiring active engagement, thought, and decision making. Case studies are most effective when the case is presented and participants are given time to work in teams to come up with recommendations before the “rest of the story” is revealed and discussed. The same caveats apply to case studies as to simulations. That is, they must be realistic and similar enough to the participants’ actual job needs that participants can see how to apply the lessons to their work. As with simulations, much of the value derived from a case study depends on the skill of the facilitator in drawing out the lessons and applications during the debriefing. Using several different case studies to illustrate the same principle positively affects learning transfer. Nadler, Thompson, and Van Boven (2003), for instance, found that participants who were taught negotiation principles using several analogous cases were three times more likely to transfer their knowledge than those taught using only a single context. Games Sivasailam Thiagarajan (Thiagi) is probably the best-known and strongest proponent of using games to teach, arguing that engagement is essential to learning and that games produce a higher level of engagement than most other modes of instruction. Thiagi is careful to distinguish between “fun” and “engagement.” The goal of games in instructional design is to enhance engagement, not “fun” as such (ASTD, 2000). Games aren’t a good medium for delivering information, but they can help participants develop memorable mental models that enable them to better respond to complex situations in the real world that entail similar patterns. While much of traditional instructional design focuses on delivering content effectively, instructional game design focuses on the behaviors the learners need and the information required to perform them.
CH003.indd 127
6/17/10 3:25:56 PM
128
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Thiagi makes the point that designing games is relatively easy; designing effective games is hard. The same caveats apply to games as to simulations: they need to be relevant to the business situation; they need to provide insight into the problem or issue; they need to be simple enough to highlight a specific lesson or consequence of an action, and yet not be so simplistic that participants dismiss them. Both games and simulations can be delivered effectively online as well as in person. Continuing advances in computer technology make it possible to create highly sophisticated and interactive online games and simulations. Unless planned and managed carefully, however, they can quickly degenerate into style over substance and actually obscure the main teaching points. As Judith Blair and Nancy Maresh of BrainWorks like to say, “Content is queen and context is king.” That is especially true when games are used to teach. e-Learning e-Learning, like classroom learning, encompasses a wide range of approaches and techniques that vary from highly engaging and instructive to mind-numbingly dull and ineffective. The technical capabilities of e-learning have the potential to make it especially effective for teaching people certain types of skills, as in the case of the simulations discussed above. But everything depends on the actual execution. Much of e-learning has failed to fulfill the hype of a few years ago—when pundits predicted that classrooms would disappear entirely—precisely because many programs have ignored the principles of relevance, utility, transferability, and practice. Simply converting a content-heavy, passive classroom learning experience to an online course does not improve its efficacy. While the periodic “quizzes” and self-checks typical of e-learning programs do require retrieval from memory, and therefore help foster retention, most fail to provide meaningful formative evaluation to help the learner improve his or her skills. That’s because the vast majority of the questions require only simple recall, whereas application to most jobs requires much higher-level cognitive and psychomotor skills (Shrock & Coscarelli, 2007). One other caveat regarding e-learning is worth mentioning. That relates to the issue of cognitive load. Cognitive load theory (Sweller, 1994) and numerous research studies illustrate that learning declines as the information processing demands on working memory increase (Clark, Nguyen, & Sweller, 2006). Instructional software and technology are now so powerful that it is easy to overwhelm the learner with too many simultaneous inputs (flash video, narration, text, and graphics all at once) so that understanding is actually impaired rather than enhanced. Action Learning Action learning would seem to be ideally suited to delivering for
application because it takes place in the context of real work. Its relevance and
CH003.indd 128
6/17/10 3:25:57 PM
Deliver for Application
129
utility should be immediately apparent and facilitate the transfer of the lessons learned to new challenges on the job. Smith and O’Neil (2003a, 2003b) summarize the key elements of action learning as follows: • Participants tackle real problems in small, stable learning groups. • The problems addressed are relevant to the participants’ workplace realities. • The groups meet periodically over time and participants take action between the meetings. • A collaborative learning process is followed that is based on mutual exploration, reflection, questioning, and constructive challenge. Numerous studies have demonstrated that, managed well, action learning can produce significant performance improvement. In part, as Kirwan (2009) points out, that is because “there is a large degree of overlap between the learning situation and the application situation, and so many of the barriers to transfer that might otherwise be in place are already dealt with” (p. 32). The downside of action learning is that, unless it is carefully managed, it quickly degenerates into simply another task in which learning takes a back seat to just getting the job done. Bolt expressed the concern that “the definition of action learning is getting broader and looser, with anything identified as projectoriented, experiential learning, or related to business problems being defined as action learning” (2005, p. 12). The learning component needs to be planned and executed with the same level of attention to detail as other forms of instruction. In particular, effective action learning requires guided reflection on lessons learned and facilitation that helps participants generalize from their specific problems to more broadly applicable principles and approaches.
Make It Memorable Retrieval of information from memory is essential at multiple points in the process of responding to a stimulus (Figure D3.7). Thus, the ability to recall the insights and skills gleaned from training is prerequisite to their adaptation and application. An important aspect of the Third Discipline, therefore, is to utilize instructional methods that enhance long-term memory and subsequent retrieval. This is especially important in preparing people for situations that they may not encounter for some time, such as difficult personnel issues, crisis management, leadership challenges and so forth. Such topics need to be presented in ways that are particularly memorable—so that they come immediately to mind much later during a crucial moment.
CH003.indd 129
6/17/10 3:25:57 PM
130
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D3.7.
GENERAL MODEL FOR THE ROLE OF MEMORY IN DIRECTING ACTION
Search memory for similar stimuli
Become aware of situation; direct attention to it
Retrieve relevant experiences, rules, and approaches from memory
Analyze and characterize situation
Retrieve the psychomotor skills needed to execute
Formulate plan of action
The research on human memory and learning is extensive—see, for example, reviews by Anderson (2010) and Medina (2008). New discoveries relevant to the craft of workplace learning continue to be made. In this section, we call attention to several findings that have specific bearing on improving people’s ability to recall what they have learned so that they are able to then apply it. These include: • • • • • •
Attention is essential, but limited Emotions matter Stories stick Repetition, especially at intervals, aids retention Connections count Learning requires reflection
Attention Is Essential, But Limited “The more attention the brain pays to a given stimulus, the more elaborately the information will be encoded—and retained” (Medina, 2008, p. 74). The problem that creates for corporate learning programs, however, is several-fold. First, humans can attend to only a very limited number of inputs at any given time. Second, attention is short-lived and easily diverted. Third, people don’t pay attention to boring things.
CH003.indd 130
6/17/10 3:25:57 PM
Deliver for Application
131
Multiple lines of evidence show that people can truly attend to only one or two input streams simultaneously. The issue appears to be a bottleneck in the processing of sensory input, rather than limits on the input as such (Anderson, 2010, p. 63). You know from your own experience that when you are truly attending an interesting conversation with someone at a crowded reception, you are able to “tune out” the other conversations occurring around you, even though many are clearly audible. Another example familiar to many learning professionals is the classic work of Simons and Chabris (1999). They showed that when people were asked to closely attend to a specific action in a video, over 50 percent completely failed to notice a man in a gorilla suit who walked into the center of the action and beat on his chest. The relevance to corporate learning is that participants cannot truly attend to the program if they are simultaneously reading their email or text messaging. The common practice of attempting to “multi-task” during webinars reduces the effectiveness of both the learning and the task, since there are demonstrable moments of mental “black-out” as attention shifts from one task to the other (Medina, 2008, p. 87). Compounding the problem of the bottleneck in the processing of input is the fact that attention is easily diverted. This is a special problem for knowledge workers, who need to be in what Csikszentmihalyi (1990) termed “the flow” to do their best work. The trouble is that it is not easy to get into “the flow.” It takes, on average, fifteen minutes for a knowledge worker to start working at maximum productivity. And it is very easy to be knocked out of the flow. Any number of distractions—phone calls, instant messages, email alerts, and so on—are sufficient to divert attention. Taking just one minute to answer a text message in effect costs sixteen minutes of high-productivity work. The same principle applies to learning. Frequent and unnecessary interruptions—including self-generated interruptions (“I’ ll just quickly check my inbox”)—disrupt the intense concentration needed to truly master a new topic or skill. In one study, for example, a single instance of a ringing cell phone demonstrably reduced the amount learned (McDonald, Wiczorek, & Walker, 2004). The point is that we need to minimize disruptions to maximize learning, and we need to educate learners on the cost of divided attention. What we attend to is affected by many factors, interest in particular. We find it easier to pay attention to things that interest us. Likewise, humans also are better able to remember items that they find personally interesting. Each of us knows someone who has a passion for some particular subject, sport, or hobby. Such people are able to recall information about their favorite topic—dates, names, statistics, and so forth—at a level of detail unimaginable to those who do not share the same passion. Their interests fuel their learning. The challenge for
CH003.indd 131
6/17/10 3:25:58 PM
132
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
corporate education is to create the same sort of passion for learning by making the relevance of the subject matter so compelling that it captures participants’ interest and, in turn, heightens their ability to attend to, absorb, and retain new learning (see Figure D3.8). Finally, the brain needs a break now and then. It is very difficult to truly attend to anything The brain needs a break for long periods. Medina (2008) feels strongly now and then. that the most common error in teaching is the tendency to overstuff students with information, with too little time allotted to “connecting the dots.” He recommends breaking all instruction into ten-minute segments because most learners’ attention begins to wander after ten or fifteen minutes. He suggested giving audiences a break from FIGURE D3.8.
LEARNING NEEDS TO BE RETAINED TO BE USEFUL
© Frank Cotham/Condé Nast Publications/www.cartoonbank.com. Used with permission.
CH003.indd 132
6/17/10 3:25:59 PM
Deliver for Application
133
the fire hose of information every ten minutes or so with some sort of “hook” that will get through to their executive control and recapture attention. Effective “hooks” have two characteristics: they are relevant to the topic and they evoke some sort of emotion—laughter, anxiety, disbelief, surprise, and so forth. Well-chosen stories and anecdotes can be especially effective. The point is that people have to first pay attention before they can learn and remember. So a key task of instruction is to capture, hold, and periodically recapture attention. Emotions Matter Why does Medina recommend that the periodic attention “hooks” involve some sort of emotion? Because emotions are extremely powerful at capturing attention and creating long-lasting memories. This is again something you know from your own experience; memories of traumatic or especially emotional events persist for years and are easily recalled, even when you would prefer to forget them. It turns out that all emotions—joy, sorrow, surprise—aid memory and recall. The reasons are beyond the scope of this book, but the practical application is that engaging participants’ emotions as well as their reason will help them remember information. That is why a surprising outcome to a simulation, an engaging game, or an amusing anecdote that underscores a point are powerful teaching devices. Stories Stick “Stories are easier to remember,” writes Daniel Pink in A Whole New Mind, “because, in many ways, stories are how we remember” (Pink, 2006, p. 101). In their superlative book, Influencer, about effecting lasting change, Patterson and colleagues (2008) underscore the power of stories this way: “A well-told narrative provides concrete and vivid detail rather than terse summaries and unclear conclusions. It changes people’s view of how the world works because it presents a plausible, touching, and memorable flow of cause and effect” (p. 59, emphasis added). Information is remembered more rapidly and in more detail when it is first presented as a story; it is also more persuasive (Martin & Power, 1982). The same information presented in story form is, surprisingly, considered also more believable than “just the facts.” Researchers presented MBA students with the same information in three different formats—verbal descriptions with facts and figures, charts and tables, and as a story involving a little old winemaker. “To the researchers’ surprise, when tested several weeks later, not only did those who heard the story recall more of the detail than the other two groups did (that
CH003.indd 133
6/17/10 3:26:00 PM
134
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
was predicted), but they also found the story more credible” (Patterson, Grenny, Maxfield, McMillan, & Switzler, 2008, p. 60). The finding was a surprise because most business people are acculturated to believe that hard-nosed analytical thinking with facts and data is what drives business. Obviously, good business decisions do require facts and data and sound analysis. But facts and data alone are not memorable, nor do they suffice to change behavior, which is what, at heart, most training initiatives seek to do. Writing in The Leader’s Guide to Storytelling, Stephen Denning explains: “At a time when corporate survival often requires transformational change, leadership involves inspiring people to act in unfamiliar and unwelcome ways. Mind numbing cascades of numbers or daze-inducing PowerPoint slides won’t achieve this goal. Even logical arguments for making the needed changes won’t do the trick. But effective storytelling often does” (Denning, 2005, p. 5). What’s the point? To make the message of training both compelling and memorable, encourage leaders and instructors to use stories to illustrate key lessons. The power of stories is the core concept behind 50Lessons, a company that specializes in capturing leaders’ stories in short, topical, memorable vignettes. Repetition Aids Retention The value of repetition to aid later recall has been known since Ebbinghaus’s classic studies in the late nineteenth century that differentiated long- and shortterm memory and showed how repetition could slow the rate of forgetting (Ebbinghaus, 1913). Revisiting the same topic at intervals enables learners to store information in a manner that facilitates long-term retrieval and makes the information more resistant to forgetting than a single presentation or non-spaced repetitions (Figure D3.9). What are the practical implications for corporate training and development? Returning to the same topic several times will increase its later recall, especially if these repetitions occur at intervals—for example, in both the Phase I preparation and again at various points of the Phase II instruction. In multi-day programs, starting each morning with a review of the prior day will help cement lessons learned. Charleen Allen, director of global learning and development at Baker Hughes, provides an example: “Reviewing each morning was handled differently than the usual review. We asked participants what one thing from the previous day resonated with them. By the time everyone shared, you had a review with the advantage of self-reflection included. By the third or fourth day of the program, these were deep, heart-felt revelations. I have never seen a better way to anchor the learning points to individuals emotionally” (Allen, 2008).
CH003.indd 134
6/17/10 3:26:00 PM
Deliver for Application
135
FIGURE D3.9. LEARNING AND FORGETTING WITH SPACED LEARNING
During Learning 100 80
Remembering on the Job
Spacing slows learning slightly But spacing makes learning more resistant to forgetting
60 40 20 0 During learning events, memory of information is strengthened
As soon as the learning event ends, forgetting begins Spaced learning Non-spaced, all-at-once learning
From Thalheimer, 2006. Copyright © 2006, Work-Learning Research. Used with permission.
For e-learning programs, shorter modules taken over a period of days or weeks are likely to produce more durable memory than those that can be completed in a single session. Finally, requiring participants to submit periodic progress reports post-training (see D4) and providing performance support tools (see D5) help ensure long-term, sustainable memories and skills (Figure D3.10). Jim Trinka of the Federal Aviation Administration, where lives depend on getting it right all the time, every time, explains: “The key to our training is repetition. There is no shortcut to repetition and practice. And so we repeat ourselves a lot and we practice over and over and over. Repetition is the key to competency for us” (personal communication, 2009). It’s also important to use multiple examples that illustrate the application of a principle, technique, or skill in different contexts. People are better able to abstract the relevant features of concepts when they are taught in multiple contexts rather than in just one (Gick & Holyoak, 1983). Using multiple examples helps learners generalize the knowledge and thus facilitates its transfer and application to novel situations (National Research Council, 2000).
CH003.indd 135
6/17/10 3:26:01 PM
136
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D3.10.
LEARNING AND FORGETTING WITH SPACED REPETITIONS ON THE JOB
During Learning 100 80
Remembering on the Job
Learning Curve
60 40 20
Forgetting Curve
0 Spaced learning on the job turns the forgetting curve into a learning-and-forgetting curve, improving memory. From Thalheimer, 2006. Copyright © 2006, Work-Learning Research. Used with permission.
Connections Count Usable knowledge is much more than mere lists of disconnected facts. Experts’ knowledge is connected to and organized around important, unifying concepts (National Research Council, 2000). Humans are better able to remember new information when it is linked to existing ideas, patterns, and knowledge already stored in long-term memory (Buzan & Buzan, 1993). Concepts that extend or enrich existing knowledge are much easier to recall—and therefore use—days, weeks, or months later than those that are free-standing or disconnected. The richer and more relevant the network of connections between new and existing knowledge, the easier it is to retrieve and use the new information appropriately. Elaborative rehearsal—thinking about or talking to others about an event (see Case in Point D3.3)—greatly strengthens its connections and the ability to recall it (Medina, 2008). A key difference between experts and novices is the richness of their mental schemas. “Schemas enable experts to categorize problems and consequently solve them. Novices, not possessing schemes, . . . have no alternative other than
CH003.indd 136
6/17/10 3:26:02 PM
Deliver for Application
137
Case in Point D3.3 Elaborative Rehearsal Glenn Hughes is director of global learning for KLA-Tencor, the world’s leading supplier of process control and yield management solutions for the semiconductor and related microelectronics industries. When we asked Glenn about what learning strategies have the highest payoff, he thought immediately of elaborative rehearsal. “I realized that that’s probably my preferred learning tool. People have often remarked at my memory and how I can remember the names of Japanese temples I went to twenty years ago. I can remember many movies, line for line and script for script. I remember courses, events, and conversations in much the same way, and I could never really understand why until I read about elaborative rehearsal. And then I realized that the first thing I do when I walk out of a learning experience is I go and explain it to someone. “I literally walk out, I come home and I tell my wife, ‘Hey! I was just at this class today, here’s what I learned.’ And bang, bang, bang, I go through it. That weekend, when I call my dad I tell him, ‘This is really an interesting class,’ and then I tell him about slide:ology or the 6Ds or whatever I was just learning about. I’ll come into work and I’ll get out my pen and I’ll diagram it on the board and tell my colleagues what it was I just learned. “And people challenge me and ask me questions; they force me to be clear about my thinking. They bring their own applications. And of course, the whole while I’m telling them about it, I’m tapping it into experiences that the two of us have in common. So I’ll say, ‘Hey, you know, remember three months ago when we were talking to this leader and he said . . . Well, I think I might have found the answer.’ “That’s the sort of web I weave within, say, forty-eight hours of any critical learning experience. I weave this web that involves a lot of other people and even different media and tools, how it relates one idea to another. And what’s interesting is from that network of people, the number of application points multiplies exponentially, because they all see ways that it can be used too. And so, then it becomes very easy to take something or apply it and have some reinforcement in the environment. “So that’s probably the most important thing I do when I come out of a learning experience. It is the action I take—the fact that I go through this whole elaborative rehearsal process.”
to engage in general search techniques” (Cooper, 1990). Thus, helping participants see the relationships between new topics and what they already know strengthens the staying power of what they have just learned and improves their ability to apply it. But it takes time and effort for participants to forge their own connections between the new material, what they already know, and how they might use it. We recommend having the facilitator encourage people to “connect the dots.” A useful exercise is to stop periodically and ask participants to write down their insights and ideas for application in a learning journal, action planning sheet, or other similar device. An example is shown in Figure D3.11.
CH003.indd 137
6/17/10 3:26:02 PM
138
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
FIGURE D3.11. AN EXAMPLE OF A WORKSHEET TO HELP PARTICIPANTS LINK NEW WITH EXISTING KNOWLEDGE
Connections and Applications Worksheet A key concept from this session is:
How it reinforces things I already knew:
How I can use it in my work:
It causes me to reconsider:
Related program concepts include:
What the benefits will be:
Copyright © 2010 Fort Hill Company. Used with permission.
The act of writing down ideas for application (rather than just being asked to think casually about them) is important; it requires deeper thought and begins the process of personal ownership. Since each person’s “mind map” is unique, the connections that a person creates himself or herself are the most powerful. It is nevertheless valuable to ask a few participants to share their insights and ideas for application. Publicly stating a plan deepens the owner’s commitment. It also gives other participants additional ideas for their own application and, as a side benefit, enriches the instructor’s reservoir of relevant examples. Learning Requires Reflection Forum Corporation convened a panel of leading corporate educators and executive coaches to formulate principles to guide corporate education. In their report, Principles of Workplace Learning, the panel concluded that a best practice was alternating periods of action and reflection. The problem is that “when we are faced with little time and an urgent need for results, we sacrifice reflection for action. But reflection is the motor that propels the cycle—without it, learning slows or stops completely” (Atkinson & Davis, 2003, p. 25).
CH003.indd 138
6/17/10 3:26:03 PM
Deliver for Application
139
Setting aside time for reflection, however, runs counter to the pressure to reduce training time and also to an instructor’s natural zeal to transmit as much information as possible; the temptation is to fill every waking moment of a program with activity and instruction. This “sausage stuffer” approach to corporate education, by eliminating time for reflection and practice, is counterproductive. Reflection is essential to build the mental schemata that differentiate experts from novices. Prompting Reflection is the motor— guided reflection during learning (Phase II) as well without it, learning stops. as transfer (Phase III) is important to the elaborative rehearsal that makes learning sticky and useful. Leo Burke, director of executive education for the University of Notre Dame, believes that the emphasis on values and on reflection are key to the success of Notre Dame’s innovative Integral Leadership program (see Case in Point D3.4).
Case in Point D3.4 Reflection in Leadership Education The University of Notre Dame’s Integral Leadership program is a comprehensive approach to leadership development that incorporates individual and collective perspectives as well as internal and external points of view. According to Leo Burke (personal communication, 2005), associate dean and director of executive education, its success is a result of “the holistic nature of the program. In particular, we have built in a more substantive reflective dimension than one would normally find in leadership programs.” Prior to attending the five-day intense, residential portion of the program, participants submit a strategic business issue, threat, problem, or opportunity and complete a customized 360-degree assessment. During the week-long session, participants use a structured problem-solving and journaling process that requires them to explore their values, their organization’s values, and societal or more market-related factors, and then look for areas of alignment and misalignment. “To really get a grasp of that, participants need time to reflect in this exploration process, so we build that in each day,” says Burke. “In addition, there are coaching sessions that also give people pause for reflection as well. “We relate all of this back to their business issue. So let’s not talk about changed behavior in the abstract, let’s talk about it with relation to the issue that you have selected. What are you going to do differently with regard to this issue that you were not going to do prior to coming into this program? And that becomes the litmus test for whether people are really serious about change. One of the key themes we emphasize is that you have a choice in terms of your response to the situation; it is your responsibility.” Is it working? In follow-up telephone interviews, 95 percent of the participants were extremely satisfied and many rated it as the best leadership program they had ever attended. Most important, they were able to cite specific examples of how they had used what they had learned to make significant improvements to their businesses and personal lives.
CH003.indd 139
6/17/10 3:26:03 PM
140
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
The most effective programs, in our experience, are those that stop after each key learning segment and give participants time to reflect and make connections. Agilent considers time for reflection one of the most important parts of every exercise in their Managing at Agilent course and provides participants with four questions to help guide the process (Girone & Cage, 2009): • • • •
I hadn’t realized before that . . . I hadn’t considered before that . . . I hadn’t thought before that . . . I hadn’t noticed before that . . .
Other useful reflection questions include: “How could you use what we have just covered to improve performance in your area of responsibility?” and “What specific actions could you take to put this learning to use?” These not only help participants relate the learning to their specific circumstances, but also reinforce the importance and expectation for practical application. Learning professionals need to protect time for reflection against the urge to stuff in more content. As Fred Harburg, writing about corporate training and development, put it: “If there is not time for reflection, there is almost no chance for improvement” (2004, p. 21).
Prepare for Transfer The final aspect of delivering for application is to structure the learning experience in such a way that the participants are prepared and looking forward to using what they learned. We have already discussed the importance of setting expectations for transfer as part of Phase I and communicating the plan and timeline for assessing achievement (Phase IV). Preparing for transfer also includes goal setting, action planning, and getting ready for re-entry. Goal Setting If the program has been successful in motivating employees to want to learn, and the delivery has taught them how, then the third precondition for generating results is having opportunities to practice their new knowledge and skills while they are still fresh. An important first step in that process is to be sure that each participant has specific goals for learning transfer and application. Many programs already include a goal-setting exercise in which participants are asked to set specific objectives to apply what they have learned. Ideally, the process should begin in Phase I. For example, building on Brinkerhoff ’s concept
CH003.indd 140
6/17/10 3:26:04 PM
Deliver for Application
141
of “learner intentionality” (Brinkerhoff & Apking, 2001, p. 88), Plastipak’s High Impact Learning Job Aid for Supervisors provides step-by-step guidance for preparing the learner that includes asking the associates’ thoughts about the business goals, key results, on-the-job behaviors, and key skills they need the most; the outcome is an agreement between the manager and associate on the learning focus and a personal learning “roadmap.” Associates are then expected to bring their learning roadmaps to the training along with their other required preparatory work. Similarly, Phase I for Pfizer’s Advance Transition program includes having each participant meet with her or his manager to identify top priorities. Chubb facilitates a meeting between participants and managers (see Case in Point D5.2). In our experience, however, such programs are exceptions. Goal setting is usually left until the end of Phase II and is frequently weak in otherwise superlative programs, resulting in poorly articulated, half-hearted, often trivial goals that no one takes seriously. Such inadequate attention to setting objectives for transfer and application can seriously compromise a program’s full potential. Participants’ learning objectives need to be treated with the same seriousness as their business objectives, because they are, in effect, business objectives, the whole rationale of training being to support the greater business goals. Goals Learning objectives need to for using learning should be planned, be treated with the same executed, tracked, and rewarded with the seriousness as business same degree of attention as other perforobjectives. mance metrics. Unfortunately, in most organizations, learning transfer objectives are still seen as distinct from business objectives and of lesser importance. The problem usually begins with their creation. The most common problems with writing learning transfer objectives and recommended solutions are presented in Table D3.3. Each is discussed below. Problem 1: Not Enough Time For obvious reasons, final goal setting cannot be done until all the main topics have been covered. Accordingly, the goal-setting and application-planning exercise is usually scheduled at the very end of the course. The first cause of poor transfer and application goals is failure to schedule enough time for this segment. It takes significant time and effort to develop a good set of objectives and an implementation plan. This is as true for learning transfer objectives as it is for other business objectives. The short time scheduled for goal setting and application planning is often further compromised. Educational programs tend to fall behind schedule;
CH003.indd 141
6/17/10 3:26:04 PM
142
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
TABLE D3.3. COMMON PROBLEMS WITH GOAL SETTING AND RECOMMENDED SOLUTIONS Problem
Solutions
1. Not enough time
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4
2. No quality control
2.1 Review the goals 2.2 Send the goals to the manager
3. Writing strong goals is hard
3.1 Provide a structure 3.2 Provide examples 3.3 Have participants share their goals
Start earlier Allocate enough time to begin with Stay on schedule Provide preset goals for application
facilitators are, understandably, reluctant to cut off a particularly fruitful or interesting discussion just to stay on schedule. When subject-matter experts are the presenters, they find it hard to resist the urge to elaborate (something we struggle with in our own workshops) and often go over their allotted time. As a result, some of the time set aside for goal setting and action planning is used to cover the last few topics. In addition, some participants inevitably leave early, especially in open-enrollment programs. They may miss the planning exercise entirely, and their parting farewells disrupt the group, further consuming the limited time available. The time constraints imposed on corporate training and development are real and likely to intensify; managers are increasingly asking for shorter courses to reduce employees’ time out of the office. Under such pressures, the temptation is to eliminate goal setting and action planning as part of the curriculum and expect participants to complete them later. Experience proves this to be a poor tradeoff. Every time we have acceded to requests to allow participants to set their objectives after the course, the results have been unsatisfactory; fewer than half ever do, despite repeated requests. Participants’ day-to-day work simply overwhelms even the best intentions. To receive the maximum benefit from training and development experiences, participants should not be allowed to leave the formal coursework without clear and compelling goals for application. Anything less impedes transfer and increases the amount of “learning scrap.” Solution 1.1: Start Earlier Thinking about learning transfer objectives is most
effective when it begins in Phase I because it fosters learning intentionality, which has multiple benefits in terms of motivation, commitment, and value derived (Brinkerhoff & Apking, 2001). Participants should be encouraged to meet with their
CH003.indd 142
6/17/10 3:26:05 PM
Deliver for Application
143
managers to discuss what business goals the learning will advance; what behaviors (performance of tasks) need to be strengthened, changed, added, or deleted; and why these are important to both individual performance and business success. As we will discuss in greater detail in D5, both managers and participants should be provided with guidelines for that discussion and provided with easy-to-use forms and processes. Suggested outlines, worksheets, and examples are available in Getting Your Money’s Worth from Training and Development (Jefferson, Pollock, & Wick, 2009); a learning management system (LMS)–compatible version is also available. Start the goal-setting process earlier in the course itself. Build in short, specific times for reflection after each major topic or segment. Encourage learners to think about what they have just learned and write down their ideas for how they might apply their new knowledge and skills to improve their performance and that of their unit. The time spent in such short, focused periods of reflection is recaptured by making the final objective-setting process more efficient; participants can review the objectives they set in Phase I and the ideas they captured as the learning progressed, then select the most valuable to define as the specific targets of their post-course follow-through. Another way to reduce the class time required for setting goals is to have participants create a first draft as a homework assignment on the night before the last session. That way, class time can be devoted to discussion and refinement rather than to initial conceptualization. Solution 1.2: Allocate Enough Time to Begin With The second part of a solution
is to be sure that enough time is allocated for goal setting and action planning to begin with. How much is enough? That depends on the nature, length, and complexity of the course, whether the goals are individual or team-based, and how much preliminary work (reflecting on potential application) has been done. For an in-depth course, an hour is needed to generate high-quality goals and initial action plans, more if they are team-based. The best test for whether enough time has been allotted is for the designers to try to complete the actual exercise to see how long it takes and the quality of the work they produce. Providing too little time sends the wrong signal. It undermines the importance of goal setting, since it suggests that even the instructional designers did not take it seriously or really expect it to be done. Solution 1.3: Stay on Time Staying on time is hard—we know—but it is vital.
Having enough time set aside in the agenda is of no value unless it is respected. Allowing other sessions to run over so that goal setting and action planning are compromised sends the wrong message: it implies that content is more important than application, when quite the opposite is true in terms of business results.
CH003.indd 143
6/17/10 3:26:05 PM
144
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
If portions of the course chronically run overtime, it suggests a flaw in the fundamental design: too little time was allocated originally for the material or exercises. The solution is to consciously revise the program plan, not to skip goal setting. The design team needs to reexamine and adjust the number of topics and the time allotments as part of a continuous improvement effort. It also may be useful to appoint an impartial timekeeper to remind the facilitators of approaching stop times. Solution 1.4: Preset Goals for Application In theory, participants should have
greater ownership and commitment to goals they set themselves, especially for leadership or other personal development programs. But if the program has a clear and relatively narrow focus, or if management has specific expectations for post-course actions and results, then it may be both more efficient and more efficacious to simply let participants know what those are rather than having them try to re-create what the designers had in mind. That’s what Charleen Allen, director of global learning and development at Baker Hughes, did for the Sales Organization Leadership Development (SOLD) program. Because there were very specific things participants needed to do to drive a culture of effective account ownership following training, Charleen developed three goals that were common for all participants rather than having them create their own. “This helped us drive a common culture and common skill sets based on the course objectives,” she explained (Allen, 2008). A web-based learning transfer management system (Friday5s) was used to ensure that participants followed through on these objectives. As a result, Charleen and her team were able to document positive outcomes in the areas of the greatest importance to the business. Research has shown that both assigned and participant-specified goals are efficacious in helping maintain new behaviors post-training (Wexley & Baldwin, 1986). Whichever approach is used, the most important thing is to make expectations and timelines clear. Problem 2: No Quality Control Even if enough time is allocated to goal setting and action planning, it isn’t worth much unless the process generates meaningful objectives (1) that are related to the business needs the course was designed to address, and (2) that the participants are truly committed to accomplishing. It is surprising, given the importance of setting strong goals, that so few programs include any kind of quality-assurance process. Each year, we process more than fifty thousand objectives from a wide range of corporate training and development programs. We are surprised by how many
CH003.indd 144
6/17/10 3:26:06 PM
Deliver for Application
145
are weak or bear no apparent relationship to the business or the program. A few real examples will suffice: • “ Lose ten pounds ” (after a three - day, $ 4,000 leadership program at Gettysburg). • “Read a book on management” (following a multi-day leadership development program for high-potential candidates). • “Be a better listener.” Such objectives are unlikely to produce meaningful transfer or business impact. If they were to become known to management as representative of the output of training, then the program’s efficacy (and likely its future) would be called into question. Either the program failed to help participants understand how to apply the material to the work of the firm or it allowed them to make a mockery of the objective-setting exercise. Whatever the case may be, low-quality objectives reflect badly on the program, the instructors, and the participants; they represent a serious breakdown in the learning process. Solution 2.1: Review the Goals One of the first and simplest steps to improve the quality of post-course objectives is for learning professionals to actually review them (or at least a sample of them). Surprisingly, this is not common. Indeed, most learning organizations have no idea what kinds of objectives participants are setting, nor, for that manner, do their managers (see discussion below). Imagine how absurd it would sound if the same process—or, rather, lack of process—were applied to other business functions: if the sales department had no idea what an individual salesperson’s targets were, or if the research department did not know what its scientists were working toward. No business enterprise could succeed if it allowed its managers to set their own business goals and then file them away without ever reviewing them with anyone. But that is precisely what happens with most learning and development objectives. Small wonder most participants do not take the process seriously. Copies of participants’ learning transfer objectives can be obtained in any number of ways. Goal forms can be collected, copied, and returned before the end of the program. Carbonless NCR forms could be used for writing goals and a copy left with the instructor. If privacy is an issue, names could be omitted from the copies, since the purpose is to analyze the overall goal quality and alignment, rather than specific individuals’ objectives. We personally favor electronic learning transfer management systems because once the goals are in electronic form they can be utilized for communication (see discussion below) as well as analysis.
CH003.indd 145
6/17/10 3:26:06 PM
146
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
However they are obtained, the participants’ goals (or for very large programs, a sample of the goals) should be reviewed by learning professionals to determine their quality and whether they are in alignment with the business objectives of the program. Basarab (in press) recommends establishing criteria and a success rate for acceptable goals in advance and then reviewing the goals from each iteration of the program to ensure that they meet the quality standards. The core concept is that intention precedes adoption, which is prerequisite to results (Figure D3.12). If you don’t start with the right intention, then the odds of getting the desired results are low. If the If you don’t start with the right percent of acceptable goals falls below the preintention, the odds of getting determined success rate, then the program needs results are low. to be revisited and adjusted since it is failing to produce the desired intent. Electronic learning transfer management systems (which are discussed in more detail in D4) allow learning professionals to efficiently review both the quality and the distribution of a very large number of goals (Figure D3.13). Knowing the distribution of participants’ objectives allows the learning organization to adjust emphasis as necessary to ensure objectives are congruent with the most important business needs. A striking example of why this is important is a client who had planned and conducted a several-day program on change management. When the learning team reviewed the participants’ objectives, however, they discovered that fewer than one in ten were actually concerned with change management. Clearly there was a disconnect: either the program’s message was not getting through or the program did not address the most pressing issues perceived by participants. Adjustments were made to the program’s focus and presentation. Had learning and development not reviewed the participants’ transfer objectives, they might have continued offering the same program, oblivious to the misalignment.
FIGURE D3.12. THE PREDICTIVE EVALUATION MODEL, WHICH STRESSES THE IMPORTANCE OF GOALS (INTENT) New skills, knowledge, and beliefs from training
INTENTION (goals)
ADOPTION (actions, transfer)
IMPACT on performance
Copyright © 2010 V.A.L.E. Consulting. Used with permission.
CH003.indd 146
6/17/10 3:26:06 PM
Deliver for Application
147
FIGURE D3.13. ELECTRONIC LEARNING TRANSFER MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS FACILITATE REVIEWING THE DISTRIBUTION AND QUALITY OF A LARGE NUMBER OF GOALS
Distribution of 1,455 Participants’ Managing@Agilent Goals Situational Leadership 29%
Improving Team Performance 19%
Other 1% Performance Planning and Development 9% Giving and Receiving Feedback 13%
Business Knowledge 4%
Setting Clear Priorities and Expectations 25%
From Roche, Wick, and Stewart, 2005. Used with permission.
Solution 2.2: Send the Goals to Managers The second solution to making sure that learning transfer objectives are treated more seriously is to send a copy of each participant’s goals to his or her manager. Just as business objectives must be discussed with one’s boss and mutually agreed on, so should learning objectives. Yet discussions of learning objectives between supervisors and their direct reports happen far less frequently than either management or learning directors suppose, despite clear evidence of the importance and benefit of such discussions (Brinkerhoff & Montesino, 1995; Gregoire, Propp, & Poertner, 1998). The magnitude of the problem was evident in a study we did in collaboration with a leading technology company. The course represented a significant
CH003.indd 147
6/17/10 3:26:07 PM
148
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
investment for the department and the participants. The sponsoring department was billed $2,500 per participant, each of whom spent a full five days out of the office. Participants were encouraged to discuss their objectives with their managers. Yet when we polled the participants’ managers three months after the program, fewer than half reported that they knew what their direct reports’ post-program objectives were (Figure D3.14). It is hard to see how managers can provide the needed support, coaching, reinforcement, and opportunities to use new knowledge and skills when they have no idea what their direct reports are trying to accomplish. To address the issue, the client instituted an electronic learning transfer management system that automatically sent each manager a copy of his or her direct reports’ goals. Thereafter, 100 percent of the managers reported that they were aware of their direct reports’ objectives. More importantly, the number of discussions between managers and their reports about the program more than doubled, the amount of effort spent on learning transfer increased, and the managers’ ratings of post-program improvement also increased. The other salutary effect of sending managers a copy of their direct reports’ goals is that the quality of the goals improves. If participants know that their objectives will be sent to their managers, they put a lot more quality thought into their objectives than when they know the objectives are just going to be put on the shelf. The first time that Hewlett-Packard introduced participants to the idea that their goals would be sent to their managers, there was a stunned silence. After an FIGURE D3.14. MANAGERS’ AWARENESS OF THEIR DIRECT REPORTS’ LEARNING TRANSFER OBJECTIVES BEFORE AND AFTER INSTITUTING A TRANSFER MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
% of Managers
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% Before
CH003.indd 148
After
6/17/10 3:26:08 PM
Deliver for Application
149
appropriate pause, the learning director quipped, “I guess that changes the way you will write them, doesn’t it?” Based on our experiences of the past ten years, we now recommend to all our clients that they send a copy of each participant’s goals to his or her manager and that this be done automatically, rather than left to individual initiative. We have found that exhorting participants to share their goals with their managers is not as effective as simply sending them. Obviously, this is more easily accomplished with an electronic transfer management system, but it can also be done by making an extra copy of paper-based forms. In the rare instances in which a developmental goal is truly personal or is related to an issue involving the manager, it may make sense to allow individuals to designate one (but not all) goals as “private” (non-shared). Because managers can provide (or deny) opportunities to put new knowledge to work, they need to be informed not only of the overall business objectives of the training, but also their direct reports’ personal objectives. Absent such knowledge, managers are less able to create opportunities and coach, with the result that much of the knowledge will be lost and the program may fail to deliver the desired results. If you send managers their direct reports’ goals, it is helpful to also provide them guidance on how to evaluate the goals and how to coach for optimal performance. A suggested rubric and process are provided in Getting Your Money’s Worth from Training and Development for Managers (Jefferson, Pollock, & Wick, 2009, p. 37). Problem 3: Writing Strong Goals Is Hard A third reason that learning transfer and application goals are often weak is that writing good objectives is more difficult than generally supposed. Course designers usually assume that because most participants have experience with management by objectives, they know how to write good objectives. Our analysis indicates otherwise; indeed, some of the weakest objectives are from the most senior managers. Going over the SMART acronym in class does not seem to make a great deal of difference. A number of the programs in our database included a discussion or handout on SMART goals (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound—or some variation thereof). There is no evidence that the goals from these groups are consistently better than those in which SMART was not discussed. It is not clear whether the root cause is that participants have heard about SMART so often that they find it mind-numbing and tune out, or whether not enough time or guidance was allocated to assess the goals against the SMART criteria.
CH003.indd 149
6/17/10 3:26:09 PM
150
The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning
Whatever the cause, a high percentage of the goals set following learning and development programs are not specific, quantifiable, business-related, or timebound. Such goals do not reflect well on the course or the participants and are unlikely to lead to meaningful effort and results. Given the importance of “intent,” improving the quality of the objectives set in corporate education programs will improve learning transfer, business impact, and return on investment. Solution 3.1: Provide a Structure In our experience, giving participants a template to follow has been much more effective than presenting SMART or other models for goal setting. The template should guide the participants to specify what they will do, by when, why, and how they will know. (See Exhibit D3.2.) Such a template is a simple performance support tool that enables your participants to craft goals that meet the SMART criteria without having to spend time on another ineffective discussion of the model. This is similar to the structured essay concept in academic education. Traditional essay questions present students with a topic to discuss but provide little or no guidance on how to do so. Each student approaches the topic in a different way. As a result, it is difficult for the instructor to know whether a student failed to discuss a specific topic because he thought it was unimportant or because he knew nothing about it and so avoided mentioning it. The solution is to give students an outline of the topics to discuss, thus structuring the essay for them and ensuring greater uniformity and completeness. Providing a template for learning transfer goals achieves the same benefit; it gives form to the participants’ objectives and ensures that each contains the key elements of a strong and actionable objective: a specific target, time frame, rationale, and measur