Update 15 published December 2003 Update 14 published September 2003 Update 13 published May 2003 Update 12 published J...
386 downloads
3696 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Update 15 published December 2003 Update 14 published September 2003 Update 13 published May 2003 Update 12 published January 2003 Update 11 published October 2002 Update 10 published August 2002 Update 9 published December 2001 Update 8 published October 2001 Update 7 published July 2001 Update 6 published December 2000 Update 5 published October 2000 Update 4 published May 2000 Update 3 published December 1999 Update 2 published October 1999 Update 1 published April 1999
Please note: References to the masculine include, where appropriate, the feminine. Extracts from Parry’s Valuation and Conversion Tables, A W Davidson (1989), (Estates Gazette) reproduced by permission of the College of Estate Management which owns the copyright. Appendix A, Section 2.3 is reproduced from the Building Cost Information Service publication, Standard Form of Cost Analysis: Principles, Instructions and Definitions (1969). Published by RICS Business Services Limited a wholly owned subsidiary of The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors under the RICS Books imprint Surveyor Court Westwood Business Park Coventry CV4 8JE UK No responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting or refraining from action as a result of the material included in this publication can be accepted by the author or publisher. ISBN 0 85406 865 1 © RICS Business Services Limited (RBS) December 2003. Copyright in all or part of this publication rests with RBS, and save by prior consent of RBS, no part or parts shall be reproduced by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, now known or to be devised. Typeset and printed by Q3 Print Project Management Ltd, Loughborough.
1998 FOREWORD Knowledge is of two kinds: we know a subject ourselves, or we know where we can find information upon it. Samuel Johnson (1709–1784)
The fact that our profession serves a changing world increases the need for it to rely on well thought-out and reliable practices and procedures. Events move at an ever-increasing pace, imposing a requirement for quicker response times. Modern communication methods such as facsimile and now e-mail result in the need for information to be available almost instantly. This is made more difficult by an industry growing in complexity and which is subject to increasing customer expectations in terms of service and quality. The RICS has published this Surveyors’ Construction Handbook to help surveyors meet these needs. It is intended to become an important source of reliable information and guidance to all Chartered Surveyors who practise in construction. Much of the excellent information produced by the divisions in the past has now been updated for inclusion. Other material not yet revised will be added. The whole will be regularly reviewed and updated as necessary. RICS practice panels are continuing to produce information for inclusion to make it a useful construction reference document. We hope that this Handbook will become an invaluable aid to your day-to-day activities.
Christopher Powell, FRICS PRESID ENT, QUANTITY SURVEYORS DIVISION, 1997–98
Trevor Mole, FRICS PRESID ENT, BUILDING SURVEYORS DIVISIO N, 1997–98
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Professor Roy Morledge, Professor of Construction Procurement at The Nottingham Trent University, for contributing the text of Part 3, Section 1. Major D.R. Bassett, Royal Engineers, for his contribution to the research underpinning the construction time charts in Part 3, Section 1; Central Unit for Procurement, HM Treasury (now Office for Government Commerce), for permission to use CUP guides extensively in the drafting of Part 1, Section 1 and Part 3, Section 1. Alan Turner, JP FRICS ACIArb, author of Building Procurement, for permission to use a number of the diagrams from his text in Part 3, Section 1.
CONTENTS Foreword Acknowledgements List of Abbreviations Introduction A B C D E F
Aim and Scope of this Handbook Arrangement of Content Status of Content Currency of References Invitation Subscription Service
1 1 1 2 3 3 3
Part 1: The Client Section 1.1: The Client’s Requirements and Roles 1.1.1 Establishing the Client’s Objectives 1.1.2 The Role for Independent Advice 1.1.3 Project Brief 1.1.4 The Client’s Role 1.1.5 The Client’s Responsibilities 1.1.6 Appointment of Project Manager (where appropriate) 1.1.7 Appointment of Consultants 1.1.8 Appointment of Constructors Appendix A: Further Reading
1 1 3 3 4 6 8 8 9 1
Section 1.2: Value Engineering
1 Introduction 1 1.2.1 Why Value Engineering? 2 1.2.2 Applicability 2 1.2.3 At What Stage Should Value Engineering be Carried Out? 3 1.2.4 Who Should Carry Out Value Engineering? 4 1.2.5 How Long Should It Last? 5 1.2.6 Preparing for a Value Engineering Workshop 5 1.2.7 Functional Analysis of Design Relative to the Client’s Requirements 5 1.2.8 Pricing the FAST Diagram 8 1.2.9 Presenting a Design Solution to a Value Engineering Workshop 8 1.2.10 The Workshop 8 1.2.11 Assessing the Value of the Workshop 9 1.2.12 Implementing the Results 10 1.2.13 Feedback from Post-Occupancy Evaluation 10 Appendix A: Health Centre Value Tree 1 Appendix B: Typical Example of a Value Engineering Process 1 Appendix C: Further Reading 1
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Contents (12/03)
Page 1
Part 2: Construction Design and Economics Section 2.1: Pre-contract Cost Planning and Cost Management Introduction 2.1.1 Pre-contract Cost Planning and Cost Management 2.1.2 Preliminary Cost Studies and Feasibility Studies 2.1.3 Budget 2.1.4 The Cost Plan at Outline Proposals Stage 2.1.5 The Cost Plan at Scheme Design Stage 2.1.6 Cost Checking 2.1.7 Action after Receipt of Tenders Appendix A: Sources of Cost Information Appendix B: Format of Budget and Cost Plans Appendix C: Element Unit Quantities Generation for Hypothetical Buildings Appendix D: Further Reading
Section 2.2: Life Cycle Costing Introduction 2.2.1 The Client Context 2.2.2 The Life Cycle Costing Calculation 2.2.3 Tax Allowances, Incentives and Business Rates 2.2.4 Data Sources 2.2.5 Worked Examples Appendix A: Residual Values Appendix B: Obsolescence Appendix C: Costs And Values Appendix D: Glossary of Terms for Taxation Appendix E: Examples of Items of Expenditure Likely to Attract Taxation Allowances Appendix F: Further Reading
Section 2.3: Elements for Buildings
Section 2.4: Design and Build - Guidance for Employer’s Agents Introduction 2.4.1 Background 2.4.2 Contract Documentation 2.4.3 Additional Services 2.4.4 Employer’s Requirements and Contractor’s Proposals (including contract sum analysis) 2.4.5 Design and Build Variants 2.4.6 Novation Appendix A: Potential Services Associated with the Role of Employer’s Agent Appendix B: Employer’s Requirements/Contractor’s Proposal Checklist
Contents (12/03)
1 1 1 1 1 5 10 14 15 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1
Introduction 2.3.1 Elements 2.3.2 Elemental Cost Analysis 2.3.3 Other Uses Appendix A: BCIS Standard Elements
Page 2
1 1 2 4 4 8 11 13 14 1 1
1 1 2 3 3 5 6 8 1 1
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Section 2.5: The Chartered Surveyor as Lead Consultant 2.5.1 2.5.2 2.5.3 2.5.4
Introduction Definitions: The Difference Between a Project Manager and Lead Consultant Benefits of Appointing a Chartered Surveyor as Lead Consultant Issues to Consider before Undertaking the Role Schedule of Lead Consultant Duties
Section 2.6 Defining Sustainable Construction Introduction 2.6.1 Technology Swaps 2.6.2 How Can the Environment and Sustainability be Valued? 2.6.3 How Does This Effect the Construction Industry? 2.6.4 Green Building Materials 2.6.5 Whole Building Sustainability 2.6.6 The Government Line 2.6.7 What Might the Future Hold Appendix A: Embodied Energy Content of Building Material Appendix B: Useful Addresses
1 1 1 2 3 3 1 1 2 3 4 7 8 9 11 1 1
Part 3: Construction Planning and Procurement Section 3.1: Developing an Appropriate Building Procurement Strategy Introduction 3.1.1 The Client’s Role 3.1.2 Procurement Strategy 3.1.3 Selection of Most Appropriate Procurement Strategy 3.1.4 Implementation Appendix A: Procurement Options
Section 3.2: Building Services Procurement Introduction 3.2.1 Appointing the Building Services Designer 3.2.2 Design Coordination 3.2.3 Appointing a Building Services Contractor 3.2.4 Tender Documents Appendix A: Typical Example
1 1 2 12 25 29 1 1 1 3 11 19 34 1
Part 4: Construction Administration and Management Section 4.1: The Problems of Practical Completion Introduction 4.1.1 What Happens in Practice 4.1.2 Standard Form Approaches 4.1.3 Effects of Practical Completion 4.1.4 Methods for Dealing with Practical Completion 4.1.5 Definitions 4.1.6 Subsidiary Issues Appendix A: General Objectives to be Achieved at Practical Completion for Small to Medium-sized Building Projects Appendix B: Table of Cases Appendix C: Further Reading
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Contents (12/03)
1 1 1 3 13 14 16 20 1 1 1
Page 3
Section 4.2: Ascertaining the Amount of Loss and Expense Incurred in Building Projects Introduction 4.2.1 General Principles 4.2.2 Definitions 4.2.3 Entitlement 4.2.4 Ascertainment 4.2.5 Admissible Items 4.2.6 Inadmissible Items Appendix A: Ascertaining the Cost of Running a Site Appendix B: Disruption Appendix C: Ascertaining the Cost of Head Office Overheads Appendix D: Checklist of Items for which Loss and/or Expense are Allowed Appendix E: Checklist of Steps Required when Considering Submissions by Contractor Appendix F: Further Reading
1 1 1 4 4 7 9 13 1 1 1 1 1 1
Section 4.3: The Management of Risk
1 Introduction 1 4.3.1 Definitions 2 4.3.2 The Rationale for Risk Management in the Construction Process 2 4.3.3 The Risk Management Process 5 4.3.4 Summary 14 Appendix A: Further Reading 1
Section 4.4: Valuations for Interim Certificates Introduction 4.4.1 Valuations 4.4.2 Assumptions 4.4.3 Valuation Under a JCT Contract: Background 4.4.4 Recommended Action at the Start of a Contract 4.4.5 Communications 4.4.6 Approach 4.4.7 Content of a Valuation 4.4.8 Administration 4.4.9 Special Situations 4.4.10 Other Contract Terms (relative to valuations) 4.4.11 Valuations Under Other Forms of Contract Appendix A: Further Reading Appendix B: JCT Definition of ‘Reasonable Proof’ Appendix C: Example of Priced Activity Schedule
Section 4.5: Extension of Time 4.5.1 4.5.2 4.5.3 4.5.4 4.5.5 4.5.6 4.5.7 4.5.8 4.5.9 Page 4
Introduction Extension of Time Clauses Assumptions Extension of Time Under a JCT Contract Notice by the Contractor of Delay to Progress The Award of an Extension of Time during the Contract Period and Before the Completion Date The Award of an Extension of Time after the Completion Date Relevant Events Concurrent Delays Consequential Entitlement Contents (12/03)
1 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 8 15 16 17 18 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 3 4 5 6 7 12 13
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
4.5.10 Administration 4.5.11 Extension of Time under an ICE Contract 4.5.12 Extension of Time under a GC Works Contract Appendix A: Further Reading
13 14 14 1
Part 5: Additional Guidance and Information Section 5.1: Surveying Safely Section 5.2: Construction (Design and Management) Information 5.2.1 Schedule of Sources of Useful CDM Information
Section 5.3: Built environment group roles and information Section 5.4: Building Cost Information Service 5.4.3 BCIS Online 5.4.4 Other BCIS Publications and Services 5.4.5 Further details
Section 5.5: Building Occupancy Cost Information (BMI) 5.5.2 5.5.3 5.5.4 5.5.5
BMI Quarterly Cost Briefing Building Maintenance Price Book Special Reports for Benchmarking News, Digests and Reports
Section 5.6: Electronic document storage – legal admissibility Introduction 5.6.1 Code of Practice – DISC PD 0008: 1999 5.6.2 Weight of evidence and document destruction 5.6.3 Authenticity 5.6.4 Photocopies, microfilm and image processing 5.6.5 Document storage 5.6.6 Storage and access procedures 5.6.7 Format of the Code of Practice 5.6.8 Conclusion Appendix A: Specimen form for recording scanning information Appendix B: Specimen form for recording retrieval Appendix C: References
Index
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
1 1 2 1 1 1 2 4 1 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 3 3 4 4 5 6 20 1 1 1 1
Contents (12/03)
Page 5
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ABE ABI ACA ACE AQL BCIS BEC BMI BRE BRECSU BREEAM BSI BSRIA BWIC CA CAWS CDM CD-R CECA CIB CIBSE CIC CIRIA CITES CCT CSM DBFO DoE DETR DMS DOM EC EU FAST FCEC GNP HBF HMSO HSE IChemE ICE IDMA The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Association of Building Engineers Association of British Insurers Association of Consultant Architects Association of Consulting Engineers Acceptable quality level Building Cost Information Service Building Employers’ Confederation Building Maintenance Information Building Research Establishment Building Research Energy Conservation Support Unit Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method Building Standards’ Institution Building Services Research and Information Association Builder’s Work in Connection Contract Administrator Common Arrangement of Works Section for Building Works Construction (Design and Management) Compact disc recordable Civil Engineering Contractors’ Association Construction Industry Board Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers Construction Industry Council Construction Industry Research and Information Association Control in Trade of Endangered Species Compulsory Competitive Tendering Chartered Surveyors Monthly Design Build Fund and Operate Department of the Environment (now known as the DETR) Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions (formerly the DoE) Document Management System Domestic Sub-Contract European Commission European Union Functional Analysis Systems Technique Federation of Civil Engineering Contractors Gross National Product House Builders’ Federation Her Majesty’s Stationery Office (now known as The Stationery Office) Health and Safety Executive Institution of Chemical Engineers Institution of Civil Engineers Information and Document Management Association Abbreviations (10/02)
Page 1
IFC JCT LCC LQ M&E MERA MW NEC NEDO NJCC NSC OMR PFI PSA RIBA RICS VAT WCD WORM WRC
Page 2
Intermediage Form of Contract Joint Contracts Tribunal Life Cycle Costing Limiting quality Mechanical and Electrical Multiple Estimate Risk Anaylsis Minor Works New Engineering Contract National Economics Development Office National Joint Consultative Committee for Building Nominated Sub-Contract Optical Mark Reading Private Finance Initiative Property Services Agency Royal Institute of British Architects Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors Value Added Tax With Contractor’s Design Write-Once-Read-Many Water Research Centre
Abbreviations (10/02)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
I NTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION A Aim and Scope of this Handbook A1
The aim of this Handbook is to help both building and quantity surveyors to provide construction-related professional services effectively and efficiently. It seeks to achieve this by providing guidance which reflects what is often good custom and practice, and relevant information (including references to other useful material). It should be appreciated that this Handbook does not attempt comprehensive coverage of necessary or good practice. The Handbook is addressed to surveyors providing services to clients (as defined), not surveyors undertaking the role of the client’s representative who gives instructions to surveyors on behalf of the Client.
A2
‘Construction’ in this Handbook means new construction, conversion, refurbishment works and alterations to the form of buildings, and also civil engineering works. The contents of this Handbook apply across the complete range of this definition unless otherwise stated. So ‘construction’ does not embrace building surveys or building maintenance.
A3
‘Client’ in this Handbook is used to include companies and their Directors or Officers, Trusts and their Trustees, partners, managers and employees who may instruct a surveyor.
A4
Throughout the Handbook, it is assumed that possession and necessary access to the site are available and, in principle, the rights to construct the development and use the buildings when constructed. The Handbook does not cover project management services, obtaining planning permission and building regulation approvals, or dispute resolution.
A5
The document is drafted on the basis of UK law and practice, although much of it is relevant to practice elsewhere.
B Arrangement of Content B1
After sets of Definitions and Abbreviations which apply throughout, the Handbook is arranged in five Parts. The first four Parts represent sequential phases of the construction process. The last Part, Part 5, provides Additional Guidance and Information. Each part is followed by Further Reading, to which the numbered cross references in the Parts apply.
B2
The first four Parts are as follows: Part 1: The Client seeks to help surveyors to work with clients. It discusses the establishment of their construction objectives and constraints, leading to the
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Introduction (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 1
I NTRODUCTION
development of construction briefs. It defines the client’s roles during the construction process, and comments on the engagement of professionals involved in the construction process. Part 2: Construction Design and Economics covers development of the design concept, feasibility studies, design and economics (including life-cycle costing, risk assessment, and cost-value relationships), and confirmation of the final design proposal. Part 3 relates to Construction Planning and Procurement, i.e. to the time the construction contract is placed. Part 4 covers Construction Administration and Management, i.e. all post-contract matters. Any Appendices are situated at the end of each Part. B3
An Index follows Part 5.
C Status of Content C1
For convenience, Guidance and Information is integrated. Each paragraph is prefixed with a G or an I to indicate its status.
C2
‘Guidance’, as the word implies advice to Members of the RICS on aspects of their profession. Where recommended for specific professional tasks, procedures are intended to embody ‘best practice’, i.e. procedures which in the opinion of the RICS meet a high standard of professional competence. Members are not required to follow the advice and recommendations contained in such paragraphs. They should, however, note the following points. Should an allegation of professional negligence be made against a surveyor, the Court is likely to take account of the contents of any relevant guidance notes published by the RICS in deciding whether or not the surveyor had acted with reasonable competence. In the opinion of the RICS, a Member conforming to the practices recommended in this Note should have at least a partial defence to an allegation of negligence by virtue of having followed those practices. However, Members have the responsibility of deciding when it is appropriate to follow the guidance. If the guidance has been followed in an appropriate case, the Member will not necessarily be exonerated merely because the recommendations were found in RICS Guidance.
Page 2
Introduction (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
INTRODUCTION
On the other hand, it does not follow that a Member will be adjudged negligent if he has not followed the practices recommended in this Handbook. It is the responsibility of each individual surveyor to decide on the appropriate procedure to follow in any professional task. However, where Members depart from any practices recommended in this Handbook, they should do so only for good reason. In the event of litigation, the Court may require them to explain why they decided not to adopt a recommended practice. In addition, Guidance Notes are relevant to professional competence in that each surveyor should be up to date and should have informed himself of Guidance Notes within a reasonable time of their promulgation. C3
Material classified as ‘information’ is intended to provide information and explanations to Members of the RICS on specific topics of relevance to the profession. The function is not to recommend or advise on professional procedures to be followed by surveyors. It is again, however, relevant to professional competence to the extent that a surveyor should be up to date and should have informed himself of such information within a reasonable time of its promulgation. Members should note that if an allegation of professional negligence is made against a surveyor, the Court is likely to take account of the contents of any relevant information published by the RICS in deciding whether or not the surveyor has acted with reasonable competence.
D Currency of References The cases cited and the editions quoted were up-to-date at the time of writing. However, readers should check current rulings and additions.
E Invitation RICS Books would welcome comments upon and suggestions for additions and amendments to this Handbook. They should be provided in writing to RICS Books Publishing, Surveyor Court, Westwood Business Park, Coventry, CV4 8JE.
F Subscription Service Any change of address should be notified to the address appearing below: The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook Subscription Service RICS Books Surveyor Court Westwood Business Park Coventry CV4 8JE Tel: 020 7222 7000 ext 647
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Introduction (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 3
PART 1, SECTION 1
PART ONE: THE CLIENT SECTION 1: THE CLIENT’S REQUIREMENTS AND ROLES 1.1.1 Establishing the Client’s Objectives G
1.1.1.1
Client satisfaction will be maximised if the client’s objectives as established in the business case for the project are met. The surveyor should be able to assist with the development of the business case and the prioritisation of project objectives (see 3.1.1.6 and 3.1.1.9).
G
1.1.1.2
The type of client will affect the criteria which must be met if the client is to be satisfied with the project.
I
1.1.1.3
Owner occupiers are usually primarily concerned with building performance in terms of functionality and costs in use. They may also be concerned with image and building style. In this sense, value for money is a key criterion. Developers, on the other hand, may be driven by market conditions which enable the project to be let or sold at maximum commercial advantage. They may be predominantly concerned with speed rather than performance.
I
1.1.1.4
This is not to say that owner occupiers are unconcerned about time. Indeed, certainty of completion date may be a key issue. Nor is it fair to suggest that developers are unconcerned about building performance or cost. There are market conditions where both of these issues may become important.
I
1.1.1.5
However, the client’s purpose in initiating a building project is usually driven by the need for the project as a functional unit or as an investment. There will usually be particular criteria for achievement which are critical or important to each particular client. Possible objectives are as follows: (a) Cost-related • minimise capital cost • maximise capital cost/value ratio • maximise capital cost/worth to client ratio • achieve necessary income cash flow profile • minimise management costs • minimise maintenance and insurance costs • minimise tax liability • respect capital cost constraint • be energy efficient.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 1
PART 1, SECTION 1
(b) Marketability • maximise prompt or future disposal (freehold or otherwise). (c) Use-related • optimise operational requirements of intended occupier(s) • provide greatest flexibility in potential uses • reflect intended occupier’s requirements/preferences/ability to afford • meet social/management/occupier’s special needs (e.g. disabled). (d) Environmental • minimise health and safety risks • choose materials which reflect sustainability • aesthetically please (e.g. impression on occupier’s customers) • minimise any alterations to specific features • reflect planning authority’s brief/policies • minimise potential opposition • reflect corporate style or personal preferences of proposed occupier/employees • maximise comfort of occupants • minimise inconvenience to others during construction. (e) Timing • construct within a defined period • minimise risks of delay during construction. G
1.1.1.6
The importance of each of these criteria will be relative to the objectives of the client, the business case for the project and to the extent to which he/she is able to cope with risk (see 3.1.2.9). It is important that the client seek investment appraisal advice in respect of the project and that the appraisal considers ‘what if’ questions to ensure that the impact of changes of key components in the appraisal is clearly understood. A chartered surveyor will be able to assist the client in these matters. However, the giving of advice on some of the requirements listed above is, of course, outside the competence of the surveyor. Where such a particular requirement is important to the client and outside the client’s expertise, the client should be advised to seek other professional advice.
G
1.1.1.7
Many construction projects suffer from poor definition due to inadequate time and thought being given at an early stage1. This is often because there is a sense of urgency fuelled by the desire for an immediate solution. Investing time at the beginning of a project in developing a complete definition taking account of all the requirements will reduce the likelihood of changes later. The later that changes are made in a project, the more they are likely to cost in both direct and knock-on effects (see 3.1.4.14 and 3.1.2.14(f) & (g)).
1
Page 2
Construction Industry Board, Briefing the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997.
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 1
1.1.2 The Role for Independent Advice G
1.1.2.1
With the potential for the involvement of many consultants and/or constructors in a project and the range of contracts associated with their employment, all but the most experienced client may need advice. The advice offered should be informed and unbiased and it should be based upon a logical analysis of the needs of the client, the type and character of the project and the range of appropriate strategies available.
G
1.1.2.2
This advice can be offered by a member of the client’s design team or can be a separate function. It may be more difficult for a design team member to remain impartial in carrying out this process and it is recommended that any expert retained should be solely for this purpose. This function can be identified as the role of the principal adviser and may encompass:
• • • • •
I
1.1.2.3
Assistance in preparing the business case underpinning the project Identifying the needs and requirements of the client Defining the project Matching needs and project characteristics with appropriate procurement strategy Facilitating the associated selection and contractual processes and policies
(the business case) (briefing) (project definition) (procurement strategy) (implementation)
Possible sources for the appointment of independent advisers include suitably qualified and experienced construction professionals such as chartered surveyors.
1.1.3 Project Brief G
1.1.3.1
The importance of a clear project brief to the successful completion of the project and in ensuring appropriate performance of the project cannot be over emphasised. The inexperienced client will need professional help in the preparation of the brief. The project brief is a comprehensive statement of the client’s requirements for the project based on close consultation between the client and users and based upon the parameters established (see 3.1.1.10 and 3.1.1.12). The project brief may include: (a) project description; (b) how it fits into the client’s corporate plan (e.g. it may be part of a larger planned development);
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 3
PART 1, SECTION 1
(c) number of people that are to occupy the building, together with their space requirements; (d) schedule of accommodation and quality of internal environment; (e) standards; (f) equipment and special services/requirements; (g) when the building needs to be available for use; (h) quality and cost limitations; (i) life span; (j) site; and (k) statutory controls. G
1.1.3.2
This is the initial control document for the early planning of the project; without it, little constructive work can be done. If all the information required for the project brief is not readily available, it is better to issue it in an incomplete form and to update it progressively1.
1.1.4 The Client’s Role G
1.1.4.1
This section briefly explains the client’s responsibilities through the life of a construction project. In carrying out their role, clients, depending on their knowledge and expertise, will need help from their professional advisers, project managers and other consultants, whose roles are also explained in this handbook. This section aims to outline the client’s task in setting policy and formulating strategy, and explains how it should be carried out.
G
1.1.4.2
The success of any project will depend upon the motivation given by the client. Experienced clients may take a leading role in the procurement process; less experienced clients will need to seek advice or to appoint advisers to assist them. Where projects are of a large or complex nature it may be advisable to consider the appointment of a project manager.
G
1.1.4.3
Effective management is vital in any construction project. The client’s prime role is to establish a structure for the management of the project and to make sure that it works. A crucial part of any effective management structure is efficient communication. To perform effectively, all parties must have timely
1
Page 4
Construction Industry Board, Briefing the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997.
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 1
access to all information relevant to their tasks and the project’s objectives and status (see 3.1.4.11). G
1.1.4.4
The client has substantial influence on the design of the project in respect both of functional efficiency and of overall appearance, and, therefore, has to take particular care to: (a) understand fully the purpose of the building; ensure that the requirements of the users are accommodated; and communicate those requirements to the designers (see 3.1.1.10); and (b) appoint designers with proven ability in designing buildings which satisfy users’ requirements and harmonise with and contribute to the quality of the built environment. The selection of the right people is emphasised as a key to success (see 3.1.4.8).
G
1.1.4.5
The accompanying figure indicates the activities in the procurement process and when activities are usually performed. As can be seen, the client’s role is significant, with a wide range of activities to perform and implement before both the design and the construction processes. In the performance of these activities, the client can expect to be supported and advised by his/her adviser or (if appointed) the project manager. More detail for each of these activities can be found in the section of this handbook indicated in brackets in the figure.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 5
PART 1, SECTION 1
FIGURE TO INDICATE THE ACTIVITIES IN THE P ROCUREMENT PROCESS
Client’s Role
Pre-Design Phase
Pre-Construction Phase
Construction
Post-Construction
Develop business case for project (3.1.1.9)
Procurement strategy (3.1.1.13)
Design overview (3.1.4.12)
Commissioning (3.1.1.17)
Appoint adviser (3.1.1.6)
Design overview* (3.1.4.12)
Cost control overview (3.1.4.13)
Occupation and takeover (3.1.1.18)
Define client’s responsibilities (3.1.1.7)
Cost Control overview* (3.1.4.13)
Time control overview (3.1.4.14)
Project Brief (3.1.1.12)
Whole-life Costs (3.1.4.15)
Quality control overview (3.1.4.18)
Appointment of PM (if appropriate) (3.1.4.7)
Value Engineering (3.1.4.17)
Appointment of design and cost consultants (3.1.4.8)
Time control overview* (3.1.4.14)
Change control overview (3.1.4.19)
Procurement strategy* (3.1.1.13)
Quality control overview* (3.1.4.18)
Value management (3.1.4.16)
Appointment of constructors (3.1.4.9) Confirming the business case (3.1.1.9)
Procurement Strategy
Procurement strategy development (3.1.2)
Implementation
Resources (Client) (3.1.4.3–5)
Contractual arrangements (3.1.4.10)
Organisational structure (3.1.4.6)
Systems and controls (3.1.4.11)
Systems and controls (3.1.4.11)
Contractual arrangements* (3.1.4.10) Systems and controls* (3.1.4.11) Implementation policy (3.1.4.2)
* ()
Indicates the activity will continue into the next phase Indicates the section of this document referring to the activity in more detail
1.1.5 The Client’s Responsibilities G
1.1.5.1
The client should set policy and outline strategy including: (a) setting and prioritising the project objectives within the business plan; (b) planing to meet the objectives (the pre-design phase); (c) implementing the plans (the pre-construction phase); (d) controlling their implementation (the construction phase);
Page 6
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 1
(e) arbitrating between conflicting demands; and (f) evaluating the complete post-construction phase). G
1.1.5.2
project
against
the
objectives
(the
The client also has a dual management function: (a) to manage the client input; to co-ordinate functional and administrative needs; to resolve conflicts; to act as the formal point of contact for the project (see 3.1.4.11); and (b) to supply the technical expertise, to assess, procure, monitor and control the external resources needed to implement the project (see 3.1.4.3–5).
G
1.1.5.3
In particular, the client should be satisfied that: (a) the project brief is comprehensive and clear and has the full support of the users1&2 (see 3.1.1.12); (b) any constraints demanded by the project funder(s) are known and their impact understood; (c) the critical assumptions made in preparing the initial estimates and programmes are valid, realistic and achievable (see 3.1.1.9); (d) cost estimates are comprehensive and include all capital and resource costs; (e) allowances made in the feasibility and viability assessments to cover possible risks are sufficient (contingency allowance); (f) substantial sensitivity analysis and ‘what if’ studies have been carried out to assess the effect of possible changed criteria on the viability of the project; and (g) plans are in place for adequate project management including systems for cost, time, quality and change control.
G
1.1.5.4
The client should also co-ordinate and resolve conflicts between all interested sections of the client organisation including (see 3.1.4.6): (a) user groups – who will work in the building;
1
Kelly, J., MacPherson, S., and Male, S. (1992), The Briefing Process: A Review and Critique, RICS, Department of Building Engineering and Surveying, Heriot Watt University. This document is out of print. 2 Construction Industry Board, Briefing the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 7
PART 1, SECTION 1
(b) specialist groups – responsible for technical systems within the building, e.g. communications, computers; (c) facilities management – who will manage the completed building including maintenance and security; (d) finance and accounts – who will plan and control expenditure and pay bills as they arise; and (e) legal advisers – who will advise on and monitor the client’s formal relationships with outside parties. G
1.1.5.5
The client is responsible for ensuring that all necessary decisions are made on time. Timely decisions are necessary to avoid delays and increased costs: the decision-making process requires as much planning and management as any other activity. This will include (see 3.1.4.11): (a) scheduling the key decisions to be made; (b) identifying the decision makers and their required procedures; (c) ascertaining the time required for making decisions; (d) establishing a formal programme for decisions; (e) warning decision makers regarding forthcoming submissions – making sure items are on the agenda; (f) preparing on time fully detailed submissions and/or presentations in full compliance with procedural requirements; (g) following up submissions throughout the decision making process; and (h) promptly communicating decisions made to the parties affected by them.
1.1.6 Appointment of Project Manager (where appropriate) (see 3.1.4.7) G
Page 8
1.1.6.1
Due to the complexity of modern buildings and the potentially large number of parties involved in the process the client may wish to appoint a single person to draw the process together and manage it to ensure that the overall performance, time, cost and quality requirements are achieved. The project manager may be a member of the client organisation who is given sole, or predominant, responsibility for the project. Project management practices also exist to enable appointment to be made on a consultancy basis. In this case,
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 1
selection should be based upon resources, reputation, and price; and services should be clearly identified. G
1.1.6.2
It should be emphasised that the role of the project manager should be to act as part of the client organisation.
1.1.7 Appointment of Consultants (see 3.1.4.8) G
The process of selecting and appointing the design team and the cost consultant is carried out by the client who may seek the advice of his/her advisers. The terms and conditions of these appointments are governed by the procurement strategy adopted for the project.
1.1.8 Appointment of Constructors (see 3.1.4.9) G
The selection of those who will actually construct the project is often key to a successful outcome. Selection should always be on quality as well as price and ideally the procurement strategy governing when they are appointed should facilitate the early involvement of constructors in the design process. The selection of procurement strategy is a complex one and is referred to in Part 3 section 1 of this handbook.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 9
PART 1, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
Appendix A: Further Reading Construction Industry Board, Briefing the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997 Construction Industry Board, Partnering in the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997 Construction Industry Board, Selecting Consultants for the Team: Balancing Quality and Price, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997 Construction Industry Council, The Procurement of Professional Services: Guidelines for the Value Assessment of Competitive Tenders, CIC, London, 1997 European Construction Institute, Partnering in the Public Sector: a Toolkit for the Implementation of Post-Award, Project Specific Partnering on Construction Projects, ECI, Loughborough, 1997 Kelly, J., MacPherson, S., and Male, S., The Briefing Process: A Review and Critique, RICS, Department of Building Engineering and Surveying, Heriot Watt University, 1992. This document is out of print.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 1
PART 1, SECTION 2
PART ONE: THE CLIENT SECTION 2: VALUE ENGINEERING Introduction Value management (and within it, value engineering) is a structured method of eliminating waste from a client’s brief and from the design on a construction project before binding commitments are made. Used to deliver more effective and better quality buildings, for example, through taking unnecessary costs out of designs, value management ensures a clearer understanding of the brief by all project participants and improves team working. According to the Construction Task Force report, ‘Rethinking Construction’ (published by the DETR in July 1998) it is practiced by up to a quarter of the construction industry in the UK. The report also estimates that while the objective of value management is to increase value, it can also reduce costs by up to 10 per cent. Value management is the wider term used in the UK to describe the overall structured team-based approach to a construction project. It involves clearly defining the client’s strategic objectives, considering optimum design solutions within the context of the client’s business objectives and deciding which of these provides the optimum lifetime value to the client, as well as a review of the whole process after occupancy. Value management includes value engineering as part of this process. Value engineering is a ‘systematic approach to delivering the required functions to the required quality at the least cost’, i.e. a method of ensuring that the client gets the best possible value for money in terms of safety, performance and delivery targets. It is a structured form of consensus decision making that compares and assesses the design solutions against the value systems declared by the client. This section of the handbook looks at the carrying out of a value engineering exercise during the early design phase of a project, i.e. an evaluation of design solutions against the client’s brief. Value engineering, as described here, can be a stand-alone exercise (a value engineering workshop) or may be part of an overall value management process. In describing the value engineering process this section aims to assist surveyors both in advising clients on the use of value engineering and taking part in a value engineering exercise as part of the design team. It is not intended for surveyors acting as value engineering facilitators and makes no attempt to address the very particular skills required for this role.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 (12/99)
Effective from 1/1/00
Page 1
PART 1, S ECTION 2
G
G
1.2.1 Why Value Engineering? 1.2.1.1
Value engineering has grown in popularity for the simple reason that it actually works. Construction projects can often take on a life of their own when members of the design team become focused on their own particular problems and time constraints. Consequently, the true objectives of the client get lost along the way. Value engineering relates design proposals directly back to a client’s business, thus ensuring that a management system is in place which forces designers to justify their decisions when tested against the client’s required function.
1.2.1.2
A value engineering exercise can only relate design proposals to a client’s business requirements if early value management studies have encapsulated these requirements within the brief. If a value engineering exercise is carried out in isolation from any strategic review of the project requirements, it can only act as a functional assessment of the technical design solutions and their relative cost. However, even in this limited function it can still be very useful.
1.2.2 Applicability 1.2.2.1
The technique of value engineering can be employed on any project. However, more complicated and higher value buildings are likely to benefit the most (see figure 1). This is because it is more difficult to develop the design brief in such instances and consequently a design solution may be adopted without being questioned, usually because of time constraints placed upon the designers. Figure 1: Projects Benefiting from Value Engineering High
Essential
Complexity
Optional Low Low
High
Value
1.2.2.2
Page 2
Many client organisations will only undertake value engineering on schemes over a certain value. For example, Railtrack will carry out the technique on projects valued at £250,000 or more and Northumbrian Water will only consider it for projects worth over £1m. Despite this, there is no reason why the process should not be applied to smaller schemes. Furthermore, value engineering will be invaluable where repetitive schemes are being considered
Part 1, Section 2 (12/99)
Effective from 1/1/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 2
as improvements and savings can be incorporated into future schemes. They can also be tested in practice, leading to the sort of continuous improvement recommended by the ‘Rethinking Construction’ report. 1.2.2.3
G
Value engineering works irrespective of the procurement route taken. It is a discipline upon the design team members and the clients who appoint them. Where the contractor is mainly responsible for the design, for example, design and build, develop and construct or PFI projects, the technique is just as appropriate in ensuring that a well-defined statement of requirements is first established and that subsequent design solutions address the function of the building most economically.
1.2.3 At What Stage Should Value Engineering be Carried Out? 1.2.3.1
The greatest benefits can be obtained by commencing the VE process at the earliest possible stage. Once it has been established that the client’s needs will best be met through a construction project the purpose of the first VE exercise should be to inform the brief. When an experienced client has prepared the brief, or a value management exercise has already examined the client’s requirements, the value engineering exercise (which will address the proposed design solutions) is best done towards the end of the ‘scheme design’. Several workshops may be necessary at each of the crucial decision-making stages of a project: (a) A first exercise (a functional analysis of requirements), to define the project needs and inform the brief, could be carried out as early as ‘option appraisal’, and since this could generate the greatest benefit to the client the timing is crucial. Carry it out too early and not enough will be known about the problems associated with the building function, whereas too late and minds become set on the solutions formulated by the design team. (b) A review of the project at ‘outline design’ could be conducted to ensure that the decisions taken earlier have been implemented or, if changed, that they still meet the functional requirements. (c) Another review (a functional analysis of the solutions) would then be carried out at ‘scheme design’ to test individual building elements involving traditional cost planning/life cycle costing techniques.
1.2.3.2
This section of the handbook considers the evaluation of a design at the end of the scheme design phase, but the process will be the same whenever it is carried out. The ‘objectives’ of the project should remain the same throughout the process and they should be validated at the beginning of each workshop. The objectives of each workshop may be different. If the project objectives do change the whole direction of the project will need to reassessed.
1.2.3.3
It is important that time for the value engineering process and any resultant redesign is included in the scheme design programme at the outset.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 3
PART 1, SECTION 2
G
1.2.4 Who Should Carry Out Value Engineering? 1.2.4.1
It is strongly recommended that a value engineering exercise is organized by an experienced value management facilitator to ensure that the value engineering participants retain their objectivity and that an unbiased approach is maintained.
1.2.4.2
The value engineering participants should represent the principal stakeholders in the project namely, the client, the building users and the design team (designer, engineers and quantity surveyor) and also the contractor, where applicable. It is important that each of the participants have the authority to make decisions at the workshop. It may also be appropriate to include clients’ advisers, for example, letting agents or rating valuers. The participants should be those who can make decisions and provide information related to the specific aims and objectives of the workshop. These may include: • those people with responsibility for the needs of the business; • those with specific responsibility for development, design and implementation of the operation/project; • those with responsibility for the management and/or maintenance of the operation; and • those who will be affected by the outcome. Different stakeholders will be required to participate at different stages of the project.
Page 4
1.2.4.3
The optimum size of a value engineering panel would depend upon the complexity of the project as well as the skills of the facilitator. However, it is considered that panels of more than twelve members are difficult to manage. Panels with fewer than four members could be considered ineffective. However, it is important that all stakeholders are represented even if this results in a larger group.
1.2.4.4
It is common practice in North America to appoint an outside team of consultants to question the design team’s solutions. However, this practice has been known to cause resentment between the project team and the external advisers and might therefore compromise the final design solutions. It is considered that an experienced facilitator independent of the design team, with an appropriately briefed panel, will ensure that the design team’s solutions are adequately tested at the workshop.
Part 1, Section 2 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 2
G
G
1.2.5 How Long Should It Last? 1.2.5.1
The length of time taken over the value engineering workshop will depend on the complexity of the project and the level of design detail that has been completed.
1.2.5.2
The ‘40-hour workshop’ is the classic industrial value engineering standard. However, two-day workshops at key points during the design process are more common in the UK construction industry.
1.2.6 Preparing for a Value Engineering Workshop 1.2.6.1
Prior to the workshop, it is most important that an agenda is agreed by the panel and distributed by the facilitator.
1.2.6.2
In addition to an agenda, a functional analysis of the client’s requirements should be drawn up. The client’s value criteria will have been developed in the first value management workshop. With each successive workshop these criteria will be developed further into a function diagram. This should be included in the workshop handbook. If it is to be developed further this will take place as part of the information stage of the workshop. The functional analysis should always be generated by the client representatives with the help of the other members of the workshop. It is the role of the facilitator to facilitate this process, not to take part in it. All participants must be prepared to propose and challenge design solutions. The input of all participants (not just those who are experts in a particular discipline) is one of the strengths of the VE process and should be encouraged by the facilitator.
G
1.2.7 Functional Analysis of Design Relative to the Client’s Requirements 1.2.7.1
It should be understood that it is not possible to find meaningful alternatives to a technical solution without first identifying the function required of it.
1.2.7.2
Functional analysis is any technique designed to appraise value by careful analysis of function. This can be simple ‘creative session’ of the functions and possible alternatives, but the most common method is using a functional analysis systems technique (FAST) diagram.
1.2.7.3
The FAST system uses a ‘function diagram’ which identifies the basic function ‘what is required’ on the left-hand side and more detailed secondary functions working from left to right until all the means of achieving these
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 5
PART 1, SECTION 2
functions ‘how are they to be fulfilled’ are identified on the right. See figure 2 for an example of a FAST diagram. It should be understood that this is a broad-brush technique. The objective of functional analysis is to produce a complete description of the end purpose of the design in terms of what it must do. Reference is sometimes made to different types of FAST diagram: Classical FAST, Technical FAST or Customer/Task FAST. The original FAST diagram was a presentation of the user-related and product-related functions of a design solution. It was a technique used to assemble the functions of a product in a hierarchy and to assess ‘why’ and ‘how’ they are delivered. This is known as a Classical FAST. Subsequently it was recognized that all functions did not fit into the flow logic so it was decided to separate out the functions that are always active, whether the product is operational or not. It was also decided to separate out those functions that only occur one time regardless of repetitiveness of the process. This diagram describes what a product, element or component must do and is known as a Technical FAST. It was then recognized that, ideally, it is the customer who should determine the value of the product and that the FAST diagram should include the customer/user in the development of value study projects. The resulting FAST Figure 2: FAST Diagram
Page 6
Part 1, Section 2 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 2
diagram has become known as a Customer or Task FAST. It is this concept from which the Value Tree has developed. All FAST diagrams should include a scope line on the left-hand side of the diagram. The scope line limits the area of the project on which attention is being focused. The scope is the portion of the project that is selected for the value study. The FAST model displays functions in a logical sequence and tests their dependency. It does not indicate how a function should be performed. There is no such thing as a correct FAST model, only a valid FAST model. 1.2.7.4
Most practitioners insist that functions are defined in terms of ‘active verb/measurable noun (or phrase)’ combinations, for example, ‘minimize energy consumption’. This improves clarity, helps all panel members develop a shared understanding and promotes the examination process. These should be interrogated by asking ‘why’ the client requires this in order to examine how it should be achieved.
1.2.7.5
The process of setting up a FAST diagram is of matching the functional elements of the building (object functions) to the client’s required functions (user functions). The functional requirements need to be broken down until they are reflected in elements which can be priced (and built). This process is called ‘functional decomposition’. For example, the requirement for increased energy efficiency might be provided by increased levels of insulation which might be achieved by changes to all or any of roof, walls, floor, windows and doors or finishes. The number of levels ‘of decomposition’ required cannot be predetermined.
1.2.7.6
VALUE TREE A Value Tree is a diagram that describes the business driver (mission) for a project or need and the criteria that need to be satisfied in order to achieve it. A Value Tree should be developed at an early stage in order to inform the brief. However, it can be developed at any stage in order to confirm the brief. It will generally be carried out by the client organization in order to establish whether a project is the solution to their needs. The criteria are then developed further into the functions required in order to achieve them. The scope line for a project will begin to the right of the Value Tree.
1.2.7.7
Appendix A gives an example of part of a Value Tree and a FAST diagram for a health centre. Function elements (object functions) are defined in the BCIS publication, Standard Form of Cost Analysis: Principles, Instructions and Definitions and in Section 2.3 of this handbook. A typical example of a value engineering process is included in Appendix B.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 7
PART 1, SECTION 2
G
G
1.2.8 Pricing the FAST Diagram 1.2.8.1
As the FAST diagram progresses and different solutions are found, it becomes possible to establish alternative costs for achieving a given function. However, it is important that all functions are clearly defined if costs of alternative proposals are to be meaningful. Also, it should be remembered that it is the design solutions to the functional requirements that are being priced and compared to the value and importance that the client puts on that function. For example, the client can identify the value of savings from reduced energy consumption or may rank this as important for other reasons. The value engineering team’s task is to put a price on the various design solutions suggested that will achieve this end. It is creativity in finding the most economical solution that is the essence of the value engineering exercise.
1.2.8.2
Fees and value added tax (VAT) and other financial and fiscal matters may also need to be considered.
1.2.9 Presenting a Design Solution to a Value Engineering Workshop 1.2.9.1
G
Design solutions should be presented as designers normally would to any panel of users. However, they should expect to be questioned quite extensively. They should keep an open mind and maintain objectivity in justifying their proposals because the objective is to find the most cost-effective solution, not to criticize for the sake of it. On the other hand, designers should be prepared to stand by their design solution if they think it is correct for the function being considered.
1.2.10 The Workshop 1.2.10.1
A value engineering workshop will work through phases of information, speculation, evaluation, development and presentation: (a) The ‘information phase’ identifies the spaces, elements and components in terms of the functions they fulfill. It asks the questions about what is the prime function of an element?; what are it’s subsidiary functions?; what does it cost?; what is it’s value? It is at this stage that the FAST diagram is developed and it is against the background of this information that the value engineering evaluation will be made. (b) ‘Speculation’ is the brainstorming stage which will generate the ideas from which solutions will be developed. It is important that each member of the panel thinks positively. The facilitator will ensure that no one is allowed to become overly critical of another member’s contribution in order that ideas flow. All ideas should be logged at this stage. However, in order to encourage idea building, they should not be analysed or rejected. It is important that the underlying functions of suggestions for improvement are listed for evaluation later. Design solutions should not be developed at this stage to ensure that
Page 8
Part 1, Section 2 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 2
‘what is to be achieved’ is properly addressed. All optional solutions should only be considered at the evaluation stage. (c) ‘Evaluation’ is the analysis of the ideas generated by the earlier speculation. Again, a positive feeling will be encouraged by the facilitator with advantages/disadvantages being discussed in an even-handed manner. At this stage some ideas will be rejected and the best taken forward. It is essential to ensure that all the ramifications of any suggested changes should be considered. For example, if the exercise has suggested a change to a piece of M&E equipment, the effects on the control management systems and structural requirements must also be considered. Life cycle costing can be an important factor in the process when considering optional solutions but the criticality of this aspect will hinge on the client’s philosophy. (d) ‘Development’ of the ideas to be taken forward will be initiated at the meeting and a programme established for completion of this stage. Often the detailed development including life cycle costing, if appropriate, will be continued beyond the initial meeting and the outcome presented to a subsequent meeting for the panel to determine which design options to adopt. (e) ‘Presentation’ takes the form of a report prepared by the facilitator which records in some detail all elements of the study and concludes with those options to be incorporated in the developed design. This report is normally presented to the client by the value engineering panel at a meeting held within one or two weeks of the date of the workshop. 1.2.10.2
G
The workshop should focus on expensive items or ‘mismatches’, for example, parts of the FAST diagram which are important to the client but which have been allocated little money or have cost a lot of money but do not contribute to the function.
1.2.11 Assessing the Value of the Workshop 1.2.11.1
Areas for research/change identified at the workshop could be grouped into three categories: (i) those that are removed/changed and result in reduced cost; (ii) those that are added/changed and result in additional cost; and (iii) those that are identified for investigation but not implemented
1.2.11.2
The financial benefit should then be identified against all elements within categories (i) or (ii).
1.2.11.3
A major benefit of the workshop which will be enjoyed by the panel members is a better understanding of the project functions and common ownership of the team-based designs solutions which have evolved.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 9
PART 1, SECTION 2
G
G
1.2.12 Implementing the Results 1.2.12.1
The value engineering panel’s decisions are recommendations that need to be accepted by all stakeholders. Those stakeholders that are not part of the panel are likely to have a right to comment before decisions are adopted.
1.2.12.2
Once the workshop’s proposals have been sanctioned by the client, decisions should be fed back to the design team, briefing those members whose work is affected as to why the changes were made.
1.2.12.3
If necessary, amendments to the design brief, design programme and scope of professional team’s brief should be incorporated into these documents.
1.2.13 Feedback from Post-Occupancy Evaluation 1.2.13.1
Page 10
It is important for any client to carry out a project review to demonstrate how project objectives have been achieved and particular problems overcome. As part of the project evaluation process, it should be established whether the project represents best value for money and whether or not key design changes made as a result of value engineering have achieved the benefits expected. These should always be set against the cost of carrying out the exercise.
Part 1, Section 2 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 2, APPENDIX A
Appendix A: Health Centre Value Tree
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 Appendix A (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 1
PART 1, S ECTION 2, A PPENDIX B
Appendix B: Typical Example of a Value Engineering Process B1
BACKGROUND A retail client with a regular development programme for a series of new stores (typical size 8,000m2) entered into a partnering agreement with key members of the construction team for four new projects. To encourage value engineering, the partnering contractors share in any savings that relate to any accepted proposals. For two of these projects the client opted for a design and build contract for the services installations (mechanical, sprinklers and electrical). In an effort to reduce costs and ultimately add value to the schemes, the client set a target of reducing the costs on these projects by 10 per cent, with no material effect on quality or health and safety. To set a benchmark for this reduction model cost plan costs for a typical store (derived from historical records) were modified to suit the new scheme layouts. Allowances were included for any items that were classified as ‘site specific’ (e.g. acoustic requirements stipulated by the district surveyor). Cost plan figures were based on the client’s current specification. Due to the volume of developments undertaken by the client and the repetitive nature of the works, the savings generated by value engineering can be incorporated in any future schemes.
B2
SPECIFIC EXAMPLE: VENTILATION TO SALES FLOOR The original design was based on previous solutions and included ‘traditional’ ventilation. At the ‘information phase’, the functional requirement, including the need for ventilation, was examined against the client’s desire to reduce capital costs. This identified that a high proportion of the cost of the mechanical installation related to the provision of ventilation to the sales floor of the store (plant, distribution ductwork, diffusers, etc.) At the ‘speculation phase’, the client’s engineering department worked closely with the mechanical partnering contractor to consider alternative methods of ventilating the sales floor of the store. The alternative method of ventilation proposed was of the displacement type. With displacement ventilation, air is only conditioned at the level at which occupiers are breathing. Air is introduced at low level and at low velocity. Natural convection currents are utilised to remove excess heat and pollutants out of the occupied zone. There is a saving in the amount of ductwork required, as only two runs of ductwork are needed on the sales floor. (The
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 Appendix B (12/99)
Effective from 1/1/00
Page 1
PART 1, S ECTION 2, A PPENDIX B
traditional method is designed for four separate branches of ductwork.) The new specification requires diffusers of the displacement type, with the facility of automatically varying the air throw pattern whether in heating or cooling mode. Furthermore, the proposed system required ventilation to the occupied zone only rather than the full building space. This has resulted in capital cost savings on plant and in the likely running costs of the system. The evaluation identified significant savings. Summary of Value Engineering Exercise
Original installation:
Traditional ventilation
Value engineering proposal: Displacement ventilation Benefits:
Saving on air handling plant size Saving on chiller plant size Saving on sales floor ductwork
Savings on capital cost:
Air handling plant Chiller plant Ductwork and diffusers
10% 5% 25%
At the ‘development phase’, the proposed method was discussed with other members of the design team to ensure that any impact on the other building elements, the project programme and the interface with other subcontractors were taken into account.
Page 2
Part 1, Section 2 Appendix B (12/99)
Effective from 1/1/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 1, SECTION 2, APPENDIX C
Appendix C: Further Reading British Standards Institute. Value Engineering, Value Analysis Vocabulary – Part 1: Value Analysis and Functional Analysis, BS EN 1325–1 1997, British Standards Institute, London, 2000. Building Cost Information Service. Elements for Design and Build, BCIS Ltd, 1996 Building Cost Information Service. Standard Form of Cost Analysis; Principles, Instructions and Definitions, BCIS Ltd, 1969 (Reprinted 1997) Connaughton, John, N., Green, Stuart, D., Construction Industry Research and Information Association. Value Management in Construction: A Client’s Guide, CIRIA, London, 1996 Dell’isola, Alphonse. Value Engineering in the Construction Industry, Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, 1983 Dell’isola, Alphonse. Value Engineering: Practical Software Applications for Design, Construction, Maintenance and Operations, R. S. Means & Co., Kingston, MA, 1997 Green, Stuart, D. and Popper, Peter, A. Value Engineering: The Search for Unnecessary Cost, Chartered Institute of Building, Berkshire, 1990 Institution of Civil Engineers. Creating Value in Enginering, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1996 Kelly, John and Male, Stephen. A Study of Value Management and Quantity Surveying Practice, RICS Books, Coventry, 1988 Kelly, J.R. and Male, S.P. A Study of Value Engineering and Quantity Surveying Practice, Heriott-Watt University, Edinburgh, 1989 Kelly, J.R. and Male, S.P., Heriot-Watt University, Department of Building Engineering and Surveying, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors. The Practice of Value Management: Enhancing Value or Cutting Cost? RICS, London, 1991 Law, Alastair, G. An Introduction to Value Engineering: A New Technique in Technology Assessment and Evalution, Alastair G. Law, Washington DC, 1981 May, Susan, C., College of Estate Management. Value Engineering and Value Management: A CPD Study Pack, College of Estate Management, Reading, 1994 Mole, Kelly, Fernie, Grongvist and Bowles. The Value Management Benchmark: Good Practice Framework for Clients and Practitioners. Thomas Telford Publishing, London 1998 Norton, Brian, R. and McElligott, William, C. Value Management in Construction: A Practical Guide, Macmillan, Basingstoke, 1995
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 1, Section 2 Appendix C (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 1
PART 1, SECTION 2, APPENDIX C
Palmer, Angela. A Critique of Value Management, Chartered Institute of Building, Berkshire, 1990 Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors. Value and the Client (papers presented at a conference held at the RICS on 29 January 1992), RICS, London, 1992 Smith, J., Jackson, N., Wyatt, R., Smyth, H., Beck, M., Chapman, K., Shirazi, A., Hampson, K., Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors. Can Any Facilitator Run a Value Engineering Workshop? RICS, London, 1998 Zimmerman, Larry, W. and Hart, Glen, D. Value Engineering: A Practical Approach for Owners, Designers and Contractors, Van Nostrand Reinhold & Co, New York, 1982
Page 2
Part 1, Section 2 Appendix C (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
PART TWO: CONSTRUCTION DESIGN AND ECONOMICS SECTION 1: PRE-CONTRACT COST PLANNING AND COST MANAGEMENT Introduction This Section of the Handbook sets out procedures which enable pre-contract cost management of building projects to be carried out from the client’s brief, through the various design stages to the acceptance of a contractor’s tender. Control of costs can only be achieved by the actions of the whole project team, including the client. The quantity surveyor’s role is to facilitate the design process by systematic application of cost criteria so as to maintain a sensible and economic relationship between cost, quality, utility and appearance which thus helps in achieving the client’s requirements within the agreed budget. The information and guidance which follow are based on a traditionally procured new-build project, but varying client requirements and different procurement methods may prevent implementation of some aspects of the following procedures. In practice, the design of the elements may proceed at different speeds and the stages described here may overlap. However, the principles of budget, cost plan, cost checks and reconciliation should be adhered to whenever possible. (See the figure showing the outline of the cost planning procedure.) On projects where non-traditional procurement routes are used, the responsibility for developing the cost plan may change but the stages suggested here remain appropriate. For example, on Design and Build (D&B) schemes, the client’s quantity surveyor will be responsible for the cost plan at feasibility and outline proposal stage and the D&B contractor’s quantity surveyor will be responsible for developing the cost plan with the contractor’s design team to produce the tender. The process described would apply to refurbishment or conversion schemes and the elemental approach would be suitable even if all elements were not required. The procedures are not designed for use with civil engineering projects, but should provide a framework appropriate to civil engineering needs.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 1
2.1.1 Pre-contract Cost Planning and Cost Management I
2.1.1.1
DEFINITION Pre-contract cost planning is the technique by which the budget is allocated to the various elements of an intended building project to provide the design team with a balanced cost framework within which to produce a successful design. It allows for the redistribution of the budget between elements as the design develops. Cost management is the total process which ensures that the contract sum is within the client’s approved budget or cost limit. It is the process of helping the design team design to a cost rather than the quantity surveyor costing a design.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
G
2.1.1.2
OBJECTIVES (a) To ensure that the client obtains an economical and efficient project in accordance with the agreed brief and budget; (b) to make the design process more efficient, thus reducing the time needed to produce a successful design; (c) to ensure that all requirements arising from the client’s brief to the design team are included in the cost planning process (e.g. the engineering services should also be subject to the cost planning process); and (d) to advise the client and members of the design team of cost-in-use or life-cycle costing techniques.
G
2.1.1.3
GENERALLY (a) A general principle applies throughout the cost planning process that any agreed budget or cost limit is seen as the maximum cost, and the quantity surveyor should, at all times, work with the other design team members to satisfy the client at a lower cost if possible, whilst still maintaining the desired objectives for quality and function. (b) If, at any time, sums have been included in the approved budget, for example, for abnormal site costs which subsequently are found to have been wholly or partially unnecessary, the consequential saving should always be notified to the client.
G
2.1.1.4
DESIGN STAGES References to Design Stages are to the RIBA Plan of Work (taken from the RIBA Handbook of Architectural Practice and Management) and refer to the main stages through which a project design typically passes. The links to the cost planning procedures outlined in this section are summarised here: Design Stages
Quantity Surveyor
Stage B: Feasibility
Prepare feasibility studies and determine the budget
Stage C: Outline Proposals
Consider with client and design team alternative strategies and prepare cost plan
Stage D: Scheme Design
Carry out cost checks and update cost plan if necessary
Stage E: Detail Design Stage F: Production Information Carry out cost checks Stage H: Tender Action The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Prepare reconciliation statement
Part 2, Section 1 (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 1
I
2.1.1.5
VALUE ENGINEERING A value engineering exercise may be carried out on all or part of the design during the design process. (For further details see part 1, section 2 of this handbook.) This might affect both the client’s requirements and the chosen design solution and changes would, therefore, affect the budget and the cost plan.
2.1.2 Preliminary cost studies and feasibility studies G
2.1.2.1
It is recommended, as a matter of importance, that before and during the formulation of the client’s brief (Design Stage B: Feasibility), the quantity surveyor, in consultation with other members of the design team and the client, should undertake such feasibility studies as may be necessary to ensure that the client’s requirements can be reasonably accommodated within the finance that is available for the project. The client’s budget is established as a result of these studies. (See 2.1.3.)
2.1.3 Budget I
2.1.3.1
DEFINITION Budget is the total expenditure authorised by the client which is the responsibility of the design team at the end of the feasibility stage (Design Stage B).
G
2.1.3.2
OBJECTIVES (a) To establish the limit of expenditure necessary to meet the client’s brief. The client’s and project’s status with regard to VAT (Value Added Tax) will also need to be established; (b) to provide the client with a statement of the likely area and quality of building, which is achievable within the limit of expenditure; (c) to provide a statement of the recommended methods of construction and of the contractual procedures to achieve the required occupation date; and (d) to provide the client with alternative budgets for different occupation dates and qualities of building, if appropriate.
G
2.1.3.3
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS (a) The ideal requirements from the client and members of the project team to the quantity surveyor are given below. On projects where this level of information is not available, the quantity surveyor should state clearly any assumptions made. It is possible to produce a typical elemental estimate for
Page 4
Part 2, Section 1 (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
a particular type of building from very little information, but it is important to clarify as many information issues as possible before such an estimate is accepted as the budget for a particular project. (b) Information required from the client: • location of the site; availability of the site for commencement of construction work; • in conjunction with the designer, architect or building surveyor, a schedule of accommodation; • names of other similar buildings of broadly suitable quality if appropriate; • the required occupation date or phased occupation dates; • any specific requirements relating to life-cycle costs; • any specific requirements as to specification and/or procedures; • requirements in respect of the treatment of inflation; • instructions regarding Construction (Design and Management) Regulations; and • the client’s VAT status and any other tax matters which may affect the overall cost of the project. (c) Information required from the designer, architect, building surveyor, or other source: • approximate location of the building on the site; • advice on necessary storey heights for any specialist areas shown on schedule of accommodation; • advice on statutory regulations; • advice on routes of public sewers and the like; • designer’s concept of building; and • names of similar projects previously designed by the practice. (d) Information required from the structural engineer: • advice on probable ground conditions; • advice on probable floor loadings; and • any information on structural solutions. (e) Information required from the services engineer: • advice on areas of building which will require specialist engineering services; • any information on the types of systems; and • advice on availability of public utility services. Note: If the quantity surveyor is not responsible for cost planning the engineering services, this should be clearly stated in the budget and cost plan. The information from the quantity surveyor to the design team is as follows:
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 5
PART 2, SECTION 1
(An example of a format for the quantity surveyor’s report is given in Appendix B to this Section.) (f) Information to be provided to the client involves a report containing: • the budget, with alternative proposals if appropriate; • a statement of the basis of the budget calculation including any important assumptions made; • a statement setting out the programme for design and construction on which the budget is based; • an outline cash-flow forecast; • a statement of any items not included; and • assumptions in respect of inflation forecasts and current/future market conditions. (g) Information to be provided to the designer: • a copy of the report sent to the client; and • a more detailed statement of the quantity and quality parameters included in the calculations. (h) Information to be provided to other consultants: • such quantity and quality parameters as relate to their area of design. G
2.1.3.4
METHODS OF PREPARATION (a) The method of preparation depends on the type of project involved. Unusual projects, projects of great complexity and projects containing a large element of alterations are more difficult to budget accurately at an early stage. (b) For most types of project, it is possible to build up an elemental budget using the parameters set out under G 2.1.3.5. This can be based on cost information from previous projects, from the RICS Building Cost Information Service (BCIS), other published sources, or on an appropriate cost model. (c) The main elemental quantities of hypothetical buildings can be generated using agreed parameters, to which rates applicable to agreed quality and performance standards can be applied. An example of a method of calculating hypothetical quantities is described in Appendix C to this Section. (d) Once the budget has been established, it provides the first cost plan for the project, and the framework for the actual design to be developed.
G
2.1.3.5
STATEMENT OF QUANTITY AND QUALITY PARAMETERS The main parameters which should normally be incorporated in the calculation are as follows (the list is not exhaustive):
Page 6
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
(a) Quantity • in addition to the briefed areas, a statement of the allowances (e.g. circulation) used to calculate a gross floor area; • the number of storeys of a possible solution; • the storey height(s); • the square index or wall/floor ratio (see appendix C to this section); • the density of vertical division or partition/floor ratio (see appendix C to this section); • proportion of window area; • floor loadings; • thermal resistance values of fabric; • air change rates; • heating and hot-water loads; • lighting levels; • total electrical load; • areas of the brief with special functions of significant cost; • road area and number of car parking spaces; • paved pedestrian areas; and • length of boundary walls or fencing. (b) Quality • A general statement of quality and specification which relates to the rates used for the budget calculation. This should cover specifically at least the following: foundations, roof, external walls, floors and vertical circulation, internal vertical division, internal finishes, lighting and other services. External works should include roads, paths, landscape, boundary walls and fences, and service mains, planting and the like. G
2.1.3.6
INFLATION (a) The prediction of future inflation may not be necessary for some clients, and a statement of cost at current prices may be adequate. Where an assessment of inflation is required for more than a few months ahead, a range of probable inflation is best provided. This can be calculated using predictions published, for example by BCIS or the Department of Trade and Industry. The assumptions upon which the prediction is made should be stated. (b) Some clients, particularly in the public sector, have their own inflation controls. Where the client requests that a particular level of inflation be included in the budget, the quantity surveyor should inform the client if he or she believes it to be unrealistic.
G
2.1.3.7
COST REPORTING If at any time during the design process it becomes apparent that the agreed budget is likely to be exceeded without the brief being changed, the client should be informed and instructions requested. Likewise, if it becomes
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 7
PART 2, SECTION 1
apparent that the whole of the agreed budget will not be required, the client should be informed.
2.1.4 The cost plan at outline proposals stage I
2.1.4.1
DEFINITION The cost plan at outline proposals stage is a statement of the probable cost of the project at Design Stage C which sets out the cost targets for the main elements of a building, together with their approximate quantity and quality parameters.
G
2.1.4.2
OBJECTIVES (a) To describe, together with the outline proposal drawings, the chosen distribution of the resources within the budget to provide a balanced design to meet the client’s needs; (b) to set cost targets for the main elements so that, as the design develops, the targets can be checked and adjustments made so that the overall cost of the project is managed within the budget; (c) to provide the design team with controls which communicate the costs, quantity, quality and time parameters to be followed; and (d) to provide the opportunity for consideration of life-cycle costs.
G
2.1.4.3
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS The basic information requirements from the members of the project team to be provided to the quantity surveyor are as follows: (a) Information required from the client: • the budget. Where alternative budgets have been quoted in the budget report, the client should state the preferred alternative; • confirmation of the programme for design and construction times stated in the budget report; • confirmation of the brief; • acceptance or variation of any other matters within the budget report; and • authority to proceed. (b) Information required from the designer: • outline drawings of the building and site works indicating alternative solutions; and • an indication of the preferred specification for the main elements. (c) Information required from the structural engineer: • outline proposals or alternative structural solutions.
Page 8
Part 2, Section 1 (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
(d) Information required from the services engineer: • outline proposals for installations, indicating any alternative systems; and • an indication of the preferred specification, after acceptance by the designer of its visual implications. (e) Information required from specialist consultants: • outline proposals. The basic information requirements from the quantity surveyor to the design team are as follows: (An example of a format for the quantity surveyor’s report is given in Appendix B to this Section.) (f) Information to be provided to the client involves a report containing: • a statement of cost; • a broad indication of the specification; • a statement of floor areas; • a request for decisions on any alternative proposals and/or procurement routes, with advice thereon; • an updated cash-flow forecast; • allowances for contingencies and design reserve; and • an update of inflation projections. (g) Information to be provided to the designer: • a copy of the documents sent to the client; and • the cost plan with target costs for each element. (h) Information to be provided to other consultants: • such quality and quantity parameters as relate to their design responsibilities and target costs. G
2.1.4.4
METHODS OF PREPARATION (a) The method of preparation should be appropriate to the level of detail available for each element and may be: • the measurement of approximate quantities and the application of rates to the quantities generated; • comparison of the requirements with analyses of previous projects of a similar character; • use of appropriate cost models; and/or • a mixture of the above methods. (b) Evaluation should be made of the alternative forms of construction, or systems, of the ‘key’ elements, e.g. structural elements, and service installations. The ‘key’ elements on each project will vary. However, they are likely to be those with major financial consequences, and to include the structural and service elements.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 9
PART 2, SECTION 1
G
2.1.4.5
STATEMENT OF QUANTITY AND QUALITY PARAMETERS The quantity surveyor’s statement should include the following: (a) Quantity Confirmation of information provided at budget stage with the addition of: • the areas of the accommodation divided into use classification (e.g. office/classroom space, sanitary accommodation space, plant-room space, circulation space), totalled to give gross floor area; and • a schedule of those items for which lump sum allowances have been incorporated and a note on the sources of this information. (b) Quality • a statement of quality and specification, in a similar format to that provided at budget stage, expanded to incorporate additional information. The parameters should follow those included at the budget stage, and where possible, be based upon the outline drawings and preferred specifications.
G
2.1.4.6
DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION PERIOD (a) In establishing the outline cost plan, it is recommended that the quantity surveyor take account of proposals made by the other members of the design team and their effects upon both the design and construction programmes. (b) If completion dates are critical, components and/or systems should be selected with a view to the availability of acceptable alternatives so as to avoid supply difficulties.
G
2.1.4.7
CONTROLLING CHANGES TO THE COST PLAN Should a change be proposed to the outline cost plan, or to the scope of the work, the following procedures should be implemented: • all relevant members of the design team should be informed; • the designer should confirm his agreement, in principle, to the proposal; • no proposal should be incorporated into the cost plan without the agreement of the quantity surveyor, and his confirmation or otherwise that the proposal can be met within the elemental target; • where the proposal involves additional cost over the elemental target, or would cause the total budget to be exceeded, the quantity surveyor should identify to the design team alternative savings that are available in order to maintain the overall budget; • the quantity surveyor should take into account, when considering a proposed change, any likely effect on the design and construction programme; • in all considerations of alternative proposals, the use of consultants for additional work should take into account any consequential addition to professional fees. In particular, this applies to consulting engineers, whose fees are calculated only on specific parts of the project; and
Page 10
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
• upon the determination of a proposed change, the quantity surveyor should communicate to the client and all members of the design team, the effects of such change and provide an updated cost plan. G
2.1.4.8
INFLATION Any changes in inflation forecasts should be reported periodically.
2.1.5 The Cost Plan at Scheme Design Stage Note: If the cost plan has been produced at an earlier design stage only updating may be required. I
2.1.5.1
DEFINITION The cost plan at scheme design stage is a statement of the cost of a selected design at Design Stage D which details the cost targets for all elements of a building, together with the quantity and quality parameters described by the scheme drawings and specifications.
G
2.1.5.2
OBJECTIVES (a) To set out for the design team the actual distribution of resources described by the scheme design; (b) To set cost targets for all the elements so that, as the detail design develops, the targets are checked and adjustments made in order that the overall cost of the project is managed within the budget; and (c) To provide the whole design team with a control document which describes, in detail, the costs, quantity, quality and time parameters which have been adopted.
G
2.1.5.3
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS The information to be provided to the quantity surveyor is as follows: (a) Information required from the client: • confirmation or otherwise that the cost plan prepared at the outline stage is accepted; • confirmation of the brief; • an indication of any preferred alternatives in a previous cost plan; • acceptance or variation of any other matters within the previous cost plan report; and • authority to proceed. (b) Information required from the designer: • scheme drawings and scheme specifications. (c) Information required from the structural engineer; • scheme drawings and scheme specifications;
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 11
PART 2, SECTION 1
• confirmation of floor loadings and the like; and • provisional indication of reinforcement weights, where appropriate. (d) Information required from the services engineer: • scheme drawings and scheme specifications; and • detailed design parameters, e.g. heat loads, and electrical loads. (e) Information required from specialist consultants: • scheme drawings and scheme specifications. The basic information requirements from the quantity surveyor to the design team are as follows: (An example of a format for the quantity surveyor’s report is given in Appendix B to this Section.) (f) Information to be provided to the client, involves a report containing: • a statement of the cost; • a statement of the specification; • a statement of the floor areas; • a statement of the proposed design and construction programme; • a cash-flow forecast, where appropriate; • a statement of the relevant life-cycle costs, where appropriate; and • an update of inflation forecasts. (g) Information to be provided to the designer: • a copy of documents sent to the client; and • the cost plan with target costs for each element. (h) Information to be provided to the other consultants: • such quality and quantity parameters as relate to their area of design and their target costs. G
2.1.5.4
METHODS OF PREPARATION (a) The method of preparation is normally by measurement of approximate quantities from the proposed scheme drawings. The degree of detail to be measured should relate to the cost significance of the elements in the particular design. The pricing should be similarly related. Some elements may still be most suitably priced on an elemental unit rate basis, where the cost significance is low. Major elements will normally need to be priced in greater detail. (b) The preliminary engineering and specialist services scheme drawings and outline specification notes will be required from the consulting engineers, from which approximate quantities of equipment can be measured and priced using all-in rates. Pipework and cables will normally still need to be priced on an overall basis relating to floor area or service points at this stage. This ensures that the likely implications of the builder’s work are understood by the design team and the costs are taken into account.
Page 12
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
G
2.1.5.5
STATEMENT OF QUANTITY AND QUALITY PARAMETERS The quantity surveyor’s statement should include the following: (a) Quantity confirmation of the information provided at outline proposal stage (b) Quality a statement of quality and specification based on scheme drawings in sufficient detail to provide control of the production information drawings by the designer and consultants (c) Life-cycle information a statement of the likely relevant maintenance, cleaning, and running costs which are required or implied by the scheme design proposals and the expected life of major components.
G
2.1.5.6
CONTROLLING CHANGES TO THE COST PLAN The principles have been described in G 2.1.4.7.
G
2.1.5.7
INFLATION Any changes in inflation forecasts should be reported.
2.1.6 Cost Checking I
2.1.6.1
DEFINITION Cost checking is the process of calculating the costs of specific design proposals and comparing them with the cost plan during the whole design process (Design Stages D–F).
G
2.1.6.2
OBJECTIVES (a) To confirm that as the design develops, the cost remains within the budget; and (b) To reduce the abortive design work and lost time caused through proceeding too far in the design process before realisation that the budget will be exceeded.
2.1.6.3
PRINCIPLES (a) The methods will vary according to the stage reached in the design process. Normally, however, this takes the form of measurement of approximate quantities from the consultants’ drawings to provide a check on the quantity and quality of parameters set down in the appropriate cost plan. The gross floor area should always be the first check at any stage. (b) The dominant considerations in deciding the priorities for cost checking elements are as follows:
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 13
PART 2, SECTION 1
• the cost significance of an element related to the total cost of the project; and • the known variability in cost of any element. Should a wide range of cost be possible in an element, it becomes necessary to cost check it before checking any elements of low variability but of the same overall cost significance. G
2.1.6.4
IDENTIFICATION AND NOTIFICATION OF EXCESS COSTS (a) It is recommended that judgement be applied before notifying the designer of possible excess expenditure in a particular element. If an excess revealed during cost checking is of such significance that it is highly improbable that compensating savings are available elsewhere, then such excess should be reported immediately and the design team be asked to consider modification of the cost plan. If, however, the excess (or saving) revealed in an element is relatively small and there are still a number of elements to be checked, it is usually more appropriate to advise the designer of the difference and to suggest that action is held until other cost checks have been carried out. (b) It is important for the quantity surveyor to maintain records of the cost checking process, and to set down in summary the value of the elements cost checked compared with the cost plan targets. Identification of the drawings and information upon which the cost check has been based is also important.
2.1.7 Action after Receipt of Tenders G
2.1.7.1
DEFINITION (a) Action after receipt of tenders is that required at the tender stage (Design Stage H) in analysing each tender and updating information for the client and consultants. (b) The following points should be noted: • In most cases, sound cost planning will produce tenders within budget. If, due to market conditions or late changes in designs and specification, adjustments need to be made to a tender, information on potential savings will need to be identified by the design team; and • If there are significant changes from the initial tender documents, consideration should be given to the need for seeking revised tenders.
G
2.1.7.2
OBJECTIVES (a) To obtain a contract sum within the approved budget; and (b) To provide suitable analyses for future projects.
Page 14
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1
G
2.1.7.3
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS Information to be provided to the quantity surveyor is as follows: (a) Information required from the client: • acceptance of potential savings, if required; • details in respect of any analyses required. (Where the client body is a Public Authority or similar, where standard analyses are always required, consideration of this matter should be given during the preparation of the Bills of Quantities); and • permission to submit analyses to BCIS if appropriate. (b) Information required from the designer, architect, building surveyor and other consultants; • a provisional list of potential areas of saving (to be considered during tendering period and before tender acceptance); and • a detailed list of drawings and other sources of data from which to determine actual savings, if required. (c) Information required from other sources: • indexing of the tender by BCIS to establish confirmation of tender levels, if appropriate. The basic information requirements from the quantity surveyor are as follows: (d) Information to be provided to the client involves a report containing: • a statement of the cost reconciled to the latest budget; • any further information in respect of the construction programme; and • an updated preliminary cash-flow forecast, where appropriate. (e) Information to be provided to the designer: • a copy of documents sent to the client; and • a detailed reconciliation between the tender and the latest cost plan. (f) Information to be provided to the other consultants: • such information as relates to their area of design and associated costs.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 15
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
Appendix A: Sources of cost information A1
OBJECTIVE To ensure that all costs used are up to date and accurate.
A2
SOURCES
A2.1
Elemental cost analysis • in-house cost analyses of previous projects; • Building Cost Information Service (BCIS); and • Architects’ Journal.
A2.2
Unit rate information • in-house priced bills of quantities; • specialist suppliers’ quotations; • Spon’s (E & FN Spon) – a range of price books covering most areas of construction; • Laxton’s – a range of price books covering most areas of construction; • Ti Wessex – a range of price books covering most areas of construction; • Griffiths Building Price Book; • Building Maintenance Information’s Building Maintenance Price Book; and • Glenigan Cost Information Services – Material Price Guides. Note: Current editions of price books are available from RICS Books.
A2.3
Published indices • tender indices and cost studies on regional variations – BCIS; • the published indices of the Department of Trade and Industry; • Price Adjustment Formulae for Construction Contracts (NEDO) Indices – Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions; • Architects’ Journal; and • Building.
A3
The use of published information The following points should be considered carefully when using any of the above information: • differential rates of inflation on various aspects/elements of the building; • acute shortages in specific trades at different times; • regional variations; • market conditions applicable to information based on project specific information such as elemental cost analyses and bills of quantities; • external published information;
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix A (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
• • •
• •
• • •
Page 2
consideration of the tender period of the analysis and its relationship to the current project’s tender period; high levels of inflation demand constant checking and revision of rates and prices; the assumption that cost information in elemental cost analysis is tendered price information, whereas a significant amount could be in prime cost or provisional sums; initial quotations from specialists are likely to be low; building regulations can be statutorily amended, e.g. energy conservation measures have increased the ‘U’ value (a measurement of thermal resistance) requirements for insulation properties of roofs and walls. Care must therefore be taken to ensure that the analysis used is consistent with current building standards; firm price or fluctuating contract terms; special planning conditions applying either to the analysed or to the current project; and site-specific constraints in either the analysed or current project.
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix A (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
Appendix B: Format of budget and cost plans B1
OBJECTIVE
B1.1
To communicate clearly the basis of the budget and cost plans to the client, designer and consultants.
B2
FORMAT
B2.1
The presentation of information to the client and design team should be of a high standard. Budget and cost plans result from the application of a high level of professional skill, and the format of documents should reflect the importance that the profession attaches to this service.
B2.2
The example format included here is intended to be an example of good practice showing the main areas of information that may require coverage. The presentation and content will need to be adjusted to meet the specific requirements of individual organisations and their clients. The ‘Report to Client and Design Team’ is intended as a guide as to what can be provided to a client to ensure that there is a clear statement of the budget or cost limits, its inclusions and exclusions, together with the total programme to which the budget relates and the standards which have been used in its calculation. These are client orientated. Provision is made for the quantity surveyor to suggest alternatives which the client may wish to consider. A copy of information sent to the client should also be sent to the design team.
B2.3
Additional information to be sent to the design team once the cost plan is prepared is set out in the ‘Report to the Design Team’. The main parameters affecting the cost targets should be clearly set out.
B2.4
The level of detail to be included in these documents should relate to the size and complexity of projects. Simple projects may require less information than shown in the example; complex projects significantly more.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix B (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (referred to in B2.2 of this appendix) CONSTRUCTION BUDGET AND PROGRAMME Client Project Location Budget serial number: COSTS (for basis see sheet .......) Price base date: New building work:
Site works:
Alterations:
Construction costs (at stated price base) Estimate inflation to probable tender date of
Construction costs at tender Estimated increased costs payable to contractors during construction period Construction costs at completion Professional fees of all consultants including expenses
Value Added Tax – On construction On fee
% %
Total budget of construction works and fees
Exclusions from budget
Page 2
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix B (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
zzz
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) TIME Preliminary/Final Programme (weeks) as Budget Cost 0
Alternative 1 0
Alternative 2 0
Client decision to accept budget and proceed Final brief and scheme design approved
Receipt of first tenders
Formation of contract
Construction commencement
Client occupation: phase phase phase phase Total Cost Variation (including fees)
Contractor and/or construction implications of programme
The alternative time scales shown make the following assumptions: Alternative 1
Alternative 2
CASH FLOW – FORECAST Quarterly from acceptance of budget and authority to proceed (including fees)
1Q
2Q
3Q
4Q
5Q
6Q
7Q
8Q
9Q
10Q 11Q 12Q
Balance
Total
As Budget Cost
Alternative 1 Alternative 2
Note: All figures in thousands ’Occupation quarter indicated by ‘O’
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Construction commencement quarter indicated by ‘C Balance shown normally payable during first year of occupation
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) BASIS OF BUDGET Areas Schedule of accommodation
Area m2
Min. floor to ceiling height (m)
Max. floor loadings – kN/m2
Comment
TOTAL FLOOR AREA
Quality Standards External elevations:
Internal finishes:
Heating & ventilation:
Lighting:
Site works:
Other (specify):
Exclusions from budget:
Page 4
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) Alternative standards
Alternatives
Cost: extra/saving
Comment
Budget prepared by:
Signature:
____________________________________________
Firm:
____________________________________________
Date: ____________________
____________________________________________ ____________________________________________ ____________________________________________
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix B (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 5
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO DESIGN TEAM (referred to in B2.3 of this appendix) TECHNICAL QUANTITY AND QUALITY PARAMETERS Budget serial number BUILDING
Quantity Gross floor area
m2
Maximum square index
(Perimeter on plan
m.)
No. of storeys
Floor to ceiling heights: lowest floor
m.
intermediate floors
m.
highest floor
m.
Floor/roof zone
m.
Calculated external wall/floor ratio
Proportion of glazed external wall area
%
Density of vertical division
(length of partitions and internal walls measured over door openings m.)
Calculated partition/floor ratio Lifts ____________________________
Number ____________________
Type _______________________________
Stairs: number of flights
Structural Ground bearing pressure
kN/m2
Floor loadings:
Ground water level Ground
kN/m2 (maximum live)
Intermediate
kN/m2 (maximum live)
Highest
kN/m2 (maximum live) kN/m2 (maximum live)
Roof loading:
Environmental Fabric ‘U’ values:
Roof
W/m2°C
Walls (average)
W/m2°C
Ground floor
W/m2°C
Air change rates and air temperature (Specify spaces and rates/hour and minimum temperatures) Heating load
kW
Hot water load
kW
Page 6
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix B (05/03)
(
Effective from 1/7/03
W/m2)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO DESIGN TEAM (continued) REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) TECHNICAL QUANTITY AND QUALITY PARAMETERS (continued) Lighting levels (Specify spaces, lux level and load in W/m2)
Total lighting load
kW
(
w/m2)
Total power load
kW
(
w/m2)
Special areas with higher than average service or other costs (specify)
Other
External Works Site area Road area
hectares m2
Pedestrian paved area
m2
Boundary walls or fencing
m2
Car Parking: Number of spaces
No.
Area
m2
Other
If quantities calculated from drawings state drawing number(s) etc.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 7
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO DESIGN TEAM (continued) REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) COST PLAN
Building: .....................................................................................................
Element
Total cost
1
Substructure
2A 2B 2C 2D 2E 2F 2G 2H 2
Frame Upper floors Roof Stairs External walls Windows and external doors Internal walls and partitions Internal doors Superstructure
Cost per m2
Element unit quantity
Element unit rate
3A Wall finishes 3B Floor finishes 3C Ceiling finishes Internal finishes 4
Fittings
5A 5B 5C 5D 5E 5F 5G 5H 5I 5J 5K 5L 5M 5N 5O 5
Sanitary appliances Services equipment Disposal installations Water installations Heat source Space heating and air treatment Ventilating systems Electrical installations Gas installations Lift and conveyor installations Protective installations Communications installations Special installations Builder’s work in connection Builder’s profit and attendance Services Building sub-total
6A 6B 6C 6D 6
Site works Drainage External services Minor building works External works
7
Preliminaries Total (less contingencies)
8
Contingencies Construction costs
Page 8
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) REPORT TO DESIGN TEAM (continued) COST PLAN
Building: .....................................................................................................
Elements
1
Specification included in budget/cost plan
Alternatives
Cost + or –
Substructure
2A Frame 2B Upper floors 2C Roof 2D Stairs 2E External walls 2F
Windows and external doors
2G Internal walls and partitions 2H Internal doors 3A Wall finishes 3B Floor finishes 3C Ceiling finishes 4
Fittings and furnishings
5A Sanitary appliances 5B Services equipment 5C Disposal installations
Page 9
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) REPORT TO DESIGN TEAM (continued) SPECIFICATION
Building: ................................................................................................
Elements
Specification included in budget/cost plan
Alternatives
Cost + or –
5D Water installations 5E Heat source 5F
Space heating and air treatment
5G Ventilating systems 5H Electrical installations 5I
Gas installations
5J
Lift and conveyor installations
5K Protective installations 5L
Communication installations
5M Special installations 5N Builder’s work in connection with services 5O Builder’s profit and attendance on services 6A Site work 6B Drainage 6C External services 6D Minor building works
Page 10
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX B
REPORT TO CLIENT AND DESIGN TEAM (continued) REPORT TO DESIGN TEAM (continued) COST TARGETS Building: .......................................................... Elements
Page 11
Price base: ............................................ Parameter
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix B (4/98)
Rate
Effective from 1/6/98
Target cost
19 ............... Cost per m2
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX C
Appendix C: Element Unit Quantities Generation for Hypothetical Buildings Where very little quantity information is available at the early stages of a project, estimates of elemental quantities can be produced using standard formulae and typical assumptions. Some of the most common formulae and some worked examples are given here. WALL TO FLOOR RATIO This is a simple method of expressing the relationship of the external walls to internal floor area. It is the ratio of the area of external walls (including windows and doors) to the gross internal floor area. Formula w = e A
where e = area of external walls including windows and doors A = gross internal floor area w = wall to floor ratio
SQUARE INDEX This is an alternative way of expressing the relationship between the floor area and the external walls. It describes the degree to which the perimeter length of an actual building exceeds that of a building of the same area which is a perfect square. Any single storey building can be described, as can also multi-storey buildings, with a constant shape on each floor. Formula s =
where p = perimeter length on plan
p — 4í a
a = area on plan (not the gross floor area in multi-storey buildings) s = square index
DENSITY OF VERTICAL DIVISION This density provides a coarse measure of the amount of partitioning, loadbearing walls, etc. that a building contains. As the formula includes the perimeter of the building, it takes into account the contribution to the enclosure of spaces that this makes. Formula d = ( 1–2 åp) + L A
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix C (4/98)
where p = sum of the perimeter lengths of a building measured on each floor L = total length of partitions, etc. measured over doors A = gross internal floor area d = density of vertical division
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX C
Example of element quantity generation for a hypothetical building ASSUMPTIONS From brief, gross floor area = 1350 m2 (including circulation) Site area dictates a two storey solution = 2 storeys Average floor to ceiling height: 2.7 m. Assumed floor/roof zone: 0.6 m. Square index*: 1.4 Wall to floor ratio*: 0.7 Percentage of windows and doors in external walls*: 30% Density of vertical division*: 0.3 Area of ground floor = 675 m2 * These parameters can be based on information from typical or similar schemes.
The quantities calculated in this, or similar ways, can then be used with selected element unit rates to calculate budgets and cost plans for projects in the earliest stages of design, or for checking the approximate cost difference of alternative design solutions. † A percentage can be used to split ‘wall’ from ‘window’, e.g. window and door area = external walls × w = 945 m2 × 30% = 284 m2.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix C (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX C
where
A= n= a= s= f= d= w=
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
gross floor area number of storeys ground floor area square index floor to wall ratio density of vertical division percentage of windows and doors in external walls.
Part 2, Section 1 Appendix C (4/98)
Effective from 1/6/98
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX D
Appendix D: Further reading A selection of further reading is given below. Whilst not comprehensive it is considered to be appropriate. Copies of articles and older books are available from the RICS Library whilst current books are available from RICS Books (www.ricsbooks.com). BOOKS Ahuja, H. N., Successful Construction Cost Control, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1980 Ashworth, A. and Hogg, K., Willis’s Practice and Procedure for the Quantity Surveyor (11th edition), Blackwell Science, Oxford, 2001 Ashworth, A., Building Economics and Cost Control: Worked Solutions, Butterworths, London, 1983 Ashworth, A., Contractual Procedures in the Construction Industry (4th edition), Longman, 2001 Ashworth, A., Cost Studies of Buildings (3rd edition), Longman, Harlow, 1999 Ashworth, A., Pre-Contract Studies: Development, Economics, Tendering and Estimating (2nd edition), Blackwell, Oxford, 2002 Bathurst, P. E. and Butler, D. A., Building Cost Control Techniques and Economics (2nd edition), Heinemann, London, 1980 Brandon, P. (ed.), Building Cost Techniques: New Directions, E & FN Spon, London, 1982 Brandon, P. S. (ed.), Building Cost Modelling and Computers, E & FN Spon, London, 1987 Buchan, R. D., Fleming, F. W. E. and Grant, F. E. K., Estimating for Builders and Surveyors (2nd edition), Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 2003 Building Cost Information Service, Elements for Design and Build, BCIS, Kingston upon Thames, 1996 Building Cost Information Service, Standard Form of Cost Analysis: Principles, Instructions and Definitions, RICS, 1969 (reprinted August 2001) Cartlidge, D. P. and Mehrtens, I. N., Practical Cost Planning: A Guide for Surveyors and Architects, Hutchinson, London, 1982 Chudley, R. and Greeno, R., Building Construction Handbook (4th edition), Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 2001 Ferry, D. J., Ferry, J. D. and Brandon, P. S., Cost Planning of Buildings (7th edition), Blackwell Science, 1999 Egan, J. and Construction Task Force, Rethinking Construction, DETR, London, 1998 Gruneberg, S. L. and Weight, D. H., Feasibility Studies in Construction, Mitchell, London, 1990
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix D (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX D
Hackett, M. et al., Pre-Contract Practice and Contract Administration for the Building Team (9th edition), Blackwell, Oxford, 2002 Hall, F. and Greeno, R., Building Services Handbook (2nd edition), Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 2003 Institution of Civil Engineers, Management of International Construction Projects, Thomas Telford, London, 1985 Jaggar, D. et al., Building Design Cost Management, Blackwell, Oxford, 2002 Jaggar, D. and Morton, R., Design and the Economics of Building, E & FN Spon, London, 1995 Jaggar, D. M. and Liverpool John Moores University, Civil Engineering Cost Analysis (CECA), BCIS, Kingston upon Thames, 1997 Kelly, J. et al., Best Value in Construction, Blackwell, Oxford, 2002 Kharbanda, O. P., Stallworthy, E. A. and Williams, L. F., Project Cost Control in Action (2nd edition), Gower Technical Press, Aldershot, 1987 Latham, M. and Department of the Environment, Constructing the Team: Joint Review of Procurement and Contractual Arrangements in the United Kingdom Construction Industry: Final Report July 1994, HMSO, London, 1994 Masterman, J., Introduction to Building Procurement Systems (2nd edition), Spon Press, 2001 McCabe, S., Benchmarking in Construction, Blackwell Science, Oxford, 2001 Miller, F., Building and Civil Engineering Cost-Value Comparisons, Ruthtrek Limited, Herne Bay, 1992 Neil, J. N., Constructing Cost Estimating for Project Control, Prentice Hall Inc., New Jersey, 1982 Nisbet, J., Estimating and Cost Control, Batsford, London, 1961 Pilcher, R., Project Cost Control in Construction (2nd edition), Blackwell Scientific Publications Ltd, Oxford, 1994 Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, Developing an Appropriate Building Procurement Strategy (see part 3, section 1 of this handbook) Seeley, I. H., Building Economics: Appraisal and Control of Building Design Cost and Efficiency (4th edition), Macmillan, Basingstoke, 1996 Stone, P. A., Building Design Evaluation: Costs in Use (3rd edition), Spon, 1980 Stone, P. A., Building Economy, Design Production and Organisation (3rd edition), Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1983 Strategic Forum for Construction, Accelerating Change, Rethinking Construction, 2002 Ward, S. A., Cost Engineering for Effective Project Control, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1992
Page 2
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix D (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 1, APPENDIX D
Wilson, R. M. S., Cost Control Handbook (2nd edition), Gower Publishing, Aldershot, 1983 ARTICLES AND REPORTS Abdullah, R. Z. and Tyler, A. H., ‘Meeting the Problems of Cost Control Systems’, Building Technology & Management, 24(4) August/September 1988, 14–16(3) Baxendale, A. T., Integration of Time and Cost Control, Chartered Institute of Building (Construction Papers 7), Ascot, 1992 Betts, M. and Gunner, J., ‘Consultant Cost Control in The Pacific Rim’, Cost Engineering, 34 (1) January 1992, 17–24(8) Bowen, P. and Edwards, P., ‘Interpersonal Communication in Cost Planning During the Building Design Phase’, Construction Management & Economics, (1996) 14, 395–404(10) Costing Services, Building Services, 14(11) November 1992, 25–31(7) Farrow, J. J. and Rutter, D. K., Performance Setting and Monitoring on Building Projects for Contractors, Chartered Institute of Building (Construction Papers 67), Ascot, 1996 Ferry, D. J. O. and Flanagan, R., Life Cycle Costing: a Radical Approach, CIRIA Report 122, Construction Industry Research and Information Association, London, 1991 Gilmour, J. and Skitmore, M., ‘A New Approach to Early Stage Estimating’, Chartered Quantity Surveyor, 11(9) May 1989, 36–38(2) Kaka, A. P. and Price, A. D. F., ‘Modelling Standard Cost Commitment Curves for Contractors’ Cash Flow Forecasting’, Construction Management & Economics, 11(4) July 1993, 271–283(13) Ministry of Education Building Bulletin No. 4, Cost Study, first edition March 1951, second edition March 1957, third edition 1972 Ministry of Public Building and Works/International Tutor Machines Ltd, ‘Cost Control in Building Design’, R and D Building Management Handbook 4, HMSO, London, 1968 Morris, A., ‘A Rational Approach to Cost’, Building, 260(7889) 21 April 1995, 33(1) Skitmore, M. et al., ‘The Accuracy of Construction Price Forecasts’, University of Salford, Salford, 1990 Southgate, T., ‘A New Approach’, Chartered Quantity Surveyor, 11(3) November 1988, 35–36 Watson, B., ‘Cost Planning Engineering Services Contracts’, Cost Engineer, 28(4) 1990, 8–10(3) Watson, K., ‘Procurement – the Key Area for Cost Control’, Construction Computing, (52) April 1996, 12–13(2)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 1, Appendix D (05/03)
Effective from 1/7/03
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 2
PART TWO: CONSTRUCTION DESIGN & ECONOMICS I
SECTION 2: LIFE CYCLE COSTING Introduction It is becoming increasingly important that investment appraisal uses a whole life approach in a more systematic way than at present. Major construction clients are now insisting upon an analysis of life cycle costs and not just capital costs. The life cycle cost (LCC) of an asset is defined as the present value of the total cost of that asset over its operating life (including initial capital cost, occupation costs, operating costs and the cost or benefit of the eventual disposal of the asset at the end of its life). Life cycle cost techniques can be used, for example, to:
• evaluate design options at the elemental or component level; • evaluate total building options, for example refurbishment versus new build; • determine optimum maintenance strategies; • analyse relocation strategies; and • determine sinking fund requirements to finance planned maintenance programmes. Worked examples for the above are included in 2.2.5. The objective of this Section is to inform chartered surveyors of the increasing need to adopt life cycle costing (2.2.1) and to introduce them to the techniques and their application.
2.2.1 The Client Context 2.2.1.1
Following the recession of the early 1990s construction clients are generally more streamlined and competitive and some recognise that their ongoing property costs may provide them with the business ‘edge’ they need. There is therefore increased attention to life cycle costing. The following Sub-sections expand on this trend by covering recent changes in the industry and their effect on LCC.
2.2.1.2
VALUE ENGINEERING Value engineering involves preparing structured option appraisals during the design process so demonstrating value for money for clients. Its use is
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2
increasing and with it comes the opportunity and need for LCC to be part of the options appraisal criteria. 2.2.1.3
THE LATHAM REPORT Sir Michael Latham’s report Constructing the Team1, calls for a 30% real reduction in construction costs. This statement includes life cycle costs. The report also strongly advocates the need to ‘build right first time’ in which environment life cycle cost calculations (involving assumptions about future maintenance) have more credibility.
2.2.1.4
CONSTRUCTION (DESIGN AND MANAGEMENT) REGULATIONS 1994 The Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 1994 place a specific duty upon clients and their designers to consider the potential hazards associated with the construction process during design, and furthermore to consider the health and safety implications of maintaining the structure when complete. Such increased focus on maintenance may therefore encourage greater consideration of maintenance costs. This principle is enshrined in Regulation 13(2)(a)(i) and (ii) which states: “(2)
Every designer shall: (a)
ensure that any design he prepares and which he is aware will be used for the purposes of construction work includes among the design considerations adequate regard to the need: (i)
to avoid foreseeable risks to the health and safety of any person at work carrying out construction work or cleaning work in or on the structure at any time, or of any person who may be affected by the work of such a person at work,
(ii)
to combat at source risks to the health and safety of any person at work carrying out construction work or cleaning work in or on the structure at any time, or of any person who may be affected by the work of such a person at work.”
It follows that the selection of materials for certain elements of a structure that may involve maintenance, (particularly where access to those elements involves working at height), complies with the spirit of Regulation 13. For example, the selection of PVCu window frames with ‘easy clean’ hinges involves limited maintenance and allows cleaning from the inside. Similarly marble flooring is cheaper than cork tiles over a 60-year period and while the decision to use marble is economically sound it also removes health hazards
1
Latham, M., Sir, (1994), Constructing the Team: Joint Review of Procurement and Contractual Arrangements in the United Kingdom Construction Industry: Final Report, HMSO London
Page 2
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
associated with fumes and vapour when cork has to be resealed. In purely capital cost terms, the selection of the materials referred to above may be more expensive than their traditional counterparts. The use of life cycle costing places initial capital cost in the context of future maintenance expenditure, and helps justify decisions which have beneficial health and safety implications. 2.2.1.5
THE PRIVATE FINANCE INITIATIVE (PFI) The PFI is driven by a cash flow which is achieved by the private sector provider delivering a service to the client. This service will include the management of a building which should be heated, cooled, lighted, cleaned, maintained, secured, insured and renovated. This cash flow should sufficiently cover all costs and outgoings, leaving the provider with a surplus or profit which should be commensurate with his risk exposure. It is therefore critical that the provider accurately predicts the cost in use of the service or the facility over its operational life so that he can calculate the cash flows generated by the assets over the term of the contract. Such data is vital so as to negotiate the complexities of the contract to both parties’ satisfaction. To assist this process some suppliers give guaranteed long-term costs, e.g. for lifts and kitchen equipment. By reducing costs over this term it should be financially viable for the private sector to provide a service to the public sector and to achieve an acceptable return. Life cycle costs and their accurate prediction, control and reduction are critical to the successful performance of a PFI deal.
2.2.1.
ENERGY EFFICIENCY ISSUES IN RELATION TO BUILDING PROJECTS Studies by the Building Research Establishment through the BRECSU (Building Research Energy Conservation Support Unit) ‘Best Practice Programme’ have found that energy consumed to heat, light and service buildings accounts for almost half of the UK’s energy bill, and there is considerable scope to reduce it. Office buildings were found to have the highest energy costs, especially prestigious, air conditioned property (typically £20/m2 per year in 1991 compared to £15/m2 for the same ‘best practice’ office). There is common feeling that property overheads are too large, with energy bills contributing significantly to the operating costs. Energy costs are potentially one of the most controllable items of overheads and life cycle costing can be used as a tool for predicting the benefits of investment in energy efficiency. Typical investments for analysis would be economic thickness of insulation, energy efficient services, building energy management system installations, intelligent buildings, energy conscious refurbishment of buildings and passive cooling techniques versus air conditioned design. For example, a manufacturer can supply a light bulb some ten times more expensive than a normal one, however, it lasts longer, uses less
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 2
electricity and performs better. Similarly, condensing gas boilers can save 10–20% of fossil fuel bills with pay back in five years. It is also worth noting that oil is becoming increasingly harder to extract and environmental concerns generally will increase in the very near future. Sainsbury has been the first grocery retailer to produce an environmental report and recognises that energy probably accounts for its single biggest direct environmental impact. Significantly it is also the third largest controllable cost in running a typical supermarket. 2.2.1.7
MECHANICAL AND ELECTRICAL BUILDING SERVICES The increasing capital cost significance and complexity of M & E services has resulted in greater cost emphasis during the early design stages. Such costing is increasingly carried out by a specialist Quantity Surveyor so bringing greater opportunity to focus on M & E life cycle costs which are a significant proportion of a building’s cost in use, accounted for by the operation, energy use and replacement costs associated with the M & E installations.
2.2.1.8
BUILDING SUSTAINABILITY If there is to be a conscious shift of opinion towards sustainable buildings i.e. those which have a viable life expectancy beyond their initial designed use, then there has to be a simultaneous re-examination of a building’s costs in use or perhaps more correctly costs in uses. Buildings have not been traditionally designed for anything beyond their immediate requirement. However, as more are being converted to alternative uses it is probably only a matter of time before investors in property call for properties to be constructed with a view to extending the building’s usable life, e.g. conversion to house a growing less mobile and aged population. Such consideration is more valid the shorter the predicted current building life, e.g. some light industrial units for English Partnerships have been designed for a ten-year life. Similarly, Hertfordshire County Council have housing and nursing homes with a 20-year life expectancy. Such a concept will require building layouts and structures to be more flexible with maintenance, re-servicing and conversion to alternative uses being simplified and made more economical. A cost in use study at design stage may justify larger bay sizes, raised flooring or greater storey heights to demonstrate continual viability for future generations. A cost in use study would explore the economics involved of using a building for its notional design life and for its intended use in the usual way. However, supplementary investigations would explore potential alternative uses for the building and the conversion cost (and possibly the cost in use for a further notional period). If sufficient consideration were to be given at the initial design stage for potential future uses of a building, it could be used to demonstrate the continued asset value of the property and go a considerable
Page 4
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
way to minimising the obsolescent properties which currently dominate certain market sectors.
2.2.2 The Life Cycle Costing Calculation INTRODUCTION The calculation generally involves the appraisal of options, each option having different capital and future costs. To determine and analyse the future costs it is necessary to establish:
• the building life; • the discount rate (which, expressed simply, is the difference between the interest and inflation rate and is used to convert future payments to present values); • the cost and frequency of future payments (at the component, elemental or total building level as appropriate); • any tax implications (see 2.2.3). 2.2.2.1
THE BUILDING LIFE An essential element of life cycle costing is defining the life cycle period to be adopted. An assessment must therefore be made of the life of the investment – ‘building life’. Typically the relevant building life will be the period over which the organisation, for whom the study is being conducted, will be expected to hold an interest in the building, and would take into account the residual value. At the end of the life of a building, the building (or component) and the land will have a residual value. In the case of relatively short life cycles or high value land, residual values can be very significant factors in determining the optimum life cycle cost options. Residual values are briefly discussed in Appendix A (and worked example 2.2.5.3 includes a residual value in the calculation). When the building life is assessed to be over 40 years, the precise life is not critical for the purposes of life cycle costing (as discounting, explained below, minimises the effect of such future payments). In cases where calculations are based on a relatively short building life, say 20 years or less, the assessment of the time horizons must be considered with special care. Building life is influenced by obsolescence, the causes of which are summarised in Appendix B.
2.2.2.2
THE DISCOUNT RATE The life cycle cost technique is concerned with the assessment of the time stream of costs and revenues that will flow throughout the life of a construction project option.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 5
PART 2, SECTION 2
As ‘money today’ has a different value from ‘money tomorrow’ or ‘money in ten years’ time’, a technique has to be adopted that will express future costs or revenues in present values. The process of converting ‘future money’ to ‘present money’ is called discounting. Discounting involves establishing the discount rate to be used. In making the decision on a discount rate for a particular project, some judgement will need to be made about the degree of risk return (interest) and the likely levels of future inflation rates. Interest rates are particular to the client and the degree of risk. It is therefore essential to involve the client (and his accountant if appropriate) in the process and reach agreement on the discount rate to be used. Economists, accountants and clients will all have different views about future levels of inflation and interest rates. Some forecasters may take the view that as different categories of cost inflate at different rates, these differences should be taken into account in setting discount rates. These diversities of view ‘before the fact’ make it difficult to recommend any firm guidelines for surveyors to adopt for selecting discount rates. There are two main approaches to discounting: (a) use a rate which ‘implies’ inflation of future costs and values (in this case future costs and values will be priced at today’s prices); (b) use a rate which requires an ‘explicit treatment’ of inflation in relation to future costs and values, (in this case future costs and values will be priced at today’s prices and adjusted by a factor to reflect future inflation). It is suggested that it is easier to deal with the former situation where future costs and values are assessed at current prices. Three approaches on the selection of discount rates are given for guidance purposes and in each the future costs are priced at current prices. 2.2.2.3
DISCOUNT RATE METHODS (a) Test Discount Rate In the absence of better information it is recommended that a test discount rate should be used. This recommendation is based on the assumption that when inflation rates are reasonably low, i.e. less than 15%, there is quite a stable relationship between inflation and the bank base interest rate, implying a real discount rate of between 4% and 5% (i.e. the interest rate is 4 to 5% greater than inflation). It is recommended that in the circumstances, where no better information is
Page 6
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
available, a test discount rate of 4% is used. This method is often adopted in the public sector where minimal risk associated with the investment is assumed. (b) No risk return discount rate Investment in long-term Treasury Bonds can be assumed as having no risk, and are a good reflection of the return to be expected on other investments where there is no risk. Therefore the discount rate can be taken as the Treasury Bond rate less an allowance for the expected rate of inflation. On this basis the discount rate would be assessed as: Treasury Bond rate of return Less Inflation No risk return discount rate
8% 5% —— 3% ——
(c) Average risk premium discount rate The average return on equities reflects the interest required on an average risk. The excess of this rate of return over that expected from the above Treasury Bonds can then be taken as the premium expected for the average risk. On this basis the average risk premium could therefore be calculated as: Average equity rate return Less Treasury Bond rate Average risk premium discount rate
16% 8% ——– 8% ——–
Therefore if construction is deemed to be half as risky as equities, the discount rate for construction investment could be assessed as: No risk return Construction premium risk (8% × ½) Average construction risk return discount rate
3% 4% ——– 7% ——–
(d) A further approach to establishing a discount rate is to analyse transactions involving the sale of comparable properties, and to utilise the ‘all risks’ yield as the discount rate. In the examples of the calculation of discount rates, concurrent interest and inflation rates have been added and subtracted in order to clarify the methodology. This is mathematically imprecise. The actual calculation will need to be compounded.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 7
PART 2, SECTION 2
In the ‘no risk return discount rate’ method, for example, the calculation should be as follows: Treasury Bond rate of return Inflation rate
8% 5%
Discount rate (i.e. Treasury Bond rate net of inflation (1 = Treasury Bond rate) = ——————————— – 1 (1 + Inflation rate) 1.08 = —— – 1 1.05 = 0.02857 = 2.857% The same methodology should be adopted for actual calculations using other methods. As an approximation however this may be ignored. (e) In summary, the effect of future payments on an LCC calculation is in inverse proportion to the level of discount rates i.e. the higher the discount rate the less effect future payments have on the LCC calculation. For example, a risk taking client is less likely to spend money on the building to reduce future costs since he can use this money to get a higher return elsewhere. Selection of a suitable discount rate is crucial as it can overwhelm all other decisions. Once the discount rate is established valuation tables can be used to convert future payments to present value. For example, the present value of £100 to be paid in five years’ time at a discount rate of £4% = £100 × 0.82192 (from valuation tables at 2.2.5.7 ‘present value of £1’) = £82.19 Such conversion of future payments to present value provides a basis for comparing alternative expenditures. 2.2.2.4
THE COST AND FREQUENCY OF FUTURE PAYMENTS The costs are generally dealt with using current prices (using the discount rate to allow for inflation), with assumptions made regarding when payments will occur in the future. 2.2.4 includes possible sources for such data. Depending upon requirements, some calculations will be relatively straightforward (see the option appraisal exercise for internal doors as shown
Page 8
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
in the worked examples). However, all expenditure throughout the life of the building could be included if the total building analysis were required. The major categories of costs are:
• • • • • • •
capital costs financing costs operation costs annual maintenance costs intermittent maintenance, replacement and alterations costs occupancy costs residual values and disposal costs.
An expanded check list of costs is given in Appendix C. Estimates for these costs will be based upon assumptions about future events and should be clearly stated. Indeed an additional advantage of life cycle costing is that it requires design assumptions to be stated explicitly rather than implied. Although current costs are generally used, it is important that future cost assessment should reflect any expected divergence of a specific cost from the level of inflation allowed in the discount rate. For example, it would be unwise to assume that market conditions would remain unchanged for any extended period when tender levels for building work are very depressed. Some allowance should therefore be made to adjust current building prices to more normal market conditions when pricing future building work. The level of detail used will be dictated by the availability of information and the requirements of the client. The following costs for each category should be considered and where necessary established with the client. (a) Capital costs – include land, building, professional fees, furniture and equipment, or permanent improvements thereto, which form assets for the business to use in its operation, with an intended useful life of more than one year. The significance of any tax benefits and grants should be established with the client. (b) Financing costs – the method of funding the project should include, inter alia, the cost effect of alternative sources of funds, the future flexibility of funds in terms of amounts and sources, and gearing. Consideration should also be given to
• the accounting effect of capital employed; • construction period finance charges and long-term finance costs; and • the taxation implications of the various options. The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 9
PART 2, SECTION 2
(c) Operation costs – include estimates of rent, rates, energy costs, cleaning costs, building related staffing costs and other staffing costs. (d) Annual maintenance costs – average maintenance costs are available but once details of design are completed, a more relevant estimate can be produced based on information obtained from manufacturers or maintenance managers. (e) Intermittent maintenance, replacement and alteration costs – replacement costs can be produced using normal cost estimating techniques. In seeking a realistic assessment of the life of materials and components, reference should be made to manufacturers, maintenance managers and other sources of such data (as discussed in 2.2.4). (f) Occupancy costs – the cost of performing the function for which the building is intended (e.g. producing motor vehicles). Occupancy costs are distinguished from operation costs, as they relate to costs attributable to a specific process undertaken by the client, which may change within the life of the building. As an example, a car manufacturer may change to the production of heavy goods vehicles. This would impact on his occupancy costs, whereas his building related operation costs could be relatively unchanged. Some clients might not require the surveyor to take these costs into account, as not relating directly to the building. (g) Residual values and disposal costs – estimate of the resale value and the cost of disposing of the building, plant, land and other assets after the expiry of the life cycle. Many buildings, particularly those with an ‘open market value’ will have a significant residual value. Care should be taken in assessing this value as it can have a major effect on the life cycle costing calculations (see Appendix A).
2.2.3 Tax Allowances, Incentives and Business Rates INTRODUCTION This Sub-section deals with the effect of taxation allowances and incentives available for expenditure upon property and construction applicable in the United Kingdom to date, during the life of the asset. A glossary of terms is included in Appendix D. Currently, legislation offers tax relief by allowing expenditure upon certain assets to be depreciated, and to be offset against a private commercial organisation’s taxable profits. Tax relief is available on both capital and revenue expenditure. Capital costs receive this relief by way of capital allowances which are deductible items from the taxpayer’s taxation liability account. Maintenance costs are a charge on the profit and loss account, which again reduces the tax payable. Page 10
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
The significance of tax relief depends upon the amount of allowable expenditure. This varies considerably, being dependent upon the type and function of the asset, its design and sophistication (particularly in respect of services) and whether or not the project is a new building or a refurbishment. The impact of tax relief on the life cycle evaluation lessens proportionately with the ratio of allowable expenditure to the total expenditure and the timing of relief, which is dependent on the annual rate of taxation allowances. For example, a new oil refinery will have a greater proportion of allowance than a shop unit shell. It is also worth noting that capital allowances tend to be greater on plant than on buildings, so making the use of efficient plant more attractive than increasing the thermal efficiency of the building. The impact of tax relief should be sensitively tested at the earliest possible stage. A detailed estimate of the allowable expenditure should only be prepared if tax relief is found to be significant. 2.2.3.1
The following example shows the net discounted cost, after tax relief, of £1,000 spent on differing types of expenditure.
Expenditure
No relief
Where capital allowances are allowed on 50% of capital expenditure
Where capital allowances are allowed on 100% of capital expenditure
Relief given on maintenance 100%
£
£
£
£
1,000
1,000
1111
222
350
889
778
650
1,000
Tax relief assuming 35% Corporation Tax Net discounted cost after tax relief 1
1,000
1,000
i.e. 50% of £1,000 × 25% reducing balance × 35% Corporation Tax with future allowances discounted at 10% per annum (a discounting calculation is required in order to establish the above figures).
2.2.3.2
TYPES OF ALLOWANCES The types of allowances and rates of depreciation often change. Following the Finance Act 1985, capital allowances available that relate to Real Property were as follows:
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 11
PART 2, SECTION 2
Allowable expenditure Plant and machinery Industrial buildings Agricultural buildings Dredging Scientific research Cemeteries and crematoria Dwelling houses let on assured tenancies – only expenditure expended prior to 1 April 1987 Hotels Enterprise zone building expenditure Mining and certain related construction works
Timing or percentage per annum 25% (reducing balancing) 4% (straight line) 4% (straight line) 4% (straight line) 100% Ratio based upon grave spaces used
4% (straight line) 4% (straight line) 100% 40% plus a ratio based upon usable life
Subsequent to the Finance Act 1997 first year allowances were changed and at the time of writing were still being finalised. In certain circumstances allowances may be at a higher rate i.e. they relate to specific incentives, certain assisted projects or expenditure relates to a transitional period e.g. terms of the Finance Act 1984 (applicable until 31 March 1987). Different types of allowances, initial, first year and writing down are explained in the Glossary of Terms (Appendix D). Straight line allowances are calculated as a percentage of original cost and at 4% the allowance is spread evenly over 25 years. A reducing balance computation is achieved each year by first deducting all previous allowance amounts from original cost and then applying the allowable percentage to the balance, i.e. 25% in the first year, 25% of 75% in the second, and so on. While the building itself may be subject to a 4% straight line allowance the plant and machinery in the building will receive a 25% reducing balance. It should be noted that the significant part of capital allowance relief on a 25% reducing balance basis comes in the first five to seven years. This is included in the above example where the tax relief amount is a product of the incremental annual writing down allowance, discounted. Regional development grants (or their Northern Ireland equivalent) may also be available. These are not treated as taxable and may be disregarded when assessing the capital cost upon which tax relief is calculated. Currently the running and maintenance costs of an asset are deductible in full (i.e. 100% allowance) against taxable profits in the year of expenditure. 2.2.3.3
Page 12
VALUE ADDED TAX (VAT) Capital allowances are given against the net capital cost to the taxpayer. Therefore, as VAT is part of that capital cost, clients will incur differing overall capital expenditure for the same item depending upon whether they can or cannot recover, or recover only a proportion of, the VAT.
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.3.4
CALCULATION OF THE EFFECT OF CAPITAL AND REVENUE ALLOWANCES Before calculating the effect of taxation allowances, certain parameters need to be ascertained: (a) the Corporation Tax and allowances rate that will be current at the date of construction of first use; (b) the future Corporation Tax and allowance rate at the date of replacement; (c) the Corporation Tax rate current at dates between date of construction of first use and the date of replacement, against which revenue running costs can be charged; (d) whether the owner will be liable to tax during the period between the date of construction or first use and the date of replacement, and if the owner will have sufficient taxable profits to use the allowances generated in any one year. (e) whether the item’s economic life will be shorter than the tax write down period. This will either generate an added write down amount when it is demolished, or if the item or building is to be sold at the end of its economic life, its profit or loss on cost. These circumstances will generate a taxable profit or loss on proceeds above or below the tax write down value and will attract a balancing adjustment; (f) the value of the balancing allowances, charges or taxable profits needs to be considered against the relevant Corporation Tax rate; (g) the impact of these adjustments therefore needs to be taken into account in the life cycle costing assessment. Caution is further necessary as there are specific restrictions. The recipient has to prove to the Inland Revenue that he qualifies for allowances (i.e. the entitlements are aimed at providing incentives for commercial organisations and therefore expenditure upon residential property is largely excluded. Entitlements are also restricted between connected persons).
2.2.3.5
DYNAMICS The surveyor should therefore appreciate the variables and frequent changes that occur in respect to the application of taxation allowances. These arise because: (a) the Government uses taxation to impose fiscal policy and influence the economy and therefore statutes are introduced amending previous rates of depreciation, regulations and entitlements; (b) the interpretation of entitlement is affected by case law precedents.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 13
PART 2, SECTION 2
(c) the Inland Revenue practices and extra statutory concessions develop to address specific issues or vagaries. 2.2.3.6
APPLICATIONS Taxation allowances provide the opportunity for innovative funding arrangements whereby the tax relief can be ‘exported’ to a party who can enjoy more benefit from the entitlement. They also need to be advised during property transfers so the relevant balancing adjustments can be calculated and the purchasers advised of their proper entitlements.
2.2.3.7
WORKED EXAMPLES Worked example 2.2.5.3 summarises the effect of capital and revenue allowances. Worked example 2.2.5.6 includes a detailed calculation of the capital and revenue allowances. Business Rates Large plant and machinery regarded as an integral part of the building can attract additional rates which can be influenced by design niceties (such as how the plant is covered over). Expert advice should be sought in such a situation. Further reading for taxation Tolley’s Capital Allowances, Tolley Publishing Co. Ltd – generally published annually. Butterworths Yellow Tax Handbook, Butterworth & Co. (Publishers) Ltd – abstract of Statutes Tax Statutes and Statutory Instruments, CCH Editions Ltd – incorporating extra statutory concessions
2.2.4 Data Sources Lack of data in a suitable format for maintenance, replacement and energy costs is said to be a significant reason for LCC rarely being carried out at present. Notwithstanding this, Building Surveyors and Facility Managers will often have valuable in-house data. Furthermore, professional judgement should not be disregarded. LCC calculations require information regarding the durability of materials/components, and/or energy costs. Lack of such accurate data in a suitable format may affect the credibility of the LCC calculation. However, while historic data is useful, reality is dependent upon individual design, installation and usage as well as technical development. Page 14
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
Whilst the selection of data sources given in Appendix F is not comprehensive, it gives an indication of the level of information available. Trade literature which is a prime source of detailed information is not included.
2.2.5 Worked Examples INTRODUCTION Life cycle costing can be used in numerous situations. The intention of this Sub-section is to give the reader an appreciation of its application, as used by surveyors in practice, and the relative complexities of associated calculations, ranging from a simple elemental option appraisal to complex total building analyses. The examples follow in order of complexity, worked examples 2.2.5.1 and 2.2.5.2 will readily convey the principles of life cycle costing including discounting. The remainder consider more detailed scenarios. 2.2.5.1
DESIGN OPTION: INTERNAL DOORS This example is kindly provided by Messrs Gardiner & Theobald, Chartered Quantity Surveyors. The objective is to evaluate four comparative specifications over a building life of 60 years using a discount rate of 4% (7% interest rate less 3% inflation rate). The information is summarised in the table below with an explanation of the calculation for option 1 detailed at (a) to (d) below. Any tax implications are excluded. (a) The present value for purchasing the doors is obviously the same as the capital cost: £35,000 (b) For the annual running costs: • £10.89/m2 × 20 m2 = £218 • £218 incurred every year for 60 years at 4% discount = £218 × 22.6* = £4,927 present value (c) For maintenance the present cost of £6,040 for new ironmongery and repainting taking place in, say Year 12 at 4% discount = £6,040 × 0.62459** = £3,773 (d) The replacement cost after 40 years = £35,000 (present cost) × 0.20828** = £7,290 • The total present value of the capital cost, annual running cost, maintenance and replacement costs = £57,037 showing option 1 is the most expensive life cycle cost * from valuation tables at 2.2.5.7 (year’s purchase or present value of £1 per period) **from valuation tables at 2.2.5.7 (present value of £1)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 15
PART 2, SECTION 2
PROJECT: Life Cycle Model
PROJECT LIFE Discount Rate
Discount Rate
SHEET NUMBER: ELEMENT:
60 Years 4.00% per annum
4.00% per annum
(Interest Rate (7%), Inflation (3%))
COSTS Capital Costs Aluminium Glazed Hardwood Glazed Vision Panels Softwood Metal Contingency
£ 1750.00 m2
Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint OPTION 2 Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint
Page 16
OPTION 3 Softwood
OPTION 4 Metal
Finish Life 40 Years
Finish Life 30 Years
Finish Life 20 Years
Finish Life 30 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Estimated Cost
Present Value
35,000
35,000
Estimated Cost
Present Value
20,000
20,000
£
10.89 m2
£ £ £
9.99 m2 5.90 m2 17.99 m2
Year Present Cost 4 340 8 340
Estimated Cost
Present Value
14,000
14,000
Estimated Cost
17,000
Capital Costs
Total Annual Running Costs
OPTION 1
OPTION 2 Hardwood Glazed Vision Panels
–
Annual Running Costs Aluminium Glazed Hardwood Glazed Vision Panels Softwood Metal Maintenance
OPTION 1 Aluminium Glazed
£ 1000.00 m2 £ 700.00 m2 £ 850.00 m2
Total Year 1
LCCM5 Internal Doors Unit: 20 m2
35,000 218
–
–
17,000 –
20,000
14,000
17,000
4,927 200
4,520 118
13,068
4,927
340 340
291 248
11,988
4,520
300 300
256 219
12 16 20
6,040 340 340
6,040 340 340
3,773 182 155
24 28 32
6,040 340 340
6,040 340 340
2,356 113 97
36 40 44
6,040 340 340
6,040 340 340
1,472 71 61
48 52 56 4 8
6,040 340 340 300 300
6,040 340 340
919 44 38
12 16 20
6,000 300 300
6,000 300 300
3,748 160 137
24 28 32
6,000 300 300
6,000 300 300
2,341 100 86
36 40 44
6,000 300 300
6,000 300 300
1,462 62 53
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Present Value
Effective from 1/6/99
2,670
7,080
2,670
360
8,140
21,588
8,140
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
PROJECT: Life Cycle Model (continued
PROJECT LIFE Discount Rate
60 Years 4.00% per annum
Discount Rate
4.00% per annum
(Interest Rate (7%), Inflation (3%))
Maintenance
OPTION 2 Hardwood Glazed Vision Panels
OPTION 3 Softwood
OPTION 4 Metal
Finish Life 40 Years
Finish Life 30 Years
Finish Life 20 Years
Finish Life 30 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Maintenance Period 4 Years
Present Value
Estimated Cost
Present Value
Estimated Cost
Present Value
Estimated Cost
Present Value
300 300 6,100 300 300 6,100 300 300 6,100 300 300 6,100 300 300 6,100
256 219 3,810 160 137 2,380 100 86 1,486 62 53 928 39 33 3,810
17,000
5,241
Year Present Cost
New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint OPTION 3 Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint New ironmongery Repaint Repaint Repaint OPTION 4 Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Repaint Replacement
OPTION 4
LCCM5 Internal Doors Unit: 20 m2
OPTION 1 Aluminium Glazed
Estimated Cost
COSTS
OPTION 1 OPTION 2 OPTION 3
SHEET NUMBER: ELEMENT:
48 52 56 4 8
6,000 300 300 320 320
12 16 20
6,000 300 300
913 39 33 320 320
274 234
3,820 320 320
3,820 320 320
2,386 171 146
24 28 32
3,820 320 320
3,820 320 320
1,490 107 91
36 40 44
3,820 320 320
3,820 320 320
931 67 57
48 3,820 52 320 56 320 4 300 8 300 12 6,100 16 300 20 300 24 6,100 28 300 32 300 36 6,100 40 300 44 300 48 6,100 52 300 56 300 Year Present Cost 40 35,000 30 20,000 20 14,000 40 14,000 30 17,000
3,820 320 320
581 42 36
35,000
7,290 20,000
6,166 14,000 14,000
6,389 2,916
Total Maintenance/Replacement Costs
62,560
17,109
47,000
15,776
46,480
15,917
44,400
14,993
Total Running Costs
75,628
22,037
58,988
20,297
53,560
18,586
65,988
23,132
Total Net Present Value of Life Cycle Costs
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
57,037
40,297
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
32,586
Effective from 1/6/99
40,132
Page 17
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.5.2
BUILDING SERVICES DESIGN OPTION: AIR CONDITIONING AND UNDER FLOOR TRUNKING VERSUS HOT WATER HEATING AND RING MAIN ELECTRICS This example is again provided by Messrs Gardiner & Theobald. The objective is to evaluate the above options for a building of 3,000 m2 floor area, a life of 60 years and a discount rate of 4% (7% interest less 3% inflation). The information is summarised overleaf with the methodology for the calculation being exactly as that for the previous example. Any taxation implications are excluded.
Page 18
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
Element: Services PROJECT LIFE Discount Rate
Unit: 3,000 m2 60 Years 4% per annum
Discount Rate 4.00% per annum (Interest Rate (7%), Inflation (3%)
COSTS
OPTION 1 Air Conditioning U/Floor Trunking
OPTION 2 HW Heating & Ring Main Electrics
OPTION 3
OPTION 4
Finish Life 15 Years
Finish Life 25 Years
Finish Life
Finish Life
Maintenance Period 5 Years
Maintenance Period 7 Years
Maintenance Period Years
Maintenance Period Years
Estimated Cost
Present Value
750,000
750,000
Estimated Cost
Present Value
450,000
450,000
Estimated Cost
Present Value
Estimated Cost
Present Value
Capital Cost Air Conditioning U/Floor Trunking HW Heating & Ring Main Electric
250 m2 150 m2
£ £
Contingency
5%
Total Year 1
Capital Costs
37,500
22,500
787,500
472,500
Annual Running Costs Air Conditioning U/Floor Trunking
£ 25.00 m2
HW Heating & Ring Main Electric
£
Total Annual Costs Maintenance
Year
75,000
1,696,762
5.00 m2 4,500,000
1,696,762
15,000
339,352
900,000
339,352
Present Cost
OPTION 1 Overhall
5 Equipment 10
5,000 5,000
5,000 5,000
4,110 3,378
Overhall Overhall
Equipment 15 Equipment 20
5,000 5,000
5,000 5,000
2,776 2,282
Overhall Overhall
Equipment 25 Equipment 30
5,000 5,000
5,000 5,000
1,876 1,542
Overhall Overhall
Equipment 35 Equipment 40
5,000 5,000
5,000 5,000
1,267 1,041
Overhall
Equipment 45
5,000
5,000
856
Overhall Overhall
Equipment 50 Equipment 55
5,000 5,000
5,000 5,000
704 578
OPTION 2 Genearl repaint/repair
7 14
2,000 2,000
2,000 2,000
1,520 1,155
Genearl repaint/repair Genearl repaint/repair
21 28
2,000 2,000
2,000 2,000
878 667
Genearl repaint/repair Genearl repaint/repair
35 42
2,000 2,000
2,000 2,000
507 385
Genearl repaint/repair Genearl repaint/repair
49 56
2,000 2,000
2,000 2,000
293 222
300,000 300,000
112,535 42,214
OPTION 3 OPTION 4 Replacement
Year
OPTION 1
OPTION 2
15
Present Cost 600,000
600,000
333,159
30 45
600,000 600,000
600,000 600,000
184,991 102,719
25 50
300,000 300,000
OPTION 3 OPTION 4 Total Maintenance/Replacement Costs
1,855,000
641,278
616,000
160,375
Total Running Costs
6,355,000
2,338,040
1,516,000
499,728
Total Net Present Value of Life Cycle Cost
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
3,125,540
972,228
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 19
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.5.3
MAINTENANCE OPTION: WITH/WITHOUT CLEANING GANTRY This example is kindly provided by Gerald Hall. The following figure compares two options, firstly to provide the cleaning gantry and secondly to omit the gantry. The capital cost and costs associated with anticipated maintenance were calculated by using normal cost estimating techniques. Assumed criteria: – Building Life – VAT assumed to remain at current levels with the client being an ‘end user’ under VAT rules – Gantry capital cost – The gantry will have a residual value – Capital cost for opening lights in lieu of gantry – Discount rate (assuming the interest rate will average 11% over 25 years and the inflation rate 6%) – Corporation Tax
25 years 17.5% £30,000 £2,000 £5,000 5% 33%
Taxation Calculation The capital cost for plant and machinery receives a 25% reducing balance. Maintenance and running costs receive 100% allowance. Year 1 with gantry calculation: Capital Maintenance
£35,250 × 25% × 33% £881 × 33%
= =
£ 2,908 291 ——– 3,199 ——–
Year 2 with gantry calculation: Capital Maintenance
£35,250 less 25% × 25% × 33% £881 × 33%
= =
£ 2,181 291 ——– 2,472 ——–
The methodology applies for the rest of the 25 years as summarised overleaf. The client initially considered that the gantry would pay for itself due to savings in maintenance and cleaning cost. However: with gantry investment without gantry investment Page 20
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
£36,510 present value £26,447 present value The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Financing
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Operation
TOTAL PRESENT VALUE AT END OF INVESTMENT LIFE
30,000
1
Capital
0
Year
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
750
–
Annual
–
1,750
–
–
250
–
–
1,750
–
–
250
–
–
1,750
–
–
250
–
–
1,750
–
–
250
–
–
–
Intermittent
Maintenance
Costs
COMPARATIVE COMPONENT LIFE CYCLE COSTING
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Occupacy
(2,000)
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Disposal/ residual value
(1,250)
2,500
750
750
1,000
750
750
2,500
750
750
1,000
750
750
2,500
750
750
1,000
750
750
2,500
750
750
1,000
750
750
30,000
TOTAL
131
438
131
131
175
131
131
438
131
131
175
131
131
438
131
131
175
131
131
438
131
131
175
131
131
5,250
VAT 17.5%
(1,119)
2,938
881
881
1,175
881
881
2,938
881
881
1,175
881
881
2,938
881
881
1,175
881
881
2,938
881
881
1,175
881
881
35,250
TOTAL inc VAT
311
973
296
298
397
303
307
991
320
330
440
360
383
1,092
454
509
679
679
808
1,660
1,211
1,518
2,024
2,472
3,199
0
Less tax allowance
(1,430)
1,965
585
583
778
578
574
1,947
561
551
735
521
498
1,846
427
372
496
202
73
1,278
(330)
(637)
(849)
(1,591)
(2,318)
35,250
NET TOTAL
0.295
0.310
0.326
0.342
0.359
0.377
0.396
0.416
0.436
0.458
0.481
0.505
0.530
0.557
0.585
0.614
0.645
0.677
0.711
0.746
0.784
0.823
0.864
0.907
0.952
1.000
Present value of £1 @ 5%
CLIENT: PROJECT TITLE: Retail Development/Shopping Mall JOB NO: OPTION: Cleaning ‘with’ gantry – curtain walling to new facace
36,541
(422)
609
191
199
279
218
227
809
245
253
354
263
264
1,028
250
229
320
137
52
953
(258)
(524)
(733)
(1,443)
(2,207)
35,250
PRESENT VALUE
36,541
36,963
36,354
36,163
35,964
35,685
35,467
35,239
34,431
34,186
33,933
33,580
33,316
33,052
32,024
31,775
31,546
31,226
31,089
31,037
30,084
30,343
30,866
31,600
33,043
35,250
CUMULATIVE PRESENT VALUE
PART 2, SECTION 2
Page 21
Page 22
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
The life cycle costing is based on an agreed investment life of 25 years.
It is assumed that VAT will remain at around 17.5% and the client is the ‘end user’ under VAT rules.
3
4
There are disposal cost advantages with this option.
Details of the maintenance requirements and cost estimates can be provided upon request.
2
5
The capital cost includes allowances for preliminaries and associated builders work.
1
FORECASTER’S ASSUMPTIONS
COMPARATIVE COMPONENT LIFE CYCLE COSTING
Discount rate:
9
(1 + 11%) ————— (1 + 7%) – 1 × 100% = 5% discount rate.
(ii) Inflation rate – 7% average over 25 years;
(i) Interest rate – 11% average over 25 years;
Taxation allowances are subject to negotiation and agreement.
total
Maintenance and running costs with 100% allowance – ie 1st year
Capital cost as plant and machinery with 100% tax allowance – i.e. 1st year
8
7
6
(continuation of table on page 21)
291 ——— 3,199
£ 2,908
PART 2, SECTION 2
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Financing
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Operation
TOTAL PRESENT VALUE AT END OF INVESTMENT LIFE
5,000
1
Capital
0
Year
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
–
Annual
–
1,500
–
–
–
–
–
1,500
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
1,500
–
–
–
–
–
–
Intermittent
Maintenance
Costs
COMPARATIVE COMPONENT LIFE CYCLE COSTING
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Occupacy
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Disposal/ residual value
1,500
3,000
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
3,000
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
6,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
3,000
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
1,500
5,000
TOTAL
263
263
263
263
263
263
263
525
263
263
263
263
263
1,138
263
263
263
263
263
263
263
263
263
263
263
875
VAT 17.5%
1,763
3,525
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
3,525
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
7,638
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
3,525
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
1,763
5,875
TOTAL inc VAT
582
1,163
582
582
582
582
582
1,163
582
582
582
582
582
2,521
582
582
582
582
582
1,163
582
582
582
582
582
0
Less tax allowance
1,181
2,362
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
2,362
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
5,117
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
2,362
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
1,181
5,875
NET TOTAL
0.295
0.310
0.326
0.342
0.359
0.377
0.396
0.416
0.436
0.458
0.481
0.505
0.530
0.557
0.585
0.614
0.645
0.677
0.711
0.746
0.784
0.823
0.864
0.907
0.952
1.000
Present value of £1 @ 5%
CLIENT: PROJECT TITLE: Retail Development/Shopping Mall JOB NO: OPTION: Cleaning ‘with’ gantry – curtain walling to new facace
26,444
349
732
384
404
424
445
467
981
515
541
568
596
626
2,849
690
725
761
799
839
1,763
925
971
1,020
1,071
1,124
5.875
PRESENT VALUE
26,444
26,095
25,363
24,978
24,575
24,151
23,706
23,239
22,257
21,742
21,202
20,634
20,037
19,411
16,562
15,872
15,147
14,386
13,587
12,749
10,986
10,061
9,090
8,070
6,999
5,875
CUMULATIVE PRESENT VALUE
Page 24
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
The life cycle costing is based on an agreed investment life of 25 years.
It is assumed that VAT will remain at around 17.5% and the client is the ‘end user’ under VAT rules.
3
4
There are disposal cost advantages with this option.
Details of the maintenance requirements and cost estimates can be provided upon request.
2
5
The capital cost includes allowances for opening lights now required, without capital allowances.
1
FORECASTER’S ASSUMPTIONS
COMPARATIVE COMPONENT LIFE CYCLE COSTING
Discount rate:
9
(1 + 11%) ————— (1 + 7%) – 1 × 100% = 5% discount rate.
(ii) Inflation rate – 7% average over 25 years;
(i) Interest rate – 11% average over 25 years;
Taxation allowances are subject to negotiation and agreement.
Maintenance and running costs with 100% allowance.
Capital cost as plant and machinery with 100% tax allowance – NIL
8
7
6
(continuation of table on page 23)
PART 2, SECTION 2
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.5.4
HOUSING SINKING FUND (BASED UPON COSTED PLANNED MAINTENANCE) (a) Background This example is kindly provided by Ian Sloan of Armour Construction Consultants. Housing Associations and Co-operatives in Scotland generally request that their investment/sinking fund requirements are prepared in accordance with the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations’ (SFHA) ‘Planned Maintenance and Repairs (Revised), Guidance Booklet No 3’ published in January 1997. There are various ways of presenting the data. One method widely accepted is shown below, on two spreadsheets, a Planned Maintenance Programme, and a ‘costed’ Planned Maintenance Programme which establishes in this case the present value of future costs. The spreadsheets can be ‘fine tuned’ to meet specific client requirements. In due course they can be adapted to allow historical information to be fed into the programme, which then allows actual costs and maintenance periods incurred to form the basis of the life cycle costs, thereby providing a more accurate projection. (b) Brief The client needed to establish the capital to be invested for a new build housing project to cover all maintenance and repairs for the next 60 years. The discount rate is 6%. An example of the calculation shown overleaf is: Year 15, total maintenance and repair expenditure at current prices
£9,013 × 0.41726*
= £9,013 = £3,761
i.e. £3,761 would have to be invested now for 15 years at 6% compound interest in order to meet the costs in Year 15 of £9,013. In summary £24,942 would have to be invested now at 6% to cover all maintenance and repairs for the next 60 years. The data could also be presented as an annual sinking fund e.g. the amount to be invested for each of 15 years at 6% compound interest in order to meet the costs in Year 15 of £9,013 is: £9,013 × 0.04296**
= £387
* from valuation tables at 2.2.5.7 (present value of £1) ** from valuation tables at 2.2.5.7 (annual sinking fund)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 25
Page 26
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
SERVICES
FITTS FURN
INT FABRIC
EXT FABRIC
STRUCTURE
DISPOSAL INST
HEAT SOURCE
HEAT SYSTEM
VENTILATION
5.5
5.6
5.7
WATER SUPPLY
5.3
5.4.2.
SERVICES EQUIPMENT
5.2
INTERNAL DRAINAGE
SANITARY APPLIANCES
5.1
5.4.1.
FITTINGS & FURNISH
DOORS
3.4
4.1
FLOORS
CEILINGS
3.2
3.3
INTERNAL WALLS
WINDOWS
2.3
3.1
EXTERNAL WALLS
2.2
EXTERNAL DOORS
ROOF
2.1
2.4
STAIRS
STRUCTURE
1.1
1.2
ELEMENT
CODE
4
5
5.7.1. Fans etc
5.6.1. Boilers/equipment
5.5.1. Radiators/fires
5.4.1.1.
Pipes & Fittns
Insulation
5.3.3.
5.4.2.1. Pipes & Fittns
Water pipes etc
Stainless steel
Wcs, baths, whbs
Units/Worktops
5.3.2.
5.3.1. Water storage
5.2.1. Kitchen sinks
5.1.1. Sanitary ware
4.1.2. Grab rails etc
4.1.1. Kitchen Units
3.4.2. Ironmongery
Timber
Timber
3.3.2. Skirtings
3.4.1. Door Operation
Timber/Vinyl
3.3.1. Flooring
Plasterboard
Ceramic
3.1.2. Wall Tiling
3.2.1. Ceilings
Brick/pboard
Timber/Metal
3.1.1. Walls & Open’s
2.4.4. Ironmongery
2.4.3. Painting
2.4.2. Pointing
2.4.1. Door Operation
2.3.4. Ironmongery
2.3.3. Painting
2.3.2. Pointing
2.3.1. Window Op
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< < <
<
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
<
< <
<
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
<
1 <
1 <
<
< <
< <
1 <
< <
T
T
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< < < 1
1 1
1 1
T
T
< T
< <
< <
< T
< <
< <
< T
< <
< <
< <
< T
< <
< <
< <
< < < <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< < < <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
<
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
< Timber/Glass
2.2.3. Ventilation
< <
<
< <
2.2.2. Rendering
< <
<
< <
< <
UPVC
2.1.3. Gutters etc
< <
< <
<
replacement
T = Test until
/ = Decorate
/ = Inspect &
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< T
< T
< 1
1 1
< <
< <
< <
1 <
1 /
1 <
1 /
< 1
< <
1 <
< <
1 1
T
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
<
1 < <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
T
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< 1
< <
< <
T
< T
< T
1 <
< <
< 1
1 <
1 <
< <
< /
< <
< /
< <
< <
< 1
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
<
< <
T
T
< T
< T
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< /
< <
< /
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
< <
< <
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
1 1
1
T
< T
< T
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 <
< <
1 <
< /
1 <
< /
<
1 1
< <
< <
< <
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
< <
9
< <
8
< <
7
< <
6
< <
Facing Brick
Lead
2.1.2. Flashings
<
<
3
2.2.1. Walls
Concrete Tiles
Timber
1.2.2. Handrails etc
2.1.1. Roof Tiles etc
Timber
Concrete/Brick
1.2.1. Stairs
1.1.3. Openings
Timber
1.1.2. Floors
COMPONENT
2
< = until Replacement
1 = Renewal/Replacement 1
< = Inspect and Remedy
1 = Inspect/Consider 02/12/98 Timber
KEY
1.1.1. Roofs
SUB-ELEMENT
Date Printed
PLANNED MAINTENANCE PROGRAMME EXAMPLE
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cost
Cumulative
PART 2, SECTION 2
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
EXT WORKS
SERVICES
PROTECTIVE INST
COMMUNICATION
LANDSCAPING
BOUNDARIES & ENCLOSURES
DRAINAGE
EXTERNAL SERVICES
OUTBUILDINGS
5.11
5.1.2
6.1.1
6.1.2
6.2
6.3
6.4
GAS INSTALLATION
5.9
LIFT INSTALLATION
ELECTRICAL INST
5.8
5.10
ELEMENT
CODE
4
5
<
< <
<
<
< <
<
/
/
< <
< T
<
< <
< <
1
1 1
COST IN ,000’s of
6.4.1. Binstores/platts
6.3.1. Ducts & cables
/ = Decorate
/ = Inspect &
<
< <
<
<
/
/
< <
<
<
<
< <
<
<
<
< <
< 1
<
<
< <
1 <
1 <
1 <
<
T 1
T
1 <
1
<
< <
<
<
<
< <
<
<
/
/
< <
<
<
<
< <
< T
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
1
1 1
T
< 1
<
/
/
< <
<
<
<
< <
<
<
<
< <
<
<
/
/
< <
< T
<
<
< <
<
< <
< <
<
T 1
T
< <
<
<
< <
<
<
/
/
< <
<
<
<
< <
<
<
1 1
<
< <
1
< 1
1 1
1 <
1 1
< 1 1 0
<
1 0
1 1
1
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
<
/
/
< <
<
<
<
< <
< <
<
<
< <
<
T
1
< <
/
/
< <
< T
<
6.2.2. Manholes etc
<
<
< <
<
<
<
< <
<
< < <
<
<
<
£
Close Light
replacement
T = Test until
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
6.2.1. Pipes & fittings
6.1.2.3. Clothes poles
6.1.2.2. Walls etc
6.1.2.1. Fences and gates
6.1.1.2. Grass/planting
6.1.1.1. Roads, footpaths
5.12.2 Telephones
5.12.1. Door entry
5.11.2. Smoke detectors
5.11.1. TV system etc
–
5.9.1. Equipment & supply
5.8.3. External Lighting
<
9
T
8
T
7
< 1
6
< <
3
5.8.2. Switchgear
2
<
COMPONENT
1
< = until Replacement
1 = Renewal/Replacement 02/12/98
< = Inspect and Remedy
1 = Inspect/Consider
<
KEY
5.8.1. Power and lighting
SUB-ELEMENT
Date Printed
PLANNED MAINTENANCE PROGRAMME EXAMPLE (Continued)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cost
Cumulative
PART 2, SECTION 2
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 27
Page 28
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
SERVICES
FITTS FURN
INT FABRIC
EXT FABRIC
STRUCTURE
Disposal inst
Heat source
Heat system
Ventilation
Electrical inst
5.4.2
5.5
5.6
5.7
5.8
Water Supply
5.3
Internal drainage
Services Equipment
5.4.1
Sanitary Appliances
Fittings & Furnish
4.1
5.2
Doors
3.4
5.1
Floors
Ceilings
3.2
3.3
Internal walls
Windows
2.3
3.1
External walls
2.2
External doors
Roof
2.1
2.4
Stairs
Structure
1.1
1.2
ELEMENT
CODE
2.1.3. Gutters etc
4
25
100
50
5
20
5
5 60
5
5 5
5 5
5
5.6.1. Boilers/equipment
5.8.1. Power and lighting
25
100
50
20
inc
inc
inc
20
20
100
100
100
100
100
60
5
5 5
5 5
5 60
5
5 5
5 5
5 60
5
5 5
5 5
5 60
5
5 5
5 5
5 60
5
5 5
5
inc
50
20
inc
10
inc
290
20
275
10
inc
83
inc
50
20
inc
10
inc
inc
400
inc
inc
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
20
inc
60
650
inc
60
inc
inc
125
5
5
5
5
20
inc
60
inc
inc
125
inc inc inc inc 160
5
5
5
5
100
5
5
5
5
100
5 200 5
5
5
5
1500
5
5
5
5
5
100
200
40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 750 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 750
20
inc
60
inc
inc
125
5
5 450 5
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 160 inc inc inc inc
5
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 200 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 200
60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 800 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 800
inc
5.7.1. Fans etc
inc
20 inc
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 480 inc inc inc inc
inc
5.1.1. Radiators/fires
20 inc
83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83
inc
50
20
inc
10
5.3.3. Insulation
5.4.1.1. Pipes & Fittns
25
100
50
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 60 inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc
5
5
5.3.2. Water pipes etc
5.4.2.1. Pipes & Fittns
25
100
50
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 210 inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc
100
125
Stainless steel
Wcs, baths, whbs
Units/Worktops
9
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
5.3.1. Water storage
5.2.1. Kitchen sinks
5.1.1. Sanitary ware
4.1.2. Grab rails etc
4.1.1. Kitchen Units
3.4.2. Ironmongery
Timber
Timber
3.3.2. Skirtings
3.4.1. Door Operation
Timber/Vinyl
3.3.1. Flooring
Plasterboard
Ceramic
3.1.2. Wall Tiling
3.2.1. Ceilings
Brick/pboard
Timber/Metal
3.1.1. Walls & Open’s
2.4.4. Ironmongery
2.4.3. Painting
2.4.2. Pointing
2.4.1 Door Operation
2.3.4. Ironmongery
2.3.3. Painting
8
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 2100
inc
2.3.1. Window Op
7
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 150 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 150
2.2.3. Ventilation
2.3.2. Pointing
6
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 220 20 20 20 20 inc
Timber/Glass
3
75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 2380
2
Years 1
2.2.2. Rendering
Facing Brick
Lead UPVC
2.1.2. Flashings
2.2.1. Walls
Concrete Tiles
Timber
1.2.2. Handrails etc
2.1.1. Roof Tiles etc
Timber
1.2.1. Stairs
Concrete/Brick )
Timber )
1.1.2. Floors )
1.1.3. Openings )
Timber
COMPONENT
02/12/98
1.1.1. Roofs
SUB-ELEMENT
PLANNED MAINTENANCE PROGRAMME (COSTED) Date Printed EXAMPLE
5
40
inc
5
10
60
inc
83
inc
inc
5
5
inc
100
10
10
20
20
75
21
140 140
25
100
50
20 inc
inc
100
100
5
5
60
5
5
5
5
5
5
60
5
5
5
5
5
5
60
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5 450
650
inc
60
inc
125
250
5
5
5
100
5
5
5
5
960
735 3,400
1500
3,330
1,380
0
360
0
125
875
485
1,040
870
4,020
5 200
40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 750
20
inc
60
inc
inc
125
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 160
5
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 200
60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 800
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 480
0 3,607
780
120
550
60
120
83 83 83 83 83 83 83 83 1200
290
20
275
10
540
145
545
420
1,000
290
2,390
0
0
120
1,000
990
4,555
0
150
0
600
300
Cost
Cumulative
inc
inc
50
20
inc
10
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 60
5
5
inc inc inc inc inc inc inc inc 210
100
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
inc
inc
20
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 220
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 150
75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75 75
25
100
50
22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
PART 2, SECTION 2
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
EXT WORKS
SERVICES
Communication
Landscaping
Boundaries & Enclosures 6.1.2.1. Fences and gates
5.1.2
6.1.1
6.1.2
External services
Outbuildings
6.3
6.4
Drainage
Protective inst
5
8
9
150
25
100
inc
25
25
inc
inc
150
25
100
inc
25
25
inc
inc
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
100
10
10
100 240
TOTAL COST PER YEAR
6.4.1. Binstores/platts
6.3.1. Ducts & cables
6.2.2. Manholes etc
6.2.1. Pipes & fittings
6.1.2.3. Clothes poles
6.1.2.2. Walls etc
PRESENT VALUE
40
50
50
25
inc
100
200
40
50
25
inc
100
50 40
40
50
25
inc
100
50 40
50
500
400
inc
500
750
300
750
525
0
1,000
1,270
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
85 80 177 71 188 148 60 57 124 395 48 105 42 40 655 36 33 74 30 471 54 25 24 52 59 20 44 18 17 469
Present Value
£3701 £24942 (Present Value)
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 (Yrs 31–60) 518 518 1208 518 1448 1208 518 518 1208 4068 518 1208 518 518 9013 518 518 1208 518 8673 1048 518 518 1208 1448 518 1208 518 518 15460 £57902 £115804 (Current cost)
21241 Yrs 1–30)
50
25
inc
100
50
489 461 1014 410 1082 852 344 325 715 2272 273 600 243 229 3761 204 192 423 171 2704 308 144 136 298 337 114 251 101 96 2692
40
Current Cost per yr
Repeat Years
(at discount rate of 6%)
40
57,902 (Yrs 1–30)
50
25
inc
100
50
10,200
3,650
2,400
0
0
690
525
0
150
200
0
Cost
Cumulative
518 518 1208 518 1448 1208 518 518 1208 4068 518 1208 518 518 9013 518 518 1208 518 8673 1048 518 518 1208 1448 518 1208 518 518 15460
40
10 10 500 10 10 500 10 10 500 10 10 500 10 10 3000 10 10 500 10 10 500 10 10 500 10 10 500 10 10 3000
100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 750
10
6.1.1.2. Grass/planting
10
n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
75
150
25
inc
inc
30
50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 500 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 500
£
7
10 10 10 10 75 10 10 10 10 75 10 10 10 10 75 10 10 10 10 75 10 10 10 10 75 10 10 10 10
25
25
6
6.1.1.1. Roads, footpaths
5.12.2. Telephones
5.12.1. Door entry
5.11.2. Smoke detectors
5.11.1. TV system etc
–
5.11
5.9.1. Equipment & supply
Gas installation
Lift installation
5.10
6.2
4 inc
Close Light
3
5.8.3. External Lighting
2
Years 1 inc
COMPONENT
5.8.2. Switchgear
SUB-ELEMENT
5.9
ELEMENT
CODE
PLANNED MAINTENANCE PROGRAMME (COSTED) (Continued) Date Printed 02/12/98 EXAMPLE
PART 2, SECTION 2
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 29
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.5.5
CENTRALISATION OF OFFICES STUDY (a) Brief This example is kindly provided by Gerald Hall. The client wished to investigate a centralisation (of offices) strategy as a means to improve business efficiency in an increasingly competitive market. The offices were originally spread out over three main sites. Three options were identified:
• do nothing, although this would require repair and refurbishment of the existing offices; • centralise at location A and construct additional new offices; • centralise at location B and construct additional new offices; (b) Capital Costs These were calculated using traditional cost estimating and included cyclical capital costs. The distinction between cyclical capital costs and cyclical maintenance costs is often vague, those costs in excess of £10,000 are included in the capital cost element under the assumption they would be part of the capital cost programme. Relocation costs (labour and plant required to transport office equipment, stores, machinery, compound materials and stationery items) are included under Year 0 on the assumption they would be complete within 12 months and a contingency for new furniture included. (c) Revenue Costs • fuel: the energy manager provided existing costs which were used as the basis for the new proposal; • water costs were excluded (the client was a water company); • maintenance costs under £10,000; • rates were not provided by the client by the deadline and are therefore excluded; • cleaning costs are based on existing cleaning costs and judgement; • security costs are based on existing security costs and judgement; • operation costs for this client included waste removal, water coolers, sanitary hire, mail collections, fire prevention, telephones, hygiene, insurances. Again this was based on existing client data plus judgement. Even with constant staff numbers these costs reduce with centralisation; • staffing costs were excluded as they would remain constant. (d) Capital Income Options 2 and 3 will free up existing space for sale and rent which are included as a deduction against expenditure. (e) Discount Rates In accordance with the client guidelines the investment horizon is 40 years and the discount rate 8%. Page 30
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
(f) Tax Implications Tax allowances have been excluded on the basis that this study is a minor part of the overall company business and assumptions are not appropriate. However it is worth noting that:
• Value Added Tax on all capital costs would affect the financial benefits of options 2 and 3 which require considerable capital expenditure; • Capital Allowances would help support options 2 and 3. (g) Renewal and Refurbishment Costs General building refurbishment has been allowed in ten-year cycles; electrical and mechanical plant replaced after 20 years with a refurbishment after ten years or mid-life; felt roofs replaced after 20 years; profiled metal decking, windows and doors after 30 years. All costs are calculated using traditional cost estimating and included as present costs. (h) Cost Comparison The detailed calculation is summarised over for option 2 which is the most cost effective over 40 years. Year 0 Expenditure £ £203,000 £1,164,900 £1,262,100
Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
Year 40 Net Present Value £ £1,960,950 £1,607,896 £1,843,068
(i) Sensitivity Analysis An analysis of different discount rates and time frame confirm option 2 as the most favourable. Discount Rates
Life Cycle
Option 1 £
Option 2 £
Option 3 £
6% 6% 6%
0 20 40
287,900 1,859,000 2,444,420
1,164,900 1,593,000 1,762,522
1,262,100 1,826,100 2,047,091
8% 8% 8%
0 20 40
287,900 1,614,000 1,960,950
1,164,900 1,515,000 1,607,896
1,262,100 1,721,100 1,843,068
10% 10% 10%
0 20 40
287,900 1,423,000 1,632,562
1,164,900 1,451,000 1,506,721
1,262,100 1,638,100 1,709,146
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 31
Page 32
0
0
Value 1200
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
EXPENDITURE
NET PRESENT VALUE
Present Value of £1 @ 8%
Net Cash Flow
0
0
0
0
0
0
6
0
0
0
0
7
0
0
0
0
8
0
0
0
0
9
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5.2
0
5.2
7.1
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
18
NVP£=1,607,896
1165
17
16
15
14
13
12
11
1 0.93 0.86 0.79 0.74 0.68 0.63 0.58 0.54
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
0
0
0
14
0
0
0
0
15
0
0
0
0
16
0
0
0
0
17
0
0
0
0
18
0
0
0
0
19
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
10
97
9
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
0
0
0
21
0
0
0
0
22
0
0
0
0
23
0
0
0
0
24
0
0
0
0
25
0
0
0
0
26
0
0
0
0
27
0
0
0
0
28
0
0
0
0
29
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
8
7
7
6
6
5
5
5
69
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
4
4
3
3
3
3
2
2
2
0.2 0.18 0.17 0.16 0.15 0.14 0.13 0.12 0.11
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
-7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5
300
0
0
300
20
0.4 0.37 0.34 0.32 0.29 0.27 0.25 0.23 0.21
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
-7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5
0.5 0.46 0.43
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
0
0
0
13
0
0
0
0
31
0
0
0
0
32
0
0
0
0
33
0
0
0
0
34
0
0
0
0
35
0
0
0
0
36
0
0
0
0
37
0
0
0
0
38
0
0
0
0
39
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
-7.5
310
0
0
310
40
41
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
15
0.1 0.09 0.09 0.08 0.07 0.07 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.05 0.05
0
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
-7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5
393
0
0
393
30
213
291
70
0
492
0
57
-363
-55
-308
2,393
9
16
2,369
£000
Total Value
1608
0
5.2
5.2
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
0
0
0
12
1164.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 209.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 319.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 412.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 19.9 329.9
7.1
7.1
1.7
0
12
0
1.4
-8
0
0
0
0
0
11
0
0
1.7
12
12
0
0
0
1.7
1.4
1.4
-8
0
190
0
0
190
10
1,123
0
Staff Costs
0
0
0
0
5
27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4
5.2
Operation Costs
Value
7.1
Security
0
0
4
0
0
1.7
12
Maintenance
Rates
0
Cleaning
1.4
Fuel
Value -62.5
Water
-8
-7.5
-55
Land Sale
Revenue Costs
0
0
-7.5
Annual Rental
Capital Income
3
-7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5 -7.5
0
0
8.5
Furniture
0
15.5
0
2
0
1
0
Building Works 1176
0
WATER COMPANY LIMITED CENTRALISATION OF AREA OFFICE STUDY 3985 29th MARCH 1996
Relocation Costs
Capital Costs
£’000
YEAR (SEPT 1996)
CLIENT JOB TITLE JOB NO DATE
PART 2, SECTION 2
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.5.6
TOTAL BUILDING OPTION: DEMOLISH AND REBUILD VERSUS REFURBISHMENT (a) Brief The life cycle cost appraisal is to evaluate the life cycle cost effects of the following options:
• demolish existing building and rebuild to the client’s specific requirements incorporating ‘all-air’ air conditioning systems; • refurbish the existing building to meet, as far as practicable, the client’s requirements, re-using existing systems wherever possible. The appraisal is to include all taxation implications for comparative purposes. VAT is to be included as the client is VAT-exempt. The following costs are to be excluded: – costs associated with the purchase of land; – financing charges associated with the redevelopment; – costs associated with the removal and temporary re-housing of staff during the construction period; – occupancy costs; – residual values of land or buildings. (b) Discount Rate The building is in owner-occupation and the client’s accountants have advised the use of a long-term government stock interest rate of 7%. The client has been advised that an inflation rate of 3% is a reasonable assessment. The discount rate calculation is as follows [(1.07) – 1] —— × 100 = 3.88% [(1.03) – 1] The client has agreed that the discount rate can be rounded to 4%. (c) Building Life It has been agreed with the client to use a 20-year life cycle. (d) Description of Existing Building Late 1950s office block of multi-storey framed construction with curtain wall cladding to front and rear. Solid party walls to both sides. Single-storey concrete basement. (e) Description of Existing Engineering Services Gas-fired low pressure hot water boiler situated in basement serving perimeter convector system with warm air ventilation to central parts of the building. Fluorescent luminaires to all office areas and tungsten fittings to circulation. The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 33
PART 2, SECTION 2
(f) Condition of the Existing Building The building is structurally sound with few defects; however, it is in a poor state of decorative repair. (g) Basic Requirements of the Redevelopment Gross internal area Ratio of net to gross internal area Number of occupants Ratio of occupants to net internal floor area External wall area (excluding party walls)
1500 m2 70% 110 9.7 m2 700 m2
The adjacent buildings will continue to remain in use as offices during and after the development. The structural engineers have advised that no work is required to party walls, other than temporary shoring. (h) Summary Net Present Value £k OPTION A demolish existing building and rebuild to the client’s specific requirements, incorporating ‘all air’ air conditioning systems; OPTION B refurbish the existing building to meet as far as practicable, the client’s requirements, re-using systems wherever possible. % difference (A extra on B)
3889
2177 ——— 79% ———
The net present value is a key factor in the option appraisal. However other less tangible benefits and disadvantages of each option should be carefully considered in relation to the business objectives. It is also recommended that a sensitivity analysis be carried out, for instance to look at different discount rates and time frames. The calculation of the above is detailed below.
Page 34
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Present value
Present value of £1 at 4%
NET TOTAL
Less Tax allowance
Total (inc VAT)
VAT 17½%
Total
Disposal/residual value
Occupancy
intermittent
annual
Maintenance:
Operation
Financing
Capital
Costs
OPTION A Year
LIFE CYCLE COST SUMMARY
131
23
154
102
52
.9615
50
2154
377
2531
0
2531
1
2531
61
.9246
66
88
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
2
68
.8890
76
78
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
3
TOTAL NET PRESENT VALUE £3889k
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
104
2154
27
-
£k
-
£k
-
1
0
72
.8548
84
70
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
4
77
.8219
94
67
161
24
137
-
-
6
27
104
-
-
£k
5
76
.7903
96
61
157
23
134
-
-
3
27
104
-
-
£k
6
74
.7599
97
57
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
7
72
.7307
99
55
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
8
71
.7026
101
53
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
9
103
.6756
153
74
227
34
193
-
-
62
27
104
-
-
£k
10
68
.6496
105
52
152
23
134
-
-
3
27
104
-
-
£k
11
77
.6246
124
55
179
27
152
-
-
21
27
104
-
-
£k
12
64
.6006
106
48
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
13
61
.5775
106
48
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£1
14
69
.5553
124
56
180
27
153
-
-
22
27
104
-
-
£k
15
58
.5339
108
49
157
23
134
-
-
3
27
104
-
-
£k
16
54
.5134
106
48
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
17
52
.4936
106
48
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
18
50
.4746
106
48
154
23
131
-
-
-
27
104
-
-
£k
19
81
.4564
177
80
257
40
217
-
-
86
27
104
-
-
£k
20
PART 2, SECTION 2
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 35
Page 36
-
89
-
-
Financing
Operation
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
104
18
122
75
47
.9615
45
904
158
1062
0
1062
1
1062
Total
VAT 17.5%
Total (inc VAT)
Present value
Present value of £1 at 4%
NET TOTAL
52
.9246
56
66
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
2
56
.8890
63
59
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
3
TOTAL NET PRESENT VALUE £2177k
-
-
Disposal/residual value
Less Tax allowance
-
-
-
-
intermittent
Occupancy
15
-
annual
Maintenance:
-
£k
904
£k
Costs
1
Capital
0
OPTION B Year
LIFE CYCLE COST SUMMARY
58
.8548
68
54
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
4
71
.8219
86
56
142
21
121
-
-
17
15
89
-
-
£k
5
62
.7903
78
48
126
19
107
-
-
3
15
89
-
-
£k
6
59
.7599
78
44
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
7
58
.7307
79
43
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
8
56
.7026
80
42
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
9
80
.6756
118
57
175
26
149
-
-
45
15
89
-
-
£k
10
55
.6496
85
41
126
19
107
-
-
3
15
89
-
-
£k
11
63
.6246
101
46
147
22
125
-
-
21
15
89
-
-
£k
12
50
.6006
84
38
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
13
49
.5775
84
38
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£1
14
61
.5553
110
50
160
24
136
-
-
32
15
89
-
-
£k
15
46
.5339
87
39
126
19
107
-
-
3
15
89
-
-
£k
16
43
.5134
84
38
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
17
41
.4936
84
38
122
18
104
-
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
18
40
.4746
84
38
122
18
104
-
-
69
15
89
-
-
£k
19
64
.4564
140
63
203
30
173
-
-
15
89
-
-
£k
20
PART 2, SECTION 2
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
CAPITAL OPTION A GFA: 1500 m2 Elemental Cost Plan
OPTION B
Total cost £k
£/m2GFA £
Total cost £k
£/m2GFA £
Demolition
70.0
47.0
14.0
9.0
Substructure
42.0
28.0
–
–
Superstructure
315.0
210.0
17.5
12.0
External walls
490.0
327.0
101.0
67.0
Internal walls
14.5
10.0
54.0
36.0
Internal finishings
84.0
56.0
105.0
70.0
Fittings/fixtures
2.0
1.0
–
–
Sanitary appliances
9.5
6.0
9.5
6.0
21.0
14.0
21.0
14.0
Mechanical services
252.0
168.0
94.5
63.0
Electrical services
147.0
98.0
126.0
84.0
Lift installation
77.0
51.0
91.0
60.0
External work
21.0
14.0
7.0
5.0
Drainage
8.5
6.0
3.0
2.0
Sub-total
1553.5
1036.0
643.5
429.0
Preliminaries (% of sub-total)
232.0
15%
96.5
15%
Contingencies (% of sub-total)
46.5
3%
19.5
3%
1833.0
1222.0
759.5
506.0
321.0
17.5%
144.5
19%
Public Health services
Total construction cost Professional fees( % of construction cost) Total capital costs to life cycle cost summary
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
2154.0
904.0
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 37
PART 2, SECTION 2
OPERATION
Energy see next page
OPTION A
OPTION B
£ per annum
£ per annum
13617
9964
Cleaning OPTION A Budget allowance £7.00 per m2
10500
OPTION B Budget allowance £9.00 per m2 NB: existing building materials more labour intensive for cleaning
13500
Rates (including water rates) OPTION A Budget allowance £50.00 per m2
75000
OPTION B Budget allowance £42.00 per m2
63000
NB: air conditioned building attracts higher rates Insurance Building fabric replacement OPTION A Budget allowance 0.2% of building cost (£2154)
4308
OPTION B OPTION B Budget allowance 0.2% of building cost (£904) Total operation costs Total £k to life cycle cost summary
Page 38
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
1808
103425
88272
104
89
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99) 2200 2200
Small Power
Power for mechanical services
60
100
80
5.50
5.50
5.50
1.076**
1500
1500
1500
1500
114,840
33,000
52,800
240,000
(f)
kwh*
13617
6316
1815
2904
2582
£ per annum (g) f × c/100
1500
1500
1500
1500
(d)
m2
Area
20
10
20
190
(e)
w/m2
Energy rate
3 9,600
33,000
52,800
285,000
(f)
kwh*
OPTION B
Effective from 1/6/99
*** Assume cooling load 120 watts/m2 Conversion rate electricity to cooling 2.5:1 Therefore w/m2 for cooling 120/2.5 = 48 + 10 (other mechanical plant) = 58
** Gas Board rate per therm 30p 1 therm = 27.8 kwh rate per kwh = 35.2/27.8 = 1.076
1000
9964
2178
1815
2904
3067
£ per annum (g) f × c/100
*NB: formula for kwh = area (d) × energy rate (e) × unit energy cost (c) × building usage (a) × diversity (b)
58***
10
20
160
(e)
w/m2
m2 (d)
Energy rate
OPTION A Area
Total energy costs to operation costs summary
2200
50
(c)
(b)
2000
(p/kwh)
(%)
(hrs per annum) (a)
Unit energy cost
Diversity
Building usage
Lighting
Electricity
Heating – Option A
Gas
SYSTEM
ENERGY
PART 2, SECTION 2
Page 39
PART 2, SECTION 2
ANNUAL MAINTENANCE OPTION A £/m2 General building maintenance Engineering services maintenance Lifts – service agreement
OPTION B
£ per annum
£/m2
£ per annum
4.00
6000
4.00
6000
12.00*
18000
4.00
6000
1.50
2250
1.50
2250
Total annual maintenance costs
Total £k to life cycle cost summary
£26,250
£14,250
£27k
£15k
* NB: full air conditioning maintenance for Option A
Page 40
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
–
External decoration (fire escapes only)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
–
paintwork, etc.
–
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
–
–
Total £k to life cycle cost summary
–
–
electrical (luminaires)
lifts (major overhaul)
Totals
–
–
mechanical (equipment)
Engineering services:
paintwork, etc.
carpets
–
–
External decoration (facades, etc.)
Internal finishings:
–
£k
Costs
Roof renewal
0
Year
OPTION B
–
Total £k to life cycle cost summary
–
–
electrical (luminaires)
lifts (major overhaul)
Totals
–
mechanical (equipment)
Engineering services:
–
carpets
Internal finishings:
–
£k
Costs
Roof renewal
0
Year
OPTION A
INTERMITTENT MAINTENANCE
£k
1
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
1
£k
2
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
2
£k
3
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
3
£k
4
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
4
–
17
16.5
–
–
–
5.5
–
11
£k
5
6
6
–
–
–
5.5
–
0.5
–
£k
5
–
–
3.0
3.0
–
–
–
–
3.0
£k
6
3
3
–
–
–
–
3.0
–
–
£k
6
£k
7
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
7
£k
8
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
8
£k
9
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
9
–
45
44.5
–
14
14
5.5
–
11
£k
10
62
62
–
14
42
5.5
–
0.5
–
£k
10
–
–
3
3.0
–
–
–
–
3.0
£k
11
3
3.0
–
–
–
–
3.0
–
–
£k
11
–
–
21
21
–
–
–
–
21
£k
12
21
21
–
–
–
–
21
–
–
£k
12
£k
13
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
13
£k
14
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
14
–
32
32
15.5
–
–
5.5
–
11
£k
15
22
21.5
15.5
–
–
5.5
–
0.5
–
£k
15
–
–
3
3.0
–
–
–
–
3.0
£k
16
3
3.0
–
–
–
–
3.0
–
–
£k
16
£k
17
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
17
£k
18
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
18
£k
19
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
£k
19
69
68.5
–
14
14
5.5
14
11
10
£k
20
86
86
–
14
42
5.5
14
0.5
10
£k
20
PART 2, SECTION 2
Page 41
PART 2, SECTION 2
TAX VAT
CHARGEABLE VALUE
VAT RATE
OPTION A
OPTION B
£k
%
£k
£k
320.8 56.2
OPTION A
Capital costs Fees
1833 321
17½ 17½
OPTION B
Capital costs Fees
759.5 144.5
17½ 17½
132.9 25.3
Total VAT to capital costs
377
158.2
Total £k to life cycle cost summary
377
158
VAT is chargeable directly on all running costs items and appears on the summary. Corporation Tax The client currently pays corporation tax at the rate of 31%. This percentage has been assumed for all calculations. Tax allowance - running costs 100% tax deductible based upon total inclusive of VAT*, e.g. running cost VAT Total Tax allowance @ 31%
£100 £17.50 £117.50 £36.43
Tax allowance - capital costs Certain capital items are classified as plant and machinery (see appendix E) and are tax deductible at a rate of 25% per annum on reducing balance, e.g. capital item £10,000 First year tax allowance 10,000 × 25% × 31% Second year tax allowance 7,500 × 25% × 31% Tax allowances can only be allowed one year in arrears. *NB. This is only applicable when the client is an end user and exempt from VAT. If, in the course of his business, the client can claim back VAT he cannot claim tax relief on this portion of his costs.
Page 42
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
–
122
243
75
Total Apply current tax rate 31%
Total £k to LCC summary
121
From LCC summary (inc VAT)
Running cost allowances
reducing balance
£482.1k (inc VAT) @ 25% p.a.
Total allowances see next page
Capital allowances
OPTION B
Total £k to LCC summary
102
328
Total
Apply current tax rate 31%
154
174
£k
£k
–
1
0
From LCC summary (inc VAT)
Running cost allowances
reducing balance
£696k (inc VAT) @ 25% p.a.
Total allowances see next page
Capital allowances
OPTION A
TAX ALLOWANCE
66
212
122
90
88
285
154
131
£k
2
59
190
122
68
78
252
154
98
£k
3
54
173
122
51
70
227
154
73
£k
4
56
180
142
38
67
216
161
55
£k
5
48
155
126
29
61
198
157
41
£k
6
44
143
122
21
57
185
154
31
£k
7
43
138
122
16
55
177
154
23
£k
8
42
134
122
12
53
171
154
17
£k
9
57
184
175
9
74
240
227
13
£k
10
41
133
126
7
52
167
157
10
£k
11
46
147
147
–
55
179
179
–
£k
12
38
122
122
–
48
154
154
–
£k
13
38
122
122
–
48
154
154
–
£k
14
50
160
160
–
56
180
150
–
£k
15
39
126
126
–
49
157
157
–
£k
16
38
122
122
–
48
154
154
–
£k
17
38
122
122
–
48
154
154
–
£k
18
38
122
122
–
48
154
154
–
£k
19
63
203
203
–
80
257
257
–
£k
20
PART 2, SECTION 2
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 43
PART 2, SECTION 2
CAPITAL ALLOWANCE
GFA: 1500 m2
Proposed capital allowance for taxation purposes Subject to negotiation and agreement with the Inland Revenue on evidence of eventual costs Total cost £k
Elemental cost plan Demolition Substructure Superstructure External walls Internal walls Internal finishings Fittings/fixtures Sanitary appliances Public Health services Mechanical services Electrical services
70 42 315 490 14.5 84 2.0 9.5 21 252 147
OPTION A % tax allowable £k
Tax allowable £k
Total cost £k
OPTION B % tax allowable £k
– – – – – – 20 100 – 100 60
– – – – – – 0.4 9.5 – 252.0 88.2
14 – 17.5 101 54 105 – 9.5 21 94.5 126
– – 30 – 30 – – 100 – 100 60
Tax Remarks allowable £k – – 5.3 – 16.2 – – 9.5 – 94.5 75.6
Lift installation External work Drainage Sub-total Preliminaries (% of sub-total)
77 21 8.5 1553.5 233
100 – – 27.5 27.5
77.0 – – 427.1 64.1
91 7 3 634.5 96.5
100 – – 45.4 45.4
91.0 – – 292.1 43.8
Contingencies (% of sub-total) Total construction cost Professional fees (% of construction cost) VAT Total tax-allowable capital costs to previous page
46.5 1833 321
27.5
12.8
45.4
8.9
27.5
88.3
19.5 759.5 144.5
45.4
65.6
377
27.5
103.7 696
158
45.4
71.7 482.1
Page 44
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
BWIC allowable on refurbishment BWIC allowable on refurbishment
Office lighting and associated switchgear not allowable
Taken on proportion of construction costs
Option A – Fees only
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
2.2.5.7
A SELECTION FROM PARRY’S VALUATION AND INVESTMENT TABLES (for full tables rewference is made to Parry’s Valuation and Investment Tables, A W Davidson (1989), (111th Edition) (Estates Gazette) YEARS’ PURCHASE
No Income Tax
Single Rate
RATE PER CENT Years 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 60
2 0.9804 1.9416 2.8839 3.8077 4.7135 5.6014 6.4720 7.3255 8.1622 8.9826 9.7868 10.5753 11.3484 12.1062 12.8493 13.5777 14.2919 14.9920 15.6785 16.3514 17.0112 17.6580 18.2922 18.9139 19.5235 20.1210 20.7069 21.2813 21.8444 22.3965 22.9377 23.4683 23.9886 24.4986 24.9986 25.4888 25.9695 26.4406 26.9026 27.3555 27.7995 28.2348 28.6616 29.0800 29.4902 29.8923 30.2866 30.6731 31.0521 31.4236 34.7609
3 0.9709 1.9135 2.8286 3.7171 4.5797 5.4172 6.2303 7.0197 7.7861 8.5302 9.2526 9.9540 10.6350 11.2961 11.9379 12.5611 13.1661 13.7535 14.3238 14.8775 15.4150 15.9369 16.4436 16.9355 17.4131 17.8768 18.3270 18.7641 19.1885 19.6004 20.0004 20.3888 20.7658 21.1318 21.4872 21.8323 22.1672 22.4925 22.8082 23.1148 23.4124 23.7014 23.9819 24.2543 24.5187 24.7754 25.0247 25.2667 25.5017 25.7298 27.6756
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
4 0.9615 1.8861 2.7751 3.6299 4.4518 5.2421 6.0021 6.7327 7.4353 8.1109 8.7605 9.3851 9.9856 10.5631 11.1184 11.6523 12.1657 12.6593 13.1339 13.5903 14.0292 14.4511 14.8568 15.2470 15.6221 15.9828 16.3296 16.6631 16.9837 17.2920 17.5885 17.8736 18.1476 18.4112 18.6646 18.9083 19.1426 19.3679 19.5845 19.7928 19.9931 20.1856 20.3708 20.5488 20.7200 20.8847 21.0429 21.1951 21.3415 21.4822 22.6235
5 0.9524 1.8594 2.7232 3.5460 4.3295 5.0757 5.7864 6.4632 7.1078 7.7217 8.3064 8.8633 9.3936 9.8986 10.3797 10.8378 11.2741 11.6896 12.0853 12.4622 12.8212 13.1630 13.4886 13.7986 14.0939 14.3752 14.6430 14.8981 15.1411 15.3725 15.5928 15.8027 16.0025 16.1929 16.3742 16.5469 16.7113 16.8679 17.0170 17.1591 17.2944 17.4232 17.5459 17.6628 17.7741 17.8801 17.9810 18.0772 18.1687 18.2559 18.9293
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
6 0.9434 1.8334 2.6730 3.4651 4.2124 4.9173 5.5824 6.2098 6.8017 7.3601 7.8869 8.3838 8.8527 9.2950 9.7122 10.1059 10.4773 10.8276 11.1581 11.4699 11.7641 12.0416 12.3034 12.5504 12.7834 13.0032 13.2105 13.4062 13.5907 13.7648 13.9291 14.0840 14.2302 14.3681 14.4982 14.6210 14.7368 14.8460 14.9491 15.0463 15.1380 15.2245 15.3062 15.3832 15.4558 15.5244 15.5890 15.6500 15.7076 15.7619 16.1614
7 0.9346 1.8080 2.6243 3.3872 4.1002 4.7665 5.3893 5.9713 6.5152 7.0236 7.4987 7.9427 8.3577 8.7455 9.1079 9.4466 9.7632 10.0591 10.3356 10.5940 10.8355 11.0612 11.2722 11.4693 11.6536 11.8258 11.9867 12.1371 12.2777 12.4090 12.5318 12.6466 12.7538 12.8540 12.9477 13.0352 13.1170 13.1935 13.2649 13.3317 13.3941 13.4524 13.5070 13.5579 13.6055 13.6500 13.6916 13.7305 13.7668 13.8007 14.0392
Effective from 1/6/99
8 0.9259 1.7833 2.5771 3.3121 3.9927 4.6229 5.2064 5.7466 6.2469 6.7101 7.1390 7.5361 7.9038 8.2442 8.5595 8.8514 9.1216 9.3719 9.6036 9.8181 10.0168 10.2007 10.3711 10.5288 10.6748 10.8100 10.9352 11.0511 11.1584 11.2578 11.3498 11.4350 11.5139 11.5869 11.6546 11.7172 11.7752 11.8289 11.8786 11.9246 11.9672 12.0067 12.0432 12.0771 12.1084 12.1374 12.1643 12.1891 12.2122 12.2335 12.3766
Page 45
PART 2, SECTION 2
No Income Tax
PRESENT VALUE OF £1 RATE PER CENT
Years 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 60
Page 46
2 .9803922 .9611688 .9423223 .9238454 .9057308 .8879714 .8705602 .8534904 .8367553 .8203483 .8042630 .7884932 .7730325 .7578750 .7430147 .7284458 .7141626 .7001594 .6864308 .6729713 .6597758 .6468390 .6341559 .6217215 6095309 .5975793 .5858620 .5743746 .5631123 .5520709 .5412460 .5306333 .5202287 .5100282 .5000276 .4902232 .4806109 .4711872 .4619482 .4528904 .4440102 .4353041 .4267688 .4184007 .4101968 .4021537 .3942684 .3865376 .3789584 .3715279 .3047823
3 .9708738 .9425959 .9151417 .8884870 .8626088 .8374843 .8130915 .7894092 .7664167 .7440939 .7224213 .7013799 .6809513 .6611178 .6418619 .6231669 .6050164 .5873946 .5702860 .5536758 .5375493 .5218925 .5066917 .4919337 .4776056 .4636947 .4501891 .4370768 .4243464 .4119868 .3999871 .3883370 .3770262 .3660449 .3553834 .3450324 .3349829 .3252262 .3157535 .3065568 .2976280 .2889592 .2805429 .2723718 .2644386 .2567365 .2492588 .2419988 .2349503 .2281071 .1697331
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
4 .9615385 .9245562 .8889964 .8548042 .8219271 .7903145 .7599178 .7306902 .7025867 .6755642 .6495809 .6245970 .6005741 .5774751 .5552645 .5339082 .5133732 .4936281 .4746424 .4563869 .4388336 .4219554 .4057263 .3901215 .3751168 .3606892 .3468166 .3334775 .3206514 .3083187 .2964603 .2850579 .2740942 .2635521 .2534155 .2436687 .2342968 .2252854 .2166206 .2082890 .2002779 .1925749 .1851682 .1780463 .1711984 .1646139 .1582826 .1521948 .1463411 .1407126 .0950604
5 .9523810 .9070295 .8638376 .8227025 .7835262 .7462154 .7106813 .6768394 .6446089 .6139133 .5846793 .5568374 .5303214 .5050680 .4810171 .4581115 .4362967 .41552-7 .3957340 .3768895 .3589424 .3418499 .3255713 .3100679 .2953028 .2812407 .2678483 .2550936 .2429463 .2313774 .2203595 .2098662 .1998725 .1903548 .1812903 .1726574 .1644356 .1566054 .1491480 .1420457 .1352816 .1288396 .1227044 .1168613 .1112965 .1059967 .1009492 .0961421 .0915639 .0872037 .0535355
Effective from 1/6/99
6 .9433962 .8899964 .8396193 .7920937 .7472582 .7049605 .6650571 .6274124 .5918985 .5583948 .5267875 .4969694 .4688390 .4423010 .4172651 .3936463 .3713644 .3503438 .3305130 .3118047 .2941554 .2775051 .2617973 .2469785 .2329986 .2198100 .2073680 .1956301 .1845567 .1741101 .1642548 .1549574 .1461862 .1379115 .1301052 .1227408 .1157932 .1092389 .1030555 .0972222 .0917190 .0865274 .0816296 .0770091 .0726501 .0685378 .0646583 .0609984 .0575457 .0542884 .0303143
7 .9345794 .8734387 .8162979 .7628952 .7129862 .6663422 .6227497 .5820091 .5439337 .5083493 .4750928 .4440120 .4149644 .3878172 .3624460 .3387346 .3165744 .2958639 .2765083 .2584190 .2415131 .2257132 .2109469 .1971466 .1842492 .1721955 .1609304 .1504022 .1405628 .1313671 .1227730 .1147411 .1072347 .1002193 .0936629 .0875355 .0818088 .0764569 .0714550 .0667804 .0624116 .0583286 .0545127 .0509464 .0476135 .0444986 .0415875 .0388668 .0363241 .0339478 .0172573
8 .9259259 .8573388 .7938322 .7350299 .6805832 .6301696 .5834904 .5402689 .5002490 .4631935 .4288829 .3971138 .3676979 .3404610 .3152417 .2918905 .2702690 .2502490 .2317121 .2145482 .1986557 .1839405 .1703153 .1576993 .1460179 .1352018 .1251868 .1159137 .1073275 .0993773 .0920160 .0852000 .0788889 .0730453 .0676345 .0626246 .0579857 .0536905 .0497134 .0460309 .0426212 .0394641 .0365408 .0338341 .0313279 .0290073 .0268586 .0248691 .0230269 .0213212 .0098759
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2
No Income Tax
ANNUAL SINKING FUND FOR THE REDEMPTION OF £1 CAPITAL INVESTED
Years 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 60
2 1.0000000 .4950495 .3267547 .2426238 .1921584 .1585258 .1345120 .1165098 .1025154 .0913265 .0821779 .0745596 .0681184 .0622020 .0578255 .0536501 .0499698 .0467021 .0437818 .0411567 .0387848 .0366314 .0346681 .0328711 .0312204 .0296992 .0282931 .0269897 .0257784 .0246499 .0235963 .0226106 .0216865 .0208187 .0200022 .0192329 .0185068 .0178206 .0171711 .0165557 .0159719 .0154173 .0148899 .0143879 .0139096 .0134534 .0130179 .0126018 .0122040 .0118232 .0087680
RATE PER CENT 3 1.0000000 .4926108 .3235304 .2390270 .1883546 .1545975 .1305064 .1124564 .0984339 .0872305 .0780774 .0704621 .0640295 .0585263 .0537666 .0496108 .0459525 .0427087 .0398139 .0372157 .0348718 .0327474 .0308139 .0290474 .0274279 .0259383 .0245642 .0232932 .0221147 .0210193 .0199989 .0190466 .0181561 .0173220 .0165393 .0158038 .0151116 .0144593 .0138439 .0132824 .0127124 .0121917 .0116981 .0112298 .0107852 .0103625 .0099605 .0095778 .0092131 .0088655 .0061330
4 1.0000000 .4901961 .3203485 .2354900 .1846271 .1507619 .1266096 .1085278 .0944930 .0832909 .0741490 .0665522 .0601437 .0546690 .0499411 .0458200 .0421985 .0389933 .0361386 .0335818 .0312801 .0291988 .0273091 .0255868 .0240120 .0225674 .0212385 .0200130 .0188799 .0178301 .0168554 .0159486 .0151036 .0143148 .0135773 .0128869 .0122396 .0116319 .0110608 .0105235 .0100174 .0095402 .0090899 .0086645 .0082625 .0078820 .0075219 .0071806 .0068571 .0065502 .0042018
5 1.0000000 .4878049 .3172086 .2320118 .1809748 .1470175 .1228198 .1047218 .0906901 .0795046 .0703889 .0628254 .0564558 .0510240 .0463423 .0422699 .0386991 .0355462 .0327450 .0302426 .0279961 .0259705 .0241368 .0224709 .0209525 .0195643 .0182919 .0171225 .0160455 .0150514 .0141321 .0132804 .0124900 .0117554 .0110717 .0104345 .0098398 .0092842 .0087646 .0082782 .0078223 .0073947 .0069933 .0066163 .0062617 .0059282 .0056142 .0053184 .0050396 .0047767 .0028282
6 1.0000000 .4854369 .3141098 .2285915 .1773964 .1433626 .1191350 .1010359 .0870222 .0758680 .0667929 .0592770 .0529601 .0475849 .0429628 .0389521 .0354448 .0323565 .0296209 .0271846 .0250045 .0230456 .0212785 .0196790 .0182267 .0169043 .0156972 .0145926 .0135796 .0126489 .0117922 .0110023 .0102729 .0095984 .0089739 .0083948 .0078574 .0073581 .0068938 .0064615 .0060589 .0056834 .0053331 .0050061 .0047005 .0044149 .0041477 .0038977 .0036636 .0034443
7 1.0000000 .4830918 .3110517 .2252281 .1738907 .1397958 .1155532 .0974678 .0834865 .0723775 .0633569 .0559020 .0496508 .0443449 .0397946 .0358576 .0324252 .0294126 .0267530 .0243929 .0222890 .0204058 .0187139 .0171890 .0158105 .0145610 .0134257 .0123919 .0114487 .0105864 .0097969 .0090729 .0084081 .0077967 .0072340 .0067153 .0062368 .0057951 .0053868 .0050091 .0046596 .0043359 .0040359 .0037577 .0034996 .0032600 .0030374 .0028307 .0026385 .0024598
8 1.0000000 .4807692 .3080335 .2219208 .1704565 .1363154 .1120724 .0940148 .0800797 .0690295 .0600763 .0526950 .0465218 .0412969 .0368295 .0329769 .0296294 .0267021 .0241276 .0218522 .0198323 .0180321 .0164222 .0149780 .0136788 .0125071 .0114481 .0104889 .0096185 .0088274 .0081073 .0074508 .0068516 .0063041 .0058033 .0053447 .0049244 .0045389 .0041851 .0038602 .0035615 .0032868 .0030341 .0028015 .0025873 .0023899 .0022080 .0020403 .0018856 .0017429
Extracts from Parry’s Valuation and Investment Tables, A W Davidson (1989), (11th Edition) (Estates Gazette) reproduced by permission of the College of Estate Management which owns the copyright.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2 (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 47
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX A
I
Appendix A: Residual Values A1
At the end of the life of a building, the component/building and the land will have a residual value.
A2
There will be one of two situations. Either the building will have reached the end of its life, with no alternative use, or the building will have reached the end of the life for its planned purpose, but does have an alternative use.
A3
In either situation the residual value of the building and/or the land may be significant and will need to be carefully assessed as it may have a substantial effect on life cycle costing calculations. Residual values will be of particular significance if the time horizon used for life cycle costing calculations is relatively short.
A4
In considering residual values, an allowance should be made for the cost of disposing of plant and equipment and for the demolition of buildings, if appropriate. In assessing demolition costs, allowance should be made for the value of any re-usable materials.
A5
Owners also need to be cognisant of taxation issues and whether these affect their property/building decisions.
A6
There are strict guidelines for taxation adjustments that arise at disposal. If the plant and machinery is ‘scrapped’ the remaining value is written off and a balancing allowance brought into account. Alternatively if the building (and the plant and machinery contained therein) is sold, the vendor should declare whether allowances have been claimed. An adjustment to their after tax cost will arise depending upon whether the disposal value is greater or less than the written down value remaining on the vendor’s accounts.
A7
This area of tax advice is experiencing increased scrutiny from the Inland Revenue and the District Valuer’s Department, as parties to property transactions sometimes select/contract disposal values of tax relievable components with specific tax planning objectives.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix A (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX B
I
Appendix B: Obsolescence B1
Building life is influenced by obsolescence. Almost all its forms relate to economic considerations. However, six different forms of obsolescence can be categorised as:
• • • • • •
physical economic functional technological social legal.
B2
Buildings usually end their ‘life’ before the end of their physical life. The most common reasons for buildings becoming obsolete are probably economic and functional considerations. Buildings designed for a specific specialised use, with little or no flexibility for changing their use, are therefore likely to have shorter lives than buildings offering flexibility for the change of function of the building.
B3
The table below gives definitions and examples of each form of obsolescence: Types of obsolescence
Definition of type of obsolescence
Basis for assessment of building life
Examples of factors leading to obsolescence
Physical
Life of the building to when physical collapse is possible.
How long will the building stand up?
Deterioration of external brick walls affecting their structural stability. Deterioration of suspended concrete floors, containing high alumina cement, in multi-storey buildings, affecting structural stability.
Economic
Life of the building to when occupation is not considered to be the least cost alternative of meeting a particular objective.
How long will the building be economic for the client to own or operate?
The value of the land on which the building stands is more than the capitalised full rental value that could be derived from letting the building. The asset would achieve a better rate of return in the possession of another, or in the redevelopment or refurbishment scheme.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix B (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX B
Types of obsolescence
Definition of type of obsolescence
Basis for assessment of building life
Examples of factors leading to obsolescence
Functional
Life of the building to when the building ceases to function for the same purpose as that for which it was built.
How long will the building be used for the purpose for which it was built?
Cinemas converted into bingo halls, village railway stations converted into private houses.
Technological
Life of the building until the building is no longer technologically superior to alternatives.
How long will the building be technologically superior to alternatives?
Prestige office unable to accommodate introduction of high level of computing facilities. Storage warehouse unable to accommodate the introduction of robotics for goods handling.
Social and Legal
Page 2
The life of a building until the time when human desire or legal requirement dictates replacement for reasons other than economic considerations.
How long will the building meet human desires, (with the exclusion of economic considerations).
Timber football stand replaced (following Bradford Football Club fire disaster). Multi-storey flats in inner city demolished (following social and community problems).
B4
Notwithstanding the difficulty of the task, the surveyor, in consultation with the client, should make an informed assessment of the building life to be used in any particular study. In making that assessment the surveyor will need to take account of a number of factors which may influence the final assessment of building life in any particular case.
B5
While the above examples relate to the whole building, obsolescence of elements or components is also relevant, for example major refurbishment of retail buildings at say 15-year intervals to remain attractive.
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix B (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX C
I
Appendix C: Costs And Values The following checklist provides suggestions for cost and value categories to be considered. This list is not exhaustive and items may need to be added or others disregarded as applicable to any particular project. C1 C1.1 C1.2 C1.3 C1.4 C1.5 C1.6 C1.7 C1.8 C1.9 C1.10 C1.11 C1.12 C1.13
CAPITAL COSTS Land Fees on acquisition Design team professional fees Demolition and site clearance Construction price for building work Cost of statutory consents Development Land Tax Capital Gains Tax Value Added Tax Furnishings Other capital costs Commissioning expenses Decanting charges
C2 C2.1 C2.2 C2.3
FINANCING COSTS Finance for land purchase and during construction Finance during period of intended occupation Loan charges (public sector)
C3 C3.1 C3.2 C3.3 C3.4 C3.5 C3.6 C3.7 C3.8 C3.9 C3.10 C3.11
OPERATION COSTS Energy Cleaning Rates Insurances Security and Health Staff (related to the building) Management and administration of the building Land charges Energy conservation measures Internal planting Equipment associated with occupier’s occupation
C4
ANNUAL MAINTENANCE COSTS, INTERMITTENT MAINTENANCE, REPLACEMENT ALTERATION COSTS Main structure External decorations Internal decorations Finishes, fixtures and fittings Plumbing and sanitary services Heat source
C4.1 C4.2 C4.3 C4.4 C4.5 C4.6
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix C (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
AND
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX C
Page 2
C4.7 C4.8 C4.9 C4.10 C4.11 C4.12 C4.13 C4.14 C4.15
Space heating and air treatment Ventilating systems Electrical installations Gas installations Life and conveyor installation Communications installation Special and protective installations External works Gardening
C5 C5.1
OCCUPANCY COSTS Client’s occupancy costs
C6 C6.1 C6.2 C6.3
RESIDUAL VALUES Resale value – building, land and plant and equipment Related costs – demolition and site clearance and disposal of fees and charges Capital Gains Tax and balancing charges
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix C (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX D
I
Appendix D: Glossary of Terms for Taxation D1
CAPITAL EXPENDITURE Money expended in acquiring long life assets which includes land, buildings, permanent improvements or additions/extensions to existing assets including associated professional fees, furniture and equipment thereto, which are intended for use in the carrying out of business operations. These assets should have a useful life of more than one year.
D2
REVENUE EXPENDITURE Expenditure incurred as a trading expense e.g. salaries, consumables, occupancy and regular maintenance costs.
D3
TAXATION ‘DEPRECIATION’ ALLOWANCES (FOR TAXATION PURPOSES) This is a collective term for taxation relief afforded to commercial (tax paying) organisations to offset the cost of capital expenditure incurred upon assets used for the purposes of their trade. As explained in 2.2.3 there are various types of taxation allowances and the proportion of initial expenditure which attracts tax relief is often varied by successive Finance Acts. This should be differentiated from the rate of depreciation adopted by accountants/auditors when preparing company management accounts to allow provision for replacement of assets. This is because the depreciation allowance for taxation purposes is fixed by legislation. When an asset is disposed of a review of the allowances received is required and an adjustment may be necessary.
D4
INDUSTRIAL BUILDING Industrial buildings or structures which qualify for capital allowances are defined in the statutes CAA 1968 S7 and CAA 1990 S18. These include factories, manufacturing, storage, docks, tunnels and mines. There are specific rules which apply where part of the building is used for a non-qualifying purpose.
D5
PLANT AND MACHINERY This type of tax relief was introduced after the second world war to provide an incentive to industry to replace equipment used in industry and commerce. The precise definition of plant and machinery is frequently contested in the courts. To assist clarification examples of items likely to attract taxation relief are illustrated in Appendix E.
D6
INITIAL ALLOWANCES/FIRST YEAR ALLOWANCES These were introduced to provide an acceleration to the standard rate of annual tax relief (depreciation allowance) being a proportion of the original capital expenditure.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix D (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX D
Governments use successive Finance Acts to vary the proportion awarded to increase or reduce this incentive as a method of influencing or stimulating capital investment within the commercial sector of the economy. D7
ANNUAL ‘WRITING DOWN’ ALLOWANCE This is the annual depreciation allowance awarded in respect to ‘qualifying expenditure’ as a proportion of the residual balance of the initial expenditure i.e. original cost less the amounts already calculated and benefiting from tax relief.
D8
BALANCING ALLOWANCE Upon disposal of an asset a comparison between its value and the written down amount remaining on the owner’s accounts is required. If the asset is sold for a sum in excess of the vendor’s after tax relief cost, then a ‘profit’ has arisen which is subject to an adjustment to the depreciation allowance (i.e. reduction of tax relief), termed a ‘balancing charge’. Alternatively, if the asset is ‘scrapped’ or disposed of at low value (compared with the residual amount) then an additional tax relief is awarded, termed a ‘balancing allowance’.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix D (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX E
I
Appendix E: Examples of items of Expenditure Likely to Attract Taxation Allowances Item Finishes/fixtures/ fittings
Plant and equipment 1. 2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7. 8.
Wall finishes where they can be removed from the building, e.g. curtains, curtain track, battens for fixing Floor finishes such as carpets and any floor finishing that can be removed from the building Door mats and matwell frames Suspended ceilings which are airtight and can be used as an extract system or any ceiling which is an integral part of the heating, ventilating or air conditioning system Any movable fixtures and fittings Demountable partitions Curtains, blinds and furnishing Cupboards, lockers, shelves, display counters, chalkboards, dustbins, cloakroom fittings, telephone booths
Plumbing and sanitary services
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Sanitary fittings (not the pipework) Vanity units Soap dispensers Mirrors Demountable toilet partitions Coat hooks and racks Towel rails and cabinets Toilet roll holders Tanks
Heat source
1.
Boilers and equipment, fuel pumps, water pumps, flue, etc. (not the pipework from the boiler) Boiler bases and foundations Oil storage tanks and foundations Fuel hoppers, ash removal plant Control equipment to the heating system Builder’s work in connection with the heat source Part cost of boiler room
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Space heating and air treatment
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Ventilation systems
1. 2. 3. 4.
Electrical installations
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Gas installations
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
1.
Equipment in connection with heating, air conditioning and hot water installation (not the pipework or ducting) Builder’s work in connection with the equipment Plant room Electrical and mechanical control system Solar heating systems Insulation to pipework Dust and fume extraction equipment including ductwork and builder’s work in connection Extract fans and builder’s work Ventilators Instrumentation controls Electrical installation to all plant and equipment (excludes conduit and wiring to power and lighting for the building generally) Light fittings Emergency lighting Switchgear and transformers Control gear and distribution boards Plant rooms Builder’s work in connection with the electrical installation Gas fires, cookers and equipment including flues and builder’s work in connection
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix E (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX E
Item Lift and conveyor installations Communications installations
Special installations/ protective installations
Plant and equipment 1. 2.
Lift installation complete including builder’s work in connection with lift motors, lift guides and plant room Escalators and hoists are as for lifts
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Clocks Sound distribution, bells, signals and the like Fire alarms Burglar alarms Telephone installation Builder’s work in connection with communication installations
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
Page 2
Sprinkler system Dry riser system Hosereel system CO2 system Fire extinguishers Refrigeration equipment Kitchen equipment Laundry equipment Health equipment Laboratory equipment Manufacturing equipment Incinerators and flues Water heaters Hand dryers Window cleaning hoists and equipment including track, motors and ancillary builder’s work Refuse disposal equipment including ancillary builder’s work Lighting conductors and earthing systems Occupational equipment associated with the building user Computer equipment and all ancillary work Crane gantries All builder’s work in connection with items 1 to 20 above
Special items within a building (the items shown are only given as indicative of the types of item)
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Removable fire escapes Shelving Safes and strong rooms Roller shutters Ladders Dock levellers Signs/notice boards Interior planting
External works
1. 2. 3. 4.
External signs Traffic signs, crash barriers Drainage where it is specifically required for plant and equipment Cycle racks
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix E (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX F
I
Appendix F: Further Reading Ferry, D.J.O., Flanagan, R., Life Cycle Costing: A Radical Approach, Construction Industry Research and Information Association (CIRIA Report 122), London, 1991 Flanagan, Roger, Norman, George, Furbur, J. David & Townsend, Geoffrey M., Life Cycle Costing For Construction, Surveyors Publications, London, 1983 Flanagan, Roger, Norman, George Meadows, Justin Robinson, Graham, Life Cycle Costing: Theory and Practice, BSP Professional Books, Oxford, 1989 HM Treasury. Guidance Note No. 35: Life Cycle Costing, Central Unit on Procurement, HM Treasury, London, 1992 Data Sources Bernard Williams Associates, Facilities Economics. Bernard Williams Associates, Building Economics Bureau Ltd, Kent. Tel: 0181 460 1111, 1995. A comprehensive study including hard costs. BMI. Energy Consumption Study, Building Maintenance Information, 12 Great George Street, London, SW1P 3AD, Tel: 0171 222 7000, 1996. Covers typical energy costs for different building types. BMI. Occupancy Cost Planning, Building Maintenance Information, contact details as above, 1992. Includes addresses of numerous trade and professional organisations as possible data sources. BMI. Review of Maintenance and Occupancy Costs, Building Maintenance Information, contact details as above, 1994 British Standard 7543: 1992 Guide to Durability of Buildings and Building Elements, Products and Components, British Standards Institution, London, 1992 Building Research Energy Conservation Support Unit. Energy Efficiency Best Practice Programme. Building Research Energy Conservation Support Unit, Watford, WD2 7JR. Tel: 01923 664 258. Includes numerous good practice case studies, good practice guides and energy consumption guides for different building types including costings. CIB. CIB W80 report 96: Prediction of Service Life of Building Materials and Components CIBSE. CIBSE Guide, Section B18, Owning and Operating Costs. Chartered Institute of Building Services Engineers, London. Gives indicative details of energy consumption, maintenance costs and rough life spans for plant (currently being updated in more detail).
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix F (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 2, APPENDIX F
HAPM Component Life Manual. E & FN Spon. Tel: 0171 204 2481, 1985. Comprehensive life-span assessment for over 500 housing components based on insured life assessments. ISO Guide to Service Life Planning of Buildings (under preparation at the time of writing but it will include a method of estimating the durability of individual building components). Jones Lang Wootton. Office Service Charges Analysis 1995, Jones Lang Wootton, London, 1995. A review of 300 buildings including unit costs. Kirk, Stephen J., Dell’isola, Alphonse J., Life Cycle Costing For Design Professionals, (2nd Edition), McGraw-Hill Inc, New York, 1995. Includes 45 pages of maintenance and replacement data (in dollars) covering all elements. NBA Construction Consultants. Maintenance Cycles and Life Expectancies of Building Components and Elements: a guide to data and sources. NBA Construction Consultants PSA Cost in Use Tables, 3rd Edition, London HMSO 1991. Includes elemental analysis of cleaning, maintenance and repair costs. RICS. Life Expectancies of Building Components. RICS Research Paper Series No 11, 1992. Preliminary results from a survey of Building Surveyors’ views.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 2, Appendix F (4/99)
Effective from 1/6/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 3
PART TWO: CONSTRUCTION DESIGN & ECONOMICS SECTION 3: ELEMENTS FOR BUILDINGS Introduction The Building Cost Information Service (BCIS) elements were originally produced for use in cost planning, i.e., the development of a design with a preset budget and were published in the BCIS document, Standard Form of Cost Analysis: Principles, Instructions and Definitions. However, since their introduction elements have become widely used for structuring building information in value engineering, specifications, contract drafting and tender evaluation as well as for cost planning/cost analysis. This section discusses some of the uses for elemental information and gives a complete definition for each element. The elements are also referred to in other sections of the handbook.
I
I
2.3.1 Elements 2.3.1.1
An element is a part of a building which fulfils a specific function or functions irrespective of its design, specification or construction, for example, the element ‘external walls’ provides the external vertical envelope to a building, separating the internal and external environment, irrespective of how it may be constructed.
2.3.1.2
Elements relate to the design process. Therefore, budget estimates are normally prepared in elemental form and developing the designs are normally described and costed in this manner.
2.3.2 Elemental Cost Analysis 2.3.2.1
An elemental cost analysis is prepared following the receipt and acceptance of a tender for building work.
2.3.2.2
The tender cost is broken down into the standard BCIS elements (see Appendix A) using the definitions to determine which items should be included in any particular element.
2.3.2.3
The elemental cost analysis can then be used to estimate future projects of a similar type.
2.3.2.4
For further information on the preparation of an elemental cost analysis using the BCIS elements, please refer to the BCIS publication, Standard Form of Cost Analysis: Principles, Instructions and Definitions.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 1
PART 2, S ECTION 3
I
2.3.3 Other Uses The standard elements can be used successfully for other purposes, as detailed in the following subsections. 2.3.3.1
DESIGN AND BUILD In the procurement of design and build projects there has been an increase in the use of elements to structure both employer’s requirements and the contract sum analysis. However, the use of non-standard elements and definitions can be confusing. Standard elements, on the other hand, encourage a structured thought process and produce more coherent employer’s requirements. This helps to avoid some conflicting statements that may arise in contract documents if standard elements are not used. (a) Employer’s Requirements The Joint Contracts Tribunal (JCT) practice note on the Standard Form of Building Contract With Contractor’s Design, CD/1A states that the employer’s requirements may be little more than a description of accommodation required, or may be anything up to full ‘scheme design’ or further, prepared for the employer by his own consultants or other professional advisers: • Any design input from the employer must be embodied in the employer’s requirements as there is no provision for design input from the employer during the course of the contract. • There is no set format for the employer’s requirements, but if anything beyond basic accommodation requirements is being given, particularly where an outline specification is being prepared, setting it out in design elements will be helpful to both the employer and the contractor. • Using the element headings to structure the requirements will act as a checklist for the employer and his representatives in producing any design requirements they may have. It also means that the requirements are presented to the contractor in a form that will assist him in developing his design proposal. • Elements are the most helpful form for structuring specifications to be included in the employer’s requirements. Performance specifications and outline specifications naturally fit into an elemental format. Where a more detailed specification is required it may be more helpful to give performance requirements in elemental form, with the more detailed specification in trade (work sections) form, where necessary.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 3 (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3
(b) Contractor’s Proposals The contractor’s proposals should follow the format of the employer’s requirements. The preparation of the specification for materials and workmanship in elemental form facilitates the development of the specification alongside the design and tendering process. It also highlights any amendments to the employer’s requirements either proposed by the contractor or requested by the client. (c) Contract Sum Analysis Design and build contracts are for a lump sum price, but the standard forms of contract provide for a contract sum analysis for assisting the employer in assessing tenders, for checking interim payments and for valuation of changes in the employer’s requirements. The use of standard elements to format the contract sum analysis makes the foregoing procedures simpler (see Section 2.3.3.1 (e)). (d) Evaluation of Tender Proposals On client-led design projects where tenders are based on a detailed set of employer’s requirements and a highly developed design, the employer should in theory be able to accept the lowest tender. Comparison of the tender with the cost plan element by element helps in assessing the contractor’s compliance with the employer’s design. Where alternative solutions have been put forward for particular elements, the existence of an elemental cost plan and an elemental contract sum analysis prove invaluable in assessing the tender value. Contractor’s proposals on contractor-led design projects should be systematically checked to ensure that they meet the employer’s requirements. The structuring of the requirements, the proposal and the contract sum analysis in consistent elemental form greatly assists in this process. Indeed, it is difficult to imagine any successful detailed technical check of a tender that did not follow a design elemental form. If the contractor’s proposals were not structured in this way, the process would be much more difficult. Contract sum analyses presented in consistent elemental form allow comparison both with the client’s quantity surveyor’s original cost plan and between the competing tenders. This identifies where individual tenders have proposed any elemental solutions with a significantly different cost. (e) Interim Payments The JCT Standard Form of Building Contract With Contractor’s Design 1998 (CD98) provides for the use of one of two methods for interim payments. Alternative A is by stage payments and Alternative B is by periodic payments. If the contract sum analysis has been set out elementally it lends itself to Alternative A, as elements and sub-elements provide easily definable stages.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 3
PART 2, S ECTION 3
With Alternative B - periodic payments - an elemental breakdown of the contract sum analysis makes valuations relatively easy, particularly if different design solutions within a single element are identified separately. For example, a periodic payment for the external walls would be a simple task of proportioning the amount of external wall completed to the total. This overcomes some of the problems that arise in checking interim valuations where the contract sum analysis has been prepared in trade format but no bill of quantities or quantified schedule of rates has been provided. 2.3.3.2
ACTIVITY SCHEDULES The JCT Standard Form of Building Contract 1998 (JCT98) contains an option for the contractor to include an activity schedule for use in interim payments. The activity schedule is defined as ‘the schedule of activities as attached to the Appendix with each activity priced and with the sum of those prices being the contract sum excluding provisional sums, prime cost sums and any contractor’s profit thereon’. If the contractor does include an activity schedule, it must be by agreement with the employer. There is no standard format stipulated for the activity schedule. However, using a BCIS standard list of elements (Appendix A) to provide an activity schedule eliminates any problems with definitions. Furthermore, an elemental breakdown makes valuation for interim payments simple (see Section 2.3.3.1 (e)) and overcomes some of the problems that may arise if activity schedules have been broken down into trades. The use of an activity schedule broken down into BCIS standard elements would also allow an elemental cost analysis to be completed relatively easily and would be particularly useful if projects have been procured without bills of quantities.
Page 4
Part 2, Section 3 (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
Appendix A: BCIS Standard Elements (Please also refer to the notes which follow the definitions) 1
SUBSTRUCTURE All work below underside of screed or where no screed exists to underside of lowest floor finish including damp-proof membrane, together with relevant excavations and foundations.
2
SUPERSTRUCTURE
2A
Frame Loadbearing framework of concrete, steel or timber. Main floor and roof beams, ties and roof trusses of framed buildings. Casing to stanchions and beams for structural or protective purposes.
2B
Upper floors Upper floors, balconies and structural screeds, suspended floors over or in basements.
2C
Roof 2C1 Roof structure Construction, including eaves and verges, plates and ceiling joists, trusses, gable ends, internal walls and chimneys above plate level, parapet walls and balustrades. 2C2 Roof coverings Roof screeds and finishings. Battening, felt, slating, tiling and the like. Flashings and trims. Insulation. Eaves and verge treatment. 2C3 Roof drainage Gutters where not integral with roof structure, rainwater heads and roof outlets. (Rainwater downpipes to be included in ‘Internal drainage’ (5C1).) 2C4 Roof lights Roof lights, opening gear, frame, kerb and glazing. Pavement lights.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 1
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
2D
Stairs 2D1 Stair structure Construction of ramps, stairs and landings other than at floor levels. Ladders. Escape staircases. 2D2 Stair finishes Finishes to treads, risers, landings (other than at floor levels), ramp surfaces, strings and soffits. 2D3 Stair balustrades and handrails Balustrades and handrails to stairs, landings and stairwells.
2E
External walls External enclosing walls including that to basements but excluding items included with ‘Roof structure’ (2C1). Chimneys forming part of external walls up to plate level. Curtain walling, sheeting rails and cladding. Vertical tanking. Insulation. Applied external finishes.
2F
Windows and external doors 2F1 Windows Sashes, frames, linings and trims. Ironmongery and glazing. Shop fronts. Lintels, sills, cavity damp-proof courses and work to reveals of openings. 2F2 External doors Doors, fanlights and sidelights. Frames, linings and trims. Ironmongery and glazing. Lintels, thresholds, cavity damp-proof courses and work to reveals of openings.
2G
Internal walls and partitions Internal walls, partitions and insulation. Chimneys forming part of internal walls up to plate level. Screens, borrowed lights and glazing. Moveable spacedividing partitions. Internal balustrades excluding items included with ‘Stair balustrades and handrails’ (2D3).
2H
Internal doors Doors, fanlights and sidelights. Sliding and folding doors. Hatches. Frames, linings and trims. Ironmongery and glazing. Lintels, thresholds and work to reveals of openings.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
3
INTERNAL FINISHES
3A
Wall finishes Preparatory work and finishes to surfaces of walls internally. Picture, dado and similar rails.
3B
Floor finishes Preparatory work, screeds, skirtings and finishes to floor surfaces excluding items included with ‘Stair finishes’ (2D2) and structural screeds included with ‘Upper floors’ (2B)
3C
Ceiling finishes 3C1 Finishes to ceilings Preparatory work and finishes to surfaces of soffits excluding items included with ‘Stair finishes’ (2D2) but including sides and soffits of beams not forming part of a wall surface. Cornices, coves. 3C2 Suspended ceilings Construction and finishes of suspended ceilings.
4
FITTINGS AND FURNISHINGS
4A
Fittings and furnishings 4A1 Fittings, fixtures and furniture Fixed and loose fittings and furniture including shelving, cupboards, wardrobes, benches, seating, counters and the like. Blinds, blind boxes, curtain tracks and pelmets. Blackboards, pin-up boards, notice boards, signs, lettering, mirrors and the like. Ironmongery, other than to doors and windows. 4A2 Soft furnishings Curtains, loose carpets or similar soft furnishing materials. 4A3 Works of art Works of art if not included in a finishes element or elsewhere. 4A4 Equipment Non-mechanical and non-electrical equipment related to the function or need of the building (e.g. gymnasia equipment).
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 3
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
5
SERVICES
5A
Sanitary appliances Baths, basins, sinks, etc. WC’s, slop sinks, urinals and the like. Toilet-roll holders, towel rails, etc. Traps, waste fittings, overflows and taps as appropriate.
5B
Services equipment Kitchen, laundry, hospital and dental equipment and other specialist mechanical and electrical equipment related to the function of the building.
5C
Disposal installations 5C1 Internal drainage Waste pipes to ‘Sanitary appliances’ (5A) and ‘Services equipment’ (5B). Soil, anti-syphonage and ventilation pipes. Rainwater downpipes. Floor channels and gratings and drains in ground within buildings up to external face of external walls. 5C2 Refuse disposal Refuse ducts, waste disposal (grinding) units, chutes and bins. Local incinerators and flues thereto. Paper shredders and incinerators.
5D
Water installations 5D1 Water – mains supply Incoming water main from external face of external wall at point of entry into building including valves, water meters, rising main to (but excluding) storage tanks and main taps. Insulation. 5D2 Cold water services Storage tanks, pumps, pressure boosters, distribution pipework to sanitary appliances and to services equipment. Valves and taps not included with ‘Sanitary appliances’ (5A) and/or ‘Services equipment’ (5B). Insulation. 5D3 Hot water services Hot water and/or mixed water services. Storage cylinders, pumps, calorifiers, instantaneous water heaters, distribution pipework to sanitary appliances and services equipment. Valves and taps not included with ‘Sanitary appliances’ (5A) and/or ‘Services equipment’ (5B). Insulation. 5D4 Steam and condensate Steam distribution and condensate return pipework to and from services equipment within the building including all valves, fittings, etc. Insulation.
Page 4
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
5E
Heat source Boilers, mounting, firing equipment, pressurising equipment, instrumentation and control, ID and FD fans, gantries, flues and chimneys, fuel conveyors and calorifiers. Cold and treated water supplies and tanks, fuel oil and/or gas supplies, storage tanks, etc., pipework, (water or steam mains) pumps, valves and other equipment. Insulation.
5F
Space heating and air treatment 5F1 Water and/or steam (heating only) Heat emission units (radiators, pipe coils, etc.) valves and fittings, instrumentation and control and distribution pipework from ‘Heat source’ (5E). 5F2 Ducted warm air (heating only) Ductwork, grilles, fans, filters, etc., instrumentation and control. 5F3 Electricity (heating only) Cable heating systems, off-peak heating system, including storage radiators. 5F4 Local heating (heating only) Fireplaces (except flues), radiant heaters, small electrical or gas appliances, etc. 5F5 Other heating systems (heating only) 5F6 Heating with ventilation (air treated locally) Distribution pipework ducting, grilles, heat emission units including heating calorifiers, except those which are part of ‘Heat source’ (5E) instrumentation and control. 5F7 Heating with ventilation (air treated centrally) All works as detailed under 5F6 for system where air treated centrally. 5F8 Heating with cooling (air treated locally) All work as detailed under 5F6 including chilled water systems and/or cold or treated water feeds. The whole of the costs of the cooling plant and distribution pipework to local cooling units shall be shown separately. 5F9 Heating with cooling (air treated centrally) All work detailed under 5F8 for system where air treated centrally.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 5
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
5G
Ventilating systems Mechanical ventilating system not incorporating heating or cooling installations including dust and fume extraction and fresh air injection, unit extract fans, rotating ventilators and instrumentation and controls.
5H
Electrical installations 5H1 Electric source and mains All work from external face of building up to and including local distribution boards including main switchgear, main and sub-main cables, control gear, power factor correction equipment, stand-by equipment, earthing, etc. 5H2 Electric power supplies All wiring, cables, conduits, switches from local distribution boards, etc., to and including outlet points for individual installations. 5H3 Electric lighting All wiring, cables, conduits, switches, etc. from local distribution boards and fittings to and including outlet points. 5H4 Electric lighting fittings Lighting fittings including fixing.
5I
Gas installations Town and natural gas services from meter or from point of entry where there is no individual meter: distribution pipework to appliances and equipment.
5J
Lift and conveyor installations 5J1 Lifts and hoists The complete installation including gantries, trolleys, blocks, hooks and ropes, downshop leads, pendant controls and electrical work from and including isolator. 5J2 Escalators As detailed under 5J1. 5J3 Conveyors As detailed under 5J1.
5K
Protective installations 5K1 Sprinkler installations The complete sprinkler, installation and CO 2 extinguishing system. Including tanks, control mechanism, etc.
Page 6
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
5K2 Fire-fighting installations Hose reels, hand extinguishers, asbestos blankets, water and sand buckets, foam inlets, dry risers (and wet risers where only serving firefighting equipment). 5K3 Lightning protection The complete lightning protection installation from finials conductor tapes, to and including earthing. 5L
Communication installation Warning installations (fire and theft) Burglar and security alarms Fire alarms Visual and audio installations Door signals Timed signals Call signals Clocks Telephones Public address Radio Television Pneumatic message systems
5M
Special installations All other mechanical and/or electrical installations (separately identifiable) which have not been included elsewhere, e.g. chemical gases; medical gases; vacuum cleaning; window cleaning equipment and cradles; compressed air; treated water; refrigerated stores.
5N
Builder’s work in connection with services Builder’s work in connection with mechanical and electrical services.
5O
Builder’s profit and attendance on services Builder’s profit and attendance in connection with mechanical and electrical services.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 7
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
6
EXTERNAL WORKS
6A
Site works 6A1 Site preparations Clearance and demolitions. Preparatory earth works to form new contours. 6A2 Surface treatments Roads and associated footways Vehicle parks Paths and paved areas Playing fields Playgrounds Games courts Retaining walls Land drainage Landscape work 6A3 Site enclosure and division Gates and entrances. Fencing, walling and hedges. 6A4 Fittings and furniture Notice boards, flag poles, seats, signs.
6B
Drainage Surface water drainage. Foul drainage. Sewage treatment.
6C
External services 6C1 Water mains Main from existing supply up to external face of building. 6C2 Fire mains Main from existing supply up to external face of building; fire hydrants. 6C3 Heating mains Main from existing supply or heat source up to external face of building. 6C4 Gas mains Main from existing supply up to external face of building. 6C5 Electric mains Main from existing supply up to external face of building. 6C6 Site lighting Distribution, fittings and equipment.
Page 8
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
6C7 Other mains and services Mains relating to other service installations (each shown separately). 6C8 Builder’s work in connection with external services Builder’s work in connection with external mechanical and electrical services: e.g. pits, trenches, ducts, etc. 6C9 Builder’s profit and attendance on external mechanical and electrical services. 6D
Minor building work 6D1 Ancillary buildings Separate minor buildings such as sub-stations, bicycle stores, horticultural buildings and the like, inclusive of local engineering services. 6D2 Alterations to existing buildings Alterations and minor additions, shoring, repair and maintenance to existing buildings.
7
PRELIMINARIES Priced items in preliminaries bill and summary but excluding contractors’ price adjustments. This is not classed as an element but is included for allocation of costs.
8
EMPLOYERS CONTINGENCIES This is not classed as an element but is included for allocation of costs.
Notes 1
Substructure (a) Where lowest floor construction does not otherwise provide a platform, the flooring surface shall be included with this element (e.g. if joisted floor, floor boarding would be included here). (b) Stanchions and columns (with relevant castings) shall be included with ‘Frame’ (2A). (c) External enclosing walls to basements shall be included with ‘External walls’ (2E).
2A
Frame (a) Structural walls which form an integral part of the loadbearing framework shall be included either with ‘External walls’ (2E) or ‘Internal walls and partitions’ (2G) as appropriate. (b) Beams which form an integral part of a floor or roof which cannot be segregated therefrom shall be included in the appropriate element.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 9
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
(c) In unframed buildings roof beams and trusses and floor beams shall be included with ‘Upper floors’ (2B) or ‘Roof structure’ (2C1) as appropriate. (d) If the ‘Stair structure’ (2D1) has had to be included in this element it should be noted.
Page 10
2B
Upper floors (a) Where floor construction does not otherwise provide a platform the flooring surface shall be included with this element (e.g. if joisted floor, floor boardings would be included here). (b) Beams which form an integral part of a floor slab shall be included with this element. (c) If the ‘Stair structure’ (2D1) has had to be included in this element it should be noted.
2C1
Roof structure (a) Trusses which form part of a whole building framework shall be included in ‘Frame’ (2A). (b) Beams which form an integral part of a roof shall be included with this element. (c) Roof housings (e.g. lift motor and plant rooms) shall be broken down into the appropriate constituent elements.
2D1
Stair structure (a) The cost of external escape staircases shall be shown separately. (b) If the stair structure has had to be included in the elements ‘Frame’ (2A) or ‘Upper floors’ (2B) this should be stated.
2E
External walls (a) If walls are self-finished on internal face, this shall be stated.
3A
Wall finishes (a) Surfaces which are self-finished (e.g. self-finished partitions, fair-faced work) shall be included in the appropriate element. (b) Insulation which is a wall finishing shall be included here.
3B
Floor finishes (a) Where the floor construction does not otherwise provide a platform the flooring surface will be included either in ‘Substructure’ (1A) or ‘Upper floors’ (2B) as appropriate. Access floors.
3C
Ceiling finishes (a) Where ceilings principally provide a source of heat, artificial lighting or ventilation, they shall be included with the appropriate ‘Services’ element.
4A1
Fittings, fixtures and furniture (a) Ironmongery to ‘Windows and external doors’ and ‘Internal doors’ should be included in (2F) and (2H) respectively.
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
4A3
Works of art (a) Where items in this element have a significant effect on other elements a note should be included in the appropriate element.
5B
Services equipment (a) Local incinerators shall be included with ‘Refuse disposal’ (5C2).
5C1
Internal drainage (a) Rainwater gutters are included in ‘Roof drainage’ (2C3).
5D2
Cold water services (a) Header tanks, cold water supplies, etc. for heating systems should be included in ‘Heat source’ (5E).
5D4
Steam and condensate (a) Steam and condensate pipework installed in connection with space heating, or the like, shall be included as appropriate with ‘Heat source’ (5E) or ‘Space heating and air treatment’ (5F).
5E
Heat source (a) Chimneys and flues which are an integral part of the structure shall be included with the appropriate structural element. (b) Local heat source shall be included with ‘Local heating’ (5F4).
5F
Space heating and air treatment System described as having: (a) ‘Air treated locally’ shall be deemed to include all systems where air treatment (heating or cooling) is performed either in or adjacent to the space to be treated. (b) ‘Air treated centrally’ shall be deemed to include all systems where air treatment (heating or cooling) is performed at a central point and ducted to the space being treated.
5F3
Space heating and air treatment - Electricity (heating only) (a) Electrically-operated heat emission units other than storage radiators should be included under ‘Local heating’ (5F4).
5H1
Electric source and mains (a) Installation for electric heating (‘built-in’ systems) shall be included with ‘Space heating and air treatment’ (5F3).
5J1
Lifts and hoists (a) Special structural work, e.g. lift walls, lift motor rooms, etc., shall be included in the appropriate structural elements. (b) Remaining electrical work shall be included with ‘Electrical power supplies’ (5H2). (c) Each type of lift or hoist shall be stated separately where appropriate.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 11
PART 2, S ECTION 3, A PPENDIX A
Page 12
5K1
Sprinkler installations (a) Electrical work shall be included with ‘Electrical power supplies’ (5H2).
5L
Communication installations (a) Each installation shall be stated separately where appropriate. (b) The cost of the work in connection with electrical supply shall be included with ‘Electrical power supplies’ (5H2).
5M
Special installations (a) The cost of each installation shall, where appropriate, be shown separately. (b) Items deemed to be included under ‘Refrigerated stores’ comprises all plant required to provide refrigerated conditions (i.e. cooling towers, compressors, instrumentation and controls, cold room thermal insulation and vapour sealing, cold room doors, etc.) for cold rooms, refrigerated stores and the like other than that required for ‘Space heating and air treatment’ (5F8 and 5F9).
5N
Builder’s work in connection with services (a) Builder’s work in connection with each of the services elements shall, where possible, be shown separately. (b) Where tank rooms, housings and the like are included in the gross floor area, their component parts shall be included under the appropriate elements. Where this is not the case the items shall be included here.
5O
Builder’s profit and attendance on services (a) The profit and attendance in connection with each of the services elements shall, where possible, be shown separately.
6B
Drainage (a) To include all drainage works (other than land drainage included with ‘Surface treatment’ (6A2)) outside the building, to and including disposal point, connection to sewer or to treatment plants.
6C8
Builder’s work in connection with external services (a) Builder’s work shall be stated separately for each installation where appropriate.
6C9
Builder’s profit and attendance on external mechanical and electrical services (a) Profit and attendances shall be stated separately for each installation where appropriate.
Part 2, Section 3 Appendix A (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4
PART TWO: CONSTRUCTION DESIGN & ECONOMICS SECTION 4: DESIGN AND BUILD – GUIDANCE FOR EMPLOYERS’ AGENTS Introduction This section describes some of the tasks and responsibilities that a surveyor may be asked to undertake when appointed as an employer’s agent on a design and build contract. (Note: The organisation or person commissioning a building is referred to in this section as both the client and the employer. Generally, the term ‘client’ is used in relationship to the employer’s agent and ‘employer’ to denote the relationship to the contractor.) At its most basic, the role of the employer’s agent is to act on behalf of the client in the matters specified in the contract. However, in practice there are a wide range of tasks that a client may ask an employer’s agent to undertake. This section is not about procurement options; it assumes that all optional procurement strategies have been carefully considered by clients and their advisors and that the decision has been made to adopt design and build. With regard to procurement strategies, reference should be made to part 3, section 1 of this handbook (‘Developing an Appropriate Building Procurement Strategy’) which provides extensive guidance on selection of the most appropriate option for the procurement of buildings. ‘Design and build’ describes contracts whereby the contractor assumes responsibility both for completing the design for the works and for carrying out the construction in return for a fixed lump sum. There are a number of ‘standard’ forms of design and build contracts, but where specific reference is made in this section, it is to the current edition of the Joint Contracts Tribunal (JCT) Standard Form of Building Contract With Contractor’s Design 1998 (CD 98). This form of contract makes no provision for a contract administrator (CA) and all matters which would have been certified by the CA are ascribed to either the client or the contractor. It should be noted that the prescribed duties of the employer’s agent are restricted to ‘access to documents on site’ and ‘access to works, workshops, etc.’. Importantly however, the contract also allows the client to delegate his or her responsibilities under the contract and in practice this is usually what happens. The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 4
The services of an employer’s agent can be provided by any one of the construction professionals (determined by the nature of the project) but often it is a chartered surveyor. On more complex projects the role of employer’s agent may sometimes be provided by a team comprising the ‘lead’ consultant, with other consultants advising on matters relative to their respective disciplines. In such circumstances, the function of the lead consultant may not be dissimilar to that of a project manager. In appendix A the services which may be requested from an employer’s agent are set out. However, the scope of the role can vary considerably depending upon the particular circumstances of the commission. It would be unusual for any client to require all the services listed in appendix A but they serve to indicate the extent to which this role can be developed.
G
I
2.4.1 Background 2.4.1.1
Design and build is not a new concept. Many historic buildings have been procured in this way and the technique has been used for simple industrial shell buildings. However, in recent years the use of design and build has extended to cover a significant number of building projects of all types.
2.4.1.2
It is thought that design and build has become more popular because clients believed that in some circumstances the traditional route failed to deliver their projects on time and to budget.
2.4.1.3
Proponents of design and build claim that it can deliver coordinated planning, reduced professional fees, improved lead-in times, shorter construction programmes and cost savings, as well as providing greater cost certainty for clients through a single point of contact.
2.4.1.4
Responsibility for the development of the design, as well as the construction of a project, is firmly placed with the contractor. This is perceived to clarify any litigation or dispute between the parties to the contract.
2.4.1.5
Proponents of design and build also claim that it can allow tenderers to bring their skills to the design which, through the competitive process, can deliver benefits to the client in terms of buildability. Furthermore, tenderers can take account of current availability of labour, materials and plant in their design and pricing considerations.
2.4.2 Contract documentation 2.4.2.1
Page 2
The JCT Standard Form of Building Contract With Contractor’s Design was first introduced in response to demand for a form of contract which allowed the contractor to carry out a complete contract (including design development) for a lump sum.
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4
G
2.4.2.2
Throughout its life the JCT Standard Form of Building Contract With Contractor’s Design has been subject to many amendments to account for changes in the law, regulations affecting building development and increasing expectations and involvement of clients.
2.4.2.3
In England and Wales the contract documents under this form are: • the employer’s requirements; • the contractor’s proposals; • the contract sum analysis; and • the articles and conditions set out in the form including optional supplementary provisions and appendices.
2.4.3 Additional services 2.4.3.1
The list in appendix A is intentionally comprehensive and involves some duties which may be beyond a surveyor’s normal skills. Great care should be exercised by the employer’s agent in advising on which duties to incorporate within the commissioning contract. An inability to deliver a service could expose the employer’s agent to claims for negligence from both the client and the contractor.
2.4.3.2
The employer’s agent will normally be involved from the outset and will be instrumental in producing the contract documentation, including the employer’s requirements based on the brief developed with the client. Thereafter, the agent can arrange or assist with the selection of tenderers and arrange the formal tendering process. Subsequently he or she can review the contractor’s proposals (including the developed design and the contract sum analysis) to ensure that all aspects of the employer’s requirements have been met with particular reference to quality, time and cost issues.
2.4.3.3
Where the employer’s agent has been delegated the authority by the client, he or she is responsible for ensuring that the project is carried out in accordance with the conditions of contract, employer’s requirements, contractor’s proposals and contract sum analysis. The role will usually include monitoring the construction process to ensure best practice, controlling expenditure and overseeing contractor compliance with all current regulations. Typically, it will also involve the administration of the project in terms of design and cost by sanctioning all design issues and by instructing any changes. The employer’s agent will be responsible for checking the contractor’s valuations and confirming interim and final payment amounts to the client in accordance with the contract conditions.
2.4.3.4
If a day-to-day inspection is required this should be carried out by a clerk of works, resident engineer or quality control inspector and should be the subject of a separate agreement outside the employer’s agent commission.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 4
G
Page 4
2.4.3.5
The role of employer’s agent is not just one of monitoring the contractor’s performance; good practice requires an active approach to ensure that the contractor undertakes all of his or her responsibilities under the contract. However, the employer’s agent should not hinder or prevent the contractor from fulfilling his or her duties.
2.4.3.6
The employer’s agent should advise the employer on those roles that are within his or her competency, which attract a duty of care similar to that under traditional procurement methods and advise the employer on the appointment of any other consultants required to fulfil any additional roles.
2.4.3.7
It has been held that an employer’s agent was responsible for failure to comment on high risk design elements of the contractor’s proposals and an ongoing failure to approve the contractor’s design development proposals. It would be an unusual project arrangement if these essential tasks were not delegated by the client to the employer’s agent. On the other hand, the duty to approve the contractor’s design development and drawing should be included expressly or by implication in the contract between the client and the employer’s agent.
2.4.3.8
Design and build is fundamentally about the allocation of risk and responsibility. Therefore, it is strongly recommended that the agent’s contractual responsibilities as delegated by the client, together with any additional duties the agent has agreed to undertake on behalf of the client, are clearly defined and recorded, and that the client understands the position.
2.4.4 Employer’s requirements and contractor’s proposals (including contract sum analysis) 2.4.4.1
The contractor’s proposals and the employer’s requirements taken together set out the scope of the works, so it is important that the proposals are examined in detail and that they match the requirements. Any areas of conflict should be resolved since the contract assumes they are compatible when it is signed. If the employer’s requirements and the contractor’s proposals are long and/or complicated, concern about the possibility of a conflict between the two documents may well remain, even after thorough checks have been carried out. In this case it may be worth consdering inserting an additional clause as to how conflicts between the two are to be resolved.
2.4.4.2
The appointed employer’s agent has an obligation to guide the client, provide technical and professional advice and draft the employer’s requirements in order to protect the client and to ensure the project is completed.
2.4.4.3
The employer’s requirements can be by way of performance specification, or on a prescriptive basis where a great deal of design may have been produced initially.
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4
2.4.4.4
The employer’s agent and the employer should agree between them the standard of performance and the requirements of the building. The employer’s agent should offer guidance on the effect that this might have on the contractor’s flexibility in design and construction. Some clients may require a detailed level of specification. However, if the employer’s requirements become unnecessarily prescriptive as to the contractor’s basic construction methods, the contractor may lose sight of the client’s real requirements. The requirements should always be sufficiently detailed to ensure the client obtains the building he or she needs. Therefore, great care should be exercised by the employer’s agent in advising the client on the appropriate level of detail to be provided in the employer’s requirements and that requested in the contractor’s proposal.
2.4.4.5
The employer’s agent should try to encourage the client to concentrate on the purpose, performance and desired end requirements of the project and to avoid involvement in the construction method.
2.4.4.6
It is, however, most important that the client’s input is sufficiently detailed to enable the production of clear and concise ‘employer’s requirements’ to achieve the client’s objectives. The requirements should also be comprehensive enough to avoid amendments during the construction process as these can be very costly.
2.4.4.7
All relevant parts of the client’s brief should be given in the employer’s requirements. Additional requirements arising from meetings during the tender process should be incorporated into the requirements by amendment. There should be no misunderstanding as to what comprises the employer’s requirements. Similarly, any amendments to the contractor’s proposals after they have been submitted should be incorporated. Any ambiguity between these two documents could give rise to conflict at a later date.
2.4.4.8
Contractors are only responsible for that which they design or specify; in turn employers or their consultants are responsible for all that they design and/or specify, unless there has been a pre-agreed limitation to the contract. Thus, in order for the employer to maximise the benefit from design and build, the extent of any designing and specifying by prescription in the employer’s requirements should be limited to those elements in which the employer requires such control.
2.4.4.9
The Building Cost Information Service (BCIS) publication, Elements for Design and Build offers guidance to employer’s agents on the use of building elements for structuring the employer’s requirements and the contractor’s proposals/contract sum analysis. Elements for Design and Build is considered to be important supplementary reading. The list of elements, and their definition, is also given in section 2.3 of this handbook.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 5
PART 2, SECTION 4
Note should also be made of the Code of Procedure for Selective Tendering for Design and Build published by the National Joint Consultative Committee for Building (NJCC) in 1995 and as amended from time to time. Appendix B is a checklist of matters which surveyors are advised to consider when compiling employer’s requirements and checking contractor’s proposals. The list covers the major matters and the elements that relate to buildings in general. It cannot be exhaustive when applied to any particular buildings. Any chartered surveyors acting as employer’s agents are advised to make themselves aware of all matters which are relevant to the client and the client’s business so as to ensure that the employer’s requirements/contractor’s proposal reflects the client’s needs.
I
2.4.5 Design and build variants 2.4.5.1
The forms of design and build contract allow for the production of variation to the conventional design and build contract, for example:
• • • • • • 2.4.5.2
package deal; turnkey; develop and construct; two-stage tender; joint venture/negotiated; and design build fund and operate.
PACKAGE DEAL AND TURNKEY Package deal and turnkey are both expressions used to describe traditional design and build, but with the absolute minimum of client involvement in the design development (or the building operations). A turnkey contract additionally requires that the building is fully fitted out to enable immediate operation by the end user.
2.4.5.3
DEVELOP AND CONSTRUCT Develop and construct is the name given to the ‘variant’ where the client, as part of the employer’s requirements, imposes a design and/or specification developed to a greater degree than most (for example, listing specific manufacturers’ products). The contractor is obliged to adopt this data and should reflect this developed design information in the contractor’s proposals. A fully developed preliminary design may negate many of the advantages associated with conventional design and build. However, the client may be happy to forego these advantages and to impose his or her own particular design or specification in return for other benefits perceived to derive from a design and build procurement strategy.
Page 6
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4
2.4.5.4
TWO-STAGE TENDER Two-stage tender requests seek to obtain proposals from a number of tenderers from which one is selected. That tenderer then works up the preferred submission in greater detail.
2.4.5.5
JOINT VENTURE/NEGOTIATED Joint venture/negotiated projects arise when a client is approached by a contractor or developer with a proposal which broadly aligns with the client’s needs. Many successful projects have been carried out using this route with considerable benefit to the client. Clearly, the earlier the employer’s agent can be introduced the better, since his or her involvement should help limit any abortive design.
2.4.5.6
DESIGN BUILD FUND AND OPERATE Design build fund and operate (DBFO) contracts have been created as a result of the private finance initiative. Although this form of procurement has been listed as a design and build variant it should be remembered that the end user never actually owns the building (unless otherwise provided). CD 98 is not therefore appropriate as part of the primary agreement, although it could feature in a subcontract. In most instances, the client will appoint a shadow design team to ensure that user’s requirements are properly established and communicated to the bidders. The shadow team checks the offers received to ensure that the user’s requirements have been addressed and continues to monitor design and development with the preferred bidder. Thereafter the shadow team ensures that the building incorporates the specified user requirements. Irrespective of the design and build variant employed, the service of the employer’s agent does not alter radically and can still be developed from the items of service listed in appendix A.
I
2.4.6 Novation 2.4.6.1
Novation can be employed on any of the design and build variants and involves the transfer of the client’s contract with his or her designer (or designers) to the successful contractor, this arrangement having been included in the tender documents. The contractor assumes the responsibility for the payment of fees and associated value added tax (VAT), and receives the benefit of continuity of design. Often when novation is implemented, it is not applied to the quantity surveyor who remains with the client acting as the employer’s agent during the design development and construction phase. Novation is not defined in CD 98, although it is widely practised.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 7
PART 2, SECTION 4
2.4.6.2
Page 8
Where designers are novated it is important for clients to understand that their designers’ allegiance transfers from the client to the contractor. This transfer of allegiance should be properly explained to the client prior to a decision to implement novation. It is also important that the employer’s agent advises on selecting appropriate designers and contractors and that the transfer of roles occurs and is maintained.
Part 2, Section 4 (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4, APPENDIX A
Appendix A: Potential services associated with the role of employer’s agent The services to be provided should follow the NJCC’s Code of Procedure for Selective Tendering for Design and Build (1995). Reference should also be made to the BCIS publication Elements for Design and Build which provides guidance on how to structure documents for design and build contracts. The scope of services should be fully agreed between the employer’s agent and the client at the outset of the commission and all interested parties should be informed as to the extent of delegated authority. A1
INITIAL DESIGN INPUT
• Advising on the need for specialist appointments where necessary including appointments under CDM (Regulations) 1994 (also competency and resource check). • Agreeing with the client the scope of the employer’s requirements (including the need for preliminary design, if any) and ensuring that these are ‘signed off’. • Examining land transfer documents to clarify boundary positions including an assessment of the likely impact of existing easements (including rights of light, rights of way, restrictive covenants, etc.). • Initiating measured survey with levels. • Preparing or procuring preliminary design for the development. • Establishing with the client the programme to suit funding availability. • Assessing suitability and cost effectiveness of general and structural design. • Reviewing scheme under Town and Country Planning Acts including consultations with local planning authority leading to initial outline town planning application. (Note: submission of formal full town and country planning application is normally at a later stage (see A2) and sometimes this application is by the contractor.) • On projects involving the refurbishment of existing buildings the provision of design, cost assessment and submission of formal town and country planning applications. • Investigating/establishing location of existing services to site with local and statutory authorities. • Initiating and reviewing subsoil reports. • Consulting as appropriate with relevant agencies, for example, English Nature and English Heritage. • Advising on the implementation of the Construction Act and any other relevant legislation.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix A (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 4, APPENDIX A
A2
PRE-CONTRACT
• Advising on the need for further specialist appointments where necessary. • Preparing cost estimate/structured cost plan. • Advising on need for risk analysis to include market research to underpin financial viability. • Advising on any possible archaeological implications for the site. • Reviewing subsoil reports and commenting on foundation design and contamination considerations. • Assessing environmental impact and advising generally on environmental issues. • Conducting local public investigations as related to town planning, including consultation with building occupiers prior to submitting a full town and country planning application. • Arranging drawings and performance specification for mechanical and electrical services. • Arranging design/cost audit at appropriate work stages if appropriate. • Advising on the need for provision of Party Wall Act or Access to Neighbouring Land Act Agreements. • Developing project brief with client and reflecting same in the employer’s requirements. • Establishing with client the format of the contract sum analysis. • Assisting with completion of formal applications in connection with approvals relating to funding, necessary consents and other requirements. • Advising level of contingencies and preparing appropriate daywork clause. • Advising on tendering options including single- or two-stage tendering, develop and construct or joint venture. • Advising on optional clauses in standard forms of contract, in particular CD 98 supplementary provisions which provide both parties with time and cost certainty. • Advising on dispute resolution. • In consultation with client finalising the employer’s requirements document and arranging for this to be formally ‘signed off’ by the client. • Where applicable, advising (after interview if required) on the selection of suitable tenderers including their capacity, resources, financial and tax exemption status. • Reviewing and reporting on tenders received for the project including comparison with cost plan and comment on programme proposed by each. • Advising on all aspects of future maintenance of the completed development. • Advising on services installation and future maintenance to these services including checking and commenting upon working drawings produced by tenderers. Page 2
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix A (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4, APPENDIX A
• Advising on energy ratings, for example, National Housing Energy Rating and Standard Assessment Procedure. • Ensuring access audit is executed (to meet the requirements of the Disability Discrimination Act). • Auditing contractor’s proposals (including design and detailed drawings) to ensure compliance with employer’s requirements, town and country planning, building regulations and any further criteria imposed upon the project by external organisations. • Preparing cash flow forecasts. • Advising on necessity for and wording of performance bonds and, where applicable, parent company guarantees. • In conjunction with the client’s broker reviewing contractor’s and client’s insurances (including professional indemnity insurance of designers). • Preparing and agreeing a schedule of rates for valuation or negotiation purposes. • Advising both client and tenderer on any agreed amendments to the employer’s requirements following receipt of contractor’s proposals and other relevant inputs. • Providing information to client in connection with post-tender documentation for lender/funder. • Agreeing with contractor cash flow based on stage or periodic payments. • Arranging for all necessary collateral warranties to be prepared and completed by contractor, subcontractors and consultants. • Arranging for the appointment of a clerk of works. • Advising on assignment and subcontracting (including design). • Advising on novation of designers’ contracts, if appropriate. • Preparing contract documentation, agreeing documentation with both parties and arranging execution. • Visiting the site with the contractor and agreeing by schedule and photographic records the existing condition of any buildings to be retained, also, roads, footpaths, trees, shrubs and other similar items liable to be damaged. • Attending site with contractor and assisting in arranging closure of roads and footpaths. A3
CONTRACT DURATION
• Issuing letters of intent where appropriate. • Distributing contract documents in accordance with the contract. • Approving/monitoring/commenting, as appropriate, on contractor’s design development. • Visiting the construction site. (The number of site visits depends on the stage of construction (or as agreed with client) and may be weekly during initial stages until all superstructure is erected and complete.) • Ensuring that there are regular properly conducted site meetings with a chairman operating to a prescribed agenda and formal minutes. The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix A (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 4, APPENDIX A
• • • • •
• • •
•
• • • • • • • • •
•
• • • • • • Page 4
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix A (09/03)
Attending all site meetings. Generally monitoring the works in terms of quality and progress. Assessing compliance with contract conditions by contractor. Assessing compliance of service installations. Regularly reporting to client, in a format agreed with the client, matters of interest, for example, quality, progress against programme, site organisation and labour employed. Also, defects and weather stoppages, etc. Monitoring spend rate against cash flow forecasts including earned value analysis. Ensuring that there is no adjustment to the contract sum other than as provided in the contract. Issuing instructions on behalf of the client to instigate changes to the design quality or quantity of the works or on any other matter as required by the contract. Measuring for and agreeing with contractor any variations resulting from changes to the employer’s requirements during construction as well as the expenditure of any provisional sums. Agreeing valuation of fluctuations in the cost of labour, plant and materials. Addressing requests from contractors for payment for off-site material. Receiving requests, assessing, preparing, granting and issuing any notice of extension of time. Negotiating and agreeing any loss and expense claims submitted in writing by the contractor. Checking contractor’s valuations for stage or periodic payments and notifying the client. Preparing and issuing financial statements as may be required by the client. Ensuring that appropriate VAT is levied in accordance with current legislation. Ensuring compliance with all reserved matters contained within Town and Country Planning Certificate. Ensuring that adoption procedure is put in hand at appropriate stage and following through to achieve adoption prior to handover and to include for drainage installation. Issuing, where applicable, non-completion certificate and advising on the implications of imposition as well as the amount of liquidated and ascertained damages which may be deducted by the client from any payment certified. Ensuring that all required tests are carried out by the contractor and documented proof provided prior to practical completion. Issuing certificate of practical completion. Checking contractor’s final account and issuing final statements. Issuing all other final statements relating to the final accounts that may be required by the client. Preparing snagging lists. Arranging and attending pre-handover inspections. Effective from 1/11/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 4, APPENDIX A
• Ensuring that all snagging items are rectified before inviting client to receive handover. • Ensuring the provision of ‘as built’ information compiled in manual form and supplied to the client at completion of construction process – user’s manual and/or computer disk. • Ensuring that all service installations are completed in accordance with original approved design, attending final commissioning and procuring test certificates. • Arranging and attending handover sessions. A4
POST-CONTRACT
• Receiving health and safety file from planning supervisor and delivering to client. • On partial possession and/or sectional completion, agreeing value thereof. • Ensuring compliance with any insurance requirements. • Advising on values for building insurance purposes. • Reviewing means of escape as built and ensuring procurement of fire certificate by the contractor. • Issuing notices of practical completion on client satisfaction or beneficial occupation, if appropriate. • Obtaining final clearance certificates from local authority in connection with compliance with building regulations. • Preparing post-contract schedules of defects after occupation and arranging for rectification by contractor and on completion notifying client. • Issuing notices on making good defects at end of defects liability period, examining the rectified works and certifying completion of making good defects, where applicable. A5
GENERAL ADDITIONAL SERVICES
• Dealing with essential items of defect that arise during maintenance periods. • Resolving any issues concerning latent defects. • Advising on alternative means of remedying defects. • Advising on insolvency of any party involved with the contract. • Advising on obtaining statutory approvals such as registration for food preparation. • Advising on provision of post-handover service relating to ongoing maintenance. • Preparing capital allowances and revenue schedules. • Advising on special design requirements, for example, Feng Shui, if applicable. • Advising on contingency planning and business recovery for select buildings, for example, terrorist insurance, bomb threats and construction of communication rooms. The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix A (09/03)
Effective from 1/11/03
Page 5
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
Appendix B: Employer’s Requirement/Contractor’s Proposal Checklist B1
CONTRACT DOCUMENTATION The contract documentation will include: • the employer’s requirements • the contractor’s proposal • the contract sum analysis • the article conditions, optional supplementary provisions and appendices set out in the form of contract. The employer’s requirements can be a brief statement of the client’s accommodation requirements, an outline design or a fully worked up design. The contractor’s proposals should be in sufficient detail to allow the client to judge between the tenders on design as well as price. The required level of detail will vary from client to client and contract to contract but it is suggested that information on this checklist would be the minimum requirement. Where little design work has been carried out before tenders and proposals are invited, a performance specification would be normally required. However, where a great deal of design work has taken place a prescriptive specification would be needed.
B2
CHECKLIST (Note that this list is not intended to be exhaustive in total or in any section)
B2.1
General Information • Project title • Employer • Employer’s agent • List of drawings and other information accompanying documents • Location, including a narrative on the proposed use/user of the building. An indication of the employer’s business and overall objectives (to provide a feel for the eventual product) • Access to site • Site boundary defined • Form of contract • Permissible modification to standard form of contract • Details of appendices to the conditions of contract • Form of contract sum analysis
B2.2
Building and Accommodation Outline Outline description of the building Accommodation schedule • schedule of net usable areas (including definition of occupancy) • schedule of occupancy numbers and duration of occupancy • circulation requirements
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 1
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
Basis of design Conceptual design statement and drawings • site layout • plans • elevations • sections • relevant working details • site works and landscaping layouts • sketch perspectives • structural design • services design Design standards • legislation or standards • details of standards which apply (for example codes of practice) • statement of workmanship • tolerances • CDM regulations Aesthetics • specific aesthetic needs (other than planning requirements) Integration of components • relationship with each other • methods of dealing with interfaces • method of dealing with services installations. For example, level of concealment of services and architectural treatments to exposed surfaces B2.3
Form of Detailed Specification (Note: The detailed employer’s requirements can be drafted in performance specification terms, or in prescriptive terms (contractor delivery) by including detailed specification and drawings, or a combination of performance and prescriptive specification.) The scope of work (see Section B2.4) assumes an employer’s requirement drafted in performance specification terms and the contractor’s proposals should convert these performance specifications into clearly defined design proposals. The specifications and design checklist (see Section B2.5) can be used in preparing employer’s requirements or a specification for a contractor’s proposal. A performance specification should be checked to ascertain that it is feasible to design a structure with the requirements given and that there is no conflict between performance and other prescriptive requirements given.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
B2.4
Scope of Work (Performance Requirements) Performance specification may relate to the whole building or include elements or both. The following are some matter which may be addressed. Image/description of key areas • drawings • sketches • statements Flexibility • flexibility of accommodation • flexibility of design Energy • energy conservation and heat measures • insulation values • Building research establishment environmental assessment method (BREEAM) certification rating • plant room layouts Loading requirements Details of dead and imposed loadings Facilities for disabled • provision statement to comply with building regulations and current disability legislation • specific needs of disabled Building configuration • written statement and/or drawing • relationship of accommodation • size of accommodation • purpose • layout • dimensional constraints including clear heights under slabs and beams • natural lighting - lux levels and method of measurement • natural ventilation • column grid arrangement including projections from walls, etc. • clear ceilings/soffit heights • tolerances • vehicle access door heights and widths • toilet/bathroom/locker room requirements • kitchen/catering requirements • restaurant/vending requirements • plant room configuration • noise breakout between rooms
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 3
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
• storage space, cleaners, cupboards, maintenance facilities • access for cleaning and maintenance • security Means of escape Plantrooms External works • car parking • leisure facilities • environmental considerations • visual effects • waste disposal • emergency vehicle access • water features • loading bays • existing site features and treatments • function buildings within externals • site survey B2.5
Specifications and Design Specification of performance, or the form of construction, kind and quality may be given in elemental or other format. The standard elements are listed below. (Please see Section 2.3 of this handbook or the BCIS publication, Standard Form of Cost Analysis for definition of elements.) 1 Substructure 2 Superstructure 2A Frame 2B Upper floors 2C Roof 2C1 Roof structure 2C2 Roof coverings 2C3 Roof drainage 2C4 Roof lights 2D Stairs 2D1 Stair structure 2D2 Stair finishes 2D3 Stair balustrades and handrails 2E External walls 2F Windows and external doors 2F1 Windows 2F2 External Doors 2G Internal walls and partitions 2G1 WC cubicles 2H Internal doors 3 Internal finishes
Page 4
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
3A Wall finishes 3B Floor finishes 3C Ceiling finishes 3C1 Finishes to ceilings 3C2 Suspended ceilings 4 Fittings and furnishings 4A Fittings and furnishings 4A1 Fittings, fixtures and furniture 4A2 Soft furnishings 4A3 Works of art 4A4 Equipment 5 Services 5A Sanitary appliances 5B Services equipment 5C Disposal installations 5C1 Internal drainage 5C2 Refuse disposal 5D Water installations 5D1 Water mains supply 5D2 Cold water service 5D3 Hot water service 5D4 Steam and condensate 5E Heat source 5F Space heating and air treatment 5F1 Water and/or steam (heating only) 5F2 Ducted warm air (heating only) 5F3 Electricity (heating only) 5F4 Local heating (heating only) 5F5 Other heating systems (heating only) 5F6 Heating with ventilation (air heated locally) 5F7 Heating with ventilation (air heated centrally) 5F8 Heating with cooling (air heated locally) 5F9 Heating with cooling (air heated centrally) 5G Ventilating systems 5H Electrical installations 5H1 Electric source and mains 5H2 Electric power supplies 5H3 Electric lighting 5H4 Electric lighting fittings 5I Gas installation 5J Lift and conveyor installations 5J1 Lifts and hoists 5J2 Escalators 5J3 Conveyors 5K Protective installations 5K1 Sprinkler installation 5K2 Fire-fighting installations
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 5
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
5K3 Lightning protection 5L Communication installations 5M Special installations Details of each installation 5N Builder’s work in connection with services 5O Builder’s profit and attendance on services 6 External works 6A Site works 6A1 Site preparation 6A2 Surface treatment 6A3 Site enclosure and division 6A4 Fittings and furniture 6B Drainage 6C External Services 6C1 Water mains 6C2 Fire mains 6C3 Heating mains 6C4 Gas mains 6C5 Electric mains 6C6 Site lighting 6C7 Other mains and services 6C8 Builder’s work in conjunction with external services 6C9 Builder’s profit and attendance on external mechanical and electrical services 6D Minor building work 6D1 Ancillary buildings 6D2 Alterations to existing buildings B2.6
Particular Requirements Additional Responsibilities The employer’s requirements should state who is responsible for all matters that affect the construction of the building including such matters as: Site investigations • soil survey • ground conditions • topographical surveys • existing services • hazardous waste • archaeological features Development controls or other controls • planning permission (including reserved matters) • building regulations • Water Authority • Licensing Authority (liqour) • Licensing Authority (entertainments) • fire officer requirements
Page 6
Part 2, Section 4 Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 4, A PPENDIX B
• • • • • • •
factory inspector environmental health officer employer’s building insurers (if appropriate) Traffic Planning Authority utilities National Rivers Authority Any other authority or statutory undertaker which has jurisdiction with regard to the works
Establish responsibility for fees payable in connection with above Other legislation or provisions Adjoining premises • rights of access to adjoining premises Trespass, nuisance • contractor to acquire rights as required and absolve the employer of responsibility Use and maintenance of existing: • roads • sewers • services If the responsibility for any of these matters is to be with the contractor the client should include disclaimers in any information which is provided to the contractor. Information requirements The employer’s requirements should give details of all records, drawings, etc., required to be handed over on completion including: • record drawings • maintenance manuals • CAD data disks • design calculations • staff training requirements • warranties and guarantees Exclusions Give details of items not to be designed and/or constructed by the contractor and the requirements and responsibilities for integrating these into the works Future developments Provide details of any provisions required for future developments
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 4 (10/99) Appendix B (10/99)
Effective from 1/11/99
Page 7
PART 2, SECTION 5
PART TWO: CONSTRUCTION DESIGN AND ECONOMICS SECTION 5: THE CHARTERED SURVEYOR AS LEAD CONSULTANT Introduction Over recent years many property and construction professionals have diversified into areas outside their core discipline. Some have become barristers; many have become planning supervisors; but the most common and obvious diversification has been to take on the role of lead consultant or project manager. In the past, this role has largely been the domain of the architect. However, in recent years many clients have increasingly used the services of the chartered surveyor to carry out these duties. For those embarking on this route care must be taken to ensure that the additional duties required by the role of lead consultant are fully understood and considered when undertaking the project, together with the associated professional liabilities. This section highlights some of the issues which the chartered surveyor should consider before undertaking this role. It also identifies some of the benefits for both clients and projects when appointing a chartered surveyor as lead consultant. A schedule of the additional duties that are likely to be required in excess of the main professional duties defined in appointment documents (such as those for building and quantity surveying) is included at the end of the section.
I
2.5.1 Definitions: The Difference between a Project Manager and Lead Consultant 2.5.1.1
The role of project manager is to directly manage and coordinate all other consultants involved with a project on behalf of the client. Ultimately the delivery of the project is the direct responsibility of the project manager. On some projects consultants are appointed by the project manager as subconsultants, or are managed and paid by the project manager (although the client directly appoints them). This arrangement is most beneficial to clients who, through desire or inexperience, do not wish to have a pro-active involvement with the project.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
Page 1
PART 2, S ECTION 5
Figure 1: Project Structure using a Project Manager
Client
Managing & coordination
Project Manager
Arch.
2.5.1.2
Eng.
QS
Plann. Sup.
etc..
The position of lead consultant is more of a coordinating role, ensuring that other parties in the design, procurement and construction process of a project provide the right input at the right time, and to take an overall view to ensure coordination of all aspects of the project. However, the management of the other consultants is ultimately down to the client and, therefore, is better suited to more informed clients who may have their own in-house project managers undertaking an overall management role. Figure 2: Project Structure using a Lead Consultant
Client
Client’s Representative
Advising & coordination
Lead Consultant
Arch.
I
QS
Plann. Sup.
etc..
2.5.2 Benefits of Appointing a Chartered Surveyor as Lead Consultant 2.5.2.1
Page 2
Eng.
In many circumstances a chartered surveyor can provide a greater breadth of knowledge and understanding of the complete process of a construction project. By utilising this awareness, the chartered surveyor can provide added value to the management of a construction project. Chartered building surveyors are not only involved in design, but also in the peripheral activities such as wayleaves, right to light, party wall and boundary disputes. Chartered quantity surveyors have an inherent knowledge of the complete design package through their cost control role, and often clients will appreciate this financial control being extended to a project liaison function.
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 5
I
I
2.5.2.2
As well as simply the design of the buildings, many other skills are required to provide a functional space for a client and the chartered surveyor is often more conversant with these additional activities.
2.5.2.3
The chartered surveyor is frequently called upon in matters associated with land purchase, valuation, condition survey, development potential and building cost. This front-end advice provides the opportunity to advise clients and add value before the appointment of the architect, or in parallel with the concept designs. This early involvement opens the door of opportunity for the chartered surveyor to take up the reins as lead consultant.
2.5.2.4
Other benefits to a client can be derived where the ‘project’ requires a distinct specialism and the design process is only part of a more specialised activity, for example farms management.
2.5.3 Issues to Consider before Undertaking the Role 2.5.3.1
Before taking on the role of lead consultant, careful consideration must be taken to ensure that there is sufficient competency to undertake the additional duties involved in the role. This level of competency will impact directly on professional liability insurance policies and ‘competency’ under the Construction (Design and Management) (CDM) Regulations.
2.5.3.2
Fees for these additional activities must be at the discretion of the provider. They should take into account the level of additional time and resources required in excess of the core professional services provided. It may be that some of the lead consultant duties overlap with existing duties and that economies may be obtained. However, the converse may equally apply and it is essential that the chartered surveyor thoroughly reviews the actual additional duties required before providing fee quotations.
2.5.3.3
With the constant changes in the way that buildings are procured and designed, the chartered surveyor is in a prime position for providing real added value to the process. For those individuals or practices who do not wish to undertake the more encompassing role of project manager, but feel that they can make a positive contribution by directing a particular project, then the role of lead consultant fits the bill. However, care must be taken to ensure that the necessary additional skills exist to be certain that the increased responsibility can be taken on comfortably and to the ultimate benefit to the client.
2.5.4 Schedule of Lead Consultant Duties 2.5.4.1
The schedule of duties of a lead consultant is not exhaustive. The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors provides a range of publications which describe in more detail individual professional services such as quantity and
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
Page 3
PART 2, S ECTION 5
building surveying and it is recommended that, wherever possible, the surveyor refers to these when confirming the scope of service to be provided as lead consultant. 2.5.4.2
PURPOSE During a construction project many issues can arise on which the client may require professional advice from his or her consultants. The lead consultant’s role is to provide the client with comprehensive professional support to ensure that the client’s requirements are met with regard to legislation, standards, cost and programme. The client nominates a lead consultant for each capital project undertaken. The lead consultant, who may or may not be an active design member of the project team, will liaise with the client representative and will be responsible for the following activities.
2.5.4.3
2.5.4.4
GENERALLY (a)
Establish the client’s brief and ensure that it is agreed with the client and communicated to all designers.
(b)
Monitor the service provided by all consultants to ensure that they are carrying out their duties to the standard required at each work stage. Submit all reports, plans and proposals to the client with the request for approval to proceed to the next work stage.
(c)
Deal with all queries and solve problems as they arise. Seek advice from the client where necessary, but be aware that professional responsibility for the proper management of all aspects of the project lies solely with the lead consultant and project team members.
(d)
Ensure that all drawn and specification material is forwarded to all other consultants in accordance with the previously agreed project team programme. Review, coordinate and confirm design drawings of all project team members.
(e)
Regularly review the design with the client and designers and formally minute any agreed amendments. Inform the client of the impact of these amendments on time, cost and design.
STAGES A AND B: INCEPTION, FEASABILITY AND BRIEFING AB/1 Establish the scope of the project and ensure that all other members of the project team have the same understanding. AB/2 Advise on the need for site investigations. AB/3 Investigate planning constraints.
Page 4
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 5
AB/4 Direct the activities of any supporting consultants such that the option appraisal/feasibility study is fully investigated. Collate and prepare a report for submission to the client. Attend presentation meetings as required. AB/5 Assist the client with the preparation of detailed briefing documents with special input on technical, legal, statutory, financial and programming requirements. AB/6 Advise on procurement methods. AB/7 Advise the client with regard to the general application of the CDM Regulations and comply with Regulation 13(1). AB/8 Agree fee with the client. AB/9 Obtain further instructions from the client. 2.5.4.5
2.5.4.6
STAGE C: OUTLINE PROPOSALS C1
Arrange dates and venues. Chair and minute all regular design team meetings (at least monthly up to tender stage).
C2
Arrange to circulate a list of specific duties of each consultant to establish roles and responsibilities. Discuss and agree a detailed design and general construction programme with all members of the design team.
C3
Arrange dates and venues with the architect and client representative for brief development and presentation meetings.
C4
Arrange for surveys, investigations and consultations with statutory bodies.
C5
Ensure compliance with Regulation 13(2) of the CDM Regulations and liaise with the planning supervisor.
C6
Compile and submit Stage C report to the client.
C7
Request approval to proceed to Stage D.
STAGE D: SCHEME DESIGN D1
Arrange for any site investigations and consultations which are still necessary.
D2
Review progress, brief and the client’s decisions. With the project team’s assistance prepare and agree a detailed design programme of work and flow of information.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
Page 5
PART 2, S ECTION 5
2.5.4.7
2.5.4.8
Page 6
D3
Prepare the initial health and safety plan (if acting as the planning supervisor).
D4
Ensure compliance with Regulation 13(2) of the CDM Regulations and liaise with the planning supervisor.
D5
Clarify items of fixed furniture and equipment required by the client.
D6
Compile the Stage D report from work undertaken and coordinated by all project team members.
D7
With the architect, undertake a formal presentation (or presentations) to the client.
D8
Request approval to proceed to Stage E.
STAGE E: DETAILED DESIGN E1
Review the outcome of planning submission.
E2
Consider the need for pre-ordering of materials or equipment.
E3
Compile and submit the Stage E report to the client which, in addition to the usual reports and cost plans, should comprise: • furniture and layout drawings; • sample boards and recommendations for selection of materials and finishes; • reports from advising authorities; • phasing and site management drawing showing the effects of disruption on the operation of the establishment; and • schedule of areas showing the direct relation to the areas in the brief.
E4
Ensure compliance with Regulation 13(2) of the CDM Regulations and liaise with the planning supervisor.
E5
Advise on the form of contract.
E6
Request approval to proceed to Stage F.
STAGE F: PRODUCTION OF INFORMATION F1
Ensure appropriate applications for approval under other applicable statutory requirements (including negotiating waivers or relaxations).
F2
Ensure appropriate applications for approval under the building regulations or other applicable statutory requirements (including negotiating waivers or relaxations).
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 5
2.5.4.9
F3
Discuss any aspects of the design, construction methods or site management that could be of concern under health and safety legislation. Update the health and safety plan.
F4
Ensure that a list of tenderers from approved register of contractors is obtained. Contact each contractor giving outline details of the scheme and request that they confirm their interest in submitting a bona fide tender.
F5
Confirm all requirements from the planning authority, fire officer, crime prevention officer and highway authority will be incorporated in the contract documents.
F6
Report to the client at monthly intervals on progress and cost plan checks.
STAGE G: BILLS OF QUANTITIES G1
Discuss with the client and project team suitable amendments to standard contract preliminary clauses, the completion of the appendix to the contract, performance bonds, changes to standard contract conditions, methods of appointing subcontractors and suppliers and insurance liabilities.
G2
Ensure that planning and building regulation approval has been achieved.
G3
Obtain pre-tender estimate from quantity surveyors. Inform the client of readiness.
G4
On instructions to proceed to tender, instruct the quantity surveyor (if appointed) to issue tender documents. Follow all the client’s standard procedures for this activity.
2.5.4.10 STAGE H: TENDER ACTION H1
Ensure that all arrangements for temporary works and client site preparation have been undertaken. Liaise with the property manager/client for all temporary site management and services issues.
H2
Be available to assist tenderers in the clarification or correction of data within the tender documents.
H3
Carry out tender appraisal in conjunction with other consultants and submit a formal tender report to the client recommending (or otherwise) the acceptance of a single tender.
H4
If necessary, undertake redesign, and/or negotiation with tenderer(s) and client, on reductions in tendered contract sum to meet the client’s budget.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
Page 7
PART 2, S ECTION 5
2.5.4.11 STAGE J: PROJECT PLANNING J1
Prepare the building contract and arrange for it to be forwarded to the client or his or her solicitor, and signed by the contractor.
J2
Notify the client’s insurers.
J3
Arrange a pre-contract meeting with the contractor, subcontractors, consultants, clerk of works, client and head of establishment. Advise on arrangements for access to the site and deal with queries and concerns on works.
J4
Ensure that all temporary and enabling works are complete.
2.5.4.12 STAGE K: OPERATIONS ON SITE
Page 8
K1
Ensure that the contract is administered in accordance with its terms. Ensure that cost control of the project is maintained.
K2
Visit the site as appropriate to inspect the progress and quality of work.
K3
Liaise and coordinate the work of all design consultants during the postcontract period ensuring solutions are found to issues that may arise and that the schedules for issue of later design information are met.
K4
Hold regular meetings on site with the head of establishment, client and clerk of works to appraise them of progress and to establish and resolve any concerns that may be arising.
K5
Attend regular site meetings with the contractor, other consultants and clerk of works.
K6
Give a short general report at appropriate intervals during the course of the contract on progress, site relationships, quality of workmanship and any other pertinent matter. Monitor contractor’s health and safety plan and records.
K7
Ensure that certificates are issued for interim payments on the RIBA standard form to the client. Produce short financial reports on a cumulative basis (cash flow predictions are required to be attached to each valuation certificate). Produce a detailed financial report showing the value of all actual and expected variations to be issued at three monthly intervals throughout the construction process.
K8
Ensure that all the client’s handover procedures have been followed before accepting the building from the contractor.
K9
Notify the client’s insurers that work is complete and arrange for release of bonds.
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, S ECTION 5
2.5.4.13 STAGE L: COMPLETION L1
Check making good of all outstanding patent defects. Resolve any issues relating to emergency latent defects over the defects period. On completion of all making good, agreed with the head of establishment in writing, issue certificate of making good defects.
L2
Ensure that the terms of the contract, in relation to completion of the works, are administered.
L3
Continue to produce a financial report at three monthly intervals.
L4
Ensure that the quantity surveyor completes the final account to an auditable standard. Send to the client with the request for approval to issue final certificate.
L5
Ensure that the issue of final certificate is made and that all consultants complete construction certificate.
L6
Complete quality assurance questionnaire on performance of the client, contractor and other consultants.
L7
Resolve any issues relating to emergency latent defects after the patent defects period.
L8
Resolve contractual claims and provide any necessary reports to the client.
L9
Ensure that the health and safety file is completed and handed to the client.
L10 Ensure that all fire safety certificates, building control certificates, licenses, etc. are obtained and handed to the client. L11 Review the project from start to finish and report findings to the client, complete with observations on successes and failures. Ensure that all parties involved are sent a copy of the report.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 5 (05/00)
Effective from 1/7/00
Page 9
PART 2, SECTION 6
PART TWO: CONSTRUCTION DESIGN & ECONOMICS SECTION 6: DEFINING SUSTAINABLE CONSTRUCTION Introduction The term ‘sustainable’ was first used in the construction industry when it was applied to sources of timber. At that time timber was declared to come from ‘sustainable sources’. Today, timber from ‘sustainable sources’ has been replaced with the expression ‘well managed’ or even ‘managed’ sources implying that there is a difference between being sustainable and being well managed. But what is this difference? The definition of sustainability that seems to have achieved almost universal acceptance is that put forward by the World Commission on Environment and Development in 1987, often referred to as the Brundtland definition: ‘Humanity has the ability to make development sustainable – to ensure that it meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.’ This definition appears quite clear in its meaning: we are charged with the responsibility of ensuring that our activities do not damage the legacy which we are passing on to our successors. Development can be taken in any context, from the economic development of a nation to the construction of a simple building. It confers upon us the responsibility to consider the impact of our activity now and the legacy that we are leaving behind us. This can be regarded as the principal of ‘common inheritance’ or, alternatively, ‘intergenerational equity’. The time frame element is therefore the difference between something which is well managed and something which is sustainable. A source of supply for timber may be well managed, but may only be so for 20, 30, 40 or 50 years. Something which is sustainable has, theoretically, an infinite timescale and therefore has inter-generational equity (where the term equity can mean a resource stock, capital stock or a stock of technologies). In the construction industry a resource stock can either be land, the availability of raw materials or the buildings from which the raw materials have been constructed. Unless purely organic materials, which are capable of self-regeneration, are used, then in-organic materials are used such as stone, clay and minerals which are deposits available in finite quantities and cannot be regenerated.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 (10/00)
Effective from 1/12/00
Page 1
PART 2, S ECTION 6
The mineral resources that are used are therefore not sustainable in themselves, and in order to demonstrate a sustainable, or at least a ‘more’ sustainable construction industry it is the industry’s responsibility, under the definition, to ensure that the buildings being constructed from the finite raw material resources are capable of inter-generation usage. To summarize, the construction industry cannot be considered to be sustainable in terms of resource usage because raw materials, which are only available in finite quantities, are being extracted and processed into building products for incorporation into a building where the building itself is only designed for a finite life. For the industry to be seen to act in a sustainable manner it needs to provide a building stock that demonstrates appropriate investment of these raw materials such that the swap is an equitable one. To ensure that this takes place, the industry has a responsibility to consider the design, detailing and construction methods as well as the cost in use to show that a valuable legacy has been left to future generations.
I
2.6.1 Technology Swaps Sustainability can be demonstrated, and the consumption of finite raw materials justified, if a technology is produced that is a substitute for the original raw material resource once this is exhausted. The best demonstration of this, and probably the first major challenge that will face humankind, is the exhaustion of fossil fuels. Today, development, economic and political stability depend entirely upon the availability of oil as a fuel and a raw materials source. Although estimates of available economic oil reserves continually extend, and we are likely to enjoy the benefits of it for at least another 100 years or so, it is universally agreed that human activity will have to change and the reliance upon oil will have to decline as the availability diminishes and it becomes more costly to extract. The development of an alternative renewable, sustainable, pollution-free energy source is therefore vital to the sustainability of human development. Oil provides a very good example of non-sustainability in practice. However, if the revenues generated from the use of oil were diverted to the research and development of alternative, sustainable energy sources, this would be an example of sustainability in practice in the form of a technology swap. In this instance, the result of using one resource has been the production of an alternative technology which is a direct substitute for the resource that has been exhausted. The definition of sustainability has therefore been satisfied in that the activities of one generation in achieving their goals has not prevented future generations from achieving their goals. The inter-generational equity principal is therefore a mechanism by which the total available resource to future generations is maintained at a constant level.
Page 2
Part 2, Section 6 (10/00)
Effective from 1/12/00
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 6
This resource, which is available for their use, can either be in the form of raw materials, capital wealth or alternative technologies. The important factor is that the overall equity stock must not be diminished.
I
2.6.2 How Can the Environment and Sustainability be Valued? At present the only method that has been developed for assessing the impact of human activities has been to put a financial value on everything. In the fullness of time it is to be hoped that we will devise different methods of quantifying value. An example of a technology advance resulting in huge potential environmental damage is the CFC gases that have been identified as being largely responsible for the depletion of the ozone layer. But how do we value the environmental damage and possibly attempt to justify it in terms that are economically acceptable? It has been suggested that the only way that ozone layer depletion could be argued and justified as economically acceptable is if there was a way of reinstating it at an acceptable cost. In other words, a technology advance has been made for economic gain but at an environmental cost. This environmental cost cannot be quantified in economic terms because no cost yardstick has been devised for attributing economic value to our environmental stock. This could, however, be quantified if there was a technology to replace the ozone layer which would itself carry the missing cost element within the equation. This leads to the conclusion that acts which damage the environment do carry a penalty for future generations and therefore to ignore them is a risk. This risk may not necessarily be a risk for the present generation, but one that is being imposed on future generations. Under a philosophy of sustainability it is the responsibility of the present generation to hand on to the next generation the same total stock as it itself inherited so as to ensure the same overall balance of advantages for future development as originally inherited. Providing that each generation adheres to these principals, the element of timescale judgement is removed as each successive generation looks after the next. Under these criteria, knowledge and technical advances will still be made and future generations will still be at least as well off as the present generations; but the likely loser will be the industrialized economy which will have to alter the way in which the indicators of economic development are measured. At present, industrialized nations generally consider economic development to mean an increase in Gross National Product (GNP) per capita. However, GNP assumes all matters relating to the environment have zero value. If economic values are attributed to environmental functions in relation to economic development, the national economic balance sheets would take on a considerably different complexion.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 3
PART 2, SECTION 6
I
2.6.3 How Does This Affect the Construction Industry? 2.6.3.1
MATERIALS Most construction materials are a finite resource and will eventually be exhausted. Many already are. Local British sources of Portland stone, which has been used as a cladding material for many years, have been exhausted or the quarries closed and it now has to be obtained from the Continent. Certain colours of terrazzo marble, once popular in the 1960s, are no longer available as entire mountains in Italy have been levelled. The use of terrazzo has now been superseded by the increased use in solid marble and granite although it will only be a matter of time before these sources are similarly exhausted. Even organic materials are not immune. Brazilian Rio Rosewood, which was very popular for making high-quality furniture in the 1960s, is now so endangered that it appears on the Control in Trade of Endangered Species (CITES) list as being illegal for fear of extinction. Mahogany is also on the fringes of being listed and it is widely reported that there are no longer any legal sources for the supply of the true Swietenia mahogany. An example closer to home is the UK’s reliance upon imported timber having used up its own supply. The history of timber production in the UK is an interesting one which has seen the rapid depletion of forests from approximately 90 per cent forest coverage at the time the Romans arrived to a low point of less than 5 per cent of land coverage at the early part of this century. Timber was first imported after the Great Fire of London and in 1668 it became necessary for Acts of Parliament to be passed to create forest reserves like the New Forest in Hampshire to try to arrest the situation. World War I saw timber in short supply again and resulted in the birth of the Forestry Commission as a Government Agency in 1919. World War II resulted in timber shortages again and the emergency created the major post-war plantation of quick-growing conifers. Humankind has a history of failing to adequately consider the impact that its activities are having on the resource base and examples are easy to find.
2.6.3.2
BENCH MARKING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS In order to be able to assess the effect that we are having upon the environment as a result of our activities a scientifically rigorous and consistent method of analysis and bench marking is required. Such a method would have to attribute units of measurement to each environmental impact and in turn to relate these back to a datum to render the results meaningful on a human scale. The Building Research Establishment (BRE) has undertaken more work than most in this area. It has developed Envest, an environmental estimating software tool which attributes Ecopoints to environmental impacts, with 100 Ecopoints being equivalent to the environmental impact of the average UK citizen. Using a variety of comparison models and mathematical techniques Ecopoint values have been attributed to building materials and systems, and it
Page 4
Part 2, Section 6 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 6
is now possible, via the software package, to calculate the total Ecopoints score for building types, building operations, refurbishment and custom use. From this data one form of construction can be analysed against another. It is also possible to quantify the decision-making process using environmental criteria, not only by building type and the method of construction that should be used but also the decision whether to build new or to refurbish. Environmental Impacts In undertaking the assessment of environmental impacts and attributing Ecopoints values to various activities and products, the following must be considered carefully: • climate change; • fossil fuel depletion; • ozone depletion; • human toxicity to air and water; • waste disposal; • water extraction; • acid deposition; • eutrophication (or over enrichment of water courses); • ecotoxicity; • low-level ozone creation (summer smog); and • mineral extraction. All these factors have been considered, quantified, compared and weighted in relation to the impact associated with a typical UK citizen and are shown in table 1. Table 1: Environmental Impact of UK Citizens Issue
% weighting
Characterized impact associated with a typical UK citizen
Climate change
37.8
12300 kg CO2 eq. (100yr)
Fossil fuel depletion
12.0
4.09 tonnes oil eq.
Ozone depletion
8.2
0.286 kg CFC11 eq.
Human toxicity to air
7.0
90.7 kg toxicity
Waste disposal
6.1
7.19 tonnes
Water extraction
5.4
418000 litres
Acid deposition
5.1
58.9 kg SO2 eq.
Eutrophication
4.3
8.01 kg PO4 eq
Ecotoxicity
4.3
178000 m3 toxicity
Photochemical ozone creation
3.8
32.2 kg ethene eq.
Mineral extraction
3.5
5.04 tonnes
Human toxicity to water
2.6
0.0275 kg toxicity
% may not add up to 100% due to rounding
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 5
PART 2, SECTION 6
So for example, to calculate the Ecopoints for 1 tonne of mineral extraction: Characterized impact = 1 tonne mineral extraction Characterized impact for 1 typical UK citizen = 5.04 tonnes mineral extraction Normalized impact = 1 divided by 5.04 = 0.198 Weighting = 3.5% Ecopoints = 0.198 multipled by 3.5 = 0.693 Ecopoints 2.6.3.3
EMBODIED ENERGY As materials can be extracted in any part of the world and either processed into building components locally or transported as raw materials, it is virtually impossible to examine all of the possible environmental impacts that the various activities are likely to have because the variables are just so great. Perhaps the only constant method there may be in the winning and working of materials, their transportation and processing into building components up to the point when they are assembled into completed buildings is the energy requirements of the various processes. The actual monetary value of energy can also be different from country to country, therefore it is not possible to use monetary value of energy as a unit of measure. However, the unit of energy input itself can be used. As energy is required to be consumed at every stage of the production process, from extraction of the raw material to its incorporation into a construction, and eventually to demolition and possible reprocessing, the sum total of these energy inputs can be termed as the embodied energy of that product. It should therefore be scientifically possible to establish a method of calculating the quantity of embodied energy that is required to make a building component, be it a cubic metre of concrete, a single brick, a square metre of glass or a sheet of plasterboard. Appendix A shows a comparison of embodied energy values for some common materials. From this it can be appreciated just how energy intensive some processes are and therefore how relatively good and bad some components are. If materials have to be imported or are chosen to be imported on the grounds of economic cost these will, by definition, carry a larger embodied energy by virtue of the cost of global transportation. Conversely, economies may be derived by local energy consumption and waste disposal which can also be incorporated into the equation. Embodied energy impacts associated with materials have also been assessed quantitively by the BRE using Envest (see 2.6.3.2) which can also take account of the building form and fabric typical replacement intervals and other data held by the Centre for Sustainable Construction. The results generated are quoted in Ecopoints per m² of element and factors such as replacement intervals can also be factored in as part of a full cost and use study. A fundamental difference in environmental terms between refurbishment and redevelopment is the saving of embodied environmental impact and energy if refurbishment is undertaken in preference to demolition and redevelopment.
Page 6
Part 2, Section 6 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 6
2.6.3.4
LEGISLATIVE CHANGES Armed with bench-marking data it would be possible for systems of regulation to be built into the existing regulations. With the increasing emphasis on energy conservation within the building regulations (which currently concentrate on energy consumed in use) it would be a simple extension of these regulations to lay down embodied energy maxima per square metre for various building types. A major criticism that could be levelled at such a system is that it would starve the construction industry of design flexibility. However, this could be overcome by introducing a scale of energy taxation. This would enable those that wish to exceed the design criteria of the regulations to do so, but they would have to pay for the privilege. Conversely, those who produce buildings and achieve significant savings beneath the bench mark could receive aid in the form of grants as recognition for their efforts and ingenuity.
I
2.6.4 Green Building Materials Timber is undoubtedly the material most favoured by green designers. As well as having a relatively low embodied energy content, it absorbs and stores carbon from CO2 when growing, and is strong, insulating and easy to work. Ideally, timber should be sourced in the UK but the supply is severely limited. When sourcing imported timbers designers should ensure that the material originates from a suitable source. The Forest Stewardship Council and the Timber Trades Federation both supply lists of suppliers of timber from good UK sources (see Appendix B). Some species of timber are better than others at resisting rot and decay. In particular, Western Red Cedar and Douglas Fir, which are again being considered as a viable alternative to PVC-u or aluminium. Note: specifiers should exercise care with regards to the source of timber as all is not always as it seems. Masonry construction can be considered green, especially if lime mortars are specified, because this enables the bricks to be used again in the future. Brick manufacturers are now keen to promote their products which use low energy kilns. Another form of construction finding favour is a solid block or concrete wall with insulation and render externally. Dense concrete blocks are preferred to lightweight aerated blocks which use more energy in production. Pulverized fuel ash blocks contain over 50 per cent fuel ash which is a waste product from power stations. It is also now possible to obtain plaster and plasterboard made from waste gypsum which is a by-product from fuel gas de-sulphurization.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 7
PART 2, SECTION 6
Insulation boards made from polyurethane, extruded polystyrene and phenolic foams have given way to mineral wool, glass fibre, expanded polystyrene, and in some cases foam glass or cork. Recycled cellulose fibre (newspaper print) is now being specified more for loft insulation and wall insulation in timber frame construction. One such product is known as ‘warm cell’ and is available from Excel Industries (see Appendix B). These are just a few examples of alternative material resources now available. It is of course interesting to consider that as these materials gain popularity and become specified as a matter of course, this will cause problems in sourcing adequate quantities to satisfy demands. There is a logic to the use of recycled materials (where the embodied energy can be utilized again) as being perhaps the greenest contribution to be made. Second-hand bricks, timber, roofing materials and assorted ironwork are already available, unfortunately at premium prices.
I
2.6.5 Whole Building Sustainability The matters discussed above help us to use resources and raw materials wisely and to produce better buildings in terms of energy consumed in construction and use. However, this in itself is not sustainable construction, although it is certainly a vital component in the process. Sustainable construction would only be achieved when the finished product can demonstrate usefulness and serviceability on an inter-generation basis, rather than being constructed for a single use and then rendered redundant when there is no longer a requirement for the original purpose. An example of such practice is the current trend for the conversion of redundant 1960s office buildings into residential accommodation, as well as warehouses and barns, which have for many years been seen as suitable residential conversion opportunities. The uses to which these buildings are now being put were never originally envisaged at the time of their planning, design and construction, but suitable alternative uses have been found. One of the key issues in building sustainability is to ensure that what is originally constructed from the resources becomes a similar resource for the future generations. In order to achieve this, attention must be turned to wise material usage and reduction of waste as well as to producing a building of the highest possible quality and with maximum adaptability. The building created must continue to serve future generations well for whatever purpose they wish to put it to, with the minimum of additional cost in terms of energy and raw material resource input in order to convert and use it for their own purposes. There are many buildings of over 200 years of age that have found suitable alternative purposes beyond that for which they were originally designed. It is therefore possible to establish with a reasonable degree of certainty what the vital component parts are in ensuring the success of a building for say a 200, or even a 300 year design life.
Page 8
Part 2, Section 6 (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 6
The methods of funding and, in particular, the timescale over which a building is considered a viable proposition would need to be reviewed and an alternative method of valuing the asset would need to be established. This would reflect not just the economic value, but also the environmental resource value invested in the construction, and the social impact and benefits that the construction is likely to have for future generations. The planning process could be slightly extended such that alternative uses are identified and documented and form an integral part of the planning process. This would require the procurers and designers of the building to demonstrate how it could be used for identified alternative purposes and to ensure that the design, as proposed, is sufficiently flexible for the alternative uses to be achieved with minimal additional input. The other components to ensure that a building is suitable for inter-generation use is to get the detailing, product selection and construction quality right such that the building does not wear out before the inter-generation uses can be realised. Whilst some technologies have changed very significantly the base skills have not and nor have the materials. It may be necessary for us to re-learn some old skills in order to produce buildings of a long life expectancy but it is now necessary for us to change from being a disposal society to a considerate and conserving one.
I
2.6.6 The Government Line In May 1999 the Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions (DETR) published A Better Quality of Life – A Strategy for Sustainable Development for the United Kingdom. This document endeavoured to set out a framework and priorities for achieving sustainable development which included: • more investment in people and equipment for a competitive economy; • achieving higher growth whilst reducing pollution and reuse of resources; • sharing the benefits of growth more widely and more fairly; • improving towns and cities and protecting the quality of the countryside; and • contributing to sustainable development internationally. The Government also felt that the construction industry can contribute to achieving the sustainable development aims by:
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 9
PART 2, SECTION 6
• being more profitable and more competitive; • delivering buildings and structures that provide greater satisfaction, well-being and value to customers and users; • respecting and treating its stakeholders more fairly; • enhancing and better protecting the natural environment; and • minimizing its impact on the consumption of energy (especially carbon-based energy) and natural resources. In April 2000 the DETR published Building a Better Quality of Life – A Strategy for More Sustainable Construction. (It should be noted that the inclusion of the word ‘more’ is now associated with a sustainable development strategy which perhaps indicates a slight rethink of absolutes.) This document shows that the Government now feels that the main themes for action in achieving ‘more’ sustainable construction can best be served by adopting the following action points: • reuse existing built assets – meeting functional requirements may not require new buildings and refurbishment and renovation may work better; • design for minimum waste – specify materials with care, think about using recycled materials, design out waste at all phases in the construction and occupation process and involve the supply chain; • aim for lean construction – aim for continuous improvement, waste elimination, customer focus, value for money, high quality management of the projects and supply chain and good communication; • minimize energy in construction – be aware of embodied energies and transportation of construction projects. Adopt ‘green’ travel policies; • minimize energy in use – consider more energy efficient solutions and energy production from renewable sources; • do not pollute – understand environmental impacts; • preserve and enhance bio-diversity – look for opportunities throughout the construction process to provide and protect habitats; • conserve water resources – design for increased water efficiency in building services and within the built environment; • respect people and their local environment – be responsive to the community and consider your workforce; and • set targets – measure and compare your performance with others and set targets for continuous improvement. Page 10
Part 2, Section 6 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 2, SECTION 6
I
2.6.7 What Might the Future Hold If sustainability is going to be the way forward in the next millennium many existing conceptions of development have to be reviewed and overhauled. The way the environment and resources are valued, and how they are used, have to be re-examined and justified against a policy of sustainability. The materials and resources that are used in construction activities and the buildings that are created will require fresh justification against sustainability objectives. This will require an overhaul of the planning process and regulatory frameworks within which the construction industry operates, requiring funders, building users, material technologists, material manufacturers and suppliers to re-examine and justify their methods. The sourcing of the materials and the methods employed in conversion and production of building products must be the first priority in making progress towards sustainable constructions. The way in which raw materials are extracted and processed at source can have the most direct impact upon the environment and must be closely examined as well as the actual material manufacturers themselves. The second area for examination would have to be the philosophy behind procuring buildings and meeting user requirements, the method by which buildings are funded, the method of valuation and justification, together with the demands for greater longevity and flexibility. Thirdly, the professions responsible for the design and construction of buildings to meet the requirements of funders and users must respond to the challenge of sustainability in order to deliver the required product. This would require new demands and disciplines in relation to the construction form and the standard of construction itself. New materials and techniques would need to be developed and adapted into sustainable construction. The professionals would have to put new demands upon the material producers in the production of more sustainable materials, but above all they must build for longevity and flexibility with minimum re-investment by way of adaptation and maintenance if the goals and targets are to be met. Finally, the contribution that those actually constructing the building have to make would need to be considered. The sustainable building should be a piece of procession engineering, simply constructed but to the very highest of quality standards with good detailing and nothing left to chance. The finished product would have to be a monument to sustainable construction and inter-generational equity making the optimum use of the energy and materials invested. In other words the principles of sustainability must be fully embraced by every participant from the supplier of the raw material, through the material manufacturing process, the procurement and design functions right up to the occupation of the completed building where the responsibility passes to the occupiers, the facilities managers and the future owners, occupiers and managers of the building to each play their part in making the most of what we have.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 (10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 11
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Material
Part 2, Section 6 Appendix A (10/00)
0
kWh/m3
Effective from 1/12/00
Source: The Architects Handbook 8 June 1995
10000
15000
195000
Aluminium 5000
63000
9300
Steel
1806
15000
1222
Glass
Plastic
Plaster
Bricks
833
694
Timber
Lightweight concrete
625
417
Concrete
Lightweight blocks
Appendix A: Embodied Energy Content of Building Material
PART 2, S ECTION 6, A PPENDIX A
Page 1
PART 2, SECTION 6, APPENDIX B
Appendix B: Useful Addresses Timber Trade Federation Clareville House 22/27 Oxenden Street London SW1Y 4EL Centre for Sustainable Construction Building Research Establishment Garston Watford WD2 7JR Department of Transport, Local Government and Regions (formerly Department of Environment, Transport and Regions) Sustainable Construction Team Eland House Bressenden Place London SW1E 5DU The Forest Stewardship Council Unit D Station Building Llanidloes Powys SY18 6EB Excel Industries 13 Rassau Industrial Estate Ebbw Vale Monmouthshire NP3 5SD Construction Resources 16 Great Guildford Street London SE1 0HS The Building Centre 26 Store Street London WC1 The Environment Information Service PO Box 197 Cawston Norwich NR10 4BH
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 2, Section 6 Appendix B (revised 10/01)
Effective from 1/12/01
Page 1
PART 3, SECTION 1
PART THREE: CONSTRUCTION PLANNING AND PROCUREMENT SECTION 1: DEVELOPING AN APPROPRIATE BUILDING PROCUREMENT STRATEGY Introduction This section is intended to provide both clients and their advisers with procedures which will assist them in the selection of an appropriate procurement strategy for a building project. The strategy developed for the purpose of project procurement should result from an objective assessment of client needs and project characteristics, since it is considered that there will be no single procurement strategy suitable for all projects and all clients. Choice of an inappropriate strategy can, however, result in a failure to meet client objectives, disappointment and potential litigation. The selection process should, therefore, provide a best-fit solution based on good judgement and which is acceptable in terms of the identified criteria and the acceptable distribution of risk. The selection of an appropriate procurement strategy is identified as a key decision in terms of achieving client objectives. Conversely, an inappropriate choice can be a key factor in performance failure, resulting in cost and time overruns and poor building performance. This section looks at the client’s role (3.1.1), the development of procurement strategies (3.1.2), the selection of the most appropriate procurement route (3.1.3), and the implementation process (3.1.4). 3.1.1 informs clients as to their involvement as it relates to key stages in the process. It also stresses the importance of appropriate professional advice. In 3.1.2–3, the key issues are addressed together with the characteristics of a variety of procurement strategies: the aim is to match client needs, the particular project’s criteria and the chosen strategy. The implementation of strategies is considered in 3.1.4 where reference is also made to standard contracts for the designer, consultant or constructor appointment. Appendix A outlines procurement options. The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 1
PART 3, SECTION 1
EFFECT OF CLIENT TYPE ON SATISFACTION CRITERIA The type of client will affect the criteria which must be met if the client is to be satisfied with the project. Owner-occupiers are usually primarily concerned with building performance in terms of functionality and costs in use. They may also be concerned with image and building style. In this sense, value for money is a key criterion. Developers, on the other hand, may be driven by market conditions which enable the project to be let or sold at maximum advantage. They may be predominantly concerned with speed rather than performance. This is not to say that owner-occupiers are unconcerned about time. Indeed, certainty of completion date may be a key issue. Nor is it fair to suggest that developers are unconcerned about building performance or cost. There are market conditions where both of these issues may become important. Attempts to categorise clients in various ways may be helpful in the early stages of developing procurement strategy. However, each client is unique and will be more or less experienced in the process of building procurement depending on company size and stage of development. It is important to consider those factors which will affect client satisfaction as well as the level of knowledge and experience of the client in the process of building procurement. These factors should have a major influence on procurement strategy and whether the client should take an active role in the procurement process. This Section addresses these issues and provides, through the form of a checklist, a process to aid selection. SCOPE The section and the processes included should be used as a prompt and a focus for the issues to be addressed during the development of procurement strategy. It is not intended that the section will be used as a substitute for judgement.
3.1.1 The Client’s Role (It is recommended that this be read in conjunction with Part 1, Section 1)
Page 2
G
3.1.1.1
INTRODUCTION
G
3.1.1.1
This subsection explains the client’s responsibilities through the life of a project. Although it is written for building projects, much of the advice is applicable to other types of project. In carrying out their role, clients, depending on their knowledge and expertise, will need help from their
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
consultants, project managers and other advisers, whose roles are also explained in this section. It is advisable, wherever possible, that clients obtain advice from an objective and independent adviser who will then not be involved as a consultant on the project. This subsection aims to assist both current and future clients in setting policy and formulating strategy. It outlines their task and explains how it should be carried out. It has been written with the lay client in mind, but will also assist experienced clients and their advisers. The success of any project will depend on the motivation given by the client. Experienced clients may take a leading role in the procurement process; less experienced clients will need to seek advice or to appoint an adviser to assist them. Where projects are of a large or complex nature it may be advisable to consider the appointment of a project manager, who will manage the whole project on behalf of the client. G
3.1.1.2
A building project represents a discrete piece of work with clear start and finish dates, providing specified benefits at accepted cost. It is unlike any other manufactured product because it has:
• • • • G
3.1.1.3
It has three other particular characteristics:
• • •
G
3.1.1.4
a unique demand – the client’s specific need for accommodation (but future adaptability and possible disposal must not be ignored); a unique location – the site available for the building; unique constraints – the cost and time parameters for the project; and a unique end product – the finished building.
the final product, although itself unique, is built up of many standard parts assembled in accordance with a series of standard rules and practices; its construction involves major expenditure over a comparatively short period of time; and the construction of a new building requires a large team of individuals and firms with particular expertise to work together to complete the project satisfactorily. This team will normally only be formed for this unique project and then be disassembled. It is unlikely that the same team will work together again, and if it does, the project is likely to be different. Each project is, therefore, a prototype and involves a learning curve. Project testing is rare.
(a) Effective management is vital in any construction project. The client’s prime role is to define the project and to establish a structure for the management of the project to make sure that it works. (b) A crucial part of any effective management structure is effective communication. To perform effectively all parties should have timely access to all information relevant to their tasks and the project’s objectives and status.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 3
PART 3, SECTION 1
(c) The client can have substantial influence on the design of the project in respect of both functional efficiency and of overall appearance, and, therefore, has to take particular care to: • develop a business case for the project identifying primary needs and analysing costs and benefits • understand fully the purpose of the building; ensure that the requirements of the users are accommodated; and communicate those requirements to the designers; • appoint architects and engineers with the proven ability of designing buildings which satisfy users’ requirements and harmonise with and contribute to the quality of the built environment. The selection of the right people is emphasised as a key to success. (d) This subsection sets out the role and responsibilities of the client through all stages of the project. (e) The diagram on the next page indicates the primary activities in the procurement process and when activities are performed. As can be seen the client’s role is significant with a wide range of activities to perform and implement before both the design and the construction processes. In the performance of these activities clients can expect to be supported and advised by their advisers or (if appointed) the project manager.
Page 4
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Systems and controls (3.1.4.11)
Commissioning (3.1.1.17) Occupation and takeover (3.1.1.18)
Design overview (3.1.4.12) Cost control overview (3.1.4.13) Time control overview (3.1.4.14) Quality control overview (3.1.4.18) Change control overview (3.1.4.19)
Procurement strategy (3.1.1.13) Design overview* (3.1.4.12) Cost control overview* (3.1.4.13) Whole-life costs (3.1.4.15) Value engineering (3.1.4.17) Time control overview* (3.1.4.14) Quality control overview* (3.1.4.18) Appointment of constructors (3.1.4.9) Confirming the business case (3.1.1.9)
Contractual arrangements (3.1.4.10) Systems and controls (3.1.4.11)
Post-construction
Construction
Pre-construction phase
Effective from 1/3/03
( ) Indicates the subsection of this document referring to the activity
Indicates the activity will continue into the next phase
Diagram to indicate the activities in the Procurement Process
Resources (3.1.4.3–5) (Client) Organisational structure (3.1.4.6) Contractual arrangements* (3.1.4.10) Systems and controls* (3.1.4.11) Implementation policy (3.1.4.2)
Implementation
*
Procurement strategy development (3.1.2)
Procurement strategy
Pre-design phase
PRIMARY ACTIVITIES IN THE PROCUREMENT PROCESS
Appoint adviser (3.1.1.6) Develop the business case for the project* (3.1.1.9) Define client’s responsibilities (3.1.1.7) Project definition (3.1.1.10) Project briefing (3.1.1.12) Appointment of PM (if appropriate) (3.1.4.7) Appointment of design and cost consultants (3.1.4.8) Procurement strategy* (3.1.1.13) Value management (3.1.4.16)
3.1.1.5
Client’s role
G
PART 3, SECTION 1
Page 5
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.1.6
INDEPENDENT CLIENT ADVICE (a) With the potential for the involvement of many consultants and/or constructors in a project, and the range of contracts associated with their employment, all but the most experienced client may need advice. The advice offered should be informed and unbiased and it should be based upon a logical analysis of the needs of the client, the type and character of the project and the range of appropriate strategies available. (b) This advice can be offered by a member of the client’s design team or can be a separate function. It may be more difficult for a design team member to remain impartial in carrying out this process and it is recommended that any expertise retained should be retained solely for this purpose. This function may encompass:
• • • • •
Assistance in preparing the business case underpinning the project Identifying the needs and requirements of the client Defining the project Matching needs and project characteristics with appropriate procurement strategy Facilitating the associated selection and contractual processes and policies
(the business case) (briefing) (project definition) (procurement strategy) (implementation)
(c) The decision as to which procurement strategy to select should be based upon information from the client and information about the project. (d) A best practice guide is available to assist in this process1. (e) Possible sources for independent client advice include a suitably qualified and experienced construction professional such as a chartered surveyor. G
3.1.1.7
CLIENT’S RESPONSIBILITIES (a) The client should set policy and outline strategy including: • setting and prioritising the project objectives; • clarifying client attitude to project risk; • establishing procurement strategy; • arbitrating between conflicting demands; and • evaluating the completed project against the objectives.
1
Page 6
Construction Industry Board, Briefing the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997.
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
(b) The client also has a threefold management function: • to provide financial resources and land for the project; • to manage the client input; to co-ordinate functional and administrative needs; to make decisions when needed; to resolve conflicts; to act as the formal point of contract for the project; and • to supply the technical expertise, to assess, procure, monitor and control the external resources need to implement the project (throughout the procurement process). (c) In particular the client should be satisfied, as far as possible, that: • the project brief is clearly defined as far as possible and linked back to the client’s business case for the project; • the project brief is comprehensive and clear and has the full support of the users; • any constraints demanded by the project funder(s) are known and their impact understood; • the critical assumptions made in preparing the initial estimates and programmes are valid, realistic and achievable; • advisers have developed cost estimates which are comprehensive and include all capital and resources costs; • allowances made in the feasibility and viability assessments to cover possible risks are sufficient (contingency allowance); • an adequate risk analysis has been completed; • substantial sensitivity analysis and ‘what if’ studies have been carried out to assess the effect of possible changed criteria on the viability of the project; • plans are in place for adequate project management including systems for cost, time and change control, and that health and safety has been adequately addressed; • land will be purchased and available for the commencement of the work. (d) The client should also co-ordinate and resolve conflicts between all interested sections of the client organisation including: • user groups – who will work in the building; • specialist groups – responsible for technical systems within the building, e.g. communications, computers; • facilities management – who will manage the completed building including maintenance and security; • finance and accounts – who will plan and control expenditure and pay bills as they arise; • legal advisers – who will advise on and monitor the client’s formal relationships with outside parties.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 7
PART 3, SECTION 1
(e) The client is responsible for ensuring that all necessary decisions are made on time. Timely decisions are necessary to avoid delays and increased costs; the decision-making process requires as much planning and management as any other activity. This will include: • scheduling the key decisions to be made; • identifying the decision makers and their required procedures; • ascertaining the time required for making decisions; • establishing a formal programme for decisions; • pre-warning decision makers of forthcoming submissions – making sure ‘items are on the agenda’; • preparing on time fully detailed submissions and/or presentations in full compliance with procedural requirements; • following up submissions throughout the decision making process; and • promptly communicating decisions made to the parties affected by them. G
3.1.1.8
KEY CLIENT ACTIVITIES Notwithstanding overall responsibility for the whole of the project, the client will have an active personal involvement in the key activities explained in the following subsections.
G
3.1.1.9
DEVELOPING THE BUSINESS CASE FOR THE PROJECT (a) The client’s purpose in initiating a building project may be driven by the need for the project as a functional unit or long-term investment. (b) The client will need to review project feasibility in terms of time and cost against benefits which will stem from the proposed project. In doing so he/she will have to consider the returns expected, the value (in use) of the projected asset against projected land costs, construction costs, cost of fees, fitting out and commissioning costs, operating and maintenance costs and the opportunity cost of money. (c) The importance of each of these issues will be relative to the objectives of the client and to the extent to which the client is able to cope with risk. (d) Further influences in the case of a development project may include likely annual rental, period between rent reviews, and growth of rental value. In terms of the project development, total development time and taxation issues may also be influential on the decision process. (e) It is important that the client seeks advice in terms of investment appraisal of the planned project and that any appraisal considers ‘what if’ questions to ensure that the impact of changes of key components in the appraisal are clearly understood. A chartered surveyor will be able to assist the client in these matters.
Page 8
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.1.10
PROJECT DEFINITION The importance of a clear project definition to the successful completion of the project and in ensuring appropriate performance of the project cannot be over emphasised. The inexperienced client will need professional help from the advisers or design team in the preparation of the definition. The project definition is a comprehensive statement of the client’s objectives and parameters for the project based on close consultation between the client and users covering:
• • • • • G
3.1.1.11
project description; function of building; equipment and special services/requirements; target programme; and site.
ESTABLISHING PRIMARY OBJECTIVES (a) In establishing the primary objectives for the project it is necessary to prioritise these objectives to ensure that when developing a procurement strategy appropriate emphasis is given to the most important objectives. (b) Since there can be a tension between the long-term objectives set for the project in the business plan and the short-term objectives set for the project by the project team, the identification of priorities is very important. (c) One way to achieve this is to consider ‘what if’ scenarios to establish the importance of key factors: • what if the project does not meet its functional requirements? • what if the project is delivered late? • what if the cost of the project exceeds the budget? (d) By carrying out an analysis in this way relative importance can be given to each aspect by weighting that aspect against a total. For example: Function Completion Cost
% 50 20 30 100
Each of these can be subdivided to produce clarity, e.g. cost can be divided into capital and running costs, time into speed or reliability of delivery date and function into layout, environmental quality and specification.
(e) This is the initial control document for the early planning of the project; without it little constructive work can be done. If all the information required for the project definition is not readily available, it is better to issue it in an incomplete form and progressively update it. G
3.1.1.12
BRIEFING (a) Once the project definition has been completed the briefing process will be carried out. This is when the design team and cost consultants are able to flesh out
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 9
PART 3, SECTION 1
the project prior to extensive design work. The process commences with concept design building upon project definition and progresses through to a project brief which should encompass the client’s aesthetic, spatial and service requirements. (b) While it may be difficult for inexperienced construction clients to visualise the descriptions outlined during the briefing process it is worth spending time seeking consensus on its content to avoid waste in the later design process. (c) The Construction Industry Board (1997) have produced an excellent guide called Briefing the Team which summarises the processes involved.1 (d) Following the development of the brief for the project the design process will commence (see 3.1.4 – Implementation). G
3.1.1.13
DEVELOPMENT OF PROCUREMENT STRATEGY The client is responsible for selecting the procurement strategy most suited to the project and deciding how it is to be administered. The client may need to take consultant advice on which strategy is most appropriate considering the prioritised objectives and attitude to risk. This is a three-stage process which may be key to project success:
• • •
selecting the strategy; implementing the strategy; and planning the administration of the contracts underpinning the implementation of the strategy.
The processes of procurement strategy selection and implementation are dealt with in 3.1.3 and 3.1.4. G
Page 10
3.1.1.14
(a) Strategies may include: • traditional – design by consultants completed before lump sum tenders are obtained; • design and build – detailed design and construction by the contractor for lump sum; design and construction may overlap. Where a concept design is produced by the consultants before the contractor is appointed, the strategy is called develop and construct; • management contract – design by consultants; management contractor appointed early and work package contracts let progressively in the contractor’s name; design and construction overlap; • design and manage – outline design by the consultants; as ‘management contract’ but detailed design by the management contractor; design and construction overlap; and • construction management – design by consultants; construction manager appointed early to produce and manage trade package contracts made directly with the client; design and construction overlap.
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.1.15
(a) The extent of collaboration possible between those who design the project and those responsible for delivery will vary with the strategy adopted. (b) Selection strategies may include selection by competition for price; on the basis of the quality of the bid as well as price alone; or by negotiation. In some cases a high level of collaboration is possible enabling those responsible for delivery to adopt a ‘Partnering’ approach to project delivery. (c) Partnering is not so much a contract strategy as a way by which the project team can be drawn together for their mutual benefit. Partnering is usually most advantageous where the client has a range of projects to procure but can be adopted for single projects. (d) The principles associated with Partnering are based on inclusiveness and depend upon a trust being established within the team. There is also a focus on achieving the best outcome for the client as well as a satisfactory outcome for each participant. The primary principles include developing mutual objectives, simple approaches to dealing with disputes and a focus on continuous improvement which can be measured. (e) This approach represents a change in the culture traditionally adopted by the UK construction industry which has previously been based on price-bid approaches and will need to be carefully managed. However, evidence is beginning to emerge of real all-round benefits being achieved particularly by regular and experienced construction clients. (f) The Construction Industry Board have published a most useful guide to partnering1. (g) The number and style of contract documents will depend on the contract strategy selected.
G
3.1.1.16
(a) Where direct consultant appointments are made each will be subject to a separate form of contract, but where a design and build strategy is selected, designers may be appointed by the contractor. In the case of construction management, the client will be required to enter into many individual trade contracts. (b) Contract implementation can be complex and may encompass the additional appointment of consultant advisers or the novation of designers from the client to the contractor. In addition, forms of warranty and collateral contracts may be involved. The consultant advisers can assist the client in the selection of appropriate contracts and the documentation associated with them.
1
Construction Industry Board, Partnering in the Team, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 11
PART 3, SECTION 1
(c) The responsibility for contract administration will depend upon the procurement strategy selected, and may fall upon the design team, the project manager, a contract administrator, or the client him/herself. The client should seek advice to ensure that the administration process is appropriately planned and delegated. (d) Guidance on the appointment of consultants and contractors is included in 3.1.4 (Implementation). G
3.1.1.17
COMMISSIONING (a) Once the building work is complete the systems which will support comfort must be commissioned to ensure they are working effectively and reliably. (b) In relatively simple buildings the client can insist that this is a function which the contractor must perform. Where buildings have sophisticated systems controlling the internal environment or facilitating staff movement or safety, commissioning can be established as an independent activity carried out by specialists. (c) However commissioning is facilitated, it must be achieved before any building can function effectively.
G
3.1.1.18
OCCUPATION AND TAKE-OVER (a) The client is responsible for addressing the issues of occupation, staffing and subsequent operation and maintenance of the building. This activity is separate from the design and construction process, although it will affect it, and will have its own time, resource and cost implications which should be incorporated into the overall project plan. (b) For large projects, the client may wish to arrange for the nomination of a member of the department to act as occupation manager to manage this activity or may appoint a facilities manager. Occupation plans should be established during the design stages of the project and should cover: • the operation of the building on a regular on-going basis; • the hand-over and acceptance of the building from the contractor(s); • the progressive final fitting-out (if any) and physical occupation of the building with minimum disruption to the client’s operations.
3.1.2 Procurement Strategy G
Page 12
3.1.2.1
Designing and constructing a new building is rarely straightforward. It is subject to a series of risks and uncertainties and involves a number of organisations especially assembled for the project. The way in which the client and the various designers, contractors and suppliers work together as a team is determined by the procurement strategy and forms of contract entered
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
into between the project participants and the client. The procurement strategy should be consistent with the objectives of the project and should enable the risks to be controlled to achieve a successful outcome. G
3.1.2.2
Procurement strategy is the outcome of a series of decisions which are made during the early stages of a project. It is one of the most important decisions facing the client. The chosen strategy influences the allocation of risk, the design strategy and the method of employment of consultants and contractors. Risks are also allocated by means of the associated contracts. Procurement strategy has a major impact on the timescale and ultimate cost of the project.
G
3.1.2.3
Generally, clients can choose from several different strategies. A successful strategy is one which leads to a completed building which meets the client’s objectives. The preferred aim is for contributing parties to work together for a quality result rather than competing against each other.
G
3.1.2.4
Where the development of design does not maintain the pace anticipated, or the programme is otherwise affected by unexpected occurrences, the selected strategy must be reviewed. It is most important that the strategy is reconsidered at key times in the progress of the project such as when planning approval is given, before contract strategy is decided and before construction contracts are let.
G
3.1.2.5
DEFINITION OF TERMS Different procurement strategies provide different ways of allocating risk and responsibility to the organisation contributing to the project. They can either integrate the design and construction processes or segregate them. Approaches to the selection of processes enabling collaboration are referred to in 3.1.4 (Implementation). The main types of procurement strategy are summarised below (they are covered in more detail in Appendix A).
• •
•
traditional: design by consultants is completed before contractors tender for, then carry out, construction; construction management: design by the client’s consultants and construction overlap. A fee-earning construction manager defines and manages the work packages. All contracts are between the client and the trade contractors. The final cost of the project may only be accurately forecast when all packages have been let; management contracting: design by the client’s consultant and construction overlap. A management contractor is appointed early to let elements of work progressively by trade or package contracts (called ‘works packages’). The contracts are between the management contractor and the works contractors. As with construction management, the final cost can only be accurately forecast when the last package has been let;
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 13
PART 3, SECTION 1
•
•
design and manage: similar to the management contract, with the contractor also being responsible either for detailed design or for managing the detailed design process; and design and build: detailed design and construction are both undertaken by a single contractor is return for a lump sum price. Where a concept design is prepared before the contractor is appointed, the strategy is called develop and construct.
G
3.1.2.6
On some projects it may be necessary to use more than one strategy to meet the project’s objectives. For example, a traditional approach may be used for completing the building structurally with main services installed. This is known as a shell and core contract. A separate strategy, for example, construction management, may be used to fit out the building with ceilings, raised floors, carpets, partitions and electrical fittings. The use of two strategies allows the client more time to finalise the user’s detailed requirements, without delaying the start of construction.
G
3.1.2.7
When the choice of procurement strategy has been made, the resultant contract strategy and forms of contract should be chosen (i.e. the terms and conditions of the contract). To avoid the need for fresh legal drafting each time, various standard forms of contract are available, both for the appointment of consultants and contractors. Construction professionals re usually experienced in understanding these contracts and can advise on the implications of their adoption. The range of contracts available is referred to in 3.1.4 (Implementation).
G
3.1.2.8
PROJECT OBJECTIVES (a) Construction (and refurbishment) projects are often complex with potential for cost and time overruns or the finished building performing less well than planned. To minimise such risks the client should select the procurement strategy which matches the objectives of the project. These must be clearly established and prioritised before any design or other work begins (see 3.1.1.10–11 – Project Definition, Establishing Primary Objectives). (b) The client must decide the relative importance of the three main types of criteria – time, cost and performance: • time: earlier completion can be achieved if construction is started before design is finished. The greater the overlap between the two, the less time will be required to complete the project; • cost: with the exception of simple ‘standard’ buildings and certain ‘design and build’ strategies, a final construction contract sum cannot be established until the design is complete. Any overlap between design and construction means that construction starts before the cost is fixed. This increases the importance of accurate cost forecasting and the risk to the client; and
Page 14
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
• performance (design): the quality and performance characteristics required from the completed building determine both the project time and cost. Some strategies reduce the client’s ability to control and make changes to the detailed building specification after the contracts have been let. (c) Performance includes the function of the building, its quality and appearance and other factors such as durability, cost in use and flexibility. The relative importance of each objective must be given careful consideration because decisions throughout the project will be based on balances between the other objectives (see Figure 1). In any project these three criteria will be interdependent and decisions affecting one will affect one or both of the other criteria. The appropriate procurement strategy will recognise this interrelationship and reflect the client’s objectives and the characteristics of the project. It is uncommon for a project simply to emphasise one criterion alone and most projects would emphasise time and cost, time and performance or cost and performance. The project strategies most commonly adopted reflect this characteristic. The strategy should also reflect the client’s technical ability and resources and the amount of control over the process which he/she wishes to exert directly or through the project manager (if appointed).
FIGURE 1 THE RELATIONSHIP BE TWEEN P RIMARY CRITERIA
Time aspects (speed to completion, programme certainty)
As the emphasis on one or two of these criteria increases the other(s) will be affected
Cost Issues (level of price, certainty of price)
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Performance Issues (quality, functionality, design)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 15
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.2.9
RISK AND RESPONSIBILITY (a) There is a finite amount of risk and responsibility associated with any project and this should be an influencing factor on the selection of the procurement strategy. The uncertainties of time, cost and performance are the three main risks that are present in every project. Risks are usually considered as uncertain future events, which may have significant effects, e.g. extra cost, delay or damage to the performance of the finished project. Having set the priorities for the project’s objectives, the client should consider the effect of those objectives not being met and the resulting risks to which he/she could be exposed. Although the project is subject to a wide variety of risks, it is important to note that only a few have a major effect. This is a powerful argument for concentrating attention during cost estimating and management decision-making on the few largest sources of uncertainty and risk and for developing strategies for managing out risk and for setting up contracts in such a way that the allocation of the major risks is clear. (b) The risks which are considered to have potentially the greatest impact on construction projects include: • a project which will not function in accordance with the client’s needs; • a project which is of inadequate quality; • a project which is completed later than required deadlines; and • a project which costs more than the client’s budget or ability to pay. In each case, the strategy can be to transfer the whole risk to another through the medium of contract. This is possible but will attract high price premiums or will expose the transferee to risks which they may not be able to ‘own’ or insure and therefore the party transferring the risk will remain exposed. Risk may alternatively be retained in part by the client, or reduced by adequate pre-design or pre-price investigation. (c) As has been already suggested, an adequate brief will reduce risk and ensure functionality and quality standards. Equally, adequacy of programme will reduce the risk of overrun and adequacy of cost estimates should ensure a resultant cost which is within budget. Both construction time and construction cost estimates depend upon sufficient design development, which itself will depend upon an adequate brief and parallel investigation of ground conditions and the particular requirements of statutory controls. In ensuring that the brief is adequate, and that design is appropriately developed, the client can successfully reduce some risk in a way that will not result in high price premiums. (d) Ideally, risk and responsibility should go together, so that the party responsible for performing a task is accountable. Each risk should be allocated
Page 16
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
to the party with the greatest ability to own the risk and to manage its effects. If, for example, the client considers it critical that the price for the building is fixed before construction commences, the risk of meeting that objective could be passed to contractors, making them contractually responsible for completion to an agreed design and specification for a lump sum price. G
3.1.2.10
PASSING ON RISK (a) Responsibility for risk and the ability to control a project interact. The more the client chooses to allocate risk to other parties, the less control the client has over the way in which the project is executed. In the example above, if the contractor has to meet the agreed specification within the budget and time, the client has little influence over the way in which these objectives are met. In practice, risk allocation is determined by the chosen strategy and allocated by means of contracts between the client and those responsible for managing, designing or constructing the project. The way in which risk and responsibility are allocated by different contract strategies is indicated below and shown in Appendix A. (b) In all cases where risks are transferred in contractual terms, it is necessary to ensure the ability of the transferee to own the risk. In the case of design failure, for example, this is usually passed to the design team including the architect and engineering consultants. Because of the nature of their professions they should have insurances of sufficient capacity to meet the maximum possible cost of correcting the design failure. The client should ensure that such insurances are in place, adequate and paid for; where a project manager or consultant adviser has been appointed, this is a role that may be performed by him/her. (c) Some design work may be carried out by subcontractors who may or may not continue to pay design liability insurance premiums and usually will have limited liability status. Liability for their design work is commonly passed by warranties but these are less secure. Equally, where time risks are passed to contractors their attempts to transfer them to small subcontractors may fail where the capacity to own or accept the risk is limited. In situations such as these it may be possible to pass risks contractually but the lack of security associated with the transfer may result in the risk being borne by the party attempting to pass it. It is difficult to allocate blame in team situations. The client should be aware of this weakness in terms of risk allocation. (d) While the transfer of risk provides an incentive for the receiving party to minimise its impact, the client should avoid transferring risks when the receiving party has no control over them or no capacity to absorb them. Generally, the more the risk of cost and time slippage is allocated to other
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 17
PART 3, SECTION 1
parties, the higher the tendered cost. In pricing the project, tenderers may over-estimate the size of the risk or add a high safety margin to an accurate estimate and thereby increase the project’s costs unnecessarily. G
3.1.2.11
RISK AND PROCUREMENT STRATEGY (a) Risks are inherent in the data used by the client in the preparation of the brief, they are inherent in the characteristics of the project, and they are inherent in the procurement strategy which is selected. The identification of primary risks and an analysis of the client’s ability to be a risk taker, or need to be risk averse, should affect procurement strategy. With this information in mind steps should be taken:
• •
to inform the client of the extent of the risks involved; and to prepare a strategy for managing risk.
Since the latter will have a cost the client should also be advised of the expense of managing risk. (b) Appendix A refers to the characteristics of each procurement strategy and indicates the levels of risk associated with time, cost and performance in each case on the assumption that the procurement strategy is properly utilised and in no way abused. (Thus, for example, in relation to the traditional system it has been assumed that design completion is achieved before measurement and documentation is carried out.) These primary risks are summarised (by simple examples in Figure 2) by procurement method in the categories time, cost and performance. Where design is by the client’s consultant, design risk is placed by the appointment agreement. Where design is by the contractor, design risk is placed by the building contract agreement. Where lump sum price is fixed by the contract the responsibility rests with the contractor. Where a contract sets standards of specification, meeting these standards is the contractor’s responsibility (risk). Thus by contractual agreement primary risks can be distributed between client, designer and constructor. It is impossible to dispose of all risk inherent in construction projects and some will inevitably remain with the client. For example, the risks listed here tend to be client risks and although they may be of varying likelihood they should be understood.
Page 18
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
FIGURE 2 S U M M A R I S I N G T H E P R I M A RY R I S K S , B Y E X A M P L E Time
Cost
Performance
Traditional
Fixed but extension of time possible due to client and designer initiated changes
Fixed but subject to change where design changes are made, where inflation occurs or where contractor is alleged to have grounds for contractual claims
Designed by client’s consultant. Quality set by contract documents
Design and Build Contractor
As traditional
As traditional
Design by contractor but with varying levels of input by client – quality set in same way
Separate management function
Time not fixed by contract
Cost not fixed before commencement
As traditional
(c) This short list segregates residual risk by procurement method. The extent to which risk remains with the client can be established by a detailed analysis of contractual agreements.
•
•
•
G
3.1.2.12
Traditional – building suitability – risk of contractor insolvency – risk of delay by consultant or the causes allowed by contract Design and Build – building suitability – design functionality and usability – design insurance if contractor moves away from this type of business, goes out of business or fails to pay premium Management Contracting/Construction Management – as traditional procurement plus: risk of cost overrun risk of time overrun
SUMMARY (RISK) Risk can be reduced, retained, transferred or distributed. To transfer risk successfully the risk taker should have the capacity to take the full extent of the risk or the risk placer will have failed. Where there are so many relatively small firms, as in the UK construction industry, this can be problematic because many contracts place risks with risk takers without sufficient capacity. They may be limited liability companies or may be unable or unwilling to insure.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 19
PART 3, SECTION 1
Thus, for example, attempting to enforce large scale liquidated damages for late completion on a small-sized domestic subcontractor may fail for lack of financial capacity within the small company. Procurement strategy should therefore reflect the ability to place risk, and where possible risk should be managed out. G
3.1.2.13
PROCUREMENT STRATEGY AND THE PROJECT CYCLE The development of procurement strategy follows the stages in the life of a project. Initially, a preliminary strategy is determined. It is based on a broad definition of objectives and is an essential step in establishing the way forward for the project. It encourages the client to consider strategy early. The preliminary procurement strategy is usually developed with help from the client’s adviser and possibly other consultants. Procurement strategy development has three components:
• • •
analysis – assessing and setting the priorities of the project objectives and requirements; choice – considering possible options, evaluating them and selecting the most appropriate; and implementation – putting the chosen strategy into effect.
During strategy preparation, it may be necessary to seek specialist advice from other consultants, for example, in relation to expected costs for the project. The adviser should advise the client on this. Specialist advice should be sought when developing the strategy for novel or especially difficult projects. Until construction contracts are let, the client, with help from his adviser, must systematically ensure that the strategy is on course to meet the project’s established objectives. This is important because objectives sometimes change. G
3.1.2.14
IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS The factors listed below should be considered in analysing project objectives, requirements and their relative priorities (each is then considered in detail) and may have an effect on the choice of procurement strategy:
• • • • • • • • Page 20
factors outside the control of the project team; client resources; project characteristics; ability to make changes; risk management; cost issues; timing; and quality and performance.
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
Inevitably, some of these requirements will be in conflict and priorities need to be decided. The choice of strategy should ensure that control is maintained over those factors which are of most importance to the client. The way in which this choice can be made is covered below and in 3.1.4. (a) Factors outside the control of the project team Consideration should be given to economic, technological, social, political and legal factors which influence the client and the project team or are likely to do so during the lifetime of the project. These may include forecast and actual:
• • • •
interest rates; inflation; changes in output of construction industry affecting tender price levels and the availability of skilled labour; and legislation, particularly legislation affecting the design and construction of projects. In many cases the client will have responsibility for legal compliance, particularly in relation to health and safety matters and should seek the advice of his/her advisers (including the design team) on such issues as a matter of importance.
(b) Client resources The client’s knowledge and experience of the company’s organisation and the environment in which it operates are vital in assessing the appropriate procurement strategy. Project objectives are influenced by the nature and culture of the company, external influences and the expectations of individuals affected by the project. The extent to which the client is prepared to take a full and active role is a major consideration. (c) Project characteristics The size, complexity and location of the project should be carefully considered and particular attention given to projects with novel elements. For example, if the building is especially large or complex there may be a bigger risk of cost or time overrun. Novel projects present special risks. The novelty potential factor means that estimates of time, cost and performance are all subject to greater error with an increased probability of one or more of the project’s objectives failing. (d) Ability to make changes It is preferable to identify the total needs of the project during the early stages but this is not always possible. Rapidly changing technology often means late changes. Changes in the scope of the project very often result in increased costs, especially if they arise during construction. Changes introduced after the design is well advanced or construction has commenced often have a disproportionate effect on the project, in terms of cost, delay and disruption, compared with the change itself. The design process goes through a progressive The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 21
PART 3, SECTION 1
series of ‘freezes’ as it develops but the client should set a final design freeze date after which no significant changes to requirements or design are allowed. Some procurement strategies such as construction management are better than others at handling the introduction of changes later in the project without having to pay some form of specific premium. (e) Cost issues Price certainty – influences the project timing and the procurement strategy which should be used. Generally, design should be complete if price certainty is required before construction commences. Cost of changes – if cost certainty is to be maintained during the course of construction changes should be avoided. Changes often have cost and time implications on the project well in excess of the change itself. It is therefore important for the client to fix a date after which no significant changes should be introduced. (f) Timing The programme of the project is influenced by many of the above factors. A particularly large and/or complex project is likely to require more time for design, specification and construction than would be required for a simple small building. It is of vital importance to allow for adequate design time in terms of the total project. If design is required to be complete before construction commences (where perhaps cost certainty is required) this is particularly the case. In the process of the appointment of the design team assurances should be obtained about resource levels and the ability to meet key dates or programmes. It is not usual to impose contractual dates upon designers, although their progress is probably the key to the overall completion date. Decisions to progress with a project may be influenced by the gaining of planning approval, by the successful operation of compulsory purchase order, by land purchase or by some other non-specific but critical factor (such as obtaining funding approval). Depending on whether these factors occur earlier or later, they may be an influence upon the planned or desired time available for design. Procurement strategies such as management contracting, construction management, and design and build provide an overlap between the design and construction stages, so construction can start earlier than sequential strategies and offer the potential for earlier completion. It may be necessary to review planned procurement strategy in the light of design progress at the point where restraints to constructions are removed, bearing in mind the stage of design and the consequence in terms of risk. Page 22
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
F IGURE 3 CON STRUCT ION T IME S The following times are based upon historical data and are only a guide. Projects of relatively simple design may be constructed more quickly and more complex designs may take longer. New purpose built cost (£millions)
Retail facilities weeks
New speculative cost (£millions)
Retail facilities weeks
30
90
30
100
25
80
25
95
20
75
20
90
15
70
15
85
10
65
10
80
5
55
5
70
New purpose built cost (£millions)
Office facilities weeks
New speculative cost (£millions)
Office facilities weeks
30
120
30
135
25
110
25
130
20
100
20
120
15
90
15
110
10
85
10
100
5
70
5
85
(g) Construction times Total construction time is a consequence of design. Insufficient time allowance can result in apparent delay when in fact the targets were unachievable. Design is a time-consuming process and often will take as long as construction itself (sometimes longer). More complex structures will take longer given the same cost or size, and may require more resources. Although it is possible to work on site for extensive hours or to increase resources, it is not always possible to achieve directly resulting productivity. The law of diminishing returns will have an influence because of the limited space and the nature of traditional construction methods (such as concreting and bricklaying). Indications of construction times are shown in Figure 3. These are only a general guide and should not be relied on without careful review. The data on which these are based was available only for commercial and industrial projects. This data was used to confirm, enhance and update that published by NEDO (1988), Faster Building for Commerce and the construction costs have been updated by index to the year 2002. If possible (as in the case of The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 23
PART 3, SECTION 1
management contracting and construction management) those who will be involved in the construction process should also be involved in the planning process, as they are more likely to be aware of the logistical consequences of particular designs. Other projects are likely, in most cases, to be more complex and may therefore take longer. (h) Design times There is no reliable data available to indicate the time to be allowed for design. As a general rule it will take between two thirds of construction time to one and a half times construction time to design a building. The impact that this will have on the overall programme will depend upon the choice of procurement strategy and whether any overlap of design and construction is allowed. (i) Performance The required performance of the project measured both in terms of its response to the needs of the client and the quality of individual elements must be clearly identified. If performance is over-specified, a premium will be paid for exceeding actual requirements, thereby affecting the cost objective. Over-specification will also lead to time overruns. Conversely, failure to recognise the true performance objective leads to an unsatisfactory product. If quality and performance are particularly important the client will probably want to keep direct control over the development of the design. This can be achieved by employing the design team directly. G
3.1.2.15
PROCUREMENT OPTIONS When all the factors influencing the project have been identified and the project requirements analysed, the final strategy for the project must be developed. It is likely that there will be more than one way to achieve the requirements of the project. It is important to consider carefully each option, as each will address the various influencing factors to a different extent. In developing strategies, a potential danger is that only the most obvious course of action may be considered – this is not necessarily the best in the longer term.
G
3.1.2.16
Common strategies differ from each other in relation to:
• • • •
Page 24
the financial risk that the client is exposed to; the degree of control that the client has over the design and construction processes; the information required at the time construction contracts are let; the extent of involvement of the contractor in the design stage when the contractor may be able to influence the ‘buildability’ of the project;
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
• • G
3.1.2.17
the organisational arrangements which distribute responsibility and accountability; and the sequential nature of the process.
In Appendix A each of the most commonly used procurement strategies is described and is also illustrated by diagram. Each diagram has a consistent format to indicate:
• • • •
the contractual relationships (showing administrative responsibility in most cases); the advantages and disadvantages; the sequential nature of the process; and the dominant risks categorised broadly (as high, medium or low).
3.1.3 Selection of Most Appropriate Procurement Strategy G
3.1.3.1
The ultimate responsibility for selection of appropriate procurement strategy will rest with the client, based upon advice from the project team and principal adviser. The selected strategy should be:
• •
suitable in the light of the client’s needs, the project type and the client’s exposure to risk; and feasible in the light of the client’s expertise, internal management structure, resource and funding facility.
Professional judgement is a reliable way of selecting an appropriate procurement strategy although some procurement strategies can be inappropriately adopted because of individual preference. A procurement selection checklist is provided here to assist the client and advisers in the identification of an appropriate strategy. G
3.1.3.2
PROCUREMENT SELECTION CHECKLIST This process has been designed to establish a range of information about client needs and about the particular project being considered, and to develop this information in parallel with the characteristics of procurement strategies and associated risk. It is intended to inform judgement, not to replace judgement. The relative importance of time, cost and performance (design) forms a key criterion in the selection mechanism as does inherent risk and its apportionment.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 25
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.3.3
METHOD Checklists 1, 2 and 3 should be carefully completed in consultation with the client. The resultant information should then be transferred to Checklist 4 which will enable the information to be analysed and evaluated. The analysis can then be compared with the characteristics of each procurement method, and the associated risk so that an informed decision can finally be made.
CHECKLIST 1: TIME The following should be considered: 1.1 Is completion needed by a specific date? 1.2 Is completion needed in the shortest possible time? 1.3 Is the client prepared to pay more for earlier completion? 2. Does the answer to question 1.1 suggest a faster than ‘normal’ total project time in the judgement of the adviser? 3. How long is it in months from the date of completion of this protocol until the desired ‘move in’ date? 4. Define the reason for the identified completion or ‘move in’ date: 4.1 end of lease 4.2 sale of premises 4.3 new business opportunities 4.4 unsuitability of present premises 4.5 company restructuring 4.6 other. 5.1 Is the need for completion by a specific date or within a specific time more important than certainty of construction cost before work starts? 5.2 Is the need for completion by a specific date or within a specific time more important than spending an extended time on design? 6. What is the approximate value, in sterling, to the client of the building or facility in terms of contribution, rental or cost savings per month? 7. If the building is completed later than the specified or desired time will the client: 7.1 stay in existing premises? 7.2 find temporary accommodation? 7.3 close down? 7.4 don’t know.
Page 26
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
Upon the completion of this part, the following information should have been established and should be transferred to Checklist 4: 1(a) specified completion time; 1(b) reason for completion time; 1(c) whether required completion time is relatively fast; 1(d) whether time is seen as the predominant client need; 1(e) the potential financial implication of earlier or later completion; and 1(f) what action the client may take if the dates are not achieved. CHECKLIST 2: DESIGN/PERFORMANCE 1. Has the client clear ideas about building functionality and its desired design? 2. Does the site (if selected) pose any particular problems for the designer in respect of: 2.1 shape or topography? 2.2 access? 2.3 storage space? 3. Does the building type suggest relative design complexity? 4. Does the building type suggest emphasis upon functionality? 5. Does the building type suggest highly complex mechanical, electrical or engineering installations? 6. Is it anticipated that extensive changes to design may be required during the construction phase? 7. Does the client wish to particularly emphasise low running costs? 8. Does the client wish to particularly emphasise low maintenance costs? 9. Does the client wish to particularly emphasise product quality at a higher potential cost? Upon the completion of this part of the process, the following information should have been established and should be transferred to Checklist 4: 2(a) whether the client has clear ideas about his/her needs; 2(b) whether the site poses complex design problems; 2(c) whether the building design is complex; 2(d) whether functionality is particularly important; and 2(e) whether the client has a long-term view about the cost of the building.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 27
PART 3, SECTION 1
CHECKLIST 3: COST 1. What is the client’s maximum budget? 2. Can the budget be allocated as below? 2.1 land purchase and fees 2.2 construction, including fees 2.3 fittings and plant 2.4 contingencies 2.5 other (define). 3. Will the client need to have a fixed contract price for the construction element of his budget or will a reasonably accurate budget be adequate? Upon the completion of this part of the process, the following information should have been established and should be transferred to Checklist 4: 3(a) total maximum spending capacity; 3(b) total construction spending capacity; and 3(c) need for pre-construction cost certainty. CHECKLIST 4: ANALYSIS
•
•
As an overview, is the project feasible in terms of time and viable in terms of cost on the basis of the information in 1a, 2a, 2b, 2c, 3a, 3b, 3c? If yes, proceed. If no, advise client and seek other solutions. Is the reason given as to why it should be completed by the specified date vital to the project’s success in terms of client needs, or can slippage be coped with if cost is considered? See 1b, 1d, 2a, 2b, 2c, 3c. If vital, the project has to be carefully planned from a reasonably advanced design. Design and construction should be planned. Where design is completed, the completion date can be contractually fixed. Where design cannot be completed, fast-track systems can achieve relative speed by overlapping design and construction.
If relative speed is required can the client accept less cost certainty? See 1c, 3c. If yes, this may mean that fast-track approaches may be suitable. If no, a method of achieving cost certainty relatively quickly may be through negotiation. • Does the information provided indicate that the project is complex in terms of design or in terms of site-related problems? See 2b, 2c, 2d. If so, adequate time should be allowed for a design process to occur which will provide the client with an acceptable design solution.
Page 28
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
•
G
3.1.3.4
Some fast-track solutions will enable the design process to be extended into the construction phase where pre-construction time is not available. This will reduce cost certainty. Is the need to ensure that the project can be built within a budget a priority? See 3c. In this event, design should be complete before construction is commenced or a sufficiently large contingency should be allowed. The latter will not give cost certainty and may result in a less balanced project in financial terms.
CHECKLIST SUMMARY Having established whether the project is both feasible and viable, the importance of time, cost and design has now been reviewed. There is always an interrelationship between these three primary criteria and procurement systems selected should reflect this. Projects can probably be broadly categorised into those which will be design-led and those which will be production-led. Design-led projects usually reflect the characteristics of procurement systems where the client appoints his/her own design team; whereas production-led projects enable the constructor to take on some or all of the design function. Design-led projects have the greater capacity for cost and time overrun, whereas the potential capacity for design shortcomings may rest with production-led systems. System selection should consider whether the project is design or production-led but should also consider the client’s need to manage and/or distribute risk.
3.1.4 Implementation G
3.1.4.1
Having selected a procurement strategy for a project, the strategy should be successfully implemented. The client should implement the strategy but may do this with the advice of consultants or a project manager. In many cases they will carry out most or all of the necessary functions in achieving implementation and the client’s role will be to formally approve their actions. Notwithstanding the role of consultants or a project manager, the client should ensure that he/she puts in place the necessary resources, organisational structure, contractual arrangements, systems and controls necessary for a successful project outcome.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 29
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.4.2
IMPLEMENTATION POLICY Implementation of procurement strategy is a key role for the team and warrants sufficient thought and review. The policy developed to ensure appropriate implementation should be clearly communicated to all the key players. By ensuring that implementation policy is maintained, the client has a greater chance of obtaining the right project at the right time at the right cost with the minimum of conflict.
G
3.1.4.3
FINANCIAL RESOURCES (a) In this section, the funding function has been assumed to be a matter for the client. It is a vital function and by the time the procurement strategy is set, sufficient funding should be available at appropriate times in the pre-construction and construction process. (b) Funding requirements are usually a consequence of contractual agreements, whether they be agreements to purchase land, to design or to construct. It is possible to take account of each contractual agreement and to plan expenditure in the form of a cash flow. Useful advice in this context can be provided by the project manager or the project cost consultant. Both of these team members should be in place at an appropriate time to ensure that funding arrangements are appropriate.
G
3.1.4.4
HUMAN RESOURCES In terms of client organisation, the client should be prepared to allocate appropriate in-house personnel to the project or should be prepared to appoint consultants for this purpose. In most cases, consultants are appointed to design and cost a project, but a client will have his/her own staff member who will provide liaison and a focus for decisions. Where this is not possible the appointment of a project manager is desirable. Only one individual should have the authority to instruct those carrying out the design or construction on behalf of the client.
G
3.1.4.5
PHYSICAL RESOURCES (a) Where physical resources such as land, plant and machinery have to be provided by the client, it is self-evident that the client should ensure their availability in a suitable form at the right time. Where alternative accommodation is required, or where specific arrangements for decanting are necessary, this is a matter for the client and/or the client’s organisation although these are matters which can be handled by a project manager. (b) Design and construction resources must also be appropriately selected and in place at the right time. (c) The criteria for the selection of the design team are outlined below and are based upon the factors of capability, competence, staff and cost, with value for money, rather than cost being the major influence in selection.
Page 30
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
(d) The criteria for the selection of contractors are referred to below and are broadly the same, but this tends to be a much more complex process and the criteria are dependent upon the procurement strategy selected. The basis for selection of constructors can be price competition, based upon a fixed design and specification or can, in the case of design and build options, be based upon competition for design solutions too. Selection can also be by negotiation with one or two constructors, or can be based upon a two-stage process. Suitable documentation for the selection process must be prepared and the client should seek the advice of consultants or the project manager who may also be required to manage the process. (e) A number of Codes of Procedure for the selection process are available and are referred to in sections 3.1.4.8 and 3.1.4.9. G
3.1.4.6
ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE (a) The client has a dual management role, part of which is to manage the client input; to co-ordinate functional and administrative needs; to resolve conflicts; as well as to act as the formal point of contact for the project. (b) This will require the creation of an organisational structure for the life of the project to enable communication to occur and to facilitate effective decision-making. (c) The organisational structure created may be headed by a key member of the client organisation or may be headed by an imported project manager. Whichever choice is made, the designated member must have sole authority to communicate decisions to the project design and/or construction team. Where more than one individual is empowered to instruct, or to require changes, extreme confusion can take place. (d) Building users, specialists, facilities managers, maintenance staff, finance and accounts personnel, legal advisers and security personnel can all have input to the project through the created organisational structure by invitation, or right, and, as appropriate, can meet with designers or constructors to ensure effective communication; but decisions are reserved to the in-house executive or the project manager.
G
3.1.4.7
APPOINTMENT OF A PROJECT MANAGER (WHERE APPROPRIATE) (a) Due to the complexity of modern building and the potentially large number of parties involved in the process the client may wish to appoint a single person to draw the process together and manage it to ensure that the overall performance, time and cost requirements are achieved. The project manager may be a member of the client organisation who is given sole, or predominant, responsibility for the project. Project management practices also exist to enable appointments to be made on a consultancy basis. In this case, selection
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 31
PART 3, SECTION 1
should be based upon resources, reputation and price, and duties should be clearly identified. (b) It should be emphasised that the role of the project manager should be to act as part of the client organisation. (c) The client’s role upon the appointment of a project manager should include: • explaining the project objectives and their priorities, defining the project and outlining parameters associated with time, cost, performance and risk; • defining the criteria for control and management of the project; • managing the project manager’s performance of delegated responsibilities; • monitoring the implementation by the project manager of control and management systems; • ensuring that the project manager receives decisions on time; • assisting the project manager in the resolution of problems; • receiving and reviewing detailed reports on the project from the project manager; • establishing with the project manager a common approach to major issues which arise; and • maintaining with the project manager at all times an overview of the project status in relation to the established objectives. (d) The client’s relationship with a project manager will be crucial to the success of the project and will require careful development and nurturing within the following guidelines: • the client, though taking the project manager’s advice should lead, not follow; • no matter how much responsibility is delegated to the project manager, the client will retain ultimate authority and therefore must have adequate knowledge and information about the project to be able to exercise the authority properly; • the client should agree with the project manager the precise extent of any delegated authority together with those decisions reserved for the client; • where a project manager has been appointed the client should not formally communicate directly with consultants and contractors employed on the project – such communications will always be routed through the project manager, although the contracts will be direct with the client; • no matter what may be said in private, the client should publicly support the project manager and avoid any actions which could undermine that manager’s authority over the consultants and contractors.
Page 32
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
G
3.1.4.8
APPOINTMENT OF CONSULTANTS (a) The process of selecting and appointing the design team and the cost consultant is carried out by the client but he/she may seek the advice of his/her adviser. The terms and conditions of these appointments are governed by the procurement strategy adopted for the project. (The client is also required under the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 1994 to appoint a competent planning supervisor to ensure that the design team have met their responsibilities under these regulations and to advise the client and the constructors how they can comply.) (b) The following alternatives exist in selecting the design team: • single appointment – either of a multi-discipline firm which can itself provide the full range of architectural and engineering design services required, or of a lead consultant, normally the architect on building projects, who will subcontract design of other disciplines to independent professional firms and be responsible for their work and its co-ordination; or • separate appointments – for each of the design disciplines required, one firm being appointed design team leader with the responsibility for co-ordinating the work carried out by the others. The former has the benefit of administrative simplicity and of single source responsibility for design. The latter offers the chance of selecting the best firm in each discipline but makes communication more difficult. The final selection will depend on the particular features of the project. (c) The selection of the design team and the cost consultant (and other consultants as appropriate) will require the client to make a balanced judgement on the following factors: • capability – the experience of the firm in projects of similar size and function and the availability within the firm of sufficient uncommitted resources for it to meet the demands of the project; the demands of the project programme may be particularly important; • competence – the performance of the firm on past projects, to be ascertained by detailed, confidential references from past clients; efficient performance by design consultants cannot be taken for granted; • staff – the personal capability and experience of the key staff whom the firm proposes to employ on the project; and • the cost – quoted by the firm, unless large differences exist between offers from competing firms this should not be critical. (d) Value for money, not lowest price, should be the aim in the selection of design team members.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 33
PART 3, SECTION 1
(e) Guidelines for the value assessment of competitive tenders in the procurement of professional services are available1. (f) Fees payable to professional consultants may be expressed in one of the following ways: • as a percentage of the construction cost of the project; • as a lump sum; • on a time charge basis; or • a permutation of all three. (g) Percentage fees based on the out-turn construction cost are not generally recommended as they increase when cost overruns occur. (h) Lump sum fees may be the most satisfactory form of remuneration provided only that the scope, value and timescale of the project can be established with reasonable accuracy before the appointments are made and that the services to be provided by the consultants can be accurately defined. Where lump sum fees are to be paid, the client will need to establish systems for monitoring the consultants’ performance to ensure that they provide the full, specified service and do not skimp their services to save money. (i) Where time charge fees are to be paid, the final amount of fees payable is not fixed and there is a substantial risk that this amount may exceed initial estimates. G
3.1.4.9
APPOINTMENT OF CONSTRUCTORS (a) The client is responsible under the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 1994 to be reasonably satisfied that the constructors appointed are competent and have adequate resources. (b) The timing of the need to appoint constructors (whether contractors or trade contractors) will be dependent upon the procurement strategy which is selected, but the client will have a formal role in this process. The client’s role will include selecting those constructors with whom he will negotiate or who will be invited to tender. In the case of the latter, it will be the client who formally selects the constructor(s) to carry out the work and then contracts with this company. (c) Assistance with the selection, documentation for tender and advice in relation to contract issues can be obtained by the client from professional advisers and particularly the principal adviser. There are a number of codes of procedure to assist in this process, of particular assistance is the Code of Practice for the Selection of Main Contractors2 which has been approved by the National Audit Office. In broad terms, the factors which affect the
1
Construction Industry Board, Selecting Consultants for the Team: balancing quality and price, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1996. 2 Construction Industry Board, Code of Practice for the Selection of Main Contractors, Thomas Telford Publishing, London, 1997.
Page 34
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
selection of design and cost consultants shown above (capability, competence, staffing and cost) will affect the choice of constructors, but the documents on which selection is made (particularly for cost) can be extensive and very complex. (d) European Union legislation has an effect on the procurement of public works and the supply of services in the public sector. Usually this relates to projects over about ¤5 million and requires appropriate tender advertising and selection. Clients from the public sector must be aware of the existence of and the procedures demanded by such regulations. (e) As with the selection of design and cost consultants, value for money, rather than lowest price should be the aim in the selection of constructors. Where clients regularly build, there may be a case for considering a special arrangement with a construction firm as indicated in 3.1.1.15. G
3.1.4.10
CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS (a) Having selected an appropriate procurement strategy and methods of consultant and constructor selection, this strategy should be implemented by a range of contractual arrangements. Many of these arrangements will be based upon standard forms of agreement in common use in the construction industry. The distribution of major project risks results from the wording of the contract selected. Most clients will need specialist advice on contract selection. This is outside the remit of this handbook.
G
3.1.4.11
SYSTEMS AND CONTROLS (a) Once resources, organisational and contractual arrangements are in place, the client should see that systems are put in place to ensure that the procurement process can be implemented in fact. (b) These systems should include: • financial systems to ensure that payments are made in accordance with contract agreements; • decision systems to ensure that decisions made are communicated at the appropriate time and with appropriate authority; • design change systems to implement and monitor change as it becomes necessary; and • cost and time monitoring systems to inform the client of the current position at any point in time. This may mean delegating elements of the process to the project manager (if appointed) or ensuring that existing company systems are specifically adapted.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 35
PART 3, SECTION 1
(c) Controls are also important to ensure that cost is controlled within budget, pace is controlled within programme, quality is controlled within standards set, and systems are properly employed. (d) Cost control can be achieved by ensuring appropriate pre-construction cost planning and an adequate system of regular cost reporting. These services can be provided by the cost consultant. (e) Pace can be monitored against a programme or time plan and can be controlled by the imposition of contract completion dates. Programming can be provided by a project manager or developed with the advice of the principal adviser. (f) Quality can be controlled through the provision of a sound contractual specification. It may be appropriate to appoint a clerk of works to inspect the works during progress and to ensure that work is satisfactory and matches the specification. (g) Controlling the client systems to ensure that they are appropriately applied and not abused is a matter for the client’s management team – perhaps this is the key management input from the client. G
3.1.4.12
DESIGN OVERVIEW (a) While responsibility for achieving a successful design solution to the client’s requirements lies chiefly with the designer, the responsibility rests with the client both for ensuring that his/her needs are met and for the impact of such development on the local environment. The blame for a poor building is likely to be ascribed to the client as well as to the designer. Equally, a well-designed building reflects credit on those who commissioned it as well as on the designers who conceived it. (b) Design is an important factor in ensuring good working conditions for staff and convenience for members of the public who need to visit the building. A well-designed building is a good investment. Good design can contribute to economy and efficiency – by efficient layout and economical use of space, by energy efficiency (in heating, insulation, mechanical services, etc.) by low maintenance costs, and by ensuring flexibility to meet changing requirements. (c) No one person has all the design skills for any but the very simplest project and therefore the collaboration of many designers will be necessary. This is particularly the case in specialist buildings or buildings which have sophisticated mechanical and/or electrical installations. (d) The formulation of an accurate design brief and the development of design in strict accordance with that brief are key processes for the client (or the project manager) to oversee. In practical terms, the client will require:
Page 36
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
• close collaboration between users and the design team in the development of the design; • formal checking that the developed design meets, but does not exceed, the requirements of the design brief; and • formal presentation of developed designs to the users and formal sign-off by the client. (e) It will also prove valuable for the client to indicate clearly his/her intentions in respect of the programme and for the design team to respond in terms of their strategy for meeting this programme. Methods for updating progress should also be sought by the client. (f) As the majority of users, and indeed the client, are likely to find the reading and interpretation of design drawings a difficult task, it is important to ensure that the design team present their proposals in a form that can be readily understood. (Computer aided design [CAD] may enable three dimensional presentation.) The setting of the design and not just the design in isolation should be taken into account. The client should feel able to say ‘no’ and ‘try again’ and to expect alternatives within the fee. G
3.1.4.13
COST CONTROL OVERVIEW (It is recommended that this be read in conjunction with Part 1, Section 1.) (a) It is essential that the client understands the difference between: • estimating – giving an informed opinion at a particular time of what the final cost of the project is likely to be; and • cost control – managing the consequences of the design and construction processes so as to achieve value for money and ensure that the final cost does not exceed the budget. Estimates cannot be expected to be proved accurate unless they are based upon reliable data and cost control is exercised. (b) The techniques used to produce estimates vary according to the type and level of data available when they are prepared. The general level of estimating accuracy improves as the design of a project develops. Notwithstanding this progressive improvement in accuracy, provided that cost control is being exercised, the general level of accuracy of early estimates can be stated with sufficient precision for them to be valid parameters for decision making and for the management of the project. (c) For estimates to be effective, the client should require that all estimates are supported by: • a risk analysis – an assessment of the potential risks, their probability and the associated time and cost consequences if they should occur; and • a sensitivity analysis – a statement of the comparative effects on the total estimate of changes to principal data and assumptions on which the estimate is based.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 37
PART 3, SECTION 1
(d) The amount included in estimates to cover the uncertain cost of risks based on the analyses described above is known as the contingency. It is important that contingencies are sufficient to cover risks and are not eroded to facilitate any lack of cost control. (e) A primary concern may be the cost of running and maintaining the building. The term ‘cost-in-use’ is used to describe how these costs can be estimated, enabling the client to take these matters into account when considering total project costs and building design. In some cases higher initial costs will result in lower running or maintenance costs during the life of the building. (f) The earlier cost control procedures are instituted, the more effective they will be. By way of simplistic illustration: • cost varies with (but not in direct proportion to) size: once the size of a building is fixed, so is the general level of cost; • the selection of the most economical design for basic elements such as foundations, structural frame, external cladding and roofing, is of far greater cost significance than the types of finishings; and • the overall cost of mechanical and electrical systems and the effectiveness of the cost control procedures which can be applied to them is largely governed by early decisions as to the type of system selected. (g) The methods used for cost control differ radically between the pre-construction and construction stages of a project. Cost control during the former depends partly on formulating an appropriate procurement strategy but more on controlling the design process within that strategy; during the latter it is a function of effective management and avoidance of change after commitment. (h) Pre-construction cost control, in simple terms, comprises: • preparing a cost plan – an allocation of the control budget into cost centres which match readily identifiable elements of expenditure, with allowances for contingencies, reserves for changes in market prices and the like; and • cost checking each element as it is designed against its allowance in the cost plan. If the cost of an element as designed exceeds its allowance in the cost plan, the excess can only be corrected by: • redesigning the element to reduce its cost; or • transferring money into that element from contingencies or from another element yet to be designed.
Page 38
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
If neither is done, the control budget will be exceeded. (i) Successful cost control during the construction stage depends on: • ensuring that all design work is completed and fully co-ordinated before any commitment to construct is made (this applies in a progressive way when design and construction overlap); • administering the contract efficiently and promptly in strict accordance with its terms and conditions; and • minimising changes to the design, for any reason, after construction has started. (j) Regular cost reports can be produced throughout the construction stage from which potential overspending can be identified before it occurs with the intent that corrective action should be possible. The client should, however, recognise that such corrective action is not always beneficial, since: • cost savings can be made only by reductions in standards or by omissions of part of the work remaining to be finalised, that is largely in the visible finishings and fittings, with the resultant possibility that the requirements of the brief will not be met; and • late cost savings are inefficient as any amount saved will be reduced or may be negated by the costs of disruption inherent in making the changes needed to generate the savings. (k) All estimates and cost control procedures should take account of inflation, i.e. the increase in construction cost from the date when the estimate is prepared to the date when the work will be carried out. It is essential for effective cost control that: • allowances should be made for inflation in all estimates and that the assumptions on which such allowances were calculated be stated; • these allowances for inflation should be clearly identified within the estimates and not be allowed to be used to correct other overspending; • the assumptions on which inflation allowances are calculated be reviewed as each new estimate is prepared and the allowances corrected in accordance with such reviews; and • a clear policy and method for drawing down inflation reserves be established and observed. (l) The client should distinguish between inflation and the effect on construction prices of market conditions at the time of tender. In simple terms, contractors adjust their tender prices by reducing or increasing their target profit margins in accordance with their need to obtain new work. It is unwise to base early estimates on an assumption of favourable market conditions at the time of tender as the construction industry is subject to wide, comparatively swift, changes in workload in accordance with economic conditions. (m) Things will go wrong on the project. The unexpected will happen. Such unforeseen happenings are covered in the cost control system by the The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 39
PART 3, SECTION 1
contingency. The client should develop a policy for management of contingency funds to ensure that, at all times in the project, the remaining contingencies match the remaining risks. The client may also establish and control a client reserve, not disclosed to the consultants or the contractors, to cover late changes in user requirements and unforeseeable third party events. G
3.1.4.14
TIME CONTROL OVERVIEW (a) The overall programme of activities which will constitute the project should be developed at a very early stage in the procurement cycle. This programme will form the time framework within which the designers and the constructors should complete their activities, and within which other key stages, such as land purchase, funding and planning permission should be completed. (b) The programme of activities should be feasible and realistic. Insufficient design time will have an effect upon client risk as will insufficient time allowed for construction. (c) The client should be aware of those tasks which are vital to completion on time and those tasks where some flexibility may be available. Time for the approval processes should be included as specific activities in the time plan for the project. These are invariably vital as the need to obtain approval is likely to be a prerequisite to further work on the project proceeding. (d) The process of time control is in many ways analogous to that of cost control. Thus a time control system can embrace: • time budget – the overall project duration as fixed either by specific constraints or by the selected procurement strategy; the period which, once fixed, becomes a key parameter for management of the project; • time plan – the division of total time into inter-linked time allowances for readily identifiable activities with definable start and finish points; the overall project programme; and • time checking – monitoring closely actual time spent on each activity against the allowance in the time plan; reporting divergence as soon as it is observed. (e) If the time taken for an activity exceeds its time allowance there are essentially only two forms of corrective action available: • the re-sequencing of later activities, which may involve abandoning low priority restraints and/or phased transitions from earlier activities to later activities logically following them; or • shortening the time allowance for future activities by increasing the resources to be made available for them.
Page 40
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
If neither is done, the overall time budget will be exceeded and the project will finish late. (f) The client should recognise that time control is as important during the design stages of the project as the construction stage. Designers should work to a series of deadlines at which different elements of the design should be agreed (i.e. frozen) if costs and the overall programme are to be kept under control. (g) The client should consider developing (with the help of the project manager if appointed) a time contingency (reserve), with strict procedures for allocating the reserve to specific events. This concept is essential on projects which are subject to external time constraints, for example, where a building has to be available for occupation before the lease on another building expires. (h) The client should take account at all times of fundamental relationships between time, quality and cost: • any extension of the overall timescale for a project always generates additional costs to either constructor or client; every project contains time-related costs whether these are openly stated or not. Who carries such additional costs depends on the detailed contractual arrangements between the parties; it is likely that some of them will be borne by the client; and • making up lost time by re-sequencing later activities may be achievable but often only at the risk of compromising quality or cost control. G
3.1.4.15
WHOLE-LIFE COSTS (a) In addition to considering project cost purely in terms of initial capital costs the client may wish to consider costs over the projected life of the building. Such considerations may review higher initial costs against lower running costs or longer life to replacement or maintenance. This may be of particular impact where shorter-life inherent assets, such as mechanical or electrical equipment, or where planned maintenance or energy consumption, are being considered. (b) The techniques associated with whole-life costing are often complex and predictive. The project manager or project cost consultant will be able to advise the client of the availability of their application in each case.
G
3.1.4.16
VALUE MANAGEMENT (a) Value management is usually reserved for relatively complex projects where value for money is important and concerned with defining what ‘value’ means to the client in meeting a particular need. In general, any project seeks to satisfy the differing requirements of several parties. Value management provides a structured framework for the examination and discussion of these requirements to reach a consensus before the project brief is finalised. It is
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 41
PART 3, SECTION 1
used to ensure that the need for and scope of any construction is thoroughly analysed before any further commitment to proceed is made. The aim is to establish a clear statement of a project’s objectives matched to their relative values. (b) Value management is usually carried out at the concept and feasibility stages of a project. The aim is to ensure that: • a project is commissioned in response to a careful analysis of balance of needs; • a wide range of options and alternatives to meet that need is considered; and • the project objectives are made explicit and are commonly understood by all parties. (c) The client may wish to appoint a professional adviser experienced in these techniques and who will provide support in writing the objectives and subsequent brief. G
3.1.4.17
VALUE ENGINEERING (a) This occurs later in the development of the project and is concerned with how value is achieved rather than what the relative values are as defined in the project brief and objectives. (b) Value engineering studies are pre-planned, formal reviews of the design philosophy and the detailed solutions at one or more stages of the design development. They are sometimes carried out by firms or individuals not connected with or employed on the project and are short exercises intended to review the detailed design solutions against the objectives and to establish whether they can be achieved in a more cost effective manner.
G
3.1.4.18
QUALITY CONTROL OVERVIEW (a) The final quality of the project is governed, progressively, by: • the project brief – a clear statement of the standards of quality required; great care is needed to ensure that this standard is unambiguous, such phrases as ‘the highest quality attainable within the control budget’ should be avoided; • the original design – the adequacy of the components selected for the building; the interface between related components and systems; the integration of mechanical and electrical systems into the overall design; the completeness of design before construction starts; • specification – the conversion of the quality standard demanded by the project brief into precise requirements for both the supply and the installation of materials, components and systems; the setting out of criteria against which the standard of the finished work will be judged, e.g. by reference to standards, codes of practice or the like;
Page 42
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1
• quality control – setting up control mechanisms to apply to the execution of the work on site; the detailed, on-going supervision by the contractor; the programmes for testing; the procedures for rectifying any defective work; and • inspection – the independent inspection and verification of the contractor’s work by the design team; procedures for witnessing tests, for commissioning plant and systems, for pre-completion inspection for defects lists and defect rectification and for final hand over. (b) The client may choose to appoint a clerk of works whose function is to act as an inspector of work done to ensure quality, but who should recognise that inspection and verification is the last line of defence. The key to quality control on site is to specify clearly, and to monitor closely, the quality control activities carried out by the contractor while work is being done. (c) Many construction companies and firms of consultants within the building industry have adopted, or are in the process of adopting, formal quality assurance systems for their own work or services in accordance with ISO 9000 or equivalent standard. G
3.1.4.19
CHANGE CONTROL OVERVIEW (a) Clients should aim to make no changes once a particular design feature has been decided because these are one of the more significant causes of cost and time overruns in construction projects. The avoidance of change should be a prime objective of the project strategy. If changes are unavoidable, they should be dealt with as described in the paragraphs below. (b) Client changes (as distinct from design development) are changes which are made either by: • the design team, with the approval of the client, to a design feature which, it has been decided, should be frozen, or ‘improved’, or altered to overcome design errors and inconsistencies; or • the client after the design brief has been agreed. The most significant of these are changes to the scope of the works. (c) Client changes can be relatively minor, such as adding a few extra power points, or can have major cost implications, such as the addition of an extra storey. (d) The cost of client changes depends on when they are made: • before the construction contract has been let, the cost can be contained to that of the changed feature itself, and perhaps some relatively small resource cost; and • after the construction contract has been let, the cost will be disproportionate to the value of the change, it can disrupt the contractor’s work and invariably gives rise to a higher cost than if the change had been included in the contract as let. Many minor changes
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 43
PART 3, SECTION 1
can have a cumulative and serious effect. Disruption claims caused by a large number of small changes are common. (e) Some client changes are unavoidable. Examples of such changes are: • compliance with changes in legislation; • requirements of the health and safety or fire prevention authorities; • those required by unforeseen ground conditions; and • previously unforeseen users’ requirements. (f) The contingency in the project budget should be sufficient to take account of the likelihood of such changes based on risk assessments. (g) Changes proposed prior to construction may either be unavoidable or optional. If they are unavoidable, the client, if satisfied that they are, should authorise a transfer from the contingency in the budget to cover them. If they are optional they should be approved if it can be demonstrated that they offer good value for money (or a saving) and that there are sufficient funds available to pay for them. (h) Changes proposed after the construction contract has been let can have major time and cost implications and should be avoided if at all possible. If they are not essential they should be deferred until the project is complete and then reviewed to see if they are necessary and economically justified. (i) The need for changes should be minimised by: • ensuring, with the assistance of an experienced project team and designers, that the project brief is as comprehensive as possible and the users have ‘signed it off’; • taking into account any proposed new legislation; • having early discussions with outside authorities so as to anticipate their requirements; • undertaking adequate site investigation or condition surveys1 if existing buildings are to be renovated; • ensuring that designs are fully developed and co-ordinated before construction contracts are committed; and • imposing discipline on users to finalise and sign off their requirements in strict accordance with the project programme. (j) When changes do occur, the client should call for: • the reasons for the change; • the source of the change; • the full cost and time consequence of the change; • proposals for avoiding or mitigating time overrun; and • source of funding of any cost overrun, e.g. contingencies, client cost reserves, compensating savings elsewhere. 1
Page 44
Stock Condition Surveys, RICS Guidance Note, RICS Books, Coventry, 1997.
Part 3, Section 1 (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
Appendix A: Procurement Options A1
TRADITIONAL (SEQUENTIAL) (a) Under a traditional procurement strategy, design should be completed before tenders are invited and before the main construction contract is let. As a result, and assuming no changes are introduced, construction costs can be determined with reasonable certainty before construction starts and a completion date can be fixed. In most cases the price is established on the basis of tender documentation, often including a bill of quantities which describes the extent of work to be done. (b) The contractor assumes responsibility and financial risks for the building works as described whilst the client takes the responsibility and risk for design team performance. Therefore, if the contractor’s works are delayed by the failure of the design team to meet their obligations, the contractor may claim against the client for additional costs and/or time to complete the project. In turn, the client could possibly seek to recover these costs from the design team members responsible, if negligence can be proven. (c) Clients are able to influence the development of the design to meet their requirements because they have direct contractual relationships with the design team. When construction begins, they usually have a single contractual relationship with a main contractor and are therefore able to influence (but not control) the construction process through a single point of contact. (d) The strategy is unfortunately open to a level of abuse if any attempt is made to let the work before the design is complete. Such action may result in many post-contract changes which could delay the progress of the works and increase the costs. Where a traditional strategy is chosen because of its particular advantages, the temptation to let the work begin before the design is complete should be strongly resisted. (e) It is possible to have an accelerated traditional procurement strategy where some design overlaps construction. This can be achieved by letting a separate, advance works contract, for example, by allowing ground works (site clearance, piling and foundations) to proceed to construction whilst the design for the rest of the building is completed, and the construction tendered separately. This reduces the total time to complete the project at the risk of losing certainty of cost before construction starts. More importantly, a substantial risk is created in that the contractor who builds the superstructure will take no responsibility for the foundation works carried out by another contractor. (f) Another alternative is to let the work by a two-stage process or by negotiation thus reducing the pre-construction time involved and enabling the contractor to have some (limited) involvement in the design and planning stage.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 1
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
FIGURE A1 PROCUREMENT ARRANGE MENT – TRADITIONAL CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIP
CLIENT
CONSULTANTS (fee contracts)
MAIN CONTRACTOR (standard lump sum contract)
ARCHITECT (fee contract)
SUPPLIERS (various contracts) SUBCONTRACTORS (standard lump sum)
administrative responsibility on behalf of the client
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
competitive fairness
slow to start on site (no parallel working)
satisfactory public accountability
open to abuse where design incomplete (resulting in less certainty)
procedures well known changes reasonably easily arranged
contractor not involved in design or planning (no buildability)
and valued
adversarial potential SEQUENCE brief
design
competition
construction
Risk Low cost risk due to lump sum contract Medium time risk due to fixed contract date (but contractor has right to claim extensions) Low quality/design risk where the majority of the work is designed by insured consultants working directly for the client
(g) The organisational structure of a traditional strategy is shown in Figure A1. Standard forms of contract are available. (h) The main advantages of a traditional contract strategy are: • competitive fairness; • design-led, facilitating high level of quality in design; • reasonable price certainty at contract award based upon market forces; • the strategy is satisfactory in terms of public accountability; • the procedure is well known; and • changes are reasonably easy to arrange and value.
Page 2
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
(i) The main disadvantages are: • the strategy is open to abuse, resulting in less certainty; • the overall programme may be longer than for other strategies as there is no parallel working; • no ‘buildability’ input by contractor; and • the strategy often results in adversarial relationships developing. A2
MEASUREMENT CONTRACTS Measurement contracts are used when the work required cannot be accurately measured for the tender bill of quantities. The contract sum is only established with certainty on completion of construction, when re-measurement of the quantities of work actually carried out takes place and is then valued on an agreed basis. Measurement contracts are sometimes referred to as re-measurement contracts and are based upon the prices tendered by the contractor. The most effective use of a measurement contract is where the work has been substantially designed but final detail has not been completed. Here, a tender based on drawings and a bill of approximate quantities will be satisfactory. Measurement contracts allow a client to shorten the overall programme for design, tendering and construction but usually with the result of some lack of price certainty at contract stage because the approximate quantities reflect the lack of information on exactly what is to be built at tender stage. The scope of the work, the approximate price and a programme should be clear at contract stage. Measurement contracts provide more risk than lump sum contracts for the client but probably with programme advantages. They are typically used with civil engineering works where there can be significant uncertainty about ground conditions. (b) The organisational structure of a measurement contract strategy is shown in Figure A2. Standard forms of contract are available for this strategy. (c) The main advantages of the measurement contract strategy include: • pre-construction time-saving potential; • competitive prices; • average public accountability; • the procedure is well known; • the strategy enables changes to be made easily; and • there is some parallel working possible. (d) The main disadvantages of the strategy are: • the strategy offers poor certainty of price; • there is no contractor involvement in the planning or design stage; and • there is a potential for adversarial relationships to develop.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 3
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
FIGURE A2 PROCUREMENT ARRANGE MENT – ME ASUREME NT CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENT
CLIENT
CONSULTANTS (fee contracts)
MAIN CONTRACTOR (standard measurement contract)
ARCHITECT
SUPPLIERS (various contracts) SUBCONTRACTORS (standard contracts)
administrative responsibility on behalf of the client ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
pre-construction time saving potential competitive prices average public accountability procedures well known easy to arrange changes some parallel working
low certainty of price potential no contractor involvement in planning or design potentially adversarial
SEQUENCE
brief
design competition
construction
Risk Variable cost risk as the final figure will be uncertain until the design and often construction is complete Medium time risk as the extent of work will vary and contractors can claim extensions to the period for construction Medium quality/design risk in the sense that design may not be complete at the outset
A3
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT (a) Under a construction management strategy, the client does not allocate risk and responsibility to a single main contractor. Instead, the client employs the design team and a construction manager is engaged as a fee-earning professional to programme and co-ordinate the design and construction activities and to improve the buildability of the design. Construction work is carried out by trade contractors through direct contracts with the client for distinct trade or work packages. The construction manager supervises the construction management process and co-ordinates the design team on behalf of the client. The construction manager, who has no contractual links with the
Page 4
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
design team or the trade contractors, provides professional construction management expertise without assuming financial risk, and is liable only for negligence by failing to perform the role with reasonable skill and care, unless some greater liability is incorporated into the contract. (b) On appointment, the construction manager will take over any preliminary schedule and costing information already prepared and draw up a detailed programme of pre-construction activities. Key dates are normally inserted at which client decisions will be required. In adopting the construction management system, the client will be closely involved in each stage of design and construction. The client should have administrative or project management staff with the time and ability to assess the recommendations of the construction manager and take the necessary action. The client needs to maintain a strong presence through a project management team that is technically and commercially astute. This strategy is not, therefore, suitable for the inexpert or inexperienced client. (c) With this contract strategy, design and construction can overlap. As this speeds up the project, construction management is known as a ‘fast track’ strategy. Although the time for completion can be reduced, price certainty is not achieved until the design and construction have advanced to the extent that all the construction work (trade) packages have been let. Also, design development of later packages can affect construction work already completed. The construction manager should therefore have a good track record in cost forecasting and cost management. A package is made up of work for which one of the trade contractors is responsible, e.g. foundations, concrete, electrical installation or decorating. These packages are tendered individually, for a lump sum price, usually on the basis of drawings and specification. (d) The Latham Review1 recognised that construction management has been used predominantly for large and/or complex projects, but suggested that there is no intrinsic reason for this. Indeed, it is particularly recommended for projects where there is a high degree of design innovation, where the client wants ‘hands on’ involvement. (e) The organisational structure of a construction management strategy is shown in Figure A3. (f) The main advantages of a construction management strategy are: • the strategy offers time-saving potential for overall project time due to the overlapping of procedures; • buildability potential is inherent; • the breakdown of traditional adversarial barriers; • parallel working is an inherent feature; • clarity of roles, risks, and relationships for all participants;
1
Latham, M., Sir, Constructing the Team: Joint Review of Procurement and Contractual Arrangements in the United Kingdom Construction Industry: Final Report, HMSO, London, 1994.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 5
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
FIGURE A3 PROCUREMENT ARR ANGEMENT – CON STRUC TION MAN AGEM EN T CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENT
CLIENT Fee contracts
CONSULTANTS including Lump sum contracts
CONSTRUCTION MANAGER
WORK or TRADE CONTRACTORS
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
time saving potential for overall project time
no cost certainty at outset
trade packages let competitively
needs informed client, able to take an
buildability potential
active part
breaks down traditional adversarial barriers
needs a good quality brief
parallel working inherent
relies on a good quality team
clarity of roles, risks and relationships for
needs time and information control
all participants late changes easily accommodated
SEQUENCE
brief
design construction
Risk Medium cost risk since the actual cost is unknown until the last package is let Medium time risk since no one organisation carries the risk for timed completion Low quality/design risk because there is a close link between client, designers and constructors
• changes in design can be accommodated later than some other strategies, without paying a premium, provided the relevant trade packages have not been let and earlier awarded packages are not too adversely affected; and • the client has direct contracts with trade contractors and pays them directly. (There is some evidence that this results in lower prices because of improved cash flow certainty.)
Page 6
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
(g) The disadvantages are: • price certainty is not achieved until the last trade packages have been let; • an informed, proactive client is required in order to operate such a strategy; • the client must provide a good quality brief; • the strategy relies upon the client having a good quality team; and • time and information control is required. A4
MANAGEMENT CONTRACTING (a) With this contract strategy, a management contractor is engaged by the client to manage the building process and is paid a fee. The management contractor is responsible for all the construction works and has direct contractual links with all the works contractors. The management contractor therefore bears the responsibility for the construction works without actually carrying out any of that work. The management contractor may provide some of the common services on site, such as office accommodation, tower cranes, hoists and security, which are shared by the works contractors. The client employs the design team and therefore bears the risk of the design team delaying construction for reasons other than negligence. (b) Management contracting is a ‘fast track’ strategy. All design work will not be complete before the first works contractors start work although the design necessary for those packages must be complete. As design is completed subsequent packages of work are tendered and let. Cost certainty is thus not achieved until all works contractors have been appointed. A high level of cost management is therefore required. (c) With the agreement of the client, the management contractor selects works contractors by competitive tender to undertake sections of the construction work. The client reimburses the cost of these work packages to the management contractor who, in turn, pays the works contractors. The management contractor co-ordinates the release of information from the design team to the works contractors. (d) Where the management construction team is not of the highest quality, or where this fee is inadequate, the management contractor can be less than proactive and the system can become a reactive ‘postbox’ approach. It is therefore vital to select the management contractor carefully and to ensure that the fee is appropriate bearing in mind market conditions. Similarly, resistance to works contractors’ claims can be affected by the same circumstances. (e) The organisational structure of a management contract is shown in Figure A4. (f) The main advantages of a management contracting strategy are: • time-saving potential for overall project time; • buildability potential;
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 7
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
FIGURE A4 PROCUREMENT ARR ANGEMEN T – MA NAGEMENT C ON TRAC TING CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENT
CLIENT
MAIN CONTRACTOR (standard fee contract) CONSULTANTS (fee contracts)
WORKS CONTRACTORS (standard lump sum contracts)
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
time saving potential for overall project time
need for good quality brief
buildability potential
poor certainty of price
breaks down traditional adversarial barriers
relies on a good quality team
parallel working inherent
may become no more than a ‘postbox’
late changes easily accommodated work packages let competitively
system in certain circumstances removes resistance to works contractors’ claims
SEQUENCE
brief
design construction
Risk Medium cost risk since the actual cost is unknown until the last package is let Medium time risk since total construction time is a consequence of package selection Low quality/design risk because there is a close link between client, designers and constructors
• breaks down traditional adversarial barriers; • parallel working is inherent; • changes can be accommodated provided packages affected have not been let and there is little or no impact on those already let; and • works packages are let competitively. (g) The disadvantages are: • need for a good quality brief; • poor certainty of price is offered; Page 8
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
• relies on a good quality team; • it may become no more than a ‘postbox’ system in certain circumstances; and • removes resistance to works contractors’ claims. A5
DESIGN AND MANAGE (a) A design and manage strategy is similar to management contracting. Under a design and manage contract, the contractor is paid a fee to manage and assume responsibility, not only for the works contractors, but also for the design team. (b) The main advantages of a design and manage strategy are: • early completion is possible because of overlapping activities; • the client deals with one firm only; • it can be applied to a complex building; and • the contractor assumes the risk and responsibility for the integration of the design with construction. (c) The disadvantages are: • price certainty is not achieved until the last work package has been let; • the client loses direct control over the design quality; and • the client has no direct contractual relationship with the works contractors or the design team and it is therefore difficult for the client to recover costs if they fail to meet their obligations.
A6
DESIGN AND BUILD (a) Under a design and build strategy, a single contractor assumes the risk and responsibility for designing and building the project, in return for a fixed-price lump sum. (b) A variant, known as ‘develop and construct’, describes the strategy when the client appoints designers to prepare the concept design before the contractor assumes responsibility for completing the detailed design and constructing the works. Often this strategy is associated with a process where the contractor takes over the client’s designer (architect) contract in a form of ‘contract switch’ or novation. The designer is then employed for the rest of the contract by the contractor who is usually responsible for all of the design including that done prior to the switch. (c) Design and build is a fast-track strategy. Construction can start before all the detailed design is completed, but at the contractor’s risk. (d) As explained in 3.1.1, by transferring risk to the contractor, the client loses some control over the project. Any client requirement which is not directly specified in the tender documents will constitute a change or variation to the contract. Changes are usually more expensive to introduce after the contract has been let, compared with other types of strategy.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 9
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
(e) It is very important, therefore, that the brief and performance/quality specifications for important requirements in the project are fully and unambiguously defined before entering into this type of contract. If requirements are not specific, the client should provide contractors with a performance specification at tender stage. (f) The contractor develops the design from the specification submitting detailed proposals to the client to establish that they are in accordance with the requirements of the specification. Clients are, therefore, in a strong position to ensure that their interpretation of the specification takes preference over the contractor’s. (g) Specification is a dangerous area for inexperienced clients: over-specification can cut out useful specialist experience; under-specification can be exploited. (h) The client will often employ a design team to carry out some preliminary design and prepare the project brief and other tender documents. Sometimes the successful contractor will assume responsibility for this design team and use them to produce the detailed design. If a design and build strategy is identified as a possibility at an early stage, then the basis of the appointment of the design team should reflect this possibility. If it does not, the client may have to pay a termination fee to the design team. The client may wish to retain the independent services of a cost consultant throughout the contract for early cost advice involvement in the bidding process and cost reporting during construction. (i) Consideration may need to be given to the inclusion of a special clause in design, or design and build, type contracts to ensure that the responsibility for design performance is properly shared. Such a clause should identify specific obligations that are absolute, that do not require the designer to be an expert in the client’s business and, as a consequence, are reasonably insurable. (j) Current forms of contract for design and build vary their treatment of design liability. (k) To be effective, the client’s requirements will need to be stated clearly and accurately and delivered on time. (l) The imposition on contractors of fitness for purpose in design is usually expressly excluded in standard forms of contract and it is a matter of judgement for clients and their professional advisers, even though tenderers in recessionary markets are likely to agree to undertake such risks. (m) Non-availability of insurance to cover a higher than normal risk should be weighed against the financial ability of contractors to meet design default claims. It will normally be preferable and represent better value for Page 10
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
money to impose a lesser, yet insurable, liability, which will be the subject of an insurance payout in the event of a design fault, rather than an insurance fitness for purpose requirement on a contractor of limited financial assets. Most importantly the client should ensure that adequate design liability insurance is in place and maintained for the period of liability. (n) Increasingly, collateral warranties are being used to place additional responsibility on designers or subcontractors. In addition, the client may take out insurance to cover post-construction liability, but this will be at a cost. This is a matter for specialist advice. (o) A range of options is available as illustrated in Figure A5. These range from a package deal or turnkey where the client has little involvement in the design development or building procurement process (effectively, a complete hands off approach), to develop and construct where the client appoints designers to develop the brief to a level of sophistication which will leave the design and build contractor to develop detail or specialist design elements.
FIGURE A5 P ROCUREMENT ARRANGEMENT – DESIGN AND BUILD
Some options available, showing proportional involvement in the design proces by client and contractor between package deal, and develop and construct.
Turnkey Package deal Design and build (competitive) Design and build (negotiated) Develop and construct
The range of options enables the procurement arrangement to be used for a wide range of client types, and for clients to be involved to a greater or lesser extent.
Client involvement Contractor involvement
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 11
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
(p) The project organisation structure for design and build is shown in Figure A6. Contractors may use their own firms’ resources for undertaking the design (in-house design and build), or may more usually subcontract these to one or more professional firms whilst retaining control. (q) The main advantages of a design and build strategy are: • the client has only to deal with one firm; • inherent buildability is achievable;
FIGU RE A6 PROC UREMENT ARRA NGEMEN T – D ESIGN A ND BU ILD CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENT
CLIENT
DESIGN AND BUILD CONTRACTOR (standard lump sum contract) SUPPLIERS (various contracts)
SUBCONTRACTORS (standard lump sum contracts)
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
single point contact and responsibility
client needs to contract before design is complete
inherent buildability early firm price possible
no design overview unless consultants appointed
reduced total project time
difficult for clients to prepare adequate brief bids difficult to compare design liability limited by standard contract client driven changes can be expensive
SEQUENCE
brief
competition
design construction
Risk Low cost risk since most contracts will be let on a lump sum basis Low time risk since the contractor will usually fix the time and be committed to it High design/quality risk where the contractor controls design there are risks related to both design suitability and to the capacity of the design-build firm to own such risks
Page 12
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
PART 3, SECTION 1, APPENDIX A
• price certainty can be obtained before construction starts provided that the client’s requirements are adequately specified and changes are not introduced; and • reduced total project time due to early completion is possible because of overlapping activities. (r) The disadvantages are: • the client is required to contract before the detailed designs are completed; • there is no design overview unless separate consultants are appointed by the client for this purpose; • difficulties can be experienced by clients in preparing an adequate brief; • bids are difficult to compare since each design, programme and cost will vary; • design liability is limited by the standard contract; and • client changes to project scope can be expensive.
The Surveyors’ Construction Handbook
Part 3, Section 1 Appendix A (01/03)
Effective from 1/3/03
Page 13
PART 3, SECTION 2
PART THREE: CONSTRUCTION PLANNING AND PROCUREMENT SECTION 2: BUILDING SERVICES PROCUREMENT 3.2 Introduction The guidance in this section is intended to improve the way in which the procurement of building services is handled by all building professionals active in this field. It is aimed at clients, project managers, quantity surveyors and commercial managers who are involved in the procurement of building services. It is intended to provide guidance to clients on the production of clear appointment criteria and the benefits that will manifest through the whole procurement process. It is also intended for use by project managers advising on the procurement strategy for both consultant services and construction work, and for quantity surveyors/commercial managers involved in the selection of a procurement route, production of tender documentation and the management of the tender process. The value of building services can represent anything up to 50 per cent of a project’s total cost (see table 1) and a considerable proportion of the construction risk. It is therefore important that guidance is given to all professionals who provide advice in this field. It is hoped that this guide will lead to a more consistent approach throughout the construction industry. Table 1: Elemental Breakdown as a Percentage of Total Construction Cost Group element
Highly-serviced factories
Air conditioned offices
General hospitals
1. Substructure
19
8
6
2. Superstructure
62
44
33
3. Finishes
4
11
8
4. Fittings
–
2
4