=
-4
.
~
~ >
:r:
()
Z
-<
r
S
.2
-
>
O
...... ~
..... ~
t;..., t;...,
~
~
.....
m
:r:
O
,.
2
t
~
=
::
e
z
>
~
Hl1(-1-t FI LM AN O CULTU RE
A
; ,.,.,t'j
'lC"I/I/'¡///
What Madc Pislachio NI/ti ? Farly Sound
mly Pre..-.'
11,/
Edll~'¡
b\' jU/¡/i /;, //1,,,
Comedy ami/he [la /ldn,i!le Aeilhetic
\!,f,,,lramu und Mudan;ty; l:ar/I' Sell,""'/'''!.d '/IIt'mrl .11"/ {IJ COflfl'X¡'SEN SI~Gtk
HENRY JENKINS
HUJJdrmu 1)~({t TtCIJ(
Show,'/oppers: Busby Be'-kele)' al1d Ihe Traduio" ofSpeclade
MARTIN RUBIN
Projuliofls of War: Hollywood, Americal/ C" II/lre, anti World War [/ THO MAS DOHERTY
WILLlAM PAU L
LAughing Hysterically; Amn -ican Screen Comedyoflhe 195°S
ED SIKOV
Primitill<' Pas..-iollS: Vúua lity, SexualilY, Elhnography, a"d COlllemporar)' Chillese Ci/1e1l1a
REY CH OW
The Cinema ofiv!ax Ophuls: Magis/erial Visio" a'nd the F.gure of Woman Black Women a" Cuu ural Rl!tUiers
J"
~/11,t"J~ I
UIIII
ti!'"
AL. ISON GRIFFITHS fJ c:.'flf,"
(hl(1
1/,,/llb"HH1 1',-I/t·( 1,
}'ro/'IJJ!.ootiu in llll \ lfll.
Naúullalldentily, japanese Film DARRELL WILLlAM DA VI S
/I,,, ','.Ii, (1 1;,1
Jt:J.
J/lkln/.. ·
J / U/)}fJd'U/h
,'\ru '/,¡/
¡)(" ,.: '\';11." \,,'"
11 '111'/"1 l Jt.:ifgn¡Il,l.,'
n
ROBERT lAN'~
/1,(11)''''(1'''/ Fti",
TH E
.1, ,,(
impossible
MICHELE PIFRSON
. 1,[ /), r
If .'0 1Htll {'UUIIOI,
/h,- Ft'llItllc Form
lid
LUCr FI~CH~k
DAVID LYN CH
Cold War, Cool ¡\f..dw/1/ '1 '/'1"1"""', :\.1cCurth)'¡jm, dlldlll/(I/(.III ( '/lfltlle TH OM AS DOHERTY ,l.
¡;,.mini,,1
AN DREW BRITTON
1-f()1/1<
RICK AL.T MAN
in Ho l/),/('ood' rhe fmagi1ltlry
Geogral'l.)' (Jf Hollywood
TODO McGOWA N
ELlSABETH BRONFEN
Atlack ofthe Leading LAdies: Gender, Sexuality, und SpeaalOr.,hip ill Classic Horro,. Cinema
Hollywood and the Cuilure Elile; HOl(J the "fo ll;e; Bnamr: American PETER DECHERNEY
Tait/Ja fl Film Director.c 1I
RHONA J. BERENSTEIN
Th ú Mad Masquerade: Sla/dom alld Masculinily in the ja;:;", Age
Tr~a,'urt:
Jiland
EM ILIE YUE H-YU YEH AND DARRELL WILLl AM DAV IS
Shocl(;ng Rcpresm/aliol1: HU/arica/
GAYLYN STUDLAR
Sexual Poliúes a",1 Narrativ,· Film: Hollywood alld Beyol1d
¡\1,UClIlint'
Si/mI FIII/I '\"111,,1
JACQUELlNE BOBO
Piclu";.ng japa ne¡~"ess: Monumental Slyle,
ROBIN WOOD
Th e Soul1ds ofCommerce: Marketing Popular JEFF SMITH
Onoll Wd[e.<, Shal(e.
COlrlo l ,
,h, .{ , /JlU' ¡
Ka rharlll" [-(,pilltll, ' .\r."
SUSAN M_ WHlTE
Film Music
uf
LO U IS PI ZZ ITOLA
LAugh il1g Screamiflg' Modero Hollywood Horror and Comedy
,lIId l il1l1
MICHAEL AN DEREGG
Pre-Code Hollywood: Sex, [mmol'(]lily, and h1Jurrectlon in A,nt",.icall Cinema,
1930-- 1934 THOMAS DOHE RTY Sound Tuhnology an d ,he American Cúul1la:
Trauma, Natiotla l Cinema, and rhe Modern Horror Film ADAM LO WEN STEIN
Ch¡'w
O" Ser",.,,.. C¡'¡n-m" dlld .'\/,.ullm
CHRIS 8E RRY A N D MARY FAR QU HAR
The Nc-w r'-" rope¡J/1 Cinema. Redrdu'lII/!, r/¡e Map
RO SA lI ND G ALT
Georgc G J llup in Ho ll ywood SUSAN OH MER
Elec/rú' Souflds: 'fedm%gical Ch(ltJgt: alld
PerccplÍon, Rcpresm/aúrm, Modemit
tlr,. 1?1S<' lit Cr"'P0mrc' Mllss Media
JAM ES LAS TR A
STEV E J. WU RTl LER
~
\,.J
I
ti
M" I A 11 H I Y I /I~, i T...
tJ WI ', ",
NlW YO'I(
For J)a shicl l and Thco Ncroni, who allowed me to uno crstand l,'rag '-,'¡ cad
e ~ol ul11biJ U nivt rt; ity Prl.: SS
I'"blishn s Silla 1893 ',,«' w Y'Jr k
Chich c...q cr, Wcst Susse l:
'"pyright G)
\11 right,
200 ¡
C.olumbi a- U nl vers iry Prcss
l <,slTved
.• l.l:tr y ofC'..ungrcss C" 13 lol!i ng- in -Public"tion Data \leGo\\'.n , Todd.
Th o imp"" ible Da,·id Lr nch I TodJ MeGow. n p.
cm. -
(Film "nd cullure)
In d ud es bibliog ra phi GIi 'eferellces "nd index o
rSBN- '3: 978 0-23'. 13954-0 (c1",h : . Ik. pa per)
rSBN- lo: O-'3l-13954-3 (c1orh: olk . paper)
-
ISBN 0-23 1- 13955 -1 (pbk . : :d k. p.lper)
[. Lynch, O;.\Vid, 19-1 6- - C ri(icisrn ;.l lld
in lcrprc;t:Hion. I. Tirlt:. 11. St: ri t." s.
P N I ~·3· L96:-' I34
2007
79 '-43Q2 i'.lCl92-<1c22
IBI
2oo602lh23
olumbiJ Uni vc::rsit y Prcss perm~\I'\e m
bo(}k~ !1ft
ano dur~lblc ~l c id ·frce
printed on
p :l p(" f.
Prima l in ch e U nitcd St3H':Sof Ame ricJ. 1091;765 4 32 ' P . 09 8 7 6 51 3 2
C
CONTENTS
A
e K N o W LEo G M
EN T S
IX
INTROD UCTlON T he Bi za rre N atu re of N o rmality
ONE Sac rificing One's Head for an E raser TWO Thc Integration
26
oC th e Impossible O bject in
The E/ephant Man
49
THREE Dunc and (he Patn to Salvat ion
68
FOUR Fa nrasizing the Fa ther in Blue Ve/vet FIVE The Absence of Desire in Wild al Hearr
90
11 0
SIX Twú¡ Peaks: Fire Walk with Me
and Identification with the Object SEVEN Findi ng O ursclvcs OD
:l
12 9
Los! Highway
154
EIGHT T he Eth ics o f Fantasizing in Th e Straight Story
177
NINE Naviga ting Mulholland Drive, Da vid Lyn ch's
P an egy ric to Holl ywood
194
CONCLUSION T hc E th ics of Fa ntasy N OTES
IN
o ex
220
22 5
.!~'I
VII
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Thanks to th e Unive rsiry of Texas Press for permitting me to reprint material that nrst appeareJ iD Ci nema Joum a!. Much of chapter 7orig jnaUy appean:~d as "Fin di ng O urselves on a Lost High way: Da vid Lyn ch's Lesson in Fantasy," Cinema joumal39.2 (W in te r 2000): 51 -73, and m uch oE chapter 9 appeared as "Lost on Mulholland Dril/e: Na vi gating David Lynch's Panegyric to Hollywood," Cinema joumal 43.2 (Winter 2004) : 67-89, copyrig ht © 2000 an d 2004 by the Uni versiry of Texas P ress; all rights rese rved. r owe a trem endous debt [O Juree Sondker at Colum bi a U ni versi ty Press for having faith in the book even when tbis faith seemed mis placed, and to Roy Thomas for h is carefu l wor k o n the manuscript. T ha nks to Dashiel l an d T heo Ncroni, for sitting patiently while 1 ri rse com posed many of the chapte rs, and for proviJing relief when 1 wasn't composing anything. Many of th e ideas in this book were renned o ver two sumille r c(jur~es, du ring whicb [he contributions of many students, including rhose of Cate Racek , Sara Bumen, Carl y Ma rino, a nd ]onathan San horn owere l:xtre mely helpful. Itan b ro E lí~abc th Bronfe n, w hose thoughtfuI comments on the IX
manuscript allovved me to see the overall direction of the argument in a new light. 1 would l ike to thank Ken Rcin hard for putting together the Semi nar on Experimental Critical T heory in the summer of 2004, which in formed the d irection of my thoughts on L ynch and allowed me the op portuni ty to present w hat ultimately developed into the conclusion of this boo k. Slavoj Ziie k provided an insightful read ing of tbe m a nuscript, an d his w ork has remained the starting point and the end point for m y ap proach to Lynch. My conve rsaxions with David Jenemann allowed me to anticipate many of the potential objections to the arguments ad vanced bere. Anna Kornbluh was instrumental in advancing my though t and helpi ng me to work through many of the issues of the book. Q uentin Martin also helped me to develop my thinking on Lynch. T hanks to Sarah N ilsen and Jean W yatt for their consci entiolls an al ysis of significant portions of the book and for highlighting its most dogma tic moments. I owe a buge debt ro Pb il Poster fo r reviewing th e book in él rough fo rm and for helping m e to construct a first intclligible draft. r app rcci ate Da niel N orford's careful reading of rhe m anuscr ipt. Myles Jewell provided a deta iled read ing th at belped highlight all me places where tbe book w as n't clear. Thanks ro Vin ney Cavallo fo r tbe subtlc suggestions th at made this a muc h more read able and accu rate work. F inall y, thanks to Wa lter Davis, Panl E isenste in, a nd HiJary Neroni, w ho havc informed everything I th ink about Lynch and have ac quaintcd th cmselves so tho ro ug hly ,vitb this book that they have al mos l w ri tten it themseJ ves.
X
ACK N OWLEOGEMEN TS
THE
impossible
D AVI D LY NC H
INTRO DUCT ION T he Bizarre Nature ofNormality
Wotching from a Distance The g reatness of a work of art depends on its abili ty ro transform the :lUJience. As Rilke form ulates ir in his poem "The A rcha ic Torso of Apallo," the great work of art tell s us that we have to change our lives.' 1f one accepts this defin irion, ir immediatdy rh rows the idea of a great film un o d oubt. Though we may pro ject oursel ves ioro filmic na rra tives thro ug h idcntification w ith lhe cam era ur w ith ch aracters, the ilmitations of [he medi um m ean mat the film we are watching never Sees us and never add resses us directly. Perhaps this is wh y Orson We lles insists that "no movie that w ill ever be made is worthy of being c1iscussed in th e same b rea rh lwith one of Shakespeare's plays]."2 One doesn't simply watch a play; as an audience me m ber, one is part of the pt!rformance--Dr at ¡east one has the possibil ity of seeing haw the per formance takes its aucl ience into accou n t. A play from Shakespeare can .\dd ress its aud ience members directly a ncl demand tha t th ey change theír Qwn lives ba sed on what t ranspi res on the stage. For their part, novcls invol v~ their reade rs by demandi ng an imaginativ e act that com pletes the artwork . Bur .he cinema is predicated on the distancc that m e vícwing silU;J tinn tcnds to creare hetwee n spectators and wh at they see IIIl tite \crn·n.
Spec ta tors wa tch fmm a d ista ncc; they watch the screen images from a position that ens ures the ir lack of d irect involvement in what they see. In contrast wi th attend ing a play, watching a film, as numerous film the orists have noted, allow$ us a high degree of anonymity. Much of the ap pea l of film spectatorship stems fro01 our ability to watch filmic events without being seen. T hc uni d irectional view ing situation permits the spectator ro remain safe within rhe anonymity of darkness.3 The distance between screen an cl spectator becomes a more signifi cant problem inso fa r as it so often rem ai ns unperceived amid the illu sory presence of screen images and events . Through identification with the camera and characters, the spectator attains a sense of proximity and involvement with what transpires on the screen. When watching a film, one often feels oneself in a position internal to the events rather than externa!. But this proximity is imaginary, proximity from a dis tance, and the distance allows the spectator to avoid any encounter in the cinema that migilt challenge or alter the spectator's subjectivity. Any experience of a film's immediacy is a thoroughly mediated one be cause characters 00 screen remain seen but never see while the specta tor sees without being seen. From his first feature craserhead (1977) through each of his subse quent films, m e fi lms of David Lynch present a challenge to this view ing situation. The great achievement of his films lies in their ability ro break clown the clistance ber ween spectator and scree n. Rather than permitting the im aginary proximity that dom in a tes in m ainstream cin ema, Lynch's fil m s implicate tb e spectator in their very structure. Tb e structure of a Lynch film altas the cinema tic viewing situation itself and deprives tbe spectator of the u nd erlying sense of remain ing at a safe distance from what tak es place on the screen. Lynch incl udes cine matic momcnts that force the spectalor to beco me aware of how th e film itself takes into account the spectator's desire. His films confront one with sequences that rl: \ eal one's own ir:vestment in what one sees. Ir is in this sense that Lynch is "weird" : one cannot watch a Lynch film in the way that (lne watches a standard Hollywood film nor in the way that one watches most radical films. The structure of a Lynch film challenges the spectator's tradirional experience of the cinema just as it engages and challenges the history of film tb eory. The aim of th is book is ro take up that challenge an cl to pursue the th eo retical possibilities presented to us in Lynch 's films.
THf; IMPOSSIBlE DAVID lYNCH
Lynch's challenge to spectators departs significantly from tb_e ap proach that dominates radical cinema, which consists in enhancing the spectator's sen se of distance fr(lm events on the screen rather than e1im ina ting it. This approach has informed not just ho\\' alternative film ma kers construct their films but al so how theorists have conceived the possibility of a radical cinema. To unoerstand Lynch's uniquencss as a filmmaker, we must first examine the alternative that his films defy. Psychoanalytic film theor,ists in the late 1960s and I~:!70S such as C hristian Metz and ]ean-Louis Haudry were a ttuned ro cinema's ahility to create spectators who watch at a distance without at the same time hav ing any awareness of this distance. They saw this vievving situation as the primary way in which cin ema functioneo ideologicalIy to aid in subject.ing spectators. \\Thile watching a film, as Metz puts it, "it is al ways the other who is on the screcn; as for me, 1 am there to look at him. T tak e no part in tb e perceived, on the contrary, 1 am al1-perceiving. All perceiving as one says all-powerful (this is the famous gift of'ubiquity' m e film gives its specta tor); all -percei vi ng, too, beca use 1 am entirely on che side ufthe pcrccivi ng instance."4 The act of wa tchi ng a film, acco rd ing to th is way o f thinki ng, is a on c-way ex pe rience in w hich the specta tor bas no in volvement in what is visible on che screen. By leav ing the specta tor jn th is si tuation of being "all-perceiving," the cinema allows the specta tor to expe rience the combination of distance from an d prox im ity to the screen events. a combinaríon th at permits the spectator to be simulcaneo usl y involved and noto lusofar as it works to sustain spectator d istance, rhe cinema seems fu ndamen ta lly voye uristic. As Lau ra Mul vey notes, "the extreme con tms t betwecn tbe darkness in the auditorium (wh ich also isolated the spcctators from one another) and the brilli ance of the shifting patterns of ligh t and shade on th e screen helps to prom ote the illusion of voy eu ristic separaríon."5 M ulvey is careful to note here that the separation or distance inhe re nt in cinematic voyeurism (and in voyeurism as SU€'h) is ¡¡¡usory. W 'hy? The thrill of voyeurism depends on a fundamental fúilu re o f self-recognition. T be voyeur believes that she/he is looking at a sceIle tbat sim ply exists in itself and th at has oot been constructed for halhis look. Hence, the voyeur can see otbers in their private world, wh:u cx ists lX' l1c:llh tbeir public face, and the voyeur's enjoyment de rives f rol1l ,ccing liti s private wor ld . This utte rly private OJoment
IN rRO DUCTlO N
would be, in the thinking of the voyeur, what others were rcally like , how they appea r when no one is looking. But when che voyeur looks on this private moment, what shclhe mi sses is its structured na ture. E ve n the most intimate l110ments in our lives structure themselves arouad a puhlic look, even when that look is absent. The suhject in a private moment continues, al beit most often unconsciously, to act and presen t her/himself for an imagined 100k. 6 We per form our in timate acuvi ties in ways that confirm a certain idea we have of ourselves, and m is self-image implies an external look what Freua calls an ego idea l-that apprehends it. The implicit on look e r gives m eaning and structure to the private activity. Without the implicit on looker or ego ideal, \Ve would hav e no sense of how to act in private, no method for organizing our private lives) In short, the scene that the voycu r witnesses is always a scene created for the look of the voye ur, ond this is what the voyeur cannot seco There is something fundamentally disappointing about voycurism: it never sees w hat it's looking ror hllt instead sces J moment created for its look. The strllctured natllre of the private mOlllent is most cmphati cally true in the case of ci nema: we ca nnot even imagine a film not or gani zed around the look of a spectator, and yet this is prec isely w ha t most fil ms-and , just as impo rta ntly, most spectators-attempt to dis avow. In rbis sense, the fi lm itself does look back at the spectators inso far as its very structure takes their dcsire as spectators into accoun t. There is no film that has becn made not to be seen. 8 W hi le wa tch ing a fi lm, especially a typica l Holly wood fi lm , the spec tator does not experiencc he r/himself playing a role in th e eve nts. T hey happen-the film plays-and the spectator s.impl y looks on. What be com es masked in th is situation is the structuring dynam ic behind the events: w ha r (he spectator sees on the screen is not sim ply there to be secn, but crea ted specificalIy with the spectator's loo k in m ind. Every event on the screen a nticipares a spectator who completes it through the act of wa tching. Rather than being llninvol ved with a nd distanced from th e even ts 00 the screen, the spcctator is fu 11 y enm eshed. 9 Not ooly d oes the com bina tion of distance a nd p roximity inform the cinematic view ing siwation irself, but ir also informs the societal atti tud e ro che cinema as such. Spectato rs kee p the cincma itself at a dis lance by consig ning ir te> tbe rea lm of fan la sy alld ~n'i ll ¡'; i l : I~ :1 place of escape from lheir dail y rea li ty. [f we try In Ihill" tlllllIl~ 1t '''' _ di ~'l ,r bil1g
TII E IM POSS IOL E 0""' 1[) I YNCH
or traunutic naturc of a film we have seen, we often hear-or even say to ourselves- that "it's just a movie." Th e common practice of critics calling hit films "grea t rides," as if the cinema were ao amusement park, fits into this pattern of distancing. [f we conceive of the cinema solely as an escape, thcn we dissociate ourselvcs from what takes place there. O ne goes to the cinema for fun, for release, but never for an ex perience that migh t impact one's real life. E\'cn films that don't promise fun in thc traditional sense-likc MonJter (Patty Jenkins, 2003) or Schindler's L ú t (Steve n Spiel be rg, 1993)--offer us a glimpse of a foreign world tha r we tend to see as ha ving no rdation to our own. At the sam e time that spectators relega te cinema to the status of an escape, they also accept the rea lity of w hat they see in the cinema. Spec tatoes distance themselves from the cinema and its effects by acknowl edging its purel y fantasmatic status, and yet when they go to the cin ema, they take the images on the screcn seriously. As spectators, we Lend to end ow fi lm w ith what Joe! Black calls the "reality effect." Ac cord iag to Black, "one of film's key effccts has been to provide viewers with a kind of enhanced, X-ray vision tha t all ows them tú feel that they can penet rate che veil of supcr.ficial appea rances and see the hidden structu re of reality ir.sclf."'" T he a bility to "see the h idden structure of reality itself" is, ofcoursc , false, bu t it nooetheless infor ms tbc na ture of m e cin ematic experience. As a result, the "escape" from rea lity-the cinema itself- bccomes the priv ileged si te fol' d etermi_ning the way in whi ch rhe subject unde rstands thar reali ty.
Jean-Luc Godard as Alternativa
In re ~ ponse lO the situa tion of tbe cinematic spectator, radicall theorists and fi lmm akers of the 1960s and r970s called for a cinema that es chewed th e im agi nary proxirnity of the typical Hollywood film and [oreed spectators to recogru ze their alienation. Thcy adopted an ap proach to the cinema that m irrored Bertolt Brecht's approach to the rheater. In his politici zed theater, Brecht wants to produce detached spectato rs wh o are aware of mci r detachm ent and in no \Vay prone to idenrifi cation with w hat happens on stage. As Brecht puts it, "The es scntial poia t of the cpi c theatre is perhaps that it appeals less to the feel ings !.han rh(" spectator's rea sull. lnstead of sharing an cxper ience the spectJtor mu st C()mc LO g rips w ith th ings." 11 Brecht's spectator watches
I NrrRO o u C,T ION
distance, which is what distinguishes his spectator from the traditional
mas ks the Jomination that inheres in he rlh is very symbolic positio n as an authority figur e. Shelhe appears warm and accessible, but this oh
cinematic spectator. In order to facilitate greater understanding on the
s cure~ the symbolic, structu ra 1 distance betwee n th e authority figure
spectator's part, Brecht's theater challenges spectators to experience
and us as ord ina ry subjects. Exposing rhe symbolic authority be nea th
their actual social position without its fantasmatic rerricve. Transferring Brecht's theoretical innovations from the theater to the
Lhe imag inary g uise becomes a political proj ect. Similarly, theorists like
cinema, film theorists and filmmakers embraced a filmm a king style
by confronti ng th e imag ina ry mode in w hich we experience it.
tha t foreg rounded spectator distance fmm the activities on the screen a nd took up what Brecht calls the "alienati(ln-effect." l o the same essay
tance from tb e events on the screen represcn ts the only possi bili ty fu r an
from a distance but always remains aware thal shelhe watches from a
M ulvey a nd Metz w a nt to lay ba re che symb<Jlic structure of the cinema A ccording to m ese theorists, making spectators awa re of their dis
proximity, Laura Mulvey chamrions precisely this type of response:
:llte rnative cinema. The atte mpt to go the other way-to iocrease tbe spectator's sense of proxi mi ty and eli m inate the spectator's sym bolic
The first blow against the monolithic accumulation of traditional
dista nce-cannot succeed. Distan ce is, for tbese theorists, the sine qua non of the cinematic experi ence, a nd proximi ty is a lways an illusion
io which she denounces classical Hollywood cinema's use of imaginary
film conventions (already unde rtaken by radical film-makers) is to
that attempts
free the look (lf the camera into its materiality in time and spaee
can struggle against the im aginar)' proximi ty th at the cine ma crea tes,
to
hide thi s fun da m ental fact o f the cinema. Filmmak e rs
and the look of the audience into dialectics, passionate detachment.
but they can't do an ym ing about the distance thar ex ists bctwee n the
There is no doubt that this destroys the satisfaction, pleasure and
spectato r and the screen w hi ch is the resul t of th e facts of film ex hibi
privikge of the "invisible guest," and highlights how fi lm depended
tio n and cven the social o rder itse\f. Layers of mediati on sepa rare the
on voyeuristic acti ve/rassi ve mechani sm s. J2
specta to r from the events él film depicts. T he ecanomic sys tem that pro duces the film, tbe directo r's visiono the technologica l a ppa ratus lh at
Mulvey's goal for radical filmm aking- "passionate d etachment"-is a state in which the spectator thinks rather than hlindly id enti fies. Mul vey
Jisplays the fil m-lh ese fo rces a nd others mediate w hat m e spectator sees 011 the screen , and one cannot si m ply elim inale them .
ehamrions films that privilcge the symbolic situatedness o f the specta
Th is is w h y Constance Penley takes issue w ith supposed radical film
tor--or, as Christian Merz puts ir, fi lms that "attempt to disengage the
makers who attempt to rely so lely o n ra dical images to shoc k spectato rs ¡nto change. Such filrnmakers, according to Pen ley, ioev itably contrib
cinema-object from the imaginary and to w in it for the symbolic." '3 T his allusion to psychoanalytic theorist Jacques Lacan 's categories of
ute lO the very cinematic fa~cinatio n and imagina ry blin d nes~ that they
experience-the imagi na ry and the sym bolic-provides anothe r way
setout to con tes t. T his is beca use, ac w rding to Penlcy, "Jmages have ve ry
of undcrstanding the relation ship betwecn proximi ty and distance in
little a na lyrical powc r in them sel vcs; their power of identificatian and
the cinema. The symbolic order, fo r Lacan, is the order ofla nguage and
fascinatian is too strong. T his is w hy there must alw ays be a commentary Oll the image simul taneousl y w ith the com mcntary of and with them." '4
society: it provides the structure that organizes our social rcal ity and crea tes the identities that we inhabit. This order underlies the visible
Peoley 's criti que he re call s for a film maker w ho wo uld forsa ke the fa lse
world and thus rem ai ns la rgely invisible, though its laws determine
lmmediacy of the cinem atic imaginary fo r a filmm a king style that high
much of what happens in the visible ",orld . It functions through ah
lighted the symbolic mediatian alw a ys at work but unperceived in the cine m aric experience. The m ost prom inent filmm aker who embodies
sence, shaping our li ves in wa)'s that \\ie remain unaware of. What we see, in contrast, is the imaginar)', a world of images that appear to be immediately presento The imaginary deceiv es us imofar as ir hides the underlying symbolic structure that urholds it. f nr i n~ t;lI1 cc. lhe imag e
lhis theorerical aspirati on is und o ubted ly Jean-Luc Godard (though it predomi na tes l.hroughout avant-ga rde cine ma).15
of an authority figure. as a gcnuincly carill¡..\
ing
T'-IE 'MP OSS ' BLE
DAVID LYN C II
IlI"f'" I I. l \l"1
ir ir b lrue,
G oJ
fi lll1. By duillg Ihi~, he aims to b reak the fa scinating powc r o fth e
I N ' ~OD U C T I ON
cinema over the spectator and create awareness of the process that pro duces the events on the screen, thereby facilitating a more thoughtful engagement betwee n the spectator and the film -a more dialectical ex perience. As Pascal Bonitzer notes, "the image, since GoJard, has been affirmed as resolutely false."16 Even as early in his career as A Bout de souffle (Brea thless , 1960), the jump cuts and self-conscious allusions to other films have an aliena ti ng effect that highlights the constructed na ture of the image. As he develops as a filmmak er, however, this quality becomes more pronounced (in films such as Vivre sa vie IMy Life to Live, 19 62 ], Les Carabznzás [The Rifleme12 , 19(,31, and Pierrot lelou [19651). Le MépriJ (Contempt, 1963), for instance, begins with a long tracking shot of a tracking shot being shot by the actual cameraman for the film while we hear the film's credits rcad aloud. This beginning confronts the spectator with visual evidence that hreaks down any illusion of proxim ity to the events that will follow. Ir signals to the spcctator that the events are not real and are, in fact, thoroughly med,i ated. Later in the 19605, Godard develops this aesthetic fu rther in Week Hnd (19 67), wherc we see shots oftex t intersperscJ at points in the film intcr rupting an cxtraordinarily long tracking shot. [n addition, the second half of the film completely unravels the narrati vc structure that opens the film, thereby demanding that the spectator recogni ze the cOl1str ucteJ nature ofme filmic narrati ve- anJ of all filmic narrative. The viewer of Week F:nd constantly has her/ his immed iate rda tion to the film inter rupted by blatant intrusions of media tion. T hi s film, lik e almost all of Godard 's films, aims to eliminate the halluci nato ry proxi mi ty chat seem s to inhere in the cinematic situation and tú allow th e speccator to wa tch from a distance. 1n doing so, m ese films work to strip away the lie of the cinema, to make it a 1e5S fantasmatic experience. Goda rd 's subsequent films move cven more raJically in this direction. His aim remai ns con stant: alienating the spectator into a proper g rasp of cinematic distance. Goda rd wants to create a ci nema of mediation as part ofa struggle against
Hollywood and bourgeois id eology's illusion ofimmediacy. The hope underl ying this type of cinema is actually a fundamentally anti-cinematic one. Ir aims to use the cinema tú assist the spectator in transcending the cinema's fascination. The ideal specta tor for this alter native cinema will escape the seduction of fanta~ y a mi thu s be able to see the actual structure of the cinema a mI (Ir Sll~ ¡l'l y il ~l·1 r. T h:l t is. the ideal subject will see th e real íty Oflhl"
THE IMP OS $ IBLE D AV I D
LYNCl~1
p l"l ll llll 11111 1
I IIIlÚ :~' r:l1 her rha n
th e fascinating comrnoJities that disguise this proccss. By accomplish ing this, th e spectator will be on tbe way to becoming él raJical suhject ready to cha nge existing social relations beca use this spectator will no longer be blin d to the way tbings rea lly are. Idea lly, such a spectator wiJl overcome commodity fetishism itself, in wh ich, according tú Ma rx's famous form L1lation, "a definite social relati on between men ... as sum es ... the fanrastic form of a rdation hetween things."17 By expos ing the im age as constructcd, as the product of él "definire social rela tion," Godard's films attack this form of fascination at a site (the cin ema) where it usually predominates. G rasping one's alienation in the cinema would become the key, ultimately, to revolutionizing capital.ist society. The problem wi th the attempt lO create él spectator whom the cin ema does not seduce is its tacit assumption: it imagines that th e specta tor can attain apure view ing position. Th e Brechtian aesthetic forgets about the d esire of the spectator and fails to see haw desire necessarily impli ca tes the spectato r in what occurs 00 th e screen. Even though dis tance ís inherent ín th e ci nema tic viewing situa tion itself, no spectato r can remain completc\y d istanced, evcn from a G oda rd film . Some e1c ment or fascin ation remains at work and continues to i.ovol vc the spec tator in m e i mages on th e screen--oy e/se the spectator would simply walk out 01 the film. In othe r words, a film's alien ation-effect has to fail to sorne extent in order fo r the fil m to retain th e desire o f ¡ts spectators. Thc sLlccessfuJly d istanced specta to r ccases tú be a spectator at all. The impossíbil ity of rhe pure spectator condemns rhe Brechrian aes m etic to an une nding pursuit, but d oes n't necessarily ind icate that the pursu it itself is \.vrong beaded. T he deeper problem with me opposition to cinema tic fascinar íon líes in íts conception of .vhat moti va tes politi cal activ ity ancl change. T his position contenJ s that knowleclge itself seeing how things reall y are, how the procluction process really \Vorks, ete.-has a ra J icali zing effccr on spectators and su bjects in general. Ac co rru ng to this view, subjects accept their subjection to an oppressi ve social ord er only because they fail lO recogni ze that an e1eme nt of fasci nation has Juped them into this acceptance. Thus, the th inking goes, if we remove me fascination and expose the rclations of production as they actuall y :lrt~. we w ill produce radical subjects. But kn owledge vvirhour dl'~ i n d
111l_c\O IJ " ' I U N
.,
through the prcv ailing ideology and yet continue to obey.1H For in stance, \Ve continue ro cnjoy the gratuiwus sex scene in IVaYlle'J fVorld (Penelope Sp heeris, 1992) even when a su'btitle labels it as such, or \Ve continue to suppon wars even when we see through the deceptive ra tionale g iven for them. Subjects aclopt a position of cynical distance in which the tra nsparency of th e game becomes pan of the game itself. 1n this sense, a cinema that emphasi zes distancing the spcctator only plays into the hand of contempora ry ideology. The further lacu na in the Brechtian aesthetic is its inability to con sider a motivarion for political change \vithin fascination itself. Though fascination accommodates subjects to their subjection, it also has the ability ro encourage them to challenge that subjection . This is beca use fantasy as such em erges in order to cover up a teal gap within ideology or the symbolic ord er. Lacan uses the ter m "real" as a third category of cxperience (in addition to imaginar)' and symbolic) to indicate the in complctcness of the symholic structure, its fa ilure ro constitute itself as a coherent w hole. Ideology use s fantasy to shore up its point of greatest weakness- the point at w hich its explanations of social phenomena brea k dow n-and tbis injects a potential radicality into every fantasy that proponcnts ofthe B rechtian aesthetic faíl tosee. In the act of decry ing fan tasy as an im agina ry manipul ation, the proponents of a di stanc ing cinema fa il to see the real moment w ithin every fa nta sy. It is this m om ent that th e fi lm s of David L yn ch em p hasize.
The Proximity of David Lynch Dav id Lynch began m aki ng films at the Pennsylvan ia Acad emy ofFine Arts in Ph iladelphia, w here he initial ly we nt to beco me a painter. His first film , Six Figures Gettillg Sick (1967), w hich he made there, lasts one minute and repea ts on a continuous loop. A fter directing a four-minute foll ow-up film, T he Alphabet (1968), he moved tú Los Angeles, w here he attended th e Am erican F il m I nstitute and made a 34-minurt' fi ,lm entitl eJ The Grandmother (1970). E ach of these early shorts evinced ,y nch's interest in using film as a fantas 01atic m edium, but it is The Gral/dmother that inaugurated thc fundam ental ;1 csthct ic stru cture d1at wou ld dom inate Lynch's fealU re fil ms. In [972. l..ynch rl'~c i vl' d $ro.ooo fr om MI to make EI"I.JScrhead ([ 977), wh idl II( prn pllwd as another short. After five year~ ofprep m cluc tillll, ~llIttllill ¡':. Il1d 1 1I1~l pr()du ctio n ,
10
[H E I MPQSS IBLE DAVI J) ,Y NC H
it became Lynch's first feature, bcgin ning a carecr in the cinema that stands out likc no other. Lynch's distincti ve ness stems from his ability to exist withi.n main stream cinema and independen t cinema simultaneously. His fiLms of ten show at the local multiplex , and he has received three Academy Award nominaLÍons for Bes t D irector (for The F:!ephant Alan 119 80 1, Blue Velve! [1986], and Muiholland Orive [200rJ). Hc is not simply a di rector cel ebrated at Can nes and ignored in Los Angeles. But his films also challenge vi ewers in ways that few Othcr widel}' distributed films do. They contain d istur bing imagcs (l ike the sexual assault of Lula [L aura D ernJ in Wild at Heart 11990)), narrative confusion (Iike the trans form ation of the main character into someone else in the middle of Lost High way Ir9971), and un usual shot sequences (Iike the opening montage in Blue Velvet). Lynch's films do not always receive a we!come reception al1l ong critics or the public, but the bare fact that ,films such as his gain widesprcad attention ar all is startling . . This book is an attem pt ro come to terms with the incongmity of Ly nch's positio n w ithin coIltemporary cinema and to link this incon g rui ty w ith t he acsthetic that Lynch develops in hi s films. Lynch 's work has occasioned sorne important work s of critic ism, including Michcl C hi on 's David Lynch (BFT, 1995) and Sta voj Zizc k's T he Ridiculous Sublime: On David Lynch\ "Lost Highway" (Uni versity of Wash ington Prcss, 2000), bu t only one book -lc ng th stud y dcaling wi th L ynch's films fro m a sustaincd theo retical perspective- Ma rtha Nochimson's The PassiorJ ol DavId L )I11c1I: Wild al Heart in Hollywood (Uni versity of exas P ress, 1997)·19 For N och il1lson, Lynch is the poe t of the creative power of the su bconsciou s. His film s e ncourage us to let go of our fan tasies of controll ing others and access, via our empathy, the real connec tions between peopl e. According to this theory, Lynch is a realist, anti fantasma tic film m ake r, a fi lmmak er opposed to standard Hollywood practice. H is fil ms don 't strike us as realistic beca use we are so enmeshed in
I I¡ UQ IIU CT II1N
11
the aim of altering the spectator's relationship ro the given social reality,
within it. To tbis e nd , his pe rsonal idiosyncrasies function as an exten
th ey go about accomplishing this in opposite ways. Whereas Godard
sion of this fundamental idea informing his film s. Tbro ugh th e wa)'
(like many alternative filmmakers) works ro alienate spectators and
tha t Lynch engages in them , behav iors central to Ame rican mythology
force them to recognize their Jistance from the images on the screen,
take on an alien a ppea ra nCt:. T his leads P au l W oods ro labe! Lynch "an
Lynch tries ro close this distance to an even grea ter extent than typi cal
All-American M artian 80y."22 Ly nch 's child hood in small-town Mis
Hollywood films. I f Godard is a filmmaker of distance, Lynch is a film
soula, Montana, his success in the Boy Scouts (bccoming a n Eagle
maker of proximity. But Lynch does not create proximity in the wa y \Ve might expect
Scout), hi s da ily trips to th e local B ig Boy resta ura nt, an d his del ive ring
by deconstructing th e binary opposition hetween fantasy and daily rea l
of th e norm in a way rhat causes ir to seem irregular Or strangc.
ity, between the outside world ¡¡nd the cinema. Unlike traditional alter
the WaLl StI-eef ¡ouma! to fin ance Eraserhead all ev ince his embodiment But ir is L ynch 's mode of drcss that best reveals his reJation to normal
native filmmakers, Lynch has no interest in deconstruction beca use
ity. During th e 1970s, fashion dictated that th e shirts of stylis h men
deconstruction involves sustaining oneself at a distance from the oppo
should be u nbuttoned e noug h to revea l their chest. T his style, popular
sition that one is Jeconstructing. 21 Rather than complica te or eve n und o
ized by, among othcrs, Jo hn Travolta in Saturday Night Fever (John Bad
binar)' oppositions, Lyn ch revels in them . Not only that: he push es bi
ham, ' 977) signified re beLliousness against the office dress code tha t de
nar)' oppositions to an extreme. In his films we see stark oppositions in
manded a coat and tie. O n e opened ooe's shirt and felt one's radicality.
character, in mise-en-sce:ne, in editing stylc, and in narrative structure.
The more buttons unbutto ned , the more radi cal. The conserva tive op
This is apparent, for in stance, in the opposition between th e two worlds
tion in volved leaving ju st the rop butto o undone. L ynch too k- a nd sti ll
of John Merrick (John Hurt) in Th(;' F.!ephant Man : the propriety of
takes- this conservnri ve position one step furth e r a nd buttoned his sh irt
l\ l1crrick 's daytime existen ce at the hospital contrasts ahsolutdy with th e
all the wa y. W ith out an accompanying tie, the shü t ful ly buttoned takes
perversity a nd ugliness of his nights there. During the day, T reves (An
o n an odd appearan ce, especially at a time when fas h ion d icta tes :l O un
thony Hopkin s) and Merrick 's visitors treat M errick with kindness and
buttoned look . O ne looks at Lynch wi th the fu ll y b u ttolled shi rt, and one
respect, whereas at night, the night porter (Michael Elphick) and lhe
sees somethi ng srran ge-pe rhaps evcn rad ica l- bul not somethin g u ut
visitors he brings to see Merrick treat hi m as a freak , retu rn ing Merrick
side the ma instream. H is a ttire brings lO light the odd ity o f the m ai n srream itself.
e motionall y t0 hi>~ days in the carnival und e r the vieious co nt rol ofBytes (Freddie J ones). Some such opposition structures a ll of Lynch 's films ,
ync h 's style of drcss is imporra n t o n ly insofar as it fo llows from and
and in each case Lynch sustai m; the oppos iti on throug h out th e film ,
¡lI umina tes h is filmic p roject. H is fiJms a re excessi vcl y normal in pre cisely the same way. T hey create a d ivision betwee n the rea lm of desire
con tributing ro the bi za rre quality ofh is \vork. Ironi ca ll)', the films seem bizarre to
precisely because of the exces
and the rcal m of fa ntasy, between the ex igencies of socia l rea lity a nd our
si veness of thei r normality- a nother twist in the separa tion hetween a
psychic respite from those exige ncies. 23 T his n ear-absolute division in
filmmaker such as Jean -Luc Godard and Lynch . \Vh e reas G odard aims
Ly nc h 's films plays a m ajo r pan in the quality ofme biza rre tha t we find
at offering an alternative to bourgeois cinema
in m em , and ye t this type ofse pa ration betwee n socia l reaLi ty ;.¡nd fantasy
w ants ro embody it funy. He is , in a word, bizarrely normal. This is
rep resents the very d efini tío n of n o rma lity.
LIS
what separa tes Lynch from so many of the other filmm a ke rs existing
W e tend to th ink (lf nor mali ty as culturally rel a ti ve and thus as be
on th e outskirts and outside of Hollywood. By taking up mainstream
reft o f theorericaJ sig nin.cance: the norm in one culture is abnormal in
filmm a king who leheartedly, he reveals th e radicality and pe rve rsity of
ano ther ; ga y partners hold ing ha n ds in publ ic is norma l in New Yo rk
the mainstream itself. He is too mainstream for th e tn ain ~tre:'l m .
C ity and It n.JCceprahle in r ural K'lmas. Ru t hy tracing how the d es iring
Throu g h th e ac t oftaking normality rll it~ I Clgi~,d tx t rcm~, Ly nch re vea ls h ow th e bi zarre is not oppos('.! to
12
rtlF IM PO S SI BlE DAVID I YNC It
tll l
IIl1t 111 .11 Inrt ¡nhere nt
su b jc:ct ('(Itl1l'~ ¡m/) IK ing, a
norr ll .t1lt v
t .ll i
1l111fl'
lhcu rl· ti"ally \ ig nificant conceptinn o f
hnlltllc vi\ihlc.; TIK dt.:\lri ng Stlh ,l'ét éill t.: rgc:s whcn an
IN I "OOUC 11 01'1
1',
individual encounters social demands-demands for sociall y acce pt able behavi or- fro m parents or some othcr soc ial authority. In. L acan's idiom, this fig ure w ho embod ies the social arder and its regu lations is rhe Other. The subj ecr enlers the soci al order confranted w irh rhe O th er's articul ated dem ano, hut th is demand conceal s u narticulareable dc si re. We hear a demand fro m an autho rity fig ure-"Clean up your room' " or "Do as you're told' ''-but we don 't know exactl y w ha t the authority reall y desires from uso 0 11 one level, of course, the auth ori ry just Wallts us to obey, bur no au thori ty wan ts st ri c! obedience. T he un imaginativ e child or studeot w ho follo ws every ru le to the len er inev i tably disappoints the parc nt o r teacher even more tha n th e rebe\. F ol lowing every rule to the le tter indica res that one has not seeo the desirc benea th the demando The subj ec t rece ives demands fram the O ther, but no words can teH the subj ec t w hat the Other desires. W hen we confront a demand, \Ve can ask the Other w har shelhe l't'uLiy wan ts fro!11 us, but th e O ther can o nly ans.ve r in words, w hich wi ll produce anothe r q uestion as to what d esir e th ose wo rd s are hiding. W hen, in BLue Ve/vet , JefErey Beau mont (Kyle MacLachlan) confron ts the demand of D etective W illiams (George Dickerson) rhar he put an end ro any iote rcst in the case ~ ur roundin g the derached ea r that he fo und , ir is not at all cl ea r whal De tec ti ve Wi lliams reall y desires . His o emand is unambiguolls, but one can also surmise thar he app reciates Je ffrey's inre rest in the intricacies of police inv estigarion. W hen Je ffr ey defies Dctecúve Will iams' explici t demand a nd pursues hi s ow o investigarion, he is fo ll owing-or beueves thar he is foll ow ing-rhe dcsi re mat lies be neath th is dem ando T he point is not that Detective W illiams ma kes a hypocritica l demand but rhat all dem ands coneeal sorne desire. T he depthlessness o f sig nifi crs as Joan Co pj ec insisrs, "sigl1ifien- are not transparellt"24- inevitahl y crc ates a sense of mysrery concerning tbe desire rh at m ight lie be neath. The subj ec t's desire arises out of the encounter w ith the indecipherable desire of the O ther, and in this sense, as Lacan often repeats, o ne's desire is the desire of the O th er. The p roblcm of this desire is tha t it is al ways elsewhere; we can neve r pin it do wl1 , just like \Ve can never pin down the moment tha r is "now." F or rhe su bj ccr w ithin langunge (for every subject), ir is an irn poss ible object. A s desi ring subjeets, we li ve in a worl d nI ,l nl lj.'llI li'l1 l. Ik~in: nffcrs us rwo antagon isrie poss ihili ties--hav ill g 11 11 ,, 11) 11 1 , 1\ " \I',I\(·S 111 be t/It!
14
THf
lMP(J S S 1 B ~E
DAV I D lYtoI Cl t
objeer, or not hav ing thc object- a.ll d ne ither of rhese possihiliries are sarisfying. Bur anragoni sm is nor sirnply a negati ve ca tegory. Ir cons ri tutes our sense of rcality: the extc rn nl wu rld appea rs rea l to us beca use of the absencc of th e des ire of the O the r, the ahsence of the obj ect that would offer the subjeet the ultim are en joymen t. But this a lso mean s rhat this social (ca lity Ieaves liS never full y satisfied as su hj ects. Fantasy providcs a way fo r sub jecl ro bea r rhe dissatisfaction of the socia l reali ty. In thi s sense, it supplements the funcrioning of id col ogy and kccps subjects relativel y conten t with an imagina ry sarisfae rion. Through fa ntasy, we do the impossible, acccssi ng the imposs ihle desi re of rhe Orher ancl glimpsing the enjoyrnent rhat it promises. The Other's oesire becomes a secret thar one mig ht uncove r, not a co nst itu tivdy impossible objec r rhar exists on ly in irs absence. We don't neces sarily fantasize ohtaining th is impossible objecr and enj oy ing rh e pos sess ion of ir. In stead, fa nra sy construcrs a na rrariv e th ar explains the loss of th e objecr and/or poi n ts roward its recovery. This narrati vc gives mean ing ro the IOS 5 of th e obj ec t ano transforms rhe impossihlc objecr into a possible one. F or instanee, rh e fantasy o f hu manity 's expul sion fram the G a rden of Ed en allows us to believe rh ar pa rad ise is a possibil ity, even lhough ir is los t. Such an id ea offers us a feel ing of hopc amid sr rhe general ized di ssatis faction tha r characrerizes our cxperi ence of the object as an im possibil ity. But fa nrasy is not just a private compensation for public dissatisfac tion. Jt silcntly info rms our everyday cxperience oEthe social reality it self and has the effect of taki ng some oE its d issatisfac rio n away. F anta sy's trans form ati on of the Other's uesi re allows the subjecr ro expe rience a realíry w here the ultima re cnjoyment is a possi bi lity residing just be nea rh rhe su rface of things. Fan tasy hleeds into our expe ri ence of the ex rernaJ wo rl d and gi ves us ou r sense of the fullness of rea l ity. Bur the normal subject, in psyc hoanal ytic terms, mainra in s an abso lute d ivide berween social real ity and fan tasy- what F reud call s the ex terna l and (he interna l-and kno\Vs how to distin guish them. For rh e no rm al subj ect, as Freud puts ir, "what is unreal , merely a prese nra rion and subjective, is only internaJ; w hat is real is also th ere outside." 25 rvorma L thus m ea ns no con fusion of external and inrern al, social reality an d fantasy. This idea of norm aliry is not juSt a F reu dian ooe: most psychologists- ao o even mosr of the popula LÍon at large- accepr the id ea that 11 0fl ll : d 'lIbjccts are t hose w ith lhe ahil iry tú disringu ish w hat
me
I NI'QDUCl IOt-l
15
really happens in the world from what th e)' fantasizc. Such normality, however, is impossible a prio ri : no one experiences reality without sorn e fantasma tic in vestm ent. Which is tu say that what we fantasize that w e will see info rms w hat we do see.:<6 Nonethelcss, according to the strict ps)'c hoanalyti c dcfmition, nor mality allows no such confusion, which is w h)' psych oa nal)'sis also recog ni zes that we ne ve r encountcr a normal subject. T he re is always some slippage bet\vee n normality on th e one hand and neurosis and psychosis on the other. U nlike the "nor ma !" suhject, neurotics and ps)'chotics don 't experi ence things so clearly. Th e psychotic confuses reality and fantas y and experiences them as equiva lcnt, whilc the ncurotic sceks in fantasy a substitute satisfaction fo r w hat she or he did not fin d in rcality. Hence, for the psychotic eve ry expe ri ence, even a fantasma tic one, seems rea l, ano for the neurotic every ex perience, even a rea l one, has at lcast a hint offantasy. There is, in ooth cases, a blurring of the lines. 27 This hlurring of the lines occurs in most films as wd!. Narrative fi lms typica lly revolve around th e in termixing and interaction of desire and fantas)'. Desire fuds the movement of narrati ve heca use it is the search for answe rs, a process of questioning, an opening ro possibility. Fantasy, in contrast, provid es an ans wer to this gues ti oning, a solution to the enigma of desire (albeit an imaginary one), a resolu tio n of unce r tainties. In ou r experience of most fi lms-fi lms that have an ev ident na rrati ve co herence-the rela tionship between desire and fantasy ap pea rs seamless: we ca n't readily delineate the p recise moment ar wh ich we pass from d es ire to fan tasy, nor do they a ppear as sepa rate rcalm s. Instead, fanta sy is constantly there, clear ing up desire's ambigu iries. We don't know exactly what will happen next, but we do feel secure in a reality replete w ith meaning-a reali ty in which evell ts fun damenta!!y m ake sen se. It is the task of fantas y lO provide us wirh this sense of in habiting a t ruly meaningful reali ty, a reality in w hi ch m ea ning itself is not up for grabs. 2B T he rel ation between desire and fantasy in film may becom e cleare r light of a film that offers littl e fanLasmatic resoluti on-C h ristopher in Nolan's Memento (2000). Th ough o ne quiekly adjusts to the (ge ne rall y) backwa rds movement of the film's na rration, one cannot construct an una mbig uous account of the evc:nts rha t the film s ll gg ~s r s have ha p pened. N o maner how m any times a Speel:ll
16
lH[ IMPO SS IOL E DAVID LYNCJI
could not discover the truth of rhe fil m's central eve nt: how th e \Vife of Leonard Shelby (Guy Pearcc) died, ano vvho was rcsponsi'hle for her dcath. This e\ie nt motivates rhe ~c ti o n in lhe film , a,n d the Ifw rrativc mov cs in 'lhe direction ofth is m ysl<:ry. But it remai os completcl y eni g mati c. The film prompts specta tor d esire for a sol utio n bUIt dnes not pro vide the fantasm atic scena rio that wo uld allow the solution to appear. The impossible obj ect remain s impossihle even a t th e end of m e film. Rather than providing a (fan tasmatic) solu tion to rhe crime, the endi ng shows us ool y L eonard's wi ll ful self-deception th ar puts hi m on rhe track of someone he doesn't thi nk is res ponsible. Memento sticks out beca use it proviJes a world of desire in a relatively plLre form, not b!ending it with fanta sy.19 In me ver)' commo n films that blur me line betwccn d esire and fan tasy, we neve r have an initíal experience of desire in its p urity prior to th e onset of bntas)', jusr as we don 'r initia lly expe rience a qllestion apa rt from sorne idea of a n answer, or d ou bt witholltsom e kind of certainty. F antasy, in other words, exists alongside desire from the beginning, structurin g its very path ; it isn't so methwg added 0 11 te desire after the fa ct. In this sense, fil ms tha t blu r the Une betwee n dcsire and fa nta sy bcst approxim ate ou r q uotidian experi ence oFthe world , in w hic h fa n tasy saves us from havi ng tú en dure the inherenrly trau matic desire of the Omer un prepared . Fantasy is the set of bli nders rhat obscures rhe trau matic (unanswerabl e) qucstíon that this desire asks of USo We can see th is clcarl y in the case of film noif. I~ the fi gu re of the fe mm e [ata le, desirc and fa ntasy ope rare sim ulta neously: on the one haod, shc is a traum atic fig ure fo r the spectator and the noir hero-we confront her traumatic d esire and a re thereby reduced to the position of me dcsiring subject-but on the other, she fi ts nea dy into our fantasy fra me precisely inso far as she is a fcmme fata le, a representative of t ransgr essive pleas urc. F or insta nce, "vhen Phyllis D ie trichson (Barbara Stanwyck) ma kcs her famous appea rance at the top of the sta irs wear ing onl y a ro wcl in Double Indemnity (Billy W ilder, 1944), Walter N cff (F red MacMu rra y) and the spectator see her th rough the lens of fa n tasy-as lhe licentious femme fatale. W hen we see hcr as femm e fatale, we have;: an initial fa ntasmatic frame.: th rough w hich to ma ke sense of her and her J e:;ire. I n other wo rds, ( r llm t he beginni ng we know thar she mt'a n¡; t rullble. A ll [he indi:;cc rnihilily
I t ll ROU U CllON
1/
the film-up tu her inability to shoot Walter nea r the film's end emerge against the back ground of this initial fantas matic [rame. Our relation ship to P hyIlis and her desire doesn't exist apart from the fan tasm atic imagc ofher as femme fa ta lc. In Double lndemnity- as in m ost films and as in Our everyday ex pe ri encc-the worlds of d es ire and fan tasy overbp and com m ingle . Lyn ch's filrns, howeve r, attempt lO hold these worlds separate)O This separation marks the begirm ing of Lynch 's imposs ibl e cinema. The idea of apu re desire, a d esire unmediated by [an tasy, is itsel [ the ulti ma te fantasy; desire does not exis t prior to fan tasy but emerges ou t of it. Fantasy does not simply provi dc an answe r for the question posed by desire; instead, desire poses the questi on for the an swe r that fa ntasy provides. Or, as Slavoj Zizek puts it, " It is only throug h fantasy that th e subject is constitutcd as desiring: th rough fantasy, we learn how to de sil'e."3' Hence; Lynch's depiction of the wú rld of dcsire prior ro fantas)' would be un thin k able outside the fantasma tic mcdium of film ilse lf. He uses filmic fa ntasy tu prcse nt desire in its imm ed iacy and the reby aJ!ows us to sce precisel y how desirc a nd faotas)' interrela tc. Lync h's film s present the distinct worlds of desi re and fa ntasy through radical di fferences in form w ith in each film . T he model fo r his films is The Wizard ofOz (Victor Fle ming, 1939), w hich creates a d ivi sion betwee n the social rea li ty of Ka nsas and the d rea m 'No rld of O~ . F lemin g uses blac k-and-w hite photograph y [O depi ct th e d issalisfac tion Dorothy (Jud y G arland) feels in Kansas a nd colo r tO ind ica re tbe enj oy rnent that the O z fa ntasy hrings. The fi rst pan (l f the fi lm foll ows the logic of d es ire insofa r as Dorothy seeks a satisfaction tha r seems constitutively d en ied to her. N o one pays attention to he r on the fa m ily ranch, and hcr on ly fri end, her dog To to, faces execLl tio n fo r his unru ly behav ior. In K an sas, sh e can lo ng for a n impossible obj ect tha t exis ts "somewhere over the rainhow," hut ir is cl ea r that she ca nnot arta in it. The turn ro the w o rld of Oz changes Dorothy's fortu ne com pletely. She beco mes the ce n ter of attention, the source of hope for others , and a hero for havin g k ill ed the W icked W itch of the East. Even the diffi cul ties th at she enco unters brin g an excitement an d enjoyment ch at weTe impossi ble in K ansas. The fan tasmatic land o f Oz sol v e~ Lhe dilemmas rhat the Ka nsas section of the fil m, th e world 01' d e~ire. pn :se nts as in soluble. Th e emergc ncc o f colo r photogr:lph y i~ ,11 1l0 <' l· 1lit el11t:rgeocc of new poss ibility.
18
nl~ I M POSS I Dl E
DA V I D I 'I'N' II
Though Lynch never uses this p rt:ci se way uf creating an opposition between social rea lity and faotasy, lhe id ea of the separation itself in forms each of his films Y In a film like Mulholla nd Dl'ive (2001), the dif ferences het ween th e drab social real ity in whi ch Dia ne (Naomi W atts) exists and the colorful fantasrna tÍc al tern ative w here she becomes Betty (also N aom i W atts) become almost as con spicuous as F lern ing 's split ting through th c use of d ifferent fi lm stoc k. Ly nch clai ms th ar T he Wiz ard ofOz "must've got insid e me w hen 1 first saw ir, like it did a million other people."33 He learm from it an aesthetic structure that allows him to separate twO filmic worlds and then li nk togethc r w hat has becn se p arated , u-\ough he ultimately uses this structure to far different ends tha n Flem ing, whose film uses the dream of O z to reconcile spectators to the monoton y of their Kansas. Taking The Wizard of Oz as bis point o[ departure, L ynch depicts worlds of desire by emphasiz ing the absence oE the object. These wo rlds are typica ll y spa rse an d bland, if nor bleak and desolate. The dark Light ing, stilted acting, mini m al décor, and an absence o f moveme nt within shots in the 6 rst pan of L ost Highway, for exarnple, contrib ute ro rhe m ise-en-scene th at is meant to spur spectato r desire. In Eraserhead, "ve see characters constit utively d epri ved of any enjoyment-that is, stuck in the d issatis facrion and lack rhat is desire-but even more, we as spec tators experi ence ou r own sen se of lac k when confronted w ith an image m at is largely d a rk and emp ty. T hese worlds of d esire bomba rd the spectator Wilh d isplays of absence. T he worlds of fan tasy in Lynch's films m ark a defi n itive contrasto Here, the excess anel heig htencd presence of th e fi lm ic im age th at we as sociare wi th cinem a as such bursts for th . Rather lhan endu ring the ab sence of lhe imposs ible object-cause of desire, the spectator fin ds ind ica tioos of th is ob ject eve rywhere, eithc r in specific characters like F rank Booth (Dennis Hopper) popu lating rhe underwo rl d in Rlue Velvet or in tbe brigh t and colorful setting we see w hen Laura Pa lmer (Sheryl Lee) fir st appea rs in Twlll PeakF Flre Wa1k with Me (1992). T h ro ugh their ex cessi veness, the fa n rasy worlds unleash enj oyment on borh the characters witbi n them and th e spectato r watching. As a rcsu lt, they a re as difficult lO exper ience as the worlds of desire, m ough for the opposite rcason. W hiJe watching the worlds of fan ta sy unfold io a Lynch fil m, one sees too rnuch of the objecl and enj oys too m ucho But th is al terna ting expe ri ence of absence and excessive prcsen ce is norm ality itsel f. By separating
I NnoD u C ll ON
19
the n.: alms of desire and fantas y, Lyncb's fiJms providc a n unsetu ing in sight into normality that everyda y Jife militates aga inst. One effect of this separ:ltion is to make clear the wa y in wh ich fan tasy acts as a compensation for what the soci al reali ty- the world in which we can only desire-doesn't pro vidc. Un li ke th e social real ity, fantasy provides the il!usion of deli vering the good s; it o ffers a fo rm of enjoyment for subjects lhat social reaJity cannot- like, for insta nce, [he enjoyment that comes from wa tching a filmic narrati ve un fold. This becomes clearl y visible in Lynch's filros , however, only beca use Lynch maintains a sepa ration between the world of social reali ry and that of fantasy, a separation as disconcerting as ir is reveaJin g . The separation between the world of des ire and the world offan tasy becomes increasingly pronounced as Lynch 's ca reer d evelops. lt is far more visible in Iater films such as L os! Highway or Mulholland D rive than earlier films likc E ra.'erhead and The Elep/lam Mall. Look ing at the films chronological!y, we can see Lynch constantly changing the way he crea tes opposing worlds, adding nuancc Js his career J cvclops, but rhe opposition itself remains consta nt. Each interp retarion tha t foll o\Vs wil! stress how cach fi lm extends a nd qualifics the imigh ts of lhe ea rl ie r films . W e w il! not see a straigh t line of p rogrcss but a path of aesmetic exploration and inc reasing comp lcxity. F ur th erm orc, in o rder to exam ine how Lynch ope rates differently w ith in the same meJ iu m (wh ich al ways provides similar possibi lities), 1 w iJ l res trict the focus in lrus book to his nine fc atu re fi lms , leav in g asid c hi s sho rt fi lms and his tele "ision work (inclu di ng Twin Peaks ). T he difficu llY oC the film s th em selves suffices without the fu rr ber complication s in troduced by Ule quesrions of medium specific ity and coll...boration. The difficulty o f Lynch's films d oes not lie so m uch in how subve r sive or radical they are, bu t in the fact that they o ffer a far m ore normal perspective than m ainstream Holl ywood film. They create an absolute division betwee n social rea lity and fan tasy, 'and thi s is a normal ity that \Ve arcn't used to seeing, eitbe r in Holl ywood or in ou r everyd ay J¡ves. As Freud points ou t, cven the most normal su b jcct we encountcr is ro some degree a neurotic; that i5 , she or he allows fa ntasy to shape hcr or his cx perience of reali ty,34 L ynch 's fil m s d isconccrt us precisely bccause ~ hey confront us with normal iry-and normalíty ~e('ms comrktely for eign. But in [be d iv ide betwecn de~ irc and C1I1 L"Y l.yllrh allm.v~ us to
20
THE IMPOSS I Blf DA V ID l YNC l 1
expcrience the cinema io a w.IY that challenges ilS ryp ical relationship with id eology.
The Impossible David Lynch
When cinema exists simply as an escape fo r spectarors-i.e., when films deploy fantasy wimollt full y in vesting the rn selv es in it- it can effec tively play the role of a fantasmatíc idcological supplement. That is, it can provide subjects with a m ode of enj oym cnt th at compensates for the dissatisfactions of th eir daiI y reality. If, for instance, subjects expcri ence dass antagonism in their li ves, [hey can enj oy the transcendence of this antagonism w hile watching the romance between the upper-class Rose (Kate Winslet) and the lowe r-class Jack (Leonardo DiCa prio) in Titanic (Jam es Cam eron , (997) and th ereby continue a contented exis tence within the wo rld of class antagonismo T he brief elimin ati on of class antagonism in the cinema provid es
IIII ROD U CT I O N
'1
in this way experi ences both the enjoym ent that fantasy brings and its psychic-and often material-costs. We might imagine a Lyn ch version of a television program like r.x treme Makeover, a rea lity show depi cting the com plete tran sformation of a person's appear:mce through the aid of plastic surgeons, beauticians, and other experts. Each episoue ends with the realization of a d ream: the once unattractive person m eets family and frienc1s in a changcd form, and ev eryone celebrates the impro vement, usually w ith tears anu hugs. One need not be a psycho,uulytic or Marxis t theorist to see how the real ization of the fantasy he re functions id eol ogically. not just by curing the participant of her dissatisfaction but by convincing spectators that a po tential cure for their o\\ln dissatisfaction exists \\Iith the propcr commod üies. The show docs noth ing ro arrest the beauty aesthetic that causes the suffering in the first place bllt works instead to increase spectator invest ment in ir. The limitation ofthis critigue is that it sees only the ideologi cal function of fantas)' where the hypothetical Lynch version of the show would reveal something further. The pleasure that spectalOrs derive fmm Extreme Makeover de pends on the point at "v hich it stops. The show depicts th e participant show ing off the new look, but it neve r shows LIS th e new life in its entirety. The Lynch version wOllld continue past the initial m eeüng an d show the new life that the makeove r created-perhaps follo wing rhe par tici pant for the next year. It would invest itself more fu lly in the fantasy than the actual Extreme Makeover rathe r than deconstrucring ir. We would see the participant discove r the surpassed old life return in th e ne\V one, w hich \Vould traumatize borh th e pa rticipant and the specta rol'. The underlying identity of th e excitin g alternative and the old te dious reali ty would become visible, dep ri vi ng us of tbe idea of another life where things would be differenr. T his is a f;:¡dical insight th at we cannot arrive at through sim ply denouncing fantasy; one must fully play it out. But Lynch's fi lms do Il ot depict fantasy in this unadulterated wa y in order lO display the dangers of fascinatÍon. The total experience of fan tasy that the Lynch film creates aims to trigger a spectator response of identification with the traumatic mom ent enacted with in the fantasy. Lynch offers the fantasmatic expe rie nce in ord er lo ra cilita lt! th is iden tification w ith wb at seem$ mnst di ~t;¡1l1 eroll t .mll li1rciglJ to us as spectators.
22
Tllf IMPOSStO LE DA VID IYN' 11
Of courSl:, not l:very c i.nem ~l li c spec lato r is lhe sa me, and film thcory has spent many ycars focused on the nuances of spectawr diffcrence. But such discussions ha ve as their foundation an empirical conception of the spectator: they im ply thar th e specrator is external to the film and thus don't focus on the way that fi lms internall y posit their ow n specta tors oE ve ry film demands a certain response. It is the ta sk of interpreta tion to locate düs d emand, and it i5 the task of the actual spectato r in the th ea ter to be adequatc to it. 35 This is especia lly im perative in the case of L ynch beca use ofhis approach to fa ntasy. I n Lynch 's films , the fan tasi es that the cinema enacts for us are not si m ply a nice diversion, but rather th ey house the truth of our being as spectators. Lynch's cinematic fantasies contai n the truth of our being insofar as they reveal wher e we direct our desire. Our everyday experience allows our own desire ro remain unconscious: we c! on 't see how our desire shapes what we see; we bclieve tha t we simply see w hal appea rs in the wo rld to be seen. By presenti ng us with an alternate fantasma tic 'vvorld vastly differcnt from our everyday experience, Lyllch creates a situat ion w here the di sto rtin g power of our desire becomes visibl e to us o O ur very in vestment in the fantasies tha t his fi lm s offer revca ls our uncon seious: we expe rience a fam iliaI ity in w har is com pletel y u nfamj[ia r..l ú In this way, Lynch's fil mrn aki ng tcsti fies ro ¡rs kinsh ip with Hege lia n pbilosoph y. H e is the Hegel of fílm m ake rs, one of rhe few d irectors to use ci nema to enact a process on the speclaror tha t Hegel c.an only descr ibe)7 Philosophical thi nki ng, in Hegel 's rn i.nd, involves "pure self recogn ition in absolute oche rn ess," a recognition that one'5 identi ty ex ists ou t5ide oneself in the ob ject that appears m ost other to oneself.38 This is the recogn iti on of whar Hegel ca lls speculati vc identi ty: in the aet of spee ulati ve identity, the subject grasps its connection with w hat it caunot encompass. Hegel beg ins tbe Phenomello1ogy of Spirlt wirh the complete op posi tíon of subject an d substance in order to be able to show the identity of what our thin ki ng fo rmul ares as most opposed. T he initial d iv ision is necessa ry, for H egel as for Lyn ch, in order ro make clear that rhe connec tion mo ves through absolute otherness rather than just eliminating it. Tbis leaves the subject no room for res pite, no difference into w hich it might escape. H egel's most powerfuJ example of specul ative id en rity de ri ves from the-discred i.ted, even during Hege! 's time-pseudosci ence of phrenolng-y. By link ing pe rson atity a lld illtdl igcn cc ro th e size and
!HIROO lt ff lrm
13
shape of thc skull, phrenology aJlows m to see the fundamental dcpcn
ters the very structurc of the filmi c world Y It is the sepa ration of the
dence of spirit nn its stupid materiality. For all its transccndcnce- and H egel thinks rhis transcendence is nonetheless real , w hich is why he im't a phrcnologist- s pirit cannot escape its inorga n ic origins.
worlds of desire and bntasv that rcnders this act visihle. In j:'rasahead, we see Henry attain the Radiator L ady, his fJnt ~lsy object; in F-fephant
Even our most profound speculative tho ug hts rema in dependent on our material being, though this specula tion believes thar it lea ves the material world far behind. As Hegel puts ir, "the actuality and exútellce
ofman is his skutl-bone."39 Ultimately, phrenology is n ot, for Hegel , the last word on spirit. But this is only beca use it does not ye t re present the most extreme form of speculati ve identi ty. The position of the a bsolute, which is wherc Hegelian philosophy a lways ends up, involves the sub ject seeing \-vhat it can't see-what Hegel calls "rhe negative of itself, or its limit."4 0 The subject recognizes that the li mir:Jtion on its u ndcr standing is in fact integral to its ver y ability to und e rst;:t nd . This is a recognirion mirroring that of the patient at the end of psychoanalysis who sees t hat "I am that": I id e ntify myself w ith the trallmatic object, and in doing so, I become who I alway s was. It is th e p rinc ipal virtue ofLynch's films to insist on speculati ve ide n tiry, thi s " self-recognition in absol ure otherncss." rn the experience of a Ly nch film, one can no longer slIstain a sense of di sta nce between o ne self as specta tor a nd the events on the screen beca use h is fi lm s reveal the und erlying ide ntity of every opposition. To return ro the example of The E lephant Man, we see the iden t ity of T rcves, rhe one w ho trcats Me rrick w ith kindness, a nd Bytes, rhe one "vho exploits him me rci lessly. As spectators we gladly iden tify ourselvcs w irh the he ro ism oC T reves a nd dctest the CrtIel ty of Bytes, but rhe ti 1rn forces us to sc:e how the ac tions of Treves mi rror those of Bytes, the reby implicating LIS in the ex ploi ta tion of Merrick . Tbere is no safe oppos it ion fur rhe specta tor in Ly nch 's cinema. Lyn ch's films d em a nd tha t the specta tor revalua te her/ his rdatio n ship to the cinema. The cinema i5 no longer an esca pe without an y co n nection to the outside worl d, nor is it a reality unto itsclf. ln stead, it is the re ve rse si de of tha t ou tside world-the fan tasmatic underside thar holds tbe truth of the btter. If we escape at all in Lynch\ cin em a, we es cape into the trauma thar re mains bidd en h UI nnI H.: lhdc~c; slructures the outside world . Despice me grea t va riety in rhcir su hjttl 111.1 11' 1', I.Yl1r h\ films al ways end the sa rne way-w ith ,11 1 illl ll"",d.I'I' 1 1lLll l' llId.lI l1 entallv 31
14
Tllr IM PO SS I DI. r OAVI IJ
I VNt:~1
Man, we see Jo hn Merrick become a nor mal person; in D une (1984), we see Paul create rain on a desert plane t; an d so on. E ach of rhese instances involves;¡ character fulfi Wng a fa ntasy a nd thereby breaking do w n the distance between the bn tasy world a nd the world of desire (with its constitutive dissatisfacti on). 1'0 return to Freud's terms, th ese a re cases where the internal successfully becomes th e exte rna!. These a re cases w hen the imposs ible becomcs possible. For Lacan, a link ex ists between impossibili ty and whar he caUs the real. Within cver)' sym bo lic order, the real occupies the pl ace of what cannot be tho ug ht or imagiJled -the position of the impossible. The rea l is not rea li ty but the failure of the sy mbolic order to explain every thing. W hen seen in this light, the imposs ible is not materially im possi ble but rather logically imposs ible as long as we remain within me cur re nt social structure . In Semzna l' XVfI , Laca n claims r.hat "the real is the impossibl e. N o t on accou nt of a sim ple stumblin g bloc k aga inst which we bang our hea ds, but because of the logical stumbling bl oc k o f what announces itself as impos5ible in the symboLic. Ir is from there th at me real a rises."4.l. W hat is impossible in me symbolic o rder is, in the rea l, perfecrl y ach ievabJe. It is in this sense of m e térm impossible tha t Lynch's fil m s allow us to experience ir acruall y tak ing place. They mus prov ide a fun da m ental ch allcnge to the rul ing sym bolic str ucture, for cing us to see poss ibi lities where we a re used to seeing impossibili ties. he even ts depicted within Ly nch 's films reflect the relationship with the spccta tor that rhese fil m s co nstructoJust as the cha racre rs in Ly nch 's films rnus t endure the realiza tion o f their fantas ies w ithout re spite, so must rhe specta tor of these fil ms. To watc h a David Ly nch film properl y is always to to uch th e screen , to find oneself be reft of the 5afe di stance thal the ve ry a rch itecture of rhe ci nema seems to prom ise. 43
i IlIP OO\Je. II ON
75
o NE
Sacrificing One's Head for an E raser
The Loss of the Life Subsfonce Ei-aserhead (1977) bega n as a 42-minute studem fi lm that Lync h p ro
poseel [Q th e American Film I nstitute in Los A ngeles while he was en rolled there. It g rew into a loo -mi nute feature d uring the five yca rs tha t it took Lynch to complete it. But not only the length oC lhe IiIm 's pro duction stands out: Ly nch mad e rn uch of the fi lm cla ndestinely in aban doned buildin gs on AFI property, w here he constructcd his ow n min iat ure studio. F unding w as neve r constant, anu shooting stopped ma n y times during the fi ve yea rs w hen the m oney dr ied u p_ It is che onl y Lynch film m ade in this ind epe nd ent way. Subsequen tl y, he wou ld ha ve m oney-sometirnes too m uch, somctimes less ch an he wou ld like, but always enough to continue shooti ng. In order to rea Lize the idea of Eraserhead, however. the absence of moncy was not a barri er to success; it was integral. Lynch's fi lm s ex plore the psyche to such an extenl th at rhey never seem to touch th e grou nd, to en gage [he economic a nd political realiti es that shape our everyJay li ves. [f there has bee n on e su';rained theme of criticism of L ynch's work, it ha s fo ll owcd thesl' lines: he crcales fi lrn ic worlds rhat sh ow liltle sign of the m:ttn i:d ,,"II rlo! ,,1 ,I:t~~ inc.:q ual iry, rnarg inali zed people, o r economit st 11 1~IJ.\k , 1\ \ tl ,i\ ~ltI\l. I.ynch i~ very n
much a Hollywood filll1maker, unconce rned w irh the socioeconomic realities of late capitalist life amI co mmitted to Jeliver ing fantasics to his audiences, even if rh ese fanta sies do themselves d ev iate from the Holl ywood norm. On él Jjrerallevel , rhere is some tru th to this criticismo Lynch's filmic explorations of th e psyche lend ro remain on that level and leave the link between the psychic and the social implicit. But in his first fea tu re, Fraserhead, he demonstrates explicid y the link between the intrapsychic struggles ofHenry Spen ce r (Jack N ance) and his situation as a capitalist subject. As in L ynch's later film s, the struc ture of E raserhead separates into two di sparate world s of des ire :lOd fantasy-t he social realiry and the escape from th at reali ty. Throughout m ost of the film, we see Henry exi sting in a desolate postindustrial land sca pe whe re he continuall y ex pe riences noth ing but di ssa tisfaction. These experiences contrast with h is brief moments of ecstasy, whi ch occur wh en he fantasi zes about a small wo m an (Laurel Near) who sing s and dances on a stage hidden in his radi ator. The brig h tness of th e scenes w ith the Radiator Lad y paral lels the enjoy me nt that th ey depict and con trasts with the dark ncss of the rest of rhe fi lm. In Eraserhead, L ynch employs rhis separa ti on in or der to reveal the rcl ationship between the psychic di ssatisfac ti on of the su bjece and the f u ncrioning of capitali st society, As the film makes clear, rhis fun ctioning de pends on a continual act of sacrifice on the part of the subjecr-the sacrifice of che subject's kernel of cnjoyment for the sa ke of producti viry. T he sam e sacrifice th at lead s to lhe chronic dissar isfac non of the subject fu els the socia l m echanis ms of production. W hen the su b ject refuse_~ (h is sacrifi ce, the mec hanis ms oC production brea k d own. At the end of the film , H enry arrives at the poinr w here he can em brace ratha than sacrifice his en joym ent. This becomes possible be cause he becomes aware of the p roduction process throug h fantasy. Ra ther tha n being solely a veil that hi des th e process of production and the su bj ect's role in rh is p rocess, fan tasy in Eraserhead works to ex pose how the subjcct's castration- th e loss thar one experiences w hen enteri ng into society- se rves che production process. By showing fan tasy func tio n in g in this way, the fiJm challenges trad iti onal ideas about Cantasy's r c la f io n~h ip to producoo n. Fo r earl y psychoanalytic film the a ry, the f~U1 1 a,m;l! ir dim ension (lf cine ma rcprese nrs its g reatest ideo logicaJ dan).;"1 lit ( ,,1\\ r. ltH.I~y a lways hides p rndllct ion. In fact, accorcl ing to tl ll\ \' 1I, 1V. 1~ 1I1t '-lc,y c' llIt'rgcs Jl rectly (H it (Jr the ,ttlcm pt to obscure
nA"rRl/f AO
the rol e that production and labor pla y in the construction of the social
tempt to explain un origin runs i!1 LO lhe p roblem that Kant di agnoses in
order. Christi a n Metz loca tes this problem in the einema's privileging of story (what happens on the screen) at the expem e of d iscourse (the aet of relating the eve nts on the screen). He notes, "the basic characteristic of
the dynamical antinomies of The Critique of Pure Reason, whcre he probes the questio n of w he m er the worl d itsdf h ad a begi nning o r no to W hat Kan t finds is tha[ no explanaüon of origin ca n eve r be definiti ve
[cinema tic] discourse, and the ve ry principie of its effectiveness as dis course, is prec isely that it oblitera tes all traces of the enunciation, and masquerad cs as sto ry."1 \Vhilc \vatchingth e typica l Hollywood film, we
beca use we can always seek the origin of this supposed origino The search for an origin leads to 3n infinite regress.3 Just as reason cannot loca te the origin of the world, idcology cannot locate rhe origin of the
invest ourselves in a series of images that take pai ns to ohscure the pro ductive apparatus ane! the labor that produ ces them . Building on th e
social order. But fantasy, beca use it uses na rrati ve ra the r than straight forw ard explan ati o n, can fiU in this gap a nd offe r us a w a)' o f unde r standing origino
analysis of Me tz and others, Daniel Dayan adds, "the film -disco urse presents itsclf as a product without a produce r, a discourse without an origino It speaks. \Vho speaks? Things speak for th e mselves and, of course, they tell th e truth. Classical cinema establishes itself as the ven
vid ual subject, the fantas)' of the primal scene (which is one of the funda mental fo rms tha t fa ntas)' tak es) tra nsfo rms the utterl y conüngent ract of the subject's birth-w hy this individual and not a norh er-into a narra
triloquist of ideology."2 The filmic fantasy, at least in its traditional man ifestatio n in H ollywood cinema, supplem ents a speeifically capita li st
tive that re nders thi s birth m ea ningful. In this fanta sy, pa re ntal coi tus becomes not just a n a rbitrary act but one full of a d efinite intention. Tt has
ideology. Thi s ideology d epends on hiding the la bor that produces eve ry com modi ty in order to facilitate the "free" exchange of commod ities. In Eraserhead, L ynch challenges this traditional conception of fan
as its specifi c des ig n creati ng m e indi vidual sub jcct who fanrasi ze s ch is eventoA simi la r p rocess occurs in fantasies constructed for an en lire so cial order, w hich ta ke the form of m yth. Virg il's creation of rh e m yth in
ta sy (and thus offilm) as an id eological supplem em. Fantasy (as pla yed out in He nry's dream) becomes the m eans through w hich the subject's sac rifice of en joyment for the sa ke of social productivi ty hecomes visi
w h ic h Aeneas foun ds thc Cil)' o f Rome strips the fo und ing (lf contin
ble. Tho ug h fantasy does obscure the mec ha nis l1l s of prod uction, at the sa m e time it makes visible the genesis of produc tivity itse lf - the mo ment of the subject's insertion illto th e social order. E very fantas y is in sorn e sense a fantasy of origins: fa masy em erges in order to pro vid e scenari o rh at explica tes th e origin of the subj ect and the o rigin of the social order, w hich is w hat ideology itsdf remai ns constitutively unable to ex plain. Tb e origin is me site of a gap with in ideol og ical explanations: ideol ogy can only explain the emergence of the prese nt socia l order retroac ti vdy, in terms of its result, wb ich m ea ns that ideology lacks the prope r terminolog)' that a genuine exp lan atíon would requíre. Because ideol ogy works to justify tbe ex is ting socíal order, it reuuces w hat is p rio r to this ord e r to the le ve! of the order itself. rn short, ideology 's ve ry ability explain eve rything lea ves it paradoxica ll y unahk l O l:xpl ai n o rigino The question of origin bccomes a hLlll k \1'111 Wllh ill idclllogy, a mo ment of conringcncy with in tlw idcolllgil". d \\'lId d , d Il!' re~ ~ i ry. Any a t to
28
'IH~
IM POSS ID LE DAV I D l YNCH
Fantasy does this on a social as weU as a subjective leve!. For th e indi
genc)' and a ll ows Romans to see themselves as lhe products of a specific destioy. In bom these cases, the o rigin ceases to be a disturbing point ancl becomes the fo unda tion ma t solid ifies a sense of iden tity. Fa n tasy's o rientaLÍon toward me origin a110w5 it to playa part in ob scuri ng a gap with in ideology. Bu t fantasy can also make this gap vis i bl e; it can show us w hat we othe rw ise would be un able to see. We re qu ire fa ntasy in o rd e r ro sce our initia l sacrifice of en joy m ent beca use this act of sac rifice has no cm pi rical existence. Tb a t is to sa y, as mem ber5 of society, we have always al ready sac rificed our enjoyment-our m embership in society is d efined by this sac rifice-maki ng it impossi ble to isol ate the mom ent of rhe sacrifice itself. Not o nl y d(les rhe sacri fice have no empirical existence, but me subject in no way has any e n joyment prior to its sac rifi ce. T hc social order demands tbat the subject give up w ha t it d oesn't have, and it is th is sacrifice of nothing-the pure
~1\',rllI/f'A[)
'2Q
rema in und etceted without the fantasmatie distortion. If we un de r stand fantasy in this way, we can revaluate attempts by avant-garde filmmakers to ex pose the p roductive proccss be hind their filrn s: w hiIe sueh efforts mal' in faet expose fl lmi c fantasy as a construct, they also hav c the effect of detracting from fa ntasy's power to ex pose the origins of the social ord er and the subject. In attempting to d econstruct the ideologi eal power üf filmic fantasy, one simultaneously und ermi nes its revolutiona ry power as wcll. Henry Spencer's comp lete immersi on in fantasy demonstrates the pO'vver of fantasy to expose the initial sacrifice of enjoym ent that m akes possible th e proccss of prouuction, even as it obscu res that process irse!f. That is to say, fantasy initially ubscures rhe proeess of prod uction by se dueing liS wit h a series of images, hut its attempt to na rrate an orig in has the subseguent effeet of exposing this proecss. Th e fi lm enaets the dynamic played out in Henry with th e spectatür on the leve! of formo Just as Henry becomes aware of his own sacrifice of enjoyment and its connection to the process of production through hi s fantas y, (he spccta tor becom es aware of the same thing throug h th e filmic fantasy that is Eraserhead itse lf.
Produdion and Sacrifice
The film begins w ith the d i rect link betwee n Henry's expe rienee of rhe loss of enjoyment and the onset of industrial produeti on. T he open ing is compl ete! y surreal: we see the u ppe r part of H enry's body floatin g in space while Iying on its sid e. Lyn eh superim poses [he image of Henry on that of a pla net. W hen Henry di!;appears from the fram e, lhe cam era moves closer to the planet. After a cu t to w hat seems to be the plan et's sur faee, rhe camera en ters a cab in where aman si ts by a w indow with three levers in front of him . T he film cuts back to the image of He nry whose express ion chaI1ges from Oll e of d ull anx iety to terror. Af ter a guick shot that returns to the man in the cabin as he sud d en ly jerks, we see Henry's mouth open and a sperm like substanee seems to emerge from it (though the creature is superim posed on the imáge of Henry) . Lynch euts back to the man in me cabin. w ho pu ll s one of me levers, wh ic h scems to have th e effcet-w hi r h we \C!" in lhe su bsequent shot-of sending I he spe rm likc su bsl:l w t" , 11 <11 I1 111 ); ,_,"1 IIf the frame. T he man in m e cabin pulls :1 ~"(Cl I1 " .1 11.1 11111.1 kVC 1. :llId \Ve <¡ce the JO
lHF I MPOSS I 9L E D AV I D l YNr: "
substance splashing mto a pool of water. Thc C
fRASER HfAO
JI
On th e one hand, the parent enjoys this li fe substance throug h the child and id entifies with th e aliveness that the child has (and that the parent her/him sdf lacks). On the other hand, the pa rent env ies the chiI J '- alive ness Of enjoymcnt, vicw ing it as an enj oyment properl y belonging to the parent herlhimself. 80th the dotíng parenr and the abusive p
The Malaise of the Desiring Subject Lynch sugges ts causali ry by locatin~ thl' lI nl, '¡ c1ill g 111 tlll' world of de sire just after th e openíng de pinioll 0 1 l kili ~ \ .1< Id I t t ql enJoyment in the film. It seems as rhis d iss.l li , I.I, .IIPI1 1I :~ ,,1I!. Ir, 11 11 1knry's sacrifice
ir
32
H IE IMP OSSI Bl.E DA V ID lYN¡; 11
of 'bis enjoyment to the machjnc of capitalíst production. This part of the film begins with a close-up of He nry looking backward over his shouklcr at what he is in the proccss of walki ng a way from. Though we see this shot of H e nry looking and a pu zzled or anxious look on his f:lce, we do not see a reve rse shot of w hat He nry sees (whieh we might typíca Jl y expect in thi s situatíon) . In chis world, the obj ect is missing. Lynch exp resses this absence dlfOUgh the film's form-or through the absence of the expected form, ,he reverse shot. T h e fi lm follows the m issing re verse shot with a mise-en-scene that further stresses absence rather m an presene e. Thi s is espec ially the case in the wa y that Lynch ligh ts the film-or rathe r in the way that he doesn 't light the film. Lynch's desire for a dark mise-en-sd:ne even in formed the way in w hich the negatives were processeJ. While having the film devdoped, Lynch insis ted on the darkest feasiblc loo k to the prints. The extreme Jarkness produces a sense of ahsence within al mos t eve ry shot of the film. T he Jistri butio n of the light emphasi zes the experience of absence. L ynch almost ne vcr lig hts a scene even ly; instead, he stresses the con trast between Iig ht and da rk ness . As Michel C hion notes, "Lynch da rcd to use li g ht w hich illuminates onl y in pools, so that parts of th e ser re ma ined in shad ows or in complete dar kness."7 Mue h of th e sense of em ptin ess rhat Ercuerhead creates stem s from this use of light. We can neve r look at él scent:' an d experi ence rhe overpresence lhar we are used to seeing in a film. The gaps in the ligh ting create a world tllat entices desire by high lighti ng w hat ca nnot be secn or know n.8 Even [he world movcs slowly, struc tured around a circuitous path to me object of des ire. T he slow nes5 becomes evident w hen He nry enters rhe e\evatú r in his apartment buildi ng for the fir st time. We see a long shot ofHenry as he enters t.oe dev ator a nd turns to press the button for h is Aoor, whil e Lynch susta ins the shot unril the deva tor doors close. 1n itsel f, this is not necessa rily unusua l. But wha t is distinctive is how much time passes between He nry's pushing the bu tton and the elevator doors closing. The typical fi lm com presses (h e ti me tbar eleva tor doors take to close; Lynch elo ngates it: tue doo rs take a full seventee n seconds to close, d uring w hich time the camera d oes not move. He nry himself doesn't movc ei ther, wh ich m eans tb at we as spectators mus t en dure scventeen seconcls ofhlll1 ill "' h icn noth ing at all harr ens. Thi ~ nnl h ing-this tem poral al)\( 1I1l' \\ Iti 11 11 1he lIarrati\lc SI ru" \1 n.: tiC t h~ fi Im- hcl ps to sign ify r.A~r. H 'AIl
3.1
that this is a world ofdesire. Desire revolves aroun d absence and depends on the continual failure ofits oh ject to become presento Jack Nance plays Henry as a character \;vho nev er moves quickly nor responds quickly to other characters. W hen "ve first see H enry, he is slowly wal king home with a sac k of groceries. And Lynch makes his pace seem e ven slower by shooting long takes ofthis wal k. When Henry interacts wi tb his neighbor (Judith Anna Roberts) just after arriv ing home, his slown ess becomes even more apparent. The neighbor tclls him that his girlfriend Mary (Charlotte Stewa rt) h as calIed and invited him to dinner, and Henry waits for a prolonged period of time befare simpl y thanking her for the message. This de la y creates a scnse of awk wardness, as if something is missing in their conversation, and it under lines the absence of any fan tasmatic structure in this part of the fi lm. Fantasy serves to filI in aw kward lacunas just like this one, ro sp<.:ed up om interactions (and the pace of our lives) so that we don't see the ab sences. Eut absences characterize our bare socia l realit)' without a fan tasmatic su pplement. Henry consta n tly seems ro be miss ing somcthing. He dcs ires some tbing that rcmains absent or at least concealed , but he does not ev en know enough about th is object to k now what he desires. Lync h himself describes Henry in te rms ofthe attitude of desiring subj ectivity: "Henry is ve ry sure that something is ha ppcning, but he doesn 't understa nd it at al 1. He w atches things very, very carefully, because he's tryiog to fig ure the l11 out. . .. E ve rything is new. It m ig ht not be frightening to h im , but it could be a key to something. Everything shou ld be looked at. There could be cl ues in it."9 In this first pa rt of the film, He.nry's desire does not have the coordin ates that migh t d irect it toward an object. lt is in this sensc that Henry is the pure subject of desire: his desire is unal loyed by fantas y to such an extent that it has no d irecti on at a.11 . H enry privileges no particulas object but view$ the w ho le world as a mystery that might disclose the object; for him, as Lynch himself notes, every thing "could be a key."
one who fits comfortably wllbin tlle world tbat he occupies. T h rough out the film, he wea rs an unfashi onabIc, nondescript suit, pants thal are too short, and a pocket protector fillc:d with m ulti plc pens ancl pencils. As Henry, Nance aJ ways mnves mecbanicall y in the film. W hi le he walks, he seems to pl
Both Hcnry's mode of dress and Jack N ance's way of pbying the role make clear his alienation fram the world in w hich he exists. As
E ojoy rn ent has been reIegated to the margins, outside human subjectivity-even the film 's aud io track hosts a consta nt din of factory noises d u ring all of the exterior anG ma ny of the interior shots. The
Paul W oods notes, "His relationship with the wo rld i ~ th;lt or a passive, bemused on looker-h e cannot be said ro lH1V(' .Iny tri le plan: in ir. His desires are ma ny, but fr ustratcd. " 'o I-kn ry i, .'1 IPlI lll "'wnlinl ~k:s iring subiect because he is a complete olltsidcl. l it d,,,··, lIu' dll"., li ke ~Clme -
sounds indi cate acti vity and vitaLty, buri t is the vitality of machines. As G reg H ainge notes, "T he noise pe rrm:atillg EraJerhead is an industrial drone which ~ llggests that the vicwer is inhahiting ,\ m ach inic world." " Visu
3~
Tli< I MPOSS IB LE DA V ID I YN C I1
~"~H tl rA (J
locateo elsewhere-in the ycars past, beforc the ste el ba rreis, pi pes, a nd
th e gra ndmothe r's ha nds. She stanos hehind the g ramlm oth e r, g rab s
chai n fe nces by w hich H enry walks became lhe traces of van ished in
he r hands hold ing the tongs, and to~ses th e sa lad by manipula tiog her han e! s. This brief seq ueoce hig hligh ts the in activity ofthe granomother. She exists he re as a lifeless pu ppet, a status confirmed by w ha t happen s
dustrial ac tivity. T he process of industrial ca pital ist productioll fun ctions through the sac rifice of laborers who work ra the r than en joy t h e mselves. W ithout this pe rpetu al sac rifice, product ion wou ld come to a stand still. In thi s se nse, ca pitalist industry feed s off the e nj oyment o f t hose who work fo r it. Bu r rhe sacrificed enj oym ent does not just disappear. The machin es of industry themselves manifes t the enjoymen l that h um a n workers 12 have give n u p: they run with a vitality that the human w ork e r lac k s. The capitalist production process also displays thi s e nj oy m ent throug h its by-product-su rplus value. According to Mar x, t he cap it~¡\i s t pays the wor ker faidy for the va lue of h e rlhi s labor, but wha r the capitalist appropriates without compensarion is the surplus value tha t the ver y productivity oflabor generates. Surplus val ue beco m es th e so urce of th e capital ist's profit, and it conspi cuously alludes to w hat the worke r has sacrificed.! 3 But the film neve r a ll ows us tu see direcrIy the industrial production rhat feeds off the sacrifice of enjoyment m ade by subjects such as H e nry. In th is world of desi re, the re are t races of enj oyment, bu t e nj oyment itself is always elsew here. The opposition between the a bsencc of cn joyment 3mo n g humao subjects aoe! the location of en joym e nt in produc tio n ano the natural world becomes clea r whcn Hen ry g oes to di noer at Ma ry's house. T he intera ction between He nry, M rs. X, a nd Mary just after Hen ry 's arrival d isplays the co nt rast. In the X livi ng roo m, we see Henry a nd Mary sit ting on a co uch w h il e Mrs . X sits on a nearby chai r. Long stretches of si lence and misun derstand ing punctua te thei r conve rsa tion . Mrs. X asks H enry wha t he does, and , after a long pa use, H e nry respo nds, 'T m on vac.1 tion." This respon se, w hich cl early misundersla nds h er question, forces M rs. X to ask, "W hat did you do? " The sti ltec.1 nature ofthc con versation betwce n H enry and Mrs. X re veals th e rol e that lack plays in this world. Neithe r of these char acters d isplays any ali ve ness in the sceoe, w hich is w hat makes m e conversa tion secm so difficult. The gra ndmothe r (Jea n Lange) ex hibits more cClOspicuously the life lessness at th e X home. Th roug hou t H cnry's c nlin' Vi~l l , she SilS in the same cha ir in th e kitchc n without sta ndin g up 111 ' ¡'yi l1 g a word . H c r onl y movcment occurs w hcn M rs. X uses her 1" ¡1I' l ' If(~ di!: ~;¡\ ad. Mr,. X lays the salao howl in rh e gr:\I1umCltlll' r\ 1. 1\ \ :1111\ pl. if l·S , .t. lIll( ll lg~ in
36
TH E I It\PO SSIBLE D AV ID LYNC H
subseq ue ntl y. After using the g ra nd m other to toss the salad, Mrs. X puts a ciga rette io th e grandmoth er's mo uth and lig hts it. Puffi ng on th e ciga rette is the on ly activity we see the g rand m other do, thoug h we never see her Iíft hc r hand ro remove the ciga rette from h e r m outh. ynch draws a ttentio n to her ulter immobiLity in order ro emp hasize the absence of a nim ation not on l)' in the X fa m ily but also in Henry's entire worlcl. Ali ve ness appears w herc we woulJ n 't expcct to see it. T hro ughout the con ve rsa tio n betwee n Hcnry, M rs. X, and Mary. we hea r in th e back g rou nd t he obtruJí og no ise of seve ral p uppies suckl ing their mother. Of course, puppies suckling their mother is not an uncommon occurrence, bl.lt w hat is uncomm on is its visibility a nd a udibi li ty. After we see Henry, Mary, and Mrs. X seated in the li ving room, Ly nch cuts to a shot of the Aoo r tha t graphicall y shows th e puppies a nd lheir mother. The sound o f rhe suck li ng stands ou t to s ueh an exrent thallhe enrire subsequent con versation seem s tooccu r in the backgrou nd o[ the suckl ing puppies. This juxtaposition stresses the eX lreme opposition betwce n the excess o f eo joyment in the animal world and the lack of it in th e hum a n wo rld. A simi la r opposition becomes a ppa re nt during the oinn er itself. Por d inne r, Mr. X (Allen Joseph) prepa res w ha t h e calls "m a n-mao e rh ickcn." Bu t whcn He nry tries ro cut the "chicken ," it begins to move spontaneousl y, ano a liqu id oozes ou t of ir. After we ~ee a shot of the ch icken 's movemen t, Ihe subseque nt shot de picts M rs . X beginning to co nvulsc al> her eyes rol! to the baek o f her h ead. Lynch ell ts ro a close-up of the m oving ehicken and then back to a m edi um shot of Mrs. X moan ing with her head tilted ba ck. The sequeoce of shots here in dica tes a ca usal rel atiollshi p: M rs. X 's cunvu lsions emerge in response to the man madc chick en 's di splay of ali ve ness-an aliveness tha t she hersel fl acks . Eraserhead de picts a world of abscnce in orde r ro sh ow wha t results from che inilial sac rifi cc of enj oym en t. In ln is worid, th e absen ce of the objcct-cause of des ire colon; eve ry scem:. Ht n ry exi sts he re as a d issatis ficd, desir ing subjecr. 13m becawic Iht: di :;s ¡¡r i s l ~lcr i on ex i~ts in the ve ry struclu n: tlr Ihe lil m ie wo rld itsd r- -ill 1li t· 1I11'il' - t' n 'iCc:nc, in th e ed it ing, in
I ilc 1 í1tl1(lO\lfin ll
(lf ti1/.·
~Ilt lt..
I1
111'\ 11 11 In
t' \
Hlt'l1l Ihal H cnry
IIA 5 HlltA l'
\1
cannot simply rouse himself: the dissati sfa ction has a constitutive status for Hcnry and, the film implies, for the subject as such. The dcsiring subject nece$sarily exists in a world of absence whe re the only satisfac tion is elsewhere.
The Cause of Fantasy
Despite what we might think, dissatisfaction and frustration alone do not lead directly to the d eveloprnent of a fantasmatic alternative ro the world of desire. TypicJ lly, we tend to see fantasizing soiel y as a response lO dissatisfaction within social reality. F reud gives a general description of this process in the Clark Lectures. He says, "The energetic and suc ccssful man is one who succeeds by his cfforts in turning his wi shful phantasies into reality. Wh ere this fails, as a result of the resistances of the external world and of the subj ect's own weakness, he begins lO turn away from reality and withdraws into his more satisfying world of phantasy, the content of "vhich is transformcd in to symplOms should he fall ill."14 Here, Frcud claims that fantasy providcs an internal com pen sation for what the subject fails to attain in rh e external world. In Emscrhead, Lynch tloes nol so much refute this idea as add a deg ree of nuance. For Lynch, fa ntasy re mains a response to dissatisfaction wiLb one's social reality, but it d oesn 't emerge when rhe subj ect's desired ob jcct is com pletely abscnt. I t emerges at the momen t when the sub ject encounters a rem inder in the O ther of the subject's ow n lack. Throughout the beg inning of the fil m , Henr)' endures the dissatis faction of his existence without recourse to fantasy. W hen Henry enters his apartment for the first tim e in the film (after srcpping in a puddle while walking home) , we see him lie on his bed and sta re at the radia lOr, but at this poillt he doesn't see the fantasm a tic scene that willlater appear. He think s he has lost Mary, and he sits alone in his apartment with nothing to do. ln the mid st of the complete absence of the object of desire , he does not turo to fantas)', though he dnes stare at the spot where his fantas)' wiII lilter tak e shape. Lynch suggests here that the subj ec t can endure the absen ce of enjoyment as long as no apparcnt barrier to this en joyment is visible. Ironi ca lI y, it is the barr ier lo the suhject's enjoyment rlLat causes rhe subject to cxpe ricnce it.sel r as lack ing, and the suhject tu rns to fantasy only al tlll' 1l lIJ1l 1l' Ol w heo she/he must confront this barricr.l 'i
38
fHf IMP O SS I9 LE P" VID lI NCtl
After the din ner scene at the X home, the fi lm cuts ro Mary taking care of the baby (a startling. re ptilian-like mutant) in H enry's apart ment. It is onl)' after we see Mary
_AH .'f'AO
\'1
woman beeomes visible. T h is seene is unlike :1Oy that have come be fare
head , k nocking it to the grou nd. T hc hcael ofth e bahy then rises out of
it: not only is the lighting much brighter than in the rest of the film, hut
H enr y's body ancl aSSlUnes the place ofhis head. The sourcc ofHenry's
the en tire eheery atmosphere of the seene stands in stark contrast to the samber tone of all the scenes up til! novv.
castratían is n ot, as we might expccl from the standa rd psyehoanalytic
In rhe fant: 1sy of tbe Radiator Lady, Henry expe riences what he
aCCOUnl, a d eman d by lhe social la w thar He nry give up his privíleged lo ve objee t. rns teéld,it is H en ry's own baby w hose head emerges out of
misses in the world of desire. Here, the object of desire becomes a pres
H en ry's to rso an d the rcby pops Henry's own head off. This striking im
ent ohject tllat one can see, if not actual1y touch. As Michel Chian notes,
age suggests Chat the misshapen ba by is itself the SOurce of Henry's cas
"The Lady in the Radia tar is related to perfect love and the dream of
tra tion. T he link bctwee n the ba by ane! ch e subject's lack de rives from
inccstuous fusiono When Henry comes on to the stage ofhis fantasy and
thc rep rod uetive p rocess. In the act of reproducti on, the subject attests to
touches her with his fingertips. a blinding fl as h and a burst of sound are used to convey the unbearable intensity of this mament ,"17 This kinu of
it" 5taLUs as lacking-a.s a sexed bcing. 1f the subject w ere com plete in it self, it woul d nave no n eed or even ab ili ty to reproduce itself. When sexed
intensity is entirel y lacking in the world of desire that the rcst of the
film depicts. It serves as a harhinger of the film 's conclusion, in which
rep rod uetio n occurs, the child emerges as a replacement for the parents and em bodi es rhe life substance lhat they ha ve sacrificed. 18 Thus, as
He nry's turn to fantasy becomes complete. But Henry's fantas)' at this
Hegel puts it, when parents g ive bi rt h ro a chi ld , "they generate their
point is nat confineu to the encounter with the Radiator Lady; it also
Ow n dealh." '9 I n Heruy's fan rasy sequ ence, he is able to witness this pro
revea ls the truth of his situation w ith lo the system of production.
cess ar wor k in a way that remain s vci leo in the ordinary experience of rcality. T haL is to say, subjects typicall y don't see directly the role that
Du ring rhe famasy seguence, H c nry imagines himsclf on the stage w irh the Rad iaro r Lad y, w ho holds her hanus ,in front ofher faee inv it comes complerely w hite vvith light-a lig ht so bright that it forces the
hei r ehil drc o p la y in ()b jecti fying o r sig nifying thei r eastration . But bec;wse fantasy hrings lhe subjeet ha ck ro lhe n onexis tent m oment oforigi nary loss, ir allo ws thc suhjee t to see the impossible.
speetators to look a way, especially after one h as become accusromed to looking at such a sparsely ligh ted film. Thi s wh iteness suggests the ulti
By a l/owing rhe subjcct this view oCthe impossible, rhe faDtasy lies. Ir narrates o r temporal izes ao ex per icnce of 1055 th at has no tempo ral
m ate enj oym ent embodied in the famasy objeet, b Ul just afte r the expe rience o f ir, the Rad iato r Lady di sappea rs.
existence. Loss constitutes tbe subiect as a subieet; to nar ra re tbis IOS5 is
ing h im toward her. But w hen Henry touches her hands, the screen be
Capitalist Produdio n a nd Human Re produdion
ro imagine a su bjeet prior [o 10sS---<Jr a su bject existing p rior to bccom ing a subjecL I n doing so, fantasy crea tes a sense of paranoia in the sub ieer: rarhe r rhan seein g its loss as cons túuti ve, the subject ide ntifies an age nt responsible for lhe loss-in Henry's case, the baby. C lea rly, Henry
In this fa ntasy sccne, Henry comes close to the en joyment of his fanta sy obj ect but fina lly cannot reach it. I-lis fai lure exposes hi s castration, which is the lack of fu ll e njüyme nt that every subjeet has ;¡s a result of being subj ected to the restr ictions of the social order. 1n psychoanaIytic term s, castratian is oot a lite ral event but a mctaphorical process that produces the desiring subjcct. It is the mythical sacrillce of life sub stance thar occurs at lh e bcginning o f Erascl'hcad. Just as we see castra tion unfo ld al th e beginni ng o f the film , Henry st:cs it occur du ring the hn rasy seque ncc thar bcgins w ith th e Ra dial" r 1.'lI ly. A fter the disappca rance of rh e Radi al'" 1•• 1' Iy, I 11, IIl II.I~y t"ol1linues as sorne k i nel of protuherance e m e rges I'r" l\ l I I( 111
•",
THl' ' MPO SS I!1l (
DA" IIJ I YN C II
>", 11e 111 y .11101 dl'placl:s h is
lived in a desolate wo rlc.l barren oE en joy men t be fore the arrival of the baby, b u t lhc fant3SY locales the theft of Henry's enjoyment in this fig ure. [n (lne sense, the Ca ntas y c.Ieceives H e nry concerning the real source ofhis di ssalisfaction, but in ano ther scnse il provides him with a unigue glance at wha t his everyd ay life obscures. Fantasy's lie acts as a vchicle th ro ug h w hi ch it can reveal a fllnd il me l1tal truth about suhjectivity. T he ins ig ht of Henr y's fa n rasy ~eq uence stems from the relationship that it e n visions between th e 10$5 tha! oceurs in sexed reprod u etioo (in sexuatj¡m as 'iUch) a nd thc IOS5 lha l occms (i.r I'he labo rer llnder capital ism. This is iI vo.:cd qucsrion for psycl lllan.dysi s. ;l nd it oftcn t()rici\1
d lll d l " 111
C;)lISl'S
his
di .. rni~l' thl' p"'YC hll:II1;¡ lylil' ;I, '<'I1\1n l .. 1' (';ISITatillfl .
I
~A·.!Hlll' ",U
41
This account, so the critiq ue goes, conceives a structural process at work when the process is actuall y historically rooted .20 That is to say, for its detractors the psyc hoanalytic narrative of castration fails to accommo date historical variegations- spec ificaUy, the form of loss that capital ism prod uces Ü'l the subj ect. But Lynch makes clea r the connection hetwcen the loss that accom panies sexed reproduction and the loss necessitated by capitalist pro duction when the film depicts the role that Henry's head plays in the productive process. After the dream sequence d epicts Henry's head falling to the g round , we see a puddle of blooo form around it, and cve ntually the head surreally d rops through this puddle onto the ground outside Henry's apartment building. Through this scemingly impossi ble sequence of even ts, the dream logic connects Henry's private psy chic drama to the functionin g of society as a whole. Lynch 's film em phasizes here the interconnection of these two realm s despite their seeming incongruity. After Henry's head bUs ro th e g round ou ts ide, a young boy runs and picks it up. He brings Henry 's head to a pencil factory where he tri es ro seH it. The factory buys the head from the boy after a tec hnician tests its usefulness by dri lli ng into it and cxtracting ma terial to insert into a ma chine that produces penci l erasers. After the machine prod uces an eraser with rhe material from Henry 's head, the technician tests the eraser ro confirm that it works properl y. We see Henry's ca stratíon di rectly providing th e material for th e producti on of a com modiry. 2\ But not just any commodity. Hen ry fantasi zes his head becom ing material for an cras cr becausc it allows him to im agine h imself pla ying a pan in the elimination of the materiali ty of the signifi er. Not on ly is Henry subjected to the signifier li ke a1l of us, but he also works as a printer: his labor involves the production of signifi ers. T he eraser un does this lahor and rcnd ers ít useless. Thc fanta sy thus provides a n ave nue through which H enry can nega te the source of his dissatisfaction. But the by -product of this p rocess is an insight into the violence of the prod uctive apparatus. Clearly, no one m.1kes erasers from human heads. But wha t Lynch's film suggests here is the ability of capitali~1 produ ction lO capiLa lize 00 the loss th at occurs in castration. 1·.Vl· 1 v ~"n : d urdl'r dLmands castra tion-th:Jt is, it d em an ds a sacri licl' "r I 1\ (11\ 111 1 111 by Ih ~ lI h j ects. \~ hat makes caIJitalislrJ disti ncl, an'II IIlill}! 1' , d. ,_ d" !li l W'lll~'nce of
~2
[Itr IM P OSS IBlE OAV lfl I Y~I~I '
Eraserhead, is what it dnes w ith th e sac ri fi ce. It uses the sJcrificed cn joy m ent ro feed its cve r-ex IJ
The Iess )lou ea t, dri nk and buy books; rhe Icss you go tu the thea ter the da nce hall , the public house; the less you think, love, theo rize, sing, pa int, fence, erc, the m ore yousa ve-the greater bcco mes your treasure whi ch neither m orhs nor dust wi ll devour-your capital . The less you are , the less you exp ress your own life, the grearer is your alienated !ife, the more you have, tbe grearer is your store of cs tranged being." Capitnlism requires an ev er-increasing g uanti ty of sacrifice-the ced ing of enj oyment for wh ar Ma rx calls "est ranged being"-since the acts of sacrificc feed rhe g rowt h thar capitalism must have . To our contem porary ea rs, Marx's idea th ar cap ital ism d ema nds th ar we catod rin k, and bu y less seems ahs u rd . Consum er capira lism not only tolerates excessive eating, drin k i ng , and buying, but it aCLU3Jly demands rhese activities, just as it cliscourages saving. BUl ro dismiss Ma rx's c1a im as anachronistic in our cu rrenl version ofcap itali sm would miss th e im portance o f the contrast he clraws. A capitali st economy d ema nds that we place an emphas is on havi ng rather than be ing, and it p rompts us to tbink of all ou r expe riences in ter ms of what we can llave. Even in con sumer capital ism , rhe log ic ofh av ing predomi nates. O ne wan ts literally to ha ve agood time, notro allow oneself to enj oy.23 T he mO re we wa nt to have, the m ore we support th e m achinery ofcapitalist production. But rhe su bject unde r ca pitalism is not simpl y a hopeless victim ofthis producti on p rocess. As Lynch indicares throug h this drea m sequence, a way out exi sts throug h fanrasy. F antasy has a rad ical potential beca use it can rendcr visible the subject's castra tion and the role that this castration plays in the fun ctio nillg of capital ist society. It stages H enry's castration fo r h im t hrough th e way tha t it presents the impossible ohject. As long as Henry exists as a su bject in the w orld of cl esi re, he experie nces a vague ..enseo flack, hu t he never gra$ps exacLl}' wha t ba rs his access to tbe priv i leged ohj ('( 1. 111 dli., wor ld. rhe objc.ct is si m pl), ;¡ hst: nt. But in lhe fantas m" ti~- tlt litlll , d u. ,¡I!lt·('f hcc()me~ prescn l ;In.! sccrni llg ly al·cl's~ihlc. T hc
NA .\ / RIII AD
A~
illusion of the ohject's accessibility allows Henry to see his castration as
From H enry's perspective, we see lhe roan g ropin g the ileighbor as she
the barrier preventing him from attaining it and to ~ee tbe role that his
is opening [he door ro hc.:r apartmt:nt. Then \Ve sec the neighbor look
castration plays in mechanical proJuction. Thc vision provided hy fan tasmatic expcricnce cnahles him to struggle against the perennial dissat
ing Jirectly at He nry with a puzzled expressio n. A reverse shot sho\Vs the head of the baby on H enr y's shoul dcrs in me place of his own head.
isfaction that had h ithe rto Jefined his ex·istence.
This sequcnce reveals the presence of enjoyment surrounding Hcnry, but it also depicts his own scnse of ca strarion (and the visihility of that castration). H enry quickly shuts the door aftcr this encounter a nd sta res
The Proximity of the Enjoying O ther
through the key hole as the door to th e neighbor's aparun ent shuts be
Aftcr Henry awakens from m e dream, the film indicates that he expe ri
hind the couple. After this encounte r w ith the enjoying other and with he foregrounding of his own cast ration , Henry lashes out violently
ences a chan ged reality. The first shot aftcr the el ream sequence shows him waking up in his bed in his apartment. What is instantly striking in this shot is the lack ofthe noise that we usually hear in the apartment the baby crying. This absence provides the first due that sometning has
•
aga ins r the baby. Cutting awa y the baby's bandages-an act signifying H e nry's re fusal to accept the restrictions that the social order places on one's
changed, which H enry's sl.lbsequent glance out th e window confirms.
enjoym ent-has t\Vo re!ated effEcts, anJ hoth inJicate ao attempt to
This look out the window is shocking in the first instance simply beca use
unleash enjoym ent. The most obvi ous effect is the death of the baby it
Henry can see outdoors. Though prior to the dream a brick wall was
self. H enry's fantasy has shown him the part mat the baby pla ys in his
flush against the window, e limi nating any possiblc view, now the wall no
castra tion, a nd he re H enry responds by deslroy ing the baby, tbereby
Jonger cxists. Looking through the wi ndow, H e nry sees someone vio lently assaulting another person oL ik e the very existence of the wi ndow,
ond efreet is metaph or ical: Hen ry a ll ows the insi des of th e baby ro burs t
this incidcnt tells us a great dcal aboul the transformation that H enry has
fo n h. T he act of sta bbing these insi d es with his scisso rs, though it kills
undergone in his drcam. Wh e rea s bdore the dream He n ry Jives in a worlJ of abscnce and 1i t
the baby, rcleases a huge q uantity of foarny substa ncc from w ithin th e ba by. T he fi lm dc picts lhis substa nce oozing o ut and coro plete ly cove r
tle enjoyment, the postdream wo rl d forces H enry to expe rience the en
ing its bod y. Here, \.Ve see unleas hi ng of bodil y enj oyment a fter che so cial restri ctions have be.en cut away. T h is u nleas hin g of enjoyment de
joymcnt that occurs around him. Rccau se the drca m faotasy aJl ows
re jecting that castration and ¡ts a ttendan t
IOS5
u f en joyme nt. T he scc
H enry to witness his o wn castra tion, he now fecl s his ow n failure to
stroys the baby, di srupts the rnec hanisms of prod uction, and even
enjoy- and the ubiquitous enj oy rnent of th e O ther- a ll the more ta n
crea tes a hole in the world. But it frees He nry from his castration and
gibly. The unav oidable dissatisfaction of the bricked -over w indo w gives way lO a n image of viole nt enjoyment and mus prese nts a turn
makes it possible for him to expe rie nce rh e di rect contact with his fan
from absence to presence. H cnry can now see w hat lay hidden in the
tas y obj ec! tha t was prev io usly impossible. By detaili ng Henry's violcnr des truction of the helpless baby, Lynch
empty spaces and ahsences o f the w orld of Jesire, a nd this changes me
begins to e1aborate the price lhat o ne pays for the realization of one's
way that he exists as a Jesiring subject. The visibili ty of cnj uyment becomes m ast apparent in H enry's rela
fa ntasy. The grotesque form of the baby doe~n't necessarily Icssen the horror of m e acto But nonetheless, the film depicts it as a triumph for
tionship ,vith his ne ighhor. When she appears in the first part of the
He nry. The condusion that this act brings about proví des its implicit
film, the neigh bor exud es a sense of m ystery. bUl Ht:nry neve r learns anything about her. 1n the d ream sequence. l-k llry r;lnw si zc.: ~ ab ou t the
justification.
neighhor having sex w it h hi m in h is hedo A h " 1 Ih~'
c njo)' ourscl ves. I t is ra the r that che re:lli za riol1 uf flntas y, w hile fu lly possibk. is : ¡j way~ viole nt. In rhe
status of the neigh bor ch a Jl gcs dramali, .dl, WI" 'I\ the hall, H enry opcns his d l)() r an" " '1;;-' tl l!' 111. 1L', l d ulI
44
T HE IMP O$SIUlt DI'IVI Il I Y N C ~I
Il i
\'
111.11 \.1 110ise in IIh ,llIlI lhl.: r mano
Ly nch's poi nt he re is not mat we m us r kili pu r children jf we are to
essari ly .1, 'lI(1y~ ~t1 I, H ha rr ic r ro cnjoyrnt' 111 I kl1 1:\I\ I.Isy posits. Fl'lLier / ... \ / ~! , r"o
·1',
head im plicates th e spectator directl y io H enry's act o f destructioo be
cause it in vests the spectator io the rea lization ofH enry's fantas y. A t this ca rl y point in hi s filmmaking car ec r, Lynch is at his most am bivalent ahout rem aioing true
to
onc's LlOtasy. Th ough he de picts
Afte r Henry dcst roys the baby, th e fi lm 's form changes in o rd er to convey lhe un leas h ing of en joyment. The Iights in H enry 's apart ment begin ro fl icke r. At an dectrical o utlet whe!"e a lamp is pluggeJ in , spa rks Ay ou t. A backgro und hu m grows louder and loude r. The n
H e nr y's reality as oppressi \"C a nd restri ct.iog, he emphasizes the de
Lynch inelu des a series of al te rnating shots of H enry's head and the ba
stru cti l"c ;'less of Henry 's embrace of the fantasm a ti c alterna tivc. In the
by's hea d in ra pid succession . T his scq uCllce co nelu ues with a c\ose-up
Iast instancc , l:'mserhead endorses H enry's act as a political gesture th at
uf the lig h t, w hich fi na ll y burns ou t into a total da rkncss th a t covcrs the
uol eashes the enj oy mcnt tha t he has sacrificed to capita list p roduction .
scrccn. Nex t, the film cuts ro a shot ofth e p la net (from the opcning se
T he fíl m co nceivcs of allegia nce to fantasy as a moJe of combating cap
que nce) brea k ing opeo . T hc dust fro m thi s expl osjo n sparkles behind
itali sm . But this end o rsement d oes not come w ithout a caveat.
Hen ry's head in a sho t tha t p laces Henry in fr o nt of a bl ack backg round . A fter this fa m ous imagc of He nr y, rh e cam e ra return s to the pl anet and mov es fo rward into thj: hole rhat has brokeo ope n. T he subseguent
Having It All
sh o t of the m an in rhe cahin indi ca tes th e effect that H enry's choice of E raserhead ends in th e way th at ev ery David Lynch film ends: the pro
refusa l of castration h as on th e m echa n ica l p roduction process. W e see
tagoni st realizes he rlhi s fantasy a nd achieves a m oment of complete
hi m st rivíng to hold the fina l leve r in place, but he cannot. The film
sati sfac tioo. This would seem to locate E raserhead , despite its hi za rre
fad es to white, and the Radiator Lady ap pea rs. She walks forwa rd and
stru cture, w irhi n the orbit of tradition a l Ho llywood film. In the typical
hugs Henry, as he a ttains the hithe r to inaccessibl e fantasy objec t.
Holl ywood fi lm , the suhj ect a lso real izes its fanta sy-as, fo r instance, at th e co nclusion of Pretty Womal1 (Garry Marshall, 1990) when the
With th is co ncludi ng em brace of the Radiato r Lad y, H e nry fin a lly escapes the JissaLisfaction lhat has haunred him througho ut the film .
w t:a lthy Ed wa rd (Richard Gere) arri ves in a lim ousine
He d iscovers the e n joymcot ma t der ives from emb racing one's private
tCJ
ask the pros
ti tute V ivian (Julia Robe rts) to m a rr y h im. lo term s of its narrati ve tn
fantasy. Through rhe act of opting for hi s famasy. Henry atta in s enj oy
jtc tory, the conclusion of E raserhead is evc ry bi t, if not m o re, fa ntas
me nt but shalters h is wod d ano destroys hi s h;1by. Of cour se, this wo rl d
ma tic: He nry m a nagcs to cm b race th e w holly faota sma tic- a nd
i~ bleak industri alized wastelaod , an d his baby is inh uma n. lo this
h ith erto ou t of reach-Rad iator Lad y, anJ we see their embrace bathed in ao ethereal w hi te Lig ht . The Jiffe re nce between these two cooclu
sen se, Henry 's aCl ar the end of me fi lm SCems perfecrl y justi6ed and
sions lies in their explora tio n of the full conseq u cnces th a t attcnd fan ta sm atic fu lfi ll ment. In the case of Pretty Womal1 (o r any ty pi ca l Holl ywood film ), the cul
even a ppropriate. However, even if the fi na l lurn to w C! rc! fan rasy is Jib erating , Ly nch neve r allows us ro forge t th at it necessita tes destr uctio n as wd!. One has a cho ice, the sarue choice tha t eve ry su bject has as it en tcrs the soc ial ord er: cither dissa tisfaction w ithin a consi stent soc ial re
minating fan tasy has th c powe r to sol ve an tagonisms-that is, sexual o r
ality or e n joyment witholltit. By retu rni ng to this choi ce a nd revc rsing
el ass antago nisms- that rhe na rra tive has p rcv iously explored . But the
hi s earl ier decision , Henry fr ees h imself fro m his own sacrifice, just as the film suggests tha t we ca n. 2~
film neve r ~ hows u s the cost of th is solution . The resolution has no eE fcct o n the struc ture of th e ~o c i a l order, o n the des ire of the cha racters in volved , or o n the stru cture o f rhe narra ti ve itself. Ir is precisely thi s la
T he em brace of fa llta sy d cstroys th e con sistency of Our social rcality beca use its consistency depcnd s on the sha red sacrifi ce of enjoyment. If
cuna tha t locares Pretty Wom an w ithin th e o rbit of the trad itio nal H ol
even one su b ject aban dons rhis sacrifice, such ao act c rca tes .a di stur
ly"vood 61m. [o thi s sen se, uJllike Pretty Wornan, Eraserhelld refuses to
bance in our social re~djty. T he political irnp licarions of e m bracing o ne 's fantasy stCI11 (mm it~ lin k l O the r e fusa 1 o( sac rifi cc. The subject who
employ fa ntasy a nd hold i l at a d ista nce sirnllltam: ' )lI ~ l y. h <.:vinces a fuI! commi tment to fa ntas)' in its de no uemc nt,
:1 11"
1!1i, 1"11 11 c"l)l\Jm itJu ent
exposes both fantas y's l iberati ng possihil ji il , ,1 1111 11\ ~ Iq! ! I r ll\IS.
4/,
IH( I MrOSS I 9 Ll
DAVI D InlC 11
rduses
In
,arri[,n '
pm,c.:~\
;11101
" ' II'~
\
.\1
rhc same time rc fll st:s rhe capi ta li sr prouuction
1"II' lIft. 1/1
,he world \I''' Iai nn l by ,!Ji, proccss. ,
~;,SI
RHC#.P
~
I
In Eraserhead, Lynch revea ls how the capitalist systern of production clpitali zcs on th e sacrifice of e nj oy ment that th e subject makes in the act of becoming a sexed being. This sacrificc produces dissatisfaction for the subject, bue it also produces the surplus enjoyment that rno ves the gears of capitalist producti o n. By accepting our dissa tisfaction, we sus tain this movcment. The film thus com pels us to s.ee our individual
TWO The Integration of the Impossible Obj ect
in The Etephant Man
complicity in the furtherancc of this prod uction process. Howeve r, the attempt to escape this state of dissatisfaction cannot
OCCUf
without vio
lence. As El'tlserhcad shows, we can get what we want-we can accom plish the impossible-and esca pe the chronic dissatisfaction of the capi talist world, but we can't do so without the destruction of the world itsclf. This is a barrier that few, <.:ven the most rad ical subjects, are able ro cross. Our inv es tment in the capitalist world derives from the stable grounding tha t it provides for our identity. In Semina l' XX, L aca n points out that a secure and constant "meaning is provided by the sense eac h of us has of being part of hi s world."25 O ur wo rle! is not just a place we inhabit; it is a fictional center to which we can always appea!. Spec ifi cally addressing the leftists in h is audie nce, L aca n te lls them, "you are more attached to it than you care ro know and would do \Vd l to sou nd
A Doubly Divided Film
the ue pths of your attachme nt. "21i Eraserhead offers subjects-Ieftists
Emserhead (1 977) est~lblish ed Lync h as a signifíca n t new voiee in in de pend ent cinema , but not man y people saw the fi lm . Ir screened prim ar
and all others-an opportunity to "sound the dcpths" of their attac h
ily a t m idn ight showi ngs in New Yo rk C ity, w hich a llo wed it to att ract
ment to th e dissatisfactions of the capita list worl d. By prese nting the
a cult follow ing. Rcspected di recto rs like John W ate rs and Stanley K u
destruction of this world ane! the m e.l n ing it provicl es as tb e price for
brick nociced and app recia red the film , bu t ir was Mel Broo ks anu bis
escaping its chains, Lynch cleman ds th at we con fr on t the ulti m ate bar rier to political acts---our in vestm e nt in the very str ucture tha r o ur acts
watching a p riva re screen ing of the fi lm , Brooks offered Lynch the
wou Id con test.
chance to d irect a project r.ba r he was p roducing for Paramount. This
love oC th e film t h al tra nsform ed Lynch's film m aki ng cart er. A fter
project beca me The Elephant Man (1980). the film that brought Lynch an ex ponential increasc in publ ic and critical recog n ition. Whe reas
Eragrhead toiled away as a m idn ig ht m o vie, Tlze E lcphant Man ea rned Academ y Award no minations for Best Picture, Best Director, Bes t Screenpla y, and Best A ctor (John Hurt). It changed Lynch's life.' T he turn from Fra.serhead to The Elephu17t Mar¡ is a tu rn from in depen dent and ex perimental filmm aking to Hollywood cinema. But Lynch's fu ndam en ta l conce rns as a fi lmmaker nonetheless remain con Tht· Rlcplw llf Ma11 de velops a nd radiGdi zes the distincti on tha t Ems(!/,/¡ md d r¡¡ W~ 1)('1 Wl'en the world of de,in.; ;lJlJ l he wn rl d o ( fan ta sy. st:lnL
HL'n:, tl l (~ \\lI d d 4~
IH~
IMPOSS I Rlr O... V IU tUI<
IIf
CIIII : I ~y loses th t; dn:a mlike llu nlily
Ih:1 1
ir h;lS in
11 4 1J
Eraserhead and becomes anoth er mode of rea lity itself. That is, The Ele phant Man de piets two ve rsions o f reality--one stru ctured through Je sire and the other through fantasy. In the same wa y as Eraserhead; the film uses this division in order to reveal what res ults when one fu\ly re a'¡¡zes one's fantasy. Through the tum away from desire, both the spec tatar and the ce ntral characters are able to realize th eir fanta sies, but this rea li za tion comes at a visible cost. Fantasy allows the subject to ac compJish the impossiblc but does so by destroying the subject itself. Whereas Eraserhead shows how the reali zation of the fantasy necessi tates an act of violent des truction, The Rlephant Man revea ls that the vi olence m ust also be d one to oneself. 1n this sense, L)'nch suggests that th e subject retains its subjective id enrity by sustaining distance from its fundamental fantasy. The Elephant Man erases thi s di stan ce w hen it turos from the Jepiction of a worl d of desire to immerse us fully in a wo rld of fantas)'. Mos t c ritics havc noticed th e radical division that exists in the rea li ty
film. Eut the oecision is essential ro the structu re of tbe film : Merrick's body initially fun ctions as a present a bsence in the film, produc.i ng a world of d esirc in which the obj ec t-cause of desire-Mcrrick's boJy itself- remains an absence that attracts and structures our desire. Laca n distinguishes between the actual object of desire and the ob jec t-ca use of d csire, which he calls rhe objet petit á. Unlike objects of de sire, which we access all the time, the objet petit a remai ns fundam en tally inaccess ible. It has no actual exi stencc but nonetheless se rves to trigge r the desire of the subj ect. It is the inAection th at tran sforms the everyday object into al1 object of desire, thereby e rotici zing the visual field. The su bject d oesn't sce the objet petit a, but its abscnce from the visual fidd is what mak es the subject desire to look. The re pulsiveness of Me rrick's actual hooy in no way disgualifies it from playing the role of the objet petit a hecause this object is constitutivel y absent anJ cannot become presento Fantas)' en visions access to this im possible obj ec t, allowing us to see
th at The Elephant Man prese nts. F o r instance, Ma rtha N ochimson notes that "the dop pelganger effect of mod el Victorian Jife and its shadow is, as in Blue Velvet, rend e reo with adear division betwee n the two, offe r ing an elementary Lynchia n d epiction of the caroi valesq ue relatiollship between social order and social disorder."2 Fo r Nochimson, the pri mary di visioll in the film exists between the kind ness shown for Joho Merrick (John H urt) during the d ay and the exploita tion of him at night. Merrick's d octo r Fred erick Trevcs (A nthony Hopk ins) is the re presentative figure of the fir st realm . and the nig ht po rter (M ichael Elphick) is the re presentat ive fig ure of the second . BU{ this d ivision he t\Vee n the daytime kindness of T reves and the nighttime ex ploitati oll of the night poner is not a divisio n berwee n a world of desire and its fan tasmatic underside. It represents rwo d iffere nt m odes of fantasmatic expe rien ce-one posi tive and one negative -and it serves to obscure the m ore radical split between the wo rld of desire and the world of fan
what otherwise remai ns invisi ble. Ir provides enjoyment fo r lhe subject precise!y beca use it changes the impossible obj ect in to a possible one. When Lynch exposcs Merr ic k 's body after th e fi rst thirty minutes of t he fil m, we e nte r a wo rld of fantasy in w hi ch a fan tasmat ic scena rio al lows LIS a m od e of access to the impossible obj ect. In rh is way, The E lephant M an opera tes a roun d th e same splil that an ima tes all of Lynch 's fil ms .
tasy that Lynch establish es in the film. Lynch creates the dis ti nction between experience structured through desire and experience struc tu red th roug h fantasy in the wa)' that he de pl oys the g rotesque body of John Merr ick . T hc mosr con t roversial d eci sion that Lynch m aJe as the young director
film cuts to a tracking shot of Treves as he walks through a bustling th rong of people. This shot stresses the fren eric activity of thi s crowd, and eventually the ca rnera even loses sigh r of Treves am idst this activ ity. After w e lose sight of T reves, Lynch cuts to a sig n that says "FREAKS" and to a d ose-u p oF a donr tbat sa ys "No E ntry" aboye it..> T hese two s h lll ~ l:~tablis h the idea of alll"llj o)'Illl" llt ("FREAKS") rha t is
~o
I Hf I", PQSS I BU
D" VI D lYN r : 1I
The Inoccessibility of the Horrible Object
A ftcr JO in itial m ontage sequence tha t attem pts ro con vey the trau m a tic elcphant a ttac k that allegedl y produced the di sfigurement of John Mer rick, The Elephant Man begins with an emphasis on the intense enjoy m e nt that accompa ni es the expe rience of seeing Me rrick. W e see Treves at a cami val frea k show on a quesl ro glimpse the E lephan t Man. This scene begins w ith a dose-up ofblasts of fire ar the carni val, anJ then the
1/1/
IH'P//"'N I M"N
:.1
off- limits (" N o E ntr)' ''). On hi s wa y to sees th e fr ea b, Treves passes through another ooor th at says "No Entry" and walks through labyrin thine narrow co rridors. W e even see a woman being leo in tears out of the exhibit, which suggests the trauma :lssociated with see ing Merrick . The sig ni fi ers that appear in thi s scene-"FREA KS'· ano "No Entry"-indicate in simi lar w ay s th e presence of en joym enr. Enjoy ment d eri ves from an encounter "vith a symbolic limit and thm requires the limit. 4 Th e freak show all ow s the subj ect a ttending it to transg ress the dictates of their own co nscience that tells them of its inhum anity and barbarity. On e enjoys a freak sh ow not in spite of one's moral re vul sion at the idea but because of ir. Th e spectacle allows th e sUbject to enjo)' violating its intern al superegoic comm and . The sig n that says "N o E ntry" performs a simila r function in rel ation to the external law. It provides [he subject w ith a sig nifie r ofla w that th e subj ect can enj oy transgressing. He re we see th e most fund amental function of the super ego and the la w: they act as vehicles fo r our enjoyment through the limits that they establis h..5 \Vhen Treves fin ally traverses all the barri ers to the Elephan t Man exhi hi t and is on the ve rge of seeing Mer rick for the first time, a police officia l cl oses the exh ibi r. T he offi cial tells Bytes (Freddie Jones), Me r ri ck 's "m anager," that the ve ry g rotesque ness of Me rrick preclud es his publi c oistJlay. The exchange between the officiaJ and Bytes helps to crea te a sense of the extre m e na tu re of Merrick 's defo rmity and thus al so the inc red iblc en joymen t that wou ld come from looking at him: OFP lCIAL: T he exh ibit deg rades everybody who sees it, as well as the poor crea tme himseLf. B YTE S; He is a fr ea k. How clsc wil l he ¡ive ? P OLl CE O FF ICIAL: F rea ks art: one th ing. We have no objection to frea ks. But this is e ntirely d ifferenr. T h is is m onstrous. Ir shaJl n ot be aUowed. P OLl CE
Th ro ug h th is d ialogue, th e fi lm esta bli shes the a bsolute prohibition 00 see ing Merr ic k a nd fur the r locates him as an ohj ect-cau se desire. A fter th e po(jce offi cial"s ha r ~1l1g11e against Bytes. Ihe poli ce lIslwr ,111 t he spec tators, incl udi ng T reves, (lul o f rh c blli ldi llg tl ' ;lI I l" " ~l" f\t~r ll ck. In a fin al shot, che film shows Rytes s:1 )' ing to th, 1111""111 ¡'tu t 11 k, "Time to m ovc agai n, rny t rc:m m:."
~~
r 111
I M~O~) r~1 1
OAV I" 1VNOI
Lync h begi ns the fi lm wirh ch is (ailed encounte r with the Elephant Man in order to 10c:1 te him beyo nd the field of representatio n. Th e in terdicti on of tlle object work s both w ith in the fi lm and in the film 's re laüon ro the specta tor. T he spectato r experie nces the impossibility and p rohibi tion of the objec t jllst as Treves and the oth cr cha r~lCters in the film do. By stressing th e impossibilil)' o f the object on both ¡evels, Lynch allvws Lhe specrator to expe rience m e desi re that structures the fi lmic world he presen[s. O n ch e leve! ofna rrati ve, che opening sequen ce is un necessary. Lyn ch might have begun the film wi th T reves's next attempt to see Merrick, wh ich is successful, but he chooses to begin with the initial failed en counter in o rder [o place the spectator in the position of the desiring subj cct. When one goes to see a fil m like TJze Elephal2t Man, on e is to a certún extent p repa red for t he g rotesq ue. H owe ver, by thwarting our encou nter with cll e g rotesq ue and by surrounding th e E le phan t Ma n with rhe au ra o fim possibi li ty, Lync h sugges ts that Me rrick's grotesque ness wi ll transcend whateve r expectati ons we lTligh t hav e.6 T he subsequent scenes in th e fi rst th i r ty mi nutes of the film all o\\! liS c10ser ~lCCt'SS to the fig ure of Mcrrick, but they lea ve him beyon d the field o[ rep resentarion. It is as ir m e prohi bi tion disappea rs-the poli ce no Iongcr deny T revt:S and the spectato r access to Merrick- but th e impossibiJ ity orthe object rema ins. On his next visir to see me Elephant Man, T reves succeeds in seei ng h im, bu t we as spectato rs do not, Ly nch sh oots this $cene in such a way th at it furt her est~ bl ishes Merrick 's sta tus as the oNet petit a or object-Cél l,l Se of desire inso fa r as it sustain s him as a constiturive absence in the visual ficld w hich eroticizes that fielo . We see Treveswalk through a dilapidated slu m in order to arri ve at sire where Bytes is now kecp ing Me rrick . Bytes initiall y refuses to allow Trcves to see Mc rrick. However, when T reves offers [ O pay for a look, Bytes opcns a door ro an image of tow l da rkness as a low ton e be gins ro sou nd in rhe bac kground . Bytes th en lea os Treves down a hall way to the room w here he has Mc rrick . In this room , Bytes gives hi s standa rd speech rccollnting the tragic history of the E le phant Man how h is cl isflgurement resu lts from 3n elephant attack on his mother cl uri ng hc r pregnancy-and rhen m e boy who works for him puJls bnck lhe cnn nin ro revea l che Eleph ant Ma ll . Sur im reaJ of sceing Mer riek h ill1 ~c' l r, \\'l' ~( ' l· :1 rcanion $hQt oCT ri. ve~, who looks sh ückcu , fol lowl'c1 I,)' n!t" .( II p~ nf Bytes :Inel rl1t" ho y, Firl1l lly, d ll' (i lll l shttws Mc r
me
' /u'
f U~ /l MH MAll
,' ,1
rick himsclfin the subsequent shot, though only the outline ofhis figure is vi~ib lc because of the extreme darkness of the shot. The scene contin ues with another reaetion shot ofTreves, and as the camera moves for ward to a c1ose-up ofhis face, he begins to cry. In the conclu di ng shot of this seene, Treves moves forward to exa mine Me rrick , but just when he begins to remove Me rrick's hat and mask, the film faJ es to black. At cvery point in this scene, Lynch buil ds the spectator's desire to see Me r rick and subsequcntly frustrates that desire, placing the figure of Mer rick at the center of the spect3tor's Jcsire. This world of desire continues eve n after Trevcs brings Me rrick to the hospital. In fact, Lynch goes to extreme cinematic Icngths to sustain Merrick as an im possible object during Treves's Iecture to his colleagues coneerning Merrick's case. During this lecture, Treves displays Merrick publicl y in order to illustrate the case while he kctures on it. Lynch be gins with a long shot of Treves Iccturing with Merriek positioned next to hi m behind a eurtain . During the leeture, we see a shot of assistants beginning to pull baek the eurt3in in ord er to expose Merriek's body. But just as they pul! the eurtain haek , Lyneh cuts 180 negrees to a shot looking at Merriek from bchind th.rough another eurtain. As a result, we see Me rriek in a silhouette shot rather tha n in the direet shot tbat we would ha ve had if Lyneh had kept the camera in fro m oCMcrrick. T he assistants use pointers to refer to the diffe rent defo rmities on Me rriek 's bod y wh ile Treves speaks about thcm, bllt even this is visible onl y in silhouette. Finall y, wnen Treves concl udes his lecture::, Lynch returns ro the frontal view of Merr iek just as the assistants c10se the curtai ns. The dramatic cJiting in th is scene serves ro aecentuate the impossibility of Merrick 's body, its inability to exist within th e fielJ of representation. The Elephant Mall begins with a se ries of faiJures, but these failures n:present the ve ry way in \>"hich desire itself sueceeds. The hrst half hour of The Elephant Mcm rev eals , as Lacan says in Seminar XI, that "what one looks at is what can not be seen."7 By denying the spectator acccss to the im possible object, Lynch here makes clear w hat all his films emphasize: the missing of [he object is at once the way in w h ieh desire sustains itself. Wh en one retreats from the absence of the object ane! fantasizes its presencé, one leaves the dom ain of desire. Neithe r Treves, Merrick, nOf th e fi lm itself can rem ain wirbin rhe world of de sire. Each follows a logi c ,hat Icnels inexor;dlly 1II ,1 1 . 111 1 "~II,. lI ic re~ol u tion in wh ich the impossihlc objcct clI\l:rw .. .1' •• 1 11I .. ~~"II II 'Y
:'4
TH[ IM POSSI OI ( PAVIO I YI~I 11
The Troumotic Turn to Fontosy
After the first thirty minutc$ of Tlle ELephant Mall openl y hides Mer rick's disfigured bocly from thc spectator's vision, the rest of the film displ ays this body just as openl y. If the first pa rt of the film emph:lsizcs Me rrick's status as the impossi ble objec t, the second part of the film manages to disco\'er a wa y of accessing mis object. The turo from the one to the othe r is the turo from a wo rl J of perpctu ally dissatisfied de sire to a worlel of fa ntasma tic enjoymen t. By chronicling thi s turn into a worl d of fanta sy, the film forees us to recognize the price that accom panies fantasm atic fulfiUment. Initially, the presence of the impossible object emerges as a Jistur ban ce in the function ing of the world of nesire. Its presence has the sta tus of a trauma beca use w hen one perceives it, one perceives something at precisely rhe poi nt where one expeets to pe rceive nothing-a pres 'nce at the site w here one has hitherto exper ienced an absence. Whi le vi ewing T/le Elepha11t Ma11, the spectator expe riences this mornent along with a young nurse in th e hosp ital w ho is bringing food to Mer rick. T he film stresses the na'lveté alle! fear of this woman as she ap proaches Merrick 's room. Lynch s ho()t~ thi s ap proach w ith a high-angle shot tha t m akcs her stature see m even smalle r than it actuall y is. As she wa lks. we begin to hear a deep pul si ng sound tha t portends danger. We see he r open lhe doo r to Merrick 's room, and th en me fi lm CULS to the fi rst d ireel image ofMerr ick 's b()dy: he is sitting up on his bed w ithout a shirt 011. The film quickl y Cllts back tú a shot of the nurse, w ho scream s as she drops the bow l of fooJ that she has been carrying. The camera quickJ y lracks forw~lrd to a c1 ose-up of th e ho rrined look on her face. The qu ick movem cn t of me camera registers the disturbance that the appca rance o fMerric k has caused in th e fi eld of representation. At the mome nt when Merrick 's body becomes a possible presence in the fi lm, rhe field of represen tation undergoes a radical change. W e lea ve a world of desire organi zed around the imposs ibi lity of d1e object-cause of de 5i re and en ter into a world of fantasy o rganized around accessing this object. Because Lynch establi shes Merrick's body as a fo rm o f [he objet petit a uu ring the fir~t hal fh o ur (lf the fIlm , il s ;¡ppear:lnce w ithin the: fra m e accom p lish(;~ t1w im poss iblc. The objet (J lünllioll~ IJn ly as an absence, I11tlti \,, 'lItlg d " \\1111(;1," 1\ d¡;sire th r" ll~h iI ~ ill,ICll·,sihi h IY. Onc ca nn nt I I¡~
f l fr llANI MAN
f . ',
ha ve a prcsent objet a, and yet this is what occurs whell Merrick's bocl)'
radical change in sta tus- from im p,lsc¡iblc ob ject m at resi sts rep rese n
initially becomes visible. T he moment of seeing the objet a directly would be akin to seeing on esel flooking; one would see hO\v one's own desire distorts the visual ficld from within the clistorted perspective (which is logically imposs ible). When Lynch reveals \\ le rrick's body, he
tation to objcct fuJl y re p resented- testi fies to po wer of fa ntasy to access the inaccessible. Just as rhe fil m turns to fantasy for rhe spectator, the terrain also shifts for the characrers wirhin the film.
forces the specta tor tu becom e aware of he r/himself as looking and as desiring. In our reaoion to this revelation, we ourselves become visible as spectators: the disturbance that M e rrick's body causes for our look renders that look-and the dcsire informing it-evident for the first time. At this point, \Ve can no longer be! iev e tha t we are neutral observ ers looking on a preexisting series of images; instead, we are desiring subjects looking on a visual fie!d created specifically for our desire. 8 Merrick's body does not disturb the visual field beca use it is gro tesque or horrifying. I t performs th is function insofar as Lynch places it in the structural posi tion of the objet petit a through his construction of the beginning of the fil m. The objet petit a 0 ,[ object-cause of desire has the status that it has by virtue of the place that it occupi es rather than any positive conten to Any ob}ect can pla y this role, especiall y in a film, provided that eme cons tructs the fi lm around its constitutive absence. Though the in itial appearan ce ofMerrick's body d isrupts the world of des ire crea ted in the opening of T he E lephant Ma n, the fi lm su bse quently integrates the presence of thi s di stur bil1g obj ect into íts ficl d of representation. 9 In th e rest of the film, Me rrick ceases to be an absence that haunts the frame ancl a ppea rs present wi th in the fr ame ü ke m e other characters. In fact, Merr ick'~ bocly appears so fr eque ntJ y in the film that it complctely loses its ability to distu rb the specta tor. W e do not, contrary ro what sorne inte rprete rs of the film contend, ex pe rience "the pleasure derivecl from seeing the pr ivate and forbidd en." ro T he film shows how even a figure as d istur bing as the E le pha nt Man can be smoothly integrated ioto sociery and into the fie!d of re presentation. This capacity for in tegration testi fies to the power of fan tasy and the role that it plays in the fu nc tioning of the social order. The faotasy thar rhe fi lm plays out after M erri ck's body a ppears ís one of the complete in tegratíon of lh e impossible object. 1t is as if our bEnd spot as specta tOr s, the poin t from w hic h we :Jr(: lunk ing, could be rendered visible
S6
1Hf 'MP OS~ I\l1 1- DAV I'I l 1YII' 11
1111" 11" \
l'U. tI 111'111. T his
me
Through the effons of Tre ves alJ d aclress M adge Ke ndal (A nne Bancroft), Mcrrick bccomes nor onl y a pa rt ()[ Victorian society but a highly regarded e!ement w,i thin trus sociery. He g aios th e accepta.nce by soci.ety that he ne ver hacl any h ope of discove ring w hile he lahored in the carnival sideshow. In this sense, the second part of the film provides a fantas)' scenari o for Me rrick and fo r the spectator who witnesses his ent rance into society. The film shows M crrick accomplishing rh e im poss ible wirh the aid of Treves and Ke ndal. After rescuing M erric k from Bytes a nd fin di ng him a room in the hospital, Treves takes the adclitional step of having Merrick into his home for tea. T h ere, Me rrick meets Anne (H annah G ordon), T rcves's wi fe, who rreats Merrick like an honored guest in her hom e, even th oug h rhe film makes clea r her díscomfort whc n she inirially sces Me r rick. Annc's trearm ent of Merrick moves him to tea rs. As h e takes he r hand , he begi ns to cry ane! says, 'Tm not used to beiog rr eareel so weU by a beautiful woma n." Me rrick 's tea rs he re in di ca re the ex tent to which he is living out a fa ntasy sce na rio. F rom the perspective in w híc h he 0 ists at the beginning of the film, utte rl y deg raded and deh um ani zed by Bytes a nd the ca rniva l goe rs, rhi s scen c with Anne is completely U I1 imaginable, w hich is w hy it l11 0ves him to the extent rhar it does. Bur [he fi lmic fa ntasy allows Merrick to accomplish the im possible, which is wha t m akes this such a moving scene. Though Treves begin s U1e integration of Me rrick into poEte society, it is Ma dge Kendal who corn pletes the p rocess. After learning ofMerrick's in telligence and h is acqua inra nce wi th culture, Treves publici zes Mer rick's case an d atrracts the atten tion of K c nda l, a fam ous actress on the L ond on stage. Ke ndal visits Nlerrick and reads a scene from Romeo and Julret w ith him. Aft e rwa rds, sh e tells him, "Mr. Merrick, you're not an el epha nt ma n at all-you're Romeo." Thi s kjnd of acceptaoce an d eveo adoration allows Merrick ro h ave a rasre ofthe normall ife that he has de sired bu t never bee n able ro a traio . 1r fa n tasmatically p rovides him with a se nse uf the ul timate en joyme nr thar he associa tes w ith norm ality. Though h e ncve r directIy st.1.les ir, Me rr ick 's J csírc fi)r n()r m ~di ty be co m es
;l PIM!'l'n t
in hi~ rcaction tu caeh nunn :l liz ing
<.: Vi.: Ilt:
",r "
he (' " inces
t~IIJ\Nr MAN
'"
g rea t joy w henevc r he expe riences the everyday ac tivi ties ofa normallife (d rinking tea , reading, going ro the thea ter, ancl so on). But it is Merrick's fin al act-lying clown to sleep lik e everyone clse, eve n thoug h he knows it w ill kilI him- that fully reveals the ex tent of his d es ire for normality. He wants it so much th at he is willing to die for it. N ea r the end of the film , K end al in vites Merrick to be her guest at the th eate r, and after th e performance, she appea rs o n the stage and dedicates the performance to Me rrick. At tbis point, the entire audi enee stanu s and applauds Merrick. This standing ovation at the theater und erlines the acce ptance of Merrick and the h igh point of his fa ntasy scenJrio. Even if Me rri ck is " realIy " living out this cvent in the film, he expe rie nces it-and we as spectalO rs experience it-as a fanta sy simply beca use it sol ves co mpletely the problem of desire with which the film began . We experi ence the successful integration of the impossible ob ject inlO ou r evcryd ay wo rld, and Merrick himself ex peri ences what was for him the impossihle normallife. Mer rick 's ex istence now see ms meaningful: he no longe r endures the senseless abjection of the ca roi val; he has a purpose. But this pu rpose is w holly fantasmatic beca use it invol ves m e attainm ent of th e impossibl e. Obviously the turo to fa ntasy for the spectator and fo r characte rs with in the fi lm is not the same . F ilms can deploy fa ntasies for the spec talO r while depicting cha rac ters w ithin th eir social rea lity and can lea ve spec tators desiring w ithout a fan tasm a tic escape w hile showi ng charac ters ensconced in a fanta sy wo rld . But in Th e Elephant Man Lyn ch aligns the spectator's expe rie nce w ith that of m e ch a racters: w hen we tu ro fr om an expe ri ence of a wo rld of desire to a worIu of faotasy, Mer rick and Treves do as wd!. This paralIel structure that Lynch often em ploys has the effect of breaking cl own the opposition between what oc curs in the act of sc reening the film and what occurs within the film itself. T he spcctato r fincl s her/ h imself in precisely the sa m e position rel ati ve to fantasy as the cha ra cters themselves. Though The Elephant Man follows the logic of fantasy, it d oes not break fro m the con ve ntiol1s of realism in the way that EraJerhead does. It does not signal to us as spectators in a cl ear fas hion that we ha ve moved on to the te rrain of fantasy. T his marks a furthe r re.fincm ent of Lynch 's id ea of the role rhat fan tasy plays for tll(" slI h j,'\ 1. W itll Tht" Ele phant MUfl, he begins lO sce how f~l!1tllsy i ~ "lit \i ll1l,ly .111 ,·,raJll: fro m
·· e
TI1 E
I M ~ OSSl n l ~
DAV I O lVNCl1
m e soc ial real ity, an alternative l() our everyday drudge ry, but the sup po rt of Our scnse of rcality. F an tasy becomes a mode of reaIity.
The Other Side of Fontosy
In one sense , The E/ephant Man is a ce lebration offa ntasy and wha t it is ablc ro p ro vide. W he n Mcr rick cries after A nne Treves shows him k ind ness, w hen Maclge Ke nda l compares Merrick to Romeo, and when the theater audicn ce gives Me rrick a stan ding ovation, we as spectato rs sha re in Me rrick's en jay ment. The fantasy sce na rio that informs these m om ents produces an enj oymen t that srem s from accom plishing the impossibl c. By in clud in g and emph asiz ing these mom ents, Lynch testi fi es to the po we r of faotasy and to its ability lO del ive r enjoyment. Rather than criticizing the tu ro to fanrasy as an escape from an unsatis fying rea li ty, T he Elephant Man embraces fantasy as a way of structur ing one's en joy men t.' , But lhe film uoes nor u neq u ivocall y celeb rate the turo ro fantasy. Lynch d o("~ not simply shnw the fanta sy of Me rrick finding acceptance in polite Victoria n society; he also shows the und erside of accc ptancc: Merrick 's immersi()n in to tll e ugly und crsid e o f Victor ian society, rep rese nted by the figure of me rtig h t po rte roNot on ly does Lynch se pa rate the fi lm into distinct worlds o f desire ano famasy, but he also splits the fantas m
, 111'
r I "·tiMJI
MAN
'9
a similar role in the filmic fanta~y. Lynch shows Kendal in her dressing room reading a letter about Ivlcrrick in the LOl1dol1 Times, and he cuts directly from this scene to one of drunken rnelers in a bar listening to the night poner reading the same letter. This ~triking juxtaposition makes clear that despite the class differences between Kendal and the night porter and despite their vastly different way~ oftrca ting Merrick, both characters adopt a similar re!ation ro him. They both transform Mcrrick into an object of curiosity that people are desperate to glimpsc. The differencc is that Kendalleads high socicty to see ~1errick and that the night poner leads the lower class. The visits ofKendal and her kind produce the positivc mode of Merrick's fantasy experience, wh ile the visits of the night porter and his e ntourage produce the ncga tive mode of that cxperiencc. By cinematically linking Kendal's treatment of Merrick with the night porter's, Lynch indicts the spectator as well as Kendal. N o specta tor watches The Flephant Man and identifies herlhi~ re! ationship to Mcr rick with that ofthe night poner. Thc film allows us to identify with the gentler position of figures like Ke ndal and T reves. That is, Lynch does not trcat the spectator as one of the exp loiters of Merrick but as one of those w ho succor him . Howcve r, beca use he hints at the speculative iden tity ofKe ndal and the nigh l porter, Ly nch does not leave ti'; in thi s posi tion. As we recognize Kendal's complicity in Merrick's exploitation, we simultaneously must rccogni zc our own as spectators. O ur very decis ion to go to a film li ke The Elephant Man , Llke the bare fact of Ke ndal's intc r est in Me rrick, attests to our in ves tm ent in the idea of Merri ck as an odd ity, even if all we fee! is compassion or frie ndship for him . Not only does Lynch cinematically stress the paraLlcl betwee n Ken dal and the night poner, he also shows us how rhe relationship with Kendal and with fashionabLe society renders the nightly abuse more horrific for 1\1errick. After Mc rrick reccives a dressin g case as a gift, we see a crosscutting sequence that juxtaposes Merrick trying out his new ite ms ane! the night poner preparing another group to visit him. Lynch shows a close- up ofMe rri ck sampl ing cl ifferen t colognes foll owed by a shot of the bar where the nig ht porter rounds up clients for his sadistic tour. Lynch then cut.'; back to a long shot of Merrick brushi ng his hair with his new hrush, after w hich he sho\Vs Lill ;\ ppro;¡ch ing g roup. We return agai n to 1-.1crr ick , w ho now prel\ n, h 111 il d.t ll'<;~ Kl-!1cLaI, but w hen he tUfIlS in thc I\lid ~ t or c!Oillg \11, 1'" Idlll ,~ \II S tri jI shut of the
(,O
f H( I MP OSS I O\ (
OAVII) IYi'H fI
night porte r, now present in Mcr ri ck's room. The subsec¡uent scene in volves the torture of Merrick: aman fo rce s a woma n to k,iss him in front of the group, the crowd pours alcohol down his throat, the porter forces him to look in the mirror, and after the to rture ends, Bytes, hid den among the crowd, stea ls Me rrick away fr om the hospital. This scene is perhaps the most trau matic in the film not just because it depicts the abuse done to Merrick but beca use it links this abuse, through crosscuttmg, to those who treat Merric k w ith kindness amI compassion. The cut from Merrick preparing to address Kendal to the image of the nigh t porter there m her stead revea ls the truth ofher position. H er com passion-and ours as spectators-becornes visible as part ofthe mistrea t ment ofMerrick, not an altcrnative to it. Lynch's crosscutüng es tablishes the speculative identity of compassion and cru el ry. Watching the film, we are constantly reminded of our link to this negative side offantasy. 12 Both compassion and crue! ry treat the objec t of their concero with condescension . T hese attitudes allow the subject to ensure its own ele vated sta tus as the one g iving com passion or administering cruelty. F urthcrm ore, compassion rec¡u ires a certain amount of cruel ry in o rder to existo W ithout the cruel ty comm itted by other~ there woul d be no need for my compassion . Even Merrick's disfigurem ent would req ui re no compass ion if \Ve did not I¡ ve in a cruel world that brutalizes those w ho ha ve a distorted appea rance. rn arder to sustain oneself as compas siona te, one must not act to change the cruel world th at crea tes oppor tunities where one can display compassion. '3 Wh ich is not to 5ay that co mpassion an d cruelr)' a re equivalent, that there is no difference be tween Kendal and the nig h t porter, but simp ly ro ins ist on the inextri cable link, the speculati ve iden tity, between them. Li ke Merrick 's fantasmatic integration into society, every fantasy scenario has both él pos itive and negati ve mode. In The Elephant Man more than in any or Lynch's oth er films, the link between the positive and tbe negative fantasy is appa ren t. Merrick's acceptance into polite Victorian society is de penden t on the nighttime visits of the nigbt por ter and his entourage. As the film suggests, one cannot simpl y o pt for a positive fantasy and avoid its dark unde rside . W ith out its underside, the pos itive fantasy woulJ cease to prov iJe rhe eoj oyment that it pro vid es because it would no longer pro vidt an y indicatí on of the trau matic natu re of the im possiblc ohjccr. Hflt h Merrick ane! lh e spectato r mll~l l;:n dllr l' 111 (' nq~arivc fantas y in I1rdn 111 ~1 "I;¡ il1 Ihl; PIJSi li\ e olle.
ill l , 1t(, Pli¡O¡NT MAN
'01
Fantásy afIers the subject cn joyment tb roug h a n a rra ti vc sccna rio that accesses that impossible obj ect. H oweve r, in addition to access ing this object, fantas y must sus tai n the idea of this obj ect as threatened in order to sus tain its desirability. This is w he re the n egativ e moJ e oCÜtn tasy comes into play. Whereas the positi ve moJ e of fan tasy allows the subject ro access the impossible object, the nega tive mod e of fa ntasy threatens that access an d works to convince the subj ect th at its rd a rio n
from Bytes through the aid of om e r si deshow performers who take pity on him-highlights even m o re the difficulty, ami henee the desirability, (lf normality for Merrick.
ship to the object rem ains in peril. In this way, lhe obj ect manages to hold onto its des irability e ven when it becomes acc essibl e for th e sub ject in the fantasy. The negative m ode of fa n ta sy-the horri fi c visits of the
T he depicti on of the t\Vo sides of fantasy in The Elephant Man does not transform the film into a cond emnation of fantasy. Inste:ld, this du ality mirrors the di videcl atti tud e that the film takes toward fant:lsy, On
night porter and his customers- allows the positi ve mod e offan tasy to continue to provide the su bject wi th enjoy ment. This allows us to answer the fundamental question raised by the night porter's visits to Me rrick's room. Ra ther th a n protest, Me rrick endures these visits as if they we re the price that he m ust pay for th e kindness he receives during the daytime. Gi ve n hi s det: p fri en dsh ip and the trust that exists between them , vvhy d oesn 't he protest to Treves?
th e one hand, Ltntasy p ro vides a n enjoyment that the subject otherwise lacks, but on the other hand, it does so onl)' by adding to the trauma that the subject has faced. As a result, one can render no eJsy verdict on the role that fantasy pbys for society ami for the subjeet. T/¡e Elep/¡ant M an seems to suggcst that fantasy is \Vorth the cost. But what the film absolu tel y insists on is mat when we opt fo r fa n tasy \Ve mu st pay this
Merrick accepts this trea tm em unq uesti oningly not bec.lUse he is a masochist or suffers from sorne k ind of fa lse consci ous ness but beca use di
¡~
but as an imperiled object, which it is fo r Me rrick , the status of normality ehanges dramatieally. And in fa ct. the nigbt porter's visits do eventually k ad to Merrick's retUril to th e carnjval. The inclusion of Bytcs's capture of Merrick <.md Merriek's mel odIama tie return to Treves-he escapes
he understa nds um:ol1Sci,ousl y that the ell joymen t of his d ay time accep tance depends on this nighttime exploit:ltion. The exploitation se rves as a const:mt reminder to M errick oC the threa t to his enj oyment. A t the same tim e that this dueat impe rils Merrick 's enjoymen t, it ~usta iJlS hi s ability to en joyo F an tasy can a llow Me rrick ro cn joy the impüssible ob ject, but it mu st p reserve the ob ject as e ndangered if ir is ro remalo e.n joyable. If the [h reat to me objecr disa ppeared en tirely, it wou ld lose its abili ty te prov ide enjoym enr. T h is is the role thar rhe night porte r's vis its pla y in Merrick's fant asy ti fe and in me fiLn , ami thi s is w hy these visits are just as crucia l for Me rri ck as the day tim e vi sits of Madge Ke n dal and the other respected mem bers of soci ety. The negat ivc sid e of fant asy is necessa ry for us as spectato rs as weU. The threat that the nigh t porter represents constantl y remincls us of rhe tenuousness oHvIerriek 's en tra nee into no rmal society. The n ightly re turn to the experience of the carni val that the n ig ht porte r imposes on Mcrrick indicates the possi bility of an actual retu rn to th at ho rrifie ex is tence. This threa t sLls t:lins :1Do rmal life tór Mnri,-k .l ":1 privi k gt.:d object of desire rathe r th an a\lnwing l10rm al ity It) ¡,CC! 11111 11l1l l HJanc and ord i nm y. On its
/, 7
TH [
OWI1,
IMI'OSS I UI "
thereis nrlt hing inhcrl' (11 1) .\. :-." Ihl,¡I"lIl1 IIl1rmaliry,
DAV I O
,n·"••
cost for the enj oym ent rh at it provides uS.
The Norma l and the Abnormal
L ynch shows the spectato r th e cost th at accom panics fantasy: fa ntasy obj ecr, but it d oes so by stripping the obj ect of the prov ides us w ith very impossibili ry that mak es ir an ob ject-cause d esire in th e first place,
me
L ike Eraserhead , The Elephant Man sho'vvs liS w hat results when one fully real izes one's fantasy. T he film realize.s a fa ntasy in three different ways: for the spectator, fo r T reves, and for Me rrick himself. The film g ives us preci sely what we desire as specta to rs, but it d oes so in order to show that we don 'l really desi re our desire. That is to sa y, the appear ance of tb e im possible obj ect w ithin the second part of the film cannot but d isappoint the spectator w ho eagerly longed for its presenee while wa tehing [h e first part. After Merrick's body beeomes plainly visible w ithin the film's mise-en-sce ne, ir loses all th e potential for enjoyment that it form e rly embodied , O ne watches Merrick in the second part of the film wi rhout :l ny se nse that o ne is expe riencing a moment that tran seends the timits of the orde r of tbe püssible. By re.1lizing our d esire ro see M críick's bocl y. Lynch forces LIS to con fro nr rhe 11: 111.11 il y (I r Ihe object, ro recogn i7.t rila r il is not the obj ect itself rh:lt prr ,d u\ 1' .. .] t·,ire lalt nur clcsirc th:1I C k- v ; lI l'~ :U l o nJ ina ry ob ject in to r'/1 II l pI ,,.,,,,r MAN
6J
an impossible one. As we watch the second part of the film, \Ve see lhe strangeness o f Me rrick's bod y beco me ordinary. This is what separa tes The Elephant Man (and Ly nch 's films in gen e ral) from the rest of Hol ly wood. An ordin a ry H ollywood fi lm wo uld a ttempt to preser ve Mer rick as an objet pctlt a e\ en as it allowed liS a qui ck fa ntasmatic glimpse of th is object. It would, in short, blend togeth er the expe rience of desire and fantasy in o nl e r to sustain the power of fa masy ove r us as subjeots. The typical Hollywood film is fan tasmati c to the extent that it holds back from a full imm e rsion in fantasy and thus p rese r ves the fantJ. sy's fundamenta l illusio n-that it can really provide access to the impossi ble object without destroying the object's impossible status. By refusing to turn wholl y into the real m of fantas y, film sustain s oUr belief that the ultimate enjoyme nt is possible. This is precisel y w ha t The Elephant Ma n rejects. Just as the film fo rces the spectator to realize he rfhis desire and face the cost of this rea li zati on, it does the same for bo th Treves and Merr ick within the film . Trevcs begins the film ck siring to m a ke a name for
!ij :~
spond . Lynch uses the facle-out a nd the a bsence of a respo nse ro punctu ate the ques tio ns a nd m a ke c1 ea r rha t Treves has g rasped so m ething essential abo ut hi s own d esire. He couldn 't ha ve se ripted m e narrativ e any better: he gai ns noto ri ely for d iscovcring Mer rick , d octors th rough out Englanu now kn ow ofhim, a no M e rri ck fecl s in de htcd to Treves fo r savin g h is life a nd giving him a no rma l ex istence. Bu t preciscl y becau se of the degree of success he cnjoys, Trev es bcgill S to suffer. The fantas matic rea li za ti on of hi s uesire m ak es evident the simila rit y hetwee n Bytes and hi m sel f. Ra ther tha n acting for the goo d of M e rrick or for the good of sc ie nce itself, Treves has acted as he has in ord er ro become a noted scientist, to increase his cultural capi ta l, just as Bytes has actee! in order to enrich him self ma teri a Uy. The compl ete success of Treves's fa ntasy lca ves him, as ir lea ves th e spectator, with no alternative bu t to confron t his own desire. The seem ing purity ofTrev es's d esire initiall y all ows us to experie nce ourselves as pure specta to rs. But T reves's recog nitio n abo ut his own desire indicts u s as well: we recogn ize th a t there is no p ure vicw ing position fro m whi ch to wa tc h Thc E lephanr Man. W ha teve r is the dr iving fo rce bc hind O UT decisio n to see the film , it is no t just a sim ple desi re to see. T he d es ire to
rumself as a doc to r by di sco ve ring M er ri ck a nd presenting his case to t he medical world . N o t onl y does Treves rea li ze this d esire, but he also succeeds in introd ucing Merrick into el ite Victo ri a n society. He he
see, Ly nch suggests, is co nnected to an unconscio us desi re that we do
comes a famou s doctor a t the same tim e m a t he rescues Me rrick fr om the depredatio ns of Byres ano changes Me rri ck's life u n imaginably.
not avow. O ne is not simply curi o us to see Merrick 's story; o ne wants ro see his Ji sfi g ureme nt. The E lephant Man fo rces th is latte r aspect of d e
Treves reali zes h is desire by playing o ut the perfect fantasy scen ario. But this sce na rio d oes Do t p rovid e T reves w ith the sati sfactioD lil ar he expects. It leaves him ucspo ndent heca use ir expo ses an aspect of his character that could remain hidden as lo ng as he w as onl y an ambitious
sire to becom e visible. Th is is w hat sepa ra tes the film s of DllV id Lyn ch
you ng doctor and not the discove rer of the Elep ha nt M a n. H e becolO es aware that ambitio n a nd the desire for renow n, not the dri ve for sci en
revela tio n is necessari ly traumatic. Th e successful fantas y [ea ves us no possibiliry fo r cl a im ing that this is no t w ha t we wa nt. In additi oD to reve¡,11ing the h idd en k ernel of o ur desire, the full im
tific knowledge, was the m otiva ting force behind hi s acrions. As the tra jec to ry ofTreves sh ows, fantasy lays ba re the hidd en k ernel of the desiring subj ect to the subj ect itsel f, and thi s is o ne rea son wh y we resist fully imm e rsin g ou rsel vcs in fantasy (in the wa y th ar Thc Elephant Man demands tha t we d o). A fter Mad ge K end al visits Merrick in the hospital and hig h society beg ins to foll ow he r lead , T reves has a moment of self-recognitio n. H e says ro Aune, h is wife , "l'rn beg in ning to beli eve t hat Mr. Bytes a nd 1are ve ry m uc h alik e . . . _W h:11 was il . dll ; , r ~ Why d id Ido it ? A m 1 a good m an , o r a m 1 a had lil a n ~ •. ,\ lit I 1"1\.\1;\ u tl l: r:. I h is fi n alline, the scene end s w ith;:¡ fade lo hla l k ..II I1 I " · l. d,'! 1111,111. " A ll ne re
/' 4
T H~
I MPOSS I BlE D A V I D LYNC tl
me
from oth e r fi lms. By d ivid ing experience of d esire and fa ntasy, Ly nch 's fi lms show w ha t results whcn we im rne rse o ursc\ves completely in fan tasy. T hi s irnme rsioD reveals tbe rea l of Our d es ire, and such a
m ersion into fantasy also demon stra tes th e cost tha t our fanta sies exact from usoT hroug h the final gcsture of Merrick himself, we see Me rrick sacrifice hi s life in o rd er ro complete hi s fam as)'. Throughout the film, Merrick h as sustained th e fant asy of becom ing a normal subj ect, and w hen the film en d s, he ach ieves mis fan tasy as he fi nally lies down to sleep in the way th at eve ryo ne else Joes. Ea rli e r in th e film, Me rrick tells T re ves, " Tw ish ( could slec p li kc no rmal pco ple." By Iying d o,vn to sleep, howcvc.: r, Mer rick k nowingly cul s off' hi s ;Ihili ty to breaw e a nd suffoca lc ', llill1w lf.
" "
t L1 ¡' I/ ANT MAN
Lynch shoots this final seyuence of the film in a way that emphasizes its fantasmatic y uali ty. W e see Merrick sign m e m odel cburch thar he has complcrcd building, and then we see a long shot of Merrick remo v ing the pillows from hi s bed. L ynch l110ves the cam era slow ly towa rd Merrick as he begins to lie down. F inally, Merrick closes his eyes and lies Rat. The camera pans from Merrick's fae c ro the pic tures on his des k and to his moJel church . As the camera moves up th rough and into a brilliant starry sky, an imagc of Merrick's mother appea rs an d then faJes to whi tc as the film ends. In this scen e, Me rrick achieves the perfect fantasmatic bliss: he becomes a normal subject, and he recon ciles w ith an image of his beloved mother. But this success also dcstroys him. In a scenario in w h ich the subject can achieve the im possible-Merrick can become norm al- the subject must disappear. As Lacan insists, "the 1 as such is precisel y exclud ed in the fantas y." '41t is rhe position ofrhe subjeet that rend ers the object im possible, and th us fantasy im;lgines the object without the presence of the subject. The subject's very jC1cntity is tied ro its status as lacking; if one eliminatcs this Iack, one simultaneousl y elimina tes (he subject. This is w hy every fantasy, not just that of John Merrick, is a fantasy of the subj ect's disappearance. Most of the tim e, however, we indulge in fan tasy w ithout recognizing w hat it entails. The R/ephant Man dema nd s thar we becorne cogni zant of the ramificati ons of fa ntasy as ir condudes with the fantasy-d riven death of Mcrri ck. h asks us ro see famasy fo r what it is and ro opt for it, if we d o, wh ile embracing m e sacr ifice that it d emands.' ) The conclusion ofthe film completés a radical reve rsa l for m e spec tator. T he fi nal image of Merric k sleeping on his back forces the specta tor to experi cnce the speculati ve iden ti lYof norm ali ty and abno rm ality, of w hat is normal and what is most opposed to the no rmal. Despite h is position as an extreme outsider, Me rrick vvants nothing other tha n to exist as the norm al subject does. According ro the logi c that the fi lm de velops, the normal subject is the Elephant Man . W e don't just observe, as Jam es Keller contends, that "the misshapen indi vidual is show n ro be ... fully human ." d, l ns tead , Merrick's alienation and abj ection h ig h ligh t that of the norm al su bjcct. ur very abili ty ro in Vest oursc! ves in hi~ 1: 1111 a ,y (,r 11 t H m:d 11 y nnd lo find his fin al gestu re 3 C()1ll pell i ng aet test ji It · ~ 1' 1 " ' 11 t ' \~' II HI j l~ II ;1led rda tion ro nor m al ity. If we sim r ly in ha¡'il t'd 1I1~ItI I " dil ,\ . tl 1II111 11 :tllly pr..
66
THr
IM POSS' O L ~
O"Y IO LVN ( 11
vid ee! a seamless identity for us, we wo uld nOl have the psychic spaee to take an interest in Lynch's presentation of Merrick's story. Ly n ch con cl udes the film as he does in ord er to force the spectator into a position o[ speculative identity with Merrick. Recogn ition of thi s speculative identity de prives the spectator of any sense of distance from him and his abnormality. One can no longer view h im compassionately beca use compassion always implies the idea of safe distance from the object. O ne feels compassion for Merrick or for starvin g children on the other side ofthe world only as long as they don't come too close. L yn ch 's film has the virtue of bringing Merrick too close and clem anding that w e see ourselves in what first appears as his im possible difference. In so doing, we accomplish the imposs iblc ourselves.'7 If one watches The Elephant Man and experiences one's speculativc identity with Me rrick, one accomplishes an eth ical act. It see ms silly, of eourse, to talk abo ur tbe bare act of watching a film as an ethical act, si nce watching a film inv ol ves disco nnecting from m e omer and expe riencing a prívate in te raction witb the screen. Su t \vatch ing Lynch's film in the way that it dern ands to be see n has [he effcct of fac ilitating the transformat íon of one's mode of relating to the othe r. T he film en cou rages us to see sa mcness o r identity beneath the other's di ffe rence. ,8 S u t what the film p rofre rs is not a uni ve rsa l humanism in which al! subj ects share an essentiall y hum an core that th ey never lose and on the basis of w hi ch they can idcn tiEy with each oth er. Th is is w hat occurs in m ost monster movies, which ai m ro affirm the com m on hu manity h id den bencath me monstrosity. Acco rding to the logic of T he Elephant Man , w hat we have in common is our monstrosi l)', a kernel of desire m at p revents LIS fr om eve r adopti ng a positiol1 of neu trali ty and from ever being simpl y human . Mc rrick's bod y is the ob jective correlative of our m onstrosi ty, and insofar as we see o ursel ves in its deformity, we be come the erhical subjects that the film asks li S to become.
r!l r
ti
t "'I AN r
MAN
6'
This beco mcs the standard wa y o f excusing its f,Jilure. W hen he makcs
D une, according to th e standard n a rrative of Lynch 's ca reer, Hollywood swallows Lynch, and the result is a H olly wood failllre and not an au thcntic Lynch film. When Erica Sheen, who laments that "a lmost noth
THREE Dune and the Pa th to Sal vation
ing of intcrest has becn w rincn about it," attempts to fill in this lacuna, she does so with an ·essay that stresses, in contrast to the other essays collecteJ in The Cinema of David Lynch, th e economic ba ckground of thefilm rather than the filmic text itself.2 Sbcen's essay focuses on "the production histo ry (lf Dune as a paradigm ofLynch 's often difficult and always critical relations with the film industry."3 For Sheen, the ve ry structure of the film is the site o f a power struggle between the type of film that H ollywood at the time d e mands and the innovation charac teri stic of Lynch 's style of fil rn making. Lynch him sel f takcs every op portllnity to support this vcrsion of the film's co nstruction. He daims that, in Dunc, "f n ever carried anything far enough for it to really be my own. "4 Despi te th is conte ntion and despite irs narrative dissimilarity w ith Lynch's other films , Dune rt: mains a Lynch film. f t is not just that
A Hollywood Narrative
Lync h place s his styJjstic o r fo rm al stamp o n the film (though he does)
After the succt:ss ofThe Elephant Man(1 98o), Lynch had nu m e rous op porrunitics to ad va nce his status as an up-an d -com ing director in Hol lywood, including an offc r from George L ucas to direct the third in stallment of the Sta/' Wars trilog y. Believ ing m at thi s fi lm would aJl ow him little creative freedom , Lynch opted inste~J d fo r anoth cr scien ce fic tio n project, this one o ffered by prod uce r D ino de Laurentiis. T h is project wa s based on th e novel D une by F rank H crhcrt, a nd it pro \ iJ ed Lynch a budget of $42 mi ll ion, m e largcst budget for a ny fil m up to th a t time (and more money-not ad justed fo r in Aatiün- than Lync b ob tained for a n y subsequen t film) . Because o f the püpul~l r i ty of He rbe rt 's novel (and its seq ucls), a buil t-in a udience existed fOI" the fi lm. W ith the success of Star vVa/'s and th e return of the Star Trek franchi se in the carly 1980s, an appetite fo r science fiction w as p resent
;:J. S
we/ l. Lyn ch even
signed on not just for Dune (1984) bu t also for [Wo sequels. Despite these positive signs, the film became Lynch 's greatest fai lme, making back just $15 million at the domestic box ofnce and bom bi ng a mong critics ancl am o ng m ost Lynch fans. I
Dune is not only the m ost llni vt:r~;¡ lI y J, '\ d"" !t( rl, lvid I~y , , ¡:h'l> I1L111$ but also rhe on e most assoc i:llcd \Vil h I\'I'". d I I,I1h \VI JI" I lillll/1J : Jking.
but that the film echoes the fundam en tal thematic preoccu pation of ynch's o ther fil ms. L ike bo th Eraserhead ([977) and The Elepham Man bcfo re it, DUlle explores w har occur" w hen we full y im m erse ourselves in the w orld o f f;m ta sy. Thoug h a c1ear lin k exists berw een Dune and Lynch's other films, it is nonetheless rme thar DulU' deviates less from d assical H ollywood na rrati ve structure tha n th e othc r fiLms . Ir this is the remIl of the ex i genci cs of a m a jor studio prod uction, rhese ex igenc ies he/p to create one ofLync h's m ost theoreticall y co rn plex films . In o rder to de/ve fully into th e wo rld of fa ntasy and ro reveal fantasy's cost, L ynch constructs a film with a narratíve trajectory that seem s com pletel y in keeping with D a vid Bord well's descriptio n of the dassi cal Hollywood plot or syuzhet. Bordwell notes, "Usuall y the elassical syuzhet prese nts a douhle causal strueture: Qne involving hete rosexual romance (boy/girl, husband/ wife), the other line in volving ano th er sphere-work, wa r, a mission or a q ues t, other pe rso nal rel ationships. E ach lin e will possess a goal, obsta eles, and a elim a x."5 Dune, likew ise, brings together these two causal struc tures--rom a nce and adventun:- a nd both conduJ e in a d enoue rn en l th al I idil y Wr:lpS u p the loose ends in c:J('h . T h u5. d es pi te lhc co m p!
II O IJI ''' IIH
'1t \:l rtl:rs ahour Ihe ( tlJllu \ illg
1l:11 ll r c;
(J I' rlw pl ot in
6a UN!
69
~
Lynch's versi on of DUlle , it is actually more indebted to the classical Hollywood structure than the plots of any of Lynch's other films. But Dune does not simply fall quietly into Hollywood's conventions. Rather, it imme rses itself in the classical H ollywood structure to such an exten t that it pushes this structure to a breaking point and exposes, as few films do, the radical possibilities implicit in the fantasma tic resolution that classical Hollywood structure promises. In spite of their reliance on the enjoyment that derives from fantasy, most classical Hollywood narratives provide only the hint of a fa ntas matic resolution without fully investing themselves in the logic of fan tasy. They employ fantJsy, and yet at the same time keep fantasy at arm's length, allowing the spectator to remain at a safe distance. The logic of fantasy is one that accom plishes the impossible: it overcomes or at least finds a way around the antagonisms-e~pecially the sexual antagonism-that haunt every social order. 6 The social order as such continues to exist through antagonism: its fa ilure ro constitute itsclf fully is at once what enables it ro endure. Irs existence depends on its ahil ity to produce desiring subjects becau se only clesiring subjects lacking subjects- act as prod ucti ve citi ze ns. A fi lm thJ t fu ll y io vests it self in the logic of fantas y would necessari ly depict a radical trao sfor mati on of the soci al ord e r itsel f, since th e soci al order is construc ted around the impossibility of what tanta sy envisions. But this is not w hat cl assical H ülly "vood narrati ve does. [nstead, the narrativ e offers J pa r ti al fantasmatic resolution wh ile embedd in g that resolution w ithin the continuecl existence of a world of desire ancl antagonismo At the eno ofJohn Ford's Stagecoach (1 939), fo r im tan ce, \-ve see [b e Ringo K.id (John Wayrre) successfull y defend a trou bled stagecoach from Apach e attacks anu w in the affections (lf the rescued prostitu te D alias (Claire Trevor}- precisely the "double causal structure" that Bordwell identifies and th at Lyn ch employs in Dunc. This conclusion heals both the sexual and social antagonism s and thereby promises an existence free from antagon ism-or at lea st an existence in w hi ch we can imagine oursclv es fre e from antagonismo The film suggests that a compl ete healing is possibl e, that the threats to soc ial stability are em pirical rather than on tologica\.7 Stagccoach deceiv es us concerning w ha t 1hl' Ril1)!" K it! lI1 ust undergo
to Jccom p lish this im possihle heal ing. I k o, lllI ply ,¡d"!, I ' , ti\¡, pnsition uf the hero in order to savc thc pco pk 0 0 d lt ;,I.ll!.' :fll ,lil¡ ,111 ,1 ckfcat the
70
lH ~
, M'OSS l n Lt I'JA V I f) I. YNCI I
Apaches. His underlying id enti ry aoo that oCsuciety itsclf remain con stant. Thc fantasma tic resolu tion req uires no radical transformation or radical destruction. Ir is in this sense that class ical Hollywood narra tive uses fantasy ro accomm Qdate the spectaror ro exi stin g social relations. These narratives impl y tha t we can attaia a Fan tasmatic en joyment while remaining with ,in th e security of the current social oroer. We el n achieve the impossiblc \vitbou[ disruptin g the world that cannot accommodate such an act. Dune enacts t he same healing of antago nism that play s itself out in Stagccoach anu num erous oth er classical Holl ywood films. But it does not go about it in th e sam e way. If Stagecoach and the classical H olly wood narrative reduce an ontological antagonism ro a merely empirical one, DUllé' ele vates an empirical antagoni sm to the status ofan ontologi cal one and heals it noneth eless. T hat is ro sayo P Jul ¡\.treides (Kylc MacLachlan) is not simply a hero w ho overcom es an oppressive adver sary and ge ts the wom a n; in ord er to save the F rem en and have Ch ani (Sean Young) as his lov er, he becomes the Kw isa tz Hade rach, \-vhat an other cha racter in the fi lm cal}; ''[he uni ve rse's super-being."8 H e is able tú en d opp ression as such , hea l th e sex ual anmgonism , and even m irac ulousl y defy the laws oCnature. At the end of Dune, Lynch depicts Pa ul as a subject who has ove rcome the p roblem of subjcctivity i tsel f. T houg h Dune em pl oys classical HoLl ywood n:nr31ive structure, w hat st;:¡ nd s ou t abou t Lynch 's fi lm is its refusa! to perrnit the spectator an y es cape from its full im pli ca ti orrs. Fan tasy prom ises the sub ject th e ul tim ate enj oyrnent, w hich Dune d epicts, bue by showing thi s impos sible act, the film exposes the traumati c natu re of the ultimate enjoy ment. It is en joymeDt com pletel y opposed to pleasure: achi ev ing it sh atters tbe stabili ty and securit y chat consti tu tes our eve ryday life. In fantasy, one enjoys beyond the signifier and the o rder of meaning, which is why ful ly accessing this erlj oyment forces one to recogni ze its iden tity w ith the ultimate ho rro r. Usually, our h3lf-hearted ap proach ro fantasy obscures this identity, and we can find a certain pleasure in fan tasy by indulging in it bu t not taki ng it ser iously. D unc places us all the way into fan msy's logic and dem ands th at we suffer the enjoyment it produces just as Pa ul does. Total immersio n in fantasy all ows (he fi lm to wnrk ou t fantas,y's po litical conseq ue nces. W hat Dw¡c a dd~ l o I-y ll eh\ ¡;xplor<1 tion of me logic nI Cllll . I'V in Tlw E lephant A1uI1 IS 11m '!l(" ' dll ((¡ell s . T he pla yi ng
/'"11 1
1I
out ofthe perfect fa ntasy scenario not only transfürm s me subject (Paul)
fantasy). As w e have seen, Ly nch cmphasizes the di vision through
but a lso leads ro a polí tical uphea vét! , which üccurs because famasy ín
changes in mise-e n-sd:ne, cditing, camera m ovem ent, and sound . The
herently undermines all external positions of a uthority in orde r ro ac cess the impossiblc object.
distinction in Dune is not so exrre m e, in d ica ring the increased power and extent of the fantas y in DUlIe. Ly nch establishes tbe two worlds of
The revolutionary denouement in D une follows from the com pletely
dcsire and fantasy as actual different worlds-the planets of Caladan
fant;lsmatic naturc ()fthe film's narrati ,'e structure. The trajectory tha t
and Arrakis, respectively. A rrakis is th e center of th e fantas)' amI the
Paul follow s in the film is the perfcet fan t as)' sccnario: it fits into a n O ed i
site of the ultimate cnjoyment, but th e film shows m is c njoyment pro
pal flarrative structure without requiríng P a ul to be rcsponsible for the
liferating elsewhc re. Only C a ladan, the home planet of che Atrcides
death of his fath er or requiring him to marry his moth er. That is, the narra tive allows Paul to have the triumphs m a t Oedipu s d oes without
farn il y, offe rs a degree of res pite.
sharing the latter's guilt . Like O edipus, Paul becomes th e libcrator of a
other sets in Dune. 0 0 e very other plane t, we see extremes in décor,
subjccted peoplc with his mother at his side, and a fte r this liberati on he
costume, character, and atmospher e. Bu l C al ada n seems lik e a normal
avcnges the death ofh is famer. By becoming the liberator ofthe F re men,
planet where people act li ke we expect them
Both r.h e inte riors and exte rio rs on Caladan look diffe rent than the
to
act. There a re no char
he assumcs the d estin)" that his father has predictcd for him. Though,
acters here like the diseased Baron Ha rk o nnen (Kenneth McM illan)
unl ike Oedi pus, Paul d oe s not pla y any part in the de lth of his faLh er, this
flying arou nd the room or the com pletely blue-eyed Frernen clressed in
d eath is nonetheless necessary for his ascension as th e sa vior of Arrak is .
suits that recuperate a l! their bodily w aste, nor are there creatures like
I t thrusts P a ul anu his m other into the society of the Freme n, who a!en
the malformed G uild na vigators or the worms of A rrakis _ T he mise
Paul to his des tiny. In the process of assull1i ng his des Lin y, he finds a
en-sccne reveais Caladan as a sta ble place that is la rgel y bereft of oven
spouse among lh e subj ec ted people, and the romance and ad venture
fa ntasma tic in tr u sions.
plots un ire in the manner of m e c1assical Hollyw ood narra tive.
L ynch establ ishes Ca ladan as a wo rl d of des ire pri m a ril y th ro ugh
In te rm s of this n a rrati vc structu re, Dune is too m uch o f a cl:J ssica l
the place it occupies in the nar rative. Ir mark s the starting point of
H oll ywood fi lm, foll o wing the model too perfectly a nd the reby ex pos
Pau l's quest. E very scene 00 Ca lad an conveys an attituele of expecration
ing the hidd en radical ity of the m odel itsdf. This is wh at accounts for
for the future and helps to generate a d esire in the specta tor to see it. We
much of the nega tive critica l reacti cm to it. In the aet of gi ving us w hat
see Paul t raining w il.h the mentors that his father, D u ke Le to A ueides
too much, for cing us to see the
(Jü rge n P rochnow), has assigned to a id in his development. He spars in
consequenees of nu r fantasy, to sce w har hap pens w hen we WQ uld es
a kni fe figh t w ith G umey Halleck (Patrick Stewar t)i he de monstrates a
cape the constrain ts of antagonism o Lync h's film fo rces us ro co nfro nt
new wcapon (the weirding modu le) that wi l! help in the upcoming
the fantasy w ithout the distance tb at this type of fi lm making ryp ically offe rs.
war; and he submits
we wan r as specta to rs, Ly nch gi ves
liS
tO
a test of pain th reshold given by the Bene G esse
rit Reve rend Mother Ga ius Helen Mohiam (Sian P hillips). E ach sccne is important not in itself but for w hat it suggests abou r w here the film
No Sofe Place to Desire N ot only cl oes D utle represcnt a break fro l11 Eraserhead a ncl Elcphant Man through its narrati ve :;tructure, hut il also depa rts from Lynch 's
is headed. The depiction of Paul's nighttime confcre nce with his father punc tuates the attitude of the film's C aladan sequence. As Paul and Leto look
OUt
ove r the beautiful sea with wa vcs cr,lshing into rocks creating
earlier wo rk through the w ay that it deploys desin.: ;l nd hll t . l ~y. In bOlh Eraserhcad ami E lephat21 Man , rhere are two dl \' 111< I wc "leI, -
a mist around them, Le to defe ncls bi s d ecision to !cave fo r A rrakis, a
other cha rac terizcd by Ilcig htUlt:J Pl c-"""'-'':.lllId í'lIhl\'lrll~ lll (:1 wo rl J of
sOl11el hll\f~ ~Ic ( p ~ Imlcle liS
7'
TrI!
IM" O~r. l n l ( O AV II~ LYN Ctl
desert planet w he fe it never rai ns. Ly nch shoots the scene in a w ay that e mphasi z~" P.lIJI \ (uturc. In d osc-up. Lt, to s ay~ , "Wirhout change,
a nd scl dolll :Iw:lkl'm." Ly ll ch Cln s to a cl ose-
DIINf
1:'
¡:i
j
up o f Paul li ste ning ;.md back to Leto finishing his statcmcnt: "The sleeper m us t awaken. " The cut to Paul just after L eto says rhe wo rd "awa ken" and t,he final command to a\-vaken implicitly directed towa rd Paul indi cate the prospec t ofhi m awa kening iota a new wo rld , a w o rlJ in which hi s fantasies becom e rcali zcd. Before leaving ealadan, Paul has a dream that Lynch depicts th ro ugh a montage sequence. W e see a drop of water fa lling into a pool th at d is sol ves ro a close-up of F ey d-Rautha (Sting), a mem be r of the House H a rkonnen (the enemy of the Atreides), say ing, 'T U kili you ." A nother dissolv e leaos ro the ¡mage of a moon (as Paul's voi ce-ove r says, "the second m oon"), and this dissolves bac k to more drops of water falling into a pool. The fi nal im age depicts the F rem en C hani, who says, "Tell me of yOllr home world, Usul. " Through rhis dream mom age, Pa ul foresees rhe res t of rhe film : he wiU becom c a F rem en w ith the name Usul, discover vast amouots of wa ter on Arrakis, fi g ht and kili Feyo Rauth'1 after freeing Arrak is, and fall in love w ith C hani. Su t from the pcrspective of the world of d esi re, this is ooly a d ream , nol yet a reality. The promi sed enjoyment ex ists here only in a futural sc nsc. Sut enj oy m ent does penetrate in to the wo rlo of Calada n in the for m of the threa tcning othe r. In Dune, th e worlJ w he rc the imposs ible ob ject is absent has onl y a Aeeting existencc ano finds irscJf u nd er assault from the beginning. Calada n is an island that enj oymenr rhreatens ro overru n . When Paul spa rs witb G urney, Lynch shows them fi gh ting with shieJd s to protec t themselves. T hese tra nslucent fo rce ficl ds CQve r the eotire body and protect each person from m e opponen t's knife thrusts . But at th e end of the fi g ht, both Paul and G uroey penet rate the other's shield and hold each other at knifepoint. This is poss ible, as they explain, beca use the shicld can not dcfend a slow movement ofthe kn ife. One has protec tion fr om the th rea t, but one rem ain s vu ln erable. The threa t m akes its presence more keenly felt w hell Reve rend Mother Gaius H elen Mohiam tests Paul. She forces him to place hi s hand in a green box that produces pain, and if he removes his hand , she will stab him with a poison d an. As she acti vates me box, L ynch shows an imJ ge of Paul's charred ha nd wim Aames su perimposed and smoke coming from ir. H e alternates a se ries of shor~ sh mving incn.:a.¡jng dam age to Paul 's hand wi th shots showing hi s aglllll zn l LllT ¡llI d I he Rcver end Mother administering (he pa in . \ 1 11", 1' 1111 "(ti,, ' " nt'~srIJI test, Pau! removes hi s h¡lnu frorn th!.' 11t )\, .1 11.1 Wl' ~r,' I'lItl \ll\d:llnnged
,.\
111\
\ M~OSS llll1
D~ v\n
\ Y,.,l' lI
hand . Hc co nfronts-ano we co nfro nt-an irnagc o f burning, but not actual burning. The world of oesi re depicted here is a ",orld in which the rcal thr::ats and the real enj oymen t are elsewhere.
Voices Unhinged Seyond Caladan, the world depicteo in DU17C is co mpl etely fantasmatic: enjoyment is present throughout lhis world. The ind iea tions that the film fuHy immerses us in a world offantasy are apparent in the nu ances of the film's formo The form lacks the stability ;l nd distance that we find in social reality; the barricrs ano limita tions that constitute Our experi ence of ex ternal rea lity are absent. Thi s becomcs espee i:dly ev ident in the film 's yoicc-over narration. Dune begin s with the image of a narra tor, Princess J rulan, speaking directly into the ca mera. Rathe r than pro vide a se nse of narrativ e stability that would allow us to loeate ourselves w ith in the narra tjve as spectators, this initial direct addrcss and subse quent vojce-over has the oppos ite effect. In mis sense, the role of voice over narration in Dune co ntrasts with the role that it plays in most other films, especiall y in film noir. W hen film noi r em ploys a narrato r, hc- almost al ways he-has the cffcc t of provi d ing a g uide for our journey in to the darkness of the film noir world . I n such films , the na rrator se rves as our Virgi l, guiding us and providing us w ith a se nse of stabil ity in a world lack ing ir. T he film noir voice-ovcr work s ro offse t the radicali ty of the fi lm's explorati on of soci ety's underside. lt locates the spectator safely wi thin the social order wh ile invcstigating challenges to it. S ut thc voice-ove r narration in Dune works in almost exactl y the opposite way. lt se rves to destabilize the spectator beca use of its u nusual deployment.9 Lynch demonstrates the lack of stability in Iru lan's narra tion in the opening scene and in the patte rn-or lack of patte rn-in her subse quent narrati vc intrusio ns. The first shot of lhe fi lm is a close-up of Ir ulan's eyes. T hc camera pulls ba ck to a shot of he r eotire face, and she narrates the backg roun d for th e film's story. Sut as Trul an begin s to dis cuss the spice and ¡ts ce ntra l role in the economy of the filmic world, the image of her face disa ppears fr om th e scrcen. She subsequent ly reap pca rs, and then, as she oisappears a sccond rim c, ~h c quickl y reappears again :11 11 1 nOf es Ih ;lr she fo rgot to disC ll ~, li le 1I1/" L im p' )rwnt detail the loC II jlll l ,,[ 11 " 'picc. T h is om i:;sillll .11111 ( elf n'~ I ¡
, ,,
lan's ;lUthority (as films scldom do wirh their narrarors) and subverts the sense of srahil iry rha t vo ice-ove r narra tion tend s to proviJ e for the
When one employ s "t.he voice," 0 I1 C'S OW11 voi ce alters in piteh a nd ronal ity, a nd thi s alte rarion allows the speaker ro ca use ot.he rs to aet in
specrator. Th e di sappearance and reappea ra nce of her image on th e screen disconnects vo ice from im age, furth c r destabilizing the spec tator in relation to the na rrariv e. r o
ways thar they do not consciousl y intend . Lynch's presentation of the voice 'cmphas izes its ability ro thwart the mastery we usuall y associate with speec h. The sOll nd of the speake r's voice loses the disrincuve ehar
Bur what is most significant about this opening scenc of direct ad dress is rhe timing of the initi al disappea rance ofIrulan's image. Irulan's
acrer of the speaker, beeoming d eep and completely hollow. W hat a cha racter say~ while using m e vo ice lacks the usual tim ber that we hea r in he r voice and reso un d s in a haunting register. It is as if durin g rhe
face disappears when she talks about the spice and its power. By linking the disappearance of the film's narrato r to her discussion of the spice, Lynch impli es th e incompa tibility of subjecti ve mastery and enjoymcnr. The spice, a substance of pure enjoyme nt, oerails the mastering powe r of lrulan's narr:ltion and eve n causes he r to forger momentarily a c ru cial part of he r prese ntatíon. In the fanta sy world of Dunc, cnjoyment, not the mastering powe r o f voice-ove r narration, hold s sway. This is also why Irulan 's narration during rhe rcsr (lf the film is so inconsiste nt. After her ini rial d esc riptions of the n a rrati ve situarian, he r na rration disappea rs for long period s of time and reappea rs at random . This is one of rhe ways in which L ynch departs from his source text, Frank H erbert's novel DI/ne. Whe reas Lynch esrahlishes lrulan 's narra tive voice as unreliabl e anc! incon sistent, He rbert uses it as a consta nt and reassuring p rese nce. Thi s depa rture from m e novel suggests the fantas matic narure of the world Lynch sets up in tbe film. Here, the mas ter ing voice no longe r holo s sway: the fan tasma tic world of the film seve rs rhc voice from its role in stabilizing our cx peri ence. Mastery fails in the fantas)' when it comes up against the prolife ra tion of the impossible objecr. The role of Irula n's voice in her narration exem plifies Ly nch's trea t ment of the voice rhrough our hi s film s. Fo r Lynch, the voice functions as an impossible object e mbod ying the ultimate enj oy m e nt. Rather than quelling our d esire by providing a sense of m aster)', he depicts the voice as an eng ine for our desi rc-on e of the objecr-causes that triggers ir. Slavoj Zizek cla ims thatDunc isolates "the obseene, cruel, superego-like, incom prehensible, impenetrable, trauma rie dim e nsion of th e voice which is a kind of foreign hody perturbing the bal