Structural Aspects of QUANTUM FIELD THEORY Vol. I
8771hc_v1_9789814472722_tp.indd 1
17/4/13 11:10 AM
April 8, 2013
...
179 downloads
2836 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Structural Aspects of QUANTUM FIELD THEORY Vol. I
8771hc_v1_9789814472722_tp.indd 1
17/4/13 11:10 AM
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
2
book
Structural Aspects of QUANTUM FIELD THEORY Vol. I
Gerhard Grensing University of Kiel, Germany
World Scientific NEW JERSEY
•
8771hc_v1_9789814472722_tp.indd 2
LONDON
•
SINGAPORE
•
BEIJING
•
SHANGHAI
•
HONG KONG
•
TA I P E I
•
CHENNAI
17/4/13 11:10 AM
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
STRUCTURAL ASPECTS OF QUANTUM FIELD THEORY AND NONCOMMUTATIVE GEOMETRY (In 2 Volumes) Copyright © 2013 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 978-981-4472-69-2 (Set) ISBN 978-981-4472-72-2 (Vol. I) ISBN 978-981-4472-73-9 (Vol. II)
Printed in Singapore
May 2, 2013
9:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
PREFACE
Quantum field theory certainly has to be counted as an essential part of our intellectual background. Many exceptional physicists have made decisive contributions to this subject. It has far reaching impact on disciplines such as elementary particle physics, quantum statistical mechanics, and also mathematics. The present text is a modest attempt to explain its main underlying concepts and major results. Some comments on the kind of exposition should be made. According to my preferences, the book is mostly written in a rather condensed style, as I believe is appropriate for the present subject. I have abstained from writing a lengthy introduction to the topic of quantum field theory and what has been reached; the reason is that such an introduction would necessitate the whole vocabulary the newcomer wants to learn. Also I have refrained from further enlarging the text by exercises. Many calculations have only been indicated so that a lot of details remain to be filled in; hence there is room enough to test one’s own status of comprehension. Of course, quantum field theory as a highly developed discipline is also a ‘vast field’. Therefore, the text is divided into two volumes; the first covers the more or less standard topics and can serve as a textbook, whereas the second is devoted to more recent developments. Both are organized in several parts; starred chapters and sections may be omitted on a first reading, but doubly starred ones may be entirely omitted since they are not necessary for the further understanding. Below a description of the contents of the book is given.
The first two parts are entirely devoted to the subject of classical relativistic field theory. In part I kinematical aspects are covered; we shall almost follow the historical development and introduce free fields, such as the Maxwell field describing photons and the Dirac field for electrons. Their classical analogues are discussed by discretizing the fields on a cubical lattice. In the Dirac case it will be shown that already at the classical level Dirac wave functions must be anticommuting quantities. Furthermore the point is made that the famous doubling problem of fermions is void if the spinor field is put on a lattice of finite extent and antiperiodic v
book
April 30, 2013
10:52
vi
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
boundary conditions are chosen in all spatial directions. For the discussion of the spin of the various fields some group theory is needed; in particular the importance of the Lorentz and the Poincar´e group is emphasized in order to ensure the relativistic invariance of the field equations; the relevant background is explained in an appendix on Lie groups and Lie algebras. We will end with a rather thorough treatment of Berezin’s differential and integral calculus for classical anticommuting variables. The second part II on classical relativistic field theory deals with dynamical principles. We shall rely on the Weyl principle to introduce local symmetries of both internal and external type. Here we will differ from common practice in that the Glashow-Salam-Weinberg theory of electroweak interactions, the standard model of particle physics, as well as general relativity and supergravity are all subsumed under the heading classical field theory. Indeed, what underlies all these theories are — more or less — geometric principles, for an understanding of which second quantization, i.e. quantum field theory, is not needed. In the last chapter a rather detailed account to cosmology is given, including a discussion of dark energy and quintessence. Quantum field theory starts in the third part III, which is devoted to operator methods. Beginning with the canonical quantization of free fields, we shall then turn to a discourse on perturbation theory; it includes a discussion of the in- and out-picture, and the reduction formulas. Having available these techniques, we will derive the Wick theorem and can then compute cross sections of some elementary processes of quantum electrodynamics in lowest order. In a more modern approach to quantum field theory though, operator methods are mostly avoided. Instead, one uses path integral techniques; the reason is that nonabelian gauge theories of the Yang-Mills type are extremely difficult to quantize directly since classically they are highly complicated constrained systems. Therefore we need path integral techniques, and in a first attempt we restrict ourselves to systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom. This is done in the fourth part IV, where the Feynman path integral for a nonrelativistic quantum mechanical particle is obtained from basic quantum mechanical principles. It comes in two versions, a Hamiltonian form and a Lagrangian form. The construction requires a latticization of the finite time interval considered; the continuum limit is to be performed at the very end. At least in all those cases we shall investigate, the continuum limit is well defined; this might prove to be useful in order to escape the measure theoretic intricacies connected with the continuum definition of the path integral. There are some quantum mechanical systems for which the path integral can be given in closed form; to these belongs the harmonic oscillator, with and with-
book
April 30, 2013
10:52
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Preface
book
vii
out an external driving force. The path integral naturally admits also perturbative methods, as is demonstrated on the example of the anharmonic oscillator; the perturbative expansion coincides with the one obtained by means of conventional quantum mechanical perturbative techniques. Beyond this, the path integral is equally well accessible to nonperturbative techniques, the analogue of the WentzelKramers-Brillouin approximation. In particular, it is applicable to the problem of a particle in an external electromagnetic field; in case of a constant electromagnetic field it is even exact, and reproduces a famous result of Schwinger. Here one would like to proceed and turn to the treatment of a particle in a gravitational field, but this is an extremely difficult theme; since the WKB expansion amounts to a small time expansion, the best one can do, following B. de Witt, is to calculate the heat kernel expansion for the Laplace-Beltrami operator and its variants. However, if one wants to treat fermions with path integral techniques, the Feynman path integral does not work; in that case a basis of so called coherent states is required, for which the creation and annihilation operators obey anticommutation relations instead of commutation relations. Beyond these two types of path integrals, even a third one is required if one wants to cope with unphysical real fermions, so called ghosts, with such techniques; this third type is needed later on for the path integral of nonabelian gauge theories. But with these three types the path integral theme is not at an end since in the second volume a fourth and a fifth type will be introduced; number four is adapted to generalized coherent states, and number five is the path integral invented by Berezin, which will be needed in the context of anomalies and index theorems in order to treat the quasiclassical spin degrees of freedom. In the fifth part V we shall treat the path integral approach to quantum field theory. In order to make accessible the techniques of the fourth part, the field theoretic system is restricted to a finite spatial domain; in addition, this domain is taken to be a lattice so that one now has a quantum mechanical system with a finite number of degrees of freedom, and thus the techniques of the preceding part apply. Therefore, a path integral for a field theoretic system only makes sense on a lattice, i.e. one must introduce a lattice quantum field theory; the continuum limit is to be taken afterwards on sending the lattice constants to zero. But now the limit is no longer well defined, and it is this fact which may be seen to lie at the origin of the renormalization problem. Accordingly, we will begin with the lattice quantum theory of a scalar operator field and its path integral. Afterwards we treat the lattice theory of a spin one-half field, i.e. a Dirac fermion; in order to avoid the doubling problem, antiperiodic boundary conditions in the spatial directions are chosen. In the literature, however, other strategies have been pursued in order to cope with the doubling problem. The one given by Wilson proceeds via brute force on supplementing the lattice Dirac operator by a second order term. A more subtle construction starts from the observation that on putting a fermion on a
April 30, 2013
10:52
viii
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
lattice, the lattice constant is effectively doubled. This defect can be cured by dividing the lattice into a coarse and a fine lattice, and restricting the fermion to the coarse lattice one obtains the Gliozzi form of the Dirac operator; it differs from the na¨ıve lattice Dirac operator by an improvement term, which prevents the doubling phenomenon. The Gliozzi form is also of some interest in a related context, for the so called Dirac-K¨ ahler operator. This is a construct which arises in the context of the ‘squaring of spinors’; since the square of a spinor can be identified with an element of the exterior algebra, the action of the Clifford algebra on the spinors can be transferred to the exterior algebra and acts there through what is called Clifford multiplication. This correspondence will prove to be important, among others, in the later treatment of anomalies and index theorems. It remains to give the path integral for gauge fields, and therefore one must establish a lattice gauge theory on a finite lattice. In particular, one has to specify boundary conditions; this is a problem which was studied by G. ’t Hooft in 1981, with the result that the boundary conditions for a nonabelian gauge field are specified by what is called the Weyl-’t Hooft algebra; in more modern parlance one would say that this algebra is a (rational) noncommutative torus. Having finished the construction of the path integral by means of the associated lattice quantum field theory, we shall turn to the path integral treatment of quantum field theories and their renormalization. Beginning with the scalar φ4 -theory, we introduce the renormalization group, determine the Callan-Symanzik β-function, and compute the Coleman-Weinberg effective action. The same program is carried out for quantum electrodynamics; its effective action for a constant electromagnetic field was first computed long ago by Euler and Heisenberg. We also give a discussion of the Casimir effect. The analogous program for quantum chromodynamics is considerably more involved since the gauge fixing procedure is more intricate. In this case the solution relies on the Faddeev-Popov trick and the Becchi-Rouet-Stora approach; the deeper foundation of these techniques are discussed in the second volume. The new phenomenon which emerges is, following ’t Hooft, Politzer, and Gross & Wilczek, for not too many flavour degrees of freedom the theory turns out to be asymptotically free; this term expresses the revolutionary fact that for a nonabelian gauge theory perturbation theory only works for high energies. Hence, here one faces a dramatically new situation; gluons and quarks are not visible as ordinary states. The first volume ends with part VI, which is devoted to quantum statistical mechanics, i.e. relativistic and nonrelativistic quantum field theory at nonzero temperature. Functional integral methods have decisive impact on this subject. In particular the canonical ensemble of N particles can adequately be described by the Feynman type of path integral and, e.g., gives rise to a natural derivation of the quasiclassical Wigner-Kirkwood expansion. What is more, the holomorphic path integral is perfectly adapted to the treatment of the grand canonical ensemble. This
book
April 30, 2013
10:52
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Preface
book
ix
is demonstrated in two important examples, Bose-Einstein condensation and superconductivity; in both cases it will be seen that functional integral techniques are considerably more efficient than traditional Green’s function methods. We conclude with a third example, the fractional quantum Hall effect; as one of the most important experimental discoveries of the last century it has evoked an host of rather advanced theoretical approaches. In particular so called anyons, particles of spin lying in between spin zero and spin one-half, are believed to be somehow responsible for the fact that the filling fraction takes quantized fractional values. We first give a rather detailed overview of what belongs to the standard repertoire in this field, in particular we reproduce the well known arguments leading to Laughlin’s trial ground state wave function for the fractional effect. In the last chapter it is then shown that the Laughlin trial ground state is not only almost exact, it is even the exact ground state of an N -particle system of two-dimensional electrons in a perpendicular constant magnetic field, in which the electrons are additionally coupled to an abelian Chern-Simons field since they must be endowed with the degrees of freedom being available in two dimensions; here it is essential to note that one has to quantize first and impose the constraint afterwards, and not the other way round. The second volume covers more specialized topics; they require some amount of mathematics that normally is not taught in standard courses. It starts with the seventh part VII, which is entirely devoted to systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom. We begin with a synopsis on symplectic geometry and the Hamiltonian formalism, and then turn to the subject of symmetries in that context. On the example of the harmonic oscillator in three dimensions and the hydrogen atom we show that quantization leads in these cases to a degeneracy of the energy states, which is said to be accidental since there is no obvious explanation of this fact. However, a closer look reveals that these Hamiltonian systems have a larger Lie group symmetry than one would expect from its Lagrangian form, and it is these symmetry groups which are responsible for the degeneracy. In the case of the hydrogen atom this observation was made by Pauli already in the year 1926, before the advent of the Schr¨ odinger equation. The situation changes essentially on considering what we call the Landau problem, i.e. a charged particle moving in a rectangular domain of the plane, which is subject to a perpendicular constant magnetic field. As is well known, the lowest energy state of the associated quantum problem, the lowest Landau level, is degenerate, but there is no Lie group available which could explain this degeneracy. A more detailed analysis shows that the system is anomalous in the sense that the translations of this system are realized projectively; restricting the system to a rectangular domain, a remnant of the translations survive quantization, which turn out to be the generators of an already mentioned noncommutative 2-torus. In the last chapter of the book it will finally be recognized that the generators of the noncommutative 2-torus form the auxiliary
April 30, 2013
10:52
x
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
algebra of a quantum group, the quantum deformation of the su(2) Lie algebra, and this yields the ultimate explanation for the degeneracy of the lowest Landau level. In the following part VIII the symplectic techniques are applied to a system with first class constraints, of which the Yang-Mills theory is a main example. What we want to reach is a serious justification of the Faddeev-Popov trick; this means that a derivation of the basic path integral formula from first principles must be given. But this also means that those readers who are able to simply accept that path integral formula can entirely skip this part without any loss of continuity. The point of departure is a finite dimensional analogue of Yang-Mills type, i.e. a Hamiltonian system with constraints such that their Poisson brackets reproduce the Lie algebra of a compact Lie group. In order to make this constrained system well defined, one must choose an equal number of subsidiary constraints (‘gauge fixing conditions’) with the property that the determinant of the matrix being built from the Poisson brackets of the constraints with the subsidiary constraints does not vanish. One then shows, and this is the content of the Marsden-Weinstein theorem, that by means of the original and the subsidiary constraints one can reduce the system to a smaller one, for which the reduced Poisson brackets are well defined; they coincide with what are known as Dirac brackets on the reduced symplectic space. These Dirac brackets can explicitly be given for a Yang-Mills theory, and in the abelian case they reproduce the standard transverse Poisson brackets. In the nonabelian case, however, the reduced phase space is highly noncanonical; at least in principle one could apply the Mackey-Segal approach to quantization, but this is rather implicit only and not suitable for a path integral treatment. What eventually works is a variant of the original Marsden-Weinstein reduction; this can be extended to the unreduced system and results in the so called Faddeev formula for the real-time partition function. It is the same as that obtained by formal manipulations with the Faddeev-Popov trick, and then the usual BRS techniques apply. In part IX we introduce Weyl quantization. This concept was founded as early as 1927 by Weyl, and extended in the sixties by Berezin to fermionic degrees of freedom; it serves two purposes. Consider a system of classical mechanics, being specified by its Hamiltonian function. Quantization then amounts to the problem of ascribing to the Hamiltonian function an operator; but in general there are many possibilities available, depending on the choice of the ordering of the position and momentum operators. As will be seen, at least for the examples we shall consider, there is one optimal choice, and this is the Weyl order. Its further virtue is that for the short time transition element, which is needed for the construction of a path integral, it yields the so called midpoint rule; as known, this is essential in order to guarantee gauge invariance of the path integral for a charged particle being subject to an external electromagnetic field. In addition, and this is the second purpose, the Weyl calculus gives rise to a deformed product for phase space functions, the
book
April 30, 2013
10:52
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Preface
book
xi
Groenewold-Moyal product; it is made use of to introduce a new type of path integral, which goes back to Berezin. Beyond this, it will be shown that the realtime partition function can be given in closed form; in particular in the fermionic case the result will play a decisive role for the supersymmetric proof of the index theorems. What underlies the above constructions is the so-called Weyl operator; in the bosonic case it is obtained on exponentiating the position and momentum operators and yields a projective realization of the abelian group of phase space translations. But translations are not the only transformations which leave the commutation relations intact; there are also symplectic transformations in the bosonic, and rotations in the fermionic case. The generating functions of these transformations can be elevated to operators which are quadratic in the generators; upon exponentiation one obtains for bosons what is called the metaplectic representation of the symplectic group, and in the fermionic case the Dirac representation of the rotation group. In both cases the quantization of the rotation resp. symplectic group yields a twofold covering, i.e. the spin resp. metaplectic group. The defining representation for fermions is finite dimensional, whereas for bosons it is infinite dimensional and considerably more difficult to analyze. The metaplectic representation should be of comparable relevance as the Dirac representation; to give an example, in the one-dimensional case it makes it appearance in quantum optics in the context of squeezed states. There is still another role of the Weyl operator; it is the basic ingredient for the construction of coherent states. Restricting ourselves to the conventional bosonic case, it looks reasonable to generalize this concept to other groups, in particular to nonabelian ones. The simplest example is the group SU (2), which will lead to astute applications for spin systems such as ferromagnets and antiferromagnets. Part X addresses the subject of anomalies in quantum field theory; they arise if a classical symmetry does not survive the quantization process. Such a phenomenon occurs in gauge theories with massless fermions; then the classical theory is invariant against chiral transformations, but the quantized theory is not since the chiral current is no longer conserved. One has to distinguish two cases, which are essentially different. Firstly, the chiral invariance is not gauged, i.e. there is no gauge field which couples to the chiral current; this chiral anomaly has measurable consequences, e.g. it solves the problem of the neutral pion decay into two photons. Secondly, if the chiral invariance is gauged, i.e. if the chiral current is coupled to the gauge field, then this chiral gauge anomaly destroys gauge invariance, and thus renormalizability is ruined. In four dimensions, the gauge anomaly is proportional to a completely symmetric 3-tensor on the gauge group, and thus there are at least two possibilities to save renormalizability. The obvious one is that the 3-tensor vanishes in all representations; groups with this property are called safe. But this is not what happens for the main example of a theory with a possible chiral gauge
April 30, 2013
10:52
xii
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
anomaly, the standard model of particle physics. Its gauge group is the direct product U (1) × SU (2) × SU (3), in which the first and third factor are not safe. Here the second possibility is realized; namely, due to the presence of several fermions the anomaly cancels since there are the same numbers of leptons as there are flavours of quarks. The actual determination of the two types of anomalies is a subtle business. We present several approaches to the calculation of the chiral anomaly in the ungauged case; up to a prefactor, the result is identical to what is stated by the AtiyahSinger index theorem. In particular, we give the supersymmetric proof of the index theorem; it heavily relies on Weyl quantization and the Groenewold-Moyal product for real fermions. The calculation of the chiral gauge anomalies requires techniques going far beyond; with the index theorem as point of departure, they are derived by means of the Stora-Zumino descent as tertiary characteristic classes. The last chapter of this part is devoted to applications; it centers around the Wess-Zumino-Witten model. We begin with the fact that this model can be realized as the unique solution of quantized pure nonabelian Chern-Simons theory in the Schr¨ odinger picture. As observed by Polyakov and Wiegmann, the Wess-ZuminoWitten model may also be derived as the exact effective action of 2-dimensional quantum chromodynamics; we also comment on the much discussed chiral version, which is plagued by the gauge anomaly. In part XI a more recent theme is treated, noncommutative geometry. This subject is competently laid down in the seminal monograph of its founder A. Connes 1994, and Connes & Marcolli 2008. For a mediocre physicist such as the present author, however, these texts are rather advanced and difficult to appreciate — at least at first sight. Therefore, we introduce the subject by first acquainting the reader in a separate chapter with the basic algebraic tools; to these belong the noncommutative differential calculus and cyclic cohomology. The necessary analytic tools are described in the following chapter; there we introduce the main construction, i.e. spectral triples with a real structure, and the Dixmier trace together with the related Wodzicki residue. The application of noncommutative geometry to particle physics is covered in the next chapter; it is devoted to the spectral action of Chamseddine and Connes, which must be viewed as one of the most fundamental discoveries in the last twenty years. It is a really essential new device in constructing gauge field actions since it produces the Maxwell and Yang-Mills term, as well as the Hilbert-Einstein term, and all these with the correct sign in front. Even more important, for the product geometry being built from the canonical spectral triple and a finite spectral triple over a virtual manifold made of two points, it also yields the Higgs action, with the correct ‘wrong’ sign in front of the mass term. A further decisive insight is delivered by the fact that the Higgs field is a gauge field, of spin zero; hence, all matter fields carry spin one-half, and all elementary fields of integer spin less than or equal to two
book
April 30, 2013
10:52
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Preface
book
xiii
are recognized as gauge fields. We also discuss the impact of the spectral action principle on cosmology, and the question whether torsion is a physical degree of freedom or not. In the last chapter an overview of noncommutative quantum field theory is given. We begin with an introduction to noncommutative spacetimes and noncommutative tori; as to the latter, we point out that the noncommutative 2-torus is just the essential construct for the Landau problem in a finite domain. We then consider various quantum field theories on these spaces and comment on some of the new developments in this topic. Part XII covers another more recent theme, so called quantum groups; this subject was founded by Faddeev and Drinfel’d and others in the fourth quarter of the last century. Roughly speaking, quantum groups — or better, quantum algebras — arise as deformations of the four series of simple Lie algebras and are equipped with the structure of a Hopf algebra. But they have more structure, they are even quasitriangular; as such they have a universal R-matrix, which gives rise to the Yang-Baxter relations. These relations remind of the third Reidemeister move of knot theory, and indeed, quantum groups with the additional property of being ribbon allow to define a quantum trace, and this in turn permits the introduction of a Markov trace, underlying the construction of the famous knot invariants. But we will not expand on applications of quantum groups to knot theory. Instead, what we are interested in for the physical applications we have in mind are real structures on quasitriangular Hopf algebras; we will show that beyond the standard real structure there can also be defined a second nonstandard real structure with equally nice properties. That such an additional nonstandard real structure is really needed will be shown in the basic example of the quantum deformation Uq (su2 ) of the Lie algebra su2 with q the deformation parameter. We also study the representation theory of this quantum group. As we shall see, there is one series of representations of Uq (su2 ) for q = exp 2πi/p with p an odd integer, which turns out to be unitary with respect to the nonstandard real structure mentioned above; it is these particular representations that will become important in the following part. In the final part XIII we can be rather brief; its purpose is to exhibit that quantum groups and noncommutative geometry are intimately related. To begin with, we demonstrate such a relation on the example of the quantum group Uq (su2 ) and the noncommutative 2-torus. We first show that the generators of Uq (su2 ) can be expressed in terms of the generators of the noncommutative 2torus with the same deformation parameter. Recall then that the noncommutative 2-torus with deformation parameter q = exp 2πi/p and p an odd integer is realized in the Landau problem; it is the p-dimensional Hilbert space of the lowest Landau level, on which the two generators of the noncommutative 2-torus act irreducibly
April 30, 2013
10:52
xiv
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
and unitary. This Hilbert space is identical with the representation space of that particular representation Uq (su2 ) mentioned above, which is unitary with respect to the nonstandard real structure. To summarize, for the Landau problem no Lie algebra symmetry is available which could explain the degeneracy of the lowest Landau level; but what exists instead is a quantum algebra, which precisely serves this purpose. Before proceeding, another realization of the 2n-torus is given; it is obtained by means of Weyl quantization on restricting a 2n-dimensional flat phase space to a rectangular domain. Then we go on to show that the above relation generalizes to the 2n-dimensional noncommutative torus and the quantum group Uq (sun+1 ), where the deformation parameter can take arbitrary complex values of modulus one. In the last chapter we show that an important physical system exists, the fractional quantum Hall effect, for which the quantum group Uq (su2 ) with q = exp 2πi/p and p odd plays the role of a spectrum generating algebra, in the sense that it explains the experimentally observed quantum numbers ν = 1/p of the filling fraction. Here we elaborate the approach described in part VI by restricting the quantum Hall system to a rectangular device. Then one must impose boundary conditions, which turns out to be a subtle affair since the Chern-Simons gauge field gets involved. To resume, it is the beautiful architecture of a quantum group in conjunction with the noncommutative torus that yields a satisfying explanation of the quantum Hall effect. I would like to thank T. Sch¨ ucker for reading large parts of the manuscript and for helpful advice. I also want to express my gratitude to C. Henning for producing the figures and graphs in this book; he is responsible as well for a decisive idea in the context of Bose-Einstein condensation. In addition I am indebted to him for invaluable help on the TeXnical side of the project. Last but not least I would like to thank the members of the mathematical seminar of the Christian-AlbrechtsUniversit¨ at in Kiel for discussions in the course of numerous joint seminars.
book
April 30, 2013
10:52
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Preface
book
xv
General References A list of textbooks on classical and quantum field theory, which necessarily is incomplete, is given below. As to my personal preferences, I have always admired the books of Bjorken & Drell and Itzykson & Zuber.
Berestetzkii V. B., Lifshitz E. M. and Pitaevskii L. P., Relativistic Quantum Theory, Pergamon Press, Oxford 1971 Berezin F. A., The Method of Second Quantization, Academic Press, New York 1966 Bjorken J. D. and Drell S. D., Relativistic Quantum Mechanics and Relativistic Quantum Fields, McGraw-Hill, New York 1965 Brown L. S., Quantum Field Theory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1992 Faddeev L. D. and Slavnov A. A., Gauge Fields, Introduction to Quantum Theory, Benjamin, Reading 1980 Hatfield B., Quantum Field Theory of Point Particles and Strings, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City CA 1992 Honerkamp J. and R¨ omer H., Klassische Theoretische Physik, Springer-Verlag, Berlin 1986 Huang K., Quarks, Leptons and Gauge Fields, World Scientific, Singapore 1982 Itzykson C. and Zuber J. B., Quantum Field Theory, McGraw-Hill, New York 1980 Kaku M., Quantum Field Theory, A Modern Introduction, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1993 Landau I. D. and Lifshitz E. M., The Classical Theory of Fields, Pergamon Press, Oxford 1975 Nair V. P., Quantum Field Theory, A Modern Perspective, Springer, New York 2005 Peskin M. E. and Schroeder D. V., An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory, Addison-Wesley, Reading 1995
April 30, 2013
10:52
xvi
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Polyakov A. M., Gauge Fields and Strings, Harwood Academic Publishers, London 1987 Ramond P., Field Theory: A Modern Primer, Benjamin, Reading 1981 Ryder L., Quantum Field Theory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1985 Schweber S. S., An Introduction to Relativistic Quantum Field Theory, Harper and Row, New York 1964 Schwinger J. (ed.), Quantum Electrodynamics, Dover Publications, London 1958 Stone M., The Physics of Quantum Fields, Springer-Verlag, New York 2000 Taylor J. C., Gauge Theories of Weak Interactions, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1976 Weinberg S., The Quantum Theory of Fields, Vol. I Foundations, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1995; The Quantum Theory of Fields, Vol. II Modern Applications, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1996 Zee A., Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell, Princeton University Press, Princeton N.J. 2003 Zinn-Justin J., Quantum Field Theory and Critical Phenomena, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1989
References for special topics are supplied at the end of each part; they refer to authors cited in the main text by name and year enclosed in round brackets.
book
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
CONTENTS
Volume I v
Preface
I 1.
CLASSICAL RELATIVISTIC FIELD THEORY: KINEMATICAL ASPECTS
1
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
3
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 2.
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
Lagrange Formalism for Fields 2.1 2.2 2.3
2.4 3.
Maxwell’s Equations in Relativistic Notation . . . . Klein-Gordon Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Group Velocity and Special Relativity . . . . . . . . Nonrelativistic Limit and the Schr˝odinger Equation . Classical Interpretation of Fields . . . . . . . . . . . Normal Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantized Harmonic Oscillator * . . . . . . . . . . . Quantization of the Klein-Gordon Field * . . . . . .
3 9 11 13 14 16 18 22 25
Functionals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Euler-Lagrange Equations for Fields . . . Variational Principle . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1 Nonrelativistic classical mechanics 2.3.2 Relativistic classical mechanics . . 2.3.3 Reparametrization invariance * . 2.3.4 Relativistic field theory . . . . . . Appendix: Improper Bases * . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
25 27 29 30 31 33 36 37
Relativistic Invariance
45
3.1 3.2
45 54
Minkowski Space and its Symmetry Group . . . . . . . . . . . . Transformation Law of Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xvii
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
xviii
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
3.3
4.
5.7
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
Dirac’s Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Relativistic Invariance of Dirac’s Equation . . Variational Principle for the Dirac Equation . On the Origin of Gauge Invariance . . . . . . Nonrelativistic Limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ‘Classical’ Interpretation of Fermions . . . . . 5.6.1 Fermions on a lattice . . . . . . . . . 5.6.2 Canonical quantization of fermions * 5.6.3 The doubling problem . . . . . . . . . 5.6.4 Resolution of the doubling problem . Clifford Algebras and Spin Groups * . . . . .
6.5
75 77 77 79 81 85 89
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4
7.
Inertial Frames and Causality . . Lengths and Time Intervals . . . Addition Theorem for Velocities Rotating Frames . . . . . . . . . Accelerated Inertial Frames . . . Appendix: Product Integral . . .
56 56 61 75
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6
6.
Appendix: Lie Groups and Lie Algebras * . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1 Fundamentals of group theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2 Lie groups and their algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Special Relativity 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
5.
book
Scalar Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dirac Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Maxwell Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Spin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4.1 Representations of rotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4.2 Fields and their spin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Transformation Law of Fields and Induced Representations *
89 93 97 99 100 102 103 105 108 109 110 119
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
119 120 122 124 125 128 131
Neutral Fermions
133
7.1 7.2 7.3
133 135 136
Charge Conjugation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Majorana Spinors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neutrinos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
8.
Symmetries and Conservation Laws
141
9.
Differential and Integral Calculus for Anticommuting Variables
151
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Contents
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4
II
Real Grassmann Variables . . . Fourier Transformation . . . . Complex Grassmann Variables Appendix: Pfaffians * . . . . .
. . . .
xix
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
CLASSICAL RELATIVISTIC FIELD THEORY: DYNAMICAL ASPECTS
167
10. Dynamical Principles: Internal Symmetries 10.1
10.2
10.3
Internal Gauge Theories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.1 Gauge invariance in quantum mechanics 10.1.2 Weyl’s principle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yang-Mills Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Field equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Covariant current conservation . . . . . . 10.2.3 Chern-Simons theory . . . . . . . . . . . Gauge Theories and Elementary Particle Physics 10.3.1 Higgs-Kibble mechanism . . . . . . . . . 10.3.2 Glashow-Salam-Weinberg model . . . . . 10.3.3 Standard model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.4 Majorana neutrinos . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.5 Appendix: SU(N) . . . . . . . . . . . . .
169 . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. Dynamical Principles: External Symmetries 11.1 11.2
11.3
151 158 161 164
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dynamics of a Relativistic Point Particle in a Gravitational Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.1 Geodesic equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.2 Gravity and gauge invariance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.3 Newtonian limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.4 Energy-momentum tensor of a relativistic point particle Differential Geometry: A First Course . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.1 Covariant differentiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.2 Metric postulate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.3 Riemann’s curvature tensor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.4 Bianchi identities and symmetry properties of the curvature tensor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.5 Parallel displacement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.6 Normal coordinates and the principle of equivalence . . 11.3.7 Riemann normal coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.8 Jacobi operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
169 170 172 174 180 181 185 186 187 202 205 210 214 223
.
224
. . . . . . . . .
226 228 231 232 234 236 237 240 242
. . . . .
243 245 248 251 253
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
xx
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
11.4
11.5
11.6
11.7 11.8
11.3.9 Vector analysis and integration . . . . . . . . . . . Einstein’s Theory of Gravity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.4.1 Hilbert action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.4.2 Coupling of matter fields to gravity . . . . . . . . 11.4.3 Gravity as a special relativistic field theory . . . . 11.4.4 Linear approximation and gravitational waves . . 11.4.5 Schwarzschild solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Differential Geometry: A Second Course . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.1 Coordinate transformations and the general linear group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.2 Geodetic function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.3 Geodetic parallel transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.4 Coincidence limits * . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.5 Riemann normal coordinates revisited . . . . . . . Differential Geometry: A Third Course . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6.1 Orthonormal frames . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6.2 Spin connexions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6.3 Differential geometry as a gauge theory: Cartan connexions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Accelerated Observers and Inertial Systems ** . . . . . . Gravity as a Gauge Theory of the Poincar´e Group . . . .
book
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
255 257 258 263 267 272 274 279
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
279 283 286 287 289 290 291 292
. . . . . . . . . . . .
298 301 307
12. Supergravity 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5 12.6
315
Super Poincar´e Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Supersymmetry and Differential Geometry: Cartan Connexions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rarita-Schwinger Fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Supergravity as a Gauge Theory of the Super Poincar´e Group Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Majorana Spinors in Higher Dimensions . . . . . . 12.6.1 Properties of gamma matrices in four dimensions . . 12.6.2 Fierz identities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.6.3 Properties of Majorana spinors in four dimensions . . 12.6.4 Majorana spinors in higher dimensions . . . . . . . .
. .
315
. . . . . . . . .
319 323 327 333 333 335 335 336 337
. . . . . . . . .
13. Cosmology 13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6
Gauss’ Normal Coordinates . . . . . . . . . Symmetric Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Realization of Maximally Symmetric Spaces Robertson-Walker Metric . . . . . . . . . . General Relativistic Hydrodynamics . . . . Friedmann Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . .
341 . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
341 342 345 347 348 350
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Contents
13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10 13.11 13.12 13.13
III
xxi
Models of the Universe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Present Status of the Universe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Observational Astronomy and Cosmological Parameters Cosmological Constant Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quintessence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Geometric Optics in the Presence of Gravity Appendix: Local Scale Invariance and Weyl Geometry * 13.13.1 Weyl geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.13.2 Conformally invariant matter fields . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
RELATIVISTIC QUANTUM FIELD THEORY: OPERATOR METHODS
377
14. Quantization of Free Fields 14.1
14.2
14.3
379
Scalar Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.1.1 Canonical quantization . . . . . . . . . . 14.1.2 Feynman propagator . . . . . . . . . . . Dirac Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2.1 ‘Canonical’ quantization . . . . . . . . . 14.2.2 Feynman propagator . . . . . . . . . . . Maxwell Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3.1 ‘Canonical’ quantization . . . . . . . . . 14.3.2 Feynman propagator . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3.3 Maxwell’s theory as a constrained system
. . . . . . . . . *
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
15. Quantum Mechanical Perturbation Theory 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7
Interaction Picture . . . . . . . . . . . . . Time Independent Perturbation Theory * Formal Theory of Scattering * . . . . . . In and Out Picture * . . . . . . . . . . . . Gell-Mann & Low Formula * . . . . . . . Transcription to Quantum Field Theory * Reduction Formulae * . . . . . . . . . . . 15.7.1 Scalar field . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.7.2 Dirac field . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.7.3 Maxwell field . . . . . . . . . . . .
379 379 381 386 386 390 391 391 394 395 397
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
16. Perturbative Quantum Electrodynamics 16.1 16.2 16.3
352 356 359 360 362 363 366 366 371
QED Hamiltonian in the Coulomb Gauge . . . . . . . . . . . . . QED Scattering Operator and States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wick’s Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
397 404 412 419 421 423 425 425 429 430 433 433 436 437
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
xxii
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
16.4 16.5 16.6 16.7
16.8
IV
book
Scattering Matrix Elements . . . . . Feynman Rules for QED . . . . . . . Cross Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . Elementary Processes . . . . . . . . 16.7.1 Compton scattering . . . . . 16.7.2 Pair annihilation . . . . . . . 16.7.3 Møller scattering . . . . . . . 16.7.4 Electron-positron scattering Appendix: Gamma ‘Gymnastics’ . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
440 445 447 453 453 457 458 462 462
NONRELATIVISTIC QUANTUM MECHANICS: FUNCTIONAL INTEGRAL METHODS 465
17. Path Integral Quantization 17.1 17.2 17.3
467
Feynman Path Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gauge Invariance and the Midpoint Rule . . . . . . . . . . . . . Canonical Transformations and the Path Integral * . . . . . . . .
18. Path Integral Quantization of the Harmonic Oscillator 18.1 18.2
483
Harmonic Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Driven Harmonic Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
19. Expectation Values of Operators 19.1 19.2 19.3
Expectation Values for a Finite Time Interval . . . . . . . . . . . Expectation Values for an Infinite Time Interval . . . . . . . . . Driven Harmonic Oscillator Revisited . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Imaginary Time and Quantum Statistical Mechanics . . . . . . . Ground State Energy of the Quartic Anharmonic Oscillator . . .
21.4 21.5
Expansion in Terms of Planck’s Constant . . . . . . . . . Small Deviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stationary Phase Approximation: Particle in an External Potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin and Stationary Phase Approximation: Compatibility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stationary Phase Approximation: Charged Particle in an External Magnetic Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
491 494 497 503
21. Nonperturbative Methods 21.1 21.2 21.3
483 487 491
20. Perturbative Methods 20.1 20.2 20.3
467 477 479
503 504 507 511
. . . . . . . .
511 513
. . . .
516
. . . .
518
. . . .
521
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Contents
21.6 21.7
xxiii
Particle in an External Gravitational Field and Heat Kernel Expansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Partition Functions and Functional Determinants . . . . . . . 21.7.1 Second order operators and the zeta function method 21.7.2 First order operators and the zeta function method: Preliminary version . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.7.3 First order operators and the zeta function method: Improved version . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.7.4 First order operators and the zeta function method: Final version . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
526 532 532
. .
535
. .
542
. .
545
22. Holomorphic Quantization 22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4 22.5
549
Coherent States: Bosons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Coherent State Path Integral: Bosons . . . . . . . . Coherent States: Fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Path Integral for Fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Driven Harmonic Oscillator: Bosonic and Fermionic
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
23. Ghost Fermions 23.1 23.2 23.3 23.4 23.5
V
Schr¨ odinger Representation . . Vector Space Realization . . . . Dirac States and Their Duals . Feynman Type Path Integral . Poisson Structures for Fermions
571 . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
RELATIVISTIC QUANTUM FIELD THEORY: FUNCTIONAL INTEGRAL METHODS
24.3
Lattice Lattice 24.2.1 24.2.2 24.2.3 Lattice 24.3.1 24.3.2
Bosons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lattice fermions and the doubling problem Dirac-K¨ ahler fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . Lattice fermions and the path integral . . . Gauge Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gauge theories on an infinite lattice . . . . Gauge theories on a finite lattice and the ’t algebra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
587 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooft . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
587 593 594 602 610 614 614
. . . .
618
25. Self Interacting Bosonic Quantum Field 25.1
572 575 576 580 581
585
24. Quantum Fields on a Lattice 24.1 24.2
549 553 557 562 565
Partition Function and Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . .
621 621
April 8, 2013
14:15
xxiv
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
25.2 25.3 25.4 25.5 25.6 25.7 25.8 25.9
Effective Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Effective Action and Perturbation Theory Dimensional Regularization . . . . . . . . Renormalization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ‘Cosmological’ Constant . . . . . . . . . . Renormalization Group Equations . . . . Asymptotia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Coleman-Weinberg Effective Potential . . 25.9.1 Stationary phase approximation . 25.9.2 Zeta-function evaluation . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
26. Quantum Electrodynamics 26.1 26.2 26.3 26.4 26.5
26.6 26.7 26.8
665
Path Integral for the Free Dirac Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Path Integral for the Free Electromagnetic Field . . . . . . . . . Path Integral Representation of Quantum Electrodynamics . . . Ward’s Identity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Regularization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26.5.1 Regularization of the self-energy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26.5.2 Regularization of the vacuum polarization . . . . . . . . 26.5.3 Regularization of the vertex part . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26.5.4 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Renormalization and the Callan-Symanzik Function . . . . . . . Application: Anomalous Magnetic Moment . . . . . . . . . . . . Structure of the Physical Vacuum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26.8.1 Ground state wave functional of the free electromagnetic field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26.8.2 Casimir effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26.8.3 Euler-Heisenberg effective field theory . . . . . . . . . . .
27. Quantum Chromodynamics 27.1 27.2 27.3 27.4 27.5 27.6 27.7
Faddeev-Popov Device . . . . . . . Becchi-Rouet-Stora Transformation Zinn-Justin Equations . . . . . . . Feynman Rules . . . . . . . . . . . Regularization . . . . . . . . . . . Asymptotic Freedom . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . .
625 629 632 644 648 652 657 659 660 662
665 666 668 671 674 676 677 678 679 680 682 684 684 688 691 697
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
697 700 703 705 708 714 715
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Contents
VI
xxv
QUANTUM FIELD THEORY AT NONZERO TEMPERATURE
719
28. Nonrelativistic Second Quantization 28.1 28.2 28.3
721
Field Operators and the Fock Space Construction . . . . . . . . . Multilinear Algebra and the Fock Space Construction * . . . . . Second Quantized Form of the N-Particle Hamiltonian . . . . . .
29. Quantum Statistical Mechanics 29.1 29.2 29.3
733
Thermodynamics and the Partition Function . . . . . . . . . . . Canonical Ensemble . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Constant Mode Expansion of the Canonical Partition Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
30. Grand Canonical Ensemble 30.1 30.2 30.3 30.4 30.5 30.6
Path Integral Representation of Second Quantized Fields . . Grand Canonical Partition Function as a Functional Integral Perturbation Theory in Direct Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Perturbation Theory in Fourier Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . Connection with Thermodynamic Quantities . . . . . . . . . Noninteracting Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking and Condensation Condensation and Feynman Rules . . . . . . . . . . Schwinger-Dyson-Beliaev equations . . . . . . . . . . Hugenholtz-Pines Relation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nonperturbative Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Superfluidity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Effective Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
33.2
Relativistic Ideal Gas 33.1.1 Bosons . . . . 33.1.2 Fermions . . . 33.1.3 Gauge bosons Symmetry Restoration
741 743 745 747 749 750
753 756 760 761 763 767 771
33. Relativistic Quantum Field Theory at Nonzero Temperature 33.1
738
753
32. Superconductivity 32.1 32.2
733 736
741
31. Bose-Einstein Condensation 31.1 31.2 31.3 31.4 31.5 31.6
723 727 729
. . . . .
34. Fractional Quantum Hall Effect
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
771 772 781
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
781 781 782 785 786 789
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
xxvi
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
34.1 34.2 34.3 34.4 34.5 34.6 34.7
Classical Hall Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Landau Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Second Quantization and the Integer Effect . . . . . . . . . . Chern-Simons Theory and Ginzburg-Landau Effective Theory Laughlin Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Excitations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Braid Statistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.7.1 Path integral quantization in a non-simply connected space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.7.2 Artin’s braid group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.8 Chern-Simons Theory and Braid Statistics . . . . . . . . . . . 34.9 Edge Excitations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.10 Virasoro and Kac-Moody Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.11 Laughlin Ground State and Vertex Operators . . . . . . . . . 34.12 Laughlin’s Trial Wave Function as an Exact Ground State . . 34.12.1 Canonical properties of Chern-Simons theory . . . . . 34.12.2 Quantization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.12.3 Regularization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34.12.4 Excitations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
790 791 794 797 798 804 808
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
808 811 814 816 817 827 832 834 838 845 847 I-1
Index Volume II
v
Preface
VII
SYMMETRIES AND CANONICAL FORMALISM
851
35. Hamiltonian Formalism and Symplectic Geometry 35.1 35.2 35.3 35.4 35.5
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Canonical Transformations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generating Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vector Fields as Generators of Diffeomorphisms . . . . . One Parameter Subgroups of Canonical Transformations
853 . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
36. Conventional Symmetries 36.1 36.2 36.3
Symmetries and Conservation Laws: Lagrange Formalism . . . . Symmetries and Conservation Laws: Hamilton Formalism . . . . Gauge Invariance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
37. Accidental Symmetries
853 858 864 866 869 875 875 881 887 891
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Contents
37.1 37.2
xxvii
Hydrogen Atom or Quantum Mechanical Kepler Problem . . . . Three-Dimensional Harmonic Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
38. Anomalous Symmetries 38.1 38.2 38.3 38.4 38.5
VIII
901
Generalized Noether Charges and Anomalies Cochains and Boundaries . . . . . . . . . . . BRS Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Landau Problem: 1. Variation . . . . . . . . Cohomology of Lie Groups and Algebras * . . 38.5.1 Cohomology of Lie groups . . . . . . 38.5.2 Cohomology of Lie algebras . . . . . 38.5.3 Heisenberg-Weyl group . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
GAUGE SYMMETRIES AND CONSTRAINED SYSTEMS
935
Linear Reduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nonlinear Reduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Constraints and Reduction . . . . . . . . . . Symmetry and Marsden-Weinstein Reduction Dirac Brackets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dirac Brackets and Poisson Structures . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
40. Quantum Reduction of Constrained Systems 40.1 40.2 40.3 40.4 40.5 40.6 40.7 40.8
Gauge Theories as Constrained Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . Finite Dimensional Analogue of Gauge Theories . . . . . . . . Quantum Mechanical Time Evolution of Constrained Systems Quantization of Constrained Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Geometry of Systems with First Class Constraints . . . . . . Geometry of Yang-Mills Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yang-Mills Theory and Poisson-Dirac Brackets . . . . . . . . Faddeev’s Path Integral Formula for Constrained Systems . .
BRS Invariance . . . . . . . . Extended BRS Formalism . . Fradkin-Vilkovisky Theorem . Zinn-Justin Equations . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
935 937 940 942 945 947 949
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
41. BRS Quantization of Constrained Systems 41.1 41.2 41.3 41.4
901 904 907 909 920 920 925 929
933
39. Constrained Systems and Symplectic Reduction 39.1 39.2 39.3 39.4 39.5 39.6
891 895
949 953 957 959 961 965 969 975 981
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
981 984 987 990
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
xxviii
IX
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
WEYL QUANTIZATION
993
42. Weyl Quantization of Bosons
995
42.1 42.2 42.3 42.4 42.5 42.6 42.7
Weyl Order: Real Representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weyl Order: Complex Representation . . . . . . . . . . . . Groenewold-Moyal Bracket . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generalized Weyl Formalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Berezin’s Path Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Other Ordering Schemes and Symbols: Real Representation Other Ordering Schemes and Symbols: Complex Representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.8 Generating Functions and Their Quantum Counterparts . . 42.9 Weyl Ordering and the Path Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.10 Appendix: Pseudodifferential Operators and Weyl Quantization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.10.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.10.2 Symbol calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.10.3 Symbol classes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.10.4 Elliptic pseudodifferential operators . . . . . . . . . 42.10.5 Elliptic pseudodifferential operators on manifolds .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . 1019 . . . 1022 . . . 1025 . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
43. Weyl Quantization of Bosons and Canonical Transformations 43.1 43.2 43.3 43.4 43.5 43.6 43.7
Symplectic Vector Spaces and Symplectic Transformations Complex Structures and Complexifications . . . . . . . . Complex Realization of the Symplectic Group . . . . . . . Heisenberg-Weyl Group and Quantization . . . . . . . . . Metaplectic Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bargmann Transform . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Symplectic Transformations and Quantum Mechanics . .
Generalized Coherent States: SU(2) . . . . . . . . . Coherent States: Noncompact Picture . . . . . . . . Coherent State Path Integral: Noncompact Picture . Coherent States: Compact Picture . . . . . . . . . . Coherent State Path Integral: Compact Picture . . . Spin Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44.6.1 Ferromagnets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44.6.2 Antiferromagnets: Ground state . . . . . . . 44.6.3 Antiferromagnets: Quadratic approximation 44.6.4 Antiferromagnets and Chern-Simons term . 44.6.5 Topological solitons . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1026 1027 1028 1031 1036 1037 1039
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
44. Geometric Quantization and Spin 44.1 44.2 44.3 44.4 44.5 44.6
995 1000 1003 1006 1008 1016
1039 1041 1046 1049 1051 1057 1058 1067
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
1067 1075 1077 1079 1080 1085 1086 1087 1090 1093 1096
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Contents
xxix
44.6.6 Topological solitons and Hopf fibration . . . . . . . . . . 1098 44.6.7 Hopf invariant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1101 44.6.8 Hopf invariant and Chern-Simons term . . . . . . . . . . 1102 45. Weyl Quantization of Fermions 45.1 45.2 45.3
Canonical Symmetry: Weyl and Spinorial Operator . Weyl Ordered Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fermionic Heisenberg-Weyl Transformation of Wave Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45.4 Antiholomorphic Representation . . . . . . . . . . . 45.5 Complex Realization of Rotations . . . . . . . . . . . 45.6 Quantum Mechanical Representation of Canonical Transformations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45.7 Fermionic Weyl Formalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45.8 Groenewold-Moyal Bracket for Fermions . . . . . . . 45.9 Generalized Weyl Formalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45.10 Berezin’s Path Integral for Fermions . . . . . . . . . 45.11 Partition Function in the Weyl Approach . . . . . .
X
1107 . . . . . . . 1107 . . . . . . . 1110 . . . . . . . 1111 . . . . . . . 1112 . . . . . . . 1114 . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
ANOMALIES IN QUANTUM FIELD THEORY
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
1116 1118 1120 1122 1124 1130
1137
46. Anomalies and Index Theorems 46.1
46.2 46.3 46.4
46.5
Axial Anomaly . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.1.1 Chiral fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.1.2 Quantization of chiral fermions . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.1.3 Computation of the axial anomaly: Heat kernel regularization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.1.4 Computation of the axial anomaly: Zeta-function regularization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.1.5 Physical origin of the axial anomaly . . . . . . . . . 46.1.6 Axial anomaly and the supersymmetric proof of the theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Axial Gauge Anomaly . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Physical Consequences of Anomalies . . . . . . . . . . . . . Anomalies and Geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.4.1 Chern-Weil theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.4.2 Algebraic approach to anomalies . . . . . . . . . . . 46.4.3 Anomalies and cohomology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gravitational Anomalies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.5.1 Supersymmetric proof of the index theorem: External case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1139 . . . 1139 . . . 1139 . . . 1141 . . . 1143 . . . . . . index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1147 1151 1160 1169 1173 1174 1174 1184 1186 1193
. . . 1194
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
xxx
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
46.6 46.7
46.8
46.5.2 Index theorems for the classical complexes . Supersymmetric Relativistic Point Particle with Spin Appendix: Spin and Spinc Structures . . . . . . . . 46.7.1 Orientations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.7.2 Spin structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46.7.3 Spin c structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Geometric Gauge Fixing Conditions . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
47. Integrated Anomalies 47.1
47.2 47.3
XI
Pure Non-Abelian Chern-Simons Theory 47.1.1 Classical properties . . . . . . . 47.1.2 Quantization . . . . . . . . . . . Nonabelian Schwinger Model . . . . . . Chiral Nonabelian Schwinger Model . .
1227 . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
NONCOMMUTATIVE GEOMETRY
48.2
48.3
48.4
48.5
1253
Basic Algebraic Tools . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48.1.1 Modules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48.1.2 Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Noncommutative Differential Geometry . . . . . . . . 48.2.1 Universal differential graded algebras . . . . . 48.2.2 Universal connexions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48.2.3 Hermitian connexions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48.2.4 Gauge transformations . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyclic Cohomology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48.3.1 Elements of homological algebra . . . . . . . . 48.3.2 Noncommutative integral calculus . . . . . . . Graded Cyclic Cohomology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48.4.1 Z/2-graded modules and algebras . . . . . . . 48.4.2 Cyclic cohomology for Z/2-graded algebras . . Berezin Integration and Graded Cyclic Cohomology *
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
49. Noncommutative Geometry: Analytic Tools 49.1 49.2 49.3 49.4 49.5
Spectral Triples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Spectral Triples and Universal Differential Dixmier Trace . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wodzicki Residue . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Real Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49.5.1 Classification of Clifford algebras
1227 1228 1231 1236 1245
1251
48. Noncommutative Geometry: Algebraic Tools 48.1
1199 1210 1214 1215 1216 1217 1219
1254 1254 1259 1268 1268 1273 1275 1276 1277 1277 1281 1285 1285 1290 1296 1321
. . . . . Calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
1321 1325 1329 1335 1342 1342
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Contents
xxxi
49.5.2 Charge conjugation in four dimensions 49.5.3 Real structure in arbitrary dimension . 49.5.4 Spectral triples with a real structure . . 49.6 Order One and Orientation . . . . . . . . . . . 49.7 Regularity and Finiteness . . . . . . . . . . . . 49.8 Axiomatic Foundation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49.9 Internal Symmetries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49.10 Appendix: Review of C ∗ -Algebra Basics . . . . 49.10.1 Banach spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49.10.2 Continuous linear operators . . . . . . 49.10.3 Banach algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49.10.4 C ∗ -algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
50. Noncommutative Geometry : Particle Physics 50.1 50.2
50.3
Fermionic Action . . . Bosonic Action . . . . 50.2.1 Spectral action 50.2.2 Spectral action 50.2.3 Spectral action 50.2.4 Spectral action 50.2.5 Spectral action Outlook . . . . . . . .
1367
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . for Yang-Mills fields coupled to gravity for a Higgs field coupled to gravity . . . and cosmology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . and nonzero torsion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
51. A Glance at Noncommutative Quantum Field Theory 51.1
51.2 51.3
XII
Noncommutative Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51.1.1 Noncommutative spacetime . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51.1.2 Noncommutative 2-dimensional torus . . . . . . . Landau Problem: 2. Variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Noncommutative Quantum Field Theory . . . . . . . . . . 51.3.1 Scalar field theory on noncommutative spacetime 51.3.2 Gauge theory on noncommutative spacetime . . . 51.3.3 Scalar field theory on a noncommutative torus . . 51.3.4 Gauge theory on a noncommutative torus . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
1391 1391 1393 1397 1399 1399 1402 1404 1407
1413
52. Hopf Algebras Motivation Algebras . . Coalgebras Bialgebras .
1368 1369 1370 1373 1376 1382 1386 1389 1391
QUANTUM GROUPS
52.1 52.2 52.3 52.4
1346 1348 1349 1349 1352 1353 1354 1358 1358 1361 1362 1364
1415 . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
1415 1417 1422 1427
April 8, 2013
14:15
xxxii
52.5 52.6
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Hopf Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1430 Hopf ∗-Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1441
53. Quasitriangular Hopf Algebras 53.1 53.2 53.3 53.4 53.5
1447
Almost Cocommutative Hopf Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quasitriangular Hopf Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ribbon Hopf Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Matrix Realizations of the Universal R-Operator and Artin’s Braid Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quasitriangular Hopf Algebras and ∗-Structures . . . . . . . . . .
54. Quantum Groups: Basic Example 54.1 54.2 54.3 54.4 54.5 54.6 54.7 54.8
XIII
Motivation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Uq (sl2 ) as an Algebra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Uq (sl2 ) as a Hopf Algebra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Uq (sl2 ) as a Quasitriangular Hopf Algebra . . . . . . . . Uq (sl2 ) as a Quasitriangular Ribbon Hopf Algebra . . . Elements of q-Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Real Forms of Uq (sl2 ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Representation Theory of Uq (sl2 ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54.8.1 Deformation parameter not a root of unity . . . 54.8.2 Deformation parameter a primitive root of unity 54.8.3 Unitarity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54.8.4 Quasitriangularity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54.8.5 Example: Deformed harmonic oscillator . . . . .
NONCOMMUTATIVE GEOMETRY AND QUANTUM GROUPS
55. Quantum Groups and the Noncommutative Torus 55.1 55.2
1462 1465 1467
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
1467 1469 1470 1473 1475 1476 1479 1483 1483 1485 1488 1491 1495
1497 1499
Landau Problem: 3. Variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1500 Weyl Quantization and Quantum Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1501
56. Quantum Hall Effect with Realistic Boundary Conditions Index
1447 1451 1456
1505 I-1
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
PART I
CLASSICAL RELATIVISTIC FIELD THEORY: KINEMATICAL ASPECTS
1
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
2
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Chapter 1
RELATIVISTIC FREE FIELDS: BOSONS
In our first approach to the subject of quantum field theory we begin by neglecting the qualification ‘quantum’, i.e. we restrict ourselves to classical field theory. Simplifying even further, we start with a discussion of free classical fields, of which the electromagnetic field is a main example. It opens the opportunity to introduce relativistic notation and the underlying symmetry, the Lorentz and Poincar´e group. Furthermore, one can relate such relativistic fields to the realm of classical mechanics on restricting the system to a finite lattice so that traditional methods are available. Hence the only prerequisites needed are the basic facts of classical electrodynamics. Accordingly, a convenient point of departure for an approach to relativistic field theory should be provided by the Maxwell equations, dating back to the year 1864; indeed, they stand objections up to the present day. The gravitational analogue of Coulomb’s law is Newton’s law; though the latter force is by many orders of magnitude weaker than the electric force and always attractive, nevertheless, it is a rather strange fact that both laws look that similar. The Einstein-Hilbert theory of general relativity from 1915 attempts a similar description of gravitational phenomena, and often Einstein is viewed as the legitimate successor of Maxwell. For many people, Einstein’s theory even seems to have a better reputation than Maxwell’s since it is expected to reveal the origin of our universe, and so it is also attributed a rather philosophical or even religious attitude. As opposed to the former theory, however, which can successfully be quantized and is in perfect agreement with the available experimental data, general relativity has resisted quantization up to now, and will do so also in future since it is an effective theory only, the validity of which is restricted to the domain of low energies. Hence, Maxwell’s and Einstein’s theory also differ by orders of magnitude as is concerning the degree and power of prediction.
1.1
Maxwell’s Equations in Relativistic Notation
The reasons why electrodynamics is ideally suited to gain a first understanding of relativistic field theory are twofold. The first is that the particles, which are 3
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
4
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
described by the (free) Maxwell equations, are massless photons; we shall see this below. Hence, they are always relativistic, as it is reflected in the fact that the velocity of light makes its appearance. The second reason is that Planck’s constant is miraculously absent from these equations, and so one seems to be outside of the domain of quantum mechanics; thence it appears that a classical treatment is possible. The equations governing electromagnetic phenomena are (in HeavisideLorentz units) ∇×H =
1 ∂ 1 D+ J c ∂t c
∇·D =ρ
(1.1)
1 ∂ B. (1.2) c ∂t ˙ Maxwell’s essential new insight was the discovery of the term D/c on the right hand ∇·B = 0
∇×E =−
side of the first of the eqs. (1.1); as we shall see, its presence guarantees the charge conservation law. For now we simply accept the validity of the Maxwell equations; their deeper origin will be revealed later. The above equations divide into two groups; the first group (1.1) containing the current J and charge density ρ are true equations of motion, whereas the second group (1.2) constitute compatibility requirements. We begin with the latter, the first equation of which can be solved by means of the vector potential A in the form B = ∇ × A.
(1.3)
But this representation is not unique since the transition to A′ = A−∇α, where α is a scalar function of space and time, leaves the magnetic field strengths unaltered in the sense that B ′ = B holds. This kind of freedom in choosing the vector potential is called gauge invariance, for perverse historical reasons. Now we can use (1.3) to treat the second equation in (1.2), which gives 1 ∂ ∇× E + A =0 c ∂t and this is solved on introducing the scalar potential ϕ by 1 ∂ A. (1.4) c ∂t If we pass in this equation from A to A′ , then this entails that we must pass also from ϕ to a ϕ′ such that E = E ′ holds. In order to determine ϕ′ , we only need to consider 1 ∂ 1 ∂ 1 ∂ ′ A = −∇ϕ′ − A+ ∇α = E E ′ = −∇ϕ′ − c ∂t c ∂t c ∂t from which we read off 1 ∂ α ϕ′ = ϕ + c ∂t telling us how the scalar potential behaves under gauge transformations. What we have achieved on passing from E and B to the vector and scalar potential is that E = −∇ϕ −
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
5
the degrees of freedom are reduced from six to four, which is an essential reduction; beyond this, gauge invariance will enable us to restrict the potentials even further by imposing one additional condition, called a gauge fixing condition. The origin of gauge invariance, which at the present stage is observed in a rather experimental manner, can only be understood in a quantum mechanical context; we shall later clarify the deeper meaning of gauge invariance in detail. Note that the representations (1.3) and (1.4) are sufficient criteria for fulfilling the second couple of Maxwell equations; what we actually need is the other direction. This is supplied by Poincar´ e’s lemma, the content of which is the following (see, e.g., Flanders(1963)). Let U be a contractible subset of
Rn ; a differential p-form ω on U
is called closed if dω = 0, and exact if it can
be written as ω = dλ where λ is a (p − 1)-form. Then Poincar´ e’s lemma states that a closed form is exact, i.e. one can find a (p − 1)-form λ defined in U such that ω = dλ holds; this λ is unique
1 ε dxj ∧ dxk , which is 2 ijk λ = Ai dxi with dλ = B i σi , dω = (∇ × E)i σi = 0; for
up to an exact form. For the magnetic field, we set ω = B i σi with σi =
a 2-form. Since dω = ∂i
B i d3 x
it is closed; hence we can find a 1-form
giving the assertion. For the electric field, we take ω = Ei dxi with
simplicity, only the time-independent case is considered. We can thus find a 0-form λ = −ϕ, giving dλ = −∇i ϕdxi , which is what we wanted to show. To summarize, the representation of the electric and magnetic field strengths in terms of the scalar and vector potential is guaranteed
by the Poincar´ e lemma. What we also learn is that a formulation of Maxwell’s theory in terms of differential forms seems to be appropriate.
Turning now to the first couple of Maxwell equations (1.1), we restrict ourselves to the microscopic case with ε = 1 = µ so that the relations D = E and H = B are valid. Making use of the identity ∇ × (∇ × V ) = ∇(∇ · V ) − ∇ · ∇V , they take the at first sight rather unappetizing form ! 2 1 ∂ 1 1 ∂ −∇·∇ A+∇ ϕ+∇·A = J (1.5) c ∂t c ∂t c
1 ∂ c ∂t
2
!
−∇·∇ ϕ−
1 ∂ c ∂t
1 ∂ ϕ+∇·A = ρ c ∂t
(1.6)
where in the second equation we have added and subtracted the first and third term on the left-hand side. Then the operator which in both of these equations acts on the first term, is recognized as a a generalization of the Laplace operator, and it is this observation that suggests to introduce a new notation which makes this fact apparent. What the new notation looked for must take care of is the fundamental fact that the second time derivative and the Laplacian in the operator in question carry a relative minus sign. So let us unite the modified time coordinate x0 = ct and the spatial vector x = (xi )i=1,2,3 in a single 4-component vector with components xµ , where the Greek index takes the values µ = 0, 1, 2, 3, that is x = (x0 , x) = (xµ )µ=0,1,2,3 .
(1.7)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
6
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Furthermore, in order to consider the relative minus sign, one is unavoidably led to introduce the metric tensor +1 −1 (gµν )µ,ν=0,1,2,3 = (1.8) −1 −1
where all elements not explicitly indicated are zero. The inverse, denoted g µν , has the same matrix representation as in (1.8) and obeys g µρ gρν = δ µ ν
(1.9)
where δ µ ν is the standard Kronecker symbol. Our notation is such that a vector always carries an upper (contravariant) index, whereas a covector always carries a lower (covariant) index. Furthermore we adopt the convention, when the same index appears once in an upper position and once in a lower position, then a summation is understood to occur on that index; to give an example: vµ wµ :=
3 X
vµ wµ .
µ=0
This economical Einstein summation convention is used throughout. The metric tensor is also employed to raise or lower an index, for example v µ = g µν vν
wµ = gµν wν
and hence x0 = x0 , whereas xi = −xi . In addition, by means of the metric tensor we introduce an inner product x · y = xµ gµν y ν = x0 y 0 − x · y
(1.10)
which is nondegenerate, but indefinite since x · x can take positive and negative values. The four-dimensional real vector space equipped with this inner product is called Minkowski space. Furthermore, also the abbreviating notation ∂ ∂µ = (1.11) ∂xµ for the partial derivatives is introduced; the reason why the index on the partial derivative is chosen in lower position will be given later when we discuss Lorentz transformations. Finally, the Minkowskian analogue of the Laplacian in 3-space is the operator 2 1 ∂ µν µ −∇·∇ (1.12) g ∂µ ∂ν = ∂ ∂µ = c ∂t
which is also known as the d’Alembert operator. This ends our discussion on notational conventions in Minkowski space. For a novice, such a fumbling around with indices is often disgusting; indeed, it is and has also always been so for mathematicians, who thus aim at giving a coordinate independent description. This can easily be accomplished in the present context,
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
7
but the most efficient formulation of electrodynamics is by means of differential forms; nevertheless, for our more moderate aims at this stage, there is often no way out in giving the final result explicitly in terms of coordinates. Let us return now to the preliminary equations (1.5) and (1.6); we set ∇ = (∇i )i=1,2,3 and A = (Ai )i=1,2,3 , and unite the latter vector potential together with A0 = ϕ into a 4-vector potential; the same is done with cρ = J 0 for the current and the charge density. Then we obtain the compact form ∂ µ ∂µ Aν − ∂ ν ∂µ Aµ =
1 ν J c
(1.13)
and the gauge transformed 4-potential now is A′µ = Aµ + ∂µ α.
(1.14)
The connection with the original Maxwell equations can be made more manifest on introducing the field strength tensor Fµν = ∂µ Aν − ∂ν Aµ .
(1.15)
This is a gauge invariant quantity because ′ Fµν = ∂µ A′ν − ∂ν A′µ = ∂µ Aν − ∂ν Aµ + ∂µ ∂ν α − ∂ν ∂µ α = Fµν
where we have assumed that, under appropriate smoothness conditions on the 4potential, the partial derivatives commute. Hence, the field strength tensor should be related to the electric and magnetic fields; indeed, the relation is F 0i = −E i
F 12 = −B 3 , . . . .
(1.16)
Now we can rewrite the equations (1.13) as 1 ν J (1.17) c which is the final version in Minkowski space notation. On using (1.16), they are easily seen to reduce to the first set of Maxwell’s equations; but the information being contained in (1.17) goes beyond that of the equations (1.1) since in view of (1.15) the six degrees of freedom E and B are replaced by the four components Aµ of the gauge potential, which is an essential reduction. The compatibility equations can be brought into a similar form. For this purpose, we introduce the dual field strength tensor ∂µ F µν =
∗
Fµν =
1 εµνρτ F ρτ 2
(1.18)
where εµνρτ is the Levi-Civit` a tensor in 4 dimensions with normalization ε0123 = 1; the remaining Maxwell equations may then be written as follows: ∂ µ∗ Fµν = 0.
(1.19)
We give the verification of this equation since a simple, though effective, argument gets involved which will repeatedly be made use of; it is for this reason why we
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
8
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
explain it here once and for all. Let Aµν be an antisymmetric, and Sµν be a symmetric tensor; then the following sum is identically zero Aµν Sµν = Aνµ Sνµ = −Aµν Sµν = 0 since, for the first equality, we only need to rename the summation indices and, for the second, use the antisymmetry of A and the symmetry of S. The same argument applies to ∂ µ∗ Fµν =
1 εµνρτ ∂ µ F ρτ = εµνρτ ∂ µ ∂ ρ Aτ = 0 2
because the Levi-Civit` a tensor is completely antisymmetric in all its indices and the partial derivatives commute. We leave it to the reader to check that (1.19) reduces to the second couple of Maxwell’s equations. After all, no further comment is needed why the Maxwell equations (1.17) entail the conservation law for the 4-current ∂µ J µ = 0.
(1.20)
This reduces to the standard conservation law, on the assumption that the current is nonvanishing only in the interior of a (large enough) 3-volume V 3 , as in this case Z Z Z d d 3 xρ + d 3 x∇i J i d 3 x∂µ J µ = dt V 3 V3 V3 Z Z d d 3 = d xρ + dσi J i = Q = 0 dt V 3 dt 3 ∂V where we have used the 3-dimensional Gauss theorem. Hence, the 4-dimensional conservation law for the current reduces to the well-known conservation of charge.
We collect here the main properties of the Levi-Civit` a tensor ε i1 ···id in d euclidean dimensions. By definition, it is skewsymmetric under the exchange of any two indices and normalized to ε1···d = 1; denoting by π(i1 · · · id ) the permutation which maps (i1 , . . . , id ) to natural order, we have ε i1 ··· id = (−1)|π(i1 ···id )| (1.21) with (−1)|π| the sign of the permutation. In three euclidean dimensions, the ε-tensor can be represented as a determinant i 1 1 δ 1 δ i2 δ i3 δ l δ m δ 1n ε ij k = δ j 1 δ j 2 δ j 3 ε lmn = δ 2 l δ 2 m δ 2 n (1.22) δ k1 δ k2 δ k3 δ 3l δ 3m δ 3n
where the raising and lowering of indices is performed with the (Kronecker) metric tensor; for the product, this gives i δ l δ im δ in j ij k j j ε ε lmn = δ l δ m δ n (1.23) δ kl δ km δ kn
since the determinant of the product of two square matrices is equal to the product of the individual determinants. Contracting over one index, the result is ε ij k ε imn = δ j m δ k n − δ j n δ k m .
(1.24)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
9
In Minkowski space with the signature (+, −, −, −), we have ε 0123 = 1 and ε 0123 = −1; this is the reason why in −ε µνρσ ε αβγσ = + g µ α g ν β g ρ γ + g µ γ g ν α g ρ β + g µ β g ν γ g ρ α
(1.25)
−ε µνρσ ε αβρσ = 2! (g µ α g ν β − g µ β g ν α )
(1.26)
− g µα g ν γ g ρβ − g µγ g ν β g ρα − g µβ g ν α g ργ
−ε
µνρσ
ε ανρσ = 3! g
µ
α
(1.27)
a minus sign appears on the left hand side. In d euclidean dimensions, the general formula is X 1 i1 ··· ip ip+1 ··· id ε ε i1 ··· ip jp+1 ··· jd = (−1)|π| δ ip+1 jπ(p+1) · · · δ id jπ(d) . (1.28) p! π∈S d−p
As a useful application of the Levi-Civit` a tensor, let A = (A i j ) i,j=1,...,d be a square matrix, with i the row and j the column index; its determinant |A| can be written in the form ε i1 ··· id |A| = ε j1 ··· jd A i1 j1 · · · A id jd . (1.29) For the verification one only needs to recall eq. (1.21), which relates the ε-symbol to the sign of the corresponding permutation.
1.2
Klein-Gordon Equation
As is well known, Maxwell’s equations entail the Coulomb law; this fact can be demonstrated by elementary means. For reasons to become apparent below, we here give a derivation which makes essential use of the method of Green’s functions. For this purpose, we go back to Maxwell’s equations in the form (1.13) and consider the second term on the left-hand side. This contains the quantity ∂ µ Aµ , which one may get rid of on invoking gauge invariance. We shall later see that one can always achieve the Lorentz condition to hold: ∂ µ Aµ = 0.
(1.30)
Then only the first term in (1.13) survives, of which we take the 0th component: ∂µ ∂ µ ϕ(x) = ρ(x).
(1.31)
Furthermore, we assume the given charge density to be independent of time, i.e., we consider the static case where ∆ϕ(x) = ρ(x) with −∇ · ∇ = ∆ the Laplace operator. This Poisson equation is solved on looking for the solution of the simpler equation ∆ G(x) = δ(x) where G(x) is called the Green’s function; if it is known, then we can immediately write down the solution of the original equation: Z ϕ(x) = G(x − x′ )ρ(x′ )d3 x′ . (1.32)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
10
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
The defining equation for the Green’s function is solved by Fourier transformation Z 1 ˜ G(x) = d3 k eik x G(k) (1.33) (2π)3
˜ and insertion yields G(k) = 1/k2 ; but this function is singular at the origin. To make it well-defined, we modify Coulomb’s equation as follows ∆ + µ2 ϕ(x) = ρ(x) (1.34) where µ is a parameter with the dimension of an inverse length that, if this procedure ˜ works, is set equal to zero in the end. The Fourier transform G(k) = 1/(k2 + µ2 ) of the Green’s function is now well defined at the origin, and so the integral (1.33) can be evaluated on introducing polar coordinates. Exploiting rotational invariance, we may choose x as the third axis in k-space, and thus 1 G(x) = (2π)3
Z∞ Zπ Z2π 0
0
k2
1 eikr cos θ k 2 dk sin θdθdϕ + µ2
0
where k = |k| and r = |x|. The integration over ϕ can immediately be done; further, we perform the change of variables θ 7→ z = kr cos θ so that dz = −kr sin θdθ, where an additional minus sign comes in since z = +kr at θ = 0 and z = −kr at θ = π, and so +kr Z∞ Z Z∞ 1 k 1 k sin kr iz G(x) = dk e dz = dk. 2 2 2 2 4π r k +µ 2π r k 2 + µ2 0
−kr
0
The remaining integral is of a generalized Dirichlet type (see Gradshteyn and Ryzhik (1965), formula (3.723.3) there) Z∞ k sin kr π dk 2 = e−µr . (1.35) 2 k +µ 2 0
Hence, the final result is G(x) =
1 e−µ|x| 4π|x|
(1.36)
which is the Yukawa potential ; it is a screened Coulomb potential in the sense that it tends to zero faster than 1/|x| when |x| approaches infinity. We take this result as an indication that it makes sense to generalize (1.34), and so also (1.31), to the case where µ takes nonzero values. The parameter µ should contain a mass m, and what we must arrange is that µ−1 has the dimension of a length. In order to construct such a quantity out of m and c we need an additional fundamental constant with the dimension of an action, denoted ~; hence, it is Planck’s constant which we must invent for dimensional reasons. Then the parameter µ, we are looking for, can be written in the form µ−1 = ~/mc
(1.37)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
11
which is called the Compton wave length of the particle of mass m; its meaning will be explained later. To summarize, we expect the equation ~2 ∂µ ∂ µ + m2 c2 ϕ(x) = 0 (1.38)
to make sense as a straightforward generalization of the free Maxwell equations in terms of the 4-potential. This is called the Klein-Gordon equation; it was known to Schr˝ odinger even before that equation, which now bears his name, but rejected for reasons to be discussed.
1.3
Group Velocity and Special Relativity
The Klein-Gordon equation can easily be solved by Fourier transformation. In order to show this, we first try a solution of the form ϕ(x) ∼ e−ik·x where k is an arbitrary 4-vector with the dimension of an inverse length. Insertion into (1.38) then implies that k must obey ~2 k 2 = (mc)2 .
(1.39)
Let us introduce the energy-momentum 4-vector p = ~k, which yields the fundamental relation p2 = m2 c2 of special relativity. It can be solved for the 0th component p 1 p 0 = m2 c2 + p 2 = E (1.40) c where, for the present purposes, we restrict ourselves to the positive square root; the discussion of the other possibility is postponed to a later stage. The identification of the energy E makes sense at least for purely dimensional reasons. The phase of the exponent then takes the form k · x = (Et − px)/~; since a solution of the Klein-Gordon equation is obtained by linear superposition, it thus reads Z i 1 ϕ(x, t) = d 3 p e− ~ (Et−p x) ϕ(p). ˜ (1.41) (2π~)3 For the moment the explicit form of the dispersion relation, i.e. the dependence of E on the 3-momentum, is left open. Furthermore, we consider the special situation where the Fourier transform ϕ(p) ˜ is nonvanishing only in the neighbourhood of a ◦ fixed 3-momentum p; then the energy can be expanded ◦ ∂E ∂E ∂E ◦ E=E+ p ◦ + ◦ (p − p) + · · · = E − p+ ··· ∂p p ∂p ∂p p◦ p so that, if the dotted terms are omitted, the Klein-Gordon field may approximately be written Z ∂E d3 p i ∂E i E− p ◦ t exp − t − x p ϕ(p). ˜ ϕ(x, t) = exp − ~ ∂p (2π~)3 ~ ∂p p◦ p This latter form can be simplified to give i ∂E ∂E ϕ(x, t) = exp − E− p ◦ t ϕ(x − (1.42) t, 0) ~ ∂p ∂p p◦ p
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
12
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
where the first factor is identified as a phase, and the second as an amplitude that no longer depends explicitly on time. The amplitude is constant if v=
∂E ∂p
(1.43)
holds; here we can dispense from now on with the superscript on p, without giving rise to confusion. This quantity governs the time-evolution of constant values of the amplitude, and also the maximum of its modulus; it is called the group velocity. Making use of the dispersion relation (1.40), the group velocity takes the explicit form c2 p v= . (1.44) E Since E ≥ c|p|, with the equality sign holding for m = 0, we thus conclude from (1.44) that the group velocity obeys v≤c
(1.45)
where v = |v|. Hence, for a wave function that is strongly localized in k-space, we can introduce the group velocity; it describes the time-evolution of a wave packet and, for a massive field, this is always strictly less than the velocity c. By contrast, a massless ‘photon’ always propagates at the velocity of light. One may also introduce a phase velocity, the definition of which is suggested by eq. (1.41) to be E . |p|
(1.46)
vph vgr = c2
(1.47)
vph =
It is related to the group velocity v = vgr by
which implies that the phase velocity is always greater than, or at least equal, to the velocity of light. What one can determine in an experiment, however, this is the group velocity, but not the phase velocity. We return to the relations (1.40) and (1.44), which may be used to express the energy and the 3-momentum in terms of the (group) velocity with the result m c p= p . (1.48) 2 v 1 − (v/c) Hence, the Klein-Gordon equation is capable of yielding a basic result of special relativity; this is the above relation, giving us the 4-momentum expressed through the velocity. In accordance with what we have learned from the group velocity, these relations become meaningless in the limit where v approaches the velocity of light, which thus represents a limiting velocity for massive (free) fields. Let us note that in the literature one often finds p a quantity m(v), called the dynamical mass, which is defined as m(v) = m/ 1 − (v/c)2 : But we do not use that term because the mass m characterizes an intrinsic property of a particle. As
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
13
can also be inferred from the defining equation p2 = m2 c2 , this is a quantity being independent of the kinematic status of the particle, i.e. it is independent of its velocity. We conclude with a remark on what are called tachyons; they are obtained by reversing the sign of the mass term so that the field equation now reads ~2 ∂µ ∂ µ − m2 c2 ϕ(x) = 0.
For a plane wave solution e−ik·x , we thus find the relation p2 + m2 c2 = 0 where p = ~ k, and so p 0 2 = p2 − m2 c2 ≥ 0 implies p2 ≥ m2 c2 . Then the same kind of logic as used above yields v = ∂E/∂p = c2 p/E for the group velocity, but now p 0 = E/c < |p| entails that v > c; hence, tachyons always propagate at a (group) velocity strictly greater than the velocity of light. Though much discussed in the science fiction literature, however, such tachyonic particles have never been observed in nature. 1.4
Nonrelativistic Limit and the Schr˝ odinger Equation
Let us investigate the nonrelativistic limit v ≪ c of the massive Klein-Gordon equation. Under this assumption eq. (1.48) entails |p| ≪ mc, and so we obtain the following expansion of the energy: s 1 2 p2 E = mc2 1 + = mc2 + p + ··· (1.49) 2 (mc) 2m The first term on the right side is called the rest energy, for obvious reasons, and the second term is recognized as the kinetic energy of a free (massive) particle. Accordingly, we separate off the dominant term in the energy and make the following ansatz for the (complex) Klein-Gordon wave function i
2
ϕ(ct, x) = e− ~ mc t ψ(x, t).
(1.50)
Insertion into the Klein-Gordon equation then yields ∂ ~2 ∂ 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 −~ ∇ + m c − m c − 2im~ + 2 2 ψ(x, t) = 0 ∂t c ∂t so that the contribution from the rest energy cancels against the mass term. Furthermore, in the limit c → ∞ the second time-derivative can be neglected, and we thus find ∂ ~2 2 ∇ ψ(x, t) = i~ ψ(x, t) (1.51) 2m ∂t which is the free Schr˝ odinger equation. In conclusion, the nonrelativistic limit of the massive Klein-Gordon equation is recognized to be the basic equation of quantum mechanics. Turning the argument around, also the Klein-Gordon equation is a quantum mechanical equation; hence, even though a nonrelativistic limit for −
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Maxwell’s equations does not exist, the latter as well are of quantum mechanical origin ! For the general case, we must anticipate the Pauli equation; it is obtained in sec. 5.5 from the Dirac equation in an external electromagnetic field. If we neglect in (5.72) the coupling to the spin, then one can perform the restriction to one component of the 2-spinor; in this way the Schr¨ odinger equation ~2 e 2 i~ψ˙ = − ∇ + i A ψ + Uψ 2m ~c with interaction is derived from first principles. To say it in modern jargon, already at this level the Dirac operator appears to be the ‘high end’ construct of quantum mechanics.
1.5
Classical Interpretation of Fields
Remarkably, a relativistic field admits a classical interpretation as a system of classical mechanics with a finite number of degrees of freedom if it is put on a finite lattice; this is the topic to be addressed below. In order to pursue the announced program, we simplify the situation by restricting the Klein-Gordon field to one space dimension; furthermore, the one coordinate x is restricted to a finite interval of length X: X X ≤x≤+ . (1.52) 2 2 This is implemented for the field by imposing periodic boundary conditions −
ϕ(x + X, t) = ϕ(x, t).
(1.53)
We also choose natural units with ~ = c = 1 so that all quantities with a physical dimension can be expressed in terms of a fundamental length; then the Klein-Gordon equation takes the form 2 ∂ ∂2 2 − 2 + m ϕ(x, t) = 0. (1.54) ∂t2 ∂x The essential step will be to discretize the system; hence, we divide X into N subintervals of length a, the lattice constant, viz. N N ,...,+ (1.55) 2 2 where N is assumed to be even. For the field evaluated in the lattice points we introduce the notation 1 ϕ(x, t) x=an = 1/2 qn (t) (1.56) a where the prefactor on the right side will find its explanation below. The differential quotient in the x-coordinate admits two versions (ϕ(x + a) − ϕ(x)) /a d ϕ(x) = lim (1.57) a→0 dx (ϕ(x) − ϕ(x − a)) /a x = an
: n=−
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
15
so that the discretized second derivative can be written as d2 d 1 1 ϕ(x) ≡ (ϕ(x) − ϕ(x − a)) ≡ 2 (ϕ(x + a) − ϕ(x) − ϕ(x) + ϕ(x − a)) . 2 dx dx a a Hence, on the lattice the Klein-Gordon equation takes the form 1 (1.58) q¨n = − 2 [(qn − qn+1 ) + (qn − qn−1 )] − m2 qn a where the boundary conditions are periodic: qn+N = qn .
(1.59)
This simulation of the field theoretic problem can be interpreted as a chain of N masses (of unit mass), which are coupled by springs to their equilibrium position and to the next neighbours. Thus, the interaction is local; it is attractive if qn −qn±1 takes positive values and repulsive in the opposite case. Note that we could have started as well from the massless (Maxwell) case; the generalization to the massive case would then be suggested by the addition of the harmonic term, being proportional to the mass squared. Since we now have a system of classical mechanics, all the standard techniques are available, such as the Lagrangian formalism. In particular, we can construct the Lagrange function from the equations of motion. These are written in the form ∂ (1.60) V (q) : q = (q− N , . . . , q N −1 ) q¨n = − 2 2 ∂qn where the potential is N 2 −1 X 1 1 2 2 2 V (q) = (qn+1 − qn ) + m qn . (1.61) 2 a2 N n=−
2
Hence, the Lagrangian is −1 X 1 1 1 2 q˙n − 2 (qn+1 − qn )2 − m2 qn2 2 2a 2 N
N 2
L=T −V =
n=−
(1.62)
2
and what we want is to return to the continuum. This is achieved by means of the representation of an integral through a Riemannian sum N +X/2 Z 2 −1 a → 0 X dx f (x) = lim a f (an) : X = aN fixed (1.63) a→∞ N → ∞ N n=− −X/2 2 which, for the case at hand, gives ( ) +X/2 2 2 Z 1 ∂ 1 ∂ 1 2 2 L(t) = dx ϕ(x, t) − ϕ(x, t) − m ϕ(x, t) . 2 ∂t 2 ∂x 2
(1.64)
−X/2
Here the particular normalization chosen in (1.56) finds its explanation since it provides the prefactor a in the Riemannian sum. The transition to the 3-dimensional
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
16
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
case is readily performed by the substitutions n → n and x → x, where the generalization of (1.56) is 1 ϕ(x, t) = 3/2 qn (t). (1.65) a We thus obtain in relativistic notation Z Z 1 1 ∂µ ϕ(x)∂ µ ϕ(x) − m2 ϕ(x)2 = d 3 xL(x) (1.66) L(t) = d 3x 2 2 where L(x) = L(ϕ(x), ∂ϕ(x))
(1.67)
is called the Lagrange density. The correspondence rules between classical mechanics and field theory are summarized in the following table: classical mechanics discrete
classical field theory ≡
i
x
continuous
q i (t)
≡
ϕ(x, t)
∂L(t) ∂q i (t)
≡
δL(t) δϕ(x, t)
In words, the transition from a system of classical mechanics with a finite number of degrees of freedom to the field theoretic case is performed on replacing the discrete index i of the generalized coordinates q i (t) by the continuous variable x, and so the corresponding field ϕ(x, t) is obtained; the meaning of the last line will be explained later.
1.6
Normal Coordinates
The equations of motion (1.58) for the Klein-Gordon field on the lattice can be decoupled by means of what are called normal coordinates. Let us pass from the qn to Ql =
N 2
1 N
1 2
−1 X
2π
e−i N ln qn
n=− N 2
: l=−
N N ,...,+ − 1 2 2
(1.68)
where the new variables are constructed such that they are periodic as well: Q∗+l = Q−l .
Ql+N = Ql
(1.69)
This transformation can be inverted by means of the basic identities N
δnn′
2 −1 ′ 2π 1 X e+i N l(n−n ) = N N
l=−
2
N
δll′
2 −1 ′ 2π 1 X = e−i N (l−l )n . N N
n=−
2
(1.70)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
17
For the proof, it is sufficient to show that the following sum vanishes for s = N X
eisn = eis
n=1
N X
eis(n−1) = eis
n=1
2π N l
6= 0:
eis 1 − eisN = (1 − ei2πl ) = 0. 1 − eis 1 − eis
Here, for the second equality sign we have used the geometric progression, and for the last the assumption that N is even. The inversion of (1.68) then is qn = and insertion yields X
qn2 =
n
X n
(qn+1 − qn )2 =
N 2
1 N
1 2
−1 X
2π
e+i N ln Ql
X 1 X X −i 2π (l−l′ )n ∗ Q l Q l′ = Q∗l Ql e N N n ′ l
l,l
X n
(1.71)
l=− N 2
2qn (qn − qn+1 ) =
X n
(qn − qn−1 )2 =
X n
2qn (qn − qn−1 )
X X 2π ±i 2π l ∗ N =2 1−e l Q∗l Ql Ql Ql = 2 1 − cos N l l X π 2 ∗ = 2 sin l Ql Ql N l
where we have repeatedly used the boundary conditions. Hence, the final result for the Lagrangian is 1 X ˙∗ ˙ Ql Ql − ωl2 Q∗l Ql (1.72) L= 2 l
with
2
ωl =
2 π sin l a N
2
+ m2 .
(1.73)
What we have achieved by means of the normal coordinates is that the new Lagrangian is the sum of N decoupled oscillators, but the frequency (1.73) depends on l, the points of the dual lattice. For the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion, we need ∂L = Q˙ ∗l = Pl∗ ∂ Q˙ l
(1.74)
where one has to take care of the relation Q∗l = Q−l , which supplies a factor of two. The equations of motion are ¨ + ω2Q = 0 Q l l l
: Q∗l = Q−l
the general solution of which can immediately be written down 1 Ql (t) = e−iωl t a+l + e+iωl t a∗−l : al+N = al . r (2ωl )
(1.75)
(1.76)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
18
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Here we have introduced a normalization factor, with the real parameter r remaining to be determined. Let us return to the original variables; on using the periodicity of both the amplitude and the frequency, one finds qn (t) =
+N 2 −1
1 N
1 2
X
l=− N 2
1 −i(ωl t− 2π ln) +i(ωl t− 2π N N ln) a∗ e a + e l l . (2ωl )r
(1.77)
This is the general solution of the Klein-Gordon field on the lattice, with the al being arbitrary expansion coefficients. Note that periodicity allows us to sum as well over the range l = − N2 +1, . . . , + N2 , and thus, with the substitution l → j = l + N/2, also over the range j = 1, . . . , N ; we have chosen the above version in order to make the limit to an infinite lattice accessible. 1.7
Quantized Harmonic Oscillator *
Though this first part is entirely devoted to classical field theory, nevertheless, we take the opportunity to make some basic remarks about canonical quantization of free fields in the present and the next section; they are optional and may be omitted on a first reading. As we have seen, the Klein-Gordon field can be interpreted as a collection of independent harmonic oscillators, if it is put on a lattice; as such, it can then be quantized by applying standard quantum mechanical methods. For this, we begin with a single harmonic oscillator and return to the case at hand in the section to come. A two particle system, being subject to a harmonic force, can be reduced to a one-particle problem on passing to center of mass coordinates with Hamiltonian 1 2 µ 2 2 H= p + ω q (1.78) 2µ 2 where µ is the reduced mass. Instead of solving the associated Schr¨odinger equation directly, which results in the standard energy spectrum and the corresponding eigenfunctions in terms of Hermite polynomials, we choose the algebraic approach; this is singled out by the fact that there is no need to solve any differential equation. The device consists in introducing the operators √ √ ∗ 1 1 ~a = √ ~a = √ (µωq + ip) (µωq − ip) (1.79) 2µω 2µω with commutation relation [a, a∗ ] = 1
(1.80)
where the rationale behind would √ will be explained later. Note that a better choice ∗ be to omit the factor ~ so that we then have the commutator [a, a ] = ~ with
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
19
Planck’s constant appearing on the right-hand side; but we here follow general custom. The Hamiltonian then takes the form 1 1 H = ~ω(a∗ a + aa∗ ) = ~ω a∗ a + (1.81) 2 2 where the number operator N = a∗ a
(1.82)
makes its appearance, which has commutation relations [N, a∗ ] = +a∗ .
[N, a] = −a
(1.83)
Since the coordinate and momentum operator are generally assumed to be selfadjoint, we expect the operators a and a∗ to be mutually adjoint with respect to an inner product h · | · i that remains to be specified; then N will be a selfadjoint operator. For now, let us forget about the origin and consider the operators a and a∗ as the generators of an algebra with the relation [a, a∗ ] = 1; our aim is to construct a representation of this algebra on a separable Hilbert space. What we would like to have at our disposal is a nontrivial eigenvector of the number operator: N ψ = λψ.
(1.84)
However, on a Hilbert space there exist operators which have no eigenvector at all so that the above requirement is a rather strong assumption that must be justified. Nevertheless, taking the existence for granted, let us examine the vectors am ψ and a∗n ψ; their properties are obtained by means of the commutators [N, am ] = −mam
[N, a∗n ] = +na∗n
(1.85)
which follow from (1.83) by induction. They entail the eigenvalue equations N am ψ = (λ − m)am ψ
N a∗n ψ = (λ + m)a∗n ψ
(1.86)
by means of which we want to investigate whether am ψ and a∗n ψ may be zero for some m or n; for this, we now assume the existence of a scalar product h | i and compute hψ|aa∗ ψi = hψ|a∗ aψi + hψ|ψi =k aψ k2 + k ψ k2 >k aψ k2 ≥ 0.
(1.87)
Hence, we conclude that a∗ ψ 6= 0, and similarly that a∗n ψ is nonzero for all n ∈ N0 . As to the vectors am ψ, we consider ham ψ|N am ψi = (λ − m)ham ψ|am ψi = ham ψ|a∗ aam ψi = (λ − m) k am ψ k2 =k am+1 ψ k2 ≥ 0
(1.88)
and so there must exist an m ∈ N0 such that this sequence of eigenvectors terminates. Call this ψ0 , which thus obeys aψ0 = 0
(1.89)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
20
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
and consequently, also N ψ0 = 0. We now require hψ0 |ψ0 i = 1 by definition; we also ∗n introduce the eigenvectors ψn = c−1 n a ψ0 of N with eigenvalues N ψn = nψn
(1.90)
and determine the normalization constants cn such that their norm is equal to one. So consider 1 =k ψn k2 = |cn |−2 ha∗n ψ0 |a∗n ψ0 i = |cn |−2 ha∗n−1 ψ0 |aa∗ a∗n−1 ψ0 i (1.91) c 2 c 2 c 2 n−1 n−1 n−1 = hψn−1 |aa∗ ψn−1 i = hψn−1 |(N + 1)ψn−1 i = n cn cn cn √ which yields the recursion |cn |2 = n|cn−1 |2 ; its solution is cn = n!, up to a factor of unit modulus. To collect the results, the complete set of orthonormal eigenvectors of N is given by a∗n ψn = √ ψ0 n!
: n ∈ N0 .
(1.92)
On introducing the notation ψn = |ni, the action of the operators a and a∗ on this basis follows with a∗n a∗n−1 a∗n−1 a∗n−1 a|ni = √ |0i = aa∗ √ |0i = ([a, a∗ ] + N ) √ |0i = (1 + (n − 1)) √ |0i n! n! n! n! to be a∗ |ni =
√
n + 1|n + 1i
a|ni =
√
n|n − 1i
(1.93)
which are the basic equations. We leave it to the reader to verify that the operators a and a∗ obey (a∗ )∗ = a with respect to the scalar product. Furthermore, for the Hamiltonian the well-known discrete and equally spaced eigenvalues are obtained: 1 |ni. (1.94) H|ni = ~ω n + 2 In retrospect, the nontrivial assumption that the number operator N has a nonzero eigenvector is now seen to be equivalent to the requirement that the spectrum of the Hamiltonian is bounded from below. One can also construct the Schr˝odinger wave functions by starting from the ground state condition √ 1 ∂ ψ0 (q) = 0 ~ aψ0 (q) = √ µωq + ~ ∂q 2µω the normalized solution of which is the Gaussian α 41 α 2 e− 2 q ψ0 (q) = π
: α=
and (1.92) may then be used to obtain the excited states.
µω ~
(1.95)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
21
Finally, we want to demonstrate that the ground state minimizes the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, and so we need the expectation values of s r ~ µ~ω ∗ ∗ q= (a + a) p=i (a − a). 2µω 2 Since hqi = hψ0 |q|ψ0 i = and
s
~ hψ0 |(a∗ + a)|ψ0 i = 0 2µω
hpi = 0
~ ~ ~ ~ hψ0 |(a∗ + a)2 |ψ0 i = hψ0 |aa∗ |ψ0 i = k a∗ ψ0 k2 = (1.96) 2µω 2µω 2µω 2µω µ~ω µ~ω µ~ω hψ0 |(a∗ − a)2 |ψ0 i = hψ0 |aa∗ |ψ0 i = (1.97) hp2 i = − 2 2 2 we obtain for the mean-square deviations µ~ω ~ (∆q)2 = hq 2 i − hqi2 = (∆p)2 = hp2 i − hpi2 = . (1.98) 2µω 2 Hence, we find ~ (1.99) ∆p ∆q = 2 which is the assertion. As to the energy, we define its mean-square deviation by 1 µ 1 2 µ 1 µ ∆E = h p2 + ω 2 q 2 i − hp i + ω 2 hq 2 i = (∆p)2 + ω 2 (∆q)2 . (1.100) 2µ 2 2µ 2 2µ 2 Classically, this quantity is zero, but quantum mechanically, it is not. The value of ∆E may be determined by the subsidiary condition that the Heisenberg uncertainty relation (1.99) for the momenta and the coordinates be minimized, giving ~ (1.101) ∆E = 2 which is precisely the zero point energy. Hence, the minimum energy is not the classical value zero, where the particle is localized at the origin, since this would give a large ∆p; the energetically most favourable value is the compromise where ∆q is given by (1.98), being nonzero. Usually, these quantum mechanical vacuum fluctuations are negligibly small; but under suitable conditions they may lead to observable macroscopic effects. This happens to be the case, e.g., for He4 at low temperatures, where the zero point fluctuations prevent liquid helium from solidifying. We shall have occasion to pursue this theme in later chapters. On the assumption that the zero point energy may be neglected, a particle interpretation becomes available. Then the state |ni can be viewed as an n-particle state, where each particle carries the elementary quantum of energy ~ω, and N is the operator which counts the number of these quanta. It is for this reason that the operators a∗ and a may be called creation and annihilation operators. But we repeat, for emphasis, such an interpretation is only valid if that the zero point energy can be neglected. hq 2 i =
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
22
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
1.8
book
Quantization of the Klein-Gordon Field *
Now we are able to return to the Klein-Gordon field. From the Lagrangian (1.72) and the definition of the momenta (1.74) one obtains for the Hamiltonian X 1X ∗ H= Pl∗ Ql − L = (Pl Pl + ωl2 Q∗l Ql ). (1.102) 2 l
l
We pass to the amplitudes (see (1.76)) 1 (ωl Ql + iPl ) al = (2ωl )1−r
a∗l =
1 (ωl Q∗l − iPl∗ ) (2ωl )1−r
(1.103)
where we have chosen t = 0; this can be done since we now use the Hamiltonian formalism. Quantization is then straightforward; for this purpose, we pass to operators and postulate the basic commutation relations 1 [Pl∗ , Ql′ ] = δll′ (1.104) i which for the creation and annihilation operators give [al , a∗l′ ] = (2ωl )2r−1 δll′
(1.105)
as to be expected. For the Hamilton operator, we need 1X 1X (ωl Q∗l − iPl∗ )(ωl Ql + iPl ) = H − ωl 2 2 l
l
and one then finds
H=
1 X (2ωl )2(1−r) a∗l al + ωl . 2
(1.106)
l
We set r = 1/2 in order to obtain the canonical form X 1 H= ωl a∗l al + 2
(1.107)
l
but, as we shall see later, the value r = 1 will also be an appropriate choice. This is the Hamiltonian of a set of N independent harmonic oscillators, where the Hilbert space of states can be constructed in analogy with that developed in the previous section. The orthonormal basis is given by |n1 , . . . , nN i
(1.108)
and the corresponding Hilbert space is called the Fock space. Furthermore, the operators a∗l and al act on this basis as √ a∗l |n1 , . . . , nN i = nl + 1|n1 , . . . , nl + 1, . . . , nN i (1.109) √ (1.110) al |n1 , . . . , nN i = nl |n1 , . . . , nl − 1, . . . , nN i and from H|n1 , . . . , nN i =
X l
1 nl ω l + |n1 , . . . , nN i 2
(1.111)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Bosons
book
23
we read off the energy eigenvalues. If we neglect the zero-point energy, then the basis vector |n1 , . . . , nN i can be interpreted as a state with n1 particles in the first state, with n2 particles in the second state, and so on. Below we shall also have need for the commutation relations of the discretized Klein- Gordon field, which follows from (see (1.77)) qn (t) =
+N 2 −1
1
X
1
N2
pn (t) = −i
l=− N 2
+N 2 −1
X
1 N
1 −i(ωl t− 2π ln) +i(ωl t− 2π N N ln) a∗ e a + e l l (2ωl )r
1 2
l=− N 2
ωl −i(ωl t− 2π ln) +i(ωl t− 2π N N ln) a∗ e a − e l l (2ωl )r
(1.112)
(1.113)
and (1.105) to be 1 δmn . (1.114) i This result holds irrespective of what choice for the parameter r is made. We can now return to the continuum limit of the field. For this purpose, recall the relation (1.56); furthermore, we introduce [pm (t), qn (t)] =
1
a(k) = X 2 al
(1.115)
with 2π l X and so we obtain from (1.112) with r = 1/2: k=
1 ϕ(x, t) = X
2π +π a− X
X
k=− π a
1 1
(2ω(k)) 2
x = an
e−i(ω(k)t−kx) a(k) + e+i(ω(k)t−kx) a∗ (k) .
(1.116)
(1.117)
What remains to investigate is the limit a → 0 of the dispersion relation (1.73), which gives 2 a 2 sin k + m2 → k 2 + m2 : a → 0. (1.118) ω(k)2 = a 2 Hence, the continuum limit a → 0 and N → ∞ such that X = aN remains fixed is finally obtained to be X
ϕ(x, t) =
1 2π
+2 Z
−X 2
dk
1 −i(ω(k)t−kx) +i(ω(k)t−kx) ∗ e a(k) + e a (k) 1 (2ω(k)) 2
(1.119)
√
where ω(k) = k 2 + m2 , and the commutation relations of the creation and annihilation operators in the continuum read [a(k), a∗ (k ′ )] = 2π
X δll′ 2π
→ 2πδ(k − k ′ ).
(1.120)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
24
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
For further details concerning this limit, we refer to the last section of the following chapter. The generalization to the 3-dimensional case can now immediately be done and is left to the reader. We only want to comment on the equal time commutator of the field operator ϕ(x, t) and the associated momentum operator π(x, t) = ϕ(x, ˙ t), which is obtained either directly from (1.114) or from the commutation relations (1.120) for the creation and annihilation operators, with the result 1 δ(x − y). (1.121) i This is the basic canonical commutator of the Klein-Gordon field; conversely, one may postulate (1.121) from the outset and take it as the starting point for quantization. [π(x, t), ϕ(y, t)] =
book
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Chapter 2
LAGRANGE FORMALISM FOR FIELDS
The Lagrangian formalism for fields can be developed by following the analogy with a system of classical mechanics with a finite number of degrees of freedom. This approach necessitates the introduction of some elements of functional calculus; we only give a poor-man’s-view of that subject.
2.1
Functionals
Let us begin once more in the spirit of one of the preceding sections and consider a finite lattice with lattice points (x1 , . . . , xN ), being assumed to be one-dimensional for the moment, and a real valued function f (xn ) ∝ fn thereon. For a function F (f1 , . . . , fN ) = F (f )
of the variables fn we want to investigate the limit where the lattice constant a tends to zero. Then we face the transition F (f ) −→ F [f ]
(2.1)
with the limit depending now on a continuum of values since (f1 , . . . , fN ) = {fn }n∈NN −→ {f (x)}x∈R .
We thus have a map F : C(M ) → R with f 7→ F [f ], where in the general case M denotes a subset of Rm ; the properties of F and the space of functions C(M ) of maps f : M → R are not specified further. Such maps F are called functionals, the dependence on the function f conventionally being signified by a square bracket. To give some examples, let R R F (x)f (x)dx F (x, x′ )f (x′ )dx′ F [f ] = F [f ](x) = (2.2) exp R F (x)f (x)dx f (x)
In the first case, it is an ordinary function F (x) that determines the functional. In the second case, we restrict ourselves to the first example; here it is a function F (x, x′ ) of two variables which defines the functional. For its lattice version, Fn (f1 , . . . , fN ) would be an appropriate choice of notation. 25
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
26
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Our approach to functionals makes the analogue of partial derivatives in the discrete case easily accessible since X ∂F (f ) F (f + δf ) = F (f ) + δfn + · · · = F (f ) + δF (f ) + · · · ∂fn n Z δF [f ] −→F [f + δf ] = F [f ] + dx δf (x) + · · · = F [f ] + δF [f ] + · · · (2.3) δf (x) which is called the functional derivative (or Fr´echet derivative in the mathematical literature); it can also be defined by the (formal) limit Z δF [f ] F [f + εg] − F [f ] dx g(x) = lim . (2.4) ε→0 δf (x) ε
The functional derivatives for the first group of the above examples are F (x) δF [f ] = δf (x) F (x) exp R F (x′ )f (x′ )dx′
For the second group, we begin with the first of the two linear functionals, giving Z δ F (x, x′ )f (x′ )dx′ = F (x, y) δf (y)
from which the second one, being taken as the definition of the Dirac δ-function in the standard approach to distributions, can be obtained by setting F (x, x′ ) = δ(x − x′ ); this yields δf (x) = δ(x − x′ ). δf (x′ )
(2.5)
Hence the defining equation (2.3) for the functional derivative is natural, and not very difficult to evaluate for a given functional. It is no more difficult to infer from the discrete analogue the product rule δ(F [f ]G[f ]) δF [f ] δG[f ] = G[f ] + F [f ] δf (x) δf (x) δf (x)
(2.6)
and the chain rule for a functional F [G[g]] = F [f ] with f (x) = G[g](x), which reads Z δF [f ] δG[g](x) δF [G[g]] = dx (2.7) δg(y) δf (x) δg(y)
as a straightforward verification shows.
The above arguments can be made more rigorous; let us introduce the function ϕ(ε) = F [f + εg], which we assume to have a convergent Taylor expansion ϕ(ε) =
∞ X
n=0
ϕ(n) (0)
εn n!
(2.8)
in a neighbourhood of the origin. We then define the functional derivative of F [f ] according to eq. (2.4), i.e. Z F [f + εg] − F [f ] δF [f ] ϕ(1) (0) = lim = dx g(x) (2.9) ε→0 ε δf (x)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
book
27
and induction may be used to show that for the higher derivatives one has Z δ n F [f ] ϕ(n) (0) = g(x1 ) · · · g(xn ) dx1 · · · dxn . δf (x1 ) · · · δf (xn )
(2.10)
The Taylor expansion (2.8) can thus be written as F [f + εg] =
Z ∞ X εn δ n F [f ] g(x1 ) · · · g(xn ) dx1 · · · dxn n! δf (x1 ) · · · δf (xn ) n=0
(2.11)
and if we assume that (2.8) converges for ε = 1, we arrive at the functional Taylor expansion Z ∞ X 1 δ n F [f ] F [f ] = f (x1 ) · · · f (xn ) dx1 · · · dxn . (2.12) n! δf (x ) · · · δf (x ) n 1 n=0 f =0
In this way convergence issues with the functional series (2.12) are settled; it converges if the Taylor series of the ordinary function ϕ(ε) at ε = 1 is convergent.
A functional integral is a considerably more difficult construct and we only discuss a simple case. Let us begin with the well-known Gaussian integral r +∞ Z 2π − 12 αx2 dx e = α
: α>0
(2.13)
−∞
the generalization of which to the case of N variables we write in the form of the identity +∞ N Z Y
−∞
√
N P
dfn − 21 n=1 fn2 √ = 1. e 2π n=1
For fn = af (x) a function on the lattice, with x = an and a the lattice constant, we can now take the formal continuum limit to obtain +X/2 R
Z
d[f ] e
r
a df (an) 2π
− 21
dxf 2 (x)
−X/2
=1
(2.14)
where d[f ] ≡
N Y
n=1
: N →∞
is the properly normalized functional measure. Hence by a subtle normalization of the measure on the lattice, the Gaussian integral can be generalized to a functional integral; we shall have to return to this topic in more complicated situations. 2.2
Euler-Lagrange Equations for Fields
As an application of the functional calculus, we investigate the Euler-Lagrange equations of the Klein-Gordon field. To begin with, let us consider the simpler
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
28
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
case of a Lagrangian L(q, q) ˙ for a finite number of degrees of freedom and with corresponding action S[q] =
Zt2
dt L(q(t), q(t)) ˙
(2.15)
t1
where the notation requires explanation. For the right-hand side, it is understood that an arbitrary path q(t) from t1 to t2 is given, which is inserted into the Lagrangian to obtain a function L(t) ≡ L(q(t), q(t)); ˙ afterwards one integrates over t ∈ [t1 , t2 ], and the result is the action, which thus is a functional of the given path. Strictly speaking, the action functional also depends on the boundary values of the time interval, but for simplicity we suppress this dependence. Hence, it makes sense to determine the functional derivative of the action which, as we know, follows from S[q + δq] = S[q] +
Zt2
t1
dt
δS[q] δq(t) + · · · = S[q] + δS[q] + · · · δq(t)
and so we need to compute δS[q] =
Zt2
t1
dt
∂L(t) d ∂L(t) − ∂q i (t) dt ∂ q˙i (t)
d δq (t) + dt i
∂L(t) i t2 δq (t) . ∂ q˙i (t) t1
If we restrict the admissible class of paths q(t) from q(t1 ) to q(t2 ) by the requirement that the endpoints be fixed, then the boundary term vanishes, and so ∂L(t) d ∂L(t) δS[q] = i − . δq i (t) ∂q (t) dt ∂ q˙i (t)
(2.16)
Thus, the Euler-Lagrange equations are equivalent to the requirement that the first functional derivative of the action vanishes; this is just the functional extremum condition for the action. Let us turn to the field theoretic situation; we begin with the Lagrange density, which is a function of the field ϕ and its first partial space-time derivatives ∂ϕ, and consider Z L[ϕ(t), ϕ(t))] ˙ = d3 x L(ϕ(x, t), ∂ϕ(x, t)). (2.17)
As the notation indicates, this is really a functional of the field and its time derivative, because the knowledge of ϕ(x, t) and ϕ(x, ˙ t) for all values of x ∈ R3 gets involved on the right-hand side. Hence, for the variation of L(t) ≡ L[ϕ(t), ϕ(t))] ˙ we find δL(t) = (2.18) Z Z δL(t) d δL(t) d δL(t) d3 x − δϕ(x, t) + d3 x δϕ(x, t) δϕ(x, t) dt δ ϕ(x, ˙ t) dt δ ϕ(x, ˙ t)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
book
29
where a partial integration has been performed. For a Klein-Gordon field, the functional derivatives are obtained from Z 1 1 1 L(t) = d3 x ϕ(x, ˙ t)2 − (∇ϕ(x, t))2 − m2 ϕ(x, t)2 (2.19) 2 2 2
and read
δL(t) = ∇ 2 ϕ(x, t) − m2 ϕ(x, t) δϕ(x, t)
δL(t) = ϕ(x, ˙ t) δ ϕ(x, ˙ t)
(2.20)
where we have assumed that ϕ(x, t) vanishes when |x| approaches infinity; the latter property then holds for the variation δϕ(x, t) as well. Thus, the Euler-Lagrange equations for L(t) are ˙ δL[ϕ(t), ϕ(t))] ˙ d δL[ϕ(t), ϕ(t))] − =0 dt δ ϕ(x, ˙ t) δϕ(x, t)
(2.21)
which, for the example considered, coincide with the Klein-Gordon equation. These are the functional analogues of the conventional Euler-Lagrange equations for a finite number of degrees of freedom. We are now able to discuss also the transition to the Hamiltonian formalism for fields. The momenta are defined by π(x, t) = so that the Hamiltonian is H[π(t), ϕ(t)] =
Z
δL(t) δ ϕ(x, ˙ t)
d 3 x π(x, t)ϕ(x, ˙ t) − L[ϕ(t), ϕ(t))]. ˙
(2.22)
(2.23)
The Hamiltonian equations of motion then involve functional derivatives and read δH[π(t), ϕ(t)] = +ϕ(x, ˙ t) δπ(x, t)
δH[π(t), ϕ(t)] = −π(x, ˙ t). δϕ(x, t)
(2.24)
They may be taken, as in the case with a finite number of degrees of freedom, as the motivation to introduce Poisson brackets Z δF [π, ϕ] δG[π, ϕ] δF [π, ϕ] δG[π, ϕ] {F [π, ϕ], G[π, ϕ]} = d3 x − (2.25) δπ(x) δϕ(x) δϕ(x) δπ(x)
where F and G are arbitrary functionals on the phase space of fields and their canonically conjugate momenta. 2.3
Variational Principle
Both in classical mechanics and in field theory the equations of motion can be derived from the action by means of a variational principle. Mostly, this action is found by trial and error, and one then shows afterwards that it yields the correct equations of motion. But one can give a systematic approach that permits to derive the action from the given equations of motion; it is developed below.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
30
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
2.3.1
book
Nonrelativistic classical mechanics
We begin with the simplest case and consider a particle subject to a conservative force with the equations of motion m¨ qi +
∂ V (q) = 0. ∂q i
(2.26)
Multiplying this with the variations δq i , with the sum over i understood, and integrating over t we obtain Z t2 ∂ 0= dt(−m¨ qi − i V (q))δq i ∂q t1 Z t2 d ∂ i i i = dt − (mq˙i δq ) + mq˙i δ q˙ − i V δq dt ∂q t1 Z t2 t2 m i =δ dt q˙i q˙ − V (q) − mq˙i δq i . 2 t1 t1
Since the endpoints remain fixed by assumption, the boundary term vanishes, and so we can read off the action Z m q˙2 − V (q) (2.27) S= dt 2
as claimed. The procedure also works in more complicated cases, such as the Lorentz equations for a particle in an external electromagnetic field: e m¨ x = eE + x˙ × B. (2.28) c The right-hand side is the prototype of a force, which is velocity dependent, and as such always difficult to handle. The essential step consists in passing from the electric and magnetic fields to the scalar and vector potential. Then proceeding as before, we obtain Z t2 e 0= dt −m¨ x + eE + x˙ × B · δx c t1 Z t2 e 1 ∂ A) · δx + (x˙ × (∇ × A)) · δx . = dt −m¨ x · δx + e(−∇ϕ − c ∂t c t1 We must compute now x˙ × (∇ × A)) · δx = x˙ i δAi − x˙ j ∇j Ai δxi and can thus rewrite the terms inside the large round brackets as e ∂ e e d ˙ (−mx˙ · δx) + mx˙ · δ x˙ − e∇ϕ · δx − A · δx − x˙ · ∇A · δx + δA · x. dt c ∂t c c The fourth and fifth term combine to give −
e ∂ e e d A · δx − x˙ · ∇A · δx = − A(x(t), t) · δx(t) c ∂t c c dt
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
book
31
and so we obtain Z t2 d e d e 0= dt (−mx˙ · δx) + mx˙ · δ x˙ − e∇ϕ · δx − A · δx + δA · x˙ dt c dt c t1 Z t2 d e e e = dt − ((mx˙ + A) · δx) + mx˙ · δ x˙ − e∇ϕ · δx + A · δ x˙ + δA · x˙ dt c c c t1 Z t2 t m 2 e e 2 dt x˙ + A · x˙ − eϕ . = −(mx˙ + A) · δx + δ c 2 c t1 t1
Hence, the action for a particle in an external electromagnetic field turns out to be Z m e x˙ 2 + A · x˙ − eϕ (2.29) S= dt 2 c where, and this is the decisive fact, the coupling is through the scalar and vector potential; moreover, the Lagrangian m e L = x˙ 2 + A · x˙ − eϕ (2.30) 2 c contains a gyroscopic term, which is responsible for essential complications. For the momenta one obtains ∂L e p= = mx˙ + A (2.31) ∂ x˙ c and for the Hamiltonian this gives 1 e 2 H(p, x) = p − A + eϕ. (2.32) 2m c As the reader should verify, the Hamiltonian equations of motion reproduce the Lorentz equations. From the Hamiltonian (2.32) we infer that the coupling to the electromagnetic field is accomplished on replacing the 3-momenta pi by pi → pi − ec Ai and the energy E by E → E − eϕ; this prescription, which in 4-vector notation reads e pµ → pµ − Aµ (2.33) c is called the minimal substitution. It is a rule of basic importance, which will also be used in the relativistic case - as well as in the field theoretic situation, where it will find its deeper foundation. 2.3.2
Relativistic classical mechanics
The generalization to the relativistic case can be achieved as follows. For this, observe that by means of the construct ct x(t) = (2.34) x(t) the action (2.29) may be rewritten in the preliminary form Z m dxµ (t) dxν (t) e dxµ (t) S = dt − gµν − Aµ (x(t)) 2 dt dt c dt
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
32
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
where we have added the constant term −mc2 /2, which does not affect the equations of motion. Note, the parametrization (2.34) of a curve is rather standard; e.g., in 2 dimensions one can also write a curve in the form x(x) = (x, f (x)) where f is an
R-valued function.
However, the above action is not an invariant since time is singled out. Here we anticipate the meaning of the term ‘invariant’; it denotes invariance under Lorentz transformations, as explained in sec. 3.1 below. This defect can be cured by noticing that the line element squared for the particle trajectory x(t) in Minkowski space may be interpreted as v 2 (t) ds2 = c2 dt2 − v 2 (t)dt2 = c2 1 − 2 dt2 . (2.35) c
Hence the quantity
dτ (t) =
1 γv(t)
dt =
r
1−
v 2 (t) dt c2
: v = |v|
with v = |v|, is an invariant by construction; the integrated form Zt r v 2 (t′ ) ′ dt τ (t) = 1− c2
(2.36)
(2.37)
0
is called proper time. The nomenclature derives from the notion that, if the velocity v(t) can be transformed to zero by means of a pure Lorentz transformation, then one has dτ = dt, and this can be identified as the time which elapses in the system at rest. Such an interpretation presupposes, however, that for an accelerated observer - in the special relativistic context - a comoving frame can be defined. But this is a questionable point since the parameters of a Lorentz transformation have constants values, and so one could argue that one leaves the domain of validity of special relativity; this problem will be taken up again at a later stage. Here we simply interpret τ as the parameter of a path τ 7→ x(τ ) with x˙ · x˙ > 0 and x˙ 0 > 0, which is equal to the arc length.
Accordingly, we consider the particle trajectory to be parametrized in terms of proper time c t(τ ) x(τ ) = (2.38) x(τ )
and so we can construct the 4-velocity
dx(τ ) = x(τ ˙ )= q dτ
1 1−
v 2 (t) c2
c = u(τ ) v(t)
(2.39)
where from now on the overdot denotes the differentiation with respect to proper time. Note that we have met this 4-vector already earlier (see eq. (1.48)) in the form pµ = muµ ; indeed, this quantity will be seen to transform as a 4-vector under Lorentz transformations, and it is timelike since u 2 = c2
(2.40)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
book
33
and future directed. Now it is easy to rewrite the action in invariant form: Z m e S = dτ − gµν x˙ µ (τ )x˙ ν (τ ) − Aµ (x(τ ))x˙ µ (τ ) . (2.41) 2 c However, it has the unpleasant property that, on account of (2.40), the kinetic term is constant. In order to avoid this drawback, we amend the above approach as follows. Let x(τ ) be a curve in Minkowski space M , where the parameter τ is not taken to be proper time now, but arbitrary. Then the tangent vector x(τ ˙ ) behaves under Lorentz transformations (see sec. 3.1) x 7→ x′ = Λx as x˙ ′ (τ ) = Λx(τ ˙ ), i.e. 2 is indeed a 4-vector. With this agreement, x(τ ˙ ) is no longer constant, and so we can freely vary x(τ ) 7→ x(τ ) + δx(τ ), being subject to the endpoint restriction δx(τ1 ) = 0 = δx(τ2 ) only, to obtain Z τ2 e e d µ µ ν µ µ (−mx˙ µ δx ) + m¨ xµ δx − (∂µ Aν )(x)x˙ δx − Aµ (x)δ x˙ dτ δS = dτ c c τ Z 1τ2 d e e µ ν µ = dτ − ((mx˙ µ + Aµ )δx ) + (m¨ xµ − (∂µ Aν − ∂ν Aµ )x˙ )δx . dτ c c τ1 We thus read off the equations of motion
e (2.42) m¨ xµ = Fµν x˙ ν c which are the generalizations of the nonrelativistic Lorentz equations (2.28) to the relativistic case; their relativistic invariance is manifest. In the nonrelativistic limit they reduce for µ = k to (2.28), and for µ = 0 to the energy conservation law. If we multiply (2.42) with x˙ µ and sum over µ, the right-hand side gives zero, and so the left-hand side amounts to d (x˙ µ x˙ µ ) = 0. (2.43) dτ Hence, we may assume x˙ 2 = c2 so that, afterwards, we can interpret τ as proper time. We thus have managed to make the variational principle consistent by starting with an arbitrary parametrization of the particle trajectory. 2.3.3
Reparametrization invariance *
Actually, the above conclusion that (2.43) implies x˙ 2 = c2 is a bit subtle since, a priori, x˙ 2 can take any value, in particular the value x˙ 2 = 0; we reconsider this point below. Let us begin with the observation that eq. (2.43) can also be inferred from a conservation law. It is derived from the invariance of the action (where now q denotes the charge) Z τ2 m q (2.44) S= dτ − x˙ µ x˙ µ − Aµ (x)x˙ µ 2 c τ1
against the substitution
◦
τ → τ′ = τ + τ
xµ (τ ) → x′µ (τ ′ ) = xµ (τ )
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
34
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory ◦
where τ is a translation of the parameter of the curve. At the infinitesimal level, this implies x′µ (τ ′ ) = x′µ (τ + δτ ) = x′µ (τ ) + x˙ µ (τ )δτ = xµ (τ ) + δxµ (τ ) + x˙ µ (τ )δτ = xµ (τ ) so that δxµ (τ ) = −x˙ µ (τ )δτ , and thus Z τ2 d q q δS = dτ − mx˙ µ + Aµ δxµ + m¨ xµ δxµ − Fµν x˙ ν δxµ dτ c c τ Z 1τ2 d q q = dτ mx˙ µ + Aµ x˙ µ − m¨ xµ x˙ µ + Fµν x˙ µ x˙ ν δτ dτ c c τ1
where the last term in the second line vanishes. On the other hand, using the equations of motion, we obtain Z τ2 q d mx˙ µ + Aµ x˙ µ δτ δS = dτ dτ c τ1
and equating these two expressions for δS, we find Z τ2 − dτ m¨ xµ x˙ µ δτ = 0. τ1
2
This indeed yields that x˙ is constant since the τ -interval is arbitrary; but the actual value of x˙ 2 is again not fixed because, in principle, it can take any value. This defect can be cured by modifying the action such that the invariance group, which in the above is a one-dimensional translation group, is enlarged. Such an approach is suggested by the observation that the action (2.44) is not invariant under reparametrizations of the curve. These are maps τ 7→ τ ′ (τ ), where the transformation law xµ (τ ) 7→ x′µ (τ ′ ) = xµ (τ ) remains unchanged; we restrict these maps by the requirement dτ ′ /dτ > 0, saying that τ ′ (τ ) is monotonically increasing. The action can be made invariant under these reparametrizations (or local translations of the curve parameter) by introducing an additional degree of freedom, denoted e(τ ), which is called an einbein for reasons to become apparent later; namely, the reparametrization invariance is the 1-dimensional analogue of the 4-dimensional coordinate invariance of general relativity. We assume that also e(τ ) > 0 holds, and the transformation law is required to be ′ −1 dτ ′ ′ e(τ ). (2.45) e (τ ) = dτ In order to design an invariant action, the strategy is to insert an appropriate power of the einbein in all those terms that are not invariant. Furthermore, since the einbein does not contribute to the dynamics, we still have the freedom to add a (‘cosmological’) term proportional to e, and so we arrive at Z τ2 1m q 1 2 µ µ S= dτ − x˙ µ x˙ − Aµ (x)x˙ − e mc . (2.46) e 2 c 2 τ1
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
book
35
This is really invariant since the 4-velocity transforms as ′ −1 d ′µ ′ dτ d µ x (τ ) = x (τ ) ′ dτ dτ dτ and the condition δS =0 δe(τ ) yields x˙ 2 = e2 c2 , or r x˙ 2 e= . (2.47) c2 Hence, the einbein can be Z eliminated in (2.46) to give p q (2.48) S= dτ −mc x˙ µ x˙ µ − Aµ (x)x˙ µ c so that we gain the action mostly being considered in the literature. It has the virtue to be invariant against reparametrizations. In particular, taking the free case for simplicity, one can thus return from τ to ordinary time, i.e. choose the ‘gauge’ x0 = ct; we then obtain the action r Z v2 2 S = −mc dt 1 − 2 (2.49) c which yields the usual kinematics. The nonrelativistic approximation is Z relativistic m : c → ∞. (2.50) S= dt −mc2 + v 2 + · · · 2 Hence, this action also has the correct nonrelativistic limit; the rest energy enters with a minus sign since it is the Lagrangian action, which is considered. Returning to the original form (2.46), one can also set e = 1 there; then we are back again at the action (2.44), up to a constant term that does not matter. We end this section with a cautionary remark. The drawback of the action (2.48) consists in the fact that it does not admit a relativistic Hamiltonian treatment but such an objection does not apply to (2.44), i.e. the quadratic form. To see this, we begin with the euclidean case in order to avoid sign questions; we choose the conventional form for the arc length in Z d=3qdimensions, viz. s[x] = dt gij x˙ i x˙ j (2.51)
(where the metric could depend on the coordinates as well). The momentum is given by 1 pj = p gij x˙ j gkl x˙ k x˙ l and thus the Hamiltonian vanishes: q H = pi x˙ i − gij x˙ i x˙ j = 0.
Moreover, the momenta are not independent since g ij pi pj = 1. Returning to the Minkowskian situation, the same remarks apply, and so one encounters a constrained system. This complication can be avoided, however, on going back to the action (2.49), which must be treated as a functional of the 3-dimensional coordinates and velocities, i.e. in a nonrelativistic manner.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
36
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
2.3.4
Relativistic field theory
Also in the field theoretic case the action can be obtained from the field equations. We begin again with the Klein-Gordon field, which we now take to be complex; the equations of motion are (~ = c = 1) (∂µ ∂ µ + m2 )ϕ(x) = 0 (∂µ ∂ µ + m2 )ϕ∗ (x) = 0. Multiplying the left one by δϕ∗ and the right one by δϕ, adding these two, and integrating overZa 4-dimensional volume V afterwards, we find 0= d4 x −δϕ∗ (∂µ ∂ µ + m2 )ϕ − (∂µ ∂ µ + m2 )ϕ∗ δϕ ZV = d4 x ∂µ δϕ∗ ∂ µ ϕ + ∂µ ϕ∗ ∂ µ δϕ − m2 δϕ∗ ϕ − m2 ϕ∗ δϕ . V
where we have omitted a boundary term since it is assumed that δϕ∗ (x) and δϕ(x) vanish for x ∈ ∂V ; so we obtainZ the action S[ϕ] = d4 x(∂µ ϕ∗ ∂ µ ϕ − m2 ϕ∗ ϕ). (2.52) V
The same Z strategy works for Maxwell’s Z equations (1.17), which give 4 µ ν 0= d x(∂ Fµν − Jν )δA = d4 x (∂ µ (Fµν δAν ) − Fµν ∂ µ δAν − Jν δAν ) V V Z 1 µ ν ν µ ν 4 = d x − Fµν (∂ δA − ∂ δA ) − Jν δA 2 V Z 1 4 µν ν = d x − Fµν δF − Jν δA 2 V Z 1 µν ν 4 =δ d x − Fµν F − Aν J 4 V where we have taken for granted that the current is independent of the vector field; hence, the Lagrangian for Maxwell’s theory is 1 L = − Fµν F µν − Aµ J µ . (2.53) 4 Conversely, assume that the Lagrangian L(φ, ∂φ) for a real multi-component field φA with A = 1, . . .Z, N is given; Zthen the yields variation of the action ∂L ∂L δφ + δ∂µ φ δS = d4 x δL = d4 x ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) V V Z ∂L ∂L ∂L 4 = d x ∂µ δφ + − ∂µ δφ ∂(∂µ φ) ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) V and since again δφ(x) = 0 for x ∈ ∂V is required, we read off ∂L ∂L − ∂µ =0 (2.54) ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) which are called the Euler-Lagrange equations. It is left as an exercise for the reader to verify that their functional version 2.21 can also be brought to this form. We have only given the Euler -Lagrange equations for later reference, as in most cases it is too long-winded a procedure to compute the equations of motion from the Euler-Lagrange equations; instead, the simplest strategy is to determine the field equations directly from the variation of the action.
book
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
2.4
book
37
Appendix: Improper Bases *
We make a digression in this section and discuss a formal device, being due to Dirac, which is used throughout by physicists, but difficult to justify rigorously for mathematicians. It consists in associating to the linear space of functions over the real numbers a basis, which is labelled by an index taking values in the real numbers as well. What we give here amounts to a rather heuristic approach by studying the problem on a lattice and performing the formal continuum limit afterwards. Let us first introduce Dirac’s notation on a vector space V over the real numbers of finite dimension N , which is also equipped with a positive definite scalar product. We choose a basis en with hem |en i = δmn and introduce the standard abbreviating ket and bra notation en = |ni and e∗n = hn| so that hm|ni = δmn
(2.55)
where, in case that no inner product is given, the thermore, we have the completeness relation X |nihn| = 1N
e∗n
denote the dual basis. Fur(2.56)
n
which is to be interpreted as a tensor product. Indeed, for simplicity, take the case N = 2 with the basis 1 0 e1 = e2 = 0 1 and choose as basis of the tensor product {11, 12, 21, 22}; we then obtain 1 0 10 e∗1 ⊗ e1 + e∗2 ⊗ e2 = 1 0 ⊗ + 01 ⊗ = 0 1 01
as claimed. We now connect the basis |ni to a lattice, and accordingly let n take the values − N2 ≥ n ≥ N2 − 1, as we have done that in the previous chapter; furthermore, we introduce x = an, where a is a lattice constant. What we want to define is a basis |xi, where the limit a → 0 can be performed at the end. This will then give us a basis, for which the label x takes continuous values. In order to pursue this program, we introduce a further basis |li with − N2 ≥ l ≥ N 2 − 1 by means of the basis transformation |ni =
+N 2 −1
1 N
1 2
X
l=− N 2
e
1 −i 2π N (l+ 2 θ)n
|li
|li =
+N 2 −1
1 N
1 2
X
n=− N 2
2π
1
e+i N (l+ 2 θ)n |ni (2.57)
where we have slightly generalized the earlier approach (see (1.68) and (1.69)) by allowing for the parameter θ in the exponent. This takes values 0 ≤ θ ≤ 1 and its effect is to provide for more general twisted boundary conditions since |n + N i = e−iπθ |ni
|l + N i = |li
(2.58)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
38
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
so that only the periodicity property for the basis |ni is altered, whereas the |li basis remains unaffected; for the former, the boundary conditions are periodic for θ = 0 and antiperiodic for θ = 1. Strictly speaking, this generalization is only allowed for a complex vector space; but we are mainly interested in the extreme values of θ, where we only need the real case. This basis transformation is unitary, as follows from the identities (see (1.70)) N
+ 2 −1 ′ 2π 1 1 X hn|n i = e+i N (l+ 2 θ)(n−n ) N N ′
l=−
2
N
+ 2 −1 ′ 2π 1 X hl|l i = e+i N (l−l )n . (2.59) N N ′
n=−
Furthermore, we define x = an
k=
2π X
and set X = aN
∆x = a
∆k =
2
1 l+ θ 2 2π X
(2.60)
K=
2π . a
(2.61)
In addition, let us introduce the modified bases 1 1 |xi = |ni |ki = |li (2.62) CX CK where the normalization constants CX and CK remain to be determined. For the modified bases, the transformation takes the form CK 1 |xi = CX N 21
2π π +π a− X +X θ
X
X
e
−ikx
π k=− π a+Xθ
|ki
+ 2 −a CX 1 X e+ikx |xi. (2.63) |ki = CK N 12 x=− X 2
Now we partially dispose of the constants and set 1 CX 1 CK 1 1 = ∆k = = a = ∆x CX N 21 X 2π CK N 21 so that 1 |xi = ∆k 2π
2π π +π a− X +X θ
X
π k=− π a+X θ
e
−ikx
|ki
|ki = ∆x
+X 2 −a
X
x=− X 2
e+ikx |xi.
(2.64)
(2.65)
Formally, two different limits can now be performed. The first is the limit N → ∞ to an infinite lattice; then x remains discrete, whereas k becomes a continuous variable: Z + πa +∞ X 1 |xi = dk e−ikx |ki |ki = ∆x e+ikx |xi. (2.66) 2π − πa x=−∞
The other one is the continuum limit a → 0 and N → ∞ such that X = aN remains fixed, which gives Z +X +∞ X 2 1 ∆k e−ikx |ki |ki = dx e+ikx |xi (2.67) |xi = 2π −X 2 k=−∞
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
39
where x is continuous and k discrete. Whereas for an infinite lattice the boundary conditions disappear, they make itself felt in the formal continuum limit since 2π |x + Xi = e−iπθ |xi |k + i = |ki. (2.68) a Afterwards, we can also take X → ∞ and thus 1 |xi = 2π
+∞ Z dk e−ikx |ki
+∞ Z |ki = dx e+ikx |xi
−∞
(2.69)
−∞
so that now both x and k are continuous variables. Turning to the orthogonality relations, for the modified bases they take the form 1 1 hx|x i = 2 CX N ′
2π π +π a− X +X θ
X
X
e
+ 2 −a ′ 1 1 X hk|k i = 2 e−i(k−k )x . (2.70) CK N X
+ik(x−x′ )
′
π k=− π a+Xθ
x=−
2
We now fix the constants CX and CK by the choice 1
CK =
CX = a 2
1
(2.71)
1
X2
which respects (2.64), and so we obtain 1 hx|x i = ∆k 2π ′
2π π +π a− X +X θ
X
e
+ik(x−x′ )
′
hk|k i = ∆x
π k=− π a+Xθ
+X 2 −a
X
′
e−i(k−k )x . (2.72)
x=− X 2
For the infinite lattice with N → ∞, we then find Z + πa +∞ X ′ ′ 1 ′ hx|x i = dk e+ik(x−x ) hk|k ′ i = ∆x e−i(k−k )x 2π − πa x=−∞
(2.73)
where the interval [−π/a, +π/a] is called the (first) Brillouin zone; in the continuum limit, this gives Z + X2 +∞ X ′ 1 +ik(x−x′ ) ′ ′ e hk|k i = ∆k hx|x i = dx e−i(k−k )x . (2.74) X 2π −2 k=−∞
What remains is the infinite volume limit
1 δ(x − x ) : = hx|x i = 2π ′
′
+∞ Z ′ dk e+ik(x−x )
(2.75)
−∞
+∞ Z ′ ′ ′ 2πδ(k − k ) : = hk|k i = dx e−i(k−k )x
(2.76)
−∞
which provides us with the definition of the δ-function in x- and k-space. With the obvious generalization to d dimensions, we thus obtain for the formal relation between these bases d
|xi ≡ a− 2 |ni
d
|ki ≡ X 2 |li
(2.77)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
40
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
and for the Kronecker and Dirac symbol 1 δ(x − x ) ≡ d δnn′ a ′
′
δ(k − k ) ≡
where the volume of the elementary cell is
X 2π
d
δll′
(2π)d . V Finally, from the completeness relations in the discrete case, we read off Z Z d dk d d x|xihx| = 1 |kihk| = 1 (2π)d ∆x = ad
∆k =
(2.78)
(2.79)
(2.80)
which are the formal completeness relations in the continuum case. Let us now turn to the essence of the Dirac formalism. We begin with the finite dimensional case where, using the completeness relation, we can write a vector |f i in the form X X fn |ni = |nihn|f i |f i = n
n
so that we may identify fn = hn|f i. In order to pass to the continuum case, we define 1 (2.81) f (an) = 1 fn a2 and can thus proceed as follows; setting Z + X2 |f i = dx f (x)|xi (2.82) −X 2
we can interpret f (x) as f (x) = hx|f i
(2.83)
which says that the value of f at the point x is the projection of the (uncountably) infinite dimensional vector |f i = {f (x)}x∈[−X/2,+X/2]
(2.84)
onto |xi, being looked at as a basis vector. In an analogous manner (see (2.71)) we define 2π 1 1 f (2.85) l+ θ = X 2 fl N 2 so that on the lattice the functions f (x) and f (k) inherit the periodicity property 2π f (x + X) = eiπθ f (x) f k+ = f (k). (2.86) a In particular, the Fourier transform is strictly periodic with period 2π/a. Furthermore, the combined continuum and infinite volume limit is compatible with the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
41
The Riemann-Lebesgue lemma states that if the Fourier transform g of a function f on exists, then f must vanish at infinity. So let f (x) =
1 2π
R
+∞ Z
dk eikx g(k)
−∞
where we must verify that lim
+∞ Z
x→∞ −∞
+∞ Z
dk g(k) sin kx = 0 = lim
x→∞ −∞
dk g(k) cos kx
and analogously for x → −∞; we only give a heuristic proof since we assume that g(k) is a differentiable function. Furthermore, we restrict ourselves to the sine integral; an integration by parts then yields +K Z
−K
1 1 dk g(k) sin kx = − (g(+K) − g(−K)) cos Kx + x x
+K Z dk g ′ (k) cos kx → 0
: x→∞
−K
and afterwards we also let K approach infinity. One can weaken the requirement that g(k) be differentiable; the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma holds as well for a Lebesgue integrable Fourier transform.
To summarize, the above intuitive approach suggests that it makes sense to interpret the value f (x) of a function f at a point x as the expansion coefficient of f with respect to |xi, i.e. the improper basis being labelled by the continuous variable x; for a rigorous approach to this topic, we refer to the mathematical literature (Ge’lfand and Vilenkin (1964), see also Bohm and Gadella (1989)). In concluding we take the opportunity to give a derivation of the Poisson summation formula for functions obeying generalized boundary conditions, which will be needed later; it is left to the scrupulous reader to specify the necessary conditions under which the manipulations to follow are legitimate. So let f , α 7→ f (α), be a smooth function defined on the whole real line, taking values in C; from this we construct a function fθ obeying the twisted periodicity property fθ (α + 2π) = e iπθ fθ (α)
: θ ∈ [0, 1]
by periodization: fθ (α) =
+∞ X
e −iπθm f (α + 2πm).
(2.87)
(2.88)
m=−∞
In this way, fθ (α) may be restricted to the domain α ∈ [0, 2π], the boundary points being identified by means of the periodicity property. Accordingly, the function fθ (α) can be Fourier decomposed as fθ (α) = with Fourier coefficients f˜θ (n) =
+∞ 1 X iα(n+ θ ) ˜ 2 f (n) e θ 2π n=−∞
Z2π 0
θ
dα e −iα(n+ 2 ) fθ (α).
(2.89)
(2.90)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
42
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Reinsertion yields the twisted periodic δ-function δθ (α − α ′ ) =
+∞ 1 X i(α−α ′ )(n+ θ ) 2 e 2π n=−∞
: δθ (α + 2π) = e iπθ δθ (α)
(2.91)
defined on the compact interval [0, 2π]; for a function of the type (2.88), an analogous procedure gives +∞ X
e −iπθm f (α + 2πm)
m=−∞
=
Z2π
+∞ X
1 2π n=−∞
=
dα ′
+∞ X
+∞ X
+∞ X
n=−∞ n ′ =−∞
=
n=−∞
=
n ′ =−∞
+∞ X
1 2π n=−∞
e i(α−α
′
)(n+ θ2 ) −iπθn ′
e
f (α ′ + 2πn ′ )
n ′ −∞
0
+∞ X
+∞ X
1 2π
′ 2π(n Z +1)
1 2π
′ 2π(n Z +1)
dα ′′ e i(α−α
′′
+2πn ′ )(n+ θ2 ) −iπθn ′
′′
)(n+ θ2 )
e
f (α ′′ )
2πn ′
dα ′′ e i(α−α
f (α ′′ )
2πn ′
+∞ Z
dα ′ e i(α−α
′
)(n+ θ2 )
f (α ′ )
−∞
and we thus read off
δθ (α − α ′ ) =
+∞ X
n=−∞
e −iπθn δ(α − α ′ + 2πn)
(2.92)
saying that also the periodic δθ -function is obtained from the standard one by periodization. A similar technique can be used to express the Fourier coefficients of the function fθ through f with the result +∞ Z θ f˜θ (n) = dα e −iα(n+ 2 ) f (α)
(2.93)
−∞
and so eq. (2.88) together with (2.89) takes the form +∞ X
e
−iπθm
m=−∞
+∞ X
1 f (α + 2πm) = 2π n=−∞
+∞ Z ′ θ dα ′ e i(α−α )(n+ 2 ) f (α ′ )
−∞
(2.94)
which is the generalized Poisson summation formula. Its interpretation is facilitated on passing from α to the variable x with the dimension of a length X, defined by α = 2πx/X; from (2.93), we then infer +∞ Z 2π 2π 2π θ θ 2π ˜ f˜θ (n) = dx e −i X (n+ 2 )x f (x) = f (kn ) : kn = n+ X X X 2 −∞
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Lagrange Formalism for Fields
book
43
R +∞ where f˜(k) = −∞ dx e −ikx f (x) denotes the standard Fourier transform. We thus arrive at the formula +∞ X
m=−∞
e −iπθm f (x + mX) =
1 X ikn x ˜ e f (kn ) X
(2.95)
kn
telling us that the left hand side, which is just the periodization fθ (x), is determined by the conventional Fourier transform of f , evaluated at the discrete points kn = θ 2π X (n + 2 ). It is left to the reader to spell out the extension of the Poisson formula to a d-dimensional lattice.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Chapter 3
RELATIVISTIC INVARIANCE
Up to now we have only introduced a compact 4-dimensional notation, but not discussed its significance. As we shall see, the notation hides fundamental symmetry properties of Minkowski space. The rather formal, albeit basic tools that follow will play an essential rˆ ole in relativistic field theory, to be revealed in the present and the chapter to come. 3.1
Minkowski Space and its Symmetry Group
As we have learned, Maxwell’s theory provides compelling reasons to unite space with coordinates x and time with ‘coordinate’ x0 = ct in a single four-vector x = (xµ )µ=0,1,2,3 ; furthermore, this linear space is equipped with an inner product x · y = g(x, y) = xµ gµν y ν
(3.1)
where diag g = (+, −, −, −). This inner product is not positive definite for profound physical reasons; if it were, then the 4-momentum squared of a photon would obey (p4 ≡ ip0 ) p21 + p22 + p23 + p24 = 0. But this equality entailed p = 0 so that there were no photons at all, and we would sit in the darkness. Nevertheless, everyday experience suggests that space and time are of rather different a nature: Space spreads out before our eyes, whereas time ‘flows’. Thus, the four-vector notation could also conceal essential differences ! We put such objections aside and consider the linear space of four-vectors, being equipped with the inner product (3.1), as the basic construct that underlies the conceptions about our world. This is called Minkowski space, denoted by M ; its elements x ∈ M can be divided into three disjoint regions of (i) timelike vectors with x2 > 0 (ii) lightlike vectors with x2 = 0 (iii) spacelike vectors with x2 < 0. 45
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
46
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
The regions of spacelike and timelike vectors are separated by the lightcone, which is the locus of points {x ∈ M |x2 = 0}. One can also consider the elements x of M as events, which happen at the time instant t in the point x. Two spacelike separated events can not be causally related since a signal, connecting these two events, would have to propagate at a velocity that exceeds the velocity of light. An often needed property of timelike vectors x and y of Minkowski space M states that the Schwartz inequality holds in the reversed form (x · y)2 ≥ x2 y 2
(3.2)
with the equality sign being valid only when x and y are linearly dependent. For the proof, introduce the linear combination u = ax − by with a = x · y and b = x · x, obeying u · x = 0; since x is timelike, this implies that u is either spacelike or zero. We thus have 0 ≥ u2 = b(b y 2 − a2 ), and as b = x2 > 0 it follows that a2 ≥ by 2 , which is the reversed Schwartz inequality. The equality holds if u = ax − by = 0, and since a, b 6= 0 this implies that x and y are linearly dependent. Furthermore, for timelike x and y in M with the same time orientation, the triangle inequality holds in the reversed form |x + y| ≥ |x| + |y| (3.3) where |x| = (x2 )1/2 ; the equality sign holds only when x and y are linearly dependent. The
verification starts from the version |x · y| ≥ |x| |y| of the reversed Schwartz inequality; since
x · y > 0, it implies x · y ≥ |x| |y| so that (x + y)2 ≥ x2 + 2|x| |y| + y 2 = (|x| + |y|)2 , which proves
the inequality. If the equality holds, then (x + y)2 = x2 + 2|x| |y| + y 2 entails x · y = |x| |y| or (x · y)2 = x2 y 2 , and so, by the preceding result, |x| and |y| are linearly dependent.
The Minkowski space is naturally endowed with a symmetry group, which is obtained by considering the line element ds2 = gµν dxµ dxν .
(3.4)
Let x 7→ x′ be an invertible transformation of Minkowski space so that the Jacobian obeys ′ ∂x ∂x 6= 0.
We call this a symmetry transformation if it leaves the line element invariant in the sense that ds′2 = ds2 holds. In explicit terms, the condition reads ds′2 = gµν dx′µ dx′ν = gµν
∂x′µ ∂x′ν ρ τ dx dx = ds2 = gρτ dxρ dxτ ∂xρ ∂xτ
which suggest that the equations gµν
∂x′µ ∂x′ν = gρτ ∂xρ ∂xτ
(3.5)
must hold. In order to make the above argument rigorous, some care is required. For this, we must give a precise meaning to the ‘line element’ squared (3.4); it is a line element in the original sense if, for a given curve x(τ ), we make the identification dxµ ≡ x˙ µ (τ )dτ so that p ds = ±gµν x˙ µ x˙ ν dτ (3.6)
for gµν x˙ µ x˙ ν ≷ 0. Since the tangent vector x˙ µ transforms under x 7→ x′ (x) as ∂x′µ (x) x˙ ′µ (τ ) = x˙ ν (τ ) ∂xν x=x(τ )
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Invariance
book
47
we must guarantee ds′2 = gµν
∂x′µ ∂x′ν ! x˙ ρ x˙ σ dτ 2 = ds2 = gρσ x˙ ρ x˙ σ dτ 2 . ∂xρ ∂xσ x=x(τ )
However, from g(x˙ ′ , x˙ ′ ) = g(x, ˙ x) ˙ we cannot infer that eq. (3.5) holds. But this conclusion can be drawn if we interpret ds2 as the tensor product g=
1 gµν dxµ ⊗ dxν = gµν dxµ ∨ dxν . 2
(3.7)
2
Because the dxµ ∨ dxν form a basis in the symmetrization ∨T ∗ (M ), we can then conclude from g ′ = gµν dx′µ ∨ dx′ν = gµν
∂x′µ ∂x′ν ρ ! dx ∨ dxσ = g = gρσ dxρ ∨ dxσ ∂xρ ∂xσ
that necessarily eq. (3.5) must be fulfilled. Hence, with the version (3.7) of the ‘line element’ squared the invariance condition indeed follows, whereas for the geometrical line element (3.6) the requirement (3.5) is only a sufficient criterion for invariance.
The integrability conditions for the set of partial differential equations (3.5) are obtained on operating with ∂σ on these, which gives +gµν
∂ 2 x′µ ∂x′ν ∂x′µ ∂ 2 x′ν +g = 0, µν ∂xσ ∂xρ ∂xτ ∂xρ ∂xσ ∂xτ
−gµν
∂x′µ ∂ 2 x′ν ∂ 2 x′µ ∂x′ν −g = 0, µν ∂xτ ∂xσ ∂xρ ∂xσ ∂xτ ∂xρ
∂x′µ ∂ 2 x′ν ∂ 2 x′µ ∂x′ν +gµν = 0. ρ τ σ ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂xτ ∂xρ ∂xσ Here we have supplemented two conditions; they arise from the first by cyclic permutation of the indices σρ τ , the second being supplied with an overall minus sign. Adding these three equations, only the left term in the first and the right term in the third line survive, and so we find +gµν
∂ 2 x′µ ∂x′ν = 0. ∂xσ ∂xρ ∂xτ Because the transformation is invertible, we can rewrite the integrability conditions in the final form ∂ 2 x′µ =0 (3.8) ∂xρ ∂xτ saying that the transformation must be linear inhomogeneous, viz. gµν
x′µ = Λµ ν xν + aµ .
(3.9)
where Λ is a 4 × 4-matrix and a an arbitrary 4-vector. Since we have
∂x′µ = Λµ ν ∂xν invertibility requires |Λ| 6= 0; after all, insertion of (3.9) into (3.5) yields that Λ must obey Λµ ρ gµν Λν τ = gρτ .
(3.10)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
48
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Consequently, Λ also leaves the inner product invariant: for all x, y ∈ M.
g(Λx, Λy) = g(x, y)
(3.11)
Linear transformations Λ : M → M with the property (3.11) are called Lorentz transformations. We also write the condition (3.11) in the form Λ·τµ· Λτ ν = g µ ν
: (Λ−1 )µ ν = g µσ Λρ σ gρν = Λ·νµ·
(3.12)
saying that the transpose of Λ with respect to g is equal to the inverse. Hence, both versions show that the determinant takes values |Λ| = ±1, and so invertibility of Lorentz transformations is not an extra condition. Beyond this, they form a group, as is easily verified; this is denoted by L and called the complete Lorentz group. As we have remarked, the determinant |Λ| of a Lorentz transformation Λ can take the values ±1; accordingly, one defines: +1 : proper Lorentz transformation |Λ| = (3.13) −1 : improper Lorentz transformation
Lorentz transformations can be characterized even further; to see this, consider X Λµ 0 Λµ 0 = (Λ0 0 )2 − (Λk 0 )2 = 1 k
µ
Λ0 Λ
0
µ
0
2
= (Λ 0 ) −
so that
X
(3.14)
(Λ0 k )2 = 1
k
|Λ0 0 | ≥ 1. Accordingly, we define sign Λ0 0 =
+1 −1
(3.15)
:
orthochronous
:
nonorthochronous
(3.16)
and introduce the proper orthochronous Lorentz group L0 = {Λ ∈ L| |Λ| = 1, Λ0 0 ≥ 1}
(3.17)
which is indeed a subgroup of the complete Lorentz group. For the proof one must show that the product Λ12 = Λ1 Λ2 of two orthochronous transformations Λ1 and Λ2 is again orthochronous. We begin with the observation that (see (3.14)) for an orthochronous Λ the two inequalities sX sX Λ0 0 > (Λk 0 )2 Λ0 0 > (Λ0 k )2 k
k
are valid; using Schwartz’s inequality in the form v · w ≥ −|v| |w| for v, w ∈ R3 , we then find sX sX X ((Λ1 )0 k )2 ((Λ2 )k 0 )2 > (Λ12 )0 0 = (Λ1 )0 0 (Λ2 )0 0 + (Λ1 )0 k (Λ2 )k 0 ≥ (Λ1 )0 0 (Λ2 )0 0 − k
k
k
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Invariance
book
49
sX sX sX sX ((Λ1 )0 k )2 ((Λ2 )k 0 )2 − ((Λ1 )0 k )2 ((Λ2 )k 0 )2 = 0 k
k
k
k
which is the assertion.
The name orthochronous derives from the following fact. A nonzero timelike or lightlike vector x ∈ M with x0 > 0 (x0 < 0) is called future (past) directed; then an orthochronous Lorentz transformation leaves the time direction invariant. As to the proof, note that for a future directed nonzero timelike or lightlike vector x ∈ M we have x0 ≥ |x|, and thus !1/2 X 0 0 0 0 k 0 0 0 2 (Λx) = Λ 0 x + Λ k x ≥ Λ 0 x − (Λ k ) |x| k
X
>
(Λ0 k )2
k
!1/2
(x0 − |x|) ≥ 0
as claimed. Since the continuous image of a connected set is connected, the complete Lorentz group L is not connected; but as we shall see later, the proper orthochronous Lorentz group L0 < L is. Consequently, L decomposes into four disjoint connected components; representatives of the remaining three are given by −1 −1 0 |Λ| = +1, sign Λ 0 = −1 : ΛP T = −1 −1 +1 −1 0 |Λ| = −1, sign Λ 0 = +1 : ΛP = (3.18) −1 −1 −1 +1 0 |Λ| = −1, sign Λ 0 = −1 : ΛT = +1 +1
where the subscript P stands for parity or space inversion, T for time inversion, and P T for the complete inversion. We can thus decompose the complete Lorentz group in the form L=
∪
J=I,P,T,P T
ΛJ L 0 .
(3.19)
The discrete transformations, if supplemented by the identity I, yield a discrete subgroup V4 = {I, P, T, P T } of L (which is identical with the Kleinian four-group).
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
50
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
As is easily checked, the connected component of the identity L0 < L is an invariant subgroup with respect to the discrete transformations; hence, we even have L0 ⊳ L, i.e., the proper orthochronous Lorentz group is an invariant (normal) subgroup of the complete Lorentz group. Let us return to the inhomogeneous transformations; they are transformations of Minkowski space as well. In order to make this property apparent, we write these in the form x′ = Λx + a = (a, Λ)x
(3.20)
where (a, Λ) is composed of a Lorentz transformation and a translation, and called a Poincar´e transformation. Those pairs are naturally endowed with a product structure, as follows from x′′ = (a′ , Λ′ )x′ = (a′ , Λ′ )(a, Λ)x = Λ′ x′ + a′ = Λ′ Λx + Λ′ a + a′ = (a′′ , Λ′′ )x so that we read off the composition law (a′ , Λ′ )(a, Λ) = (a′ + Λ′ a, Λ′ Λ).
(3.21)
Again, it is readily verified that these inhomogeneous transformations of Minkowski space form a group, called the complete Poincar´e group and denoted by P ; e.g., the inverse element of (a, Λ) is given by (a, Λ)−1 = (−Λ−1 a, Λ−1 ).
(3.22)
Hence, the Poincar´e group may be viewed as the natural symmetry group of Minkowski space. For what follows we restrict ourselves to the connected component of the identity, if not stated otherwise. In the foregoing we have tacitly assumed the reader to have some nodding acquaintance with the basic notions of a group. We give the definitions in the next but one (starred) section, where also some concepts of Lie groups and their algebras are developed. Here we keep the discussion at a low-brow level and only use some elementary facts, which should be intelligible in their own right. What we need to explain is the concept a Lie group, as opposed to a group of finite order (see, e.g., Choquet-Bruhat, DeWitt-Morette and Dillard-Bleick (1982), and Sattinger and Weaver (1986)). In the discrete case, the distinct elements gi can be labelled by a finite set I, whereas for a (connected) Lie group, continuous parameters α taking values in a subset of Rm are needed. Hence, an element of a Lie group G can be written in the form g(α) with α ∈ Rm , and it is assumed that the dependence on the parameters is smooth. The parametrization is always supposed to be arranged such that g(0) = e holds, where e denotes the unit element. The number of independent parameters for a Lie group is called its dimension. Let us count it for the Lorentz group; for this purpose, we expand Λ about the unit element: Λµ ν = g µ ν + αµ ν + · · ·
(3.23)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Invariance
book
51
Insertion into the defining equation (3.10) yields (gτ µ + ατ µ + · · · )(g τ ν + ατ ν + · · · ) = g µ ν + αµ ν + α·νµ· + · · · = g µ ν
and so the αµν = gµρ αρ ν must be antisymmetric: +αµν = −ανµ .
(3.24)
Hence, there are six parameters for the Lorentz group. The expansion (3.23) also serves another purpose; in order to explain it, we antisymmetrize the first order term so as to make the dependence on the antisymmetric parameters explicit: 1 Λµ ν = g µ ν + (g µ ρ gντ − g µ τ gνρ )αρτ + · · · (3.25) 2 Quantities of basic importance for Lie groups are the infinitesimal operators or generators, defined by ∂ g(α) : a = 1, . . . , m (3.26) Xa = ∂αa α=0 the number of which equals the dimension of the Lie group. For the Lorentz group, they are read off from (3.25): ∂ ρ (Mµν )ρ τ = Λ (α) = gµ ρ gντ − gν ρ gµτ . (3.27) τ µν ∂α α=0 It is left to the reader to compute the commutator of two infinitesimal operators, which can be written [Mµν , Mρτ ] = −gµρ Mντ − gντ Mµρ + gµτ Mνρ + gνρ Mµτ .
(3.28)
What we thus learn is that the commutator is again a linear combination of the infinitesimal operators. This is also the general rule; the commutators close in the sense [Xa , Xb ] = C c ab Xc
(3.29)
with the structure constants C c ab being antisymmetric in the lower indices. That construct is known as the Lie algebra of the Lie group G. We want to return now from the Lie algebra to the corresponding Lie group, and this can be achieved as follows. For that purpose, consider the exponential of a complex square matrix X, defined by ∞ X Xn exp X = . (3.30) n! n=0 The series converges for arbitrary X with finite entries; furthermore, the exponential function can also be expressed in terms of a limit 1
exp X = lim (e n X )n . n→∞
(3.31)
Here it is understood on the right-hand side that exp n1 X ≡ I + n1 X; this representation is well known for the standard exponential function, and it also holds for matrices. If for X the general element X = αa Xa of the Lie algebra is chosen, then
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
52
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
the right-hand side of (3.31) under the limit is the product of elements of G in the vicinity of the unit element. Consequently, it is again an element of G; this may also be shown to hold for the limit so that an element g(α) in the vicinity of the unit element can be written in the form of an exponential: a
g(α) = eα
Xa
∈ G.
(3.32)
In general, this exponential map is not surjective, i.e., one does not reach all elements of the Lie group; this happens, in particular, if G is not connected. But in favourable cases it is even onto if we restrict ourselves to the connected component. Let us make the above observations explicit for the Lorentz group. It is easy to write down one-parameter subgroups of L0 ; there are two different types: 1 0 0 0 cosh β 3 0 0 sinh β 3 0 cos α3 − sin α3 0 0 10 0 3 (3.33) Λ(0, 0, α3 ) = 0 + sin α3 cos α3 0 Λ(0, 0, β ) = 0 01 0 0 0 0 1 sinh β 3 0 0 cosh β 3
The first with 0 ≤ α3 < 2π is recognized as a rotation, and the second with −∞ ≤ β 3 < +∞ is known as a pure Lorentz transformation; the other one-parameter groups are defined similarly. It is not an accident that rotations of the vector part x of x occur here, since the rotations R(α) form a subgroup of L: 1 (3.34) Λ(α) = Ri j (α) i,j=1,2,3 Hence, it suggests itself to decompose a general Lorentz transformation Λ ∈ L0 in the form of a product of a rotation and a pure Lorentz transformation, viz. Λ(α) = Λ(β)Λ(α)
(3.35)
with the parameters α and β being related to the αµν by αk0 = β k
αij = −εijk αk .
(3.36)
Correspondingly, for the infinitesimal operators we have ∂ ∂ 3 3 N3 = Λ(0, 0, β ) = M , . . . M = Λ(0, 0, α ) = M12 , . . . (3.37) 30 3 ∂β 3 ∂α3 β=0 α=0 where, for rotations, the ellipses are to be understood as cyclic permutations. The factorization (3.35) is adapted to the subgroup SO(3) < S 0 (1, 3); hence we have the
projection map π : S 0 (1, 3) → S 0 (1, 3)/SO(3) onto the homogeneous space S 0 (1, 3)/SO(3), for which the pure Lorentz transformations Λ(β) provide the natural section.
What we aim at now is to compute the individual factors in (3.35) by means of the exponential function: k
Λ(α) = eα
Mk
Λ(β) = eβ
k
Nk
.
(3.38)
Let us begin with rotations; we introduce the notation (α 6= 0) ei =
αi α
: α = |α|
(3.39)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Invariance
53
and for the infinitesimal operators we use the explicit form (Mk )i j = εi kj .
(3.40)
We then find (in Minkowski signature) R(α)i j = cos α g i j − (1 − cos α)ei ej − sin α εi jk ek
(3.41)
which is a result that is said to date back to the year 1840, called the Rodrigues formula. Note that since Ri j (α)ej = ei holds, the vector with components ei can be identified as the axis of rotation. The proof of the Rodrigues formula rests on the fact that, up to prefactors in α, the even and odd powers mutually reproduce themselves, as is seen from (αk Mk )i j = −αek εki j ((αk Mk )2 )i j = +α2 ek el εki m εlm j = α2 ek el (g kl g i j − g k j g il ) = −α2 (g i j + ei ej ) ((αk Mk )3 )i j = +α3 (g i k + ei ek )el εlk j = α3 ek εki j
((αk Mk )4 )i j = −α4 ek el εki m εlm j = α4 (g i j + ei ej )
Using induction, we thus obtain
α2 i α4 i g j+ g j + ··· 2! 4! 1 α α3 − ek εki j + ek εki j + · · · 1! 3! α2 i α4 i −ei ej + ei ej − e ej + e ej + · · · 2! 4!
R(α)i j = g i j −
= cos α g i j − sin α ek εki j − ei ej + cos α ei ej as claimed.
For pure Lorentz transformations, we introduce the notation fi =
βi β
: β = |β|
(3.42)
when β 6= 0, and the infinitesimal operators are (Nk )µ ν = g µ k g0ν − g µ 0 gkν . In matrix notation, a pure Lorentz transformation is cosh β −fk sinh β Λ(β) = +f i sinh β g i k + (1 − cosh β)f i fk i,k=1,2,3
(3.43)
(3.44)
the importance of which will be commented upon below. Note that the parametrization does not become singular for β → 0 since f i sinh β → β in this limit; a similar remark applies to rotations. Again, the even and odd powers mutually reproduce themselves up to scalar prefactors since (β k Nk )µ ν = βfk (g kµ g 0 ν − g k ν g 0µ ) ((β k Nk )2 )µ ν = β 2 fk fi (g kµ g 0 τ − g k τ g 0µ )(g iτ g 0 ν − g i ν g 0τ ) = β 2 (g 0µ g 0 ν − fk fi g kµ g i ν )
((β k Nk )3 )µ ν = β 3 fj (g jµ g 0 τ − g j τ g 0µ )(g 0τ g 0 ν − fk fi g kτ g i ν ) = β 3 fk (g kµ g 0 ν − g k ν g 0µ )
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
54
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
and so on; thus, by collecting the individual terms Λ(β)µ ν = g µ ν β1 fk (g kµ g 0 ν − g k ν g 0µ ) + · · · 1! β 2 0µ 0 (g g ν − fk fi g kµ g i ν ) + · · · + 2! = g µ ν + sinh βfk (g kµ g 0 ν − g k ν g 0µ ) − (1 − cosh β)(g 0µ g 0 ν − fk fi g kµ g i ν ) +
which gives the above result.
In order to discuss the significance of pure Lorentz transformations, recall the formula (1.48) obtained earlier, which gives the 4-momentum of a particle of nonzero mass m in terms of its usual 3-velocity. We introduce the corresponding 4-velocity u by pµ = muµ
(3.45) ◦
where u0 = γc and uk = γv k ; in particular, the 4-velocity u of a particle at rest is given by c 0 ◦ u= (3.46) 0 . 0
In order to transform a particle at rest into a particle at 4-velocity u, we use a pure ◦ Lorentz transformation, i.e., we set Λ(β)u = u, which determines the pure Lorentz transformation to be u0 uk − c c ◦ Λu = : Λu u = u. (3.47) ui i ui uk + gk− c c(u0 + c) i,k=1,2,3 This is another basic formula of special relativity which we shall have to return to later. 3.2
Transformation Law of Fields
Now that we know what Lorentz and Poincar´e transformations are, we can discuss the transformation law of fields. We begin with the Klein-Gordon field ϕ(x) and consider the transformation of the argument x 7→ x′ = Λ x + a.
(3.48)
We use this to introduce the transformed field ϕ′ by ϕ′ (x′ ) = ϕ(x)
(3.49)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Invariance
book
55
traditionally being called a passive transformation. A better version is the active transformation, which is obtained on interchanging x′ and x, giving ϕ′ (x) = ϕ(Λ−1 (x − a)) = (T (a, Λ)ϕ)(x).
(3.50)
This definition of the field transformation T (a, Λ) has the virtue that it yields a representation of the Poincar´e group on the linear space of fields in the sense that T (a, Λ)T (a′ , Λ′ ) = T (a + Λa′ , ΛΛ′ )
(3.51)
holds, as the reader should verify. We want to prove that the Klein-Gordon equation is invariant under Poincar´e transformations where, for simplicity, we choose the passive form. For this, we need the transformation law of the partial derivatives ∂µ , which is obtained by means of the chain rule: ∂ ∂x′ν ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ = = (Λν τ xτ + aν ) ′ν = Λν µ ′ν . µ µ ′ν µ ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x Remember that up to now we have left open the question why for the partial derivatives the index is chosen to be in lower position; here we obtain the answer since we then have ∂µ = Λν µ ∂ν′
∂µ′ = Λµ ν ∂ν .
(3.52)
Hence, the d’Alembert operator is invariant because ∂µ′ ∂ ′µ = Λµ ρ Λµ τ ∂ρ ∂ τ = ∂ρ ∂ ρ and so we conclude (∂µ′ ∂ ′µ + m2 )ϕ′ (x′ ) = (∂µ ∂ µ + m2 )ϕ(x) = 0 saying that, if the unprimed field solves the Klein-Gordon equation, then this also holds for the primed field. The situation is slightly different for the Maxwell field. We begin by first extending the free Maxwell equations to the massive case: ∂ µ ∂µ Aν − ∂ ν ∂µ Aµ + m2 Aν = 0.
(3.53)
These are called the Proca equations, having the peculiar property that (for m 6= 0) they entail the Lorentz condition ∂µ Aµ = 0 automatically; this is compatible with the fact that gauge invariance is lost in the massive case. In the present case it is not sufficient to transform the argument according to (3.48) only, also the 4-vector potential must be transformed. It is natural to define it as the passive transformation A′µ (x′ ) = Λµ ν Aν (x)
(3.54)
(T (a, Λ)A)µ (x) = Λµ ν Aν (Λ−1 (x − a)).
(3.55)
and in the active case
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
56
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
We leave it to the reader to show that with this definition the Proca equation is invariant. Finally, we make a digression in order to fill another gap that we have left open. As the alert reader will have noticed, up to now we did not discuss at all the Lie algebra of the Poincar`e group. We can do this here since with (3.50) a linear representation of the Poincar`e group - which acts nonlinearly on Minkowski space - is available. According to the general definition, the generators of Lorentz transformations and translations are given by ∂ T (Mµν ) = + µν T (a, Λ) a=α=0 = xµ ∂ν − xν ∂µ ∂α (3.56) ∂ T (Pµ ) = − µ T (a, Λ) a=α=0 = ∂µ . ∂a Then a straightforward computation yields the commutation relations [T (Mµν ), T (Mρτ )] = −gµρ T (Mντ ) − gντ T (Mµρ ) + gµτ T (Mνρ ) + gνρ T (Mµτ ) (3.57) [T (Pµ ), T (Pν )] = 0
[T (Mµν ), T (Pτ )] = −gµτ T (Pν ) + gντ T (Pµ ).
(3.58)
We could as well omit the decoration of the infinitesimal operators with the symbol T since we know that T (a, Λ) is a representation of the Poincar`e group. This is the reason why the first set of these commutation relations is identical with that in (3.28) above. Had we taken the field representation for the 4-vector potential, being more complicated, the result for the commutation relations would turn out to be the same. Let us conclude with the remark that, of course, it is not an accident that the generators of translations (see (3.56)) are just the partial derivatives. This observation can be made use of in order to deepen the insight into the origin of the Klein-Gordon equation since the Klein-Gordon operator T (Pµ )T (P µ ) is one of the two Casimir operators of the Poincar`e group, which commutes with all the generators. 3.3
Appendix: Lie Groups and Lie Algebras *
For the convenience of the reader we collect here some basic facts about group theory and transformation groups. We then turn to Lie groups and their algebras, and develop some tools that will be needed in later chapters. 3.3.1 3.3.1.1
Fundamentals of group theory Groups
Definition 3.1. A group is a set G equipped with an internal operation µ : G×G → G, written multiplicatively as µ(g1 , g2 ) = g1 g2 for g1 , g2 ∈ G, with the properties
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Invariance
book
57
(i) the multiplication is associative, i.e. (g1 g2 )g3 = g1 (g2 g3 ) for all g1 , g2 , g3 ∈ G (ii) there exists an element e ∈ G, called unit, with ge = eg = g for all g ∈ G (iii) for every g ∈ G there exists a g −1 ∈ G, called the inverse, such that g −1 g = gg −1 = e. Remark: The neutral element is unique since, given another e′ with the property e′ g = g for all g ∈ G, we find, on choosing g = e, that e′ e = e = e′ , which is the assertion. Remark: A group with the property g1 g2 = g2 g1 for all g1 , g2 , g3 ∈ G is said to be abelian. To give an example of a group, consider a finite dimensional complex vector space V and let Aut(V ) be the set of invertible linear maps of V onto V ; since the composition of maps is associative, Aut(V ) is a group with idV the unit element, which is called the general linear group associated to V , denoted by GL(V ). A subset H of G is called a subgroup of G, denoted H < G, if for all h, h′ ∈ H also hh′ ∈ H and h−1 ∈ H. An example is the subset of GL(V ) consisting of those elements for which the matrix representation has determinant one; this is denoted by SL(V ), where S stands for special, i.e., determinant one. A map ϕ : G → H of two groups G and H is called a homomorphism if ϕ(g1 )ϕ(g2 ) = ϕ(g1 g2 ) for all g1 , g2 , g3 ∈ G, and ϕ(e) = f where f denotes the unit element of H. The kernel is the set ker ϕ = {g ∈ G|ϕ(g) = f }. This kernel is a subgroup of G since, for g1 , g2 ∈ ker ϕ, it follows that ϕ(g1 )ϕ(g2 ) = ϕ(g1 g2 ) = f , i.e., g1 g2 ∈ ker ϕ; furthermore, for g ∈ ker ϕ we have, on account of ϕ(g)ϕ(g −1 ) = ϕ(gg −1 ) = ϕ(e) = f , that also g −1 ∈ ker ϕ. Beyond this, the kernel of a homomorphism is distinguished by a further remarkable property; for g ′ ∈ ker ϕ and any g ∈ G, we have ϕ(gg ′ g −1 ) = ϕ(g)ϕ(g ′ )ϕ(g −1 ) = ϕ(g)f ϕ(g −1 ) = f , and so it follows that g(ker ϕ)g −1 = ker ϕ for all g ∈ G. This instructs us to call a subgroup N of a group G a normal subgroup or invariant subgroup of G, denoted N ⊳ G, if gN g −1 = N for all g ∈ G. 3.3.1.2
Factorization of groups
Let two groups G1 and G2 be given and consider the cartesian product G1 ×G2 ; this is made a group by declaring the multiplication to be (g1 , g2 )(g1′ , g2′ ) = (g1 g1′ , g2 g2′ ). It is called the direct product of G1 and G2 , and it is easy to see that G1,2 ⊳ G1 × G2 . Conversely, assume that a group G contains two normal subgroups N1 and N2 such that N1 ∩ N2 = e and N1 N2 = G as a set. We then conclude from N1 ⊳ G that −1 −1 −1 n2 n−1 1 n2 ∈ N1 for all n2 ∈ N2 , and hence also n1 n2 n1 n2 ∈ N1 ; analogously, for −1 −1 −1 N2 we have n1 n2 n−1 1 n2 ∈ N2 . But then N1 ∩N2 = e tells us that n1 n2 n1 n2 = e, or n1 n2 = n2 n1 for all n1 ∈ N1 and n2 ∈ N2 . Furthermore, the factorization is ′−1 ′ ′ unique since n1 n2 = n′1 n′2 implies n′−1 1 n1 = n2 n2 = e so that n1 = n1 and n2 = n2 as claimed; in addition, the map µ : N1 × N2 → G defined by µ(n1 , n2 ) = n1 n2 is an isomorphism.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
58
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
One can also obtain a factorization, if only one of the two factors is a normal subgroup. So we assume that N ⊳ G and H < G and G = N H; the factorization is unique if and only if N ∩ H = e holds. Then we can write the multiplication as (nh)(n′ h′ ) = n(hn′ h−1 )hh′ with hn′ h−1 ∈ N and hh′ ∈ H, where n′ 7→ hn′ h−1 is an automorphism of N . Conversely, let G1 and G2 be two groups and α : G2 → Aut(G1 ) be given, where Aut(G) denotes the automorphisms of G, i.e. the invertible homomorphisms of G onto itself; they form a group. Then the multiplication law on G1 × G2 is taken to be (g1 , g2 )(g1′ , g2′ ) = (g1 α(g2 )g1′ , g2 g2′ ) which defines the semidirect product, denoted G1 ⋊ G2 , of G1 and G2 . We then have G1 ⊳ G1 ⋊ G2 (but G2 < G1 ⋊ G2 only) since (g1 , g2 )(g1′ , e2 )(g1 , g2 )−1 = (g1 α(g2 )g1′ , g2 )(α(g2 )−1 g1−1 , g2−1 ) = (g1 α(g2 )g1′ g1−1 , e2 ) ∈ G1 × {e2 }. The semidirect product is direct iff α(g2 ) = idG1 for all g2 ∈ G2 . To give an example, consider the Poincar´e group P with its two subgroups T and L, where a ∈ T is a translation and Λ ∈ L a Lorentz transformation; we introduce the natural homomorphism α : L → Aut(T ) by α(Λ)a = Λa and define the multiplication by (a, Λ)(a′ , Λ′ ) = (a+α(Λ)a′ , ΛΛ′ ), this being the multiplication as given in (3.21) above. Hence, the Poincar´e group is the semidirect product P = T ⋊ L of translations and Lorentz transformations. In the following we give a characterization of semidirect products; it is a result that will only be needed at a later stage, and so may be omitted on a first reading. To begin with, consider a sequence of group homomorphisms ϕi : Gi → Gi+1 , which we visualize as the chain of maps ϕi−1
ϕ
· · · → Gi−1 → Gi →i Gi+1 → · · · The sequence is said to be exact if im ϕi−1 = ker ϕi for all i, i.e. if the image of one homomorphism is the kernel of the next; we then have that Gi−1 ⊳ Gi , i.e. ϕ Gi−1 is normal in Gi . As a special case, take the sequence 1 → F → G where ϕ is a homomorphism of the group F into the group G, and the map 1 → F denotes the injection of the unit into F ; this sequence is exact if and only if ϕ is injective. χ Similarly, the sequence of homomorphisms G → H → 1 is exact if and only if χ is surjective. Let us focus then on what is called a short exact sequence π
1→N →G→H →1
(3.59)
where N necessarily is a normal subgroup of G and π the projection π : G → G/N ∼ = H. A short exact sequence of groups is said to be split if there exists a
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Invariance
59
homomorphism σ : H → G such that π ◦ σ = idH , i.e. the projection π admits what is called a section or splitting: π
→ H → 1. 1 → N → G←
(3.60)
σ
We want to show now the validity of the following Proposition 3.1. A group G is isomorphic to a semidirect product N ⋊H of N ⊳G and H < G if and only if the short exact sequence π
1→N →G→H →1
(3.61)
splits. ι
N Proof. Let us begin with the verification that the short exact sequence 1 → N → pH N ⋊α H → H → 1 splits. Here, ιN denotes the inclusion and pH the projection; furthermore, α : H → Aut(N ) with h 7→ αh determines the multiplication (n, h)(n′ , h′ ) = (nαh (n′ ), hh′ ) in the semidirect product. We only need to define the section to be σ = ιH with ιH (h) = (eN , h); this is a homomorphism since σ(hh′ ) = (eN , hh′ ) = (eN αh (eN ), hh′ ) = (eN , h)(eN , h′ ) = σ(h)σ(h′ ) that obeys π ◦ σ(h) = π(eN , h) = h, i.e. π ◦ σ = idH as required. π Conversely, assume that 1 → N → G → ← H → 1 with π◦σ = id holds. We define
σ
H
a homomorphism α : H → Aut(N ) through αh = Ad(σ(h)) where Ad(g)n = gng −1 ; this is indeed a homomorphism since N ⊳ G and αh αh′ = Ad(σ(h))Ad(σ(h′ )) = Ad(σ(h)σ(h′ )) = Ad(σ(hh′ )) = αhh′ .
Furthermore, we claim that the map ϕ : N ⋊α H → G defined by ϕ(n, h) = nσ(h) is an isomorphism. The homomorphism property is simple to verify since ϕ((n, h)(n′ , h′ )) = ϕ((nαh (n′ ), hh′ )) = nαh (n′ )σ(hh′ ) = nσ(h)n′ σ(h)−1 σ(hh′ ) = nσ(h)n′ σ(h′ ) = ϕ(n, h)ϕ(n′ , h′ ). As to the inverse χ of ϕ, we set χ(g) = (g (σ ◦ π)(g −1 ), π(g)) and first convince ourselves that g (σ ◦ π)(g −1 ) is contained in N ; indeed, we have π(g(σ ◦ π)(g −1 )) = π(g)(π ◦ σ ◦ π)(g −1 ) = π(g)π(g −1 ) = e.
To check the property χ = ϕ−1 , we begin with the right inverse ϕ ◦ χ(g) = ϕ(g (σ ◦ π)(g −1 ), π(g)) = g (σ ◦ π)(g −1 )σ(π(g)) = g and continue with the left inverse χ ◦ ϕ(n, h) = χ(nσ(h)) = (nσ(h)(σ ◦ π)(nσ(h))−1 , π(nσ(h)))
= (nσ(h)(σ ◦ π)(σ(h))−1 (σ ◦ π)(n)−1 , π(n)(π ◦ σ)(h)) = (n, h)
so that the proof is complete.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
60
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
3.3.1.3
Transformation groups
Let a group G and a set M be given; G is said to act as a left transformation group on M if an external multiplication G × M → M is given, written as (g, x) 7→ gx with g ∈ G and x ∈ M , subject to the requirements g(g ′ x) = (gg ′ )x
: g, g ′ ∈ G, x ∈ M.
ex = x
The action of G on M is said to be (fixed point) free if gx = x for some x ∈ M implies g = e; the action is said to be effective if gx = x for all x ∈ M implies g = e. As to the latter notion, consider the subset N of elements n ∈ G with the property that nx = x for all x ∈ M ; this is a subgroup of G since n, n′ ∈ N implies n(n′ x) = nx = x. Furthermore, for n ∈ N and g ∈ G we have gng −1 x = g(n(g −1 x)) = g(g −1 x) = e so that N E G, and so we can pass to the factor group G/N which then acts effectively on M . ◦ From now on assume that the action of G on M is effective. Then, let x be an ◦
arbitrary but fixed point in M and consider the subset G of elements in G with ◦◦ ◦ the property g x = x; this is a subgroup of G, called the stability subgroup or little ◦ ◦ ◦ group of x. Furthermore, the subset Gx is said to be the orbit of G through x. The action of G on M is called transitive if any two points of M can be connected by an element of G, i.e. if for arbitrary x, y ∈ M there exists a g ∈ G such that y = gx. ◦
◦
◦
◦
In this case, the stability subgroups G and H of x and y are isomorphic since there ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦◦ ◦ ◦◦ ◦ ◦ exists a g ∈ G with y = g x, and thus x = g x implies y = g gx = g gg −1 y so that ◦
◦
H = g Gg −1 as claimed. For a transitive action of G on M , we thus have a left coset decomposition ◦
◦
G = ∪x∈M gx G, where the gx ∈ G are chosen such that x = gx x holds. In this ◦
way, we have constructed a bijective map G/G → M and the associated surjection π : G → M . The assignment x 7→ gx can also be looked at as a map σ : M → G with the property π ◦ σ = idM ; it is called a section of the surjective map. 3.3.1.4
Group representations
Let V be a finite dimensional vector space over C; a homomorphism D : G → Aut(V ) is called a representation (Darstellung) of G; hence, the abstract group is realized as a matrix group. To give an example, consider the abelian (additive) group R and choose V to be real and 1-dimensional; then the representation property requires v(x + y) = v(x)v(y) and v(0) = 1, the solution of which is the exponential function. Hence, the representation theory of groups seems to be, and indeed is, the most effective approach to the theory of special functions (see Talman (1968), and Vilenkin (1968)). Two representations D1 and D2 on a vector spaces V are defined to be equivalent, if they are conjugate in the sense that there exists an A in Aut(V ) with D2 (g) = AD1 (g)A−1 for all g ∈ G. This defines an equivalence relation on the set of all representations; therefore one does not distinguish between equivalent repre-
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Invariance
book
61
sentations. We assume that V is also equipped with a scalar product h· | ·i; then a representation D is said to be unitary if hD(g)v|D(g)v ′ i = hv|v ′ i for all v, v ′ ∈ V and g ∈ G, in which case D(g)+ = D(g)−1 holds. Let D be a representation of G on V and U < V be a subspace; U is called an invariant subspace if D(g)u ∈ U for all g ∈ G and u ∈ U . The representation is said to be irreducible if {0} and V are the only invariant subspaces, and reducible otherwise. In the reducible case, a basis can be chosen in V such that the representation takes the form A(g) C(g) D(g) = 0 B(g) and thus, D(g)|U = A(g) is a representation of G on U . We can then construct a subspace W < V such that V = U ⊕ W ; hence, another representation of G can be constructed by declaring D(g)w and D(g)w′ with w, w′ ∈ W to be equivalent if they differ by a vector in U . But in general, one cannot choose a basis in V such that D(g) takes a block-diagonal form; then also W were an invariant subspace. If so, the representation is said to be completely reducible. Let V also be endowed with a scalar product, with respect to which the reducible representation D(g) is unitary. Then it is completely reducible since the direct sum can be chosen to be orthogonal. Namely, set W := U ⊥ ; then for all u ∈ U and w ∈ W , hD(g)u|D(g)wi = 0 by hypothesis, hence GW ⊆ W as asserted. We finally prove a result, being of fundamental importance in the theory of group representations: Lemma 3.1 (Schur’s Lemma). The only linear operators that commute with an irreducible representation are multiples of the identity. Proof. We divide the proof into two parts. As to the first, let A ∈ End(V ) be an operator, which commutes with D(g) for all g ∈ G, and consider its kernel kerA = {v ∈ V |Av = 0}. This is an invariant subspace since v ∈ kerA implies AD(g)v = D(g)Av = 0 so that D(g)v ∈ kerA for all g ∈ G. Since D is irreducible, we thus conclude that either kerA = {0} or kerA = V . Let us turn then to the second part, assuming that A is bijective. Because C is algebraically closed, A has an eigenvector vλ with Avλ = λvλ . As A−λ1 also commutes with the representation and vλ ∈ ker(A − λ1), we conclude that ker(A − λ1) = V . In other words, A = λ1, as was to be proven. 3.3.2
Lie groups and their algebras
Here we restrict ourselves to matrix groups, as is legitimate on account of a theorem of Ado, stating that a Lie group is locally isomorphic to a subgroup of the general linear group.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
62
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
3.3.2.1
book
Matrix exponential
We begin with studying the properties of the matrix exponential exp X =
∞ X Xn n! n=0
(3.62)
of a matrix X ∈ End(V ), where V is assumed to be a complex vector space; the series (3.62) converges for any matrix X with finite entries. We also accept without proof that the matrix exponential can as well be written as the infinite product exp X = lim (I + n→∞
1 n X) . n
(3.63)
Convergence of the matrix exponential series (3.62) holds in the operator norm k X k= sup k Xv k kvk=1
P of End(V ) as a Banach algebra, where v ∈ V and k v k= ( |vk |2 )1/2 . For a convergent series k P P cn X n then converges f (z) = cn z n in z ∈ C with radius of convergence R, the series f (X) = in the operator norm for all X with k X k< R. Hence, exp X is defined for any matrix X ∈ End(V );
also the inverse function X = log A is defined for all A with k A − I k< 1 and obeys exp log X = X.
For proofs see, e.g., Arnold (2001).
Lemma 3.2. (exp X)+ = exp(X + ) Proof.
(3.64)
This is an immediate consequence of (3.62).
Lemma 3.3. X e = etrX
(3.65)
Remark This formula can also be read in suggestive form as log det A = tr log A. Proof. The verification follows from |1 + ε X| = 1 + ε trX + O(ε2 ) and the representation (3.63) of the matrix exponential: X e = lim |I + 1 X|n = lim |1 + 1 trX|n = exp trX n→∞ n→∞ n n Lemma 3.4.
d tX e = XetX = etX X dt Proof.
The simple proof is left to the reader.
(3.66)
This property can also be stated as saying that the solution of the first-order differential equation d A(t) = XA(t) dt
(3.67)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Invariance
63
with the initial condition A(1) = A = exp X is given by A(t) = etX . With the notation ad(X)Y = [X, Y ]
(3.68)
the following formula is valid: Lemma 3.5. eX Y e−X = ead(X)Y =
∞ X 1 n ad (X)Y n! n=0
(3.69)
Proof. Introduce the t-dependent matrix Y (t) = etX Y e−tX , which obeys the differential equation Y˙ (t) = etX [X, Y ]e−tX = [X, Y (t)], or Y˙ (t) = ad(X)Y (t) Its solution is Y (t) = e
t ad(X)
: Y (0) = Y.
Y , giving the assertion.
Lemma 3.6. For X, Y ∈ End(V ) with [X, [X, Y ]] = 0 = [[X, Y ], Y ], the following Weyl formula holds: 1
eX eY = eX+Y + 2 [X,Y ] . Proof.
(3.70)
Consider the matrix A(t) = etX etY e−t(X+Y ) , which obeys
˙ A(t) = etX (X + Y )etY e−t(X+Y ) − etX etY (X + Y )e−t(X+Y ) = etX [X, etY ]e−t(X+Y ) . This result can be further simplified by means of [X, etY ] = XetY − etY Xe−tY etY = −t[Y, X]etY so that ˙ A(t) = etX t[Y, X]etY e−t(X+Y ) = t[X, Y ]A(t) 1 2
and the solution of the latter differential equation with A(0) = 1 is A(t) = e 2 t which for t = 1 gives the assertion.
[X,Y ]
,
The Weyl formula entails the property e(s+t)X = esX etX
(3.71)
(etX )−1 = e−tX
(3.72)
and this in turn shows
which, taken together, say that etX is a one-parameter group. Above, we only considered the case of a matrix exponential exp X(t) in which X(t) is linear in t; but the case of utmost importance in many applications is where the dependence of X(t) on t is arbitrary. Hence, what we are interested in, this is a formula for the derivative d X(t) e . dt
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
64
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
It is obtained on considering exp sX(t) with differentiation in t produces
d sX(t) ds e
book
= esX(t) X(t); subsequent
d d sX(t) d ˙ e = esX(t) X(t) + esX(t) X(t). dt ds dt Multiplication of the latter equation with exp −sX(t) from the right yields d d d sX(t) −sX(t) −sX(t) ˙ e e = esX(t) X(t)e−sX(t) + esX(t) X(t)e dt ds dt d d sX(t) −sX(t) d = e e + esX(t) X(t)e−sX(t) ds dt dt
which may be rearranged to give d sX(t) d −sX(t) −sX(t) ˙ e e = −esX(t) X(t)e . ds dt We thus arrive at e
X(t)
d −X(t) e =− dt
Z1
−sX(t) ˙ ds esX(t) X(t)e
(3.73)
0
which is also known as (a variant of) Duhamel’s formula; its integration is elementary since Z ∞ ∞ X X 1 n 1 d −X(t) ˙ ˙ e =− ad (X(t))X(t) ds sn = − adn (X(t))X(t). dt n! (n + 1)! n=0 n=0 1
e
X(t)
0
Introducing the (entire) function ϕ(z) =
z z2 ez − 1 =1+ + + ··· z 2! 3!
(3.74)
for z ∈ C, we finally obtain: Lemma 3.7. eX(t)
eadX(t) − 1 ˙ d −X(t) ˙ e = −ϕ(adX(t))X(t) =− X(t). dt adX(t)
(3.75)
This is an important formula that will be made use of at various places. As an application of the preceding lemma, let us compute the product eX eY = Z e ; for this, we define eZ(t) = eX etY . We begin with expressing adZ(t) by means of adX and adY ; since eZ(t) X ′ e−Z(t) = eX etY X ′ e−tY e−X = eadX et adY X ′ = eadZ(t) X ′
for X ′ ∈ End(V ), we read off
adZ(t) = log eadX et adY .
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Invariance
book
65
Consider then d Z(t) e = eX etY Y = eZ(t) Y dt the solution of which we know from (3.75) to be d Z(t) ˙ e = Y = ϕ(−adZ(t))Z(t) : Z(0) = X. dt We thus need the function 1/ϕ(− log z) with z ∈ C; since e−Z(t)
ϕ(− log z) = it is
e− log z − 1 z−1 = − log z z log z
z log z : ϕ(− log z)ψ(z) = 1. (3.76) z−1 This is an analytic function in a neighbourhood of z = 1; remarkably, the related function χ(z) = 1/ϕ(z) = z/(ez − 1) is the generating function of the Bernoulli numbers. Collecting results, the differential equation takes the form ψ(z) =
˙ Z(t) = ψ(eadX et adY )Y the integration of which yields: Lemma 3.8. (Campbell-Baker-Hausdorff) Z 1 Z=X+ dt ψ(eadX et adY )Y
(3.77)
0
The first few contributions 1 1 1 Z = X + Y + [X, Y ] + ([X, [X, Y ]] + [Y, [Y, X]]) − [X, [Y, [X, Y ]]] + · · · (3.78) 2 12 24 are obtained by integrating term wise; the computation is elementary but tedious. 3.3.2.2
Lie algebras
Let G be a matrix group with elements g(α), where α with components αa and a = 1, . . . , m takes values in a connected open subset of Rm ; the parametrization obeys g(0) = e by convention. Then the product g(α′′ ) = g(α)g(α′ ) is defined, and the functions α′′ = α′′ (α, α′ ) are assumed to be smooth. This yields what is called a real Lie group of dimension m, even though the entries of the matrix g(α) = g A B (α) A,B=1,...,N may be complex valued. Consider now the expansion of an element g(α) with |αa | ≪ 1 about the unit element ∂ g(α) = g(0) + g(α) αa + · · · ∂αa α=0
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
66
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
and introduce the infinitesimal operators ∂ Xa = g(α) . (3.79) ∂αa α=0 They form a real vector space of dimension m, denoted L(G), with the Xa as basis. Now an element in the vicinity of the identity takes the form g(α) = I + αa Xa and (3.63) then tells us that an element in a neighbourhood of the identity can be written as 1 a n a g(α) = lim e n α Xa = eα Xa ∈ G. (3.80) n→∞
This is indeed an element of G since the right side under the limit, as a product of elements in the vicinity of the identity, is contained in G, and so the limit as well (due to the Banach algebra structure). Hence, by exponentiating the elements of the linear space L(G), the Lie group is reconstructed, at least locally. In general, the exponential map need not be onto; but it is if G is connected and compact. The linear space L(G) can be endowed with an additional structure. To see this, a b consider the product g(α)g(β) = eα Xa eβ Xb which, on using the Campbell-BakerHausdorff formula (3.77), may be written in the form 1
g(α)g(β) = eX(α)+X(β)+ 2 [X(α),X(β)]+···
(3.81)
where, e.g., X(α) = αa Xa , and the dots denote higher commutators. Consequently, the commutator of two elements from L(G) must again be an element of L(G); for the basis, this closure condition is written in the form [Xa , Xb ] = C c ab Xc .
(3.82)
c
The coefficients C ab , being antisymmetric in the lower indices, are referred to as the structure constants. Hence the linear space L(G) is also equipped with a nonassociative product, the commutator; it forms what is called a Lie algebra. To give an example, consider the group SU (2) of complex unitary 2 × 2-matrices of determinant unity. Its dimension is 3, and so let αa with a = 1, 2, 3 be the parameters; their domain will be specified below. The expansion about the unit matrix of an element U (α) of SU (2) then is U (α) = 1 + αa Ta + · · · so that unitarity requires the generators to be antihermitian, and determinant one that they have zero trace. A basis of such matrices is obtained by means of the Pauli matrices 01 0 −i +1 0 σ1 = σ2 = σ3 = (3.83) 10 +i 0 0 −1
with the commutation relations [σa , σb ] = 2iεabc σ c ; hence, we only need to set Ta = − 2i σa in order to have [Ta , Tb ] = C c ab Tc
: C c ab = εc ab
(3.84)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Invariance
67
The general group element is obtained by exponentiation a
U (α) = eα
Ta
(3.85)
α α · 1 − i sin · ea σa 2 2
(3.86)
and reads U (α) = cos
where α = |α| and ea = αa /α for α 6= 0; the computation is straightforward and left to the reader. For a compact connected Lie group, the exponential map is known to be surjective. This statement applies to the present case, since an arbitrary element U ∈ SU (2) can be written in the form a b U= (3.87) −¯b a ¯ where a, b ∈ C must obey |a|2 + |b|2 = 1; so the group SU (2) is diffeomorphic to S 3 , the sphere in R4 of radius one. With the notation a = n4 − in3 and −¯b = n2 − in1 , where n = (n1 , n2 , n3 , n4 ) ∈ S 3 , we can write 4 n − in3 −n2 − in1 U= (3.88) n2 − in1 n4 + in3 and comparing this with eq. (3.86), viz. cos α2 − i sin α2 e3 −i sin α2 (e1 − ie2 ) U (α) = U (α, e) = −i sin α2 (e1 + ie2 ) cos α2 + i sin α2 e3
(3.89)
we can identify n1 = sin
α 1 e 2
n2 = sin
α 2 e 2
n3 = sin
α 3 e 2
n4 = cos
α 2
so that α/2 takes values in the interval [0, π]; the associated polar angle is here chosen to be α/2 since the group SU (2) is intimately related to the group SO(3) of rotations in 3-dimensional euclidean space, as we shall see below. 3.3.2.3
Adjoint representation
The above construction gives rise to the Definition 3.2. A finite dimensional vector space L over K, which is equipped with an internal multiplication, denoted by [v, w], with the properties (i) [u, λv + µw] = λ[u, v] + µ[u, w] : λ, µ ∈ K; u, v, w ∈ V (ii) [v, w] = −]w, v] (iii) [u, [v, w]] + [w, [u, v]] + [v, [w, u]] = 0 is called a Lie algebra.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
68
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
The property (iii) is called the Jacobi identity; this is automatically fulfilled for the case at hand, since the Lie bracket is the commutator. Note that the Lie product is not associative. A subspace K of L is said to be a Lie subalgebra, denoted K < L, if [K, K] ⊂ K; at the Lie group level, a Lie subalgebra corresponds to a local subgroup. Let ϕ : L → L′ be a linear map of two Lie algebras L and L′ , considered as vector spaces; it is called a Lie algebra homomorphism if it respects the Lie bracket in the sense : v, w ∈ V.
[ϕ(v), ϕ(w)] = ϕ([v, w])
(3.90)
This is the analogue of a Lie group homomorphism. The kernel of a Lie algebra homomorphism has the obvious property [L, Kerϕ] ≤ Kerϕ; this gives rise to the definition of an ideal J of L, denoted J EL, as a subspace J ≤ V such that [L, J] ≤ J holds. At the Lie group level, an ideal corresponds to a local invariant subgroup. The centre of a Lie algebra is the maximal ideal C with the property [L, C] = 0. A Lie algebra is said to be simple, if it contains no nontrivial ideal; it is called semisimple, if it contains no nontrivial abelian ideal. Let G be a Lie group with Lie algebra L; then one can define a representation of G on L by Ad(g)Y = gY g −1
: Y ∈ L, g ∈ G
(3.91)
which is of special relevance and called the adjoint representation. A representation of a Lie algebra is a Lie algebra homomorphism ρ : L → End(W ), where W denotes a finite dimensional vector space. Now choose W = L and define the analogue of the adjoint representation of G by ad(X)Y = [X, Y ].
(3.92)
Then (3.91) translates into the statement Ad(g) = ead(X)
: g = eX .
(3.93)
The adjoint representation can be written in explicit terms. Applying the Jacobi identity to the basis Xa with commutation relations (3.82), one obtains C e ad C d bc + C e cd C d ab + C e bd C d ca = 0.
(3.94)
adc b (Xa ) = (Ca )c b = C c ab
(3.95)
Since
the identity for the structure constants can be written by means of the adjoint representation in compact form as [Ca , Cb ] = C c ab Cc
(3.96)
and so the adjoint representation of G simply is a
Ad(g) = eα
Ca
.
(3.97)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Invariance
book
69
As it turns out, the adjoint representation is one of the most basic constructions in the theory of Lie groups and their algebras. For the example considered above, the group SU (2), the representation Ad is well known; it is U (α)Ta U (α)−1 = Rb a (α)Tb
(3.98)
where R is the 3-dimensional rotation Ra b (α) = cos α δ a b + (1 − cos α)ea eb − sin α εa bc ec .
(3.99)
This follows without any calculation from (3.40) and the derivation of the Rodrigues formula given there. Hence, what we learn is that Ad(SU (2)) = SO(3), i.e. the adjoint representation of the group SU (2) is just the 3-dimensional rotation group. So far we have not discussed the admissible range of the vectors α ∈ R3 in eq. (3.99), and for that purpose we proceed as follows. The trace of an element R ∈ SO(3) obeys 3 ≥ tr R ≥ −1 or +1 ≥ (tr R − 1)/2 ≥ −1, and this interval can uniquely be parametrized by cos α with 0 ≤ α ≤ π; on the other hand, from the representation (3.99) we infer tr R(α) = 2 cos α + 1 so that the requisite values are indeed reproduced. Furthermore, from 1 (Rab (α) − Rba (α)) = − sin α εabc ec 2 it follows that for a 6= b one can uniquely solve for e ∈ S 2 if sin α does not vanish. This happens for α = 0 and α = π; in the former case there is no problem since Rab (α)|α=0 = δab , whereas for α = π we have Rab (α)|α=0 = −δab + 2ea eb . Writing R(α) = R(α, e), this implies (Raa (π, e) + 1)/2 = ea 2 which shows that for α = π the unit vectors +e and −e determine the same group element. To summarize our findings, let Dn (r) = {x ∈ Rn |x·x ≤ r2 } denote the closed n-dimensional disc (or ball) of radius r; its boundary is the (n − 1)-dimensional sphere ∂Dn (r) = S n−1 (r). The group SO(3), if looked at as a manifold, is thus recognized as the 3-dimensional disc D3 (π) of radius π, for which antipodal points on the boundary S 2 (π) have to be identified. Up to a rescaling of the radius, this is the manifold P R 3 , with the acronym standing for the 3-dimensional real projective space. In particular we see, the group SO(3) is not simply connected. It is also known that the real projective space P R n can be realized as the quotient of the sphere S n with respect to the equivalence relation +n ∼ −n of points n ∈ S n ; hence, recalling that the group SU (2) is diffeomorphic to S 3 , the homomorphism (3.98) determines the map S 3 → S 3 / ∼ which identifies antipodal points on the 3-sphere.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
70
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
3.3.2.4
book
Killing form
On a Lie algebra L one can introduce a natural inner product, called the Killing form, which is defined by (X|Y ) = tr(ad(X)ad(Y ))
(3.100)
(Xa |Xb ) = γab = tr Ca Cb .
(3.101)
γab = 2δab
(3.102)
and on the basis For SO(3), this simply gives but in the general case, the above inner product may be both degenerate and non positive. An important property of the Killing form is given by the following Lemma 3.9. The Killing form of a Lie algebra L(G) is invariant under the adjoint action of G. Proof.
We know that Ad(g) is an automorphism of L; as such it obeys ad(Ad(g)X) = Ad(g)ad(X)Ad(g)−1
and we thus find (Ad(g)X|Ad(g)Y ) = tr (ad(Ad(g)X)ad(Ad(g)Y )) = tr Ad(g)ad(X)Ad(g)−1 Ad(g)ad(Y )Ad(g)−1 = tr(ad(X)ad(Y )) as claimed.
We leave it to the reader to prove that the structure constants Cabc = γad C d bc
(3.103)
are completely antisymmetric in their lower indices; for the verification, one has to make repeated use of the Jacobi identity. We now state without proof the following important Theorem 3.1. (Cartan) A Lie algebra L is semisimple if and only if the determinant of the metric tensor γab is nonzero, i.e. the Killing form is non-degenerate. A Lie group G is defined to be semisimple, if its associated Lie algebra L(G) is. For a semisimple Lie algebra, we then have · a d ea C a bc = −Ccb · = −γcd C be γ
(3.104)
which shows that tr Ca = 0 and Ad·ba· (g) = Ada b (g −1 ).
(3.105)
Hence, we see that a Lie group G is semisimple if and only if the adjoint representation is Ad(G) = SO0 (p, q) with p + q = m, i.e., is a pseudo-orthogonal group.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Invariance
3.3.2.5
71
Haar measure
We return to the beginning of the subsection on Lie algebras, where we have introduced the C ∞ -functions α′′ (α, α′ ) = α′′ that govern the product of two group elements g(α′′ ) = g(α)g(α′ ).
(3.106)
We differentiate this latter equation in α′ , and afterwards set α′ equal to zero: g(α)Xa = Let us introduce the quantities
∂α′′b (α, α′ ) ∂ g(α′′ ) α′ =0 . ′a ′′b ∂α ∂α
X a b (α) = so that
∂α′′a (α, α′ ) α′ =0 ∂α′b
g(α)Xa = X b a (α)
(3.107)
∂ g(α). ∂αb
The X a b (α) form an m × m-matrix; since X a b (0) = δ a b , it is regular in a neighbourhood of the origin, and so we can introduce there the inverse θa b (α) with X a c (α)θc b (α) = δ a b
(3.108)
to obtain g −1 (α)
∂ g(α) = θb a (α)Xb . ∂αa
(3.109)
Consider then 2 2 tr g −1 (α)dg(α) = tr θb a (α)Xb dαa
where on the right we need the trace of two generators; for convenience, we now choose G = SU (n), for which the normalization can be chosen such that 1 tr(Xa Xb ) = − δab . 2
(3.110)
We then obtain 2 1 1 (3.111) tr g −1 (α)dg(α) = − δcd θc a (α)θd b (α)dαa dαb = − gab (α)dαa dαb 2 2 where the right-hand side is recognized, up to the prefactor, as the line element on the Lie group. From gab (α) = δcd θc a (α)θd b (α)
(3.112)
with gab (0) = δab , we also infer that the θa b may be interpreted as an n-bein. Hence, the natural volume element on a Lie group is the Haar measure dµ(g) = |θ(α)|dm α.
(3.113)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
72
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
Its importance relies on the fact that it is invariant under the action of the group. For the proof, take the product g(γ) = g(β)g(α) where γ = γ(β, α) is considered a function of α; we then have g −1 (γ)dg(γ) = g −1 (α)dg(α), and thus gcd (γ)dγ c dγ d = gab (α)dαa dαb = gcd (γ)
∂γ c ∂γ d a b dα dα ∂αa ∂αb
so that gcd (γ) which implies
∂γ c ∂γ d = gab (α) ∂αa ∂αb
∂γ |θ(α)| = |θ(γ)| . ∂α
Setting g(α) = g and g(β) = h, we thus find dµ(hg) = |θ(α)|dα, which gives dµ(hg) = dµ(g)
(3.114)
saying that the Haar measure is left-invariant. One can also consider the right action and introduce a right-invariant measure, which are related through dµR (g) = |Ad(g)|dµL (g)
(3.115)
dµL (g −1 ) = (−1)dimG |Ad(g)|dµL (g)
(3.116)
and one can also show
the rather straightforward proofs being left to the reader. For a semisimple group, the Haar measure can be given in explicit form on making use of the basic formula (3.75); we begin with the n-bein that, taking into account the identity ad(Xa ) = Ca , reads a θa b (α) = (e−α·C − 1)/(−α · C) b (3.117) The metric tensor then is
gab (α) = δcd ϕ(−α · C)c a ϕ(−α · C)d b and using (3.104), we thus have (α · C)a b = −(α · C)b a which implies ϕ(−α · C)a b = ϕ(+α · C)b a so that gab (α) = (ϕ(+α · C)ϕ(−α · C))ab . By means of the explicit form (3.74) of the function ϕ(z), it is seen that 2 z 2 sinh ϕ(z)ϕ(−z) = z 2 giving for the metric tensor gab (α) =
sinh 12 α · C 1 2 α·C
2 !
ab
(3.118)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Invariance
and so we obtain
sinh 1 α · C dα dµ(α) = 1 2 2 α·C
book
73
(3.119)
as the final result for the Haar measure (cf. also Choquet-Bruhat, DeWitt-Morette and Dillard-Bleick (1982)). To give an application, let us calculate the volume of the group SU (2) (see eq. (3.89)). For the determinant in (3.119) one finds sinh 12 α · C 2 α 2 = sin 1α·C α 2 2
where one needs that the determinant of an n × n-matrix of the form Aa b = δ a b + γea eb with e an n-dimensional unit vector is |A| = 1 + γ; this yields 2 α 2 3 sin d α (3.120) dµ(α) = α 2 where 0 ≤ α ≤ 2π, and thus Z dµ(α) = 16π 2 (3.121) SU(2)
as an elementary computation shows.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Chapter 4
SPECIAL RELATIVITY **
As we have experienced already (see sec. 1.3 and sec. 3.1), all the basic notions of special relativity follow rather naturally from the theory of relativistic free fields. Now we consider special relativity as a subject of classical physics; a priori, it is then of purely kinematic origin. Indeed, it will be shown below that special relativity can be viewed as the prime example of a theory for which all physical properties of the system are entirely determined by the symmetry group of the underlying space. 4.1
Inertial Frames and Causality
The space in question is Minkowski space M , and its symmetry group the Poincar´e group P , being composed of translations and Lorentz transformations. By means of an element (a, Λ) ∈ P0 , one can pass from 4-coordinates x with x0 = ct and x = (xi )i=1,2,3 to new coordinates x′ where x′ = (a, Λ)x = Λx + a.
(4.1)
The translations permit to choose a common origin of space and time for all admissible coordinate systems so that they may be compared at all; this is an essential point. Recall now that each element Λ ∈ L0 can be written as the product of a pure Lorentz transformation, which mixes time and space coordinates, and a rotation, which only affects the space coordinates. The latter form a subgroup of L0 and can be used to rotate the space coordinates of two admissible coordinate systems; hence, they may be oriented in the same way. What remains to provide is the physical meaning of pure Lorentz transformations. For this, we return to the observation made earlier that they may be parametrized in the form (3.47), which we now rewrite in terms of the 3-dimensional velocity to give γ −γ vck 1 (4.2) Λu = : γ=q 2 v i vk vi i 1 − vc2 +γ c δ k + (1 − γ) v2 i,k=1,2,3
where a detailed interpretation of the 3-vector v with v = |v| still remains to be given. 75
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
76
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
The form (4.2) of a pure Lorentz transformation will turn out to be the central input for a proper treatment of special relativity, which, to say it with the words of A. Wightman (1960), “un physicien doit connaˆıtre par cœur”. Nevertheless, it can only rarely be found in the literature; e.g., in the monumental book of Misner, Thorne and Wheeler (1973) it is hidden in an exercise (on p. 69) without any comment on its origin, and also nowhere used in the rest of the text. In order to interpret the above pure Lorentz transformation, we need the explicit version of the transformed Minkowski space vector x′ = Λu x, which is v · x t′ = γ t + 2 c (4.3) v · x ′ x = x + γt − (1 − γ) 2 v. v We view this transformation, which in such a general form seems to have first been given by Møller (1952), as the transition from a coordinate system (Koordinatensystem) K with coordinates x to a coordinate system K ′ with coordinates x′ ; its essential property is that space coordinates and the time coordinate get mixed. If in K the space point x moves at velocity −v, that is x(t) = −vt, then insertion into (4.3) yields t′ =
1 t γ
x′ = 0.
As is concerning the spatial part, this result can be interpreted as saying that the coordinate system K is at rest relative to K ′ , and so K ′ moves at velocity +v relative to the unprimed system. In particular, for v ≪ c we recover the Galilei transformation of nonrelativistic mechanics. To resume, by means of Poincar´e transformations we can achieve that any two permissible coordinate systems have the same origin, that their space axes are oriented in the same way, and that they are at rest. This then permits observers to compare their length and time standards. Accordingly, we define inertial systems as those coordinate systems, which can be transformed into each other by means of a Poincar´e transformation; we exclude discrete transformations from the discussion. The velocity v of an inertial system must be strictly less than the limiting velocity c, which is the velocity of light. We also take for granted that light rays propagate along straight lines, as it is guaranteed by geometric optics. These are the only physical assumptions that underlie the theory of special relativity. As a consequence, only those systems are related by a Lorentz transformation, which can communicate with each other by means of light signals; it is this property that R. Haag called Einstein causality. However, there is a subtle point concerning the choice of an ‘absolute’ inertial frame, from which all other ones are obtained on applying a Poincar´e transformation; this distinguished inertial system at rest or this privileged (divine) observer is required to exist a priori; it lies outside human capability to give a proof of its existence.
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Special Relativity
4.2
book
77
Lengths and Time Intervals
The physical properties of pure Lorentz transformations now follow from the definitions. For the present purposes, we need the inversion of the transformation (4.3), which is obtained from (4.3) by interchanging the primed and unprimed quantities, and replacing the velocity by its negative, so that v · x′ t = γ t′ − 2 c (4.4) v · x′ v. x = x′ − γt′ + (1 − γ) 2 v
We begin with time intervals, being measured by a clock, which is at rest in the primed system. Let a first event happen in K ′ at the time instant t′ in the space point x′ , and assume that a second event happens at the later time instant t′ + ∆t′ in the same space point x′ ; then we infer from (4.4) that the corresponding time, having elapsed in the system K, is given by ∆t = γ∆t′ ≥ ∆t′ .
(4.5)
Accordingly, time runs more slowly in a moving inertial frame; this effect is called time dilation. Let us turn to space intervals. So we consider a rod in the unprimed system, the endpoints of which are located at x1 and x2 , and we also assume that ∆x = x2 −x1 is directed along the relative velocity. What we want to determine is the relative position of the rod with coordinates x′1 and x′2 , which are measured at the same time instants t′1 = t′2 in the primed system. From (4.4), we infer v · ∆x′ v v2 showing that ∆x′ is again parallel to the relative velocity, and thus ∆x = ∆x′ − (1 − γ)
|∆x| = γ|∆x′ | ≥ |∆x′ |.
(4.6)
Hence, a length is diminished in a moving inertial frame; this effect is called Lorentz contraction. The general rule thus is that in a moving inertial frame the length and time standards are reduced; they take their maximal values in the unprimed inertial frame. 4.3
Addition Theorem for Velocities
Since pure Lorentz transformations do not form a subgroup of the Lorentz group, the product of two transformations Λu and Λu′ is not again a pure Lorentz transformation; instead, we have ◦
Λu Λu′ = Λu′′ Λ(u, u′ )
(4.7)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
78
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
◦
where Λ(u, u′ ) is a rotation. More generally, for Λ ∈ L0 , consider ◦
◦
Λ u = u′ = ΛΛu u = Λu′ u
◦
where u = c(δ
µ
0 )µ=0,1,2,3
(4.8)
is the velocity at rest; hence, we infer that ◦
Λu′ −1 ΛΛu = Λ(u, Λ)
(4.9)
is a rotation, called a Wigner rotation. This is an element of the stability subgroup ◦ of u, also called Wigner’s little group that, in the present case, just consists of space rotations. It is a purely technical problem now to determine the individual factors on the right hand side of eq. (4.7); the computation can be simplified considerably by means of more advanced techniques to be dealt with later. At any rate, the result is obtained to be cosh β ′′ = cosh β cosh β ′ + sinh β sinh β ′ f · f ′ (4.10) ′ ′′ ′′ ′ ′ ′ ′ sinh β f = sinh β f + sinh β cosh β f − sinh β (1 − cosh β)f · f f
for the boost, and
′
cos
′
cosh β2 cosh β2 + sinh β2 sinh β2 f · f ′ α′′ = ′′ 2 cosh β2 (4.11) ′
β β α′′ ′′ 1 sinh 2 sinh 2 sin e =− f × f′ ′′ 2 4 cosh β2
for the accompanying rotation. ◦
One could try to calculate Λu′′ and Λ(u, u′ ) from (4.7) by direct attack, but this would amount to a rather tedious computation since 4× 4-matrices get involved. The task is essentially simplified on considering instead of L0 the homomorphically related group SL(2, C) of complex 2×2-matrices of determinant one; these matters will be explained in the next chapter. Here we anticipate that by means of the polar decomposition (see eq. (5.42) below), the general element A(α) of SL(2, C) (see eq. (5.39) below) can be factorized as the product A(α) = A(β)A(α) where A(α) with A(α)+ = A(α)−1 is the analogue of a rotation, and A(β) with A(β)+ = A(β) is the analogue of a pure Lorentz transformation. In order to obtain the boost, one must choose in (5.41) below the parameters to be ui vi u0 =γ sinh β f i = =γ . (4.12) cosh β = c c c ′ ′′ ′′ ′′ ′′ For the computation of A(β)A(β ) = A(β )A(α ) = A(α ), one first determines A(β ) from A(α′′ )A(α′′ )+ = A(β′′ )2 = A(2β ′′ ), and afterwards A(α′′ ) from A(β ′′ )−1 A(β)A(β ′ ) = A(α′′ ); one then obtains the result as given in the main text.
The first set of the formulae (4.10), if rewritten in terms of the 3-velocities, then gives v · v′ ′′ ′ γ = γγ 1 + 2 c and the second: γ 1 1 ′ ′ ′′ v+v + v × (v × v ) . (4.13) v = ′ 1 + γ c2 1 + v·v c2
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Special Relativity
book
79
The last result (4.13) is called the addition theorem for relativistic velocities; in this compact form it was first given by Macfarlane (1962). For parallel velocities, it yields Einstein’s addition theorem as a special case. Hence, the derivation of the general addition theorem is a purely group theoretical problem. It would require a rather tedious calculation to derive it strictly within the domain of special relativity, i.e., directly from Lorentz transformations; in any case, it is advantageous to use its universal covering group. After all, one now has an explanation of the fact why the velocity space, which in nonrelativistic physics is a linear space, is no longer linear in the relativistic case. Consider the subset of 4-velocities uµ with uµ uµ = c2 and u0 > 0; they ◦ can be reached from the rest frame with uµ = cδ µ 0 by applying the pure Lorentz ◦ ◦ transformation Λu with Λu u = u. The stability subgroup of u is the 3-dimensional rotation group SO(3), and so the one-sheeted hyperboloid of vectors u with uµ uµ = c2 and u0 > 0 is diffeomorphic to the homogeneous space SO0 (1, 3)/SO(3); this is not a linear space, but the prototype of a hyperbolic or Lobachevski space, which inherits a non flat metric as a submanifold of Minkowski space. We close with the following remark; it is often taken as one of the axioms of special relativity that the velocity of light is the same in any inertial frame. Actually, this is a property that simply follows from the definitions, as we show now. One repeatedly finds in this and related contexts statements like the following. Working with the restriction to one space-dimension, the addition theorem takes the simple form v′′ =
v + v′ 1+
v v′ c2
≤ c.
(4.14)
If one now chooses v′ = c, then this yields v′′ = c, so that one might conclude that a velocity can never exceed c; however, what is wrong with this argument is the assumption v′ = c, since both v and v′ must be strictly less than the velocity of light. The reason is that in the addition theorem all velocities getting involved refer to massive particles; massless particles such as photons are excluded.
For the proof, consider inertial systems K ′ and K ′′ , where K ′ is mapped onto K by means of the boost Λu ; a photon in K ′ , which moves at the velocity of light, has the velocity 4-vector u′ = dx′µ /dτ , and this squares to zero ′ 2 dt v ′2 ′2 u = c 1− 2 =0 dτ c ′′
so that indeed v ′2 = c2 must hold. The 4-vector of the photon in the inertial frame K ′′ is given by u′′ = Λu u′ , and since Λu is a Lorentz transformation, we also have u′′2 = 0 so that again v ′′2 = c2 as claimed. 4.4
Rotating Frames
Up to now we have restricted the considerations to translations and Lorentz transformations, for which the parameters are constant. But one can also consider the
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
80
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
situation where the parameters depend on time; to be precise, we choose this to be a kind of proper time τ , but for the moment it has simply the meaning of an arbitrary parameter. Hence, we now have τ -dependent Lorentz transformations Λ(τ ) ◦ and translations a(τ ); by means of the former, we can then pass from the basis eµ of an inertial frame to the τ -dependent basis ◦
eµ (τ ) = Λν µ (τ ) eν
(4.15)
in a rotating frame, where in what follows ‘rotating’ is meant in the 4-dimensional sense. Its ‘time’ evolution is then governed by ◦ ˙ ν µ (τ )eν (τ ) e˙ µ (τ ) = Λ˙ ρ µ (τ ) eρ = Λ˙ ρ µ (τ )(Λ−1 )ν ρ (τ )eν (τ ) = (Λ−1 Λ)
where here and below the dot denotes differentiation with respect to τ ; we write this in the form e˙ µ (τ ) = ω ν µ (τ ) eν (τ )
(4.16)
˙ µν . ω µ ν = (Λ−1 Λ)
(4.17)
with
We claim that the quantities ωµν (τ ) = gµρ ω ρ ν (τ ) are antisymmetric. This property is a consequence of the fact that Λ(τ ) is a Lorentz transformation for all τ so that (eµ (τ )|eν (τ )) = gµν holds; differentiation in τ then yields the assertion since 0 = (e˙ µ (τ )|eν (τ )) + (eµ (τ )|e˙ ν (τ )) = ω ρ ν (τ )(eρ (τ )|eν (τ )) + (eµ (τ )|eρ (τ ))ω ρ ν (τ ) = ωµν (τ ) + ων µ (τ ). Thus, the generalization of the angular velocity ω i or ω ij = εij k ω k in three dimensions to the case of n dimensions is given by an antisymmetric two-tensor ω µν with n(n − 1)/2 independent components, as constructed above in four dimensions. Note that the τ -dependence of Λ(τ ) = exp α(τ ) is entirely determined by the parameters αµ ν (τ ); if they are assumed to be of the form α(τ ) = τ α, we have ω = α, i.e. the angular velocity is constant and can be identified with the parameters α of the Lorentz transformation. Consider then a vector v(τ ) in the rotating frame, viz. v(τ ) = v µ (τ )eµ (τ ).
(4.18)
Its τ -derivative receives now an additional contribution since also the basis is τ dependent; by means of (4.16), we find v(τ ˙ ) = v˙ µ (τ )eµ (τ ) + ω µ ν (τ )v ν (τ )eµ (τ ) = where the abbreviation D µ v = Dτ
d δµ ν + ω µ ν vν dτ
Dv µ (τ ) eµ (τ ) Dτ
(4.19)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Special Relativity
book
81
has been introduced. In particular we now choose v(τ ) = x(τ ˙ ), with x(τ ) denoting a particle trajectory which is parametrized by proper time. If we also admit a τ -dependent translation a(τ ), we then find the equations of motion D2 µ x = k µ − m¨ aµ Dτ 2 where k denotes a given external force; in explicit terms it reads: m
m¨ xµ = k µ − 2mω µ ν x˙ ν − mω µ ρ ω ρ ν xν − mω˙ µ ν xν − m¨ aµ .
(4.20)
In complete analogy to the nonrelativistic case, the second term on the right side is the Coriolis force, being proportional to the velocity, the third is the centrifugal force, being proportional to the angular velocity squared, and the last two constitute the d’Alembert force. In particular, the last one can be used to simulate Einstein’s elevator since it permits the local elimination of a gravitational field. 4.5
Accelerated Inertial Frames
As we want to show now, one can as well analyze accelerated observers without leaving the domain of validity of special relativity. Here we reach deep water since this is a rather controversial topic in the literature. Our approach relies on the fact ◦ that in the matrix Λu (see (3.47)), which transforms the velocity u at rest into the general velocity u, we can admit u to depend also on proper time. We shall see below that this generalization makes perfect sense. So let the future directed timelike trajectory x(τ ) of a particle be given, which is parametrized by the arc length. In a first step, we want to associate with it the world line of an observer so that τ is his proper time. For this purpose, what we would like to construct is a ‘rep`ere mobile’ or ‘comoving frame’ along this curve such that its normalized tangent vector u(τ )/c can be identified with the timelike basis vector e0 (τ ); if, in addition, we can also find basis vectors ei (τ ) with the property g(eµ (τ ), eν (τ )) = gµν , then a comoving frame is attached to the accelerated observer. For the construction, the crucial observation is that the matrix Λu(τ ) ◦ with Λu(τ ) u = u(τ ) or cΛu(τ ) µ 0 = uµ (τ ) is available where, as opposed to the case considered earlier, the 4-velocity u now depends on proper time. If the orthonormal ◦
◦
basis of the inertial frame K at rest is denoted by eµ , we define the basis in the comoving frame K(τ ) by ◦
eµ (τ ) = Λu(τ ) ν µ eν
(4.21)
1 µ ◦ u (τ )eµ . c
(4.22)
having the required property e0 (τ ) =
◦
The latter formula says that e0 , expressed in terms of the basis eµ , points in the direction of the velocity u; the new basis is also orthonormal since Λu is a Lorentz
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
82
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
transformation, hence, this transformation is permissible. We can also write (4.22) in the form ◦
◦
u µ eµ (τ ) = uµ (τ ) eµ
(4.23)
which seems to be counterintuitive but, nevertheless, is correct. Accordingly, in the ◦
◦
accelerated frame K the 4-velocity u is constant, whereas in the system K at rest the velocity u is non constant. We are not so much interested in the time evolution of the basis. What we want instead is to determine the evolution of a general vector wµ (τ ) being attached to ◦ the given trajectory, which is similarly defined in terms of a constant vector w µ in K by ◦
wµ (τ ) = Λu(τ ) µ ν w ν .
(4.24)
We then need the rate of change in proper time of this vector; we have w˙ µ = −ω µ ν wν
(4.25)
with the angular velocity being given by µ ω µ ν = (Λu Λ˙ −1 u ) ν
(4.26)
where an additional decoration of ω with u is suppressed. The proof that this is an antisymmetric quantity in its two indices proceeds as in the previous subsection (see (4.16)): ˙ −1 )µ ν + (ΛΛ˙ −1 )µ ν = Λ˙ µ ρ (Λ−1 )ρ ν + Λµ ρ (Λ˙ −1 )ρ ν 0 = (ΛΛ = Λνρ (Λ˙ −1 )ρµ + Λµ ρ (Λ˙ −1 )ρ ν = ων µ + ω µ ν . The difference here is that the parameters of the τ -dependent Lorentz transformation are now completely determined by the tangent vector of the particle trajectory. Initially, our strategy is similar to the conventional approach to a comoving frame, for which the point of departure is the construct (x(s), e1 (s), . . . , ed (s)) where x(s) denotes a curve in d euclidean dimensions being parametrized by the arc length s, and ei (s) a comoving basis that remains to be specified; the above quantity is an element of the affine space Rd(d+1) . The definition of the first basis vector through x(s) ˙ = v(s) = e1 (s) is the same, but the essential difference comes in on defining the remaining basis vectors. To give an example, for the Frenet formulae in d = 3 dimensions one defines v(s) ˙ = κ(s)e2 (s) where κ(s) is the curvature, and e3 (s) = e1 (s) × e2 (s). We here define, however, the basis for all i = 1, . . . , d through ◦
ei (s) = Rv(s) ei ◦
◦
where Rv(s) v = v(s) with v i = δ i 1 so that no s-derivative of v(s) gets involved.
The calculation of the components of the 4-dimensional angular velocity from eq. (3.47) is straightforward, if a bit tedious, and yields u0 u˙ k − u˙ 0 uk u˙ k + 0 0 c(u + c) u +c ui u˙ k − u˙ i uk . = c(u0 + c)
ω0k = ωi k
(4.27)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Special Relativity
book
83
The rotational part is the well known Thomas precession, having been obtained here with a clean strategy by purely group theoretical arguments; on passing to the angular velocity defined by ω i j = εi jk ω k , it reads 1 ωi = − εi jk ui u˙ k ω0 = 0 (4.28) c(u0 + c) or γ 1 dv ω=− v× . (4.29) 1 + γ c2 dt The version (4.27) can be used to cast the entire set of ωµν into a formal 4dimensional notation; it is obtained to be 1 1 (4.30) ω µ ν = 2 (uµ u˙ ν − u˙ µ uν ) + εµ νρσ ω ρ uσ c c and so we end up with 1 1 w˙ µ = − 2 (uµ u˙ ν − u˙ µ uν ) + εµ νρσ ω ρ uσ wν . (4.31) c c In particular, for w = u this formula reduces to an identity. The first term on the right side of (4.31) will be identified below as a one that determines what is called Fermi-Walker transport, and the second is the Thomas precession in 4-dimensional disguise. Hence we see that a constant vector in the system K of the accelerated ◦
observer, as seen in the frame K at rest, undergoes both Fermi-Walker transport and Thomas precession. The above eq. (4.31) is a linear system of ordinary differential equations of first order with nonconstant coefficients, which can be solved; the necessary techniques are explained in a subsequent appendix. The solution with the initial condition ◦ wµ (0) = w µ , which assures that for τ = 0 the bases of the accelerated observer and the observer at rest coincide, is given by µ Zτ 1 ◦ µ ρσ w (τ ) = T exp − ω (s)Mρσ ds ν w ν (4.32) 2 0
where the symbol T denotes time ordering. To summarize what we have shown, for an accelerated observer a comoving basis can be constructed. But the basis is ‘rotating’ since it is subject to the 4-dimensional Thomas precession. In principle, the comoving observer could detect this by a Fouceault like experiment. Hence, in its present form we do not accept the comoving frame as an inertial system. In order to overcome this defect, we want to get rid of the Thomas precession, i.e. the ‘rotational’ part. We do this on performing a further basis transformation such that only the Fermi-Walker part remains; this new system will provide the accelerated inertial frame we aim at. For the proof, let us split the total angular velocity tensor into two parts ω µ ν = ′µ ω ν + ω ′′µ ν , where 1 1 ω ′′µ ν = εµ νρσ ω ρ uσ . (4.33) ω ′µ ν = 2 (uµ u˙ ν − u˙ µ uν ) c c
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
84
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
The basis transformation looked for we write in the form e α = eµ α e µ
: α = 0, 1, 2, 3
(4.34)
µ
where the invertible matrix with entries e α is called a tetrad, and the index α a Lorentz index; the nomenclature is adopted from a more general context to be discussed later. Since the new basis is also assumed to be orthonormal, we must have gαβ = eµ α eν β gµν
(4.35)
where also (gαβ ) is a Minkowski metric; we use the notation eα µ = g αβ eν β gνµ
(4.36) α
for the inverse of the tetrad. The time evolution of a vector w = e Lorentzian basis is then determined by the equation
α
µw
µ
in the
w˙ α = e˙ α µ wµ +eα µ w˙ µ = (e˙ α µ −eα ν ω ν µ )wµ = (e˙ α µ −eα ν ω ′′ν µ −eα ν ω ′ν µ )wµ . (4.37) In order to eliminate the Thomas precession, we require e˙ α µ = eα ν ω ′′ν µ
(4.38)
and so we have reached our aim since w˙ α = −ω α β wβ
: ω α β = eα µ ω ′µ ν eν β
(4.39)
where the ω α β are again antisymmetric. Once more using the results of the ap◦ pendix, the solution of eq. (4.38) subject to the initial condition eα µ = δ α µ is obtained to be Z0 1 ∗ E(τ ) = T exp Mρσ ω ′′ρσ (s)ds : E = (eα µ )α,µ=0,1,2,3 (4.40) 2 τ
∗
where T denotes the anti-time ordering. On looking at the discretization of the product integral, it is easily seen that the matrix E is indeed a Lorentz transformation; hence, this defines a permissible transformation, and so the twofold transition ◦
◦
eµ 7→ eµ (τ ) 7→ eα (τ ) ◦
connects the rest system K with the basis eµ to the ‘non rotating’ Lorentz system L(τ ) with eα (τ ) as basis. To write down the final result, we need u˙ α = e˙ α µ u µ + eα µ u˙ µ = −eα ν ω ′′ν µ u µ + eα µ u˙ µ = eα µ u˙ µ
since ω ′′ν µ u µ = 0; we also have u˙ α = e µ α u˙ µ , the proof of which similar. Thus, the angular velocity tensor takes the form 1 ω α β = 2 (uα u˙ β − u˙ α uβ ) (4.41) c and therefore the proper time evolution in the new comoving frame is governed by the law 1 (4.42) w˙ α = − 2 (uα u˙ β − u˙ α uβ )w β . c
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Special Relativity
book
85
This is the final result, showing that a general vector undergoes pure Fermi-Walker transport in the comoving inertial (non rotating) frame of the accelerated observer. In order to give a further characterization of Fermi-Walker transport, let us rewrite the time evolution eq. (4.42) in terms of the operator D α d 1 w = δαβ + 2 (uα u˙ β − u˙ α uβ ) wβ . (4.43) Dτ dτ c Thus, the vector w obeys Fermi-Walker transport along the curve x(τ ) if D α w (x(τ )) = 0 (4.44) Dτ holds. In particular, setting wα (x(τ )) = x˙ α (τ ), it is easily seen that the tangent vector of the curve obeys Fermi-Walker transport; furthermore, it preserves inner products in the sense that d D D ′ (w · w ′ ) = w · w′ + w · w (4.45) dτ Dτ Dτ holds. This construction constitutes a generalization of parallel transport in flat space; we shall return to this theme in the context of general relativity. Having available an inertial frame for an accelerated observer, we can now give a consistent resolution of the twin paradox, about which there is so much vague thought in the literature. As argued by Einstein, the answer cannot be obtained within the domain of special relativity; however, according to what we have shown above, it can since the parameter of the worldline τ is the proper time of the accelerated observer in his inertial system L so that Zt′′ r Zτ ′′ v2 dτ = 1 − 2 dt < t′′ − t′ . c τ′
t′
Hence, the answer is to the affirmative since the time measured by an accelerated observer is strictly less than that measured by an observer at rest. Consequently, the resolution of the twin paradox does not lie outside the scope of special relativity; as we have seen, the actual proof only requires some more advanced techniques. What we have avoided with our approach is the crucial fault, repeated everywhere, that consists in dividing the path of the accelerated twin into two straight paths, along which the journey is assumed to happen at constant 3-velocities +v and −v; but in this way the sudden accelerations at the starting and return point, which cannot be realized physically, are simply brushed under the carpet. 4.6
Appendix: Product Integral
Consider the following linear system of ordinary first order equations with nonconstant coefficients (for rigorous accounts, see Araki (1973) and Arnold (2001)) x˙ a (t) = Aa b (t)xb (t)
: a, b = 1, . . . , m
(4.46)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
86
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
where t ∈ [t′ , t′′ ], and the initial conditions are xa (t′ ) = x′a ; we write this in vector space notation with x = (xa )a=1,...,m and A = (Aa b )a,b=1,...,m so that x(t) ˙ = A(t)x(t).
(4.47)
The vector space can be taken to be either real or complex. In order to solve the present system we discretize the problem, i.e., the finite interval [t′ , t′′ ] is partitioned into N +1 equidistant subintervals of length ∆t = (t′′ −t′ )/(N +1) with intermediate points tn = t′ +n∆t for n = 0, 1 . . . , N . We then have x(tn+1 ) = (1+A(tn )∆t)x(tn ), and iteration yields (4.48) x(t′′ ) = lim eA(tN )∆t · · · eA(t0 )∆t x(t′ ) ∆t→0
where the limit can be shown to exist if the entries of the matrix A(t) are finite. The latter result is commonly written in the form x(t′′ ) = K(t′′ , t′ )x(t′ )
(4.49)
with the kernel t′′
R A(tN )∆t A(t0 )∆t ′′ ′ t ···e = Te ′ K(t , t ) = lim e
A(t)dt
∆t→0
.
(4.50)
Here we have introduced a time-ordering symbol since the matrix-valued factors exp(A(tn )∆t) are ordered, with increasing time from right to left; the right-hand side of (4.50) is called a product integral. By construction, this kernel solves the differential equation d K(t, t′ ) = A(t)K(t, t′ ) (4.51) dt with K(t′ , t′ ) = 1 the initial condition; furthermore, it obeys the composition law K(t2 , t)K(t, t1 ) = K(t2 , t1 )
(4.52)
and is nonsingular since its determinant is |K(t′′ , t′ )| = e
tR′′
trA(t)dt
.
t′
(4.53)
The two latter properties are easily derived from equation (4.50) in the defining discrete version. Note also that if the matrix A(t) is skewsymmetric, we then have K(t′′ , t′ )+ = K(t′′ , t′ )−1
: A(t)+ = −A(t)
(4.54)
: x(t′ ) = x′
(4.55)
saying that in this case the kernel is unitary. Having available the solution of the homogeneous equation, the solution of the inhomogeneous equation x(t) ˙ = A(t)x(t) + b(t)
can be constructed rather easily. It is achieved on using the method of the variation of constants. Hence, we try the ansatz x(t) = K(t, t′ )c(t) where c(t) is arbitrary up to the requirement c(t′ ) = x(t′ ); insertion then yields c(t) ˙ = K(t, t′ )−1 b(t)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Special Relativity
book
87
so that ′
′
x(t) = K(t, t )x(t ) +
Zt
K(t, s)b(s)ds
(4.56)
t′
is the solution looked for. One can also obtain the solution of the differential equation (4.51) for the kernel, subject to the initial condition K(t′ , t′ ) = 1, by successive approximation; this will provide us with an alternative, useful representation of the kernel. For that purpose, we cast the differential equation (4.51) into the form of an integral equation Zt ′ K(t, t ) = 1 + dsA(s)K(s, t′ ). (4.57) t′
The approximated kernel is defined by Zt ′ Kn (t, t ) = 1 + dsA(s)Kn−1 (s, t′ )
: n = 1, 2 . . .
(4.58)
t′
with K0 (t′ , t′ ) = 1, which gives Zt2 Ztn Zt Zt ′ dt1 A(tn )A(tn−1 ) · · · A(t1 ) dtn−1 · · · Kn (t, t ) = 1 + dt1 A(t1 ) + · · · + dtn t′
t′
t′
t′
where the order of the operators is important; the limit limn→∞ Kn (t, t′ ) = K(t, t′ ) can be shown to exist in the finite dimensional situation. Furthermore, in order to extend the range of integration to the whole interval [t′ , t] we insert step functions θ(t), defined by θ(t) = 1 for t > 0 and θ(t) = 0 for t < 0, and so the kernel takes the form Zt ∞ Zt X ′ K(t, t ) = dtn · · · dt1 θ(tn − tn−1 ) · · · θ(t2 − t1 )A(tn ) · · · A(t1 ). (4.59) n=0 t′
t′
Now one uses the fact that the integrations commute; hence, the integrand can be symmetrized. To this end, we introduce a further time-ordering prescription X
π∈Sn
T {A(tn ) · · · A(t1 )} =
(4.60)
θ(tπ(n) − tπ(n−1) ) · · · θ(tπ(2) − tπ(1) )A(tπ(n) ) · · · A(tπ(1) )
and thus obtain Z Z ∞ Rt X 1 K(t, t ) = dtn · · · dt1 T {A(tn ) · · · A(t1 )} = T e t′ A(s)ds n! n=0 t
t
′
t′
(4.61)
t′
where now the right-hand side has a different meaning. This is the alternative version of the kernel in the form of an infinite sum; again, for a finite dimensional vector space as considered here, it can be shown to converge.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Chapter 5
RELATIVISTIC FREE FIELDS: FERMIONS
One of the most fundamental equations of theoretical physics was created in the year 1928 by Dirac; it is the subject of the present chapter. In retrospect, Dirac’s original motivation for rejecting the Klein-Gordon equation as a consistent quantum mechanical system does not stand critique. For this and other reasons it has become fashionable to avoid Dirac’s approach in obtaining his equation by more sophisticated group theoretical arguments. Here we leave aside the historical motivation and follow, with some omissions, the main line of Dirac’s reasoning. In this context one should also remember that Dirac’s equation had an important predecessor, namely, Pauli’s two-component equation for nonrelativistic electrons. 5.1
Dirac’s Equation
What we aim at is a relativistic analogue of Schr˝odinger’s equation which, as opposed to the Klein-Gordon equation, is of first order in the time derivative: ∂ ˆ ψ = Hψ. (5.1) ∂t In order to meet the request for relativistic invariance of the generalization sought for, the following two conditions are imposed: i
ˆ is a hermitian operator. (i) The Hamiltonian H (ii) A twofold application yields the Klein-Gordon operator. As to the second requirement, this says ∂2 ˆ 2 ψ = (−∇2 + m2 )ψ. ψ= H ∂t2 Accordingly, we guess that the Hamilton operator must be linear in the momenta, and so we try the ansatz −
ˆ = −iα · ∇ + mβ. H i
(5.2)
One cannot expect the quantities α and β to be scalars; the simplest generalization coming to mind is that they should be matrices. Hence the Hamiltonian will be a 89
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
90
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
matrix valued operator, and thus the wave function a complex column vector, called a spinor ; the meaning of this nomenclature will become clear in what follows. As usual, the momenta pk = −i∇k are assumed to be hermitian; but we must verify afterwards that this assumption is really justified. Consequently, according to the first requirement, the matrices αi and β must be hermitian (αk )+ = αk
β + = β.
(5.3)
In order to proceed, let us compute the square ˆ 2 = −αj αk ∇j ∇k − im(αj β + βαj )∇j + m2 β 2 H 1 = − (αj αk + αk αj )∇j ∇k − im(αj β + βαj )∇j + m2 β 2 . 2 Hence, we infer the following relations αj αk + αk αj = 2δ jk
αj β + βαj = 0
β2 = 1
(5.4)
i
which entail that also the α must square to the identity matrix. Dirac’s generalization of the Schr¨odinger equation can be rewritten in relativistic notation; for this purpose, we multiply eq. (5.1) from the left with β to obtain (iβ∂0 + iβαk ∂k − m)ψ = 0 so that it proves to be convenient to pass to the γ-matrices γ0 = β
γ i = βαi
(5.5)
which thus obey the anticommutation relations γ µ γ ν + γ ν γ µ = 2g µν .
(5.6)
Furthermore, the γ i are antihermitian and γ 0 is hermitian; these properties can be combined in closed form as (γ µ )+ = γ 0 γ µ γ 0 .
(5.7)
Finally, the relativistic Schr˝ odinger equation then takes the form (iγ µ ∂µ − m)ψ(x) = 0
(5.8)
which is called the Dirac equation. After the fact, it is easy to see that the square of the Dirac operator yields the Klein-Gordon operator; indeed, the property (5.6) of the γ-matrices, also called the Clifford relations, entail 0 = (−iγ µ ∂µ − m)(iγ ν ∂ν − m)ψ = (γ µ γ ν ∂µ ∂ν + m2 )ψ 1 µ ν ν µ 2 = (γ γ + γ γ )∂µ ∂ν + m ψ = (g µν ∂µ ∂ν + m2 )ψ 2
as claimed. In particular, we have the basic result (γ µ ∂µ )2 = ∂µ ∂ µ
(5.9)
which is the ultimate reason why the Dirac operator is of so fundamental importance, both in physics and in mathematics. It says that the operator γ µ ∂µ may be
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
91
looked at as a kind of square root of the Laplace operator, a construct that makes sense in arbitrary dimension and for arbitrary signature. What remains to be shown is that a realization of the Clifford relations does exist; indeed, one need not look far apart to obtain it. Let us begin with the 3-dimensional case; the well known Pauli matrices 01 0 −i +1 0 1 2 3 σ = σ = σ = (5.10) 10 +i 0 0 −1 obey the relations σ j σ k = δ jk + iεjkl σl .
(5.11)
σ j σ k + σ k σ j = 2δ jk
(5.12)
In particular, they entail that
holds, which is the analogue of (5.6) in three dimensions, and so the Clifford relations are really nothing strange. In four dimensions, we content ourselves with simply giving a realization by 4 × 4 matrices (Cartan and Sommerfeld) 0 −1 0 +σ i γ0 = γi = (5.13) −1 0 −σ i 0
where 1 denotes a 2 × 2 unit-matrix; we leave it as an exercise for the reader to check that it does the job it is supposed to do. The interested reader is referred to the final section 5.7 of the present chapter, where it is shown that this is the only representation in 4-dimensional space-time up to unitary equivalence. As should be noted, it is a purely accidental fact that the (complex) Dirac spinor ψ has four components, which is the same number as the dimension of Minkowski space; in higher dimensions this is no longer true.
As mentioned, also in mathematics the importance of the Dirac operator can not be overestimated. In this context the rational behind its construction is again the attempt to construct a ‘square root’ of the Laplacian, which in d euclidean dimensions is √
∆ = −δij ∂i ∂j .
Hence, one looks for an operator D = −1γ i ∂i with the property D 2 = ∆; as above, it will not suffice to choose the coefficients γ i to be scalar valued since D2 = −
1 i j (γ γ + γ j γ i )∂i ∂j . 2
Thus the γ i should be matrix valued quantities in GL(n, C) for some n ∈ i j
j i
γ γ + γ γ = 2δ
N, which must obey
ij
and so we are back at the situation considered in the main text. Under some mild restrictions, also a generalization of the Dirac operator over a d-dimensional Riemannian manifold can be constructed, and as such it receives widespread applications in differential geometry. Here we restrict ourselves to a rather simple demonstration of its relevance and consider the case of a 2-dimensional euclidean space; a realization of the γ-matrices is then given by the subset of Pauli matrices γ k = σ k with k = 1, 2. Let us investigate the solutions of the (massless) Dirac equation ∂ γ k k ψ(x) = 0. (5.14) ∂x
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
92
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
In component notation we have γ k ∂k =
0 ∂1 − i∂2 ∂1 + i∂2 0
ψ=
ψ1 ψ2
book
(5.15)
where the spinor components ψ1 (x1 , x2 ) and ψ2 (x1 , x2 ) are complex-valued differentiable functions. Hence, it suggests itself to pass to complex variables z = x + iy and z¯ = x − iy, with x1 = x and x2 = y; since ∂ 1 ∂ 1 = (∂x − i∂y ) = (∂x + i∂y ) ∂z 2 ∂ z¯ 2 the Dirac equation translates into ∂ f (¯ z , z) = 0 ∂ z¯
∂ g(¯ z , z) = 0 ∂z
(5.16)
where we have introduced ψ1 (x, y) = f (¯ z , z)
ψ2 (x, y) = g(¯ z , z).
Hence, the function f must be analytic, i.e. be independent of z¯; similarly, g must be anti analytic. The content of, e.g., the first of the differential equations (5.16) can alternatively be expressed by the statement that the real and the imaginary part of the function f (¯ z , z) = u(x, y) + iv(x, y) must obey the Cauchy-Riemann equations ∂u ∂v =+ ∂x ∂y
∂u ∂v =− . ∂y ∂x
Furthermore, the fact that the square of the Dirac operator reduces to the Laplacian finds its analogue in the well known implication of the Cauchy-Riemann equations that the functions u and v are necessarily harmonic. In the 2-dimensional case, one can also choose a real representation of the γ-matrices; one possibility is γ 1 = σ1 and γ 2 = σ3 . Then also the spinor may be chosen to be real; this is called a Majorana representation. We shall later have to say more about such Majorana spinors. Now setting ψ1 = u and ψ2 = v, one again arrives at the Cauchy-Riemann equations. To resume, the Dirac operator in 2-dimensional euclidean space is deeply related to complex analysis; in higher (even) dimensions it may in fact be viewed as a natural generalization of the Cauchy-Riemann operator.
There is another representation of the γ-matrices, which will be needed later when we discuss the solutions of the Dirac equation; it is equivalent to that of Cartan and obtained by means of the unitary matrix 1 1 +1 B=√ (5.17) 2 −1 1 where B −1 γ 0 B =
+1 0 0 −1
B −1 γ i B = γ i =
0 +σ i −σ i 0
(5.18)
so that only γ 0 is altered, being diagonal now; this is called the Pauli or Dirac representation. In the present context, we stick to the Cartan representation for reasons to become clear soon. One often needs the matrix, which is the product of the four γs; the commonly used form is γ 5 = iγ 0 γ 1 γ 2 γ 3
(5.19)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
93
where the prefactor is chosen such that γ 5 is hermitian and obeys (γ 5 )2 = 1; it easy to prove that it anticommutes with the Dirac matrices, viz. γ 5 γ µ + γ µ γ 5 = 0. Its explicit form is 5 γC
+1 0 = 0 −1
γP5
=
(5.20)
0 −1 −1 0
(5.21)
where the subscript C stands for the Cartan, and P for the Pauli representation. Let us draw one first conclusion from the Dirac equation. Consider the adjoint of the final form (5.8); it reads −i∂µ ψ + (γ µ )+ − mψ + = 0 which, on using (5.7), can be written as −i∂µ ψ + γ 0 γ µ γ 0 − mψ + = 0. If we multiply this from the right by γ 0 we are instructed to introduce the Dirac adjoint ψ¯ = ψ + γ 0
(5.22)
the usefulness of which will be seen later; for a 4 × 4-matrix M , we accordingly ¯ = γ 0 M + γ 0 so that eq. (5.7) reads as γ¯ µ = γ µ now. For the Dirac adjoint define M of the wave function we thus obtain the equation ¯ µ − mψ¯ = 0. −i∂µ ψγ
(5.23)
Then it is easy to demonstrate that the 4-current ¯ µψ j µ = ψγ
(5.24)
is conserved in the sense that ∂µ j µ = 0 holds. This conclusion is reached on multiplying the Dirac equation from the left by ψ¯ and the adjoint Dirac equation from the right by ψ, and subtracting these two. Hence, since j 0 = ψ + ψ is positive definite, one should have a probabilistic interpretation for the Dirac theory, as one has this for the Schr˝ odinger theory. Though such arguments are compelling, they are nevertheless false; we shall see the reason why in the next but one section. 5.2
Relativistic Invariance of Dirac’s Equation
What we have not touched upon by now is the question in which sense the Dirac equation is relativistically invariant. In order to appreciate the relevance of this question, let us take a look back at the 4-potential of Maxwell’s theory. For this we have learned that the passive transformation under Lorentz transformations (see (3.54)) not only affects the argument, but also the 4-potential itself, which is multiplied by a Lorentz transformation as well. Something similar we expect for
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
94
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
the Dirac wave function, since this is also a multi-component quantity. Hence, we try the ansatz ψ ′ (x′ ) = S ψ(x)
: x′ = Λx + a
(5.25)
where the 4 × 4 matrix S, which we assume to be invertible, should be related to the Lorentz transformation in some way. The form of S is narrowed down by the request that the Dirac equation be invariant under such transformations; so we consider the Dirac equation in the primed system: (iγ µ ∂µ′ − m)ψ ′ (x′ ) = (iγ µ Λµ ν ∂ν − m)Sψ(x) = S(iS −1 γ µ SΛµ ν ∂ν − m)ψ(x). The latter equation is equal to zero if we require the matrix S to obey S −1 γ µ S = Λµ ν γ ν
(5.26)
because in this case the right hand side reduces to the Dirac equation, multiplied from the left by S; hence, then the Dirac equation in the primed system is valid if and only if it holds in the unprimed system. The formula (5.26) is of basic importance and we shall later have occasion to discuss its significance. It remains to solve the condition (5.26) for the γ-matrices. This is achieved on using an expansion about the identity element, which for the Lorentz transformation we know (see (3.23)) to have the form 1 ρτ α (Mρτ )µ ν + · · · (5.27) 2 being the parameters. In a similar vein, for
Λµ ν = g µ ν + αµ ν + · · · = g µ ν + with the antisymmetric quantities αµν S we try an expansion of the form
1 µν α σµν + · · · (5.28) 2 are to be determined. Insertion into (5.26) yields that
S(α) = 1 + where the 4 × 4-matrices σµν they must obey
[σµν , γτ ] = −gµτ γν + gντ γµ
(5.29)
which can be solved in terms of the γ-matrices: 1 1 [γµ , γν ] = (γµ γν − gµν ). 4 2 For the proof, one needs the general formulae σµν =
[AB, C] = A{B, C} − {A, C}B
[A, BC] = {A, B}C − B{A, C}
[AB, CD] = A{B, C}D − {A, C}BD + CA{B, D} − C{A, D}B
(5.30)
(5.31) (5.32)
being formally valid for arbitrary operators. The matrices σµν are antisymmetric in the indices µ and ν, and obey the commutation relations [σµν , σρτ ] = −gµρ σντ − gντ σµρ + gµτ σνρ + gνρ σµτ
(5.33)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
95
which, and this is the remarkable fact, are identical with the commutation relations (3.28) of the Lorentz group. What this coincidence tells us is the following. Let us use the exponential map for the generators σµν in order to construct group elements 1 µν S(α) = e 2 α σµν
(5.34)
which locally generate a group that remains to be identified. In the vicinity of the unit element this new group is locally isomorphic to the proper orthochronous Lorentz group; but it will differ from the latter in the large. What we face now is the task to compute (5.34) in explicit form. This is facilitated by the observation that the generators (5.30) are block-diagonal in the Cartan representation of the γs, viz. i σ3 1 +σ3 σ12 = σ30 = − σ3 −σ3 2 2 and similarly for the other generators. Hence, the group element obtained by exponentiation will be block-diagonal as well A(α) S(α) = A′ (α) so that the task is reduced to the computation of i k 1 k A(α) = e− 2 β σk e 2 α σk = A(β)A(α)
(5.35)
and A′ , where we have introduced the same factorization of a group element as for the Lorentz group. In order to proceed we need two basic formulae, that hold for a matrix of the form A = exp(X), where X is a given square matrix, otherwise being arbitrary; these are A+ = exp(X + )
|A| = exp(TrX)
(5.36)
a proof of which can be found in the last section of the foregoing chapter. We are then able to investigate the behaviour of the individual factors in (5.35) under adjunction A(α)+ = A(α)−1
A(β)+ = A(β)
saying that A(α) is unitary and A(β) hermitian. Accordingly, we find for A′ that A′ (α) = A(−β)A(α) = (A(β)+ )−1 (A(α)+ )−1 = (A(α)+ )−1 and so the matrix S is S(α) =
A(α)
A+ (α)−1
(5.37)
where the determinant of A is unity: |A(α)| = 1.
(5.38)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
96
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
As a last remark, since A(β) is related to A(α) through the identity A(β) = A(α) α=iβ
book
(5.39)
it suffices to calculate the 2 × 2-matrix A(α), which is unitary with determinant one. This is a straightforward task being left to the reader, and the result is α α A(α) = cos 1 + i sin ek σk (5.40) 2 2 where we have adopted the notation introduced for the Lorentz group. According to (5.39), we then find A(β) = cosh
β β 1 − sinh f k σk 2 2
(5.41)
so that we are done. After all, the group with elements A as having been constructed above is now seen to be SL(2, C), which denotes the group of complex 2 × 2-matrices of unit determinant; this is inferred from the factorization (see (5.35)) A(α) = A(β)A(α)
(5.42)
since it is the polar decomposition into a hermitian and a unitary matrix. The unitary matrices A(α) make up what is known as the group of unitary complex 2 × 2-matrices with unit determinant, denoted by SU (2); we obviously have that SU (2) < SL(2, C).
(5.43)
In retrospect, we see that the natural section of the projection SL(2, C) → SL(2, C)/SU (2) is indeed provided by the factorization (5.42), the polar decomposition. One could as well choose the parametrization i A = exp (αk + iβk )σ k (5.44) 2 which exhibits that the group SL(2, C) may also be viewed as the complexification of the group SU (2). We know now that the matrix S is a direct sum of SL(2, C) matrices, and so the basic formula (5.26) yields a homomorphism from SL(2, C) onto the Lorentz group L0 . It is made explicit on introducing the 4 × 4-matrix X = xµ γµ
(5.45)
the transformation law of which follows from (5.26) to be SXS −1 = X ′
: x′ = Λx.
(5.46)
One can also rewrite this in terms of 2 × 2-matrices since S is block-diagonal. For that purpose, we define ! ∼µ 1 1 σ ∼ ∽ µ σ= σ= γ = − ∽µ (5.47) −σ k k=1,2,3 +σ k k=1,2,3 σ
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
so that X=−
∼ ∽
x
x
!
∼
∼
: x = xµ σ µ
book
97
∽
∽
x = xµ σ µ .
(5.48)
∼
Note that, e.g., the σ µ do not obey the Clifford relations. We then obtain (van der Waerden 1929) ∼′
∼
x = AxA+
(5.49)
which is the form usually being a priori given in the literature. However, the homomorphism SL(2, C) → L 0 is not an isomorphism since the elements ±1 are both mapped into the unit element in L 0 . In technical terms, the simply connected group SL(2, C) is a twofold covering of the proper orthochronous Lorentz group; the latter is not simply connected because the subgroup of 3-dimensional rotations is not. For later reference, let us also give the spin transformation in the Pauli representation 1 A + (A+ )−1 A − (A+ )−1 D(A) = B −1 S(A)B = (5.50) 2 A − (A+ )−1 A + (A+ )−1 which is no longer in block-diagonal form; but for the SU (2) subgroup it still is. To summarize what we have learned, the Dirac equation enforces the transition from the Lorentz group L0 to the group SL(2, C), and it is the latter that determines the transformation law of the Dirac field, which we write in the form T (a, A)ψ(x) = S(A)ψ(Λ−1 x − a)
(5.51)
where S(A) is given in (5.37), and A in (5.34) together with (5.40) and (5.41). This entails, as we shall show later, that the spin of the particles described by the Dirac equation is one-half; this value is accessible only since the 3-dimensional rotation group, which only admits integer spin values, is replaced by the group SU (2) of unitary complex 2 × 2-matrices of determinant one. 5.3
Variational Principle for the Dirac Equation
We are going to design an action for the Dirac field; for this, we first make a digression and put further the analogy with nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. Let us begin by noting that the Schr˝odinger wave function ψ(x, t) can also be viewed as a nonrelativistic field with the inner product Z (ψ|ψ ′ ) = d 3xψ ∗ (x, t)ψ ′ (x, t) (5.52) V
where ψ and ψ ′ are solutions of the Schr˝odinger equation i~
∂ ˆ ψ(x, t) − Hψ(x, t) = 0. ∂t
(5.53)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
98
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
book
The Hamilton operator is selfadjoint with respect to (5.52) if the wave functions obeys ψ(x, t) = 0 for x ∈ ∂V ; as a consequence, the right-hand side of (5.52) is independent of t since ψ and ψ ′ satisfy (5.53). The Schr˝odinger equation can be obtained from a variational principle by multiplying (5.53) with δψ ∗ from the left and integrating over x and t, and similarly for the adjoint equation; adding these two, we obtain Z t2 Z ˆ + (−i~ψ˙ ∗ − (Hψ) ˆ ∗ )δψ 0= dt d3 x δψ ∗ (i~ψ˙ − Hψ) =
Z
t1 t2
t1
dt
Z
V
V
∂ ˙ − (δψ ∗ Hψ ˆ + ψ ∗ Hδψ) ˆ d3 x −i~ (ψ ∗ δψ) + i~(δψ ∗ ψ˙ + ψ ∗ δ ψ) . ∂t
The boundary term vanishes if δψ(x, t1 ) = δψ(x, t2 ) = 0; furthermore, we have omitted surface terms, being legitimate since together with ψ also the variations δψ must vanish on the boundary ∂V of the 3-dimensional volume. Then the action is Z Z ∗ ˆ S[ψ , ψ] = dt d3 x(i~ψ ∗ ψ˙ − ψ ∗ Hψ) (5.54) and so it should make sense to consider Z ˆ H= d3 xψ ∗ Hψ
(5.55)
as the Hamiltonian for the Schr˝odinger theory, if viewed as a nonrelativistic field theory. We shall later come back to the interpretation of this result. We imitate the above approach for Dirac’s theory, where the Hamiltonian (5.2) is selfadjoint with respect to the scalar product Z (ψ|ψ ′ ) = d 3 xψ(x)+ ψ ′ (x) (5.56) V
if ψ(x, t) = 0 for x ∈ ∂V ; again, the right side is time independent for solutions of Dirac’s equation. As opposed to the Schr¨odinger case, however, the Hamilton ˆ is not positive definite - a fact, which will be analyzed further below. operator H Note also that the scalar product is invariant against rotations only since the Hamiltonian formalism is not relativistically invariant. Nevertheless, proceeding for the variational principle similarly as in the nonrelativistic case, one finds Z t2 Z ∂ ˆ 0= dt d 3 x −i (ψ + δψ) + i∇k (ψ + αk δψ) + δ(iψ + ψ˙ − ψ + Hψ) ∂t t1 V
and we require δψ(x, t1 ) = δψ(x, t2 ) = 0, where δψ(x, t) vanishes for x ∈ ∂V 3 by assumption; thus, the action for the Dirac field is Z Z ˆ S= dt d 3 x (iψ + ψ˙ − ψ + Hψ). (5.57) This can also be written in manifestly invariant form as Z ¯ µ ∂µ − m)ψ S= d 4 x ψ(iγ
(5.58)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
and, beyond this, we may also view H=
Z
ˆ d 3 x ψ + Hψ
book
99
(5.59)
as the Hamiltonian for the Dirac theory; we shall further comment on this construct when discussing quantization. Finally, the Dirac field can be coupled to the electromagnetic field on using the minimal substitution ie ∂µ → Dµ = ∂µ + Aµ (5.60) ~c so that the total action is Z 1 1 4 µ µν ¯ S= d x cψ(i~γ Dµ − mc)ψ − Fµν F . (5.61) c 4 On varying the gauge field, this yields Maxwell’s equations, where the current is ¯ µ ψ of the Dirac field. identified as the microscopic current j µ = −eψγ 5.4
On the Origin of Gauge Invariance
We are now ready to gain some deeper understanding of gauge invariance. Recall that the field strength tensor is invariant against the substitution Aµ (x) → Aµ′ (x) = Aµ (x) + ∂µ α(x)
(5.62)
where α is an arbitrary real function over Minkowski space; this, we reiterate, is a purely ‘experimental’ fact, being void of any explanation on its origin. Under a gauge transformation, the generalized derivatives Dµ transform as ie ′ ie Aµ = Dµ + ∂µ α. (5.63) ~c ~c They act on the Dirac wave function; if we now transform also ψ according to Dµ
7→
ψ(x)
Dµ′ = ∂µ +
7→
e
ψ ′ (x) = e−i ~c α(x) ψ(x)
(5.64)
then the additional term in the generalized derivatives gets cancelled: ie
Dµ′ ψ ′ = e− ~c α Dµ ψ = (Dµ ψ) ′ .
(5.65)
Hence, the derivative Dµ ψ of ψ is not invariant, but equivariant in the sense that it transforms in a definite manner under the local U (1)-transformation (5.64); these transformations are called local since the rigid, i.e. constant, phase of the U (1)ie element exp ~c α is replaced by an x-dependent phase. But what we have also managed now is that the action (5.61) is strictly invariant against gauge transformations, and this is the virtue of this new interpretation. As we shall discuss later, a transformation that leaves the action invariant leads to a conserved quantity; anticipating the result, it is the law of charge conservation which is explained by gauge invariance.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
100
5.5
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Nonrelativistic Limit
We have seen that the nonrelativistic limit of the Klein-Gordon equation yields the Schr˝ odinger equation; as it is shown now, the nonrelativistic limit of the Dirac equation (Dirac 1928) in an external electromagnetic field reproduces its precursor, the Pauli equation (Pauli 1927), which describes the coupling of the electron spin to the magnetic field. The point of departure is again the Dirac equation, being coupled to the electromagnetic field through the minimal substitution: e (i~γ µ Dµ − mc)ψ = 0 : Dµ = ∂µ + i Aµ . (5.66) ~c We write this in nonrelativistic notation i~ψ˙ = U ψ − cαk πk ψ + mc2 βψ
(5.67)
with U = eA0 and πk =
e ~ ∇k + Ak . i c
Furthermore, the Pauli representation (5.18) is used, for which 1 σk k β= α = . −1 σk
(5.68)
(5.69)
Now we split off the rest energy E0 = mc2 , being the dominant term in the nonrelativistic limit; accordingly, write the Dirac wave function in the form − ~i E0 t ψ ψ≡e (5.70) χ where on the right side ψ and χ now denote 2-component spinors. Insertion then yields ψ σ·πχ ψ˙ 2 ψ 2 +ψ mc + i~ =U −c + mc χ −χ χ σ·πψ χ˙ and we first look at the lower components, for which we read off i~χ˙ = U χ − cσ · πψ − 2mc2 χ. In the limit c → ∞, the dominant contributions come from the two last terms on the right side so that we can express the lower components in terms of the upper components as 1 σ · πψ. 2mc It is for this reason that the upper ones are also called the large and the lower ones the small components. A word of caution is appropriate here since the generalized momenta πk also contain a factor 1/c through the vector potential; but this factor χ=−
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
101
is a matter of convention, e.g., in electrostatic units it would be absent. Now we can insert χ in the equation for the upper components i~ψ˙ = U ψ − cσ · πχ and obtain 1 i~ψ˙ = U ψ + (σ · π)2 ψ. 2m The last term on the right-hand side can be simplified by means of
(5.71)
(σ · π)2 = σ j σ k πj πk = (δ jk + iεjkl σl )πj πk where the second terms gives e ~ e ~ ∇j + Aj ∇k + Ak εjkl πj πk = εjkl i c i c e e2 e = εjkl −~2 ∇j ∇k − i~ ∇j Ak − i~ (Ak ∇j + Aj ∇k ) + 2 Aj Ak c c c e l lkj e = −i~ε ∇j Ak = −i~ B c c and so the final result turns out to be e~ 1 i~ψ˙ = U ψ + π · πψ + B · σψ. (5.72) 2m 2mc which is the famous Pauli equation. Here, the first two terms on the right hand side are conventional and yield the standard coupling to the electromagnetic field; only the last term is new and describes the coupling of the spin to the magnetic field. In order to understand its rˆ ole, we drop the electric potential and consider the case when the magnetic field is constant, viz. Ai = We then have π2 =
1 εijk B j xk 2
~ ∇ i
2
−i
: ∇i Ai = 0.
(5.73)
e~ e~ e2 ∇ · A − 2i A · ∇ + 2 A2 c c c
where the second term on the right-hand vanishes, and the last one can be neglected if we confine ourselves to a weak magnetic field; furthermore, since 1 ~ ˆ) A · ∇ = B · (ˆ x×p i 2 we finally obtain i~ψ˙ =
1 e ˆ + 2S) ˆ ψ pˆ · pˆ + B · (L 2m 2mc
(5.74)
where we have introduced the angular momentum and the spin operator ˆ =x ˆ ×p ˆ L
ˆ = ~ σ. ˆ S 2
(5.75)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
102
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
The conventional definition of the magnetic moments of the electron, being associated with the orbital angular momentum L and the spin S, is e e Morb = L Mspin = g S (5.76) 2mc 2mc where the constant g = 2s + 1, with s = 1/2 in the present case, is called the Land´e factor. Hence, the nonrelativistic limit of the Dirac equation in a constant magnetic field tells us that g = 2 is the correct value. However, it is modified by a quantum field theoretic correction that was first calculated 1948 by J. Schwinger; we shall redo his calculation in a later chapter. At this point the opportunity is offered to introduce what is known as an N -extended supersymmetric system. For this purpose, let us set U = 0 in eq. (5.71); from the derivation given above, leading to the Pauli equation (5.72), we immediately infer that on introducing the operator Q= √
1 4m
(p +
e A) · σ c
(5.77)
the Pauli Hamiltonian may be written as H = 2 Q2 , or, in terms of an anticommutator: H = {Q, Q}.
(5.78)
This is a special case of a situation in which a Hamilton operator H acting on a Hilbert space H is given, which is built from N selfadjoint operators Qi (i = 1, . . . , N ) on H such that {Qi , Qj } = δij H
(5.79)
holds. This is called an N -extended supersymmetric system with supersymmetric charges Qi and supersymmetric Hamiltonian H (Nicolai (1976), Witten (1981)); hence, the Pauli equation is an example of a supersymmetric quantum mechanical system with N = 1. The nomenclature for the operators Qi partly derives from the immediate consequence that they commute with the supersymmetric Hamiltonian: [Qi , H] = 0
for all i = 1, . . . , N.
(5.80)
Accordingly, if for the case at hand the electromagnetic field is time-independent, then the supercharges are symmetries of the system. Such supersymmetric systems are further characterized by the property that the energy eigenvalues are positive, as follows from the definitions. We shall later have occasion to return to these matters; then the term supersymmetric will also find its explanation.
5.6
‘Classical’ Interpretation of Fermions
Recall from our treatment of the Klein-Gordon field that the device of discretizing the field theoretic problem can serve as a means to interpret and study it as a system of classical mechanics with a finite number of degrees of freedom. As such, it is then amenable to canonical methods of quantization. We have also seen that the formal continuum limit poses no difficulties for a bosonic system, both in the unquantized and the quantized version. Hence it is tempting to pursue the same kind of approach for fermions; we shall see, however, that in this case serious difficulties are encountered, the origin of which may ultimately traced back to the fact that the Dirac equation is of first order in both time and space derivatives.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
5.6.1
book
103
Fermions on a lattice
Let us work in a finite volume of our three-dimensional space, which we approximate by a cubic lattice. Accordingly, we set x = an where a is the lattice constant and the nj are integers, the range of which have to be specified. In the Hamiltonian of the Dirac field Z ~ j α ∂j + mcβ ψ(x) (5.81) H =c d3 x ψ(x)+ i V
one then must make a choice for the approximation of the partial derivatives, and we take the symmetric difference 1 ∂j ψ(x) ≡ ∇j ψ(x) = (ψ(x + aˆ ) − ψ(x − aˆ )) (5.82) 2a where ˆ is the unit vector along the j-axis; note that this a better approximation than the standard choice, since the right hand side is correct up to and including terms of order a1 , and not to the order a0 only. Setting ~ = 1 and c = 1, the Hamiltonian on the lattice then reads X H = a3 ψ(x)+ −iαj ∇j + mβ ψ(x). (5.83) x
As one should recognize at this point, it is only due to the symmetric derivative that the discretized H is hermitian. In order to make (5.83) a well defined expression, we must impose boundary conditions. If X = aN denotes the linear extent of the lattice with N an even integer, we adopt the customary choice, i.e. periodic boundary conditions with ψ(x + X ˆ) = ψ(x)
(5.84)
where the integers nj are restricted to the range − N2 ≤ nj ≤ + N2 − 1. Now we can use Fourier decomposition on the lattice 1 X ikx ψ(x) = e ψ(k) (5.85) V k
where the dual variables take values N N 2π lj : − ≤ lj ≤ + − 1. (5.86) kj = X 2 2 This choice guarantees the boundary conditions to be respected; furthermore, the Fourier transform X ψ(k) = a3 e−ikx ψ(x) (5.87) x
has the periodicity property
2π ψ k± ˆ = ψ(k). a
For the Hamiltonian a straightforward computation then gives 1 X H= ψ(k)+ Ω(k)ψ(k) V k
(5.88)
(5.89)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
104
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
with Ω(k) = mβ +
X
αj
j
1 sin(kj a). a
(5.90)
The eigenvalues of the hermitian matrix Ω(k) are easily determined since it squares to a multiple of the unit matrix, i.e. Ω2 (k) = ω 2 (k) 1 with 2 X1 2 2 ω (k) = m + sin(kj a) . (5.91) a j
Had we chosen another lattice derivative, the dispersion relation would have come out to be a more complicated expression. The quantities pj (k) = sin(kj a)/a can be interpreted as the momenta on the lattice; in the continuum limit a → 0 they take the simple form pj = kj , and so we regain from the dispersion law the standard relativistic relation between energy and momentum. We now want to determine the eigenvectors of Ω(k); they are denoted by ψ (±) and obey Ωψ (±) = ±ωψ (±) , with ω the positive square root of (5.91). Let us emphasize, it is not the Dirac equation that is solved here; as will be seen later, however, the eigenvectors given below can indeed be used to construct its solutions. It will prove to be advantageous to perform the calculation in the Pauli representation of the γs; furthermore, we require ψ¯(±) (k)ψ (±) (k) = ±1 (5.92) as normalization condition for these eigenvectors. The result turns out to be 1 0 r r 0 1 m + ω(k) 1 ψ (+) (k, − 1 )= m + ω(k) − ψ (+) (k, + ) = 3 p (k) p (k) 2 2m 2 2m m+ω(k) m+ω(k) + 3 −p (k) m+ω(k)
p (k) m+ω(k)
ψ
(−)
1 (k, + ) = 2
r
−p3 (k) m+ω(k)
−p+ (k) m + ω(k) m+ω(k) 2m 1 0
ψ
(−)
1 (k, − )= 2
r
−p− (k) m+ω(k)
p3 (k) m + ω(k) m+ω(k) 2m 0 1
where p± = p1 ± ip2 ; the somewhat special notation will be commented upon later. We shall also need below that these eigenvectors have the normalization properties ω(k) δs3 ,s′3 ψ (+) (k, s3 )+ ψ (−) (k, s′3 ) = 0 (5.93) ψ (±) (k, s3 )+ ψ (±) (k, s′3 ) = m with s3 = ± 21 ; furthermore, it is a matter of straightforward computation to verify the completeness relation ω(k) X ψ (+) (k, s3 ) ⊗ ψ (+) (k, s3 )+ + ψ (−) (k, s3 ) ⊗ ψ (−) (k, s3 )+ = 1 (5.94) m s 3
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
105
where 1 denotes the 4 × 4 unit matrix. The general spinor in k-space can then be written in the form r m X (+) ψ (k, s3 )a(+) (k, s3 ) + ψ (−) (k, s3 )a(−) (k, s3 )∗ (5.95) ψ(k) = ω(k) s 3
in which a(+) and a(−)∗ denote arbitrary expansion coefficients. The prefactor is chosen such that insertion into the Hamiltonian finally yields the result H= π
(5.96)
2π
+a− X X 1 X X ω(k) a(+) (k, s3 )∗ a(+) (k, s3 ) − a(−) (k, s3 )a(−) (k, s3 )∗ . V j π s kj =− a
3
Here we have been careful in maintaining the order of factors; the reasons will be explained below. What this result says is that the classical Hamiltonian is indefinite, an unavoidable outcome. Hence, there is no really classical interpretation of fermions, a result being in marked contrast to the Klein-Gordon field, the classical analogue of which, as we have seen, is a collection of harmonic oscillators. This indefiniteness has its origin in the existence of eigenvectors with ‘negative energy’, i.e., those which enter the Hamiltonian with a minus sign. We could simply discard these, as it is done in the one-particle theory of the Dirac equation. Then the reduced Hamiltonian could also be interpreted as a collection of conventional (bosonic) harmonic oscillators. One can escape the above conclusion by taking a further, though rather radical step: If in the Hamiltonian (5.96) the Fourier coefficients are required to be anticommuting instead of conventional commuting quantities, then the second term changes its sign and the result is formally positive definite. Hence, if we are willing to give up conventional ideas and invent the strange concept of anticommuting variables, then all inconsistencies are expected to disappear. We shall have to return to these matters. 5.6.2
Canonical quantization of fermions *
In order to substantiate the above rather bizarre idea, some remarks about quantization will be helpful at this point. Again, even though the present part is devoted to classical field theory, we interrupt here the main line of development and insert an optional section on canonical quantization of the Dirac field. As shown, a complete treatment of the Dirac field must take at face the existence of negative energy eigenvectors, which prevent the Hamiltonian from being positive. Traditionally, this intriguing fact is circumvented by quantizing the system. Then the expansion coefficients become operators, and the asterisk is accordingly understood to denote the adjoint. For the Hamilton operator, the property of not being
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
106
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
positive definite is avoided by postulating that the fermionic creation and annihilation operators a(±) (k, s3 )+ and a(±) (k, s3 ), respectively, obey anticommutation relations instead of commutation relations, i.e. {a(±) (k, s3 ), a(±) (k′ , s′3 )+ } = V δk,k′ δs3 ,s′3
(5.97)
with the curly bracket of operators A and B being defined as {A, B} = AB + BA; furthermore (see also below) all the remaining anticommutators are required to vanish. With this choice, the Hamiltonian takes the form H=
(5.98) 1 X 1 1 ω(k) a(+) (k, s3 )+ a(+) (k, s3 ) − V + a(−) (k, s3 )+ a(−) (k, s3 ) − V V 2 2 k,s3
which now is a positive definite operator, were it not for the zero-point energy that, remarkably, for fermions enters with a minus sign. We ignore this problem here and postpone a discussion of the zero-point energy at a later stage. Furthermore, using the completeness relation (5.94), one finds for the canonical anticommutator {ψ(x)s , ψ + (x′ )s′ } = δx,x′ δ s s′
(5.99)
and also ′
{ψ(x)s , ψ(x′ )s } = 0
{ψ + (x)s , ψ + (x′ )s′ } = 0.
(5.100)
We will comment on the meaning of this decisive result in a section to come. To resume, at the quantum level the Dirac Hamiltonian describes a consistent system if anticommutation relations are imposed; it can then be interpreted, much in the same way as for bosons, as a collection of (quantized) fermionic harmonic oscillators, the properties of which will be explored below. In order to study the properties of the Hamilton operator (5.98), we simplify the notation and collect the labels l and s3 in a single index i ∈ {1, . . . , n} of finite range. Furthermore, as the negative energy part enters additively, it may be discarded since it can be treated similarly. We then arrive at the Hamiltonian X 1 + (5.101) H= ω i ai ai − 2 i
where the operators
a+ i
and ai obey {ai , a+ j } = δij .
(5.102)
What is still missing, however, is a relation amongst the ai , and accordingly for the adjoint operators; a somewhat strange, though consequent choice is {ai , aj } = 0
+ {a+ i , aj } = 0
(5.103)
so that they anticommute amongst themselves. This requirement entails (ai )2 = 0 2 and (a+ i ) = 0, i.e., these operators are nilpotent.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
107
In order to show that these rules are consistent and non void, we construct a representation of this algebra and begin with the case n = 1. Let us assume the existence of a normalized vector |0i with the property a|0i = 0
(5.104)
|1i = a+ |0i.
(5.105)
a|1i = |0i
(5.106)
a+ |1i = 0.
(5.107)
and set +
+
Since aa |0i = a|1i = (1 − a a)|0i = |0i, we also have + 2
+
+ 2
and from (a ) |0i = a |1i together with (a ) = 0 we furthermore obtain
It is a simple exercise to show then that the inner product on the 2-dimensional vector space is the standard one with h0|0i = h1|1i = 1 and h0|1i = 0; beyond this, one has (a+ )+ = a, i.e. with respect to this inner product the operators a and a+ are adjoint to each other. Thus we have constructed an irreducible, two-dimensional representation of the anticommutation relations. One can also introduce the number operator N = a+ a with the property N 2 = N ; on the basis it acts as N |0i = 0 and N |1i = |1i. Hence the only possible eigenvalues of N are 0 and 1, which is the statement of the famous Pauli exclusion principle. It is easy to find a matrix realization of the fermionic algebra. We set 1 0 |0i = |1i = (5.108) 0 1 and in this basis we have 01 00 00 + a= a = N= (5.109) 00 10 01 as is immediate to verify. The generalization to a set of n fermionic oscillators is straightforward. The basis of the fermionic Fock space is given by m1 mn |m1 , . . . , mn i = (a+ · · · (a+ |0i n) 1)
: mi = 0, 1
(5.110)
being antisymmetric under the interchange of any two nonzero quantum numbers. The creation and annihilation operators act on this basis as ai |m1 , . . . , mn i = (−1)m1 +···+mi−1 mi |m1 , . . . , mi − 1, . . . , mn i
a+ i |m1 , . . . , mn i
m1 +···+mi−1
= (−1)
(1 − mi )|m1 , . . . , mi + 1, . . . , mn i
(5.111) (5.112)
where the sign factor arises since, e.g., ai has to be anticommuted through in front 2 of the i-th position. Finally, since (a+ i ) = 0, two fermions with the same quantum numbers cannot occupy the same state, this again being the manifestation of the Pauli exclusion principle, now for the n-particle system. We shall later put the fermionic as well as the bosonic Fock space construction in a broader context, which will reveal their common origin.
April 8, 2013
14:15
108
5.6.3
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
The doubling problem
The discussion in the last but one subsection is not complete since we still have to perform the limit a → 0 in order to return to the continuum. For this purpose, assume the lattice to be infinite. Then the Hamiltonian takes the form π
H=
1 (2π)3
Z+ a
d 3 k ψ + (k)Ω(k)ψ(k)
(5.113)
−π a
with the integration extending over the Brillouin zone π π + ≥ kj ≥ − (5.114) a a where opposite edges are to be identified; hence, the manifold in momentum space is the 3-dimensional torus. Let us have a closer look at the fermionic dispersion law (5.91), which we restate here 2 X1 sin(akj ) (5.115) ω 2 (k) = m2 + a j in order to compare it with the corresponding bosonic result (see (1.118)): a 2 X2 2 2 ω (k) = m + sin kj . (5.116) a 2 j As the comparison shows, the fermionic case can be obtained from the bosonic case by the simple substitution a → 2a, i.e., the lattice constant is merely doubled. This seems to be a harmless modification since, at least in the continuum limit, it should make no difference whether a or 2a is ultimately sent to zero. Nevertheless, this tiny difference has drastic consequences. The bosonic dispersion law has only one minimum at the center since the argument of the sine function takes values in the range π a π + ≥ kj ≥ − (5.117) 2 2 2 whereas the fermionic dispersion law has three because now +π ≥ kj a ≥ −π.
(5.118)
The reason is that the Brillouin zone is twice as large in the fermionic case. Hence, apart from the minimum at the center, one has two additional minima at the corners of the Brillouin zone for each spatial direction; but in all, one only has two different sectors since opposite corners must be identified. As a consequence, one encounters 23 = 8 degrees of freedom for each single component of the Dirac spinor so that in total one has 4 × 8 = 32 (complex) fermionic degree of freedom. The unexpected proliferation of fermionic species is referred to as the fermion doubling problem. Let us stress that this phenomenon is generally not considered a lattice artefact; it is looked at as a problem of principle nature.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
109
Another aspect of the doubling phenomenon comes from the observation that the ground state with k = 0 is degenerate since the energy (5.115) has the periodicity property π ω k ± ˆ = ω(k). a
This fact calls for an additional discrete symmetry, which explains the ground state degeneracy
(cf. chap. 36.3). Indeed, the discrete group that generates the degenerate states can be specified; these matters will be discussed later (see subsec. 24.2.1.2) in the 1 + 3-dimensional setting.
5.6.4
Resolution of the doubling problem
We now refine the above approach, and return to the situation where the lattice is of finite extent. What then has to be specified are the boundary conditions; for fermions, however, this amounts to a subtle affair. Of course, for fermions in the context of statistical mechanics it is well known that one has to choose the boundary condition to be antiperiodic in the euclidean time, which plays the rˆ ole of the inverse temperature. Also, for the supersymmetric string both periodic Ramond and antiperiodic Neveu-Schwarz boundary conditions are known to be relevant. But here we are talking about conventional Dirac fermions, and what is not told in the literature is the fact that for these antiperiodic boundary conditions in the spatial directions turns out to be the natural choice.
Hence, it appears to be appropriate to exercise some scrutiny, and it is for such reasons that we modify the na¨ıve lattice approach and introduce twisted boundary conditions (cf. (2.86)) of the form ψ(x + Xˆ) = eiπθj ψ(x)
(5.119)
where θj ∈ [0, 1], and N is chosen to be an even integer. For θj = 0 they are periodic, and for θj = 1 antiperiodic; the admissible lattice vectors are again restricted to the domain − N2 ≤ nj ≤ + N2 − 1. Note that these generalized boundary conditions are available only for a complex valued field (which in that case also leave the canonical anticommutation relations intact). In the Fourier decomposition of the lattice field 1 X ikx ψ(x) = e ψ(k) (5.120) V k
the momenta are modified now into kj =
2π X
1 l j + θj 2
(5.121)
where again − N2 ≤ lj ≤ + N2 − 1. This choice guarantees the twisted boundary conditions to be respected. The Hamiltonian is also again given by (5.89), and the matrix Ω takes the same form as in (5.90), only the momentum vector now has a different meaning. What is decisively different, however, this is the dispersion relation since the range of the momentum vectors then is −
π π 2π π π + θj ≤ kj ≤ + − + θj . a X a X X
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
110
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
In particular, for antiperiodic boundary conditions along all spatial directions, the domain of definition takes its maximally symmetric form π π π π − + ≤ kj ≤ + − (5.122) a X a X so that, with this choice, the admissible values are now entirely contained in the interior of the first Brillouin zone ! To give a r´esum´e, on a finite lattice the doubling problem of fermions disappears, provided that antiperiodic boundary conditions are imposed; then the system is perfectly well defined. All the pathologies encountered for an infinite lattice are absent as well if the infinite volume limit is performed afterwards. Hence, for fermions, antiperiodic boundary conditions are to be considered as the really natural choice. We shall come back to the above resolution of the doubling problem later on in a more advanced context. The Dirac spinor field in the Schr¨odinger picture lives on a 3-dimensional torus, which in the end may be made arbitrarily large. It can be shown that a general n-torus admits so called 2n different spin structures (see sec. 46.7); they are determined by the choice of boundary conditions. There is precisely one choice of a spin structure which avoids the doubling problem; it is the one for which the spinor field obeys antiperiodic boundary conditions in all spatial directions. In the limit where the extent of the torus is sent to infinity, no relic of the boundary conditions remains since the spinor field must vanish at infinity.
5.7
Clifford Algebras and Spin Groups *
We shall later have need for some basic facts about Clifford algebras and their corresponding spin groups in arbitrary dimensions. A.
The abstract formulation of a Clifford algebra is given in the following
Definition 5.1. Let V be a d-dimensional real vector space, being equipped with an inner product g, i.e. a map g : V × V → R which is bilinear, symmetric and nondegenerate; the Clifford algebra Cl(V, g) is the associative algebra with unit e, being generated by V , and with the multiplication being subject to the relation v1 v2 + v2 v1 = 2g(v1 , v2 )e for all v1 , v2 ∈ V . Remark 5.1. We shall often omit the unit e, as well as the additional label g in Cl(V, g), when confusion is not likely. Remark 5.2. One could as well restrict the above definition to v1 = v = v2 on replacing the metric by the quadratic form q(v) = g(v, v); by means of the polarization identity 2g(v, w) = q(v + w) − q(v) − q(w)
the metric can then be regained from the quadratic form.
(5.123)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
111
Explicitly, Cl(V ) can be defined as follows. Consider the tensor algebra T (V ) over V , and let J(V ) be the ideal generated by elements of the form v1 ⊗ v2 + v1 ⊗ v2 − 2g(v1 , v2 ); then Cl(V ) is the quotient algebra T (V )/J(V ), where the quotient product in Cl(V ) is denoted by juxtaposition; the vector space V can be considered as a subspace of the Clifford algebra. From Cl(V ) as an associative algebra one can construct a Lie algebra, whose underlying vector space is Cl(V ), by defining [w1 , w2 ] = w1 w2 − w2 w1
: w1 , w2 ∈ Cl(V )
(5.124)
so that the bracket is simply the commutator. Let us choose a basis {e1 , . . . , ed } in V with g(eα , eβ ) = gαβ for α = 1, . . . , d. Using the relations eα eβ + eβ eα = 2gαβ
(5.125)
it is easily seen that the products eα1 · · · eαp
: 1 ≤ α1 < · · · < αp ≤ d
(5.126)
for p = 1, . . . , d, and e (p = 0) constitute a basis in Cl(V ). Since the number of these basis vectors for fixed p is dp , the dimension of Cl(V ), considered as a vector P space, is dp=1 dp = 2d . By means of the tensor εα1 ···αp β1 ···βp =
X
π∈Sp
(−1)|π| δ α1 βπ(1) · · · δ αp βπ(p)
(5.127)
where sign(π) = (−1)|π| denotes the sign of the permutation π, we can also construct the basis 1 (5.128) eα1 ···αp = εβ1 ···βp α1 ···αp eβ1 · · · eβp p! being completely antisymmetric in its lower indices. B. We now assume the metric to be euclidean, the general case will be dealt with afterwards; furthermore, we pass to Cl(V ∗ ), i.e., consider the dual situation. One can construct a further, convenient basis from the generators eα through 1
e(θ) = (e1 )θ · · · (ed )θ
d
(5.129)
where the components of the vector θ only take values θα ∈ {0, 1}
: α = 1, . . . , d.
(5.130)
It is straightforward to obtain the multiplication law e(θ)e(θ′ ) = ε(θ, θ′ )e(θ + θ′ )
(5.131)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
112
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
for this basis. Here, the sum θ + θ′ is to be taken mod 2 since (eα )2 = 1, and the explicit form of the sign factor is ′
ε(θ, θ ) = (−1)
d P
θα
α−1 P
θ ′β
.
(5.132)
ε(θ′ , θ)ε(θ′′ , θ) = ε(θ′ + θ′′ , θ)
(5.133)
α=2
β=1
Its main properties are easily verified to be ε(θ, θ′ )ε(θ, θ′′ ) = ε(θ, θ′ + θ′′ ) and ε(θ, θ′ )ε(θ′ , θ) = (−1)θ
p ε(θ, θ) = (−1)(2)
2 ′2
θ −θ·θ ′
2
(5.134)
α
where θ = p. In particular, with the notation α ˆ = (0, . . . , 0, θ = 1, 0, . . . , 0) we have ε(ˆ α, θ) = (−1)θ
1
+···+θ α−1
ε(θ, α) ˆ = (−1)θ
α+1
+···+θ d
(5.135)
which are also quantities that we shall frequently encounter later. By means of the multiplication law of the basis we can construct a finite group, denoted Gd , being intimately related to the Clifford algebra. This is obtained from ε1 e(θ1 )ε2 e(θ2 ) = ε1 ε2 ε(θ1 , θ2 )e(θ1 + θ2 ) so that the multiplication law for an element (ε, θ) = εe(θ) ∈ Gd is (ε1 , θ1 )(ε2 , θ2 ) = (ε1 ε2 ε(θ1 , θ2 ), θ12 ) where θ12 = θ1 + θ2 mod 2; hence, the order of the discrete group Gd is 2 · 2d . C. Let us assume the dimension to be even; then one might guess from the examples with d = 2, 4 that there should exist a representation of the Clifford algebra generators by complex N × N matrices with N = 2n where d = 2n. Indeed, it does, and this representation is obtained by means of a remarkable construction, essentially being due to Jordan and Wigner (1928), which since then has repeatedly been rediscovered by many authors. Let Cl(V ) = C ⊗ Cl(V ) be the complexification of the given Clifford algebra with a euclidean metric, and introduce operators aj and a+ j with j ∈ {1, . . . , n} by γ2j−1 = aj + a+ j
γ2j = −i(aj − a+ j ).
(5.136)
From the Clifford relations it follows that these operators obey the anticommutation relations {aj , a+ k } = δjk
(5.137)
and all other anticommutators vanish. Hence, they are fermionic creation and + annihilation operators, obeying (a+ j ) = aj , by means of which we can construct the fermionic Fock space with its standard inner product. As a consequence, we find a representation of the Clifford algebra of dimension 2n , which is irreducible by construction, and the matrix elements of the self-adjoint operators γα are hmn , . . . , m1 |γα |m′1 , . . . , m′n i
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
113
where the mj and m′j take values in {0, 1}. In order to obtain these matrices in explicit form, one must fix an ordering of the basis vectors. One can avoid this by using the following simpler, equivalent realization by means of a n-fold tensor product, being built from Pauli matrices; it reads i−1
n−i
γ2i−1 = ( ⊗ σ3 ) ⊗ σ1 ⊗ ( ⊗ 1)
i−1
n−i
γ2i = ( ⊗ σ3 ) ⊗ σ2 ⊗ ( ⊗ 1)
(5.138)
for i = 1, . . . , n, where the γ2i−1 are real and the γ2i purely imaginary; furthermore, the figure 1 denotes the unit matrix in two dimensions. The verification of the Clifford algebra relations is by direct computation. The above construction can be extended to cover also the odd dimensional case with d = 2n + 1 by choosing n
γ2n+1 = ± ⊗ σ3
(5.139)
where the ambiguity in sign will commented upon below. D. In the representation ρ(eα ) = γ α of the Clifford algebra generators, having been given in the preceding paragraph, the matrices γ α are hermitian. Hence, the p basis of the Clifford algebra obeys γ + (θ) = (−1)(2) γ(θ). Of special relevance is the element γ(1, . . . , 1) = γ 1 · · · γ d , an appropriately normalized version of which is d
γ d+1 = i(2) γ 1 · · · γ d
(5.140)
with (γ d+1 )2 = 1 and (γ d+1 )+ = γ d+1 ; the freedom of choosing a ± sign on the right hand side will be considered at the end of this appendix. Since γ d+1 γ α = (−1)d−1 γ α γ d+1
(5.141)
we see that γ d+1 commutes with all generators for d odd, and anticommutes with all generators for d even. For d odd, Schur’s lemma (for Gd ) then tells us that γ d+1 = λ1, where 1 denotes the unit matrix in N dimensions and λ is an arbitrary phase; hence, there is no faithful representation in odd dimensions. For a general element γ(θ) of Cl(V ) we have the easily verifiable identity α
γ α γ(θ) = (−1)θ·θ−θ γ(θ)γ α
(5.142)
from which we want to conclude that, except for the cases θ2 = 0 and θ2 = d, one can find a γ α such that γ α γ(θ)γ α = −γ(θ)
(5.143)
holds; indeed, for θ2 even, choose some α with θα = 1, and for θ2 odd, choose an α with θα = 0, giving the assertion. From now on we restrict ourselves to the case of an even dimension d = 2n, the odd case will be dealt with subsequently. Then we know from (5.141) that also γ d+1 anticommutes with all generators, and so (5.143) holds for all θ2 6= 0; hence, using the cyclic property of the trace, we conclude that Trγ(θ) = 0
: θ2 6= 0.
(5.144)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
114
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
This property entails 1 Tr(γ(θ)γ(θ′ )) = ε(θ, θ′ )δ(θ, θ′ ) (5.145) N since the trace of γ(θ + θ′ ) is non vanishing only if θα + θ′α = 0 mod 2 for all α, which implies θ = θ′ . We rewrite this latter result in the form 1 Tr(γ + (θ)γ(θ′ )) = δ(θ, θ′ ) : 0 ≤ θ2 , θ′2 ≤ d (5.146) N from which one easily infers that the 2d matrices γ(θ) are linearly independent. Because we also know now that N = 2n , the γ(θ) form a basis of End(CN ), and so we can express an arbitrary complex N × N - matrix A in terms of these: X A = A(θ) γ + (θ). (5.147) θ
The inverse relation is
A(θ) =
1 Tr(A γ(θ)) N
and the completeness relation reads 1 X γ(θ)s s′ γ + (θ)t t′ = δ s t′ δs′ t N
: s, s′ , t, t′ = 1, . . . , N.
(5.148)
(5.149)
θ
Furthermore, we have
X 1 A∗ (θ) B(θ) Tr (A+ B) = N θ
so that
1 Tr (A+ B) (5.150) N is the appropriately normalized Frobenius or Hilbert-Schmidt inner product. Let us restate these results in the alternative tensorial basis γ α1 ···αp , where for p = 0 this is the identity matrix per definition; the normalization is given by 1 Tr (γ α1 ···αp γβ+1 ···βq ) = δ p q εα1 ···αp β1 ···βp (5.151) N and the completeness relation reads (A|B) =
N X 1 α1 ···αp s (γ ) s′ (γα+1 ···αp )t t′ = δ s t′ δs′ t . p! p=0
The equations corresponding to (5.147) and (5.148) are X 1 1 A = Aα1 ···αp γ α1 ···αp Aα1 ···αp = Tr (A γα+1 ···αp ) p! N p
with the coefficients Aα1 ···αp being totally skewsymmetric, and X 1 A∗α1 ···αp B α1 ···αp . (A|B) = p! p
(5.152)
(5.153)
(5.154)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
book
115
We shall have need for these formulae in the further development. It can be shown, and we will do so below, that the hermitian representation of the γ-matrices, having been constructed in the preceding and made use of in the present subsection, is the only one that exists and is unique up to unitary equivalence. Furthermore, a representation for a Clifford algebra of odd dimension d = 2n + 1 can be constructed by starting from the 2n-dimensional case. One only needs to take the element γ2n+1 in 2n dimensions as the hermitian γd in 2n + 1 dimensions; actually, there is an ambiguity in sign, one can choose γd± = ±in(2n−1) γ1 · · · γ2n
: d = 2n + 1.
(5.155)
These two representations will turn out to be inequivalent and, up to unitary equivalence, there are no other ones. Finally, let us remark on the case of a non-euclidean metric; this can be reduced to the one considered above since, for an α with gαα = −1, the simple substitution γα → iγα produces the requisite change of sign. E. We prove that the representations of the Clifford algebra Cl(V ), having been constructed above, are the only ones that exist and are unique up to unitary equivalence. For the proof (see also Roe (1988)), we use the finite group Gd with elements g = (ε, θ) and its representations to determine those of Cl(V ); the metric is taken to be euclidean. For this, the concept of a class of conjugate elements is needed. Two elements g1 and g2 of a group G are said to be conjugate if there exists another element g ∈ G such that g2 = gg1 g −1 holds; this defines an equivalence relation, and so G decomposes into disjoint classes of conjugate elements. Let us determine the number of conjugacy classes for the case at hand. Using the formulas for ε(θ, θ′ ), one finds (ε′ , θ′ )(ε, θ)(ε′ , θ′ )−1 = (ε ε(θ′ , θ + θ′ )ε(θ + θ′ , θ′ ), θ).
(5.156)
Hence, we conclude (which is the content of (5.142)) that +e(θ) and −e(θ) constitute a class, unless e(θ′ ) is an element which commutes with all elements of the group, i.e. is an element of the centre Z. As we know, the centre is Z = {+e, −e} = Z2 for d even, and Z = {+e, +ed+1, −e, −ed+1} for d odd; therefore, the number of conjugacy classes c is 2d+1 − 2 2d+1 − 4 + 2 = 2d + 1 d odd : c = + 4 = 2d + 2 . 2 2 The general representation theory for a finite group G then states (see, e.g., Fulton and Harris (1991)) d even :
c=
(a) Every irreducible representation of G is equivalent to a unitary representation. (b) The number of inequivalent irreducible representations ρλ is equal to the number c of conjugacy classes.
April 8, 2013
14:15
116
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
(c) If dλ with λ = 1, . . . , c denotes the dimension of the irreducible representaP tion ρλ , then |G| = d2λ . λ
We begin by exploiting the observation that the element −e of Z2 = {+e, −e} can only be represented by +1 or −1. For +1, we thus have a representation of Gd /Z2 , which is abelian and of order 2d ; hence, there are 2d of these representations, and they are all one-dimensional. For d even, property (b) then tells us that there remains precisely one irreducible representation, and this is the only nontrivial one as a representation of the Clifford algebra. We call it the Dirac representation, denoted as ρ∆ , for which −e is represented by −1; furthermore, from (c) we infer that its dimension is 2d+1 = 2d + (d∆ )2 or d∆ = 2n = N , which is the same as that of the explicit construction. Hence, up to unitary equivalence, there is precisely one irreducible representation of the Clifford algebra for d even; this is isomorphic to the matrix algebra End(CN ), a fact we have proven explicitly already earlier. Let us turn then to the case with d = 2n + 1 odd, which is slightly more complicated. From (b) we infer that there are two inequivalent representations, denoted ρ∆+ and ρ∆− ; since ed+1 commutes with all group elements, it can be ± represented either by +1 or −1, and these two representations with γd+1 = ±1 are inequivalent; hence, ρ∆± have equal dimension which, according to (c), is d∆± = 2n . As a consequence, the even-dimensional case with dimension 2n can be used to construct these two representations; we only need to define ± γ2n+1 = γd± = ±in γ1 · · · γ2n
(5.157)
where we have used that in(2n−1) = in , and so the classification is complete. F. As we have noted earlier, from Cl(V ) one can construct a Lie algebra by defining the bracket to be the commutator. Of special relevance are the quadratic elements 1 1 [γα , γβ ] = (γα γβ − gαβ ) (5.158) 4 2 where we choose the unique representation of the γ-matrices for d even, and one of the two representations for d odd. By means of the general formula σαβ =
[AB, CD] = A{B, C}D − {A, C}BD + CA{B, D} − C{A, D}B
(5.159)
they are easily shown to obey [σαβ , σγδ ] = −(gαγ σβδ + gβδ σαγ − gαδ σβγ − gβγ σαδ ).
(5.160)
These are the Lie algebra relations of the group SO(V, g); furthermore, we have [σαβ , γδ ] = −gαδ γβ + gβδ γα so that, on introducing real parameters αγδ = −αδγ , we find 1 1 αγδ σ γδ , γ α = −αα β γ β = − αγδ (M γδ )α β γ β . 2 2
(5.161)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields: Fermions
Hence, we can make use of the exponential map to define the operator 1 S(α) = exp αγδ σ γδ 2 obeying S + = S −1 ; this has the basic property S −1 γ α S = Rα β γ β
book
117
(5.162)
(5.163)
where R = exp( 12 αγδ M γδ ) is an element of SO(V, g) by construction. We have defined in (5.162) an element of what is called the spin group, denoted by Spin(d); let us remark that, at the level of group elements, it makes no difference which of the two inequivalent representations for a Clifford algebra in an odd dimension is used. Since the exponential map is in general defined only locally, the spin group is generated by this local group. The relation of the spin group with the corresponding rotation group is provided by (5.163); this gives us a homomorphism of the simply connected Spin(d) onto SO(d), which is a twofold covering map. Another line of reasoning that is often used in the literature, and which we shall meet again later in the context of the symplectic group, is the following. The argument only works in even dimensions, so let R ∈ SO(2n) and consider the new basis γ ′α = Rα β γ β
(5.164)
of generating elements, which are also hermitian and also obey the Clifford relations. Because the representation of the γ-matrices is unique up to unitary equivalence, there must exist a unitary matrix S with γ ′α = S −1 γ α S and thus we are back at (5.163); this yields a map S 7→ R, which in explicit terms is 1 (5.165) Rα β = Tr S −1 γ α Sγβ . N In the neighbourhood of the identity, we can use the expansion S = 1+ 21 αγδ σ γδ +· · · where the matrix σ γδ must obey (5.161), which is solved by (5.160) and so the circle closes. However, for later purposes we remark that eq. (5.163) does not determine S in terms of R uniquely. One still has the freedom of a phase factor, i.e. one can replace S as specified in eq. (5.162) by S c = e−iα/2 S; this will later give rise to the introduction of the group Spinc (d), which may be viewed as a central extension of the spin group by the circle group. Let us note that it makes sense as well to introduce the following elements of the Clifford algebra α
X = xα γα ∈ Cl(V )
(5.166)
where v = x eα ∈ V ; X is a hermitian matrix which is mapped by means of S into SXS −1 = X ′ with x′ = Rx, being the natural transformation law. Note also that it makes sense to extend this construction to the Clifford algebra as a whole, as well as to its complexification; we shall have occasion to return to this remark. An element S of the spin group acts on 2n -dimensional complex vectors, which are generally referred to as spinors. In even dimensions d = 2n, the realization of
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
118
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
g S is not an irreducible representation of SO(2n) (but can be made so if discrete transformations are included) since the γs anticommute with γ d+1 , and thus [σ γδ , γ d+1 ] = 0.
(5.167)
Hence, γ d+1 also commutes with S; but γ d+1 is not a multiple of the unit matrix for d even because the representation of Cl(2n) is faithful, and thus Schur’s lemma gives the assertion. Since (γ d+1 )2 = 1 and (γ d+1 )+ = γ d+1 , the matrix γ d+1 can only have eigenvalues ±1; a (half-)spinor with eigenvalue +1 respectively −1 is known as a spinor of positive respectively negative chirality. The fact that the spinor representation of Spin(d) is not irreducible can also be seen in the Fock space realization. Since the infinitesimal generators σ γδ are quadratic in the operators a and a+ , the spinor transformations S leave invariant Pn the subspace of vectors |m1 , . . . , mn i with i=1 mi even or odd, respectively, and it is easily verified that the group elements S act irreducibly on these subspaces. It is instructive to make this explicit, and for that purpose we now use γd+1 = ǫ(n)in γ1 · · · γ2n
(5.168)
where we maintain the freedom ǫ(n) of a ± in front, which we have simply set equal to unity earlier. By means of the Jordan-Wigner formula (5.136) we then find Y + γd+1 = ǫ(n) (ak + a+ k )(ak − ak ) k
+ + and this can be simplified, using (ak + a+ k )(ak − ak ) = 2ak ak − 1 and mk (2a+ |mk i k ak − 1)|mk i = −(−1)
to give γd+1 = ǫ(n)(−1)n
Y (−1)Nk k
a+ k ak
where Nk = is the kth number operator. Hence, with the choice ǫ(n) = (−1)n , we obtain the final result Y γd+1 = (−1)Ni (5.169) i
showing explicitly that γd+1 is diagonal and has eigenvalues ±1, as claimed. Hence, a better choice for the matrix γd+1 appears to be γd+1 = (−i)n γ1 · · · γ2n
(5.170)
and we shall later have need for this modification when we introduce the so called supertrace.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Chapter 6
RELATIVISTIC FREE FIELDS AND SPIN
A discussion of the solutions of the Klein-Gordon and Dirac equation has already be given in our treatment of fields on a lattice. Now we turn to the continuum and give a systematic construction for the solutions of free fields with spin less than or equal to one.
6.1
Scalar Field
In all cases under consideration the relevant field must solve the Klein-Gordon equation which, for a real one component field ϕ(x), is (∂ µ ∂µ + m2 )ϕ(x) = 0.
(6.1)
The solutions of this equation can be written as a Fourier transform Z 1 ϕ(x) = d4 p θ(p0 )δ(p2 − m2 ) e−ipx a(p) + e+ipx a(p)∗ (6.2) (2π)3 where we must explain the various factors under the integral sign. The function a(p) is the general Fourier amplitude, which in the second contribution in brackets appears as the complex conjugate so that the right hand side is indeed real; furthermore, the δ-function guarantees the Klein-Gordon equation to be fulfilled, and the Heaviside function θ(p0 ) only admits positive energies. This form of the solution makes it manifest that the field has the correct transformation law under proper Lorentz transformations since the argument of the δ-function as well as the sign of the energy is an invariant. The integration over p0 can be done by means of the identity X δ(x − x◦ s ) ◦ δ(f (x)) = : f (xs ) = 0 (6.3) ◦ ◦ s k∂f (xs )/∂ xs k where x ∈ Rn and f : Rn → Rn ; the sum extends over the zeroes of the function f , which are assumed to be simple, and kJk denotes the absolute value of the determinant |J| of the Jacobi matrix. In the present case of only one variable, p0 , we thus have p 1 δ(p0 − ωp ) : ω p = m2 + p 2 θ(p0 )δ(p2 − m2 ) = 2ωp 119
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
120
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
and so the solution can be written in the equivalent form Z 3 1 d p −ipx ϕ(x) = e a(p) + e+ipx a(p)∗ (2π)3 2ωp
(6.4)
where the measure
d3 p =: (2π)3 dµ(p) ≡ d4 p θ(p0 )δ(p2 − m2 ) 2ωp
(6.5)
is invariant under proper Lorentz transformations by construction; it is the Lorentz invariant volume element on the set of 4-momenta obeying p2 = m2 , the mass hyperboloid. Note that the above results also hold in the massless case. 6.2
Dirac Field
Each component of the Dirac equation must obey the Klein-Gordon equation; hence, according to the preceding section, we can immediately write down the solution of this latter equation Z 3 1 d p −ipx (+) +ipx (−) ψ(x) = e ψ (p) + e ψ (p) (6.6) (2π)3 2ωp where the ψ (±) (p) are arbitrary Fourier coefficients. They are further restricted by the Dirac equation in momentum space (6 p ∓ m)ψ (±) (p) = 0
(6.7)
where we have introduced Feynman’s notation: 6 p = γ µ pµ .
(6.8)
The solutions take their simplest form in the Pauli representation of the γ-matrices; ◦ in particular, in the rest frame, where (γ 0 ∓ 1)ψ (±) (p) = 0, one immediately finds four linearly independent solutions for which we use the notation 1 0 0 1 1 1 ◦ (+) (+) ◦ = u p, − = (6.9) u p, + 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 ◦ (−) ◦ (−) = u p, − = (6.10) u p, + 1 0 . 2 2 0 1
We could also compute directly the solutions for arbitrary momenta, as we have done this on the lattice, but a more intelligent approach is the following. Remember that we have determined earlier the pure Lorentz transformation Λp ◦ with the property Λp p = p; this can also be done at the level of the corresponding
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin
book
121
spinor group SL(2, C), where the analogue Ap is hermitian and determined by the property (cf. eq. (5.49)) ◦
∼
∼
: A2p =
Ap pAp = p
1∼ p. m
The calculation, being left to the reader, yields 1 1 (m + ω)1 − pk σk A−1 (m + ω)1 + pk σk Ap = p p = p 2m(ω + m) 2m(ω + m) so that the result we need is 1 r 0 ω+m D(Ap ) = 2m +p3 ω+m
0
1
p− ω+m
+p3 p− ω+m ω+m
1
p+ −p3 ω+m ω+m
2
p+ −p3 ω+m ω+m
0
2
At arbitrary p with p = m we define
. 0 1
◦
u(±) (p, s3 ) = D(Ap )u(±) (p, s3 )
(6.11)
(6.12)
where we have introduced s3 = ±1/2; indeed, these are solutions since ◦
(γ µ pµ ∓ m)u(±) (p, s3 ) = (γ µ pµ ∓ m)D(Ap )u(±) (p, s3 ) ◦
◦
= D(Ap )(γ µ pµ ∓ m)u(±) (p, s3 ) = 0.
Hence, the solutions u(+) (p, s3 ) and u(−) (p, s3 ) are given as the columns of the matrix (6.11), to be read from the left to the right in the order as shown in (6.9). Note that these solutions are the same as those found directly in the lattice context. One only has to pass there to the continuum limit, where the opposite sign in the spatial momentum components of the negative energy solutions is due to the different definition of the Fourier transform; beyond that, we have also switched from nonrelativistic to relativistic normalization. Furthermore, using the hermiticity of the matrix (6.11), it is a matter of routine computation to prove the orthonormality properties u¯(±) (p, s3 )u(±) (p, s′3 ) = δs3 s′3
u¯(+) (p, s3 )u(−) (p, s′3 ) = 0.
(6.13)
Hence, the general solution of the Dirac equation can be written in the form 2m (2π)3
Z
d3 p 2ωp
ψ(x) = (6.14) X e−ipx u(+) (p, s3 )a(+) (p, s3 ) + e+ipx u(−) (p, s3 )a(−) (p, s3 )∗
s3 =± 21
where the a(+) (p, s3 ) and a(−) (p, s3 )∗ are arbitrary expansion coefficients; the special normalization will be explained later. Furthermore, we shall need the completeness relations for the solutions of positive and negative energy: X π (±) (p) = ± u(±) (p, s3 ) ⊗ u ¯(±) (p, s3 ). (6.15) s3
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
122
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
This follows from π
(±)
book
(p) = D(Ap ) ±
and
X s3
u
(±)
◦
(p, s3 ) ⊗ u ¯
(±)
◦
!
(p, s3 ) D(Ap )−1 =
1 (±D(Ap )2 γ 0 + 1) 2
6 p = mD(Ap )2 γ 0 to be ± 6p + m . (6.16) 2m These are projection operators with the requisite properties, which project onto the subspace of positive (+) and negative (-) energy solutions, respectively. Hence we see that the above approach has the virtue to circumvent lengthy explicit computations; in addition, it will pay when we come to the discussion of spin. π (±) (p) =
6.3
Maxwell Field
We start off from the free Maxwell equations, expressed in terms of the vector potential, which read ∂µ ∂ µ Aν (x) − ∂ν ∂ µ Aµ (x) = 0.
(6.17)
The crucial point will be to exploit the gauge invariance of this system, that is, the freedom Aµ (x) → A′µ (x) = Aµ (x) + ∂µ α(x)
(6.18)
which can be made use of to get rid of the second term in (6.17); this is achieved by requiring that the Lorentz condition ∂ µ Aµ (x) = 0
(6.19)
be fulfilled. In order to show that this gauge fixing condition may be imposed, let ∂ µ Aµ 6= 0; then we pass to the gauge transformed vector field (6.18) and impose the condition ∂ µ A′µ = 0, giving ∂µ ∂ µ α(x) = −∂ µ Aµ (x). As we shall see in the next chapter, this equation can be solved for the gauge parameter so that the argument is complete. However, gauge invariance is not exhausted completely, since we still have the freedom to replace Aµ → Aµ + ∂µ α, where the scalar function α must now be a solution of the massless Klein-Gordon equation. Hence, the Maxwell equations (6.17) reduce to the massless Klein-Gordon equation for each single component, and so we can immediately write down the solution Z 3 1 d k −ikx Aµ (x) = e Aµ (k) + e+ikx Aµ (k)∗ : k µ Aµ (k) = 0 (6.20) 3 (2π) 2ωk
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin
123
where k 2 = 0. The transversality condition for the Fourier amplitude is a consequence of the Lorentz condition, but the residual gauge invariance A′µ (k) = Aµ (k) + kµ ε(k) (6.21) still remains. It is worthwhile to stress that, as opposed to the Dirac case, there are no further conditions coming from the field equations, which restrict the admissible solutions for the Maxwell field; it is the request for gauge invariance, which precisely serves this purpose for the case at hand. In order to simplify things we would like to have available something like a ‘rest system’, but massless photons are never at rest; the best we can do is to choose as reference momentum vector 1 ◦ 0 k = κ−1 (6.22) 0 1 where κ is a constant with dimension of an inverse mass. We may then take for the ◦
Fourier amplitude at momentum k as basis 1 0 ◦ ◦ 0 1 1 e(k, 0) = e(k, ±1) = √ 0 2 ±i 1
+1 ◦ 0 e′ (k, 0) = 0 . −1
0
◦
(6.23) ◦
But the transversality conditions forbids the last basis vector since k · e′ (k, 0) 6= 0, and the residual gauge invariance can be used to eliminate the first basis vector ◦
◦
◦
since e(k, 0) is proportional to k; hence, only the two polarization vectors e(k, ±1) remain. These are the only physical degrees of freedom that are allowed for the massless vector field. We must still extend the above results to general momentum vectors, and this is again achieved with the help of a Lorentz transformation Λk such that ◦
k = Λk k. (6.24) We do this by first boosting the energy to arbitrary (positive) values ω by means of a pure Lorentz transformation Λ(0, 0, β 3 ), and afterwards we rotate the spatial part (0, 0, ω) of the momentum vector into arbitrary directions by means of a rotation Λ(α1 , α2 , 0). Hence, the task that remains is to calculate the parameters α1 , α2 and β 3 in ◦
k = Λ(α1 , α2 , 0)Λ(0, 0, β 3 )k and some simple algebra left to the reader gives the result ω2 +κ−2 ω 2 −κ−2 0 0 2ωκ−1 2ωκ−1 k1 ω2 −κ−2 k3 k2 k2 k1 k2 k1 ω 2 +κ−2 ω 2ωκ−1 ω + ω(ω+k − 3) ω(ω+k3 ) ω 2ωκ−1 Λk = 2 2 −2 . k ω −κ k2 k1 k3 k1 k1 k2 ω 2 +κ−2 − ω(ω+k + ω 2ωκ−1 3) 3 −1 ω ω(ω+k ) ω 2ωκ k3 ω 2 −κ−2 ω 2ωκ−1
1
− kω
2
− kω
k3 ω 2 +κ−2 ω 2ωκ−1
(6.25)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
124
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Note that this parametrization of the hyperboloid k · k = 0 with k 0 = ω > 0 is merely valid for those momenta, for which ω + k 3 6= 0 holds; hence, the section is not defined globally. Now we are done if we define for arbitrary momenta the polarization vectors to be ◦
By construction, they obey
e(k, ±1) = Λk e(k, ±1).
e(k, s3 )∗ · e(k, s′3 ) = δs3 s′3
k · e(k, s3 ) = 0
(6.26) (6.27)
where we have introduced the notation s3 = ±1; in addition, the 0th components vanish 1 0 nµ eµ (k, s3 ) = 0 :n= (6.28) 0
0 as is easily inferred from the explicit form of Λk , in which the 1- and 2-component of the 0-row vanish. Furthermore, we need the ‘completeness’ relation X π µν (k) = − eµ (k, s3 )eν (k, s3 )∗ (6.29) s3 =±1
the computation of which yields π µν (k) = g µν − having the obvious properties
1 1 (k µ nν + k ν nµ ) + kµ kν k·n (k · n)2
kµ π µν (k) = 0
nµ π µν (k) = 0.
(6.30)
(6.31)
Finally, we can write down the general solution of the free Maxwell equations Z 3 d k X 1 e−ikx eµ (k, s3 )a(k, s3 ) + e+ikx eµ (k, s3 )∗ a(k, s3 )∗ Aµ (x) = (2π)3 2ωk s =±1 3
(6.32) where the a(k, s3 ) are arbitrary Fourier coefficients, which represent the remaining degrees of freedom. It is worthwhile to stress that the vector field not only obeys the Lorentz condition, but also nµ Aµ (x) = 0; hence this is an even stronger condition, called the radiation gauge, in which the Weyl ‘gauge’ A0 = 0 and the three-dimensional Coulomb gauge ∇ · A = 0 are united into one single gauge fixing condition.
6.4
Spin
The spin of fields is determined by the subgroup SU (2) of SL(2, C), the latter being the universal covering group of the proper orthochronous Lorentz group. Hence, we first construct the unitary and irreducible representations of the Lie algebra of SU (2), the spin of fields being discussed afterwards.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin
6.4.1
book
125
Representations of rotations
We are interested in the unitary and irreducible representations of the Lie algebra of the 3-dimensional rotation group on a complex finite-dimensional vector space V ; for this purpose, it is advantageous to pass from the antihermitian Lie algebra operators Ma with a = 1, 2, 3 to the hermitian operators Ua = iMa with commutation relations [Ua , Ub ] = iεab c Uc .
(6.33)
Furthermore, since we seek for representations on a complex vector space, it makes sense to introduce the operators U± = U1 ± iU2
(6.34)
which (formally) obey (U3 )+ = U3 and (U− )+ = U+ and have commutation relations [U3 , U± ] = ±U±
[U+ , U− ] = 2U3 .
(6.35)
Again, because we consider representations, it makes sense to consider the p-th power U± p with [U3 , U± p ] = ±p U± p
(6.36)
as is easily proved by induction. The operator U3 plays a special role; since V is complex and finite-dimensional, there exists an eigenvector v ′ ∈ V , i.e. U3 v ′ = λ′ v ′
(6.37)
and, since U3 is hermitian, the eigenvalue λ′ is real. With (6.35) we then conclude U3 U± p v ′ = [U3 , U± p ]v ′ + U± p U3 v ′ = (λ′ ± p)U± p v ′
(6.38)
where we assume that U± q v ′ 6= 0 for q = 1, . . . , p. These eigenvalues are all different, and so the eigenvectors U± q v ′ of U3 are linearly independent. Hence, there must exist an integer r such that U− r v ′ 6= 0 and U− r+1 v ′ = 0 since V is of finite dimension; we set v = U− r v ′ and this v obeys U− v = 0
U3 v = λv.
(6.39)
Let us introduce vp = U+ p v with U+ vp = vp+1
U3 vp = (λ + p)vp .
(6.40)
Furthermore, from U− v1 = U− U+ v0 = [U− , U+ ]v0 + U+ U− v0 = −2U3 v0 = −2λv0 we infer that generally U− vp = cp vp−1
(6.41)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
126
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
holds, where cp follows from U− vp = U− U+ vp−1 = ([U− , U+ ] + U+ U− )vp−1 = −2U3 vp−1 + cp−1 U+ vp−2 = (cp−1 − 2(λ + p − 1))vp−1 = cp vp−1
to be cp = cp−1 − 2(λ + p − 1)
: c0 = 0 , p ≥ 1.
This recursive relation is solved by iteration with the result p(p − 1) cp = −2 λp + . 2
(6.42)
Once more, since V is finite dimensional, there must exist an n ∈ N such that U+ vn−1 6= 0 and U+ vn = 0 with vn−1 , vn 6= 0. Hence, p takes values in {0, 1, . . . , n}, and from 0 = U− U+ vn = ([U− , U+ ] + U+ U− )vn = −2U3 vn + cn U+ vn−1 = (cn − 2(λ + n))vn we conclude cn = 2(λ + n) = −2λn − n(n − 1); this gives λ = −n/2 so that cp = p(n − p + 1).
(6.43)
Collecting results, we thus have (p = 0, 1, . . . , n) n U3 vp = (p − )vp U+ vp = vp+1 U− vp = p(n − p + 1)vp−1 . (6.44) 2 This is an (n + 1)-dimensional representation of the Lie algebra su(2) with n ∈ N0 ; for n = 0, it is the trivial representation. We want to make this a unitary representation. For that purpose, we construct a scalar product ( . | . ), with respect to which (v0 |v0 ) = 1 by definition; in addition, it must obey (U+ vp−1 |vp ) = (vp−1 |U− vp ).
(6.45)
We set vp = ap fp with (fp |fp ) = 1 so that (vp |vp ) = |ap |2 = (vp−1 |U− vp ) = cp (vp−1 |vp−1 ) = cp |ap−1 |2 giving |ap |2 = cp |ap−1 |2 ; the solution is obtained by iteration and reads ! 12 p Y ap = cq
(6.46)
q=1
where a possible p-dependent phase has been set equal to unity. Insertion then yields n U3 fp = p − fp 2 U+ fp =
ap+1 √ fp+1 = cp+1 fp+1 ap
U − f p = cp
ap−1 √ fp−1 = cp fp−1 ap
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin
127
which is further simplified on setting l = n/2 and m = p − n/2 with −l ≤ m ≤ +l; furthermore, we define em = fp and set cp = (l + m)(l − m + 1) = α2m so that U+ em = αm+1 em+1
U− em = αm em−1 .
In explicit terms, the final form is U3 em = mem
U± em =
p (l ∓ m)(l ± m + 1)em±1
(6.47)
−l ≤ m ≤ +l.
To summarize, we have shown that for every positive integer or half-integer l there exists precisely one unitary representation of su(2) of dimension 2l + 1, for which (6.47) gives the action of the Lie algebra generators on the orthonormal basis. The basis vector e+l is said to be of highest weight, and e−l of lowest weight or cyclic since repeated application of U+ generates the entire representation space. We claim that these representations are irreducible. For the proof, assume that we have a proper subspace W < V , which is invariant. Then there exists a nonzero P vector w = cm em ∈ W , which is annihilated by U− , that is m
0 = U− w =
l X
cm αm em−1 .
−l+1
Because the em are linearly independent, the coefficients cm αm must vanish, and since αm 6= 0 for −l + 1 ≤ m ≤ l, we conclude that cm = 0 for m = −l + 1, . . . , l; we thus have w = c−l e−l ∈ W . By repeated application of U+ , however, we then reach all basis vectors, this giving the contradiction. For these representations, it makes sense to introduce the quadratic Casimir operator U 2 = U12 + U22 + U32
(6.48)
which commutes with all generators since [U 2 , Ua ] = U b [Ub , Ua ] + [Ub , Ua ]U b = −iεabc (U b U c + U c U b ) = 0. In terms of U3 and U± , the operator (6.48) reads U 2 = U3 (U3 + 1) + U− U+
(6.49)
and thus its action on the basis is U 2 em = m(m + 1) + α2m+1 em = (m(m + 1) + (l + m + 1)(l − m)) em
giving
U 2 em = l(l + 1)em .
(6.50)
Hence, the Casimir operator U 2 acts as a multiple of the identity operator, as is also required by Schur’s lemma.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
128
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Let ρ1 and ρ2 be irreducible representations of a (compact) Lie group G on vector spaces V1 and V2 ; then one can define a representation of G on the tensor product V1 ⊗ V2 through (ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 )(g)v1 ⊗ v2 = ρ1 (g)v1 ⊗ ρ2 (g)v2
(6.51)
which is called the tensor product of the two representations. For the corresponding representation of an element X of the Lie algebra L(G), we then have (ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 )(X)v1 ⊗ v2 = (ρ1 (X) ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ ρ2 (X))v1 ⊗ v2 .
(6.52)
This representation is generally reducible; assuming the complete system of irreducible representations of L(G) to be known, one is interested in the problem, into which irreducible subrepresentations ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 decomposes. We address this problem for the Lie algebra su(2); so let V l1 and V l2 be the representation spaces of the representations ρl1 and ρl2 of highest weights l1 and l2 . A basis of V l1 ⊗V l2 is given by el1 m1 ⊗el2 m2 with l1 ≥ m1 ≥ −l1 and l2 ≥ m2 ≥ −l2 . For the generator U3 acting on the tensor product we thus find the eigenvalues ρl1 ⊗ ρl2 (U3 )el1 m1 ⊗ el2 m2 = (m1 + m2 )el1 m1 ⊗ el2 m2
or l1 + l2 ≥ m1 + m2 ≥ −(l1 + l2 ). The multiplicity of the eigenvalue l1 + l2 is one, that of l1 + l2 − 1 is two, and generally the degeneracy of the eigenvalue l1 + l2 − r is r + 1. Hence, the highest weight l1 + l2 belongs to the subrepresentation ρl1 +l2 , which occupies m1 + m2 = l1 + l2 − 1 once, so that the representation with l = l1 + l2 − 1 occupies the second eigenvalue. Continuing this process, the representation ρl =: (l) with l = |l1 − l2 |, . . . , l1 + l2 all occur with multiplicity one; the resulting decomposition (l1 ) ⊗ (l2 ) =
l1 +l2
⊕
l=|l1 −l2 |
(l)
(6.53)
is called the Clebsch-Gordan decomposition. 6.4.2
Fields and their spin
Recall that we have constructed fundamental solutions of the field equations for the Klein-Gordon field, the Maxwell-Proca field, and the Dirac field; we restrict ourselves to the massive case. Let us denote these fundamental solutions in phase space by φ(±) (p, s3 ) and write the general solution as φ(x) =
Z
(6.54) X dµs (p) e−ipx ϕ(+) (p, s3 )φ(+) (p, s3 ) + e+ipx ϕ(−) (p, s3 )φ(−) (p, s3 ) s3
(±)
where the ϕ (p, s3 ) are arbitrary Fourier amplitudes. The transformation law of the positive and negative frequency parts X φ(±) (p) = ϕ(±) (p, s3 )φ(±) (p, s3 ) (6.55) s3
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin
129
under Poincar´e transformations is given by T (a, A)φ(±) (p) = e±iap D(A)φ(±) (Λ−1 p).
(6.56)
Remember also that we have constructed the fundamental solutions such that ◦
φ(±) (p, s3 ) = D(Ap )φ(±) (p, s3 )
(6.57)
holds, where ◦
∼
◦
∼
Ap pAp + = p.
Λp p = p
Then we can rewrite (6.56) in the form X (±) ◦ T (A)φ(±) (p) = ϕ(±) (p, s3 )D(Ap )D(A−1 (p, s3 ) p AAΛ−1 p )φ
(6.58)
s3
◦
and here we encounter the matrix A−1 p AAΛ−1 p , which leaves p invariant, the momentum at rest; for the corresponding Lorentz transformation we have ◦
◦
−1 −1 Λ−1 p = Λ−1 p ΛΛΛ−1 p p = Λp ΛΛ p p = p. ◦
◦
◦
◦
◦
Those Lorentz transformations Λ that leave p fixed, viz. Λp = p, form a subgroup of L0 ; it is called the little group. In the massive case, this is the 3-dimensional rotation ◦
∼
group or, in the Dirac case, the unitary subgroup SU (2) since p = m 1 requires that ◦
◦
A must be unitary. As is easily checked now, the fundamental solutions at p obey X ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ D(A)φ(±) (p, s3 ) = D(A)s′3 s3 φ(±) (p, s′3 ) s′3
where for the Maxwell-Proca field we have to choose the natural basis. Thus, if we define the transformation of the Fourier amplitudes by X U (a, A)ϕ(±) (p, s3 )φ(∓) (p, s3 ) T (a, A)φ(±) (p) = s3
we find U (a, A)ϕ(±) (p, s3 ) =
X
(±) D(A−1 (p, s′3 ) p AAΛ−1 p )s3 s′3 ϕ
(6.59)
s′3
which is Wigner’s form of the unitary and irreducible representations of the Poincar´e group in the massive case. Let us go through the three examples that we have considered; for the present purposes, we write the representations (6.47) in the form p U3 |s, s3 i = s3 |s, s3 i U± |s, s3 i = (s ∓ s3 )(s ± s3 + 1)|s, s3 ± 1i. (6.60)
We begin with the Klein-Gordon field, where ◦
s = 0: D(A) = 1
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
130
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
This is the trivial so that the spin of the Klein-Gordon field is zero. ◦representation ◦ A s = 21 : D(A) = ◦ A Here one simply has the direct sum of two half-integer spin representations for positive and negative energy solutions. For the basis {| 12 , + 21 i, | 21 , − 21 i}, the spin matrices are 1 +1 0 01 00 U3 = U+ = U− = (6.61) 0 −1 00 10 2 and their action is 1 1 =0 U+ , + 2 2
1 1 U− , + = 2 2
1 1 1 1 U+ , − = , + 2 2 2 2
1 ,−1 2 2
1 1 U− , − =0 2 2 ◦
1 1 1 1 1 U3 , + = + , + 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 U3 , − = − , − 2 2 2 2 2
Since, e.g., the upper components of u(+) (p, ± 21 ) are identical with the basis | 12 , ± 12 i, the Dirac field has spin one-half. ◦ 1 s = 1: D(A) = R In the same way as one passes from M1 and M2 , and M3 with 0 0 +i 0 −i M1 = 0 −i M2 = 0 M3 = +i 0 (6.62) +i 0 −i 0 0 to M± = M1 ± iM2 with
one must pass from the basis e+
1 = √ 2
which gives
0 ∓1 M± = 0 −i ±1 +i 0 e1 , e2 and e3 to 1 1 1 +i e− = √ −i 2 0 0
M+ e+ = 0
√ M− e+ = − 2e3 M3 e+ = +e+
√ M+ e− = + 2e3 M− e− = 0 M3 e− = −e−
On the other hand, from (6.60) we have for spin one √ √ U+ |1, −1i = 2|1, 0i U+ |1, 0i = 2|1, +1i √ U− |1, −1i = 0 U− |1, 0i = 2|1, −1i
(6.63)
0 1 e3 = √ 0 2 1
(6.64)
√ M+ e3 = − 2e+ √ M− e3 = + 2e− M3 e3 = 0.
U+ |1, +1i = 0 √ U− |1, +1i = 2|1, 0i
with the same action of the third generator. Accordingly, we must identify the natural basis e± , e3 as follows: e3 = −|1, 0i e± = ±|1, ±1i. Hence, if one sticks to the natural basis, one must make a different choice for the phase factors (cf. the remark following eq. (6.46)) which we have simply set equal to one there.
To summarize, we know now that the Klein-Gordon field has spin s = 0, the Dirac field has spin s = 1/2, and the Maxwell-Proca field has spin s = 1; hence, our notational conventions have afterwards found their explanation. Higher spin fields will be dealt with later.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Relativistic Free Fields and Spin
6.5
book
131
Transformation Law of Fields and Induced Representations *
A geometric construction for the transformation law of fields can be given that helps to gain a deeper understanding of its origin. Recall, in the general case of a representation D : SL(2, C) → Aut(V ) on a complex vector space V , a field is a smooth map φ : M → V ; the field then transforms as T (a, A)φ(x) = D(A)φ(Λ−1 (x − a))
(6.65)
and it is easy to verify that this is indeed a representation (of the universal covering) of the Poincar´e group. The motivation behind this construction is provided by the method of induced representations. Let G be a Lie group and H < G be a Lie subgroup; further, for V a finite dimensional linear space over C, we assume a representation ρ of H on V to be given, that is, a homomorphism ρ : H → Aut(V ). Consider then the linear space of functions ϕ:G→V
(6.66)
which are assumed to obey ϕ(gh) = ρ−1 (h)ϕ(g)
: g ∈ G, h ∈ H
(6.67)
also termed the covariance condition. This defines a linear subspace of the functions (6.66), and on this subspace we define a representation of G by T (g)ϕ(g ′ ) = ϕ(g −1 g ′ ).
(6.68)
This is compatible with the covariance condition since (T (g)ϕ)(g ′ h) = ρ−1 (h)(T (g)ϕ)(g ′ ) and thus it leaves invariant the subspace of functions obeying (6.67); it is known as the representation of G induced by the representation ρ of H, which is indeed an apt characterization. The induced representation defined by (6.68) and (6.67) can be cast into an alternative form, being the one we need. For this, consider the set of left cosets G/H = M , on which G acts as a left transformation group. We now assume for simplicity that a smooth (global) section s : M → G exists, i.e. s obeys π ◦ s = idM where π is the natural projection π : G → G/H. For x ∈ M set s(x) = gx ; we then have the decomposition G = ∪ gx H into disjoint equivalence classes. Thus, an x∈M
element g ∈ G acts on x ∈ M as
g −1 gx = gx′ h(x, g)
: x′ = g −1 x
(6.69)
−1 gx−1 gx ′ g
where h(x, g) = ∈ H. Let us return then to the induced representation; by means of the covariance condition we can restrict the functions ϕ on G to the homogeneous space G/H on introducing φ(x) = ϕ(gx ).
(6.70)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
132
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
We then calculate T (g)φ(x) = T (g)ϕ(gx ) = ϕ(g −1 gx ) = ϕ(gx′ h(x, g)) = ρ(h(x, g))−1 ϕ(gx′ ) giving the final form T (g)φ(x) = ρ(gx−1 ggg−1 x )φ(g −1 x).
(6.71)
This defines a representation of G on functions φ : M → V , which is of profound geometrical significance. It is not difficult to verify that the choice of a different section leads to an equivalent representation. Let us apply this construction to the case where G is the universal covering ˜ P0 = T (1, 3)⋊SL(2, C) of the Poincar´e group and H the universal covering SL(2, C) of the Lorentz group L0 ; since (a, A) = (a, 1)(0, A) we have the natural (global) decomposition G = ∪ gx H, where x ∈ M , gx = (x, 1) and x∈M
(a, A)−1 (x, 1) = (Λ−1 (x − a), 1)(0, A−1 ).
Now choosing a representation ρ = D of SL(2, C) on a vector space V , we precisely recover eq. (6.65), i.e. the field representation. For those readers having some familiarity with the concept of bundles, we note that the requirement (6.67) underlies the construction of an associated bundle. Namely, as principal bundle P → M choose the special case where P = G and M = G/H, i.e. the structure group is the subgroup H; then the sections of the associated vector bundle E = P ×ρ V can be identified with the maps (6.66) obeying the above covariance condition.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Chapter 7
NEUTRAL FERMIONS
The present chapter mainly centers around the theme of particles and their antiparticles, special emphasis being laid on the discussion of massless neutral fermions. 7.1
Charge Conjugation
The Dirac wave function is a complex spinor, and as such it can be coupled to the electromagnetic field. Accordingly, if the positive energy solutions carry charge minus one in units of |e|, then the negative energy solutions carry charge plus one. Hence, the Dirac equation describes both electrons and positrons; the antiparticles, the positrons, are different from the particles, the electrons, but have equal mass and spin. A priori, the assignment of charge plus or minus e is ambiguous, only the coupling to the electromagnetic field discriminates between these two possibilities. If we choose the sign convention to be (iγ µ ∂µ − eγ µ Aµ − m) ψ = 0
(7.1)
then we expect that there should exist a transformation ψ 7→ ψ c , called charge conjugation, which reverses the sign of the charge: (iγ µ ∂µ + eγ µ Aµ − m) ψ c = 0.
(7.2)
If we also define a charge conjugate gauge potential by Acµ = −Aµ , then under this combined transformation the Dirac equation is invariant. Such a transformation is straightforward to find for the Dirac wave function on using the Cartan representation (5.13) of the spin group, in which (see (5.37)) A S(A) = . (7.3) (A+ )−1 This is the direct sum of the two inequivalent representations A and (A+ )−1 of the group SL(2, C); that they are indeed inequivalent follows from the basic formula ε (A+ )−1 ε−1 = A∗ 133
(7.4)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
134
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
where the asterisk denotes complex conjugation, and +1 2 ε = iσ = . −1
Thus, on making use of
S(A)∗ =
ε (A+ )−1 ε−1
ε A∗ ε−1
(7.5)
= γ 2 S(A) (γ 2 )−1
the complex conjugate ψ ′ ∗ (x ′ ) = S(A)∗ ψ ∗ (x) of the transformed wave function can be written as ψ ′ c (x ′ ) = S(A)ψ c (x) with ψ c = η c iγ 2 ψ ∗
(7.6)
where η c is an unobservable phase, which we set equal to one. We also define the charge conjugate spinor by eq. (7.6) in an arbitrary representation of the γ-matrices. On the fundamental solutions (see sec. 6.2), the charge conjugation acts as u(+) (p, +1/2)c = +u(−) (p, −1/2)
u(+) (p, −1/2)c= −u(−) (p, +1/2) (7.7)
u(−) (p, +1/2)c = −u(+) (p, −1/2)
u(−) (p, −1/2)c = +u(+) (p, +1/2) (7.8)
and we thus define u(+) (p, ±1/2) = +u(p, ±1/2)
u(−) (p, ±1/2) = ∓v(p, ∓1/2)
(7.9)
so that we have uc (p, s3 ) = v(p, s3 )
v c (p, s3 ) = u(p, s3 ).
(7.10)
With these conventions, the general solution (6.14) of the Dirac equation reads Z 3 2m d p X ψ(x) = e−ipx u(p, s3 )a(p, s3 ) + e+ipx v(p, s3 )b(p, s3 )∗ (7.11) 3 (2π) 2ωp 1 s3 =± 2
which is the final version that will be used from now on. It implies that the charge conjugation operator replaces particles by antiparticles and vice versa. The conventional notation for the charge conjugation invokes the Dirac adjoint; since ψ¯ = ψ + γ 0 implies ψ ∗ = γ 0 ψ¯ ∼ , where here and below the tilde denotes the transpose, we obtain ψ c = C ψ¯ ∼
: C = iγ 2 γ 0 = −iσ 1 ⊗ σ 2 .
(7.12)
Here C is called the charge conjugation matrix ; its main properties are 5
C + = C −1 = C ∼ = −C µ
5 µ
For the basis 1, γ , γ , γ γ , σ
µν
C 2 = −1.
(7.13)
of the Clifford algebra, one also checks that
C −1 γ 5 C = +(γ 5 )∼ C −1 γ µ C = −(γ µ )∼
C −1 γ 5 γ µ C = +(γ 5 γ µ )∼ C −1 σ µν C = −(σ µν )∼
(7.14)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Neutral Fermions
book
135
With the second of these rules it is straightforward to prove that the charge conjugate wave function indeed obeys (7.2); the calculation is left to the reader. Finally, on taking care of the fact that the Dirac spinor is an anticommuting ¯ µ ψ into quantity, one verifies that the charge conjugation maps the current jµ = eψγ its negative: ¯ µ ψ. jµ c = eψ c γµ ψ c = −eψγ
(7.15)
This property also justifies the nomenclature. Furthermore, introducing the abbreviation D = iγ µ ∂µ , we have D ψ c = D C ψ¯ ∼ = iC (C −1 γ µ C) ∂µ ψ¯ ∼ ¯ µ ) ∼ = C(D ψ)∼ = −iC(γ µ )∼ ∂µ ψ¯ ∼ = −iC(∂µ ψγ or D ψ c = (D ψ)c
(7.16)
saying that the Dirac operator and the charge conjugation commute. 7.2
Majorana Spinors
Again, the Dirac spinor is complex, hence it is charged; but ‘charge’ need not be the conventional charge, it might also be a hypercharge, or something similar. Accordingly, one could argue that neutral fermions do not exist. However, this impression is wrong since one can pass from the Cartan form (7.3) of the spinor transformation to a real representation (Majorana 1937). To see this, note that (7.4) implies 1 A 1 A = ε (A+ )−1 ε−1 A∗ and since 1 2
1 i1 A 1 −i1 Re A +Im A = =: SM (A) i1 1 A∗ −i1 1 −Im A Re A
(7.17)
we obtain the real Majorana representation SM (A) = U SC (A) U −1 of the spinor group, where the unitary equivalence operator is 1 1 iε U = √ . 2 i1 ε
(7.18)
(7.19)
µ µ −1 The Majorana representation of the γ-matrices γM = U γC U is purely imaginary 2 +σ −iσ 3 −i1 +iσ 1 0 1 2 3 γM = γM = γM = γM = −σ 2 +iσ 3 −i1 −iσ 1
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
136
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
5 γM
=
+i1
−i1
(7.20)
µν µ ν and thus the generators σM = 14 [γM , γM ] are indeed all real, as is the spinor transformation 1 µν SM (A) = exp αµν σM . 2 µ µ Hence, the Dirac operator iγM ∂µ −m is real, and also in the Dirac equation (iγM ∂µ − m)ψM = 0 we can restrict the spinor ψM = U ψ to the real subspace. Consequently, such Majorana particles do not couple to the electromagnetic field. For the rest of this section we only consider the Majorana representation, and so we can afford to omit the subscript M in what follows. Let us collect the main properties of the γ-matrices in the Majorana representation; they are purely imaginary, i.e. (γ µ ) ∗ = −γ µ , and behave as (γ 0 ) ∼ = −γ 0 and (γ k ) ∼ = +γ k under transposition, or
γ 0 (γ µ ) ∼ γ 0 = −γ µ .
(7.21)
We now introduce the real matrix C = iγ0
(7.22)
having the same properties (7.13) as the charge conjugation matrix; also the properties (7.14) are reproduced with this choice. Though a misnomer, it is for these reasons that the matrix (7.22) is also called the charge conjugation matrix and denoted as such. Since C(σ µν )∼ C −1 = −σ µν , we have 1 C S(A)∼ C −1 = exp − α µν σµν = S(A)−1 2 and so we define the adjoint spinor in the Majorana representation by ψ¯ = ψ ∼ C.
(7.23)
This is also a real quantity with the transformation law −1 ¯ S(A)ψ = ψS(A)
and thus the inner product ψ¯ χ is invariant against spinor transformations in the real representation (which form a subgroup of Sp(4), the symplectic group in four dimensions). 7.3
Neutrinos
The neutrino was postulated by Pauli in the year 1931 in order to explain the spectrum of what is called the β-decay, i.e., the decay of the neutron into a proton, an electron, and a (anti) neutrino: n → p + e + ν¯.
(7.24)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Neutral Fermions
137
It is a particle of spin 1/2, which is neutral and so does not participate in electromagnetic interactions. But a quarter of a century had to pass before the neutrino was detected in 1956 by Reines and Cowan. Furthermore, only ‘left’ handed neutrinos are observed in nature, their ‘right’ handed partners being absent; hence, parity invariance is broken in weak interactions (Lee and Yang 1957). In addition, until quite recently, these neutrinos were believed to be strictly massless; nowadays one assumes that at least some of the three known species of neutrinos νe , νµ and ντ have a (tiny) mass. Another basic problem is whether a neutrino is identical with its antiparticle or not; for nearly half a century it was taken for safe that it is not, but this is again an open question at present. Though one could argue that it should make no difference whether a mass is strictly or only almost zero, nevertheless, this tiny difference turns out to be of crucial importance. We begin with the strictly massless case so that the Dirac equation reads iγ µ ∂µ ψ = 0. Because γ 5 anticommutes with the massless Dirac operator, γ 5 ψ is a solution of the Dirac equation if ψ is. Since (γ 5 )2 = 1, it follows that ±1 are the only eigenvalues; accordingly, we classify the solutions by means of their γ 5 -eigenvalues, viz. γ 5 ψR = +ψR
γ 5 ψL = −ψL .
(7.25) 5
An element of the subspace of Dirac spinors with eigenvalue +1 (−1) of γ is said to be of positive (negative) chirality; the reason for the denotation with the subscripts R and L will be explained in a moment. The operators 1 1 PR = (1 + γ 5 ) PL = (1 − γ 5 ) (7.26) 2 2 are projection operators onto the subspaces of positive and negative chirality, respectively, with the requisite properties (PL )2 = PL
PL PR = 0
(PR )2 = PR
(7.27)
and PL + PR = 1.
(7.28)
In the Cartan representation, PR projects onto the upper components, and PL onto the lower ones. Hence, in the massless case, the Dirac equation decouples into the direct sum of subspaces with positive and negative chirality. In the massive case, such a decoupling is not available since the upper and lower components get mixed through the mass term. The decoupling can explicitly be seen in Fourier space; this kind of approach has the added virtue that it is independent of the choice of a special representation. The momentum vector for positive or negative energy is ! ±|k| k± = (7.29) k
April 8, 2013
14:15
138
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
and we must consider 6 k ± ψ (±) (k) = 0, which we write in the form ˆ · α ψ (±) (k) = ±ψ (±) (k) ˆ = k/|k|. k : k Let us introduce the (hermitian) spin matrices Σ1 = Σ23 =
i 2 3 1 γ γ = 2 2
where Σµν = iσ µν ; they obey
1 σ
σ1
,···
(7.30)
1 5 k γ α = Σk 2 as the reader should verify, and we thus find ˆ · Σ ψ (±) (k) = ±γ 5 ψ (±) (k). 2k
(7.31)
(7.32)
The operator to the left is two times the projection of the spin onto the threemomentum; one also calls the quantity 2Σ the helicity operator and its eigenvalues 2s3 the helicity. Hence, in the massless case, this equation tells us that for particles chirality equals helicity, whereas for antiparticles chirality is equal to minus helicity. Let us return to the Cartan representation of the γ-matrices, in which γ 5 is diagonal; it is also called the Weyl representation since this two-component theory of the neutrino is due to him (Weyl 1929). We choose the ‘rest’ frame to be ±1 ◦ 0 k± = (7.33) 0 1
and can thus construct the two solutions 1 ◦ 0 u(+) (k, +1/2) = 0 0
of helicity +1, and the two solutions 0 ◦ 0 u(+) (k, −1/2) = 0 1
0 ◦ 1 u(−) (k, −1/2) = 0
(7.34)
0 ◦ 0 u(−) (k, +1/2) = 1 0
(7.35)
0
of helicity −1. The first set is composed of the left-handed neutrino νL and its antiparticle ν¯R , and the second of the right-handed neutrino νR and its antiparticle ν¯L ; in both cases, the particle and the corresponding antiparticle are different. We restrict the further discussion to the solutions of positive chirality. They define a theory being invariant under Lorentz transformations since the spinor transformation SC (A) is block diagonal, and so the two different chiralities do not get mixed. Furthermore, the action Z S = dx ϕ+ i(∂0 − σ · ∇)ϕ (7.36)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Neutral Fermions
book
139
where ϕ denotes the upper 2-component spinor, is also invariant under Lorentz transformations ϕ(x) 7→ Aϕ(Λ−1 x), and the field equations are i(∂0 − σ · ∇)ϕ = 0.
(7.37)
Hence, it is legitimate to make the restriction to the left-handed neutrino νL and its antiparticle ν¯R with positive chirality, being strictly massless. An unnatural feature of the two-component Weyl neutrinos consists in the fact that ϕ is complex so that such neutrinos may be coupled to the electromagnetic field, at least in principle. This option is not available for fermions obeying the condition ψ c = ψ, which we call Majorana fermions. As we shall show later (see sec. 10.3.4), they can also have a nonzero mass. To summarize, it appears that such Majorana fermions should constitute the more natural realization of neutrinos.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Chapter 8
SYMMETRIES AND CONSERVATION LAWS
Having available the basic facts about the symmetries of Minkowski space and the symmetries of fields defined over there, we can now turn to the investigation of conservation laws. They are provided by the so called Noether theorem, according to which conserved quantities are obtained as a sole consequence of the symmetry properties of the corresponding action. In the following, we denote by φ an N -component field which, for notational convenience, is mostly taken to be real; the modifications that are needed for a complex field will be considered afterwards. Furthermore, we assume the Lagrangian L(φ, ∂φ) to be given a priori so that we have the action Z 1 S= dx L(φ, ∂φ) (8.1) c V where V is an arbitrary 4-dimensional volume. Consider then an infinitesimal transformation x → x′ = x + ∆x of Minkowski space and the corresponding infinitesimal transformation of the field φ, which we write in the passive form φ(x) → φ′ (x′ ) = φ(x) + ∆φ(x).
(8.2)
In order to explain the notation, we use Taylor expansion for φ′ (x′ ) = φ′ (x + ∆x), giving φ′ (x′ ) = φ′ (x) + ∂µ φ(x)∆xµ
(8.3)
where, for the second term on the right side, we have omitted the prime on φ since this contribution is already of first order. The corresponding active transformation (with δx = ∆x) yields δφ(x) = φ′ (x) − φ(x) = ∆φ(x) − ∂µ φ(x)∆xµ .
(8.4)
Here it is essential to note that, for the more basic active transformation, the argument of the field φ′ (x) remains unaltered since it only makes sense to compare fields at the same point. To give an example, let φ be complex and choose the transformed field to be ′ φ (x) = e−iα φ(x); in this case the space-time point remains unaltered, and so the 141
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
142
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
active and passive transformation coincide. A more complicated example is the Poincar´e transformation with φ′ (x′ ) = D(A)φ(x)
: x′ = Λx + a.
For a translation this gives δφ(x) = −∂µ φ(x)δaµ
(8.5)
∆φ(x) = 0.
(8.6)
whereas
For a Lorentz transformation we have 1 δφ(x) = (Σµν + (xµ ∂ν − xν ∂µ )) φ(x)δαµν (8.7) 2 and this yields 1 ∆φ(x) = Σµν φ(x)δαµν ∆xµ = δαµ ν xν (8.8) 2 where the Σµν denote here collectively the infinitesimal generators of Lorentz transformations in the chosen representation D(A) of the universal covering group. They are given by A 0 D(A) = 1 D(A) = D(A) = Λ (8.9) 0 (A+ )−1 for s = 0, 12 , 1 in this order. Note that an active variation δ generally commutes with partial differentiation, viz. δ∂ = ∂δ
(8.10)
since ∂φ(x) → ∂φ(x) + δ(∂φ(x)) = ∂φ′ (x) = ∂φ(x) + ∂δφ(x). By contrast, for a passive variation ∆ we infer from ∂µ′ φ′ (x′ ) − ∂µ φ(x) = ∆(∂µ φ(x)) =
∂xν ∂ν (φ(x) + ∆φ(x)) − ∂µ φ(x) ∂x′µ
and ∂xν = δµ ν − ∂µ ∆xν ∂x′µ
(8.11)
that ∆(∂µ φ) = ∂µ (∆φ) + (∆∂µ )φ
: ∆(∂µ ) = −∂µ (∆xν )∂ν
(8.12)
and so the passive variation does not commute with partial differentiation. The fact that the active variation commutes with partial differentiation was considered by A. Sommerfeld (in the context of classical mechanics) as a teleological principle; as we see, it follows from the definitions.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Symmetries and Conservation Laws
book
143
For the Lagrangian, we use the passive version of the transformation in the form L(x) = L(φ(x), ∂φ(x)) → L(φ′ (x′ ), ∂ ′ φ′ (x′ )) = L′ (x′ )
(8.13)
so that the action is mapped into ′ Z Z Z ∂x (x) ′ ′ 1 1 1 ′ ′ ′ ′ L (x (x)). (8.14) S= dx L(x) → S = dx L (x ) = dx c V c V′ c V ∂x For the evaluation, we expand
L′ (x′ ) = L′ (x) + ∂µ L(x)δxµ
where L′ (x) = L(x) + δL(x) and begin with with the determination of δL(x), which can be written ∂L ∂L δφ + δ∂µ φ ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) ∂L ∂L ∂L = − ∂µ δφ + ∂µ δφ . ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) ∂(∂µ φ)
δL =
For the action S′ = we then obtain 1 δS = c where
1 c Z
Z
dx(1 + ∂ν δxν ) (L + δL + ∂µ Lδxµ ) = S + δS
V
dx V
∂L ∂L − ∂µ ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) πµ =
δφ + ∂µ (π δφ + Lδx ) µ
µ
∂L . ∂(∂µ φ)
(8.15)
It is of crucial relevance to note that we have not omitted any boundary term. If we assume the Euler-Lagrange equations to be fulfilled, we can write the final result in the form Z 1 δS = − dx ∂µ δJµ c V where for the active variation
δJµ = −(π µ δφ + Lδxµ )
(8.16)
and in terms of the passive variation δJµ = (π µ ∂ ν φ − g µν L)∆xν − π µ ∆φ.
(8.17)
¯ µ − g µν L)∆xν − (¯ δJµ = (¯ π µ ∂ ν φ + ∂ ν φπ π µ ∆φ + ∆φπ µ )
(8.18)
In case that the field φ is complex, let φ¯ denote the complex conjugate field or, for a spinor, the Dirac adjoint; then the result corresponding to (8.16) is
April 8, 2013
14:15
144
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
where now πµ =
∂L ¯ ∂(∂µ φ)
∂L =π ¯µ . ∂(∂µ φ)
(8.19)
In the following we assume that the action is strictly invariant under the transformation x → x + δx and φ → φ + δφ so that the 4-divergence of the (infinitesimal) ‘current’ vanishes since V is arbitrary, i.e. ∂µ δJµ = 0.
(8.20)
This is the content of the Noether theorem. Let us distinguish between an internal symmetry, where the argument x of the field remains unaffected, and an external symmetry, where the change of the argument is nonzero. We begin with an internal symmetry, the simplest example of which is provided by a complex one-component Klein-Gordon field, the correctly normalized action of which reads Z 1 dx ~2 ∂µ ϕ∗ ∂ µ ϕ − m2 c2 ϕ∗ ϕ (8.21) S= 2mc
in the massive case. It is invariant under the substitution ϕ(x) → e−iα ϕ(x), giving the conserved current i~ ∗ µ Jµ = e (ϕ ∂ ϕ − ∂ µ ϕ∗ ϕ). (8.22) 2m Another example is provided by the Dirac field with the action Z µ ¯ S= dx ψ(i~γ ∂µ − mc)ψ (8.23) being invariant as well against multiplication of the spinor by a phase factor; here ¯ µ : π ¯ µ = i~cψγ
δJ µ = −¯ π µ δψ yields the current
1 µ ¯ µψ J = eψγ (8.24) c which we have obtained already earlier by different means. It is worthwhile to note that this current is a formally real quantity. A generalization is obtained on considering more complicated phase factors of the form a
U (α) = e−iα
Ua
where the Ua are hermitian N × N -matrices and the αa real parameters; then these matrix-valued phase factors are unitary since U (α)+ = U (α)−1 holds. We know by now that such a construct is intimately related to the concept of a Lie group; in the present case, this is the group SU (N ) if the generators Ua with a = 1, . . . , N 2 − 1 are taken to be traceless. So let us assume the Dirac wave function to have N
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Symmetries and Conservation Laws
book
145
components, i.e. each ψ A represents a 4-component Dirac spinor, and take the inner product to be X (ψ + )A ψ ′A . ψ+ ψ′ = A
Then the action (8.23) is invariant against the substitution ψ → U (α)ψ and the corresponding additional currents are 1 µ ¯ µ Ua ψ J a = q ψγ (8.25) c being N 2 − 1 in number. As we shall see later, at the quantized level the charges Z Qa = d3 x ψ + Ua ψ
also reflect the Lie algebra commutation relations. An internal symmetry of a rather different origin is encountered on considering the Maxwell field, which is invariant under gauge transformations; we postpone the discussion of such a type of symmetry at a later stage. Let us turn to external symmetry transformations, the prime example of which is Poincar´e symmetry. Recall that this is the symmetry group of our space-time, the Minkowski space, and the field equations are constructed such that they are invariant against Poincar´e transformations. As the reader should verify, also the corresponding action is (strictly) invariant under the substitution (8.14) for Poincar´e transformations. We begin with translations, the nonlinear part of a Poincar´e transformation; in this case the transformation law of the field is given by (8.6), and from (8.18) we then read off the conserved current δJµ = Pµν δaν the explicit form of which is ¯ µ ) − g µν L Pµν = (¯ π µ ∂ ν φ + ∂ ν φπ
: ∂µ Pµν = 0.
(8.26)
This second-rank tensor is called the canonical energy momentum tensor ; in general, it is not symmetric in its upper indices. Turning to the linear subgroup of the Poincar´e group, under a Lorentz transformation the field behaves according to (8.8); hence, we infer from (8.18) that 1 µ νρ ¯ νρ π µ )δανρ δJµ = Pµν δανρ xρ − (¯ π Σ φ + φ¯Σ 2 1 ¯ νρ π µ ) δανρ = (Pµν xρ − Pµρ xν ) − (¯ π µ Σνρ φ + φ¯Σ 2 1 = − Mµνρ δανρ 2 and so we obtain the conserved angular momentum tensor Mµνρ = − (Pµν xρ − Pµρ xν ) + Sµνρ
: ∂µ Mµνρ = 0
(8.27)
April 8, 2013
14:15
146
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
which is antisymmetric in the indices ν and ρ by construction. It is composed of an external and an internal part, the latter one ¯ νρ π µ Sµνρ = π ¯ µ Σνρ φ + φ¯Σ
(8.28)
being called the spin density; the reason is that the quantity Z 1 νρ S = dσµ Sµνρ c
(8.29)
Σ
with Σ a spacelike hypersurface in M can be identified as the total spin of the field. Analogously, from the energy-momentum tensor and the angular momentum tensor we can construct the quantities Z Z 1 1 µν νρ ν dσµ P M = dσµ Mµνρ (8.30) P = c c Σ
Σ
However, as opposed to the total spin, these are conserved in time and can be identified as the total momentum and angular momentum of the field. The conservation laws admit the following interpretation where, for simplicity, the field is chosen to be real. The 4-divergence of the energy-momentum tensor is calculated to be ∂L ∂L µν ∂µ P = − − ∂µ ∂ν φ (8.31) ∂φ ∂(∂µ φ) and so we see that the validity of the Euler-Lagrange equations implies the invariance under translations. For the angular momentum tensor we have ∂µ Mµνρ = Pνρ − Pρν + ∂µ Sµνρ if the equations of motion are used; hence, invariance under Lorentz transformations is equivalent to the equations ∂µ Sµνρ = −(Pνρ − Pρν )
(8.32)
which relate the 4-divergence of the spin density to the antisymmetric part of the energy-momentum tensor. Let us determine the canonical energy-momentum tensor for fields of spin less than or equal to one. We begin with the complex Klein-Gordon field, the energymomentum tensor of which is ~2 (∂ µ ϕ∗ ∂ ν ϕ + ∂ ν ϕ∗ ∂ µ ϕ) − g µν L. (8.33) 2m It is symmetric; in particular, the zero-zero component yields the Hamiltonian density. The symmetry property of the canonical energy-momentum tensor is no longer valid for the Dirac field, the Lagrangian of which we now take to be (cf. (8.23)) Pµν =
L=
i~c ¯ µ ¯ µ ψ) − mc2 ψψ ¯ (ψγ ∂µ ψ − ∂µ ψγ 2
(8.34)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Symmetries and Conservation Laws
book
147
in order to obtain real conserved quantities; the energy-momentum tensor then is i~c ¯ µ ν ¯ µ ψ) − g µν L Pµν = (ψγ ∂ ψ − ∂ ν ψγ (8.35) 2 but this is asymmetric. We furthermore need the spin density i~c ¯ µ νρ ψ(γ Σ + Σνρ γ µ )ψ (8.36) Sµνρ = 2 ¯ µν = −Σµν ; note also that the spin where we have taken care of the property Σ density is totally antisymmetric, being due to the identity i{γ µ , Σνρ } = εµνρ σ γ 5 γ σ . For the Maxwell field with the action Z 1 1 µν S = dx − Fµν F c 4 we obtain from 1 1 µν δ − F Fµν = − F µν (δ(∂µ Aν ) − δ(∂ν Aµ )) = −F µν δ(∂µ Aν ) 4 2 that ∂L π µν = = −F µν ∂(∂µ Aν )
(8.37)
(8.38)
and thus the scalar potential is not a dynamical degree of freedom since the zerozero component of the field strength tensor vanishes. For the canonical energymomentum tensor we then obtain 1 (8.39) Pµν = π µ τ ∂ ν Aτ − g µν L = −F µρ ∂ ν Aρ + g µν F ρτ Fρτ 4 which is neither symmetric, nor gauge invariant; furthermore, we have Sµνρ = −F µν Aρ + F µρ Aν
(8.40)
for the spin density of the Maxwell field. To summarize, the canonical energy-momentum tensor has some unpleasant features. In particular, for the Maxwell field it is not gauge invariant, and this is an unacceptable result at least at the classical level. Nevertheless, as is concerning the transition to the Hamilton formalism, the energy density will turn out to be correct; the same remark applies to the Dirac field. We shall have to return to this remark at a later stage. The canonical energy-momentum tensor can be symmetrized by means of a method, in essence being due to Belinfante 1939. For this purpose, we pass to Tµν = Pµν + ∂ρ χµρν
: +χµρν = −χρµν
(8.41)
where the third-rank tensor χµνρ has to be determined; its symmetry properties are chosen such that if Pµν is conserved, then also the new energy-momentum tensor is. Furthermore, from Z Z Z 1 1 1 d3 x T0ν = P ν + d3 x ∂ρ χ0ρν = P ν + dσk χ0kν c V3 c V3 c ∂V 3
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
148
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
we conclude that the total momentum remains unaltered if χ0kν vanishes on the boundary of the 3-dimensional volume, what is taken for granted. For the angular momentum tensor, this transition implies Mµντ = xν Tµτ − xτ Tµν − xν ∂ρ χµρτ + xτ ∂ρ χµρν + Sµντ
= xν Tµτ − xτ Tµν + χµντ − χµτ ν + Sµντ − ∂ρ (xν χµρτ − xτ χµρν )
and in the same vein as for the energy-momentum tensor, we pass to Jµντ = Mµντ + ∂ρ (xν χµτ ρ − xτ χµνρ )
(8.42)
Furthermore, we impose the condition Sµντ = −(χµντ − χµτ ν ),
(8.43)
Jµντ = xν Tµτ − xτ Tµν
(8.44)
in order to achieve that
holds; then the angular momentum is indeed the ‘moment of the momenta’. For this improved angular momentum tensor the conservation law, i.e. Lorentz invariance, is now equivalent to the symmetry of the improved energy-momentum tensor. The further virtue is that (8.43) can be solved to give 1 χµντ = − (Sµντ − Sτ µν + Sντ µ ) (8.45) 2 and so the additional degree of freedom brought in by (8.41) is entirely determined by the spin density. Let us apply the symmetrization procedure to the examples considered above. For the spinless Klein-Gordon field, the energy-momentum tensor is already symmetric, so that we are done. Turning to the Dirac field, in this case the spin density is totally antisymmetric, and we immediately find i~c ¯ µ ν ρ 1 ψ(γ γ γ + γ ρ γ ν γ µ )ψ. (8.46) χµρν = − Sµρν = 2 8 The calculation of the 4-divergence then yields i~c ν ¯ µ ¯ ν ψ − ψγ ¯ µ ∂ ν ψ + ψγ ¯ ν ∂ µψ ∂ ψγ ψ − ∂ µ ψγ (8.47) ∂ρ χµρν = 4 where we have assumed the validity of the equations of motion. Under the same assumption, the symmetric energy-momentum tensor follows to be i~c ¯ µ ν ¯ ν ∂ µ ψ − ∂ µ ψγ ¯ ν ψ − ∂ ν ψγ ¯ µψ Tµν = ψγ ∂ ψ + ψγ (8.48) 4 which shows that this is simply the symmetrization of the canonical energymomentum tensor: Tµν = P(µν) .
(8.49)
Proceeding to the Maxwell field, from (8.45) we infer χµνρ = F µν Aρ
(8.50)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Symmetries and Conservation Laws
149
which, on using the equations of motion, yields 1 Tµν = −F µρ F ν ρ + g µν F ρτ Fρτ . (8.51) 4 This is the well-known symmetric energy-momentum tensor of the Maxwell theory; it has the further virtue of being traceless. Here, the components 1 T0k = (E × B)k (8.52) T00 = (E 2 + B 2 ) 2 are the energy density and the Poynting vector, and the space-components 1 Tij = (E i E j + B i B j ) − δ ij (E 2 + B 2 ) (8.53) 2 are known as the Maxwell stress tensor. The situation is entirely different for interacting fields, and the discussion below will show that the rˆ ole of the symmetrization procedure is rather subtle. For this, we consider the coupled system of the Dirac and Maxwell field, the coupling being implemented by means of the minimal substitution Z i~ ¯ µ 1 µν µ 2¯ SMG = dx (ψγ Dµ ψ − Dµ ψγ ψ) − mc ψψ − F Fµν (8.54) 2 4c
where SMG = SM + SG , with the subscript M standing for matter and G for gauge field, and ie Dµ = ∂µ + Aµ . (8.55) ~c The symmetrization procedure only applies to a closed system, so we know that the total energy-momentum tensor TMG µν = PM µν + ∂ρ χM µρν + PG µν + ∂ρ χG µρν µνρ
(8.56) µνρ
is symmetric by construction. Since the spin densities SM and SG are not affected by the coupling, the ‘potentials’ χM µρν and χG µρν are again given by (8.46) and (8.50); but their divergence is altered since the equations of motion for the matter and the gauge field are different now. We find for the matter part ∂ρ χM µρν =
and so
(8.57)
i~c ν ¯ µ ¯ ν ψ − ψγ ¯ µ ∂ ν ψ + ψγ ¯ ν ∂ µ ψ − 1 (J µ Aν − J ν Aµ ) ∂ ψγ ψ − ∂ µ ψγ 4 2c PM µν + ∂ρ χM µρν =
(8.58)
i~c ¯ µ ν ¯ ν Dµ ψ − Dµ ψγ ν ψ − Dν ψγ µ ψ − 1 J µ Aν ψγ D ψ + ψγ 4 c which, due to the last term, is not symmetric. A similar remark applies to the gauge field part with 1 1 (8.59) PG µν + ∂ρ χG µρν = −F µρ F ν ρ + g µν Fρτ F ρτ + J µ Aν 4 c
April 8, 2013
14:15
150
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
where the last term destroys both the symmetry property and gauge invariance. The way out consists in defining the energy-momentum tensor TG µν for the gauge field by the standard form (8.51), the symmetry of which is manifest. Accordingly, for the matter part we must define TM µν = PM µν + ∂ρ χM µρν +
1 µ ν J A c
(8.60)
which is then also symmetric since in TMG µν = TM µν + TG µν
(8.61)
both the MG- and G-part are; this follows as well from the explicit form i~c ¯ µ ν ¯ ν Dµ ψ − Dµ ψγ ν ψ − Dν ψγ µ ψ . TM µν = (8.62) ψγ D ψ + ψγ 4 But note, however, that the symmetric energy-momentum tensor (8.60) of matter neither is the symmetrization in the Belinfante sense, nor does it yield the total momentum of the matter part. The reason is the last term in (8.60), which identifies the symmetric energy-momentum tensor of the matter part as the classical analogue of the minimal substitution prescription. A deeper geometric foundation of the symmetrization procedure, being due to Hilbert, will be given later (see sec. 11.8) in the general relativistic context.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Chapter 9
DIFFERENTIAL AND INTEGRAL CALCULUS FOR ANTICOMMUTING VARIABLES Up to now we have not taken at face one crucial fact, namely, that in the domain of field theory one must also deal with anticommuting variables. They come in through the mere existence of fermions, as explained in sec. 5.6, and so one has to cope with the problem to develop calculational tools for handling such quantities. Indeed, what must be viewed as one of the decisive achievements, having been gained in the second half of the twentieth century, is the creation of a differential and integral calculus for anticommuting variables. In particular, J. Schwinger shared many of the essential insights in the treatment of anticommuting variables, but the ultimate breakthrough came not until the year 1966 with the work of the Russian mathematical physicist F. Berezin, who was courageous enough to invent calculational rules in dealing with such entities (Berezin (1966)). It is the purpose of the present chapter to acquaint the reader with these tools. We attempt this at a relatively early stage in order to become familiar with these techniques; they form part of the standard repertoire in modern field theory.
9.1
Real Grassmann Variables
A key to the understanding of fermions is provided by the insight that n real variables xi may abstractly be viewed as an algebra with generators xi and relations xi xj − xj xi = 0 since this description is sufficient for many purposes; in particular, a differential and integral calculus of such variables (generators) can be developed (see the later chap. 48), which is independent of the existence of an inverse and a limiting procedure. In the same spirit, a unital associative algebra over the reals with n generators ξ i that are subject to the relations ξi ξj + ξj ξi = 0
: i, j = 1, . . . , n
(9.1)
is called a Grassmann algebra, denoted by Gn . By contrast with the conventional case, these generators (variables) anticommute; in particular, the relations entail that they are nilpotent, i.e. (ξ i )2 = 0. The general polynomial in such ‘odd’ 151
April 8, 2013
14:15
152
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
variables or indeterminates takes the form n X 1 f (ξ) = fi1 ···ip ξ i1 · · · ξ ip p ! p=0
(9.2)
where the real coefficients fi1 ···ip are totally antisymmetric in their indices; the term with p = 0, denoted by f0 , is the one proportional to the unit. Furthermore, the sum terminates at n since higher products in the ξs vanish. The number of independent terms on the right-hand side is easily counted; for this it is convenient to pass to the basis (ξ 1 )θ1 · · · (ξ n )θn (9.3) Pn n with θi ∈ {0, 1}, which gives p=0 p = 2n independent terms. Clearly, Gn is an algebra since two functions of the form (9.2) can be multiplied. In order to define a differential calculus for these variables, it is natural to assume that the algebraic operator of differentiation is also an odd quantity, and so we require the rule ∂ i1 ξ · · · ξ ip = δ i1 i ξ i2 · · · ξ ip − ξ i1 δ i2 i ξ i3 · · · ξ ip + · · ·+ (−1)p−1 ξ i1 · · · ξ ip−1 δ ip i (9.4) ∂ξ i to hold. What we aim at now is to develop an integral calculus over such variables. First of all, an integral is a linear map J : Gn → R which to f ∈ Gn assigns a real number. This map is also written in the form Z J(f ) = d n ξ f (ξ) (9.5)
as if the ξ i were really variables; here, however, the differential d n ξ is just a symbol. Let us first restrict ourselves to one Grassmann variable; in this case, the polynomial takes the simple form f (ξ) = f0 + f1 ξ. Furthermore, the integral is required to be invariant against translations ξ ′ = ξ + η with η another Grassmann variable that anticommutes with ξ, viz. Z Z ′ dξ f (ξ ) = dξ f (ξ). As should be noted, no transformation law of the differential gets involved here. The explicit form of this invariance property reads Z Z dξ(f0 + f1 ξ) = dξ ((f0 + f1 η) + f1 ξ)
so that the condition is met with the choice Z dξ = 0
Z
dξ ξ = 1.
(9.6)
These two equations are the defining Berezin rules of integration for one Grassmann variable. In particular, they entail Z d dξ f (ξ) = f1 = f (ξ) (9.7) dξ
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
book
153
and thus integration is identical to the effect of differentiation, whereas in the standard case with numerical variables, integration is inverse to the process of differentiation. One cannot expect something similar in the present situation as the derivative operator is nilpotent, so there is no inverse operation. It will also be of interest to investigate the behaviour of the Berezin integral under a homogeneous transformation, which in the 1-dimensional case is simply the multiplication by a real number a 6= 0; using the definition, we have Z Z d d dξ f (aξ) = f (aξ) = a f (ξ) = a dξ f (ξ). (9.8) dξ dξ The latter result should be contrasted with the corresponding property of the conventional improper integral Z∞
dx f (x)
−∞
being assumed to be well defined; in that case one has instead Z∞
−∞
1 dx f (ax) = a
Z∞
−∞
1 dx f (x ) = a ′
′
Z∞
: x′ = ax.
dx f (x)
−∞
Hence, even in the 1-dimensional case, there is a characteristic change in that the fermionic integral transforms opposite to the conventional one since the prefactor a−1 is replaced by a, the inverse. These rather bizarre rules can be generalized to the case with n degrees of freedom. We now revert the above procedure and begin with the sole requirement Z ∂n d n ξ f (ξ) = f (ξ) = f1···n (9.9) ∂ξ n · · · ∂ξ 1 which can also be written in the form ( Z 0 d n ξ ξ i1 · · · ξ ip = εi1 ···in
: p
.
(9.10)
Alternatively, we could impose translational invariance in the form J(T (η)f ) = J(f ) with T (η)f (ξ) = f (ξ + η), i.e. Z Z d n ξ f (ξ + η) = d n ξ f (ξ) (9.11) which, with a similar argument as in the 1-dimensional case, results in the rules (9.10) before. In particular, they entail the property Z ∂ d n ξ i f (ξ) = 0. (9.12) ∂ξ saying that such a ‘boundary integral’ vanishes.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
154
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Of course, the reasoning that the request for translational invariance uniquely determines the Berezin integration rules is heuristic, at best. The flaw in the argument consists in the assumption that J is a map J : Gn → R since T (η)f is also η-valued. We shall later give (in sec. 48.5) a rigorous argument. Finally, let us investigate the behaviour under homogeneous transformations ξ i 7→ ξ ′i = Ai k ξ k where the determinant |A| of the real matrix A is supposed to be nonzero. According to the definition of the determinant, we have ξ ′1 · · · ξ ′n = A1 i1 · · · An in ξ i1 · · · ξ in = A1 i1 · · · An in εi1 ···in ξ 1 · · · ξ n = |A|ξ 1 · · · ξ n and we thus conclude that Z
d n ξ f (Aξ) = |A|
Z
d n ξ f (ξ).
(9.13)
Consequently, as opposed to the conventional case where +∞ +∞ +∞ Z Z Z n n ′ ∂x ′ −1 d x f (Ax) = d x f (x ) = |A| d n x f (x) ∂x′
−∞
−∞
−∞
the Berezin integral transforms with the determinant, and not its inverse. One should note that the affine transformations ξ 7→ Aξ + η constitute the natural symmetry group of the Grassmann algebra since they leave the defining relations (9.1) intact, as the reader is urged to verify. As an application, we may then turn to the discussion of the fermionic Gaussian integral which, according to our conventions, is taken to be Z 1 (9.14) d n ξ e− 2 ξ · Aξ
where ξ · η = ξ i gij η j ; the metric metric is here chosen to be gij = δij , but could also be more general. The anticommutativity property of the generators requires ξ · Aξ = ξi Ai k ξ k = −ξ k Ai k ξi = −ξk A·i k· ξ i
so that the matrix A must be antisymmetric with respect to the metric. As known, for n = 2m even there exists a special orthogonal matrix O, i.e. O∼ = O−1 with |O| = 1, such that (see app. 9.4 below for a proof) a1 J 0 · · · 0 . ◦ 0 . . . . . . .. 0 −1 −1 A = OAO = . : J = (9.15) +1 0 .. . . . . . . 0 0 · · · 0 am J
saying that a skewsymmetric matrix can be skew diagonalized; we may assume a1 , . . . , am ≥ 0. Introducing the notation f (ξ, A) = exp − 12 ξ · Aξ, we thus find Z Z Z Z ◦ ◦ ◦ 1 d n ξ f (ξ, A) = d n ξ f (Oξ, A) = |O| d n ξ f (ξ, A) = d n ξ e− 2 ξ·Aξ
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
book
155
◦
where eq. (9.13) was used. Since exp − 21 ξ · Aξ = (1 + a1 ξ 1 ξ 2 ) · · · (1 + am ξ n−1 ξ n ) ◦
we can isolate the top term fn (ξ, A) = a1 · · · am ξ 1 · · · ξ n , and so one arrives at the result Z 1 d n ξ e− 2 ξ · Aξ = a1 · · · am = |A|1/2 : A∼ = −A (9.16)
which defines the square root of an antisymmetric matrix; the restriction to an even n could also be dropped. An alternative version of the result (9.16) is obtained on expanding the integrand; this yields n/2 1 1 |A|1/2 = − εi1 j1 ···in/2 jn/2 Ai1 j1 · · · Ain/2 jn/2 . (9.17) 2 (n/2)! The right hand side defines what is called the Pfaffian of a skewsymmetric matrix. We shall reproduce the conventional approach to the Pfaffian in an appendix to this chapter. Let us collect some further basic formulae of Berezin’s calculus, the detailed verification of which is left to the reader. Up to now we have only defined what is called the left derivative, also denoted as ∂ − /∂ξ i , but we shall as well have need for the right derivative ∂ + /∂ξ i ; both can succinctly be defined by the variations δf = δξ i
∂+f i ∂−f = δξ i ∂ξ ∂ξ i
(9.18)
so that p X ∂ − i1 ip (ξ · · · ξ ) = (−1)q−1 ξ i1 · · · ξ iq−1 δ iq i ξ iq+1 · · · ξ ip ∂ξ i q=1
p X ∂ + i1 ip (ξ · · · ξ ) = (−1)p−q ξ i1 · · · ξ iq−1 δ iq i ξ iq+1 · · · ξ ip . ∂ξ i q=1
(9.19)
(9.20)
In order to avoid possible future confusion, let us stress that the variations (differences) δξ i are odd quantities. One then shows, two derivatives of the same type anticommute, and of opposite type commute: ∂ − ∂ −f ∂− ∂−f = − ∂ξ i ∂ξ j ∂ξ j ∂ξ i
∂+ ∂+f ∂ + ∂ +f = − ∂ξ i ∂ξ j ∂ξ j ∂ξ i
∂+ ∂−f ∂ − ∂ +f = + . ∂ξ i ∂ξ j ∂ξ j ∂ξ i
(9.21)
(9.22)
There is also a chain rule for functions f (g(ξ)) with ξ ′i = g i (ξ) available: ∂ − g j (ξ) ∂ − f (ξ ′ ) ∂ − f (g(ξ)) = ∂ξ i ∂ξ i ∂ξ ′j
∂ + f (g(ξ)) ∂ + f (ξ ′ ) ∂ + g j (ξ) = . ∂ξ i ∂ξ ′j ∂ξ i
(9.23)
We now define an involution, denoted by an asterisk, as follows p (ξ i1 · · · ξ ip )∗ = ξ ip · · · ξ i1 = (−1)(2) ξ i1 · · · ξ ip
(9.24)
April 8, 2013
14:15
156
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
the effect of which thus is to reverse the order of factors; in case that the coefficients in the expansion (9.2) are allowed to take complex values, then the ∗-involution is meant to include a complex conjugation. For its action on derivatives one finds − ∗ + ∗ ∂ ∂+ ∗ ∂ ∂− f = f f = i f∗ (9.25) i i i ∂ξ ∂ξ ∂ξ ∂ξ so that the involution interchanges left and right derivatives. The algebra of functions can be equipped with a natural Z/2-grading. For this purpose, we write the elements of Z/2 as (−1)θ with θ = 0, 1. Let f have Grassmann parity θf , i.e. f (−ξ) = (−1)θf f (ξ); the product of two such functions thus obeys gf = (−1)θf θg f g
(9.26)
and its parity is θf g = θf + θg . For functions of definite parity, the two types of derivatives are related as follows: ∂ −f ∂+f = −(−1)θf . i ∂ξ ∂ξ i
(9.27)
Furthermore, there is a product rule of differentiation − ∂− ∂ −f θf ∂ g (f g) = g + (−1) f ∂ξ i ∂ξ i ∂ξ i
+ ∂+ ∂+g θg ∂ f (f g) = f + (−1) g ∂ξ i ∂ξ i ∂ξ i
which in turn yields for the integration by parts the formula Z Z ∂+f ∂−g d n ξ i g = d n ξf i ∂ξ ∂ξ
(9.28)
(9.29)
where the rule (9.12) was used; consequently, the restriction to functions of definite parity may be dropped. On the algebra of functions f one can introduce a sesquilinear inner product; an obvious choice appears to be Z hf1 |f2 i = d n ξ f1 (ξ)∗ f2 (ξ) (9.30)
since it is constructed in analogy with the conventional case. But unlike the latter, it has the drawback not to be hermitian. This follows from its explicit form hf |f ′ i =
p n X (−1)(2) ¯ fi1 ···ip εi1 ···ip ip+1 ···in fi′p+1 ···in (n − p) !p ! p=0
(9.31)
n which entails that hf |f ′ i = (−1)( 2 ) hf ′ |f i; it could be made so upon multiplication n with (±i)( 2 ) , but even with this modification the inner product is indefinite. However, the inner product (9.30) is not the only one that can be introduced; there are other choices to be discussed. Consider now the operator ∂i− = ∂ − /∂ξ i ; applying the rules (9.25) and (9.29), we obtain Z Z Z hf1 |∂i− f2 i = d n ξ f1 (ξ)∗ ∂i− f2 (ξ) = d n ξ ∂i+ f1 (ξ)∗ f2 (ξ) = d n ξ (∂i− f1 (ξ))∗ f2 (ξ).
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
book
157
We thus find that hf1 |∂i− f2 i = h∂i− f1 |f2 i
(9.32)
and analogously for the right derivative. Hence, with respect to the above inner product, the left and right partial derivatives are selfadjoint operators - unlike conventional partial derivatives that are skew adjoint with respect to the standard inner product. In concluding, a word of caution is appropriate. As has become customary, one can interpret the result (9.13) by affiliating the determinant |A| to the ‘volume element’ d n ξ, and this may be achieved on imposing a further axiom, namely, that the integral be invariant against linear transformations ξ 7→ ξ ′ = Aξ; this requirement in conjunction with the basic result (9.13) gives Z Z Z d n ξ f (ξ ′ ) = |A| d n ξ f (ξ) = |A| d n ξ ′ f (ξ ′ ) and so we read off
d n ξ ′ = |A|−1 d n ξ
: ξ ′ = Aξ.
(9.33)
The volume element thus transforms with the inverse determinant of the Jacobian. But note, the derivation of the Gaussian integral, which is the only result one really needs, did not make use of the latter argument. If one accepts the formula (9.33) as valid, then one is indebted to give a proper definition of the volume element. It is tempting to interpret it as a product of differentials, i.e. d n ξ = dξ 1 · · · dξ n
(9.34)
and so one has to make a decision in which sense this product is to be understood. The transformation law (9.33) suggests that the differentials should anticommute among themselves in order to generate the determinant, in some way; but this conclusion is at variance with the property that it is the inverse of the determinant instead of the determinant which emerges. In order to escape this discrepancy, Berezin (Berezin (1979)), see also the footnote in Berezin (1987)) proposed to introduce two types of volume forms; he also distinguishes between two types of differentials, one sort of commuting and the other one of anticommuting type. As we shall argue later, however, there is no need for such a construction; a clear cut answer to the above conflict can only be given with some knowledge of rather advanced techniques, having been gained more recently in the context of what is known as ‘noncommutative geometry’. These matters will be treated in a chapter to come, and there we shall learn that the differentials dξ i must commute, as opposed to the differentials dxi of conventional variables which anticommute. For now we content ourselves with the motivating remark that both for commuting and anticommuting variables one wants to construct an operator d of exterior differentiation, which is designed to be an odd operator in order to guarantee the property
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
158
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
d 2 = 0 to hold; in the commuting case it has the form d = dxi ∂/∂xi so that the differentials must be odd, whereas in the anticommuting case with d = dξ i ∂/∂ξ i the differentials dξ i must be even since the variables ξ i are odd quantities now. But the differentials dξ i should not be confused with the finite differences (being denoted by δξ i in eq. (9.18)) that obtain in the context of Taylor expansion; such differences are odd quantities. Furthermore, the Berezin integral can be understood as what is known as a character ; this notion was invented by A. Connes and is a kind of integral calculus on a generally noncommutative algebra. In broad terms, it is a map subject to certain properties that assigns a number to a differential form over an algebra, and this is precisely the construction which is needed to define an integral over a function of anticommuting variables. Then there is also no conflict with the property that the differentials dξ i commute and that the inverse of the determinant appears in eq. (9.33); whereas in the conventional case with commuting variables the determinant comes from the antisymmetry of the volume element d n x = dx1 ∧ · · · ∧ dxn , in the case with anticommuting variables it is the antisymmetry of the derivatives ∂/∂ξ i (instead of the volume element d n ξ) where the determinant comes from. To resume, formulas such as ?
?
{dξ i , dξ j } = 0
{ξ i , dξ i } = 0
(9.35)
that notoriously make their appearance in the literature are simply invalid and should be dismissed. The same remark applies to another standard formula, which reads Z ? dξ i ξ j = δ ij (9.36)
If it were R true, this would imply that the Berezin integration, which is really a linear map : Gn → R only, could be defined by an iterative process. 9.2
Fourier Transformation
We assume, in addition to the Grassmann variables ξ i , a second set of Grassmann variables ηi to be given that anticommute with the ξs; one can then introduce the construct ξ · η = ξ i ηi which is an even quantity. We now define Fourier transformation by Z (F f )(η) = d n ξ eη·ξ f (ξ)
(9.37)
(9.38)
the explicit form of which is calculated to be (F f )(η) =
n X ¯ 1 ¯ (p i1 ···ip ip+1 ···in 2) f (−1)p+ ηip+1 · · · ηin i1 ···ip ε p ¯ !p ! p=0
(9.39)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
book
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
159
where here and below p¯ = n − p .
(9.40)
Introducing the so called Hodge dual, a construction known from the theory of differential forms, which is defined by 1 (∗fp )ip+1 ···in = fi1 ···ip εi1 ···ip ip+1 ···in (9.41) p! we obtain the slightly more succinct version n X ¯ 1 ¯ (p 2) (∗f )ip+1 ···in η (F f )(η) = (−1)p+ (9.42) p ip+1 · · · ηin . p ¯ ! p=0 For the ηs we choose the convention Z d n η ηn · · · η1 = 1
(9.43)
which, upon comparison with the inner product (9.31), yields Z Z n+1 n ∗ ′ ( ) 2 d ξ f (ξ) f (ξ) = (−1) d n η (F f )(η)∗ (F f ′ )(η).
(9.44)
with the reversed order, and so the inner product in Fourier space follows to be Z n (p) n X (−1) 2 d n η (F f )(η)∗ (F f ′ )(η) = (−1)n+( 2 ) fi∗1 ···ip εi1 ···ip ip+1 ···in fi′p+1 ···in p ¯ !p ! p=0
But let us reiterate, by contrast to conventional Fourier transformation, the inner product is indefinite. Turning to the inverse transformation, we take it to be Z n f (ξ) = (−1) d n η e ξ·η (F f )(η) (9.45)
so that
f (ξ) = (−1)n
Z
d nη
Z
′
d n ξ ′ e (ξ−ξ )·η f (ξ ′ ).
(9.46)
Here we encounter a twofold integral, where some care is required on interchanging the integrations. For ξ i with i ∈ {1, . . . , n} the generators of a Gn , and η j with j ∈ {1, . . . , m} those of a Gm , we have Z Z Z Z d m η d n ξ ξ 1 · · · ξ n η 1 · · · η m = 1 = (−1)n m d m η d n ξ η 1 · · · η m ξ 1 · · · ξ n
and in order to compensate for the sign factor in front, we decree the grassmannian version of Fubini’s theorem to read as Z Z Z Z m n nm n d η d ξ f (ξ, η) = (−1) d ξ d m η f (ξ, η). (9.47)
Returning to eq. (9.46), this gives rise to the definition of the fermionic analogue of Dirac’s δ-function Z ′ δ(ξ − ξ ′ ) = d n η e (ξ−ξ )·η = (−1)n (ξ − ξ ′ )1 · · · (ξ − ξ ′ )n (9.48)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
160
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
with the property f (ξ) =
Z
d n ξ ′ δ(ξ − ξ ′ )f (ξ ′ ).
(9.49)
Analogously, for the conjugate variables η the δ-function is Z ′ δ(η − η ′ ) = d n ξ e (η−η )·ξ = (−1)n (η − η ′ )n · · · (η − η ′ )1
(9.50)
Z
(9.51)
and satisfies
g(η) =
d n η ′ δ(η − η ′ )g(η ′ )
where g = F f . It is left to the reader to check that the conventions chosen are consistent. We are now able to determine the fermionic Fourier transform of a Gaussian, where the restriction to even dimensions is made. For 1
f (ξ) = e− 2 ξ·Aξ
: A∼ = −A, |A| 6= 0
we evaluate F f (η) =
Z
1
d n ξe− 2 ξ·Aξ+η·ξ
by completing the square, and using (9.16) the result is Z −1 1 1 1 d n ξ e− 2 ξ·Aξ+η·ξ = |A| 2 e− 2 η·A η .
(9.52)
(9.53)
(9.54)
Hence, the Fourier transform of a Gaussian is again a Gaussian. The observation made above that fermionic Fourier transformation is related to the Hodge dual, opens new vistas. Instead of (9.38) we now define Z ′ (F f )(ξ) = d n ξ ′ e ξ·ξ f (ξ ′ ) (9.55)
where ξ · ξ ′ = ξ i δij ξ ′j ; the difference, as compared to the earlier version (9.38), is that the primed ξs obey the same Berezin rules as the ξs do. With the definition (9.55) we have a map F : Gn → Gn , obeying n+1 F 2 = (−1)( 2 ) 1.
A new inner product can then be defined by Z Z n ′ (f |f ′ ) = (−1)( 2 ) d n ξ ′ d n ξ e ξ·ξ f (ξ)∗ f ′ (ξ ′ )
which is hermitian and also positive definite; these properties are manifest in the explicit form n X 1 ¯i1 ···ip ′ (f |f ′ ) = f fi1 ···ip (9.56) p ! p=0
where the raising and lowering of indices is performed by means of the Kronecker metric. The above scalar product is strongly reminiscent of that for conventional differential forms; we shall have occasion to return to these matters.
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
9.3
book
161
Complex Grassmann Variables
Let us address the complex case; the Grassmann algebra is now generated by 2n variables ci and c∗ i with i = 1, . . . , n. The antilinear involution ∗ supplies for an analogue of complex conjugation, i.e. (ci )∗ = c∗i ; furthermore, the action on products of generating elements is required to reverse the order of the factors, e.g. (ci cj )∗ = c∗j c∗i .
(9.57)
In order to simplify the writing we use the notation c¯i = δij c∗j ; furthermore, we introduce the product c¯ · c′ = c¯i c′i
(9.58)
which has the property that c¯ · c is even, and ‘real’ in the sense that (¯ c c)∗ = c¯ · c holds. For the general polynomial X 1 φ(¯ c, c) = c¯ip · · · c¯i1 φi1 ···ip j1 ···jq cj1 · · · cjq (9.59) p !q ! p,q we want to achieve that the finite difference operator (which should not be confused with the operator of exterior differentiation) takes the form δφ(¯ c, c) = δ¯ ci
∂φ i ∂φ + δc . ∂¯ ci ∂ci
(9.60)
It is for this reason that for the c¯i the left derivative ∂ c¯i · · · c¯ip = δ i i1 c¯i2 · · · c¯ip −δ i i2 c¯i1 c¯i3 · · · c¯ip +· · ·+(−1)p−1 δ i ip c¯i1 · · · c¯ip−1 . (9.61) ∂¯ ci 1 and for the ci the right derivative ∂ i1 c · · · cip = ∂ci
(9.62)
δ ip i ci1 · · · cip−1 − δ ip−1 i ci1 · · · cip−2 cip + · · · + (−1)p−1 δ i1 i ci2 · · · cip is chosen; the further requirements ∂ j ,c = 0 ∂¯ ci
∂ , c¯j ∂ci
=0
(9.63)
complete the definition. Let us turn to the Berezin integral over complex Grassmann variables; consistent rules are given by Z d n c c1 · · · cn = 1 Z (9.64) d n c¯ c¯n · · · c¯1 = 1
April 8, 2013
14:15
162
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
where, in the latter case, the variables being integrated over carry the opposite ordering. Introducing the notation d n (¯ c, c) = d n c¯ d n c, the normalization condition for the iterated integral is Z n Y d n (¯ c, c) ci c¯i = 1. (9.65) i=1
With this convention, the integral over the exponential function exp −¯ c · c can be done as follows. First note that X e−¯c·c = (1 + c1 c¯1 ) · · · (1 + cn c¯n ) = (c1 c¯1 )θ1 · · · (cn c¯n )θn (9.66) θ
where θi = 0, 1; we then obtain Z Z d n (¯ c, c) e−¯c·c = d n c¯ d n c (c1 c¯1 ) · · · (cn c¯n ) = 1 because only the term with θi = 1 for all i = 1, . . . , n gives a nonvanishing contribution. Now it is rather trivial to do the Berezin integral over the Gaussian exp−¯ c ·Ac; ′i i k with c = A k c we have Z Z ′ n −¯ c·Ac d (¯ c, c) e = d n (¯ c, c) e−¯c·c Z = d n c¯ d n c (c′1 c¯1 ) · · · (c′n c¯n ) Z = d n c c′1 · · · c′n where use has been made of (9.47), and so we end up with the result Z d n (¯ c, c) e−¯c·Ac = |A|
(9.67)
in which the determinant of the complex matrix A need not necessarily be nonzero. Hence, again the crucial difference between the bosonic and the fermionic case is that for bosons the determinant |A| occurs in the denominator, whereas for fermions it occurs in the numerator. As a converse to the above approach to complex Grassmann variables, one can also start from a real Grassmann algebra with 2n generators ξ a , from which the complex Grassmann algebra with generators ci and c¯i is then obtained by 1 cj = √ (ξ 2j−1 + iξ 2j ) 2
1 c¯j = √ (ξ 2j−1 − iξ 2j ) 2
: j = 1, . . . , n.
(9.68)
We look at the transition ξ → (¯ c, c) as a linear transformation, and so the heuristic rule (9.33) yields that the volume element d n (¯ c, c) = d n c¯ d n c is related to d 2n ξ by d 2n ξ =
1 n n d c¯ d c in
(9.69)
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
since the Jacobi determinant is ∂(c1 , c¯1 , . . . , cn , c¯n ) = 2−n ∂(ξ 1 , . . . , ξ 2n )
1 +i 1 −i . .. = i −n . 1 +i 1 −i
book
163
(9.70)
For the complex variables, Berezin’s rule (9.10) entails Z Z 1 1 1 = d 2n ξ ξ 1 · · · ξ 2n = i −n d n c¯d n c (c1 + c¯1 )(c1 − c¯1 ) · · · (cn + c¯n )(cn − c¯n ) 2i 2i Z = d n c¯ d n c c1 c¯1 · · · cn c¯n
which coincides with (9.66), and can also be read as in eq. (9.64). Hence, both approaches are compatible. For later reference, note that for the dual variables η 1 , . . . , η 2n which appear in the Fourier transform (9.38) and which obey the different rule (9.43), some changes arise. Again we define associated complex variables αi and their conjugates α ¯i by √ 1 1 2 α = (η + iη )/ 2 etc., and thus (9.43) gives Z d nα ¯ d nα α 1 · · · α nα ¯n · · · α ¯1 = (−1) n . (9.71)
This entails for the Gaussian integral Z ¯ d nα ¯ d n α e−α·Aα = (−1) n |A|
(9.72)
so that, as compared to eq. (9.67), an additional sign factor occurs. We end this section with a remark on the result (9.67); what we want to point out is that the determinant on the right hand side may also be obtained by means of real Grassmann variables. Since one set of real anticommuting variables only yields the square root (see eq. (9.16)), it is tempting to use a set of two real variables in order to ‘realize’ in (9.67) the determinant. So let us introduce two independent sets of real Grassmann variables ζi and η i with i ∈ {1, . . . , n}, which are also supposed to anticommute with each other. We adopt the conventional normalization for the η i , viz. Z d n η η1 · · · ηn = 1 (9.73) whereas for the ζ i we choose
R so that d n ζ d n η e−ζ·η to obtain
Z
d nζ ζ n · · · ζ 1 = 1 (9.74) R n n −ζ·A η = 1. We now pass in d ζ d η e from η to η ′ = A η Z
d n ζ d n η e−ζ·Aη = |A|
(9.75)
which is the advertised result. It will be made use of later in the context of so called ghost fermions.
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
164
9.4
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Appendix: Pfaffians *
In the first section we were concerned with the Gaussian integral over real anticommuting variables and met the square root of a skewsymmetric matrix; this is known as a Pfaffian, a term that we explain now. In what follows we anticipate some elements of exterior algebra which will be supplied at a later stage. So let V be an oriented vector space over the reals of even dimension n = 2m, and ∧· (V ) the exterior algebra. Denoting a basis of V by ei with i ∈ {1, . . . , n}, a basis of ∧· (V ) consists of the wedge products ei1 ∧ · · · ∧ eip
: i1 < · · · < ip ; p = 1, . . . , n.
(9.76)
Consider then the construct 1 2
A = Aij ei ∧ ej
(9.77)
where the matrix A with entries Aij is skewsymmetric; in particular, we investigate the weighted mth exterior power 1 m 1 ∧ A = m Ai1 j1 · · · Aim jm (ei1 ∧ ej1 ) ∧ · · · ∧ (eim ∧ ejm ). (9.78) m! 2 m! On using the identity ei1 ∧ · · · ∧ ein = εi1 ···in e1 ∧ · · · ∧ en , we may rewrite this as X 1 1 m ∧ A= m Ai1 j1 · · · Aim jm εi1 j1 ···im jm e1 ∧ · · · ∧ e2m m! 2 i <···
where the last equality sign follows from the fact that there are 2m possibilities to choose ip < jp or ip > jp for all p ∈ {1, . . . , m}. The Pfaffian of A is then defined by (−1)m m ∧ A = Pf(A) e1 ∧ · · · ∧ e2m m! the explicit form of which may also be written as Pf(A) =
(−1)m εi j ···i j Ai1 j1 · · · Aim jm . 2m m! 1 1 m m
Under a change of basis e′ i = C j i ej we have 1 2
A′ = A′ij ei ∧ ej
: A′ij = C i k C j l Akl
so that 1 1 m ′ ∧ A = m Ai1 j1 · · · Aim jm εi1 j1 ···im jm e′1 ∧ · · · ∧ e′2m m! 2 m! 1 = m Ai1 j1 · · · Aim jm εi1 j1 ···im jm |C|e1 ∧ · · · ∧ e2m 2 m!
(9.80)
(9.81)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Anticommuting Variables: Differential and Integral Calculus
book
165
and thus for the Pfaffian it follows: Pf(A′ ) = |C|Pf(A).
(9.82)
Finally, we want to relate the Pfaffian of A to the square root of its determinant |A|; to this end, the skew diagonalization of an antisymmetric real matrix A is needed. So consider the purely imaginary hermitian matrix B = iA; since the eigenvalue equation Bw = αw with α ∈ R entails B w ¯ = −αw, ¯ the spectrum of A in the complex orthonormal basis w1 , w ¯1 , . . . , wm , w ¯m ∈ Cn is given by −iα1 , +iα1 , . . . , −iαm , +iαm , where some of the αs may vanish. We renumber the basis according to u2l−1 = w ¯l and u2l = wl where l = 1, . . . , m; since w ¯l · wl = 1 and w ¯l · w ¯l = 0 = wl · wl , we have u2l · u2l−1 = 1 and ui · ui = 0. Let us now pass to 1 1 v2l−1 = √ (u2l−1 + u2l ) v2l = √ (u2l−1 − u2l ) 2 i 2 which is a real, orthonormal basis with the properties Av2l−1 = −αl v2l
Av2l = +αl v2l−1 .
As an easy calculation then shows, there exists an orthogonal matrix O ∈ SO(n) ◦
such that A = O A O−1 is skew diagonal, viz. 0 −α1 +α1 0 ◦ . .. A= . 0 −αm +αm 0
(9.83)
′ ′
Since Aij = Oi i′ Oj j ′ Ai j , we can now use the result (9.82) to conclude that Pf(A) = ◦
Pf(A), and so the variant (9.79) yields ◦
Pf(A) = α1 · · · αm . We thus end up with the final formula Pf(A) = |A|1/2 .
(9.84)
This result is remarkable in that the determinant |A| of a real antisymmetric matrix may be written as a perfect square; it is the Pfaffian which, as the determinant, is a polynomial in the matrix elements. References ´ (1) Araki H., Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 6 (1973) 67 (2) Arnold V. I., Gew¨ ohnliche Differentialgleichungen (2nd ed.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin 2001 (3) Berezin F. A., The Method of Second Quantization, Academic Press, New York 1966 (4) Bohm A. and Gadella M., Dirac Kets, Gamow Vectors and Gel’fand Triplets, SpringerVerlag, Berlin 1989 (5) Choquet-Bruhat Y., DeWitt-Morette C. and Dillard-Bleick M., Analysis, Manifolds and Physics (rev. ed.), North-Holland, Amsterdam 1982
April 8, 2013
14:15
166
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
(6) Flanders H., Differential Forms with Applications to the Physical Sciences, Academic Press, New York 1963 (7) Fulton W. and Harris J., Representation Theory, Springer-Verlag, New York 1991 (8) Gel’fand I. and Vilenkin N., Generalized Functions, Vol. IV, Academic Press, London 1964 (9) Gradshteyn I. S. and Ryzhik I. M., Tables of Integrals, Series and Products, Academic Press, New York 1965 (10) Jordan P. and Wigner E., Z. Phys. 47 (1928) 631 (11) Kayser B., Gibrat-Debu F. and Perrier F., The Physics of Massive Neutrinos, World Scientific, Singapore 1989 (12) Macfarlane A. J., J. Math. Phys. 3 (1962) 1116 (13) Misner C. W., Thorne K. S. and Wheeler J. A., Gravitation, Freeman, San Francisco 1973 (14) Mohapatra R. N. and Pal P. B., Massive Neutrinos in Physics and Astrophysics (2nd ed.), World Scientific, Singapore 1998 (15) Nicolai H., J. Phys. A 9 (1976) 1497 (16) Roe J., Elliptic Operators, Topology and Asymptotic Methods, Longman Scientific & Technical, Harlow (UK) 1988 (17) Sattinger D. H. and Weaver O. L., Lie Groups and Algebras with Applications to Physics, Geometry and Mechanics, Springer-Verlag, New York 1986 (18) Talman J. D., Special Functions: A Group Theoretic Approach, W. A. Benjamin, New York 1968 (19) Vilenkin N. J., Special Functions and the Theory of Group Representations, American Mathematical Society, Providence RI 1968 (20) Wightman A. S., “L’invariance dans la m´ ecanique quantique relativiste”, in Dispersion Relations and Elementary Particles, eds. C. de Witt and R. Omn` es, Wiley, New York 1960 (21) Witten E., Nucl. Phys. B 188 (1981) 513
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
PART II
CLASSICAL RELATIVISTIC FIELD THEORY: DYNAMICAL ASPECTS
167
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
This page intentionally left blank
168
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
Chapter 10
DYNAMICAL PRINCIPLES: INTERNAL SYMMETRIES
The charge conservation law arises as a consequence of the fact that the Lagrangian for a complex field is invariant against the multiplication of the field by a phase factor; such symmetries and nonabelian generalizations thereof are called internal, and thus depend on the detailed structure of the Lagrangian. By contrast, whatever the internal properties of a field theory are, any relativistic field theory is invariant under Poincar´e transformations, giving rise to energy-momentum conservation, and to conservation of the relativistic angular-momentum tensor; these universal symmetries, which hold for any type of relativistic field theory, are called external. The present chapter is entirely devoted to the discussion of internal gauge theories. We begin with the gauging of such symmetries in the section to come; afterwards, we supplement this topic by a section on model building, which will culminate in the so called standard model of the weak, electromagnetic and strong interactions. In the next chapter, we will then turn to external symmetries, leading us to the general theory of relativity as a model of gravitation, which can also be viewed as a kind of gauge theory. We continue these ideas with the extension to the supersymmetric case and give a description of (simple) supergravity as a gauge theory of the super Poincar´e group. The last chapter is concerned with the application of conventional general relativity to the subject of cosmology, which in recent times has undergone a revolutionary development; in an appendix we treat Weyl geometry and make some remarks on the Brans-Dicke-Jordan extension of general relativity.
10.1
Internal Gauge Theories
In this section the topic of gauge invariance is reconsidered, a theme that we briefly discussed in the context of the Dirac equation in sec. 5.4; it deserves closer examination since it will turn out to be the building principle behind a fundamental generalization of Maxwell’s theory, called Yang-Mills theory. In addition, it will provide for a strategy to generate new types of interactions. 169
book
April 8, 2013
14:15
170
10.1.1
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
book
Structural Aspects of Quantum Field Theory
Gauge invariance in quantum mechanics
A proper understanding of gauge invariance can only be reached in a quantum mechanical setting, and we begin by explaining this basic fact in the context of the nonrelativistic Schr¨ odinger theory. So let us recall that the coupling of the electromagnetic field to a charged particle is implemented through the vector and the scalar potential; we have derived the corresponding Lagrangian in sec. 2.3.1 (see eq. (2.30)), which reads L=
m 2 e x˙ + A · x˙ − eϕ. 2 c
Under a gauge transformation, the potentials transform according to A′ = A − ∇α
ϕ′ = ϕ +
1 ∂ α c ∂t
where α(x, t) is a real valued scalar function on Minkowsi space, and so the Lagrangian is transformed into L′ = L −
e d α c dt
:
d ∂ = x˙ · ∇ + . dt ∂t
Hence, the Lagrangian is invariant against gauge transformations up to a total time derivative, which does not affect the equations of motion; of course, this property is obvious from the Lorentz equations (2.28), in which only the electric and magnetic field strengths get involved, and these are invariant by construction. The situation is drastically different at the level of classical Hamiltonian dynamics; for the Hamilton function (see (2.32)) 1 e 2 H(p, x) = p − A + eϕ 2m c
gauge invariance gets totally lost. We shall have occasion to return to this problem at a later stage (sec. 36.3) in the context of canonical transformations. The way out is to perform the transition to quantum mechanics. If in the classical Hamiltonian function the momenta and coordinates p and x are replaced ˆ = −i~∇ and x ˆ = x, one faces the situation that there is as usual by the operators p more than one possibility to choose a Hamilton operator, this being due to ordering ambiguities; for reasons to be explained in a moment, we make the following choice: 2 e 1 ˆ − A(ˆ ˆ) = p x) + eϕ(ˆ x). (10.1) H(ˆ p, x 2m c As will be seen, it is precisely this ordering, and no other one, that guarantees gauge invariance at the quantized level. What gets involved in the above Hamilton operator is a generalized or covariant derivative, which we denote by the symbol D =∇−
ie A(x, t). ~c
(10.2)
April 8, 2013
BC: 8771 - Structural Aspects of Quantum Field - FA
14:15
Dynamical Principles: Internal Symmetries
book
171
Let us anticipate, this form makes it evident that the vector potential can be identified as what is known as a connexion; we shall have to return to this remark. With this notational convention, the Hamilton operator takes the compact form 2 ˆ = − ~ D2 + eϕ(x, t). H 2m Under gauge transformations the generalized derivative is mapped into
(10.3)
ie ∇α(x, t). (10.4) ~c The basic observation now is that this transformation law can also be read as follows: D′ = D +
ie
e
D′ = e−i ~c α De− ~c α .
(10.5)
For notational simplicity, we here deviate from the convention that a derivative only acts on the immediately following factor; in full detail, the above line is to be interpreted as ie e D′ · · · = e−i ~c α D e− ~c α · · · .
This simple rewriting of the covariant derivative makes it apparent that gauge ine variance has a profound group theoretical origin since the phase factor exp −i ~c α can be identified as an element of the group U (1), the unitary group in one dimension. However, one here has an essential generalization of a conventional Lie group since the phase α depends on space and time; this is called a l