Structural Failure and Plasticity
Elsevier Science lnternet Homepage http://www.elsevier.nl (Europe) http://www.elsevier.com (America) http://www.elsevier.co.jp (Asia) Consult the Elsevier homepage for full catalogue information on all books, journals and electronic products and services.
Elsevier Titles of Related Interest VOYIADJIS & KATTAN Advances in Damage Mechanics: Metals and Matrix Composites ISBN: 008-0436013
Related Journals Free specimen copy gladly sent on request: Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford, OX5 1GB, UK Engineering Fracture Mechanics European Journal of Mechanics - A/Solids European Journal of Mechanics - A/Solids with European Journal of Mechanics - B/Fluids (Combined Subscription) International Journal of Fatigue International Journal of Impact Engineering International Journal of Non-Linear Mechanics International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping International Journal of Solids and Structures Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids Mechanics Research Communications Theoretical and Applied Fracture Mechanics Tribology International Wear
To Contact the Publisher Elsevier Science welcomes enquiries concerning publishing proposals: books, journal special issues, conference proceedings etc. All formats and media can be considered. Should you have a publishing proposal you wish to discuss, please contact, without obligation, the publisher responsible for Elsevier's engineering mechanics publishing programme: Ms Nicola Garvey Publishing Editor Elsevier Science Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 IGB, UK
Phone Fax E-mail
+44 (0) 1865 843879 +44 (0) 1865 843920 n.garvey @elsevier.co.uk
General enquiries, including placing orders, should be directed to Elsevier's Regional Sales Offices - please access the Elsevier homepage for full contact details (homepage details at the top of this page).
Structural Failure and Plasticity Proceedings of The Seventh Intemational Symposium on Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) 4-6 October 2000, Melboume, Australia
Edited by
X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta Department of Civil Engineering, Monash University, Claywn, VIC 3168, Australia
2000
PERGAMON An Imprint of Elsevier Science Amsterdam- Lausanne- New Y o r k - Oxford- Shannon- Singapore - Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK
9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Science, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, PO Box 800, Oxford OX5 i DX, UK; phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also contact Global Rights directly through Elsevier's home page (http://www.elsevier.nl), by selecting 'Obtaining Permissions'.. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (978) 7508400, fax: (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London WlP 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 207 631 5555; fax: (+44) 207 631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of Elsevier Science is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier Seience Global Rights Department, at the mail, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made.
First edition 2000 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record from the Library of Congress has been applied for. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record from the British Library has been applied for.
ISBN: 0 08 043875 X
The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Transferred to digital printing 2005 Printed and bound by Antony Rowe Ltd, Eastbourne
Preface The IMPLAST series of symposiums began in 1973 at the Indian Institute of Technology, in New Delhi, India. The theme of the symposia has been in the large deformation of materials and structures subjected to quasistatic, medium and high rates of loading. This symposium is the seventh in the series and the first time it has been held outside of India. Australia was chosen as a venue because of the strong bond that exists between the two countries and also because of the research work currently being carried out in the field of impact mechanics, crashworthiness and plastic deformation of structures. Delegates from more than 20 different countries from 5 continents have come together to present and discuss results from numerous studies in the field of impact and plasticity. What better place to hold such an international event at the start of the new Millennium than in a young nation, where a week before the symposium another inspiring international event was held, the Olympic Games. Most of the symposia have been run under the careful guidance of Professor N. K. Gupta. A very warm and generous host, Professor Gupta always encourages international researchers to visit his institute to motivate and inspire his fellow researchers. He has also encouraged a large number of famous international researchers to attend and speak at the various IMPLAST symposia so as to enhance the exchange of ideas and results among the world's applied mechanics fraternity. Professor Gupta's keynote lecture provides an overview of the contribution the IMPLAST series has made to impact and plasticity engineering and provides further insights into the plastic deformation of tubes and frusta. Melbourne has traditionally had a very strong research school in thin-walled structures. This evolved as a result of investigations into the West Gate bridge failure by the distinguished Professor Noel Murray. His contribution to engineering was honoured at the symposium dinner. This is also why this symposium had a distinct focus on thin-walled structures by the other two keynote presenters. Professor Rhode's paper provides an excellent overview of buckling of plated and thin walled structures, whereas Professor Usami's paper on plastic deformation of thin-walled structures under cyclic loading provides us with some valuable information on how such structures behave during seismic events. As mankind continues to push back the boundaries and begins to explore other worlds and the ocean depths, a thorough understanding of how structures behave when subjected to extremes in temperature, pressure, and high loading rates will be essential. This symposium provides the perfect forum for presenting research into structures subjected to such extreme loads. There were a large number of papers presented under topics of impact, blast and shock loading, indicating a strong research interest in high rates of loading. Similarly new topics have been added to the traditional symposia list such as fire loading, earthquake loading, and fatigue and connection failures. It is clear now that fundamental knowledge of plastic deformation of structures subjected to various extreme loads is coming of age. When the planning of this symposium began a large number of distinguished researchers agreed to join the International Scientific Committee to assist with technical content. The editors are honoured and grateful to all the members for their assistance. The editors were also saddened by the recent passing away of Dr. Raymond Woodward from Australia and Dr. Dusan Kecman from Cranfield, IYK. The international applied mechanics community holds Dr. Woodward's contributions to understanding material behaviour subjected to impact loads and in particular penetration mechanics, and Dr. Kecman's contributions to crashworthiness standards for vehicles and in particular bus rollovers, in high regard. As quiet achievers who encouraged scientific endeavour, their contributions and company will be sadly missed. The editors would also like to thank the organising committee for their assistance. They would also like to thank in particular the reviewers of the papers listed in the proceedings. Each full paper was peer reviewed by at least two experts in the field. The editors are most grateful to them for giving up their valuable time. Finally the editors would also like to warmly thank each of the delegates for preparing their papers, attending the conference and helping make the IMPLAST series a success. Raphael Grzebieta Xiao-Ling Zhao
V1
International Scientific Advisory Committee W. Abramowicz N. Burman S. F. Chen W. F. Chen E. C. Chirwa P. U. Deshpandey P. Grundy N. K. Gupta G. J. Hancock N. Ishikawa N. Jones D. Kecman t
C, W. Kim S. Kitipornchai T. Krauthammer J. Lindner H. A. Lupker Y. W. Mai P. Makelainen N. W. Murray G. Nurick J. A. Packer A. K. Rao R. G. Redwood S. R. Reid J. Rhodes J. Rondal G. Sedlacek G. S. Sekhon H. Schmidt N. E. Shanmugam Z. Y. Shen K. Sonoda G. Thierauf T. Usami J. Wardenier R. L. Woodward *
T. X. Yu R. Zandonini
Impact Design, Europe Department of Defence, DSTO Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology University of Hawaii, Manoa Bolton Institute Ministry of Defence Monash University Indian Institute of Technology The University of Sydney National Defence Academy University of Liverpool Cranfield Impact Centre Yonsei University University of Queensland The Pennsylvania State University Technical University of Berlin TNO Crash-Safety Research Centre The University of Sydney Helsinki University of Technology Monash University University of Cape Town University of Toronto Engineering Staff College of India McGill University UMIST University of Strathclyde University of Liege RWTH, Aachen Dept. of Applied Mechanics Universitat Gesamthochschule Essen National University of Singapore Tongji University Osaka City University Universitat Gesamthochschule Essen University of Nagoya Delft University of Technology Department of Defence, DSTO Hong Kong University of Science & Technology University of Trento
Poland Australia P. R. China USA UK h~dia Australia India Australia Japan UK UK South Korea Australia USA Germany The Netherlands Australia Finland Australia South Africa Canada India Canada UK UK Belgium Germany India Germany Singapore P. R. China Japan Germany Japan The Netherlands Australia P. R. China Italy
vii
Local O r g a n i s i n g C o m m i t t e e
Chairman Co-Chairman Symposium Manager Founding Chairman
Raphael H. Grzebieta Department of Civil Engineering, Monash University Xiao-Ling Zhao Department of Civil Engineering, Monash University Irene Thavarajah Office of Continuing Education, Monash University N. K. Gupta India Institute of Technology, India
Members: R. AI-Mahaidi G. Burkitt D. Saunders P. Dayawansa
G. X. Lu S. Richardson L. Pham A. Potts B. Wang L. Wilson
Department of Civil Engineering, Monash University VicRoads Department of Defence, DSTO Department of Mechanical Engineering, Monash University Swinburne University of Technology ATEA CSIRO Building, Construction & Engineering Australian Marine and Offshore Group Brunel University, Uxbridge, UK Australian Institute of Steel Construction
viii
Reviewers A. Abel A. Afaghi-Khatibi R. AI-Mahaidi M. Attard A. Baker J. Barrados Cardosa L. Beai A. Beasley I. Bennetts P. Berry M. Boutros E. Breil R. Q. Bridge N. Burman S. L. Chan W. F. Chen Y. Cheng S. Cimpoeru E. C. Chirwa P. Ciancy M. Clarke C. Clifton G. Davies P. Dayawansa I. Donald J. Eftis C.J. Flockhart H.B. Ge J. Ghojel J. Giercrak Y. Goto J.R. Griffiths R. H. Grzebieta P. Grundy N. K. Gupta L. Hammond B. K. Han L. H. Han G. J. Hancock H. Hansson N. Haritos S. Herion I. Herzberg W.P. Hu N. Ishikawa N. Jones
C. W. Kim H. Kitoh V. Kodur T. Krauthammer Y. Kurobane R. Lapovok L.A. Louca G. Lu S. J. Maddox M. Mahendran Y. W. Mai Y. Maki
The University of Sydney The University of Sydney Monash University The University of New South Wales DSTO Instituto Superior Tecnico Queensland University of Technology University of Tasmania Victoria University of Technology University of Western Sydney University of Western Australia University of Southern Queensland University of Western Sydney DSTO The Hong Kong Polytechnic University University of Hawaii, Manoa The University of Sydney DSTO Bolton Institute Victoria University of Technology The University of Sydney HERA Nottingham University Monash University Monash University University of Texas, E1 Paso DSTO Nagoya University Monash University Technical University of Wroclaw Nagoya Institute of Technology CSIRO Monash University Monash University Indian Institute of Technology DSTO Hong-ik University Hanbin University of Civil Engineering The University of Sydney Defence Research Establishment The University of Melbourne Universtiy of Karlsruhe Monash University DSTO National Defence Academy University of Liverpool Institute of Automobile Technology Osaka City University Institute for Research in Construction The Pennsylvania State University Kumamoto Institute of Technology CSIRO Imperial College, London Swinburne University of Technology TWI University of Queensland The University of Sydney Hosei University
Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia Portugal Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia P.R. China USA Australia Australia UK Australia Australia New Zealand UK A ustralia Australia USA Australia Japan Australia Poland Japan Australia Australia Australia India Australia South Korea P. R. China Australia Sweden Australia Germany Australia Australia Japan UK South Korea Japan Canada USA Japan Australia UK Australia UK Australia Australia Japan
ix
P. Makelainen J. Marco I. Marshall R. Meichers P. Mendis T. Mori A. Mouritz N. W. Murray W. Muzykiewicz N.T. Nguyen G. Nurick J. A. Packer A. W. Page N. Page J. Papangelis H. Pasternak Y. L. Pi K.W. Poh A. Potts J. Price B. V. Rangan A. K. Rao K. Rasmussen G. Rechnitzer A. Resnyanski C. A. Rogers A. Ruys G. Sanjayan Z. Y. Shen D. R. Sherman D. Shu L. Sironic S. Sloan I. Smith K. Sonoda G. Stevins N. Stokes N. Stranghoener M. Takla G. Taplin J. G. T eng P. Thomson F. Tin-Loi C. Tingvall N. Trahair B. Uy B. Wang C. Wang K. Weynand T. Wilkinson B. Wong M. Xie Y. L. Xu Y. B. Yang G. Yiannakipoulas T. X. Yu R. Zandonini Q. Zhang X. L. Zhao R. Zou
Helsinki University of Technology DSTO Monash University The University of Newcastle The University of Melbourne Hosei University DSTO Monash University The University of Mining & Metallurgy The University of Sydney University of Cape Town University of Toronto The University of Newcastle The University of Newcastle The University of Sydney BTV Cottbus The University of New South Wales Victoria University of Technology Australian Marine & Offshore Group Monash University Curtin University of Technology Engineering Staff College The University of Sydney Monash University DSTO McGill University The University of Sydney Monash University Tonji University University of Wisconsin Nanyan Technical University Monash University University of Newcastle University of New Brunswick Osaka City University The University of Sydney CSIRO HRA Ingenieurgesellschaft mbH RMIT Monash University The Hong Kong Polytechnic University Monash University University of New South Wales Monash University The University of Sydney The University of New South Wales Brunel University DSTO RWTH, Aachen The University of Sydney Monash University Victoria University of Technology The Hong Kong Polytechnic University National Taiwan University DSTO Hong Kong University of Science & Technology University of Trento University of Western Sydney Monash University Monash University
Finland Australia Australia Australia Australia Japan Australia Australia Poland Australia South Africa Canada Australia Australia Australia Germany Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia India Australia Australia Australia Canada Australia Australia P. R. China USA Singapore Australia Australia Canada Japan Australia Australia Germany Australia Australia P. R. China Australia Australia Australia Australia Australia UK Australia Germany Australia Australia Australia P. R. China Taiwan Australia P. R. China Italy Australia Australia Australia
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS Preface International Scientific Advisory Committee
vi
Local Organising Committee
vii
Reviewers
viii
Keynote Papers IMPLAST Symposia and Large Deformations- A Perspective N. K. Gupta Buckling of Thin Plates and Thin-Plate Members- Some Points of Interest J. Rhodes
21
Failure Predictions of Thin-Walled Steel Structures under Cyclic Loading T. Usami and H.B. Ge
43
Impact Loading On the Criteria for Cracking and Rupture of Ductile Plates under Impact Loading N. Jones and C. Jones
55
Dynamic Behavior of Elastic-Plastic Beam-on-Foundation under Impact or Pulse Loading X.W. Chen, T.X. Yu and Y.Z. Chen
61
Load Deformation of Thin Tubular Beam under Impact Load N. lshikawa, Y. Kajita, K. Takemoto and O. Fukuchi
67
Normal Impact of Spherical Balls on Metallic Plates P.U. Deshpande and N.K. Gupta
73
Impact Performance and Safety of Steel Highway Guard Fences Y. ltoh, C. Liu and S. Suzuki
79
Impact Behavior of Shear Failure Type RC Beams T. Ando, N. Kishi, H. Mikami and K.G. Matsuoka
87
Nonlinear Dynamic Response Design and Control Optimization of Flexible Mechanical Systems under Impact Loading J. Barradas Cardoso, P.P. Moita and J.A. Castro
93
Influence of Impact Loads on the Behavior at Alternative Bending over Pulleys of Steel Wires G. Crespo
99
xii Dynamic Actions on Highway Bridge Decks due to an Irregular Pavement Surface
103
J. G.S. da Silva
Elastic-Viscoplastic-Microdamage Modeling to Simulate Hypervelocity Projectile-Target Impact and Damage
109
J. Efiis, C. Carrasco and R. Osegueda
Experimental and Numerical Studies of Projectile Perforation in Concrete Targets
115
H. Hansson and L. ~g&rdh
Prototype Impact Tests on Ultimate Impact Resistance of PC Rock-Shed
121
N. KishL H. Konno, K. Ikeda and K.G. Matsuoka
Penetration Equations for the Impact of 7.62 mm Ball Projectile against Composite Material Sheets of an Aircraft
127
P. Kumar, R.A. Goel and KS. Sethi
High Strength Concrete Beams Subjected to Impact Load- Some Experimental Results 133 J. Magnusson, H. Hansson and L. ~gttrdh
Impact Response of a Laminated Cylindrical Composite Shell Panel
139
P. Mahajan, K.S. Krishnamurthy and R.K. Mittal
Dynamic Testing of Energy Absorber System for Aircraft Arrester
145
K.K. Malik, P. K. Khosla, P.H. Pande and R. K. Verma
Characteristics of Crater Formed under Ultra-high Velocity Impact
151
S. Pazhanivel and V.K. Sharma
Diagnostic Techniques for High Speed Events
157
V.S. Sethi and S.S. Sachdeva
Shock Test and Stress Analysis of a Heavy Metal Forge
165
Y. M. Wu, B. Samali, J. C. Li and S. Bakoss
Blast/Shock Loading Air Blast Simulations using Multi-Material Eulerian/Lagrangian Techniques
173
J. Marco
Damage Evaluation of Structures Subjected to the Effects of Underground Explosions
179
R. Kumari, H. Lal, M.S. Bola and KS. Sethi
An Investigation of Structures subjected to Blast Loads incorporating an Equation of State to Model the Material Behaviour of the Explosive
185
W.P. Grobbelaar and G.N. Nurick
An UNDEX Response Validation Methodology J.L. 0 'Daniel T. Krauthammer, K.L. Koudela and L.H. Strait
195
xiii
The Effects of Local Cavitation and Diffraction on the Underwater Shock Response of an Air-backed 2D Plate Structures with Large Deflections L.C. Hammond and C.J. Flockhart
201
Ductile Failure of Welded Connections to Corrugated Firewalls subjected to Blast Loading L.A. Louca and J. Friis
209
Design Criteria for Blast Tolerant Bulkheads 1. Raymond, M. Chowdhury and D. Kelly
217
The Ballistic Impact of Hybrid Armour Systems H.H. Billon
223
Large Scale Blast Analysis of Reinforced Concrete with Advanced Constitutive Models on High Performance Computers K.T. Danielson, M.D. Adley, S.A. Akers and P.P. Papados
229
Fracture Mechanism of Pre-split Blasting A. K Dyskin and A.N. Galybin
235
Evaluation of Energy Absorption System for Intense Shock Mitigation LJ.L. JaggL R. Kumari, H. Lal and V.S. Sethi
241
Blast Damage Effects of an Explosion of 5 ton TNT Kept in Storage Magazine H. Lal, R.K. Verma, M.S. Bola and V.S. Sethi
247
Evaluation of Damage and TNT Equivalent of Ammunition, Explosive and Pyrotechnics P. Buri, M.M. Verma and H. Lal
255
New Approach to Street Architecture to Reduce the Effects of Blast Waves in Urban Environments E. H. Mahmoud and J. G. Hetherington
261
Generation and Measurement of High Stresses under Shock Hugoniots S.S. Sachdeva, H. Lal, M.S. Bola and V.S.Sethi
267
Dynamic Response of Model Reactor Structure subjected to Internal Blast Loads A.K. Sharma, V.S. Sethi and P. Chellapandi
275
Spallation of Explosively Clad Metal Plates V.K. Sharma, II. Srivastava and D.R. Kaushik
281
Stress and Strain Magnification Effects in Structural Joints under Shock Loading G. Szuladzinski
287
Numerical Methods in Underwater Shock Simulations H.H. Tran and J. Marco
295
xiv Reinforced Masonry Walls under Blast Loading C. Mayrhofer
301
Crashworthiness
Plastic Collapse Mechanisms of Lifeguards for the Class 465 EMU Bogies E.C. Chirwa, E.J. Searancke, A. Hoe and S.M.P. Wong
311
Application of Multibody Dynamics for Simulating Vehicle Impacts on Steel Safety Guardrails G. Sedlecek, C. Kammel, U.J. Gefller and D. Neuenhaus
319
A Large-Deflection Design Technique for the Collapse and Roll-over Analysis of Thin-Walled Tubular Frames S.J. Cimpoeru, N. W. Murray and R.H. Grzebieta
325
A Method of Estimating Velocity in a Car Crash K. Fujiwara
333
Dynamic Characteristics of Bicycle Helmets S.K. Hui and T.X. Yu
339
Crash and High Velocity Impact Simulation Methodologies for Aircraft Structures C.M. Kindervater, A. Johnson, D. Kohlgrfiber and M. Liitzenburger
345
Design for Crash Safety in Mine Shafts G.J. Krige, W. van S c h a l ~ k and M.M. Khan
353
Comparison of Different Car Front Structures under Nonaxial Impacts M. KrOger
361
Impact Attenuation of Frontal Protection Systems in Passenger Vehicles P. Bignell, D. Thambiratnam and F. Bullen
367
Tubular/SheU Structures
Unified Theory for Collapse of Thin Rectangular Tubes under Compression C.W. Kim, B.K. Han and C.H. Jeong
375
Stress-Strain Relationship for Confined Concrete in Various Shapes of Concrete-Filled Steel Columns K.A.S. Susantha, H.B. Ge and T. Usami
383
Experimental Behaviour of Internally-Pressurized Cone-Cylinder Intersections Y. Zhao and J. G. Teng
389
FEM Analysis of Buckling of Thin-Walled Tubes under Dynamic Loading B. Wang and G. Lu
395
XV
Axial Crushing of Aluminum Columns with Aluminum Foam Filler A.G. Hanssen, M. Langseth and O.S. Hopperstad
401
Failure Mechanism and Behavior of Thin-Walled Reinforced Concrete Barrels under Lateral Loading M.A. lssa, M.A. Issa and R.H. Bryant
407
Crushing Behaviour of Composite Domes and Conical Shells under Axial Compression N.K. Gupta, R. Velmurugan and M.S. Palanichamy
413
The Influence of Residual Stresses in the Vicinity of Circumferential Weld-Induced Imperfections on the Buckling of Silos and Tanks M. Pitcher and R.Q. Bridge
419
Improved Marshall Strut Element to Predict the Ultimate Strength of Braced Tubular Steel Offshore Structures K. Srirengan and P. IV. Marshall
425
The Aseismatic Behaviour of High Strength Concrete Filled Steel Tube Z. Wang and Y.H. Zhen Stub-Column Failure Test of Welded Box Steel Section under Axial Compressive Loading Y.C. Zhang, J.J. Zhang, IV. Y. Zhang and D.S. Li
431
437
Strength and Ductility of Concrete Filled Double Skin Square Hollow Sections X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta
443
The Quasi-Static Piercing of Square Tubes G. Lu and J. Zhang
451
The Splitting of Square Tubes G. Lu, T.X. Yu and X. Huang
457
Strength and Ductility of Concrete-Filled Circular Compact Steel Tubes under Large Deformation Pure Bending M. Elchalakani, X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta
463
Connections
Finite Element Modelling of Bolted Flange Connections J.J. Cao, J.A. Packer and S. Du Experimental Behaviour of Moment Connections between Concrete Filled Steel Tubes and Structural Steel Framing Beams J. Beutel, N. Perera and D. Thambiratnam Strength and Ductility of Bolted Connections in Normal and High Strength Steels A. Aalberg and P.K. Larsen
473
479
487
xvi Evaluation of Beam-to-Column Connections with Weld Defects based on CTOD Design Curve Approach
495
K. Azuma, Y. Kurobane and Y. Makino
Simulation of Fracture Failure of Steel Beam-to-Column Connections
501
Y. Chen, Z.D. Jiang and Y.J. Zhang
Failure Analysis of Bolted Steel Flanges
507
P. Schaumann and M. Seidel
Ultimate Capacity of Bolted Semi-Rigid Connections to the Column Minor Axis
513
L.R.O. de Lima, P.C.G. da S. Vellasco and S.A.L. de Andrade
Buckling The Effects of Fabrication on the Buckling of Thin-Walled Steel Box Sections
521
M. Pircher, M.D. 0 'Shea and R.Q. Bridge
Inelastic Dynamic Instabilities of Steel Columns
527
T. Yabuki, Y. Arizumi, C. Gentile and L. W. Lu
Plastic Buckling of Circular Sandwich Plates
533
S. C. Shrivastava
Buckling Instability of a Curved-Straight Pipe Configuration Conveying Fluid
539
A.M. Al-dumaily
Axial Crushing of Frusta between Two Parallel Plates
545
A.A.A. Alghamdi, A.A.N. AljawL T.M.-N. Abu-Mansour and R.A.A. Mazi
Strength Analysis of Buckled Thin-Walled Composite Cylindrical Shell with Hydrostatic Loading
551
J. Brauns
Imperfection Sensitivity Function in Dynamic Response and Failure of 1-D Plastic Structures
557
F.L. Chen and T.X. Yu
Straightening Effects of Steel I-beams Failed by Lateral-Torsional Buckling
563
M. Kubo and N. Sugiyama
Ductility/Constitutive Models Investigation of Damage Accumulation using Equal Channel Angular Extrusion/Drawing
571
R. Lapovok, R. Cottam and R. Deam
A Simplified Constitutive Model for Steel Material under Cyclic Loading Conditions S. Murakami, S. Nara, Y. Shimazu and T. Konishi
579
xvii Acceleration Waves and Dynamic Material Instability in Constitutive Relations for Finite Deformation P.B. B~da and G. B~da
585
Plastic Deformation and Creep of Polymer Concrete with Polybutadiene Matrix O. Figovsky, D. Beilin and dr. Potapov
591
Study of Influence of Loading Method on Results of the Split Hopkinson Bar Test A.D. Resnyansky
597
Enhanced Ductility of Copper under Large Strain Rates D.R. Saroha, G. Singh and M.S. Bola
603
Kinematics of Large Deformations and Objective Eulerian Rates A. Meyers, O. Bruhns and H. Xiao
609
A Study of the Large Deformation Mechanisms of Weft-Knitted Thermoplastic Textile Composites P. Xue, T.X. Yu and X.M. Tao
615
Fire Loading Nonlinear Analysis of Three-Dimensional Steel Truss in Fire P. Fedczuk and W. Skowrohski Modelling of Plastic Strength of Composite Tubular Members under Elevated Temperature Conditions M.B. Wong, ,1.1. Ghojel and N.L. Patterson The Experimental and Theoretical Behaviour of Composite Floor Slabs during a Fire C. G. Bailey
623
629
635
Thermal Contact Resistance at the Concrete/Steel Interface of Concrete-Filled Steel Columns J.I. Ghojel
641
Mathematical Model for the Prediction of Temperature Response of Steel Columns Filled with Concrete and Exposed to Fires J.I. Ghojel
647
Non-elastic Load Capacity of Compressed Steel Truss Member during Fire G. Ginda and W. Skowrohski Fire Resistance of Concrete Filled Steel Tubular Beam-Columns in China State of the Art L.H. Han and X.L. Zhao
653
659
xviii
Earthquake Loading Experimental Study on Steel Bridge Piers with Inner Cruciform Plates subjected to Cyclic Lateral Loads K. Iwatsubo, T. Yamao, T. Yamamuro and M. Ogushi
667
Evaluation of Steel RoofDiaphragrn Side-Lap Connections subjected to Seismic Loading C.A. Rogers and R. Tremblay
673
Low Cycle Fatigue of Concrete Filled Steel Tube Members K. Tateishi, T. Saitoh and K. Muramta The Importance of Further Studies on the Capacity Evaluation of Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes under Large Deformation Cyclic Loading C. Lee, R.H. Grzebieta and X.L. Zhao Design of Large Bridge over the Matchesta River in Seismic Zone A. Likverman, G. Shestoperov and V. Seliverstov
679
685
691
Fracture/Fatigue Tensile Fracture Behaviour of Thin G550 Sheet Steels C.A. Rogers and G.J. Hancock
699
Fatigue Strength Properties of Stainless Clad Steel T. Mori
705
Testing of Welded T-Joint with Fatigue Cracks and Comparison with Failure Assessment Diagram T. lwashita, Y. Makino, K. Azuma and Y. Kurobane
711
Crack Surface Contact under Alternating Plasticity C.H. Wang and L.R.F. Rose
717
Modelling of the Cyclic Ratchetting and Mean Stress Relaxation Behaviour of Materials Exhibiting Transient Cyclic Sot~ening W. Hu and C.H. Wang
723
Influence of Specimen and Maximum Aggregate Size on Concrete Brittle Fracture M.A. Issa, M.S. Islam, M.A. Issa and A. Chudnovsky
729
Fatigue Design of Welded Very Thin-Walled Tube-to-Plate Joints using the Classification Method F.R. Mashiri, X.L. Zhao and P. Grundy
735
Cosserat and Non-local Continuum Models for Problems of Wave Propagation in Fractured Materials E. Pasternak and H.B. Miihlhaus
741
xix Dynamic Tensile Deformation and Fracture of Metal Cylinders at High Strain Rate M. Singh, H.R. Suneja, M.S. Bola and S. Prakash
747
Energy Balance in Dynamic Brittle Rock Failure B. G. Tarasov
753
Stress Intensity Factors for Tubular T-Joints with a Curved Surface Crack B. Wang, S.T. Lie and Z.H. Xiang
759
Effect of the Environment and Corrosion on the Fatigue Life of a Simulated Aircraft Structural Joint S. Russo, P.K. Sharp, R. Dhamari, T.B. Mills, B.R.W. Hinton, K. Shankar and G. Clark
765
Numerical Simulation
Plastic Instability Simulation of Steel in Tension S. Okazawa and T. Usami
775
Several Practical Criteria for Nonlinear Dynamic Stability of Lattice Structures Z.-Y. Shen, Z.-X. Li and C.-G. Deng
781
Snap-Through Analysis of Toggle Frame using the Software Package, NIDA, by 1 Element per Member S.L. Chan and J.X. Gu Second-Order Inelastic Analysis of Steel Gable Frames Comprising Tapered Members G.Q. Li and J.J. Li
787
795
A Parallel Three-Dimensional Elasto-Plastic Finite Element Analysis in a Workstation Cluster Environment Z. Ding, S. Kalyanasundaram, L. Grosz, S. Roberts and M. Cardew-Hall
801
Limit Analysis of Cylindrical Shells subjected to Ring LoadA Comparative Study between Analytical and Numerical Solutions J.R.Q. Franco and F.B. Barros
807
Finite Element Simulation of Deep Drawing of Laminated Steel Y.F. Kwan and M. Takla
813
Analytical Solution for Semi-Infinite Body subjected to 3D Moving Heat Source and its Application in Weld Pool Simulation N. T. Nguyen
819
Pseudorigidity Method (PRM) for Solving the Problem of Limit Equilibrium of Rigid-Plastic Constructions Y. Routman
827
Damage Identification and Restoration of Space Frame using Genetic Algorithm C.W. Shen, X.B. Tang and H.H. Sun
833
XX
Simulation of the Hysteretic Behavior of RC Columns with Footings F.F. Sun, Z.Y. Shen and X.L. Gu
839
An Analytical Method for Analysis of Curved Pair Members tied with Struts H. lshihara, T. Yamao and 1. Hirai
845
Numerical Analysis and Simulation for Cold Extrusion S.X. Zhang, B.K. Chen and H.H. Sun
851
General Structures
Experimental Analysis on Key Components of Steel Storage Pallet Racking Systems N. Baldassino, C. Bernuzzi and R. Zandonini Response of Large Space Building Floors to Dynamic Loads which Suddenly Move to a New Position S. W. Alisjahbana
859
865
Effects of Cables on the Behavior of I-Section Arches Y.L. Guo and J.S. Ju
871
Shakedown of Three Layered Pavements S.H. Shiau and H.S. Yu
877
Laser Application to Surface Deformation and Material Failure S.H. Slivinsky, P. Kugler, H. Drude and R. Schwarze
883
Author Index
889
Keynote Papers
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All fights reserved.
IMPLAST SYMPOSIA AND LARGE DEFORMATIONSPERSPECTIVE
A
N.K. Gupta Department of Applied Mechanics, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, New Delhi 110 016, India
IMPLAST symposia have come of age, and are valued by the IMPLAST fraternity. A brief history of IMPLAST and its growth since the first in the series was held in 1973, and the contributions that these symposia have made to the subject in general, are reviewed. Over the years there has been a phenomenal growth in the analytical, numerical, and experimental methods for the study of large deformation problems. Mechanics of large deformations, however, is yet not fully understood, and experimental observations are of help in providing plausible explanations, realistic assumptions, and parameters for the analysis of the phenomenon. In the second part of this paper, some observations in large deformation experiments which I hope would be of interest are presented. 1. A JOURNEY THROUGH TIME It is a great honour to be invited to deliver this lecture to IMPLAST-2000, organised by Prof. R. H. Grzebieta and Dr. X.L. Zhao of Monash University. It is the seventh symposium in this series, and in fact the first one outside India- all the previous six were held at the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi (liT, Delhi). The first of the series was held in November 1973, and its main theme was "Stress Waves in Solids". It all began in 1971 when some like-minded people, encouraged by Prof. B. Karunes of the Department of Applied Mechanics, IIT, Delhi, met. They thought that it would be both expedient and essential for scientists from laboratories, industry and academia to group together and seek motivation in becoming aware of the technical developments in the areas of large deformations at low medium and high velocities of impact. This motivation was essentially conceived in national (Indian) context and a beginning was sought in providing a forum wherein the scientists from various organisations would come together and share their findings on a specific topic within the realm of Plasticity and Impact Mechanics. It was also envisaged that we would invite some renowned scientists from abroad who would share their perception and familiarise us with the latest developments in the subject. We all felt the need to point towards another dimension of curriculum development such that the student body was enabled to keep pace with the theory and practice thus substantiated. Efforts were also made for sensitising and activating hard core industry and state enterprises to make use of the research produced, in the aegis towards real life applications.
During that period some of our own research on large deformation problems involved analysis based on stress wave phenomenon. We also got in touch with scientists working in the area, particularly those in Indian defence laboratories where a lot of experimental work was being done on high speed impact problems. Stress waves in solids, particularly for large deformation problems, seemed almost the obvious choice for the theme of the first symposium that was held on November 1 and 2 in 1973. About eighty scientists from defence and other laboratories, and academic institutions in India attended the symposium; and, Prof. H. Kolsky from Brown University was the key invitee. It was also the beginning of an era in which our defence scientists began participating in an open platform to share their experiences, hitherto kept in closets, mostly. The symposium had its impact on the national scene, and the scientists working in the area became familiar with others having similar interests. Experimental techniques, and analytical as well as numerical methods were progressing at a rapid rate. Every institute, not being able to afford in house all the facilities and the expertise, greatly benefited from the co-operation between scientists, which definitely got a big boost because of this coming together. A modest beginning was made - a nucleus of a fraternity was thus formed. Several analytical, numerical, and experimental studies involving large deformations under low, medium, and high velocity impact were presented [1] in the symposium. Discussions among the participants and those with Prof. Kolsky were quite stimulating. The experience was so good that in the valedictory meeting, it was decided that we would have such meetings biennially on some specialised themes within the general area of static and dynamic plasto-mechanics of large deformations. In 1975, the second symposium was held under the title "Large Deformations in Solids". Here again, the problems dealt with were those of large deformations at speeds ranging from a few mm/s to km/s [2]. The current state of research in India was reviewed as scientists from defence laboratories as well as those from other institutes presented the problems of their immediate interest and disclosed their inadequacies. This provided a basis for some of very fruitful co-operation between the laboratories and the academic institutes. During the above period, much progress was made in improving our own experimental facilities at IIT Delhi, and several of us had increased interaction with senior scientists outside India as well. I too spent six months in 1977 at the University of Cambridge, U.K., with Professor W. Johnson. That was my first stay abroad and it was the first time that I attended an international conference outside India. This provided me with an opportunity of meeting several other scientists in the area. On my return I found Professor Karunes very sick, and in June, 1978, he sadly passed a w a y - and that was the end of our ten-year long memorable and fruitful association. On 17-19 Dec., 1978, we had the third symposium which was dedicated to the memory of Late Prof. B. Karunes. This symposium saw a great change in both objectives of the meeting and the level and quality of participation. We had 130 scientists participating from India and about 25 from abroad. An excellent account of the state of research in large deformation mechanics was given by Prof. W. Johnson [3] and this provided great stimulation and impetus for us. Prof. Th. Lehmann's paper on "Some aspects of coupling effects in thermo-plasticity"[4] and Prof. E.T. Onat's presentation on "Why (and how) should one use a tensor to describe the internal state and orientation of deforming material?", [5] provided an excellent exposition of the constitutive behaviour
of materials. The symposium proceedings was entitled "Large Deformations" [6], and it contained papers dealing with analytical, numerical and experimental studies. Though it took more than two years to come out after the symposium was held, the papers eventually were much improved because of the discussions that took place during the symposium. Those four days of being together generated a bond between all the participating scientists and the IMPLAST fraternity became international. Prof. Johnson encouraged such activity and himself attended all the three IMPLAST symposia held at liT Delhi, thereafter. In the mean time several other congresses came to be organised by societies such as the Indian Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics and particularly the Indian Society of Mechanical Engineering, which was formed in 1977. Several of us became office bearers of such societies and were responsible for organising their functions that included the annual conferences. IMPLAST seemed to have merged into these, and was not held as a separate event in the eighties. However, the interaction that started between the scientists during the earlier three meetings continued. The conferences of the societies were very broad in scope and it was quite natural that we began to feel the need for putting in special efforts in exchanging our ideas and reviving our own forum for disseminating our research in the area of plasticity and impact mechanics. The fourth event, as a consequence, was thus organised on Nov. 7-13, 1990. In this meeting each day was devoted to an aspect of large deformations. Keynote lectures presented by Prof. W. Johnson, Prof. N. Jones and Prof. S.R. Reid, amongst others, set the ball rolling in different sessions [7]. A special feature of this meeting was that time was found to discuss some already published research papers on each important aspect. The exercise turned out to be very interesting and extensive exchange of ideas took place leading to suggestions for possible procedures in studying various problems, which were of current interest to many of us. The experience of being together for a few days created fresh bonds and it was decided that the IMPLAST meetings would be held henceforth every third year. IMPLAST'93 was the fifth symposium and it was held on Dec. 11-14, 1993 with the title Plasticity and Impact Mechanics. This coincided with the 10th anniversary of the start-up of the International Journal of Impact Engineering. "Unfinished military history, Plate cutting, and Heat lines" was the title of Prof. Johnson's keynote lecture [8]. In the first part of the lecture, he talked of some historical facets related to Benjamin Robins and his stay in India in the middle of the 18th century. Attention was drawn to the fact that the historical facet is now almost totally neglected by universities; students are not afforded the opportunity to read and learn about men such as themselves, to gain insight into how they faced their life and its specific issues in previous generations. Other keynote lectures [9] included those of Prof. C.R. Calladine [10], Prof. N. Jones [11], Prof. Kozo Ikegami [12], and Prof. N.W. Murray [13]. Prof. Murray's presence in the symposium brought several of us close to him and to Australia. His personal charm and concern for others led to lasting friendships, which we all cherish. The participation in IMPLAST'93 and also in IMPLAST'96, held on 11-14 Dec., 1996, was truly international with scientists participating from various countries including Australia, Canada, France, Germany, India, Japan, the Netherlands, Russia, Singapore, South Africa, UAE, UK, and USA. These symposia dealt with mechanics of large deformation and failure of structures and components when subjected to low, medium, and high velocity impact. Different
materials considered included metals, composites, concrete, wood, and ice. Basic principles, experiments, and formulations presented dealt with important problems such as formulation of constitutive equations including high temperatures and strain rates; analysis of large deformations and failures in structures subjected to excessive dynamic loading; design for survivability and control for collision damage in aircraft, ships, trains, and road vehicles; and determination of ballistic response of armours and structures to high velocity impact and explosion. Keynote lectures in IMPLAST'96 [14] were delivered by Prof. W. Johnson [15],Prof. O.T. Bruhns [16] and Prof. N. Jones [17]. Prof. W Johnson had his 75 th birth anniversary in 1996, and in IMPLAST'96 we had a special function to felicitate him for the contributions he has made to various facets of plasticity and impact engineering. In the valedictory meeting of IMPLAST'96, Prof. Grzebieta kindly offered to hold IMPLAST'2000 in Australia, which was more than readily agreed by all the participants. This is thus the first meeting of the series outside India and of course so well organised. With the phenomenal growth of the multinationals, and global transactions opening up of the geographic space beyond India, this symposium in itself, is the starting point for yet another dimension of the IMPLAST. I do hope that all the participants will enjoy being together during the symposium, and would look forward to being together every three years in future too. Over a period of three decades, from a modest beginning, essentially conceived to be a national endeavour, IMPLAST has grown to be a valued international event. Prof. R.H. Grzebieta and Dr. X.L. Zhao have done a magnificent job in organising this symposium over three days in Melbourne just after the Olympics have concluded. I am sure we all are enjoying our stay here. I express my gratitude to them for this - and for all the efforts that they and their colleagues have put in to make it such a grand and memorable affair. 2. LARGE DEFORMATIONS - A PERSPECTIVE Mechanics of large deformation is inherently a complex phenomenon. What makes it more complex is its dependence on various parameters like strain rate, inertia, history of loading, annealing and thermal processes, and geometry. Simple formulations that describe large deformations and bring together various facets affecting deformation are not available. There is a lack of understanding of the mechanics of the large deformation phenomenon. Structured experiments are essential to be able to study the phenomenon and be able to understand the effects thereon of various parameters of the situation. Motivated by the needs of defence, desire for better safety measures against disasters, industrial applications, and academic interests, great improvements have been made in analytical, numerical, and experimental methods for the solution of such problems. However, many problems relating to the deformation modes and their dependence on various parameters, remain unresolved. Our experiments at IIT Delhi, for understanding the mechanics of large deformations, over the last four decades have been an attempt to study the phenomenon in its varied aspects and to propose simple solutions based on the mechanics observed. In what follows, typical observations in some large deformation experiments, which are of interest, are presented in a hope that plausible explanation for these having been found, would help in understanding the large deformation
phenomenon. Obviously, I have not tried to exhaustively dwell in explaining the phenomenon, some of which can be seen in the references cited.
2.1. Necking in Simple Tension The tensile deformation and the corresponding influence of specimen size, particularly in relation to the instability condition leading to the onset of necking [18, 19] is an interesting phenomenon. The classical treatment of instability suggests that a neck would appear in a round specimen of a strain hardening material at the peak of the load displacement relation. This criterion, as revealed by past studies appears to be valid for time independent material behaviour and also when slenderness ratio is quite high. Studies have shown that the appearance of necking is delayed well beyond the point of maximum load due to both strain rate sensitivity and decrease in slenderness ratio. It is, however, evident from the existing literature that tensile deformation, particularly after
2.00t
(o) 3230 I 20
1.00
LO=10Omrn,do=30rnrn
0~ I
~~'"~'~
to0.20
C~,~
"~
~~
O.lO
]D
09/-,
d
(b) b
c
z
Q- 10 0
I
10
j,,
~
,
I
rn)2Orn30~ 8( ,045
0s
80 80100120150180220d. ~(MNm_2)._.
Fig. l. (a) Load - deformation curve for an aluminium specimen; and (b) stress - plastic strain data superposed for several aluminium specimens the onset of necking, has not been amenable to simple analytical solution. Presented below are some results of simple uniaxial tension tests on specimens of different original diameters and slenderness ratios, which reveal some very interesting features. These are of relevance to the understanding of (a) stress and load conditions at the onset of nonuniform deformation and its further localization; (b) the manner in which uniform deformation transforms itself into localized necking; and (c) effect of specimen size on the tensile response of a material. A typical load deformation curve for an annealed aluminium specimen is shown in Fig. 1(a), wherein three regions AB, BC and CD have been identified and corresponding extensions during these periods are denoted as 61 , 6 2 , and 8 3 respectively. A typical true stress and plastic strain data based on the current diameter measurements at the neck section, both before and after its formation, is shown in Fig. 1(b), superposed for many specimens. The corresponding three regions herein are marked as ab, be, and cd. Careful experiments on several specimens revealed that (a) 81 is dependent on length of specimen and independent of its diameter; (b) 8 2 is a function of both diameter and
length of the specimen; and (c) ~53 is dependent on original diameter of the specimen and is rather independent of length. Fig. 2 illustrates the nature of these relationships for 45-
40-
/
(o)
30 E ,EE20co 10 / / / / 0
19 -
/ $1=0"225 L~ ,
I 20 r
~
,
50
,
100
,
150 200
(b)
o< =Lo/d o
eb=0"2011 f15 ~" s =0.3456 E o< =16.67~
/
=
/
9.33-
10 -
/
6.67-',Z~/,
Lo(mm) ' ' "
do(rnm) ~
do(turn)
--~
Fig. 2. Dependence of (a) ~51, (b) ~52, and (c) ~53, on length or diameter of the specimen aluminium specimens. Interestingly no such dependence was apparent in the stressplastic strain data, derived from the continuous measurements of the current specimen diameter, see Fig. 1(b). During a test, if we measure the current diameter at two sections of the specimen - a neck section and a section away from the neck - it is seen that, (a) the diameter reduction is identical at both sections until the specimen extension is 51 , and, therefore, the specimen deformation is uniform until this stage; (b) during the period of extension 8 2 , the reduction in diameter at neck section is faster than the corresponding reduction at the other section, indicating thereby that the deformation during this period begins to be differential over the length of the specimen; and (c) the deformation during the period of extension 6 3 is accompanied by a continuous fall of load, with diameter reducing only at the neck section. Loss of stability is thus seen to be a gradual process that occurs during
_d2.5 "
,-1. '
I--
-
I--~-60~--"11~- 0 100 ,--. (o) _[.6.2 ~-~6C -"~,
5.4
.."
J
I
""---'-1"
--q.lOl'--~ 60
"~1 . ~
D
=I
~1OI------60----~ =.101~---
~----- 60
-f:
-
60"-"--~
-,
(d~1:
Fig. 3. Alumium specimen: (a) untested; (b) when unloaded at a stage of necking; (c) refigured; (d) with neck formed at the specimen end on retesting
the period of extension 82 , and as a consequence a sort of diffused neck extending over the length of the specimen precedes the appearance of a localised neck. With the onset of non-uniform deformations, strain hardening, and the instability stress marking the initiation of necking, begin to be different over the length of the specimen [15]. To illustrate this, a uniform specimen of diameter 9 mm, see Fig. 3 (a), was subjected to simple tension test, and, at some stage after the necking had begun it was unloaded. Neck diameter at this stage was 6.2 mm, Fig. 3 (b). The specimen was then machined to make its diameter uniformly 6.2mm through out. It was then refigured, see Fig. 3 (c), at its mid length, where an artificial constriction was machined to make the minimum diameter 5.4 mm at the mid length i.e., the mid length area of the specimen was reduced by 25% as compared to the rest. This specimen was again subjected to the tension test until a new neck appeared. It is important to note that this neck appeared at the specimen end and not at its middle where the area of cross-section was reduced by 25%.
2.2. Barrelling in Simple Compression When a short cylindrical specimen is subjected to a uniaxial compression between two overhanging rigid platens, forces of friction generated at the interface of platen and specimen end face begin to constrain its deformation there. Consequently, lateral expansion of the specimen, at any time, is maximum at its equatorial section and minimum at the end sections. This gives rise to barrelling of the free cylindrical surface, the extent of which depends in a complex manner on factors including interface friction, strain hardening characteristics of the material, and history of loading. Use of conical dies or intermittent lubrication and machining the specimen, when barrelling became evident, was carried out earlier to offset the effects of friction and obtain uniform deformation. Several studies have discussed qualitatively the effect of lubricant (which creates conditions of low interface friction) on the barrel profile, and obtained bollarding with P.T.F.E. sheet used as a lubricant. The friction conditions, however, are generally not very well understood. Several experiments conducted on various metallic materials reveal that specimen deformation at some stage of barrelling begins to be accompanied by the rolling or folding of the material from the cylindrical surface to the end faces of the specimen. The end face thus after this stage consists of the original end face surrounded by a ring of rolled material. Initiation of this rolling process is accompanied by a sharp rise in the load deformation curve. It is, therefore, important to identify the precise stage at which the rolling begins, its extent and the changes it would induce in the load deformation behaviour. Cylindrical specimens used in the above tests [20] were marked by drawing concentric circles on the end faces and parallel circles along the height at different intervals. During a test, the diameter at the equatorial plane, the current height of the specimen, current diameters of concentric circles marked on the end faces (by interrupting the test) and the current diameter of the end face (which includes the ring of rolled materials) were measured. Several specimens of different diameters and slenderness ratios were tested [21 ]. Fig. 4 shows a plot between e a and e h , where e a is strain at the equatorial plane based on diameter measurement and e h is the strain based on height measurement. A linear
10 relation in Fig. 4 gives a sensible approximation considering the complexities involved in the phenomenon. Its use affords great amount of simplification in the otherwise complex DO=50 mm
~
.
,7"40
OIL~--L / 0.4 ""
(~h
'
o.4F J or
0
3" (a)
.2' " ~
20
~P-" P'"
/.. --
12 L
(b)
"/
L/,",,
. J " In _ 0.8i"" ~hO 4
/..
Do =20ram " "
o 0.4 o.B ~.2
--
/ /oo,o..
~
~~
V, .......
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 2.8,0 0.40.g 1.2 1.6 2.0
6a Ea Fig. 4. Height strain versus area strain plots for different diameter specimens of (a) aluminium, (b) steel problem. Nature of variation of the current diameter of the end face (including the rolled material), the current diameter of the original end face, and other concentric circles with the nominal stress is illustrated in Fig. 5 for 30 mm diameter specimens of height to diameter ratios varying from 0.5 to 3.
H(,o D
Ca) ~
:~~
.0
!~'~ 1 .0
(6)
!
Hobo
~----~~2.0
,.o
~I} ~,-~
Holdo
2.O
" 2.0
o ~
/////),
~ 2~i ~. 81012182022
Ho/Do
-3.0 r - ~ 0 . 5
,~,,~
~0
.Concentric circtes 28 32 36 40 44 48 52 56
Current diameter
Fig. 5. Nominal stress versus current diameters of concentric circles and the end face including rolled ring. It is of interest to note that the rolling of material as indicated by the point of bifurcation of the two curves in Fig. 5, appears to coincide with the point of inflexion in the corresponding load compression graph. This clearly indicates that the rising load gradient is direct consequence of the initiation of rolling phenomenon. It is also seen that the width of the ring of rolled material increases with the increase in the slenderness ratio of the specimen. It is interesting to note that all other conditions remaining the same, higher the slenderness ratio, lower is the increase in diameter of the original end face, and that
most of the increase in the end face diameter is due to rolling of material from the free surface of the specimen to its end faces, see Fig. 5 (c). 2.3. Collapse of Thin Metal Shells The plasto-mechanics of structural elements like tubes of circular and non-circular cross-sections, spherical shells, and conical frusta, have received considerable attention during the last four decades. Their application in the design of devices for absorbing kinetic energy in situations of a crash or an accident is common. Various factors that determine the efficiency of performance of the energy absorbers, and their selection criteria have been discussed in detail in [22]. The axial collapse mechanisms of thinwalled tubes of circular, square or rectangular sections under static or dynamic loading in particular, have been studied by various investigators in the past [23-25]. Here we present some experimental observations, which are of interest. 2.3.1. Axial Crushing of Round Tubes Axially crushed thin walled tubes are perhaps the most investigated structural elements. Their progressive collapse is either axisymmetric due to local axial and radial buckling or diamond due to local circumferential buckling They provide an efficient way of absorbing the kinetic energy of impact. Therefore, study of plasto-mechanics of their post-collapse deformation has received considerable attention. Most of the solutions available in literature pertain to the concertina mode of collapse and the analysis for diamond mode of collapse is almost non-existent. The analytical approaches of analysis of tubes and frusta for axisymmetric folding have so far been by either considering straight folds or curved folds of circular curvature or their combination. In the straight fold models, the energy absorption in bending is assumed to be concentrated at the location of hinges. In many of these studies, the folding has been assumed to be either total outside or total inside. It has, however, been observed in experiments on cylindrical tubes that the folds are partly inside and partly outside. Plausible factors contributing to such folding include consideration of the influence of variation in stress-strain behaviour of the material in tension and compression [26]. The problem in these modelling techniques is in the estimation of the peak load at which the folding starts. The average load obtained analytically on the basis of the formation of independent folds can not be compared with the experimental results because the folds do not form independently. In most of the analytical studies, only two modes of deformation viz. bending and circumferential deformations have been incorporated. Experiments on round tubes of materials like aluminium and mild steel of different sizes and aspect ratios have shown that their mode of deformation remains quite insensitive when tested under quasi-static or drop hammer loading. It is however seen [27] that the size of the specimen, annealing processes, and the presence of any discontinuity like a circular hole influence the mode of deformation very much. The experiments on both as-received and annealed tubes of aluminium and mild steel, reveal that the progressive collapse mode is concertina, diamond, or mixed depending on their state of work hardening, subsequent annealing process and the geometry of the tube. For tubes of d/t ratios between 10 and 40, it is found that a highly cold worked as-received aluminium tube deforms in diamond mode and when annealed, it deforms in a ring mode. On the other hand, as-received strain-hardened steel tubes deform in concertina mode and
12 on annealing, they deform in diamond mode, see Fig. 6; this behaviour is exactly opposite to that of aluminium tubes.
Fig. 6. Deformed shape of the 52.6 mm diameter steel tube in (a) annealed; and (b) asreceived state The corresponding stress-strain curves of the respective materials reveal that their slope at the onset of plastic deformation is much higher in the case of aluminium when annealed and in the case of steel in as-received condition. An experimental study has been carried out in which two diametrically opposite holes were drilled in the tubes of various dimensions of aluminium and mild steel. The diameters of these holes in different tests were varied. It has been observed that the collapse begins at the location of holes if the diameter of hole is greater than a minimum value. It was seen in experiments that these tubes did not buckle in the Euler mode, even for lengths that were much larger than the buckling length of tubes without holes. Figure 7 shows typical load-deformation curves for aluminium tubes of D = 36 mm. It was seen that the tubes without holes collapsed in the Euler mode for L/D = 5, while the tubes with holes did not collapse in the Euler mode even for L/D = 10. The D/t in this case was 22, and it may be seen that holes afford the possibility of increasing the critical overall buckling length by more than 100%. Deformed shapes of a typical aluminium specimen of D/t = 36 mm, L/D = 3 are shown in Fig. 8 at six different stages of the test. The hole diameter is 9 mm in this case. Typical deformed shape of an aluminium tube with two opposite holes is shown in Fig. 9.
201- / ~ / \
~
OL 0
.....
\
, 10
W i t h hole
X._
L=9
, , - 7-" 20 30 - 40 C o m p r e s s i o n (ram)
'"
'
T 50
Fig. 7. Load deformation curve for tubes with and without holes.
"'
, 6c
13
Fig. 10 Deformed shapes of aluminium tubes of.49.4 mm diameter with two opposite holes in one, two and three planes respectively from right. The holes also reduce the first peak load and this reduction is dependent on the hole diameter. The holes may be in one or more planes mad their number is to be optimized. Typical deformed shapes of tubes with two opposite holes in one, two or three planes are shown in Fig. 10.
14 2.3.2. Axial Crushing of Frusta
One of the major advantage in using a frusta as compared to cylindrical tubes as energy absorbing device is that it minimizes the chances of collapse by buckling in Euler mode. Another significant feature of frusta is its increasing collapse load with progression of crushing excepting for large semi-apical angles (> 60 ~ for which reverse bending takes place at some later stages of collapse and that causes fall in load. In experiments, frusta have been found to normally fail by diamond mode excepting those of very low and very high semi-apical angles. As the frusta of low semi-apical angles may fail in concertina mode that is perhaps why many of the studies available in literature seem to be for frusta of low semi-apical angles. The frusta of semi-apical angles up to about 30 ~ are found to begin yielding with an axisymmetric ring, and thereafter these collapse progressively by multi lobe diamond fold mechanism [28]. In case of frusta of semi-apical angles of about 45 ~ and above, plastic buckling is initiated at the smaller end by a rolling plastic hinge resulting in the formation of an inverted frusta. Some typical load-deformation curves of frusta collapsing due to the movement of rolling plastic hinge are shown in Fig. 11, wherein it is seen that the
2,I 18
_q tK
--'dr =180"5
/
.
{;[~N"~J(/~-
0'
0
l
10
-
.
.
I
.
t
20 30 Compression (ram)
61.9 ...... I
40
I
5O
Fig. 11 Load-Compression curves of frusta collapsing due to the movement of rolling plastic hinge structural component shows the ability to sustain the load at the nmximum level with the progress of compression. Figure 12(a) and (b) show deformed shapes of the frusta of semi-apical angle 30 ~ and 45 ~ respectively. The former collapse in diamond mode while the latter collapse by the movement of rolling plastic hinge. Similarity of the collapse mode of the large angle frusta with that of hemispherical shells under axial loading [29] can easily be seen; collapse in these is initiated by inward dimpling and it progresses with the formation of the rolling hinge. In the case of these frusta with low t/d values, in the later stages of compression, stationary plastic hinges are also formed. In all the cases of frusta of semi-apical angles 65 ~ at a certain stage of compression, a reverse bending occurs from the larger end associated with a rolling plastic hinge.
15
Fig. 12 Deformed shapes of frusta of semi-apical angle (a) 30~ and (b) 45 ~
2.4. Collapse Behaviour of Composite Shells Composite thin walled shells, such as tubes, frusta, hemispherical shells, and domes are potential candidates for their use as energy absorbing elements in crashworthiness applications in aircraft and other transport vehicles due to their high specific energy absorbing capacity and the stroke efficiency. The main advantage is that designers have greater flexibility in tailoring the material to meet the specific requirements of loading and changing environment. Their failure mechanism however is highly complicated and rather difficult to analyse. This includes fracture in fibers, in the matrix, and in the fibermatrix interface in tension, compression, and shear. Experimental and theoretical studies on axial compression of empty and foam filled cylinders and cones [30-31 ], reveal that once the matrix crack is formed, it is followed by the breaking of the fibres due to hoop strain. This leads to the formation of petals with fibres bending both inside and outside the mean radius of the shell; nature of this petal formation depends on the material and size of the shell. Axial loading experiments on the composite hemi-spherical shells reveal that their collapse is mainly due to the fracture zones initiated along the meridian and circumferential directions; the latter form at certain regularly decreasing intervals (dl) depending on the radius, thickness and the co-latitude angle ~ of the shell. Shells of lower thickness are found to collapse by fragmentation, but those of higher thickness collapse by inward splaying [32]. The progressive collapse of a dome observed along the meridian and circumferential directions is shown in Fig. 13. The zones of collapse along the circumferential direction are formed successively with the progress of collapse. Mean collapse load of the composite hemi-spherical shells is influenced more by their thickness than their radius. The lateral collapse of GFRE tubes of varying D/t ratios occurs by the formation of four longitudinal fracture lines. For tubes with D/t greater than 10, all fracture lines are located at 90 ~ phase angle. Tubes of D/t less than 10, however, fail by the formation of two fracture lines close to the contact lines of tube with flat platens and the remaining
16 two are located at about 60~ angle; see Fig. 14 [33]. Also, the zones between these close fracture lines are subjected to heavy delamination. Formation of two close fracture lines Too. f-ptate
]--[
l J_ tdh T
.
Z t.
"
~ ~ Bottom ptote
Z~--~,~
c,ne of actuat fracture ercurnferentiat direction) Assumed zone
/ x~/ ./~,1 ] Zone of fracture in the ~' ~ ' . ~ ' x y ~2/y/~'mer'dian direction
Fig. 13 Schematic diagram showing the formation of fracture zones in domes. is due to delamination occuring in the region of the first two fracture lines. It is due to this reason that a considerable portion of the fiat load-deformation curve is obtained for tubes of smaller D/t ratio. Tubes of smaller D/t ratio may also undergo progressive fracture. When D/t is small, variation of strain across the thickness is large, and thus leading to progressive fracture rather than sudden fracture. On the other hand for tubes with large D/t ratio, enough strain gets developed simultaneously in all layers, which is sufficient for causing sudden fracture over the total thickness of the tube. In the case of
A
~
._,'IX
2
,
~
. . . . . .
I~
~
"-. X
~,
/~B=AB=b
_-4--- -I-
Fig. 14 Lateral collapse model for composite tubes with D/t < 10
17 the random orientation of fibres in the tube, stresses developed in the fibres crossing the fracture lines are different. Only those fibres get fractured in which fracture strength is exceeded and the rest remain unfractured. Delamination occurs when the bond strength between the fibres is exceeded. In that case fibres do not get fractured because the delamination causes relief of stress in the fibres. It is due to this reason that the tube does not get separated along fracture lines like brittle material and significant recovery of deformation is observed in experiments. Recovery after failure, however, is not important because energy absorption potential of recovered GFRE tubes is very small as seen from their load-deformation curves. 2.5. Impact of Projectile on Plates Comprehensive surveys of the mechanics of penetration and perforation of projectiles into the targets have been published by Backman and Goldsmith [34], Zukas [35], and Corbett et.al. [36] covering the major experimental and analytical works done in the field. The first formulae to be developed predicted the penetration depths into semi-infinite targets when struck normally by a projectile. The advent of battleship armour in the 19th century led to the development of equations predicting the depth of penetration of finite thickness armour plating. Even to this day these formulae and others like them are being used extensively by impact engineers. In recent years appreciable advances have been made in the analytical approach to the problem of impact with the models gradually becoming more and more sophisticated and more accurate. However, these, too have relied heavily, and indeed still do, on experimental data to justify certain assumptions made and to supply various parameters for the models. A commonly used measure of a target's ability to withstand projectile impact is its "Ballistic Limit Velocity (BLV)" simply known as "Ballistic Limit" and much work has been carried out by researchers to enable estimates of this parameter. Another useful term I '
1000 -
(a)
"Fin
E 800
t = a 10 m m o 12
I
A16
I
o MiLd steel o Atuminium
o 20
120l-|
10o_ 9
._~
u 600 O
(b)
25 --Computed
7
_~ 0 -
>
-6 400
~ 4a h5 g 2o
:3
I/1
200
Z
I0
20 30 40 59 Thickness of ptote (ram)
60
70
O0
,
,I,
10
I
J
i ,
i,,
I
.J
20 30 40 50 60 70 AngLe of obl.iquity
Fig. 15 (a) Residual velocity variation for the impact of projectiles on plates of different materials, and (b) Velocity drop with the angle of obliquity for MS plates. Incident velocity is 820 rn/s.
18 is "Ballistic Limit Thickness (BLT)" [37], which is the minimum thickness of plate required for a projectile of known weight and velocity to prevent any perforation. Figure 15 (a) shows a typical residual velocity variation for the impact of projectiles on plates of different material and thickness for 820 m/s incident velocity. The relationship between the velocity drop and the angle of obliquity is shown in Fig. 15 (b) for MS plates of various thicknesses. Armour steels although the oldest of armour materials, are still considered satisfactory material in dealing with ballistic protection. A basic requirement of armour steel is that it should have high hardness; but it seems that there is no simple correlation between hardness and resistance to perforation, as measured by a structure's ballistic limit. Increasing thickness of the monolithic homogeneous armour beyond a limit begins to present constraints of weight, manufacture, and cost. This has led to the consideration of possible targets made of layered plates of metals, non-metals and their combinations for improving the efficiency of the armour as well as for achieving the required thickness conveniently. It has also been noted that an efficient combination is a hard front face to break up the projectile and a ductile rear face to absorb the projectile's kinetic energy. Many of the available studies pertain to the behaviour of layered targets of the same material. It is seen that for relatively thick plates (with t > t*/4, where t* is the ballistic limit thickness) in two layers, the residual velocities are comparable to those for single plates of the same total thickness. However, when the plates are thin, (t < t*/4), the layered combinations in contact gives higher residual velocity. For spaced targets, the residual velocity is higher than for the plates in contact. For two-layered targets of MS, when the total thickness is greater than t* and the thickness of each layer is less than t*, the projectile gets embedded when the front layer is thinner than the rear layer. However, when the front layer is thicker, one encounters an interesting phenomenon; the projectile penetrates up to a certain depth and then rebounds back, presumably due to a stress wave effect. When a projectile perforates a target at an oblique angle of incidence, it is observed in experiments that it does not come out of the rear side in the same straight path, but tends to turn towards or away from the normal to the plate. This deviation depends on the angle at which it strikes the plate, its material, and the thickness of the plate. When the projectile is fired at an angle greater than the angle for the ballistic limit, a stage comes when the projectile penetrates the plate and comes out of it from the impacted side itself. 3. CONCLUDING REMARKS I have presented above some examples of experimental observations in their pristine form in an attempt to draw attention to the basic complexities of the large deformation phenomena. I have tried not to obscure these by theory or mathematics. There are, however, many issues, concerning the delineation of the mechanics of large deformation under various loading and boundary conditions; numerical methods and analytical solutions; and material constitutive behaviour, which need attention. Three days of the symposium will address many important aspects of relevance to these issues. I conclude by observing that IMPLAST-2000 has been prodigiously successful in bringing us together from all parts of the world. I am sure, we shall carry fond memories of the days spent in Melboume. We all are conscious of the immense efforts required to organise a successful conference of this magnitude; Prof. Grzebieta and Dr. Zhao have
19 no doubt done a fabulous job. I thank them both personally for giving me this opportunity and wish you all an enjoyable and fruitful stay. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25.
B. Karunes and N.K. Gupta (eds.), Stress Waves in Solids, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, 1973. B. Kanmes, N.K. Gupta (eds.), Large Deformations, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, 1975. W. Johnson, Large Deformations, Proc. of the Symposium held at IIT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1978) 1. Th. Lehmann, Large Deformations, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1978) 37. E.T. Onat, Large Deformations, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1978) 164. N.K. Gupta and S. Sengupta (eds.), Large Deformations, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, 1978. N.K. Gupta (ed.), Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, 1990. W. Johnson, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at IIT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1993) 1. N.K. Gupta (ed.), Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, 1993. C.R. Calladine, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1993) 71. N. Jones, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1993) 29. Kozo Ikegami, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1993) 52. N.W. Murray, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1993), 197. N.K. Gupta (ed.), Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, 1996. W. Johnson, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1996) 1. O.T. Bruhns, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at liT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1996) 37. N. Jones, Plasticity and Impact Mechanics, Proc. of the Symposium held at IIT Delhi, N. Delhi, India, (1996) 21. N.K. Gupta and B.P. Ambasht, Mechanics of Materials, 1 (1982) 219. N.K. Gupta and B. Karunes, Int. J. of Mech. Sci., 21 (1979) 387. N.K. Gupta and C.B. Shah, Proc. of Symposium on Large Deformation, (1978) 146. N.K. Gupta and C.B. Shah, Machine Tool Design and Research, 26 (1986) 137. W. Johnson and S.R. Reid, Applied Mechanics Reviews, 31 (1978) 277. J.M. Alexander, Q. J. Mech. Appl. Math., 13 (1960) 10. W. Abramowicz, N. Jones, Int. J. Impact Engng, 2 (1984) 263. N.K. Gupta and R. Velmurugan, Int. J. Solids & Structures, 34 (1997) 2611.
20 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37.
N.K. Gupta and H. Abbas, Int. J. Impact Engng., Communicated. N.K. Gupta and S.K. Gupta, Mechanical Sci., 35 (1993) 597. N.K. Gupta, G.L.E. Prasad and S.K. Gupta, I. J. Crash, 2 (1997) 349. N.K. Gupta, G.L.E. Prasad and S.K. Gupta, Thin Walled Str., 34 (1999) 21. N.K. Gupta, R. Velmurugan and S.K. Gupta, J. of Composite Materials, 31 (1997) 1262. N.K. Gupta and R. Velmurugan, Int. J. of Composite Materials, 33 (1999) 567. N.K. Gupta and G.L.E. Prasad, Int. J. of Impact Engg., 22 (1999) 757. N.K. Gupta and H. Abbas, Int. J. of Impact Engng. 24 (2000) 329. M.E. Backman and W. Goldsmith, Int. J. of Engineering Science, 16 (1978) 1. Zukas, J.A., High Velocity Impact Dynamics, John Wiley and Sons, 1990. G.G. Corbett, S.R. Reid and W. Johnson, Int. J. o Impact Engng., 18 (1996) 141. N.K. Gupta and V. Madhu, Int. J. of Impact Engg., 19 (1987) 395.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
21
B u c k l i n g of Thin Plates and T h i n - P l a t e M e m b e r s - S o m e points of interest J Rhodes
Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Strathclyde Glasgow Scotland, UK.
A brief examination of some of the research on the post-buckling elastic and plastic behaviour of plates and plate structures is outlined. This field is so wide ranging that only a very superficial examination has been carded out, and the writer has concentrated on some specific aspects of the general field of study.
1. INTRODUCTION When Euler produced the first paper on the buckling of columns in 1744 this constituted, to quote Salvadori [ 1] " a solution in search of a topic" since with the materials and structures current at that time nothing buckled. Indeed, for quite some time thereafter the problem of buckling was theoretical pie-in-the-sky. This did not remain the case forever, and nowadays a knowledge of buckling and its effects are basic requirements for engineers. In the case of plate structures probably the first references to buckling arose during the mid 19th century. Walker [2] told of a series of tests carded out in the laboratories of University College London on box beams of a variety of cross sections in connection with a projected suspension railway bridge across the Menai Straits by Robert Stephenson. The tests showed that in a number of cases failure was due to the phenomenon now known as local buckling.
The first theoretical examination of plate buckling was by Bryan [3] who obtained a solution to the problem of a simply supported plate under uniform compression in 1891. Since then numerous researchers have investigated local instability in plates under a wide variety of loading and boundary conditions using many different methods of analysis. There has been a number of excellent text books which have described the main results of these investigations, for example [4]-[5], and the reader is referred to these textbooks for a general study of plate instability. In this paper attention will be focussed mainly on the effects of buckling on subsequent plate behaviour.
22 2. POST-BUCKLING BEHAVIOUR OF PLATES AND SECTIONS. 2.1. Plate behaviour at and after buckling.
When a compressed plate buckles it develops out of plane ripples, or buckles, along its length. This behaviour is illustrated in Figure 1 for a thin-walled section in which local buckling is present in all the plate elements. In the elastic range the buckled portions of the plate shed load, and become ineffective in resisting further loading, while in the portions of plate close to supports the out of plane buckling is diminished, and these parts have post-buckling reserves of strength and stiffness. The plate as a whole sustains increases in load after buckling, but the axial stiffness reduces. This effect is demonstrated in Figure 2, where point A is the buckling point. For a plate without imperfections the post-buckling axial stiffness drops immediately upon buckling, and thereafter reduces still further as loading increases. Also because of the highly redistributed stress system the maximum stress grows at an increased rate after buckling, ensuring earlier failure than if the plate remained unbuckled.
Perfect plate " Load P
rfect _
plate
I
End displacement u Figure 1. Locally buckled thin-walled section
Figure 2. L o a d - End displacement path.
As the load increases the stresses also increase. The consequences of this are inevitably detrimental to the plate continuing to fulfil its function, but the way in which the plate fails depends very much on the material from which the plate is made. Fibrous composites, for example, have a wide variety of failure possibilities. In this paper such possibilities will be disregarded, and research into ductile material only will be considered.
2.2. Von Karman Large Deflection Equations
The post-buckling behaviour of thin plates is governed by two simultaneous non-linear differential equations originally set up by von Karman [6] and modified some time later by Marguerre [7] to take account of the presence of initial imperfections. These equations may be written in terms of deflections w, initial imperfections Wo and stress function F as follows:-
23
34F
O~4F
~+2 3x 4
o14w ~ X4
o~x2B y2
+2
- q+D[ - D
+
o~4 w
03 X 2 t~ y 2
[(
3 4F 3 y4 = E ~ oxO y) - Ox 2 0 y z
+
a4w
(1)
=
t~ y 4
c9~F 3 2 ( w + w o) + 3 2Fc92(w+wo) 1 - 2 3xO y2 03xO y Ox 2 By2 J
3zF r
o3y 2
[,c)xOy ) ..I Ox z c?y z
tgx2
(2)
The first of these equations, sometimes called the "Compatibility Equation", ensures that in an elastic plate the in-plane and out-of-plane displacements are compatible. The second equation is based on equilibrium principles, and is sometimes termed the "Equilibrium Equation". Exact solution of these equations is only possible for the simplest loading and support conditions, and in the earliest days of plate postbuckling analysis recourse was made to empirical equations and to significantly simplified analysis to examine plate behaviour.
2.3. Empirical Equations Early research into the post-buckling behaviour of thin-plates was carried out largely in the aircraft industry. In 1930 a large series of compression tests on plates of various materials and having a wide variation in plate width was carried out by Schuman and Back [8]. The plates were simply supported on all edges, and the tests indicated that for plates wide enough to buckle locally before failure the ultimate load which could be carried did not increase in proportion to the width. Indeed beyond a certain width the ultimate load was insensitive to variation in actual width. Over the next few years a number of theoretical investigations were carried out to examine this phenomenon, and in 1932 the first effective width expression was developed by von Karmen et al [9]. This expression states that for a plate of actual width "b" an effective width "b," can be used in the evaluation of the load carrying capacity. Von Karman's effective width expression can be written in terms of the critical stress crcR and yield stress o'r as follows:-
b
where
Vo'r
K ~z2E t 2 CrcR = 12(1_v2) b2
(3)
(4)
In the case of a simply supported plate 1(=4 and for a steel plate with E = 205 N/IIII/I 2, v--0.3 and (rr =280 N/ram 2 the effective width at failure is 51.4t where t is the plate thickness regardless of the plate actual width.
24 It should be mentioned that in the evaluation of the effective width expression it was ensured that the buckle half wavelength in the plate assumed a value which would produce the minimum effective width. Von Karman's effective width expression was found to be conservative and reasonably accurate for thin plates for which the critical stress is very much less than the yield stress. In the case of plates in which the critical stress and yield stress are similar there is a great deal of scatter, imperfections cause substantial reduction in the load capacity and equation (1) is nonconservative. To overcome this, Winter [10] later modified yon Karman's equation to:-
b
VO'e)
(5)
The second term within the brackets modifies yon Karman's equation mainly at the point where the yield stress and applied edge stress are similar. This expression was used in the AISI specification for cold-formed steel members [ 11] until it was modified again (The 0.25 term was changed to 0.218, or 0.22 in some design codes) and in its latest form is probably the best known and most widely used expression from which plate post-buckling strength can be determined. This equation is used in many National design specifications, and in International specifications such as Eurocode 3 [12]. In the determination of the compressive capacity of a cross section the effective widths for all plate elements of the cross section are computed at the yield condition and then summed to evaluate the total effective area of the section. This is then multiplied by the yield stress to provide a value for the squash load of a strut taking local buckling into account. In the application of this approach each plate element is considered separately, although some design codes take some account of interaction between elements via the critical stress. In the 1940s and for some time later an alternative method of approach, based largely on testing, was developed. A number of investigators, e.g. Heimefl [13], Schuette [14], Chilver [15] derived empirical equations governing the load capacity of different short strut sections. Some of these are as follows:-
/0.2 Heimerl [ 13]
am'x = 0.769 ~
t, a , )
a~
f
for Z and C sections
(6)
/0.2
O'm~x = 0.794 O'CR
for H Sections
(7)
25 (
Schuette [14]
or.= =
\0.25
0.8" [
Chilver [15]
r
t, a , ) [
(rtmx =
or,
(8)
for aluminium channels
(9)
,~1/3
= 0.863 | O'c, |
a,
for Z , C and H sections
-%113
0.736 ""/c'~'/
for steel channels
(10)
t a, )
The fact that all of these expressions have factors less than unity signifies that for members in which yield and local buckling theoretically occurred simultaneously the experimental results were less than the theoretical buckling, or yield, load due to imperfections. It is interesting to note that equations (4) - (8), empirically derived for sections, have smaller indices than 0.5, derived for individual plate elements. Figure 3 shows a comparison of the "Plate effectiveness" (i.e. either Effective width/full width or Maximum stress/yield stress) given by each equation. As may be observed the values given by Eqn. (5), i.e. the effective width curve are less than those given by the curves based on complete section strength. This could perhaps be taken to suggest that the curve from Eqn. (5) is rather conservative. This is not borne out by Figure 4, however, which plots a comparison with the effective width/full width ratio for the tests which had originally been used to establish this effective width equation. Note that in Figure 4 the abscissa is the square root of that in Figure 3. -------- Eqn (6) Eqn (7)
1.2 r
...... - Eqn (8) ....
.g'_
Eqn (9)
--------- Eqn (10)
0.8
- = = - = - Eqn (5)
~ 0.6 JlB~
~
~lll~l
IIIIBIIIB
~IRI~
~lllllll
iiiiiill
mlllll i allll ii
N 0.4 0.2 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
Ratio of Yield Stress to buckling stress
Figure 3. Variation of Effectiveness with Ratio of Yield Stress to Buckling Stress
26 1.2 ....
0.8 ,.Q
Eqn (5) 9 Experiments
0.6 0.4 III
0.2 F
9
o 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
V((YY/(YCR) Figure 4. Comparison of Winter' effective width expression with experiments The main reason why the effective width curve for individual elements gives lower values than an effectiveness curve derived on the basis of a complete section is the fact that in a section some elements are participating fully in buckling while others are not. In a cross section some elements initiate buckling, while other elements restrain the buckling elements. The elements which initiate buckling lose effectiveness readily, while the restraining elements remain highly effective until the compression reaches a stage at which these elements would buckle naturally. This is illustrated in Figure 5, from Ref [ 16]. In the box section under examination the thinner walls buckle first, with high restraint from the thicker elements which have much lower deflections than the thin elements initially and the axial stiffness of the box is only reduced to about 80%-85% of its initial value due to buckling. When the end displacement reaches the value at which the thicker elements would naturally buckle as simply-supported elements then these begin to participate fully in the buckling of the section and the axial stiffness drops sharply to well under half of its original value. The effective width approach as used in design codes such as the AISI code [ 11] cater for this differential behaviour of different elements in a cross section, as each element is analysed individually, while the complete section approach cannot take the individual variances in sections into account unless different formulae are used for different sections. It appears that the complete section approach, which has taken second place to the effective width method
2.4. Elastic Plate Analysis Just after Von Karman produced the first effective width equation, Cox [ 17] performed an approximate energy analysis of plate post-buckling behaviour. Cox's approach considered that the membrane strain in the loaded plate was constant in the direction of load. The approximations effectively lead to neglect of the effects of shearing stresses in a plate and the method postulated by Cox became known to later researchers as the "lower bound" method, as the plate post buckling stiffness was generally underestimated due to the neglect of some of
27 160tl 120~- 8 0 -
t;,i~k;/ p,ot.
---/----i~,it
/,0-
1:ft.: 1: I 2
line |0| gives ~ corresponding to buckling of
.~ ;/~ I f _
if edges were simply supported
jr
0-
I
I"
10
0
'
20 u
-
i
.......
30
~0
b l-*P--t,
'~ ,,-, P
=
Pb
30q /
,77
~
.'I / I", '."l ..)' ..... , f ........ t" q
/
,'P"
,= 2 0 -
/,,/
." 0 ;-0
i 1"
"
..-'.---"
'|
II
i
i
2
3
i
~
'"i 5
W
tl
Figure 5. Buckling of a Box Section with sides of unequal thickness the strain energy. This method is not a bound of any kind, but provides a simple approach to the approximate analysis of plate post buckling behaviour. After this early pioneering work Cox went on to produce extremely important theoretical findings in plate post-buckling research including the explanation of the reason for snap changes in buckle mode etc. In the years immediately following Cox's first at)proximate analysis a number of researchers produced variations on this approach until the first rigorous solution of the plate post-buckling problem was carried out by Marguerre in 1937 [18]. Marguerre's approach was to postulate an approximate deflected form for the plate, determine the corresponding stress function by solving the compatibility equation (1), and employ the Principle of Minimum Potential Energy, rather than the equilibrium equation to furnish the final solution. Researchers in later years very often used a similar type of approach, i.e. combining an exact solution of the compatibility equation with either evaluation and minimisation of the Potential Energy, or an approximate solution (for example using Galerkin's method ) of the equilibrium equation. With the development of rigorous solutions to plate problems came the recognition of the importance of boundary conditions. While deflection and edge slope conditions were quite
28 obvious and were well appreciated because of their applicability in the examination of initial buckling, rigorous examinations of post-buckling behavieur required also a knowledge of the in-plane loading and deformation conditions. These are highly dependant on the type of construction under consideration. In many bridge, ship and aeroplane structures, where a multiplicity of plates are aligned in much the same plane, the in-plane displacements of adjacent plates at their junctions is such that displacements normal to the plate edge are either zero, or are constant along the plate. Perhaps the most widely applicable condition here is that the plate edges can move outward or inward, but must remain straight. In light structural members, where each plate element is orientated at an angle to the adjacent element any tendency for the edge of a plate element to move in plane is generally not resisted adequately by the adjacent element and so waving of the edges of such elements is probable in the postbuckling range. A detailed examination of the boundary conditions applicable to plate elements is given by Bentham in Ref [ 19] With regard to out of plane displacement conditions, situations in which the plate edges are held straight in-plane also tend to induce conditions approaching simple support, or fully fixed, conditions e.g. for bridge, plate and ship type plates while plate elements of thin-walled structural sections in general have some intermediate degree of restraint on rotation of the unloaded edges. In the years immediately following the second word war a number of investigators improved the knowledge of plate post-buckling behaviour. Among notable research presentations Levy produced the first "exact" solution, in series form, to yon Karman's equations [20], Hemp [21 ] examined simply supported and fixed edge plates under uniform compression. Cox [22] investigated in depth the effects of in-plane edge on plate behaviour, and obtained a solution to the problem of sudden "snap" transition from one buckled wavelength to another, a phenomenon which had previously been observed experimentally. Hu et. al. [23] and Coan [24] studied the effects of imperfections. Yamaki produced perhaps the most comprehensive analysis up to that date in 1959 [25], [26], examining plates with combinations of simply supported and fully fixed boundary conditions, with unloaded edges either free to wave inplane or constrained in-plane. An investigation by Stein [27] in 1951 is worthy of special mention. Stein used the perturbation approach in which the solution is obtained in terms of the power series expansion of a "perturbation parameter". The parameter used by Stein was :P
a=------l+
wo
----
(11)
where P is the applied load and PcR is the critical load to cause buckling A complete picture of the plate behaviour could be derived in terms of a power series of this parameter. The first two terms of this power series could effectively detail the plate post buckling behaviour well into the far post buckling range. Essentially this meant that by obtaining analytical solutions at two specific points, one of which could be the buckling point, and utilising the pertubation approach a picture of the complete post-buckling range of behaviour of identical plates with any magnitude of imperecfion could be produced.
29 Walker used this approach in 1969 [28] to obtain explicit solutions for square simply supported plates. The results were used in the 1975 edition of the UK specification for the design of cold-formed steel specimens. Williams and Walker [29] extended this study to deal with a wide variety of plate geometries and boundary conditions, and tables of coefficients obtained from a finite difference analysis were given from which the reader could analyse the plate of his choice. It is only a short step to go from this position to fitting expressions to the coefficients so that by solving simple equations the coefficients governing rectangular plates of arbitrary buckle half wavelength and arbitrary boundary restraint conditions can be determined. In Ref [30] slightly modified forms of explicit expression, obtained on the basis of a Marguerre type analysis allied to the perturbation technique, are presented. The explicit expressions are in the following forms:P]
)
P/
Pc
0" m
O'eR
-
= ( q - 1 ) t ~ + c 20:2
(12)
=
1)a + c,
(13)
= csCt + c6Ct2
(14)
(c, -
with ct as defined in Eqn. (11), CrcRas defined in Eqn. (4), O'm the maximum membrane stress and e and ecR being the average and critical strains in the plate loaded direction. Expressions for the coefficients Cl to c6 for plates free to wave in-plane on the unloaded edges with varying buckle half wavelengths and rotational restraints on the unloaded edges are given in Appendix 1. The rotational restraint coefficient, R, has a value such that Mb R = ----OD
(15)
where M is the moment per unit length opposing rotation of a plate unloaded edges, 0 is the rotation of the unloaded edges, b is the plate width and D the plate flexural rigidity factor. These formulae gave fairly simple yet accurate representation of the behaviour of plates with any buckle half wavelength, any magnitude of initial imperfection and any degree of restraint on edge rotation within the limits of plate large deflection theory. The slight modifications which were incorporated into the explicit expressions were made to eliminate the possibility of ill conditioning affecting the postulated behaviour in the far post-buckling range, and these equations give results in close agreement with existing theory in comparable cases. Load-out of plane deflection curves and load compression curves for simply supported square plates are shown for illustration in Figures 6 and 7.
30 w0=0
/t
'.~-0.2 0.4 ' - ' ~ 0.6 ~0.8
~ ' ~ 1.0
P
PcR
l
~
el 1 Simply supported
unloadal edges 0
1
2
3
w/!
Figure 6. Load --out of plane deflection curves for square plates
-~- - 0 0.2 0.4 0 6 t I -/-/~o's
3
P
|
0
Simply supported
2
4
6
8
Figure 7. Load end displacement curves for square plates. Figure 8 shows, in the case of .perfect plates for clarity, the variation of load with axial compression into the far post buckling range for plates of a variety of buckle half wavelengths
31
~.
e--I 0.9 0.8
10
0.7
0.6 0.:5 ~. &
0.4 P
yon Kannan
Simple support on unloaded edges
0
lO
20
30
40
50
Figure 8. Load-compression behaviour in the far post-buckling range From this figure it is obvious that as the compressive strain increases the buckle half wavelength for minimum load decreases, although not by as much as the von Karman expression suggests. The von Karman effective width expression is shown here, and it can be seen to be a little more conservative than the lowest of the perturbation curves, but is fairly close to the lower envelope of these curves. In recent years elastic plate postbuckling analysis has been extended substantially by the computer, by virtue of finite element and finite strip approaches. There have many of these approaches presented in journals and conferences in recent years, and some sample references are [31]-[35].
3. ELASTO- PLASTIC ANALYSIS Investigators who have studied the elastic postbuckling behaviour of plates and plate structures have often suggested that failure occurs more or less coincidentally with first membrane yield in compression. This hypothesis has held up over the years mainly because of two facts, namely (1) - It is simple and (2) - It accurately portrays the situation. However, although the failure load can be accurately obtained in many cases by this hypothesis, the deformation behaviour of plates and plate structures at and after failure cannot be evaluated accurately for ductile materials by elastic theory. Because of this, in any case in which the failure and post failure behaviour of a structure is required then generally plastic behaviour must be taken into consideration.
32 In the design codes for cold-formed steel sections it was assumed for many years that the ultimate load which could be carried by light gauge members was that which caused first yield to occur, and first yield was taken as the failure criterion for cold-formed beams. In the writer's PhD research [36] he observed that tensile yield could be accommodated quite safely so long as the compressive stresses were elastic. This has now come to be recognised, and design taking account of tensile yield is allowed in several light gauge steel design codes. The situation where compressive yield occurs in a thin-walled member is much more complicated, however. Probably the first elasto-plastic plate post-buckling analysis was carded out by Mayers and Budiansky [37] in 1955. The accuracy of their method of approach depended upon the accuracy with which they could postulate expressions for three different displacements simultaneously, and this prevented them from determining a condition in which the applied load reached a maximum value. The writers therefore considered that collapse would have occurred when the unit shortening, or average edge strain attained a value of 1%, and took the load at this point as the collapse load. The loads so evaluated were greater than those obtained in experiments. A substantial amount of research into elasto-plastic plate behaviour was carried out in the 1960s at Cambridge University, e.g. [38], [39]. Perhaps the major work here was that of Graves-Smith who examined the interaction of local and column buckling in a landmark paper which also used a rather rigorous plasticity analysis [40]. This paper was the forerunner of numerous papers in the 1970s on elasto-plastie plate behaviour, for example by Moxham [41], Frieze et. al. [42], Rogers and Dwight [43], Little [44], Crisfield [45] to mention only a few. Most of the work was highly computer-orientated, using finite difference and finite element approaches. There were a number of attempts made to obtain simplified analysis of plate elasto-plastic behaviour. One of these, due to the writer [46] will be briefly detailed here. It had been found by Botman and Besselling in the 1950s [47] that derivation of an effective width for plates using elastic analysis gave good predictions of failure when applied to plates with non-linear behaviour, e.g. aluminium. It was therefore interesting to investigate whether effective widths determined in terms of strains or plate shortening using elastic analysis and then using these together with the elasto-plastic stress strain law would give a realistic assessment of the behaviour. As it happens, such an approach gives an extremely accurate assessment of the actual behaviour. It was found that the simple approach gave results in very good agreement with computer predictions and/or experimental findings for a wide variety of plate conditions. Figures 9 to 11 show comparisons of the results of the simple analysis and those of elastoplastic computer analysis, or experimental findings as appropriate. Figure 9 shows results of the simple approach compared to those of Frieze and Dowling for simply supported plates with the unloaded edges constrained to remain straight. The agreement is excellent. In Figure 10 the simple approach predictions are compared with the experimental results of Moxham again showing excellent agreement. It is noteworthy that the approximate results seem to be equally good for cases in which the theoretical buckling strain is greater than the yield strain as it is for cases when initial buckling is elastic. This suggests that elastic buckling analysis can be used in the post-yield range for plates, with strains substituted for stresses. It is of course true that for purely elastic plates the buckling strain is independent on the modulus of
33 (DIO
0"8
P/Py
v'(ovlE) - 1'037
(blt) v'(oyIE) - 2-074
0-6
Simply suPoortecl square plates Unloaclecl eOges constratneO to rema, n straegnt
0.4
wolf - 0 0 9 4
,L . . . . . .
0.2
0
1
Present method Frieze et al 2
~JEy
3
Figure 9. Comparison of approximate elasto-plastic analysis with Frieze et. al. !
.,m, .':"
-.
.0.8
...(_b/t)~ay/E= 1.59 0-61, P/PY ~
/
/ |
0'2l
i/
0
/
/
I
l,~rX;:,
I
x,-~...
"---"
"~'~"~~'_-~
T (blt)~/OY/E= 2"12
simol.VSUOl:)oneclplates.....
Stres.s-lree on unloaoea eoges vo.;,.*o-O
_
Present m e t h ~
0:s
..... ;
,:s
~Ey
~
2.~
Figure 10. Comparison of approximate elasto-plastic analysis with experiments
34
--15-7
0-6 b -21-9 t
O-S J~
Pv Present method Experiment (Rogers & Dwight) 0.2
(~s
1
1.5
~Y
Figure 11 Comparison of approximate elasto-plastic analysis with experiments on outstand elements elasticity, but theories which do not presume linear elasticity of the material do not result in the same simple finding. This result is therefore most interesting. The simple approach also applies to flange elements, or unstiffened elements, or outstand elements. Figure 11 illustrates the simple analysis for simply supported- free plates with length to width ratio of 8:1 and three different plate width to thickness ratios in comparison with the experimental results of Rogers and Dwight. Here again the simple analysis is equally good for plates in which yield precedes buckling as it is for plates which buckle elastically. For these plates the simple analysis was much closer to the experimental results than was the numerical analysis of the authors. In the case of plates with a free edge loaded by compressive stresses which have their maximum nominal values at the free edge local buckling causes the stresses near the free edge to shed and the stress variation in this region can be complex. Here again, however, the use of an elastically derived effective width for these elements yields a simple evaluation of strength. It can be shown that a simple von Kannan effective width type analysis for unstiffened elements yields an effective width at yield varying as the cube root of the critical strain ecR divided by the yield strain, er. Using the formula
35 /"
b__, =
b where
ece-
-xl/3
(16)
\er)
with
12(l-v2) ~-2
3.4
K = 2+
for the channels considered
h ) l+h
values of the effective flange width b~ at failure can be determined using an elastic/perfectly plastic stress strain law and applying simple elastic or elasto-plastic beam theory as appropriate. The comparison of failure moments calculated in this way with experiments [48] shows good correlation as is illustrated in Figure 12. It is of interest here that steel plates with compressed free edges and having a width to thickness ratio of up to 30 can be seen to display some post-elastic capacity, while these plates with width-thickness ratios of around 15 show experimentally fully plastic capacity. It is worthy of note that these were cold-formed steel channels, and design codes for cold-formed steel do not in general suggest anything like the capacities found here. The channels examined had flange width to web width ratio, h, varying from 0.25 to 1, and the upper solid curve is the theoretical curve corresponding to h=0.25 while the lower curve is the theoretical curve for h=l. In the range of b2/t < 30 the failure load tends towards the fully plastic load, and it is noteworthy that for these sections the shape factor is of the order of 1.8.
Mull
"i
~t
\o-
tO
/
I
~'-i
b2/ /~M
/
I Elasto-plastic range
b~
b2 is flange width h = b2/bl
Elastic range
~
. o o
- --~b
zo
30
40
---
sO
eO
7o
80
9o
b2/t Figure 12. Variation of ultimate moment with flange width/thickness ratio for plain channels bent such that the flange free edges are in compression
36 4.
PLASTIC MECHANISM ANALYSIS
The growth in the use of plastic mechanism analysis to examine failure and post-failure behaviour of thin-walled members has been substantial over the past three decades or so. In 1960 Pugsley and McCaulay [49] and Alexander [50] examined cylindrical columns using mechanisms, and cylinders have since been subjected to intensive research with regard to axial crushing, e.g. [51]- [54]. Ben Kato [55], in 1965, was the first author to the writer's knowledge to apply mechanism theory to investigate axially compressed plate elements. The main aim of his work was to derive knowledge of limiting width to thickness ratios of plate elements below which the full plastic capacity could be ensured without buckling. From the early 1970s an explosion in the development of the mechanism approach ensued. This was influenced in no small way by the work of Murray e.g. [56], [57] who published extensively on the use of plastic mechanisms in thin walled beams, stiffened panels etc. Murray summarised the research to date in 1984 [58]. It is not within the scope of this paper, nor the capability of the writer, to give an exhaustive account of plastic mechanism analyses. These now have been used to study the behaviour of Civil, Mechanical, Offshore, Automobile, Train and Aircraft structures, and within these fields mechanism analysis has been applied to such a wide variety of problems that to attempt any comprehensive coverage can not be contemplated within this paper. Instead, a brief mention of the mechanism analyses which have been carried out at the University of Strathclyde in recent years will be made, on the grounds that very little of the research at this University on plastic mechanisms has been published other than in the form of Research Theses.
4.1. Research at Strathclyde University, UK There have been a few M.Phil research projects carried out over the past 15 years or so dealing with the static and dynamic impact behaviour of transversely loaded beams. The work of these projects has not been published. Sin [59] examined a variety of problems involving plate and beam behaviour using mechanism analysis. Included among these were the collapse behaviour of channels in bending, and "refined mechanism analysis of plates". In an endeavour to produce a mechanism approach which could differentiate between different types of plate in-plane and out of plane boundary conditions Sin took account of membrane yield and bending yield lines in plates and produced results quite close to those discussed earlier in Figures 9-11 on the basis of mechanism analysis. Wong [60] studied static and dynamic axial crushing behaviour of closed hat sections. To aid his research Wong was largely responsible for the design and build of an impact test rig which could hurl a 60 kg mass at a specimen with a velocity of up to 60 miles per hour. Wong carried out about 500 static and dynamic crushing tests. Setiyono [61] used mechanism analysis to study the crippling behaviour in thin-walled beams.
37 Lim [62] examined the behaviour of plain and lipped channel and Z section beams using mechanism approaches. Lim's main aim here was to examine statically indeterminate beams when the cross section slenderness was such that local buckling could occur either before plasticity had started, or when moment redistribution was ongoing. There are two other PhD projects under way on side-impact absorbers at the present time.
4.2 Some remarks regarding inclined plastic hinges. Around 1980, on first studying mechanism analysis, some particular points raised the writer's interest. One of these concerned the general capability of mechanism theory to consider the finer points of plate behaviour, i.e., as mentioned previously, the differences in behaviour of plates with different in-plane boundary conditions was not immediately amenable to calculation using the methods available. Some of the work in Sin's thesis studied this, with some degree of success, but as there still remains some work to be done on this nothing has been published to date. A second, and related, topic concerns the question of the moment capacity of inclined hinges. The writer examined the inclined hinge shown in Figure 13 in the early 1980's, using the von Mises yield criterion to get the following expression for the moment per unit length on the inclined hinge:-
Ilia/ ] '
17,
1 -4[.NooJ sin27 (4 - 3 sin 7)
where No is the yield stress resultant. N ~
I",,
!
",,,
N
Figure 13. Inclined hinge in axially loaded plate.
38 Although this expression was used by Sin [59], Wong [60] and Lira [62] in their PhD theses, and has also been adopted by some colleagues in joint research in Poland, it has not until now been compared with other yield line analyses for inclined hinges. In addition, since its publication until recent times has been limited to PhD theses its existence has not been noticed. It is perhaps an appropriate time to give this expression an airing. In preparing this paper a substantial amount of theoretical and experimental work carried out on the yield capacity of inclined hinges has been brought to the writer's attention. Of particular interest here are the mechanism analyses of of Zhao and Hancock [63]-[65] and the further work of Zhao, Lip and Gzebieta [66]. In ref [64] expressions for the moment capacity of inclined yield lines were derived, and checked against a series of experiments in [65]. The expressions derived could only be solved iteratively, although simplified versions were also produced by curve fitting. Figure 14 shows a comparison of the results given by Equation 17 with those of Ref [64] for hinges at angles, y, of 0, 30 ~ 60 ~ and 80~ Since Equation 17 is based on the von Mises yield criterion, and this is generally considered the most accurate then only the von Mises results from [64] have been shown. These were obtained simply by measurement from the relevant figure in [64] and apologies are made for any unintended errors in reproduction of these results. Also, since Equation 17 was derived for a moment per unit length of hinge then to compare directly with [64] the non-dimensional moment values from Equation 17 must be multiplied by cos y.
1.2
Solid lines give values obtained using Eqn. (17) and symbols alongside each line are values from Ref [64]
1
3,=30~
t-(9
E o 0.8 E r
~60 ~
t--
._o 0.6 C 0
E "? 0.4 c-
y=80 ~
o
z
0.2 ~"
0
*
.
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
N/No Figure 14. Comparison of inclined hinge moment capacities
39 As may be seen from Figure 14 the differences between the predicted moment capacities is not great, although there are differences. For zero hinge inclination it seems that both approaches give identical results- in Equation 17 the denominator becomes unity. For other values of hinge inclination there are some differences with Ref [64] values being slightly greater at low values of axial loading, with Equation 17 values being slightly greater at high axial loading for some hinge inclinations. As to which of these two particular approaches is the more accurate it is not easy to say, the differences are not substantial. There are some basic differences in the analytical reasoning behind the two approaches, but the end results do not seem very different. The behaviour of inclined hinges is also discussed thoroughly in Ref [67] which reviews much of the work prior to 1990 5.
CONCLUDING
COMMENTS
This paper was intended to give a brief summary of plates and plate structures in the elastic and plastic range from the writer's particular viewpoint, without attempting to be in any way comprehensive. It has quickly become obvious that a such a summary of this rapidly expanding field is certain to omit vast quantities of extremely important research. Some of the main researchers in the field have either not been mentioned, or only mentioned in passing, although their contributions to the field have been extremely substantial, and the writer apologises for the necessary omission of many important names and works.
REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5 6
M.G. Salvadori. Buckling, Buckling ...Buckled. Introductory Speech at 1986 Annual Technical Meeting of the Structural Stability Research Council A.C. Walker. A Brief Review of Plate Buckling Research. Behaviour of Thin-Walled Structures. Eds J Rhodes and J Spence. Elsevier, 1984 G . H . Bryan. On the stability of a plane plate with thrusts in its own plane with applications to the "buckling" of the sides of a ship. Proc London Math. $oc. 22,1981 S.P.Timoshenko and J. M. Gere. Theory of Elastic Stability.McGraw-Hill, 1961 P.S. Bulson. The Stability of Flat Plates, Chatto and Windus, London, 1970. T. von Karman. Festigheitsprobleme im Maschinenbau. Encyclopaedie der
Mathematischen Wissenschaften, 4, p349, 1910 K. Marguerre Zur theorie der gekreummter platte grosser formaenderung. Proc fifth Int. Congress for Applied Mechanics. Cambridge, 1938 8. L. Schuman and G Back., Strength of rectangular flat plates under edge compression, NA CA Rep. No.356, 1930. 9. von Karman, E. E. Sechler and L. H. Donnel., Strength of thin plates in compression, Trans. ASME, 54, 1932. 10. G. Winter, Strength of thin steel compression flanges, Cornell Univ. Eng. Exp. Stn, Reprint No.32, 1947. 11. American Iron and Steel Institute Specification For The Design of Cold Formed Steel Structural Members, AISI, New York, 1996
7
40 12. CEN ENV 1993-1_3:1996. Eurocode3:Design of Steel Structures - Part 1.3:General Rules-supplementary rules for cold-formed thin gauge members and sheeting 13. G. J.Heimerl. Determination of plate compressive strength, NACA Tech.Note No.1480, 1947. 14. F. H. Schuette, Observations on the maximum average stress of flat plates buckled in edge compression, NACA Tech. Note No.1625, 1947. 15. A. H. Chilver, The maximum strength of the thin-walled strut, Civil Engineering, 48, 1953. 16 J. Rhodes. Secondary local buckling in thin-walled sections. Acta Technica Academiae Hungaricae, 87, 1978 17. Cox, H. L., Buckling of thin plates in compression, ARC R & M No.1554, 1934. 18. K. Marguerre, The apparent width of the plate in compression, NACA TA No.833, 1937. 19. J. P. Benthem The reduction in stiffness of combinations of rectangular plates in compression after exceeding the buckling load Nat. Aero Research Inst, Amsterdam, NLL- TRS 539, 1959. 20. S. Levy, Bending of rectangular plates with large deflections, NACA Ret No. 737, 1942 21. W. S. Hemp, The buckling of a fiat rectangular plate in compression and it behaviour after buckling, ARC R & M No.2041, 1945. 22. Cox, H. L., The theory of flat panels buckled in compression, ARC R & A No.2178, 1945. 23. P. C. Hu,, E. F. Lundquist and S. B. Batdorf, Effect of small deviations from flatness on effective width and buckling of plates in compression, NACA TA No. 1124, 1946. 24 J.M. Coan, Large deflection theory for plates with small initial curvature loaded in edge compression, Trans. ASME, 73, 1951. 25. N. Yamaki, The post-buckling behaviour of rectangular plates with smt initial curvature loaded in edge compression, J. of App. Mech. 26, 1959. 26. N. Yamaki, The post-buckling behaviour of rectangular plates with smt initial curvature loaded in edge compression -(Continued), J. of App. Mech. 27, 1960. 27 M. Stein, Loads and deformations in buckled rectangular plates, NASA Teci Rep. R-40, 1959. 28 A.C. Walker. The posr-buckling behaviour of simply supported square plates. Aero Quarterly, XX, 1969 29 D.G. Williams and A. C. Walker. Explicit solutions for the design of initially deformed plates subject to compression. Proc I. C. E, 59, 1975 30 J Rhodes. Microcomputer design analysis of plate post-buckling behaviour. Jnl of Strain Analysis, 21, 1986 31. S Sridharan and T. R. Grave Smith. Postbuckling analysis with finite strips.Proc. ASCE, 107, EM5, 1981. 32. G.J. Hancock, A. J. Davids, P. W. Key, S. C. W. Lau and K. J. Rasmussen Recent developments in the buckling and nonlinear analysis of thin-walled structural members. Thin-Walled Structures 9, 1990. - The N. W. Murray Symposium. 33 S. Wang and D. J. Dawe. Spline FSM post-buckling analysis of shear deformable rectangular laminates. Thin- Walled Structures, 34, 1999 34 Y.K. Cheung, F. T. K. Au and D. Y. Zheng. Nonlinear vibrations of thin plates by spline finite strip method. Thin-walled structures, 32, 1998 35 K.S. Sivakumaran and N Abdel Rahman. A finite element analysis model for the behaviour of cold formed steel members. Thin-walled structures, 31, 1998
41 36 J. Rhodes. The nonlinear behaviour of thin-walled beams subjected to pure moment loading. Phi) Thesis, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, 1969. 37 J Mayers and B Budiansky. Analysis of the behaviour of simply supported flat plates compressed beyond the buckling load into the plastic range. NACA TN No 3886, 1955 38 A.T. Ratcliffe. The strength of plates in compression. PhD Thesis, Cambridge, 1966 39 J. B. Dwight and K. E. Moxham Welded steel plates in compression.. The Structural Engineer, 47, 1969 40 T.R. Graves Smith The ultimate strength of locally buckled columns of arbitrary length. Thin-walled steel constructions. Symposium at University College, Swansea, 1967 41. K. F. Moxham. Theoretical determination of the strength of welded steel plates under in plane compression. Cambridge University, Report CU ED/C-Struct~R65, 1971 42. P. A. Frieze, P> J Dowling and R. F. Hobbs. Ultimate load behaviour of plates in compression. Steel plated structures. Crosby Lockwood Staples, London, 197Z 43. N. A. Rogers and J. B. DWIGHT Outstand strength. Steel plated structures. Crosby Lockwood Staples, London, 1977. 44. G. H. Little, Rapid analysis of plate collapse by live energy minimisation, Int. J. Mech. Sci, 19, 1977. 45. M. A. Crisfield. Ivanov's yield criterion for thin plates and shells using finite element, Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Rep. LR919, Crowthorne, 1979. 46 J. Rhodes On the approximate prediction of elasto-plastic plate behaviour., Proc. Inst. Civ. Engrs., 71, 1981. 47. M. Botman and J. F. Besseling. The effective width in the plastic range of flat plates under compression. NIL, Amsterdam, Report 5,445, 1954 48. J Rhodes. Research into the mechanical behaviour of cold formed sections and drafting of design rules. Report to the ECSC, 1987 49 S. A. Pugsley and M Macaulay. The large scale crumpling of thin cylindrical columns. Quart. J. Mech. And Appl. Math., XIII, Part 1, 1960 50 J.M. Alexander. An approximate analysis of the collapse of thin cylindrical shells under axial loading. Quart. J. Mech and App. Math, XIII, Part 1, 1960 51 A. Andronicou and A. C. Walker. A plastic collapse mechanism for cylinders under axial end compression. Jnl of Constr. Steel Research, 1, 1981 52 R . S . Birch and N. Jones. Dynamic and static axial crushing of axially stiffened cylindrical shells. Thin-Walled Structures 9, 1990. The N. W. Murray Symposium. 53. R. H. Grzebieta Research into failure Mechanisms of some thin-walled round tubes. Plasticity and Impact Mechanics. Ed N. K. Gupta. New Age International (P) Ltd., 1998 54 N.K. Gupta and R. Velmumgan. Axi-symmetric axial collapse of round tubes Plasticity and Impact Mechanics. Ed N. K. Gupta. New Age International (P) Ltd., 1998 55 B Kato Buckling strength of plates in the elastic range. IABSE, 25, 1965. 56 N.W. Murray. Buckling of stiffened panels loaded axially and in bending. The Structural Engineer, 51, 1973 57 A.C. Walker and N. W. Murray. A plastic collapse mechanism for compressed plates. IABSE, 35, 1975. 58 N.W. Murray. Introduction to the theory of thin-walled structures. Clarendon Press~ Oxford, 1984. 59. K.W. Sin The collapse behaviour of thin-walled sections. PhD Thesis, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, 1985
42 H . F . Wong. Dynamic and static crushing of closed hat section members. PhD Thesis,
60
University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, 1993. H. Setiyono. Web crippling of cold formed plain channel steel section beams. PhD
61
Thesis, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, 1994 T . H . Lim Some plasticity studies relating to thin-walled beams. PhD Thesis, University
62
of Strathclyde Glasgow, 1995 63. X. -L. Zhao and G. J. Hancock. Plastic mechanism analysis of T-joints in RHS subject to combined bending and concentrated force University of Sydney. School of Civil and
Mining Engineering. Research Report No. R763, 1993 64. X. -L. Zhao and G. J. Hancock. A theoretical analysis of the plastic moment capacity of an inclined yield line under axial force. Thin-Walled Structures, 15, 1993 65. X. -L Zhao and G. J. Hancock. Experimental verification of the theory of plastic moment capacity of an inclined yield line under axial load. Thin-Walled Structures, 15, 1993 66. X. -L. Zhao, E. O. T. Lip and R. H. Grzebieta. Plastic Mechanism analysis using newly derived yield line theory. First Australian Congress on Applied Mechanics, Melbourne,
1996 67. R. H. Grzebieta. On the equilibrium approach for predicting the crush response of mild steel structures. Ph.D Thesis, Monash University, 1990. APPENDIX.
Table
1.
Table of buckling coefficients K and postbuckling coefficients for use with Eqns. 4 and 11-15 Coeff
Simply supported plates
Cl
3 + 1.1e 3
Cls =
0.22
C2s
(e
C3
-
0.07) 2 +
1 + 13e 4
c6
C2r = (e - 0.2)2 + 0.07
GF
---
2.44 + 13.25 e l+5e 3
C4s = 0.54 + 0.08 2
0.15 C4v = ""5- + 0.1
C~s = L64 + 2.35e 2 + 0.255e4
Csr = 1.2 + 3.6e 2 + 0.3e 4
e
c5
1 + 1.375e 3
++
0.088
0.06
3 + 50.6e 4 C3s =
Intermediate conditions
2.44 + 1.7 e 3 elF m
1 + 0.673e 3
C2
C4
Fully fixed plates
C,~ =0.21e2 + 044/e 2 -0055
c,
Ks = 2
+ e 2 + l/e 2
C3 "--
C3s -(0.08 +0.5e) R C3r 1 - (0.08 + 05e) R
c4= C~ --(O.175+O075e) R C4v 1 - (0.175+ 0075e)R
e -
C~
C6r =0.4e 2 + 0.08e 4 - 0.15
K r =2A9+5.139e 2 +0.975/e 2
11 Cls - 0.094R/C-at
C2 = C2s - (0.071 e 2 )R C2u 1 O.07Rle 2
C6 "-
IK
1 - 0.094R
Css - 0 . 2 R Csv 1 - 0.2R
C6s - 0.2 e: R C6r
r= g
1 - 0.2e 2 R
-QRtG
1-QR
Q = 0.1e / (0.152 + e)
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
43
Failure predictions of thin-walled steel structures under cyclic loading Tsutomu Usami and Hanbin Ge Department of Civil Engineering, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464-8603, Japan This paper deals with failure predictions of thin-walled steel structures subjected to cyclic loading. To trace inelastic behavior of steel structures, an elastoplastic large displacement analysis using a modified two-surface plasticity constitutive model for the material, is carried out. Discussions of the buckling mode, displacement and strain at failure are made in detail. Empirical formulas for predicting the ultimate strength and ductility are also presented. 1. INTRODUCTION The basic philosophy in the seismic design of a structure is to ensure that the supply capacity is no less than the demand anticipated by a specified earthquake motion. To this end, sufficient capacity in regards to strength, ductility and/or absorbed energy should be provided by the structure. It is well known that thin-walled steel structures are susceptible to local and overall interaction buckling because their sections are characterized by a large width/radius to wall thickness ratio. Their failure behavior can be investigated through an experimental procedure. However, such an approach is far from covering various structural profiles and related parameters. On the other hand, when an analytical approach is considered as an alternative, it is no doubt that a precise analysis is needed. This paper presents failure predictions of thin-walled steel structures under cyclic loading. Elastoplastic large displacement cyclic analysis is carried out to study inelastic behavior and obtain the supply capacity. Cantilever-type steel columns either with a box section stiffened by longitudinal stiffeners or with a pipe section are chosen as numerical examples. To simulate the cyclic behavior of steel with good accuracy, a modified two-surface plasticity model developed at Nagoya University (Shen et al. 1995) is employed. To gain a good understanding of inelastic behavior, numerical results of the local buckling mode, deformed configuration and stress progression are presented in detail. Finally, formulas for predicting the strength and ductility at failure, which are based on the extensive parametric analysis, are briefly summarized.
2. STRESS-STRAIN RELATIONSHIP FOR DIFFERENT MATERIAL MODELS When we conduct a cyclic elastoplastic analysis of a steel structure, the use of a constitutive model that can accurately predict the stress-strain behavior of the structural steel under cyclic loading is quite important. At the present time, available constitutive models, which have been implemented in many software packages for structural analysis, are the isotropic hardening (IH) and kinematic hardening (KH) models that use the von Mises yield criterion. Moreover, the equivalent stress and equivalent strain relationships assumed for structural steel in most of the past studies employing such classical plasticity models are typical bilinear or multilinear curves, as shown in Fig. 1. Cyclic characteristics of these models under uniaxial loading are illustrated in Fig. 2. They are compared with that of a modified two-surface plasticity model (2SM) developed at Nagoya University
44 2 (Shen et al. 1995). The equivalent stress and equivalent strain curve predicted by the 2SM is also shown in Fig. 1. It is worth noting that the 1.5 modified two-surface model was developed on the basis of a large number of cyclic experiments of the material and its validity has been verified for various types of steel structures. As is seen from Fig. 2, cyclic 0.5 . . . . . . . 2SM behavior predicted by classical models, except -----.-- Multilinear for the IH model with the multilinear stress-strain 0 I , , I I Bilinear curve, is completely different from that of the 0 50 I00 2SM model (Fig. 2(a), (b) and (c)). Although eiEy the IH model with a multilinear stress-strain Figure 1. Equivalent stresscurve and the 2SM model seem to give close equivalent strain curves predictions, the former overestimates the stress during the first two cycles. The main reasons why classical models simulate the cyclic behavior so differently from actual behavior are: (1) no yield plateau is included in the bilinear stress-strain curve; (2) Bauschinger effect, reduction of the elastic range of the unloading curve and cyclic hardening effect can not be taken into account.
f
;3 2
2SM .......
I
'
l
'
I
'~
B-KH
16.......__ '
I
d
12
o
J
,,.e
-1 I
,
I
-80
i
,
-40
0
I
t
40
I
i
80
"
2SM
M-KH
r I
~
1
i
I
'
I
'
.
r .
,
o
--"9
t,'" ; . . . .r. .................. . .. . ~ i I -80 -40
,
.
,,JJ
I
,
I
-40
9
.I
0 e/Ey
" - -
";llt ,
0
I
i
I
40
i
"
80
120
- - - -
....... 9
M-IH
I'
,
,
21
,~ , ~ ~ _ ~ ~
2
.
I
1
'
~ -
'
.
,
r,,l
.
,
--=
..e
1/
-80
""
i
.,,'' ,,,''' ..
3
-o
.
-120
l "7
..... I I ;l
~
o
,
ellEy
.
~
t
o
tiSy 3
,
I l l .... : t t ,- . . . . . . . . . .... . .
-16 -120
120
1
...........
-4 -8
-3 -120
2SMiI..
~
. 4 --
, I
s 1
40
I
3
,
80
D
120
i '
~d-'d~l
-120
i
-80
-
_._
I
-40
I
0
40
i
I
80
,
120
t/ey
Figure 2. Stress and strain relationships of material models under uniaxial cyclic loading 3. CYCLIC BEHAVIOR OF STIFFENED BOX-SECTION S T E E L COLUMNS 3.1. Hysteresis curves To show the effects of these plasticity models on the cyclic behavior of steel structures,
45 two tested column specimens with stiffened box sections were analyzed using the M-IH, M-KH, and 2SM models. Fig. 3 shows the lateral load-lateral displacement curves of a thin-walled column B 14 with Rf= 0.56 and ~- = 0.26 (Nishikawa et al. 1996). Here, R/is the width-thickness ratio parameter, ~- is the column slenderness ratio parameter, and their definitions are given as follows. b I12(1-1p2) 4n2/g 2
~ /~
2
I ' I I
Rf ----t
(1)
I I I I I i ], BI 4
3
,,'"
~o =
~/ , z~ ~
_
"'
,'"
-2 -10
"
~"
.
[[
-8
i I I -a -4
2
''
-2
~o =
4
' i'i'
6
"i'
I'LKD.IO
-' . ~ ~
.'-'-"~e~-,
"~c
-3 i I I I , I I I a I J -10 -8 -a -4 -2 0 2 8/8y
L
3
Rf=0.35
I,
,-
--
r,,ck
I! ,
i ,
, i
4
, i
6
M-lit 8 10
' ] KD-10
-
-"9; - ~ . - ~ - ,
1
-1
'
(a) . . . . . . . . . . . . .
M-IH 8 10
liB14
i
,
;~'i,'- ~""
.,
-
I 0 2 818y
I '
~
2 --
.]
-
.
..
--'i
{b),
"
i i
-2
[ I
I I I i
-10
-~ --
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
iest M-KH
2
4
6
8
10
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
818y 2 ~
.
I I i
' i 'l
3
i I[ BI4 -
_ -
-10
. "
-1
, I , I , I , -8
-6
-4
-2
i 0
M-KH 2
4
6
8
10
818y
1 -
-2
. Test
-2 - ( b ) -3 i I I I I, I i I i
, I 0
2
Rr=0.35
] i I i
' l'
l '1 KD-lO
"
l _
"
-1
crack-
~
j
"
2SM 4
6
8
-3 10
618y Figure 3. Predicted hysteresis curves of a box-section steel column: B 14
, I ,I,
-10
-8
-6
I i I , -4
-2
, II 0
2
2SM 4
6
8
10
816y Figure 4. Predicted hysteresis curves of a box-section steel column: KD-10
46
~ : 2hr7r1~~
H (2)
Failure Point
|emn@mn@gmmee~ll II
in which, txy- yield stress; E - Young's modulus; v - Poisson's ratio; b - flange :. : Envelope Curve plate width, t - plate thickness; n number of subpanels separated by stiffeners; h - column height; and r radius of gyration of the cross section. The dashed line denotes the analytical ~m ~95 results, while the solid line represents the test result. These figures show that the Figure 5. Definition of failure point strengths predicted by the three material models at each reversal point are very close to the test results. From this point of view, the 2SM model does not display any advantage compared with M-IH and M-KH models. However, the hysteresis loops of M-IH become quite "fat" near the peak point due to the omission of the Bauschinger effect. In the case of the M-KH model, the analytical result at the post-buckling stage overestimates the experimental result because the M-KH model does not consider the reduction of the material property's elastic range for the unloading curve (Figs. 1 and 2). On the other hand, the 2SM analysis can predict the test result over the whole range with reasonably good accuracy. Figure 4 compares the hysteresis curves of the analyses and the test of specimen KD-10 where Rf- 0.35. This specimen is a thick-walled column. In the case of M-IH [see Fig. 4(a)], the hysteresis loops of the analysis are much "fatter" than that of the test. The maximum strength and post-buckling capacity are largely overestimated. The reason for this is that it is very difficult for local buckling of such a thick-walled column to occur. On the other hand, the M-KH model [see Fig. 4(b)] gives a lower prediction than the test result. Fig. 4(c) shows the comparison of the 2SM analysis with the test result. It is observed that except for the final loop, the analysis result coincides precisely with the test result. As reported by Nakamura et al. (1996), this specimen suddenly lost its load carrying capacity in the final loop due to a crack occurring on the tension side at the base.
3.2. Progression of local buckling Before we proceed to discuss the progression of buckled deformation during the process of cyclic loading, definition of the failure point that is considered to be the ultimate state of a structure's capacity is first described here. Fig. 5 shows a lateral load-lateral displacement curve which represents the envelope curve of the hysteretic curve. Usually, a point where the load is reduced to 95% of the maximum load (H95)is defined as the failure point. Hence, special attention should be paid to the deformation and stress level at or around this point. Figure 6 shows the local buckling configuration of a column where Rf- 0.35 and ~ -~ 0.35 at states of Hmaxand H95,which are obtained from the cyclic analysis using the 2SM model. At HI,L~,as shown in Fig. 6(a), the compressive flange plate deforms slightly inward and the stiffener buckles out of plane. This observation indicates that local buckling is initiated before the maximum load is reached. On the other hand, Fig. 6(b) exhibits obvious local buckling deformation in both the flange plates and stiffeners corresponding to H95, namely at failure point. To investigate quantitatively the buckled deformation, the lateral load-inward displacement curves at Point A in flange and Point B in stiffener (see Fig. 6(b)), where maximum deformation has occurred, are shown in Fig. 7. The inward displacement A is normalized against the plate thickness t. Values of A/t at the failure point are 2.6 at Point A and 1.7 at Point B. It should be noted that the value of A/t is related to the main structural parameters including Rf and i-, and a further study of the correlation is needed. Such a relationship would be useful in practice because the residual strength of damaged structures can be estimated by measuring plate deformation. m
47
!t !
!
W Jl ~ P
~ aim w
(a) at Hm,,x (b) at H95 Figure 6. Buckling modes of a stiffened box-section column 2
F'
J'lmax
9
I
I
"
I
"__ . . ". , [ J,,~.,~ I '
1
Hy
m -1
-1
-2[ Pos,ition: " ...." .... I, . q .2 Position: Point B in stiffener -6 .5 -4 -3 .2 -1 0 0 2 4 (a) A/t (b) A/t Figure 7. Deformation progression in a stiffened box-section column
6
4. C Y C L I C BEHAVIOR OF PIPE-SECTION STEEL COLUMNS 4.1. Hysteresis curves Figure 8 compares the hysteresis curves of a pipe section column for the test and analyses for models 2SM, B-IH and B-KH. The column has a slenderness ratio parameter of ~ - 0.26 and a radius-thickness ratio parameter of Rt - 0.11. Rt is defined as r, = a ,
Oc,
o, o
O)
E 2t
where D and t are the diameter and the thickness of the pipe section, respectively. The curves of the nondimensionalized lateral load versus lateral displacement from both the test and 2SM analysis are shown in Fig. 8(a). The shape of the hysteresis loops from the 2SM analysis agrees with the experimental result at both the peak and post-buckling stage. Figs. 8(b) and 8(c) show the corresponding lateral load-lateral displacement hysteresis curves obtained by using the B-IH and B-KH material models compared with the experimental result. The following phenomena can be observed: (1) The load carrying capacity at each half-cycle is overestimated by the B-IH model; and (2) The computed hysteresis curve by the B-KH model is in good agreement with the experimental result when the horizontal displacement lies within 48y. Beyond that, the analytical curve deviates from the experimental curve and overestimates the load-carrying capacity. These differences are the result of drawback of the B-IH and B-KH material models. The Bauschinger effect is
48 neglected in the B-IH model, and in the B-KH model the size of the elastic range for the unloading curve is assumed constant. This differs from the actual behavior of structural steel, especially during the large plastic deformation range. Moreover, both the B-KH and B-IH models can not properly model the yield plateau and fail to consider accurately the effect of cyclic strain hardening. In contrast, the 2SM takes into account the aforementioned important cyclic characteristics of structural steel. Therefore, the analysis using the 2SM can predict accurately the cyclic behavior of a pipe-section steel column.
4.2. Progression of local buckling
,1.! . . . .
, a,:?.,l
I o
-I
(a) -2 2
pl
9
l.
.
~
.
.
.
.
.
.
Rt=O.l I
~ , -....' ~.-~.. ~.=o.z.~
I o
-I -
"~. . . .
"";-~.:
~.er~.7~'7
."
Figure 9 compares the buckling modes between the test and the analyses, 2 P l [. . . . . . . . I Rt=0.11 respectively. It is observed that the 1 ' 0..~/:~ -. I ~--o.z6; buckling modes predicted by the 2SM and B-KH analyses are quite similar to that of the tested specimen. At the 0 commencement of local buckling, the length of the buckle is limited to an extremely small area in both the -1(c) - ' " ~ longitudinal and circumferential directions. With an increase in loading -I0 -5 0 S IO cycles, this buckling wave that was an 8183 outward displacement will be transmitted Figure 8. Predicted hystereticcurves of rapidly in the circumferential direction, a pipe-section column and eventually an elephant-foot buckling mode is formed. This phenomenon matches well with the actual mode of the steel bridge piers failed in the Hyogoken-Nanbu earthquake. However, the extent of deformation of the B-KH analysis is smaller than those of both the test and 2SM analysis. On the other hand, the buckling mode predicted by the B-IH model greatly differs from that of the test. The position of the local buckle shifts upward. One possible reason why this occurs is due to the exaggerated expansion of elastic range of the B-IH model, as stated previously. Comparison of the buckling modes in Fig. 9 indicates that the 2SM model can duplicate the buckling mode of the test with satisfactory accuracy, whereas both the B-IH and B-KH models predict unlikely buckling modes. _ Figure 11 illustrates buckled deformation of a thin-walled column where RI - 0.11 and - 0.3 at H,,,,x, H95 and other points, as noted in Fig. 10(a) for monotonic loading and Fig. 10(b) for cyclic loading. It is observed that maximum deformation occurs at Point A in both the monotonic and cyclic loading, but the outward displacement w/t corresponding to H,n,,x is about 0.5 and 1.0, respectively. When the load has decreased to 1-195 in the monotonic loading, the value of w/t at Point A increases to 1.3. In the case of cyclic loading, a loading point corresponding to H95 is not available in the hysteresis loops, so two points at Hs5 and 0.89Hy (Hy is yield load) are chosen to show deformation progression. As is seen in Fig. 11 (b), the outward displacement w/t at Point A reaches approximately 2.0 at Hss, and 3.0 at 0.89Hy, respectively. Figure 12 shows how the stress progresses at Point A under two types of loading
49 programs. Plots (a) and (b) represent the inner surface and outer surface, respectively. Maximum axial strain at the failure point is around 50 times of Ey (Ey--" 0.00141 for this column). Computed results of a thick-walled column where R r - 0.05 and it - 0.3 are shown in Figs. 13 to 15. It can be observed that the maximum axial strain at failure point (H95) is about 150 times Ey (Ey = 0.00114 for this column). Thus, such an analysis needs an accurate plasticity model that can simulate cyclic behavior in a large strain range. m
5. S T R E N G T H TILITY
AND
DUC-
Based on extensive elastoplastic large displacement analyses using the 2SM model, some of empirical formulas have been proposed by authors (Gao et al. 1998, Figure 9. Buckling modes of a pipe-section column Usami and Ge 1998) to determine the strength and ductility of steel columns subjected to cyclic lateral loading and a constant axial load. The columns are composed of stiffened box-sections or pipe-sections. These equations are expressed as functions of the main structural parameters such as Rf (or R3, it, and P/Py. Here, P is the axial load, and Py is the squash load of the cross section. For stiffened box-section columns, the ultimate strength (Hmax/Hy)and ductility (Sm/Sy, 895~y) can be calculated from the following equations: Hma x
0.10
H,
(Rf;t-~')~
~
=
S,,,
= ~
S, •95
t~,
0.22
+1.06
(4)
+ 1.20
(5)
Rs ~-~Z, '
=
0.25
(1 + PlPy)Ry~~
'
+ 2.31
(6)
in which X,' is the stiffener's slenderness ratio parameter (Usami and Ge 1998), which is defined as
50 2
,
D--891mm, t-8.41mm, h : 4 3 9 0 m m
9
,,,t
|
1
9
,
,
9
9
9
9
i
*
9
- - -Hmax
1.5
1
gl
. o.sE/
t
~.~/iss0.89H,1
0 -1 ~
7.=0.30
0
P/Py:O.15
0 (a)
2
4
6
8
10
-2
i
"
-5
.
.
,
,
0
,,.
, 5
. . .
.
"
.
!
8~5y (b) 8~y Figure 10. Lateral load-lateral displacement curves of a thin'walled pipe'section column &~k" &
0.1
[ - - ' O - - - a t Hmax I - - - ~ - - a t H95
---O----at Hmax - & - at Hss - - - O - - - a t 0.89Hy
0.1
x: Distance from the base w: O u t w a r d displacement
"~ 0.05
~0.05 Point A
Point A
...,41' ~
O=
0
0.5 1 1.5 0 (a) wit (b) wit Figure 11. Deformation progression in a thin-walled pipe-section column :
9
,
9
9
|
,
9
,
,
i-
9
' 9
l .-
9
: Hnmx Failure P o i ~ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
1
" Hnmx .
..:,,
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
" H95 ~ . . . . .
- 1
-1
(a)
1
"::
1
"
-2 Position: Point -150 -100
-_
. . . . .
A, Inner surface
-50
0
-2
~.. . . . . .
Monotonic
Position: Point A, Oute'~r
-40 -20 0 (b) e]Ey Figure 12. Stress progression in a thin-walled pipe'section column
20
E~Ey
1 al~-~ (7)
where Q is the local buckling strength of plate panels given by
51
2 ~
,t=16.8mm, hf4390mm
1
9
2 ..
.
,
. ' '. . . .
_It,.,] "
9
1.5 !
Hmax
Rtffi0.05 L-0~0
0 ~ 10
20
'-
.98
"
-1
P/Py=0.15
0
9
|;
0.5
94
-2
"
30
t
.
.
,
,
-10
0
10
(a) ~Y (b) ~y Figure 13. Lateral load-lateral displacement curves of a thick-walled pipe-section c o l u m n
'&
! --4J---at Hmax "--&---at H9s x: Distance from the base w: Outward displacement
0.1
~0.05
0.1
~0.05
Point A
0
1
(a)
2
0
wit
1
Co)
2 w/t
Figure 14. D e f o r m a t i o n p r o g r e s s i o n in a thick-walled pipe-section column
2.''1 ;:::::H:-.:m:x: ~::.:::::.....-::-..........~jiure_ Point. .
.
.
.
I
"
' '
'
i
.
.
.
.
.
2
.
. H;~,~==I~, ,,~TI ~- ~
1
-2 Position: Point A, Inner surface[ -300
-200
(a)
-100
~[l~y
. ,0
-1 .
_?..c
-2 -100
-50
(b)
. /
t ~
:
Point A, Outer surface 0
50
100
e/ey
F i g u r e 15. S t r e s s p r o g r e s s i o n in a thick-walled pipe-section c o l u m n
Q=~y1 [P-~/p2-4R, ]
(8)
= 1.33R f "~ 0.868
(9)
52 and ct is aspect ratio of flange plate (= a/b, a is flange length), rs - radius of gyration of the T-shape cross section which consists of one longitudinal stiffener and the adjacent subpanels. In the case of the pipe-section columns, the proposed equations are given by Hn~ x - - - 0.02 ~ + Hy (Rt~-) ~
6m _
~,
~9._.ff_5 =
~y
1.10
(10)
2 3
(11)
1 3(R, ~'-~ ) ~
0.24
(12)
(1 + P I ey)2/3-~/3R,
6. CONCLUSIONS Elastoplastic large displacement analysis was carried out to predict the failure of steel structures under cyclic loading. The cyclic characteristics of classical isotropic and kinematic hardening plasticity models as well as a modified two-surface model were investigated, and their application to failure prediction of steel structures were presented. Moreover, local buckling, deformation and stress progressions were discussed. Comparisons of analytical and experimental results showed that accurate failure predictions require an accurate plasticity model. REFERENCES
Gao S. B., Usami T., and Ge H. B. (1998). Ductility evaluation of steel bridge piers with pipe sections. J. Engrg. Mech., ASCE, 124(3), 260-267. Nakagawa, T., Yasunami, H., Kobayashi, Y., Hashimoto, O., Mizutani, S., and Moriwaki, K. (1996). Evaluation of Strength and Deformation for Box Section Steel Piers by Finite Element Analysis. Proc. of The 1st Conference on Hyogoken-Nanbu Great Earthquake, JSCE, 599-604. Nishikawa K., Murakoshi J., Takahashi M., Okamoto T., Ikeda S., and Morishita H. (1999). Experimental study on strength and ductility of steel portal frame pier. J. Struct. Engrg., JSCE, 45A, 235-244 (in Japanese). Shen C., Mamaghani IHP, Mizyno E., and Usami T. (1995). Cyclic behavior of structural steels. 11: theory. J. Engrg., Mech., ASCE, 121, 1165-1172. Usami T., and Ge H. B. (1998). Cyclic behavior of thin-walled steel structures - numerical analysis. Thin-walled structures, Vol. 32, 41-80.
Impact Loading
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
55
On the criteria for cracking and rupture o f ductile plates under impact loading Norman Jones and Caroline Jones Impact Research Centre, Department of Engineering (Mechanical Engineering) The University of Liverpool, Liverpool L69 3GH, U.K.
ABSTRACT Some recent studies which have been undertaken into the behaviour of circular plates subjected to impact loads which produce large inelastic strains and material failure are discussed in this article. The experimental data yields the threshold conditions for failure. In order to predict the quantities which might be used to construct a failure criterion, the threshold conditions are examined using a numerical finite-element code, without activating any failure algorithms. It turns out that critical values of the rupture strain and the strain energy density are both promising failure criteria worthy of further study.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
Maximum values of dynamic loadings which cause structural failure are required for economical and safe designs. This article is concerned with the failure of ductile structures which are subjected to dynamic loads causing large inelastic strains. Structural instability and other types of structural failure are not considered. Rigid-plastic methods of analysis [1] are often used to predict the response of structural members when subjected to sufficiently severe dynamic loads. These methods predict various features of the response including the permanent displacement profile of a structure, but they assume that the idealised material has an unlimited ductility. Nevertheless, these methods have been developed further to explore the failure of structures and have identified three modes of failure in impulsively loaded beams [1 ]. The first failure mode is called mode I and relates to the large permanent ductile deformations which are produced without any material failure. For larger impulsive loads, a mode II material failure might occur when the uniaxial rupture strain of the material is exceeded. At still higher blast loads, a transverse shear failure might develop and is known as a mode III failure. This approach has been used by several groups to examine the dynamic inelastic failure of other structures subjected to impact and blast loadings, as discussed in Reference [2], and has been successful in highlighting the principal response characteristics, in identifying the major parameters and is a useful aid for interpreting experimental data. Numerical schemes such as finite-element codes are used extensively in modem structural design. However, a numerical code requires a universal failure criterion, but even the dynamic inelastic failure criterion for a simple beam is unknown [3] and, moreover, the failure mode depends on the kind of dynamic loading. Many numerical calculations assume that a dynamic inelastic failure occurs when the maximum equivalent strain reaches the corresponding value at
56 failure in a static uniaxial tensile test. This simplification ignores any change of the rupture strain with strain rate or any variation with the hydrostatic stress [4]. The dynamic response of a fully clamped ductile metal beam struck by a mass having a sufficient initial kinetic energy to produce large inelastic strains and material failure was studied in Reference [5]. This experimental arrangement was selected because it is quite straightforward and easy to control. Initially, the beams suffered large inelastic deformations without failure (mode I), but, as the initial kinetic energy was increased, cracking was first observed, then complete failure occurred for sufficiently large impact energies. Thus, the dynamic loading conditions associated with the failure threshold could be established. The experimental test beams were made from mild steel and the static and dynamic tensile properties were obtained using specimens cut from the same block of material over the range of strain rates observed in the beam impact tests. A more comprehensive programme of tests was conducted recently on fully clamped beams struck by a mass travelling with an initial impact velocity which causes large inelastic deformations and material failure [6]. The beam test geometry, dynamic material properties and the impact loading details, for the threshold conditions, were then employed in the ABAQUS finite-element numerical code. No failure criterion was implemented in the implicit finiteelement code. This enabled the parameters required for a variety of failure criteria to be assessed at the initiation of cracking or at the threshold of failure, indicated by the experimental results, without the numerical code being prejudiced towards any particular failure criterion. However, the numerical values for various quantities such as the equivalent strain, strain energy density, shear stress, etc., can be obtained at the threshold of failure and, therefore, can be used to suggest a criterion which controls failure. This partnership between experimental results and accurate numerical predictions is essential because it is very difficult, if not impossible, to record all of the detailed information from experimental tests at the initiation of failure for structures subjected to dynamic loads which produce large inelastic deformations and swains. It transpires from a careful comparison between the experimental results [5,6] and the numerical predictions [3,6] that the maximum membrane force in a beam cross-section and the uniaxial tensile rupture strain appear to be the most promising criteria for a tensile failure, while the maximum Tresca stress or maximum Mises stress and the maximum plastic strain energy density are worthy of further study for predicting a shear failure. The results of a recent experimental test programme on the impact loading of fully clamped mild steel circular plates are discussed in the next section. Numerical calculations for the plates using the ABAQUS finite-element code are discussed in Section 3. This article is completed with a discussion and conclusions in Sections 4 and 5, respectively.
2. FAILURE OF PLATES DUE TO IMPACT LOADS A beam might be considered as a one-dimensional structure from a global, or design, perspective, although local three-dimensional affects are important at the failure site. The impact failure of plates, which are nominally two-dimemional structures, is examined in this section. A considerable body of theoretical work and several empirical equations have been published on the behaviour and perforation of ductile plates struck by missiles [7]. Nevertheless, the field remains active with articles being published currently on high velocity perforation producing adiabatic shearing effects etc. and on low velocity impacts causing large transverse displacements which induce membrane forces in a plate before failure. The material failures in
57 these studies occur in the plate immediately underneath the striking mass. It is difficult to develop a universal failure criterion on the basis of the behaviour in this highly localised region, even for a low velocity impact [8]. Tests have been conducted recently on 203.2 mm diameter (D) fully clamped circular plates struck by masses which produce large inelastic deformations and material failure. It was the objective of these tests to promote failure around the outer boundary of a plate and away from the complicated behaviour at the impact site. Static and dynamic material properties were obtained from tests which were conducted on specimens cut from the same mild steel plate. In order to achieve material failure at the plate boundary, an indenter having a rounded nose was constructed with the same profile as that used for the beam tests discussed in Reference [6], but generated as a volume of revolution. The centreline of the impacter having a main cylindrical body with a diameter D/5 is located at a distance of D/8 from the plate boundary and seven different failure modes were identified for 1.6 turn and 3 mm thick plates. These failure modes lie within the four categories: Mode Mode Mode Mode
I: II: III: IV:
large permanent ductile deformations of a plate, through-thickness failure in a plate underneath the impactor, through-thickness failure at the clamped edge of a plate, and through-thickness failure at the clamped edge of a plate and limited failure underneath the impactor.
Photographs of typical mode I to IV failure-s in 1.6 mm thick circular mild steel plates are shown in Figures 1(a)-(d) for specimens IBP15 (4.50 m/s), IBP17 (8.23 m/s), IPB 14 (11.00 m/s) and IPB3 (14.45 m/s), respectively. A laser-Doppler velocimeter was used during the impact tests in order to record the velocitytime histories of the indenter from which the temporal variations of the impact forces in Figure 2 were obtained. Faster rise times of specimens IPB14 and IPB3 for mode III and mode IV failures, respectively, are due to the higher impact velocities of 11.00 and 14.45 m/s in Figure 2. The slowest rise time is associated with test specimen IPB15 which undergoes large ductile deformations, or a mode I response, without any material failure. The largest force is associated with a mode II failure 0BP17) and is likely due to the development of large membrane forces before a local through-thickness failure occurs underneath the indenter. The lower maximum forces associated with mode III and mode IV failures are probably because the length of tom plating at the boundaries in Figures l(c) and (d) prevents the development of localised membrane forces as large as those for a mode II failure. It is interesting to note that the pulses (i.e., areas under the curves in Figure 2) are similar for those specimens exhibiting modes II (137 Ns), III (147 Ns) and IV (130 Ns) failures. The pulse of 74 Ns for the mode I case in Figure 2 is much lower became the impact velocity of 4.50 m/s is well below the mode II threshold value of 8.17 m/s, approximately. On the other hand, the input energies are 147 J, 497 J, 878 J and 1513 J for the mode I to IV cases in Figures 1 and 2. The impact forces of the four test specimens in Figures 1 and 2 are replotted in Figure 3 with the impactor displacement as the abscissa. The areas under these curves give the external work of 140 J, 494 J, 875 J and 1304 J for modes I to IV, which, with the exception of the mode IV value, are very similar to the values noted previously.
58
Figure 1. Photographs depicting examples of plate specimens that exhibit the failure modes (a) I, (b) II, (c) 1II and (d) IV under low velocity impact conditions 100
A
60
a)
o
40
u.
20
z
0
IPB17 (11)
IPB3
80
IPB14 (111)
IPB15 (I) -20
0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Time (ms)
Figure 2. Force-time histories for the plate specimens in Figure 1.
59 100 -
E]15 (i)
f~
80-
-.
A
Z _~e O O t_ O It-
60 4020
O.
d,
IPB17 (11) B14 (111)
30v)
L x
I"
|
0
10
l
20
30
40
50
Displacement of Impactor (mm)
Figure 3. A comparison of force-displacement histories for the plate in Figure 1.
3. NUMERICAL FINITE-ELEMENT STUDIES ON THE IMPACT RESPONSE OF BEAMS AND PLATES The finite-element code ABAQUS has been used to examine the experimental studies on beams and circular plates subjected to impact loads which are reported in the previous two sections. It was observed that good agreement between the numerical predictions and the experimental results were obtained when the plates suffered large permanent transverse displacements without any material failure (mode I response). This comparison serves as a calibration of the ABAQUS finite-element code for this particular plate impact problem and offers a degree of confidence in the numerical predictions. It appears from these preliminary numerical calculations for the circular plate specimens in Figures 1 to 3 and the recent tests on thicker plate specimens (3.0 ram) that the strain energy density and the rupture strain criteria are the most suitable for predicting material failure. However, other criteria are being explored currently and furt.her details will be published in due course.
4.
DISCUSSION
The preliminary conclusions of the current research programme suggest that critical values of the uniaxial tensile rupture strain and the plastic strain energy density are both promising criteria for the material failure of mild steel beams and plates which are subjected to impact loadings producing large inelastic strains. However, additional studies, particularly experimental ones, are required to clarify the role of the triaxiality (ratio of hydrostatic and yield stresses) and strain rate on the uniaxial rupture strain criterion. The various observations have been made for structures made from mild steel. Clearly, the failure criteria for structures made from other materials might be different. In fact, the impact behaviour of flat aluminium alloy beams have been examined in Reference [9] and it was observed that, in contradistinction to the flat steel beams, failure occurred either at the
60 support or at the impact location. Moreover, all of the failures for the beams with enlarged ends occurred at the supports. 5.
CONCLUSIONS
The experimental results in this article for circular plates subjected to impact loads, which produce large inelastic strains and material failure, together with the experimental data on the static and dynamic properties of the materials over a range of strain rates, can be used as benchmark studies for the calibration of numerical codes and the development of dynamic inelastic failure criteria. In the present work, the predictions of various quantities given by the ABAQUS finite-element code are calculated for the impact conditions at the threshold of failure according to the experimental test results. The numerical conditions do not activate any failure criteria which might be available in the computer code in order not to prejudice any conclusions. However, the inelastic material behaviour observed in the experimental work was incorporated in the numerical scheme. This partnership between experimental results and numerical predictions suggest that critical values of the uniaxial tensile rupture strain and the plastic strain energy density are both promising criteria for the material failure of mild steel beams and plates which are subjected to impact loadings producing large inelastic strains. However, further studies are necessary to examine the accuracy of these failure criteria for other types of dynamic loadings, different structures and other materials.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors are grateful to EPSRC for their support of this study under grant number GR/J 699998 and to Mrs. M. White for her secretarial assistance. REFERENCES ~
2. .
~
.
N. Jones, Structural Impact, Cambridge University Press, paperback edition, 1997. N. Jones, Dynamic inelastic failure of structures, Trans. Japanese Society of Mechanical Engineers, 63( 616), 2485-2495, 1997. J. Yu and N. Jones, Numerical simulation of impact loaded steel beams and the failure criteria, Int. J. Solids and Structures, 34(30), 3977-4004, 1997. M. Alves and N. Jones, Influence of hydrostatic stress on failure of axisymmetric notched specimens, J. of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 47(3), 643-667, 1999. J. Yu and N. Jones, Further experimental investigations on the failure of clamped beams under impact Loads", Int. J. Solids and Structures, 27(9), 1113-1137, 1991. N. Jones and C. Jones, Dynamic inelastic failure of beams and plates, Impact response of Materials Structures, Eds. V. P. W. Shim, S. Tanimura and C. T. Lim, Oxford, pp. 3747, 1999. G. G. Corbett, S. R. Reid and W. Johnson, Impact loading of plates and shells by freeflying projectiles: A review, Int. J. Impact Engineering, 18(2), 141-230, 1996. N. Jones, S. B. Kim and Q. M. Li, Response and failure analysis of ductile circular plates struck by a mass, Trans. ASME, J. Pressure Vessel Technology, 119(3), 332-342, 1997. J. Liu and N. Jones, Experimental investigation of clamped beams struck transversely by a mass, lnt. J. Impact Engineering, 6(4), 303-335, 1987.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000)
Editors:X.L.Zhaoand R.H.Grzebieta 9 2000ElsevierScienceLtd.All rightsreserved.
61
D y n a m i c Behavior o f Elastic-Plastic B e a m - o n - F o u n d a t i o n under Impact or Pulse Loading* X. W. Chen a"b, T. X. Yu b and Y. Z. Chen a alnstitute of Structural Mechanics, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang City, Sichuan, 621900, China bDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong A mass-spring model is used to analyze elastic-plastic BoFs under impact or pulse loading. A general analytical method for elastic-plastic BoFs under dynamic loading is proposed. The elastic, perfectly plastic BoFs under dynamic loading undergo various deformation scenarios, merely depending on a few dimensionless parameters. Two peculiar phenomena, i.e. "plastic hinge migration" in the beam and the successive propagation of plastic deformation in the foundation, as early explored in case of static loading [1 ], also occur in the dynamic cases.
1. Introduction The analysis of beam-on-foundation (BoF) systems has a large variety of engineering applications. Besides being directly applied to the case of actual foundation-supported structures or networks of beams, BoF is also used to form a simple but useful analogy to the structures consisting of thin-walled cylindrical shells. Most theoretical models and analytical methods of BoFs are mainly based on either elastic or rigid, perfectly plastic idealization. For example, Yu and Stronge [2] analyzed the dynamic response of a rigid, perfectly plastic BoF (RPB/RPF) subjected to a rigid-mass impact. Elasticity often plays a significant role not only in the elastic stage of the structure response, but also in altering the deformation history and the energy dissipation partitioning in the structure compared with the prediction of a rigid-plastic model. The incorporation of elasticity will make an essential step in developing more advanced model for BoFs. Chen and Yu [1] developed a discrete spring model and analyzed the static behavior of elastic-plastic BoFs. By using a similar mass-spring model, this paper is mainly aimed to analyze the dynamic behavior of elastic-plastic BoFs under impact or pulse loading.
2. Model and Formulation Consider an elastic-plastic beam of finite length L and density per unit length o, resting on an elastic-plastic foundation of Winkler-type. A rigid-mass G (or a pulse) impacts the BoF at * The project supportedby the NationalNatural ScienceFoundationof China under the ContractNo. 19672059
62 Qi+!
oad I bar
1
i-I i
node 1 2
Ill i-
i i+l (a)
n-I
Q,-]
Mi
A
1'
_ ~ )
y
.L4' T Mi.i
,;ii ..... Qi., * Qi Pi
(i-l)th bar n-I
Fi
ith node
i ith bar
n (b)
Fig. 1 The mass-spring model of an elastic-plastic BoF system any position with an initial velocity v0. Due to the limitation of Winkler model, i.e. the independence of individual spring elements, shear and the mass of foundation are not considered. In addition to the assumption of small deflection, the effect of axial force and strain-rate are neglected. It is also assumed that the foundation and the beam must always be in contact. A mass-spring model is proposed and all the springs representing the beam and the foundation are supposed to be bilinear ones. As shown in Fig. 1, the original beam is first discretized into (n-l) elements of equal length, while the mass of each element is assumed to be concentrated at its two ends. Hence the model consists of n flexible nodes with lumped mass p L / n , which are connected by (n-l) massless rigid links of length L/(n-1). The flexural deformation is represented by the relative rotation between adjacent rigid links and resisted by an elastic-plastic rotational spring, which reflects the flexural rigidity of the beam. At each node, an elastic-plastic spring linearly acting along the transverse direction of the beam is added to represent the effect of Winkler-type foundation. Using matrix notations, {F} =
(FI,...,Fn) T, {W} = (Wi,...,Wn) T, {Q} = (QI,...,Qn_I) T,
{m} =
(ml,...,mn) T, {(I~}= ((I~l,...,r
T, {~IJ}=
(1)
(~zJi,...,Vn) T
where {F} and {w} are the reaction force and the deflection of the foundation springs, respectively. {Q} and {M} represent the shear force and the bending moment of the beam springs, respectively. {~} and {q'} denote the absolute rotation of each link and the relative rotation angle between the adjacent links, respectively. To non-dimensionalize the formulation, define {f}-"
L{F}/My, {w}= {W}/L, {q}= L{Q}/My, {m}--{M}/My, {~}= {~}/q2y, {W} = {~}/~y,
rr = Z x/ o Z / M y , x = t / r r , (
)= d / d'r,, f y
= L Fy / M y , Wy = Wy / L ,
(2)
9I t ? l a x / r r m a x ~, = -~, 1"1= UeB /t.,eF = MrqJy* /(VrWr ), e0 = UOK/My = ,L(~ + ,a/n)Vo2 2My
where My and ~I,~ denote the maximum elastic bending moment of beam and the maximum elastic relative rotation angle of beam springs, respectively. Fr and wr are the yielding force
63 and the maximum elastic deflection of foundation springs, respectively, x is the mass ratio of the colliding body to the beam. 11 is the ratio of the maximum elastic deformation energies dissipated in the beam and foundation, e0 is the ratio of the initial kinetic energy u ~ to the maximum elastic bending moment of the beam. The governing equations of an elastic-plastic BoF can be formulated as
(3)
{W}= -n(n - I)B-I(AAT ~m}- nB-I {f }
{q} = -(,.-OA ~ {m}. {q.}= -(,.-O'r
{V} = -A{~.} = (.-OA,r {w}/~;
(4)
where/1 and B are both matrixes 1
"~
En n~
Ao l
and B -
0 + nVna)Enaxna
(5) E nxn
-- 1 nx(n-l)
in which E is a unitary matrix, ns/n and n,,/n denote the relative loading position and the loading width on the BoF, respectively. If only pulse loading is applied, B should be a unitary matrix, w~ is related to the compliance of the beam w~ = q'__L,~r - MrL n E1
(6)
Non-dimensional quantities of BoF can be formulated as k
~--(,.-0' L3K k =~ My
,
~r
~
kWy / ~lz ,
n-
(7)
L2KVey t 2Fy9 wr f r _ r Wy . . . . . . My My L k, k
~, . . . .
,
where K is the stiffness of Wirdder foundation. By the definition, k and ~ represent the nondimensional relative rigidity and limit load of elastic-plastic BoF, respectively. The non-dimensional constitutive laws of the bilinear springs of BoF can be described as
(8)
{m}= G{,V}+ Z, {I}- Z{w}+ where G, Z, H and D are all diagonal matrices and the corresponding parameters are
Gu
= ~1, elastic loading & unloading Lcz, plastic loading
0, elastic loading & reloading Z~i = ~ (1-or), plastic loading [-(1-(x)(qs:-1),
unloading
(9)
64
k., elastic loading & unloading Hii = k.f~, plastic loading
f O, elastic loading & reloading plasticloading
Oi~= (l-13)fr,
(10)
where a and fl are the hardening parameters of springs of beam and foundation, respectively. Thus the Eq. (3) can be finally rewritten as (11)
The non-dimensional initial conditions at x = 0 can be written as wi = O, i = l, ..., n
and
{ f~i = O, i = l, ..., ns, ns + na + l, ..., n ,.
fvj -
(12)
,
--~-+ k , j = ns + l, ..., ns + n a
The solution can be obtained by Runge-Kutta method. Calculations have confirmed that when n is sufficiently large, say n>_60, the solution is almost independent of n. An examination of the equations indicates that only a few non-dimensional parameters, i.e., a , 13, k, ~, 11, e0 and ~, (~, =0 for pulse loading), together with ns/n and na/n which related to the location of impact or pulse loading, are needed to characterize the dynamic behavior of a bilinear BoF system. 3. M a s s I m p a c t
on elastic, perfectly
plastic BoFs
Considering an elastic, perfectly plastic BoF, i.e. ~ =0 and 13=0, subjected to a mass impact at the mid-span of the beam ((ns +0.5na)/n=0.5). For the initial impact, we assume ;~ = 1, e0 =0.1 and na/n= 5/81 = 0 . 0 6 2 . Thus only k, ~, and rl are needed to characterize the dynamic behavior of the elastic, perfectly plastic BoF. Based on the quasi-static analysis [ 1], in general, the following conditions are required. For EB/EPF, k should be small enough and n >> 1 ; for EPB/EF, k should be large but 11<< 1 ; for EPB/EPF, k should be sufficiently large. ,/ is used to distinguish "short" or "long" beams, i.e. if v > 64, the elastic-plastic BoF is regarded as a "long" one; while if v < 64, the BoF is regarded as a "short" one. Thus, with various combinations of k, ,~ and rl, three typical deformation scenarios will be examined below. Scenario 1. EB/EPF (k - 4000, y - 8, n = 100 )
After an initial elastic vibration stage, a plastic region is initiated under the impact position and then expands outwards in the foundation, as shown in Fig. 2, whilst the beam remains in elastic bending. The velocity of the beam reduces abruptly due to the energy dissipation in the plastic deformation of the foundation. Fig. 3 demonstrates the evolution of the elastic-plastic
65 Non-dimensional lencjth x 0.25 0.5 0..7~ ................
-3 0
._o
~
,_,
~-_ _ ~.
_- _- - : -
_
9: _ . . . ' _
__
- . _
r 19
E=
3 ~
0
6
~
t=O 003
.~9~"
0.06
I11 t,--
._o I9
I
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I
19
EE tO
z
Z " O
_, .
.
.
f
'
0
,
.
Fig. 2 Deformed shapes of EB/EPF
'~ I
i
"l
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Non-dimensional length x
Fig. 3 The evolution of E-P boundary in the foundation of EB/EPF
boundary in the foundation of EB/EPF with time. The BoF collapses when the foundation deforms plastically along the whole length. -- 100, rI = 0.1 ) Fig. 4 shows the bending moment distributions of the beam at different time. After initial mass impact, as shown in Fig. 5, the stationary plastic hinge occurs at the sides of impact position. The stationary hinge may change alternatively between positive and negative yields due to the vibration of the beam after impact. It also disappears for a while during the transition. The migration of plastic hinge only takes place before the bending moment changes sign at the stationary hinge position. Under quasi-static loading, as shown in [1], the reverse plastic hinge migrates continuously and is limited in a very small distance until collapse. Differently, under impact loading, the second or third plastic hinges appear and migrate skippingly in the beam, and they can also change between positive and negative yields. As the foundation deforms elastically, only a little energy dissipates in the plastic yielding of beam. The BoF finally re-experiences elastic vibration. Scenario
2. E P B / E F ( k = 10,000, y
Scenario
3. E P B / E P F
( k = 80,000, ~ = 100,11 = 2 )
Fig. 6 depicts the evolution of the elastic-plastic boundary in the foundation and the plastic hinge in the beam. Actually the BoF undergoes a local yielding in the foundation, accompanied by the occurrence of a stationary plastic hinge in the beam. Like that of EPB/EF, the stationary hinge can change between positive and negative yielding, and it may E
.o~
1 T'~
Iil~
t=O.O09 --+- t=0.0228 =
"
~, 9 ~
0.1 o.o7s
•
.......
Non-dimensional
length x
"
o "-
~
c
o
eZ
0.025 9m = l
| ..Q
-1 Fig. 4 Bending moment diagrams of EPB/EF
9m=-I
0
, , 7,,=1,=
0
0.25
.~
, ,
0.5
,
,
0.75
1
Fig. 5 The evolution of plastic hinges in the beam of EPB/EF
66 --
-~ 9
0.1
0.075
i ~ W/Wy>1
o
"~ *"
m
.==
~ / / /
0.025
w/wy= 1 = hinge(m=1) hinge (m=-l)
._~Non_dimensiona?ie~gOl~ 0897
z
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Non-dimensionallength x
Fig. 6 The evolution of E-P boundary and plastic hinges in EPB/EPF
---- t=0.0153 ....§ ....t=0.0429 --o .... t=0.0663
3 Fig. 7 Deformed shape of EPB/EPF
disappear during the transition. The plastic deformation region becomes smaller with the increase of time and finally disappears. That means, the plastic deformation is replaced by the elastic unloading. As shown in Fig. 7, the maximum plastic deflection of foundation in the first yielding stage is obviously larger than that in the second plastic deformation stage. The reverse (upward) deflection always behaves as elastic during the vibration of the BoF. Finally the elastic recovery occurs completely and the BoF re-experiences an elastic vibration. In the quasi-static analysis [1], two collapse mechanisms exist, i.e. plastic yielding of foundation and "rigid-body" rotation of beam. Differently in dynamic analysis, only one collapse mechanism is observed, i.e. the entire yielding of foundation. Actually, the dynamic behavior of an elastic, perfectly plastic BoF is determined not only by its own characteristics k, ~( and 11, but also by the impact loading parameters, especially by ~. and e0. These factors strongly affect the final phase of BoF after impact, meanwhile result in the transition of various scenarios in impact. More details are discussed in a successive paper. 4.
Conclusions
1. A mass-spring model is developed to analyze dynamic response of elastic-plastic BoF subjected to impact or pulse loading. 2. Any bilinear BoF under impact or pulse loading can be characterized by a few dimensionless parameters, e.g. ~, p, k, ~,, 11, e0, X, ns/n and na/n. 3. The migration of plastic hinge in the beam and the propagation of plastic region in the foundation, are demonstrated in the dynamic analysis of elastic, perfectly plastic BoF subjected to rigid-mass impact. References
[1 ] X.W. Chen and T.X. Yu, Elastic-plastic beam-on-foundation under quasi-static loading, Int. J. Mech. Sci., in press. [2] T.X. Yu and W.J. Stronge, Int. J. Impact Engng., 9 (1990) 115. [3] E. Manoach and D. Karagiozova, Computers & Structures, 45, 3 (1992) 605-612.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
67
Load deformation of thin tubular b e a m under impact load Nobutaka Ishikawaa, Yukihide Kajita a, Kensuke Takemotoa and Osamu Fukuchi b Department of Civil Engineering, National Defense Academy, Yokosuka, 239-8686, Japan b Nippon Kokan Light Steel Co. Ltd., Tokyo, 103-0012, Japan
a
The aim of this study is to examine the local deformation of thin tubular beam subjected to impact load. First, the weight dropping type impact test was performed for the thin tubular beams. The modified Ellinas formula that expresses the relation between the load and local deformation of steel pipe is validated comparing with the experimental results. Second, the impact test was carried out for the thin tubular beam reinforced by tie bolt. It should be noticed that this newly devised technique is remarkably effective in order to control the local deformation of thin tubular beam under heavy impact load. 1. INTRODUCTION In recent years, many steel pipe check dams as shown in Photograph 1 have been constructed as the protective structure against debris flow in the mountainous area in Japan. These structures can absorb the kinetic energy of huge rocks in the debris flow by the local deformation of steel pipe and the structural deformation. Herein, the authors propose a new type of steel pipe check dam in which thin tubular beams are equipped as the impact energy absorbers against huge rocks in front of main check dam structure as shown in Figure 1. The aim of this study is to examine the local deformation of the thin tubular beam under impact load as a shock absorbing system. Many studies have been so far devoted to the tubular beam under impact loading. For instance, N.Jones et.ah[1,2] have investigated the lateral impact response of fully clamped pipelines from the viewpoints of the theoretical and experimental approaches. C.P.Ellinas et.al.[3] have proposed a formula that expresses the load~local deformation relation of tubular member. T.Hoshikawa et.al.[4] have also proposed a modified Ellinas formula considering the strain rate effect. In this study, the weight dropping type impact test was first performed in order to confirm the validity of the modified EUinas formula for thin tubular beams with different span length. Second, the impact test was carried out for the short thin tubular beam reinforced by the tie bolt in order to reduce the local deformation. Finally, experimental results are compared with the modified Ellinas formula and are examined on the effects of span length and tie bolt. 2. OUTLINE OF EXPERIMENT 2.1 Experimental apparatus Weight dropping type of impact loading apparatus as shown in Figure 2 was used. The impact load is applied by dropping the weight (W--1.78kN) with spherical shape of diameter 22cm under the different dropping heights (velocities). The specimen is simply supported at
68
Figure 2. Weight-dropping type impact apparatus
Figure 3. Local deformation profile
both ends and the concentrated load is applied vertically at the center of it. 2.2 Measurement The impact load is obtained by multiplying the mass of the weight by acceleration measured by the accelerator attached to the weight. The upper displacement at the loading point of the beam means the total displacement ( 6 r ) (the sum of local (6L) and beam (6 s ) deformations), which is found by integrating the value of the acceleration twice. The beam displacement (6 B) was measured by the laser type displacement sensor. It is found from Figure 3 that the following equation holds during the deformation of pipe. 6 r + 6 D ffi6 L + 6 B + 6 0 • D + 6
B
where, 6 0 : the deformed diameter which is m e a s u r e d by slide calipers. the local deformation 6~ can be obtained as follows : 6L = D - 60
(1) Therefore,
(2)
Consequently, the ratio ( a ) of local deformation (6L) and diameter ( D ) is found by measuring the deformed diameter (6 D) as follows"
69 200
1000
.
/
.
.
.
.
.
.
200 A ,..L,.
~,.
.
.
.
.
200
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1400
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A
.
.
.
unit (mm)
. j . 200
~
f
.........................
267 4 .
200A
r
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1800
.
.
.
A
.
.
.
.
.3
i .....
.200
~
fl
..........................
267 4 A
2.3
&
Figure 4. Specimen (SPCC, o3,-170Mpa)
0.
i20 .
.
A
000 .
200 o A
.
1 ..... v .........:
~
Figure 5. Specimen reinforced by tie bolt (M10) a - - t$- -L - 1 - - - t$ o D D
(3)
2.3 Specimen The SPCC (cold-reduced carbon steel sheet, ISO3574-1986) pipe with diameter (D)-thickness (t) ratio (D/t=ll6) was used as about 1/3~ 1/4 scale model of the actual shock absorbing pipe. The three kinds of span length L=I.0, 1.4, 1.8m were selected as shown in Figure 4 in order to examine the effect of span length on the impact local deformation. The newly devised specimen reinforced by tie bolt was also made for the short span (L=l.0m) in order to control the local deformation as shown in Figure 5. 2.4 Dropping weight The dropping weight (W=l.78kN) was chosen as about 1/3.3 scale of the maximum rock weight 20kN in the debris flow by using the Froude scale law. 2.5 Determination of kinetic energy Herein, it is assumed that the external kinetic energy of dropping weight is absorbed by only local deformation of the pipe beam. C.P.Ellinas et.al.[3] have proposed the static load "~local deformation relation of a tubular beam. For the thick tubular beam (D/t<40), T.Hoshikawa et.al.[4] modified it to the dynamic load~local deformation relation by considering the strain-rate effect as follows 9
where, P 9dynamic local load, 6 L local deformation, D 9diameter of pipe, t 9thickness of pipe, o yd (--1.20 y) 9dynamic yield stress considering the strain-rate (~ --10~ effect, "
70 O y 9static yield stress, K 9constant value obtained by the test as follows [4] 9
i
K --- 161
TM
[185
(D o < 3.5D)
20 18! 161
~
(5)
( 0 o > 3.50)
~beam
,o,a, '
~ 10 ~' 8 6
,//
4
where, Do " diameter of impacting body. Therefore, the absorbing energy by the local deformation can be found by integrating Equation (4) as follows:
U =f:"Pd6 L ..1KtTyat2 aL---~SD 1.8
(6)
2 0
10
,
,
,
r
,
,
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
5 (ram) (a) Ho.4=74.5cm (V---382cm/s) 20 18 16 14
.-
--12 ~ 10
where, U" absorbing energy by local deformation of pipe. When the kinetic energy of dropping weight is assumed to be absorbed by the energy due to only local deformation, the former energy is equal to the latter one as follows:
loca~.~.~f.. ,'p
14 '12-
local f
J
" ~
.~" ~t'~otal
6 4 .
0
2/ .
10 20 30
.
.
40 50
.
60 70
-
_
80 90
5 (ram) (b) 1-Io.5=106.5cm (V=457cm/s)
Ea - l m v 2
--U
where, E,,
9kinetic energy corresponding to the local deformation ratio a , m 9dropping
(7)
Figure 6. Load - deformation curve (L--1.4m) Effect of dropping height
weight mass, Va : impact velocity corresponding to a . Therefore, it is found that the external kinetic energy can be expressed as the function of a ~ 6L/D. For instance, E0.3 is defined as the kinetic energy so that the value of a =0.3 may be found by changing the dropping height (velocity) at the constant weight W=l.78kN. Therefore, the relation between kinetic energy and dropping height (velocity) is found by using Equations (6) and (7) as shown in Table 1. Herein, the kinetic energy is determined so that the local deformation ratio a may be occurred in the range of a =0.3~0.6. It is desired, however, from the viewpoint of design purpose that the value of a may be occurred in the range less than 0.5 ( a ~--0.5). Table 1. Relation between kinetic energy and dropping height (velocity) ct E~ (kN" cm) Ha (cm) V~ (cm/sec) 0.3 75.8 42.6 ...... 289 0.4 132.9 74.7 382 0.5 189.9 . . . . . 106.7 ..... 457 0.6 274.7 154.3 549
71
0.8 0.7 'A @ 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 / 0.0 0
I__im ,id9in -for.a
L=l.0m(L/D=3.73) L=l'4m(L/D=5"24) L=l.8m(L/D=6.73)
~
~
modifiedEllinasformula 9 /
0.8 0.7
0.6_
/
/~ usualpipe
0.50.40.3 i i i
I I
Eo3 i Eo.4 I Eo.sl .
1
50
.
.
,
[
,
250
Figure 7. ct"~E,~ relation 9 Effect of span length
I
I
0.1 0.0
Eo.o
100 150 200 Ect (kN-era)
~~----,
300
0
50
I
100 150 200 Ect (kN cm)
250
300
Figure 8. ct "~E,~ relation 9Effect of tie bolt
Photo~aoh 2. Effect of tie bolt (E0.5)
3. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND CONSIDERATIONS 3.1 Load~"deformation curve Figure 6(a) and (b) illustrate the load "- deformation curves at the dropping height H0.4=74.5cm and Ho.5=106.5cm in case of the span length L=l.4m. It is recognized that the beam deformation becomes large as the increase of the dropping height, although the local deformation is not so changed.
3.2 Comparison with the modified Ellinas formula Figure 7 shows the relation of a "~Ec~ comparing with the modified Ellinas formula. It is found that the modified Ellinas formula estimates relatively large local deformations (safe evaluation) in the ranges of small kinetic energy and long span length. It should be noted, however, that the experimental value c~ becomes sometimes larger (critical evaluation) than the modified Ellinas formula in the range of large kinetic energy and short span length. Therefore, the local deformation should be controlled by reinforcing by the tie bolt in case of short span length (L=l.0m).
72 3.3 Effect of span length It should be also noted from Figure 7 that the value of a decreases generally as the span length increases. This tendency may be the reason why the beam deformation is increased and, as such, the local deformation will be reduced as the span length increases. 3.4 Effect of tie bolt Figure 8 illustrates the c~"~E~ relation comparing the pipe reinforced by tie bolt with the usual pipe in case of short span length (L=l.0m). It is found that the local deformation is about 20% reduced by reinforcing by tie bolt. Photograph 2 shows the deformation profile taken from the end side of the beam when the impact load is applied at the center of span in case of kinetic energy E~=0.5. It is noted that the reinforcement due to tie bolt is remarkably effective for the control of the local deformation. 4. CONCLUSIONS The following conclusions are drawn from this study. 1. It was noted that the beam deformation increases as the increase of dropping height, although the local deformation was not so changed in case of long span beam. 2. It was recognized that the modified Ellinas formula can approximately estimate the ratio of local deformation of thin tubular beam in the range of kinetic energy E~ =0.3~-0.4 and the long span length. 3. It is noted, however, that the local deformation of short span exceeds the modified Ellinas formula in case of E~ =0.5. 4. It was found that the local deformation of short span was reduced about 20% by reinforcing with the tie bolt. Therefore, the short span pipe with tie bolt will be effective for the control of local deformation under heavy impact load. The effect of tie bolt will be required to examine from the analytical point of view in the future. REFERENCES 1. N.Jones and W.Q.Shen, A Theoretical Study of the Lateral Impact of Fully Clamped Pipelines, Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs. Vol.206, pp.129-146, (1992). 2. N.Jones, S.E.Birch, R.S.Birch and M.Brown, An Experimental Study on the Lateral Impact of Fully Clamped Mild Steel Pipes, Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs. Vol.206, pp.111-127, (1992). 3. C.P.Ellinas and A.C.Walker, Damage on Tubular Bracing Member, IABSE, Colloquium, Copenhagen, Vol.42, (1983). 4. T.Hoshikawa, N.Ishikawa, H.Hikosaka and S.Abe, Impact Response Displacement of Fixed Steel Pipe Beam Considering Local Deformation and Strain Rate Effect, Proc. JSCE, No.513fl-31, pp.101-115, April, (1995).
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
73
Normal impact of spherical balls on metallic plates b P.U. Deshpande a and N.K. Gupta a
b
Defence Research & Development Organization, Sena Bhavan, New Delhi 110 011, India Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, Hauz Khas, New Delhi 110 016, India
Experiments involving the normal impact of spherical metallic balls of Tungsten Carbide, and Mild Steel on thin metallic plates of Mild Steel, Armour Steel, and Duralumin have been reported. Based on these test results, a semi-empirical model for the prediction of the ballistic limit and residual velocity has been developed. The results obtained from the model have been compared with the experiments and these match well.
1. INTRODUCTION Comprehensive surveys of the Literature on mechanics of projectile impact, available up to the time of their publication, have been published by Backman and Goldsmith [1], Zukas [2], and Corbett et.al. [3] These cover major experimental and analytical studies that deal with the penetration and perforation of plate targets when impacted by projectiles. The first formulae that were developed [1, 4] predict the penetration depths into semiinfinite targets when struck normally by a projectile. The advent of battleship armour in the 19th century led to the development of equations predicting the depth of penetration of finite thickness armour plating [5]. Even to this day these formulae and others like them are being used extensively by impact engineers. One of the major works dealing with the perforation of plates by spherical balls is by Goldsmith and Finnegan [6] who have reported a series of tests in which Aluminium and Mild Steel plates were struck normally by hard steel spheres, travelling between 150 and 2700 rn/s covering sub-ordnance, ordnance, and ultra-ordnance ranges. A commonly used measure of the target's ability to withstand projectile impact is its "ballistic limit" and much work has been carried out by researchers to estimates this parameter. In general terms the ballistic limit of a structure is the greatest projectile velocity the structure can withstand without perforation. Another term "ballistic thickness" was introduced by Gupta and Madhu [7] This is defined as the minimum thickness of plates required for the projectile of known weight and velocity to prevent any perforation. In recent years appreciable advances have been made in the analytical approach to the problem of penetration, with the models gradually becoming more and more sophisticated and accurate. However, these, too have relied heavily, and indeed still do, on experimental data to justify certain assumptions made and to supply various parameters for the models. It shows
74 the continuing importance of experimental data in improving the understanding of perforation process. The present paper is an attempt in this direction for developing a model for prediction of ballistic limit and residual velocity in the case of the normal impact of a spherical ball on a metallic plate. 2. EXPRIMENTS Experiments were conducted in DRDO laboratory wherein Tungsten Carbide (TC) and Mild Steel (MS) spherical balls were fired on Mild Steel, Armour steel (AR), and Duralumin (DU) plates using a standard fragment launching gun. The velocity of the impacting balls were within the ordnance range. Result of about 100 tests are summarised in table 1. All plates were square in shape and were held at their four comers onto a specially designed fixture with the help of C-Clamps. The impact and residual velocities of the balls were measured with the help of foil and counter method. There was no significant deformation of the balls after perforation of the plates. The sequential record of the perforation of 8 mm thick MS plate by 16 mm MS spherical ball weighing 16.5 g at an impact velocity of 651.5 m/s is shown in Fig. 1.
Weight W (g)
Ball Dia d (mm)
TABLE 1 Experimental Data Plate Thick t (mm) .
Striking Vel. Vs (m/s) .
No. N~ of Data
Tungsten Carbid e Ball, Mild Steel Plate ,Tensile Strength s 430 MPa 1.832-1.930 6.0 04.0 700-1050 1.690-1.875 6.0 06.0 700-1000 1.730-1.780 6.0 08.0 900-1200 1.865 6.0 10.0 1150-1150 Mild Steel Ball, Mild Steel Plate, Tensile Strength =430 MPa 1.050 6.0 04.0 800-1100 16.400-16.420 16.0 06.0 500-1000 16.430-16.600 16.0 08.0 650-1100 16.590-16.620 16.0 10.0 650-1100 Mild Steel Ball, Armour Plate, Tensile Strength =430 MPa 16.360 16.0 10.0 806-1018 16.500 16.0 12.0 942-1061 01.028 06.3 04.0 661-721 01.028 06.3 06.0 1127-1167 Mild Steel Ball, Duralumin Plate, Tensile Strength =430 MPa 01.028 06.3 10.0 99-0231 Overall Range 1.028-16.62 6.0-16.0 4.0-12.0 99-1200
4 4 4 1
15 16 9 5 14 91
75
Fig.1
Sequential Perforation of MS Plate by MS Ball at 651.5 m/s (Thickness of Plate = 8 ram; Dia. of baU = 16 mm; Weight of BaU = 16.5 g)
3. A N A L Y S I S Most of the previously derived expressions for the prediction of residual velocity can be written in the form [8]
Vr =or
(Vsp-
q
(1)
76 where, Vs, V r, and V b are the striking, residual and ballistic limit velocities respectively in m/s, p and q are the parameters varying fi-otn one author to another, and
1
ot =
(2)
where, W is the weight of tile ball, Wp is tile weight of the target ino jetted in rront of the ball, and 13 is a parametric constant. A dimensionally ho.nogeneous relation used in Ihe prese.t work fi>r the prediction of ballistic limit velocily is:
I (t Y Vb - +#-p-tCi) where, t is the thickness of the target plale, d is the diamcler of Ihe Imlls, p is the density of ball material, and ft is the tensile strength of the target plate. The values of tile five parametric constants involved in the model 13, Y, p, q, and r have been estimated from the regression analysis of the test data derived from more than 100 experiments. The value of these constants is found Iv be IT = 6.6,1' = 1.6, p = 0.8, q = 1.54, and r - 0.64.
800 '0 "~ 600
.....
....
/
~
A MS/AR x ~
O
>
t3
.~
A
0 0
400 0
4~ o 9~
200
4••x
o
............... T" 0
T--
200
400
O l ~
600
l ~ i d m l Vekxzity
Fig. 2. Predicted Versus Observed Residual Velocity (m/s)
800
77 0
0
,-
............
i
o
. . . . . . . . . . -=~-. . . .
600
~-
[............'.........d=6. t 4
o
d=6, t,=6
~
~4oo
'
I
K
l 0 d'16, t ' 6 i / ," : ....................d..--'16, t=6 I / a : /
500
- - - - - - d--6. l=6 ~9 d='6, t*8 . . . . . . d'~6. t,=8
,..600
8
~
o d--6, I-4 ------- d=6. t'-4
i ~ d2)o,~'sLl
'I/ ""I/
I ...... d~~ 1"8 ~ i [---
d.--16, t-.lO~a : I / "
~3oo
400
/
"o
. .r
200
t00 0
.... ~ . . . . . . . . .
-~...:.,
0
300
_ :: . . . . . .
:::::::::::::::::::::
.
600
~- - = - . : : : = : = = 7
900
0
---~
0
1200
300
60,0
9(K~
1200
Striking Velocity (n~s)
Striking Velocity On/s)
Fig. 4 M S Ball, MS Plate
Fig. 3 T C Ball, hiS Plate
250
t...............; .............d;~i6,~=i6
1
i .......... a~z6, ~,,10 :
u d=16, 1=12, [ .~ .................d--16, t=12 ! a d.~6.3, t=~4
I! . . . . . .
"~" =
---
200
i J
d_-6.3, t ~
r
I .~r
t~ ,,tq
d'~6,.3, 1,,,.6 ] ]'1;t,
o
t50
_9,0
,i
5O
0
I .....
0
300
600
900
Striking Vdo~ty (m/s) Fig. 5 MS Ball, Armour Plate
1200
0
=
........ ~'
......... : ~ :
3O0
--*-
~. . . . . . . . . .
600
i-- ...........................
90O
Striking Velocity (u4x) Fig. 6 MS Ball, DU Plate
12O0
78 4. CONCLUSIONS The paper presents result of experiments in which mild steel, armour steel and duralumin plates were subjected to normal impact by tungsten carbide or mild steel balls. A model has also been developed to predict the residual velocity of the spherical balls impacting metallic plates with a velocity up to 1200 m/s. Results computed from this model match the experiments well. The model is dimensionally homogenous and is applicable to various combinations of impacting balls and target plates considered. REFERENCES
1. Backman, M.E. and Goldsmith, W., The mechanics of Penetration of Projectiles into Targets, Int. J. of Engineering Science, 1978, 16, 1-99. 2. Zukas, J.A., High Velocity Impact Dynamics, John Wiley and Sons, 1990. 3. Corbett, G.G., Reid, S.R. and Johnson, W., Impact Loading of Plates and Shells by Free Flying Projectiles: a Review, Int. J. oflmpact Engineering, 1996, 18, 141-230. 4. Young, C.W., Depth Prediction for Earth Penetrating Projectiles, Proc. ASCE, 1969, 95, SM3,803-817. 5. Johnson, W., Some Conspicuous Aspects of the Century of Rapid Changes in Battleship Armours ca 1845-1945, lnt. J. lmpact Engineering, 1988, 7, 261-284. 6. Goldsmith, W., and Finnegan, S.A., Penetration and Perforation Process in Metal Targets at and Above Ballistic Limits, Int. J. Mech. Sci., 1971, 13,843-866. 7. Gupta, N.K., and Madhu, V., An Experimental Study of Normal and Oblique Impact of Hard-Core Projectile on Single and Layered Plates, Int. d. Impact Engineering, 1997, 19, pp. 395-414. 8. Lambert, J.P., and Jonas, G.H., Ballistic Research Laboratory, BRL-R1852(ADA021389), 1976. 7. Gupta, N.K., and Madhu, V., An Experimental Study of Normal and Oblique Impact of Hard-Core Projectile on Single and Layered Plates, Int. J. Impact Engineering, 1997, 19, pp. 395-414. 8. Lambert, J.P., and Jonas, G.H., Ballistic Research Laboratory, BRL-R1852(ADA021389), 1976.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000)
Editors:X.L.Zhaoand R.H.Grzebieta 9 2000ElsevierScienceLtd.All rightsreserved.
79
Impact performance and safety of steel highway guard fences Yoshito Itoha, Chunlu Liua and Shinya Suzukib "~Center for Integrat~ Research in Science and Engineering, Nagoya University, Fum-cho, Chilcasa-ku, Nagoya 464-8603, Japan bD~almaent of Civil Engineering, Nagoya University, Furo-cho, Chikusa-ku, Nagoya 464-8603, Japan
In the recent years, a lot of obvious changes with the traffic safety and reliability of highways have happened along with the improvement of the road network and vehicle capacities. These changes consist of the increases of the traffic stxxxt, the large-scale vehicles and heavy trucks, the improvement of vehicular performances, and the height of the center of gravity of tracks. Therefore, to take into consideration these changes into the design and construction of new highway guard fences, the design specifications of guard fences were re-examined and the revised specifications were implemented from April 1, 1999 in Japan. However, because of the huge consumption in time and cost to test the performances of full-scale guard fences in the field, some assumptions are adopted while modifying the design specifications. Numerical analyses are still necessary to confirm the impact performance and safety of new types of steel highway guard fences for the design of new highway guard fences. Fuaher, it is also very important to study such issues of the existing guard fences that were design under the old specifications and are taking effect in the field. In this study, FEM models are developed for trucks and guard fences to reenact their behaviors. The validity of these models is demonswated through numerical examples. The solution approach is carried out using nonlinear dynamic analysis software of stmctuw,s in three dimensions and the calculation results ale compared with the full-scale experimental data_
1. INTRODUCTION With the improvement of the road network and vehicle capacities, the vehicles have taken a more imtmrtant role in the freight transport. In Japan, the change of the allowable weight of tracks from 20 tf to 25 tf from November 1994 increases the percentage of heavy trucks and the height of the gravity center of the tracks. Accordingly, from both the function and safety viewpoints, these changes challenge the conventional transportation infrastructures such as roads, bridges, and guard fences. Furthermore, the increases of the traffic speed, the large-scale vehicles and heavy tracks, the improvement of vehicular performances, and the height of the center of gravity of tracks also challenge the design and analysis of highway guard fences. Therefore, to take into consideration these changes into the design and construction of new highway guard fences, the design SlXX:ificationsof guard fences in Japan were re-examined and the revised SlXX:ifications were implemented from April 1, 1999 to replace the former design guideline published in 1972tq. In USA, the nationally recommended procedures for the safety performance evaluation of highway fea..aues comprise of three factors: the structural adequacy, occupant risk, and vehicle trajectoryt2]. However, because of the huge consumption in time and cost to test the performances
80 of full-scale guard fences in the field, some assumptions are adopted while modifying the design specifications. Numerical analyses are necessary to confirm the impact performance and safety of new types of steel highway guard fences for the design of new highway guard fences. Furthermore, it is also very important to study such issues of the existing guard fences that were designed under the old guidelines and are taking effect in the field. Several approaches in this field have been carried out on the impact simulation between vehicles and roadside safety hardware [3' 4], a finite element computer simulation for the vehicle impact with a roadside crash cushion t~, and a procedure for identifying the critical impact points for longitudinal barrierst6]. Because of the huge consumption of time and cost, it is difficult in the field to measure the collision performances of the full-scale guard fences for various cases. In this research, by taking the advantages of both computer software and hardware, the collision impact process between the heavy trucks and the guard fences is simulated based on the presented numerical calculation models for both the heavy tracks and guard fences. A nonlinear, dynamic, three-dimensional finitemlement code LS-DYNA3D is capable for simulating the vehicle impact onto the guard fences['0. The analysis results are further compared with the full-scale experimental results using a real truck in order to demonstrate the approach presented in this research.
2. FEM ANALYSIS MODELS OF GUARD FENCF~ AND TRUCKS 2.1FEM malysis modd of guard fmces This re.seamh focuses on the collision impact of heavy tracks with a high ~ onto the guard fences at the two sides of roads and bridges. The angle between the truck movement direction and the guard fence plane is an important pamnrder to determine the impact force and displacement in addition to the track speed, the track weight, the height of the gravity center of the track, the guard fence, the curb, and others. Figure 1 shows the basic collision analysis components including a moving vehicle, the guard fence, the impact speed and the impact angle in this research. The codes of columns and beams are also given in this figure.
Figure 1. Collision features
Figure 2. Analysis model of guard fence (mm)
In 1992, a structural model was presented for the steel bridge guard fences for the purpose of the full-scale experiment carried out in the Public Work Research Institute of Japan tsl. In the present ~ h , an FEM analytical model based on the shell elements was formulated for the structural components of the steel bridge guard fences and the application procedure was presented in the previous research t91.Figure 2 shows the cross section of a highway bridge guard fence and the FEM model of the guard fences in three-
81 dimensions. The fence column is made of the H-type steel whose web and flange are 150 mm wide and 9 mm thick, and 150 mm wide and 9 mm thick, respectively. Both the main beam and sub-beam are of pipe sections. The pipe diameter and thickness of the main beam are 165 mm and 7 mm, restxx:tively. The pipe diameter and thickness of the steel sub-beam are 140 mm and 4 mm, respectively. The span of the beams over two contiguous columns is 1500 mm. The Young's modulus of steel is 206 GPa, and the Young's modulus of concrete is 24.4 GPa. The Possoin's ratios of steel and concrete are 0.3 and 1/6, mstxx:tively. The shear moduli of steel and concrete are 88 GPa and 10.5 GPa, respectively. The yield stress and initial swain hardening of steel are 235 MPa and 4.12 GPa, restxx:tively. The strain hardening of steel starts from 0.0014. The concrete volume modulus is 12.18 GPa. The concrete compressive and tensile strengths are 23.52 MPa and 2.29 MPa, respectively. The steel is assumed to be an isotropic elasto-plastic material following the von Mises yielding condition. The swain hardening and strain velocity are taken into consideration the stress-strain relationship. The concrete constructed in the curb is assumed as a general elasto-plastic material. This means that the concrete is in the general elasto-plastic condition while the concrete in the compressive side reaches the yield point and only the cut-off stress is available once the tensile stress increases to the tensile strength. The boundary condition at the concrete curb is considered as a fixed end. 2.2 FEM analytical model of trucks In this research, the tracks whose weights are 25 tf are studied by modeling the truck frame, engine, driving room, cargo, tiers and so on. The structure of the 25 tf track is similar to the 20 tf truck except the strengthened flan~ and the loading capacity of the vehicle axles. As shown in Figure 3, the track is modeled according to the ladder-type track frame whose two side members are of channel sections so that some facilities such as the fuel tanks and pipelines can be attached inside the side members. The thickness of the side member is 8 mm, and the yield stress is 295 MPa. The general elasto-plastic stress-strain relationship is adopted. The solid element with the same shape and volume is modeled for the engine and the transmission, and their weights are adjusted according to the practical vehicles. The tiers, wheels, and gears of a truck influence its behaviors during the collision impact significantly. The connection of the tier and the wheel is assumed to be a rotation joint so that the movement of the wheel can be simulated. A constant value of 0.45 is used for the friction coefficient between the tier and the road pavement. The driving room and other small portions are also modeled for the purpose of the numerical calculation.
Figure 3. Truck frame model
Figure 4. Truck structural FEM model
82 Figure 4 represents the presented FEM model of a heavy truck that will be used in the following of this paper. In this model, the numbers of nodes and elements are 3532 and 3904, restxx:tively. The Young's modulus of steel is 206 GPa, while that of aluminum is 70 GPa. The Possoin's ratios of steel and aluminum are 0.30 and 0.34, respectively. The shear moduli of steel and aluminum are 88 and 26 GPa, ~ v e l y . In the case of guard fences, the steel is assumed to be an isotropic elasto-plastic material following the von Mises yielding condition, and the sires-strain relationship is perfectly elasto-plastic. The aluminum used for the cargo body is assumed in a multi-piece linear stress-swain relationshiptl~
3. PARAMETRIC STUDII~ 3.1 Effects of Strain ~ and Slrain Veka:ity Paramelric study is first carried out to check the effects of the strain hardening and strain -velocity on the displacement of the guard fence c o u n t s . It is assumed that the strain hardening starts from 0.0014 and the initial strain hardening modulus is 4.01 GPa (2% of the Young's Modulus). On the other hand, the yield stress usually increases with the increase of the strain velocity. The scaling relation of the yield stress is used in this research to investigate the effects of the strain velocity. Figure 5 shows the displacement of a column with time in four combined cases by considering the strain hardening and strain velocity or not. In this calculation, the track weight, collision speed and collision angle are 14 tf, 80 km/h and 15~ respectively. According to the displ~,.ement tracks as shown in this figure, the effects of the swain hardening and strain velocity on the maximum response displacement and the residual displacement are very obvious. The displacements follow the similar tracks with time if one of the swain hardening and the strain velocity is considered and the other is eliminated. It should also be noticed that at about 0.5 second after the collision impact the displacement increases rapidly within a very short time at all cases. The experimental results,are close to the results obtained by considering both the strain hardening and the strain velocity. Therefore, these two factors will be taken into account in the following part of this paper. f"
'
'
'
"
'
' " '
'
~ is01-l-
~ o u t v e l o c i t y_..,...,..-.-.-IF-~ r I Withouthardening/Withvelocity
no0
'
'
i
i
I
I 0.5
i
i
i
'
....
'
'
.
.
.
.
' ' /
] P10(1-2-8model) -I
~' ~ _
i
Time (sec) Figure 5. Effects of strain hardening and velocity
I I
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
d
. . . . .
~"
N~xpefimentalmaximumdisplacement ,
'"
L ,ooI- ............. ~ ......... b - - - ~ . . -
F- --~f Experimentalresidualdisplacement I 0
"'
[ Experimentalmaximum ~ displacement " .
N~--'-WI~ h~den'in~bVith-v-eI-'ocTty-" ~
.......
O_
;~/'
houtvelocity
i F~ ......':-~ ~:a" s0~ ~
'
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
:1.6mode!) .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
L / \ P10(8-8-32 model, ~ .__~"~/ Experimentalrelsidualdisplacement , _O--
0
0.5
I
Time (sec) Figure 6. Effects of mesh sizes
3.2 Effects of Mesh Sizes Further study is carried out to dexermine the appropriate mesh sizes by following the tracks of the displacement of the bridge guard fence with time. The calculation results are compared with the
83 experimental values by adjusting the mesh sizes of the column web, the column flange, and the horizontal beam pipe. Three cases, 1-2-8 model, 4-4-16 model and 8-8-32 model, are studied. The three numbers of each model represent the classified portions of the column web, column flange and beam pipe, lr.SlXX:tively.The numbers of FEM nodes of these three models are 5739, 10404, and 28125, respectively. Their elements are 5158, 9574, and 27045, re~qx~ively. The calculation results are shown in Fig. 6 as well as the detected values from the actual experiment for the case when the truck weight, collision speed and collision angle are 14 tf, 80 kmha and 15~ respectively. This figure shows the displacement of only one column C 10 whose position can be recognized from Fig. 1. According to the displacement curves in Fig. 6, the residual response displacements in cases of 44-16 model and 8-8-32 model are very large at 0.5 second after the collision impact (about 40%). The tracks in these two cases are almost same within the first 0.5 second. The final displacement is about 10% less than the maximum value in all cases. Compared to the maximum and residual displacements from the ex~riment, the 4-4-16 model contributes very good agreements. Therefore, this model will be adopted in the following analysis.
4. NUMERICAL IMPACT ANALYSF.S OF GUARD F E N C ~ Further study is carried out to demonstrate the presented models by comparing the calculated results with the actual experimental results in the case of collisions between the heavy truck and guard fences. In both the experiment and calculation, the impact speed is 80km/h and the impact angle is 15~ The weight of the track is 14 ft. The impact performances of the guard fence after 0.1 and 0.5 seconds of the vehicle collision are shown in Fig. 7 (a). Figure 7 (b), (c), and (d) represents the calculated results and the experimental results of the displacement responses for the columns at the top, the main beams, and the sub beams, respectively. In Figs 7 (b), (c), and (d), the horizontal and vertical axes represent the time (s) and displacement (mm), respectively. The responses of several fence column tops in the form of displacement are shown in Fig. 7 (b) in terms of different types of iines. The maximum and residual response displacements of the column C10 are 95 mm and 85 mm, respectively. In the practical vehicle experiment, these two values are 97 mm and 84 rnm, respectively. It is obvious that the calculation results are quite near to the experimental results. Figures 7 (c) and (d) show the displacement curves of several main Ix:ams and sub-beams with time, ~vely. The calculation value of the main beam B10 at the central section is 99 mm, about 30% higher than the detected value of 76 mm from the practical experiment. However, the calculated displacement value of 105 mm of the sub-beam $9 at the central section is less than the experimental value of 130 mm. 5. CONCLUSIONS The following conclusions can be stated from this research: (1) It is possible to simulate the collision process and to visualize the movement of the track and the performances of bridge guard fences due to the collision impact of heavy tracks based on the FEM models for trucks and guard fences.
84
200
150
I
'
'
'
i
I
'"'
'
'
'
/'
Experimental residual displacement
Experimental residual displacement
S9 100
9
-
.
.
.
SI0
.
I00 ..........
I
~i
--1-,
0 c)
_ _ . ~ _ - 2. . . . ,
,
J
I
0.5
,
,
I
I
o-
I
~ 0
!
ss
Sl2
~ 0.5
I
d)
Figure7. Displacement responses and comparisons of guard fences
(2) Parametric studies show that both the strain hardening and the strain velocity should be considered, and the mesh sizes also effect the acxaaacy of calculation. (3) The performances of heavy trucks during the collision impact obtained from this research are very consistent with the actual experimental results. This research can be extended in several ways. Energy absorption of each guard fence component needs further emphasize in the revision of the present design ~ifications. The performances of passengers within and after the collision impact need research in detail. It is also invaluable to study the performances of guard fences under a continuous collision. Further rese,a~h is also needed to study the performances of guard fences and concrete curbs simultaneously.
85 REFERENC~ 1. Design spec~cations of guardfences, Japan Road Association, Tokyo, 1999 (in Jalmnese). 2. Recommended Procedures ]br the Safety P e r f o ~ e Evaluation of Highway Features, NCHRP Report 350, Transportation Research Board, Washington, 1993. 3. Wekezer, J., Oskard, M., Logan, R. and Zywicz, E., Vehicle Impact Simulation, Journal of Transportation Engineering, ASCE, 119:4, 1993, 598-617. 4. Reid, J., Sicking, D., Paulsen, G., Design and Analysis of Approach Terminal Sections Using Simulation, Journal of Transportation Engineering, ASCE, 122(5), 1996, 399-405. 5. Miller, P. and Camey, J., Computer Simulations of Roadside Crash Cushion Impacts, Journal of Transportation Engineering, ASCE, 123:5, 1997, 370-376. 6. Reid, J., Sicking, D., and Bligh, R., Critical Impact Point for Longitudinal Barriers, Journal of Transportation Engineering, ASCE, 124:1, 1998, 65-72. 7. Hallquist J., LS-DYNA3D Theoretical Manual, Livermore Software Technology Corporation, LSTC Report 1018, University of California, 1991. 8. A study on the Steel Guard Fences, Research Report No. 74, Public Works Research Institute, Tsukuba 1992 (in Japanese). 9. Itoh Y., Moil, M. and Liu C., Numerical Analysis on High Capacity Steel Camrd Fences subjected to Vehicle Collision Impact, The Fourth International Conference on Steel and Aluminium Structures, Espoo, Finland, 53-60, 1999. 10. Itoh, Y., Ohno, T. and Liu, C., Behavior of Steel Piers subjected to Vehicle Collection Impact, The Fourth International Conference on Steel and Aluminium Structures, Estx~, Finland, 821-828, 1999.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
87
I m p a c t b e h a v i o r of shear failure t y p e R C b e a m s Tomohiro ANDO a, Norimitsu KISHI a, Hiroshi MIKAMI b, and Ken-ichi G. MATSUOKA a aDepartment of Civil Engineering, Muroran Institute of Technology, 27-1 Mizumoto, Muroran, 050-8585 Japan b Technical Research Institute, Mitsui Construction, Co. Ltd., 518-1 Komaki, Nagareyama, 270-0132 Japan
In this study, in order to establish a rational impact resistant design procedure of shear failure type Reinforced Concrete (RC) beams, weight falling impact tests are performed. Twelve simply supported rectangular RC beams without shear rebars are used for these experiments. All the RC beams are of 150 mm width and 250 mm depth in cross section, in which rebar and shear span ratios are taken as variables. Impact load is surcharged onto the midspan of RC beams by freely dropping a 300 kg steel weight. Here, iterative and single loading methods are applied to investigate the effect of loading method on impact behavior of the beams. From these experimental results, it is seen that the impact resistant design for shear failure type RC beams may be rationally performed by using static shear capacity with some safety margin. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
In order to enhance the safety margin of RC structures against impact load such as rock sheds, check dams, and nuclear power plants, many researchers have been studying the impact resistance of RC members (i.e., beam, slab, and column) experimentally and analytically[l, 2, 3]. Consequently, it becomes clear that the impact resistance of bending failure type RC beams may be estimated by using static bending capacity, and the impact resistant design for the beams may be also rationally performed based on the relationships among maximum reaction force, input and absorbed energy, and residual deflection[4]. However, the impact resistance of shear failure type RC members has not been adequately understood yet even regarding beams. From this point of view, the impact behavior of shear failure type RC beams without shear rebars is experimentally discussed in this paper. 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L OVERVIEW
The static design values of twelve RC beams used in this study are listed in
88 Table 1 List of static design values of twelve RC beams Impact Rebar Shear span Static shear Static bending Shear-bending capacity ratio ratio capacity capacity Specimen velocity ratio a(=V,,,c/P,,,c) aid Vu,~ (kN) P,,,c (kN) v (m/s) Pt 0.42 A24'I, S 1-3, 3 2.4 163.1 0.63 A36-I,S 1-3, 3 0.018 3.6 68.8 108.7 0.84 A48-I,S 1-3, 3 (A) 4.8 81.5 0.67 B24-I, S I - 2 , 2 2.4 78.4 1.00 B36-I,S I - 3 , 3 0.008 3.6 52.3 52.2 1.33 B48-I, S 1 - 3, 3 ( B ) 4.8 39. 2
Figure 1. Dimensions of RC beams
Photo 1. Experimental set-up
Table 1. Nominal name of each beam is designated with reference to main rebar type (A or B), shear span ratio a/d (2.4, 3.6 or 4.8, here, a: shear span; d: effective depth), and loading method (I: iterative loading or S" single loading). The static shear and bending capacity V~,c, P~,c are calculated using conventional prediction equations[5]. According to the equations, all the RC beams except B48 beam will be collapsed with shear failure mode under static loading, since those shear-bending capacity ratio as (= V,,,c/P,,,c ) are smaller than 1.0. General view of RC beams used here is shown in Figure 1 which is of rectangular cross section of 150 x 250 mm in size and their clear span length is varied from 1.0 to 2.0 m long. Here, two kinds of deformed rebar are used: A type( 19 m m in diameter); and B type( 13 m m in diameter). At commencement of the experiment, the average concrete compressive strength and yielding stress of rebars are approximately 32 MPa and 390 MPa, respectively. Each RC beam is simply supported and is pinched on its top and bottom surface at a point 200 m m inside from the ends as shown in Photo 1. Impact force is loaded onto the mid-span of beam by means of a freely falling method using a 300 kg steel weight. Here, two types of loading method are applied:
89
zx-
zX
(a) A~4-I
(d) B24-I
(b) As6-X
(~) Bs6-I
/x
/X (r
A48-I
(f) B 4 8 - I
Figure 2. Crack patterns of six RC beams after Rerative loading iterative loading with 1 m / s initial and incremental impact velocity until RC beam is collapsed; and single loading with the same impact velocity to the final one in the iterative loading case. It is assumed that RC beams have been collapsed when a severe diagonal crack was developed from the loading point to supporting point (see Figure 2(a),,~(e)). On the other hand, in case of bending failure type RC beams, it is assumed that RC beams have been collapsed when cumulated residual deflection reached one-fiftieth of span length[4]. Here, only B48 beam has been collapsed with bending failure mode (see Figure 2(f)). In this study, weight impact force, reaction force, and the mid-span deflection (hereafter, deflection) are continuously recorded by using wide-band analog data recorders. The maximum measurable frequencies of the load cells and LVDT are 4 kHz and 915 Hz, respectively. All these analog data are converted into digital ones with 100 ps sampling time. 3. E X P E R I M E N T A L R E S U L T S A N D D I S C U S S I O N S 3.1. Characteristics of response waves
Time histories of impact and reaction force P, R and the deflection ~ for A36 and B48 beams are shown in Figure 3. Here, reaction force is evaluated summing up the values both supporting points. From Figure 3(a), it is seen that the duration and maximum value of impact force are similar to those of reaction force in each impact test. And these two forces are excited with only one half-sine wave having about 10 ms duration in cases of impact velocity V = 1, 2 m/s. The duration is a little longer than the fundamental natural period of the beam which is about 7 ms. In case of V = 3 m/s, the second wave is subsequently generated after the half-sine wave. On the other hand, the deflection wave behaves depending upon the magnitude of impact velocity. In cases of V = 1, 2 m/s, the deflection wave behaves as a damped free vibration. Whereas, in case of V - 3 m/s, it faintly vibrates with some drift after unloading. From Figure 3(b), it is seen that at the beginning of impact in each impact velocity, even though distribution characteristics of impact and reaction force waves are different each other, the duration and maximum values of the forces are almost similar. Namely, the impact force is excited with two hMf-sine
90
9 Iterative loading (kN) impact force, P
150
lm/s
1SO
75 0-
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
-75
7S
,,
0
f%v ~_
__ ~,,
/%
,
-75 1SO TS --
150
2m/s 75
o
I\
-75 150 7s
~
0
3m/s
-Single 5~ling Reaction force, R
(kN)
-75 150 750
q
6 3
(ram) Deflection, 8
0
r,~,
__ . . . .
12
,
, ,
6
'
_A
0
-
'11~r
.
-%
20
,.o 60 ti..(m,)
80 _TSo-
20
L __,,
-3
40
timelm.)
80 -1~'0
60
:..J.
r-
.
.
40
.
.
80
120
160
(~) As~
- - - - - - Iterative loading 150 lm/s
(kN) Impact force, P
1SO 75
75 . . . . .
Single loading (kN) Reaction force, R
1SO
150 T5
......
-75 1SO 75
, ,,
JIt-~.~
-
1501 3m/s 7 5 - -
-%
- _
20
,
4o 6o e..(m.)
o-
~'
]'~
.
.
.
C-
.
.
.
.
.
....
S
~3
12
. ,
o
-75
Oi..
3
'-----. ......
-TS
0
6
.
-75
2m/s 75
(ram) Deflection, 8
-~
,
,
_Ts[L 80 0
I 2o
i -I 4o 60 t~.e(m.)
-6
~ '/"
,,
24 ,
_
80
(b) B4S
Figure
3.
Time histories of impact
force, reaction
force
and deflection
waves: a main wave having comparably long duration; and an incidental wave at the beginning of impact having extremely short duration and two times bigger amplitude than that of the main wave. On the other hand, reaction force is excited with almost only one half-sine wave. The deflection wave behaves as a damped free vibration in spite of the magnitude of impact velocity. The vibration period is gradually prolonged with the impact velocity V being increased, as well as duration of the impact and reaction force. This is due to the progress of damage of R C beam.
Comparing the results obtained from iterative and single loading tests for A36 beam with impact velocity V ffi 3 m/s, it is seen that the m a x i m u m impact and reaction forces in single loading test are slightly bigger than those in iterative loading one. Whereas, the m a x i m u m deflection in single loading test is smaller than that in iterative loading one. However, in case of the B48 beam with bending failure mode, the m a x i m u m values of each force and deflec-
91
15~ I
100f~ 0~-
R-a 6
"12
Deflection,
150~,, 100[
= -O.o" 5 0 ~ "
. . . .
!
, 'v=;./, 1
V= 2m/$ _
o" 50~
"
l
P-a
eL
,
i
' Vf''lm/s-I
'
,
,
18
8' (mm) ,
t
24
18
24
0
6
12
18
i
|
V= 3m/s
Deflection, 8 (mm)
24
(a) A36-I
i '
-
V= 1m/$
--- :P-a , :R-8
i2
Deflection, 8 (mm)
i
t~--~ i'2" 1'8 24 Deflection, 8 (mm)
""
'
....
t~"1
'
"
i
I
1
, _
12
18
Deflection, 8 (mm)
24
g"
6 12 18 24 Deflection, a (mm)
(b) B48-I Figure 4. Hysteresis loops P-6, R-6 for A36/B48 -I beams tion are almost the same irrespective of loading method, respectively. 3.2. Hysteresis loops of P-6 and R-6 Hysteresis loops of impact force - deflection P-~ and reaction force - deflection R-6 for A36/B48 -I beams are shown in Figure 4. From this figure, it can be seen that absorption energy estimated integrating a looped area is increased with increment of the impact velocity, and the distributions of P-6 and R-$ loops are similar to each other except the initial hysteresis in B48 beam. In case of A36 beam, it is seen that both P-6 and R-6 loops can be drawn as a triangular form. Because taking deflection as abscissa, impact and reaction forces are increased monotonically at the beginning and then they are reduced after reaching the maximum value. On the other hand, in case of B48 beam, since 1) maximum reaction force is generated at the impact force being decreased, 2) magnitude of the force is kept almost constant irrespective of the deflection increasing, a n d 3 ) the force is decreased according to decreasing of the deflection, the R-6 loop may be drawn as a parallelogram.
3.3. Distribution of dynamic response ratio Maximum dynamic reaction force - static capacity ratio R~d/P~ (Rffid: maximum reaction force, P,~" static capacity) at failure in each type RC beam is shown in Figure 5. From this figure, it is seen that the ratios for all beams except B48 beam are almost equal to unity irrespective of loading method. However, the ratio for B48 beam is bigger than unity because the beam is failured with bending mode[4]. It suggests that the dynamic capacity of RC beams governed with shear failure mode under static loading is almost equal
92
d
2.0
ii I
9
II
I
e i
1.5 o a , n -B m
t~ ~e
em
E m
a
~
1.0 L
l
0.5 r | 0.0 a:
. 9
- 0
. ~
W
0 : iterative loading O: si~l. lo,~ing I 9 9 ' A24 A36 B24 A48 B36 B48
(0.42) (O.i$) (O.i7) (0.114) {1.OO) (1.$3)
Spedmen Figure S. Distribution of dynamic response ratio
R~d/P~,,
to the static shear capacity. 4. CONCLUSIONS From this experimental study on impact resistant behavior of shear failure type RC beams without shear rebars, following results are obtained: 1) Both impact and reaction force waves behave similarly to each other and are excited with almost a half-sine wave; 2)The mid-span deflection wave of RC beams with no diagonal cracks developed behaves as a damped free vibration. However, after RC beams suffering severe damage due to diagonal cracks developing, it faintly vibrates with some drift; 3) The distributions of impact force - deflection and reaction force - deflection hysteresis loops are similar to each other; 4) The maximum impact and reaction forces at the ultimate state are almost equal to the static shear capacity; and 5) Shear failure type RC beams without shear rebars subjected to an impact load may be designed by using static shear capacity with some safety margin.
REFERENCES 1. N. Kishi, K. G. Matsuoka, H. Mikami and Y. Goto, Proc. of the 2nd Asiapacific conference on shock & impact loads in structures, (1997) 213. 2. M. Kobayashi, M. Sato, N. Kishi and A. Miyoshi, Proc. of the 2nd Asiapacific conference on shock & impact loads in structures, (1997) 221. 3. N. Kishi, M. Sato, H. Mikami and K. G. Matsuoka, Proc. of the 6th East Asia-Pacific Conference on Structural Engrg. & Construction, (1998) 973. 4. T. Ando, N. Kishi, H. Mikami, M.Sato and K. G. Matsuoka, Proc. of the 7th East Asia-Pacific Conference on Structural Engrg. & Construction, (1999)1075. 5. JSCE, Japan Concrete Standard, 1996, in Japanese.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Nonlinear dynamic response design a n d control mechanical systems under impact loading
93
optimization
o f flexible
J. Barradas Cardoso, P.P. Moita and J.A. Castro Instituto Superior T6cnico, Universidade T6cnica de Lisboa Av. Rovisco Pais, 1049-001 Lisboa, Portugal
A design and control sensitivity analysis and multicriteria optimization formulation is derived for flexible mechanical systems. This formulation is implemented into an optimum design code and it is applied to a nonlinear impact absorber and to a flexible vehicle chassis with suspension. Structural dimensions as well as lumped damping and stiffness characteristics plus control driven forces, are the decision variables. The dynamic response and its sensitivity are discretized via space and time finite elements. Nonlinear programming and optimality criteria are used for the optimization process.
1. INTRODUCTION Structures and flexible mechanical systems, by one hand, as well as optimal design and optimal control, by another hand, have been traditionally treated with separated formulations. However, as the theory and methods of nonlinear structural analysis have progressed, there is no more distinction between flexible mechanical systems and structures. Also, in the last decade there has been the integration of optimal design and optimal control problems [ 1-5]. This paper presents an integrated methodology for optimal design and control of nonlinear flexible mechanical systems. In order to implement it, one uses: (i) a nonlinear structural finite element technique to model large displacements, referring all the quantities to an inertial frame and using stress and strain measures that are invariant with the rigid body motion; (ii) a conceptual unification of time variant and time invariant design parameters, by including the design space into the control space and considering the design variables as control variables not depending on time. By using time integrals through all the derivations, then the design and control problems are unified. Both types of variables are designated here as design variables. A bound formulation is applied to handle the multicriteria problem. The systems are modeled by space-time finite elements and the solution of the dynamic equations is obtained either by global integration or step-by-step. The aim of the Design Sensitivity Analysis (DSA) is the calculation of the gradients of performance measures w.r.t, the design variables. It represents an important tool for design improvement and it is a necessary stage within the optimization process. A general overview of the DSA problems and methods of nonlinear structural mechanics is given elsewhere [6]. Both the direct differential method and the adjoint system method are applied in this work, the latter one for global integration system response, the
94 former one for the step-by-step response. The response analysis and corresponding DSA are implemented in the interactive optimal design code OPTIMISE in order to use optimality criteria or nonlinear programming optimization runs.
2. RESPONSE ANALYSIS AND DESIGN SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS The virtual work dynamic equilibrium equation of the system at the time t is given as ~iW = ~ ( f - 6 u - pu . 6 u - S . 6 6 ) d V + ~ T . ~ u dF = 0
(1)
where all the quantities are referred to the undeformed configuration, 8 represents variation of the state fields, '.' refers to the standard tensor product, upper dot '.' refers to the material time derivative, p is the mass density at time t = 0, u is the displacement, S is the 2nd Piola stress measure, c is the Green strain tensor, f is the body force, T is the surface traction, V is the u_nderformed volume of the body, and F is the surface of the body. Considering now a general performance measure defined in the space-time domain as q~ = j'{j"G(S,e,u,u ,u ,b) dV(b)+ j"g (T ,u,u ,u ,b) dF(b)}dt
(2)
the DSA problem is to derive the total variation 8 qJ = 8 qJ + 6 W w.r.t, the design b, 8 and 15 representing respectively the explicit and implicit design variations. In order to formulate adjoint structure or direct differentiation methods, write Eq. (1) as W a= ~ (Ou "u a + S'e a- feu a) dV - ~Tou a dF = 0
(3)
where ca replaces 6s after substitution of 6u by u a, and define an extended 'action' functional A = ~F- JW adt
(4)
The basic idea of the direct differentiation method is to satisfy equilibrium after design variation. Then, auxiliary fields ua are determined by the equation 8 W a=0
or
8W a=-SW a
(5)
and used to determine 6 ~. The basic idea of introducing an adjoint structure is to replace the implicit design variations of the state fields by explicit design variations and auxiliary fields to be determined by imposing the 'action' functional A to vanish [4,5], 8 A=0
(6)
and stating the total design variation of the functional q~ as m
8 qJ = 8 A
(7)
DSA of dynamic response is path-dependent. The selection of the DSA method is based on the number of active constraints and design variables and on the response time integration
95 method. For step-by-step integration, we have selected the direct differential approach due to its easier implementation. For the at-once integration, the adjoint approach has been chosen because the number of constraints is smaller than the number of design variables.
3. DISCRETE MODEL The dynamic analysis and sensitivity analysis responses are discretized by a space-time nonlinear finite element model. Design sensitivities are calculated at the element level and assembled in order to get the DSA model for the entire system. For the space discretization, several structural elements have been implemented together with their corresponding sensitivity models [5], using hermitean and isoparametric interpolation. After space discretization we have the governing matrix equation as M tO + t c t~j + tK tU = tR
(8)
For temporal modelling, we considered finite elements of dimension At, selecting hermitean cubic elements to model displacements, velocities and accelerations, and quadratic lagrangean elements to model the excitations, extending the algorithm given in [7] to the case of nonlinear systems. By one hand the time derivative of Eq. (8) is taken, and by another hand, Eq. (8) is integrated once and twice using average values of stiffness tK and damping tc in At. These four equations combine to give the dynamic time-element equation as D e z e = R e,
z e = ( t , t+Atz)'
tz = (tu, tO, tQ )
(9)
Eq.(9) may be solved step-by-step, or assembled as Dz = R to be solved globally, i.e, at-once. In this case, the 2n time boundary conditions, where n is the number of space degrees of freedom, are imposed by transferring the corresponding coluns of the assembled matrix D to the right-hand side of the equation Dz = R after multiplying the vector U c of those conditions, resulting KU=R-DcU c (10) This is a nonlinear equation where K is a nonsymmetric matrix dependent on the response U. It has to be solved iteratively. Concerning to DSA, application of Eq.(5) to Eq.(10) or of Eq.(6) to Eq.(4), gives respectively, for the direct differentiation and the adjoint system approaches, n
.
.
~
w
m
K 5 U = 5 R - DcSU c -5 F,
6 9 6 9 + (6~/5U)6 U
(11)
i~T U a= (6W/5U) T,
g qJ = 6 W.+ (U a )T (6 R - iic~U c - ~ F)
(12)
---
where F = lDz is the vector of internal forces and K results of derivating D w.r.t, z and again imposing the time boundary conditions. In Eqs.(11) and (12), R and U c are respectively to be considered the driven forces and initial condition control variables.
96 ~,
K=Kox]u[ -1
0.4 0.2 ,--, 0.0
M
--=.
r
~%~~~
"~ -0.2
C=Co• -1
~ -0.4
u
-
-0.6
0.02
o
-0.01
I
5
10
-0.02 -0.03
D e s i g n w r t K 0 a n d 120
t
0.260 0.259
v
-0.04
0
t[s] Figure 3. Absorber optimal control-Case I.
el
c3' I '0*'%--k3
c2
c5' I,k4L'%"- k5
c4
14~176! Beam Element 1
5 t[s]
10
Figure 4. Absorber optimal control-Case II
kl
I e
~
0.266 7 0.265 0.264 -~'o0.263 ~ 0.262 rj 0.261 ~
0.01
,-'h
-
lO.O
Figure 2. Optimal designs for the impact absorber
Figure 1. Nonlinear impact absorber.
o.oo
-
-..,, ----- :
- - = ~DesignwrtKOandCO + Control
-0.8
o
. . . . . .
6 ~ 7
k2
k4
[
eBeam Element 2 e
Figure 5. Model of vehicle chassis with suspension
97 4. N U M E R I C A L E X A M P L E S
4.1. Nonlinear Impact Absorber The system shown in Fig.1 may represent a landing gear for an aircraft impacting the ground at a certain velocity v = 1 at t = 0. The problem is to find the spring and damping coefficients K0 and Co, and the control force [P(t), 0 _< t <12 s], satisfying a displacement constraint lul -< 1, w i t h v - 11 = 2, s u c h that: (I) minimizes the maximum absolute acceleration lal of the mass M = 1, with starting decision variables at K0 = Co = 0.5 and P(t) = 0; (II) minimizes the bicriteria {Co, E = ~(100 U2+ U2+ 100 p2) dtl where E is a performance integral widely used in optimal control [3]. Starting decision variables are K0 - C o = 0.597 and P(t) = 0, and starting objective upper bound value is 20. In Case I, the optimum design was obtained by sequential quadratic programming as K0 = 0.00667, Co - 6.96, and the optimal control P(t) is shown in Fig.3. Starting and optimal acceleration responses are shown in Fig.2 for different levels of the optimization process. The responses were obtained by at-once integration. In Case II, K0 - C o - 1.57 and P as shown in Fig.4, are the optimum decision variables, and the optimum value for the performance E is 61.1, this value coinciding with the optimum objective upper bound. Responses were obtained by step-by-step integration. Optimality criteria were used in this case for the optimization run.
4.2. Flexible vehicle chassis with suspension Figure 5 shows a vehicle which suspension is kinematically excited by the ground. The tires are represented by springs k4 = k5 = 26.275 N/m and by shock absorbers c4 = c5 = 875.8 Ns/m. The chassis body is partially distributed as beam elements with p = 7800 kg/cubic meter, E = 200 GPa and partially as concentrated masses. The relationship 2nd moment of area/area for the chassis cross-section is considered as I/A = 0.01. Other masses are ml = 131.6, m3 = m4 = 43.6 kg. The distance between wheels is 3.048 m and the vehicle moves at 87.78 Km/h. Starting design is {A = 0.1 m 2, kl = 1.75e4, k2 = k3 = 5.26e4 N/m, ca = 1.75e3, c2 = c3 = 4.38e3 Ns/m} and starting control is [P(t) = 0 N, 0 _< t _< ls)], where P is the actuator control force at the passenger seat. It is intended to minimize the maximum absolute acceleration such that the relative vertical displacement between masses is not larger than 0.05m. Two optimization cases were run corresponding to a different ground conditions, both a sinusoidal obstacle of height equal to 0.1016m and: (I) wave length equal to 0.1016m; (II) wave length equal to 24.384m. In Case I, optimal design was obtained as A = 1.9562 m 2 with no changes on the other variables, and optimal control is represented in Fig.6. In Case II, optimal design was obtained as {0.35579, 6.94e4, 6.31e4, 5.02e4, 1.e6, 1.34e4, 1.e2} and optimal control is represented in Fig.7. Starting and optimal accelerations, respectively for Cases I and II, are shown in Figs.8 and 9, for different levels of the optimization process.
5. C O N C L U S I O N S A unified methodology for optimal design and control of flexible mechanical systems has been derived and implemented successfully with three main ingredients: nonlinear structural formulation; inclusion of the design space into the control space; using time integrals throughout all the derivations.
98 5.064N
3.0FA]4 2.0F_.~
0.0E-r
. 1.0F_Xl4
-
-a
--O 0.0E-~ ~ - 1.0F_Xl4
0
r,.) -1.0F_~3
-3.0F__,~
~
0.5
10
,./
-1.5FA)3
-4.0F_~
Figure 7. Vehicle optimal control-Case II.
Figure 6. Vehicle optimal control-Case I.
2.E-05
1.0E-05 ----------
0.E+00
-~"-l.0E-05 E
/
-
o
O
r j -2.(F_X]4
0.0E+00
~
eq ct~
-2.0E-05
-2.E-05 -4.E-05
-3.0E-05 -4.0E-05
-6.E-05 t[s]
t[s] Starting Design Optimal Design wrt Area . . . . . . Optimal Design wrt Area, K's and C's . . . . Optimal Design wrt Area, K's and C's + Control Figure 8. Vehicle optimal acceleration-Case I Figure 9. Vehicle optimal acceleration-Case II REFERENCES
1. M. Salama, J. Garba, L. Demsetz and F. Udwadia, Simultaneous Optimization of Controlled Structures, Computational Mechanics, 3 (1988) 275. 2. C.H. Tseng and J.S. Arora, Optimum Design of Systems for Dynamics and Controls using Sequential Quadratic Programming, AIAA Journal, 27 (1989) 1793. 3. J. Arora and T. Lin, A Study of Augmented Lagrangean Methods for Simultaneous Optimization of Controls and Structures, 4th AIAA/Air Force/NASA/OAI Symposium, U.S.A. (1992). 4. J.B. Cardoso and J.S. Arora, Design Sensitivity Analysis of Nonlinear Dynamic Response of Structural and Mechanical Systems, Structural Optimization, 4 (1992) 37. 5. J.B. Cardoso, L. Sousa, J.A. Castro and A. Valido, Optimal Design of Nonlinear Structures and Mechanical Systems, Engineering Optimization, 29 (1997) 277. 6. M. Kleiber, H. Antunez, T.D. Hien and P. Kowalczyk, Parameter Sensitivity in Nonlinear Mechanics, John Wiley & Sons, 1997. 7. M.Gellert, A New Algorithm for Integration of Dynamic Systems, Comp.&Struct., 9 (1978) 401.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000)
Editors:X.L.Zhaoand R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000ElsevierScienceLtd.All rightsreserved.
99
Influence o f impact loads on the behavior at alternative bending over pulleys o f steel wires Crespo, Germfin Universidad Sim6n Bolivar, Departamento de Mecfinica, Caracas, VENEZUELA. Fax: 58-29064062 / 9621697. Email: gcrespo@,usb.ve.
Stranded steel wires used for cable manufacturing which must be operated on pulleys, are subject to a complex state of stress where the following factors take part: axial tension, torsion, bending, crushing, and the dynamic friction or gall. Recent investigations have a tendency toward cable constructions that increase their fatigue-proofed useful life while continuously passing upon the pulleys. This paper determines the influence of the impact loads in tension over the wires in order to quantify its effect over the other stresses. Equivalent loads of up to the 25% of the breaking load of 3.15ram diameter wires were applied by free fall weights, while maintaining the wire in bending position, with relations of 30, 45 and 60, of pulley diameters to the diameter of the wire. A relation was obtained that predicts the reduction of the fatigue-proofed useful life, in comparison to the no impact situation, for various values of dynamic load. Likewise, it was observed that the predominant breakage continues to be due to fatigue, even when fractures were obtained due to the effect of the cyclic impact at less than 3000 load cycles.
1. INTRODUCTION Cables manufactured with steel wire which must bend over pulleys or chains, are subject to a state of complex stress produced by various bending effects, gall and plastic deformation in determined places, which provoke the finite life of those cables even when the tension loading they endure is not higher than the 25% of the breakage load. Some studies have theoretically quantL~ied the effect of bending (Bahke 1980a), (Freyre 1981) or experimentally the combined effect of the stresses which do not result from the constant axial tension (Oplati~ 1990), (Crespo 1995). Further to the above, in some cases the cable must stand sudden forces applications due to abrupt changes of speed or failure of the brake systems. In this study, an analysis is made of the effect of the impact loads applied over the individual wires which form the steel cables, with the purpose of trying to quantify the stress produced by this situation.
100 2. EXPERIMENTAL DEVELOPMENT Round wires of 3.15 mm diameter, used for cable manufacturing for cable cars (full locked coil rope), were tested applying in a cyclic manner loads equivalent to the 25% of the breaking load of the wire, while it is bent over a pulley, with a relation of pulley diameter to wire diameter (D/d), of 30, 45 and 60. The wires are ofpearlitic steel, with 0,79% of Carbon, 0.76% of Manganese, 0.22% of Silicium, 0.003% of Phosphorous and 0.007% of Sulphur, stranded starting from a rod of 6.35 mm of diameter until attaining a condition where the maximum resistance to the tension was 1960 MPa. For conducting the tests, equipment was used as shown in Figure 1.
Force
I
Rigid stop
IlL
Piston
Fall
Pulley
Weight Figure 1. Diagram of the testing equipment used for applying the cyclic impact loads. The pneumatic piston of Figure 1 raises the weight equivalent at 25% of the breaking load of the wire being tested, until it runs a length of 70 ram, which is equivalent, approximately, to 22.5 times the wire diameter. The air pressure is cut and the weight is set free to fall until the wire-splicing clamp makes contact with the rigid stop. Under these conditions, the fallingspeed of the weight at the moment of making contact with the stop is approximately 5 m/s, speed which is used in the major part of the load elevation systems, elevators and cable cars. The operation is repeated until attaining the wire breakage. (Test "A'3 To differentiate and quantify the effect of the pure simple bending over the wire part that is bent and straightened in a cyclic manner, the same equipment shown in Figure 1 was used, however maintaining the tension without impact constant, and lifting and lowering the "weight at a frequency of 0.25 Hz until producing the wire breakage. (Test "B') For quantifying the effect of the impact load, similar wires were tested at tension fatigue using a universal testing machine, and applying different values of maximum load for each test at a 1 Hz frequency, maintaining the minimum tension at 25% of the breaking load, until obtaining the wire breakage in approximately the same number of load cycles than when using the impact test. (Test "C")
101 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Following the order of the experimental development the results are as follows: For the Test "A" (impact condition): Conditiony. a weight of only the 25% of the breaking load and an average of 5 tests per condition with variation of +l 5% among extreme values. Results: Total failure of wires produced around load cycles of 1200, 1800 and 5300, for the relations D/d of 30, 45 and 60, respectively. For the Test "B" (pure simple bending): Conditions'. an average of 5 tests per condition with variation o f + l 1% among extreme values. Results: Wire breakage produced around load cycles of 135000, 224000 and 722000, for the relations D/d of 30, 45 and 60, respectively. For the Test "C" (tension fatigue): the Figure 2 indicates the life to fatigue of wires tested in tension-tension with a minimum load at 25% of the breaking load, as function of the maximum applied stress expressed in percentage of the static breaking load of the wire. 1000000
~
i
l
100000 ~
o..
~"
10000 D/d=60
100o "O m
100 20
30
40
50
60
70
Maximum load as percentage of the breaking load
Figure 2. Cycles of life to breakage in the tension-tension test of the wire, maintaining constant the minimum load at 25% of the breaking load, as function of the maximum load applied.
In the Figure 2, the arrow indicates the equivalent condition for the Test "A" (impact condition, 5300 load cycles), with a relation D/d equal to 60. As it can be appreciated, the effect of bending plus the impact is equivalent to increasing the load over the wire with a 27% of the breaking load. The equivalence showed in the Figure 2 for the Test "B"(pure simple bending, 722000 load cycles), means an increase of 5% of the breaking load (with the same relation D/d of 60). So, only the impact effect must be between an 80 and a 90% of the increase mentioned for the Test "A" (27%). On the other hand, if the number of life cycles is plotted as function of the D/d relation, it can be observed that an increase of this relation seems not to improve much, the working condition of the wire. (See Figure 3). If we take into account that the D/d relation in the full locked coil rope systems for cable cars is larger than 90, we could arrive to the conclusion that tests made at the laboratory would seem to reproduce with certain similarity the actual situations in the use of steel cables, although, the contact effects between wires is not being
102 considered in the present study. No influence of the pulley gorge radius was found, neither effects of superficial friction, which could alter the obtained results. Likewise, wire rotation was not detected during the tests. Although the fracture was produced at a relative low number of cycles under the condition of impact plus bending, the fractography revealed a predominant morphology of fatigue more than static load, with cracking growth in radial sense, followed by a change in the sense of the wiredrawing. Numerous secondary cracks were appreciated. The fact that the influence of simple bending results with only 20% of the cyclic total load applied (or equivalent to a 5% of the breaking load as additional amount to the basic load), seems to prove that the effect of the cyclic bending stress over wire cables is not the principal magnitude provoking the failure of wires due to fatigue, but the principal effect is the gall or local dynamic compression with relative movement (also called dynamic friction).
6~ 4~ f 50 i
~n L 30
20
[-
-
0
2000
4000
60O0
Cycles o f ~ to bmaka~ Figure 3. Influence of the D/d relation over the cycles of life to breakage for the condition of impact plus bending.
4. CONCLUSIONS The results of this study show that the effect of the cyclic impact on wires that are bent over pulleys represents an increase of a 108% of the stress applied by the basic tension, of which between an 80 and a 90% correspond to the impact itself and around a 20% to the simple cyclic bending of the wire over the pulley. Increasing the relation between the diameter of the pulley and that of the wire (D/d), would not seem to help much over the behavior to fatigue for values larger than 60.
REFERENCES 1. Bahke, E., (1980), "Bases para la resistencia de cadenas y cables de alambre', Partes I, II, Alambre, 30, 3, pp 142-150 y 30, 4, pp. 181-190. 2. Feyrer, K., (1981), "Evahmci6n estadistica de los resultados obtenidos en ensayos a flexi6n de cables de alambre'; Partes I, II, Almnbre, 31, 3, pp. 112-116 y 31, 4, pp. 167172. 3. Oplatka, G., (1990), "Relation between the number and distribution of wire breaks and residual breaking force", Wire, 40, 2, pp. 206-209. 4. Crespo, G., (1995), "Modelaje y redisefto de cables tipo cetrado (full locked coil rope) para sistemas telef&icos con contrapeso'" Anales del COBEM-CIDIM/95, CDROM.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
103
Dynamical Actions on Highway Bridge Decks Due to an Irregular Pavement Surface J.G.S. da Silva Mechanical Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, UERJ E-mail:
[email protected] An analysis methodology is proposed to evaluate the dynamical effects, displacements and stresses, on highway bridge decks, due to vehicles crossing on the rough pavement surfaces defined by a probabilistic model. To this purpose, the methodology is developed to evaluate the vehicle-structure response under a full probabilistic formulation, running in the frequency domain. The mathematical model assumes a finite element representation of the beam like deck and the vehicle simulation uses concentrated parameters of mass, stiffness and damping. The deck surface roughness is defined by a well-known power spectral density of road pavement profiles. The moving load is formed by an infinite succession of equally spaced vehicles moving with constant velocity. Only steady-state response is considered. Response data are produced on concrete box girder elements assembled as a simply supported beam with overhangs. Results of a study are presented to verify the extension of the dynamical effects on highway bridge decks, due to vehicles crossing on the rough pavement surface defined by a probabilistic model.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Since the middle 80's the scientific community in recognition of the major importarice of this subject has started a continuous effort on the study of the dynamic effects on bridge superstructures due to vehicular traffic on irregular pavement surfaces. The problem remains a major one for regions where the road maintenance is not effective leading to a premature deterioration of the bridge superstructures and their bearings [1,2,3,4]. Several studies have been published since then and it was made evident that the effects due to the interaction of the vehicles with an irregular pavement surface can be much more important than those produced only by the smooth movement of the vehicles. [4,5,6,7,8,9,10]. In design practice, most of the technical recommendations use a dynamical load factor applied to the vehicle static effects to take into account all the dynamical actions. In addition to these points, field reports say that some bridges have been submitted to excitation levels, under usual traffic conditions, which have deteriorated their service conditions and structure durability, this can be an indication of under conservative design criteria. So, it is desirable to have the problem parameters quantitatively evaluated to better estimate their participation in the structure disruption. To this purpose, the analysis methodology considers a vehicle-bridge mathematical model which includes the interaction between their respective dynamical properties and is developed
104 to evaluate the vehicle-structure response under a full probabilistic formulation, running in the frequency domain [4,6,10]. The deck surface roughness is defined by a well-known power spectral density of road pavement profiles [ 11]. The moving load is formed by an infinite train of similar vehicles regularly spaced and running at constant velocity, in such way to obtain steady-state mean maximum response quantities of the vehicle-deck system, which are necessary to a fatigue analysis of the deck material [4,12]. The analysis methodology use a frequency domain transfer on the pavement spectral densities, to obtain directly the bridge response spectral densities, followed by an integration of these functions over a suitable frequency band to get the mean square values of the vehiclebridge response quantities [4,6,10]. Response data are produced on reinforced concrete beam decks, continuous on several supports, with overhangs and with constant box cross section. A parametric study is developed to verify the extension of the dynamical effects, displacement and stresses, on highway bridge decks, due to vehicles crossing on the rough pavement surface defined by a probabilistic model. The conclusions include qualitative and quantitative aspects of the problem and the attitudes concerned with bridge design and maintenance.
2. P A R A M E T R I C
STUDY
2.1. Structure and Moving Load Model The work is carried out on a computer code, developed in previous studies [4,6,10], which follows an analysis methodology to evaluate the vehicle-structure response under a full probabilistic formulation, running in the frequency domain. The structure model includes the vehicle-deck dynamical properties interaction and the moving load is modelled as an infinite series of equal vehicles regularly spaced and moving at constant speed, in such way to determine the maximum displacements and stresses in the steady-state response of the bridge deck [ 12]. 2.2. Vehicle Properties and Data The individual vehicle of the series weighs 450kN and is modelled as a two degrees of freedom system. The vehicles keep a regular spacing, 1, and run at a constant velocity, u; from test to test The single vehicle natural frequencies, in rigid base vertical motion, corresponding to the vehicle suspended mass and non suspended mass degrees of freedom, are made equal to 3Hz and 20Hz, respectively The relative damping coefficient of the vehicle vibration mode with predominant movement of the vehicle suspended mass is assumed to be ~=0.1 [4] 2.3. Surface Irregularities The definition of the irregular pavement surface follows a non-determimstic model based on the pavement roughness power spectral density The pavement quality control parameter is chosen using grades from excellent to very poor surface according to [ 11 ]. 2.4. Structural System To verify the influence of redundant spans and of overhangs on the amplification factors due the excitation produced by the interaction of the vehicle wheels with the irregular
105 pavement surface, the infinite train of vehicles is applied to continuous beam decks modelled as shown on Figure 1. The basic span, L, is varied from L=24.0m to L=36.0m. A finite element model associated with a reinforced concrete highway bridge, is chosen to consist of a straight box-girder beam, continuous over several supports, with overhangs and constant cross section. Figure 1 presents the finite element model of the beam with the following properties: I=3.98m 4, E=3xl071d',l/m 2, distributed mass ~ =9200kg/m and damping factor, ~=0.03, for the lowest mode frequency with predominant deck displacements. mAl Am2A ..,_
A 'qp'w'
~qpqlF
1 2 3-7-/~
4 I ~ = 0.2.~_
r
9-- 11134 11135 A v
A
A Ip'~
A
A A A ~ ~ - ~
9
.Le •O.83L
T
Jh, O ~ ~lh ~ ~ ~ A ~ J~ ~ A ill A d& ~ A ~ qJ, q p q l F ~ q p q l c V q p q p / ~ , , q p q P q p q P q P ~ q P q P q l F
~,
20
14 _l_
A
Jl&
A A "'.,IP'~v
31 26
L
A
....
T
A
39 36
_!_
Le = 0.83L
t-
._~b =0 ~ S L
T
-L
Figure 1. Model of continuous beam deck with overhangs. Table 1 shows the variation of beam fundamental frequency with the changing of the span and overhang length and with the variation of the beam finite element length. This last parameter is important since the vehicle spacing is chosen to be twice its value. If it were to be shorter then more vehicles can be arranged on the deck Table 1 Continuous beam natural frequency varied with bridge geometry. Middle Span
End Span
Overhangs
Section Spacing
Unloaded Deck
Loaded Deck
L(m)
Le(m)
Lb(m)
Ls(m)
Lowest Mode Frequency Hz)
Lowest Mode Frequency Hz)
24.00 30.00 36.00
20.00 25.00 30.00
6.00 7.50 9.00
2.00 2.50 3.00
9.12 7.43 5.20
9.22 7.78 5.86
2.5. Analysis Procedure The equations of motion follow a standard procedure in which the effect of the pavement roughness is introduced considering that, for the vehicle, it acts as a base motion. The power spectral density of the vehicle-pavement interaction force is transferred through the frequency domain to obtain the vehicle-deck system response function [4,6,10]. A proportional damping matrix is adopted that includes a submatrix related to the vehicle degrees of freedom and another to the bridge nodal velocities. The effect of the rough pavement is introduced in the motion equations as a load vector analogous to which would be considered if the vehicle were subjected to a base movement equal to the irregular pavement profile [4,6,10]. By making use of the Wiener-Kintchine theorem, the second order moments of the response displacements of the vehicle-bridge system can be obtained. To keep these response quantities in the same magnitude of those obtained by a time domain approach with the same structural model [4,5,8,9], this last integration has to be taken only over a narrow band of the spectrum.
106 The criteria to establish this band width and its locations are also proposed [4,6,10]. From this point on, the second order moments of the other response quantities are reached by similar and suitable procedures [4,6,10]. The mean maximum displacement and stress values of the response of the vehicle-bridge system are evaluated based on the standard deviation obtained by a statistical analysis. The results compare very well adjusted to those of the previous study mentioned above [4,5,8,9]. The following parameters are then varied: the bridge main span, keeping the same relative overhang length; the traversing velocity and the road surface quality grade, With the study of situation of simply supported decks is now complete the case of straight continuous decks over a varying number of supports, with and without overhangs was then considered [4,5,6,8,9,10]. 2.6. Presentation of Results The response of the vehicle-bridge system has been obtained considering excitation produced by the interaction of the vehicle wheels with the irregular pavement surface. Deck displacements and stresses have been computed. Tables 2 to 4 illustrate the variation of the mean maximum values of displacements for three typical sections of the continuous beam model, presented in Figure 1. These tables present the results in terms of the medium amplification factor, FA, mean maximum displacements, By, and second order moments of the response displacements, E[v2]. These response displacements of the vehicle-bridge system are determined at the vehicle critical velocity which is equal to l.fol, where I is taken as twice the beam element length and f01 is the single vehicle natural frequency, in rigid base vertical motion, corresponding to the vehicle suspended mass degree of freedom. The medium amplification factor, FA, represents the ratio between ~t+. and the statical effects, vest. For a better understanding vest is defined as the maximum displacement at the corresponding model section due to static action of the weight of the vehicle train, as it crosses the bridge.
Table 2 Mean maximum displacements. Pavement quality: very good. Section S 1. Middle Span F--A= l'tv ~tv L(m) Vest (cm) 24.0 1.15 0.16 30.0 1.22 0.33 36.0 1.10 0.51 Table 3 Mean maximum .displacements. Pavement quality: very Middle Span F---A= lay Vest .... L(m) ..... 24.0 0.85 30.0 0.90 36.0 0.86
E[v~] (cm2)B 0.028 0.120 0.270
good. Section $9. tXv (era) 0.11 0.23 0.37
E[v:] (cm2)[] 0.013 0.054 0.140
107 Table 4 Mean maximum, displacemems. Paveme m qua!ityl m e d i ~ . Section $20. Middle Span F---A=~tv Vtv L(m) 24.0 30.0 36.0
Vest 3.20 3.40 3.28
(cm) 0.52 1.00 1.76
Z[v~] (cm~)~ 0.272 1.024 3.328
2.7. Discussion of Results The main objective of this work is the evaluation of the magnitude of the dynamical effects, due to excitation produced by the interaction of vehicle wheels with an irregular pavement surface, relatively to the static values. These FA values are higher than those obtained for the simply supported decks and have to be considered with some caution because they may not precisely represent the value of the ratio of the dynamic value to the design static value computed as recommended by many codes, if loading of alternate spans is allowed. The roughness of an excellent pavement surface produces response quantities, displacements and stresses, to the bridge deck, that can reach magnitudes to the same order as those due to the static effect of a train of vehicles long enough to load all the bridge (see Tables 2 to 3). The displacements and stresses increase drastically with the decrease of the pavement surface quality. For medium quality pavement surface some of these effects can be from 2 to 4 times higher (see Table 4). These magnitudes are several times greater than that due to load mobility alone [ 12,13]. The large number of cases studied suggest a similar condition applies to all the response quantities, either displacements or stresses.
3. C O N C L U S I O N S In all cases studied, it was verified that for typical vehicle velocities, the dynamical effects on highway bridge decks due exclusively to the interaction of the vehicle suspension flexibility with a smooth pavement surface represent a significant component of the vehiclebridge system response. They can be as high as 90% of the static effects of the moving load. The effects due to the interaction of the vehicles with an irregular pavement surface are much more important than those by considered the load mobility [ 12,13]. In some cases these effects are larger than those due to the presence of the vehicles statically. These dynamical effects increase drastically with the decrease of the pavement surface quality. The problem is still more serious if one considers lower quality pavement surfaces, irregularity amplitude larger than 1.40cm; for medium quality pavement surface some of these effects can be from 2 to 4 times higher and for the worst case, (very poor quality surfaces), the problem becomes very serious [4]. As a consequence, two main pieces of advice are offered to structural and maintenance engineers: i) considering a linear elastic analysis, special attention needs be given to the load factor magnitudes which multiply the static action of the moving loads to account for their dynamical effects; ii) the maintenance effort needs be sufficient to insure a low roughness pavement surface - irregularity amplitudes not higher than 1.40cm.
108 4. A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T S The author acknowledges gratefully the financial support for this work provided by FAPERJ, Funda~;~o de Auxilio/t Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, and CNPq, Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa.
REFERENCES 1. F.N.M. Ramalho, "A~6es Dinfimicas em Pontes Rodovifirias com Defeitos na Pista", X CILAMCE, Iberian Latin-American Conference on Computational Methods in Engineering, (1989). 2. G. Sedlacek and St. Drosner, "Dynamik bei B~cken", Baustatik Baupraxis, Universit~t Hannover, (1990.) 3. T.L. Wang, D. Huang and M. Shahawi, "Dynamic Response of Multigirder Bridges", ASCE, J. Struc. Engr., vol. 118, pp. 2222-2238, (1992). 4. J. G. S. Silva, "An~lise Dinfimica N~o-Deterministica de Tabuleiros de Pontes Rodovi/Lrias com Irregularidades Superficiais", D.Sc. Thesis, Departamento de Engenharia Civil, PUC-Rio, (1996). 5. J. G. S. Silva and J. L. Roehl, "Dynamical Analysis of Bridge Decks with Irregular Pavement Surface Defined by a Profile Spectral Density", XVII CILAMCE, Iberian Latin-American Conference on Computational Methods in Engineering, (1996). 6. J . G . S . Silva and J. L. Roehl, "Probabilistic Formulation for the Analysis of Bridge Decks with Irregular Pavement Surface", VII DINAME, International Conference on Dynamic Problems in Mechanics, (1997). 7. Cal~ada, R.; Cunha, A., "Stochastic Modeling of the Dynamic Behavior of Bridges under Traffic Loads", IV WCCM, Fourth World Congress on Computational Mechanics, (1998). 8. J.G.S. Silva and J. L. Roehl, "A~;0es D i ~ i c a s em Tabuleiros de Pontes Rodovi~irias Provenientes das Irregularidades do Pavimento", 1II SIMMEC, 30 Simp6sio Mineiro de Mecfinica Computacional, In portuguese, (1998). 9. J. G. S. Silva, "Dynamical Load Factor for Highway Bridge Decks with Pavement Irregularities", IABSE Symposium, Structures for the Future - The Search for Quality, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, (1999) 10. J. G. S. Silva and J. L. Roehl, "Analysis of Highway Bridge Decks with Irregular Pavement Surface Using a Full Probabilistic Formulation", ECCM-99, European Conference on Computational Mechanics, Munich, Germany, (1999). 11. Braun, H., "Untersuchungen Von Fahrbahnunebenheiten und Anwendungen der Ergebnisse", Von tier Fak~ltat for Maschinenbau und Elektrotechnik der Technischen Universit~t Carolo-Wilhelmina zu Braunschweig, Dissertation, (1969). 12. J. G. S. Silva and J. L. Roehl, "Dynamical Actions on Bridge Decks due to a Train of Vehicles", IV WCCM, Fourth World Congress on Computational Mechanics, (1998). 13. R. Carneiro and J. L. Roehl, "A Model for the Analysis of Moving Load Effects on Highway Bridge Girders", RBCM, Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences, vol. 12-1, 29-44, (1990).
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
109
Eiastic-viscoplastic-microdamage modeling to simulate hypervelocity projectile-target impact and damage J. Eftis, C. Carrasco and R. Osegueda FAST Center for Structural Integrity of Aerospace Systems University of Texas at El Paso, TX, 79968-0516, USA Abstract - Constitutive-microdamage equations are developed that are capable of describing the full range of thermomechanical material behavior, microdamage evolution and fracture associated with hypervelocity projectile-target impact. 1. INTRODUCTION Because of the current limits of laboratory gas gun technology in propelling other than pellet sized projectiles at hypervelocities (e.g. 6.35 mm spherical projectile at 4.9 km/s), laboratory hypervelocity impact experiments with projectiles that are four or five times as large cannot now be performed. To investigate hypervelocity impact events that are related to space sciences, such as ballistic missile interception, or the protection of orbiting space vehicles from orbiting space debris, it is necessary to rely almost entirely upon numerical simulations. This requirement places heavy responsibility upon the material constitutive model used in the computer codes. Constitutive models used for this purpose must have the capability of describing accurately the full range of thermomechanical deformation and fracture of projectile and target following hypervelocity impact. A set of material constitutive-microdamage equations that have this capability are presented below in abbreviated manner in deference to space limitations. 2. RATE OF ELASTIC DEFORMATION The rate of deformation tensor D is expressed as the additive sum of the elastic rate D e and the viscoplastic rate D p. Since there are large volume strains associated with high shock compression, D' can be decomposed into deviatoric and spherical components and expressed as the sum of the rates of small scale shear strain and large scale volume strain. The elastic shear strains are constrained to small order because of the limitations imposed by onset of plastic yield. Thus the deviatoric component is linear with respect to stress, as in small strain elasticity, while the spherical component is not. Accordingly
De = i T , + ~ -1s v 1
(1)
2/.t
T is the Cauchy stress tensor, a~, = (~3)trT is the mean stress, (..V.)represents the Jaumann rate applied to T and ~m, P and K are the isotropic shear and bulk moduli. All polycrystalline materials contain microvoids or microcracks. Since hypervelocity impact can produce large temperature increases, the corresponding dynamic fracture processes will be ductile, caused essentially by nucleation, growth and joining together of microvoids. Therefore the measure of ductile material microdamage can be described by the microvoid volume fraction
110 = '"/,., where Vv is the void volume for a material element having volume v. The microdamage is treated as a scalar valued continuous point function of position and time ~: = ~ (x, t). The volume strain ~ = (1 - ffvo)= (1 - ~/~p), where v0 , Po and v, p are the reference and current values of the volume and density. The equation relating the mean stress to volume strain and temperature (' equation of state') may be shown to have the Gruniesen form [ 1]. Thus during shock compression and release
r,
L.
+[yo
During dilatation the initial shock wave speed reduces to a tensile wave traveling at the bulk sound speed c o . This is equivalent to setting s = 0 in (2). Therefore the dilatational mean stress is given by
or.= K W~- 89 { Yo(~_-~)+ao(~._~_;}]+ )2 [to + ao(~_-~)]E(W,T), W<0
(3)
In these expressions E is the internal energy per unit volume, T is the absolute temperature, c ois the bulk sound speed, 2'o is the Gnmiesen constant, a 0 and s are material constants the latter of which is obtained from shock compression data. Large volume strains (or high pressures), large temperature variations and material microdamage alter the values of the elastic moduli which, accordingly, for high compression can be expressed as K = K ~[ (1- W'(~1] s+;(s~-"y~
"=
('i :s~)'"
[1 -a s (T~o- 1)] ~[ )4P~ L 4+/ ~3Ko'J] o
1- k.T,. - TOJ
(1-d~)(l- 6K~ + 8,Uo 2/'t~ ~
(4) (5)
where Ko, ixo are the moduli values at the reference state ~ = 0, T = TO and ~,= go = 10-3 _ lO-' -_--0 for the ideal solid without microdefects (i.e., the values determined by routine laboratory tests). T.n is the melt temperature. The first bracketed term expresses shock compression hardening of the elastic moduli, and represents the variation of the mean stress with respect to volume strain (or density). The second reflects the softening of the moduli at elevated temperatures [2], while the third softens the moduli with microdamage [3]. For zero volume strain and dilatation, ~ < 0, K and ~ are given by eqs. [4] and [5] with the parameter s = 0. The increase of the melt temperature with large volume reduction is expressed by of. [4]. Tm = Tm0eXp(2a, i//)(ij.u
I//> 0
Tin0 is the melt temperature at zero volume strain and a~ is a material parameter.
(6)
lll
3. RATE OF VISCOPLASTIC DEFORMATION The spherical and deviatoric decomposition of the rate of viscoplastic deformation Do = V~(trDP)l+ D'p allows for easy expression of the fact that plastic volume change stems only from the compressibility of the microvoids. Designating eo =-In ('-r162 as the logarithmic void volume strain, it follows that
l(trDP) I
I( W,, Ii
~
I,
where the dot signifies time rate. The deviatoric rate of viscoplastic deformation has the general form proposed by Perzyna [5], and may be given explicit expression as
D'=
J'2
[Ty ~ (D.)+ h (~.)l~ f~ (T)f, ~r
-1
Im
T'
(8)
1 S ~ T' is the deviatoric stress, J2t = ~ tr(T'. T') is its second invariant. Ty = )/4~ Ty,, where TyS~ is the uniaxial yield stress at the reference temperature and quasi-static strain rate. The dimensionless strain-rate hardening function
(.o(D'):I+ r In [D' [, D' : D ~ o ,
(9)
where D O= 1.0 s ~ . Isotropic strain hardening is described by a nonlinear concave power form
h6')= ~=l~Pl"~
(10)
with equivalent plastic strain
'[(trDP) 2 - t r ( D e ' D p ) ] 9
eP=~22dr310I~),~ildt',
II D.=-~
The temperature and material damage softening functions
[ ( )] ( T-To
fs(Y)= 1-c3(.T, _T ~
~
1, T > To , c3= - 1 , T < T o ,
[(
~-r f4(~)= 1-(~.~_~.o)3 ,
(11)
(12)
where fs(T~) = 0 and f4 (~F) = 0 ~ D p ~ oo, represent the melt and local fracture conditions respectively. For high shock compression at high strain-rates, e.g., 10~ -10 ~ s -', the material viscosity varies with pressure (or volume strain), temperature and strain rate, where higher shock pressures increase temperature and strain rate and correspondingly lower material viscosity. A material viscosity-temperature-volume strain relation has been obtained for Copper from limited high stain-rate impact data [3, 6-9], coupled with the assumption that the lower bound value for the viscosity at melt temperatures that increase with high compression, nevertheless remains constant at rl~ ~ 10-2 Poise.
[ l 01I TT0 /1
q = q0exp In
Tm(~)_ To
13,
112 The designations m~, m 2, m 3, c~, c 2, r/0, r/m, ~:0,~:F appearing above are material parameters. Values for all of the material parameters for high purity Copper are tabulated below.
4. MICRODAMAGE MODEL Micro-degradation of polycrystalline metals is generally complex. However for dynamic loading that induces high tensile mean stress and temperatures that are not low, microdamage is essentially ductile, appearing as microvoids nucleating at grain boundaries, inclusions and other defect sites. Fracture comes about as nucleated microvoids, as well as pre-existing ones, grow and join together forming micro-cracks that subsequently connect with other voids progressively forming macrocracks and fragments. For high strain-rate microdamage, the stress-temperature driven nucleation rate process is considered most important [5, 10-12], whereby
m, [ (m,l<,-<,~l)_l ]
6N = ( 1 _ r
exp
kT
'
<,<<,,.
(14)
o N is the tensile nucleation mean stress threshold, k is the Boltzmaan constant and m4, m 5are material parameters. The model that simulates voids by a hollow sphere has been employed for pore collapse analysis [ 13], and later generalized for low shock impact studies [3, 5, 14, 15]. For hypervelocity shock impact, inertial and temperature effects are important for the micromechanics of void growth. A most general calculation of the void growth rate ~G requires solution of the differential equation r A(~)-~2~+B(~)
(15)
+TI(T)F(~,~0) ~-
where
k
x=-~--
(16)
~o ; ' A ( ~ ) = ( l - ~ ) h '
B(~)= ~ [
1 (~-)~-l)- .~-(~-'-'-1)}, F(~,~o)=~4 ll?- ~ T;. In
I (~, r
--"
f,," (1 + x)" X
ldx
(T), ,
x
g(~:) e :~ ~
l~ -1 , ~"1 ~-o
(17)
(18) (19)
and
(r = (1_r
'
[32 = r162
) 9
(20)
The void nucleation rate ~N given by eq. (14), when added to the solution of the set ofeqs. (15)(20) for the void growth rate ~G, provides the void volume fraction growth rate ~ (x, t ) at any
113
point x of the solid at any instant t. Time integration of ~ will then give the void volume fraction ~ ( x, t ) appearing in the constitutive equations shown in Sections 2 and 3. 5. T E M P E R A T U R E AND I N T E R N A L E N E R G Y The entire process from shock compression to fracture takes place adiabatically. Thus with the absence of any external heat sources, the instantaneous temperature and internal energy can be obtained by time integration of the following energy rate balance equations: pocvT=[ o m ! ~+(1-V)CO tr (T.DP)
(21)
for the temperature, and 1~=1o m I(l.-~-)+tr(X.D" ) + t r ( T . D
p)
(22)
for the internal energy. In these expressions em is given by eqs. (2 or 3), D" = ( ~ , ) T ' and D p is the sum of equations (7) and (8). 6. N U M E R I C A L C A L C U L A T I O N S Material parameter values for high purity copper are shown below. Space limitations prevent discussion of how they may be determined, or from where they were adopted from the work of others. Table 1 OFHC Copper Material Parameters On = 8920 kg/m 3 Ko = 13.2 x 104 MPa go = 4.8 x 104 MPa c o = 3.94 km/s "In = 300 OK Tin.. = 1,360 OK Y0 = 2.04 13= 1.09 .
.
Ti;'] = 180 MPa ~n = 1 0 -3 -
1 0 -4
~F = 0.2 - 0.3 r/, =105P 13,, = 10-2 P s = 1.45
.
a 0 = -3.296
m 4 = 2.07
aj = 1 . 5
a 2 = 0.0038 e I = 0.025
m~ = 70.37 s -! o r~ = 500 MPa k = 1.38 x 10 ~ J/~
C2 = 292 MPa
c v = 376 J/Kg .0 K
mr=2
D " = 1.0 s "i
m 2 = 0.31
co = 0.90
x 1 0 -23 c m 3
~
ro =10 -4 cm a =20
,
,
To begin to test the constitutive model prior to performing projectile-target impact simulations, simpler calculations (made at the time of preparation for the paper) of the pressure, volumestrain and temperature at a representative point behind a passing shock wave are shown below. The calculated and experimental shock pressure volume-strain Hugoniot for copper up to 160 GPa appears in Fig 1.
114 200
6000.
150 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
t /
50001--
i /
'
--2- .1. . . . . . . . . . .
~ .............
i - J. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
40001-=~
loo
...................................
_ ...............
i
or
30001
'
i
f
20001--
so . . . . . . . . . . . . .
-i- ......
~
........
10001 o .............
0
i
0.1
l
0.2 Volume Strain
,/
i~
'
013
Fig. 1. Pressure vs. volume strain. (~ Experimental ref. 16)
0.4
...... /
i
jJ'/
i
50
................... ////
i
i ..................... = i ......................
1 ,
! i
100 Pressure (GPa)
150
200
Fig. 2. Shock pressure-temperature rise (Temperature scale is ~
We note that at 0.3 volume-strain, corresponding to 135 GPa pressure, the melt temperature increases to 4,312 ~ according to the temperature-volume strain model employed. From Figure 2, which illustrates the calculated temperature rise for pressure up to 160 G P a , the calculated temperature at 135 GPa pressure is approximately 4,400 ~ indicating that the shocked compressed material will release into the molten state at this pressure. Because of the very great difficulty of obtaining temperature measurements, directly or indirectly, o f thermal changes that are of nano-second duration, there is no experimental data available that measures high shock pressure- induced temperature fluxuations that can be used for comaprisons with calculated values. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was supported by Grant HBCU/MI BAA #97-01, of the Ballistic Missile Defense Organization and Project #F49620-97-0536 of the Air Force Office of Scientific Research, with Dr. Arje Nachman of AFOSR serving as Program Manager. REFERENCES
2.
3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
M.H. Rice, R.G., McQueen, J.M. Walsh, Solid State Physics, F. Seitz and D. Turnbul (eds.), Academic Press, New York, 1958. ll.B. Huntington, The Elastic Constants of Crystals, Academic Press, New York, 1958. J.N. Johnson, J. Appl. Phys., 53 (1981) 2812. D.J. Steinberg, S.G. Cochran and M.W. Guinan, J. Appl. Phys., 51 (1980) 1488. P. Perzyna, Int. J. Solids Struct., 22 (1986) 797. L.C. Chhabildas and J.R. Asay, J. Appl. Phys., 50 (1979) 2749. D.E. Grady, Appl. Phys. Lett., 38 (1981) 825. M.M. Carroll and K.T. Kim, J. Appl. Phys., 59 (1986) 1962. D.R. Curran, L. Seaman and D.A. Shockey, Phys. Reports, 147 (1987) 253. R. Raj and M.F. Ashby, Acta Metall., 26 (1978) 993. S.N. Zhurkov, Int. J. Fract. Mech., 1 (1965) 311. L. Seaman, D.R. Curran and W.J. Mufti, J. Appl. Mech., 52 (1985) 593. M.M. Carroll and A.C. Holt, J. Appl. Phys., 46 (1972) 1626. J. Eftis and J.A. Nemes, Int. J. Plasticity, 7 (1991) 275. J. Eftis, lligh-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids If, L. Davison, et. al. (eds.) Springer, New York, 1996. R.G. McQueen, Metallurgy at High Pressures and High Temperature, K. Gschneider et al. (eds.) Gordon and Breach, New York, 1964.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000)
Editors:X.L.Zhaoand R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000ElsevierScienceLtd. All rightsreserved.
115
E x p e r i m e n t a l a n d n u m e r i c a l s t u d i e s o f projectile p e r f o r a t i o n in c o n c r e t e t a r g e t s H. Hansson and L./kgfirdh FOA (Defence Research Establishment) Weapons and Protection Division SE- 147 25 Tumba, Sweden
In the paper measurement results from ballistic tests on fibre reinforced concrete slabs performed at FOA Grindsj6n in April 1999 are presented. The tests were performed with single and double slabs that were 60 mm thick. The projectiles were steel cylinders with the weight of 60 g and fired the velocity range 1400 - 1600 m/s. Results from the experiments were compared with numerical simulations performed with Autodyn 2D. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N One reason for the interest of steel fibre reinforced concrete is that the increased fracture energy of steel fibre reinforced concrete, might give increased protection against perforation. In [1] results from perforation experiments through concrete slabs with fibre reinforcement and conventional reinforcement are presented. Those experiments were also simulated numerically with LS-DYNA3D [2]. The major difficulties are the description of the material behaviour at the high pressures and strain rates present in this problem. 2. E X P E R I M E N T S 2.1. Specimens and material sample test results The test series consisted of three slabs with the dimensions 1.2• m, poured of a type of concrete that normally is used for bridge decks. The concrete specifications are 440 g/m 3 of Portland cement and a water cement ratio of 0.38. The aggregates is of porphyry red granite with size up to 20 mm and 55 kg "Dramix ZC 30/50" steel fibres has been used per cubic meter concrete. The slabs and 150 mm cubes for material tests were poured in December 1996. In March the unconfined compression strength was determined to 79.5 MPa and the splitting strength determined to 7.4 MPa. From earlier tests of the same type of concrete the modulus of elasticity was taken to be 52.9 GPa and the density 2330 kg/m 3. The projectiles were cylinders with diameter 15 mm, length 43 mm and weight 60 g. They were fabricated from steel SS 14 2541-03 with 0.2-limit of 700 MPa and with failure limit between 900 and 1100 MPa.
116 2.2. Experiment arrangements During the experiments the velocities before impact and after perforation of the target were estimated. In the target, craters on the entrance and exit surfaces were measured and documented. The exit velocity of the projectile was registered with the help of two measurement frames supplied with diodes and a high speed video camera used to verify the position of the projectile. The slabs were fixed in a rig about 4 m from the end of the gun barrel. Two shots were fired against the single slab and two shots against the double slabs, that were fixed together with jackets.
2.3. Results from experiments The projectile from shot no. 96 was not found, and the projectile from shot no. 99 was deformed aider perforation. Crater diameters and hole diameters are presented in table 1. Detailed views from the craters for shot no. 97 are presented in figures 1 to 2. 3. NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS The numerical simulations were performed with Autodyn 2D version 3.0.12 Four sets of simulations were performed with velocities from the tests.
3.1 Material model for the target The RHT concrete model developed at "Ernst Mach Institut" (EMI) in Germany was used for the target. The model and material parameters for concrete is described in [3], and partly also in [4]. The material model is a three invariant model for the definition of the elastic limit surface, failure surface and remaining strength surface for the crushed material, see figure 3. The model also accounts for the loading rate and the limitation of the elastic behaviour with a cap. The damage in the material grows due to increase strain after the stress in the has reached Table 1. Crater dimensions in the concrete slabs (ram). First slal; No. Target Entrance FIole Exit crater diameter crater #96 Singleslab 160 80 #97 Single slab 160 75 170 #98 Double slab 220 65 190 #99 Double slab 190 55 180 .
--
9
i
.
.
iiiii
.
.
i
ii
_
i
m
_
Figure 1. Entrance hole for shot #97.
i
.
.
Second slab Entrance mad Exit hole diameter crater
75 45
240 210 i
i
iii
Figure 2. Exit hole for shot #97.
117
the failure surface The stress is then interpolated from the strength values for the undamaged material and the completely damaged material. The used Equation of State (EOS) is the "P-o~model". Explanation is published by Herrmann [5] and is also described in the Autodyn theory manual [6]. A polynomial EOS gives the behaviour of the compacted solid material. The material parameters in table 2 are chosen from estimations and comparisons with other concrete types [3, 4]. The uniaxial compression strength for cubes was used as the compression strength for the concrete. The tension strength of the concrete is assumed to be 80% of the splitting strength. With Q~ equal to zero, the effect of the third invariant is calculated according to William-Warnke [7]. To obtain numerically robust results, erosion strains of 300 - 400 % were chosen.
3.2. Material model for the projectile The projectile was simulated with the material model Johnson & Cook material model [6, 8]. The mechanical properties are based on data for steel 4340, and an erosion strain of 300-400 %. There were also simulations performed with modified data from uniaxial material tests with the SS 14 2541-3. The used material parameters are given in table 3.
Figure 3. Meridians and surfaces for elastic-, failure- and remaining strengths. From [3]. Table 2. Used values of th e material parameters fo r RHT-model concrete mode I. Parameter Value Parameter Values Parameter Initial p 2.45 g/cm 3 cv 640 J/kgK PREFAC;F p porous 2.44 g/cm 3 G 17.2 TENSRAT c porous 2561 m/s f'c 80 MPa COMPRAT p crush 80 MPa f'df'c 0.073 D1 p lock 1000 MPa A fail 0 D2 n 1 B fail 1.6 EFMIN Solid EOS Polynomial N fail 0.61 B fric p solid 2.68 g/cm 3 QI 0 N fric A~ 85 GPa Q2 0.6805 SOFTFLAG A2 - 171 GPa BQ 0.0105 SHRATD A3 208 GPa R1 0.007 CAPFLAG TI 85 GPa R2 0.007 Bulk strain Tref 300 K RLIMYr 1 Erosion strain i
i
i
rr
i
Values 2 0.6 0.3 0.04 1 0.01 0.8 0.85 2 0.13 1 3 3
118 Table 3. Used material data for the steels 4340 and SS 14 2541-3 4340 steel SS 14 2541-3 steel 7.83 g/cm 3 7.83 g/cm 3 Reference density 159 GPa 159 GPa Bulk modulus 300 K 300 K Reference temperature 477 J/kgK 477 J/kgK Specific heat 81.8 GPa 81.8 GPa Shear modulus 792 MPa 600 MPa Yield stress 510 MPa 850 MPa Hardening constant 0.26 0.30 Hardening exponent 0.014 0.014 Strain rate constant 1.03 1.03 Thermal softening exponent 1793 K 1793 K Meitin[~ temperatur e ,
l,
,l
,
,,,
3.3. Geometric models The simulations were performed using rotation symmetry for the models. The target slab is 60 mm thick and a circular plate with a diameter of 500 mm is simulated. The element size in the target is gradually increased from the centre and outwards. To reduce the reflections at the boundary, a transmission boundary condition was used at the boundary around the plate. The target that consisted of two slabs fixed closed together was simulated both as joined plates and with a distance between the surfaces to observe the differences. Further an element grid with approximately half the element sides was used for improved simulations. For these simulations the target plates consisted of 60x100 elements and the projectiles of t6x44 elements, this gives approximately one mm's element side in the centre of the target. 4. RESULTS FROM SIMULATIONS AND COMPARISONS WITH EXPERIMENTS The results from the simulations and the comparisons with the experiments are presented below, see table 4. After perforation the length and diameters of projectiles from shot 97 and 98 was measured and compared to the simulated results, see also table 4. In figure 4 the projectiles from shot #97 and #98 are shown, representing shots against single and double slabs. In figure 5 the corresponding simulated projectiles after the test are shown. The damaged concrete zone for the models FRAG6E and FRAG7E are shown in figure 6.
Figure 4. Projectile after shot #97 (left) and #98 (right).
Figure 5. Projectile from simulation FRAG6E (left) and FRAG7E (right).
119
Figure 6. D a m a g e levels in the concrete targets after perforation, for models F R A G 6 E F R A G 7 E . T h e scale for the d a m a g e level of the concrete are s h o w n to the right.
and
Table 4. Results from simulations and experiments. i
Experiments NO.
,..,.,.,
.,..,
Simulations '"'
Vlmpac VExit
,
,.
,
,.,,, ....
,,,
,,,,,,,
i
,
t m/s
m/s
96
1637
1120
......
97
1505
1080
41
28
23
FRAG2B l FRAG6E 3 F R A G 6 F 3'4
990 1066 1051
55 46 47
98
1557
455
35
20
26
FRAG3B l FRAG3C 2 FRAG7E 3 F R A G 7 F 3'4 FRAG4B ! FRAG4C 2 FRAG8E 3 F R A G 8 F 3"4
618 598 570 563 487 498 530 538
51 51 39 40 54 55 46 48
1421
418
,, ,,,,
32
......
,
O mm
,.,
MExit g
99
L mm
,,,,,,
Identity
WExit m/s
MExit g
F R A G 1B' FRAG5E 3 F R A G 5 F 3"4
i112 1175 1160
51 42 44
26.5 -
23.7 -
20.7
25.0
f
,J
i
L mm
O' mm
-
,
C o m m e n t s : ') Coarse e l e m e n t gridl 2) Joined slabsl 3 ) E r o s i o n strain increased to 4 0 0 % for proiectile and target. 4 ) E s t i m a t e d material data for SS 14 2541-03 has been used, all other simulations with 4340 steel.
120 5. S U M M A R Y The simulations were performed with AUTODYN2D version 3.0.12 with the RHT concrete model. The results from the simulations were compared to the ballistic tests. It is shown that exit velocities of the projectile were simulated with good agreement for the single slab and fairly good agreement for the double slab. The exit velocities for the double slabs were higher in the simulation, this indicate that the concrete model may be to soft. The residual mass of the projectile was in all cases overestimated, this may be explained by the very high erosion strain used for the steel. A more suitable value would have been 150 to 200 %. The deviation can be explained by uncertainties regarding the material data for concrete and steel. However, the use of different steels in the numerical models did not have any significant influence on the result. The concrete had probably higher strength values at the time for the ballistic tests compared to the test results, because the material tests were performed one year earlier. On the other hand the compression strength determined from cubes is probably to high, this is caused by the friction constraint of the concrete at the load surfaces. In the used material model the steel fibres are not considered, thus the effect of the increased fracture energy can not yet be simulated. Therefor, it remains to perform corresponding ballistic tests of slabs without steel fibres. The reason for this is to determine the difference in behaviour for concrete with and without fibre reinforcement. There is also a need for better characterisation of the material behaviour of the used concrete at high pressures and strain rates.
REFERENCES 1. A. Bryntse, Perforation of steel fragments at 1500 m/s through steel fibre and conventionally reinforced concrete slabs, FOA-D-97-00304-311--SE, Tumba, 1997. (In swedish) 2. L. ,~,gS.rdh and L. Laine, 3D FE-Simulation of High Velocity Fragment Perforation of Steel Fibre Reinforced Concrete Slabs, Proc. Int. Symp. honouring Mr Arnfinn Jenssen, Trondheim, 1998. 3. W. Riedel, Ein makroskopishe, modulares Betonmodell fiar Hydrocodes mit Verfestigung, Sch~idigung, Entfestigung Drei-Invarientenabh~gigkeit und Kappe, EMI bericht 7/98, Freiburg 1998. 4. W. Riedel, K. Thoma, S. Hiermaier and Schmolinske E, Penetration of Reinforced Concrete by BETA-B-500. Numerical Analysis using a New Macroscopic Concrete Model for Hydrocodes, Proc. 9~ Int. Symp. IEMS, Berlin, 1999, pp 315 - 322. 5. W. Herrmann, Constitutive Equation for the Dynamic Compaction of Ductile Porous Materials, J. of App. Physics, vol 40, No 6, 1969, pp. 2490-2499. 6. Autodyn Theory Manual, Century Dynamics Ltd, Horsham 1999. 7. K. J. Willam and E. P. Warnke, Constitutive Model for the Triaxial Behaviour of Concrete, Sem. on Concrete Structure Subjected to Triaxial Stresses. IABSE Proc. 19, Italy, 1975. 8. G. R. Johnson and W. H. Cook, A constitutive model and data for metals subjected to large strains, high strain rates, and high temperatures, Proc. 7th. Int. Symp. on Ballistics, Holland, 1983, pp. 541-547.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
121
Prototype Impact Tests on Ultimate Impact Resistance of PC Rock-Shed N.Kishi a,
H.Konno
b, K . I k e d a b , and K.G.Matsuokaa
aCivil Engineering, Muroran Institute of Technology, Muroran, 050-8585 Japan bStructural Laboratory, Research Institute of Hokkaido Development Bureau, Sapporo, 062-8602 Japan In order to confirm the ultimate impact strength of Prestressed Concrete (PC) rock-sheds constructed on a highway in Japan, prototype impact tests are conducted by using two types of PC rock-shed frames: inverted L-shaped type and fully rigid frame type (frame type). These both types of PC rockshed frames are of the same dimensions which are: span length = 10.1 m, upper flange width = 150 cm, and column height = 4.65 m. Impact tests are performed by 3.0/5.0 ton steel weight iteratively and freely falling onto the center of each frame covered with 90 cm thick sand cushion. The results obtained from this study are as follows: 1) the frame type has more than 1.7 times impact resistant capacity than the inverted L-shaped one with reference to a falling weight potential energy; 2) the frame type can rationally disperse the sectional forces over the whole structure; and 3) these inverted L-shaped type and frame type PC rock-sheds designed based on allowable stress design procedure have more than four and five times margin for collapse, respectively. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
In Japan, there are many rock-sheds over mountainous and coastal roads with cliffs. So far, three types of the structure have been constructed which are Reinforced Concrete (RC), Prestressed Concrete (PC), and steel type. In future, PC rock-sheds are expected to be the most popular type because of good quality control and low labor cost due to prefabrication works. In PC rock-sheds, an inverted L-shaped type is usually applied of which column base and the top of mountainous side-waU (hereafter, side-wall) are hinged and the girder is rigidly connected to column. The structure is a first-order statically indeterminate structure. However, in order to attain economy and to increase number of redundancy for safety against an unexpected bigger impact load than specified one in design, a structural type having several redundancies should be chosen. In this paper, in order to investigate ultimate impact resistance of inverted L-shaped type and frame type PC rock-shed, steel weight falling impact tests
122
iI
steel weight
(3/Ston)
surcharged girder G3
J
/SAND
i
....
~r~be
--)
Figure 1 Experimental set-up using full scale PC rock-shed frames with 90 cm thick sand cushion are conducted. Here, impact load is surcharged iteratively and its input energy is gradually increased till the shed reaches the ultimate state. It is assumed that the PC rock-sheds are in the ultimate state when maximum response value of the main girder displacement reaches around 35 mm which is about 1/300th of the main-girder length. The ultimate impact resistance for these types rocksheds is discussed using sectional bending moment and crack pattern developed in girder after the final impact test.
2. EXPERIMENTAL OVERVIEW The both types full scale PC rock-sheds are composed of laterally arranged five frames. A girder in each frame has a simple T-shape cross section, of which dimensions are: height - 110 cm, width of upper flange (hereafter, roofslab) -- 150 cm, and length -- 12 m. The column has a rectangular cross section (110 cm • 50 cm) and is about 4.7 m high. The impact tests are conducted by freely dropping 3.0/5.0 ton steel weight onto the roof-slab of each rock-shed with a 90 cm thick sand cushion as shown in Fig. 1. The dimensions of dropped steel weights are the same in each other and these are: diameter = 100 cm and height of spherical bottom = 17.5 cm. The PC rock-shed used in this experiment is designed based on the Japanese conventional design manual 1) for anti-impact structures against a falling rock under the following conditions: 1) a 1.0 ton mass rock falls on the roof-slab with a 90 cm thick sand cushion from a 30 m height; 2) a 1.17 MN impact load, estimated by using a conventional Hertz's contact theory with Lame's constant of sand cushion )~ = 0.98 MPa, is statically surcharged onto the center of girder; 3) the impact load is dispersed in the area of 45 ~ direction of salad cushion; and 4) concrete compressive strength and allowable tensile stress
123
Table 1 List of experimental cases Notation_ L3-5 L3-20 L3-30 F3-5 F3-10 F3-20 F5-20 F5-30
Structural . type Inverted L-shaped type
Mass of weight (ton) 3
Frame type 5
Falling height (m) 5 20 30 5 10 20 20 30
Note: steel weight is dropped at the mid-span of girder are 54.0 MPa and 2.0 MPa, respectively and its Young's modulus is 34.3 GPa. The PC girders have the dimensions mentioned above and are prestressed using 24 tendons of steel strand with pretensioning system. Introduced prestress in the mid-span's upper and lower fibers of girder are 1.0 MPa tensile stress and 10.7 MPa compressive stress, respectively. The girders and columns of inverted L-shaped type axe connected to the side-wan and the basement, respectively with 2 round bars to keep a pin condition. On the other hand, those for frames type are rigidly connected introducing prestress with 12 and 4 PC tendons, respectively. The girder is rigidly connected to column by prestressing with 4 PC tendons in the outer area of column section and 8 PC tendons over the whole area for inverted L-shaped type and frame type, respectively. The sand layer is compacted by foot stamping at every 20 cm thick layer. The moisture content and relative density of sand after coInpactions are 6.4 % and 36 %, respectively. Experimental cases are listed in Table 1, in which each case is notified symbolizing structural type (L" inverted L-shaped type, F: ~frame type), mass of steel weight (ton), and falling height of steel weight (m). In these experiments, the strains in the upper and lower rebar of girder and in the outer and inner rebar of column are measured and are recorded using wide-band data recorders. These strains are converted into sectional forces using fiber model based on the linear variation concept on sectional strain distribution, in which each material stress-strain relation and axial compressive forces introduced due to prestressing are considered. And girder displacement is also measured to confirm whether the shed model reaches the ultimate state or not.
3. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS 3.1. Bending Moment Distribution of Inverted L-shaped Type Figure 2 shows the bending moment distributions in cases of L3-5 and L3-30 on inverted L-shaped type. In this figure, column and side-waU are arranged in the left and right hand side, respectively. The bending moment of side-wall
124
I
9
3 MNm
L3-5
O o o o ee~
" 0 0 00000 0
10
~
lS
msec
50
m sec
80
:~176 Co o-11
-:::.....
~176176 0
~
30
io o 1
~ OOOoOO~ ~
25 m n c
msec
I v~.... :o "l I o
9 o o
msec
60
~ 1
: " O o. .~. . . .
Ioo---~---i
99
o o
OOOO~
20 m s e c
40 m s e c
10
m sec
o
msec
,_.....o.~ao
"-~" "'""" ~
L3-30
90
~ffi.
,,
msec
o
1
o li.,oo Q_ goffi.
1o- ..... o....
msec
100
1
msec
Figure 2 Bending moment distribution in cases of Inverted L-shaped type
I3
MNm
o,,
.
A F3-5
O F3-30
[] F5-30
,,G*A
"":':"-~o~
8....-~oo ~o
10 msec
o
25 msec
~
-~176176176176 $0 m s e c
rt
80 msec
0o
- 8 ~~- - - - - e oS --
15 msec
~_
.
, ,~: DO
30 muec
~_ .......
O
20 msec
40
~
-
60 msec
(3
~..
msec
- . . . . .. . . . . . .
O
_.
;,~,~ ~"- 90 msec
~ ~ ~___?.....
70 m s e c
7
-~100
. . . . . . .
msec
Figure 3 Bending moment distribution in cases of frame type is estimated assuming one-way slab with a 1.5 m wide effective length. From this figure, it is seen that the bending moments of girder are almost linearly distributed taking the maximum value at the center (loading point) and zero moment near both ends of girder in spite of the magnitude of a falling weight potential energy. Focusing on the bending moment at the connecting point between girder and column, even though statically a half of mid-span bending moment is occurred at that point, the experimental results are less than one sixth of the mid-span's value. It implies that the erection method applied for inverted L-shaped type does not enable the girder moment to rationally transfer to the column, and the connection should be assumed as not rigid but pin condition in design. The maximum bending moment is occurred near the loading point in case of L3-30 and of 5.1 MNm which is a similar value to the ultimate moment capacity estimated by using fiber model. Then, bending cracks may have been developed near the lower surface of the mid-span of girder.
125
I
3 MNm
9
o
o 0o
~:) A~
-
I:::~ g O,g o t ~ n ^ _oa
~s...l~o 10
msec
25
L3-30
%~
msec
SO
o--
F3-30 FS-30 ..__ t i l . ~
80
msec
i2im.
.... t
m ser
G oo
IS
'-k
.__ -_, . % * _ * . , * = .
msec
30
msec
o
60
Oo
.... 20
.8.~'"
msec
~
-~~176
40
msec
I
..... 7'0
90
msec
o
"I
m sec
el 9,,IL~_*. n h .
msec
Figure 4 Comparison of bending moment distribution between two types
3.2. Bending Moment Distribution of Frame Type The comparison of bending moment distributions among three cases (F3-5, F3-30, and F5-30) for frame type is shown in Fig. 3. From this figure, since the bending moments at both ends of girder, cohmm basement, and the top of side-wall are increased with increment of a falling weight potential energy, the rigidly anchoring effect at the supporting points and rigidly connecting effect of girder to column on moment distribution can be confirmed. Therefore, negative bending moment is occurred at both ends of girder and column basement. The girder bending moment for frame type is of parabolic distribution similarly to that of statically and uniformly surcharged girder. This bending moment distribution mode may be conveyed due to the rigidly anchoring and connecting effects because the distribution in case of inverted L-shaped type is of almost linear as mentioned above. Investigating vibration mode of the whole structure, at the time of 40 msec from beginning, the frame in cases of F3-5 and F3-30 is restored to the original position and has a tendency to move to the rebounding state (negative loading state). However, in case of F5-30, the same situation comes out about 20 msec later than that in cases of F3-5 and F3-30. It means that a fundamental natural vibration period of F5-30 is prolonged corresponding to decreasing the bending stiffness due to the progress of plastic region around the mid-span accompanied with cracks developing. The maximum bending moment is occurred at the mid-span after 20 msec from beginning of which the value is about 5.2 MNm. This value is almost the same with that in case of F3-30. Then, it is seen that the safety margin of PC rock-sheds can be increased by 1.7 times (= (5 ton • 30 m)/(3 ton • 30 m)) by changing structural system from inverted L-shaped type to frame one with reference to a falling weight potential energy.
126 i colum side I
inverted L-shaped type
qr l
wall ddei
I I
| I
i I
'
frame type
I
~
I
J t
I
Figure 5 Crack pattern of girders after final impact test 3.3. Comparison of Dynamic Responses between Two Structural Types Figure 4 shows the bending moment distributions of L3-30 for inverted Lshaped type and F3-30 and F5-30 for frame type. Comparing the results between L3-30 and F3-30 which are the cases with the same input energy, it is seen that the girder moment (F3-30) for frame type is moved to the negative side and the positive bending moment is effectively decreased by rigidly anchoring the supporting points and rigidly connecting girder to column. Figure 5 shows crack patterns developed in each girder of L3-30 and F5-30 after the final impact test. From this figure, in case of inverted L-shaped type (L3-30), bending shear type cracks are developed around the mid-span area. On the other hand, in case of frame type (F5-30), the similar cracks with the case of inverted L-shaped type (F3-30) are developed except two crack lines are diagonally occurred near a quarter span in the wall side. Maximum residual displacement of girder for L3-30 and F5-30 are 1.8 mm and 3.6 m m long, respectively. As mentioned above, it is recognized that the maximum bending moment at the final impact test reaches the same with the ultimate bending capacity estimated using fiber model. However, the severe damage such as compressive failure around loading point and/or tension failure due to rebars and PC tendons yielding has not been found from the crack pattern, and still both frames have retained sufficient residual impact resistant capacity. 4. CONCLUSIONS The results obtained from this experiment can be summarized as follows: 1)the frame type has more than 1.7 times impact resistant capacity than the inverted L-shaped one with reference to a falling weight potential energy; 2)the frame type can rationally disperse the sectional forces over the whole structure; and 3)inverted L-shaped type and frame type designed based on ASD procedure have more than four and five times margin for collapse, respectively.
REFERENCE 1. Japan Road Association, "Manual for anti-impact structures against falling rock", 1983.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
127
Penetration equations for the impact of 7.62mm ball projectile against composite material sheets of an aircraft Pardeep Kumar, R.A Goel and V.S Sethi Terminal Ballistics Research Laboratory Sector 30, Chandigarh, India
Abstract An aircraft is generally exposed to the attack from antiaircraft gun (AAG) or fragmenting type of warheads. But its vulnerability is often evaluated in terms of the attack against 7.62mm BalI/API ammunition. The failure of the target is measured in terms of ballistic limit and the amount of remaining velocity or remaining energy of the projectile. To compute the vulnerability of an aircraft, extensive experimentation was undertaken on various thicknesses of a carbon fiber composite material. Empirical equations for ballistic limit and remaining velocity after perforation have been formulated and presented. 1. INTRODUCTION The ballistic survivability / vulnerability of an aircraft involves the study of the impact behaviour of the threat mechanisms, i.e fragments and small arms projectiles. The impact of a high velocity projectile on a target is a very complex phenomena and may result in partial penetration or complete penetration. A complete description of the dynamics of impacting projectile demands the accounts to be taken about geometry of interacting projectile and target, their elastic, plastic behaviour, etc. An analytical approach is not only quite formidable but does not give realistic results. Therefore, the large amount of work in this field has been experimental in nature. Thor equations can be used to determine the penetration of steel fragments of different shapes against different types of metalic and non-metalie materials. But, for small arms, Thor equations for penetration can not be used against aircraft materials because of the shape factor of the penetrator. Hence extensive experimental work was carried out to study the behaviour of the composite material against the impact of 7.62 mm ball projectile. The equations have been established between impact velocity, critical velocity and remaining velocity. 2. DEVELOPMENT OF MATHEMATICAL MODEL 2.1 DETERMINATION OF BALLISTIC LIMIT The determination of ballistic limit / critical velocity is of prime importance in the design of protective structures, in evaluation of the effectiveness of military armour vehicle, aircraft vulnerability analysis and in any problem area where an impact can cause damage. Two techniques (deterministic or probabilistic) are available to determine the critical velocity. In former, a limit velocity is determined from physical principles (the conservation laws and material constitutive relations), but because of complexity of problem, the choice of probabilistie technique is made. In this technique a statistical approach is employed. In the simplest form, Vs0 is determined by averaging six projectile striking velocities that include
128 the three lowest velocities that resulted in complete penetration and the three highest velocities that resulted in a partial penetration (a spread of 46m/s or less is required between the highest velocity for partial penetration and the lowest velocity for a complete penetration). In United States, three criteria of ballistic limit have commonly been used, i.e., Army, Protection and Navy. Under the Army Ballistic Limit (ABL) criterion, a complete penetration occurs when light is visible through the penetration in the armour or when the nose of the projectile can be seen from the rear of the armour. In the Protection Ballistic Limit (PBL) criterion, a complete penetration occurs whenever a fragment or fragments from either the impacting projectile or the armour are caused to be ejected from the back of the armour with sufficient remaining energy to pierce a thin sheet of aluminium alloy, 0.05 mm to 0.50 mm thick (witness plate) placed parallel and 15.24 cm behind the target. While the Navy Ballistic Limit (NBL) criterion for a complete penetration requires that the projectile or a major portion of a projectile passess through the plate. On the basis of procedure explained in determination of ballistic limit, the ballistic limit for carbon fiber composite panel of different thicknesses namely 4.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8.5 and 10.5 mm against a 7.62 mm Ball projectile at normal obliquity has been experimentally determined. The geometry of the 7.62mm ball projectile is standard having conical shape with CRH ratio 5/10. The mechanical properties of carbon fiber composite material are (i) Specific gravity 1.13 (ii) Tensile strength, psi 120000 (iii) Tensile modulus of elasticity, psi 6000000 A mathematical expression for Vm will depend upon density, thickness, mechanical properties and shock wave velocity in the target and angle of impact, presented area and weight of the projectile. i.e Vso : f(Pt, Ap,W, t, s, a, a )
(1)
where, p, = Density of the target Ap = Presented ~rea of the projectile t = Thickness of the target W = Weight of the projectile s = Strength of the target a = Velocity of sound in the target ot = Angle of impact The dimensional analysis will provide the solution in the following form
n, :,(n,, n,, n,)
(2)
If w e assume It I to be nondimensional group with Vso , II 2 and II 3 with s and a,
ptApt 1-I4 - " 7 , then the experimental simulation of equation (2) gives (PtApt~ ~ Vso= 2106.83[ W J The mechanical properties have been submerged in the values of constants.
(3)
129
2.2 DETERMINATION OF REMAINING VELOCITY The empirical relation for remaining velocity versus striking velocity and ballistic limit/critical velocity of 7.62 mm ball projectile against composite panels has been formulated and given below
(v,: - v d ) ": V,=
(4)
(1+ p, t ] p. o)
Where t = Length of the projectile pp = Density of the projectile V, = Striking velocity of the projectile 3 EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1 BALLISTIC LIMIT Observed and computed values of the ballistic limit have been placed in Table 1. It is evident from the Table that the maximum error between observed and computed values of ballistic limit varies from -0.37 % to 3.40 %. The graph for observed and computed values of ballistic limit verses thickness of plate has also been presented in Fig 1 which shows as thickness of plate is increased, the ballistic limit for computed and observed values is also increasing. 3.2 REMAINING VELOCITY The comparative observed and computed values of the remaining velocity of various thicknesses (4.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8.5 and 10.5) of target panels have been placed in Table 2,3,4,5,6 respectively. It is cleared from these tables that observed and computed values are within a maximum error of 4%. It is also seen as thickness of target increases, the % of error between computed and observed values of remaining velocity also increases.
350 300 E 250 -
--+- Observed Ballistic Limit Computed Ballistic Limit
E 200
o..,.
.J
.o_ 1 5 0 o.m
m
100
-
50 i
i
~
'
"
I
2 4 6 8 Thickness of the plate (mrn)
I
10
Figure 1. Ballistic limit verses thickness of plate
........ i
12
130 4 CONCLUSION It can therefore be inferred from the above paragraphs that the empirical equations formulated for ballistic limit and remaining velocity of composite panels against 7.62 mm ball projectiles are suitable to compute accurate results within an error of maximum 4%. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The Authors are greatly indebted to Sh. V.S Sethi, Director, TBRL for granting permission to publish this work.
Density of plate=l.5 g/cm 3 Presented area of projectile=0.456cm 2 Weight of projectile -9.33 g Density of projectile--11.4 g/cm 3 Length of projectile -2.87 cm Table I S. No
-
Angle of Impact .......... (degree) 1 90 2 3 4 5 -
-
~
:
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1"hickness of Plate(mm) .
.
.
.
.
.
_ ~
.
.
.
.
.
.
10.5 8.5 7.5 6.5 4.5
. . . . . . . . . .
.
observed' Ballistic ' 'Computed Ballistic Limit(m/s) Limit(m/s)
'//~Erro'r
.
305.00 265.00 231.00 206.00 154.00
,
.
.~ .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
308.84 255.98 235.29 206.77 155.95 , ...................
__
.
, .
.
.
.
-1.26 3.40 -1.86 -0.37 -1.27 .
, . ~ ,
Table 2 S.No .... 1
2 3 4
5 6 7 g
9 10
Impact .... Thickness Angle of Plate de ree (rqm 9O 4.5
Striking ' Observed ' ComPuted %Egor Velocity Remaining Remaining ..........(m/s) ...................Ve !o cit y( ~ S )_____V_elo_c.it_,y_(_m/s]. 805.68 770.55 774.47 -0.52 862.80 835.54 831.44 0.48 862.00 830.76 830.64 0.01 874.50 840.55 843.09 -0.09 760.85 728.43 729.14 -0.09 970.40 945.35 938.43 0.71 860.46 833.84 829.11 0.55 865.55 838.35 834.18 0.48 867.82 838.40 836.44 0.23 ............ 85_6"47................. 8 2 6 . 5 5 825.13 0.17
131 Table 3 s.do
Angle of Impact (degree)
Thickness of Plate (mm)
90
6.5
1
Striking . . . . . Velocity (m/s)
2 3 4
5 6 7 8
9 10 9
,
839.40 850.30 852.08 810.55 820.45 860.35 838.48 842.65 846.84 815.75 . . . . . . . .
,.
. . . . . . . .
,,
,j
.
.
Observed. . . . . Remaining Velocity
.
.
.
.
799.55 807.64 810.05 765.10 782.20 823.00 797.35 801.55 810.47 773.08 .
.
.
-
,
.
.
.
.
Computed Remaining Velocity
% Error'
790.03 800.64 802.69 761.05 770.99 810.97 789.07 793.25 797.45 766.28
1.19 0.87 0.91 0.53 1.43 1.46 1.04 1.04 1.61 0.88
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
.
.....
Table 4 _
S'l~ O .
.
.
.
Angle of ~ Thici~ness S t r i k i n g Impact of Plate Velocity (degree) (mm) (m/s) , .
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
.
.
.
.
.
90
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
7.5
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
-
.
836.15 840.64 837.54 829.40 824.00 839.50 796.33 815.64 834.55 796.38
_
.J_,
Observed Remaining Velocity
,
.
,,,
i,
Computed Remaining Velocity
(m/s) . . . . . .
789.55 795.66 793.47 777.25 778.45 793.40 748.25 768.69 790.36 746.85
,,,
L,
% Error
(m/s)
....
775.69 780.21 777.09 768.89 763.44 779.07 735.49 755.01 774.08 735.54
1.76 1.94 2.06 1.08 1.93 1.81 1.71 1.78 2.06 1.52
Table $
0
Angleof Impact (degree)
ThickneSs ''~ Striking --' of Plate Velocity (ram) (m/s)
Observed Remaining Velocity (m/s)
90 2 3
4 5
6
. . . . . . 8'.5. . . .
915.85 .... 840.50 845.45 854.84 849.80 843.40
865.73 786.25 793.70 802.25 794.34 792.45
Computed ~ % Error Remaining Velocity ....
(m/s)
846.37 770.54 775.54 785.02 779.94 773.47
.......
2.20 1.99 2.29 2.15 1.81 2.39
132 7 8 L,,
9 10 ,,
,,
,,,
.........
852.35 852.85 865.27 838.43 ,
,,
,,,
800.43 801.25 816.55 783.28 i
ii
|ll
.
i
.
,
,,
782.51 783.01 795.54 768.45
,,,,,,,
,
2.24 2.28 2.57 1.89
,,,,,,
Table 6 S,N o
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
....
Angie 'of '"Thickness Impact of Plate (degree) (mm) 90
Striking Velocity
(m/s)
Observed Remaining Velocity
864.58 816.44 854.80 844.85 861.65 753.55 838.57 836.70 824.44 757.50
795.60 747.55 788.61 778.52 796.85 680.61 767.05 770.45 755.35 685.65
10.5
.....
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,(m/s)
.
.
.
.
.
,,,
,
' Computed Remaining Velocity
(m/s)
770.45 721.06 760.45 750.26 767.47 655.79 743.82 741.90 729.30 659.92
,,,,,,,,,
---
.
% Error
.
.
.
.
.
,,
.
,,
.
,,,
.
.
.
3.16 3.54 3.57 3.62 3.69 3.65 3.03 3.71 3.45 3.75
. . . . . . . . . . . .
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPL,,IST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
133
High Strength Concrete Beams Subjected to Impact L o a d - S o m e Experimental Results Johan Magnusson, H~mn Hansson, Lennart Ag~rdh Defence Research Establishment (FOA), Weapons and Protection Division SE-172 90 Stockholm, Sweden In this investigation, high strength reinforced concrete beams have been tested for impact loads. The unconfined compressive strength of the concrete was 112 MPa. Three beams were subjected to quasi-static loading and five beams were subjected to impact loading. A weight with a mass of 718 kg dropped with a striking velocity of 6.7 m./s served as the impact load. Main emphasis was put upon performing accurate measurements for validation of numerical models. 1. INTRODUCTION Accidental loading is often comprised of impacts from collisions, striking objects, explosions etc. The failure process of the target is complex and depends on several loading parameters such as striking mass, velocity, load direction and the interface between striker and target. Also, target material parameters such as strain rate sensitivity and ductility, and structural parameters such as boundary conditions influence the failure process. For design purposes it is necessary to use validated numerical models. This investigation involves experiments of reinforced concrete beams subjected to both quasistatic and dynamic loading. The objectives were to increase our basis for numerical modelling and simulation of high strength concrete structural response and to register the crack initiation and development under slxain rates up to 100 sq . The investigation is completely reported in [1]. Similar tests and simulations have been performed with smaller beams reported in [2] and with normal strength concrete in [3]. 2. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
2.1. Specimens A total of eight concrete beams were tested, each with dimensions according to Figure 1. The unconfined compressive strength of the concrete was 112 MPa and the splitting strength was 6.7 MPa at the day of testing. Both the compressive strength and the splitting strength were determined from 150 mm cubes. Young's modulus according to CEB-FIP was equal to 44.2 GPa and according to ISO 6784 was equal to 45.3 GPa. Young's moduli were determined on ~100 x 200 mm cylinders. The beams were reinforced with both longitudinal rebars and stirrups. The mean density of the specimens was 2520 kg/m 3.
134 Stirrups d=10Ks500STslS0 1500
100 ~
l,/llll
,//
~k.
Ill
-7~
illi
100_
1500
llIll!!
i
t
.....
'
4200
.i
ELEVATION /
Jl.~
d=12 KsS00ST
~ ' " . P l I'7t
CROSS SECTION
Figure 1. Concrete beams used in the experiments. The reinforcement was of type Ks500ST with a nominal yield strength of 500 MPa. The results of a uniaxial tensile test of one rebar is shown in Figure 2. Three strain gauges were positioned on each rebar at the bottom layer of the beam as shown in Figure 1. The cover in the compression zone was increased to avoid complications in the simulation of the failure process, see Figure 1. 700
~
m
I
5OO
~ 300 200
100 0 0
2
4
6
8
Strain
10
12
14
16
(%)
Figure 2. Stress-strain curve from the uniaxial tensile test of one rebar. (Note: The broken line is an extrapolation based on the test results).
135
2.2. Quasi-Static Load Three beams were tested with a quasi-static load. The beams were simply supported with a span of 4.0 m in the quasi-static tests. The supports were considered to be rigid with negligible vertical displacements. Two uniform line loads were positioned at the third points
Crack indicator
!,.333 j,_.
~
Load (P) Load cell ~........r
3 4000
Hing~
-, "
I
........ i<
Deflection gauge [positioned at mid-s~n
Figure 3. Experimental set-up for the quasi-static tests. of the span. The load displacement rate was 1.0 mm/min for one beam and 2.0 mm/min for two beams. A load cell and a deflection gauge were positioned as shown in Figure 3. A twomillimetre wide painted line was used as a crack indicator. The line was painted on the side and 20 mm above the bottom surface of the beam. A nickel paint was used because of its ability to conduct electricity. By connecting an electric voltage to each end of the line an electric circuit was closed. When a crack was initiated the circuit was disclosed and a registration of the crack initiation was obtained. Furthermore, six strain gauges were positioned on the rebars as shown in Figure 2.
2.3. Dynamic Load Altogether five beams were tested with a dynamic load consisting of a heavy drop weight striking each beam at mid-span. The striker with a mass of 718 kg was dropped from a height of 2.68 m. The striker head struck a steel pad positioned on the beam with a velocity of about 6.7 m/s. The steel pad was 50 mm wide and 30 mm thick. The supports were considered to be rigid. In order to avoid upward displacements of the beam-ends during impact, restraints were used at the supports as illustrated in Figure 4. The span between the supports was 4.0 m. Two accelerometers were positioned on the beam as shown in Figure 4. For the last beam tested an accelerometer was also positioned on the striker head. Six strain gauges were used in the same manner as in the quasi-static tests except for the last beam tested. For this beam two strain gauges were positioned on the concrete surface on both sides of the beam at the same level as the middle gauge on the rebars, and four strain gauges were used on the rebars. Furthermore, the striker velocity was registered with a pulse transducer which was also used for the beam velocity in the last experiment. The same crack indication method was used as in the quasi-static experiments with the difference that the line was painted on the bottom surface of the beam in the dynamic experiments. A contact indicator was used between the striker head and the steel pad in order to register the time of impact. The event was recorded
136
Registrationof strikerveloci~
A [ ~
,/
v [m/s]
Steel vad
v [m/s]
Accelerometers
T
__
m l l m
L
"/
1
,, 4ooo
/
.
.
.
.
.
i .... f
A ELEVATION Figure 4. Experimental set-up for the dynamic tests.
f
f
f
f
f
f
f
A-A
with a high speed film camera with 1000 flames per second. For the last experiment 1540 frames per second was used. 3. RESULTS The load-deflection curves for the beams tested with a quasi-static load are shown in Figure 5. The mean beam deflection at the first crack initiation was found to be 1.5 mm at a crack load of 22.8 kN. From the registrations of the moment of impact in the dynamic experiments, separations between striker and beam were observed. The moment of crack initiation was captured. The maximum registered strain rates in the middle gauges on the rebars varied between 21 s ! and 102 s! for the different tests. The scatter is due to the location of the cracks. A crack in the concrete which appears where a strain gauge is located gives rise to higher registered strains and strain rates. The strain rates were determined on the upper part of the strain versus time curves, i.e., after yielding of the rebars. Strain rates from the middle gauges determined on the strain curvesbefore yielding of the rebars varied between 15 s"1 and 17 s"l. The maximum registered strain rates in the concrete before crack initiation was 6 s"~. The acceleration time history was integrated twice in order to obtain the velocity of the beam and the deflection of the central part of the beam. The beam velocity and the deflection were also determined from the high speed photos. Figure 6 shows a sequence from the high speed photos. The vertical distance between the crosses on the beam was 100 ram. Figure 7 illustrates the deflection versus time curves determined from the high speed photos and the integration of the acceleration curves. The third curve in Figure 7 illustrates the striker displacement time history obtained from the pulse transducer. The deviation of the integration curve is probably due to the integration process. The two other curves separate after about 18 ms which is the moment when the striker hits the shock absorbers (see Figure 4).
137
70 60
~ 50 "~ 40 ~
30 20 ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,
~
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
10 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,
0
'
0
20
,
'
'
40
,
'
'
60
'
'
'
80
100
...........
120
140
Deflection (ram)
Figure 5. Load-deflection curves from the quasi-static tests.
Figure 6. Beam #2 during dynamic loading. Time intervals: 0.6, 20, 30 and 50 ms respectively after beginning of deflection.
138 200 ....................,
180
' ..~. ~.--- "; . . . . . . , . .
160 "~ 140 U 120
......
,. . . . . .
I, " ~ r
,
,
0.03
0.04
I - - - - P u l s e trans.
.2o 11)0 g
8O
4O 20 0
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.06
Time (s)
Figure 7. Beam deflection from pulse transducer, high speed photos and integration of acceleration curves.
4. SUMMARY OF RESULTS The following results were obtained: 1. Registered strain rates were larger in the rebars compared to strain rates in the concrete. Strain rates up to 102 sn in the rebars were obtained. 2. Moment of impact and moment of crack initiation were captured. 3. Registrations of beam velocity and striker velocity were successful. 5.
CONCLUSIONS
The failure process during impact loading is rather complex and difficult to register in detail during the short event. In the tests several techniques were used and the experiences from using a high speed film camera and contact-free sensors, accelerometers and strain gauges are reported. As a conclusion the used techniques were applicable for the purpose of the investigation. The displacement history was also estimated from integration of the acceleration history. More efforts could be made to increase the accuracy of this technique. REFERENCES
1. L. Ag~dh, J. Magnusson and H. Hansson, "High Strength Concrete Beams Subjected to Impact Loading. An Experimental Study", FOA-R--99-01187-311--SE, Defence Research Establishment, Stockholm August 1999. 2. L. Ag~dh and L. Laine, "Experiments and FE-modelling of fibre reinforced concrete beams exposed to impact", Proceedings of the 2nd Asian Pacific Conference on Shock and Impact Loads on Structures, Melbourne, pp. 1-8. Nov. 1997. CI-Premier Conference Organisation, Singapore. 3. G. Hughes and D. M. Speirs: "An Investigation of the Beam Impact Problem", C&CA Technical Report No 546, London 1982.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
139
Impact response of a laminated cylindrical composite shell panel Puneet Mahajan, K.S.Krishnamurthy, R.K.Mittal Applied Mechanics Department, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, India The response of a laminated cylindrical composite shell panel subjected to impact by a spherical object is analysed using the finite element method. The evolution of the resulting damage in the composite has also been studied. The effects of various problem parameters such as impaetor mass, velocity, shell curvature, thickness, ply stacking on contact force and response are examined. Hertz's contact law is used to calculate the contact force between the impacting mass and the shell. Damage in the form of matrix cracking due to transverse shear or bending and subsequent delaminations are predicted using appropriate failure criteria. The stiffness matrix is modified during each time step to take account of this damage.
1. INTRODUCTION Predicting impact induced damage in fibre reinforced composite laminates has been a topic of intense research due to their "vulnerability to damage in impact, which adversely affects the overall strength and stiffness of the laminate. Accidental dropping of tools or other metallic objects on the surface of the laminates may cause such impact. Often the damage in the form of matrix cracks and delaminatic~ns may be difficult to detect by the naked eye since the damage can be wholly era.bedded within the thickness of the laminate. During an impact a high contact pressure develops within a small area of contact producing high stress concentrations. The study of impact and impact induced damage in composite laminates has been approached by various researchers through experimental, analytical, and numerical techniques. A review by Abrate [1 ] contains a large bibliography on the subject of impact on composites. While experimental methods are indispensable for direct observation, they are inconvenient for parametric studies. Analytical methods though providing deeper insight into the physics of the problem suffer from the drawback in not being able to predict damage. Finite element method is better suited to simulate the physical phenomenon such as damage initiation and propagation through use of appropriate failure criteria can be modelled. A number of researchers have deployed the finite element method for the solution of impact on laminated composite but literature on impact of laminated shells is sparse [2-8]. Chandrasbekara and Sehroder[7] have shown results for a 0/90/90/0 shell using the finite element method with a non-linear shell theory. The authors have used the contact law for loading and unloading given by Tan and Sun [2 ]. In general the analysis of impact and predicting impact induced damage by means of finite element method involves the following steps: a) Determining the contact force between impacting mass and the shell as a function of time. This contact force cannot be determined explicitly as it depends on the relative approach, ix, of the two contacting bodies.
140 b) Applying the contact force to find the transient dynamic response of the impacted structure as a function of position and time (displacements, strains, stresses, etc.) which depends on the mass and velocity of the impactor and the laminate characteristics (geometry, boundary conditions, ply arrangement, elastic properties, etc.). c) Predicting damage in the laminate using appropriate stress failure criteria. 2. METHODOLOGY The equations of dynamic equilibrium in matrix form obtained through the finite element procedure for the shell is given by
[M]{/}+ [~:]{d}: {F}
wh~r~ {F}: [o,...O,F~,O,....o] ~
O)
Here [M] is the mass matrix, [K], the stiffness matrix, {d}, the vector of nodal displacements of the shell, {F} is the force vector, and Fc is the contact force between the shell and the impactor. The force Fc is a distributed force but since the contact area is very small it is assumed as a point load. Applying Hamilton's principle to a rigid impactor results in the following equation of motion:
,,,~, : - F ,
(2) where mi and wi are the impactor mass and acceleration respectively. The initial displacement and velocity of the impactor are wi =0 and ~vi =v0. In order to solve equations (1) and (2) above, the contact force b~tween the laminated shell and the impactor must be known. It is assumed that Hertz's contact law is applicable to the loading phase and the expression given by Tan and Sun[2] can be used for the unloading phase
i.e., f = k a 312
for loading
and
r
)
f = f~ a - a,,,,, t a . -~Zo
for unloading
O)
Here o ~ = wi(t)-ws(t) is the depth of indentation, wi and ws are the displacements of the impactor and displacement of the point on the mid-surface of the shell below the point of contact, am is the indentation when force reaches the maximum value fm and a0 is a constant. The expression for k is
=
+_--
/.
E,
+
(4)
Here, ri, Vi, and F.,i are the radius, the Poisson's ratio, and the foung's modulus of the impactor. E2 is the modulus of elasticity transverse to the fibre direction in the uppermost layer of the composite laminate. The displacement of impactor at time step n+l is determined by Newmark's integration scheme for the differential equation (2), as
r
~,
r ,,t2 ]~ ~
(w,).+,: (w,). +,,,(,,). + t.Tj~w,). -t~J"
~"+'
(5)
141 This expression for displacement of the impactor is substituted into (3), yielding, for the time step n+l,
(Fc).+ ,
=k[q-(w.).+,- fl(F~).+,]
'5
for the loading phase
(Fc )n+ ! -" ki [q - (Ws )n+ 1 - i~(Fc )n+ 1 -/2'0] 2"5
(6)
for the unloading phase.
In these equations , , 8 = At ~ / 4m i and
q = (w,). + A t ( w i ) . + (At 214)(w~).
k, = F . / ( a m - Cto~ 5
(7)
The above equations for the contact force are solved by means of the Newton-Raphson root finding algorithm in conjunction with the solution for the dynamic response of the shell. Since the expression for Fr contains Ws which is not known at the beginning of any time step an iterative solution procedure has to be used. Starting with an aoproximate value of Fe, Ws is found from equation(I). With this value of Ws, Fe is recomputed using (6). The process is repeated till the required accuracy is achieved. Only 3 to 4 iterations were required for convergence. The contact force is now used to calculate acceleration, velocity and displacement of the impactor and applied on the shell for the next time step. The computer program for the dynamic analysis of shells by Hwang[8] deploying the 9 noded isoparametric shell element of Abroad which has 5 degrees of freedom at each node has been modified to work for the impact loading case. 3. IMPACT INDUCED DAMAGE Impact induced failure mechanisms are complex ;,~d predicting and relating the extent of damage with the problem parameters has been attempted by the finite element procedure notably by Choi and Chang[3,4]. The authors have given two failure criteria, one for matrix cracking and another ibr delamination failure. They have also suggested empirical constants, based on impact experiments on composite plates, to modify these failure criteria. It is assumed that these failure criteria are applicable to laminated composite shells as well. The criteria are: a) Matrix cracking criterion:
t,"r)
+
t,"s,J
e u >_ 1
= eM
Failure,
e M <_ 1
NoFailure
(8) if o n' > 0,
"Y="Yt
"Y="Yt
if o n" > 0
b) Delamination criterion Oa
El-.// n S rz ,
2
+
n + 1~..XZ ,, +l S i
n
e D
"+'Y="+iYt
/
2> - 1
+
n +I'~FY yy''
Failure,
if o'rr > 0,
-. e D
en
2
2
< 1
"+'g="+iYc
(9) No Failure if O'rr < 0
142 Details of these two formulae are given in [8]. Whenever the average stresses in any of the plies in a laminate first satisfies the criterion (eM>l) during impact, initial impact damage is predicted. It is assumed that the crack would propagate throughout the thickness of the ply group that contained the cracked ply and initiate delamination at the interfaces with the adjacent ply groups. The two failure criteria are applied at all the points where stresses have been computed in every time step. In order to modify the stiffnesses of the failed laminas, a reduced compliance matrix is used post-failure analysis. The reduced compliance matrix has, along its diagonal, Ex, Ez, Gxz, and Gxy as the only non-zero elements of the matrix. This matrix has been currently incorporated into the computer program with modifications to account for the reduced degrees of freedom. 4. RESULTS The problem solved is a 4-layered Graphite/Epoxy 0/90/90/0 symmetrical laminated composite cylindrical shell panel clamped on all four edges with the following properties: Chord length a=b= 0.254m, thickness = 2.54x10-3 m. The elastic properties of a lamina are: E1=144.8GPa, E2= 9.65GPa, G12 = 7.10 GPa, G~3 = 7.10 GPa, G23 = 5.92 GPa v:2 = 0.30, p= 1389.2 kg/m 3, c~0= 8.03 x 10-2 mm. The composite strengths are as given in [8]. The impactor is a sphere of diameter, 12.7ram and its weight is 0.08 kg. A time step of 9.5 x l 0 .7 sec has been used. 4.1. Parametric studies The effect of impactor's mass and velocity, and the curvature of the shell on the contact force history and the resulting damage( the extent of damage was noted by the number of points where matrix cracking and delaminations occurred, not shown in this paper) were obtained by varying a) the mass by a multiplying factor, keeping the curvature and velocity constant. b) The velocity at 10,20, and 30 m/see c) The curvature by varying the ratio of radius to chord length(a=b) as R/a=5,10,100 d) The ply orientation. The results are depicted in figures 2 to 5. From Fig. 2 , it appears that increase in mass leads to longer contact duration before the first separation of the impactor and the shell. The number points where matrix cracking and delamination occurred increased significantly due to input of larger amount of energy. Matrix cracking failure occurred mostly in the ply furthest from impact location and delamination at a number of points between this and next upper ply. The maximum contact force does not however proportionately increase with the increase in mass. This may be because the shell deflection has also increased which in turn reduced the increase in the approach of the two masses. Figure 3 hows the effect of the curvature on the contact force -time history for a selected mass and velocity. It appears curvature has less influence on the contact force-time in as far as the maximum contact force is concerned. The displacements experienced by the shell are however different. The extent of damage also increased with the decrease of curvature. The decrease in curvature has made the structure more flexible thereby increasing bending strains leading to higher damage in the form of matrix cracking in the layer at the bottom of lamina-stacking. The effect of velocity had on
143
/'1 ~llll
~,::Orr
Fig. 1. Composite shell geometry and impactor. R2 =oo
1250 ,
-.--- .
1000
3 x imp. mass 2 x imp. mass 1 x imp. mass
2oool ~
750 5OO
1000(,
25O 0
IrrTL velocity = 30 m/sec, Irrp. velodty = 20 nYsec, Imp. velocity =10 nYsec
m
400
0
6oo
800
looo
TIME ( X 9.5 E-07 SECONDS ) Figure 2. Effect of impa~or's mass on contar force
2000
. . . . .
2O0
c -;
400
..................
1
= R/a=10 = Rla=100 ~ Rla=5
A
TllVE(Xg.SE~7~) Rgure 3. Effect of irrpactor's velocity on contact force
2000~
1500
nl90190/0 0145145/0
1500
1000
1000
500
0
0 0
500
_ ~
0
-
'
' 200
400
600
800
1000
TIME ( X 9.5E-07 SECONDS ) F i g u r e 4. E f f e c t o f c u r v a t u r e o f s h e l l o n c o n t a c t f o r c e
0
200
400
600
800
1000
TIME( X 9.5 E-07 SECONDS) F i g u r e 5. E f f e c t of p l y o r i e n t a t i o n o n c o n t a c t f o r c e
144 maximum contact force is shown in Fig. 4. To study the effect of ply orientations, the inner two plies were changed to 450 angle with respect to the outer plies and the results are shown Fig. 5. The number of points where matrix cracking failure occurred increased from 4 to 10 at the bottom most ply. This may be due to the fact that the bending stiffness is lower for laminate with 450 plies. 4.2. Other observations
The contact law implementation poses some problem since its difficult to decide when loading ends and unloading begins. We have assumed that a switch over from loading to unloading takes place as soon as the contact force begins to fall for a short time, i.e. local peaks in force time diagram have not been ignored. Different results will be obtained if loading law is used, ignoring the local peaks, till the maximum value is reached. 5. CONCLUSIONS A finite element code to model dynamic behaviour and subsequent damage of a composite shell subject to impact loading is successfully implemented. The stiffness of the failed laminas is modified to account for their lack of contributions in appropriate directions in each time step during impact. It is shown that the degenerated shell element provides sufficient accuracy for use in impact-damage analysis. Parametric studies involving the effect of mass, curvature, ply orientations, etc. on the impact response has been shown. REFERENCES
1. S. Abrate, Impact On Composite Structures, Cambridge University Press, NY, 1998. 2. T.M. Tan and C.T. Sun, J. App. Mech 52, 6-12 (1985). 3. Choi and Chang, J. Composite Materials, 25(1991), 992. 4. Choi and Chang, J. Composite Materials, 26(1992), 2134. 5. R.L. Ramkumar, and Y.R. Thakur, J. Engg. Mat. & Tech., 109 (1987). 6. Christoforou A.P. and Swanson S.R., J. App. Mech, 27(1990) 376. 7. K. Chandrashekara and T. Schroeder, J. Composite Materials, 29(1995).2160. 8. H.C. Hwang, Static and Dynamic Analysis of Plates and Shells, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1989.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
145
Dynamic testing of energy absorber system for aircraft arrester K.K. Malik, P IK. Khosla, P.H. Pande and R.K. Verma Terminal Ballistics Research Laboratory, Ministry of Defence, Sector- 30, Chandigarh- 160020, India
Energy absorber is the heart of an aircraft arrester barrier system and is mainly responsible for absorption of the kinetic energy of the trapped aircraft. An innovative methodology has been used to test the rotary energy absorber system independently by simulating the dynamic conditions of sudden loading. A special assembly and rocket motors were used to generate the desired rotary motion. The performance evaluation of the energy absorber under dynamic conditions was observed and related parameters were monitored. The details of conducting tests and their results are presented in this paper.
1. INTRODUCTION An aircraft arrester barrier system is used to engage a fighter aircraft to halt its forward momentum in the event of an aborted take off or landing overrun with minimal damage to the aircraft or injury to the crew. It consists of an engagement system comprising of multiple element net (MEN) to envelop the aircraft during its arrestment, stanchion system to provide support and remote controlled operation for erecting and lowering the MEN assembly, purchase tape and the energy absorbing unit. The momentum of an engaging aircraft is diluted through various other mechanisms such as net engagement, stretching of nylon tape, friction of tyres of aircraft and air drag on it. Yet, the rotary energy absorber device (READ) gradually absorbs the major portion of the kinetic energy of an aircraft during the run out distance. The connection of the READ with the net is made by means of nylon tape. One end of the tape is attached to the net through a tape connector while the other end is wound on the tape drum of the energy absorber. The rotary energy absorber device is tints the heart of an aircraft arrester barrier system, which is mainly responsible for absorption of the kinetic energy of the trapped aircraft. Hence the READ is designed to sustain the sudden loading [2].
2. ENERGY ABSORBER SYSTEM DETAILS The energy absorber is a turbine type rotary hydraulic device causing fluid turbulence, used for absorbing the kinetic energy of the aircraft. It consists of a tape drum and vaned rotor, both splined to a vertical common shaft. The shaft of the rotor is supported by two
146 bearings, one mounted in the housing cover and the other in the bottom of the energy absorbing device. The rotor, which produces fluid turbulence, has nine tapered radial vanes on top and bottom surfaces. The tapered stator vanes are welded to the bottom side of the energy absorber housing cover. There are identically tapered stator vanes welded to the bottom of the housing. These static vanes contribute to impart resisting torque to the rotating shaft. An aircraft, having engaged the MEN, exerts a pull on the nylon tape, which is spiral wrapped on to the tape drum. As the tape drum and the rotor in each energy absorber are connected to the vertical rotor shaft, the tape drum and the rotor rotate as a unit. The waterethylene glycol mixture in the housing is agitated due to the rotation and interaction between the rotor vanes. The kinetic energy of the aircraft is thereby absorbed by the fluid
inside the housing by the work done against the resisting torque of the vane system. During the process of development of the energy absorber, it is mandatory to subject it to the dynamic testing to establish the strength and integrity of its various components against sudden loading. The design requirement of the READ is that it should provide the retarding force to absorb aircraft energy with in 275 m runout distance without any failure. For the performance evaluation of such a system, ideal testing would be to engage an aircraft with specific mass and speed but considering the safety aspects of pilot and aircraft, it would not be possible to perform such test. The alternate approach is to
simulate the conditions of sudden d),tutmic loading on the energy absorber.
3. PEAK FORCE CALCULATIONS During the dynamic test of energy absorber, peak force on the READ was simulated. The theoretical estimation shows that the total torque produced by the set of nine rotor vanes is 9.18 r where co is the rotational speed in rad/sec [1].The rotor can be rotated at the maximum angular velocity achieved during the aircraft engagrnent.The quick angular speed on the energy absorber was achieved by fixing two supporting arms, mutually perpendicular, on the rotor flange and rotating them with the help of suitable number of rocket motors, fixed at ends of each arm. Tmax = 9.18 o2,
where m is angular speed.
(1)
Under the extreme conditions of loading, when an aireratt of maximum mass 30,000 kg engages the system at speed of 275 kmph and with run out distance 275 m, the value of is about 104 rad/sec. Thus for the extreme loading conditions, Thrust required =
9.18 x 104 x 104 = 99291 Nm
Since two rotating couples, mutually perpendicular were planned, the thrust required per couple is 49645.5 Nm. For an arm length of 4 m, force required is 12411 N. Considering rocket motors with an effective thrust of 4120 N, three rocket motors were found adequate at each arm.
147 When the energy absorber system is subjected to rotations, each rocket motor experiences considerable amount of the centrifugal tbrce. This force also needs to be considered while designing the fixture tbr generating torque. Centrifugal tbrce = m r ~:
(2)
The rocket motors with mass 3.0 kg each were used for the test. Thus for radius of 2 m, each rocket motor experienced centrifugal force of 64896 Nm. 4. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE The energy absorber was mounted on a specially laid RCC foundation to sustain the thrust generated due to the ignition of rockets. Figure 1 shows the lowering of the energy absorber in the central cavity of the RCC foundation and Figure 2 is the view of READ fixed with the foundation bolts. The four arms, spaced at 90 ~, were attached to the lower and upper flanges of the rotor to fix the rocket motors. The rocket motors with an effective thrust of 4120 N and burning time of 0.7 sec, were used. The fixtures were designed to withstand the centrifugal forces and the bending forces [3]. Ethylene glycol and water mixture in 6 0 40 ratio was filled in the housing. A temperature sensing element with its digital readout recorded the rise in fluid temperature during the experiment.
Figure 1. The energy absorber being lowered in the cavity of the RCC foundation.
148
Figure 2. View of rotary energy absorber device with pickup coils mounted on the RCC foundation. The energy absorber with the torque generating arms and rocket motors mounted at their ends has been shown in Figure 3. The rotational speed of the rotor of the energy absorber was measured using a magnet mounted on the lower flange and three pick up coils fixed on the foundation, 120 ~ apart. Each time the magnet crossed the coils, a pulse was generated and recorded on a digital storage oscilloscope. A safety enclosure of RCC blocks was erected around the test site. The 'test results have been shown in the Table 1. Table 1. Test results
S.No.
No. of Rockets
Max. RPM
Time taken to Max. RPM (see)
Torque (kN-m)
1.
2
70
......
16.0
2.
8
300
......
64.0
3.
16
492
0.840
128.0
4.
16
491
0.776
128.0
5.
16
488
0.433
128.0
149
Figure 3. Rotary energy absorber device with fixtures for mounting rocket motors.
5. OBSERVATIONS
The energy absorber was subjected to dynamic testing by varying number of rocket motors. The system withstood these tests successfully without any sign of damage or distortions. Though the energy absorber was designed to sustain the dynamic loading of 99.3 kN-m, it could withstand higher thrust of 128.0 kN-m. A temperature rise of 3~ C was recorded inside the fluid. The time taken by the READ from ignition of rockets to the halt was of the order of 65 sec. It included the burning time of 0.7 sec. for the rocket and remaining 64.3 sec. as non-bum time. This time is quite high because towards the end, rotor keeps rotating without much of resistance on the vanes. The RPM recorded and achieved were not quite proportional to the thrust employed. This was attributed to the reduction of thrust of rocket motor due to the air drag on the fixture arms.
6. CONCLUSIONS This method of dynamic testing of energy absorber provides a very reliable and cost effective mechanism to simulate the conditions under which strength and integrity of various parts of the energy absorber system can be tested. Whereas, the major portion of the energy imparted to the system, due to ignition of the rockets, was absorbed by the fluid turbulence inside the chambers of the energy absorber, a portion of it was absorbed due to the air drag on the torque generating arms. Contrast to the time of rotation taken by the energy absorber rotor, in the actual situation it rotates till the whole length of the nylon tape has been pulled out by the engaged aircraft. The energy absorber withstood all the dynamic forces successfully.
150 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors express their thanks to Sh. V.S. Sethi, Director TBRL for his encouragement and kind permission to publish the present paper. The guidance and help rendered by Dr. S.K. Vasudeva is highly acknowledged. The authors also expresses their thanks to Sh. Neeraj Srivastav and Sh. A.K. Tewari for their co-operation in carrying out the experimental trials. REFERENCES [1]
J.R.N. Reddy and A.S. Reddy, "Theoretical Studies and Model Testing of Rotatory Energy Absorbing Device", ADE report No. ADE/Tr/90-86 (a), Jan 1990.
[2]
A.S. Reddy, "Integrated Design of Rotatory Energy Absorbing Device for Launcher", Proceeding of National Conference on Design Engineering.
[3]
N. Jones and J.G. Oliveira, "Dynamic Plastic Response of Circular Plates with Transverse Shear and Rotatory Inertia". J. Applied Mechanics (1980).
[4]
N. Jones and J.G. Oliveira, "The Influence of Rotatory Inertia and Transverse Shear on Dynamic Plastic behavior of Beams". J. Applied Mechanics (1979).
[5]
Stephen Timoshenko, "Strength of Materials". Part I.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
151
Characteristics of Crater Formed under Ultra-High Velocity Impact S.Pazhanivel*, V.K. Sharma Terminal Ballistics Researh Laboratory, Sector-30, Chandigarh -160 020, India. The impact of an ultra-high velocity projectile onto a target produces a shock wave that propagates into both the projectile and the target. Depending upon the amplitude of shock energy the projectile and the target undergo various processes like solid state phase change, melting, vaporisation and explosion. In this paper an attempt has been made to describe the target damage under Ultra-High Velocity Impact (UHVI) conditions. 1. INTRODUCTION Under UHVI, the portions of projectile and the target subjected to the impact energy can melt or vaporise if the fusion or sublimation energies of material exceed. However, the amount of projectile and target that experiences the impact pressure is limited by isentropicpressure release waves that emanate from the free surface of the materials. Thus, target damage under UHVI conditions may involve besides extensive plastic deformation appreciable target vaporisation leading to explosion. In this paper the method of calculating the threshold conditions using semi- empirical equations of state for impact explosion of metals has been discussed and an effort has been made to quantify the crater diameter created by impact explosion of metals. 2. CRITICAL PRESSURE FOR EXPLOSION OF METALS Whenever the initial heating i.e. by work of compression plus shock heating reaches the critical level (heat of sublimation of metal) the metal will explode. The heat of sublimation evidently provides a measure of cohesive energy of substance, since it is the work required to separate the substance into its components of atoms or molecules and place these at infinite distance from one another. Therefore, the critical pressure for explosion metals ' P m ' is given by Pm - 6p/IV[
(1)
as described by M.A.Cook [ 1] Where, c -Cohesive energy of metal p - Density of metal M - Atomic weight of metal Therefore, the threshold compression ratio (x = p/po) for impact explosion of metals have been calculated from Pm= (a~)q(x'/a- In(x) - aq) + cpok(x-l)3/x3
(2)
152 Where, a & k - Metal constants 13- Compressibility of metal at atmosphere pressure po- initial density of metal e- Specific heat of metal x - Compression ratio (p/po) 3. SHOCK WAVE COMPRESSION OF METALS In specifying the thermodynamic state of shocked metals, usually the pressure 'P" and change in internal energy (E-Eo), are specified as a function of the volume compression Xl = (Vo-V)/Vo The measurements of shock front and the shock particle velocities ~ ' and 'u', show that for various strength shocks 'U' and 'u' can be related by the equation for a wide range of values of ' u ' U - - c + su
(3)
Under these conditions, it can be shown immediately from the Rankine-Hugoniot relations that the pressure 'P' generated in a shock of compression 'x~' is c 2 x1
P=
(4) V o (1-SXl) 2
as described by G.B.Benedek [2]. Where, Vo -Specific volume of unshoeked metal & V-Specific volume of shocked metal The increase in internal energy (E-Eo) produced by a compression 'xl' is given by 89c2xl 2 E-Eo =
(5) (1-sxl)2
4. SEMI-EMPERICAL EQUATION OF STATE The theoretical description of hypervelocity impact requires Equation Of State (EOS) that covers a wide range of pressure and temperature Because direct measurements of the EOS are difficult to obtain over much of this range, it is desirable to develop models that do not require extensive experimental data for their calibration In this work a theoretical model has been developed by taking recourse to semi-empirical equation of state to describe the physical phenomenon that usually occurs during UHVI conditions This method also takes into account the elastic interaction of the crystal lattice, thermal vibration of atomic lattice and thermal excitation of electrons, which can not be neglected in any ease for high pressures and temperatures applications The EOS & change in internal energy in additive form A V Bushman et al[3] and L VAI' Tshuler et al[4] P = P.+P,+ Pc E - E o - F~+E, +Ec
are given, as discussed by
153 4.1 Pm E ~ - the heat portion of internal energy, which is the oscillation energy of the particles (atoms) around their equilibrium, position. Heat required for the vaporisation of metals at atmosphere pressure is calculated from QA = C (Tv-To)
(6)
The effect of pressure upon the transformation temperature depends upon the sign of (AV) volume change and enthalpy change (AH). In vaporisation process, the heat of vaporisation is always positive but the volume change may positive or negative. For metallic components crystallising in the close-packed structure, the volume change is positive and so the vaporisation point is increased upon increase in pressure. The increase in vaporisation temperature for a growth pressure 'P' is calculated by (T-TO = Tv (AV) (AP)/L
(7)
Where,
T - Vaporisation temperature of metal under the impact pressure(P) "Iv- Vaporisation temperature at atmosphere pressuregPo) L- Latent heat of sublimation AP -- P-Pc Therefore, when metal subjected to pressure, the heat required ( ~ ) to vaporise the metal is calculated from Pn = 71( c / V ) (T-To+Eo/c)
(s)
En- c (T-To)
(9)
Where, 7r Gruneisen coefficient for lattice To- Initial temperature of metal Eo- Internal energy under normal conditions c- Specific heat of metal 4.2. Pe, Ee are the terms due to thermal excitations of the electrons. By making use of the concept of electronic specific heat coefficient 'b', the pressure and energy can be written as Pe = (1/4) bpo (Vo/V)~ T z
(10)
Ee = (1/2) b (V/Vo)~ T 2
(11)
Where, b- Electronic specific heat coefficient 4.3. P,, Er - are the terms characterising the interactions of atoms at T=0~ represented by a series expansion in the power of the interatomic distance rc~d 1/3
Pc is
154 5 Pc = ~ ai d ]+v3 i=l 5 Ec= 3 V o t e a~/i(d ~a-1) i=l
(12)
(13)
Where, ai - determined from the experimental values of compressibility d = VodN'; Voc- Specific volume at P = 0 & T = 0~ 5. IMPACT VELOCITY The threshold impact velocity for explosion of metals has been calculated from P = poUu
(14)
(ptst- ppSp) ut2 + (ptet + ppep + 2ppspVO ut- (pp%Vl + ppspVi2 ) = 0
(15)
In this equation subscript 't', 'p' represents target and projectile respectively Where, V r Impact velocity of projectile & U-Shock velocity u- particle velocity Solving Equation (15) V~ can be found out. 6. EXPERIMENTATION An experimental study has been carried out to evaluate the effect of impact explosion of metals An aluminium jet (projectile) having tip velocity of 12500 m/sec formed from hollow charge was fired on 20mm thick Rolled Homogeneous Armour(RHA) target Upon the impact, the explosion of aluminum projectile was observed The explosion of projectile resulted to create larger crater diameter than the crater created by normal penetrator (without explosion) on RHA target. The quantitative analysis of crater diameter created by impact e3q~losionvis-a-vis normal penetrator impact is presented in table I. 7. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Threshold conditions for impact explosion of metals (impact pressure 'P', impact veloeityVi, compression ratio 'x') have been calculated by this model and threshold conditions for different metal combinations (aluminium-RoUed Homogeneous Armour; aluminium-aluminium) are presented in the table 2. Experiment conducted (using aluminium projectile and RHA target) has shown the effect of explosion of metal on crater diameter created on the target. The threshold conditions for explosion of metals calculated by the present method has been compared with the other methods in table 3 & 4 and the calculated values are matching with the experimental observations.. The effect of pressure on the vaporisation temperature has been studied. The increase in vaporisation temperatures for the pressures of 219GPA in aluminium and 764Gpa in RHA are 8203~ and 18494~ respectively. The role of heat in the internal energy balance is larger, in the ease of aluminiun and RHA for the above pressures, the thermal energy has become major fraction, amounting to 61% & 70% respectively.
155 Table I 9 Comparison Of Crater Diameter Created By Impact Explosion & Normal Penetrator Impact(without explosion) Projectile
Target
VI (m/see)
Crater diameter assuming no explosion of metals take place . . . . . (mm)
Crater diameter created by Impact explosion (mm)
Al
RHA
12500
56
70
Table 2 : Threshold Conditions For Impact Explosion Of Target Metals Projectile
Target
x=p/po
Al
Al
11818
~ - ~ | ~
Vl (m/sec) 12100
~
~A
E-Eo (MJ/gg) 18.02
4'1
T(~
P (Opa) 219
10450
~ [;~|O]ii~lii
Table 3 9 Comparison Of Energy Required (E-Eo) for Impact Explosion of metals Calculated By The Author With Shockey's Results [5] Metal
.....Author calculation Energy required for explosion metal upon impact (E-Eo) MJ/Kg
.... Shoekey's Results
""AI
Energy caieulated for explosion of metal (QA) MJ/Kg 3.0
Energy required"for explosion of metal upon impact (E-Eo) MJ/K 8 1 5 . 1 5 - 18.12
Iron
2.4
12.00- 24.00
,,
18.02 22.32 ......
Table 4 : Comparison of Threshold conditions (x, Vl) for explosion of metals calculated by the present method with M.A.Cook's method
Projectile .... Target Steel Steel .
.
......
.
AI Iron .
.
M.A.Cook x ....... 1.79 1.79 .
.
.
.
.... VI 13.3 14.70 .
.
"
.
Present method x 1.8:2 1.85 .
.
.
V~ 9.52 12.70
156 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors sincerely express their gratitude to Mr. V S Sethi, Director TBRL for his keen interest and kind permission to publish this work. REFERENCES 1. Melvin A. Cook, "Mechanism Of Cratering In Ultra-High Velocity Impact",pp 725735,Volume 30,Number 5, Journal Of Applied Physics, May, 1959. 2. G.B.Benedek, '~l'he temperature of shock waves in solids",Gordon Mckay Loboratory, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 3. A.V.Bushman, G.I.Kanel', A.L.Ni, V.E.Fortov, "'Intense Dynamic Loading Of Condensed Matter", 1993 Taylor & Francis. 4. L.V.AL' Tshuler, S.B.Kormer, A.A.Bakanova, and R.F.Trunin, "Equation Of State For Aluminum, Copper, and ~ in The High Pressure Re, on", pp. 573-579,Volume 11, Number 3,Soviet Physics JET P, September 1960. 5. D.A. Shockey, D.R. Curran, J.E. Osher and H.H. Chau, "Disintegration Behaviour Of Metal Rods Subjected to Hypervelocity Impact", Int. J. Impact Engg. Vol.5, pp.585593,1987.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
157
Diagnostic techniques for high speed events V.S. Sethi and S.S, Sachdeva
Terminal Ballistics Research Laboratory, Sector 30 Chandigarh- 160020, India Email : root@/lrtbrl.ren, nic. in
The transient events occurring as a result of an explosion are of very short duration~ The measurement of these events require -very accurate and sophisticated instruments having resolution times of the order of fractions of a microsecond or a few nanoseconds. The paper discusses various diagnostic techniques available at TBRL, Chandigarh for studying the salient features of explosion-target interaction The high speed instnnnentation techniques, such as Pin Oscillographic, Fiber optics , Air and Underwater blast, Medium speed photography, Ultra high speed photography and Flash radiography, for measurement of fast events have been described.
1. INTRODUCTION The detonation of an explosive charge converts the original material into gaseous products at very high temperature and pressure. The conversion takes place at a very high speed resulting in the release of high energy. High speed instruments are required for determining the characteristics of detonation and shock waves, the dynamic behavior of structures under intense blast loading and projectile-target interaction involving high strains and large deformations. Various diagnostic methods are employed to record the events occurring at very high speed. In electrical methods, the oscillographic technique is widely used to study the detonation process in explosives, to measure shock Hugoniot parameters in condensed materials and to determine the shape of the detonation wave. In optical methods, fibre optical cables are used to carry the fight signals to recording equipment. In ultra high-speed photography, streak and flaming cameras are used to photograph the transient events. Streak cameras give a continuous record of the event in space and time coordinates whereas framing camera takes discrete photographs. For the flash radiography technique, hard x-rays are used to get the radiographs of the dynamic events at different instants of time or at desired positions in space. The blast associated with the explosion causes damage to structures and installations and is characterized by blast parameters. Free air blast, under ground blast and under water blast are different branches of blast studies where damage criteria is different in each case. A brief description of these techniques with their applications is discussed subsequently. 2. PIN OSCILLOGRAPHIC TECHNIQUE (POT) As the name suggests, in this technique pins of electrical contactor are used as sensors and a high-speed oscilloscope is used as recording equipment. These electrical contactors are in open circuit connected to an R-C network. On arrival of the high an~litude pressure wave, the contactors get closed and R-C network generate very short duration pulses. Each pulse corresponds to the position of respective pin probe. Knowing the distance between two probes
158 and measuring the corresponding time accurately gives the velocity. The following types of studies have been carried out using this technique. 2.1 Determination of velocity of detonation (VOD) and shock Hugoniots Pin probes made up of copper enamelled wire are put at different positions in a cylindrical charge which is simultaneously initiated by a plane wave generator (PWG). By measuring VOD, the other parameters of the explosive can be calculated using the following relations: Pcj = po D 2/(T+ 1) Up-"D/(T+ 1) p = po (T+I)/T C=TD/(T+I) Q = D 2/2(r 1)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Where Pcj is the detonation pressure corresponding to detonation velocity D, p and po are the densities behind the detonation front and undetonated explosive, respectively. U v is the particle velocity of the explosion products, C is the sound velocity and Q the heat of explosion or chemical energy and ~/= C~ Cv, the ratio of the specific heats - a thermodynamic function. Generally T = 3 is taken for explosion products but its exact value for different explosives can be calculated from the equation given by Kamlet and Short [1] as (6)
),- 0.655 / po+ 0.702 + 1.107po
Table 1 gives the velocities of detonation and pressures Pcj for some of the important explosives. Measuring shock and particle velocities and applying jump conditions [2], other Hugoniot parameters of the materials can be determined. 2.2 Wave shaping studies When an explosive is point initiated, the general shape of the detonation front is spherical. This spherical wave can be modified in a plane wave or a converging wave by employing geometry of two explosive components, multi point initiations or interaction of detonation wave with inert materials. The pin oscillographic technique (POT) is used to determine the shape of the emerging detonation front. A plot between the radial distance of the probe vs. arrival time at the corresponding probe determines the shape of the detonation front. Table 1" Velocities of detonation and pressures of different explosives Explosive
Composition %
Cast .........................Velocity Of
T
Pressure
(C v/C0
(Pcj)
Density
Detonation0~)
gm/cc
kin/see
1.61-1.62
6.9
2.89
19.7
G Pa
TNT
100
Composition-B
RDX-60, TNT-40
1.68
7.8
2.95
25.88
Torpex
RDX-41, TNT-41,
1.81
7.6
3.07
25.69
1.85
7.45
3.1
25.04
Al-18 Pentolite
PETN-50, TNT-50
159 2.3 Other applications Shock attenuation studies (i.e. the decay of shock pressure and shock velocity with the increasing tl-Ackness of the material) can be carried out. These studies help in the development of shock attenuators to be used in various armament stores. The technique can also be used to determine the jet velocity and rate of penetration in the shaped charge studies. Generation of very high pressure of the order of megabars can be generated in targets by the impact of a flying plate propelled by explosives. The velocity of the flying plate and the pressure generated can be measured by this technique [3]. 2.4 Development of new instruments for POT * The R-C network, which generates pulses on making close contact of probes, has been replaced by a digital shock velocity recorder developed by TBRL. Each channel of this equipment senses the event at its input terminal and generates a TTL pulse at its output. The system is not prone to noise and thus avoids spurious triggering of the recorder. . A time multiplexing system has been introduced to avoid the use of numerous cables and sequential mixing of events. 9 Programmable computer based digital transient recorders with sampling rates up to 1 nsec have replaced the old high velocity oscilloscopes.
3. FIBRE OPTICS TECHNIQUE This technique has been developed in which light energy is transmitted instead of electrical signals. Thus this technique is safer than electrical methods which involves current and voltages. Moreover, sensors based on the fibre optics principle can be directly embedded in the explosive or distributed at required points over a 3D geometry of the shaped charge warhead or test sample. Fibre optic cables HFBR 3000(100 micron) and HFBR 3500(1000 micron) have been used in fabrication of these pin sensors. The simplest shock sensor has a small air gap ~ 0.1 to 0.2 mm at the terminal point and is created by using very fine steel capillaries. On arrival of the shock wave, air in the gap is ionised and produces intense light due to the shock heat. The streak record of this type of sensor is shown in fig. l(a) which shows intense line of light corresponding to variable width of air gaps. A small quantity of PETN explosive or argon filled microballoon is placed adjacent to the air gap which acts as shock amplifier. This improves the air ionisation and hence the dynamic optical pulse. Figs 1(b) and 1(e) show these sensors with the response recorded on DSO through shock velocity
Fig-1 (a)
Fig" 1(b)
Fig" 1(c)
Fig" l(d)
Fig" 1(e)
160 recorder and photo diode respectively. Fig 1(d) is a record of fixed air gap fibre optic sensor recorded through a photo diode. Fig l(e) shows the record of a multi-gap pipe sensor developed using perspex spacers and air gaps. 4. BLAST AND DAMAGE STUDIES
Blast studies provide vital information for the design and development of warheads. These studies also play a major role in design and construction of blast resistant structures using innovative concepts of shock absorbing techniques and construction materials. The studies are generally divided into two categories namely air blast and underground blast. In air blast the damage to the target is caused by direct blast from the explosion and subsequent reflection from the rigid mirfaees whereas in underground blast, ground shock and vibrations play important role. In this technique measurement of basic data on blast parameters, transmission of blast wave and interaction of blast with different types of structures and other targets are carried out. 4.1 Measurement of blast parameters
Piezoelectric crystal-baseA blast pressure gauges have been developed at TBRL. Blast gauge having a pile of twelve X-cut quartz crystals as sensing elements is used for blast measurement in the intermediate pressure range of 0.1 to 15.0 kg/cm2 .The sensitivity of the gauge is 100 pC/psi. The blast gauge has streamlined design and produce minimum distortion in the blast flow field around the gauge.. The blast parameters i.e. peak over pressure, positive time duration and impulse of the blast wave are determined at different distances and correlated with the damage to strucUnes. 4.2 Under water blast studies
Under water explosion test facility consists of a tank fabricated from 20mm thick mild steel plates. One third of the tank is embedded in the ground to withstand high pressure. Small spherical charges, up to the weight of 50 gins of explosive are used to carry out the experimental measurements. The pressure transducer is positioned at a required depth and predetermined distance from the point of explosion. Piezoelectric quartz crystal gauges developed by TBRL are used to measure pressures upto lkbar and have sensitivity of 1.5 pC/psi. Tourmaline gauges and PCB gauges are used for measurement of higher ranges of pressure. Digital storage Oscilloscope and progranunable digital transient recorders are used to record the pressure time signatures of the shock wave and bubble pressure pulses. Primary shock wave and secondary shock waves are recorded on microseconds and milliseconds time base respectively. Fig. 2(a) and fig. 2(b) show the pressure -time profile of these pressure waves. Shock energy per unit of the primary shock wave [4] at any radial distance R from the explosion can be estimated from
Fig. 2(a). Primary shock wave (~tsec record)
Fig. 2(b). Secondary shocks (msec record)
161 4nR 2 Es = ~ I p2dt W pw Cw
(7)
Similarly the energy in secondary bubble pulses, Eb can be estimated from the time period of the first bubble oscillation [4] Tb = 1.135 p l~ Ebl/3 / ph5/6
(8)
Here P is the pressure, W the charge weight, Cw the velocity of sound in water, I~ the density of water, Ph is the total hydrostatic pressure at the given charge depth. Underwater technique has been used for studying the following phenomenon 9 Comparison of explosive performance in different types of naval warheads can be carried out 9 Heat of detonation of unknown explosives can be determined. Shock energies in the primary and secondary shocks are estimated. 9 Blast parameters i.e. pressure time duration and impulse of under water explosions can be measured at different distances. 9 Effects of venting of explosion products and optimum depth of explosion for formation of primary and secondary shocks are studied. 5. MEDIUM SPEED PHOTOGRAPHY
Medium speed photographic technique is comprised of FASTEX and HIMAC make cameras with a maximum speed of 16000 pps. The technique is used for studying the high strain rates encountered in shock- structure interaction and projectile- target penetration trials. The technique is used to record strain rates of the order of 10 4 per see and the strain time histories of the loaded structures. The response of a scaled down model of a reactor structure
Fig 3(b) Deformed vessel after trial
Fig : 3(d) Strain- time history
162 subjected to simulated loads of a Hypothetical Core Disruptive Accident (HCDA) was studied. A stainless steel 1.25mm thick right circular cylinder of size 430mm x 370mm was subjected to the load of detonation of 25 gm of pentolite charge kept at its centroid in the fully water filled conditions. The cylinder was rigidly fixed at both ends as shown in fig 3(a). Fig 3(b) shows the view of specimen after the trial. The strain time history induced in the cylinder was recorded using FASTEX camera running at a speed of 2880 pps Fig 3(c) shows the shadow-graph of the expanding cylinder and fig 3(d) the strain time profile of the cylinder. 6. ULTRA HIGH SPEED PHOTOGRAPHY
This is versatile technique employed to record transient events lasting for a few microseconds. In ultra high speed photography, two rotating mirror type of cameras are used for the study of explosive dynamics. The streak cameras, models B&W 770 and Cordin 1360S, take one dimensional continuous photographs. The framing camera model B&W 189 takes two dimensional photographs in sequential order. The minimum resolution time of a streak camera is 10 nanosec and inter frame time of framing camera is 0.81asec.
Fig. 4(a) Streak record showing two slopes
Fig. 4(b) Framing record - AI jet
6.1 Applications This technique is widely used in explosive dynamics and detonics studies, shock wave propagation, hyper velocity impact phenomena and determination of jet characteristics in shaped charge warheads. Typical records of streak and framing cameras are shown in fig. 4(a) and fig. 4(b). Records of streak camera show two slopes in time and space coordinates representing the shock and particle velocities recorded for polypropylene. Framing camera photographs show aluminum jet formed by the collapse of cavity in the dynamic loading of the target material. Tip velocity determined from these records is 5.4 kin/see.
7. FLASH RADIOGRAPHIC TECHNIQUE TBRL is equipped with three channel Flexitron model 730 series X-ray system with operating voltage varied from 150 kV to 300 kV at the maximum output current 1400 A thus giving a peak power of 420 MW. X-rays are generated based upon the principle of field emission. The wavelength of the X-rays emitted at 300 kV is of the order of 0.04/~. High intensity X-ray flashes which are emitted for a fraction of microsecond (0.1 ~t sec) capture the high speed events without causing any aberration. A new addition to the facility is Scandiflash model 450S having four channels with pulse width of 25 nanosec. This technique is very helpful to diagnose the events, which are in contact with the explosive and occur for a very
163 short duration i.e. a few microseconds. Events, which are generally surrounded by explosion products and can not be viewed by ultra high-speed photography, are studied by this technique.
7.1 Applications Some of the studies of interest carded out by flash x-ray radiography are as follows: 9 Hollow charge studies: The studies include the collapse of copper liner, determination of collapse angle I$, formation and particulation of jet, tip velocity of the jet, velocity gradient and interaction of the jet with the target. 9 Explosively formed penetrator (EFP~: It is a projectile of metal/alloy which gets forged under shock loading and it can defeat armour at longer distances. The shape, size and velocity of EFP is determined by flash radiographic technique. 9 Expansion of ~agmenting sheU: Smaller size of fragmenting warhead such as shells and grenades etc are studied to see the pattern, direction, shape and size of the
Fig.5 X-ray radiographs showing expansion of 32 mm fragmenting shell fragments. Fig. 5 shows x-ray radiographic records of 32 mm fragmenting shell at different times and the velocity of expansion determined is 770 m/see. * Scabbing phenomem: When a metal plate or target is shock loaded, some chunks of the metal get detached from the free surface and move with sufficient velocity to completely damage the men/material inside the target. Prirnary and secondary effects in the multiple scabs along with their formation criteria are studied. 9 Wound ballistics: Bullets are fired at different velocities and angle of attacks in gelatin gel to correlate with the damage and cavity formation. Other associated phenomena such as tumbling and retardation of the bullet in gelatin gel can also be studied. 9 ~ h e r aoplieations: There are numerous studies that can be thought of but some important to mention are shock wave studies in opaque media, exploding wire and plasma studies, hyper velocity impact studies by the flying plates.
REFERENCES 1. M.J. Kamlet and J.M. Short, Chemistry of Detonations, VI, A rule for Gamma as a criterion for Choice Among Conflicting Detonation Measurements, Comb and Flame, 38, 221(1980) 2. M.H. Rice, R.G. McQueen and J.M.Walsh, Solid State Physics, 6 (1958) 3. H.S. Yadav, P.V. Kamat and S.G. Sundram, Study of an Explosive-Driven Metal Plate, Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechniques 11, 16-22 (1986). 4. R.H.Cole, Underwater Explosions, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 270-285 (1948).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
165
Shock test and stress analysis o f a h e a v y metal-forge Yimin Wu, Bijan Samali, Jianchun Li, and Steve Bakoss Center for Built Infrastructure Research Faculty of Engineering University of Technology, Sydney P.O. Box 123, Broadway, NSW 2007, Australia
In this paper, the stress field of the upper platen of a Metal-forge was analysed using a piezoelectric accelerometer and strain gauges. The total stress of the upper platen consists of two parts. One is pre-stress, caused by the insertion of the hammer pole into the upper platen (insertion joint), and the other being shock stress, caused by the impact of the upper platen against the forge. It was found that the pre-stress caused by the assembly is a major factor in the initiation of cracks. A three-dimensional elastic finite element program was used to analyse strains of the upper platen. The calculated strains are consistent with the measured strains.
1. INTRODUCTION Some cracks were found in the upper platen of a Metal-Forge which had failed. It was important to investigate this problem in order to reduce the possibility of failure in the future. On-line testing and stress analysis were performed to identity the mechanisms responsible for the failure of the upper platen. The maximum shock power of the Metal-Forge was one hundred ton-metre. Its working principle is shown in Figure 1. Steam energy changes into kinetic energy of upper platen through the cylinder. The piston forces the pole and the upper platen to move. Due to their movement in the opposite direction, the upper and lower platens impact against each other when they hit the forge in this process. The upper and lower platens are subject to a very large shock force.
166 Gas cyl"mder
Pole
i
:
Upperplatent ---A/~ ~ " ' f \~ ~ L e v e r ~..~. ~ ~
\~
Handle
Lowerp l a ~"~'1ii~t [ [~l ~~i~iU,__ !: Oil cylinder -a. i . i
Figure 1.A schematic diagram of the working principle of metal-forge machine 2. TEST METHOD In order to understand the stress state of the upper platen, shock acceleration and strain measurement were performed [1]. 2.1 A c c e l e r a t i o n M e a s u r e m e n t
The block diagram for electronic measurement using a piezoelectric accelerometer is shown in Figure 2. Type YD-12 Piezoelectric Accelerometer
Upper Platen HP9000-320C Computer Workstation
L
F
HP 35665A Dynamic Signal I Analyzer
Type YE5852 Conditioning Amplifier ~r TEAC XR-50C Cassette Data Recorder
Figure 2. Block diagram of electronic measurement with piezoelectric accelerometers
167
2.2 S t r a i n M e a s u r e m e n t The block diagram for electronic measurement with strain gauges is given in Figure 3. Upper Platen And Pole
~
Strain Gauges
HP 9000-320C Computer Workstation Figure 3.
-'~
Circuit
~
DPM-600 Dynamic Strain Amplifier TEAC XR-50C Cassette Data Recorder
HP 35665A Dynamic Signal Analyser
Block diagram of electronic measurement with strain gauges
3. T E S T RESULTS The maximum acceleration and velocity of the upper platen (relative to the ground) are given in Table 1. Four tests were conducted. Impact energy of the platen was varied in an ascending order from test one to test four. Tablel Maximum relative acceleration and velocity of the upper platen Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Maximum Acceleration (m/s 2) Maximum Velocity
78.6
165.8
191.0
572.1
1.69
2.22
2.27
2.92
(m/s)
Point 1
B
Figure 4.
Strain gauges distribution on surface A-A of the upper platen.
168
a(m/~;2) (a)
t(mc)
(b) .
....
--
t(~)
(c) .
Figure 5.
.
.
.
.
.
tlmc}
The variation of the acceleration, velocity and displacement of the upper platen with time
The surface stress distribution in the critical section B-B (Figure 4) is shown in Figure 6. The variation of the acceleration, velocity and displacement of the upper platen with time are shown in Figure 5. The stress distribution at the critical sections B-B and C-C (shown in Figure 6) were analysed. The results for Point 1 at cross section B-B are presented in Table 2.
t (sec)
Figure 6.
Strain distribution on the surface of the critical section B-B.
169 Table 2 Measured and calculated results for point one at cross section B-B Acceleration Shock Pre-stress Total stress Calculated (m/s 2) Stress strain ( MPa ) (MPa) ( MPa ) ~c 78.55• 1.44 24.5 25.9 72.19 165.80x2 3.05 24.5 27.5 152.53 191.00• 3.51 24.5 27.9 175.57 391.40• 7.14 24.5 31.6 359.70 572.10• 10.5 24.5 35.0 525.76
Measured strain l.t6 82.06 161.1 180.6 314.6 579.4
4. D I S C U S I O N S The stress in the upper platen of a given forging press was analysed. The total stress in the upper platen consists of two parts, a pre-stress and a shock stress. One can consider that the pre-stress remains unchanged in the platen after assembly and does not vary with time. According to the specification, the calculated pre-stress is 24.5MPa. From Table 2 it can be seen that the shock stress is only a small fraction of the total stress when the acceleration is relatively low. When the measured acceleration reaches its maximum value of 572.10m/s 2, the shock stress is still less than one half of the pre-stress. The analysis reveals that the pre-stress plays a significant role in the creation and growth of cracks and is the key factor to the upper platen damage. A three-dimensional elastic finite element program was used for the analysis. Considering the symmetry of geometry and load, the finite element analysis of the upper platen takes only one quarter of the platen into consideration. This 88 part is divided into 73 elements and there are 526 nodes. For calculations, the twenty-node equal parameter element is adopted. The calculated strains agree well with the measured ones.
5. CONCLUSIONS The measured maximum acceleration and maximum velocity at test four were 572.1 m/s 2 and 2.92 m/s, respectively. Measured strains agree well with those calculated. Among the stress components contributing to total stress, the prestress is the dominant one. The large pre-stress due to imperfect assembly is one of the major causes for the cracking and damage to the upper platen. An improvement of the connection of the upper platen to the pole should be considered to alleviate the problem.
170 REFERENCES
1. 2.
Kenneth G. McConnell, Vibration Testing, Theory and Practice, John Wiley &Sons, Inc, New York, 1995, p. 9. Anil K. Chopra, Dynamics of Structures, Theory and Applications to Earthquake Engineering, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey, 1995.
Blast/Shock Loading
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
173
Air blast simulations using multi-material eulerian/lagrangian techniques John Marco
DSTO, Aeronautical and Maritime Research Laboratory P.O. Box 4331 Melbourne 3001
Numerical finite element techniques are more increasingly being used to simulate air blast scenarios when experimental solutions are not economically possible or could cause safety problems. New techniques have been developed in recent times where by the explosive, air and structure can all be modelled using a combination of multi-materials, Eulerian and Lagrangian methods. An example of this technique using the LSDYNA explicit code will be shown by comparing the results of a field trial on a l m by l m cubic box with the two numerical techniques, the Lagrangian method incorporating externally calculated load curves and the multi-material Eulerian/Lagrangian coupled technique.
1. INTRODUCTION Air blast explosions inside naval warships can cause wide spread and catastrophic damage to the vessel's structure and equipment. Numerical finite element (FE) techniques are increasingly being used to simulate these kinds of loading scenarios when experimental solutions are not economically possible or could cause safety problems. Traditionally, explicit codes using Lagrangian techniques to model the structure and pressure time curves to represent the shock loading have been used. This method provides some insight into the modes of response of the structure, but is limited, in that; the load curves are calculated independent of the response or subsequent failure of the structure. New techniques have been developed in recent times in which the explosive, air and structure can all be modelled using a combination of Multi-Materials, Eulerian and Lagrangian methods. That is, an Eulerian fixed cell system is used to model the air/explosive components and a Lagrangian deformable cell system is used to model the structure. The Lagrangian system is 'coupled' to the Eulerian system within the code packages. The MultiMaterial feature of the code allows more than one material type to be present in an Eulerian cell (ie explosive products and air) and keeps track of each of the volumes for each material during the calculations. The shock wave produced from the explosion interacts with the structure and as it deforms, the pressure loads are redistributed to account for the change in volume and boundary conditions occurring from the resulting deformation of the structure.
174 An example of this technique using the LSDYNA [1] explicit code will be shown by comparing the results of a field trial on a lm by lm cubic box with the two numerical techniques, the Lagrangian method incorporating externally calculated load curves and the multi-material Eulerian/Lagrangian coupled technique. 2. THE FIELD TESTS A series of tests [2] where conducted in which 560 g TNT of explosive charges were placed at the centroid of lm cube steel boxes with 5mm wall thickness, see Figure 1. At the base of each box, a flange 100mm wide and 20mm thick was welded to the structure. The boxes were bolted down onto a concrete platform. Some results from the tests are included in Table 1 showing permanent vertical displacement for three locations on one of the boxes, namely, the centre of a box wall, the centre of an edge between two walls and the comer of the box, see Figure 1 for details. Table 1 Measured and Predicted Values of Vertical Permanent Displacement for an Explosively Deformed Steel Box ~1,2,3j Technique Wall Location (ram) Centre Edge Comer ;rests 118 -25 -6 Lagrangian 140 -42 - 18 Multi-material 115 -25 - 15
Note 1. .
.
FE analysis of permanent deformation values were obtained by extrapolation since simulation times was only 20 ms The centre and edge location values are relative to the comer values, where as, the comer value is relative to its undeformed position A negative value means inward motion whereas, a positive value means outward motion.
3. THE LAGRANGIAN/LOAD CURVE TECHNIQUE This technique models the box structure using one quarter symmetry, see Figure 2. Two dimensional 'shell' elements are used for the box structure and, due to the loading symmetry, fifteen pressure time curves on each one eighth wall panel were used to load all the box walls. These load curves were calculated using the Ray-Tracer program [3]. The code is based upon a source and image technique where an empirical free field explosive source profile is used to compute the pressure time history for the incident wave. At~er detonation of the explosive charge a spherical blast wave is produced which interacts with the nondeforming walls of the structure producing reflected pressure waves. Using a combination of ray tracing techniques to determine a ray path and non linear acoustic addition rules to sum the contribution of all incoming pressure waves at a point, a loading profile was produced for all the fifteen predefined wall locations. The finite element details are shown in Table 2,
175
Edge
Flanged Box
er
Center
Flange Base Figure 1. Box Geometry Charge located at box centroid - 560g TNT
Wall
Fifteen Load Locations
Flange Base
Figure 2. Finite Element Model ~/~Symmetry
176 material properties in Table 3 and the resulting permanent deformation at the three nominated locations are shown in Table 1. 4. THE MULTI-MATERIAL EULERIAN LAGRANGIAN COUPLED TECHNIQUE The multi-material technique models all the components of the scenario, including the box, the explosive and the surrounding air, see Figure 3. Finite element parameters are detailed in Table 2, material properties in Table 3 and the magnitude of the deformation responses for three locations are detailed in Table 1. This technique employs an Eulerian grid system (ie fixed) to model the air and explosive materials. Upon detonation of the explosive, a shock wave propagates into the surrounding air cells. These cells now contain two material types, explosive products and air. The box structure is modelled using a Lagrangian grid system (ie deformable) but is 'coupled' to the Eulerian system. When the approaching shock wave impinges on the box structure the 'coupling' routines transfer load from the Eulerian (ie air/explosive) to the Lagrangian system (ie box) causing it to deform. During this process all of the explosive products remain enclosed within the box structure, unless part of the wall fails and vents the gases. The size of the air model therefore needs to be large enough to surround the peak deformation of the box structure during the simulation. Figure 4 shows a sequence of time deformation plots for the box structure. 5. DISCUSSION The results in Table 1 for the three methods used clearly show that the coupled Eulerian/Lagrangian technique predicts responses similar to those of the tests and better results than the Lagrangian load curve technique. The major difference between the Lagrangian and Multi-Material techniques lies in the size of the finite element models, the preparation and execution run times. The Lagrangian load curve model is about 1/5 the size of the Multi-Material model and takes about 1/20 of the execution time of the Multi-Material model to run. The execution time of the Multi-Material model was about 38 hours on an SGI 1NDIC~: workstation for a 20 ms simulation time. Another factor that needs consideration is the preparation time to get the model up and running. Considerably more effort is required, typically several days for the Lagrangian load curve technique because the 'ray tracer' code needs to be executed first, then pressure data extracted and then formatted for the finite element structural code. This is a time consuming process and is not required if the Multi-Material approach is used. The number of elements required in the finite element model for the air-explosive parts in the multi-material technique needs to be large in order to capture and transmit the shock front. This then implies that the size of the elements for the box need to be similar otherwise numerical leakage of the shock front will occur through the box during the coupling process. Hence similar element sizes are required for the air and box structure.
177
Figure 4. Sequence of Time - Deformation Responses - Multi-Material Method
178 Table 2 Finite Element Para.meters-On.e Quarter Model Technique Component Nodes Elements Lagrangian structure 5876 5636 Multi-material structure 3240 3104 explosive 7681 6000 air 28801 24000
Mass (kg) 129 129 0.14 n/a
Table 3 Material and Equation of State Properties Metal Box Material Properties
Explosive C.harge Material Properties
Elastic Modulus (GPa) 200.0 Plastic Modulus(GPa) 0.05 Poisson's Ratio 0.3 Density(kg/m**3) 7864.0 Static Yield Strength(MPa) 450.0 Dynamic Yield Strength(MPa)600.0
Detonation Velocity(m/s) Chapman-Jouget Pressure(GPa) Density(kg/m**3) Air Material ..Properties Den sity(kg/m* "3)
6930.0 21.0 1630.0 .. 0.1293
6. CONCLUSION The implementation of the Multi-Material technique for solving air blast problems is an effective approach and more efficient than the traditional Lagrangian load curve method. Results from this new technique are comparable with test data and better than the traditional method. The increase in use of CPU time is not a disadvantage as it out weights the reduction in human time required to build and execute the model in the traditional approach. REFERENCES
[1] LS-DYNA USER'S MANUAL, Version 950, May 1999, Livermore Software Technology Corporation, USA. [2] Marco J., et al, Second International LS-DYNA3D Conference, Sept 1994, "Dynamic Deformation Modelling of Box Structures Subjected to an Internal Explosion"
[31
Blast and Structural Workstation Code, Combustion Dynamics, Canada
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
179
Damage evaluation of structures subjected to the effects of underground explosions Rajesh Kumari, Harbans Lal, MS Bola and VS Sethi Terminal Ballistics research laboratory, Sector-30, Chandigarh-160020, India
Abstract The paper presents the analysis of ground shock data and cratering parameters recorded in the instrumented studies of buried explosions of High Explosive charges. In an underground explosion, most of the energy released is irreversibly coupled to the surrounding soil media resulting in the formation of camouflet or crater .A small fraction of explosive energy about 3% results in the generation of strong ground motion in the near region. The cratering parameters and the ground shock coupling strongly depends on the depth of burst. The strong ground motion in the near region of under ground explosion results in vigorous shaking of buildings. The ground shock parameters in the near region i.e. from 2 W 1/3to 15 W ~/3 has been monitored using piezoelectric accelerometers and electrodynamic geophones .W is the explosive yield in Kg of TNT. The ground shock attenuation scaling laws have been determined for a typical alluvial soil. The paper further discusses the interaction of strong ground motion with building Structures. The key parameters of ground motion have been related to the damage. The damage correlation in terms of ground particle acceleration and ground particle velocity has been determined for various levels of damage to different categories of structures. The threshold level of vibration has also been determined for the occupants inside the structures. 1. INTRODUCTION In underground explosion most of the energy released is irreversibly transferred to the soil in the immediate neighbourhood of the explosion. In the near region it results in formation of crater or ~moflet depending on depth of burst. At far off distances the stress level in the shock falls below the elastic limit and it degenerates into a seismic wave. The subject of eratering mechanism and ground shock propagation in underground explosion has been studied by many investigators (1-3). In the earlier analysis, the investigators of U~ has used cube root scaling for cratering data of underground explosion (3). However Murphy and Vortman have quoted that extrapolation of cratering results by cube root scaling is not realistic in the case of high explosive yields and these are found to be in excess by more than 50%. A generalised empirical analysis of cratering data has been presented by Violet (4). Violet reported scaling exponents in terms of yield for eratering parameter and depth of burst as 1/3.4 and 1/3.6 respectively for a typical alluvial soil. The paper presents the analysis of experimental data acquired by conducting a number of trials with explosive weight varying from 8-120 kg with different depth of burst. A close agreement exists between the experimental data and empirical relations given by Violet.
180 The paper also presents the experimental technique for generation of ground shock data within the region of 2 W ~/3to 15 W 1/3 metres from the point of explosion. The ground shock parameters have been measured in terms of peak ground particle acceleration and peak ground particle velocity. A Cube root scaling law has been used to develop the statistical correlation between scaled distance and ground shock in terms of particle velocity and particle acceleration. Damage correlation in terms of ground shock velocity for different categories of structures have been developed. Threshold levels of vibration for occupants and structures have been used for developing safe zone for various types of activities. 2. EXPERIMENTAL SET UP AND OBSERVATIONS 2.1 Instrumentation
The instrumentation system used for capturing the ground motion was comprised of piezoelectric accelerometers, electrodynamic geophones and recorders. PCB make piezoelectric accelerometers were used to monitor the ground particle ~ l e r a t i o n at various sc~ed distances varying from 2 W t/3 to 15 W ~r~.These accelerometers contain quartz as a sensing element which produce electric charge proportional to crystal deformation. The response of the ~ l e r o m e t e r is linear up to 1/5th of its resonance frequency. The PCB accelerometers with built in amplifier used have sensitivity of 50mv/g and resonance frequency of 40 KHz. The velocity transducers consist of a permanent magnet which moves up and down within a coil. The sensitivity of the geophone is 200 mv/cm/sec which is nearly constant above resonance frequency (4.5 Hz). Recording System includes magnetic tape recorder, Digital Storage Oscilloscope, thermal array recorder etc. 2.2 Trial Set up Underground trials were conducted to establish the scaling law for a typical type of soil with characteristics shown in Table 1. These characteristics conform to the alluvial type of soil. Empirical relations for ground motion for various kinds of soil have been reported in the literature (5). High explosive cylindrical charges of TNT with weight varying from 8 to 120 kg were detonated at different depth of burst. The high explosive charges were kept at predetermined depth of burst in vertically drilled bore holes which were later on filled with loose soil. The geophones and accelerometers were tightly coupled with the Table 1 Soil Characteristics BULK DENSITY POROSITY COARSE SAND FINE SAND SILT CLAY MOISTURE CONTENT
1.72 gm/cc 38.32% 8.77% 49.38% 22.37% 19.48% 12.0%
to record the time history of the vertical components of ground particle velocity and ground particle acceleration respectively at different locations.
181 2.3 Ground Motion Parameters
In the close vicinity of the underground explosion the ground particle acceleration is of the order of 104 to 105g. As this shock travels through the surrounding soil, it decay fast into complex ground motion. We have used our instrumentation in the region 3 W ~/3 to 15 W ~/3 metres from the explosion point, where W is the explosive yield in kgs of TNT. At distances greater than 3 W ~ metres, the dominant frequency of the ground motion lies between 0.1 to 30 Hz and the maximum ground panicle acceleration is of the order of 2 g. The ground shock study has been done for depth of burst for optimum ground shock coupling. The ground shock coupling factor for alluvial type of soil approaches unity for a depth of burst of 0.55 W l/3 metre and thereafter remains constant for higher depth of burst (5). The statistical empirical relations fitted in the ground motion data of particle velocity and acceleration versus radial distance are =61.77 (R/W " Vwl/~ a = 14.52 (R/Wl,3)-l.s4 1/3)-1 53
(1) (2)
Where V = Peak ground particle velocity in cm/sec R = Radial scaled distance in metres W= Explosive yield in Kg of TNT a = Peak ground particle acceleration in terms of'g' where g is the acceleration due to gravity Figure 1 & 2 shows the relation of experimentally acquired ground shock data with the empirical relation (1) & (2). In figure 3 & 4 typical records of ground particle velocity and ground particle accelerations have been shown which were recorded when two cylindrical charges of TNT having weight 90 & 30 kg were detonated simultaneously with depth of burst of 2.87m and 1.82m respectively.
2.O
i.5
t
1.0
1.5
x- observed points ;
o s
.5
x-observed points
1.0
0.5
.25 9
0
0.5
1.0
1.5
R/W ''~
Figure 1. Scaled distance ( R / W113) Vs Ground Particle Acceleration (a. W va)
_,
0
.
_.
5
10
15
Scaled distance (R/W ''~)
Figure 2. Scaled distance (R/W ~/3) Vs Ground Particle Velocity
182
Figure 3. Typical records of ground particle velocity at a distance of 40, 75 & 100 m from the point of explosion. X axis 1 cm = 100 msec; Y axis 1 cm = 1cm/sec; M=Magnification Factor
Figure 4. Typical records of ground particle accelerations in the near vicinity of explosion, X axis 1 cm = 10 msec Y axis 1 cm = 20 g, M=Magnification
2.4 Crater Parameters A Number of trials have been conducted to yield the crater of different dia and depth by varying the blast size at different depth of burst. The experimental data of the crater radius and depth have been plotted (Fig 5 & 6) and found to be in close agreement with the empirical relation given by Violet as below:
R, / W
2
=0.61 +0.72(H/W1/36)-O.18(H/W'/36)
TM
- 0.11(H / W';36) 3 R: /W
TM
(3)
=0.177 + 0.63(H/W'/36)-O.20(,H/W1/36):
-0.13(n/W~/36)3
(4)
Where R~, R2 & H are the apparent crater radius, apparent crater depth and depth of burst in metres. W is the explosive yield in kg of TNT. x
9
?
1.O
x-observed points
x-observed points
T
z m m 0.5
apo
0.5
0
0.5
1.0
H I W I/34
1.5
2.0
Figure 5. Scaled crater depth of burst (H/W 1/36 ) vs scaled crater radius
(RIfW'I/3"4)
2.5
0.5
1.0
H I W I:~6
1.5
Figure 6. Scaled crater depth (H/W 1/3"6) vs scaled crater apparent depth (R2/W1/3"4)
183 A high degree of correlation exists between observed and computed values. The correlation coefficient r--0.95 for crater radius & 0.82 for crater apparent depth. The explosions are found to be contained if the depth of burst is increased beyond 2.3 W 1/3.6 metres and underground explosion yields the optimum crater parameters if the depth of burst lies between 0.857 W 1/3.6 and 1.029 W 1/3.6 metres. A 90 kg charge yields a crater of 7..80 metres dia and 1.70 metres depth whereas 30 kg yield a crater of 5.90 metres dia and 1.45 metres depth when detonated simultaneously at optimum depth of burst. 3. DAMAGE CRITERIA FOR BUILDING & HUMAN BEINGS Personnel and buildings can be represented by a spring mass system of single degree of freedom. Shock & vibration response of structure and personnel can be defined in terms of ground particle acceleration, ground particle velocity and displacement. If the ground vibration is of impact type like ground shock induced by an underground explosion then the ground particle velocity defines the damage criteria. If the ground vibration is of steady state type like continuous vibration induced by machinery and the vibration frequency is less than the natural frequency of the structure than the ground particle acceleration defines the damage criteria. If the ground vibration frequency is dominating than displacement will become the damage criterion (6). The possible damage sustained by structure can be divided into three zones i.e. no damage zone, minor damage zone where formation of new cracks and opening of new cracks and major damage zone where serious cracking occurs without the collapse of structure. For a brick structure, in the no damage zone particle velocity should not exceed 5.08 cm/sec. The threshold level for minor and major damage zones are 13.72 ctrgsec and 19.3 em/sec respectively (6). The Human threshold for ground vibration can be divided as just perceptible, clearly perceptible and annoying. If the peak particle velocity lies between 0.254 mrrgsec to 0.762 mm/sec it is just perceptible for human beings. If it is more than 0.76 ram/see but less than 2.5 mm/sec it is clearly perceptible and if it is more than or equal to 2.5 mm/sec it is annoying (6). 4. SAFETY DISTANCES In order to calculate the safety distance, brick structural targets have been subjected to different sizes of underground blasts. Table 2 below shows the peak ground particle velocity at different scaled distance along with damage description for brick structure. Figure 7 shows a view of damaged brick masonry model which was subjected to a blast of 47.5 kg at scaled distance of 1.82 m/kg 1/3
Figure 7. A view of damaged brick masonry model.
184
Table 2
....P.~..~~d.~c!e.ve!~it.y.. .at ...di.'ff~nt..~~..di~.~ .................................................................................................... Scale distance m/kgI~ peakparticle velocity Damagedescription to structure cm/sec > 14 14to5.57
<0.9 0.9-4.1
5.57-3.52
5 . 2 - 13.5
1.82
24.6
1.82
24.6
<0.5
-
No damage Fine hair line cracks in joints & loosening of brick cement Widening of cracks both horizontally & vertically but structure remain intact. Severe damage to brick building but not total collapse Total collapse Crater formation
5. CONCLUSION 1. Ground Shock Parameters follow cube root scading law and ground shock coupling acquires a maximum at a depth of burst of 0.55 w ~ metres 2. For alluvial type of soil unde~rmmd explosions yield the optimum crater parameter if depth of burst lies between 0.857 w t ~ to 1.029wIt3"6metres 3. The explosions were found contained if depth of burst is increased beyond 2.3w 1/3"6 4. Brick structures are safe at scale distance greater than 14 m/kg ~, suffer minor damage at sc~e distance 5.57-3.52 m/kg l~ and if the sc~e distance is equal to or 1.8 m/kg t~ suffer major damage. 5.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The attthors are thankful to the experimental trial team Shri LIL Jaggi, Smt Parmeshwari Sharma, Shri Pankaj Sajen, Shri Jatinder Pal Singh. Authors are also grateful to the DRDO for granting permission to publish this work. The authors acknowledge with thanks the excellent secretarial assistance provided by Mrs Pankajavally. REFERENCE 1. Nordyke, ]Vii), Nuclear Cralers & Preliminary theory of mechanism of explosive crater formation J. Geophysics 66(10) 3439 (1961). 2. Murphy, BF & Vortman, LJ, High explosive crater in desert Alluvium, Tuff & Basalt, J. Geophysics 66(10) 3389 (1961). 3. Test book of air armament Pt I, Chapter 5, "Craters & Earth Movement". 4. Violet CE, A generalised empirical analysis of cratering J. Geophysics 66(10), 3461
(1961).
5. P r Y i n g of symposium on the interaction of Non-nuclear munition with structure, US air force Ac~emy Colorado, May 10-13, 1983, AD-A132 115 6. A mamml for prediction of blast and fiagment loading on s t m ~ , Southwest research Institute San Antonio, Tx. Page (5.60). Report No. DOFJTIC-] 1268, 1980.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
185
An investigation of structures subjected to blast loads incorporating an equation of state to model the material behaviour of the explosive W. P. Grobbelaar and G. N. Nurick Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Cape Town, Private Bag, Rondebosch 7701, South Africa.
Numerical modelling on blast loaded structures with particular emphasis on the modelling of the explosive is presented. The modelling is carried out using the generalpurpose finite element program ABAQUS/Explicit. The Jones-Wilkins-Lee equation of state is used to model the detonation and subsequent expansion of the plastic explosive. The model is verified using existing experimental data [ 1], which considered the blast loading of thin circular clamped plates. The plates are loaded by detonation of centrally located discs of explosive. For four loading conditions the trends predicted exhibited satisfactory correlation with the experimental results.
1.
INTRODUCTION
During the past few years there have several attempts to model blast loaded structures, as for example those reported in [ 1,2,3,4]. The emphasis of the analyses has been on the prediction of the response of the structures. The predictions compare favourably with experimental results with regard to the displacement profiles of the structures. However, the loading conditions have been modelled based on assumptions of blast time and constant pressure. In the quest to understand the aspects that are dependent on the loading process, for example material behaviour, it is important to accurately model the blast loading. It is the modelling of the loading process in particular that this paper reports. The ability to model the explosive using an equation of state is assessed by considering its interaction with particular structures. Experimental data exists for blast loaded circular plates, conducted by Radford [ 1]. The plate deformations are used to verify the modelling of the explosive. Experiments [1] are simulated using ABAQUS/Explicit, but unlike the methods in [1,2,3,4] of modelling a pressure loading on the structure the explosive is modelled using an equation of state to determine its material behaviour. In this way the explosive material and its interaction with the structure is investigated. This provides an insight into the spatial distribution of the explosive process and eliminates the need to assume a pressure-space-time distribution for the loading. The Jones-Wilkins-Lee equation of state is used to define the material behaviour of the plastic explosive (PEA).
186 2.
EXPERIMENTS USED TO VERIFY THE NUMERICAL MODEL [1]
The experiments investigated blast loading of thin circular steel plates clamped at the boundary. The loading was provided by the detonation of a disc of plastic explosive (PE4) positioned centrally on the steel plate. Radford [1] used steel plates of test diameter 100mm and thickness 1,6mm. The explosive discs had diameters of 18mm, 25mm, 33mm and 40mm. The height of explosive varied to create a range of impulses causing small plate deformations to plate tearing. A schematic of the experimental load setup is shown in Figure 2.1. Detonation point I
I /F~
~ /Expl~
[
Plate ~
"
_3
Clamping rig
Figure 2.1: Schematic of the plate and explosive
3.
MODELLING
Modelling of the circular steel plates An axisymmetric model of the explosive and plate is developed. The explosive and plate are both modelled using 4-noded bilinear continuum elements through the thickness of the structures. The constraining boundary conditions simulated that of the experimental clamped conditions. This is achieved by eliminating all degrees of freedom for the nodes beyond the clamping radius on the back surface of the plate and all the nodes beyond a plate thickness in addition to the clamping radius on the front surface of the plate. 3.1
The material properties used for the steel plates are: Young's Modulus 210 Gpa, Poisson's ratio 0,3, and density 7850 kg m "3. A bilinear curve is used to approximate the plastic behaviour of the steel, with a yield stress of 194 MPa. Strain rate dependence is accounted for by incorporating the Cowper-Symonds formulation, with the commonly used values for steel, D=40,4 s1, n=5 [5].
3.2 Modelling of the explosive using the Jones-Wilkins-Lee equation of state A function of pressure with respect to density (Hugoniot curve) is used to calculate the pressure state achievable by the material behind the shock during detonation. The function relating pressure to the density used for high explosives is the Jones-WilkinsLee (JWL) equation of state. The JWL equation of state models the pressure generated by the release of chemical energy in the explosive. This causes a body, defined only by
187 the equation of state, to have a hydrostatic strength only. The JWL high explosive equation of state is shown in equation 1,
p=All_ R, PoCO~-R,e~+BIl_ P CO..PR2Po ~ -R:-~+cOp2poEmo (1) where P = pressure, p = density, and Em0 are material constants.
/3, = at density beginning of process, A, B, Rl, R2,co
ABAQUS/Explicit[6]
implements the JWL equation of state in the form of a programmed burn. A programmed burn refers to the material remaining inert until the detonation wave reaches the material point in the explosive. The release of energy is not initiated by the shock wave in the material. The burn speed and the geometry of the explosive thus determines the time to initiation of a given material point. The detonation time is computed by ABAQUS using equation 2,
ty = min[tff ~[(X "P - X ~ ) "(x mp- x ~/C) / a (2) where X mp is the position of the material point, Xrqd is the position of the Nth detonation point, tNd is the detonation delay time of the Nth detonation point and Cd is the detonation wave speed of the explosive. In order to avoid discontinuities the burn wave is spread over several elements in the finite element model. To achieve this a burn fraction Fb is computed using equation 3.
(3) where Bs is a constant that controls the width of the burn wave, le is the characteristic length of the element. The default value Bs=2,5 is used and the value for le is calculated internally; it is the same value used to compute the stable time increment. If the time is less than the detonation wave arrival time tmPd,the pressure at the material point is zero, otherwise, the pressure is given by the product Fb and P as determined by the JWL equation of state (equation 1).
4.
RESULTS
The mid-point displacements and plate profiles, amongst other parameters, were recorded by Radford [ 1] and used in this study for purpose of verification. In addition a qualitative investigation of the explosive process is presented.
188
4.1
Qualitative investigation and discussion of the explosion process The expansion of the explosive and its interaction with the plate, as calculated by the model, are shown in Figures 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3. The model shown depicts the 25ram load diameter with a resulting impulse of 7,7 Ns. The figures illustrate three phases of the explosion processPhase I
The expansion of the explosive from time of detonation to interaction with the plate (5/~ s). Phase II Explosive plate interaction (6-30 ~ s), Phase III Expansion of the explosion from time of separation from the plate to the time of plate equilibrium (40-450 ~ s). The expansion of the explosive is thus defined by three parameters: Position of the detonation point, burn speed of the explosive and the geometry of the explosive. In Figure 4.1 it can be seen that the expansion of the explosive starts at the point of detonation (centre of the explosive disc), i.e. on the axis of symmetry. The front of the initiation of expansion spreads outwards from the detonation point at the burn speed of the explosive, Ca = 8600 ms -I [7,8]. As this detonation front passes a material point, the point begins expansion. In order to avoid a discontinuity, the material points ahead of the burn front are made to experience a pressure. This pressure is calculated using the burn fraction, as discussed in section 3.2. Figure 4.1 shows the expansion of the explosive as a result of its internal pressure only. There are no 'outside' forces governing the expansion of the explosive until the explosive interacts with the plate. It can be further seen in Figure 4.1 that the first point of interaction is on the axis of symmetry. This interaction point is dependant on the geometry of the explosive and the detonation point. Since the geometry of the explosive is simple, i.e. a disc, the dominating factor is determining the first point of interaction in the point of detonation. The first stage is naturally the most energetic, and will have a significant influence on the plate profile. Figure 4.1 also shows how the expansion of the explosive is greater in the vertical (2-axis) direction than the radial (1-axis) direction. This is as a result of the overall geometry of the explosive, and the tendency for the explosive to expand in the direction of the longer boundary. At t=2,5 las the explosive is almost symmetrical about the horizontal axis. This could be attributed to the detonation point being only half the explosive height (approximately 2,5mm) above the original horizontal axis of symmetry for the explosive. The extremely high-speed interaction of the gas with the plate can be seen in Figure 4.2. The boundaries of the explosive interact with the plate at speeds up to 4000 ms ~. Note the severe deformations that the explosive elements undergo. It is at this stage that the analysis is most vulnerable to termination as a result of excessively distorted elements. Manual manipulation of the time stepping is usually employed at this stage of the analysis. By showing the displacement with respect to time it can be seen that the profile during the stages of interaction as shown in Figure 4.2 compares with the theoretical
189 predictions as discussed by Wierzbicki and Nurick [9]. Wierzbicki and Nurick [9] categorised the plate deformation in two phases. During phase 1, the stage of transient deformation, it was predicted that there is a pronounced central bulge compared with the eventual profile at equilibrium, as clearly illustrated in Figure 4.2.
Figure 4.1: Expansion of explosive from time of detonation, t=0, to time of interaction, t=5,0. Units of time are ~ . From Figures 4.1 and 4.2 is observed that the plate-explosive interaction takes place from approximately t=3 las to t=28 lxs, i.e. over a time period of approximately 25 Ixs. The extent of the interaction can be seen not to extend beyond approximately the inner half of the plate. By the time the explosive extends beyond the inner half of the plate, the outer sections of the explosive are already experiencing an upward velocity as a result of the reflection from the plate.
190
Figure 4.2: Explosive-plate interaction from time, t=6,75, to time of separation. Units of time are ~ts.
Figure 4.3 shows the plate moving under its own inertia once the interaction with the explosive is completed. It is noted that the explosive is no longer moving after it has reflected off the plate (last four frames) and the interaction is completed. This is as a result of the artificial boundary conditions being imposed on the explosive. The 'freezing' of the explosive allows the plate to reach equilibrium without the analysis being terminated because the explosive elements have become excessively distorted.
191
Figure 4.3: Expansion of explosive from time of separation, to time of plate equilibrium. Units of time are kts.
Frame 1 within Figure 4.3 shows the plate deformation at t=40 ~ with a central bulge characteristic of phase 1 deformation. The phase 1 deformation is strongly contrasted by the deformation in the final frame showing the plate in equilibrium at 457 Its. The entire plate has deformed showing a distinctive 'three curve' profile as shown in the experimental results [1]. The 'three curves' relate to the final profile having curvature that changes from concave in the centre to convex and again concave at the boundary. This characteristic is especially notable in the larger impulses of the larger loading diameters. The outer concave section was a characteristic that was unable to be theoretically predicted using the mode approximation technique as used by Wierzbicki and Nurick [9].
192
4.2
Mid-point displacement results for the plates In order to gain an overall perspective of the mid-point displacement results, a plot of the experimental values plotted against the predicted values is shown in Figure 4.4. The data points are concentrated about the line, thus representing a favourable correlation between the experimental and predicted results. 30 E o ex
25
i~
2o
~
O
e~
~
1o
e~ o ~
5
~
0
, 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Predicted Mid-Point Displacements (mm) O I B m m + 2 5 m m rt33 mm X4Omm l
Figure 4.4: Experimental mid-point displacements vs predicted mid-point displacements for 18mm, 25mm, 33mm and 40mm diameter load cases. 4.3
Plate profiles The profiles shown in Figures 4.5 to 4.8 represent an example of the results for each of the 18mm, 25mm, 33mm and 40mm load diameters respectively. The deformation profiles predicted by the model correspond well with the experimental profiles in all cases.
0.025
0.02 !" "~
~ 0.015
E ~, 0.01
0.005
0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
Plate RmUm (m)
I--'--M~d . . . . V ~ n m t ! Figure 4.5" Comparison of plate profiles for loading diameter of 18mm and a 7,9 Ns impulse
193
0.016 0.014 ,~ 0.012 0.01 0.008 0.006 "~ 0.004 0.002 0.02
0.01
0.03
0.04
0.05
Plate Radius (m) Model . . . . Experiment ] i
Figure 4.6: Comparison of plate profiles for loading diameter of 25mm and a 5,2 Ns impulse 0.035 0.03 0.025 0.02 0.015 0.01 0.005 0
0
,
,
0.01
0.02
,
,;
,
0.03
,
0.04
0.05
Plate Radius (m)
I
Model. . . .
Experiment I
Figure 4.7: Comparison of plate profiles for loading diameter of 33mm and an 11,4 Ns impulse 0.025 ,~ 0 . 0 2 - " - . . ~ 0.015 g
""
"~''.~.,
O.Ol
i~ o.005 0
'
0
~
,
,
,
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
Plate Radius (m)
I
Model . . . .
Experiment I
Figure 4.8: Comparison of plate profiles for loading diameter of 40mm and an 8,9 Ns impulse
194 5
CONCLUDING REMARKS
While the predicted response of plates and beams subjected to blast loads has been widely reported with generally satisfactory results for large inelastic deformations, the understanding of the tearing mechanism is less satisfactorily predicted. This may be attributed to many factors such as, the knowledge of the structural material properties at these severely high strain rates or the interaction between the pressure wave and the structure. The latter is addressed in this paper, in which a model incorporating an equation of state for the explosive blast was included in the computation. This model predicted similar trends observed experimentally. These results included mid-point displacements and plate profiles. The results of the blast wave expansion provided an insight into the process of the pressure w a v e - structural interaction. These results highlight the advantage of the use of an equation of state in that loading of the structure need no longer be assumed but implemented through explosive-plate contact. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors gratefully acknowledge the secretarial support of Iris yon Bentheim. REFERENCES
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [s]
[9]
G.N. Nurick and A.M. Radford, Deformation and tearing of clamped circular plates subjected to localised central blast loads, Recent developments in computational and applied mechanics, CIMNE, 1997. Pp276-301. R. Bimha, Response of thin circular plates to blast loading, MSc Thesis, University of Cape Town, June 1996. M.E. Gelman, A numerical study of the response of blast loaded thin circular plates, with both clamped and integral boundary conditions, MSc Thesis, University of Cape Town, 1996. W.P. Grobbelaar, Modelling of fragmentation damage, BSc Thesis, University of Cape Town, November 1996. N. Jones, Structural Impact, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989. Hibbit, Karlson and Sorenson, INC. ABAQUS Example Problems Manual v5.7, 1996. F. Mostert, Personal consultation, 1998 Kamoulakos, V. Chen, E. Mestreau and R. Lohner, Finite Element Modelling of Fluid/Structure Interaction in Explosively Loaded Aircraft Fuselage Panels using PAMSHOCK / PAMFLOW Coupling, Conference on Spacecraft Structures, Materials and Mechanical Testing, March 1996. T. Wierzbicki and G.N. Nurick, Large deformation of thin plates under localised impulsive loading, Int. J. Impact Engng, Vol. 18, Nos 7-8, pp 899-918, 1996.
Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST 2000) Editors: X.L. Zhao and R.H. Grzebieta 9 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
195
An UNDEX Response Validation Methodology
James L. O'Daniel a, Theodor Krauthammer b, Kevin L. Koudela b, and Larry H. Strait b a. U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center, Structures Laboratory b. The Pennsylvania State University, USA
1. INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES Underwater explosion (UNDEX) tests are costly and hazardous, generating pressure-time load histories that are not well quantified, response data that are difficult to acquire, and the tests may not be repeatable. Nevertheless, a validated approach to accurately predict the short duration dynamic response of a structure subjected to direct UNDEX pressure wave loading does not exist. Therefore, a more cost-effective method to validate the UNDEX response without using the "shock qualification" tests was sought. Krauthammer, et. alo (1996) suggested that precision impact testing can be used to produce peak loads, rise times, durations, and spatial distributions similar to those produced by explosions in air. For this study, the concept of equivalency between in-air explosive and impact loading was expanded to include UNDEX loading. It was postulated that the short duration dynamic response of structures subjected to UNDEX direct pressure wave loading can be reproduced by precision impact loading. Once equivalency is demonstrated, it is proposed that precision impact tests can be used to assess structural integrity of components subjected to direct pressure wave UNDEX loading. This investigation included two important aspects - precision tests and numerical simulations. These were combined to form the unique assessment methodology. Here, a generic UNDEX event is considered, and the concept could be applied to any far-field UNDEX problem. A more comprehensive coverage of this work can be found in O'Daniel (1998). The primary objective of this investigation was to explore the existence of a relationship between the short-duration, dynamic, structural response to UNDEX and to impact. Further, if such a relationship could be found, to develop a methodology to demonstrate an equivalency in structural response between impact and UNDEX testing. The impact tests and simulations were used to produce a response that envelopes the UNDEX response, matching important trends and characteristics. For this study, equivalency was assumed when structural strain time-histories produced by the UNDEX and impact Ioadings were equivalent. The second objective of this investigation involved the validation of a numerical code by precision impact tests. This was an essential part of the UNDEX-impact equivalency methodology. The
196
methodology was developed using an aluminum panel, and then it was demonstrated on a composite material panel to show that the developed procedures are independent of the structural material. Finally, the validated numerical code was used to predict structural responses in future UNDEX tests, and to demonstrate the effectiveness of this methodology by comparison with test data. 2. METHODOLOGY An initial simulation of the UNDEX configuration was developed to predict the short duration dynamic response that was then used to prescribe the parameters of a precision impact test that would produce an equivalent structural response. The most important part of this portion of the process was determining the UNDEX loading environment and, generally, the range of response of the structural component to that loading environment. Similitude equations were used to generate the pressure-time history using the parameters of the explosion. In parallel, the component to be subjected to the UNDEX loading was selected, and a finite element model of it generated. The approximated plane wave loading and the component model were used to produce the numerical UNDEX short duration dynamic structural responses, including strains, strain rates and accelerations. Selecting test parameters and simulating that test to check equivalency to the UNDEX response developed an equivalent structural response. The parameters of the impact test that could be varied were the impact velocity and the characteristics of the impactor, including geometry, mass, mass distribution, stiffness, and stiffness distribution. The iterative process of adjusting the parameters and simulating the new configuration was repeated until the precision impact simulation response and the UNDEX response were equivalent. Once the equivalence was established numerically between UNDEX and impact events, it had to be determined whether these simulations represented reality. A dedicated drop hammer was designed and built to accommodate the impact parameters derived from the numerical equivalency process. Precision impact tests were conducted and the measured responses were compared to numerical simulation results. If a correlation between impact test and simulation did not exist, it had to be determined whether the difference stemmed from inadequacies in the simulations or in the precision tests. Further, any new test and simulation configuration had to be analyzed to determine if the correlated impact response was still equivalent to the original UNDEX response. Once the precision impact test and the numerical simulation produced similar structural responses, the simulated UNDEX event had to be validated with a scaled UNDEX test. This established that the numerical code could simulate the real fluid-structure interaction. The process for the UNDEX simulation was the same as for the precision impact simulation. The UNDEX simulation was generated, followed by the UNDEX test, and their results were compared. The preliminary methodology was completed through the multiple comparisons between simulation and test results for the specific UNDEX and impact configurations. Its assessment was based on whether a satisfactory UNDEX event - precision impact test - numerical simulation equivalency has been established, or if further iterations were necessary. A picture of the impact-testing machine, including an aluminum test panel is shown in Figure 1. A catch mechanism ensured that the impactor was only allowed to strike
197
Figure 1: Test Structure and Aluminum Test Panel
Figure 2: Finite Element Mesh Used for The Structure
the entire face of the structure once. Tests were conducted at impact velocities of up to 4115 mm/s. The same composite test structure was used for the UNDEX tests. Blast and impact analyses share several common characteristics. Inertia effects must be considered for both types of problems. Wave propagation effects are needed to account for the interaction of stress waves between different materials and separate parts of the system. These effects lead to the use of explicit t