IN HIS HOLY NAME
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Kian Pishkar Pyeaam Abbasi University of Isfahan Winter 2014
...
138 downloads
3478 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
IN HIS HOLY NAME
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Kian Pishkar Pyeaam Abbasi University of Isfahan Winter 2014
پیشکار ،کیان- 8431 ،
سرشناسه
Pishkar, Kian / Kian Pishkar, Pyeaam A student's guide to some major plays
عنوان و نام پدیدآور مشخصات نشر
Abbasi. اصفهان :انتشارات نگارخانه۱۱84 =84۳۱ ،م.
مشخصات ظاهری
3۴۴ص.
وضعیت فهرست نویسی
978-600-7148-25-9 فیپا
یادداشت
انگلیسی.
یادداشت
کتابنامه.
شابک
موضوع
زبان انگلیسی --کتابهای قرائت --نمایشنامه
شناسه افزوده
عباسی ،پیام- 84۴۱ ،
رده بندی کنگره
Abbasi, Payam ۳ 84۳۱ 88۱۱پ1نPE /
شناسه افزوده رده بندی دیویی
۱3۱۱3۱۳۱/3۱1
شماره کتابشناسی ملی
44۱۴۱83
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays مؤلف
کیان پیشکار ،دکتر پیام عباسی
انتشارات
نگارخانه
ناظر فنی
علیرضا جنّّّّت
صفحه آرا
مرضیه ضیایی
طرح جلد
فاطمه نوروزی
چاپخانه
نگار اصفهان
نوبت چاپ
اول2931 -
تیراژ
2111نسخه
قطع اثر
وزیری
قیمت
..........ریال
شابک
387-611-8217-12-6
این اثر مشمول قانون حمایت مؤلفان و مصنفان و هنرمندان مصوب 8431است. هرکس تمام و یا قسمتی از این اثر را بدون اجازه مؤلف(ناشر)نشر ،پخش یا عرضه کند مورد پیگردقانونی خواهد گرفت
.
Cellphon: 09131703597
E- mail: pubnegar@yahoo com
Table of Contents AUTHORS 1. Sophocles 2. Sophocles 3. Shakespeare 4. Sheridan 5. Chekhov 6. Moliere 7. Ibsen 8. Ibsen 9. Ibsen 10. Ibsen 11. Shaw 12. Shaw 13. Shaw 14. Williams 15. Williams 16. Miller 17. Albee
PLAYS
Page
Oedipus Rex Antigone Othello, The Moore of Venice School for Scandal The Cherry Orchard
7 13 25 33 39
The Misanthrope An Enemy of People The Wild Duck Hedda Gabler A Doll’s House Candida Major Barbara Arms and The Men A Streetcar Named Desire The Glass Menagerie Death of a Salesman The Sandbox
69 75 87 95 105 109 127 151 159 173 189 203
18. Albee Who is Afraid of Virginia Woolf ? 19. Osborne Look Back in Anger 20. Becket Waiting for Go dot 21. Lorca Blood Wedding 22. Strindberg The Stronger 23. Bibliography
209 215 239 249 259 265
Preface Drama is not simply literature but a composite art-form; a mixture of literature and visual art, speech and movement, story and spectacle.
As a student’s guide to the critical analysis of drama, the present book is a collection of critical essays on some major plays by some major playwrights like William Shakespeare, George Bernard Shaw, Henrik Ibsen and Tennessee Williams. The essays provide students of English literature and those who are interested in reading about drama, with good critical pieces of information that will, hopefully, help them with the analytical look needed for further drama reading and analysis. The book, also, helps the readers to see that an analytical approach to a play is not an end but a means to deepen understanding and appreciation of text, and intensify reading experience. The authors of this book have tried to be cautious in writing, selecting, rewriting, and producing content so that students who wish to know more of the meaning and purpose of drama may not regret the time they give the book. Although excellent sources have been consulted, the book has, definitely, certain shortcomings that will not be improved unless our dear professors and students of the field, kindly, share their valuable suggestions and comments. May God accept this as a service to our students of English literature. Kian Pishkar Pyeaam Abbasi University of Isfahan, 2014
OEDIPUS REX By Sophocles For the beginning readers of literature, this play is of course made more difficult by the conventions of classical tragedy—the use of choruses, the nonrealistic set speeches, the “static” stage action, the (translated) poetry, the reporting off-stage action by messengers. But this particular example of Greek tragedy is made even more difficult by the apparent importance to the story of incidents that precede the play. Almost without exception, readers that precede the play. Almost without exception, readers asked to recount the plot will begin not at the beginning of the play, but at the beginning of Oedipus’s career or even at the point of the first oracle to Laios predicting a parricidal, incestuous son. The distinction between the action on stage and antecedent events must be made very clear if the nature of this play is to be properly understood. A city wracked by plague turns to its king for relief, trusting that his almost superhuman wisdom will save them. Oedipus, however, has already begun the task, for he is awaiting the return of Creon from the oracle; the message is that the murderer of the former king, living unpunished in the city, is the cause of the plague. Oedipus lays a curse on the murderer (“that the man’s life be consumed in evil and wretchedness,”) and begins his search for the identity of the guilty person. At Creon's suggestion he consults the blind Tiresias and forces him to divulge what he is reluctant to reveal “in hideous shame with
8
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
those / Most dear”. Enraged at what seems an incredible lie, Oedipus accuses Tiresias of plotting with Creon so that the latter may gain the crown. Tiresias leaves, pronouncing further that Oedipus is “to her / Who bore him, son and husband”. Creon's denial of a plot against Oedipus is logical and prudent: since he already has the rights and powers of the kingship, why would he want to add the anxieties and responsibilities of the crown? When Queen Jocasta tries to patch up the quarrel between her husband and her brother, Oedipus reports to her Tiresias’s accusation of murder, and to dispel his anger she skeptically offers him proof that soothsayers and oracles are not trustworthy: she and Laios had been told that their son would kill his father and marry his mother—yet as everyone knows, Laios was murdered by a band of murderers at a place where three highways meet. Oedipus uneasily recalls that he had received a similar prophecy, and fleeting from the home of his supposed parents to avoid such guilty acts, he had killed a man at just such a place. He begins to realize that he may indeed have been Laios’s murderer –which his own curse may alight on himself. But he takes hope from the report that the king had been killed not single-handedly but by a group. He sends for a shepherd, the lone survivor of Laios’s party, to hear the true circumstances of the murder. A messenger from Corinth arrives to announce that Oedipus’s presumed father Polybus has died of age and illness, thus apparently disproving the oracle’s prophecy that Oedipus would kill him, but Oedipus is unwilling to return as king of Corinth because his mother Merope still lives. When he tells the messenger of the prophecy that had driven him from
Oedipus Rex
9
home, the messenger offers him the good news: he need not fear, for he was not in fact the son of Polybus and Merope. Tending his flock near Mount Kitharion, this very messenger had received from a Theban shepherd an infant who had been exposed to die on the mountain, and had taken him to Polybus, who raised him as his son. Jocasta tries to dissuade Oedipus from further questioning, having deduced from this news the whole horrid truth; she is the mother of her husband, who had killed his father. The shepherd appears who had been with Laios at his death, and is recognized by the Corinthian as the man who had given him the infant. He reveals that the baby was said to be son of Laios, and was sent to be exposed on the mountain for fear of the prophecies. Now Oedipus possesses the whole truth, and rushes into the palace, from which another messenger emerges to report that the queen has hanged herself, and that Oedipus has stabbed himself in the eyes with her brooches to blind him to all the horror and misery he had unknowingly created. Being led forth from the palace, he acknowledges that although Apollo brought his “sick, sick fate” upon him, “the building hand was my own!” He summarizes his life in a powerful lament, asks Creon to care for his children, bids his daughters farewell, and begs for the fulfillment of the curse he had pronounced on Laios’s murder; banishment from Thebes. This rehearsal of the actions of the play demonstrates several important dramatic points: the only casual effect of the oracle in the action is Oedipus’s vow to discover and punish the murderer; the whole movement of the plot is toward knowledge, first the discovery of the identity of the murderer, and then the
10
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
discovery of Oedipus’s true parentage. Confusing discussions of the casual role of the gods and oracles are not necessary, even though they are tempting: we are presented with what Oedipus is, not with what he was; we share with him his quest for the truth of his past, put it is important of the throne nor the early years of his marriage. All those come forth as he searches for the truth of his past, but it is important to accept what the king is at the beginning of the play (“not one of the immortal gods, … [but] the man surest in mortal ways / And wisest in the ways of God.”) In the justified pride of his position, he goes on when others beg him to top. The search for enlightenment is rewarded with knowledge of the most horrid kind, too horrid for a mere mortal to look upon, and yet he presses for the execution of the sentence he has pronounced upon himself. Recognizing the boundaries of the action within the time of the play also clarifies the question of Oedipus’s tragic flaw. It is not the rashness of having killed a group of men who attacked him on the highway, nor is it arrogance of supposing he could avoid the prophecy by fleeing from Corinth. The pride he displays within the action is justified: as a wise king, he must take the responsibility of ridding the city of its pollution; in undertaking the search for the murderer, he is following the instructions of the oracle. His rage at Tiresias and his suspicion of Creon's plot are motivated by his certainty that he did not kill the king, and an intelligent inference based on the fact that Creon had recommended consulting the soothsayer. His flaw—the traditional terms is an unfortunate one—is his insistence on learning the truth, extending his knowledge to discover himself fully. The
Oedipus Rex
11
sight / blindness, light / dark ironies that abound in the play point in this direction, toward enlightenment too great for a man to bear. The chorus has several important functions in this drama: it comments, in a slightly obtuse, conservatively pious way on the actions it has witnessed, acting in part as a surrogate for the audience; and its songs (and dances) reinforce the moods created by the actions. By interrupting the action, it also makes the passage of time between events more dramatically credible. The links between the coral songs and the preceding actions are not always immediately clear. The Parodos is a payer for divine intervention in the plague, springing directly from the news that the oracle is being consulted. Ode 1 comments on the oracle’s warning that Laios’s murderer is still in the city, but rejects as impossible Tiresias’s pronouncements against Oedipus—the chorus is thus torn between belief and disbelief in the messages from the gods. Ode 2 is a shocked response to Jocasta’s protective and impious skepticism about oracles. Ode 3, after the revelation that Oedipus had been rescued from exposure on the mountain, ignores Jocasta’s newfound awareness that her husband will discover himself to be the most miserable of men, and instead is a hymn to Kithairon and the gods who attended Oedipus’s rescue, as if the chorus cannot bring itself to face the situation being revealed. Ode 4, after the full revelation of Oedipus’s past, grieves for the fall of so great a man, “Majestic Oedipus! … now of all men ever known / Most pitiful is this man’s story.” In the Exodus, the chorus joins with Oedipus in a “commons,” a responsive song or chant, as an introduction to the lament in
12
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
which he looks back on his life; and it concludes the play with a moral which is not exactly the central theme of the action but is appropriate to the insight of the chorus. Are the gods just to Oedipus? Has he deserved his catastrophic fate? Too much has been written on this subject already, but one might well remember that these are not the questions one usually asks about great interpretive literature— they mean “has poetic justice been served, have the good been rewarded and the wicked punished?” One might as well also ask “does suffering always bring wisdom?” and “does wisdom always bring happiness?” Perhaps rather than asking for poetic justice or for philosophic truisms, we need to bear always in mind that although Oedipus is almost godlike in wisdom, he is human, and that although his sufferings are terrifying, he bears them with courage and determination that are themselves almost godlike (for which, in another play about the end of his life, he is rewarded with elevation to an immortal demi-god). Sophocles is not writing a play about the acts of the gods—just or unjust—or about an intrinsic relationship between suffering, wisdom, and happiness. Rather, his subject is a great man who loyally does his duty to others and to his own need to know himself. Such men are not always happy.
ANTIGONE By Sophocles PROLOGUE (Lines 1-99) Antigone and Ismene come out of the palace. Antigone tells her sister about Creon’s edict forbidding the burial of Polynices and confides that she intends to defy the order: She asks Ismene to help, but the older sister is afraid and protests that they are only women and too weak to resist the king. Antigone asserts that their highest obligations are to the dead and the gods, not the king, and says: Go your own way; I will bury my brother; And if I did for it, what happiness! Convicted of reverence –I shall be content … Live, if you will; Live, and defy the holiest laws of heaven Ismene promises to keep the plan a secret, but Antigone scornfully rejects his offer of token assistance.
Ismene is hurt by her sister’s harsh words. She assures Antigone that she will always love her. The Prologue sets up the first part of the conflict of the play: Antigone feels the duty to bury her dead brother. From the legend, we know that Polynices had earlier asked Antigone to give him a decent burial. Furthermore, in the Greek view of death, a person’s soul could never come to rest (peace) until the body is decently buried. Consequently, the burial rites assumed great importance for the ancient Greeks.
14
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Antigone, therefore, is determined to carry out her promise to her brother, but also she is, in her view, fulfilling a higher law that is, she is acting according to her religious duty. Her comment to Ismene; “I owe a longer allegiance to the dead than to the living,” implies that she cannot dishonor the laws which the gods have established. PARODOS (Lines 100-152) The chorus of elders enters, chanting the verses, Hail the sun! the brightest of all that ever Dawned on the City of Seven Gates, City of Thebes!
They sing an ode in praise of the recent victory of the Theban army, describing the great battle in which Eteocles and Polynices killed each other. FIRST EPISODE (Lines 163-331) Creon enters and thanks the assembled elders for their continued loyalty. He assures them that he hopes to be a wise ruler and will always keep the interests of the state and the people foremost in his mind. “Our country is our life,” he says; “only when she rides safely have we any friends at all.” Creon announces his decision about the corpse of Polynices. He explains that Polynices was a bloodthirsty traitor who would have destroyed his own city. This act of retribution will deter all others who contemplate the betrayal of their homeland. Creon adds: I am determined that never, if I can help it, Shall evil triumph over good. Alive Or dead, the faithful servant of his country Shall be rewarded.
Antigone
15
Creon is interrupted when a frightened sentry guarding the body of Polynices enters and reports that someone has buried the corpse. Creon angrily accuses the soldier of having accepted a bribe to neglect his duty and threatens to execute him if the rebel is not found. Creon’s opening speech to the assembly of Thebans solidifies the essential conflict of the drama. Creon views the laws of the state as the highest laws. Consequently, since Polynices had deliberately attempted to destroy the state, Creon orders that his body be defiled as an example to anyone else who would intentionally revolt against the state. Creon’s action is for the benefit of public welfare; Antigone’s defiance is for her concept of religious duty. For Antigone, religious laws are superior to the laws of the state. In this first appearance, we see that Creon hopes to be a wise and good ruler. We must note that he does act out of sincere belief that his decision is best for the state. It will be much further in the play before we see that Creon is too narrow and strict to be the ideal ruler. FIRST STASIMON (Lines 332-383) The chorus sings a beautiful ode acclaiming the many accomplishments of mankind, but ending on the pensive note that death ultimately comes to all. This poem is one of finest and most famous lyrics written by Sophocles: Wonders are many on earth, and the greatest of these Is man, who rides the ocean and takes his way Through the deeps, through wind-swept valleys of Perilous seas That surge and sway …
16
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
There is nothing beyond his power. His subtlety Meeteth all chance, all danger conquered. For every ill he hath found its remedy, Save only death.
SECOND EPISODE (Lines 384-581) The sentry returns with Antigone. Creon at first does not believe that she would dare defy his command, but the soldier’s detailed account of her capture at the graveside convinces him. Antigone proudly admits that the story is true. She says she knew about Creon’s proclamation. But That order did not come from God. Justice, That dwells with the gods below, know no such law. I did not think your edict string enough To overrule the unwritten, unalterable laws Of God and heaven, you being only a man.
Creon suspects that Ismene is Antigone’s accomplice and sends for her. While they are waiting, Antigone boasts that she has followed the path of honor and has no fear of punishment. Creon repeats his conviction that Polynices was a traitor to Thebes and points out that his burial is an insult to her other brother, the heroic Eteocles. Antigone replies that even the dead have rights given to them by gods. It is not for mortals to question or amend the divine law, she says. Ismene is brought in by the soldiers. When Creon accuses her of treason she tearfully claims to be guilty and asks to share her sister’s punishment, but Antigone contemptuously recounts Ismene’s earlier refusal to assist her. After listening to the women quarrel for a while. Creon decides that they are both insane. Ismene begs him to spare her sister for the sake of his son
Antigone
17
Haemon, to whom Antigone is betrothed, but Creon refuses. The women are taken away. In this scene, Antigone seems to be almost a fanatic. She does not listen to Creon’s logic. She will not admit that one brother deserved a better fate than the other. She simply affirms and reaffirms her position that she was only following the dictates of the gods. In other words, here is a woman ruled more by her instincts and her emotions than by her rational faculties. She is also a woman of extreme pride in that she wants to take full credit and blame for her action. She will not allow her sister to assume any of the guilt. She believes that what she has done will be approved by the gods. She says that the world approved Ismene’s caution, but the gods approved her courage. The reader should remember that Creon is a new king, This is the time his order has been disobeyed. He feels, therefore, that he must by very strict, or else the populace will not respect his authority. SECOND STASIMON (Lines 582-630) The chorus sings an ode which tells the story of the ancient curse that has afflicted all the descendants of Labdacus—Laius, Oedipus, and now the children of Oedipus. The law of Zeus, it says, is immutable. No man can oppose the will of the gods: For mortals greatly to live is greatly to suffer … And short is the time before that suffering comes.
THIRD EPISODE (Lines 631-780) Haemon enters, saying he is devoted to Creon’s interest and is not moved by any personal consideration. He tells his father that he has been circulating in the city and in view of the
18
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
mood of the people and thinks it would be better to temper justice with mercy and spare Antigone. Haemon advises: It is no weakness for the wisest man To learn when he is wrong, and know when to yield.
Creon resents his son’s interference and a heated argument between them follows. Both men become furious and exchange bitter insults. Finally Heamon angrily shouts that his father will never see him again and rushes out. Creon tells the elders that he will spare Ismene, but Antigone must die. She is to be sealed up in a deserted cave outside the city and will be given a small supply of food so that Thebes will not incur the blood-guilt for her death. Haemon expresses an important Greek concept here. Generally, the Greeks thought that all justice should be tempered with a certain amount of mercy and compassion. Haemon attempts to advise his father. But we see that Creon is too proud and too inflexible to listen to the advice of others. He must insist on his own way. Consequently, his failure to heed the advice of others makes him directly responsible for the tragedy at the end of the drama. THIRD STASIMON (Lines 781-882) The hours chants an ode on the power of love, Where is the equal of love? Where is the battle he cannot win … . He is there; he is here … . And the grip of his madness Spares not god or man. Aphrodite immortal Works her will upon all.
Antigone
19
FOURTH EPISODE (Lines 883-943) Antigone is brought in guarded by soldiers. The elders are moved by her pitiful appearance and cry, But there is a sight beyond all bearing, At which my eyes cannot but weep; Antigone forth faring To the bridal-bower of endless sleep.
Antigone is no longer self-assured and defiant. She does not regret her violation of Creon’s order, but is grieved by the realization that her life is coming to an end, that she will never experience the joy she has yearned for. She chants a pathetic lament for herself: So to grave, My bridal-bower, everlasting prison, I go to join those many of my kinsmen Who dwell in the mansions of Persephone, Last and unhappiest, before my time … Never a bride, never a mother, unfriended, Condemned alive to a solitary death. What law of heaven have I transgressed?
Creon enters, remarks that lamentations are no help to anyone and orders the soldiers to carry out the sentence. The guards lead Antigone away. FOURTH STASIMON (Lines 944-987) As the soldiers and Antigones pass by, the chorus sings an ode about well-known figures of the past who were also forced to endure cruel punishments. Upon them, they say to Antigone, “the grey fates laid hard hands as upon thee.” FIFTH EPISODE (Lines 988-1114) The blind prophet Tiresias comes in. He warns Creon that
20
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
the gods are angry about the blasphemous treatment of Polynices’ body and will punish the city for this sacrilege. He advises Creon that: Only a fool is governed by self-will. Pay to the dead his due. Wound not the fallen. It is no glory to kill and kill again.
Creon suspects Tiresias of making a false prophecy for personal gain and refuses to heed the warning. The seer predicts that if Creon does not end the desecration of the cropse and pardon Antigone, the gods will take vengeance by the death of his own son and the city will be defiled. Having said this, Tiresias turns and leaves. Torn between what he believes to be right and the fear of the horrible fate foretold by the prophet, Creon cannot decide what to do. He appeals to the elders for advice, and then rushes out with his attendants to bury Polynices and free Antigone. As in Oedipus, the blind prophet comes in and gives his prophecy, which Creon refuses at first to believe. Again we see that Creon is unable to acknowledge that someone else might be right and that he could be wrong. He cannot admit that there is a higher law than that of the state. When he finally comes to the realization of his error, he goes out to correct his mistake, but in the last scene, we see that he is too late. FIFTH STASIMON (Lines 1115-1152) The chorus sings a joyful ode in praise of the god Dionysus. EXODOS (Lines 1153-1353) A messenger enters and calls everyone together to hear his
Antigone
21
news, shouting, … hear and attend … people of Thebes! What is the life of man? … Chance raises a man to the heights, chance casts him down, And none can foretell what will be from what is.
Haemon has killed himself, the messenger says, and Creon, who once was envied by all men, who once was rich, powerful, honored, is now broken by his misfortunes. Queen Eurydice comes out of the palace and asks what the excitement is about. The messenger tells her how Creon and his servant buried the mutilated body of Ploynices and then went to the cave where Antigone had been entombed. Inside they found Haemon mourning over her dead body, for she had committed suicide. When Creon tried to comfort him, Heamon drew his sword and attacked his father, then stabbed himself. Eurydice begins to weep and goes back into the palace. The elders worry that she may attempt to harm herself and send the messenger after her. Meanwhile, the king and his attendants return. Creon is carrying Haemon’s body in his arms and seems overwhelmed by remorse. The messenger appears at the door of the palace and announces that the queen has killed herself. Creon cries pitifully, “I am nothing. I have no life. Lead me away.” He acknowledges his responsibility for all these tragic events and prays that his own death will come soon. The heartbroken Creon wanders away while the chorus muses about the things that have taken place and says: Of happiness the crown
22
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
And chiefest part Is wisdom, and to hold The gods in awe. This is the law. That, seeing the stricken heart Of pride brought down, We learn when we are old.
In Antigone, Sophocles examines the age-old conflict between the requirements of human and divine law. This universal problem is crystallized in the dispute about the burial of Ploynices, in which Creon’s understanding of the public welfare is opposed to Antigone’s conception of her religious duty. The central character of the play is Creon, a distinctly tragic figure who acts from sincere, patriotic, and selfless motives, but who is too inflexible and narrow in outlook to heed criticism or admit error until it is too late. At the close of the play Creon recognizes and accepts his guilt, but the consequences of his acts can no longer be changed. Creon’s tragedy is his inability to recognize that anyone else can be right and his failure to acknowledge a higher good than that of the state. In part, the characterization of Creon is Sophocles’ commentary on the corrupting influence that absolute power has even on a good man, and is typical of the democratic Athenian attitude. Though her role is smaller, Antigone is the more difficult character to understand. Some have judged her to be guilty of the sin of pride and overwhelmed by an immature or masochistic desire to martyr herself. Others consider her a woman of innate nobility and idealism, unwilling to compromise the truth as she sees it, who suffers a cruel and undeserved punishment. In either
Antigone
23
case, it is important to realize that Antigone is driven by her instincts and emotions, while Creon acts on the basis of principle and a reasoned analysis of the situation. The positions of Antigone and Creon are opposed; but both posses stubborn belief in their own righteousness. Thus, on the issue of the burial one is right and one is wrong, but to an extent both share the blame for the tragic end of the play. There are many excellent minor characters in this play and the psychological authenticity of the conversations (e.g., the political argument between Creon and Haemon which is an undertone of father-son rivalry) has often been praised. The choral odes and Antigone’s lament are all of high poetic quality. The first stasimon is particularly renowned because of the similarity between its expression of traditional Greek religious thought and the ideas of certain Old Testament Psalms. Because the tragedies of Sophocles were written in a foreign language, and an ancient one at that, the English speaking reader is faced with certain difficulties. There are many prose and verse translations of Sophoclean drama available, but inevitably each one differs to some extent for all the other. Since translators are individuals, it is only natural that their own personalities and preconceptions may affect their versions of the play. In addition, translators’ aims often differ, and this too can affect their work. One, perhaps, will strive for an accurate and literal prose version for students of Greek; another will attempt to duplicate the majestic poetry of Sophocles and capture the spirit of the original in an English metrical from, even if some accuracy must be sacrificed; and still another will exercise great license on
24
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
the text to produce a simplified up-to-date version for use in the modern theater. Other divergences may be caused by translators’ interpretations of the play, the degree of their understanding and sympathy for Greek culture, the environments of which they are themselves products, and, of course, their knowledge of Greek and their ability in writing English.
OTHELLO, THE MOOR OF VENCIE By William Shakespeare Of the many “problems” that have been analyzed in the extensive criticism of this play, the one that most intrigues beginning readers is explicitly voiced by Othello when he asks about Iago in act 5, “Why he hath thus ensnared my soul and body,” to which Iago retorts “What you know, you know,” and vows silence. Iago’s motivation is a central issue because he himself so often talks about it, and no doubt also because Coleridge famously pronounced that the soliloquy that concludes Act I reveals “the motive-hunting of motiveless malignity,” a fiendish lack of human motivation in a character who continually attempts to find in himself the motives that other men do have. At one point or another, Iago credits himself with ambition, spiteful envy of Cassio’s promotion to first lieutenancy, sexual jealousy because Othello has cuckolded him, profit from robbing Rodrigo, the pleasure of deceiving Rodrigo and Othello, jealousy that Cassio too has slept with Emilia, love for Desdemona, hatred of Cassio’s handsomeness, and mere hatred of Othello; and the careful critic will have no difficulty in finding other implied but not stated motives. That these do not sufficiently define Iago may be seen in disparities between stated motives and action; why, if he loves Desdemona, does he conspire in her death? Why, if he wants the lieutenancy, does he destroy the man who could give it to him? Why, since Rodrigo can so easily be robbed of cash, does he kill him? Why, if he is so jealous of his wife, does he, align
26
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
and finally kill her? While the changing circumstances of the play may answer some of these questions, it is this sort of arithmetic of motive and action that makes Coleridge’s conclusion so attractive. Intelligent, cunning, capable of tempting and controlling the characters around him, Iago nevertheless does not use his powers to achieve his stated goals, but in fact renders those goals unattainable. Like Milton’s Satan, Shakespeare’s antagonist fascinates, drawing the attention of the reader to himself and in part robbing the protagonist of the attention due him. The more we notice Iago, the less we Othello, whose ontological presence interferes with Iago’s absence. The result is what Shakespeare certainly did not intend, that Othello be read merely as Iago’s victim, as passively susceptible as are Roderigo, Desdemona, and Cassio. If only Coleridge’s word could be taken, one might more easily focus his interest not on Iago and what makes him sick, but on the great central figure, the tragic hero. Othello’s greatness is nearly a definition of the Shakespearean tragic hero: his weakness or “flaws” are virtues carried to excess. He loves, but “too well,” too intensely and totally; he trusts, but too much, and too indiscriminately; he has so great a sense of moral virtue and of his own honorable responsibility that he makes of himself an agent of divine justice to extirpate sin; his sensitive, poetic imagination leads him to vivid, pictorial fantasies of his wife and her lover. Iago in his soliloquies provides a partial catalogue, though of course he sneers at the general’s virtues: “The Moor is of a free and open nature / That thinks men honest that but seem to be so”; “The
Othello, The Moore of Venice
27
Moor, howbeit that I endure him not, / is of a constant, loving, noble nature.” And Lodovico spokesman for the Venetian government can only grieve to witness Othello’s abuse of Desdemona: “Is this the noble Moor whom our full Senate / Call all in all sufficient? Is this the nature / Whom passion could not shake? Whose solid virtue / The shot of accident nor dart of chance / Could neither graze nor pierce?” The thematic center of the play is the perversion of Othello’s goodness by the evil workings of his mind, and the chief concern is Othello’s fall from greatness, not as victim but as the agent of his own destruction. By insinuation and apparent reluctance to speak, Iago forces Othello to draw from him his suspicions, and excites Othello’s visual imaginations into picturing scenes of Desdemona’s lustful acts; and then, once he has administered this small dose of poison, Iago urges Othello onward into a deeper conviction by pretending to argue against the certainty of Desdemona’s guilt. The growth of Othello’s jealousy is the result of his own energies, the strength of his love and his desire for perfection driving him to take up the sword of divine justice. Is Othello gullible? Does he succumb too quickly, too easily to Iago’s temptation? Roderigo is indeed what Othello calls himself in act 5 after he has learned of Desdemona’s innocence: fool, dolt, a man without honor. Roderigo’s willingness to wait his turn to enjoy the woman he “loves,” the ease with which Iago can manipulate him into the cowardly attempt on Cassio’s life, the whining stupidity which makes him so easy a prey—these are explicitly contrasted to Othello’s true love and noble nature. Iago
28
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
marks the contrast in his first soliloquy when he apologizes to himself for wasting time gulling such a “snip” as Roderigo (“sport and profit” excuse the waste), and sets as his real target a man of “free and open nature” to be led (he hopes as easily as such “asses” as Roderigo. Like Satan’s, Iago’s cunning is in leading people into self-destruction, not merely in duping them—and his skill is great. For no one in the play has the least suspicion of him (until Roderigo in act 4), not even the two people who must know him best, his wife Emilia and his battlefield companion Othello. If Othello is vulnerable to him, so are Cassio, Desdemona, and Roderigo, and even Montano and Lodovico: everyone to whom he lies believes him (a statistical demonstration that Othello is not to be considered especially susceptible), and ironically almost everyone turns to him for advice. Structurally, Othello moves toward its catastrophe inexorably, with an increasing narrowing of focus. The first act, in Venice, has the breath of three parallel situations, the gulling of Roderigo, the military danger of the invasion of Cyprus, and the private conflict between Brabantio and the newly married general and his wife. The subplot of Roderigo is maintained right up to the fifth act, repeating again and again Iago’s ability to manipulate the young man’s sensual ambitions for his own profit and the pleasure of watching him squirm. In terms of development, the Iago-Roderigo action is less a subplot than a recurring situation, a reminder of what Iago can do to lesser men whose “love” is only lust. The great public issue of a Turkish invasion, which in act 1 vies in importance with the private affair of the “unnatural” marriage, is removed at the opening of act 2
Othello, The Moore of Venice
29
when the enemy fleet is “banged” and dispersed by the storm (no doubt Shakespeare’s audience would recall the similar fate of the grand Spanish Armada), constricting action to Iago-OthelloDesdemona. The reader hears of the Turks the proclamation in Act II that links their loss with the celebration of Othello’s nuptials as the double occasion for general holiday. The cashiering of Cassio raises Roderigo's false hopes and sets up Iago’s plan to make Othello suspect the motives of his wife as she generously pleads for the lieutenant’s reinstatement. Othello’s downfall commences in Act IV, after the play has amply established the many virtues in his character. As the poisonous suspicion grows in him, we witness a deterioration of his free, open, and trusting nature, as he commits himself to one act after another that undercuts his greatness: he sets Emilia to spy on Desdemona, he deputizes Iago to take vengeance on Cassio, he stoops to eavesdropping as Iago interviews Cassio, he subjects Desdemona to verbal and then to physical abuse, he lurks in the darkness observing the ambush of Cassio, and then finally murders his innocent wife. But this deterioration is all the while accompanied by the perplexing and paradoxical constancy of his love, for although he is convinced of Desdemona’s guilt, he cannot refrain from loving her. This is shown clearly when he exclaims on the “pity of it” after Iago draws him back from thoughts of her sweetness, delicacy, gentleness, and beauty. As he approaches the murder in the last scene, he has managed to subdue whatever hatred he had displayed in abusing her, and thinks of himself as the abstract agent of divine justice, however, but simultaneously, he is drawn by the beauty of her skin, her
30
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
balmy breath, the “cunning’s pattern of excelling nature,” to kiss her again and again, even to wish that he could preserve her physical perfection and love it after her death. Like the loving God who must punish his beloved creature for her sin, he must strike the one he loves and pities. After the murder, as the unwinding mysteries reveal to him the extent of his injustice, Othello’s character sinks lower. For a moment he is willing to hide his crime behind Desdemona’s dying words, but then pulls himself up to denounce her lie. His lowest moral point comes in the speech at, in which he gives way to self-pity, blames his act on “fate” and the stars, and cries out for punishment of hell to remove him from the sight of what he has done all without acknowledging that he has been personally responsible. This is counterbalanced by his final speech, when once again he resumes his noble, moral character: he yields up his pride as a great commander, asks only for an honest, plain report of his character, and then reorienting himself in the wide geographical world he had inhabited, he accepts both his guilt and his responsibility to the state. Recalling his defense of Venice against her enemies, he identifies himself both with the Turk who “bent a Venetian and traduced the state,” and with the hero who brought him to justice. He began the last scene in ignorant usurpation of the role of divine justice; he ends his life in an enlightened act of human justice and a final farewell to his beloved. There can be no serious question about Othello’s race. Iago, Brabantio, and Roderigo all refer disparagingly to it (“thicklips,” “sooty bosom”), and Othello himself states plainly “I am
Othello, The Moore of Venice
31
black.” The word “moor” was used in Shakespeare’s time to identify black Africans as well as practitioners of Mohammedanism. Ideologically speaking, Othello is black and, insofar as his religion is identified, a Christian, and a foreigner in Venice. His race is thematically important, particularly as it would have provided a prejudiced point of departure for Shakespeare’s audiences. Brabantio’s attitude toward it may be taken to represent the common attitude: his daughter is “unnatural” in loving a black, her action to extreme as to make him suppose that magic or witchcraft is the cause (and Desdemona herself acknowledges that her elopement was “downright violence and storm of fortunes”). Common prejudices of the time would have presumed the black man to be less rational, more passionate and lustful, less civilized, and, at the extreme, inherently evil (as the play indicates, the devil himself was thought to be black in hue). Against these assumptions Shakespeare creates a noble, Christian, virtuous man of great imagination, calm self-control, frankness, and honesty, and he bestows on white Iago the qualities of a devil. An audience perceives not only the literal color contrast between the protagonist and antagonist, but the contrasting inversion of the moral qualities symbolically associated with their colors. As he so often does, Shakespeare achieves intense dramatic effects by demonstrating that common prejudices are opposite to the truth.
THE SCHOOL FOR SCANDAL By Richard Brinsley Sheridan The situations in The School for Scandal are quite a possibility. The dialogue of The School for Scandal is light, witty, and airy, but it is also literary, and few characters open their mouths without giving expression to a carefully rounded or phrased sentence or period. The dialogue abounds in wit throughout; the piece produces new and interesting situations in every scene, and sentiments the most natural and elevated arise from those situations. Virtues and principles, operating on conduct, are strongly recommended. Vice is described in its most hideous garb. It is the unfailing point that wit and polish of dialogue make this play a classical of the English stage. The two main kinds of comic language are the language of humor and the language of wit. In Sheridan's conception of character, he is a wit rather than a humorist. He creates character by a distinctly intellectual process; he does not bring it forth out of the depths, as it were, of his own being. His humor, fine and dry as it is, is the humor of the wit. His wit is the wit of common sense. The language of wit predominates in The School for Scandal. The language of wit uses grammar and sentence structure and rhetorical devices with such uncommon fluency that its speech diverges from a norm of good speech and writing, by its more considerable excellence. The language of wit is superb writing, and the nature of its excellence is a symptom of what is
34
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
right with the speaker, using the language of wit. The speaker exceeds the civilized norm and makes us admire his urbanity, insight and wisdom. In the language of wit, the audience perceives a consummate use of words that stems from excellences of character, and the resultant laughter is admiring. The School for Scandal, largely because of its witty language, has been Sheridan's most admired play. The Scandal scenes in particular have been considered a triumph of witty language and they will only work because they are witty. The danger of these scenes, particularly in a poor production, is that they are situations. Nothing happens in term. The plot does not advance. In the language of wit, the audience laughs at the cleverly-used language and becomes a literary appreciator. The point might by proved by taking any the play’s well-turned jokes if not, indeed, destroying the strength of the jokes. For instance, in act 1, the poetaster Sir Benjamin Backbite, unknowingly, makes a joke against his own vapid verses when he describes the appearance of his forthcoming slim volume "a beautiful guar to page, where a neat rivulet of text shall meander through a meadow of margin.” The delight of jokes comes from two sources. The obvious point is the originality of the metaphor, and the subtler point is the reinforcement of sound first in the "neat Rivulet of text," and next in the m's of "meander through a meadow of margin." To rephrase the remark in unmetaphorical and unalliterative statement is to arrive at some thing like: "a beautiful quarto page where a few lines are set off by a wide margin." Sheridan's wit could be genial as well as icy— of which there could be no better proof than the success with which he has enlisted our sympathies for the characters of this
School for Scandal
35
comedy. Sheridan's characters have descriptive names such as Mr. Snake and Sir Benjamin Backbite. The entire cast of this play consists of comic stereotypes whose ruling passions are accurately labeled by their names. This is an expose of social vice and hypocrisy in which the name of characters contributes to both the comic and moral dimensions of the drama. One group of characters clearly represents the scandal mongering which forms the major activity of the play, their names revealing their various skills in the arts of gossip and slander. The allusion to Miss Prim and Miss Nicely suggest a fleeting satire on social prides—the word nice in the eighteenth century English conveyed the idea of fussy, and finicky, while the figures of Moses and Mr. Premium similarly attack the practices of usury and brokerage. Indeed, almost every name in the play has its satiric point. Perhaps the most important name in the play is Maria. Maria may allude to the purity and innocence of the Virgin Mary, though a religious reference of this kind would seem to be on a very different level from the social satire of the other characters’ names. However, one interprets her name, Maria, to represent true candor and levelheaded judgment in the artificial, brittle social world which Sheridan portrays, refusing to participate in, or even listen to, the malicious gossip of the school for scandal, she steadfastly remains true to Charles, despite all surface evidence. The chief characters are all stock characters of comedy such as the elderly husband, the giddy young wife, the spendthrift young man with a heart of gold. And not only are the character all witty, but they all talk alike. Their wit is Sheridan's wit, which is
36
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
very good wit indeed. Much more to Sheridan's taste was the reputation of a society with which the work chanced to be the best comedy of his century. The great objects of the satire are detraction and hypocrisy which, according to character and situation, the author has very artfully blended, sometimes in the same person and sometimes distinct. The point of the scenes of gossip is to show malicious wit at work and to satirize "high society" as Sheridan saw it. However, Sheridan also employs a double plot of considerable intricacy, involving on the one hand the intrigues of the school for scandal and on the other Sir Oliver Surface's legacy to his nephews. The plot centered on Sir Oliver is a farcical exhibition of the misjudgment which results from scandal mongering and belief in surface appearances. These recognition of scenes employs comic and dramatic irony to make their satiric point: the audience knows more than characters and so can enjoy the working out of the delicious twists and turns of the plot from the eminence of superior knowledge. Thus, all the witty talk of the play is reinforced by the patterned action, with a denouement in which Lady Teazle and Joseph are chagrined and Charles and Maria rewarded. Indeed the moral of the play is that actions speak louder than words. In the eighteenth century, sentiment referred to a refined moral perception combined with emotional sensitivity. Throughout the play, there are many allusions to sentimental comedies in which virtuous characters spoke in eloquent phrases, and proverbs became a literary vogue in the middle of the
School for Scandal
37
eighteenth century. Sheridan's attitude toward sentiment is mainly ironic. By equating Joseph's sanctimonious platitudes and proverbs with sentiment, he implies that facial expression of moral idea, and tender feeling is suspect unless accompanied by genuinely moral actions and behavior. The custom and fashion for literary sentences is satirized in Joseph's hypocritical epigrams, which often comically contradict each other. Sheridan's satiric treatment of the sentimental man is in part a reaction to the custom of the period, which saw the word used as an almost meaningless term of approbation. Despite Sheridan's ironic view of moral platitudes, he does not banish all sentimental feeling from his play.
THE CHERRY ORCHARD By Anton Chekhov Despite Chekhov’s designation of the play as “A Comedy in Four Acts,” and his correspondence with the Moscow Art Theater during the preparation for the first production in 1904 reaffirming that designation (it is “not a drama but a comedy, in places even a farce”; “the last act will be merry, and indeed the whole play will be merry and frivolous”), the serious interpretation used in that production has generally prevailed the play which has most often been performed as pathetic drama or even tragedy. It is not difficult to understand why this contradiction of the author’s intention should have taken hold among producers and critics, for the subjects of the play are depressingly serious: the loss of an ancestral estate, the rise of a semiliterate, ambitious middle class to replace the aristocrats, the dispossession and scattering of an entire family, the guilt and remorse of a woman who cannot resist her attachment to an unworthy man, and the utter ineffectuality of an entire household. The play is concerned with loss, the failure to comprehend and communicate, and the destruction of an old order. The Cherry Orchard presents a dilemma: the family faces two unacceptable alternatives, either to lose the estate by auction because of the unpaid mortgage (an experience Chekhov’s own family suffered during his childhood), or to destroy it by chopping down its unique distinctive feature and razing its house to replace it with summer cottages. The second alternative (which is finally
40
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
taken by the man who busies it at auction) offers a “vulgar” economic solution at the expense of the old values; the first preserves the sense of values, at the cost of everything. In this impossible situation, where the choice of either action is insupportable, Mme. Ranevskaya chooses not to act (the play has been criticized for its lack of action, a curious judgment since the subject is inaction). But before we lament the losses presented in the play, it is well to understand precisely what is being lost—and whether it was really ever possessed by the characters in the play. The cherry orchard is the central symbol, representing to the characters various things: to Mme. Ranevskaya and her brother Gayev, the orchard represents childhood innocence, the stability of generations, the beauty of the past, and their own identity as landowners; to Lopakhin, the self-made man who is sentimental about the past but is creating his own future, the orchard (and the estate and its owner) is a reminder of serfdom and the generous condescension of the landed class, but is now non- productive and useless, remarkable only for the acreage it covers; to Trofimov, the idealist pressing for a utopian socialist future, It is a remnant of oppression and injustice; to the half-deaf old servant Firs (who preferred to remain with his former owners) cherries were abundant, sweet, and profitable. But in this variety of attitudes, Chekhov also presents a number of undercutting realities. Mme. Ranecskayan is not, nor has she been for long time, an innocent girl living in a beautiful world (it is to recapture that lost past that she has come back to Russia); the days of serfdom which both Firs and Trofimov link to the orchard were neither as sweet as
The Cherry Orchard
41
Firs claims (Lopakhin reminds him, though Firs does not hear it, that those were the days of flogging) nor as vicious as Trofimov declares (since both Firs and Lopakhin recall their early lives sentimentally). What is being lost is not in fact an old order of stability, family love and unity, innocence, and usefulness-these which are already long gone. The destruction of the orchard and the estate is the destruction of illusions, a symbolic double negative which the play explores at many levels of action, characterization, and theme. Throughout, this comedy relies for its comic effort on the linking of contraries, the ambivalence of opposite extremes united in single persons and actions. To take on obvious example from the opening of act II, the governess Charlotta soliloquizes about her rootlessness, the emptiness of a life without purpose, her lack of identity (“where I come from and who I am—I do not know”) and then, even before she has finished, she pulls a cucumber out of her pocket and chomps on it, muffling her words (“I have no one”) with a ludicrous action. She combines her pathetic selfevaluation with clownishness and, in her magic tricks, exuberance. Her very first line, during the tearfully joyous entry of the family in act I, is “My dog even eats nuts,” and hilarious irrelevancy that punctures the sentiment of the scene. All of the other characters, and many of the scenes of emotion, follow this pattern: sentiment, pathos, joy, idealism, is suddenly or simultaneously juxtaposed with ludicrousness, pomposity, and slapstick clumsiness. Chastising herself for being a spend-thrift, Mme. Ranevskaya gives a gold coin to a beggar. Apparently insensible to the beauty of the orchard, Lopakhin recalls “when
42
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
my poppies were in bloom, what a picture it was!” Like Charlott with her cucumber, Gayev pops a candy in his mouth as he is vowing “On my honor, I’ll swear by anything you like, the estate shall not be sold.” This device is not merely ironic undercutting or the satirizing of people whose actions do not match their words or whose words are inconsistent. It is based on Chekhov’s honest observation of human nature and the human predicament: we are all mixtures of opposites (a religious writer like Tolstoy would see this as the condition of mankind after the fall of Adam), and the ending of the play does not falsify this fact by providing or promising any implausible conversions. Mme. Ranevskaya will return to Paris, squander the little money that she has borrowed to pay the mortgage, and then—who knows? Varya will continue to yearn for the two opposite types of existence (wife, nun) while she duplicates her life as housekeeper in someone else’s family. Anya’s naïve innocence will no doubt ultimately give way, probably to imitate her mother whose childhood she represents. Gayev, the victim of mortgage holders, is not likely to last long working in a bank. And so on—nothing will really change these people, since they are genuine human beings for whom miraculous changes are unavailable. Having been stripped of the illusion of stability and beauty, they may not be so easily duped in the future, but there is not even any certainty that this has been a “learning experience” for them. They have had to face their reality, but in life that does not mean they will not again succumb to an unrealistic vision of themselves. The ambivalent structure of the play reinforces this
The Cherry Orchard
43
evaluation of character. Act I takes place at dawn in springtime, with the orchard in full bloom—but the weather is freezing; the family has come together for a joyous homecoming, yet the progression of the act is toward sleep and silence (Semyonov – Pishchik even dozes off in the middle of speaking, and Anya falls asleep while Varya is telling her of the household problems); only the idealist Trofimov is awake at the end, looking forward to sunshine and springtime and love. Symbolically throughout this act of reunion and family solidarity, very little of the dialogue is actual conversation: each character speaks from within, without responding to the beginning, the family reunion is a collection of separate, self-involved people—and, as Lopakhin keeps reminding them, they are in the process of losing the symbol of their identity and unity. Act II is a midsummer sunset scene, out of doors, with the future in the modern world implied by the distant town and the telegraph poles leading toward it, the past is represented by decaying relict of religion. The family group assembles after a meal in town, but we do not have the idyllic fulfillment of familial closeness that was forestalled by travel weariness in act I. Rather, lassitude predominates, topics for conversation have to be concocted, and the act is full of pensiveness, pauses, and long silences. Lopakhin and Trofimov press for their two very different versions of the future, but silence overcomes them all as they “sit lost in thought,” together but isolated as the action winds down to a standstill. And then the sound of the breaking string propels them into various responses—fears, confusion, prophecy—and the beggar shows them another version of the future, a frightening
44
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
vision of poverty and wandering. While the first two acts seem to be moving into lethargic disunity, in ironic contrast to the seasons and to the desire to reaffirm community and stability the last two acts are bursting with life though the occasions are dismal. Mme. Ranevskaya has scheduled her party on the day of the auction, and alternately gives way to anxiety and bursts forth with gaiety. Slapstick and clowning are at their height; Charlotte’s tricks delight them all, while Yepikhodov’s clumsiness seems to have infected Trofimov (falling down the stairs), Lopakhin (knocking over a table), and Varya (swinging the pool cue). Gayev enters with grief in his heart, and anchovies and herrings in his hand. Act IV is in almost every way an inverted mirror image of act I: in the same room, now denuded of its nostalgic reminders of childhood, it is afternoon (not morning) in October (not springtime) –and the uncharacteristic frostiness of the spring has been replaced by an autumn that is warm and sunny. The family is preparing to disperse to various destinations, to carry out separate, individual lives, in contrast to their coming together to reunite in shared community. There is the same amount of hustle and bustle, a lavish amount of sentimentality, but at the end the only one to doze off (perhaps, according to some critics, to die) is the ancient servant Firs. The gaiety of Anya and Trofimov, looking to the future, is balanced against the despair of Gayve and Mme. Ranevskaya as they grieve for “life, youth, and happiness.” This is not, on the face of it, a “happy ending,” with all still form of Firs alone on the stage while the breaking string again sounds and the axes destroy the orchard and all the past. It is,
The Cherry Orchard
45
however, a “real” ending, and it holds some promise. Old Firs is the embodiment of the last illusion, dressed as always in his formal jacket and white waistcoat as if there were still a prosperous, aristocratic world to be served. Anys, Varya, and Mme. Ranevskaya have all voiced concern that he was to be sent to the hospital, but this sincere emotion has not been put to practice; the deaf old man has been left behind, a memory of loyal and efficient service in a life now past. What prompted Chekhov to undertake in The Cherry Orchard a dramatic work with new thematic dimensions, one strikingly different in key from his preceding dramas? The answer must be sought in the attitude of the critics toward the thematic content–not the style—of The Three Sisters, as well as in Chekhov’s own responsiveness to the social and aesthetic demands of the time. Even when working on the new play, Chekhov was critical of his manner of writing. “I have the feeling that my style has grown old.” Or, “I feel that as a writer I have already outlived my time; every sentence I write strikes me as completely worthless and unnecessary.” Chekhov sought “renewal” of his dramatic technique in devices of the comic genre. Let us consider Chekhov’s observations on vaudeville at the time when he was writing The Cherry Orchard, his penchant for a comic tone: these reveal to us the sources of the unique compositional features of The Cherry Orchard, especially as they relate to tone. Directly following the staging of The Three Sisters early in 1901, Chekhov notes: “The next play that I write will be, without
46
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
fail, funny, very funny, at least in its conception.” Or: “At times I am overcome by a strong desire to write a four-act vaudeville or comedy for the Moscow Art Theater.” And again: “I still dream of writing a funny play, where the devil is running loose,” “I’d like to write a vaudeville, but there is just no time; I can’t pull myself together. I have some kind of presentiment that vaudeville will soon come back into fashion.” At this very time Chekhov was revising his old vaudeville, On the Harmful Effect of Tobacco. While shaping the new play and developing the characters, Chekhov wrote to O.L. Knipper “if my play doesn’t come out as I have conceived it, then clout me on the head. There’s a comic part for Stanislavski, for you too.” “The last act will be gay, light hearted.” Apropos the comic role of Charlotta Ivanovna, Chekhov wrote: “Ah, if only you were to play the governess in my play. It’s the best role; the other ones don’t appeal to me.” In characterizing the play as a whole, Chekhov wrote again: “I have a feeling that there is something new in my play, however boring it may be. Incidentally, there’s not one shot in the entire play.” “I’m calling the play a comedy.” “It turned out to be not a drama, but a comedy, in places even a farce.” In the dramatis personae, there is a tendency to indicate by the first and last names of the characters whether they belong to the “intelligentsia” or not. The characters in the play are delineated through 1) recurrent themes in their dialogue and 2) peculiarities of individual speech and gesture. We may single out by way of example Lyubov Andreevna Ranevskaya. She is characterized by Lopakhin, Gayev, Anya, her own words; by an incident from everyday life (she drops her purse, the money
The Cherry Orchard
47
scatters); by her relations with Varya, Trofimove, Gave, and with “him” [her lover] living in Paris who sends her telegrams open, “joyous” emotions, excitability, rapid transitions from tears to laughter—all this is typical of Ranevskaya. Her movements, intonation, patterns of behavior are set forth in Chekhov’s stage directions. There is no division of the act into scenes. We may single out the basic themes that recur in the dialogue, as follows, in the order of their appearance within the act.
The first act introduces the initial and characterizing themes that arise in the context of Ranevskaya’s arrival at the estate. Thus the theme of Lopakhin with a flashback and a view of Ranevskaya, as well as a partial development of the theme of Dunyasha. Transition: the arrival of Epikhodov. The theme of Epikhodov and, partially, that of Dunyasha. Transition: the scene of the arrival of Ranevskaya, speeches and special characterizations of Ranevskaya and Varya. The theme of Anya and, partially, that of Dunyasha. The theme of Anya, characterization of Ranevskaya by Anya, with a general flashback, and with the introduction of the everyday plot element (the bankruptcy and impending sale of the estate). The theme of Varya. The dialogue between Varya and Anya is interrupted by a brief exchange between Yasha and Dunyasha. The dialogue concludes with a flashback by Anya. The theme of Firs. The theme of Gave. As we progress—with all the characters introduced—the characterization themes recur and interchange, though there is no full development of these themes. Thus: the themes of Ranveskaya and Lopakhin, with the exposition of the
48
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
plot, with the settlement on a general theme, and with a preliminary clash of the characters (Lopakhin, Ranevskaya, and Gave and the sale of the cherry orchard); the themes of Gave, Pishchik, Charlotta, Pishchik, Firs, Ranevskaya. The arrival of Trofimov. The theme of Trofimov and the termination of the theme of Pishchik. A new grouping of characters. The theme of Yasha, the characterization of Renevshaya as seen by Gave. The theme of Anya and Gave with a general exposition. The theme of Varya. In the final scene we have a genre scene lyrically presented. We shall designate the main themes in Act I with capital letters: A-Lophakhin; B- Ranevskaya; C-the sale of the estate. We shall use small letters to indicate the other themes. We get a picture of an unsystematic movement of themes. In Act II, the characterizing themes are these groupings: Charlotta and Epikhodov, Dunyasha and Yasha. Transition: the arrival of new characters. Episodic scenes. Themes and speeches of Gave, Ranevskaya, Lopakhin; the theme of the sale of the estate serves as a stimulus for the characterizing theme of Gave and Ranevskaya. The theme of Ranevskaya, with self-exposition. The theme of Lopakhin. Episode with the theme of Firs. Arrival of new characters. Characterization of Lopakhin by Trofimov. Trofimov’s theme of the proud man, of the intelligentsia, of life, all of which is picked up by Lopakhin. Later, successive interchange of episodes with internal themes: Gave’s declamation, the falling bucket, characteristic replies of Firs, of the Passer–by, and the characterizing theme of Ranevskaya. Termination of the themes and the exist of characters. In the final—the theme of
The Cherry Orchard
49
Anya and Trofimov, with disclosure of the general synthetic theme of the play, lyrically interpreted. The background, in Act III, is the ball, with music. The theme of Pishchik, which is broken off by the start of the episode of Trofimov and Varya. Start of the movement of the basic theme in the act of the sale of the estate, which is broken off by the start of the episode “Charlotta and her tricks,” and later by the end of the episode of “Trofimov and Varya,” which is interpreted as the theme of the relationship of Lopakhin and Varya. The recurring, basic theme of the act is again replaced by the Trofimov and Ranevskaya, settling on the overall, “synthetic” theme, which is interrupted by the themes of Ranevskaya and Trofimov and which is concluded by a vivid, [lyrically] expressive scene. Conclusion of the scene. Start of the theme of Firs and Yasha. Recurrence of the basic, “synthetic” theme. Interchange of episodic themes: Pishchik, Charlotta Ivanovna (silent scene), Dunyasha, Epikhodov and Dunyasha, Epikhodov and Varya, Varya and Lopakhin. Recurrence of the basic theme, which makes the basic theme of the act, settling on the overall, “synthetic” theme. In the final— the theme of Ranevskaya as seen by Anya, with a lyrical treatment of the overall theme. In Act IV, the movement of the themes occurs in the context of the dialogue of departure and Farewell. The introductory dialogue between Lopakhin and Yasha, the theme of Lopakhin. The theme of Trofimov and Lopakhin with a partial movement toward the overall, “synthetic” theme. Start of the movement of the episodic theme of Firs, which moves through the entire act. The theme of Dunyash and Yasha, which concludes
50
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
their relationship. The theme of Charlotta and Pishchik. Recurrence of the theme of Firs. The theme of Lopakhin and Varya. Start of the departure scene, with the themes of Gave, Ranevskaya, Epikhodov, Yasha, Anya, and Trofimov standing out. Termination of the plot line and of the distinctive themes-inpairs: Gave – Ranevskaya and Anya-Trofimov. The finale presents the termination of the theme of Firs. Thus, the movement of themes through the acts is accomplished according to the principle of unorganized articulation, of a kind of disintegration of composition in which the devices of interruption, severance, and recurrence of themes clearly stand out. Each act, however, acquires its compositional unity through the primary movement of one basic theme in the act. Thus, Act I gives, in abundance, the themes characteristic of Ranevskaya and only partially introduces the sale of the estate. Act II distinguishes the theme of Lopakhin. Act III is organized on the principle of an uninterrupted and intensifying movement of the theme of the sale of the estate. Act IV is constructed by distinguishing the episodic theme of Firs. The functions of the acts in the general structure of the play are not unusual: Act I discloses the background in everyday life, gives the disposition of characters and their basic characterizations, and partially points up the plot line of the play (in the encounter of Lopakhin and Ranevskaya). Act II brings out the themes of the preceding act but complicates the thematic sequence with the new general themes of Trofimov [ the need for work, censure of the intelligentsia, dream of happiness, etc]. Act III dramatizes, partially along personal lines, the basic theme of
The Cherry Orchard
51
the play (Trofimov-Ranevskaya), reveals fully the synthesizing role of Lopakhin, and terminatez the plot line. Act IV rounds out the fates of the characters: Lopakhin, Trofimov, Ranevskaya, Anya, Varya Firs, and partially hints at a continuation of the action beyond the play. The play has no dramatic plot, that is, the play has no such correlation of “events” as would make it possible to develop or bring out the characters, or disclose the phases of their “movement.” Therefore, there are no dramatic moments in the play. The fate of characters, their actions and behavior, are motivated entirely by common everyday situations and “events”. The basic everyday “events” –the sale of the estate predetermined from the start of the play—is the motive force which organizes the characters and the plot structure of the play, that is, the background against which the characters unfold. There are no love themes and relationships in the play: the relationship of Trofimov to Anya is qualified as one which is not a love relationship; the relations of Lopakhin and Varya are not revealed; the love theme of Ranevskaya—of which there are clear hints—also is not spelled out in the play; the love themes of Dunyasha and Epikhodov or of Dunyasha and Yasha come across as plain comedy, almost on the plan of parody. The plot line is developed through the contrasting movement of the characters; these are arranged in two opposing groups: Ranevskaya and Gave, on the one hand, and Lopakhin, Trofimov, and Anya on the other. There is a common ground: the sale of the estate. Both groups are disclosed in their thematic and tonal relationships: that is, the sale of the estate serves to bring out
52
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
the individuality of the characters; in time these characters become polarized in patterns representing a thematic (ideological) contrast (Ranevskaya-Lopkhin), and they are presented in contrasting, lyrically expressive tones (the speeches and conduct of Ranevskaya and Gave introduce a minor tonality; those of Lopakhin, Trofimov, and Anya, a major tonality; those of Lopakhin, Trofiov, and Anya, a major tonality). Each group of characters is differentiated within itself according to the principle of antithesis. Ranevskaya is more vigorous in self-expression and address than Gave. Expressive emotional speech in Lopakhin is distinctively local and individual, whereas the expressive emotional element in Anya and Trofimov partakes of their general grasp of the “questions of life.” The play has a “synthetic” theme: a psychological pattern and then a social one are superimposed on a pattern of everyday life. The “synthetic” theme is established through the relationships of the characters to a single, everyday matter; the exact motivation of these relationships, of course, is different with each character and has a different tone color. The author develops the basic theme of the play dialectically; at the same time he suggests its markedly synthetic character in his mastery not so much of individual scenes and speeches, as of the harmonious thematic composition of the whole play. The synthetic catalyst is indicated on the comic–not the dramatic–plane of the play, in the predominantly major key of the speeches of Anya and Trofimov. Lopakhin and Trofimov carry the central speeches which reveal the general theme. But though their speeches coincide in theme, their point of departure is different.
The Cherry Orchard
53
The function of other characters is to create a background of everyday life. The relationships among the characters in the play are notably unresolved (Lopakhin-Varya; Yasha, EpikhodovDunyasha). The absence of a dramatic plot and of dramatic treatment of the majority of characters (Ranevskaya and Gave are the exceptions), together with the abundance of comic scenes and situations, allows the acts to unfold without pressure form plot or dramatic requirements. The single crisis in the play—in Act III when the sale of the estate might have been a moment of dramatic disclosure of Ranevskaya and Gave is presented in a dramatically weakened, lyrically expressive from; on the other hand, the highly dramatic action preceding this moment of everyday comedy. In short, the action is developed in the unique style of the grotesque. The same technique for lessening dramatic intensity may be observed in the design—generally lyrical—of the ends of the acts. As a rule themes are not extensively developed, but only hinted at in speeches of various characters, and then broken off. The intervening theme or episode can lead to a return to one which was dropped or not fully developed. The alternation of themes is generally without motivation, except of the most common kind. Observations grow out of ordinary situations. Rejoinders often are laconic in style and underlined to any particular theme in the dialogue. The dialogue is rich in incidents and situations drawn from everyday life. There is a conscious and extensive disposition of expressive forms of dialogue. We may distinguish some typical
54
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
examples: 1) the direct, vivid lyrical utterance which signifies an open but tense emotional state; thus, Ranevskaya [looks at the orchard through the window]: “Oh, my childhood, my innocent childhood!” and so on. 2)The lyrical, passive utterance, large, overarching themes are conveyed lyrically. Thus, Trofimov: “Yes, the moon is rising (Pause). Here it is! Happiness is here. Here it comes, nearer, ever nearer. Already I hear its footsteps. And if we never see it, if we never know it, what does that matter? Others will see it!”. 3) The short, expressive comment which reveals basic themes; for example, Anya: “Goodbye, house! Goodbye, old life.” Trofimove: “And welcome, new life!”. 4) The expressive monologue: Lopakhin’s and Anya’s. 5) The expressive, charged dialogue: the episode of Trofimov and Ranevskaya. 6) Play with contrasting overtones: Gave and Ranevskaya as opposed to Anya and Trofimov in the finale. 7) The buildup of emotions which is lyrically, though not dramatically, resolved. (Act III-Ranevskaya). 8) The lyrical endings of the acts. 9) The expressive parody forms: Gave’s speech to the bookcase; Gave declaiming; Gave. The extensive use of pauses conditions the lyrical character of the dialogue. Pauses are introduced as a sign of “reflection,” usually with Lopakhin; as a sign of a change of theme; as an indication of troubled speech; as an indication of an emotion that is being revealed. There is an abundance of pauses containing sounds— sounds that have nothing to do with the dialogue, or which form a kind of lyrical accompaniment to words; music, waltzing in Act III. The general pause with some sound which is related to the
The Cherry Orchard
55
plot is of special significance. This kind of pause emphasizes the symbolic level of meaning in the strong sound effect; e.g., the sound of the “breaking string”, the sound of the “axe striking a tree”. The general pause which is taken up by the ordinary business of life has a plot function; for example, the moment following Lopakhin’s brief remarks about the purchase of the estate. Other pauses with everyday life content bear functions having to do with staging. The pauses are distributed through the acts as follows: 10, 17, 1, and 15. The almost complete absence of pauses in Act III is explained by the compositional requirements of the act. The dialogue proceeds against the background of the ball, in the intervals between dances and amidst comedy scenes. The general decrease in pauses as compared with the peak in pauses in the preceding play [The Three Sisters] can be explained, over and above the realization of the theme of the play on a different (comedy) level, by the small scope of the entire play, but especially of the final act. The lyrical conception of the acts extends even to the formulation of stage directions; the latter not only are designed for the stage, but have a literary, narrative function. Here are some examples from Act I and Act II: (Act I) Dawn is breaking and the sun will soon be up. It is May. The cherry trees are in bloom, but it is cold and frosty in the orchard. (Act II) In open country. A small, tumble-down old chapel long ago abandoned. Near it a well, some large stones which look like old tombstones, and an old bench. A road can be seen leading to
56
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Gave’s estate. Dark poplar trees loom on one side and beyond them the cherry orchard beings. There is a row of telegraph poles in the distance and far, far away on the horizon are the dim outlines of a big town, visible only in very fine, clear weather. It will soon be sunset. Everyone sits deep in thought. It is very quite. All that can be heard is Firs’s low muttering. Suddenly a distant sound is heard. It seems to come from the sky and is the sound of a breaking string. It dies away sadly. One might also note the stage directions in the other acts, and also directions of the following type: Anya “has reverted to a calmer mood and is happy.” We find wide use of everyday mise-en-scene, of, common entrances and exist of characters, the double playing areas (Act III—the arch which divides the reception room from the ballroom), and the introduction of silent scenes saturated with the mood of everyday surroundings. The lyrical background of the action is created through lyrical pauses and sound effects, and also by silent lyrical scenes and through the alternation of “natural” background (in Act I it is May; in Act IV, October). What is original in the composition and style of The Cherry Orchard as a whole –in comparison with the preceding plays—is the understructure of comedy: comic situations and episodes in the play’s ensemble, a large number of comic characters, the introduction of a general major tonality. This style of comedy did not exclude a dramatic treatment of the emotions of the separate characters, but it forms a leitmotif to this dramatic treatment throughout the course of the play.
The Cherry Orchard
57
We may speak of another new feature of the play: through the technique of dialogue and the disposition of characters, Chekhov wrought an organic, frankly social theme – but one which is nevertheless structured within a psychological framework of everyday life. The devices for character drawing and of successive, unmotivated interchange of dialogue themes, the everyday motivations of dialogue themes, the everyday motivations of dialogue and plot, devices for treating the dialogue lyrically—all mark back in nuance and detail to the stylistic practices, chiefly, of The Three Sisters, which was closest in time to The Cherry Orchard. However, other facets of the new play give evidence that Chekhov set new dramatic tasks in his last dramatic experiment. The play’s “plotless” quality, together with the absence of love entanglements (which usually organize, dramatically, the overall actions of the characters in a psychological drama of everyday life) and the absence of “events” (which usually dramatize the sequence of happenings in daily life); the absence of any visible organization of the episodes and speeches in an act (composition without the usual dramatic principle of composition); the use of expressive lyrical transitions all solved particular tasks in the spirit of a compositional –stylistic system to which the author was already accustomed. The new general and particular tasks of the play did not destroy the principle which Chekhov had mastered in his other plays, but the combination of them in one scheme gave rise to “mixed,” distinctively grotesque forms. The features of The Cherry Orchard which we have noted
58
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
are reflected in the evolution of the text of the play and in Chekhov’s reactions to various correspondents. An examination of the evolution of the text brings into relief the author’s extremely careful reworking of the dialogue and those elements of the
new
composition
which,
as
Chekhov
repeatedly
acknowledges, were “difficult.” The letters disclose those aspects and areas of The Cherry Orchard which draw Chekhov’s attention. Chekhov observes: “The play … is making slow progress, which I explain … by the difficulty of the plot.” Or: “how hard it was for me to write the play!” Defining the scope of the play, Chekhov writes: “My Cherry Orchard will be in three acts. That’s how it looks to me, but I have not made the final decision yet.” Or: “I wanted to make The Cherry Orchard into three long acts, but I can do it in four. It’s all the same to me, whether there are three or four acts—the play will be the same anyway.” And later: “The fourth act in my play, in comparison with the other acts, will be meager in its content, but effective.” And again: “The fourth act is coming easily, almost smoothly.” In these remarks Chekhov in a way was underscoring the following compositional feature of his play (which we find also in the preceding plays): the plot of the play is brought to a close in Act III; the final act in its combination of common everyday affairs and lyric mood has the character of a final: it emphasizes the fact that the problems and relationships of the characters are not resolved and it projects the action beyond the limits of the play into a realm of everyday life. As he worked over the play, the author was troubled principally by the second act with its exclusively lyrical design.
The Cherry Orchard
59
“It was hard, very hard, to write the second act.” He writes again: “The third act itself is not boring, but the second is boring and monotonous, like a spider web.” Then again: “I was mainly frightened by the lack of movement in the second act.” At the same time Chekhov was worried by the weakening of those devices for obtaining lyrical effects which he has used in preceding plays: “it will be necessary […] very likely, to change two or three words at the end of Act III, otherwise it will probably be like the end of Uncle Vanya.” We have already seen that Chekhov, in his letters, defied the formal problem of the play as an attempt at providing an understructure of comedy, with corresponding comic characters. He paid a great deal of attention in his letters to explaining the comic and dramatic functions of the characters. When comparing, apparently, the number of people in the new play to the larger group of people in The Three Sisters, Chekhov wrote: “I am making an effort to limit the number of characters as much as possible; it will be more intimate this way.” And later, in various letters, we find characterizations of people that Chekhov defined as being, in a stage sense, “live characters”; comic characters are affirmed and comic traits singled out (Gave, Lopakhin, Charlotta, Varya, and others). Chekhov stresses the importance of maintaining a gay and lively tone in the play and gives an exact interpretation of the roles of the different characters, especially Lopakhin in Chekhov’s view the “central role in the play.” Chekhov gives special attention to the stage interpretation of gesture and external appearance of characters, to expression in the roles the characteristic themes, as well as the environment
60
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
surrounding the performance and to sound effects. Chekhov was himself present at the rehearsals of the play and frequently corrected parts of it in the interests of clarity and expressiveness. The Cherry Orchard was performed at the Moscow Art Theater while Chekhov was still living. The thematic conception of the play had demanded a new structural framework; it had been realized on a new plane of comedy; it had been implemented by well-tried methods of Chekhov’s dramatic style. The directors of the Moscow Art Theater interpreted the thematic conception of the play according to the principle which they had used in earlier Chekhov plays. But in acting by analogy and in transferring to Chekhov’s last play the directing practices used in earlier plays, the Moscow Art Theater somehow ignored the original conceptions and new dramatic perspectives of The Cherry Orchard. And Chekhov sharply censured the staging of the play in this theater: “How terrible this is! Act IV, which should last twelve minutes maximum, runs forty minutes with you. I can only say that Stanislavsky ruined the play for me.” Or again: “Why is my play so insistently called a drama in the playbills and the newspaper announcements? Nemirovich and Alekseev [Stanislavsky] simply don’t what I have written in my play, and I am ready to bet that not once has either of them read my play attentively.” The Cherry Orchard is often accused of having no plot whatever, and it is true the story gives little indication of the play’s content or meaning; nothing happens as the Broadway reviewers so often point out. Nor does it have a thesis, though many attempts have been made to attribute a thesis to it, to make
The Cherry Orchard
61
it into a Marxian tract, or into a nostalgic defense of the old regime. The play does not have much of a ploy in either of these accepted meanings of the word, for it is not addressed to the rationalizing mind but to the poetic and histrionic sensibility. It is an imitation of an action in the strictest sense, and it is plotted according to the first meaning of this word which the readers have distinguished in other context: the incidents are selected and arranged to define an action in a certain mode; a complete action, with a beginning, middle, and end. Its freedom from the mechanical order of the thesis or the intrigue is the sign of the perfection of Chekhov’s realistic art. And its apparently casual incidents are actually composed with most elaborate and conscious skill to reveal the underlying life, and the natural, objective form of the play as a whole. In Ghosts, the action is distorted by the stereotyped requirements of the thesis and the intrigue. That is partly a matter of the mode of action which Ibsen was trying to show; a quest “of ethical motivation” which requires some sort of intellectual framework, and yet can have no final meaning in the purely literal terms of Ibsen’s theater. The Cherry Orchard, on the other hand, is a drama of “pathetic motivation,” a theater-poem of the suffering of change; and this mode of actions and awareness is much closer to the skeptical basis of modern realism, and to the histrionic basis of all realism. Direct perception before predication is always true, says Aristotle; and the extraordinary feat of Chekhov is to predicate nothing. This he achieves by means of his plot: he selects only those incidents, those moments in his characters’ lives, between their rationalized efforts, when they
62
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
sense their situation and destiny most directly. So he contrives to show the action of the play as a whole—the unsuccessful attempt to cling to the cherry orchard—in many diverse reflectors and without propounding any thesis about it. The slight narrative thread which ties these incidents and characters together for the inquiring mind is quickly recounted. The family that owns the old estate named after its famous orchard—Lyubov her brother Gave, and her daughters Varya and Anya—is all but bankrupt, and the question is how to prevent the bailiffs from selling the estate to pay their depts. Lopakhin, whose family were formerly serfs on the estate, is now rapidly growing rich as a businessman, and he offers a very sensible plan: chop down the orchard, divide the property into small lots, and sell them off to make a residential suburb for the growing industrial town nearby. Thus the cash value of the estate could be not only preserved, but increased. But this would not save what Lyubov and her brother finds valuable in the old estate; they cannot consent to the destruction of the orchard, but they cannot find, or earn, or borrow the money to pay their debts either; and in due course the estate is sold at auction to Lopakhin himself, who will make a very good thing of it. His workmen are hacking at the old trees before the family is out of the house. The play may be briefly described ensemble pathos: the characters all suffer the passing of the estate in different ways, thus adumbrating this change at a deeper and more generally significant level than that of any individual’s experience. The action which they all share by analogy, and which informs the suffering of the destined change of the cherry orchard, is “to save
The Cherry Orchard
63
the cherry orchard”: that is, each character sees some value in it— economic, sentimental, social and cultural which he wishes to keep. By means of his plot, Chekhov always focuses attention on the general action: his crowded stage, full of the characters I have mentioned as well as half a dozen hangers-on, is like an implicit discussion of the fatality which concerns them all; but Chekhov does not believe in their ideas, and the interplay he shows among his dramatis personae is not so much the play of thought as the alternation of his characters’ perceptions of their situation, as the moods shift and the time for decision comes and goes. Though the action which Chekhov chooses to show onstage is “pathetic,” i.e., suffering and perception, it is complete: the cherry orchard is constituted before our eyes, and then dissolved. The first act is a prologue: it is the occasion of Lyubov’s return from Paris to try to resume her old life. Through her eyes and those of her daughter Anya, as well as from the complementary perspectives of Lopakhin and Trofimov, we see the estate as it were in the round, in its many possible meanings. The second act corresponds to the agony; it is in this act that we become aware of the conflicting values of all the characters, and of the efforts they make (offstage) to save each one his orchard. The third act corresponds to the pathos and periphery of the traditional tragic form. The occasion is a rather hysterical party which Lyubov gives while her estate is being sold at auctioning the nearby town; it ends with Lopakhin’s announcement, in pride and the bitterness of guilt, that he was the purchaser. The last act is the epiphany: we see the action, now completed, in a new and ironic light. The occasion is the departure of the family: the
64
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
windows are boarded up, the furniture piled in the corners, and the bags packed. All the characters feel, and the audience sees in a thousand ways, that the wish to save the orchard has amounted in fact to destroying it; the gathering of its denizens to separation; the homecoming to departure. What this means we are not told. But the action is completed, and the poem of the suffering of change concludes in a new and final perception, and a rich chord of feeling. The structure of each act is based upon a more or less ceremonious social occasion. In his use of the social ceremony – arrivals, departures, anniversaries, and parties—Chekhov is akin to James. His purpose is the same: to focus attention on an action which all share by analogy, instead of the reasoned purpose of any individual, as Ibsen does in his drama of ethical motivation. Chekhov uses the social occasion also to reveal the individual at moments when he is least enclosed in his private rationalization and most open to disinterested insights. The Chekhovian ensembles may appear superficially to be mere pointless stalemates—too like family gatherings and arbitrary meetings which we know offstage. So they are. But in his miraculous arrangement the very discomfort of many presences is made to reveal fundamental aspects of the human situation. That Chekhov’s art of plotting is extremely conscious and deliberate is clear the moment one considers the distinction between the stories of his characters as we learn about them, and the moments of their lives which he chose to show directly onstage. Lopakhin, for example, is a man of action like one of the new capitalists in Gorky’s plays. Chekhov knew all about him,
The Cherry Orchard
65
and could have shown us an exciting episode from his career if he had not chosen to see him only when he was forced to pause and pathetically sense his own motives in a wider context which qualifies their importance. Lyubov has been dragged about Europe for years by her never-do-well lover, and her life might have yielded several sure-fire erotic intrigues like those of the commercial theater. But Chekhov, like all the great artists of modern times, rejected these standard motivations as both stale and false. The actress Arkadina, in The Seagull, remarks, as she closes a novel of Maupassant’s, “Well, among the French that may be, but here with us there’s nothing of the kind, we’ve no set program.” In the context the irony of her remark is deep: she is herself a purest product of the commercial theater, and at that very time she is engaged in a love affair of the kind she objects to in Maupassant. But Chekhov, with his subtle art of plotting, has caught her in a situation, and at a brief moment of clarity and pause, when the falsity of her career is clear to all, even herself. Thus Chekhov, by his art of plot-making, defines an action in the opposite mode to that of Ghosts. Ibsen defines a desperate quest for reasons and for ultimate, intelligible moral values. This action falls naturally into the form of the agony, and at the end of the play Ibsen in at a loss to develop the final pathos, or bring it to an end with an accepted perception. But the pathetic is the very mode of action and awareness which seems to Chekhov closest to the reality of the human situation and by means of his plot he shows, even in characters who are not in themselves unusually passive, the suffering and the perception of change. The “moment” of human experience which The Cherry Orchard
66
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
presents thus corresponds to that of the Sophoclean chorus, and of the evenings in the Purgatory. Ghosts is a fighting play, armed for its reasons. Chekhov’s poetry, like Ibsen’s, is behind the naturalistic surfaces; but the form of the play as a whole is “nothing but” poetry in the widest sense: the coherence of the concrete elements of the composition. Hence the curious vulnerability of Chekhov on the contemporary stage: he does not argue, he merely presents; and though his audiences even on Broadway are touched by the time they reach the last act, they are at loss to say what it is all about. It is this reticent objectivity of Chekhov also which makes him so difficult analyze in words: he appeals exclusively to the histrionic sensibility where the little poetry of modern realism is to be found. Nevertheless, the effort of analysis must be made if one is to understand this art at all; he is asked to consider one element, that of the scene, in the composition of the second act. Jean Cocteau writes, in his preface to Les Maries de la Tour Eiffel: “The action of my play is in images (imagee) while the text is not: I attempt to substitute ‘poetry of the theater’ for ‘poetry in the theater.’ Poetry in the theater would be coarse lace; a lace of ropes, a ship at sea. Les Maries should have the frightening look of a drop of poetry under the microscope. The scenes are integrated like the words of a poem.” This description applies very exactly to The Cherry Orchard: the larger elements of the composition –the scenes or episodes, the setting, and the developing story—are composed in such a way as to make poetry of the theater; but the “text” as we read it literally, is not. Chekhov’s method, as Stark Young puts it
The Cherry Orchard
67
in the preface to his translation of The Seagull, is “to take actual material such as we find in life and manage it in such a way that the inner meanings are made to appear. On the surface the life in his plays in natural, possible, and at time in effect even casual.” Young’s translation of Chekhov’s plays, together with his beautifully accurate notes, explanations, and interpretations, have made the text of Chekhov at last available for the Englishspeaking stage, and for any reader who will bring to his reading a little patience and imagination. Young shows us what Chekhov means in detail: by the particular words his characters use; by their rhythms of speech; by their gestures, pauses, and bits of stage business. In short, he makes the text transparent, enabling us to see through it to the music of action, the underlying poetry of the composition as a whole and this is as much as to say that any study of Chekhov (lacking as we do adequate and available productions) must be based upon Young’s work.
THE MISANTHROPE By Moliere Much modern criticism is devoted to psychoanalyzing Alceste’s misanthropy, and to pointing out such inconsistencies between his actions and feelings, and statements as to question his right to that title. Like Shakespeare’s Iago, Alceste provides fertile ground for investigation, as, for example, when he insists that the patent rightness of his case at law will be sufficient to bring him the justice he deserves and then drops his cries for justice to take satisfaction inconsistent in his love affair, wanting the social sanction of marriage, and insisting that Celimene join him in an antisocial retreat form the world. Critics have been tempted to search for a single key, an unstated motive that will explain such conflicting desires; but it may be as well to take Alceste at face value, as one takes Iago—as a character in a drama who has no more (and no less) to him than the playwright endowed him with. That is, we must see Alceste as a central figure that provokes the conflicts that move the comedy forward. Alceste has three areas of conflict: he wants to reform the manners of society so that all speech and action will be honest and sincere; he wants to win his lawsuit (the exact nature of which is not mentioned) so as to vindicate his honor and honesty and to demonstrate that plain truth can overcome lies; and he wants to marry Celimene so as to satisfy his beloved and win her from her false and brittle manners. The first and third of these desires are similar, for they require that insincerity give way to direct
70
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
expressions of feeling and thought; the second, since it is defensive, differs to the extent that it assumes that honesty is the purpose of the system of justice rather than dishonesty is the purpose of the system of justice rather than dishonesty needs to be extirpated. In all three conflicts Alceste fails, thus justifying to himself his breaking from the social, political, and emotional bonds that hold him. (Historical criticism suggests that what he proposes to share with Celimene and determines to undertake alone is not an exile to some rocky cave or barren wilderness, but only a withdrawal from Paris, presumably to a country estate away from the court world.) The opening conversation between Philinte and Alceste establishes these three conflicts and, in the prudent and realistic attitude of Philinte, reveals the potential of them. Philinte tells Alceste that conforming to the traditions and rules of social and judicial behavior is not onerous, and is appropriate in a talk with the judges before his case is heard, is not a suggestion of bribery or corruption, but rather pints him in the right direction, toward making his human situation open to judgment, it is what Celimene has done in her own law case, and is unsavory only to the extent that she must put up with the stupidity of a man of influence. But Alceste is not willing to see himself in such mixed terms—right and wrong are to him absolutely clear; as he presumes they should be in a court of law. As his later reaction to losing the case reveals, Alcetse wants to win, but more than that he wants to be right, and if the system of justice will not proclaim him right he will have the personal satisfaction of knowing that the system is wrong.
The Misanthrope
71
The solution to his love problem, as Philinte presents it, is rather different: not that he should conform and find a livable compromise, but that he should transfer his attentions from Celimene to her more honest and sensible cousin Eliante. Such a reasonable course of action is of course rejected by Alcetse, who acknowledges that in some situations (law, manners) he is ruled by reason, but in love his irrational heart, Alceste is almost a formula for the classical definition of human nature, for in some instances he is wholly rational, while in others he is entirely emotional. This mixture in himself is what Philinte wants him to accept in others. The three conflicts are resolved is the other of their initial presentation in 1.1. Detesting both Oronte’s artificial manners and the artificiality of his sonnet, after a momentary attempt to disguise his rejection Alceste treats Ornote with such candor that his rudeness nearly leads to a duel, requiring the intervention of the Marshals to patch up the quarrel. The resolution is a defeat for Alceste, since he must seem to apologize (for his bluntness, but not for his judgment). The legal decision follows another failure that again feeds Alceste’s sense of singular superiority. Finally, when fear of solitude prevents Celimene from acting on her own proposal of marriage to Alceste, she experiences failure for a third time. Is Alceste a comic figure? Philinte credits him with the reputation of a “crank,” a characterization which seems to fit rather well, making him a subject of ridicule. The key to his personality—if there is a key—is his inflexibility, his temperamental inability to keep his rectitude “plaint” as Philinte
72
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
advises. He displays occasional attempts at pliancy, as when he euphemistically offers his judgment of Oronte’s sonnet in terms of what he once told “one whose name I shall not mention,” or when, as Philinte reports, he allows his equivocal remarks to the Marshals to be taken for an apology. But with Celimene there are no such attempts, for his courtship of her includes a fervent confession that he has tried to “exorcise” her possession of his hearth, ultimatums and demands that she says publicly what she has frankly told him in private, and a misanthropic proviso that when married they live away from society. This final condition requires that they literally exist in that microcosmic world of lovers’ hyperboles, where each is to the other the whole universe. In a tragic world, Alceste’s inflexibility would make him comparable to such tragically inflexible characters as Oedipus and Othello, but as Philinte tells him, his “philosophic rage is a bit extreme for the worlds he lives in. “Alceste’s rage does not lead to catastrophe and self-awareness, but to conflicts in which the outcome serves only to disappoint and isolate him, driving him from a society whose norms he will not accept. The compromises suggested by Philinte are the compromises required in a peopled world mixing the good and devil propensities of humanity. Modern psychology can certainly diagnose in him a case, and we are free to wonder whether he truly wants to win his battles or whether his misanthropy is a rationalization that he reinforces by losing. But whatever lies behind, in the foreground, Alceste is a self-created “crank” who invites his own unhappiness. Alceste’s position is complicated by the fact that however extreme his approach, an audience is tempted to find his values
The Misanthrope
73
superior to those he rejects. Sincerity, candor, and honesty are posed against the patent falseness of Celimene and her courtiers. Acaste’s self-approving catalogue of his qualities in the opening sense of Act III explicitly defines what his society approves, as Celimene’s gossipy portrait painting and her letters to Clitander and Acaste define the rejection. The brilliant exchange of “friendly advice” between the pretended prude Arsione and the socially successful Celimene is a direct confrontation of the do’s and don’ts of this world, made more complex and intriguing since Celimene’s retort is both beautifully balanced against Arsinoe’s attack and also is honest in response to hypocrisy. It might have done Alceste good to have heard this exchange, since Celimene’s position is not very far from his own. The pairing of Eliante and Philinte as common-sense characters exiting between Alceste’s inflexible rectitude and Celimene’s permissive pliancy provides a gauge for measuring such extremes. They demonstrate, for one thing, that persons can be in this world without being amoral double-dealers. Why doesn’t Moliere say “All people should measure up to this norm,” or at least allow Alceste and Celimene the chance to find happiness by emulating them? The Misanthrope is not a play in which such miracles are dramatically or psychologically possible: its mannered society is a true mirror of the court world of Louis XIV, not a fantasy or caricature, and it would be as out of character for Alceste to learn compromise as it would be unrealistic for Celimene to give up the pleasure of society. Celimene is as honest as her world permits—more honest, in fact, since she has plainly informed Alceste that she loves him,
74
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
and bluntly offers herself in marriage. It is not Moliere’s purpose to show that Eliante and Philinte define a better sort of society, for their predominance would be at the cost of brilliance, sparkle, and the beautiful art of living by wit and poetry. By stage tradition, the entrances and exist of characters mark the change of scene— but the scene also does literally change, since the visual spectacle. These changes are matched to modulations in the brilliance of speech, the balance of the Arsinoe-Celimene debate, the satiric portraits Celimene draws as the names of absent friends are given to her, Acaste’s ridiculous catalogue of his virtues, the low comedy of Dubois’s frustrating inarticulateness, or the spluttering rages that rob Alceste of his coherence. The defining quality of this society is the achievement of superficial beauty in this mingling of visible and audible performances, and just as Celimene is unwilling to sacrifice it for Alceste’s “desert,” so an audience is unwilling to wish that Moliere replace it with the merely sensible goodness of Eliante and Philinte.
AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE By Henrik Ibsen The first act of the play is concerned with providing background information and other matters of exposition. We are not far enough in the play yet to draw definite character personalities the exposition (i.e., the handling of background material) provides us with the knowledge that Dr. Stockmann has often been on the verge of extreme poverty, that his brother the Burgomaster has obtained a nice post for him with the new baths in the town, that the idea of the baths were originally Dr. Stockmann’s, but the Burgomaster took ever and directed the building of the baths along lines which Dr. Stockmann did not approve of. Further more, we find out that the two brothers have very little in common. The Burgomaster adheres to old and traditional views and Dr. Stockmann is a man of modern and liberal views. At this point, it is suggested that Hovstad is in agreement with. Dr. Stockmann and opposed to the Burgomaster, but this will later be dramatically reversed. There are also enough hints in his first act to indicate that Dr. Stockmann is an impulsive man. He writes articles for the newspaper on any new idea he has. He does things impetuously and without consultation. He has had many “crackbrained notion” in the past, and has refused to consult the proper authorities. Dr. Stockmann is also somewhat native in thinking that the community will be proud of him for discovering that the baths are poisonous. He fails to realize that as important as the discovery is,
76
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
it is one which will cause an immense amount of expense and inconvenience. The readers know that he was annoyed at the Burgomaster for refusing to lay the pipes where Dr. Stockmann wanted them. Now that he has found out that the pipes are causing the baths to be poisonous, there is a hint of personal satisfaction in proving the Burgomaster wrong. In fact, his happiness can drive directly from his vindication against the Burgomaster who refused to follow Dr. Stockmann’s specification for building the baths. In the statement that Dr. Stockmann has prepared, the reader must inquire whether this statement is an explanation or an accusation. Dr. Stockmann is somewhat naive and innocent when he thinks that the Burgomaster will be pleased at this discovery. The act ends on a note of irony. Dr. Stockmann thinks that he is going to be honored as a hero and feels good that he served his town and fellow citizens well. It will be only a short time before he will be declared an enemy of the people. At the end of the first act, the problem has not yet been fully presented. Now it is only that the baths are unsanitary and the conditions of the baths must be changed or altered. Act I only presents the need of the baths to be cleansed. Act II begins to develop the problem with more implications. We are now able to see that the play is going to handle the broad subject of private vs. public morality. Or as the problem will later be developed, the conflict between personal integrity and social obligation. This idea will be more fully developed in later acts. This act presents out first hint of the public’s refusal to believe Stockmann. It comes from Stockmann’s father-in-law. He believes that Dr. Stockmann is slyly trying to avenge himself
An Enemy of People
77
against his brother by making the Burgomaster and the entire town council admit that they made a tremendous mistake. If Dr. Stockmann can do that, old Morton Kill will be happy because they had previously forced him off the town council. With the appearance of Hovstad, we see the liberal who is ready to jump at any cause and champion that cause as long as he thinks the cause will be popular and will increase circulation. With Aslaksen, we see the man of cautious good will. He wants to do everything with moderation and not offend anyone. He represents the “compact majority” –that group of people who have no opinions and who follow other like a heard of animals. When the Burgomaster appears, Dr. Stockmann is shocked to find out that his proposal will cost so much and will take so long to effect. The Burgomaster then is seen as a practical man who believes that the men in authority should decide everything. His view is that the individual freedom should be subjected to the demands of the authorities. This is, of course, a legitimate view, but Ibsen does not leave it a clash between two opposing ideological views. The Burgomaster’s views must be seen in terms of his personal involvement. If the news of the bath is made public, he as the authority will be seen to have made a mistake. This will be a personal slight. But also, if the news of the baths is made public, the town will suffer tremendous losses and will be virtually destroyed; thus, his duty as the chief magistrate of the town is to try to save the town. Thus as was Dr. Stockmann’s discovery tainted by his desire to avenge himself against the authorities, so now is the Burgomaster’s defense somewhat tinged with personal motives.
78
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Dr. Stockmann is still seen as somewhat the impractical visionary, who can see nothing except that the baths are dangerous and poisonous. It may be suggested that he is so confident in his views since he knows (or thinks) that the press and the compact majority are behind him. And under all circumstances, he is a man who does believe strongly in personal freedom and will not submit blindly to the rule of the authorities. Mr. Stockmann is seen in this scene as the eternal matriarch; that is, he is the eternal mother and wife figure whose main concern is with the personal welfare of (her) immediate family. At the end of the act, we find that perhaps the town will consider Dr. Stockmann an enemy of the society. This is, of course, ironic because Dr. Stockmann thought he was doing a great service to the community. It is his desire to serve his fellow man that hurts more than anything else. Unlike the Burgomaster who believes that people are like a herd and not worthy of consideration, Dr. Stockmann here believes in the potential capabilities of all the people and counts strongly on the general public to see his point of view. Act III is the changing point in the drama. Here we see the various motives of the characters examined under pressures and thus we find out who the real men of principles are. In the beginning of the act when Aslaksen and Hovstad think that the doctor’s discovery will be popular and beneficial and when they think it will provide an opportunity to get rid of the old authorities, they are supporting him. Later when they realize that it will be harmful to the town and therefore unpopular, they turn
An Enemy of People
79
against the doctor. Aslaksen is a man who does not wish to offend anyone and who wants to proceed with moderation. But more important, when his principles are confronted with the possibility that he will lose financially, the principles are no longer important. With Hovstad, we see in his discussion with Petra, that he is not a man of true principles. He publishes not what he believes in but what he thinks will increase circulation. Thus his allegiance to Dr. Stockmann stems not from a belief in the truth of Dr. Stockmann’s ideas, but from the hope that his cause will be a popular one and thus increase circulation. With the appearance of the Burgomaster, the theme of personal integrity and social obligation becomes dominant. The Burgomaster is attempting to save the town, but in doing so, he is also trying to preserve his image as the town’s foremost citizen. If the report is made public, it will destroy both the town and the Burgomaster’s reputation because he was responsible for the construction of the water pipes which cause all the trouble. Thus for the benefit of the town and his own personal integrity, he refuses to believe the truth of Dr. Stockmann’s report and hints that the doctor has always been impetuous and wild in his ideas. Dr. Stockmann is now seen as the impractical idealist. In striving to achieve the ideal or the perfectly moral solution, he ignores all practical advice and opposes everyone who would stand in his way. In other words, he is ready to carry his idealism to absurd degrees. Mrs. Stockmann is somewhat comic in these scenes. She is opposed to her husband’s plans until people turn against him.
80
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Then she is ready to stand by him simply because he is her husband. She doesn’t understand what is at stake here, but is nevertheless convinced that her husband is right even through a few moments earlier she was trying to get him to change. The act opens with Stockmann still convinced that he is working for the sake of the people: he obtains a hall in order to give lecture. Thus, this act pits the idealist against the common herd of people, those whom Stockmann wants to serve. Apparently, Stockmann wanted to give his speech about the baths. But the democratic principles of electing chairman for the committee and then entertaining a motion as to whether Dr. Stockmann should be heard changed the nature of the speech. He therefore delivers a tirade against the democratic processes and attempts to prove that the common man has no business having a voice in the government. He is, of course, still the idealist, but here the idealist is trapped in the involved processes of bureaucracy. He sees his idealism being defeated by the very people he wanted to help; thus, he attacks the people and the officials elected by the officials. The reader must realize that Stockmann’s speech is offensive. But he remains a sympathetic character because the purpose of his speech is noble. He is striving to realize his ideals without compromising his principles. Everyone else at the meeting has in one way or another compromised himself—has sold out for personal gain or to avoid a difficult conflict. But in his attack, we must step back and realize that Dr. Stockmann has carried idealism to its extreme. The question arises then: Is Dr. Stockmann an enemy of
An Enemy of People
81
the people? If we were to isolate Dr. Stockmann’s speech, that is, take it out of the context of all that went before, and if we were to hear only what the audience at Dr. Stockmann’s speech heard, then we would see that Dr. Stockmann’s present position is one that justifies his being called an enemy of the people. He has openly advocated that the people are not capable of voting correctly. He has insulted the common people and has referred to them in terms of a herd of animals. Thus, by this speech alone, Dr. Stockmann is an enemy of the people. But actually, we know that his attack is motivated by more noble reasons and only in his disillusionment does he make such heavy charge against the very people he wants to help. Act V is a practical or materialistic test of Dr. Stockmann’s idealism. In the last act, we saw Aslaksen and Hovstad react when they stood to lose something personally. This act now confronts Dr. Stockmann with great personal losses if he continues to assert his views. This test is necessary before we can formulate a complete view of Dr. Stockmann. Before he faces his test, he first learns that his views have caused Captain Horster to lose his ship and Petra to lose her position in the school. Furthermore he has faced his own dismissal from the baths. Thus when Old Morton Kill comes to him asking him to retract his charges or else all of his inheritance will go to charity, Dr. Stockmann is about ready to yield to the public opinion. He is prevented by the appearance of Hovstad and Aslaksen. When Dr. Stockmann sees that he can gain the admiration of his fellow townsmen by admitting that he engineered the entire plan so as to gain control of the stock of the
82
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
baths, this accusation (or this admiration) is worse than the rejection by the people. He therefore decides to stand by his idealistic views. Finally, we must note that Dr. Stockmann’s idealism is not consistent. In Act IV he denied that the common curs could be of any value to society. But in Act V, he sys he is going to take the common “street-curs” and educate them into the leading men of society who will then drive out all the bureaucrats. His saving factor, however, is his strong belief in that which is right. As with most problem plays, An Enemy of the People takes a specific situation and uses it to make a larger general statement about mankind. Here we have the specific problem of the bad water pipes at the new health baths. The question then is simply one of cleaning the baths. It is a matter of civic health and sanitation. From this specific situation, Ibsen then moves to the more complex problem of private versus public morality. Or to state it in other words, Ibsen is investigating the relationship between moral and ethical responsibility when seen against practical exigency. To present this problem, Ibsen creates an idealist in the person of Dr. Stockmann and has him diametrically opposed by his own brother who is the man of extreme practicality. In other words, Dr. Stockmann represents private and public morality while his brother, the Burgomaster, represents the practical aspect of life. The problem which perplexes many readers of this play is Ibsen’s apparent failure to make his position clear. But this was not Ibsen’s purpose. He is not offering a stated solution to his
An Enemy of People
83
problem, but instead, he is presenting a full measured discussion of the problem. The sensible man would assume a position somewhere between that of Dr. Stockmann and the Burgomaster. In his idealism, Dr. Stockmann forgets that the world moves by practical means. It is revealed early in the play that Dr. Stockmann conceived the idea of the baths but could never bring them to a practical completion. It took the Burgomaster to do that. Thus, Dr. Stockmann is seen essentially as a comic figure whose idealism blinds him to the common place practically of the world. But the burgomaster is equally as blinded to the ethical questions of the world. Therefore, after a thorough consideration of the ideas, the reader should take a stand somewhere between two extremes represented by the main characters. Aslaksen is the man of cautious good will. His constant comment involves “proceeding with moderation.” He afraid of offending anyone who is in authority, unless that person is some distant abstract person who cannot immediately affect him. He represents the compact majority who believes in civic progress so long as it does not involve any expense or effort. He is the type who would rather suffer any type of bad situation rather than get involved in a drastic change. Hovstad is the professional type of liberal who constantly wants to stir things up as long as he is not directly involved and will not be personally affected. His main concern is to increase the circulation of his paper, and for this purpose he will ignore any principle. He supports Dr. Stockmann as long as he thinks compact majority and the public are behind Dr. Stockmann. But as soon as it is known that the public will not support any idea
84
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
which is going to cost money, he turns against Dr. Stockmann and supports the Burgomaster. Mrs. Stockmann is a minor character who represents the eternal matriarch. Her interest is in the family. She does not care for civic causes, but when her husband is attacked by other people, she comes to his side even though she does not understand the principles behind the cause. The Burgomaster (Peter Stockmann) represents the old established order of things. He believes that authority should rest in the hands of the officials and that all individuals should be subjected to the rule of these authorities. He does not believe in personal or individual expressions. He is convinced that he is right and anyone opposed to him must be wrong. He tells Dr. Stockmann that “the individual must subordinate himself to society, or, more precisely, to the authorities whose business it is to watch over the welfare of the society.” He is, then, the reactionary who is afraid of any change because change implies a reevaluation of authority. The Burgomaster is not a man of strong ethical principles. Instead, he is the practical man who looks to see how something will bring a practical or material reward. He cannot conceive of the possibility that he might be wrong in anything. Thus, part of his opposition to Dr. Stockmann’s news about the baths is due to the fact that the Burgomaster was responsible for placing the water pipes in the wrong place. He is incapable of facing the fact that he made a tremendous error, and therefore, he must repress the news of the bad sanitary conditions so that his own reputation will be preserved.
An Enemy of People
85
Dr. Stockmann represents the extreme idealist who has no concept of the practical side of life. His idealism blinds him to the common procedures of everyday activity. As an idealist, Dr. Stockmann believes strongly in individual freedom and the right of every man to express himself freely. He cannot become a party to any dishonest or unethical act. Thus, he cannot bend in any sense of the word. He is accurately characterized as too impetuous. As soon as he finds out about the bad sanitary conditions at the baths, he immediately makes the news public and refuses to listen to any compromise and demands that the water pipes be relied. He does not try to convince the people of his view, but instead, goes directly and blindly at a demanded improvement. It is, therefore, his lack of tact and understanding of the practical issues which place him in such an awkward position. There is, however, a touch of jealous revenge in Dr. Stockmann’s actions. He was annoyed that the Burgomaster did not build the pipes according to the doctor’s original specifications, and thus he is delighted that he is able to prove the Burgomaster to be wrong. Furthermore, Dr. Stockmann’s idealism is somewhat muddled. He is not consistent. At one point he maintains that the common people have no right to a voice in the government. But this is what the Burgomaster had previously told the doctor and the doctor had stoutly asserted the right of every citizen to express his own views. Likewise, he suggests that the common people are like curs or impure animals and can never be educated to take a significant role in the development of a society. Yet at the end he is going to take some “street-curs” and educate them to run the wolves out of the government.
86
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Dr. Stockmann is saved as a character because he puts his principles above his own desires and gains. He is not tempted by financial rewards enough to deny the truth of the condition of the baths. He is thoroughly disgusted by the petty and dishonest interpretations placed on his actions. And as a man of great personal integrity, he spurns a large inheritance in order to maintain an ethical and moral responsibility to himself and to his community.
THE WILD DUCK By Henrik Ibsen Ibsen wrote this play in 1884 as an answer to An Enemy of the People, just as that play answered the critics of Ghosts. But in The Wild Duck, Ibsen seems to focus upon himself; at least that was the interpretation given to the play by its contemporary critics, as well as by many recent scholars. In Doctor Stockmann, Ibsen presents a well-intentioned idealist and reformer who is rather bumbling and easily taken advantage of. The message of that play centers on the necessity for truth and freedom, for which the Doctor would make any sacrifice needed, of himself, his family, and his town. In The Wild Duck Ibsen concerns himself with the life-lie or life-illusion which seems necessary to bolster up some people’s lives. The idealist in this play is Gregers Werle, whose stupid attempts to satisfy his craving for truth lead eventually to tragedy. The major difficulties in interpreting this play are two. To begin with, the plot seems, at first glance, to have no central character. A closer reading, however, suggests what Ibsen is trying to do. He attempts in this play to give an objective picture of a group of interrelated characters in a domestic scene. His attitude towards all the persons of his drama except Gregers Werle is detached. Only for the idealist Gregers does Ibsen reserve his scorn. Even the tragic conclusion of the play is handled with a degree of detachment that maintains the dominant comic rather than tragic tone. Although the play is basically a
88
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
comedy with serious overtones and a tragic conclusion. It is sardonic and often bitter, especially in the treatment of Gregers Werle. The second and more serious problem concerns the symbolism in the play. Ibsen himself remarked that he gave the critics a few things to fight about and interpret. Most of the squabbling has been over the meaning of the central image, the wild duck. The following are the most common interpretations: 1. It represent Gregers Werle, the idealist who fails. 2. It represents any such idealist whose aspirations are misplaced. 3. It represents Hialmar Ekdal, limited by marriage and parenthood, and saddled with a business (photography) in which he has no real interest. This interpretation is suggested by Gregers in the text. 4. It represents Ekdal Senior, broken in mind and weakened in body, whose only contact with the bright world of nature is in the model woods set up in Ekdal’s attic. 5. It represents Ibsen’s own reforming and moralizing spirit. 6. It represents the social castaways in the play: the outcast Gregers, the pretentious Hialmar, the tipsy play-hunter old Ekdal, the washed-out Doctor Relling, and the alcoholic theology student Molvik. Good arguments can be presented for any of the above interpretations, yet no one really presents the final word on the subject. The reason for this interpretative problem is that Ibsen developed a habit in his later plays of manipulating his symbols so as to give them plural values. The result is often confusing to the reader, and critics have sometimes considered this habit one of
The Wild Duck
89
the major structural faults of Ibsen’s later dramas. As usual, Ibsen gradually unfolds his exposition or disclosure of basic facts. We are introduced to the Werles and to Hialmar (his son, a photographer). At this point, the latter seems a shy and unobtrusive young man, obviously out of place since he was the thirteenth at the table. Mrs. Sorby’s warning to Werle about the bright lights, and the latter’s admission to his son about his failing eyesight anticipate the convention later to be divulged between the elder Werle and Hedwig, the Ekdals’ daughter. The discussion between the Werles is important for two reasons. It supplies the reader with needed information about Werle Senior’s relations with the Ekdals and Mrs. Sorby. Even more important is the light that is shed on young Werle’s character. His hatred for his father and near idolatry for the memory of his mother suggest his unbalanced psychological state. Thus Ibsen supplies him with the basic ingredients of an Oedipus complex. The frequent allusions in this act to Hedwig’s weak eyes reinforce the suggestion that she may be old Werle’s daughter. Gina, however, insists that the blindness is inherited from Hialmar’s mother. This is another of those things the author said the critics would squabble over. Hialmar’s flute-playing as much as his subsequent melancholy over Hedwig’s sight is evidence of how much he enjoys being the center of little family scenes of domestic happiness. When the topic turns to Hedwig he, perhaps subconsciously, becomes melancholy until the offer of beer turns the focus back upon him. Thus our shy and retiring Hialmar of the first act is seen to be very much of a poseur (one who affects a
90
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
particular pose to impress others). This impression is verified by the elaborate lies he tells about his conversation at the dinner. Old Ekdal’s description of the shooting of the wild duck is important, because it forms the basis of most of the symbols later used by Gregers in speaking of his quest. Gregers’ mime begins to speak in mysteries. His message goes completely over the head of Hialmar, but Hedwig at least realizes that there is some hidden meaning behind much of what Gregers says. The final scene is an excellent comment on Hialmar’s / Gregers’ complete inability to make fire, and the mess he makes of his room suggest the futility and destructiveness of what Doctor rolling later refers to as his “claim of the ideal.” Hialmar’s utter indifference to productive work is completely in character. Although he refers to himself as a hardworking breadwinner, it is obvious that Gina and even Hedwig with her poor eyesight do more work than he does. The sympathy that the Gregers seem to feel for each other prepares the way for the young girl’s assuming the role that the idealist suggests to her in the last act, her last supreme self sacrifice. The warning that Hialmar gives her about the pistol is a technical preparation for Hedwig’s suicide. The fact of the gun’s being ready and loaded is established, as well as her knowledge of its location. Hialmar refers to his after-dinner periods of meditation on his invention, but Gina always simply calls this period his nap time. Hialmar’s reaction to Gregers’ prompting and suggestions is one of uneasiness, for he prefers to hear only pleasant things. His curiosity finally gets the better of him when he goes out for the walk, although his motive seems to be more to help Gregers than to learn anything.
The Wild Duck
91
Young Werle’s determination to place Hialmar’s marriage on a basis of truth reminds us of A Doll’s House, Ghosts, and Pillars of Society, all dealing with marriages not based on truth. Hialmar, however seems quite content with what he has; his only concern is to avoid unpleasantness. The final comment of Doctor Relling requires some explanation. The original reads “enakut retskaffenheber” the usual translation of “acute integrity “or probity “or “uprightness" is hardly adequate. The most brilliant translation of this phrase is by the critic and scholar Otto Heller, who calls it “acute rectitudinitis.” Although Hialmar is perfectly sincere in his confrontation of his wife, he is extremely melodramatic. What he cannot understand is her comparatively unemotional reaction to the situation. As she puts it, she was too busy making a home for him and running the business to worry about the basis of their marriage. Hialmar’s love of theatrical poses is most evident in his very dramatic tearing of the letter. What he needs to do is to dramatize himself, to create a scene in which he is, as always, the center, then enjoy it, then to relapse into ordinary routines again. The doctor’s warning about Hedwig appears a little forced. It is hardly called for, but it does prepare for her suicide. Ibsen is always careful to lay all of the necessary groundwork for his conclusions. Gregers’ surprise at Hialmar’s ungenerous conduct is to be expected, since he still admires Hialmar, considering him a wild duck capable of soaring high, in a spiritual sense. But young Ekdal as we have already seen is too much attached to his beer and bread and butter to fly in any sense
92
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
of the word. At the end of the act, Gregers literally intends that Hedwig should sacrifice her wild duck. But as early as the end of the second act, Hedwig is aware that he often means more than he says. It is possible, then, that further reflection upon his words may induce thoughts of suicide. The principal theme of the play is stated at the beginning of this act, after Relling attempts to open Gregers’ eyes as to what sort of man Hialmar really is. Young Werle admits that he can only fulfill his “claim of the ideal” outside himself. Gregers is thus the opposite of Brand, who sought his demand of the ideal within himself and found it in his final sacrifice. Young Werle, on the other hand, is only able to sacrifice others. Relling then remarks on how essential the “life-lie” is to a man—Hialmar’s greatest life-lie is his invention. Even Gregers, who insists on ideal truth, has a life-lie: his blind admiration of his former schoolmate Hialmar. What Ibsen suggests at this point is that the ideal truth thought to be beneficial may often be dangerous. Men need their little illusion in order to adjust to their lives. Hialmar’s conduct during this act leaves no doubt about his character. He builds up a little melodrama, turning Hedwig away and preparing to leave forever. His self-pity can be seen in the melancholy picture he draws of himself and his father looking for shelter in the storm. The lack of a hat settles that matter, since Hialmar is averse to taking unnecessary risks. All the time he talks about leaving, he drinks coffee and east bread and butter and even asks for more butter. His pasting together the letter is almost a stroke of genius on Ibsen’s part.
The Wild Duck
93
Dramatic irony is evident when Gregers tells Hialmar that Hedwig may make a sacrifice for her father’s sake. The sacrifice she finally makes is not what Gregers is thinking of. Also ironic is, Hialmar’s remark about his great love for Hedwig. By now it is fairly obvious that the only person he ever really loved is himself. At the end of the play we see more evidence of his selfishness when he asks why this was done to him. Gregers’ final lines suggest either that he contemplates suicide or that he now finally realizes he is a superfluous person, the thirteenth at table. Ibsen gives us no definite clue, but Gregers’ earlier refusal of money from his father was motivated by his feeling no need for it, since what little he has will last his time. The ending of this play would be tragic if it were not for the focus on Hialmar’s selfish posing. Ibsen thus maintains the comic spirit over the tragic, but the comic is rather sardonic, especially when Relling is the spokesman as he is at the end. Gregers Werle is an impractical idealist whose sole concern is to present his “claim of the ideal.” This urge manifests itself in a desire to place the Edkals’ marriage on a firm basis of fact. He idolizes Hialmar Ekdal, whom he considers graced with a noble soul and a high mind. Ibsen gives us some explanation of Gregers’ neurosis. The young man was raised by his mother to hate his father. The sympathy he feels for Hialmar may in part be due to the latter’s having been raised by two maiden aunts. Hialmar Ekdal is a true cousin of Peer Gynt, quite happy to loll about the studio while his ego is fed by his wife and daughter as well as by the admiring Gregers. Young Ekdal likes the sound of his own voice and incessantly moralizes on his position as
94
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
worker, breadwinner, and future inventor, none of which he has ever been or is ever likely to be. He inclines toward the center. As we learn from Doctor Relling, Hialmar was brought up to be admired as the center of attraction. Gina, his wife, is basically a sound, steady type, despite her past affair with Werle Senior. Her bad grammar and inept choice of words display her lack of education, yet she keeps the Ekdal household together by feeding her husband’s stomach as well as his ego, while at the same time she takes care of the family business. Hedwig, the Ekdals’ daughter, is the only true idealist in the play, since she alone is willing to make a sacrifice for others. Her near blindness, like that of her probable real father, Werle Senior, is symbolic. This defect may be taken as representing the unseeing lives of the Ekdals, happy in their own life-lies or illusions, just as old Werle’s poor eyesight is indicative of his moral blindness. Old Werle is reminiscent both of Consul Bernick (Pillars of Society) and Chamberlain Alving (Ghosts). A former libertine, he is equally unscrupulous in business. Old Ekdal went to jail in his place as a result of one of his illegal business deals. Werle salves his conscience by paying the broken old man a high price for the little copying he does. Doctor Relling and Molvik are two examples of social wreckage, like Krogstad in A Doll’s House. The Doctor, however, despite the ruin he made of his own life, is still intelligent, and, like Doctor Stockman (An Enemy of the People), is Ibsen’s own mouthpiece at times. Ibsen attempts without success to give added dimension to Relling’s character by alluding to an earlier attachment with Mrs. Sorby.
HEDDA GABLER By Henrik Ibsen Beginning with The Wild Duck (1884), Ibsen turned away from dramas of social significance to devote his energies to psychological analyses of character. His next two plays, Rosmersholm (1886) and The Lady from the Sea (1888), are thus more concerned with inner emotional conflicts than with social or political themes. Like The Wild Duck, both of these plays afford penetrating analyses of character in Ibsen’s usual fashion of disclosing past facts, one by one, that are comparable with their predecessor in the emphasis placed on symbolism, which is so complex that the plays are difficult to interpret. In Hedda Gabler, however, Ibsen returned for the last time to the realistic technique of the great social plays. The play is written with almost complete objectivity. Symbolism is absent, except for Hedda’s thin hair and her pistols, and the recurrent phrase “vine leaves in his hair.” But these are so transparent compared to the white horses and the sea in Rosmersholm, or to the wild duck, that they hardly qualify as symbols. Some critics prefer to regard them simply as marks of character. Although the major emphasis in Hedda Gabler is on intimate psychological analysis, it is not hard to find at least some social significance. Hedda represents an emancipated woman who, like Mrs. Alving in Ghosts, finds herself with a great deal of intellectual freedom, yet with emotions that have failed to keep pace in their development. Hedda, then, is left without any outlets
96
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
for her emotions, which appear almost dried up. Accordingly she has no opportunity ever to find herself, to come to any understanding of herself, as Mrs. Have ruled her, or as Peer Gynt does, when he finally sees what may be regarded as a study of the effects of the new emancipation that patterned Hedda’s character after an eighteen-year-old Austrian, Emilie Bardach, who intended to devote her life to taking married men away from their wives. In 1889, Ibsen was captivated by her for a brief time. He kept up a lively and sometimes passionate correspondence, but he soon terminated their friendship and settled down to an objective study of her. The result was Hedda Gabler (1890). The characters of George the scholar and Hedda his wife are particularly well delineated in this act. George is sufficiently involved in his work to take his aunt’s hints as meaning his library. He also remarks on the quantity of notes he was able to take during their wedding trip. It is easy to envision George and Hedda spending their honeymoon going from one library to another. Hedda’s neurotic disposition is clear in the episode over the bonnet. As she confides to Brack in the second act, she only pretended to think it was the servant’s hat. Hedda’s urge to injure motivates the greater part of her conversation with her husband. Her whole attitude is one of condescending tolerance, and her caustic remarks could only go unnoticed by a man like George Tesman. The manner in which she repulses Aunt Jualian’s attentions and then practically forces herself upon Mrs. Elvsted, shows her intensely and completely selfish nature. Eilert Lovborg the brilliant but alcoholic scholar, formerly a friend of Hedda and
Hedda Gabler
97
George, is introduced. The references to Hedda’s thin hair and Mrs. Thea Elvsted’s–a former schoolgirl with Hedda, and at one time a friend of George—abundant blond hair are very significant. Ibsen suggests that their capacities for life and love are matched ritually arid, although intellectually and social brilliant; Thea Elvsted, although a little inclined towards stupidity, leaves her husband to follow Lovborg mainly because of her comparatively greater emotional capacity, which was unfulfilled in her loveless marriage to the Sheriff. Thea’s reference to the lady with the pistols and Hedda’s comment pave the way for the conclusion of the play, as does Hedda’s leaving to play with her pistols at the end of the act. Another and more subtle example of this sort of dramatic preparation is George’s persistent mistake in referring to Thea Elvsted by her maiden name, Miss Rysing. It anticipates the budding partnership between the two at the end of the play. Hedda’s utter lack of sympathy for George’s dismay over the competition for the professorship as well as her bitter disappointment over their financial restrictions are clear proof that the marriage was one of convenience only. Hedda’s obvious ability to shoot is another example of dramatic preparation, since Hedda later lends one pistol to Lovborg and shoots herself with the other. Her dialogues with Brack, a friend of the Tesmans, reveal her apparent incapability of feeling deep emotions. She is disgusted by the word “love,” and knowledge of her own pregnancy, which George and Aunt Juliana already suspect, makes the though of motherhood repellent to her. Hedda’s boredom is the result of her inability or complete
98
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
unwillingness to commit herself emotionally to anyone or anything. It is symptomatic of a pathologically self-centered nature. Hedda’s earlier friendship again suggests her fear of emotional commitment. Her affair with Lovborg was never anything more than a Platonic relationship, devoid of anything sensual. When it did promise to become “serious,” then Hedda threatened him with her pistols. These pistols are thus Hedda’s symbolic weapon of her personal boredom; she takes the pistols out and fires them, as she does in the direction of Brack, whose intentions are not acceptable to her even if his conversation is. The reference to “vine leaves in his hair” of course refers to a manner of self-decoration common in classic times, particularly in the worship of the Greek god of wine, Dionysus, and his Roman counterpart Bacchus. For an interesting if rather forced reading of Hedda Gabler’s character as “Dionysiac,” the reader should refer to G. Wilson Knight’s Henrik Ibsen. The chief significance for us is that Hedda is looking for Eilert to do something beautiful, noble, and great, for her and through her help. We are reminded at this point of Gregers Werle in The Wild Duck, who also was compelled by his own spiritual aridity to seek his ideal outside himself. Another significance of this phrase is that Hedda, by so insisting on Eilert’s performance, betrays a well-concealed depth of emotion in herself. Her taut, overrestrained feelings also show in her nervous habits like clenching her hands or rapping on windowpanes. The most obvious betrayal of these inner feelings was her momentary lapse when she told Lovborg that her greatest cowardice years ago was not in failing
Hedda Gabler
99
to shoot him. Her meaning is that it was more cowardly of her to send him away, thus rejecting her own feeling for him. Hedda’s sending Eilert off to the party despite the danger of a relapse into his former alcoholism cannot be interpreted as anything beautiful, although she insists on his returning with vine leaves. Her motives are mixed. On the surface, she is torn by jealousy of Thea Elvsted, who is able to inspire Lovborg to write great books. A more subtle motive, however, is connected with her irresistible urges, as in the bonnet incident, to do injury. These feelings, which in the case of Lovborg may be in effect urges to hurt a loved one, have a basis in her emotional and sexual frigidity. Although she seems to have feelings deep within, she is incapable of expressing them, and horrified by the thought of their development into anything more substantial. In a word, she is afraid of sex when it involves emotion, and only disgusted with it when emotion is not present, as with Tesman. George’s state of mind when he enters with Lovborg’s manuscript is not difficult to perceive. He cannot help admitting to Hedda his jealousy of Eilert’s talent. His delay in returning the manuscript and his decision not to tell anyone, brought it home or what he intends to do with it. Brack’s motives are very obvious. He insists that he will be the only “cock-in-the-basket,” and to assure his comfortable arrangement with Hedda and George, he will remove any possible intruders. Hence he is interested enough in Lovborg’s doings to get him drunk at the party and then afterward finds out what he did. Brack’s designs upon Hedda are quite evident, and she fully realizes what he wants when she tells him that she is glad he has
100
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
no hold over her. Hedda’s destroying of the manuscript is prompted largely by Thea Elvsted’s and then Lovborg’s references to the manuscript as their child. Hedda cannot bear the thought that anyone could have more power to inspire Lovborg than she herself. Therefore she first gives him a pistol to shoot himself, and then destroys the last evidence of his relationship with Mrs. Elvsted. At the beginning of the act Hedda is dressed in black, which represents her mourning for Eilert, who she hopes is to die beautifully. George’s reaction when she admits burning the manuscript is particularly enlightening. He betrays himself not really as grief-stricken as perhaps he should be. His feelings are tinged slightly with joy, so that his happiness overflows when Hedda implies that she is pregnant. Mrs. Elvsted’s sudden production of Lovborg’s notes is one of the more obvious faults in the plot of Hedda Gabler. It is extremely unlikely that any woman in her situation would carry a large package of notes everywhere she goes. Hedda’s guest for something beautiful, earlier symbolized by the phrase “vine leaves in his hair,” now is concentrated in desire to learn of Lovborg’s beautiful death. That his death can seem so lovely to her now is a clear indication of where her own thoughts for herself are beginning to turn, as is her inability to refrain from comments upon his death even in front of George, is a sign that she is now even more aware of her surroundings. When she smuggles the pistol into the inner room, it is obvious that she contemplates suicide.
Hedda Gabler
101
The end of the play presents a powerful scene in which Hedda seems to make one futile bid for acceptance. She refuses Brack’s offer of a genteel adultery and her answer to the Judge’s remark on its being inevitable is ironic, since she has already been contemplating what now seems even more inevitable, her own death. The ease with which George and Mrs. Elvsted work together arouses Hedda’s jealousy, which she controls with great effort while she strokes Thea Elvsted’s hair, the hair she had years ago at school once threatened to burn. When she is told she can be off no help she perhaps further realizes her loneliness. Hedda’s long pent-up emotions burst forth in the wild dance she plays on the piano. Her answer, that after his she will be silent, is another example of dramatic irony, since she plans the total silence of death. The final motive for Hedda’s suicide comes with George’s simple suggestion that Judge Brack entertain her in the evening. Unable to face Brack now that he has “a hold” over her, she ends her life. The judge’s final comment is typical of his thoroughly conventional outlook, but it also recalls Hedda’s comment to Mrs. Elvsted in the first act. When the latter mentions an unknown woman who once threatened Eilert Lovborg with a pistol. Hedda replies, “no one does that sort of thing here.” Hedda Gabler was thus just as much a slave of convention as Judge Brack. Hedda Gabler is an extremely neurotic woman. Intellectually she is brilliant compared to her husband, whom she treats with thinly veiled contempt. Her upbringing as General Gabler’s daughter prepared her for a life of bright, gay social
102
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
entertainment which as the wife of a scholar she cannot afford. Partly because of this upbringing, she has gradually developed into a coldhearted, perverse woman, utterly incapable of showing affection for anyone. So disciplined are her emotions that she can no longer entertain any affection for a former friend, Eilert Lovborg. What should have been love in Hedda becomes a passion to see him do something she would consider beautiful. But her idea of beauty, like her own character, is perverted. His death, if done nobly, would seem beautiful to her. This concentration upon death, first Eilert’s and then her own, is indicative of the spiritual emptiness of Hedda Gabler. In reassessing herself, as she seems to do after Eilert’s unlovely death, she catches a glimpse of her own emptiness and purposelessness. Her suicide is then almost inevitable. Despite her external coldness, Hedda does have a potentiality for feeling. But her emotions have been suppressed for so long that they can only display themselves in grotesquely altered for so long that they can only display themselves in grotesquely altered forms. Hence she is satanically jealous of Thea Elvsted, contemptuous of her husband, occasionally abusive to Aunt Juliana, and not very careful with her toys, the pistols. Finally, whatever emotion she feels toward Eilert is expressed in the destruction of the manuscript, a symbol of his relationship with another woman, and in her wish for his death. All of these expressions of emotion are in the form of irresistible urges, as for example, her final wild piano-playing just before her death. Her suicide may be viewed as the final manifestation of a deep-seated death wish (intense longing for self-destruction),
Hedda Gabler
103
which is symbolized by her playing with her pistols. Like many neurotic women, Hedda is intensely selfcentered. Lovborg, for example, is important to her only in that she might be able to influence him to do something beautiful for her. His death affects her only in so far as it gives her a feeling of liberation to know that something meeting her twisted standards of beauty can occur. George Tesman is a caricature (exaggerated comic portrait) of a scholar. His intellect is well adapted to what he calls his “special subjects,” but he is no match for Hedda’s subtlety. He spent his honeymoon collecting research materials for his projected history of the domestic industries of Barbant in the Middle Ages. His days are spent in reading, studying and writing, whereas his wife would prefer brilliant entertainment and sparkling conversations. George Tesman is far too conventional and stodgy to participate in either. His favorite expression, “Fancy that!” is a good example of his conversational ability, and is indicative of his completely colorless personality. Eilert Lovborg is a less successful characterization. He belongs to a personality-type which Ibsen has already thoroughly explored; he is representative of the social wreckage in earlier plays, such as Krogstad in A Doll’s House, and Relling in The Wild Duck. His motive for destroying himself by returning to drink is rather conventionally melodramatic. He feels that Thea Elvsted by following him has shown lack of faith in his reformation, and, goaded by Hedda, he proves that Thea was right. He affords good contrast to George Tesman, for while the latter is conventional and talented, Lovborg is unconventional and inspired.
104
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Thea Elvsted is a foil or contrasting character to Hedda. She has abundant blond hair of which Hedda is wildly jealous. The hair symbolizes Mrs. Elvsted’s capacity for emotion and for partaking fully of life; while Hedda’s thin hair reflects her own emotional aridity.
A DOLL’S HOUSE By Henrik Ibsen Perhaps the most important corrective that can be applied to Ibsen is his own statements twenty years after the play opened, when he was saluted by the Norwegian Association for Women’s Rights as the creator of Nora: “I have been more of a poet and less of a social Philosopher than most people have been inclined to believe. I Can’t claim the honor of ever having worked consciously for Women’s rights. I’m not even sure I know what they are. To me It has seemed a matter of human rights.” This disclaimer is important because it broadens the theme rather than denying that Nora’s situation makes a statement on the position of women. Nora is certainly the protagonist, but as Ibsen implies, that does not mean that she alone carries the themes of the play. scholars today generally agree that the title used for the present translation is incorrect though in common use since it derives directly from the first English version of the play. A Doll House, referring to a child’s toy, is the literal meaning of Ibsen’s words, and more accurately reflects the situation in which Nora, Torvald, their children and servants, and to some extent their visitors exist: a prettified imitation of a home and a marriage. It focuses less on Nora and does not imply so strongly that the “house” is her possession. While her noble, criminal act has presumably made it possible for Torvald to survive and even thrive, not even Nora supposes that she is the possessor of the
106
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
home (clearly, when she departs, she wants to take nothing of Torvald’s with her.) As to who is responsible for the doll-house condition of their marriage, the reader must recognize that it is a mutual creation. After criticizing her financial irresponsibility, Torvald insists “I don’t want you any different from just what you are –my own sweet little songbird;” Nora is no less conscious of the pretenses required to maintain their play family when she tells Mrs. Linde that she might tell Torvald of her life-saving act “when I’m no longer young and pretty […] I mean when Torvald no longer feels about me the way he does now, when he no longer thinks it’s fun when I dance for him and put on costumes and recite for him.” They are both aware that their marriage is founded on childish role-playing, but at the opening of the play neither wants to change that-and it seems, with Torvald’s business success, they will never need to do so. But there are stirrings in Nora, as she tells Mrs. Linde that someday she would like to tell Torvald of her sacrifice for him, and as she tells her and Dr. Rank that like a mischievous child she wants Torvald to hear her say a naughty word. These are the stirrings toward rowing out of her child’s world that provide the impetus for the plot. The plot gets underway as a consequence of one of the many ironies that fill the play: Torvald’s promotion, which promises the happiness that money is presumed by the Helmers to buy, motivates both Krogstad and Mrs. Linde to become involved in the life of this house, and these two influential outsiders precipitate Nora’s self-examination and her final decision. Both of them enter the action with good intentions and with financial
A Doll’s House
107
difficulties, paralleling Nora’s situation of years before: Krogstad needs to improve his position in the bank and rehabilitate his name for the sake of his growing children, and Mrs. Linde needs a job and a sense of being useful to others. Krogstad’s villainy develops as he is thwarted and then scorned, while Mrs. Linde’s desire to help leads her to push Nora toward the full revelation of the past so that their marriage can be re-established on firm ground then and , by marrying, resolve their own situations and remove themselves form the life of the Helmers. Much of the action of the play involves Nora’s efforts to maintain her secret, putting herself in conflict with Mrs. Linde’s principle of honesty and at the mercy of Krogstad’s blackmail. She thus creates a dilemma for herself out of her two desires (to outgrow her child-bride role and show that she has been mature and responsible, and to maintain her presumed innocence and make the crime). The role of Dr. Rank in this action is to shed light on the dilemma Nora faces. As friend and confidant, he is a pillar of the household, both Torvald’s best friend and the person with whom Nora can talk of her hopes and affections. But under the pressure of Krogstad’s demands, Nora desperately, but playfully, turns to Dr. Rank for financial help and her coquetry leads him to declare his love, which makes it impossible for her to pursue their intimacy. On the other hand, the doctor’s fatal illness cuts him off from further friendship with Trovald (Rank knows that his friend is too immature to stand up to the ordeal of watching death). With their only friend gone, the Helmers are forced into the intimacy of the final scene. Is Nora’s transformation from child to adult too sudden to
108
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
be plausible? In one sense, the question is impertinent: we should ask instead, does her change represent a vital, human truth? Her change occurs in the space of three hours in a theatrical performance, in the space of about 36 hours of elapsed time in the dramatized action, and at a rather late point in the life of a woman with three children. However, those three “clocks” by which we measure this dramatic event all have in common a literalism about the relationship of personality to action. They ask, that is, for an examination of literal psychological causalities rather than for an analysis of a realistic drama. For we must not confuse “realistic” with “real” or “literal.” In a realistic play, the pertinent questions should be: Do people make self-discoveries that change the course of their actions? Is Nora sufficiently characterized to explain how the events that are dramatized (and those from the past that are called into the present action as influences) can account for a change in her? Does her change embody Ibsen’s themes? The answer to these questions is “yes.” And what does the future hold for Nora and Torvald? This, too, is an impertinent question, for of course there is no “future” after the final curtain. We should ask, rather, with what feelings Ibsen leaves the audience. Do we want Torvald to discover himself and the errors that have led him to his isolation? Do we believe that Nora has the courage to seek out the meaning of her life without the comfortable hypocrisies she deserts?
CANDIDA By George Bernard Shaw Shaw devotes an ample paragraph to a description of the Reverend James Mavor Morell as he is opening his morning’s letters. The energy and enthusiasm of the forty-year-old parson are underscored, as are his geniality and considerate manners, but notice is taken of his unsubtle features and that he is “a great baby, pardonably vain of his powers and unconsciously pleased with himself.” Miss Proserpine Garnett, his secretary, is “a brisk little woman of about thirty.” Candida supplies a bit more exposition as she explains to her father (to whom she is only “Candy”) who Eugene is. “A dear boy,” as she calls him, Eugene had been discovered by James (some four months earlier in the summer, sleeping on the Embankment (of the Thames River). Eugene, erroneously believing that he had no money at all, was befriended by James. Burgess cannot hide his excitement upon learning that Eugene is an aristocrat, the nephew of an Earl. Eugene’s threatening is by way of preamble to his declaration: “I love your wife.” And to James’s attempts at laughing this off as “calf love,” he accuses the husband of “complacent superiority.” But even though James begins to be shaken by the poet’s impassioned candor, he still cannot “put aside all that cant,” as Eugene suggests. In effect, he goes on preaching to an “unimpressed and remorseless” Eugene, whose “boyish crudity” is noteworthy. In other terms, the Realist poet
110
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
effectively confronts the Idealist parson. Notice should be taken of Eugene’s way of characterizing Candida at this point: “A woman with a great soul, craving for reality, truth, freedom.” Thus Eugene himself is portrayed in Candida, even if Candida, the object of his adoration, is not. Burgess wonders about Eugene’s sanity; G. K. Chesterton wondered about the propriety of ascribing such reaction as Shaw does to Eugene when he is apprised of Candida’s menial chores. In his readable George Bernard Shaw, written early in the century, Chesterton considers this detail “completely and disastrously false to the whole nature of falling in love.” According to Chesterton, Shaw, because of “his great heresy of looking at emotions from the outside,” makes Eugene “a cold-blooded prig at the very moment when he is trying, for his own dramatic purposes, to make him a hot-blooded lover.” Chesterton’s argument is that “no boy in love with a beautiful woman would ever feel disgusted when she peeled potatoes or trimmed lamps. He would like her to be domestic. He would simply feel that the potatoes had become poetical and the lamps gained an extra light. This may be irrational; but we are not talking of rationality, but of the psychology of first love.” Chesterton concludes his amusing drubbing of this part of Shaw’s anti-artistic program by stating: “for dramatic purposes, G.B.S., even if he despises romance, ought to comprehend it. But then, if once he comprehended romance, he would not despise it.” “Here is one of the most audacious speeches in any modern play,” wrote critic James Huneker, of Candida’s explanation. “It has been passed over by most English critics,” he added, “who
Candida
111
saw in Candida merely an attempt to make a clergyman ridiculous, not realizing that the theme is profound and farreaching, the question put being no more and no less than: Shall a married man accept his wife’s love without working for it, without deserving it?” This “audacious” speech was not passed over by the American playwright Robert Anderson, who scored a Broadway success with his play Tea and Sympathy, in which a married woman, perhaps five years younger than Candida, does give her shawl, goodness and purity to a young man, the age of Eugene, who is not loved as he ought to be. Appropriately, the young man in the Anderson play, asks the woman, whether she—a former actress—had ever acted in any of Shaw’s plays. He especially wants to know whether she had ever played the role of Candida. She had, and he asks if she thought Candida did right to send Eugene away. The woman, who is married to one of his schoolmasters, replies: “Well Shaw made it seem right. Don’t you think?” The Anderson play is concerned with a topic, homosexuality, that was not the concern of Shaw in Candida (or in any other of his sixty plays); but basically it dramatizes the sympathy the woman feels for “the boy” who adores her—a sympathy that grows as he is made to feel (by his school generally) that he may be homosexual. Shaw’s Candida asks her husband whether Eugene will forgive her for not teaching him the value of love. Anderson’s Laura tells her husband that she feels guilty at having failed to teach his student Tom the value of love. Moreover, since Laura is not restrained as Candida is by love for her husband (Laura tells her husband she is leaving him forever),
112
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
she enters Tom’s room at the end of the play, bolts the door, unbuttons the top button of her blouse, seats herself along side Tom in the bed, brings his hands “toward her open blouse, as the lights slowly dim out … and … the curtain falls.” In effect: an exercise in how to be totally un-Shavian while writing a variation on a Shavian (Candida) theme. The pure fool Eugene fancies he is witnessing a tragedy. The parson manages to recover himself. The second act curtain falls on a resolute and forceful Reverend James Mavor Morell. At first, however, he moves in the direction of impatiens when Lexy expostulates with him about his breaking his engagement to speak for the Guild of St. Matthew. Fiercely, he complains about people who “think I am a talking machine to be turned on for their pleasure every evening of my life.” Interestingly, apropos of the “talking machine,” Shaw was also known as “the writing machine (for that is what G. B. S. is).” It is possible that parson Morel comes to resign himself to being a talking machine even as author Shaw has resigned himself to being a writing machine; at any vent, remembering his wife’s gentle taunts, he refers to her phrase “Prossy’s complaint.” To Burgess’s asking what is wrong with Prossy, Lexy replies, “I’m afraid she’s a little out of her mind sometime.” Thus, with his comic character Burgess, we reach the grand finale of the comedy routine that Shaw entered upon in Act I: “Four in the sameouse!” cries the businessman, overwhelmed by this contagion of madness. Eugene would seem to be a symbolist poet. Much of his dialogue early in this Act is fairly clouded with symbols— certainly the Morells find it so. Despite his fanciful allusions,
Candida
113
however, he and Candida are definitely not lovers, as were Tristan and Isolt, and there is no woodland grotto. The two are sitting in chairs beside the still-burning fire of a Vicarage hearth in London. At least they are till the moment Candida expresses a desire to talk and invites the poet to sit nearer to her on the hearth-rug. Her invitation might well have dashed most poets and most men: “talk moonshine as you usually do. I want to be amused.” Shaw tells us that Eugene accepts “half in terror, half enraptured.” Stretching out on the hearth-rug he throws his head back across her knees and looks up at her—“a great grown-up wicked deceiver,” in the cajoling words of his hostess. When she is asked by the poet, who is soon “on his knees, with his hands clasped and his arms on her lap,” if he may say “some wicked things” to her, Candida gives a negative answer. Here, the stage directions merit close attention. Candida replies “without the least fear or coldness, and with perfect respect for his passion, but with a touch of her wise-hearted maternal humor.” Instead, she asks him to say anything he really and truly feels. The one word he knows that does not belong to some attitude or other is the one he keeps repeating softly: “Candida.” Every utterance of her name is “a prayer to you,” he tells Candida, who asks if it doesn’t make him happy to be able to pray. To his “yes,” she assures him that “that happiness is the answer to your prayer. Do you want anything more?” Eugene’s reply, made a moment before James’s return, is: “No: I have come into heaven, where want is unknown.” Eugene desires nothing more; he does not desire to consummate his love; his heaven is indeed spiritual. Numerous
114
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
poets and other writers could be quoted at length in their praise of the passion of ideal love. Eugene is to allude further to it himself to the husband who views with gravity a scene that might well have shocked another parson. But James is as self-contained as Candida and Eugene are unembarrassed. The playwright summarily arranges an exchange of views between the two men only. He has Candida march off to the kitchen to tell the servant Maria she may retire, for the others are off supping somewhere. The husband’s suspense keeps mounting in proportion to the poet’s failure to satisfy James’s curiosity about what has passed during his absence. Clearly, however, the poet no longer views the parson’s decision to leave him alone with Candida as brave and beautiful; he now regards it as “heroics,” which, he adds, are infectious. He too has succumbed to heroics. According to Eugene, his two-hour reading stint has been his heroic way of “standing outside the gate of Heaven, and refusing to go in.” Learning that his wife could not bear being read to any longer, James takes up what seems to be the poet’s language of sexual symbolism: “And you approached the gate of Haven at last?” Eugene’s answer brings us back to the poker, now transformed into “a flaming sword that turned every way so that I couldn’t go in; for I saw,” he continues, “that that gate was really the gate of Hell.” Thus sexual consummation is equated with the infernal, even as Candida is equated with the angelic (“she became an angel”). The “flaming sword” was the conscience of the worshiper of this angel. But the angel’s husband mundanely surmises with triumph, “She repulsed you!” –a conjecture greeted with contempt by the young poet, who states that had she done
Candida
115
that he would never have seen that he “was in Heaven already.” Much ink of speculation over these two lines has flowed since they were set down. Needless to say, the playwright’s own comments on the matter are the best of the lot, even though he was careful to indicate that his is not the only way of looking at it. “Everybody who buys the book,” Shaw conceded, “may fit it with an ending to suit his own taste.” Yet as early as April 1904, in a letter to James Hunker, Shaw was suggesting that Candida makes a man of Eugene, finally, “by showing him his own strength— that David must do without poor Uriah’s wife. And then she pitches in her picture of the home, the onions, and the tradesmen, and the cosseting of big baby Morell. The New York hausfrau thinks it a little paradise; but the poet rises up and says, ‘Out, then, into the night with me’ –Tristan’s holy night. If his greasy fool’s paradise is happiness, then I give it to you with both hands, ‘life is nobler than that.’ That is the ‘poet’s secret.’ The young things in front weep to see the poor boy going out lonely and broken-hearted in the cold night to save the proprieties of New England Puritanism; but he is really a god going back to his heaven, proud, unspeakably contemptuous of the ‘happiness’ he envied in the days of his blindness, clearly seeing that he has higher business on hand than Candida. She has a little quaint intuition of the completeness of his cure; she says, “he has learnt to do without happiness.” Much later, in a reply to Henry Charles Duffin’s interpretation of the “secret” in his Quintessence of Bernard Shaw of 1920, Shaw wrote that “the secret in the poet’s heart’ is the one you descried as the most probable: that is, that the domestic life is
116
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
not a poet’s destiny: Life is nobler than that. The starry night, and not the cozy room with the paraffin lamp, is the place for him. Your alternative solution that ‘sooner or later she will come to me after all’ is wildly silly.” In 1920 a query about the secret made by students at Rugsby elicited another such Shavian response: “The secret is very obvious after all—provided you know what a poet is. What business has a man with the great destiny of a poet with the small beer if domestic comfort and cuddling and petting at the apron-string of some dear nice woman? Morel cannot do without it: it is the making of him; without it he would be utterly miserable and perhaps go to the devil. To Eugene, the stronger of the two the daily routine of it is nursery slavery, swaddling clothes, mere happiness instead of exaltation—an atmosphere in which poetry dies. When Candida brings him squarely face to face with it, his heaven rolls up like a scroll; and he goes out proudly into the majestic and beautiful kingdom of the starry night. Read the scene over with that in your heads, and every word of it will come right. Read it with the sentimental delusion that the poet is going to drown himself because he cannot have the other fellow’s wife, and every word will seem utter nonsense. Mind, I have no doubt the Eugene found that though his head was in the start he had to keep his feet on the ground as much as Morell, and that some enterprising woman married him and made him dress himself properly and take regular meals. But he did not steal her from a friend.” It seems clear that the Auction Scene is not mounted by Shaw to dramatize Candida’s choice of two men. After all, in Act II Candida had affirmed her love of her husband. Moreover,
Candida
117
nowhere is there much of a pretense that Eugene poses a serious threat as a rival for her hand—unless it be at the close of Act I. interest resides no more in whether Eugene will steal his wife form James than in whether James is physically stronger than Eugene. The challenge posed by the outsider, the poetic visitor to the Vicarage, concerns ideas –“your ideas and mine,” as Eugene says in Act I. Of course, at that point in the play, Eugene wanted Candida to be able to choose between these ideas. But by the end of the play, viewing a Candida who has not changed even a jot during the course of it, an audience should not expect her to choose a new set of ideas any more than to choose a new husband or lover. Chiefly, in his comedy, which is a play of ideas, Shaw gives us, the readers and spectators, a choice between the two ideas. For what is delineated as the arsenic and the poetic, the author leaves little doubt about his preference. But of course he may not have prevailed upon all of us to share this preference with him. Shaw sometimes described his plays, as “dramas of ideas,” as he did, for example, in the opening scenic description of Man and Superman. Serious discussions of serious ideas may be found in nearly all Shavian plays, even though the first of his fullfledged dramas of discussion or disquisitory plays as they are often called, may be Man and Superman (especially Act III dream interlude, the so-called “Don Juan in Hell”) of the opening years of this century. Following the success of this venture, discussion became a staple of the twentieth-century drama. One has but to consider the numerous contributions to the art of discussion subsequently made by Shaw alone. Back to Methuselah and
118
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Heartbreak House are two examples. The Devil and Don Juan, or even James Morell and Eugene Marchbanks, inaugurated a distinguished series of “debates,” including those in Major Barbara and Saint Joan; moreover, such speeches as those intoned by Candida emanate from even quite late Shaw plays. Some of Aubrey’s long sermons in Too True to Be Good provide noteworthy examples, and that play followed immediately The Apple Cart, in which king Magnus is allotted an eleven-minute solo. All of these plays prove to Shaw’s detractors that in his drama “people just talk.” To his admirers, however, they often demonstrate Shaw’s inimitable success in somehow dramatizing the thrust and parry of trenchant ideas. Alongside “drama of ideas,” Shaw was well content to employ other phrases to describe his plays—“problem play” (or “thesis plays”), for example. In the “Author’s Apology” attached to one of his earlier plays, Mrs. Warren’s Profession, Shaw spoke of his determination “to accept problem as the normal material of the drama. It will be seen that only in the problem play is there any real drama, because drama is no mere setting up of the camera to nature: it is the presentation in parable of the conflict between Man’s will and his environment: in a word, of problem.” And even as he commented on one descriptive term, Shaw supplied still another one—“parable play” –that seems to some critics admirably suited to describe such Shavian drama. Sui generis (of its own kind): this Latin phrase has been used by Shaw, fittingly enough, to describe his drama, generally. In truth, definition and description are not easily brought to bear on a playwright who has said: “I am not governed by principles; I
Candida
119
am inspired; how or why I cannot explain because I do not know, but inspiration it must be; for it comes to me without any reference to my own ends or interests.” Nevertheless, he occasionally confronted the problem of play writing, in his non dramatic writing, in a somewhat more concrete fashion. “Now a playwright’s direct business is simply to provide the theater with a play,” he wrote, in his Prefatory to The Six of Calais. “When I write one with the additional attraction of providing the twentieth–century with an up-to-date religion or the like, that luxury is thrown in gratuitously; and the play, simply as a play, is not necessarily either the better or the worse for it. In answer to his own question, “What is a play simply as a play?” Shaw wrote, “Well, it is a lot of thing.” But its basic function, he argued, is the interpretation of life in action—“and all the academic definitions of a play are variations of this basic function.” (Shaw was forever assuring his readers that he did not deal in definitions.) Many of Shaw’s plays emerged with subtitles, indicating here a comedy, and there a political one. In later editions these subtitles were often dropped—as was the Shavian subtitle for Candida in its first publication: “A Mystery.” Tragedy (especially if we accept the Devil’s description of it in Man and Superman as “a play in which everybody is murdered at the end”) was decidedly not Shaw’s forte, even though he would sometimes refer to his Saint Joan, which he subtitled “A Chronicle Play,” as a tragedy. Part Four of Back to Methuselah is titled The Tragedy of an Elderly Gentleman; “A Tragedy” stands also as the subtitle of The Doctor’s Dilemma. This last play was Shaw’s extraordinary reply to the complaint of his friend William Archer
120
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
that the Shavian repertory contained no tragedy, a play culminating in death. If the “tragedy” label scarcely suffices for these plays, it must also be admitted that “comedy” seems a good deal less than adequate as a description of such plays as Heartbreak House or On the Rocks. Nevertheless, Shaw was usually content—as he was in his Preface to Plays Pleasant and Unpleasant—to let the label “comedy” be applied to the sort of plays he wrote. In the “Warning from the Author,” prefixed to The Complete Plays of Bernard Shaw, in a Horatain manner, that “If I make you laugh at yourself, remember that my business as a classical writer of comedies is ‘to chasten morals with ridicule’; and if I sometimes make you feel like a fool, remember that I treat your toothache by pulling out your tooth. And I never do it without giving you plenty of laughing gas.” Candida, arrayed alongside the “Pleasant” plays, is one of numerous Shavian “comedies” that takes place in a drawing room, whether wholly (as with Candida) or in part (as with The Philanderer). Yet, as has been observed, the play is no more a typical “drawing room comedy;” then the room of the Vicarage is a typical drawing room. Reviewing a production of this “domestic play (another convention phrase), Stark Young, after arguing that “in a sense, all drama moves toward a condition of farce,” stated that “Candida is fundamentally a farce, a kind of cerebral farce.” Young also mentioned the possibility of taking the play “as a farce of ideas pitched delightfully against each other.” Shavian characters are often spoken of as mere mouthpieces of Bernard Shaw even by persons who declare that
Candida
121
they have read some Shaw plays. Shaw himself liked to think that he “allowed every person his or her own point of view;” and an unbiased survey of the evidence of his plays should bear out the prevailing truth of his testimony. Still, in most of the plays, there is likely to be a character who, we feel, voices the beliefs and feeling of his or her creator to a marked degree. Caesar in Caesar and Cleopatra is a good example. At an opposite extreme is the “most parsonic parson,” James in Candida. Even though James is not denied sympathetic strokes of delineation while he is wholly being allowed his own point of view, there is no blinking the fact that he is, in Shaw’s own phrase, “the butt of the piece.” Specifically, he is the butt of his chief antagonist, Eugene, who early tells the parson, “I’ll fight your ideas … . I’ll pit my own ideas against them.” In pitting his ideas against James’s, Eugene is usually made to seem tight—so much to that we feel that Candida’s delight may well be the playwright’s own as she is made to exclaim extravagantly about Eugene to her husband. “He is always right. He understands you; he understands me; he understands Prossy; and you, darling, you understand nothing.” Of course, this all understanding poet, attains still further understanding before the final curtain descends—no doubt aided in reaching it by Candida herself, who finally feels she can declare with assurance that Eugene “has learnt to live without happiness.” For there is one major learning experience for the young poet that Shaw is intent upon dramatizing. The apprentice in realism cannot hope to become a Realist (at least not a Shavian one) while even so much as inclined to the amoristic complaint.
122
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
The admiration that Shaw felt for the actual poet Shelley was tempered by the reservation he felt for Shelley the amoral; apparently he sought to amend this disability in his imagined poet—to bring him to a conviction of error. What better way to open the eyes of one who is inclined to idealize Love and Woman that to plunk him into a scene of middle-class domesticity, where he could observe the male as the doll in a managerial wife’s doll house? But even granted that this “fault” in Eugene gets corrected, is one to conceive of this eighteen-year-old as the voice of Bernard Shaw in Candida? From where else in the Vicarage could Shavianism emanate? It is almost solely owing to our being made to see this domestic circle through the eyes of a far-out outsider that the comedy can be called Shavian. But surely some of Eugene’s dialogue is a disservice to poets and poetry? It is; but impatience with some of Eugene’s lines might be softened by a consideration of the time (1894), as well as of the speaker’s age— a consideration that should also extend to what some very fine English and Irish poets of the period thought and wrote, especially when they were Eugene’s age. R. F. Rattray, in his Bernard Shaw: A Chronicle, records an actor’s telling him that when he acted as Eugene in early productions of the play he regarded the poetic passages as “Faustian,” but that the playwright told him they were real poetry. Whether or nor one views this report as Shavian leg-pulling, he may sense the justice of critic Bentley’s observation that “Even the things that arouse most derision are truths which nobody in the play—or perhaps in the playhouse— shares with Eugene.” According to Bentley, “Eugene March is
Candida
123
strong by any standard. He is all the time acquiring that last ability of noble mind, the ability to live without illusions, and at the end he has acquired it. A look through the play will convince the skeptic that Shaw invariably puts the truth in Eugene’s mouth and seldom in anybody else’s.” An interpretation of Eugene that classifies him as either a comic or burlesque figure has simply jumped the tracks. Candida-worship that denigrates the role of the poet thus is idolatrous. Eugene’s role corresponds in essential with the Realist—or Vitalist—role of Captain Bluntschil in that other “Pleasant” play, Arms and the Man, which Shaw wrote just before Candida, as well as with the role of Caesar, in Caesar and Cleopatra, and many another “teaching” roles among Shaw’s dramatis personae. The title of the play plays an impressive role. But the main controversial issue about Candida concerns the part she plays in “Shaw’s theme of reality and corrupting ideals. There is likely to be far more agreement about how to apply Shaw’s three labels— Idealist, Realist, and Philistine—to the hopelessly bound parson and the eventually unbound poet than to Candida. This mother once elected to marry the Reverend James Mavor Morell and she loved him, and the kind of household we visit during the three acts of the play is overwhelmingly her handiwork. At the same time, she feels some fondness for Eugene and she sympathizes with him; and in some measure she understands him. In addition, she is more than unconsciously instrumental in helping Eugene become cured of his illusions. Candida is herself singularly free of illusions. Because this is so, and because she assists Eugene in his drive toward freedom,
124
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
she is sometimes viewed as the play’s Realist, Vitalist, Teacher. But this is a role a trifle awkward for the parson’s wife to play in this Vicarage. True, she is more than partially a realist, just as she is unconventional. But even her husband has –certainly for a parson—his unconventional moments too. Candida is, besides, “immoral”; that is, in precisely the sense that Shaw was, in his own words, “an immoral writer.” Writer and character both are opposed to what passes for morality in a society conventionbound and dedicated to current ideals. Candida’s emancipation from such “morality” is not, however, comparable to the freedom of Eugene. Eugene might well say of Candida what Schopenhauer said of women generally that they are “decidedly more sober in their judgment than we are, so that they do not see more in things than is really there, while, if our passions are aroused, we are apt to see things in an exaggerated way, or imagine what does not exist. The weakness of their reasoning faculty also explains why it is that women show more sympathy for the unfortunate than men do, and to treat them with more kindness and interest; and why it is, on the contrary, they are inferior to men in point of justice, and less honorable and conscientious.” What? Let the last word on Candida be spoken by a misogynist? How much more reasonable and fitting it will be to reflect a bit on the perceptive judgment of Stark Young, who found that “Candida ends by being a play whose roles are capable of many interpretations and are hospitable to many actors.” Why need Candida Burgess Morell be pigeon-holed into any one category, Shavian or otherwise? Why not respond with gratitude
Candida
125
to the ambiguity of a vividly realized character? “When an author’s works produce violent controversy, and are new, people are apt to read them with that sort of seriousness which is very appropriately called deadly.” It may be well to bear this (of course Shavian) warning in mind as his labels “Realist” and “Philistine” she is in part. Is she also part “Philistine”? Definitely, yes—provided that you are an “Idealist.” Here is the way Shaw put the matter of such classification. Speaking about the vast majority of persons “who comfortably accept marriage as a matter of course, never dreaming of calling it an “institution,” much less a holy and beautiful one, and being pretty plainly of opinion observed (in The Quintessence of Ibsenism) that “the idealists, hurt by this, will retort by calling them Philistines.” Let us, finally, remember another Shavian warning—about “the sort of criticism which seeks to create an impression favorable or otherwise” by simply pasting “characters all over with good or bad conduct marks.” He must have asked himself this question, for he let this subtitle drop out of sight following the first publication of the play. It was by way of allusion, no doubt, to “the secret in the poet’s heart” –the one (remember?) that husband and wife do not know. We of course know because Shaw has told us that Eugene was thinking, “if this greasy fool’s paradise is happiness, then I give it to you with both hands,” for he had frown “contemptuous of the ‘happiness’ he envied in the days of his blindness, clearly seeing that he has higher business on hand than Candida.” Very likely, as he fled out into the night, he uttered the triumphant cry of Nietzsche’s Thus Spake Zarathustra at the end of Zarathustra’s
126
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
discourse: “Do I seek for happiness? I seek for my work!” And later on, he doubtlessly muttered Owen Jack’s words in Shaw’s Love Among the Artists: “I sometimes shudder when I think that I was once within an ace of getting a wife and family … it is marriage that kills the heart and keeps it dead. Better starve the heart than overfeed it. Better still to feed it only on fine food, like music.”
MAJOR BARBARA By George Bernard Shaw Major Barbara, together with Man and Superman and John Bull’s Other Island, form part of a trilogy of philosophical comedies, all of which deal with the bankruptcy of nineteenthcentury liberalism in the face of the brute facts of sex, nationalism, and not by chance that critics holding a formalist position, from Shaw’s friend A. B. Walkley down to Francis Fergusson on our own day, have denounced the play as a kind of literary monster, while philosopher-critics have regarded it as one of the few dramas with anything serious to say on the subject of politics. Indeed, Major Barbara raises the central issue of modern aesthetics as squarely as any piece of writing can. This question— putting it in the simplest possible terms—seems to be whether art is to be regarded as autonomous and ‘sui generic’ or whether it is to be judged in relation to some ulterior standard of reality, that is, as a form of science or knowledge. The second view of the nature of art—which is certainly Shaw’s view first to the dominant literary theory of our day, and second to our political and social ideals—seems acceptable. Only the inordinate length of Man and Superman kept Shaw from publishing his three philosophical comedies together in a set as he did the Plays Pleasant and Unpleasant and the Three Plays for Puritans. For his German edition, Shaw suggested that they be grouped and given the title Comedies of Science and Religion. Like the grouped plays of the other cycles,
128
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
these plays share, besides their common theme, a common mood and a common dramatic structure. It is this latter feature—their unique dramatic form—which has first of all confused, puzzled, and exasperated critics. What Shaw does is to mix together in each play a Molieresque comedy and a Socratic dialogue. This is a heavy mixture which has delighted many and infuriated not a few who have simply found these plays morally and aesthetically indigestible. But let us see first how this slicing of forms works in practice. Each play beings by presenting us with a high-minded idealist, who takes himself with earnest seriousness and looks upon himself as an unlighted reformer. He is then made subject of a comedy in the style of Moliere, not with the idea of unmasking his hypocrisy, but with the intention of exposing the comic contradictions within his ideals and temperament. Then the problems raised by this character, which appear originally in a farcical satirical light, are treated more and more seriously until they are shown to be bound up with what Shaw calls “the destiny of nations,” and the audience which had settled down for a night of fun finds it must either transform itself from an audience of pleasure-seekers into a “pit of philosopher” or founder hopelessly in the dream sequence of Man and Superman or the last act of John Bull’s Other Island and Major Barbara. But not, Shaw would answer, to someone who believed that “Every joke is an earnest in the womb of time,” and who was firmly convinced that the prophet who did not make his audience laugh would suffer, at worst, the fate of Socrates and Christ, and, at best, that of Voltaire and Tom Paine. The idealistic liberals who are the butts of the satire are
Major Barbara
129
Roebuck Ramsden in Man ands Superman, Tom Broadbent in John Bull’s Other Island, and Lady Britomart Undershaft in Major Barbara, but since our subject is the latter play let us look at Lady Britomart as a representative of the species. The character of Lady Britomart, like most of those in Major Barbara, was drawn from a real person. It is a well-known fact that Shaw based Adolphus Cusins, his professor of Greek, on Gilbert Murray, but it is less well known that he based Lady Britomart on Murray’s real-life mother-in-law, Lady Rosalind Frances, Countess of Carlisle. (Indeed, Shaw jokingly told Murray in a letter that he was at work on a play to be called “Murray’s Mother-in-law.”) The Countess of Carlisle was, like Lady Britomart, a Whig peeress; her father was the Liberal whip in Parliament, and she was herself a crusading temperance reformer and eighteen years the leader of the natorial Woman’s Liberal Federation. Her husband the earl was more interested in art than in estate management, and she ran the extensive family estates attending in minute detail to the farmers’ personal welfare—and to their moral characters. Castle Howard and her house in Kensington were saloons for the Liberal intelligentsia. Murray himself has paid tribute to her crusading enthusiasm and to the heartening quality of her formidable benevolence. The clue to Shaw’s treatment of the comic contradictions on Lady Britomart’s character may be found in a remark by James Froude, Carlyle’s biographer, on the subject of Lady Rosalind. Froude, who disapproved of her politics but admired her character, said that though she professed to be a Liberal, she was by temperament better fitted to be an “empress.” Hence if Shaw
130
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
had chosen to make her the central figure of the play he might have imitated Moliere’s “Bourgeois Gentelman” to the extent of calling it “The Imperious Liberal.” By family tradition and personal conviction Lady Britomart is an avowed believer in free speech and a democratic franchise, but every speech that she utters shows her native aristocratic spirit and natural masterfulness at odds with these ideals. She thinks she is consulting her son Stephen about the family inheritance when she is in fact revealing her own firm convictions. She can no more be said to be consciously bullying Stephen than an avalanche can be accused of intending to obliterate a tree in its path, but the effect is just the same. She declares that her children are her fiends and equals and in reality treats them like kindergarten toddlers unable to take care of themselves. If she were not as amiable as she is willful and domineering, she would be an atrocious tyrant; but as her children are as strong-minded as herself, and as she is prevented by her affectionateness from acting as peremptorily as she talks, we even end by feeling something like pity for her as a well-intentioned mother balked in the pursuit of her heart’s desire, and too heroic in temperament to take refuge in self-pity, sulking, or quarrels. Major Barbara has been glibly likened to The Importance of Being Earnest for its wit and farce, and there is indeed a superficial resemblance between Lady Britomart and Lady Bracknell in Wilde’s play, but nothing could be more unlike Wilde than the stroke by which Shaw has the frustrated Lady Britomart burst into tears at the end of act one when her children desert her for their father. But where, if we take Shaw’s formula seriously, is the
Major Barbara
131
“earnest” of the particular joke which underlies this brilliant piece of high comedy? We do not have to look far for it. It lies in the fact that Lady Britomart represents the hereditary British governing class in its most enlightened and liberal aspect, but also under its limitations. For, with all her admirable civic energy her vision is circumscribed by two principles: her conventional “morality” and her belief in the divine right of the aristocracy to rule the country. Behind her reformism is an intense moral fervor, but she does not see that moral tyranny is in itself the most oppressive of all tyrannies and that moral indignation is no substitute for critical thought and action. When Stephen shows embarrassment, when he thinks she is about to reveal some youthful indiscretion of his father’s, she chides him: “It is only in the middle classes, Stephen, that people get into a state of dumb helpless horror when they find out that there are wicked people in the world. In our class, we have to decide what is to be done with wicked people; and nothing should disturb our self-possession.” But, as we shall see later, “helpless horror” and moral indignation are almost all that Lady Britomart can oppose to the brutal facts of the Undershaft munitions works, and the political power of a capitalist class to realize its profits at whatever cost. Lady Britomart’s moralist is not an aristocratic Mrs. Grundyism, a Queen Victoria-ism so to speak; it is merely a rationalization of her class prejudices and privileges, “right” and “propriety” being whatever furthers the Stephen age family interests, and “wrong” or “impropriety” being whatever conflicts with them. The central issue of the first act, and indeed of the play as a whole, is who will inherit the armament factory owned by
132
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Lady Britomart’s husband, Andrew Undershaft. The question of the Undershaft inheritance has caused a rift between the husband and wife: according to the tradition of the firm, the inheritance must go not to a son of the owner but to some promising adopted heir. This condition, utterly at odds with aristocratic belief in birth and blood, so offends Lady Britomart that it is useless for Andrew to argue that the Roman Empire was run successfully on this scheme and that it brought to the throne Marcus Aurelius. She is so used to thinking of the Stephenages as governors by natural right that when Andrew had refused to break the firm’s law of succession in favor of his son Stephen the resulting quarrel led to a legal separation. Lady Britomart’s way of putting this is to declare that nothing can bridge fundamental “moral” disagreement. One has only to spend two minutes is Stephen’s presence to realize the soundness of his father’s decision, for Stephen is a conscientious, thoroughly well-intentioned prig and moral pedant, tediously prating about “right” being “right” and “wrong” being “wrong”; in short, he is ten times the slave of conventional morality his mother is, with her spiritedness all soared into sulky petulance of the most high-toned sort. His sister Sarah lacks his pretentiousness, but also his starchy character, and is, in fact, no more than a fashionable nonentity. Only in their third child, Barbara, has the Undershaft Stephenage marriage justified itself as an evolutionary experiment in the crossing of types and classes, for Barbara has Lady Birtomart’s genuis for leadership and mothering, with none of her class limitations. So little is she concerned with mere propriety and good form, and so intensely
Major Barbara
133
does she identify herself with the religious spirit of the race that she has thrown aristocratic prejudice to the winds and demonstrated the family independence of mind by joining the least snobbish of the reforming religious sects of the day, the Salvation Army. We learn that Sarah and Barbara have both become engaged; Sarah to Charles Lomax, an amiable aristocratic noodle as empty-headed as herself, and Barbara to a man as complex and subtle in his moral and intellectual perceptions as Lomax is silly. Shaw shows us in Cousins a representative of the humane conscience in its most tender and perceptive form. In writing to Gilbert Murray, his model for the part, Shaw pointed out that he had taken pains to make his professor “the reverse in every point of the theatrical strong man:” “I want him to go on his quality wholly, and not to make the smallest show of physical robustness or brute determination. His selection by Undershaft should be a standing puzzle to the people who believe in the, strong, silent still-waters-run-deep hero of melodrama. The very name Adolphus Cusins was selected to that end.” In choosing Murray as his model, Shaw had in mind a type of Liberal strong contrast to the active, bustling Lady Britomart the academic, cloistered, sympathetic, skeptical, ironic, super civilized Liberal who shrinks instinctively from what E. M. Forster has called the world of “telegrams and anger.” Murray’s liberalism sprang from several sources—from the radicalism of Castle Howard, from his Irish rebel background, and from a strain of Shelley an humanitarianism that made him, like
134
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Shaw, a vegetarian and a hater of all forms of cruelty. The other side of the picture was his Hellenism. For Murray, Greek literature was a living force having direct bearing on modern politics, morals, and culture. Here is how he writes of Euripides, the Greek playwright to whom he felt especially drawn: “His contemporary public denounced him as dull, because he tortured them with personal problems; as malignant, because he made them see truths they wished not to see; as blasphemous and foul-minded, because he made demands on their spiritual and religious natures which they could not overlook.” In short, Murray regarded Euripides as standing in relation to the golden age of Athens as the “New Drama” of Shaw and Ibsen stood in relation to the age of Victoria and Edward VII. Shaw returned the compliment by hailing the production of Murray’s translations of Euripides as the Court theatre as modern masterpieces that had earned their place on the contemporary stage through their own right. During the Boer campaign of 1899-1901, Murray belonged, with his cousin by marriage Bertrand Russell, to the small but vocal Liberal minority who opposed the war. No doubt his anti-war sentiments endowed Euripides’ Andromache and The Trojan Women with particular significance for him; at any rate these were two of his earliest choices for translation into English verse. In Major Barbara Shaw makes Undershaft give Cousins the nickname “Euripides,” thus implying that he looks on human affairs with the same mixture of ironic pessimism and pity as did his Greek predecessor. When Cousins is brought face-to-face with the facts of armament-making, he tells Undershaft, “there is an
Major Barbara
135
abyss of moral horror between me and your accursed aerial battleships.” It is this group Lady Britomart has invited her estranged husband to meet in the drawing-room of her West End mansion. Her intention is the eminently practical one of extracting dowries from Andrew for the two brides-to-be, her estimate of a feckless man-about-town and a classics professor being realistically small. But Lady Britomart’s attempt to bring up once more the matter of the inheritance meets flinty resistance from Undershaft. Indeed, the family reunion appears headed for a fiasco, and only the unexpected interest Undershaft shows in Barbara’s novel religious aspirations, saves the meeting from shipwreck. It is an immense puzzle to both the naïve and the sophisticated members of the family group that Undershaft should show such a concern with his new faith, particularly since he is resolutely unashamed of his destructive trade and even seems to glory in it, declaring, “Your Christianity”, which enjoins you to resist not evil, and to turn the other cheek, would make me a bankrupt. My morality—my religion—must have a place for cannons and torpedoes in it.” Barbara challenges him to maintain this faith after visiting her East End Salvation Army shelter. Her father accepts the invitation, and issues a counter-challenge: she shall, in return, pay a visit to his arms factory and face the temptation offered by a religion of “money and gun-powder.” He warns her that she may end by giving up the Salvation Army for the sake of the cannons; strong in her conviction of the impossibility of any such enormity, she accepts his condition. The scene at the Salvation Army shelter is a remarkable
136
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
piece of law-life melodrama; equaled in English only by the works of O’Casey. The refugees at the barracks include a cynically smart young man and an old crone, both posing as redeemed sinners, and an unemployed older man who is brought in a state of semi starvation. This man, Peter Shirley by name, has been turned out of his job as overage; he finds the necessity of accepting charity all the more bitter because he holds the faith of a secularist, in contrast to the others who believe in nothing but their right to exploit the capitalist society as it has bilked and exploited them. Finally Bill Walker enters, a half-drunk, blustering bully in a very mean mood, who bawls angrily for his girl, and curses the Army for taking her from him. It will be seen that this is not a particularly cheerful, amusing, or attractive group of slum dwellers. Unlike other writers who are sympathetic to the poor, Shaw does not sentimentalize or idealize them, his argument being that if poverty actually did improve people it would be the strongest argument for making poverty compulsory. Shaw insists rather that poverty is unequivocally demoralizing: its fruits are not simple piety, honest rectitude, and altruistic sentiment; they are more likely to be, at best, hypocrisy, cynicism, and shattered self-respect; and, at worst, conscienceless brutality. Looking into this abyss, Lady Britomart would first of all be shocked at the total lack of respect of the poor for their governors—sincerely shocked, since she would be conscious of having their spiritual and physical welfare at heart; Barbara and Cousins as humanitarians seem appalled by the bitterness and violence of these lives. Moreover, Christianity itself must assume
Major Barbara
137
part of the blame for this moral debasement. For besides teaching humility and acquiescence, it also, through its Pauline Theology first preaches a retaliatory morality and then allows the blackguards to escape the consequences of his actions through a belief in a divine atonement. Shaw’s second act makes this last point through a moral parable in the vein of Tolstoy. Bill Walker, the bully, first strikes the old woman and then a young Salvation Army girl. When the old woman curses him he simply jeers at her, knowing that hard words break no bones and that she is, spiritually speaking, on the same level as himself in her vindictive desire for revenge. The young girl, by contrast, instead of reproaching him prays for him. This unexpected behavior has the effect of giving his anger time to cool, and then, as he reflects more soberly on his deed, causing a noticeable twinge of conscience. This sensitivity Barbara exploits skillfully, not scolding him, but keeping the naked fact of his deed inexorably before him. Finally he feels he must somehow make amends, and the way he tries to do this is highly significant. First he tries to “atone” by getting himself pummeled by a Salvation Army officer who is a converted boxer: this is the Pauline Christian method. When this fails, he then “fines” himself as he has seen other blackguards fined in law courts: this is, of course, only Pauline Christianity as we have institutionalized it with our legal system of planties and prisons. But Barbara, whose Christianity is not that of Paul but of Christ—that is, a Christianity which scorns vengeance, retaliation, and punishment –is still memorable; she will not play the role of Tetzel on any account. Bill Walker cannot “buy” salvation from the Salvation
138
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Army. The only way he can redeem himself is through a growth of conscience that will make it impossible for him to repeat his deed. Under no circumstances must he be encouraged to sin so that grace may abound. Barbara’s fight for Bill’s soul comes very near to success and only fails on the part of her father. The latter frustrates her simply by demonstrating that although the Salvation Army can afford to refuse to sell the blackguard his salvation for twenty shillings, it cannot, no matter how scrupulous it affects to be, refuse to sell the millionaire his for, say, five thousand pounds. Barbara had refused to accept her father’s suspense in the collection plate because the money was earned through the creation of destructive forces far more brutal in their effect than anything the slum ruffian might aspire to. But when Mrs. Baines, the Army commissioner, comes to plead for money to carry on the Army’s work in a hard winter, she is forced to accept Undershaft’s offer of the aforementioned thousands despite his sardonic emphasis on the terrifying nature of his enterprises. The ruffian, when he sees the rich man’s gift accepted where his own conscience money was rejected, turns on Barbara with cynical scorn, and Barbara, facing the failure of her attempt at salvation and a realization that the Salvation Army, if it is to exist at all, can only exist as the pensioner of the distillery and cannon industries, utters her bitter and heart-rending cry of despair, “My God: why hast thou forsaken me?” The melodrama of the scene at the Salvation Army barracks thus reaches its, climax in this loss of faith. But it is at this point that the play takes the most surprising of its many
Major Barbara
139
surprising turns. For at the moment that Barbara’s God, the God of Evangelical Christianity, appears to have failed her, the professor of Greek hails as a new deity the very man Barbara now fears as anti-Christ, her diabolical-seeming father. Cousins, in a transport of ecstasy, declares himself to be possessed by the spirit of Undershaft, whom he addressed as the new “Dionysus.” Barbara, in the pain and confusion of her loss, can of course see nothing in this behavior but a piece of perverse irony. Since the reader or spectator of the play may be left in the same puzzlement as Shaw’s West End heiress, it may be well at this point to ask what Shaw means by his idea of a “new” Dionysos. What has the ancient Greek god to do with modern society? The answer is to be found in the meaning Dionysiac religion had in the Greek world. Historians and philosophers, of whom Nietzsche is the most famous, have repeatedly emphasized the strange disparity between the serene rationalism of Greek society as we usually conceive it and the wild barbarity of the Bacchic cult which entered Greece from Thrace and Macedonia in the tenth century before Christ. Nietzsche traces the birth of dramatic tragedy itself to this irruption of frenzied rites and ecstatic orgies into the calm order and moral rationalism of Greek life, which the new religion challenged with its worship of supernormal psychic energy and its identification of the worshipper both with the new God and with the life processes of the Salvation Army as the “true worship of Dionysos,” finding in the Army’s ecstasy and enthusiasm (literally, a standing outside oneself and possession by the divine will) an analogue of the uncouth religion that shocked the cultivated Greeks as the Army
140
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
shocked the conventional Anglicanism of the West End. In its stirring religious music he had seen the primitive dithyramb reborn, its trombones, tumbrels. And drums being the antithesis of the both the tepid hymns sung in fashionable churches and the salon music of the fashionable drawing room. Even its symbols, Blood and Fire, Cousins points out, are Dionysiac symbols. Its joy and happiness are those of the God possessed, as Barbara’s later grief is that of the God forsaken. Thus Dionysianism is what Bergson calls a “dynamic religion,” with its basis not in conventional morality or institutionalism but in a mystical union with the divine will. It breaks down social barriers, taking the intellectual into University Settlements in the slums, and pitting him actively against evil. It carries its devotees beyond the bounds of logic and reason. Aroused and lacking rational direction, it finds its expression in the frenzy of the revolutionary mob. Cousins is a sophisticated intellectual who has joined the Army, as Lady Britomart puts it, to worship Barbara; (no bad object of worship, Shaw would insist.) But Barbara’s obvious religious genius attracts him strongly, and her evangelicalism, on its practical side, is not at all incompatible with his own religion of love, pity, and forgiveness. Indeed, for all his sardonic irony, he faces a crisis of his own beliefs at the same moment Barbara faces hers. As we have already seen, Cousins, in his skepticism and humanitarianism is akin to the young Euripides who casts doubts on the traditional Greek attitudes to such questions as patriotism, religion, women, and slaves. But the Greek playwright’s later development has a strange
Major Barbara
141
and unforeseen twist to it. For Euripides, who first turned the Greek drama away from its roots in Dionysiac religion toward a critical and skeptical direction, does return to Dionysus at the end of his career. In what is generally regarded as the last work of his old age, The Bacchae, the humanistic and humanitarian playwright does come face to face with the religion in which the drama had its origin. It is probably no exaggeration to say that The Bacchae is, by a good margin, the most terrifying, unedifying, and enigmatic of all Greek tragedies. You will recall that in this play Dionysus visits in disguise the city of Thebes where his rites have been forbidden by the moralistic King Pentheus and works a horrifying revenge. The problem Euripides’s drama poses, put in the briefest terms, is this: what attitude are we to adopt to this new force in society, at once so terrible of vital religion or does he symbolize some dark, demonic power from which we are to recoil in dread? Now, like the Greeks of Euripides’ day, Cousins has also been brought face to face with a brutal, primitive force of life and death which the cultivated, sensitive side of him recoils from, but which the clear-headed student of society is forced to take into account. This power is the destructive-creative energy of Cousins’ prospective father-in-law, the arms maker. And Shaw, to emphasize the fact that he has had the parallel with Euripides’ drama in mind all along, has Cousins quote some twenty or thirty lines from the play in the Salvation Army scene, in what Cousins identifies as his “own” (that is, Murray’s) new translation. It is no exaggeration to say that Shaw’s Undershaft has created the same bafflement in critics as Euripides’ Dionysus,
142
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
whether the critic be as naïve as the Time reviewer who accused Shaw of making a “complete about-face” and firing on his own socialist ranks, or as sophisticated as Mr. Francis Fergusson, who for all his learning and intelligence, denounces Major Barbara as a tissue of “unresolved paradoxes.” What then are we to make of this man who has so puzzled Shaw’s commentators? It may perhaps be best to turn first to the living models from whom Shaw may have obtained hints for his millionaire munitions maker. One was a neighbor as Ayot Saint Lawrence, Charles McEvoy, a quite and gentle man, who had manufactured torpedoes for the North during the American Civil War. But we should like to suggest that Shaw, in drawing the sardonic side of Undershaft’s character, seems to have had in mind the Swedish arms maker Alfred Nobel, the inventor of nitroglycerine. During the closing decades of the nineteenth century, Nobel’s success in creating more and more powerful explosives had sent a wave of panic around the world. A leading figure in European business and international finance, Nobel was also a man of an intellectual and literary cast. Like Undershaft, he belonged to a munitions dynasty, his father having been an armaments maker before him. In thought and sentiment, Nobel was as Shelley, a radical and humanitarian, but this did not limit his hardheadedness in business, and he sold his patents indiscriminately to autocratic and liberal states alike. Nobel’s motto, “my home is where my work is, and my work is everywhere,” might well have been Undershaft’s. And, of course, one of the last deeds of this complex and enigmatic man was his endowment of the Nobel Peace Prize, which challenged the
Major Barbara
143
humanitarian liberals among his personal fiends to solve the problem his discoveries had created. The Peace Prize was first awarded in 1901, four years before Shaw began his play. This will perhaps explain, in part, the paradoxes of Major Barbara—that it is a dealer in lethal weapons who plays the role of Socrates in this socialist drama. But what of Undershaft’s peculiar commercial ruthlessness, that specifically cold-blooded side of hid personality that has so shocked and baffled critics and audiences? To unravel this puzzle we must begin by considering his background. Undershaft is an East End slum boy, reared in that wilderness of desolation that was East London in the middle of the nineteenth century. He has, like all the members of his dynasty, taken the name f the firm’s founder, an abandoned orphan reared in the parish of St. Andrew Undershaft in the City. His early career had resembled in its single-mindedness the career of the American industrial barons of the post-Civil War period. Determined to escape from the indignities of poverty, he had taken for his own the stern old Scots’ slogan: “Thou shalt starve ere I starve.” Here the second paradox appears, for as a Socialist we expect Shaw especially to condemn this spirit. But he condones it and even insists that for a poor person it is indeed the only possible “manly” attitude. (Undershaft’s Christian name, “Andrew,” means “manly.”) For Shaw, the great cardinal virtues are courage and self-respect, and he believed that if the poor in a democracy let themselves be exploited, starved, and snubbed, it is only because of their own invented abjectness.) Hence the cutting remarks which Undershaft, the ex-slum boy, addressed to Peter
144
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Shirley, the down-trodden, long-suffering worker, in the Salvation Army shelter: Shirley: [angrily]. Who made your millions for you? Me and my like. What's kept us poor? Keeping you rich. I wouldn’t have your conscience, not for all your income. Undershaft: I wouldn’t have your conscience, not for all your conscience, Mr. Shirley. Undershaft is driving home the point that the play makes over and over again, that a conviction of moral superiority is in itself the hollowest of consolations, the last resource of the weak and cowardly, and the treacherous quagmire in which true worth and manhood are lost. Honor, justice, and truth are indeed part of Undershaft’s religion, but he is firm in pointing out that these can be known as the “graces and luxuries of a rich, strong, and safe life.” Any liberal like Cousins who preaches the virtues to the poor without taking into account economic realities is a fool. Undershaft can even declare that his determinedly ruthless conduct satisfies the Kantian test, since the world would be an immeasurably better place if all the poor, behaved exactly as he has. But first we must rid ourselves of the liberal belief that moral virtue by itself is ever capable of becoming a significant force in the world. Shaw made this point abundantly clear in a speech of Undershaft’s in the unpublished Derry manuscript of the play: “Come, come, my young friends: let us live in the real world. Your moral world is a vacuum nothing is done there, though a good deal is eaten and drunk by the moralists at the expense of the real world. It is nice to live in the vacuum and repeat the fine phrases and edifying
Major Barbara
145
sentiments a few literary people have manufactured for you: but you know as well as I do that your morality is tolerated only on the assumption that nothing is to come of it. Your Christmas carols about peace and goodwill to men are very pretty; but you order cannons from me just the same. You ring out the old, ring in the new: that is, you discard muzzle loaders; they have no responsibility and no power; but she does not sing it by Greek verses. It can be stopped only by a mighty power which is not in his class room.” Undershft soon makes it clear that this power is the power of bombs. Liberal intellectuals frequently distrust power and decry the use of force. In so doing, they blind themselves to the fact that the authority of governments in liberal democracies rests on the police and army as surely as in any authoritarian state. Shaw, speaking through Undershaft, defines a government as a body of men with the courage to kill. Stephen, the conventionally-minded parliamentarian, must himself be as ready to kill his political opponents as Caesar, Cromwell, Washington, Lincoln, and Stalin were to kill theirs. Being a totally conventional young man with his head stuffed full of moral clichés and a conviction of the divinely righteous nature of upper-class British interests, he will kill stupidly and senselessly. How little his high-mindedness represents anything in the way of real scruples we see when the Undershaft arty arrives, is now all admiration for this triumph of industry. But for the intellectual humanitarian and the former Salvationist the reconciliation to the factory of death is not so easy. The last scene of the play is at once an intellectual argument
146
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
and a religious wooing of the souls of Cusins and Barbara by Mephistopheles Dionysos-Undershaft. Cusins may admit that force is the basis of present-day society and that a capitalist state exists for the sake of protecting the rich man’s dividends, just as the Salvation Army inadvertently plays into the hands of the rich by diverting the attention of the poor from revolution. But perhaps the answer is not to use force against force but to abandon force completely and to appeal for social justice on the grounds of Christianity, love, and mercy. No: Undershaft inexorably insists, government and rule means killing, and all political progress (not to mention political conservatism) rests ultimately on the willingness to kill. Since this is the idea which readers and audiences of Major Barbara have found most puzzling and unintelligible, coming as it does in a work of a writer who can by no means be accused of lacking moral sensitivity and bowels of compassion, and who otherwise hardly seem to be of the school of Hobbes and Machiavelli, let us see if we can determine exactly what Undershaft means before we raise the cry of “unresolved paradox.” It is likely that Shaw’s intention is clear enough if we give full weight to what he says in the final scene, but since these relatively straightforward statements have been for most people as music to the deaf and sunsets to the blind, we may profitably take another look at the unpublished manuscript version of the play in the possessions he maintains in the final version of the play, but he is perhaps more explicit: Undershaft [grimly]: Why do [the poor] starve? Because they
Major Barbara
147
have been taught that it is their duty to starve. “Blessed are the poor in spirit”-eh? But now mark my highest claim, my proudest boast. To those who are worth their slat as slaves I give the means of life. But to those who will not or cannot sell their manhood—to those who will not stand tamely and suffer their country to be ravaged by poverty and preyed upon by skulkers and idlers—I give the means of death. Poverty and slavery have stood up for centuries to sermons and Bibles and leading articles and pious platitudes: they will not stand to my machine guns. Let every English citizen resolve to kill or be killed sooner than tolerate the existence of one poor person or one idler on English soil: and poverty and slavery will vanish tomorrow. Barbara: Killing! Is that your remedy? Undershaft: It is the final test of conviction, the sole lever strong enough to lift a whole people. It is the right of every man who will stake his own life on his faith. It is the only way of saying Must. At this point it is perhaps natural to ask whether Shaw, in giving Undershaft these speeches, was expressing his own political philosophy or merely presenting an idea, so to speak, dramatically. Any doubts on this subject may be resolved by consideration of another British Museum manuscript that contains Shaw’s notes for a lecture on Darwin delivered to the Fabian Society in 1906, the year after the production of Major Barbara: “Revolutions, remember, can only by made by men and women with courage enough to meet the ferocity and pugnacity of the common soldier and vanquish it. Do not let us delude ourselves with any dreams of a peaceful evolution of Capitalism into
148
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Socialism, of automatic Liberal Progress, of the conciliation of our American bosses, and South African Landlords and British country society and Pall Mall military caste by the Fabian Society. The man who is not a Socialist is quite prepared to fight for his private property, or at least to pay someone else to fight for him. He has no doubt whatever of the necessity and morality of such warfare.” We must clear our minds from cant and cowardice on this subject. It is true that the old barricade revolutionists were childishly and romantically wrong in their methods; and the Fabians were right in making an end of them and formulating constitutional as fighting. Rents cannot be collected now without force, nor are they socialized—to the small extent to which they are already socialized—without force. Shaw is here appealing to history to verify Undershaft’s statement that “the ballot paper that really governs is the paper that has a bullet wrapped up in it.” The bloody suppression of the Commune of 1871 had demonstrated the willingness of the proprietarily class to fight for their property right. Later in this same Fabian lecture Shaw argues that the classic was in favor of his view, for the Reform Bill passed only when the temper of the English nation reached the point where it was clearly a choice between passing the bill and facing a revolution. The readers have called the last act a religious wooing of souls. Undershaft, seeing in Cousins the brains and sensitivity he thinks necessary in anyone who is to run a factory of death (or let us say, a democratic, or any other kind of state), offers him the
Major Barbara
149
management of the munitions work. The intelligentsia is to undertake the responsibilities of political power, that is, the power of life and death over millions. Cousins finds himself in the position of a famous predecessor of academic fame; Mephistopheles has once again put in a bid for a professor’s soul, and though Cousins, wiser than Faustus, realizes that he has already sold his soul for his professorship, this does not make his dilemma less cruel. For Barbara’s engagement to Cousins is both a love match and something more again. That is to say, their marriage is to be a religious marriage in a sense of devoting them to something beyond themselves; To “larger loves and diviner dreams than the fireside ones.” Their understanding is that unless their marriage can foster this religious side of themselves they are to part and seek other matters, or join the legion of the world’s celibate saints and philosophers. If Cousins elects to sell his soul to Undershaft he thus jeopardizes his relation with Barbara, who is first of all a “Salvationist” (in an unsectarian sense) and only secondly a fiancée. At this point Shaw turns to an episode from real life to solve the dilemma. When an idealistic student of Murray’s set out for the Greco-Turkish War in 1897, Murray had given the young man, not a copy of Plato’s Republic, but a revolver. Shaw ascribes this incident to Cousins, and makes Undeshaft seize upon it to demonstrate to the professor that he is, for all his hatred of war, committed to the side of the industrialist. Cusins is forced to concur, and declares that he will choose the “reality and power” of the factory of death, even if it means losing Barbara.
150
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
But Barbara, for all her talk about turning her back on wickedness, can no more turn away from life than can Cusins. Now she will be able to preach to the well-fed, self- respecting men and women in Undershaft’s model factory-town and know that, when they abandon their snobbishness and selfishness for higher ends, they are not simply being tempted by the bribe of bread. She has regained her faith and courage: the enthusiasm of the new Dionysianism possesses her and she goes “right up into the skies,” saved forever from the fate she has most dreaded, the boredom and triviality of the genteel drawing room.
ARMS AND THE MAN By George Bernard Shaw Arms and the Man is like a lemon meringue pie—all fluff as seen form the top, but with a good dollop of tartness underneath. Regarding the theater as both school and church, Shaw used it for educating the public and for preaching to it. Though delightfully funny, his comedies are comedies of ideas, and Shaw wrote them to instruct as well as to entertain. Typically, Shaw’s plays pit realism against romantic idealism, and support the superiority of the former. By an “ideals” Shaw meant some noble-sounding but conventional and unexamined principle of conduct with which we fool ourselves or attempt to fool others. Defying common sense, “ideals” have undesirable social consequences. When Sergius tells the story about a Swiss officer who took refuge in a Bulgarian lady’s bedroom, and charmed both the lady and her mother into protecting him, Raina and Catherine both reproach him. “Your life in the camp has made you coarse, Sergius. I did not think you have repeated such a story before me,” says Raina; and Catherine adds, “If such women exist, we should be spared the knowledge of them.” Raina and her mother here consciously use the ideal of feminine delicacy to shield their own identities as the women in the story. Much more frequently, however, the ideal is an instrument of self-deception. When Catherine pictures the famous charge: “our gallant splendid Bulgarians with their swords and eyes flashing, scattering the
152
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
wretched Serbs and their dandified Austrian officers like chaff,” she is misled into absurd hyperbole by her ideals of patriotism and national pride. The main conflict in Arms and the Man is between romantic idealism and pragmatic realism—particularly in the realms of war and love. The conflicting ideas are embodied in Sergius and Captain Bluntschil respectively, who are rivals in both war and love. Raina supports romanticism for three quarters of the play, and is then converted to realism dramatically symbolized by her breaking her engagement to Serguis and becoming engaged to Bluntschi. Sergius and Bluntschli are contrasted in five areas: appearance, social class, warfare, love, and general outlook on life. In appearance Sergius is “a tall romantically handsome man;” a man of dashing appearance and magnetic eye, the very essence of glomar. Bluntschli, on the contrary, is of “middling” stature and undistinguished appearance. There is no glamour in common sense. Serguis is by birth a member of the Bulgarian aristocracy, with all the glamour that high station implies. Bluntschil is a middle class Swiss, accused by Raina of having a “low shop keeping mind.” These contrasts in appearance and social class are symbolic of larger ones. Shaw seeks to discredit war by de-glamorizing it, stripping it of its romantic trappings, dissociating it from glory and heroism. Wars are won, he implies, not by heroism on the battlefield, but by the same qualities that make for success in managing a string of hotels. Shaw’s title ironically quotes Virgil’s
Arms and The Men
153
great patriotic epic The Aeneid. Shaw also sings “of arms and the man,” but in a quite different key. Sergius, disillusioned by the way wars are actually fought, gives Catherine a bitterly contemptuous definition of war; “Soldiering, my dear madam, is the coward’s art of attacking mercilessly when you are strong, and keeping out of harm’s way when you are weak. That is the whole secret of successful fighting. Get your enemy at a disadvantage; and never, on any account, fight him on equal terms.” Sergius wants war to be like a sporting event. When your opponenet is down, wait till he gets up before attacking again. The greatest glory is to attack against overwhelming odds (as in Tennyson’s “Charge of the Light Bridge”). Bluntschi regards war as a trade or profession. He would define war, if asked, in the same words as Sergius, but without the word “coward’s” and without Sergius’s embittered, ironic tone of voice. Sergius and Bluntschli are directly contrasted as soldiers on three occasions. First, the famous cavalry charge. Sergius, defying orders, leads a regiment of cavalry against a battery of machine guns. Bluntschli runs away. Bluntschli is undoubtedly wrong in claiming that Sergius’s horse was merely running away with him, but he is right in saying that Sergius should have been court-martialed. If the Serbians had not been sent the wrong ammunition, Sergius’s unit would have been decimated. And Bluntschli runs away—not because he is a coward—but because he recognizes that discretion is often the better part of valor, in this encounter, Sergius exhibits foolhardy courage, and Bluntschli prudent courage. Shaw’s point is that the battle wasn’t won by
154
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
Sergius’s heroic charge, it was lost by a quartermaster’s stupid mistake—by bad paperwork. The two men are compared again when Sergius and Petkoff must make out orders for moving three regiments to another town. Sergius and Petkoff are helpless before the complexities of this take; Bluntschli sees immediately what must be done, and, sitting down, does it. Sergius justifies his helplessness with one of his grandiose romantic statements: “This hand is more accustomed to the sword than to the pen.” In a third encounter Bluntschli humbugs Sergius and Petkoff into trading him fifty able-bodied men for two hundred worn-out chargers. In all three of these encounters Bluntschli is the more efficient soldier. Sergius “hasn’t the slightest chance of promotion” until his superiors are “quite sure that the peace will be a lasting one.” Shaw discredits war also by undermining its patriotic basis. Patriotism, a romantic ideal which prompts Catherine to talk of “gallant splendid Bulgarians” and “wretched Serbs,” lends glamour to murder. Patriotic Bulgarians battle patriotic Serbs, neither side really aware that they are pawns in a larger power struggle between Russia and Austria. Shaw’s hero in this struggle is neither Bulgar nor Serb but a Swiss mercenary fighting for the Serbs because theirs was the first country he came to on leaving Switzerland. This does not constitute an endorsement by Shaw of mercenary soldiering. It means only that his hero, if he does engage in war, does so undeluded by romantic ideals. He knows what he is doing and why. Romantic love, Shaw’s second major target, is illustrated
Arms and The Men
155
in the relationship between Sergius and Raina. They think of their feelings for each other as being exalted and noble. They call it “the higher love.” Actually we discover a good deal of pose in the higher love. Sergius and Raina constantly tell lofty lies to each other. When her hero returns home alive from the wars, Raina, rather than rushing out and throwing herself into his arms, waits for the most propitious moment to make an effective “entrance.” Left alone with her, Sergius declares, “Dearest: all my deeds have been yours. You inspired me. I have gone through the war like a knight in a tournament with his lady looking down at him!” Raina replies (forgetting her moments with Bluntschi in her bedchamber), “And you have never been absent from my thoughts for a moment.” When Raina goes to fetch her hat, Sergius tells her, “Be quick. If you are away five minutes, it will seem five hours.” But as soon as she is out of sight, he begins to flirt with Louka, confessing that the “higher love” is “very fatiguing” to keep up for any length of time. Question: Does Sergius really believe in “the higher love”? Answer: Yes. When Louks suggests that Raina may be spying on them, Sergius is “stung.” “I may be worthless enough to betray the higher love,” he tells Louka, “but do not you insult it.” Sergius is disillusioned about his ability to live up to his ideal, but not about the merit of the ideal itself. The relation between Bluntschli and Raina contrasts sharply with that between Sergius and Raina. Raina tells Bluntschli: “I want to be quite perfect with Sergius no meanness, no smallness, no deceit. My relation to him is the one really beautiful and noble part of my life.” When Bluntschli challenges her with her lie about the ice pudding, Raina replies, “I did to save
156
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
your life … . That was the second time I ever uttered a falsehood.” When Bluntschli also challenges this assertion, Raina grows indignant. “Do you know, sir, that you are insulting me?” “I can’t help it,” Bluntschli responds. “When you strike that noble attitude and speak in that thrilling voice, I admire you; but I find it impossible to believe a single word you say.” Raina, almost beside herself with injured dignity, suddenly collapses and says, “How did you find me out?” Her bubble of romanticism has been punctured by Bluntschli, and she is won over to his realism. Romantic lovers idealize the character of the beloved, and exaggerate their feelings for each other. Since neither really feels as strongly as they both think, and since neither is as perfect and noble as the other thinks, romantic lovers continuously pose before each other. They act out a game of make-believe, but act it out quite seriously and earnestly. Each is taken in by the other’s pose. Each thinks the other quite perfect and noble. Bluntschli, in contrast, treats Raina as an attractive but ordinary human being quite capable of lying to herself and others. And Bluntschli turns out to be the more efficient love as well as the more efficient soldier. An amusing manifestation of Sergius’s romantic temper is his fondness for striking a pose and uttering some grandiose statement of loyalty to his ideal. The utter foolishness of this “idealism” is exposed when Louka tricks him into kissing her hand after he has vowed to marry her if he ever touches her again. Louka haughtily tells him he can withdraw if he likes. Sergius declaims, “Withdraw! Never!” But when Catherine protests that he is bound by his word to Riana, Sergius draws himself up and
Arms and The Men
157
proclaims, “Nothing binds me!” In two consecutive speeches he has said in effect that he never breaks and that he never honors one. And he never recognize the contradiction. He is convinced throughout that he is acting according to some consistent principle of personal honor. He uses his “ideals,” quite unconsciously, not to guide his conduct, but to rationalize it. As Shaw informs us in a stage direction, Sergius’s “brooding on the perpetual failure, not only of others, but of himself, to live up to his ideals,” and his naïve “credulity as to the absolute validity of his concepts and the unworthiness of the world in disregarding them” have led him to a “cynical scorn for humanity.” Near the play’s end he tells Raina that love is “a hollow sham” and life is “a farce.” Bluntschli, in contrast, finds life “quite sensible and serious.” Nicola and Louka re-enact the play’s theme on a lower level. Louka has no illusions about the “higher love,” but she does have romantic aspirations of becoming a “lady.” Her fiancé, Nicola, is a realist. When Louka reproaches him with having “the soul of a servant” (compare Raina’s accusation that Bluntschli has “a low shop keeping mind”), Nicola replies, “Yes, that’s the secret of success in service.” Nicola, when the play begins, is engaged to Louka; but when he realizes that she has a real change of catching Sergius, he does not challenge Sergius to a duel. Rather, he helps her. He realizes that she is too proud and extravagant to make him a good wife; but she can be very useful to him as Sergius’s wife and his customer should he set up shop in the city. Bluntschli, recognizing a fellow realist, declares Nicola to be the “ablest man in Bulgaria” and offers him a hotel
158
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
managership if he can speak French and German. Shaw in this play has the forces of romanticism and realism lined up neatly against each other. But Shaw likes to upset the apple-cart. By a typical Shavian inversion, Sergius’s heroics do work (his charge wins the battle); Louka’s romantic aspirations prove practical (she catches Sergius); and Bluntschli, near the play’s end, describes himself as a man who has spoiled all his chances in life through an incurably romantic disposition. But we need take none of this too seriously. It’s Shaw’s mischievous tomfoolery plus his sense of the ironies of life. It doesn’t alter the basic thrust of the play. One more word about Bulntschli. He carries chocolate in his cartridge belt. Is not this a romantic whimsy? No. First, as an artillery officer, he has little need for a handgun. Second, during World War I, the U.S. Army developed a special ration for soldiers on missions that might separate them from their unit kitchens. What was it? A solid bar of chocolate. Concentrated energy food!
A Streetcar Named Desire By Tennessee Williams It is a small poor section of New Orleans, 1947. On a small street called Elysian Fields Blanche DuBois has come to see her sister. She comes bearing bad news. The family’s money has run out and with the loss of their estate Belle Reves, Blanche has no home and must now stay with Stella and her husband Stanley for a while. This news upsets Stella who moved to New Orleans to escape the hardship and death that permeated Belle Reve. As Blanche familiarizes herself with her new surroundings, problems are already apparent: Her constant condescension to Stella, her reproachful attitude towards the living condition, and her view of Stanley all provide seeds for later conflicts. Blanche DuBois is about 30. When she appears in New Orleans she appears to be the essence of purity. Wearing a white dress she is delicate and cannot bear vulgar language. She is intelligent yet prefers magic over realism. When she was 16 she married a young man who was gay. She found him in a compromising situation and when she told him he disgusted her, he committed suicide as an act which would affect her for the rest of her life. To deal with the death she began drinking and became rather promiscuous. However, there were other reasons for all the men. She felt that she had dissatisfied her husband in some way and she needed to fill her empty heart. Through the times of promiscuity she managed to retain a sense of purity and innocence. She demands to be seen for what she wished to be
160
A Student’s Guide to Some Major Plays
rather than what she really is. This is the reason for the paper lanterns and the constant bathing – she is creating her world of illusion. When Blanche meets Mitch, she shows him her world of illusion and he falls in love with it to the point that he asks her to marry him. When Stanley tells Mitch about the true Blanche, the illusion is shattered. He tries to tell this to Blanche and she insists that he leav