Although great care has been taken to provide accurate and current information, neither the author(s) nor the publisher...
132 downloads
2514 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Although great care has been taken to provide accurate and current information, neither the author(s) nor the publisher, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage, or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. The material contained herein is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any specific situation. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. ISBN: 0-8247-4717-8 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Headquarters Marcel Dekker, Inc., 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, U.S.A. tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540 Distribution and Customer Service Marcel Dekker, Inc., Cimarron Road, Monticello, New York 12701, U.S.A. tel: 800-228-1160; fax: 845-796-1772 Eastern Hemisphere Distribution Marcel Dekker AG, Hutgasse 4, Postfach 812, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 41-61-260-6300; fax: 41-61-260-6333 World Wide Web http://www.dekker.com The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above. Copyright n 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Current printing (last digit): 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
To my wife, Lisa, my daughters, Stephanie and Jennifer, my son, Daniel, my parents, James and Rita, and my brothers and sisters, Mathew, Ann, David, and Claire.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Preface
This textbook is intended for use in a senior-year undergraduate or first-year graduate course devoted to structural analyses of laminated polymer-matrix composite materials and structures. Discussion is framed almost entirely at the macromechanical (structural) level. Micromechanical issues and analyses are discussed briefly but are not covered in detail. This allows an expanded coverage of the structural response of composite beams and plates, as compared to other introductory texts on composite materials. The text contains ample material for a semester-based (15-week) course. I have used a similar manuscript for several years to support two sequential quarter-based (10week) courses, supplementing this material with one or two laboratory sessions. Since laboratory exercises depend heavily on the equipment and materials available to the instructor, these lab sessions are not described in this book. It is assumed that the reader has already completed a sophomore- or junior-level course devoted to the mechanics of isotropic solids. I have made every effort to extend the concepts of this earlier coursework in a natural and easily understandable way to the study of anisotropic composites. Chapter 1 begins with a broad overview of the various types of commercially available metal, ceramic, and polymer-based composite materials. This chapter also includes an overview of polymer and fibrous materials and the manufacturing processes used to produce polymer composites and v
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
structures. Chapter 2 is devoted to a review of force, stress, and strain tensors and how these tensors may be transformed from one coordinate system to another. Although these topics are normally covered in a course on the mechanics of isotropic solids, it has been my experience that a review of these fundamental concepts is almost always required before they can be correctly applied to the study of anisotropic composites. Various material properties required to predict the structural performance of anisotropic composites are introduced in Chapter 3, and the threedimensional, anisotropic form of Hooke’s law is developed in Chapter 4. The three-dimensional form of Hooke’s law is then reduced to the plane stress (two-dimensional) form in Chapter 5 and applied to unidirectional laminated composites. Rudimentary elements of plate theory are developed in Chapter 6 and combined with Hooke’s law, resulting in the analysis methodology commonly known as classical lamination theory (CLT). Chapter 7 describes composite failure modes and mechanisms, including a qualitative description of composite fatigue behaviors and free-edge effects. The chapter also presents methods of combining macroscopic failure criteria with CLT to predict first-ply and last-ply failure loads. Chapter 8 is devoted to statically determinate and indeterminate composite beams. The chapter begins with the observation that CLT reduces to fundamental beam theory (as studied during an earlier course on the mechanics of isotropic solids) when isotropic properties and appropriate dimensions are assumed. CLT is then used to predict the effective axial and bending rigidities of composite beams with various cross sections (rectangular, I-, T-, hat-, and box-beams). Chapters 9 through 11 address composite plates. Discussion is limited to symmetric rectangular composite plates, since this topic is extensive and a complete discussion of nonrectangular and/or nonsymmetric composite plates or shells deserves a separate text in itself. The equations that govern the behavior of symmetric and rectangular composite plates are developed in Chapter 9. Chapter 10 presents several closed-form solutions for specially orthotropic composite plates. Chapter 11 presents approximate numerical solutions for generally orthotropic plates (e.g., quasi-isotropic plates); this includes solutions for the deflections of transversely loaded plates as well as mechanical and/or thermal buckling due to in-plane loads. Three appendixes that include material referenced in the main body of the book complete the text, with the second briefly describing experimental methods used to measure in-plane composite properties. While many of these topics are covered in other introductory composites textbooks, I have included here certain pedagogical features that have, in my experience, facilitated and enhanced an understanding of the concepts. For example, the crucially important effects of environment—in particular,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the effects due to changes in temperature and/or moisture content—are integrated throughout Chapters 3 through 11, rather than being confined to later chapters, as is often the case in composite textbooks. With the exception of Chapters 1 and 9, each chapter includes numerical example problems that illustrate the concepts presented. A solutions manual for all homework problems posed in the text is available for educators using the text in their courses. I have also created a suite of computer programs that implement the analyses discussed. These executable programs may be downloaded free of charge from the following website: http : ==depts:washington:edu=amtas=computer:html These programs are meant to enhance the text and are referenced at appropriate points throughout the book. Of course, composite computer programs are now widely available, both commercially and otherwise, so the reader may opt to use resources other than those downloaded from the website provided. Preparation of this book has been a demanding and lengthy endeavor. I sincerely hope that it will be a worthy addition to the composites literature. Mark E. Tuttle
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Acknowledgments
I have been fortunate to have worked with talented and inspirational colleagues throughout my academic and professional career. I would especially like to acknowledge the lifelong influence of my two major academic advisors, Professor Emeritus Halbert F. Brinson of the University of Houston (formerly of Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University) and Professor John B. Ligon of Michigan Technological University. There are many others whom I would like to mention by name, but space does not allow it. To my friends and colleagues at Battelle Columbus Laboratories, Michigan Tech, Virginia Tech, the University of Washington, NASA–Langley Research Center, the Boeing Company, and the Society for Experimental Mechanics: thank you. Particular thanks are extended to Mr. Rob Albers of the Boeing Company, who read and gave helpful critiques of initial versions of Chapters 9 through 11. I would also like to thank the staff at Marcel Dekker, Inc.—in particular Michael Deters, Production Editor, and John Corrigan, Acquisitions Editor—for their very professional and competent help throughout preparation of the final manuscript. Finally, to the many undergraduate and graduate students who have taken my composites courses or worked with me during the pursuit of their degrees and who consequently struggled through and ‘‘edited’’ manuscript versions of this textbook: thank you for your help and patience. Mark E. Tuttle ix
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Contents
Preface Acknowledgments
1. Introduction 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Basic Definitions Polymeric Materials Fibrous Materials Commercially Available Forms Manufacturing Processes The Scope of This Book References
2. Review of Force, Stress, and Strain Tensors 1. 2. 3.
The Force Vector Transformation of a Force Vector Normal Forces, Shear Forces, and Free-Body Diagrams 4. Definition of Stress
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
The Stress Tensor Transformation of the Stress Tensor Principal Stresses Plane Stress Definition of Strain The Strain Tensor Transformation of the Strain Tensor Principal Strains Strains Within a Plane Perpendicular to a Principal Strain Direction 14. Relating Strains to Displacement Fields 15. Computer Programs 3DROTATE and 2DROTATE Homework Problems References 3. Material Properties 1. 2. 3.
Anisotropic vs. Isotropic Materials Material Properties That Relate Stress to Strain Material Properties Relating Temperature to Strain 4. Material Properties Relating Moisture Content to Strain 5. Material Properties Relating Stress (or Strain) to Failure 6. Predicting Elastic Composite Properties Based on Constituents: The Rule of Mixtures Homework Problems References 4. Elastic Response of Anisotropic Materials 1. 2.
Strains Induced by Stress: Anisotropic Materials Strains Induced by Stress: Orthotropic and Transversely Isotropic Materials 3. Strains Induced by a Change in Temperature or Moisture Content 4. Strains Induced by Combined Effects of Stress, Temperature, and Moisture Homework Problems References
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5. Unidirectional Composite Laminates Subject to Plane Stress 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Unidirectional Composites Referenced to the Principal Material Coordinate System Unidirectional Composites Referenced to an Arbitrary Coordinate System Calculating Transformed Properties Using Material Invariants Effective Elastic Properties of a Unidirectional Composite Laminate Failure of Unidirectional Composites Referenced to the Principal Material Coordinate System Failure of Unidirectional Composites Referenced to an Arbitrary Coordinate System Computer Programs UNIDIR and UNIFAIL Homework Problems References
6. Thermomechanical Behavior of Multiangle Composite Laminates 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
Definition of a ‘‘Thin Plate’’ and Allowable Plate Loadings Plate Deformations: The Kirchhoff Hypothesis Principal Curvatures Standard Methods of Describing Composite Laminates Calculating Ply Strains and Stresses Classical Lamination Theory (CLT) Simplifications Due to Stacking Sequence Summary of CLT Calculations Effective Properties of a Composite Laminate Transformation of the ABD Matrix Computer Program CLT Homework Problems References
7. Predicting Failure of a Multiangle Composite Laminate 1. 2. 3. 4.
Preliminary Discussion Free-Edge Stresses Predicting Laminate Failure Using CLT Laminate First-Ply Failure Envelopes
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5.
Computer Program LAMFAIL Homework Problems References
8. Composite Beams 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Preliminary Discussion Comparing Classical Lamination Theory to Isotropic Beam Theory Types of Composite Beams Considered Effective Axial Rigidity of Rectangular Composite Beams Effective Flexural Rigidities of Rectangular Composite Beams Effective Axial and Flexural Rigidities for Thin-Walled Composite Beams Statically Determinate and Indeterminate Axially Loaded Composite Beams Statically Determinate and Indeterminate Transversely Loaded Composite Beams Computer Program BEAM Homework Problems References
9. The Governing Equations of Thin-Plate Theory 1. 2.
Preliminary Discussion The Equations of Equilibrium for Symmetric Laminates 3. Boundary Conditions 4. Representing Arbitrary Transverse Loads as a Fourier Series References 10. Some Exact Solutions for Specially Orthotropic Laminates 1. 2. 3. 4.
Equations of Equilibrium for a Specially Orthotropic Laminate In-Plane Displacement Fields in Specially Orthotropic Laminates Specially Orthotropic Laminates Subject to Simple Supports of Type S1 Specially Orthotropic Laminates Subject to Simple Supports of Type S4
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Specially Orthotropic Laminates With Two Simply Supported Edges of Type S1 and Two Edges of Type S2 The Navier Solution Applied to a Specially Orthotropic Laminate Subject to Simple Supports of Type S4 Buckling of Rectangular Specially Orthotropic Laminates Subject to Simple Supports of Type S4 Thermal Buckling of Rectangular Specially Orthotropic Laminates Subject to Simple Supports of Type S1 Computer Program SPORTHO References
11. Some Approximate Solutions for Symmetric Laminates 1. 2. 3. 4.
Preliminary Discussion In-Plane Displacement Fields Potential Energy in a Thin Composite Plate Symmetric Composite Laminates Subject to Simple Supports of Type S4 5. Buckling of Symmetric Composite Plates Subject to Simple Supports of Type S4 6. Computer Program SYMM References
Appendixes A. Finding the Cube-Root of a Complex Number B. Experimental Methods Used to Measure In-Plane Properties E11, E22, r12, and G12 C. Tables of Beam Deflections and Slopes
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
1 Introduction
A broad overview of modern composite materials is provided in this chapter. The chapter begins with a definition of what is meant by the phrase ‘‘composite material.’’ Separate sections devoted to polymeric materials, fibrous materials, commercially available forms, and manufacturing techniques are included. The chapter concludes with a section indicating the scope of the remaining chapters. 1
BASIC DEFINITIONS
This textbook is devoted to a special class of structural materials often called ‘‘advanced’’ composites. Just what is a ‘‘composite material’’? A casual definition might be: ‘‘A composite material is one in which two (or more) materials are bonded together to form a third material.’’ Although not incorrect, upon further reflection, it becomes clear that this definition is far too broad because it implies that essentially all materials can be considered as ‘‘composites.’’ For example, the (nominal) composition of the 2024 aluminum alloy is 93.5% Al, 4.4% Cu, 0.6% Mn, and 1.5% Mg [1]. Hence, according to the broad definition stated above, this common aluminum alloy could be considered as a ‘‘composite’’ because it consists of four materials (aluminum, copper, manganese, and magnesium) bonded together at the atomic level to form the 2024 alloy. In a similar sense, virtually all metal alloys, polymers, and
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ceramics satisfy this broad definition of a ‘‘composite’’ because all of these materials contain more than one type of elemental atom. An important characteristic that is missing in the initial broad definition is a consideration of physical scale. Another definition of a ‘‘composite material,’’ which includes a reference to a physical scale appropriate for present purposes, is as follows: A composite material is a material system consisting of two (or more) materials, which are distinct at a physical scale greater than about 1106 m (1 Am) and which are bonded together at the atomic and/or molecular levels. As a point of reference, the diameter of human hair ranges from about 30 to 60 Am. Objects of this size are easily seen with the aid of an optical microscope. Hence, when composite materials are viewed under an optical microscope, the distinct constituent materials (or distinct material phases) that form the composite are easily distinguished. Structural composites typically consist of a high-strength, high-stiffness reinforcing material, embedded within a relatively low-strength, low-stiffness matrix material. Ideally, the reinforcing and matrix materials interact to produce a composite whose properties are superior to either of the two constituent materials alone. Many naturally occurring materials can be viewed as composites. A good example is wood and laminated wood products. Wood is a natural composite, with a readily apparent grain structure. Wood exhibits a higher stiffness and strength parallel to the grains than transverse to the grains. In laminated wood products (which range from the large laminated beams used in a church cathedral to a common sheet of plywood), relatively thin layers of wood are adhesively bonded together. In plywood, the layers are arranged such that the grain direction varies from one layer to the next. Therefore, this laminated wood product has a high stiffness/strength in more than one direction. Although composites have been used in a variety of structural applications for centuries, modern (or ‘‘advanced’’) composites are a relatively recent development, having been in existence for about 60 years. Modern composites may be classified according to the size or shape of the reinforcing material used. Four common classifications of reinforcements are:
Particulates, which are roughly spherical particles with diameters typically ranging from about 1 to 100 Am Whiskers, with lengths less than about 10 mm Short (or ‘‘chopped’’) fibers, with a length ranging from about 10 to 200 mm Continuous fibers, whose length are, in effect, infinite.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Whiskers, short fibers, and continuous fibers all have very small diameters relative to their length; the diameter of these products ranges from about 5 to 200 Am. Distinctly different types of composites can be produced using any of the above reinforcements. For example, three types of composites based on continuous fibers are shown in Fig. 1: unidirectional composites, woven composites, and braided composites. In a unidirectional composite, all fibers are aligned in the same direction and embedded within a matrix material. In contrast, woven composites are formed by first weaving continuous fibers into a fabric and then embedding the fabric in a matrix. Hence, a single layer of a woven composite contains fibers in two orthogonal directions. In contrast, a single layer in a braided composite typically contains two or three
Figure 1 Different types of composites based on continuous fibers.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
nonorthogonal fiber directions. Braided composites are then formed by embedding the fabric in a matrix (additional discussion of these types of composites is provided in Sec. 4). As implied in Fig. 1, composite products based on continuous fibers are usually produced in the form of thin layers. A single layer of these products is called a lamina or ply. The thickness of a single ply formed using unidirectional fibers ranges from about 0.12 to 0.20 mm, whereas the thickness of a single ply of a woven or braided fabric ranges from about 0.25 to 0.40 mm. Obviously, a single composite ply is quite thin. To produce a composite structure with significant thickness, many plies are stacked together to form a composite laminate. Conceptually any number of plies may be used in the laminate, but in practice, the number of plies usually ranges from about 10 plies to (in unusual cases) perhaps as many as 200 plies. The fiber represents the reinforcing material in these composites. Hence, the orientation of the fibers is, in general, varied from one ply to the next, so as to provide high stiffness and strength in more than one direction (as is the case in plywood). It is also possible to use unidirectional, woven, and/or braided plies within the same laminate. For example, it is common to use a woven or braided fabric as the two outermost facesheets of a laminate, and to use unidirectional plies at interior positions. In all composites, the reinforcement is embedded within a matrix material. The matrix may be polymeric, metallic, or ceramic. In fact, composite materials are often classified on the basis of the matrix material used, rather than the reinforcing material. That is, modern composites can be categorized into three main types: polymer–matrix, metal–matrix, or ceramic– matrix composite materials. Usually, the reinforcing material governs the stiffness and strength of a composite. On the other hand, the matrix material usually governs thermal stability. Polymeric–matrix composites are used in applications involving relatively modest temperatures (service temperatures of, say, 200jC or less). Metal–matrix composites are used at temperatures up to about 700jC, while ceramic–matrix composites are used at ultra-high temperatures (up to about 1200jC or greater). The matrix also defines several additional characteristics of the composite material system. Some additional roles of the matrix are:
To provide the physical form of the composite To bind the fibers together To protect the fibers from aggressive (chemical) environments or mechanical damage (e.g., due to abrasion, for example) To transfer and redistribute stresses between fibers, between plies, and in areas of discontinuities in load or geometry.
To summarize the preceding discussion, there are many types of composite materials, both natural and man-made. Composites can be clas-
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
sified according to the physical form of the reinforcing material (particulate, whisker, short fiber, or continuous fiber reinforcement), by the type of matrix material used (metal, ceramic, or polymeric matrix), by the orientation of the reinforcement (unidirectional, woven, or braided), or by some combination thereof. The temperature the composite material/structure will experience in service often dictates the type of composite used in a given application. The primary focus of this textbook is the structural analysis of polymeric composite materials and structures. Metal–matrix and ceramic–matrix composites will not be further discussed, although many of the analysis methods developed herein may be applied to these types of composites as well. Because our focus is the structural analysis of polymeric composites, we will not be greatly considered with the behavior of the individual constituent materials. That is, we will not be greatly concerned with the behavior of an unreinforced polymer, nor with the behavior of an individual reinforcing fiber. Instead, we will be concerned with the behavior of the composite formed by combining these two constituents. Nevertheless, a structural engineer who wishes to use polymeric composites effectively in practice must understand at least the rudiments of polymer and fiber science, in much the same way as an engineer working with metal alloys must understand at least the rudiments of metallurgy. Toward that end, a brief introduction to polymeric and fibrous materials is provided in Secs. 2 and 3, respectively. At the minimum, the reader should become acquainted with the terminology used to describe polymeric and fibrous materials because such terms have naturally been carried over to the polymeric composites technical community.
2
POLYMERIC MATERIALS
A brief introduction to polymeric materials is provided in this section. This introduction is necessarily incomplete. The reader interested in a more detailed discussion is referred to the many available texts and/or web-based resources devoted to modern polymers (e.g., see Refs. 1–4). 2.1 Basic Concepts The term ‘‘polymer’’ comes from the Greek words poly (meaning ‘‘many’’) and mers (meaning ‘‘units’’). Quite literally, a polymer consists of ‘‘many units.’’ Polymer molecules are made up of thousands of repeating chemical units and have molecular weights ranging from about 103 to 107. As an illustrative example, consider the single chemical mer shown in Fig. 2. This mer is called ethylene (or ethene), and consists of two carbon atoms and four hydrogen atoms. The two lines between the carbon (C) atoms
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 2 The monomer ethylene.
indicate a double covalent bond,* whereas the single line between the hydrogen (H) and carbon atoms represents a single covalent bond. The chemical composition of the ethylene mer is sometimes written as C2H4 or CH2jCH2. Under proper conditions, the double covalent bond between the two carbon atoms can be converted to a single covalent bond, which allows each of the two carbon atoms to form a new covalent bond with a suitable neighboring atom. A suitable neighboring atom would be a carbon atom in a neighboring ethylene mer, for example. If ‘‘n’’ ethylene mers join together in this way, the chemical composition of the resulting molecule can be represented C2nH4n, where n is any positive integer. Hence, a ‘‘chain’’ of ethylene mers joins together to form the well-known polymer, polyethylene (literally, ‘‘many ethylenes’’), as shown in Fig. 3. The process of causing a monomer to chemically react and form a long molecule in this fashion is called polymerization. The single ethylene unit is an example of a monomer (‘‘one mer’’). At room temperature, a bulk sample of the ethylene monomer is a low-viscosity fluid. If two ethylene monomers bond together, the resulting chemical entity has two repeating units and is called a dimer. Similarly, the chemical entity formed by three repeating units is called a trimer. The molecular weight of a dimer is twice that of the monomer, the molecular weight of a trimer is three times that of the monomer, etc. Prior to polymerization, most polymeric materials exist as relatively low-viscosity fluids known as oligomers (‘‘a few mers’’). The individual molecules within an oligomer possess a range of molecular weights, typically containing perhaps 2–20 mers. It should be clear from the above discussion that a specific molecular weight cannot be assigned to a polymer. Rather, the molecules within a bulk sample of a polymer are of differing lengths and hence exhibit a range in molecular weight. The average molecular weight of a bulk sample of a polymer is increased as the polymerization process is initiated and progresses. Another
* As fully described in an introductory chemistry text, a ‘‘covalent bond’’ is formed when two atoms share an electron pair, so as to fill an incompletely filled valence level.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 3 The polymer polyethylene.
measure of the ‘‘size’’ of the polymeric molecule is the degree of polymerization, defined as the ratio of the average molecular weight of the polymer molecule divided by the molecular weight of the repeating chemical unit within the molecular chain. The average molecular weight of a polymeric sample (or, equivalently, the degree of polymerization) depends on the conditions under which it was polymerized. Now, all physical properties exhibited by a polymer (e.g., strength, stiffness, density, thermal expansion coefficient, etc.) are dictated by the average molecular weight. Therefore, a fundamental point that must be appreciated by the structural engineer is that the properties exhibited by any polymer (or any polymeric composite) depend on the circumstances under which it was polymerized. As a general rule, the volume of a bulk sample of a monomer decreases during polymerization. That is, the bulk sample shrinks as the polymerization process proceeds. This may have serious ramifications if the polymer is to be used in structural applications. For example, if a fiber(s) is embedded within the sample during the polymerization process (as is the case for some fiberreinforced polymeric composite systems), then shrinkage of the matrix causes residual stresses to develop during polymerization. This effect contributes to so-called cure stresses, which are present in most polymeric composites. As will be seen in later chapters, cure stresses arise from two primary sources. The first is shrinkage of the matrix during polymerization, as just described. The second is stresses that arise due to temperature effects. In this case, the composite is polymerized at an elevated temperature (say, 175jC) and then cooled to room temperature (20jC). The thermal expansion coefficient of the matrix is typically much higher than the fibers, and so during cooldown, the matrix is placed in tension while the fiber is placed in compression. Cure stresses due to shrinkage during cure and/or temperature effects can be quite high relative to the strength of the polymer itself, and ultimately contribute toward failure of the composite.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2.2 Addition vs. Condensation Polymers Although in the case of polyethylene the repeat unit is equivalent to the original ethylene monomer, this is not always the case. In fact, in many instances, the repeat unit is derived from two (or more) monomers. A typical example is nylon 6,6. A typical polymerization process for this polymer is shown schematically in Fig. 4. Two monomers are used to produce nylon 6,6: hexamethylene diamine (chemical composition: C6H16N2) and adipic acid (chemical composition: CO2H(CH2)4CO2H). Note that the repeat unit of nylon 6,6 (hexamethylene adipamide) is not equivalent to either of the two original monomers. A low-molecular-weight by-product (i.e., H2O) is produced during the polymerization of nylon 6,6. This is characteristic of condensation polymers. That is, if both a high-molecular-weight polymer as well as a low-molecularweight by-product are formed during the polymerization process, the polymer is classified as a condensation polymer. Conversely, addition polymers are those for which no by-product is formed, which implies that all atoms present in the original monomer(s) occur somewhere within the repeat unit. Generally speaking, condensation polymers shrink to a greater extent during the polymerization process than do addition polymers. Residual stresses caused by shrinkage during polymerization are often a concern in structural composites, and hence difficulties with residual stresses can often be minimized if an addition polymer is used in these applications.
Figure 4 The polymer nylon 6,6.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2.3 Molecular Structure The molecular structure of a fully polymerized polymer can be roughly grouped into one of three major types: linear, branched, or crosslinked polymers. The three types of molecular structure are shown schematically in Fig. 5. Linear polymers can be visualized as beads on a string, where each bead represents a repeat unit. It should again be emphasized that the length of these ‘‘strings’’ is enormous; if a typical linear molecule were scaled up to be 10 mm in diameter, it would be roughly 4 km long. In a bulk sample, these long macromolecules become entangled and twisted together, much like a bowl of cooked spaghetti. Obviously, as the molecular weight (i.e., the length) of the polymer molecule is increased, the number of entanglements is increased. At the macroscopical scale, the stiffness exhibited by a bulk polymer is directly related to its molecular weight and number of entanglements. If all of the repeat units within a linear polymer are identical, the polymer is called a homopolymer. Polyethylene is a good example of a linear homopolymer. However, it is possible to produce linear polymers that consist of two separate and distinct repeat units. Such materials are called copolymers. In linear random copolymers, the two distinct repeat units appear randomly along the backbone of the molecule. In contrast, for linear block copolymers, the two distinct repeat units form long continuous segments within the polymer chain. A good example of a common copolymer is acrylonitrile–butadiene–styrene, commonly known as ‘‘ABS.’’ The second major type of polymeric molecular structure is the branched polymer (see Fig. 5). In branched polymers, relatively short side chains are bonded to the primary backbone of the macromolecule by means of a covalent bond. As before, the stiffness of a bulk sample of a branched polymer is related to the number of entanglements between molecules. Because the branches greatly increase the number of entanglements, the macroscopical stiffness of a branched polymer will, in general, be greater than the macroscopical stiffness of a linear polymer of similar molecular weight. In many branched polymers, the branches consist of the same chemical repeat unit as the backbone of the molecular chain. However, in some cases, the branch may have a distinctly different chemical repeat unit than the main backbone of the molecule. Such materials are called graft copolymers. Finally, the third major type of molecular structure is the crosslinked or network polymer (see Fig. 5). During polymerization of such polymers, a crosslink (i.e., a covalent bond) is formed between individual molecular chains. Hence, once polymerization is complete, a vast molecular network is formed. In the limit, a single ‘‘molecule’’ can no longer be identified. A bulk sample of a highly crosslinked polymer may be thought of as a single molecule.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 5 Types of polymer molecular structure.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Linear and branched polymers can be visualized as a bowl of cooked spaghetti. One can imagine that a single spaghetti noodle could be extracted without damage from the bowl if the noodle were pulled slowly and carefully, allowing the noodle to ‘‘slide’’ past its neighbors. In much the same way, an individual molecule could also be extracted (at least conceptually) from a bulk sample of a linear or branched polymer. However, this is not the case for a fully polymerized crosslinked polymer. Because the ‘‘individual’’ molecular chains within a crosslinked polymer are themselves linked together by covalent bonds, the entire molecular network can be considered to be a single molecule. Although regions of the chain in a crosslinked polymer may slide past each other, eventually, relative motion between segments is limited by the crosslinks between segments. 2.4 Thermoplastic vs. Thermoset Polymers Suppose a bulk sample of a linear or branched polymer exists as a solid material at room temperature and is subsequently heated. Due to the increase in thermal energy, the average distance between individual molecular chains is increased as temperature is increased. This results in an increase in molecular mobility and a decrease in macroscopical stiffness. That is, as the molecules move apart, both the forces of attraction between individual molecules as well as the degree of entanglement decrease, resulting in a decrease in stiffness at the macroscopical level. Eventually, a temperature is reached at which the polymeric molecules can slide freely past each other and the polymer ‘‘melts.’’ Typically, melting does not occur at a single temperature, but rather over a temperature range of about 15–20jC. A polymer that can be melted (i.e., a linear or branched polymer) is called a thermoplastic polymer. The molecular structure of a thermoplastic polymer may be amorphous or semicrystalline. The molecular structure of an amorphous thermoplastic is completely random (i.e., the molecular chains are randomly oriented and entangled, with no discernible pattern). In contrast, in a semicrystalline thermoplastic, there exist regions of highly ordered molecular arrays. An idealized representation of a crystalline region is shown in Fig. 6. As indicated, in the crystalline region, the main backbone of the molecular chain undulates back and forth such that the thickness of the crystalline region is usually (about) 100 A˚. The crystalline region may extend over an area with a length dimension ranging from (about) 1000 to 10,000 A˚. Hence, the crystalline regions are typically platelike. The high degree of order within the crystalline array allows for close molecular spacing, and hence exceptionally high bonding forces between molecules in the crystalline region. At the macroscale, a semicrystalline thermoplastic typically has a higher strength, stiffness, and density than an otherwise comparable
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 6 An idealized representation of a crystalline region in a thermoplastic polymer.
amorphous thermoplastic. No thermoplastic is completely crystalline, however. Instead, regions of crystallinity are surrounded by amorphous regions, as shown schematically in Fig. 7. Most semicrystalline thermoplastic are 10–50% amorphous (by volume). As just described, a thermoplastic can be melted. In contrast, a crosslinked polymer cannot be melted. If a crosslinked polymer is heated, it will exhibit a decrease in stiffness at the structural level because the average distance between individual segments of the molecular network is, in fact, increased as temperature is increased. However, the crosslinks do not allow indefinite relative motion between segments, and eventually limit molecular motion. Therefore, a crosslinked polymer will not melt. Of course, if the temperature is raised high enough, the covalent bonds that form both the backbone of the molecular chains as well as the crosslinks are broken, chemical degradation occurs, and the polymer is destroyed. A polymer that cannot be melted (i.e., a crosslinked polymer) is called a thermoset polymer. Three more or less distinct conditions are recognized during polymerization of a thermoset polymer. The original resin or oligomer is typically a low-viscosity, low-molecular-weight fluid, containing molecules with perhaps 2–10 repeat units. A thermoset resin is said to be A-staged when in this form. As the polymerization process is initiated (by the introduction of a catalyst, by an increase in temperature, by the application of pressure, or by some combination thereof), molecular weight and viscosity increase rapidly. If the polymerization process is then halted in some manner (say, by suddenly reducing the temperature), the polymerization process will stop (or be
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 7 Overall molecular structure of a semicrystalline thermoplastic, showing crystalline and amorphous regions.
dramatically slowed) and the polymer will exist in an intermediate stage. The thermoset resin is said to be B-staged when in this form. If the polymerization process is allowed to resume (say, by reheating) and continue until the maximum possible molecular weight has been reached, the thermoset is said to be C-staged (i.e., the polymer is fully polymerized). Suppliers of composites based on thermoset polymers initially B-stage their product and sell it to their customers in this form. This requires that the B-staged composite be stored by the customer for months at low temperatures (typically at temperatures below about 15jC or 0jF). Refrigeration is required so that the thermosetting resin does not polymerize beyond the Bstage during storage. The polymerization process is reinitiated and completed (i.e., the composite is C-staged) during the final fabrication of a composite part, typically through the application of heat and pressure. Most commercially available thermoset composites are C-staged (or ‘‘cured’’) at a temperature of either 120jC or 175jC. In contrast, composites based on thermoplastic polymers do not require refrigeration. In this case, the matrix is fully polymerized when delivered to the customer, and may be stored for months or years without degradation. Heat and pressure are applied during the final fabrication of a thermoplastic composite part, but no chemical reaction occurs. That is, heat is applied
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
simply to soften/melt the thermoplastic matrix, and pressure is applied to insure consolidation of the composite part. The temperature required to soften/melt thermoplastic composites is usually 350jC or higher. Note that the temperatures required to process thermoplastic composites are significantly higher than those required to cure thermoset composites. 2.5 The Glass Transition Temperature Stiffness and strength are physical properties of obvious importance to the structural engineer. These properties are temperature-dependent for all materials, but this is particularly true for polymers. The effect of temperature on the stiffness of a polymer is summarized in Fig. 8. Thermoset and thermoplastic polymers exhibit the same general behavior, except that at high temperatures, thermoplastics melt whereas thermosets do not. All polymers exhibit a decrease in stiffness near a characteristic temperature called the glass transition temperature, Tg. At temperatures well below the Tg, polymer stiffness decreases slowly with an increase in temperature. At temperatures well below the Tg, polymers are ‘‘glassy’’ and brittle. In contrast, at temperatures well above the Tg, all polymers are ‘‘rubbery’’ and ductile. Thus, the Tg denotes the transition between glassy and rubbery behaviors. This transition is associated with a sudden increase in mobility of segments within the molecular chain, and typically occurs over a range of 10– 15jC. At temperatures well below the Tg, the polymer molecules are closely packed together and tightly bonded, and cannot easily slide past each other.
Figure 8 Effects of temperature on polymer stiffness.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Consequently, the polymer is ‘‘glassy’’ and exhibits high stiffness and strength but relatively low ductility. Conversely, at temperatures well above the Tg, the molecular spacing is increased such that the molecular chains (or segments of those chains) are mobile and can readily slide past each other. Consequently, the polymer is ‘‘rubbery’’ and exhibits relatively lower stiffness and strength but higher ductility. As implied in Fig. 8, for amorphous thermoplastics, the change in stiffness (and other physical properties) that occurs as the Tg is reached may be one to two orders of magnitude. This astonishing decrease in stiffness occurs over a temperature range of only a few degrees. A similar change in properties occurs for semicrystalline thermoplastics and crosslinked thermosets, although, in general, they are less pronounced. If temperature is raised high enough, then a thermoplastic polymer will melt. The temperature region at which melting occurs is denoted Tm in Fig. 8, although, as previously discussed, a thermoplastic does not exhibit a unique melting temperature but rather melts over a temperature range. Young’s modulus tends toward zero as melting occurs, as implied in Fig. 8. Thermoset polymers cannot be melted, although the polymer is destroyed if temperature is raised to an excessively high level. The Tg has been illustrated in Fig. 8 by demonstrating the change in stiffness as temperature is increased. However, many other characteristic physical properties (density, strength, thermal expansion coefficient, heat capacity, etc.) also change sharply at this transition. Hence, the Tg can be measured by monitoring any of these physical properties as a function of temperature. The Tg exhibited by a few common polymers is listed in Table 1.
Table 1
Approximate Glass Transition Temperatures for Some Common Polymers Typical glass transition temperature
Polymer Silicone rubber Polybutadiene Polyisoprene Nylon 6,6 Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) Acrylonitrile–butadiene–styrene Polystyrene Polyester Epoxy Polyetheretherketone (PEEK) Polyetherimide
jC
jF
General character at room temperature (22jC or 70jF)
123 85 50 50 85 90 100 150 175 200 215
190 120 60 122 185 195 210 300 350 400 420
Rubbery Rubbery Rubbery Rigid Rigid Rigid Rigid Glassy Glassy Glassy Glassy
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Note that knowledge of the Tg allows an immediate assessment of the general nature of the polymer at room temperature.
3
FIBROUS MATERIALS
Reinforcing fibers are the major strengthening element in all polymeric composites. A brief introduction to these materials is presented in this section. The reader interested in additional details is referred to Refs. 5 and 6. Common continuous fiber materials are:
Glass Aramid Graphite or carbon Polyethylene Boron Silicon carbide.
In all cases, the fiber diameters are quite small, ranging from about 5 to 12 Am for glass, aramid, or graphite fibers; from about 25 to 40 Am for polyethylene fibers; and from about 100 to 200 Am for boron and silicon carbide fibers. Some of the terminologies used to describe fibers will be defined here. The terms fiber and filament are used interchangeably. An end (also called a strand) is a collection of a given number of fibers gathered together. If the fibers are twisted, the collection of fibers is called a yarn. The ends are themselves gathered together to form a tow (also called roving). The fibers are usually coated with a size (also called a finish). The size is applied for several reasons, such as:
To bind the fibers in the strand To lubricate the fibers during fabrication To serve as a coupling and wetting agent to insure a satisfactory adhesive bond between the fiber and matrix materials.
There may be thousands of filaments in a single tow and, in fact, tow sizes are often described in terms of thousands of filaments per tow. For example, a ‘‘6k tow’’ implies that the tow consists of 6000 individual fibers. Properties of several types of glass fibers, organic fibers, carbon fibers, and silicon carbide fibers will be briefly described in the following subsections. It will be seen that:
Young’s modulus (stiffness) ranges from about 70 GPa for glass fibers to 700 GPa (or higher) for carbon fibers.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Comparable tensile strengths can be obtained using any of the fibers listed. Specific gravity ranges from about 0.97 for polyethylene fiber to about 2.5 for glass fibers. Elongation at failure ranges from about 0.3% for some carbon fibers to about 5% for glass fibers. The mechanism responsible for these high stiffnesses and strengths differs from one fiber type to another. For glass fibers, the process of drawing to very small diameters simply reduces the number and size of flaws in the material, thus increasing strength. For example, glass fibers with a diameter of about 1 mm (0.04 in.) will commonly have a strength of about 170 MPa (25 ksi); but if this same glass is drawn to a diameter of 10 Am (0.0004 in.), a strength of about 3450 MPa (500 ksi) will be achieved. For organic fibers, strengthening is accomplished by stretching the fiber and thereby aligning the polymer molecules. This produces fibers that are themselves anisotropic. For carbon or graphite fibers, strengthening is accomplished by aligning the basal planes of adjoining crystals, also producing an anisotropic fiber. 3.1 Glass Fibers Glass fibers are fabricated by melting glass marbles at a temperature of about 1260jC (2300jF) and drawing the melt through platinum bushings followed by a rapid cooldown and secondary drawing. A sizing is applied to the fibers, which are then combined into a strand and wound onto a spool. The two major types of glass fibers are called ‘‘E-glass’’ and ‘‘S-glass.’’ E-glass (alumino borosilicate) is so named (‘‘e’’lectrical glass) because of its high electrical resistivity. S-glass (magnesium aluminosilicate) is so named (‘‘s’’tructural glass) because of its high tensile strength. Glass fibers are usually isotropic. Some mechanical and physical properties typical of E-glass and S-glass fibers are listed in Table 2. 3.2 Aramid Fibers The aramid polymer fiber produced by DuPont Corp. and marketed under the trade name Kevlark is perhaps the most widely used organic fiber. This fiber is based on poly( p-phenylene terephthalamide), which is a member of a family of polymers called ‘‘aramids.’’ Aramid fibers are formed by a condensation/elongation process. The resulting fibers are highly anisotropic because strong covalent bonds are formed in the fiber direction, whereas weak hydrogen bonds are formed in the transverse direction. This chemical
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Table 2
Typical Properties of Glass Fibers
Property Specific gravity Young’s modulus, GPa (Msi) Tensile strength, MPa (ksi) Tensile elongation, % Coefficient of thermal expansion, Am/m/jC (Ain./in./jF)
E-glass
S-glass
2.60 72 (10.5) 3450 (500) 4.8 5.0 (2.8)
2.50 87 (12.6) 4310 (625) 5.0 5.6 (3.1)
bonding arrangement results in the anisotropic behavior exhibited at the macroscale. That is, aramid fibers have very high tensile strength, stiffness, and toughness in the axial direction of the fiber, but relatively low tensile strength and stiffness in the transverse direction. Kevlar is commercially available in the following grades:
Kevlar 149: a high-performance, aerospace grade fiber with the highest modulus of all Kevlar fibers Kevlar 49: a high-performance, aerospace grade fiber with the highest strength of all Kevlar fibers Kevlar 129: a relatively inexpensive fiber with a lower strength and stiffness than Kevlar 149 and 49, but with a higher percent elongation Kevlar 29: a relatively inexpensive fiber with a strength and stiffness lower than Kevlar 129, but a higher percent elongation. Nominal mechanical and physical properties of Kevlar fibers are listed in Table 3. Of particular interest is the negative coefficient of thermal
Table 3
Typical Properties of Kevlar Fibers (All Properties in Axial Direction of Fiber)
Property Specific gravity Young’s modulus, GPa (Msi) Tensile strength, MPa (ksi) Tensile elongation, % Coefficient of thermal expansion, Am/m/jC (Ain./in./jF)
Kevlar 149
Kevlar 49
Kevlar 129
Kevlar 29
1.44 186 (27)
1.44 124 (18)
1.44 96 (13.9)
1.44 68 (9.8)
3440 (500)
3700 (535)
3380 (490)
2930 (425)
2.5 2.0 (1.1)
2.8 2.0 (1.1)
3.3 2.0 (1.1)
3.6 2.0 (1.1)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
expansion in the fiber direction. This implies that an increase in temperature produces a decrease in the length of a Kevlar 49 fiber. This behavior produced unexpected behavior during cooldown from cure in early applications of the fiber. Further research indicates that Kevlar 49 has a high positive coefficient of thermal expansion in the transverse direction, further demonstrating the anisotropic nature of the fiber. 3.3 Graphite and Carbon Fibers The terms ‘‘graphite’’ and ‘‘carbon’’ are often used interchangeably within the composites community. The elemental carbon content of either type of fiber is above 90%, and the stiffest and strongest fibers have carbon contents approaching 100%. Some effort has been made to standardize these terms by defining graphite fibers as those that have:
A carbon content above 95% Been heat-treated at temperatures in excess of 1700jC (3100jF) Been stretched during heat treatment to produce a high degree of preferred crystalline orientation A Young’s modulus on the order of 345 GPa (50 Msi).
Fibers that do not satisfy all of the above conditions are called carbon fibers under this standard. However, as stated above, in practice, this definition is not widely followed, and the terms ‘‘graphite’’ and ‘‘carbon’’ are often used interchangeably. Both graphite and carbon fibers are produced by thermal decomposition of an organic (i.e., polymeric) fiber or ‘‘precursor’’ at high pressures and temperatures. The three most common precursors are:
Polyacrylonitrile (‘‘PAN’’) Pitch (a by-product produced during the petroleum distillation process) Rayon. The PAN fiber is probably the most widely used. Details of the specific steps followed during fabrication of a fiber are proprietary and can only be described in a general manner. During the fabrication process, the precursor is first drawn into a thread and then oxidized at about 260jC (500jF) to form crosslinks and an extended carbon network. The precursor is then subjected to a carbonization treatment, during which noncarboneous atoms are driven off. This step typically involves temperatures of approximately 700jC (1290jF), and is usually conducted in an inert atmosphere. Finally, during the graphitization process, the fibers are subjected to a combination of high temperature and tensile elongation.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The maximum temperature reached during this step determines, in large part, the strength and/or stiffness that will be achieved. The graphite crystal is highly anisotropic, with strong covalent bonds in the basal plane and weak Van der Waals (‘‘secondary’’) bonds perpendicular to the basal plane. High strengths and stiffnesses are attained by causing the basal planes to be aligned in the fiber direction. This can be accomplished by controlled stretching of the precursor during fabrication. Major developmental efforts have resulted in the ability to produce fibers with a wide range of stiffnesses and strengths. Fibers are sometimes classified in terms of the stiffness (i.e., elastic modulus). Mechanical and physical properties typical of low-modulus, intermediate-modulus, and ultrahigh-modulus fibers are listed in Table 4. 3.4 Polyethylene Fibers A high-strength, high-modulus polyethylene fiber called Spectrak was developed at Allied Signal Technologies during the 1980s. Spectra is based on ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene (UHMWPE). It has a specific gravity of 0.97, meaning that it is the only reinforcing fiber available that is lighter than water. Spectra is available in three classifications (Spectra 900, 1000, and 2000) and several grades are available in each class. Nominal properties are listed in Table 5. The high specific strength of the fiber makes it particularly attractive for tensile applications. The glass transition temperature of UHMWPE is in the range of 20jC to 0jC, and hence the fiber is in the rubbery state at room temperatures and exhibits time-dependent (viscoelastic) behavior. This feature imparts outstanding impact resistance and toughness, but may lead to undesirable creep effects under long-term sustained loading. The melting temperature of the fiber is 147jC (297jF),
Table 4
Typical Properties of Commercially Available Graphite Fibers
Property Specific gravity Young’s modulus, GPa (Msi) Tensile strength, MPa (ksi) Elongation, % Coefficient of thermal expansion, Am/m/jC (Ain./in./jF)
Low modulus
Intermediate modulus
Ultra-high modulus
1.8 230 (34)
1.9 370 (53)
2.2 900 (130)
3450 (500)
2480 (360)
3800 (550)
1.1 0.4 (0.2)
0.5 0.5 (0.3)
0.4 0.5 (0.3)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Table 5
Nominal Properties of Spectra Fibers
Property Specific gravity Young’s modulus, GPa (Msi) Tensile strength, MPa (ksi) Elongation, % Coefficient of thermal expansion, Am/m/jC (Ain./in./jF)
Spectra 900
Spectra 1000
Spectra 2000
0.97 70 (10)
0.97 105 (15)
0.97 115 (17)
2600 (380)
3200 (465)
3400 (490)
3.8 >70 (>38)
3.0 >70 (>38)
3.0 >70 (>38)
and hence the use of polyethylene fibers is limited to relatively modest temperatures. The thermal expansion coefficients of Spectra fibers have apparently not been measured. The values listed in Table 5 are estimated based on the properties of bulk high-molecular-weight polyethylene. 3.5 Boron Fibers Boron fibers were one of the first high-performance fibers available for use in composites. They are fabricated by depositing boron on a heated core using the vapor deposition process. Both tungsten and carbon fiber cores have been used. Boron fiber diameters range from 0.1 to 0.2 mm (0.004–0.008 in), which is an order of magnitude larger than glass, aramid, or graphite fibers. Boron fibers have a Young’s modulus of about 410 GPa (60 Msi) and a tensile strength of about 3450 MPa (500 ksi). The combination of a large diameter and high stiffness greatly restricts the bend radius to which the fiber may be subjected. On the other hand, a large fiber diameter and high modulus of elasticity contribute to excellent compressive performance for boronreinforced composites. 3.6 Ceramic Fibers The single most outstanding feature offered by ceramic fibers is that they are resistant to extremely high temperatures while still maintaining competitive structural properties. An example is a silicon carbide fiber marketed under the trade name SCS-Ultrak and fabricated by Specialty Materials, Inc. (Lowell, MA), which can operate at temperatures up to 1200jC (2190jF). This fiber has a modulus of 415 GPa (60 Msi), a strength of 5865 MPa (850 ksi), and a specific gravity of 3.0. A second example is an aluminum– boron–silica fiber fabricated by the 3M Company and marketed under the trade name Nextelk. This fiber is capable of operating at temperatures up
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
to 1650jC (3000jF). It also exhibits excellent properties, with a modulus of 193 GPa (28 Msi), a strength of 2000 MPa (300 ksi), and a specific gravity of 3.03. Because ceramic fibers are normally used at temperatures far in excess of the useable temperature range of polymers, they are rarely used in polymeric composites. Ceramic fibers will not be further discussed in this book.
4
COMMERCIALLY AVAILABLE FORMS
4.1 Discontinuous Fibers Virtually all of the continuous fibers described in Sec. 3 are also available in the form of discontinuous fibers. Discontinuous fibers are embedded within a matrix, and may be randomly oriented (in which case the composite is isotropic at the macroscale) or may be oriented to some extent (in which case the composite is anisotropic at the macroscale). Orientation of discontinuous fibers, if it occurs, is usually induced during the fabrication process used to create the composite material/structure; fiber alignment often mirrors the flow direction during injection molding, for example. Discontinuous fibers are roughly classified according to length, as follows:
Milled fibers are produced by grinding the continuous fiber into very short lengths. For example, milled graphite fibers are available with lengths ranging from about 0.3 to 3 mm (0.0012–0.12 in.), and milled glass fibers are available with lengths ranging from about 0.4 to 6 mm (0.0016–0.24 in.). Chopped fibers (or strands) have a longer length than milled fibers, and composites produced using chopped fibers usually have higher strengths and stiffnesses than those produced using milled fibers. Chopped graphite fibers are available with lengths ranging from about 3 to 50 mm (0.–2.0 in.), while chopped glass fibers are available with lengths ranging from about 6 to 50 mm (0.24–2.0 in.). In general, the mechanical properties of a composite produced using discontinuous fibers (say, the strength or stiffness) are not as good as those that can be obtained using continuous fibers. However, discontinuous fibers allow the use of relatively inexpensive, high-speed manufacturing processes such as injection molding or compression molding, and have therefore been widely used in applications in which extremely high strength or stiffness is not required. One of the most widely used composites systems based on the use of discontinuous fibers is known generically as ‘‘sheet molding compound’’ (SMC). In its most common form, SMC consists of chopped glass fibers
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
embedded within a thermosetting polyester resin. However, other resin systems (e.g., vinyl esters or epoxies) as well as other fibers (e.g., chopped graphite or aramid fibers) are occasionally used in SMC material systems. 4.2 Roving Spools Most continuous fiber types are available in the form of spools of roving (i.e., roving wound onto a cylindrical tube and ultimately resembling a large spool of thread). As mentioned in Sec. 3, roving is also known as tow. The size of tow (or roving) is usually expressed in terms of the number of fibers contained in a single tow. For example, a specific glass fiber might be available in the form of 2k, 3k, 6k, or 12k tow. In this case, the product is available in tows containing from 2000 to 12,000 fibers. Fibers purchased in this form are usually ‘‘dry’’ and are subsequently combined with a polymer, metal, or ceramic matrix during a subsequent manufacturing operation such as filament winding or pultrusion. 4.3 Woven Fabrics Most types of high-performance continuous fibers can be woven to form a fabric. Weaving is accomplished using looms specially modified for use with high-performance fibers, which are stiffer than those customarily used in the textile industry. Woven fabrics are produced in various widths up to about 120 cm (48 in.), and are available in (essentially) infinite lengths. Two terms associated with woven fabrics are:
The tow or yarn running along the length of the fabric is called the warp. The warp direction is parallel to the long axis of the woven fabric. The tow or yarn running perpendicular to the warp is called the fill tow (also called the weft or the woof tow). The fill direction is perpendicular to the warp direction. Some common fabric weaves are shown schematically in Fig. 9. The plane weave (Fig. 9a) is the simplest fabric pattern and is most commonly used. The plane weave is produced by repetitively weaving a given warp tow over one fill tow and under the next. The point at which a tow passes over/ under another tow is called a crossover point. The plane weave pattern results in a very stable and firm fabric that exhibits minimum distortion (e.g., fiber slippage) during handling. A family of woven fabric patterns known as satin weaves provide better drape characteristics than the plane weave pattern. That is, a satin weave is more pliable and will more readily conform to complex curved surfaces than plane weaves. In the crowfoot satin weave (Fig. 9b), one warp tow is woven
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 9 Some common woven fabrics used with high-performance fibers. (From Ref. 7.)
over three successive fill tows and then under one fill tow. In the five-harness satin weave, one warp tow passes over four fill tows and then under one fill tow. Similarly, in an eight-harness satin weave, one warp tow passes over seven fill tows and then under one fill tow. The stiffness and strength of woven fabrics are typically less than that achieved with unidirectional fibers. This decrease is due to fiber waviness.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
That is, in any woven fabric, the tow is required to pass over/under one (or more) neighboring tow(s) at each crossover point, resulting in a pre-existing fiber waviness. Upon application of a tensile load, the fibers within a ply tend to straighten, resulting in a lower stiffness than would be achieved if the ply contained straight unidirectional fibers. Further, due to the weave pattern, the fibers are not allowed to straighten fully and are subjected to bending stresses, resulting in fiber failures at lower tensile loads than would otherwise be achieved if the ply contained unidirectional fibers. This effect is most pronounced in the case of simple weaves because each tow passes over/under each neighboring tow. For simple weaves, the through-thickness distribution of tow in the warp and fill directions is identical. Consequently, the strength and stiffness of simple weaves are usually identical in the warp and fill directions. In contrast, for satin weaves, the through-thickness distribution of tow is inherently asymmetric. Referring to Fig. 9a, for example, for the fiveharness satin weave pattern, the warp tow is primarily within the ‘‘top’’ half of the fabric (as sketched), whereas the fill tow is primarily within the lower half. The asymmetrical through-thickness distribution of tow causes a coupling between in-plane loading and bending deflections. That is, if a uniform tensile load is applied to the midplane of a single layer of a satin weave fabric, the fabric will not only stretch but will also deflect out of plane (i.e., bend). Similarly, the crossover points are not symmetrically located with respect to either the warp or fill directions. This causes a coupling between in-plane loading and in-plane shear strain. That is, an in-plane shear strain is induced if a uniform tensile load is applied to a single layer of a satin weave fabric [7]. A woven fabric is, in essence, a 2D structure consisting of orthogonal warp and fill tows interlaced within a plane. Weaving or stitching several layers of a woven fabric together can produce a woven structure with a significant thickness. Structures produced in this fashion are called ‘‘3D weaves.’’ 4.4 Braided Fabrics Note from Sec. 4.3 that woven fabrics contain reinforcing tow in two orthogonal directions—the warp and fill directions. In contrast, braided fabrics typically contain tow oriented in two (or more) nonorthogonal directions. Three common braiding patterns are shown in Fig. 10. It is apparent from this figure that a braided fabric contains bias tow that intersects at a total included angle 2a. The angle a is called either the braid angle or the bias angle. While the braid angle can be varied over a wide range, there is always some minimum and maximum possible value that depends on the width of the tow and details of the braiding equipment used. Note that if a=45j,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 10 Some common braided fabrics used with high-performance fibers. (From Ref. 7.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
then the bias tows are in fact orthogonal and the braided fabric shown in Fig. 10a and b is equivalent to a woven fabric. A braided fabric is described using the designation nn, where n is the number of tows between crossover points. A 11-bias and a 22-bias braided fabric is shown in Fig. 10a and b, respectively. A 11 triaxial braided fabric is shown in Fig. 10c. In this case, a third axial tow is present. Braided fabrics can be produced in tubular form or as a flat braided fabric. A concise description of the equipment used to produce braided fabrics, as well as a discussion of the maximum and minimum braid angles that can be achieved, is given in Ref. 8. It is also possible to braid 3D structures, in which tows are braided to form a (fibrous) structure that is subsequently infused with a matrix to form the composite. Applications include ‘‘I’’ or ‘‘T’’ cross sections, typically used with resin transfer molding (RTM) to produce composite stiffeners or beams. In contrast to structures produced using fabrics (which may be unidirectional, woven, or braided fabrics), in a 3D braided structure, there are no recognizable layers. 4.5 Preimpregnated Products or ‘‘Prepreg’’ As is obvious from the preceding discussion, at some point during the fabrication of a polymer composite, the reinforcing fiber must be embedded within the polymeric matrix. One approach is to combine the fiber and resin during the manufacturing operation in which the final form of the composite structure is defined. Three manufacturing processes in which this approach is taken are filament winding (briefly described in Sec. 5.3), pultrusion (Sec. 5.4), and resin transfer molding (Sec. 5.5). An alternative approach is to combine the fiber and matrix in an intermediate step, resulting in an intermediate product. In this case, either individual tow or a thin fabric of tow (which may be woven or braided) is embedded within a polymeric matrix and delivered to the user in this form. Because the fibers have already been embedded within a polymeric matrix when delivered, the fibers are said to have been ‘‘preimpregnated’’ with resin, and products delivered in this condition are commonly known as ‘‘prepreg.’’ The method used to impregnate a large number of unidirectional tows with resin is illustrated in Fig. 11 [9]. As indicated, tows delivered from a large number of roving spools are arranged in a relatively narrow band. The tows are passed through a resin bath and then wound onto a roll. An inert backing sheet (called a scrim cloth) is placed between layers on the roll to maintain a physical separation between layers and to aid during subsequent handling and processing. The tows/fibers are subjected to various surface pretreatments just prior to entering the resin bath. The pretreatments are proprietary but are intended to cause good wetting of the fiber by the resin,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 11 (a) Method used to impregnate unidirectional tows with resin. (b) A 3-in. wide roll of ‘‘prepreg tape.’’
which ultimately helps ensure good adhesion between the fibers and polymer matrix in the cured composite. Products produced in this fashion are commonly known as ‘‘prepreg tape’’ (Fig. 11b). Prepreg tape is available in width ranging from about 75 to 1220 mm (3–48 in.). Prepreg fabrics, produced using either woven or braided fabrics instead of unidirectional tows, are produced using similar techniques and are also available in widths ranging from about 75 to 1220 mm. A variety of fabrication methods have been developed based on the use of prepreg materials. A few such techniques will be described in Sec. 5. The first commercially successful prepreg materials were based on Bstaged epoxy resins. As discussed in Sec. 2, in the B-staged condition, a thermoset resin has been partially polymerized, resulting in relatively high viscosity, which aids in handling B-staged prepreg materials. However, prepreg must be kept at low temperatures until used, otherwise the resin continues to polymerize and slowly harden. This required that the prepreg be shipped to the user in a refrigerated condition (for small amounts, this is
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
often accomplished using insulated shipping containers and dry ice). Furthermore, the user must keep the stock of prepreg on hand refrigerated until used. Typically, storage temperatures are required to be 15jC (0jF) or below. In practice, the prepreg material stock is removed from freezer, the amount of prepreg necessary is removed from the roll of stock, and the remaining stock is returned to the freezer. Hence, the cumulative ‘‘out-time’’ that a given roll of prepreg stock has experienced (i.e., total amount of time a roll has been out of a freezer) must be monitored and recorded. The need to store thermoset prepreg in a refrigerated condition and to maintain accurate records of cumulative out-time is a significant disadvantage because these factors add significantly to the final cost of the composite structure. More recently, prepreg materials based on thermoplastic resins have become commercially available. In this case, the polymeric matrix is a fully cured thermoplastic polymer, and hence the prepreg does not require refrigeration during shipping or storage, which is a distinct advantage. Heat and/or pressure is applied during the final fabrication of a composite based on prepreg materials. In the case of thermoset prepregs, heat and pressure serve to complete the polymerization of the polymeric resin (i.e., the composite is ‘‘C-staged’’). For thermoplastic prepreg, the objective is not necessarily to complete the polymerization but rather to melt the thermoplastic matrix so as to consolidate individual plies within the laminate.
5
MANUFACTURING PROCESSES
Fiber-reinforced composites may be produced using metallic, ceramic, or polymeric matrices. However, polymeric composites are the primary focus of this book, and so techniques used to fabricate metal or ceramic composite structures will not be discussed. Even with this limitation, a complete review of the many different manufacturing processes used to produce polymeric composite materials and structures is beyond the scope of this presentation. Instead, only the most common manufacturing techniques will be described. 5.1 Layup Many composites are produced using the tapes or fabrics discussed in Sec. 4.1. These may be unidirectional tape, woven fabrics, or braided fabrics. These products are all relatively thin. ‘‘Layup’’ simply refers to the process of stacking several layers together, much like a deck of cards. Stacking several layers together produces a laminate of significant thickness. The most direct method of producing a multi-ply composite laminate is to simply stack the desired number of layers of fabric by hand, referred to as ‘‘hand layup.’’ The layers may consist of either ‘‘dry’’ fabrics (i.e., fabrics that have not yet been
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
impregnated with a resin) or prepreg materials. As will be discussed in later chapters, fiber angles are typically varied from one ply to the next, so as to insure adequate stiffness in more than one direction. Whereas hand layup is simple and straightforward, it is labor-intensive and therefore costly. It can also be very cumbersome if a large structure is being produced, such as a fuselage panel intended for use in a modern commercial aircraft. Therefore, various computer-controlled machines that automate the process of assembling the ply stack using prepreg materials have been developed. These include tow placement and tape placement machines (see Fig. 12). In either case, a roll (or rolls) of prepreg material is mounted on the head of a computer-controlled robot arm or gantry. The appropriate number of layers of prepreg is placed on a tool surface automatically and in the desired orientation. Although the capital costs of modern tow placement or tape placement machines may be very high, overall, this approach is often less costly than hand layup if production quantities are sufficiently high. In the case of dry fabrics (which are usually either woven or braided fabrics), the stack must be impregnated with a low-viscosity polymeric resin following assembly of the fiber stack. Conceptually, this may be accomplished by pouring liquidous resin over the dry fiber stack and using a squeegee or
Figure 12 A computer-controlled tape-laying machine, used to produce the composite skin used in the vertical stabilizer for a Boeing 777 aircraft. (Copyright n The Boeing Company.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
similar device to assist the resin to wet the fibers within the stack. This technique is commonly used in the recreational boat-building industry, for example. However, as can be imagined, it is very difficult to insure uniform penetration of the resin and wetting of the fibers through the thickness of the stack, to insure that no air pockets remain trapped in the stack, and to avoid distortion of the fiber patterns while forcing resin into the fibrous assembly. There are also potential health issues associated with continually exposing workers to nonpolymerized resins. Hence, the technique of impregnating a dry fiber stack using handheld tools such as squeegees is rarely employed in industries requiring low variability in stiffness and strength and/ or high volumes, such as the aerospace or automotive industries, for example. Alternate methods of impregnating a dry fiber stack with resin have been developed, such as resin transfer molding (discussed in Sec. 5.5). These alternate techniques result in a composite with a much more uniform matrix volume fraction and almost no void content. A major advantage of using prepreg materials, of course, is that the fibers have been impregnated with resin a priori. Therefore, it is much easier to maintain the desired matrix volume fraction and to avoid entrapped airpockets. Further, prepreg material based on a B-staged thermoset are typically ‘‘tacky’’ (i.e., prepreg materials adhere to neighboring plies much like common masking tape), and hence once a given ply has been placed in the desired orientation, it is less likely to move or be distorted relative to neighboring plies than is the case with dry fabrics. 5.2 Autoclave Process Cycles Following layup (which may be accomplished using hand layup, automatic tow placement or tape placement machines, or other techniques), the individual plies must be consolidated to form a solid laminate. Usually, consolidation occurs through the application of pressure and heat. Although a simple hot press can be used for this purpose, applying pressure and heat using an autoclave produces highest-quality composites. An autoclave is simply a closed pressure vessel that can be used to apply a precisely controlled and simultaneous cycle of vacuum, pressure, and elevated temperature to the laminate during the consolidation process. Although many variations exist, a typical assembly used to consolidate a laminate using an autoclave is shown in Fig. 13. Some of the details of the assembly are as follows:
The final shape of the composite is defined by a rigid tool. A simple flat tool is shown in Fig. 13, but in practice, the tool is rarely flat but instead mirrors the contour(s) desired in the final product. For example, the surface of a tool used to produce the skin of an air-
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 13 Typical assembly used to consolidate a polymeric composite laminate using an autoclave (expanded edge view).
plane wing would possess the curvature(s) necessary to provide an aerodynamic surface. Various materials may be used to produce the tool, including steel alloys, aluminum alloys, ceramics, or composite materials. The tool surface is coated with a release agent. Various liquid or wax release agents are available, which are either sprayed or wiped onto the surface. The purpose of the release agent is to prevent adherence between the tool and the polymeric matrix. A peel ply is placed next to both upper and lower surfaces of the composite laminate. The release ply does not develop a strong bond to the composite, and hence can be easily removed following consolidation. The peel ply may be porous or nonporous. Porous peel plies allow resin to pass through the ply and be adsorbed by an adjacent bleeder/breather cloth (see below). Note that the surface texture of the consolidated laminate will be a mirror image of the peel ply used. For example, Teflon-coated porous glass fabrics are often used as peel plies, and these fabrics have a clothlike surface texture. Hence, a composite laminate consolidated with such fabrics will exhibit a clothlike surface texture as well. One or more layers of a breather/bleeder cloth is placed adjacent to the porous peel ply. The bleeder cloth has the texture of a rather stiff cotton ball. Its purpose is to allow any gases released to be vented (hence the adjective breather), and also to adsorb any resin that passed through the porous peel ply (hence the adjective bleeder). The breather/bleeder is usually a glass, polyester, or jute cloth.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
An edge dam is placed around the periphery of the laminate. The edge dam is intended to maintain the position and resin content of the laminate edges. A pressure plate (also called a caul plate) is placed over the breather/ bleeder cloth. The pressure plate insures a uniform distribution of pressures over the surface of the laminate. The entire assembly is sealed within a vacuum film or bag. Often this is a relatively thick (say, 5 mm) layer of silicone rubber. Sealant tape is used to adhere the vacuum film to the tool surface, providing a pressure-tight seal around the periphery of the vacuum film. The volume within the vacuum bag is evacuated by means of a vacuum port, which is often permanently attached to the silicone rubber vacuum film. The vacuum port often features a quick-disconnect fitting, which allows for easy connection to a vacuum pump or line. Following vacuum bagging of the laminate, the assembly is placed within an autoclave, the autoclave is sealed, and the thermomechanical process cycle that will consolidate the composite is initiated. A bagged composite laminate being loaded into an autoclave is shown in Fig. 14. The thermomechanical process cycle imposed using an autoclave varies from one composite prepreg system to the next, and also depends on part
Figure 14 A vacuum-bagged composite skin used in the tail-section of a Boeing 777 aircraft, about to be loaded into a large autoclave. (Copyright n The Boeing Company.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
configuration (e.g., part thickness). Recall that if the prepreg is based on a Bstage thermoset resin, then the autoclave is used to complete the polymerization of the resin (i.e., the composite is C-staged). Alternatively, if the prepreg is based on a thermoplastic, the pressure and heat applied during the autoclave cycle soften the matrix and insure polymer flow across the ply interfaces. The laminate is then solidified upon cooling. A typical cure cycle, suitable for use with standard thermosetting resin systems such as epoxies, is as follows:
Draw and hold a vacuum within the vacuum bag, resulting in a pressure of roughly 100 kPa (14.7 psi) applied to the laminate. The vacuum is typically maintained for about 30 min, and is intended to remove any entrapped air or volatiles, and to hold the laminate in place. While maintaining a vacuum, increase the temperature from room temperature to about 120jC (250jF), at a rate of about 2.8jC/min (5jF/min). Maintain this temperature for 30 min. During this 30-min dwell time, any remaining air or other volatiles are removed. After 30 min, increase autoclave pressure from atmospheric to about 585 kPa (85 psi), at a rate of 21 kPa/min (3 psi/min). Release vacuum when autoclave pressure reaches 138 kPa (20 psi). When an autoclave pressure of 585 kPa is reached, increase the temperature from 120jC to 175jC (350jF), at a rate of about 2.8jC/ min (5jF/min). Maintain temperature at 175jC for 2 hr. Polymerization of the thermosetting resin matrix is completed during this 2-hr dwell. Cool to room temperature at a rate of about 2.8jC/min (5jF/min), release autoclave pressure, and remove cured laminate from the autoclave.
Process cycles used with thermoplastic prepregs are similar, except that higher temperatures (500jC or higher) are involved. 5.3 Filament Winding Filament winding is an automated process in which tow is wound onto a mandrel at controlled position and orientation. A filament winder being used to produce a small rocket motor case is shown in Fig. 15 [10]. During operation, the mandrel rotates about its axis, and a fiber carriage simultaneously moves in a controlled manner along the length of the mandrel. The angle at which fibers are placed on the mandrel surface is a function of the mandrel diameter, rate of mandrel rotation, and translational speed of the fiber carriage. The mandrel can include domed heads to accommodate fiber
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 15 A carbon-epoxy pressure vessel being produced using the filamentwinding process and unidirectional prepreg. The prepreg used in this case is based on large 50k tows of Zoltek Panexo 35 carbon fiber. (a) A band of prepreg is wound onto a mandrel, forming a Fhj fiber pattern. (b) Eventually the mandrel is completely enclosed by one or more Fhj plies. (c) One or more 90j (‘‘hoop’’) plies are often added to the cylindrical region to resist the high hoop stresses induced in cylindrical pressure vessels. (Photos provided courtesy of Entec Composite Machines Inc., Salt Lake City, UT.) R
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
turnaround at the ends, or to wind the domes of a cylindrical pressure vessel (as shown in Fig. 15). If dry tows are used, then the tow must pass through a liquid resin bath before being wound onto the mandrel. In this case, the process is often referred to as ‘‘wet’’ winding. Often fiber tension provides sufficient compaction of the laminate, and so no additional external pressure is required. If a thermosetting resin that cures at room temperature is used, following completion of the winding operation, the structure is simply left in the winder until polymerization is complete. Of course, if prepreg tow is used, then the tow is already impregnated with a resin and is not passed through a resin bath. This process is called ‘‘dry’’ winding. In this case, heat and pressure are normally required to complete polymerization of the resin (in the case of a thermosetting polymer matrix), or to cause resin flow and consolidation (in the case of a thermoplastic polymer matrix). The appropriate heat and pressure are usually applied using an autoclave. Filament winding machines are available in highly automated, numerically controlled models (costing millions of dollars), but high-quality filament winding can also be accomplished for simple shapes and patterns on inexpensive gear/chain-driven machines similar to a lathe. For simple wound shapes with open ends (such as tubes), the mandrel is usually a simple solid cylinder whose surface has been coated with a release agent. In this case, the mandrel is forced out of the internal cavity after consolidation of the composite. Mandrel design and configuration become more complex when a shape with restricted openings at the ends is produced (such as the pressure tank shown in Fig. 15). In these cases, the mandrel must somehow be removed after the part is consolidated. Several different types of mandrel designs are used in these cases, including:
Soluble mandrels, which are made from a material that can be dissolved in some fashion after the cure process is complete. In this approach, the mandrel is cast and machined to the desired shape, the composite part is filament wound over the mandrel, the part is cured, and the mandrel is then simply dissolved. The wall of the composite structure must obviously have at least one opening, such that the dissolved (and now liquidous) mandrel material can be drained from the internal cavity. Soluble mandrels can be made from metallic alloys with suitably low-melting temperatures, eutectic salts, sand with water-soluble binders, or various plasters. Removable (or collapsible) mandrels, which resemble giant 3D puzzles. That is, the entire mandrel can be taken apart piece by piece. The composite structure being wound must have at least one wall opening,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
which allows the mandrel pieces to be removed from the internal cavity after cure. Obviously, the mandrel is designed such that no single piece is larger than the available opening(s). ‘‘Inflatable’’ mandrels, which take on the desired shape when pressurized and then are simply deflated and removed after winding and consolidation. Metal or polymer liners, which are actually a modification of the inflatable mandrel concept. Liners can be described as metal or polymer ‘‘balloons’’ and remain in the filament wound vessel after cure. The liner does not contribute significantly to the strength or stiffness of the structure. In fact, the wall thickness of the liner is often so small that an internal pressure must be applied to the liner during the winding process to avoid buckling of the liner wall. Metal liners are almost always used in composite pressure vessels, where allowable leakage rates are very low, or in filament wound chemical storage tanks, where corrosive liquids are stored. 5.4 Pultrusion Pultrusion is a fabrication process in which continuous tows or fabrics impregnated with resin are pulled through a forming die, as shown schematically in Fig. 16 [10]. If dry tow or fabric is used, then the tow/fabric must
Figure 16 Sketch of a typical pultruder.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
pass through a resin bath prior to entering the forming die. In this case, the process is called ‘‘wet’’ pultrusion. If prepreg material is used, then there is no need for a resin bath and the process is called ‘‘dry’’ pultrusion. The cross-sectional shape is defined by the die and is therefore constant along the length of the part. The principal attraction of pultrusion is that very high production rates are possible, as compared to other composite manufacturing techniques. 5.5 Resin Transfer Molding In the resin transfer molding process, a dry fiber preform is placed within a cavity formed between two rigid molds, as shown in Fig. 17. The dry preform may consist of a 3D braided structure, or may be made by stitching together multiple layers of 2D woven or braided fabrics. Liquidous resin is forced into the cavity under pressure via a port located in the upper or lower mold halves. Air originally within the internal cavity (or other gases that evolve during cure of the resin) is allowed to escape via one or more air vents. Alternatively, a vacuum pump may be used to evacuate the internal cavity, which also assists in drawing the resin into the cavity. When a vacuum is used, the process is called ‘‘vacuum-assisted resin transfer molding’’ (VARTM). Both the upper and lower molds must be sufficiently rigid so as to resist the internal pressures applied and to maintain the desired shape of the internal cavity. Usually, the closed molds are placed within a press, which provides a clamping pressure to assist in keeping the molds closed. 6
THE SCOPE OF THIS BOOK
A broad overview of modern composite materials has been provided in the preceding sections. It should be clear from this discussion that modern
Figure 17 Picture/sketch of the RTM process.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
polymeric composite material systems are a multidisciplinary subject, involving topics drawn from polymer chemistry, fiber science, surface chemistry and adhesion, materials testing, structural analysis, and manufacturing techniques, to name a few. It is simply not possible to cover all of these topics in any depth in a single book. Accordingly, the material presented in this book represents a small fraction of the scientific and technological developments that have ultimately led to the successful use of modern composite material systems. Specifically, the focus of this text is the structural analysis of laminated, continuous-fiber polymeric composite materials and structures. Having identified the structural analysis of laminated continuous-fiber polymeric composites as our focus, we must make still another decision: At what physical scale should we frame our analysis? The importance of physical scale has already been discussed in Sec. 1 in conjunction with the very definition of a ‘‘composite material.’’ Specifically, we have defined a composite as a material system consisting of two (or more) materials, which are distinct at a physical scale greater than about 1 Am and which are bonded together at the atomic and/or molecular levels. Fibers commonly used in polymeric composites possess diameters ranging from about 5 to 40 Am (Sec. 3). Therefore, we could perform a structural analysis at a physical scale comparable to the fiber diameter. Alternatively, laminated polymeric composites consist of well-defined layers (called ‘‘plies’’) of fibers embedded in a polymeric matrix. The thickness of these layers ranges from about 0.125 to 0.250 mm (Sec. 4). We could therefore elect to begin a structural analysis at a physical scale comparable to the thickness of a single ply. A distinction is drawn between structural analyses that begin at these two different physical scales. Analyses that are framed at a physical scale corresponding to the fiber diameter (or below) are classified as micromechanics analyses, whereas those framed at a physical scale corresponding to a single ply thickness (or above) are classified as macromechanics analyses. This distinction is comparable to the traditional distinction between metallurgy and continuum mechanics. That is, metallurgy typically involves the study of the crystalline nature of metals and metal alloys, and is therefore framed at a physical scale roughly corresponding to atomic dimensions. A metallurgist might attempt to predict Young’s modulus* of a given metal alloy, based on knowledge of the constituent atoms and crystalline structure present in the alloy, for example. In contrast, continuum mechanics is formulated at a much larger physical scale, such that the existence of indi-
* The definition of various material properties of interest to the structural engineer, such as Young’s modulus, will be reviewed and discussed in greater detail in Chap. 3.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
vidual atoms is not recognized. In continuum mechanics, a metal or metal alloy is said to be ‘‘homogeneous’’ even though it actually consists of several different atomic species. A structural engineer wishing to apply a solution based on continuum mechanics would simply measure Young’s modulus exhibited by the metal alloy of interest, rather than try to predict it based on knowledge of the atomic crystalline structure. In much the same way, composite micromechanics analyses are concerned with the predicting properties of composites based on the particular fiber and matrix materials involved, the spacing and orientation of the fibers, the adhesion (or lack thereof ) between fiber and matrix, etc. For example, suppose that a unidirectional graphite–epoxy composite is to be produced by combining graphite fibers with a known Young’s modulus (Ef) and an epoxy matrix with a known Young’s modulus (Em). An analysis framed at a physical scale corresponding to the fiber diameter (i.e., a micromechanics analysis) is required to predict the Young’s modulus that will be exhibited by the composite (Ec) formed using these two constituents. In contrast, composite macromechanics analyses are framed at a physical scale corresponding to the ply thickness (or above). The existence or properties of individual fibers or the matrix material are not recognized (in a mathematical sense) in a macromechanics analysis. Instead, the ply is treated as a homogenous layer whose properties is identical at all points, although they differ in different directions. Details of fiber or matrix type, fiber spacing, fiber orientation, etc., are represented in a macromechanics analysis only indirectly, via properties defined for the composite ply as a whole, rather than as properties of the individual constituents. Micromechanics-based structural analyses will not be discussed in any detail. A simple micromechanics model that may be used to predict ply stiffnesses based on knowledge of fiber and matrix properties, called the rule of mixtures, will be developed in Sec. 6 in Chap. 3. However, the material devoted to micromechanics in this text is abbreviated and does not do justice to the many advances made in this area. The lack of emphasis on micromechanical topics is not meant to imply that such analyses are unimportant. Quite the contrary, micromechanics analyses are crucial during development of new composite material systems because it is only through a detailed understanding of the behavior of composites at this physical scale that new and improved materials can be created. Micromechanics has been minimized herein simply due to space restrictions. The reader interested in learning more about micromechanics is referred to several excellent texts that cover this topic in greater detail, a few of which are Refs. 5, 7, 11, and 14. Finally, then, the scope of this book is macromechanics-based structural analysis of laminated, continuous-fiber polymeric composites.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4.
5.
6. 7.
8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
Rodriguez, F. Principles of Polymer Systems; 3rd Ed.; Hemisphere Publ. Co.: New York, 1989; ISBN 0-89116-176-7. Young, R.J.; Lovell, P.A. Introduction to Polymers; 2nd Ed.; Chapman and Hall Publ. Co.: New York, 1991; ISBN 0-89116-176-7. Strong, A.B. Plastics: Materials and Processing; 2nd Ed.; Prentice-Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ, 2000. ISBN 0-13-021626-7. The Macrogalleria (http://www.psrc.usm.edu/macrog/index.htm), website maintained by the University of Southern Mississippi and devoted to polymeric materials. Watt, W., Perov, B.V., Eds. Strong Fibres; Vol. 1. In Handbook of Composite Materials; Kelly, A., Rabotnov, Y.N., Series Eds.; Elsevier Sci. Publ.: New York, NY, 1985; ISBN 0-444-87505-0. Donnet, J.-B.; Wang, T.K.; Peng, J.C.M.; Reboillat, M. Carbon Fibers; 3rd Ed.; Marcel Dekker, Inc.: New York, NY, 1998; ISBN 0-8247-0172-0. Cox, B.; Flanagan, G. Handbook of Analytical Methods for Textile Composites. NASA Contractor Report 4750. NASA-Langley Res. Ctr., Hampton, VA, 1997. Hasselbrack, S.A.; Pederson, C.L.; Seferis, J.C. Evaluation of carbon–fiber reinforced thermoplastic matrices in a flat braid process. Polym. Compos. 1992, 13 (1), 38–46. Kalpakjian, S. Manufacturing Processes for Engineering Materials; 3rd Ed.; Addison-Wesley Longman, Inc.: Menlo Park CA, 1997; ISBN 0-201-82370-5. Schwartz, M.M. Composite Materials Handbook; New York, NY, McGraw-Hill Book Co.: 1983; ISBN 0-07-055743-8. Hyer, M.W. Stress Analysis of Fiber-Reinforced Composite Materials; New York, NY,McGraw-Hill Book Co.: 1998; ISBN 0-07-016700-1. Herakovich, C.T. Mechanics of Fibrous Composites; John Wiley and Sons: New York, NY, 1998; ISBN 0-471-10636-4. Jones, R.M. Mechanics of Composite Materials; McGraw-Hill Book Co.: New York, NY, 1975; ISBN 0-07-032790-4. Hull, D. An Introduction to Composite Materials; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1981; ISBN 0-521-23991-5.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2 Review of Force, Stress, and Strain Tensors
In this chapter, the fundamental definitions of force vectors, stress tensors, and strain tensors are reviewed. The chapter begins with a discussion of force vectors, since the concept of ‘‘force’’ is encountered in everyday life and is therefore very intuitive. Separate sections devoted to stress tensors and strain tensors are then presented. Certain parallels will be drawn between force vectors and stress/strain tensors. An important underlying principal is that a tensor cannot be described in a mathematical sense until a specific coordinate system is selected for use. Also, a tensor cannot be properly described using only a single component of the tensor, i.e., all components of a tensor must be known in order to describe the tensor.
1 THE FORCE VECTOR Forces can be grouped into two broad categories: surface forces and body forces. Surface forces are those that act over a surface (as the name implies) and result from direct physical contact between two bodies. In contrast, body forces are those that act at a distance and do not result from direct physical contact of one body with another. The force of gravity is the most common type of body force. In this text, we are primarily concerned with surface forces; the effects of body forces (such as the weight of a structure) will be ignored.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
A force is a 3-D vector. A force is defined by a magnitude and a line of action. In SI units, the magnitude of a force is expressed in Newtons, abbreviated N, whereas in English units, the magnitude of a force is expressed in pounds-force, abbreviated lbf. A force vector F acting at a point P and referenced to a right-handed x–y–z coordinate system is shown in Fig. 1. Components of F acting parallel to the x–y–z coordinate axes, Fx, Fyy, and Fz, respectively, are also shown in the figure. The algebraic sign of each force component is defined in accordance with the algebraically positive direction of the corresponding coordinate axis. All force components shown in Fig. 1 are algebraically positive since each component ‘‘points’’ in the corresponding positive coordinate direction. The reader is likely to have encountered several different ways of expressing force vectors in a mathematical sense. Three methods will be described here. The first is called vector notation and involves the use of unit vectors. Unit vectors parallel to the x-, y-, and z-coordinate axes are typically labeled ıˆ, jˆ, and kˆ, respectively, and by definition have a magnitude equal to unity. A force vector F is written in vector notation as follows: F ¼ Fx iˆ þ Fy jˆ þ Fz kˆ
ð1Þ
The magnitude of the force is given by: qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi jF j ¼ Fx2 þ Fy2 þ F 2z
ð2Þ
Figure 1 A force vector F acting at point P. Force components Fx, Fy, and Fz acting parallel to the x–y–z coordinate axes, respectively, are also shown.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
A second method of defining a force vector is through the use of indicial notation. In this case, a subscript is used to denote individual components of the vectorial quantity: F ¼ ðFx ; Fy ; Fz Þ The subscript denotes the coordinate direction of each force component. One of the advantages of indicial notation is that it allows a shorthand notation to be used, as follows: F ¼ Fi ;
where i ¼ x; y; or z
ð3Þ
Note that a range has been explicitly specified for the subscript i in Eq. (3). That is, it is explicitly stated that the subscript i may take on values of x, y, or z. Usually, however, the range of a subscript(s) is not stated explicitly but rather is implied. For example, Eq. (3) is normally written simply as: F ¼ Fi where it is understood that the subscript i takes on values of x, y, and z. The third approach is called matrix notation. In this case, individual components of the force vector are listed within braces in the form of a column array: 8 9 < Fx = ð4Þ F ¼ Fy : ; Fz Indicial notation is sometimes combined with matrix notation as follows: F ¼ fFi g
ð5Þ
2 TRANSFORMATION OF A FORCE VECTOR One of the most common requirements in the study of mechanics is the need to describe a vector in more than one coordinate system. For example, suppose all components of a force vector Fi are known in one coordinate system (say, the x–y–z coordinate system), and it is desired to express this force vector in a second coordinate system (say, the xV–yV–zV coordinate system). In order to describe the force vector in the new coordinate system, we must calculate the components of the force parallel to the x V-, y V-, and zV-axes—that is, we must calculate FxV, FyV, and FzV. The process of relating force components in one coordinate system to those in another coordinate system is called the transformation of the force vector. This terminology is perhaps unfortunate in the sense that the force vector itself is not ‘‘transformed,’’ but rather our de-
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
scription of the force vector transforms as we change from one coordinate system to another. It can be shown (1,2) that the force components in the xV–yV–zV coordinate system ( FxV, FyV, and FzV) are related to the components in the x–y–z coordinate system ( Fx, Fy, and Fz) according to: FxV ¼ cxVx Fx þ cx Vy Fy þ cxVz Fz
ð6aÞ
Fy V ¼ cy Vx Fx þ cy Vy Fy þ cy Vz Fz FzV ¼ czVx Fx þ czVy Fy þ czVz Fz The terms ci Vj that appear in Eq. (6a) are called direction cosines and equal the cosine of the angle between the axes of the new and original coordinate systems. An angle of rotation is defined from the original x–y–z coordinate system to the new xV–yV–zV coordinate system. The algebraic sign of the angle of rotation is defined in accordance with the right-hand rule. Equation (6a) can be succinctly written using the summation convention as follows: FiV ¼ ci Vj Fj
ð6bÞ
Alternatively, these three equations can be written using matrix notation as: 8 9 2 38 9 cxVx cx Vy cxVz < Fx = < FxV = ¼ 4 cy Vx cy Vy cy Vz 5 Fy ð6cÞ F : yV ; : ; czV x czVy czVz FzV Fz Note that although values of individual force components vary as we change from one coordinate system to another, the magnitude of the force vector [given by Eq. (2)] does not. The magnitude is independent of the coordinate system used and is called an invariant of the force tensor. Direction cosines relate unit vectors in the ‘‘new’’ and ‘‘old’’ coordinate systems. For example, a unit vector directed along the xV-axis (i.e., unit vector ıˆV) is related to the unit vectors in the x–y–z coordinate system as follows: iVˆ ¼ cx Vx iˆ þ cxVy jˆ þ cx Vz kˆ
ð7Þ
Since iˆ V is a unit vector, then in accordance with Eq. (2): ðcx Vx Þ2 þ ðcxVy Þ2 þ ðcxVz Þ2 ¼ 1
ð8Þ
To this point, we have referred to a force as a vector. A force vector can also be called a force tensor. The term ‘‘tensor’’ refers to any quantity that transforms in a physically meaningful way from one Cartesian coordinate system to another. The rank of a tensor equals the number of subscripts that must be used to describe the tensor. A force can be described using a single
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
subscript, Fi, and therefore a force is said to be a tensor of rank one, or equivalently, a first-order tensor. Equations (6a)–(6c) is called the transformation law for a first-order tensor. It is likely that the reader is already familiar with two other tensors: the stress tensor, rij, and the strain tensor, eij. The stress and strain tensors will be reviewed later in this chapter, but at this point, it can be noted that two subscripts are used to describe stress and strain tensors. Hence, stress and strain tensors are said to be tensors of rank two, or equivalently, second-order tensors. Example Problem 1 Given. All components of a force vector F are known in a given x–y–z coordinate system. It is desired to express this force in a new xU–yU–zU coordinate system, where the xU–yU–zU is generated from the original x–y– z coordinate system by the following two rotations (see Fig. 2):
A rotation of h about the original z-axis (which defines an intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system), followed by A rotation of b about the xV-axis (which defines the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system). Problem. (a) Determine the direction cosines ciUj relating the original x–y–z coordinate system to the new xU–yU–zU coordinate system; (b) obtain a general expression for the force vector F in the xU–yU–zU coordinate system; and (c) calculate numerical values of the force vector F in the xU–yU–zU coordinate system if h=20j, b=60j, and Fx=1000 N, Fy=200 N, Fz=600 N. Solution Part (a). One way to determine the direction cosines ciUj is to rotate unit vectors. In this approach, unit vectors are first rotated from the original x–y–z coordinate system to the intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system, and then from the xV–yV–zV system to the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system. Define a unit vector I that is aligned with the x-axis: I u ð1Þiˆ That is, vector I is a vector for which Ix=1, Iy=0, and Iz=0. The vector I can be rotated to the intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system using Eqs. (6a)–(6c): IxV ¼ cxV x Ix þ cxV y Iy þ cxV z Iz IyV ¼ cyV x Ix þ cyV y Iy þ cyV z Iz IzV ¼ czV x Ix þ czV y Iy þ czV z Iz
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 2 Generation of the xW–yW–zW coordinate system from the x–y–z coordinate system.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The direction cosines associated with a transformation from the x–y–z coordinate system to the intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system can be determined by inspection [see Fig. 2(a)] and are given by: cxV x ¼ cosine ðangle between xV- and x-axesÞ ¼ cos h cxV y ¼ cosine ðangle between xV- and y-axesÞ ¼ cosð90B hÞ ¼ sin h cxV z ¼ cosine ðangle between xV- and z-axesÞ ¼ cosð90B Þ ¼ 0 cyV x ¼ cosine ðangle between the yV- and x-axesÞ ¼ cosð90B þ hÞ ¼ sin h cyV y ¼ cosine ðangle between the yV- and y -axesÞ ¼ cos h cyV z ¼ cosine ðangle between the yV- and z-axesÞ ¼ cosð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV x ¼ cosine ðangle between the zV- and x-axesÞ ¼ cosð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV y ¼ cosine ðangle between the zV- and y-axesÞ ¼ cosð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV z ¼ cosine ðangle between the zV- and z-axesÞ ¼ cosð0B Þ ¼ 1 Using these direction cosines: IxV ¼ cxV x Ix þ cxV y Iy þ cxV z Iz ¼ ðcos hÞð1Þ þ ðsin hÞð0Þ þ ð0Þð0Þ ¼ cos h IyV ¼ cyV x Ix þ cyV y Iy þ cyV z Iz ¼ ðsin hÞð1Þ þ ðcos hÞð0Þ þ ð0Þð0Þ ¼ sin h IzV ¼ czV x Ix þ czV y Iy þ czV z Iz ¼ ð0Þð1Þ þ ð0Þð0Þ þ ð1Þð0Þ ¼ 0 Therefore, in the xV–yV–zV coordinate system, the vector I is written as: I ¼ ðcos hÞiˆ V þ ðsin hÞjˆ V Now define two additional unit vectors, one aligned with the original y-axis (vector J ) and one aligned with the original z-axis (vector K ), i.e., let J=(1) jˆ and K=(1) kˆ. Transforming these vectors to the xV–yV–zV coordinate system, again using the direction cosines listed above, results in: J ¼ ðsin hÞiˆ V þ ðcos hÞjˆ V K ¼ ð1Þ kˆ V We now rotate vectors I , J, and K from the intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system to the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system. The direction cosines associated with a transformation from the xV–yV–zV coordinate system to the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system are easily determined by inspection [see Fig. 2(b)] and are given by: cx Ux V ¼ 1 cy Ux V ¼ 0 cz Ux V ¼ 0
cx Uy V ¼ 0 cy Uy V ¼ cos b cz Uy V ¼ sin b
cx Uz V ¼ 0 cy Uz V ¼ sin b cz Uz V ¼ cos b
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
These direction cosines together with Eqs. (6a)–(6c) can be used to rotate the vector I from the intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system to the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system: Ix W ¼ cxW xV IxV þ cxW yV IyV þ cxW zV IzV ¼ ð1Þðcos hÞ þ ð0Þðsin hÞ þ ð0Þð0Þ IxW ¼ cos h IyW ¼ cyWxV IxV þ cyWyV IyV þ cyWzV IzV ¼ð0Þðcos hÞ þ ðcos bÞðsin hÞ þ ðsin bÞð0Þ IyW ¼ cos b sin h IzW ¼ czWxV IxV þ czWyV IyV þ czWzV IzV ¼ð0Þðcos hÞ þ ðsin bÞðsin hÞ þ ðcosbÞð0Þ IzW ¼ sin b sin h Therefore, in the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system, the vector I is written as: I ¼ ðcos hÞiˆ W þ ðcos b sin hÞjˆ W þ ðsin b sin hÞkˆ W
ðaÞ
Recall that in the original x–y–z coordinate system, I is simply a unit vector aligned with the original x-axis: I u (1)ıˆ. Therefore result (a) defines the direction cosines associated with the angle between the original x-axis and the final xU-, yU-, and zU-axes. That is: cxWx ¼ cosine ðangle between xU- and x-axesÞ ¼ cos h cyWx ¼ cosine ðangle between yU- and x-axesÞ ¼ cos b sin h czWx ¼ cosine ðangle between zU- and x-axesÞ ¼ sin b sin h A similar procedure is used to rotate the unit vectors J and K from the intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system to the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system. These rotations result in: J ¼ ðsin hÞiˆ W þ ðcos b cos hÞjˆ W þ ðsin b cos hÞkˆ W K ¼ ð0Þiˆ W þ ðsin bÞjˆ W þ ðcos bÞkˆ W
ðbÞ ðcÞ
Since vector J is a unit vector aligned with the original y-axis, J=(1)jˆ, result (b) defines the direction cosines associated with the angle between the original y-axis and the final xU-, yU-, and zU-axes: cxWy ¼ cosine ðangle between xU- and y-axesÞ ¼ sin h cyWy ¼ cosine ðangle between yU- and y-axesÞ ¼ cos b cos h czWx ¼ cosine ðangle between zU- and y-axesÞ ¼ sin b cos h Finally, result (c) defines the direction cosines associated with the angle between the original z-axis and the final xU-, yU-, and zU-axes: cxWz ¼ cosineð angle between xU- and z-axesÞ ¼ 0
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
cyWz ¼ cosine ðangle between yU-and z-axesÞ ¼ sin b czWz ¼ cosine ðangle between zU-and z-axesÞ ¼ cos b Assembling the preceding results, the set of direction cosines relating the original x–y–z coordinate system to the final xU–yU–zU coordinate system can be written as: 2 3 2 3 cxWx cxWy cxWz cos h sin h 0 4 cyWx cyWy cyWz 5 ¼ 4 cos b sin h cos b cos h sin b 5 czWx czWy czWz sin b sin h sin b cos h cos b Part (b). Since the direction cosines have been determined, transformation of force vector F can be accomplished using any version of Eqs. (6a)–(6c). For example, using matrix notation, Eq. (6c): 8 9 2 38 9 cxWx cxWy cxWz < Fx = < FxW = F W ¼ 4 cyWx cyWy cyWz 5 Fy : y ; : ; czWx czWy czWz FzW Fz 2 38 9 cos h sin h 0 < Fx = ¼ 4 cos b sin h cos b cos h sin b 5 Fy : ; sin b sin h sin b cos h cos b Fz 8 9 8 9 ðcos hÞFx þ ðsin hÞFy < FxW = < = FyW ¼ ðcos b sin hÞFx þ ðcos b cos hÞFy þ ðsin bÞFz : ; : ; ðsin b sin hÞFx þ ðsin b cos hÞFy þ ðcos bÞFz FzW Part (c). Using the specified numerical values and the results of Part (b): 9 8 9 8 ðcos 20B Þð1000 NÞ þ ðsin 20B Þ200 N = < FxW = < FyW ¼ ðcos 60B sin 20B Þð1000 NÞ þ ðcos 60B cos 20B Þð200 NÞ þ ðsin 60B Þð600 NÞ ; : ; : FzW ðsin 60B sin 20B Þð1000 NÞ þ ðsin 60B cos 20B Þð200 NÞ þ ðcos 60B Þð600 NÞ 8 9 8 9 < FxW = < 1008 N = F W ¼ 442:6 N : y ; : ; FzW 433:4 N Using vector notation, F can now be expressed in the two different coordinate systems as: F ¼ ð1000 NÞiˆ þ ð200 NÞjˆ þ ð600 NÞkˆ or equivalently F ¼ ð1008 NÞiˆ W þ ð442:6 NÞjˆ W þ ð433:4 NÞkˆ W
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
where ıˆ, jˆ, kˆ and ıˆ U, jˆ U, kˆ U are unit vectors in the x–y–z and xU–yU–zUcoordinate systems, respectively. Force vector F drawn in the x–y–z and xU–yU– zUcoordinate systems is shown in Fig. 3(a) and (b), respectively. The two descriptions of F are entirely equivalent. A convenient way of (partially) verifying this equivalence is to calculate the magnitude of the original and transformed force vectors. Since the magnitude is an invariant, it is inde-
Figure 3 Force vector F drawn in the x–y–z and xW–yW–zW coordinate systems.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
pendent of the coordinate system used to describe the force vector. Using Eq. (2), the magnitude of the force vector in the x–y–z coordinate system is: qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi jF j ¼ F x2 þ F y2 þ F z2 ¼ ð1000 NÞ2 þ ð200 NÞ2 þ ð600 NÞ2 ¼ 1183 N The magnitude of the force vector in the xU–yU–zU coordinate system is: ffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 2 2 jF j ¼ ðFxWÞ þ FyW þðFzWÞ ¼ ð1008 NÞ2 þ ð442:6 NÞ2 þ ð433:4 NÞ2 ¼ 1183N ðagreesÞ 3 NORMAL FORCES, SHEAR FORCES, AND FREE-BODY DIAGRAMS A force F acting at an angle to a planar surface is shown in Fig. 4. Since force is a vector, it can always be decomposed into two force components, a normal force component and a shear force component. The line-of-action of the normal force component is orthogonal to the surface, whereas the line-of-action of the shear force component is tangent to the surface. Internal forces induced within a solid body by externally applied forces can be investigated with the aid of free-body diagrams. A simple example is shown in Fig. 5, which shows a straight circular rod with constant diameter subjected to two external forces of equal magnitude (R) but opposite direction. The internal force (F I, say) induced at any cross section of the rod can be investigated by making an imaginary cut along the plane of interest. Suppose an imaginary cut is made along plane a-a, which is perpendicular to the axis
Figure 4 A force F acting at an angle to a planar surface.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 5 The use of free-body diagrams to determine internal forces acting on planes a-a and b-b: (a) free-body diagram based on plane a–a–a–a perpendicular to rod axis; (b) free-body diagram based on plane b–b–b–b, inclined at angle h to rod axis.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
of the rod. The resulting free-body diagram for the lower half of the rod is shown in Fig. 5(a), where an x–y–z coordinate system has been assigned such that the x-axis is parallel to the rod axis, as shown. On the basis of this freebody diagram, it is concluded that an internal force F I = (R)ıˆ+(0)jˆ+(0)kˆ is induced at cross-section a-a. That is, only a normal force of magnitude R is induced at cross-section a-a, which has been defined to be perpendicular to the axis of the rod. On the other hand, the imaginary cut need not be made perpendicular to the axis of the rod. Suppose the imaginary cut is made along plane b-b, which is oriented at an angle of h with respect to the axis of the rod. The resulting free-body diagram for the lower half of the rod is shown in Fig. 5(b). A new xV–yV–zV coordinate system has been assigned so that the xV-axis is perpendicular to plane b-b and the zV-axis is coincident with the z-axis—that is, the xV–yV–zV coordinate system is generated from the x–y–z coordinate system by a rotation of h about the original z-axis. The internal force FI can be expressed with respect to the xV–yV–zV coordinate system by transforming FI from the x–y–z coordinate system to the xV–yV–zV coordinate system. This coordinate transformation is a special case of the transformation considered in Example Problem 1. The direction cosines now become (with b=0j): cxV x ¼ cos h
cxV y ¼ sin h
c xV z ¼ 0
cyV x ¼ sin h czV x ¼ 0
cyV y ¼ cos h czV y ¼ 0
cy V z ¼ 0 czV z ¼ 1
Applying Eqs. (6a)–(6c), we have: 8 9 2 38 9 38 9 2 c xV x c xV y c xV z < F x = cos h sin h 0 < R = < FxV = F V ¼ 4 cyV x cyV y cyV z 5 Fy ¼ 4 sin h cos h 0 5 0 : y ; : ; : ; czV x czV y czV z 0 0 1 FzV Fz 0 8 9 < ðcos hÞR = ¼ ðsin hÞR : ; 0 In the xV–yV–zV coordinate system, the internal force is F I = (R cos h)ıˆV(R sin h)jˆV+(0)kˆV. Hence, by defining a coordinate system which is inclined to the axis of the rod, we conclude that both a normal force (R cos h) and a shear force (R sin h) are induced in the rod. Although the preceding discussion may seem simplistic, it has been included in order to demonstrate the following:
A specific coordinate system must be specified before a force vector can be defined in a mathematical sense. In general, the coordinate
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
system is defined by the imaginary cut(s) used to form the free-body diagram. All components of a force must be specified to fully define the force vector. Furthermore, the individual components of a force change as the vector is transformed from one coordinate system to another. These two observations are valid for all tensors, not just for force vectors. In particular, these observations hold in the case of stress and strain tensors, which will be reviewed in the following sections.
4 DEFINITION OF STRESS There are two fundamental types of stress: normal stress and shear stress. Both types of stress are defined as a force divided by the area over which it acts. A general 3-D solid body subjected to a system of external forces is shown in Fig. 6(a). It is assumed that the body is in static equilibrium, that is, it is assumed that the sum of all external forces is zero, SF i = 0. These external forces induce internal forces acting within the body. In general, the internal forces will vary in both magnitude and direction throughout the body. An illustration of the variation of internal forces along a line within an internal plane is shown in Fig. 6(b). A small area (DA) isolated from this plane is shown in Fig. 6(c). Area DA is assumed to be ‘‘infinitesimally small.’’ That is, the area DA is small enough such that the internal forces acting over DA can be assumed to be of constant magnitude and direction. Therefore, the internal forces acting over DA can be represented by a force vector which can be decomposed into a normal force, N, and a shear force, V, as shown in Fig. 6(c). Normal stress (usually denoted r) and shear stress (usually denoted s) are defined as the force per unit area acting perpendicular and tangent to the area DA, respectively. That is, N DA!0 DA
r u lim
V DA!0 DA
s u lim
ð9Þ
Note that by definition, the area DA shrinks to zero: DA!0. Stresses r and s are therefore said to exist ‘‘at a point.’’ Also, since internal forces generally vary from point-to-point (as shown in Fig. 6), stresses also vary from pointto-point. Stress has units of force per unit area. In SI units, stress is reported in terms of Pascals (abbreviated Pa), where 1 Pa=1 N/m2. In English units, stress is reported in terms of pounds-force per square inch (abbreviated psi),
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 6 A solid 3-D body in equilibrium.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
that is, 1 psi=1 lbf/in2. Conversion factors between the two systems of measurement are 1 psi=6895 Pa, or equivalently, 1 Pa=0.1450103 psi. Common abbreviations used throughout this text are as follows: 1 103 Pa ¼ 1 kilo-Pascals ¼ 1 kPa
1 103 psi ¼ 1 kilo-psi ¼ 1 ksi
1 106 Pa ¼ 1 Mega-Pascals ¼ 1 MPa 1 106 psi ¼ 1 mega-psi ¼ 1 Msi 1 109 Pa ¼ 1 Giga-Pascals ¼ 1 GPa
5 THE STRESS TENSOR A general 3-D solid body subjected to a system of external forces is shown in Fig. 7(a). It is assumed that the body is in static equilibrium and that body forces are negligible, that is, it is assumed that the sum of all external forces is zero, SF i = 0. A free-body diagram of an infinitesimally small cube removed from the body is shown in Fig. 7(b). The cube is referenced to an x– y–z coordinate system, and the cube edges are aligned with these axes. The lengths of the cube edges are denoted dx, dy, and dz. Although (in general) internal forces are induced over all six faces of the cube, for clarity, the forces acting on only three faces have been shown. The force acting over each cube face can be decomposed into a normal force component and two shear force components, as illustrated in Fig. 7(c). Although each component could be identified with a single subscript (since force is a first-order tensor), for convenience, two subscripts have been used. The first subscript identifies the face over which the force is distributed, while the second subscript identifies the direction in which the force is oriented. For example, Nxx refers to a normal force component which is distributed over the x-face and which ‘‘points’’ in the x-direction. Similarly, Vzy refers to a shear force distributed over the z-face which ‘‘points’’ in the y-direction. Three stress components can now be defined for each cube face, in accordance with Eq. (9). For example, for the three faces of the infinitesimal element shown in Fig. 7: Stresses acting on the +x-face: Vxy Nxx Vxz rxx ¼ lim sxy ¼ lim sxz ¼ lim dy;dz!0 dydz dy;dz!0 dydz dy;dz!0 dydz Stresses acting on the y-face: Nyy Vyx Vyz ryy ¼ lim syx ¼ lim syz ¼ lim dx;dz!0 dxdz dx;dz!0 dxdz dx;dz!0 dxdz
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 7 Free-body diagrams used to define stress induced in a solid body.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Stresses acting on the +z-face: rzz ¼ lim
dx;dy!0
Nzz dxdy
szx ¼ lim
dx;dy!0
Vzx dxdy
szy ¼ lim
dx;dy!0
Vzy dxdy
Since three force components (and therefore three stress components) exist on each of the six faces of the cube, it would initially appear that there are 18 independent force (stress) components. However, it is easily shown that for static equilibrium to be maintained (assuming body forces are negligible):
Normal forces acting on opposite faces of the infinitesimal element must be of equal magnitude and opposite direction, and Shear forces acting within a plane of the element must be orientated either ‘‘tip-to-tip’’ [e.g., forces Vxz and Vzx in Fig. 7(c)] or ‘‘tail-totail’’ (e.g., forces Vzy and Vyz) and be of equal magnitude. That is, jVxy=Vyxj, jVxz=Vzxj, and jVyz=Vzyj. These restrictions reduce the number of independent force (stress) components from 18 to 6, as follows:
Independent force components
Independent stress components
Nxx Nyy Nzz Vxy ð¼ Vyx Þ Vxz ð¼ Vzx Þ Vyz ð¼ Vzy Þ
rxx ryy rzz sxy ð¼ syx Þ sxz ð¼ szx Þ syz ð¼ szy Þ
An infinitesimal element showing all stress components is shown in Fig. 8. We must next define the algebraic sign convention we will use to describe individual stress components. We first associate an algebraic sign with each face of the infinitesimal element. A cube face is positive if the outward unit normal of the face (that is, the unit normal pointing away from the interior of the element) points in a positive coordinate direction; otherwise, the face is negative. For example, face (ABCD) in Fig. 8 is a positive face, while face (CDEF) is a negative face.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 8 An infinitesimal stress element (all stress components shown in a positive sense).
Having identified the positive and negative faces of the element, a stress component is positive if:
The stress component acts on a positive face and points in a positive coordinate direction, or if The stress component acts on a negative face and points in a negative coordinate direction otherwise, the stress component is negative. This convention can be used to confirm that all stress components shown in Fig. 8 are algebraically positive. For example, to determine the algebraic sign of the normal stress rxx which acts on face ABCD in Fig. 8, note that (a) face ABCD is positive and (b) the normal stress rxx which acts on this
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
face points in the positive y-direction. Therefore, rxx is positive. As a second example, the shear stress syz which acts on cube face CDEF is positive because (a) face CDEF is negative and (b) syz points in the negative z-direction. The preceding discussion shows that the state of stress at a point is defined by six components of stress: three normal stress components and three shear stress components. The state of stress is written using matrix notation as follows: 2 3 2 3 rxx sxy sxz rxx sxy sxz 4 syx ryy syz 5 ¼ 4 sxy ryy syz 5 ð10Þ szx szy rzz sxz syz rzz To express the state of stress using indicial notation, we must first make the following change in notation: sxy ! rxy sxz ! rxz syx ! ryx syz ! ryz szx ! rzx szy ! rzy With this change, becomes: 2 rxx sxy 4 syx ryy szx szy
the matrix on the left side of the equality sign in Eq. (10) 3 2 rxx sxz syz 5 ! 4 rxy rzz rxz
rxy ryy ryz
3 rxz ryz 5 rzz
which can be succinctly written using indicial notation as: rij ;
i; j ¼ x; y; or z
ð11Þ
In Sec. 1, it was noted that a force vector is a first-order tensor since only one subscript is required to describe a force tensor, Fi. From Eq. (11), it is clear that stress is a second-order tensor (or equivalently, a tensor of rank two) since two subscripts are required to describe a state of stress. Example Problem 2 Given. The stress element referenced to an x–y–z coordinate system and subject to the stress components shown in Fig. 9.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 9 Stress components acting on an infinitesimal element (all stresses in MPa).
Determine. Label all stress components, including algebraic sign. Solution. The magnitude and algebraic sign of each stress component are determined using the sign convention defined above. The procedure will be illustrated using the stress components acting on face CDEF. First, note that face CDEF is a negative face since an outward unit normal for this face points in the negative y-direction. The normal stress which acts on face CDEF has a magnitude of 50 MPa and points in the positive y-direction. Hence, this stress component is negative and is labeled ryy=50 MPa. One of the shear stress components acting on face CDEF has a magnitude of 75 MPa and points in the positive x-direction. Hence, this stress component is also negative and is
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
labeled syx=75 MPa (or equivalently, sxy=75 MPa). Finally, the second shear force component acting on face CDEF has a magnitude of 50 MPa and points in the positive z-direction. Hence, this component is labeled syz=50 MPa (or equivalently, szy=50 MPa). Following this process for all faces of the element, the state of stress represented by the element shown in Fig. 9 can be written as: 2
rxx 4 syx szx
sxy ryy szy
3 2 sxz 100 MPa syz 5 ¼ 4 75 MPa rzz 30 MPa
75 MPa 50 MPa 50 MPa
3 30 MPa 50 MPa 5 25 MPa
6 TRANSFORMATION OF THE STRESS TENSOR In Sec. 5, the stress tensor was defined using a free-body diagram of an infinitesimal element removed from a 3-D body in static equilibrium. This concept is again illustrated in Fig. 10(a), which shows the stress element referenced to an x–y–z coordinate system. Now, the infinitesimal element need not be removed in the orientation shown in Fig. 10(a). An infinitesimal element removed from precisely the same point within the body but at a different orientation is shown in Fig. 10(b). This stress element is referenced to a new xV–yV–zV coordinate system. The state of stress at the point of interest is dictated by the external loads applied to the body and is independent of the coordinate system used to describe it. Hence, the stress tensor referenced to the xV–yV–zVcoordinate system is equivalent to the stress tensor referenced to the x–y–z coordinate system, although the direction and magnitude of individual stress components will differ. The process of relating stress components in one coordinate system to those in another is called the transformation of the stress tensor. This terminology is perhaps unfortunate in the sense that the state of stress itself is not ‘‘transformed,’’ but rather our description of the state of stress transforms as we change from one coordinate system to another. It can be shown (1,2) that the stress components in the new xV–yV–zV coordinate system (riVjV) are related to the components in the original x–y–z coordinate system (rij) according to: ri V j V ¼ ci V k cj V l rkl
where i; j; k; l ¼ x; y; z
or equivalently (using matrix notation): ½ri V j V ¼ ½ci V j ½rij ½ci V j T
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð12aÞ
Figure 10 Infinitesimal elements removed from the same point from a 3-D solid but in two different orientations.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
where [ciVj]T is the matrix form: 2 rx V x V r x V y V 4 ryV xV ryV yV rzV xV rzV yV
transpose of the direction cosine array. Writing in full 3 2 32 c xV x c xV y c xV z rxV zV rxx ryV zV 5 ¼ 4 cyV x cyV y cyV z 54 ryx rz V z V czV x czV y czV z rzx 2 3 c xV x c y V x c z V x 4 cxV y cyV y czV y 5 c xV z c y V z c z V z
rxy ryy rzy
3 rxz ryz 5 rzz ð12bÞ
As discussed in Sec. 2, the terms ciVj which appear in Eqs. (12a) and (12b) are direction cosines and equal the cosine of the angle between the axes of the x–y–z and xV–yV–zV coordinate systems. Recall that the algebraic sign of an angle of rotation is defined in accordance with the right-hand rule and that angles are defined from the x–y–z coordinate system to xV–yV–zV coordinate system. Equations (12a) and (12b) are called the transformation law for a second-order tensor. If an analysis is being performed with the aid of a digital computer, which nowadays is almost always the case, then matrix notation [Eq. (12b)] most likely will be used to transform a stress tensor from one coordinate system to another. Conversely, if a stress transformation is to be accomplished using hand calculations, then indicial notation [Eq. (12a)] may be the preferred choice. To apply Eq. (12a), desired values are first specified for subscripts iV and jV, and then the terms on the right side of the equality are summed over the entire range of the remaining two subscripts, k and l. For example, suppose we wish to write the relationship between rxVzV and the stress components in the x–y–z coordinate system in expanded form. We first specify that iV=xV and jV=zV, and Eq. (12a) becomes: rxV zV ¼ cxV k czV l rkl
where k; l ¼ x; y; z
We then sum all terms on the right side of the equality by cycling through the entire range of k and l. In expanded form, we have: rxV zV ¼ cxV x czV x rxx þ cxV x czV y rxy þ cxV x czV z rxz þ cxV y czV x ryx þ cxV y czV y ryy þ cxV y czV z ryz þ cxV z czV x rzx þ cxV z czV y rzy þ cxV z czV z rzz
ð13Þ
Equations (12a) and (12b) show that the value of any individual stress component riVjV varies as the stress tensor is transformed from one coordinate system to another. However, it can be shown (1,2) that there are features of the total stress tensor that do not vary when the tensor is transformed from one coordinate system to another. These features are called the stress in-
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
variants. For a second-order tensor, three independent stress invariants exist and are defined as follows: First stress invariant ¼ H ¼ rii ð14aÞ 1 rii rjj rij rij Second stress invariant ¼ U ¼ ð14bÞ 2 1 Third stress invariant ¼ W ¼ rii rjj rkk 3rii rjk rjk þ 2rij rjk rki 6 ð14cÞ Alternatively, by expanding these equations over the range i, j, k=x, y, z and simplifying, the stress invariants can be written as: First stress invariant ¼ H ¼ rxx þ ryy þ rzz
ð15aÞ
Second stress invariant ¼ U ¼ rxx ryy þ rxx rzz þ ryy rzz r2xy þ r2xz þ r2yz
ð15bÞ
Third stress invariant ¼ W ¼ rxx ryy rzz rxx r2yz ryy r2xz rzz r2xy þ 2rxy rxz ryz
ð15cÞ
The three stress invariants are conceptually similar to the magnitude of a force tensor. That is, the value of the three stress invariants is independent of the coordinate used to describe the stress tensor, just as the magnitude of a force vector is independent of the coordinate system used to describe the force. This invariance will be illustrated in the following example problem. Example Problem 3 Given. A state of stress referenced to an x–y–z coordinate is known to be: 2 3 2 3 rxx rxy rxz 50 10 15 4 ryx ryy ryz 5 ¼ 4 10 25 30 5ðksiÞ rzx rzy rzz 15 30 5 It is desired to express this state of stress in an xU–yU–zU coordinate system, generated by the following two sequential rotations: (i) Rotation of h=20j about the original z-axis (which defines an intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system), followed by (ii) Rotation of b=35j about the xV-axis (which defines the final xU–yU– zU coordinate system). Problem. (a) Rotate the stress tensor to the xU–yU–zU coordinate system and (b) calculate the first, second, and third invariants of the stress tensor using
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
both elements of the stress tensor referenced to the x–y–z coordinate system, rij, and elements of the stress tensor referenced to the xU–yU–zU coordinate system, riUjU. Solution Part (a). General expressions for direction cosines relating the x–y–z and xU–yU–zU coordinate systems were determined as a part of Example Problem 1. The direction cosines were found to be: cxWx ¼ cos h cxWy ¼ sin h cxWz ¼ 0 cyWx ¼ cos b sin h cyWy ¼ cos b cos h cyWz ¼ sin b czWx ¼ sin b sin h czWy ¼ sin b cos h czWz ¼ cos b Since in this problem h=20j and b=35j, the numerical values of the direction cosines are: cxWx ¼ cos ð20B Þ ¼ 0:9397 cxWy ¼ sin ð20B Þ ¼ 0:3420 cxWz ¼ 0 cyWx ¼ cos ð35B Þsin ð20B Þ ¼ 0:2802 cyWy ¼ cos ð35B Þcos ð20B Þ ¼ 0:7698 cyWz ¼ sin ð35B Þ ¼ 0:5736 czWx ¼ sin ð35B Þsin ð20B Þ ¼ 0:1962 czWy ¼ sin ð35B Þcos ð20B Þ ¼ 0:5390 czWz ¼ cos ð35B Þ ¼ 0:8192 Each component of the transformed stress tensor is now found through the application of either Eq. (12a) or Eq. (12b). For example, if indicial notation is used, stress component rxUzU can be found using Eq. (13): rxWzW ¼ cxWx czWx rxx þ cxWx czWy rxy þ cxWx czWz rxz þ cxWy czWx ryx þ cxWy czWy ryy þ cxWy czWz ryz þ cxWz czWx rzx þ cxWz czWy rzy þ cxWz czWz rzz
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
rxW zW ¼ ð0:9397Þð0:1962Þð50 ksiÞ þ ð0:9397Þð0:5390Þð10 ksiÞ þð0:9397Þð0:8192Þð15 ksiÞ þ ð0:3420Þð0:1962Þð10 ksiÞ þð0:3420Þð0:5390Þð25 ksiÞ þ ð0:3420Þð0:8192Þð30 ksiÞ þð0Þð0:1962Þð15ksiÞþð0Þð0:5390Þð30ksiÞþð0Þð0:8192Þð5 ksiÞ rxWzW ¼ 28:95 ksi Alternatively, if matrix notation is used, then Eq. (12b) becomes: 2 3 2 32 rxWxW rxWyW rxWzW 0:9397 0:3420 0 50 10 4ryWxW ryWyW ryWzW5 ¼40:2802 0:7698 0:57365410 25 rzWxW rzWyW rzWzW 0:1962 0:5390 0:8192 15 30 2 3 0:9397 0:2802 0:1962 4 0:3420 0:7698 0:53905 0 0:5736 0:8192
3 15 30 5 5
Completing the matrix multiplication indicated yields the following: 2 3 2 3 rxWxW rxWyW rxWzW 40:65 1:113 28:95 4 ryWxW ryWyW ryWzW 5 ¼ 4 1:113 43:08 10:60 5 ðksiÞ rzWxW rzWyW rzWzW 28:95 10:60 13:72 Notice that the value of rxUzU determined through matrix multiplication is identical to that obtained using indicial notation, as previously described. The stress element is shown in the original and final coordinate systems in Fig. 11. Part (b). The first, second, and third stress invariants will now be calculated using components of both rij and riUjU. It is expected that identical values will be obtained since the stress invariants are independent of the coordinate system. First stress invariant: x–y–z coordinate system: H ¼ rii ¼ rxx þ ryy þ rzz H ¼ ð50 þ 25 5Þ ksi H ¼ 70 ksi xU–yU–zU coordinate system: H ¼ ri Wi W ¼ rxWxW þ ryWyW þ rzWzW H ¼ ð40:65 þ 43:08 13:72Þ H ¼ 70 ksi As expected, the first stress invariant is independent of the coordinate system.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 11 Stress tensor of Example Problem 3 referenced to two different coordinates (magnitude of all stress components in ksi).
Second stress invariant: x–y–z coordinate system: 1 rii rjj rij rij ¼ rxx ryy þ rxx rzz þ ryy rzz 2 r2xy þ r2xz þ r2yz n U ¼ ð50Þð25Þ þ ð50Þð5Þ þ ð25Þð5Þ ½ð10Þ2 þ ð15Þ2 o þ ð30Þ2 ðksiÞ2 U¼
U ¼ 350ðksiÞ2 xU–yU–zU coordinate system: U¼
1 r W Wr W W ri Wj Wri Wj W 2 ii jj
U ¼ rxWxWryWyW þ rxWxWrzWzW þ ryWyWrzWzW r2xWyW þ r2xWzW þ r2yWzW
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
n U ¼ ð40:65Þð43:08Þ þ ð40:65Þð13:72Þ þ ð43:08Þð13:72Þ o ½ð1:113Þ2 þ ð28:95Þ2 þ ð10:60Þ2 ðksiÞ2 U ¼ 350ðksiÞ2 As expected, the second stress invariant is independent of the coordinate system. Third stress invariant: x–y–z coordinate system: 1 W ¼ rii rjj rkk 3rii rjk rjk þ 2rij rjk rki 6 W ¼ rxx ryy rzz rxx r2yz ryy r2xz rzz r2xy þ 2rxy rxz ryz W ¼ ½ð50Þð25Þð5Þ ð50Þð30Þ2 ð25Þð15Þ2 ð5Þð10Þ2 þ 2ð10Þð15Þð30Þ ðksiÞ3 W ¼ 65375ðksiÞ3 xU–yU–zU coordinate system: 1 W ¼ ri Wi Wrj Wj WrkWkW 3ri Wi Wrj WkWrj WkW þ 2ri Wj Wrj WkWrkWi W 6 W ¼ rxWxWryWyWrzWzW rxWxWr2yWzW ryWyWr2xWzW rzWzWr2xWyW þ 2rxWyWrxWzWryWzW W ¼ ½ð40:65Þð43:08Þð13:72Þ ð40:65Þð10:60Þ2 ð43:08Þ ð28:95Þ2 ð13:72Þð1:113Þ2 þ 2ð1:113Þð28:95Þ ð10:60Þ ðksiÞ3 W ¼ 65375ðksiÞ3 As expected, the third stress invariant is independent of the coordinate system. 7 PRINCIPAL STRESSES The definition of a stress tensor was reviewed in Sec. 5, and transformation of a stress tensor from one coordinate system to another was discussed in Sec. 6. It can be shown (1,2) that it is always possible to rotate the stress tensor to a special coordinate system in which no shear stresses exist. This coordinate system is called the principal stress coordinate system, and the normal stresses
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
that exist in this coordinate system are called the principal stresses. In most textbooks, principal stresses are denoted r1, r2, and r3. However, as will be discussed later (see Fig. 2 in Chap. 3) in this textbook, the labels ‘‘1,’’ ‘‘2,’’ and ‘‘3’’ will be used to label the axes in a special coordinate system called the principal material coordinate system. Therefore, in this text, the axes associated with the principal stress coordinate system will be labeled p1, p2, and p3 axes, and the principal stresses will be denoted rp1, rp2, and rp3. Knowledge of the principal stresses induced in an isotropic structure is of extreme importance, primarily because failure of isotropic materials (e.g., yielding and/or fracture) can often be directly related to the magnitude(s) of the principal stresses. This is not the case for composite structures, however. As will be seen in later chapters, failure of composite structures is not governed by principal stresses, and hence the topic of principal stresses is only of occasional importance to the composite engineer. Principal stresses may be related to stress components in an x–y–z coordinate system using the free-body diagram shown in Fig. 12. It is assumed that plane ABC is one of the three principal planes (i.e., n = 1, 2, or 3) and therefore no shear stress exists on this plane. The line-of-action of principal stress rpn defines one axis of the principal stress coordinate system. The direction cosines between this principal axis and the x-, y-, and z- axes are cpnx, cpny, and cpnz, respectively. The surface area of triangle ABC is denoted AABC. The normal force acting over triangle ABC therefore equals (rpnAABC). The components of the normal force acting in the x-, y-, and z-directions equal cpnxrpnAABC, cpnyrpnAABC, and cpnzrpnAABC, respectively. The area of the other triangular faces are given by: Area of triangle ABD=cpnxAABC. Area of triangle ACD=cpnyAABC. Area of triangle BCD=cpnzAABC. Summing forces in the x-direction and equating to zero, we obtain: cpn x rpn AABC rxx cpn x AABC sxy cpn y AABC sxz cpn z AABC ¼ 0 which can be reduced and simplified to: ðrpn rxx Þcpn x sxy cpn y sxz cpn z ¼ 0
ð16aÞ
Similarly, summing forces in the y- and z-directions results in: sxy cpn x þ ðrpn ryy Þcpn y syz cpn z ¼ 0
ð16bÞ
sxz cpn x syz cpn y þ ðrpn rzz Þcpn z ¼ 0
ð16cÞ
Equations (16a)–(16c) represent three linear homogeneous equations which must be satisfied simultaneously. Since direction cosines cpnx, cpny, and cpnz must also satisfy Eq. (8), and therefore cannot all equal zero, the solu-
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 12 Free-body diagram used to relate stress components in the x–y–z coordinate system to a principal stress.
tion can be obtained by requiring that the determinant of the coefficients of cpnx, cpny, and cpnz equal zero: ðrpn rxx Þ sxy sxz sxy ðrpn ryy Þ syz ¼ 0 sxz syz ðrpn rzz Þ Equating the determinant to zero results in the following cubic equation: r3pn Hr2pn þ Urpn W ¼ 0
ð17Þ
where H, U, and W are the first, second, and third stress invariants, respectively, and have been previously listed as Eqs. (14a)–(14c) and (15a)–(15c).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The three roots of the cubic equation (that is, the three principal stresses) may be found by application of the standard approach (3), as follows. Define: 1 3U H2 3 1 3 2H 9HU þ 27W b¼ 27 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 b b2 a3 þ A¼ þ 2 4 27 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 b b2 a3 þ B¼ 2 4 27
a¼
The three principal stresses [i.e., the three roots of Eq. (17)] are then given by: 8 H > > AþBþ > > 3 > > > < A þ B pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi A B H þ 3 þ ð18Þ rp1 ; rp2 ; rp3 ¼ > 2 2 3 > > > > A þ B pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi A B H > > : 3 þ 2 2 3 By convention, the principal stresses are numbered such that rp1 is the algebraically greatest principal stress, whereas rp3 is the algebraically least. That is, rp1 > rp2>rp3. Two comments regarding the practical application of either Eq. (17) or Eq. (18) are appropriate. First, many handheld calculators and computer software packages feature standard routines to find the roots of nth-order polynomials. Hence, the three roots of Eq. (17) (that is, the three principal stresses) may often be found most conveniently through the use of these standard calculator routines or software packages, rather than through application of Eq. (18). The second comment is that if the principal stresses are to be calculated through application of Eq. (18), then calculation of constants A and B generally involves finding the cube root of a complex number. The need to find the cube root of a complex number is encountered infrequently, and hence the reader may not be aware of how to make such a calculation. For convenience, a process that may be used to find the cube root of a complex number has been included in Appendix A. In any event, once the principal stresses are determined, the three sets of direction cosines (which define the principal coordinate directions) are found by substituting the three principal stresses given by Eq. (18) into Eqs. (16a)– (16c) in turn. Since only two of Eqs. (16a)–(16c) are independent, Eq. (8) is
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
used as a third independent equation involving the three unknown constants cpnx, cpny, and cpnz. The process of finding principal stresses and direction cosines will be demonstrated in the following example problem. Example Problem 4 Given. A state of stress referenced to an x–y–z coordinate is known to be: 2 3 2 3 rxx rxy rxz 50 10 15 4 ryx ryy ryz 5 ¼ 4 10 25 30 5 ðksiÞ rzx rzy rzz 15 30 5 Problem. Find (a) the principal stresses and (b) the direction cosines that define the principal stress coordinate system. Solution. This is the same stress tensor considered in Example Problem 3. As a part of that problem, the first, second, and third stress invariants were found to be: H=70 ksi U=350 (ksi)2 W=65375 (ksi)3 Part (a). Determining the principal stresses. In accordance with Eq. (17), the three principal stresses are the roots of the following cubic equation: r3 70r2 350r þ 65375 ¼ 0 As discussed earlier, the three roots of this equation can often be found most conveniently using appropriate handheld calculators or software packages. In this example solution, the roots will be found through application of Eq. 18. Following this process, we have: i 1h 1 3U H2 ¼ 3ð350Þ ð70Þ2 ¼ 1983 a¼ 3 3 1 3 2H 9HU þ 27W b¼ 27 i 1 h 2ð70Þ3 9ð70Þð350Þ þ 27ð65375Þ ¼ 31801 ¼ 27 vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi u u 3 2 3 3 t 48134 b b a ð48134Þ2 ð1983Þ3 þ A¼ þ þ ¼ þ 2 2 4 27 4 27 ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi p ¼ 3 15900 þ ið6010Þ
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
We find that constant A equals the cube root of the complex number: z ¼ 15900 þ ið6010Þ Following the process described in Appendix A, the modulus and argument of this complex number are: pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r ¼ a2 þ b2 ¼ ð15900Þ2 þ ð6010Þ2 ¼ 16998 6010 1 u ¼ tan ¼ tan1 ð0:37799Þ ¼ 0:3614 radðorÞ2:780 rad 15900 Since in this case: a ¼ 15900 < 0 b ¼ 6010 > 0 it is clear that the argument u corresponds to an angle in the second quadrant of the complex plane (refer to Fig. A.1). Hence, we select u=2.780 rad. Applying Eq. A.3, we find: hui h u io pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi lnðrÞ n A ¼ 3 a þ ib ¼ exp cos þ i sin 3 3 3 ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi p lnð16998Þ A ¼ 3 15900 þ ið6010Þ ¼ exp 3
2:780 2:780 cos þ i sin 3 3 A ¼ 25:71f0:6005 þ ið0:7996Þg A ¼ 15:44 þ ið20:56Þ Following an identical procedure, constant B is found to be: B ¼ 15:44 ið20:56Þ We now apply Eq. (18) to find: 8 8 54:21 ksi AþBþH > > > > 3 > > > > > > > > < A þ B pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi A B < H þ 3 þ rp1 ; rp2 ; rp3 ¼ ¼ 27:72 ksi 2 2 3 > > > > > > > > > > A þ B pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi A B H > > : : 3 þ 2 2 3 43:51 ksi Hence, rp1=54.21 ksi, rp2=43.51 ksi, and rp3=27.72 ksi.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Part (b). Determining the direction cosines. The first two of Eqs. (16a)– (16c) and Eq. (8) will be used to form three independent equations in three unknowns. We have: ðrpn rxx Þcpn x sxy cpn y sxz cpn z ¼ 0 sxy cpn x þ ðrpn ryy Þcpn y syz cpn z ¼ 0 ðcpn x Þ2 þ ðcpn y Þ2 þ ðcpn z Þ2 ¼ 1 Direction cosines for rp1. The three independent equations become: ð54:21 50Þcp1 x þ 10cp1 y 15cp1 z ¼ 0 10cp1 x þ ð54:21 25Þcp1 y 30cp1 z ¼ 0 ðcp1 x Þ2 þ ðcp1 y Þ2 þ ðcp1 z Þ2 ¼ 1 Solving simultaneously, we obtain: cp1 x ¼ 0:9726
cp1 y ¼ 0:1666
cp1 z ¼ 0:1620
Direction cosines for rp2. The three independent equations become: ð43:51 50Þcp2 x þ 10cp2 y 15cp2 z ¼ 0 10cp2 x þ ð43:51 25Þcp2 y 30cp2 z ¼ 0 ðcp2 x Þ2 þ ðcp2 y Þ2 þ ðcp2 z Þ2 ¼ 1 Solving simultaneously, we obtain: cp2 x ¼ 0:05466
cp2 y ¼ 0:8416
cp2 z ¼ 0:5738
Direction cosines for rp3. The three independent equations become: ð27:72 50Þcp3 x þ 10cp3 y 15cp3 z ¼ 0 10cp3 x þ ð27:72 25Þcp3 y 30cp3 z ¼ 0 ðcp3 x Þ2 þ ðcp3 y Þ2 þ ðcp3 z Þ2 ¼ 1 Solving simultaneously, we obtain: cp3 x ¼ 0:8276
cp3 y ¼ 0:2259
cp3 z ¼ 0:5138
8 PLANE STRESS A stress tensor is defined by six components of stress: three normal stress components and three shear stress components. Now, in practice, a state of stress often encountered is one in which all stress components in one coordinate direction are zero. For example, suppose rzz=sxz=syz=0, as
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
shown in Fig. 13(a). Since the three remaining nonzero stress components (rxx, ryy, and sxy) all lie within the x–y plane, such a condition is called a state of plane stress. Plane stress conditions occur most often because of the geometry of the structure of interest. Specifically, the plane stress condition usually exists in thin, platelike structures. Examples include the web of an Ibeam, the body panel of an automobile, or the skin of an airplane fuselage.
Figure 13 Stress elements subjected to a state of plane stress.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
In these instances, the stresses induced normal to the plane of the structure are very small compared to those induced within the plane of the structure. Hence, the small out-of-plane stresses are usually ignored, and attention is focused on the relatively high stress components acting within the plane of the structure. Since laminated composites are often used in the form of thin plates or shells, the plane stress assumption is widely applicable in composite structures and will be used throughout most of the analyses discussed in this textbook. Since the out-of-plane stresses are negligibly small, for convenience, an infinitesimal stress element subjected to plane stress will usually be drawn as a square rather than a cube, as shown in Fig. 13(b). Results discussed in earlier sections for general 3-D state of stress will now be specialized for the plane stress condition. It will be assumed that the nonzero stresses lie in the x–y plane (i.e., rzz=sxz=syz=0). This allows the remaining components of stress to be written in the form of a column array rather than a 3 3 array: 8 9 2 3 r rxx sxy 0 > < xx > = 6 7 4 sxy ryy 0 5 ! ryy > > : ; 0 0 0 sxy Note that when a plane stress state is described, stress appears to be a firstorder tensor since (apparently) only three components of stress (rxx, ryy, andsxy) need be specified in order to describe the state of stress. This is, of course, not the case. Stress is a second-order tensor in all instances, and six components of stress must always be specified in order to define a state of stress. When we invoke the plane stress assumption, we have simply assumed a priori that three stress components (rzz, sxz, and syz) are zero. Recall that either Eq. (12a) or Eq. (12b) governs the transformation of a stress tensor from one coordinate system to another. Equation (12b) is repeated here for convenience: 2 3 2 32 3 c xV x c xV y c xV z rxV xV rxV yV rxV zV rxx rxy rxz 6r V V r V V r V V 7 6c V 6 7 cyV y cyV z 7 4 yx 54 ryx ryy ryz 5 yy yz 5 ¼ 4 yx rzV xV rzV yV rzV zV czV x czV y czV z rzx rzy rzz 2 3 cxV x cyV x czV x 6c V c V c V 7 4 xy ð12bÞ yy z y 5ðrepeatedÞ cxV z cyV z czV z When transformation of a plane stress tensor is considered, it will be assumed that the xV–yV–zV coordinate system is generated from the x–y–z
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
system by a rotation h about the z-axis. That is, the z- and zV-axes are coincident, as shown in Fig. 14. In this case, the direction cosines are: cxV x ¼ cos ðhÞ cxV y ¼ cos ð90B hÞ ¼ sin ðhÞ cxV z ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 cyV x ¼ cos ð90B þ hÞ ¼ sin ðhÞ cyV y ¼ cos ðhÞ cyV z ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV x ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV y ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV z ¼ cos ð0B Þ ¼ 1 If we now (a) substitute these direction cosines into Eq. (12b), (b) label the shear stresses using the symbol s rather r, and (c) note that rzz= sxz=syz=0 by assumption, then Eq. (12b) becomes: 2 3 2 3 32 rxV xV sxV yV sxV zV rxx sxy 0 cos h sin h 0 6s V V r V V s V V7 6 7 76 ryy 0 5 4 yx yy y z 5 ¼ 4 sin h cos h 0 54 syx szV xV szV yV rzV zV 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 3 cos h sin h 0 6 7 4 sin h cos h 0 5 0
0
1
Completing the matrix multiplication indicated results in: 2
rxV xV 4 s yV x V s z V xV 2
s x V yV r yV yV s z V yV
3 s xV z V s yV z V 5 r zV zV
cos2 hrxx þ sin2 hryy þ 2cosh sin hsxy
6 2 2 ¼6 4cosh sinhrxx þ cosh sinhryy þ ðcos h sin hÞsxy
sin2 hrxx þ cos2 hryy 2cosh sinhsxy
3 0 7 07 5
0
0
cosh sinhrxx þ cosh sinhryy þ ðcos2 h sin2 hÞsxy
0
As would be expected, the out-of-plane stresses are zero: rzVzV=sxVzV=s yVzV=0. The remaining stress components are: rxV xV ¼ cos 2 ðhÞrxx þ sin 2 ðhÞryy þ 2cos ðhÞsin ðhÞsxy ryV yV ¼ sin 2 ðhÞrxx þ cos 2 ðhÞryy 2cos ðhÞsin ðhÞsxy
ð19Þ
sxV yV ¼ cos ðhÞsin ðhÞrxx þ cos ðhÞsin ðhÞryy þ ½cos 2 ðhÞ sin 2 ðhÞsxy
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 14 Transformation of a plane stress element from one coordinate system to another.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Equation (19) can be written using matrix notation as: 9 2 8 > cos2 ðhÞ = < rx V x V > 6 ryV yV ¼ 4 sin2 ðhÞ > > ; : sxV yV cos ðhÞsin ðhÞ
sin2 ðhÞ cos2 ðhÞ
3 2cos ðhÞ sin ðhÞ 7 2 cos ðhÞ sin ðhÞ 5
cos ðhÞsin ðhÞ cos2 ðhÞ sin2 ðhÞ
9 8 > = < rxx > ryy > > ; : sxy
ð20Þ
It should be kept in mind that these results are valid only for a state of plane stress. Transformation of a general (3-D) stress/tensor should be performed using Eq. (12a) or (12b). The 3 3 array that appears in Eq. (20) is called the transformation matrix and is abbreviated as [T]: 3 2 cos2 ðhÞ sin2 ðhÞ 2cosðhÞsin ðhÞ 7 6 ð21Þ ½T ¼ 6 sin2 ðhÞ cos2 ðhÞ 2cosðhÞsin ðhÞ 7 5 4 cos ðhÞsin ðhÞ
cos ðhÞ sin ðhÞ
cos2 ðhÞ sin2 ðhÞ
The stress invariants [given by Eqs. (14a)–(14c) or Eqs. (15a)–(15c)] are considerably simplified in the case of plane stress. Since by definition rzz=sxz=syz=0, the stress invariants become: First stress invariant ¼ H ¼ rxx þ ryy Second stress invariant ¼ U ¼ rxx ryy s2xy
ð22Þ
Third stress invariant ¼ W ¼ 0 The principal stresses equal the roots of the cubic equation previously listed as Eq. (17). In the case of plane stress, this cubic equation becomes (since W=0): r3 Hr2 þ Ur ¼ 0
ð23Þ
Obviously, one root of Eq. (23) is r=0. This root corresponds to rzz and for present purposes will be labeled rp3 although it may not be the algebraically least principal stress. Thus, in the case of plane stress, the z-axis is a principal stress direction and rzz=rp3=0 is one of the three principal stresses. Since the three principal stress directions are orthogonal, this implies that the remaining two principal stress directions must lie within the x–y plane.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Removing the known root from Eq. (23), we have the following quadratic equation: r2 Hr þ U ¼ 0
ð24Þ
The two roots of this quadratic equation (that is, the two remaining principal stresses, rp1 and rp2) may be found by application of the standard approach (3) and are given by: pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi i 1h ð25Þ HF H2 4U rp1 ; rp2 ¼ 2 Substituting Eq. (22) into Eq. (25) and simplifying yields the following: rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi r r 2 rxx þ ryy xx yy 2 rp1 ; rp2 ¼ F ð26Þ þsxy 2 2 The angle hp between the x-axis and either the p1 or p2 axis is given by: 2sxy 1 ð27Þ hp ¼ arctan 2 rxx ryy Example Problem 5 Given. The plane stress element shown in Fig. 15(a). Problem. (a) Rotate the stress element to a new coordinate system oriented 25j clockwise from the x-axis, and redraw the stress element with all stress components properly oriented; (b) determine the principal stresses and principal stress coordinate system, and redraw the stress element with the principal stress components properly oriented. Solution Part (a). The following components of stress are implied by the stress element shown (note that the shear stress is algebraically negative, in accordance with the sign convention discussed in Sec. 5): rxx ¼ 70 MPa ryy ¼ 15 MPa sxy ¼ 50 MPa The stress element is to be rotated clockwise. That is, the +xV-axis is rotated away from the +y-axis. Applying the right-hand rule, it is clear that this is a negative rotation: h ¼ 25B
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 15 Plane stress elements associated with Example Problem 5.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Equation (20) becomes: 8 9 2 > < rxV xV > = 6 ryV yV ¼ 6 4 > :s V V > ; xy
3
8 9 < 70 = 7 sin2 ð25B Þ cos2 ð25B Þ 2cosð25B Þsinð25B Þ 7 5: 15 ; 50 2 B B B B 2 B B cosð25 Þsinð25 Þ cosð25 Þsinð25 Þ cos ð25 Þ sin ð25 Þ 9 8 9 38 8 9 2 0:8214 0:1786 0:7660 > 70 > 98:5 > > > > > > > < rxV xV > = 6 < = < = 7 7 ryV yV ¼ 6 0:1786 0:8214 0:7660 5 15 ¼ 13:5 MPa 4 > > > > > > : ; > > > : ; > : ; sxV yV 0:3830 0:3830 0:6428 50 11:1 cos2 ð25B Þ
sin2 ð25B Þ
2cosð25B Þsinð25B Þ
The rotated stress element is shown in Fig. 15(b). The principal stresses are found through application of Eq. (26): sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 70 þ 15 70 15 2 rp1 ; rp2 ¼ þð50Þ2 ¼ 42:5 F 57:1 MPa F 2 2 rp1 ¼ 99:6MPa
Part (b).
rp2 ¼ 14:6MPa The orientation of the principal stress coordinate system is given by Eq. (27): 1 2ð50Þ hp ¼ arctan ¼ 31B 2 70 15 The stress element is shown in the principal stress coordinate system in Fig. 15(c).
9 DEFINITION OF STRAIN All materials deform to some extent when subjected to external forces and/or environmental changes. In essence, the state of strain is a measure of the magnitude and orientation of the deformations induced by these effects. As in the case of stress, there are two types of strain: normal strain and shear strain. The two types of strain can be visualized using the strain element shown in Fig. 16. Imagine that a perfect square has been physically drawn on a surface of interest. Initially, angle BABC is exactly p2 radians (i.e., initially BABC=90j) and sides AB and BC are of exactly equal lengths. Now suppose that some mechanism(s) causes the surface to deform. The mechanism(s) which causes the surface to deform need not be defined at
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 16 2-D element used to illustrate normal and shear strains (deformations shown are greatly exaggerated for clarity).
this point, but might be external loading (i.e., stresses), a change in temperature, and/or (in the case of polymeric-based materials such as composites) the adsorption or desorption of water molecules. In any event, since the surface is deformed, the initially square element drawn on the surface is deformed as well. As shown in Fig. 16, point A moves to point AV and point C moves to point CV. It is assumed that the element remains a parallelogram, i.e., it is assumed that sides AVB and CVB remain straight lines after deformation. This assumption is valid if the element is infinitesimally small. In the present context, ‘‘infinitesimally small’’ implies that lengths AB and CB are small enough such that the deformed element may be treated as a parallelogram. Normal strain exx is defined as the change in length of AB divided by the original length of AB: exx ¼
DAB AB
ð28Þ
The change in length AB is given by: DAB ¼ ðAVB ABÞ From the figure, it can be seen that the projection of length AVB in the xdirection, that is, length AUB, is given by: AWB ¼ AVBcosðBAVBAÞ
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð29Þ
If we now assume that BAVBA is ‘‘small,’’ then we can invoke the small-angle approximation,* which states that if BAVBA is expressed in radians and is less than about 0.1745 radians (about 10j), then: sinðBAVBAÞcBAVBA
tanðBAVBAÞcBAVBA
cosðBAVBAÞc1
Based on the small-angle approximation, Eq. (29) implies that AUBc AVB, and therefore the change in length of AB is approximately given by: DABcðAUB ABÞ ¼ AUA Equation (28) can now be written as: exx ¼
AUA AB
ð30Þ
In an entirely analogous manner, normal strain eyy is defined as the change in length of CB divided by the original length of CB: eyy ¼
DCB CB
Based on the small-angle approximation, the change in length of CB is approximately given by: DCB ¼ ðC VB CBÞcC UC and therefore: eyy ¼
C UC CB
ð31Þ
As before, the approximation for change in length CB is valid if angle BCUBC is small. Recall that the original element shown in Fig. 16 was assumed to be perfectly square and, in particular, that angle BAVBC is exactly p2 radians (i.e., initially BAVBC=90j). Engineering shear strain is defined as the change in angle BABC, expressed in radians: cxy ¼ DðBABCÞ ¼ BAVBA þ BC VBC
ð32Þ
The subscripts associated with a shear strain [e.g., subscripts xy in Eq. (32)] indicate that the shear strain represents the change in angle defined by line segments originally aligned with the x- and y-axes.
* The reader is encouraged to personally verify the ‘‘small-angle approximation.’’ For example, use a calculator to demonstrate that an angle of 5j equals 0.08727 rad, and that sin(0.08727 rad)=0.08716, tan(0.08727 rad)=0.08749, and cos(0.08727 rad)=0.99619. Therefore, in this example, the small angle approximation results in a maximum error of less than 1%.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
As discussed in the following sections, it is very convenient to describe a state of strain as a second-order tensor. However, in order to do so, we must use a slightly different definition of shear strain. Specifically, tensoral shear strain is defined as: exy ¼
1 c 2 xy
ð33Þ
Since engineering shear strain has been defined as the total change in angle BAVBC, tensoral shear strain is simply half this change in angle. The use of tensoral shear strain is convenient because it greatly simplifies the transformation of a state of strain from one coordinate system to another. The use of engineering shear strain is far more common in practice, however. In this text, tensoral shear strain will be used when convenient during initial mathematical manipulations of the strain tensor, but all final results will be converted to relations involving engineering shear strain. Although strains are unitless quantities, normal strains are usually reported in units of (length/length), and shear strains are usually reported in units of radians. The values of a strain is independent of the system of units used, e.g., 1 (m/m)=1 (in/in). Common abbreviations used throughout this text are as follows: 1 106 meter=meter ¼ 1micrometer=meter ¼ 1 Am=m ¼ 1 Ain=in 1 106 radians ¼ 1 microradians ¼ 1 Arad We must next define the algebraic sign convention used to describe individual strain components. The sign convention for normal strains is very straightforward and intuitive: a positive (or ‘‘tensile’’) normal strain is associated with an increase in length, while a negative (or ‘‘compressive’’) normal strain is associated with a decrease in length. To define the algebraic sign of a shear strain, we first identify the algebraic sign of each face of the infinitesimal strain element (the algebraic sign of face was defined in Sec. 5). An algebraically positive shear strain corresponds to a decrease in the angle between two positive faces, or equivalently, to a decrease in the angle between two negative faces. The above sign conventions can be used to confirm that all strains shown in Fig. 16 are algebraically positive. Example Problem 6 Given. The following two sets of strain components: exx ¼ 1000 Am=m Set1 : eyy ¼ 500 Am=m cxy ¼ 1500 Arad
exx ¼ 1000 Am=m Set2 : eyy ¼ 500 Am=m cxy ¼ 1500 Arad
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 17 Strain elements associated with Example Problem 6 (not to scale).
Determine. Prepare sketches (not to scale) of the deformed strain elements represented by the two sets of strain components. Solution. The required sketches are shown in Fig. 17. Note that the only difference between the two sets of strain components is that in Set 1, cxy is algebraically positive, whereas in Set 2, cxy is algebraically negative. 10 THE STRAIN TENSOR A general 3-D solid body is shown in Fig. 18(a). An infinitesimally small cube isolated from an interior region of the body is shown in Fig. 18(b). The cube is referenced to an x–y–z coordinate system, and the cube edges are aligned with these axes. Now assume that the body is subjected to some mechanism(s) which causes the body to deform. The mechanism(s) which causes this deformation need not be defined at this point, but might be external loading (i.e., stresses), a change in temperature, the adsorption or desorption of water molecules (in the case of polymeric-based materials such as composites), or any combination thereof. Since the entire body is deformed, the internal infinitesimal cube is deformed into a parallelepiped, as shown in Fig. 18(c). It can be shown (1,2) that the state of strain experienced by the cube can be represented as a
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 18 Infinitesimal elements used to illustrate the strain tensor.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
symmetric second-order tensor, involving six components of strain: three normal strains (exx, eyy, ezz) and three tensoral shear strains (exy, exz, eyz). These six strain components are defined in the same manner as those discussed in the preceding section. Normal strains exx, eyy, and ezz represent the change in length in the x-, y-, and z-directions, respectively. Tensoral shear strains exy, exz, and eyz represent the change in angle between cube edges initially aligned with the (x-,y-), (x-,z-), and ( y-,z-) axes, respectively. Using matrix notation, the strain tensor may be written as: 2 3 2 3 exx exy exz exx exy exz 4 eyx eyy eyz 5 ¼ 4 exy eyy eyz 5 ð34Þ ezx ezy ezz exz eyz ezz Alternatively, the strain tensor can be succinctly written using indicial notation as: eij ;
i; j ¼ x; y; or z
ð35Þ
Note that if engineering shear strain is used, then Eq. (34) becomes 2 3 2 3 exx ðcxy =2Þ ðcxz =2Þ exx exy exz 6 7 6 eyy ðcyz =2Þ 7 4 exy eyy eyz 5 ¼ 4 ðcxy =2Þ 5 exz eyz ezz ezz ðcxx =2Þ ðcyz =2Þ If engineering shear strain is used, the strain tensor cannot be written using indicial notation [as in Eq. (35)] due to the 1/2 factor that appears in all offdiagonal positions. In Sec. 1, it was noted that a force vector is a first-order tensor since only one subscript is required to describe a force tensor, Fi. The fact that strain is a second-order tensor is evident from Eq. (35) since two subscripts are necessary to describe a state of strain.
11 TRANSFORMATION OF THE STRAIN TENSOR Since both stress and strain are second-order tensors, the transformation of the strain tensor from one coordinate system to another is analogous to the transformation of the stress tensor, as discussed in Sec. 6. For example, it can be shown (1,2) that the strain components in the xV–yV–zV coordinate system (eiVjV) are related to the components in x–y–z coordinate system (eij) according to: ei V j V ¼ ci V k cj V l ekl
where k; l ¼ x; y; z
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð36aÞ
Alternatively, using matrix notation, the strain tensor transforms according to: ½ei V j V ¼ ½ci V j ½eij ½ci V j T which expands as follows: 2
e xV xV 6e V V 4 yx e z V xV
e xV y V ey V y V e zV y V
3 2 32 e xV z V c xV x c xV y c xV z exx 7 7 6 6 eyV zV 5 ¼ 4 cyV x cyV y cyV z 54 eyx czV x czV y czV z e zV zV ezx 3 2 c xV x c y V x c z V x 6c V c V c V 7 4 xy yy zy5 c xV z c y V z c z V z
exy eyy ezy
3 exz 7 eyz 5 ezz ð36bÞ
The terms ci Vj which appear in Eqs. (36a) and (36b) are direction cosines and equal the cosine of the angle between the axes of the xV–yV–zV and x–y–z coordinate systems. As was the case for the stress tensor, there are certain features of the strain tensor that do not vary when the tensor is transformed from one coordinate system to another. These features are called the strain invariants. Three independent strain invariants exist and are defined as follows: First strain invariant ¼ He ¼ eii
ð37aÞ
1 eii ejj eij eij ð37bÞ 2 1 ð37cÞ Third strain invariant ¼ We ¼ eii ejj ekk 3eii ejk ejk þ 2eij ejk eki 6
Second strain invariant ¼ Ue ¼
Alternatively, by expanding these equations over the range i, j, k=x, y, z and simplifying, the strain invariants can be written as: First strain invariant ¼ He ¼ exx þ eyy þ ezz
ð38aÞ
Second strain invariant ¼ Ue ¼ exx eyy þ exx ezz þ eyy ezz e2xy þ e2xz þ e2yz
ð38bÞ
Third strain invariant ¼ We ¼ exx eyy ezz exx e2yz eyy e2xz ezz e2xy þ 2exy exz eyz
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð38cÞ
Example Problem 7 Given. A state of strain referenced to an x–y–z coordinate is known to be: 3 2 3 2 1000 Am=m 500 Arad 250 Arad exx exy exz 7 6 7 6 1500 Am=m 750 Arad 5 4 eyx eyy eyz 5 ¼ 4 500 Arad ezx ezy ezz 250 Arad 750 Arad 2000 Am=m It is desired to express this state of strain in an xU–yU–zU coordinate system, generated by: (i) Rotation of h=20j about the original z-axis (which defines an intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system), followed by (ii) Rotation of b=35j about the xV-axis (which defines the final xU– yU–zU coordinate system). (This coordinate transformation has been previously considered in Example Problem 3 and is shown in Fig. 10.) Problem (a) Rotate the strain tensor to the xU–yU–zU coordinate system and (b) Calculate the first, second, and third invariants of the strain tensor using both elements of the strain tensor referenced to the x–y–z coordinate system, eij, and elements of the strain tensor referenced to the xU–yU–zU coordinate system, ei Uj U. Solution Part (a). General expressions for direction cosines relating the x–y–z and xU–yU–zU coordinate systems were determined as a part of Example Problem 1. Further, numerical values for the particular rotation h=20j and b=35j were determined in Example Problem 3 and were found to be: cxWx ¼ cos ð20B Þ ¼ 0:9397 cxWy ¼ sin ð20B Þ ¼ 0:3420 cxWz ¼ 0 cyWx ¼ cos ð35B Þsin ð20B Þ ¼ 0:2802 cyWy ¼ cos ð35B Þcos ð20B Þ ¼ 0:7698 cyWz ¼ sin ð35B Þ ¼ 0:5736 czWx ¼ sin ð35B Þsin ð20B Þ ¼ 0:1962
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
czWy ¼ sin ð35B Þcos ð20B Þ ¼ 0:5390 czWz ¼ cos ð35B Þ ¼ 0:8192 Each component of the transformed strain tensor can now be found through application of Eq. (36a) or Eq. (36b). For example, setting iV=xU, jV=xU, and expanding Eq. (36a), strain component exUxU is given by: ex Ux U ¼ cx Ux cx Ux exx þ cx Ux cx Uy exy þ cx Ux cx Uz exz þ cx Uy cx Ux eyx þ cx Uy cx Uy eyy þ cx Uy cx Uz eyz þ cx Uz cx Ux ezx þ cx Uz cx Uy ezy þ cx Uz cx Uz ezz ex Ux U ¼ ð0:9397Þð0:9397Þð1000Þ þ ð0:9397Þð0:3420Þð500Þ þð0:9397Þð0Þð250Þ þ ð0:3420Þð0:9397Þð500Þ þð0:3420Þð0:3420Þð1500Þ þ ð0:3420Þð0Þð750Þ þð0Þð0:9397Þð250Þ þ ð0Þð0:3420Þð750Þ þð0Þð0Þð2000Þ ex Ux U ¼ 1380 lm=m Alternatively, if matrix notation is used, then Eq. (36b) becomes: 2 3 2 3 0:9397 0:3420 0 exUxU exUyU exUzU 6 7 6 7 4 eyUxU eyUyU eyUzU 5 ¼ 4 0:2802 0:7698 0:5736 5 ezUxU ezUyU ezUzU 0:1962 0:5390 0:8192 2 3 1000 500 250 6 7 4 500 1500 750 5 2
250 0:9397
6 4 0:3420 0
750
2000
0:2802 0:7698 0:5736
0:1962
3
7 0:5390 5 0:8192
Completing the matrix multiplication indicated, there results: 3 3 2 2 1380 Am=m 727 Arad 91 Arad exUxU exUyU exUzU 7 7 6 6 1991 Am=m 625 Arad 5 4 eyUxU eyUyU eyUzU 5 ¼ 4 727 Arad ezUxU ezUyU ezUzU 91 Arad 625 Arad 1129 Am=m Notice that the value of exUxU determined through matrix multiplication is identical to that obtained using indicial notation, as expected.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Part (b). The first, second, and third strain invariants will now be calculated using components of both eij and eiUjU. It is expected that identical values will be obtained since the strain invariants are independent of the coordinate system. First strain invariant: x–y–z coordinate system: He ¼ eii ¼ exx þ eyy þ ezz He ¼ ð1000 þ 1500 þ 2000Þ Am=m He ¼ 4500Am=m ¼ :004500 m=m xU–yU–zU coordinate system: He ¼ eiUiU ¼ exUxU þ eyUyU þ ezUzU He ¼ ð1380 þ 1991 þ 1129Þ Am=m He ¼ 4500Am=m ¼ 0:004500 m=m As expected, the first strain invariant is independent of the coordinate system. Second strain invariant: x–y–z coordinate system: 1 eii ejj eij eij ¼ exx eyy þ exx ezz þ eyy ezz e2xy þ e2xz þ e2yz 2
Ue ¼ ð1000Þð1500Þ þ ð1000Þð2000Þ þ ð1500Þð2000Þ Ue ¼
½ð500Þ2 þ ð250Þ2 þ ð750Þ2 g ðAm=mÞ2 U ¼ 5:625 106 ðAm=mÞ2 ¼ 5:625 106 ðm=mÞ2 xU–yU–zU coordinate system: Ue ¼
1 eiUiU ejUjU eiUjU eiUjU 2
Ue ¼ exUxU eyUyU þ exUxU ezUzU þ eyUyU ezUzU e2xUyU þ e2xUzU þ e2yUzU Ue ¼ fð1380Þð1991Þ þ ð1380Þð1129Þ þ ð1991Þð1129Þ ½ð727Þ2 þ ð91Þ2 þ ð625Þ2 g ðAm=mÞ2 Ue ¼ 5:625 106 ðAm=mÞ2 ¼ 5:625 106 ðm=mÞ2
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
As expected, the second strain invariant is independent of the coordinate system. Third strain invariant: x–y–z coordinate system: 1 eii ejj ekk 3eii ejk ejk þ 2eij ejk eki 6 We ¼ exx eyy ezz exx e2yz eyy e2xz ezz e2xy þ 2exy exz eyz We ¼
We ¼ ½ð1000Þð1500Þð2000Þ ð1000Þð750Þ2 ð1500Þð250Þ2 ð2000Þ ð500Þ2 þ 2ð500Þð250Þð750Þ ðAm=mÞ3 W ¼ 2:031 109 ðAm=mÞ3 ¼ 2:031 109 ðm=mÞ3 xU–yU–zU coordinate system: 1 eiUiU ejUjU ekUkU 3eiUiU ejUkU ejUkU þ 2eiUjU ejUkU ekUiU 6 We ¼ exUxU eyUyU ezUzU exUxU e2yUzU eyUyU e2xUzU ezUzU e2xUyU þ 2exUyU exUzU eyUzU We ¼
We ¼ ½ð1380Þð1991Þð1129Þ ð1380Þð625Þ2 ð1991Þð91Þ2 ð1129Þ ð727Þ2 þ 2ð727Þð91Þð625Þ ðAm=mÞ3 W ¼ 2:031 109 ðAm=mÞ3 ¼ 2:031 109 ðm=mÞ3 As expected, the third stress invariant is independent of the coordinate system. 12 PRINCIPAL STRAINS The definition of the strain tensor was reviewed in Sec. 10, and transformation of the strain tensor from one coordinate system to another was discussed in Sec. 11. It can be shown (1,2) that it is always possible to rotate the strain tensor to a special coordinate system in which no shear strains exist. This coordinate system is called the principal strain coordinate system, and the normal strains that exist in this coordinate system are called principal strains. In most texts, the principal strains are denoted e1, e2, and e3. However, as will be discussed later (see Fig. 2 in Chap. 3), in this text, the axis labels ‘‘1,’’ ‘‘2,’’ and ‘‘3’’ will be used to refer to the principal material coordinate system rather than the directions of principal strain. Therefore,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
in this text, the axes associated with the principal strain coordinate system will be labeled p1, p2, and p3 axes, and the principal strains will be denoted ep1, ep2, and ep3. Since both stress and strain are second-order tensors, the principal strains can be found using an approach analogous to that used to find principal stresses. Specifically, it can be shown (1,2) that the principal strains must satisfy the following three simultaneous equations: ðepn exx Þcpn x exy cpn y exz cpn z ¼ 0
ð39aÞ
exy cpn x þ ðepn eyy Þcpn y eyz cpn z ¼ 0
ð39bÞ
exz cpn x eyz cpn y þ ðepn ezz Þcpn z ¼ 0
ð39cÞ
Since direction cosines cpnx, cpny, and cpnz must also satisfy Eq. (8), and therefore cannot all equal zero, the solution can be obtained by requiring that the determinant of the coefficients of cpnx, cpny, and cpnz equal zero: exy exz ðepn exx Þ ðepn eyy Þ eyz ¼ 0 exy exz eyz ðepn ezz Þ Equating the determinant to zero results in the following cubic equation: e3pn He e2pn þ Ue epn We ¼ 0
ð40Þ
where He, Ue, and We are the first, second, and third strain invariants, respectively, and have been previously listed as Eqs. (37a)–(37c) and (38a)– (38c). The three roots of the cubic equation (that is, the three principal strains) may be found by application of the standard approach (3), as follows: Define: 1 3Ue H2e 3 1 3 2He 9He Ue þ 27We b¼ 27 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 b b2 a3 þ A¼ þ 2 4 27 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 b b2 a 3 B¼ þ 2 4 27
a¼
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The three principal strains [i.e., the three roots of Eq. (40)] are then given by: 8 > > > > > > > <
He AþBþ 3 p ffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi AþB AB He þ 3 þ ep1 ; ep2 ; ep3 ¼ > 3 2 2 > > > p ffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi > AþB AB He > > : 3 þ 2 2 3
ð41Þ
By convention, the principal strains are numbered such that ep1 is the algebraically greatest principal strain, whereas ep3 is the algebraically least. That is, ep1>ep2>ep3. It is appropriate to note that many handheld calculators and computer software packages now feature standard routines to find the roots of nthorder polynomials. Hence, the roots of Eq. (40) may often be found more conveniently using these standard routines, rather than Eq. (41). The calculation of constants A and B that appear in Eq. (41) often involves finding the cube root of a complex number. The need to find the cube root of a complex number is encountered infrequently, and hence the reader may not be aware of how to make such a calculation. For convenience, a process that may be used to find the cube root of a complex number has been included in Appendix A. Once the principal strains are determined, the three sets of direction cosines (which define the principal coordinate directions) are found by substituting the three principal strains given by Eq. (41) into Eqs. (39a)– (39c) in turn. Since only two of Eqs. (39a)–(39c) are independent, Eq. (8) is used as a third independent equation involving the three unknown constants, cpnx, cpny, and cpnz. The process of finding principal strains and direction cosines will be demonstrated in the following example problem. Example Problem 8 Given. A state of strain referenced to an x–y–z coordinate is known to be: 2
exx
6 4 eyx ezx
exy eyy ezy
exz
3
2
1000 Am=m
7 6 eyz 5 ¼ 4 500 Arad ezz 250 Arad
500 Arad 1500 Am=m 750 Arad
250 Arad
3
7 750 Arad 5 2000 Am=m
Problem. Find (a) the principal strains and (b) the direction cosines that define the principal strain coordinate system.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Solution. This is the same strain tensor considered in Example Problem 7. As a part of that problem, the first, second, and third strain invariants were found to be: He ¼ 0:004500 m=m U ¼ 5:625 106 ðm=mÞ2 W ¼ 2:031 109 ðm=mÞ3 Part (a). Determining the principal strains. In accordance with Eq. (40), the three principal strains are the roots of the following cubic equation: e3pn ð0:004500Þe2pn þ ð5:625 106 Þepn ð2:031 109 Þ ¼ 0 Following the standard procedure for finding the roots of a cubic equation, we have: i 1h 1 3Ue H2e ¼ 3ð5:625 106 Þ ð0:004500Þ2 a¼ 3 3 ¼ 1:125 106 1 3 2He 9He Ue þ 27We b¼ 27 1 h 2ð0:004500Þ3 9ð0:004500Þð5:625 106 Þ b¼ 27 þ27ð2:031 109 Þ ¼ 3:435 1010 sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 b b2 a3 þ A¼ þ 2 4 27 vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi u u 3 10 t 3:435 10 ð3:435 1010 Þ2 ð1:125 106 Þ3 þ þ ¼ 2 4 27 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 A ¼ 1:718 1010 þ ið1:524 1010 Þ A ¼ 594:5 106 þ ið146:7 106 Þ sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 b b2 a 3 þ B¼ 2 4 27 vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi u u 3 3:435 1010 t ð3:435 1010 Þ2 ð1:125 106 Þ3 ¼ þ 2 4 27
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
B¼
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 1:718 1010 ið1:524 1010 Þ
B ¼ 594:5 106 ið146:7 106 Þ 8 H 2689Am=m > > AþBþ > > > > 3 > < A þ B pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi A B H þ 3 þ ep1 ; ep2 ; ep3 ¼ ¼ 651Am=m 2 2 3 > > > > > > > > > > A þ B pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi A B H > > > > 3 þ : : 2 2 3 1160Am=m 8 > > > > > > > <
Hence, ep1=2689 Am/m, ep2=1160 Am/m, and ep3=651 Am/m. Part (b).
Determining the direction cosines.
Equations (8), (39a), and (39b) will be used to form three independent equations in three unknowns. We have: ðepn exx Þcpn x exy cpn y exz cpn z ¼ 0 exy cpn x þ ðepn eyy Þcpn y eyz cpn z ¼ 0 ðcpn x Þ2 þ ðcpn y Þ2 þ ðcpn z Þ2 ¼ 1 Direction cosines for ep1. The three independent equations become: ð2689 1000Þcp1 x 500cp1 y 250cp1 z ¼ 0 500cp1 x þ ð2689 1500Þcp1 y 750cp1 z ¼ 0 ðcp1 x Þ2 þ ðcp1 y Þ2 þ ðcp1 z Þ2 ¼ 1 Solving simultaneously, we obtain: cp1 x ¼ 0:2872
cp1 y ¼ 0:5945
cp1 z ¼ 0:7511
Direction cosines for ep2. The three independent equations become: ð1160 1000Þcp2 x 500cp2 y 250cp2 z ¼ 0 500cp2 x þ ð1160 1500Þcp2 y 750cp2 z ¼ 0 ðcp2 x Þ2 þ ðcp2 y Þ2 þ ðcp2 z Þ2 ¼ 1 Solving simultaneously, we obtain: cp2 x ¼ 0:5960
cp2 y ¼ 0:5035 cp2 z ¼ 0:6256
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Direction cosines for ep3. The three independent equations become: ð651 1000Þcp3 x 500cp3 y 250cp3 z ¼ 0 500cp3 x þ ð651 1500Þcp3 y 750cp3 z ¼ 0 ðcp3 x Þ2 þ ðcp3 y Þ2 þ ðcp3 z Þ2 ¼ 1 Solving simultaneously, we obtain: cp3 x ¼ 0:7481
cp3 y ¼ 0:6286
cp3 z ¼ 0:2128
13 STRAINS WITHIN A PLANE PERPENDICULAR TO A PRINCIPAL STRAIN DIRECTION It has been seen that a strain tensor is defined by six components of strain: three normal strain components and three shear strain components. Now, in practice, there are circumstances in which it is known a priori that both shear strain components in one direction are zero: exz=eyz=0, say (or equivalently, cxz=cyz=0). This implies that the z-axis is a principal strain axis. In these instances, we are primarily interested in the strains induced within the x–y plane, exz, eyy, and exy. Two different circumstances are encountered in which it is known a priori that the z-axis is a principal strain axis. In the first case, all three out-of-plane strain components in the zdirection are known a priori to equal zero. That is, it is known a priori that ezz=exz=eyz=0. Not only is the z-axis a principal strain axis in this case, but, in addition, the principal strain equals zero: ezz=ep3=0. Since the three remaining nonzero strain components (exx, eyy, and exy) all lie within the x–y plane, it is natural to call this condition a state of plane strain. Plane strain conditions occur most often because of the geometry of the structure of interest. Specifically, the plane strain condition usually exists in internal regions of very long (or very thick) structures. Examples include solid shafts or long dams. In these instances, the strains induced along the long axis of the structure are often negligibly small compared to those induced within the transverse plane of the structure. The second case in which the out-of-plane z-axis may be a principal axis is when a structure is subjected to a state of plane stress. As has been discussed in Sec. 8, the state of plane stress occurs most often in thin, platelike structures. In this case, the z-axis is a principal strain axis, and ezz is again one of the principal strains. However, in this second case, the out-of-plane normal strain does not, in general, equal zero: ezz p 0. It is emphasized that a state of plane stress usually, but not always, causes a state of strain in which the z-axis is a principal strain axis. This point
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
will be further discussed in Chap. 4. It will be seen there that it is possible for a material to exhibit a coupling between in-plane stresses and out-of-plane shear strains. That is, in some cases, stresses acting within the x–y plane (rxx, ryy, and/or sxy) can cause out-of-plane shear strains (exz and/or eyz). In these instances, the out-of-plane z-axis is not a principal strain axis, although the out-of-plane stresses all equal zero. In any event, for present purposes, assume that it is known a priori that the out-of-plane z-axis is a principal strain axis, and we are primarily interested in the strains induced within the x–y plane, exx, eyy, and exy. We will write these strains in the form of a column array, rather than a 33 array: 9 8 9 8 2 3 2 3 e exx exy 0 exx ðcxy =2Þ 0 > = > < exx > = < xx > 6 7 6 7 eyy eyy 0 5 ! eyy ¼ 4 exy eyy 0 5 ¼ 4 ðcxy =2Þ > > > ; > : ; : exy 0 0 ezz 0 0 ezz cxy =2 Note that ezz does not appear in the column array. This is not of concern in the case of plane strain since, in this case, ezz=0. However, in the case of plane stress, it is important to remember that (in general) ezz p 0. Although in the following chapters we will be primarily interested in strains induced within the x–y plane, the reader is advised to remember that an out-of-plane strain ezz is also induced by a state of plane stress. The transformation of a general 3-D strain tensor has already been discussed in Sec. 11. The relations presented there will now be simplified for the case of transformation of strains within a plane. Recall that either Eq. (36a) or Eq. (36b) governs the transformation of a strain tensor from one coordinate system to another. Equation (36b) is repeated here for convenience: 2 3 2 32 3 e xV xV e xV y V e xV z V c xV x c xV y c xV z exx exy exz 6e V V e V V e V V 7 6c V 6 7 cyV y cyV z 7 4 yx 54 eyx eyy eyz 5 yy yz 5 ¼ 4 yx czV x czV y czV z e z V xV e z V y V e z V z V ezx ezy ezz 3 2 c xV x c y V x c z V x 7 6 ðrepeatedÞð36bÞ 4 cxV y cyV y czV y 5 c xV z c y V z c z V z Assuming that the xV–yV–zV coordinate system is generated from the x–y–z system by a rotation h about the z-axis, the direction cosines are: cxV x ¼ cos ðhÞ cxV y ¼ cos ð90B hÞ ¼ sin ðhÞ cxV z ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
cyV x ¼ cos ð90B þ hÞ ¼ sin ðhÞ cyV y ¼ cos ðhÞ cyV z ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV x ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV y ¼ cos ð90B Þ ¼ 0 czV z ¼ cos ð0B Þ ¼ 1 Substituting these direction cosines into Eq. (36b) and noting that by assumption, exz=eyz=0, we have: 2 3 2 32 3 cos h sin h 0 exx exy 0 exV xV exV yV exV zV 6e V V e V V e V V 7 6 76 7 eyy 0 5 4 yx yy y z 5 ¼ 4 sin h cos h 0 54 eyx ezV xV ezV yV ezV zV 0 0 ezz 0 0 1 2
cos h
6 4 sin h 0
sin h cos h 0
0
3
7 05 1
Completing the matrix multiplication indicated results in: 2
e xV xV
6 6 e yV x V 4 e z V xV
e x V yV e yV yV e z V yV
exV zV
3
7 e yV z V 7 5 e zV zV
2
3 cos2 hexx þ sin2 heyy þ 2 cos h sin hexy cos h sin hexx þ cos h sin heyy þ ðcos2 h sin2 hÞexy 0 2 2 ¼4cos h sin hexx þ cos h sin heyy þ ðcos2 h sin hÞexy sin hexx þ cos2 heyy 2 cos h sin hexy 05 0 0 ezz
As would be expected, exVzV=eyVzV=0. The remaining strain components are: exV xV ¼ cos2 ðhÞexx þ sin2 ðhÞeyy þ 2 cosðhÞsinðhÞexy eyV yV ¼ sin2 ðhÞexx þ cos2 ðhÞeyy 2 cosðhÞsinðhÞexy
ð42Þ
exV yV ¼ cosðhÞsinðhÞexx þ cosðhÞsinðhÞeyy þ ½cos ðhÞ þ sin ðhÞexy 2
2
ezV zV ¼ ezz Tensoral shear strains were used in Eqs. (36a) and (36b) for mathematical convenience; that is, tensoral shear strains have been used so that rotation of the strain tensor could be accomplished using the normal transformation law for a second-order tensor. Since engineering shear strains are far more commonly used in practice, we will now convert our final results, Eq. (42), to ones which involve engineering shear strain (cxy). Recall from Sec. 9 that
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
exy ¼ 12 cxy . Hence, to convert Eq. (42), simply replace exy with 12 cxy everywhere, resulting in: exV xV ¼ cos2 ðhÞexx þ sin2 ðhÞeyy þ cosðhÞsinðhÞcxy eyV yV ¼ sin2 ðhÞexx þ cos2 ðhÞeyy cosðhÞsinðhÞcxy ð43Þ c xV y V c xy ¼ cosðhÞsinðhÞexx þ cosðhÞsinðhÞeyy þ ½cos2 ðhÞ þ sin2 ðhÞ 2 2 ezV zV ¼ ezz Equation (43) relates the components of strain in two different coordinate systems within a single plane and will be used extensively throughout the remainder of this text. The first three of Eq. (43) can be written using matrix notation as: 8 9 3 e xV xV > 2 > > > cos2 ðhÞ sin2 ðhÞ 2 cosðhÞsinðhÞ < = ey V y V 7 6 ¼4 sin2 ðhÞ cos2 ðhÞ 2 cosðhÞsinðhÞ 5 > > c V V > xy ; > : cosðhÞsinðhÞ cosðhÞ sinðhÞ cos2 ðhÞ sin2 ðhÞ 2 9 8 exx > > > > = < eyy ð44Þ > > > ; : cxy > 2 Compare Eq. (44) with Eq. (20). In particular, note that the transformation matrix, [T], which was previously encountered during the discussion of plane stress in Sec. 8, also appears in Eq. (44). The strain invariants [given by Eqs. (37a)–(37c) or Eqs. (38a)–(38c)] are considerably simplified when the out-of-plane z-axis is a principal axis. Since c by definition exz ¼ c2xz ¼ eyz ¼ 2yz ¼ 0, the strain invariants become: First strain invariant ¼ He ¼ exx þ eyy þ ezz Second strain invariant ¼ Ue ¼ exx eyy þ exx ezz þ eyy ezz Third strain invariant ¼ We ¼ exx eyy ezz ezz
c4xy
c2xy 4
ð45Þ
4 The principal strains equal the roots of the cubic equation previously listed as Eq. (40). Substituting Eq. (45) into Eq. (40) reduces to: e3pn ðexx þ eyy þ ezz Þe2pn þ ðexx eyy þ exx ezz þ eyy ezz ðexx eyy ezz ezz
c2xy Þ¼0 4
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
c2xy 4
Þepn ð46Þ
One root of Eq. (23) is epn=ezz. For present purposes, this root will be labeled ep3 although it may not be the algebraically least principal strain. In the case of plane strain, ep3=ezz=0. Removing the known root from Eq. (46), we have the following quadratic equation: c2xy
Þ¼0 4 The two roots of this quadratic equation (that is, the two remaining principal strains, ep1 and ep2) may be found by application of the standard approach (3) and are given by: sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi e e 2 c 2 exx þ eyy xx yy xy ð47Þ F ep1 ; ep2 ¼ þ 2 2 2 e2pn ðexx þ eyy Þepn þ ðexx eyy
The angle hpe between the x-axis and either the p1 or p2 axis is given by: cxy 1 hpe ¼ arctan ð48Þ 2 exx eyy Example Problem 9 Given. A state of plane strain is known to consist of: exx ¼ 500 Am=m eyy ¼ 1000 Am=m cxy ¼ 2500 Arad Problem. (a) Prepare a rough sketch (not to scale) of the deformed strain element in the x–y coordinate system; (b) determine the strain components which correspond to an xV–yV coordinate system, oriented 25j CCW from the x–y coordinate system, and prepare a rough sketch (not to scale) of the deformed strain element in the xV–yV coordinate system; and (c) determine the principal strain components that exist within the x–y plane, and prepare a rough sketch (not to scale) of the deformed strain element in the principal strain coordinate system. Solution Part (a). A sketch showing the deformed strain element (not to scale) in the x–y coordinate system is shown in Fig. 19(a). Note that: The length of the element side parallel to the x-axis has increased (corresponding to the tensile strain exx=500 Am/m). The length of the element side parallel to the y-axis has decreased (corresponding to the compressive strain eyy=1000 Am/m).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 19 Strain elements associated with Example Problem 9 (all deformations shown greatly exaggerated for clarity).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The angle defined by x–y axes has increased (corresponding to the negative shear strain cxy=2500 Arad). Part (b). Since the xV-axis is oriented 25j CCW from the x-axis, in accordance with the right-hand rule, the angle of rotation is positive, i.e., h=+25j. Substituting this angle and the given strain components in Eq. (44): 8 9 2 3 exV xV > > cos2 ð25B Þ sin2 ð25B Þ 2 cosð25B Þsinð25B Þ > > <e = 6 7 yV yV ¼6 cos2 ð25B Þ 2cosð25B Þsinð25B Þ 7 sin2 ð25B Þ 4 5 > c V V> > ; : xy> 2 B B B B 2 B B cosð25 Þsinð25 Þ cosð25 Þsinð25 Þ cos ð25 Þ sin ð25 Þ 2 8 9 500 > > > > > > = < 1000 > > > 2500 > > > ; : 2 Completing the matrix multiplication indicated results in: 9 8 9 8 exV xV > > 725 Am=m > > > > > > = = < < ey V y V ¼ 225 Am=m > > > > > > : ; ; > : c xV y V > 1378 Arad 2 A sketch showing the deformed strain element (not to scale) in the xV–yV coordinate system is shown in Fig. 19(b). Note that: The length of the element side parallel to the xV-axis has decreased (corresponding to the compressive strain exVxV=725 Am/m). The length of the element side parallel to the yV-axis has increased (corresponding to the tensile strain eyVyV=225 Am/m). The angle defined by the xV–yV axes has increased (corresponding to the negative shear strain cxVyV=2756 Arad). The principal strains are found through application of Eq. (47): sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi 500 1000 500 þ 1000 2 2500 2 F þ ep1 ; ep2 ¼ 2 2 2
Part (c).
ep1 ¼ 1208 Am=m ep2 ¼ 1708 Am=m The orientation of the principal strain coordinate system is given by Eq. (48): 1 2500 hpe ¼ arctan ¼ 29:5B 2 500 þ 1000
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
A sketch showing the deformed strain element (not to scale) in the principal strain coordinate system is shown in Fig. 19(c). Note that: The length of the element side parallel to the p1-axis has increased (corresponding to the tensile principal strain ep1=1208 Am/m). The length of the element side parallel to the p2-axis has decreased (corresponding to the compressive principal strain ep2=1708 Am/m). The angle defined by the principal strain axes has remained precisely p/2 radians (i.e., 90j) since in the principal strain coordinate system, the shear strain is zero.
14 RELATING STRAINS TO DISPLACEMENT FIELDS Most analyses considered in this text begin with the consideration of the displacement fields induced in the structure of interest. That is, mathematical expressions that describe the displacements induced at all points within a structure by external loading and/or environmental changes will be assumed or otherwise specified. Strains induced in the structure will then be inferred from these displacement fields. In the most general case, three displacement fields are involved. Specifically, these are the displacements in the x-, y-, and z-directions, typically denoted as the u-, v-, and w-displacement fields, respectively. In general, all three displacement fields are functions of x, y, and z: Displacements in the x-direction: u=u(x,y,z). Displacements in the y-direction: v=v(x,y,z). Displacements in the z-direction: w=w(x,y,z). However, if the out-of-plane z-axis is a principal strain axis, then u and v are (at most) functions of x and y only, while w is (at most) a function of z only. In this case: Displacements in the x-direction: u=u(x,y). Displacements in the y-direction: v=v(x,y). Displacements in the z-direction: w=w(z). A detailed derivation of the relationship between displacements and strains is beyond the scope of this review, and the interested reader is referred to Frederick and Chang (1) or Fung (2) for details. It can be shown that the relationship between displacement fields and the strain tensor depends upon the magnitude of derivatives of displacement fields (also called displacement gradients). If displacement gradients are arbitrarily large, then
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the associated level of strain is said to be finite, and each component of the strain tensor is related nonlinearly to displacement gradients as follows: " # Bu 1 Bu 2 Bv 2 Bw 2 þ exx ¼ þ þ Bx 2 Bx Bx Bx " # Bv 1 Bu 2 Bv 2 Bw 2 þ eyy ¼ þ þ By 2 By By By " # Bw 1 Bu 2 Bv 2 Bw 2 þ ezz ¼ þ þ Bz 2 Bz Bz Bz Bu Bv Bu Bu Bv Bv Bw Bw þ þ cxy ¼ þ þ By Bx Bx By Bx By Bx By Bu Bw Bu Bu Bv Bv Bw Bw þ þ cxz ¼ þ þ Bz Bx Bx Bz Bx Bz Bx Bz Bw Bv Bu Bu Bv Bv Bw Bw þ þ cyz ¼ þ þ By Bz By Bz By Bz By Bz The expressions listed above define what is known as Green’s strain tensor (also known as the Lagrangian strain tensor). In most cases encountered in practice, however, displacement gradients are very small, and consequently the products of displacement gradients are negligibly small and can be discarded. For example, it can usually be assumed that: 2 2 2 Bu Bv Bw Bu Bu c0; etc: c0 c0 c0 Bx Bx Bx Bx By When displacement gradients are very small, the level of strain is said to be infinitesimal, and each component of the strain tensor is linearly related to displacement gradients as follows: Bu Bx Bv eyy ¼ By Bw ezz ¼ Bz Bv Bu þ cxy ¼ Bx By
exx ¼
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð49aÞ ð49bÞ ð49cÞ ð49dÞ
Bw Bu þ Bx Bz Bw Bv þ cyz ¼ By Bz
ð49eÞ
cxz ¼
ð49f Þ
For most analyses considered in this text, we will assume that strains are infinitesimal and are related to displacement fields in accordance with Eqs. (49a)–(49f). The one exception occurs in Chap. 11, where it will be necessary to include nonlinear terms in the strain–displacement relationships. As stated above, most analyses begin with the consideration of the displacement fields induced in a structure of interest. Strain fields implied by these displacements are then calculated in accordance with Eqs. (49a)–(49f). This process insures that strain fields are consistent with displacements. Consider the opposite approach. Specifically, suppose that mathematical expressions for strain fields are assumed, perhaps on the basis of engineering judgment. In this case, it is possible that the assumed strain fields correspond to physically unrealistic displacement fields. For example, displacement fields inferred from assumed strain fields may imply that the solid body has voids and/or overlapping regions, a physically unrealistic circumstance. A system of six equations known as the compatibility conditions can be developed that guarantee that assumed expressions for the six components of strain do, in fact, correspond to physically reasonable displacement fields u(x,y,z), v(x,y,z), and w(x,y,z). To develop the compatibility conditions, differentiate Eq. (49d) twice, once with respect to x and once with respect to y. We obtain: B2 cxy B3 u B3 v ¼ þ 2 2 Bx By BxBy BxBy From Eqs. (49a) and (49b), it is easily seen that: B2 exx B3 u ¼ BxBy2 By2
B2 eyy B3 v ¼ Bx2 By Bx2
Combining these results, we see that expressions for the strain components exx, eyy, and cxy correspond to physically reasonable displacement fields (i.e., ‘‘are compatible’’) only if they satisfy: B2 cxy B2 exx B2 eyy ¼ þ BxBy By2 Bx2
ð50aÞ
Equation (50a) is the first compatibility condition. Following a similar procedure using Eqs. (49e) and (49f), we obtain: B2 cyz B2 eyy B2 ezz ¼ þ ByBz Bz2 By2
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð50bÞ
B2 cxz B2 exx B2 ezz ¼ þ BxBz Bz2 Bx2
ð50cÞ
These are the second and third compatibility conditions. Next, the following expressions are obtained using Eqs. (49a), (49d), (49e), and (49f), respectively: B3 u B2 exx ¼ BxByBz ByBz B2 cxy B3 u B3 v ¼ 2 BxByBz BxBz Bx Bz B3 u B2 cxz B3 w 2 ¼ BxByBz BxBy Bx By B2 cyz B3 w B3 v þ ¼ Bx2 By Bx2 Bz Bx2 Combining these four expressions, we find that assumed expressions for strain components exx, cxy, cxz, and cyz, are compatible if: B2 exx B Bcxy Bcxz cyz ¼ þ 2 ð50dÞ ByBz Bx Bz By Bx This is the fourth compatibility condition. The final two compatibility conditions are developed using a similar process and are given by: B2 eyy B Bcyz Bcxz cxy ¼ þ ð50eÞ 2 BxBz By Bx By Bz B2 ezz B Bcyz Bcxz cxy ¼ þ ð50f Þ 2 BxBy Bz Bx By Bz 15 COMPUTER PROGRAMS 3DROTATE AND 2DROTATE A review of the force, stress, and strain tensors has been presented in this chapter. These concepts will be applied routinely throughout the remainder of this text, as we develop a macromechanics-based analysis of structural composite materials and structures. It will be seen that the transformation of stress and strain tensors is of particular importance. Indeed, nearly all analyses of composite materials and structures presented herein require multiple transformations of stress and strain tensors from one coordinate system to another. Two computer programs, 3DROTATE and 2DROTATE, that can be used to perform transformations of force, stress, or strain tensors have been developed to accompany this text. These programs can also be downloaded
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
at no cost from the following website: http://debts.washington.edu/amtas/ computer.html. Program 3DROTATE performs the calculations necessary to transform a force, stress, or strain tensor from the x–y–z coordinate system to the xU–yU–zU coordinate system, where the xU–yU–zU coordinate system is generated from the x–y–z coordinate system by (up to) three successive rotations. Derivation of the direction cosines that relate these two coordinate systems is left as a student exercise, but are listed in Homework Problem 2. Program 3DROTATE also calculates the angles between the x–y–z and xU–yU–zU coordinate axes, invariants of the force, stress, or strain tensors, and principal stresses and strains. All of the numerical results discussed in Example Problems 1, 3, and 7 can be obtained through the use of program 3DROTATE. The second program, 2DROTATE, can be used to rotate stresses within a plane (as discussed in Sec. 8) and/or strains within a plane (as discussed in Sec. 13). For the most part, thin platelike composite structures will be considered in this textbook. Therefore, it can usually be assumed that the direction normal to the surface of the composite is a direction of principal stress or strain. Hence, most of the stress or strain transformations considered in this text involve rotations within a plane. Most of the numerical results discussed in Example Problems 5 and 9 can be obtained through the use of program 2DROTATE.
HOMEWORK PROBLEMS In the following problems, the phrase ‘‘solve by hand’’ means that numerical solutions should be obtained using a pencil, paper, and nonprogrammable calculator. Solutions obtained by hand will then be compared to numerical results returned by appropriate computer programs. This process will insure understanding of the mathematical processes involved. 1. Solve part (c) of Example Problem 1 by hand based on the rotation angles listed below. In each case, calculate the magnitude of the transformed force vector. Confirm your calculations using program 3DROTATE. (a) h=60j (b) h=60j (c) h=60j (d) h=60j (e) h=45j
b=45j. b=45j. b=45j. b=45j. b=60j.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(f ) h=45j (g) h=45j (h) h=45j
b=60j. b=60j. b=60j.
2. Consider an xVVV–yVVV–zVVV coordinate system, which is generated from an x–y–z coordinate system by the following three rotations:
A rotation of about the original z-axis, which defines an intermediate xV–yV–zV coordinate system [see Fig. 2(a)], followed by A rotation of b about the xV-axis, which defines an intermediate xVV– yVV–zVV coordinate system [see Fig. 2(b)], followed by A rotation of w about the yVV-axis, which defines the final xVVV–yVVV–zVVV coordinate system. Show that the xVVV–yVVV–zVVV and x–y–z coordinate systems are related by the following direction cosines: 2
3 cxVVV x cxVVV y cxVVV z 4 cyVVV x cyVVV y cyVVV z 5 czVVV x czVVV y czVVV z 2 3 cos w cos h sin w sin b sin h cos w sinh þ sin w sin b cos h sin w cos b ¼4 cos b sin h cos b cos h sin b 5 sin w cos h þ cos w sin b sin h sin w sin h cos w sin b cos h cos w cos b
3. The force vector discussed in Example Problem 1 is given by: F ¼ 1000iˆ þ 200jˆ þ 600kˆ Using Eq. (6c), express F in a new coordinate system defined by three successive rotations, as listed below, using the direction cosines listed in Problem 2. In each case, compare the magnitude of the transformed force vector to the magnitudes calculated in Example Problem 1. Solve these problems by hand and then confirm your calculations using program 3DROTATE. (a) h=60j (b) h=60j (c) h=60j (d) h=60j (e) h=60j
b=45j b=45j b=45j b=45j b=45j
w=25j. w=25j. w=25j. w=25j. w=25j.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4.
Solve Example Problem 3 by hand using the following rotation angles: (a) h=20j (b) h=20j (c) h=20j
b=35j. b=35j. b=35j.
Confirm your calculations using program 3DROTATE. 5. Use Eq. (12a) to obtain an expression (in expanded form) for the following stress component [in each case, the expanded expression will be similar to Eq. (13)]: (a) rxVxV. (b) rxVyV. (c) ryVyV. (d) ryVzV. (e) rzVzV. 6. Use program 3DROTATE to determine the stress invariants for the stress tensor listed below, and compare to those determined in Example Problem 3. (Note: this stress tensor is similar to the one considered in Example Problem 3 except that the algebraic sign of all three normal stresses has been reversed.): 2
rxx 4 ryx rzx
rxy ryy rzy
3 2 rxz 50 ryz 5 ¼ 4 10 rzz 15
10 25 30
3 15 30 5 ðksiÞ 5
7. Use program 3DROTATE to determine the stress invariants for the stress tensor listed below, and compare to those determined in Example Problem 3. (Note: this stress tensor is similar to the one considered in Example Problem 3 except that the algebraic sign of all three shear stresses has been reversed.): 2
rxx 4 ryx rzx
rxy ryy rzy
3 2 rxz 50 ryz 5 ¼ 4 10 rzz 15
10 25 30
3 15 30 5 ðksiÞ 5
8. Use program 3DROTATE to determine the stress invariants for the stress tensor listed below, and compare to those determined in Example
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Problem 3. (Note: this stress tensor is similar to the one considered in Example Problem 3 except that the algebraic sign of all stress components has been reversed.): 2
rxx 4 ryx rzx
rxy ryy rzy
3 2 rxz 50 ryz 5 ¼ 4 10 rzz 15
10 25 30
3 15 30 5 ðksiÞ 5
9. Use program 3DROTATE to determine the strain invariants for the strain tensor listed below, and compare to those determined in Example Problem 7. (Note: this strain tensor is similar to the one considered in Example Problem 7 except that the algebraic sign of all shear strain components has been reversed.): 2
exx 6 4 eyx ezx 10.
3 2 1000 Am=m exz 7 6 eyz 5 ¼ 4 500 Arad ezz 250 Arad
500 Arad
250 Arad
3
1500 Am=m
7 750 Arad 5
750 Arad
2000 Am=m
Use program 3DROTATE to determine the strain invariants for the strain tensor listed below, and compare to those determined in Example Problem 7. (Note: this strain tensor is similar to the one considered in Example Problem 7 except that the algebraic sign of all normal strain components has been reversed.): 2
exx 6 4 eyx ezx 11.
exy eyy ezy
exy eyy ezy
3 2 1000 Am=m 500 Arad exz 7 6 eyz 5 ¼ 4 500 Arad 1500 Am=m ezz 250 Arad 750 Arad
250 Arad 750 Arad
3 7 5
2000 Am=m
Use program 3DROTATE to determine the strain invariants for the strain tensor listed below, and compare to those determined in Example Problem 7. (Note: this strain tensor is similar to the one considered in Example Problem 7 except that the algebraic sign of all strain components has been reversed.): 2
exx 6 4 eyx ezx
exy eyy ezy
3 2 1000 Am=m 500 Arad exz 7 6 eyz 5 ¼ 4 500 Arad 1500 Am=m ezz 250 Arad 750 Arad
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
250 Arad
3
7 750 Arad 5
2000 Am=m
REFERENCES 1.
Frederick, D.; Chang, T.S. Continuum Mechanics; Scientific Publishers, Inc: Cambridge, MA, 1972. 2. Fung, Y.C. A First Course In Continuum Mechanics; Prentice-Hall, Inc.: Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1969. 3. Consult any handbook of mathematical functions and tables, for example, CRC Basic Mathematical Tables; Shelby, S.M. The Chemical Company: Cleveland, OH, 1970.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
3 Material Properties
In this chapter, various material properties required to predict the performance of composite structures are introduced. The chapter begins with a general discussion of isotropic vs. anisotropic material behaviors. It will be pointed out that most composites can be classified as either orthotropic or transversely isotropic materials. Sections devoted to those material properties of primary interest to structural engineers then follow. Specifically, separate sections are presented, which describe material properties that allow an engineer to:
Relate stress to strain Relate temperature to strain Relate moisture content to strain Relate stress (or strain) to failure.
In each section, material properties will first be defined for anisotropic materials. These general definitions will then be applied to the case of composites (i.e., they will be specialized for the case of orthotropic or transversely isotropic materials). 1 ANISOTROPIC VS. ISOTROPIC MATERIALS The phrase material property refers to a measurable constant that is characteristic of a particular material and can be used to relate two disparate quantities 117
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
of interest. Material properties that describe the ability of a material to conduct electricity, to transmit (or reflect) visible light, to transfer heat, or to support mechanical loading, to name but a few, have been defined. Material properties of interest herein are those used by engineers during the design of composite structures. Two specific examples are Young’s modulus, E and Poisson’s ratio v. These two familiar material properties, which will be reviewed and further discussed in Sec. 2, are used to relate the stress and strain tensors. The adjectives ‘‘anisotropic’’ and ‘‘isotropic’’ indicate whether a material exhibits a single value for a given material property. More specifically, if the properties of a material are independent of direction within the material, then the material is said to be isotropic. Conversely, if the material properties vary with direction within the material, then the material is said to be anisotropic. To clarify this statement, suppose that three test specimens are machined from a large block at three different orientations, as shown in Fig. 1. The geometry of the three specimens is assumed to be identical, so that the only difference between specimens is the original orientation of each specimen within the ‘‘parent’’ block. Now suppose that the axial stiffness (i.e., Young’s modulus E ) is measured for each specimen. Young’s modulus measured using specimen 1 will be denoted Exx (i.e., subscripts are used to indicate the original orientation of specimen 1 within the parent block). Similarly, Young’s modulus measured using specimens 2 and 3 will be denoted Eyy and Ezz, respectively. If the parent block consists of an isotropic material, then Young’s modulus measured for each specimen will be identical (to within engineering accuracies)—for isotropic materials: Exx = Eyy = Ezz. In this case, an identical value of Young’s modulus is measured in the x-, y-, and z-directions, and is independent of direction within the material. In contrast, if the parent block is an anisotropic material, a different Young’s modulus will, in general, be measured for each specimen—for anisotropic materials: Exx p Eyy p Ezz. In this case, the value of Young’s modulus depends on the direction within the material the modulus is measured. For anisotropic materials, a similar dependence on direction can occur for any material property of interest (Poisson’s ratio, thermal expansion coefficients, ultimate strengths, etc). It is the microstructural features of a material that determine whether it exhibits isotropic or anisotropic behavior. Consequently, to classify a given material as isotropic or anisotropic, one must first define the physical scale of interest. For example, it is well known that metals and metal alloys are made up of individual grains, and that the atoms that exist within these grains are
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 1 Illustration of method used to determine whether a material is isotropic or anisotropic.
arranged in well-defined crystalline arrays. The most common crystalline arrays are the body-centered cubic (BCC), the face-centered cubic (FCC), or the hexagonal close-packed (HCP) structure [1]. Due to the highly ordered and symmetrical atomic structures that exist within these arrays, an individual grain exhibits different properties in different directions, and hence is anisotropic. That is to say, if material properties are defined at a physical scale on
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the order of a grain diameter or smaller, then all metals or metal alloys must be defined as anisotropic materials. It does not necessarily follow, however, that a metal or metal alloy will exhibit anisotropic behavior at the structural level. This is because individual grains are typically very small, and the orientation of the atomic crystalline arrays usually varies randomly from one grain to the next. As a typical case, it is not uncommon for a steel alloy to exhibit an average grain diameter of 0.044 mm (0.0017 in.), or roughly 8200 grains/mm3 (134 106 grains/in.3) [1]. If the grains are randomly oriented, which is a common case, then at the structural level (say, at a physical scale >1 mm), the steel alloy will exhibit isotropic properties even though the constituent grains are anisotropic. Conversely, if a significant percentage of grains is caused to be oriented by some mechanism (such as cold rolling, for example), then the same steel alloy will be anisotropic at the structural level. Polymeric composites are anisotropic at the structural level, and the microstructural features that lead to this anisotropy are immediately apparent. Specifically, it is the uniform and symmetrical orientation of the reinforcing fibers within a ply that leads to anisotropic behavior. As a simple example, suppose two specimens are machined from a thin unidirectional composite plate consisting of high-strength fibers embedded within a relatively flexible polymeric matrix, as shown in Fig. 2a and b. Note that the coordinate system used to describe the plate has been labeled the 1–2–3 axes. In this case, the 1-axis is defined to be parallel to the fibers, the 2-axis is defined to lie within the plane of the plate and is perpendicular to the fibers, and the 3axis is defined to be normal to the plane of the plate. Note that fibers are arranged symmetrically about the 1–3 and 2–3 planes. The 1–2–3 coordinate system will henceforth be referred to as the principal material coordinate system. Referring to Fig. 2a, specimen 1 is machined such that the fibers are aligned with the long axis of the specimen, whereas in specimen 2, the fibers are perpendicular to the axis of the specimen. Obviously, Young’s modulus measured for these two specimens will be quite different. Specifically, the modulus measured for specimen 1 will approach that of the fibers, whereas the modulus measured for specimen 2 will approach that of the polymeric matrix. Therefore, E11> >E22, and Young’s modulus varies with direction within the material, satisfying the definition of an anisotropic material. The principal material coordinate system is not always aligned with the fiber direction, as shown in Fig. 2c and d. In this case, the thin composite plate is formed using a braided fabric. As discussed in Sec. 4 of Chap. 1, braided fabrics contain fibers oriented in two (or more) nonorthogonal directions. The three principal material coordinate axes lie within planes that are symmetrical with respect to the fiber array. As before, the 1- and 2-axes lie within the plane of the plate, and the 3-axis is defined normal to the plane of the plate.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 2 Illustration of the principal material coordinate system for thin composite laminates.
One of the most unusual features of anisotropic materials is that they can exhibit coupling between normal stresses and shear strains, as well as coupling between shear stress and normal strains. A physical explanation of how this coupling occurs in the case of a unidirectional composite is presented in Fig. 3. A specimen in which the unidirectional fibers are oriented at an angle of 45j with respect to the x-axis is shown, and a small square element from the gage region is isolated. Because the element is initially square and, in this example, the fibers are defined to be at an angle of 45j, fibers are parallel to diagonal AC of the element. In contrast, fibers are perpendicular to diagonal BD. This implies that the element is stiffer along diagonal AC than along diagonal BD.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 3 A 45j off-axis composite specimen used to explain the origin of coupling effects.
Now assume that a tensile stress is applied, causing the square element (as well as the specimen as a whole) to deform. Because the stiffness is higher along diagonal AC than along diagonal BD, the length of diagonal AC is increased to a lesser extent than that of diagonal BD. Hence, the initially square element deforms into a parallelogram, as shown in the figure. Note that:
The length of the square element is increased in the x-direction (corresponding to a tensile strain, exx). The length of the square element is decreased in the y-direction (corresponding to a compressive strain eyy, and associated with the Poisson effect). BDAB is no longer p/2 rad, which indicates that a shear strain cxy has been induced.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Hence, in this example, the normal stress rxx has induced two normal strains (exx and eyy) as well as a shear strain cxy. Hence, coupling exists between rxx and cxy, as stipulated. The couplings between normal stresses and shear strains (as well as couplings between shear stresses and normal strains) will be explained in a formal mathematical sense in Chap. 4. However, two important conclusions can be drawn from the physical explanation shown in Fig. 3. First, note that the specimen shown is subjected to normal stress rxx only. In particular, note that no shear stress exists in the x–y coordinate system (sxy = 0). Consequently, the in-plane principal stresses applied to the specimen are rp1 = rxx and rp2 = ryy = 0, and the principal stress coordinate system is defined by the x–y coordinate system. However, a shear strain does exist in the x–y coordinate system (cxy p 0). Consequently, the x–y coordinate system is not the principal strain coordinate system. We conclude, therefore, that the principal stress coordinate system is not aligned with the principal strain coordinate system. This is generally true for all anisotropic materials and is in direct contrast to the behavior of isotropic materials because for isotropic materials, the principal stress and principal strain coordinate systems are always coincident. Secondly, note that the physical argument used above to explain the origin of the coupling effect hinges on the fact that the fiber direction differs from the direction of the applied stress rxx. Specifically, the fibers are oriented 45j away from the direction of the applied stress rxx. If the fibers were aligned with either the x- or y-axis, then a coupling between rxx and cxy would not occur. We conclude that the unusual coupling effects exhibited by composites only occur if stress and strain are referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system. Anisotropic materials are classified according to the number of planes of symmetry defined by the microstructure. The principal material coordinate axes lie within the planes of symmetry. For example, in the case of unidirectional composites, three planes of symmetry can be defined: the 1–2 plane, the 1–3 plane, and the 2–3 plane. Composites fall within one of two classifications of anisotropic behavior. Specifically, composites are either orthotropic materials or transversely isotropic materials (the distinction between orthotropic and transversely isotropic materials will be further discussed in Sec. 2). During the composite structural analyses discussed in this text, the composite will be called ‘‘anisotropic’’ if the coordinate system of reference is a nonprincipal material coordinate system. Use of the term ‘‘anisotropic’’ will therefore signal the possibility of couplings between normal stresses and shear strains, and couplings between shear stresses and normal strains. If, instead, a structural analysis is referenced to the principal material coordinate system, the composite will be called either orthotropic or transversely isotropic.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Although many kinds of material properties may be defined, in this text we are only interested in those properties commonly used by structural engineers. The properties needed to perform a structural analysis of composite structures will be defined in the following sections. In each section, a general definition of the material property will be given, suitable for use with anisotropic materials. That is, the properties of a composite material when referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system will be discussed first. These general definitions will then be specialized to the principal material coordinate system (i.e., they will be specialized for the case of orthotropic or transversely isotropic composites). Typical values of the properties discussed in this chapter measured at room temperatures are listed for glass/epoxy, Kevlar/epoxy, and graphite/ epoxy in Table 3. These properties do not represent the properties of any specific commercial composite material system, but rather should be viewed as typical values. Due to ongoing research and development activities within the industry, the properties of composites are improved more or less continuously. Therefore, the properties listed in Table 3 may not reflect those of currently available materials. The properties that appear in the table will be used in example and homework problems throughout the remainder of this text. 2 MATERIAL PROPERTIES THAT RELATE STRESS TO STRAIN Both stress and strain are second-order tensors, as discussed in Chap. 2. The material properties used to relate the stress and strain tensors are inferred from experimental measurements. Conceptually, two different experimental approaches may be taken. In the first approach, the material of interest is subjected to a well-defined stress tensor, and components of the resulting strain tensor are measured. In the second approach, the material of interest is subjected to a well-defined strain tensor, and the components of the resulting stress tensor are measured. From an experimental standpoint, it is far easier to impose a well-defined stress tensor than a well-defined strain tensor, and hence the first approach is almost always used in practice. Recall that there are two fundamental types of stress components: normal stress and shear stress. As a consequence, two fundamental types of tests are used to relate stress to strain—specifically, a test that involves the application of a known normal stress component and a test involving application of a known shear stress component. In either case, a stress tensor is imposed in which five of the six stress components equal zero, and the resulting six components of the strain tensor are measured. Tests that involve application of a known normal stress component are called uniaxial tests. In a typical case, a single normal stress component is
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
applied to a test specimen (say, rxx), while insuring that the remaining five stress components are zero (ryy = rzz = sxy = sxz = syz = 0). The six components of strain caused by rxx are measured, which allows the calculation of various material properties relating a normal stress component to the strain tensor. In contrast, tests that involve application of a known shear stress component are called pure shear tests. In a typical case, a single shear stress component is applied to a test specimen (say, sxy), while insuring that the remaining five stress components are zero (rxx = ryy = rzz = sxz = syz = 0). The six components of strain caused by sxy are measured, which allows the calculation of various material properties relating a shear stress component to the strain tensor. A detailed description of experimental methods used to impose a specified state of stress is beyond the scope of the present discussion. It should be mentioned, however, that some of the stress states discussed below are very difficult to achieve in practice. For example, because composites are usually produced in the form of thin platelike structures, it is very difficult to impose well-defined stresses acting normal to the plane of the composite, or to measure the strain components induced normal to the plane of the composite by a given state of stress. For present purposes, these very real practical difficulties will be ignored. It will simply be assumed that the stress tensors discussed have been induced in the test specimen, and that methods to measure the resulting strain components involved are available. A number of international and industrial organizations publish annual test standards that describe available experimental arrangements in detail. Some of the best known standards are those published by the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM). ASTM tests standards that describe techniques to measure composite material properties relevant to the present discussion are listed in Table 1. There are also many composite test methods used routinely in industrial, governmental, or university composite laboratories that have not as yet been standardized by organizations such as the ASTM. New test methods are being developed continuously, and the reader should be alert for new methods and test standards as they become available. 2.1 Uniaxial Tests Referring to Fig. 1, suppose a uniaxial test is conducted using specimen 1 (i.e., material properties are measured in the x-direction). As the test proceeds, stress rxx is increased from zero to some maximal level, and the components of strain induced as a result of this stress are measured. An idealized plot of strain data collected during a uniaxial test of an anisotropic material is shown in Fig. 4, where it is has been assumed that the magnitude of stress is relatively
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Table 1
ASTM Test Standards for Determining Elastic Moduli of Polymeric Composites and Related Standards Designation D3039 D5450 D695 D3410
D5467
D5449
D3518
D5379 D4255 D5448
Related standards D5687 D638 D882 D4018 D2343
Title Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials Standard Test Method for Transverse Tensile Properties of Hoop Wound Polymer Matrix Composite Cylinders Standard Test Method for Compressive Properties of Rigid Plastics Standard Test Method for Compressive Properties of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials with Unsupported Gage Section by Shear Loading Standard Test Method for Compressive Properties of Unidirectional Polymer Matrix Composites Using a Sandwich Beam Standard Test Method for Transverse Compressive Properties of Hoop Wound Polymer Matrix Composite Cylinders Standard Practice for In-Plane Shear Response of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials by Tensile Test of a +45j Laminate Standard Test Method for Shear Properties of Composite Materials by the V-Notched Beam Method Standard Guide for Testing In-Plane Shear Properties of Composite Laminates Standard Test Method for In-Plane Shear Properties of Hoop Wound Polymer Matrix Composite Cylinders
Standard Guide for Preparation of Flat Composite Panels with Processing Guidelines for Specimen Preparation Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Plastics Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Thin Plastic Sheeting Standard Test Methods for Properties of Continuous Filament Carbon and Graphite Fiber Tows Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Glass Fiber Strands, Yarns, and Rovings Used in Reinforced Plastics
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 4 Idealized plot of the six strain components caused by the application a uniaxial stress rxx.
low, such that a linear relationship exists between the stress component rxx and the resulting strains. Strains induced at high nonlinear stress levels, including failure stresses, will be considered in Sec. 5. Note that for an anisotropic material, stress rxx will induce all six components of strain: exx, eyy, ezz, cxy, cxz, and cyz. This is not the case for isotropic materials; a uniaxial stress rxx applied to an isotropic material will not induce any shear strains (cxy = cxz = cyz = 0); furthermore, the transverse normal strains will be identical (eyy = ezz). Hence, for anisotropic material, there is an unusual coupling between normal stress and shear strain, which would not be expected based on previous experience with isotropic materials. As would be expected, as the magnitude of rxx is increased, the magnitude of all resulting strain components is also increased. Because stress rxx causes six distinct components of strain for an anisotropic material, six material properties must be defined in order to relate rxx to the resulting strains. Let us first consider material properties relating normal stress rxx to normal strains exx, eyy, and ezz. The relationship between rxx and normal strain exx is characterized by Young’s modulus Exx (also called the ‘‘modulus of elasticity’’): rxx Exx u e xx
ð1Þ
Young’s modulus is simply the slope of the rxx vs. exx curve shown in Fig. 4. In words, Young’s modulus is defined as ‘‘the normal stress rxx divided
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
by the resulting normal strain exx, with all other stress components equal to zero.’’ Subscripts xx have been used to indicate the direction in which Young’s modulus has been measured. Because we have restricted our attention to the linear region of the stress–strain curve, Eq. (1) is only valid at relatively low, linear stress levels. The relationship between the two transverse strains (eyy and ezz) and exx is defined by Poisson’s ratio: eyy vxy u e xx
ezz vxz u e xx
ð2Þ
In words, Poisson’s ratio vxy (or vxz) is defined as ‘‘the negative of the transverse normal strain eyy (or ezz) divided by the axial normal strain exx, both of which are induced by stress rxx, with all other stresses equal to zero.’’ As before, subscripts have been used to indicate the uniaxial stress condition under which Poisson’s ratio is measured. The first subscript indicates the direction of stress, and the second subscript indicates the direction of transverse strain. For example, in the case of vxy, the first subscript x indicates that a uniaxial stress rxx has been applied, and the second subscript y indicates that transverse normal strain eyy has been used to calculate Poisson’s ratio. Combining Eqs. (1) and (2), a relationship between rxx and transverse strains eyy and ezz is obtained: eyy ¼
vxy rxx Exx
ezz ¼
vxz rxx Exx
ð3Þ
Now consider material properties relating normal strain exx to shear strains cxy, cxz, and cyz. Material properties relating normal strains to shear strains were discussed by Lekhnitski [2] and are called ‘‘coefficients of mutual influence of the second kind.’’ In this text, they will be denoted using the symbol g, and are defined as follows: cxy gxx;xy u e xx
c gxx;xz u e xz
xx
cyz gxx;yz u e
xx
ð4Þ
In words, the coefficient of mutual influence of the second kind gxx,xy (or gxx,xz, or gxx,yz) is defined as ‘‘the shear strain cxy (or cxz, or cyz) divided by the normal strain exx, both of which are induced by normal stress rxx, when all other stresses equal zero.’’ Subscripts have once again been used to indicate the stress condition under which the coefficient of mutual influence of the second kind is measured. The first set of subscripts indicates the direction of stress, and the second set of subscripts indicates the shear strain used to calculate the coefficient. For example, in the case of gxx,xy, the first two subscripts xx
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
indicate that a normal stress rxx has been applied, and the second two subscripts xy indicate that cxy has been used to calculate the coefficient. Combining Eqs. (1) and (4), a relationship between rxx and shear strain cxy, cxz, or cyz is obtained: gxx;xy cxy ¼ e rxx xx
gxx;xz cxz ¼ e rxx xx
gxx;yz cyz ¼ e rxx xx
ð5Þ
Equations (1)–(5) define six properties measured in the x-direction, using specimen 1. Referring again to Fig. 1, analogous results are obtained when properties are measured in the y- and z-directions, using specimens 2 and 3: Properties Measured Using Specimen 2 (syy Applied) ryy 1 ðorÞ eyy ¼ ryy Eyy u e yy Eyy vyx exx vyx u e ðorÞ exx ¼ ryy yy Eyy vyz ezz vyz u e ðorÞ ezz ¼ ryy yy Eyy cxy gyy;xy gyy;xy u e ðorÞ cxy ¼ e ryy yy yy gyy;xz cxz gyy;xz u e ðorÞ cxz ¼ e ryy yy yy cyz gyy;yz gyy;yz u e ðorÞ cyz ¼ e ryy yy yy
ð6Þ
Properties Measured Using Specimen 3 (szz Applied): rzz 1 ðorÞ ezz ¼ rzz Ezz u e zz Ezz exx vzx vzx u e ðorÞ exx ¼ rzz zz Ezz eyy vzy vzy u e ðorÞ eyy ¼ rzz zz Ezz cxy gzz;xy gzz;xy u e ðorÞ cxy ¼ e rzz zz zz gzz;xz cxz gzz;xz u e ðorÞ cxz ¼ e rzz zz zz cyz gzz;yz gzz;yz u e ðorÞ cyz ¼ e rzz zz zz
ð7Þ
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2.2 Pure Shear Tests If a pure shear stress (say, sxy) is applied to an anisotropic material, six components of strain will be induced. An idealized plot of strain data collected during a pure shear test of an anisotropic material is shown schematically in Fig. 5, where it is assumed that magnitude of shear stress is relatively low such that a linear relationship exists between the stress component sxy and the resulting strains. Strains induced at high nonlinear stress levels, including failure stresses, will be considered in Sec. 5. Once again, the stress–strain response of an anisotropic material differs markedly from that of an isotropic material. Specifically, for an anisotropic material, stress sxy will induce all six components of strain: exx, eyy, ezz, cxy, cxz, and cyz. If an isotropic material is subjected to a pure shear stress sxy, only one strain component is induced (cxy); all other strain components are zero (exx = eyy=ezz = cxz = cyz = 0). Hence, for anisotropic material, there is an unusual coupling between shear stress and normal strain, as well as an unusual coupling between shear stress in one plane (say, the x–y plane) and out-ofplane shear strains (cxz and cyz). Neither of these coupling effects occurs in isotropic materials. As would be expected, as the magnitude of sxy is increased during the test, the magnitude of the resulting strains is also increased. Because stress sxy causes six distinct components of strain, six material properties must be defined in order to relate sxy to the resulting strains.
Figure 5 Idealized plot of the six strain components caused by the application a pure shear stress sxy.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Let us first consider material properties relating shear stress sxy to shear strains cxy,cxz, and cyz. The relationship between sxy and shear strain cxy is characterized by the shear modulus Gxy: sxy Gxy u c ð8Þ xy In words, the shear modulus is defined as ‘‘the shear stress sxy divided by the resulting shear strain cxy, with all other stress components equal to zero.’’ Because we have restricted our attention to linear stress levels, Eq. (8) is only valid at relatively low, linear shear stress levels. The relationship between transverse strains (cxz, cyz) and cxy is characterized by Chentsov coefficients, which will be denoted using the symbol l in this text: cyz c lxy;yz u c ð9Þ lxy;xz u cxz xy xy In words, the Chentsov coefficient lxy,xz (or lxy,yz) is defined as ‘‘the shear strain cxz (or cyz) divided by the shear strain cxy, both of which are induced by shear stress sxy, with all other stresses equal to zero.’’ The first set of subscripts indicates the stress component, and the second set of subscripts indicates the out-of-plane shear strain used to calculate the Chentsov coefficient. For example, in the case of lxy,xz the subscripts xy indicate that a pure shear stress sxy has been applied, and the second two subscripts xz indicate that cxz has been used to calculate the coefficient. A comparison between Eqs. (2) and (9) reveals that Chentsov coefficients are directly analogous to Poisson’s ratio. Poisson’s ratio is defined as a ratio of normal strains caused by a normal stress, whereas Chentsov coefficients are defined as a ratio of shear strains caused by a shear stress. Combining Eqs. (8) and (9), a relationship between sxy and shear strain cxz or cyz is obtained: lxy;xz lxy;yz cxz ¼ sxy cyz ¼ sxy ð10Þ Gxy Gxy Finally, consider material properties relating shear stress sxy to normal strains exx, eyy, and ezz. Material properties relating shear stress to normal strains were discussed by Lekhnitski [2] and are called ‘‘coefficients of mutual influence of the first kind.’’ In this text, they will be denoted using the symbol g, and are defined as follows: exx gxy;xx u c xy
eyy gxy;yy u c xy
ezz gxy;zz u c xy
ð11Þ
In words, the coefficient of mutual influence of the first kind gxy,xx (or gxy,yy, or gxy,zz) is defined as ‘‘the normal strain exx (or eyy, or ezz) divided by
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the shear strain cxy, both of which are induced by shear stress sxy, when all other stresses equal zero.’’ The first set of subscripts indicates the stress component applied, and the second set indicates the normal strain used to calculate the coefficient. For example, in the case of gxy,xx, the first subscripts xy indicate that shear stress sxy has been applied, and the second set of subscripts xx indicates that exx has been used to calculate the coefficient. Combining Eqs. (8) and (11), a relationship between sxy and normal strain exx, eyy, or ezz is obtained: gxy;xx gxy;yy gxy;zz exx ¼ sxy eyy ¼ sxy ezz ¼ sxy ð12Þ Gxy Gxy Gxy Equations (8)–(12) define six properties measured when a pure shear stress sxy is applied. Analogous material properties are defined during tests in which pure shear sxz or syz is applied. Properties Measured Using Pure Shear t xz sxz Gxz u c xz cxy lxz;xy u c xz cyz lxz;yz u c xz exx gxz;xx u c xz eyy gxz;yy u c xz ezz gxz;zz u c xz
1 sxz Gxz lxz;xy cxy ¼ sxz Gxz lxz;yz cyz ¼ sxz Gxz gxz;xx exx ¼ sxz Gxz gxz;yy eyy ¼ sxz Gxz gxz;zz ezz ¼ sxz Gxz
ðorÞ cxz ¼ ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ
ð13Þ
Properties Measured Using Pure Shear t yz syz Gyz u c yz cxy lyz;xy u c yz cxz lyz;xz u c yz exx gyz;xx u c yz eyy gyz;yy u c yz ezz gyz;zz u c yz
ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ ðorÞ
1 syz Gyz lyz;xy cxy ¼ syz Gyz lyz;xz cxz ¼ syz Gyz gyz;xx exx ¼ syz Gyz gyz;yy eyy ¼ syz Gyz gyz;zz ezz ¼ syz Gyz cyz ¼
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð14Þ
2.3 Specialization to Orthotropic and Transversely Isotropic Composites As previously shown in Fig. 2a and b, for unidirectional composites, the principal material coordinate system is defined by the fiber direction. That is, the 1-axis is defined parallel to the fiber direction, the 2-axis is perpendicular to the fibers and lies within the plane of the composite, and the 3-axis is perpendicular to the fibers and lies out of plane. In other cases, such as the braided composite shown in Fig. 2c and d, the 1–2–3 principal material coordinate system is not aligned with the fiber direction, but is instead defined by planes of symmetry associated with the fiber architecture involved. For all composite fabrics based on continuous fibers and typically encountered in practice (i.e., unidirectional, woven, or braided fabrics), the principal material coordinate system is readily identified. We will now consider those properties that are measured when the composite is referenced to the principal material coordinate system. It will be seen later that properties of an anisotropic composite (i.e., a composite referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system) can always be related to those measured relative to the 1–2–3 coordinate system. To simplify our discussion, we will assume that the composite under consideration is a unidirectional composite, and hence that the 1–2–3 axes are parallel and perpendicular to the fibers. A stress element representing a unidirectional composite subjected to uniaxial tensile stress r11 is shown in Fig. 6. The deformed shape of the element is also shown. Note that:
The element has increased in length in the l-direction, corresponding to a tensile strain e11. The element has decreased in width in the 2- and 3-directions, corresponding to compressive strains e22 and e33, respectively. The deformed element is a rectangular parallelepiped. That is, due to the symmetrical distribution of fibers with respect to the 1-, 2-, and 3coordinate axes, in the deformed condition, all angles remained p/2 rad (90j). Hence, all shear strains equal zero (c12=c13=c23=0). Applying Eqs. (1), (2), and (4), we have: r11 E11 u e 11
ð15aÞ
e22 v12 u e 11
ð15bÞ
e33 v13 u e 11
ð15cÞ
g11;12 ¼ g11;13 ¼ g11;23 ¼ 0
ð15dÞ
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 6 Deformations induced in a unidirectional composite by uniaxial stress r11 (deformations are shown greatly exaggerated for clarity).
Because no shear strains are induced by r11, the coefficients of mutual influence of the second kind all equal zero. This is only true when the composite is referenced to the principal material coordinate system. That is, uniaxial stress acting in a nonprincipal coordinate system will cause a shear strain, as previously shown in Fig. 3, for example. Therefore, the coefficients of mutual influence of the second kind do not equal zero for anisotropic composites (i.e., if the composite is referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system). Methods of calculating composite material properties in nonprincipal coordinate systems will be presented in Chap. 4. Similarly, material properties measured when stress r22 is applied are: r22 E22 u e ð16aÞ 22 e11 v21 u e ð16bÞ 22 e33 e22 g22;12 ¼ g22;13 ¼ g22;23 ¼ 0 v23 u
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð16cÞ ð16dÞ
Once again, due to the symmetrical distribution of fibers, stress r22 does not induce any shear strains, so the coefficients of mutual influence of the second kind all equal zero. As previously mentioned, due to the thin platelike nature of composites, it is difficult in practice to apply a well-defined out-of-plane uniaxial stress r33, or to measure the resulting normal strain induced in the out-of-plane direction e33. Assuming that these practical difficulties are overcome, the material properties measured when stress r33 is applied are: r33 E33 u e ð17aÞ 33 e11 v31 u e ð17bÞ 33 e22 v32 u e ð17cÞ 33 ð17dÞ g33;12 ¼ g33;13 ¼ g33;23 ¼ 0 For unidirectional composites, both the 2- and 3-axes are defined to be perpendicular to the fibers, and hence properties measured in the 2- and 3directions are typically similar in magnitude. In fact, if the distribution of fibers in the 2- and 3-directions is identical at the microlevel, then properties measured in these directions will be equal: E22 = E33, v12 = v13, v21 = v31, and v23 = v32. If this occurs, then the composite is classified as a transversely isotropic material. In contrast, if the distribution of fibers differs in the 2- and 3-directions, or if the composite under consideration is a woven or braided composite, then properties measured in the 2- and 3-directions will not be identical and the composite is classified as an orthotropic material. Optical micrographs showing the fiber distribution in the 2–3 plane for a unidirectional graphite–polyimide laminate are shown in Fig. 7. Fig. 7a was taken at a magnification of 150, and shows the fiber distribution in four adjacent plies. The fiber angles are (from left to right) 0j, 45j, 90j, and 45j. Fig. 7b was obtained for the same laminate but at higher magnification (300), and shows fiber angles (from left to right) of 0j, 45j, and 90j. As indicated, for this laminate, thin resin-rich zone exists between plies. The thickness of the resin-rich zone varies from one laminate to the next, depending on the material system, stacking sequence, and processing conditions used to produce the laminate. If the resin-rich zone is very thin (say, less than about 1/10 the ply thickness) and if the fibers are uniformly distributed within the interior of each ply, the composite will respond as a transversely isotropic material. If these conditions do not exist (if the thickness of the resin-rich zone is an appreciable fraction of the ply thickness, or if the distribution of fibers in the 2- and 3-directions differs substantially), then E33 will differ from E22, and the composite will respond as an orthotropic material.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 7 Optical micrographs of fibers within several plies of a [0/45/90/ 45]2s graphite–polyimide (IM7/K3B) composite laminate. Note the resin-rich zone between plies.
Let us now consider properties measured through the application of a pure shear stress in the principal material coordinate system. A stress element representing a unidirectional composite subjected to a pure shear stress s12 is shown in Fig. 8. The deformed shape of the element is also shown. Note that:
The angle originally defined by the 1–2 axes has decreased, corresponding to a positive shear strain c12.
Figure 8 Deformations induced in a unidirectional composite by pure shear stress s12.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Due to the symmetrical distribution of fibers with respect to the 1-, 2-, and 3-coordinate axes, in the deformed condition, all remaining angles remained p/2 rad (90j). Hence, the remaining two shear strains equal zero (c13 = c23 = 0). The length, width, and thickness of the element have not changed; hence, all normal strain are zero (e11 = e22 = e33 = 0). Applying Eqs. (8)–(10), we have: G12 u
s12 c12
ð18aÞ
l12;13 ¼ l12;23 ¼ 0
ð18bÞ
g12;11 ¼ g12;22 ¼ g12;33 ¼ 0
ð18cÞ
Because only c12 is induced by s12, the Chentsov coefficients as well as the coefficients of mutual influence of the first kind are all equal to zero. This is only true when the composite is referenced to the principal material coordinate system. That is, a shear stress acting in a nonprincipal material coordinate system will, in general, cause both normal strains and shear strains. Therefore, neither the Chentsov coefficients nor the coefficients of mutual influence of the first kind equal zero if the composite is referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system. Methods of calculating composite material properties in nonprincipal coordinate systems will be presented in Chap. 4. Once again, due to the thin platelike nature of composites, in practice, it is difficult to apply well-defined out-of-plane shear stress s13 or s23, or to measure the resulting shear strains induced in the out-of-plane direction c13 or c23. Assuming that these practical difficulties were overcome, the material properties measured when stress s13 is applied are: s13 c13
ð19aÞ
l13;12 ¼ l13;23 ¼ 0
ð19bÞ
g13;11 ¼ g13;22 ¼ g13;33 ¼ 0
ð19cÞ
G13 u
If the fibers are not uniformly distributed within the 2–3 plane, or if the composite is based on woven or braided fabrics, then the composite will behave as an orthotropic material and G12 p G13. If the composite is based on a unidirectional fabric and fibers are uniformly distributed, then the composite is transversely isotropic and G12 = G13.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Following an analogous process, material properties measured when s23 is applied are: s23 G23 u ð20aÞ c23 l23;12 ¼ l23;23 ¼ 0
ð20bÞ
g23;11 ¼ g23;22 ¼ g23;33 ¼ 0
ð20cÞ
A total of 12 material properties have been defined above for orthotropic or transversely isotropic composites: three Young’s moduli (E11, E22, and E33), six Poisson’s ratios (v12, v13, v21, v23, v31, and v32), and three shear moduli ( G12, G13, and G23). However, it will be seen later that for orthotropic composites, only nine of these 12 properties are independent, and for transversely isotropic composites, only five of the 12 properties are independent. Therefore, only nine material properties must be measured to fully characterize the elastic response of orthotropic composites; for transversely isotropic composites, only five material properties must be measured. The number of material properties required in most practical engineering applications of composite is reduced further still. For reasons that will be explained later, it is usually appropriate to assume that a composite structure is subjected to a state of plane stress. Ultimately, this means that we only require material properties in one plane. Hence, whereas an orthotropic composite possesses nine distinct elastic material properties (and a transversely isotropic composite possesses five), in practice, only four of these properties are ordinarily required: E11, E22, v12, and G12. Most of the ASTM test standards listed in Table 1 describe techniques used to measure these properties. Also, a brief summary of common experimental methods used to measure in-plane properties is provided in Appendix B. Typical values for several composite material systems are listed in Table 3. As a final comment, an often overlooked fact is that the elastic properties of composites usually differ in tension and compression (in fact, this is true for many materials, not just for composites). For example, for polymeric composites, it is not uncommon for E22 measured in tension to differ by 10– 15% from that measured in compression. Materials that exhibit this behavior are called ‘‘bimodulus materials.’’ Although it is possible to account for these differences during a structural analysis (e.g., see Ref. 3), the bimodulus phenomenon is a significant complication and will not be accounted for herein. Throughout this text, it will be assumed that in-plane elastic properties E11, E22, v12, and G12 are identical in tension and compression. The reader should be aware that these differences usually exist, however. If in practice the measured response of a composite structure differs from the predicted
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
behavior, the discrepancy may well be due to differences in elastic properties in tension vs. compression. 3 MATERIAL PROPERTIES RELATING TEMPERATURE TO STRAIN If an unconstrained anisotropic composite is subjected to a uniform change T T in temperature DT, six components of strain will be induced: exx , eTyy , ezz , T T T cxy , cxz , and cyz. The superscript ‘‘T’’ has been used to indicate that these strains are caused solely by a change in temperature. Note that three of these strains are shear strains; for anisotropic materials, a change in temperature will, in general, cause shear strains to develop. Strains induced solely by a change in temperature are referred to as ‘‘free thermal strains’’ or simply ‘‘thermal strains.’’ Properties that relate strains to temperature change are called coefficients of thermal expansion (CTEs). As previously discussed, it is the microstructural features of a material that determine whether it exhibits isotropic or anisotropic behavior. The contention that a change in temperature will induce shear strains may seem unusual (because isotropic materials do not exhibit such behavior), but can be easily explained in the case of unidirectional composites. An initially square unidirectional composite is shown in Fig. 9, where it has been assumed that the fibers are oriented at an angle of 45j with respect to the x-axis. Because the composite is initially square and, in this example, the fibers are defined to be at an angle of 45j, fibers are parallel to diagonal AC and are perpendicular to diagonal BD. Now, the coefficient of thermal expansion exhibited by highperformance fibers is typically very low (or even slightly negative), whereas for
Figure 9 Deformations caused in a 45j unidirectional composite by a uniform change in temperature DT (deformations are shown greatly exaggerated for clarity).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
most polymers, it is relatively high. For example, the coefficient of thermal expansion of graphite fibers is about 1 Am/m jC, whereas for epoxies, it is on the order of 30 Am/m jC. Therefore, assuming that the composite shown in Fig. 9 consists of a graphite/epoxy system, then an increase in temperature will cause a slight decrease in the length of diagonal AC, but will cause a relatively large increase in the length of diagonal BD. Hence, the initially square composite deforms into a parallelogram, as shown in the figure. The fact that angle BDAB has increased reveals that a shear strain cxy (in this case, a negative shear strain cxy) has been induced by the change in temperature DT. Hence, there is a coupling between the change in temperature and shear strains, as stipulated. Note that this physical explanation of the coupling between a uniform change in temperature and shear strain indicates that this coupling only occurs if strain is referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system. An idealized plot of the six strain components induced in an anisotropic composite by a change in temperature is shown in Fig. 10. As would be
Figure 10 Idealized plot of the six strain components caused by a change in temperature DT.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
expected, as DT is increased, the magnitude of all strain components also increases. For modest changes in temperature (say, DT<200 jC), the change in temperature is linearly related to the resulting thermal strain components. That is, the slopes of the six strain vs. DT curves shown in Fig. 10 are constant at relatively low levels of DT. At high levels of DT, the slopes of the curves typically increase. For polymeric composites, the temperature at which the curves become nonlinear is related to the glass transition temperature Tg of the polymeric matrix (the glass transition temperature of a polymer is discussed in Sec. 2 of Chap. 1). Most composite structures are designed to operate at temperatures below the Tg; hence, we will focus our attention on the linear range shown in Fig. 10. Because a change in temperature causes six strains to develop for anisotropic composites, six coefficients of thermal expansion must be defined: eTxx DT cTxy axy u DT
axx u
ayy u
eTyy DT
cT axz u xz DT
eTzz DT cTyz ayz u DT azz u
ð21Þ
Because we have limited our discussion to the linear range shown in Fig. 10, the coefficients of thermal expansion defined by Eq. (21) equal the slopes of the corresponding strain vs. DT curves within the linear range. These properties will henceforth be called linear coefficients of thermal expansion. In SI units, they are usually reported in terms of Am/m jC or Arad/jC (for normal or shear strains, respectively). In English units, they are usually reported in terms of Ain./in. jF or Arad/jF. A CTE can be converted from SI units to English units by multiplying by the factor 5/9. For example, a CTE of 15 Am/m jC equals 8.3 Ain./in. jF. Equation (21) can be easily rearranged and written in matrix form as follows: 3 3 2 T 2 exx cTxy cTxz axx axy axz 7 7 6 6 7 7 6 T 6 6 cyx eTyy cTyz 7 ¼ ðDTÞ6 axy ayy ayz 7 ð22Þ 7 7 6 6 5 5 4 4 cTzx cTzy eTzz axz ayz azz The reader should note that the strains caused by a change in temperature can be transformed from one coordinate system to another, in exactly the same way that mechanically induced strains are transformed. In particular, any of the strain transformation equations reviewed in Chap. 2 (e.g., Eq. (36), Eq. (41), Eq. (43), Eq. (44), or Eq. (47)) can be used to transform thermally induced strains from one coordinate system to another.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
3.1 Specialization to Orthotropic and Transversely Isotropic Composites We will now apply these general definitions to the case of a unidirectional composite referenced to the principal material coordinate system. It will be seen later that CTEs of an anisotropic composite (i.e., a composite referenced to a nonprincipal material coordinate system) can always be related to those measured in the 1–2–3 coordinate system. Although unidirectional composites are used in the following discussion, a equivalent discussion applies to woven or braided composites, when referenced to the principal material coordinate system. A unidirectional composite subjected to a uniform change in temperature DT and referenced to the 1–2–3 coordinate system is shown in Fig. 11. Because the fibers are distributed symmetrically with respect to the 1 - , 2-, and 3-coordinate axes, a change in temperature does not cause a shear strain to develop. Hence, in the principal material coordinate system, Eq. (21) becomes: a11 ¼
eT11 DT
a22 ¼
eT22 DT
a33 ¼
eT33 DT
a12 ¼ a13 ¼ a23 ¼ 0
ð23Þ
As before, if the fibers are distributed uniformly throughout the 2–3 plane, then a22=a33 and the composite will be transversely isotropic. If the fibers are not uniformly distributed, then a22 p a33, and the composite will be orthotropic. Woven or braided composites are always orthotropic because
Figure 11 Deformations induced in a unidirectional composite by a change in temperature DT (deformations are shown greatly exaggerated for clarity).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the distribution of fibers in the 2-direction differs substantially from that in the 3-direction. Experimental methods of measuring thermal expansion coefficients for polymeric composites have not been standardized by organizations such as the ASTM. In practice, the in-plane thermal expansion coefficients exhibited by polymeric composites are most commonly determined through the use of resistance foil strain gages. Strain gage manufacturers often provide recommendations for measuring thermal expansion coefficients using strain gages (e.g., see Ref. 4). Typical CTEs for several common polymeric composites are included in Table 3. 4 MATERIAL PROPERTIES RELATING MOISTURE CONTENT TO STRAIN It is possible for water molecules to diffuse into (or out of ) the overall molecular structure of polymeric materials. In other words, the moisture content of polymeric-based materials, including composites, slowly varies as the relative humidity of the surrounding atmosphere varies. The moisture content of a polymer is usually expressed as a percentage by weight, and typically ranges from f0% to as high as f5%. From a structural point of view, the effects of a change in moisture content are analogous to those caused by a change in temperature. For example, a plot of strains as a function of moisture content would resemble Fig. 10, except that DM would be plotted along the horizontal axis rather than DT. Hence, if an unconstrained anisotropic composite is subjected to a uniform change in moisture content DM, then six components of strain will M M M M M M be induced: exx , eyy , ezz , cxy , cxz , and cyz . The superscript ‘‘M’’ has been used to indicate that these strains are caused solely by a change in moisture content. Strains induced by a change in moisture content are sometimes referred to as hygroscopic strains, and can be just as large as or larger than those associated with a change in temperature. In this text, it will be assumed that strain is linearly related to changes in moisture content. Properties that relate strains to changes in moisture content will be called linear coefficients of moisture expansion, abbreviated as ‘‘CMEs,’’ and will be denoted using the symbol b. Because a change in moisture content causes six strains to develop for anisotropic composites, six CMEs must be defined: bxx u bxy u
eM xx DM cM xy DM
byy u
eM yy DM
cM bxz u xz DM
bzz u byz u
eM zz DM cM yz DM
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð24Þ
The units of the CMEs are typically Am/m/%M or Arad/%M. Equation (24) can be easily rearranged and written in matrix form as follows: 2
eM xx
6 6 M 6 cyx 6 4 cM zx
cM xy
cM xz
eM yy
cM yz
cM zy
3
2
bxx
7 6 7 6 7 ¼ ðDMÞ6 bxy 7 6 5 4 M bxz ezz
bxy byy byz
bxz
3
7 7 byz 7 7 5 bzz
ð25Þ
A comparison between Eqs. (24) and (21), or between Eqs. (25) and (23) will reinforce the fact that strains induced by a change in moisture content are analogous (in a mathematical sense) to those caused by a change in temperature. 4.1 Specialization to Orthotropic and Transversely Isotropic Composites In the principal material coordinate system, there is no coupling between a change in moisture content and shear strains. Hence, in the principal material coordinate system, Eq. (24) becomes: b11 u
eM 11 DM
b22 u
eM 22 DM
b33 u
eM 33 DM
ð26Þ
b12 ¼ b13 ¼ b23 ¼ 0 If the composite is based on a unidirectional fabric and fibers are distributed uniformly throughout the 2–3 plane, then b22 = b33 and the composite will be transversely isotropic. If the fibers are not uniformly distributed, or if the composite is based on woven or braided fabrics, then b22 p b33 and the composite will be orthotropic. Recommended experimental methods of measuring linear coefficients of moisture expansion are described in the ASTM standard D5229 [5]. Typical CMEs for several common polymeric composites are included in Table 3.
5 MATERIAL PROPERTIES RELATING STRESS (OR STRAIN) TO FAILURE Material properties that relate stress or strain to failure are measured during either a uniaxial test or a pure shear test. These properties are referred to collectively as material strengths. Before we begin our discussion of material strengths for composite materials, let us briefly review the definitions of
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
material strengths customarily used by engineers to report the failure response of conventional structural materials such as metals or metal alloys. Three idealized plots of the axial strain exx measured during a uniaxial test are shown in Fig. 12a–c. These figures are similar to Fig. 4, except that now: (a) only one of the strain components caused by rxx has been plotted (specifically, only exx has been plotted), and (b) data have been included at high nonlinear stress levels, up to and including the stress level at which the specimen fractures into two (or more) pieces. Materials that exhibit a stress– strain response similar to Fig. 12a are called brittle materials. As indicated, for a brittle material, the stress–strain curve is nearly linear at all stress levels, up to and including the final fracture stress. In fact, a perfectly brittle material exhibits no nonlinear behavior at all; stress is linearly related to strain at all levels, up to final fracture. In contrast, Fig. 12b and c shows the stress–strain behavior for ductile materials. The characteristic feature that distinguishes the two material types is that a ductile material exhibits a far larger region of nonlinear behavior prior to failure than does a brittle material. A second distinction is that the maximum strain a ductile material can withstand prior
Figure 12 Idealized plots of the axial strain qxx caused by application of a tensile uniaxial stress jxx. (a) Stress-strain plot for a brittle material. (b) Stress-strain plot for a modestly ductile material. (c) Stress-strain plot for a highly ductile material.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 12 Continued.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
to final fracture is (in general) far higher than that of a brittle material. The toughness of a material is defined as the area under the entire stress–strain curve. Hence, brittle materials typically possess a low toughness when compared with ductile materials. Four common measures of material strengths (illustrated in Fig. 12c) in terms of stress are the proportional limit rp the percent offset yield strength ry, the ultimate strength ru, and the fracture strength rf. Although the axial strain that corresponds to each of these stress levels can also be defined as a measure of strength, typically only the percent offset yield strain ey and the fracture strain ef are customarily used in this fashion. Many materials exhibit distinctly different strengths in tension vs. compression. Hence, in this text, a superscript ‘‘T’’ or ‘‘C’’ will be used to indicate whether a given strength has been measured in tension or compression, respectively. For example, because Fig. 12 represents stress–strain curves measured in tension, the superscript associated with all measures of strength that appear in these figures includes the character ‘‘T.’’ The proportional limit rxxpT is defined as the maximum stress level at which stress is linearly related to strain. However, for many materials, the deviation from linearity is so gradual that it is difficult to precisely identify the proportional limit based on experimental measurements. In these cases, the stress level at which significant nonlinear behavior begins is defined based on the ‘‘offset method.’’ A line parallel to the initial (linear) region of the stress–stain curve is drawn on the stress–strain curve, but is offset along the strain axis by some standard amount. The stress level at which this offset line intersects the experimental stress–strain curve is defined as the percent offset yield strength ryT xx . A strain offset of either 0.001 or 0.002 m/m (0.1% or 0.2% strain, respectively) is most commonly used, and hence yield strengths measured in this manner are reported as the 0.1% offset yield strength or the 0.2% offset yield strength, respectively. The ultimate strength ruT xx is defined as the maximum stress the material can withstand. The fracture stress rfT xx is defined as the stress that exists at final fracture. Note from Fig. 12 that a given material may not exhibit all four types of material strength. For example, for modestly ductile materials (Fig. 12b), fracture usually occurs at the maximum stress level, and hence for this type of material, there is no distinction between the ultimate strength and the fracture strength. For brittle materials (Fig. 12a), there may be little or no nonlinear behavior prior to fracture, and hence a yield strength is not defined and only the fracture strength (or ultimate strength) would be reported. All of the above definitions may be applied to the data collected during a pure shear test as well. An idealized plot of the shear strain cxy measured during a pure shear test of a modestly ductile material is shown in Fig. 13. This figure is similar to Fig. 5, except that now: (a) only one of the strain
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 13 Idealized plot of the shear strain cxy caused by application of pure fP fP shear stress sxy, including the shear fracture stress and strains sxy and cxy , and yP yP the shear yield stress and strain sxy and cxy .
components (cxy) caused by sxy has been plotted, and (b) data have been included at high nonlinear stress levels, including the shear stress level at which the specimen fractures into two (or more) pieces. Because anisotropic materials may exhibit different strengths in different directions, strength must be measured in three orthogonal directions; the x-, y-, and z-directions. It is possible for anisotropic materials, including many composites, to exhibit brittle behavior in one direction (say, the x-direction) but ductile behavior in other directions (the y-direction and/or z-direction). 5.1 Specialization to Unidirectional Composites Strengths measured for composites are referenced to the principal material 1– 2–3 coordinate system. In the case of unidirectional composites, strengths are measured parallel to the fibers (i.e., parallel to the 1-axis) and transverse to the fibers (parallel to the 2- and 3-axes). As would be anticipated, the strength of a composite in the 1-direction is determined primarily by the strength of the
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
fibers, whereas strengths in the 2- and 3-directions are determined primarily by the strength of the matrix. Most fibers used in polymeric composites, such as graphite or glass fibers, are nearly perfectly brittle materials. Therefore, most unidirectional polymeric composites exhibit a brittle failure response in the 1-direction. Prior to about 1980, most commercially available polymeric composites were based on relatively brittle thermoset matrices such as epoxies. Consequently, composite material systems available prior to about 1980 exhibited a brittle response in the 2- and 3-directions as well, and exhibited a low overall toughness. Substantial research efforts to develop tougher composite material systems were conducted throughout the 1970s and 1980s, and new-generation composite material systems with substantially increased toughness are now commercially available. This increase in toughness was accomplished primarily by replacing the brittle polymeric matrices with tougher (i.e., more ductile) polymers or polymer blends. Two approaches were used. In the first approach, the toughness of inherently brittle thermosets (such as epoxies) was increased through the addition of a second ductile rubber phase. This resulted in a class of toughened matrices called ‘‘rubber-toughened’’ epoxies. The second approach was to replace the inherently brittle thermoset matrix with a more ductile thermoplastic polymer.* Examples of this latter approach include the use polyketone, polyamide, or polyimide polymers as matrix materials. From a purely structural standpoint, the net result of these developments is that most new composite material systems exhibit a ‘‘modestly ductile’’ response to failure in the 2- and 3-directions, qualitatively similar to Fig. 12b. Consequently, new-generation composites exhibit a much-improved toughness relative to older systems. Methods to characterize the strengths of composite for purposes of structural design have not been widely standardized within the composites industry. Therefore, in this text, composite strengths will be described using terminology similar to that traditionally used with metals and metal alloys. A r11 vs. e11 curve measured for most unidirectional polymeric composites resembles Fig. 12a. That is, in the fiber direction, unidirectional composites exhibit nearly perfectly brittle behavior, although very modest nonlinear behavior may begin to occur at stress levels approaching final fracture. Due to the limited nonlinear response, it is not appropriate to define a yield stress in the 1-direction. Throughout this text, it will be assumed that a uniaxial stress in the fiber direction r11 causes failure due to fracture. That is, at failure, the
* The difference between a thermoset and a thermoplastic polymer is discussed in Sec. 2.4 of Chap. 1.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
specimen breaks into two or more pieces. The stress that causes fracture is fT fC or r11 , depending on whether r11 is tensile or compressive, denoted r11 fT fC respectively. Similarly, the strain at failure is denoted e11 or e22 . Because very little nonlinear behavior occurs prior to failure, it is possible to relate the fracture stress and strain using Young’s modulus. That is, for most composites, the measured fracture stress and measured fracture strain in the 1direction may be related (to within engineering accuracies) using Young’s modulus: fT rfT 11 i ðE11 Þðe11 Þ
fC rfC 11 i ðE11 Þðe11 Þ
On the other hand, for most modern unidirectional polymeric composites, both the r22 vs. e22 and the r33 vs. e33 curves resemble Fig. 12b. That is, the response measured in the 2- and 3-directions is usually ‘‘modestly ductile.’’ In this case then, ‘‘failure’’ may be defined either on the basis of a tensile yield stress/strain (i.e., on the basis of yielding), or a tensile fracture stress/strain (i.e., on the basis of fracture). In this text, the stress and strain values present at the onset of yielding yT yT yT yC yC yC yC will be denoted (ryT 22 ; e22 ; r33 ; e33 Þ or ðr22 ; e22 ; r33 ; e33 Þ; where the superscript ‘‘T’’ or ‘‘C’’ has once again been used to indicate whether the yield stress/ strain is measured in tension or compression, respectively. Note that it is possible to relate the tensile yield stress and strain (to within engineering accuracy) using Young’s modulus: yT ryT 22 i ðE22 Þðe22 Þ
yC ryC 22 i ðE22 Þðe22 Þ
yT ryT 33 i ðE33 Þðe33 Þ
yC ryC 33 i ðE33 Þðe33 Þ
fT fT , e22 , The stress and strain values present at fracture are denoted (r22 fT fC fC fC fC e33 ) or ðr22 ; e22 ; r33 ; e33 Þ: Because most modern composites exhibit a modestly ductile response in the 2- and 3-directions, the fracture stress is less than the value that would be calculated using a failure strain and Young’s modulus: fT , r33
fT rfT 22 < ðE22 Þðe22 Þ
fC rfC 22 < ðE22 Þðe22 Þ
fT rfT 33 < ðE33 Þðe33 Þ
fC rfC 33 < ðE33 Þðe33 Þ
Shear stress–strain curves (i.e., a plot of s12 vs. c12, s13 vs. c13, or s23 vs. c23) for unidirectional composites typically exhibit a shape somewhere between Fig. 12b and c. That is, the shear response is usually more ductile than that measured for normal stress in the 2-direction, and in some cases may be considered to be ‘‘highly ductile.’’ In the principal material coordinate
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
system (e.g., in the 1–2 coordinate system), the shear response is insensitive to the algebraic sign of the shear stress. That is, in the 1–2 coordinate system, an identical s12 vs. c12 curve will be measured regardless of whether s12 is positive or negative.* As before, a ‘‘shear failure’’ may be defined on the basis of a yield shear stress/strain or a shear fracture stress/strain, depending on application. In this text, the shear stress and strain at yielding will be denoted y y y y y y s12 and c12 (or s13 and c13 , or s23 and c23 ), whereas the shear stress and strain at f f f f f f and c13 , or s23 and c23 ). As before, fracture will be denoted s12 and c12 (or s13 the yield shear stress/strain may be related using the shear modulus, but the shear fracture stress/strain may not: sy12 iðG12 Þðcy12 Þ
sy13 iðG13 Þðcy13 Þ
sy23 iðG23 Þðcy23 Þ
sf12 < ðG12 Þðcf12 Þ
sf13 < ðG13 Þðcf13 Þ
sf23 < ðG23 Þðcf23 Þ
The preceding discussion is for orthotropic composites. Following the discussion presented in Sec. 2, if the composite is transversely isotropic, then the following strengths are related as indicated: yT ryT 22 ¼ r33
yC ryC 22 ¼ r33
fT rfT 22 ¼ r33
fC rfC 22 ¼ r33
sy12 ¼ sy13
sf12 ¼ sf13
Recommended methods of measuring in-plane composite strengths are included in most of the ASTM test standards previously listed in Table 1. Additional ASTM testing standards related specifically to failure of polymeric composites are listed in Table 2. Due to the thin platelike nature of composites, it is difficult to apply well-defined out-of-plane stresses, or to measure the resulting out-of-plane strains. Hence, in practice, the yield and fracture stresses associated with the out-of-plane 3-direction are measured infrequently. Typical yield and fracture strengths measured in the 1–2 plane for three common polymeric composites at room temperatures are included in Table 3. These properties do not represent the properties of any specific commercial composite material system, but rather should be viewed as typical values. In fact, due to ongoing research and development activities, the failure
* However, in a general nonprincipal material coordinate system, the shear strength is sensitive to the algebraic sign of the shear stress. This important point will be further discussed in Secs. 5 and 6 of Chap. 5.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Table 2
ASTM Test Standards Related to Failure of Polymeric Composites (see also Table 1) Designation D3479 D5766 D2344 D5528
E1922 D2290
Title Standard Test Method for Tension–Tension Fatigue of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials Standard Test Method for Open Hole Tensile Strength of Polymer Matrix Composite Laminates Standard Test Method for Apparent Interlaminar Shear Strength of Parallel Fiber Composites by Short-Beam Method Standard Test Method for Mode I Interlaminar Fracture Toughness of Unidirectional Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Matrix Composites Standard Test Method for Translaminar Fracture Toughness of Laminated Polymer Matrix Composite Materials Standard Test Method for Apparent Tensile Strength of Ring or Tubular Plastics and Reinforced Plastics by Split Disk Method
strengths of composites are improved more or less continuously. Therefore, the properties shown in Table 3 may not reflect those of currently available materials. Note that the failure strengths listed in Table 3 represent values measured at room temperatures. This will become an important factor in later chapters. In particular, in Chap. 7, we will consider methods of predicting failure of general composite laminates with multiple fiber angles. As will be seen, failure predictions for a multiangle composite laminate depend (in part) on the difference between the temperature at which the laminate is consolidated (this temperature is called the ‘‘cure temperature’’ throughout this text) and the ‘‘service temperature’’ at which the failure prediction is desired. For example, if a composite laminate is cured at a temperature of 175jC and then cooled to room temperature (20jC), the laminate has experienced a temperature change of 155jC during cooldown. Failure predictions for the laminate are then based on the temperature difference of 155jC, and on failure strengths measured at room temperature. If, instead, a composite is cured at 175jC and then cooled to some other service temperature, say, 100jC, then the laminate has experienced a temperature change of 75jC and failure predictions for the laminate are based on failure strengths measured at 100jC. It is pertinent to point out that the matrix-dominated tensile strengths exhibited by polymeric composites are often lower than the failure strength of the polymeric matrix alone. For example, the tensile strength of a
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Table 3 Property E11 E22 v12 G12 fT r11 fC r11 yT r22 yC r22 fT r22 fC r22 y s12 f s12 a11 a22 b11 b22
Nominal Material Properties for Common Unidirectional Composites Glass/epoxy
Kevlar/epoxy
Graphite/epoxy
55 GPa (8.0 Msi) 16 GPa (2.3 Msi) 0.28 7.6 GPa (1.1 Msi) 1050 MPa (150 ksi) 690 MPa (100 ksi) 45 MPa (5.8 ksi) 120 MPa (16 ksi) 55 MPa (7.0 ksi) 140 MPa (20 ksi) 40 MPa (4.4 ksi) 70 MPa (10 ksi) 6.7 Am/m jC (3.7 Ain./in. jF) 25 Am/m jC (14 Ain./in. jF) 100 Am/m %M (100 Ain./in. %M) 1200 Am/m %M (1200 Ain./in. %M)
100 GPa (15 Msi) 6 GPa (0.90 Msi) 0.33 2.1 GPa (0.30 Msi) 1380 MPa (200 ksi) 280 MPa (40 ksi) 35 MPa (2.9 ksi) 105 MPa (15 ksi) 45 MPa (4.3 ksi) 140 Msi (20 ksi) 40 MPa (4.0 ksi) 60 MPa (9 ksi) 3.6 Am/m jC (2.0 Ain./in. jF) 58 Am/m jC (32 Ain./in. jF) 175 Am/m %M (175 Ain./in. %M) 1700 Am/m %M (1700 Ain./in. %M)
170 GPa (25 Msi) 10 GPa (1.5 Msi) 0.30 13 GPa (1.9 Msi) 1500 MPa (218 ksi) 1200 MPa (175 ksi) 50 MPa (7.25 ksi) 100 MPa (14.5 ksi) 70 MPa (10 ksi) 130 MPa (18.8 ksi) 75 MPa (10.9 ksi) 130 MPa (22 ksi) 0.9 Am/m jC (0.5 Ain./in. jF) 27 Am/m jC (15 Ain./in. jF) 50 Am/m %M (50 Ain./in. %M) 1200 Am/m %M (1200 Ain./in. %M)
nonreinforced bulk epoxy is commonly about 70 MPa (10 ksi), whereas from Table 3, we see that graphite–epoxy typically possesses a matrix-dominated tensile strength on the order of 50 MPa (7.25 ksi). Even more pronounced is the reduction in tensile strain at fracture: for a nonreinforced bulk epoxy, the tensile strain at fracture commonly ranges from about 1% to 5% (10,000– 50,000 Am/m), whereas for graphite–epoxy, the matrix-dominated tensile fT strain at fracture (e22 ) rarely exceeds about 0.7% (7000 Am/m). The relatively low matrix-dominated strengths exhibited by polymeric composites can be explained on the basis of micromechanics analyses [6–9]. Briefly, two factors lead to low matrix-dominated tensile strengths. The first is thermal stresses induced at the microlevel during cooldown from cure temperatures. Recall that the thermal expansion coefficient of most high-performance fibers is very low and, in fact, is often slightly negative. For example, thermal expansion coefficients of glass, Kevlar, and graphite fibers are about 5, 2, and 0.5 Am/m jC, respectively (see Sec. 3 of Chap. 1). In contrast, the thermal expansion coefficient of polymers is quite high and usually exceeds 30 Am/m jC. Consequently, during cooldown from cure temperatures, the matrix is restrained from thermal contraction by the fibers, leading to self-equilibrating
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
tensile stresses in the matrix and compressive stresses in the fibers. The second factor is the stress-concentrating effect of the fibers. Because most advanced composites are produced with a fiber volume fraction of about 0.65, the tensile stresses induced within the matrix surrounding a fiber are not dictated strictly by the CTE mismatch between matrix and fiber but are also influenced by the presence neighboring fibers. Together, these two factors give rise to thermal stresses at the microlevel that are generally tensile in the matrix and compressive in the fibers. The magnitude of the thermal stresses induced in the fiber is very low relative to the fiber strength. However, the magnitude of the tensile stresses induced in the matrix represents a substantial fraction of the tensile strength of the matrix alone. Numerical micromechanics analyses based on the finite element method have shown that thermal matrix stresses can often be 50–60% of the bulk matrix tensile strength [11–14]. Hence, these thermal stresses are responsible for the low matrix-dominated tensile strengths and tensile strain at fractures exhibited by composites. They also explain in a qualitative sense why the magnitudes of matrix-dominated compressive strengths are invariably higher than matrixyC yT fC fT dominated tensile strengths (i.e., r22 >r22 and r22 >r22 ).
6 PREDICTING ELASTIC COMPOSITE PROPERTIES BASED ON CONSTITUENTS: THE RULE OF MIXTURES Various material properties exhibited by composites at the structural level have been described in preceding sections. These properties are usually measured for a composite material of interest, using one or more of the ASTM (or equivalent) test standards listed in Tables 1 and 2. However, in practice, the need to predict composite material properties exhibited at the structural level also arises. That is, in practice, there is a need to predict composite properties at the structural level based on properties of the individual constituent materials (i.e., the fiber and matrix). As a typical example, suppose a new high-performance graphite fiber has recently been developed, and properties of the fiber itself have been measured. Naturally, the structural engineer is interested in determining whether this new fiber will lead to improvements in composite material properties at the structural level. The potential improvement in properties can, of course, be evaluated directly, by embedding the new fiber in a polymeric matrix of interest and by measuring the properties exhibited by the new composite material system. However, creating and testing the new material system in this fashion is timeconsuming and expensive. A need to estimate the properties that will be provided by the new fiber exists, so as to justify the time and money that will
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
be invested during the development of the composite material system based on the new graphite fiber. As described in Sec. 6 of Chap. 1, an analysis performed at a physical scale corresponding to the fiber diameter is classified as a micromechanics analysis. In the present instance, we wish to use a micromechanics-based analysis to predict composite properties at the structural level. A simple micromechanics model that can be used to make this prediction is called the rule of mixtures and is developed as follows. Consider the representative composite element shown in Fig. 14. As indicated, the element consists of unidirectional fibers embedded within a polymeric matrix. The principal material coordinate system, labeled the 1– 2–3 coordinate system, is defined by the fiber direction. It is assumed that the fibers are evenly spaced, and that the matrix is perfectly bonded to the fiber. If a force F11 is applied to the element, as shown in Fig. 14a, the length of the element is increased by an amount DL and the width of the element is decreased by an amount DW. Force F11 is related to the average stress imposed in the 1-direction by F11=r11A, where A is the cross-sectional area of the element. Furthermore, the sum of forces present in the matrix and fibers must equal the total applied force, which implies: r11 A ¼ rf Af þ rm Am
ð27Þ
where Af is the total cross-sectional area of the fibers presented within the element and Am is the cross-sectional area of the matrix. The strain in the 1direction is associated with the change in length (DL), and is identical in fiber and matrix because the fiber and matrix are assumed to be perfectly bonded. That is: DL ef ¼ em ¼ e11 ¼ L Stresses are assumed to be related to strains according to: r11 ¼ e11 E11
ð28aÞ
rf ¼ ef Ef ¼ e11 Ef
ð28bÞ
rm ¼ em Em ¼ e11 Em
ð28cÞ
The expressions for stresses rf and rm are only approximate. In reality, a triaxial state of stress is induced rather than a uniaxial stress state, as implied by Eqs. (28b) and (28c), due to the mismatch in fiber and matrix properties as well as the presence of adjacent fibers. Properly accounting for this (and other) complicating factors requires a rigorous analysis that is beyond the scope of the brief introduction presented here. Therefore, we will assume that
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 14 Representative composite element used to derive rule-of-mixtures equations. (a) Composite element deformed by a load F11, acting parallel to the fiber direction. (b) Composite element deformed by a load F22, acting perpendicular to the fiber direction. (c) Composite element deformed by shear load F12.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
fiber and matrix stresses are given by Eqs. (28b) and (28c) despite their shortcomings. Substituting these expressions into Eq. (27) and rearranging, we find: E11 ¼ Ef
Af Am þ Em A A
This expression allows us to predict E11 based on properties of the constituents (Ef and Em) and the area fractions of fiber and matrix (Af/A) and (Am/A). If no voids are present, then: A ¼ Af þ Am Usually, rule-of-mixtures expressions are written in terms of volume fractions rather than area fractions. Volume fractions are given by: Vf ¼
Af A
Vm ¼
Am A Af ¼ ¼ ð1 Vf Þ A A
where Vf is the volume fraction of fibers and Vm = (1Vf) is the volume fraction of matrix material. Consequently, the predicted value of E11 based on the rule of mixtures approach is given by: E11 ¼ Em þ Vf ðEf Em Þ
ð29Þ
Polymeric composites used in practice are typically produced with a fiber volume fraction Vf of about 0.65, although it can be lower (say, Vf = 0.30), depending on application and the manufacturing process used to consolidate the composite. Equation (29) shows that if Ef Em (which is usually the case), then to a first approximation, E11cVfEf. The value of E11 is dictated primarily by the fiber modulus Ef and fiber volume fraction Vf. E11 is therefore called a fiber-dominated property of the composite. Now consider the Poisson effect exhibited by the composite element shown in Fig. 14a. As per our normal definition, the average Poisson ratio is defined as the negative of the transverse normal strain (e22) divided by axial normal strain (e11), both of which are caused by r11: v12 ¼
e22 e11
The transverse normal strain associated with the change in width of the entire element (DW) is given by: e22 ¼
DW W
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The change in width can also be written as the sum of the change in width of the fibers present in the element DWf and the change in width of the matrix present DWm. These are approximated as follows: DWf ¼ WVf vf ef ¼ WVf vf e11 DWm ¼ WVm vm em ¼ WVm vm e11 where vf and vm are Poisson ratios of the fiber and matrix, respectively. Hence, the transverse strain is given by: e22 ¼
DW ¼ ½Vf vf þ ðVm Þvm e11 W
Applying the definition of Poisson’s ratio for the composite as a whole, we have: v12 ¼
e22 ¼ V f vf þ V m vm e11
Noting as before that Vm=(1Vf), the predicted value for Poisson’s ratio v12 based on the rule of mixtures becomes: v12 ¼ vm Vf ðvm vf Þ
ð30Þ
Measurement of Poisson’s ratio of the matrix material vm is a straightforward matter. However, measuring Poisson’s ratio of the fiber vf is more difficult due to the small fiber diameters involved. Experimentally measured values of vf are often unavailable, even for fibers widely used in practice. The data that are available imply that both vm and vf are algebraically positive, and also that vm>vf. Hence, Eq. (30) implies that the composite Poisson ratio v12 varies linearly with fiber volume fraction Vf, and that Poisson’s ratio of the composite is less than that of the matrix (v120. Assuming an identical fiber distribution in the 1–2 and 1–3 planes, then an identical analysis can be conducted to predict Poisson’s ratio v13, which will result in an identical expression: v13=v12. Next, consider prediction of the transverse modulus E22 based on the rule-of-mixtures approach. A composite element subjected to a force applied perpendicular to the fibers, force F22, is shown in Fig. 14b. This force is related to the average stress imposed in the 2-direction by F22 = r22A. We assume that an identical and uniform stress r22 is induced in both the fiber and matrix. Once again, this assumption is approximate at best; in reality, a triaxial state
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
of stress is induced in both the fiber and matrix. Based on this assumption, the strains induced in the fiber and matrix perpendicular to the 1-axis are: r22 Ef r22 em ¼ Em
ef ¼
The transverse length represented by the fibers present in the element equals VfW, whereas the transverse length represented by the matrix equals VmW. Hence, the change in width W caused by the application of r22 is: DW ¼ ðVf WÞ
r22 r22 þ ðVm WÞ Ef Em
The average transverse strain caused by r22 is:
DW Vf Vm ¼ r22 e22 ¼ þ Ef Em W Young’s modulus E22 as predicted by the rule of mixtures therefore becomes: E22 ¼
r22 1 Ef Em ¼ ¼ Vf Vm e22 E V m f þ Ef Vm Ef þ Em
As before, if no voids are present, then Vm=(1Vf), and we obtain: E22 ¼
Ef Em Ef Vf ðEf Em Þ
ð31Þ
For most polymeric composite material systems, Ef> >Em. Nevertheless, Eq. (31) shows that E22 is dictated primarily by Em, and is only modestly affected by the fiber modulus Ef. Indeed, even in the limit (i.e., as Ef !l), the predicted value of E22 is only increased to: Em E22 Ef !l ¼ 1 Vf Because Vf is usually about 0.65, this result shows that E22 is still less than three times the matrix modulus Em, even if the composite is produced using a fiber whose stiffness is infinitely high (Ef !l). E22 is therefore called a matrix-dominated property of the composite. Assuming an identical fiber distribution in the 1–2 and 1–3 planes, then an identical analysis can be conducted to predict Young’s modulus in the 3-direction E33, resulting in an identical expression. Hence, E33=E22.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
As before, E33 is dictated primarily by Em and is a matrix-dominated property. Now consider the shear modulus G12. An element subjected to a pure shear force F12 is shown in Fig. 14c. This force is related to the average shear stress according to F12=s12A. In a rule-of-mixture analysis, it is assumed that an identical shear stress is induced in both the fibers and matrix regions. This assumption is approximate at best. Nevertheless, on the basis of this assumption, the shear strains induced in fiber and matrix are given by: s12 cf ¼ Gf s12 cm ¼ Gm where Gf and Gm are the shear moduli of the fiber and matrix, respectively. The total shear strain is given by: s12 s12 c12 ¼ Vf cf þ Vm cm ¼ Vf þ Vm Gf Gm The shear modulus predicted by the rule of mixtures is then: G12 ¼
s12 1 Gf Gm ¼ ¼ V V c12 Gm Vf þ Gf Vm f m Gf þ Gm
Assuming no voids are present, then Vm=(1Vf), and we obtain: G12 ¼
Gf Gm Gf Vf ðGf Vm Þ
ð32Þ
Comparing Eq. (32) with Eq. (31), it is seen that the shear modulus is related to fiber and matrix properties in a manner similar to E22 and E33. The value of G12 is dictated primarily by the shear modulus of the matrix Gm, and is considered a matrix-dominated property. Assuming an identical fiber distribution in the 1–2 and 1–3 planes, then G13=G12. To summarize, the analysis presented above allows prediction of elastic moduli E11, v12=v13, E22=E33, and G12=G13, based on knowledge of the fiber modulus Ef, matrix modulus Em, and fiber volume fraction Vf. Although not presented here, a rule-of-mixture approach can also be used to predict thermal expansion coefficients a1 and a2, or moisture expansion coefficients b1 and b2 (e.g., see Chap. 3 of Ref. 11). The analysis presented above is only one of several micromechanicsbased models that have been proposed. The rule of mixtures is certainly the simplest approach, but unfortunately is often the least accurate. In general,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
E11 and v12=v13 are reasonably well predicted by Eqs. (29) and (30), respectively. However, matrix-dominated properties E22=E33 and G12=G13 are generally underpredicted by Eqs. (31) and (32). The accuracy of these predictions is not high because many important factors have not been accounted for. A partial listing of factors not accounted for include:
The more or less random distribution and spacing of fibers present in a real composite The triaxial state of stress induced in both matrix and fiber due to the mismatch in fiber/matrix properties. Differences in fiber distribution in the 1–2 and 1–3 planes The adhesion (or lack thereof ) between fiber and matrix Variations in fiber cross-sections from one fiber to the next The presence of voids or other defects The anisotropic nature of many high-performance fibers (e.g., Young’s modulus parallel and transverse to the long axis of the fiber usually differs).
A rigorous closed-form analytical solution that accounts for all of these factors (as well as others) is probably impossible to obtain. Consequently, most advanced micromechanics analyses are performed numerically using finite element methods. Because the primary objective of this book is to investigate composite materials at the structural (i.e., macroscopic) level, only the simple rule of mixtures is presented herein. The reader interested in learning more about micromechanics analyses is referred to the many excellent texts that discuss this topic in greater detail, a few of which are listed here as Refs. 6, 9–13. HOMEWORK PROBLEMS 1. An orthotropic material is known to have the following elastic properties: Exx ¼ 100 GPa
Eyy ¼ 200 GPa
Ezz ¼ 75 GPa
vxy ¼ 0:20
vxz ¼ 0:25
vyz ¼ 0:60
Gxy ¼ 60 GPa
Gxz ¼ 75 GPa
Gyz ¼ 50 GPa
gxx;xy ¼ 0:30
gxx;xz ¼ 0:25
gxx;yz ¼ 0:30
gyy;xy ¼ 0:60
gyy;xz ¼ 0:75
gyy;yz ¼ 0:20
gzz;xy ¼ 0:20
gzz;xz ¼ 0:05
gzz;yz ¼ 0:15
lxy;xz ¼ 0:10
lxy;yz ¼ 0:05
gxz;yz ¼ 0:10
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(a) What strains are induced if a uniaxial tensile stress rxx=300 MPa is applied? (b) What strains are induced if a uniaxial tensile stress ryy=300 MPa is applied? (c) What strains are induced if a uniaxial tensile stress rzz=300 MPa is applied? (d) What strains are induced if a pure shear stress sxy=100 MPa is applied? (e) What strains are induced if a pure shear stress sxz=100 MPa is applied? (f ) What strains are induced if a pure shear stress syz=100 MPa is applied? 2. An orthotropic material is known to have the following elastic properties: E11 ¼ 100 GPa
E22 ¼ 200 GPa
E33 ¼ 75 GPa
v12 ¼ 0:20
v13 ¼ 0:25
v23 ¼ 0:60
G12 ¼ 60 GPa
G13 ¼ 75 GPa
G23 ¼ 50 GPa
(a) What strains are induced if a uniaxial tensile stress r11=300 MPa is applied? (b) What strains are induced if a uniaxial tensile stress r22=300 MPa is applied? (c) What strains are induced if a uniaxial tensile stress r33=300 MPa is applied? (d) What strains are induced if a pure shear stress s12=100 MPa is applied? (e) What strains are induced if a pure shear stress s13=100 MPa is applied? (f ) What strains are induced if a pure shear stress s23=100 MPa is applied? 3. A tensile specimen is machined from an anisotropic material. The specimen is referenced to an x–y–z coordinate system, as shown in Fig. 15a. The cross-section of the specimen is initially a ‘‘perfect’’ 55 mm square. In addition, ‘‘perfect’’ 55 mm squares are drawn on the x–y and x–z surfaces of the specimen, as shown. A uniaxial tensile stress rxx=700 MPa is then applied, causing the specimen to deform as shown in Fig. 15b–d. Determine the values of Exx, vxy, vxz, gxx,xy, gxx,xz, and gxx,yz that correspond to these deformations.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 15 Tensile specimen described in Problem 3 (deformations shown greatly exaggerated for clarity). (a) Tensile specimen machined from an anisotropic material. (b) Change in cross-section. (c) Change in dimensions on x–y face. (d) Change in dimensions on x–z face.
Table 4
The [0]8 Specimen (Width=1.251 in.; Thickness=0.048 in.)
Load (1 bf) 0 260 630 1220 1910 2600 4100
Axial strain (Ain./in.)
Trans strain (Ain./in.)
0 192 454 860 1335 1807 2784
0 61 146 279 433 587 930
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Table 5 The [90]16 Specimen (Width= 1.254 in.; Thickness=0.090 in.) Load (1 bf) 0 64 102 172 275 385
Axial strain (Ain./in.) 0 300 539 923 1489 2072
4. Load vs. strain data collected during two different composite tensile tests are shown in Tables 4 and 5. Use linear regression to determine the following properties for this composite material: (a) Determine E11 and v12 using the data collected using the [0]8 specimen (Table 4). (b) Determine E22 using the data collected using the [90]16 specimen (Table 5). (c) Determine the value of v21 for this composite material system.
Figure 16 Tensile specimen described in Problem 5.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Figure 17 Deformed square described in Problem 6.
5. A thin tensile specimen is machined from a material with unknown properties. A ‘‘perfect’’ square with dimensions 5 5 mm is drawn on one surface of the specimen, as shown in Fig. 16. A tensile stress of 500 MPa is then applied, causing the square to deform. Determine Exx, vxy, and gxx,xy for this material. 6. A ‘‘perfect’’ square with dimensions 11 mm is drawn on the surface of a plate. The temperature of the plate is then uniformly increased by 300jC, causing the square to deform as shown in Fig. 17. Determine the corresponding strains exx, eyy, and exy, and coefficients of thermal expansion axx, ayy, and axy.
REFERENCES 1.
Dieter, G.E. Mechanical Metallurgy; New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Inc., 1986; ISBN0-07-016893-8. 2. Lekhnitski, S.G. Theory of Elasticity of an Anisotropic Body; Holden-Day: San Francisco, 1963. 3. Bert, C.W.; Reddy, J.N.; Reddy, V.S.; Chao, W.C. Analysis of thick rectangular plates laminated of bimodulus composite materials. AIAA J. 1981, 19 (10), 1342– 1349. 4. Measurement of Thermal Expansion Coefficient, M-M Tech Note 513; Measurement Group, Inc.: Raleigh, NC, USA (available at the Measurement Group website at: http://www.measurementsgroup.com/guide/indexes/ tn_index.htm). 5. Standard Test Method for Moisture Absorption Properties and Equilibrium Conditioning of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials, Test Standard 5229;
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
American Society for Testing and Materials: West Conshohocken, PA, USA (may also be accessed via the ASTM website at: http://www.astm.org/). 6. Hyer, M.W. Stress Analysis of Fiber-Reinforced Composite Materials; McGrawHill Book Co.: New York, NY; 1998; ISBN 0-07-016700-1. 7. Herakovich, C.T. Mechanics of Fibrous Composites; John Wiley and Sons: New York, NY, 1998; ISBN 0-471-10636-4. 8. Hull, D. An Introduction to Composite Materials; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, Great Britain, 1981; ISBN 0-521-23991-5. 9. Gibson, R.F. Principles of Composite Material Mechanics; McGraw-Hill Inc.: New York, NY, 1994; ISBN0-07-023451-5.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4 Elastic Response of Anisotropic Materials
In this chapter, we will consider the strains induced in anisotropic materials when subjected to arbitrary combinations of stress, uniform changes in temperature, and/or uniform changes in moisture content. The chapter begins with a consideration of the strains induced by stress under constant environmental conditions. A ‘‘generalized’’ form of Hooke’s law, which relates strain to stress for any anisotropic material, will be developed. Next, Hooke’s law will be specialized for two particular types of anisotropy. First, for orthotropic materials, and then for transversely isotropic materials. Attention will then be focussed on strains caused by uniform changes in temperature or moisture content. As before, relationships for anisotropic materials will be developed first, and will then be specialized to the case of orthotropic and transversely isotropic materials. Finally, the strains induced by the combined effects of stress, temperature, and moisture will be discussed. 1 STRAINS INDUCED BY STRESS: ANISOTROPIC MATERIALS A review of the stress and strain tensors has been provided in Chap. 2. Stress is a symmetrical second-order tensor. In tensoral notation, stress is written as 167
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
rij, where subscripts i and j take on values of x, y, and z. Alternatively, the stress tensor can be written using matrix notation as: 2 3 rxx rxy rxz ð1Þ rij ¼ 4 ryx ryy ryz 5 rzx rzy rzz Because the stress tensor is symmetrical (i.e., ryx=rxy, rzx=rxz, and rzy = ryz), only six independent stress components appear in Eq. (1). Similarly, strain is a symmetrical second-order tensor eij and can be written as: 3 2 3 2 ðexx Þ ðcxy =2Þ ðcxz =2Þ exx exy exz 7 6 6 ðeyy Þ ðcyz =2Þ 7 ð2Þ eij ¼ 4 eyx eyy eyz 5 ¼ 4 ðcyx =2Þ 5 =2Þ ðc =2Þ ðe Þ ðc ezx ezy ezz zz zx zy Only six independent strain components appear in Eq. (2). Also, the tensoral shear strain components equal one-half the more commonly used engineering shear strain components, that is, exy ¼ eyx ¼
cxy cyx cyz czy c c ¼ ; exz ¼ ezx ¼ xz ¼ zx ; eyz ¼ ezy ¼ ¼ 2 2 2 2 2 2
ð3Þ
For any elastic solid, the strain and stress tensors are related as follows (assuming temperature and moisture content remain constant): eij ¼ Sijkl rkl
ð4Þ
All subscripts that appear in Eq. (4) take on values of x, y, and z. Equation (4) is called generalized Hooke’s law, and is valid for any elastic solid under constant environmental conditions. It is seen that the strain and stress tensors are related via the fourth-order compliance tensor Sijkl. Because strains are unitless quantities, from Eq. (4), it is seen that the units of Sijkl are 1/ (stress) (i.e., either 1/Pa or 1/psi). Because the compliance tensor is described using four subscripts and because each subscript may take on three distinct value (e.g., x, y, or z), it would initially appear that 34=81 independent terms appear within the compliance tensor. However, due to symmetry of both the strain and stress tensors, it will be shown below that the compliance tensor consists of (at most) 36 material constants. It will be very convenient to express Eq. (4) using matrix notation. However, because Sijkl is a fourth-order tensor (and hence can be viewed as having ‘‘four dimensions’’), we cannot expand Sijkl as a two-dimensional
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
matrix directly. To expand Eq. (4), we must first define the components of stress and strain using contracted notation, as follows: exx ! e1 eyy ! e2 ezz ! e3 cyz ¼ czy ! e4 cxz ¼ czx ! e5 cxy ¼ cyx ! e6
rxx ! r1 ryy ! r2 rzz ! r3 ryz ¼ rzy ! r4 rxz ¼ rzx ! r5 rxy ¼ ryx ! r6
ð5Þ
Notice that the symmetry of the strain and stress tensors (cyz=cxz, etc.) is embedded within the very definition of contracted notation. Also note that the shear strain components (e4, e5, and e6) represent engineering shear strains, rather than tensoral shear strains. Based on this change in notation, we can now write Eq. (4) as: ej ¼ Sij rj
where i; j ¼ 16
ð6Þ
In contracted notation, the strain and stress tensors are expressed with a single subscript (i.e., ei and rj), and hence in Eq. (6), they appear to be firstorder tensors. This is, of course, not the case. Both strain and stress are second-order tensors. We are able to write them as using contracted notation only because they are both symmetrical tensors. Similarly, contracted notation allows us to refer to individual components of the fourth-order compliance tensor expressed using only two subscripts. We will henceforth refer to Sij as the compliance matrix, and the use of contracted notation will be implied. Expanding Eq. (6), we have: 8 9 2 e1 > S11 > > > > > 6 > > > e2 > S21 > > > 6 > > = 6 <e > 6 S31 3 ¼6 6S > > e > 6 41 > 4> > > 6 > > > 4 S51 > e5 > > > > ; : > e6 S61
S12 S22 S32 S42 S52 S62
S13 S23 S33 S43 S53 S63
S14 S24 S34 S44 S54 S64
S15 S25 S35 S45 S55 S65
38 9 S16 > r1 > > > > > >r > S26 7 2> > > 7> > > > 7> < 7 r3 = S36 7 S46 7 > > r4 > 7> > > > 7> > > r5 > S56 5> > > > ; : > S66 r6
ð7Þ
In contracted notation, the compliance matrix has six rows and six columns, so it is now clear that it consists of 36 independent material constants (at most), as previously stated. Furthermore, through a consideration of strain energy, it can be shown [1] that the compliance matrix must
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
itself be symmetrical. That is, all terms in symmetrical off-diagonal positions must be equal: S21 ¼ S12 S31 ¼ S13
S32 ¼ S23
S41 ¼ S14
S42 ¼ S24
S43 ¼ S34
S51 ¼ S15
S52 ¼ S25
S53 ¼ S35
S54 ¼ S45
S61 ¼ S16
S62 ¼ S26
S63 ¼ S36
S64 ¼ S46
ð8Þ S65 ¼ S56
Hence, although the compliance matrix for an anisotropic composite consists of 36 material constants, only 21 of these constants are independent. Substituting the original strain and stress terms (defined in Eq. (5)) into Eq. (7), we have: 9 2 9 8 38 exx > S11 S12 S13 S14 S15 S16 > rxx > > > > > > > 6 > > > 7> > > > > > > ryy > S S S S S S e 21 22 23 24 25 26 yy > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > > 7 6 < e = 6S < S32 S33 S34 S35 S36 7 rzz = 31 zz 7 6 ¼6 ð9Þ 7 r > cyz > > yz > > > > 6 S41 S42 S43 S44 S45 S46 7> > > > > > 6 > > 7> > > c > > > > 4 S51 S52 S53 S54 S55 S56 5> > > > > xz > > rxz > > > ; ; : : cxy S61 S62 S63 S64 S65 S66 rxy The individual constants that appear in the compliance matrix can be easily related to the material properties defined in Chap. 3 by invoking the principal of superposition. That is, because we have restricted our attention to linear elastic behavior, an individual component of strain caused by several stress components acting simultaneously can be obtained by adding the strain caused by each stress component acting independently. For example, the strains exx caused by each stress component independently are given by: 1 rxx rxx causes ðfrom Eq: 3:1Þ exx ¼ Exx myx ryy causes ðfrom Eq: 3:6Þ exx ¼ ryy Eyy mzx rzz causes ðfrom Eq: 3:7Þ exx ¼ rzz Ezz gyz;xx syz causes ðfrom Eq: 3:14Þ exx ¼ syz Gyz gxz;xx sxz causes ðfrom Eq: 3:13Þ exx ¼ sxz Gxz gxy;xx sxy causes ðfrom Eq: 3:12Þ exx ¼ sxy Gxy
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
To determine the strain exx induced if all stress components act simultaneously, simply add up the contribution to exx caused by each stress individually, to obtain: exx ¼
gyz;xx myx 1 mzx rxx þ ryy þ rzz þ syz Exx Eyy Ezz Gyz gxy;xx gxz;xx þ sxz þ sxy Gxz Gxy
ð10aÞ
Using an identical procedure, the remaining five strain components caused by an arbitrary combination of stresses are:
eyy
gxz;yy mxy mzy 1 ¼ rxx þ ryy þ rzz þ syz Exx Ezz Gyz Eyy gxz;yy gxy;yy þ sxz þ sxy Gxz Gxy
gyz;zz myz mxz 1 ezz ¼ rxx þ ryy þ rzz þ syz Ezz Exx Eyy Gyz gxy;zz gxz;zz þ sxz þ sxy Gxz Gxy
ð10bÞ
cyz ¼
gxx;yz gyy;yz gzz;yz 1 rxx þ ryy þ rzz þ syz Gyz Exx Eyy Ezz lxz;yz lxy;yz þ sxz þ sxy Gxz Gxy
ð10cÞ
cxz
gyy;xz lyz;xz gxx;xz gzz;xz ¼ rxx þ ryy þ rzz þ syz Exx Eyy Ezz Gyz lxy;xz 1 þ sxz þ sxy Gxz Gxy
ð10dÞ
cxy
gxx;xy gyy;xy gzz;xy lyz;xy ¼ rxx þ ryy þ rzz þ syz Exx Eyy Ezz Gyz lxz;xy 1 þ sxz þ sxy Gxy Gxz
ð10eÞ
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð10f Þ
Equation (10a)–(10f) can be assembled in matrix form: 38 9 2 9 8 gyz;xx gxy;xx gxz;xx myx 1 mzx > > > > > > > r e xx > > > 7> > 6 Exx > > xx > > E E G G G > > > > yy zz yz xz xy 6 > > > > 7 > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > > g g g m m 1 7 6 xy zy yz;yy xz;yy xy;yy > > > > > > > > e r 7 6 > > > yy > yy > > > > 7 6 > > > > E E E G G G xx yy zz yz xz xy > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > > 7 > 6 mxz > > > g g g m 1 > > > > yz yz;zz xy;zz xz;zz > > > > 7 6 > > > > e r zz zz = 6 E = < < 7 6 xx Eyy Ezz Gyz Gxz Gxy 7 pc ¼ 6 7 gyy;yz gzz;yz lxz;yz lxy;yz 7> > 6 gxx;yz > > 1 > > 6 > > cyz > > 7> syz > > > > > > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > 6 Exx Eyy Ezz Gyz Gxz Gxy 7> > > > > > > > > 7 6 > > > > g l l g g 1 > > > > yy;xz yz;xz xy;xz xx;xz zz;xz 7 6 > > > > c s > > > > 7 6 xz xz > > > 6 Exx > > > > > G E E G G 7 yy zz yz xz xy > > > > > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > > 5 4 g g g l l 1 > > > > xx;xy yy;xy zz;xy yz;xy xz;xy > > : cxy > : sxy > ; ; Gxy Exx Eyy Ezz Gyz Gxz ð11Þ By comparing Eqs. (9) and (11), it can be seen that the individual components of the compliance matrix are directly related to the material properties measured during uniaxial tests or pure shear tests: S11 ¼
1 Exx
S22 ¼
1 Eyy
S33 ¼
S44 ¼
1 Gyx
S55 ¼
1 Gxz
S66 ¼
mxy Exx myz S32 ¼ S23 ¼ Eyy gyy;yz S42 ¼ S24 ¼ Eyy gxx;xz S51 ¼ S15 ¼ Exx gzz;xz S53 ¼ S35 ¼ Ezz gxx;xy S61 ¼ S16 ¼ Exx gzz;xy S63 ¼ S36 ¼ Ezz lxz;xy S65 ¼ S56 ¼ Gxz S21 ¼ S12 ¼
¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼
myx Eyy mzy Ezz gyz;yy Gyz gxz;xx Gxz gxz;zz Gxz gxy;xx Gxy gxy;zz Gxy lxy;xz Gxy
mxz Exx gxx;yz S41 ¼ S14 ¼ Exx gzz;yz S43 ¼ S34 ¼ Ezz gyy;xz S52 ¼ S25 ¼ Eyy lyz;xz S54 ¼ S45 ¼ Eyz gyy;xy S62 ¼ S26 ¼ Eyy lyz;xy S64 ¼ S46 ¼ Eyz S31 ¼ S13 ¼
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼
1 Ezz
1 Gxy mzx Ezz gyz;xx Gyz gyz;zz Gyz gxz;yy Gxz lxz;yz Gxz gxy;yy Gxy lxy;yz Gxy
ð12Þ
Because the compliance matrix must be symmetric, Eq. (12) shows that many of the properties of anisotropic materials are related through the following inverse relationships: myx mxz ¼ Exx Eyy myz mzy mxz mzx ¼ ¼ Exx Ezz Eyy Ezz gxx;yz gyz;xx gyy;yz gyz;yy ¼ ¼ Exx Gyz Eyy Gyz gxx;xz gxz;xx gyy;yz gyz;yy ¼ ¼ Exx Gxz Eyy Gyz gxx;xy gxy;xx gyy;xy gxy;yy ¼ ¼ Exx Gxy Eyy Gxy lxz;xy lxy;xz ¼ Gxz Gxy
gzz;yz gyz;zz ¼ Ezz Gyz gzz;xz gxz;zz ¼ Ezz Gxz gzz;xy gxy;zz ¼ Ezz Gxy
ð13Þ lyz;xz lxz;yz ¼ Gyz Gxz lyz;xy lxy;yz ¼ Gyz Gxy
The inverse relationships are very significant from an experimental point of view because they dramatically reduce the number of tests that must be performed in order to determine the value of the many terms that appear within the compliance matrix of an anisotropic composite. Specifically, if the compliance matrix were not symmetrical, and hence if the inverse relationships did not exist, then 36 tests would be required to measure all components of the compliance matrix. The fact that the compliance matrix must be symmetrical reduces the number of tests required to 21. Of course, this is still a large number of tests. Fortunately, because the principal material coordinate system of composites is readily apparent, the elastic properties of composites are usually measured relative to the principal material coordinate system rather than an arbitrary (nonprincipal) coordinate system. As discussed in Sec. 2, this further reduces the number of tests required. The 21 terms within the compliance matrix of an anisotropic composite can then be calculated based on properties measured relative to the principal material coordinate system. Thus far, we have discussed Hooke’s law in the form of ‘‘strain–stress’’ relationships. That is, given values of the components of stress, we can calculate the resulting strains using Eq. (9) or Eq. (11), for example. In practice, we are often interested in the opposite problem. That is, a common circumstance in practice is that the components of strain induced in a structure have been measured, and we wish to calculate the stresses that caused these strains. In this case, we need a ‘‘stress–strain’’ form of Hooke’s law. The stress–strain form of Hooke’s law can be obtained by simply
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
inverting previous results. For example, inverting Hooke’s law given by Eq. (6), we have: ri ¼ Cij ej
where i; j ¼ 16
ð14Þ
Cij is called the ‘‘stiffness matrix.’’* The stiffness matrix is the mathematical inverse of the compliance matrix Cij=Sij1. In expanded form, Eq. (14) is written as: 8 9 2 38 9 C11 C12 C13 C14 C15 C16 > e1 > r1 > > > > > > > > 7> >r > > > 6C > > > > C C C C C e2 > 21 22 23 24 25 26 > > > > 7 6 2 > > > > > > > > 7 6 > r4 > 4> > > > 6 C41 C42 C43 C44 C45 C46 7> > > > > > 6 > 7> > > > > 4 C51 C52 C53 C54 C55 C56 5> > > > r > > > > 5> > > e5 > > : : ; ; r6 e6 C61 C62 C63 C64 C65 C66 The stiffness matrix is symmetrical (C21=C12, C31=C13, etc.). The units of each stiffness term are the same as stress (either Pa or psi). 2 STRAINS INDUCED BY STRESS: ORTHOTROPIC AND TRANSVERSELY ISOTROPIC MATERIALS As discussed in Sec. 2 of Chap. 3, many of the unusual couplings between stress and strain exhibited by composites referenced to an arbitrary coordinate system do not occur if the stress and strain tensors are referenced to the principal material coordinate system. In this text, a material referenced to an arbitrary (nonprincipal) coordinate system is called ‘‘anisotropic’’ whereas if the same material is referenced to the principal material coordinate system, it is called either an ‘‘orthotropic’’ or ‘‘transversely isotropic’’ material. All of the following coupling terms are zero for orthotropic or transversely isotropic materials:
Coefficients of mutual influence of the second kind: g11;12 ¼ g11;13 ¼ g11;23 ¼ g22;12 ¼ g22;13 ¼ g22;23 ¼ g33;12 ¼ g33;13 ¼ g33;23 ¼ 0
* The variable names assigned to the compliance and stiffness matrices in this chapter have evolved over many years and are widely used within the structural mechanics community. The reader should note that, unfortunately, the symbol ‘‘S’’ is customarily used to refer to the compliance matrix, whereas the symbol ‘‘C’’ is customarily used to refer to the stiffness matrix.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Coefficients of mutual influence of the first kind: g12;11 ¼ g12;22 ¼ g12;23 ¼ g13;11 ¼ g13;22 ¼ g13;33 ¼ g23;11 ¼ g23;22 ¼ g23;33 ¼ 0
Chentsov coefficients: l12;13 ¼ l12;23 ¼ l13;12 ¼ l13;23 ¼ l23;12 ¼ l23;13 ¼ 0
Because these coupling terms do not exist, Hooke’s law for orthotropic or transversely isotropic materials is simplified considerably relative to that of an anisotropic material. For an orthotropic material, Hooke’s law becomes (compare with Eq. (11)): 9 8 > > > e11 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > e22 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > e 33 > > = <
2
m21 6 E22 6 6 6 m21 1 6 6 E E22 6 11 6 6 m23 6 m13 6 6 E11 E22 6 ¼6 > > > 6 > > > 6 > c23 > 0 0 > > 6 > > > > 6 > > > > 6 > > > > > 6 > > > 6 > > > > 0 0 c > > 13 > 6 > 6 > > > > 6 > > > > > > > 6 > > > > 4 > > 0 0 ; : c12 > 1 E11
m31 E33
m32 E33 1 E33
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1 G23
0
0
1 G13
0
0
0
0
1 G12
9 38 > > > r11 > > > > 7> > > > 7> > > > > 7> > > > 7> > > > 7> > > r22 > 7> > > 7> > > > 7> > > > > 7> > > > > 7> > > > 7> r 33 > > = 7< 7 7 > 7> > > 7> > > s23 > > 7> > > > > 7> > > > 7> > > 7> > > > 7> > > > s13 > 7> > > 7> > > > 7> > > > > 7 > > > 5> > > > > > > : s12 ;
ð16Þ
Alternatively, Eq. (16) may be written as: 9 8 e11 > > > > > > > > > > > > e > > 22 > > > > > > > > > = < e33 >
2
S11
6 6 S12 6 6 6S 6 13 ¼6 6 > > > 6 0 c23 > > > > > 6 > > > > 6 > > 6 0 > c13 > > > > > 4 > > > > ; : c12 0
S12
S13
0
0
S22
S23
0
0
S23
S33
0
0
0
0
S44
0
0
0
0
S55
0
0
0
0
38 9 r11 > > > > > 7> > > > > > > 0 7 r > > 22 7> > > > > 7> > > > > < 0 7 7 r33 = 7 7 > > s23 > 0 7> > > > 7> > > > 7> > > > s13 > 0 7 > > > 5> > > > > ; : s12 S66 0
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ð17Þ
The fact that the compliance matrix must be symmetrical (S21=S12, etc.) has been included in Eq. (17). Each compliance term in Eq. (17) is related to the more familiar engineering properties as follows: 1 E11 1 ¼ G23
1 E22 1 ¼ G13
1 E33 1 ¼ G12
S11 ¼
S22 ¼
S33 ¼
S44
S55
S66
m12 m21 ¼ E11 E22 m13 m31 ¼ ¼ E11 E33 m23 m32 ¼ ¼ E22 E33
ð18Þ
S21 ¼ S12 ¼ S31 ¼ S13 S32 ¼ S23
It can be seen that only nine independent material constants exist for an orthotropic material. The set of nine independent constants can be viewed as: ðS11 ; S22 ; S33 ; S44 ; S55 ; S66 ; S12 ; S13 ; and S23 Þ or, equivalently, as: ðE11 ; E22 ; E33 ; m12 ; m13 ; m23 ; G12 ; G13 ; and G23 Þ Equation (17) is the strain–stress form of Hooke’s law suitable for use with orthotropic materials. To obtain a stress–strain relationship, Eq. (17) is inverted, resulting in: 9 2 9 8 38 C11 C12 C13 0 0 0 > e11 > r11 > > > > > > > > > > > > e22 > 6 C12 C22 C23 0 0 0 7 > > > r22 > > > > > 7> 6 > > > > = 6 0 s23 > c23 > 0 0 7> 0 0 C44 > > > > > > > > 7 6 > 4 > >s > > > c > 0 5> 0 0 0 0 C55 > > > 13 > > > > ; ; : : 13 > s12 c 0 0 0 0 0 C66 12 Individual components within the stiffness matrix for an orthotropic material are related to the compliance terms as follows: S22 S33 S223 S S11 S33 S213 ¼ S 1 ¼ S44
S13 S23 S12 S33 S S12 S13 S11 S23 ¼ S 1 ¼ S55
S12 S33 S13 S22 S S11 S22 S212 ¼ S 1 ¼ S66 ð20Þ
C11 ¼
C12 ¼
C13 ¼
C22
C23
C33
C44
C55
C66
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
where: S ¼ S11 S22 S33 S11 S223 S22 S213 S33 S212 þ 2S12 S13 S23 Alternatively, the stiffness terms may be calculated using the elastic properties described in Sec. 2 of Chap. 3: ðE22 m223 E33 ÞE211 X ðm12 m23 þ m13 ÞE11 E22 E33 ¼ X ðm23 E11 þ m12 m13 E22 ÞE22 E33 ¼ X
ðm12 E22 þ m13 m23 E33 ÞE11 E22 X 2 ðE11 m13 E33 ÞE222 ¼ X ð21Þ ðE11 m212 E22 ÞE22 E33 ¼ X
C11 ¼
C12 ¼
C13
C22
C23
C44 ¼ G23
C55 ¼ G13
C33
C66 ¼ G12
where: X ¼ E11 E22 m212 E222 m213 E22 E33 m223 E11 E33 2m12 m13 m23 E22 E33 Hooke’s law for transversely isotropic materials is simplified furthermore because in this case, E22=E33, m12=m13, m21=m31, m23=m32, and G12=G13. Also, it can also be easily shown that for transversely isotropic E22 . Hence, for transversely isotropic composites, Eq. composites, G23 ¼ 2ð1þm 23 Þ (16) reduces to: 38 9 1 m21 m21 > > > > 0 0 0 r > > 11 6 E11 7> > E22 E22 > > 6 7 > > > 6 m 1 m 7> > > > 6 7> 21 32 > > > 0 0 0 7> r 6 > 22 > > > 7> 6 E11 > E22 E22 > > 7> 6 > > > > > 7 6 m12 m 1 > > 23 > 7 6 > r33 > 0 0 0 7> = < 6 E E22 E22 11 7 6 ¼6 7 > 6 > > 7> 2ð1 þ m23 Þ > > > > > > s23 > c23 > 6 0 0 7 0 0 0 > > > > > > > 7> G22 > 6 > > > > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > > 7> 6 > > > 1 > 6 > > > 7 > > > c s 13 > 0 7> 0 0 0 0 > > 13 > 6 > > > > > > > > G12 7 6 > > > > > > > > 7 6 > > > > > > > > 5 4 > > >c > > 1 > > ; : 12 ; : s12 > 0 0 0 0 0 G12 9 8 > > > > e > > 11 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > e > 22 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > = < e33 >
2
which may also be written as: 9 2 8 S11 S12 S12 e11 > > > > > > > 6 > e22 > > > 6 S12 S22 S23 > > = 6S <e > 6 12 S23 S22 33 ¼6 > 6 0 c23 > 0 0 > > > > > 6 > > > 4 c > > 0 0 0 > ; : 13 > c12 0 0 0
0 0 0 2ðS22 S23 Þ 0 0
0 0 0 0 S66 0
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
9 38 0 > r11 > > > > > > r22 > 0 7 > > > 7> > > < 7 0 7 r33 = 7 s23 > 0 7> > > 7> > >s > > > > 0 5> 13 > > ; : s 12 S66
ð22Þ
ð23Þ
It can be seen that only five independent material constants exist for a transversely isotropic material. The set of five independent constants can be viewed as: ðS11 ; S22 ; S66 ; S12 ; and S23 Þ or, equivalently, as: ðE11 ; E22 ; m12 ; m23 ; and G12 Þ Equation (23) is the strain–stress form of Hooke’s law suitable for use with transversely isotropic composites. To obtain a stress–strain relationship, Eq. (23) is inverted, resulting in: 8 9 2 9 38 C11 C12 C12 0 0 0 > e11 > r11 > > > > > > > > > 7> 6C > > > > > > > > C C 0 0 0 e 7 6 > > > r 12 22 23 22 > 22 > > > > > > > > 7 6 > 6 > > > = = < < 7 C C 0 0 0 C e r33 12 23 22 7 33 6 ¼6 7 > > c23 > 6 0 s23 > 0 7 0 0 2ðC22 C23 Þ 0 > > > > > > > 7> 6 > > > > > > > > 7 6 > > > > s c > > > > 0 0 0 0 C 0 5 4 13 66 13 > > > > > > > > ; ; : : s12 c12 0 0 0 0 0 C66 ð24Þ Individual components within the stiffness matrix for a transversely isotropic composite are related to the compliance terms, as follows: S22 þ S33 X 2 S S11 S23 ¼ 12 XðS22 S23 Þ
C11 ¼ C23
S12 X 1 ¼ S66
C12 ¼ C66
C22 ¼
S11 S22 S212 XðS22 S23 Þ
ð25Þ
where: V ¼ S11 ðS22 þ S23 Þ 2S212 Alternatively, the stiffness terms may be calculated using the elastic properties described in Sec. 2 of Chap. 3: E211 ð1 m23 Þ m12 E11 E22 E22 ðE11 m212 E22 Þ C12 ¼ C22 ¼ X Xð1 þ m23 Þ X 2 E22 ðm23 E11 þ m12 E22 Þ C22 C23 E22 C44 ¼ ¼ C66 ¼ C12 ¼ Xð1 þ m23 Þ 2 2ð1 þ m23 Þ
C11 ¼ C23
ð26Þ where: X ¼ E11 ð1 m23 Þ 2m212 E22
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Example Problem 1 The properties of a composite material are known to be: E11 ¼ 170 GPa m12 ¼ 0:30 G12 ¼ 13 GPa
E22 ¼ 10 GPa m13 ¼ 0:35 G13 ¼ 10 GPa
E33 ¼ 8 GPa m23 ¼ 0:40 G23 ¼ 8 GPa
Note that nine distinct material properties have been specified, indicating that this composite material is orthotropic. Determine the strains caused by the following state of stress: 9