Sports Facilities and Technologies
Developers, designers and operators increasingly need to create safe, versatile spo...
544 downloads
7691 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Sports Facilities and Technologies
Developers, designers and operators increasingly need to create safe, versatile sports amenities that are of lasting value to local and wider communities. Successful sports and leisure facilities have to be user-friendly and operate efficiently. The design process involves many disciplines which are interdependent and mutually supportive, using a holistic approach to achieve the appropriate controls, simplicity, efficiency and economy. This guide covers planning, design, construction, operation and maintenance criteria, including: • • • • • • • • • •
buildings for indoor and outdoor sports; building regulations and health and safety; structure and facades; heating and ventilation; acoustics and lighting; infrastructure; communications and security; stairways and elevators; sustainability; sports-led urban regeneration.
Containing most types of sports building, this book uses examples from around the world to develop a definitive reference for practitioners, researchers and students in the areas of sport, leisure, the built environment, building design and facilities management.
Peter Culley is an independent engineer whose work ranges from housing to closing-roof stadiums. His specialist experience in sports facilities design dates back to 1990 when, as a Structural Advisory Engineer with British Steel, he was asked to take a leading role in marketing the steel industry’s products to developers and designers of the new generation of all-seater stadiums. John Pascoe is a content editor (electromechanical) with Electro components plc. He previously worked with Arup (1979–2002), Constrado (1978–79) and British Steel (1972–77). Peter and John co-edited the award-winning book Stadium Engineering (2005).
Cover photo Time Warner Cable Arena, City of Charlotte in North Carolina, USA, is the home of the National Basketball Association’s (NBA) Charlotte Bobcats and a premier host venue for concerts and other arena events. The dominant visual element in the arena’s seating bowl is the centre-hung state-of-the-art video display and scoreboard. It is the most technologically advanced scoreboard and sound system in the country and features the largest video screen in use in any NBA facility. Full-screen LED technology allows an unlimited configuration of live and recorded video, scores, animation and graphics. A unique, three-dimensional backlit cityscape above the scoreboard features the Charlotte skyline. This uses a 360° projection system which allows the skyline to change and feature graphics such as airplanes and fireworks, and night-time or daytime skies. Photograph by Mark Steinkamp, courtesy Daktronics.
To those who advocated publication of the book – Jaime Aldaya, Eddie Hole, Geraint John, Caroline Mallinder, Ian Mudd and Eric Taylor
And to those who inspired us to write it – Colin Dexter, Les Hackett, Kisho Kurokawa, Peter Rice, Ron Taylor and David Whyte
Sports Facilities and Technologies Peter Culley and John Pascoe
First published 2009 in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA Simultaneously published by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2009. To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk. © 2009 Peter Culley & John Pascoe All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. The publisher makes no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the information contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions that may be made.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Culley, Peter. Sports facilities and technologies / Peter Culley & John Pascoe. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Sports facilities. 2. Physical fitness centers. 3. Recreation centers. 4. Public architecture. I. Pascoe, John, MCAM II. Title. GV405.C85 2009 725’.8043—dc22 2008052779
ISBN 0-203-87602-4 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN10: 0-415-45868-4 (hbk) ISBN10: 0-203-87602-4 (ebk) ISBN13: 978-0-415-45868-9 (hbk) ISBN13: 978-0-203-87602-2 (ebk)
Contents
Preface
vii
Foreword by Professor Geraint John
viii
The authors
ix
Acknowledgements
ix
Introduction
1
Part One Sports and Facilities 1 Sports halls
3 5
2 Squash courts
15
3 Gymnasiums
23
4 Dance studios
31
5 Swimming pools
39
6 Ice rinks
49
7 Integrated sports facilities
57
8 Sports-led urban regeneration
69
9 Stadiums
79
10 Indoor facilities for outdoor sports
93
Part Two Facilities Development
99
11 Building regulations
101
12 Health and safety
107
13 Feasibility, site selection and investigation
111
14 Masterplanning, transportation and infrastructure
119
15 Building form, structure and facades
127
16 Indoor sports surfaces
137
17 Heating, ventilating and air-conditioning
147
18 Electrical installation
155
19 Facilities management
161
20 Continuous improvement
167
contents
Part Three Technologies
175
21 Materials
177
22 Acoustics
187
23 Lighting
193
24 Communications
201
25 Safety and security
209
26 Accessibility
215
27 Controls and automation
221
28 Sustainability
227
29 Refurbishment
235
30 Recycling
239
Conclusion
243
Appendix I Construction Specifications Institute (CSI) MasterFormat
244
Appendix II Indoor sports: space planning drawings
246
References
257
Index
267
Image credits
278
vi
P re f a c e
We’ve written this book for everyone who shares our enthusiasm for the universal language of sport and its power to break down barriers. We have also written it specifically for professionals, researchers and students in the fields of sports development, sport engineering and technology, sports management, sport history, architecture, the built environment, construction and building engineering design. Sport is global, so we’ve written for a global audience. To demonstrate points that we make we have, however, had to refer to specific regulations, codes of practice, standards and specifications and to their implementation in specific projects. In such cases we’ve quoted attribute units and values in local use, with common equivalents in brackets, for example ‘1in (25.4mm)’. Project examples which are valid for a particular application in a specific time and place are not, of course, necessarily appropriate or even legal in another time and place. Each of the following chapters could be a book in its own right. So we’ve compiled a chapter-by-chapter References list (printed at the end of the book) to help readers pursue their further interests in each chapter’s theme. This is a big book which covers a wide range of subjects. We have checked and cross-checked its content continuously. We apologise in advance for any errors. If you should see an error then please do let us know. We will be very grateful to you and will make the correction for any future editions. Finally, one of the advocates of publishing this book said, ‘Hopefully it will be readable’. This is what we want too, and what we have striven to achieve. Whether or not we have succeeded is for you to judge. Peter and John April 2009
vii
F o re w o rd b y P ro f e s s o r G e r a i n t J o h n
I have been asked to write a foreword to this book, and I am pleased to do so. The range of the work is enormous, witnessed by the long list of references at the end of the book. It is a kaleidoscope of simple explanations, contrasted with detailed technical information, early historical background leading to present and future trends, and small facilities contrasting with large scale Olympic developments. It is clearly strong on engineering and material matters, bearing in mind the background of the authors. I asked myself which readership will find this book the most valuable: I think the answer is that there is something to learn here for all those interested in sports facilities. It is a book to both be useful for reference and also to dip into. Peter Culley and John Pascoe are to be commended on the work they have produced. Geraint John*
* professor geraint john Senior Advisor to Populous (formerly HOK Sport Architecture) Honorary Life President of the International Union of Architects (UIA) Programme Sport and Leisure Visiting Professor at the University of Hertfordshire Visiting Professor to the Universidad Camilo Jose Cela, Madrid Former Visiting Professor: Sport Building Design at the University of Luton Council Member of the RIBA (Royal Institute of British Architects) Former Chief Architect and Head of the Technical Unit for Sport at the GB Sports Council Member of the UKTI Global Sports Projects Sector Advisory Group
viii
The authors
Acknowledgements
Peter Culley is an independent engineer whose work ranges from housing to closing-roof stadiums. His specialist experience in sports facilities design dates back to 1990 when, as a structural advisory engineer with British Steel, he was asked to take a leading role in marketing the steel industry’s products to developers and designers of the new generation of all-seater stadiums. This involved him in most of the stadium and sports ground redevelopments in the UK during the 1990s. It also made him a valued member of the international stadium design community. Before joining British Steel in 1978, Peter worked with British Rail. Here, he is best known for the reconstruction of London Bridge Station in the 1970s, with its then innovative NODUS space frame roof structures. Before London Bridge, Peter had, since 1958, designed, detailed and supervised road and rail bridges in concrete and steel, including major bridge and retaining wall works for the new M25 motorway.
This book is the result of inputs from hundreds of people. Most organisations and individuals involved are named in the text, photo credits or copyright references. Additionally, the authors and publisher would like to thank the following: Richard Hughes (Archaeologist – Mohenjo-Daro Site), Daniel Imade, Pauline Shirley (Arup), Cindy Carrasquilla (Charlotte Bobcats), Michelle Wright (Corus Group), Kathryn Harvey (Dalhousie University), John Martin (De Montfort University), Michael Burns, Mike Butt, John Evans, Peter Hare (Electrocomponents), Peter Milburn (Griffith University), Kerry Slatkoff (Ketchum Sports Network), Julie Atkinson (Marl), Terry Paine (Monodraught), Judy Nokes (Office of Public Sector Information), Mark Magner (Queensland University of Technology and Griffith University), Sally Graham, Marcus Kingwell (PMP Consult), Laura Whitton (RIBA), Craig Braham, Carl Chambers, Shereen Roache (Serco), Josh Wheeler (Wheeler Electric).
John Pascoe is a content editor with Electrocomponents plc, responsible for thermal management, lighting, heatsinks, development hardware, electrostatic, cleanroom and test and measurement products. He previously worked with Arup (1979–2002), Constrado (1978–79) and British Steel (1972–77). John is the former editor of the magazines Tubular Structures, Corus Group/British Steel 1977– 2002, Profils Creux en Acier – The Hollow Section – Stahlhohlprofile, CIDECT 1979–86 and Building with Steel, Constrado – BCSA 1978–79. He worked with Frank Pyle, Trevor Slydel and other members of the team which produced the CAD Good Practice Guide (1994). His additional published works include papers and publications on cladding systems, space frames and stainless steels. John is a member of the Construction Writers Association, Illinois, and the Council for British Archaeology. As a member of Hercules Wimbledon AC, he qualified for and competed in the European and Commonwealth Games Trials held at the Gateshead International Stadium in June 1982.
The following firms made substantial contributions to the book content: • Arup (www.arup.com) • Corus Group (www.corusgroup.com) • Electrocomponents plc (www.electrocomponents.com) Commissioned photographs: Simon J Atkinson www.sjatkinson.com Original drawings: Peter Culley
Peter and John co-wrote more than 30 publications on stadiums and sports facilities in the 1990s. In 2002 they assembled, from friends and colleagues, some of the world’s leading specialists in key aspects of stadium design to work together to produce the first book on stadium engineering. That book, Stadium Engineering, was published in 2005 and was the winner of a 2005 Construction Specifications Institute (CSI) Award, 2005 Communicator Award and 2005 Society for Technical Communication (STC) TransEuropean Award (sole UK winner).
ix
‘Sport is a universal language. At its best it can bring people together, no matter what their origin, background, religious beliefs or economic status. And when young people participate in sports or have access to physical education, they can experience real exhilaration even as they learn the ideals of teamwork and tolerance.’ Kofi Annan, New York City, 5 November 2004
I n t ro d u c t i o n
The book is divided into three parts. Part 1 covers different types of sports facilities, sports provision within buildings, the significance of sports facilities in urban developments and the exciting possibilities of sports-led urban regeneration. Part 2 covers sports facilities planning, design, construction, operation and maintenance. Part 3 is about the technologies that are making such facilities increasingly desirable places to be. While Part 1 is sports-specific, the content of Parts 2 and 3 is of wider application and implication. The book is written against a background of major and rapid changes – in the UK alone during the period 2006–08 new building regulations, wiring regulations and construction (design and
management) regulations were implemented. In addition to meeting new requirements, sports facilities designers and managers everywhere are taking advantage of emerging and developing technologies to achieve comfort and delight for building users, while at the same time working to achieve ever-more stringent energy-efficiency targets. This book is about sports facilities and their adaptation to the needs and aspirations of modern societies. We have chosen to use local examples from different parts of the world, to demonstrate ways of addressing global issues, rather than incorporate in our content sports facilities project case studies of a general nature.
1
Part ONE
Sports and Facilities
1.1 Western High School, Washington DC: girls’ basketball (circa 1899)
Chapter 1
Sports halls
Western High School and Warfield Gymnasium
Springfield, and Dr Thomas Wood, Director of Women’s Physical Education at Stanford. Female spectators were also discouraged because doctors said they could be rendered hysterical by seeing women exerting themselves playing a men’s sport. The earliest photograph of a women’s basket ball game that we know of was taken by Frances Benjamin Johnston (1864–1952) at Western High School, Washington DC, around 1899.
Basketball was known as ‘basket ball’ – two words – until 1921. It was designed to meet the need for an indoor sport that would help male athletes keep fit through the winter months. Its inventor James Naismith, a Canadian by birth and a man of strong religious convictions, devised the sport to ‘assist youth to discover moral as well as physical strength through education’. The first game was played between two nine-man teams using a soccer ball at Springfield, Massachusetts, on 12 December 1891. Features of basket ball included passing the ball (rather than dribbling), targeting high-level goals (to prevent collisions) and using peach baskets for the goals (which necessitated the use of ladders to remove the ball from them). Containment baskets were replaced by metal rings with drop-through netting and, when basketball became an arena sport, the backboard was introduced to prevent delays in play due to over-thrown balls landing in the first tiers of spectator seating. Today’s rings are often powder-coated solid steel and backboards may be in plywood or in newer materials, such as reinforced polypropylene resin. Soon after Naismith invented the game for men, Senda Berenson, Director of Physical Training at Smith College, Massachusetts, introduced it to women. The first women’s game was played at Smith College on 22 March 1893. The nine-woman teams wore heavy woollen uniforms covering all of their bodies except for the face, neck and hands. On the day of the game, the armory (drill hall) windows were guarded by women wielding sticks (to keep men away). The only two men present were Walter E Magee, a physical education instructor who had seen basket ball played at
1.2 Naval Base Ventura County, Port Hueneme, California: Warfield Gymnasium (2005)
5
Table 1.1
Playing areas of popular indoor sports Playing area (m)
Playing area (ft)
Ht min.: m (ft)
Ht max.: m (ft)
Aikido Archery (six archers) Athletics (200m track) Badminton Baseball Basketball BMX (track Length) Bocce Bowls: carpet Bowls: indoor level green Bowls: short mat Bowling: 10-pin
9×9 22 × 7.5 87.65 × 43.18 13.4 × 6.1 8.2 × 8.2 (11.6 across) 26 × 14 300 to 400 3–4 × 23–30.5 9.1–10.1 × 1.83–1.98 36.5 × 4.6 min. 12.2–13.75 × 1.83 22.9 × 1 (lane)
29’6” × 29’6” 72’2” × 24’6” 287’6” × 141’8” 44’ × 20’ 27’ × 27’ (38’ across) 85’3” × 46’ 984’ to 1312’ 10–13’ × 76–100’ 29’10”–33’1” × 6’–6’6” 119.7’ × 15’ min. 40’–45’ × 6’ 77’10” × 3’3” (lane)
7 (23’) 3.6 (11’8”) – 7.6 (25’) – 7 (23’) – – – – – –
7.5 (25’) 4.6 (15’1”) – 8.4 (27’5”) – – – – – – – –
Boxing Cricket (six-a-side) Curling Cycling (track length) Fencing Football (soccer) five-a-side Futsal Go-kart Gymnastics Handball High jump (pit) Hockey Ice hockey/ice skating Jai alai Judo Karate Kendo Korfball Lacrosse (men’s) Lacrosse (women’s) Netball Pool Pole vault (pit) Rackets Rowing (tank) Small-bore pistol shooting Small-bore rifle shooting Snooker and billiards Squash: hardball Squash: softball Squash: doubles Swingball and tetherball Table tennis Tchouk-ball Tennis Trampolining Triple jump (from take-off) Volleyball Volleyball: beach (indoor) Weight training Wrestling
6.1 × 6.1 29.12–33.12 × 7.32–8 44 × 4.3–4.75 133 to 500 14 × 2 25–50 × 16.5–35 25–31 × 15–16 30.5 × 30.5 min 32–36 × 22.5–26 40 × 20 3 × 4.3 40 × 20 61 × 26 54 × 15.24 16 × 16 8×8 11 × 10 31–40 × 16–20 46–48 × 18–24 29–42 × 15–21 30.5 × 15.2 2.7 × 1.4 3.7 × 4.3 9.14 × 18.28 13–18 approx 25 × 6.4 25 × 4.2 3.7 × 1.9 9.7 × 5.6 9.7 × 6.4 13.7 × 7.6 6 diameter 7–14 × 5–7 20–40 × 15–20 23.8 × 8.2 5.2 × 3 21 (min) × 2.75 18 × 9 16 × 8 minimum 4 × 3 or more 12 × 12
20’ × 20’ 95’6”–109’ × 24’–26’2” 146’ × 14’2” –15’7” 436’ to 1640’ 46’ × 6’6” 82–164’ × 54’1”–114’10” 82’–101’7” × 49’–52’2” 100’ × 100’ min 105’–118’1” × 73’8”–85’3” 131’2” × 65’6” 10’ × 14’ 131’2” × 65’6” 200’ × 85’3” 176’ × 50’ 52’2” × 52’2” 26’1” × 26’1” 36’ × 32’9” 101’7”–131’2” × 52’4”–65’7” 150’11”–157’6” × 59’1”–78’9” 95’2”–137’10” × 49’3”–68’11” 100’ × 50’ 8’9” × 4’4” 12’ × 14’ (min) 30’ × 60’ 42’8” × 59’1” 82’ × 21’ 82’ × 13’ 8” 12’ × 6’ 32’ × 18’5” 32’ × 21’ 45’ × 25’ 20’ diameter 22’9”–45’9” × 16’4”–22’9” 65’7”–131’2” × 49’–65’7” 78’ × 27’ 17’ × 10’ 68’10” (min) × 9’ 59’ × 29’6” 52’4” × 26’1” minimum 13’ × 10’ or more 39’4” × 39’4”
7 (23’9”) 4.5 (14.8’) – – – – – – 6.7 (22’) 7.6 (24’9”) – 7.6 (25’) – 12.2 (40’) 7 (23’) 7 (23’) 7 (23’) 7 (23’) – – 7 (23’) – – 9.14 (30’) 9 (29’6”) 3.6 (11’8”) 3.6 (11’8”) – 5.49 (18’) 5.4 (17’7”) 5.49 (18’) 3 (pole) 2.7 (8’8”) 15 (49’2”) 9 (29’)* 6.7 (22’) – 7 (23’) 7 (23’) 3.5 (11’6”) 7 (23’9”)
– 5 (16’5”) – – – – – – 7.6 (25’) 9 (29’6”) – – – – 7.5 (25’) 7.5 (25’) 7.5 (25’) 9 (29’6”) – – 7.6 (25’) – – – – 4.6 (15’1”) 4.6 (15’1”) – 5.49 (18’) 5.7 (18’7”) 5.49 (18’) 10 (pole) 4 (13’1”) 20 (65’7”) 10.67 (35’)* 9.1 (29’8”) – 9.1 (29’8”) – – –
Indoor sport
* Tennis court: height 9m (29’) at net (club) and 10.67m (35’) at net (championship); 5.75m (18’10”) at baseline; 4m (13’1”) minimum at back. Note: the table is a simplification so there are inconsistencies and omissions, e.g. in some cases playing areas only are quoted and in some cases playing areas plus mandatory run-off areas are quoted. For cue sports the critical issue of the height of the lighting over the table is not addressed. The References section at the end of the book includes sources of detail on sports playing areas.
6
sports
halls
Towards enclosure
Interestingly, in the 1920s, Johnston would go on to photograph architecture, driven by a passion to document buildings and gardens which were falling into disrepair or were about to be redeveloped and lost. (Johnston was made an honorary member of the American Institute of Architects for her work in preserving old and endangered buildings.) What intrigues us about the Western High School photograph is that the girls of 1899 are enjoying a virtually identical sporting experience to that of the girls in the second photograph, taken in 2005, where All-Marine Telita Huffman (left) goes up high with Army’s Chelsea Bryant. Major developments in clothing and footwear have clearly taken place in the intervening 100 years and you may have spotted a significant difference in the two venues – Western High is of conventional construction and Warfield Gymnasium has an all-steel structure because it is on board Naval Base Ventura County, Port Hueneme, California. These two photographs demonstrate the universality and exhilaration of sport, which Kofi Annan articulates in the quotation in the prelim pages (see p. x). They also give an inkling of the importance of sports facilities and technologies to sports development, which is the theme of our book.
Most of the sports listed in Table 1.1 were conceived as outdoor sports. Badminton is now one of the world’s most popular indoor sports. The modern indoor game was launched in 1873 at Badminton House in Gloucestershire, home of the Duke of Beaufort, after having gained popularity as an upper-class, English country house amusement in the 1860s. The 19th century game derived from the 18th century games of poona (British India) and battledore and shuttlecock (England), but similar games were played in the ancient world in Greece, Egypt, India, China, Japan and Siam. The other principal indoor court sports are basketball and volleyball and these sports, amazingly, were invented within 16km (10 miles) of each other. Basketball, we have seen, was invented in Springfield, Massachusetts, in 1891, and volleyball (then known as Mintonette) was invented in Holyoke, Massachusetts, in 1895. There is a saying in the UK that ‘things happen in threes’ and it is interesting to note that, although squash in the USA is generally accepted to date from 1891 in Philadelphia, America’s first squash court was built by St Paul’s School at Concord, New Hampshire, in 1883. It is also interesting to note that Mintonette (volleyball) was so named because of its association with badminton, which was designed to be a game involving less physical contact than basketball and incorporated not only aspects of badminton and basketball but also elements of baseball, tennis and handball. (Mintonette became Volleyball when the ball was perceived to be ‘volleyed’ back and forth over the net.) Enclosing volumes for individual court sports has a much longer tradition than enclosing volumes for multifunctional sporting use. The King George VI Sports Hall at Lilleshall was built in 1955 and acclaimed as the first indoor sports hall in the UK. The first community sports hall in the UK was opened at Harlow, Essex, in 1964. School sports halls were integral to the UK school building programme of the 1960s and more than one-third of the programme’s expenditure was on consortium-based, industrialised school-building systems. This placed a large proportion of the new UK schools and their sports halls among the first nonindustrial buildings to express all the character and virtues of structural steel; a fact which was recognised internationally. The design of steel framed schools in the UK in the 1960s was on a par with the beautiful but austere works of Mies van der Rohe and his architectural school at the Illinois Institute of Technology.
Indoor sports facilities The authors define a sports hall as an enclosure capable of containing a designated indoor sport or permutation of indoor sports. The size of a sports hall will be arrived at by balancing the aspiration (for sports and users to be accommodated) with the budget. Because sport is a fast-growing and fast-changing business, designers of sports facilities have to consider flexibility in use and potential for future extendibility. Table 1.1 gives the playing areas of some popular indoor sports that the client may wish to accommodate. Heights quoted are clear heights. Although maximum clear heights may be specified by sports governing bodies, in practice they may usually be greater, determined by the need of principal height-critical sports hall activities (such as badminton, tennis and gymnastics).
7
1.3 Hillsborough Leisure Centre (1991)
Many of the world’s finest sports halls are the focal points of schools and colleges in North America. At Berkeley High School, California, sliding glass walls open between the sports hall and the student union to create a quality space capable of hosting community and school-wide events. At Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, the Ralph S O’Connor Recreation Center has a multi-use sports hall for basketball, volleyball and badminton with a 165m (541’4”), four-lane jogging track, 30ft (9.144m) climbing wall and four racquetball courts (two of which are convertible to squash courts) together with weight room, fitness centre and three multipurpose rooms. The National Intramural-Recreational Sports Association (NIRSA) recognises outstanding sports facilities in the USA through its annual awards scheme. Winners in recent years have included Western Washington University, Wade King Student Recreation Center, which has a three-court sports hall with elevated running track, multi-purpose activity court, locker rooms and multipurpose rooms for aerobics, martial arts, yoga and fencing. Today a typical ‘standard’ sized sports hall is approximately 33m (108’3”) long × 18m (59’) wide × 7.6m (24’11”) high (594m2/6387ft2) and can accommodate four badminton courts in parallel. Badminton courts have traditionally been used as a modular yardstick because of the popularity of the sport and its demanding functional requirements, which include lighting, roof
structure and height, background wall and roof colours (to aid shuttle visibility) and air velocity. A large sports hall would be considered to be in the order of 36.5m (119’9”) × 32m (105’) × 9.1m (29’10”) high (1168m2/12,574ft2).
Roof structure Sports halls are built in a wide variety of materials and configurations. Materials include structural steel, concrete, prestressed concrete, timber and membranes and cables (in lightweight structure solutions). Configurations include beams and trusses, space frames, stressed skins, rigid frames, folded plates, shells, arches, vaults and domes, cable-stayed structures and other types of lightweight structure. While arches and domes are appropriate for the hosting of stadium and arena-type events, a rectangular or square plan sports hall is likely to be more efficient for accommodating permutations of the rectangular and square plan playing areas listed in Table 1.1. A constant height, capable of accommodating planned activities with the greatest clearance requirements, will also optimise flexibility in use. The box-like, repetitious solution has led to the
8
sports
halls
Table 1.2 Steel grade cost and strength comparisons S355M
S460M
1000 tonnes
700 tonnes
660,000
610,000
1,100,000
875,000
Anti-corrosion treatment, US$
260,000
260,000
Construction cost, US$
175,000
175,000
219,500,000
192,000,000
Steel grade Quantity Materials cost, US$ Fabrication cost, US$
Total cost, US$ Saving in materials quantity
30%
Saving in total cost
14%
are widely used in the constructional steelwork industry. Their use reduces energy inputs and increases the value in service of each unit of output, placing these steel products at the forefront of global initiatives in sustainable building development. Unprecedented demand for sports and leisure centres coincided with the development of computerised analytical techniques in structural engineering design and the introduction by steel manufacturers of high yield strength structural steel sections. The conjunction of these three factors promoted a rapid growth of interest in the development of two-layer grid space frame systems for sports hall developments. These systems can transmit the forces resulting from roof dead weight and superimposed loading out of the roof structure, not in the usual single direction (normally along the shortest span) but in two directions. Because of this ability, such space frames can be used to create efficiently the types of wide-span roofs necessary to produce large column-free floor areas. Reducing or eliminating the need for intermediate building columns increases the flexibility and utility value of space within leisure centres. From the 1960s steel space frame roofs have been used to cover many physical activities requiring large areas (and often large associated volumes) of uninterrupted space. Alexander Graham Bell (1847–1922), the inventor of the telephone, experimented with space truss structures made of octahedral and tetrahedral units in the early years of the 20th century. The first commercially available space frame system was MERO, introduced in Germany in the 1940s. Subsequent systems included TM Truss (Japan), Abba Space (South Africa), Octetruss
1.4 Clydebank Leisure Centre (1994)
widespread use of structural steel for sports hall roof structures over the past 40 years. Such structures are workshop-prefabricated for bolting or welding together quickly on site. They offer not only the means of creating the requisite flexibility in use, but also inherent extendibility. The main factors affecting sports hall cost are shape, size and standard of finishes. Large halls cost more because they have greater height and wider spans, and use more construction material. Sometimes, the seemingly prohibitive costs of larger structures merit closer scrutiny. For example, high strength steels can be used to create wider spans. These steels derive from the development of micro-alloy theories in modern metallurgy, combined with advanced controlled-rolling practices in the steel industry. The benefits of using such steels can be dramatic. Let us take, as an example, an increase in yield strength from 355MPa to 460MPa (steel grades S355M and S460M as defined in European Structural Steel Standard EN10025:2004), see Table 1.2. In the above example, a weight saving of 30% and an overall cost saving of 14% are achieved by choosing the higher grade steel over the lower grade steel to perform the same function (current calculations suggest that material savings in the range 23.3–40% are achieved by specifying high strength steels as opposed to low alloy steels and carbon steels). Higher grade steels
9
sports
and
facilities
1.5 Sports Hall for Acrobats, Berlin (2007)
(USA), Triodetic (Canada), Tridirectionelle SDC, Tridimatic, Pyramitic, Unibat (France) and Space Deck (UK). More recently developed systems have included the Conder Harley System 80 and Space Deck ‘Multiframe’. These systems comprise specially developed joints used in combination with metal connectors. The NODUS system, using cast joints and structural hollow section connectors, was introduced in the UK in the 1970s. It was used to roof many sports and leisure facilities. The authors have chosen the NODUS joint as their demonstration space frame joint (Chapter 7) because one (JP) was once the NODUS Marketing Planner and the other (PC) used NODUS in his best-known
project, the redevelopment of London Bridge station. Because space frames have two-layer grids, lighting, heating and ventilation systems can readily and accessibly be supported within the roof depth. They have also been used very successfully with space partitioning systems to isolate different playing areas under the common ‘umbrella’.
10
sports
Walls
halls
No official sports flooring standards currently exist in North America. The German DIN series is the most widely used sports flooring standard in the USA (DIN V 18032-2, now superseded by EN 14904: 2006), see Chapter 16.
External wall claddings for sports halls may include colour-coated steel. Where profiled metal is used, it looks better when run horizontally. Cedarboard cladding is cheaper than metal cladding and requires no maintenance. External windows and door frames should be in powder-coated aluminium, galvanised steel, UPVC or hardwood. Internal wall surfaces should be flush and without projections or sharp corners. They must be capable of withstanding impact from building users’ bodies, sports equipment and projectiles. They must be able to support any sports hall equipment that may be installed at the outset or that could be introduced in the future (sports hall fittings include wall-mounted or ceilingmounted hinged basketball goals, roof-mounted spotting rig for gymnasts, tracked division netting, sockets with flush-fitted cover plates, pulley-mounted net bags and spotting rig ducts). Wall finishes should be matt, easily cleaned and non-abrasive to a height of at least 3m above the floor (above 3m a sound absorptive material capable of withstanding ball impact may be used). Higher standards of material and acoustic quality may be necessary if the facility is to perform wider amenity or assembly functions.
Heating and ventilating Heating and ventilating requirements vary according to activity and season. Winter temperatures of 13–22°C are suitable for most activities. Air renewal should be four times per hour with a performance of at least 50m3 per hour (comparatives are three changes per hour for a storeroom and 10–12 changes for changing and shower rooms). Sports halls may use warm air or radiant heating, or a combination of both. Warm air heaters are well-suited to low air change rates. Radiant heaters provide instant heat at the point of need, without having to raise the ambient temperature. This makes them suitable for localised heating or for overall heating in those parts of a sports centre with high ceilings or high ventilation rates. Ventilation openings such as windows, louvres, fans and mechanical inlets/outlets must be located in order to avoid draughts on sports participants and other building users.
Floors
Lighting
Commonly used flooring materials for sports halls include semisprung hardwood, PVC carpet with chipboard or plywood underlay, PVC with foam backing and rubbers or plastics in sheet form or laid in situ. Semi-sprung beech, beech veneer and various composition and synthetic surfaces meet impact and energy absorbing criteria defined in British Standard 7044 (Part 4). The choice will depend principally on the nature of the activities involved. For example, the surface must offer true and predictable bounce (joints will not be permissible if they affect playing performance – hardwood surfaces must be laid with support under all board joints). Surfaces should generally be non-slip, but the designer should beware because some sports, such as football and tennis, require a degree of ‘slide’. All floors should be wear-resistant and easy to maintain. Some will have to cater for localised heavy loading and the movement of heavy equipment across them. Floor colour should contrast with the walls and be of 40–50% reflectance value.
The New Buildings Institute has established some excellent fundamental approaches to achieving energy-effective sports hall design: • ‘Use daylight as a primary light source. There is ample evidence that daylight makes people happier, healthier and more productive. It’s also free and environmentally friendly. Diffuse skylights, monitors and north-facing clerestories are good choices. • Use light-reflective surfaces to maximize brightness perception while minimizing glare and energy use. In a good design, the building should generally be the light fixture. In other words, paint the ceiling and walls white. Use colour bands for school colours. • Select appropriate target light levels. High school facilities require higher light levels during competitive events than those of elementary or middle schools.
11
sports
and
facilities
1.6 Indoor triple jump
• Use luminaires with some uplight to provide some brightness on the ceiling. • Light the competition area to a higher level than the spectator areas. • Use occupancy sensors to ensure that lighting is not energized except when needed. • Provide manual bi-level switching capacity, at a minimum, in all areas. This is a requisite criterion in the USA to qualify for
energy-efficiency (Energy Policy Act 2005) tax deductions. This will also facilitate multiple uses within the space, ranging from basketball tournaments to the school sock hop. • Use automatic daylight harvesting controls that either switch some lighting off or continuously dim as daylight becomes available.’ (New Buildings Institute 2006)
12
sports
halls
Equipment storage
Back to square one
Planners and designers of sports halls should allow a minimum of 12.5% of the floor area for sports equipment storage. If the hall has to double up as a community resource, then the additional need to store furniture will significantly increase the proportion of the building that must be allocated to storage. Mats require a separate one-hour fire-rated storage enclosure, vented to the external air and equipped with a smoke detection system.
On 25 June 2008 we were chatting with our publisher, Fran Ford, about sporting derivations of phrases like ‘for love or money’. Fran said that the phrase ‘back to square one’ had a sporting derivation too. As we had thought it derived from board games like ‘snakes and ladders’ we were intrigued, especially as this is a phrase in common use in the construction industry. ‘Back to square one’ pre-dates the TV era, going back to early BBC radio commentaries. It refers to the division of a sports pitch into eight notional squares, which enabled radio commentators to convey more clearly to listeners the progress of the ball around the field of play. The Radio Times referred to the practice in an issue dated January 1927 and prints of the pitch diagram still exist. Sound recordings also survive, in which a second commentator calls out square numbers as the ball moves from square to square. There is, however, no surviving recording in which the phrase ‘back to square one’ is actually spoken, but we like to believe it was.
Upgrading existing sports halls The success of sports halls depends on their ability to successfully accommodate specific sports or permutations of sports. Where the current need is for a multifunctional facility, an existing sports hall may be considered inadequate. It may be possible to extend the length of an existing facility to increase its capacity, but it is not often possible to increase building width or height economically. Adding ancillary buildings to an inadequate principal building simply multiplies the number of inadequate buildings on site. Essentially, if existing facilities are too small, then they need to be replaced. In 2006 sportscotland published The National Audit of Scotland’s Sports Facilities, a review of 6000 facilities, which concluded that changing patterns of demand suggested facilities should be replaced rather than refurbished. Maintenance of the country’s stock of indoor sports facilities was calculated to be costing £78 million per annum.
1.7 Listeners’ plan for first live radio commentary on a football match
13
2.1 Jai Alai Hall, Havanna, Cuba (circa 1904)
Chapter 2
Squash courts This chapter is dedicated to Raju Chainani, the leading and irreplaceable squash journalist, who died suddenly in Mumbai on 31 August 2001, aged 49
Introduction
law court when he was, in fact, building a local squash court. A new squash court at Sumbawanga, Tanzania, lay unfinished until the colonial administration arrested a known criminal, who was also a mason, and set him to work on the plastering. The birth of squash in the USA is normally dated at 1891, when the Philadelphia Racquet Club built a court and instituted a championship. However, in the USA a harder rubber ball had been developed to cope with local low or rapidly dropping temperatures, and this was found to be better suited for use on a narrower 18½ft (5.6m) court. Squash played on the 18½ft wide court with a hard ball was the only form of squash played in the USA until the mid1980s, when growth of the sport internationally led to some 21ft courts being built in the USA and to the ‘international’ soft ball being used on both types of court.
The ancient and universal practice of hitting a ball with a closed fist, as in Fives, was developed by the Aztecs into the sport introduced by Hernan Cortés into Andalucía as pelota (ball), which became known by the Basques as jai alai (pronounced ‘high lie’). Jai alai spread subsequently to Mexico, Cuba and the USA, gaining a reputation as the fastest game in the world. Other variations of ‘handball’ had evolved by the mid-12th century in France into ‘le paume’ (the palm of the hand), which developed into jeu de paume, real tennis, royal tennis and – well – tennis. In the early 19th century a variation of racket sport was invented in the Fleet Prison, London, when the inmates – mainly debtors – began using their limited space to hit balls against the prison’s walls, of which there were many. This new game, rackets, found its way into the English public school system. Pupils at Harrow discovered that a punctured rackets ball ‘squashed’ on impact with the wall. The resulting ‘slow ball’ meant that the players had to run faster and harder to return the bouncing ball to the front wall, producing a more energetic game with a greater variety of shot-making opportunities. It is this further variation on rackets that led to the world’s first four ‘squash’ courts being built at Harrow School in 1864. The standard size of squash court was adopted from the dimensions of a beautiful 32ft (9.75m) × 21ft (6.4m) court built at the Bath Club, London, for Lord Desborough in the 1920s. England was, at that time, a perfect launching pad for squash since the British Empire provided the means for the new sport to spread around the globe, often in rather mysterious ways. In British East Africa in the 1930s, at Handeni in Tanzania, a colonial administrator gained authorisation to commission a new ‘court’, knowing that it would be assumed that the application was for a
2.2 San Diego Squash, Sorrento Mesa, California: Junior Squash Clinic (2007)
15
2.3 Yale University, New Haven: Payne Whitney Gymnasium – Brady Squash Center (2005)
Heating, ventilating and air-conditioning (HVAC)
Squash is an exceptional promoter of cardio-respiratory fitness, muscle endurance, strength and speed, flexibility and a low percentage of body fat. Heart rate rises in the first few minutes of play to 80–85% of maximum. The sport is today played in 140 countries by more than fifteen million people on more than 50,000 courts. The sport’s governing body, the World Squash Federation (WSF), has 118 national associations in membership.
Air-conditioning provides air circulation, cooling and dehumidification appropriate to playing squash, but whether air-conditioning or mechanical ventilation is used, HVAC equipment should be fitted flush so that there are no intrusions of fans, thermostats or ducts into the playing volume.
The court Court ceiling and lighting
The WSF publishes a specification which ‘defines recommended standards for Singles & Doubles Squash courts for the International Game of Squash; referred to in North America as “Softball” Squash’. The aims of the specification are:
The court ceiling should be made of an impact-resistant and soundabsorbent material to take the force of stray balls and to reduce reverberation. It should have a plain matt finish and be white or a light colour against which the players can sight the ball easily. All lighting should be flush with the ceiling and no part of any lighting fixture can be lower than 5.64m (18ft 6in) above court floor level. Shadows are unacceptable, so lights should be dispersed throughout the ceiling in order to illuminate all parts of the court equally. Many squash courts are lit by fluorescent tubes, which have a tendency to flicker. Other options include incandescent bulbs and metal halide lights.
• to ensure compatibility of recommended standards for courts from one country to another, and • to guide manufacturers, builders and designers as to suitable standards of squash court construction and design. The specification defines the basic characteristics of squash courts without reference to materials or methods of construction.
16
squash
The court floors
courts
by pulling on a rope hanging down just below the top of the rear wall.) The critical nature of squash wall construction was demonstrated in the refurbishment of the Royal Automobile Club in Pall Mall, London, which was completed between 2003 and 2004. The RAC Club had been designed by Mewès & Davies, following their design of the Ritz Hotel in Piccadilly. It was built in 1911 and is one of London’s first steel-framed buildings. The consulting engineers for the 2003–04 refurbishment, Faber Maunsell, were told that the squash court walls had been in need of constant repair due to cracking. They assumed that there was a problem with plaster and backing brickwork. What they found was that the building’s original engineer, Sven Bylander, whose firm would become Bylander Waddell, had designed the courts for fives, with brick walls faced in voided concrete and lined with teak. This wall design eliminated noise from the adjacent shooting gallery. At some point in the building’s history, the teak linings were removed to facilitate change in use of the courts from fives to squash. As a result the courts were being used for a purpose for which they had not been designed and, consequently, they were taken down and rebuilt (with the exception of one wall which English Heritage wished to retain in the reconstruction). It is interesting to note that teak court linings of the RAC Club’s original type probably derive from the use of teak-lined courts by British expatriate rackets and squash enthusiasts working in the timber trade in northern Thailand.
Floors must be hard, smooth, true, non-slip and able to absorb moisture. A lightly sprung timber floor is appropriate. It should be constructed of light-coloured wood of, or similar in hue to, English beech or Canadian rock maple. Boards should be tongueand-groove, in the maximum possible lengths, and laid parallel to the side walls (not transversely). Floors should be sanded but, ideally, not painted, varnished, oiled or polished (which can cause players to slip). They should be swept regularly using a V-mop, which has an impregnated cotton head that attracts dust and rubber particles from the squash balls. Rubber or other flexible material is used under the timber to give the floor the ‘spring’ or ‘give’. The playboard or ‘tin’, which extends across the bottom of the front wall, may be of metal or metal-faced plywood.
The court walls In squash, the court wall surface is crucial. It must be true, hard, smooth and plumb. It must be able to withstand impact and to absorb some condensation. Walls can be constructed in brick or concrete block, or in other solid and non-yielding material such as plastic or reinforced panels. The most common construction is brickwork, carefully bonded to white plaster that is finished with special squash court paint. The wall has to be able to cope with both ball and racket impacts. A squash ball may weigh only around 24g but it can reach speeds of up to 160km/h (99.4mph), imposing considerable force on the wall construction. The court back wall is preferably made of glass, with a door in the centre of the wall. Such glass is a special product and should be sourced from a recognised supplier. The back wall does not have to be in glass but this is preferred in order to enable spectators to watch the game. If the back wall is in plaster, then the door should be set flush with the plaster. Door handles and hinges should be recessed to eliminate protrusions. For match play there should be provision for a referee to stand above the centre of the back wall, with an unimpeded view of the court. (It is interesting to note that many early squash courts had no door – they were accessed, usually at the rear left hand corner, by a counter-weighted ladder pivoted at the top. Once on court, players pushed the ladder up, where it stayed because of the counterweight. After the match, the ladder was lowered
Glass walls The problem with squash as a sport was that, despite its player appeal, it had very limited spectator appeal. A reasonable crowd for a squash match was around 25–30 people. That changed completely and forever when, in 1977, the UK firm Prospec of Sheffield (now based in Rotherham) developed the world’s first squash court glass wall and installed it – under the name Ellis Pearson – at Sheffield’s Abbeydale Club. This innovation opened up the sport to spectators while retaining the existing levels of playability and safety. Prospec has since installed more than 30,000 Ellis Pearson glass walls around the world for squash, racketball and pelota (which in Europe is another ball and wall sport deriving from jeu de paume). Prospec went on to develop the world’s first all-glass tournament squash court, which had its inaugural use at the French
17
2.4 Grand Central Station, New York: Bear Stearns Tournament of Champions (2008)
Open in 1984. The design and construction materials of this court facilitate its erection almost anywhere. One of the most spectacular backdrops has been the pyramids at Giza, near Cairo, where a court was erected for the World Open in 1999. The first English Open squash tournament was held at the Crucible Theatre, Sheffield, from 13–17 August 2003. For this event the Prospec all-glass court provided an unimpeded view of the court, from all around the Crucible auditorium, while at the same time using colour-surface-treated glass and a coloured floor to create optimum playing conditions.
front of the Falaknuma Palace, Hyderabad, for the final rounds of the Qatar Airways Challenge (4–9 July 2006) on the Women’s International Squash Players Association (WISPA) World Tour. Some of the world’s top players were involved in testing the new floor at the ASB headquarters in Germany. The colour of the floor is determined by the colour of the surface under the glass, which creates an advertising opportunity for sponsors. In 2007 ASB launched – literally – the first all-glass court designed for use on modern cruise ships. This was installed on the uppermost deck of the cruise liner AIDAdiva belonging to AIDA Cruises of Germany, which operates passenger voyages in northern Europe, the Mediterranean and beyond. The court’s glass walls and double-layer, anti-skid, safety-glass floor are mounted on a sprung aluminium base using rubber bearing connections. This solution reduces stress on the players’ joints, while further demonstrating the ‘anytime, anywhere’ advantage that squash can have over other sports. In this case, the transparent enclosure enables passengers to exercise safely while still being part of the ocean-going sightseeing experience. The AIDAbella subsequently became the second of four AIDA line cruise ships to be fitted with an ASB All-Glass-Court. Squash at sea has, in itself, an intriguing history worthy of greater study. In 1912 the ill-fated Titanic had a squash court located below the bridge at G Deck (court floor) and F Deck (upper court/viewing gallery). The Queen Mary, as originally constructed in 1936, had a gymnasium and squash court on her Sun Deck, to the rear of the vessel. The Queen Mary ’s full-size court was sound-proofed from adjacent areas and designed to prevent vibration affecting the deck below. A skylight with diffused glass beneath was designed to eliminate the possibility of shadows on court. The spectators’ balcony had a bronze balustrade, sycamore wall panelling and walnut mouldings.
Convertible courts In 2004 McWil Courtwall announced the availability of a new type of glass-walled court with a movable side wall to allow both singles and doubles to be played on the same structure. This development was stimulated by demand from events such as the Commonwealth Games and Asian Games, which wanted to stage singles and doubles on the feature court on the same day. The participation of glass fabricator Glaverbel Hardmaas in this initiative helped to reduce development time to just six months.
Glass courts In 2006 Horst Balinsky, founder of the squash court construction company ASB, designed and developed an all-glass squash court floor. Its inaugural use was in an all-glass ASB court erected in
18
2.5 Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games: Scotstoun Stadium
Safe-screen
A panel floor system was developed for speed of erection. Floor panels run the length of the court, to avoid unacceptable lateral joints, and are fully sprung. The floor appears to be and performs as a conventional first-grade maple spanning floor (that can be supplied in a colour such as blue if required). A clear volume of 12.53m × 9.8m × 7.2m (41’ × 32.1’ × 23.6’) is required in which to erect a court measuring 10.73m × 7.38m × 6.9m (35.2’ × 24.2’ × 22.6’).
In 1977 BBC TV’s Tomorrow’s World programme featured in model form a transparent-walled squash court developed by the British consulting engineers Campbell, Reith Hill (CRH). In 1982 the partners of CRH decided to design, develop and own a prototype ‘Safe-Screen’ squash court, constructed using Perspex (ICI’s acrylic sheeting) which they believed would provide a preferable material to glass for demountable courts. This innovation paved the way for squash to become a ‘fishbowl’ event, with unique one-way viewing. Its use attracted record crowds for the British Open and World Masters tournaments in 1983. Continuous improvements in the Safe-Screen court included a transparent ‘tin’ and transparent ‘cutline’, introduced for the Patrick International Squash Festival in 1983, and the introduction of a yellow ball and blue floor for the Davies & Tate British Open in 1984. Essentially, the Safe-Screen court has four walls of transparent material unobstructed by the steelwork frames along each wall. At some venues, slender corner columns are required but at others it is possible to suspend the ceiling structure from the roof of the spectator hall, allowing all-round clear vision into the court. The opaque pattern of dots on the Perspex wall material (white dots inside and black dots outside) creates one-way vision, whereby the inside of the court is illuminated and the outside is relatively dark – spectators and TV cameras can see in, but players cannot see out. This combination, together with a uniformly illuminated ceiling and 2000 lux (186 foot-candles) lighting to the court, optimises playing conditions and television coverage. Court ventilation is via a perforated membrane located between the top of the court walls and the illuminated ceiling.
Mini squash Mini squash was introduced at the International Squash Rackets Federation (now World Squash Federation) Annual General Meeting in Helsinki in November 1991. It was developed in Australia and New Zealand to introduce the game to youngsters aged from four upwards. It is played with a coated foam ball one-and-a-half times the size of a standard squash ball. The racket is lighter and shorter than standard, with a large face and smallerdiameter grip. Mini squash can be played on a squash court and against any suitable indoor or outdoor wall. Demountable mini courts with clear plastic walls have also been developed for quick erection on flat surfaces.
Beach squash Beach squash is another variation on the ‘anytime, anywhere’ theme. A beach squash court can be erected on an area 10m ×
19
sports
and
facilities
7m, with the requisite 6.5m available height. This type of court is designed to enable it to be easily set up, dismantled and driven to new locations.
Brady Squash Center, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut In the early 1990s the leaders of amateur squash in the USA adopted international standards of play. US colleges and universities started building international courts for their intercollegiate programmes. The international game necessitated playing to new rules, with a softer ball, on a court wider by 2.5ft (0.762m) and with a tin higher by 2in (50.8mm). At Yale, the main squash facility at Payne Whitney, in the east wing of the fourth floor, had been built to US specifications and lacked space and amenities for spectators of the increasingly popular sport. Yale alumnus Theodore P Shen ’66 made a donation that enabled a Phase 1 renovation of six new international-standard courts, including one court with three glass walls. In 1997 President Richard C Levin called upon the Skillman Associates, a volunteer organisation of Yale squash, to help raise funds for Phase 2. Fundraising was led by Henry (Sam) Chauncey ’57 and Skillman Associates’ president, William T Ketcham Jr ’41, ’48 LL.B. Their fundraising efforts were completed when alumnus Nicholas F Brady ’52 announced a landmark $3million gift. Nicholas Brady had lettered in both tennis and squash during his undergraduate years and, as captain of the 1952 varsity squash team, had led Yale to a national championship. Mr Brady went on to receive an MBA from Harvard in 1954 and became Secretary of the US Treasury during both the Reagan and Bush Snr presidencies. The Brady Squash Center was designed by Ellerbe Becket of Washington DC, working with engineers Flack & Kurtz. Contractor Whiting Turner completed court demolition and reconstruction works by the autumn of 1999. The new squash centre has 15 international singles courts, all with glass back walls and viewing galleries. Three of the courts are exhibition courts. Two of these have three glass walls and the centrepiece of the development – Brady Court – has four glass walls. The first six of the new courts make up the Theodore Shen Wing. The development now includes new coaches’ offices and a team room with video viewing
2.6 Royal Tennis Court, Falkland Palace, Fife
facilities. It is one of the best squash court centres in the world. The refurbished facility was officially inaugurated at dedication ceremonies on 22 January 2000. On 18 March 2006, Brady Squash Center also became the permanent home of the newly launched US Squash Hall of Fame.
Squash Tournament of Champions, Grand Central Terminal, New York The Squash Tournament of Champions at Vanderbilt Hall, Grand Central Terminal, New York City, is an annual event that has been held for 14 years (interrupted only by the terminal’s renovation, 1996–98). The tournament was sponsored for five consecutive years, 2004–08, by Bear Stearns (which was sold to JP Morgan Chase in March 2008). In 2008 the Professional Squash Association Tour Super Series Silver event took place 10–16 January. This is the biggest squash spectator event in the world by virtue of its combination of reserved seating (for 500) and free public viewing
20
squash
courts
2.8 Manchester Tennis and Racquet Club
2.7 Real tennis: 19th century print
Historical note: real tennis The world’s oldest real tennis court still in use is the Falkland Palace Royal Tennis Court, Kingdom of Fife, which was built for King James of Scotland between 1539 and 1541. Masons W & A Allerdice were paid £70 for their construction work. Carpenters under Richard Stewart built the penthouses. James V had limited opportunity to use the new facility because he died, at Falkland Palace, in December 1542. The oldest enclosed real tennis court still in use is in Manchester. The Manchester Racquet Club opened in May 1876 in Miller Street, on the corner of Blackfriars Road. In the following year the London and North West Railway Company obtained a compulsory purchase order on the new club so that they could build the approach road to Exchange Station. The club formed a limited company, the Manchester Racquet and Tennis Courts Ltd, which built the present club in Blackfriars Road with a real tennis court, racquets court and skittle alley. The new club opened in 1880 and was let to the Manchester Tennis & Racquet Club in return for the net income of the club. In 1914 the shareholders sold the premises to the club for £3000 and the ownership was vested in trustees acting on behalf of the club (an arrangement which continues in 2009). A squash court was added to the facilities in 1926. The 1880 redbrick building, by George T Redmayne, has many original features, including its wooden skittles alley, wine cellar and workshop for the resident professional to make real tennis balls (a skill which originated in 16th-century France).
(by around 150,000 Grand Central commuters during terminal week). John Nimick, president of tournament promoter Event Engine, said, ‘Vanderbilt Hall is a spectacular physical setting and, equally importantly, provides the players with the rare opportunity to showcase their sport to the public spectators who pass through Grand Central Terminal’.
Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games Squash is one of 17 sports chosen for the Games, to be held between 23 July and 3 August 2014. Scotstoun Stadium, which regularly hosts athletics events, will be significantly modernised to host the squash and table tennis events. Scottish Squash, established in 1936, was a strong supporter of Glasgow’s Games bid, seeing success as the opportunity to create a planned and funded legacy which ensures increased and sustained participation in sport.
21
3.1 Western High School, Washington DC: boys’ physical education (circa 1899)
22
Chapter 3
Gymnasiums
Introduction
membership while retaining a high proportion of existing members. So the question is, ‘What can gyms do with their facilities to maintain public appeal?’. The answer may be that the industry needs to take on some of the ‘wider mantle’ of health and education adopted by the ancient Greeks.
The Latin and English word ‘gymnasium’ is a form of the Greek noun γυμναστήριο ‘gymnasion’, which derives from the Greek adjective γυμνόσ ‘gymnos’ (naked) and the related verb γυμνάζω ‘gymnazein’ (to do physical exercise). The ancient Greeks exercised and competed in athletics events naked. This is why ‘gymnasion’, which would logically have meant ‘place to be naked’, actually meant ‘place for physical exercise’. Because the Greeks appreciated the links between exercise, education and health, their gymnasiums developed into more than places for physical exercise. They became places where boys would do physical education and take instruction in morals and ethics. As the pupils completed their education, they used the gymnasium not only to maintain fitness but also to assemble for less structured intellectual and social pursuits. Philosophers would come to speak to the ready-made audiences – Plato lectured at the Academy in Athens and Aristotle spoke at the Lyceum. These world-famous centres of culture were actually gymnasiums. In the modern world, the gymnasium reverted to its principal role of fitness venue. Fitness is big business. It is a $14.8 billion industry in the USA, where 39.4 million people are health club members. However, the club membership drop-out rate is big too. If, like the authors, you’re a member of a UK gym, then you’ll know that club membership peaks and facilities are used most during January, coinciding with New Year resolutions to ‘get fit’ or ‘lose weight’. As the daylight hours increase, outdoor activities begin to compete and gym usage tapers off. In the USA the dropout rate at fitness venues is around 30%. Club membership dropout is not a critical issue because the industry is growing, but it would be better still if the industry could continue growing gym
3.2 Western High School, Washington DC: girls’ physical education (circa 1899)
23
3.3 Lodge Park Sports Centre, Corby: multigym (l–r) Rob Purdie, Helen Dibble, John Pascoe (1977)
Gymnasium enclosure
loads only are resisted. For example, with a single leaf of 100mm (4in) the column spacing cannot be greater than 40 × 0.10m = 4m (40 × 4in = 160in = 13.3ft). The wall leaves must be securely tied to the columns. For further information see BS 5628-1, DD140, BS EN 845-1 and authors such as Kicklighter on modern masonry. Sports building roofs and floors are incorporated in the content of Chapters 15 and 16. The gymnasium designer will be particularly interested in using daylight as a primary light source because daylight is natural, preferred by people, cost-free and environmentally friendly. These positive aspects promote the use of gymnasium roof designs which incorporate – if feasible – skylights, monitors or north-facing clerestories. Regarding floors, designers have a vast selection of specific ‘gymnasium floor covers’ (recommended search engine keywords) to choose from for new-build and refurbishment projects, which come in different materials, textures, shapes and edge types (e.g. butting or interlocking).
The modern gymnasium is a building enclosure designed to protect exercisers and equipment against the weather. Whatever happens in any building, whether due to static or dynamic force actions (including an estimate for furniture and equipment), a static, uniformly distributed load is taken over the whole floor area within the perimeter walls. Gymnasiums have a higher uniformly distributed load (UDL) than many other types of building, typically 5kN/m2 (0.1kip/ft2) compared with 3kN/m2 (0.06kip/ft2) for a classroom and 1.5kN/m2 (0.03kip/ft2) for a house. Structural steel is widely used for creating the common form of gymnasium building frame. Such structures are ‘braced’ or ‘framed’ boxes, with the columns designed for wind loading. The cladding or walling may span either horizontally, giving a uniform loading, or vertically onto a purlin or beam, which gives point loading to the column. The leaves of a brick wall can easily be built around the steel frame in a variety of positions. Brick walls may also determine the column spacing because the slenderness ratio (SR) of a wall is limited to 40, where wind
24
3.4 Harborough Leisure Centre (2008)
Gymnasium space
humidity, by physiological influences such as disease and debility, and by psychological influences such as anxiety. The more people exercise, the better their bodies cope with the heat, but it is clear that what will be a comfortable environment for one gym user will be uncomfortable for another. Some new commercial office buildings offer individual members of staff the facility to control their own microclimates from their workstations. Achieving this is a much greater challenge in the gymnasium, where building users make multiple location changes between very different machines operating in very different ways. Air within buildings is generally at least seven times more polluted than air outside buildings, so there is plenty of scope for getting the basics right in the gymnasium environment. Airflow velocities and patterns, air quality, humidity control, thermal comfort, ventilation and energy-efficiency are covered in Chapter 17
In a gymnasium people of different genders, ages and levels of fitness are working out on different types of equipment at different intensities over different durations of time. These variables alone would make the gymnasium a challenge in terms of environmental control. But the situation is even more complex than it at first appears. For example, sweating is an essential part of the temperature regulatory system in humans and sweat glands are everywhere on the body except on moist surfaces such as the lips. Older people sweat less than younger people, partly because changes to the central nervous system reduce its sensitivity to temperature fluctuations and partly because sweat glands diminish in number as the circulation to the skin deteriorates and the skin loses elasticity. There are also racial variations in how much people sweat and the number of sweat glands they have. Those who have evolved from a northern European climate have about 550 sweat glands per square centimetre of finger skin; Indians have about 740 and Africans 950. The amount of sweating is determined by external influences such as temperature and
25
3.5 Harborough Leisure Centre (2008)
Gymnasium layout
supported by masonry pilasters. The gymnasium roof consists of a 3in (76.1mm) exposed metal deck, which adds to the open ambience of this building. The gymnasium designer has created a gymnasium with the flexibility to accommodate court sports, thus making it even harder to distinguish between a gymnasium and a sports hall. Clear floor areas maximise the flexibility in use of a facility, but the gymnasium in a leisure centre can function around intermediate columns in ways that competition pools, basketball courts and squash courts cannot. This, of course, increases the chances that the gym will be planned into an area of the building where intermediate columns are located. When this happens, it should be seen as an opportunity rather than a constraint. Electrical conduit can be fixed to the intermediate column, a simple way of keeping wiring away from the thoroughfares that people use to move from machine to machine. The faces of the intermediate column can also be used for health and safety purposes (such as displaying signage or siting fire extinguishers), in-gym entertainment (via wiring and fixings for LCD or plasma screens) and gymuser facilities (such as fixed paper towel dispensers). Before computers, a gym layout was produced by drawing the gymnasium floor area to scale on graph paper.
In the 1960s in the UK the school sports hall usually doubled as the school gym. Timber wall bars could be swung out at 90° and fixed to concealed, predetermined boltholes in the floor, and could also be used to help create obstacle courses. Portable timber gym equipment such as horses and balance rails could be brought out from an adjacent store room as required. This doubling up in use created confusion in the meaning of the terms ‘sports hall’ and ‘gymnasium’ which is still apparent in sports literature today. The authors apply the distinction, admittedly not a mutually exclusive distinction, that a gymnasium accommodates gym equipment but does not require the height or columnfree area that a sports hall needs to accommodate court sports such as basketball and badminton. Stand-alone gymnasium buildings have conventionally been designed using short-span beams and columns, but there is every reason to pursue a building design solution free of internal columns. The Calipatria Unified School District, California, wanted a 104ft (31.7m) × 96ft (29.3m) gymnasium. Simon Wong Engineering of San Diego created a column-free facility by spanning the building width using open-web, long-span steel trusses
26
Scale drawings of the base dimensions of each piece of gym equipment to be accommodated could then be positioned and re-positioned to arrive at the optimum equipment layout. This system still works in the same that it always did, but graphic representations of plan areas taken up by the different types of gym equipment can now be input into CAD and stored on CD-ROM to facilitate space planning. A wide variety of proprietary software is now available to create a scaled version of how a gym space will look. Some software allows the gym operator or supervisor to click onto a scaled graphic of a piece of gym equipment and drag it into the desired position on the representation of the gym floor, enabling the different categories of equipment such as cardio (cross trainer, exercise bike, rowing machine, stepping machine, treadmill), strength (bench, multigym) and accessories (dumbbell station, exercise ball pick-up point, mat) to be grouped most effectively. Such software can be used to locate or relocate existing equipment in a new, refurbished or existing facility, or to populate an empty or virtual gym as a basis for procurement (the electronic layout can be emailed to equipment suppliers as a basis for quotation).
3.6 Power Plate (2007)
Brunswick Corporation, founded in 1845, is a company famous for many leisure industry products (including the large, ornate, neo-classical saloon bars of the type seen in Western films). In the late 1970s, Life Fitness, a division of Brunswick, brought out as its first product the Lifecycle® exercise bike, the first-ever piece of electronic fitness equipment. More than 30 years later, the Life Fitness gym innovation is an application and user interface named VIVO. Gym users are given a personal identification number that they tap into the touch screen on the fitness equipment console. A customised workout, based on the user profile, is then wirelessly downloaded to the equipment. The VIVO Virtual Coaching System on each piece of resistance equipment displays the user’s workout schedule, real-time repetitions and weight-lift statistics, together with on-screen guidance on range and speed of motion. If required, a video training clip can be viewed. On completion of a workout, the results are displayed so that the exerciser can review progress. VIVO self-service kiosks are located within the gym to enable users to access information, update programmes and manage the fitness experience. Users can also log on to their personal VIVO web page from home or the workplace to review schedules, view progress against targets and make changes. Personal Digital Assistant (PDA) functionality and wireless connectivity enable gym staff, trainers, coaches and instructors to
Equipment By the 1970s gym equipment had evolved out of its timber era and into a bright new world of steel and chrome. The Nissen Poly-Gymn Conditioner had a robust frame, built-in transporter and 12 stations, including leg press, leg curl and thigh machine, abdominal conditioner, chest press and shoulder press. At that time there was no interactive communication between gym user and machine, so it was very difficult to determine whether routines were being carried out too fast or too slowly, and whether too much or too little weight was being pushed or pulled. It was crucial to know what you were doing with equipment like the Poly-Gymn, but too few people had sufficient knowledge at the time. Gym users would try to push or pull a bit more weight than their mates, regardless of their relative size, strength and fitness. Much of today’s equipment has preset and pulse-driven programs, and is capable of transmitting digital cues to regulate workouts according to professionally designed schedules. It may feature LED display feedback on, say, calorie count, speed, distance, time, calories burned and pulse.
27
3.7 Harborough Leisure Centre: firing up the Wii (2008)
add, edit or review the content of a workout programme with the user. VIVO can convey the news that a user arriving at a facility needs attention by triggering the instructor’s handheld PDA. The VIVO system can be retrofitted to Life Fitness weight resistance equipment that has already been installed. The retrofit, including networking, takes about 48 hours. Another success story in the use of gymnasium equipment is Curves. Gary and Diane Heavin introduced this fitness concept for women into USA in 1992. The idea was to use hydraulic resistance techniques to create a safe and effective 30-minute workout combining strength training and sustained cardiovascular activity. Importantly, this exercise training would take place in a comfortable and supportive environment. The Heavins developed plans for franchising the concept. The first Curves club opened in Paris, Texas, in 1995. There were 1000 clubs in the year 2000 and 9000 in 2005. By 2008 Curves had encouraged more than four million women to take up exercise at more than 10,000 locations in 44 countries. It had become the world’s biggest fitness franchise and the world’s tenth largest franchise company. My Gym similarly features fun and fitness in a controlled and safe gymnasium environment, but for a client base ranging in age from a few months up to 13. The physical early-learning and pregymnastics classes are associated with other activities such as birthday parties and camps. The aim is to inspire children to learn about health early in life and to use and build on that knowledge throughout their lives. By 2008, My Gym had more than 140 centres in 30 American states and in Asia.
These initiatives did not address the fitness needs of a teenage America that was becoming more inactive due to cuts in physical education programmes and the attractions of sedentary pursuits, such as playing video games and surfing the net. On Saturday 23 September 2006, the USA’s first teenagers-only Overtime gym opened at Mountain View, California. This gym appeals to teenagers’ interest in technology to encourage workouts on high-tech equipment such as virtual reality bikes that simulate the experience of racing around an apple orchard. To enter the gym, teenagers are identified by thumbprint using a biometric reader, which calls up an image of the member on a PC screen, then unlocks the door. Overtime was initially restricted to 13–18-year-olds but parents, who were formerly restricted to the lobby, can now work out with their teenaged sons and daughters. The above examples show how converts to the pursuit of fitness and well-being have been won from all sectors of society. To meet the new demands, and thereby aid the fitness processes, equipment manufacturers have extended their ranges of specialist machines, introducing new machines of both specialist and universal appeal. An example of the latter is the Power Plate®, a gentle-exercise machine that nevertheless gives a high-speed workout by using vibrations to contract and relax the body’s muscles from their normal state at a rate between once or twice a second to 30–50 times a second. The manufacturer claims that a 15-minute session on the vibrating platform offers the same benefits as an hour-long gym workout. In 2003 the Official Journal of the American College of Sports Medicine published the results
28
gymnasiums
The gymnasium in outer space
of a study at Leuven University, Belgium, which concluded that Power Plate ‘elicits involuntary muscle contraction and induces strength gain within a short period of time without much effort’. The study suggested that Power Plate has ‘great potential in a therapeutic context where it may enhance muscular performance in patients and the elderly, who are not attracted to, or who are not able to perform, standard exercise programs’. Dutch Olympic trainer, Guus van der Meer, developed the machine for the health and fitness sector in 1999. He drew on the invention of Russian scientists working with Russia’s highly successful Olympic athletes of the 1970s, the work of Vladimir Nazarov, whose vibration training prevented astronauts’ muscles and bones wasting while in space, and the experience of Russian ballet dancers who discovered that vibration could help to heal injuries by increasing muscle strength. What the machine does is to boost muscle power, improve circulation, strengthen bones (giving it special appeal to post-menopausal women), improve flexibility (giving it special appeal to injury-prone sports professionals) and break down fatty cells (reducing cellulite and improving mobility of tissue layers). What it does not do is confer any significant cardiovascular heart– lung benefits, which means that it is not, and never can be, the complete fitness solution. Power Plate is, however, said to be responsible for the finely-honed bodies of Madonna, Claudia Schiffer and Natalie Imbruglia. It was used by host nation Germany in its preparation for the 2006 Football World Cup and is used by English football league clubs, including Manchester United FC. The University of Houston, Clear Lake, is a primary research hub for NASA and has been testing the Power Plate to identify its potential applications within the US space programme.
Market research carried out in the USA and Japan showed that demand for space tourism renders it financially viable and that space tourists want to stay in orbit for several days or longer. Consequently, the need for ‘space hotels’ was established. The first building in space to be associated with the space hotel is likely to be the space gymnasium, where hotel guests can enjoy zero-gravity activities. Such a gymnasium might take the form of a spherical aluminium alloy shell receiving electric power, HVAC and ‘station-keeping’ services from the hotel via a flexible connection which isolates vibrations. The gymnasium thermal control system could incorporate passive design, using multi-layer insulation and heaters attached to the external surface, and active systems using cooling water, cold-plates, air-conditioning equipment and temperature sensors. The atmosphere in the gymnasium would be monitored and maintained primarily through atmospheric exchange with the central hotel system. Electric power for lighting, environmental sensors and control, emergency systems and miscellaneous equipment would be supplied from the hotel’s power system, generated from solar panels. If it were to be designed to operate autonomously in the event of an emergency, then solar panels would also be mounted on the outer surface of the gymnasium and interconnected to the power system.
29
4.1 Western High School, Washington DC (circa 1899)
Chapter 4
Dance studios
Introduction
be column-free. Dance studios have been built in a variety of shapes – including oval or circular on plan with curving walls. Such shapes are limiting. Also, for many dance activities, it is necessary to locate front. For these reasons a rectangular space is the most appropriate. Suitable dimensions for a dance studio are 15–17m long × 12–17m wide (approximately 50–56ft × 40–56ft). These figures put the optimum plan area at 180m2 (1937.5ft2) to 289m2 (3110.77ft2). The dimensions quoted are for a stand-alone dance studio or a dance studio incorporated within a sports and leisure building. A specialist dance centre will have more studios, usually of smaller plan area. The well-known San Francisco Dance Center, located on Market and Seventh Streets in the heart of San Francisco, has six studios with dimensions of:
Dance outperforms every other activity in this book in terms of diversification and change. It is at once joined up by its universality and fragmented by its geographies, cultures and histories. Its records go back further than anything else in the book – beyond the Tombs of the Pharaohs circa 3000bc to the Rock Shelters of Bhimbetka, Central India, circa 9000 bc (where dance is portrayed in Stone Age cave paintings). The different genres of dancing require different amounts of space. South Asian and African genres tend to be centred on one spot while ballet makes frequent use of travelling on the diagonal. Dance technique classes may be largely single spot, but with significant needs for unimpeded travel. Choreographic work has very diverse needs – there may be requirements to split into groups, so that more than one activity can go on simultaneously, so that individuals are able to stand back and have an outside view, or so one group can watch another. The reason for pointing out some of the different genres of dancing is that the space in which they take place must be capable of accommodating the possible permutations.
• 52ft (15.8m) × 36ft (11m) = 1872ft2 (173.8m²) for each of Studios 1, 2 and 5; • 46ft (14m) × 36ft (11m) = 1656ft2 (154m²) for each of Studios 3 and 6; • 46ft (14m) × 27ft (8.2m) = 1242ft2 (114.8m²) for Studio 4. A dance area of 9m × 9m (29½ft × 29½ft) is adequate for small practice groups. This smaller space has a plan area of 81m2 (871.88ft2). David Henshaw refers to an area of 10m × 9m (32.8ft × 29.5ft) as being sufficient for 18 adults to take part in a modern dance technique class and as providing appropriate dimensions for choreographic work, without a feeling of being cramped. It should also be noted that in the UK ‘A’ Level Dance Examinations require an area 10m (32.8ft) × 10m (a dance space 10m × 7.5m (24.6ft) with 2.5m (8.2ft) additional depth for the examiner to sit back and take a wide view).
Dance studio space In terms of calculating dance studio capacity, a useful rule of thumb is that a minimum of 3m2 (30ft2) per participant is necessary for participants of primary school age and 5m2 (50ft2) for participants in the secondary and tertiary age range. But, to achieve flexibility and efficiency in use, the dance area needs to
31
4.2 Ballet Rambert, Chiswick, London (circa 1970)
Rambert Dance Company
the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation enabled the company to acquire its own headquarters and studio by converting the top floor of a reconstructed furniture warehouse at 94 Chiswick High Road. The dancers needed a greater storey height than the existing 2.7m (8ft 10in). This problem was overcome by replacing the two low-pitched warehouse roofs. Structural steelwork was craned
Polish dance teacher Marie Rambert established the Rambert Dance Company in 1926. It was for many years an itinerant organisation, performing at halls and studios throughout the Greater London area. At the beginning of the 1970s a grant from
32
dance
into the top floor, using the fully extended jib (21.3m/70ft) and fly jib of a hydraulic mobile crane parked on the busy main road. Sixteen 4in × 4in (101.6 × 101.6) rolled hollow section (RHS) stanchions were installed and a new roof structure of three 11m (36ft) span RHS plane girders was lifted into position on them. In this way the roof height was increased to the 3.9m (12ft 9½in) required by the dancers. The Rambert Dance Company is today Britain’s flagship contemporary dance company. By 2008 it had 22 dancers, considered to be among the finest and most versatile in the world. But the floors of the Chiswick studio, which had not been purpose-built, had become unsafe for the dancers to work on and the rehearsal spaces were no longer large enough to replicate the stage areas on which the company had become used to performing. So the company is moving to new, purpose-built premises to meet its current needs and enable it to realise its future potential. The purpose of this anecdote is to demonstrate an activity in transition. Dance has developed from its roots in rented, makeshift premises through to reconstructed or remodelled venues and – finally – to the specialised facilities necessary to enable it to move forward. One of the photographs in this chapter was taken by Crispin Eurich (1935–1976) for Tubular Structures 19 (October 1971 issue). Crispin Eurich was an artist before he became a photographer. This rare image is a fitting tribute to both the photographer and to the late Marion Giordan, who was the first editor of Tubular Structures before becoming Consumer Affairs Advisor to the then European Economic Community. Marion was a great researcher and ‘seeker of the truth’ who knew all the best architectural photographers, commissioned some terrific images and changed people’s thinking about building for sports and leisure.
studios
be in hardwood, tongue-and-groove, laid with the grain running in one direction, non-slip, with a smooth finish and constructed for ease of maintenance (and that portable floors might be laid where both ballet and modern dance have to be accommodated). Tung-oil or linseed oil was considered to be an appropriate finish or, alternatively, several coats of wood sealer. The recommended method of cleaning was by damp mop only. Wide double doors were recommended, to accommodate people surging into and out of the room, and door sills had to be level with the floor to allow the movement of large equipment and accessories (such as a piano). Walls were to be thick (ideally soundproofed), smooth, easily maintained and capable of supporting ballet barres and mirrors. Incandescent light was preferred to fluorescent light and it was noted that rheostat lights serving as houselights during performances should be controlled from wall switches as well as from the light control board. The use of natural lighting was advocated, if practical, with a preference for north lighting to avoid direct sunlight. Commonsense but crucial advice on space planning included the need to locate sound equipment for performance and security, and to enable all participants to hear both music and instruction. The facility optimum temperature range was identified as being 65– 72°F (22– 26°C), with the thermostat located in the studio areas. Requirements were flagged up for adequate air circulation, consideration of the use of natural air, humidity kept at or below 95% and silent or close-to-silent heating and air circulation systems.
National Dance Teachers Association, UK, 2005 In the UK, the National Dance Teachers Association (NDTA) has been drafting guidelines for a dance tuition studio specification. The NDTA makes the correlation between floor requirement and number of participants and points out that: 10m × 9m (32.8ft × 29.5ft) is a typical size providing space for 18 pupils to take part in a dance class and allowing appropriate dimensions for choreographic work based on 5m2 (54ft2) per pupil; the recommended size in the Education School Premises Regulations is a surface area of 145m2 (1560ft2) for 30 pupils; the most effective teaching space is rectangular in shape, with a designated front. The floor surface is considered the most important aspect of dance
National Dance Association, USA, 1985 In North America in the early 1980s the National Dance Association drew up guidelines to assist in the development of modern dance and ballet facilities. The NDA recommended a minimum area of 100ft2/approx 10m2 per participant and a ceiling height of 16ft/4.88m (minimum) to 24ft/7.32m (for dance areas of more than 2400ft2/ approx. 240m2). It identified the need for air space between floor and foundation and the use of ‘floating’ and/or spring floors for resiliency. It noted that such floors should
33
sports
and
facilities
Dance studio mirrors
provision with a fully sprung (ideally) or semi-sprung floor being laid to enable pupils to step, jump and land safely. Studio height must be sufficient to provide a circulation of fresh air and the opportunity to jump and lift. A vestibule/storage space is considered necessary to:
Mirrors at least 6ft 6in (2m) high and as wide as reasonably possible should be mounted flush to the wall, approximately 1ft–1½ft (300–450mm) above the floor. Portable vertical mirrors of approximately 4ft (1.2m) × 6ft (1.8m) are also commercially available. Leaf-folded mirrors, which can be folded for protection or curtained off during performances, may be installed along two adjoining walls so that dance movement can be analysed from two directions. Modern alternatives to glass as the mirror material include boPET. Biaxially-oriented polyethylene terephthalate (boPET) is the super-reflective material used in the Hubble Space Telescope. It is better known in the USA and UK by the trade names Mylar and Melinex. The polyester film has high tensile strength, chemical and dimensional stability, transparency, gas and aroma barrier and electrical insulation properties. Metallised boPET plastic film gives a brighter, sharper reflection than plate glass and is a safer material because it cannot shatter.
• prevent pupils stepping onto the dance floor wearing inappropriate footwear; • offer a space for storing personal belongings and making footwear changes; • accommodate learning resources and props for dance; and • secure the information and communication technology (ICT) and music system. Accessible and quickly responsive control of ventilation and heating is considered essential: • the heating system should provide an even temperature throughout; • it is recommended that the studio temperature should not fall below 18.3°C (64.9°F); • operating temperature should be maintained around 21– 24°C (69.8–75.2°F); • extractor fans should be fitted to ensure adequate circulation of fresh air.
Ballet barres Ballet barres should be made of wood, typically oak, and be smooth in texture. If feasible, double barres should be considered: one at a height of 36in (0.914m) and one at 42in (1.067m), extending 6in (152.4mm) to 8in (203.2mm) from the wall. If possible, recessed floor sockets should be incorporated in the floor design so that barre supports can be screwed in and out to facilitate their relocation (e.g. towards and away from the mirror). Free-standing barres are available. These include models which have independent adjustment to allow dancers on opposite sides to set the equipment to their own preferred height between 31in (787.4mm) and 45in (1143mm). The minimum length of barre to accommodate one dancer is 5ft (1.524m).
Regarding interior decoration and lighting: • use light colours to create a feeling of space; • place the studio wall mirrors and wall-mounted ballet barres (normal height 36–38in/91.4–96.5cm) opposite the main teaching front; • use curtains to cover mirrored walls when mirrors are not in use; • fluorescent tubes will be adequate for general lighting; • place the whiteboard on the wall behind the normal teaching front, opposite the mirror wall; • place display boards around the studio but not behind the main teaching front; • ensure that adequate electrical points are available for audiovisual equipment (cassette, CD and minidisc players, large screen TV monitor, video recorder, digital camera, camcorder/ digital camcorder, CDi player).
Music The piano is still a popular and versatile instrument for accompanying dance, especially ballet and tap dance. Moving affects the tuning
34
dance
studios
4.3 Portable small stage audio amplifier entertainment system
of a piano so it should be placed in a permanent position, ideally alongside an internal wall to reduce temperature variations. It needs, of course, to be covered and locked. If it does have to be moved frequently then it should be located on a heavy-duty dolly. The studio must be able to accommodate professional sound systems. The San Francisco Dance Center has upright pianos together with sound systems incorporating playback equipment with pitch as well as volume control for cassettes and CDs, cable to connect to either MP3 players or computers, and cable connections for microphone or mini-mixers in Studios 3, 5 and 6.
England in 1999, the successful bid being one of only five to attract funding awards of more than £10 million in that year. The new building was completed in 2002 and is the world’s largest purpose-built centre for contemporary dance. It received immediate recognition in the RIBA Awards 2003 when it was named Building of the Year, winner of the Stirling Prize. Also, in 2003, it was named Royal Fine Art Commission/BSkyB Building of the Year – Dance Centre, and was Highly Commended in the British Construction Industry Awards. In 2004 it was the winner of a Civic Trust Award. Laban has 13 dance studios, a 300-seat theatre, purpose-built for contemporary dance, a video recording and editing suite, offices, study rooms and a dance health centre incorporating therapy and sports injury clinics, together with Pilates facilities to support the organisation’s work in dance science. There are also public spaces including a library and cafeteria. These diverse spaces are all treated as free-floating volumes encased in translucent skins within a single enclosing structure. The building features two glass-walled courtyards that drop from roof level to different depths. Circulation uses both ramps and spiral stairs. The in-situ concrete frame is complex, incorporating curved walls and ramps. Activities are based on two main levels: the dance theatre is in the centre of the building, on the first (ground) floor, while the dance studios are dispersed along corridors on the upper floor. Laban’s original church building at Laurie Grove, New Cross, had
Laban Centre, New Cross, London, 2002 Laban is one of Europe’s leading conservatoires for contemporary dance artist training. The school opened in 1953 and was named after the Hungarian dancer, choreographer and teacher Rudolph Laban (1879–1958). By 1995 its existing building, an extended church in New Cross, had become inadequate. Laban believed that the pre-eminence of its facilities could only be assured by relocating to a high-quality, purpose-built space. It worked with Swiss architects Herzog & de Meuron and UK engineer Whitbybird (now Ramboll Whitbybird) to create an exceptional building design that would help to attract funding assistance. The proposal was awarded £12.5 million of National Lottery funding by Arts Council
35
4.4–4.5 Laban, Deptford, London (2002)
housed the studio spaces, which were restricted in dance area, very reverberant, lacking in sound separation from adjacent areas and subject to noisy ventilation. On the plus side, the building was an exciting place to be. The designers wanted sound from the new studios to spill out into the circulation spaces, to carry across the feeling of vibrancy and community in the building, but they wanted to eliminate music or dance impacts on some new areas, such as the lecture theatre and library. The 300-seat theatre is used for dance performances accompanied by recorded music or musicians. Its acoustic design was driven by considerations of control and intimacy. The minimisation of intrusive noise during performances was considered essential to promote dramatic effect. This was achieved by use of a heavy concrete structure for the auditorium shell and a lownoise, underseat displacement ventilation system. Each of the 13 new studios was designed to have a different form, size, shape, light and music response. The studios all have irregular shapes, with one wall convex, curved or angled in plan (all therefore creating exceptions to this chapter’s guidelines on form and dimensions!). The new ceilings are exposed concrete slabs with a deeply-ribbed profile that, on the first floor, slopes to follow the roof profile. While these features scatter the sound
in the space, the non-parallel walls prevent the ‘flutter echoes’ that dance studios often suffer from. Design of the studio walls and floors was driven by considerations of cost-effectiveness and the fulfilment of as many functions as possible. The walls are deep, twin-walled plasterboard constructions, like those used to divide multi-screen cinemas, but also incorporating ventilation, storage and loads from mirrors and barres. Instead of using highload, high-cost floating concrete slabs for the floors, only the screeds were floated, to isolate the impacts from the dancers. A key intent of the building design was that all the dance studios should be naturally lit (for visual interest, quality of the lit environment and economy). Lighting studies on the building facade included computer analysis, scale model tests and a halfscale mock-up of a typical dance studio on site. The resultant lighting solution gives sufficient, but not excessive, daylight in the dance studios and eliminates glare from the incoming daylight. The selection of light-admitting materials took into consideration their relationship with the internal spaces, with the aim of achieving good balances of daylight and electric light, without the need for active shading elements. The building facade consists of transparent or translucent glass, with innovative, coloured polycarbonate cladding panels mounted in front of the glass to
36
protect against sun, glare and heat radiation. The shadows of the dancers inside the studios fall onto the matt glass surfaces of the interior walls to fascinating visual effect. Laban now trains some 400 professional dancers and choreographers from more than 30 countries. It developed the UK’s first BA (Hons) and MA dance degrees, and has more recently pioneered an MSc in dance science. The organisation’s increased presence in New Cross gives this deprived part of London a growing international profile and outlook. It has also begun an exciting process of local social and cultural regeneration. These benefits are the outcomes of an ambitious urban regeneration project, which created a building of great beauty on the toxic site of a disused waste-transfer station (for which extensive ground decontamination measures were carried out prior to construction commencing).
37
5.1 Great Bath, Mohenjo-daro
Chapter 5
Swimming pools
The ‘Great Bath’, Mohenjo-daro
Two wide staircases led down into the tank from the north and south, and small sockets at the edges of the stairs suggest that wooden planks or treads were installed. At the front of the stairs is a small ledge with brick edging that extends the full width of the pool (when the water was shallow, people descending the stairs could move along this ledge without stepping into the pool). The floor and walls of the tank were made watertight by means of their finely fitted bricks with sand-rubbed surfaces allowing for narrow and highly precise jointing, only 1–3mm (0.04–0.12in) wide. The floor bricks are laid on edge, and those of the walls have well-staggered joints. All of the brickwork appears to be laid in a gypsum mortar, in contrast to mud mortars used in house walls. The Bath walls have an incredibly flat and smooth surface, illustrative of a fine construction art and intended, one assumes, to help limit skin abrasions to frolicking bathers! To increase the integrity of the tank further, a thick layer of natural black bitumen was imported from open tar pits in what is now Baluchistan. This was placed or cast as a 10–30mm (0.4–1.2in) thick vertical membrane, set within the thickness of the walls and laid beneath the floor. Surrounding the walls of the Bath are soil-filled cellular brick structures which, presumably, helped to resist lateral forces when the tank was empty. Brick colonnades were discovered on the eastern, northern and southern edges of the tank. The preserved columns have stepped edges that may have held wooden screens or window frames. Two large doors led into the complex from the south and there is additional access from the north and east. A series of rooms is located along the eastern edge of the building.
The earliest known built pool is the ‘Great Bath’ structure at Mohenjo-daro (Mound of the Dead), discovered in 1925 in the south of what is now Pakistan. The city, part of the Indus civilisation, was founded between four and five thousand years ago on the flood plain of the mighty River Indus and had at least 35,000 residents. Mohenjo-daro was a planned city, built of fired brick and set on top of a vast mud-brick platform some 1km (approximately 1100 yards) square and 7m (23ft) high. The buildings and streets were laid out on a regular grid and built with walls often 1–2m (3.25–6.5ft) thick for thermal performance, given summer temperatures reaching 55°C (131°F). Each property consisted of one- and two-storey buildings with courtyards containing washing and lavatory facilities. When the Indus River changed its course around 3700 years ago, the civilisation declined and the city was abandoned. The fired brick was so good that the walls were looted to create the nearby railway embankment, which was constructed in the late 19th century. The Great Bath measures approximately 12m (39ft) × 7m (23ft) and has a maximum depth of 2.4m (7ft 10½in). It is thought that the pool was for washing, perhaps associated with ritual cleansing for a priest class, rather than being for general recreational swimming; after all, the river was nearby for fishing, normal washing activities and even swimming. The water for the bath, very salty because of the flood plain location, came from wells set in several nearby locations and formed from wedged-shaped fired bricks to distribute the surrounding earth forces. It is also possible that rainwater was harvested from roofs during the monsoon but there is no archaeological evidence for this. The Bath was emptied through a special underground culvert, and was famed for its arched stone roof.
39
5.2 Santa Cruz Natatorium, California (1908)
Indoor pools development
The sport of swimming received a massive fillip from its inclusion in the 1896 Olympics in Athens (100m, 500m and 1200m freestyle swimming events and a 100m competition for sailors). Women were first allowed to swim in the Olympics in 1912 (Stockholm). The cause of competitive swimming had been advanced by the establishment of the Amateur Swimming Association of Great Britain in 1880, with more than 300 members. The world swimming association ‘Fédération Internationale de Natation’ (FINA) was formed in 1908.
The Romans were masters of water engineering who built some 640km (approximately 400 miles) of aqueducts to supply water to their cities and towns. Because the lead supply pipes into each dwelling were taxed according to size, most households had only a basic supply. For washing, citizens used local baths, which became places of social interaction. Roman baths were based on the use of a furnace to heat the wter and a hypocaust (space under the floor) for carrying heat around the complex. Following their invasion of Britain in ad 43, the Romans advanced into the west of England. Near to the point at which they crossed the River Avon, they discovered a spring that brought more than a million litres (220,000 gallons) of hot water, at around 48°C (118.4°F), to the surface each day. Around this spring the Romans built the city of Bath, the site of one of the finest examples of a Roman baths complex in Europe. Although some Roman baths complexes were extensive – the emperor Diocletian built one the size of a soccer pitch – they were intended essentially for bathers who might want to swim rather than for swimmers who might want to bathe. The first indoor swimming pool in the UK was opened in London on 28 May 1742 as the ‘Bagnio’ at Lemon Street, Goodman’s Fields, Whitechapel. For a subscription of one guinea, a gentleman (no ladies allowed) could use a 43ft (13.1m) long, heated pool and could call on the services of ‘waiters’ for swimming instruction. The word ‘bagnio’, pronounced ‘ban’yō’ comes from the Italian ‘bagno’ (bath) which derives from ‘balneum’ (Latin) and ‘balaneion’ (Greek). Because ‘bagnio’ also once meant ‘bordello’, there has been speculation that additional services may have been on offer at Lemon Street – but the authors know of no hard evidence of this. One of the earliest indoor (municipal) swimming pools in North America opened on 21 June 1884 at the intersection of Twelfth Street and Wharton Street, Philadelphia. On the West Coast a very large pool – The Plunge at Santa Cruz – was built in 1907. This offered heated seawater as a welcome alternative to the chilly waters of Monterey Bay, and continued in service until 1963 (when it was converted into a miniature golf course).
Pool dimensions Swimming competition is based on races of multiples of 100m. Swimmers compete in lanes 2–2.5m wide and competition pools are usually of six, eight or ten lanes, with 500mm added to the side of the outside lanes. International standard competition pools are 50m × 21m (25m preferred), national and regional pools are 50m × 13m or 17m and county and club level competition pools can be 25m × 13m or 17m (an exception is a 33⅓m long variation in the UK). An Olympic swimming pool is a pool that meets FINA standards for Olympic Games and World Championship events. It must be 50m (164ft) in length by 25m (82ft) wide, divided into eight lanes of 2.5m (8.2ft) each, plus two areas of 2.5m (8.2ft) at each side of the pool. The water must be kept at 25–28°C (77–82.4°F). Depth must be at least 2m (6.5ft) and other regulations must be met, such as colour of lane rope and positioning of backstroke flags. For international and national competition, the pool must be of minimum depth 1.8m throughout. World records are only recognised when swum in 50m pools (because the shorter the pool, the faster the time for the same distance due to speed gains from pushing off the wall after each turn). Pools for regional or local competition usually slope from 0.9m to 1.8m or 2m. Water polo requires an area 30m × 20m for international and national competition, with 1.8m minimum water depth. For club competition a volume 20m × 8m × 1.2m deep is acceptable. Movable bulkheads have been used since the 1970s to create different course lengths (e.g. to convert a
40
swimming
pools
Approach to swimming pool design Pools can be sunk into the ground or built above ground, either partially or completely. The ground conditions will help to determine the most appropriate type of pool for the site and will influence choice of materials and construction method. Tanks can be built using in-situ reinforced concrete, reinforced gunite, precast concrete units, glass-reinforced plastic (GRP), steel or aluminium. Reinforced concrete is normally used for the bigger types of pool, which are the subject of this chapter. Permanent shuttering usually consists of hollow concrete blocks into which reinforcement and in-situ concrete are placed. Continuity between the base and walls of the pool has to be maintained by reinforcement. Concrete pools without shuttering can be formed by spraying concrete onto a reinforcing mesh, permitting greater flexibility in pool shape, although this technique is less suitable for large pools. Waterproofing from within and without the pool has to be considered, and concrete blockwork should be back-rendered to prevent damage from sulphate- or acid-bearing soils. Where the water-table is high then, unless the pressure is relieved, groundwater can cause an empty pool to lift. Land drainage measures should be implemented under the pool. In some cases it may be necessary to set hydrostatic relief valves in the floor of the pool. Pool tanks should be insulated using rigid polystyrene foams, expanded cellular glass or other suitable proprietary materials. Internal finishes available include rendering and paint, Marbelite plaster, flexible heavy-duty plastic vinyl liners, rigid GRP membranes and traditional glazed ceramic tiles or ceramic and glass mosaic. It is important that all inlets, outlets, skimmers, underwater lights and other pool features are considered at project outset, so that they can be incorporated as the pool is constructed. It may be difficult or impossible to accommodate them late in the schedule. Pool finishes include plastic liners, paints (chlorinated rubber or epoxy-resin based for durability), terrazzo or marble chip, fibreglass reinforced plastics and mosaics. Tiles are among the most durable finishes. Those used for lining pools are of a higher quality than the familiar decorative tile. Tiles should be bedded on a two-coat waterproof rendering, using only adhesives recommended by the manufacturer. Special adhesives are necessary for fixing tiles that have been frost-proofed by wax-based
5.3 National Recreation Centre, Crystal Palace: swimming pool (1990)
50m pool into a 25m or 25 yard race course). Such bulkheads are usually of fibreglass box girder or stainless steel truss construction, with PVC or fibreglass grating. A mechanically or hydraulically driven pool floor can be used to adjust the water depth to meet the needs of different sports and leisure functions. These types of movable floor have been popular in western Europe since the early 1970s. If diving facilities are required, then a separate diving pool should be provided: 10.5m × 10.0m × 3.5m deep for 1m and 3m springboards; 12.0m × 12.5m × 3.8m deep for springboards up to 5m; 12.5m × 15.0m × 4.5m deep for springboards up to 10m. Synchronised swimming events can be accommodated in the main pool, but are well suited to the diving pool, requiring a minimum volume of 12m × 12m × 3m deep (250m2 pool area preferred). Pool surrounds should be a minimum of 2m wide, non-slip and sloping away from the tank to drainage channels.
41
5.4 Colne Leisure Centre (1992)
impregnation. Manufacturers of tiles for swimming pool linings also produce special tiles to give non-slip surfaces, recessed steps and skimmer channels (together with accessories such as hand grips and freestanding steps, which must be resistant to corrosion and are often manufactured in stainless steel). If steps are not recessed as part of the tank design then they must be removable for competition.
Pool hall lighting
The pool hall
Mechanical equipment
Roofs over competition-standard swimming pools are usually designed in steel trusses, with the steelwork suitably finished to protect against corrosion due to condensation. Timber roofs are effective, provided that humidity is controlled and air circulation is well-engineered. Concrete roof structures are non-corrosive and durable but cost more than the steel and timber alternatives.
Well-managed pool water is odourless, tasteless, clean and clear. Public perception is an important consideration because most people would not want to swim in a pool that looks dirty, even if it were actually hygienic. Swimming pool water must be maintained with very low levels of bacteria and viruses to prevent the spread of diseases and pathogens between users. Strong oxidising agents are often used, especially simple chlorine compounds such as sodium
The lighting requirement depends on the standard of pool. It ranges from 300 lux at water level for local and regional recreation, training and competition to 500 lux for national competition and diving. The international (World and Olympic standard) requirement is greater than 1500 lux.
42
swimming
hypochlorite, calcium hypochlorite (‘cal hypo’), cyanurated chlorine compounds (‘stabilised’ chlorine) or chlorine gas is dissolved directly in water. Other disinfectants used include bromine compounds and ozone, generated on-site by passing an electrical discharge through oxygen or air. When any of these pool chemicals is used, it is necessary to keep the pH of the pool within the range 7.2 to 7.6. A lower pH causes bather discomfort, especially to the eyes. A higher pH reduces the sanitising power of the chlorine due to reduced oxidation-reduction potential (ORP), a factor measured in millivolts with a minimum 650mV considered adequate to achieve the required 1-second kill rate for microorganisms introduced into the water. ORP test cells are available as handheld instruments and as probes for mounting permanently in the pool circulation plumbing to control automatic chlorine feeders. Pool water has not only to be cleared and purified, but also to be heated. The American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and Air-Conditioning Engineers sets the desirable temperature for swimming pools at 27°C (80.6°F) but the optimum figure will vary, by as much as 5°C (9°F), depending on geographical region of the world and culture. Sizing of the system for temperature and flow rates depends on: • • • •
pools
be at the water surface level, where the maximum pollution is liable to occur. Surface skimmers should be provided at the rate of one per 40–50m2 of surface area. Surface skimming may also be achieved by connecting an outlet to a continuous channel around the perimeter of the pool. Some skimmer outlets have additional suction points for connection of a vacuum sweeper (as an alternative, an additional outlet can be connected to the strainer inlet by a gate valve). Over-sizing filtration units, in relation to the anticipated throughput, will extend operating life. Plastic pipes are generally preferred to metal pipes for water circulation. Metal fittings should ideally be in stainless steel, chromed brass or an equivalent material.
Waste heat recovery By the 1980s rising energy and other running costs had adversely affected swimming pools in the UK to the extent that many older local authority pools were being closed or threatened with closure. A major cause of high maintenance costs in swimming pools was attack on their structure, fabric and equipment by condensation that was highly acidic due to residual chlorine from the water purification process. Traditionally, swimming pool hall conditions had been controlled only on dry bulb temperature and pool water temperature. The humidity within the space was, however, related to the amount of evaporation from the pool surface and the quantity and condition of air being introduced. Air distribution systems tended to be at high level and inefficient. Then, in the early 1980s, a combination of modern energy technology and integrated design created the opportunity to achieve profitability for pool owners and improved internal environments for building users. The new philosophy for supply and extraction of pool air was to create a stream of warm dry air to sweep the structure and to exhaust as close to the source of evaporation as possible. Excess moisture removed in this way provided, via heat exchangers, a source of recovered heat that could be used to promote energy efficiency in the building as a whole. Its removal protected pool hall structure and fabric from surface and interstitial condensation. The importance of this innovation has increased because the trend is for warmer water temperatures and consequent warmer air temperatures (1°C > water temperature) resulting in increasing evaporation rates.
conduction through the pool walls; convection from the pool surface; radiation from the pool surface; and evaporation from the pool surface.
Essentially, the size and capacity of the equipment needed will increase with the size of the pool and the anticipated intensity of its use. For large pools, equipment may be duplicated to allow for breakdowns and maintenance, and to cater for exceptional loads. Pool hall boiler installations can be based on the use of any of the conventional heating fuels. The clearing, purification and heating processes require pool water circulation and this is achieved by the use of pumps. Water is drawn off the pool from outlets at high and low level. It is passed through a strainer to remove debris and large particles. Then the water is passed through a filter containing sand or diatomaceous (powdery siliceous) earth and a heating unit and chlorinator. At least two outlets should be provided for every pool. The low level outlet must be located at the lowest point of the pool, because it is also used for drainage, and the other outlets should
43
5.5 Manchester Aquatics Centre (2002)
Swimming pools became financially viable again through the use of new technologies in combination with established good construction practice:
glass rather than concrete and brick. The result is a new generation of light and airy pool halls which, unlike their often noisy and claustrophobic predecessors, are exhilarating to use.
• • • • •
Manchester Aquatics Centre
good ventilation; adequate insulation of walls; moisture-resistant acoustic ceilings; perforated bricks and tiles; and double glazing for window areas.
This 110m × 55m × 20m (above ground level) natatorium is the first in the UK to incorporate two 50m pools. It is believed to contain the world’s largest area of movable floors and booms. These can be reconfigured to form pools of varying sizes and depths, aimed at maximising flexibility in use and, hence, revenue. The diving boards include one of the world’s first 3m wide, 10m boards, to cater for synchronised diving events. The building form was developed to meet the requirements of the diving platforms and to control the acoustics. Floodlighting is incorporated and is located in order to avoid unwanted reflections, facilitate maintenance and meet the FINA requirements. Energy conservation measures include small-scale combined heat and power (CHP) and desiccant dryers. The roof structure spans from masonry-clad concrete towers on the south elevation, over an intermediate support at the rear
Condensation was brought under control (relative humidity in pool halls is now widely being maintained at the optimum of less than 60%). Wadebridge Leisure Centre, Cornwall, demonstrates the trend with a new air-handling unit installed in 2006 to recover heat from the air around its 25m pool and use it to heat the bathing water. This cuts carbon dioxide emission by at least 150 tonnes per annum, cuts running costs by £14,000 per annum and improves air quality for the facility’s customers and staff. Sports and leisure centres everywhere are seeking to achieve similar efficiencies in energy consumption. Waste heat recovery is good news in the battle against global warming. It has also afforded architects and engineers the means of designing pool halls of unprecedented beauty, by creating the freedom to design larger areas in steel and
44
swimming
pools
Beaurepaire Centre Pool, University of Melbourne, Australia
of the spectator seating, and then arches over the pool hall onto thrust blocks founded 5m below ground on the north side. Support to the main roof is by four pairs of main semi-arch ribs, crossbraced across its full width. The form of these ribs changes about the apex of the building from tapered plate girders on the visible north side to truss rafters above the acoustic ceiling. There are no movement joints within the main roof and concrete structures. Instead, thermal/shrinkage control joints are provided around all the one-piece concrete pool tanks, which are cast on slip membranes. All pool tanks were designed as water-retaining structures and were cast to a specific design sequence to avoid early shrinkage cracking. The profile of each pool tank is punctuated by recesses for the submersible booms, water supply trenches, windows and ladders. To permit the thermal and deflection movements of the semiarch shaped roof, the glazed gable walls are supported from aerofoil mullions restrained laterally at their head. The connection allows both vertical and horizontal movement, with the plane of the mullions stabilised by the circular hollow section (CHS) tie element which follows the roof profile. Under longitudinal thermal movements the glazed wall simply moves out of plumb. The mullions also provide support for the external cleaning walkways. The building design team decided to use the roof deck for acoustic absorption. By perforating the inner liner sheet, the mineral wool for thermal insulation could also be made to absorb sound. However, this solution reduced the structural strength of the liner sheet, which limited the amount of perforation that could be accommodated. The leisure, competition and diving pool areas are lit by 1000W metal halide and 400W SON floodlights mounted on a central overhead gantry, positioned to avoid specular reflection off the water from the lights. The main metal halide floodlights are fitted with toughened diffused glass lens units to control glare (a design consideration for backstroke swimmers). Each floodlight is mounted on a specially designed, purpose-made retractable arm bracket which allows easy lamp replacement from the gantry. Switching patterns can be controlled to pre-set levels to meet FINA requirements. To control glare from direct sunlight and daylight entering the pool hall, integral sealed window blinds are provided on the north, west and east facades. Each blind system is operated by protection rated (IP-rated) motorised control units linked to master controller stations located around the pool hall. The rooflights are on the north side of the roof and are opaque.
The content of this chapter may give the impression that the only really good pool is a really new pool. However, industries have grown up around meeting needs to repair, refurbish and restore existing facilities (see Chapter 29). In 2004 the Beaurepaire Centre Pool won the RAIA Lachlan Macquarie Award for Heritage, Australia’s top award for conservation architecture. Emeritus Professor Peter McIntyre chaired the RAIA Heritage Award Jury which commented: ‘As a fine and assured example of the so-called Postwar Melbourne regional style, the Beaurepaire Centre is of considerable historical, social and aesthetic/technical importance. Designed by Eggleston, MacDonald and Secomb in collaboration with Bill Irwin in 1954 for the University of Melbourne, it was completed in 1957. The project was part of the university’s 1950s building programme which resulted in a significant group of Modernist Functionalist buildings. Today it retains all its major elements, which demonstrate its original form and function as a swimming pool and gymnasium complex. The work by Allom Lovell and Associates spans conservation, reinstatement and adaptation. Contemporary uses and modern facilities are accommodated within the original fabric in a way which celebrates the original structure, materials and surfaces. This is no museum piece. The conservation team has cleverly inserted new services without dominating the existing surfaces. New floor finishes that are more appropriate to contemporary activity have been inserted in a way that has neither destroyed nor completely hidden the original. Contemporary building codes, including equity of access, have been managed by the insertion of new elements which look appropriate and hide nothing. The university and the architects are to be congratulated for choosing to conserve and adapt this building to current usage. This has not only retained a significant piece of architecture from a period which is often looked upon as being unworthy of retention, but also provides a very clear statement that the reuse of existing buildings is often more financially viable than their replacement. In this respect
45
5.6–5.7 Beijing 2008 Olympics: Water Cube visualisation (2007)
National Swimming Center, Beijing (the Water Cube)
there is the added benefit of reducing the energy input when recycling is undertaken instead of demolition and replacement. The Beaurepaire Centre project is the successful culmination of conservation ethics and practice. It takes its place as a model for society to rethink its attitude to conserving buildings of significance from our recent past.’
This building was designed to act like a greenhouse, absorbing solar radiation and avoiding heat loss. The double skin facade of bubbles is so well insulated that it has the potential to achieve an annual net heat gain. The principle is to capture the solar radiation in the area of the building where it is most needed – around the pool – and keep it there. The thermal mass of the concrete and the water absorbs and re-radiates this heat at night, when it is most required. To achieve the right balance, the facade
46
5.8 London 2012 Olympic Games: Aquatics Centre visualisation (2008)
World’s biggest swimming pool
of the building has three modes of operation to respond to the summer, winter and mid-season climates. The clear and translucent facades allow high levels of natural daylight, which removes the requirement to artificially light the pool during the day. A core feature in the design of the ethylene tetrafluoroethylene (ETFE) foil skin is the variable shading control system. By modifying the pressures in the cavity, the internal foils can be either ‘open’ or ‘closed’. This allows the light levels to be controlled to create a dappled effect, similar to the light under a tree or deep under water. The light can be controlled to fall only on areas that do not suffer from glaring reflections. Alternatively, the entire roof and wall can be turned ‘off’ to achieve optimal lighting conditions for television cameras. At night the building glows, highlighting the activities within.
The 1000m (3280ft) long pool at the holiday resort of San Alfonso del Mar, Algarrobo, Chile, has been the world’s biggest swimming pool since 2007. It is 8ha (17.6 acres) in surface area, the equivalent of 6000 domestic pools. Its volume is 250,000m³ (8,830,000ft³) and it contains 300,000,000 litres (66,000,000 gallons) of seawater. Revolutionary clear water lagoons are transparent to depths of 35m (115ft) at the pool’s ‘deep end’. A computer-controlled suction and filtration system is used to keep fresh seawater in permanent circulation, drawing it in from the ocean at one end and pumping it out at the other. The sun warms the water to 26°C (78.8°F).
47
6.1 St Nicholas Rink, New York City (1896)
Chapter 6
Ice rinks
Introduction
• paint the thin layer white, or pale blue for greater contrast, and mark out as appropriate for ice hockey or curling and to accommodate logos or other decoration; • spray on another thin layer of water; • build up the ice to a thickness of 2–3cm (0.8–1.2in) by repeated flows of water onto the surface.
The world’s first mechanically frozen ice rink was opened by John Gamgee in Chelsea, London, in January 1876. Two months later he established a bigger, 40ft (12.2m) × 24ft (7.3m), permanent ice rink at 379 King’s Road, Chelsea. This had a concrete surface overlain with earth, cow hair, timber planks and oval copper pipes. The pipes were covered with water and a solution containing glycerine, ether and peroxide of nitrogen was pumped through them (this being a process discovered by Gamgee during his research into methods of freezing meat for import into the UK from Australia and New Zealand). Gamgee operated the rink on a membership basis, appealing to wealthy people who had experienced open-air ice skating during winters in the Alps. He installed an orchestra gallery and decorated the walls with views of the Swiss Alps. Initial success encouraged Gamgee to open additional rinks at Rushholme, Manchester, and Charing Cross in London. The latter ‘Floating Glaciarium’ contained a much bigger rink measuring 115ft (35m) × 25ft (7.6m). But the process was expensive and the club members were put off by mists rising off the ice. All three of Gamgee’s rinks had closed by mid-1878 but the Southport Glaciarium, opened in 1879, perpetuated application of the invention. Subsequent developments used chilled fluid pumped through pipes within a bed of sand or slab of concrete to lower temperature so that a covering of water would freeze. The procedure for preparing the surfaces of modern rinks is:
After the ice has been used it can be resurfaced periodically using a machine called an ice resurfacer (often called a Zamboni, a reference to its invention in 1949 by Frank J Zamboni). This is a
• with the pipes cold, spray a thin layer of water on the sand or concrete to seal and level it (sand) or prevent marking (concrete);
6.2 Olympia Arena, Detroit, Michigan: new pipework installation (1967)
49
6.3–6.4 Oxford Ice Rink (1984)
Specialist ice skating facilities: Oxford Ice Rink
truck-like vehicle which drags a ‘conditioner’. It uses a very sharp blade to shave the surface off the ice and collects up the shavings. An ice-edger, a machine similar to a rotary lawnmower, is used to cut the edges of the ice rink that are beyond the range of the resurfacer. The Continuous Edging System (Conti-Edger) integrates edging into the general resurfacing process by mounting a secondary, pneumatically-controlled blade on the side of the resurfacer. Many ice resurfacers are fitted with a board brush, a rotary brush powered by a hydraulic motor, extended and retracted on the left side of the machine on a hydraulic arm. The brush sweeps accumulated bits of loose ice along the kick plates below the dasher boards of the rink into the conditioner. Board brushes reduce the need for edging the rink. Between ice rink events, and if the facility is to be used for alternative purposes, the ice surface may be covered with a heavily insulated floor or melted by heating the fluid in the pipes. Examples of dual-function venues include the renovated 13,800seat Boardwalk Hall in Atlantic City, New Jersey, which hosts ice spectaculars between non-ice events such as boxing matches and concerts (by musicians including rock performers Bruce Springsteen, Paul McCartney and Elton John). The Agganis Arena at Boston University, Massachusetts, has the principal function of supporting the university’s ice hockey and basketball programmes but is also expandable in spectator capacity to 7200 seats for interim concerts, conventions, trade shows and family entertainment. In the UK, conversion of the London Arena in 1998 included installation of an ice pad and refrigeration plant, 48 luxury high-level 10-seat VIP boxes, additional seating and a centre ice video scoreboard. This created a multi-purpose entertainment arena capable of hosting ice hockey and ice shows as well as the established attractions of concerts, conventions, boxing and wrestling.
Popular interest in ice skating in the UK came with the success of the ice skating partnership of Torvill and Dean and their unforgettable ‘Bolero’ routine in the early 1980s. This was different from the concurrent ‘Covett’ effect on participation in athletics because the UK already had athletics facilities – now those who wanted to emulate Torvill and Dean stimulated an unprecedented demand in the UK for ice skating facilities. Oxford City Council captured the mood of the time with Oxford Ice Rink. This was completed on site in September 1984, within a period of 10 months, using a management contract. It demonstrated that new types of building could be created economically to cater specifically for new directions in public demand for sports facilities. The building was constructed close to the centre of the city on a Victorian refuse tip that had been infilled and grassed over to create a recreational area. A simple portal or braced frame solution could have been adopted, but the client wanted not only to avoid the ‘warehouse’ feel that was characteristic of existing ice skating venues but also to acquire a landmark building. A distinctive nautical effect was achieved by using stayed steel masts and a central longitudinal steel spine beam. The geometry resulted in a large vertical load (380 tonnes) at each mast position and a smaller uplift at the anchor points. These loads are carried on straight shafted piles bored into the Oxford clay, whereas the perimeter columns, carrying only 20% of the roof load, are founded on shallow footings in the fill, providing the client with a particularly economic foundation solution. The roof is formed with a perforated profiled steel deck spanning between the roof beams, without purlins, and covered with thermal insulation and a single layer PVC waterproofing system. A transparent triple-
50
ice
rinks
6.5 Hanley Ice Rink, Telluride, Colorado: youth ice hockey (2006)
glazed wall, to the Oxpens Road frontage, advertises the ice hall activities and is spectacularly illuminated by disco lighting at night.
‘hurley on the ice’ being played at Windsor, Nova Scotia, around 1800. However, it was not until 1875 in Montreal that the first eye-witness account was recorded of two specific teams competing in a specific place, at a specific time, with a final score (2–1). The venue was the Victoria Rink, designed by Montreal architects Lawford and Nelson as a steel-arch-type structure 250ft (76m) long × 100ft (30.5m) wide, illuminated by mains gaslights and enclosing a 202ft (61.5m) × 80ft (24.4m) naturally frozen ice surface. Meanwhile, in the 1870s, St Paul’s School, Concord, in that extraordinary area of sporting innovation in Massachusetts and New Hampshire (see Chapter 1), was staking a claim as the birthplace of US ice hockey when it established nine hockey rinks on its Lower School Pond and began hosting matches against opponents including Harvard and Yale. Ongoing advances in ice-making technologies and refrigeration techniques, together with the growing use of structural steel for long-span structures, would eventually see ice events accommodated throughout the world, in all climates.
Ice hockey Games between teams striking an object with a curved stick date far back into antiquity – drawings on the tombs in the Valley of the Kings in Egypt depict such sports being played 4000 years ago. Skating on ice, using skates made of smoothed animal bones or wood, was widespread in Scandinavia more than 3000 years ago. The descendant sport of ice hockey has a similarly intriguing and mysterious background. Ice hockey is related to ‘bandy’, which is similar to association football (soccer) but played with sticks and a small ball on an outdoor sheet of ice. Bandy probably originated in the Fenlands of eastern England, where the shallow waters freeze over quickly in winter and form a relatively safe skating surface. The sport has now virtually died out in the UK. It is known that the court of Peter the Great played bandy on the frozen Neva River in Saint Petersburg in the early 1700s, leading to its popular adoption throughout the Russian Empire by the latter part of the 19th century. Today, bandy is played in Belarus, Canada, Estonia, Finland, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Latvia, Mongolia, the Netherlands, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the USA. In Russia, bandy is called xоккей с мячом (hockey with ball) and ice hockey is xоккей с шайбой (hockey with puck). In Finland, bandy is called jääpallo (ice ball) and ice hockey is jääkiekko (ice puck). European immigrants to the New World brought with them all sorts of hockey-like games, including bandy from England, shinty from Scotland and hurling from Ireland. The Canadian historian and author Thomas Chandler Haliburton (1796–1865) wrote of
Ice rink design The standard dimensions of a modern ice hockey rink are a minimum 56m (183.7ft) × 26m (85.3ft), with corners 7m (23ft) radius, and maximum 61m (200ft) × 30m (98.4ft), with corners 8.5m (27.9ft) radius – not dissimilar to the dimensions and area of Montreal’s Victoria Rink, which had opened in 1862. An ice hockey rink has to be surrounded by a solid 1–1.22m (3.25–4ft) high continuous fence (the boards), which has access and exit points for skaters and a 3m (9.8ft) wide gate for the resurfacing machine. Gates must open away from the ice surface. A circulation space of at least 1.2–1.5m (3.9–4.9ft) must be provided
51
sports
and
facilities
around the perimeter. Appropriate storage provision within the building enclosure has to be made for goalposts 1.22m high × 1.83m wide × 1m deep (4ft × 6ft × 3.25ft), the line-marking machine, resurfacing machine and any bleacher seating. Specific criteria to be taken into account in ice rink design include the possibility of heave due to alternate freezing and expansion of the soil under the rink (this may necessitate drainage and/or heating of the sub-soil). The facility’s walls and ceilings should be designed to reduce noise reverberation. A plant room approximately 11m (36ft) × 6m (20ft) × 3.7m (12ft) high will be needed. The temperature of the facility should be maintained at around 10–13°C (50–55.4°F), usually by heating/cooling combined with mechanical ventilation. Warm air must not be circulated directly above the ice. The designer should consider recycling heat generated by the refrigeration plant and rejected at the condenser. Rink lighting design should allow for variation between 300 lux (27.87 foot-candles) for recreational skaters to 500 lux (46.45 foot-candles) for ice hockey matches and other competitive events. Among the high-quality ice hockey venues constructed in recent years is the US$52 million TD Banknorth Sports Center at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut, which opened in January 2007. This is a dual facility with basketball (3570-seat) and ice hockey (3286-seat) ‘wings’ meeting at an entry court which has large glass walls offering spectacular views into the arenas. The curved arena roofs are supported by custom-made, three-dimensional tubular steel trusses which give the development its bird-like shape and provide armatures for lighting, sound equipment, scoreboards and banners.
6.6 Sun Gro Centre, Beausejour, Manitoba: curling club (2007)
Curling Curling is a sport of complex stone placement and shot selection played out on a rectangular sheet of ice by two teams, each comprising four players. The teams take turns at sliding heavy (maximum 44lb/19.96kg) polished granite stones, of up to 36in (0.9144m) circumference and 4.5in (11.43cm) height, along the ice to the target ‘house’, a 12ft (3.7m) wide set of concentric rings. The sport is believed to have been invented in late medieval Scotland. The first written reference to a contest using stones on ice comes from the records of Paisley Abbey, Renfrew, Scotland, in February 1541. For curling, the ice surface is ‘pebbled’ by allowing loose drops of cold water to fall onto the ice and freeze into rounded peaks. The Scottish verb ‘curr’ means ‘to make a rumbling sound’. In Scotland and Scottish-settled regions of the world (e.g. southern New Zealand) curling is still known as ‘the roaring game’ because of the sound the stone makes as it passes over the pebble. Friction between stone and pebble causes the stone to turn to the inside or outside, creating the ‘curl’. The amount of curl can change during a game as the pebble wears. The surface of the ice for curling is maintained at a temperature near 23°F (-5°C). Lighting is a crucial design criterion since areas in shadow could jeopardise the players’ assessment of the stones’ positions. The luminous uniformity coefficient must be very high for playing and, as appropriate, broadcasting. The recently inaugurated Pinerola Ice Rink, Italy, has 200 metal iodide spotlights (186 asymmetrical beam and 14 narrow beam), each rated at 1000W, to enhance its curling competition.
Sledge hockey Sledge hockey was developed in Norway in the 1960s to enable disabled people to compete in ice sports. It is played on a regulation ice surface with regulation nets. Competitors are strapped into low sleds (sledges), which are mounted on 10in (254mm) metal skates. They use short ice picks to move the sled and strike the puck. Sledge hockey is a full contact sport and, because ablebodied people can use the sleds, it offers a level playing field in every sense of the word.
52
ice
rinks
6.7 Lewis Ice Arena, Aspen, Colorado: National Disabled Veterans Winter Sports Clinic – curling (4 April 2007)
Utah 2002: speed skating
placing the air-handling units (AHUs) in the building’s four corners, outside the oval. There are no established performance design criteria for humidity levels required by athletes so humidity control was initially an issue of preventing condensation on the roof, frost on the ice surfaces and fogging in the arena. To achieve this, the dehumidification capability of the chilled water coils in the AHUs was used, combined with fresh-air control and building pressurisation. During commissioning, condensation appeared on the perimeter Perspex protective screens around the central hockey fields within the oval. Surfaces adjacent to the ice, with lower temperature than the roof, were especially prone to condensation when the external conditions experienced a spike in wet bulb temperature. There were also issues of restricting infiltration due to heavy traffic in and out of the building. A system of desiccant dehumidification was added to provide background humidity control to 45% RH (relative humidity) set point, a level that gave the operations staff sufficient time to investigate and monitor system response to rising internal humidity. The preferred temperature for skater comfort is 15.6°C (60°F) but racing conditions require that the space temperature be lowered to 10°C (50°F), with the ice held at -6.6°C (20.12°F). Maintaining 10°C in the racing zone had proved difficult in some other arenas, principally because of high roofs. In big roof spaces it is desirable to have heat gains rise under buoyancy and form warm upper layers, but in a speedskating arena, where a large floor is held at -6.6°C, it is often necessary to blow hot air to achieve the 10°C above the ice. This hot air must be forced down into the floor zone – against its natural tendency to rise – without softening the ice. The low
Speed skating is considered to be the fastest human-powered, non-mechanically-aided sport on earth. A highly specialised form of rink is used. This is the two-lane oval, similar to an athletics track. Standard speed skating tracks are 400m (437.4 yards) or 333.33m (364.5 yards) long. The curves have a radius of 25m (82ft) to 26m (85.3ft) in the inner lane and each lane is 3m (9.8ft) to 4m (13.1ft) wide. On such specialised tracks, skaters can achieve phenomenal speeds of up to 48kmh (30mph). There are few speed skating facilities in the world but, where they do exist, they demonstrate the benefits to the skaters of close collaboration between client, architect and sub-consultants. The Oquirrh Park Skating Rink is situated near Kearns, 22km southwest of downtown Salt Lake City, Utah. When the Salt Lake Organizing Committee (SLOC) for the 2002 Winter Olympics selected its speedskating site, it went for the highest altitude (1425m/4084ft) of any indoor skating oval in the world. Thin air is less resistant to skaters, while the dense, hard ice of high altitudes gives faster times. The challenges at Utah were to create the fastest sheet of ice in the world, provide a bright and pleasant training environment, set an example of energy efficiency, accomplish all of this within a limited budget and – not the least challenging – complete the facility a year before the Olympic Games were to begin. Meeting the aims suggested a utilitarian solution, but SLOC worked with architect GSBS and engineer Arup to create a signature building. The roof was designed as a suspended steel girder system, which reduced the enclosed air volume by 22% over the next best option, a steel truss roof system. The air-handling system is divided into four zones and the use of space is optimised by
53
sports
and
facilities
interior height afforded by Utah’s suspended steel girder system made conditioning the space more manageable. Initial plans for the ventilation outlet configuration envisaged motorised nozzle jet diffusers, automatically adjustable to take account of the supply air temperature, but the cost of this option proved prohibitive. The alternative, both innovative and economical, was to configure the nozzles at the required angle for heating, with high-level automatic relief ducts that open during cooling to bleed some of the cold air supply away from the supply jets. Cold draughts are thus avoided during peak cooling conditions. This system also allows the operators a degree of fine-tuning and control over the final system configuration, without having to manually adjust each of the 200 nozzle diffusers at ceiling level above the ice. To further discourage stratification, this system was combined with placing the AHU return air suction grilles at floor level to remove air from the racing zone. In tests before the Olympics, the systems maintained design conditions throughout the space with less than 1°F (0.56°C) variation at all locations in the racing zone and less than 2°F (1.11°C) variation between the racing zone and the ceiling condition. In March 2001, the Utah Olympic Oval was among the first 12 buildings to be given LEED™ certification for sustainable design. In the final speedskating event of the 2002 Winter Olympic Games at Utah, Germany’s Claudia Pechstein set her second world record, bringing the event’s aggregate to eight world records set in ten Olympic races.
6.8 Skatetown, Roseville, California: Ice Skating Instruction (2007)
Turin 2006
Figure skating
Turin’s indoor ice skating venues for the XXth Olympic Winter Games were the 8500 spectator capacity Oval Lingotto (speed skating), 4320 capacity Torino Esposiezioni and 12,350 capacity Palasport Olimpico (ice hockey) and the 10,000 capacity Torino Palavela (figure skating, short-track and speed skating). The Palavela is a striking, reinforced concrete ‘sail’ structure that was modified to host Olympic ice events and, following the Olympics, to serve as a multi-purpose facility capable of division into two parts. Post-Olympic events hosted have included temporary exhibitions and an interactive tour of Egypt, created by the Egyptian Museum Foundation. The Palasport Olimpico, completed in 2005, was designed as a multi-purpose indoor sports/concert arena – the biggest in Italy – which has hosted concerts by leading musicians, including Bruce Springsteen, Pearl Jam and Bob Dylan.
The International Skating Union (ISU), founded in 1892, regulates international figure skating judging and competitions. Competition skaters aim to perform the most difficult routine possible (technical merit) and present the routine in the best possible way (presentation). The United States Figure Skating Association (USFSA) is the governing body for amateur ice skating in the USA. Its test structure to measure skaters’ achievements comprises essentially: • freestyle – individual skating involving a required number and type of jumps, spins and other moves; • dance – a man and a woman performing a choreographed dance on ice, with the man ensuring that he does not lift the woman above his waist or throw her; and
54
6.9 Palavela, Turin: Olympic figure skating (2006)
(now known as the O2 Arena) accommodated a sell-out event hosting 17,500 fans for Saturday/Sunday evening back-to-back ice hockey matches between the Anaheim Ducks and the Los Angeles Kings. The teams competed on a 1200m2 (12,917ft²) purpose-built ice rink that was completed in five days using 21.75km (13.5 miles) of underfloor pipes to freeze the surface. Having been frozen, the 2cm (0.8in) thick ice was maintained at a constant temperature of -9°C (15.8°F). The Anaheim Ducks and Los Angeles Kings were competing for the Stanley Cup, the most prestigious ice hockey trophy, in the first National Hockey League (NHL) season opening match to take place in Europe. The Stanley Cup – also known as The Cup, The Holy Grail and Lord Stanley’s Mug – is the oldest sports trophy in North America. It was originally awarded to Canada’s top-ranking amateur ice hockey club and became the NHL championship trophy in 1926. The Cup was forged in Sheffield and purchased from a silversmith in Regent Street, London, by Lord Stanley in 1892. Lord Stanley had been appointed Governor General of Canada by Queen Victoria in 1888 and became hugely enthusiastic about ice hockey, which he first observed at Montreal’s 1889 Winter Carnival. One of his sons, Arthur, would go on to establish ice hockey in the UK.
• pairs – a man and a woman performing jumps, lifts and throws, with the man pushing the woman from him. Up until 1999 USFSA included in its test structure compulsory figures – with the individual skater following a trace on an area, a ‘patch’, of the ice in the form of an 8, or other complex figure. Other disciplines of figure skating include synchronised skating, moves in the field (field moves), fours, theatre on ice (ballet on ice), adagio skating, special figures and acrobatic skating (acrobatics on ice, extreme skating), which offers a spectacle demonstrating the utmost in aesthetic and physical excellence.
Recycling buildings Many existing buildings are adapted to host ice events and some existing buildings are converted to permanent ice rinks. The Millennium Dome on the Greenwich Peninsula, London, hosted the Millennium Experience exhibitions and arena events in the year 2000. It has subsequently been used for concerts and other events (including sporting events). In September 2007 the Dome
55
7.1 National Recreation Centre, Crystal Palace, London (2007)
Chapter 7
Integrated sports facilities
Introduction
the UK (such as the Swiss Cottage Sports Centre and Coventry Central Baths) and has influenced similarly high-quality sports architecture in North America and West Africa.
This chapter is about providing facilities for different sports within a single building or complex. In the UK the pioneering project was the National Recreation Centre at Crystal Palace, Sydenham Hill, South London. This is a campus-type, greenfield development incorporating athletics stadium, sports hall and athletes’ hostel tower. The 63m × 63m × 19m (207ft × 207ft × 62ft) high multi-functional sports hall, designed 1953–59 and built 1960– 64, accommodates swimming pools and dry sports. Swimming facilities include a 50m racing pool, diving pool with springboards and 5m, 7.5m and 10m platforms, 18.28m (60ft) teaching pool and 25m training pool. Sports facilities include squash, basketball, korfball, five-a-side and eleven-a-side football, volleyball, trampoline, karate, aerobics, weight training, netball, hockey, tennis, badminton, skiing, gymnastics and a climbing wall. Today Crystal Palace is one of six national centres operated for Sport England. It hosts Grand Prix Athletics every summer and other activities, training sessions and national and regional events throughout the year. The massive single roof is supported by a concrete A-frame which forms the spine of the building and allows views across the whole of the interior. Swimmers and dry sport participants can interact easily by crossing the aisle created by the A-frame. Innovative use of prestressed concrete made possible the slim and elegant beams forming the facades. The revolutionary flying roof, with underside clad in timber, adds a sculptural quality to the concrete framed building. The National Recreation Centre was rooted in the architecture of the 1950s, but has all of the social exuberance of the 1960s. It is the forerunner of other concrete-framed sports complexes in
The space age Europe’s first 400m 3M ‘Tartan’ synthetic track was installed at Crystal Palace in 1968. At that time David Bedford was revolutionising world distance running with his huge training mileages. On 13 July 1973 Bedford set a new World Record of 27:30.8 for the 10,000m on the Crystal Palace track. In tandem with these revolutionary events, a revolution was taking place in building design and construction as an outcome of contemporary advances in computing technology. Since about 1945 a new system of metal roof construction was being developed and became known under various names including three-dimensional frames, space frames, space decks and double-layer grids. The simplest such structure is of two-way intersecting lattice girders, making up a top and bottom layer interconnected by vertical and sloping members. Because the members of the girders are mainly subjected to axial forces (tension and compression) the stress in any member is uniform (and in a grid system compression members extend only from joint to joint, so buckling length is small). Because of this, double-layer grids make more efficient use of material. In the 1960s advances in computing stimulated the design and development of many new space frame systems. NODUS was one such space frame system, comprising cast joints and tubular steel connectors. It was invented by Hugh
57
on site – the erection team simply switched from high-level work on the halls to assembly of space frames at ground level, prior to craning into position. Similarly, rain can cause stoppages on site because people cannot walk on wet steel but, in this case, it was possible to switch to the ground level construction. All castings in the NODUS size 35 joint range selected for the NEC project could be handled by one man working alone. Specifically, it was found that one space frame could be assembled on site in four days by a team consisting of a charge-hand and four workers. The reason for describing NEC is that, apart from hosting exhibitions, it became a significant sporting venue. It has accommodated mass-participation events such as the Interplas Marathon 1981. Its international arena can be used in ice rink mode to host ice skating events. It was the proposed location in the City of Birmingham’s (unsuccessful) bid for the 1992 Olympic Games and has hosted many major sports-related events such as the BBC Sports Personality of the Year (December 2007). More significantly, the NEC demonstrated the advantages of using space frames in general, and NODUS in particular, to achieve the wide spans required for sports and leisure facilities.
7.2 NODUS space frame joint: exploded view (1975)
Walker and his colleagues at British Steel Corporation, developed with Professor Z S Makowski and his team at Surrey University and tested at Cowthwick Quarry near Corby, Northamptonshire. Initial applications were for small car showroom canopy structures in the Newcastle-upon-Tyne area. Then, astonishingly, NODUS was specified for the new National Exhibition Centre (NEC) at Birmingham, one of the biggest building projects ever undertaken in the UK. Steelwork erection of the NEC initial development of six halls (1, 2, 3, 3a, 4, 5), total area 72,400m² (779,300ft²), commenced on site in late 1973 and was completed in 1975. The NODUS space frame system was used for the 93 identical roof structures, each measuring 27.9m × 27.9m (91.5ft × 91.5ft). These contain 45,384 rectangular and circular steel hollow sections (488 members in each space frame). Birmingham International Arena, 10,125m² (108,985ft²), was subsequently built on site in 18 months. This has NODUS roof structures suspended from masts to create a clear span multi-purpose area 60m × 60m (197ft × 197ft). The use of steel space frames for the initial NEC development created the large uninterrupted spans appropriate to the exhibitions business, allowed for unimpeded future extensions in any direction and offered the capacity to carry extensive overhead services. The small size components used in the space frame construction enabled fast workshop production, easy transportation to site and quick erection. Because the space frames were identical, high wind conditions did not result in work stoppages
Sunderland Leisure Centre An example of the use of the space frame is Sunderland Leisure Centre, completed in 1976 to allow family groups as well as individuals to participate in a wide variety of sports and leisure activities. The 138m × 78m × 15m (453ft × 256ft × 49ft) high building has a plan area of more than a hectare (over 2.2 acres) – almost the equivalent of three soccer pitches. It accommodates: a two-court sports hall; multi-purpose sport area; eight squash courts; a free-form leisure pool; diving pool; two restaurants/cafés; crèche; sauna suite; bars; six-lane flat bowling hall; general purpose and club rooms; ice rink; changing, storage and general circulation areas; shop units; administrative and staff areas; exhibition and display areas; discotheque; plant and supplementary accommodation. The roof is a single massive 3m (9.8ft) deep space frame supported on twelve groups of four columns, resulting in major support spacing of 48m + 42m + 48m (157ft + 138ft + 157ft) longitudinally and 33m + 36m (108ft + 118ft) transversely. Columns were designed to double up as lifting sticks. The two-layer space frame roof has a 3m square bottom grid with a diagonal top layer grid connected mainly with NODUS size 45 joints. The roof design load (excluding wind) is
58
7.3 Harrow Sports Centre, London (1973)
1.7kN/m2 (0.035kip/ft²). Structural analysis of the frame was made on the basis of symmetry and for a quarter of the whole roof. Because of the large number of connecting members and joints involved, it was necessary to expand the computer program to such an extent that the frame analysis had to be handled by the large NASA computer in Houston, transmission being bounced off telecommunication satellites. The 800 tonne roof, containing more than 24km (15 miles) of rectangular hollow sections, was successfully lifted into position in October 1975, using the Lift Slab method. The frame was protected by factory blast-cleaning and 75 microns zinc spray, a wash primer of 13 microns and three coats of chlorinated rubber to 125 microns.
The multi-purpose main sports hall and the squash courts were built using rolled hollow sections (RHS) and the bowls hall was roofed using NODUS. The London Borough of Harrow’s Engineer’s Department chose NODUS for the bowls hall because there was a limit on the depth of roof structure and internal roof supports were not permitted. A square-on-diagonal grid was adopted with a top chord module of 2.4m (7.9ft) and a depth of 2m (6.6ft). Universal columns 4.5m (14.8ft) high, set at 4.8m (15.7ft) centres, were used to support the roof at bottom chord level. Although the grid has a cornice edge, secondary steelwork was used to generate a vertical fascia to suit the curtain walling and drainage requirements. The 55 tonne grid was assembled at ground level in two weeks and the lift, employing eight 15 tonne cranes, was carried out in two hours. No ‘fit’ problems were encountered.
Harrow Leisure Centre Herringthorpe Leisure Centre, Rotherham
HRH Princess Anne opened this building on Wednesday 11 June 1975 as a multi-purpose centre unique in north-west London for the range of activities that it offered. Wet sports include a main pool 33.3m × 16.7m (109ft × 55ft) and a learner pool 16.7m × 14.4m (55ft × 47ft). Both pools have water up to the level of a tiled surround – the ‘level deck’ system common in Europe and North America. Overlooking the pools are fixed accommodation for 120 spectators, the restaurant and a bar area. The dry sports facilities include: sports hall 38.4m × 33.6m (114.2ft × 110.2ft); weight-lifting training hall 16m × 10m (52.4ft × 32.8ft); small training hall (above) 16m × 10m; range for shooting, golf, archery and cricket; twelve squash courts, three with fixed spectator seating behind glazed rear walls; an external covered area 33.4m × 19.2m (109.6ft × 63ft) for five-a-side football, basketball, hockey, etc.; a bowls hall 43.2m × 43.2m (141.7ft × 141.7ft).
In this project two identical 38.4m × 32m (126ft × 105ft) grids, of square-on-square offset design with a Mansard edge, were used, one for the sports hall and one for the swimming pool. Each roof was assembled offset from the final grid position, to enable the columns to be erected prior to lifting. The swimming pool roof was assembled on scaffolding over the pre-constructed pool and propped to the concrete pool floor, where necessary, using Acrow props. The sports hall roof was assembled on a level concrete floor. Assembly times were 520 person-hours (0.42 personhours/m²) for the swimming pool and 300 person-hours (0.24 person-hours/m²) for the sports hall. Erection was carried out using
59
7.4–7.5 Heringthorpe Leisure Centre, Rotherham (1975)
two 25-tonne and two 40-tonne telescopic cranes. The 40-tonne cranes were necessary because the working radius was increased due to a social facility block extending along the side of the sports hall. The sports hall roof was lifted in three hours. Then, at the corner lifting position of the swimming pool roof adjacent to the social block, the crane jib was telescoped through the mansard edge of the grid of the already-erected sports hall roof to overcome the access difficulty at that point. This 32-tonne lift was then completed in 2½ hours.
they began to run out of time. Also, and this had ruled out many of the competition designs, they were looking for a temporary building because they wanted to restore Hyde Park to its original appearance after the Great Exhibition had taken place. Paxton proposed the world’s first ‘modular’ or ‘prefabricated’ public building and completed his original design within 10 days. The building measured 1848ft (536m) × 408ft (124m) and covered 772,784ft2 (71,794m2), the equivalent of 19 acres (7.6ha). The structure comprised 550 tons of wrought-iron, 3500 tons of castiron, 300,000 panes of glass covering 900,000ft2 (84,000m2), 202 miles (323km) of sash bars and 30 miles (48km) of gutters. Doubts were expressed from the outset and had to be taken seriously because the critics included Sir George Biddell Airy, the Astronomer Royal, and Richard Turner, who had constructed the Palm House at Kew Gardens. Strains on the ironwork were not considered to be a problem because the girders were designed to take several times their anticipated loading. What was seen to be a problem was resonance – the idea that a large crowd, moving regularly inside the building, could cause it to vibrate more and more until it collapsed. This had happened before in bridge structures (and the phenomenon would be encountered in the future by, for example, the designers of London’s Millennium Bridge in the year 2000). In the case of the Great Exhibition, an experiment was set up with a test construction on which 300 workmen walked backwards and forwards, regularly and irregularly, and then jumped simultaneously in the air. Then, to induce the most regular oscillations possible, the army’s Sappers and Miners (now the Royal Engineers) were called in to march ‘at the double’ over a platform erected between the girders. The maximum girder movement was one-
Back to the future Back in the 1850s cast-iron and modular construction were used to create a ‘crystal palace’ which would become one of the most influential buildings of the Victorian era. In terms of sports facilities, the influence of the crystal palace is clearly seen in space frames, in the UK’s Standardised Approach to Sports Halls (SASH) initiative of the 1980s and in the UK’s big, light, airy, steel and glass sports and leisure centres of the 1980s and 1990s. The Crystal Palace was designed by James Paxton for the Great Exhibition of 1851 in Hyde Park, London. Paxton was a gardener and landscape designer with experience of large greenhouse construction. He proposed a design for the building for the Great Exhibition after the planners had rejected 220 competition designs and failed to gain support for their own alternative. They were looking for a solution with strength, durability, simplicity of construction and economy – pretty much what planners of today are looking for. To these attributes they added speed of erection, as
60
i n t e g r at e d
sports
facilities
specified that ‘The principal building to be constructed in any development of the pink land consequent upon the provisions of this Act shall reflect the architectural style of the original Crystal Palace’. The Crystal Palace of 1851 was, at 71,794m2 (772,785ft²), remarkably similar in covered area to the initial National Exhibition Centre halls development of 1975 which was, at 72,400m² (779,300ft²), one of the major UK building projects of the 20th century. The big and technically challenging Sunderland Leisure Centre covers 15% the area of Crystal Palace. While Crystal Palace was exceptional, this chapter will demonstrate that, far from setting an unattainable standard, its design and construction positively informed sports facilities development in the UK.
Standardised Approach to Sports Halls (SASH) 7.6
The Sports Council was founded by the Labour Government in 1965. It became the intermediary between government and sport and, in 1972, began distributing the first government funds allocated specifically for the development of British sport and its facilities. Funds previously hoarded by cost-conscious local authorities were also suddenly released and spent – in anticipation of local government reorganisation – on sports and leisure centres, swimming pools and golf courses. In 1972 the UK had 27 sports centres. In 1980 there were 770 and the municipal leisure centre had become a focal point of towns and cities throughout the UK. New estimates indicated that by the early 1990s the UK could support a total of 3000 sports and leisure centres. The Sports Council targeted 800 additional facilities of one type or another by 1987, with 240 of the 800 being entirely new construction. To provide these buildings within the prevailing restricted national budget was a major challenge to politicians and the whole of the recreation management profession. The Sports Council response was to invest its research and development resources in the development of a standardised sports hall. The Council’s Technical Unit for Sport (TUS) comprised architects, engineers and quantity surveyors, who worked with local authorities in developing sports facilities. A particular collaboration, over Tamworth Sports Centre in Staffordshire,
Harborough Leisure Centre: swimming pool overlooked by gym treadmills (2008)
quarter of an inch (6.35mm). In further efforts to shake the structure Herr Reichardt, a well-known tenor, was asked to sing at one end of the building. Then a full orchestra was tried, and then the full orchestra with all the bass pipes of the organ groaning in discord. But no pane of glass moved or showed any response. Building work would proceed. Construction commenced in September 1850 and was completed in January 1851, ready for opening on May Day 1851. The Great Exhibition attracted 600,000 visitors in six weeks, which represented a huge success (the population of England in 1851 was 16.8 million compared with 60.9 million in 2007). After the event Hyde Park was restored and the crystal palace was dismantled and re-erected as the focal point of a 200 acre (80ha) Victorian theme park established at Sydenham Hill in South London, where it would give its name to the area. Crystal Palace was opened by Queen Victoria on 10 June 1854. It was ultimately destroyed by fire on the night of 30 November 1936. The timeless nature of the Crystal Palace is suggested by the Bromley London Borough Council (Crystal Palace) Act 1990 (c.xvii) which
61
7.7 Bitterne Leisure Centre, Southampton (1984)
became in many respects the prototype for what came to be known as the SASH Sports Centre Programme. SASH evolved following a national competition which attracted 122 entries and was won in 1982 by a Bovis-led team comprising Bovis Construction Ltd (Design and Construction Manager), Nicholas Grimshaw & Partners (Architect), Arup (Structural, Mechanical and Electrical Engineer) and Brian Clouston & Partners (Landscape Architect). The programme had two basic objectives – economy and speed of provision. Concomitant requirements were ease and speed of individual projects and completeness, in terms of fitting out and equipment. The SASH neighbourhood sports centre was designed to complement existing facilities, to fill a gap in local sports provision or serve a newly developing community. Each centre would accommodate the needs of a catchment population of between 15,000 and 25,000. The basic layout was a sports hall the size of four basketball courts and a fitness room, together with social and service facilities. To this could be added one or more swimming pools, squash courts, a separate multi-purpose hall, additional changing accommodation and more social areas. In October 1982 the Bovis team was commissioned for its first SASH sports hall, to be built at Eastbourne. The team was on site by March 1983 and the building was completed in December 1983. By that time another seven schemes were under construction. The average time for construction of a basic centre was set at 37 weeks. This imposed a discipline of efficiency and economic performance on every building element. Bovis and its design team developed a building fitting a modular grid because the programme constraints meant that many of the building components had to be manufactured and prefabricated off site. This was true not only of
the structure but also of the finishing elements. Products had to be readily available, easily constructed and durable, with low maintenance requirement. Steel was specified as the principal structural element and was used in many forms throughout the buildings. A simple pin-jointed steel frame system was selected for ease of fabrication, painting, transportation and erection. Stanchions were erected directly on to foundation pads, beams connected to columns with simple bolted end-plate details and conventional bracing was provided in the perimeter walls. The only mezzanine floor, providing the plant room, was formed using permanent Holorib steel decking with a concrete slab on top. The steel structure supporting this floor was clad in fireproof dry lining which was itself pre-clad in steel to provide a damage-resistant wearing finish. The interior load-bearing walls were designed in 140mm (5.5in) concrete blockwork and offered rigid support for the lightweight steel sections. In the main hall the roof was supported by three main beams. The introduction of circular holes in the webs gave a light and pleasing appearance when painted white (the Sports Council brief was for no natural light in the sports hall). Arup said that ‘such an opportunity to use a stressed skin roof deck was not to be missed’. Long span (8m, 26.2ft) steel decking was fixed directly to the top flange of the roof beams. This carried the lateral forces to the wall bracing and provided stability to the compression flange of the beams. The roof decking was perforated to permit the thermal insulation to perform the additional function of sound absorption. The roof deck finish was white throughout the sports centre, eliminating the need for a suspended ceiling. Grimshaw wanted a building which would be attractive and pleasing to approach. High tensile profiled steel cladding was
62
7.8 Bitterne Leisure Centre, Southampton (1984)
Dubai sports halls
used on all external walls, with circular perforations for the bright red steel porthole windows. The cladding was generally in metallic silver finish with two bands of red and blue. The main option in the external envelope was the choice between full-height cladding and the use of a 1m high brick plinth. A higher-cost alternative of a pre-insulated steel panel was available. A striking and original use of steelwork within the building was the use of red Nylon-coated sheet steel panels formed to provide four deep bulkheads which enclosed all the piped and electrical services at high level, through the toilet and changing areas to the showers. These epitomised the modular kit form of construction. They provided a ready-made facility for all final fixing of socket outlets, air-conditioning grilles, public address speakers and lights. Bovis, as team leader, coordinated and programmed the design work. They also developed a method of taking advantage of the modular/kit form of design to maximise economy and efficiency on site. The target time of 37 weeks for construction of a SASH centre was quickly bettered, with the average being brought down to 35 weeks and then 31 weeks (with an average 16-week lead-in). Structural steelwork usually commenced on site after eight weeks, at which stage the ground floor slab was ready to be cast. The fabricator delivered the steel to site ready painted, erected the steel frame inside one week and included temporary roof bracing prior to the roof skin being fixed. Once the frame was fully erected the roofing works commenced, overlapping with the start of the external cladding. This provided protection against inclement weather, eliminating interruptions to construction work within the structure. Buildings were usually watertight at or before 18 weeks.
The use of precision-manufactured structural steel was at the same time making feasible some of the world’s biggest-ever sports facilities. In the 1980s HH Sheikh Hamdan bin Rashid Al Maktoum, UAE Minister of Finance and Chairman of Dubai Municipality, granted a donation which enabled Dubai’s four principal football clubs each to receive an indoor sports centre designed to international standards. The four facilities are huge. Each is about three quarters the area of the UK’s National Sports Centre building at Crystal Palace. The architectural concept called for a column-free area of 62m × 48m (203ft × 157ft) containing a main court area 50m × 42m × 13m (164ft × 137ft × 42.6ft) clear height to cater for basketball, volleyball, handball, tennis, badminton, gymnastics, weightlifting, boxing, wrestling, bowling, squash and table tennis. Seating for 3000 spectators at each venue is provided mainly on terraces of fixed seating and by retractable bleacher seating. Four massive reinforced concrete shear walls were designed to support the main roof trusses. Each hall has two 110 tonne, 3.5m (11.5ft) deep main trusses, of hexagonal cross section, fabricated in sizes up to 300 × 300RHS (rectangular hollow sections) (11.8 × 11.8 in). This met the aesthetic requirements and enabled large air-conditioning ducts to be installed at the most energy-efficient locations. The main trusses span 48m between the shear walls and were designed using principles applicable to bridge structures, with particular attention being paid to provision for thermal movement and rotation at bearing points. Secondary tubular trusses, at 9m (29.5ft) centres, are of triangular section, 1.7m (5.6ft) deep. Main
63
sports
and
facilities
trusses were pre-assembled at ground level and lifted into position by a 500 tonne capacity hydraulic crane. At the time of construction, the roof steelwork erection was the biggest on-shore lift in the UAE and the completed roofs were the largest clear span structures in the Gulf area. The project was completed, within budget, to a 16-month programme.
sole break in the structural rhythm is at the forum, which is enclosed by a circular flat roof punctuated by a small glass dome). Circular hollow sections were chosen for the roof members because of their structural efficiency, elegant appearance and ease of jointing, painting and maintenance. The triangular crosssection of the trusses and the lateral and torsional rigidity of the tubes provided a stable structural element for the long spans without the need for additional bracing along the length of the main trusses. High grade steel was used to keep the size of the main boom members to the minimum, meeting a planning constraint of limited truss depth relative to the longest spans. In the ice rink/swimming pools area the two-storey high ridged mall frames support the main CHS triangulated roof trusses, which span a maximum 38m (124.7ft) to the curved perimeter on the north elevation. CHS curved edge trusses and a CHS ring beam complete the elevation and provide support for the gutter and lateral support to the masonry walls below. Here the main trusses are supported on CHS columns with specially welded plate column heads set clear of the wall (because the pitched roof intersects a curved edge, the column heights and column head geometries vary). A combination of banded masonry and curtain wall glazing was used in the wall behind the column and column head. The differential deflections caused by adjacent unequal main truss spans and by unequal snow loadings were studied by F J Samuely, by analysing the interaction between main and secondary trusses, using grid analysis computer programs. The analyses showed that, in order to control bending stresses in the secondary trusses and torsional effects on the main trusses, it was necessary to connect them using pin-jointed and guided end connections. These joints allowed adjacent main members to move vertically relative to each other. The exception to this arrangement occurs near the outer ends of the main members, where differential deflections are small. Here, rigid connections between main and secondary trusses were introduced to provide torsional stability to the main trusses. The same basic elements were used on the south side of the building to form a fragmented, informal edge. In this area the main trusses overshoot the external walls and are supported externally to the building envelope by freestanding cantilevered CHS columns clad in banded masonry. Warren braced secondary CHS trusses span east–west between the main trusses, at high or low level, at 4m (13.1ft) centres. Stability in the north–south direction is provided by the pinfooted mall A-frames. In the east–west direction the latticed
The Dome, Doncaster Leisure Park In the UK in the 1980s building form and materials choice were used to explore the approach to interaction of a sports and recreation centre with park landscaping. Architect FaulknerBrowns and engineer F J Samuely & Partners drew on extensive combined sports and leisure building experience to create the largest building of its type in the UK, and one of the largest in the world outside the USA and Germany. The opportunity arose when Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council wanted to take advantage of a national surge of growth in the leisure industry to develop a 130ha (286 acre) disused coalmining site on the eastern edge of the town. This was very much a regeneration project, with establishment of the Dome being seen as the necessary precursor to further development of the park. The aspiration was for a fun building of the 21st century which would embody the exuberant spirit of sports and leisure. Consideration was given initially to locating the proposed four principal activities of swimming, ice skating, bowling and court sports in four separate buildings linked by walkways. This option was abandoned in favour of a solution in which all the activities would be integrated, at various levels, into one building envelope. Particular attention was paid to the planning of the circulation spine, which expands dramatically at the centre of the building into a 30m × 19m (98ft × 62.3ft) high atrium. It was decided that access to the atrium would be free, to encourage casual visitors to the building. Thus, the central atrium forms a foyer area which opens onto public ‘malls’ which afford ‘shop window’ views of the various sports and leisure activities in progress. A tubular steel roof structure, 15.5m (50.8ft) at its highest point, was designed to make an elegant transition across considerable height differences, ranging from the 3m (9.85ft) of the ice rink to the 12m (39.4ft) of the sports hall. Triangulated lattice trusses 2m (6.56ft) deep span a maximum of 45m (147.6ft), at 7.8m (25.6ft) spacing, and are used as steps in the roofing (the
64
7.9 The Dome, Doncaster (1989)
bottom chords of the main trusses distribute lateral load to two ‘K’ braced bays along the north edge, via inclined ‘K’ bracing to the diagonally-braced mall frames near the centre and to the reinforced concrete health suite on the south edge. The health suite provides vertical support to the main trusses and to some secondary trusses. Steelwork is attached to the health suite via bearings guided in the north–south direction. The roof deck is supported on secondary trusses spaced at 4m centres. These are connected to the triangular members at different levels, to suit architectural and services requirements, and with the air ducts supported beneath the structure. The bowls hall/sports hall area is of similar construction to the ice rink/swimming pools area. Main air ducts run within the trusses and, in the sports hall, the deck spans directly between the bottom booms to provide a flat soffit. Changing rooms are located in a three-storey steel-framed structure between the bowls hall and sports hall. The east side of the building contains two-storey offices and a single-storey boiler-house, which are steel-framed, and single-storey squash courts, which are of load-bearing masonry. All steelwork in the roof, and much of the steelwork in the floors, is exposed to view as an architectural feature. Most members were transported to site in one piece but the larger main triangulated trusses were delivered in sections for welding together on site. All chord members and single tubular members were full strength, full penetration butt welded using backing rings. The CHS member linking the ends of the main trusses together was full strength, full penetration butt welded at every joint to provide
continuity for the transmission of lateral wind loads into the bracing systems. Curved beams were formed by first bending the chord members to the correct profile and then holding the chords in a jig to allow welding-in of the diagonals and verticals. Construction of the 15,100m2 (162,535ft²) building commenced in November 1986 and the Dome was completed in August 1989. Substructure works included concrete stanchion bases, reinforced in-situ concrete perimeter ground beam and floor slabs and swimming pool structures, all on a bed of granular material, together with a temporary dewatering system. External works included site contouring, topsoiling, grass seeding and planting, creation of a 6400m2 (68,890ft²) plastic-membranelined lake, hard paving around the building, tarmacadam entrance, service roads and parking for 600 vehicles, external lighting, surface-water drainage and collecting manholes.
The Play Drome, Clydebank Tourist Village Clydebank Tourist Village was established to provide sports facilities for a local urban population of 50,000 and a wider catchment area of 125,000. The complex divides into three areas: wet sports pool hall 45m × 45m (147.6ft × 147.6ft) with 25m competition pool, 330m2 (3552ft²) leisure pool, teaching pool, tyre ride, water slide);
65
7.10 Clydebank Leisure Centre (1993)
dry sports (multi-purpose) sports hall 36m × 32m (118ft × 105ft) and bowls hall 43m × 26m (141ft × 85.3ft), with squash courts, health suite and changing rooms); three-storey link (wet sports changing facilities, gymnasium, management suite, plantroom). The roof is tension-stayed, being supported primarily by tubular hangers suspended from perimeter masts. This form was selected to meet the need for large clear internal spans, optimise usable space within the building envelope (by minimising the size of the elements of construction, commensurate with structural economy)and to act as a landmark which, appropriately, symbolises the form of the River Clyde’s shipyard cranes. The roof structure comprises eight pairs of cellular principal rafters with a maximum span of 29m (95ft) radiating out from a central tubular steel tower and supported at the building perimeter by 17m (55.8ft) tall tubular steel masts. Cellular beams are also used for secondary rafters and for purlins. The purlins are spaced at 3.3m (10.8ft) centres, span 6.4m (21ft) and support a highperformance roof cladding system using metal decking and cladding, sandwiching 135mm (5.3in) of mineral wool insulation. The cellular rafters are supported from above the roof at approximately one-third points by tubular steel hangers suspended from the perimeter masts. Hangers are each formed from two parallel CHS members spaced 270mm (10.6in) apart. Hanger loads are resisted by mass concrete blocks. Load transfer to the mass concrete is by a universal column (UC) fabricated anchor cast into each mass concrete base. Means of fine adjustment of hanger length were provided at the hanger–rafter connection and at the foundations to cater for fabrication and erection tolerances. The perimeter masts are formed from twin CHS connected by fully welded cross members. This arrangement
provided the required strength and stiffness while achieving a light appearance. All visible connections between principal tubular members are by purpose-made cast steel forked connectors, joined with steel pins. Connectors were cast with a spigot and shoulder size to suit respectively the internal and external diameters of the tube. The tubes were square cut to length and butt welded to the castings. Cast steel was also used for the purpose-made saddles located where the tubular hangers connect to, and change direction around, mast outriggers. Pool hall and externally exposed steelwork was protected generally by hot dipped galvanising to a thickness of 140 microns followed, after etch primer, by two coats of chlorinated rubber paint to a total dry film thickness of 100 microns. Components that were too large for galvanising were zinc-sprayed and sealed. Where zinc spray coatings were used, intricate fabricated components such as forked connectors, which could not be effectively sprayed, were designed to bolt on to the main members and were hot dipped galvanised. All stainless steel components were electrically isolated with non-conductive washers and bushes at connections with mild steel.
Changing rooms If a sports centre accommodates both wet and dry sports, then an early decision must be taken as to whether the changing rooms for the two types of activity will be separated or combined. Changing provision required per person is 0.2m2 (2ft2) excluding
66
i n t e g r at e d
sports
facilities
Circulation
circulation. Including circulation, the requirement is 0.7–0.85m2 (7–9ft2). The number of changing room spaces needed equates to roughly twice the number of people using each activity per hour. However, for swimming pools the numbers relate to pool area and are one per 8.4m2 (90ft2) of formal pool area and between 6.5m2 (70ft2) and 4.2m2 (45ft2) of leisure pool area. Shower facilities have to be provided and an early decision has to be taken as to whether these will be individual or general. One shower will be required for every seven people using the facility at any one time. Lockers are also necessary. They are available in all sizes but full-height ones may be up to, say, 0.5m × 0.5m (20in × 20in) by around 1.8m or 6ft tall. Toilet cubicles should be a minimum 1.4m (4ft 7in) × 0.8m (2ft 7in). One should be provided per 15–20 males and one per 7–10 females. One urinal should also be provided per 15 males and the usable space allocated per urinal should be at least 0.75m (2ft 5in) × 0.625m (2ft 1in). One sink should be provided per 15 people and a usable area of 1.1m (3ft 7in) × 0.7m (2ft 3in) should be allocated for washing at a sink. Additional toilet and washing facilities will be required if the sports centre is to cater for spectators as well as participants. The requirement for spectators is less intensive than for participants. For example, seven additional toilets would accommodate up to 1000 male spectators or up to 900 female spectators, with an associated requirement of one sink per 60 spectators. Every public building should incorporate at least one unisex wheelchair-accessible toilet. A single changing unit incorporating toilet and washing facilities for a disabled sports participant will require a minimum of 2.6m (8ft 5in) × 2m (6ft 7in).
Circulation has to be planned into the sports centre and must be inclusive. Corridors should be a minimum of 1.2m (4ft approximately) wide, although 1.5m (5ft approximately) is preferable. Handrails should be provided on major routes. Otherwise projections from walls, such as litter bins, should be avoided in order to assist building users with impaired vision. Doors should be 0.9m (3ft) wide with minimum 2.3m (7ft 6in) between door faces. They should have levers rather than knobs, kick plates 0.4m (1ft 4in) high and toughened or wire glass vision panels down to approximately 1m or 40in above floor level. Doors should not normally open on to corridors. All door locations should be planned to facilitate wheelchair access.
Wealth of experience The results of a 2004 survey by the National IntramuralRecreational Sports Association (NIRSA) indicated that 333 US universities and colleges planned, between 2004 and 2010, to spend approximately $3.17 billion on new and renovated sports and recreation facilities. NIRSA has, since 1988, been presenting annual Outstanding Sports Facilities Awards for creative, innovative designs of new or expanded facilities. It has published details of the award-winning buildings as a resource for campus master planners, recreational sports directors, architects and other consultants, contractors and students. Case studies of many outstanding North American university and college sports and recreation centres feature in Robert Yee’s book (see References).
Restaurants Restaurants (including kitchens, counters and seating) are essential support facilities in sports centres. The biggest space-filler is the seating. If the usual table-plus-four-chairs arrangement is adopted, and placed on a diagonal layout, then the space required for the basic table-plus-chairs module is 1.9m (6ft 3in) × 2.2m (7ft 2in) which amounts to 4.18m2 (45ft2) and gives a restaurant density per person of 1.05m2 (11ft2). Allowance must also be made within the building for vending machines. These can be similar in height to a full-height locker (1.8m or 6ft) with plan area of up to around 1m × 1m (40in × 40in).
67
8.1 Don Valley Athletics Stadium, Sheffield (1990)
Chapter 8
Sports-led u r b a n re g e n e r a t i o n
Introduction
for this is that the school is to be found everywhere, even in the most sparsely settled regions. Legislatures of several states have coupled this fact with the universal need for recreation and have empowered boards of education to establish and provide personnel and equipment for community leisure-time programs. Even without legislative authority, people in some rural areas are utilizing school facilities and personnel for recreation purposes because to them the public school is an acceptable channel for the disbursement of tax-monies devoted to activities associated with their education and well-being’.
Sports development was inextricably linked with community development in school-building programmes in the USA from the late 1930s, which, in turn, had a positive influence on schoolbuilding in the post-World War II regeneration of the UK. In this regeneration, system-built schools became one of the first nonindustrial types of building to express all the character and virtues of steel. This was recognised internationally when the post-war British schools were considered by many architects to be on a par with the beautiful but austere works of Mies van der Rohe and his architectural school at the Illinois Institute of Technology. Subsequent landmarks of sports-led urban regeneration in the UK are the cases of Sheffield (1991) and Manchester (2002). These city-wide initiatives are different from London 2012 because building for the London Olympics was designed to exert a country-wide influence in sports facilities construction that is closer in concept to the much earlier system-built schools initiative.
By the mid 1950s it was possible to say that in the USA the modern elementary school was also designed to function as a neighbourhood centre, combining the best features of the school, small park or playground and neighbourhood recreation building. The gymnasium in the modern school-cum-neighbourhood-centre was used for physical education classes during regular school hours, for extra-curricular class groups after school and for the community centre recreation programme in the evening. It was the busiest component of the school development and a focal point for the local community. School administrators, therefore, continuously wanted more usable floor space for their ‘gym dollar’. The most costly part of the gym was its roof, because the necessary wide spans required support on braced columns rather than bearing walls. Popular solutions of the time included steel or timber bowstring trusses, rigid frame steel construction with intermediate purlins, rigid frame laminated timber construction – if frames were within 6ft (1.8m) apart – or a type of heavy corrugated steel panel arch construction which eliminated the need for built-up roofing.
School and Community Sports Facilities, USA In the USA in 1939 the Educational Policies Commission, appointed by the National Education Association and the American Association of School Administrators, published Social Services and the Schools, which reported that: ‘School authorities are now administering programs of public recreation in a number of communities. One reason
69
Table 8.1 Uses of steel in consortia components System
Structure
CLASP
Staircases
External walls and roofing
Internal components
Channel stringers and tray treads Rigidly or flexibly braced frame; box-section columns; lattice floor and roof joists
Vitreous enamel infill panelling
Stelvetite-faced partitioning and door frames
SCOLA
Rigidly braced frame; box-section Channel stringers columns; channel or castellated perimeters; lattice floor and roof joists
Galvanised window walling, with mullions; fixed and opening lights; vitreous enamel infill
Tee suspension bars; ceiling tiles
SEAC
Rigid frame; box-section columns; Channel stringers; tray treads; balusters channel perimeters; lattice floor and roof joists
Galvanised window walling, with mullions; fixed and opening lights; vitreous enamel infill; galvanised roof deck
Tee suspension bars; ceiling tiles
CMB
Rigidly braced frame; box-section Channel stringers; tray treads; balusters and rails columns; lattice floor and roof joists
Opening lights; galvanised roof deck; galvanised box gutters
–
CLAW
Box-section columns; space deck roof frame
–
Panel units
–
MACE
Box-section columns; lattice diagrid roof frame
Folded sheet stringers and treads
–
Colorcoat-faced partitioning
ONWARD
–
Channel stringers
–
–
ASC
Lattice roof joists
–
Opening lights
–
Consortium Building, UK
By 1949 school-building was underway throughout the country but often proved to be very expensive and educationally unsuitable. The Ministry decided that its newly-formed Development Group would design building systems, in collaboration with specific industrial firms, to better meet the needs. A light hot-rolled steel frame was developed for an initial project at Wokingham and a cold-formed steel frame for a second project at Belper. The Ministry also encouraged the use of privatelysponsored systems, many of which did emerge but subsequently fell away. Sponsors did not have a large guaranteed market and without this they could not afford to study in depth changing educational needs, which might require modifications to their systems. Also, because they did not insist on the use of standard parts, they found themselves manufacturing uneconomic ‘specials’. In 1955 Nottinghamshire initiated development work on modern building methods to facilitate the Nottinghamshire School Building Programme. It realised that, in the interests of economy, it was necessary to guarantee a construction programme larger than that required for its own use. So Nottinghamshire invited other authorities which were facing similar challenges to participate. Six other authorities accepted the invitation and the Consortium of Local Authorities Special Programme (CLASP) was born. In 1957 the first CLASP school was completed, at Mansfield. In 1962, again as the result of local initiative, the Second Consortium of Local Authorities (SCOLA) was established. The
What was happening in the USA would profoundly affect postWorld War II school-building in the UK. At the end of World War II the then Ministry of Education in the UK had to face challenges arising from a shortage of school places. Some school buildings had been destroyed. Many others were damaged and in need of repair. At the same time, building materials were in short supply and there was a severe shortage of building manpower. The situation was exacerbated by the raising of the school-leaving age to 15 in 1945. A national programme HORSA (Hutting Operation for the Raising of the School Leaving Age) was initiated to build hutted school accommodation. But the huts had been designed during the war years and had little relevance to schools. However, the Ministry also encouraged individual authorities to find their own solutions. With several New Towns in its area aggravating the problem, Hertfordshire believed that a more satisfactory longterm solution would be to develop a component-based building system using factory-manufactured parts wherever possible, for assembly on site by semi-skilled labour. Pilot projects commenced at Cheshunt and Essendon in 1947. The Hertfordshire system was based on a 99in (2.5m) modular grid. Its steel frame had lattice beams fabricated from top and bottom channels with rod lacings, and stanchions fabricated from four angles, secured with ring battens welded internally. Under its Chief Education Officer John Newsom, Hertfordshire would build 100 new schools by 1954 and another 100 by 1961.
70
8.2 Ponds Forge International Sports Centre: Sheffield (1991)
South-Eastern Architects Collaboration (SEAC) was formed in 1963, based on the systems developed in Hertfordshire. Then came the Consortium for Method Building (CMB), Consortium of Local Authorities in Wales (CLAW), Organization of North Western Authorities Rationalized Standard Design (ONWARD), the Anglian Standing Conference (ASC) and the Metropolitan Architectural Consortium for Education (MACE). These consortiums ranged from a closed building system (CLASP) to a component approach to building (CMB) and a bulkbuying mission (CLAW). The importance of the consortiums was heightened by another forthcoming increase in the school-leaving age (to 16 in 1972). CLASP adopted a steel frame because of its need to take into account ground movement due to mining subsidence. Prestressed and precast concrete, being essentially rigid construction methods, were considered unsuitable for subsidence sites. Timber was not a viable alternative because of fire safety issues above a height of two storeys. Lightweight steel frame construction resolved the subsidence issue and facilitated transportation of components to site, handling on-site and lifting into position. The other significant benefit was speed of erection. CLASP found it common practice for the complete steel frame of a primary school to be erected
within four to five days, taking up as little as 1.5% of the total site labour content. SCOLA wanted quick design and erection, within very strict cost controls, but with freedom of choice in external appearance and internal variety. Again, the choice was a steel frame which, because it was quickly erected, allowed a large proportion of following work to be carried out under cover. Equally important to SCOLA was the flexibility offered by steel frame construction in terms of internal partition layout, with minimum interruption from stanchions. Changing patterns in education make the ability to change the internal layouts of buildings desirable. This is cheaper and easier with steel than with traditional building types in which load-bearing walls dominate. The consortiums generally carried the steel theme through into the design of staircase stringers, treads, balusters and rails. CMB had two methods for constructing staircases and both were based on using steel. Either the steelwork fabricator could provide the – usually dog-leg – staircases and erect them with the steel frame. Or a standard dog-leg staircase, using metal trays for steps, was available from the component supplier for completion on site to the particular finish required. The MACE staircase
71
8.3 Hillsborough Leisure Centre (1991)
was factory prefabricated from folded sheet steel. ONWARD, which did not have a structural steel frame, did have a steel staircase component. The consortiums made extensive use of steel in external walling. SEAC offered a developed modular range of steel window walling and associated components. These were bolted together according to the shapes and sizes of proposed buildings, without restricting aesthetic criteria. CLASP made use of vitreous enamel panels for their low cost, durability of finished surface and wide colour range. The roofing of consortium buildings was accelerated by the use of profiled galvanised steel decking, spanning up to 15ft (4.5m) and available in continuous lengths up to 36ft (11m). SEAC pioneered the use of the steel roof deck for educational buildings and demonstrated its cost competitiveness. CMB too, with a preference for non-organic materials, found steel decking costeffective for the range of spans required on its flat roofs. The CLASP partitioning components were based on the use of Stelvetite pvc-faced steel panels bonded to plasterboard, supported by steel studs spanning 8ft (2.4m) or 10ft (3m) from cold-
rolled steel channels at the top and bottom. Such a partitioning system, which could contain the columns, gave fire protection of one hour and sound insulation values up to 42 decibels. Steel was also used for associated door frames (Stelvetite cold-formed channels), ceiling tiles and tee-suspension bars. CLASP found that the cost of the steel frame in a series of primary schools dropped from 8 shillings per square foot (1956) to 5 shillings 2 pence (1969). The cost reduction included 25% attributed to re-design and system development, and 14% attributed to increased production. This cost saving occurred during a period when steel costs increased by 10% on average. Later systems included Module 2, which derived from study into the use of light-gauge steel for the construction of schools, recreation centres, offices, factories and hospitals. A common theme of Module 2 buildings was maximisation of clear floor space to permit a high degree of flexibility in planning and subsequent use. An example of Module 2 is Bridgend Comprehensive School, which was built in the late 1960s. This featured a large communal block with prominent entrance, entrance canopy, decorative mural and spacious hall with administration at first
72
sports
floor level. In the original brief the main sports facilities were given as a swimming pool and gymnasium of 1800ft² (167m²). Because of the economic construction it proved possible not only to have the proposed 55ft × 24ft (16.75m × 7.3m) swimming pool but also to replace the gymnasium with a sports hall of 7200ft² (669m²). One end of the sports hall was designed for gymnastics but a much wider range of indoor sports could now be accommodated. As required, the gymnasium area could be divided from the sports hall as a whole by the use of movable screens. The flexibility of the consortium school-building programme was demonstrated many times by school extension and refurbishment projects of the 1980s and 1990s. The following two examples were by Hampshire County Council. In the 1980s, at Horndean Community School, a 1350m² (14,530ft²) hall – the Barton Hall – was commissioned for shared use between the school and local outside groups. The new-build is a steel-framed structure infilled with glazing and fairfaced concrete blockwork. This integrated with the 1970s’ SCOLA school development while achieving a cost-effective, fast-track construction programme. A barrel-vaulted roof, light timber floor and range of lighting moods help to meet needs ranging from school assembly and examinations to sport and dance, while achieving the appropriate acoustic and ventilation standards for all these activities. In the early 1990s, at Fleet, a deteriorating system-built block was given a new shallow-pitched, overhanging roof of insulated steel composite panels and a three-storey steel colonnade with sun and rain breakers. By these means the roof was made watertight, its insulation improved and the facades sheltered from the effects of rain and sun. The transformation rendered the refurbished block indistinguishable from adjoining new drama and mathematics blocks, which used a similar form of construction.
-led
urban
r e g e n e r at i o n
station, shopping centre and landscaped roundabout at Park Square. Within the tight confines of these boundaries, the building design sought to explore and articulate the complex relationships between international sports competition, leisure pursuits and tourist attractions while relating these to the needs of the city community. The result was unarguably the finest swimming pools complex in the UK – one widely considered to be the best facility of its type in the world. The 400 tonne tubular steel barrel vault roof over the main pool area is 54m (177ft) clear span × 84m (275ft) long, designed to appear as if floating overhead. Erection of this complex roof structure was completed without mishap to its planned three-month erection sequence, enabling construction of the main pool to follow to schedule. Sheffield Arena is arguably the first sports arena of the modern era to be built in the UK. It accommodates audiences from 3500 up to 12,500 for events including sports, ice rink, exhibitions, concerts and theatre-style shows. Its unique corporate hospitality provision includes 32 private suites, each catering for up to 12 people, and the Arena Club, a purpose-built facility which offers the opportunity to enjoy pre-show fine dining for up to 100 guests before taking some of the best seats in the venue. The suites (skyboxes) had been designed to be put in or left out at the last minute since, in 1991, there was no confidence that they could be sold. The positive decision was taken to keep them in and locate them high up along each side of the arena. The original intention was to hang the steel box structures from the roof frame but this proved impractical because of consequent fire protection requirements to the main roof structure. As an alternative, the skyboxes were designed as steel propped cantilevers, supported directly by the concrete frames, with a floor slab cast on permanent metal decking. The success of this scheme changed the British way of thinking on the feasibility of premium facilities at stadium and arena venues. The Don Valley Athletics Stadium is located in the lower Don Valley, at the old industrial heartland of Sheffield. It is the first purpose-built athletics stadium to be built in the UK and was conceived as a generator in the planned revitalisation of the whole area of the lower Don Valley. Its structure combines tubular steel with membrane roof canopies, providing a link with the site’s steelmaking past. Circular hollow sections (CHS) were used throughout for their high multi-directional resistance to buckling. The inheritor of the World Student Games facilities is Sheffield International Venues (SIV) which incorporates Sheffield City Hall,
XVI th Universiade 1991, Sheffield, UK Sheffield’s hosting of the XVIth Universiade, the World Student Games, represented one of the most ambitious ventures ever for the regeneration by sport of a major western European city. Principal generating elements of the plan included Ponds Forge International Sports Centre, Sheffield Arena and the Don Valley Athletics Stadium. Ponds Forge International Sports Centre is located on a disused industrial site at Sheffield’s city centre, locked between the bus
73
8.4 City of Manchester Stadium (2002)
Sheffield Arena, Ponds Forge International Sports Centre, Don Valley Stadium, the English Institute of Sport, Hillsborough Leisure Centre, the Concord Sports Centre, iceSheffield and four golf courses. This portfolio makes SIV one of the largest sports, leisure and entertainment companies in Europe. The venues are managed on behalf of SIV by Live Nation, the world’s biggest music company (in 2006 Live Nation connected 60 million fans to 26,000 events in 18 countries).
stands and demountable/temporary stands. Phase 2, the football configuration, included permanent end stands and an excavated lower seating tier. Stadium facilities include catering, VIP accommodation, private boxes, meeting rooms and conference rooms. The stadium roof is a mast and cable structure. Its design reduces bulk and depth while providing long cantilevers for uninterrupted views of the playing surface. The structural plan form of the roof is orthogonal, simplifying construction and permitting the possible future incorporation of a structurally separate moving canopy to enclose the stadium during inclement weather. The structural masts (maximum height 64m) also signal the stadium location and, by rising through the main circular access ramps, orientate spectators for safe access to and egress from the areas of seating. A cablestayed roof is vulnerable to load reversal. There are applied vertical downward loadings arising from snow and positive wind pressure on the upper surface, and applied vertical upwards loadings arising from wind uplift. A key and innovative part of the structural design is the grounded catenary tension ring used to preload the tension cables so that they can resist uplift loads without going slack. Approximately 2000 tonnes of steel were used for the stadium superstructure and
Sportcity, Venue for the 2002 Commonwealth Games, Manchester Sportcity is the largest concentration of sporting venues in Europe. It is located within the Medlock Valley in east Manchester, just two miles (3km) from Manchester City Centre. The brief required that the 38,000 seat main athletics stadium for the Commonwealth Games be convertible to a 48,000 seat football stadium from 2003, as the new home of Manchester City FC. Phase 1, the athletics configuration, incorporated an international standard athletics track with permanent main
74
8.5 London 2012 Olympic Games: Aquatics Centre
the cantilevered roof is aluminium-clad, with its leading edge translucent to increase light. The other principal components of Sportcity are: Manchester Aquatics Centre (Chapter 5); Manchester Regional Arena (6500 spectator capacity, with eight-lane, 400m track); the English Institute of Sport (medical assistance, rehabilitation, physiotherapy, performance analysis, coaching); Sportcity Fitness Studio (70-station gymnasium, health suite, workout studio); the National Squash Centre (six standard courts and one glass show court, each configurable for singles or doubles play at the push of a button); Regional Tennis Centre (six indoor and six outdoor courts); the National Cycling Centre – Manchester Velodrome – which is acknowledged to be one of the best sporting venues of its type in the world; Philips Park, 31 acres (12.5ha) of woodland, wild grassland, water and rolling hills with facilities including a visitor centre, children’s play area, hardstanding ball court, junior football pitch, bowling green, pavilion and show-field for hosting events. In creating the principal sports facilities of Sportcity the design team had to overcome the constraints of brownfield development which included:
• roads, including junctions for limited access off Alan Turing Way on the eastern site boundary; • proposed light rapid transit (LRT) line and two stops to be built alongside the Ashton Canal, with pedestrian access required along Alan Turing Way to the eastern side. Site development necessitated substantial land remediation, and the removal/relocation of services and earthworks, which had to be achieved at minimum cost.
London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics When its core construction work started on site in 2008, London 2012 became the biggest regeneration project in Europe. For the first time in Olympic history, the Games and its legacy formed part of the same overall plan. Following 2012, the Olympic Village becomes affordable housing for key workers, with 9000 new homes created. The Olympic Park is constructed on recycled brownfield land which, after 2012, becomes the Ecopark – the largest new urban park in Europe – with sports facilities set in an attractive environment created by restoring waterways, establishing new wildlife habitats and forging efficient transport links. Regeneration for the Games of the Lower Lea Valley, Hertfordshire, and Stratford, east London, was planned to help stimulate the sub-regional development of both east London and the Thames Gateway. International standard sports facilities were established
• abandoned recorded mineshafts (but not beneath the stadium location); • mine workings in coal seams; • contaminated ground from previous site usage; • River Medlock culvert; • foundations from demolished buildings; • services (electricity, gas, water, foul water and stormwater) and electrical sub-stations;
75
8.6 London 2012 Olympic Games: main stadium
in the Home Counties and beyond, in the run-up to 2012, for use as training facilities for visiting teams of 2012 competitors and ongoing use by local communities. Some of the structures for the 23 London venues of the Olympic events were designed to be demountable, or partially demountable, so that the concentration of new facilities in the capital could benefit regional sports facilities development and regeneration post-2012. Some of the London 2012 Olympic events themselves were allocated beyond London. Examples are sailing (Weymouth and Portland Harbour, Dorset) and the football which takes place in London (New English National Stadium, Wembley), Birmingham (Villa Park), Cardiff (Millennium Stadium), Manchester (Old Trafford), Newcastle (St James’ Park) and Glasgow (Hampden Park). The 80,000 seat Olympic Stadium for London 2012 is located on former industrial land at Marshgate Lane, Stratford. It is accessed by footbridges across the modified waterways of the Old River Lee, City Mill River, Old Pudding Mill River, St Thomas’ Creek and parts of the Bow Back Rivers. The stadium’s sunken bowl, excavated out of the soft London Clay, brings spectators close up to the action. The bowl contains 25,000 permanent seats, surrounded by 55,000 demountable seats to be taken away after the Games. This is the first Olympic stadium to have such a large proportion of demountable seating and such a mix of permanent and temporary seating. The seating is over-sailed by a 28m (92ft) wide cable-supported fabric roof, which is continuous around the stadium and covers two-thirds of the spectators. Catering and merchandising facilities are grouped into self-contained ‘pod’
structures. Party concourses planned outside the stadium were inspired by the successful ‘fan zones’ of the 2006 Germany World Cup where spectators congregated to eat, drink and watch the action on giant screens. Following the Games, the stadium will be big enough to host grand prix athletics events and national sporting events, but not too big to host local events and/or to attract a lower-league football or rugby club tenant. Innovative features of London 2012 included its Sustainable Development Strategy (SDS) aimed at setting new standards for the sustainable design and construction of major sports venues and infrastructure. The SDS made initial commitments to: • identify, source and use materials that are environmentally and socially responsible; • ensure that at least 20% of the materials in the permanent venues and Olympic Village have been previously used elsewhere or are recycled products; • maximise the use of timber from sustainable sources, with all timber coming from known, legal sources with clear supply chain evidence; • achieve 90% reuse or recycling of demolition material.
76
sports
-led
urban
r e g e n e r at i o n
Leading the field We like our political leaders to be sports participants – for the reasons cited by Kofi Annan in the quotation in the prelim pages (see p. x). On 11 May 2005 one of the authors (JP) was privileged to accompany Judy Chong, of construction manager Gilbane, on a Construction Writers Association tour of the newly-refurbished Robert F Kennedy Main Justice Building, Washington DC. One point of interest is no longer there – the top-floor area of the building that Robert Kennedy had marked out as a basketball court so that he and his colleagues could shoot some hoops between meetings. Eight blocks away, at the White House, Franklin D Roosevelt built a pool, Dwight D Eisenhower installed a putting green, Richard Nixon constructed a bowling alley and Bill Clinton laid a running track (on the edge of the south lawn). In 2009 Barack Obama planned to replace the bowling alley with an indoor basketball court.
8.7 Barack Obama: basketball with the US Military, Djibouti (2006)
77
9.1 Airdrionians FC, Broomfield Park, Airdrie (1959)
Chapter 9
Stadiums
Introduction Homer wrote that competitors in the foot-race ran to a mark in the distance, turned around it and ran back to the starting point so the ancient Greeks raced up and down a straight track, not around bends. The ‘stade’ (Greek racecourse) gained its name from the fact that it had a sprinting track which was one stade (600ft/180m) long, with all races being multiples of that . However, the track at Olympia, reputedly stepped out by Herakles, son of Zeus, was 192.27m (630.8ft) long. The track at Epidaurus was 181.3m (594.8ft) and that at Delphi 177.5m (582.3ft). Whoever stepped out the track at Pergamon out-stepped even Herakles – with a whopping 210m (689ft). The ancient Greek stadium was therefore non-standard but in the common form of a long parallelogram some 180m long by some 30m (98.4ft) wide. The enclosure containing the stadium would allow approximately 15m (49.2ft) at either end of the track and might be square, as at Epidaurus, or curved, as at Delphi and Athens, hence the derivation of the shape of the modern stadium.
Inside or outside The Greek stadiums were for outdoor sports. Previous books on sports facilities have tended to exclude stadiums because of their association with outdoor sports. However, this is a difficult distinction to make now because of the new generation of stadiums with closing roofs and the development within stadiums of under-terrace, fully-enclosed sports facilities. Just as the Greek stadiums were marvels of the ancient world, the new closing-roof stadiums are
9.2 British Steel Wide Span Sports Solutions (circa 1970)
79
9.3
9.4
Rugby Union Football HQ, Twickenham:
Rogers Center (formerly Skydome), Toronto:
under terrace accommodation (1996)
Jays v Tampa Bay (30 September 2007)
among the wonders of the modern world. Closing roofs can prevent inclement weather from spoiling events, put a lid on noise and present the opportunity to control the enclosed environment. The authors’ involvements in these projects have ranged from a single day (PC – Stüttgart, 2007, re Aslantepe Türk Telekom Stadyumu) to more than a decade (PC – Wembley Stadium Redevelopment).
corners of the ground (rather than today’s continuous, wraparound-the-pitch style of spectator accommodation) and the incorporation of intermediate roof-supporting columns which interrupt sightlines (and are eliminated in today’s designs). There is also now a wholly different approach to Health and Safety on site.
Airdrionians FC, Broomfield Park
Wide-span solutions
Developments at Broomfield Park, Airdrie, at the end of the 1950s comprised concrete substructure and lightweight steel superstructure – which are typical not only of stadium construction in the late 1950s but also of stadium construction today. Principal differences between then and now include the standing terraces with their crush barriers (rather than today’s all-seater stadiums), grandstands to the length and side of the pitch – separated by massive floodlighting towers at the four
High strength steel was developed by British Steel in the 1960s specifically for the roof of the BOAC 747 01 Hangar at Heathrow Airport. By demonstrating the wide-span capability of steel to accommodate servicing of the 747 airplane, British Steel demonstrated the viability of business and leisure air travel as we know it today. The 01 hangar was a direct, necessary and urgent response to a global demand created by the introduction of the new widebodied generation of passenger aircraft. It was the biggest steel
80
s ta d i u m s
9.5 Millennium Stadium, Cardiff (2000)
structure of its kind in the world and the world’s largest-ever diagonal steel grid. It posed a unique challenge in the history of construction because of the exceptionally large dimensions and the magnitude of loads supported by the structure. Its success meant that structural steel would thereafter always be the first choice material for aircraft hangar construction globally. British Steel’s structural marketing manager Ron Taylor said that from now on architects would only be constrained by the limitations of their own imagination. He encouraged architects to think wide span, and then wider and wider span. One of the first sports manifestations of high strength steel was the 9000-seat Celtic Football Club Grandstand, which was completed in an 18-week contract period, April to August 1971, in readiness for the 1971–72 playing season. In association with Ron and his colleagues, architect James Cunning and structural engineer Vivian Rossi reached the conclusion that it would be technically feasible to give the grandstand’s full complement of spectators an uninterrupted view of the playing area from their seats. The proposal which made this possible was for a roof supported by an enormous central spine girder 97.5m (320ft) long × 5.4m (17.7ft) deep, fabricated from circular hollow sections (CHS) to BS4360 in Grades 55C, 50C and 43C. The main chords of the twin top and bottom booms are 406.4mm (16in) outside diameter in Grade 55C in all but the end booms. This was the largest tubular steel girder of its kind in Europe.
Ron Taylor continued to advocate spans greater than 100m (328ft), and up to and beyond 300m (1000ft), to make full use of the high grade steels available. Ron went into private practice when his design development for a Channel Bridge placed him at odds with a British government committed to a Channel Tunnel. He continued to design innovative wide span structures for construction throughout the world, including many aircraft hangars and sports facilities.
Millennium Stadium, Cardiff This is the first closing roof stadium in the UK. It needed to be in the order of 50m (164ft) larger than the pitch in all directions, to accommodate the 72,500 seats required, and the opening had to be at least the size of the pitch. This gave roof dimensions in the order of 220m (720ft) long × 180m (590ft) wide with an opening of approximately 120m × 80m (390ft × 260ft). At an early stage of design it was decided that the following criteria should be adopted: • to keep the roof as low as practicable to reduce the stadium’s impact on adjoining buildings;
81
Miller Park, Milwaukee In April 2001 Miller Park opened at Milwaukee, Wisconsin, where extremes of heat and cold, with unpredictable snow and rain, had previously resulted in low attendances and lost games. The need for a natural grass playing surface has been met with a 600ft (138m) span retractable roof that opens and closes within 10 minutes. With the roof closed, temperatures for spectators can be raised or lowered by ±17°C (9.54°F). The heating, ventilating and air-conditioning (HVAC) design strategy was to introduce air by way of jet nozzles above each seating level to create an envelope of warm air, supplemented at the highest level by jets introducing more warm air into the downdraught from the roof and determining the dominant air movement through the space. Mixing of the two airstreams is sufficient to temper the cold airstream but insufficient to prevent its downward momentum. The airflow then rises due to gains above the seating deck. Air is returned through the concourse and vomitories to the air-handling units (AHUs) which contain indirect gas-fired heaters to provide heating capacity for the bowl and concourses, and smoke control capability. These systems use a minimum outside air quantity of 0.14m³/min per person. The quantity of air equivalent to the ventilation requirements for the bowl is exhausted by the concession hoods or dissipated through the facades. In 2002 Miller Park was the winner of an Excellence in Engineering Award presented by the Structural Engineering Association of California (SEAOC).
9.6–9.7 Miller Park, Milwaukee, Wisconsin: (top) roof closed (2001); and (bottom) roof open (2001)
• to keep the structure and edge of the opening as low as possible to reduce the extent of shading on the pitch; • to make the track, for the retractable roof to move along, as near to flat as possible to simplify the retractable roof mechanism and, therefore, make it more cost-effective and less problematic. These criteria were met in a structural solution which incorporated continuous primary plane lattice trusses over the full 220m (720ft) length of the stadium, rising 35m (115ft) above the pitch.
82
Table 9.1 Selected projects – stadiums designed with closing or moving roofs Name
City
Country
Open
Capacity
Owner
Architect
Club
Singapore National Stadium Swedbank Arena
Kallang
Singapore
2012
55,000
DP Architects
N/A
Solna
Sweden
2012
50,000
Sweco
Stade Borne de l’Espoir Lille
France
2011
50,186
–
Swedish National Football Team + AIK Lille OSC
Dallas Cowboys New Stadium Aslantepe Türk Telekom Stadyumu Lucas Oil Stadium
Arlington
USA
2009
80,000
Singapore Sports Hub Consortium SFF, Solna Municipality, PEAB, Fabege, Jernhusen Urban Community of Lille Métropole Arlington, Texas
HKS, Inc
Dallas Cowboys
Istanbul
Turkey
2009
52,647
Galatasaray SK
Mete Arat
Galatasaray SK
Indianapolis
USA
2008
63,000
HKS, Inc
Indianapolis Colts
New English National London Stadium, Wembley
UK
2007
90,000
Indiana Stadium and Convention Building Authority The Football Association
N/A
University of Phoenix Stadium Commerzbank-Arena (Waldstadion)
Glendale
USA
2006
63,400
Frankfurt
Germany
52,300
LTU Arena
Düsseldorf
Germany
1925 (rebuilt 2005) 2004
51,500
Arizona Sports and Tourism Authority Waldstadion Frankfurt Gessellschaft für Projektwicklung City of Düsseldorf
World Stadium Team (Foster and Partners + HOK Sport) Peter Eisenman/ HOK Sport Gerkan, Marg ünd Partner
Fortuna Düsseldorf
Reliance Stadium
Houston
USA
2002
71,500
Harris County
Hascher Jehle and Associates HOK Sport
Veltins Arena
Gelsenkirchen Germany
2001
61,482
Schalke 04
Schalke 04
Nagoya Grampus + Toyota Verblitz Milwaukee Brewers
Ōita Stadium
Ōita
Japan
2001
40,000
Ōita Prefecture
Hentrich-Petschnigg ünd Partner Kisho Kurokawa
Toyota Stadium
Toyota
Japan
2001
45,000
Toyota City
Kisho Kurokawa
Miller Park
Milwaukee
USA
2001
42,200
HKS, Inc + NBBJ + Eppstein Uhen Architects
Minute Maid Park Houston (formerly Enron Field) Telstra Dome (formerly Melbourne Docklands Stadium, Victoria Stadium, Colonial Stadium)
USA
2000
40,950
Australia
2000
53,355
Southeast Wisconsin Professional Baseball District Harris County – Houston Sports Authority James Fielding Funds Management
Safeco Field
Seattle
USA
1999
47,116
Millennium Stadium
Cardiff
UK, Wales
1999
72,500
Chase Field (formerly Bank One Ballpark) Gelredome
Phoenix
USA
1998
49,033
Arnhem
Netherlands 1998
32,500
Amsterdam ArenA
Amsterdam
Netherlands 1996
51,628
Japan
1993
35,695
Canada
1989
31,074
Canada
1976 (roof 1987)
Fukuoka Fukuoka Yahoo! Japan Dome (formerly Fukuoka Dome) Rogers Centre Toronto (formerly Skydome) Montreal Olympic Quebec Stadium
HOK Sport
Rogers Communications Régie des Installations Olympiques
Post-2008 opening dates are best guesses (table produced September 2008) Selected projects are 30,000+ spectator capacity Spectator capacities quoted are for principal sport mode (higher capacities may be achieved for hosting sports with reduced playing areas and for hosting concerts)
83
Houston Texans
Ōita Trinita
Houston Astros
Daryl Jackson Architects + HOK Sport
Carlton, Essendon, North Melbourne, St Kilda, Western Bulldogs, Melbourne Victory, Melbourne Storm NBBJ + 360 Architecture Mariners
Washington-King County Stadium Authority Welsh Rugby Union HOK + LOBB Partnership Maricopa County, Ellerbe Becket Arizona Kjell Kosberg Gemeente Amsterdam Stadion Amsterdam NV Hawks Town
Arizona Cardinals + Fiesta Bowl Eintracht Frankfurt
WRU + Football Association of Wales Diamondbacks Vitesse Arnhem
Bouwcombinatie
AFC Ajax
Takenaka Corporation + Maeda Corporation
Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks
Rod Robbie & Michael Allen Roger Taillibert
Toronto Blue Jays + Toronto Argonauts Montreal Expos
is a mixture of standing seam aluminium and 30% translucent polycarbonate sheeting (the latter allowing diffused light through the roof leading edges). A moving roof over the whole of the southern side of the stadium was required to provide maximum covered seating for spectators while providing daylight for the turf. The permanent roof structure running north–south provides the runway beams supporting the track for the panels. The area of roof that moves is split into five bays. The middle section extends the 135m (443ft) length of the pitch and there are two bays at each end which cover the end stands. Each of the two end bay panels is subdivided to enable double-stacking on top of the fixed roof, without projecting over the southern edge of the building. The roof panels are framed by fabricated box sections up to 3m (9.8ft) deep (for the central large cantilever panel) which are connected to the running bogies. Secondary framing universal beam (UB) sections are used with full diagonal rod bracing for each panel, to ensure that racking of the panel does not occur. A full opening or closing cycle for the roof takes 20 minutes. 9.8 Wembley arch erection (2005)
Bird’s Nest Stadium, Beijing 2008 New English National Stadium, Wembley, London, UK
This is a huge stadium – 230m wide × 330m long × 55m high (755ft × 1083ft × 180ft). Although it will always be thought of in the ‘bird’s nest’ context, its form was actually inspired by ancient Chinese ‘scholar stones’, heavily veined pebbles mounted on small plinths, and by traditional crackle-glazed ceramics. The perforated exterior facade was conceived to enable people to move freely into and out of the stadium, making it part of the city. The geometry of the stadium’s steel superstructure derives from a small patch from the inside face of a vast toroid. At its edges the roof flows into smooth corners. This creates a seamless transition into the facade, which slopes inward at 14° from the vertical. The original stadium design accommodated a moving roof but the Beijing Organizing Committee for the Olympic Games (BOCOG) dropped this feature (reducing steelwork from 55,000 tonnes to 45,000 tonnes). This design change enabled the opening above the playing area to be enlarged, so drawing in more light and air. Principal structural elements are 1.2m × 1.2m (4ft × 4ft) boxes with plate thickness 15mm (0.6in) to 60mm (2.4in). Depth of the bottom chord box sections reduces towards the centre of the stadium, from 1.2m (4ft) to 800mm (31.5in). Design was to
This stadium is signposted from miles around by the iconic 315m (1033ft) ‘Wembley Arch’, a 138m (452.7ft) high, 7m (23ft) diameter unclad lattice structure. The arch is formed of 457CHS (18in outside diameter) longitudinal chords with diaphragms at approximately 20m (65.6ft) centres. Alternate diaphragms are primary and support the roof stays. Steel grades are S355 JO or J2 to BS EN 10025. Rolled hollow sections (RHS) are S355 J2H to BS EN 10210. Protection is 400dft micron epoxy primer/buildcoat and a 75dft micron finish coat, over a blast-cleaned surface to Sa 2.5 of BS 7079, giving a period to first maintenance of 30 years. Access to the arch, through its centre, permits structural inspection, lighting maintenance/replacement, repainting (30-year intervals), festivity/celebration (e.g. pyrotechnics) and dressing the arch with flags or banners. The stays are spiral strand galvanised wires grade 1570. The roof plate main structure runs north–south. The roofing material
84
9.9 Beijing 2008 Olympics: main stadium
Chinese building codes and the computer analysis used CATIA software. The cladding is inset by 800mm within the steelwork grillage and comprises a single-ply ethylene tetrafluoroethylene (ETFE) skin, with an acoustic lining beneath. To prevent rainwater pooling, each cell of the roof drains into a pipework system running within the primary steel members.
athletics venue, as a model for the city’s Minyuan Stadium (which continues to host meetings as an 18,000 all-seater stadium). In 1941 Liddell moved to Shaochang to serve the poor. The SinoJapanese war had broken out in 1937 and reached Shaochang in 1943, when the Japanese incarcerated Liddell at the Weihsien Internment Camp. The British Prime Minister Winston Churchill initiated a prisoner exchange and Liddell was among those due to be released, but he gave up his place in favour of a pregnant woman and died in captivity in 1945, aged 43. China interred his remains in the Mausoleum of Martyrs at Shijiazhuang, 150 miles (240km) southwest of Beijing, where 700 selected individuals who made the ultimate sacrifice in the liberation of China are honoured. The simple wooden cross which had marked his resting place at Weihsien (now Weifang) has been replaced with a granite gravestone carrying the biblical quotation: ‘They shall mount up with wings of eagles, they shall run and never be weary’.
Eric Liddell (Li Airui) Eric Liddell (or Li Airui as he is known in the Far East) won the 400m at the 1924 Paris Olympics, representing Great Britain by virtue of his Scottish parentage. In so doing, he became the only China-born Olympic gold medalist until Xu Haifeng won the 50m pistol shooting at Los Angeles in 1984. Liddell returned to his home city of Tianjin in 1925, where he worked as a missionary and science/sports teacher at the Anglo-Chinese College. He approached the British Embassy about building a stadium at Tianjin and subsequently used Stamford Bridge, his favourite
85
sports
C
and
facilities
DN R R DT
9.10 The ‘C’ value
C
20,000mm365mm 6,000mm 6,000mm 20,000mm 800mm
Sightlines
– this is because we tend to tilt our heads backwards slightly as the action moves closer towards us, reducing the distance between the centre of the eye and the top of the head to around 90mm. At a football match the action moves to all parts of the playing surface so, ideally, every football stadium would be designed to provide a ‘C’ value of 120mm to all parts of the playing surface:
20,000mm 6,365mm 6,000mm 20,800mm A feature which sets the stadium apart from other sports facilities is the much greater amount of seating incorporated for spectators. 127,300mm 6,000mm The modern stadium has to offer excellent views from quality 120mm 20,800mm seating. To achieve this there must be no