OXF O R D E N G L I S H M O N O G R A PH S General Editors ...
41 downloads
1170 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
OXF O R D E N G L I S H M O N O G R A PH S General Editors . c
This page intentionally left blank
Texts and Traditions Religion in Shakespeare 1592–1604 B E AT R I C E G ROV E S
CLARENDON PRESS · OXFORD
1
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York Beatrice Groves 2007 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2007 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Data available Typeset by Laserwords Private Limited, Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd., King’s Lynn, Norfolk ISBN 0–19–920898–0
978–0–19–920898–2
1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
For my husband
This page intentionally left blank
Preface In the late seventeenth century Richard Davies, Archdeacon of Coventry, claimed that Shakespeare had created the character of ‘Justice Clodpate’ in order to satirize ‘Sr Lucy’ who had had him whipped for poaching. Davies also stated that Shakespeare ‘dyed a papist’. The Archdeacon’s unreliability as a witness (his inability to distinguish between Justice Shallow and a character created by Shadwell over three-quarters of a century later) is one example of the difficulties that bedevil any attempt to prove Shakespeare’s Catholicism. Nonetheless the idea has found its advocates since the Victorian period, and has recently become one of the most popular and hotly contested areas of Shakespeare studies. Peter Milward, E. A. J. Honigmann, Richard Wilson, Stephen Greenblatt, and Clare Asquith are among those who have lately suggested that Shakespeare’s own beliefs underlie his trademark ambiguity of tone and the romance world of chantry chapels and wayside crosses inhabited by many of his characters. This book, however, attempts to engage with the religious nuances in Shakespeare’s plays in a less sectarian manner. Shakespeare’s dramaturgy includes traces of Catholicism’s visual emphasis but it also embraces the rich verbal stimulus of Protestantism’s focus on the Word. This book is entitled Texts and Traditions because it argues that Shakespeare enriched his plays through appropriating both the linguistic wealth of the English Bible and the theatrical splendour of liturgy, images, and mystery plays from England’s recent Catholic past. Rather than find the clue to these appropriations in his own biography, this monograph aims to articulate the way that Shakespeare’s verbally sophisticated, embodied drama engaged with the religious culture in which both he and his works were embedded; a culture which, as recent historical research has suggested, assimilated rather than destroyed much of its Catholic past. This less confessional approach enables a focus which is not directed at Shakespeare’s beliefs but at the interpretative possibilities that his engagement with religious culture opens up within his plays. This work grew out of an Oxford D.Phil. and I would like to thank my supervisors Peter McCullough and Emma Smith, for their
viii
Preface
encouragement, advice, and friendship, for which I am ever indebted. My gratitude is also owed for the generosity of my grandmother Phil who gave me a place in her home in which to study. I would also like to thank all those who have taught and inspired me, foremost among whom is my mother Jane, who first fed my love for Shakespeare, and took me to see his plays. A great debt of gratitude goes also to my undergraduate tutors: Jeremy Maule, Adrian Poole, Anne Barton, Bart van Es, Phil West, and, above all, Eric Griffiths. I have been amazed, throughout the time spent working on this project, by the generosity I have encountered. I have found both strangers and friends content to give up their time and eager to share their expertise. I particularly want to thank Pascale Aebischer, Philippa Berry, Santha Bhattacharji, Imogen Black, Jeremy Boulton, Henry Chadwick, Helen Cooper, Helen Deeming, Sarah Dewar-Watson, Katherine DuncanJones, Trevor Griffiths, Helen Hackett, Ralph Hanna, Lorna Huett, Martin Ingram, Felicity James, Karen Junod, Laurie Maguire, Diarmaid MacCulloch, Stephen Medcalf, Llewelyn Morgan, John Muddiman, David Norbrook, Adrian Paterson, Benjamin Prance, Alison Shell, and Jenny Wormald. I am grateful to the Arts and Humanities Research Council for the award of a scholarship which enabled me to write my D.Phil. and to St John’s College, Oxford, for my time there as a graduate student. In particular I would like to thank the fellows of Wolfson College, Oxford, whose award of a Junior Research Fellowship enabled me to complete this book. I am grateful to the many librarians who have been unfailingly helpful during my research, in particular those of the Duke Humphrey and Upper Reading Room of the Bodleian. Thanks are also due to the staff of the Oxford English Faculty library, the British Library, the Cambridge University Library, and numerous college libraries. The chapter on the second tetralogy first appeared in a slightly different form in Shakespeare Survey as ‘Hal as Self-Styled Redeemer: The Harrowing of Hell and Henry IV Part 1’ Shakespeare Survey 57 (2004): 236–48. My thanks to Peter Holland and Cambridge University Press for allowing its inclusion here. I am grateful to Tom Perridge and all the staff at Oxford University Press involved in the publication of this monograph, and in particular for the helpful advice of their anonymous readers.
Preface
ix
I wish to thank my parents, all my family, and Alan and Dorothy Groves for their love, kindness, and support. Finally, this book is dedicated to my husband, Peter, in love and gratitude for all that he has given me in the years of its writing. B.L.R.G.
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Introduction
1
1. Drama and the Word: The Bible on the Early Modern Stage
10
2. Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic: The Mystery Plays and Catholicism
26
3. Comedic Form and Paschal Motif in the First and Second Quartos of Romeo and Juliet
60
4. ‘I am not he shall buyld the Lord a house’: Religious Imagery and the Succession to the English Throne in King John
89
5. ‘Covering discretion with a coat of folly’: The Redemptive Self-Fashioning of Hal
121
6. ‘Usurp the beggary he was never born to’: Measure for Measure and the Questioning of Divine Kingship
154
Conclusion
184
Bibliography Index
189 223
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction I wonder who Will be the last, the very last, to seek This place for what it was; one of the crew That tap and jot and know what rood-lofts were? (Philip Larkin, ‘Church Going’)
To Larkin, in 1954, rood-lofts (carved wooden balconies which surmounted the rood screen and supported the rood) have become the epitome of arcane church furniture which only a ‘ruin-bibber, randy for antique’ would be able to describe. This is because, with their vast Crucifixion scenes and physical connection with the division of clergy and laity, they became the focus of Reformation iconoclasm. They were destroyed during the Edwardian purges of 1547 and 1548, but rebuilt under Mary. In the early years of Elizabeth’s reign they became the subject of the most determined struggles between reformers and parish officials, although, as Henry Machyn records in his diary, by 1560 the battle seemed won: ‘the ij yere of the quen Elesabeth was alle the rod-loftes taken down in London, and wrytynges wrytyne in the sam plase’.¹ The Royal Order of 10 October 1561 stated: ‘it is thus decreed and ordained, that the rood-lofts … be quite taken down unto the upper part of the vaults, and beam running in length over the said vaults, by putting some convenient crest upon the said beam’.² John Shakespeare, ¹ Ronald Hutton, The Rise and Fall of Merry England: The Ritual Year 1400–1700 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994), 81–2, 96, 108–9; The Diary of Henry Machyn, Citizen and Merchant Taylor of London, From A.D. 1550 to A.D. 1563, ed. John Gough Nichols (London: The Camden Society, 1848), 241. However, rood-lofts did remain up to the 1580s in some outlying parishes in Lancashire and Essex: Alexandra Walsham, Church Papists: Catholicism, Conformity and Confessional Polemic in Early Modern England (Woodbridge: The Boydell Press, 1999), 15. ² Walter Howard Frere, ed., Visitation Articles and Injunctions of the Period of the Reformation (London: Longmans, Green, 1910), iii. 108.
2
Introduction
acting as Chamberlain of Stratford, oversaw the dismantling of the rood as well as the white washing of the wall paintings in the Stratford Guild chapel in 1564.³ Memory, however, cannot be destroyed in the same way as objects, despite the implicit aim to whitewash minds as well as walls in the Edwardian Injunctions of 1547, which ordered that ‘monuments of idolatry’ should all be destroyed ‘so that there remain no memory of the same in walls, glass-windows, or elsewhere’.⁴ Rood-lofts were almost entirely destroyed, although their ghost remained, and still remains, visible in the fabric of some churches in the rood-loft stairs that lead nowhere. One rood-loft which did survive (in King’s College chapel) was fitted up to accommodate the queen in a strikingly appropriative gesture: ‘a fayr closet glased towardes the Queen was devised and made in ye mydle of the Rode lofte yf ye Quenes maiestie perhaps would there repose herselfe’.⁵ In Sir Thomas More (1593) a rood-loft carries instead the eponymous hero, a rebellious Catholic: Methought I saw him here in Chelsea church, Standing upon the rood loft, now defaced, And whilst he kneeled and prayed before the image, It fell with him into the upper choir, Where my poor father lay all stained in blood.⁶
For this writer, unlike for Larkin, rood-lofts are not part of an unrecoverably distant and dreamlike past, but powerful enough to haunt dreams. Anthony Munday, who, despite his apparently ardent Protestantism, had a profound interest in the devotional objects of Catholicism, was probably responsible for this passage.⁷ Munday lays anachronistic stress ³ S. Schoenbaum, William Shakespeare: A Documentary Life (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975), 30–1. ⁴ Frere, Visitation Articles, ii. 126. ⁵ Alan H. Nelson, ed., Cambridge, Records of Early English Drama (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1989), i. 233. ⁶ Anthony Munday et al., Sir Thomas More, ed. Vittorio Gabrieli and Giorgio Melchiori (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1990), 4. 2. 37–41. ⁷ Munday’s spying on English Catholics in Rome resulted in a tract which details many such rituals: Anthony Munday, The English Roman Life, ed. Philip J. Ayres (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980), 45–78. Some critics have wondered whether Munday may actually have been a crypto-Catholic: Munday, English Roman Life, p. xiv. Munday’s detailed account of the ‘Papist lies’ about Elizabeth was censored in the second edition of the English Roman Life.
Introduction
3
on the defacement of the rood (which had not happened by Thomas More’s time) and is able to make powerful dramatic and aesthetic use of a devotional artefact that he himself, being born in 1560, had probably never seen. In Sir Thomas More the figure of a living man who could have walked up the rood-loft stairs in Catholic times and knelt before the image blends with the figures of Mary and John kneeling at the foot of the cross; the blood of Christ’s body which would have been seen on his statue and displayed from the rood-loft during Benediction is transferred onto More and the destruction of the rood (the felling of St Paul’s rood had actually killed someone) becomes metonymic for More’s fall from grace and the demise of his religion.⁸ This striking image in Sir Thomas More (a play in which Shakespeare was involved) is evidence of how relics of medieval religion, even this most vilified example, were not only known but put to creative use by Shakespeare’s contemporaries. The allusion is evidence of a framework which, although officially abolished by the Reformation, could still be used and understood by early modern writers, readers, and theatregoers. England’s Catholic past is likewise an abiding presence in Shakespeare’s work, although often in slightly more subtle manifestations. Hamlet, for example, can be read as an extended meditation on maimed funeral rites. The play begins with a mourning period interrupted by a wedding—‘the funeral baked meats | Did coldly furnish forth the marriage tables’—and one precipitating cause of its catastrophe is Laertes’s anger at his father’s obscure burial: ‘No trophy, sword, nor hatchment o’er his bones, | No noble rite nor formal ostentation.’⁹ Ophelia too is interred with curtailed obsequies and her brother asks angrily: Must there no more be done? · · · · · · I tell thee, churlish priest, A minist’ring angel shall my sister be When thou liest howling.
(5. 1. 229–37)
The angel invoked by Laertes is heard again as Hamlet dies ‘Good night, sweet prince, | And flights of angels sing thee to thy rest’ (5. 2. 311–12) ⁸ The felling of St Paul’s rood in 1547 killed at least one workman: Margaret Aston, ‘Iconoclasm in England: Official and Clandestine’, in Clifford Davidson and Ann Eljenholm Nichols, eds., Iconoclasm vs. Art and Drama (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 1989), 71. ⁹ Hamlet, 1. 2. 179–80, 4. 5. 211–13. All references to Shakespeare’s plays, unless otherwise stated, are to William Shakespeare: The Complete Works, ed. Stanley Wells and Gary Taylor (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986).
4
Introduction
and here it unmistakably echoes the Latin antiphon sung during the Requiem Mass: In Paradisum deducant te angeli … aeternum habeas requiem (May the angels bear you to paradise, and may you have eternal rest).¹⁰ This echo of Catholic liturgy suggests that these repeatedly disrupted sacraments engage with the psychic rupture caused by Reformation’s abandonment of traditional mourning practices. The world of the play reflects the world in which it was first performed, and with the destruction of the panoply of Catholicism, rituals become fractured and fragmentary. The words of the requiem are spoken by a friend rather than a priest, Ophelia sings ‘lauds’ over her own drowning body, and Hamlet’s father comes from purgatory to request a rather different sacrifice than the masses which were traditionally offered for the repose of souls. These distortions seem to brood over Protestantism’s destruction of the comforting and familiar rituals of death, and the hero’s stasis itself can be read as a reflection on the unavailability of official forms of mourning.¹¹ Criticism which is sensitive to the way that Shakespeare’s plays engage with the religious obsessions and uncertainties of his time has much to teach us about his work. We need, however, to disentangle the acknowledgement of Catholic nuances in his plays from the search for evidence about the beliefs of the writer himself. Anthony Munday was a Protestant spy who persecuted Catholics, and yet his play retains the symbolic power of the old faith. Finding similar echoes in Shakespeare does not commit us to believing that he was a crypto-Catholic, an idea which has recently resurfaced in a blaze of publicity. ‘Catholic Shakespeare’ has seized the popular imagination and been explored through numerous books and magazine articles, as well as television shows and conferences, which have suggested that Shakespeare’s ‘signature ambiguity ¹⁰ Peter Milward, The Catholicism of Shakespeare’s Plays (Curdridge: Saint Austin, 1997), 45. See also: Maurice J. Quinlan, ‘Shakespeare and the Catholic Burial Services’, Shakespeare Quarterly 5 (1954): 303–6; Baldwin Peter, ‘Hamlet and In Paradisum’, Shakespeare Quarterly 3 (1952): 279–80. ¹¹ Stephen Greenblatt, Hamlet in Purgatory (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2001), 247 and passim; Stephen Greenblatt, Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare (London: Jonathan Cape, 2004), 312–22; Gerard Kilroy, ‘Requiem for a Prince: Rites of Memory in Hamlet’, in Richard Dutton, Alison Findlay, and Richard Wilson, eds., Theatre and Religion: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003), 143–60; Laurie Maguire, ‘ ‘‘Actions that a man might play’’: Mourning, Memory, Editing’, Performance Research 7/1 (2002): 74. My grateful thanks to Laurie Maguire for sending me this paper.
Introduction
5
came from the collision of his Catholic context with his need to conform’.¹² We need, however, to recognize the cultural desires which underlie the Catholic Shakespeare, just as clearly as we can see the cultural conservatism which bolstered the ‘Anglican’ Shakespeare who preceded him. Shakespeare is at the heart of the canon in a period which is uneasy about canonicity, and his postulated Catholicism invests him with an exciting marginality. Entertaining a ‘Catholic’ Shakespeare is the intellectual equivalent of the visual effect of looking at the Xray photograph of the Flower portrait (reproduced on the cover of this book): the slight shock with which we recognize the Virgin Mary behind the familiar hooded eyes of the Bard.¹³ The analogy with the Flower Portrait, however, is peculiarly potent. Initially the image is startling, but the explanation is quite matter of fact. A portrait of Shakespeare ¹² Richard Wilson, ‘‘Introduction: A Torturing Hour—Shakespeare and the Martyrs’, in Richard Dutton, Alison Findlay, and Richard Wilson, eds., Theatre and Religion: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003), 6. This book, and its companion volume, are the conference proceedings of the Lancaster University conference about whether Shakespeare was the ‘Shakeshaft’ who was a player in a recusant Lancashire household in the 1580s: Richard Dutton, Alison Findlay, and Richard Wilson, eds., Region, Religion and Patronage: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003). For other works on Shakespeare’s Catholicism, see Henry Sebastian Bowden, The Religion of Shakespeare (London: Burns & Oates, 1899); John Henry de Groot, The Shakespeares and ‘The Old Faith’ (New York: King’s Crown, 1946); H. Mutschmann and K. Wentersdorf, Shakespeare and Catholicism (New York: Sheed & Ward, 1952); Peter Milward, Shakespeare’s Religious Background (London: Sidgwick & Jackson, 1973); Ian Wilson, Shakespeare: The Evidence: Unlocking the Mysteries of the Man and his Work (London: Headline Book Publishing, 1993); Eric Sams, The Real Shakespeare: Retrieving the Early Years, 1564–1594 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1995); Eamon Duffy, ‘Was Shakespeare a Catholic?’, The Tablet, 27 April (1996): 536–8; Milward, The Catholicism of Shakespeare’s Plays; Richard Wilson, ‘Shakespeare and the Jesuits’, Times Literary Supplement, no. 4942, 19 December 1997; E. A. J. Honigmann, Shakespeare: The ‘Lost Years’, 2nd edn. (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1998); Park Honan, Shakespeare: A Life (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999), 64–71; Velma Bourgeois Richmond, Shakespeare, Catholicism, and Romance (London: Continuum, 2000); Greenblatt, Hamlet in Purgatory; Michael Wood, In Search of Shakespeare (London: BBC Worldwide, 2003), 270–3, 340; Richard Wilson, Secret Shakespeare: Studies in Theatre, Religion and Resistance (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2004); Greenblatt, Will in the World; Clare Asquith, Shadowplay: The Hidden Beliefs and Coded Politics of William Shakespeare (New York: PublicAffairs, 2005). ¹³ Paint analysis has proved conclusively that the Flower portrait is a nineteenthcentury image, and not early seventeenth century, as has been sometimes thought. See Tarnya Cooper, Searching for Shakespeare (London: National Portrait Gallery, 2006), 72–5. For an earlier overview of theories about the painting, see Paul Bertram and Frank Cossa, ‘ ‘‘Willm(-) Shakespeare 1609’’: The Flower Portrait Revisited’, Shakespeare Quarterly 37/1 (1986): 83–96.
6
Introduction
was a saleable commodity; a picture of the Madonna and child was not. There is no mystery about the reuse of the panel. Shakespeare painted over the Virgin and Christ child is not a secret code revealing his true faith but a vivid illustration of the indubitable truth that the present rises like a phoenix from the ashes of the past. Catholicism lies behind Shakespeare as surely as it lies behind his image in the Flower portrait, but not because it can be proved to be what he truly believed. Catholicism was the faith of England’s past and whatever Shakespeare’s own doctrinal affiliations we should be neither shocked nor surprised to find Catholicism underlying his dramaturgy as well as his portrait. Drama is a synthesis of visual and verbal and Shakespeare’s dramaturgy is sensitive both to the intensely visual aspects of his Catholic cultural heritage and to the rich verbal texture of Protestantism with its long, punning sermons, catechizing, Prayer Book, witty Marprelate tracts, and, above all, the Bible to be heard and read in English. This book engages with the way in which Shakespeare appropriated both the linguistic wealth of the English Bible and the theatrical splendour of liturgy, images, and mystery plays from England’s recent Catholic past in order to enrich his plays. It will not attempt to unravel Shakespeare’s beliefs, but instead will explore the influence of the sacred texts and traditions of his time on his dramaturgy and argue for the new interpretative possibilities which live in these religious nuances. The two first chapters will tease out the shaping effect of both Protestant and Catholic religious culture on his dramaturgy in order to establish a foundation from which to pursue the in-depth studies undertaken in the rest of the book. The first chapter is about the primary text of Shakespeare’s society—the Bible—and its relationship with the stage: its familiarity to both Shakespeare and his audience, and the way that stage censorship fostered subtle allusion and engagement with biblical themes. The second chapter looks at residual Catholicism in early modern culture, focusing on the mystery plays, and argues that their Incarnational aesthetic was inherited by Shakespeare. The rest of the book will centre on close readings of Shakespeare’s plays and consider how both the religious consciousness of the time and the relics of medievalism in early modern England affected his dramaturgy. It will focus on the first half of Shakespeare’s career—from King John to Measure for Measure —because critical work on Christian and Catholic nuances in Shakespeare has tended to focus on the reconciliations and theophanies of the late plays and mature tragedies. The readings given here of these earlier plays show that from the beginning of his career
Introduction
7
Shakespeare uses biblical allusions, strengthened by staging which recalls liturgy or the mystery cycles, to explore and enrich the wider concerns of his drama. The third chapter establishes a previously unrecognized allusion to Easter, and the Easter sepulchre, in Romeo and Juliet. It argues that the religious echoes confer sanctity on the young couple and encourages the audience expectation that Juliet will rise from her tomb. The paschal motif strengthens the comedic impulse of the play, created through comic characters and the subject matter of young love, and so increases the powerful shock of the tragic ending. The fourth chapter argues that in another of Shakespeare’s early plays, King John, Christian imagery is likewise used to enhance the sympathetic portrayal of one of the protagonists, in a way fundamentally opposed to the Christic imagery of his sources. Shakespeare takes the crypto-religious quality which surrounds the king in his sources and transfers it on to Arthur. Instead of the proto-Protestant martyr king, it is now the innocent boy who is the locus for holiness in the play. The sympathy for the innocent suffering of Arthur is intensified by the powerful language and theatrical memory of the Passion, particularly in the blinding scene of Act 4 Scene 1. The biblical echoes interact with the political concerns of the play and form part of the wider conception of Arthur as the true king, unique to Shakespeare’s telling of the story. The fifth and sixth chapters consider in greater depth Shakespeare’s engagement with the language of divine right. The fifth chapter focuses on 1 Henry IV, contextualizing it within the religious iconography employed by the eponymous kings of Richard II and Henry V. This chapter argues for the Incarnational nuance of Hal’s self-fashioning as a Cheapside rogue turned royal prince. Hal stages his own redemption in Christian terms: a Lenten period of expectant, self-imposed exile is followed by a reconciliation between father and son through a decisive single combat with a rebellious enemy. The dramatic form of the liturgy, the biblical story, and the mystery plays, have been appropriated by Hal to invest his own history with its power. The final chapter looks at Shakespeare’s first play after the regime change of 1603 and considers how the fusion of divine and royalist imagery examined in King John and 1 Henry IV is affected by the advent of the new king. Measure for Measure is one of a cluster of plays performed before the king shortly after his accession which have a disguised protagonist. Angelo’s allusion to ‘power divine’, combined with the biblical title of the play, has led some critics and directors to
8
Introduction
posit a connection between the Duke and Christ. By exploring new biblical and mystery play sources for parts of the play—in particular the scenes between the Duke and Lucio and the reappearance of Claudio—this chapter both creates a firmer basis for this supposition and questions the praise implicit in some Christianized readings of the play. Divine aspects of the Duke’s enterprise may flatter the king, but Shakespeare also suggests through them the impossibility of a perfect imitation of Christ in an earthly ruler. The play engages with and critiques contemporary conflations of human and divine law, and this chapter argues that central to this is the creation of a divine image of rule, which the Duke cannot sustain. In the portrayal of the Duke of Measure for Measure, as in the portrayal of Hal or King John, biblical echoes may appear to fall in with the language of power, but on closer scrutiny Shakespeare is not simply parroting the royalist panegyric of his age. The three very different rulers all attempt to project a holy image of themselves in these plays. Shakespeare, however, uses biblical language and analogues to suggest the fundamental dichotomy between earthly kingship and Christ’s rule. Biblical echoes which are present in Measure for Measure, King John, the first tetralogy, and Romeo and Juliet are more complicated than has often been realized. The matrix of associations surrounding such an intensely analysed and almost overfamiliar text, ensure that biblical allusions are complex and multifaceted. Shakespearean drama explores and exploits this ambiguity to its utmost. Shakespeare draws on the emotional and dramatic power of biblical stories—familiar through Bible reading, liturgy, mystery cycles, and the fading visual culture of Catholicism—and assimilates it into his own secular drama. This book argues for the influence of both embodied and verbal religious forms on Shakespeare’s stagecraft, as elements in a drama which integrates word and image. The Reformation involved a tug of war over competing epistemologies. In medieval England, according to Walter Ong, ‘the culture as a whole assimilated the biblical word not verbatim but as an oral culture typically assimilates a message, thematically and formulaically, tribally rather than individually’.¹⁴ With the Reformation came the insistence on sola scriptura, the logocentrism of the reformer’s programme decisively empowered by print which made exact, almost unvarying texts possible. Typographical accuracy ¹⁴ Walter Ong, The Presence of the Word: Some Prolegomena for Cultural and Religious History (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1971), 269.
Introduction
9
gave a strong foundation for a semantic system which relied on the written, printed word as the bearer of truth. This was in sharp contrast with the biblical drama of the mystery cycles which was less concerned with literal fidelity to the words of Scripture than with emotional engagement with its patterns of fall and redemption, judgement and salvation.¹⁵ Shakespearean drama, however, unites these approaches. Shakespeare’s intimate knowledge of the biblical text, as the following chapters will demonstrate, allows him to allude to it in verbally specific ways. However, he also inherits from earlier English drama a thematic and formulaic interpretation of the Bible based on the emotional power of recurring patterns. This book aims to articulate the way that Shakespeare’s verbally sophisticated, embodied drama engaged with the religious culture in which both he and his works were embedded. ¹⁵ Ibid. 272; Michael O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye: Iconoclasm and Theater in Early Modern England (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), 28–9.
1 Drama and the Word: The Bible on the Early Modern Stage In Love’s Labour’s Lost Shakespeare presents on-stage a biblically illiterate audience. When presented with the Pageant of the Nine Worthies Berowne and his companions feign ignorance and affect to mistake Judas Maccabaeus for Judas Iscariot: (as Judas) Judas I am— A Judas? Not Iscariot, sir. (As Judas) Judas I am, yclept Maccabaeus. Judas Maccabaeus clipped is plain Judas. A kissing traitor. (5. 2. 590–5)
Holofernes’s ‘Not Iscariot’ is itself a biblical quotation: John’s Gospel stresses that Judas son of James is speaking by stipulating: ‘Iudas said unto him (not Iscariot)’.¹ Dumaine’s slightly forced use of the word ‘clipped’ (meaning shortened) sets up Berowne’s pun on ‘clipped’ (meaning embraced). This joke indicates the currency of the knowledge that Judas betrayed Jesus with a kiss, as this kind of humour relies on being widely and immediately recognized. A more subtle biblical knowledge is assumed in Boyet’s final line to Holofernes: ‘a light for Monsieur Judas! It grows dark; he may stumble’ (5. 2. 624). This alludes to the biblical passage about night having fallen when Judas left the Last Supper, a metaphor for the darkness within his heart: ‘assoone then as he had receiued the sop, he went immediatly out, and it was night’ (John 13: 30).² ¹ John 14: 22. All biblical references, unless otherwise stated, are to The Bible, Translated according to The Ebrew and Greeke, and conferred with the best translations in diuers Languages (London, 1594). This is the Geneva Bible, which is the version which Shakespeare seems to have known best. For the evidence of Shakespeare’s knowledge of different biblical versions, see below. ² Thomas Carter, Shakespeare and Holy Scripture: with the Version he used (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1905), 38. Most modern editors do not recognize the allusion.
Drama and the Word
11
Many biblical allusions in Shakespeare are seamlessly integrated into the text and it is difficult to tell whether he, or his audience, were aware of them; although as Shakespeare’s audience was part of only the second generation to whom an English Bible was accessible, its language would not yet have become simply proverbial.³ Passages such as this, however, where jokes and puns would make no sense without the biblical context, show Shakespeare consciously using biblical quotation and holding up biblical illiteracy—confusing Judas Maccabaeus with Judas Iscariot—as something which can destroy theatrical presentation. Judas’s kiss was proverbial, but the joke about his exit into darkness at the Last Supper suggests that Shakespeare expected his audience to recognize allusions even to relatively obscure parts of biblical stories.⁴ Shakespeare can stage biblically learned spectators feigning ignorance in his comedy precisely because he knows that most of his audience will catch the references and laugh at the jokes. Shakespeare’s audience not only knew the Bible, but could be relied on to bring their knowledge to what they saw on the stage.⁵ The Bible was a unique resource for early modern playwrights as, unlike the classics or even the chronicle histories, it was known by the vast majority of their audience. Church attendance was compulsory in Elizabethan England and every person who did not attend their parish church each Sunday and on holy days had to pay a fine of twelve pence for every abstention. The increasing fear of Catholicism later in Elizabeth’s reign led to the fines being increased, and legislation in 1581 imposed the immense penalty of twenty pounds a month for those absenting themselves from church.⁶ The documentary evidence suggests ³ Richmond Noble, Shakespeare’s Biblical Knowledge and the Use of the Book of Common Prayer as Exemplified in the Plays of the First Folio (London: Macmillan, 1935), 41. ⁴ This passage in John 13 was also used by Shakespeare in Macbeth, when Macbeth leaves the supper table at which Duncan, the master he intends to betray and the man he intends to murder, is eating his last meal. On leaving Duncan, Macbeth’s words (‘if it were done when ’tis done, then ’twere well | It were done quickly’ (1. 7. 1–2) ) recall Jesus’ words to Judas at the Last Supper: ‘that thou doest, doe quickely’ (John 13: 27). See Roy Walker, The Time is Free: A Study of Macbeth (London: Andrew Dakers, 1946), 53–5. ⁵ For more on this argument, see Harold Fisch, The Biblical Presence in Shakespeare, Milton and Blake: A Comparative Study (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999), 17; Gerald M. Pinciss, Forbidden Matter: Religion in the Drama of Shakespeare and His Contemporaries (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 2000), 15–16. ⁶ Frere, Visitation Articles, iii. 168; William Page, ed., Warwick in The Victoria History of the Counties of England (London: Archibald Constable, 1908), ii. 37.
12
Drama and the Word
that the majority of English people not only attended church but also partook in its central rites: there was near universal baptism and, at Easter at least, most also received communion.⁷ Religious conformity was not left to the individual conscience, but imposed by the order of law, and legislation was likewise passed requiring all heads of families to instruct their children in the catechism and principles of religion.⁸ Recent historical research in the field of late Elizabethan and early Jacobean popular religion has suggested that this programme of reform was to a large extent successful and most people’s beliefs could be characterized as ‘unspectacular orthodoxy’.⁹ Protestantism was a religion of the Word, but this did not mean that the illiterate were exempt from the drive towards religious uniformity. The religious literacy of Shakespeare’s audience—their ability to recognize allusions to the Bible or Christian ideas in his work—has a complex relationship with actual literacy. Protestant evangelism in post-Reformation England championed educational reform and even the most conservative estimates suggest that it was not only the noblemen in Shakespeare’s audience who could read and write. According to David Cressy’s seminal study, the overwhelming majority of London tradesmen could sign their name by the early seventeenth century, but even this has been widely regarded as a ‘spectacular underestimate’ of reading ability in the period.¹⁰ Those who could read would have been familiar with basic Christian tenets from their infancy: they learnt from hornbooks inscribed with the Lord’s Prayer and their earliest schooling was based on Bible ⁷ Martin Ingram, ‘From Reformation to Toleration: Popular Religious Culture in England, 1540–1690’, in Tim Harris, ed., Popular Culture in England, c. 1500–1850 (London: Macmillan, 1995), 110; J. P. Boulton, ‘The Limits of Formal Religion: The Administration of Holy Communion in Late Elizabethan and Early Stuart London’, The London Journal 10/2 (1984): 137; Patrick Collinson, The Religion of Protestants: The Church in English Society 1559–1625 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982), 212. ⁸ Ivy Pinchbeck and Margaret Hewitt, in Children in English Society, i. From Tudor Times to the Eighteenth Century (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1972), 260. ⁹ The phrase is from Martin Ingram, Church Courts, Sex and Marriage in England 157/0–1640 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 94, 123. ¹⁰ David Cressy, Literacy and the Social Order: Reading and Writing in Tudor and Stuart England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980), 146–7; Margaret Spufford, ‘First Steps in Literacy: The Reading and Writing Experiences of the Humblest Seventeenth-Century Spiritual Autobiographers’, Social History 4/3 (1979): 407–35; Keith Thomas, ‘The Meaning of Literacy in Early Modern England’, in Gerd Baumann, ed., The Written Word: Literacy in Transition (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985), 103.
Drama and the Word
13
reading.¹¹ But even complete illiteracy was compatible with reasonably sophisticated religious knowledge. In addition to compulsory church attendance, crowds of people flocked to public sermons and preaching was a large part of the appeal of Protestantism in a semi-literate culture.¹² William Prynne angrily proclaimed that there was ‘no Analogie betweene Preachers and Players, Sermons and Playes, Theaters and Churches’, but it seems that he was fighting against a public who enjoyed both forms of entertainment and instruction. The substantial audience overlap for sermons and plays meant that, as Bryan Crockett has suggested, ‘preachers could assume a high degree of receptivity to oral performance, as the playwrights could assume their audiences’ tendency to cast their experiences is religious terms’.¹³ Catechisms were also an essential form of religious instruction for those who could not read, and children, servants, and apprentices were sent to church on Sundays, an hour before the evening service began, to be catechized by the priest. Catechisms were immensely popular; it has been estimated that by the early seventeenth century there were over one million catechisms in circulation in a population of about four million.¹⁴ Catechisms with titles such as A breefe Catechisme so necessarie and easie to be learned euen of the symple sort (1576), or A Catechisme, or short kind of Instruction, whereby to teach children and the Ignoravnter sort (1588), indicate that the authors of these aphoristic texts had an illiterate or semi-literate market in mind. Many introductory epistles stressed the duty of the buyer to ‘instruct your children and servants in this Catechisme’ and Thomas Sparke and John Seddon’s catechism details how the literate members of a household could teach the illiterate by reading and explaining more complex concepts to them. Such a vision may seem implausibly idealistic, ¹¹ Margaret Spufford, ‘ ‘‘I bought me a primer’’, or, ‘‘How godly were the multitude?’’: The Basic Religious Concepts of Those Who Could Read in the Seventeenth Century’, in Spufford, ed., The World of Rural Dissenters, 1520–1725 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 72–3, 85; Spufford, ‘First Steps in Literacy’, 410–11. ¹² Collinson, Religion of Protestants, 243–5, 257–64. ¹³ William Prynne, Histrio-Mastix (London, 1633), 934; Bryan Crockett, The Play of Paradox: Stage and Sermon in Renaissance England (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1995), 7. See also Martha Tuck Rozett, The Doctrine of Election and the Emergence of Elizabethan Tragedy (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1984), 15 ff.; Jeffrey Knapp, Shakespeare’s Tribe: Church, Nation, and Theater in Renaissance England (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002), 5–6. ¹⁴ Ian Green, The Christian’s ABC: Catechisms and Catechizing in England c.1530– 1740 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996), 102–6; Spufford, ‘ ‘‘I bought me a primer’’ ’, 73.
14
Drama and the Word
but Lady Margaret Hoby’s diary gives evidence of how, in godly households at least, servants were read to from the Bible and involved in religious discussions. The preface to Eusebius Paget’s immensely popular catechism Short questions and answeares (1584) claims: ‘in foure monethes space, I have seene these principles and aunsweres, learned by Gentelmen, Yeomen, Horskeeperes, Shepheardes, Cartars, Mylkemaydes, Kitchenboyes, & al in that houshold (where these orders were observed)’.¹⁵ There were also less didactic means of religious instruction open to those on the margins of literacy, such as the singing of psalms. The popularity of this pastime is shown not only by the many references to it (such as Falstaff ’s quip: ‘I would I were a weaver—I could sing psalms or anything’ (1 Henry IV, 2. 5. 132–3) ) but also by the staggering 124 editions of Sternhold and Hopkins’s Psalms in English Meter which were printed (1583–1608).¹⁶ The visual culture of pre-Reformation England had also not entirely disappeared, and had to some extent been appropriated by the lurid pictures in Foxe’s Actes and Monuments, which was the only major European reformed martyrology to be illustrated.¹⁷ Pictures helped to sell books at both ends of the market, and ballads and pamphlets were often illustrated with didactic images, in a similar manner to Foxe’s lavish folio. Tessa Watt’s excellent study of cheap print in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries has argued that the huge trade in ballads, broadsides, and chapbooks illustrates the ¹⁵ Stephen Denison, A Compendious Catechisme: Wherein are briefly expounded, the Apostles Creed, the ten commandements and the Lords prayer, together with other fundamentall points of Christian Religion, very necessary for children and servantes to learne, before they go to the holy communion (London, 1632), A3r ; Thomas Sparke and John Seddon, A Catechisme, or short kind of Instruction, whereby to teach children and the Ignoraunter sort, the Christian Religion (Oxford, 1588), A3v –4r ; The Private Life of an Elizabethan Lady: The Diary of Lady Margaret Hoby 1599–1605, ed. Joanne Moody (Stroud: Sutton, 1998), 3, 24, 35, 38–9, 48, 144; Eusebius Paget, Short questions and answeares, contayning the Summe of Christian Religion (London, 1584), A3r−v . This latter catechism went through at least nineteen editions between 1579 and 1639. ¹⁶ Peter Blayney, ‘The Publication of Playbooks’, in John D. Cox and David Scott Kastan, eds., A New History of Early English Drama (New York: Columbia University Press, 1997), 388. For contemporary witness to psalm-singing in the period see Nicolas Bownde, The Doctrine of the Sabbath, Plainely layde forth, and soundly proued by testimonies both of holy Scripture, and also of olde and newe ecclesiasticall writers (London, 1595), Iir−v ; Diary of Lady Margaret Hoby, 38. ¹⁷ For the importance and popularity of Foxe’s illustrations see Andrew Pettegree, ‘Illustrating the Book: A Protestant Dilemma’, in Christopher Highley and John N. King, eds., John Foxe and his World (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2002), 133–44.
Drama and the Word
15
piety of ordinary people, including those on the fringes of literacy.¹⁸ The prevalence of cheap religious print, catechizing, sermons, Bible reading, and churchgoing ensured that even the illiterate were familiar with basic religious concepts and Bible stories. At the beginning of the Reformation, when illiteracy was rife, the stage itself was enlisted as a means for promulgating the Gospel. Foxe even classed the theatre with sermons and books as a didactic tool, writing that ‘plaiers, Printers, Preachers’ were ‘a triple bulwarke against the triple crowne of the Pope’.¹⁹ Protestants such as Martin Bucer, John Bale, and Foxe embraced the didactic potential of theatre. Early in the English Reformation Bucer, writing for the young Edward VI, described how Scripture could be used as a source for the stage: The Scriptures everywhere offer an abundant supply of material for tragedies, in almost all the stories of the holy patriarchs, kings, prophets, apostles, from the time of Adam, the first parent of mankind. For these stories are filled with divine and heroic personages, emotions, customs, actions and also events which turned out contrary to what was expected, which Aristotle calls a reversal.20
Theodore de B`eze himself dramatized the sacrifice of Isaac and his play was a phenomenal success, going into ten editions in the sixteenth century and translated into Italian, Latin, and English.²¹ In the early Reformation period there were new plays written in England on New Testament subjects such as Grimald’s Christus Redivivus (1543) and Foxe’s Christus Triumphans (1556).²² In the 1530s John Bale set to work to write a series of biblical plays which were presumably meant to be a purified form of the mystery cycles, although the plays that survive show how differently the same stories could be dramatized by a Protestant playwright. In Bale’s God’s Promises (1538), for example, the ¹⁸ Tessa Watt, Cheap Print and Popular Piety, 1550–1640 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991), 322–3. Cf. Peter Lake, ‘Deeds against Nature: Cheap Print, Protestantism and Murder in Early Seventeenth Century England’, in Kevin Sharpe and Peter Lake, eds., Culture and Politics in Early Stuart England (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1993), 277. ¹⁹ John Foxe, Actes and Monuments […] (London, 1583), ii. 1348. ²⁰ Martin Bucer, De Regno Christi (1550) in Melanchthon and Bucer, ed. Wilhelm Pauck (London: SCM, 1969), 51. ²¹ Theodore de B`eze, A Tragedie of Abrahams Sacrifice, Written in french by Theodore Beza, and translated into Inglish, by A[rthur] G[olding] (London, 1577); O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 104. ²² For records of other new plays on the New Testament (up to 1561), see Alfred Harbage, Annals of English Drama 975–1700: An Analytical Record of all Plays, Extant or Lost, Chronologically Arranged and Indexed by Authors, Titles, Dramatic Companies &c, edn. Sylvia Stoler Wagonheim, 3rd edn. (London: Routledge, 1989), 4–38.
16
Drama and the Word
traditional cycle play about the prophecies of Christ’s birth is reworked so that it centres on the eradication of idolatry. From the Elizabethan period however, Protestant biblical theatre began to encounter censorship. Elizabeth issued a proclamation early in her reign prohibiting unlicensed interludes (16 May 1559) which stated that nothing could be played: ‘Wherein either matters of religion or of the governance of the estate of the commonweale shall be handled or treated, being no meet matters to be written or treated upon, but by men of authority, learning and wisdom, nor to be handled before any audience, but of grave and discreet persons.’²³ What this proclamation (penned by the Queen herself) suggests is that religious theatre was becoming a victim of its own success. The Latin plays, such as those by Grimald and Foxe were acceptable to those in authority; English biblical drama performed for a large, uneducated audience was not. The popularity of biblically based drama is evident from the vigorous tradition of scriptural theatre which was sustained into the late Elizabethan period, despite the censorship and censoriousness it provoked. The next chapter will look at the traditional biblical theatre of the mystery plays, but Bale was not the only Protestant to follow their lead. There is some evidence of Protestant staging of the Passion itself in Elizabeth’s reign. Thomas Beard’s Theatre of God’s Judgements (1597) notes God’s vengeance on what was presumably a university play about the Crucifixion: In the Vniversity of Oxford the history of Christ was also played, and cruelly punished, and that not many yeares since: for he that bore the person of Christ, the Lord struck him with such a giddinesse of spirit and brain, that he became mad forthwith, crying when he was in his best humour, That God had laid this judgment upon him for playing Christ.24
There is also a record of a new Passion play being staged by Thomas Ashton, the Protestant headmaster of Shrewsbury school, who fostered the dramatic talents of his students (among them Philip Sidney and Fulke Greville) with regular performances. A rather damaged document records that in 1560 the school performed ‘Mr Ashton’s first playe playe [sic] vpon the passion of Christe’. Thomas Ashton’s productions ²³ Tudor Royal Proclamations, ed. Paul L. Hughes and James F. Larkin (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1964–9), ii. 115. ²⁴ Thomas Beard, The Theatre of Gods Judgements […], 4th edn. (London, 1648), 147.
Drama and the Word
17
appear to have been mounted to great applause: the local poet Thomas Churchyard estimates they were seen by twenty thousand spectators and Queen Elizabeth herself attempted to see his play of Julian the Apostate in 1565–6.²⁵ Although Ashton’s play is a strikingly late example of a new Passion play, there were a large number of plays on wider biblical themes written and performed at the beginning of Elizabeth’s reign, such as Lewis Wager’s Life and Repentaunce of Marie Magdalene (1566–7), which likewise portrayed Jesus on the stage. Many of the plays—such as A Pretie new Enterlude both pithie & pleasaunt of the Story of Kyng Daryus, Beinge taken out of the third and fourth Chapter of the thyrd booke of Edras (printed 1565, with a second edition in 1577)—proudly declared their biblical source. After the 1560s biblical drama became less common, but four biblical plays printed between the opening of the Theatre and the end of Elizabeth’s reign are extant: Theodore de B`eze’s Abraham’s Sacrifice (1577), Thomas Garter’s The Most Virtuous and Godly Susanna (1578), Thomas Lodge and Robert Greene’s A Looking-Glasse for London and England (1594), and George Peele’s The Love of King David and Fair Bethsabe (entered 1594, published 1599). However, there is evidence that many similar plays have been lost. Henslowe’s diary, for example, records performances for numerous biblical plays including Abraham and Lot (1594), Hester and Asseuerus (1594), Nebuchadnezzer (1596–7), William Haughton, William Birde, and Samuel Rowley’s Judas (1602), Pontius Pilate (1602), Anthony Munday and Thomas Dekker’s Jephthah (1602), Henry Chettle’s Tobias (1602), Samson (1602), and Samuel Rowley’s Joshua (1602).²⁶ Such plays show that the theatregoing public was enthusiastic about watching biblical subjects on their stage, and in some cases also indicate the audience’s prior familiarity with such stories. In George Peele’s ²⁵ J. Alan B. Somerset, ed., Shropshire, Records of Early English Drama (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1994), i. 201; Katherine Duncan-Jones, Sir Philip Sidney: Courtier Poet (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1991), 31. For the evidence as to whether this really was a Passion play, see Patrick Collinson, ‘The Shearman’s Tree and the Preacher: The Strange Death of Merry England in Shrewsbury and Beyond’, in Patrick Collinson and John Craig, eds., The Reformation in English Towns, 1500–1640 (London: Macmillan, 1998), 218; O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 101 n. 24. ²⁶ Henslowe’s Diary, ed. Walter W. Greg (London: A. H. Bullen, 1904), i. 8v –9r , 25v –26r , 69v , 95r –96r , 105v –106v , 108r ; Lily B. Campbell, Divine Poetry and Drama in Sixteenth-Century England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1959), 240–2.
18
Drama and the Word
The Love of King David and Fair Bethsabe, for example, a popular and long-running play, dramatic irony depends on the audience’s knowledge of the story.²⁷ The play is littered with references to Absalom’s hair, and the anticipatory dread of this motif only works if the audience knows how he dies. There is also a presentiment of his death after his first disobedience when he is reconciled to his father with the words: ‘ah Absalon my sonne, ah my sonne Absolon’. These words echo David’s lament over his son’s death in 2 Samuel, and they reappear in the play after Absalom has died: ‘O Absalon, Absalon, O my sonne, my sonne, | Would God that I had died for Absalon.’²⁸ The fame of these mourning words is confirmed by Sidney’s use of them in the New Arcadia. When Philoclea believes Pamela to be dead she cries: ‘Pamela, my sister, my sister, Pamela, woe is me for thee, I would I died for thee.’²⁹ The pre-echo of the phrase before Absalom’s death in David and Bethsabe is evidence that the theatre audience were expected to be scripturally literate, just as the more educated audience for Sidney’s Arcadia was.³⁰ There were also plays which incorporated biblical stories and themes with a certain degree of theological sophistication. The parable of the prodigal son, for example, which was ubiquitous in Elizabethan comedy from Nice Wanton (1550) through to The Famous Victories of Henry the Fifth (1586), was combined with Roman comedy to create a new and relatively sophisticated theological form. The integration creates a distinctively Christian theme: the old man who needs to be subdued is not the Senex of Roman comedy, but the internalized ‘old man’ of ²⁷ Its popularity is suggested by the title page, which declares ‘As it hath ben diuers times plaied in the stage’, and by the fact that fourteen copies of the original quarto survive: Murray Roston, Biblical Drama in England: From the Middle Ages to the Present Day (London: Faber & Faber, 1968), 100. Henslowe’s diary records a payment in October 1602 for the Earl of Worcester’s men ‘pd for poleyes & worckmanshipp for to hange absolome … xiiijd ’, which either alludes to a new play about Absalom or indicates the longevity of Peele’s play: Henslowe’s Diary, i. 116v . ²⁸ George Peele, The Love of King David and Fair Bethsabe, ed. W.W. Greg (Oxford: The Malone Society Reprints, 1912), ll. 987, 1925–8. The words are from 2 Samuel 18: 33: ‘O my sonne Absalom, my sonne, my sonne Absalom: woulde God I had dyed for thee.’ ²⁹ Philip Sidney, The Countess of Pembroke’s Arcadia, ed. Maurice Evans (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1977), 558. ³⁰ The first and chief audience for both versions of the Arcadia was Sidney’s sister Mary, Countess of Pembroke: Duncan-Jones, Sir Philip Sidney, 143, 192. Professor Duncan-Jones also draws attention to the more strongly charged religious language of the revised version (in which this phrase is found), ibid. 263.
Drama and the Word
19
Ephesians.³¹ More solidly Protestant drama, such as the anonymous Jacob and Esau (1568), performed a protracted staging of reformed dogma, in this case the doctrine of election and reprobation: But before Jacob and Esau yet borne were, Or had eyther done good, or yll perpetrate: As the prophete Malachie and Paule witnesse beare, Jacob was chosen, and Esau reprobate: Jacob I loue (sayde God) and Esau I hate. For it is not (sayth Paule) in mans renuing or will, But in Gods mercy who choseth whome he will.³²
Protestant doctrine, however, might influence drama in more subtle ways. Scott McMillin and Sally-Beth MacLean, for example, have suggested that the Queen’s Men, with their connections with Leicester and Walsingham, and their drama which insisted on ‘truth’ and ‘plainness’, were spreading Protestant ideology in scarcely perceptible ways as they toured throughout the country.³³ It is likewise possible that the Queen’s Men were involved in the most contentious performance of theological controversy on the Elizabethan stage, and that this involvement led to their decline as a leading London company.³⁴ The Martin Marprelate scandal raged from 1588 to 1590 and when more scholarly attempts to answer his anti-episcopal satire had failed, the ecclesiastical authorities employed the prose wits of the age to quash him. Nashe makes it clear that the anti-Martinists brought the dispute into the theatre: ‘Me thought Vetus Comaedia beganne to pricke him at London in the right vaine, when shee brought foorth Divinitie wyth a scratcht face, holding her hart as if she were sicke, because Martin would have forced her.’³⁵ Graphic descriptions of scenes ³¹ Ervin Beck, ‘Terence Improved: The Paradigm of the Prodigal Son in English Renaissance Drama’, Renaissance Drama 6 (1973): 107–22. See also Alan R. Young, The English Prodigal Son Plays: A Theatrical Fashion of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (Salzburg: Salzburg University Press, 1979), 121. Both Young and Beck note the importance of the prodigal son plot for many Shakespearean plays. ³² Jacob and Esau, ed. John Crow and F. P. Wilson (Oxford: Malone Society Reprints, 1956), ll. 8–14. For other predestinarian sections in the play, see ll. 150–1, 230–1, 447–50, 891, 981, 1471–8, 1780–91, 1801–19. ³³ Scott McMillin and Sally-Beth MacLean, The Queen’s Men and Their Plays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), ch. 2. ³⁴ Ibid. 49–55. ³⁵ The Works of Thomas Nashe, ed. Ronald B. McKerrow (London: A. H. Bullen, 1904–10), i. 92. For a discussion of the connection of the Marprelate controversy with the stage see Patrick Collinson, ‘Ecclesiastical Vitriol: Religious Satire in the 1590s
20
Drama and the Word
in which Martin has been wormed, lanced, bled, whipped, and beaten are frequently detailed in the anti-Martin tracts to show how he has been ‘made a Maygame vpon the Stage’. The scurrilous anti-Martin plays are an explicit example of how theological debate could contribute directly to popular drama. They were played out on the stage of the Theatre at the start of Shakespeare’s career and there is evidence that he was himself influenced by the stage Martin.³⁶ This particularly vivid example of the alliance between theology and the theatre, however, was also probably directly responsible for the increased censorship which was to force playwrights to approach religious subjects in less open ways. In 1589 a Censorship Commission was created to ‘stryke oute or reforme suche partes and matters as they shall fynd unfytt and undecent to be handled in playes, both for Divinitie and State’.³⁷ This hardening of the law against biblical theatre was replaced by a blanket ban in 1606 when the Act to restrain the Abuses of Players made it illegal in ‘any Stage play, Interlude, Shewe, Maygame, or Pageant jestingly or prophanely speake or use the holy Name of God or of Christ Jesus, or of the Holy Ghoste or of the Trinitie’.³⁸ The theatre reacted by using the word ‘Jove’ as a signifier for God, but authorities recognized that pagan religion was often used to mask profanity. One piece of evidence for this comes from the and the Invention of Puritanism’, in John Guy, ed., The Reign of Elizabeth I: Court and Culture in the Last Decade (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 154, 159, 165–9; Kristen Poole, ‘Facing Puritanism: Falstaff, Martin Marprelate and the Grotesque Puritan’, in Ronald Knowles, ed., Shakespeare and Carnival: After Bakhtin (London: Macmillan, 1998), 97–122; Robert Hornback, ‘Staging Puritanism in the Early 1590s: The Carnivalesque Rebellious Clown as Anti-Puritan Stereotype’, Renaissance and Reformation/Renaissance et R´eforme 24/3 (2000): 31–67; Ritchie D. Kendall, The Drama of Dissent: The Radical Poetics of Nonconformity, 1380–1590 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1986), 176–87. ³⁶ For the influence of Martin on the creation of Falstaff, see below, ch. 5. Robert Hornback has argued that other Shakespearean characters (such as Jack Cade) also show the influence of the Marprelate plays: Hornback, ‘Staging Puritanism’, 44–50. ³⁷ Acts of the Privy Council of England, AD 1589–90, ed. John Roche Dasent (London: His Majesty’s Stationary Office, 1890–1964), xviii. 215. See also Richard Dutton, ‘Censorship’, in John D. Cox and David Scott Kastan, eds., A New History of Early English Drama (New York: Columbia University Press, 1997), 295. ³⁸ E. K. Chambers, The Elizabethan Stage (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1923), iv. 338–9. See also Gary Taylor, ‘Swounds Revisited: Theatrical, Editorial, and Literary Expurgation’, in Gary Taylor and John Jowett, eds., Shakespeare Reshaped 1606–1623 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993), 51–106.
Drama and the Word
21
astonishing fine incurred by the players of the Fortune for what was presumably a parody of Laudian worship: Thursday last [2 May 1639] the players of the Fortune were fined £1,000 for setting up an altar, a bason, and two candlesticks, and bowing down before it upon the stage, and although they allege it was an old play revived, and an altar to the heathen gods, yet it was apparent that this play was revived on purpose in contempt of the ceremonies of the Church.39
The exploitation of pagan rites, so common in Shakespeare’s late plays, is only one example of the way in which censorship, through outlawing openly Christian drama, unintentionally promoted a subtle and sophisticated engagement with biblical language and Christian ideas in ostensibly secular plays. The censorship of the early 1590s shows that the authorities were turning away from the overtly Christian drama, popular in the Edwardian and early Elizabethan periods, and becoming unwilling to employ theatrical companies, such as the Queen’s Men, for distinctively Protestant aims. Annabel Patterson has written on the enabling aspect of censorship in this period, the way in which it led writers to exploit the ‘functional ambiguity’ of language.⁴⁰ The censorship of the 1590s may have indirectly fostered the complex and fruitful engagement with biblical language and stories which we find emerging in Elizabethan drama at precisely this time. Shakespeare inherited a language enriched by a vigorous tradition of biblical translation in the decades before his birth and throughout his lifetime.⁴¹ His own knowledge of the Bible was excellent. It has long been recognized that Shakespeare was familiar with a range of biblical versions, in particular the Bishops’ Bible (1568) and Geneva Bible ³⁹ William Douglas Hamilton, ed., Calendar of State Papers, Domestic Series, of the Reign of Charles 1. 1639 (London: Longman & Co., Trubner & Co., 1873), clxx. 140. See also Gerald Eades Bentley, The Profession of a Dramatist in Shakespeare’s Time: 1590–1642 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1971), 179–81; E. K. Chambers, William Shakespeare: A Study of Facts and Problems (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1930/1988), i. 240–1. ⁴⁰ Annabel Patterson, Censorship and Interpretation: The Conditions of Writing and Reading in Early Modern England (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1984), 18 and passim. ⁴¹ For connections between Shakespeare’s and Tyndale’s language see David Daniell, ‘Shakespeare and the Protestant Mind’, Shakespeare Survey 54 (2001): 5–7; Brian Cummings, ‘Hamlet’s Luck: Shakespeare and the Sixteenth-century Bible’ (Tyndale Society IX Annual Lecture, Oxford, October 2003).
22
Drama and the Word
(1560).⁴² The Bishops’ Bible replaced the Great Bible as the official Bible of the English Church, and in 1571 Convocation decreed that a copy should be placed in every cathedral, and, where possible, in every church. This Bible was predominantly printed as a lavish folio, too expensive for most people to own as their private copy. It is a reasonable hypothesis therefore, that Shakespeare’s allusions to the Bishops’ version are drawn primarily from a memory of what he heard in church. The Geneva Bible by contrast was printed in highly popular quarto, octaro, and duodecimo formats. These editions numbered the verses and divided them into separate paragraphs (which made for easier reference and quotation) and had extensive explanatory notes. The Geneva version was also the most scholarly translation of any sixteenth-century Bible, and was popular among not only the godly but with such mainstream Church of England divines as Richard Hooker and Lancelot Andrewes. In 1576 a new version of the Geneva New Testament was printed, with notes based on those by Theodore de B`eze, which had been translated by Laurence Tomson. The Tomson New Testament swiftly became extremely popular. The period covered by this book (1592–1604) saw the printing of fifty editions of the Bible: two Bishops’ Bibles, five Bishops’ New Testaments, twenty-two Geneva Bibles, twelve Tomson New Testaments, and nineteen composite Geneva–Tomson Bibles, the latter composed of the Geneva Old Testament and the Tomson New Testament bound together.⁴³ As the Geneva Bible was not read in church it seems likely that Shakespeare’s knowledge of this biblical translation came primarily from his own reading. The hypothesis that Shakespeare chose to read the Bible suggests a commitment to its study which might appear surprising in view of the apparently secular nature of his entire output (apart from sonnet 146). Naseeb Shaheen has shown, however, that the extent of Shakespeare’s allusions to parts of the Bible not read in church indicates that Shakespeare’s private reading of the Bible was, in fact, the main source of his comprehensive knowledge of it.⁴⁴ Shakespeare also alludes to the Genevan annotations, a part of the Bible ⁴² See Noble, Shakespeare’s Biblical Knowledge, 64–76; Naseeb Shaheen, Biblical References in Shakespeare’s Plays (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1999), 17–50. ⁴³ See A. S. Herbert, T. H. Darlow, and H. F. Moule, eds., Historical Catalogue of Printed Editions of the English Bible 1525–1961 (London: The British and Foreign Bible Society, 1968), 106–23. ⁴⁴ Naseeb Shaheen, ‘Shakespeare’s Knowledge of the Bible—How Acquired’, Shakespeare Studies 20 (1988): 210–12.
Drama and the Word
23
that would never have been read out in church or passed into proverbial language.⁴⁵ Shakespeare uses biblical quotation throughout his career, and often (particularly in his comedies) the allusion functions simply as a brief joke. For example, Pistol’s description of Falstaff’s sexual appetite—‘He woos both high and low, both rich and poor, | Both young and old, one with another’ (The Merry Wives of Windsor, 2. 1. 92–93)—is much funnier when it is recognized that Falstaff’s indiscriminate lust is worded so as to recall the universality of the Psalmist’s message: ‘As wel lowe as high, riche and poore, one with another’ (Psalm 49: 2).⁴⁶ Yet even where the echo is meant to make the audience laugh it can have a deeper relation with the action of the play. In The Merchant of Venice the famous story of Jacob’s gulling of his blind father Isaac is recalled by the clowning in which Blind Old Gobbo is unable to recognize his son. Jacob’s trickery in imitating the hairiness of Esau is alluded to and inverted when Lancelot Gobbo, trying to help his father recognize him, has Old Gobbo pat his head. The blind father, however, thinking he is touching his child’s face, wonders whether he has been growing a beard lately (2. 2). It is a moment of enjoyable slapstick, but it also brings forward a biblical story which has profound relevance for the main plot. An impeccably Pauline understanding of the Jacob and Esau story saw it as an analogue of the transfer of God’s favour away from his firstborn (Esau or the Jews) to his younger children (Jacob or the Christians).⁴⁷ The apparently irrelevant comic fooling about hairy faces has an important and subtle connection with the relations between Jews and Christians in the main plot.⁴⁸ In the early modern period the Bible was a uniquely holy text, and the reverence with which it was treated, and the layers of interpretation which it was subjected to, meant that biblical language carried a ⁴⁵ See Carter, Shakespeare and Holy Scripture, 15; R. A. L. Burnet, ‘Shakespeare and the Marginalia of the Geneva Bible’, Notes & Queries, 26/2 (1979): 113–14; R. A. L. Burnet, ‘Some Echoes of the Genevan Bible in Shakespeare and Milton’, Notes & Queries, 27/2 (1980): 179–81; Roger Stritmatter, ‘The Influence of a Genevan Note from Romans 7:19 on Shakespeare’s Sonnet 151’, Notes & Queries, 44/4 (1997): 514–16; Roger Stritmatter, ‘By Providence Divine: Shakespeare’s Awareness of Some Genevan Marginal Notes of I Samuel’, Notes & Queries, 47/1 (2000): 97–100. ⁴⁶ James Sims, Dramatic Uses of Biblical Allusions in Marlowe and Shakespeare (Gainesville, Fla.: University of Florida Monographs, 1966), 32. ⁴⁷ See Romans 9; Thomas Sutton, Englands First and Second Summons (London: John Norton, 1633), 172–3. ⁴⁸ See Steven Marx, Shakespeare and the Bible (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), 120–4.
24
Drama and the Word
fund of powerful associations. This wider interpretative framework means that single biblical phrases often resonate beyond the immediate theatrical moment in Shakespeare’s dramaturgy. For example, Hamlet’s mention of Jephthah—‘O Jephthah, judge of Israel, what a treasure hadst thou!’ (2. 2. 403)—is clearly a condemnation of Polonius’s treatment of Ophelia.⁴⁹ However, the story was also read as a fiat against swearing, and James Black has argued that the allusion to Jephthah indicates that Hamlet is still subconsciously turning over his promise to his father’s ghost.⁵⁰ The connective habit of mind central to Hamlet’s character is illuminated by the fact that the example of parental cruelty with which he chooses to condemn Polonius was at the centre of contemporary arguments about the moral valency of swearing. Likewise, the brief echo of Psalm 137 in Mowbray’s lament of exile (Richard II, 1. 3. 154–7) harnesses the nationalistic fervour of the Psalm, and the allusion resonates with the play’s larger concerns with nationhood.⁵¹ In Macbeth the analogy between the main plot and the Old Testament story of Elisha and Hazael seems to shed light on what Susan Snyder calls ‘the mystifications of responsibility’ which are crucial to the play.⁵² The story (2 Kings 8: 7–15) shares with Macbeth the combination of riddling prophecy and regicide, and the biblical analogue supports a reading of Shakespeare’s tragedy in which the protagonist is in thrall to his own susceptibility to evil rather than the power of external agencies. It is also generally recognized that the biblical allusions in King Lear have a profound relation to the central concerns of the play. Numerous critics have argued that King Lear is comparable in its grandeur of conception ⁴⁹ For more on Jephthah in Renaissance drama, see Hamlet, ed. Harold Jenkins, The Arden Shakespeare (London: Routledge, 1993), 475–7; Debora Kuller Shuger, The Renaissance Bible: Scholarship, Sacrifice and Subjectivity (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994), 134–60. ⁵⁰ James Black, ‘Hamlet’s Vows’, Renaissance and Reformation 2/1 (1978): 40–1; James Black, Edified by the Margent: Shakespeare and the Bible: An Inaugural Professorial Lecture in the Faculty of Humanities, University of Calgary (Calgary: Faculty of Humanities, 1979), 11–12. ⁵¹ Hannibal Hamlin, ‘Psalm Culture in the English Renaissance: Readings of Psalm 137 by Shakespeare, Spenser, Milton and Others’, Renaissance Quarterly 55 (2002): 246–7. The nationalistic agenda of the Psalm was also recognized by John Awdely in his jingoistic ballad against ‘all Traytours, Rebels, and papisticall enemies’ which stipulated ‘syng this after the tune of the cxxxvij Psalme’: Claude M. Simpson, The British Broadside Ballad and its Music (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1966), 585. ⁵² Susan Snyder, ‘Theology as Tragedy in Macbeth’, Christianity and Literature 43/3–4 (1994): 289–300.
Drama and the Word
25
and execution, and its treatment of suffering and doubt, with the Book of Job.⁵³ The currency and status of the Bible made it a uniquely powerful source, and a brief allusion to a biblical story could open up a fund of associations, ambiguities, and analogues. The biblical plays of the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries are evidence that religious theatre remained popular with audiences who knew the Bible and could be expected to connect their knowledge with what they saw on the stage. Censorship, however, curtailed the overt expression of biblical stories and language and forced playwrights to approach this popular subject in subtler and more complex ways. This sublimation of the Bible reached its zenith in Shakespeare, who harnesses the power of biblical language and Christian stories and uses them metonymically to express, echo, and comment upon central themes, ideas, and emotions within the plays. ⁵³ See e.g. Harold Bloom, Ruin the Sacred Truths: Poetry and Belief from the Bible to the Present (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1989), 19; Robert Pack, The Long View: Essays on the Discipline of Hope and Poetic Craft (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1991), 251–76; Jan Kott, Shakespeare Our Contemporary, trans. Boleslaw Taborski (Bristol: Methuen, 1965/1986), 100–33; Peter Milward, Biblical Influences in Shakespeare’s Great Tragedies (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1987), 156–7, 163, 167, 173–4, 177–80, 185, 187, 189, 191, 197; Kenneth Muir, King Lear: Critical Essays (London: Garland, 1984), 289–90; Marx, Shakespeare and the Bible, 59–78. In this particular case there is also an intriguing connection in form, for Job was approached by some sixteenth-century exegetes as a tragedy: see Theodore de B`eze, Iob expounded by Theodore Beza, partly in manner of a Commentary, partly in manner of a Paraphrase (London, 1589), A7r , A8r .
2 Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic: The Mystery Plays and Catholicism In the Elizabethan period Protestants and Catholics alike believed that the old faith persisted because people clung to the faith of their fathers. Protestants chose to satirize this behaviour as analogous to Jews who had refused to recognize the Messiah because he embodied a break with their past. Hugh Latimer argued that Jews ‘would folowe theyr forefathers (as our papistes are wonte to say)’ and over fifty years later Thomas Aylesbury likewise suggested that a Jew was ‘somewhat popish loath to leaue the tradition of his fathers’.¹ This was not simply the belief of Protestant polemicists, but of Catholics too. Cecily Stonor, rebuked by judges for her recusancy in Oxford in 1581, believed that by remaining true to the Catholic church she was keeping faith with the religion of her upbringing: ‘I was born in such a time when Holy Mass was in great reverence, and brought up in the same Faith … I hold me still to that wherein I was born and bred’.² The 1576 proceedings of the Lord Mayor’s Court in York, which record the explanations recusants gave for their behaviour, repeatedly testify to the desire to remain, as Gregory Wilkinson expressed it, ‘in the faith that he was baptized in’. Isabel Porter declared that ‘she cometh not to the church because her conscience will not serve her, for things are not in the church as it hath been aforetime in her forefathers’ days’.³ In the twentieth century a number of historians were unwilling to believe that pre-Reformation Catholicism could be so persistent. ¹ Hugh Latimer, Certayn Godly Sermons […] (London, 1562), Sv ; Thomas Aylesbury, The Passion Sermon at Pauls-Crosse; Upon Good-Friday Last, Aprill 7.1626 (London, 1626), 13. ² Henry Clifford, The Life of Jane Dormer, Duchess of Feria (London: Burns & Oates, 1887), 38–9. ³ John Morris, The Troubles of Our Catholic Forefathers: Related by Themselves (Roehampton: James Stanley, 1872–7), iii. 249–50.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
27
A. G. Dickens formulated an influential distinction between residual Catholicism and that inspired by the Counter-Reformation, arguing that the conservative attachment to the old faith soon declined to be replaced by the dynamic Catholicism of the Jesuits and seminary priests: ‘Between survivalism and seminarism little or no connection existed; arduous proselytism, not the weight of tradition, accounted for the romanist revival’.⁴ However, the re-evalution of the strength of medieval Christianity has led likewise to a reappraisal of the continuity between pre- and post-Reformation Catholicism, and to a recognition of the accuracy of the contemporary understanding: ‘Separated English Catholicism was no novel creation of Continental missionaries, but a logical extension of its immemorial and Marian heritage: the recusant community which emerged into view a generation after the reign began neither wholly displaced nor was sharply distinct from the confused and uncoordinated collection of conservatives that was its predecessor’.⁵ The reassessment of Catholic belief in Elizabethan England has rightly stressed the importance of residual Catholicism, a Catholicism born out of affection for the church of people’s childhood—the faith of their fathers—which was strengthened, rather than created, by the missionary priests who arrived in the last quarter of the century. A certain amount of recent research has suggested that Shakespeare might be one of those who ‘somewhat popish’ was ‘loath to leaue the tradition of his fathers’. The evidence for Shakespeare’s actual father’s Catholicism has been eagerly championed by critics anxious to prove his son’s adherence to the old faith. There are two main pieces of evidence for John Shakespeare’s religious beliefs, the first being that he was cited for recusancy, 25 September 1592. Appearance on a recusancy register proved that the offender was not a regular churchgoer, but did not prove that the reason for this non-attendance was religious ⁴ A. G. Dickens, ‘The First Stages of Romanist Recusancy in Yorkshire, 1560–1590’, The Yorkshire Archeaological Journal 35 (1941): 181. See also John Bossy, The English Catholic Community 1570–1850 (London: Darton, Longman & Todd, 1975), 4, 106–7, 147–8; J. C. H. Aveling, The Handle and the Axe: The Catholic Recusants in England from Reformation to Emancipation (London: Blond & Briggs, 1976), 19, 49–50, 52, 60–1. ⁵ Walsham, Church Papists, 95. See also Eamon Duffy, The Stripping of the Altars: Traditional Religion in England c.1400—c.1580 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992); Christopher Haigh, ‘The Continuity of Catholicism in the English Reformation’, in Haigh, ed., The English Reformation Revised (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 176–208; Christopher Haigh, English Reformations: Religion, Politics, and Society under the Tudors (Oxford: Clarendon, 1993), 251–67: J. J. Scarisbrick, The Reformation and the English People (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1984), 136–61.
28
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
non-conformity.⁶ In John Shakespeare’s case the commissioners seem to have accepted an alternative explanation. Beside the list containing his name has been written ‘it is sayd that these laste nine, coom not to Churche for feare of processe for Debtte’. John Shakespeare’s financial difficulties during the late 1570s are well documented: he sold off land, was exempted from payments to the council on which he served, and was unable to settle debts.⁷ The second piece of evidence which is used to support the belief that John Shakespeare’s recusancy was caused, or exacerbated, by doctrinal differences with the established church, is a document discovered in 1757 known as the Spiritual Last Will and Testament of John Shakespeare. If genuine, this would indeed prove that Shakespeare’s father, at least, ‘died a papist’ but there are a number of question marks surrounding it. When the document was shown to Malone he had immediate doubts about the handwriting, and after accepting it as genuine changed his mind and finally repudiated it. It has since disappeared so cannot be subjected to modern analysis.⁸ John Shakespeare conformed to the Church of England (his children were baptized in the parish church) but he may nonetheless have been some form of church papist. The primary relevance to Shakespeare studies of the new emphasis on Catholic continuity in Elizabethan England, however, lies not in its specific legacy to the playwright, but in its general legacy to his generation. The renewed realization that there was an organic continuity between medieval Christianity and the sixteenth-century Catholic community has brought forward an understanding that it was not only those who became recusants who retained an affection for the old ways. Elizabethan religious policy, by concerning itself with church attendance rather than the reception of the sacrament, was specifically formulated to enable and encourage those who preferred the old faith not to cut themselves off from their parish church. This successful fostering of conformity, rather than theological assent, renders ‘almost invisible an indeterminate number ⁶ However, recusancy often ran in families and the appearance of John Shakespeare’s granddaughter, Susanna, on a recusancy list (6 May 1606) makes the case for Catholicism in Shakespeare’s family highly plausible: Schoenbaum, William Shakespeare, 234–5. ⁷ Schoenbaum, William Shakespeare, 36–9. Some critics, however, have felt that debt is an insufficient explanation for John Shakespeare’s withdrawal from public life at this point, and suggest that it may have been a convenient excuse when he was charged with Catholicism: Patrick Collinson, Elizabethan Essays (London: Hambledon, 1994), 250. ⁸ Ibid. 41–6. Its probable inauthenticity has recently been established by Robert Bearman, ‘John Shakespeare’s ‘‘Spiritual Testament’’: A Reappraisal’, Shakespeare Survey 56 (2003), 184–202.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
29
of silent sympathisers of the Old Faith, whose Catholicism was above all an attitude not an act’.⁹ This new historical perspective opens up a less sectarian understanding of the Catholic nuances in Shakespeare’s plays. The acknowledgement that there may be references to ‘creeping the cross’ in Troilus and Cressida, the Exultet in The Merchant of Venice, the sprinkling of holy water in A Midsummer Night’s Dream, or the cloistered life in Twelfth Night need not involve us in the speculation that Shakespeare spent his youth in a recusant community in Lancashire or even, as Richard Wilson has suggested, that he considered training as missionary priest.¹⁰ They may be evidence of nothing more striking than that Shakespeare, in common with much of his audience, retained an affection for the old ways. Shakespeare’s plays are full of Catholic references but their subordination to the passion of his heroines makes it difficult to read them as conclusive evidence for his own piety. Peter Milward, for example, argues that the Angelus, which was recited at morning, noon and night, is recalled when Imogen desires Posthumus: ‘At the sixth hour of morn, at noon, at midnight, | To encounter me with orisons, for then | I am in heaven for him’(1. 3. 32–4).¹¹ The slippage that matters here is not so much that the timing is wrong (the Angelus was said at 6 p.m. not midnight) or that this is not, as Milward claims, a parting message (rather a message that is never imparted (1. 3. 26–7) ), but that Imogen is not thinking about the Virgin, but about Posthumus. Through her prayers she hopes to encounter not Mary or God, but her beloved, whom she is ‘in heaven for’. Likewise, it has been argued that Rosalind’s description of Orlando’s kiss as ‘as full of sanctity as the touch of holy bread’ (As You Like It, 3. 4. 12–13), would have been ‘inconceivable to anyone with a Protestant upbringing’.¹² Nonetheless Shakespeare, as with the example from Cymbeline, is subjecting specifically Catholic practices (if ⁹ Walsham, Church Papists, 91; see also 11–12. ¹⁰ Milward, Shakespeare’s Religious Background, 26; Gary R. Grund, ‘The Fortunate Fall and Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice’, Studia Neophilologica 55 (1983): 154; Wilson, Secret Shakespeare, 146–7; Anne Lecercle, ‘Country House, Catholicity and the Crypt(ic) in Twelfth Night’, in Richard Dutton, Alison Findlay, and Richard Wilson, eds., Region, Religion and Patronage: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003), 84–100. For the evidence that creeping the cross lived on in folk memory, see Ronald Hutton, ‘The English Reformation and the Evidence of Folklore’, Past and Present 148 (1995): 108–9. For the Lancashire hypothesis, see Honigmann, Shakespeare: The ‘Lost Years’. For the Douai hypothesis see Wilson, ‘Shakespeare and the Jesuits’. ¹¹ Milward, Shakespeare’s Religious Background, 26. ¹² F. W. Brownlow, ‘John Shakespeare’s Recusancy: New Light on an Old Document’, Shakespeare Quarterly 40 (1989): 190. In one of the most delightful pieces of
30
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
‘holy bread’ is a reference to blessed bread rather than the eucharist) to an almost blasphemous pressure through the comparison.¹³ Richard Wilson describes Portia as one ‘who is accustomed to ‘‘stray about | By holy crosses, where she kneels and prays’’ for hours, accompanied by ‘‘None but a holy hermit and her maid’’ (5. 1. 30–4)’.¹⁴ But to search for the relevance of such images in the biography of the playwright, rather than their action within the play, is to blunt their subtlety. Wilson has softened the sharp edges of Portia’s piety, glossing over the fact that this picture is a fiction created to conceal Portia’s disguise as Balthasar. Portia has not been praying at wayside crosses ‘for happy wedlock hours’; she has not entrusted her nuptial bliss to God but has secured it through her own skill by winning the freedom of her husband’s friend and thus has ensured that Bassanio’s affection can centre exclusively on herself. Shakespeare subordinates Catholic imagery to the vagaries of his plots. In this he is comparable to many other 1590s writers of romantic poetry who used Catholic tropes freely, not with reverence, but with the knowledge that they were relics of a discarded religion. Helen Hackett argues that the 1590s saw a secularized Catholic revival, an occurrence which Greenblatt attributes to ‘the fifty year effect’: a time in the wake of the ideological struggle in which the revolutionary generation are dying out and the survivors look back with a certain longing to the world that has been lost. Enough time has elapsed for Catholic terms to feel safe and have both a nostalgic appeal for the older generation, and novelty value for the younger.¹⁵ Hackett argues that Catholic tropes survived in both popular and literary culture as images with a colour and vibrancy which outlived their religious significance. She concludes that for the Protestant sonneteer Barnaby Barnes, for example, Catholic imagery enabled him to ‘[have] it all ways: creating that frisson effect of rubbing up religion—and forbidden religion at that—against sex, Shakespearean censorship, Warburton changed the phrase ‘holy bread’ to ‘holy beard’ and glossed its meaning as ‘the kiss of charity from hermits and holy men’: The Works of William Shakespeare, in Eight volumes (Edinburgh, 1795), ii. 60. ¹³ See Michael Davis, ‘‘The Transubstantial Bard: Shakespeare and Catholicism’, in Douglas Burnham and Enrico Giaccherini, eds., The Poetics of Transubstantiation: From Theology to Metaphor, Studies in European Cultural Transition (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2005), 39–40. ¹⁴ Wilson, Secret Shakespeare, 254. ¹⁵ Helen Hackett, Virgin Mother, Maiden Queen: Elizabeth I and the Cult of the Virgin Mary (London: Macmillan, 1995), 161; Greenblatt, Hamlet in Purgatory, 248–9.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
31
while not doing anything that was theologically improper in a Protestant state’.¹⁶ To some extent the religious language in Shakespeare’s plays does have a different tenor than that of Barnes’s Parthenophil and Parthenophe, Spenser’s Amoretti, or Donne’s ‘Songs and Sonnets’. There is a breadth of reference that goes far beyond the conventional images of saints, shrines, pilgrimages, and incense, and an engagement which suggests that, in the plays at least, he is not using the references either as deconsecrated tropes nor to generate the outrageous and exciting frisson of the forbidden. There is something almost ordinary and accepted: the references are part of the furniture of the plays and belong there in a way that they do not in Barnes, Donne, or even his own sonnets. The difference is partly due to the genre—many of Shakespeare’s plays are set in the past and for the characters within them prayers to the Virgin, requiem masses, and Easter observances are simply part of their world. Juliet’s evening mass and the chantry chapels of Illyria are treated with neither reverence nor disdain, but as the props of a story: useful, colourful, and evocative of a different time and place. There is circumstantial evidence for church papistry in Shakespeare’s upbringing but no secure foundation for proving what he himself believed. The only external evidence that Shakespeare did not conform to the established church is that there is no record of his name in the communion token books of St Saviour’s Southwark. Patrick Collinson and Eamon Duffy have cited this as evidence that he did not receive and therefore may have been a church papist.¹⁷ However, Jeremy Boulton, the authority on St Saviour’s communion tokens, states that only the name of the head of a household would have been recorded in a communion token book, and therefore had Shakespeare been lodging in Southwark, his name would not have been recorded whether he received or not.¹⁸ There is, therefore, no substantive evidence that Shakespeare did not communicate while he was in London. Shakespeare’s faith is not provable and a certain equivocation often lies in attempts to suggest that it is. The riddling argumentative ¹⁶ Helen Hackett, ‘The Art of Blasphemy? Interfusions of the Erotic and Sacred in the Poetry of Donne, Barnes, and Constable’ (forthcoming). My grateful thanks to Helen Hackett for sending me a copy of this paper. ¹⁷ Collinson, Elizabethan Essays, 251; Duffy, ‘Was Shakespeare a Catholic?’, 537. ¹⁸ Jeremy Boulton clarified this in personal communication with me, August 2003. My grateful thanks to him. See also Boulton, ‘The Limits of Formal Religion’, 130–54.
32
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
structure of Richard Wilson’s Secret Shakespeare, for example, includes dubious assertions such as ‘until 1558 Catholicism had, after all, been the official state religion’ and that ‘the text [of Henry VIII ] seems to call attention to the fact that … Cardinal Wolsey’s hat was now worn by his impersonator’.¹⁹ Mutschmann and Wenterdorf ’s attempts to prove Shakespeare’s Catholicism lead them to the questionable assertion that ‘the cardinal in Shakespeare’s King John is in no sense an unworthy figure’.²⁰ Eric Sams’s similar quest likewise provokes the disingenuous description of John Shakespeare’s Last Will and Testament as a document ‘once in the possession of Edmund Malone and published by him as genuine. There is no reason to doubt its authenticity.’²¹ It is important to read the religious engagement of Shakespeare’s plays and his exploitation of the theatrical and poetic potential of the old religion in a wider way than simply as evidence of his own doctrinal affiliation. The work of historians such as Christopher Haigh, Alexandra Walsham, J. J. Scarisbrick, and Eamon Duffy has shown the pervasiveness of unanalysed Catholic habits of mind in conforming Elizabethans, not simply among recusants. There is an elegiac nostalgia in many of Shakespeare’s plays which interacts with the residual Catholicism present in Elizabethan England as a whole. As Duffy has expressed it ‘the sensibility which evoked in sonnet 73, ‘‘Bare ruin’d choirs, where late the sweet birds sang’’, was certainly receptive to the beauty of the old faith, alert to the tragedy and loss involved in Reformation’. As Duffy himself has shown, however, such sensitivity was not confined to Catholics.²² Marotti has well expressed the nonsatiric engagement with magical experience in Shakespeare’s mature plays, and suggested that: ‘In one sense Shakespeare (like many conservative Protestants) might have been trying to salvage for a post-Catholic English culture some of those emotionally powerful features of medieval ¹⁹ Wilson, Secret Shakespeare, 6, 262; italics mine. For the evidence that Shakespeare’s Wolsey was not, in fact, wearing the real thing see John Lee, ‘The Man Who Mistook His Hat: Stephen Greenblatt and the Anecdote’, Essays in Criticism 45 (1995): 285–300. ²⁰ Mutschmann and Wentersdorf, Shakespeare and Catholicism, 301. Burton Raffel goes so far as to call him ‘virtuous’: ‘Shakespeare and the Catholic Question’, Religion & Literature 30/1 (1998): 47. ²¹ Sams, The Real Shakespeare, 32. ²² Duffy, ‘Was Shakespeare a Catholic?, 538; Eamon Duffy, ‘Bare Ruined Choirs: Remembering Catholicism in Shakespeare’s England’, in Richard Dutton, Alison Findlay, and Richard Wilson, eds., Theatre and Religion: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003), 42–3, 52–3. See also William Empson, Seven Types of Ambiguity (London: Penguin, 1995), 21.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
33
Catholicism … participating in a rehabilitation of magic and the visual that is elaborated in the Stuart Court masque.’²³ Shakespeare’s evocation of England’s abandoned cultural heritage—church furniture, paintings, liturgy, and the mystery plays—was available to the playwright and his audience whether they, or he, were convinced Catholics, lapsed church papists, or simply Protestants with retentive memories and developed aesthetic sensibilities. Much recent historical research has in fact centred precisely on the way in which aspects of Catholicism were assimilated rather than destroyed during the English Reformation. Tessa Watt, David Cressy, Ronald Hutton, and Alexandra Walsham have shown that many popular forms—such as ballads, wall hangings, and the festal calendar—concentrated on consensual values and created a synthesis, rather than a confrontation, between Bible-centred Protestantism and traditional visual piety.²⁴ These historians focus upon the cheap print and seasonal celebrations that were intended to entertain and engage the laity during their leisure time. It is possible that in the theatre likewise evidence may be found of an assimilation of Catholic practice which is neither the coded proof of papist playwrights, nor evidence of a charisma that has been entirely devalued in its transfer to a secular sphere. It is, in fact, as theatre that Catholic devotional practices proved most persistent in the Elizabethan period. The mystery plays were one of the few aspects of medieval worship which survived the Reformation, initially at least, relatively unscathed. Plays focusing entirely on Marian doctrine were abandoned, and nervous justifications were added to nonscriptural episodes such as the harrowing of hell, but throughout the country these large-scale civic productions of salvation history focusing on the life and Passion of Christ were performed well into the Elizabethan period. The plays are also often preserved in strikingly late manuscripts. Recent research has suggested that the Towneley manuscript was copied during Mary’s reign and all six surviving manuscripts of the complete ²³ Arthur F. Marotti, ‘Shakespeare and Catholicism’, in Richard Dutton, Alison Findlay, and Richard Wilson, eds., Theatre and Religion: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003), 230, 232. See also Greenblatt, Will in the World, 112–13. ²⁴ See David Cressy, Bonfires and Bells: National Memory and the Protestant Calendar in Elizabethan and Stuart England (London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1989); Watt, Cheap Print, 324–8 and passim; Hutton, ‘The English Reformation’, 89–116; Alexandra Walsham, Providence in Early Modern England (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999), 3–5 and passim.
34
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
Chester cycle were copied after 1590.²⁵ A number of critics have argued that these plays are not merely anachronistic texts that happen to survive into the sixteenth century but an integral part of late medieval and early modern religious life. Lawrence Clopper has suggested, for example, that the medieval Chester play was predominantly a Passion play, and the content, shape, and techniques of production which we associate with the Chester cycle are in fact a sixteenth-century phenomenon.²⁶ Throughout the country mystery plays survived into Elizabeth’s reign, the first decade of which saw Corpus Christi pageants acted in at least Newcastle, New Romney, Norwich, Worcester, Chelmsford, Malden, Braintree, Bungay, Chester, Coventry, York, Dublin, and Cornwall. Lincoln’s Corpus Christi plays, which had been revived under Mary, were replaced by a play about Tobias, which reused the ‘gear’ of the old plays.²⁷ The York pageants were not suppressed until 1569, and in 1579 the ‘house books’ record the city’s decision ‘that Corpus Christi play shalbe played this yere’ but Archbishop Grindal seems to have impounded the play text that was sent to him for approval.²⁸ Chester’s final performance is not until 1575. The pageants at Durham and Doncaster were acted until 1576 and Tewkesbury accounts mention payment for ‘six sheep-skins for Christ’s garments’ in 1578. Kendal, and probably Preston too, had cycles which lasted into James’s reign—perhaps until around 1605.²⁹ Religious drama was still popular in the provinces in the 1570s and 1580s and ²⁵ Barbara D. Palmer, ‘Recycling ‘‘The Wakefield Cycle’’: The Records’, Research Opportunities in Renaissance Drama 41 (2000): 96; David Mills, ‘The Chester Cycle’, in Richard Beadle, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Theatre (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 110; Peter Happé, Cyclic Form and the English Mystery Plays: A Comparative Study of the English Biblical Cycles and Their Continental and Iconographic Counterparts (Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2004), 240. ²⁶ Gail McMurray Gibson, The Theatre of Devotion: East Anglian Drama and Society in the Late Middle Ages (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1989), 2; Lawrence M. Clopper, ‘The History and Development of the Chester Cycle’, Modern Philology 75 (1978): 231; Lawrence M. Clopper, ‘English Drama: From Ungodly Ludi to Sacred Play’, in David Wallace, ed., The Cambridge History of Medieval English Literature (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999), 750–1. ²⁷ Other Corpus Christi pageants known to have survived the Reformation include Aberdeen, Beverley, Canterbury, Hereford, Kingston-on-Thames, Louth, Manningtree, Morebath, Reading, and Tewkesbury: E. K. Chambers, Mediaeval Stage (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1903/63), ii. 329–406. ²⁸ Alexandra F. Johnston and Margaret Rogerson, eds., York, Records of Early English Drama (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1979), 355–6, 390. ²⁹ Chambers, Mediaeval Stage, ii. 396; Audrey Douglas and Peter Greenfield, eds., Cumberland Westmorland Gloucestershire, Records of Early English Drama (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1986), 17–19.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
35
the post-Reformation genesis of a Corpus Christi play at Sherborne, in Dorset, shows that the form was not simply dying slowly, but was sufficiently vibrant to spring up in new places.³⁰ There is also the aforementioned case of Thomas Ashton’s 1560 Passion play and Shrewsbury school’s other performances of religious subjects. In 1567–8 the records state that tradespeople were willing to give financial support to this ‘greate playe’, a civic sponsorship which suggests interesting correlations with the cycle drama.³¹ When, however, by the mid-Jacobean period, the cycle plays were entirely suppressed, their memory lived on. John Shaw’s record of an old man whom he catechized during the Civil War, unwittingly reveals the dramatic power of the mystery plays: I asked him, How many Gods there were? he said, he knew not: I informing him, asked him again: how he tho’t to be saved? he answered, he could not tell yet tho’t that was a hard question than the other, I told him yat the way to Salvation was by Iesus Christ God-man, who as he was man shed his blood for us on the crosse etc Oh, Sir (said he) I think I heard of that man you speake of, once in a play at Kendall, called Corpus-Christi play, where there was a man on a tree, & blood ran downe.³²
In 1644 the memory of a play suppressed in 1605 is still vivid, and the visual power of red, streaming blood is present to the old man in a more tangible way than the preacher’s commonplace formulation of salvation through the blood of Christ. The memory of the mysteries was retained by educated, Protestant men as well, such as the Lancashireborn John Weever (1576–1632). Weever’s Ancient Funeral Monuments (1631) is caught between the author’s Protestantism (one chapter extols the abolition of the pope’s ‘exorbitant authoritie’) and his instinctive desire to preserve and value the past. Recording the tomb inscription of Richard Marlow, he explains: This Marlow was Lord Maior in the yeare 1409. in whose Maioralitie there was a play at Skinners Hall, which lasted eight dayes (saith Stow) to heare which, most the greatest Estates of England were present. The Subiect of the play was the sacred Scriptures, from the creation of the world: They call this, Corpus ³⁰ Peter Greenfield, ‘Regional Performance in Shakespeare’s Time’, in Alison Findlay, Richard Wilson, and Richard Dutton, eds., Region, Religion and Patronage: Lancastrian Shakespeare (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003), 245 and passim. ³¹ Collinson, ‘The Shearman’s Tree’, 218. ³² Douglas, Cumberland Westmorland Gloucestershire, 219. See also Helen Cooper, ‘Blood Running Down’, London Review of Books 23/15 (2001): 13–14.
36
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
Christi Play in my countrey, which I haue seene acted at Preston, and Lancaster, and last of all at Kendall, in the beginning of the raigne of King Iames.³³
If people alive in the 1630s and 1640s were eyewitnesses of the Corpus Christi plays (in Weever’s case, three of them) it seems at least plausible that many Londoners would have known them a generation earlier. Mystery plays, as Weever testifies, had been performed in London before the Reformation and Henry Machyn’s diary for 1557 records a Marian Passion play, ‘the vij day of Juin. begane a stage play at the Grey freers of the Passyon of Cryst’. According to Prynne a Passion play was also performed in London in the early seventeenth century, at which ‘there were thousands present’.³⁴ More importantly, perhaps, London was the focus of internal migration in England, and despite its high number of deaths and low birth rate the population of London grew from 60,000 in the beginning of the sixteenth century to 575,000 by the end of the seventeenth. The levels of migration to London in this period, much of it from northern England, means that many of those going to see Shakespeare’s plays would have had their theatrical expectations shaped by provincial religious drama.³⁵ Shakespeare, an immigrant from rural Warwickshire, is one specific example of someone who may have taken with him to London the memory of mystery plays performed in his home county.³⁶ Only fourteen miles from Stratford-upon-Avon was staged the most famous and popular mystery cycle in Tudor England: the Coventry cycle. This cycle remained an important annual event until 1579; its demise signalled by the single sentence in the City Annals, April 1580: ‘and ³³ John Weever, Ancient Fvnerall Monvments […] (London, 1631), Mm5r . ³⁴ Diary of Henry Machyn, 138; Chambers, Mediaeval Stage, ii. 379–82; Miri Rubin, Corpus Christi: The Eucharist in Late Medieval Culture (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991), 229–32, 275–82. ³⁵ C. G. A. Clay, Economic Expansion and Social Change: England 1500–1700 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984), i. 27, 197, 210; E. A. Wrigley and R. S. Schofield, The Population Histories of England 1541–1871: A Reconstruction (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989), 166, 467. Helen Cooper has argued that the ‘dominant living theatrical experience’ for the audience of the 1590s was the cycle plays: ‘Shakespeare and the Mystery Plays’, in Stuart Gillespie and Neil Rhodes, eds., Shakespeare and Elizabethan Popular Culture, Arden Shakespeare (London: Thomson Learning, 2006), 24. My grateful thanks to Helen Cooper for giving me a copy of this piece at an earlier stage. ³⁶ Another early-modern dramatist, Thomas Heywood, seems also to have been aware of the mystery plays and his Apology for Actors stated that pageants were still flourishing among Catholics and in the north: Thomas Heywood, An Apology for Actors (London, 1612), E4r , G3r .
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
37
this yeare the padgins were layd downe’.³⁷ The excitement generated by cycle plays, even in the Elizabethan era, is demonstrated by the distances people were willing to travel to see them, such as the Shropshire man who went to Chester in 1577 because ‘he heard of the plays [t]here’.³⁸ It seems highly likely, therefore, that a young man interested in theatre would have travelled the short road between Stratford and Coventry to see the most famous dramatic presentation of his day, and Shakespeare could have seen the Coventry cycle at any time up to his fifteenth year. The Coventry cycle’s popularity in the Tudor period is attested by the number of contemporary references to it. The earliest is the jestbook account of an unlearned Warwickshire village priest who preached on the articles of the Creed, and told his congregation: ‘yf you beleue not me, then for a more suerte & suffycyent auctoryte, go your way to couentre, and there ye shall se them all played in corpus cristi playe’.³⁹ John Heywood’s The Foure PP (1547), although it was not written for a Coventry audience, nonetheless chooses the Coventry Harrowing of Hell play to make a joke about a devil acting in a play. The character who goes down to hell recognizes the porter as ‘oft in the play of Corpus Cristi | He had played the deuyll at Couentry’.⁴⁰ It is also a Coventry weaver, John Careless, who, according to Foxe, is released from his imprisonment in 1556 ‘to play in the Pageant about the City’.⁴¹ As ³⁷ R. W. Ingram, ed., Coventry, Records of Early English Drama (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1981), 294; Lawrence M. Clopper, Drama, Play, and Game: English Festive Culture in the Medieval and Early Modern Period (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2001), 282, 293. ³⁸ A. L. Beier, Masterless Men: The Vagrancy Problem in England 1560–1640 (London: Methuen, 1987), 75. ³⁹ Leonard R. N. Ashley, ed., Shakespeare’s Jest book: An edition of A Hundred Mery Talys (1526) edited in 1866 by Hermann Oesterley: A Facsimile Reproduction (Gainesville, Fla.: Scholars’ Facsimiles & Reprints, 1970), 100. It has been inferred from this that Coventry was a Creed play: Alexandra F. Johnston, ‘What if No Texts Survived? External Evidence for Early English Drama’, in Marianne G. Briscoe and John C. Coldewey, eds., Contexts for Early English Drama (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1989), 11; Margaret Rogerson, ‘The Coventry Corpus Christi Play: A ‘‘Lost’’ Middle English Creed Play?’, Research Opportunities in Renaissance Drama 36 (1999): 143–78. Despite being an interesting possibility, this seems an over-literal interpretation of the jest as any mystery cycle performs the Christian story and therefore would ‘verify’ the creed. Also the extant pageants from the Coventry cycle dramatize events—such as the Presentation at the Temple, the slaughter of the innocents, and Isaiah’s prophecies—that are not in the creed. ⁴⁰ John Heywood, The Foure PP, in Specimens of the Pre-Shakespearean Drama, ed. John Matthews Manly (New York: Biblo & Tannen, 1967), 509–10. ⁴¹ This is a particularly interesting anecdote as it is an example of Protestantism’s initial enthusiasm for biblical theatre and the non-sectarian attitude towards the mystery
38
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
late as 1656 Sir William Dugdale reported that ‘I have been told by some old people, who in their younger years were eye-witnesses of these Pageants so acted, that the yearly confluence of people to see the shew was extraordinary great, and yeilded no small advantage to this City’.⁴² Unfortunately for the study of the possible influence of this famous theatrical event on Shakespeare, almost all the Coventry cycle has been lost. Only two plays survive: the Shearmen and Taylors’ Nativity pageant, and the Weavers’ pageant, which is about Christ’s childhood—his Presentation and his discussion with the doctors in the Temple. The records also give evidence for the staging of the Passion by the Smiths, the Harrowing of Hell and Resurrection by the Cappers, and a Doomsday play by the Drapers. There is also some evidence that the Deposition was performed by the Pinners and Needlers, and the Assumption by the Mercers. Traditionally it has been thought that there were ten pageants performed in total, and it has been assumed that the pageants which are unaccounted for enacted the Old Testament subjects and Jesus’ ministry, hence creating a cycle similar in scope to those in York, Chester, Beverley, and Cornwall.⁴³ This has been questioned recently by Margaret Rogerson, who has suggested that the two pageants may be relics of a creed play rather than a scriptural sequence, and by Lawrence Clopper, who conjectures that Coventry’s cycle may have centred on the Passion.⁴⁴ Whatever the exact form the Coventry cycle took it is widely accepted that it is at least probable that Shakespeare caught the local expression of England’s rich heritage of civic religious drama.⁴⁵ Although the plays which enabled the Protestant weaver and the Catholic authorities to co-operate in ensuring the performance of the cycle: Foxe, Actes and Monuments, ii. 1920. ⁴² William Dugdale, The Antiquities of Warwickshire, illustrated from records, leigerbookes, manuscripts, charters, evidences, tombes and armes: beautifed with maps, prospects and portraitures (London, 1656), 116. On the importance of the cycle to Coventry see also Charles Phythian-Adams, ‘Ceremony and the Citizen: The Communal Year at Coventry 1450–1550’, in Peter Clark and Paul Slack, eds., Crisis and Order in English Towns 1500–1700: Essays in Urban History (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1972), 57–85. ⁴³ Hardin Craig, English Religious Drama of the Middle Ages (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1955), 286–92; Clifford Davidson, ‘Civic Drama for Corpus Christi at Coventry: Some Lost Plays’, in Alan E. Knight, ed., The Stage as Mirror: Civic Theatre in Late Medieval Europe (Cambridge: D. S. Brewer, 1997), 145. ⁴⁴ Rogerson, ‘The Coventry Corpus Christi Play’, 143–78; Clopper, Drama, Play, and Game, 173. ⁴⁵ Duffy, The Stripping of the Altars, 582; Collinson, Elizabethan Essays, 225. See also Clifford Davidson, ‘ ‘‘What hempen home-spuns have we swagg’ring here?’’ Amateur
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
39
cycle was suppressed in 1579, certain members of the community were still agitating for its revival in the 1590s. In 1591 Coventry’s council recorded that ‘it is also agreed by the whole consent of this house that the distrucion of Ierusalem the conquest of the Dans or the historie of KE the 4 … shalbe plaid on the pagens … & non other playes’. As Ingram notes, the codicil ‘& non other playes’ sounds as though the council still feels the need in the early 1590s to curb the idea that the mysteries might be revived.⁴⁶ The guilds were certainly tenacious in retaining their costumes and props. A 1591 inventory of the Coventry Cappers’ props includes ‘pylates dublit … the spirate of godes cote gods cotes and the hose pylats heade fyve maries heades … mary maudlyns gowne … gods head the spirites heade … pylates clubbe hell mowth … adams spade’.⁴⁷ This determined retention of the physical accoutrements of the Corpus Christi plays is an objective correlative to the mental tenacity of those who in the 1630s and 1640s still remembered the biblical drama of their youth, and it also bears comparison with the widespread refusal to destroy vestments, mass books, and chalices which likewise accompanied the Reformation. One pious optimist, for example, bequeathed gold candlesticks to the church in Edmonton, Middlesex, in 1570, ‘should mass ever be said there again’.⁴⁸ The mystery plays, like the mass, had been a powerful spectacle, and the memory of both remained in many early-modern minds. Emrys Jones has suggested that however enthusiastically Protestantism was embraced, inward mental habits and unanalysed assumptions which were part of the older order would have been unconsciously retained for many years. He has argued that when Shakespeare came to write plays of a historical or tragic kind, he had the Passion plays of his boyhood as a dramatic paradigm and that the two tetralogies form a secular cycle inspired by the Coventry performance of scriptural history.⁴⁹ The strongest evidence that Shakespeare saw, and remembered, Actors in A Midsummer Night’s Dream and the Coventry Civic Plays and Pageants’, Shakespeare Studies 19 (1987): 87–100. ⁴⁶ Ingram, Coventry, 332. Three songs were added to the Shearmen and Taylors’ pageant in 1591 presumably in expectation of a revival: Thomas Sharp, A Dissertation on the Pageants or Dramatic Mysteries Anciently performed at Coventry […] (Coventry, 1825), 113; Chambers, Mediaeval Stage, ii. 422. ⁴⁷ Ingram, Coventry, 334. ⁴⁸ Scarisbrick, The Reformation and the English People, 141. See also Haigh, English Reformations, 252–3. ⁴⁹ Emrys Jones, The Origins of Shakespeare (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1977), 33–4, 51.
40
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
the mysteries is that a number of the scenes and characters in his plays seem to echo those found in the cycle drama. Most conspicuously, his explicit references to biblical characters often seem to have been inspired by the dramatic spectacles of his youth rather than the Bible reading of his adulthood. The most famous example of this is Hamlet’s complaint—‘I would have such a fellow whipped for o’erdoing Termagant. It out-Herods Herod’ (3. 2. 13–14)—which, by connecting Herod with boisterous overacting, indicates that Shakespeare is thinking of a dramatic presentation of the biblical character. Likewise Falstaff ’s letter in The Merry Wives of Windsor causes Mistress Page to exclaim ‘what a Herod of Jewry is this!’ (2. 1. 19–21), because Falstaff ’s jigging verses, absurd boasts, and sartorial excesses recall the strutting, ranting Herod of the mystery plays.⁵⁰ Henry V ’s graphic description of the slaughter of the innocents (‘mad mothers with their howls confused | Do break the clouds, as did the wives of Jewry’ (3. 3. 122–3) ) likewise appears to derive less from Scripture, which refers only to the single voice of Rachel mourning for her children, than from the communal grief staged in the Coventry cycle: ‘who hard eyuer soche a cry | Of wemen that there chyldur haue lost’ (1. 870–1).⁵¹ There is one suggestive correspondence with the mystery plays which is a rare example of a possible verbal echo. Shakespeare makes two explicit references to Judas greeting Jesus at the moment of betrayal with an ‘All hail!’: Witness the loving kiss I give the fruit. He kisses the infant prince [Aside] To say the truth, so Judas kissed his master, And cried ‘All hail!’ whenas he meant all harm. (3 Henry VI 5. 7. 32–4) ⁵⁰ Diana Whaley, ‘Voices from the Past: A Note on Termagant and Herod’, in Tom Cain, Claire Lamont, and John Batchelor, eds., Shakespearean Continuities: Essays in Honour of E. A. J. Honigmann (London: Macmillan, 1997), 24–8; Michael O’Connell, ‘Vital Cultural Practices: Shakespeare and the Mysteries’, Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 29/1 (1999): 157–9; Jonathan Gil Harris, ‘ ‘‘Look not big, nor stamp, nor stare’’: Acting Up in The Taming of the Shrew, and the Coventry Herod Plays’, Comparative Drama 34/4 (2000–1): 375. ⁵¹ Harris, ‘ ‘‘Look not big, nor stamp, nor stare’’ ’, 376. For further examples of the influence of the Coventry cycle on Shakespeare, see Irvin Leigh Matus, ‘An Early Reference to the Coventry Mystery Plays in Shakespeare?’, Shakespeare Quarterly 40/2 (1989): 196–7; Cherrell Guilfoyle, Shakespeare’s Play within Play: Medieval Imagery and Scenic Form in Hamlet, Othello and King Lear (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 1990), 85–9; Naomi Conn Liebler, ‘Shakespeare’s Medieval Husbandry: Cain and Abel, Richard II, and Brudermond’, Mediaevalia 18 (1995): 452–6.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
41
Did they not sometime cry ‘All hail!’ to me? So Judas did to Christ. (Richard II 4. 1. 160–1)
This phrase does not originate with the Bible, for in all sixteenth-century versions Judas greets Jesus with a simple ‘Hail’. It has therefore been argued that the phrase comes instead from the mystery plays, for in the York Agony and Betrayal Judas greets Jesus with an ‘All hayll’ (28. 248). As the Coventry play of the betrayal is not extant it may well be that Shakespeare is remembering a similar ‘All hail’ from the geographically closer cycle.⁵² Shakespeare’s debt to the mystery cycles is, however, to a large extent unrecoverable at a verbal level. This is partly because most of the text of the Coventry cycle is lost. More fundamentally, however, it is because Shakespeare’s debt to the earlier drama does not lie at the level of text. Drama is an embodied art form, and at the centre of the mysteries is the Incarnation; the cycle plays acted out the enfleshment of the Godhead. This centrality of the body is something that Shakespearean drama shares.⁵³ The strongest evidence that Shakespeare was influenced by the mysteries is found not in the words of his characters but in his embodiment of concepts and the shaping of his scenes. Throughout his career Shakespeare’s scenes repeatedly recall mystery play staging and secular situations find an echo in sacred stories. Michael O’Connell argues that this is the specific legacy of medieval religious drama in Shakespeare: The pressure—moral, affective, and intellectual—of dozens of scenes both comic and tragic drawn from a history still considered sacred. It is this specific legacy that we need to know about more and that we need to ponder more attentively as we write and read about the blinding of Gloucester, the killing of Macduff ’s children, the jealousy of Leontes.⁵⁴ ⁵² Shaheen, Biblical References in Shakespeare’s Plays, 335–6. This expression is linked with Judas in many other texts of the period: Edmond Ironside; and Anthony Brewer’s The Love-Sicke King, ed. Martin Randall (London: Garland, 1991), 5. 1. 29–31; Samuel Rowlands, The Betraying of Christ (London, 1598), B4r , C4r ; A Letter written out of England to an English Gentleman remaining at Padua […] (London, 1599), B2r . Shakespeare, therefore, may simply be showing knowledge of a widely used phrase that had entered the language through the mystery plays. However, this, in itself, would be highly suggestive for a study of the effect of the cycle plays on Renaissance drama. ⁵³ See Pauline Kiernan, Shakespeare’s Theory of Drama (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996). ⁵⁴ Michael O’Connell, ‘God’s Body: Incarnation, Physical Embodiment, and the Fate of Biblical Theater in the Sixteenth Century’, in David G. Allen and Robert A. White,
42
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
The first (and one of the best) pieces of such criticism was Glynne Wickham’s argument for the influence on Macbeth of the mystery play staging of the harrowing of hell and the massacre of the innocents.⁵⁵ Wickham draws attention to some specific correspondences (such as the knocking on the gate, the allusion to a ‘devil porter’, and the arrival of a ghostly figure during a banquet) which connect Macbeth with the embodiment of evil in the earlier drama. While Macbeth is not reduced to a ‘type’ of Satan or Herod, his degeneracy is clearly signalled by the parallels. Correspondences have likewise been found in the Henry VI plays, and Emrys Jones has suggested that Humphrey’s fall in 2 Henry VI and the death of York in 3 Henry VI are both shaped by the mystery play staging of the Passion.⁵⁶ John D. Cox has extended Jones’s work and argued that York’s occupation of Henry’s throne at the beginning of 3 Henry VI is a dramaturgical and visual allusion to Lucifer’s occupation of God’s throne at the beginning of the mysteries.⁵⁷ The opening of King Lear may likewise recall an inverted Fall of Lucifer in which the angelic characters are cast out and the demonic characters given the throne.⁵⁸ In these plays it seems that Shakespeare is remembering the cycles’ powerful commencement which displays God’s omnipotence and justice. By giving King Lear and 3 Henry VI an opening scene in which the expected order is inverted, Shakespeare signals not only the individual ineptitude of the kings concerned, but indicates that this weakness will have repercussions for the whole kingdom. One of the most persuasive recent connections between Shakespeare’s dramaturgy and the mystery plays is the suggestion that Mary’s pregnancy is the model for Shakespeare’s inversion of the classic fabliau in which the cuckolded husband’s jealousy is well founded. Throughout Shakespeare (for example, in The Merry Wives of Windsor, Much Ado about Nothing, Othello, Cymbeline, and The Winter’s Tale) husbands’ apprehensions about their wives’ chastity proves to be mistaken. Shakespeare may have found a powerful dramatic antecedent for this eds., Subjects on the World’s Stage: Essays on British Literature of the Middle Ages and the Renaissance (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1995), 81–2. ⁵⁵ Glynne Wickham, Shakespeare’s Dramatic Heritage: Collected Studies in Mediaeval, Tudor and Shakespearean Drama (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1969), 214–31. ⁵⁶ Jones, Origins, 38–52. ⁵⁷ John D. Cox, Shakespeare and the Dramaturgy of Power (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989), 82–103. ⁵⁸ Guilfoyle, Shakespeare’s Play within a Play, 113.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
43
reversal in the mystery play dramatization of Joseph’s doubts about Mary’s fidelity—as occur, for example, in the N-town play Joseph’s Doubt. The sanctity of Shakespeare’s portrayal of many of these injured women (such as Desdemona and Imogen) lends weight to the correspondence, and the visual impact of Hermione’s heavily pregnant body would have made the connection especially close in her case.⁵⁹ The correspondences between Elizabethan and medieval drama, however, are far more widespread than such specific examples can show. Critics have suggested, for example, that many of the physical aspects of early-modern theatre—such as the thrust stage and the organization of the audience—retain aspects of mystery play staging.⁶⁰ These physical connections may preserve some of the valency of the medieval stage and the connection between Shakespearean drama and the mystery plays lies deeper than verbal connections, character types, or parallel scenes, although it is only through such connections that the particular relation of his plays with the earlier English drama can be established, and the meaning of the correspondences understood. The body of this book, therefore, will consider the previously unrecognized debt of specific scenes to the mystery plays, as well as to the Bible and Christian doctrine, but the rest of this chapter will consider some of the wider contexts for this work and the ways in which early-modern drama is the inheritor of the mystery plays. The dramatic theory available to early modern dramatists belonged not to their native productions, but to classical drama. Such prescriptions, enthusiastically supported by English theorists such as Sidney, taught that plays had to abide by certain rules and that decorum should be observed in the segregation of genre and classes of characters, unity of action, and the absence of staged violence. Among the decorums which Sidney famously valued, and Shakespeare famously violated, was Aristotle’s unity of action, which became the unities of time and place in Renaissance dramatic theory: ⁵⁹ Michael O’Connell, ‘Vital Cultural Practices’, 161–2. ⁶⁰ Pamela M. King and Clifford Davidson, eds., The Coventry Corpus Christi Plays (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 2000), 12; Glynne Wickham, Early English Stages 1300–1660 (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1959), ii. 37; Cooper, ‘Shakespeare and the Mystery Plays’, 26–7. For the argument that the valency of the Elizabethan stage’s space was affected by medieval staging, see Robert Weimann, Shakespeare and the Popular Tradition in the Theatre: Studies in the Social Dimension of Dramatic Form and Function (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1978), 73–85, 224–46.
44
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
The stage should always represent but one place, and the uttermost time presupposed in it should be, both by Aristotle’s precept and common reason, but one day … [in most plays, however,] you shall have Asia of the one side, and Afric of the other … . Now, of time they are much more liberal: for ordinary it is that two young princes fall in love; after many traverses, she is got with child, delivered of a fair boy; he is lost, groweth a man, falls in love, and is ready to get another child; and all this in two hours’ space.⁶¹
When Jonson revised Every Man in his Humour for his 1616 Folio he added a prologue that promised this play would not ‘make a child, now swadled, to proceede | Man, and then shoote vp, in one beard, and weede, | Past threescore yeeres’. The prologue is a jibe levelled at Shakespeare as the lines about ‘Yorke, and Lancasters long iarres’ and more particularly a ‘Chorus’ that ‘wafts you ore the seas’ makes clear.⁶² In The Magnetic Lady (1632) Jonson extended his critique of old-fashioned drama: a child could be born, in a play, and grow up to a man i’the first scene, before he went off the stage: and then after to come forth a squire, and be made a knight: and that knight to travel between the Acts, and do wonders i’the Holy Land, or elsewhere; kill paynims, wild boars, dun cows, and other monsters; beget him a reputation, and marry an emperor’s daughter for his mistress; convert her father’s country; and at last come home, lame, and all-to-beladen with miracles.⁶³
The killing of a dun cow was an exploit of Guy of Warwick and considering Jonson’s rivalry with the Warwickshire playwright, it seems likely that he is once more making Shakespeare his target. However, the word ‘miracles’, which is repeated three times in the next three lines along with other words connected with anti-Catholic satire—‘juggle’ and ‘Hocus Pocus’—suggests that the old Catholic drama was also the subject of Jonson’s lampoon.⁶⁴ It is suggestive that Jonson’s satire may encompass both Shakespearean and medieval drama. His complaints register his ⁶¹ Sir Philip Sidney: A Critical Edition of the Major Works, ed. Katherine Duncan-Jones (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989), 243. ⁶² Ben Jonson, ed. C. H. Herford, Percy Simpson, and Evelyn Simpson, 11 vols. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1925–52), iii. prologue, 7–9, 11, 15. ⁶³ Ben Jonson, vi. 1 chorus, 16–24. ⁶⁴ For the connection of ‘juggling’ with anti-Catholic satire, see Marie Axton, ed., Three Tudor Classical Interludes: Thersites, Jacke Jugeler, Horestes (Cambridge: D. S. Brewer, 1982), 19–20. ‘Hocus Pocus’ was an early seventeenth-century name for a juggler and assumed to be a corruption of the words of the Latin Mass ‘Hoc est corpus’: The Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. hocus pocus.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
45
increasing exasperation with the popularity of that ‘mouldy tale’ Pericles in particular—Shakespeare’s most disunified play.⁶⁵ Pericles is in fact not only close to medieval religious romances in form, but shares a major aspect of its plot with the King of Marcylle episode in the fifteenth-century play Mary Magdalene. However, Peter Womack has shown that this is not because Mary Magdalene influenced Pericles, but that the source of Pericles influenced the source of Mary Magdalene. Womack’s argument here is not only persuasive for the specific case he cites—that Confessio Amantis is the real origin of this episode—but for the wider point he is making: So if, as has more than once been suggested, Pericles is a Jacobean miracle play in secular disguise, there is more to the conjunction than a biographical collision, such as the hypothesis that Shakespeare was a crypto-Catholic, or that he had seen a fugitive saint play in his youth. The point is rather that romance and miracle are separable but not separate manifestations of a common repertoire of plots and plot devices … Sidney’s implicit program can be seen in this context as a strategy for decatholicizing the theater … by insisting on a single stage world, he effectively calls for a secularised theater, devoid of heaven, hell, theophany and magic.⁶⁶
Romance was not only written in the Catholic past, it was also a Catholic form. Jonson’s critique is part of the humanist attack on the implausibility of romance, begun by men such as Sir Thomas More.⁶⁷ This critique was perpetuated by Protestant Elizabethans such as Roger Ascham, and it began to assume an anti-Catholic edge. Roger Ascham’s attack on romance is situated within an argument against travel to Catholic Italy: ‘In our forefathers tyme, whan Papistrie … couered and ouerflowed all England, fewe bookes were read in our tong, sauyng certaine bookes of Cheualrie, as they sayd, for pastime and pleasure, which, as some say, were made in Monasteries, by idle Monkes, or wanton Chanons: ⁶⁵ Ben Jonson, vi. 492. ⁶⁶ Peter Womack, ‘Shakespeare and the Sea of Stories’, Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 29/1 (1999): 169–77. For a more confessional argument about romance as a Catholic form, and its connection with Shakespeare, see Richmond, Shakespeare, Catholicism, and Romance. ⁶⁷ Thomas More, The Latin Epigrams of Thomas More, ed. and trans. Leicester Bradner and Charles Arthur Lynch (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1953), epigram 174. See also Robert P. Adams, ‘Bold Bawdry and Open Manslaughter: The English New Humanist Attack on Medieval Romance’, Huntington Library Quarterly 23 (1959–60): 33–48.
46
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
as one example, Morte Arthure’.⁶⁸ The polemic of Protestants such as Ascham and Sidney highlighted what they perceived as Catholic stylistic methods in English writing and dramaturgy. Classical decorum celebrated by the humanists likewise decreed that there should be separation of rank along generic boundaries: tragedy belonged to high-class characters, comedy to low.⁶⁹ Sidney disapproves of the ‘mingling of kings and clowns’, a device ubiquitous to both medieval and early-modern drama.⁷⁰ The mystery plays enthusiastically mixed high-seriousness with comic play and low characters with the tragic protagonists. The domestic concerns and comedy of Noah’s wife, Mary’s midwives, or old Joseph doubting his young bride’s fidelity are mingled with the recounting of God’s salvation of the world. Even the climax of the tragedy, the Crucifixion, is played out by workmen who joke about the torture they commit as if it were a game. These characters, however amusing or disturbing, might seem incidental to the dramatic project of the mysteries, perhaps brought on simply to please the crowd, but in fact they are inherent to a theatrical enterprise which dramatizes the Incarnation. The central character of the mystery cycles imploded the classical decorum which separated high and low. The rustic carpenter, who is also the architect of the universe, is at one and the same time king and clown. The social fluidity of the Corpus Christi drama as a whole has this central indecorum as its source. The genre of the mysteries is likewise mixed by definition: the Crucifixion was the greatest tragedy, leading to the most profound comedy, of Western culture. Any cycle that staged both the Crucifixion and the Resurrection could never aim to disentangle the tragic from the comic. George Whetstone’s dedicatory epistle to Promos and Cassandra (1578) is a forthright denunciation of popular dramaturgy and Whetstone is probably thinking of mystery plays as the primary abusers of ⁶⁸ Roger Ascham, The Scholemaster, ed. John E. B. Mayor (London: Bell & Sons, 1892), 135. My thanks to the members of the Oxford Tudor reading group, and Fred Schurink in particular, for a stimulating discussion of this passage. See also Nashe’s complaint about romances written by ‘Abbie-lubbers’: Works of Thomas Nashe, i. 11. Stephen Gosson’s attack on plays about knights ‘passing from countrie to countrie’ and fighting monsters made of brown paper may also contain an anti-Catholic jibe in that the hero is so altered that on his return he can only be recognized by ‘a piece of cockle shell’—the symbol of a pilgrim: Playes Confuted in fiue Actions […] (London, 1582), C6r . ⁶⁹ In classical drama tragedy (such as Aeschylus’ Agamemnon or Sophocles’ Oedipus the King) is primarily about kings or military rulers and comedy (such as Aristophanes’ Lysistrata or Plautus’ Amphitryo) women or servants. ⁷⁰ Sir Philip Sidney, 244.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
47
the classical decorums of place, time, and person. Whetstone explicitly objects to Continental religious drama, which ‘is too holye: for [it] presentes on everye common Stage, what Preachers should pronounce in Pulpets’. His rejection of English popular theatre declares that the English playwright ‘fyrst groundes his worke on impossibilities: then in three howers ronnes he throwe the worlde: marryes, gets Children, makes Children men, men conquer kingdomes, murder Monsters, and bringeth Gods from Heaven, and fetcheth Divels from Hel … Manye tymes (to make mirthe) they make a Clowne companion with a Kinge’.⁷¹ Whetstone’s complaint about gods and devils being portrayed on stage suggests that he is thinking of biblical drama as the chief culprit in this regard. A diatribe against mixing kings and clowns may seem a surprising opening for Promos and Cassandra for those who know that Whetstone’s version of the unjust judge story is the source for Shakespeare’s lowerclass characters in Measure for Measure. In Whetstone’s play, however, there are discrete scenes of comic low-life, a strict separation of style on social principles, and the tacit assumption of high social status with virtue. As John Cox has noted, while Shakespeare undoubtedly followed Whetstone’s lead in introducing lower-class elements, he pointedly eschewed Whetstone’s social stratification, preferring instead the popular—and ultimately medieval—model of mingling kings and clowns freely.⁷² Debora Kuller Shuger has argued that in the torn consciousnesses of Shakespeare’s greatest tragic heroes—King Lear and Hamlet—Shakespeare has taken such a model to its logical extreme, by ‘assimilating the ancient Christian discourses of social injustice to the structures of the psyche … The mixing of beggars, clowns, and kings takes place within the tragic protagonist’.⁷³ In one sense, however, this radical move is simply a return to the source of the mysteries’ social conscience and indecorous style: the God-man, carpenter-king, shepherd-ruler, Jesus of Nazareth. The social agenda of the mysteries is inspired by the Incarnation, and played out both in the jumbling of characters and in the virtue of the lowly and wickedness of those in authority. The status conferred on ⁷¹ Geoffrey Bullough, ed., Narrative and Dramatic Sources of Shakespeare (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1964–75), ii. 443. ⁷² Cox, Shakespeare and the Dramaturgy of Power, 153. ⁷³ Debora Kuller Shuger, ‘Subversive Fathers and Suffering Subjects: Shakespeare and Christianity’, in Donna B. Hamilton and Richard Strier, eds., Religion, Literature, and Politics in Post-Reformation England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), 57.
48
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
lower-class characters, such as Mary, may also be the dramatic precedent not only for the indecorum of much early-modern drama, but even for an aspect of its structure. Classical drama, as Aristotle records, centres on one complete action and hence rarely has a fully developed sub-plot. Sub-plot characters, and their ability to comment on the action of the protagonist, are germane to Shakespeare and other early-modern dramatists, despite being alien to classical drama. The interweaving of two strands of plot, separate but interrelated (a structural device that Shakespeare brings to perfection in 1 Henry IV ), is not part of English drama’s classical inheritance.⁷⁴ The comic characters parody the main plot characters, and in doing so make the audience interrogate what they stand for: Falstaff ’s catechism on honour grounds Hotspur’s eulogy about it, Stephano’s bottle (which he orders Caliban to venerate with the words ‘kiss the book’) gives him an authority over his companions which shadows the ascendancy given to Prospero through his books and Lucio’s sneering denial of the bail Pompey had expected reflects on Isabella’s manner of refusing her brother’s hoped-for reprieve. This complex, sophisticated, and deeply satisfying plot-structure may have evolved from the iconographic and dramatic cycles of medieval culture. In a fifteenth-century Book of Hours, for example, the painter of the Gold Scrolls has complemented the illustration of Passion with an interwoven life of the Virgin in the historiated initial of each page. As Peter Happé has argued: ‘The emotional effects of such juxtapositions must have been considerable, especially as the tone of the Life of the Virgin is essentially triumphant, in spite of her sorrows, whilst the Passion is progressively more sombre, yet potentially triumphant in a different way.’⁷⁵ The life of the Virgin was also used in an analogous way in drama, and it has been suggested that the addition of events in Mary’s life in the N-town cycle, so that her story becomes a mirror of Christ’s life, creates the first consciously developed double-plot in English drama.⁷⁶ The influence of the reflective strands of plot in the mysteries on the sub-plots of early-modern drama has yet to be ⁷⁴ There are no extant Greek tragedies with a developed double-plot. The only Latin play I am aware of that in any way shares this form is Plautus’ Amphitruro. ⁷⁵ Roger S. Wieck et al., Time Sanctified: The Book of Hours in Medieval Art and Life, 2nd edn. (New York: George Braziller in association with the Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, 2001), fig. 45; Happé, Cyclic Form, 95. ⁷⁶ Martin Stevens, Four Middle English Mystery Cycles: Textual, Contextual and Critical Interpretations (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1987), 245.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
49
fully articulated, but it is implicit in Empson’s brilliant discussion of double-plots in the Wakefield Second Shepherd’s play and 1 Henry IV.⁷⁷ One final example of a classical decorum violated by both mystery plays and Shakespeare involves the presentation of violence on stage. In classical drama death, such as the killing of Agamemnon or the dismemberment of Pentheus, was reported rather than performed. Early-modern drama, however, does not shrink from staging murder, as the holocausts at the end of such plays as Hamlet, The Duchess of Malfi, and Women Beware Women testify. Few Greek tragedies have on-stage deaths (the eponymous heroes of Ajax and Hippolytus are, perhaps, unique examples) whereas in the mystery plays the Crucifixion was the climactic stage spectacle of the whole cycle. Like death, violence against the body (such as Oedipus’s self-blinding) is generally committed off-stage in classical drama, but the scourging and beating of Christ’s body, as well as his agonized death on the cross, were vividly enacted in the mystery plays. In Shakespeare the violent power of medieval theatre, rather than the decorum of classical theatre, is revived in drama which forces the sight of Lear’s death, Gloucester’s blinding, Desdemona’s suffocation, Antony’s mangled suicide, and the gangmurders of Hector and Caesar upon its audience.⁷⁸ Elizabethan drama as a whole has inherited its emphasis on affective, high-octane theatre from the mystery plays in which the violence and death inflicted on the protagonist was the central, graphically staged event. Elizabethans knew Greek tragedy primarily through Seneca’s Latin translations, but early-modern theatre replaced Senecan descriptions of pain with the physical presence of the wounded body. Rhetoric does not elicit a comparable emotional response to that created by actually observing pain and death, a truism which Elaine Scarry has theorized by arguing for the inexpressibility of pain: not merely that it is difficult to define, or that it reduces its victims to pre-linguistic cries and groans, but ⁷⁷ William Empson, Some Versions of Pastoral (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1966), 29–31. ⁷⁸ See Richard Strier’s excellent discussion of how the violation of classical decorum in the staging of Gloucester’s blinding creates the audience’s sympathy for the action of the servant: Richard Strier, ‘Faithful Servants: Shakespeare’s Praise of Disobedience’, in Heather Dubrow and Richard Strier, eds., The Historical Renaissance: New Essays on Tudor and Stuart Literature and Culture (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988), 119–20.
50
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
that because ‘it takes no object it, more than any other phenomenon, resists objectification in language’.⁷⁹ The staging of suffering is central to both the mysteries and early-modern drama, and in Shakespeare it is often at these moments that the connection with medieval dramaturgy is strongest.⁸⁰ In mystery plays the suffering victim was the central character and medieval affective piety encouraged the audience to enter as fully as possible into his torment. The centrality of suffering in both forms of theatre has lead Michael O’Connell to argue that: it was the traditional biblical theater that in fact authorized the portrayal of violence and physical brutality on stage and gave it a moral valence … the central point of relation is one that rests on the implications of incarnation, that God and man share a body, a body that may be shown to suffer and die. When the enactment of a singular sacred body became transgressive, the new public theater that emerged in the last quarter of the sixteenth century can be understood as refracting that body into a variety of tragic experience.⁸¹
The Incarnation lies at the core of the differences between the mysteries and classical drama that have been discussed above. The mystery plays enacted the Incarnation in which God and man become one and hence any attempt to keep characters in separate social spheres was both untenable and undesirable. They performed the whole of salvation history and hence could not preserve the unities of time or space. Their climax was the torture and killing of this God-man and therefore to obviate stage violence or death would be anathema to the affective design of the drama. The Incarnation was the subject of the cycle plays and it enforced and enabled a new form of drama. The celebration of the Incarnation, and its re-enactment in the mass, was also the occasion of these plays as well as their central event. The genesis of the mystery plays occurred as part of the festival of Corpus Christi. This feast celebrated the body of Christ in all its incarnations: the historical moment when God became man, the church as the body of ⁷⁹ Elaine Scarry, The Body in Pain: The Making and Unmaking of the World (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985), 5. ⁸⁰ This has been recognized, in particular, at the blinding of Gloucester and the deaths of York and Desdemona. See O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 87–8; Beatrice Groves, ‘ ‘‘Now wole I a newe game begynne’’: Staging Suffering in King Lear, the Mystery Plays and Grotius’s Christus Patiens’, Medieval and Renaissance Drama in England 20 (forthcoming 2007); Jones, Origins, 54–6; Cox, Shakespeare and the Dramaturgy of Power, 93–9; The Third Part of King Henry VI, ed. Michael Hattaway, The New Cambridge Shakespeare (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), notes to 1. 4. 67, 1. 4. 78–83, 1. 4. 93; Milward, Shakespeare’s Religious Background, 250. See also Ch. 4. ⁸¹ O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 87–8.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
51
Christ now present on earth and, primarily, in the mass.⁸² The doctrine of transubstantiation was formalized at the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 and the feast of Corpus Christi was created by Pope Urban IV in 1264 to celebrate and give devotional focus to the new doctrine. By 1318 the feast of Corpus Christi had arrived in England and by the second quarter of the fourteenth century the Corpus Christi procession was accompanied by dramatic presentations or tableaux vivants. Corpus Christi theatre grew out of these displays, and although many towns and cities did not have the fully fledged cycles that have been recorded in York, Chester, and Beverley, most celebrated the festival with some form of drama such as a Passion or sacrament play.⁸³ In the Croxton Play of the Sacrament for example, which Gail McMurray Gibson has argued was part of the Corpus Christi celebrations in Bury St Edmunds, the play merges with the other festival celebrations as the host at the centre of the plot is borne to church in procession by the character Episcopus.⁸⁴ The fever of dramatic activity that surrounded the festival from the fourteenth to the sixteenth century proves the ubiquity of dramatic creation to the celebration of the feast. Throughout England the embodied art was recognized as belonging to the festival of Christ’s body.⁸⁵ Corpus Christi drama has a fundamental connection with the Incarnation, but it is also possible to argue that the emergence of drama as a whole in medieval Europe coincided with the revaluation of the humanity of the incarnate Christ. Most extant dramatic, liturgical texts date from the twelfth and early thirteenth centuries when the doctrinal debate which culminated in the doctrine of transubstantiation was taking place. Michael O’Connell has argued that the impetus for theatre came from this new concern with corporeality and that the revaluation of Christ’s humanity underlay the way in which Christianity would ⁸² For the emphasis on the church as the body of Christ in this festival see Mervyn James, Society, Politics and Culture: Studies in Early Modern England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986), 16–47. On the cycles’ relation to the festival see V. A. Kolve, The Play Called Corpus Christi (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1966), 44–9; Peter W. Travis, Dramatic Design in the Chester Cycle (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1982), 1–29; Lauren Lepow, Enacting the Sacrament: Counter-Lollardy in the Towneley Cycle (Rutherford, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1990). ⁸³ Rubin, Corpus Christi, 199, 272–5. ⁸⁴ Gibson, The Theatre of Devotion, 38. ⁸⁵ Rubin, Corpus Christi, 229–32, 275–82. In certain places it was also the Corpus Christi guild which provided the play for the festival: Karl Young, ‘An Interludium for a Gild of Corpus Christi’, Modern Language Notes 48 (1933): 84–6; Chambers, Mediaeval Stage, ii. 118–19, 371.
52
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
come to valorize materiality and the physical expression of spiritual concerns. The same argument has been made by Gail McMurray Gibson, originating in her study of the devotion of fifteenth-century East Anglia. The physical aspects of devotional piety in the late-medieval period and its tendency to transform the abstract and theological to the personal and concrete, Gibson argues, show a conscious effort to objectify the spiritual even as the Incarnation itself had given spirit a concrete form.⁸⁶ The Incarnation gave theoretical justification to a defence of the visual arts, and Incarnational aspects of the Corpus Christi cycles can be seen as metonymic not only for medieval drama as a whole, but for the whole emphasis on the visual and the concrete in late-medieval devotion.⁸⁷ This Incarnational aesthetic resulted in the specific aspects of English drama that have been discussed above—mingling of genre, persons, the staging of chronological impossibilities, and violence—and the phenomenology of theatre itself also carried with it a legacy of Incarnational understanding. As Helen Cooper has argued the fundamental connection of early-modern drama and the mysteries lies here: ‘For it is that element of enactment—of subordinating the word to the deed, supplementing speech with embodiment, that the plays written for the sixteenth-century public theatres carry over from the cycle plays, and which mark both sorts as a distinctive kind, not just of text, but of theatre.’⁸⁸ The inheritance of this Incarnational aesthetic by Elizabethan and Jacobean drama is one reason why the reformer’s challenge to the theatre went beyond the suppression of the mystery plays. Theatre is a mixed medium—visual as well as verbal—and the polemists’ horror at men dressed as women, or falsehood presented as truth, or biblical phrases found in the texts of profane plays, is a symptom of a much deeper distrust of theatrical presentation as a whole. Pure and true language is infected by its visual medium: ‘The reuerend word of God, & histories of the Bible set forth on the stage by these blasphemous plaiers, are … corrupted with their gestures of scurrilitie.’⁸⁹ The mixed medium of theatre shares, in Protestant anti-theatrical tracts, the taint of the Catholic eucharistic rite. Anti-Catholic and anti-theatrical polemic converged in this period: Catholics were attacked for being theatrical, ⁸⁶ O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 47, 64–5; Gibson, The Theatre of Devotion, 6–8 and passim. See also Duffy, Stripping of the Altars, 22–37, 183–6. ⁸⁷ Gibson, The Theatre of Devotion, 13–15; O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 38–41, 50. ⁸⁸ Cooper, ‘Shakespeare and the Mystery Plays’, 19. ⁸⁹ Eutheo Anglo-phile, A second and third blast of retrait from plaies and Theaters […] (London, 1580), H2r .
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
53
actors for performing papist rites. The value placed on the physical elements of the mass was linked in the reformers’ language with the gaudy frippery of props and costumes. The instinctive fear of mixture and taint in godly rhetoric recoiled from both the drama of the mass and the ritual of plays in which powerful words are embedded in an emotionally involving spectacle. Both Catholic ceremonial and dramatic presentations rely on the assimilation of word and image, and diatribes against plays and the mass became mirror-images of each other.⁹⁰ Catholicism’s Incarnational aesthetic, centring on an event in which God became man, and re-enacted in a sacrament in which bread became flesh, was something that reformers, with their stress on purity and the primacy of the Word, wished to struggle free from. Despite the initial enthusiasm for theatrical performances in the early Reformation, by the late-Elizabethan period reformers were as antagonistic to theatrical performance as they were to church ritual. Drama which contained scriptural allusions was most violently opposed, but for many reformers all theatre was idolatrous, not merely biblical theatre. William Rankins was not simply describing mystery plays when he wrote: ‘No doubt but there is amongst them can play Iudas, as naturally as if he were the very man that betrayed Christ, & verily … these godlesse men crucifie Christ a newe, when they thus seeke to deface his glory, to mangle his members, and rent in peeces his sacred body.’⁹¹ In Rankins’s heated rhetoric the performers who deface the image of God in their bodies (by counterfeiting in secular plays) enact a Passion play: secular theatre is transformed into religious theatre simply because it is embodied. Early-modern drama acts out its action through the bodies of its performers, and although this might seem germane to all theatre, classical drama as inherited by Elizabethan England was a predominantly verbal medium. It has long been argued that Seneca was intended for declamation rather than for portrayal, as his plays replace affective spectacle with rhetoric and action with long speeches.⁹² Helen Cooper has argued that the mystery cycles, rather than Greek and Latin drama, were the source for early-modern theatre’s emphasis on embodied action: ‘drama that acts its action is not the automatic default position, as ⁹⁰ Jonas Barish, The Antitheatrical Prejudice (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1981), 160–5. ⁹¹ William Rankins, A Mirrovr of Monsters […] (London, 1587), Gv –G2r . ⁹² Norman T. Pratt, Seneca’s Drama (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1983), 132–63; John G. Fitch, ‘Playing Seneca?’, in George W. M. Harrison, ed., Seneca in Performance (London: Duckworth, 2000), 9–10.
54
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
classical and humanist drama shows. Rather, it is a medieval invention, and one that the sixteenth-century public theatre adopted and built on.’⁹³ Reformist biblical drama shows what classically inspired earlymodern theatre looks like. These plays centre on Christ’s words rather than his presence. The legend on the title page of Bale’s God’s Promises declares where its emphasis lies: ‘in the worde (whych now is Christ the eternall sonne of God) was lyfe from the begynnynge’.⁹⁴ The play which follows God’s Promises in Bale’s cycle is John the Baptist’s Preaching (1538), rather than the traditional Nativity play. This is because Bale is not interested in the affective spectacle of the infant Christ: for Bale, Christ is only a truly dramatic character once he can speak.⁹⁵ Bale’s stress on Christ as the Word leads to plays which are in some senses simply animated doctrine. Other reformers, such as Stephen Gosson, went even further and thought all plays should be closet drama, written only to be read. He suggests that the Passion play attributed to St Gregory of Nazianzus is one such, and imputes to St Gregory an anachronistic hatred of the mysteries in order to argue that verbal drama is a distinctively Protestant form, created to combat the physicality of Catholic theatre: For Naziancen detesting the corruption of the Corpus Christi Playes that were set out by the Papistes, and inveighing against them, thought it better to write the passion of Christ in numbers him selfe, that all such as delight in numerositie of speach might reade it, not beholde it vpon the Stage, where some base fellowe that plaide Christe, should bring the person of Christ into contempt.⁹⁶
The embodiment that is ignored by Bale, alien to Gosson, and irrelevant to Seneca is central to both mystery plays and Elizabethan drama. The ‘enfleshment’ of scripts by actors lies at the heart of the shared medieval and early-modern conception of theatre. The anti-theatricalists of the sixteenth century were clear that it was the aspect of embodiment (even more than any religious subject matter) ⁹³ Cooper, ‘Shakespeare and the Mystery Plays’, 20. ⁹⁴ The Complete Plays of John Bale, ed. Peter Happé (Bury St Edmunds: D. S. Brewer, 1986), ii. 2. ⁹⁵ For the evidence that there is no missing Nativity play see Bale’s account of the performance of these plays: Chambers, Mediaeval Stage, ii. 374. ⁹⁶ Gosson, Playes Confuted, E5v –6r . George Sandys detects the influence of St Gregory of Nazianzus on Hugo Grotius’s Passion play, which (in its English translation) was not intended for the stage: Hugo Grotius, Christs Passion A Tragedie: with annotations, trans. George Sandys (London, 1640), A3r .
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
55
which made drama idolatrous. As seen above Stephen Gosson could even defend the religious subject of St Gregory of Nazianzus’s Christos Paschon because he argued that it was not intended to be staged, but that any play ‘to ye worldes end, if it be presented upon the stage, shall carry that brand of his backe … that is, idolatrie’.⁹⁷ When in 1576 Hutton, the Dean of York, forbade the performance of mystery plays, he issued an order stating that: ‘No Pageant be vsed or set furthe wherein the Maiestye of god the father god the sonne or god the holie ghoste or the administration of either the sacramentes of Baptisme or of the lordes Supper be counterfeyted or represented; or anythinge plaied which tende to the maintenaunce of superstition and idolatrie.’⁹⁸ For both Gosson and Hutton the real stumbling block is the idolatry inherent in all physical enactment. The charge of idolatry did not just belong to religious drama, but was levelled against all theatre because it was an art form which promoted the visual and embodied its action.⁹⁹ Polemists and members of the church hierarchy who inveighed against mystery plays were invariably supporters of the suppression of drama as a whole. In 1575, when Elizabeth visited Kenilworth Castle, Coventry players petitioned her for the revival of their plays, ostensibly asking for the return of the secular drama The Conquest of the Danes, which was performed ‘without ill exampl of mannerz, papistry, or ony superstition’ but had been recently suppressed by ‘the zeal of certain theyr Preacherz: men very commendabl for their behauiour and learning, & sweet in their sermons, but sumwhat too sour in preaching awey theyr pastime’.¹⁰⁰ Zealous Protestants were antithetical to all drama, not simply religious drama, because to them all plays smelt of popery. This position is wittily expressed in Thomas Randolph’s The Muses Looking-Glasse (1638), which light-heartedly acknowledges an irreducibly Catholic aspect to early-modern theatre. London playhouses were built in the liberties: those areas of the city which lay outside the city’s jurisdiction because they had been the sites of religious houses. To Puritans playhouses were the spiritual heirs of the insititutions they replaced, inheriting their vacuous visual splendour as well as their anomalous legal status, and The ⁹⁷ Gosson, Playes Confuted, E7r . Cf. O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 34. ⁹⁸ Quoted in Alan H. Nelson, The Medieval English Stage: Corpus Christi Pageants and Plays (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974), 85. ⁹⁹ O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 14–15, 20, 26–7. ¹⁰⁰ Robert Laneham, A Letter: Whearin, part of the entertainment vntoo the Queens Maiesty, at killingwoorth Castle, in Warwik sheer in this Soomerz Progress 1575 iz signified […] (n. pl., 1575), C2r .
56
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
Muses Looking-Glasse reports a Puritan quip about Blackfriars playhouse that ‘He wonders how it scapd demolishing | I’ th’ time of reformation.’¹⁰¹ Blackfriars may no longer be the abode of Dominicans, but the connection between the two institutions goes deeper than their coincidence of name and situation. Reformers feared that while they were suppressing idolatry in one sphere, reducing the visual stimulus of worship by whitewashing walls, simplifying vestments, and discontinuing the elevation of the host, it might be simply re-emerging elsewhere. A number of critics have argued that it is no coincidence that the most vibrant and exciting time in England’s theatrical history occurred at the same time as the solidification of the hegemony of Protestantism. An early proponent of this idea was C. L. Barber, who argued that the restriction of the impulse for physicality in the new Protestant worship created a compensatory fascination with drama.¹⁰² Concrete evidence for this idea seems to come from the use of vestments on the stage. Records in King’s College Cambridge state that in the 1550s ‘certayne vestmentes [were] transpoised into players garmentes’.¹⁰³ Evidence from various other parish records and players’ accounts indicates that this was not an isolated phenomenon.¹⁰⁴ Glynne Wickham uses this evidence to support his theory that the immediate parentage for the sartorial excesses of the post-Reformation stage is the colour and richness of the ecclesiastical vestments that had been purged from Protestant worship, arguing that theatre compensated for something lost in the religious sphere.¹⁰⁵ Stephen Greenblatt has argued that vestments, though originally perhaps used as an aggressive appropriation of the accoutrements of the Catholic religion by Protestant players, had the ¹⁰¹ Thomas Randolph, The Muses Looking-Glasse (London, 1638), A3v . ¹⁰² C. L. Barber, Creating Elizabethan Tragedy: The Theater of Marlowe and Kyd, ed. Richard P. Wheeler (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988), 125. ¹⁰³ For this and other similar records see Nelson, Cambridge, i. 127, 843, 152–3, 180–1. The records in Kings have been amended by the Marian sacristan, Carleton, who not only converted the costumes back into vestments, but entered this into the earlier inventory. He added to the 1552–3 account of ‘Item one coope of the best redde tusshes turnyd into a cloke with a cape of the best redde’ the words ‘& now in to a coope againe’ (p.181), and repeated this codicil for almost all the converted vestments. ¹⁰⁴ Somerset, Shropshire, i. 211–13; Giles E. Dawson, ed., Records of Plays and Players in Kent 1450–1642, Collections Volume VII (Oxford: Malone Society, 1965), 207; Wickham, Early English Stages, ii. 38; George David, ed., Lancashire, Records of Early English Drama (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1991), 40; Chambers, Mediaeval Stage, ii. 343, 367. See also Paul Whitfield White, ‘Reforming Mysteries’ End: A New Look at Protestant Intervention in English Provincial Drama’, Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 29/1 (1999): 134. ¹⁰⁵ Wickham, Early English Stages, ii. 38
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
57
unexpected function of transferring to the theatre what remained of Catholicism’s charisma, although fundamentally devalued in its transfer from the sacred to the secular. The vestments stand as an objective correlative for the theological material which the Reformation had unsettled from its institutional moorings and thereby made available for theatrical appropriation.¹⁰⁶ Visual splendour is an important connection between Catholic ritual and the early-modern stage. The stage was a place of gorgeous costumes and ritual, a new space consecrated for sensory pleasure at the time when the church was becoming bare and stripped of all such visual stimulation.¹⁰⁷ As Glynne Wickham has argued: ‘Elizabethan censorship of subject matter … has neither suppressed the stagecraft associated by tradition with the Catholic ritual out of which it had developed, nor reformed the public appetite for the glamour of this ritual.’¹⁰⁸ More recent critics might be cautious about assuming the evolutionary model from liturgy to drama, but Sarah Beckwith has likewise argued that: ‘Shakespeare’s theater does not represent the supercession and succession of religion, purgatory, and ritual action by a disenchanted theater, but the persistence of its historical concerns in the incarnation of performance.’¹⁰⁹Louis Montrose also sees the theatre absorbing and providing a vital ritualistic function within Shakespeare’s society by providing a compensatory source of engaging and deeply satisfying collective experience.¹¹⁰ This reading of early-modern theatre as a visually stimulating and emotionally affective form of ritualistic communal engagement is a broadly persuasive view of the way that Elizabethan and Jacobean theatre relates to the religious climate of its time. This mode of expression had been curtailed in religious worship and it seems highly ¹⁰⁶ Stephen Greenblatt, Learning to Curse: Essays in Early Modern Culture (New York: Routledge, 1990), 162–3. See also Greenblatt, Hamlet in Purgatory, 249; Stephen Greenblatt, Shakespearean Negotiations: The Circulation of Social Energy in Renaissance England (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1988), 94–128. ¹⁰⁷ For the astonishing value and variety of costumes see Andrew Gurr, The Shakespearean Stage 1574–1642, 3rd edn. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 194–8. ¹⁰⁸ Wickham, Early English Stages, ii. 37. ¹⁰⁹ Sarah Beckwith, ‘Stephen Greenblatt’s Hamlet and the Forms of Oblivion’, Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 33/2 (2003): 275. ¹¹⁰ Louis A. Montrose, ‘The Purpose of Playing: Reflections on a Shakespearean Anthropology’, Helios 7/2 (1979–80): 64, 60. See also Barber, Creating Elizabethan Tragedy; Crockett, The Play of Paradox, 33–4; Ramie Targoff, ‘The Performance of Prayer: Sincerity and Theatricality in Early Modern England’, Representations 60 (1997): 60 and passim.
58
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
suggestive that it should have emerged elsewhere. Nonetheless theatre did not only grow out of the demise of Catholicism, but also engaged with the vigour of Protestantism. Elizabethan theatre enacted embodiment, but it also engaged with the Reformation scepticism about the relationship between representation and truth. Huston Diehl has argued that although Elizabethan and Jacobean drama articulates the anxieties created by Protestant assaults on late medieval piety, it is not particularly sympathetic to the old religion. Central to Diehl’s argument is the idea that the meta-theatre in early-modern theatre calls attention to the act of seeing and underlies the fictionality of what is perceived, and in doing so encourages a distrust of Incarnational ways of thinking and seeing.¹¹¹ Diehl, like Greenblatt and Dawson, argues that the terms of the eucharistic controversy—central to the understanding of semiotics in the post-Reformation period—affected the way that theatrical presentation was understood.¹¹² Diehl’s argument is a useful corrective to an over-romanticized view of the relation between Catholicism and early-modern drama, but meta-theatre does not destroy theatrical presence. Anthony Dawson has argued in response to Diehl that ‘the meta-theatrical sets up a second, contrary movement whereby the affective power of the visible is underscored’.¹¹³ O’Connell likewise concludes that Shakespeare’s insistent meta-theatricality ends in a celebration of the visual. He argues that: affirmation of spectacle is thus more than an allowance of the visual character of theater. It is a legitimation of a way of knowing asserted against humanist claims for an exclusive, or near exclusive, truth in language … . the fullness of theater ¹¹¹ Huston Diehl, Staging Reform, Reforming the Stage: Protestantism and Popular Theatre in Early Modern England (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1997), 5, and passim; Huston Diehl, ‘Observing the Lord’s Supper and the Lord Chamberlain’s Men: The Visual Rhetoric of Ritual and Play in Early Modern England’, Renaissance Drama 22 (1991): 147–74. For engagements with, and critiques of, Diehl’s argument see Anthony B. Dawson, ‘Huston Diehl. Staging Reform, Refroming the Stage: Protestantism and Popular Theater in Early Modern England’, Shakespeare Quarterly 50/2 (1999): 221–4; Crockett, The Play of Paradox, 54–5. ¹¹² Stephen Greenblatt and Catherine Gallagher, Practicing New Historicism (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000), 136–62. For readings of specific plays with reference to eucharistic controversy see Anthony B. Dawson and Paul Yachnin, The Culture of Playgoing in Shakespeare’s England: A Collaborative Debate (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 148–9; Barber, Creating Elizabethan Tragedy, 99–102; Joel B. Altman, ‘ ‘‘Vile Participation’’: The Amplification of Violence in the Theater of Henry V ’, Shakespeare Quarterly 42/1 (1991): 4–5, 13 n. 38, 16, 19 n. 50, 30–1. ¹¹³ Dawson, The Culture of Playgoing, 22.
Shakespeare’s Incarnational Aesthetic
59
rests also on what is taken in by the eye, and its very ground is impersonation by living, breathing human bodies.¹¹⁴
Late sixteenth-century theatre is committed to both ritualistic display and meta-theatricality; to visual pleasure and the verbal interrogation of the reality of the presentation. Early-modern theatre embodied the Incarnational legacy of Corpus Christi drama, but it was also responsive to contemporary controversies about the truth of presentation. As Dawson has recently argued, these differences can be reconciled by regarding early modern theatre as a medium that reflexively stages the conflict about images, celebrating and employing affective spectacle while remaining sceptical about audience susceptibility and the relation of visual power to truth.¹¹⁵ The different devotional foci of Catholicism and Protestantism meant that reformers polarized them as the religion of the eye and the religion of the ear. The ear was the primary organ of truth for Protestants who wanted to replace the visual with the aural, the sacring of the mass with sermons, priests with preachers. Visual, embodied theatre was seen as irreducibly Catholic in the eyes of early-modern Protestants. William Lambarde, reflecting on the dramatic Catholic liturgy he watched as a child, concluded ‘sence true Faithe cometh by hearinge and not by seinge, [Faith] is more then al the Spectacles in the Worlde can bringe to pass’.¹¹⁶ Shakespeare, however, was engaged in awaking a different kind of faith and his drama celebrates both the visual, physical nature of its embodied art and its poetic and rhetorical sophistication. Early-modern theatre does not privilege the ear over the eye, nor the image over the word, but harmonizes them in drama which suits, as Hamlet says, ‘the action to the word, the word to the action’. The 1590s was an innovative time in English theatre when the cultural heritage of the old faith and the linguistic excitement of the new learning were both appropriated by the stage. The lingering memory of the visual stimuli of Catholicism, and the rising literary awareness inspired by Protestantism, created a culture ripe for the most verbally sophisticated and visually affective dramaturgy. ¹¹⁴ O’Connell, The Idolatrous Eye, 143–4. ¹¹⁵ Dawson, The Culture of Playgoing, 135–6. ¹¹⁶ William Lambarde, Dictionarium Angliae Topographicum & Historicum (London, 1730), 459–60. Although not published until the eighteenth century, this account was written before Lambarde’s death in 1601. Some theatrical apologists cheekily inverted this well-known formulation into: ‘Men are not wonn by th’eares so well as eyes’: Randolph, The Muses Looking-Glasse, A4r .
3 Comedic Form and Paschal Motif in the First and Second Quartos of Romeo and Juliet In John Madden’s film Shakespeare in Love the hero is writing a comedy (Romeo and Ethel the Pirate’s Daughter) which eventually, in response to the thwarted love affair in his own life, metamorphoses into tragedy. The scriptwriters Marc Norman and Tom Stoppard have wittily picked up on a truth about the Shakespearean plot their story is based on. The generic instability of much of Romeo and Juliet was admitted not merely in the 1990s or by the late seventeenth century, when it was played as a tragedy and tragi-comedy on alternate nights, but also by Shakespeare himself when he burlesqued his story as the ‘very tragical mirth’ of Pyramus and Thisbe.¹ A central aspect of comedic form in the play is the plot’s climax in the apparent death and resurrection of Juliet, an event concocted by the Friar to circumvent the obstacles facing the young lovers. The elasticity of death is germane to comedy and plays which copied the plot device of the sleeping potion in the following years all transmuted it into comedy.² In A Midsummer Night’s Dream, likewise, Pyramus/Bottom does not remain dead but leaps up to explain the redemptive aspect of the plot to the spectators: ‘no, I assure you, the wall is down that parted their fathers’ (5. 1. 332). ¹ Ann Pasternak Slater, ‘Petrarchism Come True in Romeo and Juliet’, in D. J. Palmer, Roger Pringle, and Werner Habicht, eds., Images of Shakespeare: Proceedings of the Third Congress of the International Shakespeare Association (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1988), 131. For the evidence that Romeo and Juliet preceded Dream, see Kenneth Muir, The Sources of Shakespeare’s Plays (London: Methuen, 1977), 77; Amy J. Reiss, ‘ ‘‘Tragical Mirth’’: From Romeo to Dream’, Shakespeare Quarterly 43/2 (1992): 215. ² John Day, Law Tricks by John Day, 1608, ed. John Crow (Oxford: The Malone Society, 1949), ll. 2288–90; Thomas Dekker, Satiromastix in The Dramatic Works of Thomas Dekker, ed. Fredson Bowers (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1953), i. 5. 2. 96–108; Edward Sharpham, The Fleire by Edward Sharpham: Nach Der Quarto 1607, ed. Hunold Nibbe (Vaduz: Kraus Reprint, 1912/63), 4. 195–284.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
61
This stock romance device of an apparent death followed by restoration to life is also part of the paschal motif which runs through Romeo and Juliet and strengthens the comedic matrix of the tragedy.³ Many of the plot parallels between Romeo and Juliet and the Easter story (such as the friar who flees, like the women, from the tomb) were already present in Shakespeare’s sources: Brooke’s The Tragicall Historye of Romeus and Juliet and Painter’s The Story of Romeo and Julietta.⁴ In both of these the love-story is set within a liturgical framework. The birth and death of Romeo and Juliet’s relationship occurs in synchrony with the birth and death of Christ: they meet at Christmas and are parted at Easter.⁵ Shakespeare has removed these markers of a paschal theme—his play is set in July—but retains their import. The sources draw attention to the significant timing of the tragedy, but they make little of its metaphorical possibilities. Shakespeare, by contrast, takes up their prompt and employs it with sophisticated artistry to imbue the fabric of his play with a subverted promise of redemption. Easter is no longer openly referred to, but the threat of death and the hope of resurrection become deeply entwined with the story. This chapter will not only argue that the Easter allusions are one, unrecognized, part of the comedic theme, but also that the play’s earliest texts—An Excellent conceited Tragedie of Romeo and Iuliet, printed in 1597 (Q1) and The Most Excellent and lamentable Tragedie, of Romeo and Iuliet, printed in 1599 (Q2)—diverge in their presentation of the paschal motif and other comedic elements.⁶ A thoroughgoing study of ³ The popularity of this motif in romance appears to date from the first century and it has recently been suggested this is due to the influence of Christianity on the Graeco-Roman world: N. T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God (Bath: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, 2003), 69–75. My thanks to Stephen Medcalf for alerting me to this. ⁴ There has been scant critical attention of this aspect of the play. The only two references I have found are Roy Battenhouse, Shakespearean Tragedy: Its Art and Its Christian Premises (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1969), 115; Peter Milward, Shakespeare’s Religious Background, 29. ⁵ Bullough, Narrative and Dramatic Sources, i. ll. 155, 959; William Painter, The Story of Romeo and Julietta (1587), in Elizabethan Love Stories, ed. T. J. B. Spencer (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1968), 54, 65. The idea of a liturgically situated love affair, commencing at Christmas and ending at Easter, also occurs in Du Bellay’s L’Olive: Joachim Du Bellay, L’Olive, ed. Ernesta Caldarini (Geneva: Librairie Droz, 1974), sonnets 5, 111; Verdun L. Saulnier, Du Bellay (Paris: Hatier, 1968), 63. ⁶ All quarto references are to An Excellent conceited Tragedie of Romeo and Iuliet (London: John Danter, 1597) and The Most Excellent and lamentable Tragedie, of Romeo and Iuliet. Newly corrected, augmented, and amended (London: Cuthbert Burby, 1599).
62
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
differences which consistently alter an aspect of the text, the groundwork for a theory of authorial revision (most famously used in Taylor and Warren’s reappraisal of King Lear) has not yet been attempted for Romeo and Juliet. However, Q1 and Q2 are among the early Shakespeare texts which show patterned variation: coherent differences which create distinct continuities (such as in character, language, or theme) within the texts. There are many other Shakespearean examples of such divergences in the early texts, such as the strengthening of the character of Emilia in the Folio Othello, the presentation of the war in the two texts of King Lear and the different relationship of Hamlet to Laertes and Claudius in the second quarto and the Folio.⁷ Such themed variation, which reshapes one aspect of the play, strongly suggests that some of the differences between quarto and folio texts are the result of intentional rather than random alteration. There is no proof that this reviser is the author, but Grace Ioppolo has shown that there is ample manuscript evidence in plays of this period for authorial revision which reworks character, plot, theme, and structure in ways comparable to the differences perceived in Shakespeare’s multiple texts.⁸ The themed yet delicate alterations apparent in Shakespeare’s early texts seem to be most plausibly explained as the work of the dramatist himself, as it is the author who is most likely to take such care over revising his own play. John Kerrigan has shown that non-authorial revisers tend to add or remove large sections of text, while revising authors—then as now—tend to tinker, fidgeting over single-word substitutions.⁹ This chapter suggests that the divergence of Q1 and Q2 Romeo and Juliet raises the possibility that Shakespeare revised his play, and altered his foul papers (the copy text for Q2) to give prominence to the comedic side of the plot and the latent Easter narrative which is integral to the promise of a happy resolution. ⁷ Nevill Coghill, Shakespeare’s Professional Skills (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1964), 164–202; Gary Taylor, ‘The War in King Lear’, Shakespeare Survey 33 (1980): 27–34; Paul Werstine, ‘The Textual Mystery of Hamlet’, Shakespeare Quarterly 39/1 (1988): 1–26. See also E. A. J. Honigmann, ‘Shakespeare’s Revised Plays: King Lear and Othello’, The Library, 6th ser., 4 (1982): 142–73; Gary and Michael Warren Taylor, eds., The Division of the Kingdoms: Shakespeare’s Two Versions of King Lear (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983); John Jones, Shakespeare at Work (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995), 166–84, and passim. ⁸ Grace Ioppolo, Revising Shakespeare (London: Harvard University Press, 1991), 44–77. ⁹ John Kerrigan, ‘Revision, Adaptation, and the Fool in King Lear’, in Taylor and Warren, eds., The Division of the Kingdoms, 195–213.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
63
Juliet is central to the comedic strand of the tragedy: the witty female who is the instigator of her own marriage, passionate in her desire for sexual fulfilment, and whose language is alive with double meaning when she banters with Paris. She is also at the heart of the paschal imagery in the play, and although this grows to a climax at her death, it is present even in the account of her infancy. The nurse’s garrulous and amusing anecdote about weaning Juliet describes how she put wormwood on her teat which the baby then refused, and at this moment an earthquake shook the dovecote: ’Tis since the earthquake now eleven years, And she was weaned—I never shall forget it— Of all the days of the year upon that day, For I had then laid wormwood on my dug, Sitting in the sun under the dovehouse wall.
(1. 3. 25–9)
It is a commonplace of Shakespeare criticism that the comic characters explain more than they intend. The second part of the nurse’s story (in which the child falls and hurts herself) can be taken as a metaphor for the ensuing plot, and the ‘Ay!’ with which she responds to the nurse’s husband’s sexual innuendo prefigures the absolute directness with which Juliet commits herself to love and its physical expression.¹⁰ The first part of the nurse’s story likewise reveals a theme underlying the main plot. The nurse swears ‘by the rood’ (1. 3. 38) and the scene by the dovehouse wall is a Crucifixion in innocent miniature, holding within itself the Passion imagery which will underlie the passionate intensity of the lovers. There was an earthquake too when Christ was thirsty on the cross. He was given ‘gall’, and like Juliet ‘when he had tasted thereof, he would not drinke’ (Matt. 27: 34). The nurse has given Juliet wormwood to wean her: the milk will taste so bitter that Juliet will no longer desire the breast. It was a common interpretation of the gall and vinegar given to Jesus, that it was a cruel trick to deny him the drink ostensibly proffered. This remained the dominant interpretation in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, as well as being the explanation favoured by the mystery plays. In the Chester Passion Jesus is given the mixture with the words: ‘Yea, thou shalt have drynke ¹⁰ John Woolley, ‘Juliet’s Earthquake’, Critical Survey 3/1 (1991): 32. See also Barbara Everett, ‘Romeo and Juliet: The Nurse’s Story’, in C. B. Cox and D. J. Palmer, eds., Shakespeare’s Wide and Universal Stage (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1984), 134–45.
64
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
therfore | that thou shalt lyst to drynke no more.’¹¹ And shortly afterwards, as with Juliet, ‘the earth did quake, & the stones were clouen’ (Matt. 27: 51). The earthquake and wormwood are part of the biblical account of the Crucifixion, but the nurse’s story contains another associated image—doves and a dovecote—which also belonged to meditations on the Passion and the mystery plays. An early seventeenth-century sermon connects the spirit which Christ gave up when he died with the dove released from the ark: ‘as Saint Ambrose comments, hee [the dying Christ] sent his spirit out of his body as Noah sent his Dove out of the Arke’.¹² In mystery plays too, the moment of Christ’s ‘giving up the ghost’ was staged with a dove. One stage direction reads ‘bowing his head, he gives up the spirit and a white dove shall fly off’; another indicates that ‘a live dove is to be hidden in the cross, to fly out at the death of Christ’.¹³ It is perhaps the representation of Christ’s spirit as a dove that led Richard Rolle, in his ‘Meditations on the Passion’, in which he imagines Christ’s crucified body as infinitely open and permeable, to use the image of a dovecote for the Saviour’s body: ‘swet Jhesu, thy body is like to a dufhouse. For as a dufhouse is ful of holys, so is thy body ful of wounds.’ This dovecote metaphor arose from the devotional apprehension of the accessibility of Christ’s body. It is a striking link between the nurse’s anecdote and the Passion and is also present in the morality play Wisdom, in which Christ describes his crucified body as being ‘full of holys as a dovehows’.¹⁴ It is not only the events of the nurse’s story that recall Christ’s story; the dramatic method of surrounding a child with pre-echoes of ¹¹ The Chester Mystery Cycle, ed. R. M. Lumiansky and David Mills, Early English Text Society, 3 and 9 (London: Early English Text Society, 1974–86), 16a. 353–4. For the longevity of this interpretation, see Hugo Grotius, Christ’s Passion, A Tragedy; with Annotations, trans. George Sandys, 2nd edn. (London, 1687), F4v . ¹² Samuel Wallsall, The Life and Death of Iesus Christ in part: Summarily Comprising his Infirmities and Sorrowes &c (Cambridge, 1607), D3r . For the iconographic connection between Noah and the crucified Christ in the Holkham Bible Picture Book, see Happé, Cyclic Form, 106. ¹³ Peter Meredith and John E. Tailby, The Staging of Religious Drama in Europe in the Later Middle Ages (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 1983), 119. ¹⁴ Richard Rolle, English Writings of Richard Rolle: Hermit of Hampole, ed. Hope Emily Allen (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1963), 35; The Play of Wisdom: Its Texts and Contexts, ed. Milla Cozart Riggio (New York: AMS, 1998), l. 1106. For the importance of the permeability of Christ’s body in medieval devotional poetry see Sarah Beckwith, Christ’s Body: Identity, Culture and Society in Late Medieval Writings (London: Routledge, 1993), 56–63.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
65
death is a traditional part of the Nativity. In Matthew’s Gospel, for example, the wise men’s words ‘King of the Jews’ (2: 2) are to be repeated in that Gospel only when they are written above him on the cross (27: 37). Crucifixion images were likewise ubiquitous in medieval paintings and plays of the Nativity. The Chester playwright dwells on the pre-echo of Christ’s death in the magi’s gift of myrrh, the ointment with which Christ’s dead body is anointed in John (19: 39).¹⁵ The narrative of Juliet’s childhood at the beginning of the play partakes of these traditional intimations of death; and her ‘death’ near the end of the play, like Christ’s death, is likewise surrounded with hopes of resurrection. In John 20: 3–4 Peter and John race to the sepulchre, but John outstrips Peter. When this story was dramatized in medieval Easter liturgy, the youth of John and the age of Peter were emphasized: ‘let the cantor appoint two, one old and the other young, who … should come to the sepulchre, the youth first’. This has been described as the most dramatic part of the Easter liturgy, because the priests impersonate the disciples, and it is therefore unsurprising that it was also performed in the mystery cycles. The stage direction of the N-Town play runs: ‘Hic currunt Johannes et Petrus simul ad sepulchrum, et Johannes prius venit.’¹⁶ When Juliet is believed to have died, there is likewise a race to her tomb in which the young man arrives first. This arrival of the beloved young man, and then the old man, at Juliet’s tomb seems to be dramatically affected by and reminiscent of the race between the young and old disciples. The echo imbues Juliet with sanctity and her death with the hope of resurrection, and it adds another facet to the opposition of youth and age within the play. The religious resonance here, as in the nurse’s enjoyable but apparently inconsequential story, is incorporated into the comedic strand of the play. The old are consistently slow with their delivery of news to the young in Romeo and Juliet. With the nurse, in both her early long-winded ¹⁵ See also the echo of the magi’s words in Mary’s language as she brings her gift of myrrh: Chester Mystery Cycle, 9. 176–81, 18. 329–32. ¹⁶ David Bevington, Medieval Drama (London: Houghton Mifflin, 1975), 38; Karl Young, The Dramatic Associations of the Easter Sepulchre (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1920), 128; The N-Town Play: Cotton MS Vespasian D.8, ed. Stephen Spector, Early English Text Society, 11 and 12 (Oxford: Early English Text Society, 1991), 36. 364. See also the anti-Catholic satire, Regnum Papisticum, translated into English in 1570, which describes this race being performed on Easter day: Thomas Naogeorgus, The Popish Kingdome, or reigne of Anti christ, trans. Barnabe Googe (London, 1570), P4v .
66
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
anecdote, and her refusal to impart Romeo’s proposal without a good sit down and a drink first, this tardiness is played as comedy. Comedy revels in delayed revelation and in this latter scene, at least, Shakespeare is drawing on the humour of the sluggish running slaves of Plautus.¹⁷ With Friar John, however, the gap between young and old creates the fall into tragedy. In the first half of the play, Romeo and Juliet echoes both the situation and the characters of Roman comedy, with its young lovers who bear down the restraints of elderly parents who stand in the way of their love. But after the deaths of Mercutio and Tybalt, the variance between the young and old takes a tragic turn: the young die and the old lose their children. Both the comic and tragic aspects of age are crystallized in the second quarto. In Q2 Old Capulet is far more of a pantaloon: his wife quips that he needs a crutch rather than a sword (Q2 only, A4r14), and himself admits that he is too old for quarrelling ‘and tis not hard I thinke, | For me so old as we to keepe the peace’ (Q2 only, B2v9–10). Likewise his nostalgic remembrance of his visor-wearing youth—‘tis gone, tis gone’—is also only present in Q2 (C3r14–17). Nostalgia is part of the comic presentation of old men (think of Justice Shallow), but Q2 also highlights the tragedic side of old age.¹⁸ The mature women in the play, lamenting the death of those they have nursed and loved, feel their approach to death accelerated by suffering. The nurse, in the midst of the grief for Tybalt’s death says, ‘These griefs, these woes, these sorrows make me old’ (Q2 only, G2v21) and Juliet’s mother, seeing her daughter’s body, says ‘this sight of death, is as a Bell | That warns my old age to a sepulcher’ (Q2 only, L4v26). Death is the absolute which underlies tragedy, but it is rendered pliable in comedy. Susan Snyder has shown how in popular plays performed before Romeo and Juliet resuscitations—such as the reappearance of Emilia in Comedy of Errors, Sempronio in Knack to Know an Honest Man, Dorothea in James the Fourth, and Jack in Peele’s Old Wives’ Tale —all belong to comedy.¹⁹ Through the device of the sleeping potion death becomes something that can be controlled, and hence ¹⁷ Act 2 Scene 4 imitates the slow delivery of news by Pinacium in Stichus, Curculio in Curculio, and, in particular, by Acanthio in Mercator: Plautus, trans. and ed. Paul Nixon, The Loeb Classical Library (London: William Heinemann, 1916–38), v. ll. 274–401, ii. ll. 280–370, iii. ll. 111–224. See also Franklin M. Dickey, Not Wisely but Too Well: Shakespeare’s Love Tragedies (San Marino, Calif.: Huntington Library, 1957), 74–5. ¹⁸ For this characteristic of old men in comedy, see Marvin T. Herrick, Comic Theory in the Sixteenth Century (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1950), 154. ¹⁹ Susan Snyder, The Comic Matrix of Shakespeare’s Tragedies: Romeo and Juliet, Hamlet, Othello and King Lear (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979), 20–1.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
67
a central aspect of Romeo and Juliet’s plot is attuned to comedy. Snyder argues that the turning point away from comedy occurs with the first real death, the death of Mercutio.²⁰ The mood of the play certainly changes with his demise; however, Snyder underestimates the extent to which comedic elements are kept in play. Mercutio’s most famous pun is uttered even as he is dying and the nurse’s doubles entendres outlive both Mercutio and Tybalt. Juliet retains her comedic role as a witty female in her double-edged repartee with Paris outside Friar Lawrence’s cell and the humorous servants, who populate the first act, resurface in Act 4: drawing Old Capulet into banter at the beginning of 4. 2 and 4. 4, and then performing their own comic riff after the rhetorical excesses of the mourning scene. This scene itself has many comic possibilities, and for an audience expecting a happy ending Friar Lawrence’s long-winded speech reads as comic suspense rather than the delay of tragic inevitability.²¹ Shakespeare teases his audience with the possibility of an averted catastrophe up to the moment Romeo kills himself—for example in the otherwise gratuitous death of Paris, which means that the suitor favoured by old Capulet no longer stands as a threat to the young lovers.²² Aristotle writes that pity and fear are evoked when events ‘happen contrary to expectation but because of one another’.²³ This thwarting of expectation is precisely what Shakespeare achieves in Romeo and Juliet. As Snyder has argued: ‘by evoking the world where lovers always win, death always loses, and nothing is irrevocable, a dramatist can set up false expectations of a comic resolution so as to reinforce by sharp contrast the movement into tragic inevitability’.²⁴ Shakespeare uses the comic matrix of his tragedy, therefore, to create the illusion that the young lovers may yet reconcile the families without having to be sacrificed. The comedic aspects of the plot are part of its tragic pleasure, and Shakespeare sustains them until the bitter end. ²⁰ Snyder, Comic Matrix, 62. ²¹ James Forse, ‘Arden of Faversham and Romeo and Juliet: Two Elizabethan Experiments in the Genre of ‘‘Comedy-Suspense’’ ’, Journal of Popular Culture 29/3 (1995): 93; Charles B. Lower, ‘Romeo and Juliet, Iv. V: A Stage Direction and Purposeful Comedy’, Shakespeare Studies 8 (1975): 177–94. ²² E. Pearlman, ‘Shakespeare at Work: Romeo and Juliet’, English Literary Renaissance 24 (1994): 325–6. ²³ Aristotle, Poetics I, trans. and ed. Richard Janko (Indianapolis: Hackett, 1987), 3. 3. 2. ²⁴ Snyder, Comic Matrix, 5.
68
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
The Easter allusions explored by this chapter are central to the comedic strand of the play. Romeo’s propitious dream at the beginning of Act 5, which is unique to Shakespeare’s version of the story, sustains the hope of a happy ending and imputes to Juliet a quasi-divine power: I dreamt my lady came and found me dead · · · · · · · And breathed such life with kisses in my lips That I revived and was an emperor. (5. 1. 6–9)
Romeo imagines that Juliet can bring him back from the dead, and his description of her power is a pre-echo of Isabella’s description of Christ’s salvation: ‘and mercy then will breathe within your lips, | like man new made’ (Measure for Measure, 2. 2. 80–1). Redemption is a second creation of man in God’s image; Isabella’s words, and perhaps Romeo’s too, are derived from the creation of Adam by God’s life-giving breath (Gen. 2: 7). One of the strongest and most thoroughgoing aspects of Romeo and Juliet which highlights the possible religious connotations of the story is the language in which the lovers address each other as ‘the god of my idolatry’.²⁵ Romeo—as his name suggests²⁶—is a pilgrim to the shrine of Juliet and the implications of this are punningly teased out in the lovers’ first exchange: If I profane with my unworthiest hand This holy shrine, the gentler sin is this: My lips, two blushing pilgrims, ready stand To smooth that rough touch with a tender kiss. Good pilgrim, you do wrong your hand too much, Which mannerly devotion shows in this. For saints have hands that pilgrims’ hands do touch, And palm to palm is holy palmers’ kiss. Have not saints lips, and holy palmers, too? Ay, pilgrim, lips that they must use in prayer. O then, dear saint, let lips do what hands do: They pray; grant thou, lest faith turn to despair. ²⁵ For a recent discussion of Romeo and Juliet’s language of ‘incarnate spirituality’ see Graham Ward, True Religion (Oxford: Blackwell, 2003), 5–34. ²⁶ Florio defines ‘Romeo’ as ‘a roamer, a wanderer, a palmer’: John Florio, A Worlde of Wordes, or Most copious, and exact Dictionarie in Italian and English (London, 1598), Ee5r .
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
69
Saints do not move, though grant for prayers’ sake. Then move not while my prayer’s effect I take. (1. 5. 92–105)
The conversation takes the form of a shared sonnet and is phrased in the religious terminology popular in contemporary sonnet sequences. The language of saints, shrines, prayer, and pilgrims that Romeo and Juliet use here was in vogue not only among sonneteers but among many early modern poets and Shakespeare’s other lovers frequently speak in a similar vein.²⁷ The Catholicism of saints and shrines may have led to such language being heard as romantic rather than blasphemous; however, some sonneteers moved beyond the possibly deconsecrated language of Catholicism to describe their love in terms reminiscent of biblical descriptions of Christ, or God the Father.²⁸ Romeo and Juliet behave likewise: when Romeo asks his love what he should swear by, she replies: Do not swear at all, Or if thou wilt, swear by thy gracious self, Which is the god of my idolatry, And I’ll believe thee. (2. 1. 154–7)
With these impulsive words Juliet not only overturns Christ’s injunction, which she has just quoted—‘Sweare not at all’ (Matthew 5: 34)—but she also instructs her ‘god’ to follow the action of God described in Hebrews: ‘for when God made the promises to Abraham, because hee had no greater to sweare by, he sware by him selfe’ (6: 13).²⁹ Shakespeare is not alone in such daring biblical allusions, but he does make particularly striking use of them in this play. When Romeo says to Juliet ‘call me but love, and I’ll be new baptized’ (2. 1. 92) he imputes a godlike power to her: just by speaking that name ‘love’, she will baptize him anew. When he tells Friar Laurence ‘her I love now | Doth grace for grace and love for love allow’ (2. 2. 85–6), he describes Juliet’s return ²⁷ See All’s Well That Ends Well, 1. 1. 96–7; The Two Gentlemen of Verona, 2. 4. 127 ff.; Margaret Aston, England’s Iconoclasts: Laws Against Images (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), 466–7. Helen Hackett fully and subtly explores this language in contemporary sonnet sequences in ‘The Art of Blasphemy?’. ²⁸ See Resolved to Love: The 1592 Edition of Henry Constable’s Diana Critically Considered, ed. Robert F. Fleissner (Salzburg: University of Salzburg, 1980), sonnets 4, 7, 15; Michael Drayton, The Works of Michael Drayton, ed. J. William Hebel (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1961), i, sonnets 12, 19, 29. ²⁹ Shaheen, Biblical References in Shakespeare’s Plays, 513.
70
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
of his affection in the biblical language of Christ’s giving himself to humanity: ‘and of his fulnesse haue all we receiued, and grace for grace’ (John 1: 16).³⁰ These moments, like all the religious allusions so far discussed, are present in both the early texts of the play. However, the Easter nuances, latent in the story which centres on the resuscitation of the protagonist in a tomb, and brought out by Shakespeare through biblical echoes and sacred descriptions of erotic love, are rendered more prominent in the second quarto. The status of the first quarto of Romeo and Juliet is a matter of scholarly debate. New Bibliographers argued that Q1 was a memorial reconstruction by an actor attempting to remember the manuscript underlying Q2. It was therefore considered not to be authorial, and could be dismissed by the textual critic. Recent criticism, however, has shown that there are a number of problems with memorial reconstruction as a theory in general and with its bearings on this text in particular. Laurie Maguire has argued that the textual disturbance caused by an actor’s faulty memory is difficult to identify because it is often identical with that caused by scribes, compositors, revising authors, or adapters. Peter Blayney has debunked a central tenet of the theory of memorial reconstruction, in which the short quartos were ‘stolne, and surreptitious copies’, by showing that no printer would have been eager to pirate Shakespeare’s work.³¹ Lucas Erne has likewise recently suggested that Q1 Romeo and Juliet, along with other ‘bad quartos’, is the product ‘of a more authorized and communal undertaking than has often been assumed’.³² A reader or director approaching Q1 Romeo and Juliet as a text in its own right is unlikely to consider it as deficient. It plays particularly well and is fast paced and coherent.³³ Despite being a considerably shorter text, 92 per cent of Q1’s lines are roughly ³⁰ Sims, Dramatic Uses of Biblical Allusions, 46. ³¹ Harry Hoppe, The Bad Quarto of Romeo and Juliet: A Bibliographical and Textual Study (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1948); Laurie Maguire, Shakespearean Suspect Texts: The ‘Bad’ Quartos and their Contexts (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), 155–211; Blayney, ‘The Publication of Playbooks’, 389–94. ³² Lukas Erne, Shakespeare as Literary Dramatist (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003), 218. ³³ For a discussion of Q1 as ‘an excellent acting text’ see Michael Mooney, ‘Text and Performance: Romeo and Juliet, Quartos One and Two’, Colby Quarterly 26/2 (1990): 124; Pascale Aebischer, ‘Looking for Shakespeare: The Textuality of Performance’, in Lukas Erne and Guillemette Bulens, eds., The Limits of Textuality (Tübingen: Gunter Narr, 2000), 168. Pascale Aebischer directed Q1 in 1998; my grateful thanks to her for discussing its theatrical virtues with me.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
71
equivalent to lines in Q2. This has lead to the idea that Q1 is a deliberately cut play-text. There are a number of speeches that sound truncated, and of more than eight hundred lines unique to Q2, around five hundred occur in blocks of at least four lines.³⁴ The first quarto shows signs of redaction, but this alone is not sufficient to explain the differences between the two earliest quartos. The alternative, and older, explanation—that the early quartos record Shakespeare’s first thoughts and the later printings his revisions—has lately been regaining currency. A number of critics have suggested examples of minor, lexical variants between Q1 and Q2, which add depth or interest to the text and hence seem to suggest Shakespearean revision. Jay Halio, for example, argues that the small differences in the Queen Mab speech are authorial.³⁵ Grace Ioppolo likewise posits that in the process of transferring the ‘grey-eyed morne’ speech from the Friar to Romeo Shakespeare appears to have introduced minor second-thought variants.³⁶ Such analysis supports more ambitious arguments which suggest that single word alterations are themed in such a way as to promote an alternative reading of the text. Steven Urkowitz, for example, has shown that the final scene of Act 2 (where the two texts diverge completely) has been entirely altered in tone as well as content. He argues that Shakespeare has revised the meeting between Romeo and Juliet in Friar Lawrence’s cell so that a scene which in Q1 ‘rings exuberantly’ has been transformed into one which ‘tolls ominously’. Yaship Bains has shown how the death scene of Mercutio has been entirely reconceived in a way which changes his characterization. Katherine Duncan-Jones argues that the references to plague in Q1 are consistently absent in Q2, so that a terrifying reality becomes no more than a vague threat.³⁷ ³⁴ David Farley-Hills, ‘The ‘‘Bad’’ Quarto of Romeo and Juliet’, Shakespeare Survey 49 (1996): 28–31; Kathleen Irace, Reforming the ‘Bad’ Quartos: Performance and Provenance of Six Shakespearean First Editions (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1994), 142. ³⁵ Jay L. Halio, ‘Handy-Dandy: Q1/Q2 Romeo and Juliet’, in Jay L. Halio, ed., Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet: Texts, Contexts and Interpretation (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1995), 135. See also David Farley-Hill’s suggestion that the Prologue was invented by the redactor of Q1, and Q2’s prologue is Shakespeare’s revision of the interpolation: Farley-Hills, ‘The ‘‘Bad’’ Quarto of Romeo and Juliet’, 34, 43. ³⁶ Ioppolo, Revising Shakespeare, 90. ³⁷ Steven Urkowitz, ‘Two Versions of Romeo and Juliet 2.6 and Merry Wives of Windsor 5.5.215–45: An Invitation to the Pleasures of Textual/Sexual Di(Per)versity’, in R. B. Parker and S. P.Zitner, eds., Elizabethan Theater: Essays in Honor of S. Schoenbaum (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1996), 229; Yaship Singh Bains, Making Sense
72
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
The main problem with the traditional argument that Q1 is Shakespeare’s original text and he revised it to create Q2 is the widespread agreement that Q1 is set from a prompt book and Q2 from foul papers. This is suggested by the latter’s permissive stage directions, unstable speech prefixes, unmarked entrances and exits, and ‘false-starts’, which are not present in Q1. A possible reading of the differences between the two texts, which reconciles Q2’s advert ‘newly corrected, augmented, and amended’ with the universally accepted idea of foul paper copy for Q2, is that two years after Q1 had been printed, Romeo and Juliet was popular enough to warrant a new printing. Q1 had been set from the prompt book, which had been formed from a fair copy cut for performance. For the second printing, however, the uncut foul papers are used as the copy-text. Before the papers were sent off to the printer Shakespeare looked over his script and tinkered with it. He revised the stress and tone of the play through the addition of the odd line, altering the occasional word or phrase and rewriting Act 2 Scene 6 entirely. Nevill Coghill describes the revisions in Othello in terms of Shakespeare’s return to and alteration of something with which he was dissatisfied.³⁸ One of the aspects of Romeo and Juliet that Shakespeare returned to the play to alter may have been the submerged Easter narrative. In the revised text, perhaps, he determined to draw it nearer to the surface. Studying Romeo and Juliet in its unconflated texts leads to an illumination of the Easter motif, because of minor variants that are focused precisely on this theme. The divergence is apparent from the opening scene in which Q1 lacks Benvolio and Tybalt’s dialogue in the first brawl. This means that Benvolio’s echo of Christ’s words as he is nailed to the cross ‘they know not what they do’ (Luke 23: 34)—‘you know not what you do’ (A3v 36)—is only present in Q2. This line carries with it an unmistakable overtone of the paschal story and it is in keeping with the text as a whole that it should not be present in Q1, which downplays the sacred aspect of the narrative. Although Shakespeare has removed his sources’ direct references to Easter, liturgical festivals are constantly alluded to throughout both texts. of the First Quartos of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, Henry V, Merry Wives of Windsor and Hamlet (Shimla: Indian Institute of Advanced Study, 1995), 27; Katherine DuncanJones, ‘William Shakespeare: Romeo and Juliet ed. Jill Levenson’, Review of English Studies 52 (2001): 447. ³⁸ Coghill, Shakespeare’s Professional Skills, 200.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
73
The Nurse and Old Capulet both use them to measure time: the nurse repeatedly relates that Juliet was born on Lammas eve (1. 3. 15–23) and Capulet says it is twenty-five years since he wore a mask ‘Come Pentecost as quicklie as it will’ (1. 5. 36).³⁹ It is only in Q2, however, that the love affair is described in relation to the liturgical year. In Q2, as Juliet keeps watch for Romeo, she likens herself to one waiting for a holy day: So tedious is this day, As is the night before some festiuall, To an impatient child that hath new robes And may not weare them.
(Gv 27)
The image of a child’s clothes is suited to Juliet’s half-way state. She is no longer a child precisely because she is about to be covered by a man, as Donne has it: ‘To night put on perfection, and a womans name’.⁴⁰ Juliet’s apprehension of her marital consummation as a holy day is in keeping with her Q2 characterization. Juliet, who is central to the paschal theme, undergoes one of the most striking changes between Q1 and Q2.⁴¹ Juliet’s rich mental life, expressed in Q2 through her erotic soliloquy as she waits for her new husband to arrive and her internal struggle before she drinks the potion, is downplayed in Q1 in which these speeches are absent or appear in a shortened form. In keeping with her smaller role, Q1’s Juliet does not have the active religious life that her Q2 counterpart does. For example, it is only in Q2 that Juliet’s language shows traces of the Book of Common Prayer. When Juliet describes how the news of Romeo’s banishment ‘presses to my memorie, | Like damned guiltie deeds to sinners mindes’ (Q2 only, G3r 7), her words recall the general confession of the Communion service, in which the penitent states: ‘the remembrance of them is grievous unto us, the burthen of them is intolerable’. Juliet’s simile is the product of a mind used to conceiving of sin as a weight pressing on the memory. Likewise, in Q1 Juliet seeks the help of the Friar to solve what is a secular problem ³⁹ See also 2. 3. 127, 5. 1. 57. For the festive associations of July, the month in which the play is set, see Philippa Berry, ‘Between Idolatry and Astrology: Modes of Temporal Repetition in Romeo and Juliet’, in Dympna Callaghan, ed., A Feminist Companion to Shakespeare (Oxford: Blackwell, 2000), 360–3, 368–9. ⁴⁰ The refrain of ‘Epithalamion made at Lincoln’s Inn’: The Poems of John Donne: Edited from the Old Editions and Numerous Manuscripts, ed. Herbert J. C. Grierson (London: Oxford University Press, 1953), i. 141–4. ⁴¹ For the relevance of alteration of a central character to a theory of authorial revision, see Werstine, ‘The Textual Mystery of Hamlet’, 11.
74
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
of keeping faith with Romeo. By contrast in Q2 she is distressed about breaking faith with God as well as her husband (Iv 20), and tells the Friar: ‘God ioynd my heart, and Romeos thou our hands’ (Q2 only, I3r 7), echoing of the Book of Common Prayer’s marriage service: ‘then shall the Priest ioyne their hands together, and say. Those whome God hath ioyned together, let no man put asunder.’⁴² Unique to Q2 likewise are her lines about the state of sin that bigamy would entail: I haue need of many orysons, To moue the heauens to smile vpon my state, Which well thou knowest, is crosse and full of sin. (I4v 23)
In both texts Juliet is estranged from her nurse because of her advice that she should marry Paris, but it is only in Q2 that the sacred fiat against bigamy weighs on Juliet’s mind along with the impossibility of deserting Romeo. To preserve herself from a forced marriage she drinks the potion, is believed to be dead, and is ‘laid into the Tombe’ (Q2 only, Kr 16), from which she hopes to rise again to a blessed life with Romeo. As the climax of Q2 draws closer the hopes and fears of the paschal story crowd in upon the text. The catalyst for the catastrophe is the proposed marriage of Juliet to Paris. Shakespeare has darkened her parents’ motives from the sources in which, miserable at their daughter’s month-long weeping at (as they think) the death of her cousin, they determine on a marriage to make her happy. Even so her father is hesitant to marry her so young. In one source he objects: ‘scarce saw she yet full xvi’, and in the other that: ‘sith as yet she is not attained to the age of eighteen years, I thought to provide a husband at leisure’. Juliet’s youth is also sharply out of line with the normal marrying age of a woman in late sixteenth-century England, which was their early twenties.⁴³ Despite these changes the Capulets in Q1 are not entirely forcing their daughter against her will. Steven Urkowitz has pointed out how, in the scene in which Lady Capulet ⁴² The Booke of Common prayer, and administration of the Sacraments, and other Rites and Ceremonies in the Church of England (London, 1590), Nr , O8v . Shaheen notes both these Prayer Book references, although he does not mention that they are unique to Q2: Shaheen, Biblical References in Shakespeare’s Plays, 517, 520. For evidence of the popularity of, and familiarity of the populace with, the Book of Common Prayer in early modern England see Judith Maltby, Prayer Book and People in Elizabethan and Early Stuart England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 33, 44–5, 118–19. ⁴³ Bullough, Narrative and Dramatic Sources, i. l. 1860; Painter, Romeo and Julietta, 75; Ingram, Church Courts, 129.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
75
first introduces the match to her daughter, the variants between Q1 and Q2 systematically increase the coercive pressure of the mother.⁴⁴ When the marriage with Paris is urged the second time, the parents are again harsher in Q2. In Q1, Old Capulet is described as ‘pittying’ (G4r 30) his daughter’s sorrow. Q2 omits this word and when the argument between father and daughter comes his anger is harsher and more sarcastic. The climax in the divergence in Juliet’s treatment by her parents comes as Capulet prepares for his daughter’s wedding day, unaware that she is lying like death in her room. In Q1 he cries: Make hast, make hast, for it is almost day, The Curfewe bell hath rung, t’is foure a clocke. (Ir 17)
The father is not such a guilty man in this text and his words here are ominous only in that the audience knows that sorrow awaits him. In Q2, however, at this moment the old man is cast as the unwitting Peter in this Passion story. Shakespeare has altered his source to make Peter a prominent name. The church at which Juliet was to be married is dedicated to St Peter instead of St Francis (as it was in Brooke) and Juliet swears she will not marry Paris: ‘by Saint Peter’s Church, and Peter too’ (3. 5. 116). St Peter’s is the name of the church at which Old Capulet was to have betrayed his child into a loveless marriage, and Peter is the name of the servant who, in Q2, he repeatedly names in this scene (Kv 29–31). In Q2 Capulet enters saying: Come stir, stir, stir, the second Cock hath crowed. The Curphew bell hath roong, tis three a clock. (Kv 12)
The second line is almost identical with Q1—‘the Curfewe bell hath rung, t’is foure a clocke’—with only a single change in the time from four to three o’clock. John Jones’s excellent work on the insistent number changes in King Lear argues that they are a sign of the author’s mind ‘fidgeting and tinkering as he attends to a mental itch which is also a symptom of something else’.⁴⁵ I think this is true of this number ⁴⁴ Steven Urkowitz, ‘Five Women Eleven Ways: Changing Images of Shakespearean Characters in the Earliest Texts’, in D. J. Palmer, Werner Habicht, and Roger Pringle, eds., Images of Shakespeare: Proceedings of the Third Congress of the International Shakespeare Association, 1986 (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1988), 298–9. ⁴⁵ Jones, Shakespeare at Work, 176.
76
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
change too. ‘Three a clock’ is a portentous time in a way that four is not. It is the time at which Christ died.⁴⁶ The alteration of the time is accompanied by a change in the way the time is heralded: ‘the second Cock hath crowed’.⁴⁷ At the sound of the second cock crow, Peter realized that he had denied Christ, and Capulet is heading for a similar awakening. Mark is the only Gospel that has the cock crow twice, but this is the more dramatically effective version, as it makes the listener forcibly aware that Jesus’ prophecy is about to come true. The stage directions of N-town play 29 (‘Et cantabit gallus … Et cantabit gallus … and Petyr xal wepyn’) and Jesus’ prophecy in the Towneley cycle (‘or the cok have crowen twyse, | Thou shall deny me tymes thre’) show that in these cycles the second cock crow was certainly staged. We cannot be sure about the Coventry play, but the accounts do record a payment for ‘cokcroing’.⁴⁸ This aspect of St Peter’s story had also been dwelt on in Southwell’s poem Saint Peter’s Complaint, in which three verses are dedicated to the cock crow.⁴⁹ This poem came out almost immediately after Southwell’s execution in 1595, and it went through three editions in that year alone. Despite being written by a Catholic priest, the book found popularity among all denominations, and it would have been surprising if Shakespeare had not known about one of the most talked-about poems of the year.⁵⁰ Southwell’s poetic meditation on Peter’s betrayal of Christ spawned numerous imitations and made the topic highly fashionable both at the time Shakespeare wrote Romeo and Juliet, and during its early performances.⁵¹ The double cock crow in Q2 gives that text a sense of expectation, and of dread, not present in Q1. The ⁴⁶ For another example in which 3 o’clock might carry this significance in Shakespeare, see Steve Sohmer, Shakespeare’s Mystery Play: The Opening of the Globe Theatre 1599 (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1999), 96. ⁴⁷ The curfew bells, which are mentioned in both texts, also had a festal association, see Duffy, Stripping of the Altars, 40. ⁴⁸ The N-Town Play, 29. 198, 212; The Towneley Plays, ed. Martin Stevens and A. C. Cawley, 2 vols., 13 and 14 (Oxford: Early English Text Society, 1994), xx. 452–3; Ingram, Coventry, 289. ⁴⁹ Robert Southwell, Saint Peters Complaint, with other Poemes (London, 1595), Ev . ⁵⁰ Some critics have thought the connection closer than this. One version has a prose dedication to ‘W.S.’, and there are possible puns on Venus and Adonis and Shakespeare’s name in the dedicatory poem. For an overview of this theory see Alison Shell, ‘Why Didn’t Shakespeare Write Religious Verse?’, in Takashi Kozuka and J. R. Mulryne, eds., Shakespeare, Marlowe, Jonson: New Directions in Biography (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006), 85–112. My grateful thanks to Alison Shell for giving me a copy of this essay. ⁵¹ Alison Shell, Catholicism, Controversy and the English Literary Imagination, 1558– 1660 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999), 57–79.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
77
audience becomes aware of the sorrow that is inherent in the father’s bustling joy. As far as the world is aware Juliet has died, but there are some who are hopeful that she will come back to life. When the Friar comes to open the tomb, Q2 draws parallels (absent from Q1) with Christ’s sepulchre on Easter morning. The Q2 stage directions detail that the Friar should carry ‘Lanthorne, Crowe and Spade’ (L3v 1), implements that mark him as ready to open a tomb, which like the women on Easter morning, he will find already open. With a cry he says: Alack alack, what bloud is this which staines The stony entrance of this sepulchre? (L3v 26)
In the New Testament the word ‘sepulchre’ is associated with just one thing: the Easter tomb. The Gospels in the Geneva Bible use ‘sepulchre’ thirty-seven times and only referring to Christ’s tomb. The word is not present in Q1, which has instead: What bloud is this that staines the entrance Of this marble stony monument? (K2r 25)
In Shakespeare ‘sepulchre’ can simply refer to a tomb, but it is noticeable that the word is present in two of his rare, explicitly pious references to Christianity. Henry IV speaks of leading a crusade ‘to the sepulchre of Christ’ to fight under his ‘bless`ed cross’ (1 Henry IV, 1. 1. 19–20), and Gaunt’s paean to England includes a reference to her soldiers who are famed as far away ‘as is the sepulchre, in stubborn Jewry, | Of the world’s ransom, bless`ed Mary’s son’ (Richard II, 2. 1. 55–56). The sacred resonance of the word may be the reason that it is used in Q2 to describe Juliet’s tomb. Until Elizabeth’s reign the Easter liturgy in England centred on a sepulchre built inside the church. The Easter sepulchre appeared in churches in the south of the country around the tenth century and by the sixteenth century they were present in the overwhelming majority of urban parishes.⁵² It is possible that Shakespeare and some of his audience could have been aware of the liturgical ceremonies associated with the sepulchre. At the beginning of the Reformation, Henry allowed the ancient customs of the imposition of ashes on Ash Wednesday, the carrying of palms on Palm Sunday, the Easter sepulchre, and creeping the cross to continue ‘as good and laudable things to put us in memory ⁵² Hutton, Rise and Fall of Merry England, 52–3.
78
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
of what they signify’, and the Easter sepulchre was never specifically forbidden by Royal Injunctions under Henry or Edward. Nonetheless it is clear from the rebuilding of sepulchres carried out under Mary that many were destroyed, and Cranmer’s Articles for Canterbury Diocese (1548) pursues clergy who ‘upon Good Friday last’ used ‘the sepulchres with their lights, having the Sacrament therein’.⁵³ Under Mary, Easter ceremonial such as the veiling of the rood, the lighting of the paschal candle, and creeping the cross were enforced by visitations, and the lack of prosecutions suggests that such physical aspects of the Easter liturgy were widely readopted.⁵⁴ The enthusiastic support for the sepulchre during Mary’s reign does not always show a comparable diminishment at her death. In Ludlow, for example, the only difference between the accounts for the setting-up of the sepulchre in the last years of Mary’s reign and the beginning of Elizabeth’s is, surprisingly, that the latter involves far more expensive and elaborate rites, despite the government’s attempts to suppress the sepulchre.⁵⁵ In the neighbouring diocese to Shakespeare’s, a year after his birth, the clergy were ordered to ‘abolish and put away clean out of your church all monuments of idolatry and superstition, as … sepulchres which were used on Good Friday’.⁵⁶ Bishop Bentham was right in suspecting that clergy and parishioners were hoarding their Easter sepulchres, for evidence of them remains to this day in at least sixteen Warwickshire churches.⁵⁷ Most stone sepulchres were never entirely destroyed, and an inventory of 1566 shows that many had kept even the wooden structures too. A dismantled sepulchre frame turns up in an inventory for St Michael’s, Chester as late as the 1590s.⁵⁸ There is also evidence of Easter sepulchre ceremonies which began to be practised as folk ritual after they had been banned by the Church. In Pembrokeshire, for example, ‘Christ’s bed’ was made on Good Friday by weaving a figure ⁵³ Frere, Visitation Articles, ii. 38, 183–5; Duffy, Stripping of the Altars, 461. ⁵⁴ Hutton, The Rise and Fall of Merry England, 97. ⁵⁵ Churchwardens’ Accounts of the Town of Ludlow, in Shropshire, from 1540 to the end of the reign of Queen Elizabeth, ed. Thomas Wright (London: Camden Society, 1869), 86, 91–2. ⁵⁶ Frere, Visitation Articles, iii. 169. ⁵⁷ Clifford Davidson and Jennifer Alexander, The Early Art of Coventry, StratfordUpon-Avon, Warwick and Lesser Sites in Warwickshire: A Subject List of Extant and Lost Art Including Items Relevant to Early Drama (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 1985), 32, 91–2, 132–3. ⁵⁸ Pamela Sheingorn, The Easter Sepulchre in England (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 1987), 52; Ingram, Coventry, 65, 69, 73.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
79
out of reeds and laying it solemnly, together with a cross, in a concealed place in the countryside.⁵⁹ As such survivals show, the Easter sepulchre was a popular part of the liturgy and it lived on in people’s memories as well as being memorialized in stone. In the late sixteenth century Roger Martin wrote an account of the liturgy of his youth: ‘In the quire, there was a fair painted frame of timber, to be set up about Maundy Thursday, with holes for a number of fair tapers to stand in before the sepulchre, and to be lighted in service time … the sepulchre being placed, and finely garnished, at the north end of the high altar.’⁶⁰ Another account, written in 1593, recalls how the sepulchre in a church in Durham was ‘sett upp in the morninge, on the north side of the Quire, nigh to the High Altar … all covered with red velvett and embrodered with gold’ and describes how, at the Good Friday service there were ‘two tapers lighted before it, which tapers did burne unto Easter day’.⁶¹ A liturgical drama was created in and around the sepulchre in which the host and a cross were ‘buried’ on Good Friday (the depositio) and raised on Easter day (the elevatio), after which the empty tomb was visited by the three Marys and the disciples (the visitatio sepulchri). Scholars have long argued that the dramatic revival in medieval England grew out of the third part of this liturgy, the visitatio sepulchri and the quem quaeritis.⁶² Even though this view is no longer accepted, the liturgy of the sepulchre was certainly intensely dramatic, both during Easter and at Corpus Christi, when Miri Rubin has described it as the site at which drama and eucharistic practices merged.⁶³ The sepulchre ⁵⁹ Hutton, ‘The English Reformation’, 102. See 101–4 for other examples of Easter sepulchre ceremonies which survived outside the church. ⁶⁰ David Dymond and Clive Paine, The Spoil of Melford Church: The Reformation in a Suffolk Parish (Ipswich: Salient Press, 1992), 3–6, 61; Bevington, Medieval Drama, 33. ⁶¹ A Description or Briefe Declaration of all the Ancient Monuments, Rites, and Customes Belonginge, beinge within the Monastical Church of Durham Before the Suppression, ed. James Raine (London: J. B. Nichols, 1842), 10. For another contemporary account of the Easter sepulchre see Philips van Marnix van St. Aldegonde, The Bee hiue of the Romishe Churche, trans. George Gilpin (London, 1579), Cc8v –Ddr . ⁶² Young, Dramatic Associations. For the critique of this idea, see O. B. Hardison, Christian Rite and Christian Drama in the Middle Ages: Essays in the Origin and Early History of Modern Drama (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1965), 12–13; David A. Bjork, ‘On the Dissemination of Quem quaeritis and the visitatio sepulchri and the Chronology of Their Early Sources’, in C. J. Gianakaris, John H. Stroupe, and Clifford Davidson, eds., The Drama of the Middle Ages: Comparative and Critical Essays (New York: AMS, 1982), 1–24. ⁶³ Rubin, Corpus Christi, 294–7. See also Gibson, The Theatre of Devotion, 93.
80
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
was the dramatic focus of the Easter liturgy: curtains and lights were erected round it, and the story which it symbolized was re-enacted. When the Friar arrives at Juliet’s tomb, he is shocked (like the women in the visitatio sepulchri) to find the ‘sepulchre’ already open and light shining out of it (5. 3. 125–7, 135).⁶⁴ In the Bible there are bright angels in the empty tomb and in the Chester Resurrection light pours out of the tomb, blinding the watch: ‘Alas, what ys thys great light | shyninge here in my sight?’ (18. 210–11). Light surrounding or emanating from Juliet’s tomb could also have been reminiscent of the Easter sepulchre, and Q2 highlights this aspect of the staging. Throughout both versions Romeo describes Juliet in terms of the Christian iconography of light: ‘It is the east, and Juliet is the sun’ (2. 1. 45).⁶⁵ However, the final light imagery, uttered at the tomb, occurs only in Q2: A Graue, O no. A Lanthorne slaughtred youth: For here lies Iuliet,and her bewtie makes This Vault a feasting presence full of light.
(L2v 34)
Here the image of a darkened hall, lit by lanterns for late night feasting, slides into a profane refraction of the final feasting place of the blest in a heaven irradiated by the glory of God.⁶⁶ In Romeo’s imagery the radiance of Juliet’s beauty is an analogue to the divine luminescence that shines out of the tomb in the biblical accounts. As Romeo dies and leaves his light beside her, his metaphor is actualized. The boy leading the others to the tomb says: ‘this is the place there where the torch doth burne’ (Q2 only, L4r 22). The Easter sepulchre was lit throughout holy week by the ‘sepulcre lyght’ and the candles surrounding the sepulchre were one of the main focuses of devotion to it: the commonest form of individual benefaction was the endowment of wax to light the sepulchre during holy week. John Garyngton of Mundon, Essex, for example, willed thirty ewes to his ⁶⁴ There is also another possible parallel: some versions of the visitatio sepulchri elaborated on the Gospels to include an episode in which the Marys stopped to buy their spices, before taking them to the sepulchre, just as Romeo stops to purchase drugs at the apothecary before proceeding to Juliet’s tomb: E. K. Chambers, The English Folk Play (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1933), 165–8. ⁶⁵ For the importance of light imagery in the lovers’ descriptions of each other see Caroline Spurgeon, Shakespeare’s Imagery and What It Tells Us (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 310–12. ⁶⁶ ‘Lanthorn’ is a variant form of ‘lantern’, and at this time the word was ‘applied to things metaphorically giving light. Formerly often of persons’, Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. lantern. For a possible interpretation of ‘lanthorn’ as a type of candle-lit grave see Gilian West, ‘Juliet’s Grave’, English Language Notes 28/1 (1990): 33–4.
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
81
parish church in 1517 to pay for ‘ij Tapurs brennyng yerely afore the sepulchre at the fest of Easter as long as the worlde doth stande’.⁶⁷ It is probable that the stage property for Romeo’s ‘torch’ was likewise some form of candle (the latter being used in open air theatres to signify night).⁶⁸ The staging at this point in Q2 would, therefore, have increased the resemblance between tomb and sepulchre. This effect has been powerfully realized in one of the most famous film productions of modern times. In Baz Lurhman’s William Shakespeare’s Romeo + Juliet (1996) religious imagery is fetishized and nowhere more so than in the ‘supersaturated religiosity of the Capulet tomb’. However, Peter Donaldson has described how the thousands of candles which surround Juliet in this production also highlight the sacrality of her resting place: ‘as shots proceed from wide shots to close-ups of Romeo, the myriad candles shift function, from markers of excess to resonance with his grief, and then, as we draw nearer still, to light sources, tender, [and] appropriate’.⁶⁹ In addition to the candles at Juliet’s side, she is also curtained off, just as the sepulchre would have been. According to Q1’s stage directions, after Juliet has drunk the potion ‘she fals upon her bed within the Curtaines’ (Ir 8). Then, after the lament over her body, ‘they all but the Nurse goe foorth, casting Rosemary on her and shutting the Curtens’ (Q1 only, I2v 8). Shortly afterwards Paris enters and ‘strewes the Tomb with flowers’ (Q1 only, I4v 9). Most critics believe that the early quartos can give a guide to contemporary staging, and although caution needs to be exercised over this assumption, it is likely, if this is how the play was staged, that the flower-strewn bed and the flower-strewn tomb are one.⁷⁰ There are no stage directions for moving Juliet, and the careful ⁶⁷ Duffy, Stripping of the Altars, 34; Pamela Sheingorn, ‘ ‘‘No Sepulchre on Good Friday’’: The Impact of the Reformation on the Easter Rites of England’, in Clifford Davidson and Ann Elijenhom Nichols, eds., Iconoclasm vs. Art and Drama (Kalamazoo, Mich.: Medieval Institute Publications, 1989), 161. ⁶⁸ Gurr, Shakespearean Stage, 198; R. B. Graves, Lighting the Shakespearean Stage 1567–1642 (Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1999), 204. ⁶⁹ Peter S. Donaldson, ‘ ‘‘In Fair Verona’’: Media, Spectacle, and Performance in William Shakespeare’s Romeo + Juliet’, in Richard Burt, ed., Shakespeare after Mass Media (New York: Palgrave, 2002), 67, 79, and passim. ⁷⁰ Alan Dessen is the strongest advocate of this theory; see his ‘Q1 Romeo and Juliet and Elizabethan Theatrical Vocabulary’, in Jay L. Halio, ed., Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet: Texts, Contexts and Interpretation (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1995), 107–22. However, for the contrary view see Paul Werstine, ‘Touring and the Construction of Shakespeare Textual Criticism’, in Laurie E. Maguire and Thomas L. Berger, eds., Textual Formations and Reformations (Newark: University of Delaware
82
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
curtaining of her body suggests that she has remained on stage, shielded from the action either by the drapes of her bed, or behind the arras, until ‘Romeo opens the tombe’ (Q1 only, Kr 24) by drawing back the curtains.⁷¹ This curtaining-off of Juliet’s tomb/bed connects it with the Easter sepulchre, which was likewise carefully shielded. The accounts of St Matthew’s, Friday Street, London, for 1547–8, record a payment of nine shillings ‘receyved of Mr. Beche for ij curtyns whiche hong about the sepulker, sold within the tyme of this accompt’. Likewise the accounts of St Michael’s, Bedwardine, Worcester, for 1547, record two pence paid ‘for wyer for the Curteynes for the Sepulter at Easter’. As this wire suggests, it seems that the curtains were fixed in such a way that they could be drawn to conceal or reveal the contents of the sepulchre: ‘item ij blew Cortyns [to] draw afore the sepulture; iij Cortyns of launde to draw afore the sepulture on the ester holy days’.⁷² Flowers, such as those which the Nurse strews on Juliet’s bed, and Paris strews on her grave, were likewise a ubiquitous part of the decoration of the Easter sepulchre. The anti-Catholic satire, Regnum Papisticum, translated in 1570, describes the rites at the Easter sepulchre thus: And frankensence and sweete perfumes before the bread doth burne: With tapers all the people come, and at the barriars stay, Where downe upon their knees they fall, and night and day they pray: And violets and every kinde of flowres about the graue They straw.⁷³
The candles, curtain, and flowers surrounding Juliet may all have recalled an Easter sepulchre, but the strongest connection with that liturgical object is perhaps that, as discussed above, Juliet’s tomb is also Press, 1998), 45–66. John Jowett has persuasively argued that the stage directions of Q1 are probably derived from the printing house: ‘Henry Chettle and the First Quarto of Romeo and Juliet’, Papers of the Bibliographical Society of America 92/1 (1998): 53–74. I am cautious, therefore, of arguing that Q1’s stage directions are accurate records of sixteenth-century staging. However, even if they were written in the printing house, they could still record a memory of performance. ⁷¹ A survey of the stage directions of early-modern plays suggests that the secretion of a bed behind stage curtains, presumably in the discovery space, was a common device: Alan C. Dessen and Leslie Thomson, eds., A Dictionary of Stage Directions in English Drama, 1580–1642 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000), s.v. bed and discover. ⁷² Neil C. Brooks, ‘The Sepulchre of Christ in Art and Liturgy, with Special Reference to Liturgical Drama’, University of Illinois Studies in Language and Literature 7/2 (1921): 81. ⁷³ Naogeorgus, Popish Kingdome, P3v .
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
83
her bed. In The Rape of Lucrece Shakespeare describes Lucrece’s head as ‘entomb`ed’ between the hills of her pillow: ‘Where like a virtuous monument she lies | To be admired of lewd unhallowed eyes’ (391–2). Lucrece’s bed is described as a tomb to prefigure her death, and Juliet’s tomb, conversely, is staged and described as a bed to convey the hope of her rising to new life. Paris enters in Act 5 Scene 3 with flowers, which could be brought either to sweeten a bridal bed, or to dress a corpse. As Gertrude says as she throws blooms on Ophelia’s body: ‘I thought thy bride-bed to have decked, sweet maid, | And not t’have strewed thy grave’ (Hamlet, 5. 1. 242–3). Paris’s flowers express the equivocal nature of this tomb as he reimagines it as her bridal bed: ‘sweet flower, with flowers thy bridal bed I strew. | O woe! Thy canopy is dust and stones’ (5. 3. 12–13). Beds and graves were frequently twinned in religious texts for didactic purposes. Lancelot Andrewes, for example, continuously stresses the religious significance of the metaphor of sleeping for death and waking for resurrection in his Easter sermons. In his 1606 Easter sermon on Romans 6: 9—‘knowing that Christ being raised from the dead, dieth no more, death hath no more dominion over him’—Andrewes wrote: he said ‘death is … a fall … like to that of men into their bedds, when they make accompt to stand up again’ … The very word which the Apostle useth (εγ ερθεις —egertheis) implieth … a fall into a bed in our chamber; where though we lye (to see to) little better than dead for a time; yet in the morning we awake and stand up notwithstanding.74
The correlation between tombs and beds, which is created in Romeo and Juliet to convey a hope of resurrection for Juliet, is present also in the Easter sepulchre, a tomb which was known to be only temporary. In the medieval and early Tudor period the Blessed Sacrament was honoured with people’s most expensive possessions, which was often their bed linen. People who lived along the route of the York Corpus Christi procession were instructed by the civic order of 1544: ‘that every howseholdr that dwellith in the hye way ther as the sayd procession procedith, shall hang before ther doores & forefrontes beddes & coverynges of beddes of the best that they can gytt and strewe before ther doores resshes and other suche fflowers’.⁷⁵ People also bequeathed bedding to the sepulchre. In 1500 Henry Willyams willed to a church ⁷⁴ Lancelot Andrewes, XCVI Sermons (London, 1629), Nn3v . ⁷⁵ Johnston and Rogerson, York, i. 283.
84
Comedic Form and Paschal Motif
in Stanford, ‘my coverlet to the use of the sepulcre’ and in the same year Basilla Laxton left a bed-sheet to the same sepulchre.⁷⁶ Elizabeth Hatfield, likewise, in 1509 bequeathed her arras bed to the parish church in Hedon, York, to be used to cover her tomb on her year’s mind (the anniversary of her death) and to adorn the sepulchre at Easter.⁷⁷ It was no doubt the costliness of the bed linen that caused it to be donated to the Easter sepulchre, but once the structure was swathed in coverlets and sheets, and curtained off, it may have reminded the pious of a bed—such as that in the Corpus Christi Carol—in which the Blessed Sacrament was merely to sleep, to rise again on Easter day.⁷⁸ Elizabeth Hatfield’s bequest, in which her bed was used to adorn both her tomb and the sepulchre, shows the powerful association between the burial of ordinary men and women and that of the host at Easter. Likewise, John Cheyne of Bedford willed in 1413 that the tapers that burned beside his body during his funeral should ‘brenne to fore the sepulcre from good freiday in to Esterday’.⁷⁹ The strongest symbolism, however, occurred in churches whose permanent stone sepulchres doubled as the tombs of wealthy patrons. These people had created a resting place for themselves which would also be the sepulchre for the host, and the tombs were adorned with Resurrection imagery which interwove personal hopes with a visualization of the Gospel story.⁸⁰ This combination of an expensive tomb with the liturgical burial place of Christ seems particularly resonant for Romeo and Juliet and strikingly there is a fine example of one such sepulchre in the chancel of Holy Trinity, Stratford, underneath Shakespeare’s mural. This is the tomb of Dean Thomas Balsall, erected in the late fifteenth century, and decorated ⁷⁶ R. M. Serjeantson and H. Isham Longden, ‘The Parish Churches and Religious Houses of Northamptonshire: Their Dedications, Altars, Images and Lights’, The Archaelogical Journal 70/279 (1913): 229–30. An 1538 inventory for the Benedictine Priory at Castle Hedingham, Essex, listed silk cloths and sheets for the sepulchre: Sheingorn, ‘ ‘‘No Sepulchre on Good Friday’’ ’, 150. ⁷⁷ Brooks, ‘The Sepulchre of Christ’, 82. ⁷⁸ In the Corpus Christi Carol Christ’s bleeding body lies o