Amazon.com: Tasks in Second Language Learning (Research and Practice in ...): Virginia Samuda, Martin Bygate, Christophe...
325 downloads
4084 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Amazon.com: Tasks in Second Language Learning (Research and Practice in ...): Virginia Samuda, Martin Bygate, Christopher N. Candlin, David R. Hall
Tasks in Second Language Learning (Research and Practice in Applied Linguistics)
Close Window
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/images/140391186X/ref=dp_image_0?ie=UTF8&n=283155&s=books5/6/2011 7:15:57 AM
Research and Practice in Applied Linguistics
All books in this series are written by leading researchers and teachers in Applied Linguistics, with broad international experience. They are designed for the MA or PhD student in Applied Linguistics, TESOL or similar subject areas and for the language professional keen to extend their research experience. Titles include: Francesca Bargiela-Chiappini, Catherine Nickerson and Brigitte Planken BUSINESS DISCOURSE Sandra Beatriz Hale COMMUNITY INTERPRETING Geoff Hall LITERATURE IN LANGUAGE EDUCATION Richard Kiely and Pauline Rea-Dickins PROGRAM EVALUATION IN LANGUAGE EDUCATION Marie-Noëlle Lamy and Regine Hampel ONLINE COMMUNICATION IN LANGUAGE LEARNING AND TEACHING Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate TASKS IN SECOND LANGUAGE LEARNING Cyril J. Weir LANGUAGE TESTING AND VALIDATION Tony Wright CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT IN LANGUAGE EDUCATION Forthcoming titles: Dick Allwright and Judith Hanks THE DEVELOPING LEARNER Anne Burns LITERACIES David Butt and Annabelle Lukin GRAMMAR Alison Ferguson and Elizabeth Armstrong COMMUNICATIONS DISORDERS Lynn Flowerdew CORPORA AND LANGUAGE EDUCATION Sandra Gollin and David R. Hall LANGUAGE FOR SPECIFIC PURPOSES
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
General Editors: Christopher N. Candlin and David R. Hall, Linguistics Department, Macquarie University, Australia.
Marilyn Martin-Jones BILINGUALISM
Norbert Schmitt VOCABULARY Helen Spencer-Oatey and Peter Franklin INTERCULTURAL INTERACTION Devon Woods and Emese Bukor INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES AND PROCESSES IN LANGUAGE EDUCATION
Research and Practice in Applied Linguistics Series Standing Order ISBN 1–4039–1184–3 hardcover Series Standing Order ISBN 1–4039–1185–1 paperback (outside North America only) You can receive future titles in this series as they are published by placing a standing order. Please contact your bookseller or, in case of difficulty, write to us at the address below with your name and address, the title of the series and one of the ISBNs quoted above. Customer Services Department, Macmillan Distribution Ltd, Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS, England
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Martha Pennington PRONUNCIATION
Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate Lancaster University
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Tasks in Second Language Learning
© Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate 2008
No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2008 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin's Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN-13: 978-1-4039-1186-5 hardback ISBN-10: 1-4039-1186-X hardback ISBN-13: 978-1-4039-1187-2 paperback ISBN-10: 1-4039-1187-8 paperback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 17
9 16
8 15
7 14
6 13
5 12
4 11
3 10
2 09
1 08
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham and Eastbourne
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
To the memory of Chris Brumfit
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgements
viii
Introduction
Part 1 1. 2.
1
Background
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
7
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context: Some Key Issues
18
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context: Some Key Issues
37
4.
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
51
5.
Defining Pedagogic Tasks: Issues and Challenges
62
6.
Engaging Learning Processes: Implications for the Use of Second Language Tasks
71
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
82
3.
7.
Part 2
Interactions between Research and Practice
8.
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
133
9.
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
192
Part 3 10.
Research Directions
Part 4 11.
Exploring Tasks 233
Resources
Further Resources
267
References
277
Name Index
291
Subject Index
295 vii
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Contents
Our most central acknowledgments should be apparent through the references in these pages. We owe particular debts of gratitude to tutors, colleagues and students, through the years at Lancaster, Leeds, London, Manchester, Michigan, Oregon, Reading and Sonoma; to our patient and constructive editors; and to our enduringly supportive families, including Dave, for never forgetting to ask whether we’d finished writing this book. Lauzerte Summer 2007
viii
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Acknowledgements
Quote 1.1 Dewey on educative, uneducative and miseducative tasks If one means by a ‘task’ simply an undertaking involving difficulties that have to be overcome, then children, youth, and adults alike require tasks in order that there may be continued development. But if one means by a task something that has no interest, makes no appeal, that is wholly alien and hence uncongenial, the matter is quite different. Tasks in the former sense are educative because they supply an indispensable stimulus to thinking, to reflective inquiry. Tasks in the latter sense signify nothing but sheer strain, constraint, and the need of some external motivation for keeping at them. They are uneducative because they fail to introduce a clearer consciousness of ends and a search for proper means of realization. They are miseducative, because they deaden and stupefy; they lead to that confused and dulled state of mind that always attends an action carried on without a realizing sense of what it is all about. They are also miseducative because they lead to dependence upon external ends; the child works simply because of the pressure of the taskmaster, and diverts his energies just in the degree in which this pressure is relaxed; or he works because of some alien inducement – to get some reward that has no intrinsic connection with what he is doing. (1913/1975: 54–6)
This book explores the ‘educative’, ‘uneducative’ and ‘miseducative’ properties of tasks in second language education. As part of the raw material that second language teachers, learners and researchers work with in different ways, tasks have been an element in second language teaching and research for over 30 years, and yet their use continues to invite controversy and debate. One of the aims of this book is to explore why this should be so, and to consider what people do to make tasks educative or uneducative, why this can happen and what the alternatives might be. 1
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Introduction
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Part 1 Background
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Part 1 offers a broad overview of the historical and conceptual background from which ‘tasks’ have emerged as a significant force in second language education and research. The use of holistic activities for learning is not unique to language education, and has been one of the major focuses of educational debate over the last century. Nor indeed are tasks exclusive to education: they are a key research construct throughout the social sciences. Hence in Part 1 we review the construct of ‘task’ from a broad perspective, before narrowing the discussion to the use of tasks within language education.
5
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Introduction
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
1.1
Holistic activity
In talking about the role of tasks in second language learning, our starting point is the assumption that the aim of second/foreign language teaching is to develop the ability to use the target language. By ‘use’ we mean that the language is used not only to practise or show mastery, but also for information (personal and professional), for social, political and artistic purposes, as well as for aesthetic pleasure. One way of engaging language use is through holistic activity.
Concept 1.1
Holistic activity
Use is ‘holistic’ in the sense that it involves the learners’ knowledge of the different sub-areas of language – phonology, grammar, vocabulary and discourse – to make meanings. Holistic activities contrast with analytical activities, in which phonology, grammar, vocabulary and discourse are each taught and studied separately, and not used together. Analytical activities are designed to reduce the number of aspects of language which the learners have to attend to, so they can concentrate more narrowly on a selected target feature, as in a pronunciation exercise focusing on a selected phonological contrast, for example. Holistic activities involve the learner in dealing with the different aspects of language together, in the way language is normally used. Much first language learning occurs through holistic activities, and it seems likely that holistic activities can also play a significant role in second language learning, teaching and testing.
Tasks are one kind of holistic activity. The holistic nature of tasks can be represented schematically in a diagram such as the following: In Figure 1.1, the words in italics are points where the learner is required to make a choice. The overall purpose is broadly set between teacher and 7
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
1
8
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Overall purpose of task
wording
Figure 1.1
wording
meaning
wording
wording
grammaticisation
grammaticisation
pronunciation
pronunciation
Schematic structure of a task
learners. The italics indicate that to achieve this purpose the learner must choose and sequence relevant meanings, words and grammar, with the pronunciation following in the light of that choice. By involving learners in making purposeful, on-line choices of meaning and form, a task engages holistic language use: through engaging with the task, learners are led to work with and integrate the different aspects of language for a larger purpose. In contrast, analytical language activities have been traditionally used in language teaching to focus attention on a pre-selected language item or items, as in a drill involving the production of a particular vowel sound or a minimal pair contrast without attention to meaning.
Concept 1.2
Analytical activity
An exclusively analytical activity, like an exercise focusing on a single verb form, would predetermine the meaning, or the meaning and word, or the meaning, word and grammatical structure, or even the meaning, word, grammatical structure and pronunciation, with the learner being required to work with the target forms at some point of focus isolated by the exercise.
The argument of this book is that it is in holistic language work that key language learning processes take place, and that tasks are invaluable in achieving this purpose. Yet, although tasks seem to offer a key resource for language learning, the very fact that they are holistic creates a fresh series of educational challenges. For, like any teaching activity, tasks need to be
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
meaning
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
9
• What goals can different tasks serve for different students? • How can tasks be exploited by teachers and learners to meet those goals? • What are the strengths and weaknesses of different tasks, and of different ways of using them? • What could learners and teachers usefully know about tasks that the tasks are made to serve learners’ and teachers’ ends? An enduring pedagogical challenge – and a recurring theme in this book – is how to balance a focus on aspects of the target language in ways that enhance learning, without losing the overall holistic quality of normal language use.
1.2
A sample task: Things in Pockets (TIP)
Example 1.1 illustrates what we mean by ‘task’ and the weight of some of these questions. In this task, participants are given a bag of objects, allegedly the contents of a person’s pockets, and are invited to work in small groups to speculate on the identity of that person. Each group needs to reach a consensus on their ideas concerning the person’s identity, presenting and justifying their conclusions to the rest of the class, first as an informal oral presentation and finally in written form as a poster or report.1 In this version, the groups use a chart to record their initial hypotheses about the person’s identity under categories such as age, gender, occupation, etc. The chart also requires groups to register the degree of probability/possibility of each initial hypothesis:
Example 1.1
A sample task
Things in Pockets An overcoat was found on a plane after a flight from San Francisco to London. The objects that you have in front of you were all found in the pockets of that overcoat. Can they tell us anything about the owner? As a group, look at everything carefully and share your ideas about the identity of the owner of the overcoat. Be ready to present your group’s ideas about the person to the rest of the class and to explain how certain you are about your ideas.
1 A different version of this task appears in H. Riggenbach and V. Samuda (2000) Grammar Dimensions: Form, Meaning, Use: Book 2, Boston, MA: Heinle & Heinle.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
seen to serve a learning goal in the eyes of the learners and teachers who use them. This raises important central questions, in particular:
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 1.1
(Continued)
You can use the chart to organise your ideas and to show how certain you are about each one. For example, if you are 100% certain that you know the person’s name, write it in column 3 (100% certain). But if you are not at all certain about the person’s name, use Column 1 (less than 50% certain). If you are almost certain that you know this person’s name, use Column 2 (90% certain). Less than 50% certain (it’s possible)
90% certain (it’s probable)
100% certain (it’s certain)
Name Sex Age Marital status Occupation Likes and interests Recent activities Any other ideas
In the rest of this book, we will be drawing on this task (henceforth TIP) as a reference point for highlighting issues involved in task use, design and research. In Example 1.1 we see what the task looks like as it appears on the page, as set out by a materials writer or task designer. While this reflects how the designer envisages the task unfolding when enacted, it does not in itself say anything about what actually will happen or about the different ways that learners and teachers might redefine and reinterpret the designer’s intentions. To highlight areas of potential difference between the task on paper and what happens when it is enacted, Breen (1987) distinguishes between ‘task-as-workplan’ and ‘task-in-process’:
Quote 1.2
Breen on task-as-workplan and task-in-process
Any language learning task will be reinterpreted by a learner in his or her own terms. This implies that a pre-designed task – the task-as-workplan – will be changed the moment the learner acts upon it. The task-as-workplan will be redrawn so that the learner can relate to it in the first place and, thereby, make it manageable. ... When considering what happens during language learning tasks, we can initially distinguish between the original task-as-workplan and the actual task-in-process. It is the latter which generates typically diverse learning outcomes and the quality and efficacy of any task must be traced directly to its use during teaching and learning. (Breen, 1987: 24–5)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
10
11
Example 1.1 then is an illustration of the TIP task-as-workplan. Example 1.2 is an illustration of the same task-in-process. It shows students engaging with the TIP task as part of their normal classroom coursework in a ‘low intermediate/high beginner’ intensive English pre-academic programme in a North American university. The extract in Example 2.1 is taken from an early phase of the task: the teacher has divided the class into groups and invited them to brainstorm their initial thoughts about the identity of the person. The learners in this example are four young women – three Japanese and one Swiss-French – in their early twenties who were familiar with each other as classmates, and who also associated with each other as friends outside the classroom. Here they are looking at the objects, and having established the owner as male, are trying to figure out his likely marital status on the basis of a diary and other personal items:
Example 1.2
Sample task-in-process: Things in Pockets
Group 1: Marital status episode 1
5
10
15
20
A: Maybe he divorced C: Why? A: Because Paula Paula maybe Paula his girlfriend N: Divorced? C: Can I see? Y: Yeah at lunchtime (indicating diary) C: Or, or N: Yes, but C: he married but he has girlfriend A: Not divorced? C: Not divorced but he has another girlfriend A: Ahh, it’s possible Y: If, if he married and he has girlfriend why write down in schedule A: [noooo] C: [noooo] (laughter) A: Ohhh C: Divorced N: (reading from diary) Wice presi vice president lunch vice president Y: His company? N: Or Y: (reading from diary) Anniversary C: What’s this thing? Y: Anniversary, wedding anniversary (.) He’s married C: {huh? A: {huh? Y: Wedding anniversary
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 1.2 25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
(Continued)
C: Anniversary? A: huh? N: But maybe something something A: huh? N: Maybe just anniversary not wedding A: for him? or or⫽ C: ⫽friend? Y: if [he] N: [no] because here, here (points to diary), he have golf A: Yeah C: Yeah (laughter) N: No (.) Play golf Y: So he married (.) Wedding anniversary N: Maybe it’s just, it just uh⫽ A: ⫽write down N: Yeah Y: Ohh N: Yeah maybe ten years that he will be married (.) because he play golf not Y: But daytime N: Yes, but Y: Yeah his wife? I don’t know (laughter) C: He married uh one year ago then he⫽ N: ⫽Yeah maybe⫽ A: ⫽Divorced C: No don’t divorce but he married uh maybe one month ago no one year ago and he still play with her N: Maybe A: Or my, my opinion N: Or may, oh sorry Y: You see Paula is his wife C: Yeah N: Yes, but why Paula send him this (showing document) Y: He’s busy (laughs) N: (reading from document) Sorry I didn’t meet you on Sunday C: Yeah I think she is not wife N: No (reading from document) because I was worried that somebody might see us together C: Huh? N: (reading) Please forgive me A: (reading) Call me [soon] N: [call me] soon A: No, not wife
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
12
65
70
75
13
C: No, no A: Huh? Wait (.) Somebody? N: Yeah A: Ahhh, he’s married Y: Yeah A: He’s married C: He’s married A: Ohh [wow] C: [wow] A: Sure? C: Sure (laughter) Y: Trust me (laughter)
This extract illustrates one episode in a very early phase of the task-inprocess, a phase in which the learners are exploring possible interpretations of part of the task materials. The instances of laughter, the number of overlapping turns and the sustained focus on one topic suggest a high level of engagement; much of the talk here is highly elliptical, possibly reflecting the shared frame of reference of the task materials, the social relationships among the participants, as well as the in-group flavour of this phase of the task, where ideas are being developed collaboratively in private, and not yet ready for public consumption. In terms of the workplan, we might expect that the demands of later phases of the task (presentation and justification of ideas to the rest of the class and the teacher; writing up final conclusions, for example) to give rise to other kinds of talk. But we cannot be sure of this from the workplan itself; nor can we be sure of this from this extract of this phase of one small episode of the task-in-process. The intricacy of the relationships between phases of the task-as-workplan and phases of the task-in-process and how those relationships relate to our understanding of the use of tasks in second language pedagogy and research is a recurring theme in this book, and we will be returning at various points to these examples later.
1.3
Features of tasks for second language learning
In this section we draw on the TIP task to illustrate a number of general features of second language tasks. First, as can be seen, the task is holistic in the sense that it requires learners to decide on potential relevant meanings, and use the phonology, grammar, vocabulary and discourse structures of the language to convey these in order to carry out the task.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
Tasks in Second Language Learning
A second feature of any task is the need to achieve one or more meaningful outcomes. This is essential for the dynamic of the task. In the TIP task, the learners were asked to come up with a description of the likely owner of the objects. Depending on the teacher’s instructions this could take one of various forms: written, oral or possibly a non-verbal representation, such as a picture, set of notes or ID forms, selected from an array. What these have in common is a target outcome in the form of a verbal or nonverbal representation of information. That is, it is not sufficient for them to produce accurate language: they have to produce a pragmatically credible response. Third, the task could not work without the input material – in this case, the objects and the instructions. Here, the input material is the springboard for all that follows. Changing the objects or the instructions could change the procedures the students follow or the target outcome, or both. Input material is therefore an essential element. In following the instructions in order to work towards the task outcome, learners engage in a process. ‘Task process’ refers to any language process(es) used in working towards an outcome. This can include the language used to plan and organise the work, to distribute sub-tasks, to monitor progress, to identify and share information, to suggest or hypothesise missing information, interpretations or solutions; to evaluate, counter, agree/ disagree; and to negotiate an outcome such as a conclusion, solution, report or graphic representation. Both the product and the process are by definition necessary: without a target product there is no call for the process. But equally, without a process learners cannot achieve a product. Sometimes particular task processes are targeted by the teacher, whether explicitly or implicitly. Sometimes they are shaped by the way the task has been designed. Sometimes task processes are left to the initiative of the learners. The task also involves a number of different phases. This is one key dimension where tasks differ from analytical activities like drills or exercises, which once started involve the same operations from beginning to end. From a task-as-workplan perspective, the phasing of a task generally involves breaking down the overall task into a series of interlocking steps (see Example 1.1) with the aim of making the task more manageable. Here phases might be framed in terms of an initial search for information contained in or relating to the input material, an exchange and pooling of opinions and ideas relating to that information, leading to some form of synthesis based on the demands of the task. These phases reflect a route for moving through the task envisaged by a task designer or teacher. From a task-in-process perspective, however, the task is phased by the actual
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
14
15
strategies that the learners use at different points in the activity. Possible examples here are an initial organisation and administration phase as learners orient themselves to the input material and to ways of engaging with it, followed by a phase of pooling, checking and exchanging preliminary ideas (as in Example 1.2), followed by a phase involving reorganisation and reworking of those ideas, a phase involving coordination and consolidation, a phase involving rehearsal and further reworking and checking, and finally a phase involving public presentation. These may or may not correspond with the phases set out in the workplan since the task-in-process is phased by the learners’ need to make the content and the language manageable as the task unfolds. Phasing, then, is an element of the workplan and process and may be accomplished differently in each. An important point here is that the different phases of a task can serve different functions, and thus may give rise to different types of exchange and different types of talk. This means that generalisations about generic features of ‘task interaction’ or ‘task talk’ may be of limited value without reference to the phase of the task in which they occur. Pedagogically, it is important for teachers to know what aspects of the language are being targeted, whether in terms of product or processes, since without this knowledge/awareness they cannot prepare and brief the students or provide relevant feedback. Likewise, in research terms, knowing the likely scope of a particular task with different kinds of students in different contexts is likely to be useful in developing the design and use of a repertoire of tasks. It may also shed light on second language learning. Language development is complex: it involves a number of distinct, though related processes such as social interaction, perception, ideational comprehension, motor control, contextual mapping and strategic control. Hence there are multiple ways in which a task can be exploited to contribute to development and a number of ways in which they can be researched. So although both the pedagogic use and the study of tasks start from the assumption that holistic activities in second language teaching are valuable, there are as many distinct ways of using and researching them as there are ways of conceptualising holistic language use and holistic language learning. Another major factor that is important for pedagogical exploitation concerns conditions, which in any context influence the way people work. ‘Conditions’ can refer to the use and manipulation of external pressures, such as the imposition of time pressure, the use of competition or collaboration or both, and provision of pre-, while and post-task support. ‘Conditions’ can also include the atmosphere in and ethos of the class, the attitudes of the group members, their level of proficiency, how far teacher
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
Tasks in Second Language Learning
and students attend to the processes and outcomes of the task, and how far work on the task is perceived to contribute to learning. Finally, the different uses of a task can be worth exploring. A task like TIP can fulfil a number of aims. For example, it can be used to raise awareness of a language area which learners need to get to grips with; it can be used to encourage them to use what they already know to communicate in an area they have difficulty with; it can be used to give them the opportunity to improve their handling of a particular area; or it can be used to give them a basis for reflection for a future task. The features of a task such as TIP can be summarised as follows:
Concept 1.3
General features of a task
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
It involves holistic language use. It requires a meaningful target outcome or outcomes. It necessarily involves some individual and group processes. It depends on there being some input material. It is made up of different phases. It is important for teachers – and at some point the learners – to know what is being targeted in the language learning purpose. 7. The conditions under which it is implemented impact on process and outcome and can be manipulated and variously exploited. 8. It can be used for different pedagogic purposes at different stages of learning.
1.4 The use of tasks for second language learning: some key questions Apart from the first general defining characteristic, the remaining seven all make explicit a wide range of ways in which tasks can be exploited to contribute to language learning, and raise questions that we could usefully know more about. For instance, in terms of process, we might find it useful to understand the ways in which students can work through a task, and how far any differences affect learning. It might help to know how far the task can be made to work at different levels of proficiency and what happens in each case. It could be enlightening to understand the different options that teachers have to introduce tasks, to monitor tasks and to provide post-task follow-up, and to see whether they work in different ways, and why. In the classroom from which Example 1.2 was taken, this task was used at the start of a cycle of work and was followed by teacher input. (A full description of a study of this task can be found Samuda, 2001: Part 2, 7.1). But the same task could be used in many other ways, so it would be valuable
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
16
17
to see how it can be deployed at other points in a cycle of work, and how else it could be synchronised with the teacher’s input. Also, we do not know how far a task of a particular format, such as this one, can be recycled to reuse language that is becoming familiar while introducing new language. And we do not know how this task differs from others. So far we have characterised ‘task’ as a set of general elements, drawn from a single example; this has been done to sketch some of the broad questions that this book seeks to explore and to create a shared frame of reference for the background issues that we turn to next – influences from general education and human sciences research. However, later in Part 1 we return to the issue of what a task is and what it is not by exploring in more detail some of the ways that second language pedagogic tasks have been defined in the literature and some of the challenges that these definitions present.
1.5
Summary: the general elements of a task
We have noted that a task is a holistic activity, and that such activities are important to the extent that they target and enable the development of appropriate second language processes and appropriate language products. As we have seen, however, holistic activities of necessity involve the use of all aspects of language, and allow more choice than analytical exercises. This means that they can be harder for teachers and testers to use, since the language work will be relatively more complex and less predictable. For this reason it is worth attempting to understand how tasks work. A first step has been to identify some of the key elements involved. With these in mind, the aims of this book are to promote understanding of tasks for four main reasons: 1. To support development in the design of tasks. 2. To improve our understanding of how to select, adapt and use tasks in the classroom with different learners. 3. To increase our understanding of how to stimulate classroom language use. 4. To increase our understanding of the processes of language learning, and in particular the dynamic relationship between language knowledge and language use. Our overall aim is to promote an empirical approach – to explore the use of tasks, their potential, ways of improving their design or use, and if necessary to seek out and develop alternative resources for achieving our aims.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Language Use, Holistic Activity and Second Language Learning
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context: Some Key Issues
Many of the principles underlying the design and use of what we now call ‘tasks’ in second language pedagogy owe their genealogy to developments in general education over the last century. In this chapter, we trace some of those developments. We start with the influence of Dewey and a number of issues that his work brings into focus. These are: • experience as a catalyst for learning; • the role of personal relevance and purposeful activity in mediating the world of the learner and classroom learning; • the role of functional relevance in classroom learning; • the roles of learners as active agents in their own learning. Then through a series of brief illustrations we explore how these issues variously come into play in the work of educators centrally concerned with relationships between experience and learning, with examples from Freinet, Kilpatrick, Kolb and Freire. From here we explore connections between these themes and aspects of the work of Bruner, focusing on: • the organisation of knowledge and learning for use; • the complementariness of the development of analytical and intuitive thought; • the building of systematic relationships between concrete experiences and broader generalisation. After this, we draw on the work of Barnes to explore aspects of these themes in relation to the role of classroom talk in the development of 18
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
2
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
19
knowledge, focusing on:
The themes brought into focus here, together with the pedagogic challenges that they pose, will recur in various forms throughout this book.
2.1
The influence of Dewey: experience and learning
Since the nineteenth century, educationists have been increasingly concerned to make school learning socially purposeful or functional. By 1913 Dewey was arguing that classroom learning needed to be focused and shaped so that it met the personally held interests that pupils brought with them, and the ends that they held in sight:
Quote 2.1
Dewey on means and end
The problem may be stated as one of the relations of means and end. Anything indifferent or repellent becomes of interest when seen as a means to an end already commanding attention. Or seen as an end that will allow means already under control to secure further movement and outlet. But, in normal growth the interest in means is not externally tied onto the interest in an end; it suffuses, saturates, and thus transforms it. (Dewey, 1913/1975: 25–6)
In presenting material as a string of received facts unconnected to pupils’ interests and personal goals, ‘traditional’ classroom learning was thus seen by Dewey as essentially ‘abnormal’.
Quote 2.2
Dewey on traditional classroom learning
Learning here means acquisition of what already is incorporated in books and in the heads of the elders. Moreover, that which is taught is thought of as essentially static. It is taught as a finished product, with little regard either to the ways in which it was originally built up or to changes that will surely occur in the future. (1938/1963: 19)
In this approach to education, a focus on ‘finished product’ treats learning as a simple accretion of items of knowledge, unconnected both from each other and from pupils’ broader experiences of the world. It is based on a static body of knowledge which is backward-looking, at best reflecting
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
• relationships between process and product in learning; • the roles of exploratory and final draft talk in learning.
20
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 2.3 Dewey on school learning Almost everyone has had occasion to look back upon his school days and wonder what has become of the knowledge he was supposed to have amassed during his years of schooling, and why it is that the technical skills he acquitted have to be learned over again in changed form in order to stand him in good stead. Indeed, he is lucky who does not find that in order to make progress, in order to go ahead intellectually, he does not have to unlearn much of what he learned in school. These questions cannot be disposed of by saying that the subjects were not actually learned, for they were learned at least sufficiently to enable a pupil to pass examination in them. One trouble is that the subject-matter in question was learned in isolation; it was put, as it were, in a water-tight compartment. When the question is asked, then, what has become of it, where has it gone to, the right answer is that it is still there in the special compartment in which it was originally stowed away. But it was segregated when it was acquired and hence is so disconnected from the rest of experience that it is not available under actual conditions of life. (Dewey, 1938/1963: 47–8)
Dewey argued for a congruent relationship between pupils’ larger purposes and any narrowly focused learning activities. Here, personal relevance is the key. Thus in his view (1917/1963) a functional approach helped to make the subject as a whole relevant by connecting it to personal experience. The implication is that we need to seek out new ways of teaching so that the content is accessible, useful and relevant given the levels of experience and understanding of learners. Thus disciplinary content needs to be made available to learners in terms of their own experience, and how it relates to what they already know. To this end, we need to seek out ways that pupils may be brought into active mental engagement with new content and in ways that relate to what is already familiar. For Dewey, active mental engagement entailing the integration of what is known with what is new is necessarily effortful.
Quote 2.4 Dewey on good teaching Good teaching, in other words, is teaching that appeals to established powers while it includes such new material as will demand their redirection for a new end, this redirection requiring thought – intelligent effort. (Dewey, 1913/1975: 58)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
the competencies of competent users, rather than those of learners. For Dewey, this leads to a fundamental misconception of the relationship between learning and the outside world:
21
Although experience provides the site for effective learning to take place, it also raises its own set of pedagogic challenges: how to uncover ways in which appropriate pedagogical experiences can be provided for learners in sequences that will make school subjects relevant. Some macro-element is necessary to provide a credible, motivating context for ‘intelligent effort’. For Dewey, the macro-element for bringing together the learner’s experience of the real world, the logic of the subject matter and the accumulated experience of educators was through the use of ‘overt and executive activities’, in which the learner learns through the interaction between thought and action.
Concept 2.1
Overt and executive activities
By ‘overt and executive activities’ Dewey was referring to activities in which the learner had to make some decisions or perform a skill, what others have referred to as the use of ‘procedural knowledge’. (Johnson, 1996)
The search for functional relevance grounded in experience and realised through holistic activity has underpinned the development of various pedagogic initiatives since Dewey’s time; some of these have been directly influenced by Dewey’s thinking and others have developed independently. To illustrate, we begin with two examples from the early part of the twentieth century: the work of Freinet, developed independently of Dewey’s; and the work of Kilpatrick, developed with explicit reference to aspects of Dewey’s thinking.
2.2 2.2.1
Experience and learning: some pedagogic examples Freinet
Freinet, working in rural primary schools in France between the First and the Second World Wars, wrote:
Quote 2.5
Freinet on sense of purpose
L’enfant qui sent un but à son travail et qui peut se donner tout entier à une activité non plus scolaire mais simplement sociale et humaine, cet enfant sent que se libère en lui un besoin puissant d’agir, de chercher, de créer. [The child who has a sense of purpose in their work and who can entirely give themselves over to an activity so that it is no longer schoolwork, but just social human activity – that child feels come to life a potent need to do, to search, to create.] (Freinet, 1971: 88)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Freinet’s pedagogic practices, which were embedded in the child’s natural environment, amply illustrate this point. Here is an extract from a colleague’s observation of his interaction with a group of children whom he had taken out of the classroom for a walk in the countryside they were familiar with. In this extract we see how Freinet exploited this familiarity to draw his pedagogic focus from the children’s existing knowledge and experience, thereby making the task of producing descriptions of locations, or calculating measurements, functionally relevant:
Quote 2.6
Freinet drawing on his pupils’ experience
– M’sieur, disait Lulu, là-bas, je vois ma mére dans mon champ! – Où? Où? – Explique bien, Lulu, disait le maître; explique, pour que nous la voyions aussi. – Regarde, là-bas: tu vois la route? Tu vois le contour du pont? Eh bien, monte le petit chemin: tu vois le grand chêne? Eh ben! C’est un peu plus loin de ce côté. ... – M’sieur, on est haut, ici! – On est plus haut que le château? Et des comparaisons s’ensuivaient des évaluations de distances, de mesures, des notions de longueurs, et voilà le point de départ d’une excellente leçon de calcul donnée à même la vie.’ – [Sir, Lulu says, over there, I can see my mother in my field! – Where? Where? – Explain it properly, Lulu, says the teacher; explain so that we can see her as well. – Look, over there: see the road? See the edge of the bridge? Well, follow the little pathway: you see the big oak? Well! It’s a bit further on along there. – ... – Sir, we are high up here! – Are we higher than the château? And comparisons followed on from the estimates of distances, measures, notions of length, and that was the starting point for an excellent lesson in arithmetic, based in life itself.] (Freinet, 1971: 24–5)
In Freinet’s work, then, learning arises from the learner’s experience; it is given a purpose by that experience and is shaped by the teacher’s mediating role in enabling connections between individual experiences and broader generalisations. Freinet’s search for functional relevance is perhaps most famously exemplified in the printing press he set up in his primary school.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
22
23
This, he believed, would help his pupils to see writing as socially functional and as a result enable them to become effective readers and writers – engaging children in the act of printing would bring them into contact with the act of writing, which itself could be grounded in the child’s own priorities. By 1926, children in his primary school were producing printed bulletins to exchange with twinned schools, and some were starting to produce little illustrated books (Freinet, 1971: 55). Within a year or so of the first exchanges, newsletters were exploring questions which could still provide a focus for pedagogic task research today.
Quote 2.7 Freinet on the use of the printing press as a means of linking experience and learning: eliciting pupils’ views L’imprimerie dans ses rapports avec le travail scolaire: a) Suivez-vous seulement l’intérêt dominant de la classe, selon le travail et les saisons, ou bien adoptez-vous des centres d’intérêt etablis d’avance? Comment procéder? Quels résultants semblent obtenus? b) Comment lier l’enseignment à l’imprimerie? Notamment: quel parti tirer des imprimés journaliers ou bi-mensuels reçus par échange? Qu’en faire après la lecture? Quelle est l’utilisation possible? Peut-on supprimer des manuels? Lesquels? Comment? c) Comment relier les imprimés? Quel est le format le plus pratique? d) Quelle a été l’appréciation de votre I.P., de votre directeur, de la population? [The printing press and its relationship to the work of the class: a) Do you simply follow the main interest of the class, depending on the work schedule and the movement of the seasons, or do you instead adopt centres of interest drawn up in advance? How to proceed? What seem to be the outcomes? b) How to link teaching to the printing press? In particular: how to exploit the daily or bi-monthly printings received in exchange? What to do with them after they have been read? How might they be used? Could we dispense with textbooks? Which ones? How? c) How to bind the printed pages? What is the most practical format? d) What was the evaluation of your school, your head teacher, the local population?] (Circulaire de mai 1927, cited in Freinet, 1971: 61–2)
2.2.2
Kilpatrick and the ‘Project Method’
Arguing in 1918 that ‘the child needs the opportunity to purpose’, Kilpatrick proposed that ‘the purposeful act’ should be made the unit of instruction. This would prepare the child for life as a democratic citizen
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
24
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 2.8
Kilpatrick on project types
Type 1: Purpose: to embody some idea or plan in external form (building a boat; writing a letter; presenting a play) Type 2: Purpose: to enjoy some aesthetic experience (listen to a story; appreciate a picture; hear a symphony) Type 3: Purpose: to straighten out some intellectual difficulty, or solve a problem (finding out how dew falls; how New York City outgrew Philadelphia) Type 4: Purpose: to obtain some degree of skill or knowledge (learning the irregular verbs in French) (Kilpatrick, 1918, 1922: 16)
At the broadest level, the focus on learner purpose suggests a resonance between this conceptualisation of ‘project’ and some of the current conceptualisations of pedagogic task mentioned above. For Kilpatrick the learner’s purpose is made central through the nature of the pedagogic activities to be engaged with; and by schematising differences in the kinds of ‘purposeful act’ to be pursued, Kilpatrick is also schematising the potential for different relationships between project type and learner performance. Since he also argued that one project type could be used in relation to another as a means to an end, he also situates projects within a broader sequence of pedagogic activity. While admitting that there was perhaps an inevitable element of overlap in the project types, Kilpatrick nonetheless considered some form of overall classification valuable because of the light shed ‘on the kinds of projects teachers may expect and on the procedure that normally prevails in the several types’ (Kilpatrick, 1918: 16–17). Thus, projects were not to be seen as discrete activities, but in relationship with each other, and embodying patterns of typicality that could be recognised and anticipated by teachers. As can be seen from these examples, Freinet and Kilpatrick were both concerned with issues of functional relevance and ways of making connections between school learning and the outside world. Both were also concerned with holistic learning through purposeful and relevant activity. However, there is some difference in their respective orientations to the pedagogic focus of such activity. For Freinet, pedagogic focus was what emerged naturally from interactions between learner, experience
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
while also constituting ‘the present worthy life itself’ (Kilpatrick, 1918, 1922). The ‘purposeful act’ was realised pedagogically though four types of project work:
25
and activity, and thus we assume not necessarily predictable in advance. For Kilpatrick, the pedagogic focus was potentially embodied in the type of activity itself, thus enabling some element of predictability and planning both within that activity and across a sequence of activities. Interestingly, these differences in orientation prefigure differences in subsequent conceptualisations of task-based second language learning, and consequently, as we will see below and in Chapter 9, they are still reflected in current debates on the use of tasks in second language pedagogy. Our next examples, drawn from approaches to experiential and participatory education, build on these themes by introducing elements of reflexivity and criticality as a means of bridging experience and learning. 2.2.3
Experiential education
A number of educational initiatives broadly rooted in Dewey’s ‘learning by doing’ principle have come to be grouped under the umbrella term ‘experiential education’, as seen in Lewin 1(951) and Kolb (1984). A number of different experiential education initiatives build on Dewey’s view that certain elements need to be in place if learning is to proceed from experience.
Example 2.1 • • •
Elements of learning from experience
Observation of surrounding elements. Knowledge obtained by recollection. Judgment which puts together what is observed and what is recalled to see what they signify.
(Dewey, 1938/1977)
One example of how these principles have been reflected across various approaches to experiential education is Kolb’s four-phase model, which characterises learning in terms of an experiential cycle.
Example 2.2 1. 2. 3. 4.
Kolb’s four-phase experiential cycle
Concrete experience. Reflective observation. Abstract conceptualisation. Active experimentation (to test out newly developed principles).
(Kolb, 1984)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Although the number of phases in the experiential cycle may vary from model to model (Pfeiffer and Jones, 1975, propose five phases; Greenaway, 1995, three), experiential models all construe learning as leading from experience via a sequence of phases, crucially involving an element of concrete experience as starting and end points, and an element of reflection. Reflection on experience is thus seen as the key mediating factor between the experience itself and the types of learning it may motivate. It is through reflection on experience (usually guided and supported by the teacher) that learners develop meta-awareness of both the processes and the outcomes of learning, and through increased metaawareness, gradually achieve greater autonomy and self-direction in their learning. Involvement in choosing, designing, evaluating and revising the activities they engage with is thus seen as a key element in experiential practice. Kolb’s model, and its various adaptations, have been applied across a diverse range of domains and disciplines, including (among many others) outdoor and environmental education (e.g. ‘Outward Bound’ programmes); cultural and community journalism (e.g. Foxfire magazine, grounded in local community and culture, written and published by secondary school pupils in southern Appalachia); pilot training (through the use of full flight simulators); sports training and music education (through the use of master classes). The work of Viljo Kohonen and colleagues in Finland is an example of how experiential principles have been applied in foreign language education.
Quote 2.9
Kohonen on experiential education
The learner is seen as a self-directed, intentional person who can be guided to develop his or her competencies in three interrelated areas of knowledge, skills and awareness: (1) Personal awareness: self-concept and personal identity, realistic self-esteem, self-direction and responsible autonomy (2) Process and situational awareness: management of the learning process towards increasingly self-organised, negotiated language learning and self-assessment, including the necessary strategic and metacognitive knowledge and the selfreflective interpersonal skills (3) Task awareness: Knowledge of language and intercultural communication: the meta-knowledge of language at the various levels of linguistic description, providing an unfolding ‘map’ of the whole language learning enterprise. (Kohonen, 2001: 36)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
26
27
Kohonen’s statement of experiential principles explicitly frames experiential learning as a developmental process involving guidance and support, which in turn suggests cyclical progressions of ‘doing’, followed by reflection on doing. It also implies a restructuring of conventional classroom role relationships and discursive practices. Practical examples of second language pedagogies that also embody these principles include Dam, 1995; Dam and Gabrielson, 1988; Legutke and Thomas, 1991; Finch et al., 2003. 2.2.4
Participatory education
Participatory education, rooted in an agenda for radical political and social change, offers a slightly different perspective on experience and learning. It grew out of mother tongue literacy programmes developed by Paulo Freire with non-literate fieldworkers and shantytown dwellers in Brazil during the 1950s. Here Freire sought to engage learners in dialogue about key words relating to problematic issues in their daily lives, and from this invited them to reflect on and critically analyse those issues, exploring the causes underlying the problems and possible ways of taking action to change them. The development of literacy was thus seen as a key for enabling marginalised members of society to become active participants in transforming social and political processes.
Quote 2.10
Freire on education
Education either functions as an instrument which is used to facilitate the integration in to the logic of the present system and bring about conformity to it, or becomes the practice of freedom, the means by which men and women deal critically and creatively with reality and discover how to participate in the transformation of their world. (Freire, 1970: 15)
Central to this approach is a view of education as a ‘participatory’ and transformative process:
Quote 2.11 education
Auerbach on Freire’s model of participatory
Both the content and the processes of this model invite learners to become the subjects of their own education. Content centers on problematic issues from their lives so literacy is immediately relevant and engaging. Because this reality is problematized (presented in all its complexity without predetermined solutions), participants become the creators rather than the recipients of knowledge. They
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 2.11
(Continued)
engage in a process of reflection and dialogue, developing both an understanding of the root causes of the problem and generating their own alternatives for addressing it. (Auerbach, 1992: 17)
In practice, this is enacted through a four-phase cycle of reflection and action.
Example 2.3 Freire’s four phase process of participatory curriculum development 1. Initial identification/generation of a shared problem. 2. Dialogue about the problem, critical reflection on its root causes and generation of alternative ways of addressing it. 3. Decoding and recoding: focus on linguistic analysis in terms of relationships with learners’ own lives and the problem identified in Phase 1. 4. Action: return to the problem identified in Phase 1, and work to change the conditions that give rise to it.
The starting point, then, is an aspect of the world as experienced by the learner. This leads to critical reflection on relevant underlying issues and possible ways of addressing them, which in turn leads to analysis of those aspects of language that may enable the learner to engage with and take action on the issues identified. Freire’s phased cycle of experience, critical reflection, analysis and action not only situates the experiences that learners bring with them, but also provides a means for mediating and structuring those experiences for learning, for action and for political and/or social change. Freire’s model has been adapted for use in very different contexts from those in which it originally evolved – for example, multicultural literacy in American primary schools (Ada, 2003), family literacy programmes (Ada and Campoy, 2003), second language instruction for adult immigrants and refugees (Wallerstein, 1983) and workplace learning programmes (Auerbach and Wallerstein, 1987) (Chapter 9). As can be seen from these examples, the approaches to participatory and experiential education touched on here share a broad Deweyian concern with personal and social relevance as the touchstone for learning, and with education that is rooted in learners’ actual and potential experiences of the world. Likewise, they illustrate some of the ways that
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
28
29
the slipstream of experience may be distilled to serve as a springboard for learning through iterative phases of experience and reflection. However, a question worth exploring is the extent to which the phases highlighted in experientially-driven models such as those referred to here capture the full range of complex cognitive processes involved in learning from experience. In the next two sections, we consider issues relating to the kinds of support that may be necessary to enable learners make systematic connections between individual experience and broader generalisations, and some of the pedagogic challenges that this implies.
2.3
The influence of Bruner: learning for use
Some fifty years after Dewey, Bruner argued similarly that in any area of education learners need to have the target knowledge available. This knowledge needs organising mentally so that it is arranged in ways that dovetail with the ways in which the material will be needed in contexts of use. Or as Bruner put it, there is a distinction between learning general structures of patterns, and the ability to use them:
Quote 2.12
Bruner on learning for use
Whether the student knows the formal names of these operations is less important for transfer than whether he is able to use them. (Bruner, 1960/1977: 8)
‘Learning for use’ leads us to situate the learner not simply in terms of the classroom, or of the target material, isolated from the social world. Bruner argued that pupils learning a subject in school (physics, for example) are hindered by having to master the ‘middle language’ of textbooks rather than being given the opportunity to engage with the discipline itself. In a famous formulation, he characterises learning not only as gaining control over information or skills, but also as joining a community of thought.
Quote 2.13
Bruner on learning
[I]ntellectual activity anywhere is the same, whether at the frontier of knowledge or in a third-grade classroom. What a scientist does at his desk or in his laboratory, what a literary critic does in reading a poem, are of the same order as what anybody else does when he is engaged in like activities – if he is to achieve
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 2.13
(Continued)
understanding. The difference is in degree, not in kind. The schoolboy learning physics is a physicist, and it is easier for him to learn physics behaving like a physicist than doing something else. (Bruner, 1960/1977: 14)
Thus, the child should not be simply cast in the role of ‘pupil’, but encouraged to situate herself as a practitioner, albeit a novice practitioner, in a new domain: through cognitive involvement, educational engagement is seen as extending into participation within a community. Elements of what Bruner argues here are also found in the work of Wertsch (1985), Lave and Wenger (1991, and elsewhere) and reflected in applications of neo-Vygotskian thought to second language learning (e.g. Lantolf, 2000) as we see in Part 2. In much of his early work, Bruner highlights the complementary nature of analytic and intuitive thinking in school learning, and emphasises the need to pay attention to the development of intuitive understanding, even in subject matter commonly associated with analytical thought:
Quote 2.14 Bruner on the complementarity of analytic and intuitive thinking The development of effectiveness in intuitive thinking is an objective of many of the most highly regarded teachers in mathematics and science. The point has been repeatedly made that in the high school plane geometry is typically taught with excessive emphasis upon techniques, formal proofs, and the like, that much more attention needs to be given to the development of students who have a good intuitive feel for geometry, students who are skillful in discovering proofs, not just in checking the validity of or remembering proofs with which they have been presented. ... Similarly, in physics, Newtonian mechanics is typically taught deductively and analytically. In the judgment of many physicists, at least, there is too little attention to the development of intuitive understanding. (Bruner, 1960/1977: 56)
The development of intuitive understanding may well depend on learners being given the space to confront problems, as well as their willingness to explore ways of engaging with those problems. This suggests a pedagogic climate which encourages effortful mental engagement with alternatives rather than the simple pursuit of a right answer.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
30
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
Bruner on the development of intuitive thinking
It seems likely that effective intuitive thinking is fostered by the development of self-confidence and courage in the student ... Such thinking, therefore, requires a willingness to make honest mistakes in the effort to solve problems. (Bruner, 1960/1977: 65)
However, Bruner argued that importantly linked to the kind of educational engagement envisaged here is the ability to seek out regularity or patterns of similarity across different experiences.
Quote 2.16
Bruner on regularity across experience
Children, as they grow, must acquire ways of representing the recurrent regularities in their environment, and they must transcend the momentary by developing ways of linking past to present to future – representation and integration. (Bruner, 1973: 348)
What is highlighted here is the need for the child to be actively involved in making generalisations on the basis of different experiences, and for connections to be found across them. Bruner (1983) provides an illustration of how this might happen over time.
Concept 2.2
Formats and their role in learning
In studying the emergence of language in the young child, Bruner reports a number of studies from a longitudinal dataset which reveal a significant level of organisation in the discourse children experience, with a striking amount of repetition over time. Children repeatedly encounter a small number of structured discourses, which Bruner terms ‘formats’. By engaging with adults in these formats, children appear to go through a gradual process of acquisition. At first the focus is on the meaningful structure of the format, with the child grasping and responding to main meanings within the discourse. From an overall grasp of the sequence, the child then gradually comes to perceive and focus attention on particular sound sequences, words, phrases or utterances which occur at different points in the discourse. Since the formats recur, the sequences are also repeated, and the child is steadily able to recognise, recall and produce more and more of them. This suggests that multiple encounters with the kinds of activities we have been calling tasks can enable these connections to be made.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Quote 2.15
31
Tasks in Second Language Learning
In common with aspects of Dewey’s work, Bruner highlights not simply the importance of experience-based education, but also the need to create opportunities for the learner to build systematic connections between individual instantiations of concrete experience, and generalisation at a broader level of abstraction. The kinds of activities that learners engage with have an important role to play here. A full understanding of that role, however, implies an understanding of how those activities work, the kinds of talk they might generate and the learning they might give rise to. We consider some implications of these issues for second language task research and pedagogy in Chapters 7 and 9; we also return to other aspects of Bruner’s work later in this chapter.
2.4
The influence of Barnes: classroom talk and learning
In a series of studies carried out in British secondary schools during the 1970s, Barnes explored relationships between two types of classroom talk and learning (Barnes, 1976; Barnes and Todd, 1977; 1995). Focusing on pupils’ talk during group work in a number of curricular subjects, including English literature, history and science, Barnes distinguishes between talk that is ‘exploratory’ and talk that is ‘final draft’, and emphasises qualitative differences between the processes surrounding the two types of discourse and their roles in learning. Exploratory talk is characteristically (but not exclusively) associated with pupil–pupil talk in the absence of a teacher during collaborative group work; final draft talk is characteristically associated with ‘well-shaped utterances’ elicited by the teacher:
Quote 2.17
Barnes on exploratory and final draft talk
I call [pupils’] groping towards a meaning ‘exploratory talk’. It is usually marked by frequent hesitations, rephrasings, false starts and changes of direction. I want to argue that it is very important whenever we want the learner to take an active part in learning, and to bring what he learns into interaction with that view of the world on which his actions are based. That is, such exploratory talk is one means by which the assimilation and accommodation of new knowledge to the old is carried out. [.....] The more a learner controls his own language strategies and the more he is enabled to think aloud, the more he can take responsibility for formulating explanatory hypotheses and evaluating them. (Barnes, 1976: 28–9) Final draft language is the contrary of exploratory: far from accompanying (and displaying) the detours and dead-ends of thinking, it seeks to exclude them and present a finished article, well-shaped and polished. (Barnes, 1976: 108)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
32
33
Whereas ‘final draft’ language is presented for evaluation, and seems to deny the possibility of revision and the learning processes that can go with it, ‘exploratory’ talk seems to allow, and indeed encourage, the active formulation and reformulation of hypotheses, engagement with understanding of the material, and with the thought processes that enable that understanding. However, as Barnes points out, the normative order of a school does not easily give rise to contexts for the development of exploratory talk: ‘When teachers entered the groups, asking questions intended to further their pupils’ understanding, the style of speech shifted from the exploratory towards a style appropriate to showing the teacher that they had ‘the right answer’ (Barnes, 1976: 108). Peer collaboration on group tasks then is one context where exploratory talk may be fostered.
Quote 2.18 Barnes and Todd on types of exploratory talk most likely to contribute to learning [The types of group talk most likely to contribute to learning was when pupils engaged in]: a) b) c) d) e)
solving a problem interpreting texts making choices on the basis of evidence applying a principle to new cases planning and carrying out a productive activity to fulfil criteria which may either have been given or defined by the students themselves f) exploring an issue for which there is no single right answer (Barnes and Todd, 1995: 88)
Barnes argues that different tasks seem to give rise to different strategies on the part of individuals and their groups, and the studies show how group tasks can be designed and used to generate exploratory talk which participants use to seek out responses to problems. Barnes is therefore charting a significant distinction between process and product, one to which we return at the end of this chapter. At the same time, he traces connections between the surface discourse produced by the groups and the underlying thinking which drives it. The tasks that pupils undertake can thus be seen as creating space within the classroom for the development processes needed to engender understanding and conceptual mastery: this means that final draft language is not abandoned, but rather that significantly more space is created for learners to work their ways towards a satisfactory final draft. In other words, tasks are used here to open up the dynamics of learning to the attention of learners and to
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
34
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 2.4 Barnes’ model for sequencing exploratory and final draft talk 1. Focusing Stage: Topic presented in full class, and pupils encouraged to verbalise necessary preliminary knowledge as a basis for group work. 2. Exploratory Stage: Pupils in groups carry out any necessary manipulation of materials and talk about issues that their attention has been directed towards on the basis of current knowledge and understandings. 3. Reorganising Stage: Teacher refocuses attention, tells groups how they will be reporting back and how long to prepare for it. 4. Public Stage: Groups present their findings to one another and this leads to further discussion. (Based on Barnes, 1976: 197)
Discussing relationships between aspects of the tasks that pupils engage with and the nature of the talk that may be produced, Barnes distinguishes between tasks based on ‘well-formed problems’ (open to single solutions, the validity of which can be demonstrated) and tasks based on problems where many different ‘answers’ are possible. Barnes argues that in tasks of the latter type, pupils need to decide for themselves on what principles the data will be selected and ordered, while in ‘well-formed tasks’ this is largely decided for them. Thus, speech is likely to have a more complex part to play in learning in problems that are not well formed, and indeed, as Barnes points out, most of the choices that we make in everyday life are based on problems that are far from well formed. This raises an important pedagogic challenge regarding the amount of structure inherent in the tasks pupils engage with: too little structure and pupils don’t know what to do; too much and ‘we interpose ourselves between the children and the experience we want our pupils to recode’ (Barnes, 1976: 194). Paradoxically, in their different ways, both extremes can have a restricting effect on the ways pupils carry out the task.
Quote 2.19
Barnes on the teacher’s dilemma
This is every teacher’s dilemma: how can one support pupils with a framework which does not at the same time constrict their participation? How can one enable the learner to order his own learning without abandoning him in a trackless wilderness? (Barnes, 1976: 88)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
teachers, not merely to structure ‘final draft’ performance. Importantly though this is not to deny a role for final draft talk, and Barnes outlines a pedagogic model that places the two types of talk in relation to each other in a sequenced progression of stages.
35
This dilemma, rooted as it is in a tension between freedom and control, brings us back to many of the issues raised earlier by Dewey. As Dewey himself recognised, reconceptualising traditional practices does not in itself offer solutions, but in fact brings into focus a different set of problems that need to be understood in their own terms. For example, Dewey famously argued that both the advocates and the opponents of progressive education appear to share the same mistaken assumption (albeit for different reasons) that the use of holistic activity implies that learning is left unguided; this assumption, Dewey argued, leads to two extreme, but equally erroneous, positions about the nature of holistic learning activities.
Quote 2.20
Dewey on chaos and magic
One extreme is to neglect [holistic learning activities] almost entirely, on the grounds that they are chaotic and fluctuating ... The other extreme is an enthusiastic belief in the almost magical educative efficacy of any kind of activity.. When we vibrate from one of these extremes to the other, the most serious of all problems is ignored: the problem, namely, of discovering and arranging the forms of activity ... which are most congenial, best adapted [to the learners]. (Dewey, 1910: 44)
The two opposing perspectives on holistic activity highlighted here are also relevant to understandings of second language pedagogic tasks. As we shall see, on the one hand, there appears to be a belief that second language pedagogic tasks engage learning processes as if by magic simply through interaction, and any attempt to shape the way learners carry out a task, whether through design or implementation, is to intervene in the those processes. On the other hand, there is a belief that task engagement is too chaotic, fluctuating and inconsistent to provide a basis for a systematic pedagogy. Dewey, however, was arguing for a more constructive though more difficult way forward through a systematic approach to the use of holistic activities:
Quote 2.21
Dewey on ‘organising’ experience
The problem for progressive education is: What is the place and meaning of subject-matter and of organization within experience? How does subject matter function? Is there anything inherent in experience which tends towards progressive organization of its contents? (Dewy, 1917/1963: 20)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in an Educational Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
That is, while traditionalists are mistaken to insist exclusively on teacherled learning, and progressivists are right to wish to bring learner-driven activities into the classroom, progressivists are wrong to advocate total learner control, and traditionalists are right to argue for the teacher’s role in developing coherence through the curriculum. The flaw is to believe that learner-driven activities are not amenable to systematic use by the teacher: we need to explore how the logic of our disciplines can be brought into contact with our learners’ experiences of the world. Planning, then, ‘must be flexible enough to permit free play for individuality of experience and yet firm enough to give direction toward continuous development of power’ (Dewey, 1938/1963: 58). What we are calling ‘tasks’ can thus be seen as a means of creating experience-based opportunities for language learning; the management of those opportunities however remains an enduring pedagogic challenge.
2.5 Summary: holistic, experience-based tasks in an educational context: the case for a systematic pedagogy Thus far we have highlighted some key recurring themes from general education. In particular, we have noted that for there to be a connection between learning activity and the learner, there needs to be a connection between learning activity and learning, and more specifically between learning activity and behaviour. This implies seeking congruence between the whole learner, particular learning activities and particular learning behaviours. That is, there needs to be a relationship between activity and learning. In second language education, this entails the creation of opportunities for learners to associate the target language with action and the need to achieve some goal, and through this, thought about how to accomplish it and reflection on the outcomes. Activities like Dewey’s ‘overt and executive activities’ have a significant role to play in enabling such connections to be made. But in second language education, as in general education, the design and implementation of those activities is dependent on an understanding of how they work.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
36
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context: Some Key Issues
The use of holistic activities fits not only with educational thinking. Since at least the middle of the twentieth century, holistic tasks have been used in human sciences research (including applied language study) as a means of eliciting and sampling behaviour. In what follows we distinguish between the study of tasks in what might be considered relatively stable, ‘bounded’ contexts, and the study of tasks in the broad social context in which they occur. From examples of research carried out on holistic tasks in both contexts, we explore a set of issues relating to the use of holistic tasks for research purposes: • consistency of research focus; • impact of task type on task performance; • participant vs. researcher interpretation of the task as given. These issues bring into focus a number of implications for ways of researching second language tasks and for understanding learners’ performance on those tasks.
3.1
The study of tasks as ‘bounded’ contexts
For many researchers in the human sciences, holistic tasks are of interest because they provide a bounded context with a goal (asking people to recount their ‘near-death’ experiences, as in Labov, 1972; Labov and Waletzky, 1967; or asking chess grandmasters to build on opening moves in a chess game, as in de Groot, 1978). Within these boundaries, researchers can focus on aspects of task performance and use them, if desired, as a basis for comparison (e.g. how different people carry out the same or different tasks). Performance on tasks can thus create a window 37
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
3
Tasks in Second Language Learning
on observable facets of performance itself (discourse patterns in neardeath experience stories) or on underlying cognitive processes (charting the eye movements of a chess grandmaster scanning the next move to tap into mental representations of expert knowledge). Performance can be on novel tasks (as in the near-death stories) or on typically occurring tasks in a familiar domain (as in the chess example), or on combinations of both (a novel task in a familiar domain, for example). Importantly, however, although the context of the task may be bounded, instructions given to participants may be open and nondirective. An example of this is a well-known applied language study.
Example 3.1 Similarities in organisational structure in task performance Linde and Labov simply asked participants to describe their apartments, and investigated the strategies that speakers used. They found that well over 90 per cent of all interviewees structured their descriptions as though they were giving a guided tour, walking with the interviewer through the apartment from one room to another. (Linde and Labov, 1975)
Interestingly, then, although the interviewer’s question was extremely simple and very open, nearly all the speakers spontaneously chose to follow the same organisational structure. Also using a holistic task in a bounded context, Levelt (1989) reports a study focusing on a central problem in speech and writing, that of ‘linearising’ information. All speech and writing is inevitably linear. This creates a potential problem because semantic content can be sequenced in numerous different ways, and in fact is not sequenced until it is transformed into language (something which anyone who has ruined a good joke by giving away the punch line too early will be painfully aware of ).
Example 3.2
Similarities in processing in task performance
To study the ordering of words in speech, Levelt asked participants to describe an underground route on a map, and found that it was possible to identify the points at which speakers were making decisions of sequencing, and the kinds of information which were problematic (such as the placement of prepositional phrases indicating direction and destination). (Levelt, 1989)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
38
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context
Similarities in processing in task performance
Kellerman and van Hoof asked speakers of different language backgrounds to recount part of a film, and carried out a micro-analysis of the speech and gestures they used in describing a series of movements. The study shows interesting patterns of synchronisation of speakers’ gestures of movement with the words denoting direction. Speakers whose languages expressed the direction of movement in the verb (such as French, Spanish, Italian – e.g. ‘Marie a traversé la rue en courant’) timed their gestures to coincide with the verb; speakers whose languages expressed the direction of movement in the preposition (‘Mary ran across the road’) gestured at the point of uttering the preposition. (Kellerman and van Hoof, 2003)
Studies such as these highlight how holistic language production on tasks can reflect similarities in processing, whether at the schematic level (the way people described their apartments in Linde and Labov’s study) or at the lexical and syntactic levels (in Levelt’s and Kellerman and van Hoof’s studies). We return to the implications of findings such as these for second language task research in Part 2.
3.2
The study of tasks in their social context
In contrast to studying performance on bounded tasks such as those cited above, other researchers focus on tasks in terms of the broader, constantly evolving social contexts in which they are situated. For example, in studying expertise in the context of the workplace, Engestrom and Middleton characterise expertise as the ‘ongoing collaborative and discursive construction of tasks, solutions, visions, breakdowns, and innovations’ (Engestrom and Middleton, 1998b: 4) rather than as individual performance on stable, well-defined tasks, as in the chess grandmaster studies mentioned above. Laufer and Glick (1998) make this point explicitly.
Quote 3.1 Laufer and Glick on researching problem-solving in real-world activities The focus of [expertise] research has generally been on problem solving in ‘well structured’ problem domains that lend themselves readily to problem descriptions and identification of linkages between problem representations and linear solution strategies. But does this logical/rationalist model of thinking apply to the more mundane tasks that people face in their everyday life and work? What constitutes problem solving in real-world activities? (Laufer and Glick, 1998: 177)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Example 3.3
39
40
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 3.2 Goodwin and Goodwin on researching cognition in the workplace In order to focus as clearly as possible on some of the issues involved in the analysis of cognition in the workplace, this chapter will investigate a single, very simple, but very pervasive, activity performed by different kinds of workers in a mediumsized airport: looking at airplanes. Despite the brevity of individual glances, they are in no way haphazard. Workers look at planes in order to see something that will help them accomplish the work they are engaged in. Understanding that looking, therefore, requires analysis of the work activities within which it is embedded. (Goodwin and Goodwin, 1998: 61)
Different people may ‘look’ in different ways, and this involves understanding their seeing ‘in an appropriate task-relevant way’ (1998: 61). But this can only be understood in the global context of people’s work.
Quote 3.3
Goodwin and Goodwin on ‘seeing’
By looking at how participants actually accomplish relevant seeing within specific tasks in local environments we will provide detailed analysis of ... performances. ... Consider the tasks faced by someone responsible for loading baggage on an Atlantic Hawk flight to a specific destination, say Oakland. On the field in front of her are ten identical Atlantic Hawk planes ... . How is she to determine which plane to load, i.e., how can she see which of the ten planes is going to Oakland? Seeing the plane itself is not enough, since the plane she is looking for looks just like all of the other planes in her field of view. For airport personnel, planes do not stand alone as isolated objects. Instead, they are defined by their positions in larger webs of activity. (Goodwin and Goodwin, 1998: 62)
One of the challenges for the study of tasks in a broad context like the workplace is that work activities ‘are rarely straightforward individual actions’, but often require continuous switching among activities embedded within each other during a limited time period, and are commonly interwoven with (and thus dependent on) the contributions of co-workers (Rogers and Ellis, 1994). One way of addressing this challenge has been to study workplace activity in terms of the ‘distributed cognition’ of groups of workers involved in collective routines rather than in terms of
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Goodwin and Goodwin (1998), researching social cognition in workers in an airport characterise the issue thus:
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context
41
individual performance on isolated, serial tasks. An interesting example is Hutchins’ 1995 study of the navigation of a ship:
Distributed cognition and task performance
Hutchins shows how the accomplishment of many routine navigation tasks (for example, taking a bearing when moving near land) involves the coordination of a number of discrete activities carried out by different members of the ship navigation team (for example, searching for landmarks on the shore; measuring the bearings of the landmarks; reporting the readings to the bearing time-recorder; logging the bearings; transmitting the bearings to the ship’s pilot; plotting the bearings on a chart through the use of various instruments). By themselves these various activities may not amount to much, but when carried out in conjunction with each other and in the correct order they constitute ‘the computation of the ship’s position’. (Hutchins, 1995)
Interestingly then, even within broad webs of collective activity, we can see that the construct of ‘task’ provides an important mediating context. In the case of the Engestrom and Middleton study, the task is a reference point for understanding what constitutes a solution, a breakdown or an innovation; in the case of the Hutchins study, it is also a reference point for highlighting interdependence among sub-tasks.
3.3 Some issues arising from the use of holistic tasks for research purposes Whether the research task is construed as a bounded context or is studied in its social context is an issue of relevance to the study of second language pedagogic tasks. In Chapter 7 we make the point that the context in which a task is studied – whether bounded, in controlled conditions and conducted outside the classroom, or in the situated context of naturally occurring activities within an intact classroom – does not in itself entail the use of any one theoretical framework or paradigm, and explore in some detail a number of assumptions about relationships between research context and research paradigm. In this section, we briefly focus on some issues arising from the use of holistic tasks in both bounded and situated contexts of research, and also relevant to the study of second language pedagogic tasks. These are: 1. the extent to which the use of a holistic task provides a sufficiently stable basis for research purposes; 2. the impact of the type of task used on the way it is carried out;
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Example 3.4
42
Tasks in Second Language Learning
3. the extent to which participants in research studies re-interpret the task in ways that may be at odds with the researcher’s intentions. Holistic tasks and consistency of research focus
A recurrent concern with the use of holistic tasks in human sciences research relates to the consistency of behaviour elicited. For example, to what extent can unscripted, holistic tasks, like those used in the studies exemplified above, provide a stable enough basis for generalisation or comparison? In what ways might we expect the holistic nature of such tasks to undermine of the consistency of the research focus? Interestingly, a number of studies have shown that even when engaging in an open, spontaneous task, participants respond with a degree of consistency. In some cases, this is a reflection of cultural patterning. For example, in a much cited study, Bartlett (1932, in Baddeley, 1991: 335) showed that people unfamiliar with Native American culture would very consistently have the same difficulties recalling the same details of Native American stories they were asked to recall. Cultural influences can also affect consistency in the ways that children respond to tasks. Bruner cites the following case.
Quote 3.4
Bruner on the influence of cultural background
Indeed, each culture has certain unique ways of dealing with the relation of the three systems [i.e. iconic, enactive, symbolic]. In [Greenfield’s] field studies in Senegal, she found that Frank’s screening procedure, so successful in a Western setting, had little effect with Senegalese children. What could produce change was giving the children conservation tasks in which they themselves rather than adults manipulated the materials, largely because the children expected magic powers of adults, but not of themselves. (Bruner, 1973: 323)
A different kind of example can be found in Tannen (1980).
Example 3.5
The influence of cultural background
Tannen studied how Greek and American-English speakers reported a silent film which they had watched individually. She found a very strong tendency for the American speakers to treat the task as a memory test, while the Greek speakers were very much more likely to handle the task as requiring them to provide a dramatic oral account of what they had seen. Although this study showed that the two cultural groups responded very differently, it also demonstrated there was a high degree of predictability regarding the kind of discourse that they would produce, given their distinctive orientations. (Tannen, 1980)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
3.3.1
43
In other words, general knowledge affects comprehension processes. Since much of our general knowledge is culturally shaped, it differs across different cultural backgrounds. For example, given that background knowledge is one important element, and that background knowledge is partly culturally shaped, it is perhaps not surprising to find that studies have shown that people can respond differently, but consistently, to tasks according to their cultural background. Our more general point is that when given holistic comprehension tasks, people spontaneously encounter very similar comprehension problems. From such studies, it is possible to infer the kinds of processes that occur and major ways of resolving comprehension problems. Furthermore, spontaneous attempts to resolve problems can be consistently interpreted in terms of over-assimilation as in Bartlett’s study, or over-accommodation, as in foreign language studies where rather than over-assimilating, readers are often found to ignore their personal stores of general knowledge, and attempt to work out the meanings of texts purely on the basis of the literal meanings on the page – a form of over-accommodation. What is relevant for our purposes is that tasks can be devised to engage text comprehension processes which enable researchers to infer the kinds of sub-processes that are involved, to identify different types of processing problem and to interpret the different kinds of strategies that people use. That is, the tasks are deliberately holistic to ensure that normal processes are engaged; yet, they are also focused to target particular parts of the process. Holistic tasks then can be used to show that we all use similar processes in producing or comprehending language. However, holistic tasks have also been used to study individual differences, and as such can be seen as an anchor for focusing on differences in the ways that people carry out the same task, as Bruner et al. show.
Example 3.6 Individual differences in approaches to problem-solving Bruner et al. set children a questioning task involving cards each with a drawing made up of a different combination of elements (for instance, a man, with or without a hat, with or without a stick, with or without very big shoes). He found that children differed in the extent to which they gambled on rapid success, or slowly worked out the solutions by a process of logical elimination. He concluded that there were distinct approaches to this kind of problem-solving, some highly conservative, attempting to avoid any incorrect guesses at the cost of considerable work, some highly risky, going for the solution by one-off guesses, willing to carry the cost of many errors. (Bruner, Goodnow and Austin, 1956)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Tasks of the sort described here are holistic in the sense that participants have to sort out what to say, how to say it and in what order, bringing together the formulation of particular utterances into a whole discourse strategy. Learner differences occur, but there is no reason to think that these are infinite in number. For instance, elsewhere Bruner comments on reading strategies, as revealed through story retelling tasks:
Quote 3.5
Bruner on story telling tasks
One gets a sense of the psychology of genre by listening to readers ‘tell back’ a story they have just read or spontaneously ‘tell’ a story about a ‘happening’ in their own lives. ‘Telling back’ a Conrad story, one reader will turn it into a yarn of adventure, another into a moral tale about duplicity, and a third into a case study of a Doppelganger. The text from which they started was the same. Genre seems to be a way of both organizing the structure of events and organizing the telling of them . . . (Bruner, 1986: 6)
The examples from human sciences research noted here suggest then that it is possible to capture elements of difference in the ways that holistic tasks are carried out by individuals, but that it is also possible to capture patterns of consistency. 3.3.2
Impact of task type on task performance
Another recurring question about the use of tasks for eliciting performance is the extent to which the type of task selected artificially pushes the type of behaviour it elicits: to what extent can task performance be taken as a reflection of performance in other contexts, and to what extent an artefact of that particular task? In communication strategies research (Bialystok, 1990; Kasper and Kellerman, 1997), where the focus is on the ways that individuals deal with communication problems – misunderstandings, breakdowns in communication, seek clarification, and so on – the issue is brought into focus in different ways.
Quote 3.6 research
Bialystok on tasks in communication strategies
There are few studies that compare performance of a single subject across methods, since each researcher tends to use only one procedure. Comparisons across tasks, then, tend to be highly inferential. (Bialystok, 1990: 50)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
44
45
In a study of her own, Bialystok found that while task type affected the quantity of language produced, it had no significant effect on the frequency or type of communication strategies elicited. In spite of this, she argues that elicitation type almost certainly has some impact on results, and, by implication, we can assume that in the classroom it is likely to influence learning. Williams, Inscoe and Tasker (1997) argue that weaknesses in earlier communication strategies research were essentially due to the type of task selected: ‘the selection of CSs [communication strategies] is determined by the nature of the situation – the interactive goal – as well as the role of the participants – ‘expert’ versus needing information’ (1997: 306). For this reason they adopted a different type of task for their study, one typical of non-language learning contexts (tutoring interactions in the organic chemistry laboratory) and in which the NNS is the expert and the NS the non-expert:
Quote 3.7 Williams et al. on impact of task type in communication strategies research [This approach] extends the notion of CS to situations involving other kinds of gap in knowledge, for example, gaps which are primarily information-based, rather than code-based. Specifically, we look at episodes in which either the NS or the NNS fails to comprehend some aspect of the task or another participant’s actions and must seek some way of resolving the problem. . . . Secondly, such gaps in knowledge tend to show up in comprehension problems rather than in production. ... We will examine the CSs of both the NNSs and NSs because we believe that the achievement of comprehension is a joint process. While the NNSs and NSs do appear to have different strategies, they must be viewed together, rather than separately. (Williams, Inscoe and Tasker, 1997: 306–7)
The key point here is that the design of the task has a central role since it is informed by the researchers’ conceptualisation of communication strategies. The same would be true if we were to substitute the word ‘teacher’ for ‘researcher’. The issue of the impact of task type can be further illustrated with reference to elicitation material originally designed by Krauss and Weinheimer (1964) and subsequently used in the study of adult first language communication (Clarke and Wilkes-Gibbs, 1986; Bongaerts and Poulisse 1989).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 3.7
Impact of task type on strategy use
In this study, the material consisted of twelve unconventional shapes, which participants were required to refer to in order to complete a task. The fact that they were unconventional meant there was no pre-existing word or phrase available to refer to them, hence requiring the speakers to find some verbal strategy to manage the task. One speaker was asked to instruct the other to lay the twelve figures out in an array of their choice. Two types of strategy were used – an analogical strategy, likening the shapes to something familiar of a roughly similar shape; and a literal (or analytical) strategy, describing the parts of the figures. Bongaerts and Poulisse found that Dutch speakers used similar strategies in both their L1 and their L2. (Bongaerts and Poulisse, 1989)
Although the results of this study are not in question, it is worth pointing out that the nature of the strategies elicited could be strongly influenced by the kind of task employed. If both speakers are able to see the figures on the table, the chances are this will severely reduce the use of inventive strategies. If, on the other hand, one speaker is asked to describe a figure so that the other can draw it, this is very likely to bias the speakers towards the use of analytical strategies, since an analogical strategy is bound to neglect some important elements of the figures. Hence in language elicitation, task design is crucial in targeting the kinds of behaviour that are of interest. Studies of child language development have also demonstrated some effect of task on performance which could explain some of the historic results reported by Piaget (e.g. Piaget and Inhelder, 1956). Research by Kahan and Richards (1986) into the referential communication of children and college students demonstrated that the context within which language was presented significantly affected the way both the children and the adults handled the task. In other words task type affected performance. Other research has shown more direct educational relevance:
Example 3.8
Impact of task type
Snow et al. studied the ability of multilingual primary school children to produce formal (i.e. decontextualised) and informal definitions of words. They found evidence to suggest that the quality of children’s decontextualised definitions related closely to both their overall proficiency (written as well as oral) and to academic ability. In other words, the ability to manage decontextualised definitions could be seen as related to the extent to which they were specifically socialised into that activity. That is, familiarity with the specific type of task seemed more important than oral proficiency in the language. (Snow et al., 1989)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
46
47
As we shall see in Chapters 7, 8 and 9, the impact of task type on task performance is a topic of considerable interest to second language task researchers. This should not be surprising: if tasks are a pedagogical tool for generating language work, then the kind of language that arises as a result of their use is bound to be of central interest to teachers, learners, designers and others who consider their use to promote language development. 3.3.3
Participants’ re-definition of tasks
Many studies of task performance appear to assume convergence between the aims of the researcher setting the task and the aims of the participants carrying it out. However, referring to the issue as ‘one of the skeletons in the psychologist’s closet’, Bruner et al. (1956) make the point that participants in research studies cannot be expected to share the same agenda as the researchers setting the task. It is possible, indeed likely, that they will have different interpretations of the objective of the task, and different understandings of what is required to accomplish it. This opens up the possibility that the task may be ‘redefined’ in ways that make sense to the individual carrying it out, but that may be at variance with the researcher’s original intentions. This in turn implies that any task can be transformed into something individual and unique each time it is carried out, and thus calls into question many of the assumptions about tasks as stable contexts for studying behaviour discussed above. Interestingly, as Bruner et al. suggest, although the extent to which a research task can be viewed as external to the person carrying it out and imposed, and the extent to which it can be viewed as internal to, and defined by the performer, is recognised as an issue that needs to be confronted in human sciences research, it is not widely discussed or accounted for in research reports. The quotes and examples that follow, however, illustrate some of the ways that human sciences researchers have acknowledged and confronted those issues.
Quote 3.8 Pepinsky and Pepinsky on the ‘official’ and the ‘private’ task We can anticipate the necessity of distinguishing between the task as defined by (a) the actor to whom it is assigned and (b) the setter who assigns it. (Pepinsky and Pepinsky, 1961: 219–20; cited in Hackman, 1969)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context
48
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Hackman argues that since a research task is inevitably transformed when carried out, task redefinition should be viewed as a normal part of the performance process, with ‘objective’ and ‘redefined’ tasks occupying different temporal positions in the performance sequence. For Hackman, both objective and redefined tasks are nonetheless still ‘tasks’, and can be differentiated on the same dimensions. This implies the ‘objective’ task, as assigned by the researcher, can function as an anchor for exploring ways in which the task is actually reinterpreted and redefined by task participants. To this end, Hackman proposes a framework broadly corresponding to the different aspects of the objective task, and which he argues can be used as reference points for tracing both what was intended by the researcher, and what actually happened. (Hackman, 1969)
Working from a different theoretical perspective, Griffin et al. (1982) discuss problems of ‘locating’ tasks within the larger social networks within which they are carried out. With reference to their study of children’s problem-solving in a range of contexts, they comment that recognising where a task began and ended was clear-cut in test conditions, relatively clear in classroom conditions, but impossible in ‘club’ contexts (i.e. in school but out of the classroom), where things got done (cakes baked, plants grown, etc.), ‘without anyone doing anything that a cognitive psychologist could recognize as thinking’ (1982: 4). They argue that the source of this difficulty lies in the social constraints operating on people when carrying out a task/solving a problem: The larger social context within which the ‘same task’ was embedded placed very different constraints on the individuals participating in the scene. As a consequence, the individuals were more or less free to change the conditions of the task, even to the point of making it go away, depending upon what social context it appeared in. (Griffin et al., 1982: 5) To address the problem, Griffin et al. propose the introduction of ‘tracer elements’, which can be subsequently used as a basis for constructing a model system of what the task is. A tracer element might take the form of a topic or problem that children encounter in lessons, peer work, tutorials or in club settings, and thus the topic or problem can serve as a trace of the task being searched for. In this way, Griffin et al.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Example 3.9 Understanding the ‘objective’ and the ‘redefined’ task
Holistic Tasks in a Research Context
49
Quote 3.9 Griffin et al. on the use of tracer elements in research tasks By having a tracer element, we have a clearer chance to see what is varying: we can see how the researcher/teacher/club leader’s plans concerning the task are transformed to create the task that the participants perform. (Griffin et al., 1982: 10)
Thus by providing a window on the task as planned and on ways that it is variously interpreted, tracer elements offer a means to capture the slipstream of individual task enactment. From Griffin et al.’s perspective, this would enable a theory that is ‘simultaneously a theory of what the task is, what the relevant behaviors are, and the relationships between elements of the tasks and elements of behavior’ (1982: 8). We might have easily substituted ‘second language learner’ for ‘participant’ and ‘actor’ throughout this discussion, since the issue of how learners reinterpret and redefine tasks is highly relevant for task pedagogy and research, and has been widely recognised in recent years. As we saw above, it is brought into focus through Breen’s (1987) distinction between task-as-workplan and task-in-process; it subsequently emerged in relation to neo-Vygotskyian perspectives on language learning, where the distinction has been framed in terms of ‘task’ (the task as planned) and ‘activity’ (the task as enacted by individual learners) to highlight how the ‘official’ task may be uniquely transformed by the learners carrying it out (Coughlan and Duff, 1994; see also Lantolf, 2000; Donato, 2000). As we shall see in Chapter 7, for some neo-Vygotskyians the issue represents a major stumbling block for both task research and the development of a systematic task pedagogy. However, if we accept task reinterpretation and redefinition as inevitable elements in the enactment of tasks of any kind, as suggested in the examples from human sciences research cited above, then it is possible to envisage ways around the problem – for example, exploring the extent to which the notion of a ‘trace’ might apply to features of pedagogic tasks, and ways in which it could be used to provide stable points of reference for exploring potential divergences between the workplan and the task in action. Nevertheless, the pedagogic and theoretical implications of how tasks are redefined and reinterpreted in action cannot be understood fully without
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
argue, it is possible to locate recurring situations where a goal can be isolated; that is, we can identify it via its relation to the tracer.
Tasks in Second Language Learning
also taking the perspectives of task users into account. Unfortunately, to date most of the empirical work relating to task reinterpretation has been based on researchers’ interpretations of learners’ reinterpretations of tasks (Coughlan and Duff, 1994), and very little has focused on the issue of reinterpretation from the learner’s own perspective. Likewise, there has been very little work carried out on teachers’ interpretations of tasks from their own perspectives, or of task designers’ intentions from theirs. Taken together, we might expect the various perspectives of learners, teachers, designers and researchers to permit richer accounts of the capacity of the workplan, and richer conceptualisations of the boundaries between workplan and enactment. This remains an underexplored aspect of task research, and a topic to which we shall return in later chapters.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
50
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
Having traced some of the educational antecedents for the kinds of activities we are calling second language pedagogic tasks, and having considered some of the ways in which those activities have been used in human sciences research, we narrow the focus to concentrate more closely on the development of tasks as a significant force in language teaching. First, we consider the impetus communicative language teaching gave to the development of task-type activities, looking more closely at their roles within different types of communicative language teaching programme. We then turn to closer consideration of the emergence of tasks as a key element of interest.
4.1 The development of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) For many second and foreign language teachers, the broad principles underpinning the use of holistic activity in classroom activity were brought into concrete focus by Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) during the mid-1970s in the UK and Europe and somewhat later in North America. Earlier approaches to language teaching had been developed mainly in order to teach different types of language feature, such as pronunciation, grammar, vocabulary, conversational structures, functional elements. To do this they drew largely on a behavioural model of learning, based on the fundamental processes of presentation of input (involving learners’ perception and comprehension), practice (involving the learners’ reproduction and manipulation of the input) and production (involving learners’ free strategic and exploratory use of the input material), a pedagogic procedure widely referred to as P,P and P. CLT aimed to break from this paradigm, on the grounds that there was 51
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
4
Tasks in Second Language Learning
a fundamental qualitative difference between the kinds of learning that had been promoted so far within classrooms on the one hand, and the kinds of second language learning that can occur in the target language community on the other. Communication needed to become a touchstone for language teaching and learning in two main ways. First, it emphasised the central role of communication activities in all the main learning processes. Even if comprehension and production have distinct roles in language learning, communication should be central to both. Second, it questioned the viability of a pre-constructed syllabus, since learners have different levels of readiness and learn at different rates. That is, proponents of CLT argued that communication should determine both the content and the mode of learning. For many advocates of CLT theory, this implied a radical reconstrual of traditional classroom role relationships, with teachers and learners increasingly seen as co-participants (Candlin, 1987) and the role of the learner as an active agent in her own learning strongly emphasised (Breen, 1987). It was argued by some CLT proponents (notably Breen and Candlin, 1980) that issues normally considered the purview of the teacher/syllabus/institution (e.g. content, topic, classroom configuration, modes of evaluation, etc.) could now be seen as open to negotiation among learners and teachers, and importantly, space for learners to reflect on the route and processes of their own learning could be opened up.
4.2
Communicative activities and tasks
This theoretical approach gave rise to various principles intended to guide the structuring and management of second language programmes. It was also fuelled by, and in turn inspired, the development of a number of novel techniques for designing second language classroom activities which would engage learners in communication, widely referred to as ‘communicative activities’. Widdowson (1978) and Brumfit (1984a), both closely associated with the development of CLT, outlined principles, activities and practices for an emerging communicative approach. However, at that time, they rarely if ever used the term ‘task’. Allwright (1984), another important influence on the development of CLT, was concerned to elaborate an account of the language classroom in which communication entered into the teaching and learning processes at a whole series of levels. ‘Task’ is one such level, but for him ‘task’ referred to any activity which a teacher might require of a student, down to answering a question. However it is possibly
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
52
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
53
Quote 4.1
Johnson on task-oriented teaching
[M]ethodologies should be based not only on linguistic insights as to the nature of ‘knowledge of a language’, but also on psycholinguistic insights as to the processes involved in its use ... It is for reasons such as this that fluency in communicative process can only be developed within ‘task-oriented teaching’ – one which provides ‘actual meaning’ by focusing on tasks to be mediated through language, and where success or failure is seen to be judged in terms of whether or not these tasks are performed. (Johnson, 1979: 198, 200)
There is room for discussion as to whether success or failure can be judged only in terms of task completion: as in all learning, completion is not the only concern in performing a language task. Swales, for instance, while endorsing the use of tasks as a central element in language teaching, is comfortable to admit ‘the analysis and discussion of texts and situation, and the teaching and practice of form’ (1990: 72). However, Johnson makes a crucial step in highlighting the need for materials not only to focus on relevant language, but also to engage the learners in developing the skills of using it in relevant ways. 4.2.1 Tasks in the teaching of language for specific or academic purposes Johnson’s view of ‘task’ was especially explored by educationists working in the teaching of language for specific or academic purposes (LS/AP). The purpose of LS/AP programmes is to provide language training for non-language specialists who need it for academic or professional purposes, but have limited time. Central to LS/AP work is the concept of needs analysis (Munby, 1978) as the basis for the specification of the type of content and the type of task relevant to learner needs and purposes. Thus, in LS/AP the notion of genre skills and situational demands goes somewhat further than Johnson’s position, sharpening the criteria for task development. A central concern then is relevance of language and relevance of activity. However, as Swales (1990) points out, it is possible to teach relevant language but in ways that are quite unsuitable.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Johnson (1979) who was the first explicitly to articulate the need for a concept of ‘task’ to incorporate the dimension of language processing into materials and as the orientation for teaching.
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 4.2
Swales on task appropriacy
I used to teach an EAP course for students entering the largely English-medium Faculty of Law at the University of Khartoum in Sudan. One of the main genres that I used were Sudanese case reports, and for this choice I could put forward an elaborate justification. ... However, the comprehension tasks I invited the students to undertake were misconceived because they were designed to help the students to understand the stories. It was only when I attended classes given by a Criminal Law professor that I belatedly came to realize that the reading strategy required in legal education was not to understand – and retain the gist of – a narrative, but to spot the crucial fact on which the decision (rightly or wrongly) rested. The problem-solving law professor’s questions were quite different to my own. Because I had failed to appreciate the role of the genre in its environment, the reading strategies I was teaching, however well-founded in terms of ESL methodology, were probably doing the students more harm than good. (Swales, 1990: 72–3)
The language being taught was appropriate, but the task type was not. With this in mind, authors increasingly became concerned to develop materials which not only provided exposure to appropriate types of language (e.g. McEldowney, 1982; White, 1978, 1979; Moore, 1979, 1980), but also to engage appropriate types of processing (e.g. Hall and Kenny, 1988; Morrow, 1980; Scott, 1981). 4.2.2
Tasks in content-based instruction
‘Task’ has also been an influential organising factor in the design and provision of content-based instruction (CBI). There are many approaches to CBI, but what unites them is a focus on content, with language teaching subsumed to the learning of content and arising out of engagement with that content. Tasks have been widely used in CBI in second and foreign language teaching (as seen in the project work described in Legutke and Thomas, 1991, and illustrated later in this book), and also play an important part in programmes providing language minority students with access to academic curriculum content in primary and secondary schools (e.g. Mohan, 1986; Leung, 2001; Dufficy, 2004; Van Avermaet, 2006), as well as in post-secondary education (Mohan and Marshall Smith, 1992; Snow and Brinton, 1997). Tasks are also an important organising principle in many approaches to adult basic education, particularly in immigrant and refugee programmes (e.g. the Australian Adult Migrant Education Program (AMEP), and the Flanders Centre for Migration and Learning). We describe some of the work developed in these contexts in Chapter 9. In content-based instruction, then, content is organised around realworld themes or topics that learners encounter outside the language
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
54
55
classroom and the kinds of tasks that they will need to engage with; thus it is possible to see the curriculum as part-content, part-process. This enables a distinction to be made between materials which introduce learners to the conceptual and thematic content of a scheme of work and materials which engage the learners in learning and communication processes. This has the merit of creating a dual teaching and learning perspective for any aspect of the curriculum: the dual focus enriches the coherence and hence the motivational appeal of the curriculum.
Quote 4.3 Van Lier on the relationship between task-based and content-based education Task-based and content-based language teaching really go hand in hand, since a progression of tasks without some continuity or systematicity in terms of content progression (or coherence) would lead to a very disjointed, ‘scattergun’ syllabus. Conversely, content-based teaching in which little or no thought has been given to the design and sequencing of tasks will be a transmission, most likely in lecture or IRF form, of lesson material ... Therefore, task and content should be seen as a unity. ( Van Lier, 1996: 205–6)
In a number of educational contexts, however, responsibilities for the teaching of content and language are divided: the ‘content’ teacher (e.g. of geography or physics) is responsible for the learning of the curriculum in his or her specialist area, and the language teacher is responsible for pupils’ language development across those areas. This has been common practice, for example, in the provisions made for English as an Additional Language (EAL) in a number of British schools (Mohan, Leung and Davison, 2000), as well as in adjunct models of post-secondary CBI in North America (Brinton, Snow and Wesche, 1989). In contexts such as these, the adoption of a task-oriented approach can be a means of easing potentially awkward relationships between the specialist knowledge and expertise of the content teacher on the one hand, and the specialist knowledge and expertise of the second language teacher on the other.
Quote 4.4 Leung on the potential for tasks to clarify the roles of content teachers and language teachers The task-based approach creates a common platform for the two teachers to share their expertise: from the content teacher his or her knowledge and skill of the subject matter (which inevitably involves language expressions) and from the ESL
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 4.4
(Continued)
teacher his or her knowledge and skill in developing pupils’ target language appropriately within the task context. The content teacher can inform the ESL teacher what a task entails in terms of thinking processes, practical activities and specialist language use; the ESL teacher can use the task to promote understanding of the content knowledge and content-related language, and to generate language development opportunities. (Leung, 2001: 187)
By the same token, tasks can provide an effective reference point for teacher development projects, as Cameron, Moon and Bygate (1996) have noted. A further virtue of this approach is that it highlights the desirability of developing a systematic approach to the design, use and research of task types in their own right, and to the exploration of the extent to which they have consistent effects on language use and language learning irrespective of topic.
4.3 The emergence of ‘task’ in general language purpose language teaching As we have seen, the use of holistic tasks has been a key element in CLT, LS/AP and content-based instruction for some time. Over the years, however, the term ‘task’ began to emerge in its own right as the centrepiece for specialised pedagogic initiatives, as in the various approaches to task-based learning and teaching (TBLT) described below. The concept of task came to be of interest to second language researchers, teachers and methodologists for a number of reasons. For many, an interest in ‘task’ as a central guiding pedagogical principle grew out of a dissatisfaction with the ways in which mainstream CLT appeared to be developing, and in particular with CLT’s apparent inability to harness issues relating to the content of learning with issues relating to modes of learning, as reflected in many (but not all) commercially produced CLT materials and in much (but not all) pedagogic practice. For example, although many CLT materials framed syllabus content in terms of communicative function (apologies, requests, and so on) rather than linguistic form, the procedures for bringing learners into engagement with that content continued to reflect a view of learning as a gradual accretion of individual, pre-selected items, mediated through orchestrated pedagogic sequences, proceeding from teacher presentation to controlled and less
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
56
57
controlled practice and finally to free production. Thus for many researchers, teachers and methodologists the possibility of a pedagogic initiative driven by engagement with meaningful and relevant tasks offered a promising way through the communicative content/communicative procedure impasse that CLT seemed to have arrived at, and thus seen by many as an opportunity to return to the conceptual foundations of CLT (as outlined in Breen and Candlin, 1980), rather than a radical departure or innovation. From the mid- to late 1980s, the term ‘taskbased’ was increasingly adopted to describe this alternative. The potential ‘rewards’ that task-based learning was seen to offer are summarised by Candlin.
Quote 4.5
Candlin on the rewards of task-based learning
• A restructuring of the relationship between curriculum and syllabuses • A re-evaluation of the relationship between data, resources and processes in task content and task action • A re-estimation of the relationship between goal-based and norm-referenced evaluation • A review of the role relationship of ‘teacher’ and ‘learner’ in task co-participation • A re-emphasis of the potential of the classroom as a place for experimentation into language and language learning • A renewing of a critical perspective on the understanding of the second language acquisition and the place of language learning in the social identity of the learner (Candlin, 1987: 22)
More recently ‘task-based’ has come to be rather loosely applied as an umbrella term to refer to any context in which tasks are used, whether as an occasional activity to fill a gap in a lesson plan, or as the central mode of instruction. ‘Task-based’ has also been widely used in the marketing of English language teaching materials, and as a broad descriptor for curriculum proposals (e.g. the Hong Kong SAR Target Oriented Curriculum, Curriculum Development Council, Hong Kong, 1999). As a result, it is not uncommon to find ‘task-based’ materials that would not meet the task criteria set out at the beginning of this chapter, or ‘taskbased’ curricula that are broadly communicative in content, but not in mode of learning. This catch-all approach is unfortunate, partly because of the confusion and scepticism it has created in the teaching profession, and partly because it devalues ‘task’ as a distinct pedagogic construct. Thus, in our view, it is more useful to focus on the different ways
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
58
Tasks in Second Language Learning
that tasks can be used in a syllabus, whether centrally or peripherally. To this end, we can think of approaches to the use of tasks as task-based, task-referenced and task-supported. Task-based learning and teaching (TBLT)
We use the term ‘task-based’ teaching and learning (TBLT) to refer to contexts where tasks are the central unit of instruction: they ‘drive’ classroom activity, they define curriculum and syllabuses and they determine modes of assessment:
Concept 4.1 • • • •
Task-based learning and teaching
Tasks define the language syllabus, with language being taught in response to the operational needs of specific learners. Tasks are seen as essential in engaging key processes of language acquisition. Tasks are selected on the basis that they replicate or simulate relevant realworld activities. Assessment is in terms of task performance.
Well-known examples of somewhat different approaches to this view of TBLT are Long and Crookes (1992), Skehan (1998) and Willis (1996), and are discussed in Part 2. TBLT has also come to be strongly associated with the strand of second language acquisition research that has focused on ways that task interaction can give rise to opportunities for the negotiation of meaning, the provision of feedback on output and focusing on form (Gass and Varonis, 1985; Long, 1985; Pica and Doughty, 1985). Even after two decades, TBLT as outlined above continues to be extremely controversial and has attracted a number of highly vocal critics and detractors, notably Sheen (1994); Bruton (2002a, 2000b) and Swan (2005), who argue that TBLT has been imposed on teachers on the basis of limited research findings, generalised from laboratory-based studies in conditions that do not reflect the realities of the average teaching situation worldwide. Other critiques of TBLT from various perspectives include Aston (1986), Seedhouse (1999, 2005), Cook (2000), Mori (2002), Hampshire and Aguareles Anoro (2004) and Slimani-Rolls (2005). We return to the issues these raise in later chapters. 4.3.2
Task-referenced learning and teaching
We use the term ‘task-referenced’ (Bygate, 2000) to refer to contexts where progress through the syllabus is measured by performance on target
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
4.3.1
59
achievement tasks. This is widely associated with various forms of ‘outcomes-based’ approaches, as adopted for example in adult migrant education in Australia and in parts of North America. Learners are assessed on ‘competencies’ or ‘attainment targets’, which they must meet in order to progress through the programme. In the Australian Adult Migrant Education Program (AMEP), for example, typical targets include ‘can participate in a casual conversation; can respond to spoken instructions’ (Brindley and Slatyer, 2002), and are broken down into subcomponents. Our use of the term ‘task-referenced’ thus highlights the use of tasks for assessment and for setting achievement targets, but makes no assumptions about the extent to which tasks may be used in teaching.
Concept 4.2 • •
Task-referenced learning and teaching
The curriculum and learner achievement are defined in terms of a series of selected target tasks. Teachers use whatever means are most suitable for preparing students for target assessment.
In other words, a task-referenced approach is one that uses tasks to set achievement targets and to evaluate learning, but may draw on a range of teaching procedures to attain those targets, and is not necessarily restricted to the types of activity that would conform to our definition of task at the beginning of the chapter. 4.3.3
Task-supported learning and teaching
In a task-supported (Ellis, 2003; Bygate, 2000) approach to the use of tasks in the syllabus, tasks are used as a key element in the learning cycle; they are used to actualise part of the curriculum, to enrich the syllabus or to provide additional learning opportunities (Ur, 1982; Brumfit, 1984; Nunan, 1995, 2001). However, tasks are not necessarily used for assessment purposes and the syllabus itself may be defined by categories other than tasks (Nunan, 1995, 2001; Richards et al., 1997). In tasksupported teaching, then, tasks are seen as tools to be exploited by teacher and learners in the service of particular language aims and objectives, with the teacher providing support through briefing, on-line support and selective feedback.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Concept 4.3 • • • •
Task-supported learning and teaching
Tasks are an important, but not the sole. element in a pedagogic cycle. Tasks are used in conjunction with different types of activity. Tasks are one element in the syllabus, but not necessarily the defining element. Tasks may be used as an element of assessment, but not necessarily as the defining element.
The overall point we wish to emphasise here is that tasks themselves can be seen as neutral with respect to overall syllabus type or teaching approach. This reflects some of the ways that language teaching has evolved away from a technicist concern with ‘method’. In a timely paper, Kumaravadivelu (1994) argued that the communicative movement had effectively given rise to a ‘post-method’ phase in language teaching. Rather than work with entirely pre-packaged methods, teachers could now negotiate content, sequence and activity type with learners from a range of resources. This account can be seen as being largely underpinned by the twin emphases of CLT proponents on principle rather than method, and on learner rather than teacher. In this context, the task becomes a resource, and a range of tasks a repertoire, which teachers can draw on in the light of experience and learners’ preferences and needs. From this perspective, the study and use of tasks does not of itself entail the adoption of one particular type of approach to language teaching and learning. Rather, tasks can be seen as a pedagogic tool that can be used flexibly in different ways depending on purpose, setting and context, rather than as part of a pre-packaged set of a priori procedures and assumptions. In our view, the distinctions between task-based, taskreferenced and task-supported are useful because they highlight both the flexibility of task as a pedagogic tool and the range of roles that tasks can fulfil, rather than narrowly focusing on one specialised use, as for example associ-ated with Long and Crookes’ (1992) conceptualisation of task-based syllabuses. A key consideration for teachers, however, remains the issue of the pedagogic focus of tasks. We use the term ‘pedagogic focus’ here as a means of highlighting four key domains where tasks can help focus learners’ attention. These are: 1. aspects of the target language (Newton and Kennedy, 1996); 2. aspects of language processing (Anderson and Lynch, 1988);
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
60
Tasks in Second Language Pedagogy
61
In a task-based approach, the pedagogic focus of the task is seen as that which arises naturally out of task performance in response to learners’ evolving needs, very much in line with aspects of Freinet’s approach described earlier. Any attempt to target specific language features preemptively (dubbed ‘structure-trapping’ in Skehan, 1998) is seen as an artificial intervention into the naturalistic learning processes that task interaction seeks to engage. On the other hand, the use of tasks in tasksupported and task-referenced contexts could be seen as offering greater potential for flexibility in ways of introducing and exploiting the pedagogic focus of a task (including, but not necessarily restricted to, a pedagogic focus emerging naturally out of task enactment). However, as we saw earlier in relation to our discussion of Dewey, balancing the timing, role and nature of the pedagogic focus with task-oriented activity is complex, and we return to the topic in more detail in later chapters.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
3. aspects of the learning process (Bygate, 1996, 2001; and in relation to the development of learner autonomy, Kohonen et al., 2001; Breen, 2001); 4. socio-affective dimensions (Legutke and Thomas, 1991).
Defining Pedagogic Tasks: Issues and Challenges
At the beginning of this book, we proposed a set of general elements to describe what we broadly mean by ‘task’. We did so to provide an initial point of reference for talking about issues relating to the use of tasks in general education and human sciences research. As we further narrow the focus in our consideration of tasks as a pedagogic tool for second language learning, we revisit the construct of ‘task’ and attempt a more precise definition than the general elements we offered in Chapter 1. To this end, we: • Invite consideration of why a more precise definition might be desirable. • Explore some of the ways that task have been defined in the literature. • Highlight issues and challenges involved in arriving at an adequate task definition. • Offer a working definition of our own.
5.1
Approaches to task definition
In order to distinguish between activities that are tasks and those that are not, and to focus our attention on using and studying them, a widely agreed definition of the term is both desirable and necessary. But arriving at such a definition is not straightforward – a considerable part of the second language task literature has long been concerned with the search for a precise, yet comprehensive definition of ‘task’, and the sheer volume of resulting definitions, redefinitions and counter-definitions that have proliferated must come as something of a surprise to colleagues working in other areas. The sources quoted in Kumaravadivelu (1993), Skehan (1998), Bygate, Skehan and Swain (2001), Johnson (2003) and Ellis (2003) all give a sense of the range covered by these definitions, as 62
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
5
Defining Pedagogic Tasks
63
well as various points of convergence and divergence. Some of the most widely cited include the following:
Candlin defining ‘task’
One of a set of differentiated, sequencable, problem-posing activities involving learners and teachers in some joint selection from a range of varied cognitive and communicative procedures applied to existing and new knowledge in the collective exploration and pursuance of foreseen or emergent goals within a social milieu. (Candlin, 1987: 10)
Quote 5.2
Long defining ‘task’
A piece of work undertaken for oneself or for others, freely or for some reward. Thus examples of tasks are painting a fence, dressing a child. ‘Tasks’ are the things people will tell you they do if you ask them and they are not applied linguists. (Long, 1985: 89)
Quote 5.3
Prabhu defining ‘task’
An activity which required learners to arrive at an outcome from given information through some process of thought and which allowed teachers to control and regulate that process. (Prabhu, 1987: 24)
Quote 5.4
Skehan defining ‘task’
An activity in which: meaning is primary; there is some communication problem to solve; there is some sort of relationship to comparable real-world activities; task completion has some priority; the assessment of the task is in terms of outcome. (Skehan, 1998: 95)
We have chosen these examples because they illustrate ways in which definitions can vary in terms of the different dimensions of ‘task’ that are brought into focus. Candlin, for example, highlights the contextualisation of tasks as a jointly constructed activity in the social setting of the classroom, and reflects the critical, problem-posing stance of participatory educators like Freire, while Long highlights connectedness with ‘realworld’ activity; Prabhu’s definition emphasises the cognitive demands
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Quote 5.1
Tasks in Second Language Learning
placed on learners and the regulating role of the teacher, while Skehan’s is applicable to tasks for use in research and assessment, as well as in the classroom. The focus of a definition may be deliberately selective (as in Long’s alignment with the world outside the classroom) or deliberately inclusive (as in Candlin’s enumeration of all the things that a task could be). The way a task is defined, then, may depend on the perspective of the person making the definition and the purposes for which the definition is being made, a point raised in Bygate et al. (2001). For our purpose, however – a generic definition of second language pedagogic ‘task’ – we are faced with a choice: either to seek a definition that highlights those features that a task could have, or to work more parsimoniously with a definition that highlights only those features that a task must have. The advantage of the former is that it lays out the full set of options potentially available – a complete conceptual toolbox for task design and selection; the advantage of the latter is that it defines a task in terms of its bare essentials – the minimum requirements that must be present. There are obvious pluses and minuses to each approach, and although the minimalist option may be seen as considerably less ambitious, it is this approach that we follow here. We do this on the grounds that paring down a task to its essentials provides a more realistic, less idealised, more manageable and hence potentially more constructive basis for the exploration of tasks; for distinguishing among tasks and other types of pedagogic activity; and for exploring with teachers ways of working with tasks.
5.2
Criterial properties of a task: Ellis
Ellis (2003) is an example of a bare essentials approach to task definition. Based on a detailed study of a number of previous definitions (including among others those cited in Quotes 5.1–5.4), Ellis’s definition is framed in terms of a set of essential, criterial properties:
Quote 5.5
Ellis’s definition of ‘task’
1. A task is a workplan. 2. A task involves a primary focus on meaning. 3. A task involves real-world processes of language use. 4. A task can involve any of the four language skills. 5. A task engages cognitive processes. 6. A task has a clearly defined communicative outcome. (Ellis, 2003: 9–10)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
64
65
Since the properties highlighted here are based on points of convergence across the definitions Ellis surveyed, this definition could be taken as representative of areas of general agreement, although inevitably this also means that some aspects of existing definitions (e.g. ‘task’ as a jointly constructed social milieu) are not overtly represented here. Nevertheless, to explore the scope of Ellis’s approach to definition as it stands, we’ll take a look now at each of his criterial properties, point by point. 5.2.1
Task as workplan
Like most definitions, Ellis’s begins with a generic term, ‘workplan’, here echoing Breen’s distinction between task-as-workplan and task-in-process distinction. However, by framing his definition in terms of ‘workplan’, Ellis uses the definition to refer explicitly only to the intentions of the teacher (and possibly the materials writer), and thus excludes the activities the students actually engage in. That is, the definition enables ‘task’ to be defined in terms of pedagogical intention, but not in terms of what happens in practice. However, other elements of the definition are not consistent with this position. Points 3 and 5, for example, are not helpful as criteria unless we can show what kinds of processes occur. At the very least, we have to be able to show that the task as designed does give rise to realworld processes of language use and that it engages cognitive processes. As noted earlier, this means that it is not enough to look at the activity on paper; we need to observe what happens when learners engage with it. In fact, the definition of the term ‘task’ needs to accommodate the different ways in which it is used. For example, teachers and teacher educators will commonly ask questions of the kind: What did you ask the class to do? This is frequently directed at trainee teachers, for instance. Where a task is concerned, it refers to the task-as-workplan. The reason why it is relevant for trainee teachers is that they can often benefit from being encouraged to reflect about the choice and/or exact formulation of task instructions, and their relationship to the activities that learners actually engage in. In other words, teachers are encouraged to reflect on what they ask students to do, since it affects what they end up doing. Thus we need also to reflect on task as action and process. A second type of question frequently asked by teachers of each other is: How did the task work? Or: How did your group get on with the task? Here the central concern is with what learners actually did. This refers rather to the task as ‘task-in-process’, but it is worth noting that the question is asked in the light of what they were asked to do. From these two examples, we can argue that in educational contexts we are never simply interested in the task as workplan or the task in
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Defining Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
process: we are only interested in each in so far as it relates to the other. In other words, we need the term ‘task’ to refer to both dimensions of the activity, just as the word ‘activity’ itself, like words such as ‘game, set and match’, can refer both to the plan prior to the event, and to the events of the plan-in-action. All the more so in the case of language learning tasks, since without attention to both the plan and the process, the pedagogic principle is lost. Thus to understand tasks, far from ignoring what learners actually do with them, it is essential that we study how learners respond to and engage with tasks, and how they modify and reinterpret the workplan themselves. Hence, rather than defining tasks as ‘workplans’, we propose that they can be more usefully defined as a holistic type of pedagogical activity, a term which can encompass both the plan itself (the task on paper) and how that plan is subsequently interpreted and enacted by learners and teachers. 5.2.2
Language use
Items 2, 3 and 4 in the definition are all concerned with language use. However, we could argue that items 2 and 3 are implied by item 4. That is, the phrase ‘language use’ implies both ‘real world’ and ‘a primary focus on meaning’. While it might be useful to specify that tasks can involve the use of all four language skills, this is not strictly necessary, and is in any case implied in ‘holistic’ pedagogic activity. Given this, the phrase ‘language use’ can also be taken to imply that language is socially and interpersonally mediated. Hence we argue that language use is the key element of the definition. 5.2.3
Cognitive processes
Item 5 introduces the notion of cognitive process. As Ellis points out, this term has two meanings. On the one hand, any use of language involves some kind of cognitive activity; on the other, the term is often associated with problem-solving. Interestingly, many tasks used in second language pedagogy have a problem-oriented dimension, although it is worth noting that this dimension can be either problem-solving or problemposing in its orientation. For example, in the former, a problem is typically set externally by the task designer with a solution to be found by the learners, as reflected in examples of problem-solving tasks in Prabhu (1987); in the latter, a problem may be jointly created by the learners themselves on the basis of personal experience, and used as a springboard for collaborative exploration of underlying issues rather than direct solution per se, as reflected in problem-posing tasks based on Freirean principles
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
66
Defining Pedagogic Tasks
67
Quote 5.6
Bereiter and Scardamalia on problem-solving
... goal-directed activity in which a path to the goal is not known in advance and has to be discovered. (Bereiter and Scardamalia, 1993: 129–30)
Here we have a more precise characterisation of some of the cognitive processes subsumed in Ellis’s definition. But does this imply that for a problem-oriented task to be pedagogically effective, participants must know at least some of the relevant paths to the goal? Certainly knowing none of the relevant paths would create too heavy a learning load, and so we might expect that only a proportion of the paths should be unknown in advance. This much is common sense, perhaps. But are Bereiter and Scardamalia also implying that a problem-solving activity must involve the creation of a new path? If so, does this mean we risk ruling out the use of problem-oriented activities that focus on fluency development? Perhaps one way of avoiding risks such as these would be to expand this definition of ‘problem-solving’ to encompass improvement in the use of familiar paths, as well as the use of existing resources to complete the activity. An example from second language pedagogy is Samuda’s (2001) distinction between ‘knowledge-constructing’ and ‘fluency-stretching’ tasks, discussed in Chapter 8. A further puzzle for second language pedagogy is Bereiter and Scardamalia’s statement that paths have to be ‘discovered’. How does this relate to a teacher’s decision to use a task to raise learners’ awareness of the problem and to create a mental space for new relevant material to be introduced, rather than expecting them to discover the path for themselves? Questions such as these suggest that a problem-oriented dimension is not intrinsic to any particular task, but is a function of the relationship between the task and the knowledge state of the learners. To return to Ellis’s task definition, we propose that the following adaptation of Bereiter and Scardamalia’s characterisation of problem-solving provides a richer conceptualisation of the cognitive processes that may be engaged through working with tasks: a task is used to create some challenge aimed at promoting language development.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
(see section 2.2.3 above) in Wallerstein (1983). In both cases, despite obvious differences in orientation towards problem resolution, it is nonetheless engagement with some kind of ‘problem’ that functions as a catalyst for learning. With this in mind, let us consider what this could entail in terms of task processes.
Tasks in Second Language Learning
We propose that this reworking of the original definition allows for the following possibilities: raising participants’ awareness of the need for a new path; enabling them to understand and appropriate new resources which will enable them to follow a new path; or enabling them to reorganise familiar resources to track a new path, or to improve their use of familiar resources for a familiar path. (We note, though, that each of these possibilities may not always engage conscious cognitive processes.) 5.2.4
Outcome
By highlighting the need for ‘a clearly defined communicative outcome’, Ellis focuses attention on the importance of a meaningful outcome. As we saw in the case of the TIP task, this is an essential element of a task. The outcome of a task can be described as meaningful in the sense that it can be interpreted and evaluated in a number of pragmatic ways – for instance as true or false, as more or less informative, as more or less persuasive, or as more or less amusing, interesting or sad. However, Ellis’s notion of ‘a clearly defined communicative outcome’ is problematic. For example, how clear is ‘clear’ and who decides? (One might reply ‘the students, of course’, but students do not necessarily agree.) In addition, what counts as a ‘communicative outcome’? Is a number, a communicative outcome? Or a diagram? Or a performance? Or a report? Or cake? A piece of music? A poster? In order to navigate these problems, we propose some alternative phrasing here: an explicit nonlinguistic outcome, that is a language (and/or semiotically) mediated outcome that is not in itself a language focus. By ‘explicit’ we mean an outcome that is somehow signalled or stated. By ‘non-linguistic’ outcome we mean a pragmatic conclusion to the task. This can take many forms, for example, laughter, the communication of information, the production of a persuasive stretch of talk or writing, a poem, a list, a brochure, a meal, a T-shirt design, a mural, a song, a diagram, a map, a chart, and so on. We use ‘outcome’ in a generic sense, denoting it as one of the essential requirements of a task, although we recognise that it is in many cases possible and desirable for a task to have more than one outcome signalled in more than one way. There is, however, another problem. A challenge for designing educational activity in any discipline is that pedagogic activity simultaneously seeks to engage two types of learning: outcome (content) learning and process (procedural) learning. In many educational activities the emphasis is on outcome learning, although this is always accompanied by some process (or procedural) learning. In language education, however, activities are often deliberately designed, selected and used with the purpose
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
68
69
of engaging learners in the use of language in order to achieve an outcome. Unlike other disciplines, then, language is both means and end. Language learning tasks are concerned with two types of pedagogical significance: first, that associated with the immediate outcome; second, that of language development. Opportunities for language development may be targeted through the ‘product’ of the task via the outcome (e.g. feedback on the poster summarising conclusions at the end of the TIP task) or through the process of arriving at that outcome (e.g. feedback on the language used in small group discussion speculating on the objects in the TIP task), or through both. Hence we propose that tasks need to have a non-linguistic outcome and that they are used to promote language development through process or product or both.
5.3
A working definition of ‘task’
Our exploration of the implications underlying the six aspects of Ellis’s task definition has highlighted some of the challenges and issues involved in defining what a pedagogic task is in terms of its bare essentials. In attempting to speak to these issues and challenges in light of the general elements of a task we established earlier in the chapter, we offer some modifications to Ellis’s original: • • • •
A task is a holistic pedagogical activity. A task involves language use. A task has a pragmatic, non-linguistic outcome. A task is used in such a way as to create some challenge aimed at language development. • A task is aimed at promoting language learning through process or product or both. These can be expressed in a single sentence:
Concept 5.1 A working definition of a second language pedagogic task A task is a holistic activity which engages language use in order to achieve some non-linguistic outcome while meeting a linguistic challenge, with the overall aim of promoting language learning, through process or product or both.
Although the aim of a generic minimalist approach to definition is to distinguish broadly a task from other types of pedagogic work, a study of
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Defining Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
tasks necessarily must extend well beyond these minimum features to include relationships between task characteristics and language; task implementation and language; students, tasks and language; task characteristics, task implementation, students, and learning; task and social context. With our working definition of ‘task’, we have begun to narrow our focus from the use of holistic tasks in general education and in human sciences research to the use of tasks in second language pedagogy and research. We now narrow the focus again to explore the pedagogic context in which tasks came into prominence in second and foreign language teaching.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
70
Engaging Learning Processes: Implications for the Use of Second Language Tasks
To round out our discussion of the role of tasks in second language learning, we re-situate issues raised in this section in relation to broader conceptualisations of learning in two ways. In this, we: • revisit aspects of learning and problem-solving; • revisit issues of general learning processes. In both cases, we then narrow the focus again to: • highlight key factors in understanding ways that tasks can relate to second language learning, first, by revisiting aspects of learning and problem-solving; and second, by revisiting the issue of general learning processes. In both cases, we narrow the focus again to highlight key factors in understanding ways in which tasks can relate to second language learning.
6.1 Real-world activities, holistic tasks and learning: some issues As we have seen, one issue raised repeatedly since Dewey is how pedagogy can be related to real-world activity. In what ways can the slipstream of real-world experience be appropriately harnessed as a tool for learning? One dimension worth exploring is the element of structure already inherent in some types of real-world activity, and the elements of structure inherent in the sequences in which those activities may be typically encountered. Lave (1990), in a study of tailors’ apprentices learning in the context of the workplace, describes how the apprentices worked 71
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
6
Tasks in Second Language Learning
through a progression of workplace experiences starting with activities that provided access to overall goals for performance. For example, by starting with tasks like finishing and ironing completed garments the apprentices were able to develop an understanding of the expected requirements and standards for the whole task, including level of finish and the shape of components. From this they typically moved on to activities providing access to requirements for particular performances, for example, specific procedures for constructing garments. The apprentices’ workplace learning thus appeared to progress from engagement with low accountability tasks (some tolerance of error) to engagement with high accountability tasks (no tolerance of errors because of significant consequences). In citing Lave’s study, it is not our intention to imply that there is a necessary connection between apprenticeship models of learning and the use of tasks in second language pedagogy. Rather, what is of interest is that inherent in the progression described by Lave is a movement that starts with a focus on ‘the big picture’ – the demands of the whole task – and continues towards a focus on the details of its parts. The ‘whole to parts’ progression illustrated here is an option that might be usefully exploited in the use of tasks for classroom learning (see Chapters 7 and 9). However, as Ericsson and Hastie (1994) point out, we also need to take into account that, beyond a certain point, learning in real-world situations may be less efficient and less effective than in deliberately structured learning situations. Ericsson and Hastie identify two reasons for this. First, in everyday activities – whether in work or play – learning opportunities may occur randomly and many of them only occasionally. Second, whether in work or play, the purposes and rewards of the activity are generally not conducive to learning. In work, the main demand is for efficiency, while in play the search for the pleasures of ‘flow’ leads the participant away from practice at eliminating errors. Both factors work against learning. A pedagogy that uses holistic or real-world activities in the classroom thus needs to take this in account. A number of findings from the study of problem-solving highlight more precisely what it is that needs to be taken into account and how. In a survey of studies of children’s cognitive development, Ellis and Siegler (1994) highlight factors that seem significant in children’s development in problem-solving in their mother tongue. Interestingly, a number of the issues that Ellis and Siegler bring together could be related to a number of the themes we have been highlighting. With this mind, we briefly summarise some of the issues they raise and explore their potential relevance for the use of tasks in second language learning.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
72
Engaging Learning Processes
73
1. formation of strategies; 2. representation; 3. self-regulation. In this they highlight three main kinds of ‘representation’: 1. memory for past occurrences; 2. language; 3. external representations. ‘Self-regulation’ is seen in terms of: • planning; • private speech; • dialogue. While these processes are all important, Ellis and Siegler’s survey offers evidence to suggest that learning does not occur without an appropriate task structure or facilitative learning conditions (see Example 6.1).
Example 6.1 Issues arising from research into the development of problem-solving abilities 1. Planning needs support: Planning involves preparatory reflection, which can be broken down into a number of sub-features, influencing behaviour in a series of ways. Children are unwilling to plan, but planning seems to increase as a function of their sensitivity to the nature of task demands. Nonetheless, planning needs encouragement. 2. The role of feedback and collaboration: ‘Good ideas do not automatically win out over bad’ (Ellis and Siegler, 1994): Working with a partner, receiving feedback and working with a partner who used the target rule across a series of practice problems, was far more likely to lead to correct rule formulation, and to adoption of the rule. This is one reason why it may be important for learners to know the language learning purpose as well as the intended task outcome. 3. Problem/task structure: Understanding the goals that strategies must meet is critical to avoiding random trial-and-error behaviour. This implies that both problems and learning purpose need to be clearly defined for learning to take place.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Ellis and Siegler focus on three aspects of the development of problem-solving:
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 6.1
(Continued)
4. Problems and strategy development: Experience of solving particular problems leads to the development of multiple strategies for solving that class of problem. This suggests that a systematic pedagogy would need to group task types. 5. Interaction type: Beneficial effects do not follow automatically from working with others, but rather depend on the nature of the interaction. Studies of the way in which collaborative interactions actually occur suggest that the desired types of collaborative interaction are exceptional. If partners work in parallel, or one partner dominates the interaction, collaborations are no more productive than one individual working alone. Further the reluctance of the older, more expert children to relinquish control of the task to the younger, less expert one is a block to the less expert participant’s learning. In contrast designed activities which structure and support particular types of interactive questioning are effective. 6. The positive role of activity as context: Decontextualised briefing for problemsolving is ineffective because hard to transfer. In contrast, contextualising support within tasks is effective because they are applied to specific tasks, are open to joint contributions, and as a result are more motivating, allow active participation, deep processing and enable application of skills to a variety of sample tasks, encouraging generalisation.
As we can see, the research reviewed by Ellis and Siegler suggests that tasks are valuable because, in line with Dewey and Bruner, they contextualise learning. However, design, language learning focus, planning, feedback, interaction types and guidance are all essential. In other words, as Ericsson and Hastie point out, naturally occurring activities, however meaningful, are not of themselves necessarily good learning environments. Further, the research reviewed by Ellis and Siegler suggests that tasks do not necessarily lead to learning if students are not provided with feedback through practice tasks (if students are working alone or with another novice), or if one of the students does not already use the pattern. It is common for the ‘expert’ child not to enable other participants to become actively involved in the task. This research also shows that productive interactions do not occur spontaneously, but need modelling, structuring or prompting. It also appears that children have difficulty finding strategies to solve problems if the goals are not clear. Children, Ellis and Siegler argue, may be naturally unwilling to plan. All this suggests that a second language pedagogy of tasks will be viable only if it seeks out systematic relations between tasks and language learning (issues of design, learning focus and interaction types), and the ways in which tasks are implemented in the classroom to promote learning (notably the use of planning, feedback and teacher guidance and support).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
74
75
It is tempting to think of tasks as engaging language learning processes as if by magic (cf. Dewey 1910). However, Ellis & Siegler suggest that there are reasons for us to develop a critical stance regarding how tasks work to promote learning. This raises some searching questions regarding the design and use of tasks for language learning: 1. Is the goal of the task clear and do the students know what kind of learning they are supposed to be aiming for? In particular, if the goal is linguistic, do they know what language they are trying to work on? If it is not linguistic, what is the role of any eventual goal achievement? 2. Is planning presented as strategically valuable, and if so what is it focused on? 3. Is formative feedback provided? 4. If feedback is not provided, are dyads formed so that one of the pair is already an expert in the target domain, and if so, is the expert briefed to allow the novice to participate actively? 5. Is the desired type of group- or pair-interaction supported or prompted; and are the guidelines contextualised within particular tasks? In other words, research in both education and social psychology provides grounds for thinking that it is inadequate to simply provide tasks for learners to do and hope that valuable interaction or learning will take place. This would be task-as-magic, and it would be understandable if such an approach were seen as ‘task-as-chaos’. Instead, questions such as 5 above might point in a direction which could help us to answer Dewey’s question: how might activities best be arranged so as to motivate, channel and support learners’ efforts to learn? Let us explore this by returning again to Bruner.
6.2
Three types of general learning process
Bruner (1973) conceptualises learning in terms of three types of process: 1. acquisition (to refer to the processes of internalisation of new material); 2. transformation (to refer to the processes whereby the new material is adopted and deployed by learners for their own strategic purposes); 3. evaluation (to refer to any processes of review in the light of any internal and external criteria). These processes can occur more or less simultaneously, and in many cases evaluation can operate before transformation has occurred.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Engaging Learning Processes
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 6.1
Bruner on types of learning process
First there is acquisition of new information – often information that runs counter to or is a replacement for what the person has previously known implicitly or explicitly. At the very least it is a refinement of previous knowledge. Thus one teaches a student Newton’s laws of motion, which violate the testimony of the senses. Or in teaching a student about wave mechanics, one violates the student’s belief in mechanical impact as the sole source of real-energy transfer. Or one bucks the language and its built-in way of thinking in terms of wasting energy by introducing the student to the conservation theorem in physics which asserts that no energy is lost. More often the situation is less drastic, as when one teaches the details of the circulatory system to a student who already knows vaguely or intuitively that blood circulates. A second aspect of learning may be called transformation – the process of manipulating knowledge to make it fit new tasks. We learn to unmask or analyze information, to order it in a way that permits extrapolation or interpolation or conversion into another form. Transformation comprises the ways we deal with information in order to go beyond it. A third aspect of learning is evaluation, checking whether the way we have manipulated information is adequate to the task. Is the generalization fitting, have we extrapolated appropriately, are we operating properly? Often a teacher is crucial in helping with evaluation, but much of it takes place by judgments of plausibility without our actually being able to check rigorously in our efforts.’ (Bruner, 1973: 421–2)
Now let us relate this more specifically to second language learning. Bruner’s ‘acquisition’ can be related to the processes whereby aspects of the language are perceived in terms of visual and acoustic forms, and in terms of the corresponding articulatory and graphic production plans, comprehended, and then internalised into the memory system, through processes of assimilation and accommodation. These processes involve what might be called form and discourse. By form we mean intonation, pronunciation – including the articulation of phonemes in the context of co-occurring words; grammar – referential, requiring users to have referents to refer to; discoursal aspects of tense, mood, aspect, modality, formulaic chunks and collocational sequences. The term ‘discourse’ can be used in different senses: we use it to refer to speech acts, including discoursal aspects of marking and phasing of speech acts; discourse structures, monologic, such as narrative, process, description, explanation; dialogic, such as conversation, debate, argument, instruction, interviewing, consultation, service encounters. By transformation Bruner refers to the learners’ personal strategic employment of the resources that are being acquired. In second language learning, transformation processes involve the personalisation of the language by the learner, part of what has been termed ‘appropriation’ by
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
76
77
those working in a Vygotskyan perspective, as well as generalisation to new contexts. Evaluation refers to the processes of judging the match between the learners’ use of language and target uses. We exemplify these three processes in more detail later, where we map each process onto the sample TIP task, and then explore what this could imply more broadly for the use of tasks as contexts for engaging second language learning.
6.3
Tasks as contexts for engaging learning processes
The case we have made thus far suggests that tasks are activities in and around which the processes of acquisition, transformation and evaluation can occur in contexts of holistic language use. Van Lier comments that second language learning can be accomplished by learners using a variety of different resources, including: a) b) c) d)
assistance from more capable peers or adults interaction with equal peers interaction with less capable peers . . . inner resources. (1996: 193)
He also points out that feedback can have a more powerful effect on learning than interaction (1996: 192), and that one source of this can be the task itself. This suggests that in trying to understand the key ways in which tasks can relate to learning, we need to consider: a) b) c) d) e) f) g)
interaction with the task; assistance from more capable peers; assistance from the teacher before, during or after the task; interaction with equal peers; interaction with less capable peers; inner resources; other resources (e.g. printed, electronic).
This is presented diagrammatically in Figure 6.1. Now let us see relate these factors to the TIP task we introduced as an example at the beginning of this chapter: • Teacher purpose: to engage the learners in an activity which would raise awareness of the semantic area of epistemic modality (i.e. ways of expressing degrees of certainty).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Engaging Learning Processes
78
Tasks in Second Language Learning Other resources Teacher assistance
Learner purpose
Acquisition-transformation–evaluation
TASK
Inner resources
More capable peers Equal peers Less capable peers Figure 6.1 Key factors in understanding ways in which tasks can relate to second language learning
• Teacher assistance: pre-task: brief the learners orally on the purpose; underline and help learners achieve the purpose during the task as need arises and review their findings at the end of the task; post- task: draw on learners’ joint experience as a basis for targeting expressions of epistemic modality. • Task design: to engage learners in a series of processes, notably observation and interpretation of the objects, and prediction of their likely owner. In line with our previous discussion of possible differences between the ‘official’ and the ‘private’ task, we are more speculative about the learnerrelated considerations. • Learners’ purposes could include: to manage relevant participation in a group task; to participate in organising or evaluating comments; to develop aspects of lexico-grammatical repertoire; to experiment with current resources; to play. • Learner’s inner resources: might or might not suffice to enable her to locate the nature of problem, and to assess her current resources for dealing with it. • More capable peers and teacher: might help clarify the nature of the problem, and offer some resources to deal with it.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Teacher purpose
Engaging Learning Processes
79
Now let us relate these considerations to Bruner’s three types of learning process: acquisition, transformation and evaluation, outlined in section 6.1. During the task a learner might: a) In terms of acquisition • notice relevant concepts for which resources were lacking, alone, or with the aid of the teacher, or a peer; • perceive the need for missing resources; • notice resources used by other students to handle the conceptual problem; • notice functional and possibly formal similarities between some of the resources being used; • notice aspects of the use of certain resources which she was already somewhat familiar with (for instance the structural regularities of modal verb groups); • discover the possibility of extending familiar resources to handle the conceptual area; • improve accuracy in using own or others’ relevant available resources. b) In terms of transformation • simplify or complexify the conceptual demand of the task – e.g. simplifying by shifting the problem of expressing degrees of certainty to verbs of opinion; or complexifying by using a range of expressions of modality; • find and use familiar linguistic resources for dealing with the conceptual content, either from her own memory store, or from the talk of others during the task; • embed familiar resources into a more extended (e.g. explanatory) routine; • increase fluency in using relevant available resources. c) In terms of evaluation • appraise the extent of lack of resources; • appraise the adequacy of existing resources; • appraise the relevance of other people’s resources and advice; • appraise the appropriateness of their or of others’ use of new or available resources;
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
• Less capable peers: might lead her to articulate her own understanding of the problem, and how to deal with it.
80
Tasks in Second Language Learning
In short, all these resources can be seen as interacting with the learner’s purpose in engaging in the task. All can feed into Bruner’s three processes of acquisition, transformation and evaluation. The questions we will be pursuing in the rest of this volume cluster around the role of features of tasks in generating work and outcomes, and the ways in which tasks can be exploited by teachers and learners so as to promote the kinds of processes which we have outlined above.
6.4
Tasks in second language pedagogy: a summary
Rather than thinking in terms of concepts such as an all-embracing teaching method or approach, or theory of language acquisition, our focus is on the ways in which the task can be used to mediate language use, language processing and, through this, learning. This is illustrated in Figure 6.2. Figure 6.2 suggests that varying an aspect of a task is simultaneously an issue of design, of pedagogy and of language use and learning. This interaction shapes and is shaped by the classroom ecology. For instance, in the case of the TIP task, changing the number and type of objects would be a design issue, and this could change the pedagogy and the learners’ language. If the teacher decides to describe the various objects before the students start the task, then this would affect the nature of the input and could affect the learners’ language. That is, any change in the task-as-plan corresponds at the same time to a pedagogic decision and Design
Pedagogic decisions
TASK Input Instructions Conditions Processes Product
Learner’s language use/learning
Classroom ecology
Figure 6.2 How a task can be used to mediate language use, language processing and, through this, learning
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
• appraise the extent to which the task and follow-up work helped her to understand and handle the problem area.
81
to learners’ language use. Learners’ language use is engaged at two points: in understanding the input, the instructions and the conditions; and in acting on this to engage the processes and achieve the target outcome. What this amounts to is an analysis of the relationships between what might be called the ‘task-as-tool’ or instrument, and those who are using it – the teacher and the students. Similar relationships can be found in other areas of human activity. For instance, there is a comparable relationship between the rules of a game and those who play it: changing the size of a tennis racket, the height of the net or the nature of the ball will affect how the players perform. Similarly, in medicine changing the type of scanning devices that are available changes the behaviour both of doctors and of patients. These relationships can be mapped broadly in terms of the following aspects: 1. Task
Characteristics (input; instructions; intended outcomes) Implementation (task conditions: preparation, briefing, monitoring, timing, familiarity)
2. Language
Task and language product
3. Processes
Task and processing
4. Learning
Task, language processes, task conditions and learning Task, language products, task conditions, and learning
5. Participants
Task and learner/teacher differences Task and learner/teacher strategies
6. Exploitation
Teaching processes (e.g. pre-/while/post-; ⫹/⫺ explicit) Task purpose (e.g. role in the teaching cycle)
7. Ecology
Task and class ethos Task and learner identity
This may look complicated. However, the richness of a holistic approach to language teaching is bound to lead to a richness of issues for exploration. We return to these issues in the following chapters.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Engaging Learning Processes
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
We turn now to some of the key issues and challenges in researching second language pedagogic tasks. We consider studies undertaken in terms of their potential to inform users and designers of tasks in pedagogically useful ways – that is, in terms of their pedagogical relevance. To be of use, empirical research, like pedagogy, needs to focus on practice and to describe and explain what happens and why. So if tasks are aimed at developing holistic language abilities, a key priority is to explore how far tasks achieve this, in what ways, under what conditions and why. Answers to questions such as these are important in practical terms and to further our understanding about the conditions and processes of classroom language learning. Although tasks are devised and used for pedagogical purposes, the kinds of research that can be undertaken extend well beyond the theories and practices of classroom users. This is hardly surprising since it is not unusual for research to approach phenomena from many angles, with some being more closely related than others to users’ concerns. This is partly due to the fact that all phenomena can be conceptualised from a wide range of distinct perspectives. For instance, meals can be studied in terms of gastronomy, culinary arts, diet, economy, psychology, chemistry, anthropology or language, among others, not all of them relevant to the family cook. All these potential perspectives generate distinct theories, which in turn are all normally open to verification and development. And although research is subject to budgetary constraints, there is nothing to stop a line of research being developed if there are people determined to do it and participants willing to cooperate. It is no surprise then that research into tasks has been undertaken from a range of perspectives and distinct theoretical positions in ways which are not necessarily clearly related to pedagogical practices and theories. 82
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
7
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
83
It can be useful to distinguish between two aspects of research – the focus of study and the research paradigm. Both are theoretically shaped in the light of theories the researchers are interested in, whether these are derived from the classroom or from other sources. The focus is shaped by an idea of what categories or phenomena the researcher considers to be relevant; the paradigm by the research theories and practices which they consider most relevant and reliable. We can illustrate this in relation to the TIP task discussed in Chapter 1. In the TIP task, students are given objects which they are told come from someone’s pocket, and their task is to decide about who the owner is likely to be. Hence researching the task can involve any of the following: • • • •
input information; aims; discussion process; outcome.
In addition, we know that tasks have to be enacted by teachers and by learners. We also know that what happens will be influenced by the participants’ perceptions and understandings; that tasks are intended to contribute in some way to learning; that there are differences among learners and among teachers; and that they are used in the context of lessons, and of courses and curricula. So a researcher studying a task such as this one could focus on a number of features, as illustrated in Table 7.1. Essentially, each feature is considered in interaction with one or more tasks. The aim is to understand tasks in the light of empirical data about how learners, teachers, materials designers and others interact with tasks, for better or for worse. This means that the research will simultaneously provide information about the people involved in it. Sometimes this may result in information which says more about the people than about the tasks – see Foster’s (2001) study of the impact of planning on use of formulaic language, in Box 7.21. Table 7.1 could be expanded in many ways and could also be elaborated. Bruner, Goodnow and Austin (1956/1972) raised a series of more detailed questions about tasks which at the time had been devised for investigating learning (see Example 7.1). Their concern was to examine how tasks can be used to explore one aspect of learning – concept attainment – and to raise three sets of questions: focus on the learning process; questions
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
7.1 Approaches to researching second language pedagogic tasks
84
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Table 7.1 Potential elements of focus in researching second language pedagogic tasks
Learners’ procedures and processes Learners’ talk; phases of task; outcomes Impact of elements of task design Complexity of the task Demands of the discourse type Prototypically of task structure Types of roles required by the task Impact of conditions of implementation Familiarity with the task Planning time Repetition of the task Distribution of roles Dynamics around the task Negotiation for meaning Processes of talk construction Kinds of learning generated through task involvement Construals Learners’ interpretations of the task Learners’ evaluations of the task Teachers’ perceptions of the task Individual differences Learner differences: motivation, style, cultural background, age proficiency Teacher differences: e.g. style, background, experience. Task, lesson and curriculum Relationship between tasks and schemes of work/course plan Relationship between tasks and target tests Relationship between tasks and overall curriculum goals
about the internal effectiveness of the activity; and questions about what we now might call the ecology of the activity. Example 7.1 illustrates that our list of items to focus on can not only be extended, it can also be redefined, and the various parts of it can be elaborated in greater detail. At the least, these options indicate aspects of the topic which are likely to be worth exploring. They reflect thought around the topic and
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Teachers’ procedures and processes Teacher’s pre-task preparation Teacher’s post-task follow-up
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
85
Example 7.1
a. How do people achieve the information necessary for isolating and learning a concept? b. How do they retain the information gained from encounters with possibly relevant events so that it may be useful later? c. How is retained information transformed so that it may be rendered useful for testing a hypothesis still unborn at the moment of first encountering new information?
Internal effectiveness of the activity a. What concepts (i.e. repertoires and skills) do the tasks enable learners to attain? b. Using tasks, how speedily do learners achieve concept attainment (i.e. with as low a number of encounters as possible)? c. How reliably do learners achieve concept attainment? d. How comfortably do learners achieve concept attainment (i.e. without undue strain)? e. How directly do learners achieve concept attainment (i.e. without excessive error or false directions)? f. How far are learners helped to know when they have achieved their goals?
Ecology of the activity a. What are learners’ intentions and objectives? b. What is the internal structure and focus of the activity? c. How available is the feedback, and what is its quality? (Bruner, Goodnow and Austin, 1956/1972: 132ff)
offer different directions depending on one’s theoretical assumptions about what is relevant, and why further study could be informative.
7.2
Dimensions of task research
Whichever topic one chooses, however, there are a number of decisions to be made about the research methods to be used. Most of the topics outlined in Example 7.1 have to be approached along three sets of dimensions, each of which offers the researchers a choice. These are: • systemic vs. process; • macro vs. micro;
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Focus on the learning process
86
Tasks in Second Language Learning
• quantitative vs. qualitative.
7.2.1
Dimension 1: systemic vs. process
Systemic studies A systemic approach is particularly interested in obtaining a picture of one or more students at a given point in time. This might be in terms of their performance or what is inferred to be their internalised language system and might give rise to questions such as these: ‘What speech acts do speakers use on a particular task?’ ‘What kinds of verb or noun systems are used at a given/different levels of proficiency?’ ‘And with what fluency or accuracy?’ An interest in motivation, strategies or perceptions would attempt to derive a picture of a student’s strategic repertoire, motivational disposition or overall perceptions in relation to a task, asking: ‘What range of strategies do they seem to know about and/or employ in relation to a particular task?’ ‘What are their motivational attitudes towards the task?’ ‘What is the student’s perception of a give task?’ A systemic study tends to seek out information from one or more teachers or learners such as: • the range of language features used on a task or under particular conditions; • the set of attitudes to and perceptions of a task or set of tasks, or of the experience(s) of using them; • changes in language knowledge, language use or attitudes and perceptions after using one or more tasks; • how tasks relate systematically to the broader curriculum. That is, systemic studies seek to uncover systems of knowledge or understanding, often in order to make comparisons across tasks, groups or time. Systemic studies have difficulty in dealing with change processes as they tend to focus more on the differences between systems at two points in time than on the ways in which particular events between the two points might have contributed to the perceived changes. Overall this approach can be seen as trying to get a snapshot or summative view of the learner. Even if studies are longitudinal, the researcher’s target is an interlinked series of summative views. It is analogous to the cartographer’s attempt to map a territory, the chemist’s molecular view
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
To clarify these distinctions, let us briefly consider each dimension in turn.
87
of the world or the attempt in the creative arts to summarise a work or performance. However, it has two main weaknesses. The first is that snapshots generally rely heavily on inference for interpretation, because the findings tend to become disembodied from the context which yielded the data. The second weakness is related to the first, namely that snapshot data are very difficult to understand in terms of the local processes which make sense to teachers and students. This is significant because it is important to know how outcomes relate to classroom processes, for both theoretical and practical purposes. Process studies In contrast, process studies attempt to address the problem encountered by systemic approaches by focusing on what one or more learners or teachers do prior to, while engaged on or after doing one or more tasks. Process studies aim to understand how learners and/or teachers use particular activities in order to complete them, and to promote learning. Process studies therefore concentrate on tracking learners’ individual and joint behaviours moment by moment, in order to derive a picture of how tasks are accomplished. The primacy of this focus means that process studies are often carried out without reference to systemic data: such studies generate understanding of the dynamics of tasks, but may pay less attention to relating the processes to participants’ existing or subsequent understandings. This approach opens up other avenues for studying teaching and learning processes. An important strength is that teachers and learners can relate the findings to activities and episodes occurring within their classrooms, and the findings can therefore inform their use of materials. The approach does, however, have important limitations. One is that observations made in the context of particular activities are open to multiple interpretations. A question from a student may not be what it appears: the student may know, or have a strong hunch about, the answer, but wish simply to launch the discussion. Alternatively, the student may have temporarily forgotten the answer or misunderstood the issue. Equally, apparent discoveries in the context of an activity may hide misunderstandings, be only partially understood or be understood but not yet have reached the point where they can be functionally applied. The point is that the complexities of the situation make uncontroversial interpretation from outside extremely difficult. Hence the danger with process studies is that without data which adequately sample the student’s functional control it is not possible to interpret adequately what was known and what was learnt. Given their respective strengths, it
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
88
Tasks in Second Language Learning
makes sense to consider both options as potentially important allies in task research. Dimension 2: macro vs. micro
‘Macro’ studies refer to group studies, while ‘micro’ studies refer to case studies. We separate this dimension from the systemic/process distinction because it is possible to undertake a systemic study on a single case (common in child language studies and in language pathology, among other domains). It is also possible to undertake a process-oriented study involving many participants (Lynch and Maclean, 2000, 2001, discussed below, are of this kind). The key point about the macro/micro distinction is that macro studies generally seek to generalise across cases, obliging the research to omit more details than a micro study. In contrast, micro studies offer more space to the researcher to explore idiosyncrasies within the data, although it is mistaken to imagine that micro studies usually enable the researcher to avoid having to make any omissions at all, because all research is necessarily selective. It is worth noting that studies can use both macro and micro procedures, one being used to crosscheck the other (Bygate and Samuda, 2005, is a recent example). 7.2.3
Dimension 3: qualitative vs. quantitative
The final dimension is qualitative/quantitative. This concerns whether or not to handle the data numerically. We separate this from the other two because it is possible for a process-oriented study to check frequencies (see Swain and Lapkin, 2000, 2001). Furthermore, case study data can be handled either without attending to frequencies (as in Donato 1994) or with an analysis of frequencies (as is often the case in child language studies, language pathology studies and in task-related research such as Duff, 1993). The dimensions taken together offer four main research paradigms, as illustrated in Table 7.2. Examples of studies for each subtype appear in the appropriate quadrant. Most of the systemic research into pedagogic tasks has been through macro quantitative studies, while most (though by no means all) of the process research has been undertaken through micro qualitative studies. Some methodologies have been scarcely exploited at all in the study of tasks (e.g. personal construct theory, an approach to research which uses a micro-oriented methodology to investigate personal understandings has not been attempted in this field). Yet all approaches have an important contribution to make, and there are grounds for believing that all reflect some aspect of most teachers’ thinking. If our concern is whether
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
7.2.2
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks The four main research paradigms
Micro Quantitative
Qualitative
Macro Quantitative
Qualitative
Systemic
Process
Studies of how individuals personally construe tasks, or their use.
Studies of how individuals or small groups negotiate their way through a particular task. Studies of how a teacher uses a task with a particular class.
Studies of how an individual’s inter-language or motivation might change after experiencing one or more tasks. Studies of how students’ fluency or accuracy, or motivation are generally affected by different tasks, or task conditions. Interview-based studies of students’ motivation before and after using a particular type of task or task condition.
Studies of the extent to which students engage in particular discourse sequences in order to complete a task. Studies of designers’ processes in task design.
tasks are a viable teaching instrument, then teachers, testers and materials designers all need to know how particular types of task generally work and whether their use has sufficiently consistent types of impact for them to be worth using. This implies a role for systemic studies. At the same time, it is important for teachers and designers to understand how individuals work through activities, and what kinds of language processes they engage in and why, since this too may be part of what tasks are being used to activate. General patterns reflecting the processes engaged in typically by groups of students are also of interest to teachers. Further, if one’s concern is with the ways tasks are perceived and utilised, both a systemic perspective and the use of process-oriented methods will reflect some aspects of teachers’ thinking. However, it is also often important for findings from each approach to be related to analyses from other approaches. Thus, it can be important for systemic studies to be able to show how their findings relate to the processes learners engage in, while process analysts are sometimes likely to want to explore the extent to which their findings are typical/atypical in relation to a certain number of learners. In the same way, while it is important for teachers and testers to know what general processes or patterning occur under different conditions in different contexts, without
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Table 7.2
89
90
Tasks in Second Language Learning
7.3 7.3.1
Overview of approaches to the study of tasks Systemic studies of tasks: some examples
Systemic studies are interested in identifying representative patterning in data from students, individually or in groups. The aim is to understand the phenomenon being investigated in terms of a system – whether of knowledge, of proficiency, of attitudes and motivations, or of strategies. This means sampling enough to obtain information which is sufficiently thorough for the researcher to be able to conclude that the picture gained is stable, representative, not a chance occurrence, and therefore could be expected to appear again under comparable circumstances. Systemic studies can focus on a single individual or on groups. This approach is typical of many researchers (see Long, 1996; Loschky and Bley-Vroman, 1993; VanPatten, 1996; Skehan 1998; and in summary form Ellis, 2000).
Example 7.2
Long, 1981
Long’s approach to the study of the use of tasks was based on a theory of learning significantly influenced by the work of Krashen. Long (1981) assumed that language is best acquired in the context of use, for two reasons. First, he argued that contexts of use help acquisition because they contain information about the language which is essential if the learner is to be able to relate the grammatical details of the language to their discourse meanings. That is, through talk language features can be simultaneously mapped onto both the grammatical system and the discourse system. Second, he held that since it is really only language which the learner is exposed to face to face that can be properly adjusted to the learner’s level of acquisition, with problems being negotiated at source, tasks therefore offer a potentially valuable context for a learner to learn within the classroom. This means that the most effective learning is individualised, with the learner being able to identify new needed language, whether in an interlocutor’s discourse or her own and at the point of need, obtain relevant clarification. This procedure Long termed ‘negotiation for meaning’. Tasks clearly provide an opportunity for learning of this type, principally because they are centred on meaningful use of language. Deriving from Long’s main concern, researchers have studied tasks in order to assess the extent to which tasks lead learners to negotiate for meaning.
This view is most succinctly expressed in the form of the ‘interaction hypothesis’.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
studying individual cases we cannot know the kinds of experience that different learners have, and – just as important – it is impossible for us to take account of differences between learners. We review some of the main directions of research from these perspectives next.
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
91
[N]egotiation of meaning, and especially negotiation work that triggers interactional adjustments by the NS or more competent interlocutor, facilitates acquisition because it connects input, internal learner capacities, particularly selective attention, and output in productive ways. (Long, 1996: 451)
Loschky and Bley-Vroman (1993) also adopt a systemic approach to tasks: tasks are conceptualised in terms of traits which have consistent relationships to patterns of language use.
Example 7.3
Loschky and Bley-Vroman,1993
Loschky and Bley-Vroman (1993) propose that tasks can be designed to target more or less precisely the use of particular features of language. They suggest that the most precise targeting involves tasks for which a particular language feature is essential to task completion. A less focused task would be one in which the targeted language feature would be useful in the execution of the task. The least motivated level of focus is one in which the features would be natural in the execution of the task. Loschky and Bley-Vroman underpin their discussion by highlighting the importance for all learners of the processes of automatisation (whereby new knowledge is made rapidly accessible) and restructuring (whereby old knowledge is reorganised to take account of new understanding).
Clearly the underlying learning processes and the qualities of task design are seen as being applicable to everyone: hence macro studies should be appropriate for exploring issues such as these since we should be looking for major effects, not distinct differences between learners. VanPatten (1996) considers a general effect on learning of the relative meaningfulness/lack of meaning of elements of the language.
Example 7.4
VanPatten, 1996
VanPatten (1996) focuses on a central process which he argues affects all communication-based learning, namely that language which is not essential to communication in some way will be perceived as redundant, and hence hard to learn. This is another form of the ‘essentialness’ debate, which can be traced back to the seminal work of George (1972). VanPatten, like George, therefore designs listening tasks to require the learner to attend to the target features to achieve the goals. VanPatten’s approach to using listening to provide optimal input has given rise to a line of studies which essentially demonstrate that specially designed tasks can effectively draw learners’ attention to pre-selected language features while at the same time they attend to the meanings of what they hear.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Long’s interaction hypothesis
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Skehan 1998 offers another example of a researcher seeking systemic effects. Skehan essentially acknowledges the role of redundancy and the need to deal with it, but believes that rather than reduce redundancy, it is better to work with it. Hence he incorporates this insight into a larger scheme of language learning, which he too proposes as essentially universal, although his scheme allows for different aspects to be emphasised more by some learners than others.
Example 7.5
Skehan, 1998
For Skehan, learning proceeds by a process of 1) lexicalisation (i.e. item-learning); 2) grammaticisation; and 3) re-lexicalisation. In proceeding through the different phases, Skehan sees the learner as having to pay attention to three processes – fluency, accuracy and complexity. For every learner he conceives of these processes as competing with each other for attention. However, each is important. Skehan characterises them as operating within communication as follows: 1) an essentially conservative approach, which prioritises accuracy; 2) an essentially strategic approach which emphasises fluency; and 3) a fundamentally progressive approach, which focuses on complexification. Skehan proposes that all three are essential to successful language learning, but that different people will lean more readily than one than another. Teaching therefore needs somehow to manoeuvre learners into exercising all three emphases at different times. Tasks can be used to do this.
Skehan’s approach differs from VanPatten’s in that whereas VanPatten believes in biasing the content of the tasks to direct learners’ attention to the redundant grammatical features, Skehan believes that biasing should be avoided, to allow students normal task demands, using the conditions of the task rather than the task itself to influence the learner’s processing. Thus like the other authors exemplified here, Skehan proposes a universal set of processes, although he presents them in such a way as to allow for differences between learners and for them to follow different learning trajectories depending on the preferences they bring with them. Systemic approaches then agree that learning involves similar processes for everyone, although Skehan’s position is distinctive in making explicit the need to allow for differences between learners, albeit in terms of the same three universal processes. Ellis (2000) summarises the various macro approaches under the heading ‘psycholinguistic perspectives’. Theories such as these give rise to studies that seek to establish whether their predictions about how tasks can work are generally justified. It is useful to note that explanations for any results are generally a matter of informed debate, though studies often attempt to structure
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
92
93
the data collection and analysis so that if results are consistent with the theory, interpretation and discussion are assumed to be unnecessary. Null or negative results simply fail to support any proposed underlying theory, though these clearly can give rise to considerable debate over why. Findings so far generally but not always confirm the thinking that the use or type of tasks is indeed fairly predictably related to students’ use of language. Features that have been studied are the degree of structuring of tasks; the propensity of different tasks to engage particular areas of language; incidence of negotiation for meaning; the impact of implementation options such as allowing students planning time, providing teacher feedback and using familiar or repeated tasks. For most of those who have undertaken systemic studies, tasks have been of interest more because of the kinds of learning process that they were interested in promoting than because of an interest in the qualities of particular tasks (though we will also see below that in this respect process-oriented studies often approach tasks in a similar way). 7.3.2
Process studies of tasks
Process-oriented research has generally studied talk on tasks with the intention of revealing detailed aspects of language use by particular students. While it can seem as though systemic researchers have been mainly motivated to study tasks in order to explore their suitability for engaging particular types of learning, those undertaking process-oriented studies have often been especially concerned to demonstrate the power and richness of their research methods. Process-oriented researchers have sought first to explore the range of collaborative processes used by learners, and second to demonstrate the sensitivity of their research methodology to the particularities of different learning encounters. Many process studies have been inspired by socio-constructivist perspectives. This is understandable because socio-constructivists are particularly interested in how learners make sense of, structure and negotiate their way through an activity towards its completion. Because of this interest they have naturally tended to use a micro study approach. Micro-analytic approaches have also been used by researchers who are interested in the finer details of language use, albeit not from a socio-constructivist perspective, such as those working from a conversation analysis approach. Socio-constructivist studies have highlighted a number of important themes: Duff (1993) and Coughlan and Duff (1994) have shown how student and teacher, or pairs of students, have come to reinterpret tasks from their initial design. Aljaafreh and Lantolf (1998) and Swain and Lapkin (2001) have studied student–student and student–teacher dialogue as a
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
way to generate hypotheses and feedback for the learning process. Swain and Lapkin (2001) and Ohta (2001) have focused on interactive processes in the monitoring of lexico-grammatical accuracy. (We discuss these studies I more detail below.) Process studies have also been undertaken within a conversation analysis (CA) framework. CA is an approach to the analysis of talk which studies in detail the chaining of utterances in order to grasp the ways in which coherence, mutual understanding and repair are locally managed, turn by turn. This enables a fine-grained account of the different types of talk. In line with Duff, Mori (2002) demonstrates that a task – here a loosely structured interaction task in which a native speaker was interviewed by a whole class – fails to materialise in the ways in which the teacher had anticipated. In another study using CA techniques, Nakahama, Tyler and van Lier (2001) undertook a qualitative analysis that shows clear differences in the talk occurring in a three-way conversation compared with an information gap task involving the same learners. They argue that on the basis of their analysis the conversation offers a richer learning context than the information gap task. The socio-constructivist and CA-based studies mentioned above have generally adopted a set of analytical procedures to explore task-generated language data, sometimes with a pedagogically generated question (e.g. Swain and Lapkin, 2001; Ohta, 2001). However, other kinds of processoriented studies are possible. Samuda (2001) adopted a case study approach to examine how a task was used by teacher and students in a single classroom. Her intention was to track how the participants used the task at an early stage of a lesson to provide a basis for work in the ensuing phases, with the focus on the extent to which students’ group work contributed to the intended teaching dynamic. This is an example of a process-oriented study which is not situated explicitly in a particular paradigm, other than the concern to track the teaching–learning process through a task and into the following phases of the lesson. The study itself is unusual in addressing the issue of how a task can be used by teacher and learners to further an overall language learning goal. (We return to this study in Chapter 8.) 7.3.3
Reconciling the paradigms
The systemic/process and macro/micro dimensions tend to be mutually exclusive. This is partly because, as we have seen, process and system can be very difficult to interrelate. Similarly, handling data from large groups and from individual cases involves sufficiently different technologies for it to be a challenge for a single study to incorporate both types of analysis.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
94
95
Yet if a phenomenon has an impact across large groups, it must be equally amenable to investigation with individual learners (though the reverse may not be the case). Lynch and Maclean (2000, 2001) have applied this assumption to the study of the impact of task repetition. Both studies adopted the procedure of examining in detail a series of individual cases, each in its own terms, but with the aim of exploring how far the individual patterns exemplified a general trend. In each case, the analysis involved detailed comparison of the grammar, choice of vocabulary and phrasing in the different versions of talk of each individual speaker, and identified many significant changes which would not have been spotted without a case-by-case comparison. Yet the individual changes, although different for each speaker, all reflected a similar trend across the data. By presenting the analysis of a series of individual cases, Bygate and Samuda (2005) similarly showed that individual case studies can usefully contribute to understanding the qualitative discourse processes hidden behind group statistics. Similarly we find a parallel problem across types of micro study. Whereas personal construct theory (PCT) and neo-Vygotskyan approaches both assume the importance of detecting the individuals’ own systems of understanding and processes in learning, PCT can tend to lose track of the overt processes which contribute to the development of people’s internal systems of knowing, while neo-Vygotskyan approaches analyse closely individuals’ processes of learning, but seem not to come to grips with the learners’ underlying systems of knowledge. Reconciling the individual and the group, and reconciling the overt and observable with people’s invisible states of knowing, are the dual challenge for our field in general, and for understanding language learning tasks. Systemic approaches: an assessment To the extent that the key aspects of language processing are the same for all learners – an assumption that is probably shared by teachers, researchers and learners – macro studies that focus on these processes can have an important contribution to make. For instance, most would agree that, all key things being equal, different types of planning, repetition, familiarity, task structuring and task type are each likely to have a consistent effect on speakers whoever they are and whatever their learning context. We would also probably agree that many of the effects studied are likely to be relevant in stimulating language development. Furthermore, some of the results shed an interesting light on the ways in which different tasks interact differently with different conditions. Skehan and Foster (1997) and Foster and Skehan (1996) found that planning affected a simple
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
familiar task mainly in terms of fluency, whereas on the more complex decision-making kind of task, planning resulted in greater linguistic complexity. (We discuss such studies more fully below.) In addition, although it is often said that case studies are more appropriate than macro studies for generating hypotheses, a macro study with a sufficiently rich design can be very thought-provoking. Skehan and Foster’s series of studies (1996–9) eventually incorporated at least three distinct types of task, each with a more and a less structured version, each recorded with and without planning, and the whole data-set analysed in terms of the same measures of fluency, accuracy and complexity. A study of this kind is big enough for any emerging patterns to be fairly convincing, while at the same time leaving space for interesting distinct sub-patterns to appear. Ellis’s series of studies (discussed below) illustrates how macro studies can be designed so that each study provides the basis for the next, creating a series of linked investigations. In other words, both micro and macro studies can be hypothesis-creating. There are, however, limitations in the systemic studies undertaken to date. Generally because of the large amount of data to be analysed, they all have to abandon detailed study of the sequences of discourse moves through which learners deal with the tasks. For instance, in general they are not able to analyse the distinct phases of task performance or differences in the language strategies used. They also tend to neglect participants’ perceptions, and few of the systemic studies have addressed the issue of how tasks are interpreted (Garrett and Shortall, 2002, is an exception), or how they are used by teachers within the context of lessons or schemes of work. Only two sets of systemic studies have attempted to address the issue of learning – Ellis’s (e.g. Ellis, 1987; Fotos and Ellis, 1991) and Mackey’s (e.g. Mackey, 1999; Mackey and McDonough 1998) – and these are also rare in exploring learning outcomes. A major problem with the systemic paradigm then is that it allows less detailed analysis of the data and less attention to the perceptions and processes engaged in by the participants. A further apparent limitation is that studies from this perspective seem to operate with a relatively impoverished construct of what tasks are. For example, most macro studies tend to treat the learners’ processes – and hence the language they use – as essentially the same throughout the task. Many of the studies analyse only relatively small – though supposedly ‘representative’ – extracts of the recordings, the implication seeming to be that it makes little difference which part of the task the data are taken from. In addition, a lack of attention to teaching and learning is reflected in the fact that many studies fail to focus on particular aspects of language
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
96
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
97
Process studies: an assessment While most systemic studies have adopted a macro approach, most process studies have been micro in orientation. Hence when we consider the strengths and weaknesses of work in the process paradigm we get something of a reverse picture from that of the systemic studies. The process paradigm is especially effective in studying particular phases, processes and trajectories of task performance for individual learners or particular groups of learners. Hence studies from this perspective get closer to tracking the ways in which the execution of tasks diverges from the intentions or expectations of the teacher and/or learners. Such a focus takes seriously the question of the kinds of processes learners can engage in in response to a task, and this can inform issues of task design and implementation. Process studies also track the ways in which pairs and groups of students help each other to identify and understand new language, or scaffold each other in selecting and manipulating familiar language accurately. In a similar vein, this type of study can track the ways in which a teacher presents a task and exploits the students’ experience of a given task in her subsequent teaching. Hence this type of focus can illuminate the ways in which what students do on a task is connected to their learning before and after the task itself. There are, however, limitations with work carried out from this perspective. One is that although a single case may be illuminating, we need to know whether it is representative or idiosyncratic. In research terms it may be revealing to discover how a given learner works on a particular task, but for both theoretical and practical purposes we need to know not just one learner’s approach, but the main types of approach of learners in general. Further, just as with systemic approaches, some of the process studies seem to adopt a fairly impoverished model of pedagogical tasks. As with many of the systemic studies, the design and implementation of some of the tasks are often only very superficially presented. In particular they generally fail to reflect explicitly the qualitative thinking of designer or teacher about what the tasks are intended to do, why they are structured the way they are and why the implementation followed the pattern it did. Hence although the learners’ processes can be studied, it is impossible to generalise from this to the subsequent use of similar tasks.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
that could be being targeted for use or learning. Finally, a significant weakness is the lack of pedagogical grounding for the studies: few of the systemic studies report professional ratifications of the design and implementation, and the data are rarely reported as being part of a pedagogical scheme of work.
Tasks in Second Language Learning
A further potential problem with process studies can be a failure to triangulate analyses emerging from the data with the perceptions and interpretations of other judges. While there is a clear danger in systemic studies of the analyst imposing categories prior to the collection and analysis of the data, the opposite danger is for the data to be used to generate authentic categories which only the analyst(s) have recognised. Finally, given the general lack of attention to selecting tasks for study whose design and use were grounded in pedagogic contexts, the reader can easily conclude that the main aim of the study is either to test a method of data analysis and interpretation, or (conceivably) to undermine arguments in favour of systematic use of tasks in the language classroom. That is, if the object of the research is the function, use and development of pedagogical tasks, then it is essential for the study to focus on features of tasks that have pedagogical credibility. However, as we have seen, this is a limitation which is also found in certain of the systemic studies.
7.4 Research into second language pedagogic tasks: main findings In this section we look more closely at the main findings of the research that has been carried out to date in relation to a number of salient themes. Six main themes are listed in Table 7.3 (these are similar to the themes in Table 7.1). Table 7.3
Main themes in task research to date
Task content • the language focus of tasks • task phases Impact of elements of task design • the impact of task complexity • the impact of discourse type • task structure Impact of conditions of implementation • task familiarity • implementation effects • participant roles Task dynamics • negotiation for meaning • co-construction • acquisition
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
98
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
99
7.4.1
Task content
Language focus An important concern for language teachers and learners is how tasks help the learning and teaching of particular aspects of language. As we have seen, while some (e.g. Long, 1996; Willis, 1996; Skehan, 1998) argue that this is not the principal contribution of tasks, but rather to engage communicative processing of language, most would agree with McDonough and Mackey that a main challenge is ‘to create tasks that provide learners with opportunities to engage in meaningful interaction and to direct their attention to linguistic form (2000: 83). The question is, can particular areas of the language system be targeted? Long, Skehan and Willis, among others, believe that either it cannot or it should not. Others, like Loschky and Bley-Vroman (1993), argue that although it may not be possible to predict the occurrence of particular language features with certainty, most tasks are likely to be associated with the use of some language features with at least a reasonable degree of probability (e.g. Newton and Kennedy, 1996; Bygate, 1999; Mackey, 1999; Dufficy, 2004).
Quote 7.1 Newton and Kennedy on the predictability of the language used in tasks As with written genre, we would argue that the discourse produced through a task is given its identifiable shape and structure by the communicative purpose of the task. Given this, it is possible to predict the likelihood of the linguistic and discourse features in the ensuing interaction. (Newton and Kennedy, 1996: 312)
Empirically there is evidence that this is the case.
Example 7.6
Targeted information-processing in listening tasks
VanPatten (1996) reports studies in which learners’ attention can be drawn to particular grammatical features in the context of communicative listening tasks. This is achieved by ensuring that the only source of the required information is found in the target morphemes, so that students are unable to complete the task without noticing and interpreting those morphemes.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
We now review the major research studies to date in terms of these themes. The chapter concludes with a brief balance sheet, reviewing how much research seems to have achieved in relation to the potential aims outlined at the start of this chapter.
100
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 7.7
Bygate – question forms and lexical sets
Bygate (1988) found that a 20-Questions card game, carried out by eight groups of adult learners of English, was associated with the use of questions, although in many cases students avoided the use of a main verb, often but not always using intonation to mark the question. In addition, card games such as this clearly targeted particular lexical sets or domains (as could other tasks in other ways). This study provided early indications that tasks could be used to target grammar as well as lexis.
Example 7.8 Newton and Kennedy – prepositions and conjunctions Newton and Kennedy (1996) found that tasks concerned with the layout of a zoo were significantly more likely to motivate the use of prepositions; more prepositions were used on the zoo topic where information was split rather than shared between students, presumably because the split information had first to be pooled, and this led to an increase in the amount of description of locations. On the other hand where information was shared at the outset, and students had to focus on arguing a case rather than transferring information to each other, there was greater use of conjunctions.
Example 7.9
Mackey – different types of question formation
Mackey (1999) studied learner performance on a series of tasks: • • • •
Story completion task, in which students were to work out a story by asking questions. Picture sequencing task, in which students asked questions to discover the order of a picture story. Picture differences, where students identified differences between similar pictures. Picture drawing, which required students to describe or draw a picture.
In each case the students were required by the design of the task to gather the information they needed by asking questions.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Unfortunately, it is harder to do this in oral production tasks simply because in such tasks students are generally able to convey the key information by using other linguistic features. Nonetheless, some studies have shown that tasks can be used to draw students into particular areas of the language system, as illustrated in Examples 7.7–7.11.
101
Mackey found that various question forms could be effectively targeted by the four types of task, and demonstrated that performance on these tasks led to learners showing clear improvements in their production of questions as measured in pre-/post-tests. McDonough and Mackey (2000), working with learners of Thai, similarly showed that tasks like those in the Mackey (1999) study could be used to target and promote learning of question forms.
Example 7.10
Samuda – epistemic modality
Samuda (2001) reported the use of the TIP task as a way of drawing students into expressing degrees of certainty. (For a detailed discussion of this study, see Chapter 8.)
Example 7.11
Bygate – discourse patterns
Bygate (1988), with a corpus of eight groups of adult learners working on five different oral tasks, reported a degree of patterning in the discourse structures that appeared on different tasks (e.g. in terms of the occurrence of IRF sequences, short and long turns, use of non-finite structures in card games, and the incidence of collaborative utterance building, particularly in a detailed and hence quite demanding map-completion task). Furthermore, some tasks resulted in less varied discourse patterns than others. Card games seemed to give rise to relatively uniform discourse patterns across groups, while on the other hand, picture differences tasks and distributed picturestory tasks seemed to allow students option of negotiating the task, whether through a series of short turns (often where lower proficiency students seemed to be involved) or alternatively through fewer quite lengthy turns.
Studying the language of children in a multilingual classroom, Dufficy (2004) reports a notably regularity of language on a given task across different groups of children. He concluded:
Quote 7.2 Dufficy on regularity of language in task performance Given the design constraints ... of the communicative task described in this paper it may not come as a surprise to see the way the task predisposed children to choose particular patterns of language which were relatively consistent across groups. (Dufficy, 2004: 259)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
The main limitations with studies in this area are that only a limited range of features have been studied and few have been replicated. Furthermore, apart from Mackey (1999) and McDonough and Mackey (2000), few longitudinal or pre-/post-designs have been undertaken so that we have little evidence so far of acquisitional processes around the target features. It is certain that without appropriate exploitation, the more redundant the features, the less likely students are to use them. The results to date, however, give no reason to doubt that judicious selection of topic areas and of task structures can draw learners into engaging with systemic areas of a target language. To conclude this section, Dufficy (2004) considers that ‘a valuable goal to pursue for teachers in linguistically diverse classrooms might be the development of a kind of inventory describing the relationship between task types and the varied language work that accompanies them’ (2004: 259). Task phases As we saw at the beginning of Chapter 1, tasks by definition have their own internal phases, in contrast to mono-operational pedagogic procedures like drills or translation exercises. It makes little sense to ask of a drill or a translation task ‘Were the data collected at the beginning, the middle or the end of the activity?’ unless one is interested in factors such as the impact of fatigue, priming or internal practice effects. However, this is a highly relevant question where tasks are concerned, since these can often give rise to quite different kinds of interaction in different phases. For instance, many tasks require students at the beginning to work out how to use the input material, then to use it to achieve the target outcomes and finally to decide when these have been reached. In addition, during the task, there are likely to be procedural or communicational problems which need sorting out. As we saw in Chapter 2, Barnes (1976) and Barnes and Todd (1977) both provide data from L1 subject classrooms which illustrate the fact that groups need to deal with these aspects of tasks, and that in doing so, their thinking and use of language are differentially engaged. Curiously, however, little research has been devoted to this aspect of L2 tasks. One exception (Bygate, 1988) is shown in Example 7.12.
Example 7.12
Bygate – task phases
Bygate (1988) found that the five tasks in his study contrasted in terms of the types of phases they seemed to give rise to. For example, picture stories strikingly consisted of three basic phases: Phase 1: Description of each picture
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
102
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
103
Occasionally phase 1 turned into a question-and-answer sequence; phases 2 and 3 were sometimes negotiated and sometimes enacted by one speaker; and sometimes phase 2 involved significant checking moves to ensure that the various pictures had been correctly understood and remembered. Sometimes there was a fourth phase involving a telling of the full story, which might be done individually or jointly.
As can be seen, analysis of the phases of a task help us to understand more clearly what the speakers are typically doing and why. It also helps to distinguish between tasks – picture differences tasks and card gamebased tasks, for instance, each resulted in quite different phases. Three theoretical and practical issues arise here: 1. Evidence of the existence of different phases in tasks suggests that any analysis of transcripts needs to sample from across the different phases, and not from a single phase. Taking data from a single phase could easily give a highly misleading impression of the language work that the students are engaged in. 2. The analysis of phases helps to shed light on how a given task might be made easier or harder, and with what effects (e.g. in terms of negotiation of meaning, communication strategies, etc.). 3. Recognition of the existence of distinct phases might enable us to shed more light on the kinds of work that learners are doing through a task, and on the ways in which in particular they come to internalise the conceptual demands, and then to find ways of formulating the material. Studying phases might, for instance, reveal how learners engage with different aspects of the task, which could be valuable information for teachers. A final point is that analyses such as this are avowedly post hoc: they explore what learners actually do, not what they are supposed to do. As a result, the phases are seen as a creation of the students in response to the materials. Different groups might phase tasks differently, and it is an empirical question how far differences are a matter of social, cognitive or cultural factors, or simply of language proficiency, and how far they diverge from – or indeed converge with – the phases mapped out by the original workplan. Not surprisingly, given the lack of attention to this topic, there have been no studies so far of issues such as changes in phasing over time or
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Phase 2: Sequencing of the set of pictures Phase 3: Review to check the sequence
104
Tasks in Second Language Learning
of the impact of phasing to the learning of particular aspects of language, or of learner differences. Impact of elements of task design
In this section we review some of main studies that have focused on the impact of selected elements of the design of tasks. Complexity of task design Language focus is not the only area of pedagogical interest. As we saw in Chapter 1, the use of any pedagogical activity raises the issue of task complexity and the possibility of sequencing tasks in terms of their relative simplicity or complexity. The reasoning behind this is that we do not want to place too heavy a load on learners by asking them to manage too many things at the same time. So the question is, can we distinguish between tasks in terms of their complexity, in order to select better tasks for our learners’ levels of proficiency? This leads us to consider more closely the nature of different tasks and what it is that distinguishes one from another. However, as with many areas of pedagogic interest, little research has been undertaken so far. The kinds of empirical work carried out so far in this area are illustrated in Example 7.13.
Example 7.13 Brown and Yule; Brown et al. – design features and complexity of task Brown and Yule (1983) and Brown et al. (1984) proposed using the number and distinctiveness of different referential information features present in a task as a basis for distinguishing between tasks. For example: •
•
A task based on a story involving two characters, a single location and a single time-frame would be less complex than one involving six characters, three locations and two or more time-frames. Tasks based on describing or giving instructions would be less demanding if they involved objects or arrays with a small number of distinctive elements; requiring students to take account of a lot of features in order to complete the task would be more demanding.
Brown et al. (1984) found that the ability to use referential language was consistently affected by variations in task complexity.
Robinson (2001) developed an expanded framework to account for the complexity of tasks. He distinguished between task complexity, task
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
7.4.2
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
105
1. resource-directing – amount of information, whether here-and-now or distant in time and space, and whether reasoning demands were included; 2. resource-depleting – presence or absence of planning, whether one or more distinct subtasks were involved in the task, and the amount of prior knowledge students had. Robinson theorised that resource-directing factors would affect learners’ focus of attention, whereas resource-depleting factors would impact on the amount of attention that students would have available. ‘Task condition’ covered participation variables (such as whether the task had an open or closed solution, whether it was one- or two-way, and whether participants’ purposes were convergent or divergent) and participant variables (gender, familiarity of participants with each other, and power/solidarity factors). Robinson saw task difficulty as a perception of the students, which was influenced by their affective characteristics and by ability variables (e.g. aptitude and proficiency), as well as by the task itself, and the conditions under which it was used (see Examples 7.14a and b).
Example 7.14a Robinson – Features of a task contributing to increased complexity Using simple and complex versions of the same tasks, Robinson (2001) contrasted five versions of a map task, varying it on four dimensions: • ⫹/⫺ planning time • ⫹/⫺ single task (route already marked) • ⫹/⫺ prior knowledge • few or many elements
Robinson wanted to see whether varying the task along these dimensions could result in consistent difficulty effects for different students.
Example 7.14b •
Findings
Task complexity affects speaker and hearer production Task complexity significantly affects the lexical variety [more] and fluency [less] of speaker production, and amount of hearer interaction [more] in the predicted direction [ie. on the more complex versions].
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
conditions and task difficulty. He found that task complexity was influenced by two cognitive dimensions:
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 7.14b •
•
•
(Continued)
Cognitive demands of tasks and ratings of their difficulty are related Task complexity significantly affects ratings of overall difficulty, and stress in the predicted direction (i.e. more complex are perceived as more difficult). There is a trend to less confidence in ability on, and more interest in, the complex version. Sequencing and ratings of difficulty are unrelated Sequencing from simple to complex vs. the reverse sequence does not significantly affect ratings of the difficulty of the complex version. Sequencing affects speaker production but not interaction Sequencing tasks (from simple to complex vs. the reverse sequence) has significant effects on accuracy and fluency of speaker production, but has no effect on the amount of interaction.
The results suggest that the dimension can be used to influence the language, and that students’ perceptions of the difficulty of the tasks will be congruent with these effects. That is, the results seem to provide an initial opening into the questions ‘What causes task complexity?’ ‘What is the impact of task complexity on students?’ ‘What are the implications for sequencing?’
There are, however, issues relating to Robinson’s study which remain unclear. Complexity is clearly seen in terms of several distinct factors, and we need to note that the study does not tell us whether all the factors are of equal importance, or whether some (e.g. planning time or the number of elements) are more important than others. In addition, it seems reasonable to point out that the model for analysing task complexity has to be read as a preliminary hypothesis, and hence is open to modification and refinement. For instance, it seems possible that some of Robinson’s conditions could be defined as aspects of the task design, while the resource-depleting factors look rather like task conditions. Some might want to organise the concepts differently, as follows:
Task complexity information load: number of elements; here-and-now; reasoning demands Participation variables: open/closed; convergent/divergent; split/shared One or more distinct sub-tasks
Task conditions Implementation: ⫹/⫺ planning; ⫹/⫺ prior knowledge Participant variables: gender, familiarity, power/solidarity
There are various other issues that need further exploration. For instance, the impact of the number of elements cannot be interpreted without reference to the number of elements that need to be referred to for the task
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
106
107
to be completed. Furthermore, their impact is likely to be affected by the extent to which they form a more or less closely related set of elements and how far their similarity or distinctiveness is helpful or confusing so that similarity/distinctiveness of elements may need to be added to the framework. There are also questions to be asked about the importance of the match/lack of match between conceptual content and available language: in this framework the complexity and difficulty of tasks is being discussed without any reference to the language students would need or the language they actually know, which seems counter-intuitive. Robinson’s work does, however, raise a number of fascinating questions for the exploration and development of repertoires of tasks. Discourse type Foster and Skehan (1996), Skehan and Foster (1997) and Skehan (2001) have proposed that the nature of a task may be partly reflected in the type of discourse they aim to generate (although note that in their early work they used the term ‘task type’ rather than ‘discourse type’). (See Example 7.15.) Since cognitive complexity was not controlled for across discourse type, Skehan and Foster were not able to locate a particular effect for discourse type. However, it is conceivable that keeping information content constant (which these studies did not attempt to do), different discourse types may vary in demand – consider, for instance, the possible differences between a task involving a pair of parallel descriptions of two objects on the one hand, and task requiring a comparison of the same two objects on the other. We discuss the issue of familiarity below, and both familiarity and cognitive complexity again in Chapter 8.
Example 7.15 Foster and Skehan; Skehan and Foster – impact of task on discourse type Three types of task were selected as potentially distinct: • • •
personal narrative argumentation tasks
Skehan and Foster wanted to see whether each might have a different impact on the fluency, accuracy or complexity of the students’ language. Findings: •
Personal tasks generated more fluent, less complex language.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 7.15 • •
(Continued)
Narrative tasks and argumentation tasks were associated with more complex language. When performance was compared with and without pre-planning time, the opportunity to plan had different effects on performance on the three tasks, with complexity promoted on the narrative and argumentation tasks, while fluency and accuracy improved on the personal tasks.
This suggested: •
•
Personal tasks were already sufficiently familiar to the students, so that planning time made little difference to the way they performed the task, whereas planning time helped students perform more fluently on the less familiar content. Personal tasks seemed to involve less cognitively demanding material than the narrative and argumentation tasks, and hence gave rise to less complex use of language.
These conclusions suggested an effect for two factors: task familiarity and the cognitive complexity of the tasks, rather than the discourse type.
Task structure A further dimension that affects the difficulty of tasks is the extent to which the content information given to the students at the beginning of the task is already structured (see Example 7.16).
Example 7.16
Studies undertaken by Skehan and Foster
In a series of studies carried out between 1996 and 1999, Skehan and Foster used a similar set of task types (personal, narrative and argumentation) and found differences in the linguistic complexity produced by students working on different narrative tasks: • •
In the narrative task associated with less complex language students had received a picture story with the pictures already sequenced. In contrast, in the task which had generated more complex language, the students had to sequence the pictures themselves before producing the story.
Skehan and Foster (1999) found similar effects when comparing students’ retelling of two video narratives. In the simpler one, the narrative followed a familiar restaurant scenario, whereas a far more unpredictable narrative was related to more complex language. Skehan and Foster reasoned that in all cases where differences were found in the language across tasks with a similar genre (i.e. across narrative tasks) the less complex language was consistently associated with tasks in which the information was pre-structured, while tasks in which students had to work to provide a structure themselves to the narrative were associated with more complex talk.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
108
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
109
Song (2000) similarly found that where pictures for a picture story were not presequenced, students tended to have difficulty working out the motivations of the characters, the connections between the events and sometimes even had difficulty working out from the pictures what the characters were actually doing. The result was that the parts of the talk in which the students verbalised the connections between pictures were linguistically more complex.
Skehan and Foster’s argument, then, is that where the information given to the students is not already sequenced or organised into a fixed array before they start the task, the students will have a cognitively more complex task and will produce more complex talk. This is consistent with Robinson’s (2001) model and makes sense. Skehan and Foster’s results were also reflected in the differences in performance on tasks with a clear narrative thread as opposed to tasks with a random sequence of events. The notion of predictability suggests, however, that ‘structuring’ is often a product of the degree of match/mismatch between the knowledge or expectations of the students and the material they are given. That is, unpredictability is explained by a story sequence not fitting a schema with which viewers are likely to be familiar. This opens up the possibility that the structuring of a task will not be entirely intrinsic, but will depend on what is familiar to the participants. So it appears that ‘structuring’ is partly a function of whether the input information is organised and partly of whether it is organised according to the learners’ background knowledge and expectations. Some types of background knowledge may be widely if not universally shared across cultures, but others are less so, or more dependent on age and education. Participant roles In carrying out a task, participants have to do something if it is to be completed. This is partly influenced by the design of the task itself. Pica et al. (1993) propose that participant roles can be defined in terms of the following task typology.
Example 7.18 Pica et al. – task typology relating to participant role •
Required exchange tasks: tasks in which information has to be passed from one speaker to the other in order for the task to be completed – One-way tasks: one speaker has information to give to the other.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Example 7.17 Song – structure of task and complexity of language produced
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 7.18
(Continued)
Two-way tasks: both/all speakers have information to give and hence also have information to receive. • Optional exchange tasks: tasks in which information can be passed from one speaker to the other, although this is not required, and the actual information to be exchanged may not be provided by the task. • Convergent tasks: tasks in which all speakers are working to a joint agreed outcome. • Divergent tasks: tasks in which speakers can all come to different conclusions or outcomes.
Note that Robinson’s (2001) model defines these features as aspects of task conditions. In contrast, Pica et al. see these dimensions as a property of the design of the task. It is important to be aware that one of their principal interests was to define the properties of tasks which would lead or push learners to negotiate understandings. This led them to attempt to pin down ways in which tasks could define the roles of speakers. Although research suggests that there are associations between these properties and the incidence of negotiated talk (e.g. Pica and Doughty, 1985; Doughty and Pica, 1986), it is also clear that participant roles are more complex than this account seems to allow for. For one thing, although ‘convergent required exchange’ tasks are likely to give rise to negotiation of understandings, the concept of one- and two-way tasks does not fully predict the roles of the participants. For example, it is possible for a one-way task to be managed by the more forceful of two students, whether or not they are the ones who initially have the information. The same is bound to hold for two-way tasks, with the more forceful student dominating for the information they hold, as well as for what they do not hold. Furthermore, some of the other categories are ambiguous: for example, a task can be convergent without all participants being a party to the eventual outcome. The implication is that our understanding of the impact of aspects of task design could probably benefit from a richer theoretical starting point than those we have been working with so far, one, for instance, which approaches the relationship between design features and student response in terms of relative probabilities of response from a likely range. 7.4.3
Impact of conditions of implementation
In the previous section we considered some of the ways in which the design of a task can affect what students do. In this section we now review
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
110
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
111
1. 2. 3. 4.
task familiarity; planning; task repetition; attribution of roles.
Task familiarity As we have seen, Robinson (2001) suggests that there is a good likelihood that familiarity with a task will affect performance. As with many aspects of the area, however, it is important first to clarify what is meant by ‘task familiarity’. It could mean familiarity with the content of the task, but not with the task itself; familiarity with the type of task (i.e. the procedures to be used), but not with the content; or familiarity with both content and specific task. Furthermore, familiarity with the content can be broken down into content familiarity per se, and content familiarity in the context of a second language classroom activity. In addition, there is the question of the kind of impact that might be expected from task familiarity. Intuitively, familiarity with a task should mean that some aspects of the work involved in doing a task can be taken for granted, hence facilitating task performance in some way. However, there are different ways in which this might happen. For instance, familiarity could enable increased fluency or increased accuracy. Equally, it could give rise to greater linguistic complexity or elaboration of the discourse. All things being kept constant, any or all of these are possible, although some theories, such as the limited capacity hypothesis (Levelt, 1978), predict that participants can normally not improve performance on all dimensions simultaneously. Little research has been done on this; hence the range of possible effects has not been investigated. One study which did explore the impact of task familiarity was Plough and Gass’s.
Example 7.19
Plough and Gass – effects of task familiarity
Plough and Gass (1993) focused on the question of whether familiarity with a task influences the extent to which learners negotiate meanings when lacking a word, or when unsure of understanding their interlocutor or of being understood. They operationalised familiarity as familiarity with a particular type of task rather than with the content. (Note that studies of task repetition discussed below have also distinguished between task type and task content.)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
some of the ways in which the teachers’ use of tasks can affect what happens. Four main factors have been researched:
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 7.19
(Continued)
Plough and Gass describe their results as ‘uncertain’ (1993: 51), with no statistically significant differences in frequencies. In one of two types of tasks studied, five of six measures were greater on the familiar task, and, on the unfamiliar type, three of six. The most consistent (though still not statistically significant) finding was that there were more interruptions in the unfamiliar condition. From this the authors concluded that on the unfamiliar task there was ‘a greater instance of involvement leading in [their] framework to greater negotiation’. Their conclusion was that novelty produces more negotiation of meaning than familiarity.
On the whole, given the lack of statistical significance, it would be wise to treat these findings as at most exploratory. The authors’ conclusion does, however, raise several issues about how we think about the impact of familiarity. First, even if there had been significant results in favour of the unfamiliar task, both practical and theoretical reasons would still suggest that it is most unlikely that students work enthusiastically only on novel types of activities. The practical implications are impossible for any course or teacher to handle, but in addition, it is clear from experience that students often enjoy working with familiar types of activity. Second, the study raises the question of what we mean by novelty and how different degrees of novelty impact on task performance. Total novelty is presumably impossible, but it would be helpful to understand more about the impact of degrees of novelty. A third issue is that we have no account of whether familiarity of the content is helpful, and if so, what kind of content familiarity. Fourth, even if one accepted the authors’ interpretation, the frequency effects are far too slight for us to leave the matter there – further research is needed. Finally, it is important to note that the authors were only interested in the incidence of negotiation of meaning on two sample tasks. It was not their purpose to see whether familiarity with the tasks had any effect on the effectiveness of the students’ completion of the task or on other aspects of their language (such as their use of vocabulary, grammar, or pronunciation, or their general fluency), or how familiarity influenced students on other types of task. However, these issues are clearly well within the scope of any attempt to understand how familiarity/novelty impacts on learning. So, in a sense, the most important contribution of a study such as this is the way in which it clarifies further questions and opens up the topic for deeper and more extensive investigation. Related studies have explored the impact of task repetition (see below) with positive results; clearly this topic offers much potential for further study.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
112
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
113
The main studies of the impact of planning are Ellis (1987), Crookes (1989), Foster and Skehan (1996), Skehan and Foster (1997), Foster (2001) and Yuan and Ellis (2003). Two kinds of planning have been distinguished: pre-task planning and on-line planning. Pre-task planning has been widely shown to result in greater fluency and more complex language, although this depends to some extent on the nature of the task: tasks with a limited potential for complexification, such as giving instructions to get to one’s house or talking about oneself, tend to result more in fluency and accuracy than to changes in complexity. Although in an early study Ellis (1987) found that accuracy increased by provision of planning time, this study used two kinds of planning: one derived from working with the same material on an earlier task, the other from the distinction between the on-line planning available in oral and written tasks respectively. Written tasks clearly allow more on-line planning than do oral tasks, and this may have explained why they were performed more accurately. More recent studies of the effects of different types of planning on different aspects of task performance are briefly illustrated in Examples 7.20 and 7.21.
Example 7.20 Yuan and Ellis, 2003 – the impact of pre- and on-line planning Yuan and Ellis (2003) explored the impact of pre- and on-line planning by allowing speakers in one condition to operate without any time constraints, while placing others under relatively severe time limits. Findings: • •
Students receiving pre-task planning time produced more complex and more fluent language. Students provided with on-task planning produced significantly more accurate language.
The conclusion, then, is that pre-task planning impacts on fluency and complexity, but only on accuracy in the context of less complex and familiar tasks; on-line planning, in contrast, tends to give rise to greater accuracy and to less fluency. However, Bygate and Samuda (2005) suggest that these differences are mainly attributable to the capacity of working memory under the two conditions: content planning is more likely to be associated with pre-task planning, and formulation planning
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Planning
Tasks in Second Language Learning
(i.e. planning focusing on wording and grammar) is more likely to be within the scope of on-line planning. Questions remain. In particular, studies have not so far explored the extent to which planning influences different aspects of language performance, such as discourse structure, lexical selection and range, grammatical selection and range, the performance of speech acts or students’ pronunciation. Of all the studies on the impact of planning to date, only one (Foster, 2001) has focused on how planning affects a particular aspect of language.
Example 7.21 Foster – effects of planning on the use of formulaic language Foster (2001) found that planning has a different impact on the use of formulaic language by native and non-native speakers. Interestingly, she found that whereas planning appears to lead native speakers to reduce their use of formulaic language, this is not at all the case with non-native speakers, who use roughly similar proportions of formulaic language both in planned and unplanned talk.
Studies such as Foster’s shed fascinating light on the relationship between presence and absence of planning time and the way learners focus attention on language. Task repetition The main interest in planning is to explore whether it can be used to lead learners to direct more attention to aspects of their talk than they might otherwise do. An interest has developed in task repetition for a similar reason. Compared with written discourse, talk is ephemeral. Yet we frequently repeat discourses in everyday life, and this has been associated with language development in children (e.g. Bruner, 1983; Peters, 1983), and at least anecdotally for adults. This may be because repeating whole discourses enables linguistic features of talk to recur. Hence task repetition has been proposed as an opportunity for learners to rework their language when producing the same or similar talk on a second occasion. Indeed, many tasks are structured to give rise to repetition. And in order to complete some tasks, repetition may be extremely helpful.
Example 7.22 Bygate; Bygate and Samuda – effects of repeating the same task In a case study, Bygate (1996) showed how repetition of the same task can result in increased idiomaticity and increased accuracy.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
114
115
A follow-up study (Bygate, 2001) found that repetition of a specific task resulted in increased complexity and fluency, though not accuracy, while familiarity with a task type (as opposed to particular content) seemed to have no particular effect. Bygate and Samuda (2005) found that, in a subset of the 2001 data, speakers produced significantly more elaborate talk when narrating a familiar story compared with an unfamiliar story. Familiarity established through prior engagement with the content material in the target language seems to affect people’s subsequent use of the language on the same task.
Example 7.23 repetition
Lynch and Maclean – effects of task
Lynch and Maclean (2000, 2001) showed that tasks structured to ensure that interaction demands required students to retell their material to a series of different interlocutors had the effect of leading speakers to rework aspects of their talk, whether in terms of their pronunciation, vocabulary, or grammar, with individual speakers altering and improving different aspects of their own talk. (We discuss their 2001 study in Chapter 3.)
These studies show reasonably convincingly that fluency, accuracy and complexity can all be affected by some form of task repetition. Questions remain, however, over the different types of repetition, on the ways in which working with the same content can help speakers work on their language, and on the ways in which tasks can be designed and used to exploit this parameter. Little research has been done to study the effects of planning and task repetition over time. Distribution of roles Does it matter which student does what in a given task? Yule and McDonald (1990) neatly illustrated some of the ways in which the roles participants adopt can be influenced by the way the teacher chooses to implement the task.
Example 7.24 Yule and McDonald – effect of differences in proficiency levels of participants Yule and McDonald (1990) started from the assumption that to some extent participant role can be designed into the task, but they explored the extent to which participants’ relative level of proficiency might influence their interaction according to the role they were allotted.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 7.24
(Continued)
They studied mixed pairs with one high and one low proficiency (HP and LP) student in each pair; pairs were given a one-way map task. In half the groups the high proficiency student started with the information that was to be imparted, and in the other half this was given to the low proficiency student. The results were unequivocal: information was negotiated far more successfully when it was entrusted to the low proficiency student. When problems arose, the LP students were more committed to resolving the problem, and the HP student more supportive, than when it was the HP student who was holding the material to be communicated.
Results such as this suggest that task design is only one influence on how participants fulfil their roles: relative proficiency and quite probably relative confidence and forcefulness as well are just as likely to influence what happens. Finally, Skehan and Foster have noted the possible differences in the quality of talk in monologic and dialogic tasks, with the latter tending to lead to greater complexity. The vast range of potential task types falling under each of these two headings suggests that this distinction is a direction for further enquiry. 7.4.4
Task dynamics
In this section we consider features that have been studied in the dynamics of task enactment. Negotiation for meaning ‘Negotiation for meaning’ has come to be used to refer to turns of talk in which speakers check the clarity and understanding of their own and each others’ messages, particularly at points when there appears to be a breakdown or misfire in communication. These are sometimes referred to (especially in conversation analysis) as ‘repair sequences’. Several SLA researchers (Long, 1981; Gass and Varonis, 1985; Pica and Doughty, 1985) have been interested in the extent to which tasks generate ‘negotiation for meaning’ during task talk, focusing on a core set of moves believed to maximise opportunities for inter-language restructuring and development: • confirmation checks; • clarification requests; • comprehension checks.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
116
117
Unlike some of the researchers in studies reviewed above, these researchers were not primarily interested in the kinds of discourse that different tasks might give rise to or in the ways in which tasks might lead learners to attend to different aspects of language (e.g. grammar, vocabulary, pragmatics or pronunciation). Rather, the focus was on investigating whether tasks could be designed to stimulate those negotiations for meaning sequences hypothesised as both fundamental and effective in promoting language development. The implication seemed to be that if tasks did not to lead to negotiation for meaning sequences, or if negotiation for meaning failed to lead to acquisition, they would not support the pedagogic use of tasks. Various studies were carried out to explore which tasks were most likely to lead to negotiation for meaning sequences. We have already seen an example of this in Pica et al.’s (1993) task typology (see Example 7.18). Although it appears that certain task types do result in more negotiation for meaning than others, none of the studies was designed to find out whether negotiation for meaning resulted in learning. In addition, there are a number of problems with the definition of the moves that constitute ‘negotiation for meaning’ as construed by this group of SLA researchers. In particular, distinctions between the functions of apparently similar moves (e.g. confirmation check/clarification request/comprehension check) can be motivated by many concerns and not just the need to check accurate and effective use of the code. A strong association can be found between the rather narrow focus of ‘negotiation for meaning’ studies of SLA and recommendations for the use of tasks in second language pedagogy and in particular, the development of a pedagogy driven by tasks (see the discussion of TBLT in Chapter 9). In our view, it is unfortunate that so much early empirical attention to tasks was devoted to the study of negotiation for meaning when it is very clear that tasks generate considerable amounts of valuable talk other than the limited range of moves focused on in negotiation for meaning studies, and that exploratory talk is realised in a range of ways not captured by those moves. As we argued in Chapter 1, the rationale for using tasks extends well beyond their potential to stimulate negotiation for meaning sequences (see Foster and Ohta, 2005, for a similar view). Constructivist processes In this book we use the term ‘constructivist processes’ to refer to all those processes whereby individuals work together to develop and clarify their own and each others’ understandings, whether of background knowledge, of previous and current situations or of their intentions.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Some of these processes overlap with the kinds of negotiation for meaning moves discussed in previous paragraphs. But the scope of constructivist concerns goes well beyond negotiation sequences to include the moment-by-moment prompting, eliciting, responding, questioning and elaborating which, as Barnes (1976) showed, characterise joint exploratory talk (see Chapter 2). Socio-constructivists have been significantly involved in studying this in relation to tasks – see Examples 7.25 and 7.26.
Example 7.25
Donato – co-construction of meaning in tasks
Donato (1994) focused on the ways in which students learning French as a foreign language helped each other to recover grammatical rules from memory and to apply them in the context of new vocabulary items. Donato’s data were collected from students engaged in a one-hour planning session in which their task was to work out the conclusion for a dramatic scenario which they were to enact in a subsequent lesson (1994: 40). His analyses highlight the role of peers jointly ‘scaffolding’ each other’s talk – providing prompts, directions, reminders, evaluations including corrections, as well as additional contributions.
Example 7.26 tasks
Swain and Lapkin – collaborative talk on
In a series of studies, Swain and Lapkin (2000, 2001) examined how students of French work jointly on dicto-gloss activities (activities in which students first hear a short piece of talk and then work orally in pairs to reproduce in writing what they heard). They used micro-analysis on different types of ‘episodes’ occurring during task enactment to show how students help each other to recover language, negotiating for meaning and for form, that they had both heard and with appropriate grammatical features.
Studies like Donato’s and Swain and Lapkin’s highlight the productive role of collaborative talk among peers and illustrate how students seem to help each other by providing support, structure and focus to each other’s talk. Blake and Zyzik (2003) apply a similar analysis to web-based peer tutoring between learners of Spanish. Ohta (2000) also adopted a socio-cultural approach to study classroom processes in the learning of Japanese as a second language.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
118
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
119
Example 7.27 Ohta – the classroom processes of learners of Japanese as a foreign language
• • • • • •
creative use of the L2 to perform tasks; active resolution of problems that emerge through the use of the L2; peer assistance, which enables them to respond to challenges they might otherwise be unable to handle; use of L2, and minimal use of L1; taking risks and trying new language forms; a sense of flow, involving movement and development with learners helping each other and calling on the teacher when necessary.
In Ohta’s data, tasks, among other types of activity, provided a context for important types of peer interaction to occur. Yet Ohta argues that these features were impacted by task design and the manner of task implementation, as well as by the individual learners. Furthermore if a task lacks clarity, is not well integrated into the lesson or is at an inappropriate level, this seems to lead to increased use of the L1. In other words, Ohta proposes that there is an important relationship between the design, selection and use of tasks on the one hand, and the interactive processes that they can give rise to on the other. From this perspective, tasks offer a tool for mediating students’ collaborative engagement and use of language.
In many ways the work exemplified here echoes the earlier extensive studies by Barnes (1976) on mother-tongue subject classrooms in the UK, and Wells (1981, 1985) of the adult-child interaction involving children in their pre-school years. Both Barnes and Wells argued that the interaction could be relatively productive or unproductive, depending partly on how interactants collaborate, and partly on the nature of the activities they are engaged in: the activity provides a context for the joint construction of talk. Without the activity, collaborative talk would not be possible, yet the quality of the talk itself depends on the interactive involvement of the participants. Given this, socio-cultural studies can understandably choose to focus more centrally on the work of the students than the nature of the task. Indeed, a second group of socio-cultural studies (e.g. Duff, 1993; Coughlan and Duff, 1994; Mori, 2002) are more concerned to explore the ways in which language interaction is individualised, and suggest that tasks have little influence on what happens in classrooms. Hence, if any constructivist processes occur during the enactment of a task, the interest is to interpret this in terms of the constructive actions of the participants. Duff (1993), for instance, shows how a student in a series
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
In a longitudinal study, Ohta identified a number of positive features of productive interaction. These included:
120
Tasks in Second Language Learning
of one-on-one tutorials does not follow a pre-arranged set of tasks. A more recent study is Mori’s (2002).
Mori, 2000
Mori (2002) set up a series of visits by native speaker guests to a Japanese as a second language classroom. These followed class work on a video and textbook. Students were briefed to prepare for a session, consisting of the following phases: 1. Explain to the guests the content of the video and the textbook. 2. Ask the guest what kind of person his/her father is and what kind of relationship s/he has had with his/her father. 3. Tell the guests what kind of person your father is and what kind of relationship he has had with you (2002: 328). Mori presents this as a pedagogical task, with the session defined for the participants as zadankai – a meeting in which ‘several people get together and discuss opinions on a certain issue. It aims at discussing matters without enforcing formal structures.’ However, there are two issues to consider in how this task was designed and set up: 1. The instructions were not shared with the guests, so that there was a conflict between what the students were supposed to be doing and what the guests thought they were doing. Given this, Mori’s finding that the NS guests did not follow the instructions given to the students is not surprising. 2. The instructions given to the students conflict with the definition of the session as zadankai. Giving the students three phases to follow is at odds with the idea of an unstructured session. It is not clear whether the guests were told that the session was to be ‘zadankai’, but if they were, this would reinforce the problem for the students.
The central problem with both Duff (1993) and Mori (2002) concerns the implementation of the concept of ‘task’. In the first case, the student followed a different activity from the one that had been planned and the teacher allowed this to happen. In the second case, not only were the students and guests not given the same briefing, but the students were provided with two conflicting briefings. Our point is that a study that aims among other things to reflect on what tasks do or do not do has to make clear to the participants what the task is, and participants need to work to it. Otherwise, it is stating the obvious to report that the students did not ‘do’ the task. The reason they did not was either because they were allowed to change it or they did not understand what they were supposed to be doing and were not helped to do it. Not surprisingly, the studies discovered that the tasks did not result in the expected patterns of talk.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Example 7.28
121
Pedagogically, the implication of both Duff’s and Mori’s discussions seems to be that unless students do tightly determined activities (e.g. exercises and drills), there is little predictability to work with in the classroom other than the collaborative processes students will engage in when left to their own devices. This argument echoes the argument by extremes evoked by Dewey (see Chapter 1) whereby activities are either tightly predictable or totally unpredictable. No scope seems left within this reasoning to uncover types of activity which can generate broadly similarly patterned discourse, while offering some optional variations and allowing students freedom of lexico-grammatical expression. A more general point arises. We noted earlier two kinds of constructivist theory: the PCT and neo-Vygotskyan socio-cultural approaches (see section 7.3.3), with the former essentially a systemic theory and the latter a process theory. These orientations can cause problems: whereas PCT makes a virtue of the delicate detection of the particular perceptions of individuals, enabling follow-up studies of how these differ across time, it has difficulty in identifying how the surface behaviours of learners and teachers impinge on their underlying systems. In contrast, neoVygotskyan approaches are particularly adept at charting the surface behaviours, but seem to be less successful in relating these to underlying changes in learners’ personal linguistic systems and thinking. In particular, neo-Vygotskyan studies tend to rely on the analyst’s interpretation to identify whether surface moves in the discourse represent helpful talk or constitute evidence of learning, without consulting the students. In contrast, studies such as those reported in the following sub-section carry out pre- and post-tests, sometimes with multiple post-tests at different points. The purpose is to try to capture the students’ systems of knowledge after the event. This kind of concern is rare in current neo-Vygotskyan work. However, these limitations are not in principle irremediable. Meanwhile socio-cultural studies of tasks have the considerable merit of exploring the kinds of unscripted, exploratory processes of interaction between students which are a central reason for the use of pedagogical tasks and the kind of thing that teachers are concerned about. The major limitation in socio-cultural work lies in the fact that few socio-cultural specialists have as a principal objective to explore the ways in which the design and use of tasks can be improved. Acquisition Acquisition is the third and perhaps most crucial process which needs to be investigated in relation to tasks. Tasks are after all clearly intended to promote learning. Unfortunately, studies of learning generally require
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
significantly more time for data collection than others. Furthermore, acquisition is hard to assess unless there is some expectation of what aspects of language the tasks will target, and we have seen that many researchers have doubted the ability or desirability of using tasks to target particular features of language. As a result, few studies have been carried out. However, two sets of studies have approached this issue, one by Mackey (1999), the other by Ellis and co-researchers (Ellis, Tanaka and Yamazaki, 1994; Ellis and Heimbach, 1997; Ellis and He 1999; all reported in Ellis, 2001). We have already sketched aspects of Mackey’s study and her use of pre- and post-tests (see Example 7.9), and revisit it in Chapter 8, so in the following examples, we focus on Ellis and colleagues. Ellis and his co-researchers approached the issue of the role of tasks in promoting learning by exploring different types of oral input for language comprehension and acquisition. To do this they used a series of listening comprehension tasks and studied acquisition through the number of vocabulary items learnt.
Example 7.29 Ellis, Tanaka and Yamazaki; Ellis and Heimback; Ellis and He – vocabulary learning through listening tasks These studies all used tasks in which students first listened to instructions and then numbered pictures of objects, or placed picture cards into a diagram in line with the instructions. The researchers were interested to see whether the form of the instructions might influence comprehension and acquisition. They compared four types of instruction: 1. unmodified instructions of the kind native speakers might give to each other (the ‘baseline’); 2. pre-modified instructions, simplified for comprehension by non-native speakers; 3. interactionally modified instructions, simplified in response to listeners’ requests for clarification when they did not understand the baseline instructions; 4. modified output by fellow students, with listeners permitted to signal noncomprehension. They first checked the impact of the types of input on comprehension and found that although modification seems to help comprehension, this is probably mainly due to the additional time created for the student to do the task. They then checked for the impact on acquisition in post-tests. They found that ‘premodified and interactionally modified input facilitate acquisition’ (Ellis, 2001: 61), but that the advantage for the latter ‘largely reflects the additional time learners obtain for processing the input when they are given the opportunity to signal non-comprehension’ (2001: 62).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
122
123
When time is controlled for, in some cases ‘learners acquire new words more rapidly from premodified than from interactionally modified input’ (2001: 62). The authors checked the relationship between comprehension and acquisition, and found only similarly moderate correlations for the various forms of modified input, suggesting that input for comprehension and input for acquisition are not necessarily the same. In particular there is a distinction between understanding the directive and perceiving or understanding the particular vocabulary item.
Ellis (1995) investigated whether a relationship could be found between the frequency with which vocabulary items were acquired and aspects of the vocabulary items such as their length, prototypicality, frequency within the input, range of directives in which they were used and length of directives. He found that proto-typicality, frequency, range and length of directive were related to ease of acquisition, although length of directive operated positively in pre-modified input, and negatively in interactive input. Finally, Ellis and He (1999) studied the effect of involving the students themselves in using the new vocabulary items by giving the instructions to each other, working in pairs. The authors’ findings here were clear-cut: The results were quite conclusive. Giving the learners the opportunity to produce and negotiate the directives in pairs resulted in significantly higher levels of comprehension than exposing them to premodified directives or giving them the opportunity to negotiate the teacher’s baseline directives. . . . In short, the speaking task proved more effective than the listening tasks with regard to both comprehension and vocabulary acquisition. (Ellis, 2001: 67) Ellis et al. then used tasks to explore the role of different types of input in comprehension and acquisition. This is a good example of how research can simultaneously investigate a particular theory (here Krashen’s and Long’s theories of the role of input in second language acquisition) and a set of pedagogical procedures, here a range of related tasks. Both the Mackey and Ellis studies successfully addressed the intuitively appealing issue of demonstrating that tasks can link to acquisition processes. Teachers are likely to need more of studies like these before they can feel that tasks are a reliable instrument for promoting development. 7.4.5
Teachers’ use of tasks
We noted earlier that, like any artefact, what happens when tasks are used depends on two things: the characteristics of the task and the intentions of the users. The preceding subsections have discussed research which
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
has largely explored characteristics of the task, rather than the impact of the intentions of the users. One user of tasks who can have considerable influence on how they are used is the teacher. A given task can be used at various points in a lesson, and for distinct purposes. Samuda (2001) is one study undertaken from a micro-perspective which reports on both process and outcome of the TIP task (see Chapter 1). Group or pair communication tasks are often used in the classroom as a main activity in their own right, or as a follow-up activity to engage learners’ in using language they may have encountered earlier in the lesson in the context of some other activity. In contrast, Samuda’s aim was to demonstrate what can happen when a communicative task such as the TIP task is used at the start of a lesson, before the teacher introduces the relevant language. In Samuda (2001), students worked in groups to predict the likely owner of a set of objects they had been given. Following this phase, the teacher invited the groups to report on their findings for each object and for the set of objects as a whole. It is during this second phase that the teacher started to help students to form their judgements, providing words and phrases like ‘may’, ‘might’, ‘could’, ‘is probably’ and ‘must’, and using a percentage chart on the blackboard to indicate the corresponding level of probability (e.g. 100% probability ⫽ ‘must’). Groups then returned to complete their accounts, using the new vocabulary. There are three points to be made about this study. The first is that the teacher’s use of the task fits into a broader perspective of how students learn and of how tasks can be used to promote learning. In this case, Samuda describes the task as ‘preparing the conceptual ground’ for any subsequent teaching, so that by the time the students interacted in plenary mode with the teacher they already had a clear conception of the meanings that they were aiming to convey. The task thus served to prepare the conceptual terrain and to provide a need for the language. The teacher was then in a position during the plenary phase to ‘seed’ the students with language elements which the task had primed them to look for. The second point is that this study illustrates how a single micro-study can focus on both process and product, since Samuda implemented the activity within a pre-test/post-test design, enabling her to demonstrate learning gains, and hence to link the interactive processes of the lesson to systemic development. The fact that the pre-test/post-test design enabled the researcher to provide a statistical generalisation means that the study also sits astride the micro/macro distinction. The final point is that the study illustrates more generally that by studying teachers’ uses of tasks, it is possible to explore the ways in which tasks are integrated into lessons, and into more extended schemes of work. Little
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
124
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks
125
research of this kind has been done, yet from the perspective of teachers and teacher educators it looks a rich and valuable direction for future work.
Although aspects of task design are brought into focus through the studies outlined so far in this chapter, task design has not been generally treated as an area of empirical inquiry in its own right in the task research literature. An exception is Johnson’s (2003) study of the working practices of task designers.
Example 7.30
Johnson
In a procedural study of second language pedagogic task design expertise, Johnson (2000; 2003) studied how different designers responded to the same design brief. The designers differed in terms of background in task design: ‘specialist’ designers (with at least five years’ experience of task design work, all were or had been published materials writers); ‘non-specialist’ designers (with at least five years’ experience as classroom teachers, with occasional task design for own use). Analysis was based on concurrent verbalisations collected from each designer ‘thinking aloud’ while developing a task based on the design brief. Adopting a cumulative case study approach, Johnson analysed each thinkaloud protocol on a case-by-case basis, gradually building up comparisons across cases. From this, he was able to identify a number of differences in the ways that specialist and non-specialist designers approached the design process and developed their tasks, many of which are broadly in line with findings from studies of expertise in other domains; this suggests that second language pedagogic task design is a specialised activity. As a preliminary step towards understanding what this entails, Johnson frames his findings as a set of hypotheses about the characteristics of a ‘good’ task designer. Samuda (2005) reports part of a follow-up study investigating whether the differences in the design process identified in Johnson (2003) are reflected in the tasks produced, and finds a number of differences in the kinds of design features deployed by specialist and non-specialist designers.
There are two points about this work to be briefly noted here. First is its research methodology; a cumulative case study approach is being increasingly adopted in task research (e.g. Lynch and Maclean, 2000, 2001; Samuda, 2005; Samuda and Bygate, 2005) and offers considerable promise for future work. (We return to this in Chapter 8, where we focus in more detail on the Lynch and Maclean studies.) The second point is that focusing on tasks from the perspective of the designer represents a significant broadening of the research focus of task studies to date. If indeed, as Johnson suggests, task design is a specialist skill, understanding what
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
7.4.6 Dimensions and processes of task design
126
Tasks in Second Language Learning
good designers do is of considerable interest in supporting the development of ‘non-specialist’ designers.
Researching pedagogic tasks: a balance sheet
At the start of this chapter we identified a number of opportunities for research into language learning tasks. Here we revisit those in light of the studies reported in the body of this chapter. Let us now look again at the issues that we brought together in Table 7.1. There we highlighted areas for potential research focus; in Table 7.4 we provide an amended version, showing the areas of potential research focus, along with an indication of which areas have and which have not been investigated to date. (Space has precluded discussion of all of these themes.) At first sight Table 7.4 suggests a fair amount of work has been undertaken. However, in a field such as ours, the numbers of studies must be considered slight. Recall that in 1980 Brumfit appealed for large numbers of small-scale studies on the grounds that large groups tend to give rise to neutral results and make interpretations of the relationship Table 7.4
Areas of potential research focus
Teachers’ procedures and processes Teacher’s pre-task preparation Teacher’s post-task follow-up
Samuda (2001) Samuda (2001)
Impact of elements of design Complexity Discourse type Task structure Participant roles
Robinson (2001) Skehan (2001) Skehan (2001) Pica et al. (1993)
Impact of conditions of implementation Task familiarity Plough and Gass (1993) Planning time Foster and Skehan (1996), Skehan and Foster (1997) Yuan and Ellis (2003) Task repetition Bygate (1996, 2001), Bygate and Samuda (2005) Role distribution Lynch and Maclean (2000, 2001) Yule and McDonald (1990) Learners’ procedures and processes Learners’ talk Language Phases Outcomes
Bygate (1988, 1999), Mackey (1999) Bygate (1988) Ellis and He (1999), Ellis (2001)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
7.5
Researching Second Language Pedagogic Tasks (Continued)
Dynamics Negotiation for meaning Constructivist processes
Development Learning generated through task involvement Construals Students’ interpretations of tasks Students’ evaluations of tasks Teachers’ perceptions of tasks Designers’ construals of tasks Individual differences Student differences Student motivation
Doughty and Pica (1986), Pica and Doughty (1985) Swain and Lapkin (2000, 2001), Donato (1994), Ohta (2000), Blake and Zyzik (2003) Mackey (1999) Ellis (2001), Izumi and Bigelow (2000) None Garrett and Shortall (2002) Murphy (1993) None Johnson (2000; 2003)
Teacher differences
None Kumaravadivelu, 1993;Dörnyei and Kormos (2000) Samuda, 2006
Task, lesson and curriculum tasks and schemes of work/course plan tasks and target tests tasks and overall curriculum goals
None None None
between context and performance almost impossible to track. Better, he argued, to work with smaller groups and to accumulate sufficiently large numbers of studies conducted along similar lines to gradually assemble a picture that would show general patterns as well as distinctive differences for different populations. From this perspective, we have to conclude that the research undertaken so far is both slight, and unsystematic. We need far more replication and cross examination of findings, so that errors in the systematicity of sampling and design can be gradually reduced. Further, if we look again at the agenda proposed in 1956 by Bruner, Goodnow and Austin (see Example 7.1), it is clear that research into tasks for second language teaching has yet to get to the heart of the matter – learning on tasks within classroom contexts. Indeed, looked at from the perspectives highlighted in Example 7.1, it is clear that much more systematic and probing research is needed before we can confidently claim to understand how tasks work in pedagogical contexts or hope to be able to exploit research results within language pedagogy.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Table 7.4
127
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Part 2 Interactions between Research and Practice
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Having traced the historical and conceptual background from which tasks have emerged and sketched the current research state of play, we turn now to a critical exploration of a number of empirical studies and pedagogical developments. In doing this, we hope to bring together relationships between research and practice, and highlight the motivations of developments – both in pedagogical practice and in theorydriven research, as well as their theoretical and practical implications. In Chapter 8 we examine closely a representative sample of empirical studies into tasks. Chapter 9 then explores the ways in which tasks have been incorporated into curricula and materials.
131
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Introduction
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
This page intentionally left blank
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
Chapters 1–7 have sought to highlight the educational richness of using tasks in the language classroom. As we saw in Chapter 7, what has been achieved is, however (as always), less than what might be. Yet research builds on previous work, and for development to be possible much can be learned and gained. The aim of this chapter is to explore methods of researching pedagogical tasks through a small sample of studies. In an empirically informed field, individual studies are crucial: they illustrate the ideas, as well as testing them and informing their potential development. The chapter considers each study in turn, examining its rationale and design, as well as the practical and theoretical implications. We focus on eight: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Samuda (2001) Donato (1994) Yule and Macdonald (1990) Mackey (1999) Yuan and Ellis (2003) Ortega (2005) Skehan and Foster (1999) Lynch and Maclean (2001)
We have selected these, from among many possible candidates, on the basis that they illustrate a range of task-related issues that researchers have focused on, and used a variety of methods in researching them. They are summarised in Table 8.1. All eight studies address how tasks can promote learning through communication. The first four are concerned with the nature and impact of interactional processes on language use or development, exploring issues 133
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
8
Overview of the eight studies
Author
The problem
Context
Research purpose
Theoretical base
Samuda 2001
How can designers design, and teachers use, tasks to introduce students to new language?
ESL lesson for adult learners on a preacademic intensive programme at an American university
To track the impact of task and student– student and teacher–student interaction on students’ learning
Tasks may help learning of form where semantically complex aspects of language first need to be understood
Donato 1994
Does a dialogue preparation task lead students to help each other to resolve language problems?
A lesson from a French BA course for students at an American university
To investigate incidence of scaffolding moves in group work
Learning scaffolded by the students via tasks may be more effective than transmissionbased teaching
Does the relative proficiency of students in the roles of speaker and listener affect their performance of referential communication tasks?
An experiment involving NNS students at an American university
To investigate the impact of task role and relative proficiency on pairs’ success in negotiating referential problems
Reference involves each speaker allowing for others’ perspectives, and needs negotiation; can be effectively developed and tested through interactional tasks
Does participation in negotiation for meaning promote the development of certain structures?
A longitudinal experiment with NNS students in a sequence of activities at an Australian language school
To investigate impact of task-based interaction on development of learners’ questions
Involvement in negotiation for meaning may help acquisition of aspects of language
Yule and Macdonald 1990
Mackey 1999
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect 2011-04-20
134
Table 8.1
What difference does pre- and on-task planning time make to students’ talk?
An experiment involving EFL students at a Chinese university
To investigate impact of on-line and pre-task planning time on language processing through output
Tasks may provide essential language practice, but varying planning conditions may help optimise their use.
Ortega 2005
What do learners focus on during pre-task planning, and why?
An experimental study of planning involving NNS students at an American university
To investigate students strategies and perceptions of pre-task planning
Learners’ planning processes and focus of attention may relate to style and proficiency
Skehan and Foster 1999
What is the impact on learners’ talk of: content structure; prior content summary; or talking while/after watching?
An experiment involving NNS students at a British university
To investigate impact of story structure and processing load on language processing through output
Learning implies a balance between fluency, accuracy and complexity; varying story structure and task conditions may promote this
Lynch and Maclean 2001
How can designers design tasks to encourage repetition of talk, and does it affect learners’ talk?
A lesson from an English language for Medical Conferences course at a Scottish university
To explore the effect in a normal class of a repetition element built into the task
Tasks lead to repeated attempts to formulate the same content, which may lead to improved formulation
135
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect 2011-04-20
Yuan and Ellis 2003
Tasks in Second Language Learning
such as how interaction can be influenced by the task or the conditions and how interaction can promote learning; The second four share an interest in processing capacity and task demand. They all focus on how varying some aspect of task conditions (planning, task structure, simultaneous or delayed narration, and task repetition) can affect learners’ processing capacity. The studies represent different types of research design. Four (Samuda, Donato, Lynch and Maclean, and Ortega) are case studies, exploring a one-off event through transcript analysis (Samuda, Donato), interviews (Ortega) or a combination of the two (Lynch and Maclean). In one case (Samuda) the study also incorporates a pre-/post-test. Three of the case studies also use some quantification – a reminder that statistics are not incompatible with case study designs. The other four studies are all experimental, quantitative designs. The choice of research paradigm – case study as opposed to an experimental study – has implications for the choice and structure of the dataset. The case studies tend to use detailed transcript analysis to track changes in perception and formulation through the course of the activity, although Ortega’s study is structured around data collected from a semi-structured interview. In contrast, the experimental studies all use some kind of statistical cross-group analysis, with the participants divided into two or more subgroups and given different tasks or conditions. The researcher compares the language of the task (Yule and Macdonald, Skehan and Foster), or studies possible differences in pre/post-test results (Mackey). Effective statistical analysis depends crucially on the choice of appropriate categories for computing. Whereas quantification is an option for case studies (see Samuda, Lynch and Maclean, and Ortega), it is essential for experimental studies. The latter also have the option of providing illustrative examples of their data. The choice of research methodology can also have implications for the ecological validity of the study. This may be because case studies can easily research activities that are already scheduled, whereas experimental studies tend to investigate a hunch which starts independently of any existing teaching programme. Hence three of the four case studies are from a single scheduled lesson within a programme of studies with the students’ normal class teacher. The other four studies occurred in experimentally designed contexts, as one-off data elicitation events. Hence they were not part of the students’ study programme, although Mackey’s groups, while randomly grouped, were treated to experimental lessons over a three-week period. Ortega’s is the only case study not located in a taught programme, her research exploring the individual reports of students who were participating in an experimental study she was running.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
136
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective Research methods of the studies
Author
Design
Samuda, 2001
Case study of a single class, analysing transcripts and interviews and statistical (pre-/post-) analysis
Lynch and Maclean, 2001
Case study of individual students, using detailed transcript analysis, statistical analysis and interviews
Donato, 1994
Case study of one small group, using detailed transcript analysis of group talk
Yule and Macdonald, 1990
Experimental cross-group statistical design, comparing high proficiency low proficiency and low proficiency high proficiency pairings, analysing transcripts to assess students’ success in identifying and resolving problems.
Yuan and Ellis, 2003
Experimental cross-group statistical study of impact of planning conditions (three, including control), on fluency, accuracy, complexity of talk
Skehan and Foster, 1999
Experimental cross-group study of impact of task structure (two) and different performance conditions (four) on fluency, accuracy and complexity
Mackey, 1999
Experimental pre-/post- (one)/post- (two) study of impact on learning of 3 types of task, in relation to proficiency. Case study design, through semi-structured interviews
Ortega, 2005
The implication of this is that the studies that were collected from students working on a normal classroom activity as part of a scheduled course (Samuda, Lynch and Maclean, Donato) are able to show the functioning and use of tasks in pedagogical contexts. The others are not in a position to do this. However, their strength is their ability to establish whether there are underlying parameters or principles which teachers and testers could use systematically to influence either the nature of the interaction or of the language processing, which students engage in on tasks. The eight studies relate in different ways to the themes explored in Chapter 7: • Ecological issues: studies implemented in a scheduled lesson – Lynch and Maclean, Samuda, Donato; as opposed to studies occurring outside of a taught programme – Yule and Macdonald, Mackey, Yuan and Ellis, Skehan and Foster. • Language focus issues: designing tasks to engage learners with expressions of modality (Samuda); with question forms (Mackey); or in terms
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Table 8.2
137
Tasks in Second Language Learning
of fluency, accuracy and complexity (Yuan and Ellis, Skehan and Foster, Lynch and Maclean). • Process issues: notably creating a learning space for meaning and form (Samuda, Donato); engaging relevant interaction (Donato, Mackey, Samuda, Yule and Macdonald); planning (Yuan and Ellis; Ortega); task structure (Skehan and Foster); repetition (Lynch and Maclean). • Development issues: via a pre-post-design (Samuda, Mackey) or via microanalysis of short-term language changes (Donato, Lynch and Maclean). • Teacher–learner issues: learners’ perceptions of task planning (Ortega). The selected studies are tabulated in relation to these dimensions in Table 8.3. In considering these studies, there are three underlying issues which regularly arise: 1. the relative value of case studies compared with group studies; 2. the relative value of comparative studies and longitudinal studies; and 3. the relative value of pedagogically and non-pedagogically situated research into tasks. Case studies can provide the most complete picture of processes and outcomes; group studies are best able to open a window on variation and representativeness. There is no doubt that teachers and other educationists need both. Comparative studies can offer a perspective on the differences between tasks-in-action, task conditions and between groups, but say nothing about learning outcomes; longitudinal designs can help to reveal changes over time, but without a comparative element, say nothing about the relative contribution of different types of activity. Again, teachers and educationists need both. Finally, there is pedagogically and non-pedagogically situated research: here too, both are needed. Much has been written on the need for pedagogically situated studies (e.g. Ellis, 2003), but studies situated in non-pedagogical contexts are also needed: a teacher is unlikely to feel comfortable using procedures that have never been trialled before, and more generally, in seeking to understand pedagogical activities, we need to know whether they are robust enough to work both inside and outside the classrooms. In the following sections, each study is presented separately, starting with a factual account of the nature of the study, its rationale, aims, setting and participants, a description of the task and of how the data were analysed. The results are reported, with sample data presented where possible, and the study as a whole is then briefly discussed.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
138
The relationship of the selected studies to six variables
Study
Ecological context
Task variable
Special conditions
Language
Process
Development
Samuda
Scheduled lesson with intact class
Focus on predicting – meaning form
Student–student and Teacher– student negotiation
Modality
Individual and joint exploration
Use of modality expressions
Donato
Scheduled lesson with intact class
Interaction process
Joint exploration
Negotiated micro-changes
Yule and Macdonald
Dyads in nonclass context
Mackey
Randomly selected LP students, each paired with a different NS
Yuan and Ellis
Dyads in nonclass context
Pre-task/online planning
Ortega
Non-class context, with intact classes
Pre-task planning
Skehan and Foster
Students from different classes, conditions randomly assigned
Lynch and Maclean
Scheduled lesson with intact class
HP or LP ‘sender’ LP or HP ‘receiver’ / interactive task structure
/ provision of structured content
Extent of problem resolution Question forms
Different processing loads
Use of question forms
Fluency, accuracy, complexity Sts’ views on planning Fluency, accuracy, complexity Individual micro-changes
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Students’ perceptions of the activity
139
Repeated interactions on same topic
Teachers and learners
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect 2011-04-20
Table 8.3
Tasks in Second Language Learning
8.1
Samuda
Samuda (2001) studied an implementation of the TIP task introduced in Chapter 1. It is a case study of a task being used in a lesson to work on aspects of epistemic modality (used to signal the degree of certainty of our speech acts). It tracks successive steps in the lesson and focuses on how the teacher negotiates meaning and form with the class. It also considers how far the task leads the learners to focus on the target features language, and explores the impact of the lesson on the learners’ knowledge through a pre-test/post-test design. 8.1.1
Rationale
Samuda makes a distinction between language activating tasks, which are used primarily to activate, refine and stretch learners’ existing IL resources, and processing and knowledge constructing tasks, which are used to enable learners make ‘new’ form–meaning connections. In this study, the TIP task was as a knowledge-constructing task. The task design was based on three components – input data, operations on data, outcomes – which are intended to underpin a meaning → form → meaning progression ‘to manage shifts in attentional focus as the task unfolds [with] opportunities for focusing attention on novel form/meaning connections’ (2001: 121). This progression was targeted partly in the belief that highlighting meaning in task input (2001: 122), helps to introduce forms once meanings are in mind, rather than relying on a progression from form to meaning which ‘risks dislocating language form from language use’. The intention is for the forms to be encountered when the meanings are ‘in the process of being expressed’, rather than before the task has begun and the need perceived, or after it has been completed and the need has passed. This meaning → form progression may be more appropriate where the meanings are complex and the forms simpler, whereas where the forms are complex and the meanings relatively simple the linguistic environment is likely to require more attention. The rationale, design and participants of the study are presented below: Aims To explore empirically how a teacher can work with a given task ‘to complement its essential meaning → form → meaning progression’, and with what effect.
Setting Programme: a pre-academic intensive ESL programme at a North American university. The class: the lowest of a five-level programme.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
140
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
141
The lesson: a grammar/communication class, scheduled for 10–25 hours per week.
Nine students, mainly Japanese and Korean, with an average age of 22, studying for a wide range of purposes, from academic, to basic language improvement. Mean pre-tested scores on target features: 3.73/26. Teacher: eight years’ experience with similar students. Researcher: spent one morning a week in the class over the course of a term; was familiar to the students as observer and co-teacher, and this could ‘develop tasks around topics of interest to the students’ (2001: 125).
Task design Designed to target epistemic modality, but without including the forms in the input data, or prescribing use of the target forms. Piloting with NS and higher proficiency NNS groups showed that the target features were used to do the task as well as other forms of epistemic modality.
Task phases Input data • Rubric • Objects • Chart* ⇓ Operations on data • Groups: – Form initial hypotheses – Complete charts – Make preliminary presentations ⇓ Language focus Teacher: • Builds on learner-initiated meaning to introduce new language data ⇓ Operations on data Groups: • Prepare posters ⇓ Outcomes Groups: • Poster presentations *The chart which the groups worked to complete is shown in Example 1.1, pp. 9–10.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Participants: students, teacher and researcher
8.1.2
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Analysis
The analysis adopted both a process and product perspective, that is, it aimed to link how the students and teacher worked through the task and how the students’ knowledge changed. In order to follow a process dimension, the data for each of the three phases were analysed separately: the pre-focus phase, when the students worked in groups; the language focus phase, a plenary reporting phase, in which the teacher participated; the post-focus phase, in which students returned to group mode to prepare a poster. At a finer grain of analysis, the task processes were represented through extracts taken from transcripts of the lesson. The analysis distinguishes between ‘mined’ items (that is, expressions of modality that the students – as well as the teacher – appropriated from the task input material), and expressions of modality that students drew on from their own existing knowledge. The analysis also distinguishes between two types of language focus – implicit and explicit – occurring as two different sub-phases while the students were reporting their initial findings to the whole class. In the first, implicit language focus, the teacher responded to the meanings expressed by the learners by conversationally ‘interweaving’ expressions of epistemic modality into her responses without drawing overt attention to them. In the second, explicit language focus, the teacher briefly focussed attention to the form of the modals as they arose in her responses. In addition, the study reflected the students’ systemic language development by reporting pre- and post-test results, as well as by quantifying the changes in students’ use of modal forms at the pre- and post-focus phases. 8.1.3
Results
Process results Samples of extracts from the pre-focus, language focus and post-focus phases are shown in the box below. ‘Mined’ forms (that is, appropriated from the task input material by the students and the teacher) are underlined; forms provided by the students from their own knowledge appear in bold, and target forms introduced by the teacher (and subsequently used by the students) are shown in italics.
Samples of task language: Samuda (2001) Pre-language focus* A: N: A:
Is this hobby or job? May be it’s hobby, but Maybe. Maybe it’s job.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
142
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
Both. Both. It’s possible. Possible or 90 per cent? 90 per cent I think.
Language focus Implicit T: Hmmm, but you’re not certain if he smokes, huh? (looking at matchbox) A: Look (opens matchbox). Many matches so maybe he just keep for friend, not for him. (laughter) T: Mmmm I – I guess It’s possible he might smoke. It’s hard to tell just from this. Explicit T: Did you have anything here you thought was ‘probable’? Like 90 per cent? Y: Businessman. T: Businessman? 90 per cent? OK. So you’re 90 per cent certain he’s a businessman, right? Here’s another way to say this. You think it’s 90 per cent certain, so you think he must be a businessman. He must be a businessmen (writes on board). So this (points to must be on board) is showing how CERTAIN how SURE you are. Not 100 per cent, but almost 100 per cent. 90 per cent. A: So 100 per cent is ‘be’ or ‘must’?
Post-language focus Y: N: A: C: N: C: A: N: A:
He likes Golf Tennis Art Mmm (looking at chart) are just probable and chess So probable? Probable. (writing) He must like chess? And art
* A more extended sample or pre-language focus talk can be found in Example 1.2, pp. 11–13.
Quantitative results Results reflecting use of forms at the pre-focus and post-focus phases are presented in Table 8.4. Note how, although there is only a fairly small increase in the total proportion non-mined forms at the post-focus phase, four target forms appear in use, while the range of mined language expressions falls sharply.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
C: A: C: N: Y:
143
Tasks in Second Language Learning Table 8.4
Mined forms pre- and post-focus Pre-focus
Post-focus
Mined: Total (It’s) possible (It’s) probable 90% Certain 50%
27% 10.5 5.6 4.8 4.0 1.6
24% 7.3 9.7 7.3 0 0
Non-mined: Total Maybe (I’m) sure (I’m) not sure Must May Might Could
73% 53.2 11.3 8.9 0 0 0 0
76% 36.5 0 0 17.0 12.1 7.3 2.4
Table 8.5
Pre- and post-test results Pre-test (mean)
Maximum 26
3.73
Post-test (mean) ten days later 19.01
Table 8.5 presents the results of the pre- and post-tests. Note that standard deviations were not presented, and nor were the precise test methods that were used. 8.1.4
Discussion
The study presents both process and product data relating to each phase in a three-phase lesson and a snapshot of the students’ language knowledge through pre- and post-tests. It is conceivable that it is only transcript (or in writing, draft) data that are capable of presenting evidence of the nature of the surface processes which students and teacher engage in through tasks, but that statistical data give a perspective on the changing profiles of the students’ language in both use and test contexts. The study also illustrates how teachers can engage with students’ autonomous work on tasks and use the tasks as a means of focusing attention on target language features. Whereas teachers have generally
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
144
145
focused on form before students need to use it (as in PPP approaches) or after the need has passed (in post-task feedback and practice materials), this approach specifically times the teacher’s input so that it occurs at a mid-point during the task, before the task has been completed. Methodologically, this is fairly close to the idea of teachers using recasts in their oral responses to student talk, to implicitly feed in language features which students appear to lack at the point of need. However, recasts are provided on an ad hoc basis according to students’ moment-by-moment need, so that there can be little opportunity for the teacher to return to the same language point with a given student. In contrast, the approach illustrated through this study suggests using tasks systematically to target particular areas of language. The study also highlights differences in types of talk occurring in different phases of the task. Aspects of the study suggest unfinished business, however. First, although the pre- and post-tests are very suggestive, more thorough testing, especially for the post-test, and more information about the standard deviations in the scores would give a more reliable picture. Second, some written or oral self-report data from the teacher and especially from the students would help to illuminate their own assessments of the procedures being used. While to an outsider the lesson seems to work well, we should not assume that this is the students’ view. Third, a more extended longitudinal time-frame would be valuable in helping to show the ways in which phases in the teaching–learning process contribute to longerterm learning. Finally there is a danger that the report might be taken to suggest that tasks play a peripheral role compared to the teacher’s own intervention, and that in larger classes, and with less time, this use of tasks is a luxury which most teachers can easily dispense with. However, our interpretation is that this study suggests that tasks can play a powerful role in knowledge construction. Whether this proves to be the case is an empirical question, and hence we argue that what is needed is more research evidence: such decisions should not be made purely in terms of teachers’ or researchers’ instincts, but on the basis of empirical documentation.
8.2
Donato
One aspect of Samuda’s study is its interest in how interaction – first between students, then between teacher and students – could lead them to work on the meanings and to integrate new forms which would they would perceive as relevant to the meanings they wanted to express. Student–student interaction is seen as an important exploratory forum
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
Tasks in Second Language Learning
for learning. Student–student interaction has widely been seen as an important space for learners to encounter relevant language. This theme has been of particular interest to interactionists or socio-constructivists (see Chapter 7) who believe that overt interaction is a key means by which learners acquire new language and construct new understandings, and for whom the major value of tasks is their ability to generate this type of interaction. Donato (1994) is one of a number of ‘watershed’ papers written from this perspective. The paper studies the talk of a group of three students in a French class, planning a dialogue to be acted out in the following lesson. The analysis investigates how far the students help each other in the selection and production of accurate language. Aims ‘… to discover if, during open-ended collaborative tasks, second language learners mutually construct a scaffold out of the discursive process of negotiating contexts of shared understanding’ (1994: 42). ‘[to seek] to answer the question of whether learners can exert a developmental influence on each other’s interlanguage system in observable ways’ (1994: 39).
Task A one-hour planning session for an oral activity, to take place in the next class, in which a wife discovers that her husband has purchased a fur coat for another woman (1994: 40). (The activity was a scenario from DiPietro, 1987.)
Participants Third term students of French at an American university; they had been together for ten weeks, working on a range of small-group projects. Reportedly, knew each other well, enjoyed working on projects together and assumed ‘a collective orientation to problem-solving’ (1994: 39–40).
Analysis Adopts a ‘micro-genetic analysis’ (i.e. close study) of the way in which the talk develops utterance by utterance, aiming to ‘observe directly how students help each other during the overt planning of L2 utterances and the outcome of these multiple forces of help as they come into contact, and interact, with each other (1994: 42). Uses concept of ‘scaffolding’ to analyse interaction: 1. recruiting interest in the task 2. simplifying the task 3. maintaining pursuit of the goal
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
146
147
4. marking critical features and discrepancies between what has been produced and ideal solution 5. controlling frustration during problem solving, and 6. demonstrating an idealized version of the act to be performed 7. ‘Additionally, the metaphor implies the expert’s active stance toward continual revisions of the scaffold in response to the emerging capabilities of the novice.’ Definitions from Wood, Bruner and Ross (1976) and Rogoff (1990) (1994: 41).
Results
Sample transcript of group sorting out how to say ‘you remembered’ in French A1
Speaker 1
A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8 A9 A10 A11 A12
Speaker 2 Speaker 3 Speaker 1 Speaker 3 Speaker 1 Speaker 2 Speaker 1 Speaker 3 Speaker 1 Speaker 3 Speaker 1
... and then I’ll say ... tu as souvenu notre anniversaire de marriage [sic] ... or should I say mon anniversaire? Tu as ... Tu as ... Tu as souvenu ... ‘you remembered?” ’ [sic] Yeah, but isn’t that reflexive? Tu t’as … Ah, tu t’as souvenu. Oh, it’s tu es. Tu es. tu es, tu es, tu … T’es, tu t’es tu t’es Tu t’es souvenu.
Interpretation of students’ problem [This] is an attempt to render ‘you remembered’ into French. The compound past tense formation of reflective [sic: more commonly referred to as ‘reflexive’] verbs in French presents complex linguistic processing, since students are required to choose the auxiliary être instead of avoir, select the correct reflexive pronoun to agree with the subject, form the past participle, which in this case is an unpredictable form, and decide if, and how, the past participle will be marked for agreement with the subject (Donato, 1994: 44).
Representation of the scaffolding The data are represented through the use of a chart to display the relationship between the chronological dimension of the interaction, which is shown on the horizontal axis, and the accumulating clarification of information, which is set out along the vertical axis: The order of linguistic elements on the vertical axis matches that observed in the group members and reflects the structure of the interaction as it occurred in real time.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
148
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Representation of scaffolded help for ‘you remembered’* subj-pro-aux-pp subj-aux-pp
1ⴚ 1ⴚ
subj-pro-aux subj-aux
1ⴙ
3ⴚ 2ⴚ3ⴚ
1ⴙ 3ⴙ 1ⴙ 2ⴙ 3ⴙ
interactional time * The numbers represent each of the three speakers; the ‘ / ‘ symbols indicate presence or absence of understanding of the target feature.
Description of the interactions in terms of scaffolding … Speaker 3 sets the goal, or more specifically one of several sub-goals of the total task by questioning the accuracy of the utterance [of Speaker 1 in line 4]. The need to verify the accuracy of the utterance appears quite spontaneously and is attended to jointly by the other two students. … That the students collaboratively attend to Speaker 1’s initial phrase, and Speaker 3’s questioning of its legitimacy, is clearly shown. Remarkably, however, no student alone possesses the ability to construct the French past compound tense of the reflexive verb ‘to remember’. Each student appears to control only a specific aspect of the desired construction. Speaker 1, for example, produces the correct past participle (A1) but the incorrect auxiliary verb. Speaker 2 recognises the verb as reflexive (A5) but fails to select the appropriate auxiliary être. Speaker 3, on the other hand, understands the choice of the auxiliary for reflexive compound past tense forms but does not include the correct reflexive pronoun into his version of the utterance (A7). At this point in the interaction Speakers 1 and 2 synthesise the prior knowledge that has been externalised during the interaction and simultaneously arrive at the correct construction (A9–12).
8.2.1 Analysis of the interaction in terms of Wood et al.’s scaffolding features Key categories are underlined and numbered in terms of Wood et al.’s list (see above).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
The numbers 1, 2, and 3 refer to the three participants themselves. Next to each number is a positive or negative sign. The positive sign represents correct, but not necessarily complete knowledge: the negative sign reflects incomplete or incorrect knowledge. The sequence of number is faithful to the [order] in which utterances appeared in the conversation. (1994: 42-3)
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
149
‘The interesting point here is that these three learners are able to construct collectively a scaffold for each other’s performance. Following the definition of Wood, Bruner, and Ross (1976), they jointly manage (3) components of the problem, mark critical features of discrepancies between what has been produced and the perceived ideal solution (4) (A5, A7, A10), and minimize frustration and risk (5) by relying on the collective resources of the group. … ‘The affective markers in this interaction, “Oh”, “Ah”, and “Yea”, reveal … task and information management (3). They are also indicators of orientation to the task … thus signifying the point at which joint focus of the attention [sic] (1) has been achieved. … Their collectivity is also exhibited by their ability to establish intersubjectivity (1). … The convergence of affective markers appears at the critical point in the interaction, when negative evidence is transformed into positive knowledge (A5, A6, A7), indicating a point of development for the participants. ‘These students have constructed for each other a collective scaffold. During this interaction, the speakers are at the same time individually novices and collectively experts, sources of new orientations for each other, and guides through this complex linguistic problem solving. (Donato, 1994: 45–6).
This type of analysis involves a detailed study of the data to identify elements which can be interpreted in terms of the model under discussion. Utterances or parts of utterances (‘ah’, ‘oh’), or whole utterances (such as A5, A7 and A10) are identified as examples of the phenomena which the analyst is seeking. The surface interaction is then interpreted in terms of how the learners signal problems, draw each other’s attention to the problems, and propose and evaluate solutions, signalling as they go whether they understand each other and how far they have got. The analysts uses the surface utterances as evidence of what the speakers are trying to achieve and of what the speakers know at any point in time. In adopting this procedure, interaction processes are taken to be directly indicative of the students’ interlanguage capacities. In this case, Donato uses the data to argue that the students’ talk is an instantiation of joint learning in which students indicate what they do not know, and help each other to produce the correct form. 8.2.2
Discussion
Donato’s is an interesting account of the surface dynamics of the interaction. A key contribution of analyses such as this is to demonstrate in detail the work learners engage in when collaborating on a task. It shows that group talk on tasks can be textured in such a way as to enable a level
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Analysis of scaffolded help
Tasks in Second Language Learning
of personal involvement and focus on detail which would be hard to envisage in whole class interaction. In addition, such data have an immediate face validity, since they illustrate how the materials work in a way which can translate directly to the classroom. The possibility that such language work might contribute to learners’ development will obviously be of interest to teachers and quite possibly to learners too (see Lynch and Maclean’s comment on this). There are, however, some points of caution. First, the study is not concerned with tasks as defined in Chapter 1 or as reflected in the studies discussed earlier in this chapter. That is, Donato’s task does not involve learners in holistic uses of the target language, but simply in using the mother tongue to produce a target language script. This is not to say that there is no place for the use of such activities, but to note that the term ‘task’ is used by teachers and researchers in different ways. For instance, some researchers or teachers might consider Donato’s ‘task’ an example of pre-task planning. We include it here because of the potential value of the analysis he uses, and because pre-task planning is relevant for our theme, rather than as an example of a type of ‘task’. Second, we need to be aware that Donato’s description of the data is not simple, but involves significant interpretation. Consider, for example, turns A2, A3 and A4. It is possible to interpret A2 and A3 as either buying time to recall the correct forms or as simply indicating doubts on the parts of speakers 2 and 3. Similarly although in A7 Speaker 2 does not produce a fully correct phrase (it should be tu t’es), it is possible that s/he is aware of the correct phrase but needs time to access it. Hence when Donato says, ‘each student appears to control only a specific aspect of the desired construction’, he is interpreting what the students say as offering a direct window onto what they know. That is, their actual performance is taken to represent their systemic knowledge. This may not be a warranted assumption. A similar point concerns Donato’s interpretation of the scaffolding moves. For example, how justifiable is it to analyse utterances such as ‘ah’ and ‘oh’ as revealing ‘task’ and ‘information management’, and in addition as signalling ‘the presence of distributed help and mutual orientation to the task’ (1994: 46)? These interjections might have these values, but equally well might not. Presumably the terms ‘task management’ and ‘information management’ cannot be applied to all occurrences of ‘ah’ and ‘oh’ in talk. Similar questions can be asked of other aspects of the analysis: for instance, the suggestion that the interpersonal discourse gives rise to ‘a discourse structure reminiscent of that of a
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
150
151
single speaker’, or that the talk reflects the speakers’ ‘ability to establish intersubjectivity’? The question is not whether these are plausible interpretations of the data, but rather whether they are accurate. To find out, we need a way of cross-checking our interpretations with the participants. These points reflect a more general and interesting issue, namely the assumption that we can straightforwardly deduce what learners know of the target language directly from what they say. For one thing, performance cannot reflect competence directly (Chomsky, 1957). Indeed, it varies according to context (Labov, 1972) and needs to be carefully handled in attempting to identify the state of learners’ interlanguage (Tarone, 1988). So performance data can be misleading. This has a pragmatic dimension too. Various researchers (e.g. Aston, 1986; Foster, 1998; Rampton, 1995) have pointed out that for both social and psychological reasons speakers often prefer convergence to divergence. Aston (1987) has been frequently cited to critique the analysis of ‘negotiation for meaning’ sequences: people might appear to negotiate meaning satisfactorily, but ‘negotiation’ may be concluded so as to avoid inconveniencing the self or others. That is, what speakers say may not always reflect what they know. Hence we could question conclusions such as that ‘the convergence of affective markers appears at the critical point in the interaction, when negative evidence is transformed into positive knowledge (A5, A6, A7), indicating a point of development for the participants’ (1994: 46). It is possible that this was a point of development for all the students, or for two of the students, or for just one; after all, it is equally possible that much of the talk was devoted to tactfully jogging each other’s memories in order to enable one to work out the form. It is also possible that by the end of the exchange one or more of the students remained unsure of the correct form. We do not know. It is one thing then to report the data, and another to interpret it. We may need more evidence before deciding whether students have ended up with complete or incomplete knowledge. Nevertheless, we do want to know how individual utterances in intragroup talk can contribute to learning, and in this respect Donato’s study was a landmark paper, raising key questions about ways of representing and interpreting task data. It also suggests pedagogically enlightening ways in which interaction on second language tasks can be seen. The challenge though is how to analyse what we might call the ‘systemic’ importance of learning processes. We return to this issue in another guise in a later study: Mackey (1999).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
152
Tasks in Second Language Learning
8.3
Yule and Macdonald
Quote 8.1 Abstract of study Extending the research done on the effects of different types of task and different participant arrangements used to foster negotiated interaction among L2 learners, we developed a task that presents specific referential conflicts and analysed the solutions adopted within two different pairings of learners. Pairs in which the higher proficiency member had the dominant role engaged in little interactive cooperation and in some cases changed the task rather than negotiate a solution. Pairs in which the higher proficiency member had the nondominant role engaged in substantial negotiation work, sought each other’s perspective and generally shared much more in the interactive turn-taking and the successful resolution of referential conflicts. (Yule and Macdonald, 1990: 539).
Whereas Donato’s paper explores the potential of a group planning activity to generate collaborative language work, Yule and Macdonald design an activity with in-built communication problems so as to study how far students resolve the problems.
Aims To find out whether the effectiveness of SL students in negotiating referential meanings is influenced by how they interpret their own and each other’s roles, with relative proficiency seen as a potentially significant factor.
Relevant concepts Reference: the use of language to identify, locate, move or follow movement or changes in entities; seen as influenced by the ways in which speakers interpret their own and their interlocutors’ respective roles and perspectives. Referential effectiveness: inevitably influenced by the relationship between the participants in any given discourse, and in particular by their ability to take account of each other’s perspective. Speakers’ effectiveness in doing this varies.
Theoretical motivation To explore whether the design of a task can engage negotiation of reference, and how far this can be systematically affected by students’ engagement in their respective roles. Secondary motivation is to see whether relative proficiency is a relevant factor.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Yule and Macdonald (1990) summarise their study as follows:
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
153
Pedagogical motivation
Design Aims to study effects of role and relative proficiency level on speakers’ management of referential language. It analyses the frequencies of identification and resolution of problems, and surveys quantitative patterns across two types of pairing of students, making it a cross-group study.
Task Each student in a pair had a slightly different version of the same map of a city, with buildings labelled. One student was required to tell their partner a route. The task was completed when the student who knew the route had communicated it to the student who didn’t know it.
Referential problems built into the task design Problem 1: the old map has a road through one block which in the new map is closed off. Problem 2: the old map has one building labelled ‘Hats’, which in the new map (identical location) is labelled ‘Bicycles’. Problem 3: the old map has one ‘Office’ building marked in an area whereas the new map marks that ‘Office’, plus another two ‘Office’ buildings. Problem 4: the old map has a ‘Dentist’ next to a ‘Motel’ in one area whereas the new map has ‘Shirts’ and ‘Doctor’. … Those in the ‘sender’ role will encounter places where their reference points differ from those of their receivers. To achieve successful communication, there has to be some form of negotiation.
Task instructions ‘To Speaker A (“the sender”): You have a map with a delivery route marked on it, showing where ten packages have to be delivered. Your partner has a similar map, but does not know the delivery route. Describe the route so that your partner can draw the delivery route on his/her map. To Speaker B (“the receiver”): You have to draw the delivery route on your map. You can ask questions any time you want. To both speakers: The two maps are similar, but one is older than the other, so you will find that some parts of your maps are different’ (1990: 543). The sender was given the older version of the map, and the receiver the newer one, though neither knew who had which.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
To consider ways of focusing students on negotiation of reference; and since no class is homogeneous, and proficiency is relative, to explore the likely impact of giving higher or lower proficiency student the dominant role in information gap tasks.
154
Tasks in Second Language Learning
(Continued)
Participants: 40 volunteer international graduate students at a North American university, from 16 different language backgrounds, with an English language proficiency described as ‘high intermediate to advanced (TOEFL 500)’. Pairing: students paired with colleagues from a different L1 background, one (‘H’) with a mean TOEFL score of 625, and the other (‘L’) a lower mean of 562. In ten pairs H was given the sender role, and L was the receiver (H L); in the other ten pairs, the roles were reversed (L H). Task procedures: ‘In performing the tasks, the students could not see each other’s maps, but could face each other, allowing gestures to be used (though infrequently). The spoken interactions . . . all took place in separate rooms, without investigators present’ (1990: 544).
Analysis The authors sought ‘evidence in the L2 performance of students that they did, or did not, comprehend each other’, and aimed to ‘recognize when comprehension of specifically referential information was being appropriately signalled or not’. To do this, they ‘looked at those points in the task in which a referential conflict existed and determined whether the interactants resolved the conflict by arriving at a mutual understanding of their referential worlds or not’ (1990: 542). This led them to analyse the transcripts in terms of the following criteria: • • • •
Students failed to identify the problem Students identified the problem but ignored it or gave it up Students identified the problem and solved it by mandate Students identified the problem and solved it by negotiation
Results Summary: ‘The difference in performances elicited under the two conditions was so marked that it seems unnecessary to apply standard quantifying measures to characterize them’ (1990: 545).
Overview: Effectiveness in dealing with problems Did not identify problem Identified but ignored or gave up Identified, and solved by mandate Identified and solved by negotiation
HL 11 (27.5%) 11 (27.5%) 11 (27.5%) 7 (17.5%)
LH 5 (12.5%) 3 ( 7.5%) 5 (12.5%) 27 (67.5%)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Participants and procedures
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
155
Detailed results, problem by problem, and by pair type Identified the problem?
Problem 1 Problem 2 Problem 3 Problem 4 Totals %
Not at all
Yes, and Ignored or gave up
Yes, and solved by mandate
Yes, and solved by negotiation
HL LH
HL LH
HL
LH
HL LH
– 1 6 4 11 27.5
– 1 3 1 5 12.5
– 3 2 2 7 17.5
6 – 1 4 11 27.5
2 – – 3 5 12.5
4 6 1 – 11 27.5
2 1 – – 3 7.5
6 8 7 6 27 67.5
Interpretation H L pairings: although meanings are apparently being negotiated, often agreement is no more than superficial, with problems of comprehension and expression not being resolved. When LP receiver signals problems, HP sender often ignores them; and even where discrepancies between the maps are noticed, HP sender tends to mandate solutions without negotiation. Sometimes HP sender simply abandons his/her role.
L H pairings: in contrast: ‘there is a lot of evidence to show that negotiation of meaning, the discovery of the other’s perspective and a more balanced sharing of interactive turn-taking are the result. In its simplest form, the higher proficiency participant’s contribution as receiver (H-R) is to respond more actively to the directions received’ (1990: 549). The result is far more frequent use of features like clarification requests, suggesting ‘greater cooperative negotiation of their joint goal’ (1990: 551).
Advantages for both LP and HP students: ‘[W]e find the sender’s role gives the less proficient students greater opportunity (or even the necessity) to use the language productively, to create messages that
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
To see the pattern, it is necessary to read the table as a whole, rather than line by line. That is, 67.5% of the problems were successfully resolved in the L H condition, while in the H L condition, 55% were simply not resolved (lines 1 and 2), and a further 27.5% were not satisfactorily resolved. This is a massive difference in effectiveness, in favour of the L H condition.
156
Tasks in Second Language Learning
take account of their own world of reference and also what their interactive partner has told them. It also places them in a type of spoken interaction in which, instead of only responding with passive backchannels, they participate in the joint creation of linguistic structures, across turns . . .’ (1990: 552). ‘To appreciate the benefits [for the higher proficiency speaker], one has to accept that taking part in the cooperative, negotiated resolutions of referential conflicts does develop communication skills that are missed when the higher proficiency speaker, as in the H L pairings, only produces one-way talk, with little feedback. The L H interactions force the higher proficiency speaker to listen (as well as speak), to take one’s interlocutor’s perspective into account (rather than ignore it), and to tailor one’s contributions to fit a particular interactive partner’s knowledge (instead of only displaying one’s own knowledge). These are the kinds of L2 skills that are not typically addressed in the language classroom, yet which are required skills if our advanced learners are to become effective participants in a range of L2 interactions’ (1990: 553).
8.3.1
Discussion
Like Samuda (2001), this study is relatively unusual in using a task design to target a particular area of language, and one of relatively few studies to investigate how differences between students can impact on the processes and outcomes of a task. The study demonstrates once again that it is possible to build particular communication problems into the design of a task which can be used to raise awareness, in this case to assess the effectiveness of learners’ ability to use particular aspects of language. It is unusual for the key elements of task performance to be broken down into four levels of achievement as here. The analysis seems unproblematic, in that because of the design, surface features can be interpreted directly in terms of whether information has been shared and problems jointly resolved. However, we are not told how reliability of the analysis was checked. In practical terms, the issue of how to pair students in the classroom and what roles to give them is one that is rarely considered in the literature, and which would be hard for teachers to address in a principled way without research data such as this. It would be of interest to see how far speaker role relates to proficiency on other types of task and at other levels of proficiency. The study may also have interesting implications for the teacher talk in teacher–student interaction. There could be questions surrounding the claim that communicating reference successfully is more of a pragmatic interpersonal problem than other uses of language. While it is true that it is essential for speakers to assess their interlocutors’ perspectives, this is probably also the case for most areas of the grammar of the language. In addition, building
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
(Continued)
157
connections between task, pragmatics and language is theoretically tricky, though it seems to work here. However, one of the reasons why this seems a particularly valuable study is because of the way in which it illustrates two key dimensions of tasks: 1), the dimension of the particular challenge they are designed to present learners, which teachers and designers (among others) can evaluate as more or less effective; and 2) the dimension of interpersonal role, which without the use of tasks would seem to be pedagogically unmanageable.
8.4 8.4.1
Mackey The study
Mackey (1999) explores the impact of interactive participation on students’ ability to use different question forms. Thus the study researches an aspect of the interaction hypothesis – ‘that taking part in interaction can facilitate second language development’ (1999: 565). The hypothesis here is that two-way interaction between students is potentially more productive than non-interactive learning activities in which meaning negotiation is unnecessary. The focus, then, is how far the interactive dimension of tasks can contribute to the learning of targeted language structures. Aims To see if students assessed as having reached a certain stage of development in question formation could be led, through task use, to produce question forms typical of more advanced stages of development. Stages of question-form development assessed via an adaptation of Pienemann’s stage model (Pienemann and Johnston, 1987). Mackey wished to see if students could progress from Stage 3 (fronting, such as ‘Where the cats are?’) to Stages 4 (‘pseudo-inversion’, e.g. ‘Have you got a dog?’) and 5 (do-auxiliary in second position, e.g. ‘What do you have?’ ‘Where does your cat sit?’)
Research questions ‘a) Does conversational interaction facilitate second language development? b) Are the developmental outcomes related to the nature of the conversational interaction and the level of learner involvement?’ (1999: 565).
Design Participants randomly assigned to four groups: three treatment, one control, while the ‘beginner group’ joined the lower-intermediate group of ‘interactors’.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
158
Tasks in Second Language Learning
1. The ‘interactors’: Students interacted with a NS interlocutor to complete the task. NS interlocutors were briefed about the target language features. Two groups of students followed this condition – a lower-intermediate group, and a beginners’ group. This enabled a comparison of the impact of interaction on different levels of developmental ‘readiness’. 2. The ‘scripteds’: The NS followed pre-scripted input to give information to the student. If students did not understand, the scripted input could be repeated, but if they still did not understand, the interlocutor would move on to the next point. The scripting was ‘so detailed that communication breakdowns and negotiation of meaning were rendered highly unlikely’ (1999: 570). 3. The ‘observers’: Students observed a video recording of students with a NS doing each of the tasks, and completed the task sheets from watching the video. A control group did the pre- and post-tests, but none of the treatment tasks, enabling the study to check for general learning processes taking place outside the treatments. For all groups, each task took from 15–25 minutes.
Theoretical motivation The key issue is whether the three treatment conditions have different impacts on the learners, with particular interest in condition 1, the interactive condition. The reasoning is as follows: 1. The interactors: In this condition, students would share responsibility for completing the task, and would therefore be able to generate as much negotiation of meaning (i.e. as many repetitions, clarifications, comprehension checks and clarification requests) as needed to ensure task completion. The question is whether a high incidence of negotiation of meaning gives rise to more repetition of question forms, leading to more development. 2. The scripteds: In this condition, the native speaker will be less open to negotiation moves from the student, and therefore fewer questions would be used or reworked. If so, this condition should lead to less development. 3. The observers: Here the students are not personally responsible for managing the interaction; hence although they could have the same exposure as students in the interactive condition, they will not be pushed into processing the language so fully themselves. Less development is expected. 4. The control group: this group is not expected to have the relevant experiences, hence less development is expected.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
(Continued)
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
159
Participants
Tasks Four ‘treatment’ tasks were used, designed to engage learners in using questions: • • • •
a story completion task: ‘working out a story by asking questions’ a picture sequencing task: discovering the order of a picture story a picture drawing task: ‘describing or drawing a picture’ (1999: 568) picture differences: ‘identifying the differences between similar pictures’ for the tests.
Procedures Students were tested once before, and three times after, the treatment. For these tests, the picture differences task was used so that students’ performance would not be influenced by familiarity with the test type. The pre-test: used to provide a basis for comparison with the post-tests. The three post-tests: the first the day after the last treatment day, the second a week later, and the third three weeks after the second, enabled the researcher to check on longer term retention and possible delayed development following the treatment. Dyads: For all tasks, including tests, students were paired with a NS interlocutor. Administration: Participants did one of each of the three types of treatment task on three consecutive days (i.e. one of each on day 1, one of each on day 2, and one of each on day 3).
Analysis Data were analysed using two measures: • •
the numbers of students per group who improved their stage of questions (the ‘developmental stage increase’); the number of advanced stage questions per group (‘developmentally more advanced questions’).
A student was judged to have improved their stage ‘if they produced at least two different higher level question forms in at least two of the post-tests’ (1999: 571).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Thirty-four adult ESL learners from a private English language school in Sydney, Australia; randomly selected, from lower proficiency programmes and from a range of language backgrounds.
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Table 8.6
Numbers of students showing developmental change
Percentage Ratio
Interactors n7
Controls n7
Interactors (beginners) n7
Scripteds n6
Observers n7
71 (5/7)
14 (1/7)
86 (6/7)
16 (1/6)
57 (4/7)
Table 8.7 Increase in number of questions at stages 4 and 5 produced by each group in the post-tests
Post-test 1 Post-test 2 Post-test 3
Interactors n7
Controls n7
Interactors (beginners) n7
Scripteds n6
Observers n7
2.3 4.0 4.8
1.8 0.5 2.0
1.6 2.9 7.0
1.4 2.2 2.4
1.6 1.0 0.9
Figures are approximate, based on a graph in Mackey, 1999.
Results The increase in questions at stages 4 and 5 was studied by calculating the mean numbers of questions at those levels on the three post tests (see Tables 8.6 and 8.7). Table 8.6 shows that the two interactor groups benefited most, and the controls and scripteds benefited least. The observers were close to the two interactor groups. In Table 8.7 (showing the mean number of stage 4 and 5 question types per group), the interactors outperform the other groups, with the observers performing weakest. These data are interpreted as showing that the interactor condition was more helpful for development in the use of questions thanthe other conditions, with the beginners showing most improvement. That is, the ‘negotiation for meaning’ condition seems to have helped development. An ANOVA test was run on the gains for each group (the post-test scores per group minus the group’s pre-test scores). Statistically significant differences were found only for the two interactor groups (post-elementary group: p .018; beginner group: p .048), with post-test 2, and post-test 3 respectively being the point of significant gains). So comparison of the
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
160
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
161
pre-test and the three post-tests showed that the interactor groups scored higher on each successive post-test. Interpretation
Mackey interprets the results as showing that negotiation for meaning in the context of tasks is positively associated with development of the ability to use question forms:
Quote 8.2 Negotiation for meaning and the opportunity to develop use of question forms By taking part in interaction, [a sample] learner received examples of advanced structures. Through interactional modifications that arose through negotiation of meaning, some of those structures were repeated or rephrased. The learner also had the opportunity to produce questions and receive feedback through the answers. Structures that were more developmentally advanced were produced after treatment. This pattern was true for the two groups of learners who took part in interaction. (Mackey, 1999: 577)
That is, the group study shows a common pattern in the ways in which learners respond to tasks, and by the same token, types of task interaction have a recurrent quality. Mackey concludes that tasks are a valuable context for promoting learning.
Quote 8.3 Tasks as a context for language development This study suggests that one of the features that best interacts with the learnerinternal factors to facilitate subsequent language development is learner participation in interaction that offers opportunities for the negotiation of meaning to take place. This interaction is effectively obtained through the use of tasks. (Mackey, 1999: 583–4)
8.4.3
Discussion
Quote 8.3 suggests that in this study the most important aspect of tasks is their capacity to engender negotiation for meaning – that is, their role in mobilising peer group talk with the target interactive qualities. In other words, achieving this purpose is a matter of appropriate task design. However it is not only a matter of design, since in order for the tasks to
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
8.4.2
Tasks in Second Language Learning
function appropriately the NS interlocutors needed careful briefing. So, one implication of the study is that for the interactive design to function, it needs to be complemented by appropriate engagement by at least one of the interlocutors. In successfully influencing the learners’ ability to use question forms, the study also provides evidence that tasks can be designed to target particular aspects of language over and above the general nature of the learners’ language processing, such as the relative fluency, accuracy or complexity being encouraged. This, then, is a second aspect of language use that task design can be reasonably expected to activate. In terms of the impact of the tasks, this is one of the rare studies successfully to have shown a learning effect through a pre-/post-design (note, though, the series of studies of listening comprehension tasks reported in Ellis, 2001, as well as Samuda, 2001). We might wish to have more detailed information in order to study how far the tasks in fact made a qualitative difference to students’ use of questions, and whether speedier progress could have been made with more explicit teacher intervention in the context of the use of such tasks. In the future we hope to get a fuller picture of the learners’ emerging control of the language features under study. Yet overall, the broad impact of the study is robust. Mackey’s study also carries other pedagogically significant implications. One is that tasks need to be selected to target areas of language which are relevant to the learners in terms of their current level of development. One can also reasonably anticipate that it would be helpful if learners themselves perceive the need to improve their mastery of the language feature, and are aware of the value of the selected tasks for achieving this aim. There is no indication of whether the learners were aware of the focus of the experiment – the implication is that they probably were not informed, to avoid any bias. In pedagogical contexts, however, there are obvious reasons for not withholding this kind of information – if the tasks work under these experimental circumstances, then from this perspective presumably they have just as good a chance of working in the classroom. From this we can argue for further work in exploring learners’ perceptions of tasks (see Ortega, 2005, discussed below). The question of classroom effectiveness returns us to the issue of ecological validity. Although the study was pedagogically oriented in the sense that the sequence of tasks was carefully selected in light of the students’ phase of language development at the time – quite possibly even more carefully than a teacher would normally be able to manage (a significant point when we consider the relationship between teaching and
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
162
163
research) – aspects of the implementation diverged fairly significantly from most pedagogical practices: each student had their own NS interlocutor; the NS interlocutors were carefully briefed; and a series of preand post-tests was used to monitor development carefully. To build on studies such as this, we will obviously need further work cataloguing how tasks of this kind function in normal classroom contexts. Nevertheless, this study provides empirical support for the view that there are four important aspects of tasks: 1) their design; 2) their relevance for the learners; 3) the way they are used; and 4) their impact on development.
8.5 8.5.1
Yuan and Ellis The study
With Yuan and Ellis (2003) we shift from studies focusing on interaction to those researching task demand. This is one of a series studying the impact of planning time on oral performance (see also Ellis, 1987; Skehan and Foster 1997 1999, 2005; Ellis, 2005). Aims To find out how students’ performance on oral tasks is affected by a) allowing them pre-task-planning time, b) on-line planning time, and c) no planning time.
Theoretical motivation Previous studies suggest that pre-task planning influences speakers’ fluency and complexity, and sometimes their accuracy. On-line planning had not been explicitly studied, but theorising (e.g. Johnson, 1996; Skehan, 1998) and empirical studies (e.g. Ellis, 1987) suggested that having more time during performance can affect performance, especially accuracy (e.g. where SL users are able to speak more slowly, or write without time pressures). Pedagogical motivation Most communicative approaches to language teaching emphasise the importance of communication per se. However, there has long been concern that communicative activities can encourage communicative effectiveness at the cost of accuracy (Skehan, 1998), leading users to neglect formal details in comprehension (VanPatten, 1996) and in production, redundancy reduction (or ‘stem form’ English; George, 1972). If planning time can shift learners’ attention to language, this might usefully offset any neglect of form.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
164
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Forty-two full-time UG English major students in the International Business Department of a Chinese university; homogeneous in terms of age (18–20 years), learning history (eight years’ schooling, no visits to an English-speaking country) and proficiency (marks between 100 and 120 on the Higher Education Bureau Examination, and in terms of scores on a pre-test taken from the TOEFL).
Task and procedures Monologic narration of a picture story comprising six images, from Heaton (1975), carried out individually in a language laboratory booth, during a listening and speaking class. The task was selected to enable comparability with other studies (cf. Skehan, 2001; Ellis, 2005). The story was chosen to require some interpretation on the part of the learners, and to make the task reasonably demanding. Instructions were given in Chinese.
Task conditions Three groups: •
No-planning (NP) group (no pre-task planning time and a five-minute time-limit for telling the story). • Pre-task planning (PTP) group (ten minutes’ pre-task planning and a five-minute time-limit for telling the story). • On-line planning (OLP) group (no pre-task planning time and no time-limit for telling the story). The design aimed to lead the OLP group to plan more while telling the story, and the PTP group to do their planning before speaking.
Research design Table 8.8
Preparation
NP
PTP
OLP
0.5 mins
10 mins
0.5 mins
Target output
Four sentences per picture
Task time limit
5 minutes
5 minutes
None
Other instructions
None
Planning to focus on content, organisation and language. They could write notes, but not use them while speaking
None
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Participants
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
165
Categories of analysis (measures)
Independent variables
1. Length of time: total number of seconds on task 2. Syllables A: the number of syllables produced to reflect productivity. 3. Syllables B: the number of syllables produced, minus all syllables repeated, reformulated or replaced, to reflect meaningful productivity. Dependent variables (calculated per student and averaged per group)
Fluency: 1. Rate A: number of syllables per minute 2. Rate B: number of productive syllables per minute
Complexity: 1. Syntactic complexity: ration of clauses to T-units 2. Syntactic variety: total number of different verb forms 3. Lexical variety: mean segmental type-token ratio, calculated for each segment of 40 words, by dividing total number of different words by the total number of words in the segment (i.e. by 40).
Accuracy: 1. Error-free clauses (including lexical errors) – as a percentage of all clauses 2. Correct verb forms – as a percentage of all verb forms.
Analysis and results An analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted to test for statistical significance of differences between the groups’ scores. General impact of conditions Table 8.9 NP
Time Syll A Syll B
186.43 194.36 173.71
PTP
189.29 242.50 227.00
OLP
243.57 235.50 210.36
Fvalue
3.474 3.886 5.585
Sig
.041* .029* .007**
Locations of significance NPPTP
NPOLP
PTPOLP
.993 .046* .009**
.077 .101 .093
.098 .932 .598
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
To check that the conditions worked, the authors counted the following:
Tasks in Second Language Learning
These measures reflect the impact of the different conditions on the time spent talking and the amount of talk produced. The OLP group spent most time talking; the planning groups produced more than the NP group; and despite the greater time spent by the OLP group, they did not produce significantly more than the PTP group. To end up with a similar amount of talk produced with more time to produce it, the OLP group must have spoken more slowly. So the conditions seem to have the intended impact on the students’ behaviour. The next question is how far this influenced the quality of their talk.
Table 8.10
Fluency Rate A Rate B Complexity Syntactic Syn. Variety Lexical variety Accuracy Clauses Verbs
Impact on quality of talk: fluency, complexity and accuracy F-value
Sig
NP-PTP
NP-OLP
PTP-OLP
2.737 3.412
.077 .043*
.359 .247
.690 .691
7.480 2.523 4.439
.002** .093 .018*
.007** .164 .103
.008** .164 .811
.997 1.00 .025*
5.152 4.45
.010** .018*
.256 .604
.010** .020*
.322 .170
.081 .048*
Fluency The results show that in terms of fluency, the only significant difference is between PTP and OLP in terms of meaningful output (checking the means we find that it is the PTP group that is the more productive). The NP group falls between the two.
Complexity The non-planning group produces significantly less complex talk than the other two groups. The planning group once again falls between the two. However, it is only the PTP group which is significantly different in terms of lexical variety, as compared with the OLP group.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
166
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
167
Accuracy The OLP group is significantly more accurate than the NP group on both measures, this time with the PTP group falling between the two extremes. Interpretation
We now need to consider how to interpret results such as these. They are complicated in two ways. First, the comparison between three groups is harder to conceptualise than if it had been between two groups: we tend to find differences between two groups, but not between all three pairs. Second, we need to note that when we have a significant difference, this could be produced by either of the two conditions, or by a combination of the two. For instance, the PTP and OLP groups differ significantly in terms of fluency. But this may be as much due to the conditions of the OLP group (slowing them down) as to the conditions of the PTP group (either the pre-planning in which they get organised, or the five-minute time limit which speeds them up, or perhaps both). Hence when we consider findings such as these, we have to bear in mind that comparisons often involve more than one factor. 8.5.3
Discussion
What are the practical implications of this study for the use of tasks in the classroom? First, it is clear that it is tricky to ask students to attend to accuracy and fluency at the same time. Either they will take longer in trying to be more accurate, or they will try to be more fluent at the cost of accuracy. In contrast, syntactic complexity could be promoted by getting students to attend to accuracy or by getting them to prepare the content of what they want to say. If they attend to the content, they may also produce a wider range of vocabulary. More generally, encouraging a particular focus generally: a) biases performance in a particular direction, and by implication away from the other; and b) carries with it at least one other consequence (syntactic complexity, and possibly lexical variety). So when we notice that students are continually dysfluent but accurate, or fluent but inaccurate, this is understandable; and we may want to do something using information from this study to ‘balance them up’. We might wonder whether this holds for all oral activities, or only for some. Similarly, does the same thing hold for reading and writing activities? And how does it affect memory? If people initially focus on accuracy, where does this leave them if they have to use their work again?
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
8.5.2
Tasks in Second Language Learning
And what if people focus on content? This brings further questions into focus: is complexity necessarily a good thing, and are all kinds of complexity the same? For instance, do we simply want more embedding, or might we be interested in encouraging more complex types of complementation? And in the same vein, can on-line planning focus more on some aspects of the grammar than others? In relation to the theoretical implications of this study, unresolved problems remain. First, we know that people took longer in the on-line planning condition, but do we know that they were actually doing more planning on-line? And do we know what they were actually attending to? Is it possible that they were doing the same kinds of on-line planning as the other groups, but simply spending longer on it? Also, is it possible that they were not attending more to accuracy per se, but were simply being more careful in the way they accessed their memory stores? A second issue is whether the pre-task planning students were focusing only on content during their ten minutes’ preparation, or whether they were also attending to language, as they were invited to. Research into this would be useful – we need to know what students do in response to what they are asked to do (see Ortega, 2005, discussed below for a study on this topic). Third, planning prior to talk is fairly artificial in everyday, spontaneous talk. How do we justify the use of PTP in leading students towards greater competence? Here it would be useful to explore the impact of planning in relation to different levels of proficiency and especially useful to know how effective this is in normal class contexts. Overall, then, this study is valuable in various ways. It shows that even a fairly simple pair of constructs (pre-planning and on-line planning) are not straightforward in terms of how they are implemented, or what we assume is happening when they are implemented, or indeed in terms of the actual results. Second, though, it shows fairly clearly that speaking tasks are not identical: the conditions might make quite a significant difference to how people do them. Third, the study leaves open interesting questions about student responses and perceptions, about planning in relation to levels of proficiency, and more generally about the use of student planning in normal classrooms. It also illustrates how, to be productive, research in the field needs to involve a cumulative series of attempts to solve intriguing puzzles: this study follows on a sequence of studies initiated originally by Ellis in 1987 (Crookes, 1989; Skehan and Foster, 1997), each using earlier findings to reconceptualise the problem, improve the design and refine the analysis. Yuan and Ellis
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
168
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
169
themselves comment that the design used in Ellis (1987) contained problems it was worth attempting to resolve.
Ortega
8.6.1
The study
As we have seen, most studies of language learning tasks have concentrated on various types of performance data: Yuan and Ellis (above) is one example. Indeed, relatively few (notably Lynch and Maclean, 2000, 2001; see below) have investigated students’ construals of work on tasks. In contrast Ortega (2005) investigated students’ perceptions of the benefits of pre-task planning. As we noted in Chapter 7, the general purpose of such studies is to build up an understanding of the interface between pedagogical procedures and learner perception. It also provides an opportunity to open a window specifically on learners’ rationales, preferences and strategies.
Aims To study ‘the benefits afforded by pre-task planning through . . . what learners say they do when they plan’ (2005: 77)
Participants Two groups of learners of Spanish as an FL in an American university: 14 ‘low intermediate’ fourth term students; 32 ‘advanced’ students from the fifth term and beyond.
Data In the form of retrospective interviews collected in the context of a sequence of pre-task planning → narrative telling task: Phase
Activities
Comments
Pre-task
Input: Picture strip; L1 recording Planning / in writing
Task
Monologic oral narrative to peer listener Listener: story retelling in writing Speaker: retrospective interview
To ensure comprehension Enables repeated measures study of planning vis-à-vis language Authentic listener giving speaker a communicative purpose Motivates listening and occupies listener during interview
Post-task
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
8.6
170
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Planning generally resulted in greater fluency and greater complexity, with the Advanced group also showing more accuracy. The main differences between the two groups were increased lexical complexity for the Low Intermediate group, and more accurate noun-modifier agreement in the Advanced group.
Fluency Syntactic complexity
Lexical complexity Accuracy
Low Intermediate
Advanced
More disfluency markers in unplanned narratives More words and propositions per utterance in planned talk Higher type-token ration in planned talk No differences in accuracy on definite article or subject–verb agreement
Faster speech rate in planned narratives More words per utterance in planned narratives No differences in typetoken ratio More accurate nounmodifier agreement
Findings from the interview data a) Frequency of reported strategy use by type Ortega first analysed the students’ stated frequency of strategy use, in terms of strategy types, by group. No differences emerged.
Summary of mean frequencies of reported use of strategy types All strategies All participants Advanced Low-intermediate
12.11 12.78 10.33
Metacognitive
Cognitive
5.20 5.53 4.33
5.91 6.16 5.25
Socio/affective 1.00 1.09 0.75
b) Frequencies of reported use of particular strategies Next, Ortega considered the frequency of reported use of specific strategies, once again by group. Here the striking differences are in organisational planning, with the low intermediate students reporting very high use, and in rehearsing, with high frequency reported by the Advanced group, but not by the Low Intermediates.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Summary of results of pre-task planning study by group
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
171
Outlining/summarising Production monitoring Organisational planning
84% 75% 68%
Lexical compensation Translating Empathising with listener Rehearsing
64% 57% 52% 48%
(both groups equally) (both groups equally) (both groups, but low intermediates very high) (both groups equally) (both groups equally) (both groups equally) (advanced 53%, low intermediates 33%)
c) Perceptions of benefits and limitations Ortega’s interview explored students’ general perceptions of the benefits and limitations of pre-task planning. Most (59 per cent) saw planning as helpful, but a significant minority (41 per cent) found it unhelpful. In itself this information is of limited value: more helpful is to know why. The perceived benefits and limitations are reported next. Perceived benefits and limitations
Beneficial feature
Function
Extra time:
Organising thoughts; formulating thoughts; lexical solutions; practising/rehearsing Formulating thoughts; lexical and grammatical retrieval; improving lexical choice; improving content; practicing/rehearsing; monitoring grammar
Writing notes:
Locus of limitation
Limitation
Performance conditions
1. Low task complexity 2. Poverty of planning conditions
Language expertise
1. Ceiling to retrieval benefits 2. Lack of transfer to on-line performance
Learner preferences
1. Added pressure with planning 2. Extemporaneous performance feels good
Ortega summarises this as follows: • The main advantages were in terms of retrieval and organisation; and rehearsal and monitoring.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Strategies reportedly used most frequently
Tasks in Second Language Learning
• The main limitations were in terms of: – the conditions, the task was too simple, or the planning conditions did not allow access to enough sources of information; – expertise, lack of knowledge limited the value of planning time, and lack of capacity meant that what was planned didn’t transfer; and – learner preferences, for some, planning time increased the sense of pressure by increasing the challenge; for others, planning detracted from the agreeable sense of spontaneity in improvising speech. The key trend is a difference in language focus between communication and accuracy. These Ortega links to differences in level of language expertise. Table 8.11 Individual differences in focus on communication vs focus on accuracy by group Low-intermediates
Advanced
Writing
For retrieval, none for recall, fewer (33%) rehearsed.
Balanced writing for retrieval, for recall; 50% used rehearsal; cycles of organising thoughts, retrieving appropriate words and rules, and rehearsing for performance.
Monitoring
Of production and impact on listener. Little monitoring of language.
Of production, impact on listener; auditory, visual, cross-language, style and ‘double check’ monitoring.
Listener sensitivity and orientation to the language Under ‘monitoring’, there is a difference in how the two levels tended to allow for the listener. Low intermediates tended to prioritise their awareness of the impact of their talk on the listener, reducing their attention to language; in contrast advanced speakers used a far wider array of strategies for generating and monitoring the quality of their language, with the listener as a motivation for additional attention to accuracy.
Listener sensitivity and prioritization of communication • Organising the content in listener-sensitive ways. • Coming up with simple vocabulary or approximation good enough to ensure listener comprehension.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
172
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
Focusing away from language, keeping it simple. Reluctance to self-correct on-line, pressure to keep going. Slowing down during performance. Thinking of grammar that is essential for listener’s understanding.
Explicit focus on form during planning • Cross-language monitoring, translation, using meta-cognitive knowledge of self as learner, using meta-linguistic knowledge, attending to grammar of low communicative value.
In other words, it appears that in terms of attention to language, advanced learners were able to use planning time more constructively because they had more expertise to draw on, rehearsed more and had a wider range of strategies to draw on. Low intermediate learners focused more on retrieving what they knew (notably vocabulary) and reducing risks during performance, while occasionally seeking out grammatical features likely to be essential for listeners.
Summary of findings 1. Centrality of retrieval and rehearsal operations; attention to form through retrieval, monitoring and rehearsal. 2. Perceptions moderated by: • Individual differences, guiding effort in terms of what students view as important – communication or accuracy. • Differences in expertise: retrieval strategies of low-intermediate speakers leading to greater lexical complexity, balance of retrieval, rehearsal and selfmonitoring, leading to greater accuracy. 3. Presence of listener, leading to prioritising communication, deterring some ‘from engaging in propositional, lexical and/or syntactic complexity and … self-corrections’, but also leading ‘to a heightened process of meaning-form mapping by priming some learners to attend to certain aspects of grammar that were perceived as essential for the listener’s understanding’.
8.6.2
Discussion
Clearly, Ortega’s study is not particularly close to the ecology of classroom teaching: the design was experimental, involving students in nonclassroom-based pair-work; and the procedures involved more intensive debriefing than teachers would normally be able to conduct in the context of a regular programme. The study seems not to start from a particular theoretical background, and of the various studies reported in this
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
• • • •
173
Tasks in Second Language Learning
chapter, this one strikingly lacks any research questions. On the other hand, it has some rare virtues. One is that it is unique in the current literature in exploring in depth the perceptions and beliefs of students about a task-based procedure which they have just experienced. This is an informative line of enquiry, and provided it is conducted rigorously and impartially, as clearly Ortega’s study does, will generate crucial information for the future use of tasks. A second refreshing aspect of this study is the intuitively real-life complexity of the array of information generated. In this respect, the study is a challenge to the researcher not only to gather the data, but also to unpick the various strands of information in a careful and sensitive way. This is another important contribution of Ortega’s study. It is also worth noting the way in which she adopts a careful, ‘iterative’ exploratory approach to the analysis of her data, involving what she calls ‘a two-pronged approach’ combining, on the one hand, ‘content analysis of emergent themes and [on the other hand] application of a priori categories’ (2005: 83). It is unusual for researchers deliberately to combine the use of prior theoretical analytical categories with categories emerging from the particular data set, and particularly starting from a theoretically informed experimental study. Finally, an important strength is the way the closing discussion links back to one of the enduring major controversies in the field – the tension for learners between focusing on form or on meaning during communicative language use. Ortega’s data suggest that the question may be resolved in terms of relative levels of proficiency: for low proficiency learners this may well be a tension that needs careful management; however, more advanced learners may have the capacity to integrate the two. Overall, Ortega’s study illustrates how talking to learners may provide a wealth of valuable information for developing the field.
8.7 8.7.1
Skehan and Foster The study
This study brings us back to a focus on performance effects. Like Yuan and Ellis, Skehan and Foster (1999) aim to understand how communicative processing demands can affect learners’ attention to language. This study focuses on the relationship between the internal structure of tasks, their processing load and learners’ fluency, accuracy and complexity. Theoretical motivation Basic assumptions: communication is a complex activity, placing three distinct types of demand on learners’ language production: fluency,
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
174
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
175
accuracy and complexity. Each needs to be developed, but each requires different types of attention.
Fluency
the capacity to use language in real time, and emphasise meanings, possibly drawing on more lexicalised systems
Accuracy
the ability to avoid error in performance, possibly reflecting higher levels of control in the language, as well as a conservative orientation, that is, avoidance of challenging structure that might provoke error
Complexity
the capacity to use more advanced language, with the possibility that such language may not be controlled as effectively. This may also involve a greater willingness to take risks and use fewer controlled language subsystems. This area is also taken to correlate with a greater likelihood of restructuring, that is, change and development in the interlanguage system
The learner’s problem: attention capacity is limited; so during communication learners lack the means to attend to all three demands simultaneously. They therefore tend to prioritise them differently, according to individual preference. Over-emphasis on one is likely to lead to skewed language development. The dangers of over-emphasis of each language processing demand
• •
•
Consistent prioritisation of fluency may lead to over-lexicalised performance, and performance in which fossilised language is difficult to change. Consistent prioritisation of accuracy might lead to lack of fluency and avoidance of engagement with cutting-edge language, presumably as well as under-lexicalisation. Consistent prioritisation of complexity might lead to a wide range of structures but a failure to move toward accuracy and control.
So, given that communication is a prime context for language development, the authors are interested in exploring whether tasks can be used deliberately to promote fluency, accuracy and complexity. The study focuses on whether the internal structure and the processing load of a task might influence learners’ fluency, accuracy and complexity: tasks with clearly structured content may be less linguistically demanding than one with relatively unstructured content. Processing load may have similar general effects.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Skehan and Foster’s definition of the language processing demands
176
Tasks in Second Language Learning
The main pedagogical motivation is its potential use to teachers and designers. Finding ways in which task structure and processing conditions can affect students’ language could help task designers to exploit the parameters in materials they write, and could enable teachers to adjust the difficulty of tasks.
Aims and hypotheses The purpose of the present research is twofold: to explore how performance of a task can be affected by the degree of inherent structure within the task, and to explore how different processing conditions can influence performance. Drawing on the previous discussion [of earlier studies], four hypotheses were framed: Hypothesis 1: Tasks with a clear inherent structure will lead to more fluent performance than tasks without such clear structure. Hypothesis 2: Tasks with a clear inherent structure will lead to more accurate performance than tasks without such a clear structure. Hypothesis 3: Task structure will have no effect on the complexity of performance. Hypothesis 4: There will be an inverse relationship between the processing demands of the task conditions and the accuracy, fluency, and complexity of the language produced; that is, as the processing load decreases, complexity, accuracy, and fluency will increase. (Skehan and Foster, 1999: 102)
The tasks: rationale and choice of video material Monologic tasks: students retell a short comedy sketch shown on video. After piloting, two episodes of the TV series Mr Bean are selected because they are: a. short (around 8 minutes); b. highly visual and virtually dialogue-free (thus avoiding problems of comprehension); c. proven to be appealing to an international audience; d. easy to follow, without excessive cultural bias; e. amusing and engaging (and hence more likely that participants will enjoy re-telling).
It is worth noting that ‘task structure’ is actualised through the structuring of the content of the two narratives, rather than in the nature of the processes students have to engage.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Pedagogical motivation
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
177
1) More predictable story structure: the ‘restaurant’ episode ‘In this “restaurant” episode, Mr Bean goes alone to a restaurant, gets the menu, orders steak tartare, is served, and then spends some time desperately trying to hide the food (which he thinks is too disgusting to eat) in various places on and around the table. There is thus a predictable basic sequence to the narrative ... against which less predictable events are embroidered’ (1999: 103). 2) Less predictable story structure: the ‘golf’ episode ‘In this “golf” episode, Mr Bean is playing Crazy Golf and makes a very bad shot, hitting the ball outside the Crazy Golf area. At the outset, he was warned by the course owner that it is against the rules to touch the ball, and as a result of overzealously applying this rule, he hits the ball all over the town in a desperate effort to get the ball back on the course and into the hole. Inadvertently, the ball is hit onto a bus, into a shop, into a manhole, and so forth, with the problem being in each case how to retrieve it. The events have no predictable sequence and appear as a random series’ (1999: 103–4).
Four processing conditions Table 8.12 Condition
Description
Rationale
1 Watch and tell simultaneously
Participants shown the video and asked to describe the story as they watched.
Predicted to be the most cognitively demanding, because participants had to put words to an unknown story in real time.
2 Storyline given, watch and tell simultaneously
Participants briefly told the outline of the story before seeing the video, and then asked to describe the story while watching it.
3 Watch first, then watch and tell simultaneously
Participants allowed to watch the video first and then described the story as they watched it again.
Predicted to ease the processing burden somewhat by provision of prior knowledge. However, the outline necessarily only gave partial information and the real-time performance would have to deal with the considerable detail of the actual story. Predicted to ease the processing load further because participants had full knowledge of what they were about to describe, both in terms of general story outline and the more detailed elements. (Continued )
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
The two episodes
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Table 8.12
(Continued)
Condition
Description
Rationale
4 Watch first, then tell
Participants watched the video, and afterwards retold the story in their own time.
Predicted to be the least cognitively demanding. Participants had knowledge of the story they had to tell and no time pressure. Although there was a memory element involved, there was much greater scope for control.
Combining each of the four conditions with each of the two stories produced eight combinations. Participants and procedures Forty-seven students of English as a foreign language from a range of L1 backgrounds at a British university, selected from six intermediate-level classes, to which they had been allocated following a standard internal placement test. (In fact, the authors report that a total of only 45 students were involved.) They were judged to have ‘a broadly similar level of proficiency’. Participants randomly assigned to re-tell one of the two episodes under one of the four conditions (suggesting seven conditions had six students each, and one condition had five). Participants were recorded individually. Before starting, the nature of ‘steak tartare’ and the rule of not touching the golf ball were explained to the participants.
Relevant to the broader context of our discussion, in terms of ecological context, the activities being researched were not part of a normal programme, and were not carried out in normal classroom conditions.
Data analysis Complexity: analysed in terms of number of clauses per c-unit. (C-units are ‘a simple clause or an independent sub clausal unit, together with the subordinated clauses associated with them’.) Minimum value for this score is stated as 1.00, since every c-unit contains only one clause. Accuracy: assessed in terms of the number of error-free clauses, as a percentage of the total number of clauses (implying that non-clausal elements were not included). Fluency: analysed in terms of number of repetitions (immediate and verbatim), false starts (incomplete utterances), reformulations (repetition of clauses or phrases with
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
178
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
179
Like all measures these are open to discussion, but we will limit ourselves to three comments. Regarding c-units, if these include phrases like ‘yes’, ‘no’, ‘on the left’, the minimum value could presumably dip below 1.00. The accuracy measure seems to leave out of consideration errors in non-clausal units (which in monologue may not matter). The authors ultimately selected false starts as their preferred measures, on the grounds that this correlated best with the other measures. Results Presentation of results: First, descriptive statistics (means and standard deviations) are shown, comparing performance on the two video stories, and on the four conditions. Tables then present ANOVA results, followed by a comparison of the accuracy results, by story and condition.
Table 8.13
Results: Task structure Golf task (n 21)
Variable
False starts Complexity Accuracy
Table 8.14 Variable
False starts Complexity Accuracy
Restaurant task (n 24)
M
SD
M
SD
29.5 1.32 47
16.2 0.18 14
15.5 1.32 50
8.1 0.22 15
Results: Mean fluency, complexity and accuracy scores Watch and (n 11)
Storyline, watch and tell (n 12)
Watch, watch and tell (n 12)
Watch, then tell (n 11)
M
SD
M
SD
M
SD
M
SD
24.30 1.25 41
12.80 0.13 16
19.10 1.28 52
8.50 0.16 13
19.30 1.25 47
14.00 0.09 9
26.30 1.54 54
21.00 0.26 18
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
some modification) and replacements (word substitutions). Pauses were not used because in the first three conditions ‘pausing is more likely to be a reflection of the need to keep pace with the story as it unfolds’. The authors assess means and standard deviations of the different measures, and select one for statistical treatment.
180
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Fluency scores: despite differences between the means, SDs are fairly high (up to 50 per cent or more of the mean), suggesting a lack of systematic patterning for fluency. Complexity scores: although means are small (1–2 clauses per c-unit), SDs are tiny, so that a difference between any of the means may be systematic. In fact, the fourth mean is the only one to stand out from the rest. Accuracy scores: vary between 41 and 54. However, three of the SDs come from 25–33 per cent of the means, hence the differences between the means may not be ‘systematic’. ANOVA tests are then run on the three measures, in relation to the two sets of independent variables (stories, and conditions), and any interactions between them. Table 8.15
Two-way ANOVAs for false starts, accuracy and complexity
Source of variance
F
Significance of F
False starts Task Condition Two-way interaction
12.48 0.74 0.24
.001* .530 .870
Complexity Task Condition Two-way interaction
0.23 8.76 1.27
.640 .001* .300
Accuracy Task Condition Two-way interaction
0.91 2.11 3.2
.340 .120 .030*
NB: alpha levels at .05, so that p scores below .05 are judged to be statistically significant, i.e. are not chance patterns, so thought to be reasonably attributable to the conditions.
The significant results here suggest that: • story affects fluency (restaurant task is associated with more fluency); • processing condition affects complexity (‘watch then tell’ more complex);
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Results for task structure suggest that the story structure may have influenced fluency, but not complexity or accuracy. The authors then compare mean fluency, complexity and accuracy scores across the four conditions.
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
181
• accuracy – there is an interaction – i.e. accuracy is affected differentially on the two story types under one or more type of processing conditions. Mean accuracy scores by task and condition
Variable
Watch and tell
Storyline, watch and tell
Watch, watch and tell
Watch, then tell
Accuracy
.40
.56
.49
.40
.42
.47
.45
.64
Note: Pairs of scores are for the unstructured and structured stories respectively.
Table 8.16 shows how accuracy is influenced by ‘task’ and ‘condition’. For condition 1 there is little difference; for conditions 2 and 3, the unstructured story is performed more accurately than the structured one, but in condition 4 this is reversed – here the structured story is performed more accurately. 8.7.2
Interpretation
The authors interpret the results to show that: • structuring has an overall (main) impact on fluency, but not on complexity or on accuracy; • processing conditions have an overall impact on complexity, the fourth, ‘watch, then tell’, condition generating significantly more complexity than the others; • accuracy is influenced by both condition and story structure, the ‘watch, then tell’ condition being the only one to result in significantly more accurate talk on the structured story. Structuring is seen as making it easier for speakers to produce their talk smoothly. Complexity seems to be most strongly influenced by the ‘watch, then tell’ condition, giving rise to more complex talk than the other three. This may be because the other three conditions all require the speakers to speak while watching, setting a time pressure which perhaps makes more complex talk difficult. Accuracy seems unaffected by structuring or condition alone. For some reason it is the unstructured task that generates generally more accurate talk in all except the ‘watch, then tell’ condition, in which more accurate talk occurs on the structured task. This is not easily explained.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Table 8.16
8.7.3
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Discussion
Skehan and Foster are rare to have undertaken a sustained sequence of studies on the same topic. Furthermore, in doing so they have gradually expanded what is intuitively a theoretically and pedagogically interesting framework, and have used a mixture of theory-driven and post hoc thinking around their data. Bringing complexity, accuracy and fluency together reminds us that language is not simply content, but also has to be performed. The study, however, prompts a number of thoughts. • Structuring in stories: Some readers would have welcomed more discussion of the nature of structuring in stories, how it can impact on talk and the pedagogical relevance of structuring for different task types. An issue related to this is that the variable represented by the tasks (structuring) may not be what actually affects the learners’ performance: they could have been influenced by some other aspect of the film (the humour, or some distracting aspect of one of the stories). We do not know for sure in this design that the target variable (structuring) is the one that mattered. • Content familiarity: related to this is that in their background section, the authors refer to the notion of ‘content familiarity’ as the focus of studies by Ellis (1987) and Bygate (1996). However, those studies focused on the impact of having already formulated the content during a previous task on students’ subsequent performance. This type of familiarity is almost certainly different from the relative familiarity of the two story settings which they are studying here. • Choice of measures: how far is it pedagogically useful to conceptualise fluency in terms of false starts? (In Skehan and Foster (2005) the authors review a wide range of fluency measures.) The definition of accuracy could be reformulated to extend beyond the limits of grammatical error, to include discourse features and conceptual aspects (such as pragmatic or semantic appropriacy), or pronunciation; and complexity/range could be extended to cover aspects of morphology, collocation, pragmatics and discourse structures. • Interpreting the measures: one point here is to question the seemingly negative interpretation of accuracy as implying ‘avoidance’ of challenging structures and ‘conservatism’; and attention to complexity as implying a willingness to take risks, use of fewer controlled subsystems and a greater probability that learners will restructure their knowledge. Presumably, a focus on accuracy could be associated with mastery of new language (for instance we may wish to adjust the accuracy of language we have roughly acquired by attending to our own and others’
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
182
183
language), while risk-taking, which Skehan and Foster see positively, could be little more than random recklessness. • Pedagogical relevance: We cannot take for granted the pedagogical importance of the scores of relative accuracy, complexity and fluency. On the surface, the results suggest interestingly different effects on learners’ processing. Below the surface, we have the problem of knowing what levels of complexity, accuracy or fluency are significant for classroom learning, and over what time-scale. In practical terms we also need to understand more about the kinds of relationship that exist between condition and performance. For instance, the impact of high task demand is unlikely to be entirely linear since we are all likely to respond variously to excessively high or low loads by reducing or increasing our levels of performance (see Levelt, 1978, on the varying impacts of high and low task demand). Although these are problems, they are interesting ones. Furthermore, they illustrate how confronting initial hypotheses with actual data, and attempting to understand the data is a powerful way of refining one’s thinking.
8.8 8.8.1
Lynch and Maclean The study
This study (Lynch and Maclean, 2001) is one of two which the authors published (see also Lynch and Maclean, 2000), focusing on the language of different students working on a given task. Like Samuda’s (see 8.1), this is a case study of a scheduled lesson. It explores potentially significant changes in students’ language in relation to ‘task repetition’. 8.8.2
Rationale
The aim was to examine a theoretical proposal (see Bygate, 1996, 2001) that repeating their discourse on different occasions leads learners to develop aspects of their talk. The reasoning is that having already attempted the task, students will be more familiar with its content, forms and pragmatic potential, and that this will affect their use of vocabulary, grammar, pronunciation and their discourse as a whole. Bygate’s studies involved repetition of the task two days and ten weeks later respectively, with the students asked to re-tell their stories without prior warning. Complexity and fluency were greater when students were repeating precisely the same task. In contrast, Lynch and Maclean designed a task which required learners to re-run the same material with different interlocutors.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
184
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Aims In light of previous experience of using task repetition: a) as researchers, to explore the theory that students would improve aspects of their performance through repeated engagements with the material; b) as teachers, to see how their learners worked with the task; c) as materials designers, to explore how their material worked in practice.
Participants and setting • A short course in English for use at international conferences, University of Edinburgh;
• Fourteen doctors from six countries, in their late twenties-mid-fifties, of different levels of proficiency;
• Focus on three students, with the following level on an in-house test:
Listening Grammar TOEFL equivalent
Susanna
Olga
Carla
36% 12% 450
71% 36% 525
74% 44% 525
Task design and implementation Out-of-class preparation: in pairs students summarise a medical research article (800–1,000 words) and represent it in poster form. In class: Pairs display their posters. Student A stays at poster to answer questions from visitors; student B visits the others posters in turn, having about three minutes to ask questions of each student A. After student B has seen the full display, the pairs change roles. Closing plenary discussion, the teacher giving general language feedback. Aspects of task: Substantial reading input; planning focuses on preparing the poster, rather than on talk; no guidance given on procedures to follow; no rehearsal time; repetition is: dialogic, immediate (at three-minute intervals), and – since different visitors raise different points – involves ‘recycling’ rather than strict repetition.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Hence this study implemented repetition in a pedagogically convincing way, and did so within a single lesson.
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
185
Data Six conversations of three student A’s with each of their six visiting students. Students’ self-report questionnaire on their experience, prior to teachers’ comments.
Analysis The talk analysed for changes across the six recordings in terms of: • • • • • •
phonological accuracy; syntactic accuracy; choice of vocabulary and expression; self-correction; fluency, as reflected in the amount of pausing, rephrasing and repetition; other features reported when considered significant.
Results (represented in the report in the form of extensive extracts from speakers, with key parts underlined). Susanna
Olga
Carla
Changes in phonology: ‘survival’ cycles 1, 2, 3, 6, with errors at cycle 2.
Changes in syntax: ‘the excluding three hundred twenty two woman’ (cycle 1) ‘the excluding of this number of women’ (cycle 2) ‘this exclusion of these patients’ (cycle 3)
Changes in fluency: ‘I think mastectomy probably versus less extensive tumourectomy and segmentectomy and things like that’ (cycle 1)
Changes in syntax: ‘I think so’ cycles 1, 6 ‘I think that...’ cycles 2, 5 ‘I think Ø clause’ cycles 2, 3. Changes in ease of expression (cycles 1, 4, 6): ‘All patients hadn’t uh metastatic disease’ ‘we had only patients without metastasis’ ‘we had only patients after operation and no reparation evidence of metastatic disease’
Self-correction: ‘this spare surgery’ (cycle 1) ‘spare eh sparing surgery’ (cycle 6) More precise formulation: ‘to give a local control the better rates of local control’ (cycle 1) ‘to have a local control to have a proper local control’ (cycle 4)
‘um localised uh localised tumourectomy segmentectomy or radical mastectomy’ (cycle 6) General tendencies: • to self-correct • to distance herself from the study and the authors’ views • tendency to refuse to yield her turn
General inaccuracy and hesitation
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
• •
186
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Analysis confirms findings of their 2000 study of two students. Across both studies, the students ‘selected and produced more accurate L2 forms in successive cycles. All ‘... whose conversations we have analysed improved in terms of phonology (segmental or stress) and vocabulary (access or selection); all but [one, in the 2000 study] increased the semantic precision of what they were saying; and three made improvements in syntax’ (2001: 155). The task seems to provide ‘an opportunity for different types of improvement from different learners across a wide proficiency range’.
Authors’ analysis and discussion of student feedback • •
•
•
Some participants report feeling more relaxed as the task continued. Lower level students (e.g. Susanna) report no planning or implementing changes to their talk; more advanced students report planned and/or unplanned changes (2001: 156). Hence students may benefit from activities without being aware of it; so authors propose use of post-task activities and task transcripts to help increase learners’ awareness and ability to monitor their language. Data show learners learning from each other, but since they are unaware of this, or may not take advantage of the opportunity (e.g. Carla), it may be worth helping ‘learners to appreciate what they stand to gain from conversations with other learners’ (2001: 158). Repeating tasks with different partners may well provide a kind of interactive environment which can help push learners forward: ‘successive cycles of classroom activity under varied conditions may have an important part to play in proceduralisation of the L2’ (2001: 158–9).
8.8.3
Discussion
This is one of the rare studies – possibly unique in the field – able to make general claims about the talk of a group, while respecting the individuality of each student’s development. Generalisations about the power of task repetition can be extrapolated from a series of careful case studies: that is, the case studies can be aggregated into the strength of a group study. A further point to notes is that, as with the Samuda study, Lynch and Maclean bring together the two concerns of teaching (through its study of design and pedagogy) on the one hand, and learning (with their close attention to what the learners do) on the other. In addition, learners’ questionnaire responses enable them to make tentative connections between awareness and level of proficiency, and to consider pedagogical implications of the students’ lack of awareness of processes they engage in. Hence as with Samuda, this study demonstrates clear connections between materials design, teacher implementation and language
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Authors’ conclusions on transcript analysis
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
187
8.9
Summary and conclusion
The eight studies examined in this chapter used a range of types of methodology and worked in distinct paradigms. In Chapters 6 and 7, we drew attention to the potential scope for research into language learning tasks. We highlighted: task design; task selection; conditions of task implementation; teacher exploitation; language production in terms of: language content and language processing; language development; teachers’ perceptions; learners’ perceptions; teacher development. However these topics are addressed at best inconsistently by the studies that we have reviewed in this chapter, and we will return to examine the potential for further research into these topics in Chapter 10. In the introduction to this chapter we noted three themes that recur through the studies: the choice between experimental and case study designs; the value of comparative and longitudinal studies; and the value of pedagogically and non-pedagogically situated research. The choice between a case study and an experimental design It is worth considering the implications of this distinction. A key element of a case study is the opportunity it offers to study the individual cases in their own terms. In contrast, an experimental design is typically structured around the hunch that there may be similarities in people’s behaviours in given contexts. Case studies are therefore widely seen as tending to derive their categories and constructs from within, while experimental studies are commonly thought of as testing assumptions derived from outside the context of study. However, our sample shows that this distinction is inaccurate. For example, Samuda’s study is based on the idea that a task can be used to focus learners’ attention on a language feature. It also assumes that doing so will help most learners in the class, and that this can be demonstrated by comparing the marks for accuracy on pre- and post-tests. Lynch and Maclean’s case study also works from externally derived beliefs. One is that communicative repetition will tend to promote changes in accuracy in most learners; another is the belief that the design of a task will have a similar impact
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
learning theory: the issues are simultaneously of both theoretical and practical interest. However, it should be noted that the lack of a pre-/posttest comparison makes impossible any claims about systemic changes in learners’ proficiency. Also, as with the three preceding studies, this one does not address the problem of targeting particular features of language.
Tasks in Second Language Learning
on different learners. Yet Lynch and Maclean also demonstrate that it is possible to study data case by case in order to explore general patterns across a series of cases (here, patterns of changes in accuracy through repeated encounters with a task). Ortega too, while investigating individual students’ perceptions of pre-task planning, one at a time, works with a number of external categories, notably borrowed from Oxford’s ‘strategy inventory’. Yet she also derives categories from the interviewees themselves. This enables two kinds of generalisation: a detailed check on the extent to which Oxford’s strategy inventory works for individual cases (a form of validation); and, as with Lynch and Maclean’s study, the opportunity to generalise across her two proficiency groups, working from the individual statements of her participants.
Ortega’s use of a priori and emergent categories This takes the form of a ‘two-pronged attack including content analysis of emergent themes and application of a priori categories . . . evolved over three recursive phases’ (2005: 83).
In other words, case studies can have both an exploratory orientation and a verificatory (or hypothesis-testing) function. At the same time, case studies offer the opportunity to study the internal logic of the processes of the event (as in Samuda, and Lynch and Maclean), and the rationale of the various participants through the conduct of interviews (such as those in Lynch and Maclean, and Ortega). The limitation of case studies is that their isolation impedes generalisation and broader validation. Here, though, the word ‘isolation’ is important: as Lynch and Maclean’s study shows, an accumulation of case studies around a similar focus would be no impediment to development and testing of generalisations. In contrast, experimental studies start precisely from an interest in developing or testing generalisations. This is not unreasonable, given that teachers and testers have to generalise – for instance, about what is and is not likely to work for their students, and how and why. Indeed, it is not unreasonable, given the pervasive evidence that language use is highly patterned at all levels, and that learning also is patterned. Hence Mackey, Skehan and Foster, Yuan and Ellis, and Yule and Macdonald all use their studies to explore the hunch that there is an association between certain conditions and patterns of behaviour. Their conclusions are inferential: assuming the soundness of the design, they implicitly argue that we are entitled to attribute the patterning of the results to the
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
188
189
condition and to some hypothetical intervening human process. That is, their argument is based on the probability that on future occasions, given the same conditions, different people are likely to behave in the same way. There is a double justification to this kind of approach: the research findings permit generalisation to other people in other contexts, and at the same time they contribute to the development of our understanding. In addition, the field is young and grounded results are few – hence it may be that, hitherto, research was more likely to be supported if informed by some externally acknowledged theory. It can be argued though that after carrying out experimental studies like these, we still do not know the significance of such patterns within the context of the language learning of an individual or a group over time, within normal lessons. That is, although these studies are hypothesis-testing, in terms of educational practice, they remain exploratory. This is no bad thing – indeed several experimental researchers use exploratory statistical analyses to study unsuspected patterning within the data, assuming that subsequent confirmatory studies will be needed. But it might be useful if the exploratory nature of these studies were recognised more often. It also has to be acknowledged that the inferential reasoning used by such studies often tends to jump over a lack of information about the detailed real-time individual classroom processes and uses of language needed to reach the macro-results that the studies yield. The problem then is how to obtain information about probabilities and the micro-events of realtime classroom learning, rather than where to generate the hypotheses and categories of analyses. The second issue raised by the eight studies is the presence or absence of a longitudinal (or at least pre-post) time dimension. Although this is a fairly obvious consideration in pedagogical research, few studies address it. Of the eight, only Mackey’s ran over a period of three weeks, and Samuda’s was the only other one to use a pre-/post-test design. This may be partly a logistical problem: time-wise studies are inevitably more time-consuming and involve more data manipulation, and as a result, can be expensive. But here too the problem may be aggravated by the relative lack of previous research: early studies were perhaps right to concentrate mainly on analysing performance data and wait until an empirical picture emerged before attempting time-wise studies. Nevertheless, pedagogically oriented research needs to inform us on the impact of task work in real time – that is, in the course of a lesson, over the period of a scheme of work and through a syllabus. Which leads us to our third issue.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
190
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Throughout this book, we have been justifying the use of tasks for language education from a holistic educational and linguistic perspective (see Chapter 1). Our grounds for adopting this position are that tasks provide a structured space for a wide range of contextualised teaching and learning processes, involving all levels of language, whether pragmatic discourse structures or the details of grammar and phonology. It is therefore axiomatic that in terms of research, the heart of our domain is the task in pedagogical action. The kinds of problem we are trying to solve through research concerns how teachers and students can use tasks, and with what effects. From this perspective, studies such as Samuda’s, Lynch and Maclean’s and Donato’s have a distinct advantage in that they all focus on the teachers’ and students’ use of the tasks in scheduled lessons. Furthermore, their case study designs enable the researcher to track classroom processes as well as outcomes. And although these studies might be seen as exploratory (compared with experimental studies), they can also be seen as hypothesis-testing or verificatory, in the sense that the results provide evidence of the extent to which the procedures work in classrooms. The choice of context offers some important advantages. First, it means that any observed learning patterns are sufficiently robust to emerge in the context of teaching procedures and purposes. Second, it makes it possible to assess any problems that might arise in terms of the extent of the match between the task and the context, rather than simply in terms of the internal attributes of the task. Third, it generates the kinds of data which are likely to be essential for professional evaluation and subsequent dissemination. Finally, although Ortega’s study is not situated in normally functioning classrooms, the fact that her investigation focuses on the learners’ own construals of the task, of the preparatory planning activity and of how they managed them, it sheds light on issues of learner engagement and learner style, which speaks forcefully to any potential pedagogical concern. There may well have been good reasons for the relative lack of classroom-based studies, similar perhaps to those adduced for the lack of longitudinal and case designs: teachers, who are probably best situated to carry out such studies, are generally not able to add this to their workload, whether in collaboration with outside researchers or, even less likely, on their own; researchers from outside the classroom are not well situated, and in any case depend on the collaboration of teachers; teachers working with researchers from outside their institution need to have a
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
The contextualisation of the research
191
basis for collaboration if the research is to work; researchers need to be willing to negotiate with teachers and with students to carry out the research, and vice versa; and the tasks being researched need to be relevant to the teacher and the class. Apart from this, we can add the numerous contingent problems (absences, holidays, schedule changes) that can arise. In a word, such research is costly and labour-intensive. But undertaking it would ensure that the focus of research meets the needs and understandings of teachers and learners. However until classroom-based studies become a mainstream for research in this field, the pedagogical use of language learning tasks will never be properly researched, and we will have to make do with whatever researchers feel motivated to explore.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task Research from a Pedagogical Perspective
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
We began this book by observing that even though tasks have been a familiar part of second language teaching for several decades – both as an element within CLT and as the centrepiece for various task-driven initiatives – their use remains highly controversial. Issues relating to when, why and how to use tasks, or indeed whether they should be used at all, continue to invite heated debate in both the research and practitioner literatures. In this chapter we attempt to tease apart issues contributing to this controversy. Our concern in Chapters 7 and 8 has been with the study of tasks: how researchers have approached the construct of ‘task’, and what elements have emerged as relevant and interesting both for the purposes of study and as outcomes of study. The issues focused on there were inevitably filtered through the perspectives of the researchers studying them; in this chapter we explore the kinds of insight that are brought into focus through the perspectives of practitioners (teachers, designers, curriculum developers) working with tasks in light of four questions: 1. How do practitioners approach the construct of ‘task’? 2. What elements of tasks emerge as relevant and interesting from a practitioner perspective? 3. What kinds of issues are brought into prominence through everyday classroom use of tasks? 4. How do these relate to topics and issues brought into prominence through task research? In this chapter we explore these questions in light of controversies about the use of tasks that have emerged in recent years. These include: • perceptions of task-based language teaching (TBLT) as a ‘top-down’ initiative (Van den Branden, 2006), imposed on teachers by researchers 192
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
9
193
with limited understanding of the demands of everyday pedagogy (Swan, 2005); • conceptual unease among teachers about the potential pedagogic value of tasks and pedagogic approaches that make significant use of tasks (Littlewood, 2007); • unrealistic demands and expectations placed on teachers in the implementation of task-based programmes of instruction (van den Branden, 2006).
9.1
Practitioner and researcher perspectives on tasks
Example 9.1 opens up a pedagogic perspective on a number of the issues raised in previous chapters. Column A presents a selection of topics pursued in the empirical studies reviewed in Chapters 7 and 8, and Column B, topics raised by teachers in on-line discussion lists at the time of writing this chapter.
Example 9.1 Issues of concern to researchers; issues of concern to teachers A: Issues pursued by researchers
B: Issues raised by teachers
• • • • • • • • •
• Using tasks in monolingual classes in FL settings • Matching tasks with skill level • Integrating tasks with a prescribed syllabus • Viability of tasks for beginning level students • Using tasks to introduce new language • Giving feedback on task performance: how and when • Fitting tasks with other kinds of activity • Tasks and grammar learning • Using tasks in mixed ability classes • Motivating students to engage in tasks
Planning time Task familiarity Task repetition Interaction effects Interlocutor effects Discourse effects Attention capacity Task complexity Negotiation for meaning
As we might expect, there are differences in the ways that teachers orient themselves to the use of tasks: the issues in Column A are framed in relation to underlying constructs that researchers have used tasks to probe (attentional capacity, processing demands, negotiation, etc.), and in Column B, in relation to specific pedagogic phenomena that teachers
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
see themselves as having to handle while using tasks (introducing new language, the role of grammar, giving feedback, etc.). This is not surprising – researchers and teachers obviously have different concerns, and as we have already seen in Chapters 7 and 8, in much of the empirical work associated with issues in Column A tasks have been viewed as a context in which to study different aspects of language use and processing rather than as a situated pedagogic instrument mediated by teachers. But as we also saw in previous chapters a substantial amount of that work has been carried out with a view to informing pedagogic decisions about task selection, sequencing and implementation, and a number of researchers associated with Column A issues would argue that aspects of their research can – or eventually could, given sufficient time – address questions raised in Column B. Thus although the orientation may be primarily towards ‘task’ as a research construct, there is an underlying assumption that task research has the potential to say something about task pedagogy – for example, ‘implications for pedagogy’ are often included among the closing sections of research reports. In contrast, from a Column B perspective, ‘task’ is viewed primarily as a pedagogic instrument (albeit a potentially problematic one), and again not surprisingly, the focus is with how that instrument could be used, integrated within broader sequences of instruction and exploited in the light of everyday classroom demands. As Column B makes clear, an orientation towards ‘task’ as a pedagogic construct brings different concerns to the fore and offers a different lens through which to view the issues raised in Column A. A key problem here is that sets of mutual relevance across the respective sets of issues may not be readily apparent. From a Column A perspective, the kinds of questions raised by practitioners in Column B can be perceived as too broad to be answerable, too local to be generalisable or simply too ‘pedagogic’ to be theoretically interesting, while from a Column B perspective, the topics pursued by researchers are not readily recognisable vis-à-vis the day-to-day demands of working with tasks in different kinds of classrooms. This contributes to the uneasy relationship between pedagogy and research noted at the end of Chapter 8, and to the perception of tasks and TBLT as a top-down initiative. From a pedagogic perspective, this relationship becomes particularly problematic when recommendations about the use of tasks are made, when curriculum guidelines are put in place or when specific procedures are advocated without apparent awareness of – or interest in – issues of everyday pedagogy. It is in this context that tasks have come to be perceived as part of an externally imposed top-down initiative.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
194
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
Tasks in pedagogy
In recent years, the use of tasks has been vigorously promoted as part of language education policy at national, state and institutional levels worldwide. Nunan (2004), Leaver and Willis (2004), Edwards and Willis (2005), Pica (2005), Littlewood (2006) and van den Branden (2006a) attest to the breadth and scope of proposals advocated in various parts of Asia, Europe and North America. However, reports of the implementation of different task-based initiatives (Tinker Sachs et al., 2000; Carless, 2004; Hampshire and Aguarales Anoro, 2004; van den Branden, 2006a; Littlewood, 2006, among others) suggest considerably more unease among practitioners working with tasks ‘on the ground’ than is generally acknowledged in the literature. Two broad factors may be feeding into this sense of unease. One is situation-specific and relates to the conditions in which certain curricular innovations involving tasks may have been implemented (or perceived to have been implemented). Later in the chapter we take a closer look at some contexts where tasks have been introduced as significant elements in state and regional curricula. The second is conceptual and relates to different perceptions of what is meant by ‘task’ and ‘task-based’ learning, and to different understandings of the pedagogic roles that tasks can play in an overall programme of instruction. Given the enormous inconsistency with which ‘task’, ‘task-based’ and their associated acronyms (TBLT, TBL, TBI) have been used, it is not surprising that many teachers charged with implementing task-based material report ‘conceptual unease’ (Littlewood, 2007) about what tasks are and what task-based teaching involves. Example 9.2 shows some of the different ways that ‘task-based’ has been used in teaching materials, curriculum proposals and teacher resource books in recent years:
Example 9.2
Different uses of the term ‘task-based’
1. To designate an approach to syllabus design driven by target tasks that learners need to engage with outside the classroom and driven by pedagogic tasks carried out within the classroom. 2. To refer to specialised classroom procedures designed to respond to elements of task performance. 3. To describe programmes of instruction in which tasks play some role, but are not necessarily the central driving force. 4. To promote textbook materials containing tasks. 5. To characterise a general style of teaching that draws on tasks. 6. To denote a genre of meaning-focused classroom interaction. Richards (2005) also has a number of examples of how ‘task-based’ has been used.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
9.2
195
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Some of these uses of ‘task-based’ are considerably more specialised than others – 1 and 2 versus 5 and 6, for example, and in Chapter 4 we suggested that one way round this problem might be to adopt a more careful use of terminology relating to the way that tasks are used. A solution offered by Bygate (2000), Ellis (2003) and Shehadeh (2005) is to distinguish between: task-based learning and teaching (to refer to contexts where tasks are the central focus for instruction); and task-supported learning and teaching (to refer to contexts where tasks may play a less central role). To explore the usefulness of this distinction, we look at ways tasks are used in task-based and task-supported contexts, and what these imply for task pedagogy.
9.2.1 Task-based language learning and teaching In Chapter 4, we outlined the key characteristics of task-based learning and teaching (TBLT) as follows: • tasks define and drive the syllabus; • task performance is a catalyst for focusing attention on form, and not vice versa; • assessment is in terms of task performance; • task selection is shaped by real-world activities of relevance to learners and their target needs; • tasks play an essential role in engaging key processes of language acquisition. Three widely cited examples are: 1. The Bangalore Communicational Teaching Project (Prabhu, 1987). 2. Task-based syllabus design (Long and Crookes, 1992; 1993). 3. A framework for the implementation of task-based learning (Willis, 1996). Although commonly grouped together as examples of task-based learning and teaching, each is quite distinct and, so in light of misunderstandings about TBLT noted above, we trace the conceptual background of each one, with samples of representative tasks and pedagogic procedures.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
196
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
197
The Bangalore Communicational Teaching Project
Example 9.3
The Bangalore Project (Prabhu, 1987)
Setting and context Initial impetus
Theoretical motivation
Selected primary and secondary schools in southern India, 1979–85 To explore alternatives to the prevailing ‘StructuralOral-Situational method’ (structurally/lexically graded syllabuses, ‘one at a time’ presentation of discrete items, extensive controlled practice) A ‘pedagogic intuition’ that the necessary requirement for second language acquisition is ‘the creation of conditions in which learners engage in an effort to cope with communication ... to the exclusion of any deliberate regulation of the development of grammatical compe tence or a mere simulation of language behaviour’ (Prabhu, 1987: 1–2)
This was not intended as a formal experiment to prove/disprove one methodology over another, but as an exploratory, classroom-based initiative within which alternative methodologies could develop and through which pedagogic insights could be explored. The pedagogic procedures that evolved were referred to as ‘task-based teaching’.
Example 9.4 procedures • • • •
•
The Bangalore Project: principal pedagogic
Task selection and sequencing on the basis of ‘reasonable challenge’ (Prabhu, 1987), not on the basis of a pre-set structurally/lexically defined syllabus. Focus on finding appropriate task solution, and not on the linguistic accuracy with which that solution might be expressed. Criterion for successful task completion: at least 50 per cent of the class with the correct solution. No pre-emptive focus on specific linguistic features at the beginning of a lesson/task sequence; use of a teacher-led ‘pre-task’ to clarify necessary concepts and rehearse task procedures. Incidental error correction within the context of communication, without interruption to the flow of meaning; teacher reformulation of error without explanation of grammatical rules/generalisations.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
The Bangalore Communicational Teaching Project (widely known as The Bangalore Project) is an early example of a task-based pedagogic initiative put into action in a specific context at a certain period of time:
198
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Lessons were built across sequences of tasks and followed a characteristic pattern, drawing on different task types:
Task 1 (pre-task)
Task 2 (task)
Outcome assessment
Example 9.6
Task performed as whole-class activity under teacher control and guidance, using a question-and-answer format to lead pupils step by step to the outcome Parallel to pre-task, performed by pupils independently, sometimes collaboratively, seeking help from teacher as necessary Carried out by the teacher, based on content, not language; to give pupils feedback on degree of success in solving the problem posed by the task, and to provide teacher with input for task selection and planning for subsequent lessons.
The Bangalore Project: task types
Information gap* Involving transfer of given information from one form to another Reasoning gap Involving processes of deduction/inferencing to derive new information from some form of given information Opinion gap Involving identification/articulation of personal preferences, attitudes and/or responses to given information *Since pair and group work were de-emphasised, ‘gap’ refers here to the nature of the cognitive challenge posed by the task, not to the collaborative ‘gap principle’ associated with CLT (e.g. Johnson, 1979).
Over time, through a process of trial and error, ‘reasoning tasks’ based on diagrams, calendars, timetables, itineraries, maps, distances, etc. were found to be most successful in sustaining pupils’ engagement with meaning
Example 9.7
The Bangalore Project: sample task
Pre-task: The teacher asks questions about a railway timetable written on the blackboard:
Brindavan Express
Madras
Katpedi
Jolarpet
Bangalore
Dep. 0725
Arr. 0915 Dep. 0920
Arr. 1028 Dep. 1030
Arr. 1300
Some example questions: • When does the Brindavan Express leave Madras/arrive in Bangalore? • How long does it stop at Jolarpet? • How many stations does it stop at on the way?
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Example 9.5 The Bangalore Project: components of a taskbased lesson
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
Example 9.7
199
(Continued)
Bangalore Mail
Madras
Arkonam
Katpedi
Jolarpet
Kolar
Bangalore
Dep. 2140
Arr. 2250 Dep. 2305
Arr. 0005 Dep. 0015
Arr. 0155 Dep. 0210
Arr. 0340 Dep. 0350
Arr. 0550
Some example questions: When does the Bangalore Mail leave Madras? At what time does it reach Katpedi? How long does it take to go from Kolar to Bangalore?
at an appropriate level of cognitive challenge. An example – the second in a sequence of five reasoning tasks on the topic of ‘railway timetables’ – is illustrated in Example 9.7 above. Three key characteristics of the project are reflected in this example task: 1. a parallel increase in cognitive demand (i.e. degree of reasoning involved) within and across the pre-task and task (and, although not shown here, across sequences of tasks); 2. the language to be used in carrying out the task was not specified in the materials, but was to be negotiated in the classroom on the basis of teacher perception of pupil need/capacity and the intellectual challenge of the task; 3. success in task completion was marked by correctness of solution, not linguistic accuracy. A rough rule of thumb – 50 per cent of class with the correct answer – was used as the criterion for moving on to the next task. The project was evaluated in different ways over a five-year span, as shown in Example 9.8.
Example 9.8
Evaluation of the Bangalore Project
Process evaluation
Developments documented, discussed and evaluated on an ongoing basis via: • classroom observation • regular newsletter bulletins • review seminars with visiting specialists • used as feedback for ongoing project development.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Task: Pupils work independently on following timetable and questions, with initial teacher guidance as necessary
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 9.8
(Continued)
Product evaluation
• Battery of proficiency and achievement tests administered to classes participating in the project and a control group • tentative support for the project claim that ‘grammar construction can take place through a focus on meaning alone’ (Beretta and Davis, 1985) (although some qualification as to the validity of the instruments of assessment deployed are also noted).
A number of issues, both theoretical and practical, were brought into focus during the running of the project and were subject to considerable question and critique at the time and subsequently (e.g. Greenwood, 1985; Brumfit, 1984a). Some of the controversies to have surfaced are summarised here in Example 9.9.
Example 9.9 The Bangalore Project: Elements of the project brought into question • •
• •
The extent to which the pre-task was a ‘rehearsal’ for the task as intended or in fact comprised a form of covert teaching (see Prabhu, 1987, for a rebuttal). The extent to which the success of the project was carried by the enthusiasm and commitment of team members and participating teachers rather than the pedagogic procedures themselves (see Prabhu, 1987). The adequacy of ‘rule of thumb’ approaches to assessing task difficulty (Crookes and Long, 1993). Reliance on a narrow range of teacher-led, externally set problems, and a de-emphasis of open-ended, collaborative pair/group work (but see Prabhu, 1987, for an account of how these were conceived as local adaptations, and considered essential to operability in the context of southern India at the time).
Despite its limited time-span and specificity of setting, the Bangalore Project is still of considerable interest as an example of task-based principles in action. The conditions under which it was implemented – large classes, minimal resources beyond blackboard and chalk – and its radical commitment to a meaning-focused approach that went against prevailing cultural expectations of language teaching practices – also make it an interesting example of what can be achieved in so-called difficult circumstances (see also Coleman, 1987) in non-Western settings. However, the
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
200
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
201
Task-based syllabus design (Long and Crookes, 1992, 1993) The second example – also widely cited as an example of task-based learning principles – is an approach to syllabus design/programme development in which ‘task’ is taken as the key unit of analysis at every phase of the process. The theoretical perspective and principles underlying it are closely associated with proposals developed in Long (1985, 1989; 1996), Long and Crookes (1992, 1993) and Long and Robinson (1998). In contrast to the Bangalore Project, which was initially driven by pedagogic intuition and evolved through pedagogic practice, Long and colleagues make the case for a psycho-linguistically grounded approach to task-based syllabus design compatible with evidence from SLA research, particularly the body of work associated with the interaction hypothesis, and negotiation for meaning studies. (See Chapters 7 and 8.) Long and Crookes (1992, 1993) characterise the procedure for taskbased syllabus design and development as a series of steps. Central to the whole procedure is an analysis of learner needs to identify real-world ‘target tasks’. On the basis of these, appropriate ‘pedagogic tasks’ are selected/developed for classroom use. Initially less complex in focus and scope, pedagogic tasks are designed to increasingly approximate the kinds of demands ultimately made by target tasks. The overall design sequence is set out in Example 9.10.
Example 9.10 Steps in the design and development of a task-based syllabus • • • • • • • •
A comprehensive needs analysis → Diagnosis of learner needs → Identification of target tasks learners are preparing to carry out ⫹ real-world performance criteria → Classification of target tasks into task types → Development/selection of pedagogic tasks for classroom use → Sequencing of pedagogic tasks to form a task-based syllabus → Implementation of syllabus via appropriate pedagogic procedures → Assessment through performance on tasks/task-based criterion referenced tests
(after Long and Crookes, 1992, 1993)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
significance of the Bangalore Project is not just that it is an early example of TBLT, it is also one of the few examples of a systematic (though relatively short-lived) attempt to develop and explore task-based procedures in real classroom contexts and to seek different types of empirical evidence as to how they play out over time – an issue we take up again below.
202
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 9.11 General pedagogic principles for enacting a task-based syllabus • • •
Elements of linguistic form are not pre-specified in the syllabus or at the beginning of a lesson Pedagogic tasks are not ‘seeded’ with pre-selected linguistic features, nor are they designed to target particular elements of form Attention to form emerges out of task performance on the basis of problems occurring in the context of meaningful communication. These may be identified (and resolved) by learners themselves during the task, and/or by the teacher after it has been carried out.
(after Long and Crookes, 1992, 1993)
Example 9.12 is a set of thematically linked tasks proposed in Long (1997) as a means of enacting a task-based syllabus, as an illustration of how a task-based syllabus could be realised.
Example 9.12 syllabus
Sample task sequence within a task-based
An instructional sequence for a ‘false beginner’ class of young, adult, prospective tourists: •
• •
Intensive listening practice: The task is to identify which of 40 telephone requests for reservations can be met, and which not, by looking at four charts showing the availability, dates and cost of hotel rooms, theatre and plane seats, and tables at a restaurant. Role-playing: The learners take the role of customers and airline reservation clerks in situations in which the airline seats required are available. Role-playing: The learners take roles in situations in which, due to unavailability, they must choose among progressively more complicated alternatives (seats in different sections of the plane, at different prices, on different flights or dates, via different routes, etc.).
(Long, 1997)
A number of characteristics from Long and Crookes’ original proposal are present in this task sequence:
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Learners’ ultimate real-world needs are thus taken as the sine qua non of language instruction, and tasks are the pedagogic conduit for addressing those needs. Key pedagogic principles for implementing the syllabus are shown in Example 9.11.
203
• task content reflects learners’ target needs in carrying out real-world tasks (here, making tourist reservations); • tasks are sequenced in terms of complexity of demand placed on learners as they carry them out; • specific design details, for example, ways of fleshing out the above guidelines as fully developed tasks that would be operable in normal classroom conditions and consonant with relevant empirical findings, may be left open for the individual programme developer/teacher to carry forward in light of local/contexts; • the use of role play to simulate real-time demands within the target domain. Central to this perspective on task-based learning then is an interplay between two elements of the syllabus: one that is determined by realworld target need (a key characteristic of LSP programme development from the 1970s onward, as Long and Crookes observe), and another that is emergent, shaped by the needs of learners as they engage with meaning-focused pedagogic tasks (also a characteristic of the ‘deep-end’ approach’ to CLT proposed in Brumfit, 1978, 1984b). However, a distinctive plank in the Long and Crookes proposal (and one also strongly argued in e.g. Long and Robinson, 1998; Long, 2005; Robinson, 2006) is that decisions about the selection of sequencing of pedagogic tasks should be compatible with, and underpinned by, evidence from current SLA research. Various aspects of Long and Crookes’s approach to task-based syllabus design have given rise to controversy. Some of this has focused on the theoretical underpinnings on which the work rests and the appropriacy of variables selected for study as we saw in Chapter 7. Issues more directly related to classroom pedagogy have been raised in Sheen, 1994; Bruton, 2002a and b; Swan, 2005, and these include concerns about: • the overall workability of this approach to TBLT on a day-to-day basis over time; • a lack of widely disseminated evidence from fully-fledged applications of the proposal in action (in the sense intended by Long and Crookes), and consequently little documented evidence to date of full-scale programme evaluations; • the adequacy of current research findings for sustaining informed decisions about task design, selection and sequencing over extended periods of instruction and for guiding decisions about the timing of teacher interventions.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
204
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Framework for task-based learning (Willis, 1996) Willis (1996) offers a framework for task implementation at the level of the lesson/suite of lessons. As with our previous examples, it is presented as an explicit alternative to pedagogic progressions that isolate discrete elements of form and gradually build up opportunities to integrate them through controlled practice and free production (characterised by Willis in terms of the ‘P, P, P’ sequence). The framework, which grew out of the author’s experience as a teacher educator, is based on a three-phase task cycle consisting of pre-, during and post-task stages, spanning a lesson/ sequence of lessons:
Example 9.13 Willis, 1996
A framework for task-based learning:
•
Pre-task – Teacher introduces topic and task Task cycle • Task – Students carry out the task • Planning – Students plan how to report on task outcome • Report – Students report back to class • Language focus – Analysis – Practice (– Students may repeat same or similar task) (based on Willis, 1996)
Central to this cycle is the positioning of the ‘language focus’ as a posttask activity arising out of task performance. Willis summarises this from a learner’s perspective as: ‘First experience the target language in use and then examine the language you have used and learn from it’ (Willis, 2004: 35). A recurrent element in some task-based materials (e.g. Willis and Willis, 1988) is to begin the cycle with learners observing native speakers perform a task (e.g. giving instructions on a map) that they will later attempt to carry out themselves. This, it is argued, orients learners
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
To this extent, the critics argue, the full scope of the approach to taskbased learning associated with Long and Crookes’s proposal for syllabus design and development remains hard to assess in light of real-world pedagogic demands.
205
to the kinds of task-based language use that they will be engaging with themselves, and also provides baseline data that could be useful for guiding teacher interventions during the language focus stage. To this end, Willis also makes a case for the use of ‘pedagogic corpora’ based on performance on the same or similar tasks as those to be used in the classroom (Willis, 2004). Throughout her work, Willis provides numerous task exemplars, sample lesson plans and practical tips for managing each phase of the cycle for different pedagogic purposes. An example based on a reading task used as an illustration in Willis (1996) is summarised in Example 9.14 and gives a flavour of the level of support and degree of micro-planning offered to help a teacher implement this type of task-based lesson.
Example 9.14 success story
Plan for a task-based lesson – Spiders: a
Two task cycles leading into a newspaper report about woman with arachnophobia.
Pre-task (2–3 minutes) Introduction to the topic. Task cycle 1 (speaking, 2–3 minutes) Pairs brainstorm sequence of steps to help the woman overcome phobia of spiders. Planning: (2–3 minutes) Pairs prepare how to present and justify ideas from above Report and reading 1: (10 minutes) Pairs present their proposals, class discuss and vote on steps most likely to be in newspaper report. Students read (incomplete) newspaper report in light of above, and compare this with their own proposals, nominating those most similar. Task cycle 2 (reading, 4–5 minutes) Students re-read text; pairs discuss probable position of missing part of text. Planning and report 2: Students share opinions on position of missing part of text. Students check against complete text.
Language focus Analysis and practice (20–35 minutes) 1. Main theme: Spiders: Students circle phrases in text relating to spiders, and draw lines to link phrases as lexical chains. Students compare (focus on lexical cohesion). 2. Time and sequence: Students select phrases expressing time (focus on structure of sequential narrative). 3. Place and position: Students select phrases expressing place and position, and subdivide into categories as given. 4. Grammar points: – Students find four phrases containing was and look for similarities in structure. (Focus on passive voice and adverbial placement.)
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 9.14
(Continued)
Either: – Students find six phrases with to, note related verbs and categorise; note where to can be omitted. Or: – From a concordance sample, students categorise different uses of to. (Focus on uses of to.) (Suggested homework activity.) – Students identify patterns in verb phrases in given set of examples. (Focus on passive and uses of to.) Students write useful language from the lesson in their books. (based on Willis, 1996)
As can be seen, Willis’s approach differs from Long and Crookes’s along a number of dimensions, notably in placing less emphasis on tasks derived from target needs (although more recent work - e.g. Willis, 2004 – reflects a greater concern with this), and considerably more emphasis on the micro-details of lesson planning. The lesson plan in Example 9.14 reflects many general principles central to her approach: • a ‘task’ is characterised as a set of interlocking stages; • there is a progression from the whole to the parts; • there is a progression from meaning to form, and the integration of meaning and form; • language skills can be integrated across a task cycle; • there are opportunities for planning and rehearsal. Further examples of materials following the task cycle proposed here can be found in Willis and Willis (1988) and more recently in Willis (2004) and Willis and Willis (2007). One striking feature of Willis’s framework is that it is presented as a pedagogically grounded, practitioner-friendly initiative. This has had widespread and immediate appeal for teachers seeking concrete guidance on how to work with tasks, and the task cycle has been widely used as a model – sometimes the model – of TBLT in pre- and in-service teacher education in the UK and elsewhere. However, despite extensive practitioner appeal, there has been little documentation of the framework being applied in fully-fledged task-based programmes in the sense presumably originally intended, and although Willis has increasingly drawn on selected aspects of existing SLA research as a rationale for elements of the task cycle (Willis, 2004, for example), the overall concern has been to present the framework as a set of accessible guidelines for practitioners
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
206
207
to follow rather than to problematise underlying issues or to explore a psycholinguistically grounded rationale for instruction. Although seeking empirical evidence to support her pedagogic claims may not have been part of Willis’s intended remit, the framework itself appears to have attracted relatively little empirical attention within the task research community. This means that a number of questions about how (to quote Willis as cited above) learners ‘experience’ the target language, ‘examine’ the language they use and – crucially – how and what they ‘learn’ from this are yet to be empirically addressed in the kinds of task-based context Willis advocates. However, the perceived pedagogic relevance of the work is reflected in a growing number of teacher-initiated action research projects based on aspects of the task cycle. Edwards and Willis (2005) report a number of small-scale studies conducted by teachers, which explore pedagogically motivated questions emerging from task use in their own classroom across the world. Some of the issues that have been brought into focus through the use of tasks in Japan, Greece and Switzerland are summarised in Example 9.15.
Example 9.15 Some issues pursued in teacher action research projects Predictability of language items in open tasks Developing from PPP to TBL Incorporating tasks in textbooks for beginning learners Integrating task-based instruction into a business English programme Learners’ use of language at different stages of the task cycle
(Cox, 2005) (Loumpourdi, 2005) (Muller, 2005) (Pullin Stark, 2005) (Johnston,
2005)
As noted in Chapter 8, teacher-led research of this kind is a key element in building richer understandings of what happens when tasks are used in classrooms. However, much of the work reported in Edwards and Willis is not fully ‘task-based’ in the sense that we have been using the term here. In the classrooms studied, tasks were generally used in conjunction with other modes of instruction pre-set curricula, and thus more typical of what we would characterise as ‘task-supported’ contexts. This suggests that Willis’s framework may be more influential in introducing the use of tasks to supplement and extend current practices than in promoting the fully-fledged task-based learning that Willis herself advocates – although the extent to which this represents a necessary ‘halfway step’ towards
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
Tasks in Second Language Learning
full implementation of TBLT, as suggested in Shehadeh (2005), is an interesting empirical question in its own right. Looking back across the three examples – The Bangalore Project; Long and Crookes’s proposals for task-based syllabus design and Willis’s framework for task-based learning – it is clear that there are a number of distinctive differences in terms of context, scope and emphasis. However, a number of shared elements mark these as examples of ‘task-based’ learning and teaching in the sense that we are using the term: • the curriculum is defined and driven by tasks; • tasks are not pre-selected on the basis of form; • the potential pedagogic focus of any given task emerges from sustained meaningful engagement with the demands of that task; • engagement with meaning is the springboard for engagement with form; • any engagement with form mediated by a teacher should be responsive to problems/needs that learners encounter in carrying out a task. Importantly – and contrary to many common assumptions about TBLT – drawing attention to form is neither proscribed nor outlawed. Rather, as we saw in both the Long and Crookes and the Willis proposals, it is the timing of this focus – arising from task performance and not preceding it – that emerges as a key criterial element in ‘task-based’ learning. However, what is considerably less clear is how this works in practice. As we have seen here, apart from the now defunct Bangalore Project, to date there have been very few widely disseminated, fully documented examples of task-based programmes of instruction that have been implemented over time. Two major pedagogic initiatives widely described as ‘task-based’ are the Hong Kong Target-Oriented Curriculum (TOC), implemented by the Education Department of the Hong Kong/Special Administrative Region Government in 1999 and running in primary and secondary schools with various modifications since then, and a range of programmes introduced by the Flemish government in the 1990s for the teaching of Dutch to migrants to Flanders. Hong Kong Target-Oriented Curriculum (TOC) Strictly speaking, the Hong Kong/SAR TOC curriculum is not task-based. As its name implies, the curriculum is specified in terms of ‘targets’ – specific curricular goals that pupils are expected to reach, and the competencies,
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
208
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
209
Example 9.16 Hong Kong/SAR Target-Oriented Curriculum: sample strands and objectives: KS1– KS4 Strands/dimensions Language learning for the purposes of developing the ability to: • • •
establish and maintain relationships; to exchange ideas and information; to get things done (Interpersonal) provide or find out, interpret and use information; to explore, express and apply ideas; and to solve problems (Knowledge) respond and give expression to real and imaginative experience (Experience)
Learning objectives Forms and functions (vocabulary, text, types, grammar items and structures, and communicative functions) Language skills (listening, speaking, reading, writing) Language development strategies (thinking skills, information skills, skills of planning, managing and evaluating one’s learning) Attitudes (e.g. confidence in using English, sensitivity towards language use in the process of communication, respect for different cultures) (Curriculum Development Council, Hong Kong, 2002)
Tasks are seen as one of the means by which curricular targets like the ones exemplified above may be reached, and through which the desired competencies, strategies and skills may be developed. In practice, the prominence of the task element within the TOC may vary; for example, in recent years there has been a move towards ‘school-based’ materials development in Hong Kong and so the degree of emphasis given to task work might depend on teachers’ assessment of local needs or their own attitudes towards task use later revisions to the TOC, and have tended to de-emphasise tasks (e.g. Curriculum Development Council, Hong Kong, 2002, compared with earlier versions). That there have been problems in implementing the TOC is widely acknowledged (Biggs and Lam, 1997; Tinker-Sachs et al., 2000; Candlin, 2001; Carless, 2004; Littlewood, 2007),
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
strategies and skills that they are expected to develop in pursuit of those targets, rather than tasks. Tasks, however, play a prominent role as carriers of curriculum content.
210
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Quote 9.1 Teacher roles in planning, developing and implementing classroom tasks Teachers should plan and organise tasks or activities with the aim of maximising learners’ exposure to English both inside and outside the classroom ... When designing tasks, teachers are encouraged to consider and apply what follows:
Learner-centred instruction ... Learner-centred instruction may be provided through: • designing learning tasks or activities that cater for learners’ ages, needs, interests, abilities, experiences and learning styles; • engaging learners in group work or pair work for genuine communication; • applying suitable questioning techniques to stimulate thinking, encourage experimentation and facilitate knowledge construction; and • encouraging learners to contribute to the learning process by – sharing their views and learning experiences, – playing an active role in consulting the teacher, and – negotiating with the teacher on learning objectives, helping to select learning materials and choosing appropriate activities such as role-plays, games, debates and projects. (Key Learning Area Curriculum Guide (Primary 1–Secondary 3) for English Language Education, 2002: 95–6)
This is a daunting brief. It assumes that teachers have a solid grasp of the possibilities and limitations of ‘task’ as have a pedagogic construct, and principled understandings of the ways that the pedagogic focus of tasks may be interpreted and managed. However, there appears to be a mismatch between what is expected and what teachers feel they can do. Although different kinds of support for implementing TOC are made available, including supplementary materials (for example, Mok, 2003), on-line resources (for example, TeleNex, which provides task banks, lesson plans, samples of student work, multi-media links, responses to teacher queries) and in-service workshops on pedagogic procedures (e.g. cooperative learning; Tinker-Sachs et al., 2000), a persistent problem reported by teachers is lack of preparation in how to respond to the demands of the TOC and how to handle it on an everyday basis.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
and the demands placed on teachers and the expectations made are considerable, as suggested in the Curriculum Development Council document in Quote 9.1:
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
211
Task-based programmes for the teaching of Dutch in primary and secondary schools and in adult education have been offered to migrants to Flanders and subsidised by the Flemish government as part of its policy for social inclusion since the early 1990s. As reported by Kris Van den Branden and colleagues from the Centre for Language and Education at the Katholieke Universiteit, Leuven, who have been involved in developing and implementing these programmes since their inception, this work allies itself with ‘task-based’ learning as characterised above. The Flanders programmes provide a window on TBLT in action in different contexts and age ranges, and crucially, over time. Van den Branden (2006a), a collection of reports based on different aspects of the programmes, describes how tasks were derived from needs analyses, principles underlying curriculum development, assessment instruments and procedures for preparing teachers to introduce task-based innovations. This provides a close account of programme development within a particular SL setting, and Van den Branden is cautious about claims for generalisability to other types of learning situation. Nevertheless, there are many lessons to be learned, particularly with regard to the preparation of teachers, where a gradualist, bottom-up approach to the introduction of TBLT has been developed. Highly sensitive to teacher needs and perceptions, Van den Branden makes extensive use of school-based, practice-oriented coaching (Van den Branden, 2006b and c; Van Avermaet et al., 2006), with teachers involved as active agents in managing change. Ways of working with the new syllabuses were explored collaboratively in on-site coaching sessions; task-based syllabuses did not automatically replace older materials; and teachers had considerable freedom as to how much/how little of the new syllabuses they wished to adopt and how they made use of them. The highly intensive nature of this approach underscores the need for long-term investment of time and resources in teacher preparation and support if TBLT is to be introduced on a large scale; and the emphasis on gradual teacher ownership of tasks is an interesting point of comparison with the more top-down orientation of the Hong Kong TOC. There are, however, a number of intriguing questions about the Flanders programmes, for example, Van den Branden (2006a), the most widely disseminated documentation to date, has relatively little about the impact of TBLT on language development over time. And although the process of curriculum development is described in considerable detail, there are limited examples of what the finished product looks like. Nevertheless, the Flanders programmes offer important insights into what is required
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Flanders task-based programmes for the teaching of Dutch as a second language
212
Tasks in Second Language Learning
for the large-scale implementation of TBLT, and considerable potential for further exploration of its impact on learning.
We began by noting that ‘task-based’ has been loosely applied, and so we have tried here to unpick what could be considered criterial characteristics of TBLT. Our examples have been drawn from a limited range, largely because, as we have seen, there are to date relatively few situations in which TBLT as characterised here has been put into practice. Critics (e.g. Swan, 2005) have consistently argued that there is insufficient evidence on how TBLT works in real classroom contexts, particularly in the teaching of foreign languages in state schools, to warrant the current advocacy for task-based programme development. The critics are right to highlight the lack of such evidence – although this presents a classic chicken-and-egg situation: how can one systematically study TBLT in action over time in the absence of fully developed TBLT programmes to study? For some, the answer is to focus on task-supported contexts. 9.2.2
Task-supported language learning and teaching (TSLT)
In Chapter 4 we characterised ‘task-supported’ teaching and learning as involving the use of tasks: • as one element in an overall programme of instruction within a range of syllabus types, and/or to realise a range of curricular objectives; • in conjunction with different types of pedagogic activity (exercises, rule explanation, focused practice, etc.); • in different ways to serve different types of pedagogic purposes. In Example 9.17, we illustrate how these characteristics are reflected in pedagogic practice by listing some ways that tasks are commonly used in task-supported contexts:
Example 9.17 Using a task in a task-supported context: some pedagogic examples 1 2
To enact content-based/theme-based syllabuses (e.g. Leaver and Kaplan, 2004, language training programmes in Czech, Ukrainian and Russian). To integrate diverse elements taught separately within a programme of instruction and to sustain motivation over a course of study (e.g. Fried-Booth, 1986, development of a full-scale project, e.g. making a class newspaper, alongside regular programme of instruction).
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
TBLT: Problems and Issues
3
4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13
14
213
To diagnose students’ strengths and weaknesses at the beginning of a unit of instruction to inform and shape subsequent pedagogic focus, and provide summative feedback at the end (e.g. Larsen-Freeman, 2000). To create a platform for the negotiation of course/class content/modes of learning/forms of assessment (Kohnonen et al., 2001). To contextualise/raise interest/activate prior knowledge of theme/topic of a unit of instruction (Nunan, 2004). To raise awareness of specific lexico-grammatical features (Lee, 2000). To activate previously introduced language features in the final phase of a pedagogic sequence (ESA, Harmer, 2001). To mobilise and stretch students’ existing knowledge and resources and develop fluency in light of real time processing demands (Johnson, 1996). To create a learning space for the introduction of ‘new’ language (as used by the teacher in Samuda, 2001). To give rein to individual self expression/creativity (Rinvolucri, 2002). To raise awareness of different modes of learning (Legutke and Thomas, 1991). To provide a tool for self-assessment/self-reflection (Finch et al., 2003). To create a ‘rehearsal rationale’ for real life language demands (Nunan, 1991; Hutchinson and Waters, 1987). To vary pace, to make a change, to provide a break from usual classroom work, to fill a hole in a lesson plan (Ur and Wright, 1992).
As can be seen, ‘task-supported’ appears to encompass a very broad range of ways of using tasks for a very broad range of purposes – to diagnose, to provide practice, to develop fluency, to raise awareness of specific language features, to assess progress, and so on – but tasks themselves are not the central unit of activity within the overall programme of instruction, nor are they associated with a particular syllabus type: any one of our examples could be used in a pre-set syllabus, defined in various ways – structurally, functionally, lexically, topically, textually, etc. – but not necessarily in terms of ‘task’. We explore this further in the following examples of TSLT at three different levels of practice: 1) within a syllabus; 2) within an instructional sequence; and 3) within an individual task. TSLT within a syllabus A very common way of working tasks into a syllabus is shown in Example 9.18, where tasks are specified as a separate ‘strand’ within the overall scope and sequence of a theme-based course- book . This extract
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
214
Tasks in Second Language Learning
Example 9.18 Task-supported learning: tasks as a strand within a textbook scope and sequence: Cunningham and Moor, 2005 Module Language Focus
Vocabulary as writing
Reading
Task
Further skills
Study Practise Remember
Around Comparatives the and world superlatives Phrases for comparing Pronunciation: stress and /∂/ sounds
Describing towns and cities
Reading: The top 100 places to see before you die
Preparation: Listening: A tour of Australia
Real life: Booking a flight
Study tips: Keeping notes Pronunciation: spot: the sounds /I/ and /i:/
Task: Design a tour (Speaking) Follow-up:
Since ‘task’ is specified as a strand in its own right in Example 9.18, it is clearly considered a significant element within the overall syllabus. TSLT at the level of an instructional sequence The position of the task towards the end of the module suggests that its intended role here is to support linguistic content previously highlighted in other strands. The task itself is further preceded by several phases of pre-task ‘preparation’ based on a tour of Australia; these involve activating background knowledge, listening to recommendations about places to visit and drawing attention to useful language, so that by the time the students finally encounter the task, they will have been extensively primed to engage with both the topic and the language that it seeks to activate. This way of using a task will be very familiar to many teachers, since its position in the overall sequence of instruction and the role that it plays there correspond to well-established classroom procedures, such as the ‘Production’ phase in PPP, or the ‘Activate’ phase of an ESA (Engage, Study, Activate) cycle (Harmer, 2001). As we saw earlier, the ‘supporting’ role that tasks play there are in direct contrast with the catalysing role they are intended to play at the beginning of a pedagogic cycle, as in Willis’s and Long and Crookes’s approaches to TBLT.
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
from the table of contents of a course aimed at young adults gives an overview of a unit of work called ‘Around the World’:
Pedagogic Perspectives on Second Language Tasks
215
TSLT at the level of task
Example 9.19
Task: Design a tour
A 1 Either in pairs or individually, you are going to design a tour similar to the one you heard described. Choose one of the options below. • Design a tour of your country for one of the following groups. (You will be the guide!) – other students in your class; – a group of students on a budget holiday; – a foreign film star, singer, sports personality, etc. • Design a tour of either California or Scotland using the information supplied. • Design a tour of an interesting country you have visited for other students in your class. • Design a ‘fantasy tour’ of a region/country/continent that you would like to visit (for example, ‘Great Cities of Europe’, ‘Highlights of the USA’, etc.).
B Decide on the following: • How long each tour will be, and how many days will be spent in each place. • The best way to travel from one place to another. • The main things to see in each place and why they are interesting. 2 Spend 10–15 minutes planning how to describe your tour. Ask your teacher for any words or phrases you need. If possible, draw a rough map to help explain your tour. 3 Work in pairs with a student who has planned a different tour. Explain your tours to each other. Answer your partner’s questions.
Follow-up: writing Write an itinerary for your tour describing what will happen on each day: Day one ..., day two ... Read each other’s tours. Whose sounds the most interesting? (Adapted from Cunningham and Moor, 2005)
Interestingly, there doesn’t appear to be anything specific in the design of the task in itself that would mark it out as either ‘task-supported’ or ‘taskbased’. The task seeks to engage holistic language use; there is a goal and an outcome, and the design offers flexibility over choice of topic, ways of
10.1057/9780230596429 - Tasks in Second Language Learning, Virginia Samuda and Martin Bygate
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-20
The position of a task in a teaching sequence and the role that it plays there are thus two areas where we can detect differences between ‘taskbased’ and ‘task-supported’ orientations to th