The Lure of Illustration in the Nineteenth Century
Also by Laurel Brake NINETEENTH-CENTURY SERIALS EDITION ENCOUNTERS...
89 downloads
1983 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Lure of Illustration in the Nineteenth Century
Also by Laurel Brake NINETEENTH-CENTURY SERIALS EDITION ENCOUNTERS IN THE VICTORIAN PRESS: Editors, Authors, Readers (co-editor with Julie Codell) WALTER PATER: Transparencies of Desire (co-editor with Lesley Higgins and Carolyn Williams) PRINT IN TRANSITION: Studies in Media and Book History NINETEENTH-CENTURY MEDIA AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF IDENTITIES (co-editor with Bill Bell and David Finkelstein) THE ENDING OF EPOCHS (editor) WALTER PATER SUBJUGATED KNOWLEDGES: Journalism, Gender and Literature PATER IN THE 1990S (co-editor with Ian Small) INVESTIGATING VICTORIAN JOURNALISM (co-editor with Aled Jones & Lionel Madden)
Also by Marysa Demoor THEIR FAIR SHARE: Women, Power and Criticism in the Athenaeum, from Millicent Garrett Fawcett to Katherine Mansfield, 1870–1920 MARKETING THE AUTHOR: Authorial Personae, Narrative Selves and Self-Fashioning, 1880–1930 (editor) CHARLES V IN CONTEXT: The Making of a European Identity (co-editor with Marc Boone) EDITING THE TEXT (co-editor with Geert Lernout & Sylvia Van Peteghem) DEAR STEVENSON: The Letters of Andrew Lang to Robert Louis Stevenson (editor)
The Lure of Illustration in the Nineteenth Century Picture and Press
Edited by
Laurel Brake and
Marysa Demoor
Introduction, selection and editorial matter © Laurel Brake & Marysa Demoor 2009 Individual chapters © contributors 2009 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6-10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2009 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin's Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN-13: 978–0–230–21731–7 hardback ISBN-10: 0–230–21731–1 hardback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The lure of illustration in the nineteenth century : picture and press / edited by Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978–0–230–21731–7 1. Magazine illustration – England – History – 19th century. I. Brake, Laurel, 1941– II. Demoor, Marysa. NC978.L87 2009 741.695094109034—dc22 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 09 Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
2008030137
To the Royal Flemish Academy of Belgium for Science and the Arts for their many-faceted support of Belgo-British collaboration
This page intentionally left blank
Contents List of Illustrations
ix
Notes on Contributors
xiii
Chronology
xvi
Introduction: The Lure of Illustration Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
1
Part I 1800–1840s: Images in Diverse Textual Environments 1
2
3
4
The Illuminated Magazine and the Triumph of Wood Engraving Brian Maidment Accurate Dreams or Illustrations of Desire: Image and Text in the Gardener’s Magazine (1826–44) Edited by John Claudius Loudon Sarah Dewis
17
40
Alaric ‘Attila’ Watts, the Fraser’s Portrait Gallery, and William Maginn David E. Latané, Jr.
60
‘The Original to the Life’: Portraiture and the Northern Star Malcolm Chase
76
Part II Mid-Century Graphics: Fiction, Fashion, Labour and Layout 5
6
Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in Dickens’s The Old Curiosity Shop Beryl Gray Elizabeth Gaskell: Journalism and Letters Joanne Shattock
vii
97
119
viii
7
8
9
10
Contents
Among the Unknown Public: Household Words, All the Year Round and the Mass-Market Weekly Periodical in the Mid-Nineteenth Century Lorna Huett Often Taken Where a Tract Is Refused: T.B. Smithies, the British Workman, and the Popularisation of the Religious and Temperance Message Frank Murray Seductive Visual Studies: Scientific Focus and Editorial Control in The Woman in White and All the Year Round Laurie Garrison Depicting Gentlemen’s Fashions in the Tailor and Cutter, 1866–1900 Christopher Kent
128
149
168
184
Part III The 1890s: Changing Faces, Changing Technologies 11 Science and the Timeliness of Reproduced Photographs in the Late Nineteenth-Century Periodical Press James Mussell 12
Aestheticism on the Cheap: Decorative Art, Art Criticism, and Cheap Paper in the 1890s Linda K. Hughes
13 Putting Women in the Boat in the Idler (1892–1898) and TO-DAY (1893–1897) Anne Humpherys 14
Images of Englishness: The Daily Chronicle and ‘Proposed Laureates’ to Succeed Tennyson Edward H. Cohen
203
220
234
251
Bibliography
264
Index
275
Illustrations Figures 0.1 Theodore Maurisset, La Daguerreotypomanie, La Caricature, December 1839 1.1 Three coloured wood engraved title page to the Illuminated Magazine vol. 1, 1843 1.2 John Leech. Engraved illustration to ‘Tom Houlaghan’s Guardian Sprite’, the Illuminated Magazine vol. II, March 1844, 241 1.3 Ebenezer Landells. Wood engraved title page to a monthly issue of the Illuminated Magazine vol. II, December 1843, 55 1.4 W.H. Prior. Wood engraved illustration to ‘Broad Lea Farm’, the Illuminated Magazine vol. IV, January 1845, 125 1.5 Kenny Meadows. Wood engraved illustration to ‘The Philosophy of the Pistol’, the Illuminated Magazine, vol. 1, July 1843, 173 1.6 H.G. Hine. Wood engraved illustration to ‘The Monster City’, the Illuminated Magazine, vol. III, September 1844, 286 1.7 Kenny Meadows. Wood engraved illustration to ‘Death and the Drawing Room’, the Illuminated Magazine, vol. I, June 1843, 97 2.1 Front page, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 633. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200 2.2 ‘View from the Drawingroom Window at Cheshunt Cottage, looking to the Left’, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 634. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200 2.3 Work areas plan of Cheshunt Cottage, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 642–43. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200 2.4 Estate plan of Cheshunt Cottage, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 656–57. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200 2.5 ‘General View of the Hot-houses, as seen across the American Garden’, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 646. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200 2.6 ‘Rustic Covered Seat of Woodwork’, ‘Elevation of the Back’, elevation of ‘part of the front’ of a hothouse, and cross section ‘through the middle of one of the ridges of the roof’, ix
3 24
25 26 32
34 35
37 44
46
48–49
50–51
54
x
Illustrations
3.1 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6
5.7
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 9.1
9.2
Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 660–61. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200 ‘Alaric A. Watts: The Editor of “The Literary Souvenir”’. Fraser’s Magazine, June 1835, 653 Feargus O’Connor, Northern Star, December 1840 John Frost, Northern Star, September–November 1839 Richard Oastler, Northern Star, February 1840 Peter McDouall, Northern Star, Autumn 1840 Woodcut of Peter McDouall from the Charter, 7 April 1839 Hablot Knight Browne, [‘Quilp mocking the dog’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum Hablot Knight Browne (Phiz), [‘Quilp assails the effigy’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum George Cattermole, [‘The Sandboys chimney corner’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum Hablot Knight Browne (Phiz), [‘Jerry and his dogs’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum George Cruikshank, ‘Sikes attempting to destroy his dog’: Oliver Twist (1837–39). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum Hablot Knight Browne (Phiz), Frontispiece for Master Humphrey’s Clock vol. II (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum Hablot Knight Browne (Phiz), [‘Quilp at the tavern window’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum The British Workman and Friend of the Sons of Toil, No. 1 February 1855, 1 The British Workman and Friend of the Sons of Toil, No. 34 October 1857, 133 The British Workman, No. 269 May 1877, 13 The Cottager and Artisan, No. 217 January 1879, 1 The British Workwoman, Out and at Home No. 316 January 1890, 25 Opening page of The Woman in White, All the Year Round (November 1859). Reproduced with permission from the British Library Postscript by a sincere friend. All the Year Round (April 1860). Reproduced with permission from the British Library
56–57 62 77 79 81 82 87
100
102
106
107
108
111
113 157 158 163 164 165
170 174
Illustrations
9.3
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 11.1
11.2
11.3
11.4
11.5 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 14.1
Jane Morris seated, leading forward. Albumen print by Emery Walker from the photograph by John Robert Parsons. Reproduced with permission from Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery James Mundella M.P. (l.) Thomas Hughes M.P. (r) Tailor and Cutter, 14 July 1871 Highly patterned double-breasted reefer jacket with high cutaway and dittoes. Tailor and Cutter, 7 July 1871 H.R.H. the Prince of Wales wearing a double-breasted frock coat. Tailor and Cutter, 13 June 1895 Patterned waistcoat with lapels. Tailor and Cutter, 6 June 1895 ‘Region of the Milky Way to the South-west of the Trifid Nebula’, Knowledge, 13 July 1890, facing p. 174. By permission of the British Library, pp. 1447.bb ‘Domestic Pests: the Common Flea (pulex irritanis)’, from an original by the Direct Photo Eng. Co. Ltd, in Knowledge, 13 January 1890, facing 41. By permission of the British Library, pp. 1447.bb ‘Lord Kelvin’, ‘Portraits of Celebrities at Different Times of their Lives’, Strand Magazine, 5 June 1893, p. 590. Special Collections, Senate House Library, University of London Page from ‘Illustrated Interviews’, Strand Magazine, 12 October 1896, p. 381. University of Birmingham Main Library Page from ‘Curiosities’, Strand Magazine, 12 July 1896, p. 240. University of Birmingham Main Library Graham R. Tomson, ‘Henry Muhrman’, Scottish Art Review, July 1889: 37. National Library of Scotland Cover, Art Weekly, 10 May 1890. National Library of Scotland ‘Art Gossip’, Morning Leader, 8 October 1892, 3 (detail) ‘Art Gossip’, Morning Leader, 8 October 1892, 3 (detail) Oscar Wilde, ‘The Unity of the Arts: A Lecture and “a Five O’Clock,”’ Pall Mall Gazette, 12 December 1887, 13. National Library of Scotland ‘The Idler’s Club’, Idler, vol. 1 (February 1892) ‘The Man of the Future’, Idler, vol. 6 (September 1894) ‘An Idler’, Idler, vol. 10 (August 1896) Volume Title Page, Idler, vol. 11 (February–July 1897) Cover after sale to J.M. Dent, Idler (August 1898) ‘The Late Lord Tennyson’, London Daily Chronicle, 8 October 1892, 3. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL 07F00283P
xi
177 190 192 195 199
208
210
212
215 216 223 225 228 229
231 235 241 244 245 247
252
xii Illustrations
14.2
‘Proposed Laureates’, London Daily Chronicle, 7 November 1892, 3. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL 07F00283P
254
Tables 7.1
Circulation of periodicals within the period 1800–1870, as applicable 7.2 A survey of periodicals of the year 1850 (or nearest available date), based on format, efficiency and the printed area of each sheet
135
140
Contributors Laurel Brake is Emeritus Professor at Birkbeck, University of London. Her research interests are in print culture, gender, computing in the humanities, and Walter Pater. With Marysa Demoor, she has edited the Dictionary of Nineteenth-Century Journalism (DNCJ, 2008). Other publications include the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (www.ncse.ac.uk) with Jim Mussell, Suzanne Paylor, and Mark Turner (2008), Print in Transition (2001), and Subjugated Knowledges (1994). Malcolm Chase is Reader in Labour History at the University of Leeds. He has published widely on the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century social history. His books include Early Trade Unionism: Fraternity, Skill and the Politics of Labour (2000) and Chartism: A New History (2007). Edward H. Cohen, who serves on the editorial board of Victorian Periodicals Review, is the William R. Kenan, Jr., Professor of English at Rollins College in Winter Park, Florida. His most recent articles have appeared in Prose Studies, Victorian Studies, and The Book Collector. Marysa Demoor is Professor of English Literature at Ghent University, Belgium and Life Member of Clare Hall, Cambridge. She has mainly published on late-Victorian and modernist culture. Recent publications include Their Fair Share: Women, Power and Criticism in the Athenaeum, from Millicent Garrett Fawcett to Katherine Mansfield, 1870–1920 (2000) and Marketing the Author: Authorial Personae, Narrative Selves and Self-Fashioning, 1880–1930 (2004). Sarah Dewis is currently completing her PhD at Birbeck College, University of London. A study based on a selection of the publications of John and Jane Webb Loudon between 1825 and 1850, Sarah has brought her experience as an award winning graphic designer with BBC television to the materiality of nineteenth century periodicals. Laurie Garrison researches various aspects of nineteenth-century literary, visual and theatrical culture. She has published in Victorian Literature and Culture, Literature Compass and a number of collections on nineteenthcentury culture. She is currently writing a book about science, sexuality and sensation novels of the 1860s. Beryl Gray taught for many years for the Faculty of Continuing Education, Birkbeck, University of London. She is the author of George Eliot and Music (1989), and has contributed articles to a wide range of publications including The Oxford Reader’s Companion to George Eliot, The Dickensian, and Carlyle xiii
xiv Contributors
Studies Annual. She is the co-editor with John Rignall of The George Eliot Review, and is at present working on a book-length study of the dog in Dickensian society. Lorna Huett holds a PhD from the University of Cambridge; her research focused on nineteenth-century historical bibliography and author-publisher relations, with specific reference to Charles Dickens’s Household Words, and contributions to the periodical by certain women writers. She is currently an archivist, and is working on an edition of the Tennyson brothers’ poetic juvenilia. Linda K. Hughes, Addie Levy Professor of Literature at Texas Christian University in Fort Worth, Texas, specializes in Victorian literature and publishing history. Author, co-author, or editor of eight books, she has recently completed a study of Victorian poetry in the context of print culture. Anne Humpherys is a Professor of English at Lehman College and The Graduate Center, City University of New York. She is the author of Travels into the Poor Man’s Country: The Work of Henry Mayhew and various articles on the Victorian press and popular culture, Victorian marriage and divorce, as well as Tennyson, Dickens and G.W.M. Reynolds. Her most recent publication is G.W.M. Reynolds: Fiction, Politics and the Press, which she co-edited with Louis James. Christopher Kent is a professor of history at the University of Saskatchewan. He is currently engaged on three projects – a biography of the AngloAmerican popular artist Matt Morgan, a study of the relations between Victorian gentlemen and their tailors, and a history of gentlemen’s clubs in Victorian London. David E. Latané, Jr. teaches British literature at Virginia Commonwealth University; He is editor in chief of Victorians Institute Journal, and associate editor of Stand Magazine. Brian Maidment is Research Professor in the History of Print at Salford University. He has published widely on nineteenth century topics, especially writing by working men and women, visual culture and periodicals. His latest book is Dusty Bob – A Cultural History of Dustmen 1780–1870 (2007). Frank Murray is an independent researcher. Awarded PhD at University of Salford 2008. Previously Head of a successful Art Department in large secondary school, retired after 35 years to pursue research interests. Currently working on C19 wood engraving and illustrated temperance/ religious periodicals. Contributor to NDNB, Thompson Gale periodicals database, and forthcoming DNCJ.
Contributors
xv
James Mussell is lecturer in English at the University of Birmingham. He was one of the editors of the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (ncse) <www.ncse.ac.uk> (2008) and is the author of Science, Time and Space in the Late Nineteenth-Century Periodical Press (Aldershot: Ashgate 2007). Joanne Shattock is Professor of Victorian Literature and Director of the Victorian Studies Centre at the University of Leicester. She is the general editor of The Works of Elizabeth Gaskell (Pickering & Chatto 2005–6), and editor of volume one on Gaskell’s Journalism, Early Fiction and Personal Writings.
Chronology 1822–47 1823–72
1832 1833–34 1834–36 1836
1841 1842
1842
1842 1842–43
1843–January 48 1843–45 1843
1844 1845
Mirror of Literature, Amusement and Instruction Limbird’s early, cheap, illustrated weekly. Mechanic’s Magazine Iron 1873ff. Illustrated, popular science weekly (also issued monthly) with engravings, maps diagrams and portraits. Penny Magazine. National Standard, included Thackeray’s first drawing; edited by F.W.N Bayley. Unstamped broadsheet. [Cleave’s] Weekly Police Gazette 1d, 2d, 3.5d. 18 September. Weekly Chronicle. Prop. F. Mariott, illustrated news a special feature; Observer, like Weekly Chronicle, had intermittent illustrations. Article Henry Cole: LWR Wood Engraving. Daguerreotypomania cartoon published in La Caricature, in France. Punch (nb: Mark Lemon as ed. of Punch, also private secy to Ingram). Illustrated London News May (nb: Ingram planned ILN with Mariott from Weekly Chronicle and ed. Bayley from National Standard). 27 November. Lloyd’s began as an illustrated paper (#1–7), so real rival to ILN, but required to carry stamp; refurbished and re-commenced without illustrations. December Family Herald or, Useful Information and Amusement for the Million 1d. Articles: Illustrated London News Vol. 1 preface and May 1842 #1 Address Article. Quarterly Review objection to ‘Illustrated Books’. Pictorial Times. Founded by Vizetelly when row with Ingram. Illuminated Magazine (ed. Douglas Jerrold). Illustrated Weekly Times Founded by Stiff, foreman of ILN engravers; foundered quickly; Stiff London Journal. Article: Blackwood’s. [Catherine Gore]’s objection to illustration, ‘The New Art of Printing’. London Journal (Stiff owner then Ingram). xvi
Chronology xvii
1847 1853
1855–72 1860 1861–1907 1861 Nov 1869
1872; 1876
1874 1874
1885 1890 1899
Article: Douglas Jerrold’s Shilling Magazine ‘Place of Fine Arts’ engravings as democratising high culture fine art. December. Cassell’s Illustrated Family Paper founded (physically like ILN, but shorter [8pp], mainly fiction not news, and cheaper [1d]). Illustrated Times Weekly 2d/3d (cheap rival to ILN) Vizetelly ed.; Yates, Sala, Greewood are contributors. Ingram dies. Penny Illustrated Paper (cheaper rival to ILN). Article: Bookseller ‘Illustrated Periodical Literature’. Graphic 6d (although more expensive than ILN, quality justified higher price) Formed from many of the ILN literary staff. Lecture and Article. Ruskin’s ‘Ariadne Florentina’. Denunciation of even the best of illustration in journals, Barnaby Rudge and Cornhill, because of taste of popular readership to which ‘art industry’ caters. Pictorial World 3d; once bought 1882, became more notable imitator of Graphic; rival to Graphic (Williamson 396). The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News Founded by journalist from Bell’s Life (John Osborne) and Bryan Webber and bought by ILN eventually. Rival to Graphic. Book. Mason Jackson, The Pictorial Press (much of it published in ILN). Article: Magazine of Art ‘Illustrated Journalism in England’ C.N. Williamson. Article: Contemporary Review: ‘Illustrated Journalism’ Clement K Shorter. This article (finally) involved in defending place of art/wood engraving in journalism as against photography 60 years after satiric/panic print Daguerreotypomania. Shorter concedes the death of wood engraving in journalism’s process engraving. Ends with photography as ‘lower stage’ (c.f. Wordsworth sonnet in epigraph).
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction: The Lure of Illustration Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
The great end of the whole art of engraving is to render the spirit and genius of a great artist accessible to the thousands, or the millions, by embodying them in cheap and portable forms ... So completely did the ‘Penny Magazine’ bring the art of engraving on wood into general notice, that a certain young lord is reported to have said, wood engraving was invented with the ‘Penny Magazine.’ ([Henry Cole] ‘Modern Wood Engraving’, London and Westminster Review (1838), 268–69) The improvements in the art of wood-cutting, or of embellishment in relief, have been followed by their natural consequence – a great increase in the demand, greater means of supply, a lower price for ‘the article,’ and a corresponding increase in the ‘factories,’ some masters employing from twenty to thirty, or even more hands ... A natural effect of all this is, that those means, which at first were in to aid, now bid fair to supersede much of descriptive writing: certainly they render the text of many books subsidiary to their socalled illustrations. In this partial return to baby literature – to a second childhood of learning – the eye is often appealed to instead of the understanding ... a low utilitarian wish to give and receive the greatest possible amount of knowledge at the least possible expense of time, trouble, money, and we may add, of intellect. Verily it is a superficial knowledge which now pervades the country ... One publisher has put forth a ‘Pictorial Bible,’ a ‘Pictorial Shakespere,’ and a ‘Pictorial’ History of England. The Napoleon Museum is advertised as an ‘Illustrated’ History of Europe. The hoards in the streets are placarded with puffs of some refuse of American literature (?) called Peter Parley’s ‘illustrated’ Histories, written we suppose, by ‘drab-coloured’ Philadelphians, and savouring of democracy and repudiation of honest debts. We have a Weekly ‘Illustrated News,’ 1
2 Introduction: The Lure of Illustration
and a ‘Pictorial Times;’ besides scores and scores of baser newspapers ‘illustrated’ but unstamped. ([John Holmes] ‘Illustrated Books’, Quarterly Review [1844] 170–71) Avaunt this vile abuse of pictured page! Must eyes be all in all, the tongue and ear Nothing? Heaven keep us from a lower stage! (William Wordsworth, ‘Illustrated Books and Newspapers’, 1846) By the mid-1840s, as the implications of wood engraving, the Daguerreotype, and the illustrated press were set out by their detractors and champions, feelings ran high, as the epigraphs suggest. Were wood engravings a welcome technique of popular and wholesome education, extending the benefits of beauty and/or usefulness to working-class readers, or did the pictorial press threaten the status of reason and understanding, and return the reader to ‘baby literature’, and ‘a lower stage’ as the Quarterly Review (QR) and Wordsworth aver? That these positions are represented respectively by articles in the Benthamite London Westminster Review (LWR) and the Tory QR indicate the ideological underpinning of the debate at the time. From the 1830s, a shift from ubiquitous freestanding prints and crudely illustrated broadsheets, for middle-class and working-class consumers respectively, to bound serials is discernible. Media history affords multiple examples of titles of illustrated serials before 1842,1 among them the Mirror of Literature (1822ff), the Mechanic’s Magazine (1823ff), and the Penny Magazine (1832ff), before the establishment of Punch and the Illustrated London News (ILN), the title that first successfully yoked news and pictures in a sustainable and enduring publication in Britain. But despite a leading and upbeat article on wood engraving and woodcuts in the LWR in 1838, before the success of these two titles,2 this mode of illustration was not so ubiquitous, well respected or even established at the time that its longevity was not threatened by developments in photography, then in its infancy. When Theodore Maurisset’s ‘Daguerrotypomanie’ appeared in La Caricature in December 1839 (see Fig. 0.1) depicting engravers hanging themselves in the face of the popular enthusiasm for the Daguerreotype, the heyday of woodcuts to come and the elaborate illustrations in Cornhill and Good Words in the 1860s seemed unimaginable. An engraver himself, Maurisset was understandably sensitive to current developments. So, hard upon the LWR piece (August 1838) extolling wood engraving came Maurisset’s prediction of its demise. However, photography itself, described in an early volume of ILN as associated with portraiture rather than news, remained freestanding and detached from the press in Britain for another 40 years, while the double breakthrough into the upmarket quality press of Herbert Ingram’s ILN and Punch assured the development of the woodcut and its persistence as the
Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
3
Figure 0.1 Theodore Maurisset, La Daguerreotypomanie, La Caricature, December 1839. Source: Private archive of the editors.
favoured mode of illustration for news and amusement in British serials until late in the century. The word ‘press’ however, obscures distinctions that subsequent historians and critical theorists of illustration and journalism tend to make between the newspaper press, magazines and books. That is, among newspaper historians such as James Grant, Fox Bourne, Williamson, and Mason Jackson, it is the ILN that establishes the pictorial press in the nineteenth century, largely because of its link between news and illustration.3 From its launch in 1842 they argue, a gaggle of illustrated weekly newspapers follow that culminate in the Graphic, weekly and then daily. However, illustrated magazines such as the London Journal, Cornhill, Once a Week and Good Words represent another genre of the press to which the deployment of woodcuts in the earlier Penny Magazine, and Figaro in London and Punch led. To these illustrated journals, supporting instruction and satire respectively must be added serialised part-issues of fiction, dating from Pickwick Papers 1836–37, and serialised magazine fiction, each part or instalment of which often included an illustration. Together, this clutch of magazines and part-issues account for the varied functions of subsequent illustrations in the periodical press as distinct from the link of illustration with news. But a common characteristic united these illustrations, despite the variety of rhetoric or
4 Introduction: The Lure of Illustration
location, an association of illustration with art and aesthetics, in addition to diverse claims for ‘illustrated news’, usefulness, ornament, ‘truth to life’, and/or record. For much of its duration in the nineteenth century, then, illustrated journalism retained a primary association with fine art prints and the art of the engraver who produced it, and prints from titles – especially those of the ILN – were produced as collectable rather than disposable items. With the exception of Malcolm Chase’s piece on supplementary illustrations to the Northern Star, the Chartist weekly newspaper, and Ed Cohen’s on the Daily Chronicle and the laureateship, the serials treated in The Lure of Illustration appear in what we call magazines, although at the inception of the ILN, in a period when most newspapers were weekly, it confidently described itself as ‘an illustrated newspaper’ (‘Preface’, ILN (1843), Vol. 1, iii). Several titles treated here deploy illustration with respect to fact, if not news, in connection, for example, with gardening, celebrity portraiture, scientific experiment, and fashion, while chapters on dickens’s Household Words and All the Year Round assess what visual copy offers letterpress fiction. Graphic and other visual elements of the press, such as mastheads, layout, and paper are studied in a range of magazine types, including a labour periodical of the 1840s, a family magazine of the 1850s, and a decadent periodical of the 1890s. The collection as a whole, then examines illustration in a variety of modes and serial types and from a number of perspectives. Its distinction and its value lie in its attempt to examine discursively the trajectory of illustrated journalism across the century, rather than within a single period or title as modern critics such as Patricia Anderson, Celina Fox, Ian Haywood, Andrew King, Martina Lauster, Brian Maidment and Peter Sinnema have done so well.4 Likewise, whereas book illustration and illustration of literature have been singled out by recent collections,5 dedicated attention to illustrated journalism is rare. As is the case in the history of publishing, textual and paratextual change often involve technological and cultural developments. With respect to woodcuts and engraving, the impetus of Bewick’s art and their widespread deployment in vernacular and vulgar print forms were coupled with economic advantages associated with this medium. These arose from the longevity of wood blocks as compared with steel engravings in the printing process, the relative speed in which they could be produced by breaking up the image into small blocks on which many engravers could work simultaneously, their relative cheapness of production compared with metal engraving, and their gradual assimilation to stereotyping (a plaster mould) or polytyping (a metal mould). Much of this is in place by 1838, and described by Cole in the LWR, where he also charts the development of a workforce of wood engraver artisans. The demise of the medium is just as clearly registered in 1899, in Shorter’s piece in the Contemporary Review (CR). Looking back nostalgically on the efflorescence of the wood-engraving
Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
5
industry mid-century, he mourns its passing, while detailing the now cheaper technologies of process engraving, whether for line drawings or photographs. The debates around nineteenth-century illustrated journalism invoke two separate rhetorics early in the period, that of illustration and that of journalism. In so far as illustration was connected to high culture and fine art prints, its defenders could position cheap prints as the export of high culture to the working classes in the name of health, education, altruism, and for Cole, Christianity.6 For detractors from illustrated journalism, such as John Ruskin, even the best of the magazines printing woodcuts, Master Humphrey’s Clock and Cornhill, were guilty of falling short of the high art of engraving, as a result of the cheap and industrial production processes which, for him, were overdetermined to fail given their ‘lower class’ target readership. A second basis of attack was premised on widespread prejudice against visual representation itself on a number of possible counts: that it was either frivolous/ornamental and distracting from ‘higher’ matters (a position associated with non-conformist and evangelical arguments), that it involved ‘emotional’ rather than intellectual perception (a rationalist, utilitarian position), or in an evolutionary biological expression of this last argument, that it involved a reversion to babyish perception. In a review of illustrated bibles, novels, annuals, and periodicals, the fulminations of the QR critic include the charge of ‘baby literature’ (QR (1844) 171), and Wordsworth invokes this memorably in 1846, linking an alleged primitivism of childhood – its ‘lower stage’ – with social class, the implied lower-rank consumers of illustrated papers, this ‘dumb Art’. At the same time, in the face of this multi-vocal opposition, there was a popular appetite for illustration, testified even by a detractor such like John Holmes in the QR who refers to the ‘rage’ for ornamented, illustrated or pictorial books, and an enthusiast like Douglas Jerrold, who welcomes the successful circulation of fine art in the cheap and popular market as the democratising of the formerly connoisseur culture (Shilling Magazine (1847) 77). Amidst the arguments between detractors and supporters is the heightened rhetoric of the claims for the popularity and good of illustration in the ILN in its launch number and volume in May 1842 and 1843 respectively. Its ‘Address’ in #1 begins with a paean to illustration, alleging its empowerment of periodical literature in the previous decade: For the past ten years we have watched with admiration and enthusiasm the progress of illustrative art, and the vast revolution which it has wrought in the world of publication ... To the wonderful march of periodical literature it has given an impetus and rapidity almost coequal with the gigantic power of steam. It has converted blocks into wisdom, and given wings and spirit to ponderous and senseless wood. [woodcuts] It has in its turn adorned, golded, reflected, and interpreted nearly every
6 Introduction: The Lure of Illustration
form of thought ... Art – as now fostered, and redundant in the peculiar and facile department of wood engraving – has, in fact, become the bride of literature; genius has taken her as its handmaid; and popularity has crowned her with laurels ... ‘Our Address’, ILN 1.1 (14 May 1842), [1]. Six months later, in the throes of proven success, the first Volume of collected numbers of the ILN is able to replicate this heightened rhetoric in a ‘Preface’ which contains a ‘Dedication Sonnet’. Perhaps Wordsworth remembered these extravagant claims when writing his denunciation of illustration in 1846. The triumphal tone of the ILN’s effort is congruent with the rest of the Preface: outlining the benefits of illustration to the past, present and future, it goes on to assess its achievement in verse: To the great public – that gigantic soul Which lends the nation’s body life and light ... – we this muster roll Of all the deeds that pass neath its controul Do dedicate. – The page of simple news Is here adorned and filled with pictured life, Coloured with thousand tints – the rainbow strife Of all the world’s emotions – all the hues Of war – peace – commerce; – agriculture rife With budding plenty that doth life infuse And fair domestic joy – all – all are here To gild the new, and from the bygone year Present a gift to take – to cherish and to use. (ILN, I (1843) iv) The hyperbole of these exalted claims for illustration and its link with news in the ILN may be more understandable if the low status of the press at the time is recalled. This brings us to the second discourse attached to the phrase ‘illustrated journalism’, that of journalism itself. In a piece on ‘The Social Status of Journalists at the Beginning of the Nineteenth Century’, Aspinall highlights on the one hand the pejorative link between the common people and the newspaper press in the early 19C, and on the other, the newspapers’ responsibility for their bad reputation – abuses of anonymous journalism, and the established institution of blackmail or hush money paid to dailies by the victims of scurrilous paragraphs (Aspinall, Review of English Studies, July 1945, 219–20). Suggesting also that at the end of the 18C pamphlets were ‘the only medium for reputable political discussion’ (224), and that periodicals were on the whole not to be seen in the homes of common people (220), he makes an important distinction between the low status of the newspaper press and other forms of serials. So, the strenuous attempts by its defenders to link the pictorial press with Fine Art and hard news, and to emphasise its
Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
7
positive social functions – from Charles Knight’s Penny Magazine and the SDUK (Society for the Diffusion of Useful knowledge) onwards – may be seen as compensatory strategies to overcome the low status of journalism. From the 1830s the concentration of the group of publishers, editors and artists associated with the burgeoning of pictorial journalism is clearly visible through the interrelatedness of many of the illustrated titles, with F.W.N Bayley, the first editor of the ILN the former editor of the intermittently illustrated National Standard (1833ff), and the proprietor of the Weekly Chronicle (1836ff), Frederick Marriott, was a co-planner with Herbert Ingram of the ILN. Ingram and Mark Lemon were both associated with Punch and the ILN; George Stiff with the ILN, the Illustrated Weekly Times, and the London Journal; and Vizetelly with ILN and its rivals the Pictorial Times and the Illustrated Times. W.J. Linton, the chief engraver at ILN (in 1847–48) turns up as the Art and Literary Editor of Pen and Pencil, a short-lived ‘Illustrated Family Paper’ in 1855. The founder of the highly successful Graphic, W.L. Thomas, whose brother had been a member of the ILN staff, poached many of ILN’s literary staff for his new title which, though a 1d dearer, nevertheless flourished on the basis of its superior quality. Mason Jackson, author of The Pictorial Press (1885), was head of the Art Dept at ILN at its inception. Ingram and his successors at the ILN eventually bought up many of the new imitator/rivals including the Illustrated Times, the Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News, and the Penny Illustrated Paper. However, highly successful family papers such as the Family Herald (1842ff) founded by George Biggs and edited by J.E. Smith initially, and Cassell’s Illustrated Family Paper (1853 ff), both initially 1d and in a different market niche than the ILN, thrived in parallel to the ILN and the Graphic, the news-rich seam of Victorian pictorial journalism. Other cheap illustrated papers, equivalent to tabloids and tied to news, such as the Police Gazettes also co-existed with the ILN and Graphic which were at the upper reaches of the illustrated serial market. Clement Shorter’s piece, in 1899, wearily acknowledges the triumph of photography – ‘Will the public get tired of photographs? I think not – while they are able to convey with such intense reality many of the incidents of the hour’ (Shorter, CR [April 1899] 492). He notes the demise of wood engraving (‘all but dead’ [491]), noting that the first half-tone process blocks had been used 15 years earlier, in 1883 and 1884 in the ILN and the Graphic respectively. However, Shorter, a working journalist at the time, born in 1857 and raised during the height of the wood-engraving industry in the 1860s and 1870s, subbed for the Penny Illustrated Paper as a young man; from 1891 he edited the ILN and the English Illustrated Magazine for Ingram’s son William, and in 1893 Ingram and Shorter found the weekly Sketch, which Shorter edited until 1900, ending up as editor of the Sphere. In his 1899 piece for the CR, he is still the journalist interested in the future of the industry. With respect to dailies and illustration, he notes that ‘everything waits on
8 Introduction: The Lure of Illustration
the [new technology of the] printing press’ to accommodate rapid printing of mass circulation illustrated dailies. As for weeklies, he envisages Sunday supplements in the near future, ‘about the size of the ILN, less excellently printed and on inferior paper it is true, and well-nigh entirely composed of photographs’, ‘the journalism of the supplement’ he calls it (493). Meanwhile, by the turn of the century, the technology of the camera and the skills of the snapshot are quickly developing. It took twentieth-century research in nineteenth-century periodicals surprisingly long to focus on illustrations in journals and newspapers, considering the ubiquity of image in that medium. One reason may have been the slow acceptance of print media as a valuable research subject by historians and literary scholars. Another may have been the common twentieth-century assumption that images in newspapers and periodicals are a sign of low culture as reflected, for instance, in the different cultural status of tabloid and broadsheet. Students of Victorian print media may therefore have wanted to secure a place for their subject among regular literary studies first by concentrating on genre, readership, authorship, serialisation, materiality and periodicity. With the advent of the visual turn in literary studies, however, it seemed inevitable that the issue of visuality and Victorian periodicals would be addressed as well. Yet in spite of the publication of a few influential monographs on the visual aspect of periodicals and the conviction of many Victorian scholars that images were central to the Victorian mass media, there is still much work to be done. The editors of this volume have invited some of the most eminent scholars in the field of Victorian periodicals to configure the visual in nineteenth- century print media. The three sections are arranged chronologically to reflect the rise and diversity of the image in the course of the century. ‘Images in Diverse Textual Environments’ begins with Brian Maidment’s focus on Douglas Jerrold’s Illuminated Magazine (1843–45), whose role in the history of the press was significant both on account of its innovative use of wood engraving and its propagation of reformist political beliefs. The journal likewise functioned as the site of apprenticeships for a trio of the most successful wood engravers. If Landells, John Leech and Linton at first represented different traditions within wood engraving, in the Illuminated Magazine (IllumM) they combined their different training and skills, thus preparing the ground for the more sophisticated illustrations one associates with the later pictorial papers. The IllumM emerges as a crucial player in the transformation of the cultural market place in the 1840s in its attempts to reach and influence a larger readership through illustration, by trying to transform the model of the Gentleman’s Magazine to suit a mass audience. Sarah Dewis looks at a more scientific environment for wood engravings in an adjacent and just overlapping period. She shows how J C Loudon, through a deft combination of text and image in the Gardener’s Magazine
Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
9
(1825–44), turned a specialist title somewhere between a gentleman’s and a trade magazine into a vehicle of scientific knowledge, making it ‘the first periodical in Britain to bring together scientific discoveries, technological improvements and horticulture’. Driven by ideas of the Scottish enlightenment, Loudon was an idealist Victorian editor who wanted to impart knowledge to artisanal and middle-class readers of magazines: Dewis argues that Loudon risked alienating gentleman amateur gardeners by showing his appreciation for the skilled gardeners whom they employed. David Latané turns to yet other forms of ‘illustration’ – discursive and visual portraiture – in a mainstream monthly of the same period. He both treats and deploys portraiture in his investigation of a famous feud of the 1830s in Fraser’s Magazine for Town and Country. Painting individual discursive portraits of William Maginn, editor of Fraser’s, and Alaric Watts, poet and journalist, through their vituperative use of portraits, Latané follows the duel between these two Victorian figures, with Maginn as the prince of invisibility and anonymity and Watts as the ‘visual creature of visual culture’. The editor won by exploiting visual culture in a dialogue of text and image in his ‘Gallery of Illustrious Literary Characters’ (Fraser’s, June 1835), which exposed Watts for what he was: a literary entrepreneur but a poetic humbug. Celebrity portraiture of the rich, powerful or famous which adorned the pages of many journals from the 1830s through the 1890s, catered to a voyeuristic streak in the readership. Steel engraved portraits that appeared decades earlier, however, in the Chartist Northern Star were used, Malcolm Chase avers, in an ideological struggle for respectability and political mainstreaming, while they also proved a successful attempt at creating a kind of corporate identity. However, if the marketing ploy of issuing freestanding illustrations to regular subscribers led to this paper’s enormous popularity, with more than 50,000 copies sold per issue in 1839, their success resulted paradoxically in placing the paper under great strain, in terms of production. In ‘Mid-Century Graphics’, visual aspects of Dickens’s publications are predictably prominent. The 1850s and 1860s were the heyday of wood engraving, with Dickens’s fiction and journalism assuming a pivotal place in its development. Two pieces in this book (chapters 5 and 7) study visual aspects of Dickens’s weekly periodicals in relationship to fiction. Beryl Gray’s ‘Man and Dog’ treats the relationship between engravings and textual imagery in The Old Curiosity Shop, which initially appeared in Master Humphrey’s Clock. Characterising Quilp and the master of dogs Jerry, as ‘visual correlative[s] for the more energized or bizarre emanations of [Dickens’s] fancy’ (37), Gray claims that Hablot K. Browne’s clever visualisation of Quilp as the doglike creature pictured and imagined by Dickens turns this collaboration between author and illustrator into a well rehearsed pas-de-deux.
10 Introduction: The Lure of Illustration
Lorna Huett’s exploration of the get-up and graphics as well as the contents of Household Words, demonstrates how Dickens’s weekly functioned in the mid-nineteenth-century periodical market. Addressing Wilkie Collins’s and Dickens’s anxiety about mass audiences in a close analysis of ‘The Unknown Public’ (1858), she argues that the format, price, advertising and contents of Household Words were designed to compete with downmarket, popular weeklies for a niche audience. She concludes that Dickens’s journal is true to the ideology of his fiction: in Household Words he presented the lower and respectable middle-class with value for money, thus securing a place ‘in the vanguard of the explosion of inexpensive, novel-carrying papers which was to occur in succeeding decades’. In an analysis of discursive portraits that chimes with pieces on portraits by David Latané and Ed Cohen across the period, Joanne Shattock juxtaposes discursive personae in Elizabeth Gaskell’s letters, magazine fiction, and reviews. Scrutinizing the Self portrayed by Gaskell in stories she contributed to periodicals, in comparison with the ‘I’ projected in her letters, Shattock avers that the Self in the letters was as much of a construction as the fictional heroines depicted in her fiction. Similarly, the persona of Gaskell’s periodical reviews change, depending on the subject treated and the readership addressed. If they are, in general, female voices, the register Gaskell deploys varies according to the journal: her reviews in Household Words are clearly less dependent on implied foreknowledge than those in the Athenaeum or Reader. With Frank Murray’s chapter on the British Workman, a visually handsome temperance paper edited by T.B. Smithies, we directly tackle one of the central issues of nineteenth-century print culture that was habitually coupled with graphic journalism: the emergence of a new, semi-literate and aspiring readership which, economically as well as ideologically, motivated groups were eager to influence. Launched in 1855 and dedicated to ‘the supply of healthy material’, the British Workman soon became, with the receipt of sporadic grants, the first mass publication of its genre distributed free by the London City Mission, an alliance that boosted ordinary subscriptions. Adjustments of the size and quality of its wood engravings turned this muted message of temperance into a much coveted commodity and gift. The paper henceforth set the standard and influenced the appearance of other religious and temperance papers. Laurie Garrison’s ‘Seductive Visual Studies’, reads The Woman in White in terms of its proclivity for ‘visual records’ in the form of ‘overwritten passages’ that form scientific evidence in this detective novel, and All the Year Round as the context of its serialisation. Exploring how surrounding articles informed Collins’s novel, Garrison wants to prove that through and in the serialization of the story, Collins critiqued Dickens’s editing practices: there is a constant dialogue between the narrative and other contents of All the Year Round, especially with respect to the nature of vision.
Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
11
Chris Kent’s chapter is, like that on the Gardener’s Magazine, dedicated to a trade paper, but his is a later example, with shared as well as separate characteristics and problems. His identification of artisan subscribers to Tailor and Cutter (1866ff) is similar to the readership of professional gardeners identified by Dewis, and to the tension between themselves and the amateurs, but Kent finds additional issues of gender and visual culture. Fashion, Kent reminds us, is normally gendered as feminine in the nineteenth century. An important task of a trade journal like Tailor and Cutter therefore was to reassure its artisan and male tailor- readers of their powerful position visà-vis their customers. Part Three focuses on facets of ‘The 1890s’, with its new journalism, celebrity culture and new technologies. James Mussell compares photographic reproduction of scientific phenomena in three, generically dissimilar, 6d monthlies, Science-Gossip, Knowledge and the Strand Magazine. Seldom used to illustrate fiction, photographs accompanying articles and interviews were deployed as a technological novelty at the time to enhance the value of individual titles. Mussell identifies the new and varying spatial and temporal possibilities that the introduction of photographs offered in their different settings, and the ways in which these allowed for a kind of ‘visual tourism’. Linda Hughes examines a different press topic – fine art criticism – in which similar tensions among editorial matter, cheap production, and a popular audience arise. In a study of the uneasy relationship between aestheticism and fin de siècle commodity culture, she treats the art reviews of Rosamund Marriott Watson for the Art Weekly and the daily Morning Leader, paying particular attention to the juxtaposition of aesthetic principles and commercialism, in the form, for instance, of adverts. Hughes highlights the oxymoron that these cheap magazines hoped to educate their public, teaching them how to read fine art. In the penultimate chapter in ‘The 1890s’ Anne Humpherys turns to the higher incidence in the 1890s of women in the workforce involved in the production of periodicals. How did they leave their mark on artwork and letterpress? Humpherys notes the signs of the advent of women writers and illustrators in the pages of Jerome K. Jerome’s Idler (1892–98), explaining the ways in which this affected its appearance. She observes that although women aspired to keep a low profile in the magazine – with female illustrators refusing to distinguish their drawings from those of male colleagues, and the denial of ‘Advanced women’ interviewees that they were advanced – a result of these women joining the team was that the Idler ceased to be ‘an exclusive male club’, since the introduction of the women entailed ‘a change of tone’, and a gender change in the masthead. The last chapter of this book deals with the embattled image of Englishness that was reflected in the pages of a number of periodicals in 1892, following the death of Tennyson, the Poet Laureate. Edward Cohen
12 Introduction: The Lure of Illustration
discusses specifically a series of biographical articles published in the Daily Chronicle on the merits of seven candidates for the laureateship. He analyses each portrait of Englishness, and the ways in which these texts imbricate, define, and value images of nationhood. At the very beginning of her monograph The Victorian and the Visual Imagination, Kate Flint claims that the ‘Victorians were fascinated with the act of seeing, with the question of the reliability – or otherwise – of the human eye, and with the problems of interpreting what they saw’. (Flint 1) Yet seeing and interpreting what they saw did not make the Victorians any different from previous generations. What changed for them, as Flint too acknowledges, was the sheer number of images with which they were being bombarded. The advances in technology as a result of which images were being produced and reproduced more rapidly, more sophisticatedly and in hitherto unequalled numbers turned image, in the course of the century, into an invaluable accessory to text, and the mark of a whole new genre, the pictorial paper. Text and image, text alongside image, text as image – these are the combinations one is confronted with when one studies nineteenth-century print media and the rise of consumer culture. The Victorians explored and exploited all possible juxtapositions of text and image, and were very much aware of the potential power of images in their lives and their media. For them, as for us now, illustrations in all sorts of forms lured potential consumers into buying and reading illustrated periodical texts.
Notes 1. Other titles include the National Standard, Cleave’s Police Gazette and Cleave’s London Satirist. 2. Henry Cole’s informative piece on ‘Modern Wood Engraving’ appeared in LWR in August 1838. 3. Notably the less reputable Cleave’s Weekly Police Gazette (1834–36) is omitted in this connection. 4. Paul Goldman’s Victorian Illustration (1996, 2004) which encompasses the period includes magazine illustration among other types, as does Brian Maidment’s Reading Popular Prints, 1790–1870 (2001). While Martina Lauster’s new study of verbal and visual sketches focuses on a period of 20 years (1830–50), it has the rare merit of treating the breadth of journalism in continental Europe alongside that of Britain. 5. See The Victorian Illustrated Book, ed. Richard Maxwell, Charlottesville and London: University Press of Virginia, 2002 and Literature and the Visual Media, ed. David Seed. Cambridge: Brewer 2005. 6. Cole writes: Engraving is an offshoot of Christianity. It comes from that great change in the manners of men by which, for the first time in the history of the world ... all the thoughtful men in Europe were made solitary students instead of social inquirers, readers in silent cells instead of debaters in groves and gardens. The
Laurel Brake and Marysa Demoor
13
poet and philosopher of old, in Greece and Rome, addressed popular audiences, and not as now, readers in privacy ... the rich light of the stained glass from his gothic window falling on his large oak-bound volume, and the spread pages of bright black letters embellished all round with radiantly-coloured figures. The progress of books is also the progress of engraving which embellishes them. (LWR [1838] p. 272).
This page intentionally left blank
Part I 1800–1840s: Images in Diverse Textual Environments
This page intentionally left blank
1 The Illuminated Magazine and the Triumph of Wood Engraving Brian Maidment
I The Illuminated Magazine was one among the many illustrated 1s monthly magazines which characterised the nascent entrepreneurship and rapid development of the periodical idea in the 1830s and 1840s. It was short lived, running to three volumes between 1843 and 1844 under its first editor, the playwright, journalist and progressive thinker Douglas Jerrold, before slipping into oblivion after two further, increasingly eccentric volumes under the guidance of the engraver, poet and political activist W J Linton, who wound up the project after printing his doggerel epic ‘The Poorhouse Fugitives’ in the fifth and final volume in 1845. Each 64-page monthly issue used the squarish, double column page popularised by Punch, a conspicuously versatile shape for a publication containing a wide variety of illustrations.1 And illustrations were, as its title suggests, central to the Illuminated Magazine. The magazine continued to use the single page etchings and engravings which characterised the publication of fiction in the 1830s and 1840s, but also incorporated into the text a large number of wood-engraved images which might be called ‘vignettes’ were it not for the energy and boldness with which they commandeer space within the double column page, often shaping themselves into complex geometric forms very different to the soft-edged rounded shapes usually associated with end-grain wood-engraved vignettes. Nor can these illustrations properly be called ‘small’, as many of them bully the circumambient text into secondary importance. These wood-engraved images were used variously as column headings, as capital letters, as borders or as endpieces much in the style of eighteenth-century steel or copper engraved flourishes. The magazine’s title, the Illuminated Magazine, while partly a reference to the intensity of illustration employed, nonetheless had wider resonances. ‘Illumination’ was of course a reference to medieval manuscripts which represented a form of craft or artisanal production increasingly threatened by early Victorian technical innovation, not least in the field of magazine 17
18 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
and book production. Unlike the Penny Magazine, which famously incorporated a triumphant narrative of its own technologically advanced production methods into its text, the Illuminated Magazine appeared under a title which insisted on its continuity with honest or even Godly craftsmanship, an insistence made even more emphatic by its use of one of the first mass produced colour title pages. But even here, the exploitation of technological innovation was offset against a retrospective insistence on the hand made – the multi-colour title page was built up using a sequence of three different coloured wood-engraved blocks which had to be superimposed on each other to form the resplendent image, a considerable feat of artisanal skill. ‘Illuminated’ in this context also had another meaning, making reference to the idea of throwing (metaphorical) light on issues, problems, or events. Given that both Jerrold and Linton had progressive and reformist political beliefs, and were especially interested in the development of print culture as a mode of socio-political encouragement to the aspiring working classes, the chosen title of the Illuminated Magazine implicitly spoke of an advanced political agenda – nothing less than the political and cultural ‘illumination’ of the nation. The contents of the Illuminated Magazine, when briefly summarised, seem to conform to the expected template for such monthlies, comprising a mixture of fanciful or whimsical sketches, historical anecdotes and legends, travel pieces, social commentary and investigation, poems and stories and, to a limited extent, reviews. But, as we shall see, the Illuminated Magazine often did manage to redefine this mixture as something more progressive in its central endeavour to translate the ambitions of the genteel monthly into something more usefully and progressively ‘popular’. In the words of the editorial Preface to the first volume of the journal, ‘It has been the wish of the Proprietors of this work, to speak to the MASSES of the people; and whilst sympathizing with their deeper and sterner wants, to offer to them those graces of art and literature which have too long been held the exclusive right of those of happier fortunes.’2 It is the nature of this project to democratise those traditionally genteel literary and artistic ‘graces’ and combine them with a more socio-political interest in ‘deeper and sterner wants’ that forms the substance of this essay.
II Such scholarly attention as the Illuminated Magazine has enjoyed is largely the result of biographical interest in the varied and complicated careers of its multi-talented editors, Douglas Jerrold and William James Linton, and of a recognition of the quality of its stable of artists which included John Leech, Kenny Meadows and H.G. Hine under the direction of the entrepreneur and engraver Ebenezer Landells and Linton himself.3 Put unflatteringly, a lot of interesting and significant literary and artistic figures assembled themselves
Brian Maidment
19
temporarily round the Illuminated Magazine, which came to represent a brief interlude in extended and prominent careers expressed elsewhere. As Michael Slater has so carefully shown in his recent biography of Jerrold, the magazine was set up by Herbert Ingram,4 the publisher of the phenomenally successful Illustrated London News, partly to win back several of his key writers and artists who had been increasingly contributing to The Pictorial Times, the upstart rival to the Illustrated London News.5 These included Mark Lemon, the editor of Punch, whose duties did not allow him to take on another editorial role, and the group of artists – Kenny Meadows, H.G. Hine, Ebenezer Landells and John Leech – who became the mainstay of the Illuminated Magazine. Slater’s account of the magazine’s genesis suggests it was built by a clique out of a combination of rivalries, grudges and opportunism. Its progressive politics may have proceeded from a response to the conservatism of the Pictorial Times under its owners, the printer Edward Spottiswoode and Henry Vizetelly, the wood engraver who had been central to the launch of Ingram’s Illustrated London News in 1842 but who had subsequently fallen out with Ingram. Landells, too, one of Punch’s original owners but subsequently rather acrimoniously bought out by Bradbury and Evans, had reasons to look for a new and prestigious project.6 Thus, while the Illuminated Magazine could boast of an experienced, able and well established staff already hugely experienced in the increasingly complex patterns of periodical literature, its launch was not underpinned by any particular purpose or vision beyond a dislike of the conservatism of the Pictorial Times and a wish on its owners’ part to pull a group of errant staff back into their employ. While the miscellaneous nature of the journal, implicit in the contingent nature of its founding, pleased some reviewers, and, as Slater notes, ‘Jerrold’s name was a powerful talisman’,7 on the whole the Illuminated Magazine seems to have been a project that sagged right from the start. Certainly, by the time Linton took over as editor in 1844, there was some substance in Smith’s comments that it was an ‘ailing’ or even a ‘dying’ magazine,8 although Smith, as I’ll argue later, is unduly influenced by a sense that the Illuminated Magazine betrayed Linton’s radical political sympathies. The comparative failure of the Illuminated Magazine might be shrugged off by circumstantial evidence, particularly the preoccupation of its founding editor with other projects and the considerable competition from betterresourced magazines. But its failures were also exemplary ones born out of the tensions and complexities of periodical publishing in the 1840s, and it is worth spending some time considering them. If the largely hostile comments of both its contemporaries and the views of recent critics like Smith, Slater and Lovett are assembled, the perceived failings of the Illuminated Magazine might be summarised in the following ways. First of all, it failed to be Punch – the Punch, that is, of the first few volumes from the early 1840s with their bohemian/radical politics, their visual experimentation, their preoccupation with Regency caricature tropes,
20 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
especially the grotesque human body, and their roots in the collective bonhomie of a male coterie. Smith comments witheringly that the Illuminated Magazine ‘was modelled on Punch, but pretended to superior literary and artistic standards and less radical politics’.9 In short, his judgement is that the journal was just not good enough in comparison with its immediate rivals. Slater notes, in relation to Jerrold’s serial publication ‘The Chronicles of Clovernook’, that the modern reader will find it full of ‘relentless sexism, which is very much in the established Punch tradition’10, the implication being that, as a pale shadow of Punch, Jerrold had even copied the weaknesses of his model. Linked to a general belief that the Illuminated Magazine was feebly derivative was a widespread view that it was solely the product of a masculine clique brought together not just by Punch but also by working together on the Illustrated London News and the Pictorial Times. Slater quotes contemporary reviews that inveighed against a magazine ‘evidently got up by a clique’11 and notes that several contemporaries concentrated their response on what was perceived as the narrow range of contributors. Given the origins of the Illuminated Magazine such criticism was inevitable, and might be made of the illustrators as well as the writers. Jerrold had already collaborated with Kenny Meadows on the separate volume publication of Punch’s Letters to His Son12, and Linton and Meadows had worked together for many years on various projects, including Meadows’s 1840 Portraits of the English which Linton had engraved. H.G. Hine, despite his origins as a landscape painter, had been brought in to work for Punch by Landells, a role that had advertised his fluidity and ease as a comic artist.13 Indeed, given the centrality of Landells in the development of the London wood engraving trade and the interconnections created by many of the major illustrated projects of the early 1840s, it would have been extraordinary if the artists employed by Landells and then Linton to work for the Illuminated Magazine hadn’t been a clique. Yet, as I want to suggest later, to see this group of artists and writers as homogenous and narrowly focussed is far from fair – as Slater notes, the introduction of Wilkie Collins and Richard Hengist Horne as contributors to the Illuminated was an important change of focus despite the continuing presence of such long time cronies as Mark Lemon and Laman Blanchard.14 In many ways more surprising than the accusation of cliqueyness was a persistent sense that the Illuminated Magazine fell short of its ambitions to be visually spectacular and innovative. Jerrold himself put the blame largely on the shortcomings of his printers – ‘No enthusiastic lamplighter was ever more deceived by cotton-wicks and train-oil, than I by the printer. However, I hope in another month we shall be able to burn gas’.15 Slater adds that ‘the ... colour printing never did amount to much’, and it is true that it was, under Jerrold’s editorship, confined to a few rather smudgy if spectacular title pages.16 Jerrold, dependent on the contribution of Landells as his art editor, clearly considered illustration to be more of a necessary element in
Brian Maidment
21
selling his magazine than a major opportunity for innovation and experimentation – ‘I share your horror of all illustrations’ he commented to Laman Blanchard in 1843.17 Yet I believe that it is the illustration of the Illuminated Magazine that forms its greatest claim on our attention largely because the journal acted as a focus, perhaps even a synthesis, of available graphic resources and brought together in one place the remarkably varied potential of the wood engraving as an illustrative medium. The most substantial criticisms to be made of the Illuminated Magazine, however, concern its fascination with whimsy and its political caution. Whimsy reveals itself in both the texts and the illustrations to the journal, and it is damaging to the more serious elements elsewhere. The main culprit was Jerrold’s own serial ‘Chronicles of Clovernook’, described accurately and perhaps even sympathetically, by Slater as a ‘sentimental-Radical vision of a hierarchical but wholly benevolent society, a glorified mirror image of contemporary England’ but dismissed by a contemporary as ‘fancy run riot like honeysuckle’.18 Yet elsewhere there is plenty of sentimental reminiscence and drollery along the lines of R B Peake’s ‘Dogs’ Tales’. In one of these (Vol. 1, October 1843, 335–59) a startlingly literary dog tells the sad story of his master, a writer of comic plays who ‘wrote himself blind’ and ended his life a pauper, thus causing his dog to be banished to the streets. Compilations of sentimental anecdotes of this kind were a stock in trade of the magazine, and sat oddly alongside hard-edged reports like the one on the south Staffordshire colliers that appears in the same monthly issue. There was plenty of visual fantasy to set alongside the verbal – again in the same issue the text of a poem called ‘A Vision in Pan’s Dell’ is intertwined by a sinuous forest scene by Kenny Meadows. The sentimentality and whimsy of the Illuminated Magazine may well have been another aspect of Jerrold’s need to please, a means of cajoling his readers through the tougher reportage and politics elsewhere in the journal, but it creates not just dissonance within the text, but also a widespread sense of miscellaneity and lack of editorial direction. The concessionary politics of the Illuminated Magazine come as a disappointment not just to those who would have expected a more radical position from an ex-firebrand like Linton but even to those who quickly became disillusioned with Punch’s concurrent drawing back from strongly progressive positions. F B Smith, in his biography of Linton, views his shift from overt Chartist activism on through the cautious progressivism of his own short-lived journal aimed at artisans – The National (1839) – to the cautious meliorism and muted social anger of the Illuminated Magazine with something approaching contempt. Although Smith talks of Linton’s ‘individualistic, undiscriminating editorial courage’ in contrast to Jerrold’s ‘mildly radical’ editorial policy and gives due acknowledgement to the bolder of his editorial decisions, he also talks of a ‘softening’ of Linton’s views for a ‘different, middle-class family audience’ characterised by Linton’s
22
The Triumph of Wood Engraving
acceptance, as a considerable employer, of a market economy and a refusal to tackle controversial domestic issues.19 But Smith’s biography is postulated on a narrative of Linton’s career that depends on ideas of retirement and retreat, and at least one more recent commentator has argued that Linton took a more consistent and sustained political position throughout his working career built out of a dialogue between public engagement and the necessity to maintain some degree of aesthetic detachment.20 The main focus of this essay is not primarily ideological, but it is nonetheless important to acknowledge here that under both Jerrold and Linton, the address and content of the Illuminated Magazine was largely structured by a perception of the interests and needs of a wide range of potential readers rather than by any reformist or advanced political agenda. Given the journal’s declared intention to meet the needs of ‘THE MASSES’ this conciliatory tone is something of a disappointment, but it is important to remember that Jerrold’s original Preface stressed the cultural progressivism of the journal at least as strongly as he underlined its political stance. The democratic elements of the magazine are more to be found in its opening up of the interests, values and aesthetic pleasures of the traditionally genteel to the gaze of a wider reading public than in the adoption of any particular political position.
III The conventional scholarly narrative about the Illuminated Magazine, then, positions it as a predictable if exemplary failure, the victim of its origins in the turf wars of competing entrepreneurs at a moment of expansion and volatility in the magazine market, of its editor’s wish to please everyone, and its failure to meet the expectations of its readers who had plenty of alternatives to look to. But there are other ways to read the history of this journal which focus on its central place in one of the key projects of early Victorian journalism, that of translating the interests, aesthetic concerns and intellectual sophistication of the genteel into the idioms and discourses of the democratic. In its negotiation between the progressive and the bourgeois, the Illuminated Magazine epitomises that strand of periodical literature which had sought to re-invent the Gentleman’s Magazine for a mass reading public in the early Victorian period without compromising intellectual or aesthetic aspirations. Central to this re-invention of the genteel periodical was the wood engraving, brilliantly appropriated as both a decorative and informative medium by the Mirror of Literature in the 1820s from its vernacular roots in broadsides, tracts and songbooks on the one hand and from its aesthetic ambitions under Bewick’s tutelage on the other. Closely associated with the ideological battles over the ‘march of intellect’ and the knowledge wars of the 1830s, wood engraving had established itself in the 1840s as a London trade which formed the launch pad for Punch and the Illustrated London News
Brian Maidment
23
among many other projects. It was no accident that so many of the artists who worked for the Illuminated Magazine, most notably Landells and Linton, had worked for the Mirror of Literature early in their careers, and had thus been central to the establishment of wood engraving as a new medium for periodical illustration. Such a recognition of the origins of the wood engraving in a variety of artistic traditions and a willingness to exploit these traditions as a mechanism for the democratisation of complex ideas to my mind gives the Illuminated Magazine a particular claim on our attention. The immediate visual impact of the Illuminated Magazine is built out of the variety, profusion and scale of its illustrations. Certainly, when compared to fiction led contemporary monthlies like Ainsworth’s Magazine or Bentley’s Miscellany which subsisted on a diet of single page etchings or engravings, the Illuminated Magazine created an extremely highly elaborated visual statement. The modal diversity of its images has already been noted. The three colour wood-engraved emblematic title page, despite Slater’s rather sniffy remark, remains a pioneering attempt to put new printing technology, especially technology that translated the effects of expensive hand craft production, into mass market products (Fig. 1.1). Jerrold and Landells also retained the established tradition of large single page engravings familiar from serialised fiction and the fiction led journals, initially using a full page of wood-engraved images, but soon shifting to spectacular coloured engravings by Leech, like the fanciful ‘Tom Houlaghan’s Guardian Sprite’ in March 1844 (Vol. 2, 241) (Fig. 1.2). Here the large double columned Punch derived page gives these images a scale and impact missing from the smaller single column fiction monthlies. Many of these plates must have been cut out and displayed separately as they form powerful visual images quite apart from their circumambient text. Beyond these spectacular graphic elements which depended on a separation out of text and image, the text pages of the Illuminated Magazine were strewn with a variety of wood-engraved images. Some of these were clearly attempts to translate the typographical and decorative traditions of eighteenth-century printing to the new mass market. The monthly contents page, for example, featured at its top a cherub holding up an ‘illuminating’ candle from a nest among assorted decorative shrubbery, and a decorative basket of flowers and leaves below (Fig. 1.3) The insistence here on a tradition of emblematic visual content – the faint but certain rays of the magazine’s ‘illuminative’ purpose and its profusion of decorative tendrils – was taken up broadly elsewhere in the magazine, thus mediating between the decorative and the educative functions of the assembled images. In December 1843, for instance, between a rambling piece on ‘England Sixty Years go’ and a poem called ‘Reverie’, appeared a vignette tailpiece of a quill pen lying through a wreath of olive branches which served no obvious illustrative function but which acted as an independent prompt to thoughtfulness as well as a decorative space filler (Vol. 2, December 1843, 81).
24 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
Figure 1.1 Three coloured wood engraved title page to the Illuminated Magazine vol. 1, 1843.
Brian Maidment
25
Figure 1.2 John Leech. Engraved illustration to ‘Tom Houlaghan’s Guardian Sprite’, the Illuminated Magazine vol. II, March 1844, 241.
26 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
Figure 1.3 Ebenezer Landells. Wood engraved title page to a monthly issue of the Illuminated Magazine vol. II, December 1843, 55.
Brian Maidment
27
But most of the illustrations dropped into the text were wood-engraved illustrative vignettes of various shapes and sizes. Put simply, the Illuminated Magazine constructed a page that recognised early and fully the potential of the dialogue between word and image which resulted from the ability of wood-engraved images to be incorporated into circumambient letterpress. Magazines from the previous decade from entirely various traditions and with entirely differing readerships, such as, say, the Penny Novelist, the Mechanic’s Magazine, or even the Mirror of Literature itself had incorporated wood-engraved vignettes within their double columned page, thus exploiting the convenience of locating image alongside or immediately above its related letterpress. But few magazines, not even pioneers of wood-engraved illustration like the Penny Magazine or the Illustrated London News, had tried to structure entire pages round the protean shapes that wood engraving could accommodate and exploit.21 In this respect the Illuminated Magazine looked forward to the complex pages that could be built out of photoreprographic techniques, especially in Linton’s final volume in which he and Thomas Sibson developed complex patterns of text and image to illustrate Linton’s doggerel epic ‘The Poorhouse Fugitives’. It is, of course, possible to argue that such a range and diversity of visual content in the Illuminated Magazine was essentially a sign of confusion and conservatism, part of Jerrold’s misjudged attempt to give as many people as possible as many different satisfactions as could be crammed into a single periodical. Indiscriminate eclecticism, however virtuously conceived, is not the same thing as the purposive democratisation of visual information, and there are moments when the Illuminated Magazine does look overburdened with images drawn from competing traditions that only serve to illustrate contradictory discourses. But I think the progressive elements outweigh the evident anxieties. Of these progressive elements, the title page, smudged and unsophisticated as it may have been in its red, blue and golden splendour, has already been discussed as an early venture into colour printing technology. The use of an art editor, too, was an innovation that looked forward to the work of the Dalziel brothers on Good Words, and to other later Victorian journals like Once A Week which became renowned and collected for their art work. Jerrold was clear enough about the importance of Landells’s contribution to sanction a prominent notice on each monthly title page of the Illuminated Magazine to the effect that ‘the whole of the Engravings [were] under the superintendence of Ebenezer Landells’. But the truly progressive element in the illustration of the Illuminated Magazine came from the range and quality of its text based wood engravings. It is all too easy to assume that wood engravings are alike, and derive from a single tradition which allows for little difference in technique, construction or allusion to aesthetic predecessors. The narrative history of end-grain wood engraving as a dominant mode of early nineteenth century image making derives so particularly from the work of Thomas Bewick and from
28
The Triumph of Wood Engraving
the diaspora formed by his pupils and apprentices as they made their way to London to work for the new illustrated journals that it becomes hard to acknowledge the range and variety of the medium in the first half of the nineteenth century. Of the illustrators who worked for the Illuminated Magazine, Landells had been taught by Bewick and by Bewick’s apprentice Nicholson22, and John Leech had worked for John Orrin Smith, who had been taught by Harvey, another Bewick pupil. Linton, on the other hand, represented the tradition of London-based black line wood engraving handed on by Thurston and Branston, who had been his immediate teacher. Thomas Sibson was a protégé of Linton. So the magazine’s illustrators derived their skills and understanding of tradition from the apprenticeship system that had led to the rapid and successful evolution of the medium. They form a direct and immediate line of descent from its first generation of masters. Essentially linear, despite the tonal complexities wrought by Bewick and his colleagues, wood engraving became so quickly normalised in the Penny Magazine, the Saturday Magazine, the Illustrated London News and Punch (to say nothing of penny fiction) that it is hard to remember the self-transformation and conceptual shifts that artist/engravers like Landells or Linton had to undergo before they worked at ease in the new medium. Even a talented draughtsman like Robert Buss had to learn entirely new technical processes to undertake work for Dickens on Pickwick Papers only to be more or less immediately sacked because the idiom of his work looked too firmly back to the grotesqueries of Regency caricature. Interestingly, Engen says that Buss ‘began his career as a draughtsman on wood for Charles Knight’s publications’ in the early 1840s, but long before this he had worked as an etcher within a caricature tradition.23 Although the illustrators who worked on Jerrold’s magazine were established figures in the London wood engraving world it is important not to forget the variety of influences and traditions that underlay their early professional careers and still influenced the images that they made in the early 1840s. Accordingly, the illustrations to the Illuminated Magazine derive from a variety of different potentialities available within the traditions of wood engraving. As already suggested, some of the images, especially decorative tailpieces and endpieces, are direct translations of eighteenth-century copper engraved motifs into the new medium of wood engraving. Others used the nervy lines and graphic tropes of eighteenth-century caricature, a tradition mediated into early Victorian consciousness through the illustrated songbooks, comic annuals and play texts which formed the dominant sites where, in the 1830s, the traditionally vernacular mode of wood engraving began to engage with the sophisticated graphic idioms of caricature. It is precisely this transformation, or perhaps translation, of the sophisticated genteel discourses of single plate engraved caricature into a variety of literary genres and graphic modes, many of them dependent on the serial idea, aimed at a new range of consumers that sustained the
Brian Maidment
29
development of wood engraving as a comic medium. It is in texts like, to take an obvious example, the three volumes of The Universal Songster (1825– 1828), illustrated entirely by wood-engraved vignettes drawn by the Cruikshank brothers, dropped into the text (apart from the large multipanelled title pages), the vivacity and linear energy of caricature is applied to a range of songs drawn from the saloons, concert rooms, theatres and oral occasions of the circumambient vernacular culture. The Illuminated Magazine, like the emergent Punch, was quick to acknowledge the importance of this new version of the caricature tradition. In volume 1, for example, a whimsical piece by Gilbert A’Beckett about his schoolboy fantasies of Napoleon, is illustrated by three of Leech’s vignettes all of which redraw and domesticate earlier caricature versions of the demonic Napoleon in the new wood-engraved comic idiom. The first of these, ‘Miss Frounce and the Boy’ (I, 23, May 1843) uses the vignette medium in a particularly self-conscious way with the shape of the end-grain wood block clearly circumscribing the borders of the image and the free, almost casual, use of the graphic characteristics of the rapidly drawn wood-engraved line. The aim is to create an image that is both sophisticated and simple at the same time. While suggesting the rapidity of its own making and using the small scale of the wood-engraved vignette, nonetheless the image refers back to the complex iconography and structure of large-scale eighteenth-century caricature especially in the comically brooding Napoleon with his devil’s tail neatly following the shape of the left side of the image. The familiarity that early volumes of Punch and the subsequent work of the Victorian wood-engraved comic illustrators like Leech, Browne and Tenniel have given to images of this kind rather conceals the significance of the entry of the comic or caricature wood-engraved vignette (invariably laid into the surrounding text) into the illustrational mainstream in the early 1840s. It is equally easy to assume that such well established early Victorian illustrators as Kenny Meadows had worked exclusively in the new modes and genres of wood engraving of the 1830s and 1840s. Engen, for example, following the traditional view of Meadows handed on by Everett and Houfe, characterises Kenny Meadows, one of Jerrold’s key contributors, as ‘one of the first illustrators whose work recommended wood engraving to publishers ... and the list of Meadows’ illustrations grew to encompass most of the mid-century wood-engraved publications.’24 But Meadows had collaborated with the Cruikshank brothers in the early 1830s on metal engraved periodical caricature illustrations, and had later contributed on wood to Bell’s Life in London, an early and important example of a comic periodical making use of a profusion of wood-engraved comic vignettes. So, for all his close identification in both public affection and scholarly memory with the new wood engraving of the 1840s, Meadows had his roots back in the caricature traditions of the previous decades, and had made the transition to wood engraving after establishing himself in a variety of different modes.
30 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
Similarly, Thomas Sibson, who contributed extensively to the last volume of the Illuminated Magazine as a protégé of Linton, had begun his career with etched extra illustrations to Pickwick Papers and Master Humphrey’s Clock which, in their grotesquerie and thin lined nervous energy, looked firmly back to previous generations of comic illustration and certainly offer a different version of Dickens than Hablot Browne’s less confrontational, more sentimental images. Again in Sibson’s case the shift from metal engraving and etching to wood engraving was accompanied with an acknowledgement that the new dominance of wood engraving inevitably limited opportunities for the political boldness and sometimes scabrous exaggerations of eighteenth-century caricature. Nonetheless, some elements of that tradition do persist in the 1840s, and they are represented in the Illuminated Magazine alongside newer, more conciliatory illustrative genres and modes. But if one underlying purpose of the wood-engraved illustrations to the Illuminated Magazine was to popularise, render accessible, and preserve the inheritance derived from engraved caricature, the magazine was even more fundamentally concerned with making considerable claims for both the aesthetic and documentary resourcefulness of the medium. Such claims derived their credibility not just from the quality of the images published by Jerrold and Landells but also from the use of artists who had been deeply involved in a series of major projects which had fought hard to give the wood engraving a new, enhanced status as not just a linear medium for diagrammatic explanations or simplified naturalism but as a tonally complex expressive medium on a par with other longer-established graphic modes like mezzotint or stipple engraving. Again Kenny Meadows was a key figure, and his serialised Shakespeare (1839–1843), issued in multi-volume form in 1843, showed both an ambitiousness for the aesthetic possibilities of the wood engraving and a willingness to experiment with the text/image relationship of the printed page that show how widely the potential of the medium was being explored during this period. It is particularly important to note Meadows’s contribution to the development of the medium because, as all his critics have noted, he was more a competent jobbing artist than a naturally gifted comic genius.25 While Everitt notes that the Shakespeare ‘was considered by himself ... as his masterpiece’ he also offers uncharacteristically hostile judgments on its ‘strange conceptions’ and ‘preposterous ideas’ as well as on Meadows’s ability to draw figures.26 Thus Meadows is perhaps more a representative figure, someone responding to the zeitgeist, than an originator or an innovator. Notwithstanding these reluctant evaluations of his artistic achievement, the pages of Meadows’s Shakespeare show the kind of riotous use of the irregularity and protean nature of the wood engraving that characterises the Illuminated Magazine. Each play in the Shakespeare has a separately printed single image frontispiece, but within the text itself there is a startling tension between the formality of the doubleruled border and double columned text and the wide variety of wood
Brian Maidment
31
engravings dropped into text. This tension is particularly powerfully rendered on the title pages, where the cast lists are topped by cursive lettering, accompanied by weirdly shaped vignettes, and footnoted by tiny figures which combine characters with the capital letters of their names. While the artistic effect of these experimental pages is not always well integrated, nonetheless it is entirely possible to see that Landells and Linton have available to them new kinds of printed pages where visual variety and graphic energy clamour for the reader’s attention. More aesthetically successful precedents were also available from other ambitious multi-volume projects in the same period. One of these was an edition of Walter Scott’s works published by Robert Cadell in the early 1840s and clearly intended to be a rival to the great illustrated books of the late eighteenth century. The format again comprised separately printed frontispieces (steel engravings in this instance), highly decorated emblematic title pages and a text strewn with wood-engraved vignettes, headpieces and tailpieces of varying shapes and sizes. The artists assembled for this project, with Landells as their guiding spirit, represented a roll-call not just of the new generation of wood engraver/artists but also of established painters like Turner, Clarkson Stanfield and Gilbert whose work could be translated into the new medium through the artisanal skills of the engravers. All the images – which comprised historical scenes, topographical views, and dramatic incidents as well as emblems – were finished to an extremely high level and suggested the tonal potential and artistic pretensions of the woodengraved medium. Nearly all the Illuminated Magazine artists contributed to this project, many of them as major figures – Hablot Browne, Landells, Meadows and even the youthful Sibson. What is of particular interest in the whole project is the way in which a range of artists who would become almost entirely associated with comic illustration – artists, for example, like Robert Buss who had engraved some early Pickwick plates for Dickens – turned their hand to ambitious naturalistic historical and landscape images. With this broad spectrum of skill and talent to draw on, it is not surprising that Landells and later Linton filled many pages of the Illuminated Magazine with superbly finished and accomplished wood engravings that continued to claim attention for the new found confidence of the medium as something beyond a comic or expository genre. William Henry Prior’s elaborate title illustration to James Smith’s ‘Broad Lea Farm’ serves as an obvious example (Vol. IV, January 1845, 125) (Fig. 1.4), especially as it represents an obvious reworking of an illustrated page from the Cadell Scott extended and elaborated for the larger and more experimental pages of the Illuminated Magazine. Such unabashed borrowings from other work suggest the extent to which the genres and modes of illustration interconnected in the 1840s. Prior, a close associate of Charles Knight in his major publications, a pupil of William
32 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
Figure 1.4 W.H. Prior. Wood engraved illustration to ‘Broad Lea Farm’, the Illuminated Magazine vol. IV, January 1845, 125.
Brian Maidment
33
Harvey, and wedded to Harvey’s slightly staid and heavily worked style, here combined a conventional pastoral idyll with an architectural image which recalls the baroque versions of buildings that George Cattermole contributed to Dickens’s Master Humphrey’s Clock. But Prior, clearly taking his cue from Landells’s willingness to experiment with unusual page layouts, bends his image round the text into a fan-shaped illustration, thus pulling the figure at the left and the cattle at the right down into the text and allowing the title to form a rustic arch under the placid duck pond. The composition is an extremely dynamic one despite the serenity of the rural scene which it depicts, with firm tonal contrasts that depend on the strong side light being rendered in large white areas of the page. This image looks forward to the kinds of bucolic fantasies, often with the signature of Miles Birket Foster under them, so frequently to be found in the illustrated anthologies and gift books which proved such a market staple in the later Victorian period, but it is, for all its conventionality, a very impressive and ambitious composition. The technical achievement of the image is publicised by its unusual shape, its remarkably fine detail and its vigorous tonality, all accomplishments that had become the trademarks of the newly ambitious genre of wood engraving, which had striven to rival the steel engraved vignettes that Turner had contributed to Rogers’s Poems and Italy a decade before. It would not be at all difficult to add many other similar images to this discussion, see for example, H.G. Hine’s title illustration to James Smith’s ‘The Wayfaring Tree’ (Vol. III, August 1844, 227) for a similarly inventive revision of conventional pastoral motifs, or the same artist’s finely textured and beautifully drawn illustration to ‘The Two Yew Trees’ from the same year (Vol. III, September 1844, 269). Part of the substantial editorial policy of the Illuminated Magazine, both under Jerrold and Linton, had been to display the most accomplished and ambitious outcomes of the London-based trade in wood-engraved images, images with a range and quality that could rival metal engraving but which could also, crucially, be printed alongside, within or around letterpress to form a newly vigorous and attractive integrated page. While many of these kinds of highly finished vignettes of rural or urban scenery form a major element in the visual quality of the Illuminated Magazine, and exploit the wood engraving as both a naturalistic and an aesthetically ambitious medium, it is the less naturalistic, emblematic or expressionistic images which seem to me the most impressive and progressive kinds of illustration used by the magazine. Typical of these are H.G. Hine’s title illustration to Wilkie Collins’s first venture into print, ‘The Last Stage Coachman’ (Vol. I, August 1843, 209), Kenny Meadows’s opening image to Robert Postans’s ‘The Philosophy of the Pistol’ (Vol. I, July 1843, 173) (Fig. 1.5), Hine’s superbly cropped and ominous cityscape for ‘The Monster City’ (Vol. III, September 1844, 286) (Fig. 1.6) and, in another image which rather belies the charge of his lack of inventiveness,
34
The Triumph of Wood Engraving
Figure 1.5 Kenny Meadows. Wood engraved illustration to ‘The Philosophy of the Pistol’, the Illuminated Magazine, vol. 1, July 1843, 173.
Brian Maidment
35
Figure 1.6 H.G. Hine. Wood engraved illustration to ‘The Monster City’, the Illuminated Magazine, vol. III, September 1844, 286.
36 The Triumph of Wood Engraving
Meadows’s magnificent drawing for A B Reach’s ‘The Last Hour of a Suicide’ (Vol. III, August 1844, 161). Here Meadows combined a spectrally triumphant death’s head and bridge arch with an incisively delineated foreground image of a draped body on a slab, the material reality of the corpse monstrously threatened by the gathering clouds of imagined images of death. But easily the most confrontational and shocking of these images is another of Meadows’s carefully shaped engravings – the half skeleton, half fashionably dressed seamstress holding a hat box which prefaces an article on ‘Death in the Drawing Room, or, the Young Dressmakers of England’ (Vol. I, June 1843, 97) (Fig. 1.7). Although Punch was printing similarly shocking images at this time, nonetheless I think it is the sustained ability of the Illuminated Magazine’s artists to find a graphic equivalent for social and political anxieties outside the naturalistic idiom that is so impressive here. A carefully managed contrast between highly finished and naturalistically rendered details and less firmly delineated, softer lined abstractions and symbols is one technique the artists used in these images, a graphic method particularly well suited to the characteristics of wood engraving. There is not room here to trace the symbolic content of these images, which represent a shift towards the sustained emblematic narratives, built on carefully rendered naturalistic details, that structured so many Victorian genre and narrative paintings. Nonetheless these kinds of emblematic images in the Illuminated Magazine, built out of a dialogue between the literal and the symbolic, seem to me some of the most interesting and affecting renderings of socio-political issues within the graphic culture of early Victorian Britain. Other graphic elements in the Illuminated Magazine are less successful. The reliance on whimsy – goblins, fairies and other genial imaginaries – has already been mentioned, and is typified by Kenny Meadows’s spirited but ultimately trivialising bonhomie for a Christmas piece by Angus Bethune Reach (Vol. IV, January 1845, 145). Meadows’s attempts at a series of exemplary ‘boys’ to accompany a series of London ‘types’ by Mark Lemon, despite his reputation for ‘character’, seem sketchy and attenuated when compared with the resonance of his more ambitious images (Vol. 1, 1843, 36, 80, 140, 258). While it is interesting to see Lemon building on the emergent tradition of investigative journalism in these articles, and recognising the significance of illustration in this context, nonetheless Meadows seems here to abandon the detailed naturalism required for a less fully realised sketchiness. Yet overall the Illuminated Magazine represents a characteristic, and possibly even a triumphant, moment in the move from large and sophisticated metal engraved images, often with textual elements subsumed into the image, into the vignette form characteristic of wood engraving. While acknowledging the vernacular origins of the wood engraving in broadsides, tracts and songbooks, nonetheless the new generation of wood engravers were beginning to be able to assert their medium as both aesthetically
Brian Maidment
37
Figure 1.7 Kenny Meadows. Wood engraved illustration to ‘Death and the Drawing Room’, the Illuminated Magazine, vol. I, June 1843, 97.
38
The Triumph of Wood Engraving
complex and highly expressive. Even relatively ordinary talents like Meadows, given the run of the page and the freedom offered by a sympathetic editor, blossomed into work which approached the experimental and the adventurous, and his work has deliberately formed the central strand of this commentary in order to suggest both the varying success and versatility of the illustrations in the Illuminated Magazine. While many of the magazine’s illustrations suggested the turn that wood engraving was to take towards joviality and whimsicality on the one hand and idealised bucolic fantasies on the other, to say nothing of the wood engraving’s central Victorian role as a medium of exposition and explanation, nonetheless the Illuminated Magazine also contained images of rare power in delineating both the textures of contemporary experience and the socio-psychological anxieties of early Victorian Britain. More formally experimental than the Illustrated London News, more complex and confrontational than Punch and without the didactic or sectarian purposefulness of the Penny or the Saturday, the illustrations in the Illuminated Magazine, under the direction of two pioneering art editors, suggested a moment when wood engraving represented both a high level of achievement and an almost unlimited potential for further development. Just as the magazine more widely attempted to re-present genteel culture to a more democratically assembled reading public and progressive ideas to an unenlightened broad readership, so the illustrations sought to convince early Victorian society of the range and depth of images becoming available through the emergent virtuosity of wood engravers and their work.
Notes 1. F.B. Smith states categorically that the Illuminated Magazine was ‘modelled on Punch’, but, while this would hardly be surprising given Jerrold’s many links with Punch, I think the format of The Illuminated Magazine is in fact built out of many elements available in literature of the time. [Smith p. 62]. 2. Illuminated Magazine vol. 1, 1 (May 1843) Preface. All further references to the Illuminated Magazine will be in brackets in the text. 3. The key biographical sources for accounts of the Illuminated Magazine are Blanchard Jerrold (1859); F.B. Smith (1973); and M Slater (2002). 4. Spielmann, in The History of Punch, gives the full list of proprietors as Herbert Ingram, Ebenezer Landells, N. Cooke, T. Roberts, W. Little and R. Palmer (Spielmann p. 35). 5. Slater pp. 141–143. 6. Spielmann pp. 33–35. Spielmann notes that Jerrold at this time described Landells as ‘that engraving Jonah’ yet ‘was glad enough to take advantage of [his] influence the following year.’ 7. Slater p. 145. Slater very usefully prints a range of reactions to the magazine drawn from cuttings in the Moran Collection in the British Museum. 8. Smith p. 62. 9. Smith p. 62.
Brian Maidment 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 25. 26.
39
Slater p. 151. Slater p. 146. Douglas Jerrold Punch’s Letters to his Son (W S Orr 1843). For Hine’s career see R K Engen pp. 121–122. Slater p. 146. Slater p. 145. Slater p. 145. Slater p. 147. Slater p. 149. Smith pp. 63–65. Lovett p. 2003. The Illustrated London News with its multi-columned page and extremely large paper size might have been expected to show more interest in building its pages into shapes less constrained by the geometry of its columns. For a useful recent discussion of the relationship between image, text and page in Victorian periodicals see Sinnema. There is considerable dispute about how long Landells was actually a member of Bewick’s workshop – see Engen p. 149. Engen p. 38. Engen p. 179. Everitt pp. 355–363; Engen pp. 178–179; Houfe pp. 387. Everitt pp. 360–361.
2 Accurate Dreams or Illustrations of Desire: Image and Text in the Gardener’s Magazine (1826–44) Edited by John Claudius Loudon Sarah Dewis
The heterogeneity of the images (visual representations on the page), and their unevenness in quality and execution in the Gardener’s Magazine, have been perceived as a sign of failure: The Gardener’s Magazine, which was so outspoken about the quality of the plates in other horticultural magazines, is not noted for its own illustrations, many of which are merely practical diagrams of horticultural buildings and equipment [...] An exception is its wood engraved views of landscapes and gardens now imbued with period charm.1 In this chapter I will place the magazine in a print media context, and argue that the heterogeneity of the images, which was the result of technological advances that Loudon exploited, is a reflection, and product of, the diversity of his reading audience. My focus on an article from the magazine containing both image and text will demonstrate the tensions amongst this audience and the potential for fragmentation realised after the Reform Act of 1832. John Claudius Loudon (1783–43), son of a farmer, was born in Lanarkshire, Scotland, and attended Edinburgh University from 1798 to 1802, while apprentice to a market gardener. On his arrival in London in 1803, he was introduced to Jeremy Bentham, and consequently much of his work appears to have been driven by the Scottish Enlightenment’s anti-aristocratic ideal of scientific knowledge and Bentham’s utilitarian philosophy. He began his career as a landscape designer and farmer and having acquired considerable wealth before the age of 30, he went on a tour of Europe. The organisation of local governments and cities that he visited influenced the development 40
Sarah Dewis 41
of his ideas. Writing became his main occupation after his money was lost in speculation and progressive rheumatism led to the amputation of his right arm in 1825. Through monthly, bi-monthly, annual and ‘completed’ publications, which reduced costs and ensured that his work reached diverse audiences, Loudon augmented and codified professional knowledge in landscape gardening, horticulture and botany.2 Apart from the Gardener’s Magazine, he established and edited the Architectural Magazine and the Magazine of Natural History.3 His part in the development of the science of horticulture has not yet been fully documented, but his influence on the shaping of domestic ideology through gardens and architecture, exemplified in his Suburban Gardener and Villa Companion,4 has been debated by the historians Leonore Davidoff and Catherine Hall (1987), and the garden historian Heath Schenker (2002).5 The Gardener’s Magazine, and Register of Rural and Domestic Improvement (1826–44) was a new quarterly 5s periodical for gardeners first issued in January 1826.6 Initially published by Longman, Loudon was the proprietor and editor of the magazine, transforming it the following year into a bi-monthly whose price was reduced to 3s 6d.7 In 1831 it became a monthly and in 1834 the price was further reduced from 2s 6d to 1s 6d.8 Originally a periodical of over 125 pages, becoming 50 pages in its monthly form, it was the first in Britain to combine science with the aesthetics of gardens, and contained a mix of articles on horticulture, landscape, new scientific discoveries, history, and social and political issues. The intended reading audience, the ‘Gardener’s’, of the title, was a diverse one which ranged from professional gardeners at the top of their careers, land stewards, landscape gardeners, practical gardeners as well as ‘young’ gardeners starting out, to wealthy land-owners and philanthropists, and amateur practitioners, including middle-class owners or renters of gardens and male or female family members. The magazine would have been read or borrowed from the private library of the wealthier reader, but it was also available to the working man through myriad ‘library’ systems which allowed the poorer reader access to books. Coffee houses of urban areas and pubs around the country supplied reading material, and from 1827, Loudon campaigned through his magazine to establish garden libraries in parallel with urban libraries of the Mechanic’s Institutes, some of which held copies of it.9 The presence of images within the magazine allies it with the culture of scientific or technical publications which were generally illustrated, and contrasts with the dearth of images displayed in the ‘literary’ magazines of similar price, due to editorial policy that privileged written text because of the association of images with the less literate culture of the poor and of children. The production values of the images within scientific publications, however, varied. The Transactions of the Horticultural Society (1807–48), an elite and irregularly printed horticultural publication,
42 Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
contained engravings of copper, and a few of steel.10 A fine sharp tool, or burin, used to incise the copper, was similar to that used to engrave against the grain of the hard boxwood of the wood engravings which predominate in the Gardener’s Magazine.11 These displayed greater variation of light and shade than was possible in the woodcuts of handbills and cheaper publications such as the Mechanic’s Magazine (1823–29) as they were carved with broad-nibbed knives which followed the grain of the soft-wood traditionally used.12 The image of both woodcut and wood engraving, however, was carved in relief, with the areas to be printed raised up from lower-lying areas which remained white, so that it could be reproduced with type on the same page, in contrast to copper and steel plates in which the incisions followed the line of the drawing and filled with ink.13 The overall integration of text with image made possible by wood engraving marked a turning point in periodical production in 1826 when the Gardener’s Magazine (GM) first started. The relative cheapness of the process enabled a greater number of images to be printed, allowing Loudon to reduce the price of his magazine and gain a broader readership. He points out: ‘Though our articles are not ornamented by coloured plates, or engravings from copper or steel, yet they are illustrated by a greater number of engravings from wood, sufficiently intelligible for all useful purposes’ (GM, 2, March 1827, 438).14 His argument is that the function of the image in the Gardener’s Magazine is not to delight the eye but to explain process. The average proportion of image to text within the pages of the Gardener’s Magazine is not easy to estimate as the number of images varied considerably from month to month and from year to year. However, it is reasonable to conclude that there was a rise in proportion of image to text from 5 per cent in 1826 to a high of over 20 per cent by 1839, with fluctuations in the intervening years, followed by a steady decline towards the final volumes, down to an average of 3 per cent in 1842.15 The decline in number of images coincides with a rise in simple single line images and reflects the increasing financial precariousness of the magazine, as a result of the debts accrued through the production of another of Loudon’s publications, as well as declining circulation. As the budget for the Gardener’s Magazine diminished, he trained members of his family to draw plants and make wood engravings. Between 1838 and 1840, a series of articles under the title of ‘Descriptive Notices of select Suburban Residences, with Remarks on each; intending to illustrate the Principles and Practice of Landscape-Gardening’ appeared in the Gardener’s Magazine. The articles were mostly researched and written by Loudon, with images especially produced in some cases, and were positioned, generally, as the leading item of each number. The title of the series recalled the work of Humphry Repton, whose Observations on the Theory and Practice of Landscape first published in 1803, made recommendations on the
Sarah Dewis 43
aesthetics and construction of landscape and architecture for the landed gentry. Loudon’s series on suburban homes of several decades later, may have been part of his editorial strategy to maintain a metropolitan, less wealthy, middle-class and female audience, as some articles were also printed in his Suburban Gardener and Villa Companion which was intended ‘more particularly for the use of ladies’.16 At the same time, cheaper publications such as the Gardener’s Gazette, established in 1837, and the first horticultural newspaper, was diverting the readership of professional gardeners. My focus is the small seven-acre Cheshunt estate of Mr Harrison featured in December 1839 (GM, 15, December 1839, 633–74).17 It is, Loudon claims, exemplary of the Gardenesque (670), an aesthetic of planting he developed based on science. More suited to the modest acreage of the middle classes, it did not depend for its effect on the broader canvas of the picturesque derived from the composition of the paintings of Claude, or the re-creation of ‘natural’ landscape produced by Capability Brown on aristocratic estates to enhance and disguise economic productivity. As Schenker has argued in her essay on the contribution of Loudon and his wife, Jane Webb Loudon, to the development of the domestic garden, the Gardenesque can be more clearly understood in a social context, rather than within an aesthetic narrative of garden history.18 The plurality of forms of image with which the house and its land are represented in the Cheshunt text, would have been recognised by its readers. Frank Howard, whose, Sketcher’s Manual or the Whole Art of Picture Making, was reviewed by Loudon in the Gardener’s Magazine a few months previously, states: ‘The term Picture here is used in a general sense, as meaning an agreeable object, or combination of objects, for contemplation; and Pictorial Effect is the term applied to that which distinguishes a Picture from a diagram or map.’19 Howard differentiates between the polite, aesthetic discourse of the picture, and the scientific or technical discourse of the diagram or plan. The combined presence in the Cheshunt article of these diverse genre of image supports the disparate elements of the text which range from lists derived from the plans, and vocabulary of scientific treatise characteristic of scientific discourse, to the aesthetic discourse of a narrative of travel, or garden tour. My argument is that these images and texts compete for the readers’ attention, to the extent that the reader’s status is continually shifting between that of ‘spectator’ and ‘young gardener’. This creates a specific political dynamic which may have alienated the wealthier reader. Despite its proximity to London, the rusticity of Cheshunt is clearly established on the journey through ‘numerous little interesting lanes’ which are ‘very rural and umbrageous’ (GM, 15, December 1839, 631), and with the first engraving of the Cheshunt cottage itself (Fig. 2.1). Loudon addresses the ‘spectator’ (639), the ‘citizen’ (635), the ‘amateur’ (637) and the ‘stranger’ (641), who are of similar rank, but with a variety of interests, and who might all aspire to live in a house, or ‘cottage’ (632),
44 Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
Figure 2.1 Front page, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 633. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200.
Sarah Dewis 45
which is ‘replete with every description of accommodation and convenience requisite for the enjoyment of all the comforts and luxuries that a man of taste can desire for himself and his friends’ (637). The spectator is set apart from the world of work, has the wealth and leisure to look beyond his or her own life, and observe works of art and other countries and cultures. His or her province might be derived from the ‘picturesque eye’ suggested by the once influential William Gilpin in his Three Essays on Picturesque Beauty of 1792, which is to ‘survey nature; not to anatomise matter’, and which ‘examines parts, but never descends to particles’.20 We shall see, however, that because the Gardener’s Magazine involves the reader in the means of production of the garden, his/her status shifts between polite spectator and producer/gardener. The reader/viewer as spectator is signalled in both captions of two large full-page vignettes in the opening pages, ‘View from the Drawingroom Window at Cheshunt Cottage, looking to the Left’ (Fig. 2.2), and ‘View from the Drawingroom Window at Cheshunt Cottage looking to the Right’ (not shown). The ‘view’ here identifies the leisured readers who might make sketches of the surrounding landscape (a figure of a woman sketching is portrayed on the left-hand edge of Fig. 2.2), or, who, as readers of Howard or Gilpin, were interested in sketching as a fashionable activity and were accustomed to looking at images of landscape. Furthermore, the indeterminate edge of the form of the vignette itself, makes it, as Ruskin suggested at the time, a vehicle of the aesthetic imagination: ‘All harshness is thus avoided, and we feel as if we might see more if we chose, beyond the dreamy and undecided limit, but we have no desire to move the eye from its indicated place of rest’.21 The effect of the women represented in Figure 2.2, and of the woman and child in the view from ‘the Right’ (not shown), naturalises their place in the garden. Different kinds of trees and shrubs are dotted across the flat plain, and Loudon warns his readers that ‘the beauties of the place, to a stranger at his first glance, appear of the quiet and melancholy kind’ (GM, 15, December 1939, 635). He implies that appreciation of his Gardenesque style of planting, achieved at Cheshunt through the efforts of Mr Harrison, the proprietor, and Mr Pratt, the head gardener, depends on ‘nearer examination’ (Ibid) of the vegetation, and knowledge of it. Whilst Loudon claimed that the Gardenesque could be combined with a variety of gardening styles, at Cheshunt the trees are scattered singly, both to break up the view and to encourage them to grow to their ‘natural shape’ (607). A list of the plants on the lawn depicted in the drawing room views, towards the end of the text (over 30 pages after the vignette) may have been part of Loudon’s strategy to engage the ‘spectator’ or garden visitor for the first part, leaving the scientist and practical gardener to persevere to the end. Through the darkness of the pine, the starkness of ‘naked’ poplars, the contrast of leaf size, variety of form, and the varied colours with
Figure 2.2 ‘View from the Drawingroom Window at Cheshunt Cottage, looking to the Left’, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 634. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200.
Sarah Dewis 47
‘green-barked shoots’, ‘yellowish leaves’, and the ‘purple’ of the beech and hazel, culminating in the ‘scarlet’ arbutus (670), Loudon builds up an impression of abundance and diversity which is less clearly conveyed by the vignette. The differing forms, textures and colours of the ‘Montpelier maple’, the ‘American oaks’, the ‘Kentucky coffee tree’, the ‘Oriental plane’, and the ‘Nepal Sorbus’ (Ibid), also exemplify the Gardenesque as the product of, and a contributing factor towards, the expansion of empire. The vignettes ‘from the Drawingroom Window’ then, represent an outdoor laboratory, whose value lies in identification of species. Their accuracy is suggested by the precision of the captions ‘looking to the left’ and ‘looking to the right’. These remind the reader of the authenticity of the material, and the effort that has gone into the creation of the image at a time when copies of paintings and standard cuts (c.f. Bewick) and borrowings from other publications were common illustrative devices. The value of the place and moment at which the drawing has been made has more in common with Loudon’s use of the term ‘sketch’ which he referred to in his ‘Garden Calls’. These consisted of notes on gardens visited, and were placed at the back of each number. He comments: ‘We looked over the premises and made sketches’ (GM, 5, December 1829, 674). The results were small 20cm square, single line images of farm implements, including a ‘daisy rake’, and a ‘cast iron frame for a grindstone’ (Ibid). His use of the term fits with that given in the OED as ‘a rough drawing or delineation of something, giving the outlines or prominent features without the detail’. Loudon retains for science the idea of the sketch as something incomplete, which provides an accurate assessment, whilst also suggesting journalistic modesty. Martina Lauster, in her discussion of the sketch in nineteenth-century journalism, has referred to it as ‘an essentially rhetorical form which seeks to persuade the viewer or reader that less is more, while allowing a whole range of ideological agendas to work beneath the surface of the spontaneous imagination’.22 It might be that that the economy of method of production of Loudon’s vignettes of Cheshunt, which suggest the topography as it might be experienced by the tourist visiting the garden, affirm, via a literal reading, the benefits of property, consumption and family. Other forms of visual representation, the plans and diagrams, suggest alternative agendas, and, as the opening vignettes are succeeded by a series of plans of the house and its surrounding land, the reader’s status shifts, as they enable her/him to understand structure. The linear plan of the house shows numerous room and passages, including a library and museum confirming that ‘Cheshunt Cottage’ is the residence of a gentleman. Female readers might be interested in the plans, particularly of the house, as historians have shown that the maintenance of the home of the less than aristocratic, involved the house as well as duties on the surrounding land, because so much housekeeping was still linked up with husbandry in the early nineteenth century. 23
48
Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
The buildings represented on the plan of the working areas (Fig. 2.3.A & B), which succeed the house plan, are linear in order that the letters on them, indicating their function, can be clearly seen. The vegetation is tonally represented but without the projected shadow of the final plan which displays the whole of the estate, the house and offices,
A Figure 2.3 Work areas plan of Cheshunt Cottage, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 642–43. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200.
Sarah Dewis 49
B
50 Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
the farm, and the pleasure grounds, and is placed towards the end of the text (Fig. 2.4.A). The shadow of trees and the rendering of the architecture of the estate plan, is a more three dimensional, polite, view, representing the extent of
A Figure 2.4 Estate plan of Cheshunt Cottage, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 656–57. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200.
Sarah Dewis 51
the property, which would have been useful in legal disputes involving ownership and property boundaries. The simpler style of the working plan (Fig. 2.4.B) clarifies instead the different areas within the estate and the communities that serve them, showing how they co-exist in a healthy and efficient way. The visibility of the servants here questions the assumption of
B
52
Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
every rank in its place as the house of Mr Harrison, the proprietor, is off limits (it would be at the bottom left), and the privy of Mr Pratt the head gardener, is just off the centre of the page, suggestive of his primary role in the running of the estate. The privies of other servants are indicated on the plan (next to ‘23’ and ‘29’, Fig. 2.3.B) and are listed in the text, whilst those of the proprietors and house servants are indicated on the house plan. Their presence on the page is indicative of Loudon’s concern with the spread of disease; sanitary drainage and avoidance of smell are important elements of his architectural discourse.24 The reader is informed about methods of wafting unpleasant smells away from the spectator, whether from the privy, the boiling of meat for dogs, or from the heating of pitch (‘27’, Fig. 2.3.B). Loudon posits the privy here, in relation to ‘you’, the reader. This reflects the professional status of some of Loudon’s readers who as gardeners and servants might be the ‘other’. Sanitary drainage and health were issues articulated in treatises by interested individuals, government papers and some newspapers. In response to fears generated by the epidemic of Cholera in Europe of 1831, correspondents to The Times had argued for a ‘proper and complete drainage’ for London.25 In the Monthly Magazine four years later, a town in which ‘no alternative is left to the inhabitants, therefore, but fouling the streets with all kinds of excrementitious matter’ is described in relation to the ‘manufacturing population’, who are not, however, the readers themselves.26 The vignette ‘View from the Chinese Temple’ (not shown), returns to the spectator’s journey. The aesthetic of exploration is sustained by the image of dappled light and water framed within Chinese style architecture. However, immediately below this vignette, the text refers to the maintenance of rabbits and the prevention ‘of boys or idle persons getting into the rabbit-house’ (GM, 15, December 1839, 651). This is part of a list (not shown) that links to the working plan (Fig. 2.3), and makes the reader aware of the co-existence of servants, their work and their families on the estate; No. 51 is a ‘Court for enclosing the coachman’s children’; 52, the ‘Lobby to the dairy’; 53, the ‘Lobby to Mr Pratt’s brewhouse’; 54, ‘Cellar’; 55, ‘Chickenyard’; 56, ‘Farmer’s yard’; 58, ‘Place for slaughtering in’. No. 60, ‘Shed for compost’ (650) leads to an account of the production of manure. The effect on the reader of the integration of text with image on the same page, as well as the different forms of visual representation, is to make her/him conscious of the ceaseless activity of the servants who maintain the suburban residence and of the cycles of fermentation, rotting and feeding that maintain the luxuriant vegetation portrayed in the vignettes. Beyond the bushes framing the vignette, then, lies not a Chinese mountain, but a noisy, smelly, working farm. At the centre of the working plan of the estate (Fig. 2.3), lie the farm buildings, nos. ‘18’–‘26’ and it is here that the livestock are kept. Number ‘26’ indicates the tank containing food for the pigs and this gives rise to an
Sarah Dewis 53
explanation on the advantages of fermenting food that Loudon has adapted from the Quarterly Journal of Agriculture: According to the doctrine there laid down, the globules of meal, or farinaceous matter of the roots and seeds of plants, lie closely compacted together, within membranes so exquisitely thin and transparent, that their texture is scarcely to be discerned with the most powerful microscope. Each farinaceous particle is, therefore, considered as enveloped in a vesicle, which it is necessary to burst, in order to allow the soluble or nutritious parts to escape. This bursting is effected by boiling, or other modes of cookery [...] but it is also effected by the heat and decomposition produced by fermentation [...] Plants are nourished by the ultimate particles of manure, in the same way that animals are nourished by the ultimate particles of food; and hence fermentation is as essential to the dunghill as cookery to food. The young gardener, as well as the young farmer, may learn from this the vast importance of fermentation, in preparing food for both plants and animals’. (GM, 15, December 1839, 648) From the singular detail and delicacy of the membranes of meal and plant seeds which are only just visible to the ‘most powerful microscope’, the energy of the process of fermentation is described as the particles ‘escape’ and ‘burst’. The comparison of the process with that of cookery to food, highlights the connection of human beings to the feeding of plants and animals. The effect of the ‘vast importance’ of microscopic detail on the reader might be to marginalise divine purpose. I quote this passage at length in order to show that the aesthetic narrative of the tour of the opening pages has been displaced by an account of science, and that the identity of the reader as ‘spectator’ (639) or ‘stranger’ (641), has also shifted to that of producer – the ‘young farmer’ or ‘young gardener’ (648), whose chief interest lies in ‘ultimate particles’. The caption to Figure 2.5, a full-page vignette of ‘General View of the Hot-houses, as seen across the American garden’ (areas ‘3’–‘15’ on the estate plan, Fig. 2.4), reflects once more, the aesthetic of exploration. The ‘American’ of the caption refers to the origin of the plants. The buildings, whose weather vane might suggest a church spire, are surrounded by vegetation, through which the spectator or explorer may wander at peace. The text opposite the vignette animates the view (or renders it superfluous) because it draws attention to those who work in and around the hothouse. Loudon has ‘transcribed’ (647) a series of rules applying to ‘all persons working on these premises, masters and men’. The fines grow from 3d for minor offences such as not cleaning the tools or failing to return them to their correct place, to 6d for ‘bad language’, and one shilling for drunken behaviour, which, in relation to a journeyman
Figure 2.5 ‘General View of the Hot-houses, as seen across the American Garden’, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 646. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200.
Sarah Dewis 55
gardener’s pay of less than ‘10s or 12s a week’ (GM, 8, 1832, iv), and even less for the semi-skilled gardener, constituted severe punishment. The focus on bad language and drunken behaviour indicates its prevalence amongst the people who worked on the estate, while the size of the fine imposed suggests the danger that their disorderliness posed to the employer. The text then, belies the tranquillity of the view. It is also open to alternative readings. Mr Harrison’s comments that the system of fines has been effective in ‘preventing all slovenly practises, which he considers as thus purchased at a very cheap rate’ (GM, 15 December 1839, 647), might suggest a way for the reader as spectator to deal with servants. For the reader as ‘young gardener’ the masterly status of Mr Pratt, who collects the fines, and who is responsible for both men and tools, might suggest a profession to aspire to. Towards the end of the account Loudon summarises ‘the principal sources of professional instruction which the young gardener may derive from examining this place’ (659). Figure 2.6.A and B displays on a double spread, the mix of diagram and vignette which up to this point have appeared sequentially. Loudon’s use of the term ‘diagram’ is based on a kinetic process applied mainly to man-made objects, here representing the back elevation of the ‘Rustic Covered seat of woodwork’, and ‘the manner in which the barked poles’ of the seat of the vignette above ‘are arranged’ (658). This might inform the ‘young gardener’ or ‘young designer’ (659), who could construct a similar garden structure, but its proximity to the vignette competes with the illusion of leisure and the garden tour that the empty seat suggests. The diagram opposite represents the walls and roof of the hothouse. Based on the ‘ridge and furrow’ principle, Loudon had experimented with this form of hothouse or ‘botanic stove’ that his younger rival Joseph Paxton had subsequently developed to greater effect at Chatsworth. The result was a ‘pleating’ of the glass which could bear the weight of greater amounts of snow and was therefore more stable than a smooth roof, as well as increasing the amount of exposure to daylight and heat. The uneven surface (shown clearly in the diagram) facilitated the cultivation of tropical plants such as the Brugmansia suaveolens (Datura arborea L.), a native plant of India and South America, which Loudon is awed by: There is a plant of [...] 15ft. high, with a head 13ft. in diameter. When we saw it, August 10th, 277 blossoms were expanded at once, producing an effect upon the spectator under the tree, when looking up, which no language can describe. Last year it produced successions of blossoms, in one of which 600 were fully expanded at one time. This year it has had five successions of blossoms, and another is now coming out as the plant expands in growth. (645)
56 Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
A Figure 2.6 ‘Rustic Covered Seat of Woodwork’, ‘Elevation of the Back’, elevation of ‘part of the front’ of a hothouse, and cross section ‘through the middle of one of the ridges of the roof’, Gardener’s Magazine, 15 December 1839, 660–61. © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved. BL GM pp. 2200.
Sarah Dewis 57
B
58 Image and Text in Loudon’s Gardener’s Magazine
The number of blossoms, the size and the frequency of blooming, of the Brugmansia in Cheshunt is the product of the gardener’s labour and developments in the technology of glass. Loudon’s fascination with productivity, labour and science is confirmed through the heterogeneity of images featured in Fig. 2.6.A and B, suggesting the displacement of aesthetics by science, along with the marginalisation of the ‘spectator’ reader within the pages of the magazine. The diagram might also indicate the transformation of the hothouse as ‘orangery’ and part of an elite household where citrus fruits could be kept warm in winter, to the ‘conservatory’, that was becoming the property of the middle classes.27 We have seen how the Cheshunt text shifts from the discursiveness of the opening, and an account of the journey through and around the house and grounds of Cheshunt Cottage, to a series of lists attached to the plans, part of which is a scientific discourse on fermentation, and which is punctuated by varied forms of visual representation. The process of wood engraving, then allows Loudon great fluidity in the representation of his subject, and a multi-faceted exploration of the Gardenesque in which science, production and labour are the predominant factors in comparison with aesthetics and consumption. He pays his respects to Mr Harrison, the proprietor, whom he credits as the architect and designer of the estate, and he notes that servants need to be kept in order. However, Loudon’s intention was to professionalise the body of gardening knowledge and raise the status of practical gardeners. The labour of servants, exemplified by the responsibilities and creative power of the head gardener, Mr Pratt, whom, Loudon reassures his spectator readers, is a ‘singularly modest and unassuming man’ (674), is fore-grounded in this account. The effect of the visibility of Mr Pratt’s intelligence and competence on the reader might be to question inordinate differences of wealth, and the justice of the 1832 Reform Act which had denied the majority of working men the right to vote with the £10 a year householder qualification. Cheshunt cottage was part of a series whose ‘wood engraved views’ may have been intended to attract those who might own or rent suburban properties.28 In addressing all gardeners therefore, and the ‘young gardener’ in particular, Loudon risked alienating the gentlemanly reader and the female spectators portrayed in the view from the drawing room window of Fig. 2.2.
Notes 1. Desmond pp. 95–6. 2. Schenker p. 342; Taylor pp. 17–67. 3. The Architectural Magazine and Journal of Improvement in Architecture, Building and Furnishing (London: Longman, 1834–39); The Magazine of Natural History, and Journal of Zoology, Botany, Mineralogy, Geology, and Meteorology (London: Longman, 1828–36).
Sarah Dewis 59 4. The Suburban Gardener and Villa Companion: Comprising the Choice of a Suburban or Villa Residence, or of a Situation on Which to Form One (London: printed for the author, sold by Longman; Edinburgh, sold by W. Black, 1838). Henceforth to be referred to as The Suburban Gardener. 5. Davidoff and Hall pp. 180–92. 6. The Gardener’s Magazine, and Register of Rural and Domestic Improvement, 19 vols (London: Longman, 1826–44). Henceforth to be referred to as GM in endnotes and brackets. The final number of January 1844, is not included in every edition of the bound annual volumes of no. 19 (1843). 7. Longman published on commission from Loudon, with an initial agreement of 2/5 in 1826, reduced to 1/10 in 1834. In 1839 Longman ceased to publish on commission and retained distribution only. 8. Price given in an advert at the back of Loudon’s Encyclopaedia of Cottage, Farm and Villa Architecture, 1835 edition; Desmond, pp. 79–103 (p. 94). Alternatively, in 1834 the price was reduced to 1s 2d. See Brent Elliott (2004) ‘Loudon, John Claudius (1783–1843)’ Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/17031> [accessed 29 October 2007]. 9. For example, the Manchester Mechanic’s Institute. 10. The price was fixed a £1 per number in 1818 for members and at £1 1s 6d for the public. Women were not allowed to become members until 1830. 11. Desmond pp. 79–103 (p. 94). 12. The Mechanic’s Magazine contained woodcuts and wood engravings. 13. Lauster p. 35. See also Henry Cole, ‘Modern Wood Engraving’, London and Westminster Review, 29 (August 1839), pp. 265–80. 14. Desmond pp. 79–103 (p. 80). 15. These figures are based on my calculations of space covered by image in relation to total pagination of selected volumes; 1826 GM, 1; 1829 GM, 5; 1834 GM, 10; 1839 GM, 15; 1842 GM, 18. 16. Loudon, The Suburban Gardener (Frontispiece). 17. A ‘suburban’ garden ranged from one perch to a hundred acres. Loudon, The Suburban Gardener (Frontispiece; p. 622). 18. Schenker pp. 337–60 (p. 337). 19. Frank Howard (1837) The Sketcher’s Manual, or the Whole Art of Picture Making Reduced to Simplest Principles (London: Darton and Clark), pp. viii–ix; GM, 15 (August 1838), p. 470. 20. Gilpin p. 26; Bermingham p. 93. 21. Ruskin quoted by Loudon p. 37. 22. Lauster (p. 2), with reference to Richard Sha. 23. Vickery pp. 127–60. 24. ‘He was publishing designs for water closets a full generation before they were standard even in urban houses’, Mercer. 25. Times Digital Archive, Tuesday 25 October 1831, p. 3 < http://infotrac.galegroup. com> [accessed 18 January 2008]. 26. Monthly Magazine, 19 (January 1835), p. 51. 27. At the time of publication the term ‘hothouse’ was the generic term for a range of specialised greenhouses. 28. Desmond p. 96.
3 Alaric ‘Attila’ Watts, the Fraser’s Portrait Gallery, and William Maginn David E. Latané, Jr.
The Fraser’s ‘Gallery of Illustrious Literary Characters’ ran from 1830 to 1838 and influenced subsequent generations’ views of the early Victorian milieu.1 Some recent critics, especially those concerned with the representation of women writers, treat the Gallery as representative or typical of the attitudes of the age.2 It is easy to do so, in part, because the eccentric and forceful originator of the series, William Maginn, generally avoided literary celebrity (for himself), even while writing a personality-filled portrait each month. (The letterpress for his own portrait, written by his friend John Gibson Lockhart, refers to him only as ‘The Doctor’ and never mentions his name – though it is given in facsimile signature under Maclise’s drawing.) One of the keys to understanding the series, however, is to probe Maginn’s atypical concerns, especially his paradoxical championing of literary ‘personality.’ Margaret Russett has argued that ‘[t]he virulence of magazine personalities symptomatizes both the subversion of proper identity and the commodification of fame as (sheer) personality that became increasingly exaggerated in the world of periodical print’ (1997, 133). Maginn was keenly aware of both parts of this formula. Blackwood’s famously inaugurated a new era of magazining when William Blackwood in 1817 sacked his editors James Pringle and Thomas Cleghorn after the first six issues, took the reins himself, and began publishing violent personal attacks on Whigs and others by John Wilson, John Gibson Lockhart, and (in 1819) an anonymous Cork correspondent, ‘R.T.S.’ (Maginn). Maginn’s early contributions had served up spicy dishes of Cork notables, but when he arrived in London in early 1824 he found greater pressure to make bland his cookery. What was amusing when told about the Cork Philosophical Society became ‘blackguardism’ when written about Members of Parliament. One result was that Maginn wrote, to the dismay (real or feigned) of his Edinburgh friends, in ‘low’ periodicals such as the John Bull Magazine and the Telescope. For Blackwood, once a solid 60
David E. Latané, Jr. 61
subscription base existed then the worry about maintenance began. Beginning in the mid-1820s, while he encouraged Maginn to renew his flow of contributions to his ‘Maga’, he discouraged ‘personalities’.3 Fraser’s was founded in part because William Maginn was determined to activate a venue that would sustain the free-wheeling modes of the early years of Blackwood’s, and bring a personal castigation to those whom he considered the prime humbugs of the age: the commodifiers of their own fame. Maginn conceived of Fraser’s as a sort of supercharged, metropolitan Blackwood’s, doing for the big stage of London what ‘Maga’ had done in its first years for Edinburgh – fictionalizing its notable personalities through a series of carnivalesque depictions. Where Blackwood’s had its pithy ‘Chaldee Manuscript’ (September 1817), Maginn produced a lengthy ‘Election of the Editor for Fraser’s Magazine’ (May and July, 1830), which names about 160 individuals. The ‘Gallery’ deepened this nominal frame by combining Maginn’s text with lithographs by ‘Alfred Croquis’ (Daniel Maclise), seemingly drawn by stealth, that engage in dialogue with the text. The originality of the ‘Gallery’ is chiefly in this dialogue. The tradition of freestanding pictorial satire from Hogarth to Gilray to the Cruikshanks combined in the 1820s with text in such works as Charles Molloy Westmacott’s the English Spy (1825), but its pictures chastised types, and the text concealed names with dashes and asterisks. Another mode can be found in periodicals such as the Literary Speculum (1821–23), which featured a portrait each month to accompany a critical assessment, but its stiff woodcuts are invariably head and shoulder portraits, with elaborate framing, and the text does not comment on the image. Maginn and Maclise combined the sauciness and movement of the satiric print tradition with the verbal ‘personalities’ inherited from Blackwood. Maginn was not, however, interested solely in satire. He also delighted in the inside joke, the frisson of privacy half-revealed, and many of the men and women chosen for the ‘Gallery’ were friends or acquaintances – or he was the recipient of gossip from those who were. Distortions and fabrications, like those Robert Patten complains about in the entry for George Cruikshank (1992, 386, 388), were I suspect not so much made from ignorance but rather part of the fun. The ‘Gallery’ made Fraser’s a success. In the June 1835 ‘Gallery’, Maginn and his fellow Corkman Maclise pushed the boundaries of personality too far, resulting in the chief lawsuit for libel brought against the magazine during his tenure. This involved, perhaps surprisingly, the minor poet, giftbook editor, and veteran Tory newspaperman Alaric Alexander Watts (Fig. 3.1). The case of ‘Watts versus Fraser and Moyes’ was heard before the King’s Bench on 5 December 1835. The affair was illustrated in the next issue of Fraser’s by an anecdote of William Cobbett’s about two countrymen fighting with fists until the instigator, now losing, decides to pull a knife, and in turn is thrashed with a stick (‘Mr. Alaric Alexander Watts’, 1836, 129). The
62 Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
Figure 3.1 ‘Alaric A. Watts: The Editor of “The Literary Souvenir”’. Fraser's Magazine, June 1835, 653.
David E. Latané, Jr. 63
‘Gallery’ portrait, it is implied, was Fraser’s stick, and Watts had started the fight. As newspapermen, Maginn and Watts were Tory mainstays; as men of letters, however, they represent two distinct types, and to understand the case it is necessary to trace their relationship. Fraser’s explained the origins of the animosity in its post-trial commentary: It happened that Mr. Watts, for reasons which existed long antecedent to the establishment of this Magazine, thought proper to conceive a violent dislike (we hope the word is not libellous) of a gentleman long known in the world of newspapers and magazines, Dr. Maginn; and this feeling he extended towards every person and thing with which the Doctor was supposed, whether justly or not, to be connected. We have been told, perhaps erroneously, that the pique originated in some newspaper arrangements of a strictly private kind; and we are sure that Dr. Maginn did not give himself the trouble of reciprocating the ill-will of which he was the object. (‘Mr. Alaric Alexander Watts’, 1836, 130) It is well to remember that claims around lawsuits often consist of partial narratives of hotly disputed events, but Maginn’s defense is supported by plenty of evidence from the previous decade of Watts’s splenetic character. They began their literary careers at the same time and in the same place – the pages of William Jerdan’s Literary Gazette circa 1819 – and their lives, works, and relationships were intertwined to an unusual extent. Both were deeply involved in the ‘low’ but lucrative world of the newspapers, but Watts was much more concerned about his status as a gentleman and his literary ‘name’ than Maginn. He published several volumes of poetry, and was very careful to send copies, fulsomely inscribed, to as many prominent writers as possible.4 His giftbook, the Literary Souvenir, appeared with ‘Alaric A. Watts’ prominent on title page and in the table of contents of each issue. As a measure of his egotism, when he edited Men of the Time in the 1850s he gave himself three times the space of Tennyson. Maginn, to the contrary, began his career with an exceptional concern with invisibility. His creed was that only a goose would acknowledge or deny authorship to the public, and he tried to avoid having any of his numerous pseudonyms become a nom de plume. He often wrote collaboratively, and in the midst of company, and it wasn’t until 1836 that he began signing some of his magazine pieces. After his death when influential friends tried to raise a fund for his family, they were hampered by his lack of name recognition.5 Watts, one might say, was a visible creature of visual culture, of the culture of commodity. His name resonates through the age, branding giftbook, periodical, volumes of poems, and so on. Maginn’s friend, the Irish novelist Gerald Griffin, described Watts in a letter to his sister in 1829 ‘reposing amid all the glorious litter of a literary lion-monger – sofas, silk cushions, paintings, portfolios, and so on. He is a little fellow, very smart
64
Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
and bustling, with about as much sentiment as you have of bravery – I mean bloody field of battle bravery’ (qtd in Mannin 71). His observation about Watts’s lack of sentiment argues that Watts’s own very sentimental poems were just another form of literary entrepreneurship, that he was a poetic humbug. For Watts, ‘A.A. Watts’ was a trademark associated with things, rather than thoughts or positions. The change of the name of his giftbook in 1835 from The Literary Souvenir to the The Cabinet of Modern Art emphasises his quest for thingness, as he desires his book to be ‘a complete epitome, graphical and literary, of Modern Art’ (‘Preface’, 1836, vii). Maginn, to the contrary, wanted influence via anonymous and amorphous circulation of discourse that couldn’t be reified or depicted. Lockhart’s ‘Gallery’ sketch of Maginn emphasises versatility of instrument: High Church and State doctrines should be seriously adopted, and manfully maintained. Whigs, Papists, Radicals [...] should be exposed, insulted, stabbed, crucified, impaled, drawn, and quartered – in Essay, Disquisition, Review, Romance, Ballad, Squib, Pasquinade, and Epigram – in Greek, in Hebrew, in Latin, in Irish, in Italian, in English, and in Slang: but no interference with the calm pursuits of the scholar, or the graceful amenities of the gentleman. (1831, 716) Fame as an ‘author’ was not part of the programme, and in Fraser’s he boasted that ‘we who write this article in all publicity of anonymous writing, we, we say, never wrote a book ourselves’ (‘An Apology’, 1831, 2). Personalities were, however, legitimate against persons for whom authorship was a goal, and Watts certainly fit the bill. Maginn and Watts may have met through William Jerdan on one of Maginn’s summer visits to London in the early 1820s, as Maginn’s introductions in London came partly through Jerdan. Maginn was also at the time firmly ensconced in William Blackwood’s inner circle, and Watts was campaigning to be part of that group. From his lodgings in Brompton Watts posted a closely written 16-page memorandum of London literary gossip, hoping to curry favor with the Scottish publication; Maginn used the notes in an article, and when accosted by Colburn he told Blackwood ‘I of course denied everything plump. Never wrote anything for anybody’ (Oliphant, Vol. I, 496–98). Watts fed Blackwood and Maginn shop details about his former employer Colburn’s establishment for the ‘Noctes Ambrosianæ’ colloquia and later inserted (unasked) puffs about Maga in the Leeds Intelligencer (Gordon 283). Maginn seems to have trusted Watts in these years; about 1825 he sounded Watts out about the possibility of Hurst (the publisher of the Literary Souvenir) bringing out Maginn’s translations of Beranger, in a tone that implies mutual professionalism and regard (JRL MS 380/1313).6
David E. Latané, Jr. 65
Watts, however, was dishing Maginn behind his back to Blackwood, and in general showing signs of tetchiness, evidenced in his odd prefaces to the Literary Souvenir, and in the hounding of Benjamin Disraeli over Vivian Grey in his magazine the Literary Magnet.7 Maginn has gone down in literary history for his alcoholism, but the abstemious Watts could have used a drink to steady his nerves. A rival editor characterised Watts at this time as ‘splenetic and envious,’ and given to ‘paltry insinuations and spiteful observations’ (‘Saturnalia’, 1827, 56). Watts, according to one commentator, ‘had a special faculty for annoying his literary contemporaries’ (Ellis, Vol. I, 96). In the 1820s his violent quarrel with the teenage Ainsworth, his fellow Mancunian, left the latter fuming in private letters about the ‘kakodemon Watts’ (Ellis Vol. I, 128). His own son, in Alaric Watts: A Narrative of His Life, devotes a separate chapter to ‘Temper’ (1884, Vol. II, 78–86), in which he admits that his father seemed to suffer from ‘some obscure form of disease more or less akin to hysteria’ (77). Maginn, along with Wilson and Lockhart, initially found Watts more ridiculous than annoying, and impossible not to ridicule; Watts, I believe, couldn’t understand how Maginn got away with being Maginn. The origin of serious animosity arises from their joint employment in 1827 on the new Tory evening paper the Standard. The ‘arrangements’ mentioned in the ‘Defense’ were obviously with regard to the Standard, from which Watts boasted, according to testimony at the trial, ‘he could displace him [Maginn] at any time’ (‘Libel’, Times, 1835, 4). Watts was hired first and Maginn more or less usurped his place, which turned into a lucrative and influential employment. Watts and Maginn had a violent dispute in the paper’s Shoe Lane offices in June of 1827, and shortly afterwards Watts resigned, and – not coincidentally I believe – Prime Minister Canning received an anonymous letter informing him that much of the slander in prose and verse against your Administration which fills the Standard and other London newspapers is written by an unprincipled Irishman named MAGINN, who styles himself Doctor, who is protegé and friend of Mr John Wilson Croker. Doctor M. is also at the bottom of all the abuse poured out against you in Blackwood. (Aspinall, 268) Although Maginn contributed two of his best tales to Watts’ Literary Souvenirs of 1828 and 1829 (‘A Vision of Purgatory’ and ‘Jochonan in the City of Demons’), further quarrels were inevitable, and in the 1830 volume Watts unnecessarily printed a note that ‘several articles intended for the present volume reached him too late for insertion, and among others prose sketches from pens of the Author of Holland-tide [Gerald Griffin] and Dr. Maginn’ (qtd. in Mannin 72). Maginn was busy as Watts’s deadline approached (in
66
Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
the Fall of 1829) hatching Fraser’s Magazine, but Watts’s gratuitous mention of his missed deadline was surely a deliberate insult. It is hard to pinpoint, however, exactly where and when serious hostilities began in print. Maginn’s critical tomahawkings and squabashings, in the jocular phraseology of Maga, were mostly in the rough spirit of the Munster lampooning he had grown up with. As Gerald Griffin notes, Maginn ‘imagines that those he attacks think as little of the affair as himself [...]. The other day he attacked Campbell’s Ritter Bann most happily, and at the same time cuttingly, and afterwards wanted Jerdan to get up a dinner and bring Campbell and him together’ (qtd. in ‘Doctor Maginn’, 1852, 612). Watts seems to have turned from his output of sentimental poetry and silvery annuals to the satiric lash purely out of temper and malingering personal resentments. Ironically Watts, unlike Bulwer and Montgomery (and the usual Whig crew of Moore, Rogers, Campbell, et alia), was not one of Fraser’s first targets. The first mention of him, in a list in the ‘Election of the Editor’ is benign, and it isn’t until ‘Symposiac the First’ (November 1830) that, via a complicated dramatic situation, one symposiac takes a Poke at Alaric. I don’t like that Alaric Attila Watts! Whose verses are just like the pans and the pots, Shining on shelves in a cottager’s kitchen, Polish’d and prim. Now a greyhound bitch in The corner, a cat, and some empty bottles, A chubby-faced boy, and the Lord knows what else; All taken together’s a picture, which in My humble opinion is just as rich in Domestic detail, without the ‘what nots’ That smooth down the verses of Alaric Watts. Outroarious laughter followed this; and Jesse, like the rogue he is, kept it up by saying – ‘pray, Alaric Attila, where do you find those fine names – your own and Zilla Madonna? I’m told you hope to supply posterity with sugar-plums, and that they’ll say the sweet, sweet Watts was the very one worth all the rest. Tush, man, never frown – your verses in the Souvenir say all this, only in much more mystificatory language.’ ‘Mr. Jesse,’ said Alaric Attila, ‘the Tales of the Dead.’ – ‘De mortuis nil nisi bonum,’ cried O’Doherty, looking fiercely at the Souvenir, who suddenly lost his recollection, and asked for a coach. This was brought and he departed, as he always does, and dying will do, to the great joy of everyone near him. (492–93)8 The ‘Poke’ significantly presents Watts’s verses as calculated utensils for cooking sentiment, whereas the genre picture preferred (‘a greyhound bitch
David E. Latané, Jr. 67
in/The corner, a cat, and some empty bottles’) has the randomness and roughness of life. This bit of tomfoolery, to Watts’s delightfully understandable annoyance, also launched into wide circulation a deadpan joke of Lockhart’s that the ‘A’ of Watts’s middle initial stood for the fierce ‘Attila’ rather than the correct ‘Alexander’ (see Quarterly, 37, January 1828, 88). But the criticism that Watts aimed to ‘supply posterity with sugar-plums’ is fair enough – and accords with Griffin’s private comment about Watts’s lack of true sentiment. Watts, Fraser’s argues, marketed false poetic pictures. In the next issue’s article on ‘The Annuals’ the Literary Souvenir is generously ranked among the best, though Watts and his wife are criticized for spreading themselves too thin in the launching of multiple annuals, reusing plates, and egotistically printing too many of their own poems. It concludes: ‘We recommend him to concentrate his forces, and strike as boldly as he can; in which case we promise him our good word, and the good word of every other impartial critic’ (1830, 553). Fair words – but words directed to Alaric Attila Watts. Watts now begin inserting slurs on a number of Fraser’s writers in his newspapers, and the Fraserians answered in both newspapers and in Regina. A comical tempest in an ink-pot ensued. In August 1831 ‘A Word on Attila Watts’ (inside front cover) claims that Fraser’s had pulled its punches because an anonymous letter had pointed out that his financial position was precarious and his unoffending family was in need of the receipts from the Souvenir that might be affected by the quarrel. Whether the letter existed or was an invention, it is an accurate enough assessment. Significantly, Maginn charges Watts, ‘the principal fribble among the namby-pambies of the annuals,’ with traducing in his prefaces to the Souvenir ‘every person who appears to have had at any time the misfortune of his acquaintance,’ and with constantly dragging his wife’s name into print. This warning makes Watts’s decision to print a lengthy verse satire attacking the Fraserians in the Literary Souvenir for 1832 all the more extraordinary, since no young Miss wanted a giftbook full of grubstreet spleen. Journals influential in this market – such as La Belle Assemblée – took immediate notice of the poem as a strange anomaly.9 The ‘Conversazione’ begins typically enough, by heaping praise on such stalwarts of the annuals (including Watts’s own) as L.E.L. and Hemans, turns to some mild swipes at Blackwoods, makes a point (taken right from Fraser’s!) about the excessive puffing of Robert Montgomery’s poetry, mentions Watts’s ongoing squabbles with Colburn, and then aims at his main targets: And near to them, from Cork’s gay city, Two funny rogues who do the witty, Inspired by gin and true ‘potheen,’ For Mister Fraser’s Magazine; (235)
68
Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
These were Maginn and the inoffensive Crofton Croker, who while a close friend of Maginn steered clear of controversies and stuck to his job in the Admiralty and to the collecting of Irish folklore. (Watts may have thought that Croker, an amateur draftsman, drew the illustrations in the ‘Gallery,’ rather than their younger Cork friend Daniel Maclise.) The verses that follow give a picture of Maginn in his prime that only a hired counsel could (and in fact did) dispute as totally inaccurate, and is worth quoting in full: And, cheek-by-jowl, his brother twin, In all but dulness, Pat Maginn; Who though he write the LL.D. After his name, will never be A whit the graver than he is – Less fond of drunken ‘deevilries;’ Less ready for a vulgar hoax; Addicted less to pot-house jokes; And all the rough, plebian horse-play, He will so oft without remorse play! Give him a glass or two of whiskey, And in a trice he grows so frisky, So full of frolic, fun, and satire, So ready dirt around to scatter; And so impartial in his blows, They fall alike on friends and foes; Nay, rather than his humour balk His mother’s son he’d tomahawk! And so he can but set once more His boon companions ‘in a roar,’ Will scruple not, good-natured elf, To libel his illustrious self! A task so difficult, I own It can be done by him alone! And yet, to give the devil his due, He’d neither slander me nor you, From any abstract love of malice, But only in his humorous sallies; For of his friends, he’d lose the best, Much rather than his vilest jest! (236–37) Other Fraserians came off much worse – Watts is particularly bitter towards a ‘parasitic fish’ whom he evidently believed to be William Fraser, though apparently he confuses him with Hugh Fraser, and ascribes to him the writings of James Churchill (!). His collective judgment is that the Fraserians
David E. Latané, Jr. 69
are a mud-flinging ‘knot of blackguard boys/Collected in a public street,/To run-a-muck at all they meet’ (240). Needless to say the ‘conversation’ continued, with offenses on both sides, though Watts’s print libels are buried in the pages of his newspapers. Maginn’s comments are as often frank as satirical: ‘Mr. Watts fancies himself too much a genius. In his own estimation he can manage two or three kinds of “Annuals,” newspapers, and magazines, at the same moment, and with equal felicity. He is deceiving himself; he cannot do so’ (‘The Annuals’, 663). I think it is possible, however, that the central cause for Maginn training Fraser’s guns on Watts in 1834–35 was not the ‘Conversazione,’ but that Watts was spreading rumors about Letitia Landon that charged her with having affairs with both Maginn and Daniel Maclise. Macready confided to his diary in November of 1835 that John Forster, Landon’s former fiancée, had told him how ‘rumors and stories pressed upon him that he was forced to demand explanations from one of the reported narrators or circulators, Mr. A.A. Watts – that his denial was positive and circumstantial’ (1, 262). It is unclear from Macready’s entry whether Watts denied the truth of the stories, or that he was the circulator of them, or both. There is no doubt, however, that if Forster heard Watts was spreading the rumors, then Maginn would have heard as well. If the rumors began earlier in the year then they probably triggered the unusually hostile ‘Gallery’ portrait, with its claim that Watts was a backstabber. Maginn easily forgave attacks on what he had written, but zealously guarded his private life. Which brings us back to the lawsuit. Against the strong advice of his friends, Watts went to law by bringing suit against Fraser and Moyes (the printer), rather than attempting to target Maginn. Given the fact that Maginn was deeply in debt and intermittently hiding from bailiffs, and Watts recently had been involved in a number of costly suits, including a squabble with his partner in the United Service Gazette and a suit and countersuit with the publisher Colburn, this seems to have been a decision to go for the deep pockets.10 The first charge was for damages caused by an omnibus article on the annuals by Maginn and others published in November of 1834. In this piece, The Literary Souvenir and Watts’s poetry were broadly parodied – but Watts’s attorney Francis Pollock argued that the parodies had been accepted as real excerpts from the not-yet-published Souvenir, and reprinted by gullible country newspaper editors, thus hurting the sales of the annual. His example was a poem supposedly by a Polish poet writing in Magyar (!) named ‘Quaffypunchovics.’11 Fraser’s attorney Erle countered by calling witnesses to show that the Souvenir was decreasing in sales prior to this spoof, that none of the other annual proprietors had complained though given the same treatment, and that believing ‘Quaffypunchovics’ was a real poet stretched credulity. The jury sided with him and found that no libel had occurred, and awarded no damages.12
70 Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
The second, more serious, count concerned the ‘Gallery of Literary Characters’ for June 1835. In some ways it is a sign of forbearance that Maginn waited until the 61th of the series to sketch ‘Mr. Alaric Attila Watts.’ When he did it unhinged his rival, and even the republication of it with the others in the gallery 50 years later caused conniptions in Watts’s son.13 It is surely the combination of verbal and visual that makes this attack so devastating, compared with those purely verbal shafts which preceded it. Neil Flax summarises the eighteenth-century aesthetic debate over verbal versus visual semiosis thusly: Pictorial signs have the virtue of sensory immediacy, clarity, and universality but the limitation of having to resemble slavishly the mere physical aspect of their referents. Verbal signs can deal with abstract ideas and concepts and can freely combine and disconnect the data of the physical world. But they suffer in their lack of sensate, material presence and in their consecutiveness. Since words must occur one at a time in a sequence and cannot enter the consciousness all at once, they do not provide that instantaneous, global, all-encompassing cognition that truth needs to convey. (187) Turning the page in the magazine, the instant apprehension of Watts’ image is then processed by Maginn’s text, which then prompts another look at the picture. In the cycling back and forth Watts is forever fixed – like the process of washing the developer over the photographic plate. Maclise’s lithograph, the likeness based on a Henry Howard portrait of Watts exhibited that year at the Royal Academy (Watts, 1884, 1974, Vol. II, 88, 196) shows Watts at the foot of a stairway with framed portraits under his arms, a miniature tucked into his hat, and a rolled up drawing in his coat. Maginn begins by disavowing any notion of what the artist meant by sketching Watts ‘flying down stairs with a picture under either arm, and a countenance indicative of caution’ (652) – but the implication is that he is stealing the pictures.14 There had recently been an arrest for such theft of another man involved with the annuals, and the insinuation hits Watts hard not in his character as a (gentle)man-of-letters, but in his profitable sideline of picture dealing. One might see it this way: in the midst of an ordinary literary mud-sling, Watts fingers Maginn for sleeping with Letty Landon; Maginn cries ‘Stop thief!’ Maclise’s portrait also deprives Watts of the cherished iconography of writing by this choice – he isn’t pictured with book and pen, important in his own study (a pose common to many writers in the series), and his cherished connoisseurship is reduced to the snatching of commodities. In the letterpress, the deadpan Maginn discusses how Watts in his own spat with ‘Satan’ Montgomery made word-play with an author’s name, and how Montgomery had in turn claimed ‘Alaric’ was entirely bogus-Byronic
David E. Latané, Jr. 71
and that Watts’s real name was ‘Andrew.’15 Noting Watts’s wife’s literary signature, he concludes, ‘We feel bound to add, however, that it is not very likely, in the usual chance of events, that such names as Alaric Attila Watts should have met in matrimony with those of Zillah Madonna Wiffen; and an unkind world may suspect a mystification somewhere.’16 He then goes on to trace Watts’s literary career from his attempt in the Literary Gazette to expose Byron as plagiarist, to his campaign to insinuate himself into Maga, his work at the Leeds Intelligencer and his editing of the Souvenir, concluding ‘he is now head nurse of an hospital of rickety newspaperlings, which breathe but to die.’ This account, while caustic enough, is also relatively true – Watts wasn’t above personal satire on other’s names in print (hence no right to complain about ‘Attila’), and some of his 20 or so newspapers were so rickety they haven’t even survived in the newspaper library at Colindale. But it is the conclusion that sent Watts to law: There is not a man to whom he has been under an obligation, from Jerdan to Lockhart, from Theodore Hook to Westmacott, from Andrews to Whittaker, from Crofton Croker to Carter Hall, from Wordsworth to Byron, from Scott to Southey, from Landseer to Wilkie, from the man who has fed him from charity to the man who has from equal charity supported his literary repute, whom he has not in his poor way libeled. His Souvenir has lately, for, we doubt not, very good reasons, been subjected to changes; and, as mutability and mortality are yoke-fellows, may ere long, it is probable, undergo the final one. In such a case, we little anticipate its immortality elsewhere. The memories committed to its keeping, we are afraid, have a too-fair chance of perishing. Would it not have been better for him to have avoided slander, gossip, ill-nature, libel, and scandal, and gone through the world as quietly as we have? Perhaps he may yet mend. (Maginn 1836, 652) Watts’s credibility as one of the literati – and an editor dependent on contributions from famous pens and brushes – is at stake here. But the blow struck hardest against his vanity. Was it, though, untrue? Maginn had worked alongside Watts at the Standard and had known him for almost 15 years. If Watts did talk about these men behind their backs he was in a very good position to know. Certainly the reams of gossip Watts sent to William Blackwood in 1821–27 would have supported the defense if it could have been obtained from Scotland – and Maginn was privy to this stream of communication that, as Oliphant describes it, cast ‘a keen eye on the smallnesses of the great, and those mean details into which [...] the largest transaction may be brought down’ (Oliphant, Vol. I, 508). Closing the article, however, he urges Watts to follow his own example of a quiet avoidance of controversy, and thus ironically claims kinship with him; as the ‘Gallery’ demonstrated to friend,
72 Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
acquaintance, and enemy alike, Maginn’s efforts to avoid ‘slander, gossip, ill-nature, libel, and scandal’ had hardly met with success. Watts took the extraordinary step of collecting testimonial letters not only from those named by Maginn but also from everyone he had every come in contact with; he treated the trial, in short, like an academic tenure case. In October he grandly claimed to have 50 of them, and to be ready to call 100 witnesses in order to astronomically drive up the court costs and put Fraser out of business, after which he would print all the letters and the text of the trial (letter to Robert Blackwood, 5 October 1835; Oliphant, Vol. II, 174). The selection of replies printed by his son are an odd miscellany, from Hook’s droll ‘So far from authorizing or participating in the attack upon you to which you refer, I have not seen it. I can only assure you that if I had seen it, it would not in the slightest degree have altered the high opinion I have been taught to form of you’ (Watts 1884, Vol. II, 90), to Wordsworth’s and Southey’s solemn and stodgy disavowals, and Landseer’s annoyed ‘It is absurd in you to suppose for a moment that I could have anything to do with it’ (92). The trial, however, was not to be such a grand affair. Fraser’s case depended not on proving the truth of the assertions, but on demonstrating that the world of literary free-for-all was beyond the usual reach of the libel laws when engaged in by both parties. Maginn over and over defended the absolute freedom of the press to mock the press. Erle attempted to introduce numerous attacks on Maginn and Fraser’s which he claimed had been authored or authorised by Watts. Under the law of the time, however, Erle had not only to tie the libels to Watts, but also to prove that they had been ‘published.’ The way this was done was by having a third party swear to having purchased at a public venue the book, newspaper, or magazine. Thus Watts’s lawyer produced a medical student named Richard Harris to testify that he had bought the issues of Fraser’s in question at the Regent Street bookshop. Erle, however, while producing copies of various publications courtesy of Richard Allen of the Stamp-office, failed to produce witnesses to swear to their purchase, and his entire defense was disallowed. Watts was awarded by the jury a settlement of a meager £150. Fraser appealed, won a new trial, and again lost on the same technicality. Watts also won, presumably, a respite from Fraser’s attacks. ‘We therefore decline,’ it announces in the next number, ‘a controversy which our opponent proposes to carry on through the medium of barristers and juries’ (‘Mr. Alaric Alexander Watts’ 1836, 130). The opening of the same issue, however, contains a mock ‘Parliamentary Report ... to Inquire into the Conduct and to Regulate the Future Management of Fraser’s Magazine’ in which the ‘Goth’ Alaric ‘Attilla’ Watts makes a curtain call, whining, cringing, and presenting the next issue of the Literary Souvenir for Oliver Yorke’s judgment. The excerpts chosen, to drive home Watts’s failure to prove damage from ‘Quaffypunchovics,’ are parodies of poems by ‘Zillah Madonna’
David E. Latané, Jr. 73
and ‘Alaric Attila’ Watts. Zillah sings a song which points to the incongruity of the sentimental poetess’s subject matter and her daily life: Oh! do not call it idleness, if, at morn’s dewy prime, I think a pigmy poet the reverse of the sublime. Though I ‘neither toil nor spin,’ Belov’d, then unto me is given, A cup of coffee and a rusk at half-past six or seven. Oh! do not call it idleness, if, at day’s highest noon, I look in vain to find the little woodman in the moon; Or watch perchance a mazy dance, or listen to the voice Of the printer’s devil, talking of brevier or of bourgeois. Oh! do not call it idleness, if, when the day is done, At tea-time I enjoy the treat of chat and buttered bun: That hour recalls the sainted dead – forgive the shades of gloom! But the lamp ill-trimmed requires a lighted pastile in the room. (1836, 12) Her husband presents ‘The Lament of BOBADIL EL CHICK HO, the last of the Goths, after being defeated on the first count in the trial of FRASER’S MAGAZINE,’ and is sentenced to be flogged, though predictably ‘he howled before he was hurt’ (Fraser’s, 1836, 14). In July 1842, after the death of James Fraser, Watts wrote the new publisher of Fraser’s with an attempt to bury the hatchet – chiefly in the dying Maginn’s back. He asserted that he was ‘compelled’ to go to court because of ‘much unprovoked and scurrilous attacks on me’ by a ‘most unprincipled person’ (Watts, 1884, 1974, Vol. 2, 95). But the attacks, as we have seen, were not unprovoked – they were instead part of the conversation of lampoon that Maginn was determined to save from extinction. This gallery portrait, as well as many of the others, can be placed in a complex web of mostly anonymous discourse, verbal and pictorial. Behind every picture is a story.
Notes 1. The influence of the ‘Gallery’ was cemented in 1873 when William Bates, a classics Professor at Queen’s College, Birmingham, reprinted the originals with added commentary. Subsequent versions simply titled ‘The Maclise Portrait Gallery’ deleted the original letterpress, and were sold in more economical editions. D.G. Rossetti had commended the plates in the Academy a few years earlier (Thrall p. 21). 2. The drawings have also been seen as representative: ‘Incisive, elegant and economical, Maclise’s drawings for Fraser’s not only capture particular personalities, but a whole period and milieu’ (Ormond p. 686). 3. In a letter of 12 November 1826, William Blackwood answers Maginn’s criticisms of Blackwood’s tame nature in an angry fashion: I cannot see that the old and original vein of the magazine has been given up but most certainly I can have no desire or gain to see articles inserted in a
74 Watts, Fraser’s Portrait Gallery & William Maginn
4.
5.
6. 7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
reckless fashion, merely to cost me a thousand pounds in the Jury-Court, or involve all my friends in trouble & botheration. (NLS MS 30309, f. 464) Watts’s Specimens of the Living Poets in three volumes was advertised in the Literary Gazette (16 February 1822, p. 110) with a large type ‘By ALARIC A. WATTS,’ though at that time he was almost completely unknown. This edition, furthermore, was never published. In the same year Maginn, conducting the family school in Cork, exhibited the most casual and unprofessional attitude towards his prolific contributions to Blackwood’s, for which he refused both payment and credit. Lockhart, for instance, wrote John Blackwood that he was ‘astonished to find how little his name was known outside of certain very limited (and not rich) classes’ (NLS MS 4061, f. 273). The translation never appeared, though several of the individual songs were worked into later ‘Noctes Ambrosianæ’ in Maga. See Ted R. Ellis 1883. Once at the reins, Watts filled the Literary Magnet with personalities and puffs, many for himself and the Literary Souvenir, leading off with L.E.L.’s ‘Lines to Alaric A. Watts, Esq.’; he devotes much space to the attack on Disraeli in the monthly ‘Chit-Chat; Literary and Miscellaneous,’ as well several separate articles accusing Disraeli of dishonesty, stealing into Robert Ward’s house to steal his diary, etc. A sample: Mr. Colburn intends publishing a supplement to Vivian Grey in the course of the ensuing season. Another work is announced, which is expected to make a ‘great sensation’ in the fashionable world. It is to be entitled ‘The Complete Picklock,’ or how to gain access to the Private Diaries of your Friends. By Solomon Prig, Ishmaelite; with a running commentary, by a man of great refinement. (‘Chit-Chat,’ n.s. 2 (1826): p. 251) The 16-year-old John Heneage Jesse published The Tales of the Dead: and Other Poems with Murray in 1830. John Minter Morgan’s The Reproof of Brutus, a verse commentary on social conditions, was published in the same year. I do not know whether Morgan actually wrote the ‘Poke at Attila’ or not; one suspects not. In its survey ‘The Annuals’ (December 1832) Fraser’s remarks that the verses ‘damaged the character of the his book, and disgusted the gentlemanly firm that published it’ (663); after the trial Fraser’s returns to the point, noting that ‘who but such an unsavoury personage as that now wincing before us could have thought of placing a production reeking of pothouse revelry and blackguard allusions into the hands of the “unoffending female?”‘ (‘Parliamentary Report’ 1836, p. 13). A useful tonic to Watts’s son’s account of an innocent upright citizen reluctantly driven to the law is the fact that Watts was in the Courts with much greater frequency than either Fraser or Maginn. At the time of this case, he was being sued for libel himself by Henry Dundas Perrett who brought charges on five counts against Watts for an article in the United Service Gazette. This case was tried on 11 December 1835 and, though ably defended by Serjeant Talfourd, Watts lost on four of the five counts. Fraser’s gleefully noted that Watts ‘walked out of court, after a very pleasant week’s work, minus at least two hundred pounds, on the balance of the two actions’ (‘Mr. Alaric Alexander Watts’ 1836, p. 129). The Times report (11 December 1835, p. 2) of this trial states Watts’ middle name as ‘Attila’! This joke name had been deployed in Fraser’s controversy with Bowring’s translations of Magyar poetry in 1830. See Fraser’s Magazine, May 1830, p. 440.
David E. Latané, Jr. 75 12. As an indication of the partial distortions that make an accurate record of literary quarrels so difficult, when the American author N.P. Willis was savaged for his gossipy Pencillings by the Way in Fraser’s, he rallied the North American Review to his defense, which then reported that Watts had won heavy damages for Fraser’s ‘fraudulent attack on his literary reputation. The attack was no more or less than a forgery, printed in that journal as the production of Mr. Watts’ (‘Willis’s Writings,’ North American Review 43, 1836, p. 410). 13. He protests the republication of ‘base and filthy buffoonery’ and gives the text of his letter in the Athenæum protesting the ‘gross violation of public decency involved in the revival, in the name of “literature,” of such obsolete stercoracities’ (1884: 2, p. 97). 14. In 1833 the Age charged that the Souvenir didn’t pay at that Watts ‘has no other subsistence except what he may pick up from occasional picture dealing’ (‘Presentation of the Annuals,’ 3 November 1833, p. 250). 15. Watts repeated the claim that Montgomery had added the prefix ‘Mon’ and that he was, in fact, the son of a clown from Bath with the surname ‘Gomery.’ The Oxford DNB claims this is true, though I have my doubts. 16. Her name was in fact Priscilla Maden Wiffen, though known as Zillah. The ‘Madonna’ seems to have been a joke. Watts’s attorney in the libel case claimed that these sentences libeled her as an unchaste woman, but this stretcher was not seriously considered. At the trial Erle argued somewhat ingeniously that the picture showed Watts in his suburban villa having been surprised by visitors and gathering up the artwork intended for his annual lest it should be trampled!
4 ‘The Original to the Life’: Portraiture and the Northern Star Malcolm Chase
The weekly Northern Star was central to the Chartist movement but it is not generally appreciated that it had a graphic dimension. In nearly 800 issues it included barely 12 illustrations of any note. However, especially in its earliest phase (1837–39), the paper depended heavily upon gifts and special offers to build a base of regular subscribers. They alone among readers received illustrative items – usually specially commissioned portraits such as Feargus O’Connor (Fig. 4.1), the greatest and most controversial Chartist leader (and the paper’s proprietor). A complete list of these engravings is given in the appendix. Of the 34 listed, no less than 27 were portraits, all but five of them contemporary personalities. Fourteen were Chartist leaders. The majority appeared between 1837 and 1842, the years of the paper’s greatest circulation and influence – during 1839 the Star outsold even The Times. This chapter explores the role of these engravings in establishing the particular identity of the newspaper and of the Chartist movement generally, and it considers to what extent they constituted an innovation in periodical publishing. These portraits were a powerful medium through which readers acquired a sense of the movement and thus of themselves as Chartists. Within ‘polite’ society the eighteenth century had been notable, as Horace Walpole observed, for ‘the rage ... for prints of English portraits’. As Marcia Pointon has suggested, this proved an important medium for promoting a shared understanding of the public and the national: ‘the head – and above all the face – with its cognitive and physiognomical particularities, stands in metonymic relation to the body as a whole. ... The collection of “Heads” is thus an epistemology that can be understood as ordering society and making visible the body politic’.1 In a similar way, the systematic commissioning and dissemination of the Star’s pantheon made visible the Chartist body politic or, rather, O’Connor’s vision of what it should be. What these pictures were not is as significant as what they were. The Star turned its back on the satirical tradition that had been so central to the graphical dimension of British radicalism. The paper hardly ever used 76
Malcolm Chase 77
Figure 4.1
Feargus O’Connor, Northern Star, December 1840.
78
Portraiture and the Northern Star
graphic satire in its pages. Conspicuously substituting conventional portraiture in satire’s place, the Star made important claims for Chartism to be seen as respectable, disassociating it from frivolity and gratuitous insult. This was in marked contrast both to radical journals of the mid-1830s and to the Northern Liberator, the only other Chartist newspaper with pretensions to national coverage, whose occasional graphical content was rooted in Regency-style depiction of ‘old corruption’. However, there was growing contemporary popular interest in fine art, most obvious in Knight’s Penny Magazine. While portraiture was declining in prestige, relative to landscape painting, in the sphere of high art, among the popular audience there was no abatement in interest in the genre. The Star was therefore appealing to an established taste: however, the size and quality of its engravings sought to lift portraiture beyond the decorative or iconographic to an almost totemic status. Its portraits were also a graphic riposte to the simultaneous elevation of Queen Victoria as a national icon. Periodicals played a strategic role in this process, as one aggrieved street vendor told Henry Mayhew: There’s so many ‘fine portraits of Her Majesty’, or the others, given away with the first number of this or of that, that people’s overstocked. If a working-man can buy a newspaper or a number, why of course he may as well have a picture with it. They gave away glasses of gin at the opening of that baker’s shop there, and it’s the same doctrine.2 More than 50 different prints of Victoria were available by early 1839. The Star’s publication of portraits can only be fully understood in this context. Its most explicit engagement with the craze came in December 1840 when it announced a portrait of the new-born Princess Royal, subsequently revealing it as a hoax: an engraving of Richard Oastler ‘the factory reform King’ appeared instead (Fig. 4.2).3 However, the expansion of graphic culture that helped create the first media monarch, benefited Chartism too. The Star was a pioneering force in the manipulation of circulation through offering additional inducements to purchasers; and the medium it chose for the purpose was a precisely timed response to developments elsewhere on the political stage. The Star also made a moral and political claim by emphasising the quality of their offerings. This was not merely promotional hyperbole, but rather a facet of that tradition in British radicalism ‘concerned not only with structural shifts of economic and political power but with the very quality and excellence of all dimensions of human existence’. Not for Chartism crude woodcuts like those accompanying broadside ballads printed, as one contemporary remarked, on paper ‘in quality ... so vile that no decent shopkeeper would condescend to use it to wrap copper change’.4 Devoid though they were of overt political imagery, the engravings were
Malcolm Chase 79
Figure 4.2
John Frost, Northern Star, September–November 1839.
80
Portraiture and the Northern Star
profoundly political statements: in this sense they connect directly with the aspirations of William Morris and Walter Crane (who served his apprenticeship to W.J. Linton, the Chartist poet and engraver) to create popular art of the highest quality. The series also emphasised the vitality of Chartism. The movement was projected as occupying a dynamic present without need of historical precedent. Subjects we might expect to see are conspicuously absent, for example Thomas Paine or (Marvell excepted) any seventeenth-century parliamentarian. Nor is there a portrait of King Alfred, Wat Tyler or Shakespeare. There were no engravings of historical scenes at all: the Leeds Cloth Hall Meeting of 1832 was very recent history. Of the five posthumous subjects two – the veteran radicals William Cobbett and Henry Hunt – had died only in 1835. It was not simply the choice of portraiture over other genres that made a bid for respectability; the depiction of subjects was uniformly sober and, arguably, bordered on the anodyne. Nineteen of the British and Irish subjects had at some point been imprisoned, yet none were depicted in gaol. Indeed only two, the Chartist Peter McDouall (Fig. 4.3) and the charismatic Irish rebel Robert Emmet, were shown at their trials. Even then any tendency to depict a martyr was resisted. Domestic interiors were preferred. Especially striking is the inclusion of opulent soft furnishing and ionic columns. Standard features of seventeenth- and eighteenthcentury elite portraiture, they were a visual trope to which radicalism clung on. An ionic column and soft furnishings are much evident in the portrait of John Frost, engraved prior to the Newport Rising of November 1839 with which his name is most closely associated (Fig. 4.4). The background to the radical MP, Thomas Slingsby Duncombe, includes a screen of imposing trees, echoing the portrait landscape of aristocratic convention.5 A similar landscape is invoked – beyond yet another column – behind Ernest Jones. Other conventional visual tropes include the extended right hand of openness and friendship and the man of intellect and business snatching a moment from more pressing affairs. The subjects are never given to grand rhetorical gestures. At the risk of stating the obvious, the subjects were exclusively male. By privileging portraiture over allegory, mythology and historical subjects, women were completely eliminated from the pantheon. Despite – or indeed because of – the ‘modernity’ these engravings projected, Chartism was depicted as a wholly masculine realm, rooted in masculine traditions of political activism. For all their importance in promoting identity and national awareness, then, these portraits had a limiting function. They were narrow, too, in terms of the social classes depicted. This, too, had a profoundly limiting effect: its impact is most apparent when these engravings are compared with the crude woodcuts of working men that very occasionally
Malcolm Chase 81
Figure 4.3
Richard Oastler, Northern Star, February 1840.
82 Portraiture and the Northern Star
Figure 4.4
Peter McDouall, Northern Star, Autumn 1840.
Malcolm Chase 83
appeared in the paper. Of the presentation portraits only the Birmingham Chartist and prisoner John Collins, a shoemaker, was a working man. Overall, these portraits project a strong attachment to the cult of the gentleman leader, for so long a feature of British popular radicalism.6 This is most obvious in the profound resonance between Duncombe’s portrait and an 1810 depiction of Sir Francis Burdett, where the similarity is so great that it can only be the result of conscious imitation.7 These engravings also reinforced the centripetal influence of the Star, a hugely significant function in a movement wherein local and regional identities and particularisms carried such force. The exact choice of subjects was highly significant. The inclusion of a portrait in the series signalled the status of the subject. Feargus O’Connor was Chartism’s only truly national leader and he used his ownership of the newspaper, and role as patron of the series, both to promote his own reputation and that of others. The Star was the only national Chartist periodical that managed to sustain its circulation beyond a few years. However, when the Northern Star and Leeds General Advertiser, to give it its full title, first appeared in November 1837 it almost entirely depended upon a circulation in the northern textile districts, O’Connor’s powerbase at that time. For all his reputation as one of the most powerful platform orators of the age, the Star was the medium upon which he primarily depended to establish a national standing. It was no accident, then, that his portrait was the first to appear, as early as issue five (16 December 1837). And O’Connor was almost unique in appearing twice in the series – only Oastler was awarded a similar accolade. A further significant element in this process was the inclusion at an early stage of an engraving of his uncle Arthur (1763–1852), formerly an MP in the Irish House of Commons and a leading United Irishman. In his self-imposed French exile he had also served in Napoleon’s army. Through this portrait, Feargus both emphasised his radical pedigree and associated himself with a romantic revolutionary whose roots, nonetheless, lay in constitutional politics. O’Connor used the portraits to promote his version of a Chartist ‘apostolic succession’. Hunt and Cobbett’s inclusion speaks for itself. That of Oastler and the Poor Law campaigner J.R. Stephens, heroes without parallel within northern radicalism in the late 1830s, was highly desirable both in terms of building a circulation and symbolically incorporating them into the Chartist movement. Marvell, the only truly historical subject, qualified as a Yorkshire MP and republican. The other three portraits presented in the paper’s first year were Sir William Molesworth, Thomas Attwood and Bronterre O’Brien. The first was a tactical inclusion. At the 1837 general election, Molesworth had abandoned his Cornish constituency in favour of Leeds. O’Connor intended to flatter the radical baronet into supporting Chartism though their courtship was as brief as it was one-sided. By including Attwood and O’Brien, the Star was grounding Chartism explicitly in the
84 Portraiture and the Northern Star
earlier traditions of, respectively, the Reform agitation and the unstamped press, consciously appealing to a Midlands and metropolitan readership and acknowledging the role of both men in the movement’s formative period. On the other hand, this portrait gallery is as interesting for those it excluded, as it is for those it depicted. The absence of certain Chartist leaders who were critical of O’Connor is eloquent. William Lovett and Henry Vincent were conspicuously missing: portraits of both were announced but never issued. An engraving of Vincent, the one orator who – Stephens aside – came closest to rivalling O’Connor in the movement nationally, was announced in February 1840 but quietly sunk without trace. Lovett’s had a rather more chequered career, details of which illustrate the deteriorating relationship between him and O’Connor. It was announced as ‘in preparation’ within a few weeks of his imprisonment in 1839. A second notice in February the following year confirmed Lovett’s inclusion was ‘intended’. Lovett was released from prison in July but of the portrait there was no sign. In December the Lovett engraving was billed tersely as ‘to follow’, but the same issue confirmed that a second, long-awaited full-length portrait of Feargus O’Connor would be ready the next week. This appeared as scheduled (Fig. 4.1) but Lovett never did.
I Aesthetically and politically, the conscious choice of contemporary portraiture over other graphic possibilities was highly significant. It is important to register, however, that technical considerations were also central in determining the graphic dimension of the Star. Portraits were easier and quicker to engrave compared to the more-complicated depiction of historical or contemporary events. Much of the background could be formulaic and supplied using a machine. In building a mass-circulation newspaper economy and speed of production were critical considerations. Yet at the same time the promotion of gifts and offers to readers required that the product be as of high a quality as possible. It might be asked why O’Connor embarked on this strategy rather than including illustrations within the paper and make a promotional virtue of doing so. At the time it was not possible to include steel engravings alongside letterpress. Wood blocks could be integrated, via stereotyped founded blocks, into letterpress printing yet even this presented technical challenges. As a broadsheet newspaper, Northern Star could not be printed using the cylinder process, so effectively exploited from the early 1830s by the smaller format Penny Magazine and its imitators. Their inclusion of small, coarse wood engravings revolutionised graphic journalism, even if readers did have to cut these illustrations out. It was not yet technically possible, however, for
Malcolm Chase 85
the larger broadsheet formats (which required the print to be laid flat to the page) extensively to incorporate woodcuts. On one of the very few occasions the Star attempted this, the first two editions appeared with the front page bearing a blank where the picture should have been, accompanied by an explanation that the engraving was incomplete when the paper went to press. This was all the more embarrassing because it occurred in the middle of the 1842 ‘general strike’ when accurate news of events was at a premium in the movement.8 Nor, in the late 1830s, had techniques of mass production wood engraving approached the level of sophistication or verisimilitude that the Illustrated London News was to achieve in the mid-1840s. Widespread unease surrounded the accuracy of graphic news reportage. Trumpeting its coverage of the royal marriage in 1840, the Observer nonetheless felt obliged to caution its readers that illustrations were less than faithful, while Dickens lampooned ‘the artist of a picture newspaper, with a foreground and figures ready drawn for everything’.9 Even the Illustrated London News achievements were open to question: production of its graphic reportage was divided among teams of engravers, each working on a small area of the total print from sketches that were necessarily approximate. Punch lampooned its pretensions to accuracy with a cartoon depicting an artist, palate and brushes in hand, adjusting the pose of revolutionaries manning a continental barricade.10 Significantly when, in January 1843, the Illustrated London News sought to reward readers’ loyalty at the end of its first six months, it did so through the presentation of a large freestanding engraving.11 By continuing to hold its line with regard to the exclusion of illustration, the Star both signalled that it occupied the journalistic high ground, and conceded it was stuck in a technological cleft stick. It was essential to the paper’s ambitions that it maintained a broadsheet format and it was unique among Chartist papers for doing so. In journalism format was itself a graphic statement about a paper’s purpose. The Northern Star staked a claim to gravitas that bore comparison with the Leeds Mercury, Manchester Guardian or The Times. There was no surer sign of irretrievable decline than when, in August 1852, the Star of Freedom (as the paper had become) assumed a ‘tabloid’ format. Including wood engraving would not have permitted large scale, quality graphic depiction, but it would have complicated and slowed down the Star’s production: as a mass-circulation broadsheet, producing several editions of each issue to accommodate regional nuances as well as breaking news, extensive use of illustration was not an available option. Supplementing the paper, however, with freestanding illustrations enabled significantly higher graphic standards than those of contemporary wood engraving. Having rejected run-of-press wood blocks, the choice for
86
Portraiture and the Northern Star
O’Connor was forced by technical considerations: copper engraving was superior and relatively quick, but plates wore-out rapidly; lithographs were cheap to produce but relatively crude and the unwieldy printing process of the time made them unsuitable for long print-runs. Only steel engraving could provide the print-runs O’Connor needed, but preparation took three times as long as copper and was unpopular with engravers: this was probably why some ambitious initial proposals were abandoned in favour of simpler engravings. The Star made a virtue of lengthy production time: dates on which readers in each region could expect delivery of engravings were published well in advance, distribution being staggered over several weeks to spread the burden of production.12 By limiting these gifts to regular subscribers, the paper had a powerful tool with which to build its circulation. This was a strategy it effectively pioneered. It was not the first periodical to make such gifts: that accolade probably belongs to the Gentleman’s and Lady’s Magazines which gave away patriotic engravings of Wellington after Waterloo.13 These, however, were in a small format and their publication was an occasional gesture rather than a sustained circulation strategy. Periodicals’ gifts of portraits of Victoria fell into the same category. So when within five weeks of its launch the paper began issuing engravings it was embarking on an innovation that marked it out from its competitors which, if they had a graphic dimension at all, used only run-of-press woodcuts. The latter, though not negligible, only served to sharpen the quality of O’Connor’s initiative, as the contrast between the woodcut of McDouall from the Charter newspaper and Star portrait of the same subject show (Figs. 4.3 and 4.5).14 It is important to register the significance of the Star’s initiative in a culture and movement wherein non-verbal communication was highly important. In a society whose print media offered limited access to pictorial illustration, access to good quality graphic imagery was at a premium. Popular taste had long celebrated portrait prints, as Bewick recalled of his childhood.15 Then, and later, popular portraits were overwhelmingly of ‘emminent men’. The concerted promotion of Chartist portraiture therefore subverted popular deference, while the formality of depiction laid claim for parity with aristocratic and bourgeois portraiture. The Star recognised readers’ hunger for good quality art and never passed up an opportunity to stress the worth of its offerings. Thus the portrait of Irish revolutionary William Smith O’Brien was described as taken by the most eminent artist, and engraved in the most superior style ... this Portrait we unhesitatingly assert, is as perfect a likeness as art could supply, and is a superior thing to any ever given with a Newspaper. The friends of the original, who have seen it, declare that it is the original to the life.16
Malcolm Chase 87
Figure 4.5
Woodcut of Peter McDouall from the Charter, 7 April 1839.
88 Portraiture and the Northern Star
A portrait in oils of Oastler (commissioned as the basis for the engraving, Fig. 4.3) toured Chartist localities, heralded with as much clamour by the paper as if it had been the man himself. A most masterly painting of RICHARD OASTLER executed by Mr Garside for Mr O’Connor now lies at Mr Taylor’s of Ashton, for inspection, and is daily visited by thousands, one and all of whom express their unbounded admiration of the performance. It shall be sent to Huddersfield, to Mr Pitkethly, for one week, where the unflinching friends of the original will have the opportunity of seeing the Old King almost alive. ... We now promise to our Subscribers a Portrait every 3 months, of 14 inches by 11. ... [E]ngravings of so expensive a character are not given with newspapers, and, their [i.e. readers’] much indulgence is due.17 Several dealers advertised frames specially made for these pictures.18 They became ‘the invariable ornaments of most working men’s houses’, according to one Lancashire observer.19 Another, from the Potteries, described workers’ homes decorated with ‘engravings of some Chartist or Radical leader belonging to the political school of the pater familias’. Emmet’s portrait hung in ‘hundreds’ of homes ‘throughout ... democratic Yorkshire’. A former Chartist handloom weaver recalled in 1889 that ‘among the many portraits that were given with the Northern Star none was more popular than that of Robert Emmet. ... I had one of these portraits myself, which, after being framed by my own hand, served for years to adorn the wall of my bedroom’.20 A contemporary social investigator was alarmed by ‘pictures of Frost ... found in many of the cottages, [which] display too closely their sympathy with rebellion’.21 ‘One of the pictures that I longest remembered’, recollected the grandson of a Cheltenham washerwoman, ‘it stood alongside samplers and stenciled drawings, and not far from a china statuette of George Washington – was a portrait of John Frost. ... I had been familiar with the picture since childhood, and cherish it as a memento of stirring times’.22 J.R. Stephens was bemused to learn of ‘an old Dragoon Guard ... so much did he respect him that he carried his portrait under the flap of his saddle bags “that he might think of me whenever he buckled them on” ’.23 These engravings were not solely household or private artefacts. They were ‘consumed’ in collective as well as domestic settings. The selection of subjects was debated in the letters’ page of the paper. Often decorated with evergreens and illuminated by gaslight, portraits would flank banners at political meetings; and they were carried, framed, in processions. The uses to which portraits were put could be almost theatrical (interestingly, O’Connor himself used the term ‘performance’ to describe the Oastler portrait). Most theatrical of all were public burnings of Stephens’ portrait, following his renunciation of Chartism at his trial for sedition in December 1839. 24
Malcolm Chase 89
It is impossible to estimate how far the engravings contributed to sales, but rivals certainly claimed they unfairly boosted circulation. One newsagent claimed portraits doubled sales, another that they depressed those of other radical papers.25 However, as for any innovator, O’Connor’s experience was not without problems. It was difficult to regulate the production of engravings in the quantities the paper quickly came to require. Northern Star had established a massive readership and the promise of regular presentations of engravings, initially made when its circulation was in the low thousands, was by mid-1839 placing huge strains on a paper selling up to 50,000 copies per issue. Criticisms of late or non-delivery appeared frequently; so too did explanations and rebuttals by the paper: Some of our Readers seem to have a very erroneous impression respecting the process of Copper or Steel printing. They imagine it can be done as easily, and as quickly, as a power loom weaves calico pieces – or as a letterpress printing machine turns out Newspapers. The fact is, the process is the most tedious; one requiring the greatest care, of any operation I know of ... Men are working night and day. In future we will not fix a day for distribution until the whole requisite number has been printed.26 The following month readers were reminded that, ‘after all the clamour, we shall, within a period of less than ten months, have presented our Subscribers with six Portraits, worth more than five guineas, if purchased singly, and as good as the art can furnish’.27 Thereafter both commissions and the standard of engraving were simplified and O’Connor was careful not to promise more in artistic terms than the paper could deliver. Between late 1841 and June 1846 only three engravings were presented. They were now an occasional reward for loyalty rather than a sustained strategy to build circulation. (The readership had stabilized around 13,000, significantly lower than its peak in 1839.) Yet these portraits remained a powerful form of political communication. The inclusion of the Dublin Chartist, Patrick O’Higgins, in 1846 was a tactic to woo Irish support for Chartism; and in 1848 that of Ernest Jones, a newcomer to Chartism, sealed his appointment as de facto lieutenant to Feargus O’Connor. Towards the end of 1848, O’Connor resumed a regular programme of engravings. The subjects reveal a change in thinking: the addition of the European revolutionaries Blanc and Kossuth sought to locate Chartism more explicitly in an international perspective. Meagher, Mitchell and Smith O’Brien (along with two other Irish rebels subsequently dropped) constituted a belated tactical recognition that Chartism’s greatest chance of political success rested on close co-ordination with Irish nationalism. At the same time these engravings evaded the controversy that surrounded the rejection of Chartism’s third mass petition in April 1848, and the arrests and trials of large numbers of Chartist activists that followed. Although the
90 Portraiture and the Northern Star
decline of Chartism after this date has often been exaggerated, the times were not propitious for a mass-circulation radical broadsheet. The choice of subject matter for the final presentations, especially the late Sir Robert Peel, leader of the Conservatives, and the two views of the 1851 Exhibition (to which Northern Star itself was implacably opposed) is a graphic indicator of a loss of political momentum.
II One of the themes of this volume is how should periodical illustrations be ‘read’? Were they primarily ornamental, or at most a reinforcement of information and sentiments derived from the printed word? Much more likely is that they were integral, even special, to the processes by which people thought about the world around them. ‘One cannot underestimate the scale and intensity of the politics of sight, or the power these forms of communication afforded to the individuals who used them’.28 These portraits were powerful visual statements in terms of technological accomplishment and aesthetic quality. They were powerful, too, for the information they conveyed about the movement’s leadership and its cohesion around the personality of O’Connor. It would be a mistake to see them as fulfilling a decorative function alone, or simply as vectors of physiognomic information about a leadership otherwise visually remote from most of the movement. While publicity emphasised their verisimilitude, these engravings also had considerable symbolic value. Even in our own society and culture, portraits retain a powerful talismanic function. What a portrait signifies, Pointon argues, is ‘often connotative rather than denotative’.29 In other words, portraits are as important as the vectors of values as they are of factual graphic information. There is about the Star engravings an air of understated self-assurance and an absence of rhetorical flourish which suggests they were anchored in a profoundly confident mindset, one which looked forward to the successful outcome of the Chartist movement under a leadership that was fully prepared to take its place in the Westminster arena. More problematically, however, the cumulative effect of these portraits is to homogenise their subjects. Hardly any offered specific geographical context. The gaze of these portraits is a nationalised gaze, and that accentuated the difference and distance between the collective subjects and their intended viewers. The portraits sharpened the contrast between the Chartist ‘front bench’, to the construction of which they so effectively contributed, and the movement at large. Mass open-air meetings gave Chartism so much of its social and political potency, and the Star was indefatigable in its coverage of them: yet its portrait gallery exudes an air of indoor respectability. These were portraits of an anticipated near future, a pantheon of Chartist MPs to whom would be transferred the political authority presently enjoyed by the traditional elite. Thus the subjects were depicted amidst some of the
Malcolm Chase 91
trappings of that elite, while the manner of their portrayal anticipates something of the deference they might expect to enjoy. The near-cessation of the series after the rejection of the 1842 Petition until 1848 is highly significant in this respect. Ostensibly, if ever there was a point when the Star needed to act to stem a fall in circulation this was it. Instead there was a hiatus, suggestive of a deep-rooted loss of assurance. The subjects chosen for the resumed series, after the rejection of a further mass petition in 1848, reflected attempts to rethink and even relaunch Chartism as a movement more in tune with Irish and continental nationalisms. It was an attempt that failed, as the final four engravings bear witness.
Appendix: Engravings Presented by Northern Star Subject
Issued
FEARGUS O’CONNOR [small]
December 1837
ANDREW MARVELL ARTHUR O’CONNOR RICHARD OASTLER [small] HENRY HUNT SIR WILLIAM MOLESWORTH WILLIAM COBBETT THOMAS ATTWOOD BRONTERRE O’BRIEN LEEDS CLOTH HALL MEETING, 1832 1839 CONVENTION JOHN FROST J.R. STEPHENS RICHARD OASTLER [large] JOHN COLLINS PETER MCDOUALL FEARGUS O’CONNOR [large] ROBERT EMMET TRIAL OF NEWPORT PRISONERS 1842 PETITION T.S. DUNCOMBE W.P. ROBERTS
February 1838 February 1838 March/April 1838 June 1838 August 1838 September 1838 November 1838 December 1838 January 1839 May 1839 September–November 1839 (Fig. 4.4) November 1839 February 1840 (Fig. 4.2) Autumn 1840 Autumn 1840 (Fig. 4.3) December 1840 (Fig. 4.1) July 1841 July/August 1841 July/August 1842 November 1842 September 1843
PATRICK O’HIGGINS
June 1846
O’CONNORVILLE (the first Chartist land colony) ERNEST JONES JOHN MITCHELL LOUIS BLANC WILLIAM SMITH O’BRIEN TF MEAGHER
January 1847 January 1848 November 1848 Spring 1848 February 1849 June 1849
92
Portraiture and the Northern Star
KOSSUTH ROBERT PEEL PRESIDENTS of USA GREAT EXHIBITION (conjectural) GREAT EXHIBITION (actual)
September 1849 July 1850 September 1850 December 1850 April 1851
Announced but never issued: William Lovett (1839–40), Henry Vincent (1840), the Royal Lying-in (1841), Washington and the Declaration of Independence (1841), Father Matthew (1841), James Duffy (1848), Pope Pius IXth (1848), Richard O’Gorman (1848).
Notes This is based on my chapter ‘The politics of sight’, in Owen Ashton and Joan Allen (eds), Papers for the People: A Study of the Chartist Press, 2005. I am grateful to the editors and publisher, Merlin Press, for permission to publish this abridgement. 1. Walpole quoted in Donald p. 58. 2. H. Mayhew, London Labour and the London Poor ... Volume 1: London Street-Folk, p. 329. 3. N[orthern] S[tar] 12 December 1840, 2 January and 6 March 1841. 4. Yeo pp. 107–08; Charles Manby Smith, The Little World of London, p. 265. 5. Roberts and Thompson p. 61. Other engravings discussed here and reproduced in this volume are the first depicting O’Connor (p. 29), O’Brien (p. 30), Collins (p. 34), Roberts (p. 67), O’Higgins (p. 84) and Jones (p. 101). 6. J. Belchem and J.A. Epstein, ‘The Nineteenth-Century Gentleman Leader Revisited’, Social History 22/2 (May 1997). For an illuminating case study of the centrality of portraiture for the social construction of identity, see Jordanova pp. 101–15. 7. 1810 portrait drawn and engraved by William Williams (in possession of the author), depicting him standing alongside a table on which lays the text of Magna Carta. 8. NS 20 August 1842. 9. Plunkett p. 209; C. Dickens, Bleak House (1853), chapter 33. 10. Punch vol. 15 (1848), p. 39. 11. Wolff and Fox pp. 560–61. 12. NS 7 March, 4 July, 5 December 1840. 13. I am grateful to Belinda Beaton for this information. 14. Portraits of Frost and McDouall appeared in a series in the Charter in 1839: see reproductions of a selection in Roberts & Thompson. 15. Bewick p. 192. 16. NS 11 November 1848. 17. NS 1 June 1839. 18. NS 12 May 1838, 6 July and 1 August 1839 and 10 April 1841; see also Regenerator and Advocate for the Unrepresented, 3 November 1839. 19. Unpublished diary entry, quoted in Jones p. 147. 20. Farish p. 50. 21. Sinclair p. 57.
Malcolm Chase 93 22. Adams pp. 163–63. 23. Goddard p. 158. 24. NS 21 December 1839, Bradford Observer 19 December 1839 and Halifax Guardian 21 December 1839. 25. NS 5 January 1839; J.A. Epstein, ‘Feargus O’Connor and the Northern Star’, International Review of Social History, p. 75. 26. NS 2 November 1839. 27. NS 7 December 1839. 28. Vernon pp. 107–08; c.f. Porter 1988 p. 187. 29. Pointon p. 5.
This page intentionally left blank
Part II Mid-Century Graphics: Fiction, Fashion, Labour and Layout
This page intentionally left blank
5 Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in Dickens’s The Old Curiosity Shop Beryl Gray
The Old Curiosity Shop evolved as a serial in Dickens’s own threepenny weekly miscellany, Master Humphrey’s Clock, the pages of which it entirely took over from its ninth chapter until its completion.1 From the outset, a crucial element in Dickens’s vision for his periodical was that it should be enhanced by ‘woodcuts dropped into the text’,2 an idea to which he remained committed when the Clock became solely a vehicle first for the Shop, and then for Barnaby Rudge, with which it ended its run. Accordingly, 75 wood engravings (as they in fact were) were integrated with the text of the first story, and 76 with the second. George Cattermole produced 14 illustrations for the Shop, and 17 for Rudge, while Daniel Maclise and Samuel Williams provided just one apiece for the Shop, each featuring Nell, but Hablot K. Browne (Phiz) designed no fewer than 59 for each novel. He also drew every one of the periodical’s illuminated capital letters. Although it was over Cattermole’s essentially still, architectural scenes that Dickens tended to rhapsodize, he routinely left it to Browne to create a visual correlative for the more energized or bizarre emanations of his fancy. As the story outgrew the frame of the miscellany, Browne responded with a series of drawings that – as John Harvey has shown – increasingly reveal his extraordinary ability both to penetrate, and to conspire with, Dickens’s imagination.3 Furthermore, he developed ways of using the exigencies of instalment publication to complement Dickens’s narrative. This collaboration of artist with author is exemplified in Browne’s acclaimed representations of Quilp; but it is also demonstrated in his depictions of Jerry, who, though less prominent and certainly less fantastic, is the dwarf’s moral counterpart. One is conceived by Dickens as a kind of dog, the other is a master of dogs. Quilp has clear and widely-acknowledged affinities with a range of fairy-tale monsters or lawless vice figures, pre-eminently Punch.4 Brutal, preternaturally frenetic, and as gleeful in destroying others’ well-being as 97
98 Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
Punch is in despatching his fellow puppets, Quilp – like Punch – is nevertheless a great comic creation. Unlike Punch, however, his tyranny is charged with a potent animalism that both repels and compels. While Punch is amorous, Quilp is licentious. He is also a devouring, imbibing, fume-exuding, bodily organism, which Punch, manifestly, is not. With his surreal appetites and manner of indulging, displaying, and inflicting them, Quilp is a grotesquely self-exaggerating, overwhelming life-force; and it is this force from which his evil – as distinct from Punch’s entertaining anarchy – draws its potency. To whatever extent he owes his origin to Punch, then, the source of his animality is not the puppet, whose body can only dangle ‘all loose and limp and shapeless’ (131) when it is not being manipulated by his exhibiter. With an extensive range of creatures from the ferret and the hawk to the lion and the monkey contributing, as their only function in the novel, the defining characteristics of their genera to the creation of his singularity, exceptional among them is the dog – the creature to which, as Paul Schlicke has pointed out, Quilp is ‘systematically linked’.5 However, it is not merely the connection itself, but the ways in which it is developed and exploited, that most reveal the nature of Quilp’s vital peculiarity. It is through specifically canine metaphor and canine mimesis that, paradoxically, Quilp fascinates as both humanly credible and superhumanly fanciful. The chief mannerism to identify him as belonging to the canine species – the habitual ‘ghastly smile’ (as distinct from Punch’s ‘usual equable smile’ [128]) that exposes the ‘few discolored fangs6 that were yet scattered in his mouth, and gave him the aspect of a panting dog’ – is registered with his first entry into the story, which occurs in the opening paragraph of chapter 3 (Clock, VIII), the chapter in which Master Humphrey detaches himself from the narrative ‘to leave those who have prominent and necessary parts in it to speak and act for themselves’ (33). Expressly ‘dog-like’ by chapter 4; maintained as Quilp smokes and drinks throughout the night while forcing his meek wife to sit sleepless throughout the night as punishment for daring to participate in her mother’s tea-party; and called up ‘in full force’ when he hears that mother, Mrs Jiniwin, denounce him as ‘a little hunchy villain and a monster’ (45), the smile becomes associated with an ever-extending range of canine performances and impressions. These include shaking himself in a ‘very doglike manner’ (45); coiling himself into Nell’s little bed; rolling himself onto his feet; leaping out of his hammock ‘not with his legs first, or his head first, or his arms first, but bodily – altogether’ (467); his snarling threat to bite his wife in chapter 4; the ferocity with which he eats and drinks and chews (which prefigures the criminal’s voracity in chapter 18 of Barnaby Rudge, which in turn prefigures Magwitch’s attack on the food and drink Pip brings him in chapter 3 of Great Expectations);7 and his capacity for ‘entertaining himself with a melodious howl, intended for a song, but bearing not the faintest resemblance to any scrap of any piece of
Beryl Gray 99
music ... ever invented by man’ (379). The looking-glass image in chapter 5 that conveys to Mrs Jiniwin ‘the reflection of a horribly grotesque and distorted face with the tongue lolling out’ (45) – the tongue an inspired afterthought inserted into the manuscript8 – retains its influence as Quilp’s pursuit of Nell evokes the behaviour of a scent-aroused cur. Unclean,9 he is also, by implication, malodorous. From the outset, Browne’s depictions of Quilp eagerly corroborate the dwarf’s foulness, but it is not until chapter 21 (Clock, XVIII) that he has the opportunity to do full justice to his understanding of the nature of Dickens’s conception. In this chapter, Quilp – who reflexively denigrates other males as dogs, particularly his wharf boy Tom Scott10 and Kit Nubbles – takes Dick Swiveller to the hut rotting by the Thames mud, and persuades him that he can become a rich ‘lucky dog’ by marrying Nell. Swiveller’s gullibility obliges Quilp to withdraw from the hut in order to throw himself onto the ground and roll about – absolutely like a dog – in a frenzy of delight. His behaviour educes his spiritual double: In the height of his ecstacy, Mr Quilp had like to have met with a disagreeable check, for, rolling very near a broken dog-kennel, there leapt forth a large fierce dog, who, but that his chain was of the shortest, would have given him a disagreeable salute. As it was, the dwarf remained upon his back in perfect safety, taunting the dog with hideous faces, and triumphing over him in his inability to advance another inch, though there were not a couple of feet between them. ‘Why don’t you come and bite me, why don’t you come and tear me to pieces, you coward?’ said Quilp, hissing and worrying the animal till he was nearly mad. ‘You’re afraid, you bully, you’re afraid, you know you are.’ The dog tore and strained at his chain with starting eyes and furious bark, but there the dwarf lay, snapping his fingers with gestures of defiance and contempt. When he had sufficiently recovered from his delight, he rose, and with his arms a-kimbo, achieved a kind of demon-dance round the kennel, just without the limits of the chain, driving the dog quite wild. Having by this means composed his spirits and put himself in a pleasant train, he returned to his unsuspicious companion, whom he found looking at the tide with exceeding gravity, and thinking of that same gold and silver which Mr Quilp had mentioned. (169–70) It is significant that Quilp responds to the dog’s frustrated ‘salute’ as though he were indeed one of his own kind, and shared his language, but the characteristics he attributes to the animal are solely his. While the captive dog’s savageness is instinctive, and accounted for by his office and his ill use (evidenced by the broken kennel, the too-short chain), Quilp’s sadism is calculated: the facial contortions and gestures that he practises in close (though safe) proximity to the dog, and at the dog’s level, show him as the
100 Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
more cowardly animal. Fittingly, he is actually even lower than the unfortunate beast; for as the natural dog strains after his tormentor, Quilp remains on his back in bizarre imaging of the evil hybrid his nature suggests,11 until he is sated, and – in a grotesque role-reversing parody of the no less grotesque spectacle of bull-, bear-, or lion-baiting (with dogs) – ready to perform his goading devil-dance around the tethered animal. Although this behaviour does recall Punch’s fight with Toby, it is not (pace Paul Schlicke) ‘straight from’12 the puppet play, in which Toby seizes Punch’s nose, and Punch beats the dog (or Punch beats Toby, who then seizes Punch’s nose). In Dickens’s scene, there is – necessarily – no physical contact between Quilp and his foiled attacker. Rather, his encounter with the dog fans his hysterical delight into demonic malignancy, projecting his performance beyond the uninhibited antics of the puppet. Browne’s responsive dropped-in illustration presents the opposed figures face to face as an almost matching pair (see Figure 5.1).
Figure 5.1 Hablot Knight Browne, [‘Quilp mocking the dog’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum.
Beryl Gray 101
The dog’s frenzy as he stands on his hind legs, straining against the chain as he impotently claws the air, is perfectly captured. His attitude and shape are reflected by Quilp, whose legs – one higher than the other – wave in the air as though in mimicry of the dog’s fore-legs, while his backward-pointing tufts of hair both resemble the dog’s short, pointed, flattened ears, and suggest the devil’s horns. Despite the flawlessness of the depictions so far, however, there are significant discrepancies between the text and its illustration. Dickens stresses that the dwarf’s ‘head and face were large enough for the body of a giant’ (27). Browne’s Quilp’s head is less disproportionately large – less monstrous – than Dickens’s Quilp’s, while the illustration’s perspective somewhat flatters the length of Quilp’s legs. Nor is the dog large enough to accord with Dickens’s description. With Quilp on his backside rather than on his back, Browne’s modifications tend to render him slightly less grotesque than his original creator does, and – the noose-like coil of rope suspended above the fiend’s head (astutely developed from the gallowsgame symbols deeply scored on the table at which Quilp has left Swiveller) notwithstanding13 – to detract from both Dickens’s and his own presentation of him as inherently more base than his figurative kin.14 Perhaps Browne’s restraint was the consequence of Thackeray’s advice to ‘think more and exaggerate less’,15 though here exaggeration would hardly have been possible. If Swiveller’s gullibility in the early stages of the novel induces irrepressible ecstasy in Quilp, Kit’s virtue provokes his murderous frenzy towards the end of it, in chapter 62 (Clock, XXXIX). Watched by Sampson Brass, his attorney, he batters the face of the monstrous figurehead he has dragged into his lair crying, ‘Is it like Kit – is it his picture, his image, his very self? ... Is it the exact model and counterpart of the dog – is it – is it – is it?’ (479). Nell’s ethereal purity being the opposite of Quilp’s rankly virile malevolence, Kit, as the staunch champion of the one, is the natural and recognized foe of the other. But, erected as Kit’s representative, the effigy is more nearly an inflated representation of Quilp himself (the terrified Brass has not been able to decide whether Quilp sees it as a family portrait, or the likeness of an enemy). Sawn off at the waist so that it can be forced to fit into the counting-house, its head is thereby proportionately enlarged, and it looms above Quilp (described as ‘goblin-like’ in chapter 4) ‘like a goblin or hideous idol whom the dwarf worshipped’ (477). Although lambasting it as the counterpart of the ‘dog’ Kit, in effect he is (characteristically) lambasting a projection of his evil genius.16 Browne’s accompanying illustration depicts Quilp in violent simian, rather than canine, mode (see Figure 5.2). His facial expression is certainly vicious, but the head is – again – too small, so that the balance between the ratios of each figure is forfeited. However, Browne compensates by equipping the effigy with goggling eyes, to one of which the reader’s own eyes are irresistibly drawn as it stares fixedly down at the assailant, who points
102
Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
Figure 5.2 Hablot Knight Browne (Phiz), [‘Quilp assails the effigy’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum.
upwards towards it. These eyes endorse the perception that, in essence, the image returns that of the dwarf, for they faithfully accord with their textual description while also evoking the ‘great goggle eyes’ (376) that an upsidedown Quilp had trained on Kit’s terrified mother from the roof of the stagecoach fourteen chapters earlier. Into the eyes of the effigy – now ‘the dog’ (479) in its own right – the self-attacking Quilp has already been sticking forks. Having further authenticated the image (no longer ‘it’, but ‘him’) as connoting himself by cutting his own name on it, he intends ultimately to consign it to the fire to which he is himself seemingly impervious,17 but for which he is inevitably destined.18 Manifested beyond confrontations such as these, Quilp’s canine associations reinforce his connection with the novel’s itinerant entertainers: Codlin and Short, the Punch and Judy showmen; Vuffin, who exhibits giants and dwarfs;19 and – pre-eminently – Jerry, the master of the performing dogs. These travellers gather at their social nexus, the Jolly Sandboys (to which Short has also guided Nell and her grandfather), during chapters 18 and 19 (Clock, XVI and XVII).
Beryl Gray 103
As Schlicke has shown, the Shop was written at a time when such travelling show-people were under considerable pressure, and finding it ever more difficult to make a living.20 All the novel’s exhibitors seem to be experiencing diminishing returns, and the competition for audiences is keen: Codlin and Short, for example, are anxious to leave the Jolly Sandboys early in the morning ‘because unless we get the start of the dogs and the conjuror, the villages won’t be worth a penny’ (154). On the face of it, Jerry’s behaviour might indicate that he is also feeling the pinch. His arrival is anticipated by the unaccompanied appearance of his four bedraggled, ‘very dismal’ (148) dogs when they make their pre-supper entrance at the Jolly Sandboys. Significantly, the dogs are introduced not as accessories, but as protagonists, with their collective and individual demeanours, trained attitudes, and costumes described in telling detail: indeed, Short is to acknowledge the dogs’ status as fellow entertainers when he points to their dresses and says to Jerry, ‘Your people don’t usually travel in character, do they? ... It must come expensive if they do?’ (149) But our concern for the demands on Jerry’s purse is undermined by the attention that has already been drawn to the ‘small whip wherewith to awe his company of comedians’ (149) that he retained as he otherwise disencumbered himself and approached the fire. It is the dogs’ plight – especially that of the ‘old bandy dog of particularly mournful aspect’ (148) – that touches us. This old trouper, ‘stopping when the last of his followers had got as far as the door, erected himself upon his hind legs and looked round at his companions, who immediately stood upon their hind legs, in a grave and melancholy row’ (148). Tarnished and discoloured with rain and dirt, the spangled gaudiness of the dogs’ apparel loses all semblance of gaiety on the backs of its equally besmirched wearers, one of whom has been made also to wear a cap ‘tied very carefully under his chin, which had fallen down upon his nose and completely obscured one eye’ (148). The balance between the pathetic and the comic in this passage admits pity while reserving indignation. Little dogs dressed as humans were familiar show figures. Implicitly acknowledging their attraction as performers in his own presentation of them, Dickens exposes – without recourse to scolding rhetoric – the exploitation and canine misery underlying their appeal as they stand ‘patiently winking and gaping and looking extremely hard at the boiling pot’ (148) as it emits its enticing aroma of blended meats, new potatoes, and other vegetables. All the same, through the activation of our imaginative sympathies, we have become deprecating spectators even before their master’s entrance gives them the cue to drop down and walk about like dogs again (but still dogs whose natural posture remains compromised by their costumes). If we are not immediately directed to denounce Jerry, we are certainly not invited to approve of him; and when we are told that Pedro,
104
Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
the cap-wearing dog, ‘a new member of the company and not quite certain of his duty, kept his unobscured eye anxiously on his master, and was perpetually starting upon his hind legs when there was no occasion, and falling down again’ (149), the sense that the animals’ training depends not on their eagerness to please, but on their fear of displeasing, is confirmed. But if Dickens has refrained from overt moralizing up to this point, the reader’s sensibilities have been sufficiently worked upon for them to be readily outraged at the scene’s finale, which is also the finale both to the chapter, and to the sixteenth number of the Clock. When the odoriferous contents of the supper cauldron have been transferred to the tureen, the ‘poor dogs’ (150) – who have been watching the proceedings ‘with terrible eagerness’ (150) – all stand on their hind legs again. Nell’s pitying impulse is to throw them some food before even taking any herself, but is stopped by their master: ‘No my dear, no, not an atom from anybody’s hand but mine if you please. That dog’ said Jerry, pointing out the old leader of the troop, and speaking in a terrible voice, ‘lost a halfpenny to-day. He goes without his supper.’ The unfortunate creature dropped upon his fore-legs directly, wagged his tail, and looked imploringly at his master. ‘You must be more careful Sir’ said Jerry, walking coolly to the chair where he had placed his organ, and setting the stop. ‘Come here. Now Sir, you play away at that, while we have supper, and leave off if you dare.’ The dog immediately began to grind most mournful music. His master having shown him the whip resumed his seat and called up the others, who, at his directions, formed in a row, standing upright as a file of soldiers. ‘Now gentlemen’ said Jerry, looking at them attentively. ‘The dog whose name’s called, eats. The dogs whose names an’t called, keep quiet. Carlo!’ The lucky individual whose name was called, snapped up the morsel thrown towards him, but none of the others moved a muscle. In this manner they were fed at the discretion of their master. Meanwhile the dog in disgrace ground hard at the organ, sometimes in quick time, sometimes in slow, but never leaving off for an instant. When the knives and forks rattled very much, or any of his fellows got an unusually large piece of fat, he accompanied the music with a short howl, but he immediately checked it on his master looking round, and applied himself with increased diligence to the Old Hundredth. (150) Although every halfpenny would undoubtedly have counted, there is no indication in the scene that the loss of one would make a significant difference to Jerry. Not only is he a regular at the hospitable inn, but he
Beryl Gray 105
expresses no urgency about setting off in the morning (Codlin and Short will leave him snoring), and has been able to provide his ‘people’ with complete new wardrobes – representing a substantial outlay – for them to ‘come out’ (149) in the next day at the races: by his own admission, he has just not bothered to remove their defunct wet garments.21 Convivially at his ease in his own velveteen coat, there is in fact nothing about him to suggest imminent poverty; nothing to suggest that his twofold punishment of the senior dog is justified, even if we suppose that the creature could possibly be expected to associate his delayed punishment with his offence.22 As the aged and acknowledged leader of the troupe – Jerry’s deputy, in effect – it is he who should be deemed above all the others to need and to have earned his comforts; certainly his food. By depriving him of his supper, forcing him to labour while his companions are fed morsel by morsel, showing him the whip, and looking round threateningly every time the dog voices his anguished protest, the feasting Jerry entirely forfeits our goodwill. It is, as Q.D. Leavis says, ‘the most touching and pregnant scene in the book’. 23 But, as so often in Dickens, here pathos is made to contend with humour. All the elements of a popular kind of street or fairground entertainment are represented. Not only do the dressed-up dogs perform engagingly (or so many reader-observers would have found) on their master’s commands and their leader’s signal, or from instilled habit, but barrel organ and canine howling join in conceivably amusing cacophony. The Old Hundredth – the time-honoured (and still well-known) tune to the metrical version of Psalm 100, ‘All people that on earth do dwell’ – would have been familiar to Dickens’s Protestant contemporaries, to whose minds the words would instantly have sprung. 24 Exhorting worshippers to ‘Sing to the Lord with cheerful voice’, and praising Him for his goodness and everlasting mercy, the hymn includes the lines ‘The Lord, ye know, is God indeed, /.../ We are His flock, He doth us feed’. Mechanically ground out by the be- costumed, unfed animal in the presence of his own, merciless, lord, the Old Hundredth provides a wonderfully ironic, if incipiently comic, accompaniment to the Sandboys supper. With every potential for entertainment allowed, then, it is not the fact that the dogs have been trained to perform that the episode encourages us to deplore, but the inhumane methods adopted, as by Divine Right, of the trainer. 25 Dickens makes us feel the dejection, hunger, and anxiety of all the dogs; but in a scene where appetite and (in Codlin’s case) greed are stimulated through sight and smell in readiness for the satisfactions of the chapter’s (and the issue’s) culminating meal, the old dog’s protracted punishment of food deprivation is strikingly cruel and, given the lapse of time since his mistake, arbitrary. Nell’s impulse would be the reader’s too: our indictment of Jerry is reinforced by the fact that, of all the characters, it is she who is made to stay an act of kindness.
106
Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
Cattermole’s dropped-in wood engraving shows Codlin ensconced in the Sandboys chimney corner, his hands raised in ecstasy as the landlord lifts the lid of the stew-pot for the delectation of his guest, who is almost enveloped by the steam (see Figure 5.3). Dickens’s emphasis on fireside hospitality and on Codlin’s devotion to olfactory and gastronomic pleasure, is therefore visually endorsed. But the figures of Jerry and the dogs are left entirely to the power of the written word. Since – as Joan Stevens observes – ‘insets are given on their first entry not only to all the main personages, but to lesser ones’,26 this is remarkable: so absolutely do the dogs and their manager take possession of the chapter once they have entered it, that they seem to demand an illustration. However, perhaps because their images are so strongly impressed on the mind of the reader that a picture would be superfluous – even distracting – at this point, the demand is not met until nineteen chapters later. Browne’s engraving of the group – ‘unambitious but on the right lines’, as Mrs Leavis somewhat patronizingly judges27 – appears as the tailpiece to chapter 37 (Clock XXV), the chapter in which Short tells the single gentleman (in an interview illustrated by Browne) that a man ‘wot
Figure 5.3 George Cattermole, [‘The Sandboys chimney corner’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum.
Beryl Gray 107
Figure 5.4 Hablot Knight Browne (Phiz), [‘Jerry and his dogs’]: The Old Curiosity Shop (1840–41). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum.
keeps a company of dancing-dogs’ (291) had reported seeing Nell and her grandfather with a travelling wax-work exhibition. Given no specific event to depict, Browne’s composition shows Jerry and his group on the open road. In the background are appropriately insubstantial, receding images of Nell and her grandfather walking with bowed heads beside Mrs Jarley’s horse-drawn caravan (see Figure 5.4). As can be seen, only three dogs are dressed (though none should be, since they do not normally travel ‘in character’, and their old stained costumes will have been replaced). The exceptionally melancholy, bandy bulldog in the foreground – heavily clad as John Bull – apparently portrays the leader. The dog privileged to be on Jerry’s back and to be wearing only a collar is presumably the fourth member of the company since he is too large to be the little terrier – formerly Short’s Toby dog – produced from Jerry’s pocket at the Jolly Sandboys, and who is represented by the indeterminate object Browne shows protruding from that receptacle. Aptly, Browne has made Jerry himself look like a close – though less desperate – relation of Bull’seye’s master, the murderer Bill Sikes, in Cruikshank’s illustration to chapter 48 of Oliver Twist (1837) see Figure 5.5. 28
108 Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
Figure 5.5 George Cruikshank, ‘Sikes attempting to destroy his dog’: Oliver Twist (1837–39). Reproduced by permission of the Charles Dickens Museum.
Beryl Gray 109
The weekly numbers of Master Humphrey’s Clock were available as collected monthly Parts. As Stevens has argued, it is not until the sixth Part (Numbers 22–26, chapters 29–37), that Dickens seems to have settled upon a standard procedure by which the woodcuts mark off the physical identity of the monthly set. This [Part], which concludes Volume I of the Clock, opens with a headpiece and initial and ends with a tailpiece. After this, with two exceptions only, each [Part] carries a headpiece with initial on its opening recto but nowhere else, while most have a tailpiece or inset on the final verso. 29 As Stevens goes on to suggest, ‘the physical image presented by the final verso of an issue, and its usefulness for concluding a theme, or confirming a mood, with the display of a memorable illustration’ was of consequence to Dickens. ‘In the forty issues which carry OCS, seventeen final versos offer illustrations; seven are issue tailpieces, the rest half page insets. Both types mark moments of significance in narrative or theme’,30 while the ‘[t]ailpieces for issues are ... striking’.31 Curiously, however, Stevens devotes no part of her discussion to the vignette of Jerry and his dogs, despite the fact that it is a tailpiece not only for a weekly Number, but for the sixth monthly Part – the Part that, as she says, establishes the functional pattern of image in relation to text that the remaining issues of the Clock are to follow. Furthermore, it is the final verso of the periodical’s first volume, the completion of which was momentous enough to warrant a celebration dinner to which Dickens invited everyone who had contributed directly to the Clock’s workings. Apart from the novel’s final tailpiece, in which Cattermole depicts Nell being carried up to heaven by angels – it could hardly have been allotted a more significant place. Dickens’s inclusion of it among the 32 engravings he selected from the original 75 for the two-volume1861 Illustrated Library Edition of the novel, where it again appears as the last plate in the first volume, confirms its significance to him. It is even one of the eight – of which five are disproportionately selected from Cattermole’s original contributions – reproduced as plates in the 1868 Charles Dickens edition, though there brought forward from chapter 37 to chapter 20, a chapter in which there is no reference whatsoever to the canine performers, but where the illustration remains sufficiently distanced from the Jolly Sandboys scene to preclude competition with the effect of Dickens’s text.32 In the place originally assigned it, the engraving both upholds what Short recounts but has not witnessed, and re-establishes Jerry – identified by the single gentleman as ‘this man of the dogs’ (313) – as a figure of consequence: undoubtedly suitably remunerated, it is after all he who is brought to the single gentleman to tell him where to find Nell and her grandfather. 33 Furthermore, by
110
Man and Dog: Text and Illustration in The Old Curiosity Shop
juxtaposing the two dissociated groups – Jerry and his dogs in the foreground