SUPERLUBRICITY
This page intentionally left blank
SUPERLUBRICITY
Edited by Ali Erdemir Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, USA and Jean-Michel Martin Ecole Centrale de Lyon Lyon, France
Amsterdam • Boston • Heidelberg • London • New York • Oxford Paris • San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sydney • Tokyo
Elsevier Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK First edition 2007 Copyright © 2007 Elsevier BV. All rights reserved no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN-13: 978-0-444-52772-1 ISBN-10: 0-444-52772-9 For information on all Elsevier publications visit our website at books.elsevier.com
Printed and bound in The Netherlands 07 08 09 10 11
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xv
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xvii Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xxi
1 Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces J.B. Sokoloff 1.1 Superlubricity for Incommensurate Interfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 Superlubricity for Disordered Interfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 Friction Resulting from Multiscale Roughness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Superlubricity Resulting from Polymer Brushes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 1 1 3 6 11 14 14
2 Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Hirano 2.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Preliminaries: Tomlinson’s Picture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The Criterion for the Occurrence of Tomlinson’s Mechanism . 2.4 Atomistic Origin of Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.1 Frictional Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.2 Static Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.3 Dynamic Friction: Energy Dissipation . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1 Superlubricity and Adiabatic Motion of Atoms . . . . 2.5.2 Friction Diagram . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.3 Superlubricity and High Dimensionality . . . . . . . . 2.5.4 Energy Recurrence Phenomena . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17 17 17 18 21 25 25 26 27 30 30 31 33 34 36 37
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3 Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser 3.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1 Friction and Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2 Dry Friction on Idealized Zero Temperature Analytic Models v
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
39 39 39 40 40 41
vi
Contents
3.2.3 Disorder, Symmetry and Dimensionality . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.4 Thermal and Quantum Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Computer Simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1 Rough Interfaces, Elastic Solids and Superlubricity . . . . . . 3.3.2 Lennard-Jones Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.3 Adsorbed Layers, Confined Fluids and Boundary Lubrication 3.3.4 Solid Lubricants and Layered Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.5 Metallic Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.6 Carbon Films and Hydrogen-Terminated Surfaces . . . . . . . 3.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
5
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
44 46 47 47 50 51 52 53 54 54 55
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces . . . . . . . S. Ciraci, T. Yildirim, S. Dag and O. Gulseren 4.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Frictionless Sliding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.1 General Theoretical Arguments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.2 Recent Experimental Progress . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Description of Theoretical Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3.1 Atomistic Models and Details for Ab-initio Calculations . . . . . 4.4 Superlow Friction Coefficient Between Hydrogenated Diamond Surfaces 4.4.1 Force Variations in the Sliding Friction of Two Hydrogenated Diamond Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2 Sliding Friction of Hydrogenated Diamond (001) Slabs . . . . . . 4.4.3 Effect of Oxidation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5 Ab-initio Study of Atomic-Scale Friction Between Cubic BN-Surfaces . 4.6 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
57 57 57 59 59 60 60 60 61
. . . . . . .
63 63 67 68 75 75 76
. . . .
79 79 79 80 80 83 84 84 88 91 92 92 96 98 100
Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.D. Schall, P.T. Mikulski, G.M. Chateauneuf, G. Gao and J.A. Harrison 5.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 MD Simulation Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.1 Outline of Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2 Simulation of Tribology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Reactive Potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.1 Covalent Potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.2 Development and Fitting of Bond-Order Potential . . . . . . 5.3.3 Covalent + Intermolecular Forces (AIREBO) . . . . . . . . 5.4 Recent MD Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.1 Tribochemistry at the Sliding Interface . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.2 Intrafilm Tribochemistry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.3 Self-assembled Monolayers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
vii
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 What Causes Low Friction; What Causes High Friction . . . . . . . . . . Y. Zhu and S. Granick 6.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 Superlubricity in Boundary Lubrication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 Controlling the Boundary Condition of Hydrodynamic Flow . . . . . . . 6.3.1 The Mechanism that Controls Slip in Low-viscosity Fluids . . . . 6.3.2 “Slip” at Partially-Wetted Surfaces with Roughness Varied . . . . 6.3.3 “Slip” Can Be Modulated by Dissolved Gas—at Both Wetted and Partially-Wetted Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Outlook—The Purposeful Reduction in Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Frictional Dynamics at the Atomic Scale in Presence of Small Oscillations of the Sliding Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. Jeon, T. Thundat and Y. Braiman 7.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Experimental . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 Results and Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Effect of Surface Roughness and Adsorbates on Superlubricity V.N. Samoilov, C. Yang, U. Tartaglino and B.N.J. Persson 8.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2 Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3 Numerical Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.1 Clean Smooth and Rough Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.2 Dependence of the Friction on the Load . . . . . . . . 8.3.3 Role of Adsorbates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4 Summary and Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
103 103 103 103 108 109 110
. . . . .
112 114 115 115 115
.
119 119 119 120 121 129 129 129
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
9 Atomic-Scale Investigation of Superlubricity on Insulating Surfaces E. Gnecco, A. Socoliuc and E. Meyer 9.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2 The Tomlinson–Prandtl Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 The Superlubric Regime . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Experimental Evidence of Superlubricity: Quasistatic Case . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
100 100
. . . .
131 131 131 132 134 134 137 143 145 146 146 147 147 147 148 152 154
viii
Contents
9.5 Experimental Evidence of Superlubricity: Dynamic Case . . . . . . . . . . 9.6 Conclusions and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Superlubricity of Fullerene Intercalated Graphite Composite . . . . . . K. Miura and N. Sasaki 10.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Sliding of Graphite Flakes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Sliding of Graphite Flakes over Graphite . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Lateral Force versus Load Acting between Graphite Surfaces . . 10.3 Superlubricity of a Graphite/C60 Monolayer Film/Graphite . . . . . . . 10.3.1 Structure of a Graphite/C60 Monolayer Film/Graphite System . 10.3.2 Ultralow Lateral Movement of C60 Molecules . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Superlubricity of C60 (C70 ) Intercalated Graphite Composite . . . . . . 10.4.1 Preparation and Structure of C60 (C70 ) Intercalated Graphite Composite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.2 Superlubricity of C60 (C70 ) Intercalated Graphite Composite . . 10.5 Origin of Superlubricity of Fullerene Intercalated Graphite Composite 10.5.1 Elastic Property of New Composite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5.2 Internal Sliding of New Composite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5.3 Guideline for Designing Ultralow Friction System . . . . . . . . 10.5.4 Intercalated Fullerenes Can Control Ultralow Friction . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
157 159 160
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
161 161 161 162 162 164 165 165 166 168
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
168 171 172 172 173 175 176 177
11 Superlubricity of Ag Nanometer-Thick Layers under Macroscopic Sliding System in UHV Condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Goto and F. Honda 11.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 Experimental Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3 Film-Thickness Effect on the Lubricity of Ag Film . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.4 Determination of the Shear Plane in Superlubricity of Ag Film . . . . . . . 11.5 Morphological Effect on Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6 Effect of Crystal Orientation on Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.7 Origin of Ag Film Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.8 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
179 179 179 180 182 186 188 192 195 197 198
12 Superlubricity between Graphite Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Dienwiebel and J.W.M. Frenken 12.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2 Incommensurability-Induced Transition to Frictionless Sliding . . . . . . 12.3 Atomic-Scale Observation of Superlubricity between Graphite Surfaces . 12.4 Towards Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
199 199 199 200 200 204 205 206 206
. . . . . . . .
Contents
ix
13 Superlubricity of Molybdenum Disulfide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.M. Martin 13.1 Low, Ultralow and Superlow Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2 Characterization of Sputter-Deposited MoS2 Coatings . . . . . . . . . . 13.3 Experimental Details for UHV Tribometry and MoS2 Film Deposition . 13.4 Ultralow and Superlow Friction of MoS2 Coatings . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.5 HRTEM Investigation of MoS2 Wear Debris . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.6 Possible Explanation for Superlubricity of MoS2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.7 Ultralow Friction by MoS2 Single Sheets. Towards Superlubricity under Boundary Lubrication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.8 Ultralow Friction by MoS2 Nanoparticles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.8.1 Nanotribology on MoS2 Crystals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Superlubricity of Tungsten Disulfide Coatings in Ultra High Vacuum . L. Joly-Pottuz and M. Iwaki 14.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2 WS2 Coatings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3 IF-WS2 coatings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Superlubricity by H2 S Gas Lubrication of Mo . . . . . . . I.L. Singer and T. Le Mogne Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.2 Experimental . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.2.1 Friction and Surface Analysis Apparatus . . . . . 15.2.2 Sample Preparation and Friction Test Procedures 15.3 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.3.1 Friction Coefficient vs. Gas Pressure . . . . . . . 15.3.2 Friction Coefficient vs. Speed . . . . . . . . . . . 15.4 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Superlubricity in Diamondlike Carbon Films A. Erdemir and O.L. Eryilmaz 16.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.2 Superlubricity in Crystalline Solids . . . . 16.2.1 Lamellar Solids . . . . . . . . . . . 16.2.2 Other Solids . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
207 207 207 208 210 210 216 217
. . . .
220 223 223 224
. . .
227 227 227 228 230 235 235 235
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
.
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
237 237 237 237 239 239 239 240 240 245 247 250 250 250 253 253 253 254 254 256
x
Contents
16.3 Superlubricity in Amorphous Carbons . . . . . . . . . . 16.3.1 Diamondlike Carbon Films . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.3.2 Synthesis and Main Characteristics of DLC Films 16.3.3 Classification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.3.4 Lubrication Mechanisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.3.5 Origin of Superlubricity in DLC Films . . . . . . 16.4 Summary and Future Direction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
257 258 258 259 259 262 268 269 269
17 Superlow Friction of a-C:H Films: Tribochemical and Rheological Effects . J. Fontaine and C. Donnet 17.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2 The Wide Friction Range of DLC Films . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2.1 General Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2.2 Experimental Evidence of Superlow Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.3 Conditions for a-C:H Films to Achieve Superlow Friction . . . . . . . . . 17.3.1 General Requirements to Achieve Superlow Friction with DLC Films . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.3.2 Influence of Hydrogen Content in the Film: Low Interacting Surfaces 17.3.3 Influence of the Mechanical Behavior of the Film: Compliant Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.4 Achievement and Preservation of Superlow Friction with a-C:H Films . . 17.4.1 How to Achieve Superlow Friction: Tribofilm Build-Up Controlled by Surface Chemistry of the Counterface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.4.2 How to Preserve Superlow Friction: Tribo-reactivity of the Contact Controlled by Gaseous Environment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.5 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
273 273 273 274 274 275 277
18 Suppression of Moisture Sensitivity of Friction in Carbon-Based Coatings . C. Freyman, B. Zhao and Y.-W. Chung 18.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.2 Synthesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.3 Surface Characterization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.3.1 Compositional Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.3.2 Surface Roughness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.4 Tribological Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.5 Water–Film Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.6 Mechanical Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.6.1 Hardness and Elastic Modulus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.6.2 Film Stress . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.7 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
295 295 295 297 298 298 301 302 304 306 306 307 309 309
277 278 281 283 283 285 292 293
Contents
xi
19 Application of Carbon Based Nano-Materials to Aeronautics and Space Lubrication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.W. Street, Jr., K. Miyoshi and R.L. Vander Wal 19.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.2 Experimental . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.2.1 Instrumentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.2.2 Sample Preparation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.2.3 Analytic Techniques and Post Mortem Analysis . . . . . . . . . 19.3 Results and Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.3.1 Nano-onion Investigations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.3.2 Multi-walled Nanotube Investigations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.3.3 Single-walled and Surface Fluorinated Nanotube Investigations 19.4 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
311 311 311 312 312 315 316 317 317 322 332 338 338
20 Superlubricity of CNx-coatings in Nitrogen Gas Atmosphere . . . . . . . . K. Kato and K. Adachi 20.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.2 Fundamental Properties of CNx-coatings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.2.1 Coating Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.2.2 Hardness and Microstructure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.3 Superlubricity of CNx-coating on Si-wafer sliding against Si3 N4 ball . . . 20.3.1 Friction on CNx-coatings in Vacuum After Short Time Exposure to Air, O2 or N2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.3.2 Friction on CNx-coatings in Gases of 7.4 × 104 Pa . . . . . . . . . 20.4 Superlubricity of CNx-coating on Si3 N4 Disk Sliding against Si3 N4 Ball or CNx-coating on Si3 N4 Ball . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.5 Mechanisms of Low Friction and Low Wear of CNx-coatings . . . . . . . 20.5.1 The Effect of Humidity in N2 on Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.5.2 The Effect of O2 in N2 on Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.5.3 The Effect of Surface Roughness on Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.5.4 Tribolayers of Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
341 341 341 341 341 343 345
. . .
365 365 365 368 368 374 378 378 384 391 392
21 Achieving Ultralow Friction by Aqueous, Brush-Assisted Lubrication S. Lee and N.D. Spencer 21.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.2 Macroscopic Scale Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.2.1 Rigid Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.2.2 Soft Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.3 Micro/Nanoscopic Scale Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.3.1 General Aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.3.2 Water-soluble Polymer Brushes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.4 Summary and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
345 345 348 351 355 358 358 360 363 363
xii
Contents
22 Friction Control at the Molecular Level: From Superlubricity to Stick-Slip D. Mazuyer, A. Tonck and J. Cayer-Barrioz 22.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.2 Experimental . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.2.1 The Molecular Tribometer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.2.2 The Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.2.3 Experimental Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.2.4 Properties of the Confined Layer under Loading . . . . . . . . . . . 22.3 Results and Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.3.1 Squeeze Behavior of the Adsorbed Layer of the Friction Modifiers . 22.3.2 Frictional Properties of the Adsorbed Layers of Friction Modifiers . 22.3.3 Physical Interpretation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
397 397 397 402 402 403 405 406 409 409 411 422 424
23 Super Low Traction under EHD & Mixed Lubrication Regimes . . . . . . P. Vergne 23.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.1.1 Superlubricity, Near Frictionless Sliding and Super Low Traction 23.1.2 Chapter Objectives and Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.2 Traction versus Super Low Traction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.2.1 Generalities on EHD Traction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.2.2 Super Low Traction and Experimental Issues . . . . . . . . . . . 23.3 Experimental conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.4 Lubricated Super Low Traction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.4.1 Newtonian Isothermal Piezoviscous Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . 23.4.2 Shear Thinning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.4.3 Thin Film EHD Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.5 Discussion and Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annex: Main Properties of the Lubricants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
427 427 427 427 428 428 428 430 431 432 432 435 436 440 442 442 442
24 Superlubricity of In Situ Generated Protective Layer on Worn Metal Surfaces in Presence of Mg6 Si4 O10 (OH)8 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Yuansheng and L. Shenghua 24.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.2 Tribochemical Principles of In Situ Reconditioning of Rubbing Metal Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.2.1 Tribological Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.2.2 Tribochemical Reactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.3 Superlubricity of Protective Layer Generated by ART Mechanochemical Reconditioner Package . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.3.1 Protective Layer Generated in Railway Locomotive Trials . . . . 24.3.2 Observation of the Protective Layer on Cylinder Bore . . . . . . 24.3.3 Nano-hardness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
445 445 445
. . .
446 446 447
. . . .
450 450 451 453
Contents
24.3.4 Surface Roughness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.3.5 Coefficient of Friction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.3.6 Protective Layer Generated in Laboratory Conditions . . . . . . . 24.4 Possible Sources of Superlubricity of In Situ Generated Protective Layer on Worn Metal Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.4.1 Phase Structure of the Protective Layer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.4.2 Raman Spectrometry Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24.4.3 Possible Sources of Superlubricity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xiii
. . .
454 454 455
. . . . . .
461 462 466 466 467 467
25 Superlubricity of Diamond/Glycerol Technology Applied to Automotive Gasoline Engines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M.I. De Barros Bouchet and M. Kano 25.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2 Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.1 DLC Materials Preparation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.2 Tribological Tests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.3 Engine Tests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.4 Nanoscratch Measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.5 Mechanical Measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.6 Surface Analyses Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.2.7 Microstructural Analysis Technique . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.3 Results and Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.3.1 DLC Materials Characterizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.3.2 Steel/DLC Tribological Systems Lubricated by Glycerol Mono-Oleate (GMO) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.3.3 DLC/DLC Tribological Systems Lubricated by Glycerol and GMO 25.3.4 Superlubricity Mechanism as Studied by Surface Analyses . . . . . 25.3.5 Engine Test Results and Application . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25.4 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
471 471 471 472 472 472 474 475 475 475 476 477 477 481 484 485 489 491 491 492 493
This page intentionally left blank
Foreword “From Hard to Soft” David Tabor (and the British school around him) constructed our basic view of solid friction, induced by mesoscopic asperities. We often avoid solid friction by fluid intercalation: oils, water, lubricants . . . But some exotic situations still emerge. Among them, the extremely weak friction found with certain hard contacts: diamondlike films, and also incommensurate contacts between layered crystals (graphite, MoS2 , . . . ). These contacts can display a form of “superglide” “superlubricity” or “superlubrication”. They constitute the central subject of the present book. On superlubricity between two ideal graphite crystals, Friedel and the present author have recently presented a simple synthesis, using our classical knowledge on grain boundaries [1]. Two regimes are expected, depending on the missetting angle θ between the crystals: (a) Strong coupling, when θ ≤ U1 /UL where U1 /UL is the ratio of interplane/inplane interactions. Here, as shown long ago by F.C. Frank [2], we expect two ladders of screw dislocation on the interface, with a repeat distance d = aθ −1 (where a is a mesh size). The two crystals are then strongly locked: there is no superglide. (b) The other (more interesting) regime corresponds to θ > U1 /UL . Here, the Frank dislocations are too diffuse to show up, and we expect a very weak friction, analyzed by Sokoloff and others. The moving potential of (say) the top part creates phonons in the bottom part. One phonon processes are not allowed by energy and momentum conservation. Two phonon processes (Raman) are allowed, but are very weak. This discussion is helpful, although slightly incomplete, because it ignores the collective modes at the interface. On the whole, the incommensurate graphite/graphite contacts provide us with some beautiful physics, and this is well shown in the present book. But most experiments are performed with a small plaque torn out from a macroscopic crystal. When the linear size of this plaque becomes as small as the ladder periodicity d, we again enter into a very different domain. It may be that the low mutual friction between diamondlike films is related to the same concepts. Here we deal with a mosaic of small compact facets. Presumably most of the facets have θ > U1 /UL and are thus good candidates for superlubricity. But we should know more about the contact lines between adjacent mosaic units (a) when moving, they might generate a one phonon friction; (b) if the size L of the units is comparable to d, we enter in a different domain. Another gold mine of friction research is based on soft systems. The central example is the vertebrate joint with its amazing properties of low friction and resistance to squeezing. These systems are also discussed deeply in this book. The two interacting surfaces inside our hip, or knee, are based on fibrous films (hyaluronans, proteoglycans) separated by a synovial fluid of similar composition. This fluid in itself is not an exceptional lubricant xv
xvi
Foreword
(as shown by in vitro experiments). The low friction is not due to the fluid, but rather to polymer brushes on the fibrous film surface. They can be linear chains or statistically branched objects: in the real joint, the polymers are branched. Two geometrical parameters are important: – the average size R of a single molecule in water, – the average distance D between neighboring grafts. When D > R we talk of a “mushroom” regime. When D < R we have a true brush. The most useful, and realistic systems are at the cross over point (D ∼ R). Friction between synthetic brushes has been studied by a number of authors, and is reviewed recently by J. Klein [3]. From a global point of view, the quality of a brush/brush contact is essentially defined by 3 parameters: (a) the lubricant thickness λ, defined in terms of a shear stress σ and a slippage velocity V : λ = ηV /σ , where η is the velocity of water (in the narrow gap between the brushes, solute macromolecules cannot enter). We expect λ ∼ R ∼ D at the mushroom/brush cross over point; (b) the squeeze pressure ps above which the load flattens out the brush. A scaling discussion on forces confirms that ps is higher for branched objects (at the same overall molecular weight/graft); (c) the critical shear stress for tear out σt (above which the grafts are torn out). We also expect σt to be increased by branching. The conclusion (for future biomimetic systems) is relatively clear: (a) we should use branched chains; (b) they should not be too large (because ps and σt then become small); (c) at the other end, if R is too small, λ is small and the friction is too large. There is an optimum in between. Of course, this discussion is primitive. J. Klein introduces two other physicochemical factors which help to reduce the friction: (i) Hyaluronans and proteoglycans are negatively charged polyelectrolytes: this implies that the two partner brushes repel each other. (This is not a huge effect however, because, in hysiological conditions, we deal with water + salt: there is some screening.) (ii) The counterions carry an important hydration shell, which acts as a lubricant. On the whole, this preface presents a very crude view of friction processes for hard incommensurate solid contacts, and for soft polymer brushes. The contents of the present book will allow our reader to go much farther. But the present comments and rules of the thumb may provide a helpful introduction. P.-G. de Gennes Institut Curie, 26, rue d’Ulm 75005 Paris, France
REFERENCES [1] Similar ideas were produced much earlier by Lançon, F., Penisson, J.M., Dahmen, U. Europhys. Lett. 49 (2000), 603. [2] Frank, F.C. J. Cryst. Growth 51 (1981), 367. [3] Klein, J., Raviv, U., Perkin, S., Kampf, N., Chai, L., Giasson, S. J. Phys.: Con. Matter 16 (2004), S5437.
Introduction Among all physical phenomena, friction perhaps poses one of the greatest challenges to the scientific and industrial communities and has a direct linkage to energy efficiency and environmental cleanliness of all moving mechanical systems. In everyday life, we rarely think about friction or appreciate its importance, but there is no doubt that it is a major cause of lost energy, and as well as hazardous emissions to our environment. Hence, the prospect of further reducing friction in engineering systems has real-life implications From www.angstrom.uu.se/tribomaterials/. for not only preserving our limited energy resources, but also saving our planet from hazardous emissions for generations to come. Considering that in most industrialized nations, the annual cost of friction- and wear-related energy and material losses is estimated to be 5 to 7% of their gross national products, the further reduction (or even elimination) of friction in all kinds of moving mechanical systems would be extremely beneficial to the economical well-being of all nations. In short, reducing friction further is extremely important for conserving not only our ever-diminishing energy resources but also the environment and ultimately money. Recent advances in the computational, analytical, and experimental capabilities of modern tribology and related research fields have paved the way for a better understanding and hence control of friction across the force, length, and time scales. In particular, dedicated fundamental friction studies at the subnanometer scale using a wide range of advanced computational and experimental tools (i.e., ab initio and molecular dynamic simulations, atomic and friction force microscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, surface force apparatus, and quartz crystal microbalance, etc.) have enabled scientists to not only more accurately predict/simulate, but also to identify, the specific types of materials and test conditions that can lead to near-zero friction or superlubricity in a number of nano-to-macro scale sliding systems. In particular, supercomputers with huge memory and processing capabilities now enable simulation and real-time visualization of atomic-scale friction and allow predictions of those conditions that can lead to superlubricity. The word “superlubricity” was first used by Motohisa Hirano to describe a theoretical sliding regime in which friction or resistance to sliding completely vanishes (see his chapter in this book). In this regime, the extent of physical and/or chemical interactions is extremely small or essentially absent, and hence the surfaces can slide over one another without causing much friction. Historically, the earliest studies on superlubricity started in mid-1980s, but the real progress occurred during the 1990s. In particular, theoretical studxvii
xviii
Introduction
ies by Professors Jeffrey Sokoloff and Motohisa Hirano predicted the existence of such superlubricious states between weakly interacting, atomically smooth surfaces (see their chapters in this book). Their studies have provided significant fundamental insight into the atomic-scale origins of friction in general and superlubricity in particular. Other researchers who entered the field later also confirmed that such a state of near-zero-friction may indeed exist between sliding surfaces of a number of solid materials that are brought into intimate contact in an incommensurate or ideally misaligned/misfit fashion. By bringing such surfaces from a commensurate to an incommensurate state, these researchers were able to observe a clear transition from a pure stick-slip (indicative of high friction) to smooth sliding (indicative of no friction). Due to the strict structural requirements (i.e., optimal imcommensurability and/or misalignment) for superlubricity, some scientists who worked in this field during the early 2000s often preferred to use the term “structural lubricity” rather than “superlubricity,” mainly because “superlubricity” seemed related to such well-known physical phenomena as superconductivity, superfluidity, etc. Because superlubricious situations were predicted and observed only in ultrahigh vacuum in the 1990s, there was a tendency to see an analogy with superconductivity, in which electrical resistance vanishes at very low temperatures. However, the term superlubricity is quite appropriate from a tribological standpoint in the sense that the prefix “super” means “extreme;” hence, superlubricity means extreme lubricity but in no way suggests “zero” friction. Also, we are presently unable to measure friction coefficients at values below 10−4 . In the case of superconductivity, electric resistance completely vanishes or it is “zero” so that the use of the term “super” may not be totally appropriate here, either. Overall, a better terminology or description is needed to dispel the controversy over the real meaning of the prefix “super” that is often used in so many other physical phenomena to mean something that is extraordinary or unusual. The main objective of this book is to bring together leading researchers who work in superlubricity and other related fields and to provide a concise state-of-the-art overview of the recent developments and discoveries. Because this field has become rather large, complex, and multidisciplinary in nature, the chapters in this book may not sufficiently cover everything that relates to superlubricity; however, the editors have done their best to bring out some of the most important developments in superlubricity during the last two decades in a coherent manner. Within the book’s 25 chapters, readers will find a wealth of information ranging from theoretical and practical aspects of friction in general to superlubricity in particular. Each chapter is written by a group of leading experts who are well-known for their invaluable contributions to the field. The book starts with a section covering the theoretical aspects of superlubricity. This is followed by other sections that deal with the observation and/or measurement of superlubricity in real systems ranging from nano-to-macro scales under dry-sliding, vacuum, or oil-lubricated conditions. Specifically, Chapters 1–7 are devoted to the theoretical aspects of superlubricity, while Chapters 8–11 provide fundamental insight into superlubricity of various sliding systems at the nanoscale. Chapters 12 to 15 cover the superlubricity of lamellar solids over a broad range of scales, and Chapters 16 to 20 discuss the superlubricity of carbon-based thin coatings at macro scales. Chapters 21–25 highlight the superlubricity of sliding surfaces under elastohydrodynamic and boundary lubricated sliding regimes.
Introduction
xix
Readers will appreciate that recent advances in superlubricity research have indeed been phenomenal. However, they will also realize that there remain several key challenges for future scientists and engineers to overcome. In the very broad field of tribology, there are numerous test and environmental conditions, surface parameters, and material combinations that can affect friction and wear in so many ways. Early tribology pioneers and other dedicated researchers have made great strides despite the field’s very intricate and multifaceted nature. As we move forward in the 21st century with great hopes and expectations, we must work harder to develop novel surfaces, together with novel design concepts that can further reduce or even eliminate friction and hence save our environment and limited energy resources for future generations. Specifically, we need to engineer innovative ways to build new solid structures or systems that can provide universally achievable superlow friction across the physical scales. We should also increase our theoretical modeling capabilities so they can guide us in the right direction for the development of novel materials and/or sliding conditions that can lead to superlow friction and wear. Most of the tools (analytical, computational, and experimental) needed for the successful realization of this goal are now available, and the development of new and more robust tools is currently underway. Overall, the greatest challenge for the future seems to be the integration of the vast tribological knowledge bases accumulated over the years into the realization of smart tribosystems that generate little or no friction. From the very beginning, mankind has been on the move and in search of new ways and means to achieve easier and faster mobility. There should be no doubt that this trend will continue at a much accelerated pace during the 21st century, and we hope that this will result in the development of truly frictionless systems. The editors are truly indebted to the authors of each chapter in this book. Without their enthusiasm and eagerness, we could not have put this book together. They thank Prof. Pierre-Gilles de Gennes (Nobel Prize Laureate in Physics, 1991) for writing a very insightful and thought-provoking foreword. The editors also acknowledge the support of their institutions (Argonne National Laboratory—USA and Ecole Centrale de Lyon—France) and funding agencies (the United States Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Freedom Car and Vehicle Technologies Program; and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique de France CNRS). Also, Dr. Osman Eryilmaz of Argonne is gratefully acknowledged for his help in formatting some of the chapters. Last but not least, the editors thank their families for their support and understanding during the preparation of this book.
Ali Erdemir Argonne National Laboratory Energy Systems Division Argonne, IL, USA
Jean-Michel Martin University Institute of France, Paris Ecole Centrale de Lyon, LTDS Ecully, France
This page intentionally left blank
Contributors Koshi Adachi
Tohoku University, Sendai 980-8579, Japan
Yehuda Braiman
Center for Engineering Science, Advanced Research Computer Science and Mathematics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831
Carlos E. Campañá
Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada N6A 5B7
Juliette Cayer-Barrioz
Ecole Centrale de Lyon, Laboratoire de Tribologie et Dynamique des Systèmes UMR 5513 CNRS/ECL/ENISE, F-69134 Ecully Cedex, France
Ginger M. Chateauneuf
Chemistry Department, US Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21402, USA
Yip-Wah Chung
Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
S. Ciraci
Department of Physics, Bilkent University, Ankara 06800, Turkey
S. Dag
Center of Nanophase Materials Science (CNMS) and Computer Science and Mathematics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37830, USA
Maria Isabel De Barros Bouchet
Laboratory of Tribology and System Dynamics, UMR CNRS 5513, Ecole Centrale de Lyon, 69134 Ecully Cedex, France
Martin Dienwiebel
Kamerlingh Onnes Laboratory, Leiden University, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands and IAVF Antriebstechnik AG, 76187 Karlsruhe, Germany
Christophe Donnet
University Institute of France and Laboratoire Traitement du Signal et Instrumentation, UMR CNRS 5516, Université Jean Monnet, 42000 Saint-Etienne, France
Ali Erdemir
Energy Systems Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL 60439, USA
Osman L. Eryilmaz
Energy Systems Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL 60439, USA
Julien Fontaine
Laboratoire de Tribologie et Dynamique des Systèmes, UMR CNRS 5513, Ecole Centrale de Lyon, 69134 Ecully Cedex, France
xxi
xxii
Contributors
Joost W.M. Frenken
Kamerlingh Onnes Laboratory, Leiden University, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands
Christina Freyman
Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
Guangtu Gao
Chemistry Department, US Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21402, USA
Enrico Gnecco
NCCR Nanoscale Science, Department of Physics, University of Basel, CH-4056 Basel, Switzerland
Minoru Goto
Ube National College of Technology, Ube 755-8555, Japan
Steve Granick
Dept. of Material Science and Engineering, of Chemistry, and of Physics, Univ. of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61801, USA
O. Gulseren
Department of Physics, Bilkent University, Ankara 06800, Turkey
Judith A. Harrison
Chemistry Department, US Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21402, USA
Motohisa Hirano
Gifu University, 1-1, Yanagido, Gifu, 501-1193, Japan
Fumihiro Honda
Toyota Technological Institute, Nagoya 468-8511, Japan
Masanori Iwaki
Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA), Tsukuba 305-8505, Japan
Sangmin Jeon
Department of Chemical Engineering, Pohang University of Science and Technology, Pohang, Korea
Lucile Joly-Pottuz
Ecole Centrale de Lyon, Ecully 69134, France
Makoto Kano
Nissan Research Center, to Kanagawa Industrial Technology Center, Kanagawa 243-0435, Japan
Koji Kato
Tohoku University, Sendai 980-8579, Japan
Seunghwan Lee
Laboratory for Surface Science and Technology, Department of Materials, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland
Thierry Le Mogne
Ecole Centrale de Lyon, Laboratoire de Tribologie et Dynamique des Systèmes—UMR5513, F-69131 Ecully Cedex, France
Jean-Michel Martin
University Institute of France, Paris, France, and Ecole Centrale de Lyon, LTDS, 69134 Ecully, France
Denis Mazuyer
Ecole Centrale de Lyon, Laboratoire de Tribologie et Dynamique des Systèmes UMR 5513 CNRS/ECL/ENISE, F-69134 Ecully Cedex, France
Contributors
xxiii
Ernst Meyer
NCCR Nanoscale Science, Department of Physics, University of Basel, CH-4056 Basel, Switzerland
Paul T. Mikulski
Physics Department, US Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21402, USA
Kouji Miura
Department of Physics, Aichi University of Education, Kariya 448-8542, Japan
Kazuhisa Miyoshi
NASA Glenn Research Center, Cleveland, OH 44135, USA
Martin H. Müser
Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada N6A 5B7
B.N.J. Persson
IFF, FZ-Jülich, 52425 Jülich, Germany
V.N. Samoilov
IFF, FZ-Jülich, 52425 Jülich, Germany and Physics Faculty, Moscow State University, 117234 Moscow, Russia
Naruo Sasaki
Department of Materials and Life Science, Faculty of Science and Technology, Seikei University, Tokyo 180-8633, Japan
J. David Schall
Chemistry Department, US Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21402, USA
Li Shenghua
State Key Laboratory of Tribology, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
Irwin L. Singer
Naval Research Lab, Washington, DC 20375, USA
Anisoara Socoliuc
NCCR Nanoscale Science, Department of Physics, University of Basel, CH-4056 Basel, Switzerland
Jeffrey B. Sokoloff
Physics Department, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115, USA
Nicholas D. Spencer
Laboratory for Surface Science and Technology, Department of Materials, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland
Kenneth W. Street, Jr.
NASA Glenn Research Center, Cleveland, OH 44135, USA
U. Tartaglino
IFF, FZ-Jülich, 52425 Jülich, Germany and Democritos National Simulation Center, 34014 Trieste, Italy
Thomas Thundat
Center for Engineering Science, Advanced Research Life Sciences Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831
André Tonck
Ecole Centrale de Lyon, Laboratoire de Tribologie et Dynamique des Systèmes UMR 5513 CNRS/ECL/ENISE, F-69134 Ecully Cedex, France
xxiv
Contributors
Randy L. Vander Wal
The Universities Space Research Association (USRA), c/o NASA Glenn Research Center, Cleveland, OH 44135, USA
Philippe Vergne
Laboratoire de Mécanique des Contacts et des Solides— LaMCoS, UMR CNRS/INSA de Lyon n◦ 5514, 69100 Villeurbanne, France
C. Yang
IFF, FZ-Jülich, 52425 Jülich, Germany
T. Yildirim
NIST Center for Neutron Research, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA
Jin Yuansheng
State Key Laboratory of Tribology, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
Bo Zhao
Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
Yingxi Zhu
Dept. of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Univ. of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
–1– Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces Jeffrey B. Sokoloff Physics Department, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115, USA
1.1 SUPERLUBRICITY FOR INCOMMENSURATE INTERFACES A few years ago, Hirano and Shinjo suggested that two crystalline surfaces whose periods are incommensurate with each other might be able to slide with respect to each other with negligible friction [1]. They named this phenomenon superlubricity. In fact, even when two crystalline surfaces of identical periodicity are placed in contact with each other, they will almost always be rotated with respect to each other by an arbitrary angle. Consequently, they will almost always be incommensurate. The reason that an incommensurate interface can exhibit low friction is that the two surfaces have no energetically preferred position with respect to each other, and hence they can be slid relative to each other with no cost in energy. What I have just said is of course obviously true, provided that the two surfaces are infinite in extent, are perfectly rigid and interact with simple potentials, such as the Lennard-Jones potential, for example. One would suspect that under similar conditions, two disordered surfaces (e.g., two glassy or amorphous solids, as opposed to the crystalline solids discussed earlier) should also exhibit no friction under the above conditions, since they also have no preferred position relative to each other. From what has been said to this point, it would appear that superlubricity should almost always occur. Since it does not, the reason must be that this phenomenon must break down once the surfaces are not perfectly stiff, infinite in extent and interact only with simple potential functions. Then, in order to explain the nonzero friction between two solid surfaces that is usually observed, we must understand how superlubricity breaks down when the above conditions are not satisfied. We hope that by doing so, we will also find a way to predict the conditions under which some vestiges of superlubricity might survive and serve as a possible mechanism for lubrication. These are the issues that I will attempt to address in this chapter. The first question that I will discuss is whether superlubricity goes away if the surfaces are not perfectly stiff. This problem was first considered by Aubry [2] for a simple one-dimensional model, which consists of an infinitely long chain of atoms connected by springs of lattice spacing b, to represent one solid, interacting with an infinitely long perSuperlubricity Edited by A. Erdemir and J.-M. Martin © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
2
J.B. Sokoloff
fectly stiff sinusoidal potential of spacing a, to represent the second solid. The chain and sinusoidal potential are incommensurate by definition if the ratio b/a is an irrational number, such as π , (2)1/2 , etc. In fact, Aubry proved that as long as the sinusoidal potential is below a critical strength, the chain-sinusoidal potential system has a continuously degenerate ground state, meaning that one can slide the chain by an infinitesimal distance with no cost in energy. This implies that there is no static or kinetic friction, at least in the very slow sliding speed limit (i.e., no “dry friction”) for a range of potential strengths, and hence superlubricity does not disappear as soon as the solids are no longer perfectly stiff. In order to understand how this occurs, Sacco and Sokoloff [3] numerically solved the equations for the equilibrium configuration for a finite chain of atoms in a sinusoidal potential, using both periodic and free end boundary conditions. For periodic boundary conditions, the sinusoidal potential and the chain are assumed to form a ring. Then if L is the circumference of the ring, L = Na = Mb, where N and M are integers, which implies that b/a = N/M, a rational number. Thus, this model only approximates an incommensurate system in the large N and M limit. We will focus in this discussion on the periodic boundary condition version of this model, since it is easier to follow, but the result does not depend on boundary conditions [3]. Allowed equilibrium configurations of the chain of atoms exist with the chain shifted by small amounts relative to the sinusoidal potential. They alternate in energy between two values. As the values of the integers N and M are increased (i.e., we approach the incommensurate limit), the difference between these energies decreases as the ratio of the potential strength to the product of the spring constant of the springs connecting to atoms in the chain and the square of a chain lattice constant raised to the power N [3]. Thus, for relatively small sinusoidal potential strengths, the ground state of the chain becomes translationally invariant. The physical reason for why this occurs is illustrated in Figure 1.1 (Figure 3 of [3]). As can be seen from the figure, for each configuration of the chain, one atom is near a minimum of the sinusoidal potential (e.g., in the plot at the top of Figure 1.1, it is the atom at the far left). Let us arbitrarily call this the origin of the chain. For each successive configuration of the chain, corresponding to sliding the
Figure 1.1 This is Figure 3 of [3], which shows the equilibrium positions in the sinusoidal potential of the atoms in the chain of atoms in the Frenkel–Kontorova model for successive amounts of sliding of the center of mass of the chain. This figure is reprinted with permission from J.E. Sacco and J.B. Sokoloff, Free sliding in solids with two incommensurate periodicities, Phys. Rev. B 18 (1978), 6549. Copyright 1978 by the American Physical Society.
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
3
chain by a small amount to the right, a different atom somewhere else in the chain lies close to a potential minimum. If we translate the origin of the chain to this new point, the atomic configuration of the chain will be almost identical to what it was previously. This explains why the ground state energy of the chain becomes translationally invariant in the incommensurate limit for a chain which is incommensurate with the sinusoidal potential, even when the chain is not perfectly rigid. When the potential is larger than the product of the spring force constant and the square of the chain lattice constant, this simple picture breaks down. This is the origin of superlubricity for crystalline surfaces. A similar result has been found for two-dimensional atomic surfaces in contact using simulations [4–6].
1.2
SUPERLUBRICITY FOR DISORDERED INTERFACES
It was shown in [7] that two three-dimensional solids in contact at a disordered interface also exhibit superlubricity. By a disordered interface, I mean that the surfaces of the two solids in contact need not be completely amorphous; they only need to be not periodic. Intuitively, one would expect that there should be no static friction for such an interface, just as is the case for an incommensurate interface, because there is clearly no preferred position of the two solids relative to each other. The difference between disordered and incommensurate interfaces, is that static friction is only zero in the case of disordered interfaces if the solids in contact at the interface are thick (i.e., three-dimensional), whereas for incommensurate solids, the static friction is zero for thin (i.e., two-dimensional) solids as well [7]. For two thin solids in contact at a disordered interface, there is static friction which is inversely proportional to a length known as the Larkin length. For weakly interacting surfaces, the Larkin length is long, whereas for strongly interacting surfaces it is short. In contrast, for three-dimensional solids in contact at a two-dimensional interface, the Larkin length is infinite, i.e., comparable to the surface dimensions for weakly interacting surfaces and small relatively small for strongly interacting surfaces [7]. To see this let us consider a simpler model, which should be sufficient to capture the basic physics of this problem, namely we will consider a three-dimensional elastic solid in contact with a stiff two-dimensional disordered interface. The energy of this model can be written as E=
∂uα 2 ∂uα 2 d3 r K + K′ + V r + u(r) δ(z) , ∂xβ ∂xα solid α
(1)
α,β
where α and β run over the components x, y and z, uα (r) denotes the αth component of the displacement field at the point r in the elastic medium, K and K ′ are the elastic moduli (i.e., the Lame coefficients) and V (r) denotes the substrate potential per unit area. We look for an approximate solution of the form uα = uα (x/L, y/L, z/L′ ), where u varies by an amount of the order of the range of a potential well of the substrate potential when x and y vary over a distance of L or z varies over a distance of order L′ . These are the Larkin lengths along and perpendicular to the surface. We substitute this expression for uα in Equation (1), and approximate the integral of the first two terms in the integrand of Equation (1) over a single Larkin domain, by the product of the average over a Larkin
4
J.B. Sokoloff
domain of first two terms in the integrand of Equation (1) and the volume of a Larkin domain, L2 L′ , and then multiply by the number of domains, A/L2 , where A is the area of the interface. Minimizing with respect to L′ , we obtain L′ = L(Γ ′ /Γ )1/2 ,
(2)
where Γ =K
α,β=x,y
(∂uα /∂xβ′ )2
+ K′
(∂uα /∂xα′ )2
α=x,y
and
Γ ′ = K (∂uz /∂z′ )2 + K ′ (∂uα /∂z′ )2 , α
where (x ′ , y ′ , z′ ) = (x/L, y/L, z/L′ ) and · · · signifies an average over a Larkin domain. Since the derivatives of u are all of the order of atomic distances, L′ ≈ L. Assuming that V (r) is completely random and u(r) varies by a negligible amount as r runs over a domain of volume L2 L′ , the integral of V (r) over this domain is of order V0 c1/2 L/a, where V0 is the root-mean-square (rms) value of the potential of interaction between a surface atom and the substrate and c is the fraction of the surface atoms which are in contact with the substrate. In arriving at this result we assumed that the variation of u(r) when r varies over a distance small compared to L, is negligibly small compared to the length scales on the substrate. Consider two surfaces in contact which are disordered so that those atoms which are in contact are randomly distributed over the interface. Let us also assume that the atoms in contact at the interface interact only with hard core interactions. This could occur either because the surface atoms are chemically inert and there is negligible adhesion, or because the surfaces are being pushed together with a sufficient load so that the hard core interactions dominate. Let P denote the load or normal force per unit interface area, a, the mean atomic spacing and c, the fraction of the surface atoms of one surface that are in contact with the second surface. Then, each of the atoms in contact must contribute on the average to the normal force a of order P a 2 /c. Since the force due to the hard core interaction between a pair of atoms acts along the line joining the atoms, for most relative positions of the atoms, it has a component along the interface, as illustrated in Figure 1.2. In the strong pinning regime, each surface atom will sink into an interface potential minimum at the expense of the elastic forces holding it in place. Such a minimum will generally occur at an interstitial region on the second surface. If we now attempt to slide the surfaces relative to each other, each of the atoms in contact with the second surface will now, as it gets pulled out of its potential minimum, exert a component of its hard core interaction with the second surface parallel to the interface directed so as to oppose the attempted sliding motion. This is identified with the static friction. Since each of these atoms must also provide a component P a 2 /c normal to the interface on the average, it is clear the static friction is proportional to the load. This is the case because the contribution to the load and the static friction for each pair of atom in contact is provided by the same hard core force acting between the atoms. The proportionality constant μs is identified with the
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
5
Figure 1.2 This figure illustrates how the hard core interaction between a pair of atoms, one belonging to each of the surfaces in contact, can both support the load and give rise to static friction between the surfaces. Since the force F between the pair of atoms can have both a component normal to the interface, Fz , which contributes to the normal force supporting the load, and a component along the interface Fx the mean value of the magnitude of Fx must be proportional to the mean value of Fz .
coefficient of static friction which is not too much smaller than 1. This accounts for Amonton’s law without the need to assume that the friction is proportional to an ill-defined area of real contact. In the weak pinning limit, the component along the interface of the hard core force is random, and hence, for an infinite interface area and hence an infinite number of interface atoms, the components along the interface of the hard core forces cancel, resulting in effectively no static friction in the thermodynamic or macroscopic solid limit. Hence, since the magnitude of the static friction per surface atom is P a 2 /c and V (r) varies on a length scale a, V0 ≈ P a 3 /c. Then substituting this in the expression for the mean value of V (r) under Equation (2) and L′ from Equation (2) in Equation (1), we obtain E = 2(Γ Γ ′ )1/2 − P a 2 /c1/2 A/L
(3)
for the energy, which is minimized for infinite L if 2(Γ Γ ′ )1/2 > P a 2 /c1/2 and for L = 0 (which in practice means that L is as small as the smallest length scale in the problem rather than zero) if P a 2 /c1/2 > 2(Γ Γ ′ )1/2 ≈ K. Thus, it is clear that as c decreases, the interface can switch from weak pinning (if it was already in the weak pinning regime) to strong pinning. In the latter regime, by the arguments given in the last paragraph, the surfaces will be pinned together, i.e., there will be static friction. Because the interface area between two asperities in contact is only of micron size, there will be a transition from low to high, rather than from zero to nonzero static friction (as would occur for an infinite interface). This problem can also be considered using perturbation theory in the weak pinning limit [8]. To do this, following [8], one calculates u(r) which results from the random forces found from V (r) and from it calculates |u(R) − u(0)|2 using the standard expression for the elasticity Green’s function [9]. Here, · · · signifies an average over the random substrate forces. R is considered to be equal to the Larkin length when this quantity is comparable to the square of the range of a substrate potential well, as this represents the distance over which the surface of the solid can be considered as rigid from the point of view of the random substrate potential. Following arguments similar to those in [8], we find a Larkin length that is an exponential function of the ratio of Young’s modulus divided
6
J.B. Sokoloff
by V0 , which can easily be quite large compared to any reasonable size solid interface when this ratio is reasonably large, as it is in the weak pinning regime. Thus, even though the variational method that I used above gives an infinite Larkin length in the weak pinning limit, whereas the perturbation theory method of [8] gives a finite Larkin length, since the Larkin length found in [8] is extremely large (i.e., an exponential function of a fairly large number) in the weak pinning limit, the two methods can be considered to give qualitatively the same result.
1.3 FRICTION RESULTING FROM MULTISCALE ROUGHNESS On the basis of the above arguments, it appears that solid surfaces should almost never exhibit friction. Of course, no surfaces are perfectly smooth, and in fact, there can be roughness on several length scales. Let us assume then that there are n orders of length scales, which we represent as follows: We divide the surface into Mn asperities, a fraction cn of which are in contact with the second surface. In the discussion in this paragraph, the asperities are treated as rigid “hills” on the surface. Effects of distortion of the asperities will be treated later. At each pair of asperities in “contact” the contact is likely to only occur at selected isolated regions, which we may refer to as n − 1 order asperities. The interface between a pair of n − 1 order asperities can be divided up into n − 2 order asperities as well. The surfaces can never be truly self-affine, however, because when we reach atomic dimensions at n = 0 order, this sub-division into smaller and smaller length scales terminates. In more detail, we divide an N -atom surface (N is of the order of the nominal area of the surface divided by a 2 , where a is the mean interatomic spacing) into Mn asperities of which a fraction cn are in contact with the second surface, which for purposes of obtaining a qualitative understanding of the problem can be replaced by a flat substrate, as described above. We then divide the areas of contact of each of these contacting asperities into Mn−1 asperities, of which a fraction cn−1 are in contact. We then divide the area of contact between two contacting asperities into Mn−2 asperities, a fraction cn−2 of which are in contact, etc., until we have done n sub-levels of this sub-division. The area of contact of a zeroth level (i.e., smallest) asperity will contain of the order of N0 = N/(M0 M1 . . . Mn ) atoms, a fraction ca of which are in contact. It is these atoms at the zeroth (i.e., the final) order of asperities which support the load. If the nth order set of asperities are in the weak pinning regime, the static friction acting on it is reduced by a factor (cn Mn )1/2 , because by the above arguments, the static friction forces from these asperities act incoherently, and if the atoms at the interfaces of zerothorder asperities in contact are in the weak pinning regime, the static friction is reduced from the strong pinning regime value (i.e., μs not too much smaller than 1) by a factor (ca N0 )1/2 . This mechanism is proposed as a possible way to explain why coatings of stiff materials are good lubricants [10]. The arguments in the above paragraphs are only correct if each asperity is completely rigid, as we have assumed that the elastic forces which oppose displacements of the points of contact with the substrate resulting from the forces that the substrate exerts on them are due to the bulk solid. Since each asperity has some height, however, it can distort so as
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
7
to move its interface with the substrate closer to its potential minimum, even without distorting the bulk solid. Thus, whereas a particular substrate with completely rigid asperities might be in the weak pinning regime, if the asperities are able to distort by a sufficient amount, it might be in the strong pinning regime. This may explain why it is that although the estimates given earlier in this section indicate that most solids should be in the weak pinning regime, this is not consistent with the magnitudes of the friction coefficients that are observed for most solids. Let us now consider the distortions of the asperities that occur in response to the substrate potential [11]. What we will do now is to assume that there exists a bunch of smallest asperities (which will be considered the lowest or zeroth level) which are in contact with the substrate. There are several groups of these that are assumed to be attached to a bunch of larger next or first-order asperities. Groups of these first-order asperities are then attached to larger asperities called second-order asperities. This hierarchy continues until we reach an “asperity” of width equal to that of the whole interface. This hierarchy of asperities is illustrated schematically in Figure 1.3. Consider the zeroth, the lowest, order (i.e., the smallest) asperity. Let it have a height of order L′0 and a width of order L0 . To find its distortion resulting from the sum of the substrate potential energies of all of the atoms of the asperity which are in contact with the substrate, we must minimize the sum of its elastic and substrate potential energies. The substrate potential energy is given by V0 (L0 /a)f0 ( x0 /a), where V0 is the substrate potential strength felt by the asperity as it distorts while all higher level asperities remain in an arbitrary rigid configuration and f0 ( x0 /a) is a function of order unity which gives the variation of the substrate potential with x0 , the amount that the zeroth-order asperity distorts under the influence of the substrate potential, for fixed, undistorted asperities of higher order (i.e., larger size in the present context). (Clearly, each of the zeroth-order asperities has a different function; f0 denotes a generic function describing the interface
Figure 1.3 This is a schematic illustration of the asperity hierarchy on the top surface sliding on a flat substrate (i.e., the bottom block). (Real asperities have arbitrary shapes, as opposed to the square shapes shown in this schematic representation.) Each asperity of a given order has a number of (smaller) asperities of one order lower on its surface. In turn, each of these lower-order asperities has a number of (smaller) asperities of one order lower. This continues until we reach the zeroth-order asperity, whose surface consists of atoms, although only three orders of asperities are illustrated here.
8
J.B. Sokoloff
potential energy for a typical zeroth-order asperity.) Each function clearly must possess multiple minima. We are assuming here that the surface of the asperity in contact with the substrate is in the weak pinning limit. The factor (L0 /a), which is of the order of the square root of the number of atoms in this surface expresses this fact. If the surface of the asperity in contact with the substrate is in the strong pinning limit instead, this factor will be replaced by (L0 /a)2 , the number of atoms at the interface. (The scaling arguments used here for describing the asperities, assumes that we are considering the interface for a fixed load, and hence fixed area of contact for each asperity.) Treating this asperity as an elastic three-dimensional solid in contact with the substrate we find from the discussion earlier in this chapter that the interface between the substrate and this asperity is in the weak pinning limit if P0 < ca 1/2 K, where P0 is the mean load per unit interface area supported by this asperity and ca is the fraction of the surface atoms of this asperity that are in contact with the substrate. Assume that a fraction c0 of the zeroth-order asperities have atoms belonging to them in contact with the substrate. Let c1 represent the fraction of next order (first-order) asperities whose zeroth-order asperities are in contact with the substrate, c2 , the fraction of second-order asperities whose first-order asperities have their zeroth-order asperities in contact with the substrate, etc., up to nth order. Then P0 = P /(c0 c1 c2 . . . cn ), where P is the load per unit apparent area of the surface of the whole solid. Then, we conclude that the criterion for the atoms at the interface between the zeroth-order asperity and the substrate to be in the weak pinning regime is that P < (ca 1/2 c0 c1 c2 . . . cn )K. We see from this inequality that the more fractal the surface is, the more difficult it is for the zeroth-order asperity to be in the weak pinning regime. The cost in elastic energy due to the shear distortion of the asperity can be determined by the following scaling argument: The elastic energy density for shear distortion of the asperity is proportional to (∂ux /∂z)2 where ux represents the local displacement due to the distortion, the x-direction is along the interface and the z-direction is normal to it. The ux must scale with x0 and the dependence of ux on z has a length scale L′0 . Thus the elastic strain energy of the asperity is of the order of (1/2)L20 L′0 K( x0 /L′0 )2 , where K is the shear elastic constant and ( x0 /L′0 ) is the average shear strain and L0 is the mean width of the asperity. Minimizing the sum of these expressions for elastic and substrate potential energy, we obtain x0 /a ≈ V0 /Ka 3 (L′0 /L0 )f0′ ( x0 /a).
(4)
Since f0′ , the derivative of f0 with respect to its argument, it is of order one, from the definition of f0 . Let us follow a line of reasoning like that of [12] a modified version of which is given in Appendix B of [11]. For (V0 /Ka 3 )(L′0 /L0 ) below a certain value of order one, for small V0 /Ka 3 , Equation (4) can have only one solution for x0 . The reason for this is illustrated in Figure 1.4. Under such circumstances the average kinetic friction, in the limit as the sliding velocity approaches zero, is zero. For a surface with an infinite number of asperities, distributed uniformly in space, it was shown in [12] that the static friction is zero as well. A modified version of this argument, which points out that for a surface with a finite number of asperities the static friction is nonzero, but smaller by a factor of a/L0 compared to what it would be if the contributions of the asperities to static friction acted coherently is provided in Appendix B of [11]. If this asperity is in the strong pinning limit
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
9
Figure 1.4 This figure illustrates the solution of Equations (4), (5), and (6) for x0 , x1 and xn , respectively. The function f ′ (x) is a schematic illustration of the functions f0′ , f1′ and fn′ , and x denotes x0 , x1 or xn , respectively. Lines A and B represent the line y = (Ka 3 /V0 )(Ln /L′n )x, for (Ka 3 /V0 )(Ln /L′n ) < 1 and (Ka 3 /V0 )(Ln /L′n ) > 1, respectively. For the situation illustrated by line A, there are multiple solutions (i.e., multistability), while for the situation illustrated by line B, there is only one solution (i.e., there is mono-stability).
instead, we replace the factor of (L0 /a) by (L0 /a)2 to account for this and as a result, the factor (L′0 /L0 ) gets replaced by (L′0 /a), which could would easily make the asperity satisfy the criterion for multistability, and consequently, the friction from these asperities will no longer be reduced by the factor a/L0 . For a load per unit area P , assumed to be primarily due to hard core interactions, we may assume V0 ≈ P a 3 /c, where c is the fraction of the surface atoms which are in contact with the substrate. By the above arguments, c = ca c0 c1 c2 . . . cn . Then, we see that the criterion for the zeroth-order asperity to be multistable is P > ca c0 c1 c2 . . . cn K. If the criterion for weak pinning for the zeroth-order asperity surface is not satisfied, the criterion for monostability of this asperity gets changed from the above inequality to (V0 /Ka 3 )(L′0 /a) < 1, which is more difficult to satisfy since L′0 /a can be considerably greater than 1. At the next level, we have an asperity surface in contact with the substrate which consists of a collection of the lowest level (i.e., the smallest) asperities discussed in the previous paragraph. Assuming this asperity to be in the weak pinning regime, the potential of interaction with the substrate, which is the sum of all of the interactions of the substrate with the lowest-order asperities, which cover a first-order asperity, is of order V0 (L0 /a)(L1 /L0 )f1 ( x1 /a). Here L1 represents the width of this order asperity, x1 represents a displacement of the lower surface of this level asperity for fixed (i.e., undistorted) configurations of all higher-order asperities, and f1 denotes one of the functions which describes the interface potential energy of one of the first-order asperities. It has at least one minimum and runs over a range of magnitude one as its argument runs over a range of order one. The elastic energy is of the order of (1/2)L′1 L21 K( x1 /L′1 )2 , by the argument given above Equation (1), where L′1 is the height of the body of the first-order asperity, which is assumed to be much larger than L′0 . Minimizing the sum of these two energies, we obtain x1 /a ≈ V0 /Ka 3 (L′1 /L1 )f1′ ( x1 /a).
(5)
Again, we conclude, based on the arguments presented in [12], that the static friction is reduced by a factor of L0 /L1 below what it would be if the contributions to the static
10
J.B. Sokoloff
friction from each of the mini-asperities at this level acted coherently. If the zeroth-order asperities attached to this first-order asperity are in the strong pinning regime, the factor of L1 /L0 in the equation for the interaction of this asperity with the substrate is replaced by (L1 /L0 )2 , and hence, the right-hand side of Equation (2) has the factor L′1 /L1 replaced by L′1 /L0 , which can make the solutions to this equation for x1 multistable. Continuing this procedure, we find that the displacement of the nth level mini-asperity is found by solving xn /a ≈ V0 /Ka 3 (L′n /Ln )fn′ ( xn /a),
(6)
where Ln and L′n are the width and height of the body of the nth level asperity. If (V0 /Ka 3 ) > 1, and L′n /Ln ≈ 1 for all n, asperities of all orders will be multistable, implying the occurrence of large static friction. Substituting for V0 using V0 ≈ P a 3 /c, we find that this condition is equivalent to P > cK. If the condition given earlier for strong 1/2 1/2 pinning at the zeroth-order asperity interface, namely P > ca c0 c1 . . . cn K = (c/ca )K is satisfied, the condition for multistability on all levels, P > cK is certainly satisfied. Although plastic deformation for a bulk solid occurs when P exceeds the hardness of the material, which is generally much less than Young’s modulus, such small values of the hardness result from the presence of dislocations in the material. In the case of the very small length scale asperities considered here, however, the asperity does not have enough volume to accommodate a dislocation. Therefore, plastic deformation at this level should occur when the forces at the atomic level exceed the maximum interatomic force. This translates into the requirement that P /c exceed a quantity comparable to Young’s modulus. Since Young’s modulus is generally significantly larger than the shear modulus K, it should be quite possible for P /c to exceed K (the above criterion for multistability) while still being less than Young’s modulus. Let us now make numerical estimates of whether the lowest-order asperity is likely to be monostable, implying low static friction. To do this, we will apply the present model to a single micron-scale asperity in contact with the substrate. Typical values of K are of the order of 1011 N/m2 . In [13], P at the micron scale asperity level was estimated from the Greenwood–Williamson model [14] to be about 109 N/m2 which is also the maximum value of the load per unit contact area in the Greenwood–Williamson model [14], and hence V0 /Ka 3 ≈ 0.01/c, since V0 ≈ P a 3 /c. (Figure 3 in [14] is actually not correct. The mean pressure per asperity as a function of load should actually be zero at zero load and saturate at a maximum value as the load increases.) Thus from Equation (1), if (L′0 /L0 ) is of order 1, the zeroth-order asperity will be monostable if c = ca c0 c1 . . . cn > 0.01. If this condition is not satisfied, the interface will be multistable, and hence, it will exhibit relatively high friction. This makes it likely that all order asperities and hence the interface will be monostable as well, resulting in very low friction. It should be pointed out here that the mechanism for weak pinning discussed here is different from the mechanism discussed in [7] and earlier in this chapter in that it does not result from interactions between asperities (i.e., the collective pinning mechanism). It produces the same result as we found earlier assuming stiff asperities, however, namely that the friction between two asperities at a given length scale is reduced by a factor of the square root of the number of asperities
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
11
at the next lower length scale order present on its surface. This means that the friction coefficient is reduced from the strong pinning value (which is not much less than one) by a factor of nn′ =0 (Ln′ −1 /Ln′ ) where L−1 = a and the product includes only values of n′ corresponding to orders of asperities which are monostable. When the zeroth-order asperity interface is monostable, we saw that all higher-order asperities will be monostable as well. In this case the above product reduces to a/Ln for the factor by which the friction coefficient is reduced below one. As Ln in our numerical example is approximately 1 µm, this leads to a reduction factor of the order of 10−4 . We saw that the condition for the interface to be monostable, and hence exhibit ultra-low friction is that the ratio P /c be less than K. The quantity c, as it was defined earlier, can be thought of approximately as the ratio of the area of contact to the apparent area of the interface (although, as pointed out earlier, this is not precise). Since all calculations of this quantity for rough interfaces [14,15] give a constant value of this ratio, at least for small values of P , whether the surface is in the strong or weak pinning regime in the small P limit, it will remain in that regime as P increases, implying that the criterion for weak pinning depends only on the value of K and the degree of roughness of the surface as evidenced by the value of c. Since for larger values (for which c ≈ 0.05) c was found in the finite elements calculation of [15] to be a sub-linear function of P , it is possible that the interface will switch from weak to strong pinning for sufficiently large P . The results presented here only require that the restoring forces for horizontal distortions of the asperities be elastic. Therefore, they might not be invalidated even if compressions of the asperities normal to the interface, resulting from the load, are plastic [14,15]. At the numerical values of P for which we estimate that we will be in the low friction regime, however, the assumption of a purely elastic solid is quite likely to be valid. The discussion given above predicts that a material with sufficient large shear modulus should have very low friction. This may be a possible explanation for the well known fact that coating a surface with a material which has a high elastic constant and is chemically inert, such as saturated diamond (whose shear modulus is at least a factor of 6 larger than that of other solids [16]) or amorphous carbon, can significantly reduce friction [10]. Tartaglino, Samoilov and Persson [17] have recently used a multiscale molecular dynamics simulation method [18] to show that relatively small amplitude multiscale roughness can eliminate superlubricity for a disordered interface. Although a detailed numerical comparison with the scaling treatment discussed here [7,11] has not as yet been made, the two methods seem to yield qualitatively similar results.
1.4 SUPERLUBRICITY RESULTING FROM POLYMER BRUSHES Another way to achieve extremely low friction is to coat the surfaces of two solids sliding in contact with each other with polymer brushes. A polymer brush consists of a fairly concentrated coating of polymer chains, each one of which has one of its two ends tightly bound to the surface. They serve as an extremely effective lubricant, producing friction coefficients as low as 0.001 or less [19,20]! Polymer brushes are a promising way to reduce friction to extremely low values. In order to function as a lubricant, they must be immersed in a good solvent. The presence of a solvent causes the polymer brush to extend,
12
J.B. Sokoloff
allowing it to support load and produce osmotic pressure which also partially supports the load. The polymer brush lubrication mechanism is a good candidate for the well known extremely efficient lubrication of human and animal joints [19,20]. This mechanism can also provide extremely effective lubrication in many other applications. At first thought, one might say that the existence of such low friction for polymer brush coated surfaces is a trivial result because they are soaked with solvent, and hence one would expect the solvent to provide hydrodynamic lubrication. Indeed, it is well known that it is possible to design specially shaped surfaces, known as hydrodynamic bearings which guarantee that the sliding surfaces will be supported by a liquid lubricant present at the interface [21]. For the slow speed sliding limit, however, there will not be significant hydrodynamic pressure to support the load. In this situation a viscous fluid will in general not be able to prevent two surfaces from touching because there is nothing to keep most of the fluid from getting squeezed out from between the surfaces. For most liquid lubricants, it is the thin quasi-solid coating [22] which remains at the interface which is responsible for the boundary lubrication. The resulting lubrication mechanism is not hydrodynamic, but rather must come about from other mechanisms [7]. Polymer brushes provide a way to hold the fluid in place between the surfaces, so that it can support the load. For example, if there exists a solute which is constrained to remain in the region between the surfaces, the fluid would be drawn in to dilute the solute, resulting in osmotic pressure, which might be able to support the load. The monomers belonging to the polymers attached to the two surfaces could play the role of such a solute. The monomers are constrained to remain between the surfaces because they are held together to form a polymer. If it were determined that the osmotic pressure due to the low monomer density in the interface region is able to support the load, the friction would be extremely low viscous friction, i.e., friction which approaches zero as the sliding velocity approaches zero, as opposed to the usual sliding friction between two solids, which approaches a nonzero value in the zero sliding velocity limit. Furthermore, because of the low polymer density in such an interface region, there would be little wear resulting from polymers getting detached from the surfaces as a result of polymers belonging to one brush getting entangled in the second brush and then being pulled out. Some experimental results on polymer brushes [23] do, however, show static friction. It is also likely that there will be nonzero kinetic friction as well in the limit as the sliding velocity approaches zero, as occurs for the usual friction between solid surfaces (i.e., Amonton’s law friction). Therefore, it is important to study theoretically how the interactions of two polymer brushes in contact can lead to the observed magnitude and time dependence of static and nearly velocity independent kinetic friction in the slow speed sliding limit. One important question that must be answered is whether it is possible to have true static friction for polymer brush lubricated surfaces, or whether it is only possible to have a highly viscous sliding motion, which over short times appears to be static friction. This question was addressed in a recent publication [24]. This treatment of the problem, which is based on the study of microscopic physical mechanisms, combines the mean field methods of Witten et al. [25], the Flory treatment of entanglement of polymers [26], the penetration of polymers from one brush into the second brush, and a Tomlinson-like model [12] to entangled polymers to obtain the observed static and slow speed kinetic friction. Whereas reptation [26] (snake-like diffusion of a polymer among other polymers
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
13
among which it is entangled) may account for creep of the surfaces due to the polymers from the brushes becoming disentangled in time, the friction observed even at relatively slow sliding speeds cannot be accounted for by this mechanism because reptation is too slow. In [21], the creep rate for the polymer brush coated surfaces was found to be about a mm/h. The maximum load per unit contact area that a polymer brush lubricant can support before losing its low friction properties (because it becomes glass-like), is approximately one mega-Pascal. The combination of the roughness of the surfaces and the fact that the elastic constants for most solids are fairly large (around 1011 N/m2 ), however, result in the load being supported by a very small area of contact for most solid surfaces, resulting in each asperity supporting a mean load per unit asperity contact area of about 1 GPa [14]. For lubrication of human and animal joints by a polymer brush mechanism, the polymers are attached to cartilage, which is a relatively soft material [19,20,27], compared to most solids. Young’s modulus for cartilage is of the order of only 105 N/m2 . As a consequence, the load per unit contact area that must be supported is likely to be in the order of a mega-Pascal (MPa), making the polymer brush lubrication mechanism an attractive hypothesis for very effective lubrication in this system, as well as in other applications, as long as it is possible to first coat the surfaces that we wish to lubricate with an elastically soft material, to which the polymers are then attached. Since many polymers, are charged, it will be necessary to consider polyelectrolyte brushes, whose equilibrium properties have been studied using mean field theory by Zhulina et al. [28], Misra [29] and Miklavic [30]. Polyelectrolyte polymer brushes should be even more effective lubricants than neutral polymer brushes discussed above because the electric charge will support part of the load and there will be additional osmotic pressure produced by the counter ions always present in polyelectrolyte solutions to support the load. Milner et al. [31], proposed a simple way to solve the mean field theory for polymers attached at one end to a surface. In this treatment, the minimization of the free energy of the polymer brush requires that the location of the nth monomer on the ith polymer, ri (n) satisfies the equation d2 ri (n)/dn2 = ∇ wφ(ri (n) ,
(7)
where φ(r) is the monomer density and w is the strength of the monomer–monomer repulsion. This can be thought of as an “equation of motion” for the monomers, in which the index n labeling the monomers plays the role of time. It is formally analogous to Newton’s second law for motion of a particle in a potential equal to −wφ(ri (n)). Existence of a solution of the mean field equations of motion requires that φ(r) be a parabolic function of z [31]. In [20] Equation (7) was solved for forms of φ(r) which correspond to two polymer brushes in contact and two polymer brushes almost in contact. Specifically, in both cases, Equation (7) was solved for a polymer that extends out of the (parabolic [31]) monomer density profile of the polymer brush to which it belongs (by virtue of the fact that it is attached to the surface to which the polymers belonging to that brush are attached). For the case in which the two polymer brushes are actually in contact, this polymer will be entangled in the brush to which it does not belong (i.e., the polymer brush whose polymers are attached to the other surface). In both cases, the mean number of monomers of the polymer under consideration which extend out of its brush can be found by calculating from
14
J.B. Sokoloff
this solution to Equation (7) the cost in free energy to pull this polymer out of the brush. When the polymer brushes are in contact, any polymer that extends into the brush to which it does not belong forms “blobs” that fit in the spaces in mesh of that brush [26]. When one attempts to slide the surfaces relative to each other, these blobs must be pulled out of the brush in which they have gotten entangled. The force needed to do this was calculated in [24] and found to be consistent with the static friction measured in [23]. An argument based on the Tomlinson model [12] was then used, to find the kinetic friction in the limit of zero sliding velocity (which is likely not much different than the static friction) due to entanglement of the polymers. Reference [24] also discusses the possibility that the monomer density profile of the two brushes might not need to be in contact to support the load, leading to extremely low friction. The load would then be completely supported by the osmotic pressure in an interface region between the two brushes (i.e., the bulk regions of the two polymer brushes are not in contact) due to the fact that polymers from the two brushes occasionally fluctuate into the interface region. In such a case, there would be no static friction, and the kinetic friction would be relatively small viscous friction, which approaches zero as the sliding velocity approaches zero. The amount of load that can be supported by the osmotic pressure is estimated and found to be about 104 Pa.
1.5
CONCLUSIONS
In this chapter, the concept of superlubricity for interfaces between both incommensurate crystalline and disordered solid surfaces was discussed. Some of the differences in behavior of these two examples of superlubricity were discussed. A possible explanation for why superlubricity is not generally observed, based on multiscale surface roughness was given. It was suggested that the occurrence of superlubricity for stiff surfaces may provide an explanation for why hard carbon films are such good lubricants. Polymer brush lubrication was shown to be another mechanism for obtaining extremely low friction. It was argued that what the polymer brush might accomplish is to keep the lubricating liquid in place between the surfaces being lubricated, so that it is able to support the load while allowing the shear to take place within the fluid. This results in very low viscous friction.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]
Hirano, M., Shinjo, K. Phys. Rev. B 41 (1990), 11837; Shinjo, K., Hirano, M. Surf. Sci. 283 (1993), 473. Aubry, S. In: Bishop, A.R., Schneider, T. (Eds.), Solitons and Condensed Matter. Springer, 1978, p. 264. Sacco, J.E., Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Rev. B 18 (1978), 6549. Muser, M.H., Robbins, M.O. Phys. Rev. B 61 (2000), 2335. He, G., Muser, M.H., Robbins, M.O. Science 284 (1999), 1650. Lancon, F. Europhys. Lett. 57 (2002), 74. Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Rev. E 71 (2005), 056107. Persson, B.N.J., Tosatti, E. Solid State Comm. 109 (1999), 739; In: Persson, B.N.J., Tosatti, E. (Eds.), Physics of Sliding Friction. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1995, p. 179; Popov, V.L. Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 (1999), 1632. [9] Landau, L.D., Lifshitz, E.M. Theory of Elasticity, second edition. Pergamon Press, New York, 1970.
Superlubricity for Incommensurate Crystalline and Disordered Interfaces
15
[10] Heimberg, J.A., Wahl, K.J., Singer, I.L., Erdemir, A. Appl. Phys. Lett. 78 (2001), 2449–2451; Gao, G.T., Mikulski, P.T., Harrison, J.A. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124 (2002), 7202–7209; Gao, G.T., Mikulski, P.T., Chateauneuf, G.M., Harrison, J.A. J. Phys. Chem. B 107 (2003), 11082–11090; Rha, J.J., Kwon, S.C., Cho, J.R., Kim, S., Saka, N. Proc. Wear 2005 Conference. [11] Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Rev. E 73 (2006), 016104. [12] Caroli, C., Nozieres, Ph. European Phys. J. B 4 (1998), 233; Caroli, C., Nozieres, Ph. Physics of Sliding Friction, Persson, B.N.J., Tosatti, E. (Eds.). NATO ASI Series E: Applied Sciences, Vol. 311, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1996; M. Brillouin, Notice sur les Travaux Scientifiques. Gautier-Villars, Paris, 1909; Tomlinson, G.A. Phil. Mag. 7 (1929), 905. [13] Volmer, A., Natterman, T. Z. Phys. B 104 (1997), 363; Sokoloff, J.B. Static friction between elastic solids due to random asperities. Phys. Rev Lett. 86 (2001), 3312; Sokoloff, J.B. Explaining the virtual universal occurrence of static friction. Phys. Rev. B 65 (2002), 115415. [14] Greenwood, J.A., Williamson, J.B.P. Proc. Roy. Soc. London, Ser. A 295 (1996), 300; Mc Cool, J.I. Wear 107 (1986), 37060. [15] Hyun, S., Pei, L., Molinari, J.F., Robbins, M.O. Phys. Rev. E 70 (2004), 026117; Robbins, M.O. Invited talk at the March 2005 American Physical Society Meeting. [16] Kittell, C. Introduction to Solid State Physics, second edition. John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1956, p. 93. [17] Tartaglino, U., Samiolov, V.N., Persson, B.N.J. J. Phys.: Condensed Matter 18 (2006), 4143–4160. [18] Yang, C., Tartaglino, U., Persson, B.N.J. European Phys. J. E 19 (2006), 47–58. [19] Klein, J. Ann. Rev. Mat. Sci. 26 (1996), 581–612; Proceedings of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers, Part J. Journal of Engineering Tribology, Special Issue on Biolubrication 220 (2006), 691–710. [20] Yan, X., Perry, S.S., Spencer, N.D., Pasche, S., DePaul, S.M., Textor, M., Lim, M.S. Langmuir 20 (2004), 423–428; Lee, S., Muller, M., Ratoi-Salagean, M., Voros, J., Pasche, S., De Paul, S.M., Spikes, H.A., Textor, M., Spencer, N.D. Tribology Lett. 15 (2003), 231–239; Muller, M., Lee, S., Spikes, H.A., Spencer, N.D. Tribology Lett. 15 (2003), 395–405. [21] Dowson, D., Wright, V., Longfield, M.D. Biomedical Engineering 4 (1969), 160. [22] Chan, D.Y.C., Horn, R.G. J. Chem. Phys. 83 (1985), 5311; Israelachvili, J.N. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 110 (1986), 263; Reiter, G., Demirel, A.L., Granick, S. Science 263 (1994), 1741; Israelachvili, J.N. Intermolecular and Surface Forces, second edition. Academic Press, 1992; Bhushan, B., Israelachvili, J.N., Landman, U. Nature (London) 374 (1995), 607; Granick, S. Science 253 (1991), 1374. [23] Tadmor, R., Janik, J., Klein, J., Fetters, L.J. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91 (2003), 115503. [24] Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Rev. E, submitted for publication. This reference is paper no. cond-mat/0602320 on the arxiv preprint server as well as at http://www.physics.neu.edu/Department/Vtwo/faculty/sokoloff.htm. [25] Witten, T.A., Leibler, L., Pincus, P.A. Macromolecules 23 (1990), 824–829. [26] de Gennes, P.-G. Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, 1979. [27] Lambert, R.K., Baile, E.M., Moreno, R., Bert, J., Pare, P.D. J. Appl. Physiol. 70 (1991), 1152–1159. [28] Zulina, E.B., Borisov, O.V., Birshtein, T.M. J. Phys. II France 2 (1992), 63–74. [29] Misra, S., Varanasi, S., Varanasi, P.P. Macromolecules 22 (1989), 4173–4179. [30] Miklavic, S.J., Marcelja, S. J. Phys. Chem. 92 (1988), 6718–6722. [31] Milner, S.T., Witten, T.A., Cates, M.E. Macromolecules 21 (1988), 2610–2619.
This page intentionally left blank
–2– Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces Motohisa Hirano Gifu University, 1-1, Yanagido, Gifu, 501-1193, Japan
2.1 INTRODUCTION When two solid bodies contact each other and one body begins to slide against the other, a frictional phenomenon appears. The friction force is the drag against sliding, appearing along the contacting surfaces. According to whether or not two bodies move relatively, the friction forces are classified into the static and the dynamic ones. They have the different physical origins [1]. Two pictures (or models) have been advocated for the origin of the friction forces [1–3]. The first is called the surface roughness model. The contacting solid surfaces are so rough that surface asperities are mechanically locked against the gravitational force. It is necessary to apply an external force to slide one body against the other. This mechanical-locking mechanism was conjectured especially by the earlier workers such as da Vinci, Amonton, and Coulomb, and concerns with the origin of the static frictional force [4,5]. The weakest point of the surface roughness model is that basically it fails to explain an energy dissipation for the origin of the dynamic friction force since the gravitational force is an energy-conserving force. Another is due to the adhesive force between constituent atoms. The importance of the adhesive force has been first recognized by Desaguliers [6]. The adhesive force, however, is clearly different from the friction force along the contacting interface. How do the friction forces relate to the adhesive force? From an atomistic point of view, Tomlinson has described a mechanism of the energy dissipation for the origin of the dynamic frictional force, based on the adhesion model [7]. He assumed the non-adiabatic (or abrupt) change of the positions of atoms during sliding, which subsequently transforms the elastic energy into the vibrational energy. His picture involves the irreversible physical process, i.e., the energy dissipation in its natural form. Tomlinson proposed the possible mechanism for the origin of the friction forces, but did not inquire of whether or not his mechanism occurs in the realistic frictional systems [7]. The state in which friction between two sliding solids is zero and the solids slide without resistance to motion is called “superlubricity”. While such absence of friction runs counter to common sense, superlubricity does appear in realistic systems where metallic bonding, Superlubricity Edited by A. Erdemir and J.-M. Martin © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
18
M. Hirano
for example, operates. The state of zero friction is closely related to the state in which friction appears, and the existence of superlubricity has been predicted by defining the state in which friction appears. The question as to why friction appears, that is, the problem of finding the origins of friction, has been considered for a long time [1]. Friction, however, is influenced by many factors (such as plastic deformation, fractures, electromagnetic fields, chemical reactions, and ambient humidity) in a complicated manner, and it has been difficult to define these factors to examine the mechanisms that give rise to friction. In most experiments, the interpretation of experimental results has consequently been confined to phenomenology [3]. It is, therefore, important that the mechanisms of friction should be investigated at the atomic level and that the atomistic origins of friction should be clarified. New experimental techniques are making it possible to investigate friction on a clean surface at atomic-level resolutions [8]. From an atomistic point of view, the frictional systems of the idealized solid surfaces, which are assumed to be clean and flat, have been studied [9]. The system consists of many atoms interacting with each other by the Morse [10] or the Johnson potential [11], which is expected to simulate the realistic interaction potentials. The criterion for Tomlinson’s mechanism to occur has been obtained [9]. From studying the various systems, it has been concluded that Tomlinson’s mechanism is unlikely to occur in the realistic frictional systems [9]. This conclusion leads to finding superlubricity: a state of vanishing friction. Superlubricity was thus discovered from this research into the origins of friction [9,12]. This chapter describes the atomistics of friction explaining the atomistic origin of the friction forces and discusses the mechanisms of superlubricity based on a model from atomistic theory. The first condition for superlubricity to appear is the adiabatic motion of atoms. If this condition is satisfied, friction will always be zero at the limit, where sliding speed of the solid is zero, being independent of the time scale of observation. Superlubricity, i.e., a state of vanishing friction, is discussed and it is emphasized that the high dimensionality of friction model is essential for the appearance of superlubricity. The second condition is energy recurrence phenomena [13]. If this condition is satisfied, recurrence phenomena occur through the dynamics of atomic motion and the friction force observed in the time scale of recurrence is zero.
2.2
PRELIMINARIES: TOMLINSON’S PICTURE
Tomlinson proposed an atomistic picture for the origin of the frictional forces. Let us describe an essence of his idea. Suppose the friction system consisting of four atoms numbered by 1, and 1′ , 2′ , and 3′ as seen in Figure 2.1. All atoms are assumed to interact with each other. The atom 1 forms a part of the upper body, which interact with the other atoms of the upper body (not illustrated in Figure 2.1), and the atoms 1′ , 2′ , and 3′ form the lower body. We shall concentrate on the behavior of the atom 1 when the upper body slowly slides against the lower. When the atom 1 is on the atom 2′ , the atom 1 feels the attraction from the atom 2′ , as seen in Figure 2.1(a). During sliding, the atom 1 moves towards the right direction. When the sliding displacement is small, this is a process of storing the elastic energy, as seen in Figure 2.1(b). When the atom 1 goes beyond the certain distance, the
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
19
Figure 2.1 The friction system consisting of four atoms numbered by 1, and 1′ , 2′ , and 3′ . All atoms are assumed to interact with each other. The atom 1 non-adiabatically (abruptly) changes its position during sliding. The non-adiabaticity leads to transforming the elastic energy into the vibrational or kinetic energy of the atom 1. The vibrational energy of the atom 1 may be considered to dissipate into the vibrational energies of other atoms, i.e., into the thermal energy. This picture involves the irreversible physical process, i.e., the energy dissipation in its natural form.
attraction from the atom 3′ overwhelms that from the atom 2′ . The atom 1 prefers the position on the atom 3′ . Then, he assumes that the atom 1 non-adiabatically (abruptly) changes its position. The non-adiabaticity leads to transforming the elastic energy into the vibrational or kinetic energy of the atom 1, as seen in Figure 2.1(c). The vibrational energy of the atom 1 may be considered to dissipate into the vibrational energies of other atoms, i.e., into the thermal energy. This picture involves the irreversible physical process, the energy dissipation in its natural form. If the atom 1 is assumed only to change its position slowly, the atom 1 may not take an excess kinetic energy, which is concluded from the adiabatic theorem [14]. Here, we shall list some timescales relevant to the frictional systems. The sliding velocity may be 10−3 to 100 meter per second. The frequency of the atomic motion is about 1014 times per second. The upper body may slide about 10−17 to 10−14 meters per a frequency of atom, which is very small compared with the atomic interdistance of an order of 10−10 meters. The change of the potential which the atom feels during the frequency time of the atomic motion is very small; the parameter characterizing its change, ( T /v) × dv/dT , becomes 10−7 to 10−4 . This consideration implies that the atom 1 can adiabatically follow the change of the potentials yielded by sliding if the atom 1 does not change its position abruptly. As pointed out by Tomlinson [7], the assumption of the slow movement of the atom 1 fails to explain the energy dissipation in the dynamic process of friction. To clarify his idea, we shall describe this process by using a simplified model [15,16]. The atom 1 interacts with the other atoms of the upper body whose coordinate is symbolically expressed by Q. The atom 1 also interacts with the atoms of the lower body, which is assumed to be rigid. We shall concentrate on the equilibrium position of the atom 1 during sliding. The equilibrium position of the atom 1 can be determined by minimizing the interaction potential energy v(Q, r) = v1 (Q − r) + v2 (r),
(1)
where r is the position of the atom 1, v1 (Q − r) describes the interaction between the coordinate Q and the atom 1, and v2 (r) the interaction between the atom and the lower
20
M. Hirano
Figure 2.2 The explanation of Tomlinson’s mechanism by using the potential surface. The shape of the potential surface v(Q, r) depends on Q. The equilibrium position of the atom 2 is indicated by a circle, and another possible equilibrium position by the dotted circles. The left and the right local minima correspond to the equilibrium position on the atom 2′ and that on the atom 3′ , respectively. In the processes from (a) to (d), r(Q)continuously varies withQ. At the process in (d), r(Q) sites on the saddle point of the potential surface. When one proceeds further, r(Q) changes discontinuously from the left minimum to the right one as shown in (d) and (e). Then, the potential-energy difference E between two local minima transforms into the kinetic energy of the atom through the non-adiabatic change of the position of the atom 2. The kinetic energy may be consumed into exciting the vibrations of the surrounding atoms, i.e., into the thermal energy. The ingredient of this process is an appearance of the discontinuity in the equilibrium positions of atoms.
body. Q stands for the displacement coordinate of the sliding upper body against the lower one. The equilibrium position of atom is determined as a function of Q. Tomlinson’s picture may be described by using the potential surface as follows. The shape of the potential surface v(Q, r) depends on Q. Under the appropriate conditions, the potential surface takes the various shapes as Q varies, as shown in Figure 2.2. The equilibrium position of the atom 1 is indicated by a circle, and another possible equilibrium position by the dotted circle. The left and the right local minima, correspond to the equilibrium positions on the atom 2′ and 3′ , respectively. In the processes from Figure 2.2(a) to (d), r(Q) continuously varies with Q. At the process in Figure 2.2(d), r(Q) sites on the saddle point of the potential surface. When one proceeds further, r(Q) changes discontinuously from the left minimum to the right one, as shown in Figure 2.2(d) and (e). Then, the potential energy difference E between two local minima transforms into the kinetic energy of the atom by non-adiabatically changing the position of the atom 1. The kinetic
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
21
energy further may be consumed into exciting the vibrations of the surrounding atoms, i.e. into the thermal energy. The ingredient of this process is an appearance of the discontinuity in the equilibrium positions of atoms. The same mechanism has been described by the other workers [15,16]. Tomlinson proposed the possible mechanism of the origin of the frictional forces, but did not inquire of whether or not his mechanism occurs in the realistic frictional systems. The criterion for the occurrence of his mechanism has been obtained, and it has been concluded that Tomlinson’s mechanism is unlikely to occur in realistic systems [9].
2.3 THE CRITERION FOR THE OCCURRENCE OF TOMLINSON’S MECHANISM The adiabatic potential of the frictional system is defined by the total energy when two contacting solid bodies slide against each other. This assumes that the upper body slides against a fixed lower body. It is also assumed that the upper body has N u atoms and the lower body N l atoms, and that the constituent atoms belonging to both bodies interact with y each other. The position coordinates of the atoms are denoted by ri = (rix , ri , riz ) where i = 1, 2, . . . , (N u + N l ). The adiabatic potential is obtained by u
V (Q) =
l
N N i
j
u
u
,N 1 N Vaa |ri − rj | . Vab |ri − rj | + 2
(2)
i,j
Q stands for the displacement vector of the upper body against the lower body. An ri coordinate set satisfies the relationship l
u
Q=
N
ri /N
i
u
and 0 =
N
ri /N l .
(3)
i
Thus, the adiabatic potential spans a 3(N u + N l − 1)-dimensional potential surface. Since that Vab (0) = 0 and Vaa (0) = 0. Here, the summation of j in the first term of the right-hand side is expressed by l
l
V (r) =
N j
Vab |r − rj | .
(4)
V l (r)is the interaction energy that the atoms of the upper body receive from the atoms of the lower body. The terms Vbb (|ri − rj |) is dropped, since it has no Q-dependence. V l (r) has a periodicity characterized by the primitive vectors of the top layer of the lower body. The occurrence of the nonadiabatic (discontinuous) motion of atoms, i.e., Tomlinson’s mechanism means that the atom can not take the arbitrary equilibrium position. This is
22
M. Hirano
equivalent to a condition that the second derivatives of V (Q, r) with respect to r becomes be negative at the position where d2 V l (r)/dr 2 takes the largest negative value. The criterion for the occurrence of Tomlinson’s mechanism is given by [9], d2 V (Q, rmax ) d2 V u (Q − rmax ) d2 V l (rmax ) = + < 0 for a certain Q, 2 2 2 drmax drmax drmax
(5)
where V l (r) is interaction from the atoms of the lower body. V u (r) is interaction from the atoms of the 2nd, 3rd, . . . layers of the upper body. rmax stands for the position defining the largest negative value of d2 V l (r)/dr 2 , and Q stands for the displacement coordinate of the sliding upper body against the lower one. Here it is important to note that there occurs the case where Tomlinson’s mechanism does not occur. For example, we shall consider the case in which it is assumed that V u (Q − r) = k(Q − r − l)2 /2, where k is the elastic constant and l is the average mean distance between Q and r, and that V l (r) = f sin r, where f is the adhesive force and sin r represents atomic displacement whose amplitude is normalized to be unity. When substituting these interaction potentials into Equation (5), the relation k < f is obtained. For k = 1 and f < 1, Tomlinson’s mechanism does not occur. This result suggests that Tomlinson’s mechanism is likely to occur only when the interaction or adhesion between two bodies, being specified by f , becomes strong. This suggestion generally holds valid since the equilibrium positions of atoms of the upper body are slightly disturbed by the lower body for the weak case of adhesion. The equilibrium position r(Q) corresponds to the minimum point of the potential surface V (Q, r) for the given Q. Let us define an ensemble of r(Q) when Q takes various values, which is called a domain D. The problem of whether or not the Tomlinson mechanism occurs can be understood from the topological property of the domain D. When V l (r) has a periodicity of the crystalline structure, it is enough to examine the unit domain in the region 0 < r(Q) < l (l: the crystal periodicity length). The whole domain can be obtained by tiling this unit domain repeatedly. The domains are shown in Figure 2.3, according to whether or not Tomlinson’s mechanism occurs. The V l (r) is shown by a solid line, the domain for the non-occurrence of Tomlinson’s mechanism by the connected bold solid line, and that for the occurrence of Tomlinson’s mechanism by the disconnected bold lines. In moving relatively, the atom can slide by continuously changing its equilibrium position, shown by the connected bold lines. On the other hand, the atom can slide only by changing its equilibrium position discontinuously between two disconnected unit domains, shown by the disconnected bold lines. Thus, the occurrence (or non-occurrence) of Tomlinson’s mechanism is studied by examining whether the unit domains are disconnected or connected, i.e., the topological property of the tiled unit domains. This argument can be extended to the realistic frictional systems where the contacting interface is not one-dimensional but two-dimensional. The domains, where the atom can take its equilibrium position, are shown in Figure 2.4 when the adhesion increases between the upper and the lower bodies. Figure 2.4 corresponds to the case where the contacting surface of the lower body has the oblique-square crystalline symmetry. The point different from the one-dimensional case is that the path where the atom can slide by continuously changing its equilibrium position depends on the direction of sliding displacement coordinate Q. For example, let us consider four cases,
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
23
Figure 2.3 Topological property of the whole domain obtained by tiling the unit domain repeatedly. Domains are shown according to whether or not Tomlinson’s mechanism occurs. v2 (r) is shown by a solid line, the domain for the non-occurrence of Tomlinson’s mechanism by the connected bold solid line, and that for the occurrence of Tomlinson’s mechanism by the disconnected bold lines. In moving relatively, the atom can slide by continuously changing its equilibrium position. On the other hand, the atom can slide only by changing its equilibrium position discontinuously between two disconnected domains. The occurrence (or non-occurrence) of Tomlinson’s mechanism is studied by examining the topological property of the tiled unit domains.
as shown in Figure 2.4(a)–(d). The atom can slide towards arbitrary direction by continuously changing its equilibrium position for the case shown in Figure 2.4(a) and (b). In the case shown in Figure 2.4(c), the atom can slide continuously in the x-direction, but can slide in the y-direction only by discontinuous transformation. The atom can slide only by discontinuously changing its equilibrium position in any direction for the case shown in Figure 2.4(d). As seen above, the frictional property depends on the topological property, i.e., the disconnectedness or connectedness of the domains where the atom can take the equilibrium position. The three-dimensional frictional system [9] consisting of many interacting atoms is written by Nu Nu 1 u l V ri (Q) − rj (Q) + V ri (Q) , V Q, ri (Q) = 2 i
(6)
j ( =i)
where Q is the vector specifying the center of mass of the upper solid body, and is given by u
Q=
N
ri /N u .
(7)
i
Here, ri (Q) describes the equilibrium position coordinate of the ith atom of the upper solid surface, and N u is the total number of atoms of the upper solid surfaces. It has been examined whether the domain is connected or disconnected at the critical points, the centers of the ridges lines connecting between two adjacent atoms of the lower solid surface, which are indicated by the arrows in Figure 2.4(a) [4]. The criterion is given as a condition that the potential energy is a concave function in a direction perpendicular to the ridge lines. Denoting this direction s = (sx , sy ), the corresponding criterion is Vc,c ≡ Vx,x sx2 + 2Vx,y sx sy + Vy,y sy2 < 0,
(8)
24
M. Hirano
Figure 2.4 Topological property of the whole domain, where the atom can take its equilibrium position, similar to that in Figure 2.4. Figures show the cases where the contacting surface of the lower body has the oblique-square crystalline symmetry. The point different from the one-dimensional case is that the sliding path where the atom can slide by continuously changing its equilibrium position depends on the direction of sliding displacement vector Q. The atom can slide towards arbitrary direction by continuously transforming its equilibrium position for the case shown in Figure 2.10(a)–(b). In the case shown in Figure 2.10(c), the atom can slide continuously in the x-direction, but can slide in the y-direction by discontinuous transformation. The atom can slide only by discontinuously changing its equilibrium position in any direction for the case shown in Figure 2.10(d).
where Vα,β is defined by u
Vα,β ≡
N j
u l Vα,β s − rj (Q) + Vα,β (s).
(9)
u (s − r (Q)) and V l (s)(α, β = x, y) are the second derivatives of V u (s − r ) and Vα,β j j α,β V l (s) with respect to the α and β components, respectively. The criterion for Tomlinson’s mechanism states that nonadiabatic motion occurs when second-order derivative Vα,β , in a direction perpendicular to a V l (r) ridge line, is negative. The occurrence of Tomlinson’s mechanism can, therefore, be decided by judging whether or not Vα,β in Equation (8) is negative at the critical atom position. It has been examined whether or not the nonadiabatic motion occurs in realistic systems by applying Equation (8) to various systems of cubic metals in which Morse potentials are operated [9]. It has been found that Vc,c are all positive for all the metals that were examined. This shows that nonadiabatic motion of each atom does not occur, i.e., Tomlinson’s mechanism does not occur in cubic metals.
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
25
2.4 ATOMISTIC ORIGIN OF FRICTION 2.4.1
Frictional Model
The atoms slide by changing their equilibrium positions continuously, and so the energy dissipation does not occur due to Tomlinson’s mechanism. How can the problem of the energy dissipation, i.e., the origin of the dynamic friction force as well as the origin of the static friction force be considered? Here, the new picture for the origin of the friction forces is described. The following frictional system will be considered to be given by N N N |pi |2 1 + v1 (ri − rj ) + v2 (ri ) , H {pi }, {ri } = 2 2
(10)
j ( =i)
i
i
which is obtained by adding the kinetic energy term of each atom to the model given in Equation (6). The first, the second, and the third term of the right-hand side stand for the rj ) between the atoms of kinetic energy of the ith atom, the mutual interactions v1 (ri − the upper solid body, and the adhesion energy given by v2 (r) ≡ j vα (r − rj )(vα (r − rj ): the interaction energy from the j th atom of the lower body), respectively. In the frictional process, it is convenient to distinguish the translational degree of freedom, i.e., the center of mass of the upper body from the other degrees of freedom concernN u u u u ing with the internal relative motions. The notations (P = N i ri /N ) i pi /N , Q = u and (pi = pi − P, ri = ri − Q) (i = 1, 2, . . . , 3(N − 1)) are introduced, where P and Q are, respectively, the momentum and the coordinate of the center of mass, specifying the translational motion, and pi and ri are, respectively, the momentum and the position coordinate of the ith atom, specifying the internal relative motions. By using these notations, the frictional system in Equation (10) can be rewritten by |P|2 + v2 (¯ri + Q) + H0 {p¯ i }, {¯ri } , H {p¯ i }, {¯ri }; P, Q = N 2
(11)
i
−1 N −1 N |p¯ i |2 1 H0 {p¯ i }, {¯ri } = + v1 (¯ri − r¯ j ). 2 2 i
(12)
i =j
H0 ({p¯ i }, {¯ri }) involves only the internal degrees of freedom of the upper body, and the translational motion (P, Q) is connected with the internal motions (p¯ i , r¯ i ) by the second term, i.e., the adhesion term in the right-hand side. The motion of equation for the center of mass of the upper body is given from Equation (11): dP = F {¯ri }; Q , dt
dQ = P, dt
(13) (14)
26
M. Hirano
where F({¯ri }; Q) is a force acting on the center of mass of the upper body, and is defined by 1 ∂v2 (¯ri (t) + Q) F {¯ri }; Q = − u . N ∂Q
(15)
i
2.4.2
Static Friction
For the sake of simplicity, a picture for the one-dimensional frictional systems, shown in Figure 2.5, is described. The upper body is simply expressed by the linear chain where the atoms interact with each other. Each atom of the upper body feels the interaction of attraction from the lower body, which is represented by the potential curve. Here, imagine we apply an external force to push the linear chain in a right direction. Each atom rises the mountain part of the interaction potential. During sliding, the interdistances between two adjacent atoms change. The drag can be obtained by calculating the total potential energy for each Q, and by taking its first derivative with respect to Q. Alternatively, the drag against the applied force is the sum of the forces along the chain which each atom feels from the lower body. The drag from each atom can become positive or negative. Then we have the static friction force, Fs (Q) = −
∂v2 (¯ri (Q) + Q) i
∂Q
(16)
or by using Equation (15) = −N u F r¯ i (Q) , Q .
(17)
The positive part of this Fs (Q) gives the static friction force. The static friction force stems from the cooperative behavior of atoms as shown in Figure 2.5. This picture, i.e., atomistic locking, is simple and resembles the mechanical-locking mechanism in the surface roughness model shown in Figure 2.6, if one takes the following two correspondences: (i) the roughness → the non-flatter potential v2 (r) which the upper solid surface feels from the lower body, and (ii) the gravitational force → the adhesive force. The origin of the static friction force is ascribed to the atomistic surface-roughness, but not to the defects, dislocations and other imperfections.
Figure 2.5 Mechanism for the origin of the static frictional force, shown for the one-dimensional frictional systems. The upper body is simply expressed by the linear chain where each atom interacts with each other. Each atom of the upper body feels the interaction of attraction from the lower body, which is represented by the potential curve. When we apply an external force to push the linear chain in the right direction, each atom rises the mountain part of the interaction potential coherently or cooperatively. The drag against the applied force is the sum of the forces along the chain which each atom feels from the lower body.
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
27
Figure 2.6 Surface roughness model. The contacting solid surfaces are so rough that surface asperities are mechanically locked against the gravitational force. It is necessary to apply an external force to slide one body against the other. This mechanical-locking mechanism concerns with the origin of the static frictional force. The weakest point of the surface roughness model is that basically it fails to explain an energy dissipation, i.e., the origin of the dynamic frictional force since the gravitational force is an energy-conserving force.
2.4.3
Dynamic Friction: Energy Dissipation
The origin of the dynamic friction force has been studied [12]. How can the energy dissipation be explained? In Tomlinson’s mechanism, the atoms near the sliding surface move independently and each atom repeats the non-adiabatic process of dissipating the elastic energy into the vibrational or kinetic energy of the atoms. Imagine the upper body is pushed to slide against the lower body at a constant velocity, namely with P(0) = constant and p¯ i = 0 initially. If this translational momentum P(t) subsequently decreases during sliding, the force is applied to push the upper body, keeping a sliding velocity constant. This applied force corresponds to the dynamic friction force. Thus, the origin of the dynamic friction force is reformulated as the problem of how the translational kinetic energy for the center of mass decreases. The energy dissipation rate R(t) at time t is given as the reduction rate of the translational kinetic energy, R(t) = −N u
d|P(t)|2 = −N u P(t) ∗ F {ri }, Q , dt
(18)
or by using Equation (15) R(t) = P(t) ∗
∂v2 (¯ri + Q) ∂Q
i
,
(19)
where a symbol ∗ stands for the inner product between two vectors. The dynamic friction force Fd (t) can be obtained from the relation R(t) = P(t) ∗ Fd (t). From Equation (19), we have Fd (t) = −
∂v2 (¯ri + Q) i
∂Q
,
(20)
as is equal to the N u times of the force acting on the center of mass, as seen from Equation (15).
28
M. Hirano
If v2 (¯ri + Q) has a Q-dependence, namely, F({ri }, Q) = 0, the translational kinetic energy can be transformed into the kinetic energies of the internal relative motions. If the transformed energy does not turn again to the translational kinetic energy, this energy transfer occurs irreversibly. In order to examine the possibility of this irreversibility to occur, we shall compare the available phase space volumes. The phase-space volume concerning with the translational motion is estimated to have an order of N u |P|2 /2 since the translational kinetic energy, being less than or equal to N u |P|2 /2 is available. On the other hand, there are many combinations of how this kinetic energy N u |P|2 /2 may be distributed on many degrees of freedom for the internal relative motions. The number of combinations increases with an exponential order of the total number of the internal degrees of freedom. So the available phase-space volume of the internal relative motions may be estimated to u have an order of eγ (N −1) where the value of γ (> 0) depends on details of the model with internal variables, for an example, γ = 3 ln(|P|2 /2v) when H0 in Equation (11) is described as an ensemble of many independent harmonic oscillators with frequency v. From this study, the phase-space volume for the translational motion becomes negligibly small for a large N u , compared with that for the internal motions. Thus, the energy-transfer from the translational motion to the internal motion occurs irreversibly, and so it is concluded that the energy is dissipated from the translational motion to the internal motions. The frictional system is the dynamic one conserving the total energy. The irreversible energy dissipation indicates that the internal relative motions are excited, and hence the adiabaticity does not hold true for the internal relative motions. However, in order that the present idea is adequate, the system, described by H0 ({p¯ i }, {¯ri }), must work as a host system absorbing energy. In other words, the dynamic system in Equation (11) has the ergodic property. If the system energy is sufficiently low, one participates finding energy surface which is filled by the non-ergodic torus with the Kolmogorov–Arnold–Moser (KAM) stability [17]. As the energy increases, the system recovers the ergodic property. The number of empirical computer studies supports this picture. When the energy surface is filled by the KAM torus, the system is well known [13,18] to show the recurrence phenomenon where the energy repeats decreasing and increasing, and hence the energy does not diffuse. The number of studies has been made [19,20] to find the border, the critical energy, where the system becomes from non-ergodic to ergodic. The present simulations show that, for the frictional systems of the current interest, the energy seems to be distributed over the entire degrees of freedoms even for the case of the weak adhesion. The Frenkel– Kontorova frictional system [21], where the potential terms in Equation (10) is replaced by the pure Frenkel–Kontorova model has been studied [15,16,22]. The magnitude k of the spring describing the interaction between the atoms of the upper body and the magnitude f describing the adhesion are taken equal to 1 and 0.1, respectively. The momentum P(t) as a function of Q(t), started from the initial P(0), is shown in Figure 2.7(a). The momentum p¯ i (t) as a function of the coordinate r¯ i (t) is shown in Figure 2.7(b). Figure 2.7(b) implies that the system is ergodic, and so the host system works as an energy absorber, as seen Figure 2.7(a). The above mechanism can be applied to the one-dimensional frictional system, which was described previously. For any given Q, the total interaction energy where the atoms are assumed to have their equilibrium positions is shown in Figure 2.8. Suppose that the external force is applied to slowly slide the upper solid surface, keeping the lower body
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
(a)
29
(b)
Figure 2.7 Translational momentum P (t) as a function of Q(t) in (a) and the internal momentum p¯ i (t) as a function of r¯i (t) in (b) for the Frenkel–Kontorova frictional system. The dots stand for their values at every 1000 unit time intervals. The magnitude of k of the spring describing the interaction between the upper body and the magnitude f describing the adhesion are taken equal to 1 and 0.1, respectively. (b) implies that the system is ergodic, and so the host system works as an energy absorber, as seen from (a).
Figure 2.8 Mechanism for the origin of the dynamic frictional force, shown for the one-dimensional frictional system. For any given Q, the total interaction energy where the atoms are assumed to have their equilibrium positions for each Q is shown. Imagine we push the upper body to slide against the lower body. Q, the coordinate of the center of mass, begins to arise a mountain of the potential, and reach on top of the mountain. When Q moves in a right direction further, the system lowers the potential energy, and so gains the kinetic energy. This is a process of increasing the kinetic energy of the translational motion. The available phase-space volume of the internal motions becomes much larger than that of the translational motion. The energy transfer from the translational motion to the internal motion occurs irreversibly. So, the excess kinetic energy may be dissipated into the other internal motions in the body due to the mechanism.
30
M. Hirano
fixed. Q, the coordinate for the center of mass, begins to arise a mountain of the potential, and reach on top of the mountain, When Q moves in the right direction further, the system lowers the potential energy, and so gains the kinetic energy. This is a process of increasing the kinetic energy of the translational motion. This excess kinetic energy may be dissipated into the internal relative motions due to the mechanism described above.
2.5 2.5.1
SUPERLUBRICITY
Superlubricity and Adiabatic Motion of Atoms
In Tomlinson’s mechanism, the atoms change their equilibrium positions non-adiabatically, which leads to the energy transfer of the elastic energy into the kinetic energy of the atoms. Tomlinson’s mechanism explains the energy dissipation. However, it has been shown that Tomlinson’s mechanism is unlikely to occur in the realistic frictional systems. The present picture for the origin of the dynamic friction force can explain the irreversible energytransfer of the translational kinetic energy into the internal kinetic energies, i.e., the thermal energy. This mechanism, however, works only when v2 (¯ri + Q) has a Q dependence. On the other hand, if v2 (¯ri +Q) has no Q-dependence during sliding, the energy-dissipation R(t) does not occur from Equation (19). Then, the translational kinetic energy is a constant for motion, and the frictional system is in a state of superlubricity. The superlubricity can appear when the sum of the forces of each atom vanishes. It has been proved that the superlubric state occurs when the atoms have their equilibrium positions for each Q and, at the same time, the frictional system satisfies some conditions [9]. The condition is satisfied when two solid surfaces are incommensurate. The superlubricity has been theoretically discussed by McClelland [15] and Sokoloff [16] for the weak adhesion. The result in Section 2.3 implies that this state appears for a wider class of the (strong or weak) adhesion including the metallic bond and the Van der Waals interaction. It was argued that the system of incommensurately contacting surfaces has zero dynamic threshold for sliding when two contacting surfaces form a perfect periodic lattice [16,20]. The state of superlubricity is not associated with the energy dissipation. Thus, the concept of superlubricity contradicts with Tomlinson’s mechanism. The problems will be interesting of how the superlubricity is influenced by the dynamic effect [22] when two bodies moves relatively so fast that r¯ i may not be in the equilibrium position r¯ i (Q) and by the existence of the surface roughness and the imperfections such as the defects and the dislocations. It has been considered that the superlubricity may be stable, as is different from the one-dimensional case of the charge density wave (CDW) pinned easily by the defects. Why is it that individual atoms do not move in a non-adiabatic manner in realistic systems? The answer lies in the degree of freedom of atomic motion. In the past theories, friction was investigated essentially on the basis of one-dimensional models, as shown in Figure 2.9(a) [15,16]. In such a one-dimensional system, the degree of freedom in the motion of an atom is low. This means that if unstable areas (the white parts in Figure 2.9(a) in which atoms cannot stably exist) appear, an atom will undergo non-adiabatic motion as it passes through those areas. Such an unstable area, which corresponds to the area
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
31
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 2.9 Motion of atoms at a contact surface. The white parts represent unstable areas in which atoms cannot stably exist and the shaded parts to stable areas in which they can stably exist. (a) One-dimensional system; (b) and (c) two- and three-dimensional systems.
in the above chalk example where the chalk does not stick, appears as a result of strong interaction between solids, the existence of impurities, lattice defects, etc. In two- and three-dimensional systems, however, the degree of freedom in the motion of an atom is high. As a result, even if unstable areas appear, an atom can pass through the stable areas by moving around the unstable areas, as shown in Figure 2.9(b). (The white parts in Figure 2.9(b) correspond to an atom’s unstable areas and the shaded parts to an atom’s stable areas.) Simulations as well show that atoms perform non-adiabatic motion if unstable areas appear in a one-dimensional system but that they perform smooth adiabatic motion in twoand three-dimensional systems even if unstable areas appear [12]. The latter case makes it easy for superlubricity to appear [9]. Even if unstable areas should appear between lattices due to impurities and defects in two- and three-dimensional systems, non-adiabatic motion would not appear for the same reason given above (Figure 2.9(b)). In this case, while superlubricity would be stable for a certain concentration of impurities and defects, it is thought that exceeding a certain value will result in the appearance of friction with friction forces increasing monotonically as that concentration increases. Incidentally, unstable areas will grow if the interaction between solids is made strong in two- and three-dimensional systems, and non-adiabatic motion will occur if stable areas become cut off by unstable areas at some time (Figure 2.9(c)). This occurrence of nonadiabatic motion results in a friction transition in which friction changes from zero to a finite value [9]. 2.5.2
Friction Diagram
The one-dimensional friction system, given by N N pi2 1 f + (ri+1 − ri − ℓ)2 + sin(2πri ) , H {pi }, {ri } = 2 2 2π i
i
(21)
32
Figure 2.10
M. Hirano
Friction diagram for the one dimensional Frenkel–Kontorova model with kinetic energy terms.
where f stands for the magnitude of the adhesive force, is studied. This is one-dimensional Frenkel–Kontorova model [21] with kinetic energy terms. ℓ is the mean distance between two adjacent atoms. The periodicity length of the sinusoidal potential in Equation (21) is taken as a unit. The Frenkel–Kontorova model has been studied by many workers. It is known that this model shows nonadiabatic motion of atoms, as mentioned in Section 2.2, near at f ≃ 0.14, which is often called the Aubry transition [23]. The dynamics in friction has been studied by adding the kinetic energy terms to the model. To examine the friction properties including superlubricity, the dynamics has been studied after the upper solid surface at the ground state is pushed with initial sliding velocity P (0) (p¯ i (0) = 0 for any i), that is, the Hamiltonian dynamics conserving the energy. The dynamics is studied by examining quantities such as P (t), Q(t), r¯i (t), p¯ i (t) and the sliding distance ls (t) defined as the distance over which the upper solid surface slides during time t. These quantities are obtained by solving Equation (44). ℓ is assumed to be equal √ to the golden mean number ( 5 + 1)/2. Two regimes appear in the diagram shown in Figure 2.10; In the superlubricity regime, the superlubric state appears, i.e., two contacting solid surfaces slide without any resistance. The recurrence phenomenon occurs persistently; this regime repeats increasing and decreasing the translational kinetic energy with time. The friction force Fd (t) averaged over the recurrence time exactly vanishes. The sliding distance ls (t) increases linearly with time: ls (t) = c[P (0)]t. c[P (0)] is a averaged velocity satisfying c[P (0)] ≥ P (0), and depends on P (0). On the other hand, in the friction regime, the energy dissipation occurs; the translational kinetic energy is transferred into the kinetic energy of the internal motions. The upper surface slides but finally ceases to slide: ls (t) < ∞ for sufficiently large t. The friction occurs in this regime. As P (0) becomes smaller, the sliding distance decreases for the region f ≥ 0.14. The point at f = 0.14 and P (0) = 0 is the Aubry transition point: in the regime f > 0.14, the atoms change their equilibrium positions discontinuously. In the regime f < 0.14 and P (0) = 0, the atoms can slide by changing their equilibrium positions continuously, and the system can slide without any resistance. Nevertheless, the friction regime spreads over the region 0.0 < f < 0.14 with finite P (0). This is different from the result for the pure Frenkel– Kontorova model without any kinetic energy terms, and is due to a dynamic effect of the system. In particular, the distance, ls (∞), over which the upper solid surface runs till it
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
33
ceases to slide is ls (∞) ≃ 1 as the parameters f (>0.14) and P (0) approach near the horizontal axis, while ls (t) tends to stretch with time t as one approaches the border line separating the friction regime from the superlubricity regime. In the friction regime, the temporal behavior of the friction force Fd (t) depends on P (0) and f in a complex manner. As the parameter f means the magnitude of the adhesive force between the upper and the lower solid surfaces, f < fwa , say fwa ≃ 0.1, corresponds to the weak adhesion. (Note that the strength of interaction between atoms of the upper solid surface is set equal to unity.) The diagram in Figure 2.10 shows that the superlubric state appears only for two cases of the weak adhesion and of the high sliding velocity. The property that the superlubricity appears only for the weak adhesion is peculiar for the one-dimensional system. 2.5.3
Superlubricity and High Dimensionality
In the superlubricity regime, two contacting solid surfaces can slide with no resistance. A general consideration of Equations (18)–(20) concludes that the superlubric state ap pears when the system satisfies either of two following conditions: (I) v2 (¯ri (t) + Q(t)) in Equation (19), hereafter denoted by v(Q(t)), has no Q dependence, and (II) the persistent recurrence phenomenon occurs. The second condition may be a special case of (I) if v(Q(t)) is regarded as the quantity averaged over the recurrence time. Then, there arises a problem of how to construct the friction systems showing the superlubricity. One among them, for examples, is to prepare the friction system consisting of two clean flat solid surfaces, as studied in previous sections. The condition (I) has been discussed as the condition for the phason mode to exist, and can be replaced by another two conditions: (I-1) the quasi-static sliding: the sliding velocity is so slow that the atoms follow their equilibrium positions adiabatically and (I-2) two solid surfaces contact incommensurately [8]. The nonadiabatic motion of atoms do not occur if these are both satisfied. On the other hand, the condition (II) is first pointed out here, which is a result of the dynamic effect of the system. An importance of high dimensionality in the friction system has been emphasized, which makes the superlubricity appear much easily. The term ‘dimensionality’ means the number of the spatial directions towards which the atoms can move or relax during sliding. The importance of high dimensionality is demonstrated by using two-dimensional Frenkel– Kontorova model analogous to that in Equation (21), given by N 1 x2 y2 pi,i + pi,i H {pi,j }{ri,j } = 2 i
+
N 2 y 2 1 x y x ri+1,j − ri,j − ℓ + rj,i+1 − rj,i − ℓ 2 i,j
x f y cos π ri,j (cos θ + sin θ ) + ri,j (cos θ − sin θ ) π x y × cos π ri,j (cos θ − sin θ ) + ri,j (− cos θ − sin θ ) , (22)
+
34
M. Hirano
where atoms arrange on the square-lattice points specified by two index numbers i and j . The position and momentum of the (i, j )th atom are, respectively, denoted by y x , r y ) and p x ri,j = (ri,j i,j = (pi,j , pi,j ). θ is a lattice misfit angle between the upper and i,j lower solid surfaces with square-lattice symmetry. The upper solid surface is pushed with initial sliding velocity P (0) = 0.02 along the x direction, or equivalently, along the θ direction against the lower surface. The dynamic property for the case θ = 0◦ or 90◦ becomes identical to that of the one-dimensional Frenkel–Kontorova model, as easily seen from Equation (22). The case θ = 45◦ gives the largest critical value fc (≃0.25), which is about 4 times of fc (≃0.06) of the one-dimensional case, which is seen from the diagram in Figure 2.10. For the parameter f < fc , the superlubric state appears. Why does the critical value fc arise for the two-dimensional Frenkel–Kontorova model? This is explained as follows; Suppose two-dimensional friction system where the lower solid surface is assumed to have a square-lattice symmetry, as shown in Figure 2.9(b). The region where each atom of the upper solid surface can move without occurring the nonadiabatic motion is shown by shaded part, while the region where the nonadiabatic motion occurs by empty part. Two dimensions allow the atoms to move by changing its position flexibly in the shaded region. Therefore, the atom can slide avoiding the region where the nonadiabatic motion occurs, as shown by the thin arrow. The appearance of nonadiabatic region does not mean that the superlubric state breaks down. This should be compared with the case of one-dimensional systems. When the dimensionality arises further, the atoms can move more flexibly. For the three-dimensional friction systems, it as shown that the critical value fc becomes much larger than that calculated for the realistic systems: the superlubric state appear for any combinations of metals with clean and flat surfaces. (The metals were simulated by using the Morse type potentials determined empirically.) The possibility for the superlubric state to appear has been discussed by other workers [15,16]. They was based on the result for the case of the one-dimensional systems with P (0) = 0, and concluded that it appears only for the case of the weak adhesion. The above analysis shows that the superlubricity is a general phenomenon, and appears for a wide class of the (strong or weak) adhesion including the metallic bonding and the Van der Waals interaction [9]. High dimensionality is a key to understand the physics of superlubricity. 2.5.4
Energy Recurrence Phenomena
If kinetic energy is given to a solid so that it is made to slide at a finite speed, it will come to a stop in a short time. In this case, the energy of translational motion dissipates due to friction. This energy dissipation does not originate from the non-adiabatic motion of atoms as concluded above. A new energy-dissipation mechanism, however, has been described [12]. In this mechanism, the energy of a solid’s translational motion is irreversibly transferred to energy of the internal motion of solids. This irreversibility occurs because the degree of freedom of translational motion is proportional to system size while the degree of freedom of internal motion is proportional to a power of system size. The degree of freedom of internal motion can therefore be dramatically larger [12]. In contrast to this irreversible energy transfer, superlubricity appears if the translational motion of a solid is independent of the internal motion of solids and the kinetic energy of translation does not dissipate constantly. The condition for the state of no energy dissipation to occur is
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
35
existence of an energy recurrence phenomenon. If this phenomenon exists, the energy of a solid’s translational motion will increase and decrease repeatedly according to a certain recurrence time period. This corresponds to the repetition of positive and negative values of friction force in a recurrence cycle. Accordingly, if friction forces are averaged out on a time scale corresponding to the recurrence time period, average friction force will be zero. On the other hand, if the recurrence time period is much longer than the time scale of friction observation, friction will appear. This recurrence phenomenon depends on system size and energy. As a special case, we can consider a closed system consisting of a solid having a small number of atoms. In this system, the energy of the translational motion of solids will, at some point, be transferred to the energy of internal motion in the solid. Since the size of the system is small, however, this energy of internal motion will be returned to translational motion in a relatively short recurrence time. In a finite system, the recurrence phenomenon will likewise occur but the length of the recurrence time period will increase with increase in system size. In an infinite system, though, the recurrence time period becomes infinitely large and the recurrence phenomenon does not occur. If the energy of the system is sufficiently low, however, the phase space of the system will satisfy a non-ergodic orbit and the energy given to the system will exhibit the recurrence phenomenon without spreading throughout the entire system. In a friction system having finite friction forces, the energy of translational motion is irreversibly transferred to the energy of the solid’s internal motion giving rise to energy dissipation. In superlubricity, on the other hand, the recurrence phenomenon means that energy is not being continuously dissipated. Recurrence phenomena of this sort will now be investigated using the two-dimensional dynamic Frenkel–Kontorova model given by Equation (22). In this model, atoms are arranged on a tetragonal lattice. These atoms not only interact with each other, but also interact with the other solid (in the pair of solids making contact) through a sinusoidal potential function. Denoting each atom by the letters i and j , the position and momentum of atom (i, j ) are expressed as qi,j and pi,j . In Equation (1), θ is the lattice misfit angle between the solids. The momentum of all atoms is given only at first and the manner in which momentum of the center-of-gravity position varies with Q was investigated for various misfit angles θ (Figure 2.11) [24]. The interaction k1 between the solids was 0.1 and the momentum given to each atom was 0.02. Now, for small θ in which the orientations of the lattices at the contacting surfaces approach a match, the momentum of Q tends to decrease. In this case, the energy of the solid’s translational motion is irreversibly transfers to the energy of the solid’s internal motion and energy dissipates. Conversely, for larger θ in which the orientations of the lattices at the contacting surfaces do not match up, the momentum of Q does not tend to decrease, and at θ = 45 degree, the momentum of Q increases and decreases in a repetitive manner signaling the appearance of the recurrence phenomenon. In this case, the energy of the solid’s translational motion is independent of the solid’s internal motion and the energy of translational motion does not continuously dissipate. The states of atomic motion (momentum and position coordinates of each atom) for the cases of dissipation and no dissipation are instructive (Figure 2.12). For the case of energy dissipation, the atoms move in an ergodic manner so that the energy of translational motion is distributed among the many degrees of freedom of internal motion. For the case of superlubricity, however, the energy is distributed to only a few degrees of freedom.
36
M. Hirano
Figure 2.11
Momentum of a solid versus center-of-gravity position.
Figure 2.12 State of atoms’ momentum in phase space. (◦) represents state in which energy dissipates and friction appears for θ = 15 degree. (•) represents state of superlubricity in which energy does not dissipate continuously as a result of recurrence phenomena for θ = 45 degree.
2.6 SUMMARY In this chapter, we have shown that superlubricity appears in realistic systems where metallic bonding and the like operate. The conditions for the appearance of superlubricity are the adiabatic motion of atoms and energy recurrence phenomena. Two types of superlubricity can appear corresponding to each of these conditions. Because atoms move adiabatically in a realistic system, bringing two surfaces into contact so that the orientations of their lattices
Superlubricity of Clean Surfaces
37
do not match will produce a situation in which the forces acting one each atom cancel each other out. As a result, superlubricity is independent of the time scale of observation and is always zero. In a finite system, moreover, the energy recurrence phenomenon appears through the dynamics of atomic motion, and friction observed on a time scale equivalent to recurrence time is again zero. The concept of superlubricity was born out of research for the origins of friction. Investigation into the mechanism for generating friction forces has revealed the case in which friction appears and the case in which friction is zero. The problem of whether this state of vanishing friction is realistic or not is closely related to the problem of energy dissipation in friction. Specifically, superlubricity in which friction is zero is realistic if the conventional mechanism of dissipation is rejected. At the same time, a new dissipation mechanism has been proposed to replace the conventional one, and a picture of static and kinetic friction that describes the origins of friction has been drawn. The idea of superlubricity, moreover, should lead to new points of view in areas like friction control and friction in living organisms. The concept of superlubricity, i.e., the phenomenon of zero friction, thus emerged from research on friction at the atomic level [9,12,15,16,24–26]. The atomistic model of friction allows for the appearance of finite friction and zero friction depending on the commensurability of contacting surfaces [24]. It is well known that phenomena dependent on commensurability can occur in systems having two periodicities such as charge-density waves, ion conduction, epitaxial crystal growth, and adatom layers. The idea behind the commensurability of contacting surfaces has stimulated the theoretical and experimental research of atomic-scale friction, i.e., Nanotribology [25].
REFERENCES [1] For a review involving history in the field of friction see, e.g., Sota, N. Masatsu no Hanashi. Iwanami Syoten, Tokoyo, 1971 (in Japanese). [2] Bowden, F.P., Tabor, D. Friction and Lubrication of Solids, vol. II. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1964. [3] Tabor, D. Proc. Roy. Soc. London A 251 (1959), 1266. [4] Dowson, D. History of Tribology. Longm C.A. [5] Coulomb, C.A. Mémories de Mathematique et de Physics de l’Acaddemie Royale (1785), 161. An, London, 1979. [6] Desaguliers, J.T. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London 33 (1725), 345. [7] Tomlinson, G.A. Phil. Mag. 7 (1929), 905. [8] Mate, C.M., McClelland, G.M., Erlandsson, R., Chiang, S. Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987), 1942. [9] Hirano, M., Shinjo, K. Phys. Rev. B 41 (1990), 11837. [10] Girifalco, L.A., Wezer, V.G. Phys. Rev. 114 (1959), 687. [11] Johnson, R.A. Phys. Rev. 134 (1964), 1329. [12] Shinjo, K., Hirano, M. Surf. Sci. 283 (1993), 473. [13] Fermi, E., Pasta, J., Ulam, S. Collected Papers of E. Fermi, vol. II. Univ. of Chicago Press, 1965. [14] Goldstein, H. Classical Mechanics, second edition. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1980. [15] McClelland, G.M. Adhesion and friction. In: Grunze, M., Kreuzer, H.J. (Eds.), Springer Series in Surface Science, vol. 17. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1990, p. 1. [16] Sokoloff, J.B. Surf. Sci. 144 (1984), 267. [17] See, e.g., Arnold, V.I., Avez, A. Probiernes ergodiques de la mecatiique classique. Gauthier-Villar, Paris, 1967.
38
M. Hirano
[18] Tuck, J.L. Adv. Math. 5 (1973), 11. [19] Benettin, G. In: Ciccotti, G., Hoover, W. (Eds.), Proc. Inter. School Phys. Enrico Fermi Course XCVII. 1988, p. 15. [20] Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Rev. B 31 (1935), 2270. [21] Frenkel, Y.I., Kontorova, T. Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 8 (1938), 1340. [22] Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Rev. B 42 (1990), 760. [23] Aubry, S. J. Phys. (Paris) 44 (1983), 147. [24] Hirano, M. Wear 254 (2003), 932. [25] Krim, J. Surf. Sci. 500 (2002), 741. [26] Matsukawa, H., Fukuyama, H. Phys. Rev. B 49 (1994), 17286.
–3– Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity Carlos E. Campañá and Martin H. Müser Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada N6A 5B7
3.1 INTRODUCTION Superlubricity refers to the occurrence of extremely small friction between two solids in mechanical contact. Its existence was predicted by Hirano and Shinjo in the early nineties [1,2]. They argued that lateral forces are likely to cancel systematically when two incommensurate crystals are brought into contact. They furthermore suggested that many solids may not be sufficiently compliant to suppress superlubricity via elastic deformations. Whenever their arguments hold, one may expect the possibility for superlubricity. Even though the suggestion of a super-low static friction contradicts our common sense, it does not necessarily contradict classical mechanics. If the two solids in contact have flat interfaces and wear and plastic deformation are not considered, then one may expect the same (free) energy at the beginning of a sliding process as at its end, because of translational symmetry. Consequently, no work would have to be done when taking the solids from their initial to their final configuration, implying the possibility of very low friction. Even, if the surfaces of the two solids are rough, there should be as many bumps (or atoms) in the substrate pushing the slider to the right as there are surface irregularities in the substrate pushing the slider to the left for each spatial direction within the contact plane. Hence, statistically speaking, there is the possibility of an almost perfect annihilation of lateral forces. Experimentally, there is growing evidence pointing to the existence of superlubricity [3–8]. Shortly after Hirano and Shinjo’s original work, a set of experiments suggested friction coefficients μ (the ratio of friction F over load L) below the experimental resolution of 10−4 [3]. This is three to four orders of magnitude less than usually observed. Recent studies performed on nanoscale objects also suggest that lateral forces may cancel systematically at the interface between two solids. One interesting aspect of these works is that it was possible to switch in a controlled fashion between a superlubric and a regular regime. In one case this was done by rotating a graphite flake with respect to a graphite surface, thereby changing the degree of incommensurability [7]. In a second case, the superlubric regime was achieved by varying the load of an atomic force microscope tip [8]. Besides, Superlubricity Edited by A. Erdemir and J.-M. Martin © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
40
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
an increasing number of recent analyses on superlubric, hydrogen-terminated diamond surfaces have been reported [5,6]. There are many processes that can destroy superlubricity, including plastic deformation, adsorbed layers, and cold welding [9–11]. However, in most cases, it is assumed that these friction mechanisms can be suppressed by preparing the samples and setting the laboratory conditions appropriately. This leaves the competition between elastic interactions and interfacial forces as the main opposing force to sliding. Two simple but very illustrative atomic models that show how this competition can induce solid friction at small velocities are the Prandtl–Tomlinson [12,13] and the Frenkel–Kontorova model [14]. These models, which will be introduced, further below, have been very popular because of the possibilities they offer to capture characteristic features of the frictional behavior of elastic solids. Although each one of the previous models is able to qualitatively reproduce some of the experimental findings, new and more sophisticated descriptions are needed to also make quantitative, material-specific predictions on tribological properties. Reviewing the main theoretical efforts towards achieving this goal is the purpose of this contribution. The remainder of this chapter is organized as follows: In Section 3.2, a general overview of the theoretical aspects of superlubricity is provided. The role that elastic instabilities and long-range elastic deformations play within different atomic models of rigid elastic solids in contact will be discussed. Also, some basic dimensional analysis will be used to study the scaling laws that friction forces follow as a function of the system’s dimensions. Section 3.3 reviews selected computer simulation studies shedding light on various processes that can occur in sliding interfaces. Having the possibility of varying at will the geometrical properties of the interfaces or their chemical composition and being able to observe the motion of individual atoms during sliding, makes computer simulations a powerful tool in creating qualitative understanding of tribological phenomena. Conclusions will be presented in Section 3.4.
3.2
THEORY
From every-day experience one knows that a finite force has to be overcome to start lateral motion of one solid relative to another. This threshold force Fs is known as the static friction force. Once the motion has been initiated a force equal to or greater than a second threshold value, the kinetic friction force Fk has to be applied. If the shear force falls below Fk , the interface appears to be pinned—at least on experimental time scales. Superlubricity refers to situations in which the kinetic friction force becomes very small. The reasons why one can find exceedingly small threshold forces and thus superlubricity, will be described in this section. Included is a description of processes that can break superlubricity with an emphasis on the competition between intra-bulk elasticity and lateral interfacial forces, whose microscopic origin may result, for example, from roughness. 3.2.1
Friction and Superlubricity
In one of his contributions Hirano discussed the mechanisms of superlubricity based on a model from atomistic theory [15]. A similar argument was suggested by Prandtl within the
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
41
context of his work on friction many years earlier [12]. Hirano introduced two different conditions that a system must satisfy in order to be superlubric. The first condition is the adiabatic motion of the atoms. The second condition is energy recurrence phenomena. The first condition can be understood as the invariance of the total energy of the ground sate of the system with respect to translations of its center of mass. It is worth to mention that this requirement does not depend on the type of inter-atomic potentials or crystalline lattices but only on the atomic arrangement within the interfaces in contact. In the case of energy recurrence phenomena, the translational motion of the solid has to be independent of the motion of the internal degrees of freedom, i.e., the translational motion energy will fluctuate with a given recurrence period. We follow Prandtl’s argument, which required only adiabicity, or the absence of instabilities, see further below. A rigorous definition of superlubricity appears to be a difficult task. Even if there is some correlated motion of the atoms, no pair formation occurs as in the case of superfluids or superconductors. Also, the friction forces between two solids in sliding motion remain finite at finite velocities. Moreover, from the experimental point of view it will be unfeasible to test directly the adiabicity of atomic motion. For these reasons it is necessary to use an ad-hoc definition of superlubricity. A practical way of defining it is to require that the kinetic friction coefficient μk must be less than 10−3 while the local load on the contact should be in the order of 10% of the indentation hardness of the softer material. Another requirement would be that the sliding velocity has to be sufficiently high so that the system cannot relax stress through creep or thermal relaxation, but it may be small compared to the velocity of sound. It is important to keep in mind the different nature of kinetic and static friction. Kinetic friction is related to (molecular) hysteresis or non-adiabicity while static friction is due to energy barriers. Some model systems may have finite energy barriers and hence exhibit finite static friction, although hysteresis effects might be negligible, thus leading to an absence of kinetic friction. An impressive demonstration of such a system was given in a recent contribution of Socoliuc et al. [8]. Within their experiment, a transition from stickslip into continuous sliding motion of the tip of a friction force microscope was observed. The transition was achieved in a controlled fashion by changing the applied load on the tip. Even though at all times energy barriers existed, the hysteresis loop corresponding to the scanning forward–backward process disappeared for normal loads below a certain threshold and consequently the kinetic friction force vanished as well. Of course, the reason of such behavior is connected to the absence of mechanical instabilities. This will be explained in more detail in the next section. 3.2.2
Dry Friction on Idealized Zero Temperature Analytic Models
The way how the competition between elastic interactions and interfacial forces can induce large friction at small velocities is most easily demonstrated in the Prandtl–Tomlinson (PT) model [12,13]. It can be described as follows: A particle without internal degrees of freedom is pulled over a sinusoidal potential V (x) = V0 cos(2πx/a) with a spring of stiffness k. Here, V0 is the amplitude of the energy modulation due to the interaction with the substrate, a is the substrate’s lattice constant and the spring reflect the mean-field description of the coupling between an atom and its ideal lattice site. It is also assumed that there
42
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
is a drag force linear in velocity. This non-conservative force describes the interactions between the particle and the substrate’s lattice vibrations, which are not explicitly included in the model. The equation of motion of the particle reads mx¨ + γ x˙ =
2πV0 sin(2π/a) − k x − xd (t) , a
(1)
where xd (t) is the position of the atom’s ideal lattice and γ is the damping coefficient. ′′ is smaller than k, there can If the maximum (negative) curvature of the potential Vmax only be one mechanically stable position for the particle at every instance of time. The equilibrium position moves at the macroscopic sliding velocity v0 and the particle will always be close to it so that the trajectory of the particle will be very smooth. This implies that a negligibly small amount of energy is dissipated into the damping term at small ′′ is violated, then there will be moments values of v0 . However, if the condition k > Vmax in time at which a local energy minimum suddenly disappears as the equilibrium position advances in sliding direction (such as shown in Figure 3.1). The particle then drops into the next available energy minimum thereby dissipating the energy difference E of its initial position and the new mechanical equilibrium site into the damping term. The same process and energy dissipation occur per slid distance a, which usually is the substrate’s lattice constant or an integer multiple thereof. This scenario renders the friction force to be approximately ( E/ a) over a large range in velocity. Velocities that are non-negligible compared to the speed of sound and velocities sufficiently small to allow for creep motion require additional considerations. Another simple model that also includes elasticity is the Frenkel–Kontorova (FK) model [14]. Its simplest form consists of a one-dimensional chain of atoms coupled by harmonic springs and interacting with a periodic potential as shown in Figure 3.2. Unlike the PT model, it allows for long-range elasticity. An important feature of this model is that in the limit of low-sliding velocities the average kinetic friction depends on the ratio Ω = a/b, while Fk is independent of a/b in the PT model. For any irrational value of Ω, a threshold spring constant kc is found. If the springs are stronger than kc static and kinetic friction vanish. For k < kc , several energy minima can coexist in a way similar to that shown in Figure 3.1. As a consequence, the static and kinetic friction become finite. Despite its simplicity, the FK model and its generalizations to higher dimensions are useful to describe various tribological phenomena conceptually and sometimes even quantitatively. In both models, elastic instabilities induce finite friction and thus prevent superlubricity. Similar arguments apply to higher-dimensional systems. Whenever there is mechanical multistability leading to the disappearance of mechanical stable sites under sliding, instabilities occur. They result in significant energy dissipation even at small sliding velocities. One may argue that such instabilities become unavoidable due to long-range elastic deformations in macroscopically large objects [16,17]. However, one has to keep in mind that the effective elastic interactions in three-dimensional solids are fairly strong. Simple scaling arguments suggest the possibility for superlubricity even if the contacts are rough and/or disordered [18]. Both, the PT and the FK model can be combined into a more sophisticated description that includes some new subtle features but maintains the main characteristics of the previous two approaches. Known as the Frenkel–Kontorova–Tomlinson (FKT) model [11], it is
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
43
Figure 3.1 Schematic representation of an instability in the PT model. The time-dependent potential V (x) (dashed lines) is the superposition of a sinusoidal substrate potential, fixed in space, and a moving parabolic potential representing the elastic interaction between the atom and its unperturbed equilibrium position in the bulk. The full circles show mechanically (meta) stable positions. When the stable position suddenly disappears, the atom quickly advances to the next available energy minimum, e.g., when the particle position becomes unstable at x ≈ −1.7 it jumps to x ≈ 2.6 dissipating an amount of energy E = 16.6. Such a jump occur every time the solid moves by one lattice constant (in this case a = 2π ) resulting in an average kinetic friction force Fk = 16.6/2π = 2.65.
Figure 3.2 Schematic representation of the FK model. The substrate is a periodic potential and each atom is coupled to its neighbors through springs of stiffness k. The ratio of the lattice constants chain-substrate: Ω = a/b determines the degree of commensurability of the contact.
formed by a rigid substrate with its center of mass kept fixed and a free slider where each atom is coupled to its ideal lattice site and its two neighboring atoms. The effect of the competition between interfacial and intra-bulk interactions can be summarized as follows: commensurate solids, i.e., solids that share a common periodicity, have a friction coefficient that is independent of the area of contact, or, more generally speaking, independent of the number of atoms in direct contact with the substrate. If intra-bulk elasticity is sufficiently strong to prevent instabilities, symmetry plays an important role on how the friction coefficient depends on the area of contact or the number of particles N in contact. Incommensurate interfaces show a friction coefficient that vanishes linearly with the area of contact. Lastly, within disordered interfaces due to the
44
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
random distribution of the lateral forces directions, the friction coefficient increases only with N −1/2 [10,11]. These claims will be further investigated in the next section. A more quantitative discussion of how the friction forces change as a function of the local arrangement of the atoms within the surfaces and the symmetry of the lattices will be given in the next section, which will also address the role of dimensionality. 3.2.3
Disorder, Symmetry and Dimensionality
The surfaces of most real solids are not perfectly crystalline but show certain degrees of disorder. Moreover, surface atoms are not coupled elastically to their lattice sites but interact non-linearly with the other atoms that form the solid. This affects the tribological properties of the materials sensitively. Under sliding, instabilities of surface atoms do not necessarily involve the sudden motion of single atoms but they may involve the collective motion of many of them. Whether such collective instabilities occur depends on whether or not the intra-bulk elastic interactions dominate the interfacial interactions on length scales larger than atomic scales [10,18]. Furthermore, the dimensionality of a system has a direct influence in the competition between the random substrate–slider interactions and the elastic coupling within the solid. If the elasticity dominates a superlubric state becomes possible. To get an order of magnitude estimation for the relevant variables at the atomic scale, it is reasonable to assume that the elastic coupling k(Latomic ) between adjacent atoms is in the order of the bulk modulus B, say 40 GPa for a soft solid, times a lattice spacing, say 2 Å. Thus, k(Latomic ) will be approximately 8 N/m which is a reasonable value for relatively soft solids. One can also estimate the maximum local curvature of the substrate potential ks . Solids that are tied together by physical bonds have bulk moduli in the order of 4 GPa and nearest neighbor separation are in the order of 3 Å, resulting in an estimate of ks = 1.2 N/m. Thus, at the atomic scale, k > ks , so that elastic instabilities cannot be expected to occur involving only the motion of individual atoms. Of course, the condition k > ks at the atomic scale is necessary but not sufficient for superlubricity. An important question to ask is how these interactions change if we change the length scale on which the system is described. For instance, if the interactions strengths are known on a linear scale of length L, what will their respective values be on a scale twice as large? In one-dimensional systems the spring constants become softer upon coarse-graining, just like the effective capacitance of capacitors connected in series. For instance, if we replace a linear chain of N beads with interatomic distance a by N/2 beads that are separated by 2a, then we need to reduce the stiffness of the coarse-grained springs by a factor of 2. A graphical representation of this analysis can be seen in Figure 3.3. In dimensions greater than one, springs are not only coupled in series but also in parallel. As is the case for capacitors, series coupling decreases the stiffness (capacitance), while parallel coupling increases the stiffness (capacitance). This implies that the stiffness will increase upon coarse graining in higher dimensions, while it decreases in one dimension. The dependence of the
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
45
Figure 3.3 Schematic view of the interaction between chemically passivated LJ solids. Part (a) corresponds to a snapshot of the simulation. Part (b) represents the coupling of a surface atom to its neighbors and the substrate. The parabola indicates the curvature of the potential within the PT model. Part (c) describes the scaling procedure for a one-dimensional elastic chain.
spring stiffness as a function of the system’s dimensionality D and the length scale L on which the system is described can be summarized in the following equation:
k(L) =
L Latomic
D−2
k(Latomic ).
(2)
Scaling laws for the forces between substrate and slider are more difficult to establish. The scaling of these forces strongly depends on the dimensions of the interface Dint . In simple approaches, it is assumed that ks is proportional to the static friction force associated with a rigid domain of linear scale L. In a contact of solids with identical lattice constants, the curvature adds up always in phase, thus ks ∼ N , where N is the number of atoms in intimate mechanical contact. If a flat, but disordered solid is placed on a crystal, different curvatures add up in a random fashion, thus ks ∼ N 1/2 . (Contact between two disordered surfaces follows the same argument.) If the solids are incommensurate, then there will be a systematic annihilation of those curvatures, thus ks cannot grow systematically with N , i.e., ks ∼ N 0 . (The proportionality coefficient may be large for systems close to commensurability.) These arguments can be summarized in the following equation: ⎧ Dint ⎨L ks (L) ∝ L0 ⎩ LDint /2
commesurate, inconmesurate, disorder.
(3)
For a crystalline substrate, the net potential must be a Fourier sum with a leading order coefficient V0 cos(2πx/a + ϕ) or generalizations for higher dimensions. The maximum friction force 2πV0 /a and the maximum curvature (2π)2 V0 /a 2 thus follow the same scal-
46
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
ing laws which are all embedded in V0 . As the area of contact A is proportional to N we may thus conclude ⎧ 0 ⎨A μs ∝ A−1 ⎩ A−1/2
commesurate, inconmesurate, disorder.
(4)
Whenever the ratio k(L)/ks (L) increases systematically with L, one should expect the intrabulk elasticity to dominate and thus expect to have the possibility of superlubricity. In real contacts, due to the roughness at many length scales, the distribution of the normal loads sometimes allow for large values of the local pressures which would increase the value of ks at the local contact regions. In those points it is reasonable to expect elastic instabilities and hence, the loss of superlubricity. However, these instabilities typically require pressures higher than the yield strength of the material. One may thus expect the asperities to yield rather than to deform elastically. 3.2.4
Thermal and Quantum Effects
Temperature certainly has an important effect on friction. It can be incorporated in the PT and the FK model by adding random forces to the equation of motion [19]. These thermal fluctuations usually help the particle to hop from one minimum to the next one, leading to corrections in Fk that are logarithmic, or approximately logarithmic, in velocity within the low-velocity regime, which can be rationalized within Eyring’s theory [20]. Similar corrections can be obtained for the static friction force as a function of the rate of loading. For very small barriers or sliding velocities/loading rates friction can disappear completely. However, practical applications are usually far away from such extreme conditions. In FK chains, point masses also have to overcome energy barriers, which, however happens in a collective fashion via the motion of so-called kinks [21]. Kinks are narrow regions where some atoms will sit close to or on the top of the potential energy. For weak elastic coupling, no particle will sit on top of an energy barrier at zero temperature. This is the reason for the existence of finite static and kinetic friction. At finite temperatures the probability of particles to sit on top of the barrier is not zero any longer. This enables kinks to creep and as a consequence static and kinetic friction vanish provided that the experimental time scales are sufficiently long. Besides trying to understand how thermal fluctuations affect friction, there have also been attempts to study the influence of the ionic quantum-mechanical zero-point vibrations. One study by Popov [22] investigated how quantum fluctuations modify the phononic drag forces between solids, which were sub-summarized in the drag coefficient γ introduced in Equation (1). Popov thus studied friction between incommensurate, weakly interacting solids, rather than friction due to elastic instabilities. It turned out that due to the quantum nature of phonons, the phononic drag forces would decrease with the fourth power of T upon cooling. Krajewski and Müser investigated whether quantum fluctuations automatically depin FK chains [23,24]. They found that this is not the case in contrast to thermal fluctuations. Specifically, for the quantum-mechanical version of the original FK
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
47
model, they identified a critical mass for the FK atoms, below which the chain was depinned (small masses lead to large quantum fluctuations) and above which the chain was pinned, i.e., showed finite friction. For self-affine embedding potentials, no such critical masses exist. The FK chains remain pinned in the thermodynamic limit, no matter how small the atomic masses. It is important to note that in real systems, temperature-induced phenomena cannot only decrease friction, as argued in this section, but also enhance friction. Thermally-assisted plastic flow will increase the effective contact area, which increases the effective load and consequently the friction.
3.3 COMPUTER SIMULATIONS The analytical models discussed in the last section can generally not be used to make quantitative predictions for specific materials, because they elude chemical detail. In some cases, it is possible to parameterize the adjustable coefficients of the models in use such that they reflect the properties of real materials and interfaces. However, even these simplified mathematical representation of solids require the use of numerical methods, molecular dynamics (MD) being one of the most important techniques. In MD simulations atomic configurations are set up in a computer experiment, interactions between atoms are assumed (or calculated with quantum chemical first-principle techniques) and Newton’s equation of motion is solved for each individual atom. The boundary walls are typically coupled to a driving device and boundary conditions are chosen such that a tribological experiment is mimicked in the best possible way. Sliding produces heat, which then requires the use of (artificial) thermostats that remove the heat from a sliding contact. A large part of the literature is concerned with so-called generic models, where the interactions between atoms are only simple two-body potentials. Simulations of generic models can capture many tribological effects qualitatively or in some cases even semiquantitatively. Some of those models will be commented on in the next section. In the context of superlubricity, one important question to address is whether solids generically have the tendency to show finite static and kinetic friction when brought into contact or whether one should expect superlubricity only for very specific materials. 3.3.1
Rough Interfaces, Elastic Solids and Superlubricity
Even highly polished surfaces maintain roughness on many different length scales. The height profile h(x, y) of a surface is a fluctuating quantity. Its first moment corresponds to the average height. A function containing important information on the statistical properties of the profile is the height-difference correlation function C2 (r) defined as 2 C2 (r) = h(0, 0) − h(x, y) ,
(5)
where r is the magnitude of the vector r = (x, y). In many cases C2 (r) increases algebraically with r, i.e., over many orders of magnitude C2 (r) ∼ r 2H , where H is known as
48
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
Figure 3.4 Illustration of the contact between an elastically-deformable solid and a rigid rough substrate. Only the bottom layer of the top solid is shown and explicitly simulated within GFMD. The direction normal to the interface is magnified approximately 20 times with respect to the directions that lie within the interface. The right half of the GFMD layer is represented in a more transparent fashion than its left half. From [31].
the Hurst roughness exponent [25]. Besides the complexity of roughness profiles, other difficulties arise in analytical approaches [16,26,27] to tackle the tribology of real solids. Even numerical approaches of interfaces between solids with realistic roughness on many length scales are still in their infancy [26–31]. These studies are mainly focused on the contact mechanics rather than on sliding. However, as outlined further below, knowing the contact mechanics may allow one to make predictions on the friction between the solids. Recent advances in the numerical treatment of realistic interfaces were made possible by new computational methods. Many of these methods are based on the idea that a system can be described on ever more coarse-grained meshes as one moves away from the contact region [27–30]. A different approach was taken by the current authors, who implemented a Green’s function-based molecular dynamics (GFMD) technique, in which only the outermost layer has to be simulated explicitly [31]. The elastic deformation within the bulk can be integrated out prior to the simulations and encrypted in the effective interaction between surface atoms. Thus, when simulating a flat semi-infinite solid that is placed on top of a rigid, rough substrate, only one layer of atoms needs to be simulated. This is illustrated in Figure 3.4, in which one can see the true microscopic points of contacts, which occupy only a small fraction of the full contact. Note that in these simulations, the macroscopic normal pressure was 10−3 times the Young modulus E of the elastically deformable solid, which would constitute a very large value for most technological applications. An important quantity in contact mechanics is the pressure distribution function P (p). In those regions, where the pressure p exceeds the yield strength of the material, the system will yield and show dissipation. Thus, when P (p) has a significant tail at large values of p, the system must be expected to deform plastically. Moreover, at large values of p, one may expect the onset of instabilities akin of the instabilities in the PT or the FK model. Figure 3.5 shows the pressure distribution calculated for a roughness profile from a highly polished steel surface. One can see that P (p) has essentially vanished at 0.1E. Thus, no instabilities should be expected that are pressure induced at the microscopic scale.
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
49
Figure 3.5 Pressure distribution P (p) in the contact region between elastic bodies with realistic roughness. The solid line shows an exponentially decaying function. From [31].
Figure 3.6 Sliding velocity v as a function of the driving force F divided by the external load L for an elastic solid rubbed over a substrate. Experimental roughness profiles from highly-polished steel surfaces were used in the calculations. Two models are investigated: One which is based on the bare experimental data. The resulting curves are labeled as “without atomic roughness”. In the other model, roughness was artificially added at the atomic scale and labeled “with atomic roughness”. The slope of the dashed line reflects the velocity of a solid that experiences a lateral force F and the damping of the thermostat but no additional friction. In all cases, F is gradually increased.
50
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
Even if the pressure distribution in a contact is known, frictional forces can only be ascertained via sliding. For the system, whose pressure distribution is shown in Figure 3.5, it turns out that kinetic friction vanishes and that static friction, if present at all, must be very small. This can be seen in Figure 3.6: Very small shear forces, i.e., 10−4 times the normal load, are sufficient to initiate sliding. In these simulations, neither adhesion nor adsorbed molecules were included. Thus, the analysis focuses entirely on the competition of intra-bulk elasticity and roughness-induced interfacial forces. The promising result is the absence of instabilities, which thus implies that even rough surfaces can be superlubric. In the calculations, the roughness profiles were taken from experimental data of polished steel surfaces. As the data did not include roughness on the atomic scale but only down to a wavelength of 1 nm, some simulations were run at which typical atomic scale roughness was added artificially. This atomic scale roughness apparently helps to pin the interface, or at least to enhance the dissipation, as evidenced by the much reduced sliding velocities computed at shear forces that were less than 10−4 times the load. It thus appears that the roughness of the very last layer may play a key role for superlubricity, as already pointed out by the Robbins group [29]. 3.3.2
Lennard-Jones Systems
In the previous section, we discussed studies in which the interactions between atoms within solids were predominantly modeled as being elastic. However, many processes, such as plastic deformation, formation of debris, and related phenomena cannot be captured by such simple approaches. A common approach to incorporate the atomistic nature of solids in computer simulations is the study of “Lennard Jonesium,” which is a (virtual) material in which atoms interact through the Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential V (r) = 4ε[(σ/r)12 − (σ/r)6 ], where σ and ε are the LJ length and LJ energy. Using simple two body potentials allows one to validate predictions made for the role that dimensionality, commensurability, surface roughness and other variables play on the tribological properties of a system. In the context of superlubricity, simulations based on potentials as generic as Lennard-Jones, allow one to assess potential limitations to ultra-low friction. Since the detailed molecular structure of the last layer appears to play a crucial role in tribological systems, crystalline materials are favorite targets for computer simulations. One important question to address is at what interfacial strength instabilities and thus solid friction becomes unavoidable. A characteristic example addressing this question investigated the interaction between two solids, each of which was a face-centered cubic solid with (111) surfaces [32]. Figure 3.7 shows a snapshot of the simulations, in which the two solids were brought out of registry by rotating them by 90◦ . An important assumption in the simulations was the absence of chemical reactions between the solids and the lack of contamination on the boundary surfaces. All interactions between identical atoms were normalized in a way that σ = ε = 1 and the LJ parameters for pairs of atoms located on opposed sides of the interface were chosen σi = σ and the strength of (dislike) atoms εi was varied. In order to obtain instantaneous instabilities the ratio εi /ε had to be approximately equal to eight. These instabilities, however, were not elastic in nature, but they involved large rearrangement of the atoms which could be
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
51
Figure 3.7 (a) Low-load configuration of chemically-passivated solids with terraces. Both configurations are [111] surfaces of fcc LJ solids. (b) Snapshot of a configuration that result from configuration (a) after applying a high normal pressure. The friction coefficients remained below 10−2 for both systems.
interpreted as cold welding. If the simulations could be run for much longer times these instabilities could have been observed for any value of εi > ε, because mixing is thermodynamically favorable. As long as the pressure conditions are not extreme and plastic deformation is absent or relatively small, full-atoms simulations of curved tips show that many of the analytical arguments discussed before for flat contacts also apply to curved tips [33,34]. Friction appears to be largest for commensurate, intermediate for disordered and smallest for incommensurate contacts. A significant conclusion arising from those simulations is that large radii of curvature lead to a smaller ratio of lateral and normal pressure. This means that layered materials may be one possibility to achieve ultra-small friction. Despite all the insights from simulations of Lennard Jonesium, many tribological aspects cannot be captured within this model, for instance, whenever directed bonds are important. These play an obviously crucial role in molecular solids, layered materials and other chemically complex solids such as the low-friction Teflon. Also, metals are poorly described by LJ potentials, i.e., the well-known necking during contact formation between bare metals is a consequence of the particular many-body form of metals. Generally, metals have a larger propensity to annihilate free surface than Lennard Jonesium, which favors cold welding. Lennard Jonesium is unable to reproduce these effects and thus more realistic studies are required to predict friction (or the absence thereof) between these materials. 3.3.3
Adsorbed Layers, Confined Fluids and Boundary Lubrication
So far, contaminants, lubricants, or other “third bodies” have not yet been considered in this chapter. However, their presence at the interface has been shown to provide a simple and quite general explanation for the prevalence of static and kinetic friction between solid bodies [9,35–37]. Small hydrocarbon molecules are able to move relative freely along the interfaces thereby producing a local energy minimum. When the pressure increases, these adsorbed films solidify and thus lock the two contacting surfaces, even if their surface geometries do not match. Third bodies are frequently modeled within MD simulations as simple atoms or chains of atoms. Typically, monomers interact with wall atoms via LJ potentials. At large pressures, the repulsive interactions between the monomers and wall atoms dominate. The atoms behave then similar to hard disks or hard spheres. Depending on the radii of the atoms, the lubricant particles penetrate the wells between the wall atoms more or less deeply. In order to start sliding, monomers must overcome the barrier of the ramp defined by the closest surface. This geometric argument yields a static friction force Fs = μL where μ is
52
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
the local slope of the ramp and explains in a semi-quantitative way why the shear stress often increases linearly with normal stress in single-asperity contacts. When the atomic diameters of lubricating or contaminating particles are large compared to the interatomic distances within the surfaces, one would expect small friction coefficients. This argument may explain why superlubricity can be observed experimentally even when no ultra-high vacuum is applied. Of course, one of the most important functions of lubricants is to keep surfaces from making intimate mechanical or chemical contact. Thus, it can reduce the friction by an order of magnitude, in particular in contacts between metals [38]. Interestingly, it has been observed that contacts can be essentially superlubric even under boundary lubricating conditions [39,40]. Zhu and Granick [39] found that the friction between two mica sheets separated by a confined alkane fluid can be exceptionally small, i.e., much smaller than one would expect from the geometric interlocking picture for adsorbed layers suggested in [9,35–37]. Inspired by molecular dynamics simulations that were based on realistic interatomic potentials, Jabbarzadeh et al. [40] proposed that the extremely low friction was due to layering in the confined film. They observed a mechanism similar to solid lubrication in which simple shear planes existed within the fluid—see also the next section. In this scenario, the detailed nature of the confined lubricant proved crucial for the observed superlubricity. More research has to be done. However, the present results are certainly encouraging. 3.3.4
Solid Lubricants and Layered Structures
Solid lubricants are technologically important because of their practical applications in circumstances where liquid lubricants malfunction. Space and ultra-high vacuum technologies are two examples. The most prominent examples of solid lubricants are graphite, WS2 , and MoS2 , which, like other layered materials, have strong chemical bonds within the plane and weak, mostly van-der Waals interactions between the planes [41]. The low-friction behavior of these materials is related to the low shear strength between neighboring layers. For this reason, one would expect that layered solids are natural candidates for superlubric materials. Experimental recent work on the tribological properties of MoS2 suggests a combination of some specific factors as the mechanisms responsible for its extremely good lubrication properties [42,43]. Maintenance of the lamellar structure, oxidation prevention, homogeneous transfer, films formation, and inter-crystallite slip have been considered responsible for its successful performance [44]. Another interesting aspect of many layered materials, in particular graphite and WS2 is their ability to form nanotubes. These nanotubes, unlike atomic force microscope tips whose structures have remained elusive, allow one to study friction in a single-asperity contact for well-defined geometries [45–47]. In many cases nanotubes are multiwalled and the friction forces between the inner and outer tube can be measured within experiments [48]. For incommensurate tubes, nonextensive shear stresses are found suggestive of the dominant roles of surface effects in those systems. In a large number of cases, computer simulations of double-walled nanotubes show extremely small friction forces. While trying to minimize the free energy of the system, in the absence of instabilities only very little amount of heat will be dissipated
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
53
upon sliding. Surprisingly, also commensurate tubes can show small kinetic friction, at least in idealized computer simulations [49]. In the absence of any defects, the net damping calculated for commensurate and incommensurate nanotubes turned out to be of similar magnitude. Idealization of the nanotubes geometry in simulations has proven to be the main source of error when calculating the values of the friction forces [50]. However, one can obtain reasonable good agreement for kinetic friction if chemical details of the fractured end are incorporated into the simulations. Edge defects drive friction calculations to higher values especially when covalent bonds are established between inner and outer tube. In practice, an important disadvantage of layered materials is that the sheets are easily rubbed off. This process leads to the generation of debris and consequently friction increases. This effect may become particularly severe under the presence of chemical point defects. 3.3.5
Metallic Contacts
Metals are obviously not good candidates for superlubric materials, in particular due to their propensity to necking and cold welding. They are yet interesting to study, even in the context of superlubricity, for mainly two reasons: First, the term superlubricity was coined based on a theoretical study of copper interfaces [1] and second, limitations of superlubricity become probably more obvious for metals than for other materials. Under idealized conditions, i.e., absence of contact lines, perfect crystalline structures, etc., it can almost be seen as established that simple, incommensurate metals would be superlubric [15,32,51]. In real situations, however, atomic diffusion and interface reconstruction are certainly important processes at the contact regions between clean metals in ultrahigh vacuum, i.e., when two metallic surfaces are placed in contact, in the absence of contamination, metal atoms will diffuse to maximize the metal/metal and minimize the metal/vacuum surface energies. This welds the two surfaces together and thus leads to friction [38,52]. One can yet ask the question, how much friction one should expect in idealized situations. A particularly interesting study addressed the role of roughness in the very last layer. Qi et al. studied atomically smooth Ni(100)/Ni(1000) interfaces [53]. Their idealized geometries display the same superlubric behavior as expected in idealized copper interfaces. However, roughening the top layer with a mere 0.8 Å variation, changes the behavior completely, with friction coefficients increasing by several orders of magnitude. The calculated values for the surfaces with the 0.8 Å additional roughness match the available experimental data [54] extremely well. Simulations incorporating generic embedded atom models have also been used to compute the friction forces of metallic interfaces. Partial transformations of fcc structures under shear were observed creating transient, grained microstructures. Mixing of the material due to this grain formation was obtained triggering stick-slip motion at large length scales [55]. In another study by Zhang et al. [56], chemical passivated incommensurate Al2 O3 surfaces showed small but yet non-negligible friction at moderate normal loads, although no wear occurred. This behavior is in contrast to that of simple metals, where finite friction typically goes hand in hand with more dramatic structural rearrangements. It is tempting
54
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
to speculate that the directed bonds in the Al2 O3 layers are responsible for wear-less instabilities to occur. Unfortunately, no analysis was made regarding the detailed atomic nature of the instabilities. 3.3.6
Carbon Films and Hydrogen-Terminated Surfaces
Hydrogen-terminated carbon films are probably the most promising candidates as superlubric materials for industrial applications [5,6,57]. Diamond-like carbon (DLC) and carbidederived carbon (CDC) based materials represent the most significant compounds included within this group. They show typical values for the friction coefficient in open air in the range 0.20–0.25. In dry nitrogen, the values may decrease up to 0.15 and using special hydrogenation techniques post-hydrogen-treated films exhibited friction coefficients as low as 0.003 [5]. The difference between the values in dry nitrogen atmosphere (under hydrogen treatment) and open air is commonly explained by the presence/absence of sigma-bonds. Hydrogen treatment effectively reduced or eliminated those bonds providing the small values registered on the experiments [6]. Molecular dynamics simulations of the impact behavior of many hydrocarbon species on DLC physical properties have been reported recently. In particular, the sticking and H-abstraction of those species relevant for the growth of the DLC films via the updated Brenner potential were considered [58,59]. Unfortunately, there have not yet been many simulations concerning friction studies on hydrogen-terminated surfaces. Interesting new results are expected in the near future, in particular from the Harrison group, which makes efficient use of force fields that allow the modeling of chemical reactions. So far, a large fraction of computational studies of chemically-passivated surfaces has been concerned with self-assembled monolayers (SAM) [60–62]. These physical entities are much softer than chemically bonded solids, and thus while being low in friction, they appear to be inappropriate candidates to provide super-low friction. The crucial role that surface orientation plays (commensurability issues) was also found in a second computational work on friction involving monolayers. For truly commensurate layers the (differential) kinetic friction coefficient (∂Fk /∂L) turned out much larger than in those cases where line defects significantly reduced commensurability [61]. The packing density of atoms within the layers and its influence on the local hardness, contributes also to the change in friction. Less densely packed and hence softer systems will become more easily unstable than dense, hard systems. For instance, friction between an amorphous carbon tip and an SAM decreased with increasing packing [62].
3.4
CONCLUSIONS
Analytical models and computer simulations clearly point to the possibility of identifying superlubricity for many pairs of materials. Chemical passivation and smoothness of the interfaces are some of the most important ingredients favoring superlubricity. Also, the absence/saturation of dangling bonds on the contact regions between solids as well as
Theoretical Studies of Superlubricity
55
the property of some materials to form layered structures appear to be other necessary conditions to achieve ultra-low friction. Systems similar to diamond-like carbon, obtained using hydrogen treatment, are currently the best candidates to show superlubricity. They have very smooth and non-reactive interfaces. In theory, the dangling bonds in this type of systems could be terminated with atoms larger than hydrogen such as fluorine making the surfaces even smoother. However, it may be that fluorinated layers may rub off easily resulting in the formation of debris which could ultimately increase friction. As a last point, we would like to emphasize that superlubricity is not a well-defined term. Some commensurate systems where the static friction is high may not show any kinetic friction at all. To avoid confusion, the term structural lubricity had been suggested. Systems that show small static friction could be named to be structurally lubric (absence of geometric interlocking), while systems showing small kinetic friction (absence of instabilities) are superlubric. Using this terminology, structural lubricity would be a subset of superlubricity. For instance, the small friction between a graphite substrate and a missoriented graphite flake observed by Dienwiebel et al. [7] should be classified as structurally lubric, while Socoliuc et al.’s experiment [8] demonstrated superlubricity (absence of hysteresis) but not structural lubricity, because relatively large instantaneous lateral forces and thus interlocking or finite static friction were measured.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24]
Hirano, M., Shinjo, K. Phys. Rev. B 41 (1990), 11837. Shinjo, K., Hirano, M. Surf. Sci. 283 (1993), 473. Martin, J.M., Donnet, C., Le Mogne, T. Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993), 10583. Donnet, C., Martin, J.M., LeMogne, T., Belin, M. Tribol. Int. 29 (1996), 126. Erdemir, A. Surf. Coat. Technol. 146 (2001), 292. Erdemir, A. et al. Surf. Coat. Technol. 188–189 (2004), 588. Dienwiebel, M. et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 922 (2004), 126101. Socoliuc, A., Bennewitz, R., Gnecco, E., Meyer, E. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 (2004), 134301. Müser, M.H., Wenning, L., Robbins, M.O. Phys. Rev. Lett. 86 (2001), 1295. Robbins, M.O., Müser, M.H. In: Bhushan, B. (Ed.), Modern Tribology Handbook, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 2001. Müser, M.H., Urbakh, M., Robbins, M.O. Adv. Chem. Phys. 126 (2003), 187. Prandtl, L. Z. Angew. Math. Mech. 8 (1928), 85. Tomlinson, G.A. Philos. Mag. Series 7 (1929), 905. Frenkel, Y.I., Kontorova, T. Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 8 (1938), 1340. Hirano, M. Wear 254 (2003), 932. Persson, B.N.J. J. Chem. Phys. 115 (2001), 3840. Persson, B.N.J., Tosatti, E. Solid State Commun. 109 (1999), 739. Müser, M.H. Europhys. Lett. 66 (2004), 97. Kubo, R. Rep. Prog. Phys. 29 (1966), 255. Glasstone, S., Laidler, K.J., Eyring, H. Theory of Rate Processes. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1941. Braun, O.M., Kivshar, Y.S. Phys. Rep. 306 (1998), 2. Popov, V.L. Tribol. Int. 34 (2001), 279. Krajewski, F.R., Müser, M.H. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 (2004), 030601. Krajewski, F.R., Müser, M.H. J. Chem. Phys. 122 (2005), 124711.
56
C.E. Campañá and M.H. Müser
[25] Meakin, P. Fractals, Scaling and Growth Far from Equilibrium. Cambridge University Press, New York, 1997. [26] Yang, C., Tartaglino, U., Persson, B.N.J. Eur. Phys. J. E 19 (2006), 47. [27] Persson, B.N.J. Surf. Sci. Rep. 61 (2006), 201. [28] Hyun, S., Pei, L., Molinari, J.F., Robbins, M.O. Phys. Rev. E 70 (2004), 026117. [29] Luan, B., Hyun, S., Robbins, M.O., Bernstein, N. Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 841 (2005), R7.4.1. [30] Pei, L., Hyun, S., Molinari, J.F., Robbins, M.O. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 53 (2005), 2385. [31] Campañá, C., Müser, M.H. Phys. Rev. B 74 (2006), 075420. [32] Müser, M.H. Tribol. Lett. 10 (2001), 15. [33] Wenning, L., Müser, M.H. Europhys. Lett. 54 (2001), 693. [34] Luan, B.Q., Robbins, M.O. Nature 435 (2005), 929. [35] He, G., Müser, M.H., Robbins, M.O. Science 284 (1999), 1650. [36] He, G., Robbins, M.O. Phys. Rev. B 64 (2001), 035413. [37] Müser, M.H. Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002), 224301. [38] Bowden, F.P., Tabor, D. The Friction and Lubrication of Solids. Clarendon, Oxford, 1986. [39] Zhu, Y., Granick, S. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004), 096101. [40] Jabbarzadeh, A., Harrowell, P., Tanner, R.I. Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005), 126103. [41] Roberts, E.W. Tibol. Int. 23 (1990), 95. [42] Cizaire, L. et al. Surf. Coat. Techn. 160 (2002), 282. [43] Joly-Pottuz, L. et al. Tribol. Lett. 18 (2005), 477. [44] Martin, J.M. et al. Surf. Coat. Techn. 68 (1994), 427. [45] Falvo, M.R. et al. Nature 397 (1999), 236. [46] Buldum, A., Lu, J.P. Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 (1999), 5050. [47] Schall, J.D., Brenner, D.W. Mol. Simulat. 25 (2000), 73. [48] Kolmogorov, A.N., Crespi, V.H. Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 (2000), 4727. [49] Tangney, P., Louie, S.G., Cohen, M.L. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004), 065503. [50] Xia, Z., Curtin, W.A. Phys. Rev. B 69 (2004), 233408. [51] Sørensen, M.R., Jacobsen, K.W., Stoltze, P. Phys. Rev. B 53 (1996), 2101–2113. [52] Landman, U., Luedtke, W.D., Burnham, N.A., Colton, R.J. Science 248 (1990), 454. [53] Qi, Y., Cheng, Y.-T., Cagin, T., Goddard, W.A. III Phys. Rev. B 66 (2002), 085420. [54] Ko, J.S., Gellman, A.J. Langmuir 16 (2000), 8343. [55] Stankovic, I., Hess, S., Kröger, M. Phys. Rev. E 70 (2004), 066139. [56] Zhang, Q., Qi, Y., Hector, L.G., Jr., Cagin, T., Goddard, W.A. III Phys. Rev. B 72 (2005), 045406. [57] Kano, M. et al. Tribol. Lett. 18 (2005), 245. [58] Neyts, E. et al. Diamond Relat. Mater. 13 (2004), 1873. [59] Neyts, E. et al. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. B 228 (2005), 315. [60] Mikulski, P.T., Harrison, J.A. Tribol. Lett. 10 (2001), 29. [61] Park, B. et al. Langmuir 20 (2004), 10007. [62] Mikulski, P.T., Gao, G.T., Chateauneuf, G.M., Harrison, J.A. J. Chem. Phys. 122 (2005), 024701.
–4– Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces S. Ciraci1 , T. Yildirim2 , S. Dag3 and O. Gulseren1 1 Department of Physics, Bilkent University, Ankara 06800, Turkey 2 NIST Center for Neutron Research, National Institute of Standards and Technology,
Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA 3 Center of Nanophase Materials Science (CNMS) and Computer Science and
Mathematics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37830, USA
4.1 INTRODUCTION The dry sliding friction [1–3] of two objects, which are in direct contact through their asperities, involves many interesting and complex phenomena induced by the long- and short-range forces [4,5], such as adhesion, wetting, atom-exchange, bond-breaking and bond-formation, elastic and plastic deformation. In general, phonons are generated and electron–hole pairs are created at the expense of damped mechanical energy. Even the photons can be emitted. The nonequilibrium phonon distribution generated locally is dissipated by phonon–phonon and electron–phonon coupling. Simulations of dry sliding friction between a metal asperity and an incommensurate metal surface have revealed unusual atomic processes [6]. For example, the lateral force exhibits a quasiperiodic variation with the displacement of an asperity; each period consists of two different stick-slip processes involving structural transitions. It has been also found that the perpendicular elastic deformation of the substrate that is induced by the sliding object is crucial in the energy damping in friction [7]. In certain condition, owing to the elastic deformation of the substrate the corrugation of the surface potential energy can be inverted under high loading forces. This situation gives rise to the occurrence of second state (or bistability) in the stick-slip motion and anisotropy in the hysteresis curve [7]. It is also very well-known that the stiffer the sliding surfaces, the smaller is the friction coefficient [7]. The dry sliding friction between atomically flat, commensurate or incommensurate sliding surfaces is perhaps the simplest but most fundamental type of friction in tribology. Superlubricity Edited by A. Erdemir and J.-M. Martin © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
58
S. Ciraci et al.
The relative motion of two commensurate surfaces can take place through repeating stickslip stages and hence helps us to visualize the energy damping under weak elastic deformation. However, the situation is rather complex if the sliding surfaces are incommensurate and undergo an elastic or plastic deformation involving the atom-exchange and wear. The atomic-scale analysis of the interaction between sliding surfaces is necessary to understand the nature of non-conservative lateral forces and various mechanisms of energy damping. In fact, studies based on the Tomlinson’s model [8] or calculations using Frenkel–Kontorova model [9] have revealed valuable information about atomic processes in friction. The invention of atomic force microscope [10] and the friction force microscope [11,12] has made an important impact on the science of friction and opened a new field called nanotribology. Nowadays, various atomic processes can be easily observed and lateral forces in the range of a fraction of nano Newton (1 nN = 10−9 N = 0.62415 eV/Å) can be measured with precision by using these microscopes. Meanwhile atomic scale simulations involving several atoms have been performed using realistic empirical potentials [13–18]. Moreover, ab-initio studies based on Density Functional Theory (DFT) [19] treating relatively smaller systems have provided accurate calculations of interaction forces between two surfaces [5,20] and also led to the development of new empirical potentials. Theoretical studies, on the other side, have started to investigate microscopic aspects of energy transfer and energy damping processes [21–24]. While friction invokes the lost of enormous resources, the lowering of the friction coefficient has been the principal goal in various fields of science and technology. Lubricants have been used to lower the friction coefficients and to eliminate the wear in machining and in the transportation industries. In the last decade, progress made in materials science and surface coating technologies has led to a steady lowering of the friction coefficient. Developing of nearly frictionless surfaces or coating materials has been an ultimate goal of tribology and surface physics. In this work we carry out an atomic scale study based on ab-initio (first-principles) calculations and reveal physical mechanisms underlying the superlow friction coefficient in dry sliding friction. To this end, we investigate dry sliding friction between the commensurate surfaces of a covalent crystal (namely friction between two diamond (001) surfaces) and an ionic crystal (namely friction between two BN (001) surface). We examine interaction between bare surfaces and explore the effect of hydrogenation. The organization of this chapter is as follows: We first present general theoretical arguments regarding to the nearly frictionless sliding friction and outline recent experimental progress made in the field. We review theoretical methods and present a short description for the atomistic model and essential features of our ab-initio calculations. Discussion of our results obtained from the ab-initio calculations on the sliding friction of two diamond (001) and two BN (001) surfaces constitute the prime part of this chapter.
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
59
4.2 FRICTIONLESS SLIDING 4.2.1
General Theoretical Arguments
Absence of energy damping in mesoscopic objects has been pointed out earlier [25]. This question can be clarified by examining the energy damping agents involved in friction. These are long- and short-range interactions between two surfaces and various elementary excitations, such as phonon, electron–hole creation, charge density waves and photon emission. High energy excitations such as surface plasmons do not contribute to the energy damping process. Bond-breaking or rebonding, and atom exchange between surfaces and local surface reconstruction can damp mechanical energy and or mediate excitations. Normally acoustic phonons with small excitation energy can easily be excited and hence contribute to the energy damping process. Experiments performed using non-contact AFM [26] have shown that the tip vibrating over the sample gives rise to the energy dissipation even if its minimum spacing from the surface is farther than the range of short-range forces [27–30]. This argument eliminates the possibility that absolutely zero coefficient of kinetic friction, namely μk = 0 can ever occur. Apparently, superlubricity with μk = 0 (reminiscent of superconductivity or superfluidity) cannot be achieved in normal operation conditions, but very low (superlow) friction coefficient is a target one can achieve. The interaction energy, Ei (ρ, z) between two flat surfaces is a function of their spacing z and their relative lateral position ρ = x iˆ + y jˆ. Usually, the interaction energy is small and attractive (i.e. Ei < 0) for large z (z < 0), but decreases (becomes more attractive) as z decreases. It then starts to increase by passing through a minimum and eventually becomes repulsive (i.e. Ei > 0). The attractive interaction energy is specified as adhesion between two surfaces and involves the formation of bonds between surfaces which may give rise to high friction coefficient in the course of sliding motion. Under loading forces Ei can increase and change into repulsive range where elastic and at least local plastic deformations may occur. Substances (solid lubricants, inert gas atoms, etc.) are placed between surfaces to weaken Ei . In ultrahigh vacuum conditions, the friction coefficient as low as μ = 0.01 have been observed for MoS2 and diamond-like carbon (DLC) coatings [31–33]. Even if the lubrication of surfaces coated with such low friction coefficient materials appears to be desirable, the low friction coefficient can increase under different ambient and operation conditions. Coating of surfaces with special materials resulting in repulsive interaction for a wide range of spacing between sliding surfaces is required. Then the loading force will be balanced by the repulsive force derived from the interaction energy, Fz (ρ, z) = −∂Ei (ρ, z)/∂z and the atoms on one surface will be prevented from merging into other surface through a large spacing maintained between them. This way bond-breaking, rebonding and severe deformations will be eliminated. Flying of trains over the superconductive rails is reminiscent of the sliding of surfaces under a repulsive interaction between coated surfaces. In order to reduce the energy damping in the relative motion and hence to lower μk one has to also take the force constants determining the vibration frequencies of atoms into account. It is well-known that the stiffer the sliding surface the lower is the friction constant. Being the principal energy damping agents, the availability of phonons which can get excited by the any sudden release of elastic deformation is not favored. In this respect,
60
S. Ciraci et al.
coating materials made of short and stiff surface bonds are required in nearly frictionless sliding. 4.2.2
Recent Experimental Progress
In an effort to lower the friction coefficient, Erdemir et al. [34–36] reported superlow friction and wear between diamond-like carbon (DLC) coated surfaces using a hydrogen-rich plasma. They achieved kinetic friction coefficient μk as low as 0.001 and wear rates of 10−9 –10−10 mm3 /Nm in inert gas environment under 10 N load and 0.2–0.5 m/s sliding velocities. It has been shown that observed low magnitude and time-variation of μk have a close correlation with hydrogen content of the source gas. This work by Erdemir and his coworkers has been a breakthrough towards the achievement of superlow friction and long durability of moving parts in various mechanical applications ranging from the automotive industry to nanotechnology.
4.3
DESCRIPTION OF THEORETICAL MODEL
Normally, the structure of sliding surfaces contains several types of defects, such as asperities of different shapes and sizes, vacancies, impurities, domains, etc. A realistic simulation of dry sliding friction has to include all these defects. Hence the atomistic models of sample surfaces have to comprise a large number of atoms. In this respect, the classical molecular dynamics (CMD) method using empirical potentials to represent atomic scale interaction is convenient for the simulation of friction process. Recently, various processes have been simulated and new structures have been predicted by using empirical potentials developed for certain systems. Since numerical calculations using these empirical potentials are not time-consuming, large systems comprising several thousands of atoms have been treated. However, the main drawback of CMD simulations appears when a completely new system is treated. In particular, when the character of the surface atoms (such as their effective charge and bonds) deviate dramatically from those of bulk structure. Under these circumstances, whether the empirical potential parameterized using the bulk properties becomes questionable. On the other side, ab-initio calculations can provide reliable results for the optimized atomic structure, mechanical, electronic and magnetic properties and phonon density of states of a given system, if it involves small number (200–300) of atoms. Various mechanisms underlying the energy dissipation and estimations of friction coefficient with upper and lower limits can be revealed. In this respect, ab-initio methods are superior to classical methods if the system can be represented by 200–300 atoms. Besides, ab-initio methods are complementary to CMD in revealing the correct charge and bonding structure and hence in developing reliable empirical potentials. 4.3.1
Atomistic Models and Details for Ab-initio Calculations
In this study, sliding surfaces are represented by two infinite slabs made from the atomic layers of the coating materials. The atoms of slabs are treated in two different categories. In the first category, the atoms at the back surfaces of both slabs are kept fixed in their ideal
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
61
configurations, xi , yi , zi . The layers of fixed atoms represent sample or coating layers away from the sliding surface. Normally, they are not affected from the friction process. By displacing all the fixed atoms of one slab relative to the fixed atoms of the other slab one can achieve a lateral displacement of two slabs and induce a loading force. The atoms at the surface region of the slabs facing each other are treated in the second category and are relaxed while the first category atoms are fixed at given xi , yi , zi positions. This way, relative sliding of two slabs including atomic displacements, elastic and plastic deformations, etc. are modeled from the first-principles. The atomic process and forces in sliding friction have been investigated by carrying out calculations from the first-principles within DFT, which were proven to yield accurate predictions for many metal and insulator surfaces. Here we present crucial parameters of first-principle calculations. The sliding friction is treated either by supercell method using periodic boundary conditions or by finite size surfaces using local basis set. In the supercell method, the wave functions are expressed in momentum space. The magnitude of the largest wave vector sets the cutoff energy and hence the number of plane waves used in the expansion. The ionic potentials are represented by ultrasoft pseudopotentials [37,38] and then the cutoff energy is taken 300 eV. The exchange correlation potential is represented by using Generalized Gradient Approximation [39]. The Brillouin zone corresponding to the supercell is sampled within the Monkhorst–Pack special k-point scheme [40]. Optimization of atomic positions is performed by conjugate gradient method. Lateral components Fx , Fy and perpendicular component Fz of the net force induced between two slabs are calculated. We did not included the long-range Van der Waals force since it is negligible as compared to the perpendicular force Fz induced under high loading force FN .
4.4
SUPERLOW FRICTION COEFFICIENT BETWEEN HYDROGENATED DIAMOND SURFACES
Hydrogenated DLC (H:DLC) coating by all means is a complex, amorphous structure showing various irregularities. The sliding surfaces cannot be commensurate and contain irregularly distributed asperities and perhaps voids. We believe that determination of the structure of DLC by itself is important and treated earlier [42]. However, even if the structure of H:DLC realized in superlow friction [34–36] and also physical and chemical processes taking place in the course of friction are stochastic in nature, the local bond orders and C–H bond topology are expected to be similar to various hydrogenated diamond surfaces. Therefore, the interaction between H:DLC surfaces and the nature of interaction between these surfaces can be understood by using two hydrogenated diamond surfaces. In this section we will present our study of superlow friction coefficient between two hydrogenated diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces using first-principle plane wave method [41]. Clearly, our study does not promise a realistic simulation of the experiment resulted with superlow friction coefficient [34]. Our objective in this atomic scale study is to better understand the physical mechanisms involved in the superlow friction observed between hydrogenated DLC coated surfaces [34]. We hope that the ingredients of the superlow friction coefficient revealed from our study will be useful for developing new coating materials
62
S. Ciraci et al.
which are stable in the desired operating conditions. In particular, developing coating materials which can sustain to ambient conditions and oxidation is the objective our study. How simple our model can be, its two features are of particular importance. These are the full relaxation of surface atoms at any instant of sliding process, and accurate calculation of the variation of lateral force components under the constant loading force FN . Diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces are represented by two slabs facing each other at a distance. Each slab consists of 6 layers of carbon atoms. Carbon atoms at the back surface of each slab are saturated by hydrogen atoms. The atomic structure of the one individual slab is first optimized and then the carbon atoms at the 6th layer (at the back surface of the slab) and saturating H atoms (i.e. those atoms in the first category) are kept at their equilibrium positions. We believe that such configuration mimics the semi-infinite slab (or thick coating). Figure 4.1(a) illustrates two diamond (001)–(2 × 1) slab with H saturated, fixed back sides. The other surfaces of slabs face each other and are free when the distance d between them is large. The structural parameters of the bare surface which reconstructs to form dimer bonds are successfully reproduced. The normal force Fz originate from the short-range interaction between the surfaces of the slab. To this end, we kept the distance D between the back surfaces of the slabs at the preset value and calculated the total energy of whole system, ET (D, ρ) and total force on one of the slabs. Here the total energy and total force are obtained after the optimization of positions of atoms in the second category. We note that since two slabs are pressed against each other by fixing D, the calculated forces on the atoms at the back side balance the external (loading) forces which maintain D at a preset value. Therefore, total calculated
Figure 4.1 (a) Two diamond (001)–(2 × 1) slabs used to model the sliding of two diamond (001) surfaces. Carbon atoms at the back sides of the slabs are saturated by H atoms. The positions of these carbon atoms and those of saturating H atoms are fixed at the configuration corresponding to that obtained from the optimization of individual (free) slabs. The distance between the back surfaces of slabs is D, and that between two sliding surfaces facing each other is d. The crystal directions are identified by Cartesian axes shown by inset. C and H atoms are shown by filled and empty spheres, respectively. (b) Calculated normal force Fz is generated when two diamond (001) slabs are pressed towards each other by decreasing D and hence d. do and d correspond to spacing between two sliding diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces before and after relaxation. (Reproduced from [41].)
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
63
vertical force on one of the slabs is equal to the vertical interaction force Fz . By definition the loading force FN = −Fz . The variation of Fz is plotted in Figure 4.1(b) with respect to the separation between slab surfaces before relaxation, do , as well as the actual separation, d after the relaxation. The interaction is weak and repulsive for d > 2.75 Å, but Fz becomes attractive as D decreases and then jumps to contact attaining the value approximately equal to −6 eV/Å. Strong bonds form between the sliding surfaces of two diamond (001)–(2 × 1) slabs near equilibrium separation corresponding to Fz ≃ 0. Once a normal force is applied to press the slabs against each other, atoms of different surfaces come close to each other at d ∼ 1.5 Å and subsequently Fz becomes repulsive. Under these circumstances, since the sliding motion can involve local deformations, bond-breaking and rebonding, the dynamical friction coefficient, μk as well as the wear rate are expected to be high. In fact, the dynamical friction coefficient has been measured to be equal to 0.65 for the sliding DLC-coated surfaces which are free of hydrogen. 4.4.1 Force Variations in the Sliding Friction of Two Hydrogenated Diamond Surfaces
First, we will examine the variations of normal force when the sliding diamond surfaces are hydrogenated. Dangling bonds of carbon atoms on two slab surfaces facing each other are saturated by H atoms to form a monohydride phase, i.e. H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1). Upon the saturation of the surface dangling bonds the dangling bond surface states disappear and a wide energy gap opens between the valence and conduction bands of the slab. The surface charge density differs dramatically from that of the clean diamond (001)–(2 × 1). In Figure 4.2 we show the atomic configuration of the H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces. Moreover, Mulliken analysis indicates that 0.25 electrons are transferred from H atom to the C atom that is bound to it. This situations complies with the fact that the C atom is more electronegative than the H atom. As a result, the H atom is positively charged. The depletion of electrons on H atoms induces a repulsive interaction and hence a repulsive Fz even for d < 2.5 Å between H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces. This is the most essential feature in obtaining superlow friction coefficient from H:DLC coated sliding surfaces. The variation of Fz with spacing d is shown in Figure 4.2. This repulsive force Fz keeps the sliding surfaces wide apart at a distance d and balances the loading force FN . As a result, sliding surfaces are prevented from being too close. This way, deformation of C–H bonds are suppressed to a great extend. It is interesting to note that like carbon silicon is also a Group IV element and has diamond structure. A strong attractive interaction is generated between clean Si (001) slabs. However, similar to diamond (001) slabs, the attractive interaction turns repulsive upon the hydrogenation of Si (001) surfaces and generates a strong repulsive normal force. It appears that H:Si (001)–(2 × 1) displays a feature similar to that of H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1). We next examine whether this feature, namely the repulsive normal force between surfaces can lead to superlow friction coefficient. 4.4.2
Sliding Friction of Hydrogenated Diamond (001) Slabs
Having examined the perpendicular variation of Fz , we now address following questions: (i) Does the repulsive interaction continue to keep surfaces wide apart, if one of the diamond slabs is laterally displaced relative to other one. (ii) What is the range of FN
64
S. Ciraci et al.
Figure 4.2 (a) Atomic configuration of two diamond (001)–(2×1) slabs with the dangling bonds on the surfaces facing each other are saturated by hydrogen atoms to form monohydride phase H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1). The spacing d between these surfaces, normal force Fz , loading force FN . (b) Variation of the calculated normal force Fz between the two surfaces of H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1) as a function of their actual, relaxed separation d. Fz is generated when two diamond (001) slabs are pressed towards each other by decreasing D. The inset shows the variation of the same force between hydrogenated Si (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces. Right: Directions of the loading force FN , Fz , lateral force components Fx,y , and lateral displacements, x and y. Lateral force component, which is in opposite direction of displacement is indicated by superscript “<”. (Reproduced from [41].)
where the repulsive interaction between surfaces persists without any serious deformation? (iii) Can one present an upper limit for the friction coefficient? To answer all these questions we carried out a series of first-principle calculations for the interaction energy Ei , normal force Fz , lateral force FL corresponding to different loading force (hence D) and displacements ( x, y) of the upper slab. In these calculations, all the atoms have been relaxed, except C and H atoms at the back side of both slabs. The latter atoms are kept fixed in their ideal configurations after their planes are displaced to different perpendicular and lateral positions by varying D and ( x, y) in sequential increments. We note that by keeping two back ends of slabs at a distance D but relaxing the rest of the atoms induces a loading force FN (D), which in turn is balanced by Fz . Fz itself is obtained from the sum
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
65
Figure 4.3 (a) and (b) Variation of the calculated interaction energy Ei as a function of the perpendicular distance d calculated at the different lateral displacements x and y. (c) and (d) The same variation of the normal force Fz . Energy and force units correspond to per (2 × 1) unit cell. (Reproduced from [41].)
of the perpendicular component of calculated forces on the fixed atoms of one of the slabs. Namely Fz = i Fz,i , where i is the index of fixed atoms of one slab. The same sum on the other slab yields Fz with the same magnitude but in opposite direction. Similarly, the lateral forces along x (or y) axis are obtained from the sum Fx(y) = i Fi,x(y) . Performing ab-initio calculations of Ei , Fz , Fx,y as a function of d (or D) at different relative lateral positions, x and y a data base is created. In these calculations, the values of D have been varied in small steps to yield normal forces in an appropriate range of interest. Figure 4.3 presents calculated variations of Ei and Fz as a function of d for different lateral displacements, x and y, of the top slab. Here we note that the interaction energy Ei = ET − ET ,d=∞ , where ET ,d=∞ is the total energy corresponding to very large d (or twice the total energy of one slab in the absence of the other one). We note that the variation of Ei and Fz is not a smooth function owing to discrete changes of D and to the relaxation of the C–H bonds. Note that since Fz remains always repulsive and strong even at significantly large spacing, the sliding surfaces are kept apart even for large loading forces. As a result, C–H bonds of different surfaces neither merge nor interfere with each other. In the course of sliding C–H bonds experience neither significant deformation (i.e. bending, stretching or shrinking) nor wear through bonding–rebonding.
66
S. Ciraci et al.
If the sliding motion were adiabatic, no energy would be damped in sliding motion of two commensurate surfaces like we treat here. However, this is not the case; various sudden processes generate excitations and give rise to energy damping. Now we present a global approach to estimate an upper limit for μk using the variation of the lateral force from the present calculations. To this end we consider displacements along x- and y-axis and we construct lateral force variation under the given constant loading force using our data base, namely FL=x ( x, y = 0, FN ) and FL=y ( x = 0, y, FN ). Keeping the loading force FN constant is the most difficult part of our study and requires a large number of numerical calculations corresponding to different x, y and D. We considered the loading force FN = 1 and 1.2 eV/Å per cell, which are actually too high as compared to the loading force in the experiment [34] as well as in practical applications. In this respect, our estimation of μk is a stringent test. The variations of Fx and Fy are illustrated in Figure 4.4. For the reasons pointed out earlier the variation of lateral force is not smooth. Since lateral force is calculated using coarse displacement steps of D, the elastic deformation of slabs and C–H bonds induced by sliding are released suddenly. This gives rise to the stick-slip process as described by the Tomlinson’s model [8]. Of course, error bars involved in the calculation of forces. In particular, achieving the constraint of the constant loading force by limited number of data in the data base generated through ab-initio calculations can lead to hysteric variation of the lateral force. Now as an ad hoc approach to estimate μk in an energy damping medium, we assume that the work done by the lateral force FL (i.e. when it is parallel to the direction of motion as denoted by FL> ) is totally lost. Then the average friction force is calculated by F f = Fx< dx/R, R being the period of the motion. Using the data in Figure 4.4 we extract the average friction force, F f ∼ 0.05 eV/Å for FN = 1 eV/Å and F f ∼ 0.07 eV/Å for FN = 1.2 eV/Å. Then the kinetic friction coefficient 0.05 for both cases. A more realistic is calculated from μk = F f /FN to be approximately < > estimation could be obtained from F f = (Fx + Fx ) dx/R if lateral force variation were calculated precisely. Although our force variations in Figure 4.4 are too crude to obtain precise values, μk is calculated for the sake of comparison to be ∼0.01.
Figure 4.4 (a) Variation of the lateral force, FL=x [in eV/Å per (2 × 1) cell] as a function of the displacement x of the top slab relative to the bottom one. (b) Same as (a) for the displacement y. In the course of sliding the loading force FN is taken approximately constant. (Reproduced from [41].)
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
67
Figure 4.5 Calculated atomic configurations showing the effect of the oxygen atom on the H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surface. (a)–(d) The oxygen atom is placed at different sites of the surface unit cell before the relaxation of the surface. (a′ )–(d′ ) Atomic structure and bonding after relaxation of the system. The adsorbed oxygen atom is negatively charged. (Reproduced from [41].)
It should be noted that in the sliding of commensurate surfaces the lateral forces acting on each atom or cell are added constructively to yield a high total lateral force. These lateral forces are, however, conservative and do not give rise to energy damping, if the sliding motion is adiabatic. In the case of incommensurate surfaces, the total lateral force is relatively lower owing to the cancellations. H:DLC coated surfaces can be viewed incommensurate except that the disorder gives rise to higher energy damping. Consequently, the above estimation of μk obtained from hydrogenated diamond surfaces with the assumption that all mechanical energy stored into elastic is damped, is an upper limit for H:DLC coated surfaces; but it is still too low. 4.4.3
Effect of Oxidation
That the superlow friction coefficient obtained from H:DLC coated surfaces cannot be sustainable in the ambient conditions is the most serious issue [34,35]. The oxygen atom is the potential candidate which destroys the superlow friction when H:DLC coating is exposed to the air. In what follows, we clarify the effect of oxygen on the hydrogenated DLC coating leading to superlow friction. To test the effect of oxygen, we placed O atoms at the proximity of different sites of the H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surface. Upon relaxation, the system attains the minimum energy configuration, whereby O atoms break the surface bonds to form new C–O–C, or C–O–H and C–O bonds and hence they become attached to the surface. Favorably, they attacked the C–H bonds to form C–O–H radicals. Charge
68
S. Ciraci et al.
transferred to O from H and C makes O atom negatively charged as shown in Figure 4.5. This way the interaction between two atoms in different surfaces can be attractive when they carry charge of different polarity. As a result, the steady and strong repulsive interaction between the H:diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces gradually becomes weaker or turns attractive. Eventually, the superlow friction ends.
4.5 AB-INITIO STUDY OF ATOMIC-SCALE FRICTION BETWEEN CUBIC BN-SURFACES We believe that BN crystal is very hard and is expected to yield very low friction coefficient in the dry sliding [47]. In view of what we learned from hydrogenated diamond surfaces, we next investigate atomic-scale friction between two cubic BN-slabs as shown in Figure 4.6(a) using the computational approach discussed above. These two slab are placed in a supercell with lattice constant c = 24 Å. Each slab consists of 5 atomic (100) planes. Atoms of last two layers are fixed in their equilibrium bulk positions but otherwise relax all the atomic degrees of freedom using a temperature annealing minimization as a function of slab–slab distance, D and translation (along x-direction). In order to study the effect of the hydrogenation of the layers on the friction coefficient, we also consider two different hydrogen-saturated BN-surfaces as shown in Figure 4.6(b)–(c). For each system we have performed about 300 calculations, yielding almost thousand different configurations for the three systems shown in Figure 4.6.
Figure 4.6 Three different slab structures that we considered in this study. (a) BN layers, which forms N–N-dimer on the surface. (b) Single hydrogen-passivated BNH slab with bended NH-bonds. (c) Doubly passivated BNH2 slab. The distance between the fixed-B atoms on the top and bottom slabs is shown as “D”. The relevant bond-distances and atomic charges for these three structures are summarized in Table 4.1.
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
69
Table 4.1. Chemical formula, bond distances (in Å), and Mulliken atomic charges (in electrons, e) for three systems shown in Figure 4.6. The lattice parameters of the supercell are 7.23 × 7.23 × 24 (Å) for all three systems. Below Qs and Qb indicates the atomic charges for atoms at the consecutive layers, respectively System
Formula
Bond distances (Å)
Charges (e)
BN
B48 N48
dNN = 1.42, dNB = 1.56
BNH
B48 N48 H16
dNH = 1.02, dHH = 2.56, dNN = 2.56
BNH2
B48 N48 H32
dHH = 1.43, 2.61, dNH = 1.02, 1.08, dNN = 2.56
Q1 (N) −1/3, Q2 (N) = −2/3, Q3 (N) = −2/3, Q1 (B) = 1/3, Q2 (B) = 2/3, Q3 (B) = 2/3 Q(H) = 0.38 Q1 (N) = −0.78, Q2 (N) = −0.63, Q3 (N) = −0.66 Q1 (B) = 0.71, Q2 (B) = 0.64, Q3 (B) = 0.35 Q(H) = 0.25, 0.39 Q1 (N) = −0.91, Q2 (N) = −0.65, Q3 (N) = −0.65 Q1 (B) = 0.66, Q2 (B) = 0.62, Q3 (B) = 0.29
We first studied the total energy as a function of slab–slab distance as shown in Figure 4.7. For BN-layer, when the slabs are far enough, the energy is nearly zero and then goes to a minimum and then increases, with a attractive energy of 0.6 eV (Figure 4.7(a)). The N atoms on the surface are negatively charged by Q = −0.33 electrons owing to the ionic nature of BN compound. The charge on the bulk N atoms are even larger. It is noticed that when two slabs is put close enough, the N atoms on different slabs are bonded to each other, resulting sudden decrease in the energy. However this adhesive behavior requires about 1 eV energy barrier. Figure 4.7(b) shows the effect of the single hydrogenated BN-layer on the binding energy of the slabs. The energy curve is very different than that of bare BN layer shown in Figure 4.6(a). It has almost no minimum and mainly repulsive. It should be noted that GGA underestimates some of the vdW attraction. In principle, the interaction between two slabs should become slightly attractive when the Van der Waals interaction were included. This suggests that single hydrogenation of N atoms on the surface is expected to reduce the friction significantly and yield superlow friction coefficient. During the structural optimization of the BNH-layers, we also found a second metastable minima where the H-atoms are attached to B atoms and aligned perpendicular to the surface. However the system lowers its energy by about 1.4 eV/bond when the NH-bonds are bent so that BN-bond is parallel to the BN bonds as in the bulk (Figure 4.6(b)). Finally Figure 4.7(c) shows what happens if we saturate the N atom on the surface with an additional hydrogen atom. The energy curve looks like the bare BN layer but slightly larger binding energy of 0.9 eV. Hence, saturating with more hydrogen atom does not automatically mean that we would minimize the attractive part of the potential and make it repulsive. We anticipate that the large binding energy for the BNH2 case is mainly due to large atomic charges and thus the Coulomb interaction between the two slabs. Finally, while we study the different (D or z and x) slab configurations for BNH2 , we observed that when the top slab moves along x-axis by about the half of the lattice constant at small slab–slab distances, two hydrogen atoms on the different slabs actually are bonded to each other forming a H2 molecule. The energy curve of the minimization as this process occurs is shown in Figure 4.8 along with the final system configuration where we have now one free H2 molecule. Hence for BNH2 surface, we expect reconstruction on the surface
70
S. Ciraci et al.
Figure 4.7 Energy curves as the slab–slab distance D is varied for (a) BN, (b) BNH, (c) BNH2 slabs, respectively. Note that for BNH system, the potential curve is very flat and mainly repulsive. For BNH2 –BNH2 we observed H2 formation from two hydrogen atoms of two slabs for D < 9.0 Å. This reconstruction of the slab surface is shown in Figure 4.8.
as the slabs move with respect to each other. When the slab–slab distance, D, is small enough, we also observe similar reconstructions even for bare BN-slabs as we discuss it briefly below.
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
71
Figure 4.8 Energy curve during the structural minimization. When two slabs are close enough, the system lowers its energy by forming a free H2 molecule as the top slab moves along x-direction.
Figure 4.9 summarizes the energy and z-component of the total force (i.e. normal force) for the BN system for different values of slab–slab distance D as the top slab is translated along the x-axis. For most of the slab–slab distances (i.e. D = 10.6–11.0 Å), the energy first increases, reaching its maximum at half-way x-translation and then decreases back. When the top slab is translated by one-lattice vector, we recover the original structure back, indicating that we are at the elastic regime. However this is not the case for D = 10.4 Å or smaller slab-distances. Interestingly for D = 10.4 Å, the energy start to increase normally as the top-slab is being translated up to x/a = 0.5 (a is the lattice constant of the surface unit cell along x-direction) but then the energy curves does not go back to its original value; instead continue to increase. This behavior becomes clear when we inspect the optimized atomic positions as the slabs are being translated along x-axis. We find that at D = 10.4 Å, the slab–slab interaction causes the N–B bond on the surface to break, increasing it from 1.56 Å to 1.75 Å. This is shown in the inset to Figure 4.9. In fact, for slab–slab distances less than D = 10.4 Å, we also observed that the broken N-atom actually forms a new bond on the other N-atom of the other slab. Hence we expect to see adhesive behavior between two BN-slabs when they are put together close enough. We note that the optimum distance between two BN-slabs is about 10.8 Å (see Figure 4.6). Hence it is quite interesting that at D = 10.4Å (which is not too much different than 10.8 Å), there are already significant surface reconstructions. Figure 4.9(b) shows the normal forces acting on the BN slabs for different slab–slab distance. It shows an interesting variation; becomes almost flat with respect to slab translation at z = 10.7 Å. Since the Fz is almost constant at this particular z, it is very convenient to calculate the atomic-scale friction using this particular slab–slab distance. We will discuss this further later. Figure 4.10 summaries the energy and force curves for the BNH slab. The nature of BNH–BNH slab interaction is very different than BN-slabs. This is clear by comparing the
72
S. Ciraci et al.
Figure 4.9 Energy and normal forces Fz as the top slab is translated along x-direction with respect to bottom slab for different slab–slab distance D. For D = 10.4 Å, we observe significant surface reconstructions involving broken BN-bonds as depicted in inset to top panel.
curves shown in Figure 4.9 and Figure 4.10. We note that Fz force acting on the BNH layer does not become constant for any slab-distance that we studied (unlike the BN case). The energies shown in Figure 4.10(a) are much smaller indicating the weak slab–slab interactions. Below we will combine the data presented in Figure 4.10 to obtain roughly constant force loading and estimate the atomic friction force. As a last point, in Figure 4.11 we show some example plots of the forces on the slab as one of the slab is translated along x-direction for the three cases. We note that the resulting forces are oscillatory function of x-displacement for BN layer while it is very noisy for BNH2 layer. This is a nice demonstration of the effect of the surface structure on the energy and forces. In the case of BN layers, the surfaces are identical and in phase (or commensurate) with respect to each other. Therefore when one surface slides we see large variations in the energy and forces. However for the case of BNH2 system, the surface structure is quite complicated due to four H atoms and therefore two surfaces almost random (incommensurate) with respect to each other. Hence when we translate one slab, it
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
73
Figure 4.10 (a) Energy and (b) normal forces Fz as the top BNH slab is translated along x-direction with respect to bottom slab for different slab–slab distance D.
does not change the energy or the forces with respect to each other. This confirms the fact that the friction coefficient is usually low between incommensurate surfaces. Finally we obtained an estimate for the friction coefficients using the forces shown in Figure 4.11. For the normal loading force, we integrate the Fz over the cell to obtain an average force. For the x- and y-components of the lateral force, if we integrate them over the cell, we always obtain very small number from 0.01 to 0.001 eV/Å, suggesting that the most of the relaxation process during the minimization is in the elastic range. If one assumes that the induced strain or energy is efficiently removed from the system by phonons, then we can estimate an upper limit for the friction. In compliance with the discussion in Section 4.4.2, for this purpose, we calculate the average value of the lateral force Fx which is in opposite direction of the displacement. The average values are given in Figure 4.11. We note that by hydrogenating the BN layers, we reduce the friction coefficient significantly (which is given by μk = Fx /Fz = 0.06). BNH2 layer has slightly lower friction coefficient (μk = 0.03) than BN layer even though the energy dependence of the slab–slab interactions are very different. In the case of BN, it’s mainly repulsive while in the case of BNH2 it has strong attractive component. However as we discussed above, the friction is
74
S. Ciraci et al.
Figure 4.11 Forces as the top slab is translated along x-direction with respect to bottom slab. The values of the absolute-averaged forces over the unit cell are also given. For Fx and Fy , the average forces are nearly zero (less than 0.01 eV/Å). The numbers are for the integration of the absolute forces for (a) BN, (b) BNH, (c) BNH2 slabs, respectively.
very low in BNH2 because the incommensurability of the surfaces due to complex atomic structure of the surface. The above atomic-scale study of dry sliding friction between bare and hydrogenated cubic BN (001) surfaces exhibit differences from that between two diamond (001)–(2 × 1) surfaces. While the interaction between bare BN (001) surfaces weakly attractive, it be-
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
75
comes strongly repulsive upon H-saturation of each N atom. On the other hand, the dihydride formation on BN-layers by adsorbing two hydrogen atom to each N atom show strong attractive potential. However, the resulting forces and variation in the energy as the slabs are translated with respect to each other is still small. This is due to a different effect; namely the incommensurability of the surfaces with respect to each other. With two H atoms saturating N atoms, we obtain complicated surface structure and therefore as one slide moves with respect to other, nothing is really changed, resulting small forces and binding energy. Stated differently, even if |Fz | is large, lateral force components, Fx and Fy may become small due to cancellations. We also observed that under very large loading forces (with activation energy of several eV), it is possible to obtain surface reconstruction and even H2 formation by breaking the NH bonding.
4.6 CONCLUSIONS We presented a comparative study of the dry sliding friction between the atomically flat and commensurate surfaces of two different systems, namely between two diamond (001) and between two BN (001) surfaces. While the interaction between bare diamond (001)– (2 × 1) surfaces is strongly attractive until small spacing d ∼ 1.5 Å and forms strong chemical bonds between two surfaces. However, the interaction turns repulsive if two surfaces are pushed under high loading force. Upon hydrogenation, hydrogen atoms donate charge to the carbon atom and become positively charged. Then the interaction between surfaces carrying the same type charge becomes repulsive. This appears to be the most important ingredient of the superlow friction. The repulsive interaction persists at any relative position of the sliding surfaces and is strong even at large distance to prevent C–H bonds from merging. Strong and stiff C–H bonds and stiff diamond crystal by itself prevent excessive energy from dissipation. It is found that oxygenation of surfaces in the atmospheric conditions destroy the steady repulsive interaction. However the interaction between two bare reconstructed BN (001) surfaces are different from that of the diamond (001) surface due to ionic nature of the crystal. BN being an ionic crystal with electron transfer from B to N the bare surface is already negatively charged. Under these circumstances the strong chemical interaction is canceled by the repulsive Coulombic interaction resulting in a weak attractive interaction (or adhesive forces). As a result, the friction coefficient is already small in dry sliding friction two bare BN (001) surfaces. Upon saturation of each N atom by a single H-atom the weak attractive interaction is further reduced. This situation changes when single N atom is saturated by two H atoms, and the interaction becomes again attractive. The present analysis of dry sliding friction between bare and hydrogenated BN (001) surfaces indicate that this material is a potential candidate for superlow friction.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was supported by Scientific and Technological Council of Turkey, TÜB˙ITAK under Grant No. TBAG-104T537. Authors acknowledge the useful assistance of Engin Durgun in preparation of the manuscript.
76
S. Ciraci et al.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43]
Bowden, F.P., Tabor, D. Friction and Lubrication. Methuen, London, 1965. Rabinowitz, E. Friction and Wear. Wiley, New York, 1965. Persson, B.N.J. Sliding Friction: Physical Principles and Applications. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2000. Israelachvili, J.N. Intermolecular and Surface Forces. Academic Press, London, 1985. Ciraci, S., Baratoff, A., Batra, I.P. Phys. Rev. B 42 (1990), 7168; Ciraci, S., Tekman, E., Baratoff, A., Batra, I.P. Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992), 10411. Buldum, A., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 55 (1997), 12892. Buldum, A., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 55 (1997), 2606. Tomlinson, G.A. Philos. Mag. 7 (1929), 905. Frenkel, J., Kontorova, T. Phys. Z. Sowjet 13 (1938), 1. Binnig, G., Quate, C.F., Gerber, Ch. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56 (1986), 960. Mate, C.M., McClelland, G.M., Erlandsson, R., Chiang, S. Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987), 1942. Meyer, E., Overney, R., et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 69 (1992), 1777. Sutton, A.P., Pethica, J.B. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 2 (1990), 5317. Cieplak, M., Smith, E.D., Robins, M.O. Science 265 (1994), 1209. Bhushan, B., Israelachivili, J.N., Landman, U. Nature 347 (1995), 607. Sorensen, M.R., Jacobsen, K.W., Stoltze, P. Phys. Rev. B 53 (1996), 2101. Buldum, A., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 57 (1998), 2468. Buldum, A., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 60 (1999), 1982. Hohenberg, P., Kohn, W. Phys. Rev. B 136 (1964), B864; Kohn, W., Sham, L.J. Phys. Rev. 140 (1965), A1133. Zhong, W., Tomanek, D. Phys. Rev. Lett. 64 (1990), 3054; Tomanek, D., Zhong, W., Thomas, H. Europhys. Lett. 15 (1991), 887. Buldum, A., Leitner, D.M., Ciraci, S. Europhys. Lett. 47 (1999), 208. Buldum, A., Leitner, D.M., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 59 (1999), 16042. Ozpineci, A., Leitner, D.M., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 62 (2000), 10558. Ozpineci, A., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 63 (2001), 125415. Sokoloff, J.B. Phys. Lett. 71 (1993), 3450. Giessibl, F.J. Science 267 (1995), 68. Bammerlin, M., Lüthi, R., Meyer, E., Baratoff, A., Lu, J., Guggisberg, M., Gerber, Ch., Howald, L., Güntherodt, H.-J. Probe Microscopy 1 (1997), 3. Gauthier, M., Tsukada, M. Phys. Rev. B 60 (1999), 11716. Guggisberg, M., Bammerlin, M., Lüthi, R., Loppacher, Ch., Battiston, F., Lu, J., Baratoff, A., Meyer, E., Güntherodt, H.-J. Appl. Phys. A 66 (1998), S245. Kantorovich, L.N. Phys. Rev. B 64 (2001), 245409. Martin, J.M., Donnet, C., Le Mogne, Th., Epicier, Th. Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993), 10583. Sugimoto, I., Miyake, S. Appl. Phys. Lett. 56 (1990), 1868. Donnet, C., Grill, A. Surf. Coat. Technol. 94–95 (1997), 456. Erdemir, A., Eryilmaz, O.L., Fenske, G. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 18 (2000), 1987. Erdemir, A. Surf. Coat. Technol. 146–147 (2001), 292. Heimberg, J.A., Wahl, K.J., Singer, I.L., Erdemir, A. Apl. Phys. Lett. 78 (2001), 2449. Vanderbilt, D. Phys. Rev. B 41 (1990), 7892. Numerical calculations have been performed by using VASP package: Kresse, G. Hafner, J. Phys. Rev. B 47 (1993), 558; Kress, G., Furthmüller, J., ibid 54 (1996), 11169. Perdew, J.P., Chevary, J.A., Vosko, S.H., Jackso, K.A., Pederson, M.R., Singh, D.J., Fiolhais, C. Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992), 6671. Monkhorst, H.J., Pack, J.D. Phys. Rev. B 13 (1976), 5188. Dag, S., Ciraci, S. Phys. Rev. B 70 (2004), 241401. Gao, G.T., Mikulski, P.T., Harrison, J.A. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124 (2002), 7202; Gao, G.T., Mikulski, P.T., Chateauneuf, G.M., Harrison, J.A. J. Phys. Chem. B 107 (2003), 11082. Levitov, L.S. Europhys. Lett. 8 (1989), 449.
Ab-initio Atomic Scale Study of Nearly Frictionless Surfaces
77
[44] Persson, B.N.J. Phys. Rev. B 44 (1991), 3227; Persson, B.N.J., Volotkin, A.I. J. Chem. Phys. 103 (1995), 8679. [45] Dayo, A., Alnasrallah, W., Krim, J. Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998), 1690. [46] Thoms, B.D., Butler, J.E. Phys. Rev. B 50 (2000), 17450. [47] Miyoshi, K., Buckly, D.H., Spalvins, T. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 3 (1985), 2340.
This page intentionally left blank
–5– Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology J. David Schall1 , Paul T. Mikulski2 , Ginger M. Chateauneuf1 , Guangtu Gao1 and Judith A. Harrison1 1 Chemistry Department, US Naval Academy, 572 Holloway Road, Annapolis,
MD 21402, USA 2 Physics Department, US Naval Academy, 572 Holloway Road, Annapolis,
MD 21402, USA
5.1 INTRODUCTION During the past two decades, there has been much research devoted to the study of atomicscale friction. Steady advances have been made experimentally through the use of devices such as the atomic force microscope (AFM), whereby a nano-scale tip (essentially a single asperity) mounted to a cantilever is dragged across a prepared sample. With knowledge of cantilever and tip properties, inferences can be made about friction and load from the deflections of the cantilever. Related technologies, such as the friction force microscope and surface-force apparatus, are also used to probe experimentally the tribology of many liquid and solid systems with nanometer, and sometimes atomic, resolution. Complementing experimental work, computational studies of atomic-scale tribological processes using molecular dynamics (MD) have provided much insight due to the direct information they can yield about individual atomic interactions. Even with the rapid growth of computational power, dealing effectively with time-scales and system sizes is still challenging. Model systems typically include thousands of atoms and system sizes in the range of tens of thousands of atoms confine typical dimensions of the simulated tip and sample to no more than tens of nanometers in any direction. Given that AFM tips used for investigating tribology can have radii of curvature of over one hundred nanometers, it is common to employ periodic boundary conditions in the plane of the sliding interface in MD simulations. Furthermore, with first principle or quantum mechanical ab initio calculations being limited to system sizes of hundreds of atoms, atomistic tribology simulations traditionally have been approached through the use of empirical classical models of atomic interactions. Such models are built by fitting functional forms for interatomic interactions to experimental data and the results of ab initio calculations. The functional forms may Superlubricity Edited by A. Erdemir and J.-M. Martin © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
80
J.D. Schall et al.
range from simple mathematical approximations of atomic interactions to more complex models based on sound quantum–mechanic bonding principles. With regard to time-scales, adopted sliding speeds for simulations are usually much higher than what is utilized experimentally. Simulated times typically are of the order of a nanosecond at most for simulation with time-steps in the range of a fraction of a femtosecond. Fortunately, and perhaps somewhat surprisingly, simulation results have been shown to be insensitive to sliding speeds ranging over orders of magnitude for systems under significant loading [1]. Despite these challenges, MD provides a way of probing fundamental processes that is unsurpassed in terms of its level of detail and directness. Consequently, MD has proven to be an invaluable aid in the interpretation of atomic-scale experimental studies that are beset with their own distinct challenges. The following serves as a review of the use of MD in the study of tribology. Section 5.2 reviews the MD technique with some emphasis on issues that are of particular importance to using MD in the study of tribology. Section 5.3 reviews some of the reactive potentials that have been used heavily in the study of atomic-scale friction along with some historical perspective of their development and use. Finally, Section 5.4 concludes with some of the recent work by Harrison and coworkers on the tribology of amorphous carbon films and self assembled monolayers (SAMs).
5.2 MD SIMULATION METHODS 5.2.1
Outline of Method
In molecular dynamics simulations, atoms are treated as discrete particles whose trajectories are followed by numerically integrating classical equations of motion. After the geometry and boundary conditions of the system are specified and the initial position and velocity of each atom are given, numerical integration is carried out. Typical timesteps range between 0.1 to about 15 femtoseconds depending on the largest vibrational frequency of the model system. Instantaneous values of quantities such as energy, force, velocity, strain, and stress can be calculated at regular intervals and saved for post-simulation analysis. Two numerical integration schemes that are widely used in MD are the Gear predictor-corrector method [2] and the Verlet methods [3,4]. Doing work on a system through the application of external forces, as is done during sliding or indentation, can result in a rise in internal energy and temperature of the system. Therefore, methods of dissipating excess energy and maintaining a constant temperature must be employed in computer simulations. In the following, we briefly discuss three popular temperature regulation approaches. For details, the reader is referred to Allen and Tildesley [4]. A sophisticated approach to maintaining a given temperature is through Langevin dynamics, which was originally used in describing Brownian motion [5,6]. In this approach, additional terms corresponding to a friction force and a random force are added to the dynamic equation of motion of each atom, mv˙ = F − mξ v + R(t),
Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology
81
where F is the force due to the interatomic potential, m is the atom’s mass, v is its velocity, ξ is a friction coefficient, and R(t) represents a random “white noise” force. For heat flux via nuclear (as opposed to electronic) degrees of freedom in solids, it has been shown that a reasonable approximation for the friction coefficient ξ is 6β/π , where β is the Debye frequency of the solid. The random force is sampled from a Gaussian distribution where the width, which is chosen to satisfy the fluctuation–dissipation theorem, is determined from the equation
R(0) · R(t) = 2mkT ξ δ(t),
where k is Boltzman’s constant, T is the temperature, and δ(t) is the Dirac delta function. The width of this distribution depends on the temperature and the friction coefficient. The temperature regulation approach developed by Berendsen et al. [7] employs a variable friction coefficient that depends on the ratio of desired temperature to the instantaneous temperature calculated from the current kinetic energy of the system. The resulting equation of motion is mv˙ = F + mξ
T0 − 1 v, T
where T0 is the desired temperature and T is the current temperature of the system. The advantages of this approach are its simplicity and efficiency; however, if the system is not pre-equilibrated to properly populate the vibrational modes, or if nonrandom external forces are applied to the system, it can be slow to properly equilibrate the system. A thermostat that rigorously corresponds to a canonical ensemble has been developed by Nosé [8]. In this approach, an extra degree of freedom, representing the heat bath, is included in the dynamic equations of motion. This extra degree of freedom, denoted by s, relates the velocity and the time derivative of position by v = s r˙ . The dynamic equations of the system then become, m¨r = s¨ =
2m˙s r˙ F , − s s2
s s˙ + nf kB (T − T0 ), s Qs
where nf is number of degree of freedom of the system, kB is Boltzmann’s constant, and Qs is the thermal inertia parameter, which can be adjusted to control the rate of temperature fluctuation. Too large a value for Qs results in slow energy flow between the system and reservoir. If Qs is too low, long-lived, weakly damped oscillations of the energy occur, resulting in poor equilibration. Nosé discusses the choice of Qs in more detail [8]. Though the total energy is not conserved because the system exchanges energy with the thermostat,
82
J.D. Schall et al.
the Hamiltonian of the bath plus the system can be derived and is conserved, providing an indicator for checking the program code. Pressure of the system can also be regulated allowing MD simulations to be used to study systems in a constant pressure environment. Andersen [9] originally developed a method for constant pressure MD simulation by making the volume V of the system a dynamical variable. Scaled particle coordinates rs and the coordinates divided by V 1/3 are used in the dynamic equations of motion, m¨rs =
F 2mV˙ r˙s , − 1/3 3V V
(P − P0 ) V¨ = , QV where P0 is the external pressure applied to the system, P is the internal pressure calculated through the Virial theorem. The dynamics of this system mimic the action of a piston on a real system. The constant Qv represents the piston’s mass and is empirically chosen to control the rate of volume fluctuation of the system. Anderson recommends that the time scale for box-volume fluctuations should be approximately the same as that for a sound wave to cross the simulation box. It has been shown that Andersen’s theory generates the isoenthalpic–isobaric ensemble of classical statistical mechanics [10–12]. Whereas Anderson’s method changes only the system size, Parrinello and Rahman [13] generalized Andersen’s method to also allow for changes in the shape of the simulation box. A changing shape allows for a constant external stress condition; the resulting system corresponds to an isoenthalpic–isostress ensemble of classical statistical mechanics. In Parrinello–Rahman theory, the simulation box is generalized to be a parallelepiped. If the simulation box is constructed from three vectors a, b, and c, a matrix formed by the three vectors can be defined as h = [a, b, c]; h is a dynamical variable describing the size and shape changes of the simulation box. This h matrix is also the transformation matrix between the scaled coordinates rs and the real non-scaled coordinates r, as r = hrs . The strain tensor with respect to a reference state h0 is ε=
1 −1 T −1 h0 Gh0 − δij , 2
where G = hT h, and T represents the matrix transpose. Generally, the reference state h0 is chosen to be the equilibrium average value of h in a system under zero tension. Dynamic equations for rs and h are given as ˙ rs , m¨rs = h−1 F − mG−1 G˙ (P − P0 ) −1 T h¨ = V h − hΓ, Qh
where V = |h| = a · b × c, is the volume of the system, P0 is the hydrostatic pressure, and Qh is an empirically chosen constant used to control the fluctuation rate of the h matrix.
Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology
83
Like the Qv constant in Anderson’s pressure control method, Qh may be thought as a box ‘mass’. The external stress S is related to Γ via the following expression,
5.2.2
−1 T Γ = h−1 V0 . 0 (S − P0 ) h0
Simulation of Tribology
Shown in Figure 5.1 is a schematic diagram of a typical setup for a tribology simulation. Here a surface and opposing counterface are brought into contact by setting the displacement between the two regions to some constant value, through some sort of force-feedback that controls the applied normal force FN by varying the displacement, or by applying a constant pressure to generate a constant normal force. The bottom layer of the surface is held rigid to insure contact is maintained. Typically the surface structure varies according to some variable to be analyzed. This variable could be anything from chemical composition to microstructure to surface roughness. The counterface is typically, but not necessarily always, some well defined, well characterized microstructure. This allows for direct comparison of results between different sets of simulations. Alternatively the surface and counterface could be self-mated; that is, the surface and counterface are both the same. In both the surface and counterface, a region is thermostated using one of the thermostats described above. Not only is the choice of the thermostat important, but its location relative to the sliding interface also plays a critical role. If the thermostated region is too close to the interfacial region, it may interfere with the dynamics of the system and unduly influence the results of the simulation. If the thermostated region is too far away from the interface, it may not be effective in dissipating the thermal energy generated by the interface, which may lead to unrealistic effects, such as localized melting. The choice of the damping parameters or friction coefficients that determine the magnitude of the random forces applied to the atoms is also of some importance. The wrong choice of these parameters may either cause large random forces, which obscure sensitive fluctuations in the contact forces between atoms in the simulation, or the thermostat will not provide enough control over temperature. To further complicate matters, Robbins and Müser [14] have also shown that to some (possibly small) extent even the number of degrees of freedom (i.e. directionality) of the thermostat plays a role in the tribological response of the system. The type of
Figure 5.1
Schematic diagram of typical molecular dynamics simulation tribology experiment.
84
J.D. Schall et al.
material to be modeled may also play a role in the choice of thermostat. The thermostats described in Section 5.2.1 are only effective for controlling heat flux via nuclear phonon– phonon interactions. Such thermostats are effective for modeling many covalent materials such as silicon and diamond; however, in metals where the primary transfer of heat occurs through electron–electron interactions, properties such as thermal conductivity and diffusivity are grossly underestimated. Schall and Brenner [15] have proposed an ad hoc continuum-based thermostat that uses experimentally obtained values for thermal diffusivity to help address these and other issues. Padgett and coworkers [16] have successfully applied this thermostat to study the sliding of metal asperities subjected to resistive Joule heating. For a more detailed discussion of thermostats the reader is referred to a recent review article by Robbins and Müser [14]. After the surface and counterface are brought into contact, a rigid displacement of the top layer of the counterface is applied to initiate sliding. This can be accomplished in several ways. Most often the velocity of the upper layer is set to some constant value and this velocity is maintained throughout the duration of the simulation. Occasionally, a constant force is applied to the upper layer for some prescribed amount of time. This force is then removed and the dynamics of the system are monitored as the counterface slows down and energy is dissipated. It is important to remember that in atomic-level simulations, all the information for each atom in a simulation, from exact coordinates in space, to individual components of force, velocity, acceleration, etc., is available at every time step. This, of course, amounts to an enormous amount of information. The trick is to use insights and intuition to pare down this information into usable, useful data. In any case, several key things may be monitored as the simulation progresses. These may include: • Friction and normal forces (referred to in Figure 5.1 as FF and FN , respectively) between the surface and counterface or on individual atoms. • Displacement between surface and counterface (in constant-normal force simulations). • Structural changes in the free regions such as change in hybridization, dislocation nucleation, stacking fault formation, etc. • Chemical bond forming and breaking between atoms of the surface and counterface. Chemical bond forming and breaking is typically only found in a certain class of interatomic potentials known as reactive potentials. Such potentials will be discussed in detail in the following section.
5.3 5.3.1
REACTIVE POTENTIALS
Covalent Potentials
Atomistic simulation of a large number of atoms using molecular dynamics is a powerful tool for understanding the fundamental mechanisms of friction and tribology. The underpinning of such calculations is the assumed atomic interaction potential. The most desirable circumstance would be to take the atomic interactions directly from first-principles calculations; however, such calculations are orders of magnitude too slow for the shear number
Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology
85
of energy evaluations required to study a system of reasonable size and practical interest. To obtain useful information in a reasonable amount of time, researchers have developed empirical and semiempirical approximations to the atomic potentials. There are two sides to creating an effective analytic potential. The first is the development of a relatively simple functional form that captures the essential essence of the underlying quantum mechanical bonding. The second is making the potential practical by including additional empirically derived functions and parameters. An effective analytic potential energy function should have the following features; flexibility, accuracy, transferability, and computational efficiency. The potential should be flexible enough to accommodate a wide range of fitting parameters. Data might include cohesive energy, elastic constants, lattice constants, and surface energies. The potential form should then accurately reproduce the fitting database. Ideally, the potential should also have some degree of transferability, having the ability to describe structures not included in the fitting database, at least in a qualitative sense. Finally, the resulting function should be relatively efficient computationally. The process of developing a potential, sometimes referred to as an art as well as a science, requires a combination of chemical insight, trial and error, and tenacity on the part of its developer [17]. Covalent materials such as silicon and carbon form strong, directional bonds. This poses a challenge for potential development for this important class of materials. Many standard potential functions such as the Lennard-Jones potential or embedded atom method do not include any bond directionality. The Stillinger and Weber potential for solid and liquid phases of silicon was one of the first attempts to use a classic potential to overcome this challenge [18]. Stillinger and Weber based their potential model on a many-body approach. In this many-body approach, the total energy is given as a linear superposition of terms representing different types of interatomic interactions: stretching, bending, rotation, torsion, etc. For the Stillinger–Weber potential, the total energy includes only two of these terms, a pair and triplet term based on the geometric factors of bond length and bond angle, respectively. The total potential energy is given by Etot =
1 1 2 . φij (Rij ) + g(Rij )g(Rik ) cos θj ik + 2 3 ij (i =j )
ij k
Here φij is a pair-term (bond stretching) representing electrostatic interactions between atoms i and j . The second summation, a three-body term, represents bond bending between atoms i, j , and k. The term g(R) is a decaying function with a cutoff between the first- and the second-neighbor shell, and θj ik is the bond angle described by two neighbors j and k of atom i. The inclusion of the triplet term allows the potential to achieve an acceptable description of short-range order and of atom-exchanging diffusive motion in the liquid phase. While this potential is reasonably accurate when used for modeling solid silicon in the diamond cubic phase, the potential is very biased towards the ideal tetrahedral bond angle through the explicit inclusion of a factor of (cos θj ik + 1/3) in the three-body term. The inclusion of this trigonometric factor discriminates in favor of pairs of bonds with the tetrahedral geometry, i.e. cos θj ik = −1/3, and limits the transferability of the potential. For instance, it cannot accurately predict the correct energies for various non-tetrahedrally
86
J.D. Schall et al.
bonded high-pressure phases of silicon, it does not correctly predict surface structures, and coordination in the liquid phase is too low. The family of potentials derived from the many-body approach described above for the Stillinger–Weber potential is often used in simulation of organic systems. These, so-called, force-field models are able to model structural and dynamical properties of very large molecules with a high degree of accuracy. However, it is important to note that, in general, force-field methods do not allow for bond-forming or breaking to occur during simulation. Connectivity must be determined a priori. Force-field models are common in the study of tribological systems. In one example, Landman and coworkers [19,20] have applied such models to the study of the structures, solvation forces, and shear of a molecular fluid confined between both smooth and rough interfaces. Thompson and Robbins [21], Sokol et al. [22], Bitsanis [23], and others [24,25] have demonstrated confined fluids form well defined ordered layers normal to the surface and that these layers may actually lock in place. In Landman and Gao’s model, a surface and opposing counterface were represented by an embedded atom method representation of gold (the embedded atom method is discussed briefly below). The molecular fluid was represented by a united-atom force-field representation of the alkane hexadecane (each CH2 group represented by a pseudo-atom) and the interactions between the alkane molecules and the gold atoms of the substrates were represented by a simple Lennard-Jones potential. Their simulations show that there is a remarkable sensitivity to the confining surface morphology. There is a significant reduction in the ordering of films confined between rough surfaces and a strong suppression of solvation forces and the development of liquid-like dynamic and response characteristics. When the rough-surface boundaries are put into motion, the molecular interfacial layer tends to stick to the substrate resulting in a shear stress inside the fluid layer, in contrast to the atomically flat crystalline boundaries where there is vanishingly small shear stress. This result suggests that morphological patterning of surfaces could provide ways for controlled modifications of frictional processes in thin-film lubricated nanotribological systems. For a more complete review of modeling confined lubricants see [26]. In another example, Irving and Brenner [27] have conducted a series of simulations of the diffusion of the mobile lubricant tricresylphosphate (TCP) on a bound self-assembled monolayer (SAM) comprised of octadecyltrichlorosilane (ODTS) using AMBER forcefields [28]. Such bound + mobile systems are of significant importance for protecting interfaces in silicon microelectromechanical systems. The chemically bound SAM protects the device during the early stages of the device lifetime while the mobile lubricant is present to replenish the lubricant coating as the SAM fails. In their study, Irving and Brenner created a SAM substrate by affixing head groups of the ODTS molecules to a hexagonal lattice. All hydrogen atoms were treated explicitly (in contrast to the unified-atom method employed by Landman and coworkers above). The TCP was found to diffuse sufficiently fast to recover damaged areas in most, if not all experimental time cycles. They found that the dynamics of the TCP change as the TCP transitions from the SAM surface to defected areas, at which point the TCP becomes localized and tries to embed into the SAM. From a practical stand point, they argue three advantages to the TCP + SAM combination; rapid diffusion on the SAM is good because TCP molecules can quickly get to defects, local-
Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology
87
ization on the sides of the defects leads to preferential filling of the defects, and favorable TCP–TCP interactions can lead to the filling of larger defects. In 1987 Baskes proposed a modification to the already popular embedded atom method (EAM) [29,30]. In the original method, the energy of a cluster of atoms is given as
Etot =
1 F (ρh,i ), φij (Rij ) + 2 i,j (i =j )
i
where ρh,i is the spherically averaged electron density of atom i embedded in the host h electron density, Fi is the energy required to embed the atom into this density, and φij is a pair-potential term representing electrostatic interactions between atoms i and j separated by a distance Rij . Typically, the EAM method has been used to model metals, principally those with the face-centered cubic structure. Variants of the embedded atom method have been used successfully to study tribological properties of metal interfaces. Perhaps one of the most important insights gained from this type of interatomic potential has been the explanation of the jump-to-contact phenomenon observed in atomic-force and scanning-tunneling microscopy experiments. The jump-tocontact phenomenon was first reported in 1988 by Pethica and Sutton [31]. They observed that for a sufficiently small separation of a tip and a flat, ∼1–2 Å, the tip and substrate will jump together. In 1990, Landman et al. [32,33], using a series of molecular dynamics simulations of a nickel tip and gold substrate modeled using embedded atom potentials, showed that the experimentally observed hysteresis in the force versus tip-to-sample distance relationship was due to an inelastic deformation of the surface characterized by adhesion of the substrate atoms to the tip. At small sample-tip separations, this mechanical instability causes the jump-to-contact, which leads to adhesion-induced wetting of the tip by surface atoms. Baskes was somewhat surprised to find that the simple EAM model was also sufficient to describe covalent bonding in diamond-cubic materials [34]. With only bulk experimental properties for diamond-cubic silicon used for as fitting parameters, the EAM model gives semiquantitative agreement with structural energies and bond lengths of silicon calculated from local-density approximation calculations. However, there are two major problems. Both problems are related to the elastic shear constants. First, for the diamond-cubic structure, the spherically averaged EAM model gives C11 = C12 . This condition is strongly violated for silicon in the diamond-cubic structure. Second, the experimental Cauchy discrepancy C12 − C44 for diamond-cubic silicon is negative. In the EAM, the Cauchy discrepancy is proportional to the second derivative of the embedding function Fi , which is always positive. The problem lies in the directionality of the silicon bonding. Because the electron density is formulated as a spherical average, all directionality is lost. Recognizing this Baskes offered a modification to the EAM that includes more neighbors and an angular-dependent modification to the density term [35,36]. The inclusion of more neighbors allows the experimental values of C11 and C12 to be fit exactly. A modification to and
88
J.D. Schall et al.
the electron density is required to fit the C44 elastic constant, which corrects the Cauchy discrepancy. The modified density is given as ρh,i =
j =i
ρja (Rij ) +
aj1 ak1 cos θj ik − aj2 ak2 1 − 3 cos2 θj ik ρja (Rij )ρka (Rik ). j =i k =i
The first term is the usual linear superposition of atomic densities, whereas the double summation in the second term is an angular modification. A scaling factor of ρja (Rij )ρka (Rik ) is applied to the angular term such that it decreases in magnitude as either the bond lengths of the three atoms ij or ik increases. The 1 − 3 cos2 θj ik term is similar to the angular function found in the Stillinger–Weber potential in that it biases the potential towards the tetrahedral bond angle. However, the ai1 and ai2 constants give the potential far greater transferability by weighting the bias. Fitting C44 is accomplished by adjusting the constants ai1 and ai2 . The modified EAM could be used to simulate friction and wear properties in covalent materials and, in principle; it is possible to model chemical reactions at the interface using this potential with a proper parameterization. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, no such simulations have been conducted to date. This is in part due to the development of empirical reactive bond-order potentials based on the Abell–Tersoff formalism. 5.3.2
Development and Fitting of Bond-Order Potential
In 1985, Abell presented a very general description of bonding based on the observation of a universal relationship between binding energy and bond length [37]. This relationship placed the bonding in crystalline solids and molecules on the same footing. The only criterion for bonding preference is the optimization of the binding energy with respect to the local coordination. The local coordination is, in turn, the dominant topological variable in the determination of binding energy. Soon after Abell’s work was published, Tersoff developed a potential constructed to guarantee that this universal behavior was obtained [38–42]. The Tersoff potential was the first to attempt to incorporate the structural chemistry of covalently bonded systems. The general form of the potential is given as follows E=
i
Ei =
1 Vij , 2 i =j
Vij = fc VR (Rij ) − Bij VA (Rij ) ,
where E is the total energy of the system, Ei is the site energy for site i, Vij is the interaction energy between atoms i and j , and Rij is the distance between these atoms. The sum is over the j nearest neighbors of i: VR (R) and VA (R) are pair-additive repulsive and attractive interactions, respectively, and fc is a cut-off function to limit the range of the potential. For the Tersoff potential, the repulsive and attractive terms are represented by the Morse-type functions VR = A exp(−λ1 Rij ),
Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Tribology
89
VA = B exp(−λ2 Rij ), where A, B, λ1 , and λ2 are all positive constants with λ1 > λ2 . All deviations from the simple pair potential are ascribed to the dependence of the bond-order Bij on the local bonding environment or coordination. More specifically, the bonding strength for a bonded pair should be a monotonically decreasing function of the number of competing bonds, the strength of the competing bonds, and the cosines of the angles of the competing bonds. The crucial feature of the Tersoff potential is that it does not assume different forms for the angular functions for different hybridizations. In his work, Bij is given the following form −1/2n , Bij = 1 + β n ξijn ξij =
k =i,j
fc (rik )g(θj ik ) exp λ33 (rij − rik )3 ,
g(θ ) = 1 + c2 /d 2 − c2 / d 2 + (h − cos θ )2 ,
where θj ik is the bond angle between bonds i–j and i–k. The angular function g(θ ) is determined globally by a fit to structures with different coordination. This gives the function a high degree of transferability. Tersoff extended his original silicon potential to include germanium, carbon, and combinations thereof. In 1990, Brenner reported an empirical bond-order expression that described hydrocarbon molecules and solid-state carbon on equal terms [43]. Based on work by Tersoff and others, the form of this expression allows for bonds to form and break with changes in hybridization. This so-called reactive empirical bond-order potential (REBO) was originally developed to model chemical vapor deposition of diamond films, and the potention is widely used in simulating many other processes. The first-generation Brenner potential is very similar to the Tersoff potential. Pair repulsive and attractive terms are again represented by Morse-type potentials. The primary difference is in how the bond-order is handled for hydrocarbon molecules. The expression for the total bond-order is given as B¯ ij = where
Bij + Bj i conj + Fij Nit , Njt , Nij , 2
−δ E E Bij = 1 + Gi (θj ik )fc (rik )eα[(rij −Rij )−(rik −Rik )] + Hij NiH , NiC .
The quantities NiC and NjH are the number of carbon and hydrogen atoms bonded to atom i. conj
The total number of neighbors, Ni t of atom i is (NiC + NjH ), Nij depends on whether a bond between carbon atoms i and j is part of a conjugated system, G(θ ) is a function of the angle between bonds i–j and i–k and has the same form as the Tersoff potential. The two and three dimensional cubic-splines, Hij and Fij , have discrete nodal values that
90
J.D. Schall et al.
are fit to various hydrocarbon molecules. The resulting potential successfully describes the different bonding characteristics of hydrogen and carbon radicals and nonconjugated double and triple bonds (hydrogen is monovalent while carbon has valency up to four). Brenner’s original REBO has proven to be very popular. Its form was adopted by Murty and Atwater [44] to model Si–H systems and was then extended independently by Beardmore and R. Smith [45] and by Dyson and P.V. Smith [46–48] to include C–Si–H interactions. Parameterizations also exist for Si–F, Si–Cl [49], and C–Pt [50]. At the time that this publication was prepared, the original Brenner potential had over 1000 citation in literature. However, even at the time it was published, Brenner recognized it had four basic limitations: (1) The Morse-type form of the pair potential was not flexible enough to allow a parameter set that could fit both structural energies and force constants simultaneously. In his original work, Brenner provided two parameter sets, one that provided an excellent fit to bond energies and another